Soils of the Past An introduction to paleopedology
Dedicated to Ken and Wendy Retallack,for letting me be
Soils of ...
155 downloads
6304 Views
32MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Soils of the Past An introduction to paleopedology
Dedicated to Ken and Wendy Retallack,for letting me be
Soils of the Past An introduction to paleopedology
Gregory J. Retallack University o j Oregon Eugene USA
SECOND EDITION
b
Blackwell Science
02001 GregoryJ. Retallack Published by BlackwellScience Ltd Editorial Offices: Osney Mead, Oxford OX2 0FL 25 JohnStreet.LondonWClN2BS 2 3 Ainslie Place, Edinburgh M3 6AJ 3 50 Main Street,Malden MA02148-5018,USA S4University Street, Carlton Victoria 3053, Australia 10,rue CasimirDelavigne 75006 Paris, France Other EditorialOffices: Blackwell Wissenschafts-VerlagGmbH Kurfurstendamm 57 10707Berlin, Germany Blackwell Science KK MG Kodenmacho Building 7-1 0 Kodenmacho Nihombashi Chuo-ku.Tokyo 104.Japan Iowa State UniversityPress A Blackwell ScienceCompany 2 12 1S.State Avenue Ames, Iowa 50014-8300,USA The right of the Author to be identifiedas the Authorof this Work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright,Designs and PatentsAct 1988. Al1rightsreserved.Nopartof this publication may be reproduced, storedinaretrievalsystem. or transmitted. in any formor by any means. electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise. except as permitted by the IJK Copyright,Designs andpatents Act 1988. without the prior permission of thecopyright owner.
First published 1990 by Unwin-Hyman Reprinted 1991by Harper CollinsAcademic Secondedition 2001 by Blackwell Science Ltd Setby Best-setTypesetter 1,td..Hong Kong Printed and Bound in Great Britain at the Alden Press Ltd, Oxford and Northampton
DISTRIBUTORS
Marston Book Services Ltd PO Box 269 Abingdon.Oxon OX144YN (0rders:Tel: 01235 465500 Fax: 0123 5 465 5 5 5) USA Blackwell Science. Inc. CommercePlace 350MainStreet Malden. MA02148-5018 (Orders:Tel: 800 759 6102 781 388 8250 Fax:7813888255)
Canada Login Brothers Book Company 324 Saulteaux Crescent Winnipeg, Manitoba R3J 3T2 (Orders: Tek2048372987) Australia Blackwell Science Pty Ltd 54University Street Carlton. Victoria 3053 (Orders:Tel: 3 93470300 Fax: 393475001) A cataloguerecord for this title is available from the British Library ISBN 0-632-053 76-3 Libraryof Congress Cataloging-in-publication Data Retallack. Greg J. (GregJohn), 1951Soils of the past. an introduction to pdleopedology/ Gregory J. Retallack. -2nded. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-632-053 76-3 1. Paleopedology. I. Title. QE473.R473 2000 5 5 2 's -dc2 1 00-04544s For further information on Blackwell Science,visit our wehsite: www.blackwell-science.com TheBlackwell Sciencelogois a trade mark of Blackwell ScienceLtd, registered at the United Kingdom Trade Marks Registry
Contents
Preface to the second edition, vii Preface to the first edition, ix Acknowledgments,xi
Part 1: Soils and paleosols
Zeolitiiation and celadonitiation of volcanic rocks, 9 7 Coalificationof peat, 97 Kerogenmaturation and cracking, 98 Neomorphism of carbonate, 99 Metamorphism, 100 Common patterns of alteration, 100
Paleopedology,3 Soilson and under the landscape, 7 Soils and paleosols on the landscape, 7 Quaternarypaleosols, 9 Paleosols at major unconformities, 1 0 Paleosols in sedimentary and volcanic sequences, 11
Featuresof fossilsoils, 13 Root traces, 13 Soil horizons, 19 Soil structure, 24 Soil-formingprocesses, 3 7 Indicators of physical weathering, 3 7 Indicators of chemical weathering, 41 Indicators of biological weathering, 50 Common soil-forming processes, 5 7 Soil classification,63 FA0 world map, 63 US soil taxonomy, 64 A word of caution, 76 6 Mapping and naming paleosols, 77 Paleoenvironmental studies, 77 Stratigraphic studies, 8 3 Deeply weathered rocks, 86 7 Alteration of paleosolsafter burial, 87 Burial decompositionof organic matter, 89 Burial gleization of organic matter, 9 0 Burial reddening of iron oxides and hydroxides, 90 Cementation of primary porosity,9 1 Compactionby overburden, 93 Illitization of smectite. 95
Part 2: Factors in soil formation
8 Modelsof soil formation, 105
9 Climate, 108 Classificationof climate, 109 Indicators of precipitation, 112 Indicators of temperature, 11 8 Indicators of seasonality, 120 Indicators of greenhouse atmospheres, 12 5 10 Organisms, 128 Tracesof organisms, 129 Tracesof ecosystems, 145 Fossil preservation in paleosols, 153 11 Topographicrelief as a factor, 160 Indicators of past geomorphologicalsetting, 160 Indicators of past water table, 164 Interpreting paleocatenae, 166 12 Parent materialas afactor, 171 General properties of parent materials, 172 Some common parent materials, 176 A base line for soil formation, 179 13 Time as a factor, 183 Indicators of paleosol development, 18 5 Accumulation of paleosol sequences, 194
V
vi
Contents
Part 3: Fossil record of soils 14 A long-termnaturalexperiment in pedogenesis, 207 15 Soilsof otherworlds,209 Soilsof theMoon, 209 Soils of Venus, 2 1 3 Soilsof Mars, 2 16 Meteorites, 220 Relevancetoearly Earth, 225 16 Earth’s earliestlandscapes, 22 7 Oxygenation of the Earth’s atmosphere, 2 3 1 Differentiation of continental crust, 2 39 Precambrian scenery, 242 17 Early lie on land, 246 Did life originate in soil?248 Evidence for early life in paleosols, 2 56 MotherEarthor heartof darkness?260 18 Large plants and animalsonland, 263 Evidence of multicellularorganismsin paleosols, 2 6 5
How did multicellular land organisms arise?2 72 Biological innovation or environmental regulation?275 19 Afforestationof theland, 280 Early forest soils. 2 82 A diversifying landscape, 2 85 A finer web of life on land, 29 1 Theshapeof evolution, 298 20 Grasses in dry continental interiors, 300 Early grassland soils, 303 How did grasslandsarise?3 12 Evolutionaryprocesses, 3 1 4 2 1 Human impact on landscapes,31 7 Humanorigins, 320 Early human ecology, 324 Atamedlandscape, 328
Glossary, 3 34 References, 3 52 Index, 3 9 5
Preface to the second edition
In the years since first publication of this book, paleopedology has grown from a long childhood into gawky adolescence.Paleopedology’sinfancy was well captured on the opening page of Vladimir Nabokov’s (1955) Lolita, in which it is offered as the epitome of an obscure scientiic interest of Humbert. Now, it is no longer a surprise to find a paleosol or a paleopedologist. Emphasis now is on interpretation of large suites of paleosols, for example, tracking past fluctuations in atmospheric carbon dioxide from the isotopic composition of carbonate nodules in paleosols. Such isotopic studies of paleosols demonstrate that they really were soils of the past. Their message about former environments and ecosystems goes beyond their surface appearance. The study of these remarkable rocks is now in a phase limited mainly by human ingenuity. Isotopy, cathodoluminescence, magnetic susceptibility, X-radiography and microtomography are opening new vistas into the formerly hidden world of paleosols. The first edition of this book was mainly ideas and questions. This edition is devoted more to procedures
and answers. The way of paleopedology is currently being mapped out on several fronts. Global change, coevolution, mass extinctions and comparative planetary geology are some of the currently important topics informed by paleosols. In pursuit of these broader objectives, procedures for recognition and study of paleosols are becoming routine. Much of the first edition outlining such procedures has now been consigned to tables. I have also written another book (Retallack 1997a) as a source book of terminology and procedures for professionals. Here, however, emphasis remains on what paleosols can tell us of the way the world works. The theory and issues of paleopedology continue to grow in the quirky, sometimes upsetting and sometimes inspiring, manner of adolescence. In another 10 years, perhaps the field will have settled into comfortable middle age. For the moment, however, as the Chinese proverb has it, we live in interesting times. GregoryJ. Retallack Eugene, Oregon, 2000
vii
Preface to the first edition
Landscapes viewed from afar have a timeless quality that is soothing to the human spirit. Yet a tranquil wilderness scene is but a snapshot in the stream of surficial change. Wind, water and human activities constantly reshape the landscape by means of catastrophic and usually irreversibleevents. Much of this change destroys past landscapes, but at some times and places, landscapes are buried in the rock record. This work is dedicated to the discovery of past landscapes and their life through the fossil record of soils. A long history of surficial changes extending back almost to the origin of our planet can be deciphered from the study of these buried soilsor paleosols. Somerudiments of this history, and our place in it, are outlined in a final section of this book. But first it is necessary to learn something of the language of soils, of what happens to them when buried in the rock record, and which of the forces of nature can be confidently reconstructed from their remains. Much of this preliminary material is borrowed from soil science, but throughout emphasis is laid on features that provide most reliable evidence of landscapes during the distant geologicalpast. This book has evolved primarily as a text for senior level university courses in paleopedology: the study of fossilsoi1s.Itisnottheusualviewof thissubjectfromthe perspectivesof soil science,Quaternaryresearchor land use planning. It is rather the view of an Earth historian and paleontologist. Compared with the elegant outlines
of a fossil skull or the intricate venation on a fossil leaf, fossil soils may at first appear unprepossessing subjects for scientific investigation. These massive, clayey and weathered zones are fossils in their own way. Their identification within a classification of modern soils presupposes particular past conditions, in the same way as the lifestyle that can be inferred from modern relatives of a fossil species of skull or leaf. Particular features of paleosols also may reflect factors in their formation in the same way as ancient diet can be inferred from the shape of fossil teeth, or former climate from the marginal outline of a fossil leaf. This book is an exploration of the idea that paleosols are trace fossils of ecosystems. Examplesin this book are drawn largely from my own work on fossil soils, some of it not yet published elsewhere. Theoretical concepts have been borrowed more widely from allied areas of science including geomorphology, coal petrography, plant ecology, astronomy and soil science,to name a few. The fossil record of soilsis a new focus for integrating existing knowledge about land surfaces and their biota. Paleopedology remains an infantdiscipline,hungry for theory anddata of the most elementary kinds. This book is one attempt to partially quell the growingpains. GregoryJ. Retallack Eugene, Oregon, 1989
ix
Acknowledgments
This book on paleosols would be slender indeed without extensive borrowing of facts, experiments, ideas and inspiration from allied areas of science. I have been fortunate to be able to draw upon the wise counsel of prominent sedimentologists(J.R.L. Allen, A. Basu, D.R. Lowe, R.M.H. Smith, E.F. McBride andL.J.Suttner),paleontologists (R. Beerbower,A.K. Knoll,J.W. Schopf andR Shipman), geochemists (G.G. Goles, J.M. Hayes, H.D. Holland, W.T. Holser and T.E. Cerling) and soil scientists (P.W. Birkeland, S.W. Buol, L.D. McFadden, P.F. McDowell, L.R. Follmer. D.L. Johnson and A.J. Busacca). Among the emerging cadre of paleopedologists concerned with rocks older than Quaternary it is a pleasure to acknowledge stimulating discussions with D.E. Fastovsky, M.J. Kraus, W.R. Sigleo, VTP. Wright and S.G. Driese. Last and certainly not least, many of my ideas
have been reshaped by students at the University of Oregon (E.A. Bestland, D.P. Dugas, C.R. Feakes, P.R. Miller, J.A. Pratt, S.C. Radosevich, G.S. Smith, G.D. Thackray, E.S. Krull, J.G. Wynn and N.D. Sheldon). They gave real meaningtotheSocraticdictumthat theunexaminedlife is not worth living. Photographs, specimens and other illustrative materials were generously and promptly provided by H.J. Anderson, J.B. Adams, T.M. Bown, J. Gray, R. Greeley, M.J. Kraus, S.C. Morris, NASA Space Science Center and C.J. Percival. Others graciously acquiesced in my adaptation of their published work. For several fine photographs, I thank Sean Poston. The writing would not have proceeded nearly so much to my satisfaction without the happy home life created by Diane, Nicholas and Jeremy
xi
Part 1
Soils and paleosols
~~
2200 million year oldpaleosol (lightcoloredzone) near Waterval Onder, SouthAfrica.
Soils of the Past: An introduction to paleopedology Edited by: Gregory J. Retallack Copyright 02001 Gregory J. Retallack
Chapter 1 Paleopedology
Paleopedologyisthe study of ancient soils,andis derived from an ancient Greek word ( m b v ,m h v )for ground. It has nothing to do with pedestrians (Latinpes,pedis) or . of the past, pediatricians (Greek R C ~ ~~S ,a t h s )Soils either buried within sedimentary sequences or persisting under changed surface conditions, are the main subject matter of paleopedology. In this book, it is seen as a historical perspective on soil genesis and as a way of reconstructing the geological history of land surfaces on Earth. Soils, like organisms, sediments and surface environments, have changed over the past 4566 myr of recordedEarth history. The concept of fossil soils can be traced back to the Scottish physician James Hutton (1795). His insistence on arguing past causes from those that can be observed today was a prerequisite to makiig a connection between soils of today and those of the distant geological past. Red rocks along angular unconformities exposed along the course of the River Jed and at Siccar Point, southeast of Edinburgh, he regarded as comparable to surface soils and sediments on the modern landscape (Fig. 1.1).’From this it will appear, that the schistus mountains or vertical strata of indurated bodies had been formed, and had been wasted and worn in natural operations of the globe, before horizontal strata were begun to be deposited in these places. . .’ (Hutton 1795, Vol. 1, p. 438). These ideas were reiterated in John Playfair’s (1802) Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth, which, because of its conciseness and clarity of expression, was more influential than Hutton’s original two volumes. Playfair also cited a 1799 record of a fossil forest in Lincolnshire, now covered by tidal flat sediments. This is the oldest record of a Quaternaryfossil soil. The oldest record of buried soils within consolidated sedimentary rocks was the ‘dirtbeds’ (Fig. 1.2)and fossil stumps reported in latest Jurassic limestones of the Dorset coast by Webster (1826) and popularized by Buckland (1837) in a volume widely known as the
Bridgewater Treatise. Other fossil forests were discovered in the late 19th century, and their stumps and associated fossil plants described, but little was made of their substrates as fossil soils. Examples include the Eocene Sequoia forests of Yellowstone National Park, USA, and Carboniferous stumps of tree-lycopsids at Clayton (Yorkshire)and in Victoria Park (Glasgow),both UK. A summary of these early discoveries of pre-Quaternary fossil soils was given in introductory chapters of Albert C. Seward’s monumental work Fossil Plants (1898). He appreciated the significanceof fossil soils as evidence for the immensity of geological t i e and as indicators of past worlds. Study of the paleosols themselves had to await the development of soil science. During the late 19th century, buried soils also were recognized w i t h i sur6cial deposits of loess and till. These ‘weathered zones’, ‘forest zones’ and ‘soils’, as they were variously termed, were found in Russia by Feofilatkov (in the 187Os, as recounted by Polynov 1927), in the midcontiiental USA by McGee (1878). andinNewZealandbyHardcastle(1889).Bytheturnof the century such observations had been used for stratigraphic subdivision of glacial deposits (Chamberlain 1895). Despite these discoveries,the origin of paleopedology as a discretefield of inquiry can be traced back to the late 19th century development of soil science (Tandarich 81 Sprecher 1994). Since classical times, soils have been studied from the point of view of plant nutrition. It was not until 1862 that the Saxon scientist Fredrich A. FalIOU 6rst published the term ‘pedologie’for the study of soil science, as opposed to what he termed ‘agrologie’,or practical agricultural science. The foundations of modern soil science were laid by Vasily Dokuchaev with a detailed account of the dark, grassland soils of Russia (1883).This monograph demonstrated that soils could be described, mapped and classified in a scientific fashion. Furthermore, their various features could be related to environmental constraints, of which climate and
3
4
Chapter1
Figure 1.1 Angular unconformity between Lower Silurian (430 Ma) Hawick Rocks and Upper Devonian (360 Ma) Upper Old Red Sandstone along the River Jed in southeastern Scotland (from Hutton 1795).
vegetation were consideredespeciallyimportant. By the early part of the 20th century there was an established scientifictradition of research on soil geography,classification and genesisin Russia, as summarized in the influential general works of K. D. Glinka (192 7). In the course of these early Russian investigations, certain soils were found to be anomalous in that their various features did not fit the general relationship between soil type and their climate and vegetation. It had long been suspected that these were very old soils, perhaps products of past environments. In 1927, Boris Polynov summarized Soviet observations of this kind. His short paper, which introduced the term paleopedology, can be considered the foundation of this branch of science. Polynov included the study of four kinds of
POI llund
materials within paleopedology. ‘Secondary soils’ encompass those formed by two successive weathering regimes, such as grassland soils degraded by the advance of forests after retreat of glacial ice. ‘Two-stage soils’were recognized to have an upper horizon of recent origin, but deeper horizons of more ancient vintage. ‘Fossil soils’ were defined as soil profiles developed on a surface and subsequently buried. Polynov’s final category of ‘ancient weathering products’ included the redeposited remnants of soils such as laterites and china clays. Polynov and his colleagues established a logical framework for the paleoenvironmental study of paleosols of all ages that continues in Russia. Modern soil science in North America can be traced back to Eugene W. Hilgard’s (1892) monograph
Afururtre furmoilon.
Sectioii of the Drrt-led in the Isle of Portland, thewing the rrbterraneata remuitcs of’un a n h i t Forest. D e la Berhr.
Figure 1.2 ‘Dirtbeds’ (paleosols)in a stratigraphic section through the uppermost Jurassic (Tithonian, 150Ma) Purbeck Formation on the Isle of Portland, Dorset, England(fromBuck1and 1837).
Paleopedology
on the relationship of soil and climate. This, and the first Large-scale mapping and classification of North American soils by Milton Whitney (1909),were largely independent of comparable research carried out by Russian soil scientists. Soviet influence first appeared in the work of Curtis Marbut. particularly his monumental soil survey of the USA (1935). Paleopedology also was introduced into North America through a Soviet connection. Constantin Nikiforoff completed doctoral studies at the University of St Petersburg in prerevolutionary Russia, but by 1943 was a scientist with the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) Soil Conservation Service,when he published a short essay outlining the role and scope of paleopedology. A supporting study of paleosols in the same journal of 1943 by Kirk Bryan and Claude Albritton made clear the practical application of such studies. Ideas on the classification and origin of soils have been especially useful for studies of Quaternary stratigraphy and geomorphology. Such studies are now conducted in most parts of the world. coordinated by a Commission on Paleopedology established in 1965 at the Seventh Congress of the International Association for Quaternary Research, in Denver, USA. An early result of the commission’s activities was the publication, in a volume of research papers edited by Dan H. Yaalon (1971). of recommendations for recognizing and classifying paleosols. Mapping units for Quaternary paleosols have been incorporated into official stratigraphic codes (e.g. North American Commission on Stratigraphic Nomenclature 1982). Modern research on Quaternarypaleosols can be found in books and journals on soil science, geography, archeology and Quaternaryresearch (Catt 1990:Holliday 1992,1994: Follmeretal. 1998). In contrast to a steady level of interest in Quaternary paleosols, studies of older paleosols have been slow to gain momentum. In many sequences now known to contain them in abundance, paleosols were not recognized or their features were explained as diagenetic phenomena. Little was made of those few cases where paleosols were explicitly recognized (Barrel1 191 3: Collins 192 5: Allen 194 7; Thorp & Reed 1949).Beginning in the 1960s, interest in pre-Quaternary paleosols has been increasing on several fronts, as they were discovered in many nonmarine sedimentary sequences (Retallack 1997a) and even in deep-sea cores (Ford
5
1987; Holmes 1992). The study of paleosols is especiallycompatiblewith the overall aims of sedimentology to reconstruct ancient environments and geological processes.Paleosols now regularly appear in accounts of sedimentary geology (Esteban & Klappa 1983; Wright 1986a) and of weathering processes (Martini & Chesworth 1992;Ollier&Pain 1996). Paleontological research has always been concerned with reconstructing past biotas, their ecology and the ways in which they are preserved in the rock record. Paleosols can be regarded as both trace fossils of past ecosystems and as preservational environments formanykindsof fossils(Reta1lack1975,1976,1977). Paleontologically oriented accounts of paleosols are appearing now in a variety of books and journals concerned with paleoecology, paleoclimatology, and other paleontological subjects (Retallack 1991a; Parrish 1998;Stanley 1998). A final area of geological sciences now contributing to paleopedology is geochemistry.The chemical study of weathering by Samuel S. Goldich (1938), from which was derived his well-known mineral stability series, dealt with Cretaceous paleosols in Minnesota. Paleosols also were used as indicators of atmospheric conditions and the nature of weathering processes in the very distant geological past (Sharp 1940; Sidorenko 1963). Such studies are now more common in journals and books concerned with geochemistry and Precambrian geology (Holland 1984;Schidlowskietal. 1992). Looking toward the future, fossil soils may be used as stratigraphic markers in the continuing inventory and mapping of the geological resources of this and other planets. Particular features of paleosols may aid in locating especially valued resources. For example, changes in degree of development and mineral content of paleosols reflect former time for formation and degree of waterlogging, and can be used to guide exploration for petroleum, coal and uranium ores. Coal and uranium accumulated in parts of the landscape where groundwater was poorly oxygenated. Uranium is more likely to be found in and near paleosols that are variegated and that formed on the margins of uplands of uraniferous granites (Kimberley1992).Coal is associated with paleosols that are gray and formed in swamps, rather than paleosols that are red and were formerlywell drained (Retallack & Krull 1999). Paleochannei sandstones, located by following lateral trends in paleosol
6
Chapter1
development and waterlogging, can be local petroleum reservoirs (Kraus&Bown 1993). Fossil soils also provide historical validation for theories about how soils form. The geological history of soils can be viewed as a long-term natural experiment in which many fundamental conditions of soil formation, such as vegetation and atmospheric composition, have changed. Information from fossil soils can strengthen ideas about how soils form and how they should be classified. Because such ideas form the basis for much agricultural and engineering activity and their modification
in the face of accelerating global change, it is all the more important that they have a 6rm scientific basis (Retallack1996a). Finally, fossilsoilsare evidencefor reconstructing past terrestrial ecosystems and environments. They can be used to bring particular times and places into sharper focus as evidence independent of associated fossils and sedimentary structures. They are a record of the evolution of ecosystems and of their interaction with environments on land, and provide a perspective on our placeonEarth.
Soils of the Past: An introduction to paleopedology Edited by: Gregory J. Retallack Copyright 02001 Gregory J. Retallack
Chapter 2 Soils on and under the landscape
Difficultiesin defining ‘fossilsoil’ arise not so much from its fossilnature as from confusion over what is meant by soil. A fossil soil or paleosol, l i e other kinds of fossils, is the remains of an ancient soil. It may have been buried by later deposits or it may be at the surface but no longer actively forming in quite the same way. The word soil on the other hand, like other commonly used words such as love and home, means different things to different people. For farming purposes, soil is fertile, loose, tillable ground. In engineering specifications,soil is anymateria1 that can be excavated without recourse to quarrying or blasting. By both these practical definitions, unaltered sediments, such as dune sands or flood silt, are regarded as soil.Yet some extremely altered soil materials, such as hard laterites, are not. To some soil scientists, soil is the medium in which vascular plants take root (Buol et al. 199 7). This narrow definition includes rock crevices supporting large plants. Yet it excludes rocks colonized by plant-like microbes and rootless plants such as mosses and liverworts. It also excludes hard-setting parts of soils and parts of soilsbelow the level of roots (Hole 19 8 1). Taking an even wider view, what are we to call lunar, Venusian and Martian land surfaces that have been altered in place by surficial processes?The Moon and Venus are lifeless. Mars probably is also. Should calling their altered land surfaces soils necessarily imply that life is present? Or should a n alternative label such as regolith imply that they are barren of life? Similar problems beset naming fossil soils older than Ordovician, before the advent of large land plants. If one takes the view that soils are a medium of plant growth, then both the terms Precambrian soil and Precambrian regolith beg the question of the antiquity and nature of life on land. Like the question of life on Mars, the origin of life on land is an important scientific issue in its own right and should not be confused by semantic considerations. For paleopedology a wider delinition of soil is needed. In this book I take soil to be material forming the surface
of a planet or similar body and altered in place from its parent material by physical, chemical or biological processes. This is close to Nikiforoff’s (1959) concept of soil as the ‘excited skin of the subaerial part of the Earth’s crust’, and its more functional description by Colin et al. (1992)as a ‘geomembrane filter’. Soil can be envisaged as a zone of interaction between the atmosphere and crust of a planetary body. A flux of energy from the Sun, water, snow or living creatures contiinually alters rocks or sediments into what we call soil. A part of the problem with defining soils is their intrinsically intermediate nature. Soils are complex zones of interaction between sediment or solid rock and the ecosystem or atmosphere. Because of the varying levels of interaction down from the land surface, it is usual to study soils in profiles that show the layering of alteration, or soil horizons. Solum is a technical word for that part of the soil profile most altered by soil processes (Fig. 2.1).In many cases it is riddled with roots of plants. The soil solum also may be dark, red, clayey or massive, and so is very different from its underlying parent material. Weathered material between the solum and underlying sediment or bedrock has a mix of soil and inherited features, and is called saprolite, or alterite (Nahon 1991). Saprolite may be soft, oxidized, clayey or otherwise altered l i e a soil, but not to the same extent as the soil solum. Some saprolites show clearly the bedding, schistosity and deformation of parent rock. The distinction between saprolite and solum is a matter of degree of alteration.
Soils and paleosols on the landscape Soils blanket most of the landscape except for areas covered by rivers or lakes or areas freshly uncovered by erosion and human excavation. Conditions of sunshine, moisture and other soil-forming factors vary in different parts of the landscape, and so do the soils forming there. The fundamental unit of soilis acolumn of soilmaterial,
7
8
Chapter2
Figure 2.1 Technical terms for soils and their relationshipto landscapes.
or pedon, of the kind that could be dug out of the wall of a trench. Soils vary in such complex ways that few pedons are exactly alike. Some pedons are sufficiently similar that they are recognized as a discrete kind of soil, different from others in the area. One or more of these similar pedons covering an area of ground is called a polypedon (Soil Survey Staff 1993). These are like tiles in a mosaic of soils over the landscape. The assemblage of polypedons mantling the landscape is called a soilscape. Soils form over many years until covered by sediment or removed by erosion. In river valleys, for example, deposits of sand and silt left behind by an especially powerful flood, or the rubble of a landslide,may cover soilsand drive off or destroy plants and animals (Fig. 2.2). Deep burial is a common way in which paleosols are formed. The covering deposits provide a surface for recoloniza-
relict soil
pedol i t h
ll
II
A
n
sedimentary relict
exhumed soil
1
buried soils
-
Figure 2.2 Technical terms for fossilsoils (paleosols)and their
relationto sediments(fromRetallack 198 3a; reprintedwith permission from the GeologicalSociety of America).
