Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Second Edition
Editor
R.N. Rothon
Rapra Technology Limited
Particulate-Filled...
518 downloads
2267 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Second Edition
Editor
R.N. Rothon
Rapra Technology Limited
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 2nd Edition
Editor: Roger N. Rothon
rapra TECHNOLOGY
Rapra Technology Limited Shawbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, SY4 4NR, United Kingdom Telephone: +44 (0)1939 250383 Fax: +44 (0)1939 251118 http://www.rapra.net
First Published in 2003 by
Rapra Technology Limited Shawbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, SY4 4NR, UK
©2003, Rapra Technology Limited
All rights reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation no part of this publication may be photocopied, reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior permission from the copyright holder. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Every effort has been made to contact copyright holders of any material reproduced within the text and the authors and publishers apologize if any have been overlooked. Cover micrograph of aramid fibre-reinforced polyamide 6,6, reproduced with permission from P.R. Hornsby, Brunel University, UK.
ISBN: 1-85957-382-7
Typeset by Rapra Technology Limited Cover printed by The Printing House, Crewe, Cheshire, UK Printed and bound by Rapra Technology Limited, Shrewsbury, UK
Contents
Preface ................................................................................................................... 1 Contributors .......................................................................................................... 3 1
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials ........... 5 1.1
Introduction ........................................................................................... 5
1.2
Basic Characteristics of Particulate Fillers .............................................. 5 1.2.1
Cost ........................................................................................... 6
1.2.2
Chemistry, Composition and Impurities..................................... 7
1.2.3
Density or Specific Gravity ........................................................ 9
1.2.4
Hardness .................................................................................. 10
1.2.5
Abrasiveness ............................................................................ 11
1.2.6
Optical Properties .................................................................... 11
1.2.7
Thermal Properties .................................................................. 14
1.2.8
Particle Shape and Size............................................................. 16
1.2.9
Shape ....................................................................................... 17
1.2.10 Particle Size .............................................................................. 20 1.3 Surface Modification ............................................................................... 26
1.4
1.3.1
Stearic Acid and Stearates ........................................................ 26
1.3.2
Coupling Agents ...................................................................... 27
1.3.3
Polymer Modifications............................................................. 27
1.3.4
Direct Bonding ......................................................................... 28
Particle Packing and the Maximum Packing Fraction .......................... 29 1.4.1
Introduction ............................................................................. 29
1.4.2
Determination of Maximum Packing Fraction (Pf) by Oil Absorption Procedures............................................................. 29
1.4.3
Particle Packing Theory ........................................................... 30 i
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
1.4.4
Applications of Packing Principles to Particulate Filled Composites .............................................................................. 33
1.5
Interparticle Spacing ............................................................................ 34
1.6
Particle Effects on the Structure of Polymers ........................................ 36 1.6.1
Introduction ............................................................................. 36
1.6.2
Molecular Weight Reduction During Processing ...................... 36
1.6.3
Molecular Weight and Crosslinking Changes due to Cure Modifications .................................................................. 37
1.6.4
Preferential Adsorption of Polar Species .................................. 37
1.6.5
Formation of an Interphase of Immobilised Polymer ............... 38
1.6.6
Effects on Polymer Conformation due to the Presence of Particle Surfaces and Interparticle Spacing ............................... 42
1.6.7
Effects on Crystallinity............................................................. 42
References ..................................................................................................... 45 2
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers ............................................................. 53 2.1
Introduction ......................................................................................... 53
2.2
Particulate Fillers from Natural Origins (Mineral Fillers) .................... 53 2.2.1
Introduction ............................................................................. 53
2.2.2
Minerals and Rocks ................................................................. 54
2.2.3
Rocks ....................................................................................... 55
2.2.4
Calcium Carbonate Minerals ................................................... 57
2.2.5
Dolomite .................................................................................. 61
2.2.6
China Clay or Kaolin ............................................................... 61
2.2.7
Calcined Clay .......................................................................... 66
2.2.8
Mica ........................................................................................ 69
2.2.9
Talc .......................................................................................... 70
2.2.10 Montmorillonite (AlMg)8(Si4O10)3-(OH)10.12H2O ................... 72 2.2.11 Barite (BaSO4).......................................................................... 73 2.2.12 Calcium Sulfate Products ......................................................... 74 2.2.13 Wollastonite (CaSiO3) .............................................................. 74 2.2.14 Crystalline Silicas ..................................................................... 76
ii
Contents
2.3
Synthetic Particulate Fillers .................................................................. 78 2.3.1
Carbon Black ........................................................................... 78
2.3.2
Synthetic Silicas ....................................................................... 81
2.3.3
Hydroxides and Basic Carbonates ........................................... 84
2.3.4
Precipitated Calcium Carbonate (PCC) .................................... 96
Acknowledgements ....................................................................................... 96 References ..................................................................................................... 97 3
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces ............................. 101 3.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 101
3.2
Acid-Base Theory ............................................................................... 104 3.2.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 104
3.2.2
Gutmann Approach ............................................................... 105
3.2.3
Drago Approach .................................................................... 106
3.2.4
Use in Characterising Fillers .................................................. 106
3.3
Analytical Techniques ........................................................................ 108
3.4
Reactive Techniques ........................................................................... 109
3.5
3.6
3.7
3.4.1
Flow Microcalorimetry .......................................................... 109
3.4.2
Inverse Gas Chromatography ................................................ 119
Spectroscopic Techniques ................................................................... 124 3.5.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 124
3.5.2
X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy ........................................ 124
3.5.3
Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry ......................................... 130
3.5.4
Diffuse Reflectance Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy . 134
Methods for Examining Structural Order in Filler Coatings .............. 145 3.6.1
Wide Angle X-Ray Diffraction ............................................... 145
3.6.2
Differential Scanning Calorimetry ......................................... 146
Summary ............................................................................................ 147
References ................................................................................................... 148
iii
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
4
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers ............................................... 153 4.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 153
4.2
Reasons for Using Surface Modifiers ................................................. 153
4.3
General Principles of Surface Modification ........................................ 154
4.4
Methods of Using Surface Modifiers .................................................. 155
4.5
Choice of Coating Level ..................................................................... 156
4.6
Techniques for Determining the Amount of Coating Present, and Assessing the Amount Needed for Mono-layer Coverage ........... 158
4.7
4.6.1
Determination of Amount of Additive and it’s Distribution ... 158
4.6.2
The Monolayer and it’s Determination .................................. 160
4.6.3
Effects of Processing on the Coating Structure ....................... 163
Surface Modifier Types ...................................................................... 163 4.7.1
Monomeric Organic Acids and their Salts ............................. 163
4.7.2
Stearic Acid (CH3(CH2)16COOH ........................................... 166
4.7.3
Other Saturated Fatty Acids and Related Substances ............. 170
4.7.4
Effects of Stearic Acid Coating in Composites ....................... 171
4.7.5
Fatty Acid Salts ...................................................................... 173
4.7.6
Unsaturated and other Functional Organic Acids in Composites ........................................................................ 173
4.7.7
Polymeric Acids and Anhydrides ........................................... 175
4.7.8
Organo-silicon Compounds ................................................... 177
4.7.9
Examples of Silane Coupling Agent Effects in Filled Polymers ...................................................................... 190
4.7.10 Organo-Titanates and Zirconates .......................................... 191 4.7.11 Aluminates and Zircoaluminates ........................................... 198 4.7.12 Phosphates and Borates ......................................................... 199 4.7.13 Organic Amines and Amino-acids ......................................... 200 4.8
Conclusions ....................................................................................... 200
References ................................................................................................... 201
iv
Contents
5
Compound Preparation, Mixture Characterisation and Process Enhancement of Particulate-Filled Polymer Compounds ............................. 207 5.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 207
5.2
Functional Characteristics of Compounding Machinery .................... 209
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.2.1
Transport of Feedstock .......................................................... 210
5.2.2
Melting and Shear Heating .................................................... 213
5.2.3
Mixing ................................................................................... 214
5.2.4
Melt Devolatilisation ............................................................. 217
5.2.5
Melt Pumping and Pressurisation .......................................... 218
Constructional Design of Compounding Plant ................................... 219 5.3.1
Low and Medium Intensity Premixing Procedures ................. 220
5.3.2
High-Intensity Compounding Machinery .............................. 221
Characterisation of Filled Compounds .............................................. 228 5.4.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 228
5.4.2
Residence Time Distribution .................................................. 229
5.4.3
Specific Energy Input ............................................................. 231
5.4.4
Screen Pack Analysis .............................................................. 231
5.4.5
Rheological Analysis .............................................................. 232
5.4.6
Ultrasonic Measurement ........................................................ 233
5.4.7
Microstructural Analysis........................................................ 235
5.4.8
Miscellaneous Methods of Analysis ....................................... 239
Process Enhancement of Particulate Polymer Composites .................. 240 5.5.1
Addition of Rigid Particulate Fillers ....................................... 241
5.5.2
Effects on Polymer Molecular Weight .................................... 243
5.5.3
Short Fibre-Reinforced Thermoplastics Composites .............. 244
5.6
Woodflour and Natural Fibre-Filled Thermoplastics ......................... 246
5.7
Supercritical Fluid Assisted Processing of Filled Compounds ............. 249
5.8
Processing of Thermoset Recyclate Waste Materials .......................... 250
5.9
Preparation of Silicate Layer Polymer Nanocomposites ..................... 251
v
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
5.10 Conclusions ....................................................................................... 254 References ................................................................................................... 254 6
Effects of Particulate Fillers on Flame Retardant Properties of Composites ... 263 6.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 263
6.2
General Effects of Fillers on Polymer Flammability ........................... 263
6.3
Fire Retardant Testing........................................................................ 264
6.4
6.3.1
Oxygen Index Test (ASTM D2863-87) .................................. 266
6.3.2
Underwriters Laboratory Vertical Burn Test (UL94 -1980) .... 266
6.3.3
Horizontal Burn Test (ASTM D635-88) ................................ 267
6.3.4
Ignitability Test (ISO5657 1986) ........................................... 267
6.3.5
Cone Calorimeter (ASTM E1354, ISO 5660) ........................ 267
6.3.6
Smoke and Corrosive Gas Tests ............................................. 268
Fire Retardant Fillers that Rely on Endothermic Decomposition ....... 269 6.4.1
Historical Background ........................................................... 269
6.4.2
Potential Endothermic Flame Retardant Fillers ...................... 270
6.4.3
Performance of Endothermic Flame Retardant Fillers ............ 273
6.4.4
Smoke and Corrosive and Toxic Gases .................................. 290
6.5
Nano-Clays ........................................................................................ 296
6.6
Ammonium Polyphosphate (APP) ...................................................... 297
6.7
Fillers for Use in Conjunction with Halogens .................................... 297
References ................................................................................................... 298 7
Particulate Fillers in Elastomers .................................................................. 303 7.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 303
7.2
Uses of Elastomers ............................................................................. 303
7.3
Elasticity of Rubber ........................................................................... 303
7.4
Formulation of Elastomers ................................................................. 306 7.4.1
vi
General .................................................................................. 306
Contents
7.5
7.6
7.7
7.4.2
Selection of Polymer .............................................................. 306
7.4.3
The Curing System ................................................................. 308
7.4.4
Antioxidants and Antiozonants ............................................. 310
7.4.5
Coupling Agents .................................................................... 311
7.4.6
Process Oils and Plasticisers ................................................... 311
7.4.7
Fillers ..................................................................................... 313
7.4.8
Specialty Additives ................................................................. 314
The Performance of the Polymer ........................................................ 317 7.5.1
Specification of the Polymer .................................................. 317
7.5.2
Processing Considerations ..................................................... 321
7.5.3
Strength Characteristics of Polymers ...................................... 321
7.5.4
Compounding Considerations ............................................... 322
The Performance of Fillers ................................................................. 326 7.6.1
Reinforcement of Rubber by Fillers ....................................... 326
7.6.2
Processing Considerations ..................................................... 330
7.6.3
Compounding Considerations ............................................... 333
Filler Types ........................................................................................ 338 7.7.1
Specification of Fillers for Elastomers .................................... 338
7.7.2
Carbon Black ......................................................................... 340
7.7.3
Synthetic Silicas and Silicates ................................................. 343
7.7.4
Clay Minerals ........................................................................ 344
7.7.5
Calcium Carbonates .............................................................. 346
7.7.6
Alumina Trihydrate ............................................................... 348
7.7.7
Talcs ...................................................................................... 349
7.7.8
Natural Silicas ....................................................................... 349
7.7.9
Barytes and Blanc Fixe ........................................................... 350
7.7.10 Miscellaneous ........................................................................ 350 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................... 350 References ................................................................................................... 351
vii
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
8
Filled Thermoplastics .................................................................................. 357 8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
8.5
viii
Introduction ....................................................................................... 357 8.1.1
Thermoplastics and Typical Applications .............................. 357
8.1.2
Thermoplastic Composites..................................................... 359
Bulk and Process Related Properties .................................................. 361 8.2.1
Specific Gravity or Relative Density ....................................... 361
8.2.2
Acoustic Properties ................................................................ 362
8.2.3
Melt Viscosity (MFI) .............................................................. 363
8.2.4
Compounding and Extrusion ................................................. 364
8.2.5
Thermal Conductivity and Specific Heat Capacity ................ 367
8.2.6
Thermal Expansion ................................................................ 368
8.2.7
Electrical Properties ............................................................... 369
8.2.8
Barrier Properties ................................................................... 370
Mechanical Properties ........................................................................ 371 8.3.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 371
8.3.2
Modulus – Tensile and Flexural ............................................. 372
8.3.3
Heat Deflection Temperature (HDT) ..................................... 374
8.3.4
Yield Strength ........................................................................ 375
8.3.5
Impact Strength (Toughness) .................................................. 376
Effects of Filler on the Polymer Phase ................................................ 380 8.4.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 380
8.4.2
Nucleation ............................................................................. 380
8.4.3
Transcrystallinity ................................................................... 381
8.4.4
Interphase .............................................................................. 382
Surface Science Aspects ...................................................................... 383 8.5.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 383
8.5.2
Surface Energy and Surface Tension....................................... 383
8.5.3
Wetting and Spreading ........................................................... 384
8.5.4
Adhesion ................................................................................ 384
8.5.5
Dispersion and Agglomeration .............................................. 387
8.5.6
Surface Treatments – Dispersants and Coupling Agents ........ 388
Contents
8.6
8.7
8.8
8.9
Aesthetics ........................................................................................... 390 8.6.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 390
8.6.2
Colour/Pigmentation .............................................................. 390
8.6.3
Surface Finish and Gloss ........................................................ 390
8.6.4
Scratch and Abrasion Resistance ........................................... 391
Stabilisation and Recycleability ......................................................... 392 8.7.1
Introduction ........................................................................... 392
8.7.2
The Effect of Filler Chemistry and Impurities on Stability ..... 393
8.7.3
The Effect of Antioxidant Adsorption on Stability ................ 394
8.7.4
Recycleability ......................................................................... 395
Uses of Filled Thermoplastics............................................................. 396 8.8.1
Uses of Fillers ......................................................................... 396
8.8.2
Fillers in PVC ......................................................................... 397
8.8.2
Uses of Fillers in Unplasticised PVC ....................................... 401
8.8.3
Uses of Fillers in Polypropylene ............................................. 403
8.8.4
Uses of Fillers in Polyethylene ................................................ 406
8.8.5
The Use of Fillers in Polyamides ............................................ 408
8.8.6
Polybutylene Terephthalate .................................................... 409
8.8.7
Polyethylene Terephthalate .................................................... 410
Conclusions ....................................................................................... 411
Acknowledgements ..................................................................................... 413 References ................................................................................................... 413 9
Filled Thermosets ........................................................................................ 425 9.1
Introduction ....................................................................................... 425
9.2
Brief Chemistry of Thermoset Polymers ............................................. 427
9.3
9.2.1
Free-Radical Chain-Growth Curing Resins ............................ 427
9.2.2
Step Addition Curing Resins .................................................. 435
9.2.3
Condensation Resins .............................................................. 440
Mechanical Properties ........................................................................ 444
ix
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
9.4
9.3.1
Modulus ................................................................................ 444
9.3.2
Fracture Toughness and Fracture Energy ............................... 450
9.3.3
Failure Stress .......................................................................... 463
9.3.4
Fatigue ................................................................................... 469
Applications ....................................................................................... 477 9.4.1
Cost Reduction ...................................................................... 477
9.4.2
Modified Mechanical Properties ............................................ 477
9.4.3
Exotherm Control .................................................................. 478
9.4.4
Shrinkage Control .................................................................. 480
9.4.5
Processing Aids ...................................................................... 481
9.4.6
Flame Retardants ................................................................... 482
9.4.7
Metal Fillers ........................................................................... 482
9.4.8
Structural Adhesives .............................................................. 483
Acknowledgements ..................................................................................... 483 References ................................................................................................... 484 10 Composites Using Nano-Fillers ................................................................... 489 10.1 Introduction ....................................................................................... 489 10.2 Scope ................................................................................................. 489 10.3 General Comments ............................................................................ 490 10.4 Nano-Filler Forms ............................................................................. 490 10.4.1 Regular Shapes ...................................................................... 491 10.4.2 Rods, Fibres, etc. ................................................................... 492 10.4.3 Platy Nano-Fillers (Nano-Clays and Related Materials) ........ 493 10.5 Summary and Future Perspectives ...................................................... 510 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................... 511 References ................................................................................................... 511 Abbreviations and Acronyms ...................................................................... 515 Author Index ............................................................................................... 521 Index ........................................................................................................... 527 x
Preface
I was delighted to accept the chance offered by Rapra Technology to produce this updated second edition of Particulate Filled Polymer Composites, a book first published in 1995. The first edition had been very well received but has been out of print for some time. Despite the relatively short time since the publication of the first edition, much has changed and hence considerable new material has been introduced, including a completely new chapter covering the latest developments in nano-filler technology. The use of particulate fillers in polymers has a long history, and they continue to play a very important role today. Despite the apparent commodity status, the area is still very dynamic and considerable changes have occurred in applications over the last few years. The most significant of these have been the dramatic growth in the use of precipitated silica in energy efficient tyre applications and the emergence of ‘nano-filler’ technologies. The multidisciplinary nature of this topic is well illustrated by the scope of the references in the book. These are drawn from many fields, including: mineralogy, crystallography, precipitation and crystal growth, powder technology, surface and colloid science, organic and organo-metallic chemistry, optics, materials science, and polymer science and technology. It also brings together people from many backgrounds, such as filler producers, machinery manufacturers, polymer compounders and suppliers of processing aids and surface modifiers. Together with my co-authors, I have set out to describe the fundamentals involved in producing, characterising and using particulate fillers in as clear and concise a way as possible. The authors have been encouraged to pay particular attention to those areas of their subjects which their experience shows cause the most confusion, or which are poorly covered elsewhere. Most importantly, where a topic is controversial, or poorly understood, they have been encouraged to interpret the existing literature, not merely quote opposing views, as is often the case. Where possible, use has been made of previously unpublished work to illustrate key points and extensive literature references are provided so that any subject can be followed up in depth, if needed. Chapter 4, on surface modification, is a good example of the approach taken. Most works concentrate on the organo-silanes. While they are still treated in detail here, significant space is also given to fatty acids and organo-titanates. Fatty acids are of considerable commercial importance and exhibit complexities that can cause problems
1
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites for the unwary. Considerable controversy exists over the mode of action of the organotitanates and the available scientific literature is critically reviewed here. As with any editor, I am very much indebted to my co-authors for their hard work. I am also indebted to the staff at Rapra Technology, especially Frances Powers, for their help and support in turning the various contributions into a very well presented composite. Finally, I would like to express my particular thanks to the late Professor Derek Birchall, FRS, who first aroused my interest in this area and to the late Hugh Olmstead founder of Intertech Corporation and to my many friends and colleagues, especially those at Manchester Metropolitan University, Avecia Limited, Colin Stewart Minchem, CSIRO Division of Minerals, Electrolux and the Intertech Corporation, who have helped me to continue this interest in recent years. Roger N. Rothon July 2003
2
Contributors
David Ashton ICI Acrylics PO Box 34 Darwen Lancashire BB3 1QB David Briggs Siacon Consultants Ltd. 21 Woodfarm Road Malvern Worcestershire WR14 4RL Chris DeArmitt BASF Aktiengesellschaft KSP/S-E100 67056 Ludwigshafen Germany Michael Hancock 6 Poltair Avenue St Austell Cornwall PL25 4LY Graham Jackson LGC Ltd. The Heath Runcorn Cheshire WA7 4QD Peter Hornsby The Wolfson Centre Brunel University Uxbridge Middlesex UB8 3BH
Christopher Liauw Manchester Metropolitan University Centre For Materials Science Research John Dalton Building Chester Street Manchester M1 5GD Michael Orton 24, School Lane Hartford Cheshire CW8 1PE Roger Rothon Rothon Consultants and Manchester Metropolitan University 3 Orchard Croft Guilden Sutton Chester CH3 7SL David Skelhorn Performance Materials Division Imerys 100 Mansell Court East Suite 300 Roswell Georgia 30076 USA Howard Taylor Manchester Metropolitan University Department of Engineering and Technology John Dalton Building Chester Street Manchester M1 5GD
3
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
4
1
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials Roger N. Rothon and Michael Hancock
1.1 Introduction Particulate-filled polymer composites have a long history and consequently newcomers to the field usually expect to find an area of well-understood science with few intellectual challenges remaining. However, they are usually amazed to find that this is far from the truth in many areas, with few reliable generalisations (but several unreliable ones) available and much basic information yet to be established. This is largely due to the way in which the technology has developed, with different filler and polymer combinations tending to be developed largely piecemeal to meet the specific demands of various industries. The initial, and to some extent continuing, emphasis on cost reduction has also meant that many fillers have been poorly characterised. The purpose of this chapter is to give readers sufficient background so that they may approach the subject with an open mind and see the whole area as one with stimulating intellectual challenges, not as an area of mystery and witchcraft. This chapter discusses how fillers can be characterised and defined with the least ambiguity, and hence how their behaviour in composites can be understood and hopefully predicted. We also highlight the principal sources of misunderstandings and the limitations imposed by commonly used methods of measurement, and explain why and where deviations from general rules are likely to occur.
1.2 Basic Characteristics of Particulate Fillers In developing a particulate-filled composite, the formulator needs to be able to answer the following questions: 1. What property benefits are being sought? 2. What deleterious changes may also occur and can they be tolerated? 3. How easy is the filler to handle and how might it affect processing?
5
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 4. Are special additives needed? 5. What is the true cost of using the filler, is it justifiable, and are there more cost effective alternatives? Important information for answering the above questions includes, cost, purity, particle size and shape, density, hardness, optical and thermal properties and chemistry. The primary source of this information should be the filler supplier, although frequently data may be sparse. A brief description of each factor, its measurement and significance follows.
