Rheology
Polymer
of
Filled
Systems
Aroon V. Shenoy
Advisory Consultant Pune, India
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS
D...
503 downloads
2970 Views
14MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Rheology
Polymer
of
Filled
Systems
Aroon V. Shenoy
Advisory Consultant Pune, India
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS
DORDRECHT/BOSTON/LONDON
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data
ISBN 0-412-83100-7
Published by Kluwer Academic Publishers P.O. Box 17, 3300 AA Dordrecht, The Netherlands. Sold and distributed in North, Central and South America by Kluwer Academic Publishers, 101 Philip Drive, Norwell, MA 02061, U.S.A. In all other countries, sold and distributed by Kluwer Academic Publishers, P.O. Box 322, 3300 AH Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 1999 Kluwer Academic Publishers No part of the material protected by this copyright notice may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission from the copyright owner.
Printed in Great Britain
Preface
Polymeric materials have been replacing other conventional materials like metals, glass and wood in a number of applications. The use of various types of fillers incorporated into the polymer has become quite common as a means of reducing cost and to impart certain desirable mechanical, thermal, electrical and magnetic properties to the polymers. Due to the energy crisis and high prices of petrochemicals, there has been a greater demand to use more and more fillers to cheapen the polymeric materials while maintaining and/or improving their properties. The advantages that filled polymer systems have to offer are normally offset to some extent by the increased complexity in the rheological behavior that is introduced by the inclusion of the fillers. Usually when the use of fillers is considered, a compromise has to be made between the improved mechanical properties in the solid state, the increased difficulty in melt processing, the problem of achieving uniform dispersion of the filler in the polymer matrix and the economics of the process due to the added step of compounding. It has been recognized that addition of filler to the polymer brings a change in processing behavior. The presence of the filler increases the melt viscosity leading to increases in the pressure drop across the die but gives rise to less die swell due to decreased melt elasticity. The decrease in melt elasticity can raise the critical shear rate at which melt fracture during extrusion starts to occur and hence one could often consider increasing throughput rate in the case of filled polymer melt processing. The purpose of the present book is to treat the rheology of filled polymer systems in as much detail as possible. With the idea of addressing readers of this book who may come from different
backgrounds, a concerted effort has been made to provide the initial three chapters with material needed for familiarizing with the basics about polymers, fillers, physico-chemical interactions between the two, rheology and rheometry. The first chapter introduces the subject and gives an overview. It briefly discusses the various types of polymers and fillers that can go into the formation of filled polymer systems. It also gives an outline about the physico-chemical interactions between polymers and fillers. The second chapter deals with the fundamentals of rheology and provides definitions of all the basic rheological parameters. It dwells on the non-Newtonian character of filled polymeric systems and explains the various anomalies that are encountered during the flow of viscoelastic materials. Various viscoelastic phenomena are depicted and these give an idea about the complexities involved in the flow of polymeric materials, which gets further complicated in the presence of fillers. The third chapter presents some of the different methods of rheological measurements. The entire range of rheometers has not been explained here as the focus in this chapter has been to include only those that find relevance to filled polymer characterization. The fourth chapter presents some constitutive theories and equations for suspensions. Suspension rheology normally deals with the flow behavior of two-phase systems in which one phase is solid particles like fillers but the other phase is water, organic liquids or polymer solutions. Literature on suspension rheology does not include flow characteristics of filled polymer systems. Nevertheless, this chapter needs to be included as the foundations for understanding the basics of filled polymer rheology stem from the flow behavior of suspensions. In fact, most of the constitutive theories and equations that are used for filled polymer systems are borrowed from those that were initially developed for suspension rheology. Chapter 5 goes into the details of how to prepare filled polymer systems. It discusses the criteria for good mixing and the various mixing mechanisms by which fillers get compounded with polymers. The compounding techniques are discussed and compounding/mixing variables are highlighted so that the sensitivity of these variables is understood in order to obtain well-dispersed filled polymer systems under optimum conditions. Chapters 6 to 9 discuss the steady shear viscous properties, steady shear elastic properties, unsteady shear viscoelastic properties and extensional flow properties, respectively. The effect of filler type, size, size distribution, concentration, agglomerates, surface treatment as well as the effect of polymer type are elucidated. The tenth chapter has been
included to recapitulate the important aspects discussed in the presented work. It is hoped that this book will provide all the necessary background needed to understand the various aspects relating to the rheology of filled polymer systems so that even new entrants to this exciting field may benefit from the information. For those who have already whetted their appetite with a taste for this research area, it is hoped that this book will provide complete details under one cover and entice them to probe into vacant areas of research that may become obvious to them on reading this book. Aroon V. Shenoy
Contents
Preface ............................................................................
ix
1.
Introduction .............................................................
1
1.1 Polymers ......................................................................
1
1.1.1
Thermoplastics, Thermosets and Elastomers ..................................................
1
1.1.2
Linear, Branched or Network Polymers .......
2
1.1.3
Crystalline, Semi-Crystalline or Amorphous Polymers ..................................
5
1.1.4
Homopolymers ............................................
6
1.1.5
Copolymers and Terpolymers .....................
7
1.1.6
Liquid Crystalline Polymers .........................
9
1.2 Fillers ............................................................................
9
1.2.1
Rigid or Flexible Fillers ................................
10
1.2.2
Spherical, Ellipsoidal, Platelike or Fibrous Fillers .............................................
10
Organic or Inorganic Fillers .........................
11
1.3 Filled Polymers ............................................................
11
1.4 Filler-Polymer Interactions ...........................................
16
1.2.3
1.4.1
Filler Geometry ...........................................
18
1.4.2
Volume Fraction ..........................................
19
1.4.3
Filler Surface ...............................................
19
1.4.4
Wettability ...................................................
19
1.4.5
Filler Surface Treatment ..............................
21
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
v
vi
2.
Contents 1.5 Rheology ......................................................................
39
References ..........................................................................
43
Basic Rheological Concepts ..................................
54
2.1 Flow Classification .......................................................
55
2.1.1
Steady Simple Shear Flow ..........................
55
2.1.2
Unsteady Simple Shear Flow ......................
59
2.1.3
Extensional Flow .........................................
62
2.2 Non-Newtonian Flow Behavior ....................................
66
2.2.1
Newtonian Fluids ........................................
66
2.2.2
Non-Newtonian Fluids .................................
67
2.2.3
Viscoelastic Effects .....................................
71
2.3 Rheological Models .....................................................
79
2.3.1
Models for the Steady Shear Viscosity Function ......................................................
79
Model for the Normal Stress Difference Function ......................................................
84
Model for the Complex Viscosity Function ......................................................
86
Model for the Dynamic Modulus Functions ....................................................
90
Models for the Extensional Viscosity Function ......................................................
93
2.4 Other Relationships for Shear Viscosity Functions .....................................................................
99
2.3.2 2.3.3 2.3.4 2.3.5
2.4.1
Viscosity-Temperature Relationships ..........
2.4.2
Viscosity-Pressure Relationship .................. 103
2.4.3
Viscosity-Molecular Weight Relationship ................................................ 104
References ..........................................................................
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
99
104
Contents 3.
Rheometry ............................................................... 112 3.1 Rotational Viscometers ................................................
113
3.1.1
Cone and Plate Viscometer ......................... 115
3.1.2
Parallel-Disc Viscometer ............................. 117
3.2 Capillary Rheometers ..................................................
118
3.2.1
Constant Plunger Speed Circular Orifice Capillary Rheometer ................................... 119
3.2.2
Constant Plunger Speed Slit Orifice Capillary Rheometer ................................... 124
3.2.3
Constant Speed Screw Extrusion Type Capillary Rheometers .................................. 124
3.2.4
Constant Pressure Circular Orifice Capillary Rheometer (Melt Flow Indexer) ....................................................... 126
3.3 Extensional Viscometers .............................................
128
3.3.1
Filament Stretching Method ........................ 128
3.3.2
Extrusion Method ........................................ 130
References ..........................................................................
4.
vii
131
Constitutive Theories and Equations for Suspensions ........................................................... 136 4.1 Importance of Suspension Rheology ..........................
136
4.2 Shear Viscous Flow .....................................................
137
4.2.1
Effect of Shape, Concentration and Dimensions on the Particles ........................ 137
4.2.2
Effect of Size Distribution of the Particles ...................................................... 147
4.2.3
Effect of the Nature of the Particle Surface ....................................................... 150
4.2.4
Effect of the Velocity Gradient ..................... 150
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
viii
Contents 4.2.5
Effect of Flocculation ................................... 151
4.2.6
Effect of the Suspending Medium ................ 153
4.2.7
Effect of Adsorbed Polymers ....................... 154
4.2.8
Effect of Chemical Additives ........................ 160
4.2.9
Effect of Physical and Chemical Processes ................................................... 160
4.2.10 Effect of an Electrostatic Field ..................... 162
5.
4.3 Extensional Flow ..........................................................
164
References ..........................................................................
167
Preparation of Filled Polymer Systems ................ 175 5.1 Goodness of Mixing .....................................................
175
5.2 Mixing Mechanisms .....................................................
183
5.3 Compounding Techniques ..........................................
186
5.3.1
Selection Criteria ......................................... 186
5.3.2
Batch Mixers ............................................... 189
5.3.3
Continuous Compounders ........................... 192
5.3.4
Dump Criteria .............................................. 218
5.4 Compounding/Mixing Variables ..................................
221
5.4.1
Mixer Type .................................................. 223
5.4.2
Rotor Geometry .......................................... 224
5.4.3
Mixing Time ................................................. 225
5.4.4
Rotor Speed ................................................ 229
5.4.5
Ram Pressure ............................................. 229
5.4.6
Chamber Loadings ...................................... 231
5.4.7
Mixing Temperature .................................... 232
5.4.8
Order of Ingredient Addition ........................ 236
References ..........................................................................
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
237
Contents 6.
7.
8.
ix
Steady Shear Viscous Properties .......................... 243 6.1 Effect of Filler Type ......................................................
244
6.2 Effect of Filler Size .......................................................
246
6.3 Effect of Filler Concentration .......................................
248
6.4 Effect of Filler Size Distribution ....................................
262
6.5 Effect of Filler Agglomerates .......................................
272
6.6 Effect of Filler Surface Treatment ................................
273
6.7 Effect of Polymer Matrix ..............................................
279
6.8 Unification of Steady Shear Viscosity Data .................
287
References ..........................................................................
303
Steady Shear Elastic Properties ............................ 312 7.1 Effect of Filler Type ......................................................
313
7.2 Effect of Filler Size .......................................................
315
7.3 Effect of Filler Concentration .......................................
317
7.4 Effect of Filler Size Distribution ....................................
321
7.5 Effect of Filler Agglomerates .......................................
321
7.6 Effect of Filler Surface Treatment ................................
323
7.7 Effect of Polymer Matrix ..............................................
330
References ..........................................................................
332
Unsteady Shear Viscoelastic Properties .............. 338 8.1 Effect of Filler Type ......................................................
344
8.2 Effect of Filler Size .......................................................
344
8.3 Effect of Filler Concentration .......................................
345
8.4 Effect of Filler Size Distribution ....................................
350
8.5 Effect of Filler Agglomerates .......................................
356
8.6 Effect of Filler Surface Treatment ................................
360
8.7 Effect of Polymer Matrix ..............................................
372
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
x
9.
Contents 8.8 Effect of Matrix Additives .............................................
387
References ..........................................................................
390
Extensional Flow Properties .................................. 395 9.1 Effect of Filler Type ......................................................
396
9.2 Effect of Filler Size .......................................................
400
9.3 Effect of Filler Concentration .......................................
402
9.4 Effect of Filler Surface Treatment ................................
405
References ..........................................................................
409
10. Concluding Remarks .............................................. 416 Appendices .................................................................... 425 Appendix A Glossary ..........................................................
425
Appendix B ASTM Conditions and Specifications for MFI ...............................................................................
430
Appendix C Data Details and Sources for Master Rheograms ..................................................................
433
Appendix D Abbreviations ..................................................
439
Appendix E Nomenclature .................................................
441
Appendix F Greek Symbols ...............................................
449
Author Index .................................................................. 455 Index ............................................................................... 469
This page has been reformatted by Knovel to provide easier navigation.
Introduction
I
1.1 POLYMERS Polymers are high molecular weight organic substances that have usually been synthesized from low molecular weight compounds through the process of polymerization, using addition reaction or condensation reaction. In addition polymerization, the reaction is initiated by a free radical which is usually formed due to the decomposition of a relatively unstable component in the reacting species. In this reaction, repeating units add one at a time to the radical chain, and reasonably high molecular weight polymers can be formed in a short time by this polymerization. In condensation polymerization, the reaction takes place between two polyfunctional molecules to produce one larger polyfunctional molecule with the possible elimination of a small molecule such as water. Long reaction times are essential for forming high molecular weight polymers by this step reaction. An elementary introduction to polymers is given here and those wishing to gain more knowledge about the physics, chemistry and engineering aspects of polymers should consult some of the standard references [1-13] on the subject. Polymers formed through the polymerization processes discussed above can be classified in a number of different ways based on certain chosen characteristics for comparison. 1.1.1
THERMOPLASTICS, THERMOSETS AND ELASTOMERS
Thermoplastics are those polymers that can be made to soften and take on new shapes by application of heat and pressure. The changes that occur during this process are physical rather than chemical and hence products formed from such polymers can be remelted and reprocessed.
Table 1.1 Some candidate polymers used in the formation of filled polymer systems Thermosets
Elastomers
Thermoplastics
Epoxies
Neoprenes
Nylons
Phenolics
Nitriles
Polypropylene
Unsaturated polyesters
Styrene butadienes
Polystyrene
Thermosets are materials that have undergone a chemical reaction, known as curing in A, B and C stages depending on the degree of cure by the application of heat and catalyst. The A stage is the early stage, B stage is the intermediate stage and C stage is the final stage of the curing reaction. The crosslinked structure that forms in the polymer during the reaction is stable to heat. Hence products formed through these polymers cannot be made to flow nor can they be melted and thus are not reprocessible. Not all thermosets go through A, B and C stages, and in fact, processors are often interested in the flow behavior of those that have not undergone cure. Elastomers are rubbery polymers that deform upon the application of stress and revert back to the original shape upon release of the applied stress. They are lightly crosslinked molecular networks above their glass transition temperatures. They are often capable of rapid elastic recovery. They are available as natural rubbers or synthetic rubbers. Natural rubbers are elastic substances that are obtained by coagulating the milky extracts from certain tropical plants; while synthetic rubbers are those that are artificially prepared by combining two or more monomers through a chemical reaction. Some of the candidate polymers from the above three categories which are used in the formation of filled polymer systems are given in Table 1.1.
1.1.2 LINEAR, BRANCHED OR NETWORK POLYMERS
A polymer can be classified as linear or branched depending upon its structure. The thermoplastic polyethylene serves as a good example because it exists with linear as well as branched structure as can be seen from Figure 1.1. Based on the pressure (low or high), the reaction temperature and the choice of the catalyst during the polymerization process, polyethylenes with different densities and structures are formed. High-density polyethylene (HDPE) has a linear molecular structure and a density ^0.94g/cm3, low-density poly-
LOW PRESSURE
HDPE
HIGH PRESSURE
LDPE
LOW PRESSURE
LLDPE
Figure 1.1 Comparison of structures of HDPE1 LDPE, and LLDPE.
ethylene (LDPE) has a branched structure and a density ^0.92g/cm3, whereas linear low-density polyethylene (LLDPE) with a density of 0.92-0.93 g/cm3, although branched is significantly different from LDPE due to the absence of secondary branching and presence of short branches. Polycondensation of compounds with a functionality of three or more with the addition of special hardening agents to form chemical crosslinks results in polymers with three-dimensional network structure. A classical example of the formation of a network polymer is the polycondensation of phenols with aldehydes. The reaction between phenol and formaldehyde in the absence of a catalyst is very slow and hence in all commercial synthesis, catalysts are always added to
accelerate the reaction. The nature of the end product and the reaction rate depend greatly upon the type of catalyst and the mole ratio of the two reactants. When one mole of phenol is reacted with 0.8-0.9 mole of formaldehyde in an acidic medium, the reaction product is a soluble, fusible resin which can be converted into an insoluble, infusible product only upon the addition of excess formaldehyde. These resins are therefore termed two-stage resins known as novolacs. On the other hand, when one mole of phenol is reacted with one or more moles of formaldehyde at a pH of 8 or above (i.e. alkali-catalyzed medium), then insoluble, infusible products are directly formed. These resins are termed one-stage resins and known as resols, which are linear or branched low molecular products.
Resols on further heating change into resitols, a three-dimensional network polymer of low crosslink density as
The last stage of the heating process results in the formation of resites, which is a network polymer of high crosslink density as
It should be noted that the structure of phenolics is much more random than that shown above. The pictorial representation is basically a simplified version only for the sake of exemplifying the formation of a three-dimensional network. Other thermosets besides phenol-aldehyde which are formed into network polymers by similar reactions are urea-aldehyde and melamine-aldehyde polymers. 1.1.3
CRYSTALLINE, SEMI-CRYSTALLINE OR AMORPHOUS POLYMERS
Polymers can also be classified as crystalline, semi-crystalline or amorphous polymers depending on their degree of crystallinity. A crystal is basically an orderly arrangement of atoms in space. Polymers that are able to crystallize under suitable temperature conditions are called crystalline polymers. The primary transition temperature, when a crystalline polymer transforms from a solid to a liquid, is the melting temperature designated Tm. On the other hand, an amorphous polymer does not crystallize under any conditions. The phase transition for this type of polymer occurs from the glassy state to rubbery state at a temperature termed the glass transition temperature and often designated Tg. Most thermoplastics have both Tg and Tm. This is because it is relatively difficult to get to the extreme case of a completely crystalline polymer with an ideal formation of single crystals having the relative arrangement of atoms strictly the same throughout the volume. In fact, deviations from the completely ordered arrangement as well as completely disordered arrangement always exist. Thus, it is the degree of crystallinity that truly determines whether a polymer could be classified as a crystalline, amorphous or semi-crystalline polymer.
1.1.4 HOMOPOLYMERS
When a single repeating unit such as A or B exists in a polymer, it is termed a homopolymer. Thus, homopolymer is AAAAAAAA or BBBBBBB. For example,
when R = H, then the result is the homopolymer polyethylene (PE); when R = CH3, it is polypropylene (PP); when R = C6H5, it is polystyrene (PS) and when R = Cl, it is polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The materials mentioned above namely, PE, PP, PS and PVC are among the largest volume thermoplastics utilized. They are used in a maximum number of applications, mostly in those which do not require high performance or special properties. In terms of cost they are among the cheapest of the thermoplastics. Hence they are often referred to as commodity plastics. Another important class of polymers which are formed by addition polymerization like the above are based on one of the following three repeating units
1,4 addition
3,4 addition
1,2 addition
When X = H, the resulting polymer is polybutadiene; when X = CH3, it is polyisoprene and when X = Cl, it is polychloroprene. The double bond may be 'cis' or 'trans' and would thus give the cis or trans forms of these polymers. It is the 1,4 addition form that predominantly goes into the formation of commercial dienes which are all elastomers. Typical examples of homopolymers that are formed by condensation polymerization are the polyamides and polyesters
When R E=(CH2)S, the resulting polymer is polyamide: nylon-6; when R'=(CH 2 ) 6 and R"=(CH 2 ) 4 , it is nylon-66; when X = (CH2), and X' = C6H5, it is polyester: polyethylene terephthalate (PET). These thermoplastics have properties which are superior to those of commodity plastics (namely, olefinics and styrenics). They go into a number of engineering applications and are termed engineering thermoplastics. Besides poly amides (nylons) and polyesters, some of the other homopolymers which fall into this category of engineering thermoplastics are the acrylics, acetals and polycarbonates. High performance engineering thermoplastics have recently assumed increasing importance due to their exceptional properties at elevated temperatures. A number of such specialty polymers have been introduced into the market for high temperature applications and examples of some of the outstanding ones are polyphenylene oxide (PPO), polyphenylene sulfide (PPS), polyether sulfone (PES), polyaryl sulfone (PAS), polyether ketone (PEEK), polyether imide (PEI) and polyarylate (PAr). Each of the above mentioned specialty polymers exhibits enhanced rigidity at high temperatures. This is a consequence of their high glass-transition temperatures, presence of aromatic ring structures in the backbone chain and relatively strong hydrogen bonds.
1.1.5
COPOLYMERS AND TERPOLYMERS
When two different monomers are used in the polymerization process, the result is a copolymer. The repeating units A and B both exist in the polymerized product and their varying configurations give different types of copolymers (i) Random copolymer: AA B AAA BB A BBB (ii) Uniform copolymer: AB AB AB AB AB (iii) Block copolymer: AAA BBB AAA BBB AAA B B (iv) Graft copolymer: AAAAAAAAAAAAA. B B B B B B B Block copolymers may be arranged in various star arrangements, wherein polymer A radiates from a central point with a specified number of arms and polymer B is attached to the end of each arm.
Copolymerization is often used to alter the properties of homopolymers and to achieve specific performance. For example, the flow behavior of PVC is considerably improved by incorporating vinyl acetate as comonomer. Similarly, the thermal stability of polyoxymethylene is improved considerably by incorporation of -CH2-CH2-O units in the chain yielding an oxymethyline or acetal copolymer. If either of the comonomers on its own could yield a crystalline homopolymer, then copolymerization can have a very marked effect on properties by inhibiting crystallization. For example, PE crystallinity is decreased by increasing the amount of vinyl acetate content in the copolymer leading to a softer, tougher product, namely, ethylenevinyl acetate (EVA). The properties of block copolymers are dependent on the length of the sequences of repeating units or domains. The domains in typical commercial block copolymers of styrene and butadiene are sufficiently long to produce flexible plastics called thermoplastic elastomers. In fact, the copolymer butadiene-styrene is a good example of how the thermoplastic characteristics can be changed by altering the portion of two components of the copolymer. Polybutadiene is a synthetic rubber with a high level of elasticity, while polystyrene is a clear brittle plastic which is often used for making disposable containers. A copolymer made with 75% butadiene and 25% polystyrene is styrene butadiene rubber (SBR) with direct applications to carpeting, padding and seat cushions. On the other hand, a copolymer of 25% butadiene and 75% styrene gives an impact styrene which is often used for the manufacture of equipment cabinets and appliances. Most commercial varieties of high-impact polystyrene (HIPS) are graft copolymers in which the main chain is that of butadiene while styrene forms the branches. Copolymers of styrene, with acrylonitrile (SAN) and maleic anhydride (SMA) are typical examples of uniform alternating copolymers. Copolymers represent an industrially important class of polymeric materials, due to their unique combination of properties such as impact resistance, elasticity and processibility. Block copolymers, in particular, have great technological importance because of the ability of these materials to form thermoplastic elastomers which can be processed by conventional thermoplastic processing techniques. Readers wishing to know more about copolymers may refer to the excellent monographs [14-20] that are available. Polymerization of acrylonitrile and styrene in the presence of butadiene rubber results in a terpolymer called acrylonitrile-butadienestyrene (ABS). Besides grafting styrene and acrylonitrile into polybutadiene in latex form, ABS may also be produced by blending emulsion latexes of styrene-acrylonitrile (SAN) and nitrile rubber (NBR). Since ABS is a three component system, many variations are
possible. Acrylonitrile imparts chemical resistance while butadiene provides increased toughness and impact resistance. A variety of grades are available - some for general purposes, some for various levels of impact resistances and others for ease of plating. The major applications include plumbing systems, telephone housings and automobile grills (either painted or electroplated). 1.1.6
LIQUID CRYSTALLINE POLYMERS
Polymers in which rigid, anisotropic moieties are present in the backbone of the polymer chain are known to give rise to liquid crystalline behavior and are therefore known as liquid crystalline polymers (LCP) [21]. Such types of polymer have attained immense importance due to the possibility of producing ultrahigh modulus fibers and plastics. The main interest in the subject of LCP was kindled by the commercialization of the aromatic polyamide fiber, namely, Kevlar which was as stiff and strong as steel but at one-fifth the density of steel, and with excellent chemical and heat resistance. Kevlar is a lyotropic liquid crystal, that is, it attains liquid crystalline order only when dissolved in an appropriate solvent. Since the removal of the solvent is a necessary step during fabrication of the product, such lyotropic LCPs are restricted to the formation of thin fibers and films. For thicker products, however, polymers are needed which become liquid crystalline upon heating i.e. 'thermotropic' LCPs. There has been increasing interest in using LCPs as reinforcing additives in polymers to form blends and composites [22,23]. But moldable LCPs, regrettably, do not have immense commercial importance. The exceptional physical properties of these uniquely structured systems are a direct consequence of the morphology and orientation induced into the polymers due to the flow history during processing. Thus understanding the rheological behavior associated with liquid crystallinity is undoubtedly essential for processing the LCPs into the appropriate structure to exhibit their desirable properties [24]. 1.2
FILLERS
The term 'filler' in the present context is used for describing those inert, solid materials which are physically dispersed in the polymer matrix, without significantly affecting the molecular structure of the polymer. Further, the term is restricted to those materials which are in the form of discrete particles or of fibers not exceeding a few inches in length. Continuous filaments or fabrics either woven or nonwoven are not included in this category of fillers discussed
Table 1.2 Examples of rigid and flexible fillers Filler type Rigid
Flexible
Aluminum oxide Barium carbonate Calcium carbonate Calcium hydroxide Calcium silicate Clay Glass fiber Magnesium hydroxide Metal fiber Mica Talc Wollastonite
Asbestos fiber Cotton flock Cotton !inters Jute fiber Kevlar fiber Nylon fiber Polyester fiber Sisal
herein. Readers wishing to know more about fillers may refer to the excellent handbook on the subject [25]. Filler categorization can be done in a number of different ways as shown in Tables 1.2-1.4. In the following, a brief discussion is given under a variety of headings based on certain chosen characteristics for comparison. 1.2.1
RIGID OR FLEXIBLE FILLERS
Rigid fillers are those fillers that do not change their shape or spatial configuration within the polymer matrix. An example of such type of filler is glass fiber. On the other hand, flexible fillers are those fillers whose spatial configuration within the polymer matrix is not rigidly defined. For example, asbestos fibers, nylon fibers, polyester fibers, etc. would lie in folded, coiled or twisted positions within the polymer matrix. This type of filler classification is shown in Table 1.2. 1.2.2
SPHERICAL, ELLIPSOIDAL, PLATELIKE OR FIBROUS FILLERS
Fillers can be classified based on their physical form and shape as shown in Table 1.3. Among the classifications shown, only spherical fillers are symmetric in physical form and hence provide symmetric changes in properties in all three spatial directions. It is normally rare to find exactly spherically well-formed fillers. There is always a slight defect in shape, especially for finer size particles. For instance, even when controlled conditions are used in the preparation of monodisperse silica spheres in the micron size range [26,27], all particles
Table 1.3 Filler classification by physical form Filler form
3-dimensional
2-dimensional
Spherical
Ellipsoidal
Flakes
Platelets
Glass beads
Wood flour
Mica
Clay
1-dimensional
Fibers
Whiskers
Glass fibers Wollastonite
produced are not exactly spherical when viewed under the scanning electron microscope. Thus, the terms spherical or ellipsoidal can be viewed as those referring to nearly spherical or nearly ellipsoidal fillers. When the physical form of the filler is two-dimensional, the fillers may be available as flakes (larger size plates) or platelets (smaller size plates). Thus, mica particles exist as flakes whereas clay particles exist as platelets. In the one-dimensional form, filler may be available in the thicker variety as a fiber or thinner (acicular-needle-shaped) variety as a whisker. Fillers available as fibers are glass, nylon, polyester, carbon and so on. Wollastonite stands out as a good example of an acicular filler. 1.2.3 ORGANIC OR INORGANIC FILLERS
Classification of fillers can also be based on their chemical form [28,29] as shown in Table 1.4. Organic fillers fall within the subcategory of cellulosics, lignins, proteins and synthetics. On the other hand, inorganic fillers include carbonates, oxides, silicates, sulfates, carbon, metal powders and so on. 1.3
FILLED POLYMERS
The use of fillers in polymers has been going on for years. In the early history of filled polymers, fillers were added to the polymers rather empirically. Woodflour was one of the first fillers used in thermosetting phenol-formaldehyde resins because the combination was found to be valuable in enhancing certain properties whereas the addition of some other finely divided material to such resins conferred no benefit at all and hence was never done. The presence of the woodflour increased
Table 1.4 Different types of fillers Organic Cellulosics Alpha cellulose Cotton flock Sisal Jute Wood flour Shell flour Cotton-seed hulls Cotton !inters Cork dust
Lignins Processed lignin Ground bark
Inorganic Proteins
Synthetics
Carbonates
Hydroxides
Soybean meal Keratin
Acrylics Nylons Polyesters
Calcium carbonate Barium carbonate Magnesium carbonate
Calcium hydroxide Magnesium hydroxide
Inorganic Oxides
Silicates
Sulfates
Carbon
Metals powders/fibers
Miscellaneous
Aluminum oxide Antimony trioxide Zinc oxide Magnesium oxide Quartz Diatomaceous earth Tripoli Hydrogel Aerogel
Calcium silicate Magnesium silicate Clay Talc Mica Asbestos Feldspar Wollastonite Pumice Vermiculite Slate flour Fuller's earth
Calcium sulfate Barium sulfate
Carbon black Graphite
Aluminum Copper Bronze Lead Steel Zinc
Barium ferrite Magnetite Molybdenum disulphide
Source: Refs 28 and 29 (Reprinted with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers, Inc., Connecticut, USA and Gulf Publishing Co., Houston, Texas, USA).