Soils on and under the landscape tion by plants and animals. and soil begins to form anew. Soon the bare surface is dry and cracked and small plants are taking root. With the advent of plants come worms and other burrowing invertebrates as well as herbivorous mammals. In humid regions, these early successional plants and animals are followed by shrubs and ultimately there is reconstituted the kind of woodland and soil that existed before. As a soil is burrowed, penetrated by roots and otherwise altered, the ripple marks and bedding planes of original alluvium are progressively destroyed. Such sedimentary relicts persist in many weakly developed bottomland soils and paleosols. Their persistence is a reflection of the degree to which the soil has been able to form and does not negate the identification of these materials as soils or paleosols. It is not difficult to recognize that paleosols developed during times of peace and quiet between deposition of thick sedimentary layers. Sequences of paleosols can become very difficult to decipher, however, if the intervening sedimentary layers are too thin to separate them effectively (Woida & Thompson 1993: Olson & Nettleton 1998). A common situation that may cause confusion is overprinting of the upper horizon of an older soil by development of a lower horizon of a younger soil with a slightly higher surface. The older near-surface horizon, then, is not genetically related to the younger subsurface horizon. From the point of view of the younger soil,it can be considered a pedorelict of the older soil. Other common pedorelictsare nodules or clasts of pre-existingsoilswithin sedimentson which later soilshave formed.Distinguishing these older nodules or clasts from nodules or clods of the younger soil may be difficultunless they have sharp, ferruginized or truncated boundaries. Some sedimentary layers are very distinctivebecause they are composed entirely of a particular kind of soil material. Such a bed, withclasts of soil minerals and appearing l i e a soil but with Sedimentary organization, may be called a soil sediment (Catt 1998) or pedolith (Gerasimov 1971). The term pedolith was originally coined by Erhart (1965) for redeposited laterites of Tertiary age. These remain a good example because such locally derived soil material forms brightly colored red beds distinct from enclosing alluvium. Pedolith is useful only for such clear cases, where soil-derived sediments are distinct, because most sediment ultimately is derived from soils and so is pedolithic in some sense.
9
Surface soils can also be considered relict paleosols if they are of a kind completely different from those forming under prevailing conditions. Good examples of relict soilsare lateritic and bauxitic paleosolsremaining at the surface in the deserts of Australia from early Tertiary deep weathering (OIIier & Pain 1996). The true soils of deserts are not lateritic, bauxitic, red, clayey and deeply weathered, but thin, sandy and little altered from the color of their parent materials: as can be seen from soils of eastern Oregon, southern California, Nevada, the Middle East and Central Asia (Birkeland 1999).The term relict paleosol should be used only for such clear anomalies, because environmental change can be rapid, and most soils can be considered relicts of different past conditions to some extent.
Quaternarypaleosols By current estimates (Van Cowering 1997), the Quaternary geologicalperiodisthepast 1.8myr.Thousands to millions of years are the time spans it takes to form soils, so those of Quaternary age are important evidence for the way in which soils form. The study of factors in soil formation usually involves a carefully constrained analysis of soils and paleosols of varying age or situation. In the earthquake-prone Transverse Ranges of California,river terraces are uplifted and tilted by folding that is still continuing (Fig. 2.3A). The youngest surfaces are those nearest the streams, where they are still disturbed by annual floods. Older terraces, dated by radiocarbon and other means, are at higher levels. This stepped landscape includes successively older surfaces at higher levels and these in turn bear progressively better-developed soils (Fig. 2.3B). Many such sequences of alluvial terraces and their soils have been studied to document changes in soil formation with t i e (Harden 1990). Another favorite landscape for such studies is areas around the terminus of retreating glaciers (Birkeland 1992). This kind of research provides basic information about the way in which soils form that is vital to the interpretation of paleosols. Studies of Quaternary soils and paleosols reveal clearly what complex things soils are and how many factors enter into their formation (Johnson & Watson-Stegner 1987; Phillips 1993). Not all these complications are relevant to interpretation of older paleosols. Among these are human impacts such as increased incidence of
10
Chapter2
Figure. 2.3 Tectonicallytilted Pleistocene (c. 160-200Ka) terraces disrupted at CulbertsonFault (Rockwellet al. 19 8 5 ) on left skyline and theTertiaryrocksof SantaPaula Ridge in centralTimberCanyon,north of Santa Paula, California,USA (A), and a thick, well-developedsoil (TypicPalexeralf in US taxonomy)on the centraltilted terrace (B): soil horizons are indicated by standard shorthandand tape is 2 mlong.
fires,forest clearance and paving. Some of the difficulty in understanding Quaternary paleosols also has been exacerbated by focusing study on those found in outcrops or shallow trenches rather than in deep boreholes. Paleosols of uplifted terraces or stable continental regions are likely to have been influenced by a greater variety of weathering regimes than those subsiding below the zone of weathering shortly after formation.
Paleosols at major unconforrnities Many unconformities show evidence of paleosols. Not alldo because some have been scoured clean by fluvialor marine erosion before being covered by later sediment. Examination of geological maps for unconformities remains a productive method for locating paleosols, especially in Precambrian rocks, where they are difficult to recognize otherwise. Paleosols at major geological unconformities include thick, well-differentiated layers of rockenriched in ferricoxide(laterite),in alumina (bauxite), in silica (silcrete)or in calcium carbonate (calcrete). The origin of these distinctive materials is a complex issue for at least two reasons. First, they take so long to form that conditions originally encouraging their formation are almost certain to have changed in some way before their burial and preservation (Vasconceloset al. 1992: Chadwick et al. 1995). Second, these are all indurated and weather-resistant materials that can withstandsubsequent erosionalevents (Thiry 1999;Valeton 1999).A brief consideration of some of the leading theories for the formation of one kind of duricrust servesto illustrate some of these complexities. Thick (lorn) laterites are thought not to form within the soil solum, but within deeper and thicker zones of
saprolite below (Oilier & Pain 1996). Especially appropriate sites for the accumulation of ferric oxides to such a concentration are places on the side of plateaux where groundwaters enriched in iron dissolved in swamps within depressions on the plateau are oxidized within a zone of seepage around the plateau margin (McFarlane 1976). Lateritic profiles may reach considerable thickness in such geomorphologicalpositions (Fig. 2.4).Such zones of concentrated ferric oxide are soft and easily excavated within the ground, but once exposed to air they become indurated like a brick.Their excavation and drying for construction stone on the Indian subcontinent is the source of their name from the Latin later (lateritis in genitive) for brick. Indurated laterites may armor hillsides against further erosion or may persist as pebbles of conglomeratic material similar to pisolitic or nodular original laterite (Tardy & Roquin 1992). Once formed, laterites are very persistent. From this brief account of laterites, they can be seen to involve more than just soil formation. Erosional landscape lowering, reorganization of pre-existing soil horizons, changing flow of groundwater and progressive modification of the landscape also occur (Valeton 1999). The overlapping effects of so many processes make interpretation of such old surfaces of weathering difficult and controversial. Interpretation of buried examples is confounded by additional difficulties. Along major erosional unconformities it is difficult to be sure that the entire pre-existing profile has been preserved. Modern duricrusts form the surface of many landscapes because the soil under which they formed has been eroded. Many paleosols at major unconformities are likely to represent saprolite or other deep layers rather than the surface solum (Schau &Henderson 1983). A
Soils on and under the landscape
11
Figure 2.4 Laterite (darklower zone) with pockets of chinaclay (white) andmottled zone (variegated middlezone) of a Miocene paleosol (Plinthic Paleudult of US taxonomy) overlain unconformably by sand capped with a modern soil (Hapludollof US taxonomy) at north end of Long Reef beach near Sydney, Australia (laterites discussedby Faniran 1971).
second difficulty with unconformities is the way in which they juxtapose materials of very different chemical and physical characteristics. Commonly clayey impermeable paleosols are overlain by gravelly or sandy, permeable fluvial deposits. Passage of groundwater through overlying sediments could substantially alter the underlying paleosol with effects becoming less marked downward from the unconformity in a manner difficult to distinguish from former soil formation (Pavich& Obermeier 1985). Examples of formerlywelldrained paleosols that are mineralized with sulfide or uranium minerals characteristic of reducing environments (Mossman & Farrow 1992) are indications of such modillcations.
Figure 2.5 Alluvial-volcaniclastic sediments including a long sequence of superimposed paleosols of Eocene and Oligoceneage in the Pinnacles area of Badlands National Park, South Dakota, USA (from Retallack 1983a; reprinted with permission from the Geological Societyof America).
Despite these problems, paleosols at major unconformities often present soil formation so extreme as to be unmistakable. The accumulated alteration of ages is not easily erased by later events of lesser duration. As evidence of the antiquity and geological history of deep weathering and of duricrusts, they are of interest in themselves.
Paleosols in sedimentary and volcanic sequences Paleosols are abundant in some sedimentary and volcanic successions (Fig. 2.5). In many cases paleosols have masqueraded under nongenetic terms such as red
12
Chapter2
beds, variegated beds, tonstein, ganister and cornstone. Unlike conglomerates and sandstones, which are readily identiable as hardened gravel and sand, these other rock types do not resemble modern kinds of sediment.Their similarityto modern soilswas unrecognized as long as they were compared with sediments and rocks rather than soils. Ganisters, for example, are rocks found in Euramerican Carboniferouscoal measures. The word was coined by Cornish miners for hard, silicified quartz sandstone that is so chemically and physically inert that it is used for lining furnaces. Ganisters commonly are penetrated by carbonaceous root traces and underlie coal seams. It is now recognized that these were upper horizons of moderatelywell-drained soils.Their quartz-rich composition was produced in part by destruction of easily weathered associated minerals and their silicification by diagenetic mobilization of accumulated plant opal (Retallack 197 7 ;Gibling&Rust1992). Another kind of rock that seemed puzzling from a Sedimentaryperspective has been called cornstone: red rock riddled with yellowish nodules of calcium or magnesium carbonate, irregular to rounded in shape and several centimeters in diameter. Marine rocks commonly contain calcareous, sideritic and other kinds of nodules presumed to have formed after burial of the sediment (Boggs 1995), and cornstone also was thoughttobeproducedbyburialdiagenesis.Someof the classical cornstone sequences of the Old Red Sandstone in Britain contain fossil freshwater fish but no marine fossils. From this it could be argued that they formed after burial, but in lake sediments. Careful evaluation of the associated sandstones revealed that cornstones were more commonly associated with rocks thought to have formed in ancient rivers and that they resemble calcareous nodules of modern soils of dry climates (Allen 1986a).Carbonate nodules formed by burial diagenesis are less complexlycracked, less micritic and do not show displacive fabrics. The differences between calcareous nodules of marine rocks and of paleosols are now sufficiently well established that nodular paleosols can be
recognized as evidence of low sea level within shallow marinelimestones (Wright 1 982). Several general problems with the study of paleosols in sedimentary successions are apparent from these two examples. Foremost among these is their alteration upon deep burial. Cornstone was most easily understood because it is indurated and similar in appearance to modern soil nodules. Few modern soils are colored as brightly as red beds nor are many soils hard and flinty like ganisters. The likelihood of some changes after burial should not be taken to mean that all features of these rocks formed during burial. Careful attention to relationships with unquestionably original structures,such as fossil root traces and burrows, allows discrimination between original features of apaleosol and those formed during burial. A second problem is caused by the confused boundaries of some paleosols in sedimentary successions as a result of overlapping of successive paleosols. Erosion and redistribution of soil material also can be confusing. These complications can obscure the expression of soil horizons or other features that would be more obvious indications of paleosols. A third problem has been the application of inappropriate conceptual models to the interpretation of these rocks. Many nonmarine sedimentary rocks include evidence of soil formation as well as sedimentation. Each needs to be considered in interpreting geologicalhistory. Despite these problems, paleosols in sedimentary rocks are promising because of evidence for paleoenvironments that they contain. Evidence from fossil soils can be used not only to validate interpretations based on other lines of inquiry, but also to frame new kinds of interpretations. For example, fossil soils can be used as evidence of former vegetation against which can be assessed the degree of adaptation of limbs and teeth of associatedfossil vertebrates (Retallack 1991a,b).Because of their unique problems and potential, the study of paleosols in ancient sedimentary successionsis developing a research tradition of its own, distinct from that of paleosols at major unconformities and from that of Quaternary paleosols and soils.
Soils of the Past: An introduction to paleopedology Edited by: Gregory J. Retallack Copyright 02001 Gregory J. Retallack
Chapter 3 Features of fossil soils
Compared with cross-bedded sandstone or coarsely crystalline granite, paleosols at first sight may seem massive and featureless. Despite nondescript first impressions, paleosols do have distinctivefeatures. For the most part these are characteristics also found in modern soils. Yet many paleosols are no longer loose, cracked and at the land surface. Important differences result from compaction and alteration upon burial, which change many of the diagnostic chemical properties of modern soils such as pH. Eh and base saturation. Thus, identification of paleosols can be a problem for both geologists and soil scientists alike (Wright 1992a; Birkeland 1999). There are three main kinds of features by which paleosols may be recognized in the field and from laboratory studies: root traces, soil horizons and soil structure. Using these and other observations it is generally possible to distinguish paleosols from unaltered sedimentary deposits, volcanic flows or zones altered by faulting. Paleosols can be altered by groundwater, by hydrothermal activity or by metamorphism, and in these cases often have a mix of features difficult to disentangle. Alteration of paleosols after burial is the subject of a later chapter. This one is concerned with criteria to determine whether a rock is part of a paleosol or something else entirely. Root traces Fossil roots or root traces are one of the best criteria for recognition of paleosols in sequences of sedimentary rocks. They are evidence that plants once lived there, and that, regardless of the rocks other features, it was once a soil. A gray shale with clear bedding planes may look like an ordinary sedimentary deposit but the existence of a few fossil root traces in growth position means that it was once a soil.The fossil record of roots is now well documented (Pfefferkorn & Fuchs 1991; Bockelie 1994: Retallack 1997a; Elick etal. 1998) and
will be reviewed after considering general aspects of fossilroots. The top of a paleosol can be recognized as the surface from which root traces emanate (Fig. 3.1). Concentrations of other trace fossils such as burrows also can be used because they record periods of reduced or no deposition during which sediment was extensively modified at the surface. There are situations when sedimentation keeps pace with burrowing and vegetative growth, but irregularities in depositional processes are such that perfect balance between depositional disturbance and vegetative colonization is seldom attained. Usually there are zones of more than usual density of root traces and burrows that can be interpreted as horizons close to the top of a paleosol. Under favorable circumstances the original organic matter of a fossil root may be well preserved. Even if only a trace of roots is preserved by an infill of clay or calcite, there are several distinctive features by which they can be recognized. Unlike other trace fossils such as burrows, most root traces taper and branch downward. They also are very irregular in width. Large, nearvertical root traces characteristically have a concertinalike outline because of compaction of surrounding sediments. Outwardflexuresof theconcertinaare located at large lateral roots extending out into the matrix. Despite these characteristics the distinction between root traces and burrows is not always easy. Root mats may spread laterally over hardpans or around nodules. Some kinds of roots, such as the pneumatophores of mangroves, branch upwards and out of the soil (Jenik 1976). Furthermore, a range of soil invertebrates, especially ants, termites and worms, form complex branching burrow systems (Ratcliffe & Fagerstrom 1980) that may have collapsed in places. The distinction between root traces and burrowsis further blurred by soil invertebrates such as cicadas, which burrow around and into roots to feed on them (Retallack 1976). Another potentially confusing case is the preference of roots for the soft fill of fresh 13
14
Chapter3
Figure 3.1 Calcareousrhizoconcretions emanatingfrom the top of a mangal paleosol (Aquept)in the Upper Eocene (35 Ma) Birket elQarunFormationnearMadwar elBighal, Faiyum depression, Egypt (photograph courtesyof ThomasL.Bown).
burrows rather than hard clayey soil matrix (Retallack 1991a). Other structures that could be confused forroot traces include gas escape structures (Neumann-Makhau 1976) and tubular masses of soil fused by lightning strikes (Daly et al. 1993; Gifford 1999). These latter, called fulgurites, are lumpy masses of glass with exotic high-temperature minerals very different from ordinary soil matrix. Gas escape structures, such as those forming the conduit to sand volcanoes in alluvium coveringmethane-generating organic matter, are not so copiously branched or pervasive as root traces. In most cases, wispy tubular structures forming a n irregular, dense network within nonmarine rocks are root traces. One limitation on the use of root traces for recognizing paleosols is that they have not been found in rocks older than Silurian, when the first vascular land plants appeared (Retallack 1992a). There are burrows of invertebrates in paleosolsas old as Ordovician (Retallack& Feakes 1987). For paleosols older than mid-Ordovician root traces and burrows are of no use for identifying ancient soils.
Kinds of roots Fossil root traces are most easily recognized when their original organic matter is preserved. Paleobotanical research has now unearthed fossil examples of most of the major kinds of root now found (Retallack 1997a).
Roots are downward growing plant axes. They have numerous fine branches or rootlets (Fig. 3.2). Both roots and rootlets are anatomically simple, unlike the anatomical diversity seen in aerial parts of plants. Usually a central cylinder (stele) of elongate woody cells (tracheids) is separated by a zone (cortex) of equidimensional fleshy cells (parenchyma) from a tough outer rim of thick-walled cells (epidermis). The central woody cylinder and tough outer rim withstand decay longer than the intervening zone of soft cells. Partly decayed root traces may show a central dark woody streak and a carbonaceous epidermis separated by a zone filled with mud, calcite or other minerals where the cortex has decayed(Reta1lack1976).Withfurtherdecayeventheepidermal and stelar organic matter are replaced by other materials, but a concentric pattern of replacement may remain. Root hairs are individual elongate epidermal cells found in zones near the tips of fine rootlets. Because of their increased surface area compared with that of older parts of root systems, they are especially significant in gathering water and nutrients from the soil. Silurian and Devonian land plants, l i e living mosses and liverworts, lacked true roots, but had functionally comparable rhizoids. Both root hairs and rhizoids are so small and delicate that they are preserved only by exceptional circumstances, such as cellular permineralization (Retallack1997a). Various kinds of roots are distinguished by their
Features of fossil soils
15
Figure 3.2 Fossil root and rootlets from the Miocene MolallaFormationon High Hill near ScottsMills, Oregon,USA. Their original organic matter has been weakly ferruginized (RetalIack specimen R261).
pattern of branching and anatomical structure (Raven 1999).Many plants have a single, thick vertical rootortaproot, asinDevonianEddyu(Beck 1967).Carrots and parsnips are familiar modern plants that have tap roots modified into large underground structures for the storage of carbohydrates. Another kind of root system is seen in living grasses (Gramineae) and quillworts (Isoetes).These have fibrousroots radiating from a thickened stem base known as a corm or rhizomorph, as in Triassic Pleuromeiu (Retallack 1 9 9 7 ~ )If. the roots arise from the stem of a plant rather than its base, they are called adventitious roots. These may arise from rhizomes, which are stems lying in or along the ground. They also may anchor stems scrambling above ground (runners or stolons) as in modern strawberries and CarboniferousCullistophyton (Rothwelll975). Adventitious roots also form prop or stilt roots connecting erect stems and branches to the ground, as in Cretaceous Weichselia (Alvin 1971). In tree ferns, such as Carboniferous Psuronius (Morgan 1959). a very weak stem and leaf bases are completely enclosed by a mass of fine adventitiousroots.Theymay lookliketreetrunks, but these masses of roots and leaf bases are best called false stems. A variety of specialized structures of roots also are known from the fossil record. For example, tubers are underground storage organs branching from roots and rhizomes, as in the common potato and Cretaceous Equisetites(Watson&Batten 1990).Some plants of waterloggedsoilshaverootletsextending verticallyinto theair and these can be fossilized by deposition in swamp and intertidal habitats (Whybrow & McClure 1981).These
peg roots (pneumatophores) may play a role in allowing access to air for root respiration. For similar reasons, some plants of waterlogged habitats have thin-walled openings to theinside of the root (aerophores)or spongy parenchymatous tissue (aerenchyma). The most obvious of these aerating adaptations are large hollow cavities (lumina) found in roots of some swampland plants, such asPermian Vertebruriu (Retallack&Dilcher 1988). Rooting structures such as these not only indicate the existence of paleosols. but are also evidence of particular soil conditions. From the known fossil record of roots, most kinds of rooting structures have been in existence since Carboniferous time (Pfefferkorn & Fuchs 1991). Extinct woody plants whose aerial parts were very different from those alive today showed surprisingly modern kinds of roots. Presumably this is because functional constraints on root evolution have been more important than phylogenetic constraints. Useful paleoecological interpretationscan be made from fossil roots bycomparison with modern studies of root ecology and arrangement. Patterns of root traces While digging for fossil root traces it is useful to consider their arrangement, because this may provide evidence for former drainage, vegetation types and originally indurated parts of a paleosol. Because roots need oxygen to respire they seldom penetrate permanently waterlogged parts of soils. Laterally spreading (or tabular)
16
Chapter 3
Figure 3.3 Tabularrootsystemof alarge, extinct arborescentIycopod (Stigmaria ficoides) of Early Carboniferousage (Namurian.320 Ma) in the Lower Limestone Coal Group, Victoria Park, Glasgow,Scotland. The scale is 1 m for foregroundonIy.
root systems are characteristic of plants growing in swampy ground Uenik 1976) and are common among fossil stumps in sedimentary rocks of lowland environments (Fig. 3 . 3 ) . On the other hand, welldrained paIeosols may be deeply penetrated by root traces. Under wooded grassland, deeply penetrating and stout roots of trees and shrubs are scattered among a diffuse network of fine (<2 mm diameter) grass roots (van Donselaar-ten Bokkel Huinink 1966). In vegetation of drier climates the pattern of roots becomes shallower and more irregular as vegetation becomes more sparse andclumped. Under tallgrass prairie anetworkof
3 loll grass prairie
fine roots may extend as deep as 2 m below the surface (Fig. 3.4). Under short grass prairie grass roots are clumped under individual tussocks and interspersed with tubers and other rooting structures of desert perennials. Documentation of rooting patterns in rnodern soils is a laborious process that involves digging, erecting a supportive net for the excavated roots, and then carefullywashing them out (Weaver 19 19,1920). Such research provides data against which fossil root systems can be compared. Patterns of root traces also are clues for distinguishing original features of paleosols formed after burial.
Figure 3.4 Scale drawings of excavatedroot systems oE (A)short grass prairie near Colorado Springs,Colorado,U S A (B) lowland tall grass prairie near Lincoln, Nebraska, USA; and (C) mountain forest near Pikes Peak. Colorado,USA(afterWeaver 1919, 1920; withpermissionfrom thecarnegie [nstitutionof Washington).
Features of fossil soils Root traces run around hard parts of soils such as pebbles, nodules andcemented horizons (Haasis 1921). Abundant subhorizontal root traces deep within a profile are the best line of evidence for recognizing originally lithified horizons (fragipans and duripans) in paleosols now entirely lithified. Similarly, the avoidance of nodules by roots and burrows closely approaching them is evidence that the nodules were an original part of the soil. Not all root traces avoid nodules because in their early stages of formation nodules may be unindurated chemical segregations (Gile et al. 1966, 1980). With time they become indurated and better defined. As clear primary features of paleosols, root traces are guides to other original features of former soils. Rhizoconcretions Rhizoconcretionsform in soilsbecause of the local environment created by roots. Water is taken in by roots because of the tendency for soil water to dilute their cell sap across semipermeablecell membranes (by osmosis) and because the whole plant maintains a negative pressure (water potential) within thin, water-conducting tubes (xylem)by loss of water from the leaves (transpiration). Nutrients are taken in with water and their uptake is enhanced by a variety of substances exuded by roots and their surrounding mucigel zone (rhizosphere) rich in bacteria and fungi. Many nutrient cations (Ca*+,Mg*+, K+, Na+) are reIeased by dispIacement with hydrogen ions (H+)in mildly acidicsolutionsmaintainedbyorganic acids and by carbonic acid arising from dissolved carbon dioxide of microbial and root respiration. Other nutrients such as iron are dissolved in a reduced state (Fe”) by organic reductants such as caffeic acid or are fixed in particularly favorable molecular sites (chelated) by large organic molecules such as EDTA (ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid). This is not to say that the rhizosphere is always or uniformly acidic or reducing as was once thought. Most of the time it is near neutral in pH and Eh, allowing for normal aerobic respiration and nutrient uptake by both roots and associated microbes (Richards 1987). Conditions can change over short periods of time. Heavy rainfall may cause temporary waterlogged,reducing and acidic conditions. Long periods of nutrient starvation may induce dramatic increases in the production of exuded reductants or chelates over periods of afew hours (Olsenetal. 1981).Thenet ef-
17
fect of root action is thus to deplete the adjacent soil of nutrients. Zones of depletion are not especially prominent in soils because of the continued elongation of roots. The most actively adsorbing part is the zone of root hairsjustbehindthegrowingpointoftheroot.This root apexmayelongateatratesof morethan 6 cmday-l; about 2 cmday-’ istypical (Russell 1977).Becausethey are so transitory, detecting the effects of fossil rhizospheres is not simple. Nevertheless,the effectsof roots can be striking. Soils rich in calcium carbonate are widespread in desert regions, where rainfall is insufficient to leach it from the soil, and also in humid coastal dunes and beaches, where sand includes numerous grains of broken seashells. With repeated cycles of wetting and drying in such friable, sandy soils, root margins alternately become wet and acidic (dissolvingcarbonate) and then dry and alkaline (precipitating carbonate). Underthese conditions roots become heavily encrusted with concentric layers of very fine-grained, low-magnesian, calcite (Fig. 3 . 5 ) . These calcareous rhizoconcretions may become so thick and unyielding that the root dies and the hole remaining is filled with other materials (Esteban & Klappa 1983 ) . Rhizoconcretions also form by biologically mediated calcification of cells within roots (Alonso-Zarza et al. 1998a). Combinations of intracellular and extracellular calcification create what can be termed rhiolite: rock formed by the activity of plant roots (Wright et al. 1995).Iron mobiliied in the drab ferrous state from minerals within a wet rhizosphere may be oxidized to yellow or red ferric oxides near the roots to form ferruginous rhizoconcretions. Calcium carbonate and iron oxyhydrates are the most common materials encrusting roots in soils, but many other substances also form rhizoconcretions and soil nodules (Brewer 1976).
Drab-haloedroot traces A common feature of root traces in paleosols is a bluish gray or greenish gray halo extending out into the paleosol matrix (Fig. 3.6). Such drab root traces can be formed in several ways. Two of these are uncommon in paleosols and can readily be recognized using textural relationships. First, drab root traces and burrows can form in red beds or horizons when drab material from a higher horizon is washed down into a lower horizon
Chapter3
18
Figure 3.5 Calcareous rhizoconcretions exhumed from Holocenecoastal sand dunes north of WandaBeach. New South Wales, Australia (Retallack specimens P2606A, -C, -D). Scaleinmillimeters.
(Fig. 3.7). Such structures are called krotovinas, tonguing or glossic features. The boundary between drab and red material of a krotovina is a sharp discontinuity between materials of different texture, unlike the diffuse contactinmost drab haloes (Retallack1997a). Second,drab haloes form around root traces in clayey, periodically waterlogged soils. Anaerobic bacterial activity in stagnant water around roots, burrows and cracks in the soil can cause chemical reduction of those surfaces, leaving the interiors of the soil clods oxidized. Such surficial reduction from brown to gray color may
l~llllJ1 I
also result in mineralization with birnessite, pyrite or sphaerosiderite (Retallack 1997d, 1999b). These features of surface-water gley are found in very clayey lowland soils with impermeable subsurface horizons. Such variegated soils have drab-haloed root traces accompanied by drab burrows and soil cracks. Surface-water gleying does not explain soils in which only the root traces have drab haloes. A third possible origin for drab-haloed root traces is as a result of reduction and mobilization of iron within the rhizosphere. The highly reducing conditions implied by
Figure 3.6 Fossilroot traces (2 mmdiameter central streak of pale yellow, 5Y 7/4), drab halo (light gray, 5Y 7/2) and ferruginized matrix(darkred, 2.5YR316)fromthe subsurface (Bt) horizon of a paleosol of late Eocene (38 Ma) age in the basal John Day Formation, near Clarno, Oregon, USA (specimen R4 17;Getahun & Retallack 1991; Retallacketd. 2000).Scaleinmillimeters.
Features of fossil soils C
D
19
E
SOIL
Figure 3.7 Processesandproductsinthe formation of drab-haloedroot traces and superficially similarfeatures:(A) krotovinas: (B) remnants of the rhuosphere;(C) surfacewater gley;(D)reduction of soil by anaerobic decay of buried roots: (E) dehydrationof ferric hydroxidemottles.
