The coal industry
The coal industry Charles Kernot
WO O DH EA D PU B LISH I NG LI M ITE D Cambridge, England
Publi...
123 downloads
2831 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The coal industry
The coal industry Charles Kernot
WO O DH EA D PU B LISH I NG LI M ITE D Cambridge, England
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB1 6AH, England www.woodhead-publishing.com First published 2000 # Charles Kernot, 2000 The author has asserted his moral rights Conditions of sale All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. While a great deal of care has been taken to provide accurate and current information, neither the author, nor the publisher, nor anyone else associated with this publication shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. ISBN 1 85573 105 3 Typeset by BookEns Ltd, Royston, Herts. Printed by Astron On-Line, Cambridgeshire, England.
For Helen
Contents Preface About the author Index PART 1: DEVELOPMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRY
1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
Coal from the earliest times The early days How coal was mined Costs and capital Transport The social cost The start of unionism
2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9
International discoveries Introduction Australia Bulgaria China Hungary Indonesia Poland South Africa United States of America
PART 2: WHERE COAL COMES FROM
3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7
What is coal? A fossil fuel Coal classification Composition and impurities Energy content Proximate analysis Ultimate analysis Coking coal
# Charles Kernot
Contents/page i
Contents
4 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
Exploration, mining and production Introduction Feasibility studies Mining Productivity Total mining costs Reclamation
5 5.1 5.2 5.3
Treatments and quality assurance End product requirements Sampling Processing techniques
6 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4
From mine to market Transport logistics Export ports Shipping Import ports
PART 3: COAL USES
7 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7
Coal, electricity and the environment Who uses coal? How a power plant works Coal and the environment Flue gas desulphurisation Clean coal technology Competition Renewable competition
8 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5
Coking, industrial and domestic coal Coking coal Iron-making Other metallurgical coal uses Industrial and domestic uses Other industrial applications
PART 4: SUPPLY/DEMAND, TRADE AND PRICES
9 9.1 9.2
World supply Introduction World producers
Contents/page ii
# Charles Kernot
Contents
10 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6
World demand Introduction Areas of consumption The three coal markets Future demand Steel industry outlook Regional demand trends
11 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4
International trade A blessing or a curse? International suppliers International consumers The traders
12 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5
Coal pricing and hedging Introduction Contracts and pricing International coal prices Hedging Outlook
Appendix: Coal and shipping terms Bibliography
# Charles Kernot
Contents/page iii
Preface The international coal industry is a leviathan hidden beneath the surface of economic growth and prosperity. Indeed, despite its importance, it is surprising how few people know anything about the size and global reach of the industry. Whilst almost 500 million tonnes of coal are shipped annually around the world at a traded value of around US$15 bn, the total amount of coal mined each year amounts to some 3.8 billion tonnes. Assuming that this material fetches an average price of US$30/t, the total value of coal produced annually must approach US$100 bn. This is much higher than the next most important mined commodity, aluminium, which, after the substantial cost of upgrading the bauxite ore to the metal, has an annual output value of some US$35 bn. As this work has evolved it has moved from being a general book about the international coal trade into a more specialised information manual. Indeed, it contains detailed data on many parts of the international coal industry that are not available in one single source elsewhere. As a consequence, it should be useful to many of the players in the industry ± from mining exploration companies looking for coal, through the mining, processing and transport of the commodity, and ending with the consumers ± be they power generators or steel producers. Part one puts the industry in perspective, from the first discoveries of coal mines and the early development of the industry to feed the industrial revolution ± first in the United Kingdom and then spreading through the British Empire to the rest of the world. Whilst other countries also had coal industries in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, the first real developments outside the United Kingdom really began in the nineteenth century ± particularly in the United States. More recent developments include the coal mines of Colombia, Indonesia and Venezuela and the development of the steam coal export markets of Australia and South Africa. Part two looks at coal in more detail: what the commodity is and where it comes from. This has important consequences for both where the coal can be used and how it can and should be mined. Indeed, the treatments to upgrade the fuel to a saleable commodity
# Charles Kernot
Preface/page i
Preface
are still advancing, to the extent that fine material is now finding a wider market. In the future there may be developments that can aid the removal of sulphur or moisture from coal to improve its value, although the ash content of the material will still need to be placed in a secure disposal site. Part three looks at the areas where coal is used ± mainly in the power generation and steel industries. In the future the amount of coal consumed is still set to rise given the increasing demand for electricity as countries develop and their economies expand. Whilst greenhouse gas problems may lead to pressure to reduce coal burn, what is more likely to occur is an increasing efficiency of the conversion of coal energy into electricity. Moreover, the increasing concerns about nuclear energy indicate that it will account for a declining share of the global electricity supply mix and that coal, gas and renewable electricity will increase their relative market shares. Part four finally considers the state of the coal market and the international trade in the commodity. It looks at the growth in supply of coal from Australia and South Africa in the early 1970s and the more recent growth in output from Colombia, Indonesia and Venezuela. The growth in demand in the Asia-Pacific region and the changing structure of the European energy industry are also covered as these provide important indications about the future development of the industry. There is also some data on coal prices, although this is the one area of the industry that remains extremely complicated at the present time. In the future, however, the creation of coal futures contracts by the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) may well remove some of the difficulty of extracting comparable coal price information on a global scale. The overall structure of the global coal industry is in a marked state of flux. Many of the non-mining companies that entered the industry in an attempt to secure a supply of energy during the 1970s are now turning their backs as they chase for better returns elsewhere. Indeed, the recent returns from coal-mining have been abysmal as increased production in the late 1990s coincided with the Asian economic crisis and meant that too much coal was chasing too little demand with the result that prices cracked. Consequently, those who are now buying into the industry will do so at depressed prices. If they can consolidate and coordinate production across mines with different cost bases and extract
Preface/page ii
# Charles Kernot
Preface
economies of scale they should make healthy returns. The ready supply of coal has meant that the industry has been forced into a position of price-taker rather than price-maker ± a situation that the current consolidation is set to change. The implications for returns on capital and mining company profitability should therefore be substantial ± but only if the companies left in the industry are more careful about planning and opening new mines than they have been in the past. For coal consumers the recent era of cheap coal energy is slipping into the past ± after all, the rise in the price of oil in 1999 is set to be reflected in the price of coal during 2000. This should provide further incentives to encourage consumers to make their consumption of the fuel more efficient. Indeed, the rally in the price of oil in the 1970s was a de facto environmental tax that encouraged sharply reduced consumption of the fuel. The low efficiency of many coalfired electricity generating stations across the world almost requires a similar price explosion in order to wreak similar efficiency improvements. This, perhaps more than any Kyoto Protocol, is what the world needs in order to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. In my first book on the coal industry, in 1993, I suggested that countries and companies should look to carbon sinks in order to reduce their net level of carbon dioxide emissions. This idea has now started to gain credence ± especially as a consequence of the plans to introduce the international trading of emission permits. Data, however, remains sketchy and many countries are unwilling to commit to a tax that could reduce their economic competitiveness. This, certainly, was behind the strong lobbying against US acceptance of the principle of global warming by domestic energy consumers in the early 1990s. Nevertheless, whilst the purchase of existing forests may help their specific preservation, what may well be required is the extension and expansion of forested areas in order to increase carbon reabsorption. This would increase carbon capture rather than continue to allow the slow build-up of CO2 in the atmosphere through the protection of existing forested areas from destruction by slash and burn agriculture. Although coal consumers clearly have an important part to play in the creation of protected areas, mining companies also need to consider what role they need to play. After all, the rehabilitation of old mine sites, be they open pits or underground
# Charles Kernot
Preface/page iii
Preface
operations, could provide large land areas for reforestation that would clearly help to improve the global environment. This work could not have been completed without the help and assistance of my long-suffering wife, Helen, who has encouraged and helped me through the dark periods when it looked as if it would never be completed. I also need to express my sincere thanks to all of those across the coal industry who have helped and provided me with information ± even if it only accounts for a sentence in this text. After all, it is this information that helps to create a single picture of an industry that remains split into a disaggregated part of global energy supply. As I mention above, I believe that the international coal trade is set to change dramatically over the course of the next few years, and this will be of as much importance to producers as to consumers. I hope that this work will aid their understanding of the industry and will help them formulate strategies to take advantage of these changes when they occur. Charles Kernot
Preface/page iv
# Charles Kernot
About the author Charles Kernot, head of metals and mining research at BNP Paribas, was educated at Winchester College and the Royal School of Mines, Imperial College, where he obtained his honours degree in mining geology. Since joining the City in 1985, he has researched all areas of the metals and mining industry, and has specialised in the coal sector, writing a book on the privatisation of British coal in 1993. Prior to joining Paribas in 1995, he was head of international mining research at Credit Lyonnais Laing. He is also a Member of the Institution of Mining and Metallurgy and the Association of Mining Analysts.
# Charles Kernot
About the author/page i
1 Coal from the earliest times 1.1
The early days
1.2
How coal was mined 1.2.1 Origins 1.2.2 Water removal 1.2.3 Gas detection 1.2.4 Mechanical mining
1.3
Costs and capital
1.4
Transport 1.4.1 Canals cut costs 1.4.2 The age of the train
1.5
The social cost
1.6
The start of unionism
# Charles Kernot
1.1 The early days The earliest reference to the use of coal in Europe was by Theophrastus, the successor of Aristotle as head of the academy in Greece. In his treatise `On Stones' he describes a substance that was dug up in Liguria, north-west Italy, and Elis, in Thrace, because it could `be set on fire and burnt like charcoal' and was `actually used by workers in metals'. Whilst this substance is now thought to have been lignite rather than coal, it represents the first direct reference to the use of a mineral for fuel ± although the rarity of references to the use of lignite, or coals from the earth, indicates that it was not widely used during the Greek ascendancy. In the United Kingdom coal has been used at least since Roman times and probably from long before. The earliest indications come from Hadrian's Wall, where Roman troops are thought to have burned coal in order to keep out the Scottish cold over the long winter nights; and from Bath where coal provided the sacred flame in the Temple of Minerva. The destruction of forests in China also led to the early use of coal in the Asian region. One of the first recorded operations was the Fushun mine in Manchuria, which provided coal for copper smelting between AD1200 and AD1300. Despite these early sources of demand, mining is unlikely to have been carried out on an organised basis until the eleventh or twelfth centuries, and the initial gathering of coal probably took place where seams were exposed at the surface. Indeed this surface expression was one of the beneficial factors behind the early economic growth of the United Kingdom and meant that the country became the world's first major coal producer. Specifically, the first concerted efforts to extract coal in the United Kingdom were along the north-east coast, where coal seams were exposed by the erosive effects of the North Sea. This brought the fuel to the attention of the local population, which burned cheap coal in preference to the more expensive wood. It is in the thirteenth century that coal gets its first specific mention in the United Kingdom. Surprisingly, perhaps, there is no direct reference in the Domesday Book and neither did any of the other chroniclers of the earlier centuries give coal any mention. Consequently, the first explicit reference to the fuel seems to have been by the Bishop of Durham, in 1200, when he attempted to promote the development of coal in the Tyne Valley.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 1
The coal industry
In 1257 Queen Eleanor was forced to flee London because of the `fumes of the sea coals' and both Seacoal and Old Seacoal Lanes are to be found by Ludgate Circus in the City of London as a continuing reference of how coal was originally taken to the capital. Indeed, by far the easiest method of transport from the coal-mining area on the north-east coast to London was by coaster. The roads were in a dire state and it was not until the middle of the eighteenth century that the canal building programme really got underway. Notwithstanding London's increasing demand, the difficulty and expense of transport meant that there was little movement of coal from its immediate source until the thirteenth century and even this was not significant. Indeed, the majority of coal produced until the start of the sixteenth century was used within a two mile radius of a mine, and was largely restricted to the poor who could not afford to buy wood. The preference for wood was largely related to the lack of chimneys in most houses, which often just had a single central fire. As coal fires are sooty and smelly the cleaner, and in some cases more aromatic, wood was burned in preference to coal despite commanding a higher price. The population of London increased four-fold between 1500 and 1600, which led to such a great increase in demand for food that the surrounding land was cleared of forests and converted for agricultural use. Therefore, as with China, London's demand for coal was because the forests had been denuded and there was little other locally produced fuel available at an acceptable price. As coal could be transported by sea it could be moved right into the centre of the City and, therefore, directly to its market. This meant that there was little need for expensive overland movement and the low incremental cost of shipping greater distances meant that coal could be brought from further afield. The use of coal in London is first documented on a consistent basis by Westminster School, which kept records of the prices it paid for coal between 1585 and 1830. These prices are detailed in Fig 1.1, which shows that there were often marked fluctuations in the price that the school had to pay for its fuel supplies. These prices were often linked to periods of rising or falling prices generally, and the rise in price during the high inflationary period of the Napoleonic Wars at the start of the nineteenth century is clearly shown. This price rise is related both to inflation and the lack of manpower with troops fighting
Chapter 1/page 2
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
1.1 Prices of coal at Westminster School 1585±1830 (source: Kernot, 1993).
on the continent but is also related to the danger of attack by French privateers which sought to prevent coal reaching London. It should further be considered that most of the other known European coal regions were still in politically unstable countries and principalities and that there was therefore little threat of import competition. Both Belgium and Germany had large coal reserves but these countries were not in a position to invest large amounts of capital in order to serve the British market. This was despite the ease of access down the Ruhr and across the Channel. Therefore, mainland Britain was left in relative peace and security and this helped to promote the investment of capital in increasingly large-scale operations. Indeed, by the start of the eighteenth century coal was being mined in all known coal-bearing areas of the United Kingdom, with the exception of the deep Kent coalfield where mining did not start until the early twentieth century. It is difficult to estimate the total amount of United Kingdom coal production until the middle of the nineteenth century as the first country-wide statistics were not collated until 1854. Nevertheless, the annual production of coal probably averaged some 210 000 tonnes (t) in the 1550s and slowly grew to around 2.25 Mt in 1660, 2.5 Mt in 1700 and around 6 Mt in 1770. The sixteenth century saw the start of the
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 3
The coal industry
1.2 Coal production in the United Kingdom 1550±1998 (source: Author).
upturn in coal output together with the first real increase in transportation to areas other than London. The increase in demand and production is sometimes referred to as `the sixteenth century coal rush' (Fig. 1.2) although the increase in production during the nineteenth century was clearly much more significant.
1.2 How coal was mined 1.2.1
Dunite
The first descriptions of coal mines in the United Kingdom exist from the fourteenth century when mining appears to have become an entrepreneurial operation with the coal often worked for sale rather than for personal consumption. In 1316 there is a description of a mine at Cossall in Nottinghamshire being worked by 12 men. Their payment of 12 old pence (12d) a pickaxe (equivalent to about 4d/t) was probably around one-third of the selling price of the coal at the time. The sixteenth century is also important as it shows the beginnings of the division of labour as the first full-time, specialist miners are recorded. Before this mines were small-scale operations employing no more than twelve individuals who were from the locality. Even so these workers would not have been employed for the
Chapter 1/page 4
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
full year as the need for agricultural labour during harvests meant that they were often relieved of their duties to help elsewhere on their lord's estate. Indeed, the ownership of the early mines was restricted to the few landowners in the vicinity of the coast and, for many years, one of the largest was the Church. Only the dissolution of the monasteries in the 1530s brought these properties into wider ownership. This additionally occurred at the time that London was starting to suffer from a timber famine, thereby stimulating the search for alternative sources of energy. The mines from which the coal was extracted were nothing like the great enterprises that exist today. As mentioned above, they employed probably no more than a dozen people and they were either simple drift mines cut into a hill or cliff, or they were bell pits dug out from a single shaft sunk into the ground. These pits could only extract coal from a restricted area at the bottom of the shaft because of the danger of rockfalls and the lack of ventilation provided by only one entrance. Indeed, it was not until the Hartley Colliery disaster in 1862, when 204 men suffocated at the bottom of a shaft because they had no other means of escape, that it became mandatory for two shafts to be sunk in every coal mine. As far as mining techniques were concerned, the introduction of improved ventilation through the use of brattices (doors or screens) to guide fresh air through the mines started in the 1750s. The decade also saw the introduction of pit ponies for the first time and, in this context, it is strange to consider that they were still employed in a handful of collieries in the 1980s. Whilst these improvements cannot be considered revolutionary they certainly helped mines to increase output to match the increase in demand that was occasioned by the industrial revolution in other sectors of the economy.
1.2.2
Water removal
Access to capital was important as the industry developed and expanded because of the need to pay for the technological improvements that were being made and could increase the production of coal from a mine. In particular, the development of the steam pumping engine was important as it enabled mechanical rather than manual removal of water from most underground mines accessed by a shaft. In 1698 Thomas Savery devised a steam pumping engine for the
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 5
The coal industry
removal of water from underground mines in Cornwall. Unfortunately, the pump was inefficient in its energy consumption and it was necessary for Thomas Newcomen to make energy saving innovations in 1708 before the pump became more commercially viable. Demand for the modified pumps then spread across the country and by the start of the industrial revolution in the mid-eighteenth century there were around 100 pumping engines in the Tyne and Wear district.
1.2.3
Gas detection
There was only one major advance in the production of coal during the industrial revolution ± and some said at the time that it should not have been considered as an advance at all. This was the invention of the Safety Lamp. The need for safe illumination underground was well recognised in the industry and the sinking of deeper mines in order to increase output necessitated the development of a new method. This was because the deeper a mine, the poorer and more restricted its ventilation. In 1812 an explosion in the Brandling Main (or Felling) Colliery, near Durham, led to the formation of the Sunderland Society for the Prevention of Accidents in Coalmines. In 1815 the society appealed to Sir Humphry Davy to investigate methods of improving the safety of illuminating the mines, and this led to his development of the Safety Lamp. While Sir Humphry Davy later won most of the credit for the invention, his was only one of three lamps developed between 1813 and 1815, and it seems to have worked by default as he did not understand the real reasons for the success of the lamp. The other lamps were produced by Dr Clanny and George Stephenson and worked on a similar principle, restricting the amount and temperature of the air passing over the flame and thereby reducing the risk of an explosion that would have resulted from higher temperature combustion. The problem the miners faced as a result of these advances was that they were then able to extract coal from areas with poorer ventilation. This increased the potential problems of asphyxiation as a result of excess amounts of carbon dioxide (blackdamp or chokedamp) and the poisonous carbon monoxide (afterdamp) rather than the explosive methane (firedamp). This situation led to a comment by John Buddle to the 1829 House of Lords Committee into the mines
Chapter 1/page 6
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
that `we are working mines from having the advantage of the safety lamp, that we could not have possibly worked without it'. Although it was not recognised at the time, poor ventilation would have enhanced the likelihood of the miners contracting pneumoconiosis and other respiratory disorders.
1.2.4
Mechanical mining
If mechanisation is used as a strict definition of industrialisation then the industrial revolution of the British coal-mining industry did not start in earnest until the beginning of the twentieth century. The first real industrial advance was the introduction of mechanical cutting tools in the late nineteenth century but by 1900 they only accounted for 1% of the total of 228.4 Mt of coal mined in the country. The further developments of power loading and mechanical conveying were not introduced until the 1920s and 1940s, respectively, leaving the British coal-mining industry at the bottom of the world productivity table. This is not to say that there were no important innovations in the industry except for the development of the Safety Lamp. Indeed, in 1777, long before it was used above ground, the cast iron rail was being employed by Joseph Curr to aid underground transport. A wheeled corf, or wagon, was also invented by him to run on the rails and had the advantage of being able to be hauled straight up the shaft with no need to move the coal from one container to another, again reducing costs. These corfs were also hauled along the tracks using pit ponies rather than the women and boys who had previously been employed for the task. This meant that the miners could keep more of their money without the need to pay others to haul their coal out of the mine. However, it also meant that there was a large number of unemployed women and girls in the mining towns and villages and this labour attracted the textile millers who were setting up at the time. The delay in the implementation and introduction of new techniques and equipment was one of the reasons behind Britain's poor performance in the years between the two world wars. Whilst the productivity of a mine, of necessity, declines with age, a move to mechanical cutting and power loading can increase the output per man-shift considerably. However, one of the difficulties of moving to
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 7
The coal industry
the new techniques was that many of the mines had already been constructed before the advances were made. As a result, the cost of altering the existing mine infrastructure was too great to overcome, especially because the availability of relatively cheap labour meant that the extra expense did not need to be justified.
1.3 Costs and capital As the early operations were small-scale affairs they had little need for capital beyond the work that was put into them by the miners. In 1350 a mine at Coundon near Bishop Auckland in Durham cost 5 shillings (s) and 6d to set up, including the cost of ropes, scopes and windlass. Prior to the development of efficient pumps the mines would not have been very deep so it did not take long until a new mine began producing coal and paying its way. Hence what might appear to be a relatively low cost of capital. There are other examples of the industry from the period which include lease payments for the land from which the coal was produced. Lease payments were a significant part of the total cost of coal and by the seventeenth century they had been transferred into royalties specifying a payment based on the production from the mine. This was deemed necessary because the landowners started to realise that the coal was a wasting asset and that they should seek some return from this asset rather than the use of the land from which it was produced. When a landowner wanted to let out the production of a particular area the miners could be charged both rents and royalties. The leases that were offered were normally for a period of 21 years at most and were sometimes only for a shorter period. This meant that the first mines were only relatively short-life operations and that large amounts of capital could not be recouped unless the owner had the freehold rights to the property and could be guaranteed long-term tenure. These royalties were initially very high in comparison with the royalty fees that are payable today, although this was partially due to the high rates of inflation during the period 1540 to 1620. By the late seventeenth century royalty rates averaged 5d/t, although some were as high as 1s/t, around a quarter of the pit-head selling price. In his
Chapter 1/page 8
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations Adam Smith mentions that `in coal mines a fifth of the gross produce is a very great rent; . . . and it is seldom a rent certain, but depends upon the occasional variations in the produce'. One reason for these high rents, or royalties, was because of the one-third rents that were paid on agricultural produce at the time. The mention that the one-fifth payment is `a very great rent' is to emphasise that it is still less than agricultural rents despite the much lower security offered by mining operations. Smith expanded this by stating that the variations in production `are so great that, in a country where thirty years' purchase is considered as a moderate price for the property of a landed estate, ten years' purchase is regarded as a good price for that of a coal-mine'. The expansion of industry during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries required ever larger amounts of coal and the consumers also became dependent upon a secure source of supply. Both of these factors were important in the move of many manufacturers and merchants into the coal mining business, in addition to the need to control the cost of supply. This is shown in Gray's Chorographia, in 1649, where he mentions a group of Londoners buying 30 year mining leases on the Tyne. One of the advantages that these early entrepreneurs and capitalists had was a cheap source of capital. Even though inflation was relatively high during the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, the Usury Laws kept the cost of capital very low. The maximum rate of interest that could be charged was lowered from 10% to 8% in 1625 and then further reduced to 6% in 1657 and 5% in 1714. Subsequently, in 1720, the bursting of the South Sea Bubble led to the introduction of legislation that effectively halted the development of equity financed companies with limited liability. Until the `Bubble Act' was repealed in the nineteenth century, only a few companies were set up with the equivalent of limited liability under the aegis of a Royal Charter. Consequently, most of the development of the coal-mining industry was undertaken by groups of merchants who had access to family capital and who could also borrow money from each other. In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries one further constraint on the mechanisation of the British coal mines was the lack of available capital in the industry. This was exacerbated by the great
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 9
The coal industry
railway boom of the 1840s, which also attracted much of the free capital available. Indeed, by December 1845 there were 260 different railway shares (including preference and debenture stock rather than just basic equity capital) quoted on the London Stock Exchange, and in 1846 a total of 273 railway bills received Royal Assent. These new companies were made possible by the 1844 Registration Act which was then extended by a second Act in 1856 that offered limited liability to all companies registered under the 1844 Act. Whilst new companies went straight to the equity market for funds, many private concerns in the coal, engineering and iron industries just took advantage of the protection offered by limited liability status. This was particularly important because a profitable mine could be brought down by the bankruptcy of a shareholder. It was intended that the removal of personal liability would prevent this from happening.