Table 1.5 Some typical examples of filled polymer systems Polymer
Filler
Thermoset: Phenol-formaldehyde resin Elastomer: Styrene butadiene rubber Thermoplastic: Polypropylene
Wood flour/cotton flock Carbon black Calcium carbonate/talc
strength and prevented cracking of the resin by reducing the exotherm in the curing reaction. Similarly, the use of carbon black as a reinforcing agent in rubber has been going on since early in the century as it was a major factor in the development of durable automobile tyres. Glass fiber in nylon and asbestos in polypropylene confer useful properties but, if the filler and polymer are switched, i.e. asbestos is put into nylon and glass into polypropylene the results are not nearly so good unless the fillers are treated with appropriate coupling agents. Polypropylene is also often filled with calcium carbonate and talc with constructive results. Little thought was given in the early days towards the reasons for the observed behavior. Nowadays, however, the marriage of filler to polymer is done on a scientific basis and the reason for the addition of the specific filler can be elucidated on the desired property it imparts. Some of the typical examples of filled polymer systems using a thermoset, elastomer and thermoplastic are given in Table 1.5. The escalating cost of engineering thermoplastics over the last couple of decades and the awareness of dwindling supply of petrochemicals has created renewed incentives to restrict the quantities of resins used through the addition of fillers to the polymer matrix. Besides savings in cost, certain fillers provide the added advantage of modifying specific mechanical, thermal and electrical properties of thermoplastic products as can be seen from Table 1.6. When stiffness, strength and dimensional stability are desirable, the polymers are extended with rigid fillers; for increased toughness as
Table 1.6 Reasons for the use of fillers in thermoplastics 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
To To To To To To To
increase stiffness, strength and dimensional stability increase toughness or impact strength increase heat deflection temperature increase mechanical damping reduce permeability to gases and liquids modify electrical properties reduce the cost of the product
in the case of high-impact polystyrene or polypropylene, deformable rubber particles are added; asymmetric fillers such as fibers and flakes increase the modulus and heat distortion temperature; and electrical and thermal properties are modified by the use of metallized fibrous fillers. With fibrous fillers, the improvements can be further magnified due to the influence of the fiber aspect ratio and anisotropy as well as fiber orientation. The most effective reinforcing fillers are fibers of high modulus and strength. Glass fibers, which are non-crystalline in nature, or asbestos - a crystalline fiber - provide the reinforcement in most commercial fiber-reinforced thermoplastics. Carbon fibers or whiskers, single crystal fibers, are the other crystalline fibers used as reinforcement. The improvements in mechanical properties through the use of fillers acting as reinforcing agents have been discussed in detail by Nielsen and Landel [3O]. Such filled systems wherein the fillers provide reinforcements are often referred to as reinforced polymer systems or reinforced plastics. However, in the present book, the term 'filled polymer systems' is used in the most general sense and includes all systems wherein fillers are present as cost reducing agents as well as reinforcing or property modifying agents. One or more of the physical, mechanical and thermal properties of polymers can be effectively modified by the use of different types of fillers. For example, in the tyre industry, the presence of the filler carbon black in vulcanized rubber enhances properties like elastic modulus, tear strength and abrasion resistance [31-33] and also influences extrusion characteristics like extrudate distortion, extensional viscosity and die swell behavior [34-^4O]. Thus, carbon black functions as a reinforcing agent and a processing aid in the rubber industry. Different types of fillers serve different types of purposes. For example, titanium dioxide acts as a delustering agent in the fiber industry and aluminum trihydroxide as an economic flame retardant and smoke suppressing agent. In most applications, the proper balance of properties is no less important than an improvement of an individual property. It must be accepted that an improvement in one property can in all likelihood lead to deterioration of others and consequently, it is the overall performance of the filler in a given formulation that determines its choice. The predominant function of some typical fillers is given in Table 1.7. Selection of a filler is not just an art but a science and various factors would have to be considered in the choice such as, 1. 2. 3. 4.
Cost and availability Wettability or compatibility with the polymer Effect on polymer flow characteristics Physical properties
Table 1.7 Predominant function of some typical fillers Function
Typical fillers
Cost savings Reinforcement Hardness Thermal insulation
Wood flour, saw dust, cotton flock Glass fibers, cellulosic fibers, synthetic fibers, asbestos fibers Metallic powders, mineral powders, silica, graphite Asbestos, ceramic oxides, silica
Chemical resistance
Glass fibers, synthetic fibers, metallic oxides, graphites
5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Thermal stability Chemical resistivity Abrasiveness or wear Toxicity Recyclability
Undoubtedly the idea of adding the fillers is to achieve reduction in cost. However, there are some special type of fillers which are used purely on a functional basis with an accepted trade-off in the cost reduction, for example, some fiber glass reinforcements for polyesters, barium ferrite as a magnetizable filler, metallic powders for electrical and thermal conductivity improvement. In fact all these specialty fillers are more expensive than general purpose fillers and in some cases even more expensive than the polymer which they fill. In any case, the cost-effectiveness of the filler ought to be determined. The objective should be to compare the full cost of the completed product with and without the filler. The first step involves obtaining the raw material costs which must be converted from cost per pound to cost per volume. This is because cost per pound of the filler is meaningless unless adjusted for specific gravity differences. The volume of the polymer that is displaced by the filler becomes the main consideration. A three-step calculation method [41] can be used to get the polymer saved and thus to determine the cost-effectiveness of filled systems. If the filled polymer system is compounded in-house, then that cost has to be included. Similarly, added labour cost or savings due to the use of filled polymer systems must be considered. Often it is found that a minimum of 30 volume percent of low-cost filler is required to get a cost benefit when switching from unfilled polymer to filled polymer system. When selecting a filler, it is important to bear in mind that for adequate stress transfer, wettability and good adhesion between the filler and the polymer is essential. Physical properties like, for example, the density should be low so that the filler stays in suspension or at
worst is able to be resuspended with minimum mixing. Thermal stability and chemical resistivity are also very important so that the filler does not change characteristics during the preparation of the filled polymer system. Fibrous materials and non-symmetrical fillers are more abrasive than others and could cause increased wear to the processing equipment. Hence care has to be taken when selecting such fillers as they may not turn out to be cost-effective due to excessive damage to the equipment. Also the effect of fillers on polymer flow characteristics, namely, the rheology must be carefully assessed as that determines its processibility and hence is a very important parameter. 1.4 FILLER-POLYMER INTERACTIONS When a filler is added to a polymer with the specific idea of reinforcement, it is expected that the reinforcing filler component which is strong and stiff should bear most of the load or stress applied to the system while the polymer which is of low strength, fairly tough and extensible should effectively transmit the load to the filler. Maximum reinforcement benefits would be achieved from fillers when conditions occur in accordance with this concept [42]. In order that the load transfer takes place effectively, the matrix must have sufficiently high cohesive and interfacial shear strength. Thus, apart from the filler and the polymer, it is the inevitable region between them, namely, the interphase which plays a vital role in the fabrication and subsequent behavior of the filled polymer systems in service. The interphase is that region separating the filler from the polymer and comprises the area in the vicinity of the interface. It would be synonymous with the words 'interfacial region' but different from the term 'interface' which would be the contacting surface where two materials under consideration meet. Thus, for some filled polymer systems, there could exist more than one interface as in the case of coated fiber-filled polymer. In such cases, the fiber-coating interface and the coating-polymer interface would have characteristics of their own. However, normally a less atomistic view is taken and the characteristics of the 'interfacial region' as a whole are generally investigated. Good mechanical strength can be achieved only by uniform and efficient stress transfer through a strong interfacial bond between the filler and the polymer. It is important that the bond is uniform on a fine scale rather than unevenly strong in local regions as areas of the filler-polymer interface which are not in contact begin to act as cracks under an applied stress. In the absence of a good interfacial bond, fibrous fillers will pull out of the polymer and result in an annulment of the reinforcing effect [43]. Controlled debonding at the Next Page
Basic Theological
r\
concepts
4—
Filled polymer theology is basically concerned with the description of the deformation of filled polymer systems under the influence of applied stresses. Softened or molten filled polymers are viscoelastic materials in the sense that their response to deformation lies in varying extent between that of viscous liquids and elastic solids. In purely viscous liquids, the mechanical energy is dissipated into the systems in the form of heat and cannot be recovered by releasing the stresses. Ideal solids, on the other hand, deform elastically such that the deformation is reversible and the energy of deformation is fully recoverable when the stresses are released. Softened or molten filled polymer may behave as a viscous liquid or elastic solid during processing operations depending upon the relationship between the time scale of deformation to which it is subjected and the time required for the time-dependent mechanism to respond. The ratio of characteristic time to the scale of deformation is defined as the Deborah number by Reiner [1,2] as De = /lc//ls where Ac is the characteristic time, A8 is the time scale of deformation. The characteristic time, Ac/ for any material can always be defined as the time required for the material to reach 63.2% or [1 — (l/e)] of its ultimate retarded elastic response to a step change. If De > 1.0, elastic effects are dominant while if De < 0.5, viscous effects prevail. For any values of Deborah numbers other than these two extremes given above, the materials depict viscoelastic behavior. Filled polymer systems display the ability to recoil by virtue of their viscoelastic nature. However, they do not return completely to their original state when stretched because of their fading memory. Viscoelasticity allows the material to remember where it came from, but the memory of its recent configurations is always much better than that
of its bygone past, thus lending it the characteristics of a fading memory. Meissner [3] found that a filament of low density polyethylene (LDPE) at 423 K, which is stretched rapidly from 1 to 30cm length, and then suddenly set free, recovers to a length of 3 cm, thereby giving a recovery factor of 10. If the filament were made of filled LDPE, the recovery factor would be much smaller because the presence of the filler greatly reduces the stretchability as well as the recoil of the material. 2.1 FLOW CLASSIFICATION Flow is broadly classified as shear flow and extensional flow. A catalog of various types of shear flow has been given by Bird et al [4]. In the present book, the discussion is restricted to only simple shear flow that occurs when a fluid is held between two parallel plates. Simple shear flow could be of the steady or unsteady type. Similarly extensional flow could be steady or unsteady. In the case of extensional flow, it is often difficult to keep the measuring apparatus running for a long enough time to achieve steady state conditions and therefore unsteady conditions are quite often encountered. Thus, flow is classified here under three headings: 1. Steady simple shear flow 2. Unsteady simple shear flow 3. Extensional flow. Extensional flow (steady and unsteady) is treated under one heading for convenience. The definitions of important Theological parameters under each of the three headings are given below. 2.1.1 STEADY SIMPLE SHEAR FLOW
Fluid deformation under steady simple shear flow can be aptly described by considering the situation in Figure 2.1 wherein the fluid is held between two large parallel plates separated by a small gap dx2 and sheared as shown. The lower plate is moving at a constant velocity V1 while the upper plate is moving at a constant velocity of V1 H- Au1 under the action of a force / applied to it. A thin layer of fluid adjacent to each plate moves at the same velocity as the plate, assuming the no-slip condition at the solid boundary. Molecules in the fluid layers between these two plates move at velocities which are intermediate between V1 and V1 + Av1. Under steady-state conditions, the force / required to produce the motion becomes constant and is related to the velocity. The velocity profile of the fluid within the gap is given by dt^ = y dx2 where y is a constant.
Figure 2.1 Simple shear flow of a fluid trapped between two parallel plates. A.
Shear rate
The velocity gradient [Av1JdX2], which is termed the shear rate y can also be written as f 7 = ^ = Afel=lfel
dx2
dx2[dt\
dt[dx2\
l(21) ;
The term [dxi/dx2] represents the deformation of the material and is defined as the shear strain y. Thus, the shear rate is the rate of deformation or the rate of shear strain and is expressed as reciprocal seconds (sec"1). 6.
Shear-stress and extra stress tensor
The force per unit area [f/A] required to shear the material between two parallel plates is defined as the shear stress T2i, and it is basically a function (/cn) of the velocity gradient. Thus,
The units of shear stress are dynes/cm2 or Newtons/m2 (i.e. Pascals). It must be noted that i2i is just one component of the stress and, in principle, there are a number of components of stress that must be specified to completely define the state of stress. For example, a general constitutive equation which describes the mechanics of materials in classical fluid dynamics can be written as: f =-pf + f + ijv[trl5]I
(2.3)
where T(X, t) denotes the symmetric Cauchy stress tensor at positron x and time t, p(x, t) is the pressure in the fluid [T being the unit tensor), f is the extra stress tensor, T/V is the volume viscosity and D is the symmetric part of the gradient tensor of the velocity field v(x, t):
^••^[1+5] Note that Cartesian coordinates are used and vectors are denoted by single bar [—] above the letter while tensors are denoted by double bars [=] above the letter. If the fluid does not undergo a volume change, i.e. it is density preserving or incompressible, then the mass balance equation, better known as the continuity equation, reduces to tr 15 = Jp = O
(2Ab)
In such cases, the last term on the right-hand side of equation (2.3) drops out and the volume viscosity has no role to play. It should also be noted that, for flow of an incompressible fluid, the absolute value of the pressure p has no significance because it is only the pressure differences that are truly relevant. Thus, in essence, the constitutive equation (2.3) fpr an incompressible fluid connects only the 'extra stress tensor' f or T -f pi uniquely with the local motion of the fluid but always leaves the pressure p indeterminate. A general form of the constitutive equation can be written as f = ri(l H, IH)H
(2.5a)
The apparent viscosity Y] in the above equation is a function of the first, second and third invariants of the rate of deformation tensor. For incompressible fluids, the first invariant I becomes identically equal to zero. The third invariant III vanishes for simple shear flows and is normally neglected in non-viscometric flows as well. The apparent viscosity then is a function of the second invariant II alone. Hence equation (2.5a) is written in the simplified form as
In steady shearing flow, only a limited number of stress components of the extra stress tensor are necessary to completely define the fluid motion and these are written as follows: T11
f=
T12
O I
T21 T22 O O O T 33 1
(2.6)
The subscript 1 denotes the direction of flow, the subscript 2 denotes the direction perpendicular to the flow (i.e. the direction along the velocity gradient) and the subscript 3 denotes the neutral direction. The various stress components are shown on a representative cubic volume of the fluid in Figure 2.2. All the components are not shown in the figure in order to maintain clarity. Note that in steady shearing flow, the stress components T13, T23, T 315 T 32 , are identically equal to zero. T12 = T21 is called the shear stress and T11, T22, T33, are called normal stresses.
Figure 2.2 Various stress components on a representative cubic volume of fluid (stress components T12, T13, T31, T32, have not been shown in order to maintain clarity of the figure).
C. Normal stress difference The absolute value of any particular component of normal stress is of no rheological relevance, whereas the values of the normal stress differences T11 — T22 and T22 — T33 do have considerable rheological significance. The first is termed the primary normal stress difference while the latter is termed the secondary normal stress difference. Thus, N1 - T11 - T22
(2.7)
N2 = T22 - T33
(2.8)
For most fluids, N1 ^> N2 and hence the latter is often excluded in rheological discussions. Attempts to determine the value of secondary normal stress difference experimentally have been made by several rheologists but without success. It is still a challenge to quantitatively determine this material function. Nevertheless, it is not very important in most hydrodynamic calculations barring, of course, wire coating [5] wherein the secondary normal stress difference helps in providing the necessary restoring force for stabilizing the wire position whenever it becomes off-centered. D. Viscometric functions The viscosity function r\ (referred to as the steady shear viscosity), the primary and secondary normal stress coefficients ^1, and ^2, respectively, are the three viscometric functions which completely determine the state of stress in any Theologically steady shear flow. They are defined as follows: T12 = T21 = ri(y)y
(2.9)
Tn-T 2 2 = iAi(7)y2
(2.10)
2
(2.11)
T 22 - % = *2(y)y
Viscosity is the resistance of the material to any irreversible positional change of its volume elements while the normal stress coefficients exemplify the response of the material due to its elasticity or its ability to recover from the deformation. 2.1.2 UNSTEADY SIMPLE SHEAR FLOW
Unsteady simple shear flow would occur when the stresses involved are time-dependent. Small-amplitude oscillatory flow, stress growth, stress relaxation, creep and constrained recoil are some examples of such types of flows [4]. In the following, small-amplitude oscillatory flow is treated in sufficient detail while others are briefly described
and readers are encouraged to refer to Bird et al. [4] for more information. A. Small-amplitude oscillatory flow Small-amplitude oscillatory flow is often referred to as dynamic shear flow. Fluid deformation under dynamic simple shear flow can be described by considering the fluid within a small gap dx2 between two large parallel plates of which the upper one undergoes small amplitude oscillations in its own plane with a frequency CD. The velocity field within the gap can be given by Av1 — y dx2 but y is not a constant as in steady simple shear. Instead it varies sinusoidally and is given by y(t) = J0COSCDt
(2.12)
The shear stress in simple dynamic shear flow is expressed in terms of the amplitude and phase shift functions of the frequency as, ^21 (O = Jo[G'(cD) sin CDt + G'(CQ) cos cot] = r°2l sm[cDt + 6]
(2.13) (2.14)
where d is the phase angle, y0 and T^ are the amplitudes of the strain and stress, respectively, and G, G" are linear viscoelastic material functions, respectively, referred to as the dynamic storage modulus and dynamic loss modulus. To Dynamic storage modulus: G(CD) = -^- cos d (2.15) Vo
Dynamic loss modulus:
To G"(CD) — -^- sin d
7o
(2.16)
Another term of importance is the ratio of loss to storage modulus, defined as Loss tangent: —^- = tan 6 G(CD)
(2.17)
It is also possible to define a dynamic complex viscosity in terms of G and G" as follows: /•"•/// \ Dynamic viscosity: rj'(cD) = —— (2.18) Imaginary part of the complex viscosity: Y\"(CD) =
(2.19)
Complex viscosity function:
(2.20)
jf(ico) = ^(CD) — irj"(cD)
In the same manner as above, a complex modulus can be defined as below: Complex modulus: G*(ico) = G(CO) + iG"(co)
(2.21)
The storage modulus G(CO) and the imaginary part of the complex viscosity, i.e. rjf/(co), are to be considered as the elastic contributions to the complex functions. They are both measures of energy storage. Similarly, the loss modulus G"(CD) and the dynamic viscosity rj'(co) are the viscous contributions or measures of energy dissipation. B.
Stress growth
The aim of a stress growth experiment is to observe how the stresses change with time as they approach their steady shear flow values. This is done by assuming that the fluid sample trapped in a small gap between two parallel plates is at rest for all times previous to t = O implying that there are no stresses in the fluid when steady shear flow is initiated at t = O. For t > O when a constant velocity gradient is imposed, the stress is monitored with respect to time till it reaches steady state value. C. Stress relaxation The aim of a stress relaxation experiment is to observe how the stresses decay with time (i) after cessation of steady shear flow or (ii) after a sudden shearing displacement. In case (i) the fluid sample trapped in a small gap between two parallel plates is allowed to maintain constant shear rate that was started long before t = O so that all the transients during the stress growth period have evened out. Then at t = O, the flow is stopped suddenly and the decay of the stress is monitored with respect to time till it becomes insignificant or dies out. The stress would relax monotonically to zero and more rapidly as the shear rate in the preceding steady shear flow is increased. In case (ii), a constant shear rate lasting only for a brief time interval is imposed. The decay of the stress that is generated by this sudden small displacement is monitored. The stress would decrease monotonically with time. For small shear displacements the relaxation modulus is known to be independent of shear rate. D. Creep The aim of a creep experiment is to observe the changes in shear displacement as a function of time expressed in terms of creep
compliance, after a constant shear stress has been applied and maintained at that value on a sample trapped in a small gap between two parallel plates. The steady-state compliance /e is defined as -y/T21. If the driving shear stress T21 is small enough then the value of the compliance is independent of the driving shear stress. E. Constrained recoil The aim of a constrained recoil experiment is to observe the shear displacement in a fluid sample trapped in a small gap between two parallel plates when driving shear stress is suddenly removed after steady-state and then held at zero. The shear rate would then only be a function of time in the recoiling fluid. The ultimate recoil of the fluid at infinite time can be determined in this manner. 2.1.3 EXTENSIONALFLOW
Problems associated with fiber spinning, film blowing and foaming process have indicated that the shear flow material functions discussed earlier are not truly the crucial parameters. This realization led to the study of another type of flow, namely, the extensional flow. Extensional flow differs from both steady and unsteady simple shear flows in that it is a shear-free flow. In such a flow, the volume of a fluid element must remain constant. Extensional flow can be visualized as that occurring when a material is longitudinally stretched as, for example, in fiber spinning. In this case, the extension occurs in a single direction and hence the related flow is termed uniaxial extensional flow. Extension or stretching of polymer takes place in other processing operations as well, such as film blowing and flat-film extrusion. In such cases, the extension occurs in two directions simultaneously, and hence the flow is referred to as biaxial extensional flow in one case and planar extensional flow in the other. Extensional flows can orient polymer chains as well as fillers which are of the !-dimensional or 2-dimensional type and hence determine the performance and appearance of a product. A. Uniaxial extension Uniaxial extensional flow may be best visualized as a deformation caused by forces acting in a direction perpendicular to the opposite faces of a cylindrical body as shown in Figure 2.3. The velocity field in simple uniaxial extensional flow is given by V1 = SX1;
V2 = - \ £X2;
V3 = - \ £X3
(2.22)
(a) BEFORE EXIENSIOKAL DEFORMATION
(b) AFTER EXTENSIONAL DEFORMAUON
Figure 2.3 Schematic diagram of a fluid element in uniaxial extensional flow.
where e is the uniaxial extensional rate. For such a flow field, the rate of deformation tensor is given as _ B O U = O -s/2
O O
O
-s/2
O
in which
'-£
(2.23)
<2->
The uniaxial extensional rate may be constant or vary in the X1 direction of flow. When s is constant, i.e. when the axial velocity is proportional to X1, the resulting flow is steady uniaxial extensional flow. In such a flow situation, a cylindrical rod of length / is stretched along its axis according to the following equation: ft = el
(2.25)
Integrating this equation for a constant strain rate gives, / = /oexp(gt)
(2.26)
From equation (2.26), it is evident that extensional flow involves severe deformation since fluid parts are separated exponentially. The dimensions of the fluid elements change drastically in contrast with shear flows where particles in neighboring shearing surfaces separate linearly in time.
6. Biaxial extension In biaxial extensional flow, too, the dimensions of the fluid elements change drastically but they change in two directions as against the onedirection in uniaxial extensional flow. Thus, biaxial extensional flow can be visualized as a deformation caused by forces acting in two directions perpendicular to the opposite faces of a plate as shown in Figure 2.4. The velocity field in simple biaxial extensional flow is given by, V1 = E3X1;
V2 = 63*2;
^3 = -2eB*3
(2.27)
where £B is the biaxial extensional rate. For such a flow field, the rate of deformation tensor is given as,
(a) BEFORE EXTENSIONAL DEFORMATION
(b) AFTER EXTENSIONAL DEFORMATION
Figure 2.4 Schematic diagram of a fluid element in biaxial extensional flow.
C. Planar extension Planar extensional flow is the kind of flow where there is no deformation in one direction and the velocity field is represented as follows: V1 = SpX1-,
V2 = -SpX2;
V3=O
(2.29)
where sp is the planar extensional rate. In this case, the rate of deformation tensor is given as, 8P
5=
O
O
O -fip O 0 0 0
(2.30)
Extensive reviews [6-10] and a monograph [11] summarize the literature covering significant aspects of extensional flows in various commercial processes, theoretical treatment for the hydrodynamics of such flows and different methods of determining material functions such as uniaxial, biaxial and planar extensional viscosities. D. Material functions in extensional flow The material function of prime importance in extensional flow is the extensional viscosity which is basically a measure of the resistance of the material to flow when stress is applied to extend it. In extensional flow, the diagonal components of TZ; are non-zero (i.e. i{j = O for i ^j). In the case of uniaxial extension, T11 is the primary stress that can be measured, while T22 and T33 are generally equal to the pressure of the environment. Thus, the uniaxial extensional viscosity rjE is defined by, T11 - T22 = T11 - T33 = rjE(s)s
(2.31)
By the same token, the biaxial extensional viscosity t]EB can be defined as, ^33 - T11 = T33 - T22 = -*?EB(£B)£B
(2.32)
and further, the planar extensional viscosity rjEP can be written as, T11 - T22 = J?Ep(eP)£p
(2.33)
2.2 NON-NEWTONIAN FLOW BEHAVIOR The viscoelastic nature of polymers (filled or unfilled) and their peculiarities in the viscous as well as elastic response to deformation under applied stresses bring them under the category of nonNewtonian fluids. There is distinctive difference in flow behavior between Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids to an extent that, at times, certain aspects of non-Newtonian flow behavior may seem abnormal or even paradoxical [12-16]. An interesting movie about polymer fluid mechanics has been prepared [17] which clearly depicts certain peculiarities of such fluids. The dramatic differences between the qualitative responses of Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids grossly affect their industrial and practical applications. 2.2.1
NEWTONIAN FLUIDS
Isaac Newton was the first to propose the basic law of viscosity describing the flow behavior of an ideal liquid as, ? = i?0D
(2.34)
where the constant rj0 is termed the Newtonian viscosity. Fluids, whose flow behavior follows the above constitutive equation, are known as Newtonian fluids. Some of the common Newtonian fluids with which most people are familiar are water Oy0 ^ 1 mPa.sec), coffee cream (rjQ % lOmPa.sec), olive oil (rjQ ^ 102mPa.sec) and honey Of0 % 104 mPa.sec). For a Newtonian fluid, equation (2.34) yields the following stress components in simple shear flow: T n = T22 = T33 = -p
(2.35)
T = T12 = T21 = rj0y
(2.36)
All other stress components vanish. According to equation (2.35), it can be seen that the three normal stress components are equal. The nonvanishing shear stress T varies linearly with shear rate and has a proportionality constant f/ 0 which is the shear viscosity of the Newtonian fluid. In general, incompressible Newtonian fluids at constant temperature can be characterized by just two material constants: the shear viscosity rj0 and the density p. Once these quantities are measured, the velocity distribution and the stresses in the fluid can, in principle, be found for any flow situation. In other words, different isothermal experiments on a Newtonian fluid would yield a single constant material property, namely, its viscosity. On the other hand, a variety of flow experiments performed on a softened or molten filled polymer system, which is a
non-Newtonian fluid, would yield a host of material functions that depend on shear rate, frequency and time. When the viscosity is a function of shear rate, then the relationship between shear stress and shear rate is given by equation (2.9). Since its form is similar to equation (2.36) except for the shear rate dependent viscosity, the equation is said to represent a Generalized Newtonian fluid. In such a fluid, the presence of normal stresses defined by equations (2.10) and (2.11) is considered to be negligible for a specific flow situation. In effect, equation (2.5b) represents the constitutive equation for a Generalized Newtonian fluid. The hypothesis of a Generalized Newtonian fluid differs from the simple Newtonian case by the assumption that the functional relationship between the stress tensor and the kinematic variable need not be only linear. It holds, however, the suggestion that only the kinematic variable of the first order can influence the state of stress in the fluid and no attempt is to be made to describe the normal stresses in it. 2.2.2 NON-NEWTONIAN FLUIDS
Non-Newtonian fluids are Theologically complex fluids that exhibit one of the following features: (a) Shear rate dependent viscosities in certain shear rate ranges with or without the presence of an accompanying elastic solid-like behavior. (b) Yield stress with or without the presence of shear rate dependent viscosities. (c) Time-dependent viscosities at fixed shear rates. The definitions of various types of non-Newtonian fluids along with examples of common real systems falling into each category are given in Table 2.1. Detailed discussions relating to non-Newtonian fluids are available in a number of books [18-27] as well as other review articles [28-33]. From Table 2.1, it can be seen that filled polymer systems fall within the non-Newtonian category of pseudoplastic fluids, pseudoplastic fluids with a yield stress, thixotropic fluids and viscoelastic fluids.
For pseudoplastic fluids, the shear rate at any given point is solely dependent upon the instantaneous shear stress, and the duration of shear does not play any role so far as the viscosity is concerned. The shear stress vs. shear rate pattern for a pseudoplastic fluid with and without yield stress is shown in Figure 2.5. In the case of thixotropic fluids, the shear rate is a function of the magnitude and duration of shear as well as a function possibly of the time lapse between consecutive applications of shear stress. The shear
Table 2.1 Various types of non-Newtonian fluids Fluid type
Definition
Typical Examples
• Pseudoplastic
• These fluids depict a decrease in viscosity with increasing shear rate and hence are often referred to as shear-thinning fluids.
• Dilatant
• These fluids depict an increase in viscosity with increasing shear rate and hence are often referred to as shear-thickening fluids. • These fluids do not flow unless the stress applied exceeds a certain minimum value referred to as the yield stress and then show a linear shear stress vs. shear rate relationship.
• • • • • • • • • • •
• Bingham Plastics
• Pseudoplastic with a yield stress
• Thixotropic
• Rheopectic
• Viscoelastic
• These fluids have a nonlinear shear stress vs. shear rate relationship in addition to the presence of a yield stress. • These fluids exhibit a reversible decrease in shear stress with time at a constant rate of shear and fixed temperature. The shear stress, of course, approaches some limiting value. • These fluids exhibit a reversible increase in shear stress with time at a constant rate of shear and fixed temperature. At any given shear rate, the shear stress increases to approach an asymptotic maximum value. • These fluids possess the added feature of elasticity apart from viscosity. These fluids exhibit process properties which lie inbetween those of viscous liquids and elastic solids.
• • • • • • • • •
Filled polymer systems Polymer melts Polymer solutions Printing inks Pharmaceutical Preparations Blood Wet sand Starch suspensions Gum solutions Aqueous suspension of titanium dioxide Thickened hydrocarbon greases Certain asphalts and bitumen Water suspensions of clay/ fly ash/metallic oxides Sewage sludges Jellies Tomato ketchup Toothpaste Filled polymer systems Heavy crude oils with high wax content
Filled polymer systems Water suspensions of bentonite clays Drilling muds Crude oils Coal-water slurries Yoghurt Salad dressing Mayonnaise • Some clay suspensions
• Filled polymer systems • Polymer melts • Polymer solutions
FSEDDOPLASTIC FLlTD WnU YIELDSTlESS
PSEUDOPLASHC FLUID
NEWTONIAN FLUID
Figure 2.5 Variation of shear stress vs. shear rate for pseudoplastic fluids with and without yield stress.
stress pattern with time for such fluids is shown in Figure 2.6. If the shear stress is measured against shear rate which is steadily increasing from zero to a maximum value and then immediately decreasing steadily to zero, a hysteresis loop is obtained as shown in Figure 2.7. Viscoelastic fluids have a certain amount of energy stored in the fluids as strain energy thereby showing a partial elastic recovery upon the removal of a deforming stress. At every instant during the deformation process, a viscoelastic fluid tries unsuccessfully to recover completely from the deformed state but lags behind. This lag is a measure of the elasticity or so-called memory of the fluid. Due to the presence of elasticity, viscoelastic fluids show some markedly peculiar steady state and transient flow behavior patterns. Viscoelastic effects become important when there are sudden changes in the flow rate (e.g. during start-up and stopping operations of the polymer processing), in high shear rate flows (e.g. in processes like extrusion and injection molding) and in flows where changes in cross-section are encountered (e.g. entry into the mold cavity during injection molding). Some of the common encountered effects due to viscoelasticity are discussed below.
mxoiROPic FLHID
Figure 2.6 Variation of shear stress with time for a thixotropic fluid.
