DEVELOPMENTS IN SEDIMENTOLOGY 30B
SEDlMENTARY STRUCTURES THEIR CHARACTER AND PHYSICAL BASIS
VOLUME II
FURTHER TITLE...
53 downloads
1637 Views
42MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
DEVELOPMENTS IN SEDIMENTOLOGY 30B
SEDlMENTARY STRUCTURES THEIR CHARACTER AND PHYSICAL BASIS
VOLUME II
FURTHER TITLES IN THIS SERIES VOLUMES 1 , 2, 3, 5, 8 and 9 are out of print 4 F.G. T I C K E L L THE TECHNIQUES O F SEDIMENTARY MINERALOGY 6 L. V A N D E R P L A S THE IDENTIFICATION O F DETRITAL FELDSPARS S. D Z U L Y N S K I and E.K. W A L T O N I SEDIMENTARY FEATURES O F FLYSCH AND GREYWACKES 1 0 P.McL.D. DUFF, A. H A L L A M and E.K. W A L T O N CYCLIC SEDIMENTATION 11 C.C. R E E V E S Jr. INTRODUCTION T O PALEOLIMNOLOGY 1 2 R.G.C. B A T H U R S T CARBONATE SEDIMENTS AND THEIR DIAGENESIS 13 A.A. M A N T E N SILURIAN REEFS O F GOTLAND 1 4 K. W. G L E N N I E DESERT SEDIMENTARY ENVIRONMENTS 1 5 C.E. W E A V E R and L.D. P O L L A R D THE CHEMISTRY O F CLAY MINERALS 1 6 H.H. RIEKE 111 and G.V. C H I L I N G A R I A N COMPACTION O F ARGILLACEOUS SEDIMENTS 11 M.D. PICARD and L.R. HIGH Jr. SEDIMENTARY STRUCTURES O F EPHEMERAL STREAMS 18 G.V. C H I L I N G A R I A N and K.H. W O L F COMPACTION O F COARSE-GRAINED SEDIMENTS 19 W. S C H W A R Z A C H E R SEDIMENTATION MODELS AND QUANTITATIVE STRATIGRAPHY M.R. W A L T E R , Editor 20 STROM ATOLITES 21 B. V E L D E CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS IN NATURAL AND SYNTHETIC SYSTEMS 22 C.E. W E A V E R and K.C. BECK MIOCENE OF THE SOUTHEASTERN UNITED STATES 23 B.C. HEEZEN, Editor INFLUENCE O F ABYSSAL CIRCULATION ON SEDIMENTARY ACCUMULATIONS IN SPACE AND TIME 24 R.E. GRIM and N . G U V E N BENTONITES 25A G. L A R S E N and G.V. C H I L I N G A R I A N , Editors DIAGENESIS IN SEDIMENTS AND SEDIMENTARY ROCKS 26 T. SUDO and S. SHIMODA, Editors CLAYS AND CLAY MINERALS O F JAPAN 21 M.M. M O R T L A N D and V.C. F A R M E R INTERNATIONAL CLAY CONFERENCE 1 9 1 8 28 A. NISSENBAUM, Editor HYPERSALINE BRINES AND EVAPORITIC ENVIRONMENTS 29 P . T U R N E R CONTINENTAL RED BEDS T. SUDO, S. SHIMODA, H . Y O T S U M O T O and S. A I T A 31 ELECTRON MICROGRAPHS O F CLAY MINERALS 32 C.A. N I T T R O U E R . Editor SEDIMENTARY DYNAMICS O F CONTINENTAL SHELVES
DEVELOPMENTS IN SEDIMENTOLOGY 30B
SEDIMENTARY STR UCTUR ES THEIR CHARACTER AND PHYSICAL BASIS VOLUME II
JOHN R m L m ALLEN, F.R.S. Professor o f Geology, University of Reading, England
ELSEVIER SCIENTIFIC PUBLISHING COMPANY Amsterdam - Oxford - New York 1982
ELSEVIER SCIENTIFIC PUBLISHING COMPANY Molenwerf 1, P.O. Box 211,1000AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Distributors for the United States and Canada: ELSEVIER/NORTH-HOLLAND INC. 52,Vanderbilt Avenue New York, N.Y. 10017
L i b r a r y of Congress Calaloging i n Publiralinn D a l a
Allen, John R. L. Sedimentary structures. (Developments in sedimentology ; 30A-30B) Includes bibliographies and index. 1. Sedimentary structures. 'I. Title. 11. Series. &E472.A44 551.3'05 81-12561 ISBN
ISBN
0-444-41935-7(v. 0-444-41945 -4 ( v .
30A) 30B)
MCR2
ISBN 0-444-41945-4 (Vol. 30B) ISBN 0-444-41238-7 (Series) Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, 1982 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, P.O. Box 330, 1000 AH Amsterdam, The Netherlands 0
Printed in The Netherlands
V
INTRODUCTION TO VOLUME I1 As the General Preface accompanying Volume I contains an introduction to the work as a whole, it is only necessary for me here to outline the scope of the second volume. Volume I1 is about sedimentary structures found in relatively complex physical settings, where groupings or hierarchies of features are often of most interest, and more emphasis is placed than in the first volume on cohesive as opposed to cohesionless beds. Secondary currents can exist for a number of reasons in boundary-layer flows, giving rise to flow-parallel sedimentary structures on both kinds of bed. A type of secondary flow arises where river or tidal streams occupy curved channels, with the result that definite vertical and horizontal sequences of sedimentary structures are formed. Flow separation is a phenomenon associated with several kinds of sandy bedform and has a significant though not yet completely understood influence on sedimentation to their lee. Closely related physically is the upward-acting two-phase jet, deposition from which gives rise to sand volcanoes. Separated and secondary flows combined in complex and unpredictable ways are called into being by objects placed on the boundary of a flow. The result is local patterns of scour and deposition expressed as current crescents or drifts. Flute marks in mud beds, and Kurren on limestone and other soluble or partly soluble rock surfaces, record a process of mass transfer in which flow separation in certain instances plays a decisive role. An important group of sedimentary structures-soft-sediment deformations -arise shortly after (sometimes during) deposition, and reflected the deformable nature of freshly accumulated sediment, once a liquid-like state has been created through either liquefaction or fluidization. Distinctive combinations of sedimentary structures, representing complex and not yet fully understood phenomena, form when gravity currents transport sediment over the ocean floor or the slopes of a volcano. The littoral zone, where wind-waves interacting with the bottom are the dominant agent, provides another complex and only partly known setting for a Yariety of structures. The possible importance of storm-related currents in forming a species of graded bedding in shallow-marine sediments is attested by the increasing number of claims from workers in the stratigraphic record. However, as the sedimentological aspects of storms have been little studied, as opposed to their engineering implications, an important and potentially fruitful field of enquiry lies open. The final chapter in Volume I1 is essentially a miscellany, in which a variety of unrelated themes are pursued. Here can be found accounts of, for example, tool marks, adhesion ripples, mud waves, shrinkage cracks and ptygmatic folds. Reading, May 1980
J.R.L. ALLEN
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
VII
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION T O VOLUME I1
....................................
Chupter 1. LONGITUDINAL BEDFORMS A N D SECONDARY FLOWS Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General character and effects of secondary flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Causes of secondary flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Instability of a fluid in axisymmetric motion . . . .................... Inflectional instability of a rotating fluid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Asymmetry of flow boundaries (turbulent flow) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Superposed “immiscible” fluids of contrasted density . . . . . . . . . . . ... Thermal convection in a sheared fluid ............................ Langmuir circulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....... Sand ribbons in aqueous currents . ................................ ..................... O n smooth beds in streams . . . . . . . . . . . . . s ............... On rough beds in streams and beneath ebbing t Sand ribbons in the marine environment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... Sand ribbons on continuous beds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fossil record . . ....... ................................ Sand ribbons in aeol ronments ............................... Erosional grooves and ridges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ River and related aqueous environments . . ... ............... Tidal environments . Deep-sea environments . . . . . . . Deserts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Longitudinal desert dunes . . . . . . . . Tidal current ridges . . . . . . ............. Ridge-and- furrow moulds . . . . . . . . Wave-related furrows and ridges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............. Wave-related gravel stripes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Spur-and-groove . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. Glacial flutings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Trough banding in layered igneous roc ........... Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
V
I 2 5 5 7 8
13 17 17
21 23 23 24 25
43 47
52
Chupter 2. FREE MEANDERING CHANNELS A N D LATERAL DEPOSITS
................ Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fluvial and tidal meanders . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Meander settings . . . . . .... ................... Analysis and description .... ................... Hydromorphological relationships . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Flow processes in meanders and channel bends . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Superelevation of the water surface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... ............................ Secondary flow . . ryflow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laboratory and field ns o Theories of meandering ....... ........ .................. Sedimentation processes in meanders and channel bends . . . . . . . . . . . .
53
71 71 72 79
VIII Sediment particle equilibrium on a point bar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Transverse shape of point bars and meandering channels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Processes and rates of meander growth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Evolution of meander loops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain size and bedform on point bars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Lateral accretion structures and deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
80 83 86 88 91 94 100
Chupfer 3. AN OUTLINE O F FLOW SEPARATION 101 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Separation in internal and external flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 Streamline mappings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Rollers and vortices: closed and open separation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 Separation in two dimensions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 Externalflows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 107 C a v i t y f l o w s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. .. .. .. ........... .. .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . . . . .. .. .. .. .. .. ... 1 0 7 107 S t e p s a n d w a l l s. . . . . .. ..... .. . . .. ..... .. . . . ..... .. . . . .. ..... . . . .. ..... .. . . .. ..... .. . . .. ... . 1109 09 Axisymmetric flows .. ....................................... 114 Separation in three dimensions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 ................... ...................... 114 External flows 107 C a v i t y f l o w s . . . .. .. ......... .. .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . . . .. .. .. .. .. ........... .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . . 1 0 7 115 Steps and related shapes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................... 116 Pressure and stress in low-speed separated flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Distribution of temporal mean values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Pressure fluctuations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120 Vortex-production and turbulence in low-speed separated flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Rolling up of a free shear layer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 125 Velocity fluctuations and Reynolds stresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Flow separation at high speeds . . ................................. 127 128 Axisymmetric turbulent jets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131 Chupprer 4. SEDIMENTATION FROM JETS A N D SEPARATED FLOWS ............................................... Introduction . . Particle free falling velocity in the presence of turbulence ..................... Sedimentation from jets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sand volcanoes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sedimentation from separated flows with normal gravity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain size and concentration in the approaching boundary layer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grain dispersal beyond the crest of the bed feature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Avalanching in the lee of ripples. dunes. bars and deltas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Grading in avalanche deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sedimentation in the far lee: shell-pebble lags and ripple fans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Geometry and structure of lee-side deposits . . . . . . ............ ..... Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
133 134 135 137 141 141 142 143 148 152 158 168 171
Chuprer 5. FLOW A R O U N D A BLUFF BODY: OBSTACLE MARKS Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General features of bluff-body flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Two-dimensional flow past a bluff body . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Two-dimensional flow past a surface-mounted impermeable bluff body . . . . . . . . .
173 174 174 174
IX Two-dimensional flow past a surface-mounted permeable body . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Surface-mounted bluff bodies in oscillatory and rotary flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Biuff bodies in planetary boundary layers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General implications for sedimentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Controls on the character of obstacle marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Current crescents in aeolian environments . . . . . . . . . . . . Current crescents in aqueous environments . . . . . . . . ...... River and shallow tidal flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sand beaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tidal seas and the deep ocean . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Current shadows in aeolian environments . . . . . ........................ . Impermeable bodies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Permeable obstacles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................... Current shadows in aqueous environments . . . . . ....................... Scour-remnant ridges . ....................................... ......................... Scour features in comple ts Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
194 194 197 197 197 200 200 203 205
Chuppter 6. HEAT A N D MASS TRANSFER: ICE DUNES. KARREN. A N D RELATED FORMS ........... Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Regimes and mechanisms of heat and mass transfer . . . . . . . . . . . ......... ......... Controls on heat and mass transfer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Coefficients and parameters . . ................................. Analogy between momentum, heat and transfer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laminar boundary layer on a flat surface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Turbulent boundary layer on a flat surface . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. Laminar flow in a conduit . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................ Turbulent flow in a conduit . . . . . . . . Free convection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................ Heat and mass transfer in separated low-speed flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................... Heat and mass transfer in high-speed flows . . Instabilities accompanying mass or heat-with-mass transfer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... .................... Classification of Kurren . . . . . . . . . . . . First-order Kurren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................... Fhhkurren . . . . . . .... .................................. Kluftkurren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Spitzkurren ................................................ ................. Second-order Kurren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Solution basins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Trittkurren . . . . . . . . . ...... ..................... Rillenkurren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rinnenkurren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. ............. Rundkurren . . . . ........................................ Miiunderkurren and related forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... Roofpendants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cockling . . . . . . . . . . . ..... ................. Transverse Kurren and re1 ............................. Cave flutes and scallops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Iceripples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Solution ripples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dirt polygons . . . ........ ............................
207 208 210 210 213 214 214 215 215 216 217 218 219 222 224 224 226 228 230 230 233 233 235 235 238 240 241 242 242 245 246 249
i80 181
182 183
191
Structures related to high-speed flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cross-hatching . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ring waves on tektites and meteorites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pits (regmaglypts) on meteorites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
249 249 250 250 251
Chuppter 7. FLUTE MARKS. M U D RIPPLES. S I C H E L W A N N E N AND POTHOLES Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Parabolic flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Spindle-shaped flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... Comet-shaped flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Asymmetrical flutc marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Patterns of flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mud ripples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................... Potholes . . . . . . . . . . . Sichelwunnen . . . . . . . . ................................... Origin of flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Two pertinent observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An elementary theory of flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................................... Mass-transfer analogy . Flute marks on mud beds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A model for flute marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Origin of mud ripples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Origin of potholes . .. ......................................
253 253 253 255 257 258 259 259 259 261 264 267 267 268 272 277 281 286 288
Origin of Sichelwannen........................................... 289 Summary ....... ............................... 290
.
Chuppter 8. LIQUIDIZATION. LIQUIDIZED SEDIMENT AND T H E SEDIMENTATION O F DENSE PARTICLE DISPERSIONS Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. Varieties of liquefaction . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. Static liquefaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dynamic and cyclic liquefaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General effects of earthquakes and related disturbances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Laboratory studies of cyclic liquefaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Factors influencing cyclic liquefaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Estimation of liquefaction potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Varieties of fluidization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Stationary fluidization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Regimes of fluidization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Minimum fluidization velocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bedexpansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .............. ............ Polydisperse systems . . . . . . . . . . . Bulk self-fluidization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................... Grain self- fluidization . . . . . . . . . . ............................... Apparent viscosity of liquidized sedime Controls and means of measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Non-fluidized dispersions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................ Fluidized beds . .
293 295 296 298 298 300 302 304 305 306 306 310 312 314 315 317 321 321 321 325
XI Sedimentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Monodisperse systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Polydisperse systems . . ................................... Graded systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Fluidization after liquefaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chuppter 9. SOFT-SEDIMENT DEFORMATION STRUCTURES Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kinematics and dynamics of soft-sediment deformation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Classification of soft-sediment deformation structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Deformation structures related to gravitationally unstable vertical profiles of bulk density . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Convolute lamination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Loadcasts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pseudo-nodules and ball-and-pillow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Heavy mineral sags and drops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ Deformation involving an ephemeral layer: passively deformed beds . . . . . . . . . . . Deformation involving an ephemeral layer: dish structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Deformation structures related to non-uniform confining loads . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Load-casted ripple marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Folds related to the lateral spread of sand mounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Deformation structures related to a downslope b force component . . . . . . . . . . . . Sheet slumps formed from multilayers . . . . ......................... Deformed cross-bedding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Deformed cross-bedding related to fluid drag . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Interpretation of simple deformed cross-bedding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Interpretation of more complex forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . ..... ............................... Chupprer f0. STRUCTURES A N D SEQUENCES RELATED T O GRAVITYCURRENT SURGES Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... Dissipation of gravity-current surges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Turbidites and the Bouma sequence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vertical patterns . . . . ........ .......................... Patterns in the direction .................................... Interpretation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pyroclastic flow. ground surge and base surge deposits . . ............. Extent and grading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............. Radial grooves . ............................................ Plane beds and par 1 stratification . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sand waves and cross-bedding . . . . . ............................ Other structures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . .... ........................ Chuprer If . COASTAL SAND BARS A N D RELATED STRUCTURES Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Morphology of the barred beach and nearby offshore . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Longshore bars and troughs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
327 327 330 334 337 340 341
343 344 348 340 349 354 350 364 366 367 375 375 378 380 380
389 392 393
395 396 401 401 405 412 417 417 419 422 431
433 434 435
XI1
....... Form and behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Controls on longshore bars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Minor sedimentary structures associated with longshore bars and troughs . . . . . . . . . Intertidal bars and troughs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... Submerged bars and troughs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Transverse bars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................... Beachcusps . . . . ........................... Character and d ......................
435 440 446 446 450 452 453 453 C o n t r o l s o n b e a c h c u p s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 455 . 457 Theories of beach cusps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 460 Internal structure of beach cusps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 461 Beach lamination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... .. 461 Morphological and dynamical background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 462 Effects on the scale of waves . . . ...... ............ 464 Effects on the tidal scale . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... 466 Effects on a storm or seasonal time-scale . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 468 ........... Beach lamination in the stratigraphic record 469 Summary . .......................................
Chupter 12. STORM SEQUENCES IN SHALLOW WATER Introduction ............................ . Two-dimension wind effects .... .......... Wind set-up . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... Currents associated with the set-up . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... Natural surges and wind-induced currents . .......... Complex models of wind effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dependence of wind stress on wind speed . ............... A model of storm sedimentation in shallow waters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Qualitative description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... Aspects of a quantitative model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Storm sand-layers in modern sedimentary environments . . . . . . . . . . . Storm sand-layers in the stratigraphic record . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Description of examples . . . . . . . . .... ............ Comparison with the model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . ............................ Chupprer 13. MISCELLANEOUS SEDIMENTARY STRUCTURES ............................ Introduction Rill marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......... Toolmarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General . . . . . . . ... ................. Drag marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Roll marks ............................ Prod marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... Tumble marks ............................ Skim marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................... Marks related to near-approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanics of tool marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... Scratch circles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Corrasion beneath the wind . . . . . ................ Swash and foam marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Adhesion and rain-impact ripple marks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
471 472 472 477 481 483 485 487 487 491 493 496 496 504 505
507 509 509 511 516
525 529
XI11 Cavernous sand. sand holes. and sand domes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mud waves on the deep-ocean floor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Distribution and character . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Origins of mud waves . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Shrinkage cracks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Character and distribution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanics and controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sheet-like sedimentary intrusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ptygmatic folds in desiccation-crack infills and sedimentary dykes . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
535 538 538 541 544 544 550 554 556
REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
561
...............................
645
SUBJECT INDEX (for Volumes I and 11)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1
Chapter 1 LONGITUDINAL BEDFORMS AND SECONDARY FLOWS INTRODUCTION
With the exception of parting lineation and its relatives, the bedforms discussed in Volume I all have a dominant flow-transverse orientation; many of these, for example, dunes and trochoidal wave ripples, are associated with interactive separated flows. There are other bedforms elongated parallel with the mean motion, including longitudinal desert dunes, sand ribbons on sea and river beds, and various linear forms apparently dependent on wave-action at the strand. These longitudinal features all seem explicable in terms of secondary flow, that is, the motion in which a transverse circulation is superimposed on the primary longitudinal flow of the fluid, the streamlines assuming a corkscrew form (Vol. I, Chapter 1). So long as the mean motion remains stable over time, the secondary flow is itself stable and independent of time. Typically, the spiral currents occur in pairs; a longitudinally oriented cell of fluid (roll or vortex) with an internal circulation in one sense is juxtaposed with a parallel cell in which the circulation is oppositely directed. Since we are concerned with explaining a category of bedforms in terms of these vortices, each group of cells must be bordered on at least one side by a stationary boundary. On the bed there must be lines parallel with the mean flow along which streamlines separate from the bed, and other lines, also flow-parallel, along which streamlines reattach themselves. Finally, if the current is divided into more than one pair of cells, the separation and reattachment lines must alternate transversely across the flow. Evidently secondary flows share some kinematic features with the separated flows induced by flow-transverse bedforms. Secondary flows, however, do not invariably require changes of longitudinal bed slope for their formation. Many of the bedforms coupled with secondary flows are merely visualizations of flow structures having an independent origin. The same cannot be said of transverse bedforms, the character of which in large part depends on strong interactions between flow, bed shape, and bed material. That many secondary flows are independent of bed material and shape is further emphasized by the wider range of circumstances under which longitudinal bedforms are found. They appear on beds composed wholly of cohesionless sediment, on surfaces partly cohesive and partly cohesionless, and on boundaries wholly formed of cohesive material such as rock or stiff mud. The transverse features discussed above can only arise where cohesionless sediment is available in large amounts. Secondary flow has many causes, ranging from the effects of channel
2
curvature or side walls, to the combination of horizontal shear with density instability, to complex wave phenomena. The consequent flow patterns are rather similar and, at present, it is rarely possible to infer the fundamental cause from the characteristics of the forms themselves. The context often yields the most useful clues.
GENERAL CHARACTER AND EFFECTS OF SECONDARY FLOWS
Figure 1-1 shows the kinematic structure of a typical secondary flow, as developed above a flat surface in a steady uniform rectilinear boundary-layer flow. Vortices in which the circulation is to the right of an observer looking downstream alternate transversely with those in which the circulation is to the left. Longitudinal separation lines occur where the limiting streamlines converge, and reattachment lines where they diverge. Reattachment and separation lines alternate transversely at a regular spacing, the transverse distance between any two consecutive lines of each type defining the characteristic vortex wavelength, usually about twice the vortex thickness or width. The fluid in each vortex cell follows a spiral path, of a pitch measured at the cell boundaries commonly 50-150 times the cell width or thickness. Hence the deviaton angle S of a limiting streamline from the direction of the mean flow (Fig. 1-1) may be no more than 10-15" at its greatest, and in some cases much less. Vertically above each separation line, where the fluid ascends from the bed, the streamwise velocity component increases relatively gradually away from the boundary. The boundary shear stress along separa-
Fig. 1 - 1 . General character of a boundary layer with secondary flow.
3
tion lines is therefore less than average on the bed. Where the fluid is descending towards reattachment lines, the velocity gradient is relatively steep and the boundary shear stress exceeds the average. At stations between separation and attachment lines, the boundary shear stress T~ tangential to a limiting streamline can be resolved into a downstream component T~ and a transverse component T ~ .Generally r2 is at most a small fraction of T~ and, similarly, the transverse component of velocity within the vortex is seldom comparable with the streamwise value. The ratios of these components mid-way between separation and reattachment lines are measures of the strength of a secondary flow. The sedimentological implications of this motion (Fig. 1-1) may be analysed in terms of at least three idealized cases, distinguished by the amount of cohesionless sediment transportable as bedload available to the flow and the properties of the boundary supporting this load. These cases are: (1) cohesionless sediment small in amount and boundary undeformable, (2) entire boundary underlain by cohesionless sediment, and (3) cohesionless sediment small in amount but boundary deformable as the result of corra-
Fig. 1-2. Implications of secondary flow for sediment transport and transfer. a. Bed material drifted in small quantity 0ver.a rigid surface. b. Effect of secondary flow on a continuous mobile sand bed. c. Effect of secondary flow carrying a,moderate quantity of bed material over a cohesive deformable surface. d. Effect of secondary flow carrying a small amount of bed material over a cohesive deformable surface.
4
sion, fluid stressing, or plastic flow under the action of the flow forces. In the first (Fig. 1-2a), longitudinal bands of sediment should accumulate along separation lines, leaving clear lanes along the reattachment lines between, the band spacing or wavelength equalling the wavelength of the secondary flow. In justification, we can see from Fig. 1-1 that the transverse component T~ of the bed shear stress, where non-zero, is everywhere directed towards the nearest separation line. Hence any bedload particle which strays near a reattachment line will be gradually directed towards the nearest separation line, along which it will subsequently tend to move. Provided that the amount of sediment available is not too small, the bands should be low ridges with either cusped or rounded crests. The ridges may be either smooth or show superimposed transverse bedforms, depending on flow strength, sediment coarseness, and flow scale. Longitudinal ridges and furrows may also be expected in the second case, their transverse spacing again equalling the wavelength of the secondary flow (Fig. 1-2b). A ridge should occur beneath each separation zone, for the reason that the transverse component of the bed shear stress is directed towards such a zone, counteracting the tendency of the downstream-moving debris to roll under gravity into the intervening troughs. But the ridges will grow and steepen only for so long as the transverse fluid force acting upslope on each moving grain exceeds the transverse downslope component of the particle immersed weight. A limiting or equilibrium side-slope will exist only when these forces balance, the grain paths then being parallel with the ridge crests and trough axes. The equilibrium relationship between the local transverse slope-angle p of the ridges and the deviation angle 6 of the limiting streamlines (Fig. 1-2b) may be found from an analysis of particle-equilibrium in river bends (Van Bendegom, 1947; NEDECO, 1959; Allen, 1970b, 1970c), to be studied further in Chapter 2. Equating the fluid and weight forces, we find that: 37, sin 6 sin p = -P
k
in which T, is the bed shear stress tangential to a limiting streamline, D is the sediment particle diameter (assumed spherical), (I and p are the particle and fluid densities respectively, and g is the acceleration due to gravity. The side slope therefore increases with the strength of the mean flow and with the strength (inversely proportional to the pitch) of the secondary flow, but decreases with increasing particle size and relative density. Since the deviation angle is generally small, T~ may be replaced for rough calculations by its streamwise component rx as given by some suitable relationship (Vol. I, Chapter 1). Even with a fully developed sediment transport, the small magnitude of the deviation angle makes it unlikely that sin p will exceed the order of 0.1. The third case is more complex, dividing into at least two. Consider first
5
what happens when the debris supplied is insufficient to cover the whole bed but succeeds in forming longitudinally continuous ridges at separation lines (Fig. 1-2c). The stationary grains in the ridges protect the potentially deformable bed immediately beneath, leaving exposed to erosion only the surface in the zones of reattachment. Hence the bedform should comprise longitudinal furrows corresponding to reattachment, separated by ridges with but a capping of grains. A similar result would be obtained if the flow were sufficiently vigorous that the transported grains remained in suspension, or if the fluid were free from dispersed sediment and the flow was powerful enough to effect a direct erosion or plastic deformation of the bed. Secondly, consider the case when the available sediment is insufficient to afford a continuous grain-cover even along separation lines (Fig. 1-2d). If the mode of erosion is corrasion, the rate must be greatest along the separation zones, because the areal concentration of grains moving at the bed is here a maximum. The furrows now develop where there is separation, with ridges corresponding to reattachment. How might sedentary organisms such as corals and encrusting algae respond to an environment marked by a pattern of secondary flow? Their growth rate could be smaller at reattachment than at separation, because of the greater damage to tissues likely to arise in reattachment zones on account of the larger velocities and stresses there present. If loose debris was available, however, growth could be inhibited most near separation, on account of the increased likelihood of tissue-damage through the action of rolling particles. Alternatively, differential growth could result from the control by the secondary currents of the local food or nutrient supply. If the food originated near the water surface, for example, organisms living on the bottom near reattachment could by feeding impoverish those living further along the path of the circulating fluid. These mechanisms yield different end-products, with ridges either at attachment or separation, but they may help to explain those longitudinal bedforms that involve living algae and corals.