1.2.1 Cost In theory this is a fairly simple topic, but one that causes considerable problems for the unwary. It is widely assumed that polymers are expensive and fillers are cheap, and many articles on filled polymers start with the statement that fillers are used primarily to reduce costs. While this can often be the case, these savings are frequently not as great as anticipated and, in quite a few instances, compound costs, even with the lowest cost filler, can be higher than the unmodified polymer. There are two principal reasons for this. Firstly, the process of compounding filler into polymer costs money in the form of capital investment, manpower and energy [1]. In cases where compounding is essential, because other additives such as stabilisers or curatives have to be added to the polymer, then the cost of incorporating a filler is markedly reduced. In these cases, exemplified by elastomers, polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and thermosets, the use of fillers is the rule rather than the exception, unlike the case with, say, polyethylene. Secondly, prices of fillers and polymers are usually quoted in weight terms, while the majority of their composites are used on a volume basis. The specific gravity of most fillers is two to three times that of common polymers and, while raw material savings may accrue on a weight basis, more mass of the final compound will have to be used to achieve the same volume than would be the case with the unfilled polymer. When looking at potential cost savings, comparison of polymer and filler costs must therefore be made on a volume basis. On this basis one should generally regard the effective raw material costs of mineral fillers as two to three times their price (by weight). As a consequence many fillers will not give significant cost savings in the commodity plastics, such as polypropylene (PP) and this explains why the emphasis today is on achieving specific effects. However, while fillers may not ‘cheapen’ a filled composite they may well produce a cost-property performance that allows the composite to compete against and often replace more expensive systems.
6
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials
1.2.2 Chemistry, Composition and Impurities While the chemical nature of the filler is frequently of little direct importance to its use in composites, it plays two important roles, in that it determines the structure of the mineral, and also the nature of the interaction between polymer and filler. However, away from these a priori considerations, only in a few cases does the chemical reactivity of the filler play a significant role in the properties of a composite.
1.2.2.1 Bulk Chemistry Intrinsically fillers can be divided into two types, reactive and inert. Reactive fillers will react with their environment. A good example of this is gibbsite (aluminium hydroxide), which will react with both acidic and basic substances. Aluminium hydroxide also loses its water of crystallisation at around 200 °C and this enables it to provide fire retardancy in polymer formulations. The silicate minerals: (kaolin, mica, talc, quartz, etc.), are, in classical chemical terms, virtually inert, only being attacked by very strong acids and alkalis. The carbonate minerals and the hydroxide minerals are very reactive to acids. The interactions between the constituent elements in a filler determine its molecular structure and hence crystallinity, which then dictates all the intrinsic properties of the filler.
1.2.2.2 Surface Chemistry Filler surface chemistries are of more significance than the bulk ones, as they determine both the rate of wetting and the strength of interaction with polymers. They are invariably different from bulk chemistry but, unfortunately, they are poorly characterised for many fillers. Because of the interest in this very important topic, techniques for surface characterisation are covered in detail in Chapter 3.
1.2.2.3 Surface Interactions Polymers have a very much higher (20-30 times) thermal expansion coefficient than mineral fillers. Thus, in many well-dispersed, hot processed composites, a radial compressive stress develops as the polymer cools leading to an intimate interaction between matrix and filler. The value of this stress can be calculated, and depends on both polymer and filler [2]. Because of this, the interaction will at the very least be mechanical, but other types will exist depending on the surface chemistry of the filler and also the chemistry of the polymer.
7
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Wettability of filler by polymer is an indication of compatibility between the two. Wettability by polymer is not readily measured directly, but the effect that the material has on surface tension of a liquid is a measure of its surface energy. Usually water is chosen as the medium. Schlumf [3] has reported surface energies for a variety of fillers (Table 1.1). There have been a wide number of claims that surface energies determine the forces between polymer chains and different phases, determining mechanical properties of the composite. Adhesion at a polymer-filler interface has been shown to exert a considerable influence on mechanical responses, and a correlation between acid-base characteristics of filler and polymer (as determined by inverse gas chromatography) and properties has been established [4]. Lewis acid-base interactions between filler and polymer are claimed to be the most important component in the adhesion of a filler to polymers and thus in determining properties of composites [5]. For some filler-polymer systems, the strength of interfacial acid-base bonding may be appreciably enhanced by surface modification of the filler, or by modification of the polymer, giving large increases in properties.
Table 1.1 Surface energies of fillers and plastics Material
Surface energy (m Jm-2)
Diamond
10,000
Mica
240-500
Glass
1,200
Titanium dioxide Kaolin
650 500-600
Calcium carbonate
65-70
Stearate coated calcium carbonate
25-30
Talc
65-70
Polymers
15-60
Polypropylene
31
1.2.2.4 Chemical Analysis and Impurities The purity of a filler is of importance both commercially and technically, i.e., the users need to know what they are buying, whether it contains components that may be detrimental to the properties of their product and whether it will cause environmental problems. Impurities include trace elements that may be on the filler surface or in the structure of the filler and ancillary minerals, which will have been formed at the same
8
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials time as the main mineral (see Chapter 2). Sometimes additives from the filler manufacture may be present, (e.g., surfactants). The form of the impurity can be very important in determining it’s importance. Sometimes a potentially detrimental impurity can be tolerated in relatively high levels, if present in an inert form, but small traces of the same impurity, if present on the surface in an active form, can be very deleterious. Examples are certain transition metals, (e.g., iron, manganese, copper), which can seriously affect colour and thermal stability if present in an active form, even at levels of a few parts per million. Thus some micas and talcs can contain high levels of iron in an inert form, which is not detrimental to polymer ageing, while others can have lower levels of more active material. Some impurities may also pose health hazards, examples being crystalline silica and asbestos. Fillers are not always analysed for such low-level impurities and it is a mistake to believe that, if a possible deleterious impurity is not quoted in a data sheet, it is not present in the product. Conversely, it must be stressed that, if an element or substance is present in a non-active form, it may have little effect on polymer properties [6]. It is also necessary to point out that the way chemical composition is presented, can, and does, cause misunderstandings. Because of the methods of analysis used, many mineral compositions are quoted as a list of oxides rather than the actual constituent chemical. Thus a calcium carbonate may be specified as so many percent CaO or a clay may be reported in terms of SiO2 and Al2O3. This does not imply that any of the oxides are present in the free state. It should also be recognised that some standard methods of analysis do not detect very light elements.
1.2.3 Density or Specific Gravity This is one of the simplest of properties to define, understand and use. Density is mass per unit volume with SI (Système Internationale) units of kilograms per cubic meter. Specific gravity and relative density, the weight of the substance in relation to the weight of an equivalent volume of water, are often used synonymously. They are dimensionless but have the same numerical values as density. Density is determined by the size of the atoms forming the mineral, the closeness with which they are packed together and by impurities present in the crystal lattice: the heavier the atoms and the more tightly they are packed together, the higher the density. Thus, smithsonite, ZnCO3, has a higher specific gravity (4.3) than calcite, CaCO3 (2.7) because zinc has a much higher atomic mass than calcium, but magnesite, MgCO3, has a higher specific gravity (3.0-3.2) than calcite despite the fact that magnesium is lighter than calcium. This is because its ions pack much more closely together. In some fillers air is deliberately introduced into a matrix to reduce its density.
9
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites True specific gravities of particulate additives can range from less than 1.0 for hollow glass beads to over 6.0 for some metallic fillers, but most lie in the range 1.6-2.8, while common polymers range from 0.9 to 1.4. Powder densities are of commercial importance, indicating ease of handling, and polymer compounding, and even affecting plant design. Values for bulk and packing densities are usually supplied by filler producers and are a measure of how the powder packs under various conditions. They are determined to some extent by the true density, particle shape and size of the filler, but the processing involved in its production also plays an important role. Surface treatments, and the methods used to apply them, can also be important. A powder with a low bulk density relative to its true density will contain a great deal of air. It will flow easily but will be difficult to incorporate into polymers, especially in equipment such as internal mixers and screw compounders.
1.2.4 Hardness Hardness is the resistance of a mineral to scratching. It is related to the structure of the mineral, the strength of the chemical bonds and the density of packing of its constituent atoms. F. Mohs, a mineralogist drew up a table of hardness in 1812 called the Mohs Hardness Scale (Table 1.2), which is still used to rank minerals by their resistance or susceptibility to scratching by other minerals. This scale is widely used for mineral fillers, but care must be taken in using the data because the scale is not linear, with the differences becoming greater at the high end. The hardness of most common particulate fillers range from 1 to 4. Talc is the softest, with a value of one.
Table 1.2 Mohs scale of mineral hardness 1
Talc (softest)
5
Apatite
8
Topaz
2
Gypsum
6
Orthoclase
9
Corundum
3
Calcite
7
Quartz
10
Diamond
4
Fluorite
Hardness must not be confused with toughness, which relates to the ability of the mineral to resist fracture. Hard minerals can often fracture very easily, for example, by cleavage along crystal planes.
10
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials Where mixed fillers are used, if one is much harder than the other, then abrasion of the softer one may occur. This is of particular importance when hard particulates are used with easily damaged glass fibres. Minerals such as talc are soft because they readily delaminate due to weak structural features (see Chapter 2). Such soft particles can fracture or cleave when polymer composites are deformed, thus limiting their reinforcing properties [7].
1.2.5 Abrasiveness Abrasion due to the filler has quite an important role in the processing of filled polymers. It has several origins. Mohs hardness is a major factor with the harder minerals, such as quartz and wollastonite (CaSiO3), approaching, or even exceeding the hardness of the metals used in processing. Large particles and angular particles with sharp edges are particularly detrimental, probably due to a scratching mechanism, followed by attrition of the exposed edges. Sometimes the coarse component of a filler may be predominantly a harder impurity, which leads unfortunately to a combination of the two mechanisms. Chemical attack may also be caused by some reactive fillers, leading to etching and progressive erosion.
1.2.6 Optical Properties The colour, opacity and gloss of a composite are very important, both aesthetically and functionally, and will be strongly affected by the incorporation of fillers. When light strikes any surface, it is subjected to several effects: absorption, scattering, reflection, polarisation and interference. The extent of each effect is dependent on the nature of both exit and entrance media, but for all practical purposes only three media, air, filler and polymer, will be considered here in a superficial treatment. The reader is referred to works such as by Bohren and Huffman for a detailed explanation [8]. A light ray incident upon an air-solid interface at an angle, i, will be bent or refracted somewhat normal to the interface, at an angle of refraction, r. A relationship of the incident angle, i, and the refracted angle, r, sin i/sin r, is constant for a given isotropic solid. The constant always denoted as n is called the refractive index. The refractive index of a filler is one of the most important parameters affecting the optical properties of a filled polymer system and is always quoted relative to air. It is, in fact, a manifestation of the ratio of the speed of light in air to its speed in the solid.
11
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites The refractive index of a mineral is the sum of the specific refractive indices of all individual components normalised for concentrations. Simplifying, it can be said that the refractive index of a solid is directly related to its density. When light strikes a surface, some will be reflected with the amount reflected being determined by the density of the constituent atoms and is thus affected by the refractive index, n. Reflection (r) and transmission (t) coefficients are given by: r=
1− n 1+ n
t=
2 1+ n
(1.1)
To a first approximation this leads to the fraction of incident light being reflected as simply (n – 1)2/(n + 1)2 and approaches zero as the refractive index approaches unity. The response of a plane surface to an incident beam of light is complicated, as briefly described previously. Mineral fillers, however, complicate the subject even more deeply in that they are a priori made up of particles that usually have sizes in the order of the wavelengths of visible light. Thus large surfaces will reflect and transmit the light waves but particles will scatter them. Therefore, light entering a typical powdered filler, comprising many small particles, will experience reflection, refraction, diffraction and interference at each air - particle interface. Refraction into the filler particles can lead to absorption of the light (the radiation absorbed will be converted into another form such as heat) and a measure of this is the absorption coefficient. The remainder of the light is diffused by scattering and the measure of this is its scattering coefficient. The colour (sometimes referred to as brightness, reflectance or whiteness) is related to absorption and scattering coefficients by Kubelka-Munk equations [9]. The reader is referred to the original paper and to some of the speciality books on the subject [10] for more details. The level of scattering is very dependent on particle size, so that finer fillers appear whiter than coarser ones: as an approximation, scattering in air is at a maximum when the particle size of powder is one-third to one-half the wavelength of the radiation. Levels of reflectance and refraction, and hence scattering, are directly related to the refractive index of the mineral. When incorporated into a polymer matrix, the ratio of its refractive index to that of the polymer will strongly affect the optical properties of the composite. As the ratio approaches unity (which is the case for most common polymers and filler): reflection at the interfaces between filler and polymer approaches zero. This means that light scattering is reduced dramatically and light absorption becomes obvious. Mie’s theory [11] now widely used for particle size determinations from light-scattering data, predicts that as differences in refractive indices become small, not only does scattering become less but particle size effects become less and maximum scattering moves to larger sizes, often several times greater than the wavelength of the light.
12
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials A filler such as titanium dioxide, having a refractive index much higher than that of the polymer, will therefore exhibit considerable scattering and will give white products, unless its absorption coefficient is high in which case dark, opaque composites will be produced (carbon black or black iron oxide are the ultimate in this instance). Most fillers are white or off-white powders due to the reflection of visible light. This reflection consists of two components, absorption and scattering, and, as discussed previously, most fillers have low absorption but high scattering coefficients. However, the amount of light scattered depends on the refractive index of the mineral relative to the medium in which it is measured. In air the differences in refractive indices mean that most minerals scatter light and appear white. Most plastics, on the other hand, have refractive indices close to those for minerals (1.5-1.6) and much of the scattering is lost (the light, in fact cannot ‘see’ the boundary between filler and polymer). There are a few cases in which mineral and polymer have almost identical refractive indices. In these instances, scattering virtually vanishes and the composite becomes almost transparent until loadings are increased to a level at which particle-particle interaction occurs [12]. This transparency is of commercial importance in several applications such as silica-filled styrene-butadiene rubber (SBR) shoe soles, and calcined clay- and glass fibre-filled unsaturated polyester roof panels. On the other hand, for example, calcite has a refractive index of 1.6, which is sufficiently different from most of the common plastics for some scattering and hence pigmentation to occur, but whiteness and opacity will only become very noticeable at high loadings and with thick products. With the loss of light scattering, light absorption becomes the dominant optical property of a mineral-filled plastic. Light is absorbed by transition metal ions, with different wavelengths being absorbed by different species of ion, and by naturally occurring organics, which are poly-aromatic species with strong absorption across the whole spectrum (that is they appear brown or black). The impurities in mineral fillers are mainly transition metal ions, particularly iron, and humates or lignates. Colours due to these become frequently more marked in a plastic. Some minerals exhibit birefringence with refractive indices different in differing directions, due to an asymmetric crystal structure. Plastics filled with these are dichroic and exhibit unusual visual appearances. As well as being a direct cause of the colour in a filled plastic, a filler may indirectly generate colour by either degrading the polymer (forming radicals and unsaturated species) or by deactivating antioxidants/stabilisers, etc., used in the polymer. In some cases, breakdown of filler surface treatments can also generate colour problems. Filler effects can be observed in most thermoplastics but are particularly relevant in PVC where dehydrochlorination, giving a polyene conjugated structure, is readily promoted by Lewis acid sites on a mineral surface.
13
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites During the processing of filled thermoplastics, but particularly during their injection moulding, white markings are observed at points where high melt strain rates are encountered. These are especially apparent around the sprue and are very much more noticeable than for unfilled plastics. Some may be due to water or gas bubbles (splash markings), some to poor dispersion or filler separation, but most seem to result from flow patterns. These have been frozen in a strained state before they have had time to relax due to the high thermal conductivity of filled polymers [13]. When filled polymers are strained, they whiten to some extent. This is partly due to orientation of polymer chains around filler particles but also to light scattering from vacuoles formed as the polymer is pulled away from the particle surfaces. Optical properties can also be affected by the fact that filler particles can affect the morphology of the plastic by nucleating its crystallisation at the interface. Thus a composite with different light scattering properties may be obtained.
1.2.6.1 Spectral Absorption The ultraviolet and visible spectra of the common fillers are largely featureless, unless there are significant levels of transition metal ions in the mineral, when strong absorptions will occur. However, the most important practical aspect is the infra-red (IR) spectrum of a filler. This arises from the nature of the chemical bonds present and will be unique for each filler type. A common use of IR spectroscopy is as an analytical tool to identify a filler. An important practical consequence of a filler’s IR absorption is the use of certain fillers in horticultural and agricultural films (see Chapter 8). Spectra of some of the more common minerals incorporated in a lowdensity polyethylene (PE) film are shown in Figure 1.1. Calcium carbonate shows only two strong absorption bands because the only energy absorptions occur in the CO3; ion (bending, stretching and deformation modes). Kaolin, a complex aluminosilicate, shows a much more complicated IR spectrum: after calcining, the —Al—O—Si— bonds rearrange and the resultant product has a very complex IR pattern with several broad, overlapping bands.
1.2.7 Thermal Properties Leaving aside the special cases of phase change and decomposition, the principal thermal properties of interest are specific heat, thermal conductivity and coefficient of expansion.
14
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials
Figure 1.1 Infra-red spectra of mineral filled polyethylene films
1.2.7.1 Specific Heat This is usually defined as the energy required to raise 1 gram of material by 1 K with SI units of J.kg-1.K-1. Specific heats are easily measurable and available for most particulates [14]. Where they are not, rules exist for estimating the value [7]. The volume specific heats of most inorganic fillers are similar to the common polymers and the rule of mixtures gives a good approximation to the values found in composites.
1.2.7.2 Thermal Conductivity This is the rate at which heat energy is transmitted through a substance, SI units are W m-1 K-1 but it is usually quoted as cal cm-1K-1. Mineral fillers are about an order of magnitude more conducting than most polymers, while metallic fillers are even more so. Filled composites are therefore more conductive in general than the base polymer. The simple law of mixtures is only applicable at low concentrations because, as with electrical conductivity, particle-particle contact will occur at high loadings leading to a sudden
15
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites sharp increase in conductivity, the so-called percolation threshold [15], which is dependent on particle shape and packing. This increased conductivity is of considerable importance in some processing operations, especially injection moulding.
1.2.7.3 Coefficient of Thermal Expansion As the name implies, this is the rate at which a material changes volume on heating or cooling. SI units are K-1. Most polymers have coefficients of expansion at least an order of magnitude greater than mineral fillers: thus mineral-filled composites have lower coefficients of expansion than unfilled polymers and, in well-annealed systems, the rule of mixtures applies unless strong bonding occurs between filler and polymer. Some fillers have a negative coefficient of expansion and are used to achieve composites with zero expansion. Other fillers show anisotropy, that is they have coefficients that are direction dependent. The differences in expansion between particle and matrix can result in intimate contact between them in a composite and consequently considerable stresses occur. These can have the same properties as chemical bonding at low strains and can mask any effects of changes in polymer-filler interactions in some tests.
1.2.8 Particle Shape and Size The importance of these factors is felt at all stages of composite production and use. They affect powder flow, compounding behaviour, composite viscosity, and mechanical, thermal and optical properties. Indeed, most of the current predictive equations for the properties of filled composites use shape and size factors, often determined using model particles such as glass spheres and flakes. Unfortunately such particles are rare in the real world and it is important in applying equations to appreciate the limitations imposed by problems of adequately measuring and describing the morphology of fine particles. One of the principal difficulties is due to the ability of many fillers to exhibit a variety of particle shapes and sizes depending on the work done in dispersing them. Their ‘effective’ shape and size can therefore vary at any stage of composite formation and use. In principle one would like to characterise them in situ. This is, however, far less easy than characterising the initial particulate material itself and one is usually reduced to trying to carry out measurements under conditions that will represent as near as possible those encountered in use. In this context, the concept of ‘effective’ particle, which is the size and shape achieved in the actual application, is a very useful one to keep in mind and is returned to later in this chapter.
16
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials
1.2.9 Shape 1.2.9.1 Introduction Particle shape (as will be discussed in following chapters) is very important in determining the stiffness, or rigidity, of a composite, the flow and rheology of a melt or liquid, tensile and impact strength, and the surface smoothness of a component, i.e., many of the important properties of a composite. Shape is determined by the genesis of the filler, by its chemistry, its crystal structure and by the processing it has undergone. Unfortunately, it is usually poorly defined, the literature abounding with vague terms such as roughly spherical, blocky, irregular, platy, acicular, etc. Some typical particles likely to be found in fillers are shown in Figure 1.2. All the fillers commonly used are microscopic in size imposing major difficulties both in how to measure, and then how to describe and quantify shape in any simple yet meaningful way. In addition, there are problems of distinguishing between primary particles, agglomerates and aggregates that occur in a filler, especially in synthetic materials, in which a ‘structure’ is sometimes deliberately designed. The subject is complicated further because aggregates and even particles may break down during processing (see Section 1.2.10.3 for a definition of these various terms).
Figure 1.2 Some particle types likely to be found in common fillers
17
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Despite the complex problems outlined previously, fillers are used because of their shape in a very wide range of polymers to give specific properties. For example, conventional clays are used in hose and chemical lining because their shape reduces permeability to fluids; platy talcs give rigidity to PP; the complex aggregate structure of precipitated calcium carbonates contributes to the structure of liquid polysulfides; and the special structured shape of many carbon blacks and synthetic silicas is important to their performance in elastomers. A further example is the emerging use of very high aspect ratio, nano-clays as reinforcing, fire retarding and gas and fluid barrier fillers.
1.2.9.2 Origins of Particle Shape Synthetic products will have their shape determined by their chemical composition and by the production conditions. For example, precipitated calcium carbonate (CaCO3) can be produced with different shapes by changing precipitation conditions to produce aragonite, calcite or vaterite. These conditions can be chosen to produce single crystals or complicated aggregates, which can be modified during drying and milling. Another example is the very complex shape of most carbon black particles arising from the partial fusing and solidification of pyrolysing droplets into three-dimensional chain-like aggregates during manufacture. The external shape of a natural mineral is a manifestation of its crystal structure, which will be briefly discussed in Chapter 2. It is also dependent on the environmental conditions in which the mineral was formed. If allowed to grow without constraint, then the particles are bounded by crystal faces, which are disposed in a regular way such that there is a particular relationship between them in any one mineral species, which is derived from regular atomic arrangement. However, under pressure, temperature or the effects of impurities, the crystal may adopt different shapes or habits. These include cubic, fibrous (fine, long, needles), acicular (needle-like), lamellar (plate-like) and prismatic. It is very unusual for perfect crystals to be found, but even poorly formed ones will always show evidence of their intrinsic symmetry. Many fillers (as will be discussed later) being extracted from the earth or rocks and processed by fairly simple methods will exhibit the same basic original shapes. Others, however, may be extracted by complicated routes or involve intensive comminution, thus altering particle shape. This is determined by the chemical nature and strength of the bonds between the atoms and groups in the mineral. These depend on electronegative differences between atoms and the bonding can range from covalent through to ionic. Two other types of interaction or bonding are important. Hydrogen forms co-ordinate bonds with atoms with very high electro-negativities, such as oxygen. This is very important in hydrated minerals such as kaolinite and gibbsite,
18
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials with layers being bonded together by these relatively weak hydrogen bonds. In ‘neutral units’ another weak force, known as Van der Waals bonding, due to non-uniform charge distributions, bonds group together. The types and strengths of bonds present in the crystal determine the methods by which the minerals break down on processing. Thus in the calcite crystal, the weakest bonds exist between the calcium ion and the carbonate group and these cleave invariably, giving rise to a regular rhombohedral shape. Kaolin platelets, held by hydrogen bonds, separate more readily from each other rather than fracture. In talc, magnesium silicate layers are held together by weak Van der Waals forces and very readily undergo cleavage into progressively thinner plates.