THIXOTROPIC JLUID HYSTERESIS LOOP
Figure 2.7 Variation of shear stress with shear rate (which is steadily increased from zero to maximum and brought down) for a thixotropic fluid.
Figure 2.8 Weissenberg effect showing how the viscoelastic fluid climbs up the stirrer-rod when stirred at moderate speeds. (Reprinted from Ref. 34 with kind permission from Chapman & Hall, Andover, UK.) 2.2.3 VISCOELASTIC EFFECTS A. Weissenberg effect When a viscoelastic fluid is stirred with a rod at moderate speeds, the fluid begins to climb up the rod instead of forming a vortex as shown pictorially in Figure 2.8. The first normal stress difference is much larger than the shear stress and hence gives rise to this startling effect. This type of phenomenon is commonly termed the Weissenberg effect, as Weissenberg was the first to explain such an effect in terms of the stresses in fluids undergoing a steady shear flow [34-36]. In actuality, this effect was observed earlier by Garner and Nissan [37]. B. Extrudate swell When a viscoelastic fluid flows through an orifice or a capillary, the diameter of the fluid at the die exit is considerably higher than the diameter of the orifice. This happens because, at the die exit, the viscoelastic fluid partially recovers the deformation it underwent when it was squeezed through the capillary. This type of phenomenon is known variously as extrudate swell, die swell, jet swell, Barus effect or Merrington effect. Metzner [38] discusses the history of extrudate swell
Figure 2.9 Extrudate swell effect showing how the viscoelastic fluid swells in diameter when it exits from a die or orifice. (Reprinted from Ref. 34 with kind permission from Chapman & Hall, Andover, UK.) and argues against using the last two names. A review on extrudate swell has been given by Bagley and Schrieber [39]. Extrudate diameter (DE) of up to three or four times the orifice diameter (D0) is possible with some polymers. The swell ratio Sw (i.e. D E /D 0 ) decreases with the increase of tube length because of the fading memory of the viscoelastic fluid to deformation. This implies that if longer and longer tubes are used, Sw should ultimately approach unity. But it is known [40] that the limiting value of the swell ratio is greater than unity even as the length to diameter ratio of the orifice approaches infinity. The phenomenon of die swell is shown pictorially in Figure 2.9. Theoretical analyses of this phenomenon, for flow in round capillaries, are available [41-45] in which the most basic [44] of them is built upon the free recovery calculations set down by Lodge [13] using the theory of Berstein, Kearsley and Zapas [46]. The developed expression for die swell Sw in which the elastic strain recovery SR is balanced by the shear stresses arising in the die, is given by, Sw = (l + iS2R)1/6 + 0.1 where,
(2.37)
SR=^
(2.38)
The above analysis does not include the rearrangement of the stress and velocity fields at the die exit, and consequently, it was found necessary [44] to empirically modify the die swell expression by including a factor of 0.1 in the above expression. The 0.1 term has been added to improve the fit with data for small values of (T11 — T22)w/T2i,w and the ratio (TU - T22)/^ has been taken to be constant. Later work [47] has shown that die swell depends not only on the recoverable shear strain, but also on the ratio of the second to first normal stress difference coefficients ^2/1Ai as well. The influence of this phenomenon in the filled polymer industry can hardly be overlooked. The industrial problems involving extrudate swell are particularly complex and challenging because the diameter increase depends not only on the particular type of polymer but also on the type and amount of filler as well as on the operating conditions such as temperature and flow rate. C. Draw resonance Draw resonance or surging is defined as the non-uniformity in the diameter of the extrudate when a polymer is stretched at different take-up speeds as it comes out of an orifice. This phenomenon is shown schematically in Figure 2.10. When take-up speed is small or when there is no stretching, only die swell is observed as can be seen from Figure 2.10(a). When take-up speed is higher and the stretched extrudate is solidified by quenching, then the contour appears as shown in Figure 2.10(b). Now draw ratio is defined as the ratio of the linear velocity v of the extrudate settled in the quenching bath to the smallest linear velocity VQ at the die swell region. When the draw ratio DR goes beyond a critical value DRC, then the resulting phenomenon is draw resonance as shown in Figure 2.10(c). The theory of draw resonance has been developed and a method for calculating the critical draw ratio is also available [48]. Once draw resonance occurs its severity enhances with increasing take-up speed. D. Melt fracture When softened or molten polymer flows out of a capillary, a striking phenomenon of the distortion of the emerging stream is observed at shear stresses beyond a critical higher value and this is termed melt fracture [49,5O]. The extrudate distortion is a result of polymer molecules reaching their elastic limit of storing energy, thus causing
Figure 2.10 Draw resonance effect occurring when polymer melt is extruded from an orifice at various take-up speeds, (a) Extrudate without stretching, (b) extrudate with stretching DR DRC showing draw resonance.
melt fracture as a means of stress relief either at the capillary wall or at the capillary entrance. Another view [51] is that the extrudate distortion is due to differential flow-induced molecular orientation between the extrudate skin holding highly oriented molecules and the core wherein there is no significant molecular orientation. It is, of course, possible [52] that the melt fracture occurs due to a combination of the stress relief theory and the differential flow-induced molecular orientation. A number of other mechanisms [53-65] have been suggested for melt fracture. Based on a stick-slip mechanism, it is purported [53] that, above a critical shear stress, the polymer experiences intermittent slipping due to a lack of adhesion between itself and die wall, in order to relieve the excessive deformation energy adsorbed during the flow. The stick-slip mechanism has attracted a lot of attention [53-63], both theoretically and experimentally. The other school of thought [64,65] is based on thermodynamic argument, according to which, melt fracture can initiate anywhere in the flow field when reduction in the fluid entropy due to molecular orientation reaches a critical value beyond which the second law of thermodynamics is violated and flow instability is induced [64]. It is important to distinguish between melt fracture, which is a gross distortion or waviness, and a fine scale high frequency surface
Figure 2.11 Difference between the phenomenon of matte and melt fracture (on distorted extrudates of different polymers): (1) rigid polyvinyl chloride, (2) polyethylene, (3) polypropylene, (4 & 5) polypropylene viewed from two angles, (6) polymethymethacrylate, (7) polytetrafluoroethylene. (Reprinted from Ref. 66 with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers, Inc., Connecticut, USA.)
roughness [4O]. The latter may commence at output rates below those at which melt fracture is observed and is termed matte or mattness. The extreme case of mattness is referred to as shark skin. The distinction between shark skin and melt fracture has been convincingly demonstrated [66] as shown pictorially in Figure 2.11.
E.
Capillary entry flow patterns
A characteristic flow pattern at the capillary entrance develops when a polymer flows at high shear rates from a cylindrical reservoir through a capillary or die as shown in Figure 2.12. The qualitative difference between the capillary entry flows of linear and branched polyethylenes has been convincingly presented by Tordella [50] and discussed by others [67-7O]. For linear polymers, the converging flow at the die entry fills the available space, while for branched polymers there is a large
Figure 2.12 Capillary entry flow pattern for a branched polymer showing the flow cone and the recirculating vortex.
dead space filled by recirculating vortices. Vortices are induced by the viscoelastic characteristics of the converging fluid [71,72]. Polymers exhibiting larger extensional viscosities have been observed [71] to exhibit larger vortices and vice versa. The vortex or the circulating stagnant region encompasses a flow cone which becomes unstable with increasing flow rate and eventually fractures periodically as the flow rate is increased further. When the flow cone fractures, the result is melt fracture and the flow is sustained by the intermittent drawing of the fluid from the recirculating vortices.
F. Abnormal fringe patterns in calendering During the process of calendering, very stable abnormal fringe patterns may appear on the roll surface at regular intervals. Though the exact mechanism for abnormal fringe patterns in calendering is as yet unclear, it is certainly related to the viscoelasticity of the material. Depending on the frequency of roll rotation and clearance of roll nip, its intensity would increase or decrease on account of the effect of such changes on the viscoelastic response of the calendered material.
PRESSURE TRANSDUCER
NEWTONIAN FLUID
VISCOELASTEC FLDTO
Figure 2.13 Pressure hole error occurs in a viscoelastic fluid while it is absent in a Newtonian fluid. (Reprinted from Ref. 23 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.) G. Pressure hole error For Newtonian fluids, the pressure measured at the bottom of the pressure hole pM is the same as the true pressure p at the wall. For a viscoelastic fluid, on the other hand, the pressure (p + T22)M measured at the bottom of the pressure hole is always lower than the true pressure (p + T22) at the wall, no matter how small the hole is. This pressure difference arises because the elastic forces tend to pull the fluid away from the hole and results in the pressure hole error pH = (p + T22)M -(p + T22). This effect is illustrated in Figure 2.13. The possible sources of error in the measurement have been considered by Higashitani and Lodge [73] along with a review of published data. The effect of pH has been well substantiated for polymer solutions but the same is not the case for polymer melts with or without fillers. H. Parallel plate separation When a viscoelastic fluid is trapped between two parallel plates with one of the plates rotating, then there is a non-zero pressure p due to
NEWTONIAN FLUID
VISCOELASTIC FLUID
Figure 2.14 Parallel plate separation occurs in a viscoelastic fluid while it is absent in a Newtonian fluid. (Reprinted from Ref. 33 with kind permission from Gulf Publishing Co., Houston, Texas, USA.)
elasticity which tends to separate the two plates. This effect is illustrated in Figure 2.14. I. Tubeless siphon During the siphoning process, when the siphon tube is lifted out of the fluid, a Newtonian fluid will stop flowing whereas a viscoelastic fluid will continue unabated. At times, even 75% of the viscoelastic fluid in the container may get siphoned out in this manner. This effect is illustrated in Figure 2.15.
NEWTONIAN FLUID
VISCOELASIIC FLUID
Figure 2.15 Tubeless siphoning can be done for a viscoelastic fluid but not for a Newtonian fluid. (Reprinted from Ref. 23 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.)
This viscoelastic effect indicates the stability of a stretching filament of fluid with respect to small perturbations in its cross-sectional area. It has definite implications in the fiber spinnability of polymers. J. Uebler effect It has been observed [74,75] that when a polymeric fluid flows in a tube with a sudden contraction, large bubbles of the order of 1/6 to 1/8 of the small tube diameter, come to a sudden stop right at the entrance of the contraction along the centerline before finally passing through after a hold-time of about one minute. This particular behavior has been termed the Uebler effect [74,75]. This phenomenon has implications in the production of foamed plastics wherein a gas, normally nitrogen, is added to polymers such as PE, PP and PS during two-phase processing. 2.3 RHEOLOGICAL MODELS There have been a number of rheological models proposed for representing the flow behavior of softened or molten polymer and these are readily available in a number of books [18-27] and review articles [10,28,29,31,32,76]. The constitutive equations, which relate shear stress or apparent viscosity with shear rate, involve the use of two to five parameters. Many of these constitutive equations are quite cumbersome to use in engineering analyses and hence only a few models are often popular. Only such models are described and discussed in this section. 2.3.1 MODELS FOR THE STEADY SHEAR VISCOSITY FUNCTION
From the typical viscosity vs. shear rate curve for unfilled polymer shown in Figure 1.2, it can be seen that in the low shear rate range, the material is essentially Newtonian in flow behavior with a constant apparent viscosity, which at zero shear rate, is termed the zero-shear viscosity rj0. In the medium shear rate range, the apparent viscosity r\ begins to decrease, depicting the shear-thinning characteristic until it stabilizes to a constant value ^00 at a considerably high shear rate in the upper Newtonian region. It is quite obvious from this figure, that a constitutive equation with about three to four parameters would be necessary to describe the rheological behavior of an unfilled polymer over the entire shear rate range. However, when dealing with processing problems, only certain shear rate ranges attain significance and hence only portions of the flow curve need to be described by the constitutive equations thereby requiring less parameters. As a matter of fact, the very high shear rate range is invariably never reached and Next Page
Rheometry
O
Rheometry is the measuring arm of rheology and its basic function is to quantify the rheological material parameters of practical importance. A rheometer is an instrument for measuring the rheological properties and can do one of the following two things: 1. It can apply a deformation mode to the material and measure the subsequent force generated, or 2. It can apply a force mode to a material and measure the subsequent deformation. The best designs of rheometers use geometries so that the forces/ deformation can be reduced by subsequent calculation to stresses and strains, and so produce material parameters. It is very important that the principle of material independence is observed when parameters are measured on the rheometers. The flow within the rheometers should be such that the kinematic variables and the constitutive equations describing the flow must be unaffected by any rigid rotation of both body and coordinate system - in other words, the response of the material must not be dependent upon the position of the observer. When designing rheometers, care is taken to see that the rate of deformation satisfies this principle for simple shear flow or viscometric flow. The flow analyzed can be considered as viscometric (simple shear) flow if sets of plane surfaces (known as shear planes) are seen to exist and each is moving past the other as a solid plane, i.e. the distance between every two material points in the plane remains constant. The importance of viscometric flows becomes apparent when one appreciates that the equation of motion for most viscometric flows can be solved analytically. This is the reason why viscometric flows have been used for evaluating the viscosity function from viscometric data and this fact has brought about the alternative name for simple shear
flows. All flows that do not conform to the viscometric behavior as described above are termed non-viscometric flows. All rheometers have viscometric flows or at least 'near-viscometric' flows in them and hence are amenable to produce reliable material functions. Rheometers used for determining the material functions of filled polymer systems can be divided into two broad categories - (a) rotational type and (b) capillary type. Further subdivisions are possible and these are shown in Table 3.1. In what follows only those rheometers which are popularly used for rheological characterization of filled polymer systems are described and discussed in detail. For example, though the bob and cup rotational viscometer has been used [1] in the fifties for polyethylene melts, it has not been included in further detail. This is because this geometry is not at all popular even for unfilled thermoplastic melt studies, though Cogswell [2] did suggest it in the seventies for measuring shear viscosities under conditions of controlled pressure. Similarly, other rheometers which were developed for rheological measurements of filled systems, particularly suspensions such as cement [3], red mud [4] or other slurries [5,6], sealants [7], paints, foodstuffs or greases [8], dental composites [9-11], propellants [12], etc. are also not described here, as they are considered to be beyond the scope of this book. For a general discussion on rheometry, as applicable to various types of fluids, it is advisable to refer to some of the excellent monographs on this subject [13-18]. 3.1 ROTATIONAL VISCOMETERS For filled polymer studies, rotational viscometers with either the coneplate or parallel-disc configuration are used. The major advantages of cone and plate viscometers are: (i) a constant shear rate is maintained throughout the melt sample, (ii) a small quantity of sample is required for measurement. On the other hand, the chief advantage of the parallel disc configuration is that it can be used for filled polymer systems of extremely high viscosity and elasticity. The basic limitation in rotational viscometers is that they are restricted in their use only to low shear rates for unidirectional shear and low frequency oscillations during oscillatory shear. At higher shear rates as well as at higher frequencies, a flow instability normally sets in the polymer sample which then begins to emerge out of the gap between the cone and plate or parallel-disc [19,20], thereby giving erroneous results. As a consequence of the above, the measured material functions do not actually conform to the
Table 3.1 Rheometers for filled polymer systems Capillary
Rotational
Unidirectional shear
Oscillatory shear
Constant speed
Plunger type Cone-n-plate
Screw extrusion type
Circular orifice
Circular orifice
* Commercial instrument.
Plunger type
Parallel disc Circular orifice
(a) Rheometrics mechanical spectrometer* (b) Sangamo Weissenberg rheogoniometer*
Constant pressure
(a) Monsanto automatic rheometer* (b) lnstron capillary rheometer*
Slit orifice
Slit orifice
Han's slit rheometer
(a) Haake rheocord* (b) Brabender plasticorder*
Melt flow indexer (a) Kayeness* (b) Ceast* (c) Davenport*
higher deformation rates which are normally prevalent in processing operations. Commercially available rotational instruments, such as the Mechanical Spectrometer (Rheometrics Inc., Piscataway, NJ, USA) and Weissenberg Rheogoniometer (Carri-Med Ltd, Dorking, England) can be used for unidirectional rotational shear as well as oscillatory shear and come with interchangeable cone and plate/parallel-disc configurations. 3.1.1
CONE AND PLATE VISCOMETER
The cone and plate viscometer is a widely used instrument for shear flow rheological properties of polymer systems [21-32]. The principal features of this viscometer are shown schematically in Figure 3.1. The sample whose rheological properties are to be measured is trapped between the circular conical disc at the bottom and the circular horizontal plate at the top. The cone is connected to the drive motor which rotates the disc at various constant speeds while the plate is AXIAL IHKUST MEASDHWGDEVICE
TORQUE MEASDWNG DEVICE
STATIONARY FLAT DISK
POLYMER MELT
RQTA3TNG CONICAL DISK
Figure 3.1 Schematic diagram showing the principal features of a cone and plate rotational viscometer.
connected to the torque-measuring device in order to evaluate the resistance of the sample to the motion. The cone is truncated at the top. The gap between the cone and plate is adjusted in such a way as to represent the distance that would have been available if the untruncated cone had just touched the plate. The angle of the cone surface is normally very small (O0 < 4° or 0.0696 radius) so as to maintain [14] cosec2 O0 = 1. The cone angles are chosen such that for any point on the cone surface, the ratio of angular speed and distance to the plate is constant. This ensures that the shear rate is constant from the cone tip to the outer radius of the conical disc. Similarly, the shear rate can be assumed to be constant for any point within the gap because of the predesigned method of gap adjustment as described earlier. The flow curve for a sample held between the cone and plate is generated from measurements of the torque experienced by the plate when the cone is rotated unidirectionally at different speeds. The various parameters of relevance are determined as follows. A. Shear rate For a constant speed of rotation of N rpm, the linear velocity (v = cor) is 27rrN/60m/sec where co is the angular velocity (rad/sec) and r is the radial position in meters. The gap height at r is rtan90 where 90 is the cone angle. Hence shear rate in reciprocal seconds at r can be written as, _ __ __ . _ 2nrN _ nN ^ nN y ~ 60rtan0 0 ~ 30tan00 ^ 306^ ' Since the cone angle is always maintained to be very small, the approximation of tan O0 = O0 does hold good. B. Shear stress The following expression defines the relationship measured torque and the shear stress:
between
the
f* -* T = 2TiT21 / r2 dr = f nRi2l
(3.2)
Tf T 2 I=-Z 5
(3-3)
Jo
Thus,
2nR The shear stress is then obtained in pascals when T is expressed in newtons.m and R in meters. The ratio of equation (3.3) to equation (3.1) results in the apparent viscosity expressed in Pa.sec.
C. Normal stress difference The cone and plate configuration can be used for estimating the primary normal stress difference of the sample. If p is the pressure at a point on the plate in excess of that due to the atmospheric pressure, then it can be shown [14] that the total normal force NF on the plate is given by, Np = f 2nrpdr
(3.4)
JO
which on integration gives
nR2 NF=-J-Ni
(3,5)
Thus
N,=^ (3.6) nR Using equations (3.1) and (3.6), a plot of primary normal stress vs. shear rate can be generated. The shear stress and primary normal stress measurements can be done simultaneously on the sample when it is subjected to unidirectional rotational shear in the gap of a cone and plate viscometer. D. Oscillatory shear The cone and plate viscometer can be used for oscillatory shear measurements as well. In this case, the sample is deformed by an oscillatory driver which may be mechanical or electromagnetic. The amplitude of the sinusoidal deformation is measured by a strain transducer. The force deforming the sample is measured by the small deformation of a relatively rigid spring or tension bar to which is attached a stress transducer. On account of the energy dissipated by the viscoelastic polymer system, a phase difference develops between the stress and the strain. The complex viscosity behavior is determined from the amplitudes of stress and strain and the phase angle between them. The results are usually interpreted in terms of the material functions, */', G', G" and others [33-4O]. 3.1.2
PARALLEL-DISC VISCOMETER
The parallel-disc viscometer used for measuring the shear stress and normal stress difference of filled polymer systems is similar in principle
to the cone and plate viscometer except that the lower cone is replaced by a smooth circular disc. This type of viscometer was initially developed for measuring the rheological properties of rubber [41-45] and hence made use of serrated discs placed in a pressurized cavity to prevent rubber slippage. When it was adapted for other polymeric systems [27,46,47], measurements were performed using smooth discs and without pressure. The rheological properties in the parallel-disc viscometer are based on the shear rate at the outer radius of the disc. Thus, ya = coR/H
(3.7)
where co is the angular velocity (rad/sec), R is the radius of the disc (m) and H is the gap between the two parallel discs (m). Shear stress and normal stress differences are given by the following relationships: ,R=jr/1+^I) 2nR\ 3dln yJ
(3.8)
(,,-„) -(*- *>=SH^g)
M
Oscillatory shear measurements can be done with the parallel-disc arrangement in a similar manner as in the case of the cone and plate viscometer and similarly the material functions, r\ ,G, G" and others can be generated. However, a slightly different technique [48] is at times used wherein the polymer sample is deformed between two oscillating parallel eccentric discs as shown in Figure 3.2. In this case, too, it has been shown that the fluid elements undergo a periodic sinusoidal deformation and the forces exerted on the disc are thus interpreted in terms of G and G" [14]. 3.2
CAPILLARY RHEOMETERS
Capillary rheometers of various types are used for determining the rheological properties of polymer melts as can be seen from Table 3.1. The principal feature is that these rheometers are capable of extruding polymer samples at different speeds through the capillary of appropriate size. They are broadly categorized as (i) those operating at constant speed and (ii) those operating at constant pressure. A further categorization is possible based on the melt transport mechanism being of the plunger or the screw type and on the orifice
AXIALIHRUST MEASDMNGDEVICE
TORQUE MEASURING DEVICE
STAUQNARY FLATDISK
POLYMER MELT ROTAUNG FLATDISK
Figure 3.2 Schematic diagram showing the principal features of a parallel eccentric discs rotational viscometer.
shape, through which the melt is extruded, being of the circular or slit type. Each type of capillary rheometer is discussed in detail in the following subsections.
3.2.1
CONSTANT PLUNGER SPEED CIRCULAR ORIFICE CAPILLARY RHEOMETER
Commercially available instruments such as the Monsanto Automatic Rheometer and the Instron Capillary Rheometer are examples of equipment which extrude the polymer through a capillary with a circular orifice using a plunger at constant speeds. The principal features of this rheometer are shown schematically in Figure 3.3. The major advantage of this type of capillary rheometer is that higher shear rate levels than those attainable in rotational viscometers can be achieved. In fact, the achievable shear rates are within the realistic ranges that are actually observed in processing operations, thus making the rheological data more meaningful for simulating processing behavior. Of course, the highest attainable shear rate data
V-CONSTANT PLUNGER.
BESERVOIR
CAPILLARY DEB
POLYMERMELT
Figure 3.3 Schematic diagram of a constant plunger speed circular orifice capillary rheometer.
are limited due to the occurrence of flow instabilities resulting in extrudate distortion or melt fracture at die wall shear stress levels greater than 1O5Pa [49-53]. The die wall shear stress TW can be easily calculated by taking a force balance across the capillary die as, 7^APdie = 27TRN/NTW
(3.10)
TW = ^^
(3.11)
or ^N
where RN and /N are the radius and length of the capillary die, while APdie is the pressure drop required to extrude the polymer melt. Since the polymer flows from a wide reservoir into a capillary die in a converging stream and then exits into open air or another wide reservoir in a divergent stream, it is necessary to correct the shear stress value for these entrance and end effects. The use of long capillaries in the vain hope that the end effects might be negligible is not recommended and in fact, should be discouraged. In capillaries longer
than D0, pressure dependence effects become significant. Hence, end effects can never be assumed to be negligible. The customary method of incorporating end effects correction is through the use of an effective capillary length (/N + £RN) as suggested by Bagley [54]. It must be emphasized here that basically there is no alternative but to carry out the Bagley procedure to make end corrections. The wall shear stress for fully developed flow over the length (/N + £#N) is then written as, w
_
^NAPdie
~~ A'N in + _i_rj? C^N)^t
^
>
The shear rate at the die wall is expressed by the RabinowitschWeissenberg [55] equation for steady laminar flow of a timeindependent fluid as, w
,4QT3 " ^3N [4
ldln(4Q/^N)1 4 dlnr w J
(6 L6)
'
The term d In (^Q/nR^)/d In TW is basically equal to l/n where n is the power-law index depicting the non-Newtonian character of the polymer system. Thus, from equations (3.12) and (3.13), the following relationship is written RNAPdie
=
/4Q\
2(/^Ki^ H^J
(3 14a)
'
or, 'N
=
r .
c
&Pdie
^ ~ 57M /cn
/oi/iu\
(
}
Uy
The above equation is a straight line when a plot of / N /K N vs. APdie is constructed at different constant values of (4Q/nR^) as shown in Figure 3.4(a). This is done using dies of various / N /# N ratios and the intercept on the / N /^N ordinate at APdie = O determines the value of —(. There are possibilities of observing slight non-linearity in the plots as can be seen for data at 3.6 and 10.8 s'1 in Figure 3.4(a). These are probably due to the breakdown of the assumptions made during the derivation of equation (3.14) of time-independence and no wall slip. True mechanical wall slip can occur during polymer flow when the shear stresses are large enough to overcome the static friction between the wall and the flowing material [56-62]. Mechanical slip can occur as either a steady-state phenomenon or as an unsteady phenomenon known as 'stick-slip' [62-64]. This wall slip may induce the slight nonlinearity in the plots shown in Figure 3.4(a). It must be shown that the Bagley plot is linear before any capillary viscometry data are regarded
PRESSUREDROP (1O6PASCAIS)
INTERCEPT
Figure 3.4(a) Plot for determination of the Bagley correction term during polymer melt flow through a capillary rheometer.
as meaningful. Hence, only those plots which are basically linear in Figure 3.4(a) are to be used. Once the plots have been shown to be linear for a particular capillary length and class of material, it is only then the capillary can be selected for viscometric measurements. From a linear regression of these plots, the correction term is determined. Using equation (3.12), the corrected shear stress value at the wall is estimated. It should be noted that, since polymers are viscoelastic, the entrance effect needs an elastic-energy correction too. This is because when the melt converges into the capillary, elastic stresses develop and begin to relax inside the capillary. This effect is taken into account [65] by modifying equation (3.12) to include the recoverable shear term as follows: ^
APdie
,gjgx
2(/ N /R N + C + SR/2)
^1DJ
Thus, the elastic energy stored at the capillary entrance is related to the correction term by the following expression [65]. ec = C + y
(3.16a)
Assuming Hooke's law in shear, TW = G x SR where G is the apparent melt shear modulus, the correction term is rewritten as
GLASS BEAD FILLED POLYPROPYLENE
UNITS
Figure 3.4(b) Variation of capillary correction term with true wall shear stress for glass bead filled polypropylene. (Reprinted from Ref. 66 with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers Inc., Connecticut, USA.)
ec = C + ^
(3.16b)
This suggests that when ec is plotted against TW, a straight line should emerge with a slope of ^G. When such a plot is prepared in the case of filled polymer systems, an interesting behavior is observed [66] as can be seen from Figure 3.4(b). The corrections for various concentrations of glass beads in polypropylene have been plotted. It can be seen that the correction term decreases with increasing filler volume concentration at constant shear, with the exception of the filled polypropylene system containing 26 vol.% of glass beads. The decreasing trend of the correction term with increasing glass beads is consistent with studies such as the one using glass bead filled styrene acrylonitrile (SAN) systems [67]. The decreasing trend indicates that the amount of stored energy must be decreasing and hence the recovered energy or die swell would also decrease with increasing glass bead volume fraction. This was indeed found to be the case [66] when a few measurements of die swell were qualitatively compared. The slope ec vs. TW lines are seen to be constant, except for > = 0.21 and hence can be assumed to be independent of glass bead
concentration [66]. In the case of glass bead filled SAN systems, however, the ec vs. TW lines are highly non-linear [67]. The capillary rheometer can be used for estimating the normal stress difference using the total ends pressure loss [65,68] and the exit pressure loss [69-71], wherein the latter has a more rigorous theoretical basis. However, the assumption of fully developed flow existing up to the tube exit may not hold true, especially in slow flows [72] and the errors introduced by the velocity field distortions at the exit may prove significant. 3.2.2 CONSTANT PLUNGER SPEED SLIT ORIFICE CAPILLARY RHEOMETER
This rheometer is similar in all respects to that discussed in section 3.2.1 except for the fact that it has a slit orifice cross-section rather than a circular one. The major credit for the development of the concept and use of this rheometer goes to Han [69,71,72] though others [73] have also used it for polymer melt studies. The instrument makes use of a series of flush mounted transducers located along the flow channel wall which measure the pressure gradients along the flow direction. These are then converted into wall shear stress values [69] as follows: TW =fro^ (3.17) dX where b0 = half thickness of the channel. The wall shear rate is determined from the following expression given in Refs 14 and 69:
y 7w
3Q T2 lln(3Q/4^)1 ~4fl 0 *d3 + 3
lnr w
J
(3 18)
'
where U0 is the half width of the channel. In general, this instrument is capable of providing data in the higher shear rate ranges comparable to those obtainable from the circular orifice capillary rheometer described in section 3.2.1. Using exit pressure losses, this instrument can also be used for determination of normal stresses. However, the probable velocity-profile distortions at the exit may introduce errors that may not be negligible though experimental evidence based on limited data [26,71] suggests otherwise. 3.2.3 CONSTANT SPEED SCREW EXTRUSION TYPE CAPILLARY RHEOMETERS
These capillary rheometers are principally the same as those described in sections 3.2.1 and 3.2.2 except for the melt transport system which is
HOPPER
POLYMEEt POWDER OIL PELLETS
POLYMERMELT
MELT TEMPERATDRS THERMOCOUPLE
PRESSURE TRANSDUCER EXTJLUSlDN SCREW
CAPULARy BODY
CAPILLARY DIE
POLYMER MELT
Figure 3.5 Schematic diagram showing the principal features of a constant speed screw extrusion type capillary rheometer.