CAUSES OF SECONDARY FLOW
Instability of a fluid in axisymmetric motion A very simple type of instability leading to secondary flow is shown by a fluid rotating about a rectilinear axis, whenever the balance between the centrifugal force and the radial pressure gradient is suitably disturbed. The criterion for stability, established from different standpoints (Lord Rayleigh, 1916a; Synge, 1933, 1938; Von Karman, 1934), is that the square of the circulation K of the fluid should increase monotonically outward from the axis of rotation. We define the circulation as K = Ur, where U is the
6
circulatory speed of a fluid element at a radial distance Y from the axis of rotation. A necessary condition for instability, then, is that the streamline curvature is concave in the direction of increasing flow speed. I t follows that for neutral stability K ( r )= const, whence U ( r ) cannot be too steeply decreasing a function. Von Karman’s explanation of the instability proceeds essentially as follows. If a ring of fluid at Y, is displaced outward to r 2 , the centrifugal force p U ’ / r acting on the ring becomes p( r,U,/ Y ~ ) ~ / Y = ~ p( Y , U , ) ~ /This Y ~ . exceeds the prevailing pressure gradient pU;/r2 if ( r,U,)’ > ( r2U2)’ or, since K = Ur, if K f > K i . Secondary flows due to the above cause, often called Taylor-Gortler vortices, arise in three main circumstances: ( I ) in the fluid between rotating coaxial cylinders, (2) in two-dimensional boundary-layer flows over concave surfaces, and (3) in attaching or reattaching axisymmetric, two-dimensional and three-dimensional flows as a local effect. Several general reviews covering most of these cases are available (Chandrasekhar, 1961; Greenspan, 1968; Joseph, 1976a; Lin, 1955; Yih, 1969b). Secondary flow between rotating coaxial cylinders ( e g Euteneuer and Reimann, 1971) is only of theoretical interest in the context of bedforms. However, the pioneering work by G.I. Taylor (1923) on this problem is a classic, much of the more recent work being reviewed by Coles (1965) and Greenspan (1968). Because U(r ) cannot be too steeply decreasing a function for the retention of stability, it is hardly surprising that Taylor-Gortler vortices should commonly appear in boundary-layer flows over concave surfaces, for viscosity causes U to decrease rapidly towards the flow boundary, that is, with increasing r . Many natural flows occur over concave surfaces, and this cause of secondary flow may be important in the production of bedforms. The occurrence of secondary flow in laminar boundary layers on concave surfaces is well-established theoretically (Gortler, 1940a, 1940b, 1941; Meksyn, 1950; Hammerlin, 1955a; A.M.O. Smith, 1955; Gortler and Witting, 1958; Kahawita and Meroney, 1974; Aihara, 1976), the vortices appearing when, for a given Reynolds number, the radius of flow curvature becomes sufficiently small compared with the boundary layer thickness. Gregory and Walker (1951), Euteneuer (1969, 1972), Wortmann (1969), McCormack et al. (1970), and Bippes and Gortler (1972) studied the vortices experimentally, to find wavelengths between about one-third and two times the boundary-layer thickness. Of greater importance at present are the less well-known TaylorGortler vortices known to arise in turbulent boundary layers on concave surfaces (Tani, 1962; Sandmayr, 1966). A possible natural example is the pattern of dust-filled “streaks” with a wavelength of 25-30 m recorded by Swift et al. (1978) from the Copper River delta, Alaska, where a katabatic wind flowed down a beach and over the sea. Bedforms due to Taylor-Gortler vortices may also occur in that local region of an attaching or reattaching flow where the flow speed increases in
the direction towards which the streamlines are concave, for example, above the troughs of current ripples or dunes (where longitudinal elements are known to be present), and somewhat down-wind from cliffs facing with the wind. There are strong theoretical reasons for expecting the vortices, at least in laminar currents of the above kinds (Gortler, 1955; Hammerlin, 1955b; Kestin and Wood, 1970; Sadeh et a]., 1970a; Persen, 1971; Schlichting, 1971; Tobak, 1971), and there is experimental evidence that they can exist in both attached, attaching and reattached flows (Piercy and Richardson, 1928, 1930; Kuethe, 1958; Hopkins et a]., 1960; Ginoux, 1965, 1967, 1969, 1971; Sutera, 1965; Sadeh et a]., 1970b; Smits et al., 1979; Sadeh and Brauer, 1980). However, the instability may depend only partly on unbalanced pressure and centrifugal forces (Sadeh et al., 1970a; Tobak, 1973). Inflectional instability of a rotating fluid A three-dimensional boundary layer arises when a disc is turned in a still fluid of large extent (Vol. I, Fig. 1-4), or when a mass of fluid rotates in the presence of a stationary rigid boundary about an inclined axis (Schlichting, 1960). Closely related in character is the Ekman boundary layer (Vol. I, Fig. 1-5), developed in the atmosphere and in the upper and lower layers of the oceans as a consequence of flow upon a rotating Earth. These boundary-layer flows all share the property that, of the three velocity components recognizable, the normal profiles of the radial and axial velocities possess an inflection point at a distance from the boundary of the order of the Ekman boundary-layer thickness. Lord Rayleigh ( 1880) showed that motions with such profiles cannot be stable, whence unstable modes of flow may be expected in three-dimensional boundary layers, whether experimental or planetary (e.g. Gregory et al., 1955; Kreith et al., 1959; Wipperman, 1969; Chin and Litt, 1972). Being the larger, the radial component is likely to control these modes. The existence of an unstable mode in the boundary layer (laminar transitional to turbulent) formed on a disc rotating in a still fluid was established experimentally by Gregory et a1.-(1955) and also studied theoretically by them. Because of viscosity, a layer of fluid is dragged round by the disc, the limiting streamlines of this basic motion following in the laminar case a logarithmic spiral of angle 135" (Fig. 1-3). The instability takes the form of a double row of stationary vortices, the axes of which follow a logarithmic spiral with an angle of about 104O, to the right of the spiral made by limiting streamlines in the basic flow. Vortices in the lower row are wall-attached and parallel but isolated, with a common sense of rotation. The vortices of the upper row all rotate in the opposite sense and are removed from the boundary. Although the interior flow structure differs from that of ordinary secondary motions (Fig. 1-1), the patterns of limiting streamlines are similar. A major dynamical contrast is that the bed shear
8
Fig. 1-3. Secondary flow in the three-dimensional boundary layer developed on a disc rotating in a fluid. See also Vol. I, Fig. 1-5.
stresses are distributed asymmetrically under three-dimensional flow. In the motion sketched in Fig. 1-3, the stress is a maximum about one-sixth of a wavelength to the left looking downstream of each separation line, and not where reattachment occurs at one-half the wavelength. Bedforms developed beneath unstable three-dimensional boundary layers should therefore be asymmetrical, with perhaps the steeper slopes facing with the basic radial flow and in the direction towards which the vortices and limiting streamlines are convex. Gregory et a]. (1955) calculated the vortex wavelength at roughly 1.5 times the Ekman boundary-layer thickness, but measured substantially larger values consistent with later findings (Faller, 1963; Faller and Kaylor, 1966; Lilly, 1966; Tatro and Mollo-Christensen, 1967; Brown, 1970; Caldwell and Van Atta, 1970). The pattern of motion predicted theoretically by a number of these workers, however, is more like that in Fig. 1-1 than in.Fig. 1-3. Greenspan (1968) has reviewed the instability of Ekman boundary layers. Asymmetry of flow boundaries (turbulent flow)
It has long been known that secondary currents can form in rectilinear turbulent flows past asymmetrical boundaries (Fig. 1-4), for example, a flat plate with free edges parallel with flow (Elder, 1960; Davies and Young, 1963), a flow-aligned external corner (Nikuradse, 1930), or a conduit with sharp streamwise corners (Nikuradse, 1930; Cruff, 1965; Gessner and Jones, 1965; Liggett et al., 1965; Chiu, 1967; Matthews and Liggett, 1967; Allen, 1968g; Chiu and Lee, 1971; Launder and Ying, 1972; Gessner, 1973;
9
-+
Streamlines
\
_ _ _ _ Irotochs Y
t
Fig. 1-4. Schematic representation of flow (streamlines and isotachs of streamwise velocity) in a boundary layer flowing parallel with an edge or comer. a. Streamwise edge of a plate (based on Elder, 1960). b. Streamwise right-angled comer (after Nikuradse, 1930). c. Channel of rectangular cross-section (after Nikuradse, 1930). d. Channel of triangular cross-section (based on Liggett et al., 1965).
Gerard, 1978). In contrast, no secondary motion develops in two-dimensional or axisymmetric turbulent flow. Secondary currents created through flow-boundary asymmetry could be of practical importance. Natural channels are not axisymmetric and, whether or not curved in plan, should therefore cause a secondary flow. Again, when a river floods or the tide overtops channel banks, secondary currents may be developed along the channel margins, which have become external corners. The first explanation of secondary flows of the kind shown in Fig. 1-4 was advanced by Prandtl (1927a), who suggested that the turbulent velocity fluctuations tangential to an isotach in regions of isotach curvature caused a transverse flow directed from the concave towards the convex side of the isotach. The tangential velocity fluctuations at each point on a curved isotach must therefore be much greater than the normal fluctuations. Alternative theories have subsequently been developed, chiefly from a consideration of the Reynolds stresses or vorticity production (Howarth, 1938; Einstein and Li, 1958; Brundrett and Baines, 1964; Gessner and Jones, 1965; Perkins, 1970; Eichelbrenner and Preston, 1971; Hinze, 1973; Townsend, 1976). Most of these presume, either explicitly oi implicitly, that the anisotropy of the transverse normal Reynolds stresses causes the secondary flow. Gessner (1973) seems to have resolved the issue by showing that it is the gradient of the normal Reynolds shear stress in the vicinity of an edge or corner which actually drives the secondary motion, being such as to mean that energy is continuously fed from the inner flow to regions near an edge or corner where energy is lost. A closely related mechanism appears to explain secondary currents developed during turbulent flow past a surface marked by spanwise-periodic variations of roughness (Townsend, 1976), particularly if those variations are partly related to localized and reasonably intense sediment transport (Bagnold, 1954b).
10
The apparent roughness of a longitudinal strip of sand being transported vigorously over a gravel surface, for example, is paradoxically greater than that of the bare gravel surroundings, because of the added drag arising from the transport. Hence at heights sufficiently near the bed, the flow over the sand strip is retarded relative to that over the gravel. Consequently fluid drifts laterally from above the gravel to above the sand, and a compensatory flow, now directed from the sand to the gravel, is created at a higher level in the current. Profiles of the streamwise component of velocity above the sand strip and above the gravel should resemble those sketched in Fig. 1-5, there being one near-bed height at which the velocity above the sand strip equals that above the gravel. At lower heights, the velocity above the gravel is the larger, while at larger distances the greater value occurs above the sand. At a sufficient height above the general boundary, where its effects can no longer be felt, the profiles should coincide. Hence the profiles define a necessarily symmetrical transverse circulation in the fluid, at the bed from the gravel to the sand. Its spanwise scale would appear to be fixed by the height in the flow at which the two streamwise velocities become equal. This height should depend only on flow strength and sediment characteristics, and could be much smaller than the boundary layer thickness. The effect identified is self-perpetuating and self-adjusting, provided that a vigorous transport is maintained. Once a chance local covering of sand had accumulated, the secondary motion would immediately develop, appearing first as a single pair of rolls and ultimately as a pervasive array of regular longitudinal vortices. The presence of a corner or edge would not be necessary for the
u/
Equal velocities
Fig. 1-5. Probable secondary currents associated with the transport by wind of sand in stripes, usually rippled, over a gravel surface, illustrated by schematic velocity profiles (left) and streamlines in the plane normal to flow (right). A similar difference in roughness may arise in aqueous environments where sand, drifted in small quantities, can be shaped into either current ripples or dunes.
induction of the secondary flow, though such features could trigger or reinforce its development. For the above effect to be displayed, we need only a spanwise change of roughness and not that the bed has everywhere a measurable apparent roughness. Culbertson (1967), for example, describes ribbons of sand deposited on apparently smooth beds. An important difference may be noted between the secondary flow inferred above and that found in, say, Taylor-Gortler vortices. In the latter, the boundary shear stress peaks along the reattachment lines (e.g. Gregory et al., 1955). In the former, the stress along the sand stripes where separation occurs is thought either to equal (Bagnold, 1954b) or be larger than (Fig. 1-5) the value in the adjacent gravel lanes where reattachment seems to happen. Future experimental comparisons may show whether this distinction is correct. Superposed “immiscible” fluids of contrusted density Imagine a rectangular tank filled with two stationary immiscible liquids of contrasted density arranged each in a distinct layer, the one superposed on the other. The lower liquid, of density p I , extends vertically over a thickness h , from y = 0 up t o y =y I ,while the upper, of density p,, fills a thickness h , from y = y I to y = y 2 . Common experience suggests that the arrangement is unstable, tending to invert, if p, > p , and surface tension is negligible. For if some of the denser liquid lying just at the interface is displaced downward, the buoyancy force acting on it is less than the weight, and the downward motion can be continued. If the denser liquid forms the lower stratum, the reverse is true and the arrangement is stable. Alternatively, noting that the local potential energy is pgy, we can calculate the total potential energy for each arrangement when, finding that p h ,h < p2 h h z, the system can be stable only if the total potential energy is a minimum (Rayleigh, 1883). But the arrangement with the denser liquid below becomes unstable if the tank is accelerated downwards with an acceleration greater than g (G.I. Taylor, 1950). The layers again invert, the denser liquid overlying the lighter (the tank is supposed closed and completely filled). This type of instability is the Rayleigh-Taylor instability. It has often been studied (e.g. Lewis, 1950; Bellman and Pennington, 1954; Ingraham, 1954; Melcher and Hurwitz, 1967; Rajappa, 1970; Plesset and Whipple, 1974; Amaranth and Rajappa, 1976; Craik, 1976; Rajappa and Amaranth, 1977) and is reviewed by Chandrasekhar (1961), Yih (1965, 1969b), Dussan (1975) and Joseph (1976a). When instability occurs, the denser liquid flows into the lighter one as a series of regularly spaced pendants symmetrical about axes normal to the initial interface (e.g. Ramberg, 1967). The motion in each pendant resembles that during convection, consisting of circulation in a plane normal to a horizontal ring-shaped axis (Fig. 1-6a). A corresponding
, ,
,
12
flow arises in the inverse pendants formed by the light liquid as it penetrates the denser. A secondary flow similar to that in Fig. 1-1 can be developed from this type of motion if the liquids are sheared parallel with the interface and each is maintained in adequate supply. Important natural examples of gravitationally unstable “immiscible” fluids in shear are afforded by turbidity currents, sea-breeze fronts, and thunderstorm outflows (haboobs). J.E. Simpson (1969, 1972) emphasized that the nose of these surge-like flows is overhanging, with a complex lobe and cleft structure (Vol. I, Figs. 1-27, 1-28). Allen (1971b) showed that some of the medium must be squeezed far under the unstably advancing head, within or behind which it should eventually float up through the main bulk of the current. Figure 1-6b depicts in the xy-plane at a cleft and relative to the head the probable pattern of streamlines in the head and medium. Also shown, but now relative to the ground, are velocity profiles and the generalized
Fig. 1-6. Motions arising from the gravitational instability of superposed liquids. a. Motion in the vertical plane when both liquids are otherwise stationary. b. Motion at the head of a gravity current with lobes and clefts (see also Vol. I, Figs. 1-27 and 1-28). Left-hand portion of figure shows schematically the external appearance of front of head and streamlines in the plane of flow at a cleft. On the right appear suggested patterns of limiting streamlines and velocity profiles (relative to the ground) within the lobes and clefts.
13
pattern of instantaneous limiting streamlines. The base of each lobe contains a pair of spiral vortices, with reattachment occurring beneath the lobe axis and separation where clefts have closed up. Allen suggested that much larger shear stresses are to be expected beneath lobes than in clefts. The secondary flow should decay beyond the station where the entrapped blobs of medium ascend from the bed, since the gravitational instability can no longer operate.
Thermal convection in a sheared fluid A system resembling that in Fig. 1-6 arises in a horizontally sheared fluid heated from below so that it becomes gravitationally unstable. An interface is lacking, however, and the flow may be unstable over all its length. Consider first the simpler stability of a horizontal layer of stationary fluid heated from beneath, the much-studied Benard problem reviewed by Stomme1 (1947), Chandrasekhar (1961), Yih (1969b), J.S. Turner (1973), and Joseph (1976b). The heating causes the density'of the fluid to increase upwards and thus promotes instability, which commonly is expressed as hexagonal convection cells (Fig. 1-7a). But viscosity can stabilize the fluid, even though the density gradient is adverse. Instability may also be reduced in intensity or suppressed by the action of thermal diffusivity, which tends to equalize the temperature of a fluid particle and the surroundings into which it moves. Considering all these factors, Lord Rayleigh (1916b) showed that instability occurred when the parameter:
R a = - - gkTh4 Kv exceeded a certain critical value, where Ra is the Rayleigh number, k is the Cloud Streets
Fig. 1-7. Secondary currents due to thermal convection. a. Polygonal (hexagonal) convection cells arising in a stationary fluid layer either heated from below or cooled from above. b. Longitudinal vortices (roll vortices) associated with cloud streets in the atmospheric boundary layer.
14
coefficient of thermal expansion of the fluid, T is the vertical temperature gradient (negative in a coordinate system in which the upward vertical is positive), h is the layer thickness, and K and v are respectively the fluid thermal diffusivity and kinematic viscosity. Many theoretical studies of the Benard problem have been made, of which those by Jeffreys (1926, 1928), Low (1929), Pellew and Southwell (1940), Fan ( 1959, Hide ( 1959, Chandrasekhar ( 196l), and Wellander ( 1964) are important or representative. The critical Rayleigh number for instability is 1108 when the layer is constrained by a free surface and rigid boundary (the case closest to that of practical interest), the cell diameter (or wavelength) being approximately 2.34 times the layer thickness. Benard convection has also been much studied experimentally. Some of the best work is that by Krishnamurti (1970a, 1970b, 1973, 1975a), who showed that the shape and time-dependent behaviour of convection cells depended strongly on the Rayleigh number. Jeffreys ( 1928) showed theoretically that a sufficiently large shear applied to a convecting layer will stabilize the layer except to disturbances for which the cell boundaries are flow-parallel. Beginning with Ma1 (193 l), many workers proved experimentally that a distinctive sequence of convection patterns is obtained with increasing shear, ending as Jeffreys had predicted with longitudinal spiral vortices (Fig. 1-7b)(Phillips and Walker, 1932; Graham, 1934; Brunt, 1937; Chandra, 1938; Sparrow and Husar, 1969; Lloyd and Sparrow, 1970; Clever and Busse, 1977; Kimura et al., 1971; Krishnamurti, 1975b; Davis and Choi, 1977; Ruth et al., 1980). These vortices have prompted several theoretical studies (Kuettner, 1959, 1971; Kuo, 1963; Gage and Reid, 1968; Asai, 1970a, 1970b; Krishnamurti, 1975a, 1975c; Cheng and Wu, 1976; Wu and Cheng, 1976; Sun, 1978), which reveal amongst other things that the vortex wavelength is approximately three times the thickness of the convecting layer. Jeffreys himself obtained wavelengths of 2.22-3.12 thicknesses. The most important natural examples of longitudinal vortices in thermally unstable shear layers occur in the atmospheric boundary layer, where they have long been associated (Idrac, 1920; Faller, 1965) with the parallel lines of clouds called cloud streets (Malkus and Ronne, 1960; Kuettner and Soules, 1966; Plank, 1966; Kuettner, 1967; Nicks, 1970; Raustein, 1972; Scorer, 1972; Nicholls, 1978; Weston, 1980; Walter, 1981). Cloud streets (Fig. 1-8) form above the sites in the vortex system where longitudinal separation takes place on the ground (Fig. 1-7b), arising under conditions of moderately strong wind and modest thermal instability (Woodcock, 1941; Kuettner, 1959; LeMone, 1973). Hence they are most plentiful in low and intermediate latitudes, where the land or ocean can be readily warmed. According to Kuettner ( 197 1). the transverse spacing of cloud streets ranges between 2 and 8 km and lengths can attain 500 km. The existence of the corresponding atmospheric spiral motions is now well established, both
Fig. 1-8. Oblique aerial view from above of cloud streets over Oxfordshire, England, with wind blowing from upper right to lower left. Photograph courtesy of R.S. Scorer.
visually (Woodcock, 1940, 1941; Woodcock and Wyman, 1947; Gifford, 1953; Hallanger et al., 1962; Angell, 1971, 1972; Angell et al., 1966, 1968, 1972), and by instrumental methods (Plank, 1966; Konrad, 1968; LeMone, 1973; Burt et al., 1974, 1975; Frisch et al., 1975; Markson, 1975). In harmony with the experiments described, atmospheric convection assumes patterns depending on the magnitudes of the shear and thermal instability (e.g. Plank, 1966; Raustein, 1972; Scorer, 1972).-These range from equidimensional (see Fig. 1-6a), as in mammae clouds, to longitudinal as in the vortices, often called roll vortices, linked to cloud streets. Cloud streets and vortices alike lie slightly to the left of the geostrophic wind. Whereas many workers believe that buoyancy combined with shear is sufficient to produce atmospheric longitudinal vortices, others (e.g. Wipperman, 1969; R.A. Brown, 1970) suggest that Ekman-layer inflectional instability is adequate. A combination of mechanisms is possibly operative (R.A. Brown, 1972; LeMone, 1973). Langmuir circulation The surfaces of lakes and oceans affected by a combination of waves and moderate to strong winds frequently show a longitudinal banding, expressed
16
either by transverse variations in wave size and breaking behaviour or, more commonly, by lines or bands of debris and foam indicative of the existence of convergence along zones nearly parallel with the wind. These windrows or wind streaks can be made experimentally (Kraus, 1967a; Faller, 1978; Faller and Caponi, 1978) and in natural environments have often been observed (Langmuir, 1938; Van Straaten, 1950a; Faller and Woodcock, 1964; Roll, 1965; McLeish, 1968; Stewart and Schmitt, 1968; Sutcliffe et al., 1971; Eisenlohr, 1972; Harris and Lott, 1973) or revealed using dyes released into the water (Katz et al., 1965; Ichiye, 1967; Assaf et al., 1971). Their transverse spacing is usually between 10 and 50m in the oceans, depending on wind speed and thermocline depth, but in lakes seldom exceeds 10m and may be as little as 0.5 m. Hunter and Hill (1980) recently described from off the Texas coast what may be Langmuir circulations expressed by a turbidity banding. This banding occurred in water 6-14m deep and took a wavelength, increasing with water depth, between 5 and 25 times the depth. Langmuir (1938) proposed that windrows express a helical circulation in the surface layers of oceans and lakes, the motion (Fig. 1-9) being the mirror-image of that sketched in Fig. 1-1. The longitudinal velocities associated with the circulation are only a few percent of the local wind speed, but the secondary flow itself must be relatively vigorous, to judge from the measurements of Scott et al. (1969). Hence Langmuir circulations could generate longitudinal bedforms if set up by moderate to strong winds. They must also penetrate the full depth of the water body, however, which seems to restrict their action to shallow lakes and seas. Langmuir (1938) himself appreciated that the motion depended on an interaction between the wind-driven surface current and the water waves advancing beneath the wind. The mechanisms possibly involved in this interaction have subsequently been much debated, as may be seen from the reviews by Scott et al., (1969) and Faller (1971), and the theoretical studies Debrls at sonverpence
Fig. 1-9. Schematic streamlines and velocity distribution in Langmuir vortices.
17
by Craik (1970, 1976, 1977), Leibovich and Ulrich (1972), Gammelsrdd ( 1979, Craik and Leibovich ( 1976), Garrett ( 1976), Leibovich ( 1976, 1977), and Leibovich and Radhakrishnan ( 1977). The most acceptable explanation
(Craik, 1977; Leibovich, 1977, 1980) is that of an instability mechanism in which initially weak spanwise-periodic velocity variations in the wind-driven current are amplified by the effect on the vorticity of the mass-transport induced by three-dimensional wind-waves, as substantiated by the recent experiments of Faller (1978) and of Faller and Caponi (1978). Craik calculates that the transverse wavelength of the circulation is X = 0.45U ’ / g , where U is the mean wind speed. This is substantially lower than Leibovich and Ulrich’s (1972) estimate of X = 7rU2/2g, and both relationships yield wavelengths smaller than observed (e.g. Faller and Woodcock, 1964; Scott et al., 1969). Under field conditions, however, circulations of more than one wavelength may be noticeable because a spectrum of waves is inevitably present. There is experimental evidence that, even with a steady wind and waves of a single wavelength, two circulation wavelengths can arise (Faller and Caponi, 1978), in response to an energy-transfer mechanism whereby the vortices tend to fill the water-body to its full depth. SAND RIBBONS IN AQUEOUS CURRENTS
On smooth beds in streams Longitudinal bands of sand-Casey’s ( 1935) Langsstreifen and Vanoni’s (1946) sand ribbons or streaks-are seldom reported from extensive smooth beds. The straight to very gently curved examples described by Culbertson (1967) from the Rio Grande Conveyance Channel have wavelengths in the order of 0.1-0.2m and arose as a little sand was drifted over an apparently smooth bed of clay deposited from suspension not long beforehand. He interpreted them in terms of a secondary flow like that in Fig. 1-1. As the channel walls lie at a distance, a sediment-flow interaction could have been responsible for the secondary circulation. Centrifugal instability cannot be wholly ruled out, however, as some of the ribbons are curved. The rather more closely spaced straight ribbons observed experimentally by Ashida and Narai (1969) occurred on the smooth glass bed of a flume beneath a flow with a depth equal to about one-half of their wavelength. The ribbons probably reflect transverse variations in bed roughness. On rough beds in streams and beneath ebbing tidal flows During transport experiments using mixed grades of sand in a straight flume, Casey (1935) noticed that the finer particles moved over the coarser in the form of longitudinal bands or ribbons which he called Liingsstreifen. These he explained by a pattern of secondary flow having a spanwise wavelength of roughly twice the flow depth. Similar experimental observa-
Fig. 1-10. Sand ribbons developed by the ebbing tide on a gravel surface in (a) general view and (b) close-up, coast near Burnham Overy Staithe, Norfolk, England. Trowel 0.28 m long points in current direction.
tions were made by Vanoni (1946), Allen (1966c), and Ikeda (1981), who also invoked secondary flows to explain the features. Allen found that the ribbons were smooth when the current was powerful enough otherwise to fashion a plane bed but became transversely rippled beneath weaker flows.
19
Vanoni (1946) attributed the secondary flow to the creation of locally unstable sediment concentration (bulk density) gradients, a view challenged by Nemenyi (1946), who urged instead the influence of channel corners. But Vanoni worked at large width-to-depth ratios, and the influence of a corner does not extend far transversely into a flow. The best explanation seems to be that transverse variations of bed roughness gave rise to a secondary motion. Allen (1966~)used flows not much shallower than wide in a short channel, making it plausible in his case that entrance and corner effects determined the secondary flows. Ikeda ( 1981) invoked Reynolds-stress distortion. A field example of sand ribbons formed by the drifting of grains down a shallow channel floored by a level spread of stable gravel appears in Fig. 1-10. Numerous similar bedforms are recorded, largely from shallow flows in which the wavelengths developed are in the order of 0.1-0.3 m (Arnborg, 1957; Hjulstrom, 1957; Karcz, 1966, 1967, 1972, 1974; Slatt and Hoskin, 1968; Bluck, 1971, 1976; Collinson, 1971b; Dalrymple et al., 1975). Karcz noticed that as the amount of sand cover increased, the ribbons merged and became strongly marked transversely by current ripples, longitudinal features being suppressed. Those amongst the “streaming lineations” of Picard and High (1973) not related to obstacles on the bed may also be sand ribbons. The alternative name “harrow marks” was proposed by Karcz (1967) for sand ribbons, but the older name is neither genetic nor likely to mislead. The name “longitudinal rib” was applied by Martini (1977) to apparently solitary streamwise ridges of coarse sand found on bars in a coarse-load stream. Karcz (1966, 1967) and Allen (1966~)in particular urged the interpretation of these sand ribbons in terms of secondary flow. Although Karcz did not observe active currents, his photographs bear out this explanation. They show on the ribbons tiny sand drifts that are oriented relative to the ribbons in the same manner as limiting streamlines near separation (Fig. 1-1).
Sand ribbons in the marine environment Ribbons of sand resting on stable substrates and aligned parallel with the strongest sand-driving tidal currents were first recorded from the marine environment by Stride (1959a, 1961, 1963). Similar structures have since been widely identified in shallow tide-swept seas (Belderson, 1964; Flemming, 1965; Belderson and Stride, 1966; Dobson et al., 1971; N.H. Kenyon, 1970a; Kenyon and Stride, 1970; Belderson et al., 1971, 1972; McKinney et al., 1974; Dalrymple et al., 1975; G.F. Caston, 1976; Pendlebury and Dobson, 1976; Bouma et al., 1977a, 1977b, 1978; Hunt et al., 1977; B.W. Flemming, 1978, 1980; K.B. Lewis, 1979; Karl, 1980), where they are valuable indicators of bedload paths (Stride, 1963, 1973). They occur as well in tidally influenced carbonate environments (Kendall and Skipwith, 1969; G.R. Davies, 1970a; Rigby and Roberts, 1976). Thermohaline marine circu-
20
Fig. 1-1 1. Side-scan sonar record (0.8 by 2.5 km) of sand ribbons composed of trains of low sand waves (light tone), water depth approximately 59 m, English Channel. Photograph courtesy of N.H. Kenyon (see also N.H. Kenyon, 1970a).
lations have also shaped sand ribbons, at great depths (Kenyon and Belderson, 1973; Lonsdale and Malfait, 1974) and in shallows (Werner and Newton, 1975a, 1975b). Marine sand ribbons (Fig. 1-11) typically are found on extensive level surfaces underlain by lag gravels or smoothed rock. They are spaced transversely in the order of 10-200m, and range up to 15 km in length, but seldom rise more than 1 m above their surroundings. The Celtic Sea reveals three varieties of ribbon which N.H. Kenyon (1970a) shows are related to the degree of sand cover and suggests are dependent on the maximum tidal velocities. His type A ribbons (maximum velocity 1.33 m s - I ) comprise longitudinal rows of small, isolated, transversely arranged sand waves or dunes. The largely “smooth” type B ribbons exist in areas of somewhat weaker currents (maximum velocity 1.06ms-I) where the bed is less sandstarved. These ribbons are broad, expanding locally into thin but extensive sand sheets, and often composite, being formed from several ribbons which have merged and are detectable as individuals only near the margins of the sheets. Type C ribbons (maximum velocity 0.93 m s - I ) comprise trains of substantial and locally merging barkhan-like dunes or sand waves. N.H. Kenyon (1970a) distinguished a type D ribbon which he linked genetically to the previous three (see also Auffret et al., 1972; Werner and Newton, 1975a, 1975b; B.W. Flemming, 1980). These ribbons are much more closely spaced than the other varieties in similar water depths, occurring only in the troughs of large partly isolated sand waves and at steep angles to their crests, the two kinds of form making a trellis-like sand spread. The marine sand ribbons belonging to Kenyon’s types A-C are probably attributable to secondary flows created by transverse variations of bed
21
I
/
h
-E
100
--
L
mi
.
A
2: 5 c V
3
40-
20
10
L
L
I
10
/*.