1.2.9.3 Assessment and Measurement of Shape The shapes outlined previously are very difficult to specify precisely using Euclidean geometry, but various approaches have been attempted to describe shape, anisotropy and ‘structure’ as numbers. Structure is particularly interesting and, while only really recognised currently in the elastomer field, it probably has significance, as yet overlooked, in other areas. In synthetic fillers it is sometimes difficult to separate fundamental from aggregate shape but, where there is sufficient incentive, then ways will usually be found to overcome such difficulties. Such incentives arose in carbon blacks and more recently in precipitated silica, where shapes are very complex, but an understanding is critical to their high value usage in the tyre industry. Much work has been done, especially by Medalia and Heckman [16], and by Hess and co-workers [17], to develop automatic image analysis procedures. Using such procedures, all the aspects described previously have been investigated. This work has much to teach us about other filler particles. Fractal geometry is now showing great promise for describing the shape of various complex, irregular particles. As usual, the carbon black industry is leading the way in exploring the potential of fractals for describing fillers and promising results are already emerging. A good introduction to fractal geometry and its applications to particles can be found in the excellent work by Kaye [18], and a number of recent papers have explored the measurement and significance of fractal dimensions of filler particles including carbon black [19-21]. The importance of measuring ‘structure’ results from its role in describing the ability of a particle to trap and partly shield a portion of the polymer matrix from deformation. This is generally known as an occluded polymer and its presence is important, especially in many of the unique properties of carbon and silica-filled elastomers. A simplified picture is given in Figure 1.3 and structure can be thought of as increasing the effective filler volume. While the carbon black industry is leading the way in using sophisticated techniques to measure shape and assess structure, they are also prepared to use fairly simple measurements, and in particular the oil absorption procedure with certain refinements, to give a quantification of this parameter [22].
19
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 1.3 Schematic illustration of the effect of particle structure and occluded polymer
The shape of simple particulate fillers is usually expressed as its aspect ratio (AR), which is the ratio of the particle’s diameter to its thickness. Measurement of aspect ratio is relatively simple for large particles, although time consuming. But, for the micrometer-sized particles that are normally encountered in fillers used in polymers, it is difficult, needs expensive equipment (such as scanning electron microscopes), and is very time consuming, depending on the spread of aspect ratios normally found. Other techniques are being sought to give an easier, more rapid measurement. Fourty reports that a comparison of particle-size distribution curves measured by sedimentation and laser diffraction techniques can give a shape factor [23]. Electrical conductivity of an aqueous suspension of a mineral under flow compared with it at rest (after the particles have randomised) gives a mean value for AR or a shape factor. Reasonable agreement with electron microscopy has been found [24]. This complex situation is further complicated by the fact that not only is shape often dependent on size, but measurement of size is affected by shape. This interdependence is discussed next and also in the descriptions of individual minerals given in Chapter 2.
1.2.10 Particle Size 1.2.10.1 Introduction Particle size is a very important, property of a filler, but is a particularly complex area where great confusion still occurs. For an individual, naturally occurring, filler it will have been determined by the origin and mineralogy of the deposit from which it has been extracted, by the method used in mining, and by separation procedures used during processing. For synthetic fillers, size will be determined by the conditions used
20
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials in its synthesis such as precipitation and possibly by the drying and any coating procedures. Size is one variable that can be controlled (in theory at least), and its importance is felt at all stages of composite production and use. Hence, there is considerable interest in its measurement. Particle size distributions are more useful than single average values, although the latter have the merit of simplicity. Size is an easy property to measure reproducibly using a variety of techniques including sieving, sedimentation, optical scattering and diffraction from particulate suspensions. Each, however, has a different dependence upon particle dimension and varies with particle shape. Thus correlation between different minerals measured by different techniques, in different laboratories is difficult. Again the reader is referred to one of the specialised books on the subject [25]. The problems arise from the fact that most filler particles are irregular in shape and contain a wide range of sizes, some of which will be individual particles and others agglomerates (also with a different shape from the individual particles). In such instances it is not possible to describe fully the particle size by a few numbers, as is often attempted. Commercially, most producers will quote two or three values to indicate the size of their fillers (see Section 1.2.10.2 and Chapter 2). Thus the data used in published studies are often a poor approximation of the real situation and can be very misleading. Wherever possible, the reader should try to determine and to use the full particle size distribution curve and be very cautious in interpreting literature studies in which only limited data such as average particle sizes or surface areas are given. In particular very small amounts of particles above or below a critical size can sometimes dominate certain properties, (e.g., viscosity, fatigue, tensile and impact strength) but will not be apparent in many particle size determinations. An interesting example of the effect of small amounts of oversize particles on the properties of carbon black-filled elastomers has been given by Gent [26].
1.2.10.2 Particle Size Measurement As already stated, filler suppliers usually quote three or four properties as a measure of the particle size: 1. Top cut. This is the size below which the majority (usually 99% or 99.9% by weight) of the particles are finer. 2. Coarse particles may also be reported as that percentage above a certain size. 3. Average particle size is obtained from particle size distribution curves and is the size that 50% of the particles are below. This can be defined in a variety of ways, e.g., by weight, volume or number, and care must be taken to understand the definition being used.
21
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 4. Specific surface area. This is determined by a number of adsorption techniques and is affected by size, shape and structure of the filler particles. Coarse particles, i.e., particles above 40 μm in size are usually quoted separately and are measured by screening the filler through standard mesh sieves. This may be carried out in aqueous suspension or as a dry powder. If the filler is heavily agglomerated then erroneous results may be obtained especially in dry screening. For accuracy, aqueous measurements are preferred with the filler being completely dispersed both by mechanical means and also using a dispersing agent. An idea of the structure and ease of dispersion of a filler may be obtained by comparing screen residues obtained by both wet and dry screening. If the filler is hydrophobic, then difficulties will be encountered in wet screening. These may be overcome by dispersing the filler in an organic liquid such as butanol, but a wetting agent and a dispersing agent are often both required. For some applications it is important to know the amount of particles that exceed 10 μm. This may be obtained by sieving but practical difficulties due to sieve screen blinding can occur. The most widely used techniques in this case involve sedimentation in a fluid, usually water and applying Stokes’ law. This states that, under standard equilibrium conditions, the time, t, taken for a particle to settle to a fixed depth is inversely proportional to the square root of its spherical diameter, d. This is given in Equation 1.2: ⎡
1/ 2
⎤ ⎥ d = 10 ⎢ ρ s − ρ f gt ⎥ ⎣ ⎦ 4⎢
(
18ηl
)
(1.2)
where d is the particle diameter, η is the viscosity of the fluid, ρs and ρf are the densities of the solid and the fluid, respectively, g is the gravitational constant and t is the time for the particle to settle a distance, l. Diameters obtained in this manner are precise descriptions of the particles but will compare with the results of other techniques only when the particles are perfectly spherical. In practice, most fillers have irregularly shaped particles and it is common to interpret experimental data in terms of theories applicable to spherical particles. Dimensions obtained are then for ‘equivalent spherical diameters’ (esd), which are the diameters of spheres that would give the same behaviour as that obtained from the sample by the method in question. Specific surface area is usually measured by the quantitative adsorption of nitrogen following the procedure originally described by Brunauer, Emmett and Teller, and known as the BET method (Equation 1.3) [27]: 22
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials P V (Po − P )
=
C −1 P 1 + VmC VmC Po
(1.3)
where V is the volume of gas, under standard conditions, adsorbed at equilibrium pressure, P; Vm is the volume of gas necessary for monolayer coverage; Po is the saturation pressure; and C is the BET constant. Often only a single point measurement is made to obtain surface area, but it is much more reliable to measure adsorptions at several pressures and then plot P/ V(Po – P) against P/Po. Permeability of a bed of packed particles to a fluid can also be used to give a surface area [28]. However, there are major sources of difficulty and confusion in describing particle size and shape. These include adequately defining what subdivision of material is to be described as the particle, in relying on particle size measurements carried out on the powdered particulate as an adequate description of it in a composite, and how shape and size interact.
1.2.10.3 Primary Particles, Agglomerates and Aggregates It surprises many people that a variety of ‘particles’ can exist in a powder, each of which can be determined as the particle size under certain conditions of dispersion and measurement. Moreover, the appropriate particle size for consideration can itself vary according to whether one is dealing with powder flow, behaviour during compounding and dispersion, or the properties of the final composite. These different types of particles are generally described as primary or ultimate particles, agglomerates and aggregates. In some instances these particle types are readily distinguishable but in others there can be appreciable overlap. Before discussing the types of particle in detail it is necessary to clarify the terminology as two contradicting conventions are widely used, and this in itself is a cause of considerable confusion. The need is to distinguish between collections of particles that are weakly and strongly bonded together. In this book we shall use the term agglomerate for weakly bonded particle collections and aggregate for strongly bonded ones. This is opposed to the views of Kaye [18] based on the derivations of the two words. The chosen terminology is, however, at least as widely used and is especially prevalent in the carbon black industry. The reader should always ascertain which terminology is in use when reading articles in the literature. An idealised view of particle type and breakdown with work during composite formation is presented in Figure 1.4. This goes beyond primary particles and considers the case where fragmentation of these may occur, e.g., hollow glass beads during thermoplastic compounding. With such simple systems it is usually fairly easy to match the particle sizing method to the degree of dispersion expected in the composite and obtain realistic answers. 23
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 1.4 Idealised view of the way filler particles disperse and of the different forms of particle types that might be encountered
Unfortunately, many filler systems do not exhibit such simple profiles, and the steps shown are often less sharp and overlap. Some possibilities are shown in Figure 1.5. A further complication arises when agglomerates form from initially well-dispersed systems. These agglomerates are sometimes referred to as flocs and can arise due to loss of colloidal stability in polymerising systems, or to reticulation (filler network formation) above the glass transition, especially in cured elastomers, an effect often observed with carbon blacks. The most difficult situation to deal with is quite frequently met with synthetic products, especially those formed by precipitation. This is where quite strong, complex aggregates are present, in addition to agglomerates. These aggregates often break down slowly, leading to a drawn-out step in the effective size profile. Frequently, they do not fully break down to primary particles under normal processing conditions. The effective particle size will then be critically dependent on the exact processing conditions and will be very difficult to predict in advance. Precipitated calcium carbonates are a good example where this type of situation is encountered. Most particle sizing techniques attempt to break down powders to their primary sizes by use of intensive mixing, ultrasonics and dispersants, but even these can be insufficient. Curves of the type shown in Figures 1.4 and 1.5 would be very useful for predicting filler behaviour, especially if the work input could be related to different compounding procedures. In principle, this should be possible, at least in a semi-quantitative way, by varying the energy used in dispersing the powder. Such procedures have been found
24
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials
Figure 1.5 Complex particle dispersion behaviour, as often encountered with fine, precipitated fillers
valuable by one of the authors and some very useful preliminary work of this type has been reported by Thoma and co-workers [29]. Some typical results obtained by the author (RR) with a coated precipitated calcium carbonate are given in Table 1.3 (Note only average particle size values are given for illustrative purposes, the earlier comments about
Table 1.3 Effect of measuring conditions on the apparent particle size of a coated precipitated calcium carbonate Measuring Condition
Average particle size (μm)
Comments
Laser diffraction of organic dispersion using weak ultrasonics
20
Detecting agglomerates
Laser diffraction of organic dispersion using medium ultrasonics
4
Detecting basic aggregate size
Laser diffraction of organic dispersion using strong ultrasonics
0.2
Detecting some form of sub-aggregate structure
Electron microscopy
0.07
Detecting primary crystallite size
X-ray line broadening
0.07
Detecting primary crystallite size
25
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites the dangers of using a single value for a distribution still apply). Furnace-type carbon blacks provide a good example of the problems involved with concepts and terminology in this area. Such carbon black particles are formed by partial fusion and solidification of very small spherical units. These spherical units are generally referred to as the primary particles. Under no compounding or particle-sizing conditions, however, is it possible to break down the actual particles completely into these ultimate units. Unfortunately, some breakdown of the fused structures does occur, depending on the processing conditions, so that it is not appropriate to consider these fused structures as the ultimate particle either. In view of these complexities, the best rule is to keep the basic principles as outlined previously firmly in mind when trying to relate particle size as determined on a powder to what happens in an actual composite. As mentioned before, many of the previous problems would be removed if there were simple and reliable methods for assessing the ‘effective’ particle size in the polymer matrix. Various methods can be used including microscopy and contact radiology, both coupled with image analysis, and recovery from the polymer followed by conventional sizing techniques, although none are completely satisfactory. A more detailed discussion of some of these aspects will be found in Chapter 5. In the authors’ opinions the understanding of filled composites would be greatly improved by advances in this area.
1.3 Surface Modification Surface modification of fillers to give improved properties to a polymer composite is a topic that has received enormous attention over the last 30 years. Improvements in mechanical properties, dispersion of the filler (which leads to improved properties), improved rheology and higher filler loading have all been reported to accrue from rendering the surface more hydrophobic and hence compatible with the polymer or by enabling the filler to bond covalently, through hydrogen or ionic bonds to the polymer; or by changing the physical nature of the interface so that energy absorption can occur. This section will deal mainly with mineral surface interactions. The use of surface modifiers is dealt with at length in Chapter 4 and specific examples are described in Chapters 2, 7, 8 and 9.
1.3.1 Stearic Acid and Stearates The most widely used surface modification is treatment with stearic acid. This is believed to result in a stearate salt coating on most fillers and metal stearates are also used. Stearic acid will react with basic minerals to give a surface that is covered with strongly bonded long organic ions (this is discussed in more detail in Chapter 4). Stearic acidmodified silicates are commercially available but in these cases the stearic acid is almost
26
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials certainly weakly adsorbed and probably desorbs during melt compounding. Similarly, metal stearates will form weak bonds with mineral surfaces and desorb from them. Organo-amines have been used to render silicate surfaces hydrophobic, bonding probably through strong coordinate bonds. These relatively labile coatings will help improve dispersion in the initial stages of a compounding operation, before they desorb. They also give a protective coating to the filler, minimising any polymer degradation that may occur before stabilisers, antioxidants, etc., are fully dispersed.
1.3.2 Coupling Agents Surface treatments with bi-functional additives, which form very strong covalent bonds to the filler and then bond to a polymer by a variety of mechanisms, are widely available. They are based on organo-metallic compounds with the general formula: (RI)a M(RII)b
(1.4)
where M is a metal ion with valency a + b; RI is an organic group, the choice of which depends on the polymer in which it is to be used and RII is a group designed to react with a mineral surface. The most commonly encountered compounds are organo-silanes [30] and organotitanates [31], but others, including organo-zirconates [32], organo-borates [33] and complexes of chromium [34] have been proposed. R II in most of the coupling agents is an alkoxy group (methoxy, ethoxy or 2-methoxyethoxy are common), which is reactive to hydroxyl groups and to water. The preferred reaction mechanism is for hydrolysis to occur, initially by reaction with environmental or adsorbed water, with the kinetics being affected by the nature of both the alkoxy and other reactive groups on the molecule. The organo-metallic hydroxide then condenses with hydroxyls on the mineral surface or it can form oligomers followed by polymers by self-condensation reactions [35]. Multiple layers of many coupling agents can be adsorbed onto a mineral surface, with the packing of the coupling reagent on the surface being determined by the size of the RI organic group [36]. The structure of these layers can be very complex, with both strongly and weakly adsorbed species being present. This is discussed in detail in Chapter 4.
1.3.3 Polymer Modifications To try to improve energy absorption at the interface, and hence improve composite toughness, modification of the filler with a polymeric, low modulus, interlayer has
27
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites been reported [37]. There have been many papers published on this technique. Aivazyan and co-workers [38] review the surface modification of mineral fillers by polymer deposition, using polymer adsorption from solution, mixing of polymer with dispersed filler and hetero-coagulation of latex polymer particles on the filler. Good bonds between coating and filler are often achieved by grafting a reactive group on to the interfacial polymer before or during filler treatment. Thus, kaolin can be coated with a styrenediacetone acrylamide copolymer by dispersing the two monomers with the clay in an aqueous medium and polymerising with a persulfate catalyst [39]. Unsaturated monomers have been adsorbed on to fillers and then polymerised to give encapsulated products. The modulus of the polymer could be modified by selecting the monomer [40]. Acrylic acid-vinyl chloride (1:99) has been polymerised on to calcium carbonate [41]; reports of the use of 3,5-triacryloxyhexahydro-S-triazine [42], bis-phenol A and epichlorohydrin [43], methyl methacrylate [44], and acrylic acid [45] have also been published. Graft copolymers between unsaturated acids, especially acrylic acid and maleic anhydride (MA), and polyolefins (PE and PP) are widely used as surface modifiers and compatibilisers, sometimes in combination with bi-functional coupling agents [46], for talc, calcium carbonate and calcined clays. Such polymer coatings include polypropylene-maleic anhydride [47], polypropylene cis-4-cyclohexene-1,2 dicarboxylic acid [48], polystearyl or polylauryl acrylate [49], polypropylene-acrylic acid, partially oxidised poly(butane diol) [50] and ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymers [51]. Acidcontaining products can react with basic fillers. With most other types, they will simply adsorb on to the mineral surface, but they can form esters with some non-basic metal hydroxyls, notably silanols.
1.3.4 Direct Bonding Polymers themselves can be grafted on to a mineral surface and the resulting composites have been reported to be significantly better than simple mixes because of strong covalent polymer-filler bonds. Composites of clay with ethylene-MA graft copolymer, in which the anhydride groups interact with the hydroxyl groups on the surface of the clay, give increased impact strength and flexural modulus compared with a physical blend of clay and ethylene-MA random copolymers [52]. Polymerisation of monomers can be induced on the mineral by natural catalytic sites on its surface [53] or by adsorbing polymerisation catalysts on to the mineral prior to treatment with monomers [54, 55].
28
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials
1.4 Particle Packing and the Maximum Packing Fraction 1.4.1 Introduction The packing behaviour of particles in a polymer matrix determines at what loading particle/particle effects become important and is a critical factor in the understanding and design of polymer composites, especially when highly filled systems are involved. The maximum packing fraction, Pf, is a particularly useful concept. This is the maximum volume fraction of particulate that can be incorporated before a continuous network is developed and voids begin to appear in the composite. In addition to indicating the maximum practical loadings obtainable, Pf is also useful in understanding and describing the effect of filler loading on composite properties. Many properties change rapidly as one approaches Pf, almost in a percolation way, and this parameter is now incorporated into many mathematical treatments of property-loading dependence [56]. Indeed, it often goes a long way to explaining why different physical forms of the same filler material can give markedly differing results at the same loading.
1.4.2 Determination of Maximum Packing Fraction (Pf) by Oil Absorption Procedures Despite its utility, Pf is difficult to measure or predict with great precision. This is due to complex interactions between the particles and the polymer matrix, and the influence of the fabrication method used. Both of these factors affect the way the particles pack and make conventional measurements of packing, such as the tap density of the powder, of limited quantitative value. This is especially true for many typical particulate fillers, which, due to their fine size and irregular shapes, exhibit particle agglomeration and do not pack well in the dry state. Such powders often pack considerably better when wetted by suitable liquids, especially if dispersants are present. These wetting and dispersing effects lie behind the pragmatic approach of using oil absorption procedures to determine an effective Pf. Originally introduced for application in putty and paint technology, oil absorption methods rely on titrating a sample of powder with an oil or other liquid, while continually rubbing and mixing the mass. End-points are readily detected in these procedures, often defined as the point at which a putty of a certain consistency is obtained. It is generally believed that at this point all the particles are dispersed and wetted, and all the gaps between the particles are just filled with liquid. In practice, only two liquids are used to any extent, linseed oil and phthalate esters. Both simple manual and instrumental methods are available for determining oil absorption values. It is important that standard procedures are closely followed if reproducible results are to be obtained and a number of standards have been issued. The simplest procedure is the spatula rub-out method, which is embodied in ASTM D281 [57]. A useful description of its application to particulate fillers has been given by Ferrigno [58].
29
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Oil-absorption results are usually quoted as cubic centimetres of oil per 100 grams of particulate at the end point. Simple mathematical treatment using oil and particle densities can then convert this to a volume fraction. As a guide, linseed oil absorptions for calcium carbonate of 20 cm3 100 g-1 and 50 cm3 100 g-1 correspond to filler volume fractions of 0.64 and 0.41, respectively. The attraction of the oil absorption methods lies in their simplicity and their crude approximation to polymer processing. Different liquids are also observed to give markedly different values and this is believed to be due to their respective abilities to wet out and disperse the particles. Thus in theory, by choosing a liquid of similar properties to the polymer in question, one should be able to improve the usefulness of the data, although this does not seem to have been greatly used to date. As mentioned previously, only two liquids are commonly used and, of these, linseed oil generally gives lower values suggesting that it wets and disperses particles better than phthalates. The phthalates are popular because they are widely used as plasticisers in PVC compounds. Liquid paraffins have been used as model systems for olefinic polymers, and squalane could be used as a model system for PP. A detailed study of the oil absorption test and its meaning in terms of particle packing has been reported by Huisman [59]. He found that the agglomerates present in the original powder are frequently not fully dispersed during the test, but may be compressed and reduced in porosity. The degree to which this occurs critically affects the packing and hence the oil-absorption value. Differences in the degree of compaction obtained go a long way to explaining variation in oil-absorption values between different operators, and between manual and instrumental methods, as well as between different liquids. While oil absorption serves a useful purpose as a guide to the effective value of Pf, great care must be taken in applying it too literally. In some polymer systems there may be a good match with the polymer wetting properties and the dispersion procedures. In others this may be very poor. Oil absorption values are widely used for assessing carbon black properties in the rubber industry. In this field, special procedures have been developed to attempt to reproduce the effect of rubber compounding conditions on particle morphology [22].
1.4.3 Particle Packing Theory Much effort has been devoted to studying the effect of particle size and shape on the packing properties of powders. Special attention has been given to identifying those factors that allow high packing fractions to be obtained. This subject is very relevant to the design of filler systems and the general principles, which often cause considerable confusion, are outlined here. For greater detail specialist publications such as that by German should be consulted [60].