of the screw extrusion type rather than the plunger type discussed earlier. A schematic diagram of an extrusion capillary rheometer is shown in Figure 3.5. Commercially available extrusion capillary rheometers are the Haake Rheocord (Haake Buchler Instruments Inc., Saddle Brook, NJ, USA) and the Brabendar Plasticorder (Brabendar, Duisburg, Germany). The rheological property measurements can be done using a circular or slit orifice as these are separate attachments for the miniaturized single screw extruder. These types of capillary rheometer are capable of generating rheological data from medium-to-high shear rates. The applicable equations for shear stress and shear rate are the same as those discussed in sections 3.2.1 and 3.2.2. The data generated are automatically corrected for the Bagley correction and the RabinowitschWeissenberg correction through a computer software program [74]. The screw extrusion type capillary rheometers have been used for rheological studies of polymers [75,76] but have not become as popular as the plunger type capillary rheometers because they need a much larger quantity of feed. Care has to be taken that the material completely fills the extruder screw during transportation in order to avoid cavitation and erroneous results. Nevertheless, the utility of these types of instrument cannot be undermined. The single screw extrusion capillary rheometer is only one of the functions performed by the commercially available Haake Rheocord and Brabendar Plasticorder. They come with a number of other accessories such as the miniaturized internal mixer and miniaturized twin screw extruder as well. In fact, the miniaturized internal mixer too has at times been used for assessing the rheological properties of polymer systems. The
torque vs. rpm data generated by internal mixer can be easily converted [77-79] to shear stress vs. shear rate data. A more detailed understanding of torque rheometry and instrumentation can be obtained from the excellent article by Chung [74]. 3.2.4 CONSTANT PRESSURE CIRCULAR ORIFICE CAPILLARY RHEOMETER (MELT FLOW INDEXER)
This rheometer is also similar to the one described in section 3.2.1 except for two differences. Firstly, the capillary used is of very short length and secondly, the polymer is extruded by the use of dead weights (i.e. constant pressure) rather than constant plunger speed. This instrument, popularly known as the Melt Flow Indexer, is very popular in the thermoplastics industry due to its ease of operation and low cost, which more than compensates for its lack of sophistication. The parameter measured through the melt flow indexer contains mixed information of the elastic and viscous effects of the polymer. Further, no end loss corrections have been developed for this capillary equipment nor can the melt flow index be easily related to the Weissenberg-Rabinowitsch shear rate expression. In most monographs and texts on polymer rheology, the Melt Flow Indexer has been treated in a very brief manner because it has generally been considered as an instrument meant only for quality control. It was specified as a standard rheological quality control test in the ASTM, BS, DIN, ISO and JIS (see Appendix D, Abbreviations list for complete forms of these standards). However, it has been shown in the recent past [80] that the Melt Flow Indexer provides more than just a quality control rheological parameter. In fact the book on Thermoplastic Melt Rheology and Processing [81] shows the multiple uses of the data from the Melt Flow Indexer, and treats this particular instrument in the utmost detail. Hence, in the present book the Melt Flow Indexer and the Melt Flow Index are discussed rather briefly; and readers are encouraged to refer to the other book [81] for more comprehensive discussion on the subject. The basic principle employed in the MFI test by any of the standards is that of determining the rate of flow of molten polymer through a closely defined extrusion plastometer whose important parts are shown in Figure 3.6. The cylinder is of hardened steel and is fitted with heaters, lagged, and controlled for operation at the required temperature with an accuracy of ±0.5°C. The piston is made of steel and the diameter of its head is 0.075 ± 0.015 mm less than that of the internal diameter of the cylinder, which is 9.5mm. The die (or 'jet') has an internal diameter of 2.095 ± 0.005 mm or 1.180 ±0.005 mm (depending on the procedure used) and is made of hardened steel. All
LOAD
PISTON BARBEL
HEATER A 3NSUIATEQN
REMOVABLE DIE
POLYMER Figure 3.6 Schematic diagram of the melt flow index apparatus showing a crosssectional view of the important parts.
surfaces of the apparatus which come into contact with the molten polymer are highly polished. MFI is basically defined as the weight of the polymer (g) extruded in lOmin through a capillary of specific diameter and length by pressure applied through dead weight under prescribed temperature conditions. ASTM D1238 specifies the details of the test conditions as summarized in Appendix B for commonly used polymers. The test conditions include temperatures between 125 and 30O0C and different applied dead loads from 0.325 to 21.6kg giving pressures from 0.46 to 30.4kgf/cm2. The specifications have been selected in such a way as to
give MFI values between 0.15 and 25 for reliable results. ASTM D1238 gives the accuracy of the MFI value obtainable from a single measurement as carried out by different operators at different locations to be in the range of ±9 to ±15% depending upon the magnitude of the MFI. 3.3 EXTENSIONAL VISCOMETERS The rotational viscometers and the capillary rheometers described in sections 3.1 and 3.2 are those applicable for shear flows. However, there are processing operations that involve extensional flows. These flows have to be treated differently for making measurements of extensional viscosity. The extensional viscosity of a material is a measure of its resistance to flow when stress is applied to extend it. In general, measurement of steady-state extensional viscosity has proven to be extremely difficult. Steady extensional rate would be achieved by pulling the ends of the sample apart such that / = I0 exp(ef) or in other words, at a rate that increases exponentially with time. Steady-state is reached when the force is constant. However, often the sample breaks before steady-state is achieved or the limits of the equipment are exceeded or at the other extreme, the forces become too small for the transducer to differentiate between noise and response signal. Nevertheless, there have been various methods attempted for the measurement of extensional viscosity. 3.3.1 HLAMENT STRETCHING METHOD
The most common method for measurement of extensional viscosity is to stretch the filament of material shown in Figure 3.7 vertically as done by Ballman [82] or horizontally as done by Meissner [83]. The polymer must have a high enough melt viscosity of 104 Pa.sec or greater in order to be amenable for such extensional experiments. Hence such data are restricted to high viscosity polyolefins such as polyethylene and polypropylene rather than low viscosity nylon and polyester. Further, the deformation rates are to be maintained at low values to prevent breakage of filament and hence the deformation rates are limited to 5 sec"1 or less. In the method of Ballman [82], which has been used by others [84,85], a vertical thermostated filament is clamped at both ends and stretched at the rate dl/dt such as to maintain a constant deformation rate. Thus,
,-i*
(a) VERTICAL FILAMENT STKBTCHING
CB) HORIZONTAL FILAMENT STKCTCHINO
Figure 3.7 Schematic diagram showing the principal features of the filament stretching method for extensional viscosity measurements: (a) vertical filament stretching; (b) horizontal filament stretching.
In the method of Meissner [83], a horizontal filament immersed in thermostated immiscible oil is held at both ends between pairs of toothed wheels rotating with a linear velocity of V/2. Thus, deformation rate is written as,
i= V/2=
V
ik J
(3 20)
-
There are other variations of the filament stretching technique. For example, filaments are clamped at one end and taken up on a rotating roll [86,87]. This reduces the amount of filament stretching to a more uniform level and produces a more constant extensional rate. In fact, when the following filament is taken up on a cold roll [87] a better constancy in the extensional rate is obtained. Extensional viscosity based on constant stress measurements [88] has also been reported [89,9O]. In one case [89], the filament is extended vertically on top of a bath whereas in the other case [90], the vertical sample is immersed in the bath. The commercial equipment available for the measurement of extensional viscosity from rheometrics is based on the latter [9O]. A new universal extensional rheometer for polymer melts has been described by Munstedt [91]. It was specifically designed with the idea of making measurements on small samples possible in research laboratories under a variety of physical conditions, e.g. at constant stress or constant stretching rate, as well as relaxation and recoil experiments. The rotary clamp consisting of a pair of gears is a basic construction element for the design of various types of extensional rheometer described earlier. The fact that the design is amenable for use in uniaxial and biaxial extensional rheometry has been shown by Meissner et al. [92]. Other biaxial extensiometers have also been described [93,94] by other researchers. A method for measurement of viscoelastic properties of polymers in the prestationary extensional flow has been investigated by Leitlands [95]. A special experimental device using a vibrorheometer with automatic control has been suggested. Some other methods of experimental studies with regard to the extension of polymer melts have been discussed by Prokunin [96]. In terms of uniform extensional flow of polymers, a rather comprehensive review is that of Petrie and Dealy [97] which may be referred to for further information on the subject. 3.3.2 EXTRUSIONMETHOD
A typical example of extensional flow is the flow at the entrance of a capillary die. Besides the converging flow analysis of Cogswell [98,99],
there have been other analyses [100,101] in more recent times which are improved versions of the same ideas, and these can be used as better alternatives especially when dealing with filled polymer systems. Cogswell [102] has shown that the pressure losses through such dies can be used as a measure for the extensional viscosity. This method has not gained popularity because of the skepticism in accepting the complex converging flow patterns at the die entrance as representative of true extensional flow with constant extensional rate. Cogswell [103] did suggest later that the die ought to be lubricated to reduce the shear flow and the profile of the die wall should vary at all cross-sections in such a way as to ensure constant extensional rate along the die axis. Such a rheometer has been known to be developed and used for extensional viscosity data of polystyrene melt [104]. The extrusion method using a lubricated die [104,105] allows the measurements of systems with viscosity levels as low as 102Pa.sec. Thus, it can be used for extensional viscosity determinations in the case of nylon and polyester which are often spun to make synthetic fibers. Higher extensional rates, even 200 sec"1 are also achievable in this apparatus [104,105], thus making the information relevant for the polymer processing industries involved in fiber spinning.
REFERENCES 1. Philippoff, W. and Gaskins, F.H. (1956) Viscosity measurements on molten polyethylene, /. Polym. ScL, 21, 205-22. 2. Cogswell, F.N. (1973) The influence of pressure on the viscosity of polymer melts, Plastics & Polymer, 41, 39-43. 3. Kalousek, G.L. (1973) A new instrument for measuring thixotropy, Cement and Concrete Res., 3, 315-23. 4. Sarmiento, G., Crabbe, P.G., Boger, D.V. and Uhlherr, P.H.T. (1979) Measurement of the rheological characteristics of slowly settling flocculated suspensions, Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev., 18, 746-51. 5. Horie, M. and Pinder, K.L. (1979) Time-dependent shear flow of artificial slurries in coaxial cylinder viscometer with a wide gap, Can. J. Chem. Engg, 57,125-34. 6. Tuft, P. (1977) A tube viscometer for slurry investigations, 6th Australasian Hydraulics and Fluid Mech. Conf., Adelaide, Australia (5-9 Dec.). 7. Lippe, RJ. (1980) Rheological parameters: a versatile tool for the sealant formulator, Plastics and rubber: Processing, 51-54 (June). 8. Hodgetts, G.B. and Freestone, A.R.L (1977) Extrusion rheometer for characterising thixotropic materials, Rev. Sd. Instrum., 48, 411-13. 9. Jacobsen, P.H., Whiting, R. and Richardson, P.C.A. (1977) Viscosity of setting anterior restorative materials, Brit. Dent. /., 143, 393-6. 10. Whiting, R. and Jacobsen, P.H. (1979) The evaluation of non-Newtonian viscosity using a modified parallel-plate plastometer, /. Mat. ScL, 14, 307-11.
11. Vermilyea, S.G., Huget, E.F. and De Simon, L.B. (1979) Extrusion rheometry of fluid materials, /. Dental Research, 58,1691-5. 12. Baker, F.S., Carter, R.E. and Warren, R.C. (1980) The rheological assessment of propellants, Paper presented at the 8th Int. Congr. Rheol., Naples (1-5 Sept.). 13. Van Wazer, J.R., Lyons, J.W., Kim, K.Y. and Colwell, R.E. (1963) Viscosity and Flow Measurement: A Laboratory Handbook of Rheology, Interscience, New York. 14. Walters, K. (1975) Rheometry, Chapman & Hall, London; (1980) Rheometry: Industrial Applications, Research Studies Press, Chichester, England. 15. Whorlow, R.W. (1980) Rheological Techniques, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, England. 16. Schramm, G. (1981) Introduction to Practical Viscometry, Gebruder HAAKE GmbH, Karlsruhe, Germany. 17. Dealy, J.M. (1982) Rheometers for Molten Plastics, Society of Plastics Engineers and Van-Nostrand Reinhold, New York. 18. Meissner, J. (1985) Rheometry of polymer melts, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., 17, 45-64. 19. Connelly, R.W. and Greener, J. (1985) High shear viscometry with a rotational parallel-disk device, /. Rheol, 29, 209-26. 20. Kosinski, L.E. and Carruthers, J.M. (1986) The effect of particle concentration on the rheology of polydimethylsiloxane filled with fumed silica, Polym. Engg ScL, 32, 3323. 21. Weissenberg, K. (1948) Proc. Inst. Int. Rheol. Cong. 22. Pollett, W.F.O. and Cross, A.H. (1950) /. Sd. Inst., 27, 209. 23. King, R.G. (1966) Rheological measurement of three polyethylene melts, Rheol. Acta, 5, 35. 24. Chapman, P.M. and Lee, T.S. (1970) Effect of talc filler on the melt rheology of polypropylene, SPE /., 26, 37-40 Qan.). 25. Meissner, J. (1972) Modification of the Weissenberg rheogoniometer for measurement of transient rheological properties of molten polyethylene under shear, /. Appl. Polym. ScL, 16, 2877-99. 26. Han, C.D., Kim, K.U., Siskovic, N. and Huang, C.R. (1973) A comparison of measurements of the viscoelastic properties of polymer melts by means of the Han slit/capillary rheometer and the Weissenberg rheogoniometer, /. Appl. Polym. ScL, 17, 95-104. 27. Lee, B.L. and White, J.L. (1974) Trans. Soc. Rheol., 18, 467; (1975) Trans. Soc. Rheol, 19, 481. 28. Minagawa, N. and White, J.L. (1976) The influence of titanium dioxide on the rheological and extrusion properties of polymer melts, /. Appl. Polym. ScL, 20, 501-23. 29. Kataoka, T., Kitano, T., Sasahara, M. and Nishijima, K. (1978) Viscosity of particle filled polymer melts, Rheol Acta, 17,149-55. 30. Lobe, V.M. and White, J.L. (1979) An experimental study of the influence of carbon black on the rheological properties of a polystyrene melt, Polym. Engg ScL, 19, 617-29. 31. Saini, D.R. and Shenoy, A.V. (1983) Viscoelastic properties of linear low density polyethylene melts, Eur. Polym. /., 19, 811-16. 32. Saini, D.R. and Shenoy, A.V. (1984) !Dynamic and steady-state rheological properties of linear-low-density polyethylene melt, Polym. Engg ScL, 24, 1215-18.
33. Andrews, R.D., Hofman-Bang, N. and Tobolsky, A.V. (1948) Elastoviscous properties of poly (isobutylene) relaxation of stress in whole polymer of different molecular weights at elevated temperature, /. Polym. ScL, 3, 669-92. 34. Adams, J.W.C., Janeschitz-Kriegl, H., Den Otter, J.L. and Wales, J.L.S. (1968) /. Polym. ScL, A2, 6, 871-83. 35. Mills, NJ. and Nevin, A. (1971) Oscillatory shear measurements, /. Polym. ScL, A2, 9, 267-81. 36. Chen, LJ. and Bogue, D.C. (1972) Time-dependent stress in polymer melts and review of visco-elastic theory, Trans. Soc. RheoL, 16, 59-78. 37. Vinogradov, G.V., Malkin, A.Ya., Plotnikova, E.P., Sabsai, O.Yu. and Nikolayeva, N.E. (1972) Int. J. Polymeric Mat., 2,1-27. 38. Baily, E.D. (1974) Trans. Soc. RheoL, 18, 635-40. 39. Mtinstedt, H. (1976) Proc. 7th Int. RheoL Congr., 496. 40. Aoki, Y. (1979) /. Soc. RheoL, Japan, 7, 20. 41. Mooney, M. (1934) A shearing disk plastometer for unvulcanized rubber, Ind. Engg Chem. (Anal. Ed.), 6,147-51. 42. Taylor, R., Fielding, J.H. and Mooney, M. (1947) Symposium on Rubber Testing, ASTM, p. 36. 43. Mooney, M. (1947) The rheology of processing quality of raw rubber, /. Colloid. ScL, 2, 69-80. 44. Mooney, M. (1959) Proc. Int. Rubber Conf. (Washington), p. 368. 45. Mooney, M. (1962) Some neglated problems in the rheology of high polymers, Rubber Chem. TechnoL, 35, 27-31. 46. Sakamoto, K., Ishida, N. and Fukusawa, Y. (1968) Normal stress effect of molten polyethylenes, /. Polym. ScL, A2, 6,1999-2007. 47. Blyler, L.L. (1969) Normal stress behavior of linear polyethylene melts in a rotational parallel plate rheometer, Trans. Soc. RheoL, 13, 39-58. 48. Maxwell, B. and Chartoff, R.P. (1965) Studies of polymer melts in an orthogonal rheometer, Trans. Soc. RheoL, 9, 41-52. 49. Spencer, R.S. and Dillon, R.E. (1949) The viscous flow of molten polystyrene H, /. Colloid ScL, 4, 241-55. 50. Tordella, J.P. (1956) Fracture in the extrusion of amorphous polymers through capillaries, /. Appl. Phys., 27, 454-8. 51. White, J.L. (1973) Critique on flow patterns in polymer fluids at the entrance of a die and instabilities leading to extrudate distortion, Appl. Poly. Symp., 20,155-74. 52. Schott, H. (1964) Elastic effects and extrudate distortions in capillary flow of molten polyethylene resins, /. Polym. ScL, 2, 3791-801. 53. Mclntire, L.V. (1972) On the initiation of melt fracture, /. Appl. Polym. ScL, 16, 2901-8. 54. Bagley, E.B. (1957) End corrections in the capillary flow of polyethylene, /. Appl. Phys., 28, 624-7. 55. Eisenschitz, R., Rabinowitsch, B. and Weissenberg, K. (1929) Mitt. Dtsch. Mat. Pruf. Anst. Sonderheft, 9, 91. 56. Wales, J.L.S. (1975) A collaborative study of capillary flow of a highly lubricated unplasticized poly (vinyl chloride), /. Polym. ScL, Symp. No. 50, 469-85. 57. Angerer, G. and Wolff, D. (1976) RheoL Acta, 15, 57-63. 58. Menning, G. (1976) RheoL Acta, IS, 199-205. 59. Uhland, E. (1976) RheoL Acta, 15, 30-9.
60. Lin, Y.H. (1985) Explanation for slip melt fracture in terms of molecular dynamics in polymer melts, /. Rheol, 29, 605-37. 61. Knappe, W. and Krumbock, E. (1986) Slip flow of non-plasticized PVC compounds, Rheol Acta, 25, 296-307. 62. Ramamurthy, A.V. (1986) Wall slip in viscous fluids and influence of materials of construction, /. Rheol, 30, 337-57. 63. Lau, H.C. and Schowalter, W.R. (1986) A model for adhesive failure of viscoelastic fluids during flow, /. Rheol, 30, 193-206. 64. Leonov, A.I. (1984) A linear model of the stick-slip phenomena in polymer flow in rheometer, Rheol Acta, 23, 591-600. 65. Philippoff, W. and Gaskin, F.H. (1958) The capillary experiment, Trans. Soc. Rheol, 2, 263-84. 66. Faulkner, D.L. and Schmidt, L.R. (1977) Glass bead-filled polypropylene, Part I: Rheological and mechanical properties, Polym. Engg ScL, 17, 657-64. 67. Newman, S. and Trementozzi, Q.A. (1965) /. Appl. Polym. ScL, 9, 3071-89. 68. White, J.L. and Kondo, A. (1977) End pressure losses in extrusion of polymer melts through dies, /. Appl Polym. ScL, 21, 2289-92. 69. Han, C.D. (1976) Rheology in Polymer Processing, Academic Press, New York. 70. Han, C.D., Charles, M. and Philippoff, W. (1969) Measurement of the axial pressure distribution of molten polymers in flow through a circular tube, Trans. Soc. Rheol, 13, 455--66. 71. Han, C.D. (1974) Trans. Soc. Rheol, 18,163-90. 72. Han, C.D. (1971) Measurement of the rheological properties of polymer melts with slit rheometer. I. Homopolymer systems; II. Blend systems; III. Two phase systems - high impact polystyrene and ABS resins, /. Appl Polym. ScL, 15, 2567-77, 2579-89, 2591-6. 73. Wales, J.L.S., den Otter, J.L. and Janeschitz-Kriegl, H. (1965) Comparison between slit viscometry and cylindrical capillary viscometry, Rheol Acta, 4, 146. 74. Chung, J.T. (1988) Torque rheometer technology and instrumentation, Encyclopedia Fluid Mechanics, (ed. N. Cheremisinoff), Gulf Publishing, Houston, TX, Vol. 7, pp. 1081-139. 75. Blake, W.T. (1958) Determining molecular weights of thermoplastics materials, Plastics Technol, 4, 909-12, 930. 76. Schmitz, A.O. (1966) How to use the torque rheometer to solve the pressing problems, Plastics Technol, 12, 49-52. 77. Goodrich, J.E. and Porter, R.S. (1967) A rheological interpretation of torque rheometer data, Polym. Engg ScL, 7, 45. 78. Blyler, L.L. and Daane, J.H. (1967) An analysis of torque rheometer data, Polym. Engg ScL, 7,178-81. 79. Rogers, M.G. (1970) Rheological interpretation of Brabender plasti-corder (extruder head) data, Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Develop., 9, 49-52. 80. Shenoy, A.V. and Saini, D.R. (1986) Melt flow index: more than just a quality control rheological parameter, Advances Polymer Technol, 6, (Part 1} 1-58, (Part II) 125-45. 81. Shenoy, A.V. and Saini, D. R. (1996) Thermoplastic Melt Rheology and Processing, Marcel Dekker, New York. 82. Ballman, R.L. (1965) Extensional flow of polystyrene melt, Rheol. Acta, 4, 137^0.
83. Meissner, J. (1969) A rheometer for investigation of deformationmechanical properties of plastic melts under defined extensional straining, Rheol Acta, 8, 78-88. 84. Vinogradov, G.V., Radushkevich, B.V. and Fikham, V.D. (1970) Extension of elastic liquids; polyisobutylene, /. Polym. ScL1 A2 (8), 1-17. 85. Stevenson, J.F. (1972) Elongational flow of polymer melts, AIChE /., 18, 540-7. 86. Macosko, C.W. and Lorntsen, J.M. (1973) The rheology of two blow moulding polyethylenes, SPE Antec Tech. Papers, 461-7. 87. Ide, Y. and White, J.L. (1978) Experimental study of elongational flow and failure of polymer melts, /. Appl Polym. ScL, 22,1061-79. 88. Dealy, J.M. (1978) Extensional rheometers for molten polymers: a review, /. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech., 4, 9-21. 89. Cogswell, F.N. (1968) The rheology of polymer melts under tension, Plastics & Polymers, 36,109-11. 90. Miinstedt, H. (1975) Viscoelasticity of polystyrene melts in tensile creep experiments, Rheol. Acta, 14,1077-88. 91. Miinstedt, H. (1979) New universal extensional rheometer for polymer melts measurements on a polystyrene sample, /. Rheol., 23, 421-36. 92. Meissner, J., Raible, T. and Stephenson, S.E. (1981) Rotary clamp in uniaxial and biaxial extensional rheometry of polymer melts, /. Rheol., 25, 1-28. 93. Denson, C.D. and Hylton, D.C. (1980) A rheometer for measuring the viscoelastic response of polymer melts in arbitrary planar and biaxial extensional flow fields, Polym. Engg ScL1 20, 535-9. 94. Rhi-Sausi, J. and Dealy, J.M. (1981) A biaxial extensiometer for molten plastics, Polym. Engg ScL, 21, 227-32. 95. Leitlands, V.V. (1980) Investigations of unsteady elongational flow of polymer melts, Int. J. Polymeric Mater., 8, 233-42. 96. Prokunin, A.N. (1980) Some methods of experimental studies into the extension of polymeric liquids, Int. Polymeric Mater., 8, 303-21. 97. Petrie, C.J.S. and Dealy, J.M. (1980) Uniform elongational flow of molten polymers, in Rheology (ed. G. Astarita, G. Marrucci and L. Nicolais), 1, 177-94. 98. Cogswell, F.N. (1972) Converging flow of polymer melts in extrusion dies, Polym. Engg ScL, 12, 64-73. 99. Cogswell, F.N. (1972) Measuring extensional viscosities of polymer melts, Trans. Soc. Rheol., 16, 383-403. 100. Binding, D.M. (1991) Capillary and contraction flow of long glass fiber reinforced polypropylene, Composites, 2, 243-52; (1988) An approximate analysis for contraction and converging flows, /. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech., 27,177-89. 101. Gibson, A.G. (1989) Die entry flow of reinforced polymers, Composites, 20, 57-64. 102. Cogswell, F.N. (1969) Tensile deformations in molten polymers, Rheol. Acta, 8,187-94. 103. Cogswell, F.N. (1978) Converging flow and stretching flow: a compilation, /. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech., 4, 23-38. 104. Everage, A.E. and Ballman, R.L. (1978) The extensional flow capillary as a new method for extensional viscosity measurement, Nature, 273, 217-15. 105. Winter, H.H., Macosko, C.W. and Bennett, K.E., (1979) Rheol. Acta, 18, 323.
Constitutive theories and
equations for
suspensions
A
H"
4.1 IMPORTANCE OF SUSPENSION RHEOLOGY A suspension is a system in which denser particles, that are at least microscopically visible, are distributed throughout a less dense fluid and settling is hindered either by the viscosity of the fluid or the impacts of its molecules on the particles. In the present terminology of filled polymer systems, the fillers form a disperse phase and the softened or molten polymers form the continuous phase and together they could represent a suspension. However, suspension rheology does not normally refer to filled polymer rheology. In fact, it commonly discusses the rheological behavior of two-phase systems in which one phase is solid particles like fillers but the other phase is water, organic liquids (e.g. benzene, fuel oil) or polymer solutions. These systems are much easier to study than filled polymer systems as the preparation and rheological characterization of the systems can be done at room temperature. Further such systems are encountered in a number of areas other than polymer technology, namely, biotechnology [1-17], cement and concrete technology [18], ceramic processing [19], coal transportation [20-28], coating and pigment technology [29-32], dental research [33-38], propellants and explosive science [39], poultry waste handling [40,41], mineral processing [42-46], soil science [47] and various slurry flow technology [48]. Hence, the rheology of suspensions has received a lot of attention. There are a number of reviews [49-61] which discuss various aspects of the rheology of suspensions and may be referred to for detailed study. In the present chapter, the topic is touched upon rather briefly and only certain aspects are discussed in a limited manner just enough to lay the foundations for understanding the basics of filled polymer rheology. Suspensions basically show strong departures from simple Newtonian laws of fluid flow and hence form complex rheological
systems. When the dispersing medium is a Newtonian fluid or behaves like one under a given range of shear rates, then the suspension exhibits Newtonian behavior at low concentration of solids and non-Newtonian behavior with increasing concentration. When the suspending medium is a polymer solution which itself is non-Newtonian in character, the presence of solid particles magnifies the complexities of its rheological behavior. The important rheological properties which need to be studied and measured in order to be able to characterize suspensions are the same as those which have already been indicated in Chapter 2. However, only the viscous flow behavior in shear and extensional flow will be discussed in this chapter. In particular, shear viscosity will be dealt with in sufficient detail because of the wealth of information that exists on it. 4.2 SHEAR VISCOUS FLOW Several theoretical and empirical relationships have been proposed to describe the viscosity of suspensions in Newtonian or non-Newtonian viscous liquids. These relationships have also been used, with ranging degrees of success, to correlate viscosity data when the suspending medium is viscoelastic [62]. In the following various relationships are reviewed. The viscosity of Newtonian as well as non-Newtonian suspensions is affected by the characteristics of the solid phase such as shape, concentration and dimensions of the particles, its size distribution, the nature of the surface, etc. The influence of each of these factors is examined below. 4.2.1 EFFECT OF SHAPE, CONCENTRATION AND DIMENSIONS OF THE PARTICLES
Spherical filler particles have received more attention than nonspherical and asymmetric particles. In the following, the effect of concentration and dimensions of the particles are presented under the sub-sections of different shapes of particles. A. Spherical particles (a)
Dilute suspensions
Einstein [63-65] was the pioneer in the study of the viscosity of dilute suspensions of neutrally buoyant rigid spheres without Brownian motion in a Newtonian liquid. He proposed the following relationship between the relative viscosity of the suspension rjr and the volume fraction of the suspended particles 0
>7r = l + aE0
(4.1)
where rjr is the ratio of the viscosity of the suspension rjs to the viscosity of the suspending medium q0 and aE is Einstein's constant. aE equals 2.5 when the suspended particles are neutrally buoyant, hard and spherical in shape, the mean interparticle distance is large compared to the mean particle size, the particle movement is so slow that its kinetic energy can be neglected and there is no slip relative to the particle surface. Experimental determinations of Reiner [66] and Kurgaev [67] revealed that for filler concentrations of > = 0.003-0.05, aE was indeed equal to 2.5. Rutgers [68] concluded through experimental evidence that equation (4.1) with aE = 2.5 was valid for values up to 0 < 0.1. However, a slight disagreement in the value of aE = 2.5 was established from the works of Hatschek [69], who theoretically found that aE — 4.5 for (j) = 0-0.4 and Andres [70] who found that for dilute magnetic suspensions aE = 4.5 for (/> = 0-0.09. In fact Kurgaev [67] showed that when (j) = 0.15-0.18, aE = 4.5-4.75 depending upon the nature of the solid particles. The disagreement was accentuated when Happel [71] suggested a value of aE — 5.5 and Pokrovskii [72] a value of 1.5. It was revealed by Kambe [73] that the lack of agreement among the experimental results was due, among other things, to differences between the dimensions of the particles under study and the velocity gradients used for the experiments. It appears that for solid spheres with diameters large enough compared to the molecular dimensions but small enough compared to the characteristic length of the measuring instrument and for no slip at the sphere surface, the value of aE = 2.5 is generally accepted though values ranging from 1.5 to 5.5 have been suggested. Based on the theoretical analysis of Simha [74] for concentrated suspensions. Thomas [75] proposed the following expression for dilute suspensions ($ < 0.1) n, = l
+ 2.5(l +^JjJ
(4.2)
where U1 is an empirical coefficient whose value lies between 1 and 2. Thomas [75] suggested that U1 = 1.111 for > < 0.15. Simha and Somcynsky [76] suggested that the expression (4.2) proposed by Thomas [75] could be written as follows: i/r = 1+2.5^1(0) where
*<>-(>^>
(4.3)
when higher terms in 0 in the expression suggested [76] are dropped. When (j) = 0.10, however, higher terms in (/> are not negligible and to compensate for this, Thomas [75] had to use the value of ^1 — 1.111 when actually U1 = 1.85 in the unapproximated expression of A((/>) gave excellent results. Ford [77] modified Einstein's equation (4.1) using a binomial expression and wrote -=l-aE0
(4.4)
'Ir
where l/rjr is defined as the fluidity and is equal to zero when 4> = l/a E . Equation (4.4) has been shown to be valid for 4> < 0.15 by the experimental data of Cengel et al. [78]. Though there is varied opinion about the relationship between the relative viscosity of a suspension and the volume concentration of the spheres for dilute suspension, one could get a reasonable estimate on using the simplest equation (4.1) of Einstein for 0 < 0.1. When 0.1 < (f> < 0.15, Thomas's [75] equation (4.2) or Ford's [77] equation (4.4) could be used for a reliable estimate. Of course for 0 < 0.1 too, these equations could be used and the result averaged out with the prediction from equation (4.1) to obtain a good conservative estimation. (b)
Concentrated suspension
Generally, when 0.1 < 0 < 4>m the suspensions are considered to be concentrated and the above discussed equations do not apply. Here 0m is defined as the maximum attainable concentration and has the following form: 0m = 1 — e, where e is the void fraction or porosity, and is defined as the ratio of the void volume to that total volume. Theoretically, the value of >m is 0.74 for equal spheres in compact hexagonal packing, but in practice it is more like 0.637 for random hexagonal packing or 0.524 for cubic packing ([79]). When the filler concentration is increased, various phenomena take place, for example (i) the number of particles per unit volume which come in contact during the flow increases, (ii) the interparticle attraction and repulsion effects become stronger due to electrostatic charges, which depend upon the polarity of the medium, (iii) the rotation of the particles during flow, as well as the formation of doublets and their rotation during flow, produces additional dissipative effects which lead to an increase in the viscosity. Unlike the dilute suspensions, the size of the filler drastically changes the viscosity behavior of concentrated suspensions. De Brujin [80] showed that when the filler diameter is less than 10 (am, a concentrated suspension exhibits non-Newtonian behavior and the viscosity
increases with a decrease in the filler diameter. Clarke [81] found that for a filler diameter greater than 10 jam, the viscosity increases linearly with the diameter. For spheres, with increasing diameter the lateral displacement of the particles towards the centre of the tube (central tube effect) increases, thereby increasing the energy dissipated resulting in a tendency for the viscosity of the suspension to increase with increasing diameter. As there are many-fold effects of increasing the concentration of the fillers, a variety of physical models have been proposed but most of them (theoretical or experimental) can be expressed by the nonlinear relationship between rjr and c/> in the following power series form as given in Thomas [75] */r = 1 + a a 0 + a2(/>2 ± a3(/>3 ± ...