4
O
Allen ( 1 9 6 8 b ) Kenyon (19700) v Kenyon ond Stride 11970) Werner and Newton 11975b) Bouma et a1 (1977a, 1977b, 1978) * s a n d ribbons 0 sand-filled erosional grooves
A
/*
. /-
-
'
m ,
/
1
20
40
60
80 100
200
400
600 8001000
2000
Averoge sand ribbon spocing. L (m)
Fig. 1-12. Average transverse spacing of tidal sand ribbons as a function of water depth, including one case of sand-filled erosional grooves.
roughness, although Karl (1980) prefers to invoke Langmuir circulations. Stride (1959b) compared them to aeolian sand stripes which Bagnold (1954b) had interpreted in these terms. Allen (1966~)explained marine ribbons explicitly in terms of secondary currents and, using Stride's (1963) side-scan sonar records, suggested ( 1968b) that their wavelength scaled on effective flow thickness. A more recent analysis by Werner and Newton (1975b) goes far towards confirming this result (Fig. 1-12) and signifies that ribbon wavelength on the average is 3-5 times the thickness. Some of the scatter may be related to indications that more than one order of longitudinal vortex may coexist in the marine environment (Werner and Newton, 1975b). The type D ribbons found in sand-wave troughs where streamlines are gently concave towards the faster flow are obvious candidates for interpretation in terms of local centrifugal instability, and their affinity as expounded by N.H. Kenyon (1970a) may be questioned. They are best allied to the longitudinal features associated with current ripples and dunes covering continuous sand beds (Allen, 1977b). It is interesting that turbulence patterns suggest the association of longitudinal vortices with active river dunes (J.M. Coleman, 1969).
Sand ribbons on continuous beds Longitudinal ridges and furrows of low relief occasionally arise on continuous level spreads of apparently homogeneous sand. Van Straaten ( 1953a) first described them from sandy intertidal flats, under the title of longitudinal megaripples of deep-water variety. These ridges are 10-60m in wave-
22
length, up to 0.2 m in height, and locally more than 1 km long, lying parallel with the tidal currents that shaped them. During 1966 I saw many similar structures formed by ebbing tides on the flat-topped sand banks of the inner Severn Estuary (Fig. 1-13). When drained the bank tops reveal clusters of usually gently curved ridges and furrows up to 300 m long and from 0.5 to 6 m in wavelength. Ebb-oriented current ripples developed in uniformly textured sand lie transversely across them. The ridges have such little relief that they are visible only because of the deeper water standing in the furrows. Apparently, systems of longitudinal vortices are developed in the ebbing tidal current at the sites of the ridges and furrows. Inspection on calm days revealed curved longitudinal bands of differing reflectivity on the water surface, spaced similarly to the ridges and suggesting streamwise convergence and divergence in the swift flows then in the order of 1-2 m deep. Measurements by Hamilton et al. (1974) at one of these sites (Sheperdine Sands, Lydney) confirm the vigour of the currents. J.M. Coleman (1969) later made similar observations from the Brahmaputra River. On aerial photographs he saw many instances of longitudinal water-surface turbulence patterns consistent with the presence of streamwise vortices (he refers only to rows of turbulence cells), and found on dried
Fig. 1-13. Curving sand ribbons on continuous surface of fine sand, Lydney Sand, R. Severn, Gloucestershire, England. View southwest into cloud-obscured sun. Dark bands, with relatively little water ponded in troughs of current ripples, are elevated above reflective, lower-lying bands. Scale given by Labrador dog. Current curved away and to right of observer.
23
banks examples of longitudinal ridges and furrows more than 1 km long, 8-30 m in wavelength, and up to 1.5 m in height. His echo-sounder records show that, during high stage, similar features are present on nominally plane beds and in association with the vortices. Their wavelengths closely fit the trend for other sand ribbons (Fig. 1-12). Fossil record
Sand ribbons appear to have no known fossil record, unless the pebble trains of Nilsen (1968) are related to them. They perhaps have a better chance of preservation in rivers, where mud blankets can easily form (Culbertson, 1967), than in the marine environment (N.H. Kenyon, 1970a). SAND RIBBONS IN AEOLIAN ENVIRONMENTS
Bagnold (1954b) saw that during storms in the Libyan Desert the sand driven over pebble-covered sand sheets became organized into longitudinal ripple-covered stripes up to 500 m long and 40-60 m in wavelength. Between these stripes coarse-textured ballistic ripples were occasionally to be found.
Fig. 1-14. Sand ribbons with a transverse spacing in the order of 0.5-1.0m composed of bands of medium to coarse sand (large-wavelength ballistic ripples) alternating with very fine to fine sand (small-wavelength ballistic ripples), coast west of Holkham Gap, Norfolk, England. Trowel 0.28 m long points downwind.
24
He interpreted the stripes in terms of a transverse circulation in the wind controlled by the spanwise changes of roughness, Fig. 1-5 presenting this explanation in a more complete form. Similar but more closely spaced structures are often found where ill-sorted grains are supplied to a sand sheet (Fig. 1-14). Simons and Eriksen (1953) give an excellent description from the Peruvian Desert. Here the ribbons are 1.25-3.5 m in wavelength and also comprise longitudinally arranged strips a1ternately of light and dark-coloured grains. The light-coloured ribbons consist of medium-grained sand shaped into relatively small transversely arranged ballistic ripples with crest lines that are concave down-wind. Very coarse sand in substantially larger transverse ripples underlies the dark ribbons. Simons and Erikson follow Bagnold (1954b) in their explanation, a view given some support by the downwind-concavity of ripple crests in the light-coloured sand, suggesting separation along these streams.
EROSIONAL GROOVES AND RIDGES
River and related aqueous environments
Whereas sand ribbons are essentially constructional features, albeit of little relief, there are numerous longitudinal bedforms wholly destructional in origin, as modelled in Fig. 1-2d. These include bold grooves and ridges of many sizes and cross-sectional shapes sculptured in relatively coherent beds by river and related aqueous currents in the course of bedload transport. One of their earliest investigators was P.B. King (1927), who described systems of long, nearly straight, deep, U-shaped grooves and intervening sharper ridges which lay parallel with flow on the limestone bed of a river at a transverse spacing in the order of 1 m. These features he explained by corrasion, mainly because of their smoothness in comparison with the fretted and pitted limestone surfaces which lay nearby out of ordinary reach of the stream. Somewhat smaller but otherwise similar ridges and grooves were later described by Arnborg (1958) from the gneissose bed of the Angermandven. Similar forms occurred where this same river swept cohesive silts deposited when its present valley was a fjord. In each instance, quantities of sand and gravel-the tools of corrasion-were present in the grooves. Arnborg also found smaller and more delicate longitudinal grooves and ridges where the river bed was exposed in the troughs of isolated transverse dunes. Corrasion furrows as deep as 1 m and 3-10m apart were found by Sundborg and Norrman (1963) in depths of about 7 m in the Gota Alv. Gizejewski (1978) has described parallel grooves cut into the floor of a lake at a power-station outfall. Longitudinal ridges and grooves can be rapidly excavated by flows resembling sheet floods. Examples approximately 5 m deep, 80 m in wave-
25
length, and more than a kilometre long were found by V.R. Baker (1974) and Baker and Milton (1974) on the surface of the flat-lying basalt lavas scoured by the Lake Missoula catastrophic floods that swept the Washington Scablands (V.R. Baker, 1973a). These remarkably extensive floods were in the order of 100m deep and flowed at many metres per second. Large-scale secondary flows in which cavitation, corrasion, and rock-plucking acted in combination may have shaped the huge grooves (V.R. Baker, 1974). Laboratory experiments have thus far shed little light on the origin of erosional grooves and ridges. From such work the grooves appear to represent an intermediate stage in the deepening and, under some circumstances, the rounding of an originally wide and uniformly shallow channel (AbdelRahman, 1963; Mosley, 1973; Shepherd and Schumm, 1974), but the nature of the erosion processes, and the role if any of secondary flow in the initiation and growth of the structures, remain undescribed. The fossil record of erosional grooves and ridges in fluviatile sediments is not extensive. Schroder (1965), Nagtegaal (1966, 1969), and Allen ( 1974a) describe examples comparable in size and shape with Arnborg’s (1958) and P.B. King’s ( 1927) larger forms. Smaller round-bottomed erosional grooves are particularly common in the Old Red Sandstone (Allen, 1964; Friend, 1965). Corrasion grooves on the scale described by Sundborg and Norrman (1963) and V.R. Baker (1974) have probably been called channels when preserved in rocks.
Tidal environments Tidal currents have locally cut systems of longitudinal grooves and ridges into cohesive beds. Verger ( 1968) has observed corrasionai furrows approximately 0.1 m in depth and 1 m in wavelength from an intertidal mud flat. Similar features trending parallel with the tidal currents are locally preserved on the mud flats of the R. Severn (Fig. 1-15), where they branch and rejoin to reach 300 m in length, 0.35 m in depth, and 2 m in wavelength. When flushed of loose mud by the more vigorous spring tides, the grooves prove to be steep-sided and of a generally V-shaped cross-section, coarse debris often lying in the bottom. Between the grooves the bed is flat to convex-upward and may bear small rills dipping into the furrows. A metre or more of strongly flowing water can cover these grooves and ridges during the tidal ebb. Of a similar form, but developed on hard sandstone pavements, are the groups of furrows described as striations by Klein (1970) from the intertidal zone of the Bay of Fundy. Like Arnborg (1958), he observed slighter longitudinal grooves developed where bed rock was exposed between isolated transverse dunes. Klein concluded that the rock pavements had been subjected to “tidal current scour and sandblasting”. In all of the examples discussed, it is plausible’ that the differential corrasion necessary for the shaping of the grooves and ridges was initiated by secondary currents furnished with but little coarse debris.
26
Fig. 1-15. Partly sediment-filled longitudinal ridges and furrows on intertidal mud flat southeast of Oldbury Lake, R. Severn, near Aust, Gloucestershire, England. Trowel stuck upright into mud is 0.28 m long. Ebbing tide flows from upper right to lower left. The Institute of Geological Sciences (1981) has recorded similar structures elsewhere in the estuary.
Longitudinal grooves are not uncommon in water-depths of several tens of metres. Those reported by Donovan and Stride (1961) are extremely large but, because they are generally ungrouped and depend closely on outcropping hard and soft strata, are unlikely to be controlled by secondary currents. The latter explanation seems most appropriate to the systems of large grooves and ridges described by Dyer (1970), Stride et al. (1972), Newton et a]. (1973), Bouma et al. (1978), and Reinson (1979), eroded into respectively mud, gravel, fine sand over gravel, bed rock and, possibly, gravel. What may be large erosional grooves are reported by Beiersdorf et al. ( 1980). Bouma’s grooves lie in approximately 45 m of water, are probably many hundreds of metres long, and take a wavelength in the order of 100 m. Like some deep-sea and desert features described below, they are occupied by closely spaced transverse dunes incompletely covering the substrate. The grooves found by Stride showed “tuning-fork” junctures which pointed in the direction of net bed-load transport. Toimil and Reimnitz (1979) also described large apparently flow-parallel structures with such junctures, but their relationship to current direction is uncertain. Dyer loosely associated his grooves with secondary flows, though their spacing relative to flow thickness seems too large to support this idea strongly. A better fit to the trend of Fig. 1- 12 is given by Bouma’s grooves from Cook Inlet. This graph should describe grooves and ridges (other than perhaps those found in dune
27
troughs) equally with sand ribbons, for a groove occupied by transportable coarse debris is arguably a ribbon that has succeeded in embedding itself. Many examples of what could be small tidally scoured grooves and ridges occur as moulds in shallow-marine rocks, going by such names as priel casts (Martinsson, 1965), Rinnen (Hantzschel and Reineck, 1968), sand fingers (Woodrow, 1968), or gutter casts (Whitaker, 1973). The paper by H.S. Williams (1881) is sometimes taken as their first description, but to me his account suggests soft-sediment deformations. When well exposed, gutter casts (Fig. 1-16) are generally seen as arrays of long and stout, occasionally branching, straight to weakly meandrine ribs which project downwards from beneath sandstone or calcarenite beds overlying muddy rocks, or as rows of isolated calcarenite or sandstone ribs in shales (Niehoff, 1958; C.R. Barnes, 1965; Martinsson, 1965; Whitaker, 1965, 1973; Kudrass, 1967; D. Richter, 1967; Hantzschel and Reineck, 1968; Woodrow, 1968; Van Eden, 1970; Gall, 1971; Bridges, 1972; Wincierz, 1973; Allen, 1974a; Aigner and Futterer, 1978; Birkenmajer, 1979; Greensmith et al., 1980). The ribs have steep to overhanging sides, often roughly terraced in conformity with bedding in the adjacent mudstones, which like the bottoms frequently carry swarms of delicate tool marks (e.g. Bridges, 1972). Like their modern counterparts (e.g. Fig. 1-15), the ribs are spaced across relatively flat surfaces at fairly regular intervals averaging from a few decimetres to several metres. Usually the ribs comprise longitudinally transported quartz or bioclastic sandstone often rich toward the base in rolled shells, granules, and small pebbles. Related structures, in possibly lacustrine settings, are described by Berry (1961), P. Allen (1962), Prentice (1962b), and Daley (1968). R.J.Bailey’s (1966) “scour ripples” may also be allied to grooves and ridges. The corrasional origin of gutter casts has long been accepted (Whitaker, 1973), the best evidence being the striated bottoms and sides and the presence of possible tools in the infillings. Berry ( 1961) linked groove-cutting
Fig. 1-16. Schematic view from below of underside of a sandstone bed preserving gutter casts.
28
to secondary currents developed when debris in small quantities is driven across a mud surface. Whitaker (1973) also argued for groove initiation by secondary currents but, with Bridges (1972), thought that single spiral vortices only might affect some deeply excavated examples (meandrine ones particularly). Aigner and Futterer (1978) favour erosion downstream from stationary obstacles such as shells, but this explanation, while applicable to solitary grooves, does not account for the relatively even spacing of many gutter casts.
Deep-sea environments Thermohaline circulation in the oceans creates deep-lying but relatively thin bottom currents in many places vigorous enough to scour huge areas of the sea bed (Hollister et al., 1976). Commonly, the erosion is expressed by the excavation of arrays of grooves and ridges parallel with the direction of the measured currents, though some large grooves on the deep-sea floor are syndepositional (Hollister et al., 1978; Tucholke, 1979)..Under the title of longitudinal ripple marks, Taylor et al. (1975) described shallow, regularly spaced, V-shaped grooves from the muddy flanks of Gilliss Seamount. Small grooves were also reported by Lonsdale (1976) from a chalk surface in the Ecuador Trench, and by Melieres et al. (1970) from a large erosional tract swept by the Mediterranean Undercurrent (Heezen and Johnson, 1969; Kenyon and Belderson, 1973). Infillings of rippled sand or gravel were observed. Groupings of much larger furrows, with wavelengths averaging in the general order of 100 m, seem to be widespread, occurring notably on the Carnegie Ridge and the Bahama Outer Ridge (Lonsdale et al., 1973; Hollister et al., 1974; Lonsdale and Malfait, 1974; Lonsdale and Spiess, 1977). Further examples, with depths up to 10 m and widths reaching 50 m, occur on the Bermuda Rise (Embley et al., 1980). These grooves join in the measured downcurrent direction and are known to have steep terraced sides, with little doubt erosional in character if their form and the magnitude of locally-measured currents is any guide. Trains of isolated dunes (foraminiferal sand) infill the broad, steep-sided grooves found on the Carnegie Ridge, though grooves elsewhere contain no obvious partial infill. Lqnsdale and Spiess (1977) tentatively ascribed the grooves to the action of secondary flows in the benthic boundary layer, an interpretation consistent with their wavelength. The causal instability is probably in most cases related to bed-load transport, but may locally be due to streamline curvature. The location of some irregularly spaced grooves may depend on the distribution of breaches in basin rims through which sand can spill (Lonsdale and Malfait, 1974). Lonsdale and Hollister (1978) report grooves about 20 m apart associated with an abyssal meandering channel.
29
Deserts
Spectacular arrays of longitudinal corrasional forms extending over vast areas occur in several deserts. These features (Fig. 1-17) range morphologically between Mainguet’s ( 1972a) wind ridges-and-furrows and the yurdungs of Blackwelder (1934). In some cases yurdungs alone are present, but in others, notably the surroundings of the Tibesti in the Sahara, the two kinds of structure are closely associated. Wind ridges-and-furrows apparently were first described by Bagnold (1933), who found southeast of the Tibesti an impassable country “scored into grooves 10-50 ft. deep, each running in the south-west direction of the prevailing wind”. Monographic treatments of these structures in the Tibesti area are given by Hagerdorn (1971) and Mainguet (1972a), and there are several shorter reports (Grove, 1960; Peel, 1966; Hagerdorn, 1968; Mainguet, 1968, 1972b; Verstappen and Van Zuidam, 1970; Worrall, 1974; Verstappen, 1977). Similar features occur locally in the South American and Middle Eastern deserts (Rich, 1942; D.B. Krinsley, 1970). Wind ridges-and-furrows (Figs. 1-17a, 1-18) are long and straight to very gently curved hollows and crests carved into some resistant substrate, for example, sandstone, diatomite, or mudstone. Their average wavelength ranges between 10 m and 2 km, and their length is 10-100 times this spacing. Mainguet (1972a) records two main modes of close spatial association of forms of contrasted wavelength: (1) long-wavelength forms grading downwind into those of much smaller wavelength, and (2) small-wavelength ridges occupying the furrows of a more widely spaced system, reminding one of certain marine sand ribbons (Werner and Newton, 1975b). Ridge-and-furrow relief ranges between a few metres and a few tens of metres. Whereas the ridges expose the eroded substrate, the furrows are infilled with stones and blown sand, often arranged as trains of barkhans in the same manner as some marine erosion furrows (Lonsdale and Malfait, 1974; Bouma et al., 1978).
Wlnd
Wind
7
I’
Fig. 1 - 17. Schematic representation of corrasional longitudinal structures in aeolian environments. a. Ridges-and-furrows.b. Yurdungs.
30
Fig. 1-18. Vertical view (approximately 5 by 6.5 km) of wind ridges-and-furrows. Bembkchk, Chad. The ridges (stippled), cut into Palaeozoic sandstones, lie about 2 km apart and have gullied flanks. The intervening furrows (light tone) in some cases are infilled with sand shaped into transverse dunes, and in others have chains of barkhans. After an air photograph of Mainguet (1972a). Wind from lower right to upper left.
The erosional origin of ridges-and-furrows seems clear from their regularity of spacing, strict parallelism with the local dominant wind direction, and the presence on exposed rock surfaces of small flutes, grooves and ridges consistent with corrasion. In the Tibesti area, for example, the features combined with other aeolian forms define a pattern of streamlines clearly showing the wind deflection by the mountain masses (Verstappen and Van Zuidam, 1970; Mainguet, 1972a, 1972b; Roland, 1976). Warrall ( 1974) suggests that secondary currents are involved in the formation of ridges-andfurrows, and Fig. 1-2d amplifies this idea. Instability associated with sand transport is the most likely cause of these currents (Fig. 1-5);except perhaps in the case of the larger ridges-and-furrows. Similar features attributable to wind corrasion are present on Mars (Cutts, 1973; McCauley, 1973; Sharp, 1973). In contrast with ridges-and-furrows, yurdungs (Fig. 1-17b) stand in relative isolation on level debris-covered surfaces generally lacking in drifts or dunes. Yurdungs are widely distributed (McCauley et al., 1977), occurring in the Asian and American deserts (Pumpelly, 1908; Bosworth, 1922; Stein,
31
1920; Blackwelder, 1934; H.T.U. Smith, 1967; McCauley, 1973; Stoertz and Ericksen, 1974) as well as in the Sahara (W.B.K. Shaw, 1936; Capot-Rey, 1957a, 1957b; H.T.U. Smith, 1963; Mainguet, 1968, 1972a; Hagerdorn, 1971; Buckle, 1978) and the Middle East (Gabriel, 1938; Dresch, 1968, 1975; Hallier, 1976). They are best developed in relatively soft materials such as mudstone, diatomite, or friable sandstone. The typical yardang has a streamlined form, the plan approximating to a lemniscate loop, with the blunt steep and in some cases overhanging end facing into the dominant wind. The smallest have dimensions measured in metres, whereas the largest can be up to 1 km in length, 20m in height, and 200m across. It is clear from their characteristics and close association with ridges-andfurrows that yardangs have a corrasional origin, and they may be regarded as recording a more advanced stage of erosion than the ridges. Yardang production is not confined to the wind; the Lake Missoula floods sculptured the loess blanket on the Washington Scablands into large yardang-like forms (V.R. Baker, 1974). There are no known fossilized yardangs or ridges-and-furrows, though these may be expected at unconformities blanketted by aeolian sandstones. In limited exposures the forms might be taken incorrectly for wadis. LONGITUDINAL DESERT DUNES
Active longitudinal or seif dunes (Melton, 1940; Hack, 1941; Kadar, 1966; Glennie, 1970; Clos-Arceduc, 1972; Cooke and Warren, 1973), grouped amongst draa by I.G. Wilson (1972a, 1972b, 1972c), are large ridges of mobile sand lying nearly parallel with the dominant sand-driving wind or with the resultant of two or more comparably effective modal winds. They are the typical dune form in the Australian deserts (Clapp, 1926; Madigan, 1936, 1938, 1946; D. King, 1956, 1960; Wopfner and Twidale, 1967; Jennings, 1968; Mabbutt, 1968, 1971, 1977; M. Brookfield, 1970; Folk, 1971a; Twidale, 1972a, 1972b), and are plentiful in the Sahara and other African arid regions (Cornish, 1914; Bagnold, 1931, 1933; Kadar, 1934; Aufrkre, 1935; Gevers, 1936; Brosset, 1939; Capot-Rey, 1943; Monod, 1958; H.T.U. Smith, 1963; McKee and Tibbitts, 1964; Goudie, 1969, 1970; Servant and Servant, 1970; Warren, 1971, 1972, 1976). Longitudinal dunes are numerous in the Saudi Arabian deserts (Bagnold, 1951; Holm, 1960; Glennie, 1970) and occur in many others (Blanford, 1876; Doubiansky, 1928; Hack, 1941; Striem, 1954; R.B. Johnson, 1967; Hanna, 1969; D.B. Krinsley, 1970; Stone et al., 1973; Higgins et al., 1974; Tsoar, 1974). Climatic change during the Quaternary has rendered inactive but left topographically fresh many tracts of longitudinal dunes (Grove and Pullan, 1963; Pullan, 1964; Grove and Warren, 1968; Flint and Bond, 1968; Grove, 1969; Verstappen, 1970; Warren, 1970; Alexandre-Pyre, 1971 ; Goudie et al., 1973; Lancaster, 1981).
32
Fig. 1-19. Air photograph (6.5 by 7.5 km) showing longitudinal dunes in Simpson Desert, Australia. Wind from lower right to upper left. Note tuning-fork junctions.
There are several varieties of longitudinal dune, generally increasing in morphological complexity with growing size. The smallest and simplest (Fig. 1-19), with a transverse wavelength in the order of 500 m, are exemplified by forms in the Australian and Sinai deserts (e.g. Madigan, 1936; Tsoar, 1974). These ridges are straight to meandrine in plan, with crests usually a little more sinuous than their bodies, and of nearly symmetrical cross-section. Heights seldom exceed 30m. The crest is actually a chain of local summits and avalanche faces which rise up from a broad and more gently sloping plinth but shift and change their facing with the wind of the day or season (e.g. McKee and Tibbitts, 1964; I.G. Wilson, 1972c; Tsoar, 1974). The dunes join downwind at “tuning-fork” junctures, just as marine erosion grooves (Stride et al., 1972; Lonsdale and Spiess, 1977), whereas new ridges arise centrally in the corridors between established forms. The larger forms (e.g. Holm, 1960; H.T.U. Smith, 1963), with transverse wavelengths ranging to perhaps 6 km, are ridges more than 100 m in height and often more than 100 km long (Fig. 1-20). They may be chains of simple transverse dunes, pyramidal dunes, or smaller downwind-convergent longitudinal dunes. Most
33
Fig. 1-20. Air photograph (10 by 10 km) showing complex longitudinal dunes, Grand Erg Oriental, Sahara. Dominant wind from upper left toward right, but with evidence for reversals.
longitudinal dunes consist of sand of a finer texture than the debris in the corridors between, where bed-rock or clay layers, gravel, or bimodallydistributed relatively coarse sands abound. No finer material is permitted by the wind to linger in the interdune corridors. It is no surprise that the internal structure of these large dunes should be ill-known. Bagnold’s (1954b) widely quoted theoretical model suggests an internal structure composed of two kinds of deposit (Fig. 1-21a). Beneath the plinth are gently dipping strata which may be either cross-laminated (ballistic ripples) or parallel laminated. In the upper and central portions appear sets of avalanche layers dipping in opposite directions and at high angles to the dune axis. These divergent dips represent the shifting of the localised
34
Relatively coarse-grained sand (smooth beds, rippler. ribur, small transverse dunes)
Reiatively fine-grained avalanched sand
.
.
/ I
L
I
Fig. 1-21. Internal structure of longitudinal (seif) dunes. a. According to Bagnold (1954b). b. As observed after trenching a dune, Zallaf Sand Sea, Libya (after McKee and Tibbetts, 1964).
avalanche faces as the wind changes direction. The excavation of a small Libyan seif dune by McKee and Tibbitts (1964) tends to support this model (Fig. 1-21b), and Glennie (1970) provides some confirmatory data. But Bagnold’s model cannot be valid for the larger and more complex longitudinal dunes. Depending on their shape, the larger forms could resemble internally either (1) a field of transverse dunes, (2) a complex of simple longitudinal dunes, or (3) a complex of equant dunes. Four broad themes- directionist, residualist, transformationist, and vorticist- can be traced in explanations advanced for longitudinal dunes. The precise relationship of dune trend to wind direction has long been contentious, but the analyses by Dubieff (1943, 1952), I.G. Wilson (1971), and Mainguet and Canon (1976) for the Sahara, and particularly by M. Brookfield (1970) for Australia, go far towards proving the approximate parallelism of the forms with the dominant or resultant sand-driving wind (see also Striem, 1954; McKee and Tibbitts, 1964; Tsoar, 1974). Given this parallelism, are longitudinal dunes erosional or constructional forms? Several early workers suggested that they are residual features formed by the scouring of large furrows in thick alluvial deposits, the mobile surface sand
35
being a veneer (e.g. Blanford, 1876; Aufrere, 1928). Although there are local observations supporting this view, espoused up to the present (D. King, 1956, 1960; Folk, 1971a), most of the evidence suggests that the forms are essentially constructional (e.g. McKee and Tibbitts, 1964; Mabbutt and Sullivan, 1968). If the dunes are constructional, do they arise of themselves or by transformation of other dune types? Cornish (1908) thought that longitudinal dunes could arise by the breaching of partly stabilized transverse forms. In his influential book of 1941, Bagnold (1954b) argued that the dunes grew from barkhans which had been elongated in one wing by powerful cross-winds, an idea extended by Capot-Rey and Capot-Rey ( 1948) and recently resuscitated by Lancaster (1980). Madigan (1936) objected so far as Australian deserts were concerned, since he could not find the required transitional forms. Recently, Verstappen ( 1968) suggested that longitudinal dunes may be transformed parabolic forms. According to Twidale (1972a, 1972b), the Australian longitudinal dunes arise from streamwise drifts generated at obstacles in the wind path. A major objection to this idea is that the dune wavelength is much greater than the drift spacing. Although drifting at obstacles may help to localize the dunes, it seems clear that some independent mechanism selects the ultimate dune spacing. It is now widely felt that longitudinal dunes depend on a transverse instability of the wind flow. This notion was first voiced by Madigan (1936, 1946), who opined that the Australian dunes had grown from sand streamers of the sort visible on road surfaces or when snow is driven across ice, but could not successfully resolve the problem of the large scale difference between streamers and dunes. Bagnold’s (1953) proposal as reinforced by Hanna (1969) is more powerful. Bagnold suggested that the forms are Table 1-1 Occurrence and character of longitudinal vortices in the atmospheric boundary layer Authority
Vortex transverse wavelength (km)
Ratio of vortex wavelength to vortex depth
Remarks
Plank. 1966
0.3-5.0
2
wavelengths smaller in mornings than afternoons
Kuettner, 1959
2-8
2
cloud streets
Konrad, 1968
1.5
1.8
clear air convection over Ocean in morning
Markson, 1975
2.0
2.5
cloud streets over Ocean
4.8
1.9
clear air convection over land
36
constructed as sketched in Fig. 1-2a by probably heat-induced secondary currents in the atmospheric boundary layer. This idea was supported by Mabbutt et al. (1969) and, blended with residualist views, by Folk (1971a, 1971b, 1976, 1977) with a reference to the supposedly analogous behaviour of paint rolled out (McEwan and Taylor, 1966). Glennie (1970) also favoured secondary currents, but implied that these arose because of transverse roughness variations, when again dune wavelength may be expected to scale on boundary-layer thickness. As Hanna (1969) has noted, the agreement in scale between dune wavelength and the wavelength of measured atmospheric secondary flows (Table 1-1) lends some support to Bagnold’s concept. But it remains unclear whether the instability vortices have a wholly gravitational origin. The steeper flank of the Australian dunes is invariably towards the convex side of the wind streamlines (Mabbutt et al., 1969), a feature consistent with the inflectional model summarized in Fig. 1-3 and espoused by Wipperman (1969). The crucial experiment, yet to be undertaken, is to measure atmospheric conditions during sand-driving above an actual dune field. That large vortices however caused are associated with the ridges is suggested by the arrangement of accompanying smaller dunes (e.g. H.T.U. Smith, 1963, fig. 13). Unfortunately, Glennie’s (1970, fig. 74) claim to evidence of this kind (see also Cooke and Warren, 1973) is unacceptable, as it can be argued that the dominant wind is now separating from larger and apparently relict older features as it blows obliquely across them. TIDAL CURRENT RIDGES
Although lacking decisive evidence as to their origin, Off (1963) gave the name tidal current ridges to groupings of large sand shoals of compressed sigmoidal to linear plan to be found in estuaries, at the heads of bays and gulfs, and off promontaries and capes. These structures resemble longitudinal desert dunes in scale, parallelism with flow, and the superimposition of smaller sand waves and dunes (Van Veen, 1935), and seem to be their counterparts in the tidal shallow-marine environment. Off (1963), Allen (1966c, 1968b), Swift (1975), and Swift and Ludwick (1976) give general reviews. Figure 1-22 depicts tidal current ridges on the floor of the North Sea off the Norfolk coast (Houboult, 1968; V.N.D. Caston, 1972). Most are of the linear sort, lying parallel with each other at a fairly even transverse spacing or wavelength. They are representative of the ridges as developed in the shallow seas around the British Isles and elsewhere (Van Veen, 1935, 1936, 1938; G.F. Jordan, 1962; Off, 1963; Houboult, 1968; Caston and Stride, 1970; V.N.D. Caston, 1972; Stride, 1973; Lapierre, 1975; Swift, 1975; Hunt et al., 1977). The complex of banks ranging southeastwards from Haisborough Sand to Hearty Knoll (Fig. 1-22) is not untypical of the sigmoidal type
37
Fig. 1-22. Tidal current ridges (Norfolk Banks) in the southern North Sea. Morphology based on Admiralty Hydrographic Department Chart Nr. 1049; inferred sand transport directions (bold mows) from Caston and Stride (1 970).