1.4 Transport Whilst the nineteenth century development of the railways boosted demand for coal the inadequate transport network in earlier centuries forced up the price of coal away from the pit-head. It was not until the 1750s and 1760s that canals, and other advances in transportation, helped to reduce the price of coal to levels that started to stimulate demand. These years also saw an increase in coal exports from England and Wales and began the start of a major export industry for the country (Fig. 1.3). The middlemen who transported coal by sea to London also charged for their services, and the retail price of the coal was about 24s 3d for a London chaldron at Westminster in 1700. The `chaldron' was a unit of weight that was in use in both London and the Tyne. However, the Tyne chaldron seems to have varied in size over time thereby making comparisons difficult. In London the chaldron was equivalent to some 28.5 hundredweight or 3192 lbs (1.45 t) and the price of coal therefore works out at some 16s 9d/t ± a mark-up of about 600%. The high rates of inflation during the period may take some of the blame for this but much of the increase in price is related to the actual cost of transport. Nevertheless, the merchants had something of a monopoly on the transport of the coal from the coalfields to London and made use
Chapter 1/page 10
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
1.3 United Kingdom coal exports 1697±1939 (source: Kernot, 1993; Mitchell & Deane).
of this by making sure that their profits kept pace with the inflation of the period. In 1590 the Lord Mayor of London complained that the price of coal had risen from 4s to 9s a chaldron since the early 1580s when the Grand Lease of Newcastle traders was set up as a monopoly. In 1600 the Grand Lease was formally incorporated by Royal Charter as the Company of Hostmen. There were originally 24 important partners in the Grand Lease but by 1622 the number of members of the Company of Hostmen had grown to 31, as the profitability of the enterprise became known. As the cost of coal transport in the early 1700s was so great, the expanding metal mines started to ship their output to the coalfields rather than the other way around. For instance the much greater amount of coal needed to smelt the copper and tin produced from the mines of Devon and Cornwall meant that it was cheaper to take the ore to Swansea for smelting where coal was around half the price that would have to be paid in Cornwall. Coal still had to be transported to Devon and Cornwall to power the pumping engines but this was relatively insignificant in comparison with the amount of coal needed in the smelting operations. Bristol also lost out to the cheaper fuel from Wales despite its better position to supply end markets. Indeed, by 1750 over half of the total copper and lead production of the country was smelted on the south Wales coalfield.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 11
The coal industry
1.4.1
Canals cut costs
The British road network was poorly maintained and often impassable during spells of bad weather. This meant that internal trade was often slow and expensive and that access to many parts of the country in the mid-eighteenth century remained difficult despite the vast expansion in navigable rivers. Where canals had been started they were only relatively modest in scope and did not have a great effect on the movement of produce. However, the last 30 years of the eighteenth century saw a massive move to canal construction with the result that many prices fell, sometimes drastically, as the availability of produce increased. In 1724 there were some 1000 miles of navigable rivers, an amount that had doubled over the previous century. For instance, Liverpool council stated its desire to improve the waterways in the south Lancashire and Cheshire district and ordered surveys to be taken to help in the task. In particular, they wanted to improve transportation between the river Ribble and the Wigan coalfield, and along the Mersey, both south using the river Weaver to get to the Cheshire saltfield at Winsford and north up the river Irwell to that coalfield. The most famous canal of the period was that constructed for the Second Duke of Bridgewater between 1759 and 1761, in furtherance of a project started by his father. The canal was built by James Brindley and included an aqueduct and 42 miles of underground waterway to take the Duke's coal from his colliery at Worsley almost to Manchester. The last stretch of the canal into Manchester was completed in 1763 and was helped by the low level of interest rates at the time. The construction of the canal at a price of some 10 000 guineas a mile halved the price of coal in Manchester and led to a massive increase in the number of other canal proposals. Indeed, like motorways that attract traffic, the reduction in the price of coal brought about by canals stimulated and increased demand to such an extent that they provided a high initial return on investment. Such was the increase in the demand for coal from the Duke's mine that he is reported to have said that `a navigation should have coals at the heel of it'. And in 1785 J Phillips' book A Treatise on Inland Navigation stated that the Duke's `mine had lain dormant in the bowels of the earth from time immemorial without the least profit
Chapter 1/page 12
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
to the noble owner, on account of the price of land carriage which was so excessive that they [the coals] could not be sold at a reasonable price'. The success of the Bridgewater Canal and the massive boom in canal construction across the country can be shown by the large number of Private Bills sponsored through Parliament to authorise the building of the new waterways. Of the 165 Canal Acts that were passed through Parliament between 1758 and 1802 there were 90 that expected coal to be the major commodity carried. The main link from the Midlands to London was started in 1793 and completed in 1805 when French privateers were causing trouble along the coastal routes. Additionally, a total of 160 miles in the vicinity of Birmingham gave a great impetus to the construction of collieries in the Midlands coalfield as they gave access to the sea as well as to London. Between 1724 and 1815 the increase in the availability of water transport had been phenomenal, with a further doubling in the length of navigable rivers to 2000 miles and some 2200 miles of canal network had also been constructed.
1.4.2
The age of the train
The invention of the rotary steam engine and the age of the train led to a massive increase in the demand for coal. Not only was it required for the obvious powering of the engines themselves but also it was needed to make the iron both for the trains and for the tracks. The great age of the railways really started in the 1840s and continued for much of the rest of the century, helping to spur the development of the coal-mining industry at the same time. Indeed, between 1841 and 1901 the mining areas attracted around 500 000 people from rural parts of England and Wales and by 1851 there were 216 000 men and 3000 women employed as coal miners throughout the country. Although the Stockton and Darlington, the first public railway line with a moving steam powered engine, did not open until 27 September 1825, the initial work on steam engines had started at the end of the eighteenth century. This was encouraged by the need to transport the coal from the pit-head to roads or rivers where it could then be shipped to other parts of the country. Initially, during the seventeenth century, large collieries placed wood on the ground to ease the movement of wagons. In the early eighteenth century the
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 13
The coal industry
greater availability of iron meant that the wood started to be replaced by iron plates, particularly at bends where the wear was greatest. In 1767 the first track was laid by Richard Reynolds from Coalbrookdale to the river Severn. It used rails with flanges to keep the wagons in place but, as this was found to be inefficient at keeping the wagons on the rails, the flanges were transferred from the track to the wheel following the advice of John Smeaton in 1789. The Stockton and Darlington was a particularly important railway in view of its effect on the movement of materials. Like the development of the canals some 40 years earlier, this railway's prime motive was to transport coal in order to break the effective monopoly on the production and distribution of coal held by the colliery owners of the Tyne. The construction of the railway was intended to open up the country to the south so that new mines could be dug and the monopoly broken. It was the idea of a group of three Quaker businessmen, Pease, Richardson and Backhouse, and was made possible because of the invention of a movable engine rather than one that was fixed in position and wound wagons using a cable. The power of the engine had also been increased by George Stephenson who was able to improve engine efficiency by increasing the draught of the fire box so that it could pull more than its own weight. He first built locomotives for the Killingworth Colliery in 1814 and served as the engineer for the Stockton and Darlington railway. This experience must have helped him to win the Rainhill competition on the Liverpool and Manchester line between 6 and 14 October 1829, which showed that steam engines could offer faster travel than other alternatives. As with the canals, the opening of new railway lines reduced the price of coal in the areas they served, and this helped to increase the demand for the product. By the end of the 1840s a skeleton network of some 5000 miles of track had been completed, whilst by 1886 the final total of 16 700 miles of track had been laid. Overall, however, there were periods during which the expansion of the mining industry could not keep pace with the development of the railways and the price of coal was forced up. This was often only a local effect in areas of iron and steel production as manufacturers needed to purchase coal in order to maintain and increase output. It must also be related to the integration of many coal and iron companies which would supply their own plants first before selling any excess production on the open
Chapter 1/page 14
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
1.4 Coal prices fob export 1831±1913 (source: Mitchell & Deane).
market. If there was insufficient coal to meet demand then the price would be forced up because of the need to transport it from collieries further afield. The fall in price is shown if Fig 1.4 is compared with Fig 1.1 detailing the price of coal delivered to Westminster School in London. Fig 1.4 also includes a real price index to show how the deflation of much of the nineteenth century led to a real rise in the price of coal.
1.5 The social cost There can be no discussion of the history of coal-mining without reference to the social cost of the industry. The early miners in the United Kingdom had little in the way of protection and rights of employment and the yearly bond by which a miner was tied to a specific colliery was often the subject of a dispute. The other main problem covered the legislation of the period with one particular Act in 1610 stating that any able-bodied person who even threatened to run away from his or her parish could be sent to a house of correction and be treated like a vagabond. The other restriction of the yearly bond was that it would last for a year less one day. This was because of the Poor Law legislation which meant that a parish had to look after any inhabitant who had
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 15
The coal industry
spent more than one year within its boundaries. If a miner had to travel to a different parish to work there was often much disaffection between the new arrivals and the original inhabitants. This was particularly the case with small villages far from large-scale habitation that could be overwhelmed by an influx of miners to open up a new colliery. In 1606 the inhabitants of a Shropshire village complained to their landlord that the new colliery had brought with it `a number of lewd persons, the scum and dregs of many [counties] from whence they have been driven'. As already mentioned, the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries saw an increasing amount of industrial specialisation as miners started to concentrate fully on mining with little time spent on the farms of their landlords except, perhaps, at harvest time. The sparse population in many rural areas also failed to help matters as the increasing need for manpower meant that local food production could not be maintained if a mine was to be opened up. It was therefore necessary to import labour into new coalfields and to ignore the resentment shown by the indigenous population. One of the areas particularly deficient in inhabitants was Wales and the Society of the Mines Royal was given the right to conscript labour in the country in 1625. The power of the local lord was often sufficient to put down any complaint during the pre-industrial age. This was partly because of the relatively small number of employees working in any one mine and partly because of the still feudal nature of society at that time. Indeed, the feudal nature of the coal-mining industry in Scotland continued into the nineteenth century with the employees being included in any purchase agreement over a mine. It is only during the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries that the increasing size of the workforce meant that it could start to organise itself to greater effect. It was also the case that the increasing move to towns and cities meant that the feudal system started to break down and that the control that could have been exercised in the past became less effective. The increasing wealth of merchants and the power that this conferred on them also meant that the authority of a local lord was reduced. The merchants then came to usurp the previous system of feudal control and often purchased property directly, whether for mining or agricultural purposes or both. One of the most significant Parliamentary enquiries into the state
Chapter 1/page 16
# Charles Kernot
Coal from the earliest times
of employment in the British coal mines was the First Report of the Commissioners on the Employment of Children, which covered their employment in coal mines and was published in 1842. The Commissioners set themselves to look at 14 separate aspects of children's employment, including their ages and the hours that they were expected to work. One of the most revealing details was the very young age of many of the children who worked in the pits, often with very little supervision and left for long periods on their own in the dark. `The lowness of the roof or the thinness of the bed of coal . . . is no doubt the cause of employing boys instead of horses or asses' to move the coal was one of the conclusions of the report, which found children as young as six or seven at work. The publication of the report led directly to the Mines Act of 1842, which forbade the employment of boys under ten and all females with a penalty of £5 to £10 for each offence. The numbers of people employed per thousand adult males (of which there were around 200 000 at the time) is shown in Table 1.1. This preoccupation with the value of life in the industry led to the formation of some of the most militant unions to represent the miners in their claims for better pay for the work which they undertook in such frightening conditions. Table 1.1 Number of individuals employed in British coal mines per 1000 adult males County
Adult Females
Leicestershire Derbyshire Yorkshire Lancashire South Durham Northumberland & N Durham Mid Lothian East Lothian West Lothian Stirlingshire Clackmannanshire Fifeshire W. Scotland Monmouthshire Glamorganshire Pembrokeshire
22 86 333 338 192 228 202 184 19 424
13 to 18 Males Females 227 240 352 352 226 266 307 332 289 283 246 243 223 302 239 366
36 79 184 296 154 129 213 109 19 119
Under 13 Males Females 180 167 246 195 184 186 131 164 180 184 142 100 99 154 157 196
41 27 52 103 109 107 87 34 12 19
Source: First report of the Commissioners on the Employment of children in mines.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 1/page 17
The coal industry
1.6 The start of unionism Many of the problems of poor working and living conditions were beyond the control of the miners during the nineteenth century. The British population was increasing at a much faster rate than in earlier centuries and this led to a greater pressure on the workforce to find employment. This meant that there was often little option but to accept the conditions laid down by the mine's management during the early part of the period. Indeed, the lower standing of the workforce can be seen from the civil offence with which employers were charged for breach of employment contract, rather than the criminal offence with which the employee would have been charged for a similar offence. As time progressed, the widening of the voting register helped to introduce a fairer spread of views in Parliament with a succession of Commissions, Enquiries and Acts during the century. As far as the mining community was concerned, the first whisperings of unionism had started in the years following the defeat of the French at Waterloo. The recession between 1825 and 1840 led to the start of several small unions that sometimes succeeded in achieving their aims and were sometimes defeated by the employers. Nevertheless, as the scale of industrial operations became larger, it became necessary to treat the workforce on a collective basis. It followed that the repeal of the 1799 and 1800 Combination Acts was required so that the formation of employee groups, which could engage in collective bargaining, was possible. These Acts were repealed in 1824 and 1825. The spread of political thought also moved into the mining communities during the nineteenth century, although there appears to have been little influence from the Chartist movement in the 1840s. This may have been part of the reason for the delay in the miners getting the right to vote until the Reform Act of 1884. This followed from the previous Act of 1867 (when working men in towns were enfranchised) and the widening of the franchise and redistribution of seats which was given in 1832. Despite this the first miners to be elected to Parliament in 1874 were Alexander Macdonald and Thomas Burt, both of whom sat as Liberals.
Chapter 1/page 18
# Charles Kernot
2 International discoveries 2.1
Introduction
2.2
Australia
2.3
Bulgaria
2.4
China
2.5
Hungary
2.6
Indonesia
2.7
Poland
2.8
South Africa
2.9
United States of America
# Charles Kernot
2.1 Introduction During the eighteenth century, the transport of coal in coasters from the north-east coast to its main market in London meant that the fuel started to become important to Britain's shipping industry. The expansion of the British colonies also made an important contribution to the size of the British fleet as a consequence of increasing trade, and this saw coal transported internationally to meet specific areas of demand. The nineteenth century development of steel production increased the amount of steel-hulled shipping and encouraged the use of steam engines for propulsion, thereby generating an increased demand for coal in locations further away from the source of supply. Initially, these steam ships were recharged with coal transported from the United Kingdom's own mines and stored in purpose-built bunkers around the world. However, the discovery of coal in other locations encouraged the development of local production given the economic advantages this offered. In addition to the need for coal to power growing international trade, the economic growth of many countries also increased their demand for energy ± and hence coal. The early industrial heartlands of the United States were centred in areas where coal was readily available to provide cheap power. This was also true of France, where the steel and metallurgical industries were centred in the north-east of the country and in the central region of the Massif Central, where coal and iron ores were also available. Moreover, as indicated in the previous chapter, the United Kingdom did not hold onto its market dominance for long. Indeed, mines developed with the technology of the eighteenth or early nineteenth centuries were unable to compete with the mines constructed later in the nineteenth or in the early twentieth centuries. Indeed, the first mines effectively just scraped coal from the surface ± with little need for deep mining and the associated high requirements for and costs of both capital and labour. Coal deposits in other parts of the world benefited from nearsurface locations, which had been exhausted in the United Kingdom, and also from very amenable geology. This meant that the coal could be mined more easily and efficiently ± especially with the benefit of newly devised techniques, which would be expensive to retrofit into
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 1
The coal industry
existing mines ± and this helped other industrialising countries, particularly the United States, to overtake the United Kingdom's economic dominance in the early part of the twentieth century. It is interesting to note that whilst countries like Belgium and France increased coal production rapidly in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, their industries have now almost completely closed. This reflects the low level of reserves present in these countries, which meant that they were unable to sustain demand for any considerable length of time. The United States, conversely, saw a steady increase in production into the middle of the twentieth century but then, as oil became the dominant source of energy, there was a marked decline in local coal production. This situation is now reversing with increasing demand for electricity ± which can often be more economically generated from coal. Figures 2.1 and 2.2 show coal production in the United States and France to indicate the different levels of output from the two countries, and can be compared with Fig. 1.2, which details coal production in the United Kingdom. In recent years, the global coal sector has seen some consolidation. This has been driven by low coal prices and a desire of some organisations to stem losses, whilst others have hoped to improve profitability through economies of scale and other mining-related benefits. Strategic decisions by the major oil-producing companies to pull out of coal-mining, so that they can concentrate on their core oilbased operations, have also influenced mergers and acquisitions across the sector. This strategy has seen disposals by Arco and Shell,
2.1 US coal production 1831±1998 (source: EIA, OECD; Facts about coal; Author).
Chapter 2/page 2
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
2.2 French coal production 1850±1997 (source:OECD; Author).
whilst other oil companies such as Total (especially now that it has merged with Elf), Exxon and BP Amoco may not be far behind. The coal assets that have been offered in this way have largely been purchased by large conglomerate mining companies rather than by companies concentrating on the sector. This is a strange situation given the wide-ranging acquisitions of operations in the aluminium sector by companies such as Alcoa and Alcan, which would offer them the opportunity to supply customers on a truly global basis. The same is true of the copper sector, but coal mines have either been subsumed into large organisations or have been bought by coal-mining companies with operations in a single country. The other point to bear in mind is that the companies that have bought into coal assets have not been selective about the type of coal purchased, which means that most coal-miners have a range of coking and thermal coal operations. Whilst there are synergies offered by a knowledge of coal-mining technology and techniques the ability to market and sell the final product is paramount for a successful operation. In this case, the two different markets for steam and coking coal are not served by dedicated organisations but, rather, by companies with a broad specialisation across the sector. From an international perspective it is also important to ensure that any acquisition of a mine or a deposit has sufficient infrastructure and access to enable the mine to operate with minimal additional costs. Furthermore, an existing or potential market in the form of a local electricity producer or steel mill could well add to the attraction
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 3
The coal industry
of an operation. This is because it may be able to sell the coal at either the same or at a slightly lower delivered price than that obtainable by the consumer from other sources but still at a higher price than it could obtain elsewhere. If coal is being produced for the export market then access to road, rail or sea will be of prime importance and is one of the reasons for the impressive development of the Australian coal-mining industry.
2.2 Australia The first non-Aboriginal discovery of coal in Australia was made by William Bryant, an escaping convict, at the mouth of the Hunter River near Newcastle in New South Wales in 1791. Subsequently, in 1797, the first coal mines were built, supplying the bulk of the country's domestic needs. Moreover, the relative proximity of Australia to the other British colonies of the Pacific and Indian oceans helped in the development of an export industry and in 1799 coal was the first mined product to be exported from Australia when it was shipped to Bengal, India. At that time, annual exports only amounted to some 4000 t in comparison with New South Wales's current exports of around 75 Mt. The first official coal-mining operations were set up as a monopoly by the State Governor, Philip Gidley King in 1801, and employed convicts as miners in increasing numbers. By 1804 some 128 convicts worked in the operations, increasing to 553 in 1817. Even the first private mining operation employed more convicts than free men from its foundation in 1831 until 1843. This operation was set up near Newcastle by the Australian Agricultural Company (AAC) and produced 40 000 t in its first 12 months of operation, supplying coal to various steamships including Sophia Jane, the first paddle-wheel steamer to enter the Sydney Heads. Like the first government-run mine, AAC's operation was run as a monopoly but this was eventually overturned in 1847 and production expanded dramatically so that by 1868 it had increased to 18 times the 1848 level. Mining production in New South Wales continued to expand, reaching 1.3 Mt in 1881, 1.5 Mt in 1888 (when total Australian output reached 2.5 Mt) and 3.5 Mt in 1900 as more deposits were discovered and mines constructed. Some of these deposits contained coal with
Chapter 2/page 4
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
better characteristics than the initial discoveries, including the Borehole Seam near Newcastle (1850) and the Bulli Seam in the Illawarra district, which was found in the 1850s and contained a good coking coal. The development of associated industries, such as coke manufacture, iron- and steel-making and town gas generation for street lighting, increased demand, and production from these discoveries was able to provide supplies. One of the least expected locations for a coal mine is under Sydney harbour but construction of the Sydney Harbour Colliery started in 1897 after drilling proved the geological theory of a deep coal basin in the area. At this time the attraction of reduced transport costs offset the 2900 feet depth of the 10 foot coal seam discovered by the drilling, even though only a relatively small proportion of the coal could be extracted given the requirement to support the roof of the mine. Shaft-sinking took five years to complete and, initially, intersected several thin seams. This disappointment led to the reconstruction of the company and a decision to mine in the direction of the original drillhole discovery. Whilst the thickness of the seam improved, the company failed to generate any cash and mining eventually ceased in 1915. In 1924 the mine was restarted by Sydney Collieries Ltd but continuing financial problems required a second capital reconstruction as a co-operative, with the miners operating as the Balmain Coal Contracting Company Ltd. This scheme was successful for a short time but by 1931 the worldwide depression and industrial problems forced the companies into liquidation. Some work has since been undertaken looking into the possibility of extracting methane from the coal seam but this, too, has proved unsuccessful. In 1909 the mines in New South Wales were paralysed by a lengthy strike, and Victoria, which had relied on New South Wales for its coal, looked for alternative sources of supply. Coal had already been discovered at Wonthaggi, 150 km north of Melbourne, and the state government authorised the development of an emergency coal mine to stave off the threat to local industry caused by the closure of the New South Wales collieries. With a depression in the local gold-mining areas around Bendigo, the new mine attracted over 2000 individuals with aspirations of working in a state-controlled operation. Unfortunately, state ownership did not live up to expectations with the local authority refusing to
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 5
The coal industry
give the mine a monopoly position in supplying Victorian demand. Moreover, the colliery was placed under the management of the railways department, which had little practical knowledge or understanding of the industry. Strikes occurred even in the early years of operation and continued to be a factor of the entire life of the Wonthaggi State Coal Mine, which became a hotbed of Australian unionism. This was enhanced by the dire working conditions at the colliery and by the loss of at least 80 lives during the 59 years that the mine was in operation. Over this time the miners produced at least 16 Mt of coal, sometimes waist-deep in water, given the proximity of the mine to the sea. Nevertheless, the colliery eventually closed due to exhaustion on 20 December 1968.
2.3 Bulgaria The first state-owned coal mine opened in Bulgaria in 1891 and production increased rapidly thereafter to meet increasing local demand for the fuel. From output of around 130 000 t/year in 1900 production rose to 6 Mt/year by 1950. In the initial years all mining was carried out using underground techniques but, as equipment became larger and more efficient, open pit mining was also practised, as at the Maritza Iztok mine which opened in 1950. Peak production from Bulgaria's mines of around 38.5 Mt/year was achieved between 1986 and 1989, although production has since fallen considerably. The active mines still contain significant reserves and resources including 2.7 bn t of lignite, 324 Mt of brown coal and 11 Mt of black coal, which is still not considered a high quality coal. Internal consumption of coal is 85% for electricity generation, 4% for heating and 11% for other purposes. From the consumer's viewpoint, coal generates 39% of Bulgaria's electricity and provides 70% of domestic heat and power. This is achieved through 12 coal production companies, which have all been transformed into joint stock companies. The companies control over 20 mines, which in 1997 produced a combined total of 30 Mt, utilising both open pit and underground extraction methods. Bulgaria's coalfields can be zoned according to the quality of the coal that they contain. The south-west energy region stretches
Chapter 2/page 6
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
westwards from Sofia to south-west Bulgaria and includes the Sofia, Pernik, Bobov Dol and Oranovo Simitli coalfields, where a pilot mine closure programme has been initiated. The Marishki energy region comprises the east and west Maritza coalfields and the mines are located close to the regional power plants. Finally, the Sliven energy region comprises the Cerno More and Balkan mines, and is located in eastern Bulgaria.
2.4 China Coal-mining was one of the few major industries that had been developed before the Communist takeover of China, with production previously peaking at 66 Mt in 1942. This level of production was next seen in 1952 as the country recovered from the civil war that brought the Communists to power. The subsequent introduction of the country's first five year plan led to a resurgence in output growth as a direct result of increasing investment in the industry to about 12% of the State's total industrial budget. The second five year plan led to an emphasis on small-scale mining (which is now being closed down ± see Chapter 9) but this was not without problems at the time and between 1957 and 1960 about 110 000 small operations were opened in an attempt to increase local self-sufficiency. By 1974 small mining operations accounted for around 28% of total coal production within China. Most coal in the country is steaming or semi-soft coking and China, therefore, still needs to import hard coking coal to supplement its indigenous needs. In the period before 1960 growth in China's coal production was nearly 20% per year, but this fell markedly in the following 15 years to an average of only 2.8% per year. As a consequence of both the slowing in output growth and increasing oil and natural gas production, the overall share of coal in China's primary energy supply mix has fallen from almost 100% to only 73% of the total. Output of coal in China is detailed in Fig 2.3. The privatisation programme in China now means that many of the larger coal mining operations are looking for outside sources of capital. Two mining companies have so far been listed on local stock exchanges (Yanzhou Coal and Yitai Energy) and although the programme was halted in the late 1990s, as a consequence of
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 7
The coal industry
2.3 Chinese coal production (source: Howe, 1978; China Coal Industry Yearbooks; Author).
economic instability across the Asian region and the low price of coal, it is expected to restart as economic growth picks up. China's known coal reserves of 264 500 Mt place the country third in the world league table, after those of the CIS and the United States. Most of the coal deposits are present in rocks of Carboniferous, Permian or Jurassic geological age, but have a great advantage in that the seams are often very thick, flat and shallow. These factors help to reduce mining costs, although they also sometimes require innovative mining techniques such as sub-level caving above a longwall, with the coal drawn from behind the supports. The recoverable tonnage of coal is split between 129.5 bn t of bituminous coal, 81.7 bn t of sub-bituminous coal and 53.3 bn t of lignite. In 1991 the average heating value of all coal mined in China was 22 GJ/t, with a sulphur content of 1.1% and an ash content of 30%. Two-thirds of all reserves are situated in the provinces of Shanxi, Shaanxi and Inner Mongolia. The bulk of the country's reserves of coal are located in western China, although only a modest proportion of output comes from the region as demand is concentrated in the east of the country. This problem is being addressed in many ways but mainly through investment in infrastructure. This is shown by the 2.5 times increase in the transport of coal between regions between 1952 and 1956, and that by 1956 coal accounted for 40% of all rail freight and remains at a very high level.
Chapter 2/page 8
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
2.4 Hungarian coal production (source: SZEÂSZEK; Author).
2.5 Hungary Peak production of coal in Hungary was in 1965 when some 31 Mt was produced from 134 coal mines that employed between 125 000 and 130 000 individuals. The number of coal mines has fallen consistently since then with 20 mines in 1996 and 19 in 1998. About 90% of the coal production in the country is destined for electricity generation (see Fig 2.4). By the start of the 1980s, the coal-mining industry in Hungary, centred around eight districts and was controlled through the  ). The district around National Ore and Mineral Mines Company (OEÂA Mecsek in south Hungary produces hard coal, although the majority of the country's production is of brown coal, from mines spread along the northern border with Slovakia. The first deposits are situated along the Austrian border to the west, then moving eastwards, there are the Ajka, OrosziaÂny and TatabaÂnya regions. To the east of Budapest the Borsod region sits along the Slovakian border, whilst just inland is the MaÂtra district, which is a lignite producing area. During the 1990s the Hungarian Government instituted a process of change across all sectors of the economy, with local prices starting to move towards world market levels. Unfortunately for the coal industry, this meant that prices were lowered and this, in turn, led to an increase in debt as local mining companies were unable to reduce costs to match the fall in prices. Indeed, during the
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 9
The coal industry
period 1991±6 the coal-mining industry received subsidies of Ft4938 m (US$40 m). In 1990 the Hungarian Government set up the Restructuring Centre for Coal-Mining (SZEÂSZEK) to reorganise the structure of the industry. SZEÂSZEK, in turn, set up joint stock companies to control the mines and sell all of their output. The subsequent privatisation of the  began in 1991, with initial concentration on the metalliferous OEÂA mining activities of the organisation. One of the events that promoted the privatisation of the industry was the passing of enabling legislation by the Hungarian Government in 1993. The Mining Act introduced a range of Mining Laws that vested all in situ mineral resources in the state and allowed mining to be authorised by one of two routes. The first method is through a traditional permit granted to mining companies by district mining authorities for unclaimed areas. The other route is through a mining concession that covers closed areas. As with many Eastern European countries, most of the organisations had various subsidiary activities under their control, which had to be subsidised from their own budgets. As part of the initial move towards the privatisation of the industry the subsidiary companies were spun out into separate satellite organisations. At the same time the coal-mining companies were restructured into three organisations that integrated the coal mines with the power companies.