(4.5)
where (X1 is generally assumed to have a value of 2.5 as given by Einstein [63], while the coefficients a2, a 3 ,... have been assigned different values by different authors. For example, the value of a2 was 14.1 as determined by Guth and Simha [82], 7.349 by Vand [83], 12.6 by Saito [84]. 10.05 by Manley and Mason [85] and 6.25 by Harbard [86]. These varied values of a2 are the result of taking into account one or several effects appearing due to the increase in solid concentrations. Similarly, a3 values of 16.2 and 15.7 have been proposed by Vand [83] and Harbard [86], respectively. Alfrey [87] has also developed relationships of the power series form (4.5) and enlisted values of a,based on the works of Arrhenius [88], Fikentsher and Mark [89], Bungenberg de Jong et al [90], Papkov [91], Hauwink [92] as well as Brede and De Boojs [93]. As an example of the use of equation (4.5) to determine the viscosity of suspensions, one can refer to the works of Mullins [94] and Feldman and Boiesan [95] on rubbers containing fillers which are chemically inactive like wood flour or chemically active like carbon black. When the filler introduced is chemically inactive (with any (/>) or chemically active (with 0 < 0.10), the quadratic form of equation (4.5) with Oc1 = 2.5 and oc2 = 14.1 could be used to give a good estimate of the viscosity of the suspension. For higher concentrations of the chemically active filler (carbon black), particle interaction begins and the viscosity of the suspension increases markedly and equation (4.5) as such cannot then be used for an estimate. However, if particle interaction leads to agglomeration, then Mullins [94] and Feldman and Boiesan [95] recommend the use of Oi1 = 0.670, and a2 = 1.620? in equation (4.5), where a{ is the index of asymmetry of the elastomer macromolecules. The main drawback of equation (4.5) is that the termination of the series after 02 term means an error of 10% or more in the relative viscosity for > > 0.15-0.20. The validity of the series increases to
(j) cz 0.40 on the inclusion of <£3 term. However, the values of the coefficients of higher order terms are less accurate since they must include more complicated interactions than it is theoretically possible to treat. Based on the work of Eyring et al. [96] who suggested that the term OC3^3 in equation (4.5) should be of the exponential form, Thomas [75] arrived at the following expression r\r = I + 2.5(1) +10.05>2 + 0.00273 exp(16.6<£)
(4.6)
Thus a closed form expression is obtained which fits experimental data as well as the power series form with three or four adjustable coefficients. The validity of expression (4.6) is for a filler concentration varying between 0.15 and 0.60. Another power series type of expression is given by Ford [77], who added higher order terms to his expression (4.4) for dilute suspensions, making use of the data of Vand [83], to give - = 1 - 2.50 + 11<£5 - 11.5>7
(4.7)
*ir
He suggested that the inclusion of the term >5 takes into account the onset of the inhibition of particle rotation, and the term ^7 takes into account the onset of particle interlocking. Mooney [97] proposed that at very high concentrations an Arrhenius type equation (with the addition of crowding factor (1 — ac>)) of the following form could be used: *-«*&]
where ac has a value between 1.35 and 1.91. Mooney's relationship has been known to be in good agreement with experimental data ([66], [98]). The empirical expression (4.3) as suggested by Simha [74] can also be used for concentrated suspensions if the relationship for A(>) given by him is not approximated and all the higher order terms in are retained. Simha's analysis was based on the idea that the neighbors of each sphere in the suspension can be replaced by a rigid spherical enclosure, and that the finite size of the particles effectively shields the central particle from interaction with any other particle than the nearest neighbors as the concentration is increased. For concentrations up to >m, experimental data are seen to validate the following empirical expression obtained by Eilers [99] * r = [ l + n 1^ J L (1 - 0/0m)J
Note that for > -> 0m, r\r ->> oo and rightly so.
(4-9)
Frankel and Acrivos [100] did away with all empiricisms and artificial boundaries and provided an expression for highly concentrated suspensions of uniform solid spheres intending to complement the classical Einstein's equation (4.1) valid only for very dilute suspensions. Their final result is written as follows: 9
0Mn)178
"'-81-OMA n T
(410) (4 10)
'
With so many theoretical expressions (4.5) to (4.10), it is increasingly difficult to make a choice between them and decide which one would give the most reliable estimate for the relative viscosity of a concentrated suspension. For concentrated suspensions, it is necessary to account for the hydrodynamic interaction of particles, particle rotation, particle collisions, doublet and higher order agglomerate formation and mechanical interference between particles as packed bed concentrations are approached. Different authors have taken into account one or several aspects mentioned above during the derivation of their theoretical expressions. For concentrated suspensions of uniform solid spheres, the use of expression (4.6) of Thomas [75] is recommended for 0.15 < > < 0.60 and the expression (4.10) of Frankel and Acrivos [100] for 0 -> <£m to obtain reliable estimates. Though equation (4.10) predicts the correct experimental trends at large values of $ -> >m, it does not reduce to equation (4.1) when 0 ^ 0 . Further, the averaging process used for deriving equation (4.10) has been shown to be incorrect [101] and it has been argued that the dissipation in pair interactions is too small to explain the observed trends. But since equation (4.10) does fit experimental data rather well for high solids concentrations, it can be simply considered as yet another empirical equation. Attempts [102-104] to fit the entire range of volume fraction from (j) -* O to 0 -> 0m have resulted in equations which give a unique curve through the use of a plot of relative viscosity versus the ratio of 4>/4>m. The work of Chong et al. [102] has shown a good fit between experimental results and an equation of the following type:
'"Mi^fc)]' 0m is normally determined from the experimental data. It is to be noted that equation (4.11) reduces to equation (4.1) at low values of (/) when (J)n takes a value of 0.6. One of the best available empirical expressions which fits the entire range of volume fraction, is the Maron-Pierce type equation that was
carefully evaluated by Kitano, Kataoka and co-workers [103,104], and extensively tested by Poslinski et al [105,106]. rjr = [1 - 4>/(t>m}-2
(4.12a)
For suspensions of smooth spheres, a value of 0m = 0.68 has been suggested [107] and a value of 0m = 0.60-0.62 has been determined through liquid displacement experiments [105,106]. In reality, of course, using ^1n as 0.6 or 0.62 or 0.68 does not improve the data fit appreciably. But at times it may be best to view >m as an adjustable parameter and then equation (4.12a) is rewritten as follows: iyr = (1 - <£/Apr2
(4.12b)
The adjustable parameter Ap is now considered to give some measure of the thickness of the immobilized polymer adsorbed on the filler surface and thereby indicates the affinity of the polymer for the filler [108]. B. Ellipsoidal particles The theory of the viscosity of dilute ellipsoidal suspensions without Brownian motion was developed by Jeffrey [109]. He observed that Einstein's equation (4.1) could be used to estimate the viscosity by appropriately defining the Einstein constant aE. Jeffrey [109] has tabulated the values of aE for prolate and oblate spheroids. He found that aE depended on the ratio of the semi-axes of the ellipsoid of rotation. For a prolate spheroid, Guth [110,111] developed the following relationship based on Jeffrey's theory [109] when the axis ratio re ^> 1. Thus, >7r = l + a rl 0 + ar2>2
(4.13)
where «"=<2tafe>) + 2
<4
"a)
-01& Pokrovskii [112] demonstrated theoretically that concentrated suspensions of solid ellipsoidal bodies in a Newtonian fluid give rise to a viscoelastic behavior. He showed that for such suspensions it is possible to use the concept of transverse viscosity which expresses the effect of normal stresses and found that the transverse viscosity increases with velocity gradient.
C. Rod-shaped particles Suspensions of rod-shaped particles have received greater attention than ellipsoidal particles due to the obvious increasing demand for fiber-reinforced plastics. Exact theories exist for the viscosity of very dilute suspensions of rod-shaped particles. However, this is not the case for higher concentrations. The reason is evident from the fact that differences in viscosities of suspensions of different shaped particles are small at low concentrations. With an increase in the concentration, particle rotation causes the frequency of contacts between adjacent particles to increase, resulting in an increase in the viscosity (Figure 4.1). For rod-shaped particles, the above effect is accentuated with an increase in the aspect ratio as can be seen from the work of
GLASS RODS GLASS PLATES QUARTZ GRAINS GLASS SPHERES EINSTEIN'S EQUATION
Figure 4.1 Effect of concentration on the relative viscosity of different shaped particles in water at a shear rate of 327.7 sec~1. (Reprinted from Ref. 81 with kind permission from The Institution of Chemical Engineers, Rugby, UK.)
Maschmeyer and Hill [113] who showed that the presence of only a few percent of relative long fibers in the particle distribution doubled or tripled the suspension viscosity. From the work of Clarke [81] shown in Figure. 4.1, it can be conclusively seen that the viscosity of a suspension is higher for the same concentration of the particles for larger departures in shapes from spheres. In the case of dilute suspensions of rod-shaped particles, too, Einstein's equation (4.1) can be used with the appropriately defined constant <XE. Burgers [114] has established the following relationship for straight rigid rod-shaped suspensions under shear
^^l-1.8)] ^^
(415)
where ra is the aspect ratio (/P/D) and 6 and \l/ are the spherical coordinates giving the orientation of the rod (see Figure 4.2). Burgers [114] found that rod-shaped particles (and also elongated ellipsoidal particles) cause an increase in the Einstein's coefficient with increasing aspect ratio (ra) as shown in Figure 4.3, for randomly oriented particles such as would occur at very low rates of shear. At high shear rates, of course, orientation of the rods would result in a decrease in the effective value of the Einstein coefficient.
Figure 4.2 Coordinate system for a rigid rod in a field of simple shear.
Figure 4.3 Einstein's coefficient as a function of the aspect ratio of randomly oriented rod-shaped particles,
For dilute suspensions in rotational motion, Mason [115] gave the following expression for critical concentration $cr below which the interaction between the rods can be neglected. Thus, 0 c r -¥ ^a
(4.16)
Blankeney [116] observed that below this critical concentration the relative viscosity of a rod-shaped particle suspension increases slowly and linearly with $. A slight non-linear region then follows after which the relative viscosity increases rapidly. Experimentally, it was found that the value of (/>cr depended .upon the nature of the solid phase. For example, Clarke [81] found that for glass rods >cr = 0.15 and for PMMA spheres 0cr = 0.40. For concentrated suspensions of rod-like particles (i.e. for <j> > 0cr),
the following relationship was suggested by Simha [117] and later verified by Blankeney [116] >7r = l + aE> + a(aE(/>)2
(4.17)
For randomly oriented rods with purely hydrodynamic interactions between them, Simha [117] determined the value of a to be equal to 0.73. For concentrated fiber suspensions in tube flow, Brodnyan [118] suggested the following equation:
,, =expp+ o^.-i)"Vj
(418)
but the experimental data of Brodnyan [118] themselves were not found to fit for high concentration of suspension. Taking into account the particle interaction and the degree of flocculation, Ziegel [119] proposed the following equation:
3
-( f^>--)SIwhere Ji is an interaction parameter, /J0 is a rate constant for the equilibrium between free particles and floccules and Z0 is the degree of flocculation.
Hashin [120] used the flow-elasticity analogy to give the following equation which was valid only for parallel, randomly placed infinitely long fibers ^r = l +1-0 A
(4-20)
Nielsen [121] used the same analogy, but his equation has not been tested for concentrated fiber suspensions. The shape of the rod (whether straight or curved) does affect the relative viscosity of the suspension. The viscosity for curved fiber suspension is known to be higher than that for a straight fiber suspension and the difference increases with increasing concentration (Figure 4.4). 4.2.2 EFFECT OF SIZE DISTRIBUTION OF THE PARTICLES
Clarke [81] observed that mixed suspensions of mainly coarse particles and relatively few fine particles showed a marked decrease in the viscosity compared to an all coarse suspension. Contrarily, suspensions with mainly fine particles and few coarse particles showed very little change from an all fine suspension. It could thus be concluded that
STRAIGHT FIBERS CURVED FIBERS
Figure 4.4 Variation of the relative viscosity of suspensions with concentration for (a) curved fibers and (b) straight fibers.
smaller particles are interposed between larger particles, causing a reduction in the interparticle impact resulting in a decrease in viscosity. Ward and Whitmore [122], Ting and Luebbers [123] and Moreland [124] also noticed similar results using different techniques of measurement. Shaheen [125] suggested that the addition of a little amount of small particles acts as a lubricant to facilitate the rotation of larger particles, leading to a reduction in the relative viscosity. Experimentally, it was shown that the viscosity of a mixture of two different-sized particles goes through a minimum at about a volume fraction of small particles equal to 0.25. Shaheen [125] wrote the modified form of Mooney's equation (i.e. equation (4.8)) for a mixture of spherical particles of two different sizes as follows:
=
/ 2/5>a \
/ 2.502 \
'~ Mr^Mi^^J where
(421)
<-«fi?T®r
« _ Js1^nS f U \
Io
/
\
(4.23,
r/
Parkinson et al [126] arrived at a Mooney type equation for the relative viscosity of a dispersion of polydisperse spheres containing / size fractions as /
\
/ 2.5^1 \
/ 2.502 \
/ 2.50f \
"4E) -Mi^Mi=Iy-"(T=W
,,^,
<4 24)
'
where 015 0 2 ... 0f are the volume concentrations of each size fraction, and the values of /C1, fc2... fcz are derived from an empirical equation of the following general form Ic1 = 1.079 + exp(0.01008/Dp/) + exp(0.0029/D*,)
(4.25)
The above equation (4.24) is not suitable for a continuous distribution of particle diameters and the equation given by Mooney [97] has to be then resorted to: rjr = exp (2.50 T
Af"'' ) Ja1 1-0T 1 ^d(T7./
V
(4.26)
where 0 is the total volume concentration of spheres, a;l the crowding factor, Pf the particle size frequency function and alf O2 the upper and lower limits of the dimensionless radius, respectively. The two main difficulties in the use of equation (4.26) are that the nature of oc;j is known only in special cases and hence the distribution function to accurately describe the particle size distributions of different grades of the same filler is almost impossible to find. Hsieh [127] suggested a quadratic model of the following canonical form for an M-component system of particle size distribution. /M
M
\
Vr = exp ( Y, Bixt + £ V<*;) V i=l
Ki^j
(4-27>
'
where x{ is the weight proportion of the zth component in the blend of the total number of M components. The coefficients B1 and B^ were determined experimentally and for a tetramodal size distribution, Hsieh [127] has given the derived expression from equation (4.27) which was seen to agree well with the experiments for four basic aluminum trihydroxides with distinctively different particle sizes in an unsaturated polyester resin.
4.2.3 EFFECT OF THE NATURE OF THE PARTICLE SURFACE
Moreland [124] obtained viscosity data of suspensions of coal in mineral oil during which he concluded that slurry viscosities for irregular particles were greater than for spherical particles. A similar result was obtained by Clarke [81], who showed that suspensions of sharp-edged particles have a much larger viscosity than those of round-edged ones. Roughened particles are likely to increase the viscosity of suspensions in two ways: (a) primarily by harsh frictional contact and (b) secondarily, by trapping layers of inert liquid on its surface thereby causing an effective increase in the concentration as suggested by Ward and Whitmore [128]. 4.2.4
EFFECT OF THE VELOCITY GRADIENT
In the flow of suspensions, velocity gradient is known to cause two major effects, (a) migration of the particles towards the centre of the axis in a tube flow situation and (b) rotation of the particles. A. Wall effect and the central tube effect In pipe flow of a suspension, the presence of a wall and a velocity gradient causes the particles to migrate towards the tube axis and correspondingly decrease the concentration of the solid phase near the wall. This effect known as the wall effect has been observed by Goldsmith and Mason [129] for suspensions of different shaped particles in Poiseuille flow. A consequence of the wall effect is the central tube effect wherein the migration of the particles towards the tube axis causes an increase in the solid phase concentration within a narrow region of about 0.6.R1 (where R( is the internal radius of the tube). The wall effect and the central tube effect appear simultaneously and after a certain time from the start of the flow due to the velocity gradient being set up. Segre and Silberberg [130,131] have shown that these effects manifest themselves only at small concentrations of the solid phase. These effects have been taken into account during the estimation of the suspension viscosity of PMMA spheres in a ternary mixture of water, glycerol and 1.3butanediol by Segre and Silberberg [132]. A detrimental effect in the measurement of properties of a suspension, other than the viscosity, could result due to the presence of the wall and the central tube effect. Care should be taken during property measurements with probes through tube walls as the measured quantities could easily be the properties of the suspending medium rather than of the suspension. The migration of the particles towards the tube axis due to the
velocity gradient also leads to a characteristic slippage at the wall surface (Morrison and Harper [133]). A direct consequence of the slip is the increased flow rate through the tube compared to that which would occur if slip were absent. The value of shear rate calculated from the famous Mooney-Rabinowitsch equation will, therefore, be erroneous and a correction ought to be made as given by Jastrzebski [134]. B. Particle rotation At high concentrations of the solid phase, the existence of a velocity gradient results in rotation of the particles, followed by an increase in the viscosity of the suspension. Concentrated suspensions are known to exhibit non-Newtonian behavior and hence viscosity would change as the shear rate (velocity gradient) changes. It is generally assumed that the viscosity dependence on shear rate is due to some structural changes in the suspensions such as the breaking up of agglomerates during shear. For example, Chapman and Lee [135] as well as Goel [136] found that, at low shear rates (y < lsec"1) talcfilled polypropylene was more viscous than the base propropylene, but such was not the case at higher shear rates (7 > lsec"1) wherein break up of the network-like structure took place, resulting in the viscosity of the talc-filled systems equivalent to that of propropylene alone. Similar behavior was observed by Ferraro [137] for other systems. Concentrated suspensions often exhibit a yield stress below which no shear deformation takes place and after which the suspension could behave as a Newtonian, pseudoplastic or dilatant fluid. Shear dependent theories for such flows have been considered by Krieger and Dougherty [138] as well as Gillespie [139]. 4.2.5 EFFECT OF FLOCCULATION
The degree of flocculation of dispersed particles strongly influences the rheology of suspensions ([14O]). The viscosity of the suspension is known to increase sharply with flocculation, probably due to the relative immobilization of a fraction of the suspended particles trapped in the agglomerates. In shearing flow, both shear-thinning and shearthickening behavior have been observed. Govier and Winning [141] found concentrated clay suspensions to be shear-thinning. Heywood and Richardson [45] found that flocculated kaolin suspensions were shear-thinning and could be characterized by the power-law model at shear rates below 200OSeC"1. With increasing solid concentration, the flow behavior index n was seen to fall progressively while the consistency index K was seen to increase exponentially. At shear rates
above 2000 sec l, the behavior would be characterized by the Bingham plastic model with the yield stress and the plastic viscosity increasing monotonously with increasing solid concentration. Dilatant behavior is observed in certain flocculated systems with extremely high concentration of suspensions. Umeya and Kanno [142] found that concentrated suspensions of titanium dioxide in water stabilized with sodium pyrophosphate showed dilatancy. The effect of shear history on the dilatant behavior is shown in Figure 4.5, and is seen to be pronounced at high shear rates. A suspension deflocculated by shear does not recover its structure immediately after the removal of shear since the thermal energy of the particles is insufficient to overcome the energy barrier for the flocculation. As the degree of flocculation is decreased by applying high shear rates, the onset of dilatant flow occurs, the dependence of apparent viscosity on shear rate and the increase in the apparent viscosity decreases. Umeya and Kanno [142] also found that dilatant behavior of flocculated systems did
UNTTS
Water Ctaatase, 4 »0.4 *)
Shear Siren prrooudy appSed
Figure 4.5 The effect of shear histories on the flow properties of titanium dioxide (TiO2) water 27.7% suspensions stabilized with 5mg/g TiO2 of Na4P2O7-IOH2O. (Reprinted from Ref. 142 with kind permission from Society of Rheology, USA.)
depend upon the size of the particles as the degree of dispersion of larger particles was better than that of smaller ones. Hudson et al. [31] studied the time dependent effect of suspensions of pigment particles. Experimental work was undertaken to relate steady, transient and time dependent oscillatory flow in a unified manner. Hudson et al. [31] also developed a theory to explain the suspension behavior in terms of the structure formed as a result of flocculation. The viscosity rjf of a homogeneous suspension of floccules containing NJ floccules was given by In^ = f(0 f ) + vIn(N{) >7o
(4.28)
where r]0 was the viscosity of the suspending medium, f was a function of the volume fraction ($f) of the floccules in the suspension and v as a constant. A comparison of the experimental data with the theory enabled values of the model constants to be calculated. 4.2.6 EFFECT OF THE SUSPENDING MEDIUM
The nature of the suspending medium, whether Newtonian, viscous non-Newtonian, viscoelastic or viscoplastic affects the viscosity of the suspension. This has been the subject of research of a number of workers. Nicodemo et al. [143] studied the shear rate dependence of the viscosity of suspensions in non-Newtonian liquids and compared it with that of suspensions in Newtonian liquids. The relative viscosity, when the suspending medium was Newtonian, decreased with increasing shear rate toward an asymptotic value which was a function of the filler content. The concentration dependence could be correlated by equations given in section 4.2.1. When the suspending medium was non-Newtonian, Nicodemo et al. [143] found that the dependence of relative viscosity on shear rate was similar and could be correlated by a modified form of the equation of Krieger and Dougherty [138]. However, as the relative viscosity at high shear rates did not fit the existing equation, Nicodemo and Nicolais [144] searched for a mechanistic explanation. It was found that two different mechanisms in the range of low and high shear rates, respectively, existed for suspensions in polymeric solutions. When the suspending medium could be described by the power-law model, Kremesec and Slattery [145] derived the following expression for the viscosity of a dilute suspension of spheres If8 = (U-O0^)Ky"-1
(4.29)
The coefficient a0 was defined by the rate of energy dissipation within
the neighborhood of a typical sphere in the suspension. For n = \, a0 = 2.5 could be easily derived as in Einstein's equation (4.1). However, for n^\, the equations of motion, being nonlinear, are difficult to solve and hence only the upper and lower bounds for a0 as a function of n were obtained and compared with the available experimental data of Highgate and Warlow [146] to find reasonable agreement. 4.2.7
EFFECT OF ADSORBED POLYMERS
Polymers are often added as processing additives to suspensions used in ceramic forming operations [19]. Under certain conditions, the polymers adsorb on ceramic particles and alter the interparticle forces which control the state of dispersion and rheological properties of the suspension. An important criterion for achieving good particulate dispersion through steric stabilization is to ensure good coverage of the particle surfaces with the adsorbed polymer [147,148]. With low adsorption densities, the steric repulsive forces are likely to be too weak to prevent close approach of particles, thereby leading to flocculation due to van der Waals attractive forces as well as bridging flocculation due to polymer segments from one particle surface attaching themselves to the available surface site of another particle. Sacks et al. [19] studied the amount of polymer adsorbed and the state of particulate dispersion in aqueous silica suspensions containing different concentrations of poly (vinyl alcohol) (PVA). An adsorption isotherm for suspensions of 20 vol% silica at pH = 3.7, wherein the zeta potential for the chosen silica is zero, is shown in Figure 4.6. It can be seen that initial additions of PVA are almost completely adsorbed on the silica particles and very little polymer remains in solution. When overall PVA concentration is increased, the particle surface tends to become saturated with adsorbed polymer and then higher amounts of residual polymer are left in solution. The initial plateau region of the adsorption isotherm is associated with approximately monolayer coverage of the particle surface. The second plateau is probably an indication of either the development of denser packing of polymer molecules in the adsorbed monolayer or the development of multilayer adsorption. Figure 4.7(a) shows the relative viscosity versus shear rate behavior for suspensions at pH = 3.7 with varying polymer adsorption in the range of O to 1.1 mg adsorbed PVA/g silica. For the sake of comparison, the relative viscosity versus shear rate plot is also shown in the same figure for an electrostatically stabilized suspension prepared at pH = 7.0 with no PVA. At pH = 7.0, wherein the zeta potential is approximately — 55 mV, the silica suspension is extremely well
ADSORBED AMOUNT (mg PVA/g Silica)
20 vol% SHIcf
RESIDUAL POLYMER CONCENTRATION
dispersed judging from its low relative viscosity and Newtonian behavior over the entire shear rate range. In contrast, at pH = 3.7 when the zeta potential is approximately OmV, the silica suspension with no PVA is flocculated, adjudging from the high viscosity and highly shearthinning behavior. In Figure 4.7(a), it can be seen that initial additions of PVA result in higher viscosity and greater shear-thinning characteristics, thus indicating the occurrence of bridging flocculation at the low PVA adsorption densities. With additional PVA adsorption, the trend observed in Figure 4.7(a) is reversed as can be seen from Figure 4.7(b). Beyond the adsorbed amount of 1.1 mg adsorbed PVA/g silica, the bridging flocculation gives way to steric stabilization. Low suspension viscosity, approximately Newtonian behavior over the entire range of shear rate and absence of any yield stress are observed when the adsorption of PVA is such as to ensure monolayer coverage of particles. It is known that maximum flocculation occurs at approximately half coverage of the particles [44,149]. In the adsorbed PVA/silica suspension case, too, the maximum flocculation did occur at approximately half coverage of the particles as evidenced from the maximum value of the yield stress at that adsorption level as shown in
RELATIVE VISCOSITY
Amount Atf»0ib«d
RELATIVE VISCOSITY
SHEAR RATf (•"')
Amount Adaorfe**
SHEAU RATE (•'') Figure 4.7 Variation of relative viscosity with shear rate for 20 vol% silica suspensions prepared at pH = 3.7 with varying concentrations of poly(vinyl alcohol). The relative viscosity vs. shear rate plot for an electrostatically stabilized suspension (pH = 7.0) with no poly(vinyl alcohol) is also shown. (Reprinted from Ref. 19 with kind permission from The American Ceramic Society Inc., Westerville, Ohio, USA.)