of ridge, present locally in the open sea (e.g. Van Veen, 1936; Cloet, 1954) but best developed in estuaries and near islands (Newel1 et al., 1951, 1959; Illing, 1954; Robinson, 1956, 1960; Newell and Rigby, 1957; Jakobsen, 1962; Reineck, 1963; M.M. Ball, 1967; Schou, 1967; Ludwick, 1970, 1973; Gohren, 1971; Park, 1974; Dorjes and Reineck, 1977). Tidal current ridges typically are about 4 km apart transversely and 15 m in height, the crests commonly reaching to within a metre or so of the sea surface. Their wavelength (Fig. 1-23) is to a first approximation proportional to the square of the water depth (Off, 1963; Allen, 1966c, 1968b), and their length can exceed 50 km (e.g. Fig. 1-22). Most linear banks and some of the sigmoidal kind are asymmetrical in cross-section, the steeper sides facing consistently in the same direction within each array, despite the extreme length of the ridges (e.g. G.F. Jordan, 1962; Houboult, 1968; Stride, 1974). Most ridges bear sand waves, as Van Veen (1935, 1936) was early to discover. Those to be found on the linear banks, and on many sigmoidal ones with arms of grossly unequal length, face the bank crest on each side
38
I
-L-
0
t I
2
I
4
I
,
6 8 ,oo
2
4
Ridge height, d (sfnoximum
6
8
io~
2
4
6 8
water-depth, h I ( m 1
Fig. 1-23. Geometry of tidal current ridges (data of Off, 1963).
but lie obliquely to the crest on similar trends (e.g. V.N.D. Caston, 1972). On the equal-armed sigmoidal banks lie symmetrically arranged sand waves or dunes facing in the same direction as the closure of the crest (e.g. Gohren, 1971; Park, 1974). Seismic profiling and shallow coring tell something of the internal structure of tidal current ridges (McKee and Sterrett, 1961; Seibold, 1964; Imbrie and Buchanan, 1965; M.M. Ball, 1967; Houboult, 1968; Park, 1974). Many prove to be wholly constructional features, resting on a level substrate which extends beneath them between exposures on the floors of the adjacent channels. Multiple internal reflectors are commonly evident, dipping in the same direction and at a similar gentle slope to the steeper side of the ridge. Evidently the banks grow or move partly in the same direction as the steeper face. Even though large sand waves are commonly superimposed, the shelly sands making up the banks are cross-bedded on a modest scale and commonly bioturbated. Cross-bed dip directions show little consistency. Houboult (1968) records foresets from the Norfolk banks dipping down, along and up the ridge faces. Tidal current ridges occur in a complex hydraulic regime which is so far ill-understood. But it is clear that the linear banks lie approximately parallel with the strongest tidal flows (e.g. Houboult, 1968), and that the sigmoidal ones are coupled with mutually evasive flood and ebb currents, each segment closing in the direction of the dominant tidal flow (Van Veen, 1936, 1950;
39
Robinson, 1956; Jakobsen, 1962; Schou, 1967). Moreover, V.N.D. Caston ( 1972) has persuasively demonstrated how the sigmoidal and linear banks
may be related as stages within an evolutionary morphological series. Off (1963) sketched an hypothesis of the origin of tidal current ridges which involved transverse instabilities in the tidal flows as the cause of “bands of slower current” in which the structures accumulated, although his analogy with river channels is perhaps far-fetched. Allen (1968b, 1968g), Houboult (1968), and Caston and Stride (1970) backed this implied role of secondary currents, for which Houboult could adduce some confirmatory field evidence. On the sea over the channels between ridges, he found long foam and debris lines which he took to indicate the surface convergence of the flow in paired vortices similar to those sketched in Fig. 1-2a. Over or near the crests, were zones where wave properties changed, suggesting surface divergence and a corresponding bottom convergence close to the ridge crests. However, the apparent secondary flow has a much larger scale than that believed to be associated with sand ribbons in similar depths, and its cause is mysterious. The asymmetry of the Norfolk ridges suggested to Caston and Stride that the vortices of each pair had unequal strengths. The stronger must lie on the western side of the ridge, in order to explain the steeper northeastern face and the reflectors suggesting lateral migration in that direction. Stride ( 1974) later showed that the steeper side of linear banks tended to face the direction in which the tidal current rotates relative to the direction of net sediment transport, and argued that the asymmetry depends on this through a lag effect (see also Postma, 1967; Huthnance, 1973). McCave (1979) has doubted both the secondary-flow model and Stride’s (1974) lag effect, on the basis of measurements of the profile of velocity at the North Hinder Lightship, 3 km to the west-northwest of the North Hinder Bank in the Southern Bight of the North Sea. According to him, the near-bed current deviates in direction from the velocity at 10m below the surface in a manner inconsistent with the presence of a secondary flow. This is correct only if, as McCave assumes, the measurements came from the cell characterized by a bottom-current directed toward the crest of the bank. As the North Hinder Lightship is sited in a trough flanking the bank, however, it is -quite possible that the next cell outward was sampled, in which case his observations support the presence of a secondary flow. McCave’s study cannot be regarded as resolving the question of the hydrodynamic controls on tidal current ridges. Many shallow-marine cross-bedded sandstone and limestone formations may have arisen partly as tidal current ridges (e.g. Sedimentation Seminar, 1966; Narayan, 1971; Pryor, 1971; D.D. Carr, 1973), though such an origin is not proved until the form of the banks is demonstrated. An exceptionally large quarry revealed to Allen and Kaye (1973) a mud-bounded asymmetrical shoal of longitudinally transported cross-bedded calcarenite measuring 6 m in height and about 800m wide across the base. Although the quarry was too small to reveal more than one shoal, similar deposits abound at the
40
same stratigraphic level, suggesting that a complex of banks resembling tidal current ridges exists in the area. Small shoals which seem to be ridges possibly of the sigmoidal type are described from late Precambrian quartzites in north Norway (H.D. Johnson, 1977a).
RIDGE-AND-FURROW MOULDS
On the underside of some turbidite sandstones, particularly if thin and fine grained, are preserved the moulds of small, closely packed, longitudinal ridges and furrows originally shaped in mud (Fig. 1-24). These have been called longitudinal ripple-load-casts (Kelling and Walton, 1957), rill marks (Dzulynski and Slaczka, 1958), longitudinal ridges (Craig and Walton, 1962), furrow casts (McBride, 1962; Potter and Pettijohn, 1963), dendritic ridges (Dzulynski and Walton, 1963; Enos, 1969a), and longitudinal ridges and furrows (Dzulynski, 1965; Dzulynski and Walton, 1963, 1965; Kemper, 1968). In the same category fall some of Pettijohn and Potter’s (1964) flute
Fig. 1-24. Ridge and furrow moulds, Silurian rocks, Southern Uplands, Scotland. Current from left to right. Specimen approximately 0.35 m long. Photograph courtesy of E.K. Walton (see Dzulynski and Walton, 1965).
41
casts, together with the flute moulds Kuenen (1957) described as being “fine-textured” or resembling “rep tilean scales” and “fern fronds”. It is clear from the moulds (Fig. 1-24) that the original ridges are narrow and sharp-crested, joining at intervals downcurrent at “tuning-fork” junctures. Their average transverse spacing or wavelength varies between a few millimetres to a maximum of about 0.06 m and is typically about 0.01 m. The furrows between ridges are broad and range from shallow and flatbottomed to deep and rounded. Some furrows are smooth and even along their length, whereas bthers have a coarsely granular appearance. Many furrows are crossed transversely at fairly regular intervals by evenly spaced curved ridges that are concave downcurrent and bound shallow flute-like hollows, the arrangement with the main ridges creating a ladder-like effect. Ridge-and-furrow moulds are often the only structure present beneath turbidite sandstones, varying from straight to meandrine in plan and covering the sole completely (Kuenen, 1957; McBride, 1962; Potter and Pettijohn, 1963; A.M. Anderson, 1976). Unusually large exposures.(e,g. .Kruit et al., 1975) reveal lines of convergence and divergence amongst the ridges which allow them to be divided between linear zones in each of which a similar orientation is maintained. Ridge-and-furrow moulds, or structures very like them, are occasionally associated with other sole marks, for example, isolated flute moulds (Dzulynski, 1963; Parkash, 1970) and various wave-like structures (Pettijohn and Potter, 1964). Craig and Walton (1962) did much to clarify understanding of the origin of ridge-and-furrow moulds. Using the then relatively new concept of turbidity currents, they suggested that the structures were “the result of scour at a late phase of current flow when movement near the base of the flow occurred in lines or stringers”. Dzulynski and Walton (1963) found experimentally that the structures could be produced when the crenulated front of a layer of water or of a small turbidity current advanced over weakly cohesive mud, the crenulations and ridges agreeing in wavelength. From these and later experiments there grew up the idea that the ridges and furrows were erosional structures dependent on gravity-induced secondary flows generated at the heads of turbidity-currents (Dzulynski, 1965; Dzulynski and Walton, 1965; Dzulynski and Simpson, 1966a, 1966b). The lobe-andcleft structure of gravity current heads (J.E. Simpson, 1969, 1972; Allen, 1971b) was not at that time understood, however, and the instability was limited strictly to the visibly overhanging current nose. According to our model (Fig. 1-6), the unstable zone extends much further back into the head. The furrows can be associated with the lobes in the model and with the bottom-divergent secondary flows lying back from them. The link with lobes, noticed by Dzulynski (1965), is supported by the expectation that the flow is most powerful behind these bulges (Allen, 1971b). The ridges, where there has been less erosion, must therefore be associated with the weaker currents flowing in the tunnels entered through the clefts. J.E. Simpson
42
(1972) found that as the head advanced, the clefts repeatedly joined up and reformed at new points on the lobes, in a manner consistent with the ridges and their downcurrent-pointing junctures having originated at these features. That such geometrical and kinematic features of the nose and near-nose of turbidity currents can be preserved suggests that the flows creating ridge-and -furrow moulds were relatively small and gentle, a view supported by Simpson’s experimental results on the scaling of the clefts. It seems possible that the mud beds were not eroded in a conventional sense but, being weakly cohesive, were moulded plastically by the current with little accompanying loss. If they were corraded to produce the furrows and ridges, then the tools responsible have left no individual traces of their work. Clefts seem to occur at more than one characteristic transverse spacing (Dzulynski, 1965; J.E. Simpson, 1969, 1972), implying that a hierarchy of secondary flows exists in the head of a gravity current. Such hierarchies could explain the patterns of converging and diverging currents which can
Fig. 1-25. Pattern of secondary currents recorded by ridge-and-furrow moulds on the underside of a turbidite sandstone in the Tertiary deep-sea fan deposits of the San Sebastian area, northern Spain (inferred from photograph bottom of p. 36 in Kruit et al., 1975). In order to facilitate comparison with the original photograph, the reader sees the current as though looking upward through the sea bed. If the ridge-and-furrow moulds (spacing approximately 2 centimetres) represent the smallest lobes and clefts developed at the turbidity current head, then the larger scale patterns suggest the occurrence also of lobes and clefts of intermediate (spacing 0.1-0.2 m) and larger (spacing 0.25-0.75 m) sizes.
43
sometimes be inferred (Fig. 1-25) from ridge-and-furrow moulds on large bedding surfaces (J.M. Clarke, 1917; Kruit et al., 1975). The frequent addition of ladders of flute-like features suggests that the secondary currents were accompanied by a mode of longitudinal instability. The model given in Fig. 1-6 may also explain (Allen, 1971b) why some flute moulds occur in regularly spaced longitudinal clusters (Kuenen, 1957; Dzulynski, 1963; Dzulynski and Walton, 1965). Presumably the clusters were scoured by the vigorous flows behind lobes, the currents at the loci of clefts being too weak materially to affect the bed.
WAVE-RELATED FURROWS AND RIDGES
A readily disturbed balance between erosion and deposition exists at the margins of lakes, seas, and oceans. Where erosion prevails, and the margins are muddy, wave-controlled scour shapes a characteristic spatial sequence of forms elongated perpendicular to the coastline, which assume a scale possibly related to wave size and a horizontal extent dependent on bed slope and
Fig. 1-26. Schematic development at the edge of a retreating tidal marsh or mud bank of erosional furrows and ridges related to wave action.
44
water-level range. I have seen this sequence bordering small Swedish lakes and on the Louisiana shore, but it is most spectacularly developed under a large tidal range, as on the North Sea coasts. Where net erosion prevails here (Fig. 1-26), the salt marsh and high tidal-flat muds are cut into deeply embayed cliffs, which give way downslope to mazes of anastomosing furrows with intervening mounds, in turn displaced seaward by yardang-like whalebacks and pillars rising from a plain of rippled sand veneering a level surface abraded into mud. That the features are erosional is clear from many details of their form. Lamination appears on the sides of embayments, for example, and on the flanks of the mounds is exploited in the formation of encircling terraces and overhangs. Plant roots and the shells of deeply burrowing bivalves (e.g. Scrobiculuriu) are commonly exposed along the crests of the mounds. Not only is rippled sand abundant on the floors of the furrows between mounds, but gravel and shells are often to be found. The sides and floors of the furrows are smooth and commonly criss-crossed by striae and small grooves, suggesting that the muddy substrate was corraded by this debris. Strong wave surges can in fact be observed between mounds when partly inundated, and the presence of gravel and shells testifies also to the current strength. There are several mainly early allusions to the presence of these features on intertidal flats (Steers, 1934; Guilcher, 1958a; J.R. Marshall, 1962; G. Evans, 1965), and more details are given by Wohlenberg (1954), Inglis and Kestner ( 1958), V.J. Chapman ( 1960), Hawkes ( 1962), Greensmith and Tucker (1966), Kidson and Manton (1973), Reineck (1974b), Kestner (1975), Larsonneur (1975), and Augustinus (1978, 1980). Typically, the mounds are about 0.5 m apart transversely and about 0.25 m deep. Although these features generally lie at a high angle to the coastline, and nearly at right-angles to the crests of refracted waves, most authors explicitly or implicitly associate them with tidal current-action. Hawkes attributed the structures to corrasion during wave backwash. Forms similar to those in Fig. 1-26 are known to be developed on glacial tills (Steers, 1946), beachrock (Emery and Cox, 1956; Russell, 1959; McLean, 1967; Alexandersson, 1969, 1973), Mississippi delta mudlumps (Morgan and Andersen, 1961), and other hard substrates (Swinnerton, 1927; Cloud, 1959; Kaye, 1959; Shiells, 1963) in the littoral zone. Figure 1-27a shows examples with gravel fills from a marine rock-platform (calcretized mudstone of Devonian age), and I have also found them on chalk platforms. The instances shown in Fig. 1-27b were scoured into plastic mud by sand accompanied by a little gravel and shell. The presence of tools, and the observed action of waves, has led to the widespread acceptance of these littoral structures as due to wave-controlled corrasion, though rilling by fresh water is assigned importance by McLean. The structures that Shiells described are recent, as they lie at right-angles to the coast and are not definitely preserved within a rock sequence. Instances of sublittoral furrows and ridges are known. Forms spaced
45
Fig. 1-27. Erosional furrows and ridges related to wave action. a. In hard red mudstone with calcite nodules and veins, Red Marls (Devonian), Swanlake Bay, Dyfed, Wales. Hammer 0.33 m long points seaward. b. In recent intertidal muds undergoing erosion, seaward side of Scolt Head Island, Norfolk, England. Trowel 0.28 m long points seaward. Note rippled sand in furrows and weakening of ridges seaward.
46
about 4 m apart were found by Groba (1959) and Seibold (1963) to have been cut into tills on the Baltic Sea coast in water to depths of 2-3 m. Norrman (1964) attributed to corrasion under wave-action a series of slightly smaller structures encountered on a clay surface in the shallows of Lake Vattern. Neev and Emery (1967) observed large areas covered by furrows and ridges when water-level fell in the Dead Sea. Whatever mechanism governs the wave-induced corrasion of cohesive substrates into ridges and furrows aligned with the direction of wavepropagation, it seems necessary to suppose that the vigorous oscillatory wave-currents are accompanied by steadier secondary or perhaps masstransport flows which serve to concentrate into parallel zones the debris acting as tools, so permitting the bed to be eroded differentially. These currents cannot be associated with the short-crestedness of the waves, or with their reflection at the coast, for in these cases the near-bottom mass transports converge and diverge only along shore-parallel zones (Carter, 1972; Carter et al., 1973). Possibly the furrows and ridges are caused by Langmuir circulations (Fig. 1-9) that impinge on the coast. This idea is supported by the apparent dependence of the scale of the structures on the size of the waves, but two difficulties remain. Firstly, a unique directional relationship must exist between wind and wave in order for these secondary flows to arise and, secondly, furrows and ridges appear generally to be much smaller in wavelength than Langmuir vortices, at least as ordinarily developed. A point in favour of the idea is that in lakes (Norrman, 1964; Neev and Emery, 1967), the structures mark the shore exposed to the greatest fetch and the generally stronger and more persistent winds. Furthermore, the larger structures seem to be associated with the bigger fetches. Wave-formed furrows and ridges have a seemingly scanty fossil record. Subfossil examples may occur within Holocene tidal-flat and lagoonal sequences (Kestner, 1962; Van Loon and Wiggers, 1975), and on Quaternary raised beach platforms (J.A. Wright, 1964). The most convincing of older examples are described by Pannekoek (1960) from the Psammites du Condroz (see also Van Straaten, 1954b), and by Macar and Ek (1969, and J.D. Bradshaw (1966). Possibly the erosional grooves and ridges described by Barnes (1965), Goldring (1971), and Baldwin and Johnson (1977) are of a related origin. Unless a sequence of forms like that in Fig. 1-26 can be seen, the exact origin of erosion grooves in shallow-marine sequences seems difficult to determine. WAVE-RELATED GRAVEL STRIPES
On sheltered sandy beaches under calm conditions, I have often met with large numbers of equispaced stripes of granules and fine pebbles trending up and down slope which lie in ranks between contour-parallel gravelly zones
47
Fig. 1-28. Gravel stripes overlying fine to medium-grained sand, North Beach, Tenby, Dyfed, Wales. Trowel 0.28 m long points seaward.
(Fig. 1-28). The stripes can be several metres long but are only 0.1-0.3 m in transverse spacing. They are slightly elevated and the material composing them is apparently moving freely over the close-packed and less mobile sand between and beneath. How these structures arise is unknown, but a roughness-related instability of the wave swash and backwash may be suggested.
SPUR-AND-GROOVE
Where hermatypic corals and salt-water algae flourish, no clear-cut distinction is possible between wholly erosional sublittoral features attributable to furrows and ridges and structures of a similar character in the formation of which the growth of these organisms has played a substantial if not predominant role. These organically-related structures are called spur-and groove, and their existence has been known since coral reefs first attracted the attention of such investigators as Charles Darwin and Agassiz. Spur-and-groove abound along the edges of coral atolls and reefs, where marine algae commonly also flourish (Crossland, 1922; Teichert and Fairbridge, 1948; Tracey et al., 1948; Newell et al., 1951, 1959; Doty and Morrison, 1954; Emery et al., 1954; Munk and Sargent, 1954; Guilcher, 1956; Newell, 1956; Newell and Rigby, 1957; Cloud, 1959; Goreau, 1959; Wiens, 1959; Shinn, 1963; Muller, 1964; Tracey et al., 1964; Maiklem, 1968;
48
Bird, 1971; Purdy et al., 1975; Roberts et al., 1975; Faure and Montaggioni, 1976; Rigby and Roberts, 1976; Sneh and Friedman, 1980). The spur-andgroove are arrays of regularly spaced ridges and hollows which extend perpendicularly out from the reef crest into depths of 20-30m. The spurs have steep and often overhanging sides up to 20m in height. Where wave-action is intense, each spur terminates to seaward in a massive prow-like feature, but otherwise the ridge crest falls gently to the sea floor. The grooves between vary from narrow to broad and flat; their floors are usually strewn with coral and other debris, or covered by a sheet of rippled carbonate sand. The wavelength of spur-and-groove ranges from 10 m to as much as 100 m, depending on water depth and wave climate. The spur-and-groove associated with algal reefs and biostromes are generally much smaller in scale (Eardley, 1938a; Carozzi, 1962; G.R. Davies, 1970b; Stoddart, 1971; Hofmann, 1973; Logan et al., 1974), the structures somewhat resembling externally the furrows and ridges developed by waves. The algal spur-and-groove also lie at right-angles to the water’s edge. Spur and groove appear to be the expression of a complex organo-physical system in which vigorous wave-generated currents can maintain and perhaps enlarge the grooves by corrasion, while organic growth either builds a spur upward and outward or modifies a pre-existing erosional ridge (e.g. Tracey et al., 1948; Emery et al., 1954; Newell, 1956; Cloud, 1959; Shinn, 1963). The system may be similar physically to that involved in the production of the erosional furrows and ridges. Thus coral spur-and-groove generally appear only on the windward side of an atoll or reef (Munk and Sargent, 1948), take a transverse spacing related to wave size (Roberts et al., 1975), and broadly agree in wavelength with oceanic Langmuir circulations (e.g. Faller and Woodcock, 1964; Scott et al., 1969). Fossil spur-and-groove should be detectable, but are so far known only amongst algal bioherms. These are groups of parallel linear mounds which, from their internal structure, have clearly grown upward from an initial substrate, generally while debris (some derived from the bioherms) was accumulated by currents in narrow channels between (P. Hoffman, 1967, 1973, 1974; G.M. Young, 1974; Young and Long, 1976; Button and Vos, 1977; Eriksson, 1977). They are commonly interpreted as lying at right-angles to shore. GLACIAL FLUTINGS
Glaciated terrains commonly display a variety of fairly regularly spaced ridges and hollows that evidently are related to ice flow, as they are elongated approximately parallel with the direction of glacier-movement as shown by accompanying bed-rock striae. The term fluting is usually applied to the more elongated of these features where developed on surfaces underlain by till or stratified drift (Fig. 1-29). Flutings range from small features
49
Fig. 1-29. Air photograph showing glacially fluted till in Athabasca area, Alberta, Canada. Ice moved from left to right. Each square land-holding has side of approximately 400m. Photograph courtesy of J. Shaw, and reproduced by permission of Government of Alberta, Department of Mines, Energy, and Resources.
with heights in the order of 0.1 m and transverse spacings comparable with 1 m, to large ridges and hollows many kilometres in length, up to 20 m in height, and in the order of 500m apart transversely (e.g. Dyson, 1952; Hoppe and Schytt, 1953; Gravenor and Meneley, 1958; Lemke, 1958; Baranowski, 1970; J. Shaw, 1975; Boulton, 1976; Aario, 1977a, 1977b; Ehlers and Stephan, 1979; Heikkinen and Tikkanen, 1979; Moran et al., 1980). Large boulders are commonly found at the up-glacier ends of the smaller flutes, but analogous bed-rock hills are not known to accompany the larger features. Grooves and ridges comparing in size and shape with the larger flutings formed in tills are also known to have been sculptured in crystalline bed-rock (H.T.U. Smith, 1948). The larger flutings as they shorten along their crests grade into the widely distributed glacial landforms known as drumlins (e.g. Ebers, 1926; Gravenor, 1953, 1974; Reed et a]., 1962; Vernon, 1966; Trenhaile, 1971, 1976; A.R. Hill, 1971, 1973a; Finch and Walsh, 1973; Gluckert, 1973; M.J.C. Walker, 1973; G.F. Mitchell, 1976;
50
Aario, 1977a, 1977b; Finch, 1977; Rose and Letzer, 1977; Heikkinen and Tikkanen, 1979; Menzies, 1979a, 1979b). These streamlined hills composed of till or partly of stratified material are generally 10-20m in height and 250-500 m apart transversely, being usually 4- 10 times longer than wide. Their shape has been compared to an ellipsoid (Reed et al., 1962), but a leminscate loop with the blunt end facing up-glacier is a better fit in plan (Chorley, 1962), as is true for yurdungs (Mainguet, 1968, 1972a). The magnetic and particle fabrics of the sediments composing drumlins and flutings have a strong preferred orientation approximately parallel with the elongation direction of these landforms (e.g. Hoppe, 1951; Donner and West, 1957; H.E. Wright, 1957; Gravenor and Meneley, 1958; Andrews and King, 1968; A.R. Hill, 1971; Shaw and Freschauf, 1973; J. Shaw, 1975, 1977; Boulton, 1976; Morris and Morland, 1976). However, Shaw and Freschauf (1973), followed by Heikkinen and Tikkanen (1979), emphasize that there are systematic deviations from strict parallelism, the fabrics in plan showing a regional herringbone pattern related to the distribution of the landscape ridges and hollows (Fig. 1-30a). The particles not only plunge up-glacier, but are inclined away from hollows and towards ridge-crests. The streamlined form, regular spacing, flow-parallel orientation, and fabric properties of drumlins and the larger glacial flutings led Shaw and Freschauf (1973) and Aario ( 1977a) to propose that these landforms are (a)
Clast fabric
4
2
I
- ' *
-
,
I
-
-
-
.
Fig. 1-30. Glacial flutings and their origin. a. Schematic representation of clast long-axis fabrics in fluted till, and the shape of fluted bedrock. b. Possible motion in transverse section of glacier during formation of fluted till. c. Possible motion in transverse section of glacier during formation of bedrock flutes.
51
deposited by till-rich glaciers in which have been developed transversely periodic near-bed motions (Fig. 1-30b), which are or resemble secondary flows like those in Fig. 1-1. Shaw and Freschauf also suggest that glacially formed bed-rock grooves may arise in response to similar motions, but in a regime of differential erosion which permitted negligible till accumulation (Fig. 1-3Oc). These proposals are an advance on the rheological explanation of drumlins developed by Smalley ( 1 966b), Smalley and Unwin (1968), Menzies (1979a), and Whittecar and Mickelson (1979), who merely defined some of the conditions which possibly attend formation of these landforms. But the Shaw-Freschauf theory is itself far from complete, being almost wholly kinematic. Whatever the extent to which ice is capable of lateral movement, perhaps as a consequence of thermal convection (Hughes, 1976), Shaw and Freschauf imply that the motion of glaciers is at times subject to a mode of transverse instability. It is worth noting that an associated longitudinal instability may occasionally be developed, since drumlins are shortcrested and commonly en-echelon. An approach to flutings explicitly from instability may prove fruitful. The Shaw-Freschauf theory also accounts for the smaller morainic flutings. However, when these occur in the lee of large boulders, as is commonly the case, the explanation suggested by Dyson (1952), and elaborated by Boulton (1 976) and by Morris and Morland (1976), appeals more. According to this notion, the shape and fabric structure of boulder-related flutings is consistent with the lateral and upward inflow of mobile till into the spaces which open up in the lee of boulders as the glacier over-rides them. TROUGH BANDING IN LAYERED IGNEOUS ROCKS
Many workers have described, notably from layered basic igneous rocks (e.g. Wager and Deer, 1939; Hess, 1960; Upton, 1960; Emeleus, 1963; E.D. Jackson, 1971), what has come to be termed trough banding, and this structure is particularly clearly seen in the spectacularly exposed Skaergaard Intrusion of East Greenland (Wager and Brown, 1968). Trough banding of the Skaergaard Intrusion appears in the form of sharp-based layers, between 0.1 and 1.0 m thick, in which the content of ferromagnesian minerals declines upward. The layers are remarkably concordant and apparently much longer than wide. In transverse section they are weakly concave-up to flat and with upturned margins, the width generally measuring a few tens of metres. They lie directly above each other, occasionally with a slight and normally erosional offset, to form a vertical stack of several tens that is separated laterally from similar stacks at the same stratigraphical level by vertical zones of largely unbanded rock. The lenses in each stack appear to be elongated in the direction of the axis of the broadly conical (inverted) intrusion, and dip radially inward toward that axis.
52
Wager and Brown (1968) suggested that the trough banding of the Skaergaard Intrusion was formed by the action of intermittent flows, in the nature of turbidity currents, that travelled inward down the axially dipping walls of the magma chamber as it shrank through cooling. Another possibility is that the laterally alternating stacked lenses and unbanded pillars record the existence of Taylor-Gortler vortices within the boundary layer of convection currents existing within the magma. The lower walls and floor of the shrinking magma chamber appear to have been concave-up, and the high apparent viscosity of the magma would have put the Reynolds number almost certainly within the laminar range. It may be suggested from their cross-sectional shape that the trough bands formed where hot and relatively inviscid fluid from the outer part of the boundary layer descended toward the surface of solidification and diverged over this bed. This idea in no way contradicts McBirney and Noyes’s ( 1979) recent important critique of layering mechanisms in basic igneous intrusions, but adds a further dimension to their discussion.