2.6 Indonesia Indonesia has long been known as a coal-producing nation and coal-mining is talked about by Joseph Conrad in some of his books set in the region around the end of the nineteenth century. Indeed, coalmining in the vicinity of Ombilin, some 55 km north-east of Padang, the capital of western Sumatra, has been known for at least 100 years. Nevertheless, production from the underground mine, Ombilin 1, has recently ceased due to the exhaustion of reserves, although it used to be trucked and railed to the port of Teluk Bayur for export and for domestic use at Padang. In southern Sumatra the coal basin covers an area of approximately 20 000 km2 and was investigated by Bataafsche Petroleum Maatschappij prior to 1942. Between 1975 and 1976 Shell Mijnbouw
Chapter 2/page 10
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
carried out a range of exploration work in the area, including general surveying and drilling, but did not proceed with any further investigation. The Directorate of Mineral Resources then regained the property and the state coal-mining company PT Tambang Batubara Bukit Asam (Persero), or PTBA, was established under Indonesian Government Regulation No 42 in 1980 and Notarial Deed No 1 on 2 March 1981. A further exploration and drilling programme on the property was authorised in January 1982. This work was carried out between 1983 and 1986 and concentrated on the northern flank of the Muara Tuga anticline. Nevertheless, economic exploitation was prevented by the inaccessibility of the deposit and the consequent inability to transport coal out of the area efficiently. The situation changed when a railway was constructed from the deposits in the Tanjung Enim region to the dedicated coal port of Tarahan on the south coast of Sumatra and some 420 km from the Tanjung Enim mining operations. A railway was also constructed to the dedicated coal port of Kertapati 165 km away and close to the capital of Sumatra, Palembang, which is located 180 km to the north-east of Tanjung Enim. PTBA then proceeded to develop the Tanjung Enim mining operations and now produces 9 Mt/year from a number of open pit mines in the vicinity of the town. In October 1990 Government Regulation No 56 merged PTBA with PT Perum Tambang Batubara so that all of the country's state coal-mining operations were controlled through one organisation. In 1996 all of Indonesia's coal was vested in PTBA, with the company receiving a royalty equivalent to 13.5% of all coal mined in the country. The royalty was payable in cash and was to be calculated on an ad valorem basis using the price at the point of sale. The royalty income was to have been paid to the government within one year of the date of receipt. This vesting has since been rescinded and independent coal-mining companies now pay their royalties directly to the Indonesian State. Indonesia's coal production in recent years and the phenomenal growth of production as a result of the construction of new mining operations in Kalimantan are detailed in Fig 2.5.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 11
The coal industry
2.5 Indonesian coal production (source: Indonesian Coal Mining Association).
2.7 Poland For the 40 years following the Second World War, Polish mining enterprises were encouraged to maximise tonnage, almost at any price. Economic reform measures were introduced in Poland between 1990 and 1992 and so the country is more concerned with ensuring that resources are mined to the best advantage. This is a factor underlined by the Geological and Mining Code that was introduced in 1994. In 1997 Poland's coal-mining industry suffered a fall in profitability of 5.7% against a fall of 0.4% for the mining industry as a whole. In early 1999 the Ministry of Environmental Protection, Natural Resources and Forestry introduced changes to the country's mineral resources policy. This centred on environmentally compatible development, ensuring security of energy supplies and a targeting of mineral output to ensure that it was commensurate with the country's needs.
2.8 South Africa The Vaal River coalfield was discovered in 1878 by George Stow, a geologist commissioned by the Orange Free State Volksraad to
Chapter 2/page 12
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
undertake a geological survey of the northern part of the Province. During his exploration work he discovered coal near the junction of the Vaal and the Taaiboschspruit rivers. The extent of the deposit was soon confirmed, stretching from Maccauvlei in the east to Leeuwspruit in the west. Unfortunately for Stow, the Volksraad had been hoping that the geologist would find precious metals or diamonds (which had been discovered elsewhere in South Africa over the preceding decade) and cut off his funding when he reported the discovery of a large deposit of coal. Convinced of the value of the coal, Stow looked elsewhere for a new source of funding. In the diamond town of Kimberley he met Sammy Marks, a Lithuanian who had emigrated to South Africa in 1868 and had become hugely successful in the diamond industry. Following Cecil Rhodes's introduction of water pumps, there was an increasing need for fuel in the Kimberley area and, recognising this, Marks formed an association, or Vereeniging, which included Stow, to acquire the land for exploitation of its coal resources. Stow was appointed the manager of the operation and trial mining for coal commenced in 1880. As this was a success, full development of the coalfield was undertaken and the Bedworth Colliery was established in 1882, producing 360 t in its first year and 720 t in 1884. Most of the production from the mine was destined for the diamond operations to the east, although the gold discoveries near what was to become Johannesburg also provided a potential new market. However, full access to Johannesburg awaited the development of a railway linking the coal mine across the country to north and south and providing additional contracted demand to fuel the trains. By the end of the 1880s the coal mine had branched out into associated businesses, particularly bricks, tiles and refractories, which could be produced from clays found adjacent to the coal deposits. Agriculture and forestry were also initiated on the land that the association had acquired, with the forestry division concentrating on the provision of timber for the mines. The need for additional capital encouraged the owners to look to the stock market, and Vereeniging Estates Limited was incorporated on 26 August 1897 with an initial capital of £730 000. By the Boer War, the company had expanded into two new mines, Cornelia and Central, but production suffered as a result of the conflict. The Central Mine
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 13
The coal industry
Table 2.1 Expansion history of Vereeniging Estates Colliery
Date
Bedworth Cornelia Central Largo Schoongezicht Vryheid Bertha Shaft at Cornelia
1882 By 1900 By 1900 Acquired early 1920s Acquired early 1920s Acquired 1928 1941 September 1945 Acquired 1949 Opened 1950s Opened 1950s Opened 1950s Acquired 1950s Acquired 1950s 1978 1979
Springbok New Largo Springfield Schoongezicht Two Blesbok Blinkpan Koolmyn Kleinkopje New Denmark
Comments
By 1926 output reaches 2m tons By 1933 output reaches 3m tons By 1941 output reaches 5m tons Acquired by Anglo American By 1949 output reaches 12m tons
By 1964 output reaches 16.7m tons
Source: Anglo American; Author.
was also the location for the conference of Boer generals that preceded the Peace Treaty in Pretoria. Vereeniging Estates also started to benefit from the further expansion of coal demand in southern Africa (see Table 2.1). This saw the negotiation of a contract in 1910 to supply the newly formed Victoria Falls and Transvaal Power Company, which undertook to construct a power station adjacent to the mine. Under the contract the company undertook to supply 200 000 t/year of coal over a 14 year period at a guaranteed profit of 1s/t. In the period leading up to the Second World War production continued to increase and in 1936 the group combined most of its mining interests with those of the African and European Investment Company to form Amalgamated Collieries, which remained controlled by Vereeniging Estates. After the war Anglo American acquired a controlling interest in Vereeniging Estates in order to obtain gold mine holdings in the western Free State; the coal assets were almost considered as a sideshow. Post-war expansion yielded additional coal supply contracts and underwrote the future of the group through the provision of a regular income from South Africa's electricity generating stations. By the 1950s some 60% of the group's output was sold directly to pithead power stations operated by the South African Electricity Supply
Chapter 2/page 14
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
Commission (Eskom). Anticipation of continued increases in the demand for electricity within South Africa encouraged the company to look for more deposits amenable to the construction of an accompanying power station. This led to successful tenders for the Arnot and Kriel power station contracts in 1965 and 1970, respectively. With the domestic market fully supplied, the company, together with its competitors in the Transvaal Coal Owners Association (TCOA), started to look internationally for new customers and expansion opportunities. In order to ensure international demand, it was first necessary to produce a low ash coal ± effectively increasing the energy content of the coal through the reduction of the amount of waste that would have to be transported. This was achieved by Vereeniging through a two-stage beneficiation process of coal produced from the Witbank No 2 seam, with the remaining fraction sold as steam coal to local power stations. The TCOA then had to develop a market for the coal, and negotiations commenced with Japanese steel mills. In 1971 the two sides reached an agreement whereby the TCOA members would supply 27.8 Mt of coal over a 14 year period, with Anglo American supplying some 10 Mt of the total. As a consequence of the inland location of the collieries, the most important part of the project was the development of sufficient rail and port infrastructure to ensure that the coal could be delivered on time and in the required quantities. This required further negotiations, also including South Africa's port and rail authorities and the choice of a site at Richards Bay for the Richards Bay Coal Terminal (RBCT). Following a successful conclusion of a 570 km railway, the port and associated handling facilities with an initial capacity of 12 Mt/year were soon under construction and were commissioned on 1 April 1976 at a cost of R43 m. By the end of the 1970s the coal terminal had been proven a success and had started on the first of many expansions ± the first of which led to an increase in capacity to 24 Mt/year at a cost of R34m. The third expansion of the terminal cost a total of R385 m and led to almost another doubling of capacity, to 44 Mt/year, and commenced in 1980. At this stage, however, South Africa was embroiled in an international outcry over the continuation of apartheid policies and suffered from the imposition of sanctions by many international
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 15
The coal industry
countries. This led to the loss of export markets in France, Denmark and Holland. Other countries were also expanding their international marketing of coal, and increasing competition developed from Australia, Colombia and the United States, depressing prices ± a situation exacerbated by the tail-off in global energy demand after the second oil shock. Nevertheless, in an attempt to reduce unit costs by increasing throughput the terminal embarked on its fourth expansion (known as the Phase 3 Upgrade) ± to 54.5 Mt/year in 1990±91 at a cost of R290 m. The latest, and final expansion, to 66.5 Mt/year at a cost of R205 m, was approved in 1996 and incremental expansions may be able to increase capacity to a maximum of around 70 Mt/year with current infrastructure. Coal is now produced from a total of 19 separate coalfields across South Africa, of which the 16 main areas are contained in six basins covering an area 500 km east±west and 700 km north±south. The rank of coal increases to the east, i.e. towards the port at Richards Bay, although the number and thickness of the seams tends to decrease. In the main bituminous coal-producing area of Transvaal/Gauteng the coal is mined from relatively thick seams, although anthracite production in KwaZulu Natal is from thin seams. Total recoverable reserves in the country are estimated at 55 bn t, of which only 1% is anthracite and 4% is of metallurgical quality.
2.9 United States of America The United States is now the second largest producer of coal in the world, after China. Coal was first used for baking clay by the Hopi Indians in what is now Arizona by AD1000. The first Europeans to record their discovery of the fuel were the Canadian-born Louis Jolliet and Father Jacques Marquette in Illinois in 1673, and then the La Salle expedition in 1680. It was later found by Huguenot settlers at Manakim on the James River near Richmond, Virginia, in 1701, where the first commercial mining started in 1748. As with the United Kingdom, the development of the railways and discovery of coal adjacent to sea or river transport spurred the domestic United States coal industry into life. The industrialisation of the country during the nineteenth century also spurred output growth,
Chapter 2/page 16
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
especially with the increase in iron and steel production during the century. Consumption continued to increase in the early part of the twentieth century, pushing up prices and encouraging new entrants to the industry. The supply±demand balance then started to move in consumers' favour after the domestic United States coal price peaked in 1923 and continued on a downward trend until the start of the Second World War. However, the discovery of the major coal deposits in Wyoming and the development of low-cost methods of extraction and transport reversed the decline. This situation was further aided by the 1970s oil crises and the nuclear scare at Three Mile Island to the extent that coal production in the United States is now over 1 bn t/year, in comparison with the 530 Mt/year produced in the mid-1940s. One of the best-known areas of coal production in the United States is along the Appalachian mountain ranges of Pennsylvania. The occurrence of coal within the state was first recorded by John Pattin at the Kiskiminetas River in 1751 and the fuel was used by the garrison at Fort Augusta during the winter of 1758. Mining from the Pittsburgh coal seam on Coal Hill (now Mount Washington) commenced in 1761. Further development of mining operations continued during the eighteenth century and George Washington burned coal at Stewarts Crossing (Connellsville) in 1770, whilst the fuel was also used by the arsenal at Carlisle during the American Revolution. As with Coalbrookdale in the United Kingdom, the naming of Carbondale in Lackawanna county in north-east Pennsylvania was a direct consequence of local deposits of coal. The city was founded by William and Maurice Wurts who were prospecting for coal and subsequently developed open pit coal-mining operations in the locality. In another mirror image of the mother country, the mine inspired the construction of the Delaware and Hudson canal in 1825 and a gravity railway from Carbondale to Honesdale. In June 1831 the city laid claim to the world's first underground anthracite mine, although some Welsh miners may disagree. Anthracite was discovered by Nicho Allen at Pottsville in Pennsylvania in 1790, and the town soon experienced boom conditions. This was due to the iron smelting operations that had been constructed in 1800 and expanded in 1806. By the 1860s some of the mines in the region had been sunk to depths of 1500 feet but there were few qualified mining engineers in the country. As a consequence,
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 17
The coal industry
the mine owners turned to skilled workers from England, Scotland and Wales who had developed knowledge through practical experience. Some of the mining problems and the influx of British management to oversee a workforce of largely Irish origin, led to a feeling of discontent amongst the employees. During the 1860s and 1870s this led to the formation of a number of associations, including the Ancient Order of Hibernians and the more widely known Molly Maguires ± a miners' secret society that campaigned for improved working conditions. The disaster at the Avondale shaft in September 1869, in which 110 men and boys died (see Chapter 4), no doubt contributed to the discontent within the workforce and increased the overall level of violence in the mining communities. In order to find the ringleaders of the Molly Maguires, who were said to be behind the uprising, the mine owners hired the Pinkerton Detective Agency at a fee of US$100 000. The Agency then hired agents to infiltrate the Molly Maguires and obtain sufficient evidence to lead to convictions. On 21 June 1877 six members of the society were hanged at Pottsville and four others hanged at Maunch Chunk (now known as Jim Thorpe) in Carbon County. The four members of the society hanged at Maunch Chunk had been convicted of two murders; three of the four (Alexander Campbell, Edward Kelly and Michael Doyle) were convicted of the 1875 murder of John P Jones, a mine boss from the Lonsdale Mine in Lansford. The fourth, John `Yellow Jack' Donohue was found guilty of the murder of Morgan Powell, the boss of the Summit Hill mine in 1871. Controversy still surrounds the events and the trials as much of the evidence leading to the convictions was provided by the mine owners acting through the Pinkerton Detective Agency. Indeed, some still suggest that the prosecutions were instigated in order to suppress the nascent organisation of labour that the Molly Maguires represented. Nevertheless, there can be no doubt that the area was wracked with violence and that many people in positions of authority were murdered between the formation of the group in about 1857 and the crackdown on the organisation that began in late 1875. Unionism also became aggressive during the 1920s and 1930s in the eastern Kentucky coal district, which tends to produce coking coal along the Appalachian Mountains. Bloody Harlan commemorates the violence that erupted in Harlan County during disputes that highlighted working and living conditions at the time.
Chapter 2/page 18
# Charles Kernot
International discoveries
Finally, coal was first discovered in the State of Ohio in 1808 and its coking properties meant that it was suited to local iron-making activities. Following the later discovery of major iron ore deposits in the Upper Midwest, demand for Ohio coal increased due to the burgeoning demands of the iron and steel industry.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 2/page 19
3 What is coal? 3.1
A fossil fuel
3.2
Coal classification
3.3
Composition and impurities
3.4
Energy content
3.5
Proximate analysis 3.5.1 Moisture 3.5.2 Volatile matter 3.5.3 Ash 3.5.4 Fixed carbon
3.6
Ultimate analysis 3.6.1 Carbon and hydrogen 3.6.2 Sulphur 3.6.3 Nitrogen 3.6.4 Oxygen 3.6.5 Chlorine 3.6.6 Sodium 3.6.7 Fluorine 3.6.8 Phosphorus
3.7
Coking coal
# Charles Kernot
3.1 A fossil fuel Coal is the word used to describe a rock found on a widespread basis around the world. The rock is generally assumed to represent the remains of vegetable matter that has been compressed and heated to the extent that much of the hydrogen, oxygen and other elements in the original material have been driven out, leaving a carbon-rich rock behind. Given that different types of trees or forests, leaves or spores, from swamps, deltas or other environments represent different building blocks, coal can have varying chemical characteristics, which can be important when considering where it can be used. Furthermore, it has no definitive physical crystalline structure, which means that it is not strictly a mineral, whilst the definitively structured diamond or graphite are carbon-rich minerals. No two coals mined in different parts of the world are the same, moreover, coals from different seams but in the same location may also exhibit significant differences and these can determine where and how it is consumed. The key determinants are not just how the coal formed but also what geological processes have affected it over time and how this has affected its current composition. As a consequence of its method of formation, coal is a sedimentary rock, probably the one of most economic significance, found in distinct layers or horizons within a sequence of other sedimentary rocks. Depending on the degree of geological activity to which the rocks have been subjected, the layers can be anything from near-surface and horizontal to deep and vertical, although the latter, because of the difficulty and relative cost of mining, are unlikely to be extracted for commercial use unless they are located near the surface. Before the process of burial and compaction coal would have been a peaty material ± rich in organic matter formed from the death and decay of plant life in massive swamps or deltas. As each layer of vegetable matter was deposited it would first have been subject to the usual processes of decay currently present at the earth's surface. This would have promoted the decomposition of the material until it became buried beneath other plant life that had also died and fallen to the ground. At this stage the presence of water would have been important as this would have provided a reducing environment, and slowed or prevented the rotting process which destroys much of today's plant life. Evidence of the reducing environment can be
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 1
The coal industry
gleaned from the relatively high sulphur content of many coals, and with reference to swamps where peats are currently being formed. As any fan of the dinosaurs will remember, large tracts of the earth have, at various times, been covered with swampland, often in the deltas of rivers which drained into inland seas in much the same way as the Okavango river drains into a massive swamp and marshland in central Botswana today. The main feature of these areas was that they tended to sink relative to the surrounding land and that the delta therefore slowly filled up with thicker layers of sediment and organic material. The rate of sinking played an important part in the formation of the peat, as too fast a rate would have led to the drowning of the vegetation and allowed the deposition of deeper water sediments such as shales and silts. Too slow a rate would have allowed the possibility of too much erosion to occur, thereby preventing the build-up of seams of sufficient breadth or thickness to be economically viable. If the rate at which the swamp sinks is similar to the rate at which new plants grow then the surface of the swamp will stay relatively stable and more vegetation can be added and form the bed on which successive generations of the plants can develop. If the rate of sinking was too slow then the layers of vegetation would not be covered by the water and would be more likely to oxidise and hence rot away ± preventing the formation of the peat, and hence coal. Alternatively, if the land sank at too fast a rate there would have been the danger that high tides or flash floods would either have washed some of the peat away, or introduced silt or sand and reduced the thickness of individual layers of coal. In some areas a cyclical rotation can be determined by geological investigation of coal deposits, indicating a mismatch between the rates at which the various processes were occurring ± considerably limiting coal seam thicknesses. In some instances such cyclical sequences have been found to be up to 3000 m in thickness. In the major basins of the United States, the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) and China this relative sinking occurred at optimal rates and some very thick seams were formed during the local coal ages. These ages did not take place at the same time in different parts of the world because of the local differences in geological and geographic conditions, although the need for long-term deposition means that much of the hard coal produced today comes from rocks
Chapter 3/page 2
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
Table 3.1 Spread of coal deposits through geological time AGE (million years before present)
System
Share of total coal reserves (%)
Area covered; in order of importance
0±65
Caenozoic
28.7
65±135
Cretaceous
16.7
135±200 200±240 240±280
Jurassic Triassic Permian
14.3 0.5 24.3
280±370
Carboniferous 15.6
Europe, Australia, New Zealand, North America, South America North America, South America, Europe, New Zealand Asia, Europe, Australia, North America Europe, North America Africa, Antarctica, Australia, Asia, Europe, North America, South America Europe, North America, Asia
Source: World Energy Conference. Survey of Energy Resources, 1980.
that were deposited some 240±370 million years ago. The time and geographical spread of coal deposits is shown in Table 3.1. Another example of how a coal basin can form can be seen from the south and central Sumatra coal basins in Indonesia. These basins are thought to have formed along the back-deeps or foreland basins along the Indonesian island arc, and are parallel to the subduction zone on the plate boundary running from south Java to south-west Sumatra. The basins are hinged to the larger land mass that previously existed to the north-east. The basins started to develop during the Oligocene/Miocene boundary, and during the Lower Miocene epoch deposits of a range of continental, fluvial, limnic, lagoonal and open marine phases were created. This included a range of volcanic sediments that formed from the volcanicity of the island arc to the south-west. During later phases of magmatic activity intrusions beneath the basin led to the generation of folds and, in some areas, this has increased the rank of the coal present in the area. The south Sumatra basin was able to produce a regular pattern of coal deposition because of the exceptionally regular subsidence coupled with the right type of climate. In terms of plate tectonics, this period probably coincides with a hiatus in the subduction process, which was recorded in the Upper Tertiary period and would extend to the Upper Pliocene and perhaps to the Middle Pliocene. This hiatus would have reduced volcanic activity and meant that the surrounding rocks would have sunk back as the magma cooled.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 3
The coal industry
Table 3.2 Coals produced in south Sumatra Content Total moisture Ash (dry basis) Sulphur (dry basis) CV net (in situ) Sodium in ash Grindability
23%±54% 3%±12% 0.2%±1.7% 10±20 MJ/kg 1.8%±8.0% 37±56 HGI
Source: PTBA.
In the areas close to volcanic activity the coal has increased in rank to the extent that some anthracite and bituminous coals have been formed with energy contents of up to 22MJ/kg (see Table 3.2). In other areas, such as in Sydney harbour, some coals adjacent to volcanic activity have been turned to cinder, completely destroying any economic value. As can be seen in Table 3.1, there is a wide spread of coal deposits around the world throughout a wide range of geological time. There are few if any deposits older than the 370 million years of the Carboniferous period because of the lack of spread of vegetation at this time. It is also the case that the older the rock the greater the possibility that geological processes will have affected the coal physically or chemically through faulting, tilting or alteration associated with the high temperatures and pressures of metamorphism. In the United States the Carboniferous period is split in two with the earlier and later but not strictly Lower and Upper periods represented by the Mississippian and the Pennsylvanian, respectively. Coal formation occurred in major swamps during the Carboniferous period when much of the continental crust was concentrated as Gondwanaland in the southern hemisphere. Eventually, after a period thought to be as much as 40 million years, the land level rose relative to the sea and the climate became drier. This led to an end of the conducive conditions for coal formation. In some instances these temperatures and pressures are beneficial and can upgrade the type, or rank, of coal from the basic peaty material that is initially formed, to the high grade and quality bituminous coals or anthracites that are used in the metallurgical industry or in domestic applications, respectively. However, if the coal is subjected to too much heat or pressure it may volatilise with the
Chapter 3/page 4
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
Table 3.3 The calorific value of different coal types Specific gravity
Carbon (%)
BTU/lb
0.85 1.04 1.15 1.30 1.50
60.83 67.43 72.92 83.48 95.35
3 000 6 500 ± 7 000 8 000 ± 10 000 10 000 ± 13 000 15 000
Peat Lignite Brown or sub-bituminous coal Bituminous coal Anthracite Sources: G L Kerr, 1919; Author.
carbon being absorbed into surrounding rocks or, as occurred with the formation of some of the gas fields in the North Sea, may combine with hydrogen to form natural gas. As a consequence the rank of a coal is largely dependent upon its age as this increases the probability that it will have experienced many of the geological processes inherent in the formation of high rank coal. The lowest grade lignite yields the lowest amount of contained energy per unit weight and is therefore of lowest value (see Table 3.3). Anthracite, which has been subjected to the highest grades of metamorphism, yields the highest amount of energy per unit weight, and is therefore of the highest value. Other factors, such as the amount of sulphur contained in the coal are of importance due to increasing environmental concerns and major producers are now publishing sulphur contents of their coals.
3.2 Coal classification Most coals are classified according to their carbon content and the specific amount of energy that they contain. The greater the amount of carbon, the higher the effective rank of the coal and the higher the average energy content of the material. Table 3.4 shows the coal classification of the American Society for the Testing of Materials (ASTM), which is widely accepted for determining the name of a coal, although other countries and organisations have their own nomenclature. This can be particularly confusing in the international arena as different producers may describe broadly similar coals very differently. Furthermore, the use of different measures for energy content is also particularly confusing. It will be noticed that coals of higher ranks are classed in terms of
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 5
The coal industry
Table 3.4 The classification of different coal types Class
Group
Fixed carbon Volatile matter Calorific value (%) (%) (MJ/kg)
Anthracite
Meta-anthracite Anthracite Semi-anthracite
Bituminous
Low volatile bituminous Medium volatile bituminous High volatile A bituminous High volatile B bituminous High volatile C bituminous
98±100 92±98 86±92
0±2 2±8 8±14
78±86 69±78 <69
14±22 22±31 >31
>32.6 30.2±32.6 26.7±30.2
Sub-bituminous
Sub-bituminous A Sub-bituminous B Sub-bituminous C
24.4±26.7 22.1±24.4 19.3±22.1
Lignite
Lignite A Lignite B
14.7±19.3 <14.3
Source: Ward, 1984.
their carbon content whereas coals of lower ranks are classed in terms of their energy content. High carbon coals are generally used in metallurgical processes where the carbon is primarily used as a reducing agent, for instance, to take the oxygen out of iron oxide in the production of pig iron and steel, rather than specifically as a source of heat. There are also other factors that have to be taken into account when considering whether or not a coal will be suitable for use in the metallurgical industry. This criteria is mainly related to the coal's `caking' power, which is its ability to cake or fuse when heated. As only some of the organic constituents of the coal contribute to this caking process coals of a similar carbon and ash content may fall into different categories (see Chapter 7). Additionally coals of too high a rank are unlikely to have a sufficiently high level of organic constituents and may not, therefore, be suitable for use in the metallurgical industries.