SOIL KROTOVINA gruy sand
the halo would be too poor in oxygen for normal respiration of the deeply penetrating roots commonly haloed in this way. Furthermore, water and nutrient uptake is most active near the tips of rootlets, where there are zones of root hairs, whereas drab haloes are found around fossil roots too large to have borne root hairs. A fourth explanation for drab-haloed root traces is that they are reduced areas of anaerobic bacterial decay of organic matter buried within paleosols. This burial gley origin of drab-haloed mottles is likely for paleosols in which the whole surface horizon is drab, from dispersed organic matter there (Fig. 3.8A), and in which there are comparable amounts of total iron in both drab and red areas (Kraus & Aslan 1993; Retallack et al. 2 000). Fifth and finally, the contrast between drab-haloed root mottIes and surface horizons and the reddish remainder of many paleosols may have been enhanced by dehydration of yellow and brown ferric oxyhydrates to brick-red hematite during deep burial. However, it is unliiely that original oxidation occurred at depth, especially within impermeable clayey paleosols. This well-established diagenetic change (Retallack 1991b) may have enhanced the color contrast of drab-haloed root mottles, but is unlikely to have been their cause. If drab-haloed root mottles can be regarded as reflect-
1
ORIGINAL SURFACE-WATER' RHIZOSPHERE GLEY brawn clay
red clay
BURIAL GLEY gray clay
BURIAL REDDENING
::&,,
ing the former rhizosphere or anaerobic decay of buried organic matter, then the drab-haloed root traces represent the last crop of plants in the paleosol. Former roots and their rhizospheres decay rapidly once they die in well-drained soils. Drab-haloed root systems are especially useful in distinguishing between forest, woodland and wooded grassland of the past from paleosols (Retallack 1983a, 1991a; Retallack et al. 2000).
Soil horizons Soil horizons of paleosols vary considerably depending on the conditions under which the soil formed and was subsequently buried. There are, however, some general features of horizons useful for recognizing them even in highly altered paleosols. Horizons of paleosols are distinct from many kinds of geological layering in that the top of the uppermost horizon of a paleosol is usually truncated sharply whereas boundaries between lower horizons and underlying parent material commonly are gradational (Fig. 3.8). Exceptions to the general rule of diffuse contacts below the sharp top of paleosols are common enough to deserve special consideration. Some lowland soils receive thin increments of sediment through which vegetation continues to grow. Their tops are overthickened
20
Chapter3
Figure 3.8 Sharpupper contact and gradational lower contact of soil horizons in two paleosols: (A)Long Reef clay paleosol (probablya Hapludult)of Triassic age (Scytho-Anisian,245 Ma) in the Bald Hill Claystoneat Long Reef, New SouthWales, Australia (scalebar graduatedininches,paleosols discussedby Retallack 199 7d);(B) modern grassland soil (upperleft only) and two comparableChogo clay paleosols (probablyHaplustolls)of Miocene age (14 Ma) in the Fort Ternan Member, mainexcavationof FortTernanNational Monument, Kenya (hammerfor scale,paleosols discussedby Retallack 1991a).
by sedimentation rather than sharply defined by erosional truncation, and could be interpreted as cumulic paleosols. But there are usually one or more layers with roots and burrows denser than elsewhere. The bioturbated zone closest to the top of a paleosol is best taken as its surface and others above that as the tops of additional, very weakly developed, younger soils (Retallack 1997d). Other exceptions to the generally diffuse boundaries of paleosol horizons are sharp contacts occasionally found within profiles. For the most part these are relict beds from sedimentary parent materials not yet obliterated by soil formation. Associated sedimentary features such as ripple marks or load casts allow confident identification of relict bedding (Retallack&Krull1999).There also may be erosional surfaces within profiles where a pre-existing paleosol has been substantially eroded and soil developmenthas proceeded on an additional layer of sediment (Retallack1997d). Such cases may bedifficult to detect in the field if the erosional contact has been obscured by subsequent soil formation. Thin lag depositsof weather-resistant pebbles such as quartzmay be cluesto complexities of this type of soil and paleosol. Stone lines are common in very ancient soilsof stable geologicalsettings (Johnson et al. 1987). Without such field indica-
tions the true complexity of a paleosol may not become apparent until petrographic or chemical studies reveal discontinuities.
Kinds of horizons Although paleosol horizons are rather varied, a mental image of common kinds of soil horizons can be useful in recognizing them in the field. Some kinds of paleosol horizons are so striking that they have attracted specific geological names. Cornstones (Fig. 3.8B), for example, arenodularcalcareous horizons (orBkin the shorthand of soil science) and ganisters are silicified, near-surface, sandy horizons (or E horizons of soil science). Successions of paleosols with gray-green, organic surface (A) horizons and red to purple, clayey subsurface (Bt) horizons (Fig.3.8A) may form strikinglyscenic sequences as gaudy as a barber pole or candy cane (Retallack 1997a). Some Precambrian paleosols have surface (A) horizons of a distinctive lie-green color (Mossman & Farrow 1992). Somekinds of paleosol horizons may prove to be extinct, but for most the horizon nomenclature of soil science is appropriate. The variety of horizons found in modern soils are labeled with a shorthand system of letters and numbers
Features of fossil soils A horizons
profiles above C
5
Figure 3.9 Typicaldepthsfor differentkinds
of soil horizonsas revealedby their frequency distributionin North American soils (compiledfrom Marbut 193 5).These are scales appropriatefor observation of paleosol horizons.
i 2
I5
I$
I >
3
(such as A and Bt). Laboratory studies may force one to change a horizon designation, but it is best to provisionally identify paleosol horizons in the field. Field assessment of horizons may determine how a paleosol is sampled,and also its interpretation and identificationin a modern classification of soils. The field codes for horizons are descriptive rather than genetic in orientation, and the current scheme is simpler than that found in older publications (Table 3.1). Horizons are defined on the basis of the materials composing them. For buried soils, it also is useful to have an idea of typical thicknesses of different kinds of horizons in modern soils. Most surface horizons of soils (A and E) are <50cm thick and subsurface (Bt and Bk) horizons are <2m (Fig. 3.9). Unaltered sediments, duricrusts and saprolites. on the other hand, may be much thicker and reflect the operation of processes other than soil horizon differentiation (Thiry 1999; Valeton 1999). Describing soil horizons
To characterize a paleosol in a way that is amenable to interpretation, horizon thicknesses, grain size, color, reaction with acid and thenature of horizon boundaries must all be recorded in the field. Some observations will prove more important than others in understanding a paleosol, but it is difficult to anticipate which features these will be. Thus, it is useful to have a comprehensive standardized form of horizon description (Retallack 1988a). Especially useful is graphical
10
20
30
, 40
p l o b d and with no A horizon below plow line
E horizons
.
, 5
p
,, 1,5
,
Bt horizons 10
21 Bk
1 5
n=32
field logging in a large, square-ruled notebook as is the custom in making geological sections of sedimentary sequences. Like the interpretative shorthand used to describe soil horizons (Table 3.1). these various symbols and style of representation may at first appear intimidating. With familiarity, such schemes become a rapid way of summarizing and comparing profilecharacteristics. For this reason all graphical profiles in this book show uniform symbols. Information on grain size is needed for classification and interpretation of many soils and paleosols. A profile showing mean grain size, separate from the column with lithological symbols is a useful feature of graphical profiles of paleosols. Grain size can be estimated in the field using a grain-size comparison card or sediment samples. It can later be reassessed by laboratory studies of samples of the horizons, which should be clearly labeled with an indication of their former orientation in the paleosol. The simplest way of marking orientation is to draw or scratch a large (2 cm diameter) circle on the upper surface of the sample or sample container in such a way that it is parallel to the ancient land surface. Such samples can be made into thin sections oriented vertical relative to original bedding (Murphy 1986; Tate & Retallack 1995),and then point-countedunder apetrographic microscope to determine more precisely the amounts of sand, silt and clay (Fig. 3.10) or of diagnostic features such as clay skins (Murphy & Kemp 1987). Common components can be determined to an accuracy of about 2%when 500 points are counted (Murphy 19 8 3; Friedman&Johnson 1996).Alternative methods
22
Chapter3
Table 3.1 Descriptive shorthand of soil and paleosol horizons. Category
New term Description -
Master horizons
0
A E
B K C R Gradations between master horizons
AB
Subordinate
a b
BA EIB
C
e f g h i k m n 0
P q r S
t V
W X
Y Z
Surfaceaccumulation of organic matter (peat, lignite, coal) overlying clayey or sandy part of soil Accumulation of humified organic matter mixed with mineral fraction. Occurs at the surface or below an 0 horizon Underliesan 0 or A horizon and is characterized by lessorganic matter, less sesquioxides(Fe,O, and Al,O,), or less clay than the underlying horizon. This horizon is usually light colored as a result of abundant quartz Underliesa n 0,A or E horizon and shows discernibleenrichment in clay, carbonate, sesquioxides(Fe,O, and Al,O,) or organic matter Subsurface horizon so impregnated with carbonate that it forms a massive layer Subsurface horizon more weathered than bedrock but lacking degree of weathering of A, E. B and K horizons Consolidated and unweathered bedrock
OZd term 0
A A2
B K C R
Horizon with some characteristics of A and of B, but with A characteristics dominant As above, but with B characteristics dominant A horizon predominantly liieB horizon but with tongues of E horizon
A3
Highly decomposed organic matter Buried soil horizon (usually redundant for sequences of paleosols) Concretionsor nodules Organic matter intermediate in decomposition(between a and i) Frozen soil,with ice wedges or other evidence Evidence of strong gleying,such as pyrite Illuvial accumulation of organic matter Slightlydecomposed organic matter Accumulation of carbonates less than for K Evidence of cementation, such as root deflection Accumulation of sodium, halite, columnar peds Residualaccumulation of sesquioxides Plowing or other comparable human disturbance Accumulation of silica Weathered or soft bedrock Illuvial accumulation of sesquioxides Accumulation of clay Pliithite Colored or structural B Fragipan character (cemented with clay and silica and avoided by roots) Accumulation of gypsumorcrystaIcasts Accumulation of other salts or crystal casts
-
Source: AdaptedforpaleosolsfromSoilSurveyStaff (1975,1998).
B1 A&B
b cn -
f g h -
ca m sa P si ox
ir t -
X
cs sa
Featuresof fossil soils
23
100%clay (less than Zum)
Figure 3.10 Soil texturalclassesof Soil
Survey Staff (199 8). Filled circleswith numbersshow clay percentages for critical boundaries:open circles with numbers show diagnosticsand percentages (komRetaUack 199 7, A Colour Guide to Paleosols:with permissionOJohnWiley&SonsLtd).
of passing unconsolidated soil through sieves or through a column of water and then weighing each segregated size fraction are techniques used in soil science (Klute 1994).They are of limited usefulness in evaluating grain size of lithi6ed paleosols because there is no easy way of disaggregating them to their original grain-size distribution. One should be aware also that the silt-clay size criterion ( 2 pm) of soil science is different from that widely usedin sedimentarygeology (Kraus 1997). Color can be estimated in the field using a standard color chart such as the one produced by Munsell Color (1975).This is arranged to reveal changes in the primary colors such as red and yellow (hues),in the degree of lightness of the color (values)and the degree of grayness of the color (chroma).It is best to consider only the hue initially, to find the correct page of the charts. Then the color can be determined within a grid of value and chroma. Well-indurated and metamorphosed paleosols may hold their color well, but Iittle-aItered clayey paleosols of the kind widespread in scenic clayey badlands of Mesozoic and Cenozoic rocks in the western USA change color upon exposure to air and on lab0 ratory storage. Commonly they become paler (higher Munsell value)after a few hours of drying.After several months of laboratory storage, greenish gray parts of paleosol samples may become more yellow (warmer in
Munsell hue) because of oxidation of iron-bearing minerals. Thus, it is best to record color on fresh rock within a few minutes of exposure. The calcium carbonate content of paleosols can be determined in the laboratory, but should also be estimated in the field by applying drops of dilute (10% of standard 1 M solution) hydrochloric acid from an eye-dropper bottle.The degree of reaction with acid can be divided into five readily observablestages (Table 3 . 2 ) proportional to the amount of calcium carbonate present. This property is used for classifying soils, as well as for distinguishingcalcium carbonate from dolomite or chert. Another feature of horizons that should be recorded in the field is the nature of their contacts with adjacent horizons. Two aspects of the contact are of interest: whether one horizon passes into another within a narrow or broad vertical distance and whether the contact is laterally planar or somehow disrupted (Table 3.3). Abrupt or broken boundariesmay lead to suspicionthat the profile contains erosional discontinuities. Diffuse planar contacts, on the other hand, may represent genetically related horizons of a single soil. The transition zones between diffuse horizon contacts may seem so thick as to warrant a separate horizon name. When assessing a profile withespeciallydiffuse horizon boundaries it is best to take an overview of the profile to decide
24
Chapter3
Table 3.2 Field scale of acid reaction to approximate carbonate content. Class
Carbonate (wt %)
Soundof reaction (holdclose)
Reaction with diluteacid
Noncalcareous Weakly calcareous
<0.5 0.5-1
Calcareous
1-5
Strongly calcareous
5-10
Very strongly calcareous
>10
None Faintly increasing to slightly audible Faintly increasing to moderatelyaudible Easily audible, heard away from ear Easily audible
Acid unreactive, may form inert bead Little movement within the acid drop, which could be flotation of dust particles as much as bubbles Numerous bubbles,but not coalescingto form a froth Bubblesforming a white froth, with bubbles up to 3 mm diameter, but drop not doming upward Drop vigorouslyfrothing and doming upward with some bubbles up to 7 mm diameter
Source: Retallack(l997a).
which parts of the profile are most distinct, and thus constitute the main horizons, and which are merely intergrades between them. Horizons also may be characterized by laboratory analyses of hand specimens. Chemical analyses for major and trace elemental composition may be useful. For lithfied paleosols it is best to use whole-rock chemical analyses by standard geological methods such as atomic adsorption, X-ray fluorescence,inductively coupled plasma fusion spectroscopy or neutron activation analysis. Full chemical analyses were once fashionable in the study of modern soils (Marbut 193 5) and this important data base of analyses is occasionally supplemented with additional published analyses (Soil Survey Staff 1975). Determination of materials extractable by Table 3.3 Soil horizon boundaries. Category
Term
Description
Sharpness
Abrupt Clear Gradual Diffuse
<2 cmwide 2-5cm 5-1 5 cm >15 cm
Smooth Wavy
Nearly aplane Undulating, pockets wider thandeep Undulating, pockets deeper than wide Partsof the horizondisconnected
Lateral continuity
Irregular Broken
Source: SoilSurveyStaff (1993).
solvents, such as iron by sodium dithionate, is a much more common approach of soil science (Sparks 1996). This readily soluble fraction of the soil is most susceptible to diagenetic change upon burial of a soil, and this limits the use of these analyses of paleosols. A useful adjunct to chemical analyses is to determine the density of samples by the standard method of weighing sampIes coated in paraffin, to prevent water infiltration, both in and out of water (Klute 1994). Using density measurements, chemical analyses in weight per cent can be converted to values in grams per cubic centimeter, to gain an inventory of absolute chemical differences between horizons (Chadwick et al. 1990; Brimhall et al. 1991). Staining for feldspars (Houghton 19SO), scanning electron microscopic observation (Mumpton & Ormsby 1976; Smart & Tovey 1981;Sudo et al. 1981;Krinsley & Manley 1989),X-raydiffractometerstudiesof clayminerals (Klute 1994) and X-radiographs to reveal partly concealed structures (Bouma 1969) are just a few of a growing number of laboratory techniques for understanding particular aspects of paleosol horizons.
Soil structure Soils may appear to be fragmented, featureless or massive compared with, for example, cross-bedded dune sands or strongly cleaved slates. But l i e these geological structures, soils have characteristic structures of their own. These structuresare developed to different degrees and progressively overwhelm pre-existing structures of parent material such as sedimentary bedding, metamorphic foliation or igneous crystal outlines.
Features of fossil soils With experience,both the characteristic features of soil structure and their contrast with other structures of enclosing rocks allow paleosols to be readily recognized. Structures of paleosols often can be discerned in geological descriptions by such terms as ‘massive’, ‘structureless’, ‘jointy’, ‘slickensided’, ‘veined’, ‘mottled’ or ‘nodular’. Such language does not serve adequately to characterize soil or paleosol structures. On the other hand, technical jargon for these features used by soil scientists can be intimidating. In this account, the technical terms used are based on the system outlined by Brewer (19 76). Common words are here suggested as equivalent terms. In some cases these ordinary terms may prove inadequate, but they serve to introduce the subject.
25
andpaleosols arecalled cutans. They could also be called clod skins because it is the cutans and the voids with which they are often associated that define the fundamental units of soil structure, the individual clods or peds. Peds may be of various sizes ranging from large prisms occupying most of the thickness of the soil to small granules the size of sand grains. Large peds may be made up of smaller peds. Burrows and root traces are two examples of an additional general class of tubular features found in soils: pedotubules. Such a general term may be needed for objective description of these features when their origin is not obvious. Another general class of soil structures are glaebules, or naturally hardened soil lumps. These are masses of material that have a distinctive mineralogical and chemical composition. Calcareous nodules of aridland soils are a good example. Crystals of minerals such as gypsum are not regarded as glaebules, and also are found within soils. Pedotubules, glaebules and crystals have adistinctive and often also simple mineralogical composition unlike the clayey material making up most of the soil. On a microscopic scale this fine-grained soil matrix (plasma) consists of clay and amorphous iron and aluminum oxides, which support small grains of rocks and minerals (skeleton grains) inherited from the parent material of the soil. The process of weathering tends to create plasma from skeleton grains. Minerals such as plagioclase and hornblende are especially prone to alteration.
Structural elements Perhaps the most striking feature of soils is their intricate system of open cracks and hollows (Fig. 3.11). These open spacesmay form an interconnected network (packing voids),small irregularly shaped pockets (vugs) or near-spherical holes (vesicles).In paleosols such open spaces are often crushed out of existenceby compaction under overlying rocks. Fortunately, some indications of former cracks remain because of modification of soil material where water and air could circulate within the soil.These surfaces can be modified in various ways, e.g. by encrustation with washed-down clay or staining with iron oxide. Such irregularly planar features in soils
void
concretion
intersecting bright clay fabric (S-matrix, bimoseplc plosmic
lay skin (orgillan and lluviation cutan)
Figure 3.1 1 Structural units of soilsin hand specimens and petrographic thin section.
Chapter3
26
Quartz, on the other hand, is resistant and is a common skeleton grain in highly weathered soilsand paleosols. Much can be done to characterize soil structure in the field, but a complete description requires microscopic examination. Petrographic thin sections are useful for documenting differences between horizons of soils and paleosols as well as their microfabric. For this purpose, some of us (Nahon 1991; Retallack 1997a) prefer the original terminology of Brewer (1976), as a middle ground between the simpler system of Bullock et al. (1984) and the much more complex terminology of Brewer & Sleeman (1988). Emphasis on voids in the latter system is unworkable for paleosols, and simplicity of the former system does not address some soil features critical for paleosol studies.Yet another terminology for microscopic alteration of grains and crystals (Delvigne 1998) can be used to supplement these comprehensive systems.
Peds Peds are aggregates of soil: the clods of earth between cracks, roots, burrows and other soil openings. Soil peds commonly can be crushed by hand and are not as indurated as rock. They are persistent clods that tumble
I
TYPE
I
I
I
ANGULAR @LOCKY
SUBANGULAR BLOCKY
tabular and elongate with flat elongate with horizontal to land top and vertical domed top and to land surface vertical to surface surface
mquant with ShOrF nterlocking edger
quant with dull iterlocking edges
E.B~.K.C BI initial disruption of swelling and relict bedding. shrinking on accretion of wetting and cementing material drying
Bt racking around oats and burrow* welliny and hrinking on vetting and trying
81 s for angular ilacky, but with nore erosion and leposition of ioterial in cracks
PLATY
PRISMATIC
COLUMNAR
I
DESCRIPTION I
I
IUSUAL HORIZON^ L MA~N CAUSES
loosewhen one digs into the soil. Peds may initially seem so irregular and formed by such a random concatenation of processes as to be unworthy of careful scientific scrutiny.Even a little experience with soilsis sufficientto dispel such doubts. Consider, for example, the very different domed columnar peds of soils around salt pans of desert regions compared with the fine granular peds found under suburban lawns. Each reflects particular kinds of soilsand environments. Compaction and other alteration after burial of paleosols makes peds in them difficult to recognize. The pattern of cracking that determines which chips of rock come loose under the hammer from modern outcrops of lithified paleosols in most cases has more to do with jointing or other features of burial or modern weathering than with the distribution of voids in the former soil. Thus, care must be taken in paleosols to identify peds by their surrounding cutans. Soil peds are classified by their size, angularity and shape (Fig. 3.12). Platy peds, for example, are thin but extensive laterally. They are often formed by the initial disruption of relict bedding in weakly developed soils or where clay or other materials form laminar layers on top of a fine-grained impermeable lower layer of a soil. Prismatic and columnar peds are taller than wide and
I
1
very thin
1 very thick-I0
I
I
I
I
GRANULAR
CRUMB
I
I
Rn as for prismatic, but with greater erasiw by percolating water, and greater
A ictive bioturbation ind coating of soil vith films of clay, esquioxides ond rgonic matter
A as for granular, includinq fecal pellets and relict soil clasts
ery fine < 0 5 c n
ery fineG05crn
ery fine-dmm
very fine
me 0 5 to I cm
ine 0 5 to I cm
ine I to 2 mm
fine I to 2 mm
nedium I to 2 cm
nedium I to 2 cm
iedium 2 to 5 mm medium 2 to 5 mm
oarse 2 to 5 cm
oorse 2 to 5 cm
mmlvery c o a r s e ~ l O c m ~ v ~ r ~ ~ o ~ r s ery e ~ coorsesScn lOcn
ery coarse > 5 cn
veryfine
veryfine
Figure 3.12 Aclassitlcationof soilpeds (sirnpliedfrornSoilSurvey Staff 1975).
Features of fossil soils may extend through a considerable portion of a soil. They form in clayey soilsby swelling and shrinking associated with wetting and drying. Someespeciallyexpandable clays such as sodium smectites form bulging tops to the peds (McCahon & Miller 1997). These bulges distinguish columnar from prismatic peds. Blocky peds (Fig. 3.1 3) are irregular in shape and usually not quite equidimensional. They may have angular interlocking faces. Where there has been erosion or coating of ped margins they appear less sharp and subangular. A distinctive kind of blocky ped is formed in soils with highly smectiticclays,in which diagonalstresses are associated with theswellingof clayasittakesinmoistureaftereach rain. These lentil or wedge peds are separated by slickensides (Krishna & Perumal 1948; Gustavson 1991). Granular and crumb peds are differentiated on the sharpnessof theirinterlocking edges,as are angular and
-
27
subangular blocky peds. Both granular and crumb peds are smaller and more equidimensional than blocky peds. Theyarefoundinupperportionsof soils,whereas blocky peds are more often encountered in subsurface (Bt)horizons.The gradationin structurefromblocky to granular and crumb peds may reflect the relative role of soil organisms in churning the soil and producing organic compounds, such as polysaccharides, that bind ped surfaces. Granular ped structures are common in the surface horizons of grassland soils. So are crumb peds, which may in part be fecal pellets of earthworms and other creatures (Pawluk & Ball9 85). A distinctivekind of crumb ped called spherical microped comprises sandsized spheres of deeply weathered, ferruginized clay abundant in some tropicalsoils (Mermut et al. 1984). Spherical micropeds, and blocky and prismatic peds are superficially similar to clay clast breccias or con-
28
Chapter3
glomerate beds, to tectonically formed fitted breccias or tessellated pavements,and to mineraliedvein networks or boxworks. These other geological structures commonly are associated with high-temperature minerals, marine fossils or other indications that they did not form in a soil.The diagnostic features of peds in paleosols are complexly altered bounding surfaces, peds within peds, traces of former surfaces annealed within peds, and cracks between peds that widen in a way that indicates the peds were loose enough to rotate slightly (Fig. 13.13).
Cutans Cutans are modified surfaces of peds, clasts or crystals. They vary greatly in composition, which is the main basis for their classification. In the terminology proposed by Brewer (1976), various kinds of cutans are given latinate names indicating their composition, followed by the suffix '-an' to indicate that they are cutans. Argillans, for example, are clay skins. Ferrans are ironstained surfaces, and so on (Table 3.4). Similar cutanic features can form also during diagenesisand metamorphism of paleosols. Such later features are usually thicker, more coarsely crystalline and related to other distinctivemetamorphic textures such as kink folding or schistosity In contrast, cutans of the original soil before metamorphism are irregular, thin and fine grained. The chemical composition of cutans thought to be original can be important guides to former chemical conditions in paleosols (Fig. 3.14). Noncalcareous, nonclayey, ferruginous cutans (ferrans), for example, indicate acidic
Table 3.4 Terminologyfor cutans. Term
Composition
Argillan Ferran Mangan Organan Sesquan Silan Skeletan Soluan
Clay Sesquioxidesof iron Oxidesorhydroxidesof iron andmanganese Organic matter Sesquioxidesof iron and aluminum Silica Clastic grains such as quartz or feldspar Solublesaltssuch as gypsumor calcite
Source: Brewer (1976).
and highly oxidizing conditions as would be found in well-drained,sandy soilsof humid climates.This kind of information can be useful for interpreting and classifying paleosols. Subcutanic features show a fixed relation to a ped surface within the soil, but are not restricted to that surface. Two kinds are recognized. Neocutans (deep clod skins) are extraordinarily thick cutans that often lose intensity of development over a zone of centimeters away from the surface. Quasicutans (halo clod skins) also are thick and show a relation to a surface but are not right at that surface. They form a diffuse zone of alteration beneath the surface, which faithfully follows its outline. Neocutans form in similar ways to other kinds of cutans and have the same range of composition. They may reflect intense development of a cutan. Some quasicutans may form as neocutans partially destroyed by later modification of the surface; for example, a deeply ferruginized surface of aped, formed under oxidizing conditions, may then become reduced and gray in color nearest the surface because of surfacewater gleying. The origin of cutanic features may be complex, but generally falls into three categories: those formed by washing down of material into cracks (illuviation cutans), those formed by progressive alteration inward from a surface (diffusion cutans) and those formed by differential shear forces within the soil (stress cutans). These three genetic categories of cutans may be combined in confusing ways, but often are distinct. Illuviation cutans, for example, show sharp contacts with adjacent soil peds and also may be laminated from successive additions of material washed in. These are the kinds of cutans that are most clearly diagnostic of paleosols. Somewhat similar are clay cements filling secondary porosity created by dissolution during deep burial. Clay cements seldom show the grain-size variation between layers, lateral continuity of layering or correlative banding between broken pieces seen in illuviation cutans. Diffusion cutans, on the other hand, do not consist of material different from that of the peds but rather of modified ped material. They have only one sharp boundary on the outermost surface. the inner surface being a gradational change into unaltered soil material. Acommon exampleis a thick ferruginizedsurface of peds. These neoferrans are most intense and opaque at the surface, but less deeply stained toward the center
Features of fossil soils
HEMAT ITE LlMON ITE MNOXIDES SILICA
CHAMOSITE' CoIcil* Phe.phWmI*
29
:
;
--. --_I:---
--_--_ --_-.-.
~
I
PEAT PYRITE
Figure 3.14 Stablemineral associations under different conditionsof aeration (Eh) and acidity (pH)in sediments and soils (from Krumbein&Garrels1952,JourndofGeology 60,Fig.8;reprintedwithpermissionfrom University of ChicagoPress).
- 0.3
I
of theped. Stresscutansareless welldefined. Acommon indication of stress cutans is the striated and smeared surfaces called slickensides. These form in clayey soils where peds are repeatedly heaved past one another by swell-shrink during wetting and drying episodes.Slickensides also form in paleosols purely by the crushing of peds one against another during compaction after burial. Thus, by themselves slickensides are not compelling evidence of shrink and swell behavior of paleosol clays. Unlike the slickensides associated with faults, those formed in soils or during compaction of paleosols are randomly arranged along diffusezones rather than uni-
directional and concentrated in narrow bands (Gray & Nickelsen 1989). On either side of the highly birefringent, striated clay of the slickensided surface, the transition outward to unoriented clay is gradational with decreasinglyabundant wisps of highly birefringent clay (Brewer 1976).