30
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials The packing behaviour of particulate materials depends largely on their particle size, shape and surface characteristics. The behaviour of model systems with closely defined size and shape distributions is now well understood. Real particulate materials are much harder to treat, largely due to the difficulty in determining and describing their size and shape distributions accurately. Nevertheless, the principles derived for the model systems can be applied in a semi-quantitative way and appear to work reasonably well. The aims of particle packing theory are to predict the maximum volume fraction that can be obtained under a given set of circumstances and the structure of the particle assembly at this point. The first point to appreciate is that there are several ways of packing the same collection of particles, each one resulting in a different maximum volume fraction. The circumstances under which the particles are assembled will determine which of these structures is obtained in practice. In the extreme case consider a three-dimensional jigsaw puzzle. With care this can be assembled to give perfect packing with no free space. This is known as ordered packing. However, if the pieces are put in a container and shaken, it is extremely unlikely that they will ever discover this perfect packed structure. Nevertheless, it will be found that, providing there are enough particles, a certain packed density can be reproducibly obtained implying that some statistically balanced structure is obtainable. This is known as a random packing situation. More than one ordered and random packing fraction may be observed with many systems. Appreciation of the nature of ordered and random packing is important in understanding the application of packing theory. Ordered packing results in long-range structure as in a crystal lattice and, although it can sometimes be observed in suspensions of monodisperse spherical particles, is not of great importance in our context. As its name implies, random packing is a statistical process with no long-range structure and it is more relevant to particulate-filled composites. While some ordered packing configurations can be of very low density, ordered packing will always be capable of giving higher packing densities than random packing. Two classes of random packing are recognised, loose and dense random packing. Loose packing refers to the sort of packing obtained when particles are randomly assembled under conditions where they cannot easily move past each other, while in dense random packing, conditions are such that movement is possible. In powder technology terms, loose random packing corresponds with a pour density and dense random packing to a tapped density. The simplest case to consider first is the packing of smooth, regular, mono-sized particles. This has been well studied for smooth spherical particles, which can readily move past one another. With these particles a maximum ordered packing fraction of 0.74 has been established, although other, less dense packings are feasible. Random loose packing fraction is difficult to predict accurately but is about 0.60. Random dense packing is more readily predicted and is about 0.64.
31
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites The theory has been extended quantitatively to a number of regular, non-spherical shapes. Many of these such as cubes, rectangles and plates can have ordered packing fractions of unity but most have less dense random packing than spheres, largely due to the difficulty of the particles moving with respect to one another to optimise packing. Cubic particles do, however, seem to have a slightly higher random packing density than spheres (about 0.75). Quantification of the packing behaviour of irregular particles is poorly developed at present but the enhanced interparticle friction soon causes the packing fraction to decrease as the particles depart from sphericity. Values of 0.50 are not uncommon for three-dimensional irregular particles. Very low packing fractions (<0.1) are obtained with high aspect ratio fibres. The general approach to obtaining high packing fraction powders is to use small particles to fill in the pores in the packed structure obtained from large particles and then to use even smaller particles to fill in the remaining pores and so on. A simple view of this is presented in Figure 1.6. The approach is known as multimodal packing, and much effort has been devoted to defining the optimum particle size ratios and quantities of the various modes and the resulting packing fraction obtained. The case of spherical particles provides the simplest example. As we have already seen, the maximum ordered packing fraction is 0.74. From geometric principles it can be shown that this structure has two sizes of pores present, which can be filled by spheres with 22.5% and 41.4% of the diameter of the largest spheres. This results in an increase in packing fraction to 0.81. Unfortunately, such simple geometric calculations are not possible for the more relevant random packing situation, even when spherical particles are involved. This is because there will be a random distribution of pore sizes and the small particles will not spread out evenly among them. In particular, the small particles show a tendency to cluster around the
Figure 1.6 Classical bimodal packing effect
32
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials surface of the larger ones, increasing their spacing [61]. It can be shown, however, that the limiting case for random packing of a bimodal distribution of spherical particles of a single material is achieved at a packing fraction of 0.86. This is obtained with 73% large and 27% small particles and a size ratio of at least 7:1 and preferably up to 20:1 [62]. As with ordered packing, increasing the number of modes improves the packing, but similar ratios are needed for each mode. This soon results in an excessively wide particle size distribution accompanied by ever decreasing benefits. Three modes give a limiting random packed fraction of 0.91 and the ultimate limiting value appears to be 0.96. The packing behaviour of multimodal mixtures of irregular particles is very poorly understood at present, although some empirical studies have been made on simple systems. Where different sizes of similar shapes are mixed, then improvements in packing similar to those observed with spheres are usually obtained but starting from a lower level. It also appears that a wide difference in sizes and a large proportion (by weight) of the bigger particles is advantageous. Where different shapes are involved then the picture is very unclear and the packing density may even decrease. While the multimodal approach is theoretically attractive and is useful for understanding the general principles, it has some practical limitations. Continuous particle size distributions are often more readily achieved and less costly and so more relevant. Much work has gone into trying to predict the optimum shape of distribution for maximum packing. This is a very complex subject but it has been shown that packing fractions as good as those obtained from the multimodal approach can be obtained from carefully controlled continuous particle size distributions. These distributions are hard to define and are usually developed empirically. They can, however, be looked upon as being derived from multimodal principles. In general, such distributions are skewed having an abundance by weight of large particles and a long tail to the fine end.
1.4.4 Applications of Packing Principles to Particulate Filled Composites The packing principles outlined in the previous section are of great value in preparing filler size distributions capable of being processed at high loadings in polymeric systems. In the extreme case monomodal spherical particles can be specially synthesised and mixed together but this is only worthwhile in a few high value applications, such as light curable dental resins. More often adjustments are made to the natural particle size distribution of standard fillers composed of irregular particles to improve the packing. These adjustments may be by classification to remove certain fractions or by blending in extra material in specific size ranges. In some instances narrow sieve fractions are prepared and recombined in set proportions. Where comminution is used to produce fillers then the processing can be controlled to some extent to produce favourable size distributions. Practical procedures for producing maximum packing systems were originally worked
33
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites out by Furnas [63] and have recently been described in some detail by Ferrigno [64]. It must be borne in mind, however, that other considerations may restrict the particle size range that can be tolerated in a composite. While particle distributions prepared according to packing principles generally give the highest processable loadings in polymers, the prediction of these loadings and the measurement of the effective maximum packing fraction, is not very easy. As mentioned earlier a number of different random packing fractions can exist for the same collection of particles depending on the assembly conditions. Particle packing is usually determined on a powder, by procedures such as pour or tap density, or by some compression process. These are not very relevant as the particles used as fillers tend to be relatively fine and irregular and do not pack well under these conditions. When processed into polymers, the matrix itself, or additives, together with the compounding procedures, can drastically alter particle packing behaviour. Different types of packing are also relevant to different processing conditions. Where flow is required then some sort of random loose packing is probably the maximum achievable, whereas if the dispersion is subsequently compression moulded with squeezing out of excess matrix, then a denser random packing becomes more relevant. Where particles can readily move with respect to one another and a dense packed arrangement is readily obtained, then the phenomenon of dilatancy, or shear thickening, may be observed. This is caused by the need for the particles to move to a more open structure before flow can occur. In such cases processing difficulties may rule out use of compositions based on the dense packing configuration. As has been discussed earlier, procedures such as oil absorption, although imperfect, probably remain the best way of determining a relevant Pf.
1.5 Interparticle Spacing The distance between filler particles in a polymer matrix is an important consideration, which often does not receive the attention it deserves. It can be appreciated that composite properties may be markedly affected when this distance becomes very small. This is partly because the polymer chains may not now have the full freedom of movement they would have in the bulk polymer. Equally importantly, if there is a shell of modified polymer adsorbed on the particles, then at some limiting spacing this shell will overlap with that on adjacent particles leading to a percolation effect and to this phase dominating some properties (Figure 1.7). It can also be shown that the critical distance of separation is likely to be a small number of radii of gyration of polymer chains (20-200 nm). Interparticle spacing is directly determined by the number of particles present and this changes markedly with particle size. This is dramatically illustrated in Figure 1.8 by the micrographs of two poly(methylmethacrylate) composites containing equal volume fractions of aluminium hydroxide of differing particle size.
34
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials
Figure 1.7 Idealised view of the effect of interparticle distance and of absorbed polymer on composite structure and properties
Figure 1.8 Scanning electron microscope images of cross-sections of poly(methylmethacrylate) filled with equal volume fractions of two different particle size aluminium hydroxide fillers: a) 55% coarse particles, b) 55% fine particles
35
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
1.6 Particle Effects on the Structure of Polymers 1.6.1 Introduction There is now considerable evidence that particulate fillers, especially inorganics, can significantly affect the structure of the matrix polymer itself, and hence the properties of the final composite. Such effects can vary enormously from system to system and have largely been overlooked in many studies of filled composites. The existence of these effects may explain many of the anomalies reported in trying to develop and apply generalised predictive equations [65]. Matrix modifications can occur in a number of ways and the effect on properties can sometimes be at least as important as that arising from the much more widely recognised interfacial bonding effects. Unfortunately, no systematic study of this area has yet been made. The principal ways in which a particulate phase may affect polymer structure are: 1. Molecular weight reduction during processing. 2. Molecular weight and crosslink modifications due to interference with curing processes. 3. Adsorption of polar, low molecular weight species such as surfactants, plasticisers, stabilisers and antioxidants and oxidation products. 4. Formation of an immobilised shell of polymer around the particles. Often this shell is rich in a certain molecular weight fraction, which is then depleted in the matrix. 5. Modification of crystallinity in semi-crystalline polymers. 6. Effects on polymer conformation due to particle surfaces and inter-particle spacing. A brief description of the various effects together with examples of their importance is given in the next section.
1.6.2 Molecular Weight Reduction During Processing It is well known that polymers may undergo mechanochemical degradation during compounding and moulding operations [66]. Indeed this is an important feature of natural rubber processing. As most properties are dependent on molecular weight, this can play an important role in determining final properties and conditions (including the use of stabilisers) are usually chosen to limit any degradation.
36
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials As has already been discussed, and will be returned to later, the introduction of a particulate phase may markedly affect the amount of degradation. The usual effect is for degradation to be increased due to increased mechanical work, to chemical interactions at the interface and possibly to deactivation of stabilisers and antioxidants. The effect is most pronounced under conditions (especially high loadings) where viscosities are high, leading to excessive shear forces being developed. Such effects have been reported in filled elastomers [67] and polypropylene [68].
1.6.3 Molecular Weight and Crosslinking Changes due to Cure Modifications The detailed microstructure of free-radical cured polymers determines their overall properties, and is governed by the rate of cure and relative rates of various competitive polymerisation processes such as: initiation, propagation, combination and termination. Inorganic particles can modify the cure process in several ways. In particular, by lowering the overall exotherm, they can significantly reduce the cure temperature and kinetics, thus altering the relative rates of the various processes described above. The surface of the particles can also play a role by absorbing and altering the stability of the growing polymers, or by absorbing and altering the activity of the initiator and curative. Most of these effects have been reported but, unfortunately, structure determination is very difficult with crosslinked systems and little or no direct evidence for resulting structure changes has been reported. An example of the effect of different filler particles on the curing of unsaturated polyesters (and by inference on their structure), as measured by the cure exotherm, has been given by Plueddemann and Stark [69].
1.6.4 Preferential Adsorption of Polar Species Polar materials are usually more strongly adsorbed on particulates than is the matrix polymer and, where present, can displace the polymer altogether from the surface. This can modify the composite properties in two ways. Firstly, it may lead to a weak interfacial bond. Secondly, where the polar species was providing a significant matrix function such as plasticisation, cure modification or flow enhancement, this can be lost. Good examples of the preferential adsorption of polar materials have been given by Barnett and Jones [70], Evans and co-workers [71] and by Karlivan and co-workers [72]. Barnett and Jones carried out some elegant and painstaking work on the effect of mineral fillers on the reinforcement of emulsion-polymerised SBR. This type of elastomer contains high levels of organic surfactants remaining from the polymerisation process. Certain mineral fillers gave exceptional and unexpected reinforcement properties, which were
37
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites demonstrated to be due to the preferential adsorption of these surfactants, resulting in a significant improvement in the strength of the matrix. This strength improvement was, at least in part, due to modification of the curing process showing how complex and inter-related the effects of adding particulates can sometimes be. More recently, Evans and Rothon have shown how fatty acids prevent the formation of bound rubber when precipitated calcium carbonate is used as a filler in SBR elastomers. When they are absent, high levels of bound rubber are formed, accompanied by a marked increase in reinforcement. Karlivan demonstrated how certain inorganic fillers could be used to preferentially adsorb low molecular weight polar species produced by thermo-oxidation of polyolefins. These species tend to form during heat welding of polyolefins to metals and, by accumulating at the interface, limit the adhesive strength. Their removal markedly improved adhesion.
1.6.5 Formation of an Interphase of Immobilised Polymer It is now well established that, in the absence of competing polar species, molecules of the matrix polymer can be effectively adsorbed on to the surface of a particulate phase, even when this is an inorganic mineral. The strength of this adsorption can play a key role in determining composite properties as will be discussed in later chapters. It is also generally recognised that this adsorbed polymer may have different properties from the bulk, but the consequences of this for composite properties are often overlooked. This is partly because, as we shall see, the effects only become significant at high loadings and with small particles, but also because the adsorbed layers are hard to detect and characterise. Where they are observed, the effects can be at least as great as those associated with particle matrix bonding. The principal effect of this adsorbed layer is to increase the effective size and hence volume fraction of the particulate phase. A complication that has caused much confusion in the past, and is only just becoming recognised and understood, is the apparent variability in the thickness of the immobilised layer according to the method of measurement and the composite property being studied [73]. Once this difficulty is appreciated, its origins can be clearly understood. Thus, in the absence of other adsorbing species, there will be a primary layer of strongly adsorbed polymer at the filler surface. The conformation and properties of this are likely to be severely modified and probably in all instances it can be regarded as immobilised and contributing to particle volume. As one moves beyond this layer, the effects due to the particle do not suddenly disappear but will gradually tail away. This outer region will be less strongly associated with the particle and may only appear to be immobilised under certain test conditions.
38
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials As we shall see, while effects of particles can sometimes extend for large distances, the immobilised layer thickness generally appears to range from 1 to 50 nm and in many instances is much less than 10 nm. The effect of various layer thicknesses on the effective volume of different sized cubic particles is presented in Table 1.4. Only when the layer is of the order of 50 nm does it have much effect on particles over 1 μm in size, but even thin layers of 10 nm or less have a significant effect on particles about 0.5 μm, and this becomes dramatic as very small particles (0.1 μm) are reached. Because of their increased surface to volume ratio, anisotropic particles such as plates will show greater effects than those recorded in Table 1.4. Determination of the thickness of immobilised layers is far from straightforward and can give a variety of answers, as mentioned earlier.
Table 1.4 Calculated effect of surface layers on the apparent volume of various sized cubic particles Particle size (μm)
% volume increase for a layer thickness of: 1 nm
10 nm
100 nm
1000 nm
0.1
6
73
2600
-
0.5
1.2
12
174
-
1.0
0.6
6
73
2600
5.0
< 0.1
1.2
12
174
10.0
< 0.1
0.6
6
73
The adsorption and conformation of polymer molecules on particle surfaces is of great interest to colloid scientists, especially with regard to steric stabilisation of dispersions, and general guidelines can be obtained from their studies. A good description of the subject can be found in treatise such as that by Napper [74]. It is found that single point adsorption results in the molecule extending preferentially in a direction perpendicular to the surface and a layer thickness that approaches a value of twice the radius of gyration of the free polymer. The radius of gyration is dependent on molecular weight but for our purposes the effective layer thickness due to this type of conformation will be in the range of 20-40 nm. With most polymers of interest to us, multipoint attachment is more likely. This will significantly reduce the layer thickness until, in the limit of flat adsorption, this can be as low as 1 nm or less. The most direct method of determining the thickness of adsorbed polymer is by carrying out adsorption studies, either from a suitable solution of the polymer, or by extracting an actual composite and determining the residual or ‘bound’ polymer. Both approaches have
39
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites been used and the layer thickness is calculated from the volume of adsorbed polymer by dividing by the surface area of the particulate phase. The bound polymer approach has been frequently used in studies on carbon black-filled elastomers and several useful reviews have been published [75]. Unfortunately, the origin of bound polymer is complex and may be of limited use in characterising effects in the composite itself. Bound layer thicknesses determined in this way for carbon black-elastomer systems are usually of the order of 1-5 nm. There has been only limited work on determining bound polymer with mineral fillers and in polymers other than elastomers. Several studies have shown that bound rubber readily forms with high surface area silicas in elastomers [76], where calculated layer thicknesses are similar to those reported for carbon blacks. Evans and Rothon have reported on bound rubber formation with precipitated calcium carbonate in an elastomer system [71] and again the calculated layer thickness based on their data is less than 5 nm. Similar low values have been reported by Kosfeld and co-workers for kaolin and zinc sulfide [77] in a rubber-modified polypropylene and by Lipatov [78] and Boonstra [79] for silica-filled polyethylene. It is probable that these determinations only detect the polymer molecules that are strongly attached to the particles, probably in multipoint fashion. This explains the low values of thickness observed, but it does not necessarily follow that the immobilised, or modified thickness in composites is not significantly greater than this. In addition to bound polymer of the type described previously, polymer may also be shielded from some deformation processes by being occluded within the particle shape (See Section 2.8.2) and this is especially important with some carbon blacks. Viscosity measurements provide another fairly simple method for determining a layer thickness. For non-agglomerated particles, a fairly simple equation (Equation 1.5) exists relating relative viscosity of a suspension to the effective volume fraction of the solid phase: ηs – η = 1 + KΦ + K´Φ + …
(1.5)
Where ηs and η are the viscosities of the suspension and the solvent, respectively, K is a coefficient depending on particle size, shape and concentration, and Φ is the effective volume concentration. K can be determined in pure solvent without polymer being added and then used to determine the change in Φ resulting from addition of polymer. Viscometric determinations of this type tend to give quite high layer thicknesses of the order of several tens of nanometres. An example of this approach can be found in the work of Chibowski who studied the adsorption of polyacrylamide of different molecular weights on to the surface of titanium dioxide from aqueous solution [80]. He found effective layer thicknesses of 30-70 nm increasing with polymer molecular weight. The results obtained are, of course, influenced by the solvent. If possible, the measurements
40
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials should be carried out in a theta solvent, (i.e., one in which the dimensions of the polymer coil are the same as in the melt). Various procedures have been applied to composite materials to attempt to determine the amount and properties of the immobilised layer in situ. Much of the interest in this has been in the former eastern block countries of Europe and has been reviewed by Enikolopyan [81]. Among the measurements used have been density, specific heat, dielectric constant and dynamic mechanical analysis. The general conclusions are that, as one might expect from reduced configurational entropy, the surface layers are denser and more rigid than the bulk polymer. Again most work has been carried out on carbon black-filled elastomers. This has shown that a slight broadening can be observed in the glass transition of the polymer, which is interpreted as being that of the surface layers. Deconvolution indicates that the glass transition of these layers is about 10 °C higher than the matrix and the calculated volume of modified material approximates to a 3 nm layer [82]. Only isolated studies have been reported in other systems. Galeski has carried out thermal analysis of chalk-filled isotactic polypropylene [83]. Uncoated chalk was found to modify all the transitions present in the unfilled polymer and to lead to two new transitions assigned to restricted motion in the interface layers. These effects were largely eliminated when the chalk was surface treated, confirming their surface origin. No attempt was made to calculate layer thickness. Gerard and co-workers have reported on the effect of glass beads in a crosslinked epoxy matrix [84]. They used dynamic mechanical analysis and found the uncoated beads to reduce the mobility of the polymer, an effect that could be largely overcome by coating the beads. Analysis of this sort has much to offer and hopefully will be more widely applied in future work. Workers such as Pukansky and Tudos have developed procedures for calculating effective layer thicknesses from the mechanical properties of composites [85]. They have applied this to calcium carbonate-filled polypropylene and found the effective layer thickness to vary according to the property being measured. A value of 5 nm was obtained from Young’s moduli in agreement with the thicknesses expected for strongly bound polymer. A value of 150 nm was, however, calculated from tensile yield and strength calculations. It was postulated that the size of the effective interlayer depends on the elongation at which it is being determined. The aspect of bound or modified polymer still has many secrets to reveal and its existence and importance should always be assessed when new polymer/filler combinations are being developed, especially with high filler loadings and high surface area particles.
41
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
1.6.6 Effects on Polymer Conformation due to the Presence of Particle Surfaces and Interparticle Spacing The properties of polymers depend to a large degree on the conformations available to their chains. The presence of solid, particulate material can significantly modify these conformations, even in the absence of any particle-polymer interaction or other effects such as already discussed. Firstly, the presence of a solid surface will restrict the conformation of polymer molecules in its vicinity. This type of effect is widely recognised in colloid science where, as already mentioned, it has been extensively studied with regard to steric stabilisation of suspensions. Detailed treatment can be found in works such as those of Napper [74]. The basic findings are that, in the absence of multipoint attachment, chain molecules respond to this restriction by expanding in a direction parallel to the surface. This expansion can double the effective molecular size in that direction. Secondly, polymer molecules occupy quite considerable volumes, depending on their molecular weight and temperature. At high filler loadings, especially with ultrafine particles, the interparticle spacing may be of similar size or smaller. This must mean that the polymer molecules will be forced to take up a strained conformation and thereby be considerably modified in their properties. While these effects are undoubtedly present in particulate composites they have not, to the authors’ knowledge, been addressed in any detail so that their significance is still largely unknown.
1.6.7 Effects on Crystallinity There is sufficient evidence available to show that particulate fillers can affect the crystallinity of some polymers and that this may in turn affect mechanical properties. Despite this, the area has received surprisingly little attention and many studies of filler/ property effects in semi-crystalline polymers do not consider this possibility. Many thermoplastic materials are semi-crystalline and the precise nature of this crystallinity plays a major role in determining their properties. In addition to the level of crystallinity, factors such as crystal phase, crystallite numbers, orientation, size and shape are all important, but the exact way in which they affect properties is far from understood. In unfilled polymers the crystallites generally seem to be present in spherulitic aggregates [86]. Because of hindered motion, thermoplastics have a marked tendency to super cool before crystallising. The degree of super cooling will itself determine the number of
42
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials crystallites and will vary according to forming conditions. As a consequence of this super cooling, thermoplastics are very prone to nucleating effects and specially chosen nucleating agents are frequently added to ensure rapid crystallisation during forming. Among other things, this reduces cycle times. In some cases, nucleants may be used to favour certain crystal phases. Such nucleating agents are often salts of organic acids and sometimes fine fillers. Their use does not generally alter the spherulitic nature of the crystallinity, only the size and number of crystallites. Even so, there can be marked changes in properties accompanying the use of such nucleants, examples of which are given by Jansen [87]. In particular their use generally seems to increase impact strength due to the reduction in crystallite size. Given the importance of crystallinity in determining mechanical and other properties and the susceptibility of polymers to nucleation, it is pertinent to enquire whether normal filler particles have any significant effects in this context. This area is surprisingly little studied, but there is sufficient evidence to show that marked nucleation can occur, although this may vary from filler to filler, with surface treatment also playing a role. There are also indications that the type of crystallinity may be affected and thtat there is some circumstantial evidence for a link between nucleation effects and mechanical properties. This area is, however, not yet well understood and we are a long way from having a good generalised theory. The subject is probably best advanced for polymers in contact with glass fibres and certain platy particles such as sheet silicates. As well as acting as nucleants, this type of material can alter the type of crystal structure present. Thus, it is now well established that glass-fibre surfaces can lead to trans-crystallinity. This is the growth of radially oriented lamellae extending for a few hundred micrometres from the fibre surface. This topic has been discussed in detail by Thomason [88]. Transcrystallinity is also discussed in Chapter 8 of this work. Outside of these areas the picture is much less clear. Straight nucleation affects are easily detected by thermal analysis techniques. These generally manifest themselves in an earlier onset temperature and peak temperature, but not necessarily in any increase in total crystallinity. There are many reports of significant effects for various polymer/filler systems. Thus, talc has been reported as nucleating PE [89], PP [90] and Nylon 6 [89]. Calcium carbonate has been reported as nucleating PP [91-93] and PE [94], while sepiolite (Mg4 Si6 O15 (OH)2 . 6H2O) has been reported as nucleating PP [95]. Surface treatment of the filler particles has also often been found to reduce or eliminate these nucleating effects [89, 96, 97]. One of the authors (RR), has observed similar nucleating effects for aluminium and magnesium hydroxide in polypropylene and also confirmed the reduction of this effect by surface treatment. Typical results illustrating these effects are presented in Figure 1.9. What is far less clear is whether and how these nucleation effects alter the crystal structures present and whether, like organic nucleants, they alter mechanical properties.