Chapter 3/page 6
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
3.3 Composition and impurities As indicated earlier, the higher the temperature and pressure the greater the proportion of carbon in the coal. This is because of the reduction in the non-carbon constituents of the material which will, effectively, be squeezed out during the metamorphic processes. One of the disadvantages of metamorphism, however, is that it may occur with an introduction of fluids from other rocks. These fluids often contain sulphur and iron and may therefore leave deposits of iron pyrites in the coal. This is often a problem and leads to the need for flue gas desulphurisation (FGD) equipment in many coal-fired power stations (see Chapter 6). However, because of the increase in the energy content of the coal, which results from the metamorphism, consumers may be willing to bear the additional expense of FGD equipment because less coal needs to be burned to produce the same amount of energy. A range of coals of different age groups found in the United States is shown in Table 3.5. Table 3.5 Chemical composition of coals of different geological ages Age
Moisture
Volatile
Fixed
(%)
matter (%)
carbon (%)
Ash (%)
Sulphur
Energy
(%)
(MJ/kg)
Carboniferous
2.4 ± 10.2
5.2 ± 41.2
39.4 ± 81.3
4.2 ± 12.3
0.7 ± 3.3
25.45 ± 33.56
Cretaceous
5.0 ± 10.7
35.8 ± 42.4
38.1 ± 50.4
6.4 ± 15.0
0.6 ± 1.1
23.73 ± 29.64
Tertiary
5.0 ± 45.9
7.2 ± 35.8
22.1 ± 76.7
4.4 ± 15.7
0.3 ± 2.7
13.35 ± 29.45
Source: Ward, 1984.
3.4 Energy content The heat of combustion of the coal can be determined by utilising the Dulong formula where: NCP = 338C + 1423*(H ± O/8) + 92S ± 24.4*(9H + M) NCP = net calorific power in kilojoules/kg (or gigajoules/tonne) C = Weight percentage of contained carbon H = Weight percentage of contained hydrogen O = Weight percentage of contained oxygen S = Weight percentage of contained sulphur M = Weight percentage of contained moisture
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 7
The coal industry
If the gross calorific power of the coal is required then the last term in the formula should be omitted as this refers to the moisture content of the fuel. In the United States coal is more usually classified in terms of its British Thermal Unit (BTU) content. The BTU is the old imperial measure of energy and is equivalent to 1.05506 kJ. The other point to bear in mind is that the country also bases all of its statistics on imperial measures of weight and that the energy content is recorded for each pound of coal. Moreover, the unwary can be further confused as different companies will refer either to short tons (2000 lbs), long tons which are also referred to as just tons (2200 lbs) or metric tonnes (2204.6226 lbs). The relevant conversion factors are shown in Table 3.6. Furthermore, it should also be noted that GJ/t is exactly the same as MJ/kg ± both the numerator and the denominator being multiplied by 1000 in the case of the GJ/t statistics. To confuse matters further, many Pacific Rim countries calculate the contained energy of various coals in terms of the calories of energy that the coal contains. In this instance the calorie is equivalent to 4.184 joules, or one BTU is equivalent to 252.2 calories. Given the lower equivalent value of energy represented by a calorie it is often Table 3.6 Coal energy content conversion factors BTU/lb
GJ/tonne
cal/g
Mtce
6 000 6 500 7 000 7 500 8 000 8 500 9 000 9 500 10 000 10 500 11 000 11 500 12 000 12 500 13 000 13 500 14 000 14 500 15 000
14.0 15.1 16.3 17.4 18.6 19.8 20.9 22.1 23.3 24.4 25.6 26.7 27.9 29.1 30.2 31.4 32.6 33.7 34.9
3 336 3 614 3 892 4 169 4 447 4 725 5 003 5 281 5 559 5 837 6 115 6 393 6 671 6 949 7 227 7 505 7 783 8 061 8 339
0.48 0.52 0.56 0.60 0.63 0.67 0.71 0.75 0.79 0.83 0.87 0.91 0.95 0.99 1.03 1.07 1.11 1.15 1.19
Chapter 3/page 8
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
expressed in terms of calories for each gram of coal. In an attempt to bring all of the different terminologies together, some reports talk in terms of tonnes of coal equivalent. In this case a nominal energy content is supposed to represent all coals produced globally and is chosen as 29.3 GJ/t, 12 600 BTU/lb or 7000 cal/g. In the United States the heat contents of coals are classified as detailed in Table 3.7. As can be seen there is some overlap between the bituminous and sub-bituminous coal detailed in view of the other different characteristics of the fuel. It should also be noted that, in broad terms these energy contents are similar to those presented above, but are not strictly the same. Table 3.7 Classification of coals by energy content US definitions BTU/lb
Rank Anthracite Bituminous coal Sub-bituminous coal Lignite
Over 14 000 10 500 to 14 000 8000 to 11 500 6000 to 7000
GJ/tonne Over 24.4 to 18.6 to 14.0 to
32.6 32.6 25.6 16.3
Other definitions GJ/tonne Over 26.7 to 19.3 to Under
32.6 32.6 26.7 19.3
Source: Wyoming Coal Information Committee, 1997; Author; Ward, 1984.
3.5 Proximate analysis The composition of coal from a metallurgical standpoint may be expressed by either its proximate or ultimate analysis. The proximate analysis provides details of the percentage content of a range of different constituents of the material ± whether moisture, volatile matter, ash or fixed carbon. Each of these characteristics is determined by standardised procedures and it is necessary for each consumer to ensure that the same procedures are used as different procedures would yield different results.
3.5.1
Moisture
Moisture, or water content, can also upset the statistics of what may look to be a usable coal ± particularly in view of a low sulphur content. The moisture contents around the world are normally detailed in terms of the weight per cent moisture in the coal.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 9
The coal industry
Nevertheless, there can be different ways of calculating moisture content ± either as mined, as delivered or on an air dried basis (ADB). Moisture is particularly important as it adds weight to the coal but does not provide any additional heating capacity. Moreover, a coal containing up to 25% moisture will effectively contain only 75% coal ± the remaining 25% of the weight that needs to be transported from supplier to consumer is effectively dead weight that provides no benefit to the consumer. Prices of coals with high moisture contents tend to reflect this situation. Moisture in coal can be evident in four different forms: as surface moisture or as a film on top of the coal surface; as hygroscopic moisture contained in pores or capillaries; as decomposition moisture that is incorporated in some organic compounds; or as mineral moisture contained in the crystal structures of clays and other minerals. Most surface moisture is driven off at 100 ëC, but some mineral moisture is not driven off until the temperature reaches 500 ëC. Total moisture effectively calculates the amount of moisture contained by the coal in situ and is calculated through the loss of mass of the coal when heated to between 105 ëC and 110 ëC. The air dried moisture content is calculated using the same or similar techniques but with coal that has been dried in air before the test is carried out.
3.5.2
Volatile matter
The volatile matter contained by a coal encompasses all of the contents of the material that are driven off when it is heated to a temperature of between 900 ëC and 950 ëC depending on whether British/Australian or United States procedures are being followed. The only exception is moisture that is calculated separately, and it is also necessary to determine how much volatile matter is used in the classification process. Moreover, the different temperatures used in the different procedures will provide different results for the same coal and so it is necessary to confirm which has been used.
3.5.3
Ash
The ash content of the coal is also an important consideration and depends upon the specific environment of deposition. If the area was often subject to flooding then there may well have been an influx of sediment, which would not have been removed by any of the
Chapter 3/page 10
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
metamorphic processes briefly outlined above. In this instance the coal will have a higher ash content and, as the majority of the ash will be inert, a lower energy content than an otherwise similar coal. Additionally, the ash also needs to be disposed of, and the increase in the number of environmental restrictions in the United States is starting to become a problem for some of the electricity utilities, particularly those in the north-east of the country. Another way of considering the ash content of a coal is as that portion of the rock that will remain following combustion. It is effectively all of the inorganic compounds in the coal, with the exception of any carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide or moisture that is driven off in the heating process. The ash represents a cost to the consumer in two ways, first it tends to reduce the heat content of the coal and second it will need to be removed from the furnace following combustion. The ash content can be calculated through one of two methods which are again different depending on whether British/Australian or United States procedures are followed. Either the coal is slowly raised in temperature to 815 ëC and is then held at that temperature until a constant mass is attained, or it is heated first to 500 ëC and then to 815 ëC in order to prevent some of the contained sulphur being fixed into the ash. In the United States the intermediate temperature is also 500 ëC, although the top temperature is between 700 ëC and 750 ëC in both the one stage and two stage tests.
3.5.4
Fixed carbon
Fixed carbon is the last coal component calculated using proximate analysis. It is effectively the remainder after all other components of an air dried coal ± moisture, volatile matter and ash ± have been calculated. The fixed carbon content is used as an indication of the yield of carbon into coke and may also be a guide to the rank of a coal.
3.6 Ultimate analysis An ultimate analysis provides details of the content of individual elements within the coal. This includes the carbon, hydrogen, sulphur, nitrogen, and oxygen content of the coal together with minor but
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 11
The coal industry
important constituents such as chlorine, sodium, fluorine and phosphorus. Ash contents are also calculated, although this can be described in terms of its constituent elements. This is important because some of the chemical building blocks can affect the physical properties of the material and can therefore affect its uses for coking, gasification and liquefaction. The ultimate analysis is calculated on a moisture-free basis and the moisture content has to be provided separately. The reason for this is that the moisture content of the coal will vary depending on how it long has been stored and how far it has travelled and under what conditions.
3.6.1
Carbon and hydrogen
The bulk of the carbon and hydrogen contained within a coal will be found as organic compounds, although carbon may be present in some inorganic carbonates and hydrogen will be present in inherent moisture or from water contained in clays or other minerals. After allowing for these sources the content of carbon and hydrogen in a coal can be calculated from heating the material in dry oxygen and calculating the amount of carbon dioxide and moisture produced. It is also necessary to determine the amount of carbon dioxide contained in the coal's inorganic compounds as the release of this gas absorbs energy produced on combustion of the coal and reduces its overall heating power.
3.6.2
Sulphur
In view of the concerns about acid rain and increasing environmental legislation the content of sulphur in a coal is becoming ever more price sensitive. The sulphur may be present in one of three forms: as organic compounds; as inorganic compounds such as pyrite or other sulphides; or, in some instances, as sulphates (often formed by oxidation of sulphides if the coal has been exposed to the air for some time). In most analyses the total sulphur content is calculated, although it will not differentiate between the element in its different forms. This is important because some sulphates and sulphides may be removed during a coal washing process, whereas organic sulphur will be retained within the coal. Moreover, sulphur content is not only a problem with respect to acid rain, it can adversely affect the
Chapter 3/page 12
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
performance of a boiler, leading to enhanced corrosive effects and to the fouling or clogging of the boiler tubes. One method of calculating the sulphur content of a coal involves using chemical techniques such as the formation of barium sulphate. The mass of this compound produced will then indicate the amount of sulphur in the coal. Alternatively, burning to produce sulphur dioxide and thence sulphuric acid, the acidity of which will give an indication of the amount of sulphur present, is also possible. Sulphur content can be problematic when comparing coals from different areas. In the United States the sulphur content of a coal is sometimes referred to in terms of the amount of sulphur for every million BTUs of heat that burning the coal will generate. In these terms low sulphur or `compliance' coals are thought of as having a sulphur content of less than 1.2 lbs/million BTU. This was the original standard set by the Clean Air Act in the United States when defining a low sulphur coal. A ready-reckoner for the different sulphur contents of the coals and the equivalent in per cent, which is the more widespread nomenclature, is detailed in Table 3.8. In rough terms it is possible to see that the numbers are broadly similar, although the energy content of the coal clearly can have a significant bearing on the sulphur content and could take a consumer over a compliance threshold.
3.6.3
Nitrogen
Whilst not generally considered as significant as sulphur content the nitrogen content of a coal may also lead to atmospheric pollution in view of the various oxides that can be produced during combustion. In some coal and processes it is also possible that hydrogen will combine with the nitrogen to form ammonia. Nitrogen contents of coals are determined using sulphuric acid in order to produce ammonium sulphate, the yield of which will determine the original nitrogen content of the material.
3.6.4
Oxygen
Oxygen can be present in many different forms and is important because it can aid or hinder various downstream processes. In particular, too much oxygen could lead to the generation of steam or
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 13
The coal industry
Table 3.8 Conversion statistics from sulphur in lbs/million BTU to per cent when using metric energy units lbs/millionBTU 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
GJ/tonne 20
22
24
26
28
30
0.43% 0.52% 0.60% 0.69% 0.77% 0.86% 0.95% 1.03% 1.12% 1.20% 1.29% 1.38% 1.46% 1.55% 1.63% 1.72% 1.81% 1.89% 1.98% 2.06% 2.15%
0.47% 0.57% 0.66% 0.76% 0.85% 0.95% 1.04% 1.13% 1.23% 1.32% 1.42% 1.51% 1.61% 1.70% 1.80% 1.89% 1.99% 2.08% 2.18% 2.27% 2.36%
0.52% 0.62% 0.72% 0.83% 0.93% 1.03% 1.13% 1.24% 1.34% 1.44% 1.55% 1.65% 1.75% 1.86% 1.96% 2.06% 2.17% 2.27% 2.37% 2.48% 2.58%
0.56% 0.67% 0.78% 0.89% 1.01% 1.12% 1.23% 1.34% 1.45% 1.56% 1.68% 1.79% 1.90% 2.01% 2.12% 2.24% 2.35% 2.46% 2.57% 2.68% 2.79%
0.60% 0.72% 0.84% 0.96% 1.08% 1.20% 1.32% 1.44% 1.56% 1.69% 1.81% 1.93% 2.05% 2.17% 2.29% 2.41% 2.53% 2.65% 2.77% 2.89% 3.01%
0.64% 0.77% 0.90% 1.03% 1.16% 1.29% 1.42% 1.55% 1.68% 1.81% 1.93% 2.06% 2.19% 2.32% 2.45% 2.58% 2.71% 2.84% 2.97% 3.10% 3.22%
carbon dioxide during gasification or liquefaction where methane or other hydrocarbons are required. As with the determination of the fixed carbon content in proximate analysis, the oxygen content of a coal may be calculated by difference, or, alternatively, by direct determination through such methods as the generation of carbon monoxide and subsequently carbon dioxide, the amount of which can be measured to yield the amount of oxygen originally contained in the coal.
3.6.5
Chlorine
Chlorine may be present in coals either as inorganic salts (either salt itself or as potassium chloride) or as some organic compounds. Chlorine causes similar problems to sulphur ± potential acid rain together with fouling and corrosion of boilers. It is often analysed at the same time as sulphur with the determination of hydrochloric rather than sulphuric acid.
Chapter 3/page 14
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
3.6.6
Sodium
Sodium (Na) content is important in some coals, particularly those formed in an open sea environment. The sodium content needs to be investigated in order to prevent boiler slagging and fouling as a content of Na2O of over 3±4% markedly reduces ash fusion temperatures. Furthermore, a substantial impact on boiler operation is to be expected at an Na2O content of above 6±8%. Specifically, the Na2O content of the ash produced from the coals in the south Sumatra coalfield ranges from 1.8% up to around 8% and so this has to be determined before the coal can be sold. In many instances internal blending of coal and the dilution of coal by wallrock tends to reduce the concern as most wallrocks contain a significantly lower level of Na2O.
3.6.7
Fluorine
In the United Kingdom the fluorine content of a coal can be important as it too can lead to enhanced corrosion of boilers. In order to overcome this potential problem, the bulk of the deep mined coal produced in the country is blended on a five to one basis with coal produced from surface, which has a much lower fluorine content.
3.6.8
Phosphorus
Phosphorus is normally contained in inorganic compounds such as apatite. It is not normally a major concern, except in coking coals where it can adversely affect the steel-making process if concentrations are too high.
3.7 Coking coal The caking ability of coal, which is its ability to fuse when heated in the absence of oxygen, is of great importance to the metallurgical industry. This is because the coke produced is needed to support the iron ore and fluxing materials in a blast furnace. This support is important because it helps to maintain spaces for the passage of gases or molten metal within the furnace, allowing the gases to escape and molten metal and slag to be tapped out at the base. The strongest
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 15
The coal industry
cokes are required in the iron industry, whereas other metallurgical processes can be undertaken with weaker or semi-soft cokes. Not all coals are amenable to coking, or will produce cokes of varying strengths, and it is therefore necessary to determine the coking propensity of individual types of coal. In general terms heating the coal in the coking process (see Chapter 8) transforms some of its constituent carbon compounds into a semi-liquid state, and further heating then leads to the expulsion of its volatile constituents. As the volatile constituents escape the coal re-solidifies to form coke, although those coals unsuitable for coking may simply fall into a powder. The heating process may also lead to a swelling in the size of the coal and it is necessary to determine this to ensure that it does not cause any problems in the coke-making process. In some respects the only method of determining whether or not a particular type of coal will cake successfully is through practical experiment. This is because coals of similar chemical composition can exhibit vastly different caking characteristics. Moreover, some of the organic compounds in the coal may aid the process whilst others hinder it, with the inorganic and non-volatile compounds also yielding different effects. The caking ability of a coal may be determined by the measurement of its crucible swelling number (CSN). In this test one gram of coal is heated in a special crucible at 820 ëC under standard conditions, and the profile of the resultant button of coke left in the bottom of the crucible is compared with a set of standard profiles. There are 19 separate standards, from 0 to 9 in a series of half increments with 0 effectively solely powder and 9 a highly swollen coal. The second method of determination is the calculation of the coal's position on the Gray-King scale. In this test 20 g of coal is heated at 600 ëC under standard conditions and after full carbonisation of the coal the resulting material is graded from A to G depending on the amount of loss of volume of the material, with A effectively still a powder and G retaining the same volume as the original coal sample, but fused together. For coals that swell on heating the test is expanded from G1 to GX, with X up to a maximum of 19 and representing the number of grams of carbon that have to be added to the 20 g sample in order to prevent the coal from swelling above its original size. A comparison of the results of a CSN test and the Gray-King test is shown in Table 3.9.
Chapter 3/page 16
# Charles Kernot
What is coal?
Table 3.9 Comparison of crucible swelling numbers with the Gray-King scale Gray-King CSN
A
BC 1
D
EF 2
1.5
G 3
G1
G2 4
G3 5
G4 6
G5 7
G6 8
G7 8
G8 9
Source: Brame and King, 1967.
One of the factors that is important in the caking process is that two coals with different CSNs will not yield an average CSN in a 50:50 blend. The CSN of the blended material will depend on the relative proportion of components in the coal, how they are distributed and how they react when heated. In particular, the fluidity of the coal on heating, as measured by the Giesler plastometer test, can be important, aiding the blending process within the coke oven. In the plastometer test a crushed and pressed sample of coal is heated from 300 ëC to 600 ëC at a rate of 3 ëC/minute. A defined torque is applied to a spindle with a number of rabble arms set within the coal and as the coal becomes fluid the spindle will turn, producing a reading of dial divisions per minute (ddpm) on a separate dial. Table 3.10 gives an indication of the different characteristics of various Australian coking and semi-soft coking coals for comparative purposes. Table 3.10 Comparison of different Australian coking coals Producer
Brand ± Type
Total Inherent Ash Volatile moisture moisture (%)
(%)
Fixed
Total
CSN Giesler
matter carbon sulphur (%)
(%)
(%)
fluidity
(%)
(ddpm)
BHP
Blackwater ± hard
10.5
2.0
8.0
26.5
63.3
0.50
6.0
BHP
Blackwater ± semi
10.0
2.0
9.5
24.5
63.5
0.55
3.0
200 15
BHP
Bulli ± hard
9.0
1.0
9.5
21.5
67.6
0.38
7.0
1200
BHP
Gregory ± hard
8.0
2.0
6.5
33.5
58.0
0.65
9.0
7500
BHP
UHV (Gregory semi)
8.0
2.0
9.7
31.5
56.8
0.67
8.0
3000
Coal & Allied
Mt Thorley ± semi
9.0
2.5
9.5
33.5
54.5
0.50
5.0
100
Coal & Allied
Mt Thorley ± soft
9.0
2.5
8.5
33.8
55.2
0.55
5.0
100
Source: Australia's Export Coal Industry, 1999.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 3/page 17
4 Exploration, mining and production 4.1
Introduction
4.2
Feasibility studies
4.3
Mining 4.3.1 Surface mining 4.3.2 Underground mining A dangerous business Longwall mining Room and pillar mining
4.4
Productivity
4.5
Total mining costs 4.5.1 Taxes and royalties 4.5.2 Processing costs
4.6
Reclamation
# Charles Kernot
4.1 Introduction Given the geological knowledge surrounding how coal forms and with what other rocks it should be associated, the exploration process can begin. This process is relatively straightforward, especially because coal outcropping at surface is a very different rock in terms of colour and hardness than almost any other. After discovery, coal deposits can be tracked along their surface expression to provide information on the thickness and length of strike of the horizon. Examination of the local geology can also provide information about the potential lateral extent of the deposit, together with its dip and consequent depth from surface. If these initial indications are encouraging, then the deposit will be drilled in order to confirm the initial hypotheses and delineate the full extent of the resource. The initial discovery of coal deposits not exposed at surface is more complicated, and in the early days of coal-mining the only exploration that could be undertaken was through the sinking of exploration shafts or adits. It was only in 1864 that diamond drill bits were used for the first time, in this instance for boring blast holes during the construction of the Mount Cenis tunnel through the Alps. Diamond drills then gained wider acceptance, reaching Australia in the 1870s, and first finding economic quantities of coal in the Helensburgh bore in 1884, which then led to the development of the Metropolitan Colliery. As exploration techniques have advanced, regional and satellite geology can be used to give an indication of where to look for hidden deposits. Seismic analysis, like that used in the oil industry, geochemical analysis and other techniques developed over the years can also be used to provide an indication of where to look. Nevertheless, drilling will still be required in order to confirm the presence and extent of any deposit.
4.2 Feasibility studies After discovery, and assuming economic potential can be foreseen, the deposit becomes subject to a concerted testing programme to confirm its size and extent and the number of tonnes of each type or grade of coal contained. This involves the drilling of
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 1
The coal industry
additional holes over the lateral extent of the deposit to check depth and thickness of the coal seam (or seams). The drilling programme will also take samples for the large number of tests required to give an indication of the quality, and therefore value, of the coal (see Chapter 5). One further factor in the delineation of the reserves and resources is the distinction between clayey coal and coaly clay along the edges of any coal basin. This is because where a line is drawn on a map is very important with respect to ash contents and other potential impurities that can adversely affect the overall value of the coal. Thereafter a full mining programme has to be constructed for the deposit. This will determine whether the coal can be mined from surface or underground and, if from underground, how much needs to be left to support the roof. The extractable, rather than in situ, amount of coal can then be determined for the financial evaluation that is needed to calculate whether or not mining the deposit would generate a positive return on investment. This information represents one part of the data required by the company to construct a full model or feasibility study of the economic potential of the deposit. In addition to the size of the deposit and the mining process, the feasibility study will also need to calculate the capital costs of the equipment and any associated process plant required to clean the coal produced by the mine. The potential market for the coal is important in view of the costs of transport ± whether or not local rail, road or port infrastructure contains sufficient capacity for the additional tonnage that would be produced from the mine. Labour availability, power supplies and a host of other factors, including financial costs, taxation and royalties also need to be included. Finally, and now of increasing importance, a whole host of environmental considerations and their financial costs to the project, need to be taken into account. If all are still positive, then the mining company will move to financing, construction and, eventually, production from the deposit.
4.3 Mining Across the mining industry as a whole both surface and underground mines can be split into a number of different categories
Chapter 4/page 2
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
4.1 Split between surface and underground coal production in the United States (source: Facts about Coal).
depending on the many different types and shapes of orebody. Nevertheless, the shape is often restricted to a particular type of mineral and coal is almost exclusively limited to tabular deposits. By definition these deposits cover a large surface area and whilst in some instances it may be a blessing, in others it can cause problems and increase the costs of extraction in comparison with vertically oriented veins or disseminated stockworks. Recent data for the split between the amount of coal mined from surface or from underground in the United States is shown in Fig 4.1. The mining techniques used for extracting coal will be tied to the tabular orientation of most economically exploitable coal deposits. Unfortunately, in some instances, the area including the deposit may have been subjected to considerable geological deformation, as a consequence of which the coal seam may be vertical or undulating. This, in turn, will dictate the mining techniques that can be employed to extract the coal, and that can influence the further processing of the material. Indeed, it may become difficult to separate the coal from the waste rock, thereby reducing its relative thermal content and hence its value. As a consequence, the interrelation between all of the different factors can be important and must be determined before deciding on the mining and processing techniques to be employed.
4.3.1
Surface mining By far the most common term to describe a surface mine is as an
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 3
The coal industry
`open pit'. Essentially, this just means a mine open to the air with `pit' being the reference to the hole in the ground created during the mining process. Open pit mines utilise a range of mobile mining equipment including powered shovels or excavators and trucks that cart both the waste rock and the coal to either the waste dump or the next part of the operation. In view of the economies of scale offered by ever larger mines, the equipment used in the world's major mining operations is becoming ever larger. This is particularly the case in coal mines as there is normally a requirement to move a large amount of both coal and waste, and the more efficiently this can be achieved the greater the potential economic return. A 1998 survey by the Parker Bay Company indicated that 46% of the world's 760 major mining operations produced coal using large-scale equipment (see Table 4.1). Table 4.1 Use of large-scale equipment in the world's major mines Region
Coal
Gold
Copper
Iron ore
Others
Total
North America Latin America Europe/Africa/ Middle East Former Soviet Union Southern Africa Asia Australasia
202 11
45 11
23 26
13 23
57 17
340 88
44 2 14 26 55
1 6 7 0 35
8 0 4 3 14
6 8 4 8 11
33 2 13 11 17
92 18 42 48 132
Total
354
105
78
73
150
760
Source: Mining Magazine after the Parker Bay Company.