Glaebules Glaebules are naturally segregated lumps of soil material formed from the same wide variety of materials as cutans (Brewer 1976; Nahon 1991: Delvigne 1998).
30
Chapter3
Common examples are the calcareous nodules of desert soils. Glaebules range from highly irregular to almost spherical in shape and also vary in their distinctness and internal structure, but can be distinguished from cutans by their nonplanar shapes and more distinct outlines. Two common kinds of glaebulesare nodules and concretions. These two terms are widely confused as synonyms, but for soil science are distinguished on the basis of their internal structure. A nodule is massive internally whereas a concretion contains concentric layers. This difference can be discerned by breaking them open or making a thin section through them (Fig. 3.15). Internal structure may have significance for the way in which they form. Continuous growth or recrystalliiation forms nodules whereas concretions form by discontinuous, often seasonal, growth. Some nodules have a system of cracks radiating from their center. These septarian nodules appear like miniature turtle shells. They form when nodules change volume,for example,by drying out irreversibly. This may happen when siderite nodules, formed in stagnant water in lowland soils, are exposed to air (Retallack1997d).Bothnodules and concretions are hard and have a sharp and distinct outer boundary. They contrast with another kind of glaebule, called mottles, which are diffuse patches of the same kinds of materials. Mottles may in some cases be early stages in the differentiation of nodules or concretions, but for the most part are irregular patches of discol-
oration. A final kind of glaebule is local aggregations of clay with sharp boundaries. In some cases it may be clear that these are fragments of older shale or claystone in the parent materialof thesoil (lithorelicts),fragments of other soils in the parent material (pedorelicts). fragments of clay-filled cavities in the soil (illuviation argillans),pockets of minerals locally weathered to clay (clay nodules) or feces of soil-ingesting animals (fecal pellets). For the cases where the origin of such features is not so clear that they can be assigned to one of these genetic categories, the terms papule, clay gall or alteromorph are convenient, descriptiveterms (Brewer 1976; Delvigne 19 9 8). Glaebules can be described by their composition, which may be sesquioxidic,manganiferous, calcareous, sideritic, pyritic or siliceous.These compositions reflect particular soil conditions (Fig. 3.14) provided they can be shown to have originated in the soil. Glaebulescan be described as spherical, ellipsoidal, tuberose (irregular l i e a potato) or irregular (variable, but with rounded edges unlike a cutan). Mottles vary in the distinctness of their boundary with surrounding soil (Table3.5). Glaebules are abundant and conspicuous features of many soils and paleosols, but are not diagnostic of them. Marine sedimentary rocks also contain glaebules. In some cases nodules in marine rocks are thought to have formed within chemical irregularities in the sediment close to the sea floor in a way analogous to
Figure 3.1 5 Thin section of a calcareous nodule (A) and ferruginousconcretion(B). ThenoduleisfromhorizonBtof thetypeLal clay paleosol (OxicHaplustalf),and the concretionfrom the type Pila clay paleosol (AquicHaplustoll),both in the Upper Miocene (8 Ma)Dhok PathanFormationnear Kaulial village,northernPakistan (Srnithsonian specimens353779and353821:Retallack 1991a).Scalebarsare l m m .
Features of fossil soils Table 3.5 Description of glaebules and mottles. Aspect
Category
Description
Distinctness
Very sharp Sharp
Transitiontomatrixin
Diffuse
Transitionto matrix over 1-5 l ~ l l ~ l Transitionto matrix in >5 mm
c.1mm
Very diffuse Contrast
Faint Distinct
Prominent
Abundance
Sue
Recognizableonly on close inspection Readily seen,differing by at least two Munsell hues, cbromas or values Obvious, with hue, chromaor value severalMunsel1units apart
Few Common Many
<2% of exposed surface
Fine Medium Coarse
<5 mmdiameter on surface 5-1 5 mmdiameter >15 mmdiameter
2-20% of exposed surface >20% of exposed surface
Source: SoilSurveyStaff (1975).
their formation in soils, but they also may form during burial. Glaebules also form in cooling volcanic tuffs (thunder eggs), on ocean floors (manganese nodules), in shallow lakes (lime balls), and around springs (tufa: Boggs 1995). Thus care must be taken to determine whether glaebules were formed in the parent material of a soil, in the soil itself or later during burial of a paleosol. Sometimes this can be established from their relationship with original features of the soil such as root traces and burrows, and from their general chemical compatibility with other original features of the paleosol. Abundant nodules in a rock may spark suspicion that it was a soil, but care must be exercised in interpreting them. Crystals Crystals occur in some kinds of soilsand paleosols,especially in cracks and cavities such as root channels and burrows (Maglione 1981;Hartley &May 1998). Crys-
31
tals can form tubular aggregates (crystal tubes), nodular masses (crystal chambers), spherical aggregates of radiating crystals (spherulites) or sheet-like aggregates (crystal sheets), or occur as single isolated crystals embedded in matrix (intercalary crystals). In some cases, crystals enclose grains of the soil. Instead of appearing uniform, translucent and sharp-edged like normal crystals, these look like a piece of sandstone or siltstone, but in the shape of a crystal. A common example of these is so-called ‘sand crystals’ of gypsum (MacFayden 1950). In very old saline paleosols, sabkhas or playas in which original crystals have been strongly modified by diagenesis or metamorphism, only the impression or filled cavityof crystalsmayremain (Smith 1990).Theformof altered crystals in some cases may be sufficientlydistinctive to allow identification (Delvigne 1998). Cubes after halite commonly have a concentric muddy fill and slightly in-bowed sides. These are common examples of crystal pseudomorphs (Haude 19 70). Crystals are found mostly in alkaline and salty soils. Like nodules, their composition may reflect a particular soil chemistry (Fig. 3.14).Calcite and gypsum are found in soils of arid climates. One indication that crystals are an original part of a paleosol is displacivefabric: the way in which peds, nodules or other coherent parts of the soil have fallen or rotated into the crystal-filled region (Fig. 3.16C).Crystals also form during burial of a paleosol, in joints and veins, or in cavitiesformed by dissolution of soluble parts of a paleosol. Crystals can be common but are not diagnostic features of paleosols.
Pedotubules Burrows and root traces are prominent tubular features in soils and paleosols, but are not in all cases easy to distinguish from fulgurites, water-escape structures or other tubular features. A convenient nongenetic term for all such tubular features of soils and paleosols is pedotubule (Brewer 19 76). Within this system pedotubules are classified according to their compositionand contrast with surrounding material (Table 3 . 6 ) . Tubular features are common in soils but not diagnostic of them. Many burrows in soils are similar to those found in lake and ocean bottoms (Buatois et al. 1998).Burrows in paleosols may be valuable indicators of paleoenvironment, especially when sufficiently distinctive that their makers can be identified. Burrows of
32
Chapter3
A. MOSEPIC
C. CLINOBIMASEPIC
-
0.1 mm
-
0.1 mm
6. SKELSEPIC
D. OMNlSEPlC
-
0.1 mm
-
0.1 mm
Figure 3.16 Sepic plasmic (bright clay) microfabrics.all under cross-polarizedlight and with bar scales of 0.1mm. (A)Mosepic plasmic (streakybright clay) fabric from clayey surface (A) horizon of a paleosol (Sul6hemist) in the midcretaceous (9 5 Ma) DakotaFormationnear Russell,Kansas, USA(Retallack&Dilcher1981a;RetallackspecimenR101). (B) Skelsepicplasmic(grainlining bright clay)fabric from the subsurface (C) horizon of the Ogi silty clay loam light-colored variant paleosol (Fluvaquentic Eutrochrept) in theOligocene (29 Ma) SharpsFormationinBadlandsNationalPark, SouthDakota, USA (Retallack 1983a: Indiana Universityspecimen 15621).(C)Clinobimasepicplasmic(trellis-lie bright clay) fabricin the subsurface (Cg) horizon of a paleosol (Aquent) in the mid-Cretaceous(9 5 Ma) Dakota Formation near Fairbury, Nebraska, USA (Retallack&DiIcher 198l a: Retallack specimenR110). (D) Omnisepic plasmic (wovenbright clay)fabric in the clayey subsurface (Bt)horizon of a paleosol (Alfisol)in the mid-Cretaceous(95 Ma)DakotaFormation near Russell,Kansas, USA (Retallack&Dilcher 198l a: Retallackspecimen R94).
earthworms, millipedes, beetles, bees, termites, ants and rodents can be distinguished when suitably preserved (Retallack 1984,1990;Hasiotis & Dubiel1995; Hasiotis & Demko 1996a).None of these creatures can tolerate waterlogging and their depth of penetration into a paleosol may indicate the former level of the water table. As clearly original parts of a paleosol. the relationship of burrows to nodules and crystalsmayreveal their time of formation. The degree of deformation and crushing of burrows may be indicators of compaction in paleosols. Much can be learned from careful study of burrows.
Microfabric Some kinds of microscopic structure are characteristic of soils and paleosols (Brewer 1976: Fitzpatrick 1984; Delvigne 1998). Especially distinctive is the appearance of the he-grainedpart of the soil (plasmicfabric)in thin sections viewed under crossed nicols. Its appearance varies somewhat with the magnification used and the orientation and thickness of the section. Most plasmic fabrics are described from observations made at total magnifications of about 100-250 times natural size. Forworkinwhichit isimportant todistinguishpaleosols
Features of fossil soils from sedimentary rocks, it is best to cut the thin sections vertical relative to paleosol horizons and to the bedding planes of enclosing sedimentary rocks. In addition, thin sect,ionsof paleosols must be ground more carefully and Table 3.6 Terms forpedotubules.
Group
Term
Definition
Fill
Granotubule
Filled with clastic grains and little clay Filled with pellet-lie clasts of clay and grains Filled withclay and grains without orientation Fill of clay and grains showing curved layering
Aggrotubule Isotubule Striotubule Matrix
Orthotubule Metatubule Paratubule
Very similar fabric and compositionto soil matrix Differentfrom matrix, derived from another horizon Differentfrommatrii. u d i e any part of profile
Source: Brewer (1976).
33
thinner than usual for most rocks so that enough light can penetrate the clayey soil matrix, which usually is more opaque than mineral grains such as quartz (Murphy 19 86;Tate & Retallack 1995). The increased abundance of cutans obscuring original sedimentary, metamorphic or igneous textures as a soil develops is expressed on a microscopic scale by the development of bright clay fabric (sepic plasmic fabric: Collins & Larney 1983). Bright clay is highly oriented, and has a high birefringence under crossed nicols (Fig. 3.16,Table 3.7). In contrast, weakly oriented clay appears dull and randomly flecked (asepic). Different kinds of bright clay fabrics reflect increasingly extensive areas of oriented clay formed by washing into cracks, by internal stresses in the soil,and by surface weathering of soil peds. The degree of development of bright clay fabric is due in part to time availablefor soil formation and in part to the intensity of soil-forming processes such as stresses imposed by wetting and drying, filling and closing of cracks, andother alterations (Brewer & Sleeman 1969). Woven bright clay fabric (omnisepic fabric) forms most rapidly in swelling clay soils of seasonal climates, but also eventually in very old soils (Holzhey et al. 1974).
Table 3.7 Termsfor plasmic microfabric.
Term
Subdivision
Definition
Asepic
Argillasepic Calciasepic Silasepic Undulic Inundulic Isotic Crystic
Mainly clay and lacking highly birefringent streaks A mixture of clay andclay-shedcarbonate, andlacking highly birefringent streaks Many silt and sand grains, and lacking highly birefringent streaks Not quite isotropic,very dark under crossed nicols Not quite isotropic under crossed nicols,but cloudy,with large irregular isotropicpatches Isotropic (likeopal) or opaque ( l i e hematite) and thus black under crossednicols Individual euhedral crystals can be discerned
Sepic
Insepic Mosepic Vosepic Skelsepic Masepic Trimasepic Bimasepic Lattisepic Cliobimasepic Omnisepic
Smallisolated patches of highly birefrhgent plasma Partly adjoining highly birefringent streaks Highly birefringent plasma associatedwith void walls Highly birefringent plasma around skeleton grains Highly birefringent streaks forming an extensivecriss-crossingnetwork Network of highly birefringent streaks in three preferred directions Network of highly birefringent streaks in two preferred directions Network of highly birefringent streaks in two preferred directions and at a right angle Network of highly birefringent streaks in two preferred directions and at alow angle All highly birefringent, orientedplasma, with a ‘woven’appearance
Source: Brewer(1976).
34
Chapter3
A. ARGILLASEPIC
C. CRYSTIC
-0.1
mm
-01 mm
B. SILASEPIC
-0.1
mm
D. INUNDULIC
-0.1
mm
Figure 3.17 Asepic (dull clay) microfabrics.All under cross-polarized light and with bar scales of 0.1mm: (A)argillasepic (flecked clay)fabric in alacustrine oil shalein theMiddleEocene (45Ma) Green River Formationin Ulrichs Quarry near Kemmerer, Wyoming,USA (RetallackspecimenP6969B); (B)silasepic(grainy) fabric from the near-surface (E) horizon of apaleosol (Aquept) inthePennsylvanian (310Ma)FountainFormationnear ManitouSprings, Colorado,USA(Suttner&Dutta 1986;Retallack specimenP6185);(C) crystic (crystalline) fabric of fibrous andsparrycalciteinthesubsurface (Bk)horizonof apaleosol (Natrustol1)intheupperPliocene(3.2Ma)HadarFormationatalocalityALX333 4kmnorth-west of thejunctionof theKada Hadar and Awash rivers. Afarregion, Ethiopia (Radosevichet al. 1992;Taieb specimen GO): (D)inundulic (cloudy)fabric from the surface (A)horizon of a paleosol (Fibrist)in the mid-Cretaceous (95 Ma) Dakota Formation near Bunker Hill, Kansas, USA (Retallack&Dilcher1981a; Retallackspecimen R108).
Lattice-likebright clay fabric (lattisepicfabric) forms in the subsurface clayey (Bt) horizons of soils where clays are under moderate confining pressure (McCormack& Wilding 1974). Most kinds of bright clay fabric are characteristic of soils and paleosols. Important exceptions are cavity-filling and grain-coating bright clay, which also are found in sediments (Scholle 1979). Coated grains may form by pressure of compaction of hard grains against a clayey matrix or by rolling or encrustation in a variety of sedimentary and soil environments. Cavity-lining bright clay can form during late diagenetic dissolution of grains or fossils as readily as
within original cavities of the soil. A more highly oriented, but otherwise omnisepic plasmic fabric is found in paleosols metamorphosed to greenschist facies and beyond (Retallack& Krinsley 1993). Asepic microfabrics (Fig. 3.1 7; Table 3.7) are not diagnostic of soils, but can reveal much about conditions of their formation. Usually sediments also show some microscopic indications of bedding or cleavage and can be regarded as laminated (stria1fabrics).Laminated fabrics can be unidirectional (mistrial), as is usually the case for bedding, or bidirectional (bistrial) as in metamorphic rocks with both bedding and cleavage, or with
Features of fossil soils
Figure 3.18 Grain fabrics. All underplanepolarized light and with a scale bar of 0.1 mm, from the type Naranji clay paleosol (Psammentic Haplustalflin the upper Miocene (7.5 Ma) Dhok PathanFormation nearKhaur, Pakktan(Retallack 1991a):(A) granular fabric from subsurface (C) horizon (Smithsonianspecimen 353837); (B) intertextic fabric from subsurface (By) horizon(Smithsonianspecimen353831):(C) agglomeroplasmicfabric from subsurface (Bt) horizon (Smithsonianspecimen 353830); (D) porphyroskelicfabric fromsurface (A) horizon (Smithsonian specimen 353828).
C, AGGLOMEROPLASMIC
Table 3.8 Termsfor soil microfabric. ~
Term
Description
Porphyroskelic
Plasmaformsmatrixinwhichskeleton grains are set like phenocrysts in porphyritic rock Plasma forms incomplete or local matrix to skeleton grains Skeletongrains more prominent than plasma, which forms intergranular braces and pockets Skeletongrains all touching with little or no plasma in the interstices
Agglomeroplasmic Intertextic
Granular
-
A GRANULAR
Source: Brewer (1976).
two cleavage planes. Crystals are widespread in sediments, especially evaporites, limestones and dolomites, as well as in alkaline soils of dry climates (Scholle 19 78). Pyrite and siderite of swampland soils are often crys-
0.1 mm
-0.1
mm
B. INTERTEXTIC
D.PORPHYROSKELIC
-0.1
-0.1
35
mm
mm
talline. Opaque microfabric(onekind of isotic fabric)appears black in petrographic thin section. Opaque fabrics are produced by iron oxides and hydroxides,which form in well-drained soils. Isotropic microfabrics (another kind of isotic fabric) appear clear under ordinary light but black under crossed nicols. This kind of fabric is found in materials replaced by isotropic minerals such as opal or zeolites, found in soils formed in volcaniclastic materials. Few soil fabrics are completely isotropic, but some are almost so. Somber fabric (undulic) and cloudy fabric (inundulic) may be the result of the drying of highly flocculatedcolloidal material such as mixtures of clay with organic matter or iron oxides andoxyhydrates. These dull fabrics are common in the clayey portions of swampland soils and their paleosol equivalents, the seat earths of coal seams. They also can be found in clayey matrices of mud flows and other deposits of weakly orientated clay. Another aspect of soil microfabric (Fig. 3.18, Table 3.8) is the proportion of original mineral grains and rock fragments (skeleton grains) to fine-grained
36
Chapter3
material (plasma). Point counting to quantify these proportions can be useful. Porphyroskelic fabric can be the original texture of the parent material or it can be the end result of soil formation in which many mineral grains have been broken down to clay by weathering.
In microscopic as well as in readily visible features, soils and paleosols have features inherited from their parent material, as well as features acquired during soil formation. Many of these soil features are useful for both interpreting and recognizing paleosols in the rock record.
Soils of the Past: An introduction to paleopedology Edited by: Gregory J. Retallack Copyright 02001 Gregory J. Retallack
Chapter 4 Soil-forming processes
Implicit among the features by which soils are recognized and classified are the processes that formed them. Such processes are more readily observed in modern soils than in paleosols in which they ceased to act long ago. Nevertheless, processes often can be inferred from features of paleosols or from suites of paleosols. The reconstruction of processes gives meaning and connection to features and kinds of paleosols. Soil-forming processes can be reduced to physical, chemical or biologicalcomponents of weathering. That this distinction is an artificial one can be seen from the example of plant roots, which are biological structures but produce exudates with chemical effects and grow in girth to physically force apart the soil. Nevertheless, a large body of literature on soil biology, chemistry and physics is testimony to the way in which these traditional scientific divisions have permeated soil science (Bohn et al. 1985; Eisenbeis & Wichard 1987; Marshall et al. 1996). Important to the interpretation of modern soils is the measurement of physical,chemical and biological features of soils such as linear expansion of clays, pH of soil solutions and the distribution of soil organic matter. Few of these features can be measured directly from paleosols altered by burial. Other sources of information pertinent to these indices of soil formation must be sought, with due regard for common kinds of alteration after burial.
Indicatorsof physical weathering Various physical processes play a role in forming soil from underlying rock or sediment. Granite and schist form deep within the Earth then expand and break into joints when unroofed by erosion and exposed at the surface. Initial loosening allows circulation of water, which turns into ice in winter or precipitates salt in a dry season. Both of these changes result in expansion, which forces cracks wider. Thermal expansion caused by forest fire may be sufficient to crack open large rocks.
Some kinds of clay swell when moist and contract when dry (Marshall et al. 1996). Effects of such physical processes can be observed and in some cases quantified in paleosols. Physical features of paleosols are estimated by using empirical relationships or constants established by work on modern soils and calibrated by features that are measurable in paleosols.
Loosening Expansion of rocks and sediments accompanies the development of joints and soil cracks during weathering. This results in a lower bulk density, measured in grams per cubic centimeter (Klute 1994). Most rocks have a density more than twice that of water. They range from - ~more) high values for peridotite and basalt (3 g ~ m or ) . have to lower values for granite (c. 2 . 5 g ~ m - ~ Soils densities close to l . O g ~ m - ~ They . range from a low of 0.17 g in organic horizons to a high of 1.85 g cm-3 in subsurface layers (Fig. 4.1). Paleosols vary over this entire range for rocks and soils depending upon the extent to which alteration during burial has changed them into rocks. The original soil density of most paleosols cannot be determined because of compaction, cementation and other changes after burial. In somecases, however, compaction can be calculated from the folding of formerly straight and erect features of the soil such as skeletans or quartz veins. A compaction factor can be calculated from the present length of the vein by the shortest straight distance compared with the former length of the vein along its contortions (Table 4.1). Compaction factors also can be estimated from the behavior of comparable materials at the l i l y depth of burial (Caudill etal. 1997;Sheldon&Retallack2000).
Fluid flow The amount of water and gases that a soil can hold is 37
38
Chapter4
Table 4.1 Estimatingoriginal density,moisture equivalents andporosityof paleosols (fromBodman&Mahrnud1932; Birkeland 1999).
where symbols are: C, diagenetic compaction ratio (fractionof original thickness of soil as a result of burial) M , moisture equivalent (%) 0,porosity (x) P, volume (%) T,thickness (cm) v,volume (cm3) W, weight (g) X, proportion (fraction) p, density (g
and subscriptsare: a, sand c, clay f, buried or fossil soil i, silt m.n, for a given mineral s, original soil
related to the open spaces between the grains of the soil (Marshalletal. 1996).Of interestistheamountof water that can move through a soil in a given time (permeability), the amount of water that can be held in a soil (porosity)and the amount of water that can be retained by surface tension in the smallest cavities of the soil when the large pores have drained out (field capacity). None of these characteristics can be measured effectively in buried soils in which the cavities have been crushed or filled during burial. Some idea of former field capacity can be gained from paleosols by studying their grain-size distribution as established by point counting thin sections. Sandy soils are more porous and permeable, but have a lower field capacity than clayey soils. Field capacity can be approximated using a n empirical equation based on the percentageof sand, siltandclay(Table4.1). A more accurate estimate of former porosity can be obtained if the mineralogical composition and former density of the paleosol are known. The proportions of different minerals can be estimated by point counting thin sections.Originaldensity of thepaleosolcan beesti-
Soil-formingprocesses mated from its present density using compaction factors. Porosity is then calculated from the proportions of the various minerals, the density of the particular minerals from mineralogical reference works (Deer et d. 1992)andtheformerdensityof thepaleosol(Table4.1). A general idea of water flow and retention in soilsmay be gained from the distribution of root traces, burrows and soil structures. If root traces and burrows sidle along rather than penetrate a particular layer, that may have been an impermeable and hard barrier. Ferruginous concretions indicate oxygenated, free-flowing water. Sideritenodules. on the other hand, indicate stagnant, poorlyoxygenated water (seeFig.3.14). Clay swelling
The amount of physical expansion as a result of wetting of clay can be measured by changes in length or density Most clays expand to some extent when wet. This behaviorismostmarkedinsmectite (28 k Z%linearextensibility), and less so in illite (20 k 1%) and kaolinite (12 k 2%),as indicated by experiments (Nettleton & Brasher 1983) and numerical simulation (Karaborni at al. 1996). Burial compaction, dewatering and cementation of paleosols alters the swelling properties of clays. Their mineralogical composition also changes because of
regular mukkara
I
39
cations lost during dewatering. A well-known diagenetic alteration of clay is the formation of illite from smectite (Mora et al. 1998). Unraveling the amount and nature of such changes can be difficult and this compromises the use of typical values of expansion for different modern clays to interpret paleosols. Despite these difficulties, structural effects of clay heave can remain visible in paleosols. The most striking of these features is the hummock-and-swale microtopography called gilgai microrelief (Paton 1974). These natural undulations are thought to arise by swelling and upward buckling of the soil along deeply cracked hummocks. This may be exacerbated by dry soil falling into cracks, causing hummocks to heave further following the next rain. Hummocky subsurface differentiation is called mukkara structure (Fig. 4.2), and it has been recognized in very ancient paleosols (Retallack 1986a). Small-scale structures also may reflect former clay heave. Subangular blocky peds in heaving clay soils are often sheared by a conjugate system of slickensidesinto lentil and wedge peds (Krishna & Perumal 1948; Gustavson 1991).Microfabricalsomayshowarelationship to linear extensibility of clays, which is greatest (up to 12%)for woven bright clay (omnisepic plasmic) fabrics but minimal (up to 3.8%) for flecked bright clay (insepic plasmic) fabrics (Holzheyet ul. 1974).
distorted mukkaro
I
zone of dislorted mukkara
yellowish brown clay-
Figure 4.2 Mukkara structure in soilsof the Darling Downs, southeastern Queensland, Australia (fromGeoderrna 11,T.R.Paton 1974, Originandterminologyfor gilgaiinAustralia, p. 223; reprintedwithpermissionfromElsevierScience).
40
Chapter4
Fire heating
Freezing
Charcoal remains in the soil after a fire and is remarkably resistant to decay and chemical degradation (Retallack 1998a).Fossil charcoal has been found in paleosols and sediments as old as earliest Carboniferous (Cope & Chaloner 1985). In paleosols this old, it can be difficult to distinguish it from unburnt wood that has been coalified during burial. There are, however, a number of differences between charcoal and coal fragments (Table 4.2). The abundance of charcoal can be quantified by point-counting thin sections or by washing samples of known volume. A second indicator of fire is the pattern of stone spalling produced by forest fires over stony soils. The heating of stones creates concentric fractures. Curved exfoliated shells of rock are thrown off the littleweathered, rounded core of the boulder. In the absence of fire, on the other hand, rocks are more deeply weathered chemically and biologically. They may maintain an irregular shape covered with lichens and a rind of strongly weathered rock. Such differences between fired and unfired rocks are used to assess fire frequency in bouldery soils of alpine regions (Birkeland 1999).
Frigid periglacial climates create a variety of soil structures. The most distinctive of these are ice and sand wedges. Sand wedges are sharply tapering, vertically bedded, sand-filled structures (Fig. 4.3). Ice wedge casts are similar in outline but filled with slumped and horizontally layered sediment. Both sand and ice wedges have a strong taper that is very different from the deep, often contorted cracks of mukkara structure. Ice and sand wedge casts commonly are found in much coarser-grained material than the clayey soilsusual for mukkara structure. A variety of other periglacial features are known in soils and paleosols.String bogs, rock glaciers and pingos are a few examples among many (Washburn 1980: Karte 1983: Van Vliet-Lanoe 1985). Each forms in a particular modern climatic regime and this can be inferred for fossil examples (Willams 1986: Retallack & Alonso-Zarza 1998;Krulll999).
Table 4.2 Criteriafor distinguishingcharcoal from coaMed wood.
Fossil charcoal
Codified wood
Equant shape Sharplybroken or rounded ends Black and opaque Broken surface fibrous Broken surface showingcells No middle lamella between cell walls as seenwith SEM Resistant to oxidation Found inoxidized and gleyed paleosols Glows on burning
Usually elongatesplinters Irregularor frayed ends Brown to black Broken surface conchoidal Broken surface structureless Middle lamella visible between crushed cells under SEM Easily oxidized Found ingleyed paleosols only Burns with abright flame
SEM. scanningelectron microscope. Sources: Harris (1981);Cope&Chaloner (198 5).
Figure 4.3 Near-verticalsandstonewedge penetrating quartziteof the Cattle GridBreccia,both of LateProterozoic age(680Ma) intheMtGunsonMine.SouthAustra1ia (photographcourtesyof G.E. Williams).
Soil-forming processes
cal weathering. A working familiarity with common values for the weight per cent of oxides of major elements andof waysof manipulatingsuchanalyticaldata can beuseful for interpretingancient chemical weathering from paleosols. Minerals also are present in limited variety in soils compared with exotic crystals listed in mineralogical compendia (Deer et al. 1992). A few silicates (quartz, muscovite, microcline), clays (smectite, kaolinite and illite), carbonates (calcite, dolomite), sulfates (gypsum), oxides (hematite) and hydroxides (goethite) are the commonest of soil minerals. These minerals have characteristic optical properties and fields of chemical stability (see Fig. 3.14). Their textural relationships anddegree of etching observedin thin sections can be guides to the nature and severity of chemical alteration in paleosols. They preserve in an arrested state the progress of chemical reactions because chemical alteration in soilsis slow and seldomreaches thermodynamic equilibrium.