43
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 1.9 Effect of magnesium hydroxide fillers on the crystallisation of a polypropylene copolymer (DSC experiment, cooling at 10 °C/min)
There is some evidence for a link with mechanical properties in the work of Hutley and Darlington [96, 97]. They found a good inverse correlation between the nucleating ability of fillers such as calcium carbonates and falling weight impact strength in PP. Surprisingly, the organic nucleants were also found to decrease the impact strength in line with their nucleating ability, although the opposite effect is usually observed, as discussed earlier. According to these workers, other mechanical properties were little affected. Mitsuishi and co-workers have also studied the effect of calcium carbonate on the nucleation and mechanical properties of PP [91]. They reported significant correlation with the loss modulus, tensile modulus and tensile impact strength. They confirmed the decrease of impact strength with increasing nucleating effect reported by Hutley and Darlington. Quantifying the effects of the fillers on crystal structure and hence explaining the mechanical property effects described above is very difficult. This is largely because of the problems of carrying out direct observations using traditional microscopy procedures with such highly filled systems. Among the effects that could be looked for are: changes in total level of crystallinity, changes in crystal phase and its orientation, changes in the number and size of crystalline particles, and changes in the type of crystalline particle. In none of these areas is the picture completely clear and the effects obtained probably vary from system to system. One of the more detailed studies in this field has been by McGenity and co-workers on calcium carbonate and talc-filled polypropylene [98].
44
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials While there are some reports of significant effects on the overall level of crystallinity, most studies show little or no effect [92, 98]. Chacko and co-workers reported that the effect of calcium carbonate on the crystallinity of polyethylene was dependent on molecular weight with reduced crystallinity being observed at low molecular weight and no effect at higher molecular weight [94]. Multiple peaks are often observed in melt cooling studies, (e.g., Figure 1.9) and have been claimed as evidence for the nucleation of new crystal phases [92]. When X-ray studies have been carried out, they have usually failed to confirm this [99], although Murthy did report finding that talc altered the crystal phase present in Nylon 6 [89]. The present author (RR), also found that reheating of magnesium hydroxide-filled polypropylene displaying the twin peaks in Figure 1.9 only gave a single melting peak, suggesting that only one phase was present. On the other hand, fillers have been reported to increase the amounts of beta-phase in polypropylene [98] and to affect the crystal phase present in Nylon 6 [89]. The few studies that have been carried out to date strongly suggest that particulate fillers at normal usage levels markedly disrupt the normal spherulitic morphology. This is not surprising as the interparticle spacing would probably be insufficient to allow these to develop properly. There is also some evidence that new forms of crystallinity can be present associated with the particle surfaces. Thus Chacko and co-workers [94], report lamellar growths originating from selected spots on calcite surfaces in polyethylenes and radiating outwards for up to 400 μm. Rybnikar reported similar effects for calcite in polypropylene [93]. In their work, Kowalewski and Galeski carried out a detailed study of calcium carbonate in polypropylene including work with large single crystals [92]. They reported that the effects observed depended on the crystal faces present. A form of trans-crystallinity was observed on some crystal faces and epitaxial growth was postulated for others. In summary, it seems clear that particulate fillers can have significant nucleating effects in semi-crystalline polymers and that this may lead to effects on mechanical properties. Much work remains to be done to clarify this and provide a clear, coherent description of the effects involved, however. This would be greatly helped if simple techniques for determining polymer crystal structures in filled systems were available. It would also be highly desirable to have a better understanding of how the structure of polymer crystallinity affects composite properties.
References 1.
P. Challinger, Fillers in Plastics Conference, Filplas 81, British Plastics Federation, London, UK, 1981.
45
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 2.
M.E.J. Dekkers and D.J. Heikens, Journal of Materials Science, 1983, 18, 3281.
3.
H.P. Schlumf, Polypropylene Compounds — Sustaining the Market Growth, Corporate Developments Consultants Conference, Brussels, Belgium, 1991.
4.
H.P. Schreiber and F. St. Germain, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 1990, 4, 4, 319.
5.
F.M. Folkes, Proceedings of the SPE Fillers and Additives for Plastics Conference, Gothenberg, Sweden, 1988.
6.
K.F. Heinisch, Dictionary of Rubber, Applied Science Publishers Ltd., London, UK, 1974.
7.
R.P. Sheldon, Composite Polymeric Materials, Applied Science Publishers, London, UK, 1982.
8.
C.F. Bohren and D.R. Huffman, Absorption and Scattering of Light by Small Particles, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, USA, 1983.
9.
P. Kubelka and F. Munk, Zhurnal Tekhnicheskoi Fiziki, 1931, 12, 593.
10. M. Kerker, The Scattering of Light and other Electromagnetic Radiation, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1969. 11. G. Mie, Annalen der Physik, 1908, 25, 325. 12. P.N. Dunlap and S.E. Howe, Polymer Composites, 1991, 12, 1, 39. 13. M. Hancock, Developments in PVC Symposium, Loughborough, UK, 1986. 14. T.H. Ferrigno in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, 2nd Edition, Eds., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987. 15. A.A. Berlin, S.A. Volfson, N.S. Enikolopian and S.S. Negmatov, Principles of Polymer Composites, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 1991. 16. A.I. Medalia and F.A. Heckman, Carbon, 1969, 7, 567. 17. W.M. Hess, G.C. McDonald and E.M. Urban, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1973, 46, 204. 18. B.H. Kaye, A Random Walk through Fractal Dimensions, VCH Publishers, New York, NY, USA, 1989.
46
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials 19. T.W. Zerda, H. Yang and M. Gerspacher, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1992, 65, 130. 20. C.R. Herd, G.C. McDonald and W.M. Hess, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1992, 65, 107. 21. H. Barthel, F. Achenbach and H. Maginet, Proceedings of Moffis-93, Namur, Belgium, 1993, p.301. 22. R.E. Dollinger, R.H. Kallenberger and M.L. Studebaker, Proceedings of the 90th ACS Rubber Division Meeting, New York, NY, USA, Fall, 1966, Paper No.19. 23. G. Fourty, Proceedings of Moffis-91, Conference on Mineral and Organic Functional Fillers in Plastics, Le Mans, France, 1991, p.59. 24. L.F. Gate and T.W. Webb, inventors; ECC international Ltd., assignee; GB 2,240,398, 1994. 25. T. Allen, Particle Size Measurement, 3rd Edition, Chapman and Hall, London, UK, 1981. 26. A.N. Gent, Journal of Materials Science, 1980, 15, 2884. 27. S. Brunauer, P.H. Emmett and E. Teller, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1938, 60, 309. 28. Characterisation of Powder Surfaces: with Special Reference to Pigments and Fillers, Eds., G.D. Parfitt and K.S.W. Sing, Academic Press, London, UK, 1976. 29. S.G. Thoma, M.C. Ciftioglu and D.M. Smith, Powder Technology, 1991, 68, 53. 30. R.E. Godlewski, Proceedings of the 40th Annual Conference of the Reinforced Plastics/Composites Institute, Atlanta, GA, USA, 1985, Paper 4-F. 31. S.J. Monte, Modern Plastics Encyclopedia, 1976, 53,10A, 161. 32. L.B. Cohen, Plastics Engineering, 1983, 39, 11, 29. 33. M.M. Fein, B.K. Patnaik and F.K.Y. Chu, inventors; Dart Industries Inc., assignee; US Patent 4,073,766,1978. 34. J.A. Robertson, R.L. Adelman and H.E. Bergna inventors; E I DuPont de Nemours, assignee; US Patent 3,951,680, 1976.
47
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 35. J.D. Miller, K-P. Hoh and H. Ishida, Polymer Composites, 1984, 5, 1, 18. 36. B.D. Favis, L.P. Blanchard, J. Leonard and R.E. Prud’homme, Polymer Composites, 1984, 5, 1, 11. 37. W. Pompe, S. Völlmar and H.J. Weiss, Plaste und Kautschuk, 1974, 21, 9, 664. 38. G.B. Aivazyan and co-workers, Armianskii Khimicheskii Zhurnal, 1990, 43, 3, 186. 39. S.E. Gebura, inventor; Interpace Corporation, assignees; US Patent 3,557,038, 1971. 40. R.L. Kaas and Z.G. Gardlund, Proceedings of the 35th SPE Technical Conference, Montreal, Canada, 1977, p.333. 41. V.A. Popov and co-workers, Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, 1984, 275, 5, 1109. 42. F. Nitto, inventor; Japan Kokai Tokyo Koho, 80,110,138, 1980. 43. Shirashi Kogyo Co Ltd, assignee; Japan Kokai Tokyo Koho 81,100,860, 1981. 44. K. Iwaku and J. Fujimura, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1979, 24, 4, 975. 45. K. Choi and C.K. Kim, Pollimo, 1989, 13, 5, 426. 46. S. Cartasegna, SPE Symposium, Polymer Grafting in Twin Screw Extrusion, Antwerp, Belgium, 1990. 47. A. Ohhira and M. Tuzawa, inventors; Japan Kokai Tokyo Koho, 77,109,546, 1977. 48. S. Fujii, N. Miyazaki and I. Unno, inventors; Japan Kokai Tokyo Koho, 70,54,034, 1974. 49. K. Senda and co-workers, Japan Kokai Tokyo Koho, 74,07,336, 1974. 50. Chisso Corporation, assignee; Japan Kokai Tokyo Koho, 81,149,452, 1981. 51. N. Iguchi and T. Ono, inventors; Japan Kokai, 75,107,046, 1975. 52. N.G. Gaylord and A. Takahashi, Polymer Science and Technology, Volume 21: Modification of Polymers, Plenum Press, New York, NY, 1983, 183. 53. M. Litvinenko and co-workers, Zhurnal Fizicheskoi Khimii, 1989, 63, 12, 284. 54. M. Bokhitski and co-workers, Plasticheskie Massy, 1988, 8, 34.
48
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials 55. E.G. Howard, B.L. Glazar and J.W. Collette, Proceedings of the SPE High Performance Plastics, National Technical Conference, 1976, p.36. 56. T.H. Ferrigno in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, 2nd Edition, Eds., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987, 33. 57. ASTM D281-95, Standard Test Method for Oil Absorption of Pigments by Spatula Rub-out, 2002. 58. T.H. Ferrigno in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, 2nd Edition, Eds., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987, 17. 59. H.F. Huisman, Journal of Coatings Technology, 1984, 56, 712, 65. 60. R.M. German, Particle Packing Characteristics, Metal Powder Industries Federation, Princeton, NJ, USA, 1989. 61. R.M. German, Particle Packing Characteristics, Metal Powder Industries Federation, Princeton, NJ, USA, 1989, p.148. 62. R.M. German, Particle Packing Characteristics, Metal Powder Industries Federation, Princeton, NJ, USA, 1989. Chapter on bimodal mixtures of spherical particles. 63. C.C. Furnas, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, 1931, 23, 9, 1052. 64. T.H. Ferrigno in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, 2nd Edition, Eds., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987, 15. 65. B. Pukanszky, F. Tudos and I. Kelen in Polymer Composites, Ed., B. Sedlacek, Walter de Gruyter, New York, NY, USA, 1987. 66. O.S. Kauder in Thermoplastic Polymer Additives: Theory and Practice, Ed., L.J. Lutz Jr., Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 1989. 67. B.B. Boonstra and G.L. Taylor, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1965, 38, 4, 943. 68. W.V. Titow and B.I. Lanham, Reinforced Plastics, Applied Science Publishers, London, UK, 1975. 69. E.P. Plueddemann and G.L. Stark, Proceedings of the 31st SPI Annual Technical Conference, Washington, DC, USA, 1976, Section 6-D. 70. C.E. Barnett and H.C. Jones, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry, 1949, 41, 7, 1518.
49
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 71. M.B. Evans, R.N. Rothon and T.A. Ryan, Proceedings of Fillers-86, BPF/PRI, London, UK, 1986, Paper No.12. 72. V.P. Karlivan, M.M. Kalnin’, L.Y. Malers, Y.Y. Avolin’sh, Y.Y. Malers and A.V. Viksne, Plasticheskie Massy, 1976, 11, 46. 73. Filled Polymers I, Ed., N.S. Enikolopyan, Advances in Polymer Science No.96, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 1990. 74. D.H. Napper, Polymeric Stabilisation of Colloidal Dispersions, Academic Press, London, UK, 1983. 75. B. Pukansky and F. Tudos in Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Composite Interfaces (ICCI-III), Cleveland, OH, USA, p.691. 76. M. Ashida, K. Abe and T. Watanabe, Nippon Gomu Kyokaishi, 1976, 49, 11, 821. 77. R. Kosfeld, K. Schaefer, E.A. Hemmer, M. Hess, A Theisen and T.H. Uhlenbrich, Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Composite Interfaces (ICCIIII), Cleveland, OH, USA, 1990, p.385. 78. Y.S. Lipatov and F.G. Fabuliak, Vysokomolekulyarne Soedineniya, 1968, 10, 1605. 79. B.B. Boonstra, Polymer, 1979, 20, 691. 80. S. Chibowski, Powder Technology, 1990, 63, 75. 81. N.S. Enikolopyan, Filled Polymers, Advances in Polymer Science, 96, SpringerVerlag, Berlin, Germany, 1990. 82. G. Kraus, Advances in Polymer Science, 1971, 8, 155. 83. A. Galeski in Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Composite Interfaces (ICCI-III), Cleveland, Ohio, USA, May 1990, p.623. 84. I.F. Gerard in Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Composite Interfaces (ICCI-III), Cleveland, OH, USA, 1990, p.441. 85. B. Pukansky and F. Tudos in Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Composite Interfaces (ICCI-III), Cleveland, OH, USA, 1990, p.691. 86. A. Galeski, J. Grebowicz and M. Kryszewski, Die Makromoleculare Chemie, 1983, 184, 1323.
50
General Principles Guiding Selection and Use of Particulate Materials 87. I.J. Jansen, in Plastics Additives, 2nd Edition, Ed., R. Gachterand and H. Muller, Hanser Publishers, Munich, Germany, 1987. 88. J.L. Thomason and A.A. van Rooyen in Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Composite Interfaces (ICCI-III), Cleveland, Ohio, USA, May 1990, p. 423. 89. N.S. Murthy, A.M. Kotliar, J.P. Sibilia and W. Sacks, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1986, 31, 2569. 90. I. Menczel and I. Varga, Journal of Thermal Analysis, 1983, 28, 161. 91. K. Mitsuishi, S. Ueno, S. Kodama and H. Kawasaki, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1991, 43, 2043. 92. T. Kowalewski and A. Galeski, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1986, 32, 2919. 93. F. Rybnikar, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1991,42, 2727. 94. V.P. Chacko, F.E. Karasz, R.J. Farris and E.L. Thomas, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics Edition, 1982, 20, 2177. 95. J.L. Acosta, A. Linares, M.C. Ojeda and E. Morales, Revista de Plasticos Modernos, 1985, 49, 346, 441. 96. T.J. Hutley and M.W. Darlington, Polymer Communications, 25, 226. 97. T.J. Hutley and M.W. Darlington, Polymer Communications, 1985, 26, 264. 98. P.M.McGenity, J.J. Hooper, C.D. Paynter, A.M. Riley, C. Nutbeem, N.J. Elton and J.M. Adams, Polymer, 1992, 33, 5215. 99. L. Jingjiang, W. Xiufen and G. Qipeng, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1990, 41, 2829.
51
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
52
2
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers Michael Hancock and Roger N. Rothon
2.1 Introduction One of the fascinations of working in the field of particulate-filled polymer composites is the wide variety of materials used as fillers, from relatively simple chalks and limestones to complex rare-earth magnetic powders. Even apparently, mundane, relatively inexpensive, fillers can vary in subtle, but important, ways according to their precise origin and method of manufacture, thus adding their interest to the scientific and technological mind. In the space available here it is only possible to cover the major fillers and a few of the less common filler materials, the latter having been selected on the basis of lack of adequate treatment elsewhere and for illustration of important principles.
2.2 Particulate Fillers from Natural Origins (Mineral Fillers) 2.2.1 Introduction Mineral fillers are a vital and significant part of the world’s polymer industry. Consumption in rubber and plastics is currently estimated to be over 2.5 million tonnes per year in Western Europe. In the first edition of this book growth projections were very bullish and use in plastics especially was projected to grow at 8-12% per year. On a worldwide basis, it was predicted that 20 Mt per year would be used in polymers by the year 2000 [1]. However, local and world economies have suffered several blows since 1997 and this volume has not been reached. As a best ‘guestimate’ the authors believe that filler use in polymers currently is about 15 Mt per year. The majority of use consists of low-cost products in which price is the predominant specification property. Although this will continue to be an important area for mineral fillers, increasingly sophisticated applications for plastics, rubbers and composites mean that the requirements placed on fillers and the specific properties imparted by them will become more demanding; that is, they will be required to perform as functional additives conferring specific benefits in applications, which will be narrowly defined. It is therefore
53
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites important to understand the intrinsic properties of the minerals, how these affect bulk properties and how these then influence the final filled polymer. The most important mineral fillers used are carbonates, clays and talcs, while other silicates are also of interest. Several carbonate minerals are known with some having potential for use as mineral fillers, although only a few are of industrial importance in plastic and rubber applications. Calcite (calcium) and dolomite (calcium-magnesium) are the main carbonate fillers and are very widespread, being exploited in many countries. The other carbonate mineral of any importance is, in fact, a mixture of two carbonates: hydromagnesite (a hydrated basic magnesium carbonate: Mg5(CO3)4(OH)2.4H2O) and Huntite (CaCO3.3MgCO3). A large, relatively pure deposit is found in Greece and a smaller one in Texas, USA, with the former being exploited as a filler for paint and paper applications, and as a flameretardant filler in plastics and rubber. Clay minerals are aluminium silicates of either the two-layered kaolinite type or threelayered montmorillonite type. Only three clay minerals are commonly used in the polymer industries, kaolinite, montmorillonite and chlorite, and these will be discussed below. Chlorite, because it usually occurs with talc and has essentially the same properties, is discussed with that mineral. Talc (magnesium silicate) is widespread but is commonly found with other magnesium minerals such as magnesite. For a complete analysis of the world’s industrial minerals, the reader is referred to publications such as the Minerals Yearbook published by the US Department of the Interior [2] and The Industrial Minerals Handbook [3].
2.2.2 Minerals and Rocks Strictly speaking, a mineral is a substance of inorganic origin with definite chemical composition, which is found in the earth’s crust. Rocks are naturally occuring mixtures of minerals. With few exceptions, minerals possess an internal ordered arrangement of their constituent atoms or groups of atoms, that is, they are crystalline. Some lack any ordered internal structure and are said to be amorphous. The arrangements (or motifs) of the atoms are determined by the forces between them; distances and directions from each other are also determined by these forces. These arrangements are linked together in a three-dimensional repeating network known as a lattice. From a consideration of the physics of particles packing around each other, it can be shown that there are only 14 space lattices possible. These are known as Bravais lattices. There are also limitations on how the motifs are arranged in the lattice such that they fill
54
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers all space. There are only 32 possible ways of arranging atoms around a point in a lattice leading to 230 possible arrangements of objects in space, the so-called space groups. The forces between the atoms result in specific three-dimensional repeatable orders. The limiting factors depend on the shape of the unit cell and the environment in which it grows. The external faces of a mineral are therefore partly an accident of growth: changes imposed by environmental factors do not alter the fundamental properties of the crystal, although other effects may be noticed. The regular ordered structure of the crystal means that it may have different properties in different planes and directions. The nature of the atoms forming the mineral, the forces between them and their order determine its fundamental properties such as chemistry, density, optical properties, hardness and shape. They will also determine the mechanisms by which minerals fracture and thus play a strong role in determining shape, size and size distribution. Impurities, which are invariably present in the mineral from its original formation, may also be present in the crystal and will play a significant role in all the above. Impurities will also play a major role in determining the surface chemistry of the minerals due to adsorption of organics or inorganics on to faces. The chemistry of the faces may also be altered, compared with the bulk, by weathering, and ‘fresh’ faces that may be formed during processing may have different adsorption behaviour and different reactivities than weathered ones.
2.2.3 Rocks Approximately 2000 minerals are known but relatively few are common, and these are based mainly on the elements aluminium, calcium, carbon, iron, magnesium, oxygen, potassium, silicon and sodium. Some elements, such as, sulfur and phosphorus, occur in localised high concentrations. All other elements are found in trace amounts. Minerals based on silicates and carbonates dominate and these are the ones mostly used in polymers. This is illustrated in Table 2.1, which shows the principal mineral fillers used in plastics in Western Europe. They originate from one of the three main divisions of rocks: igneous, sedimentary or metamorphic. Igneous rocks are formed by the cooling and solidification of a molten rock mass. During cooling, ordered crystallisation occurs. However, minerals may be formed not only by crystallisation, but may also result from reactions between already formed minerals and molten ingredients. Minerals may be formed throughout a rock, concentrated in certain areas, or in very localised veins or strata. The bulk of the silicates such as kaolin, mica, talc, feldspar, wollastonite and quartz are all found in igneous rocks.