Rather than use a fleet of hydraulic shovels or bulldozers to load the trucks or the in-pit crushers and conveyors, some mines have looked to other methods to reduce costs and improve efficiency. One of these mines is PT Tambang Batubara Bukit Asam (PTBA) in Indonesia, which is the state-owned coal-mining company. At its Air Laya open pit mine at Tanjung Enim in south Sumatra, Indonesia, it employs five bucket-wheel excavators, which mine coal at a combined annual rate of up to 15 million bank cubic metres. The coal is then fed directly onto in-pit conveyors, which transport it to the rail loading station or the local power plant. In coal mines in Australia, South Africa and the United States,
Chapter 4/page 4
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
massive caterpillar tracked, or walking, draglines with single scoop buckets capable of moving up to 100 t are used to mine and remove waste. They tend to be faster and more efficient than a fleet of trucks and shovels, particularly because their 100 m reach means that they can dig waste and cast it to its final resting place in one movement. As a consequence, there is no need to use trucks to transport the overburden, thereby enabling significant cost savings. Indeed, the cost of production of some of the major coal mines using this technique in the Powder River Basin in Wyoming is below US$4/t. Additional advantages of using this `open cast' technique are that it is normally possible to carry out the reclamation of the mine site as mining progresses and that the use of the dragline allows careful positioning of mine waste for reclamation purposes. Admittedly, in some open pit mining operations, the pits are dug ever deeper in a series of benches or giant steps into the earth and such mines cannot be refilled until all mining has been completed. Such a mine plan is not normally used in most mineable coal deposits in view of the additional costs involved. Nevertheless, there will sometimes be particular design advantages in using this technique either due to the depth or orientation of the deposit or because of population or other infrastructural pressures. Such a scheme may also require negligible price competition so that the mine can obtain a high enough price to cover the higher costs of mining the coal using these more expensive techniques. In some instances open cast mines are referred to as `strip mines' because the coal is exposed by the dragline in a long single strip, perhaps 35 m wide and up to 2 km in length. Strip mines may also work on different seams of coal, although the cut will normally be created perpendicular to the dip of the seams. The width of the cut may be greater or less than 35 m but it will primarily depend on the size of the mobile equipment used to extract the coal exposed in the cutting. Essentially, the cut needs to be wide enough to enable the trucks and shovels to operate without any difficulties that could slow or hinder the mining process. Recent developments in satellite technology and global positioning systems (GPS) are also being introduced in large mining operations. These enable individual trucks to determine their exact location within the mine and relay this information to a central computer, which displays it on a screen. Mine managers can use the
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 5
The coal industry
information gleaned from the system to ensure efficient truck despatch so that they are idle for as little time as possible. This helps to improve productivity and reduce unit costs in view of the large amount of capital invested in each truck (on average over US$1.1 m each). As the technology advances it may become possible to dispense with drivers and to use GPS to guide trucks through a mine, although drivers will still be required for manoeuvring vehicles in small areas. An additional factor in the profitability of a surface mine is the amount of waste material that has to be removed from the surface of the coal in order to allow extraction. In some instances coal outcrops at surface, with little overburden, and this provides a very low-cost mining operation. However, it is more normal for some waste to be sitting on top of the coal, which will therefore need to be removed in order to expose the coal for mining. Waste to coal ratios can be relatively high in the case of higher value coking coal mines, given the higher value of coking coal and its consequent ability to bear higher mining costs. The relative proportion or ratio of waste to coal is normally referred to as the `strip ratio', however, this has no particular relationship with a strip mine as all open pit mining operations that need to remove waste will have one. In most metalliferous mining operations the strip ratio is given in terms of the number of tonnes of waste that need to be removed in order to expose one tonne of ore. Hence a strip ratio of 2:1 is better than one of 4:1. In the coal-mining industry, however, the strip ratio is often calculated on the basis of the number of bank cubic metres of waste that need to be removed to extract one tonne of coal. The reason for this differing basis is that much of the overburden of a coal deposit is often relatively unconsolidated rock with a low specific gravity. As a consequence, the weight of the waste is less important than the volume that it occupies as this is what will determine the number of trips that trucks need to take in order to remove it and expose the coal for mining. Indeed, unconsolidated waste rock may well occupy up to twice its volume prior to blasting and digging. Moreover, given the tight operating margins on which many mines operate, it is important to control both the volume and the distance hauled much more closely than the weight. This is additionally important in view of the relatively flat-lying nature of most coal deposits and, hence, there is little concern with the
Chapter 4/page 6
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
potential energy that would need to be expended hauling weight up a steep incline.
4.3.2
Underground mining
Underground mining is also carried out to win coal, although the material has to be of sufficient value to justify the additional expense that underground mining tends to incur. This expense is not just related to the need to dig tunnels and shafts to access the coal, but also relates to the much greater need for safety in underground coal mines. Additional safety problems arise underground due to the different gases that can seep out of a coal seam, including methane, carbon monoxide, coal dust and silica dust. The first three are more easily recognisable as lethal due to the explosions that can be caused if they are ignited. Carbon monoxide is also highly poisonous and can be fatal if it builds up to a high level in the atmosphere. Coal dust and silica dust can cause pneumoconiosis and silicosis respectively, both of which lead to the deterioration of the sufferer's lungs and breathing capacity. Efficient ventilation is therefore one of the most important aspects of underground mining. A dangerous business The slow advance of technology meant that underground mining during the nineteenth century was a very dangerous occupation. It remains hazardous today but the advance in technology makes it considerably less so than in even the recent past. One of the reasons for the increasing danger during the nineteenth century is related to one of the basic facts of mining. The first tonne is the easiest and safest to extract and the risks increase, almost at a compound rate, thereafter. This occurs because the first tonne is removed from the bottom of a shaft, or the start of an adit, whereas the last tonne will be taken from the furthest point away from the shaft bottom, with all of the ventilation and support problems that entails. Ventilation remained a problem for many years and is still one of the most difficult and dangerous areas in mining. The main reason for this is the unpredictability of rushes of methane out of the coal seams that can then be ignited to cause the dangerous explosions which have claimed so many lives. The accident at Haswell Colliery in the United
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 7
The coal industry
Kingdom in 1844 is a fearful example of the problems of insufficient ventilation. The mine suffered an explosion due to the ignition of excess coal dust in the air underground. Insufficient oxygen meant that the dust was not fully burned and so the air had a large amount of afterdamp, or carbon monoxide, in it following the explosion. It was this that killed most of the 95 miners who died, not the direct effect of the blast. Another failing of the ventilation system was brought to light by the accident at Hartley Colliery in Durham in 1862. The beam of the pumping engine at the mine broke and crashed down the shaft. Under most circumstances this might not have been a serious problem but, unfortunately, the mine only had a single shaft with a brattice or screen to separate the air flows through the mine. One side of the shaft was for the clean air going in and the other for the used air coming out. The iron beam crashed through the brattice and disrupted the air supply to the miners, who were all unharmed by the fall of the beam. However, as the oxygen at the bottom of the mine was used up the miners slowly suffocated and all 204 in the pit at the time of the accident died. This led to the requirement that all coal mines in the United Kingdom should have two shafts in order to help ensure that there was a sufficient flow of air through the mine at all times. Brattices had earlier been invented to lead the flow of air through the underground workings of a mine and prevent it from dissipating without having any beneficial effects. This idea was developed by Carlisle Spedding of Whitehaven in the 1750s and was enhanced by John Buddle who invented a system involving three shafts and a more elaborate method of `coursing' or leading the air through the workings. Sometimes, if the two shafts were at the same topographical level, the air had to be helped to start it moving through a mine. This was often achieved by lighting a fire at the bottom of the shaft through which the engineer wished the air to escape and the subsequent loss of pressure in the pit sucked air in through the other shaft. Fans were not powerful enough to be useful for the ventilation of mines until well into the twentieth century, but are now used in the majority of underground mining operations. Unfortunately, within seven years of the accident at the Hartley Colliery this method of improving ventilation led to a depressingly similar disaster. This occurred at the Avondale colliery near Plymouth in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania on the morning of 6 September 1869.
Chapter 4/page 8
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
The region was known for its union militancy at the time (see Chapter 2) and the mine had reopened that morning following a lengthy strike. As with the Hartley Colliery, the shaft was divided into two compartments with a wooden brattice and, in order to enhance the flow of air through the operation, a fire was customarily lit at the base of the upcast side of the shaft. At about 9 am the stable boss descended the shaft with a load of hay for the mules and discovered that the ventilating furnace had set fire to the woodwork in the shaft. He just had time to escape before a mass of flame engulfed the shaft, setting fire to the coal breaker and the engine house, which then fell back into the shaft, further stoking the fire, which raged for several hours. The fire was eventually quenched with water, and by half past five that evening the 40 feet of debris that had collected at the bottom of the shaft was cleared and a dog with a lamp was lowered on a rope. As the dog stayed alive and the lamp remained lit, a party of men soon followed to clear the remaining debris and search for survivors. This group was soon driven back by the noxious gases that had collected in the mine and it took a further 30 hours before a ventilating fan had blown enough clean air into the mine to enable further search parties to be despatched. At half past six in the morning, nearly two days after the fire started the searchers found the bulk of the 110 men and boys who had been in the mine when the fire started. Longwall mining Only those deposits covering a relatively large area can be exploited using the most economical means of underground mining, namely longwall mining. The technique is in widespread use around the world as it is generally regarded as both efficient and relatively safe. In this type of extraction two parallel tunnels are driven into the coal from a main driveage in the mine. The tunnels are spaced about 200 m apart and can be up to 2000 m long. Finally, a third tunnel is driven across at the end making a rectangle, or panel, of coal exposed on all four sides. This means that any geological problems can be determined before mining commences and can be built into the mining plan. A longwall shearer, which is essentially a huge gouging machine, is placed in the third, end tunnel and works its way back by taking slices off the coal. The coal is then mechanically scraped, dragged or
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 9
The coal industry
conveyed to one of the entry tunnels, from where it is conveyed to the main driveage and out of the mine. As each slice is taken the machine is moved forwards, allowing the hanging wall rock to fall into the gap left by the removal of the coal, sometimes referred to as the goaf. This reduces the potential scope for a build-up of noxious gases and as the miners are cocooned within the shearer they are relatively safe from debris that could fall from the roof. The return of the machine to the main driveway of the mine means that the state of the roof is of little matter as there will not be any more need to use the first tunnels driven through the coal. The machine is therefore available for use in the next longwall panel and after a few days to complete the move it will be back cutting coal. The machines generally cost about US$50 m, depending on their size, cutting speed and associated conveying capacity. Whilst most underground shearing operations are carried out on coal seams of up to two metres in thickness, there are some in China that are extracting seams of up to eight metres thick. In these mines the collapse of the roof is controlled and coal conveyed from a second conveyor behind the shearer until roof rock becomes visible. The shearing machine is then moved forwards to take the next undercut of the coal seam. Room and pillar mining If there are problems either with the strength of the hanging wall or with faulting within the deposit, then more expensive methods of mining need to be employed. These tend to involve the need to leave pillars of coal within the mine which can, only occasionally, be extracted as the mine closes. In view of this the recovery of coal is lower than in longwall mining, which recovers around 95% of the coal in each panel, and the cost to mine a deposit of the same geological size would be higher. It is also the case that the presence of the pillars may make it difficult to ventilate the working faces adequately to prevent the build-up of noxious or explosive gases. Indeed, in many cases, not just in coal-mining, it is very important to check the mineable size of a deposit rather than the geological size. A deposit can be huge, but if only a small fraction of it can be extracted, due to geological or other problems, then its ultimate size is of little consequence. As an example, Yanzhou Coal stated coal reserves of 1957 Mt in its 1998 listing prospectus, of which only 739 Mt
Chapter 4/page 10
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
(or 38%) was actually recoverable using modern mining techniques. The room and pillar method was by far the most used method until the development of the fully mechanised longwall method. Indeed, the widespread use of room and pillar mining, not just for coal, has led to it acquiring a number of names, including pillar and stall, post and stall, bord and pillar, and stoop and room. In this technique the coal can be mined using a variety of different equipment, from an individual with a pick and shovel to the larger continuous miners or gouging machines that can mine coal and place it directly on a conveyor for transport out of the colliery. It must be noted, however, that the technique is an `advance' mining technique, rather than a `retreat' technique, as is the case with longwall mining. As a consequence, the roof will need to be supported in order to provide access to the coal face, and this is often achieved using rock bolts which increase the cost of room and pillar extraction. In view of the relative weakness of coal-bearing strata, the greater the depth of the deposit, the greater the pressures on the rock and the likelihood that the hanging rock will fail. This means that the pillars that are left behind have to be larger at increasing depth. General statistics that were adopted in the United Kingdom coalfields give a rough guide for the recovery of coal from underground workings using room and pillar methods and clearly show why longwall mining is the more profitable and preferred method of coal extraction (see Table 4.2). Table 4.2 Depth and coal recovery in room and pillar mining Depth (feet)
Recovery (%)
300 300±600 600±900 900±1500
50 35 25 20
Source: Kerr, 1919.
In many cases it is possible to increase the recovery by taking out the pillars at the last stage of mining the deposit. This is, however, a more dangerous and expensive exercise, as support has to be given to the roof during the extraction process to prevent the roof from falling. In view of this it is often necessary to leave at least some of the pillars behind. Furthermore, there are also restrictions about the location of underground coal mines and their presumed areas of surface
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 11
The coal industry
influence. As a consequence, mining is restricted under or near sites of historical interest and centres of population. In undersea collieries, such as RJB's Ellington mine in Northumberland, the use of room and pillar mining is a requirement of the government's Health and Safety Executive (HSE) in order to minimise the risk of a breach to the seabed that could flood the mine. The need to provide support to the roof also means that there has to be a relatively large amount of rock left behind around the mine shaft, even after the end of mining, often referred to as the shaft or crown pillar. This is also because of the danger involved in removing the coal, which would then remove most of the support for the shaft and headframe. Should this collapse, then any miners underground could be trapped as their immediate escape route would be blocked. Such a problem normally only arises in the mining of tabular or relatively flat-lying deposits as, for economic reasons, the shaft would need to be positioned as close to the middle of the deposit as possible. This would minimise life of mine travelling and transport time from the coal face to the shaft for both personnel and coal. The mining of metalliferous deposits is often more complicated as the style and shape of the deposit is likely to have been influenced by a number of different factors. This is not to say that coal deposits cannot undergo large-scale deformation, but that the higher costs of mining such deposits would not make exploitation profitable. Indeed, most of the closures of coal mines in the United Kingdom have been on economic grounds rather than because they ran out of coal. Nevertheless, the room and pillar mining operation can reduce some mining risks as such a mine can be worked on several sections or faces at one time. It is also possible to mix and match different techniques ± even between open cast and underground techniques within the same deposit. Indeed, in some open cast mines, adits or tunnels are driven in under the highwall and can either be used by continuous miners to extract coal, or can be used to form panels for longwall mining operations. The different underground mining techniques employed in the United States in recent years are detailed in Fig. 4.2 and show that the bulk of the coal is produced using continuous miners, although longwall operations have increased dramatically in popularity since the early 1980s, with consequent benefits to productivity and profitability.
Chapter 4/page 12
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
4.2 Production from different underground mining techniques in the United States (source: Facts About Coal).
4.4 Productivity The British coal-mining industry suffered from poor productivity during the nineteenth century as it sought to increase production by employing more miners rather than by improving mining techniques. Indeed, by 1913, the British coal mines were much less productive in terms of annual output per employee than those of either Germany or the United States, despite Britain having a much greater overall level of output. This low level of productivity and the problems associated with the great depression of 1873±1896 led to calls for a coal combine or cartel to attempt to maintain prices and keep the industry profitable. Poor productivity seems to have resulted from the massive spread of the industry from relatively small-scale operations to much larger concerns that were provided with public capital. The real difficulty in the extraction of coal had been overcome with the invention of the pumping engine, which enabled the removal of water from underground workings beneath the water table. After this there was little concentration on the mechanisation of mining as many of the pits worked seams that were only 18 inches thick and that even today cannot be worked economically using mechanical techniques. Indeed, one of the reasons for the higher level of mechanisation of mines in other countries was the thicker seams, which enabled
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 13
The coal industry
more profitable extraction. It is also true that many of the United Kingdom's easily accessible thick seams had been worked in earlier times and that only the thinner, near surface ones were left. The deeper seams that are now being mined are also relatively thick and can be extracted using mechanical techniques but they were too deep to be mined during the nineteenth century. Despite these earlier problems, British Coal's productivity improved dramatically in the years running up to privatisation in 1994. This can be seen from the improvement in the overall productivity of the mining operations between 1979 and 1983 (see Fig. 4.3). Indeed, during the previous five years the productivity of the coal mines had fallen both in terms of output per man-year and output per man-shift from 474 t and 2.29 t to 448 t and 2.24 t, respectively. Between 1979 and 1983, i.e. before the start of the miners' overtime ban on 31 October 1983, productivity had improved to 504 t/man-year and 2.44 t/man-shift. A large part of the increase in productivity must, however, be related to the long-term nature of the improvements wrought by the 1974 Plan for Coal in view of the long-term nature of the investment needed to increase output in the mining industry. Indeed, as Derek Ezra wrote in 1983 `there is a gap of up to a decade before full benefits of major investment are realized so that the industry is now seen to be significantly influenced by the under-investment of the 1960s'. Within the framework of the Plan for Coal, the number of deep mines run by British Coal fell from 246 to 191 between 1974 and 1983 and this must
4.3 Productivity at British coal mines 1974±92 (source: Kernot, 1993).
Chapter 4/page 14
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
have had an impact on the productivity improvement in the latter years of the period. In South Africa, productivity increased from 1827 t/man-year in 1986 to 4128 t/man-year in 1995. However, mechanisation in the country is not as easy as it is in other coal-mining countries as a consequence of differing geological conditions. For instance, while longwall mining has been particularly successful in Australia, and to a certain extent in the United Kingdom, it has not achieved similar gains in South Africa. Moreover, as with the problems faced in the gold industry, the increase in public holidays following the election of the country's first truly democratic government in 1994 served to disrupt production. This, when combined with other restrictions on Saturday and Sunday working, and the occasions when public holidays fall in the middle of the week thereby disrupting output in the earlier or later days, has caused a relative fall in productivity. There has been much work within South Africa to improve the output of the mining industry. Much of this has focused on education programmes aimed at multi-skilling which should, in turn, enable a reduction in the overall numbers of employees. Nevertheless, it has often been the case that management levels have been reduced whereas the actual miners are retained. In 1994±95 Sasol's productivity was 4340 t/man-year and Ingwe's productivity was 4332 t/man-year. In Ingwe's case, merging together various operations yielded a number of synergy benefits including a wider range of production sources yielding greater varieties of quality, better blending opportunities, easier coal transport logistics and a unified marketing approach. Amcoal's 1995 productivity rose dramatically with the reduction in the labour force from 23 000 in 1985 to only 9000 in 1995, leading to productivity of just below 6000 t/manyear in 1995. Productivity at Peabody's mines in the United States is detailed in terms of short tons for each shift worked. This was 33.3 t/shift in 1990 and nearly increased by 2.5 times to 82.9 t/shift in 1996. Total output per employee from the group's mines in Australia was 11 034 short tons in 1994. Average productivity statistics across the United States, including important support staff not actively involved in winning coal, shows that the overall trend in the country has improved dramatically (see Fig. 4.4). As indicated, in all productivity
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 15
The coal industry
4.4 Productivity of United States coal mines (source: Facts About Coal; EIA)
statistics it remains important to ensure that the data is directly comparable as some companies may have different criteria to decide which employees to include in the statistics. Productivity in China has deteriorated in the state-run mines probably at least partly due to the effect of small mine expansion to only 1.33 t/man-day in 1992. Despite this push for mechanisation only 41% of state operations were classed as fully mechanised in 1993. Productivity statistics for state-run mines are detailed in Table 4.3. Table 4.3 Productivity statistics for Chinese state-run mines Location
1952
1965
1979
1992
Overall Face
0.66 2.34
0.86 3.82
0.97 4.08
1.33 6.67
Source: Mining Magazine.
In Poland's restructuring plan productivity was expected to rise from 508 t/man-year to 616 t/man-year. In 1993 productivity in Germany was 741 t/man-year whilst in the United Kingdom in the same year it was 2811 t/man-year. In 1996/97 in Queensland, Australia, productivity was 12 014 t/man-year, and in the following year it rose to 15 163 t/man-year. The rise in productivity came as a result of new longwall operations starting production, which im-
Chapter 4/page 16
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
proved the underground statistics by 43%. Nevertheless, they remained at only 10 768 t/man-year, still substantially below the 16 599 t/man-year average of the open pit mines in the state.
4.5 Total mining costs Mining costs are heavily dependent on the geological and geographical situation of the deposit, the mining technique employed and the country of operation, with respect to both employee costs and taxes. As a consequence, it is a subject that needs to be considered on a micro rather than a macro level although, as indicated above, companies are under continued pressure to reduce costs to ensure profitability in an increasingly competitive market. One of the lowest production cost areas of the world is the Powder River Basin of Wyoming in the United States. The low cost of production is related to the near-surface presence of thick seams of coal, which reduces mining costs and ensures that the coal can be priced at a level that can bear substantial transport costs. The average 1996 cost of production of Wyoming coal, based on a selling price of US$5/t, is detailed in Fig. 4.5. This shows that the mining company would have a relatively meagre net income of only about 5% of the selling price of the coal ± and it is for this reason that coal-mining has become a low margin but high volume business. This also belies the potential cash generative ability of coalmines ± especially if the additional depreciation charge of US$0.30/t is added back into the
4.5 Breakdown of average 1996 Wyoming coal costs and profits based on a US$5.00/ton sales price (source: Wyoming Coal Information Committee, 1997).
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 17
The coal industry
equation. As a consequence, a mine's cash inflow is likely to be more than twice the level of reported profits.
4.5.1
Taxes and royalties
All coal mined on federal leases in the United States is now subject to a royalty of 12.5% of coal value. This represents a rise of 500% over the previous royalty, which was of the order of US$0.20/t. In total, United States taxation and royalties can account for about 37% of the total cost of coal shipped to a consumer. This accounts for about US$1.85/t out of a potential sales price of US$5.00/t. This shows how extraneous costs can influence the economics of a mining project ± especially if the taxes are levied on an ad valorem basis.
4.5.2
Processing costs
The use to which the coal is to be put and the additional treatments required can significantly add to the cost of production. As an example, Anglo American has detailed the respective costs of production at its Eskom-dedicated mines (which tend not to need any pre-treatment ahead of sale) and its trade mines (the output from which often requires washing and sizing before sale ± especially for the export market). The free on rail costs are detailed in Table 4.4, which indicates significant costs of treating coal from the trade collieries so that it is acceptable to the export market. Table 4.4 Cash production costs of Anglo Coal South African collieries (US$/tonne) Year to 31 December
1996
1997
1998
Eskom-dedicated Collieries Trade collieries Average
6.70 12.00 8.60
6.70 13.30 9.00
6.20 12.10 8.20
Note: Costs are detailed before allowing for amortisation or the cost of transport from mine to port. Source: Anglo American.
It should also be noted that although the costs are detailed in US dollars, the actual costs will be incurred in South African rand and so the exchange rate between rand and dollars can affect the level of costs on translation. The general depreciation of the South African currency against the US dollar (a similar situation that also affects the
Chapter 4/page 18
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
Australian dollar during commodity price weakness as it is also a commodity-backed currency) tends to benefit local producers that sell into the export market in US dollars. As a consequence, costs should fall at a faster rate than revenues, assuming that local currency inflation remains under control.
4.6 Reclamation One of the increasing costs in the mining industry is the cost of reclamation of a mine following the exhaustion of reserves or closure on economic grounds. When a mine closes the reclamation programme is normally well underway ± especially as most opencast mining techniques involve the removal of overburden from the top of a coal seam and its placement in a previously mined out area. In South Africa Anglo Coal estimates that the rehabilitation of open pit mines accounts for 10% of the operating cost, whilst it is only 3% of the operating cost for deep mines. The differential is similar at RJB Mining in the United Kingdom, where provisions are £62 m for deep mines that produced 19.8 Mt in 1998 and £97 m for open pit mines that produced 5.8 Mt in the same year. In South Africa Anglo Coal estimated the cost of rehabilitation at around R130 000/ha in 1995, against the cost of land of R2000/ha when used for cattle grazing or arable farming. In the United States ongoing reclamation costs are estimated at between US$24 700/ha and US$37 000/ha with higher water management charges responsible for the top end of the range. In order to minimise some of the water management costs, Anglo Coal is investigating the possibility of using a series of beds through which water run-off from waste dumps can be channelled so that the various impurities can be neutralised. At the Arnot coal mine water is first passed through reduction beds to remove oxygen and prevent the limestone in subsequent beds from being coated with iron oxides. Limestone neutralisation of acid follows and the water subsequently passes through a bed of carboniferous material such as manure or sewage sludge. Finally, the water passes through a `polishing' wetland system before discharging into a natural watercourse. In order to ensure that a mining company is able to complete its final closure obligations it is often asked to post a reclamation bond
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 19
The coal industry
with the local authority or government. In some instances the posting of a bond is particularly important ± especially if a company is forced to close for financial reasons. In this instance the bond can be used to carry out the required closure procedures and not leave the liability with the local authority. As a further incentive the mining company may be able to complete the final closure programme more quickly than estimated and for a lower cost. As a consequence, any over-provision of closure expenses could yield additional cash flow that has not been expected. This could also involve the sale of the old mine site for landfill, or for development of industrial or other buildings. Such a site is unlikely to be used for residential housing. In the case of underground coal-mining the use of the site is likely to be precluded in view of the potential concern of subsidence that can damage the surface. Moreover, the structure of any buildings constructed above an old mine could also be undermined, thereby increasing the danger to residents or employees. As a consequence, the land above most mining operations is likely to be used for agricultural purposes. This reduces the danger that sink-holes and other surface expressions of the underground workings will open up without warning and risk injury to the local population. In addition to the straightforward filling of open pits (or their conversion into lakes or other local amenities, which could also add value to a local community) a longer term commitment often has to be given to cover mine-water drainage. Before mining commences, and during the mining process, the seepage of water is controlled and is unlikely to cause any problems to local lakes and river systems. However, when mining has been completed and the old workings fill with water there is a danger that the water will overflow. If it has picked up sulphur and formed sulphuric acid from the sulphur content of the remaining coal this can cause a long-standing problem for local aquatic life. As a consequence, mining companies are now required to construct special wetlands and other acid absorbent areas around old mines in order to reduce the risk of polluting local waterways. Mining companies also have to be aware of the potential disruption to local communities that can be caused by the mining process. This can involve the use of explosives at specific times of day and the amount of dust that surface explosions may cause.