Indicatorsof chemical weathering Soil-forming chemical reactions are for the most part of four main kinds: hydrolysis, oxidation, hydration and dissolution (Table 4.3).The reverse reactions of alkalization, reduction, dehydration and precipitation also occur within soils and within paleosols during burial. The problem of recognizing chemical reactions in paleosols would be daunting were it not for such a limited array of common reactions. The problem also is simplified by the fact that most soil consists of only a few elements and minerals. Eight elements make up 98%by bothweight andvolumeof averagecrustalrocks and soils. These are (with average weight per cent in parentheses, after Mason & Moore (1982)):0 (46.60), Si (27.72), A1 (8.13), Fe (5.00), Mg (2.09), Ca (3.63)’ Na (2.83) and K (2.59). Trace elements may be important for interpreting many aspects of paleosols, but it is these major elements that definethe net effect of chemiTable 4.3 Common kinds of chemical reactions during weathering. I. Hydrolysis 2NaAlSi,O, albite
+
11. Oxidation
Pel+ ferrous ion
+
2Fe2+ ferrous ions
+
Fe3+ ferric ion
+
+
IV. Dissolution CaCO, + CO, calcite carbon dioxide
’/202 oxygen
+
CaSO, anhydrite
+
+
11H,O water
AI,Si,O,(OH,) kaolinite
+
2NaC sodium ions
+
+
4C0, carbon dioxide
+
2HC0,+ bicarbonate ions
e- (partialreaction) electron toother element
4HC0,+ bicarbonate ions
In. Dehydration 2FeOOH 4 Fe,O, goethite hematite CaS0,.2H,O gypsum
+
2C0, carbon dioxide
+
4H,O water
4
Fe,O, hematite
H,O water
+
H,O water
Source: Garrels&Mackenzie(l971).
2H,O water Ca2+ + calcium ion
41
2HC0,bicarbonate ions
6H,O water
4H,SiO, silicic acid
42
Chapter4
Acidification Hydrolysisis the reaction of carbonic acid with a cationrich mineral grain to produce clay and cations. Clay accumulates in the soil and cations are washed out or taken up by plants in solution. As an example, we may consider the hydrolysis of albite (Table 4.3). In essence, hydrolysis involves the displacement of cations by hydronium. It is the main chemical reaction resulting in the destruction of silicate minerals (Chesworth 1992; Bland & Rolls 199 8). A widely used average measure of the prevalence of hydrolysis reactions in modern soils is their acidity as measured by pH. This is technically the negative logarithm of the hydronium ion (Ht) activity. It is usually measured by a chemically treated electrode that develops an electrical potential with respect to a standard electrode when placed in a solution of equal amounts of soil and distilled water (Sparks 1996).This approach is not suitable for paleosols in which the soil has been so compacted and cemented that it is not possible to resurrect its originally reactive surfaces. Studies of Quaternary paleosols (Simonson 1941) have shown that pH changes substantially on burial of a soil or subsidence below the water table. Fortunately, the pH of paleosols can be estimated within broad categories from the stability fields of minerals thought to have been original (seeFig. 3.14)as well as by biological and structural features. The extreme range of soil pH from 2.8 to 10 can be subdividedinto six general categories (Baas-Beckinget al. 1960). Extremely acidic soils (pH 2 . 8 4 . 5 ) are noncalcareous and consist largely of peat, pyrite, quartz or a deeply weathered clay, such as kaolinite. They show little evidence of burrowing or plant decay. Organic acids are produced by plants and microbes, carbonic acid by dissolution of high concentrations of soil carbon dioxide, and sulfuric acid by oxidation of sulfides. Extremely acidic soils contain a dearth of exchangeable cations such as Ca2+,Mg2+,Nat and Kt and are dominated by hydronium (Ht) along with aluminum (A13+)through its reaction with water to produce Al-hydroxy ions (Al(OH)2tand Al(OH)2+). Moderately acidic soils (pH 4.5-6.5) are similarly noncalcareous and base poor, but may contain a wider range of easily hydrolyzed minerals such as feldspar and of base-rich clays such as illite or smectite. Limited bio-
logical activity may be evident from the presence of fecal pellets or burrows. Plant material in moderately acidic soilsshows some signs of decay. Near-neutral soils (pH 6.5-8) are weakly calcareous. Apatite, birnessite and siderite also are stable under these conditions, along with a variety of easily weatherable minerals. These soils are 70-90% saturated with bases (Ca2+,Mg2+,Na+and Kt) depending on the kind of clay present. They have no exchangeable cationic aluminum (A13+)and little exchangeable hydronium (Ht). Fecal pellets, burrows and other evidence of biological activity may be abundant innear-neutral soils. Moderately alkaline soils (pH 8-8.5) are calcareous with free crystals and nodules of calcite or other carbonate minerals. Their clays are cation rich (largely with Ca2+and Mg2+).Pelletoidal structure from the copious activity of soil invertebrates is common. Alkaline soils (pH 8.5-9) are similarly calcareous, nodular and pelletoidal. Their clays tend to be smectitic with exchangeable cations including sodium and potassium (Na+ and K+). These are swelling clays that may create mukkara structure (Fig. 4.2). Gypsum, anhydrite, dolomite and zeolites also are characteristic of alkaline soils. Extremely alkaline soils (pH 9-11) may be sodium saturated and contain halite, gypsum and other evaporite minerals (Chen 1997). These soils have base-rich clays such as smectites.Domedcolumnar ped structures arecharacteristic(McCahon&Miller1997).Roottraces and other evidence of life in these soilsare usually sparse because these soils form in very dry and saline desert basins. These broad categories of pH can be refined by calculating mineral weathering ratios within a profile. The abundance of easily hydrolyzed minerals compared with hydrolysis-resistant minerals increases with pH, among other factors. Such ratios are more meaningful whencompared with theratioof themineralsin theparent material and when there is independent evidence of the time over which the profile developed. A commonly used mineral weathering ratio is quartdfeldspar. Microcline and plagioclase feldspar may be distinguishable from quartz by their twinning, but it may be necessary to stain a thin section with potassium dichromate (Houghton 1980) to count proportions of orthoclase and quartz. Because feldspar is much more readily hydrolyzed than is quartz, this ratio is higher in acidic
Soil-formingprocesses soilsthan in alkaline. Another mineral weathering ratio is the ratio of zircon and tourmaline to pyroxene and amphibole. The latter two minerals are much less resistant to weathering than are zircon and tourmaline. These minerals do not occur in sufficient abundance to be counted in thin sections. They should be concentrated from known volumes of soil for counting. These mineral weathering ratios are based on the observed differential stabilities of minerals in soils (Fig. 4.4). Among mineral grains of sand and silt size, microcline (a potassium feldspar)is more resistant to weathering than is albite (a sodium feldspar). Both feldspars and m&c minerals (olivine, pyroxene, amphibole and biotite) are more readily hydrolyzed than is quartz (Goldich 1938).Quartzisnot so weather resistant when fine grained, however, because of its increased surface area (Jackson et al. 1948). From these general relationships a variety of mineral weathering ratios can be devised to suit particular profiles. For metamorphosed paleosols it may be worthwhile to calculate mineralogical composition from a chemical analysis. Various recipes and computer programs are available for calculating mineralogical modes of igneous rocks from a chemical analysis, but these are based on minerals and chemical reactions inappropriate for soils. For paleosols, once the likely minerals originally present have been established, their proportions can be calculated by ‘reacting’mole fractions of each major elemental oxide on a large balance sheet (Garrels & Mackenzie 1971). Such methods for calculating modes have been computerized (Reynolds 1985; Schmitt 1999).
An alternative approach is to use chemical analyses of paleosols to obtain molecular weathering ratios, which vary greatly with soil type (Fig. 4.5).These are calculated by dividing the weight per cent of each relevant oxide by its molecular weight and then adding or dividing as specified by the particular ratio. Molecularweathering ratios useful for assessing former extent of hydrolysis reactions are aluminalbases, alkaline earthslalumina, silicalalumina and bariumlstrontium (Table 4.4). Values of aluminalbases can reach 100 or more in strongly developed soils (Oxisols and Ultisols), but areless than two in moderately developedfertile soils (Alfisols and Mollisols).The ratio bariumhtrontium is an indicator of leaching, degree of free drainage and time of development. Strontium is the more soluble of these two otherwise chemically similar trace elements. The bariumlstrontium ratio ranges from near 10 in acidic, sandy soils (Spodosols),to near two in most rocks andsoils (Retallack 1997a). Another technique using chemical analyses is to calculate the loss of cationic bases in a soil or paleosol comparedwithits assumedparentmaterial. Acid(orproton) consumption in milliequivalents is assumed equal to each mole of alkalis (Na+ and K+) lost plus each halfmole of alkaline earths (Ca2+and Mg2+)lost (Table4.5). Acid consumption of soilsis usually about a milliequivalent per square meter per year under humid temperate forests (Retallack 1996b). A more rigorous method of analyzing chemical change is to normalize chemical compositionsto a constituent thought to have remained stablein both thesoil and itsparentmaterial(Table4.6). This is a more complexprocedure that relies on a variety
STABILITY SERIES sand- and silt-size mineral grains __ ---
CO
K feld~ar
muscovite ’
least eastly
quartz-
WEATHERING INDEX clay-size mineral grains
- -- -_--.‘ .,..Z.calcite, 1.gypsum. holite apatite
* -
most easily weathered
Figure4.4 Relativestability of mineral grains of silt size or larger (left-hand side)and of clay-sizeminerals (right-hand side)under conditions of weathering in soils (data from Goldich 1938;Jacksonetd. 1948).
43
feldspar
~
- -
,
* ,‘ ~
‘
‘,3.olivine, pyroxene 4. biotite, glauconite 5 albite, pnorthite, volcanic glass 6. quartz, cristabalite ,/Z muscovite, seridte 8. vermiculite 9. smectite 0. kaolinite halloysite, allophdne II. gibbsite, boehmite 12. hematite, goethite 13. anatase, rutile. zircon
44
Chapter4 niolecular weathering ratios field observations b,Q CaOtMEO MA?, 2 K,O AI,O, SiO, Munsell color b \ percent grain size c Q soil horizon 50 2 4 0 01 020
2
cm
'*"*
dc.'"
a
'4)
Bt
a
C
a
LLU
-
m
ULTISOL (Typic Paleudult) Cecil sandv loam. Milne
amar
"1
gravel
n
b CA
sand silt
E ul clav-
gg granular peds 0
calcareous nodules
L
-
rm
ALFISOL (Tvoic Haoludalfl Miami silt loam. WestDo
MOLLISOL (Udic Haplustoll)
Decatu
LIlI
fl
rrrr
- Moody silt loam, Moo co.,SI
a
.Laveen loam, Buckeye,
LLLL
L
Figure 4.5 Profiles,grain-suedata andmolecular weathering ratios forselectedNorth American soils (from Retallack 1997, A ColourGuide toPaleosols;withpermission0 JohnWiley&SonsLtd:datafromMarbut 1935;Davis 1972;Hartman 1977; Shively 1983:Kunze 1989).
Soil-forming processes Table 4.4 Major kinds of chemicalreactions in paleosolsand molecular weathering ratios used to approximatethem.
1. H y h o b s i s
alumina/bases = AI,O,/(CaO +MgO + K,O alumina/silica = AI,O,/SiO, barium/strontium =Ba/Sr
45
+Na,O)
II. Oxidation ferrous/ferric iron =FeO/Fe,O, total iron/alumina= (Fe,O, +FeO)/AI,O, total iron and manganese/alumina= (Fe,O, +FeO+ MnO)/AI,O,
HI. Hydration silica/sesquioxides= SiO,/(Fe,O,
+A1,0,)
n! Saliniaation akalis/alumina= (K,O +Na,O)/AI,O, soda/potash=Na,O/K,O soda/alumina=Na,O/AI2O3 V. Atomic weights Si=28.09 A1=26.98 0=16.00 Fe=55.85
of assumptions about parent materials (Brimhall et al. 1991;Beauvais& Colin 1993 ) . Oxidation Oxidation reactions are those in which an element suffers electron loss when forming a compound. The reverse reaction of reduction is more easily memorized from an apparent oxymoron: ’reduction is electron gain’. Reduction occurs in waterlogged soils and in buried soils, but for well-drained soiIs oxidation is the rule. Oxygeninthe atmosphereis themostpowerfulnaturally occurring electron scavenger and elements combining with oxygen surrender their electrons to its orbitals. Of the major elements making up most Earth materials, manganese and iron can readily spare an electron, and of these two elements iron is much more abundant. At its simplest level the oxidation of iron can be expressed by a partial reaction for iron (Table 4.3). Minerals containing iron in the ferrous valence state (Fe”), such as olivine or siderite,tend to be gray or green in color. Ferric (Fe3+)iron, on the other hand, is found in minerals, such as goethite and hematite, that have yellow, brownandredcolors (Hurst 1977).Whenliberated from silicate minerals by hydrolysis, ferrous cations of iron are readily soluble in water and often are washed
K=39.10 Na=22.99
Ca=40.08 Mg=24.32
Ba=137.3 Sr=87.6
out of the profile. Ferric iron cations are relatively insoluble in water and so remain as oxides and oxyhydrates. The formation of hematite from olivine is a two-step process of hydrolysis followed by oxidation (Table4.3). An overall measure of the extent of oxidation and reduction reactions in modern soils is Eh. This is the electrode potential in volts induced by soil solutions. Low negative Eh is an indication that the soil can readily donate electrons and is reducing. A high positive Eh, on the other hand, is found in oxidizing soils with a high demand for electrons. The principal oxidizing agent in modern soils is free oxygen from the atmosphere. Its exclusion by waterlogging creates reducing conditions (Vepraskas & Sprecher 1997). Because the water content and pore structure of paleosols is so altered by burial, it is not possible to establish their former Eh by direct measurement. Like pH, Eh is altered substantially with burial or subsidence of a paleosol below the water table (Bohnet al. 198 5). The former Eh of paleosols can be reconstructed within broad limits from mineral assemblages thought to have been original (see Fig. 3.14).Because chemical reactions of mineral transformation that define these categories also are pH dependent, it is not possible to give boundary values of Eh categories in millivolts. However,
46
Chapter4
Table 4.5 Acid and oxygen consumptionof soils and paleosols.
Table4.6 Formulaerelatingvolume, thicknessandchemicaI changesin soil and paleosol horizonsduring soil formation
and burial compaction.
B=2p,(O.O1783C+0.02481M+0.01062K
+O.O.O613N)/lOO I=p(O.O1392F)/100 TI= [(D,+D, - 1 )-(DI+D,+ I)I/2 A=ZT,(B,- B,)
o=ZT,(I,-I,)
symbols: A, acid consumptionof profile (equiv.cm-2) B,base content of sample(equiv.cm-’) 1. reduced iron of sample (equiv.~ m - ~ ) C.M.K.N.F. CaO, MgO. K,O, Na,O, FeO (wt X ) (respectively) 0,oxygen consumptionof profile (equiv.cm-I) D, depthto sample (cm) T,thicknessrepresentedby sample(cm) p, bulkdensity ( g ~ m - ~ ) subscripts: i. for sample i i + 1,for sample or surfaceabove i i - 1,for sampleor parent material below i p, for parentmaterial constants: 0.01783. etc.,element weight fractionof oxides 100,percentage adjustment Sources: Holland (1984); Retallack (1996b); Bland & Rolls (1998).
there are three recognizable categories of Eh: reducing, intermediate and oxidizing. These correspond to waterlogged, wet and well-drained soils (Baas-Becking et al. 1960).This may not always have been the casebecause atmospheric oxygen may have been lower in the distant geological past (>2200Ma: Rye&Holland 1998). when well-drained soils would have been reducing. This may be a problem for interpreting the paleodrainage and former atmospheres of such ancient paleosols, but it does not affect their inferred redox status. Reducing soils (strong negative Eh) are usually bluish or greenish gray. The iron in their minerals is in the ferrous state (Fez’), which is naturally drab colored. Additional grayness may be due to organic matter (Retallack 1994a).Thesearethesoils that accumulate peat, which on burial and diagenesis is converted to coal. One bright
variables:
E , strain, or volume change comparedwith initial volume
p. dry bulk density (g ~ m - ~ ) z. transportedmass fraction, gains or losses or concentration
ratio of a chemicalconstituentcomparedwith parent material ( g ~ m - ~ ) C, chemicalconcentrationof a constituent (wt X ) F, compactionratio or fractionof originaIthicknessas a result of burial compactionor of soil formation R, amount of chosen stableconstituent (wt%) S, weight of a chemicalconstituentnormalizedto a stable constituentremainingfrom parent material (g cm-’) T.thickness(cm) W, weight (g) v. volume (cm3) X. weight of achemical constituentin a given volume (g ~ m - ~ ) subscripts: f, for the buried or fossil soil p. for the parent material s, for the originalsoil Sources: Brewer (1976):Chadwicketal.(1990).
mineral associated with reducing soils is pyrite, often in the form of framboids (Fig. 4.6).In natural exposures of paleosols pyrite may be destroyed by modern oxidation. I t can still be detected as dustings of its weatheringproduct: a light yellow powder of jarosite, which has a characteristic smell Like rotten eggs (Kraus 1998). Another distinctive mineral of reduced soils is vivianite
Soil-formingprocesses
sphoerosiderite
Figure 4.6 Some common constituents of coals and waterlogged paleosols.In some cases (botryococcoidalgae, megaspores, cuticles, coaliEedwood)specimens show marked compaction and in other cases (sphaerosiderite,pyrite framboids and sclerotinite) little change as a result of compaction.
pyrite frornboid
botryococcoid algal colony
leof cuticle
(Bloomfield 1981).This is white as nodules or replaced arthropod carapaces when reduced, but turns a distinctive bright blue color when mildly oxidized.Strongly reduced soils also contain well-preserved plant remains because lack of oxygen curtails the activities of aerobic microbial decomposers. The proportion of amorphous compared with structurally preserved plant material, or of fossil roots compared with shoots, is auseful indicator of the degree of former oxidation of a paleosol. The activity of large animals and plants in reducing soils also is limited. Stronglyreduced soils contain few burrows and fecal pellets. Root traces do not penetrate them deeply, but spread in a tabular pattern (see Fig. 3.3). Soil structures also are weakly developed in reducing soils. Original sedimentary structures such as bedding and ripple marks may persist. On a microscopic scale this may be reflected in striated (mistrial plasmic) or in dull cloudy (undulic and inundulic) fabrics (Brewer 1 976). Soils of intermediate redox status (near-neutral Eh) may be either partly or periodically waterlogged. Many swamps experience a season dry enough for forest fires that introduce charcoal into the peat. Charcoal is a distinctive component of some coal (Fig. 4.6, Table 4.2). Seasonally dry soils also may be strongly mottled. During gleyed conditions of a wet season, hydrolysis liber-
47
fungo1 sclerotium
megospore
chorcoal (burnt wood) coolified wood (unburnt)
ates drab ferrous iron (Bennett et al. 1991). During the dry season this may be oxidized and fixed as orange goethite (McCarthy et aI. 1998). Two common kinds of mottling associated with seasonal waterlogging can be recognized (Fig.4.7). Usually the lower part of a paleosol below the water table is more gleyed than the upper part. In very clayey soils impermeable layers may form a barrier to downward percolation of water (a perched water table), which can lead to greater waterlogging of the upper than the lower part of the profile. The difference between groundwater and surface-water gley is most apparent around burrows and root traces, which are more reduced than the soil matrix in surface-water gley, but more oxidized in groundwater gley (PiPujol & Buurman 1997). Different kinds of mottling must be interpreted with care for paleosols because drab-haloed root traces (see Figs 3.6 and 3.7) may be a consequence of burial rather than reflecting original conditions. In addition to these mixedredox indicators, soils of intermediate oxidation contain more mildly reduced minerals and lack the sulfideminerals of extreme reduction. Characteristic of soils of intermediate redox status are minerals such as birnessite and siderite (Moore et al. 1992).Sand-sized spherical aggregates of siderite crystals (sphaerosiderite) are common in paleosols of coal
48
Chapter4
GROUNDWATER GLEY
0
silt. .. .. . .. sand ,
a -
Bray clay
SURFACE-WATER GLEY brown clay
iron, stain
(>:-’
measures and may be products of original soilformation at intermediate Eh or of gleization attendant on burial (Ludvigsen et al. 1998). Siderite is readily oxidized to goethite or hematite. All three minerals may be present in the same paleosol as a result of an original soil regime of fluctuating oxidation, or oxidation of originally gleyed minerals in the modern outcrop. Fluctuating oxidation in the original soil would be likely if the paleosol also showed a mixture of well-decomposed and recognizable organic matter or patterns of root traces that include both deeply penetrating and tabular root systems. Swamps that are periodically dry have very low rates of peat accumulation. Paleosols formed under such conditions have little or no coal (Retallack 1994a). Fecal pellets and burrows may be present and also some crude blocky and platy ped structures. Microfabrics of soils of intermediate redox status may include bright clay (sepic plasmic fabric). Oxidized soils (high positive Eh) are warm colored with iron oxyhydrates such as brown ferrihydrite and yellowish brown goethite, and oxides such as brick-red hematite. The variation in color of these oxidized minerals can be related to light absorption by varying proportions of 0x0- and hydroxyl-groups (Rossman 1996). Hematite is especially common in paleosols because of dehydration reactions accompanying burial (Blodgettet al. 1993). Organic matter is not noticeable in oxidized
siderite, pyrite
Figure4.7 SchematicmodeIs for the formationofgroundwatergley(1eft)and surface-watergley (right).
soils except near the surface and around living roots. Dead organisms in well-drained soils are decomposed and recycled by a community of microbial decomposers. Although organic matter may be scarce, there may be abundant evidence of life in oxidized soils in the form of burrows, fecal pellets and copiously branching, deeply penetrating root systems. Well-drained soils also have well-developed soil structure including peds. illuviation clay skins and sepic plasmic microfabrics. Mineral weathering ratios are not especiallyuseful for quantifying soil oxidation because iron oxide minerals are too fine grained and dispersed to count easily. Oxidation state of a paleosol can, however, be chemically characterized using molecular weathering ratios (Table 4.4), by normalizing the relevant chemical analyses to their abundance in parent material (Table 4.6), or by calculating equivalents (i.e.electrons) used to oxidizereducediron (Table4.5).Ferric toferrousironratiosare an effective proxy measure of oxidation state. In many methods of bulk chemical analysis the two oxidation states of iron are not distinguished. The weight per cent value from such analyses may be cited as ferric (Fe,O,) or ferrous (FeO) iron. An independent method of determining the abundance of one of the oxidation states is needed: for example, potassium dichromate titration (Maxwell 1968).The abundance of the other oxidation state can be estimated by molar difference. When such additional analytical data are not available, the total
Soil-formingprocesses iron or total iron plus manganese values may be useful guides to the degree of oxidation of a paleosol. The oxidized minerals of these elements are insoluble and accumulate in soils, whereas their reduced cations are lost from gleyed soils in groundwater flow. Total iron to alumina ratios calculated for a variety of North American soils are mostly less than 0.4 (Marbut 1935). The ratio can reach 1.2 in ferruginous (spodic) horizons, 1.9 in clayey (argillic) horizons and 1.5 in red and deeply weathered (oxic)horizons. Hydration Hydration or dehydration reactions involvethe addition or loss,respectively, of water that is structurallypartof a mineral. Hydrated soil minerals such as goethite and gypsum are formed by hydration reactions and also can dehydrate tononhydrous minerals such as hematite and anhydrite (Table 4.3). The degree of hydration of a soil can be approximated by identifying and quantifying the abundance of these minerals using Mossbauer spectroscopy for iron oxyhydrates (Dixon & Weed 19 89) and X-ray diffractionfor clays (Klute 1994).Moredirectestimates of hydration can be gained by weighing ovendried soil after heating to temperatures that have been shown to drive off different volatile fractions. These volatile materials include organic matter and carbon dioxide as well as structural water (Sparks 1996). The degree of hydration of paleosols could be determined in the same way were it not for dehydration reactions following burial and compaction. Gypsum, for example,isdehydrated toanhydrite (Boggs 1995). Ferrihydrite and goethite are converted to hematite (Blodgett et al. 1993). Smectiteis altered to illite, then sericite and ultimately muscovite (Mora et al. 1998). The transition from acicular low-density gypsum to orthorhombic high-density anhydrite may be obvious from the relict crystal outlines of the formerly larger crystals of the hydrated mineral. For fine-grained minerals such as hematite and illite, however, there is no such guide. Exactly how hydrated they may have been is difficult to estimate, but hydration is likely to be proportional to the abundance of these minerals. Molecular weathering ratios also may be a crude guide to former hydration of minerals in a paleosol (Table4.4).Theratioof silica to sesquioxideswillbehigh in quartz-rich paleosols with few hydrated minerals.
49
Conversely, the ratio is low in clayey ferruginous soils, which may have been full of iron oxyhydrates and hydrated clays. Salinization The disappearance of minerals into solution and the opposite effect of precipitation of soluble salts, are widespread in soils. Dissolution is a reaction in which a compound disaggregates into its constituent ions in water like a cube of sugar in tea. Hydrolysis reactions also produce ions in solution, but during hydrolysis a new insoluble product, such as clay, is produced. A common dissolution reaction in soils is the dissolution of limestone in a weak solution of carbonic acid derived from atmospheric carbon dioxide and water. In modern soilsa useful indicator of dissolution is the ionic concentration in soil water. A good indicator of salinization is the saturation conductivity of the soil. This is measured using a Wheatstone bridge and electrical conductivity cell on a vacuum-filtered extract of saturated soil paste (Klute 1994). The conductivity of the paste increases with salt content. Neither of these direct measurements is useful for paleosols, but both dissolution and salinization may leave observableeffects.Etching and pitting of mineral grains can be observed in thin sections or scanning electron micrographs of paleosols,but it is difficultto distinguish the effects of dissolution during soil formation from former hydrolysis in the soil or from comparable diagenetic changes after burial. Dissolution is more usual in carbonate or sulfideminerals than in silicates and it may be especiallyobvious in calcareous or evaporitic paleosols. Karst topography is a striking geomorphological example of limestone dissolution. The irregular ferruginized dissolution planes in limestone (stylolites)are another example on the scale of hand specimens (Bathurst 1975). Salinization in paleosols is more amenable to analysis than is dissolution. Salts common in soils of very dry climates include halite, gypsum and mirabilite. Also characteristic of very saline soils are the phyllosilicates palygorskite and sepiolite.X-ray diffractionto determine relative abundance of these relative to other minerals may provide a useful index of salinization. On burial of a soil, most evaporite minerals are subject to alteration by dissolution of salts and by dehydration of zeolites and
50
Chapter4
hydrated phyllosilicates. However, the highly alkaline conditions under which they form in soils also promote dissolution of quartz and other forms of silica, which may cement indurated horizons of a soil. Such aridland chert may be firm enough to preserve undeformed pseudomorphs of the original crystal outlines of soluble salts (Barleyet al. 1979) and brittle enough to break into stratabound brecciatedzones after their dissolution and removal (Bowles & Braddock 1963). Deformation of sedimentary layering by salt (haloturbation) as puffy grounds can also be distinctive (Malicse & Mazzullo 1996). In very ancient rocks such pseudomorphs and breccias constitute the main evidence for former evaporites. Molecular weathering ratios are not especially useful for assessing dissolution. Salinization may be approximated by ratios of alkalis to alumina, soda to potash or soda to alumina (Table4.4). Salinizationcan be indicated bysoda/potashratios greaterthanoneorthisratioincreasing up-profile. Sodium is generally a more reliable indicator than potassium because it is more soluble than potassium and also less susceptible to diagenetic alteration (Retallack 1991b).