55
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Table 2.1 Some types of mineral fillers used in plastics in Europe Main mineral (crystalline phase)
Chemical composition (simplistic formulae used for the silicates, see individual entries for details)
Shape
Calcite
CaCO3
Aspect ratio about 3:1, blocky
Talc
MgSiO3
Platy
Kaolinite
Al2O3.2SiO2.2H2O
Platy
Calcined clay
Metakaolinite
Al2Si2O7
Low aspect ratio, platy
Calcined clay
Amorphous
Al2Si2O7
Low aspect ratio, platy
Alumina trihydrate
Gibbsite
Al(OH)3
Low aspect ratio, platy
Magnesium hydroxide
Brucite
Mg(OH)2
Variable
Wollastonite
Wollastonite
CaSiO3
Acicular
Mica
Muscovite
KFeMgAlSiOn
Platy
Mica
Phlogopite
KFeMgAlSiOn
Platy
Silica
Quartz
Si O 2
Cubic
Silica
Amorphous
SiO2
Aggregated
Filler
Natural calcium carbonate Talc China clay
Sedimentary rocks are derived from weathered rock masses and deposited by the action of water or other means, or by the sedimentation of bioliths (mineral skeletons, shells, etc., of plants and animals) into layers, or, rarely, by chemical precipitation. Massive deposits of china clay or kaolin are found as a result of weathering, followed by movement and deposition. Limestone, the general term for natural calcium carbonate rocks, is the most abundant of the sedimentary rocks and is formed by the deposition of countless skeletons and shells. Gypsum and diatomaceous earths occur widely in sedimentary rocks. Sedimentary rocks are almost universally found in layered beds, which may have folded or otherwise been altered by subsequent geological events. Layers will differ from each other in texture, mineralogy and particle size. Metamorphic rocks are formed mostly from sedimentary deposits, which have been subjected to stresses occurring within the earth’s crust. These forces will cause bending, breaking, generation of considerable heat and inclusion of magma. The temperatures
56
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers and pressures involved deform rocks, melt and recrystallise them. By far the most important metamorphic rock is marble, produced from limestone. Impurities in the limestone can lead to formation of dolomite, tremolite, wollastonite and phlogopite in the marble. Brucite (magnesium hydroxide) sometimes is found in metamorphosed limestone. Other minerals of interest to the polymer industries formed by metamorphic action are biotite, feldspar and chlorite.
2.2.4 Calcium Carbonate Minerals 2.2.4.1 Properties Calcium carbonate exists in three crystal modifications, aragonite, calcite and vaterite, but only the calcite form is of real importance. Because of calcite’s perfect rhombohedral cleavage, it is a soft mineral with a Mohs hardness of 3.0. It has a specific gravity of 2.7 and is birefringent having refractive indices of 1.65 and 1.48.
2.2.4.2 Occurrence and Processing Commercially viable deposits of calcite occur throughout the world. These deposits differ considerably not only in purity, but in size and genesis, and the variations affect the nature of a filler produced from them. Over the years various terms have been used to describe these different materials but the ones in general use today are chalk, limestone and marble. Chalk formations are soft-textured limestones, which were laid down in the cretaceous period between 70 and 130 million years ago. Nanofossils are still very commonly found in these deposits and a typical coccolith (with a diameter of about 8 μm) found in a chalk from Wiltshire in the south of the United Kingdom is shown in Figure 2.1. Limestone is a consolidated sedimentary calcium carbonate rock. Consolidation may be due to packing by the overlaying rocks or soil or by recrystallisation of calcite through the leaching effects of water. The deposits are usually organic in origin being formed by the deposition of shells and skeletons of marine organisms – predominantly coccoliths. Consolidation pressures may have substantially altered these nanofossils. Marble is metamorphic limestone. Under high pressures and temperatures in, for example, volcanic activity, the original calcite (or aragonite) has been recrystallised giving rise to a coarse-grained rock, which is more dense and harder than chalk. Both limestone and marble deposits can be heavily contaminated with dolomite, calcium magnesium carbonate, and magnesite, magnesium carbonate, from the interaction of calcite and magnesium ions in the sea water in which deposition occurred.
57
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 2.1 Coccosphere from a UK chalk deposit
During the formation of the original calcium carbonate deposits, other minerals may also have been deposited, or organic matter and salts may have percolated through the rocks under action of ground water. During metamorphic transformation, this will have been incorporated into the marble structure. Thus, a large proportion of the calcium carbonate throughout the world is contaminated resulting in dark-coloured marbles and limestones, of little use to the polymer industry. However, there are many deposits around the world of sufficient purity and close enough to the surface that products suitable for use in a wide range of applications can be obtained by a relatively simple dry-mining operation followed by grinding. Grinding can be carried out dry or in aqueous suspension depending on the exact nature of the impurities present. Chalk deposits, as mentioned previously, consist of the skeletal remains of marine animals. These skeletons consist of rounded calcite crystals around 3 μm in size, loosely bonded together. Grinding operations break these agglomerates into their constituent crystals to produce fillers with average particle size around 3 μm (40 wt% of particles finer than 2 μm) and a surface area of around 1 m2 g-1 (Figure 2.2). The top cut will depend on the energy put into the grinding but, for the plastics industry, is usually around BS 300 mesh. Coarse particles (above 10 μm in diameter) can also be removed by classification. Fine white powders produced from chalk deposits are very widely known as chalk whitings or simply whitings.
58
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
Figure 2.2 Typical particles of a ground UK chalk whiting
Marble deposits can be processed in the same way as chalk but, because marble contains different sized calcite crystals, or grains, a wider range of particle sized products, with wider size distributions are obtained, especially as there may be a need to fragment large crystals. Actual particle sizes will depend on the extent of processing, but typical products will have a mean value of 3-5 μm, with 20-30 wt% finer than 2 μm and a specific surface area around 1 m2g-1. The colour of products, from whichever rock they are produced depends on the purity of the deposit and whether selection is used prior to grinding and whether purification procedures, such as magnetic separation are used during processing. In general, ground marble powders aimed at the polymer industry are coarser, but whiter than ground whitings. There are also a large number of products produced from heavily compacted limestone, which are known as ground limestones. Their average particle-size distributions will be similar to ground-marble products, while colours can range from fairly pure white to grey. All of these products, because of the rhombohedral cleavage pattern of calcite crystals, consist of (mostly) uniform calcite crystals with a fairly symmetrical aspect ratio of 3:1. Producing even finer products than the above requires very large energy inputs because of the need to cleave these ‘primary’ calcite crystals, and energy required is approximately proportional to the new surface produced by grinding [4]. For example,
59
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites grinding calcite to obtain particles with 0.25 μm equivalent spherical diameter (esd) will use more than 20 times the energy of reducing it to 5 μm. Wet grinding is much more efficient in dissipating such energies and also in transmitting applied stresses. The calcite crystals formed by grinding very finely in either wet or dry processes will have the same aspect ratio, approximately 3:1 as the coarse powders discussed earlier. Although it is found with a large variety of habits, calcite crystals, in fact, have a rhombohedral shape, which is independent of its particle size [5]. These calcite crystals are usually fairly pure calcium carbonate with only traces of transition-metal ions (iron in particular) occurring in the lattice. Surface layers may be calcium carbonate, hydroxide or, in freshly broken crystals, possibly calcium oxide. It is now well established that coccoliths in chalk are coated with very thin aluminosilicates (smectites and other clay minerals) and organic matter (humates, etc) [6]. During comminution, compaction or metamorphosis, these coatings may be disrupted or may still adhere to the calcite surface. Aluminium silicates have been identified in pure limestones and pure marbles, and have been shown to be unattached to calcite fragments.
2.2.4.3 Surface Modification Although it seems that the calcite surface in these fillers is often covered by either organic materials or silicate minerals, their chemistry is determined by the basic nature of calcium carbonate and its reactivity towards acids. This is of considerable importance. In particular, their reaction with fatty or other organic acids, but especially stearic acid, has been used for many years [7, 8] to improve compatibility with, and dispersion in, polymers. The coated fillers are much more hydrophobic than uncoated ones, reducing water pick-up, and they have also been shown to have an effect on polymer morphology, and hence modifying properties (see Chapter 1). It is postulated that the stearic acid molecules interact with the calcium carbonate, with the carboxylate ion reacting with the surface and the organic chains sticking out normal from the surface. It has been reported that oleic acid, or any other acid, in which the presence of double bonds alters chain configuration, adsorbs up to a monolayer with the molecules lying flat on the mineral surface [9]. Much work has been carried out on other surface modifications of calcium carbonate [10] and a more detailed discussion can be found in Chapter 4. From the authors’ experience, many beneficial claims have been made (mostly in patents) for surface treatments and coupling reactions, but the evidence when examined is flawed. Certainly, the market place is sceptical of the supposed benefits because very few coupling agents/surface modifications are used commercially.
60
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
2.2.4.4 Uses Calcium carbonate is used in many rubber and plastic applications, mainly to reduce cost, but ultrafine grades, especially when stearate coated, can give technical advantages, for example, in polypropylene (PP) mouldings, unplasticised polyvinyl chloride (PVC) extrusions and polysulfide sealants.
2.2.5 Dolomite 2.2.5.1 Properties, Occurrence and Extraction The other carbonate mineral in common use as a filler is dolomite: calcium magnesium carbonate (CaCO3. MgCO3). It is in the trigonal crystal system and is usually found as rhombohedral crystals with curved composite faces. Dolomite is harder (3.5), denser (2.85), and slightly more acid resistant than calcite, but in general, the mineral properties and properties in a polymer are similar. Dolomite is very widespread with at least 60 producers in 27 countries, but the bulk of the production goes into building and chemical industries; there are only a handful of suppliers of fine powders to the polymer industries. Production is by dry mining and dry grinding, with air classification to remove coarse particles (down to 10 μm).
2.2.5.2 Uses The uses of dolomite follow the same pattern as calcite, although, because its occurrence is much less widespread, tonnage is much lower. Ultrafine products (i.e., with an average particle size of 1 μm), are not available. Because dolomite is more difficult to grind than calcite due to its higher hardness, comminution is more costly.
2.2.6 China Clay or Kaolin 2.2.6.1 Occurrence, Extraction and Properties Kaolin (Al2O3.2SiO2.2H2O), is probably more widely known as the clay mineral, china clay [11]. It is found in hydrothermal, residual and sedimentary deposits (probably about 1000 are still commercially worked) around the world with the most important resources being in Cornwall in SW England and in South Carolina and Georgia in the USA. Large
61
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites deposits are found, and are being progressively exploited in, for example, Russia, the Ukraine, the Amazon basin in Brazil, Spain, Australia, Bavaria and Bohemia. There has been a significant consolidation of the industry in the last few years. Hydrothermal and residual deposits are classified as primary occurrences, although some authorities call them secondary as they are found in the rocks from which they have been formed. Sedimentary deposits are always secondary. The kaolins are formed by the hydrothermal alteration and weathering of feldspathic igneous and metamorphic rocks (especially granite) under relatively low temperatures and pressures. The most common parent minerals are feldspars and muscovite micas. The primary deposits will usually be mixed with unaltered granite, mica, feldspar and quartz. Secondary deposits are usually found in ‘layered qualities’ with very variable purity. The main primary deposits in SW England and Brazil are exploited by hydraulic mining, while other small commercial deposits are utilised by a variety of techniques, with varying levels of sophistication. The most widespread involves dry mining of selected areas followed by a batch wet-washing and sometimes refining in terms of particle size. Products are then dried. In hydraulic mining the clay is washed out of the granite matrix using high-pressure jets of water. Refining into different particle size fractions is carried out by sedimentation of this aqueous slurry, using the principle of Stoke’s law for particles falling through a viscous medium to select the required particle size. To achieve good separation, the particles must be deflocculated (separated from each other); this is usually achieved at a neutral pH and by treatment with a polyanion (see below). Mineralogical separation is also achieved in the refining step with ancillary minerals (mostly feldspar, quartz and mica) remaining in the coarse fractions. During aqueous processing, products may be reductively or oxidatively bleached to reduce or remove coloured inorganic (usually hydrated iron oxides), and organic (humus type materials) coatings on the particle surface. The clays are then filtered, dried and, for the polymer industries, pulverised to break down agglomerates, which form during drying. Sedimentary deposits are mined by a variety of techniques depending on the nature and extent of the impurities. The simplest and cheapest production route involves dry mining, crushing and milling. More sophistication is used for air-float products, where the clay after crushing and grinding passes into an air stream of constant velocity and grit and coarse particles remain behind. More controlled, purer, products are produced by wetrefining with the dry-mined clay being dispersed in water, degritted and refined using hydrocyclones or centrifuges. Micromineral separation is being used increasingly in both types of production routes with flotation, selective flocculation and magnetic separation being used to remove impurities from the clay.
62
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
Figure 2.3 Stack of kaolinite crystals found in granite
Particle-size distributions (expressed as equivalent spherical diameter, esd) of clays depend on the inherent particle size of the deposit and the amount of refining that has been carried out during production. In primary deposits the kaolin plates are usually bound together in a book-type structure (Figure 2.3) and refining will separate them to a certain extent. Most commercial products for the polymer industries will be degritted at 300 mesh, so the normal top cut is at least 75 μm. More commonly, clays will have been refined to 20 or 10 μm for a range of applications, and speciality products will have a top cut of 5 μm or finer. Secondary clays are usually very much finer than primary clays and products that are approximately 100% finer than 5 μm can be obtained by a fairly simple air-float or degritting procedure. Although kaolin, china clay (and even clay) are often used interchangeably as names, the main mineral present is usually (but not invariably) kaolinite. In fact some ‘china clays’ are sold that contain only 25% kaolinite, but normally kaolins will contain 50-99% kaolinite with the main impurities being mica, quartz and feldspar. Other silicates, metal oxides and organic matter are usually found in trace amounts. Pure kaolinite has the idealised chemical composition Al2 O3.2SiO2.2H2O. It is a crystalline material with a triclinic form found in microscopic pseudo-hexagonal plates (Figure 2.4),
63
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 2.4 Typical kaolinite plates
which readily undergo cleavage. As a consequence it has a low Mohs hardness, between 2.5 and 3, depending on the ancillary minerals present. Its specific gravity is 2.6 and refractive index is 1.56. Its structure can be regarded as a gibbsite (Al(OH)3), layer bonded to a siloxane (Si2O5) layer. The silica atom in the siloxane layer is tetrahedrally bound to four oxygen atoms and the aluminium atom in the gibbsite grouping completes its favoured octahedral environment by coordinating to three oxygen atoms in the siloxane group. Thus, one face of this structure comprises oxygen atoms and the other of hydroxyl groups. These will interact through hydrogen bonding giving a layered kaolinite crystal, which has a pseudohexagonal platy shape. The idealised structure described above is invariably spoilt by nature. Isomorphous substitution of both silica and aluminium ions by transition metals, and particularly by iron, occurs. This leads to electrical charges occurring on the plates with edges being positively charged and faces negatively charged; the charges are countered by ions, which surround the particles in a double layer. (The reader is referred to Jepson [11] and references therein for a more complete discussion of the properties of clay and kaolinite). Because of the isomorphous substitution and also because of the occurrence of broken bonds at the edges, there are both Lewis and Bronsted acid sites on the surface of a kaolinite particle [12]. These can be very reactive. There is also evidence that some kaolinite particles are covered with a monolayer of amorphous silicic acid [13], with organic matter [14] and with hydrated iron oxides [15]. These thin, hexagonal plates have aspect ratios in
64
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers the range 5:1 to 50:1 (but very fine clays can have even higher aspect ratios), which are dependent on particle size [16]. Aspect ratios of the plates depend on the nature of the clay deposit with, for example, US clays being chunkier than clays from SW England, but they are also dependent on the processing used because kaolinite stacks or ‘booklets’ readily cleave during processing. Kaolinite reacts only with very strong acids and bases, is not affected by organic solvents, and undergoes ion exchange reactions, but from most points of view, it is an inert mineral. It does undergo a complex series of reactions when heated, which are of commercial importance and will be discussed fully next.
2.2.6.2 Surface Chemistry and Modification Although kaolin can be regarded as chemically inert it does have a complicated surface chemistry. Hydroxyl ions either from the gibbsite layer or from adsorbed gels readily react with commercial bifunctional silanes [17], titanates or other coupling agents [18]. Kaolinite plates have negatively charged faces and positively charged edges and adsorption of both positive and negative ions are of great commercial importance. For example, small amounts of polyanions adsorb on to edges, deflocculating or flocculating the clay depending on the molecular weight of the polymer, and are an essential feature of its use in aqueous media (the paper and paint industries especially). The presence of Lewis and Bronsted acid sites gives rise to a variety of chemical reactions. Amines, or other Lewis bases, readily adsorb and the use of fatty amines to render the clay organophilic has been applied for many years to modify properties in a number of applications [19, 20]. Because of these reactive sites, kaolin will enter into organic reactions and, of particular interest for plastics, will catalyse the polymerisation of certain monomers. Sometimes depolymerisation can occur and it can promote the dehydrochlorination reaction of PVC [21].
2.2.6.3 Uses China clay is a widely used white filler in the rubber industry. Depending on particle size, it can be used as a semi-reinforcing filler (hard clay) or a non-reinforcing filler (soft clay) in such applications as chemical liners, bicycle tyres, conveyor belts, shoe soles, gaskets and flooring. Its use in plastics is much more limited. In thermoplastics it is used for speciality antiblocking, in thermosets it is used in urea-, phenol- and melamine formaldehyde, in unsaturated polyesters, and in epoxy resins.
65
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 2.5 Differential thermal analysis trace for a typical china clay
2.2.7 Calcined Clay When kaolinite is heated (Figure 2.5) to above 500 °C it dehydroxylates endothermically, that is, it loses its water of crystallisation forming metakaolinite. This is then stable up to 980 °C, when a defect spinel structure, which is virtually amorphous, forms exothermically. Above 1100 °C there is a slow transformation of the defect spinel with mullite forming in an amorphous silica matrix. If the heating is carried out very rapidly, then the outside of the clay particles can fuse, forming a glass before dehydroxylation occurs. The water formed cannot escape and forms closed pores, giving a lighter weight aluminosilicate, which still has a defect spinel structure. Each separate step produces aluminosilicates with unique properties having considerable commercial importance in the polymer industries.
2.2.7.1 Metakaolin Above 500 °C kaolinite starts to lose its water of crystallisation and, by 650 °C, approximately 90% of this dehydroxylation is complete, leaving residual OH groups randomly distributed but isolated so that condensation will not occur readily. The product formed is known as metakaolin. Some crystalline structure is retained [22] but X-ray diffraction patterns are so diffuse and weak that no better, more recent, identification has been made. After these structural changes the aluminium, which was originally in six-fold octahedral sites, occupies four- and five-fold sites almost equally [23].
66
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers Metakaolin is much more chemically reactive than the kaolinite from which it was formed [24] and also, deduced from the properties of the polymer composites in which it is used; it has a very reactive surface. This is probably a consequence of an increase in the number of Lewis sites due to the reduction in coordination numbers of the aluminium ions and to the presence of reactive hydroxyls.
2.2.7.2 Calcined Clay Metakaolin is stable up to 980 °C, although between 900 °C and 950 °C the remaining OH groups become mobile and condense. This causes the rearrangement of the poorly crystalline metakaolinite structure to an amorphous defect spinel, which is commonly called calcined clay. This may also be regarded as formation of poorly crystalline mullite and a spinel phase with the separation of amorphous silica [25]. However, experimentally, the material produced up to 1100 °C is X-ray amorphous and the various phases suggested above are deduced from other techniques, such as nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). Some isolated hydroxyl ions still remain on the surface of the calcined clay [26] and these enable it to participate extensively in coupling reactions, which are of considerable importance (see Section 2.2.7.4).
2.2.7.3 Refractory Material Above 1100 °C the rearrangement of the defect spinel into amorphous silica and mullite accelerates with the mullite becoming progressively richer in aluminium up to 1500 °C. On cooling the mullite crystallises into needles, which are embedded in an amorphous aluminosilicate glass. It is a very hard, abrasive mineral, which is virtually inert to all chemicals and environments. During calcination, kaolinite plates tend to fuse face-to-face with the consequences that calcined clays are coarser than the feed clays from which they are produced, but also have significantly lower aspect ratios, approximately 5:1 (Figure 2.6). Up to a calcining temperature of 1100 °C, cleavage is the preferred mechanism of comminution, but energy requirements are high. Above 1100 °C the rearrangement into defect spinel, amorphous silica and mullite, and subsequent recrystallisation means that particles become spherical and undergo fracture on grinding. Metakaolin and the amorphous aluminosilicate produced at 980-1100 °C have approximately the same Mohs hardness of 4.0, specific gravity 2.6 and refractive index 1.6. Above 980 °C, calcined clays are almost completely inert reacting only with very strong acids and alkalis under normal conditions. Their surfaces are likewise inert except for
67
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 2.6 Particales of clay after calcination at 1100 °C
the fact that between 980 and approximately 1100 °C there are still some reactive hydroxyls present. These react readily with hydrolysable groups such as found in the standard ranges of coupling agents, giving rise to a number of commercial fillers; these are mostly based on bifunctional silanes.
2.2.7.4 Uses There is some overlap in the performance of metakaolinite and calcined clay in certain polymers and hence some contiguous applications such as low-voltage rubber cable insulation, but there are significant differences, which leads to separate use patterns. Thus, metakaolinite is mainly used in PVC cable insulation because it improves (uniquely) the electrical resistivity of plasticised PVC, while calcined clay is used in polyethylene (PE) film, rubber cables, rubber pharmaceutical applications and rubber extrusions for a variety of reasons linked to its shape, size and chemical inertness. The refractory product finds limited use in epoxy and unsaturated polyester mouldings, which have to resist abrasion and chemical attack. When silane-treated, calcined clay can be used in polyamide and polybutylterephthalate (PBT) moulding compounds and in very high-voltage rubber cable insulation. Each application needs a silane with a different functionality.
68
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
2.2.8 Mica 2.2.8.1 Properties Mica is the name of a group of phyllosilicate minerals with the generalised chemical formulation KM(AlSi3O10)(OH)2, where M may be Al, Fe, Mg or combinations of these metals. All are characterised by a plate morphology and perfect basal cleavage, a consequence of their layered atomic structure. They are all monoclinic. Crystals are rare but are usually tabular in form. Their hardness is between 2.0 and 2.5, and specific gravity between 2.76 and 2.88, both depending on impurity levels. Colour is also variable. Refractive indices are directionally dependent between 1.56-1.57 (α direction) and 1.601.615 (β direction), so they show strong birefringence.
2.2.8.2 Occurrence and Extraction There are three commercially important micas: muscovite, which is aluminium rich, with colours varying from white to silver to pale grey or green; phlogopite, which is rich in magnesium, and biotite, which is rich in magnesium and iron. Both phlogopite and biotite are usually darker in colour than muscovite micas. There are also zinnwaldite [a lithium rich mica: KLiFe2+Al(AlSi2)O10(F, OH)2], and lepidolite K(Li, Al)3(Si, Al)4O10(F, OH)2, which are widespread but of no commercial importance in the polymer industries. Muscovite is a widespread and common rock-forming mineral, which is characteristic of granite. It is therefore commonly found in conjunction with other silicates and silicas such as kaolinite, feldspar and quartz, sometimes as the major, sometimes as the minor constituent. Production in these cases is by wet refining followed by flotation. Muscovite is also found in isolated massive deposits and production follows a dry mining (for the purest products these may involve hand-selection), grinding route. It is a very platy mineral that undergoes perfect planar cleavage (see later in this section) but plates can also undergo fracture. Therefore, both dry grinding and wet grinding are employed using a variety of grinding media to achieve different particle-size products with different aspect ratios. Usually careful wet milling, using say a ball mill, is used to give products with the highest aspect ratios. Commercial deposits occur in Argentina, Brazil, Canada, France, India, Republic of South Africa, Russia, UK, USA and Zambia. Phlogopite is also widespread being formed by the metamorphosis of magnesium limestones, dolomites and tetrabasic rocks. It is found usually in isolated massive deposits and processing follows a selection, dry mining, grinding procedure. Deposits occur in Canada, India and Madagascar.