SUMMARY
Transverse modes of instability cause secondary flows in fluids under shear, in which a circulatory motion organized into counter-rotating streamwise cells becomes superimposed on the primary motion. Sand ribbons found on the rocky or gravelly floors of rivers, tidal seas, and deserts are explicable in terms of secondary flows, which heap up the mobile grains into streamwise ridges. The cause of these secondary flows may be the transverse variations of bed roughness that can develop when limited amounts of sediment are available for transport. A variety of erosional grooves and ridges, some found in rivers, others in the desert, and still others in the seas and oceans, point to the differential action of secondary flows where substrates are weak enough to experience generally corrasion. Transverse roughness variations may again promote these motions. Longitudinal desert dunes take a shape and scale relating them to secondary motions affecting the entire atmospheric boundary layer. Their cause may be either an inflectional instability promoted by the rotation of the Earth, or a gravitational instability connected with the rise of air heated at the desert surface. A secondary flow model is also able to explain tidal current ridges. The least understood secondary motions are those which appear to be responsible for longitudinal furrows beneath turbidites, wave-related ridges and stripes, the flutes and grooves observed on till sheets, and the trough banding of layered igneous rocks.
53
Chapter 2
FREE MEANDERING CHANNELS AND LATERAL DEPOSITS INTRODUCTION
A sideways twisting course is often taken by a laterally restricted flow of fluid of a sufficient size and speed when constrained by gravity against a deformable medium. Natural instances of this habit of motion abound, the term meandering being appropriate to unitary flows (Ferguson, 1975). Unquestionably the best known are single-channel rivers wandering in alluvium (e.g. F.A. Melton, 1936; Fisk, 1944; E.W. Lane, 1957), as reviewed recently by Callander (1978). Indeed, for Strabo (Russell, 1954), the River Meander (Buyuk Menderes) in southwest Turkey was the type of “everything winding”, that is, meandering. Less familiar but as important sedimentologically are the meandering channels which serve as the arteries and veins of intertidal flats and salt marshes alluviated by the sea (e.g. Dury, 1972). Meandering is not restricted to free-surface flows in alluvial settings. A thread of water will wind over a tilted glass plate (Tanner, 1962; Gorycki, 1973a). The Gulf Stream meanders (D. Hansen, 1970; Robinson et al., 1974), as do the atmospheric jet streams (Reiter, 1963). Turbidity and other currents seem able to construct meandering channels on deep-sea fans and elsewhere on the ocean floor (e.g. Komar, 1969; Cleary and Conolly, 1974; Egloff and Johnson, 1975; Chough and Hesse, 1976). On land many rivers meander through bed-rock channels containing only trifling amounts of alluvium (Dury, 1964a, 1964b, 1965). Run-off over limestone commonly engenders meandering gutters (e.g. Zeller, 1967a, 1967b; Miotke, 1968), chiefly through the mass-transfer of the rock into the carbonated water. Supraglacial streams typically form meandering channels (e.g. Zeller, 1967a; Knighton, 1972b; Ferguson, 1973b), mainly by ice-melting assisted perhaps by corrasion. This chapter discusses the meandering channels formed by rivers and by tidal streams in an alluvial context; these channels are preservable sedimentary structures. During meandering a characteristic suite of deposits is produced, typified by a distinctive arrangement and structure. Several names have been applied to these (Van Straaten, 1954a; Reineck, 1958a; Allen, 1963b), but the terms lateral-accretion deposit and lateral-accretion structure seem most appropriate. Examples of lateral accretion structure are generally hierarchical, for superimposed on the gross elements expressing channel migration are smaller structures due to the common bedforms. Furthermore, a range of lithologies usually is present. The facies to which lateral accretion deposits contribute is, with its upward-fining cyclothems, one of the most important and distinctive in the geological record.
54
FLUVIAL AND TIDAL MEANDERS
Meander settings Traditionally, meanders are ranged between two end-members. In one limiting setting (Fig. 2-la) the channel lies in bed-rock or ice, associated with little or no alluvium. Such channels are called incised (Jefferson, 1902; Dury, 1964a) or intrenched (Hack, 1965), though Kirkby’s (1972) non-committal “non-alluvial” is most appropriate. The second limiting setting (Fig. 2- Ic) shows channels in contact everywhere with alluvium previously deposited in or near them. These are Jefferson’s (1902) “meanders on flood plains”, the spilling meanders of Blench (1957), the free meanders of Dury (1964a) and Carlston (l965), and the appropriately named alluvial meanders of Hack (1965) and Kirkby (1972). At least one intermediate setting demands recognition (Fig. 2-lb). It is exemplified by the confined alluvial meanders of Galay et al. (1973) and Mollard (1973), as foreshadowed by E.W. Lane (1957) in his intermediate class “where the stream form is partly determined by the rock of the earth’s crust and partly by the stream itself”. Confined alluvial meanders have their lateral growth restricted by relatively resistant terrace deposits or bed-rock. Only confined alluvial and alluvial meanders are of concern in what now follows. Many rivers display confined alluvial meanders. Good examples (Figs. 2-2, 2-3) occur on the Beaver River (Blench, 1969; Mollard, 1973) and the
/
Flow
Fig. 2-1. Schematic settings for meandering channels. a. Incised into bedrock or other cohesive substrate. b. Laterally confined between bedrock walls. c. Freely meandering in alluvium.
55
Red Deer River (Neill, 1964, 1967; McPherson, 1969). Other cases are the Klaralven (De Geer, 191I ; Sundborg, 1956), the Oulanka (Koutaniemi, 1979), the Oka (Shantzer, 1951), the San Joaquin and Lower Missouri (F.A. Melton, 1936; Schmudde, 1963), and parts of the Omo (Butzer, 1971). Tidal meanders of any kind are ill-known, and I am unable to cite any explicit descriptions of the confined alluvial type of this origin. Examples may nevertheless exist in the Nigerian and eastern North American tide-lands (Allen, 1965e; Daboll, 1969.; Farrell, 1970; S.C. Harrison, 1972), where creeks cut back into resistant Pleistocene and older deposits. Alluvial river meanders are much described. Typical examples are found on the Pembina River (F.A. Melton, 1936; Blench, 1969) and the Qu'Appelle River (Mollard, 1973), which follow a tortuous path flanked by a broad floodplain with many abandoned meander loops (Fig. 2-4). Further examples in the Americas are the Mississippi (Fisk, 1944), Yukon (Wahrhaftig, 1965), Minnedosa (Galay et al., 1973), Assiniboine (Mollard, 1973), White (Brice, 1974a), Beatton (Hickin, 1974; Nanson, 1980), the Amazon (Tricart, 1977), and Rio Tebicuary (Rich, 1942). Many Papuan rivers exemplify the type (Speight, 1965a, 1965b; Blake and Ollier, 1971), as do the Taieri in New Zealand (A.P. Grant, 1950), the Meander (Russell, 1954) and Jordan (Schatt ner, 1962) in the Near East, and the Omo in Africa (Butzer, 1971). Tide-shaped alluvial meanders are little known. Fig. 2-5 is representative
Fig. 2-2. Air photograph (6 by 4.5 km) showing the confined meanders of the Beaver River, Saskatchewan, Canada. Flow from right toward lower left. Original photograph supplied by the Surveys and Mapping Branch, Department of Energy, Mines and Resources.
56
Fig. 2-3. Part of the Red Deer River, Alberta, Canada. River flow from top toward bottom of photograph, which represents an area measuring approximately 2.5 by 3.75 km. Photograph courtesy of C.R. Neill, and reproduced by permission of Government of Alberta, Department of Mines, Energy, and Resources.
57
Fig. 2-4. Air photograph (4 by 6km) showing the alluvial meanders and many cut-off channels of the Qu'Appelle River, near Broadview, Saskatchewan, Canada. River flows from bottom toward top. Original photograph supplied by the Surveys and Mapping Branch, Department of Energy, Mines and Resources.
58
Fig. 2-5. Meandering tidal channels in mangrove swamps, near Sombreiro River, Niger delta, Nigeria. Picture represents an area measuring approximately 3 by 4.5 km. Photograph reproduced by permission of Government of Nigeria.
of channels found in the mangrove-inhabited intertidal flats of low latitudes (see Allen, 196%; MacNae, 1966, 1968; Coleman et al., 1970; Dury, 1972). All of the channels are meandering, but whereas the larger form a net, the
59
smaller are dendritic, as with rivers. In higher latitudes, where the intertidal flats lack standing vegetation, meandering is invariably associated with dendritic channel systems (e.g. Van Straaten, 1954a; Pestrong, 1972a, 1972b; Bridges and Leeder, 1976). In the essentially supratidal salt-marsh environment, however, mixed reticulate and dendritic meander networks are found (e.g. Steers, 1934, 1960; Langbein, 1963; Myrick and Leopold, 1963; Pestrong, 1965; Land and Hoyt, 1966). As in lower latitudes, larger channels tend to monopolize the reticulate networks. Analysis and description
It is one thing to formulate a qualitative conception of meandering, but more difficult to define and analyse real meanders in a way leading to quantitative treatment. Fig. 2-6a illustrates a meandering channel. Since the edges of the water surface define the channel margins, in order to draw the channel and measure channel width ( W ) , we must also define the discharge-condition in the channel. Taking river and tidal channels as expressed on air-photographs or maps, the discharge-condition generaIly implied is that of bankfull or near-bankfull flow. The channel centreline possesses a series of inflection points, I,,I,, ...,I, which, following Brice (1964), may be joined by a smooth curve, the meander-belt axis. Developing E.W. Lane’s ( 1957) treatment, the
Pool
Riffle
Bar
Riffle
Fig. 2-6. River channel and talweg meanders. a. Definition diagram for river meanders. b. Meandering thalweg in a straight channel, showing relationship to pools and riffles (crossings).
60
meander belt lies between tangents to the outsides of the curves or meanders of the active stream. The meander-belt margins are the tangent-lines themselves, the meander-belt width ( M ) being the distance between opposite margins. These conceptions harmonize with general usage (Jefferson, 1902; Hjulstrom, 1942; Leopold and Wolman, 1960; Nagabhushanaiah, 1967; Zeller, 1967a; Chang and Toebes, 1970; Chitale, 1970). For Matthes (1941), however, the meander-belt embraces cut-off as well as active channels, and so can be wider than the meander-belt in Fig. 2-6a. Carlston (1965) uses “meander width” synonymously with meander-belt width. Meanders themselves next claim attention. Following Matthes ( 1941) and E.W. Lane (1957)’ a meander comprises two consecutive meander loops, in one of which, to the right of the meander-belt axis looking downstream, the flow is anticlockwise, and in the other of which, to the left of this axis, the flow is clockwise. With tidal channels, however, “downstream” may become a matter for choice. In every case the channel segment lying between every second inflection point comprises one meander. Each loop embraces a body of sediment called a point bar, the surface of which may show curved ridges and swales called meander scrolls (e.g. Nanson, 1980). The meander wauelength ( L ) is the distance measured along the meander-belt axis between one inflection point and the next but one downstream (Carlston, 1965; Zeller, 1967a; Chang and Toebes, 1970). Wavelength has also been measured between points of tangency on the meander-belt margins (Matthes, 1941; Inglis, 1947; E.W. Lane, 1957; Chitale, 1970). Alternatively, the spacing of inflection points at the base of a meander loop-Brice’s (1974b) “loop length’’-may be used to measure meander size, where the loop length is about one-half the wavelength (Jefferson, 1902; Popov, 1965; Kondrat’yev, 1969). Finally, meander size may be specified by the meander-path length ( A ) , the distance along the channel centreline between alternate inflection points (Chitale, 1970; Ferguson, 1973a). Other measures may be useful. The meander-loop length ( A ) , roughly Brice’s (1964, 1974a, 1974b) “height of arc”, is the distance along the axis of a meander loop betwen the meander-belt axis and the channel centreline. The loop axis carries midway the centroid, a reference point used by Brice (1974a) in studying meander migration. The meander-loop length is roughly equivalent to one-half of the meander width of E.W. Lane (1957) and Nagabhushanaiah ( 1967), or one-half of the so-called meander amplitude (Leopold and Wolman, 1960; Leopold et al., 1964; Carlston, 1965; Chang and Toebes, 1970). Meander-loop shape may partly be described by the meander-loop radius (r,,,),measured at the channel centreline. Also expressive of shape is the meander-loop central angle ( O ) , introduced independently by Popov ( 1965) and Brice (1974b). It is measured between normals to the channel centreline at inflection points. Kondrat’yev (1969) uses a whole suite of descriptive angular measures.
61
Of these measures, meander wavelength particularly has been criticized (Carlston, 1965; Speight, 1965a), for how should one choose the “typical” meander where no two meanders are exactly the same? Carlston met this difficulty by calculating an average wavelength, but even this procedure leaves considerable room for error and subjectivity. Attempts have therefore been made to objectify the assessment of meander scale by evaluating spectra and autocorrelograms for channel direction and direction-change series (Speight, 1965a, 1965b, 1967; Toebes and Chang, 1967; Chang and Toebes, 1970; Thakur and Scheidegger, 1970; Ferguson, 1975, 1977a). The outcome has been most encouraging. The results based on the different series and methods agree satisfactorily and, at least in the case of Speight’s Australasian streams, there is evidence of more than one significant modal meander wavelength. It is even possible to extract numerical measures of meander regularity from the direction and direction-change series. These techniques may seldom be applicable to palaeochannels, however, because high-quality information is required about relatively long segments of channel (see Ferguson, 1977b). In describing meander planimetric form, two aspects are of interest: the shape of the channel centreline, and the degree of parallelism of the channel margins. Four types of plan are recognized, following Brice ( 1974a, 1974b) in preference to Chitale ( 1970), namely simple symmetrical, simple asymmetrical, compound symmetrical, and compound asymmetrical (Fig. 2-7). Some of Brice’s compound asymmetrical loops and Hickin’s (1974) T bends are whole SYMMETRY SYMMETRICAL
ASYMMETRICAL
BANK CONFORMITY
I
Fig. 2-7. Classification of meander shapes, in terms of number and symmetry of bends, and conformity of banks.
62
meanders in terms of Fig. 2-6a. Parallel-sided and beaded are terms useful in describing the relationship between the margins of loops (Fig. 2-7). In a parallel-sided loop, the channel is of virtually constant width (K.S. Richards, 1976c) and the margins are similarly curved. However, the margins of a beaded loop are distinctly non-parallel and usually are oppositely curved. Ahnert (1960) first singled out beaded meanders, though he did not use this term. All river and most tidal meanders seem to be parallel-sided, at least at high discharges. Simple symmetrical fluvial meanders appear on the Pop0 Agie (Leopold and Wolman, 1957) and the Mississippi, notably near Greenville, Mississippi (Fisk, 1944, 1947). Many symmetrical tidal meanders are shown in Fig. 2-5. The Beaver and Red Deer Rivers (Figs. 2-2, 2-3) and the Klaralven (Sundborg, 1956) abound in asymmetrical simple meanders, which in planimetric form unequivocally indicate the flow direction (Raisz, 1955). Indeed, their asymmetry is frequently so marked that it amounts to the almost complete suppression of alternate quarters of a sinusoidal meander path. Compound symmetrical and asymmetrical meanders appear on numerous rivers (e.g. Schattner, 1962; Brice, 1964, 1974a, 1974b; Butzer, 1971; Hickin, 1974) as well as on many tidal channels (e.g. Fig. 2-5). Beaded meander loops are recorded from tide-lands in middle latitudes (e.g. Ahnert, 1960; Langbein, 1963; Dury, 1967; S.C. Harrison, 1972) and nearer the Equator (Allen, 1965~;Hervieu, 1968; see also Fig. 2-5). Generally, only the larger channels take the beaded form. No comprehensive classification of channel planimetric form has yet been advanced within which meandering channels may adequately be fitted and subdivided. Existing schemes fail in that the attributes of individual meanders are not distinguished clearly enough from those of meander belts and even of valleys. Schumm ( 1963a) considered only single channels, recognizing straight, transitional, regular, irregular, and tortuous patterns. All but the first are meandering, as this term is used here (Ferguson, 1975), and the last three categories combine aspects of meander shape with meander-belt crookedness. Chitale's ( 1970) scheme has similar limitations. In Dury's ( 1969) classification, only irregular and meandering channels are distinguished, presumably by appeal to a certain but unspecified regularity of appearance. Rust ( 1978) distinguished meandering from braided channels. The cross-sectional shape of a meander loop systematically changes from one station to another downstream (Figs. 2-6a and 2-8). Near an inflection point, the high-stage channel is relatively shallow and uniform in depth. These shallows constitute a rijfle or crossing where bars may emerge at low flows. Proceeding downstream into the bend, however, the cross-section grows increasingly asymmetrical and triangular, with a gradual outward shift of the fairway towards the outer concave bank and an increase in the maximum depth. Such a curved deep, called a pool, lies close to the apex of each loop. The surface of the adjacent point bars on the inner convex bank
63
0
C
C'
2 4 6
t Depth
(m)
'L/
c'
Depth (m)
Depth
00 - 2 m 2-4m
0 4 - 6 m
a
6-8m
Fig. 2-8. Secondary currents in a meander of the R. Desna, U.S.S.R.,illustrated by measured streamwise (U') and transverse (U,)components of velocity in representative cross-sections. After Rozovskii (196 1).
may be either convex-upward, straight, or concave-upward. This pattern of cross-sections is reversed as the flow passes out of the bend. Hence the river thalweg which connects the points of maximum depth in successive crosssections, swings from one channel margin to the other as each meander is traced round, as is especially clear at low flow (e.g. Grant, 1948; Hickin, 1974). The thalweg also oscillates vertically, descending from riffles into pools and either flattening out or ascending from pools to riffles. This distinctive three-dimensional geometry is shown by meandering rivers from the smallest (Wolman and Leopold, 1957; Leopold and Wolman, 1960; Wiethe, 1970; Leopold, 1973; Knighton, 1974), through those of intermediate scale (Ripley, 1927; Van Bendegom, 1947; Sundborg, 1956; Rozovskii, 1961; Nilsson and Martvall, 1972; Paulissen, 1973; R.G. Jackson, 1975), to the most majestic (Ripley, 1927; Fisk, 1947; NEDECO, 1959; Tietze, 1975). Tidal meanders are similar (Myrick and Leopold, 1963; Land and Hoyt, 1966; Dury, 1967; Reineck, 1970a; Pestrong, 1972a; Bridges and Leeder, 1976), though the beaded examples usually have a thalweg divided at
64
inflection points by mid-channel bars (Ahnert, 1960; Myrick and Leopold, 1963). In so-called straight channels (Fig. 2-6b), a riffle-pool topography and, consequently, a weakly meandering thalweg usually appear (Hensen, 1943; Leliavsky, 1955; Wolman, 1955; Kinoshita, 1957; Shamov, 1959; Fahnestock and Maddock, 1964; Leopold et al., 1964; Harms and Fahnestock, 1965; Popov, 1965; Kennedy, 1966; A.G. Anderson, 1967; Dolling, 1968; Maddock, 1969; Keller and Melhorn, 1974; Yang and Stall, 1974; K.S. Richards, 1976a). Alternate, side, or transverse bars (Allen, 1968g), firmly to loosely attached to alternate banks, define the sinuous fairway. The unstable behaviour of artificially straightened rivers (Noble and Palmquist, 1968; Yang and Stall, 1974; Lewin, 1976), drainage ditches (Dury, 1964a), and laboratory sand-bedded channels (e.g. Tiffany and Nelson, 1939; Quraishy, 1944; Friedkin, 1945; Wolman and Brush, 1961; Ackers, 1964; Ackers and Charlton, 1970b, 1970c; Schumm and Khan, 1971, 1972) leave little doubt that the riffle-pool systems of straight and of meandering channels are morphologically and dynamically equivalent, as Leopold and Wolman ( 1957) had tentatively concluded. The general topological and dynamical equivalence of the two forms of channel now seems agreed upon (Dury, 1969; Chang et al., 1971; Keller, 1972; K.S. Richards, 1976a; Keller and Melhorn, 1978), setting aside Tinkler’s unsupported views (Tinkler, 1970, 1971; Keller, 1971). Channel crookedness is the ratio of a characteristic channel length measured between two inflection points to either the air-line distance, the valley length, or the meander-belt axial length between the points. Early crookedness measures are Friedkin’s (1945) sinuosity, the ratio of thalweg length to air-line distance, and E.W. Lane’s (1957) tortuosity ratio, the stream channel (centreline) length compared with the valley length. Other early proposals are the ratio of thalweg length to valley length (Leopold and Wolman, 1957), and the ratio of meander-path length to meander wavelength within one meander (Leopold and Wolman, 1960). Measures involving thalweg length are seldom practical, however, and a restriction to single meanders presupposes a regularity of channel that is unlikely to exist. Later workers have stressed the contribution to overall crookedness that may come from the curvatures of meander belts and confining valleys (Brice, 1964; Mueller, 1968; Mansikkaniemi, 1972). We may therefore recognize sinuosity, defined as the ratio of channel length (centreline) to meander-belt axial length, preferably measured over numerous consecutive meanders (Brice, 1964; Dury, 1969), and tortuosity, which is the ratio of channel length (centreline) to air-line distance. The two measures will be numerically equal only for a precisely rectilinear meander belt; the tortuosity otherwise will generally exceed the sinuosity, though in many practical cases the difference may be negligibly small.
65
Hydromorphological relationships Engineers favouring “regime” theory (Blench, 1957), and geomorphologists stimulated by Leopold and Maddock’s (1953) outstanding work, found that the geometry of river and tidal channels depended fairly conservatively on discharge, both at-a-station, downstream within one system, and between comparable systems. The relationships involving channel width, depth, mean velocity and sediment load were originally classed under the term “hydraulic geometry”, but a grouping with other relevant dependencies under “hydromorphological relationships” may perhaps be more useful because, under the concept of hydromorphology, we can more readily look beyond the descriptive toward dynamic meanings. The dependence of width, depth and flow velocity upon discharge is now known for many rivers (e.g. Leopold and Maddock, 1953; Wolman, 1955; Leopold and Miller, 1956; Brush, 1961; Hedman, 1970; Thornes, 1970; Stall and Yang, 1972; Knighton, 1972a, 1974; Bray, 1973; Neill, 1973a) and a few tidal channels (Langbein, 1963; Myrick and Leopold, 1963; Pestrong, 1965; Dury, 1967, 1972). In terms of the conventional power functions (linear in logarithms):
W = aQ“
(2.1)
H =be“
(2.2)
U = cQp
(2.3) where W is channel width, H is mean channel depth, U is mean flow velocity averaged over the cross-section affording W and H, and Q is discharge. By continuity, Q = WHU, whence the intercept coefficients ( a , b , c ) and the exponents (m,n,p) conform to (Leopold and Maddock, 1953): abc= 1
(2 -4)
m+n+p=l
(2.5)
At a station, W, H, U and Q are instantaneous values. When downstream changes are considered, W, H, and U at the various stations take values appropriate to a selected level of discharge, for example, bankfull. The at-a-station exponents vary widely between sites on a river (e.g. Knighton, 1974), largely in response to bank strength. Because bed roughness varies with discharge, eqs. (2.1-2.3) prove in detail to be non-linear (K.S. Richards, 1973, 1976b), an observation which may weaken some theories of hydraulic geometry (Langbein, 1964; T.R. Smith, 1974). The exponents for downstream change seem more conservative. Average values for North American mid-western rivers are m = 0.50, n = 0.40, and p = 0.10 (Leopold and Maddock, 1953). The corresponding set for tidal channels reads approximately m = 0.75, n = 0.20, p = 0.05 (Langbein, 1963; Myrick and Leopold, 1963), the difference perhaps reflecting the fact that these
66
-E
lo4
-
I .
o Dury (1965)
f0
Hack (1965)
;
0 3 -
0 L
a
0
f
I02
-
10'
-
2
0
loo
O
,oo-a-Drainage basin area, A (m')
Fig. 2-9. Meander wavelength as a function of drainage basin area for a sample of North American, English, and French rivers. Data of Dury (1 965) and Hack ( 1 965).
channels are arteries as well as veins. Park (1977) has recently reviewed the hydromorphological exponents. Of special interest in palaeohydraulics are the alluvial meander wavelength-discharge relationship and, since discharge reflects drainage-basin area, the wavelength-area dependence. Only Dury (1958, 1964a, 1964b, 1965) and Hack (1965) assembled data linking river meander wavelength with basin area upstream, but really large basins unfortunately were excluded (Fig. 2-9). The visual best-fit line reads: L = 0.23A0.345
showing that wavelength gradually increases with area. Although wavelength also increases gradually with discharge (Inglis, 1947, 1949; Leopold and Wolman, 1957; Dury, 1964a, 1964b, 1965, 1976; Carlston, 1965; Speight, 1967; Zeller, 1967a; Ackers and Charlton, 1970b), Ackers and Charlton's (1970b) careful critique shows that we are far from the goal of an accurate dependence based on reliable and compatible observations. Observers have measured wavelength differently, and the quoted discharges seldom came directly from on-site rating curves. On the basis of Jefferson's (1902) and his own data, Inglis linked wavelength to the square-root of discharge, a relationship accepted and embellished by Leopold and Wolman, Dury, and Zeller. Carlston rejected this analysis, producing several rather consistent relationships:
L = 170Qi,46 L = 24.5Qt.62 L = 120Qi:
67
Mean discharge of month of maximum discharge, Omm(m3a-~)
2 I02
, , ,/ : 2
4 68i01
/ , 2
I
,,
4 6 EI02
,
, , ,,
,
2
4 6EiO3
2
Bankfull discharge,
, , ,,
,
4 6ElO4 2
I
,
4 6 E
4(m3s-I)
2
2
10
* Mean annual discharge, Om, (m3
d)
Fig. 2-10. Meander wavelength as a function of three measures of discharge in a sample of North American rivers. Data of Carlston (1965).
where the meander wavelength, L , is the mean of 6-8 observations, Q ,, is mean annual discharge, Qb is bankfull discharge, and Q , , is the mean discharge of the month of maximum discharge (Fig. 2-10). Ackers and Charlton (1970b) suggest that bankfull flow may control meander geometry in rivers. How the wavelength of tidal alluvial meanders varies with discharge is unknown quantitatively. Equation (2.1) with m = 0.5 combined with eqs. (2.7-2.9) suggest that river meander wavelength scales almost linearly with channel width. Observation strongly supports this conclusion. Adjusted for Carlston’s ( 1965)
68
criticisms, the data of Inglis (1947, 1949) show wavelength to be approximately 12.1 times width, a value supported by Leopold and Wolman’s (1960) sample. Mackay (1974) obtained a ratio of 13.6 from the Mackenzie River. Ackers and Charlton ( 1970c) determined experimentally a ratio of roughly 11, but with a weak dependence on discharge. Schumm’s (1968a) sample of American and Australian rivers gives an exceptionally large average ratio (24.7) and a wide range of individual values (8.3-87.9). The analogous ratio for riffle-pool systems in straight channels broadly agrees with the Inglis 104
8 6 4
2 0
Lsopold and Wolrnan (1960)
j 10; %
4 6 2 10’ 8 6 4
2 100
4 6ElOo 2
2
4 6EI01
4 6ElO2 2
2
4 6SlO3 2
4 6 ElO4
Channel wldth, W (m)
-
Slnuoslty 0100-125
(b)
v .
A125-175 I 75 -3 0
V V
A
-W-
0
v.j
0
4 0
.
mv 0
0
vA
0
q A
2
4
6 8
vA A
2
4
o
0
o
0
0
O=%
oo A
0
A 0
eq
6 Bl02
0
2
4
6 8 10s 2
4
,
6 8104
Channel width,Wh)
Fig. 2- 1 1. Shape of meanders in plan and profile. a. Meander radius as a function of channel width in a sample of rivers in the U S A . (Leopold and Wolman, 1960), and in the Mackenzie River, Canada (Mackay, 1974). b. Maximum channel depth in a meander loop as a function of channel width. Data largely courtesy of M.R. Leeder (1973), but with his points for the Mississippi replaced by four fresh observations and with observations from the Oredven (Nilsson and Martvall, 1972) and the Wabash River (R.G. Jackson, 1975). Note that, for each meander radius, the most sinuous rivers tend to have the largest maximum channel depths.