Chapter 4/page 20
# Charles Kernot
Exploration, mining and production
Furthermore, the transport of coal and waste from the mine to the customer or the dump, respectively, may also need to be controlled if the mine is located adjacent to a densely populated area.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 4/page 21
5 Treatments and quality assurance 5.1
End product requirements
5.2
Sampling 5.2.1 Sampling techniques Size distribution Hardness and abrasiveness Float-sink analysis
5.3
Processing techniques 5.3.1 Crushing and screening 5.3.2 Coal cleaning Jigs Heavy medium baths Cyclones Froth flotation Other separation methods
5.3.3 Dewatering
# Charles Kernot
5.1 End product requirements Coal is a generally widespread commodity with Australia and South Africa being the two major exporters. Increasing supply now means that coal producers and traders competing in the international market have to offer coals of consistent quality in order to ensure customer satisfaction. It is for this reason that treatments to produce a specific quality of coal are becoming more important such that 80% of all coal-mining operations in New South Wales have a preparation plant. Coal sold locally is often not subject to such stringent criteria, with mine mouth power stations often designed to take run-of-mine (ROM) material. This is the situation in South Africa where a large proportion of local production is consumed in power stations constructed adjacent to the collieries. With negligible transport costs there is little economic advantage in minimising the amount of waste transported to the power station. Furthermore, fly ash or bottom ash can be used as backfill in the open pit mines, thereby negating disposal concerns. Consequently, this coal is normally sent directly from the colliery to the power station with no washing or other pretreatment undertaken. Export coal, however, is washed ahead of being put onto the railway wagons for shipment to the 65 Mt/year Richards Bay Coal Terminal.
5.2 Sampling In order to determine what processes are needed to treat the coal to improve its market acceptance, it is necessary to undertake a number of different tests. Some of the potential problems with coal are detailed in Chapter 3, but there are additional factors in the makeup of the material that can affect demand. In order to determine these it is first necessary to undertake a thorough sampling programme across the deposit. This should determine how the physical and chemical characteristics of the coal change across the deposit and ensure that the coal is of consistent quality. If the quality of the coal fluctuates markedly it may be necessary to construct a mining programme that ensures an average blend of coal over the life of the mine.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 5/page 1
The coal industry
A further consideration in the market evaluation process will be the expected dilution of the coal as a consequence of the mining process. This can be either as a result of narrow partings, which cannot be selectively mined, or from roof or floor rock which may also be mined due to the lower selectivity of a highly mechanised longwall operation. Nevertheless, the lower cost of mining using highly mechanised techniques means that more can be spent on cleaning processes and that lower quality coals can be mined. It is also the case that mining companies will wish to extract as much coal as possible from any particular deposit and will therefore attempt to reduce the amount that is left behind. As mechanical mining has lower levels of accuracy it is often necessary to over-extract and then remove waste rather than leave coal in the mine. In early times much of the processing of coal relied on the handpicking of waste from conveyor belts. Moreover, as much coal was mined on a piece-work basis, there was an incentive for the early miners to add extra weight through the addition of waste rock, which is normally more dense than coal. The other main processing technique was a basic crushing and screening process to produce a product to meet local needs. As most of these were domestic much of the coal supplied had to be of larger sizes, and it is only in recent years that demand for smaller sizes of coal has increased due to their use by electricity utilities. However, one of the additional factors that needs to be considered is that if the coal is reduced to too fine a particle size it may be more likely to be blown by wind, thereby causing storage problems. Small sizes will also provide a large surface area, increasing the likelihood of ignition, which is a particular problem with lignite. In view of this it is often necessary to keep coal sizes as large as possible ± especially when still within an underground mine where potential combustion causes additional problems. Longer conveyor belts have been developed for use underground as the longer the belt the fewer the transfer points at which the coal is likely to be reduced in size. The other advantage of using conveyor belts is that both the outward and return levels of the belt can be used to take coal out of the mine and bring in waste rock for backfilling, respectively. Such a system was introduced at Deutsche Stein Kohle's (DSK) Prosper Haniel coal complex in Germany in the mid-1980s. It requires that the belt is properly maintained and cleaned in order to ensure that dirt or
Chapter 5/page 2
# Charles Kernot
Treatments and quality assurance
mud does not enter other parts of the conveyor system and disrupt production. Conveyor belts are also normally the location of sampling points during the mining process. This is important in order to check for fluctuations in the quality of the coal being mined so that corrective action can be taken rapidly. A blast of air or a rotating arm can be used to remove coal from the conveyor into a sample collection point at regular intervals. The sample will then be taken to the mine laboratory for analysis, which will concentrate on determining the energy and mineral content of the coal using the techniques outlined in Chapter 3. The techniques outlined here relate to the choice of method used for cleaning and otherwise processing the coal in order to prepare it for sale.
5.2.1
Sampling techniques
The mechanical cleaning of coal initially started over 100 years ago but it is only in recent years that the international market has started to expand and so product quality requirements have started to increase. As indicated above, the sampling process has to be undertaken carefully in view of the many changes that can occur across a deposit. This can be related either to local magmatic activity, which can increase the rank of the coal but can also lead to the introduction of sulphur or other contaminants in particular areas. Alternatively, the deposit may be located near an aquifer and in some areas may contain significantly more water than in others. The sampling process can also be extremely sensitive and, as indicated in Chapter 3, different sampling processes can yield different results for the same or similar coals. As a consequence, the sampling process needs to be carefully documented and all equipment should be detailed and carefully calibrated. After mining commences sampling is undertaken on a regular basis. This can either be through a set sample being taken from a conveyor belt at regular intervals or using static methods from drill cores or directly from the working face. The sampling is undertaken at the mine in order to determine what grade of coal is being produced and to ensure that it is placed on the correct stockpile. As a single seam can yield a number of different grades of coal, depending on location and treatments, this is an
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 5/page 3
The coal industry
increasingly important part of the process. Nevertheless, mistakes do occur and sampling on behalf of the purchaser or consumer of the coal is becoming more widespread as the international trade in coal expands. This has seen the formation and expansion of a number of specialist analytical companies, which act as independent arbiters of the quality of coal in any individual shipment. The analytical technique used is not solely important for determining the differences between North American and British or Australian requirements, it is also important to ensure that the samples have been correctly taken. As an example, a sample from a 150 000 t consignment of coal delivered on a Capesize vessel would only be a few grams. However, those few grams have to be representative of the whole tonnage delivered and so sampling must be undertaken across the whole extent of the coal. It is not just sufficient to take samples at regular intervals across the bottom of the stockpile of coal formed after it has been unloaded from the ship in view of the physics of the settling process. This naturally means that the larger sizes of material will roll to the base of the pile, whilst the smaller sizes build to form the cone. The screens used to determine the relative size fractions must also be the same in order to achieve consistent results between the seller and the buyer. This is because screens with square holes but of ostensibly the same size as those with round holes will allow coal particles of up to 18% larger to pass through, thereby generating different results. As a consequence, sampling techniques and not just the act of sampling is extremely important across the industry. Specific companies involved in sampling coal include Inspectorate Griffith, SocieÂte GeÂneÂrale de Surveillance and TES Bretby. Size distribution Most electricity utilities require that coal is supplied on a consistent basis. In most cases it has to be supplied at a maximum size of around 2 inches or 5 cm as the utilities do not want to incur a large energy penalty crushing the coal to the grain size that is required for use in the generating plant. Nevertheless, larger sizes of coal are easier to handle and suffer reduced losses due to wind erosion. It is therefore important to determine the size distribution of the coal from a mine, but it may be that the distribution cannot be determined accurately until at least trial mining commences. This is
Chapter 5/page 4
# Charles Kernot
Treatments and quality assurance
because different mining techniques could each have a specific effect on the coal and alter the size range of material produced. The size distribution of a particular coal is generally thought of conforming to the Rosin and Rammler model, which was developed in 1933. It states that: R = 100e-(x/k)
n
Where: R = the cumulative per cent of coal retained on size x; e = the natural logarithm or 2.718; k = the absolute size constant or size modulus; n = the size distribution count or dispersion modulus. The formula is able to predict the size distribution of a coal crushed to a nominated maximum size from that of a sample crushed to a smaller top size. The formula can be used on small samples of coal from drill cores and can then be scaled up to provide an indication of the particle distribution of a ROM coal. This can then be used to give an indication of the different capacity requirements of different circuits within the process plant. Hardness and Abrasiveness It is necessary to determine the hardness of a coal and its surrounding media in order to ensure that the process plant is able to break down the material effectively and thereby liberate the coal. The most widely accepted hardness test yields the Hardgrove Grindability Index (HGI) of a coal. It is derived by grinding a defined weight of coal, with a fixed particle size distribution, in a Hardgrove mill. This is a ring-ball mill and produces a finely powdered coal, which is then screened, and the HGI is calculated with reference to the mass of fine material produced. The higher the value of the index, the softer and easier to grind the material. Coals having an HGI of 50 or below often find little application for use in pulverised fuels. The abrasive nature of a coal, or more accurately any other minerals, such as quartz, that it contains may also need to be determined. This is because it can lead to undue wear of grinding mills if the coal is to be pulverised for use in power stations or as pulverised coal injection (PCI) material in blast furnaces. The abrasiveness of a coal, and its subsequent abrasion index (AI), is calculated as the loss of
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 5/page 5
The coal industry
metal on four metal blades (in milligrams per kilogram of coal) which are spun at 1500 rpm for eight minutes in a sample of coal with a specified size distribution. Float±sink analysis Most cleaning operations in a coal-mining wash plant are based on the relative densities of the coal and the waste rock produced. It is therefore necessary to determine the relative densities of these materials in order to design the wash plant so that it operates effectively over the life of the mine. In this process it is necessary to simulate the initial phases of mineral processing in order to ensure that the testing process is of a similar material to that produced when the plant starts operation. This is particularly important as degradation of shale and coal can affect the performance of the float plants and significantly affect overall recoveries. As a general rule, the number of particles in a float±sink test should not be less than 2000, and not less than ten should represent any one size fraction. The test is undertaken through placing a sample in a container of organic liquid of the lowest relative density required. The material that sinks is then drained and placed in a container with a slightly higher density liquid and the process repeated until the highest density required under the testing programme has been reached and, theoretically, no coal is left in the sink material. The ash content of each density fraction is then determined, although other factors such as sulphur and swelling index may also be tested. The efficiency of separation also needs to be determined and whilst it can be presumed to be efficient under controlled laboratory conditions the actual efficiency is likely to be considerably lower in an operating plant. The overall performance of the wash plant is dependent on the process used and on the particle size distribution, and is less affected by the washability characteristics of the coal and waste. The efficiency is determined by calculating the amount of coal produced from the plant as a per cent of the amount of coal in the feed within any particular relative density range.
5.3 Processing techniques As indicated above, there is a range of techniques that can be
Chapter 5/page 6
# Charles Kernot
Treatments and quality assurance
used to separate and upgrade the coal into higher value products than its value as a combined material when it comes out of a mine. Some of this increase in value is related to the simple separation of larger sized and potentially more valuable domestic coals from smaller sized material more amenable for use in power stations. The choice of techniques is dependent upon the results of the sampling of the ROM material but also on the end product requirements outlined at the start of this chapter.
5.3.1
Crushing and screening
The first part of the processing procedure for coal following its extraction is normally a reduction in size necessary to allow easy handling of the material. As the rock mined will contain a full range of particle sizes not all of the rock needs to be crushed and so it will also be subject to a sizing process. It is also the case that some of the larger sizes of rock are likely to contain mixtures of coal and waste so a size reduction process should ease the separation of the two materials. This is particularly because of the differential density between coal and most waste rocks, which could otherwise reduce recoveries if density separation procedures are to be used in the later stages of the process plant. In general, most underground mines will produce rock at up to 30 cm in diameter, whilst open pit operations can produce rocks of over 1 m in diameter. Prior to any further processing these rocks must be reduced to a maximum size of about 15 cm, although in some instances a maximum size of 25 mm is required, depending on the results of the float±sink tests, described above. The more the coal is inter-banded with other rock types the finer the crushing process in order to ensure effective separation of the coal. Crushing takes place in a range of different machines that are appropriate for the type of coal produced and the hardness of both the coal and the adjacent rocks. The crushers used may include jaw crushers, gyratory crushers or roll crushers, although unlike the metallurgical industry there will be no finer milling of the coal ± even using autonomous milling techniques. The amount of crushing equipment required will depend on the size requirements of the subsequent stages of the process plant, together with the HGI and the AI of the coal.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 5/page 7
The coal industry
After crushing the coal will be screened into various size fractions using large mechanical sieves. The sizing process ensures both that the crushing process has been effective (with any oversize being returned to the crushing plant) and that the further separation processes can operate at optimal efficiency. This can be achieved because individual size fractions are likely to contain greater or lesser amounts of waste rock. Coal separation can also be carried out in a classifier. This is a machine that uses the principle that the larger the diameter or density of an object the greater its settling velocity in a fluid medium. Consequently, the technique can be used either for cleaning coal or for sizing the material, particularly for particles below about 0.5 mm in size. This process can be carried out in a tank, but cyclones are more normally used in coal plants, where they also find applications for cleaning coal.
5.3.2
Coal cleaning
As indicated above, the main methods of coal cleaning are through density separation. These methods separate the less dense coal from the normally more dense surrounding rocks that may be mined at the same time. Whilst the overall principle is the same, the methods are different and have different uses depending on the size fraction of the coal to which they are applied. The methods may employ water alone as the medium in which the process takes place or a water-solid suspension that mimics a heavier density medium. The size and shape of the coal may also affect the success of the separation process. Jigs Jigs used in coal cleaning processes are different from the jigs used in the metallurgical industry, which are effectively shaking tables. The coal jig is a tank of water, which is separated lengthways and has one half enclosed with the other open to the atmosphere. The pressure in the enclosed half can be increased or reduced back to atmospheric pressure, causing the water in the tank to move up and down around the central axis. The raw coal feed enters the tank at one end and moves to the other end, by which time the constant up±down movement of the
Chapter 5/page 8
# Charles Kernot
Treatments and quality assurance
water has caused a stratification of the feed into high- and low-density fractions. The low-density fraction containing the coal forms the top layer and floats off the top of the jig whilst the higher density fraction falls to the bottom for removal using a screw conveyor or other techniques. The process is not very efficient and requires relative densities in excess of 1.45. Moreover, it is also size dependent with optimal sizes generally between 10 mm and 200 mm, although particles of around 100 mm are probably separated most efficiently. Fine fractions of coal restrict the capacity of the jig, particularly below 10 cm, although on average most jig machines are likely to be able to process 200 t/hour of raw coal feed. In order to improve the overall efficiency of the jigs a `Jigscan' controller has been developed that can analyse the different pressures and densities in different parts of the tank. This has led to a more accurate measurement of the physical separation process within a jig. The system has also resulted in an increase in residence time in the jigs thereby increasing their efficiency, and has enabled an improvement in yields of up to 10%. One of the first plants to use the Jigscan system was MIM's Newlands coal mine in central Queensland where it has been introduced on two 1200 t/hour air-pulsed jigs. Heavy medium baths A more efficient method of coal cleaning is the heavy medium bath. In most instances the fluid used for separation of the coal and the waste rock is a mixture of water and either fine-grained magnetite or other solids such as shale, sand or barite. The advantage of using magnetite is that it can be recovered easily using a magnetic separator and can therefore be re-used in the process. As with the jig process the baths are most efficient for coarse feed material of between 20 mm and 150 mm and essentially operate on the same principle as straightforward density separation across a liquid of known density. As with the jig machines, the separation process is most efficient if fines are excluded from the process due to the size constraints of the solid suspension. Indeed, the finer the material in suspension the finer the raw coal feed can be, except that a limiting factor is the ability to recover the magnetite, which is impaired if the magnetite is too finely ground.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 5/page 9
The coal industry
Cyclones Cyclones are widely used in the mining industry for the separation of samples on the basis of either size or density. A cyclone is a conically shaped tank with an angled inlet pointed towards the top, and two central outlets, one at the top and one at the bottom. The less dense and finer particles in a cyclone are drawn into a central helical vortex created by the angle of the inlet pipe and rise through the top of the tank. Those particles that are larger or denser fall to the sides and then the bottom of the tank to be extracted through the underflow. Whilst cyclones are often used as sizing apparatus instead of screens they also find applications as dense medium separators, being able to treat particles with sizes of between 0.5 mm and 30 mm. Improving efficiencies also mean that they can be effective at both larger and smaller sizes. The difference between the sizing cyclones and those used for density separation is the incorporation of a heavy medium, normally magnetite, in the liquid. This promotes the density separation effect of the cyclone. Although it is still possible to use just water, this reduces the overall efficiency of the machine. Nevertheless, in some instances the cyclones utilising a magnetite slurry may also suffer from poor efficiencies. This can occur if the magnetite is too finely ground, which tends to result in the magnetite being included in the overflow from the cyclone together with the recovered coal. Cyclones that use water with no additions are often used as two-staged units in order to improve efficiency. Froth flotation Whilst froth flotation is normally considered the preserve of the metalliferous mining industry it is used on occasion in the coal industry, particularly for the cleaning of finer particles of coal, normally for use in PCI. As a hydrophobic (or aerophilic) substance, finely ground coal normally floats in water. This propensity to float is enhanced in froth flotation cells, although the process can be aided further with the addition of reagents. The reagents are normally used to enhance the hydrophilic (aerophobic) nature of all of the waste material in the plant feed as coal is a naturally hydrophobic substance. The expense of the process, and relatively low value of steaming coal, means that it is not widely used for coal preparation, although it is gaining increasing acceptance in the coking coal industry where the
Chapter 5/page 10
# Charles Kernot
Treatments and quality assurance
value of the product is higher. Flotation is, however, widely used elsewhere in the mining industry and provides environmental advantages through the extraction of coal from waste dumps that might otherwise cause problems as a result of a high sulphur content and consequent acid drainage. Ironically, high sulphur coal is least desired by consumers in view of the additional environmental problems that it causes, but sulphur has been shown to enhance the flotation properties of the fuel. In froth flotation tanks, air and finely ground feed material are pumped in at the bottom. As the air rises to the top of the liquid in the tank it carries with it the hydrophobic coal, whereas the hydrophilic rock will sink to the bottom of the tank and can be removed using other methods. As in the metallurgical industry, the froth flotation process works best on small sized particles, generally below 0.5 mm. A new development in froth flotation is a column flotation process, designed by Microcel, to replace the tank flotation process that is more normally employed. The columns are 4 m in diameter and some 10 m tall, and each has a capacity of approximately 400 t/ hour of 0.5 mm feed, which is introduced about two-thirds of the way up the column. The hydrophobic coal is lifted by bubbles introduced at the bottom of the column, whilst ash is washed down through the deep froth zone that forms at the top. The deep froth zone allows the dirty process water to be replaced with clean water thereby improving the overall quality of the final product. Following flotation the coal is dewatered in a single stage cyclone and filtration plant. The columns have been shown to improve the overall efficiency of fine coal recovery by 4% at BHP's Peak Downs mine in Queensland (equivalent to 360 000 t/year of coking coal) and are now being introduced in a number of other mines in Australia. Other separation methods Other equipment can be installed to separate coal from the denser fractions. These include a Vorsyl Separator and a Dyna Whirlpool, which both work on the same principle as the cyclone. Other equipment includes the straightforward shaking table that is used in density separation of gold in many mines around the world. In coal mines, however, it is the less dense rather than the denser fraction that is recovered. Oil agglomerations were also once used in
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 5/page 11
The coal industry
the coal industry, utilising the ability of oil to `wet' the surface of the coal and encourage separate particles to stick together. The larger agglomerates could then be separated from smaller sized waste rock through one of the sizing processes outlined above.
5.3.3
Dewatering
After the coal has been separated from the waste rock, it is necessary to remove any additional water in order to improve the quality of the final product. As the surface area of the coal increases, and its size reduces, so the cost of dewatering also tends to rise. Coal above about 10 mm in diameter is normally dewatered on a shaking screen, which removes the water through vibration. Smaller particles (0.5±10 mm) can be dewatered using centrifuges, where the solid particles coat the inside of the centrifuge and can be extracted using a screw conveyor. For even finer coal the material needs to be dewatered using a vacuum filter, although this normally leaves the water content relatively high at 17±25%. In some instances, heat is applied to dry the coal, although it is not a usual method. This may be due to the local environment, where high water contents could lead to the freezing of the coal in arctic conditions, or to reduce the inherent water content of the coal to comply with customer requirements and/or reduce transport costs.
Chapter 5/page 12
# Charles Kernot
6 From mine to market 6.1
Transport logistics
6.2
Export ports 6.2.1 Australia New South Wales Queensland
6.2.2 South Africa 6.2.3 Russia Vostochny Ust-Luga 6.2.4 Indonesia 6.3
Shipping
6.4
Import ports 6.4.1 Rotterdam Stevedores European Massagoed-Overslagbedrijf European Bulk Services
6.4.2 Other European ports Amsterdam Sea-Invest Group Ovet
# Charles Kernot
6.1 Transport logistics Transport routes and the cost of the various forms of transport are becoming increasingly important in coal-mining and trading. The reason for this is the increasing construction of mine-mouth plants by Independent Power Producers (IPPs), which benefit from minimal transport costs and are therefore able to compete aggressively on the price of the electricity that they supply. It is also the case that a greater distance from mine to market exposes the consumer to a higher delivery risk. Conversely, construction of gas-fired Combined Cycle Gas Turbine (CCGT) plant may reduce delivery risk in developed countries in view of the highly efficient gas distribution network that has been constructed in these areas. Mine-mouth power stations may be economically efficient using conveyor belt systems for distances of up to 20±25km from the mine, but beyond this distance it is normally considered more efficient to truck the coal. Rail is more normally used for longer distances, as it tends to be the most cost-efficient method of long-distance land transport. In terms of economics the larger the train, the more economical the transport ± and given that transport costs may be a significant part of the delivered cost of the coal, any means of reducing these costs is utilised by the mining companies. Various alternatives must be considered for rail transport, and the compatibility of a system also needs to be taken into account if rail wagons are to be leased from a local railway company. Indeed, either bottom discharge or tippling wagons may be used and it is important to ensure that they are compatible with the system being installed. In some countries an own-your-own-wagon (OYOW) scheme has been introduced to overcome some problems. Loading of wagons is also important as it has to be carried out quickly and efficiently in order to ensure the most efficient use of the capital employed. It is also important as it may be that the track is only available to the mining company for the transport of coal at particular times and that if one slot is missed there may be a substantial delay until the next one becomes available. Train-loading speed through any form of rapid-loading system utilising silos will probably be most efficient but will also require additional capital investment. In some countries, such as the United Kingdom, other simpler loading systems such as a payloader or wheeled dozer are not allowed.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 1
The coal industry
In the United States, the coals of the Powder River Basin in Wyoming are normally transported by rail from the pit-head to the power station, wherever it is located, whilst coals mined in the Mississippi basin are often barged to the customer or an intermediate transfer point. In Wyoming the railway companies Burlington Northern (60% of total coal shipped) and Western Railroad Properties (34%, a joint venture between Union Pacific and the Chicago and Northwestern) are the two biggest transporters, whilst Union Pacific (6%) also moves coal on its own account from the southern Wyoming mines. The trains used in Wyoming are normally between 115 to 120 wagons long, with each wagon capable of carrying about 100 t of coal. The trains will carry 12 500 t of coal, have an axle weight of 16 500 t, be 1.25 miles in length and require three to five locomotives with a combined capacity of 10 000 to 15 000 horsepower. In Indonesia, the state coal-mining company PTBA transports coal first by rail from the mine at Tanjung Enim in Sumatra to the port at Tarahan and then by barge to the major PLN power station at Surabaya on the island of Java. Other coal mines in Indonesia are mainly located on the island of Borneo and are situated closer to the coast. Nevertheless, some need to truck or convey the coal substantial distances in order to reach water deep enough for Panamax or Capesize vessels. Indeed, whilst most coal is used internally within its country of origin, the discovery of major coal deposits that can be mined at lowcost, together with the development of a global bulk transport industry, has revolutionised the coal industry. This has seen the development of major export operations over the past 20±30 years and an increasing reliance amongst coal consumers on imports as domestic industries are allowed to fall into decline. The oil crises in the 1970s also provided impetus to countries to look for alternative fuel supplies and those that were particularly reliant on oil also moved to use coal (and later nuclear power) as primary sources of energy.