Indicatorsof biologicalweathering The influence of organisms in soil formation is so pervasive that it is difficultto draw the line between biological and other weathering processes.This is particularly true for soil microbes, which rapidly exhaust soil oxygen and coat soil peds with slimy polysaccharides (Hiebert & Bennett 1992). It is partly for this reason that soil physics and chemistry have remained so empirical in orientation. Much can be learned by applying thermodynamic chemical models or the theory of fluid mechanics to soils,but predictivephysicochemicalmodels continue to be elusive because of complications imposed by soil biology. From an organism’spoint of view, including our own agricultural perspective, the most important biological processes are those affecting productivity of the soil. Three of these will be considered here. First, humification is a biologicalprocess by which organic matter from once-living creatures is reincorporated into the soil for further use by organisms. Second,nutrient utilization is the degree to which essential elements are used within soil ecosystems. For example,magnesium from the soil is
a vital constituent of chlorophyll, which makes plants green and allowsthem to harness theenergy of sunlight for the photosynthetic manufacture of organic matter. Third. bioturbation is the degree of soil churning by organisms. The activity of roots and burrowing animals has profound consequences for soil structure. Humification Progressive decay at the surface of modern soils can be followed from the time a leaf is shed from a tree to its attack by successive waves of microorganisms on the ground and its final disappearance as amorphous dark organic matter. Chemically speaking, this is a n oxidation in which complex reduced organic compounds are converted to more simple ones such as carbon dioxide. Physically, it is a comminution of large structures into fine-grained amorphous organic matter. In practice, however,it is a series of life activities of successive waves of decomposingorganisms. Soft watery cell contents are consumed first by a variety of soil microarthropods and worms. Then the decomposing remainder is broken down further by fungi and bacteria. Only certain kinds of microbes can break down cellulose cell walls. Very few can destroy lignin, which commonly remains as a woody leaf skeleton after the rest of the leaf material has been destroyed. A good deal of the material of the leaf is metabolized by soil organisms and then by organisms that feedonthem. Someorganicmatterisreleasedto the soil in asoluble (humic. fulvicor other acids)or insoluble form (polysaccharides).The process of humification in modern soils can be characterized by the degree of destruction of identifiable plant fragments as well as by analysis for the amount of humic or fulvicacids or amorphous organic carbon in the soil. Such analyses may involve treatment with an alkali to separate soluble and insoluble fractions of organic matter followed by treatment of the soluble part with acid to separate humic from fulvic acids. Total organic matter can be determined by the loss in weight during combustion in a furnace of a soil sample already treated with acid to remove carbonate. An alternative method for estimating content of organic matter is the Walkley-Black titration procedure, in which ferrous ammonium sulfate neutralizes chromate utilized in the oxidation of organic matter within a solution of potassium dichromate in sulfuric and orthophosphoric acid (Sparks 1996).
Soil-formingprocesses Variations in the isotopiccompositionof organic carbon within soils and paleosols may also reflect humification (Sharpenseel &Pfeiffer1997). Each of these techniques for estimating the degree of humification of modern soils also can be used for paleosols, although not always with meaningful results because of modification of organic matter during burial. Diagenetic alteration affects fine-grained organic matter more than recognizable plant fragments so that the larger pieces are an especially useful guide to the degree of humification experiencedby a paleosol. Three general stages of humification can be recognized in leaf litter and surface horizons of soilsand their fossilized equivalents. This kind of fossil leaf locality is very differentfrom those formed within the fine layers of lacustrine shales or incorporated in river and delta channel deposits. In fossil litters, leaves are mixed with roots of various kinds that pass downward into the paleosol. The plant remains show varying stages of comminution, skeletonization, nibbling by insects, clumping because of the gluing effect of decompositional polysaccharides and creasing from the activity of leaf miners and fungal hyphae. A large range of such features distinguish a fossil moder humus of the kind found under broadleaf oak-hickory forests of moderately neutral to alkaline soils. A mor humus, on the other hand, shows little evidence of humification. This kind of humus is characterized by a high proportion of intact leaves and other plant remains. A typical mor humus is the carpet of pine needles found under conifer forest. The needIes are protected from decay by abundant phenols and resins within the needles and acidic soil conditions hostile to decomposingmicrobes. A mull humus, at the other extreme, contains little in the way of identifiable plant fragments. Most have been broken down into he-grained organic matter intimately admixed with clay of the soil. Mull humus is formed by the activity of productive decomposer ecosystems, which may leave abundant evidence in the form of small ellipsoidalfecal pellets.These often dominate the microfabric of mull humus. The rich, dark surface horizons of grassland soils are a good example of a mull humus. These three kinds of humus found in well-drained soils can be recognized in paleosols (Retallack 1976: Wright 1983) and quantified in them by point-counting thin sections or estimating from fossil plant collections the proportions of amorphous organic matter, structureless plant
51
fiber and pIant fragments with clearly recognizable cellular structure. Depending on which of these predominate, fossil humus can be classified as mull, moder and rnor. A comparable division of the thick peaty surface horizons of wetland soils also can be applied to the interpretation of humification in coal-bearing paleosols. Fibric peats are those formed in such stagnant or acidic bogs that more than a third of the plant fragments retain recognizable cellular structure. Sapric peats, on the other hand, contain less than a third of recognizable plant fragments and appear structureless and fine grained in thin section because of extensive decay in periodically well-drained or alkaline bogs. Hemic peats contain intermediate amounts of partly decayed plant fiber. These three kinds of peat observed in modern peaty soils may be distinguished in coals of paleosols using techniques of coal petrography (Diessel 1992). A terminology different from this approach of soil science has been used to describe coals and also can be used to assess humification in coal-bearing paleosols. A variety of coal measure rock types can be distinguished in the field (Table 4.7).but are better characterized microscopically (Fig. 4.8).Coal is very dark to opaque in thin section, and polished thick sections examined under a microscope by reflected light are more informative. Polished surfaces are also easier to make than thin sections because many coals are brittle and fractured (Laubach et al. 1998). Mineral grains are a minor component of coal. Most coal is made up of plant fragments called macerals, which can be classified by optical and shape characteristics (Table4.8).The vitrinite maceral group is gray and yellowish white with low relief under the reflected light microscope, and light orange to dark red in transmitted light. The inertinite group is light gray to white in reflectedlight and nearly opaque in transmitted light, but not nearly so bright or opaque as pyrite. The liptinite group is generally dark gray to black in reflected light and yellow to yellowish brown in transmitted light. Each kind of liptinite maceral has a distinctive shape that can be a clue to its identication (Fig. 4.6). Point counting of thin sections or polished surfaces for decayed macerals (collinite, micrinite and semifusinite) vs. undecayed macerals (vitrinite, sporinite) can yield quantitative data on the degree of humification of a coal (Diessel 1992;Parrish 1998). Paleosols also can be analyzed for total organic car-
52
Chapter4
Table 4.7 Rock types of coalmeasures. Rock type
Description
Vitrain
Bright coal: vitreous to subvitreous luster, conchoidal fracture, brittle, may contain a few ( ~ 1 0 %thin ). (<5 mm) dullcoal bands Bandedbrightcoal: mainlybrightcoalcontainigcommon( 10-40%),thin(<S mm) dullcoalbands. even fracture Banded coal: thin (<5 mm)bright and dull coal bands in proportions of 40-60% each Bandeddullcoal: mainlydullcoal withcommon (1040%),thin (<5 mm) bright bands, uneven fracture Dullcoal: mattluster anduneven fracture, maycontainsome(
Clarain Duroclarain Clarodurain Durain Fusain Cannel coal spores Torbanite Shalycoal Coaly shale Carbonaceousshale Shale Source: Diessel(1992).
bon. Unfortunately,such analyses cannot automatically be assumed to reflect original organic matter distribution. Studies comparing modern surface soils with equivalent buried Quaternary paleosols have shown that paleosols have only a fifth to a tenth of the organic matter originally present (Retallack 199lb). Some loss of organic matter is due to stripping of vegetation and erosion of the soil surface shortly beforeburial. Moreimportant for soils that do not subside into a chemically re-
ducing zone below the water table is consumption of organic matter by microbes deep within the overlying soil. Because of these losses of organic matter after burial, the shape of the organic matter profile rather than its magnitude is more important for interpreting paleosols (see Fig. 7.3). Steadily declining organic matter with depth is the rule with grassland soils, but a subsurface accumulation may be found in woodland and forest soils (Stevenson 1969).
Figure 4.8 Broken fragments of semi-fusinite (light gray, upper left)flanked by vitrinite (gray)with fragments of fusinite (white, right) in a polishedsection viewed under reflectedlight of the upper Elkhorn Number 3 coal fromLetcher County,Kentucky,USA (photographcourtesy of J. Crellig). Scale bar represents 50pm.
Soil-formingprocesses Table 4.8 Coal macerals and their origin. Group
Maceral
Origin
Vitrinite
Telinite Collinite
Wood Decayed wood
Inertinite
Fusinite Semifusinite Macrinite
Sclerotiite Inertodetritinite
Charcoal Degradedcharcoal Coarse (1040pm) soot or decay Fine (c10pn)soot or decay Fungal sclerotia Fragmentedinertinite
Liptiite
Sporinite Cutinite Suberinite Resinite Alginite Liptodetritiiite
Sporesand pollen Plant cuticles Plant corkycellwalls Plant waxes and resins Algae Fragmentedliptinite
UV fluorescent
Fluorinite
Lenses of plant oil. decay Streaky,groundmass decay Cavity-fillingdecay
Micrinite
Bituminite Exsudatinite
53
metamorphism of the greenschist facies (Summons & Hayes 1992). Many paleosols formed in well-drained parts of the landscape or subsequently highly metamorphosed contain negligible amounts of organic carbon. Fossil root traces and burrows may provide evidence that it was once present despite very low analytical values. In these cases trace elements characteristically complexed with organic matter in soil may provide a useful proxy indicator of the former profile of organic matter. Copper (Cu), chromium (Cr), nickel (Ni) and zinc (Zn),tend to follow organic matter and clay in soils.Their variation within a profile can be normalized to trace elements characteristically stable in soils, such as lead (Pb) and zirconium (a). Phosphate (P,O,) also may show a distribution parallel to that of organic matter in soils (Smeck 1973) and a number of rare earth elements, such as yttrium (Y) and lanthanum (La), commonly follow phosphate. These various trace elements can be assayed by methods such as neutron activation analysis and inductively coupled plasma fusion spectroscopy. A growing data base of trace elements in modern soils is increasing our understanding of their abundance and behavior during weathering (Wedepohll969-78; Aubert & Pinta 1977; Kabata-Pendias&Pendias 1984).
Source: Diessel(l992).
Nutrient consumption Paleosols with low amounts of organic carbon can retain sufficient carbon so that humification can be assessed from depth functions of carbon isotopic composition (Krull&Retallack2000). Within the range of values found within a soil or paleosol profile, the isotopically heaviest carbon is in the subsurface clayey (Bt) horizon, where humification is most marked (Fig. 4.9). The isotopicenrichment (measured as 6l 3C0,g)of the Bt horizon relative to other parts of the profile is significant (2%0) in weakly developed soils (Inceptisols), more marked (So/,,) in strongly developed soils (Alfisols, Ultisols) and very marked in rice paddy soils (7-8%0). Peaty soils (Histosols) show slight depletion ( 1-3YoO) at the surface, and swelling clay soils (Vertisols) have comparable isotopic composition throughout the profile (Sharpenseel & Pfeiffer 1997). Carbon isotopic composition of organic matter is resistant to alteration after burial, until alteration of D/H ratios during
Biological productivity of soils is determined in part by the availability of nutrient elements needed for metabolism. For large plants the most needed nutrients (macronutrients) are hydrogen (H), carbon (C), nitrogen (N), oxygen (0).magnesium (Mg),phosphorus (P). sulfur (S), potassium (K) and calcium (Ca). Lesser amounts of the following elements (micronutrients) also are necessary for large plants: boron (B), chlorine (Cl). vanadium (V), manganese (Mn), iron (Fe), copper (Cu). zinc (Zn) and molybdenum (Mo). Hydrogen, carbon and oxygen are readily available from air and soil as molecular oxygen, carbon dioxide and water. There is also nitrogen as molecular nitrogen in the air, but large plants are unable to fix it in that form. Nitrogen, phosphorus and sulfur are obtained in solution as cations such as nitrate, sulfate and phosphate derived from other formsof theseelements by soilmicrobes.Theother plant nutrients are obtained by roots as ions in solution resultingfrom hydrolyticweathering (Stevenson1986).
54
Chapter 4
field observations
YOorganic
6'3C -25
molecular weathering ratios
carbon
-1:
+
-%OL CsO + MgO Na,O K,O
+
peFcent grain size
Ba/Sr
10
LLLL
50
:lay
Figure 4.9 Variation in carbon isotopic compositionand organic carbon content of a strongly developed pakosol (Sombrihumult) from theLower Triassic (245 Ma) FeatherConglomerate inthe Allan Hills,VictoriaLand,Antarctica,showingmaximally heavy isotopicvalues(613C,,,)inthe clay-enrichedsubsurface(Bt)horizon,thought to reflectmaximal humificationthere (seealso Fig. 10.1 1:fromKrull&Retallack 2000:with permission from the GeologicalSociety of America).
The nutrient requirements of animals include the macronutrients of plants together with sodium (Na) and chlorine (CI). Micronutrients of animals include also fluorine (F), silica (Si). chromium (Cr),nickel (Ni), cobalt (Co), arsenic (As), selenium (Se), tin (Sn) and iodine (I). Most of these are taken in as food but some (notably Na and Cl) may be obtained from salt licks and in some cases by eating soil (Jones& Hanson 198 5). Most of the macronutrients provided by soils form positively charged ions (cations) in solution. A good overall indicator of their abundance in soils is cation exchange capacity (CEC). This has been traditionally determinedby displacing cationswith ammoniumchloride and measuring its abundance by titration. Cation exchange capacity is a measure of freely available
cationicbases,mostlyCa2+,Mg2+,K+andNa+.Twoother cations abundant in soils (A13+and H+) generate acids and these may be assayed by similar displacementtechniques to measure exchange acidity. Base saturation is another measure of soil nutrient availability. It is calculatedas thepercentageof thetotalcations that are basic. Available phosphorus, nitrogen and sulfur also may be measured in soils using similar displacement techniques. Available phosphorus, for example, may be taken as that extracted with a 0.5 M solution of sodium bicarbonate (Sparks 1996). These techniques for soils are not suitable for determining the base status of paleosols, in which nutrients formerly available on the surfaces of weathered grains are the most liiely to have been recombined during bur-
Soil-forming processes
55
100
80 BOUND H AND AI 60
w
W 2 40
I Q
Figure 4.10 Relationshipbetween soil acidity and cation exchangecapacity(fromBirkeland 1999;reprintedwithperrnissionfromOxford University Press).
::20 W
0
3
ial. However, CEC and base saturation are loosely linked with soil pH (Fig. 4.10) and weatherable-mineral content (Nettleton et al. 1998). Extremely acidic soils (pH 2 4 . 5 ) are noncalcareous and have a high exchange acidity related largely to A13+.Both their CEC and base saturation are low. Moderately acidic soils (pH 4.5-5.8) are similar but their exchange acidity is due largely to hydronium (H+).Weakly acidic soils (pH 5.8-6.5) may have rather high CEC and base saturation (70-90%) depending on the kind of clay present. Higher CEC values in the range for each kind of mineral represent finer grain sizes (Table 4.9). Thus noncalcareous paleosols with appreciable amounts of montmorillonite are likely to have been fairly highly base saturated. Near-neutral soils (pH 6.5-8) are weakly calcareous with little remaining exchange acidity.Their CEC is moderate to high depending on the kind of clay present, and their base saturation is close to 100%.This also is true of alkaline soils (pH 8-1 1).Excess calcium and magnesium may be obviousin the form of powder and nodules of carbonate in moderately alkaline to aIkalie soils (pH 8-10). In extremely alkaline soils (pH 9-1 l),sodium dominates the exchange complex and an excess of this element may be detectable in traces of salts or soil structures such as domed columnar peds (McCahon & Miller 199 7). Although nutrients are abundantly availablein extremely alkaline soils,these are soils of dry. evaporitic climates in which water is so scarce as to limit growth. The availability of other nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur and chlorine seldom can be assessed from mineralogical observations because these nutrients are usually only minor constituents of soils that are actively recycled by microorganisms (Stevenson 1986).
5
4
6
7
8
9
I0
SOIL pH
Table 4.9 Cation exchangecapacity(CEC) of common soil materials. Mineral
CEC(mequiv.per 1008)
Humus Vermiculite MontmorilIonite Saponite Nontronite ILlite Kaolinite Hydrous oxides
150-300 150 80-100 69-86 5 7-64 1240 2-1 5 4
Sources: Grim (1968):Ross (19 89).
Rock salt, gypsum, guano phosphates such as struvite and nitrates such as sodaniter may be abundant in desert soils (Mueller 1 9 68), but these soils are often too dry to be biologically productive. Similarly, sulfur in pyrite and phosphorus in vivianite are not easily available to plants because these minerals are stable under conditions more anoxic than most organisms can tolerate. To some extent, the availability of phosphorus in paleosols formed under more normal conditions (near-neutral pH and Eh) can be approximated by the abundance of apatite and bone fragments. Phosphorus is a critical limiting nutrient in old growth ecosystems, but communities early in ecological succession are more limited by nitrogen (Vitousek et af. 1997a; Chadwick etaf.1999). Chemical methods for approximating CEC and base saturation include those already outlined as proxy indi-
56
Chapter4
cators of former pH, such as the molecular weathering ratio of bases to alumina (Table 4.4). Depletion of individual nutrient elements can be calculated from chemical analyses and bulk density measurements (Brimhall etal. 1991;Bestlandetal. 1996).Acidificationestimates from chemical data also can be aguide to nutrient status of paleosols (Table4.5).Analysesfornitrogen, phosphorus and sulfur, and for various trace elements also are useful. Phosphorus commonly is present in significant amounts (0.02-0.5%,averaging 0.05%:Dixon&Weed 1989) in the mineral fraction of soils. All three may be detectable in the organic fraction of paleosols. Utilization of iron in paleosols can also be approximated by magnetic susceptibility,which is the ability of a material to enhance an applied magnetic field. Microbial enrichment of iron in the surface of desert and Precambrian paleosols (Aridisols,Inceptisols) may produce a strong peak of magnetic susceptibility at the surface of paleosols (Soreghan et d. 1997). In forested paleosols (Alfisols, Ultisols) the utilization of iron results in lowered susceptibilityat the surface and other patterns (Oches&Banerjee 1996;Maher &Thompson 1999). Bioturbation Thedevelopment of soil structureis related to the degree of reworking of the soil by organisms, or bioturbation. From their inception in colonizing barren soil. plant communities show a slow increase in biomass, usually building to a sustainable level (Kimmins 1997). Roots, nematodes and other soil organisms break soil into smaller and smaller peds. These are then coated in clay and slimy polysaccharides so that their natural tendency to shrink and swell is subdued. The net effect of plant succession is to change a rocky or alluvial subsoil into an organic, well-structured soil. In other words, plants promote what farmers cat1 tilth. The epitome of tilth is the rich dark soil formed under grasslands (see Fig. 3.8B). The building of biomass not only promotes tilth, but preserves it from disturbance. Both soil erosion and redeposition are mitigated most effectively by the largest and most complex forested ecosystems. In contrast, desert soils show little tilth or biomass and are readily eroded. The dependence of biomass, productivity and stability on increasing rainfall is a prominent feature of modern ecosystems (Fig. 4.1 1)used widely for
rangeland management (Munn et al. 1978; Sala et al. 1988). Bioturbation thus has temporal and ecological components. The degree of destruction of relict bedding may be a guide to the development of tilth in soils during early succession. A comparative scale for the persistence of bedding developed for marine trace fossils (Fig. 4.12) can be used for the evaluation of paleosols. Another proxy indicator of tilth is the percentage of a horizontal line transect (1m is sufficient in some paleosols) occupied by drab-haloed root traces formed by burial. As already argued, these may represent the last crop of large roots in a paleosol (see Fig. 3.7).This measure has proven especially useful for distinguishing paleosols formed under woodland from those of wooded grassland (Retallack 1991a).Other root traces without drab haloes may be present as well, but these represent roots that died and decayed before burial of the soil. Unfortunately, most animal burrows in paleosols do not have haloes or other evidence of their relative age. Estimates of animal activity from abundance of burrows in paleosols is compromisedby the unknown degree of occupation of burrows and the unknown rate of destruction of abandoned burrows. Estimates from abundance of fecal pellets are compromised by similar considerations. Finally, quantification of soil structures and microfabrics can be achieved by point counting thin sections under the microscope or by measuring intersections along line transects. For example, the number of clay skins encountered along a 20 cm transect in the subsurface (Bt) horizon of a paleosol is a useful measure of cutan development (Retallack 1997e). Within aparticularecosystem the degree of bioturbationreflectsthe passageof time, but differentecosystems vary markedlyin biomassand productivity (Table4.10). and thus potential for bioturbation. The measurement of biomass and primary productivity is a difficult and time-consuming process for most natural ecosystems (Lieth & Whittaker 1975). Grasslands or agricultural crops can be mown or harvested and weighed. Because most of the biomass in such ecosystems is in their roots, these also must be excavated, washed free of soil and weighed. Determining the biomass of forests is much more intimidating and seldom has been attempted directly Usually it is estimated from empirical relationships to easily measured parameters such as diameter of
Soil-formingprocesses
Figure 4.1 1 Increased productivity of herbivores and plants, optimal soil carbon storage and mollic structure, and increased depth to calcic horizon withmean annual precipitation in modern African soils:(A) herbivore net production (g m-2yr'live weighkCoeetal. 1976); (Bfnetprimary production (g m-j y-'dry weight: Murphy 1975;Scholes&Hall1996); (C)soilcarbon (kgm->:Zinke eta]. 1984); (D)thicknessof mollic epipedon(cm);(E) depth to calcic horizon of nodular form in unconsolidated parent materials (cm) (D&Ecompiledfrom Brammer 1955;Harrop 1960;ThorpetaL 1960: Anderson 1963a.b;Thompson 1965; Scholz 1968; Bonarius & Mugai 1977; FA0 1977a; Kanaka & Mugai 1977; Mbuvi & Njeru 1977;Siderius&Muriuki 1997; Sogomo et d.1980;Fenger et d.1986; Macmillanetal. 1990;Retallack 1994b).
57
-100-
0 DEPTH OF CALCIC -100 HORIZON (cm)
tree trunks at breast height (about 1.5m above the ground). This measure can be used to estimate the height of former trees from fossil logs, using empirical regression equations (Whittaker & Woodwell 1968; Pole 1999).Forpaleosols.generalecosystemtypecan be assessed from such features as root traces, soil horizons andsoilstructures(Retallack 1997a). An ingenious approach for estimating secondary productivity, or soil respiration, has been devised using the carbon isotopic composition of carbonate within goethite of paleosols (Yapp& Poths 1994).This is based
-200 MEAN ANNUAL PRECIPITATION (mm)
on the observation that respired soil CO, is isotopically lighter (13C depleted) than CO, in the atmosphere. The curve of adjustment of these two values is near the surface of the paleosol (Fig. 4.13) when soil respiration is high. Conversely, isotopically heavy CO, diffusesfurther down into soils with low respiration rates. Common soil-formingprocesses So far in this chapter soil-forming processes have been
viewed from the perspectives of physicists, chemists and
58
Chapter4
Figure 4.12 Fossilroottraces emanating from the top (carbonaceousA horizon)of a paleosol (Aquept)and cutting acrossitsrelict beddingin theMiddleTriassic(23OMa),Tank Gully CoalMeasuresnearMt Potts. New Zealand(to1eft:fromRetallack1979,with permission from the Royal Societyof New Zealand),which is two on a schematicscale for the destruction of bedding by burrows (to right; fromDroser &Bottjer1986: with permission from the Societyof Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists).
biologists. Soil scientists have yet additional perspectives, recognizing at least 17 distinct soil-forming processes (Table 4.1 l).These processes are thought to be important for understanding the main kinds of soils
cm 0
now found on Earth (Buol et al. 1997).Most classifications of soils implicitly acknowledge these processes although they are rarely used explicitly in taxonomic nomenclature (Bockheim & Gennadiyev 2000). Only
carbon isotopic composition of mole fraction ethite g13CpD8 Cog in goethite 8 -16 -14 0.004 0.OOf
---FIT--
marine fossils mdolostone m o o l i t i c ironstone
IIIIZI]red color
a
brown color
100
bedding
Figure 4.1 3 Isotopic composition of carbon incarbonate and mole fraction CO, in goethiteof a late Ordovicianpaleosol from Wisconsin, showingsurprisinglyhigh soil respiration by adjustmentof soil to atmosphericvalues (fromYapp&Poths 1994: withpermissionfromNature and Macmillan Journals).
Soil-formingprocesses
59
Table 4.10 Productivity,stature and biomass of vegetation. Plantformation
Stature (m)
Rootingdepth (m)
Biomass (kg m-2,dry wt)
Netproductivity (kgm-’yr-’)
Aquatic stromatolites Sabkha stromatolites Microbial earth Seaweedbed Microbial rockland Polsterland Salt marsh Brakeland Marsh Pondweed Mangal Forest Wooded shrubland Dry woodland Swamp Fen Carr Dune binders Oligotrophicforest Rainforest Shrubland Bog Tundra Taiga Desert scrub Heath Fire-proneshrubland Sea-grassbed Wooded grassland Open grassland
0.5 0.5 0.001 18 0.001 0.001-0.1 1 0.001-2 1 20 10 10-100 10 10 3-100 2 3-100 0.1-2 10&100 10-100 0.5-2 1 0.1-1 1-10 10 0.1-2 0.5-2 0.3 0.5-10 0.5-2
0.001 0.001 0.001 0.1 0.001 0.001-0.12 0.001-0.1 0.001-1 0.14.5 0.1 0.001-1 1-5 0.1-1 0.5-2 0.1-0.5 0.1-0.5 0.1-0.5 0.5 1-5 1-5 0.1-1 0.1-0.5 0.1-1 0.5-2 0.1-1 0.1-1 0.1-1 0.001-0.1 0.1-2 0.1-2
0.02-0.16 0.19-0.25 0.04-0.36 0.26-8.00 0.0007-0.49 0.05-0.95 0.2 1-1.9 7 0.02-0.99 0.11-30.00 0.05-2.00 2.2046.90 10.0~5.00 0.40 4.00-2 5.00 30.00-50.00 0.36-1.82 3.11-9.81 0.10-3.00 0.99-88.20 8.00-70.00 0.09-1.20 2.504.00 0.10-5.85 2.5 5-3 5.00 0.10-1.50 0.20-2.60 1.OO-10.34 0.04-8.10 1.50-6.00 0.06-30.00
0.01-0.11 0.03-0.36 0.002-0.20 2.00-12.88 0.02-0.20 0.02-0.28 0.3cb3.70 0.002-0.05 0 . 1 4 1 5.00 0.13-2.00 0.68-2.56 0.65-2.00 0.03-0.39 1.20-1.70 1.30-2.50 0.66-1.40 0.58-0.65 0.01-0.80 0.83-3.28 0.3 1-3.50 0.016-0.40 0.22-2. so 0.07-0.87 0.40-1.40 0.05-1.20 0.10-0.40 0.60-1.99 0.33-2.29 0.40-1.40 0.06-1.50
Source: Retallack (1992a).
the six most common of these processes will be consideredin moredetail here (Fig. 4.14). Gleization Waterlogged, mucky ground with a bluish gray or greenish gray color is called gley, a Russian agricultural term. Gleying or gleization is a genera1 term used to characterize processes that produce these colors and other distinctivefeatures of waterlogged soils. Stagnant
water is exhausted of oxygen by microorganisms and under these anaerobic conditions other microorganisms reduce oxidized minerals. Microorganisms almost always are involved because chemical reduction of oxide and oxyhydrate minerals is very slow at surface temperatures and pressures (Stevenson 1986). Gleization results in the production of minerals containing iron in areduced state (Fe2+)such as drab-colored clays, siderite and pyrite (Kraus 1997, 1998).Gleization also can be associated with the accumulation of organic
60
Chapter4
Table 4.11 Soil-formingprocesses.