69
value (Engels, 1905; Leopold and Wolman, 1957; Dury, 1964a; Komura and Shen, 1970; Dury et al., 1972; Keller, 1972; Keller and Melhorn, 1974, 1978; Harvey, 1975; K.S. Richards, 1976a). Thalweg sinuosities in an experimental model of the River Rhine have a wavelength almost exactly 12 times flow width (Meyer-Peter, Hoeck and Miiller, 1937). The only tidal data is for the locally beaded channels of the Crooked River, Florida (Dury, 1972). Their wavelength-width ratio is 7.1 - 14.1 for widths measured between pools and 9.7-21.0 at pools. Tidal and river channels therefore seem similar in their wavelength-width relationships. Radius of meander curvature also scales with channel width, in a way bound up with changes of pool depth (Fig. 2-1 la). Leopold and Wolman’s (1960) large and widely cast sample, together with Mackay’s (1974) data, strongly suggest that the meander radius/channel width ratio is rarely less than 2 or larger than 6, with a preferred or average value of roughly 3.25. Hickin’s (1974) analysis from the Beatton River strongly supports the lower limiting value of the ratio suggested by these data. At variance are observations from the White and Wabash Rivers (Chang and Toebes, 1970), which afford a somewhat larger typical value for the ratio and show a weak dependence on discharge. As meander radius falls for a given width (or discharge), the sinuosity generally increases and the maximum depth, h in pool or near-pool cross-sections also tends to rise (Fig. 2-1 lb), a feature made clear by the observations of Nilsson and Martvall (1972), Leeder (1973) and R.G. Jackson (1975). Since Fargue’s (1908) day it has been appreciated that channel depth generally increases relative to width with decreasing radius of bend curvature, other factors being equal (e.g. Nwachukwu, 1973; Winkley, 1973). Empirical relationships for depth prediction were developed by several early workers, as reviewed by Chatley (1931), and Leliavsky (1955), and their use has continued (Simons, 1971; Apmann, 1972). As an example, Ripley (1927) derived a general formula yielding complete and quite realistic channel cross-sections. Radius, width, and depth relationships in tidal channels seem to be similar to those for rivers (Dury, 1967, 1972; Bridges and Leeder, 1976). The sinuosity of alluvial rivers apparently rises to a maximum at intermediate valley slopes from low values at both small and large slopes. Immamura (1935) noted from Japan that for constant channel width, the meander-belt width, a surrogate for sinuosity, at first decreased steeply and then more gradually with increasing slope. Chitale (1970) later gave a similar result in sinuosity terms. On this descending limb of the sinuosity-slope graph, there is a threshold slope for each discharge below which the stream meanders and above which the flow is braided, that is, divided laterally between more than one channel (E.W. Lane, 1957; Leopold and Wolman, 1957; Henderson,’ 1966; Chitale, 1973; Chang, 1979). The ascending limb of the graph is less satisfactorily documented. However, the sinuosity of the Mississippi River (Schumm et al., 1972) increases going from the gently
graded deltaic course upstream towards the steeper valley below the Arkansas confluence. Laboratory experiments suggest that natural channels might at sufficiently low slopes become virtually straight, having only a meandering thalweg (Ackers and Charlton, 1970c, 1970d; Shahjahan, 1970; Schumm and Khan, 1971, 1972). The preceding simple correlations conceal effects apparently linked to sediment calibre. A change in the coarseness of the sediment load, for example, dramatically alters sinuosity (Schumm, 1968a, 1968b, 1969; Schumm and Khan, 1972). A general awareness of sediment influences has come partly from direct studies of rivers (E.W. Lane, 1957; Leopold and Wolman, 1957, 1960), and partly from analyses of channel stability and efficiency (e.g. E.W. Lane, 1955; Stebbings, 1963; Shen, 1971a), but the mechanisms of sediment influence remain elusive. Indeed, there is some conflict about which sediment is significant, that exposed in banks, or that potentially transportable on the bed, though modern opinion would favour the former. Schumm (1960a, 1960b) found from the Great Plains that:
( W / H ) = 255D,-’.08
(2.10)
where D, is the weighted mean percentage of silt and clay in the river bed and banks. Though similar streams generally do flow deeper and narrower between cohesive as compared with cohesionless banks, the formula may be criticized because: (1) the correlation is partly spurious ( W and H are implicit in D,) (M.A. Melton, 1961), (2) bed and bank mud contents are uncorrelated (Ferguson, 1973c), and (3) a limited category of streams is covered (S.J. Riley, 1975). Schumm (1963a, 1963b, 1967, 1968a, 1971, 1972) later proposed that:
P = 0.94Dp,25
(2.1 1) (2.12) (2.13)
and Ferguson (1973c), using the Great Plains sample (Schumm, 1960a), advanced the correlation: W = 33.1 Qi:8Do,,o.66
(2.14)
in which P is the sinuosity, Q,, is the mean annual flood discharge, and D, is the mean bank mud percentage. Equation (2.14) confirms that channel width decreases with increasing bank strength, and the other formulae show that whereas sinuosity increases with increasing bank erosion resistance, the meander wavelength decreases. Experimental data on the effects of sediment calibre generally support the field evidence (Friedkin, 1945; Nagabhushanaiah, 1967; Ackers and Charlton, 1970a; Shajahan, 1970).
71
FLOW PROCESSES IN MEANDERS AND CHANNEL BENDS
Superelevation of the water surface A horizontally curved path is forced upon water flowing round a tidal or river meander, or following a bend in an open, laboratory channel. As J. Thomson (1876) was early to show, one result of the curvature is that each fluid element is affected by a centrifugal acceleration which must be balanced by an opposite fluid pressure, expressed by a tilting of the water surface transversely to the streamwise motion (see also Wittman and Boss, 1938; Van Bendegom, 1947; Rozovskii, 1961). The water level at the concave bank therefore exceeds that at the convex shore, by an amount called the superelevation. But as the Earth is rotating, it may also be necessary to include the Coriolis force in determining the superelevation. Furthermore, if a secondary motion emerges in the fluid due to the curvature, the friction force may also contribute significantly. The approximate transverse water-surface slope which determines the superelevation may be calculated (friction neglected) by considering the following forces acting on a unit mass of water with a horizontal streamwise velocity u following a path of constant radius, r, measured positively outwards. The centrifugal force is u2/r outwards. The Coriolis force (Vol. I, Chapter 1) is 2wu sin l, where w is the Earth's angular velocity (7.29 X rad s - I ) and 5 is the latitude. In the Northern Hemisphere, the Coriolis force acts in the positive direction of Y in anticlockwise meander loops, but in the negative sense in clockwise bends; these directions of action are reversed in the Southern Hemisphere. For equilibrium, the sum of the centrifugal and Coriolis forces must be balanced by a pressure force g(dy/dr) per unit mass, where g is the acceleration of gravity, y is water-surface height above a datum, and d y / d r is the transverse water-surface slope. Now for each r in a real meander, u is some function u ( y ) over the depth. Hence the transverse slope may be written in a similar manner to Van Bendegom (1947): (2.15) where U is u( y ) averaged over the depth at r, and k , and k , are averaging constants which, for realistic u(y), may each be taken as unity. Since the Coriolis force may be either added or subtracted, the transverse slope, and therefore the superelevation, could differ between clockwise and anticlockwise bends in the same meander belt. Bend radius and latitude chiefly set the relative importance of the centrifugal and Coriolis terms, noting that U departs little from the general order of 1 m s - ' . In practice, we may neglect the Coriolis term when 2 w sin 5 is an order of magnitude or more smaller than U/r, as with all equatorial channels, and all meanders in middle and high latitudes but the larger ones and of r,/W in excess of approximately
72
10. The Coriolis force may nonetheless introduce an asymmetry into meander belts and control the direction of wholesale lateral migration of channels (e.g. Eakin, 1914; Kabelac, 1957; Dinga, 1970), because of possible dynamic inequalities between clockwise and anticlockwise bends, and cannot be neglected for slow flows in large channels (Heu, 1967). The superelevation follows by integrating eq. (2.15) without the Coriolis term for plausible forms of U ( r ) . Shukry (1950) and Ippen and Drinker (1962) assumed that U varied as l / r , as in a free vortex (J.R.D. Francis, 1975). Others considered the forced-vortex case (J.R.D. Francis, 1973, in which U increases with r (Leopold et al., 1960; Ippen and Drinker, 1962). The integration has also been performed for U = const. (Leopold et a]., 1960; B.C. Yen, 1965), and for a parabolic dependence of U upon r (Blue, Herbert and Lancefield, 1934). C.L. Yen and B.C. Yen (1971) integrated the equation for a cross-channel variation of U that accounted for the friction due to a secondary flow. However, the shape of the water surface and the magnitude of the superelevation vary little with U( r), and for rough purposes we may assume that r = rm and U = Uav,where U,, is the streamwise velocity averaged over the whole cross-section. The superelevation by is then equal to U:W/gr,,,. It is convenient for well-developed meander loops (e.g. Fig. 2-8) to assume a vertical concave bank and a rectilinear point-bar radial profile. Referring to Vol. I, eq. (1.34), we may then take U as varying with (h/h,,)'/* and therefore with ( r - rin/rex - rin)'/*,whence: A y = - K: [W-
gw
rin(1n r e x
- In 'in)]
(2.16)
where h is the depth at radius r , hex is the depth at the concave bank of radius rex, the radius of the convex bank is rin, and the velocity at the concave bank is Kx.Whichever formula is used, the superelevation in river and tidal meanders proves to be relatively small, in the general order of 0.1 m, and hence is negligible compared with depth for all but small steep streams. Calculated superelevations generally agree satisfactorily with observation (Blue et al., 1934; Shukry, 1950; Ippen and Drinker, 1962; C.L. Yen and B.C. Yen, 1971).
Secondary flow A key feature of the motion of a real fluid in a curved open channel is a secondary flow in the form of a vertically flattened helical spiral. As an
accompaniment to the general downstream movement, near-bed fluid travels inwards towards the convex bank while that near the free surface flows across the channel to the concave shore (Fig. 2-12a). This type of secondary flow was predicted by J. Thomson (1876) and confirmed experimentally by him using markers of sand, dye, threads and seeds (J. Thomson, 1877, 1879). Indeed, the motion is an everyday experience, appearing whenever a cup of
73
Fig. 2-12. Secondary flow in (a) curved open channel, (b) curved pipe of circular cross-section, and (c) curved conduit of square cross-section.
tea or a vessel of liquid is stirred with a smooth circular movement. Secondary currents also accompany fluid flow through curved pipes and ducts (Fig. 2-12b,c), oppositely rotating helical spirals lying one on each side of the plane of curvature, equivalent to the free surface in open-channel flow (e.g. Hawthorne, 1954a; Tunstall and Harvey, 1968; M. Rowe, 1970; Greenspan, 1973; Collins and Dennis, 1976; Murata et al., 1976; Humphrey et al., 1977; Agrawal et al., 1978; Masliyah, 1980). J. Thomson (1876) correctly ascribed the secondary flow in bends to friction (see also Wittman and Boss, 1938; Van Bendegom, 1947; Rozovskii, 1961). Referring above to the forces acting on a unit mass of water in curving channel flow, we notice that the pressure force varies only with the transverse water-surface slope. Therefore at each radius it is constant with depth, the magnitude depending on the average of u( y ) . But the centrifugal force depends on the local streamwise velocity u which, because of bottom friction, generally decreases towards the bed from a maximum near the free surface. Hence near the bed, where u is less than U,the centrifugal force is less in magnitude than the pressure force, and the fluid consequently drifts towards the inner, convex side of the channel. Near the free surface, however, u exceeds U,and the centrifugal force therefore is the larger. Hence surface fluid travels outwards, completing the helical spiral. Mathematical studies of secondary flow at high Reynolds numbers in curved open channels are numerous (De'Vriend, 1981). The early work of Mockmore ( 1944) assumes inviscid flow and arbitrary velocity distributions. Van Bendegom's ( 1947) analysis, though merely sketched, is more realistic, and indicates the relative importance of downstream and transverse surface velocities and the corresponding bed shear stresses. At the bed the shear stress vector makes with the mean flow an inward-directed angle proportional to h / r , where h is the flow depth at a radius r . Many later analyses rest on the equations of motion of a turbulent fluid in a curved open channel, generally simplified by assuming that (1) the flow is steady, (2) the bend, of uniform curvature, is long enough that the flow is independent of angular distance, (3) the channel width/depth ratio is large, and (4) the eddy viscosity is constant (Einstein and Harder, 1954; Rozovskii, 1961; Shen,
14
1961; Ananyan, 1965; B.C. Yen, 1965, 1972; De Vriend, 1972; Apmann, 1972; Kikkawa et al., 1973; Engelund, 1974; Gottlieb, 1974, 1976; Ikeda, 1974, 1975). Rozovskii proposed that the bed shear stress vector due to the secondary flow deviated from the mean flow by an angle 6, where: tan6= ll(h/r) (2.17) and h and r have their previous meanings. Recent work by Zimmermann (1977), however, proves that the numerical coefficient has a weak inverse dependence on bed roughness, Rozovskii’s value of 11 equating to a DarcyWeisbach friction factor of approximately 0.04, a good average for a sand bed. Van Bendegom (1947) and Engelund (1974), in contrast to Rozovskii, gave the numerical coefficient as 10 and 7, respectively. The coefficient for curved Couette flow, of some importance experimentally, is apparently 2-3 times larger (Engelund, 1975). Less is known of how the secondary flow either develops on entering a bend or decays on leaving it, no doubt because otherwise discardable terms must be retained in the equations of motion. However, Rozovskii (1961) derived from these equations both numerical and approximate analytical solutions to the problem. Given a flow entering a uniform bend from a long straight reach, he deduced that approximately full development occurred when:
Y = k 3 W f )”*(v4
(2.18)
where y is the angular distance from the bend entrance, f is the DarcyWeisbach friction coefficient, and h and r are, respectively, a characteristic depth and bend-radius. The coefficient k 3 varies with the definition of “approximately full development”, but is given as 2.3. An analogous equation predicts the decay of a fully developed secondary flow after entering a straight. Later, Muramoto ( 1967) sketched the flow development, but from vorticity considerations. He recognized a generating region, an intermediate developing region, and a region of full development, each with a unique structure. Fox and Ball (1968), and Francis and Asfari (1971), using numerical techniques, also calculated the changing velocity structure. The mean streamwise velocity in the generating region broadly follows the freeyortex law, the maximum hugging the convex bank. The position of the vortex core gradually shifts across the channel through the developing region until, in the zone of fully developed flow, the velocity maximum borders the concave bank, as in a forced vortex. The fully developed flow has been treated as having a two-layer structure (e.g. Einstein and Harder, 1954), in which an inward-thickening boundary layer partly wraps round a core of fluid- the main spiral vortex-behaving essentially inviscidly.
75
Laboratory and field observations on secondary flow A legion of experimenters have confirmed the predicted character and development of the secondary flow in open-channel bends. Field studies have also given results generally in agreement with theory, though the evidence here is less substantial. The change in the transverse distribution of the downstream velocity component from that similar to a free vortex near a bend entrance, to that resembling a forced vortex further round the curve (or even in the subsequent straight or reversed loop), is amply proved for rigid rectangular channels (Yarnell and Woodward, 1936; Mockmore, 1944; Braden, 1947; Shukry, 1950; Rozovskii, 196 1 ; Francis and Pierce, 1967; Muramoto, 1967; Fox and Ball, 1968; Francis and Asfari, 1971; Kikkawa et al., 1973; Mosonyi et al., 1975; Siebert and Gotz, 1975; Varshney and Garde, 1975; Choudhary and Narasimhan, 1977) and for trapezoidal ones (Rozovskii, 1961; Ippen and Drinker, 1962; B.C. Yen, 1965; C.L. Yen, 1970; Barela, 1972; Deslauniers and Frenette, 1972). Figure 2-13 shows some of B.C. Yen's results. Sand fed to a channel bed, though causing spatial variations of cross-section, has no substantial effect on the velocity pattern (Martvall and Nilsson, 1972; Onishi et al., 1972; Hooke, 1974, 1975; Krishnappan and Lau, 1977). In Martvall and Nilsson's work on compound bends (Fig. 2-14), an especially marked delay occurs between the flow entering a curve and becoming fully developed. The lag amounts to nearly one-half of the meander-path length. A similar behaviour of the vortex core marks river meanders, where the largest streamwise velocities (and erosive powers) near the concave bank
A'
w
A
Fig. 2-13. Secondary flow measured in a right-angled bend of a trapezoidal laboratory channel. On the left is seen the streamwise flow, given in terms of the velocity averaged over a vertical, Ur, compared to the mean flow velocity in the cross-section, U,,,,,,,. On the right the local transverse velocity, K , is compared to the mean velocity in the cross-section. After B.C. Yen ( 1 965).
16
Fig. 2-14. Patterns of (a, c) surface flow velocity and (b, d) flow depth observed by Martvall and Nilsson ( 1 972) during two runs in a doubly meandering trapezoidal laboratory channel carrying sand.
tend to occur in the downstream half of each loop. This is seen in the Iowa (Blue et al., 1934), and may be suggested for the Mississippi (Vogel and Thompson, 1933). Leopold and Wolman (1960) found evidence for the downstream transition from free to forced vortex behaviour in Baldwin Creek, Wyoming, as did Rozovskii (1961) for the River Desna. Indications of the transition come also from the Snov (Rozovskii, 1961) and Orealven (Nilsson and Martvall, 1972), and clear proof is available from the Wabash River (R.G. Jackson, 1975). In the Wabash, as in Martvall and Nilsson’s (1972) experiments, a spatial lag on the order of one-quarter to one-half of the local meander-path length separates the channel inflection point and a
77
forced-vortex velocity distribution. Whether a similar lag occurs during flow in the larger tidal channels is not yet known, but the form of beaded channels suggested to Ahnert (1960) an upstream lag during flood reversing to downstream on the ebb. Observation amply confirms the predicted structure and strength-variation of secondary flows. The results in Fig. 2-13 (B.C. Yen, 1965) typify those obtained experimentally (see also Shukry, 1950; Rozovskii, 1961 ; Fox and Ball, 1968; Onishi et al., 1972; Kikkawa et a]., 1973; Ikeda, 1974, 1975). Prus-Chacinski ( 1954) in particular explored the strength of secondary flows, finding experimentally that tan S increased with declining bend radius, and Rozovskii (1961) later confirmed eq. (2.17) in full. Although some workers explicitly reject the concept (Vogel and Thompson, 1933; Matthes, 1941), and others remain hesitant (Bluck, 1971), there can be no doubt from the wealth of field data (e.g. Fig. 2-8) of the general occurrence of secondary currents in river bends (Blue et a]., 1934; Eakin, 1935; Van Bendegom, 1947; Van Ti1 and Tops, 1953; Leopold and Wolman, 1960; Rozovskii, 1961; Hey and Thorne, 1975; R.G. Jackson, 1975; Bridge and Jarvis, 1976, 1977; Bathurst et al., 1977; Hickin, 1978; Dietrich et a]., 1979). Rozovskii finds that their strength also varies according to eq. (2.17), and Jackson gives further supporting evidence. Low-stage secondary flows in Wabash bends are generally the weaker and, moreover, seem to develop more quickly, in accordance with eq. (2.18). Bluck ( 1971) indirectly gives evidence for these effects, though his observations are interpreted in terms of questionable “bar head” and “pool” currents. He records that the high-stage cross-stratification in the River Endrick has a greater angular divergence relative to the channel centre-line, and is developed after a longer spatial delay, than the succeeding low-stage structures. Two models exist for the flow in river meanders (Fig. 2-15a,b). In I.G. Wilson’s (1973), the channel at the apex of each loop is occupied by a single spiral vortex, whereas at each crossing a double spiral with bed-divergent currents obtains. Hey and Thorne’s (1975) model resembles Wilson’s at the meander apex, except for a subsidiary vortex rotating in the opposite sense to the main one, but has bed-convergent flow at crossings. Aspects of each model receive support. A single Wilson-type vortex seems to mark the tips of meanders in Baldwin Creek (Leopold and Wolman, 1960), the Desna, Snov and Yulya-Ioki (Rozovskii, 1961), and the Wabash (R.G. Jackson, 1975), whereas there is an additional subsidiary spiral in the Dove (Hey and Thorne, 1975) and Severn (Bathurst et al., 1977), as well as in the Klaralven, to judge from salt injections (Sundborg, 1956) and my observations on logs being floated downstream. The subsidiary vortex is also known experimentally (Einstein and Harder, 1954; Einstein and Shen, 1964; B.C. Yen, 1965; Onishi et al., 1972). In bends of very large width/depth ratio, however, several equal vortices may occur side by side (Eakin, 1935; Francis and Asfari, 1970), and in curves of small ratio, spirals can be piled
78
Fig. 2-15. Hypothetical and actual patterns of flow in meandering open channels. a. Limiting streamlines according to I.G. Wilson (1973). b. Limiting streamlines according to Hey and Thorne (1975). c, d. Alternative models to (a) and (b). Remainder of figure shows sense of rotation of secondary flow (observer looking downstream) in Bozeman and Helm Bends of Wabash River during (e) high stage and ( f ) low stage, as inferred from observations of R.G. Jackson (1975).
vertically (Chacinski and Francis, 1952; Prus-Chacinski, 1954; Soliman and Tinney, 1968). Flow at crossings is less well known. A fairly convincing bed-convergent double vortex is described from the Dove (Hey and Thorne, 1975), and a similar pattern (Fig. 2- 15e) marks the Bozeman-Helm crossing on the high-stage Wabash (R.G. Jackson, 1975). At low stage, however, this crossing yields a Wilson-style pattern (Fig. 2-150. Thus neither model is completely representative of real bends, and neither may be valid for every flow stage. The models of Fig. 2-15c, d may better represent meander flow patterns. The first of these-a "high-stage" model-reconciles Hey and Thorne's ( 1975) local observations but uses simpler kinematics. A local flow separation along the convex side of a bend downstream from the apex is often reported experimentally (J. Thomson, 1879; Mockmore, 1944; Shukry, 1950; Leopold et al., 1960; Ippen and Drinker, 1962; Soliman and Tinney, 1968; Tunstall and Harvey, 1968; Hurd and Peters, 1970; Thandveswara and Seetharamiah, 1971 ; Deslauniers and Frenette, 1972;
19
Martvall and Nilsson, 1972; Hooke, 1974, 1975). Limited separation at the same position can occur in river meanders, particularly at sharp or obstructed bends, as is shown by direct observation and by sedimentary structures (D.K. Davies, 1966; Taylor et al., 1971; Teisseyre, 1978). In small tidal meanders (Leeder and Bridges, 1975; Bridges and Leeder, 1976), breakaway is favoured by a declining bend radius/width ratio (see also Bagnold, 1960) and an increasing Froude number. A criterion for separation, r m / W < (0.5 13Fr), where Fr is the Froude number based on the maximum mean flow velocity and maximum depth, may be derived from their data. Flow separation leads to additional energy losses in bends (Bagnold, 1960; Leopold et al., 1960) and reduces the flow width. However, only small vigorous streams are significantly affected, and the secondary flow may well restrict separation to a surface layer, as in Mockmore’s (1944) channel, thus minimizing its influence on the bed.
+
Theories of meandering
Investigators continue to puzzle over the still elusive question of why river and tidal streams meander in alluvium. Although the following sketch merely touches on this topic, there still remains the even wider problem of why any restricted fluid stream should meander. The idea that meandering is a response to some kind of self-perpetuating transverse oscillation of the flowing water mass underpins several theories (De Geer, 1911 ; Exner, 1921; Hjulstrom, 1942, 1949; Fujiyoshi, 1950; Werner, 1951 ; A.G. Anderson, 1967). Fujiyoshi’s equation for meander wavelength, and also Werner’s when stripped of arbitrary “corrections”, give wavelength values both broadly consistent with experience and proportional to the square root of discharge (see eqs. 2.7-2.9). Anderson finds the same discharge dependence but introduces factors of uncertain meaning. Several workers link meandering with sediment transport, stream loads, and orderly debris transfers between bank and flow (Matthes, 1941; Friedkin, 1945; Ackers and Charlton, 1970a, 1970c, 1970d; Hooke, 1974, 1975). These processes express a necessary condition for meandering, but a consideration of them has not so far led to the prediction of meander scale. Meander initiation at chance boundary irregularities has often been advanced (Exner, 1919, 1921; Prus-Chacinski, 1954; Leliavsky, 1955; Htikonson, 1973). Usually this idea is developed in conjunction with an analysis of the role of the secondary flow generated by the irregularity in further localized erosion and deposition. However, instead of being induced at an irregularity, cross-channel winds may generate the secondary flow (Wu, -1975a, 1975b). Alternatively, the action of irregularities invites the treatment of meandering as a stability problem. Since irregularities would be randomly distributed, there must be mechanisms of wavelength selection operating in a stream, so that a dominant wavelength will eventually appear. Quraishy
80
(1944, 1973) early saw meandering as a spontaneous interaction between a flow and deformable bed. Meandering could be a response of the deformable river boundary to secondary flows (Thomson, 1876; Leliavsky, 1955; Tanner, 1960, 1963; Shen and Komura, 1968; Komura and Shen, 1970; Gorycki, 1973a; Quick, 1974). Komura and Shen on this basis calculated wavelengths in excellent agreement with observation. Assuming that the angular deflection of a stream varies with the strength of the secondary flow scaled by the streamwise flow velocity, Quick graphed flow paths in many respects like meanders in plan, but failed to obtain recurving forms or calculate wavelengths. Many workers treat meandering as a stability problem (Reynolds, 1965; Hansen, 1967; Callander, 1969; Sukegawa, 1970; Engelund, 1971; Karcz, 1971; Engelund and Skovgaard, 1973; Hayashi, 1974; Parker, 1976). General conditions for meandering and braiding are defined, but only the analyses of Hansen, Hayashi, and Parker yielded an expression for wavelength. Modest to good agreement with observation can be demonstrated. Meandering is sometimes associated with the Coriolis force (e.g. Eakin, 1914; Matschinski, 1966; Neu, 1967). This cannot be an essential control, however, since rivers meander as much in equatorial as in high latitudes. The idea that meandering maximizes stream energy losses has received little support (Jefferson, 1902; Inglis, 1949), but its antithesis, that meandering minimizes the loss and that meanders are therefore the most probable form of a river, is for some persuasive (Chatley, 1940; Bagnold, 1960; Leopold et al., 1960; Langbein and Leopold, 1966; Leopold and Langbein, 1966; C.T. Yang, 1971b; Chang, 1979). These ideas were developed in parallel with the view that thermodynamic analogies are applicable to landscape development (Leopold and Langbein, 1962; Scheidegger and Langbein, 1966; Yang, 1971a) and with the belief that rivers are nondeterministic phenomena (Thakur and Scheidegger, 1968, 1970; Surkan and Van Kan, 1969; C.T. Yang, 1971b, 1971c; Stall and Yang, 1972; Cherkauer, 1973). Meandering is not inconsistent with these notions, but meander attributes have yet to be deduced quantitatively from them. Tellingly, the meander planimetric form accepted as completely random yet the most probable- the sine-generated curve (Langbein and Leopold, 1966)-is rigorously explicable in a deterministic way (Gedzelman, 1974). Yalin (197 1, 1972) relates meandering to the scale of macroturbulence in rivers, calculating wavelengths in almost as good agreement with observation as Komura and Shen (1970). SEDIMENTATION PROCESSES IN MEANDERS AND CHANNEL BENDS
Sediment particle equilibrium on a point bar
The surface of a point bar inclines downwards and outwards, usually to within a small distance of a concave bank, whereas the secondary current in
81
the flow passing round the channel acts inwards over the bar, contrary to this outward slope. Hence a sediment particle travelling in substantially continuous contact with the bar, or one lying stationary on the bar surface, must be acted on by forces usually having both transverse (radial) and mean flow (streamwise) components. These in the general case are fluid drag, the particle immersed weight, friction and, possibly, lift. Their resultant dictates whether the particle in following the loop will spiral either inwards or outwards or remain parallel with the mean flow. Several largely independent attempts have been made to analyse these forces, with a view to calculating the equilibrium transverse profiles of point bars. Equilibrium may be either static, when the particles lie everywhere in incipient motion, or dynamic, when there is zero net sediment transport across the mean flow direction. If the dynamic equilibrium-profile is calculable, then other bar sedimentological features can be predicted. Consider as in Fig. 2-16 a single spherical sediment particle of diameter D and density u travelling in water of depth h (measured positively downwards) at a radial distance r over the surface of a point bar of negligibly small streamwise slope contained in a sufficiently large uniformly curved channel (superelevation neglected). The particle is assumed to be moving in substantially continuous contact with the bar surface, at a speed small compared with the flow (see Bagnold, 1956, 1966). When the bar is dynamically stable, the net flow of bedload across the streamwise x-direction is zero, and the radial forces acting on the particle are limited to the immersed weight and fluid drag components, lift being neglected in the light of Bagnold's (1973) observations. The weight force, Fg, is: (2.19) in which p is the density of water, g is the gravitational acceleration, and p is
Fig. 2-16. Definition diagram for secondary flow and particle stability in a meandering open channel.
82
the local transverse slope angle of the bar. The fluid drag, F,, may be writ ten:
F~ = r (0/2)’7,
(2.20)
sins
in which T, is the mean bed shear stress along a limiting bed streamline and S is the deviation angle previously used. Because of equilibrium: +r(0/2)~(u
- p>gsinp=
77(~/2)’.,
sin8
(2.21)
Noting that p is generally very small, so that sin p = tan /3 = dh/dr, and that the streamwise mean bed shear stress, 7, = 7, cos6, we can write from eq. (2.2 1):
dh dr
33pSh2 2D(u-p)r
(2.22)
after introducing eq. (2.17) and the conventional hydraulic equation (see Vol I, eq. 1.32), ?y = pghS, where S is the local water-surface slope. Equation (2.22) states that, with a fully developed secondary flow, the bar transverse slope is a steeply increasing function of flow depth, an increasing function of water-surface slope, and a decreasing function of particle size and bend radius. This analysis was given by Allen (1970b, 1970c), independently of Van Bendegom (1947) and NEDECO (1959). Several others have analysed the forces acting on a particle in dynamic equilibrium (C.L. Yen, 1970; Engelund, 1974, 1975; Ikeda, 1974, 1975; Bridge, 1976, 1977; Zimmermann and Kennedy, 1978), as Allen (1978) has pointed out in a general review. Yen’s and Ikeda’s analyses include lift, and give broadly similar results to eq. (2.22), with the noteworthy difference that the bar slope is . followed by Bridge came to the remarkable proportional to D - ‘ I 2Engelund conclusion that: dh h tana -= k4(2.23) dr r in which k , is a numerical constant relating to the deviation angle and tana is the dynamic friction coefficient due to mutual encounters between grains. Since t a n a varies with D either but little (Bagnold, 1954a, 1956, 1966) or not at all (Bagnold, 1973), eq. (2.23) is tantamount to saying that bar slope is independent of sediment calibre, which seems physically implausible. The Engelund-Bridge analysis is suspect, despite its apparent numerical success (Bridge, 1976, 1978). A test of eq. (2.22) demands more information than is usually available from either the field or laboratory. Hooke (1974, 1975) experimented with meanders 1 m wide in the form of a sine-generated curve. Quartz sand of geometric mean diameter 0.0003 m was fed to the channel under three different aqueous discharges, and bed elevation and mean bed shear stress
83 0.5
-0
(0)
04
$015
A A
v v >
0
A
0
0.1
02
0 .
0.0020 m 3 s-I 0.0035 m3s-‘ 0.0050 m3s-I
0.3
0.4
0
A
05
.