Figure 4.8. It should be noted that the amount of adsorbed polymer depends not only on the overall suspension polymer-particle, polymerliquid and particle-liquid interactions. The adsorption densities are known to depend on the amount of isolated or free surface hydroxyl groups on the particles [150,151]. The effect of the adsorbed polymer in achieving different levels of dispersion also depends on the 'goodness' of the solvent for that polymer. For example, when the solvent is good, it is known [147,148] that steric stabilization is promoted because the loops and tails of the
YIELD STRESS (Pa)
ABSORBEb AMOUNT (mg PVA/g Silica) Figure 4.8 Variation of yield stress with adsorption density of poly(vinyl alcohol) on silica for suspensions prepared at pH = 3.7 with 20 vol% silica and varying concentration of poly(vinyl alcohol). Yield stress values were determined from shear stress vs. shear rate curves. (Reprinted from Ref. 19 with kind permission from The American Ceramic Society Inc., Westerville, Ohio, USA.)
polymer which extend out from the particle surface are well solvated. When the solvent is not good for the polymer, then bridging flocculation is likely to occur. The effect of solvent quality on particulate dispersion was investigated [19] using alumina (Al2O3)/poly(vinyl butyral) (PVB) suspensions prepared in methanol (MEOH), which is a poor solvent, and in a 3:1 volume ratio mixture of methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBK) with MEOH, which is a better solvent. Figure 4.9(a) and (b) shows the relative viscosity versus shear rate behavior in these two solvents for varying PVB concentration from O to 2.0vol%. In either of the solvents, highly shear-thinning behavior is observed when no PVB is added. These suspensions show poor stability against flocculation due to relatively low zeta potentials (< 25 mV) and therefore, low electrostatic repulsive forces [152]. The effect of PVB additions on the dispersion behavior can be seen from Figure 4.9 to be dependent on the suspension liquid composition. In MEOH suspension, though addition of PVB reduces the viscosity of the suspension, the system is shear-thinning indicating that the suspensions remain flocculated in poorer solvents for the added
RELATIVE VISCOSITY
CCMAMIC: 3O *«(% Al/>, LtQOIO : MCOH
SHCAP RATE (»-')
RELATIVE VISCOSITY
CCRAMtC: 3O v*l% *>}Oj UOUID: 3:1. HMK'MCOM
SMEAA RATE U•') Figure 4.9 Variation of relative viscosity with shear rate for 30 vol% alumina suspensions prepared with (a) methanol and (b) 3:1 methyl isobutyl ketone/methanol with indicated poly(vinyl butyral) concentrations. (Reprinted from Ref. 19 with kind permission from The American Ceramic Society Inc., Westerville, Ohio, USA.)
polymer. In 3:1 MIBK/MEOH suspensions, PVB additions (0.5 to 2.0vol%) give much lower relative viscosity and almost Newtonian behavior. A slight dilatancy has been observed which is not unusual in highly loaded suspensions in which repulsive forces are large [153,154]. The level of loading makes a lot of difference in the adsorption of the polymer. It can be seen from Figure 4.10(a) that for 30 vol% A^Os, there is only a small difference in the shear stress versus shear rate flow curve for the two polymer concentrations of 0.25 vol% and 0.5vol%
SMC ARSTfIESS(Pa)
CERAMIC : 30 V<*X AJjO3 UOlHD : 3:1, MAK MEOH
SHEAR RATE U'1)
SHEAR STRESS (Pat
CtRAMtC : 45 «* % AI2O3 LIOiMD: 3:1, MBK/MCOH
SHCAM RATl U-1I Figure 4.10 Variation of shear stress vs. shear rate for 3:1 methyl isobutyl ketone/ methanol suspensions prepared using (a) 30 vol% alumina and (b) 45 vol% alumina with indicated poly(vinyl butyral) concentrations. (Reprinted from Ref. 19 with kind permission from The American Ceramic Society Inc., Westerville, Ohio, USA.)
PVB. In both cases, approximately Newtonian behavior is observed and the viscosities are relatively low, indicating that the suspensions are well dispersed. However, when the filler loading is 45 vol% Al2O3, the 0.25 vol% PVB suspension shows a yield stress and an initial region of highly shear-thinning behavior, indicating that the suspension is highly flocculated at low shear rates (Figure 4.10(a)). This happens because complete monolayer coverage of the Al2O3 particle does not occur at this concentration of polymer. In contrast, the system is far better
dispersed when the 0.5 vol% PVB suspension is used, due to the higher adsorption density. 4.2.8 EFFECT OF CHEMICAL ADDITIVES
Small additions of various common 'processing aids' such as surfactants, dispersants, coupling agents and lubricants do affect the rheological properties of suspensions. The effect of various surface modifiers on the viscous behavior and dispersion of alumina in water has been studied by Dow [155]. The suspensions were prepared by first adding 1.25g of surface modifier to 125 cc distilled (DI) water and then adding alumina powder after lhr. There were visually observed differences between the four surface modifiers studied. The zircoaluminate CAVCO MOD APG and the silane Z-6020 were completely dissolved to form clear solutions. On the other hand, the silane Z-6076 and titanate LICA 12 were found to form emulsions which showed small droplets suspended in the water. This was explained as due to the difference in the solubility of the different surface modifiers. On account of this, the alumina powders were not coated homogeneously by the later surface modifiers with poorer solubility [155]. Figure 4.11 shows the plots of shear stress versus shear rate for the suspensions prepared with alumina powder and different surface modifying agents. The suspension with zircoaluminate is well dispersed as indicated by the Newtonian flow behavior and low suspension viscosity which was determined to be about 2.8 centipoise. The good dispersion is also indicated from a comparison with the electrostatically stabilized alumina suspension prepared at pH = 4.0 with no chemical additives as shown in Figure 4.12. Suspensions containing silane Z-6076 and titanate LICA 12, on the other hand, showed large yield stresses, higher viscosities and highly thixotropic flow behavior, indicating that the suspension is highly flocculated. The suspension prepared with silane Z-6020 is also not as well dispersed as the suspension with the zircoaluminate but the relatively low yield stress, lower viscosity and absence of thixotropy indicates a much improved dispersion as compared with the silane Z6076 and titanate LICA 12. 4.2.9 EFFECT OF PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROCESSES
Physical processes (e.g. crystallization) and chemical processes (e.g. polymerization) are known to modify the viscosity of a suspension with time. For a crystallization process, for example, Mistry and Warburton [156] have shown that if the solid phase concentration is small such that
SHEAR STRESS (Pa)
SHEAR STRESS (Pa)
in Water
Silane
Silane
Titanate UCA 12
SHEAR STRESS (Pa)
SHEAR STRESS (Pa)
in Water
Zircoaluminaie CAVCO UOD APG
SHEAR RATE (1/s)
Figure 4.11 Variation of shear stress vs. shear rate for suspension prepared with 20 vol% alumina in distilled water along with (1 wt% of filler) various surface modifiers as indicated. (Reprinted from Ref. 155.) Einstein's equation (4.1) holds and the crystals in the disperse phase increase with time, the relative viscosity can be estimated from the following expression. i?r(0 = l+a E (0o+*oO
(4.30)
where ^0 is the initial volume of the crystals, X0 the rate constant for volume increase of the crystals and t the time. Similarly, for concentrated suspensions, expressions like (4.6), (4.7) or (4.8) could be
SHEAR STRESS (Pa)
in Water
Zircoaluminate CAVCO MOD APG
DI Water
SHEAR RATE (1/s) Figure 4.12 Variation of shear stress vs. shear rate for suspensions prepared with 20vol% alumina in pH = 4 distilled water and with (1 wt% of filler) zircoaluminate. (Reprinted from Ref. 155.) used as first approximation with > appropriately being replaced by (/>0 H- K^t. 4.2.10 EFFECT OF AN ELECTROSTATIC FIELD When suspension particles are charged, the electroviscous effects that arise strongly influence the viscosity of the suspension as was shown by the experiments of Fryling [157] as well as Krieger and Eguiluz [158]. Pseudoplastic as well as dilatant behavior was observed in the data of Fryling [157] and when the electroviscous effects were at their maximum, the suspensions of Krieger and Eguiluz [158] were seen to have a yield stress. Electroviscous effects are essentially of three types first, second and third, and are discussed in detail by Conway and Dobry-Duclaux [159]. The combined effect of the three electroviscous effects on the viscosity of a suspension can be written as follows: fr = l + (*vl +**+**)*
(431)
where evl,ev2 and ev3 correspond to each of the three electroviscous effects. Separation of the constituent effects is difficult but was attempted by Dobry [16O]. The three effects are discussed below separately in order to appreciate the influence of each one of them on viscosity.
A. First electroviscous effect The first electroviscous effect is due to the electrostatic contribution of charged colloidal particles and its effect on the viscosity of a dilute suspension can be expressed in an extension of Einstein's equation (4.1) as follows: >/r = l + a E
(4.32)
Smoluchowsky [161] and Booth [162] both accounted for the increase in viscosity as due to the electrical double layer round a charged particle in an electrolyte and gave expressions for ev which included the specific conductivity of the electrolyte, the dielectric constant of the suspending medium, the electrokinetic potential of the particles with respect to the electrolyte and the radius of the particle (which was to be large in comparison with the thickness of the double layer for the validity of the expression). Experimental verification by Chan and Goring [163] of the expressions for ev provided by Smoluchowsky [161] and Booth [162] gives confidence for their use. B. Second electroviscous effect The second electroviscous effect is due to the electrostatic repulsion between particles approaching each other and is directly proportional to the square of the particle concentration. The essential feature about this effect is that it occurs at high concentrations of the suspensions (unlike the first electrostatic effects) and when there is an overlap of the double layer. The additional dissipative effects that appear as a result of the repulsion bring about an increase in the viscosity. Chan et al. [164] showed that an expression of the form (4.17) can be used to account for the second electroviscous effect but the coefficient a would then strongly depend on the distance between the centers of the particles and consequently, on the particle concentration. The second electroviscous effect is, at times, known to give rise to non-Newtonian behavior of a suspension as observed by Harmsen et al. [165]. C. Third electroviscous effect The third electroviscous effect is due to the change of shape of suspending particles when their electrical free energy is modified by ionization and the presence of neutral salts. If a polymer molecule can undergo ionization. e.g. by reaction with a base or by reaction with some other ion-producing substance, electrostatic repulsion between the like charges introduced on the polymer chain modifies the partial molecular free energy of the polymer in the solution. With polymeric
electrolytes, non-Newtonian viscosity behavior is not uncommon, particularly at low salt concentrations or high polyion concentrations and the effect is known to increase with degree of ionization.
4.3 EXTENSIONAL FLOW Addition of fillers during the spinning of synthetic textile fibers and the phenomenon of drag reduction with fibers inculcated an interest in the study of the rheological properties of suspensions in extensional flows. The first of such studies was that of Bachelor [166,167], who provided expressions for extensional viscosity of suspensions with long slender particles subjected to extension. The analysis of Batchelor [166] resulted in the following expression for suspensions which are so dilute that the velocity field surrounding one particle remains unaffected by neighboring particles. Thus, . L
=3
1+
2 ^ |"0.64 + ln2ra
1.659
+
+
/
1
YIl
^ ^| 9i^LT5Ti^ ^^ Hai^)jl
^
.
00 (433)
YIQ denotes the viscosity of the suspending medium, $ the volume fraction of the particles having an aspect ratio ra. It is obvious from equation (4.33) that particles with large aspect ratios would give large values of the extensional viscosity even at small concentrations of the particles. Batchelor [167] considered the effect of hydrodynamic interaction of parallel elongated particles in pure extension on the bulk stress. The governing equations were solved under the assumption that the effect on one particle by all the others could be replaced by a cylindrical boundary condition (cell model) and the geometry and concentration of the particles satisfied the following inequality. ra > d > I
(4.34)
where d = Hf/Df (Hf being the average distance between the fibers and Df the diameter of the fiber). The resulting expression for extensional viscosity was as follows:
i+
*•=^ [ yy
(435)
Equation (4.35) predicts the extensional viscosity only for high concentrations and does not give results akin to equation (4.33) at lower concentrations. However, at an intermediate concentration of the suspended particles, both theories are known to predict nearly identical results and hence in this region the extensional viscosity can be estimated by interpolation.
An expression similar to the above was obtained by Insarova [168] for the extensional viscosity of uniformly distributed rigid rods subjected to axially symmetric extension as follows:
*-^°H(*-£*-i)]
(436)
Insarova [168] showed by calculation that for a particle with an aspect ratio ra = 50, the viscosity is increased by a factor of 4 for 0 = 0.01 and by 80 for (/> = 0.1. Equation (4.36) has not been tested with experimental data but the equations of Batchelor [166,167] have been the subject of experimental verification. With the then available data of Weinberger [169], Batchelor [166,167] compared the bulk stress in a suspension of glass-fiber rods (with (/> = 0.013) in each of the liquids, 'Indopol' and 'Silicone' but found that the extensional viscosity was much higher than that predicted by the close-particle theory. Later, Weinberger and Goddard [170] noted that suspensions used in Weinberger's work neither satisfied the dilutesuspension nor the close-particle description, but fell somewhere between the two. Proper interpolation was shown to predict that the tensile stress was 8.4 times that of the suspending medium from Batchelor's theory and was found to be in good agreement with the values of 9 to 10 found by Weinberger and Goddard [170] through experiment. Mewis and Metzner [171] studied the extensional flow of fiber suspensions (with 0.001 < > < 0.01) and large aspect ratios (280 < ra < 1260). Experimental data showed that the extensional viscosities were independent of strain rate and up to 260 times larger than that of the suspending medium. The effect of particle concentration was as predicted by equation (4.35) proposed by Batchelor [167]. On the other hand, the effect of particle geometry was in close agreement with the theory only for lower values of ra like 282 and 586, but for ra = 1259 the experimental data were found to be about 30% lower than that predicted by Batchelor [167]. Kizior and Seyer [172] experimentally determined stress levels in extensional flow of suspensions with fibers having an aspect ratio of 340 and volume fraction of 0.001. It was found that the experimental value of the stress was higher than that predicted by Batchelor's theory. However, the dependence of stress on concentration and aspect ratio was well predicted by the theoretical expressions of Batchelor [167]. From the above experimental efforts, it can be concluded that sufficient evidence has been generated to verify the propriety of equations (4.33) and (4.35) given by Batchelor [166,167]. Equation (4.33) for dilute suspensions, equation (4.35) for close-particle distribution and
an interpolation between the two could predict the extensional flow behavior of suspensions of slender particles over a large range of particle concentration. However, the results of Batchelor [166,167] are valid only when the suspending medium is Newtonian. The entire body of literature which analyses the extensional flow of slender particles in non-Newtonian fluids goes to the credit of Goddard [173-175]. Goddard [173] derived a formula to describe the stress field for dilute suspensions of oriented slender fibers in a non-Newtonian fluid. The treatment was quite rudimentary but brought out an important result that particle-stress effect was considerably smaller in a shear-thinning non-Newtonian fluid compared to the Newtonian case, possibly due to tensile stiffening in the fluid itself. Qualitative agreement with the experimental data of Charrier and Rieger [176] was observed. A more sophisticated analysis of the same problem was presented by Goddard [174] using a general quasi-steady state rheological model for the suspending medium, with the assumption that in the near-field of the suspended particles the flow is shear-dominated and extends asymptotically to the extension-dominated flow in the far field. The conclusions of this analysis were the same as those arrived at earlier in Goddard [173]. The complex theoretical treatment of Goddard [173,174] are not included here. Results are available for the simplified case of the suspending medium being a power-law fluid in Goddard [175]. Goddard [175] carried out a qualitative comparison with the rheological data of Chan et al. [164] for simple shear and simple extension of polymer melts containing chopped glass fibers. It was seen that the agreement with the power-law theory was not satisfactory and even worse for the Newtonian case. Goddard concluded that the disagreement was not due to failure of the theory, but possibly because of lack of fiber alignment during experiments. Nicodemo et al. [177] were the first to show, experimentally, the spectacular reductions (at times by an order of magnitude) in the extensional viscosities of polymer solutions containing spherical particles (namely, glass microbeads) in contrast to solutions containing rod-shaped particles (namely, fibers), which are known to increase the extensional viscosities. The extensional viscosity of fiber suspension depends to a large extent on the orientation of the fiber and this has been the subject of study of a number of investigators (e.g. Taksermann-Krozer and Ziabicki [178], Bell [179], Goettler [180,181], Nicodemo et al. [182], Takano [183], Lee and George [184]). In polymer processing, as most of the flow takes place through converging dies, the study of the rheological properties in extensional flow and the orientation of the
polymer molecules and fiber are extremely important in order to control the quality of the end products. Despite the importance of extensional viscosity studies in filledpolymer processing it is unfortunate that the effects of various factors like size distribution of the fillers, nature of the surface, flocculation, etc. as in the case of shear viscosity (section 4.2), has not been studied at all. Only the effect of the shape of the filler on the extensional viscosity has been brought out by Nicodemo et al. [177]. A lot more research in this area is thus warranted. The main reason for the dearth of information in this area is probably due to the absence of a cheap and simple apparatus for the measurement of extensional viscosity. Most of the workers have had to design their own apparatus for determining extensional viscosities depending on the system to be measured and the facilities available.
REFERENCES 1. Carr, R. and Cokelet, G.R. (1981) Rheology of suspensions of normal and hardened erythrocytes and their mixtures, /. RheoL, 25, 67-82. 2. Cokelet, G.R. (1972) The rheology of human blood, in Biomechanics: Its Foundations and Objectives (eds Y.C. Fung, N. Perrone and M. Anliker), Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, pp. 63-104. 3. Cokelet, G.R. and Smith, J.H. (1973) The effect of concentric-cylinder viscometer gap size on the experimental rheological properties of human blood, Biorheology, 10, 51-56. 4. Dintenfass, L. (1973) On the possible liquid crystalline structures in artificial thrombi formed at arterial shear rates: effects of disease, proteins concentrations, and ABO blood groups, MoL Cryst. Liq. Cryst., 20, 239-66; (1982) On changes in aggregation of red cells, blood viscosity and plasma viscosity during normal gestation, Clinical HemorheoL, 2, 175-88; (1982) Haemorheology of cancer metastases: An example of malignant melanoma, survival times and abnormality of blood viscosity factors, Clinical HemorheoL, 2, 259-71. 5. Dintenfass, L., Jerdrzejczvk, H. and Willard, H. (1982) Photographic, stereological and statistical methods in evaluation of aggregation of red cells in disease: Part I: Kinetics of aggregation, Biorheology, 19, 567-77. 6. Dintenfass, L. and Fu-lung, L. (1982) Plasma and blood viscosities, and aggregation of red cells in racehorses, CUn. Phys. PhysioL Meas., 3, 293-301. 7. Evans, R.L., Kirkwood, R.B. and Opsahl, D.G. (1971) The dynamic viscosity of some human blood, Biorheology, 8,125-28. 8. Fu-lung, L. and Dintenfass, L. (1983) Effect of microrheology of blood on the apparent flow instability in a rotational viscometer, Biorheology, 20, 327-42. 9. Thurston, G.B. (1979) Erthrocyte rigidity as a factor in blood rheology: viscoelastic dilatancy, /. RheoL, 23, 703-19; (1979) Blood viscoelasticity and relaxation processes: influence of aggregation tendency, Symposium European, Hemorheologie et Pathologie, Nancy, France, 17-19 Oct.; (1979)
Rheological parameters for the viscosity, viscoelasticity and thixotropy of blood, Biorheology, 16,149-62. 10. Lightfoot, E.N. (1974) Transport Phenomena in Living Systems - Biomedical Applications of Momentum and Mass Transfer, Wiley, New York. 11. De Kee, D. and Turcotte, G. (1990) Viscosity of biomaterials, Chem. Enng Commun., 6, 273-82. 12. De Kee, D., Code, R.K. and Turcotte, G. (1983) Flow properties of timedependent foodstuffs, /. RheoL, 27, 581-604. 13. Lefebvre, J. and Sherman, P. (1977) Rheological properties of aqueous sunflower protein dispersions, /. Texture Stud., 8, 449-62. 14. Szczesniak, A.S., Loh, J. and Mannell, W.R. (1983) Effect of moisture transfer on dynamic viscoelastic parameters of wheat flour/water systems, /. RheoL, 27, 537-56. 15. Blanch, H.W. and Bhavaraju, S.M. (1976) Non-Newtonian fermentation broths: Rheology and mass transfer, Biotech. Bioeng., 18, 745-90. 16. Charles, M. (1978) Technical aspects of the rheological properties of microbial cultures, Adv. Biochem. Eng., 8,1-62. 17. Metz, B., Kossen, N.W.F. and Van Suijdam, J.C. (1979) The rheology of mould suspensions, Adv. Biochem. Eng., 11,103-56. 18. Kalousek G.L. (1973) A new instrument for measuring thixotropy, Cement Concrete Res., 3, 315-23. 19. Sacks, MD., Khadilkar, C.S., Scheiffele, G.W., Shenoy, A.V., Dow, J.H. and Sheu, R.S. (1987) Dispersion and rheology in ceramic processing. Adi?. Ceram., 21, 495-515. 20. Borghesani, A.F. (1988) Non-Newtonian flow behavior of coal-fuel oil suspensions, in Encyclopedia of Fluid Mechanics (ed. N.P. Cheremisinoff), Gulf Publishing, Houston, TX, Vol. 7, pp. 89-134. 21. Adams-Viola, M., Botsaris, G.D., Filymer, W.G., Jr., Glazman, Yu.M. and King, K.D. (1982) The effect of coal particle aggregation on the sedimentation and rheology of coal-oil mixtures, Colloids Surfaces, 4, 255-69. 22. Anderson, P.C., Veal, CJ. and Withers, V.R. (1982) Rheology of coal-oil dispersions, Powder Tech., 32, 45-54. 23. Castillo, C. and Williams, M.C. (1979) Rheology of very concentrated coal suspensions, Chem. Eng. Commun., 3, 529-47. 24. Darby, R. and Rogers, B.A. (1980) Non-Newtonian viscous properties of methacoal suspensions, AIChE /., 26, 310-12. 25. Davis, P.K., Muchmore, CB., Missavage, RJ. and Coleman, G.N. (1981) Rheological and pumping characteristics of ethacoal, /. Pipelines, 1, 139-44. 26. Munro, J.M., Lewellyn, M.M., Crackel, P.R. and Bauer, L.G. (1979) A characterization of the rheological properties of coal-fuel oil slurries, AIChE /., 25, 355-8. 27. Thurgood, J.R., Hanks, R.W., Oswald, G.E. and Youngblood, E.L. (1982) The rheological characterization of coal liquefaction preheater slurries, AIChE ]., 28, 111-16. 28. Veal, CJ., and Wall, D.R. (1981) Coal-oil dispersions - an overview, Fuel, 60, 873-6. 29. Erenrich, E.H. and Van Doren, R.E. (1977) Instrumental techniques for the rheological control of coatings, Paper presented at Pacific Paint OCCAA Convention, Canberra.
30. Heertjes, P.M., Smits, C.I. and Vervoorn, P.M.M. (1979) Some aspects of adsorption processes occurring on titanium dioxide particles, Prog. Organic Coatings, 7,141-66. 31. Hudson, N.E., Bayliss, M.D. and Ferguson, J. (1978) The rheology of pigment dispersions, Rheol Acta, 17, 274-87. 32. Saarnak, A. (1979) Characterisation of the interaction between pigments and binder solution using rheological measurements, /. Oil Col Chem. Assoc., 62, 455-60. 33. Dulik, D., Bernier, R. and Brauer, G.M. (1981) Effect of diluent monomer on the physical properties of bis-GMA-based composites, /. Dent. Res., 60, 983-9. 34. Vermilyea, S., Powers, J.M. and Craig, R.G. (1977) Rotational viscometry of a zinc phosphate and zinc polyacrylate cement, /. Dent. Res., 56, 762-7. 35. Vermilyea, S.G., Powers, J.M. and Koran, A. (1978) The rheological properties of fluid denture-base resins, /. Dent. Res., 57, 227-31. 36. Vermilyea, S.G., De Simon, L.B. and Huget, E.F. (1978) The rheological properties of endodontic sealers, Oral Surg., 46, 711-16. 37. Jacobsen, P.H., Whiting, R. and Richardson, P.C.A. (1977) Viscosity of setting anterior restorative materials, Brit. Dent. /., 143, 393-6. 38. Whiting, R. and Jacobsen, P.H. (1979) The evaluation of non-Newtonian viscosity using a modified parallel-plate plastometer, /. Mat. Sd., 14, 307-11. 39. Baker, F.S., Carter, R.E. and Warren, R.C. (1980) The rheological assessment of propellants, Paper presented at the 8th International Congress on Rheology, Naples, 1-5 Sept. 40. Chen, Y.R. and Hashimoto, A.G. (1976) Rheological properties of aerated poultry waste slurries, Trans. ASAE, 19, 128-33; (1976) Pipeline transport of livestock waste slurries, Trans. ASAE, 19, 898-902, 906. 41. Hashimoto, A.G. and Chen, Y.R. (1976) Rheology of livestock waste slurries, Trans. ASAE, 19, 930-4. 42. Brownell, W.E., Caso, G.B. and Braun, D.B. (1978) An additive to increase plastic strength, Amer. Cer. Soc. Bull, 57, 513-16. 43. Farooqui, S.I. and Richardson, J.F. (1980) Rheological behaviour of kaolin suspensions in water and water-glycerol mixtures, Trans. Inst. Chem. Engrs, 58,116-124. 44. Heath, D. and Tadros, Th.F. (1983) Influence of pH, electrolyte, and poly(vinyl alcohol) addition on the rheological characteristics of aqueous dispersions of sodium montmorillonite, /. Colloid Inter/. ScI, 93, 307-19; (1983) Influence of pH, electrolyte, and poly(vinyl alcohol) addition on the rheological behaviour of aqueous silica (aerosol) dispersions, /. Colloid Inter/. ScL, 93, 320-28. 45. Heywood, N.I. and Richardson, J.F. (1978) Rheological behavior of flocculated and dispersed aqueous kaolin suspensions in pipe flow, /. Rheol, 22, 599-613. 46. James, A.E. and Williams, D.J.A. (1982) Flocculation and rheology of kaolinite/quartz suspensions, Rheol Acta, 21,176-83. 47. Verreet, G. and Berlament, J. (1988) Rheology and non-Newtonian behavior of sea and estuarine mud, in Encyclopedia of fluid Mechanics (ed. N.P. Cheremisinoff), Gulf Publishing, Houston, TX, Vol. 7, pp. 135-49. 48. Cheremisinoff, N.P. (ed.) (1986) Encyclopedia of Fluid Mechanics, Vol. 5: Slurry Flow Technology, Gulf Publishing, Houston, TX.
49. Brenner, H. (1972) Suspension rheology, in Prog. Heat Mass Transfer (ed. W.R. Schowalter), Pergamon Press, Oxford. Vol. 5. 50. Batchelor, G.K. (1974) Transport properties of two-phase materials with random structure, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., 6, 227-55. 51. Jinescu, V.V. (1974) The rheology of suspensions, Int. Chem. Engg, 14, 397-420. 52. Jeffrey, DJ. and Acrivos, A. (1976) The rheological properties of suspensions of rigid particles, AIChE }., 22, 417-32. 53. Cheng, D.C-H. (1980) Viscosity-concentration equations and flow curves for suspensions, Chem. Indus., 403-6. 54. Mewis, J. (1980) Rheology of suspensions, in Rheology (eds G. Astarita, G. Marrucci and L. Nicolais), Plenum Publishing, New York, Vol. 1, pp. 149-68. 55. Russel, W.B. (1980) Review of the role of colloidal forces in the rheology of suspensions, /. RheoL, 24, 287-317. 56. Metzner, A.B. (1985) Rheology of suspensions in polymeric liquids, J. Rheol., 29, 739-75. 57. Darby, R. (1986) Hydrodynamics of slurries and suspensions, in Encyclopedia of Fluid Mechanics (ed. N.R. Cheremisinoff), Gulf Publishing, Houston, TX, Vol. 5, pp. 49-91. 58. Utracki, L.A. (1988) The rheology of two-phase flows, in Rheological Measurements (eds A.A. Collyer and D.W. Clegg), Elsevier Applied Science Publishers, London, 479-594. 59. Barnes, H.A. (1989) Shear-thickening ('Dilatancy') in suspensions of nonaggregating solid particles dispersed in Newtonian liquids, /. Rheol., 33, 329-66. 60. Adler, P.M., Nadim, A. and Brenner, H. (1990) Rheological models of suspensions, Adv. Chem. Eng., 15,1-72. 61. Nguyen, Q.D. and Boger, D.V. (1992) Measuring the flow properties of yield stress fluids, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., 24, 47-88. 62. Nielsen, L. (1977) Polymer Rheology, Marcel Dekker, New York. 63. Einstein, A. (1906) Eine neue bestimmung der molekuldimension, Ann. Physik., 19, 289-306. 64. Einstein, A. (1911) Ann. Physik., 34, 591-2. 65. Einstein, A. (1956) Investigations on the Theory of the Brownian Movement, Dover, New York. 66. Reiner, M. (1965) Rheologiya, Izd. Nauka, Moscow, p. 164. 67. Kurgaev, E.F. (1960) DoId. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 132, 392. 68. Rutgers, LR. (1962) Relative viscosity of suspensions of rigid spheres in Newtonian liquids, Rheol. Ada, 2, 202-10; (1962) Relative viscosity and concentration, Rheol Acta, 2, 305-48. 69. Hatshek, E. (1910) Kolloid Zh., 79, 301. 70. Andres, U.T. (1959) Gormi Zh., I, 65. 71. Happel, J. (1957) Viscosity of suspensions of uniform spheres, /. Appl. Phys., 28,1288. 72. Pokrovskii, V.N. (1968) Kolloid Zh., 30, 881. 73. Kambe, H. (1969) Int. Chem. Eng., 9,164-71. 74. Simha, R. (1952) /. Appl. Phys., 23,1020-4. 75. Thomas, D.G. (1965) Transport characteristics of suspension: VIII. A note on the viscosity of Newtonian suspension of uniform spherical particles. /. Colloid ScL, 20, 267-77.