Process
Other name
Description
Lessivage Biogeochemicalcycling Andisolization
Argilluviation
Washing down of clay into subsurface horizons Biological enrichment of soilin base cations or other soil fertilization Formation of fertile,low-density,high-porosity, amorphous weathering products from glassy volcanic ash Formation of peat Redoximorphicalterations: particularly chemical reduction of iron and manganese as a result of waterlogging Darkening of soil as aresult of increase inorganicmatter Increased abundance to dominance of sesquioxidesof iron and aluminum Acidicleaching anddestruction of clay with precipitationof humus andiron oxides and hydroxides Leaching of base cations (Ca2+,MgL+,Na+,K+) Deep cracking and heaving of clayey soils as a result of drying and wetting Crackingand heaving of soils as a result of ground ice Accumulation of soluble salts by evaporation Accumulation of carbonates such as dolomite and low-magnesian calcite Accumulation of soda and other alkalis in clays, often producing domed-columnar peds Subsurface accumulation of soda and other alkalisin clays, but surface acidiEcation,givingbleached andtruncatedcolumnar peds Cementation with silica, such as chalcedony and opal Alteration of soil by human activity
Paludization Gleization Melanization Ferrallitization Podzolization
-
-
Hydromorphism -
Lixiviation
-
Vertization Cryoturbation Salinization Calcification Solonization
Vertisolization
Solodization Silicification Anthrosoliation
-
Alkalization -
-
-
Source: Bockheim&Gennadiyev(2000).
matter (paludization), because lack of oxygen discourages the activity of aerobic decomposer microbes. Also discouraged is the activity of large plants and animals, which form distinctive low-diversity assemblages of swamps and marshes. Gleyed soils show little evidence of bioturbation and may have abundant relict structures of parent material. The root systems of trees within them tend to be planar and very near the surface because roots require oxygen to respire. Soil pH may be rather variable. It is often acidic from the organic acids, but can be made alkaline by abundant m d c minerals or nearby limestone bedrock. The process of gleization retards mineral weathering because water flow and removal of weathering products is limited. Thus, easily weatherable minerals tend to persist in gleyed soils. Gleization reflects local waterlogging rather than wider effects of climate and vegetation evident fromother soilforming processes.
Podzoliation Translocation of aluminum and iron oxides, organic matter, or all of these, to subsurface (Bsor Bh) horizons, overall destruction of clay and leaching of exchangeable cations (CaZ+,Mg2+,K+, Na') are the main features of podzoliiation.The result is acolorful, contrastingprofile with a white near-surface (E) horizon largely of quartz over brown, red or black subsurface (Bs or Bh) horizons cemented by sesquioxidesor organic matter, or both. Podzoliiation occurs under acidic (pH <4) and oxidizing conditions in moderately to well-drained soils of humid climates. The characteristic acidic reaction can arise in several ways. Such soils preferentially form on materials initially sandy and quartz-rich in which there are very low levels of weatherable minerals that would hydrolyzeto clay. They also form under particular kinds of vegetation that can tolerate low levels of nutri-
Soil-formingprocesses
GLEIZATION
PODZOLIZATION
LESSIVAGE
FERRALLITIZATION
CALCIFICATION
61
SALINIZATION
Figure 4.14 Common soil-formingprocesses.
ent bases. Typically this is conifer forest or alpine or coastal heath. Such plants contain phenolic and other acidic substances that may be washed out of the leaves by rain (Lundstrom et al. 2000). Their leaves remain in the litter for long periods of time (in a mor humus) because decomposer microbes are sparse in these low-nutrient soils. A final contributing factor to their acidity is a cool and humid climate in which cations released by weathering are more liiely to be flushed out of the profile by groundwater rather than taken up by organisms or claysorprecipitatedas salts (Fitzpatrick1980). Lessivage Differentiationof a near-surface horizon that is leached and lighter in color (E) and a subsurface zone enriched in clay and darker in color (Bt)is the soil-forming process of lessivage. UnIike podzolization. Iessivage results in an illuvial horizon that is clayey (Bt),and also may be reddish with sesquioxidesor dark with organic matter. Evidence for clay illuviation may be sought in the form of clay
skins.These are especiallystriking in thin sections of the subsurface (Bt) horizons (Holzhey et al. 1974; Murphy 1983). Those formed by lessivage tend to have bright clay (sepic plasmic) fabric and resistant grains floating in clayey matrix (porphyroskelic).A podzoliied subsurface (Bs or Bh) horizon, on the other hand, is usually grain supported. Its grains are coated with a thin opaque layer of sesquioxides or organic matter, often with fine desiccation cracks radiating from the grains (de Coninck et al. 1974). Soils formed by lessivage also are chemically distinct. They are neutral to moderately acidic. There is little exchange acidity and it tends to be dominated by hydronium (H+) rather than aluminum ions (A13+)so that clays within the profile are more stable than in podzolized soils. Hydrolytic reactions, nevertheless, remove exchangeable cations (Ca2+,Mg2+,K+, Na') from the weatherable minerals (lixiviation).These can be washed out of the profile and over time this can seriously reduce fertility.The process of lessivage is favored on parent materials such as basalt or shale, which are rich in minerals that weather to clay. Lessivage also is
62
Chapter4
favored by vegetation such as deciduous broadleaf woodland that is low in acid-generating phenolic compounds and resins (Buol et aI. 1997). The fall of broadleaves allows recyclingof nutrients and abundant soil fauna, which is a feature of soilsformed by lessivage. Ferallitization In well-drained soils of wet tropical regions, weathering is intense and deep. It may result in thick, uniform profiles depleted in exchangeable cations. As a result, the soil as a whole is enriched in clay and sesquioxidesin the form of fine-grained, weather-resistant minerals such as kaolinite, gibbsiteand hematite. The process of ferrallitization is encouraged by a long period of soilformation and under ecosystems of great biomass and stability such as tropical rainforest (Nahon 1991).As in temperate woodland soils formed by lessivage, there may be some indication of a clayey subsurface (Bt) horizon, but it is usually thick (>1m) and has diffuseboundaries. Soil reaction is buffered by abundant clay to near neutral or mildly acidic.It is paradoxical that deeply weathered and infertilesoils should be able to support such lush vegetation as rainforest. This is achieved through a nearly complete recycling of nutrients within a biologically activeleaf litter (Sanford 1987).Therootsof tropical trees in ferrallitized soils commonly are shallow and spreading.Thesoilitself may bedeeplyand copiouslyburrowed by ants and termites, which create sand-sized stable spherical micropeds that are characteristic of these soils (Stoops 1983). Calcification
In well-drained soils of semiarid to subhumid regions only the surface of the soil may be moistened by rain before the water evaporates, is used by plants or animals,
or soaks into organic matter and clay. Thus, rainwater may not flow through the soil as it does in more humid climates.In the moist and biologicallyactivesurfacelayers of the soil, exchangeable cations may be hydrolyzed out of weatherable minerals. In subsurface horizons, however, there may be sufficient water to remove some exchangeable cations (Na', K+. Mg2+)from the profile, but not calcium (Ca2+),which accumulates as a distinctive subsurface (Bk) horizon near the depth of average wetting. Compared with ferallitization, lessivage and podzolization, the process of calcification involves little loss of nutrient cations and overall soil pH is alkaline. Soils of this kind can be fairly fertile. They support open grassland or grassy woodland vegetation with abundant soil fauna. In drier regions they support desert vegetation (Jenny 1941). Salinization In very arid climates rainfall may be sufficient to hydrolyze soluble cations from weatherable minerals, but insufficient to remove them from the profile, where they accumulate as surface crusts and crystals of salt such as halite, gypsum and mirabilite (Hartley & May 1998). Salinizationcan also occur by precipitation of salts from the top of a temporarily high water table. Irrigation of aridland soils may exacerbate this process. Salinized soils are generally well drained for most of the year and extremely alkaline (pH 9-1 1).Their high salinity discourages the growth of plants other than small-leaved, evergreen, desert shrubs or cacti. The activity of soil fauna also is curtailed under such conditions. At its extreme development in barren desert playas and coastal sabkhas, salinization may be regarded in part as a sedimentary process, but even there it involves modifications in place that are the hallmark of other soil-forming processes (Calvoetal. 1999).
Soils of the Past: An introduction to paleopedology Edited by: Gregory J. Retallack Copyright 02001 Gregory J. Retallack
Chapter 5 Soil classification
Many features of paleosols can be understood by comparison with modern soils in the same way as fossil bones are best interpreted by comparison with bones of similar modern organisms. For this reason, modern soil classifications are important for understanding paleosols. Soil classificationsdate back to the latter half of the 19th century. From the beginning, these classifications had practical aims in planning for agricultural and other land use. Thaer’s classification of 185 7, for example, was based at the highest level on the kinds of crops that could be grown and on soil texture: wheat soils (clay), barley soils (sandy clay), oat soils (clayey sand) and rye soils (sand). Like other kinds of classification in natural history, soil classification provides basic units for extending and extrapolating research results. Most soil classificationshave some theoretical underpinning in soil-formingprocesses and are designedto bring order to themultitude of combinations of differentsoil properties. Such organizational systems are more easily remembered than the raw data on which they are based. Systems of classification also become a way of thinking and communicating akin to a foreign language. The optimal classification for paleopedological comparisons would be one based entirely on observable features of profiles that are relatively resistant to diagenetic alteration. Suitable classificationsin this respect are the simplified paleosol classifications(Fig. 5.1)of Macket al. (1993),andof Nettletonetal. (1998,2000). Classifications of this kind may prove important to paleopedology in the future, but are not discussed further here for two reasons. First, few paleosols or soils have been classified by these schemes (Mack & James 1994; Parrish 1998). Second, the classification of Mack et al. (1993) is a simplification of the US soil taxonomy (Soil Survey Staff 1975. 1998), which is of greater instructional value and practical utility. Also not discussed further for reasons of scope and utility are classifications of South Africa (van der Eyk et al. 1969: Soil ClassificationWork-
ing Group 1991), Australia (Stace et al. 1968; Isbell 1996) and the factual key of Northcote (19 74). Each of these classificationsmay prove useful for particular paleosol studies, but two classificationsparticularly command attention: the soil map of the Food and Agriculture Organization (FA0 1971, 1974, 1975a,b, 1977a,b, 1978a.b. 1979, 1981, 1988) of the United Nations Economic and Scientific Organization (UNESCO) and the soil taxonomy of the Soil Conservation Service(Soi1SurveyStaff 1975,1998)of theUSDepartment of Agriculture (USDA). The FA0 classification is especially good for tropical soils (Richter & Babbar 1991).TheUSsoiltaxonomy, ontheotherhand,isbased largely on soils of temperate climate in tectonically active, volcanic and glaciated terranes (Birkeland 1999). The FA0 maps are useful for h d i n g modern soilscapes analogous to suites of paleosols.The US soil taxonomy is becoming a global vocabulary for soil science, with wide application in agronomy and environmental sciences. FA0 world map The FA0 classification was begun as an international project in 1961. Explanatory volumes and soil maps began to appear in 197 1and the tenth one (VolumeV) was published in 1981.A revised legend and classification has been issued (FA0 1988),but is of little use until the maps also are revised. The maps are continental in scale (1: 5 000 000), but the accompanying volumes make up for this lack of detail with extensivenotes on climate, vegetation, geomorphological positions, parent materials and land uses of the map units. Descriptions of individual soil profiles with analytical and site data are included as examples (FA0 1971, 1974, 1975a,b, 1977a,b. 1978a,b. 1979, 1981).It is an unparalleled global data base for comparison with paleosols. The FA0 classificationretains some traditional names such as Chernozem and Podzol, and adds new names such as Acrisol and Ferralsol.The classification is based 63
64
1
Chapter5
In S,fu M s n a r a l OXISOL~a",enr,"s
1F iElJ I l l ~ i i a l t O n(It
Inlllluble Minaral.i/Camp0unds
ARGILLISOL
s P O D 0 s 01-B
* slay
o r a a n ~ cm a t t e r "d Iron
*cCYm*I.llOn 01 Soluble Mineral.
+ , CALCISOL-CaC03
GVPSISOL-CaSDa
PDOl
on a system of diagnostic horizons and is hierarchical like the US taxonomy, Instead of many hierarchical levels, the FA0 world map has only two. These are the 'major units', which have specific soil names such as Podzol and Acrisol, and 'soil units', which are specified by adjectives, for example, Humic Podzol and Ferric Acrisol. Not all of the 2 6 major units are subdivided,but some include many subunits. The total number of soil units is 106. Such a hierarchical system implies that soils must first be classified within the 2 6 major units beforebeing assigned to subsidiary soilunits.This reflects a judgement that some features of soils-their diagnostic horizons-are more fundamental for their classification than are others. For example, Ferric Acrisols have a strongly ferruginized profile like Ferralsols, but they have less deeply weathered, base-depleted subsurface horizons than Ferralsols and this feature of Acrisols is thought to be more important to their classification than ferruginization. Hierarchical systems thus involve a series of decisions. They are also easy to remember, at least at higher levels, where there are fewer categories. A potential weakness of such a global system of classification is establishing correspondence between the regional schemes of classification and soil surveying from which much of the information was extracted. It is difficult enough to achieve consistent classification in a national soil survey by scientists speaking the same language and followingthe same philosophy of soil genesis developed at a small group of universities.This problem was addressed at length by numerous working parties on the correlation of different national soil classifications. However, not all scientists were happy with all aspects of the resulting classification for the world
IIC
rich
Figure 5.1 Flowchartfor determining soil orders in the paleosolclassificationof Macketd. (1993;with permissionfromthe Geological Societyof America).
map, and it was not adopted by the Soil Conservation Service of the USDA. The original volumes accompanying the soil maps are too detailed to afford a concise introduction to the FA0 classification, but Fitzpatrick (1980) has prepared a well-illustrated introductory summary. Only soil schematic representationscan be offeredhere (Fig. 5.2), arranged in general order of increasing development, with waterlogged soils at the end. US soil taxonomy The classification of the Soil Conservation Serviceof the USDA (SoilSurveyStaff 1975,1998)was toaconsiderable extent the work of Guy D. Smith. It was guided by him through a series of early drafts, which were widely circulated for criticism and comment. The Seventh Approximation was first published in 1960 and a definitive account appeared in 19 75 under the distinctive title of Soil Taxonomy. It continues to grow and be emended, with new editions of Keys to Soil Taxonomy appearing almost annually (SoilSurveyStaff 1998). This classification was meant to be a total break with the past, which, in the USA, was C.F. Marbut's (1935) equally monumental Soils of the United States. The word 'taxonomy' is a Greek equivalent of the more familiar Latinate 'classification'.but this isnot the only change of terminology,The whole taxonomy is based on a new and rigorously defined nomenclature for soils and soil features. The soil taxonomy also marked an attempt to classify soils on the basis of their own measurable properties rather than by the various factors thought to be impor-
Soil classification tant in their origin. This is especiallyfortunate for paleopedologybecause paleoclimates and other genetic factors in the origin of soils can be inferred from paleosols identified objectively with modern soils. The nature of diagnostic horizons and other observable soil features such as calcareous nodules form the basis of the classification. For example, recent versions of the key (Soil Survey Staff 1998)include calcic horizons at less than 1m depth, as well as climatic criteria, in the definition of Aridisols. The soil taxonomy also has hierarchical structure. Thus soils are classified first at a very general level, then assigned to progressively more limited subdivisions. At the highest level there are only 12 soil orders. This is a considerable reduction of initial choices compared with the classifications of the FA0 world map. This does not mean that the US taxonomy is less precise, because each order is divided into suborders, 63 of them in all. Each suborder is divided into Great Groups, of which there are 32 7 (SoilSurvey Staff 1998).These are divided into hundreds of subgroups, then thousands of families and finally, tens of thousands of locally named soil series. This hierarchy of subdivision is built into the nomenclature for soilsin which a distinctivesuffix refers to the soil order, a prefix to suborder and qualifiers refer to subgroups. For example, a Petrocalcic Paleustalf belongs to the order AEsol (suffix ‘alf’)and the suborder that forms in dry climates (prefix ‘ust’),the Great Group that forms on old land surfaces (prefix ‘pale’) and the subgroup that has acalcareous hardpan at depth (petrocalcic).In thisway each soilnameincludes anindication of its position in the hierarchy.The soil names are meant to be formal names that rank higher than series and so are customarily capitalized. This practice has been followed for allthesoilclassificationsin this book, although this is not done for classificationsused in other countries. The three main features of the soil taxonomy+mphasis on observable features, new nomenclature and hierarchical organization-are also the source of some difficulty. The nomenclature is like a foreign language on first acquaintance. It takes time and practice to become fluent. The emphasis on objective features in the soil taxonomy has led to much of it seeming like a legal document complete with specific stipulations, provisos and caveats. Such legalistic strictures often obscure the main idea behind the particular soil type. There are some places where the aim to abandon genetic concepts
65
was not carried far enough. Climatic conditions are the main criteria for distinguishing suborders of Vertisols. The particular information needed about how many days per year the cracks are open is difficultto obtain for modern soils, and impossible for paleosols. Another problem is inherent in the hierarchical structure of the taxonomy, which calls for selective weighting of different features of soils.The diagnostic horizons and the degree of development at which they become diagnostic are clearly specified,but these same features also may be used at lower levels to define intergrades. This can be confusing until one learns to operate strictly within the hierarchy by choosing among alternatives at each level in the precise order specified.For paleosols it may be ddficult to make decisions on diagnostic criteria at high levels and the identification should stop at those levels. Despite these drawbacks, the US soil taxonomy has an undeniable influence on soil classification throughout the world. Although the FA0 decided on its own classification, it incorporated basic ideas and terms from the US taxonomy for horizons and properties diagnostic for classification. A key (Fig. 5.3) and schematic representations (Fig. 5.4) supplement the following written summary of the US taxonomy. Full-color illustrations anddescriptions of soilsandpaleosols using this classification are available (Aandahll982;Barker et al. 1983; Retallack 1997a). Other introductory accounts can be found in most textbooks of soil science (Buolet al. 1997). Diagnostic horizons and properties Fundamental to the soil taxonomy are 19 diagnostic subsurface horizons and eight diagnostic surface horizons (SoilSurvey Staff 1998).Asurface horizoniscalled a n epipedon (plural epipedons). This does not correspond exactly to the A horizon; B horizon material is included in some cases. The mollic epipedon is a soft, dark, humus-rich, finely structured surface horizon found under grasslands, including suburban lawns. High base saturation characteristic of this horizon may be implied for paleosols if they have dispersed or nodular carbonate, abundant burrows and fine root traces, or common easily weathered mineral grains such as feldspar. Characteristic granular or crumb ped structure may be preserved in paleosols (Retallack 1997b), but organic matter is sel-
66
Chapter5
AY
A
C
C
A C
A C
R
SOLONCHAK
FLUVISOL
REGOSOL
LITHOSOL
CAMBISOL
ANDOSOL
ARENOSOL
RANKER
VERTISOL
SOLONETZ
IFA0 WORLD MAP CLASSIFICATION
Y XEROSOL
YERMOSOL
Part I of 2
Figure 5.2 Schematicrepresentationsof climate,vegetation and soil profile form of the major soil units of the FA0 SoiZMupof the WorZd(basedon data from FA0 19 71,1974.197Sa,b,19 77a,b, 1978a,b, 19 79,198 1).(For key to lithologicalsymbols,see Fig. 5.4.)Sunlcloud and hourglasssymbols indicate typical climatesand t i e s for formation. (Continued)
dom preserved at original levels (Retallack 1991b). For this reason care must be exercised in considering the requirement for a mollic epipedonto have more than 2.5% organic matter in the upper 18cm or to have a dark
Munsell color (value and chroma less than 3.5 moist and value less than 5.5 dry). Also difficultto apply to paleosols because of their likely compaction and erosion are the thickness requirements for a mollic epipedon.
Soil classification
I
GREYZEM
I ACRISOL I F A 0 WORLD
PWEOZEM
CHERNOZEM
NITOSOL
FERRALSOL
MAP CLASSIFICATION
-
KASTANOZEM
RENOZINA
1
GLEYSOL
HISTOSOL
I
Part 2 of 2
67
I
Figure 5.2 (Continued)
These are more than lOcm thick if developed on bedrockandmorethan 18cmif there areother soilhorizons within 7 5 cm of the surface or if the soil is loamy or clayey, and more than 2 5 cm if these other horizons are more than 75 cm down or if the soil is on sandy or
gravelly materials. For paleosols, adjustments to the amounts of organic matter and thickness of horizons need to be made based on estimates of burial diagenetic modification. Umbric epipedons are more organic and less finely
68
Chapter5 Freeze-thaw banding,
sand wedges and other periglacial features
n
KEY
SOIL ORDERS AND PETROGRAPHY OF CHARACTERISTIC CHARACTERISTIC HORIZONS HORIZONS
GELISOL gelic materials
relict structures such as beddinq clear relict
ENTISOL ochric epipedon
ANDISOL volcanic ash surface peal more than 40 c m INCEPTISOL cambic horizon
HISTOSOL
Ek-j
granular peds
MOLLISOL mollic epipedon
more than 10% easily weathered minerals such as feldspar mainly clay with
VERTISOL cambic horizon
ARlDlSOL calcic horizon
ALFISOL argillic horizon
nodules common less than 1 m down abundant clay, which is kaolinitic or gibbsitic
fi
ULTISOL kandic horizon
common clay subsurlace horizon iron or organic cemented sandy
OXlSOL oxic horizon
SPODOSOL spodic horizon
Figure 5.3 AsimpliEedkey to the 12 soil orders of the US soil taxonomy,emphasizing field and petrographicfeatures observablein paleosols (modifiedfrom Retallack 199 3a;with permission from the Geological Society of America).
losll3o
iosiaitlv
losIllow
AWONOWl 110s 'S'n lOSllH3A
D U
10SIXO
1OSOlSIH
iosiiin
1OSlaNV
-
10SlJlV
lOSlld33NI
losoaods
10SllN3
3 V
70
Chapter5
structured than mollic epipedons, which they most resemble. In contrast to the mollic epipedon, an umbric one has base saturation of less than 50%,and so is noncalcareous with low reserves of weatherable minerals. The anthropic epipedon may resemble a mollic epipedon, but has been altered by human use. It generally has a less finely developed structure than a mollic epipedon and may show signs of trampling or fertiliation with bone scraps or shell fragments. A high content of phosphate is diagnostic (McDowell 1988). Evidence of artifacts, campfires or hut foundations also can be used to recognize an anthropic epipedon. In theory, the anthropic epipedon also includes other human works such as roadways and railway grades, but not the plaggen epipedon, which is a soil surface created by manuring and plowing. This is a dark organic horizon with a poor structure, but in other ways similar to an anthropic epipedon. Spade or plow marks may be visible as well as pieces of brick or pottery. Like the cultivated field in which they are formed, plaggen epipedons commonly occupy square or rectangular areas of ground on moderatelylevel sites. Histic and folistic epipedons are peat layers, which in paleosols are converted to coal seams. Most peats and coals were histic epipedons, defined as waterlogged for more than 30 days per year, which encourages minerals such as pyrite and siderite. These minerals are lacking in unwaterlogged. folistic epipedons, which include deep mats of pine needles and thick composts of logs and leavesin montane soils. The thickness of apeat required for a horizon to qualify as a histic or folisticepipedon is at least 20cm. For an histic epipedon to qualify as a Histosol, peat on bedrock must be more than lOcm thick, but on sediments, low-density peat of the kind formed under Sphagnum moss must be more than 60cm thick and other kinds of peat more than 40cm thick. The original thicknesses of coaly surface horizons of paleosols can be reconstructed from field or general information on peat compaction. It should be noted that peat at the base of a thick unburied histic epipedon is already compacted compared with peat at its surface. Compaction to formcoalcan be0.03-0.71 times theoriginal peat thickness (Winston 1986; Nadon 1998). By the lowest ratio a seam of woody coal only 1.2cm thick could qualify as an Histosol. Another diagnostic criterion for histic epipedons and Histosolsis the amount of organic matter and clay.The percentage of organic carbon
(0)relative to clay content (c) is given by the following conditions:o>16if c>60,0>8+(~/7.5)ifc<60.Thus, a histic epipedon or Histosolcan have no more than 84% mineral matter and no less than 8% organic matter. In practice, this means that histic epipedons and Histosols are very dark to black with organic matter rather than gray with clay. Almost all economicallymineable seams qualify as fossilhistic epipedons and Histosols. A melanic epipedon is also dark with organic matter (more than 6% organic C) but does not qualify as histic because of mineral content, usually allophane and other amorphous minerals fromvolcanic ash. Like other parts of volcanic ash soils, melanic epipedons have low bulkdensity and highcation exchange capacity. Opaque organic matter and volcaniccomponents in thin section are good guides to melanic horizons in paleosols. A final kind of surface horizon, which accommodates most others, is the ochric epipedon. This is too thin, too light colored or not organic enough to qualify as one of the other kinds. An ochric epipedon may contain organic matter, but it is less intimately mixed with clay and may contain recognizable leaf litter. It also is more likely to be sandy, blocky or otherwise more crudely structured than, for example, a mollic epipedon. Among subsurface diagnostic horizons, the argillic horizon is one of subsurface clay enrichment. Clay skins along the margins of soil peds and root channels are evidence of clay that was washed down the profile (McCarthy et al. 1998). Clay rinds extending into fractured and partly hydrolyzed grains may be evidence of clay formation in place. Neither of these features can be duplicated by mechanical ctay infiltration after burial (Buurman et al. 1998). Cornpactional effects may obscure these features in petrographic thin sections of paleosols. Compaction also alters the degree of clay enrichment and thickness of the clayey horizon in paleosols. The per cent clay ( k ) of the subsurface horizon compared with that of the surface horizon (c) required for an argillic horizon varies with the degree of clayeyness of the soilas a whole: if Oc+ 3; if 15 < c <40, then k > 1 . 2 ~andif ; 40 < c< 100,then k> c + 8. The requirement that an argillic horizon be at least onetenth as thick as all overlying horizons also must be applied to paleosols after considering burial compaction. Kandic horizons are comparable, but not exactly the same, in per cent clay enrichment of subsurface ( k ) compared with surface (c) horizons: if 0 < c < 20, then
Soil classification
k = c + 4; if 2 0 < c < 40, then k > 1 . 2 ~if; 40 < c < 100, then k > c + 8. The main distinction of a kandic horizon is its extremely low cation exchange capacity (CEC < 16 cmol kg-I). This is mainly related to the presence of minerals such as kaolinite, boehmite and gibbsite (see Table 4.9), with very low amounts of alkalis (Na,O, K,O) and alkaline earths (MgO,CaO). Another kind of clayey subsurfacehorizon is the agric horizon,which forms after cultivation.Clay washes into the large cracks opened up by the plowed layer. These wedge-shaped masses of clay may be layered with increments of washed-in topsoil. The agric horizon has a sharp lower boundary at the base of the plowed layer and may have associated human artifacts. The agric horizon is found only in Holocene soils and paleosols. The natric horizon is a clayey subsurface horizon strongly base saturated with sodium. This can be estimated for paleosols from soda to potash molecular ratios greaterthanone(Retal1ack1997a),andfromcolumnar or prismatic structure with a sharp upper boundary at the topof the horizon (McCahon&Miller 1997). A sombric horizon is like a subsurface version of an umbric epipedon. The dark organic matter of a sombric horizon is not associated with iron and aluminum oxides as in a spodic horizon, nor is it base saturated as in a natric horizon. Sombric horizons are not found under an albic horizon. They are found mainly in moist soils of high plateaux and mountains in tropical to subtropical regions. A spodic horizon is a sandy, usually quartz-rich subsurface horizon cemented by amorphous iron and aluminum oxides, or organic matter, or different layers and combinationsof these.Thisdark,cementedhorizon must be laterally continuous and at least 2.5 cm thick. There are also requirements for the amount of iron and aluminum as extractedby ammonium oxalate, but this cannot reliably be determined for well-lithified paleosols (Retallack1991b).Thespodic horizoncan beidenti6ed in thin section by complete grain coatings of opaque, amorphous sesquioxides and organic matter, which commonly have numerous radial cracks as if they had shrunk around the grains on drying (de Coninck et al. 1974).Ortstein is an especially welldeveloped spodic horizon with more than 50%opaque cement, Spodic horizons form in humid, acidic soils in which clay is destroyed, and thus have very little clay. Red or organic clayey subsurface horizons are better re-
71
garded as argillic,oxic or sombricthan spodic (Retallack 1997d). The placic horizon is a black to dark reddish hardpan cementedby amorphous iron and manganese oxides, or by an iron and organic matter complex.They are mostly thin (2-10mm). but are rather variable in thickness (14Omm) and lateral continuity (Retallack et al. 2000). Some are brittle and break into angular segments. Others appearwavy,with twoormoreof thembifurcating and anastomosingmore or less parallel to the ground surface. In thin section they show a massive opaque cement enclosingthe clastic grains. Also, unlike spodic horizons,theyarefoundinclayeysoilsand atvarious depths in the profile other than below a sandy eluvial (E) horizon. The cambic horizon is a mildly weathered, slightly clayey or oxidized subsurface horizon more altered than underlying material, but lacking the distinctiveproperties and degree of development required for other kinds of subsurface horizons. This mild weathering is best judged by comparison with underlying parent material or saprolite.The cambic horizon may appear more massive and structured, show less sedimentary or other relict features, seem colored more yellow, brown or red as a result of oxidation,or be less calcareousor salty. Oxic horizons are so highly weathered that they have few exchangeable cations remaining (CEC < 16cmol kg-'). This is reflected in the abundance of kaolinite and other 1 : 1 lattice clays, trace amounts ( 4 0 % )of weatherable minerals, such as feldspar, and molecular ratios of bases to alumina close to zero. Although very clayey,thereisusuallylittleevidenceof clay skins.Unlike argillic horizons,which show a subsurfacepeak of clay enrichment, oxic horizons are normally deep (atleast 30 cm) and show near-constant amounts of clay with depth or a very diffuse zone of subsurface clay enrichment. Stable, sand-sized, spherical, opaque micropeds arecharacteristic of oxic horizons (Stoops 1983). An albic horizon is a light-colored and sandy layer from which clay and oxides of iron and aluminum have been leached leaving naturally light-colored minerals such as quartz and feldspar (Dumanski & St Arnaud 19 66). Clay and sesquioxides washed out of the albic horizon may be just below in an argillic or spodic horizon.The albichorizon may be just at the surface and commonly is near the surface,below a thin organic and rooted horizon. The light color of an albic horizon is
72
Chapter5
often conspicuous by contrast with overlying and underlying materials. These are the pastel shades in the upper left-hand corners of Munsell color charts (value generally greater than four and chroma less than three, with some exceptions noted by Soil Survey Staff 1998). Some soils show prominent tongues of sandy albic horizon tapering downward within the underlying clayey subsurface (argillic, kandic or natric) horizons. These are called glossic horizons. A fragipan is a dense subsurface hardpan of clay. Commonly it is mottled and has a prismatic structure. Groundwater perched on top of a fragipan forms a reduced and drab-colored surface on the hardpan and its prismatic peds (Lindbo& Veneman 1993). Some fragipans may be buried soil horizons, but others are probably horizons altered by permafrost in forested humid climates (Retallack&Alonso-Zarza 1998). A petroferric contact is a strongly ferruginized upper surface to bedrock at the base of a soil profile. Its close relationship with bedrock contacts and small amounts of organic matter distinguish it from spodic and placic horizons. Specimens from petroferric contacts are heavy, dark red, and rich in iron (often more than 30wt% Fe,O,). They are extensive in forested, or onceforested, soils of tropical and subtropical regions (Ollier &Pain 1996). Plinthite is a term for a particularly distinctiveform of laterite. Plinthite is an horizon of soil (notthe whole soil) formed in place (not redeposited) and has the unusual property of drying irreversibly on exposure to air. It is a material rich in iron with scattered red mottles of hematite and goethite in a matrix of highly weathered, light-coloredclay (usually kaolinite). Hardened, vesicular, pisolitic or brecciated laterites are not included in this definition, although these and other lateritic soil materials can be derived from plinthite by drying or redeposition. Plinthite is thought to form deep within forested soils in humid, tropical to subtropical climates (Valeton1999). A distinctive kind of subsurface horizon found in marine-influenced waterlogged soilsis the sulfuric horizon. This is either flecked with golden specks from pyrite or is a dull yellow color from jarosite formed by the oxidation of pyrite. Sulfides are fixed bacterially in these soils from sulfate. The sulfuric horizon is common in soils of mangal and salt marsh (Rabenhorst & Haering 1989; Rabenhorst 1990).