69
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Biotite is an important and widely distributed rock-bearing mineral occurring in igneous rocks and thus is a major impurity in many other silicate minerals. Vermiculite, an alteration product of biotite and phlogopite, has its mica sheets interlayered with water. During calcination, exfoliation occurs due to water loss, and this expanded product has considerable use in heat and sound insulation because it has a very low specific gravity. Muscovite, ideally KAl2(AlSi3O10)(OH)2, has a dioctahedral structure but with some of the tetravalent silicon atoms being substituted by aluminium. This leads to negative charges on the aluminosilicate sheets, which are balanced by cations. Phlogopite and biotite have trioctahedral structures with, again, aluminium substituting partly for silicon and subsequent charges balanced by cations. In all three potassium is the common cation. These layered structures are only bonded weakly through large monovalent cations and thus micas cleave very readily to, in theory at least, monolayer thickness. Some rarer micas have more than one silicon atom substituted by aluminium; the extra negative charge produced by this is balanced by bivalent cations such as calcium. Stronger bonding occurs and these micas do not cleave so readily, are harder and much more brittle.
2.2.8.3 Uses Currently mica is used in phenolic moulding compounds aimed at the electrical industry and in some polypropylene mouldings. Because of the birefringence exhibited, some mica is used in decorative articles, sometimes with additional coatings.
2.2.9 Talc 2.2.9.1 Properties of Talc Pure talc has the chemical composition Mg3(Si4O10)(OH)2. It has a trioctahedral structure in which an octahedral brucite, Mg(OH)2, sheet is sandwiched between two tetrahedral siloxane (S2O5) sheets. This structure is electrically neutral and will bond to an adjacent layer only through Van der Waal’s forces. Thus talc undergoes cleavage very readily, is very soft and has a soapy feel. Faces of the layers consist of oxygen atoms, hydroxyl groups are only found at broken edges so that it is fairly hydrophobic. Pure talc is the softest known mineral with a hardness of 1 on the Mohs hardness scale, specific gravity is 2.8, and it has three indices of refraction, 1.539, 1.589 and 1.589, according to crystal direction. Typical particles are shown in Figure 2.7.
70
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
Figure 2.7 Particles of a pure, fine talc
2.2.9.2 Occurrence and Processing Talc is a secondary mineral, which is found characteristically in metamorphic rocks from the degradation of minerals such as olivine, pyroxene and amphibole and also along faults in magnesium rich rock. The designation talc covers a wide range of natural products because the metamorphic changes that gave rise to talc also produced other magnesium minerals. Impurities commonly encountered include magnesite (magnesium carbonate), chlorite (a mixed magnesium silicate-magnesium hydroxide in which Fe2+, Fe3+ and Al3+ may substitute for Mg2+ and Al3+ for Si4+) and tremolite (calcium magnesium silicate). In fact, commercial talcs may contain the mineral talc only as a minor constituent or, in some (all chlorite) not at all. The only two products of significance to the plastics industry are talc and chlorite. Processable talc deposits are widespread, although not as extensive as those of calcium carbonate or clay, with main production coming from north-east, south and west USA, Norway, France, Italy, India, China and Australia. Some massive forms, known as steatite or soapstone (after the characteristic soapy feel of talc) occur, but most of the talc is found in veins. It is produced by conventional selective opencast mining or by underground mining followed by crushing, grinding, beneficiation and classification. After the crude rock is crushed it is often subjected to a manual selection process, although automated techniques are now being introduced (based on colour selection). It is then ground in a variety of ball mills, hammer mills and fluid mills with air-classification systems included in a closed-
71
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites loop system to produce products with a range of particle-size distributions but with the majority having top cuts of 100, 200, and 300 mesh, 20 and 10 μm. Some talcs may be subjected to beneficiation by froth flotation. The talc is ground, dispersed in water, subjected to froth flotation in which the talc may be floated from the impurities or vice versa using a surfactant, selective for the appropriate surface, to transfer it to a foam and effect separation. The talc may then be subjected to grinding, classification or both to achieve the desired particle size distribution.
2.2.9.3 Other Talcs Although described as talcs, many commercial products can contain large quantities of other minerals (as described above). These can markedly affect overall aspect ratio and hardness, and care should be taken in choosing talc for a specific application. Some talcs may contain fibrous minerals which pose health problems and the use of such talcs, especially where the fibrous mineral is tremolite, is strictly controlled in many countries. While normally lamellar or platy the aspect ratio of talc can vary considerably and is not usually specified, although high aspect ratio is the most important property in its use.
2.2.9.4 Surface Modification Conventional surface treatments do not appear to be very effective on talc. This may be due to the low concentration of reactive surface hydroxyls or to the weak nature of the particles themselves.
2.2.9.5 Uses Talc, because of its high aspect ratio, is used in a variety of applications. In rubber, it is used as a partitioning agent and as a semi-reinforcing filler; in membranes, to reduce gas and fluid permeability; and in electrical insulation and sheathing. In plastics it is used to give rigidity to thermoplastics, mostly PP but also some PE and Nylon mouldings.
2.2.10 Montmorillonite (AlMg)8(Si4O10)3-(OH)10.12H2O 2.2.10.1 Properties and Occurence The montmorillonite group, also known as bentonite, comprises a number of clay minerals with dioctahedral (gibbsite) and trioctahedral (Si2O5) groups in three layer structures. They 72
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers have charge deficiencies partly due to isomorphous substitution of Al3+ and Si4+ in each layer, which are balanced by cations (principally sodium and calcium). Water, other hydroxylcontaining groups and amines readily break these ionic bonds. Once the sheets have been parted, many layers can be adsorbed producing a marked expansion of the structure. Bentonites treated with up to 40 wt% long chain fatty amines (such as octadecylamine), often called organoclays, give structure or thixotropy to organic liquids and, for example are widely used in solvent-based paints. Under certain conditions, separation of the platelets into primary layers can occur giving very high aspect-ratio products. Montmorillonite is monoclinic occurring in very thin, small platelets with specific gravity 2.5, Mohs hardness of 1-1.5 and refractive index of 1.50-1.64. It is the predominant clay mineral in bentonite and is found with other clay minerals, such as kaolin, and with silica. Commercial deposits are found in the Morocco, Spain, Turkey and USA.
2.2.10.2 Uses The main uses of montmorillonite stem from its characteristic expansion, and it is used to control viscosity or impart thixotropy to a variety of liquid polymers based on unsaturated polyesters, PVC plastisols, polysulfides, alkyds, etc. It has also been reported to control the melt rheology of thermoplastics and to reinforce polyamides. There has, over the last few years, been enormous industrial and research interest, with many papers and patents, published on montmorillonite, especially as an organoclay as the basis of polymer nanocomposites. Because of the delamination process described above plastic-organoclay nanocomposites have been reported to have very high rigidity, low permeability to fluids, and fire resistance. This subject is covered in more detail in Chapter 10.
2.2.11 Barites (BaSO4) 2.2.11.1 Occurence and Properties
This is widespread usually as a gangue (impurity) mineral in hydrothermal veins associated with metallic ores; some also occurs in limestone or clay. Its crystals are usually tabular and often diamond shaped, but fairly symmetrical. It has two features of commercial interest. Its specific gravity, 4.5, is the highest of the non-metallic minerals and it is chemically inert. It has a Mohs hardness of 3.5, and a refractive index 1.64-1.65.
2.2.11.2 Uses It is used in a variety of polymers to give a very high density, for example, for sound deadening. It is also used in applications that require very high levels of chemical resistance.
73
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
2.2.12 Calcium Sulfate Products 2.2.12.1 Occurence and Properties Gypsum (CaSO22H2O), is a common mineral very widely distributed in sedimentary beds throughout the world. It comprises monoclinic crystals with perfect cleavage yielding thin folia. It is a soft mineral with a Mohs hardness of 2, specific gravity 2.32 and refractive index 1.52-1.53. It is slightly soluble in water and hydrochloric acid, but its principal chemical reaction is that it starts to dehydrate between 65 and 140 °C giving a hemi-hydrate known as plaster of Paris, which further dehydrates up to 200 °C giving anhydrite, which is also found commercially. Gypsum can recrystallise from aqueous media to give a fibrous form, which can be dehydrated to give plaster of Paris or anhydrite in fibrous form. The hemi-hydrate will slowly rehydrate ‘hardening and setting’. Many millions of tonnes of gypsum are used worldwide as a consequence of this dehydration - rehydration reaction and are used in building boards, moulds, casts, plasters, etc. There have been significant developments in recent years in the production of calcium sulfate dihydrate, anhydrous and fibrous calcium sulfate, and their applications as flameretardants and as fillers for plastics. These are described fully by Socha and the reader is referred to that paper [27].
2.2.13 Wollastonite (CaSiO3) 2.2.13.1 Properties Wollastonite is a white, needle-like mineral with a specific gravity of 2.9, Mohs hardness of 4.5 and refractive index between 1.63 and 1.67. It is triclinic and undergoes cleavage along all three faces so it can be obtained in acicular forms with high aspect ratios. However, these needles also readily fracture to give low aspect-ratio fragments. Their aspect ratio is usually 1:8 but higher values can be obtained depending on production route. Typical wollastonite particles are shown in Figure 2.8.
2.2.13.2 Occurrence and Processing Although wollastonite is a constituent of many types of rock, it is rarely found in an economically processable form. The majority of deposits are formed by contact metamorphism of limestone and quartz. Extraction is concentrated on distinct, fairly pure, layers of wollastonite-rich rock. Worldwide production is currently about 250,000 tonnes per year, with China, Finland, India, Mexico and USA being the main producing countries.
74
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
Figure 2.8 Typical wollastonite particles
It is obtained by both opencast and underground mining. After extraction and crushing, the material is beneficiated either magnetically to remove garnet and diopside, or by flotation to remove quartz and calcite. The various wollastonite fractions are then blended, dried and ground, either in a pebble or attrition mill. The latter mill produces the high aspect ratio particles of most use in polymers. Finally, the products are classified and bagged; surface treatments are also often added to grades intended for polymer uses.
2.2.13.3 Surface Modification Numerous surface treatments are used to improve dispersion, particle alignment and particle to polymer adhesion. They can also aid in reducing the abrasiveness of the hard particles to processing equipment, especially dies. Silane coupling agents are very effective and are widely used. Stearate coatings have also been reported to have some applications, but have not been specified by the wollastonite producers.
2.2.13.4 Applications The polymer applications of wollastonite are mainly based on its combination of acicularity, chemical inertness, whiteness and low water adsorption. Primary consuming polymers include thermoplastics, such as polypropylenes and polyamides, and thermosets, such as polyester dough and sheet-moulding compounds, epoxies and phenolics. Manufacturers are predicting considerable growth in reinforced reaction injection moulding (RRIM) systems.
75
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
2.2.14 Crystalline Silicas 2.2.14.1 Properties, Occurrence and Extraction Crystalline silica is the most ubiquitous mineral on earth, being found as a component in almost all other mineral deposits. There are over 20 crystalline phases of silica, differing only slightly in physical properties. Most of these occur naturally, but only a few find any significant use in polymers, notably quartz, novacite and crystobalite. Quartz is the most widely used and is usually found as prismatic crystals. Mohs hardness is 7, specific gravity is 2.6 and refractive index 1.54-1.55. Despite the widespread nature of crystalline silicas, high-purity deposits that are close enough to the surface for economically feasible recovery are not numerous. For polymer applications the purity normally has to be 99% or greater. Good-quality silica deposits have been commercially developed in the US, Europe, India and Australia, although processing methods are most developed and the widest range of grades are available in the US and Europe. Japan has begun processing imported Australian and Indian silica, and now has some grades available. Naturally occurring silica is categorised as crystalline or microcrystalline according to the size of the primary particles in the deposit. Some deposits contain mostly large primary particles, well over 600 μm in size, while others may contain primary particles of under 100 μm. All deposits will contain mixtures of many primary particle sizes, either tightly or loosely bonded together. High concentrations of small loosely bonded primary particles usually characterise microcrystalline deposits and the matrix is thus usually quite friable. Larger, more tightly bonded primary particles are usually referred to as crystalline silica. Primary particle shape can range from round to angular, depending on the natural deposit, but once the primary particle is broken by grinding, all crystalline silica particles become angular in shape. Once ground, the performance of micrometre and submicrometre crystalline silica particles in a polymer composite is influenced by both particle size distribution and an acceptable topsize. Extraction is predominantly by crushing, removal of major impurities, drying, grinding and classification. Typical silica particles are shown in Figure 2.9.
2.2.14.2 Particle Size Crystalline silicas as used for filler applications are generally low surface area, low-oiladsorption materials with angular particles graded by topsize. Identification is on the basis of 98% passing a given spherical micrometre size. A 44 μm product would therefore have 98% by weight of particles below 44 μm. (NB: This odd-looking 76
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
Figure 2.9 Typical particles of a crystalline silica used in polymers
definition is due to the inability of 100% passing to be precisely defined by practical particle-size equipment. Passing 98% is more readily characterised and is still near enough to 100% to be meaningful.) Particle size distribution is as important as top size for many applications and can vary due to the nature of the deposit or the processing conditions used. A major issue is consistency of both top size and size distribution. In coatings and liquid composites with relatively low loadings, a narrow particle size distribution is generally preferred. At high loadings, a controlled, broad distribution is preferred for more efficient particle packing.
2.2.14.3 Uses in Polymer Composites The uses of crystalline silica are a result of its high hardness, chemical inertness, heat resistance, low coefficient of thermal expansion and good electrical insulation properties. Crystalline silicas also respond readily to silane coupling agents and have useful optical effects due to their lack of birefringence and low refractive index. Their major drawbacks are their abrasivity (causing wear of machinery) and possible health hazards (see Section 2.2.14.4). The properties mentioned previously make silica a very good functional extender for thermoset plastics, such as epoxy moulding and potting compounds for electrical and electronic parts, and unsaturated polyester compounds for microwave dishware. Crystalline silica has a natural affinity for silicone elastomers making it semi-reinforcing, especially when a silane coupling agent is used.
77
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
2.2.14.4 Health Issues Crystalline silica differs from the other minerals discussed previously in that there are considerable concerns about its safety; while all the other minerals are currently regarded as nuisance dusts, users and potential users are strongly advised to obtain specific advice and information from individual suppliers. The primary hazard with crystalline silica is the development of silicosis due to the inhalation of fine particles (<10 μm). There are reports that the exposure to silica (or the existence of silicosis) is associated with an increase in the incidence of lung cancer; the International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies silica in Group 2A ‘probably carcinogenic to humans’. The applicable governmental regulations in various countries should be consulted and followed. Also, various codes of practice, such as ASTME 1132 [28], Standard Practice for Health Requirements Relating to Occupational Exposure to Silica, and ANSI Z 88.2 [29], Practices for Respiratory Protection, may be consulted. The EU Scientific Committee on Occupational Exposure Limits (OEL) for Silica (Crystalline) issued in July 2002, recommendations that its OEL should lie below 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable dust.
2.3 Synthetic Particulate Fillers 2.3.1 Carbon Black 2.3.1.1 Introduction Although synthetic and of relatively high cost, carbon blacks are produced in vast quantities for use in polymers. This is mainly due to their widespread use as a reinforcing agent for elastomers, especially in tyre applications. Worldwide production was estimated to be 6.2 Mt in 1999, of which about 90% was used in rubber applications [30]. In addition to their economic importance, carbon blacks exhibit extreme forms of some of the most difficult characterisation issues in the particulate fillers area, especially regarding size and shape determinations, and surface chemistry. However, largely because of their commercial value, more has been done to make advances in these fields than with most other fillers and this pioneering work has much to teach us in a general sense. In elastomers, carbon blacks are used at relatively high, ‘filler’, loadings, but function as reinforcing agents, improving many properties of the composite, especially tensile strength, tear strength, stiffness, abrasion resistance and dynamic properties. In thermoplastics, they are used at lower loadings to improve weathering performance. A specialised
78
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers application is as an electrically conductive filler in the production of antistatic compounds from both thermoplastics and thermosets. They are also widely used as pigments. Because of their importance, carbon blacks have been studied extensively and have a voluminous literature. Only a brief outline of their manufacture, properties and uses will be given here. The reader is referred to specialist publications, such as that by Donnet and coworkers, for more details [31].
2.3.1.2 Production Carbon blacks are, in effect, soots produced by incomplete combustion of volatile organic materials, principally oil and gas. As such they have been made and used as pigments for well over a thousand years. Their production as fillers for polymers has only been carried out since the early part of this century. During this time, there have been four main processes resulting in products of different characteristics: furnace, channel, thermal and lamp blacks. Today, the furnace process dominates, accounting for well over 95% of all black production, the rest being largely thermal black for specialised applications. The furnace process, as its name implies, is based on combustion of gas or oil in a specially constructed furnace. A carefully controlled air to fuel ratio is used. This, together with the turbulence in the furnace, largely controls the particle shapes and sizes produced. The nature of the feedstock also affects size, with the finest particles being produced from natural gas rather than oil. Residence times in the furnace are very short and, on leaving, the hot gases are quenched by a water spray. The carbon black is collected by a combination of electrostatic precipitation, cyclones and bag filters. As discussed in Chapter 1, the morphology or structure of carbon black is a very important property. In addition to turbulence in the furnace, this is controlled by introducing additives into the flame. Because blacks produced by this route are of very low bulk density, they are difficult to transport and handle. They are therefore usually formed into free-flowing pellets by a wet-pelletising process. This has to be controlled carefully so that the pellets are strong enough to pass through solids handling equipment without breaking down, but are readily dispersed to their primary particles when used in polymers. In the channel black process, diffusion flames burning natural-gas impinge on reciprocating metal channels where carbon is deposited. Rotating drums may also be used. The carbon is scraped off, collected, micro-pulverised and then usually pelletised. These blacks have a much higher combined oxygen content than furnace blacks. This process is little used now largely due to unfavourable economics and environmental problems.
79
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites The thermal process produces low-structure blacks of fairly large particle size. These have certain niche applications and, hence, while not as economically attractive as the furnace route, some thermal black continues to be made. The process is carried out batch-wise by decomposing methane (from natural gas) into carbon and hydrogen in the absence of air, in a furnace at about 1300 °C. The furnace is preheated by burning an airfuel mixture, the fuel often being the hydrogen from the process itself. A related process is used to produce acetylene blacks. Acetylene is decomposed to carbon and hydrogen in a controlled manner. Being exothermic, this can be carried out in a continuous fashion. The black produced has laminar or platy particles. Its primary use in polymers is to impart electrical conductivity.
2.3.1.3 Properties As the name implies, carbon black is largely composed of carbon, although considerable quantities of hydrogen and oxygen can also be present. The particles are submicrometer in size, with surface areas in the range of 5-150 m2 g-1. The thermal blacks are at the lower end of the surface area range, and are approximately spherical; but the others have complex three-dimensional shapes, which can be thought of as the partial fusing together of a number of nanometre-sized spherical primary particles. This complex shape is known as ‘structure’ and is usually measured by a variant of the oil absorption procedure. Structure plays an important role in determining many of the key properties of elastomer composites [32]. Because of this, much effort has been, and still is being, devoted to describing the shape of carbon black particles and understanding how this affects composite properties. A further discussion of shape measurement can be found in Chapter 1. Carbon blacks have very chemically active surfaces resulting from their production process, with hydrogen, oxygen and sulfur being the principal surface atoms combined with the carbon. The species of most importance are acidic and basic oxides, active hydrogen groups and highly reactive sulfur moieties. These lead to strong, covalent bonds with many polymers, especially unsaturated elastomers. It is this strong bonding that helps make carbon blacks such good reinforcing agents for elastomeric compounds. One example of their high reactivity is the formation of bound (i.e., non-extractable), rubber on simple compounding. This has also been discussed in Chapter 1. Careful heat treatment can remove the reactive surface species. This process is known as graphitisation as some limited crystalline growth is also observed, although, strictly speaking, no three-dimensional graphitic order is produced. Such ‘graphitised’ blacks show little, or no, bound rubber formation and their elastomer reinforcing properties are severely reduced [33]. Electron microscopy also reveals much earlier void formation on stretching than is
80
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers observed with normal blacks, confirming reduced polymer-particle interaction [34]. Because of their large-scale use in very demanding applications, the measurement and effect of particle characteristics has received much more study with carbon blacks than with any other filler. As detailed previously, the principal factors are particle size, shape and surface reactivity. Dispersion also plays a critical and often overlooked role, and excellent work on this topic has been reported by Boonstra and Medalia [35, 36].
2.3.1.4 Uses Carbon blacks are widely used in polymers. Principal applications are as reinforcing agents for elastomers, especially in automotive tyres. Other applications include their use as conductive fillers, pigments, and as stabilisers, especially in outdoor exposure.
2.3.2 Synthetic Silicas 2.3.2.1 Introduction Two forms of synthetic silica find significant use in filled polymers. These are both very small particle, high specific surface area forms, and are known as precipitated and fumed silicas. Long known as the ‘white carbon black’ because of it’s reinforcing ability in elastomers, the use of precipitated silica has increased markedly recently, due to it’s growing use in low rolling resistance (energy or green) automotive tyres [37].
2.3.2.2 Precipitated Silica a) Production Precipitated silicas are normally made from solutions of sodium silicate (water glass). The sodium silicate solution is usually made by digesting a massive form of silica, such as sand, with sodium hydroxide solution. Precipitation is carried out by adjusting the pH with acid (sulfuric is usually used). Like all precipitations, the process is complex and governed by many variables, including: temperature, pH profile, electrolyte concentration, agitation and time. Useful information can be found in Iler [38], in Watson [39] and in manufacturer’s literature [40]. The conditions can be adjusted to give products with specific surface areas in the range 25-700 m2/g-1. For filler applications, the range 25-250 m2/g-1 is the most favoured. The products are usually isolated by filtering and washing on filter presses,
81
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites followed by drying, sieving and grinding. The products are often granulated to reduce dusting and improve handling and to speed incorporation into polymers. Precipitated silica technology has a long history and, until recently, it had all the appearance of a mature technology. This changed with the advent of the large, energy tyre application, which generated the resources for a fresh look at the product and manufacturing processes. The result has been products with significant improvements in dispersability, leading to similar improvements in vulcanisate properties such as abrasion resistance [41]. The surface structure is also claimed to have been improved, leading to products that need less silane coupling agent, a significant cost factor [42]. Although frequently used with organo-silane treatments, these fillers have not traditionally been pre-coated, the in situ method of addition being preferred (see Chapter 4). Largely due to developments in tyre technology, some pre-coated products are now becoming available. b) Properties Precipitated silicas are amorphous, and this has several advantages. Firstly, there is no problem with varying refractive indices, which helps in formulating colourless and transparent products. Most importantly, the health problems associated with crystalline silicas should be absent. In simplistic terms, the particles can be thought of as being similar to carbon blacks, and to consist of very small primary particles that are aggregated into larger structures and which are the effective particles. The primary particle size is in the range 5-100 nm and the aggregates can contain several hundred primary particles. The way in which the primary particles are combined in the aggregates can vary from open, chain-like structures, to denser, spherical structures and this will very much affect both their physical properties and performance. As with the carbon blacks, ‘structure’ is a very important parameter and is usually measured by an oil absorption method. One feature that surprises many people is the high water content of precipitated silica. The actual silica content is only about 90%. The rest of the mass is made up of three types of water: that combined as surface silanols, strongly hydrogen bonded water and loosely held water. The latter is about 5% by mass of the filler and can be removed by drying at 105 °C. The effects of this water are not often considered, but it can obviously be important, especially in reactions with surface modifiers, such as organo-silanes. Normal products also contain significant amounts of sodium and sulfate from the precipitation process.