76. Simha, R. and Somcynsky, T. (1965) /. Colloid Sd., 20, 278-81. 77. Ford, T.F. (1960) /. Phys. Chem., 64,1168-74. 78. Cengel, J.A., Faruqui, A.A., Finnigan, J.W., Wright, C.H. and Knudsen, J.G. (1962) AIChE /., 8, 335-9. 79. McGeary, R.K. (1961) /. Amer. Ceram. Soc., 44, 513-22. 80. De Brujin, H. (1951) Disc. Faraday Soc., 11, 86. 81. Clarke, B. (1967) Trans. Instn Chem. Engrs, 45, 251-6. 82. Guth, E. and Simha, R. (1936) Kolloid Z., 74, 266. 83. Vand, V. (1948) Viscosity of solutions and suspensions. I, /. Phys. Chem. Colloid Chem., 52, 277-99; (1948) II, /. Phys. Chem. Colloid Chem., 52, 300-14. 84. Saito, N. (1950) /. Phys. Soc. Japan, 5, 4. 85. Manley, R. St. J. and Mason, S. G. (1955) Can. J. Chem., 33,163. 86. Harbard, E.H. (1956) Chem. Ind.f 22, 491. 87. Alfrey, T., Jr. (1952) Mekhanicheskie Svoistva Viskopolimerov, Izd. Innostranoi Literaturi, Moscow, p. 479. 88. Arrhenius, S. (1887) Z. Phys. Chem., 1, 285. 89. Fikentscher, H. and Mark, H. (1930) Kolloid-Z. 49,135. 90. Bungenberg de Jong, H.G., Kruyt, H.R. and Lens, W. (1932) Kolloid-Beihefte, 36, 429. 91. Papkov, S. (1935) Kunststoffe, 25, 253. 92. Hauwink, R. (1937) Kolloid-Z., 79,138. 93. Brede, H.L. and De Boojs, J. (1937) Kolloid-Z., 79, 31. 94. Mullins, L. (1968) Kauchuk i Rezina, 7,10. 95. Feldman, D. and Boiesan, V. (1971) Mat. Plastics, 8, 536. 96. Eyring, H., Henderson, D., Stover. BJ. and Eyring. E.M. (1964) Statistical Mechanics and Dynamics, Wiley, New York, p. 460. 97. Mooney, M. (1951) The viscosity of a concentrated suspension of spherical particles, /. Colloid Sd., 6,162-70. 98. Severs, E.T. (1963) Rheology of Polymers, Reinhold, New York, p. 65. 99. Eilers, H. (1941) Die viskositat von emulsionen hochviskoser stoffe als funktion der konzentration, Kolloid Zh., 97, 313. 100. Frankel, N.A. and Acrivos, A. (1967) On the viscosity of a concentrated suspension of solid spheres, Chem. Engg ScL, 22, 847-53. 101. Marrucci, G. and Derm, M.M. (1985) On the viscosity of a concentrated suspension of solid spheres, Rheol Acta, 24, 317-20. 102. Chong, J.S., Christiansen, E.B. and Baer, A.D. (1971) Rheology of concentrated suspensions, /. Appl. Polym. Sd., 15, 2007-21. 103. Kataoka, T., Kitano, T., Sasahara, H. and Nishijima, K. (1978) Viscosity of particle filled polymer melts, Rheol. Acta, 17, 149-55. 104. Kitano, T., Kataoka, T. and Shirata, T. (1981) An empirical equation of the relative viscosity of polymer melts filled with various inorganic fillers, Rheol. Acta, 20, 207-9. 105. Poslinski, A.J., Ryan, M.E., Gupta, R.K., Seshadri, S.G. and Frechette, FJ. (1988) Rheological behavior of filled polymeric systems. I. Yield stress and shear-thinning effects, /. Rheol, 32, 703-35. 106. Poslinski, AJ., Ryan, M.E., Gupta, R.K., Seshadri, S.G. and Frechette, FJ. (1988) Rheological behavior of filled polymeric systems. II. The effect of a bimodal size distribution of particulates, /. Rheol., 32, 751-71.
107. Wildemuth, C.R. and Williams, M.C. (1984) Viscosity of suspensions modeled with a shear-dependent maximum packing fraction, Rheol. Acta, 23, 627-35. 108. Stamhuis, J.E. and Loppe, J.P.A. (1982) Rheological determination of polymer-filler affinity, Rheol Acta, 21,103-5. 109. Jeffrey, J.B. (1922) The motion of ellipsoidal particles immersed in a viscous fluid, Proc. Roy. Soc., A102,161-79. 110. Guth, E. (1936) Kollaid-Z., 74,147. 111. Guth, E. (1938) Phys. Rev., 53, 926A. 112. Pokrovskii, V.N. (1967) KoIl(M Zh., 29, 576. 113. Maschmeyer, R.O. and Hill, C.T. (1975) Trans. Soc. Rheol., 21,183-94. 114. Burgers, J.M. (1938) Second Report on Viscosity and Plasticity, Nordemann, New York, p. 113. 115. Mason, S.G. (1950) Pulp Paper Mag. Can., 51, 83. 116. Blankeney, W.R. (1966) /. Colloid ScL, 22, 324-30. 117. Simha, R. (1949) /. Res. Nat. Bur. Stand., 42, 409. 118. Brodnyan, J. (1959) Trans. Soc. Rheol, 3, 61-8. 119. Ziegel. K. (1970) /. Colloid Inter/. ScI, 34,185-96. 120. Hashin, Z. (1969) in Contributions to Mechanics (ed. D. Abir), Pergamon Press, Oxford. 121. Nielsen, L. (1970) /. Appl Phys., 41, 4626-7. 122. Ward, S.G. and Whitmore, R.L. (1950) Studies of the viscosity and sedimentation of suspensions. Part I: The viscosity of suspensions of spherical particles, Br. J. Appl. Phys., 1, 286. 123. Ting, A.P. and Luebbers, R.H. (1957) AIChE /., 3,111-16. 124. Moreland, C. (1963) Viscosity of suspensions of coal in mineral oil, Can. J. Chem. Engg, 41, 24. 125. Shaheen, E.I. (1971) Rheological study of viscosities and pipeline flow of concentrated slurries, Powder Tech., 5, 245. 126. Parkinson, C., Matsumoto, S. and Sherman, P. (1970) /. Colloid Inter/. ScL, 33,150-60. 127. Hsieh, H.P. (1978) Polym. Engg ScL, 18, 928-31. 128. Ward, S.G. and Whitmore, R.L. (1950) Br. J. Appl. Phys., 1, 325-8. 129. Goldsmith, H.L. and Mason, S.G. (1965) Proc. 4th Int. Congr. Rheol., Interscience, New York, p. 65. 130. Segre, G. and Silberberg, A. (1961) Radial particle displacements in Poiseuille flow of suspensions, Nature, 189, 209-10. 131. Segre, G. and Silberberg, A. (1962) Behaviour of macroscopic rigid spheres in Poiseuille flow, Parts 1 & 2, /. Fluid Mech., 14, 115-35,136-57. 132. Segre, G. and Silberberg, A. (1962) Non-Newtonian behavior of dilute suspensions of macroscopic spheres in a capillary viscometer, /. Colloid ScL, 18, 312. 133. Morrison, S.R. and Harper, J.C. (1965) Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundamentals, 4,176. 134. Jastrzebski, Z. (1967) Entrance effects and wall effects in an extrusion rheometer during the flow of concentrated suspensions, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundamentals, 6, 445-54. 135. Chapman, P.M. and Lee, T.S. (1970) Effect of talc filler on the melt rheology of polypropylene, SPE /., 26, 37-40. 136. Goel, D.C. (1980) Effect of polymer addition on the rheological properties of talc-filled polypropylene, Polym. Engg ScL, 20,198-201.
137. Ferraro, C.F. (1968) SPE /., 24, 74-8 (April). 138. Krieger, LM. and Dougherty, TJ. (1959) A mechanism to non-Newtonian flow in suspensions of rigid spheres, Trans. Soc. RheoL, 3,137-52. 139. Gillespie, T. (1966) /. Colloid ScL, 22, 554-62. 140. Fischer, E.K. (1970) Colloidal Dispersion, Wiley, New York, p. 154. 141. Govier, G.W. and Winning, M.D. (1948) AIChE Meeting, Montreal, Quebec. 142. Umeya, K. and Kanno, T. (1979) Effect of flocculation on the dilatant flow for aqueous suspensions of titanium dioxides, /. RheoL, 23,123-40. 143. Nicodemo, L., Nicolais, L. and Landel, R.F. (1974) Shear rate dependent viscosity of suspensions in Newtonian and non-Newtonian liquids, Polym. Engg ScL, 29, 729. 144. Nicodemo, L. and Nicolais, L. (1974) /. Appl. Polym. ScL, 18, 2809-18. 145. Kremesec, VJ. and Slattery, J.C. (1977) Trans. Soc. RheoL, 21, 469-91. 146. Highgate, DJ. and Whorlow, R.W. (1970) RheoL Acta, 9, 569-76. 147. Napper, D.H. (1977) Steric stabilization, /. Colloid Inter/. ScL, 58, 390-407. 148. Tadros, Th.F. (1982) Polymer adsorption and dispersion stability, in The Effect of Polymers on Dispersion Properties (ed. Th.F. Tadros), Academic Press, New York, pp. 1-37. 149. Eisenlauer, J., Killman, E. and Korn, M. (1980) Stability of colloidal silica (aerosil) hydrosols. II. Influence of the pH value and the adsorption of polyethylene glycols, /. Colloid Inter/. ScL, 74,120-35. 150. Tadros, Th.F. (1978) Adsorption of polyvinyl alcohol on silica at various pH values and its effect on the flocculation of the dispersion, /. Colloid Inter/. ScL, 64, 36-47. 151. Rubio, J. and Kitchner, J.A. (1976) The mechanism of adsorption of poly(ethylene oxide) flocculant on silica, /. Colloid Inter/. ScL, 57,132-42. 152. Sacks, M.D. and Khadilkar, C.S. (1983) Milling and suspension behavior of Al2O3 in methanol and methyl isobutyl ketone, /. Am. Ceram. Soc., 66, 488-94. 153. Sacks, M.D. (1984) Properties of silicon suspensions and cast bodies, Am. Ceram. Soc. Bull., 63,1510-15. 154. Morgan, RJ. (1968) A study of the phenomena of rheological dilatancy in an aqueous pigment suspension, Trans. Soc. RheoL, 12, 511-33. 155. Dow, J.H. (1992) PhD Thesis, University of Florida, Gainesville. 156. Mistry, D.B. and Warburton, B. (1971) RheoL Acta, 10,106-12. 157. Fryling, C.F. (1963) /. Colloid ScL 18, 713-32. 158. Krieger, LM. and Eguiluz, M. (1976) The second electroviscous effect in polymer lattices, Trans. Soc. RheoL, 20, 29. 159. Conway, B.E. and Dobry-Duclaux, A. (1960) in Rheology (ed. F.R. Eirich), Academic Press, New York, Vol. 3, pp. 83-120. 160. Dobry, A. (1950) /. Chim. Phys., 50, 507. 161. Smoluchowsky, M. (1916) Kolloid-Z., 18,190. 162. Booth, F. (1950) The electroviscous effect for suspensions of solid spherical particles. Proc. Roy. Soc., A203, 533-51. 163. Chan, F.S. and Goring, D.A. (1966) /. Colloid ScL, 22, 371-7. 164. Chan, Y., White, J.L. and Oyanagi, Y. (1977) Polym. ScL Eng. Report No. 96, University of Tennessee, Knoxville. May. 165. Harmsen, GJ., Schooten, J.V. and Overbeek, J.Th.G. (1953) /. Colloid. ScL, 8, 64-71.
166. Batchelor, G.K. (1970) Slender-body theory of particles of arbitrary crosssection in Stokes flow, /. Fluid Mech., 44, 419. 167. Batchelor, G.K. (1971) The stress generated in a non-dilute suspension of elongated particles by pure straining motion, /. fluid Mech., 46, 813-29. 168. Insarova, N.I. (1970) Inzh.-Fiz. Zh., 18, 347. 169. Weinberger, C.B. (1970) Extensional flow behavior of non-Newtonian fluids, PhD dissertation, University of Michigan. 170. Weinberger, C.B. and Goddard, J.D. (1974) Extensional flow behaviour of polymer solutions and particle suspensions in a spinning motion, Int. J. Multiphase Flow, 1, 465-86. 171. Mewis, J. and Metzner, A.B. (1974) The rheological properties of suspensions of fibres in Newtonian fluids subjected to extensional deformations, /. Fluid Mech., 62, 593-600. 172. Kizior, T.E. and Seyer, F.A. (1974) Axial stress in elongational flow of fiber suspension, Trans. Soc. Rheol., 18, 271-85. 173. Goddard, J.D. (1976) Tensile stress contribution of flow-oriented slender particles in non-Newtonian fluids, /. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mech., 1,1-17. 174. Goddard, J.D. (1976) The stress field of slender particles oriented by a nonNewtonian extensional flow, /. Fluid Mech., 78,177-206. 175. Goddard, J.D. (1978) Tensile behavior of power-law fluids containing oriented slender fibers, /. Rheol., 22, 615-22. 176. Charrier, J.M. and Rieger, J.M. (1974) Fibre Sd. Tech., 7,161. 177. Nicodema, L., De Cindio, B. and Nicolais, L. (1975) Elongational viscosity of microbead suspensions, Polym. Eng. ScL, 15, 679-83. 178. Takserman-Krozer, R. and Ziabicki, A. (1963) Behaviour of polymer solutions in a velocity field with parallel gradient. I. Orientation of rigid ellipsoids in a dilute solution. /. Polym. ScL, Al, 491-506. 179. Bell, J.P. (1969) Flow orientation of short fibre composites, /. Comp. Mat., 3, 244-53. 180. Goettler, L.A. (1970) Flow orientation of short fibers in transfer molding, 25th Annual Tech. Conf., SPI, Paper 14-A. 181. Goettler, L.A. (1974) Molding of oriented short-fiber composites, Report No. HPC-70-130, Monsanto/Washington University Association. 182. Nicodemo, L., Nicolais, L. and Acierno, D. (1973) Orientation of short fibers in polymeric materials resulting from converging flow, Ing. Ch. Ital., 9, 113-16. 183. Takano, M. (1973) Flow orientation of short fibers in rectangular channels, ARPA Report, HPC 73-165. 184. Lee, W.K. and George, H.H. (1978) Flow visualization of fiber suspensions, Polym. Engg ScL, 18,146-56.
Preparation of. filled
jr-
polymer systems
O
In context with the preparation of filled polymer systems, there are three terms, namely, compounding, blending and mixing, which are often synonymously or interchangeably used and though various researchers have defined these terms, one is at times faced with the dilemma of terminology [I]. In the present case, definitions of the terms are given as applicable to the subject matter and hence exclude any other connotations of the terms. Compounding is the term used for those cases wherein polymers are softened, melted and intermingled with solid fillers and other liquid additives to form filled polymer systems. Blending is defined as a process in which two or more components or ingredients are physically intermingled without engendering any significant change in the physical state of the components. The components are, normally, polymers to form polymer blends, and hence in the present context, will not be used to describe the intermingling of fillers with polymers. The word mixing is applied to both the processes of compounding and blending, and describes the process of intimate intermingling of polymers with fillers/additives or two polymers without any specific restrictions. It covers a broad spectrum of dispersion of various ingredients to form a homogeneous mixture on some definable small scale. 5.1 GOODNESS OF MIXING The important aspect in mixing is to evaluate the quality of mixtures [2] or the goodness of mixing [3]. The most straightforward method of characterizing the quality of the mixtures is to measure to what extent the desired properties have been attained. Industrial quality control follows that route whenever feasible. However, this requires a detailed
description of the structure of the mixture and to theoretically establish this, the spatial position of each ultimate minor particle in the matrix must be determined. It is often not possible to predict the exact path of individual ultimate particles during the mixing process because most compounding equipments achieve the mixed state randomly, though, of course, there are some in which mixing progresses at least in a partly ordered fashion. In the random mixed state there are more possible arrangements of the minor component than in the completely unmixed state. In the latter state the probability is unity and in the former case it is very large equal to 0
mixed
_ (N; + Nj)! ~ N;!Ni!
(5 1)
'
N; and N'2 are the number of ultimate particles of the major and minor component respectively. A very great number of possible random distributions have to be considered [4] to be the most uniform distribution which can be achieved with common random type compounding equipments as shown in Figure 5.1. From the inspection of Figures 5.1(d) and 5.1(e), it can be seen that in the case of filled polymer systems, this type of regular random state would undoubtedly be preferable to any other random state. In the case of small ultimate particles which cluster together to form large agglomerates (blobs), the clusters have to be broken up into ultimate particles (aggregates) and uniformly distributed by the dispersive mixing action. The random distribution of a component 'A' in a component 'B' is achieved if the probability of finding an ultimate particle of 'A' is the same at all points in the mixture and is equal to the volume fraction a of the component 'A' in the mixture. In the completely unmixed state as shown in Figure 5.1 (a), a sample of volume Vs will have a concentration of component A of either 1 or O. The probability to find XA = 1 is 'a' and to find XA = O is b, as shown in Figure 5.2 on the left-hand side. The mean is given by M=*
(5.2a)
°2 = d>
(5.2b)
and the variance as
The probability distribution for finding a particular level of concentration in a sample after drawing a great number of samples can be calculated [4] from the following expression
(a) THE COMPLETELY UNMIXED STATE.
O «1
COMPONENT: A,B VOLUME FRACTION: a,b ULTIMATE PARTICLE SIZE: a,0 Figure 5.1 Number of possible random distributions of fillers in a polymer matrix which can be achieved with common random type compounding equipments. (Reprinted from Ref. 4 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.)
STAUSTtCAL DEFINITION OF THE STATE OF MIXTURE.
THE COMPLETELY UNMIXED STATE. P(X*)
VOLUME OF CONCENTRATION OF COMPONENT A MEAN: M = a VARIANCE: 0*= a.b
SAMPLE StZE V5
THE COMPLETELY MIXED STATE. P(X*)
VOLUME OF'CONCENTRATION MEAN:^ = a OFCOMPONENTA VARIANCE:**= a.b^
Figure 5.2 Variation of the probability of filler distribution with its concentration in the polymer matrix. (Reprinted from Ref. 4 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.)
eXp
P(XA)=
/ 1(XA-^u) 2 N (~2 V
7(2^)
^
<W
where the mean is given by /* = a
(5.3b)
*2 = ^
(5.3c)
and the variance as
Again it can be seen that for a sample of the size of an ultimate particle, the variance and the probability are the same as for the completely unmixed state. On the other end of the spectrum is a sample of very large size, possibly a whole batch, in which case the measured concentration will always indicate that the sample is well mixed. Obviously, in order to make a statement about the quality of mix, series of varying sample sizes have to be analyzed. During each series N" samples of the same size are collected. Using equation (5.3c), the variance for the completely mixed state for each series can be calculated introducing the sample size for that serve. The actual mean concentration XA and the actual variance S2 can be calculated [4] from the measured values XA. as follows (Table 5.1) —
1
N
"
X
X A = xpE A« v
I=I
S2
2 = IM^XX-XA) V X
(5.4)
(5.5)
f=l
If the mixture has been properly sampled then XA should not be significantly different from a. The normal proportion test can be used to determine if any observed difference is significant. The test is applied by calculating the quantity
Z-^-M*
,5.6)
Numerous indices to quantify the extent of mixing have been proposed and these are reviewed by Fan and co-workers [5,6]. In general these are based on standard deviation S or the variance S2 of the composition of spot samples taken from the mixture. The simplest such index [7] is given by S _ (j Tn1=- or Tn1=(5.7) O o where a is the standard deviation of composition for a random
Table 5.1 Mean: XA = ^7]T X A/ ; Variance: S2 == ^L-JT(X*, = XA)2 A/". . . number of samples Significance of XA Significance of S2 _ (XA - a)-v/A/" chi-square test Z ~ S Mixing index Mixing index
Perfectly mixed
Completely unmixed
E 2
;
K «
c
4^4 <7 0 -t7
In^-InS 2 In al - In
1
o
Q
o-a>H)
or2, = a. b = a(1 - a) the variance of the completely unmixed state Source: Ref. 4 (reprinted with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA).
homogeneous mixture defined as a mixture in which the probability of finding a particle of a given component is the same at all the locations in the mixture and a is equal to ^/[a(l — a)/N'] for a binary number of mixture where a is the proportion of one component and N' is the number of particles in the sample [7]. The number of particles in the sample are often difficult to estimate and in that case, the value of N' may be taken as VJOL. The sampling of mixtures and treatment of results has been extensively reviewed by Weidenbaum [8] as well as by Hold [4] and may be referred to for better understanding. Different ways of characterizing the degree of mix by a mixing index based upon a2 and S2 have also been proposed [9]. They are summarized in Table 5.1. The chi-square test is the statistical test of significance used in comparing S2 with a2. The chi-square test can be used to determine whether the difference between S2 and a2 is significant indicating a deviation from a random mix or a deviation by chance [1O]. If the mixing index is plotted vs. the size of the sample, the size of the domains with nonuniform
composition and the degree of nonuniformity can be established from the graph. Two properties which are useful in adjudging the goodness of mixing are the scale and intensity of segregation. Scale of segregation is a measure of the average separation between regimes comprising the same component and may be correlated to the average striation thickness, which is the average distance between like interfaces in a mixture [U]. On other hand, intensity of segregation is a measure of concentration [U]. Danckwerts [3] defines the scale of segregation SL as the integral of the coefficient of correlation between concentrations at two points separated by a distance SL= f RQjdr Jo
(5.8)
The definition of the coefficient of correlation is given by the following equation N " _ _ £(XAj. -X A )(X;-X A )
(5 9) ^ =ATS2 ' where X A/ , XA. are the concentrations at two points at a distance r. The variance S2 is calculated from the concentrations at all points using equation (5.5). The coefficient of correlation R(r) ranges from 1 to —1. A value of 1 indicates that both points in each couple have the same concentration. The value —1 indicates that the concentration in one point is pure minor and in the other is pure major. The intensity of segregation is defined as follows:
I = -0 2 O
(5.10)
It expresses the ratio of the measured variance to the variance of a completely segregated system. The intensity of segregation as defined in equation (5.10) reflects to some extent 'gross uniformity' on a scale of examination reduced to the scale at which texture or local structure is being examined. Danckwerts [3] thus introduced a different method of characterizing texture and local structure. In Figure 5.3, the sample on the left-hand side has a large scale of segregation and unless the intensity of segregation, i.e. the difference in concentration between these areas is very low, the sample is poorly mixed. The specimen on the right-hand side shows a small scale of segregation: in this case a higher intensity of segregation can still be tolerated without classifying the state of mix as poor. This provides a good insight into the importance of the scale of
SCALE OF SEGREGATION:
INTENSITY OF SEGREGATION:
GROSS UNIFORMITY
SCALE OF EXAMINATION TEXTURE
LOCAL STRUCTURE Figure 5.3 Definition of the scale and intensity of segregation along with the scale of examination. (Reprinted from Ref. 4 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.)
examination in relation to the interpretation of the results of the examination. Large scale examination renders information about the gross uniformity of a mixture. With decreasing scale, information is gained about the texture and finally the local structure of a mixture. Gross uniformity is important in most mixtures. However, the degree of fineness in the texture that is needed is, of course, dependent upon the individual application requirements of the mixed material. In order to evaluate the texture, the size of the analyzed samples has to be reduced to the level which permits characterization of the texture significant to a specific application. On the other hand, the local structure has to be examined at the scale of the ultimate particles. Naturally, the local structure would depend upon the efficiency of the mixing action and also upon the compatibility of the materials. In summary, the process of mixing involves the breaking down of the individual components into smaller elements and then dispersion of the
elements of one component in the space occupied by the other [12], thereby reducing compositional non-uniformity. In the case of the filled systems, the process includes the breaking down of agglomerates, their separation and segregation, until a final random distribution is achieved of each component in the system. The purpose of mixing is to attain an acceptable degree of homogeneity or uniformity of composition, assessed through the appropriate scale of scrutiny, which is defined [11,13,14] as the minimum size of the segregation region that would cause the mixture to be imperfect for the intended purpose. It is thus reasonable to define the perfect admixture as the state in which no variations in composition or morphology are observed at the relevant closeness of examination. 5.2 MIXING MECHANISMS
Having discussed the various methods of characterizing the quality (uniformity) of a mixture, the next step is to find functional relationships between these quantitative measures of the quality of the mixture and the mixing process, the mixer geometry, operating conditions, properties and initial conditions of the components. Theoretically each ultimate minor particle has to be followed throughout the mixing process to establish the final spatial distribution and evaluate it by applying these measures of quality. During the movement of the particles in the mixing action, three basic types of motion can be encountered as shown in Figure 5.4: molecular diffusion; eddy diffusion (turbulent flow); convection. In a viscous polymer system, the influence of molecular and eddy diffusion is generally negligible, leaving forced convective flow as the main mixing process [9]. If convection causes (a) the movement of the melt elements and the solid fillers from one spatial location to another such that the interfacial area between them increases or (b) that solid filler particles are distributed throughout the polymer matrix without necessarily increasing interfacial area, then distributive mixing is said to have occurred. Distributive or simple mixing is induced by plug or bulk convection. Bulk convection can be random or ordered. Ordered bulk convection rearranges constant volumina in a well defined way, and the progress of mixing action can be predicted mathematically. In random bulk convection, chunks of material are randomly redistributed, and modeling the mixing action is for most cases not possible. Distributive mixing is basically defined as an operation which is employed to increase the randomness of the spatial distribution of the minor constituent within the major base with no further change in size of that minor constituent. Distributive mixing is influenced by the strain
CONVECTION PLUG (BULK) CONVECTION
LAMINAR CONVECTION
RANDOM ORDERED BULK BULK CONVECTION CONVECTION IMPROVES: GROSS UNIFORMITY TEXTURE LOCAL STRUCTURE
EXTENSIVE MIXtNG(STRAIN) LAMINAR, MIXING INTENSIVE, DISPERSIVE MIXING (STRESS)
MOLECULAR DIFFUSION
DISTRIBUTIVE SIMPLE MIXING
EDDY DiFFUStON NONEXISTENT
Figure 5.4 Various types of mixing mechanisms. (Reprinted from Ref. 4 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.)
imposed on the mixture. However, in the case of a viscoelastic polymer system containing agglomerated fine filler particles which show yield stress characteristics, the application of strain is necessary, but insufficient, to achieve mixing. The strain rate and hence shear stress imposed on the material determine the extent of mixing and this is known as dispersive mixing [9]. This type of mixing is accomplished by laminar convection through various types of flow: shear, extensional and squeezing. However, shear plays the major role during the mixing process and the main action occurs along streamlines. Dispersive mixing is basically defined as an operation which reduces the agglomerate size of the minor constituent to its ultimate particle size. During compounding of polymer melts with filler, it is the effect of the mixing action on the solid filler particle that achieves importance. Available research results for predicting the effect of a specific flow field on agglomerates indicates that there are a number of possible motions corresponding to the initial conditions of the velocity field and the shape of the particles. The motions are periodic and the resultant of
all the forces acting on the surface and their moments equal to zero. The periodic motion of the particles is necessary to maintain the forces and their moments in equilibrium. The forces create a stress distribution throughout the agglomerate which will result in the rupture of the agglomerate along a surface or surfaces where the stress exceeds the local cohesive forces between the ultimate particles. The breakdown of agglomerates in shear flow is described quantitatively by Tadmor and Gogos [9]. It has been shown that the maximum forces tending to divide a dumbbell shaped agglomerate in a fluid of viscosity rj is given by F max = ^yT1T2
(5.11)
where T1 and r2 are the radii of the two particles and y is the rate of change of shear experienced by the fluid, and occurs when the dumbbell axis is at an angle of 45° to the direction of shear. Thus improved mixing is achieved at higher shear stresses and, clearly, small filler particles are more difficult to separate than large filler particles, because the magnitude of the attracting forces increases with decreasing particle diameter. High shear stresses may be applied to nonreinforcing filler particles to achieve better dispersion. However, mixing of a polymer with a reinforcing fiber presents a different problem. In this case it is of importance not to break the fiber because only if the bond strength of the fiber with the matrix on both sides of a point of high stress is equal or greater than the strength of the fiber, is it possible to utilize the fiber optimally. Hence, stress levels will have to be maintained reasonably low to prevent drastic fiber breakage. Another point of importance that must be borne in mind is that dispersive mixing is laminar or streamline mixing. The streamlines never cross during the laminar flow of the mixing action. Hence initial nonuniformities of the distribution of the minor component across the streamlines of the mixing flow can only be eliminated if laminar mixing is combined with plug convection. Viewing mixing as distributive or dispersive is clearly an oversimplification when applied to practical mixing problems since both actions will occur simultaneously. Homogeneity will have been achieved when both the dispersive elements and the distributive elements of the mixing have achieved a fluctuation in average composition below a certain fixed and acceptable level. However, before either distributive mixing or dispersive mixing can effectively take place, there is an initial step in which the originally separate ingredients form a coherent mass. This process is known as incorporation or wetting. Filler particles, especially those of submicron size, are available in an aggregated form. At times, this is done on purpose by the suppliers
because agglomerates are easier to handle, are dustless, and are therefore less hazardous to health. However, due to a variety of forces such as van der Waals, electrostatic, liquid bridges, etc. [15] it is often the strong filler bonds that tend to hold finely divided particles together. In the preparation of filled polymer system, difficulties arise in dispersing the fillers in the polymer matrix due to the basic incompatibility between filler and polymer. Polymers, being organic in nature, have surface tensions that are quite different from those of most inorganic fillers. They have, thus, a natural tendency to resist wetting of the filler during compounding. Hence, during preparation of filled systems, there is certainly a possibility for increased agglomeration in this non-wetting environment, as well as an enhanced probability of forming microvoids around particle clusters. In summary, compounding of fillers with polymers basically involves four steps - the initial incorporation, then wetting, followed by deagglomeration and finally distribution of the fillers within the polymer matrix. This is achieved through the use of a variety of compounding techniques that are discussed below. 5.3 COMPOUNDING TECHNIQUES There are a number of types of compounding equipment that can potentially carry out the compounding of fillers with polymers. Compounding has traditionally been carried out on two-roll mills, internal mixers and nowadays single and twin screw extruders. The extruders are being increasingly adopted as a means of giving a consistent product in a readily usable form, i.e. pellet or sheet. The several techniques available to produce filled polymer materials vary greatly in their methods and results. Extensive experience with pre-compounded glass-reinforced polymers reveals that the physical properties of the product vary significantly (Table 5.2) with various compounding techniques [16-19]. What one should look for in a compounding machine and what one should consider when setting up a compounding operation are very important to understand. 5.3.1 SELECTION CRITERIA
When selecting a compounding equipment, careful consideration should be given to the size of the unit required. The full cost at the maximum daily or hourly production rate must be established. It should be borne in mind that use of several small equipment units rather than one large unit will usually increase labor costs and initial investment. Bearing in mind process economics, equipment availability and preference, the decision as to what compounding technique and what
Table 5.2 Effect of compounding on mechanical properties of fiber glass-filled polypropylene Compounding technique3
wt % glass fiber Type of fibers Tensile strength (psi) Flex, modulus (m psi) Izod impact ft Ib/in notched Heat defl. temp. C 264 psi (0F)
Single- Continuous Twin-screw Twin-screw Twin-screw Twin-screw mixer compounder compounder compounder compounder screw 1 extruder 4 2 3 25 23 25 25 25 25 1/8 in chopped glass
1/4 in chopped glass
Roving
Roving
Roving
1/8 in chopped glass
6100
4700
4900
5800
8000
8000
580
460
600
550
550
550
1.45
0.7
0.9
1.1
1.2
1.3
264
153
203
184
268
266
% of fibers smaller than 0.5mm Remarks
29 Glass was fed into the feed section
Screw with Moderate very strong screw after sections addition of after glass addition of glass
Mild screw after addition of glass (No. 14)
Source: Ref. 16 (reprinted with kind permission from American Chemical Society,' Washington DC, USA).