Chapter 6/page 2
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
6.2 Export ports 6.2.1
Australia
New South Wales In New South Wales the Gunnedah coalfield is located the greatest distance from a port or other centre. It is situated 320 km north-west from Newcastle, and this increases the overall cost of transporting the coal to market. In New South Wales road is generally used in the southern coalfield, where it is used for haulage to the local rail head or delivery to local domestic consumers. In total, however, rail is the most important method of transport in the state, with a rail network of over 1050 km and 29 rail loading terminals using balloon loops and rapid load-out bins. Trains range in size up to 84 wagon trains carrying 8000 t of coal. The state has three major coal export terminals, Port Waratah's Carrington Coal Terminal (CCT) and the Kooragang Coal Terminal (KCT), both at Newcastle, and the Port Kembla Coal Terminal. The Port Waratah terminals are operated as joint ventures between the local coal producers, each of which has a specific allocation of capacity. Total stockyard capacity at the two Newcastle ports is some 2.9 Mt, with three 2500 t/hour shiploaders at CCT and three shiploaders each with a rated capacity of 10 500 t/hour at KCT. The CCT has two berths and the recently expanded KCT has three berths, effectively allowing the port to load up to five vessels simultaneously. Total capacity at Newcastle is of the order of 66 Mt/year with the port able to cater for Capesize vessels. The Port Kembla Coal Terminal is located adjacent to Wollongong, 80 km south of Sydney and serves the south and western coalfields of New South Wales. The port is operated by the Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd, a consortium of five equal partners: BHP, Kembla Coal and Coke, Metropolitan Collieries, Oakbridge and Shell Coal(since taken over by Anglo American in May 2000), but is managed by BHP. The port has stockpile capacity of 800 000 t and can load Capesize vessels at a rate of up to 6600 t/hour.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 3
The coal industry
Port
Maximum vessel size LOA (m) Beam (m)
KCT CCT
Annual capacity (Mt)
Stockyard capacity (t)
Maximum loading rate (t/hour)
315 300
55 47.1
15.2 15.2
52 25
1 210 000 1 700 000
10 500 7500
±
±
±
77
2 910 000
18 000
290
45
15.2
16
850 000
6600
Total Newcastle Port Kembla
Channel depth (m)
Queensland Gladstone is the fifth largest port in Australia and the largest of the four coal export locations in Queensland, operating through two coal terminals: the RG Tanna terminal and the Barney Point terminal. The port is well situated for access to the central region of Queensland, with direct rail links to the coal-producing areas of the state. The nearest coal mine to the RG Tanna terminal is the Moura operation, which is 189 km distant, whilst the furthest is Gregory, which is 370 km away. The port is a government-owned corporation and acts as the operator of the terminals, and although debt is guaranteed by the state it is financed on an arms-length basis. The port is dredged to allow a minimum sailing draught of 17 m and up to 18 m during high tides. The RG Tanna terminal has two berths with a combined length of 699 m and can accommodate vessels of up to 220 000 t. The RG Tanna Coal Terminal exported 25.7 Mt of coal in the 1998/99 financial year, up from 22.6 Mt in 1997±98. The operation has consistently increased its throughput since the start of the 1990s, when throughput was about 17 Mt. Total throughput capacity is currently of the order of 30 Mt/year, although the terminal has plans that could double this to 60 Mt/year when required. Stockpile capacity is up to 3.9 Mt of coal in 14 separate piles ± equivalent to the number of mines supplying coal through the port. The proportion of blended coal has increased markedly with an expansion of the terminal's equipment to the extent that 11.8 Mt (46% of total throughput) was blended in 1998/99. The Barney Point coal terminal is smaller than the RG Tanna terminal with throughput of only 1.6 Mt in the 1998±99 financial year, against 3.2 Mt in 1997/98. The total design capacity of the terminal is
Chapter 6/page 4
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
about 5 Mt/year with a stockpile of 400 000 t, and there is no blending facility at the operation. The terminal can only take smaller vessels of up to 90 000 t fully loaded or up to 150 000 t partly loaded given the lower draught of 15 m in comparison with the RG Tanna terminal. The Abbot Point coal terminal is situated 25 km north of the town of Bowen and represents Australia's most northerly coal export operation. The terminal has an offshore berth catering for the Newlands and Collinsville mines, which are connected to the port via a direct rail link. Total throughput at the port in 1997/98 was just over 7 Mt against a rated capacity of up to 12 Mt/year. The port can accommodate ships of up to 166 000 t and has a notional departure draught of some 17.5 m. The Brisbane coal terminal is also a relatively small operation with an annual capacity of some 5 Mt and only capable of accommodating ships of up to 90 000 t with a 13 m draught. Like the Gladstone port, the Brisbane Port Authority is a governmentowned corporation, although it has moved to a more diversified operation in recent years. The port has a total of 28 separate berths, of which only one is used for coal. The Hay Point port includes both the Dalrymple Bay Coal Terminal (DBCT) and the Hay Point Coal Terminal (HPCT), both located 40 km south-east of the town of Mackay, Queensland. The DBCT is owned by the government, although it is operated by the mining companies that utilise its facilities on a `common user' basis. The HPCT is owned by Central Queensland Coal Associates (CQCA) and operated by BHP Australia Coal. Total throughput at the port was 51.2 Mt in 1997±98 and 53.8 Mt in 1998/99 and is set to see further growth as the DBCT expansion is completed. This expansion should lift capacity to 37.5 Mt/year from 33.5 Mt/year and will require the intallation of an additional stacker± reclaimer and associated works. The terminal can load at a maximum rate of 7200 t/hour and will accept vessels of up to 200 000 t, although the minimum approach channel depth is only 13.1 m at low water. The HPCT has an annual capacity of some 28 Mt/year following an expansion that was completed in June 1998. The terminal can accept two ships for simultaneous loading in separate berths with a maximum capacity of 230 000 t and maximum departure draught of 17.7 m, although as with DBCT the minimum approach channel depth is 13.1 m.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 5
The coal industry
6.2.2
South Africa
With the increasing consumption constraints in South Africa during the 1960s Anglo American Coal, together with other local coal companies, started to look to the international market. This led to a contract to supply 27.8 Mt to Japanese consumers over a 14 year period although, in order to secure the contract, the partners required the construction of a 570 km railway link and the development of a port and coal export terminal. The coal terminal was set up as a producers' cooperative and was originally shared along investment and export requirement lines. The railway line was constructed by COALlink, a division of Spoornet, the South African state railway company, whilst Portnet built the port infrastructure and dredged a channel deep enough for Capesize vessels. Since the latest expansion was completed in August 1999, the port has an export capacity of 66.5 Mt/year, making it the largest single coal export terminal in the world. Following this expansion, the coal terminal contains a 240 ha stockpile area with a maximum stockyard capacity of 6.5 Mt across 43 discrete grades of coal, and is capable of loading up to 750 ships per year. However, discussions are continuing over the cost of, and who should pay for, an incremental expansion to an export capacity of around 70 Mt/year. Not all of the partners in the terminal want to pay for the expansion as they would not be able to increase mine output sufficiently to make full use of the additional capacity. Nevertheless, previous disagreements over which companies should pay for past expansions have been overcome and expansion of the terminal is to be expected at some stage over the next few years, leading to a further increase in South African exports. The trains despatched from the coal mines to Richards Bay can contain up to 200 wagons, which hold either 58 t or 84 t of coal and can be up to 2.7 km long. The terminal can accommodate up to 3000 wagons per day and speeds unloading through the use of a tippling mechanism. In this instance the wagons, which are owned by COALlink, are secured on rotary couplings and so there is no need for uncoupling between tipplings, which could delay the process. Moreover, the system of four tandem tipplers allows for the unloading of two wagons at once, further speeding the process. Coal is despatched over a 58 km conveyor belt system that operates at a
Chapter 6/page 6
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
speed of up to 22 km/hour either to the stockpiles or directly to ship if it is in dock. If the coal is not sent directly to the ship, it will be placed on one of over 100 separate stockpiles and reclaimed at a later date using one of six bucketwheel stacker±reclaimers, or a separate reclaimer. The facility also has two other stackers and is computer controlled to ensure that coal sent from specific mines is loaded onto the correct stockpile and not mixed with coal from another source. Testing of coal on arrival and despatch is carried out by a completely independent testing organisation ± the South African Bureau of Standards. Finally, for shiploading, the facility has four shiploaders, two with a rated capacity of 10 000 t/hour and two rated at 8500 t/hour, with berth capacity for five ships. The peak loading rate achieved at the terminal over a 24 hour period has been 12 917 t/hour. With later takeovers, mergers and investments the stakes have changed over time and Anglo American currently holds a 26% interest in the terminal ± giving it a 26% share of its export capacity (Table 6.1). Table 6.1 Ownership of the Richards Bay Coal Terminal Company
Ownership (1996) (%)
(2000) (%)
Billiton Anglo Coal JCI Shell Duiker Total Sasol Gold Fields Coal Kangra
41.3 23.7 7.4 7.3 5.9 5.7 5.2 2.3 1.2
41.3 26.0 Ð Ð 20.6 5.7 5.2 Ð 1.2
Source: Author.
Given the potential for South Africa to find additional market demand for its coals there remains the potential for further export increases in the future. This is likely to be achieved either through an incremental expansion of Richards Bay Coal Terminal (RBCT), the construction of a new terminal at Richards Bay or through an upgrading of the existing railway line to Maputo and additional investment in the local port at Matalo. The proposal to build a second coal terminal at Richards Bay was
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 7
The coal industry
originally called the Red Terminal project but has since changed its name to the South Dunes Coal Terminal (SDCT) and current plans envisage an annual capacity of some 12 Mt/year. This terminal would increase the use of the railway line between the port and the coalfields to around 79 Mt/year ± very close to its rated capacity of 80 Mt/year. Admittedly, further investment may be able to increase railway capacity further and it is to be expected that, as with the RBCT, the terminal would be expanded rapidly to improve capital efficiency should there be sufficient demand for the coal. The second, and potentially cheaper, option would involve the upgrading of the existing railway line between northern South Africa and Maputo in Mozambique. This represents a significantly shorter distance for the trains to travel and could therefore cut unit transport costs. There are various problems with such a plan, not least of which are the poor state of the Mozambique railways and the need to spend a large amount of capital upgrading the existing port facilities, which have a nominal capacity of 4.7 Mt/year against 1995 throughput of 1 Mt. Nevertheless, the development of the port may be aided by the construction of the Mozal aluminium smelter at Maputo. The smelter will need to use the Matalo port at Maputo to import its alumina and petcoke raw materials and export the finished aluminium produced. It will also lead to a redredging of the main channels in the port and the removal of ships scuttled in the harbour during Mozambique's civil war. As a consequence, some of the problems in Mozambique may be overcome with little cost to coal producers and this may encourage additional feasibilitiy studies into using the port. Both options are under investigation but, with expansion in internationally traded coal supplies elsewhere in the world, it may be that the projects remain on the drawing board until the outlook for the market becomes clearer. The only other important coal port in South Africa is at Durban, with a capacity of 2 Mt/year and potential to expand to 5 Mt/year.
6.2.3
Russia
In order to earn hard currency, Russia has been looking to increase its commodity exports. This has seen the country increase its exports of coal despite the long railway journey between many of the
Chapter 6/page 8
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
coalfields and the sea. Nevetherless, the cost structure of the industry is such that hard currency income more than offsets the internal cost of transport, which can often be covered with bartered coal or other commodities rather than paid for in cash. Vostochny The port of Vostochny was constructed 20 km east of the city of Nakhodka in the far east of Russia in 1970 and is now Russia's largest port serving the Pacific market. To encourage its development, the port and the city are designated as a `Free Economic Zone' so that it can be used for entrepoÃt purposes. The port is located in the Bay of Vrangel between the capes of Kamensky and Petrovsky. It is in a generally ice free zone with a monsoon climate between May and August benefiting from eastern and southeastern winds, whilst between October and March the prevailing winds are from the north and north-west with temperatures averaging ±5 ëC and the lowest temperatures in January reaching ±14 ëC. Vostochny is able to accommodate ships with a draught of up to 20 m and has a range of separate terminals with different operations. These include the import of raw materials, such as alumina, which are required for the country's metallurgical industry, and for exports of finished products, both as dry bulk and in containers. The first ship loaded at the Vostochny coal terminal was loaded on 28 December 1978 when the total volume of coal handling was of the order of 2 Mt/year. Now the operation has been expanded so that it is able to handle over 12 Mt/year, split across more than 25 different ranks of coal and sourced from Yakutugol, VossibUgol, Karboimpex and Dalintorg, amongst others. The total stockpile area at the port is approximately 680 000 t of coal and the operating capacity of the stacker-reclaimers is some 3000 t/hour. The port also has defrosting devices to enable the unloading of coal from the railway wagons in the depths of the Russian winter. The coal terminal has two wharves, which can each take vessels up to 360 m in length and a draught of 15 m. Each wharf is equipped with two loading machines, which means that four 18 000 t vessels can be loaded, or two vessels with up to 100 000 t capacity can be loaded, simultaneously. The shiploaders operate at a rate of 3000 t/hour and the port operates on a 24 hour basis, seven days a week.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 9
The coal industry
Ust-Luga The Ust-Luga port is located in the south-west part of the Gulf of Finland, 110 km from St Petersburg, and is a new enterprise in Russia, with the first delivery of coal taking place in 1999. The port has a nominal capacity of 8 Mt/year and has been constructed to boost the country's export earnings, with long-term contracts to supply German consumers with coal from Rosugol until 2005.
6.2.4
Indonesia
On the island of Borneo in Indonesia, PT Adaro moves coal up to 100 km by road from its mining operation to a local river, from where the coal is barged to the coast for transshipment to ocean-going vessels. This is likely to be an expensive process, but the absence of habitation means that there are normally few delays, except during the rainy season, which has caused some problems in recent years. Trucks are loaded with more difficulty than they are unloaded and this is also a factor in the calculation of the economics of the process. Conveyors are expensive and there is a continual requirement to ensure that spare parts of sufficient quality are available. A brokendown conveyor with no spare parts can be a serious problem. Nevertheless, a steel cord conveyor is used at the Kaltim Prima Coal operation, also in Borneo. The large throughput at the mine means that the very low operating cost more than offsets the relatively high capital cost of the equipment. The equipment also means that the mine is able to load ships directly with no requirement for additional handling of the coal except through stacker-reclaimer operations at the port, if required. Indonesia's main coal shiploading ports and terminals are shown in Table 6.2.
6.3 Shipping At high tonnages it is likely that a coal consumer will want to purchase coal on the basis of a free on board (FOB) contract as freight may then be optimised by the company. For smaller tonnages and for ease of contracting a cost, insurance and freight (CIF) contract may be more beneficial. Self-discharging vessels may be useful as they will mean that there is no requirement for a ship-unloader, although they
Chapter 6/page 10
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
Table 6.2 Indonesian coal ship loading ports and terminals Operator
Location
Open
Max vessel DWT
1997 Capacity (Mt/year)
2002 Capacity (Mt/year)
Kaltim Prima
Tanjung Barat, Kalimantan Tanah Merah, Kalimantan Balikpapan, Kalimantan South Pulau Laut, Kalimantan Tarahan, Teluk Bayur, Pulau Bali, Kalimantan
1991
180 000
12.0
15.0
1993
20 000
3.0
5.0
1995
65 000
3.0
5.0
1997 2000 1989 1991 1990 N/A
90 000 200 000 65 000 40 000 20 000
10.0
25.0
8.0 2.0 1.0 8.0
15.0 3.0 3.0 15.0
8.0
12.0
61.0
110.0
Kideco Jaya Agung Dermaga Prakasa Pratama Indonesia Bulk Terminal PTBA PTBA General port Self-loading vessels Floating cranes
East/South Kalimantan
N/A
Total capacity Source: Graeme Robertson, Swabara Group, CoalTrans Bali, 1997.
attract higher freight rates. As a commodity, shipping rates can fluctuate widely (see Fig. 6.1) and it is therefore necessary to ensure that contracts are fair and reasonable. What is often forgotten or unrecognised is that shipping availability is a commodity. In poor economic times global trade 2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 6.1 Baltic Freight Index (source: Datastream).
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 11
The coal industry
suffers and, as a result the amount of spare shipping capacity increases, forcing down prices. Conversely, when the global economy is active spare capacity diminishes rapidly, leading to a shortage and forcing up prices. Such a situation is difficult for all interested parties to manage in view of the relatively short-term nature of the global economic cycle and the long-term ship ownership required in order to earn a required return on capital. Indeed, it is sometimes said that ship owners make more money from buying ships during a recession to sell at the subsequent economic peak than they do out of managing and transporting cargo.
6.4 Import ports Rotterdam is one of the largest ports in Europe, and is the largest of ten ports stretching from Le Havre to Hamburg with a share of around 42% of the total tonnage of all types of cargo handled. Given its dry bulk handling ability it is also important from the perspective of coal imports into Europe, a factor aided by its good transport links inland into the continent. The tonnage handled by Rotterdam and the top ten ports in Europe is detailed in Fig. 6.2, but given that it includes
6.2 Major European port cargo throughput (source: Rotterdam Municipal Port Management).
Chapter 6/page 12
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
Genoa, London and Marseilles, the share attributable to Rotterdam was only 35% of the total in 1998.
6.4.1
Rotterdam
Given its importance in a European context, Rotterdam is also the major coal import terminal for coal in the continent, handling some 22.5 Mt of coal in 1998, or some 40% of the total. The port has a total of 220 hectares (ha) available for the transshipment of dry bulk goods, including coal, as well as the ability to import via rail or road. The import process is organised by a number of stevedores that operate in different areas of the port. Rotterdam's deep water channels mean that it is particularly well-suited to handle the largest bulk carriers with the Maasvlakte waterway (the closest part of the port to the sea) able to take ships with a maximum permitted draught of 22.5 m. Rotterdam's total throughput of coal, both imports and exports, since 1975 is detailed in Fig. 6.3, from which it can be seen that throughput has grown steadily over the period. The rate of growth is equivalent to an average annual rate of some 4.9% and Rotterdam is planning for further capacity expansions in the future. In terms of rail transport, the expansion of the port railway should enable an increase in the total rail freight tonnage of
6.3 Rotterdam coal throughput (source: Rotterdam Municipal Port Management).
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 13
The coal industry
dry bulk goods, including coal, expanding from some 8.8 Mt in 1995 to 18 Mt in 2005 and 26 Mt by 2010. Indeed, the total tonnage of goods moved through Rotterdam grew from 287 Mt in 1990 to 297 Mt in 1995. This is expected to grow further to 318 Mt by 2000, 393 Mt by 2010 and 480 Mt by 2020, with large increases in all modes of transport. Within this overall figure the movement of dry bulk goods, including coal, should see an increase from 90 Mt in 1998 to 100 Mt by 2010 and 103 Mt by 2020. This represents a lower rate of growth than the overall figure as the port is expecting much of the increase in cargo to be in containers. Nevertheless, the closure of mines in Germany and the threat to the German nuclear programme may mean that this forecast is on the low side. The main source of coal for Rotterdam is from the main sea routes, although some coal arrives on other modes of transport. The incoming and outgoing methods of transport for the solid fuels classification of the port in 1996 (which may include other fuels) confirms this and indicates that the bulk of the outflow of coal is along inland waterways (see Table 6.3). Table 6.3 Incoming and outgoing methods of transport for solid fuels at Rotterdam port Method By sea from/to Europe Africa America Asia Oceania Total sea Inland waterway Railway Road Total
Incoming
Outgoing
Total
625 6 645 7 920 1 880 2 313
2 211 3 1 36 7
2 836 6 648 7 921 1 916 2 320
19 383
2 258
21 641
201 135 21
8 973 914 31
9 174 1 049 52
19 740
12 176
31 916
Source: Rotterdam Municipal Port Management.
Stevedores Within the port of Rotterdam there are five specific areas that can handle coal and other dry bulk goods, which are operated by different
Chapter 6/page 14
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
stevedores. The two major stevedores handling coal are Europees Massagoed-Overslagbedrijf (EMO) and European Bulk Services (EBS). A third stevedore is Ertsoverslagbedrijf Europort CV (EECV) which currently only handles iron ore for Thyssen Krupp, Mannesman and Hoesch. The company has plans to move into coking coal importing in view of the downscaling of coal-mining subsidies by the German government and an expectation of increasing German coking coal import requirements. The initial plan is that EECV will have capacity to import some 3 Mt/year, although this is expected to rise to 8 Mt/ year to 10 Mt/year in the final phase. Europees Massagoed-Overslagbedrijf The Coolsingel or `coal canal' is the location for EMO's operations. It has a discharge capacity of around 38 Mt/year of coal and iron ore, of which approximately 20 Mt/year is coal. The stevedore has 24 km of conveyor belt on its 168 hectare property, which operates 24 hours per day. EMO is 43% owned by a consortium including Thyssen Stahl, Ruhrkohle, SHV and Shell. The HES Group of Rotterdam owns 31% and Manufrance, a subsidiary of the French state coal purchasing company holds the remaining 26%. EMO is the best located of the three stevedores, with its terminal based at the most seaward end of the port, and is able to handle ships with the maximum draught of 22.5 m permitted by the harbour authorities. Moreover, other ports in the region, including Amsterdam (15 m) and Antwerp (16 m) are unable to unload large ships of over 340 000 t for iron ore and 180 000 t for coal. It should be noted that most coal loading ports are unable to load ships of greater than 180 000 t and so these are the maximum size of ship for EMO to unload. Richards Bay in South Africa, 23 days distant by sea, is the most important port for EMO supplying some 35% of the coal that the stevedore handles. Australia comes second with 32% followed by Colombia (10%), the United States (8%) and Indonesia (6%). The remaining 9% is supplied by a range of other countries, including Poland, China, Canada and Norway. The coal is then distributed to Dutch electricity generators (45%), Germany (28%), France (5%) and the United Kingdom (2%), with a host of smaller customers making up the balance. Some 17% of the total is transported to the local power station, 75% is distributed to coal consumers by barge, 6% is reexported by ocean-going vessels and 1% is loaded onto trucks.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 15
The coal industry
A 150 000 t ship can be loaded in a day but will take three days to unload, although EMO is able to unload three ships at any one time given the scale of its operations. The operation also maintains a large number of stockpiles for its various customers with coal loaded and unloaded with a stacker±reclaimer operation. With the time from Richards Bay to Rotterdam and then unloading the coal and reloading it onto a barge it is likely to be at least a month from the time the coal leaves the mine to the time it reaches its final destination. One of the reasons for EMO's success in the coal import market is its acquisition of Frans Swarttouw's Amazonehaven coal terminal in January 1991 and its ten year contract to supply coal to the joint coal bureau for the electricity companies (GKE). This contract included the blending of coal for the GKE as well as all transshipment requirements and now means that EMO handles all coal destined for Dutch power stations with the exception of Amsterdam and Borssele, which can be handled locally. In order to blend the coal to meet the GKE's requirements, EMO constructed a new blending plant and upgraded its other coal handling facilities at a cost of NLG250 m in 1992. The stevedore also has a 750 000 t/year washplant to reduce the ash content of the coal, also a by-product of the blending process. The company, finally, is able to sieve coal to required size ranges for specific customers. This is in 0±6 mm, 6±12 mm and 1, 2 and 3 nut sizes, which represent 12±25 mm, 25±50 mm and 50±100 mm ranges for domestic fires. European Bulk Services European Bulk Services (EBS), the other large coal stevedore, came into being at the end of 1993 as a result of the merger between Koninklijke Frans Swarttouw, Graan Elevator Maatschappij (GEM) and Interstevedoring. The group is a subsidiary of the HES Beheer holding company and suffered losses in the early 1990s, which inspired a major restructuring programme. In effect EBS has acted as an overflow port for EMO when the arrival of ships is concentrated in a short period of time. Much of EBS's work still concentrates on the movement of agribulk cargoes, although the company is handling an increasing amount of ores and other dry bulk cargoes such as coal. In order to improve its coal handling credentials, EBS has recently acquired new facilities for
Chapter 6/page 16
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
6.4 Coal throughput of north-west European ports (source: Rotterdam Municipal Port Management).
the manufacture of special coal briquettes in the Botlek area that were originally part of Interstevedoring.
6.4.2
Other European ports
As a matter of comparison, it is also possible to look at the relative amount of coal throughput from Le Havre to Hamburg, which is detailed in Fig. 6.4. Here, again, it is possible to see that Rotterdam is by far the largest port for coal in the whole of north-west Europe. Amsterdam Unlike Rotterdam, which can accommodate fully laden Capesize vessels, the port at Amsterdam is only able to handle ships with a maximum draught of about 16.5 m, equivalent to approximately 150 000 t, by means of a lightening service that reduces the draught of the ships to less than 14 m. The port is served by four different stevedores and processing companies that provide different services to coal suppliers and consumers. The Overslag Bedrijf Amsterdam (OBA) Bulk Terminal at the port has the facility to transship coal outside the locks so that Capesize
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 17
The coal industry
vessels can be partially unloaded and their draught reduced, but this will add to the overall cost of the process as it will involve some delay. Nevertheless, after lightening, up to three ships can be accommodated in an 800 m quay that has five discharge units to achieve a maximum discharge rate of 80 000 t/day. The terminal covers a total area of 65 ha and has stockpile capacity of 2.5 Mt. It has a range of different loading facilities which can load barges at a rate of up to 3000 t/hour, whilst a slewing stacker has increased the unloading capacity to some 4200 t/hour. OBA also operates two longitudinal stockpiles, which can be used for blending coal at 2400 t/hour and has two 1200 t/hour reclaimers, which feed directly to the local power plant. Rietlanden Stevedores has a stockpile capacity of 2 Mt on its 16.2 ha site and can simultaneously accommodate three ships with a draught of up to 45 feet on its 980 m quay. Unloading is carried out by two 36 t floating cranes and one 20 t crane, which have a capacity of up to 25 000 t/day, and throughput capacity onto barges is of the order of 3000 t/hour. The total throughput at the site was 3.5 Mt in 1997, with 2.0 Mt in the first six months of 1998. The operation also has a 1.5 Mt/year coal washplant and direct rail linkage, which can handle about 1 Mt/year. The Cargill Coal Parcel Service is a new operation, having only started in 1998 at the IGMA terminal in anticipation of an upturn in German import requirements. This terminal is equipped with seven floating cranes, and Cargill offers a comprehensive logistics service from despatch port to consumer. Finally, Amsterdam Coal Processing operates a small coal processing plant that includes a dense medium washplant (150 t/ hour) and facilities for dry screening (300 t/hour), wet screening (150 t/hour), crushing (from 250 mm down at 150 t/hour) and blending of coal. The infrastructure is situated on a 5.3 ha site and has a 180 m quay for soft-loading finished product. Sea-Invest Group The Sea-Invest Group has bulk handling operations in the ports of Antwerp, Ghent and Zeebrugge, all of which are capable of handling coal. The organisation also operates the Ghent Coal Terminal, which has a range of handling, storing, dry screening, crushing and blending facilities. The terminal also has a coal preparation plant, which has
Chapter 6/page 18
# Charles Kernot
From mine to market
conventional washing, cyclone washing, wet screening and crushing facilities. Ovet The Ovet group has operations at the ports of Flushing (Vlissingen) and Terneuzen, both of which benefit from the lowest port costs in the Amsterdam/Rotterdam/Antwerp (ARA) range. The company operates four floating cranes with 25 t capacity and 1000 t/ hour unloading rates and has crushing, blending and screening facilities at both of its terminals. In Terneuzen, the company can accommodate ships of up to 264 m length overall (LOA) by 34 m beam and 12.25 m draft, which is the constraining size of the lock on the Ghent±Terneuzen canal. The terminal at Terneuzen has a stockpile capacity of 600 000 t and an average discharge rate of up to 30 000 t/ day. In Flushing there is no lock and so the terminal can accommodate ships with a draught of up to 15.2 m and 310 m LOA. The company can also handle ships of larger size by means of an unloading facility, using the floating cranes, which it can operate for vessels of up to 16 m draft at a maximum capacity of 70 000 t/day. The stockpile capacity at Flushing is 900 000 t and the 1000 m of quay enables an average discharge rate of 40 000 t/day.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 6/page 19
7
Coal, electricity and the environment
7.1
Who uses coal?