19 January 1974 2 February 1974 25 February 1974
0 0
01
Predicted dh/dr
02
03
04
Predicted dh/dr
Fig. 2-17. Observed as compared to predicted (eq. 2.22) transverse slopes for point bars in sand-bed meanders. a. Laboratory channel I m wide (Hooke, 1974, 1975). b. River South Esk, Scotland (data by courtesy of J.S. Bridge).
were mapped. Figure 2-17a compares measured local values of dh/dr with values predicted using eq. (2.22) and the experimental data. Agreement is satisfactory, considering the presence of bedforms in the real flows, except for small depths, when the equation underestimates the slope, and for large depths at the highest discharge, when the predicted slopes can exceed the angles of repose of the sand. A similar deviation of observed from theoretical values was noted by Zimmermann and Kennedy (1978) for their equation predicting the transverse bed slope. A second test was made with data generously supplied by Dr. J.S. Bridge and Dr. J. Jarvis (pers. comm., 1976; see also Bridge and Jarvis 1976, 1977) from a meander of the River South Esk, Angus, Scotland. They measured bed profiles, mean grain sizes, flow depths and water-surface slopes in a cross-section with a fully developed secondary flow on three dates in 1974 when the river was near bankfull, the condition when eq. (2.22) may be regarded as valid. The predicted and observed transverse slopes agree to the right order (Fig. 2-17b). Since dunes cover most of the bed, the discrepancies may partly relate to the difficulty of obtaining reliable estimates of grain size and bar slope. Transverse shape of point bars and meandering channels In the case of a train of uniform meanders carrying a single grade of sediment, the local water-surface slope in eq. (2.22) must from geometrical considerations be related to thexentreline slope, S,, and radius of curvature, r,, by S = S,(r,/r). Substituting for S in eq. (2.22) affords (2.24)
84
which, upon separating variables and integrating, gives h=
20(u -p)r 33pS,rm{
(2.25)
1 - 2 0 ( u - p)Cr}
for the equilibrium transverse profile, h ( r ) , of each point bar where the secondary flow is fully developed, C being an integration constant to be found from the conditions of the problem. A real channel may exist provided that C < 1/20( u - p ) r . Introducing as reference values r, and the centreline depth, h ,,,, eq. (2.25) becomes: (2.26)
from which C is excluded. Equations (2.25) and (2.26) imply that, with a uniform bedload sediment, the point-bar transverse profile is convex-up and of a steepness inversely proportional to calibre of load. Van Bendegom ( 1947) calculated convex-up profiles, though not from an explicit equation, but NEDECO (1959) using his work derived a relation similar to eq. (2.26). The analyses of C.L. Yen (1970) and Ikeda (1974, 1975) also afford convex-up profiles which, in at least Yen's case, have power-law form (Apmann, 1972). Using assumed velocity distributions, Suga ( 1967) calculated the profile as a power function under each kind of equilibrium. Integration of eq. (2.23) given by Engelund ( 1974, 1975) and Bridge (1976) also affords a power function:
h = Crk4ta"a
(2.27)
centreline depth, h,, eq. (2.25) becomes: (2.28)
upon introducing the previous reference variables. Russian workers have used a power function similar to eq. (2.28) for bar shape (Saplyukov, 1973). Although relations like eqs. (2.26) and (2.28) may readily be fitted to measured profiles, in order to predict point-bar shape under prescribed conditions, we must know the integration constant C. It is expected that these conditions will include the aqueous and sediment discharges and the sediment calibre. Ideally, C will be calculated so that the two discharges are simultaneously conserved. With Q , as the given fluid discharge and assuming vertical channel sides:
Q,= [rcxh( r ) . U(r ) - d r
(2.29)
where U is the local mean velocity in the vertical, and rex and Tin are the prescribed radii of the concave and convex banks, respectively (Fig. 2-16).
85
Calculating U conventionally (see Vol. I, eq. 1.35) (2.30) in which f is the local Darcy-Weisbach friction coefficient, and substituting from eq. (2.25) for h( r ) in eqs. (2.29) and (2.30), we obtain: rcx
Qf
=J
r(8gS,,rm) f I/2
r,n
2D(a - P ) 33pS,r,,{ 1 - 2 D( u - p ) C r }
3/2
-dr
(2.31)
when upon integration C follows by interpolation between trial values. It is more difficult to calculate C with the sediment discharge, Q,, also conserved, partly because it is not clear which flow-sediment transport relation should be used, and partly due to uncertainty about the local ratio of sediment loads. But if the local sediment transport rate is treated as a power function of the local velocity U (Vol. I, eq. 2.32), Q, will be approximately conserved so long as U is large compared with the sediment “erosion velocity”. Figure 2-18 gives transverse profiles calculated from eq. (2.25) for a fixed discharge value, two values of the sediment calibre, and a range of channel radii. These profiles satisfactorily resemble natural meanders as seen in sections far enough downstream that fully developed secondary flow may be
STRUCTURES Current ripples and cross-lamination
rn m
Dunes and cross-bedding
t-----l
P = 3.45
Upper-stage plane beds and parallel bminotion
P = 1.011 0 100 200 300400 500
P = 1.35
P = 1.74
P ~2.53
P.3.51
Fig. 2- 18. Computed meander cross-section and bedform distribution with increasing channel sinuosity for (upper sequence) aqueous discharge= 5000 m3s I , D=0.00025 m and (lower sequence) aqueous discharge = 5000 m3 s I , D =0.001 m. Note that current ripples appear only for the finer sand and at a sinuosity of 1.26; otherwise dunes and upper-stage plane beds alone are present. ~
86
assumed (e.g. Fisk, 1947; Wolman, 1955; Rozovskii, 1961 ; R.G. Jackson, 1975), but by assumption have vertical banks and, because of the extreme thalweg position, show exaggerated maximum depths. Equations (2.26) and (2.28) each provide a good forced fit to natural profiles (e.g. Bridge, 1976), given a careful choice for the proportionality constant and the exponent, respectively. Only Van Bendegom (1947), Engelund ( 1974), and Bridge ( 1977) have calculated the three-dimensional channel geometry.
Processes and rates of meander growth Plausibly, an aqueous flow in a straight channel of uniform surroundings will scour both banks equally until a stable, non-eroding cross-section is achieved (Vol. I, eqs. 1.37, 1.38). Reference to eqs. (2.25) and (2.30), however, suggests that such stability may never arise should a local curvature in plan accidentally develop. For the flow depth and velocity will be the higher at the concave bank, with the consequence that this bank will go on eroding while a point bar grows in harmony beneath the slower, shallower flows along the convex shore. Experience amply supports this interpretation. Many erosion processes affect the concave banks of river and tidal meanders, operating in a balance set by: (1) channel scale and shape, (2) the lithology and vertical-lateral sequence of bank deposits, (3) flow regime, (4) climatic setting, and (5) season. The processes are all favoured by the large flow velocities and stresses known or inferred to occur along meander concave banks (Parsons, 1960; Apmann, 1972; Hooke, 1974, 1975). The direct processes include the corrasion of cohesive banks (A.R. Hill, 1973b), the gouging of banks by drift-ice (D. Gill, 1972), the entrainment of sand or gravel particle by particle (NEDECO, 1959), the pick-up of fracturebounded blocks of cohesive sediment (A.R. Hill, 1973b), and the melting of permafrost cements (D. Gill, 1972). Block and particle entrainment is promoted by freeze-thaw (S.S. Harrison, 1970) and by wetting and drying (Twidale, 1964), both of which progressively loosen the bank. Water waves may enhance the river or tidal erosion (D. Gill, 1972; Bridges and Leeder, 1976). The indirect erosion processes tend to be catastrophic and are often precipitated by the action of the direct ones, which tend to steepen or even undercut banks. Large usually subaqueous flowages of liquidized sediment are frequent from banks of poorly coherent sand and gravelly sand (Turnbull et al., 1966; J.M. Coleman, 1969). These failures generally occur during falling stages, for flood water is then returning to the channel via the ground and pore pressures are high. Rotational slides, sometimes stepped, typify the failure of predominantly cohesive banks (Eardley, 1938b; Fisk, 1944, 1947, 1952a, 1952b; Sundborg, 1956; NEDECO, 1959; Turnbull et al., 1966; Kesel et al., 1974; Bridges and Leeder, 1976). These slides also tend to occur as stage falls, as the result of high pore-water pressures, strength loss conse-
87
quent upon thorough wetting, and the increase of bank weight due to draw-down. A third catastrophic erosion process is expressed by the sudden collapse of moderately cohesive banks into a jumble of blocks (Twidale, 1964; Pestrong, 1965, 1972b; Bluck, 1971; A.R. Hill, 1973b; Piest et al., 1975). In cold climates, the incidence of warm weather precipitates the solifluction of thawed mud into the channel from cohesive banks (Eardley, 1938b; Sundborg, 1956) and the spalling of flakes or slabs of melted sand and gravel (Eardley, 1938b). Short-term local erosion rates on meander concave banks vary extremely widely, both from site to site and time to time (Wolman, 1959; Twidale, 1964; Daniel, 1971; A.R. Hill, 1973b; Kesel et al., 1974; D.J. Hughes, 1977). This reflects partly the episodic nature of some of the erosion processes and partly the fact that they seldom work alone. The general tendency, however, is for the larger rates to be linked in time with flood flows and in space with moderately tight bends. Teisseyre ( 1980) gives further data. Bank erosion rates measured over periods of a few years are more consistent, taking the general order of 0.001-0.1 channel widths per year, where width can be regarded as a surrogate for a reference average flow velocity. These rates come from direct surveys (Leopold and Wolman, 1957; NEDECO, 1959; Crickmay, 1960; Alexander and Nunnally, 1972; Leopold, 1973), the analysis of charts, maps, and/or air photographs (Duncanson, 1909; De Geer, 1911; Tow], 1935; Sundborg, 1956; Schmudde, 1963; Noble and Palmquist, 1968; Swenson, 1970; Handy, 1972; Brice, 1974a; Kulernina, 1975; J.M. Hooke, 1977; Laczay, 1977), and vegetation studies (Eardley, 1938b; Dietz, 1952; Hickin and Nanson, 1975). Archeological evidence may help establish longer term channel shifting (Bareis, 1964; Lathrap, 1968). There is little quantitative understanding of how bank erosion rates depend upon flow conditions, bank materials, and channel form. Rates are qualitatively greater, however, for incoherent banks than for strong cohesive ones. Recently, Popov (1965) and Kondrat’yev (1969) observed that the time-rate of change of the meander central angle (Fig. 2-6) was greatest at a sinuosity in the order of 1.5. It follows that the bank erosion rate must reach a similar maximum. This was demonstrated by Hickin and Nanson (1975) who, in an elegant dendrochronological study, found the erosion rate to increase with decreasing r, / W to a maximum when this ratio was approximately equal to 3 (Fig. 2-19a). A number of unusually small and tight bends, however, afforded rates again low. Records of the Klaralven (Sundborg, 1956), Watts Branch (Wolman and Leopold, 1957; Leopold, 1973), and the White River (Brice, 1974a) go far towards showing that the decrease of erosion rate with increasing r , / W is a general feature of meandering streams (Fig. 2-19b-d). Data come also from the Mississippi (Fisk, 1947; Carey, 1969) and the Des Moines (Handy, 1972), but are too few to suggest a pattern (Fig. 2-19e). The trends seen in Fig. 2-19 bear out theoretical analyses of meander erosion (Saplyukov, 1973; Allen, 1977a).
88
f
0 3 0.01
I\
J
0 0
2
4
6
8
rm/ W
10
12
rm/ W
Fig. 2-19. Maximum local rate of meander migration (channel widths per year) as a function of the relative meander radius. a. Beatton River, British Columbia (Hickin and Nanson, 1975). b. Klaralven, Sweden (Sundborg, 1956). c. Watts Branch, Maryland, U.S.A. (Wolman and Leopold. 1957; Leopold, 1973). d. White River, U.S.A. (Brice, 1974a). e. Des Moines and Mississippi Rivers. U.S.A. (Fisk, 1947: Carey. 1969: Handy, 1972).
Evolution of meander loops A1though some awareness of meander growth-patterns emerged early (e.g. Davis, 1902; Lobeck, 1939), it is but recently that many essentials became known, partly by experiment (Tiffany and Nelson, 1939; Friedkin, 1945), and partly from detailed field studies (Lathrap, 1968; Daniel, 1971; Lewin, 1972; Brice, 1974a, 1974b; Hickin, 1974; Hickin and Nanson, 1975). As a meander train develops from an initially straight channel, each bend may move downstream (change of phase) as well as increase in loop-length (increase of amplitude). Evolution under ideal conditions may afford either uniform meanders changing only in phase, or lead to the simultaneous cut-off of grossly amplified loops and a renewal of the development cycle.
89
These behavioural modes are evident in real meanders but are complicated by the inhomogeneity of the channel boundary and by the unsteady channel processes. Most has been learned from the pattern and age of point-bar meander scrolls (Figs. 2-2, 2-3, 2-4). Each scroll is formed and ultimately added to the bar by the slow downcurrent growth around the convex bank of a feature rampart-like at the level of the bar top but of an as yet unknown form in the .deeper channel (Sundborg, 1956; Nilsson and Martvall, 1972; Nanson, 1980). Scroll bars are therefore not isochronous. Each in the Beatton River took on the order of 20 years to form (Hickin and Nanson, 1975), and several may at one time be accreting in a loop, as I have noted on the Klaralven, Sweden. But as scrolls form rapidly compared with meander loops, they are an acceptable guide to former channel position and can safely be used in meander reconstruction. Schematic evolutionary patterns can be depicted in terms of meander scrolls, as representing earlier channels, and by continuous scroll orthogonals (Figs. 2-7, 2-20), which Hickin (1974) called erosion path lines. One orthogonal, that recording maximum total channel movement, may be singled out as the meander-loop erosional axis, although a unique axis is not identifiable when a loop changes only in phase, for orthogonals are then uniform (Fig. 2-200. River meander-loops illustrating the schematic patterns are described by Lathrap (1968), Brice (1974a, 1974b), Hickin (1974), Hickin and Nanson (1975), and R.G. Jackson (1975), though Hickin has misinterpreted compound-loop growth. The scrolls A - A and B-B' in Fig. 2-20c, d reveal such loops at a critical stage. Earlier, a single characteristic radius of curvature is (01 Simple symmetrical
(b) Simple asymmetrical
( c ) Compound symmetrical
( d ) Compound symmetrical
(e) 'Rebounding' loop
( f ) Phase growth only
Fig. 2-20. Schematic evolution of meander loops.
90
Fig. 2-21. Definition diagram for the evolution of meander loops.
identifiable, but afterwards there are two, and therefore two erosional axes must appear. Hickin used at all stages a single continuous axis to describe his compound loops. A compound loop may eventually divide (Fig. 2-20e), by the “rebound” of the weakly curved segment (Lathrap, 1968). The resulting channel is shaped like the human ear (Lathrap, 1968) or the letter T (Hickin, 1974). Lewin ( 1972) reports similar metamorphoses, attributing them to the formation of additional pools in a simpler prior meander. Rebound seems common and may be forced upon an over-lengthened channel by the discharge. Regular models of meander planimetric form are ably summarized by Ferguson ( 1973a). Of appealing simplicity is the uniformly curved circular arc (Bates, 1939; Chatley, 1940; Chitale, 1970), though fitting real loops ill (e.g. Langbein and Leopold, 1966). The sine curve (e.g. Bluck, 1971) is perhaps a worse fit, with the particular objection that a recurved channel is unobtainable. It is more difficult to discriminate between the remainder: ( 1) Fargue’s (1908) spiral, of linearly varying curvature (see discussion in Leliavsky, 1959, (2) the sine-generated curve, in which the channel direction is a sine function of distance along the channel (Fargue, 1908; Langbein and Leopold, 1966; Leopold and Langbein, 1966; Daniel, 1971), and (3) Von Schelling’s (1951) equation for the most probable path of a particle in a plane, to which the sine-generated curve closely approximates. These three models describe real meanders about equally well (Langbein and Leopold, 1966; Ferguson, 1973a) and, since none has any physical basis, may therefore be used as convenience dictates. Flow and sedimentation in channel bends are well enough understood that several general features of a dynamical model of meander evolution under simplified conditions can be stated. Let the heavy solid curve in Fig. 2-21 be part of a rectilinear train of regular alluvial meanders at one instant during development. The train may be described by: z =f,(x,t)
(2.32)
91
the solution of which is desired, where z is the normal distance from the x-axis, f l stands for a periodic function, x is distance along the meander belt
axis (positive downstream), and t is time. Uniformly spaced inflection points, I,,I,, ...,I,,, occur where this curve cross the x-axis. Further evolution will generally involve a change of both phase and amplitude. Let the dashed curve be the meanders after the elapse of a small time-increment A t , and let the arrows between the curves represent bank erosion. We see that the directions of these vectors . define further uniformly spaced points, R,,R2,...,R,l,about which the channel has merely been rotated. At these stations the channel is temporarily stable, experiencing erosion on neither bank. Hence the instantaneous form and evolution of the train depends on the operation of another periodic function: (2.33) E =f2( x ,t ,d , rm,Q , D ,S , k , ) Here E is the normal bank erosion rate (positive when measured to the left of the flow direction), d is a lag distance measured parallel with the x-direction between related inflection and rotation points, r, is the local radius of channel curvature, Q is the fluid discharge (assumed steady), D is the calibre of the bed sediment (assumed uniform), S is the valley slope, and k , describes the resistance to erosion of the bounding alluvium. Equation (2.33) also appears in Fig. 2-21. The role of several variables requires explanation. The lag distance is vital, for without it a change of phase is impossible (Allen, 1974b). Putting L as the meander wavelength, the loops can simultaneously increase in amplitude and advance downstream only when 0 < d < L/4. Amplitude alone changes when d = 0, whereas only phase varies when d = L/4, and the other possibilities do not generally match real meander behaviour. Equation (2.18) affords a preliminary physical justification for the lag distance. Equation (2.33) includes the local radius of curvature, because from eqs. (2.25) and (2.30) it follows that the bank erosion rate partly depends on the appropriate flow depth. The channel width required for calculation of the local cross-section may be assumed uniform 'over the train. It may be obtained from the prescribed discharge, bed sediment and alluvium, by using the condition that at each rotation point the channel is temporarily noneroding. One important implication of the presence of rm in eq. (2.33) is that f , includes both dz/dt and d2z/dt2. It is therefore unlikely that eq. (2.33) can be solved analytically, though a step-wise graphical or numerical solution seems possible. Grain size and bedform on point bars
In developing eq. (2.25), the calibre of the sediment supplied, though considered uniform, was implicitly treated as an independent variable. This
92
is correct, because the transverse profile presents a merely local problem, and the sediment grades entering a bend are controlled by: (1) sorting over the whole upstream channel and, (2) the character of the source debris, the weathered mantle in the case of rivers and the offshore sediments for many tidal meanders. Sediments broadly ranging in calibre are likely to reach real bends. What distribution over a point bar surface will the grades tend to assume? Solving eq. (2.25) for D and differentiating partially with respect to h and r, we find that: --
-
ah
66(a - P)s",r",~
{ 2( u - p ) r + 66p ( u - p)Sn,rmCrh}' 33pSmrmh
aD -
ar
r2{2(a- p)
+ 66p(a - p)SmrmCh}
(2.34)
(2.35)
Therefore under a fully developed secondary flow, particles will be arranged such that D increases outward across the bar towards the thalweg. Fining towards the thalweg would seem possible only across exceptionally tight bends, where r varied similarly to h. Natural bends filling this bill are exceptionally rare, so that coarsening towards the thalweg should be the rule. Allen ( 1970b, 1970c, 197la) and Bridge ( 1975a, 1975b) also reached this result from a relation similar to eq. (2.22) and an assumed bar profile, but wrongly treated sediment calibre as a dependent variable. More recently, Bridge ( 1976) calculated the cross-channel grading by combining an expression derived similarly to eq. (2.22) with Engelund's eq. (2.27) for the bar profile. Despite a predicted outward coarsening, his analysis may be invalid, as two seemingly incompatible expressions for d h/dr are involved. Records of grain-size distribution On point bars are few but tend to support the result from eq. (2.25). Some rivers show an outward and downward coarsening over a major portion of a bar (Wiethe, 1970; Bluck, 1971; Masson, 1973), suggesting a mutual adjustment over a short distance between sediment and flow. A substantially longer relative distance has been necessary for adjustment in other bends, a well-defined coarsening towards the thalweg occurring only in the downstream part (Nilsson and Martvall, 1972; Erkek, 1973; R.G. Jackson, 1975; Bridge and Jarvis, 1977). Upstream the textural trends are weak and confused, or the calibre is substantially uniform across the channel. Only at riffles should there be cross-channel uniformity of grade, because in theory there are no curvature-induced transverse forces to promote cross-stream differentiation there. That nearuniformity of texture persists well downstream into some bends points to the delayed development of the secondary flow, and is consistent with the comparative tightness of these loops. If the construction and character of point bars depended on turbulence as Leighly (1932) proposed such delays should not be observed. Nansen (1980) gives further data on grading.
93
Far less is known of grading over tidal point bars. However, texture on large bars (Land and Hoyt, 1966) varies much as in rivers; the thalweg gravels of tidal gullies are well documented (Van Straaten, 1950b, 1954a; Reineck, 1958a; G. Evans, 1965). The prediction of bedform distribution in natural channel-bends is difficult, because: (1) the bed resistance coefficient is also a response to flow, (2) there is no generally accepted scheme for calculating roughness, and (3) the larger types of roughness may be expected to lag the unsteady flow. Allen ( 1970b, 1970c) and Bridge ( 1975a, 1975b) nevertheless essayed this using an assumed bar profile, the force balance equations (2.19-2.21), a steady discharge and fully developed secondary flow, and an assumed characteristic Darcy-Weisbach coefficient for each bedform type. To grasp the kind of result obtained, substitute eq. (2.25) into the conventional hydraulic equations for bed shear stress and stream power, written in terms of flow depth. Then: ro =
2 0 ( (J - p ) g r s
33Smrm{1 - 2 0 ( -~ p ) C r } 2( (I - p ) D r 33rm{1 - 2 0 ( 0 - p ) C r }
(2.36) (2.37)
in which q,is the bed shear stress and w the flow power. The stress and the flow depth increase equally with radius of curvature, but the power grows even more rapidly. Referring to Vol.1, Fig. 8.22, for example, and to Bagnold’s (1966) universal criterion for an upper-stage plane bed, Vol. I, eq. (7.4), such sequences inwards from the thalweg as: (1) upper-stage plane bed + dunes + ripples, and (2) upper-stage plane bed + dunes + lower stage plane bed may be expected, depending on grain size and discharge. Allen and Bridge calculated many such bedform sequences. Further sequences have been calculated for the theoretical bar profiles shown in Fig. 2-18. They bear out the preceding analysis, except for the poor representation of low-power forms, a consequence of assuming vertical banks. Although bedforms are widely reported from river channels, R.G. Jackson (1975) and Bridge and Jarvis (1977) stand alone in having mapped areal distributions. The maps (Fig. 2-22) from the Wabash differ slightly from those originally given, to account for Jackson’s failure to distinguish kinds of plane bed, and the limitations of his low-resolution echo-sounder. In this revision, his depth and velocity measurements have proved invaluable, and where the secondary flow appears to be fully developed, there are bedform sequences similar to those calculated (Fig. 2- 18; Allen, 1970b, 1970c; Bridge, 1975a, 1975b). It is telling in support of Stein’s (1965) work that Jackson generally records the tallest dunes in mid-channel positions, though he also claims an increasing height towards the thalweg.
94
( a ) High stage
( b ) Intermediate
0
KEY
?Lower-stage plane beds/rippies
TO
500 m
BEDFORMS
0
Dunes
?Upper-stage plane beds
Fig. 2-22. Distribution (partly inferred) of bedforrns in the Bozernan and Helm Bends of the Wabash River (modified after R.G. Jackson, 1975).
LATERAL ACCRETION STRUCTURES AND DEPOSITS
An integration of the preceding morphological and dynamical evidence affords a general conception of the three-dimensional geometry and faciessequence of river and tidal point bars. In essence, the bar deposit is expected to overlie a laterally extensive erosion surface formed through meander migration, and should comprise an upward-fining facies-sequence transected by gently inclined curved bedding surfaces which denote episodes of channel shifting. The geometry constitutes a “lateral accretion structure”, and the facies assemblage a “lateral accretion deposit”, because sedimentation occurs on a surface inclined across the direction of the effective currents, the strata being built “sideways” with respect to them. Observations supporting these ideas accumulated earliest from small meandering gullies on intertidal flats (Figs. 2-23a, 2-24b), at first in Germany (Trusheim, 1929; Hantzschel, 1936; Reineck, 1958a, 1970b; Reineck and Wunderlich, 1969), and later in the Netherlands (Van Straaten, 1950b, 1954a) and elsewhere (G. Evans, 1965; Le Gall and Larsonneur, 1972; Bridges and Leeder, 1976). The lateral deposits are rarely thicker than 1.5 m and consist of interbedded curved layers of sand and mud, generally convexup radially but in places sigmoidal or concave. The sand layers, usually thickest and most numerous towards the base, vary from parallel-laminated to current rippled (commonest), both ebb and flood directions often being preserved. A profusion of burrowing invertebrates inhabits the deposit. Underlying the whole is an irregular erosional surface, generally overlain by a gravel of bivalve and other shells mixed with pebbles of muddy sediment derived from cut banks. Erosional surfaces more discordant than those usually underlying the sand layers appear locally. They can reflect either stages in channel planimetric evolution, as controlling the influence of flow
95
Cross- lamination Parallel lamination
-
Flood tide
C--
Ebb tide
Orientation of current-directional structures
Invertebrate burrows
/
T
Lateral accretion structure Mud
0
Sand
Crass-lamination
Erosion surface Upward-fining Crass-bedding
Mud c l a d lag
I Loferal accretions 1 -
Orientation of current-directional structures
Parallel lamination
Fig. 2-23. Models for the sequence of lithologies and sedimentary structures in point bars. a. Mixed mud-sand tidal gully. b. Sand-bed river. The orientation of the master bedding (lateral accretions) is in each case compared with that of the smaller scale directional structures.
separation on deposition and erosion in these relatively small meanders, or extreme events such as violent rainstorms (Bridges and Leeder, 1976). Storm tides could also cut such discontinuities. Closely related. conceptions of lateral accretions in river meanders have been separately developed by Bernard and Major (1963) and Bernard and others (1970), by Allen (1963a, 1964, 1965a, 1965b, 1970b, 1 9 7 0 ~1971a), by Visher (1965a, 1965b, 1972), and by Bluck (1971), Bridge (1975a, 1975b),
96
and R.G. Jackson (1976). These models, most of which depict threedimensional aspects of the deposits, are foreshadowed in the work of F.A. Melton (1936), Nanz (1954) and Sundborn (1956). Fig. 2-23b shows one of a wide range of possible models for river point bars. It is considered representative of intermediate to large sand-bedded rivers with bends growing mainly in amplitude. The stratigraphic section is in the downstream half of the bend, where the secondary flow may be considered fully developed. The basal erosion surface, with flutings, pot-holes and other scours, was cut as the meander loop grew laterally. It dips outwards slightly, since the channel became narrower and deeper as sinuosity increased for the fixed valley slope. The basal surface is diachronous. Coeval portions form a series of nested arcs imitating the channel in planimetric form, the oldest and shortest lying beneath the bar core. Sediments in the lateral accretion deposit fine upwards in general but interfinger in detail. At the base is the coarsest debris supplied from upstream, mixed with clasts formed by erosion of concave banks. Internal sedimentary structures appear upwards in order of declining flow power, an arrangement which reflects the distribution of bedforms over the bar surface, in turn revealing the inward decline of current strength. The relative abundance of the different structures changes laterally, in response to the varying channel sinuosity. Curved bedding surfaces generally sigmoidal in radial profile define the lateral accretion structure. There are at least three kinds: ( 1) non-discordant and marking vertical transitions between sediments differing in sedimentary structure and/or grade, (2) erosional and slightly discordant, generally with the coarser deposit and/or the sedimentary structure of greater flow-power above, and (3) strongly discordant and extensive, often descending to large basal scours. These surfaces define interfingerings on several scales, and they depend on the unsteady channel flow, which varies daily, seasonally, and over still longer periods. For Bridge ( 1975a, 1975b), the third type of surface forms during the annual flood, but a discharge event even more extreme may actually be necessary. Where the secondary flow was not fully developed, the deposit may be either vertically uniform in texture or even upward-coarsening over an interval (R.G. Jackson, 1975, 1976). However, the sequence of structures should differ from that in the fully developed section only as the bed sediment changes. Lateral accretion in large tidal channels is modelled in a similar manner to Fig. 2-23b (Oomkens and Terwindt, 1960; Noorthoorn Van der Kruijff and Lagaaij, 1960; Klein, 1965), with ample support coming from later work (Land and Hoyt, 1966; Howard et al., 1975; Barwis, 1978). The chief contrasts are that (1) the cross-bedded facies may include foresets of opposed dip and other features indicative of markedly unsteady currents, and (2) the upper bar is likely to be dominated by richly bioturbated, interbedded muds and sands with wave and current ripples.
Fig. 2-24. Lateral deposits in fluvial and tidal sediments. a. Lateral deposit in Catskill Formation (Devonian), Rip Van Winkle Trail, Haines Falls, New York State (see Allen and Friend, 1968). Approximately 1-1.5 m of red mudstone are followed by an erosively based sandstone which passes up into interbedded sandstone and mudstone. The master bedding in the sandstones and interbeds dips at about 20" to the left and involves at least one major erosional discordance, evidence for which can be seen upward and slightly to right of left-hand figure. The master bedding is truncated near the top of the photograph by mudstones and thin sandstones parallel with the base of the main sandstone. The person (not possessed of bilocatory powers!) is 1.7 m tall. b. Lateral deposit constructed by a meandering tidal gully (seen passing between the stakes), intertidal mud flats, Jade, Germany. Approximately 1.5 m of the mud cliff is exposed above the water level.