compounding equipment to utilize often centers around the question of how much shear is required. Compounding of non-reinforcing fillers usually requires the highest degree of dispersion. Therefore, equipment should be able to generate high shear stresses to separate the agglomerates, particularly since these fillers usually have very small particle sizes. In compounding reinforcing fillers, the opposite approach is taken as low shear compounding must be used to prevent damage to the fillers. The main consideration is to wet the filler uniformly, devolatilize and discharge. Each material formulation presents a distinct problem. It is important to know how sensitive the compound and/or compounding ingredients are to temperature. The need to control or change the temperature and pressure during compounding should be considered. Purchase of light-
duty equipment should not be overlooked if the material will be dispersed at a high temperature. Also, thought should be given to the materials which will come in contact with the final product. When dealing with glass fibers, abrasion or corrosion of the compounding equipment plays a substantial role in economics. Although a product may not be contaminated by plain steel, a polished stainless steel unit is easier to clean. Labour that is saved may more than justify the additional cost of a stainless steel unit. Other constructions such as the use of high manganese steel may also be considered. The flexibility of the unit is also worth a good look. Can the compounding equipment be readily cleaned to change from one product to another and adapt to future production demands? Thus, the simplicity, accuracy and adaptability of the compounding process are important. The equipment for compounding fillers and polymers must fulfil the following requirements: (a) provide steady-state running conditions, (b) give reproducibility of processing conditions, (c) have ease of cleaning and (d) show versatility to adapt to new formulations. The equipment has to be chosen with care to ensure that correct product properties are achieved while no undesirable effects are introduced. Proper selection of compounding equipment and optimizing equipment parameters can substantially increase the mechanical properties of the final product. To achieve optimum material quality, the equipment for compounding fillers into a polymer must be capable of performing some of the following process tasks: 1. Incorporation and homogenization of fillers without exceeding degradation temperatures; 2. Generation of sufficiently high internal shear stresses to facilitate good dispersion of non-reinforcing fillers; 3. Provision of uniform shear stress to each filler particle at any heat history; 4. Provision of short and uniform residence time distribution to minimize heat history; 5. Provision of precise temperature control over the process to ensure narrow temperature distribution throughout the process and at discharge, again to regulate and minimize heat history. Using the above discussed factors as the criteria for analysis, the processor can select either a separate or in-line system, whichever is most efficient for his needs. Each has its merits and each its limitations. A batch system may be considered more flexible since it need not be tied in with other in-line equipment, but, on the other hand, batch to batch variations, for whatever reason, may not be acceptable in the final product. A continuous system should give a consistent product, but to
be fully effective it must have the back-up of reliable feeding and takeoff equipment. Some of the factors which need to be considered in the choice of machinery have been dealt with; the various categories of machine available and the important features of each category [20-32] are discussed next. 5.3.2 BATCH MIXERS
A. Open mills The mixing mill predates all the other mixing devices [21]. Originally many mixing operations were carried out on two- or three-roll open mills [2O]. As shown in Figure 5.5, it consists of two counter-rotating differential speed rolls with an adjustable nip and imposes intense shear stresses on the material as it passes the nip. The major component, i.e. the polymer, is first melted by the introduction of heat to the rolls and from the shearing action between the rolls. Once the polymer is melted, fillers and other additives are introduced. Extensive mixing takes place at the entrance of the nip due to extensional flow. Intensive (dispersive) mixing is accomplished in the nip. To achieve homogenization some means of lateral mixing of the banding action must be included. There is little transverse mixing and thus constant operator attention is needed to displace the strip transversely. Folding of the sheet by the operator prior to reintroduction to the milling action takes care of a random plug flow distributive mixing. This method allows very good temperature control of the product since the rolls can be cooled or heated and they present a very large surface area to the polymer system. The region of high shear is very
NIP
"BANDING' ACTION
Figure 5.5 Schematic diagrams of a two-roll open mill showing the banding action and nip. (Reprinted from Ref. 20.)
small avoiding large temperature build-up. The degree of dispersion obtained with such a system can be very high. The two-roll mill is a mixer ideally suited to the processing of high viscosity materials and was used by Birchall et al. [33] to produce very high solids content moldable cement pastes. Although still available for use, this type of system would not be considered for anything but very specialist operations. Obvious disadvantages arise from the open nature of the operation, difficulty in obtaining an initial melt and initial incorporation of pigments and fillers, giving long cycles. The system is inevitably dirty and it is difficult to achieve a uniform product. B. Internal mixers The internal mixer too is among the oldest members of the mixer family. The cross section of such a mixer is shown in Figure 5.6. It has adopted the open mill mixing principle but has a completely enclosed mixing chamber in which two rotors are mounted. The rotors are sealed at each end to avoid leakage of material from the chamber. The internal mixer is generally a very high powered machine with drives up to 300OkW for a machine with 600 litre mixing chamber [2O]. Maximum capacity is about lOOOlb/batch, and depending upon the material to be mixed, production rates can be as high as 40 batches/hr. Three different mixing actions take place in the internal mixer [21]: intensive or dispersive mixing around the tips of the rotor blade; extensive mixing due to simple shear flow and extensional flow between the chamber walls and the cylindrical portions of the rotors and in the entrance region to the narrow gaps between rotor tip; and distributive mixing due to random plug convection, as a result of the interaction between the two rotor tips. The rotors can be fully intermeshing in which case they must obviously rotate at identical speeds, or non-intermeshing when, as on a two-roll mill, friction ratios (generally 1.3 to 1) can be applied. The speed of the rotors can be changed and even varied during the mixing cycle. It can be lowered for a certain period of time to cool the material down and then increased again to restart the mixing. The residence time of the material in the mixer, for instance, can be changed by changing the cycle time. Cycle times as low as 2-3 minutes are claimed and with use of refrigerated cooling still shorter times may be made possible. The amount of material put into the chamber can be varied to change the intensity of mixing and the cycle can be interrupted to add material at times which are most favorable to obtain optimum results. An internal mixer is never operated completely full of material, though pressure is maintained in the mixing chamber by means of a piston or
Figure 5.6 Cross-sectional view of an internal mixer. (Reprinted from Ref. 21 with kind permission from John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, USA.)
ram. It is found that by increasing ram pressures certain polymers can be completely massed even without heating to rotors or chamber. One of the earlier shortcomings of the internal mixer system when used for polymers was that of the single mass form of discharge, which was difficult to handle. Nowadays effective dump extruders are employed which can accommodate up to three batches from the mixer to give a continuous product through some form of pelletizing system. These dump extruders can be fitted with screens for elimination of agglomerates or foreign matter, and venting ports for removal of volatiles. One of the problems inherent in an internal mixer is that of batch to batch variation in the product. However, accurate automatic weighing
Table 5.3 Advantages and disadvantages of the internal mixer Advantages Versatility of operations Generally good temperature control Robust machines Relatively simple to operate Short mixing times Disadvantages High capital cost High and uneven power load Batch to batch variations dependent on accurate feeding and process control Rapid temperature rise needs good control Source: Ref. 20.
and dosing devices minimize changes in formulation, while automatic cycle control operating on parameters such as temperature, time or power input can reduce mixing variations. In fact, the internal mixer can be incorporated into a continuous flow of production by complete automation and buffering of its pulsating output. The advantages and disadvantages of the internal mixer are summarized in Table 5.3. The three most common internal mixers available are those of Parrel Bridge (Banbury), Frances Shaw (Intermix), and Guix. The internal mixer is certainly a versatile equipment and its operation can easily be adapted to a wide variety of mixing problems. Prime applications are for rubber and PVC compounding. These equipments are also being used for processing polyolefins, ABS, and polystyrene, along with thermosets such as melamines and urea. In the tire industry which faces the most difficult mixing problems, this type of mixer is still practically the only accepted mixing device. The tire industry has accepted the fact that the batch type mixer will not be replaced by a continuous mixing device in the near future, especially since the radial ply tire came into being, because this tire requires very tough types of rubber. The same is not the case as far as the plastics industry is concerned. In fact, predictions made several years ago that the batch type mixer will disappear and be replaced by continuous mixing equipment has come true in the filled polymers industry. Some of the continuous mixing devices are discussed below. 5.3.3 CONTINUOUS COMPOUNDERS
To meet the present demands for higher product quality and uniformity, combined with higher volume requirements, continuous
compounding equipments are required [17]. In continuous compounding systems, variation between batches is eliminated and the possibilities of human error are minimized. Because of economics and the large volume requirements of filled polymers, continuous systems are usually preferred. Any efficient processing system will allow the compounder to operate economically at high volume, and continuous compounding systems, being more efficient than batch systems, have capacities of 3000kg/hr and higher [16]. The two essential elements in a successful continuous system are absolute control over residence time and residence time distribution Continuous compounding and mixing [23,24] is accomplished by a variety of machines ranging from single-screw to twin screw extruders with variations in design and additional equipment units to achieve a range of end products. The type of compounder or mixer chosen depends upon the specifications and properties required of the end product, volume requirements, overall economics, and whether the compounding is done in-house or by a custom compounder. The basic functions of any compounding extruder are to melt the polymer and to introduce a closely controlled amount of shear energy into the melt to properly disperse and distribute additives or fillers. A. Conventional single screw extruders The simplest form of continuous compounding equipment is the single screw extruder [20,25]. The single screw extruder has been used for many years in polymer forming operations. The advantages and disadvantages of the single screw extruder are given in Table 5.4. There is much to be said for the mechanical simplicity of such machines, where motor drive can be transmitted through a straightforward gear box designed to accept the high thrust forces generated. Table 5.4 Advantages and disadvantages of the single screw extruder Advantages Mechanically fairly simple Relatively easy to operate Capable of high pressure generation Disadvantages Lack of positive conveying characteristics Limited compounding and homogenizing capabilities Large machines with long L/D Source: Ref. 20.
In the single screw extruder, a series of unit operations combine to transform the solid polymer in pellet or granular form at room temperature to a molten mass at elevated temperatures and further drive the mass at sufficiently high pressures into downstream shaping devices. The sequence of events is accomplished by different sections of the screw, namely, the feed, melting and metering zones. The polymer pellets or granules (virgin or sometimes in combination with regrind of scrap) are normally fed to the extruder throat through a conical hopper. The hopper geometry, the height of the fill and the physical properties of the particulate solids dictate the rate of delivery of solids to the feed zones of the extruders as well as the pressure under the hopper. The feeding through the hopper relies on the influence of gravity as well as the interparticle and particle/wall friction forces for the rate at which the material is picked up at the extruder feed throat. At times there are aberrations such as arching, piping and funneling flow in the hopper because of which the feed is improper and uncontrolled. Feeding by hopper is at times referred to as 'flood feeding7 as against 'starve feeding' which occurs when material is metered into the extruder feed throat by special feeding devices at controlled rates. Single screw extruders [9,10,34] are pumps that convey the material by a combination of pressure and drag flows. The operation of a single screw extruder relies on the frictional forces between the polymer and the barrel to push the polymer forward. When the ratio of polymer/ barrel friction vs. polymer/screw friction is low, then the polymer will adhere to the screw and simply rotate with it, resulting in no forward motion. If the ratio is high enough, then forward motion will occur. The lack of positive displacement characteristics means that the machines are far from self wiping. The section which is downstream of the feed zone is the melting zone. When frictional forces are present, their energy becomes apparent as heat, resulting in increased product temperatures. This effect assists the melting process, which is enhanced by pressure generation in the screw. At times, very large temperature differentials are generated between melt and unmelt. In an extreme, the region of unmelt may be surrounded by low viscosity melt and effectively insulated from the thermal or shear energy of the screw. The actual melting process in a single screw extruder is fairly well understood [34-47], and a good understanding of the extruder action too has been developed due to theoretical and computer modeling [48-51]. It is now widely accepted that, in a cold feed extruder, melting occurs at the barrel and screw surfaces and a melt pool accumulates on the leading edge of the extruder screw fight (see Figure 5.7). Melting of the solid bed takes place slowly over a length equivalent to several
BAKEtEL SDlPACE
FUMOP MOLTEN POLYMER
SOIJD MELT INTERFACE
SOLED
KLIOHT
CIRCULATORY FLOWOF PREVIOUSLY MELTED POLYMER
SCREW
Figure 5.7 Melting process in the conventional single screw extruder. (Reprinted from Ref. 29 with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers Inc., Connecticut, USA.)
screw diameters and the rate of melting is dependent on heat transfer across the relatively small interfacial area with the melt. Eventually the solid bed breaks up and complete melting is finally achieved. This gradual process often results in very long screws and length to diameter ratios as high as 30:1 are not uncommon. Single screw sizes may range from 0.06m to 0.2m in diameter with lengths of 20 to 42 times length to diameter ratio. The fact that the process is gradual does mean that different regions of polymer within a flight experience different thermal histories. Difference in heat history often can lead to non-uniformity of the product. The conventional single screw extruder is designed mainly to melt material and to pump it against pressure [21]. The flow rate Q with which the material is transported is expressed by the following equation Q = ON-P^
(5.12)
The extruder is also capable of mixing because of the shear action which moves the material along a spiral path through the screw channel. This happens in the metering zone which is downstream of the melting zone. However, the degree of mixing in the conventional single screw extruder is somewhat limited owing to the fact that the
movement of the material through the extruder and the mixing action are derived from the same shearing action. In the conventional single screw extruder, fluid flows through a channel of approximately rectangular cross section with either variable or constant depth. The two sides of the rectangle are the leading and trailing surfaces of the flight, the bottom corresponds to the screw root, and the top is the inside surface of the barrel. Fluid mechanical analyses are based on a frame of reference fixed to the channel. For shallow channels, curvature effects can be neglected and the channel visualized as being uncoiled and laid flat with barrel as an infinite flat plate moving diagonally across the channel at an angle defined by the angle of the helix. Unlike the more complex extruders,the helical flow behavior in single screw machines is well characterized [52] and well documented in books [34,53]. Fluid is conveyed forward along the channel as a result of the drag flow induced by the axial component of the relative motion between the barrel and the screw, while a pressure flow builds up in the reverse direction due to the resistance offered by the die at the outlet. The axial flow largely determines the extruder throughput, but it is the transverse flow, generated by the transverse component of barrel rotation, that is primarily responsible for mixing. An element of fluid traces a helical path as it undergoes deformation in its passage through the channel; the helix angle at any point being determined by the local velocity field. Simplified velocity profiles based on the work of Carley et al [54], which neglects end effects at the flights, provide the basis for most theoretical analyses of mixing in extruders. Although most materials to be mixed in extruders exhibit non-Newtonian behavior, Newtonian behavior is frequently assumed for simplicity. Extensions to account for purely viscous non-Newtonian effects are straightforward [34,55] and few significant qualitative differences in mixing behavior are observed. Mohr et al. [2] were the first to theoretically investigate the mechanism of mixing in extruders; they assumed an inverse linear relation between the striation thickness and strain by analogy to large unidirectional shear. McKelvey [10] used an average strain as a measure of mixing. Pinto and Tadmor [56] extended this approach to account for the distribution of strains experienced by different fluid elements. Bigg and Middleman [55] obtained similar relations for power law fluids, and Erwin [57] presented modifications to account for the effect of mixing sections. In the mixing aspect of the extrusion process, velocity distributions and, subsequently, stress distributions are the most important parameters [18]. The stress distribution inside the screw channel determines the degree of mixing which can be achieved (Figure 5.8). The mixing action in the extruder channel occurs only on the portion of
VELOCITY DISTRIBUTION OF DOWN CHANNEL FLOW
STRESS DISTRIBUTION OF DOWN CHANNEL FLOW
VELOCITY DISTRIBUTION OF CROSS FLOW
STRESS DISTRIBUTION OF CROSS FLOW
Figure 5.8 Velocity and stress distributions in single screw extruders. (Reprinted from Ref. 18 with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers Inc., Connecticut, USA.)
the material which passes over the flights as it alone is exposed to the shear action. The velocity distribution in the extruder channel in the down channel and the cross channel direction result in the spiral path of the material. The material does not back flow even at higher back pressures, but rather moves back and forth in a spiral fashion over a relatively short distance. Due to the spiral motion, the residence time in the extruder is reasonably uniform but the mixing action is very limited. By observing the velocity and stress profile of down channel and cross flow, it can be seen that the zero shear point exists inside the channel. In this area, very little or no mixing will occur. This has been confirmed by actual experiments. Further, the lack of effective reorientation of the material elements at the flights causes the bulk of the interfacial area to be oriented parallel to the channel bottom in a relatively short downstream distance,
regardless of the initial orientation. Consequently, the mixing achieved in single screw extruders is generally poor [58]. Efforts to improve the mixing efficiency of the single screw extruder have, therefore, never ceased. B. Modified single screw extruders When mixing is required then variations to the basic machine are usually considered. This involves installing mixing devices which would shift the zero shear stress point to various locations in the screw channel and hopefully achieve an adequate mix, if the equipment has a sufficient processing length. Most of these devices are designed to break down the smooth flow of material through the extruder, thereby mixing the melt with unmelt to give a more uniform distribution of polymer. (Figure 5.9). The devices being used include specialized screws for use with mixing flights or pins along with variations in pitch and screw form designed to break down the normal melt pattern or smearing sections where the polymer stream is forced over narrow gaps in the screw. There are a number of single-screw systems available with improved mixing devices such as the EVK, the fluted screw, the Maillefer type and others, which improve the mixing efficiency of the flow by redistribution of streamlines and reorientation of the intermaterial area at the expense of only a small increase in power requirements. In the simplest mixing device consisting of mixing pins, each mixing pin divides the helical flow into two streams, which are again combined into one upon passing the pin. This leads to growth of the interfacial area upon the division and combination of flow and introduces further velocity gradients, thereby increasing the total strain on the material. In the patented EVK screw design, material distributing elements are installed over the whole length of the screw which ensure an homogeneous temperature distribution. The screw length and shearing clearance requirement, however, vary depending on the material to be processed and the type of filler used. Wherever the same material formulation is run continuously without any major changes, the system performs quite well. In the fluted screw design, the barrier-type restrictions basically introduce narrow, albeit short, gaps through which all the melt elements are forced to pass at high shear stresses. This brings in some level of dispersing action besides reorienting the interfacial area, redistributing the streamlines and increasing the imposed total strain. These barriers may take different forms. A simple form is the dams or series of dams of almost the full channel height welded across the channel at selected locations. The potential problems with the fluted
Parallel interrupted mixing flights
Mixing pins
Ring barrier type
Union carbide fluted mixing section barrier type
Undercut spiral barrier type Figure 5.9 Mixing section designs in single screw extruders. (Reprinted from Ref. 25 with kind permission from The Institution of Chemical Engineers, Rugby, UK.)
screw are the hold-up of the material and dead spots [59,6O]. These can be minimized by proper selection of the helix angle, tapering the inlet channel to zero depth and by reversing the depth profile in the outlet channel. In the Maillefer type screw design, there is a spiral barrier or secondary screw flight extending over the entire length of the modified section of the screw. The mass and force balances across the Maillefer type screw are available [61] and can be used to estimate the increase in power requirements due to this modification. Additional barriers or flights may be introduced to split the flow into two or more streams, which in the limit arrives at a series of longitudinal grooves or flutes spread around the circumference of a cylinder. Static mixers, i.e. those which are motionless and do not contain any moving parts, may be incorporated into single screw extruders between the screw and the die in order to introduce distributive mixing. A review of the various types of static mixers, their mixing characteristics and performance is available [62]. They consist of a string of alternating right and left handed helical elements fixed in a tubular housing which helps in splitting and recombination of streams, resulting in a predicted increase in the number of striations. The energy for mixing is derived from the pressure loss incurred as the melt flows through the static mixer. On account of the substantial pressure drop introduced by a battery of these mixing elements, they have restricted use in filled polymer melt systems especially those with higher loading and high viscosities. Many different modifications of the geometry of the single screw extruder have been contrived (all of which are not described herein) but even then, the achievable level of dispersion of fillers is limited. Improvement in filler dispersion can be achieved only by powerful shear forces. If the speed is increased to intensify mixing, the output increases at the same time, whereby back pressure control is lost but, more importantly, the energy input to the polymer due to the viscous shear forces rises even more rapidly and can lead to excessive melt temperatures. It is this heat build-up which eventually limits screw speeds to even as low as 100-150 rpm. In summary, the limited compounding and homogenizing ability of single screw extruders usually restricts their application to straightforward melting and extrusion operations but use of mixing devices can extend their range. Their favorable economics makes them attractive for low volume compounding jobs especially for filled systems of mainly commodity plastics [63]. For tougher applications, such as compounding fillers with engineering polymers at low as well as high loadings, single screw kneaders and twin screw extruders are more ideally suited.
C. Single screw kneaders This form of continuous compounding equipment may appear as a variation of a single screw extruder. But truly it is not and hence not included in the category of modified single screw extruders, because of the radically different mixing action in it [27,64]. In this single screw compounding equipment, various types of protrusion, grooves or profiles are built into the barrel with corresponding elements along the flights of the screw in the particular section known as the 'kneading section' as shown in Figure 5.10. This induces dispersive mixing as the material passes repeatedly through the high shear stress zones in the narrow gaps formed by the interrupted screw flights and the kneading teeth on the barrel (Figure 5.11). The mixing action is unique in that the rotational motion gets superimposed by reciprocating motion, thereby giving a kneading effect to the melt. This results in a good dispersion of fillers in the polymer system even at relatively low shear rates, thus allowing good processing control for temperature sensitive materials. The kneading action is illustrated in Figure 5.12. It can be seen that the kneading teeth wipe off all the corresponding flanks of a flight during one full turn, and the material thus gets subjected to high shear stresses in the small gap between the flight flank and the barrel teeth, thereby giving good dispersive mixing. As a consequence of the good mixing action such extruders are generally only one half or even onethird of the length of conventional single screw units. Further, since the unit does not generate high pressures, when pelletized product is required, the kneader is generally coupled to a single screw extruder to pump the polymer up to die pressures. COOLED SOLIDS CONVEYIbTG SECTION
ENEADINGTEEIH FEED SCBEW ENEAD]NQ SCREW
SCREW FLIGHTS
ZONES
Figure 5.10 Schematic diagram of a single screw kneader. (Reprinted from Ref. 23 with kind permission from Gulf Publishing Co., Houston, Texas, USA.)
ISPLTT BARREL 2HEATJNGJACKET 3ENEADttJGTOOTH 4 SCBEW FLIOET SNAKROWQAP 6 CLAMPING BAR
Figure 5.11 Cross-sectional view of a single screw kneader. (Reprinted from Ref. 20.)
Typical examples of the single screw kneader are the Buss Kokneader and the Baker-Perkins Ko-kneader.
D. Twin screw extruders Twin screw extruders evolved as a result of the desire to overcome some of the limitations of single screw extruders [65]. They are the most expensive mixers per kilogram of output. The advantages of twin screw extruders are listed in Table 5.5. The term 'twin screw extruder' is basically a generic term but to treat all twin screw machines in one general category is truly not correct. Various types of twin screw extruders are commercially available and these differ widely in their operating principles and function [18] as can be seen from Figure 5.13. They differ in their abilities for distributive and dispersive mixing and hence in their application areas. A possible classification of twin screw extruders [30] is shown in Table 5.6 along with commercial examples for each category. However, it should be borne in mind that this listing is by no means exhaustive. The main distinction is made between intermeshing and nonintermeshing twin screw extruders (Figure
STARTING POSITION
FIRST QUARTER TDlN (90°)
FULL TURN COMPLETED
Figure 5.12 Kneading action in a single screw kneader. (Reprinted from Ref. 23 with kind permission from Gulf Publishing Co., Houston, Texas, USA.) Table 5.5 Advantages and disadvantages of the twin screw extruder Advantages Positive displacement characteristic gives throughputs independent of the nature of the product being processed Earlier and more complete melting allows machines to be shorter and gives better mixing Self-wiping characteristic avoids any product hang-up in the machines Disadvantages High capital cost Mechanically more complex with difficulties of fitting adequate thrust bearings to two closely positioned shafts Source: Ref. 20.
PARTIALLY INTERMESHING
COUNTER-ROTATING
LENOTHWISEAND CROSSWISECLOSED LENGTHWISE OPEN THEORETICALLY AND NOT POSSIBLE CROSSWiSE CLOSED THEORETICALLY POSSIBLE LENGTHWISE AND CROSSWISE OPEN 5_ BUTPRACTICALLY NOT REALIZED LENGTHWISE OPEN AND CROSSWISE CLOSED
CO-ROTATING THEORETICALLY NOT POSSIBLE "SB" DISKS SCREWS
FULLY INTERMESHING
SYSTEM
NOT INTERMESHING
NOT INTERMESHING
INTERMESHtNG
SCREW ENGAGEMENT
THEORETICALLY NOTPOSSIBLE
LENGTHWISE AND CROSSWISE OPEN
LENGTHWISEAND CROSSWISEOPEN
Figure 5.13 Types of twin screw extruders. (Reprinted from Ref. 18 with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers Inc., Connecticut, USA.)
5.14(a)), each of which may be divided on the basis of the direction of the rotation of the screw into co-rotating or contra-rotating (Figure 5.14(b)), also termed counter-rotating. The benefits and the drawbacks of each system have been discussed in many publications. However, arguments in favor of one system more often seem to be based on a personal preference or bias than on an objective engineering analysis. The plain fact that the systems have coexisted for a number of years must be sufficient evidence that these systems fulfil a practical need. In some applications, the co-rotating extruders may be better suited; in other cases, counter-rotating extruders may be preferred. For many filling operations, however, twin screw co-rotating systems have the widest application because of their high degree of flexibility. Instead of arguing against or in favor of a particular system, it is more useful to determine both the advantages and the disadvantages of the systems and to identify the applications for which each system would be best suited. The first known twin screw device was an intermeshing co-rotating extruder invented in 1939, and patented in 1949 [66]. Developments in twin screw extruders have come a long way since then. The mechanisms of different types of twin screw extruders shown in Figure 5.13 make a distinction between axially open machines, where there is a
Table 5.6 Classification of twin screw extruders
Corotating extruders
Low speed extruders -LMP Colombo —Windsor —Bamberger High speed extruders -Werner and Pfleiderer —Baker Perkins -Berstorff Conical extruders —Kraus Maffei —Cincinnati Milacron -AGM
lntermeshing extruders
Counterrotating extruders Twin screw extruders
Counterrotating extruders
—Cylindrical extruders —Leistritz —Kraus Maffei —Maillefer —Reifenhauser -Mapre —Kesterman —Troester, etc. Equal screw length -Bausano -Japan Steel Works Unequal screw length —Welding Engineers
Nonintermeshing extruders Corotating extruders Source: Ref. 30 (reprinted with kind permission from Society of Plastics Engineers Inc., Connecticut, USA).
No commercial examples known
intermeshing
non-intermeshing
co-rotating
co-rotating
contra-rotating
contra-rotating
Figure 5.14 Diagram showing the difference between (a) intermeshing and nonintermeshing as well as (b) co-rotating and contra-rotating or counter-rotating types of twin screw extruders. (Reprinted from Ref. 20.)
continuous passage between the inlet and outlet, and the axially closed machines, where the passage is interrupted at regular intervals. Considerable variations of screw design are possible to balance pumping and mixing characteristics [67]. The right-handed, forward, regular flighted elements shown in Figure 5.13 are only one of many types of elements employed in twin screw extruders. The other types may include left-handed, reverse, regular flighted elements, forward and reverse kneading discs, shearing discs, etc. Most twin screw extruders can be assembled using the building block principle, which involves the use of screw elements of different lengths/pitches and special kneading elements of various widths available as blocks that are interchangeable. This makes it possible to design the processing section exactly as required for obtaining optimum processing conditions because the screw elements and kneading elements blocks can be varied to tailor-make the screw configuration for the shear intensity required by a specific material. If properly designed,
twin screw extruders provide maximum process control, especially with respect to shear and stock temperature. Also, twin screw compounders allow the removal of large quantities of volatiles. The diversity among twin screw extruders is so large that a comprehensive discussion of all the various types would be an enormous undertaking. A description of some of the important characteristics of three basic types of twin screw extruders is given below. Nonintermeshing co-rotating twin screw extruders are not produced commercially and hence are not treated in this section. (i)
Intermeshing co-rotating screw extruders
These have the flights of one screw protruding into the channel of the other screw, thereby providing positive displacement pumping [68] when both screws rotate in the same direction. The degree of intermeshing can range from almost fully intermeshing to almost nonintermeshing with a corresponding range in the degree of positive conveying characteristics. The design of intermeshing screws includes variations in lengthwise and crosswise open and closed positions, which directly affect the conveying conditions, the mixing action, and the pressure buildup capacity of the screw system. Co-rotating twin screw extruders are commonly produced only as fully intermeshing and operate on the building block principle. Depending on the requirements of the compounding task at hand, proper screw elements are selected and assembled along with the right choice of kneading elements blocks. Commonly employed elements include right-handed and left-handed (forward and reverse) regular flighted elements, forward and reverse kneading discs, as well as mixing and shearing pins. For regular flighted elements, fully intermeshing corotating screws are open lengthwise, but are closed crosswise, except for leakage over the flights. When the twin screws are intermeshing, the extruder can be considered to be self-wiping, that is, all the surfaces within the processing chamber are wiped of polymer. This characteristic is important when heat sensitive materials are being processed. Selfwiping is advantageous to the operational economics as the screws require much less downtime for cleaning. Efficient self-wiping ensures no material hang-up in the machine and can be demonstrated by a short