Subsurface horizons can also become cemented with calcium carbonate. These are called calcic horizons when the carbonate is in the form of powder or isolated nodules, or petrocalcic horizons when extensively cemented to form a continuous brittle layer within the soil.These soil carbonates are generally micritic and are petrographically more complex than carbonate formed during burial (Drees & Wilding 1987; Mack & James 1992). Calcic and petrocalcic horizons have complex dissolution and cavity-fillingstructures. The remaining clastic grains characteristically have nibbled edges where replaced by carbonate. There may also be displacive fabric where carbonate has filled holes left by rotated or fallen grains. Calcic and petrocalcic horizons are found in aridland soils in which carbonate is not leached effectively by available water (McFadden et al. 1991).
Gypsic and petrogypsic horizons are similar to calcic and petrocalcic horizons, but their cementing material is gypsum (Hartley & May 1998). Salic horizons are cemented with salts that are even more soluble than gypsum, including mirabilite and halite. These form in very arid climates such as the margins of desert and playalakes (Calvoetal. 1999). Entisol (incipient soil) The main feature of this order of soils is a very slight degree of soil formation, either because of a short time available or because of exceedingly unfavorable conditions. Entisols may be penetrated by roots and show some mineral weathering and surface accumulation of organic matter, but the original crystalline, metamorphic, or sedimentary features of their parent materials remain little altered by soil formation. Entisols are thus as variable as their parent materials, which range from alluvium, till and sand dunes to a variety of rocks. Their topographic settings are also variable. Most are found on young geomorphological surfaces such as floodplains and on steep slopes where erosion removes soil material as it is formed.The climatesin which they form also vary. Those forming in humid, warm climates where soil formation is rapid are younger than those formed in dry or cold climates. Early successional vegetation of grasses and other herbs and shrubs is characteristic of Entisols. Some of these soils on steep rocky slopes and along streams support trees. For paleosols the presence of root
Soilclassification traces is diagnostic of Entisols because in other respects they are little altered from their parent material. For paleosolsof deserts and of Ordovician and older geological age, before evolution of roots, a peak in magnetic susceptibility can be a useful indication of Entisols (Soreghan et al. 199 7). Some Entisols are too stony, infertile or poorly drained for cultivation. However, large areas of Entisols in alluvial bottomlands are cultivated for a variety of grain and vegetable crops, and grassed over for pasture (Buolet aI. 1997). Inceptisol (young soil) These soils represent a stage in soil formation beyond that of Entisols but still short of the degree of development found in other soil orders. They may have accumulation of clay in a subsurface horizon, but it is insufficient to qualify as an argillic horizon, which is diagnostic for Alfisols and Ultisols. Similarly, they may have organic matter at the surface but not so thick or abundant as in Histosols. Although varied as precursors of a variety of soils, a typical Inceptisolcan be imagined as having a light-colored surface horizon (ochric epipedon) over a moderately weathered subsurface horizon (cambic horizon). These soils have developed to the extent that some relict features from their parent material may be difficult to detect within the profile. These primary igneous, metamorphic and sedimentary structures normally take some time to be obliterated entirely. In humid to subhumid climates this may be only a few thousand years, and in drier climates tens of thousands of years. Inceptisols form in low-rolling parts of the landscape in and around steep mountain fronts. In sequences of alluvial terraces they form at intermediate positions between Entisols nearest the stream and better developed soils farther away from the stream. The parent material of Inceptisols is as varied as that of Entisols, but does not include vitric volcanic ash of Andisols. The climates of Inceptisols also are varied and their vegetation ranges from forest to tundra. The shrubby woodlands of pole trees that form during recolonization of disturbed ground by forest are especially characteristic, as are open woodland and wooded grassland. Many Inceptisols offer excellent natural grazing, and they can be cultivated to improve pasture and grow a variety of vegetable and grain crops (Buoletal. 199 7).
73
Andisol (volcanic ash soil) These soils of volcanic ash are equivalent to Andosolsof the FA0 (1974,1988)classification. Siliceous volcanic ash consists of bubbles or shards of volcanic glass with a high internal surface area. This weathers rapidly to a mix of amorphous weathering products such as imogolite and base-rich clays such as smectite.These soilsthus are highly fertile, rich in organic matter, and have unusually low bulk density (Tan 1984; Shoji et al. 1993). These properties, along with imogolite and smectite, are commonly altered during burial, when distinctive minerals such as celadonite and clinoptilolite form (Retallack at al. 2000). The best guide to Andisols among paleosols is at least 60%recognizable pyroclastic fragments in thin section. One exception is the highly unusual volcanic ashes of carbonatites and nephelinites, which weather more l i e calcareous beach sand than siliceous volcanic ash (Retallack et al. 1995). Andisols form in a variety of geomorphological settings in and around volcanoes.Their overall profile form is most like that of Inceptisols, and l i e these Andisols are converted to more deeply weathered soils, such as Oxisols and Ultisols, with time. Andisols are economically important, fertile soils in tropical regions, widely used for subsistence or marketgardens, terracedforricepaddyor left for bamboo forestry. Histosol (peatysoil) These are organic-rich soils with thick peaty horizons, which form in cool, well-drained localities (folistic epipedon) or low-lying, permanently waterlogged parts of the landscape (histic epipedon). The main process in their formation is accumulation of peat, which means that organic matter is produced by growth of vegetation fasterthanitisdecomposedin the soi1.Thebreakdownof organic matter is inhibited by waterlogging because the most effective microbial decomposers require oxygen and this is rapidly depleted by microbes in stagnant groundwater (Falini 19 65). Sediment or rock underlying the peat may be altered by weathering (Bennett et al. 1991), and in some cases shows weathering from an earlier round of soil formation (Gardner et al. 1988). Associated with peat accumulation may be leaching or formation of gley minerals, such as pyrite or siderite, overprinting any prior soil or sedimentary features.
74
Chapter5
Typical rates of accumulation for woody peat are 0.5-1 mm per year (Falini 1965: Moore & Bellamy 1973). Rates are much lower in swamps that are drained for a part of the year, as this allows seasonaldecomposition of peat. Rates are much faster under herbaceous vegetation such as marsh grass, moss and algae. The plant species of Histosols are usually low in diversity and restricted to suchwaterloggedsites (Retallacketal. 1996). Histosols support bog, swamp and marsh. These soils can be drained for cultivation, but are best left alone for specialty timber cutting, rough seasonal grazing or to maintain water quality. Vertiiol (swelling clay soil) These uniform, thick (at least 50cm), clayey soils have deep, wide cracks for the dry part of the year. This cracking may produce a hummock-and-swale topography (gilgaimicrorelief)and its subsurface expressionof adisrupted, festoon-shaped surface horizon (see Fig. 4.2). Pavements, fences and trees may be unbalanced by the strong shrinking and swelling action of smectitic clays in these soils. Other kinds of clay also are found, although they are less common (Paton 1974).Most Vertisols are found on materials of intermediate to basaltic composition. They may form in only a few hundred years on claystone, shales or mark of smectitic composition. It takes thousands of years for them to form on limestone,volcaniclastic sandstone and basalt. Vertisols are found mainly in flat terrane at the foot of gentle slopes.Their climate is dry enough and their vegetation sparse enough that alkaline reaction and good reserves of exchangeable cations can be maintained (Drieseet al. 2000). These soils occur in regions with subhumid to semiarid climates (180-1 5 2 0 m mean annual precipitation) with a pronounced dry season. Their vegetation ranges from grassland to open woodland. Wooded grassland is common. These soils offer excellent natural grazing, and with irrigation can be made to produce rice, cotton and sorghum.
Molliol (grassland soil) These soils have a well-developed, base-rich surface horizon of intimately admixed clay and organic matter. Abundant fine root traces and crumb ped structure
are characteristic (Pawluk & Bal 1985). Subsurface clayey (argillic or Bt), calcareous (calcic or Bk), or gypsiferous (gypsic or By) horizons also may be present, but are not definitive of the order. The characteristic surface horizon is created by fine root systems of grassy vegetation and the burrowing activity of diverse populations of soil invertebrates. Mollisols are found under grassland vegetation in subhumid to semiarid climates. Most are found in low, rolling or flat country. They form under a wide range of temperatures from the equator to the poles and in lowlands to high mountain meadows. They also form on a variety of parent materials but especially on base-rich sediments such as clay, marl and basalt. In dry regions these soils are used mostly for open-range grazing. In wet regions they are cultivated for wheat and maize and also can produce a variety of vegetable crops (Aandahl 1982). Aridisol (desert soil) These are soils of arid to semiarid regions. Rainfall in such regions is insufficient to leach soluble salts, and these soils have shallow (less than 1m deep) calcareous (calcic,petrocalcic or Bk), gypsiferous(gypsic,petrogypsic or By) or salty (salic or Bz) horizons. These cements form large nodules or continuous layers. The surface horizons of Aridisols are light colored, soft and often vesicular (McFadden et al. 1998). Subsurface horizons not cemented with salts, carbonates or sulfates may be similarlyfriable and silty, but many Aridisolshave clayey (argillic or natric) subsurface horizons. Both clay and carbonate in these soils are thought to be derived from weathering and flushing down the profile of extremely fine-grained dust of feldspar and other easily weatherable minerals, rather than the complex processes of weathering found in forested soils (McFadden et al. 1991).Aridisols are found mostly in low-lying areas because steep slopes in arid regions tend to be eroded back to bedrock andEntisols of badlands.Theparent material of Aridisols is varied. Unconsolidated alluvium, loess and till are common parent materials. Vegetation of Aridisols is sparse and includes various prickly shrubs and cacti. Aridisols can be irrigated for cultivation, but at the risk of salinization. They are best left for sparse nativegrazing(Gi1eetal. 1980).
Soil classification G e l i d (permafrost soil) Gelisols are soils with ground ice or other permafrost features within 1m of the surface. Ice is rarely preserved in paleosols (Sugden et al. 1995),but they may show clastic dikes, freeze banding or other deformations createdbygroundice(Krull1999;Retallack1999a,c).Another clue to Gelisols of the past comes from association with tillites and other glacigenedeposits (Daily & Cooper 1976;Williams 1986).Gelisolsvarywidelyin theirtime of formation from only a few years for frost heave of solifluction deposits, to millions of years on stable Antarctic land surfaces (Bockheim 1990, 1997).They form under polar desert, tundra and taiga vegetation (Bockheim 1995). Although mostly little-weathered boulder clays, Gelisols include a surprising array of histic epipedons, desert pavements, and salic and calcic horizons.These soilshave little agricultural use, and can also be difficult building sites because of problems with ice thawing. Spodosol(sandy forest soil) The diagnostic feature of these soilsis a subsurface horizon enriched with iron and aluminum oxides or organic matter (spodic or Bs horizon). In thin section these opaque cements form distinctive radially cracked, concretionary rims to abundant quartz grains (de Coninck et uI. 1974). Commonly the spodic horizon underlies a bleached, sandy near-surface (albic or E) horizon, although this is not essential for Spodosols.This has been a source of confusionbecause the broadly equivalent Podzols and Podzolic soils in the traditional sense (Marbut 193 5) have been recognized from their albicrather than spodichorizons, and albic horizons are found in both Alfisols and Ultisols in addition to Spodosols. Alfisols and Ultisols have abundant clay in their subsurface horizons, unlike Spodosols.Spodosolscan form in only a few hundred years on quartz-rich sands, but also can form by deep weathering of more clayey parent materials (Bloomfield 1981). They form on hilly bedrock or low, rolling quartz-rich sediments. Spodosols are found principally in humidclimates, in which clay and solublesalts are dissolved and washed out of the profile. Although most common in temperate regions, they also are found in the tropics and near the poles. Conifer forest is their
75
most characteristic vegetation, but they also support other kinds of evergreen woody vegetation that can tolerate low nutrient levels and high soil acidity, Spodosols are naturally infertile and used mostly for softwood timber production (Bud et al. 1997).
AUisol (fertile forest soil) These base-rich forested soils have a light-colored surface horizon (ochricepipedon or A) over a clayeysubsurface (argillicor Bt) horizon that is rich in exchangeable cations (base saturation greater than 35%). Such base saturation can be assumed for paleosols when they containnodulesof carbonateina horizon (calcicorBk) deep (more than 1m) within the profile. If these are lacking, fossilAlfisols can be distinguished from otherwise superficially similar base-poor soils (Ultisols) by the abundance of base-rich clays, such as smectite, of easily weathered minerals such as feldspar (more than 10%in the 20-200 pn size fraction) or by molecular weathering ratios of alumina/bases of less than two (see Table 4.4). The prefix ‘alf-’ of Alfisols is derived from a traditional subdivisionof soilsinto calcareous (pedocals)and noncalcareous soils (pedalfers;Marbut 193 5). This can be a source of confusion because some Alfisols are calcareous. Alfisols form on base-rich parent materials in climates and under vegetation that allow maintenance of reserves of mineral nutrients. In general, this means sediments and rocks of intermediate to basaltic composition, climate ranging from subhumid to semiarid and vegetation ranging from grassy woodland to open forest. Their topographic setting and temperatures are extremely varied, although they are not found at the poles or on high mountain tops. When cleared they may be cultivated for a variety of fruit, vegetable and grain crops(Buo1etul. 1997). Ultisol (base-poor forest soil) Thesebase-poor forest soils aresimilar to Alfisolsin overall profile form as they include a well-developed clayey subsurface (argillic or Bt) horizon. Unlike Alfisols, Ultisols are more deeply weathered of mineral nutrients. They do not include calcareous material anywhere within the profile, have low reserves of weatherable minerals such as feldspar (less than 10%in the 20-
76
Chapter5
200 pmfraction), and have molecular weatheringratios of alumina to bases of more than two (Table4.4). Basepoor clays, such as kaolinite, and highly weathered a h minous minerals, such as gibbsite, are common in these soils. Their low base status is commonlyrelated to a long period of formation (tens to hundreds of thousands of years). Over such a period they can form on a wide variety of parent materials. They form mostly on older parts of the landscape, such as rolling hills of bedrock, high alluvial terraces, and plateau tops (Markewich et d. 1990). Ultisols form most readily in humid, warm climates. There are some examples in polar and desert regions, but these are thought to be relicts of former climates more favorable to deep weathering. Their natural vegetation is coniferous or hardwood forest. Some also support wooded grassland, which can sometimes be traced to human modification of forest. Most of these soils are used for forestry In tropical regions, some produce pineapples and sugar cane. Some also are cultivated for vegetables and grain, but only after extensive fertilization.
Oxisol (tropical deeply weathered soil) These are deeply weathered soils with texturally uniform protiles, no more than trace amounts of easily weathered minerals, and dominated by kaoliitic clays or other base-poor oxides such as gibbsite or boehmite. They have only traces of easily weathered mineral grains such as feldspar, total bases in chemical analysis make up only a few weight per cent, and molecular weathering ratios of alumina/bases are 10ormore (oxic horizon). Deeply weathered mottled horizons (plinthite) also are found in these soils. A stable microstructure of sand-sued spherical micropeds of iron-stained clay is characteristic (Stoops 1983).Theadvanced weathering of these soils is due in part to their great age, often amounting to tens of millions of years. They are found mostly on stable continental locations on gentle slopesof plateaux, terraces and plains. Their development is especially favored by humid tropical climates, where weathering is most intense. They are known also in arid and cool climates, where they are usually found to be relict soils or to have formed on highly weathered sediments (Ollier & Pain 1996).Their natural vegetation is rainforest. Large areas of these soils on Precambrian rock in tropical regions are now covered with wooded
grassland, but were initiated as forested soils in the distant geological past (at least Miocene: Valeton 1999). Oxisols can be used for rough grazing and for forestry. Some produce tree crops such as cocoa, coffee, sugar cane and tropical fruits. A word of caution
These outlines and schematic representations of the FA0 and US soil taxonomy may be a useful initial guide, especiallyfor use with paleosols. However, such outlines do not do justice to these complex and evolving classifications. There is no substitute for carefully reviewing original accounts and comparing a paleosol in detail with one of therepresentative described soil profiles.The FA0 classification is particularly useful for finding, through its unique system of shorthand and indexing, comparablemodern soilscapesto suites of paleosols.For example, the Triassic paleosol of Fig. 4.9 (see also Fig. 10.11)is deeply weathered chemically,drab colored and enriched with clay in the subsurface IikeHumicAcrisols (FA0 code Ah), comparable with map unit Ah3-2bc of the Cowlitz-Chehalis lowlands of Washington state, USA (FA0 1975a) and map unit Ahl-3a south of Auckland, New Zealand (FA0 1978b). Even with excellent field and laboratory data for a paleosol it may not be possible to identiiy it within a modern soil classification. Some paleosols can be identified only to suborder level in the US classification, whereas others can be keyed to subgroup level. For example, the only AKsols with a continuous calcareous horizon at depth are Petrocalcic Paleustalfs. Fossil Vertisols, on the other hand, can seldom be identied beyond order level because of criteria involving duration of open cracks not preserved in paleosols. In addition, some soil types may be extinct, particularly those of the Precambrian formed under oxygen-poor atmospheres (Rye& Holland 1998). At first appearance, these classificationsand their terminology may seem intimidating. My recommendation is toplungeinandmemorizethe essential features of the 12 soil orders of the US soil taxonomy. With use they become familiar, and the similarities with other classifications are more striking than the differences. Facility with the language of soil classification is useful in many walks of life related to agriculture, land planning and politics.
Soils of the Past: An introduction to paleopedology Edited by: Gregory J. Retallack Copyright 02001 Gregory J. Retallack
Chapter 6 Mapping and naming paleosols
Paleopedology is a field science. Its objects of study are too bulky to be brought back into the laboratory in their entirety, and must be characterized and sampled outdoors. Field work commonly involves identifying different kinds of paleosols and establishing their relationships with each other and the enclosing sediments or rocks. These dual activities of mapping and naming are a necessary first step in the study of paleosols. Field observations determine how a paleosol is sampled and later analyzed. More sophisticated indoor studies refine or test hypotheses developed in the field, but seldom supplant them. Thus, it pays to have a logical plan for mapping and naming paleosols. and this plan will vary according to the aims of the study. Three common aims are considered in this chapter: paleoenvironmental interpretation of paleosols, use of paleosols as stratigraphic marker horizons and portrayal of paleosols on geologicalmaps. In the face of a burgeoning scientific nomenclature for different kinds of fossils,rock layers and soils, it may fairly be asked whether there is a need to map and name paleosols. The formal mapping and naming of fossils, rocks and soils often becomes an end in itself. Their nomenclature is regulated by such long-winded and legalistic documents as the International Code of BotanicalNomenclature(Vossetal.1983)andlnternational Code of Zoological Nomenclature (International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature 1995), the International Stratigraphic Guide (International Subcommission on Stratigraphic Classification 1994), numerous local stratigraphic guides (North American Commission on Stratigraphic Nomenclature 1982) and the USDA Soil Survey Manual (Soil Survey Staff 1993)..Thenamed entities are redefined, emended and debated. If this is the result of naming and mapping, should not paleosols continue to be studied on an informal basis? It is also artificial to bestow biological binomial Latin names on such things as fossil tracks and trails (Bromley 1996). and on the acid-resistant walls of plant spores and
pollen (Traverse 1988).Yet experience in ichnology and palynology has shown that common names, acronyms or descriptive alphanumeric terms have failed to yield replicable results. Names that are concise, constructed along a pre-established set of rules, and based on real and well-illustrated examples are needed. In this way, a large data base that is internally consistent can be built and r e h e d over the years by different investigators. Mapping and naming of paleosols has not yet been legalizedto theextent of fossils,rocks and soils, but there are signs that this is happening. The North American Stratigraphic Code (North American Commission on Stratigraphic Nomenclature 1982) includes provision for formal naming of paleosols as stratigraphic marker horizons. Perhaps there will follow a national registry for such names, as is maintained by the US Geological Survey for stratigraphic names (searchable online at http://ngmdb.usgs.gov/Geolex).Other approaches to paleosol mapping are accumulating in scientific publications. These other names must be regarded at present as informal. The distinction between formal and informal names can be indicated by capitalization. The Sangamon Geosol, for example, is a formal name, whereas the type Gleska clay paleosol is not. Until there is an officially endorsed code for naming paleosols there is scope for a variety of approaches to mapping and naming them.
Paleoenvironmentalstudies My own interest in paleosols has been concerned with interpreting ancient environments of soil formation. Each type of paleosolrepresents adistinct paleoenvironment. There are no special difficulties in naming a paleosol in this context if it involves a single profile at a geological unconformity. If work is extended to characterize variation in paleosols along an unconformity or in numerous paleosols interbedded with fluvial deposits, then many distinct names may be needed in a small
77
78
Chapter6
area. In a study of paleosols in Eocene-Oligocene (39-29 Ma)volcaniclasticalluviumof thePaintedHills, central Oregon, 435 successive paleosols of 1 7 kinds were recognized in 430m of stratigraphic section (Retallacketal. 2000).In theSiwalikGroupof Pakistan, India and Nepal, there is on average a paleosol for each meter of its 6 km thickness (Retallack 1991a; Quade et ul. 1993, 1995; Tanaka 1994. 1997). For paleoenvironmental studies of such sequences a separate name is not needed for each paleosol, only for each kind of paleosol insofar as it represents a discrete subenvironment of past landscapes. Such studies are similar in concept to modern soil mapping except that the soils of many superimposed landscapes must be named and mapped rather than those of just one soilscape. Although modern soil mapping units were not designed with paleosols in mind, they are serviceable for paleopedological studies. The soil units defined by the US Department of Agriculture (Soil Survey Staff 1993) are used for naming and mapping variations in soil across the landscape (Fig. 6.1). In addition to numerous published soil surveys, data on soil series are now searchable online (at http://www.statlab.iastate.edu/soils/osd). Soilscapesare considered to consist of a number of irregularly shaped polypedons that interlock like a large mosaic (see Fig. 2.1). A pedon is the smallest volume of soil that can be recognized and identified. It may be a substantial area of soil (10m2 or so) if soil horizons are laterallyvariablein thickness. Usuallyapedon is the profile visible in a small pit (some 1m2 or less in area). The task of the soil mapper is to compile information from a number of soil pits so that areas of substantially similar soil may be delimited from areas with different soils. The basic unit of mapping is a soil series,which includes one or more polypedons scattered over the landscape. A soil series is based on field and laboratory characterization of a particular pedon and named after a nearby geographical locality,e.g. the Bellpine Series (Fig.6.1). An individual pedon can be named for the texture of its surface horizon, e.g. the Bellpine silty clay loam. With local experience,this name conjuresup an image of a thick, red, clayey soil (a Xeric Haplohumult) that forms on moderately sloping,well-drained hills of marine volcaniclastic sandstones under mixed conifer forest dominated by Douglas fir (Pseudotsugumenziesii). This soil mapping system also allows for natural variation and relationships between soils. Minor fea-
tures of the soil such as small ferruginous nodules may be used to define soil variants, such as the Bellpine silty clay loamnodularvariant.Slight variations in thickness of horizons may be used to define phases, such as the Bellpine silty clay loam eroded phase. Soil series also can be grouped into larger units or associations. The Bellpine Series, for example, is part of an association of soil series formed on moderately sloping sedimentary bedrock. These are different from alluvial soils of basaltic gravel in the nearby valley bottoms. For paleosols the problem of mapping and naming is conceptually similar. Paleosols may be characterized as they are encountered in a stratigraphic sequence by examining cliff outcrops, excavating badlands or logging d