7.2
How a power plant works 7.2.1 Independent power producers
7.3
Coal and the environment
7.4
Flue gas desulphurisation
7.5
Clean coal technology
7.6
Competition
7.7
Renewable competition 7.7.1 Wind 7.7.2 Biomass 7.7.3 Geothermal 7.7.4 Hydro
# Charles Kernot
7.1 Who uses coal? Almost every country in the world that can afford to uses coal as a primary source of energy. Given the decline in the domestic consumption of coal, this is mainly in the generation of electricity, which is then sent down power lines and more effectively distributed to the population. The major limiting factor in most of the world is the source of the coal and the resultant cost of its supply to the consumer. This has also to be compared with the relative cost of other sources of energy and their cost of transport from supplier to consumer. Nevertheless, coal use in electricity generation now dwarfs its consumption in any other application. Fig 7.1 shows the use of coal in the United Kingdom. This is an indication of its role elsewhere in the world, which has declined markedly since the end of the Second World War. The main reason for this is the increasing availability and economic advantages of other sources of power. More recently, the decline has been related to the `dash for gas' following the privatisation of and move to increase competition in the electricity generating industry. A gas-fired electricity generating plant was cheaper and easier to construct, was more efficient, and was less likely to be reliant on a militant workforce that could threaten supplies.
7.1 United Kingdom primary energy sources (million tonnes oil equivalent) (source: Department of Trade and Industry).
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 1
The coal industry
7.2 How a power plant works Electricity was an important discovery of the latter half of the nineteenth century. The first public generators were built in the 1880s and commercial generation started at Godalming, which, in 1888, became the first town to be illuminated by electricity. Coal-fired electricity generating plants work on a relatively simple basis. Essentially, coal is burned in air and the heat produced is used to boil water and produce steam. This conversion to steam occurs in an enclosed vessel and the greater volume that steam occupies in comparison with water leads to an increase in pressure. This high pressure steam is then piped into a steam turbine, forcing the blades of the turbine to spin, and turning the shaft into which the blades are set. The electricity generation unit is located at the other end of the turbine shaft. This comprises tightly wound wire coils attached to the shaft, set within a strong magnetic field. As the shaft and wire coils rotate, the changing magnetic field leads to the generation of electricity, which is tapped to an electricity substation and passed into the electricity grid. Finally, the steam is recondensed before reinjection into the boiler, thereby conserving some heat energy within the system. The efficiency of coal-fired power stations is a major issue in view of the global climate debate, and many improvements to the operation of electricity generating plants have been made in recent years. These improvements have seen coal-fired plants change from burning lump coal on grates that had to be continually raked in order to remove ash and ensure combustion, through travelling grates that could be fed with coal at one end and allowed for complete combustion of the coal at the other end where the ash would be removed, to the pulverised fuel systems that now account for 97% of all electricity generated using coal. In the pulverised fuel system, coal is pulverised so that 80% is less than 75mm in size, and it is then blown into the combustion chamber with air. In more modern systems, the coal±air mixture oscillates in order to enhance combustion, which takes place at temperatures of up to 1400 ëC. The fine grinding of the coal also increases its surface area and helps promote complete combustion, whilst blowing in air with the coal ensures a sufficient supply of oxygen to prevent the formation of carbon monoxide.
Chapter 7/page 2
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
Power plants that operate on the basis of converting heat into steam need to operate on a continuous basis in order to obtain the best efficiency ratings. This is because heat energy will dissipate if the plant is not required to generate electricity and the turbine needs to be disconnected from the generator. Over an extended shut-down, coal would cease to be burned and the temperature in the boiler would decline. In order to maintain the readiness of the plant to supply electricity on any upturn in demand, oil is normally burned to prevent the temperature declining too far. Nevertheless, more coal would have to be burned to return the water to boiling temperature and enable the build-up of steam to the pressure required for operation of the turbine. Unfortunately, increasing competition in the electricity generation and supply industry, and the new entrants with high capital costs and debt to service, means that plants that are more efficiently run on base load are normally operated as mid-merit stations on consequently much lower levels of efficiency.
7.2.1
Independent power producers
Since the late 1980s, the spread of IPP projects around the world has gathered pace. The reason behind this is the increasing demand for electricity in the developing countries and the ambition for growth inspired in electricity generating companies by the capitalist system. Most of these projects are organised under a build-own-operate (BOO) system where the IPP takes on the risk of construction and project returns rather than building a plant for a government. In such instances the IPPs are often built by a consortium including power generating equipment manufacturers and companies that already have significant generating experience. In setting up an IPP project a wide range of factors has to be considered. Not least of these is the type and source of the fuel consumed. In the case of IPPs, the fuel used tends to be coal. This is largely related to the location of IPPs in developing countries, which often means the absence of an integrated gas distribution network. As a result, new IPPs are more dependent on solid fuel supplies, which are also more secure and less likely to be disrupted ± especially if the IPP is situated close to an existing coal mine or by the coast with a dedicated port.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 3
The coal industry
An IPP will want to sign a long-term contract with its fuel supplier in order to ensure that it is able to meet any contractual requirements imposed by the authorities where the power station is constructed. If the fuel consumed is coal, the IPP will therefore want to ensure that the mining company has sufficient reserves of a sufficient quality to match the requirements of the generating plant. Moreover, it will be necessary to ensure that the coal is not contractually tied to another consumer, and will therefore be available for use by the IPP. The IPP will purchase and construct a boiler able to accept coal of a specified quality. This may be one with a specific level of moisture or heat generation capacity, sulphur or fluorine content or a mixture of these factors. It is therefore necessary for the IPP to be satisfied that the mine will be able to supply coal of a consistent quality over an expected boiler life of up to 30 years, and in order to ensure a profitable return on capital. Any treatment or cleaning of the coal may also have to be undertaken within specified parameters in order to ensure that the required coal specifications are met. In an IPP project the energy, in the shape of coal and then electricity, flows in one direction and the money in the shape of electricity consumers' payments to the distributor, generator or wholesaler flows in the other. These funds then have to cover coal transport costs and trader's profits before passing to the coal-mining company to be distributed to its employees, shareholders, banks and the state in the form of any royalties or taxes payable. At each link between one type of company and the next there is a chance that the system will break down, and it is therefore necessary for a coal-mining company to be certain about the other links of the chain. In some instances a generator will be constructed adjacent to the coal mine that supplies the fuel. Such mine-mouth power stations benefit from negligible fuel transport costs and so have a number of benefits. Admittedly, the additional capital cost of building transmission lines over longer distances, and the loss of energy on transmission may be a limiting factor if the deposit is situated in an out-of-theway location. As the generator will be tied to one supplier of coal, it will be dependent on the performance of the mining company and may require performance guarantees in order to ensure that it is able to maintain a constant supply of electricity to its customers. Coal
Chapter 7/page 4
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
supplies from distant locations, whether from sources within a country or from external sources, have an increasing level of risk as they are dependent on the availability and the cost of transport. Furthermore, there remains a need to contract long-term supplies in order to ensure a minimum degree of coal quality ± especially in an increasingly environmentally aware age. Production risk at the mine is also a concern for the IPP. The generator will not just want to satisfy itself that the mine has sufficient reserves but that it has the staff and capital to exploit them profitably. If the mining company has overborrowed, then it is possible that the mine will be unable to develop reserves and ensure long-term supply, or that it is unable to invest in new mining equipment in order to ensure that it can continue extraction at the required rate of output. Any possibility of expansion of generation capacity, in order to reduce unit capital costs and improve profitability, would also need to be investigated with the mining company as there may be insufficient scope within the mining plan to expand output to meet such an increase in demand. The choice of mining method may also be important, whether it is an open pit or an underground operation, as either could lead to a large amount of capital expenditure before the mine is brought to production and revenue starts to be generated. This is a risk both in that the company may be inadequately financed and also in that delays in the development of the mine may delay the start-up of the IPP project, which may lead to a mining company incurring penalties as it is not able to supply sufficient coal at the required time. The definition of reserves and resources has been discussed in Chapter 4, but a generator will require access to a mining company's reserve statement and will want to satisfy itself that the statement has been drawn up to international standards. Moreover, as each coal deposit is different and can be subject to different geological environments, a generator will also want to confirm that sufficient work has been undertaken on the deposit to ensure that all geological features have been fully understood. In coal, this can include washouts and other sedimentary features as well as the larger geological features such as faults and metamorphism. Risks of failure are also important in the mining operation ± whether of the mining equipment (as the failure of a main dragline can close a whole mine until it is repaired), or in the failure to take
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 5
The coal industry
account of changing geology, which means that bucket-wheel excavators are less able to change to a new mining technique than truck and shovel operations. This type of risk is often dissipated through the purchase of coal from a company with a range of mines ± as is the case in both India and the United Kingdom. The effect of a single mine failing, such as the brand new Asfordby Colliery in the United Kingdom, which was forced to close after only six months of operation, did not upset the generation of electricity in the country as coal supplies were able to be sourced from other collieries within the RJB Mining group. There will also be a requirement for a mine to stockpile coal to cover various events. One of these could be the move to a new face in an underground operation, which could take a longwall shearer out of action for two weeks, or an increase in local demand that could lead to a power station operating at 100% capacity, say during a period of extremely hot weather that increases demand for air-conditioning in a temperate country, rather than the 80±85% capacity that would more normally be the case. Moreover, if such an increase in demand was sustained, the mine may have to increase production markedly over a short period of time only to see it drop back again sharply soon afterwards. A high degree of flexibility and accurate mine planning would therefore be required of the mine operator.
7.3 Coal and the environment The environmental cost of using coal as a source of energy is gaining international recognition. This cost is significant because coal generates both carbon dioxide (CO2), a suspected greenhouse gas, and sulphur dioxide (SO2), which is the prime source of acid rain. Moreover, because almost all of the energy released through burning the carbon in coal comes from the generation of CO2, whereas it is only 44.2% from methane (as the hydrogen in methane also releases energy on combustion forming steam or water), coal is considered a more polluting fuel than methane. It is also the case that methane-burning CCGT plants are more energy efficient than coal-fired plants. This is because they convert around 50% of the contained energy into electricity, in comparison with only around 35% for a conventional coal-fired station. It must
Chapter 7/page 6
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
also be recognised that retrofitting FGD equipment reduces a coal plant's efficiency further, resulting in the generation of more CO2 ± even if less SO2 is released into the atmosphere.
7.4 Flue gas desulphurisation Most coal mined around the world contains sulphur, which can range from as little as 0.1% to levels above 7% or 8%. On combustion, the sulphur within the coal oxidises to form sulphur dioxide, and on emission into the air the SO2 combines with water and oxygen to form sulphuric acid. Whilst there was initially a state of denial within the electricity generating industry, scientific evidence eventually confirmed the link between power station SO2 emissions and the acidification of lakes and destruction of forests. Other studies have also pointed to combustion of other organic compounds and acid drainage of deforested areas as sources of some of the damage. However, this tends to indicate the need for more environmental precautions in other areas, rather than any alleviation of those imposed on the electricity generating industry. In the steam coal market low sulphur coals are now starting to command premium prices over high sulphur material. This is not easily determinable as far as the pricing of coal on the international market is concerned as most internationally traded coals are of low sulphur and low ash content, otherwise they would not be in demand. However, increasingly stringent emission control legislation introduced in the United States as a 1990 amendment to the Clean Air Act has led to higher demand and prices for low sulphur coals. The legislation set limits on the level of SO2 emissions allowed across the country and led to the creation of a market in emissions. The allowance offers them strict limits on the amount of SO2 that they can produce in any one year. Those generating utilities that purchase low sulphur coal, and thereby stay within their allowance, are able to sell their additional allowance to other generators that have contracts to purchase high sulphur coal and cannot afford to retrofit FGD equipment. This legislation ensures that the United States, as a whole, will not exceed a set sulphur emission level, although it will mean that some areas of the country will be significantly cleaner than others. In view of the increasing need for environmental compliance,
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 7
The coal industry
many of the world's governments are encouraging generators to fit FGD equipment. The reason for this is the increasing concern about acid rain and the destruction that this has caused to European and American forests. In the FGD process, the gases produced when coal is burned are collected and pumped through pulverised limestone. The limestone collects between 90% and 97% of the SO2 contained in the gas and changes its chemical composition from calcium carbonate to calcium sulphate or calcium sulphite depending on the amount of oxygen in the system. This product takes the form of a sludge, which, in some plants, is further oxidised to produce synthetic gypsum for the building industry. However, in most plants the sludge is disposed of as a damp filter cake that is often thixotropic and requires stabilisation before it can be deposited. Consequently, it is sometimes difficult to dump although it is easier to move using bulldozers when it has been extracted from the dump trucks.
7.5 Clean coal technology On its formation some 4.6 billion years ago, the earth's atmosphere contained a range of gases that would make the planet inhospitable if they were still present in the same concentrations today. One of the early gases was CO2, which was present in relatively high concentrations. However, following the development of life some 3 billion years ago, anaerobic bacteria and subsequently plants started to fix the carbon through photosynthesis, releasing oxygen back into the atmosphere. As this process continued, CO2 concentrations declined to around 280 ppm and oxygen concentrations increased to 21%, enabling the development of aerobic life. Over the past two hundred years, CO2 concentrations have increased by 28% to 358 ppm as the industrial age has led to increasing energy consumption around the world. In 1896 the Swedish scientist Arrhenius predicted that a doubling of the amount of CO2 in the air would increase the global surface temperature by between 5 ëC and 6 ëC. More recently, work has suggested that the temperature rise would be in the range of 1±3 ëC, still sufficient to lead to a marked deterioration of the polar ice caps and raise sea levels around the world. As a consequence of these
Chapter 7/page 8
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
scientific conclusions and the assumption that electricity demand, and hence generation, would continue to increase, there have been moves to reduce the amount of CO2 emitted for each unit of electricity produced. This strategy was given further impetus by the 1990 Kyoto summit on world climate change and the recognition that CO2 provides 55% of the enhanced greenhouse gas effect each year (see Table 7.1). Table 7.1 Annual contribution of greenhouse gases to global warming CO2 ± 55% CH4 ± 15% Nox ± 6% CFCs ± 24%. Source: World Coal Institute.
Average CO2 emissions in the OECD countries were 12 t/person in 1990. If the world is to ensure that increasing energy demand does not lead to excessive CO2 generation, and the potential global warming concerns that this arouses, then much of the projected increase in coal-fired electricity generation will have to be developed using clean coal technologies. These technologies are not, currently, commercially viable, but could become so with the introduction of energy, carbon or other fossil-fuel or non-renewable related taxation. Nevertheless, a potential market in excess of US$700 bn for clean coal plants has been projected over the decade to 2010. As with most energy projections, the lead time is likely to be greater than anticipated, but there is still considerable potential for increasing demand for the new technology. It must also be recognised that, although the average efficiency of a coal-fired electricity generating plant is of the order of 35±38% in the developed world, the average is only some 25% across the world, as a whole. These figures are also before taking account of energy consumption in mining and transport, which are also likely to be more significant in the case of coal in comparison with gas. Coal-fired electricity generating plants would emit about 45% less CO2 if all existing plants reached an efficiency of 47%, whilst increasing efficiency to the 55% projected under a current study would reduce emissions by a further 15%, also reducing emissions of SO2, nitrous oxides (NOx), and dust.
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 9
The coal industry
Two new clean coal systems have recently been developed using conventional pulverised coal (PF), which is already utilised in 97% of all existing coal-fired plants. The first plant is already in operation and has an energy efficiency of 45%, whilst the other, which is at an advanced planning stage, has a projected fuel efficiency of 55%. The first plant is a new unit at the North Jutland power station at Limfjorden near Aalborg in Denmark. The unit came on stream at the end of 1998 and generates 410 MW together with supplying heating to two local heating companies. The combined heat and power (CHP) offered by the plant is unusual in that it is generated by a coal station, whereas most of the developments to date have been associated with new gas-fired CCGT plant. An additional benefit to the plant's overall fuel efficiency is probably that the flue gas cleaning of NOx and dust, in addition to SO2, was specifically designed and constructed with the plant rather than being retrofitted, as is normally the case. At full capacity, the plant is expected to consume 1 Mt of bituminous coal and operate on a net fuel efficiency of 47%, a figure enhanced by between 1% and 1.5% through the use of sea water as a coolant. If the CHP project is included in the calculations then this increases total efficiency to around 90%. One of the keys to the increased efficiency is the development of a 9% chromium steel that was incorporated into supercritical plants by ELSAM, the Danish electricity utility, in the 1990s. The material is also used in VIAG's new 800±900 MW lignite-fired plants in Germany. ELSAM has already tested the material at its Esbjerg unit, achieving an energy efficiency of 45% over 7500 hours of operation. The other important factor required to enhance the efficiency of the operation is the use of motors and fans to pump air and steam through the plant. This process was also aided by a design that only allows a minimal pressure drop across the plant. The next advance is expected to be the development of higher temperature operations for steam generation. This will necessitate the introduction of new technologies and metals used in the construction of the boilers and other parts of the plant, together with the use of advanced steam turbines. The temperatures in the new plants are expected to be up to 700 ëC, compared with just under 600 ëC for what is currently considered best practice. It is this increase in temperature that is behind the anticipated increase in efficiency to above 55%.
Chapter 7/page 10
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
A project to demonstrate the viability of such a plant has been initiated under the auspices of the European Commission's Department of Energy THERMIE programme. The project is expected to last for up to 17 years and involve the construction of both a demonstration and a fully operational plant. The initial six years of the project should enable the design, construction and testing of a test plant expected to cost in the region of =C 21 m, of which the EC has granted 40%. The remainder of the funding comes from Switzerland and a range of European engineering companies. If the project then moves on to the second stage it is expected that it will cost some =C 500 m. The Shell group of companies has long been investigating the potential of new and significantly cleaner coal-fired power station technology. This was at least partly related to its interests in coalmining, which were acquired following the first oil shock in the early 1970s. Nevertheless, the company was aware of gasification technology that could be developed to improve considerably the efficiency of coal-fired electricity generation. One of the other advantages of coal gasification technology is that it can be used on all coals, including lignite and, as it is specifically designed with environmental considerations in mind, it is considerably more efficient than utilising retrofitted technology on existing plants. Coal gasification converts coal into a synthetic gas that can be further converted into electricity or other chemical products such as fertilisers. The Shell Coal Gasification Process (SCGP) relies on integrated plants that do not emit any of the usual solid or liquid residues from coal-fired electricity generating plants. Water is fully recycled in the plant, ash is converted into glass beads that can be blended into concrete, and sulphur is trapped in its elemental form for use in fertilisers. Moreover, the increased efficiency of the plant means that CO2 emissions are 15% lower than for the conventional coal-fired plant. Within the SCGP plant, coal is mixed with oxygen and steam to produce the synthetic gas, or syngas. The syngas mainly comprises carbon monoxide and hydrogen together with other minor constituents (see Table 7.2). The use of pure oxygen in the process increases the heating value of the gas considerably to about 50% of that of natural gas, in comparison with only about 20% for air-blown systems. The use of syngas considerably improves the efficiency of electricity generation in a gas turbine because the conversion of
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 11
The coal industry
Table 7.2 Composition of syngas produced by SCGP or other processes Compound
SGP (weight %)
Other processes (weight %)
Hydrogen (H2) Carbon monoxide (CO) Carbon dioxide (CO2) Methane (CH4) Hydrogen sulphide (H2S) Nitrogen (N2) Argon (Ar) Steam (H2O)
26.7 63.3 1.5 0.0 1.3 4.1 1.1 2.0
30.3 39.7 10.8 0.1 1.0 0.7 0.9 16.5
Source: Shell.
either solid or liquid fuels to a gaseous state improves contact with oxygen and therefore aids the combustion process. The further advantage of the process is that the heat from the gasification process and that from burning the syngas can both be used in electricity generation in a combined cycle process, or integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC). Shell's first pilot plant was built in Hamburg in 1979, processing 150 t/day, and this led in 1985 to the construction of the Deer Park demonstration plant in Houston, Texas, consuming 250 t/day. In 1993, a commercial operation combining gasification and combined cycle generation was built in Buggenum, Holland. This plant has a rated capacity of 253 MW and consumes 2000 t/day of coal at an overall efficiency of 43.2%. The Buggenum plant first grinds and dries the raw coal before it is transported on a nitrogen bed into storage vessels and then mixed with oxygen and steam in the gasifier. The combination of the coal, oxygen and steam takes place at between 1400 ëC and 1600 ëC, which melts any ash in the coal, transforming it into a vitreous slag. The temperature also prevents the formation of toxic by-products such as phenols and polyaromatic hydrocarbons. After formation, the syngas is partly cooled by quenching with recycled syngas before it enters a syngas cooler for further temperature reduction. This cooler produces the high pressure steam which powers the steam turbine side of the combined cycle plant. Any ash and un-gasified coal particles that are held in suspension in the gas are removed by cyclone or ceramic filter and returned to the gasifier module. Overall, this gas retains some 80±83% of the original energy content of the coal, whilst the steam from the gasifier and the
Chapter 7/page 12
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
gas cooling plant contains a further 14±16%. After cooling, the syngas is then burned in a gas turbine to produce electricity with additional heat being recovered for use in the steam turbine plant.
7.6 Competition The competitive market in energy supplies is shown in Fig. 7.2, which shows the relative costs of electricity generation in sterling per tonne of oil equivalent. These show that the price of coal used in electricity generation in the United Kingdom has remained relatively stable over the past eight years, and has, at times, been helped by fluctuations in the exchange rate. Nevertheless, the declining cost of heavy fuel oil has made coal much less competitive in the cogeneration market, although natural gas has remained more expensive on a tonnes of oil equivalent basis. In fact, the cheapest form of electricity generation in the United Kingdom has been imported coal, with CIS coal at US$49.16/t (equivalent to around £28/t) the cheapest. Whilst the security of CIS supplies may be brought into question, the low cost of Australian imports has provided a more secure alternative. A 1999 report by WEFA Ltd on `The Role of Coal in a Liberalised European Power Market' concluded that existing coal-fired electricity generating plant was cheaper than natural gas CCGT plant on both a variable cost and a full cost basis to 2020. The report also suggested that by 2010 the full cost of modern coal plant could be on a par with
7.2 Fuel input prices for electricity generation 1978±98 (source: OECD; Department of Trade and Industry).
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 13
The coal industry
gas CCGT, especially if coal plant utilisation rates could be increased to 65%. Nevertheless, coal still faces a number of problems and uncertainties that tend to deter potential users. Not least of these are: efficiency and CO2 emissions together with the potential for associated carbon taxes; longer lead times (double those of a new CCGT plant), which can affect potential market penetration; and potential liberalisation of the European gas market. This last factor could be important given the potential for lower gas prices, which could take more of the market away from coal. To secure a long-term future, the report suggests that the coal producers should move downstream ± as the gas suppliers have already done ± and forge closer links with the ultimate consumers of their energy supply. Figures used in the study were based on low coal prices but average gas prices of US$60/toe and US$149/toe. However, if a lower long-term gas price of US$112/toe is used, together with a lower capital cost then gas CCGT is less expensive than new coal, although it remains more costly than old coal. Another study has looked at the relative costs of energy in the United States. This also shows that an existing coal-fired plant is less expensive than any other source of electricity, the statistics are presented in Fig. 7.3.
7.3 Relative energy costs in the United States, 1997 (source: Ecoal, Volume 29, March 1999).
Chapter 7/page 14
# Charles Kernot
Coal, electricity and the environment
7.7 Renewable competition 7.7.1
Wind
In early 1999, installed wind turbine capacity was of the order of 9600 MW, a massive 2100MW of which was installed in 1998. To provide 20% of the total United States electricity demand would require 0.6% of the land area of 48 states. One of the main problems with wind energy is that the supply of wind is not always predictable and that calms may coincide with peak periods of demand. A Regenesys system being developed by National Power in the United Kingdom may help in this regard by being able to store energy during periods of windy weather for later release. The system should be cheaper and more flexible to operate than conventional lead-acid batteries, and by-pass the environmental constraints of other electricity storage systems such as pumped hydro-power. The system is based on a reversible chemical reaction between sodium bromide and sodium polysulphide in an electrochemical cell and is not necessarily restricted to a wind energy system. Indeed, National Power constructed a pilot plant operation at the Aberthaw power station in South Wales during the early 1990s and now plans to build a demonstration plant by 2001. The plant should be capable of storing 120 MWh of electricity with peak output of 14 MW and will be located at the Didcot power station in Oxfordshire. Clearly, as well as its benefits in other applications, the plant will be able to store electricity produced during overnight periods of low demand, supplying power when demand peaks in the morning and electricity prices rise.
7.7.2
Biomass
Biomass plants usually burn products in the same way that a coal-fired station burns coal, although it is also possible to gasify the feed for use in a turbine generator (see earlier). Nevertheless, the size of the feed is often a problem and restricts the size of these plants to around 5 MW, and up to a maximum of 15MW. In a new initiative, Scottish Power in the United Kingdom has announced plans to install CHP gas generators at five sewage works along the south coast of England. The works are located at Budds
# Charles Kernot
Chapter 7/page 15
The coal industry
Farm, which serves Portsmouth and Havant; Weatherlees Hill in Kent; Bexhill near Hastings; Portobello near Brighton; and Fors which serves Littlehampton and Bognor. They were acquired when Scottish Power purchased Southern Water in August 1996 and treat effluent produced by some 2.5 m people. The plants will utilise bacteria to break down the raw sewage and generate a gas containing methane (65%) and CO2 (3