TABLE 2-1 Some examples of lateral deposits in shallow-water (mainly fluvial) sediments from the stratigraphic record Authority Sundborg, 1956 Allen, 1965a Moody-Stumt, 1966 Beutner et al., 1967 Allen and Friend, 1968 Geology Extra-Mural Group, 1968 Cummins and Rundle, 1969 Johnson and Friedman, 1969 Gradzinski, 1970 Beuf et al., 1971 Cotter, 1971 Dodson, 1971 Maberry, 1971 Puigdefabrigas, 1973 Derr, 1974 Van Gelder, 1974 Hobday and Mathew, 1975 Nami, 1976 Elliott, 1976a Elliott, 1976b Karl, 1976 Padgett and Ehrlich, 1976
* Truedip.
Age and area Quaternary, Sweden Devonian, Wales Devonian, Spitsbergen Carboniferous, U.S.A. Devonian, U.S.A. Carboniferous, Scotland Quaternary, England Devonian, U S A . Cretaceous, Mongolia Devonian, N. Africa Cretaceous, U.S.A. Cretaceous, Canada Creticeous, U S A . Miocene, Spain Jurassic, U S A . Devonian, Ireland Permo-Carboniferous, S. Africa Jurassic, England Carboniferous, England Carboniferous, England Cretaceous, U S A . Carboniferous, Morocco
Exposure 2D 2D and 3D 2D 2D 2D 2D 2D 2D 2D 3D 2D 2D 2D 3D 2D 2D 2D 3D 2D 2D 2D 3D
Thickness (m) 7 1 .O-2.7 0.5-6.25 13.5 7 5 3 3+ 1.O- 8.5 10 10 5 < 12 <2 4 3 6 3-4 7 (3.5 3+ 5
Slope (">
7 4- 14* 4- 15* 15 22 20 4 23 5- 10 12 5-10 15 11 18 20 15 12 15* 5 6 10 ?
Fig. 2-25. Panorama taken from cliff-top looking eastward down on to foreshore at low tide, to show curved upper edges of laterally deposited sandstones in a palaeomeander, flat-lying beds, Scalby Formation (Middle Jurassic), Burniston Wyke, Yorkshire coast, England. The palaeomeander has a maximum exposed extent of the order of 125 m. Photographs courtesy of M.R. Leeder.
Lateral accretions no longer coupled to active rivers were first described by Sundborg (1956), from a Klaralven terrace, and by Allen (1965a) from the Old Red Sandstone, in which three-dimensional developments could be examined. Fluviatile lateral accretions were afterwards widely recognized (Table 2-1, Fig. 2-24a). These sequences, up to 13.5 m thick, vary from chiefly conglomerates with sandstones to mainly mudstones with sandstones of the finer grades. They generally fine upwards. The lateral accretion surfaces dip as steeply as 23”, though dips of about 10” are normal, and range in kind as in the model (Fig. 2-23b). The third type (Allen and Friend, 1968; Puigdefabrigas, 1973; Elliott, 1976a) is associated by Elliott with high-stage events. If he is correct in identifying 8-12 scroll bar deposits as lying between his adjacent discontinuities, then each such event, in terms of Hickin and Nanson’s (1975) work, could be something like the 100-year rather than the annual flood. It has been fully demonstrated that currents flowed nearly parallel with the discontinuities in lateral accretion deposits. The remarkable three-dimensionally exposed instances (Fig. 2-25) described by Beuf et al. (1971), Puigdefabrigas (1973), Nami (1976), Padgett and Ehrlich (1976), Nami and Leeder (1978), and‘Puigdefabrigas and Van Vliet (1978) are fully consistent with the flow-geometry relationship depicted in Fig. 2-23b. From washouts in rocks of the same general age as Nami studied, Black ( 1928) had earlier reported what are recognisable lateral accretions, and had referred to channels which, running parallel with the modern coast, “may then be quite clearly seen to meander”. The only tidal lateral accretion listed in Table 2-1 is Van Gelder’s (1974), which agrees well with the model (Fig. 2-23a). Other possible examples are recorded by Hobday et al. (1971). Although meanders occur on deep-sea fans, lateral accretions are not yet recognized in the deposits, but should be expected.
SUMMARY
Meandering river and tidal channels are similar in their distinctive geometry and flow dynamics. The constraining of the fluid discharge into a horizontally curved path generates a helical spiral secondary flow in each meander loop. In response, the outer side of the channel deepens and the concave bank scours, with the result that the meander loop changes in phase and amplitude in growing toward some limiting condition. In harmony, deposition on the inner bank gives rise to a lateral accretion deposit, marked internally by a characteristic geometry (lateral accretion structure) and spatial arrangement of sedimentary facies. The key to understanding the facies and geometry of these accretions, together with channel developmental patterns, seems to be a consideration of the response of the sediment carried round the channel bend to the transverse forces associated with the secondary flow, whichin turn is dependent on the channel form and discharge.
101
Chapter 3 AN OUTLINE O F FLOW SEPARATION INTRODUCTION
The brief discussion in Vol. I, Chapter 1, showed flow separation (Vol. I, Fig. 1-9) to be intimately involved with the development of an adverse (positive) pressure gradient in a boundary-layer flow, usually on account of some change in flow geometry (Prandtl, 1952; Schlichting, 1960). Where pressure increases down-current, fluid particles moving near the flow boundary are retarded and, eventually losing all their kinetic energy in conquering friction, gradually pile up. The stream is consequently forced obliquely away from the boundary by this piled-up fluid, in which a reverse motion may appear. In practice, the flow separating from the boundary in one place, becomes rejoined or reattached to it at another, a more or less closed region of rotating fluid arising between the two. The combination of a region of rotating flow with a stream temporarily freed from its flow boundary- that is, a separated flow-is associated with many sedimentary structures, and may contribute significantly to the determination of their geometry and often to the texture of the deposits marked by them. Important examples are ripples and dunes, about which much has already been said, together with flute marks and obstacle marks. The complex shapes assumed by these structures are matched harmoniously by equally complex patterns of currents and flow forces in the accompanying separated flows. We shall here review the simpler kinds of separated flow, in preparation for a return to ripples and dunes, and for a discussion of flute marks. Further details appear in P.K. Chang’s (1970) comprehensive general survey, and in the review by Brown and Stewartson (1969), restricted to laminar flows. Complex types of flow separation exist where strongly threedimensional bluff bodies are mounted on flow boundaries, for example, pebbles or massive colonial corals resting on muddy substrates. These flows and the obstacle marks they help to create will be discussed separately. The flow separation accompanying the production of sedimentary structures generally occurs at a low flow speed, in water below the velocity for cavitation, and in the air at subsonic speeds. There are features on meteorites and tektites, however, which seem to be related to separation at supersonic and hypersonic speeds, and it will be necessary briefly to review separation under these conditions. SEPARATION IN INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL FLOWS
An externalflow is one where the solid boundaries of interest are wholly enveloped by the fluid, which theoretically extends to infinity. An example is
102
a sand grain sinking through a large volume of still water. Separation shown by a ring of rotating fluid on the upper side of the grain may occur if the relative motion generates a sufficiently adverse pressure gradient. The character of the separated flow in this case depends only on the properties of the fluid and grain. The ultimate flow boundaries, which must in practice exist, are sufficiently far removed from the grain that they can be ignored. An internalflow is one strongly confined by solid boundaries or by solid boundaries in combination with a free surface, the fluid being wholly enveloped, as for example a river or the meltwater filling an englacial tunnel. Separation may occur in these flows wherever they change direction sufficiently rapidly as a body, as we saw in Chapter2, and at any abrupt boundary discontinuity, for example, a step up or down (rock ledge or dune), or a cavity (pot-hole). The character of the separated flow now depends not only on the nature of the fluid and the boundary geometry, but also on the kind and degree of boundary constraints (Kline, 1959; Ackeret, 1967). These substantially affect the shape of a region of rotating flow and seem to be amongst the controls on dune steepness. STREAMLINE MAPPINGS
Figure 3- 1 epitomizes two-dimensional separation, the criterion for which is that aU/ay = 0 at the wall, where U for a turbulent flow is understood to be the local temporal mean velocity. This criterion is satisfied in Fig. 3-la at the point S, which is a separation point. Here two limiting streamlines converge, and a streamline departs obliquely from the bed. This streamline passes through the fluid and reattaches itself at A, an attachment point, dividing into two. At A we again find that aU/ay = 0 at the wall, whence the criterion distinguishes attachment as well as separation. The streamline connecting S with A through the fluid is the separation or free streamline. It divides off a closed region of rotating flow, called a separation bubble, from the outer unidirectional stream. Figure 3-lb depicts part of the flow as expressed by limiting streamlines in the xz-plane. Because the flow is two-dimensional, the point S is but one of an infinite number of similar points which together define a transverse line S'S" on the flow boundary. This line is a singular separation line because the limiting streamlines are orthogonal to it; strictly, S should also be described as singular. Similarly, the infinity of points corresponding to A in Fig. 3-la define in Fig. 3-lb a singular attachment line A'A", on which A is a singular point. A real flow claimed as two-dimensional is never more than nominally of this kind, and many practical flows $re in fact strongly three-dimensional. Flow separation in these instances creates patterns of motion of much greater complexity than appear in Fig. 3-1 and, in addition, severe problems of definition and verification (Eichelbrenner and Oudart, 1954, 1955;
I03 Y t
x
Fig. 3- 1. Schematic representation of flow separation in a two-dimensional boundary layer. a. Streamlines and velocity profiles in the flow plane. b. Limiting streamlines in the flow boundary.
Maskell, 1955; Legendre, 1956; Eichelbrenner, 1957; Oswatitsch, 1958; Thwaites, 1960; Cooke and Brebner, 1961; Rosenhead, 1963; Perry and Fairlie, 1974, 1975; Hunt et al., 1978). We now find a tangential rather than orthogonal relationship between limiting streamlines and separation or attachment lines. The preceding simple criteria for attachment and separation break down, for non-zero velocity gradients and bed shear stresses are detectable along separation and attachment lines in three-dimensional flows. Moreover, these lines no longer comprise an infinite number of singular points, but merely a few, of two distinct kinds, obeying a precise topological rule (Coddington and Levinson, 1955; Kaplan, 1958; Rosenhead, 1963; Hunt et al., 1978).
A'
Fig. 3-2. Types of nodal point. a-c. Separation points. d-f. Attachment points.
104
Some of the patterns assumed by limiting streamlines in the neighbourhood of one of these kinds of singularity appear in Fig. 3-2 (Legendre, 1956; Rosenhead, 1963; E.S. Taylor, 1967; Allen, 19688). They share the property that the streamlines have but one kind of relationship to the point, being either all “point-seeking” (Fig. 3-2a-c) or all “point-fleeing” (Fig. 3-2d- f). Such singularities are called nodalpoints (Rosenhead, 1963). Those in the top row are all separation points, those below being all of attachment. The patterns shown in Fig. 3-2c, f are associated with separation and attachment lines, respectively, S’S” and A’A’. Aside from the singular point, each of these lines consists only of what Maskell (1955) distinguishes as ordinary points (of separation or attachment), at which the velocity gradient remains finite. The respective separation and attachment lines are also called ordinary, to distinguish them from the singular lines-E.S. Taylor’s ( 1967) “cylindrical points”-of the two-dimensional case. The second type of singularity to be found in three-dimensional separated flows is a saddle point (Rosenhead, 1963). Here some streamlines are point-seeking, whereas others are pointfleeing (Fig. 3-3). Amongst these patterns, the separation lines (ordinary) are those containing outward-directed streamlines, while the attachment lines, also ordinary, are defined by inward-directed flows (Eichelbrenner, 1957). By the definition of a limiting streamline, the mappings of these streamlines in three-dimensional flows are required to obey definite topological rules with respect to the relative numbers of nodal points (of all kinds) and of saddle points (of all kinds) (M.J. Lighthill, in Rosenhead, 1963; Perry and Fairlie, 1974, 1975; Hunt et al., 1978). These rules are hard to prove from real flows, because of the limitations of even the best flow-visualization techniques, but can be readily demonstrated from theoretical patterns (e.g. Eichelbrenner, 1957; Davey, 1961). For example, the rule for a smooth rounded body like a sphere in external flow is that the number of nodal points exceeds the number of saddle points by two. Figure 3-3e shows Davey’s (1961) calculated limiting streamlines for a flow attaching to a
Fig. 3-3. Saddle points (a,b) of separation, and (c,d) of attachment. e. Davey’s (1961) calculated pattern of limiting streamlines for a flow attaching to a surface with two rounded protuberances.
105
surface carrying two rounded, flow-facing protuberances. The mapping includes three attachment points, two nodal ( A N ) and one a saddle point (As). Our rule here requires that one more nodal point be present, presumably at a distance; it would be satisfied if the flow were external and the protuberances lay on the leading surface of a spherical body, with separation to the rear from a single nodal point (e.g. Fig. 3-2a). Hunt et al. (1978) discuss the topological rules governing nodal and saddle points for other boundary conditions, as well as providing many elegant practical examples. ROLLERS AND VORTICES: CLOSED AND OPEN SEPARATION
Separation bubbles are either rollers or vortices, accordingly as they either fully or partly close themselves off from the outer stream (Allen, 1970f). We note first that separation streamlines unite in the third dimension to form surfaces of separation. If a surface of separation and the flow boundaries combine in such a way as totally to enclose the fluid within a separation bubble, then that bubble is a roller (Fig. 3-4a). Fluid particles trapped within rollers follow recirculating paths, whence the limiting streamlines are reflexed; the separation may then be described as closed. Whereas rollers typify nominally two-dimensional and some moderately three-dimensional separated flows, vortices characterize strongly three-dimensional ones (Fig. 3-4b). A vortex is entered by many of the streamlines of the outer flow, in addition to the free streamlines which separate along the ordinary separation line. Fluid particles typically follow spiral paths in vortices and the limiting streamlines within the separation bubble normally are inflected. A vortex draws fluid from the outer stream and, at its terminus, discharges fluid back into the main flow; the separation may therefore be described as open. Very little is known about the flow patterns involved in the transition
Fig. 3-4. Idealized (a) roller and (b) vortex developed downstream of negative steps in a flow boundary.
106
between two-dimensional and three-dimensional separation. In a numerical study, however, Sykes (1980) has shown for hummocks and cavities of rounded form that, as the degree of three-dimensionality increases, a nodal point within the body of the separated fluid gradually moves closer to the bed until it reaches and joins the bed. SEPARATION IN TWO DIMENSIONS
External flows A low-speed fluid travelling parallel with a flat plate having sharp leading and trailing edges arranged transversely to flow, separates on both sides of the plate along the leading edge, and again at the trailing margin (Fig. 3-5). The captive leading-edge bubbles (W.D. Moss, 1972) are stable whether the flow be laminar or turbulent and resemble bubbles as commonly developed on plates (e.g. Gaster, 1969; Ojha, 1969). The trailing-edge bubbles are stable only at small Reynolds numbers (Hoerner, 1950; Roshko, 1954a, 1954b, 1955b, 1961; Acrivos et al., 1965), when they too are symmetrically disposed. The flow reattaches within the fluid at what might be called a free point and again along the rear face of the plate (Viviand and Berger, 1965a, 1965b; Mueller and O’Leary, 1970). A similar attachment and rearward separation marks both steady and unsteady low-speed flow past bluff plates (Taneda, 1956a, 1972; Taneda and Honji, 197l), square cylinders (Mulhearn, 1973), and circular cylinders arranged at right-angles across the flow (Tritton, 1950; Taneda, 1956a, 1972; Grove et al., 1964; Coutenceau and Bouard, 1977a, 1977b). With cylinders, the separation bubbles lengthen with increasing Reynolds number (Fig. 3-6), while the velocity of backflow U,, increases relative to the external flow velocity U,. Numerical studies yield generally similar results (e.g. Hamielec and Raal, 1969; Dennis and Chang, 1970; Pruppacher et al., 1970; Nieuws-
Fig. 3-5. Separated flows associated with a boundary layer forming on a thick flat plate of finite length.
107
AA A
e 0 0
8
A
*
A
0.15
A
*O
*
0
,"
f
A A
0
0.10
0
0
gA 8"
A
B
Taneda (19560) Grove et at. ( 1 9 6 4 ) o Coutenceau and h a r d (1977)
Grove et al. ( 1 9 6 4 )
A
o Coutenceau and h a r d (19770)
I
50
I00
Reynolds number, U, D / u
150
0
50
100
150
Reynolds number, U ' D/Y
Fig. 3-6. Features of the separated flow downstream of a circular cylinder arranged transversely to a fluid stream. a. Relative length of separation bubble as a function of Reynolds number. b. Relative maximum backflow velocity in separation bubble as a function of Reynolds number.
tadt and Keller, 1973). At Reynolds numbers greater than the order of 100, depending on the degree of confinement of the cylinder by the boundaries of the whole flow, the separation bubbles are shed periodically into the wake as a vortex street (Roshko, 1961 ; Sonneville, 1976). Cavity flows Of more relevance to sedimentary structures is low-speed flow in a two-dimensional cavity, a motion much studied on account of its practical importance (Wieghardt, 1953; Baturin, 1959). A two-dimensional cavity is specified completely by its shape, streamwise length L , and height H . Two alternative boundary conditions are involved in the experimental and numerical study of cavity flows. Under the first, the cavity is treated as open along one face to a stream flowing past. The second takes the cavity to be completely closed but with a lid moving in its own plane. Figure 3-7 summarizes schematically the results of many experiments on the flow in rectangular cavities (Wieghardt, 1953; Roshko, 1955b; Baturin, 1959; J. Fox, 1960; Tani et a]., 1961; Maul1 and East, 1963; R.D. Mills, 1965a, 1965b; Weiss and Florsheim, 1965; Haugen and Dhanak, 1966; Jarrett and Sweeney, 1967; Kistler and Tan, 1967; Pan and Acrivos, 1967; Reiman and Sabersky, 1968; Fenton and White, 1971; Raithby et a]., 1978; Rockwell and Knisely, 1979). Under the first boundary condition, the flow separates from the upstream edge and reattaches on the downstream face
108
s -
A
Fig. 3-7. The separated flow in transverse rectangular cavities at (a,c,e) small Reynolds numbers, and (b,d,f) large Reynolds numbers. No particular Reynolds number is implied by (g), which shows the downward weakening of the vortices in a deep cavity. Based on many sources.
just below the rim. In shallow to square cavities, the flow comprises a single large roller, the centre of rotation of which shifts with increasing Reynolds number towards the geometrical centre of the cavity. The Reynolds number also has some effect on the number and relative size of the secondary corner eddies (Burggraf, 1966a) which generally accompany the \main vortex. The velocity of backflow reaches up to 30% of the velocity of the outer stream and increases relatively with the Reynolds number. In deeper cavities, chains of vortices are created by the driving action of the outer flow, the rollers, tending to a square section, growing weaker as they become further removed from the open top. Similar flow patterns exist under the second boundary condition, where the moving lid takes the place of the surface of separation. Small vortices again arise in the cavity corners. Little work has been done on cavities of non-rectangular cross-section. As the apical angle is reduced in a cavity of triangular section, a solitary roller gives way to a train of increasingly smaller vortices (Henry et al., 1964;
109
Mueller and O’Leary, 1970; Rotem et al., 1970). A single vortex occurs in round-bottomed cavities (Chung and Viegas, 1961). Maul1 and East (1963) and Kistler and Tan (1967) are the only workers to have studied nominally two-dimensional cavity flows other than in the plane of flow, finding the motion to be moderately three-dimensional. Limiting streamlines deviate by upwards of 20” from the streamwise direction, and both saddle and nodal points can be mapped in the flow pattern. Because of the simplicity of the boundary conditions, numerical studies of cavity flows are remarkably successful, supporting the experimental results for both small and large Reynolds numbers (R.D. Mills, 1965a, 1965b; Weiss and Florsheim, 1965; Burggraf, 1966a, 1966b; Pan and Acrivos, 1967; Ratkowsky and Rotem, 1968; Mehta and Lavan, 1969; L.F. Donovan, 1970a, 1970b; Mueller and O’Leary, 1970; Roache and Mueller, 1970; Rotem et al., 1970; V. O’Brien, 1972; Bhatnagar and Wong, 1974; Nallasamy and Prasad, 1977; Olson and Tuann, 1979). Many of the higher Reynolds number solutions depend on the suggestion by Batchelor ( 1956) and Squire (1956) that the flow is divisible between an outer region of boundary-layer type, in contact with the cavity wall, and an inner inviscid core. Steps and walls Laboratory work and other observations soon showed that low-speed flow separation could occur both upstream and downstream from a bluff wall or other thin obstruction arranged across a boundary-layer flow, and also at both upstream-facing and downstream-facing steps (Cornish, 1897; Dobrowolski, 1924; Prandtl, 1927b; Rehbock, 1930). Strong positive pressure gradients usually exist in front of bluff walls or upstream-facing steps within boundary layers. Separation under these circumstances has been little-studied, though of practical importance, creating Scorer’s (1955) “bolster” vortices in which, for example, sand can be trapped on the upwind sides of escarpments and ridges. Wieghardt (1953), Ringleb (1961), Bradshaw and Galea (1967), and Good and Joubert (1968) have established experimentally the main features of the motion (Fig. 3-8a). At other than very small Reynolds numbers, the flow separates 2-3 step or wall heights ahead of the obstruction and reattaches on the vertical part of the surface. We now find that the flow ahead of a step or wall is less constrained than that in a cavity. In particular, the upstream separation point takes a position controlled by a strong interaction between the outer flow and the separation bubble, an interaction that is weak in a cavity confined on three sides. The calculation of separated flows ahead of walls and steps is therefore more difficult and uncertain than the prediction of cavity flows (Lighthill, 1953; Barrows, 1963; Robertson and Huang, 1969; Kiya and Arie, 1972; Taulbee and Robertson, 1972; Haussling, 1977; Dennis and Smith, 1980). Low-speed separation at a vertical wall or thin barrier arranged trans-
Fig. 3-8. Schematic representation of flow separation (a) upstream of a positive step, and (b) at a transverse wall.
versely across a boundary-layer flow creates a large roller (Prandtl, 1927b; Arie and Rouse, 1956; Kapur and Reynolds, 1967; Acrivos et al., 1968; Good and Joubert, 1968; Bradshaw and Wong, 1972; Kiya and Arie, 1972; Narayanan, 1972; Narayanan and Reynolds, 1972). Because of the upthrust imparted to the fluid at the forward face of the wall, the crest of the roller lies nearly two wall-heights above the flow boundary, while its centre of rotation occurs at about the height of the wall itself (Fig. 3-8b). The bubble for the same reason is usually relatively long, in the order of 15-20 wall-heights, but can be shortened under severe boundary constraints. The maximum velocity of backflow is 20-30% of the velocity of the external stream. Studies of flow separation at single two-dimensional downstream-facing steps are confined either to those with right-angled corners or with gently sloping risers similar in profile to a dune or ripple. A roller is formed at such a step (Fig. 3-9), whether the separating flow is laminar or turbulent, the geometry of the separation bubble changing with Reynolds number and boundary-layer thickness. Generally, there are accompanying secondary separation bubbles, as in cavity flows. At a right-angled step there is typically a large secondary bubble in the bottom corner, and usually others just beneath the surface of separation at the edge (Moffatt, 1964). Secondary
(0)
(b)
Fig. 3-9. Effect of (a) vertical and (b) sloping risers on flow separation at a tranwi’se negative step.
vortices may also occur in these positions with gently sloping risers, but they are seldom as well developed. If a laminar flow is started up at a two-dimensional downstream-facing step or a transverse ridge, a roller of gradually increasing size is shaped to lee (Honji, 1975; Longuet-Higgins, 1981). The size of the roller ultimately developed beneath a steady laminar stream increases gradually with Reynolds number and boundary-layer thickness (Tani, 1958; T.W.F. Moore, 1960; Tani et al., 1961; Nash et al., 1963; Goldstein et al., 1970; Mueller and O'Leary, 1970; Roache and Mueller, 1970; Denham and Patrick, 1974; Thomas et al., 1981). At very small Reynolds number, the roller is less than the step-height in length, but at moderate numbers is in the order of 10 times longer. Backflow velocities are small compared with the outer flow. A turbulent low-speed flow passing over a single downstream-facing step separates as a long flat roller similar to that sketched in Fig. 3-9 (Wieghardt, 1953; Tani, 1958; Tani et al., 1961; Raudkivi, 1963; Henry et al., 1964; Heskestad, 1966; Naib, 1966; Allen, 19688, 1969b; Butte and Pichon, 1970; Etheridge and Kemp, 1978). Experiments with right-angled steps show that the length L of the separation bubble grows with a decrease in the thickness h of the flow, normalized by the step-height H , as illustrated in Fig. 3-10. However, shorter and less rapidly changing bubbles arise at steps with risers sloping at about 30" from the horizontal (Fig. 3-10). The greatest velocities 8.5
8.0
7.5
7.0
L/H 0
65
0
6-0
5-5
5.0 Allen Allen 0.2
0.4
0.6 0.8 1.0
2
4
6
8 1 0
20
b/H
Fig. 3-10. Experimental variation in the relative length of the separation bubble to lee of a transverse negative step as a function of relative step-height, with the slope of the riser as a third variable. After Allen (19688, 1969b).
112
0.30-
0.25
-
0.20 -
0.15
-
0.10
urneon
a
0.05 -
-L-
O
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
L/ H
Fig. 3- 1 1. Experimental values for the backflow velocity 0.008 m above the bed and half-way along the separation bubble to lee of a transverse negative step, 0.04 m tall, as a function of the relative length of the separation bubble. Data of Allen (1968g).
of backflow at steps are in the order 20-40% of the main-stream velocity. Allen ( 1968g) found experimentally that the maximum backflow velocity gradually increased with increasing bubble length and, therefore, with decreasing flow thickness (Fig. 3-1 1). Thomas et al. (1981) give more data. In practice, a truly two-dimensional separated flow cannot exist downstream of a two-dimensional step, because of the constraints inevitably arising from side walls. Allen (1968g, 1969b) examined the patterns of limiting streamlines on both right-angled and sloping steps, finding weakly three-dimensional separation in all cases (Fig. 3- 12). Nodal and saddle points existed in alternation along each reattachment line, showing that the separation bubble was divided transversely into a number of cells, as exist in the separated flow in a two-dimensional cavity (Maul1 and East, 1963; Kistler and Tan, 1967). A reduction in flow thickness relative to step height rapidly increases the number of these cells per unit span. A separation phenomenon resembling that at a step occurs when a plane full jet (Bourque and Newman, 1960; Sawyer, 1960, 1963; Newman, 1961; Rajaratnam and Subramanya, 1968; Madjirsky, 1969; Exley and Brighton, 1971) or a half-jet (Abramovich, 1963) reattaches to an adjacent boundary. For the turbulent half-jet, Abramovich calculated a separation bubble about six times longer than the normal distance of the jet from the boundary, with backflow velocities of up to 40% of the main stream, in good agreement with experiments at steps (e.g. Naib, 1966). A double-step configuration presents downstream-facing two-dimensional steps arranged symmetrically about the plane of flow and directly opposite
1 I3
o Nodal point
Saddle point
-O
005 m
Fig. 3- 12. Experimentally determined limiting streamlines on a two-dimensional negative step 0.022 m high with sloping riser in a water stream of velocity 0.29 m s- and depth 0.064 m.
’
each other, one on each side of a conduit or channel (Mehta, 1979). At small Reynolds numbers and for right-angled steps (Fig. 3-13a) the separated flow comprises symmetrically arranged equal bubbles increasing in length with the value of the number (Hung and Macagno, 1966; Macagno and Hung, 1967a; Durst et al., 1972, 1974). At moderate and large numbers, however, the arrangement is unstable, one of the bubbles being nearly twice as long as the other (Abbott and Kline, 1962; Filetti and Kays, 1966; Durst et al., 1972, 1974). More bubbles may arise further downstream, so that the outer flow meanders unpredictably (Fig. 3-13b). Separation is suppressed if the slope of the step is reduced to about 4” relative to the mean flow direction (Schlichting, 1960). Mehta (1981) reports ‘further work on double steps.
Fig. 3-13. Flow separation in rectangular conduits with steps on opposite walls. a. Stable symmetrical flow pattern formed at small Reynolds numbers. b. Unstable “meandering” pattern of separation found at moderate and large Reynolds numbers.
1 I4
AXISYMMETRIC FLOWS
These are three-dimensional flows with the special property of being symmetrical about the mean flow direction, so that they are completely described by reference to any cross-section containing this axis. It is therefore not surprising that separation under axisymmetric and under twodimensional conditions are closely related. Axisymmetric separation in external flows at small Reynolds numbers is shown by spheres and by bodies of revolution such as spheroids, cones, and spherical caps. In laboratory and numerical experiments, a ring-like separation bubble marks the rear of such bodies, the motion in an axial section resembling that in the trailing vortex of Fig. 3-5 (Taneda, 1956b; Margarvey and Maclatchy, 1968; Masliyah and Epstein, 1970; Masliyah, 1972; Dorrepaal et al., 1976; Collins, 1979; Han and Patel, 1979). As with circular cylinders (Fig. 3-6), the bubble increases in length with increasing Reynolds number until, at a critical value, it is periodically shed to form a kind of vortex street. Narasimhan (1967) finds that separation at large Reynolds number on a cone pointing downstream is strongly influenced by the apical angle; the annular bubble increases in length as the apical angle is increased. This motion resembles that at a step with sloping riser (Fig. 3-9b), when again the presence of right-angled corners lengthens the separated region (Fig. 3-10). Little is known of separation