82
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers c) Surface Modification The true particle surface is highly hydroxylated in the form of silanols, and hence organo-silanes are very effective surface modifiers and widely used. As mentioned previously, the real surface also has significant amounts of water present, which can influence both the efficiency of the organo-silanes and the types of surface structure formed. Three types of surface silanols can be distinguished, isolated, vicinal and geminal and they have different reactivity towards silane coupling agents. More on this topic can be found in Chapter 4. For tyre applications, sulfur-containing silanes are used. Traditionally these have been added during compounding, but pre-coated forms are now becoming available. d) Polymer Applications The main applications, by far, are as reinforcing fillers in hydrocarbon elastomers. Organo-silanes, such as the mercapto, polysulfides, amino and vinyl are used to improve filler to polymer interactions and reinforcement. Particularly important uses are in tyres and in footwear. There is also significant use as a reinforcing filler in silicone elastomers.
2.3.2.3 Fumed Silicas a) Production These silicas are produced by a gas phase, as opposed to a solution process. There are a number of possible gas phase routes, but the predominant one is by hydration of silicon tetra-chloride. This is carried out in a flame of hydrogen and oxygen at a temperature of 1000 °C or above, and is similar to the chloride route for the manufacture of titanium dioxide pigments. Details of the process can be found in the work by Watson [39] (see also Figure 2.10).
2H2 + O2 2H2O SiCl4 + 2H2O SiO2 + 4HCl 2H2 + O2 + SiCl4 SiO2 + 4HCl Figure 2.10 Process for manufacture of fumed silica fillers
83
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites The solid product is separated by cyclones or gas filters and contains some residual absorbed hydrogen chloride. This is removed in a hot moist air stream, rather than by washing. For the best economics, the hydrogen chloride should be recovered and used to generate more silicon tetrachloride. Particle formation is very similar to that for carbon black, with very small, primary particles forming first and then fusing, while still mobile, into chain-like aggregates. Properties like particle size, surface area and shape are controlled by factors such as reactant ratio, temperature and turbulence. Because of the high temperature formation process, the surface is less hydroxylated than that of the precipitated silicas, and as a result adsorbs less water. The moisture loss at 105 °C is usually less than 1.5%. b) Surface Modification The presence of surface silanol groups makes these fillers very responsive to organosilanes and these are the main modifiers used. Many of the applications of fumed silica require some degree of hydrophobicity. This is achieved by reacting the surface with non-functional organo-silanes, such as dimethyldichlorosilane. Such hydrophobic silicas contain less than 0.1% moisture. c) Applications The main polymer applications for fumed silicas are as reinforcing fillers for silicone elastomers and as rheology control agents in coatings, sealants and adhesives.
2.3.3 Hydroxides and Basic Carbonates 2.3.3.1 Introduction Hydroxides and basic carbonates are classed together here, as their distinguishing feature is a marked flame retarding effect when used in polymers at high loadings. This is because they decompose endothermically, with evolution of inert gases, at temperatures at which polymers pyrolyse. As a result, large quantities of these, predominantly synthetic, fillers are used, with one in particular, alumina trihydrate (more properly aluminium hydroxide), currently dominating the market. The mechanisms by which such fillers reduce polymer flammability is discussed in depth in Chapter 6. In this chapter, only the production of the fillers, and the properties relevant to their use as fillers and flame retardants are discussed.
84
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
2.3.3.2 Aluminium Hydroxide This is by far the most widely used flame-retardant filler, being available at relatively modest cost and with a wide range of particle sizes, shapes and surface treatments to suit various applications. Although its chemical structure is that of the hydroxide, it is often referred to as alumina trihydrate (Al2O3.3H2O) or simply ATH. There is more than one crystal form of aluminium hydroxide, but that used as a flame retardant is gibbsite. For convenience the common acronym, ATH, will be used throughout this book. a) General Properties ATH is a white, non-toxic, material, which is soluble in strong acids and alkalies. It has a specific gravity of 2.4, is relatively soft (Mohs hardness about 3) and nonabrasive. It starts to decompose at about 200 °C with the loss of 34.6% by weight of water when fully decomposed. b) Production Gibbsite occurs naturally in many parts of the world but in an impure form in the rock bauxite. This is the starting point for the manufacture of filler-grade ATH. The principal source of ATH is associated with the conversion of bauxite into alumina and aluminium metal by the Bayer process. In this process, the bauxite is extracted with hot sodium hydroxide, resulting in a solution of sodium aluminate. After filtration, the solution is seeded with fine gibbsite crystals and allowed to cool. This results in crystal agglomerates of 60-80 μm in diameter, which are separated, washed and dried. They are then ground and classified to produce ATH fillers with a range of particle sizes. Considerable purification takes place during the process, but some organic matter (largely humate residues) from the bauxite remains, resulting in a reduction in whiteness. These products also contain considerable quantities of sodium ions trapped in the crystal lattice. These adversely affect water pick-up and electrical performance. They are difficult to remove completely and appear to diffuse slowly to the surface of the particles. Products obtained from the Bayer process are relatively inexpensive and hence widely used, despite their colour limitations. The Bayer process results in a waste stream known as ‘red mud’, which contains considerable amounts of sodium aluminium silicates. These can be converted into ATH if the ‘red mud’ is mixed with limestone and sodium carbonate and calcined, to form sodium aluminate. This is extracted into water and gibbsite then precipitated as in the Bayer process. These products are known as sinter hydrates. They are whiter than the Bayer products as the calcination destroys the organics, but they still contain similar levels of sodium.
85
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites The main problem of the Bayer and sinter processes from a filler point of view, is the relatively large size of the product. Although this can be ground to produce finer grades, there is an economic limit to this. Also the grinding tends to produce platy particles, due to preferential cleavage of the ATH along certain crystal planes. It is becoming more common for ATH to be specially precipitated from purer feed materials than the Bayer process, with the precipitation conditions (temperature, concentration, seed contents) also being modified. This gives purer, finer and more spherical products. c) Thermal Decomposition Starting at about 200 °C, ATH dissociates into Al2O3 and H2O, but this apparently simple reaction is actually quite complex. The first issue is stability. The onset of decomposition is critical in determining the safe processing temperature in composites, but is difficult to specify. Quoted values vary by as much as 50 °C depending on the method of measurement. The processing temperatures of some of the major polymers, (e.g., PP) lie close to the decomposition temperature and hence a realistic assessment is essential. Isothermal tests are probably the best guide and these suggest that 200 °C is probably the upper limit for safe processing unless this is carried out under high pressures. This decomposition makes ATH difficult to use with polymers such as polypropylene and considerable effort has been expended in trying to overcome this limitation. The main approach has been to use surface treatments that minimise shear heating effects. Unlike magnesium hydroxide (see Section 2.3.3.3), there is no evidence that surface treatments have any direct effect on stability. The rate and extent of decomposition is complicated by the possibility of two pathways being followed. Thus, in addition to direct decomposition to oxide, a hydroxy-oxide intermediate (boehmite, AlO(OH)) can also be formed. This only decomposes to oxide at relatively high temperatures (approximately 500 °C). Decomposition by this second route probably reduces flame-retardant effectiveness. Boehmite formation is favoured by high partial pressures of water and the extent to which it occurs will depend on heating conditions and the local environment of the ATH. It is well known, for example, that the tendency to boehmite formation increases with ATH particle size [43]. This is illustrated by the thermal analysis data for a coarse and a fine ATH presented in Figure 2.11. It is also thought that polymer matrices may impede water escape during pyrolysis and so favour boehmite formation. In support of this, surprising levels of boehmite have been reported in the residue from pyrolised polymethyl methacrylate/ATH composites [44]. This may be one of the reasons why marked ATH particle size effects are observed for such composites in some flammability tests [45].
86
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
Figure 2.11 The effect of particle size on the decomposition pathway of aluminium hydroxide (ATH)
Even in the absence of boehmite formation, ATH decomposition requires high temperatures to go to completion. This is probably due to the formation of some isolated hydroxyls, which need to diffuse for relatively long distances before they can react. The ATH flame retardant producers have long sought to develop products with sufficiently increased thermal stability to enable wider use in polyolefins and similar polymers. Some success in this area has recently been reported by Weber of Martinswerk [46]. The more stable mono-hydrate, boehmite has also recently been commercialised as a flame retardant filler [47]. d) Surface Modification ATH responds well to organo-silanes and these appear to be the materials of choice for modifying the surface, with the reactive organo-group being chosen to suit the polymer matrix. Carboxylated polymers are also effective [48] and various organic acids, both saturated and unsaturated are also utilised. Rothon and co-workers have recently reported that some unsaturated acids can be give similar coupling efficiency to the silanes in polymers such as ethylene vinylacetate [49]. e) Uses ATH is widely used as a flame-retardant filler in elastomers, thermosets and some thermoplastics. It is also used in significant quantities as a filler in other applications,
87
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites where flame retardancy is not the prime consideration. This is especially true in thermosets; where good aesthetic qualities, (e.g., translucency), are often required and the low hardness enables polishing out of scratches, etc., to be carried out.
2.3.3.3 Magnesium Hydroxide a) Introduction Magnesium hydroxide is a white crystalline material, with similar flame-retardant properties to ATH but with superior thermal stability. Until recently, commercial interest in its use as a flame-retardant filler was minimal outside Japan. This is because the only products generally available were either of poor quality or expensive. This picture has changed rapidly, as environmental concerns over halogen-containing flame-retardant systems have developed, leading to attempts to replace them in thermoplastic formulations, which process at too high a temperature for ATH to be safely used. Progress has been made on many fronts. More economic routes to highquality product forms have been developed. Significant applications have also emerged for the lower quality synthetic products, notably in the United States, where roofing and decking applications are of growing importance. Success has also been achieved in utilising natural sources for some applications. There is now every possibility that magnesium hydroxide will become a significant flame retardant, complementing ATH. b) General Properties Magnesium hydroxide is a white crystalline material. Its specific gravity is 2.4. Like ATH, it is soft and non-abrasive with a Mohs hardness about 3. It starts to decompose at about 300 °C. The naturally occurring mineral is known as brucite. The natural crystal form is as a flat hexagonal shaped plate. c) Production and Forms Available Magnesium hydroxide is potentially available in a number of product forms, which are all being developed and optimised for flame-retardant uses. Three distinct types of magnesium hydroxide can be recognised: natural, synthetic seawater or brine, and synthetic large crystal. Although uncommon, workable deposits of magnesium hydroxide (known mineralogically, as brucite) occur in several parts of the world, especially the United States and China. Some of these are relatively pure, and after milling and beneficiation processes, appear capable of producing material of filler-grade purity and size. Despite
88
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers the promise of the natural source, development of suitable products has taken a very long time. Most of the problems now seem to have been resolved and significant quantities of natural product are now being used in cable applications in Europe [50]. The commonest form of magnesium hydroxide in commercial production is generally referred to as sea-water or brine type. This is composed of roughly spherical, somewhat porous, aggregates of very small, platy magnesium hydroxide particles. The aggregates are usually 3-10 μm in diameter, are strong enough to resist breakdown during most polymer processes, and are thus the effective particle form. This type of product is produced by precipitation of the magnesium salts present in sea water or brine, by adding lime or dolomitic lime. This type of precipitation produces very fine crystals, and the conditions are deliberately chosen to lead to aggregate growth in order to facilitate product isolation and handling. Many of the impurities in the lime can be transferred to the magnesium hydroxide, and hence this has to be carefully selected for best results. Products of this type are produced on a large scale as an intermediate in the manufacture of magnesium oxide refractories and thus, in principle, are available fairly cheaply. As a result, considerable effort has been expended in trying to develop filler-grade materials from them. The particle size, porosity, surface area and purity can vary considerably according to the exact conditions used in the precipitation. Even in the most favourable circumstances these products are far from ideal for polymer applications and considerable further processing is usually required, especially if low levels of soluble impurities are to be obtained. Most flame retardant applications require very high loadings, and hence place severe demands on filler morphology and have not been accessible to these products. Some, potentially large applications, now appear to be emerging, where lower levels of flame retardancy are needed and these products are beginning to take a significant part of the magnesium hydroxide flame retardant market. Leaving aside cost, the large-crystal synthetic products have the most desirable physical form for filler applications. These are typified by crystals of the order of 0.5-2 μm in size and particle sizes not very different (i.e., little aggregation). Surface area is generally in the range of 1-10 m2 g -1. The aspect ratio of the crystals can vary considerably but is often about 3:1. They can be produced by a number of methods, including hydration of specially formed magnesium oxide [51], precipitation from a magnesium salt solution by addition of ammonium, calcium or sodium hydroxide [52] and by hydrothermal conversion of basic magnesium chloride, itself produced by precipitation from a magnesium salt by addition of a base [53]. In all cases, the conditions have to be controlled if the desired morphologies are to be obtained. The hydration route has the advantage that no
89
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites soluble by-products have to be removed by washing, as is the case with the precipitation routes, but morphology control tends to be more difficult. Among recent developments, has been the commercial launch of nickel doped large crystal magnesium hydroxide. The nickel is claimed to significantly improve the fire retardancy, and allow lower filler loadings to be used [54]. d) Thermal Decomposition The key property of magnesium hydroxide compared to ATH is its superior thermal stability. This is illustrated by the isothermal data presented in Figure 2.12, which suggests that decomposition only becomes significant at about 300 °C. Unlike ATH there is no evidence for two decomposition pathways and for formation of a stable basic oxide intermediate. Even so, decomposition is slow to go to completion and thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA) traces usually show two steps, the first making up only about 85% of the theoretical weight loss. It is believed that the first step is due to removal of bulk hydroxyls while the second slow step, is due to loss of surface hydroxyls accompanied by oxide sintering [55]. Hornsby has reported that the thermal decomposition varies with the form of the magnesium hydroxide [56]. Surprisingly some coatings do appear to modify the decomposition, as shown for a stearate-coated material included in Figure 2.12. The reasons for this are not clear. Metal impurity doping has also been claimed to alter the thermal stability, presumably by introducing some strain into the crystal structure [57].
Figure 2.12 Decomposition of magnesium hydroxide under isothermal conditions
90
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers e) Surface Chemistry and Modification Because these fillers are relatively new, this is an area where much still needs to be done. There is little information concerning the surface chemistry of filler-type magnesium hydroxide, but preliminary work by one of the present authors (RR) suggests that this can be quite complicated and that surfaces of some forms may well be highly carbonated. As would be expected, organic acids react readily with the surface and both fatty acids and the unsaturated polymeric acids described in Chapter 4 bring about useful modifications. The latter have been shown to be effective coupling agents in crosslinked elastomers and thermosets [58]. Silane coupling agents also appear to be effective treatments. The situation is constantly evolving and other coatings, especially phosphate esters, are beginning to appear [59]. The potential effect of coatings on the thermal stability of the filler must always be bourne in mind, as described earlier for fatty-acid coatings. Surprisingly, the carboxylated unsaturated polymers appear to have no effect on stability. Surface modification is likely to be a crucial area of development over the next few years as producers attempt to differentiate their products and minimise the detrimental effects on some composite properties. There is also an interest in use of surface treatments to reduce the susceptibility of the filler to carbonation, which can even lead to leaching from polymers by aqueous carbon dioxide [59]. f) Applications Currently magnesium hydroxide is predominantly used in polyethylene and ethylene vinyl acetate copolymers for electrical wire covering. The areas of greatest potential are, however, in PP and polyamides for a wide variety of uses, and it is in these areas where most development work is currently directed.
2.3.3.4 Basic Magnesium Carbonates There are a number of basic magnesium carbonates, but the ones used for filler applications approximate to the composition of the mineral hydromagnesite [4MgCO3.Mg(OH)2.3H2O]. This material is insoluble, white and dissociates over a temperature range suitable for observing flame retardant effects. It occurs naturally as the mineral hydromagnesite and can be made synthetically, e.g., by the decomposition of magnesium bicarbonate solutions. There is little exploitation of the natural material, except where mixed with huntite as discussed in the next section. Synthetic hydromagnesite normally has a very platy shape, with high oil absorption. The platy nature gives useful properties in elastomers where it finds some use, but
91
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites limits the loadings obtainable, and also the flame-retardant properties. Thus, interest in it as a flame retardant is minimal, although it is being promoted as a smoke suppressant in PVC. a) Thermal Stability This is discussed here, despite the lack of interest in hydromagnesite itself, because of the interest in mixtures with huntite. Thermal decomposition is quite complex with release of water and carbon dioxide, following more than one pathway. Thermal stability is not well established but is probably about 20 °C higher than ATH, indicating a safe processing temperature of about 220 °C. This would seem to make it suitable for PP but, in practice, the platy nature tends to cause greater viscous heating and reduce this apparent advantage. The decomposition might be expected to proceed in three distinct stages: loss of water of hydration, loss of hydroxyls, and finally loss of carbonate. In practice, these overlap considerably and one observes a broad decomposition over the range 200-500 °C. Under ideal conditions, with rapid removal of gaseous products, loss of CO2 occurs well before the temperature one would expect for magnesium carbonate itself, but, in practice, considerable magnesium carbonate can be formed on heating, delaying complete decomposition. b) Huntite/Basic Magnesium Carbonate Mixtures These mixtures occur naturally in Greece, USA and possibly elsewhere, in the form of a white, fairly pure, easily milled form suitable for filler use [60]. Although of natural origin, the main polymer interest is in their flame-retardant nature and hence they are discussed here. c) General Properties Hydromagnesite has already been discussed. Huntite is a rare, mixed magnesium calcium carbonate with the formula 3MgCO3.CaCO3. The properties of huntite have been reported in detail by Faust [61]. Specific gravity is 2.70. It is strongly bi-refringent. It appears to decompose in two steps on heating. The first, at about 645 °C, is believed to be due to decomposition of the carbonate associated with the magnesium, while the second, at about 900 °C, is believed to be that associated with the calcium. In the principal deposit in Greece, the ratio of huntite to hydromagnesite is about 1:1 and there are only traces of other minerals after milling and beneficiation. Other deposits exist with higher hydromagnesite content, but have not been exploited to any extent to date. The following information is based on material from the main deposit.
92
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers d) Filler Properties and Surface Treatments The basic magnesium carbonate appears to occur in a more favourable morphology in the natural ‘mixture’ than when made synthetically. Nevertheless, it is still quite platy, existing in the milled product as plates of about 4 μm diameter and a thickness of about 0.6 μm. The huntite, unfortunately, is even more platy, having a mean diameter of about 0.5 μm and a thickness of only about 0.04 μm. Because of the presence of these two different particles, the mixture has a distinctly bimodal particle size distribution. (NB: The mean sizes determined by standard particle-sizing techniques tend to be distorted by the platy nature of the particles.) The surface area is quite high (approximately 18 m2 g-1)) and so is its oil absorption. This gives relatively high-viscosity compounds and dispersions making the achievement of high loadings difficult. Little is known about the surface chemistry and the effect of surface modification. Organic acids would be expected to react with both components and a fatty-acid coated product is commercially available. Other coatings are also offered, including silanes, but the nature of the surface reaction with these is unclear. e) Fire Retardancy When the mixture is examined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), four main endothermic peaks are observed at 275, 440, 550 and 690 °C. From information on each separate component it seems reasonable to assume that the first two are due to the basic magnesium carbonate and the last two are mainly due to the huntite, but are lower than reported by Faust [61] for huntite itself (644, 901 °C). The reasons for this are not clear. Faust used a similar heating rate but used a fairly primitive differential thermal analysis (DTA) technique and this may have affected the results. Thus it would appear that the stability in use will be determined by the basic magnesium carbonate and is likely to be around 220 °C. Indeed, this is what the producer claims. This is about 20 °C higher than ATH, making it a more attractive filler for PP, if flame retardancy and other properties are satisfactory. The effect of the fine platy particles on viscosity may cause a greater heat rise during processing than is observed with ATH and reduce the stability advantage somewhat. Incorporation of the mixture into a polymer can also significantly modify its decomposition behaviour. This is illustrated by the DSC data presented in Figure 2.13 for the filler itself and a PP compound containing 60 wt% filler. It is seen that the first two peaks are considerably raised in temperature by incorporation into the polymer, while the second two are relatively unaffected. Presumably, most of the polymer will have disappeared by the time the huntite starts decomposing and thus the latter will have no effect on the burning of the polymer. The weak shoulder on the 550 °C peak in the neat filler is more pronounced in the presence of polymer. It is
93
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 2.13 The effect of the prescence of a polypropylene matrix on the decomposition of a huntite - basic magnesium carbonate filler
postulated that this is magnesium carbonate resulting from alteration of the basic magnesium carbonate decomposition as discussed in subsection 2.3.3.4. The fire-retardant effectiveness is a key question, which is particularly difficult to answer in the light of present information. The difficulty lies in the presence of the huntite fraction, which constitutes about half the material. As we have seen, this only appears to decompose at about 500 °C when most of the polymer has gone and its fire-retardant effect must be in doubt, and this must apply in the mixed filler. However, the mixture performs well in tests such as oxygen index. One of the present authors (RR) has himself obtained excellent results with the mixed filler in oxygen-index testing in a number of polymers and has shown by X-ray analysis that the huntite decomposes under the test conditions. There are significant problems in oxygen-index testing as discussed in Chapter 7. One of these is that the flame travels down through the filler residue during the test, raising it to a high temperature. This would certainly be sufficient to decompose huntite and significantly affect heat feedback to the underlying polymer. Such conditions may not be observed in all flame tests, however, and oxygen index may show the filler up in a particularly favourable manner. A detailed study of the effect of the two filler phases and of their mixture on the flame retardancy of PP has recently been reported by Doyle and co-workers [62].
94
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers f) Applications Huntite/hydromagnesite mixtures are used as flame-retardant and smoke-suppressant fillers in a variety of polymer types. Their utilisation very much depends on price relative to ATH, prices of which have been quite low in recent years and this has limited commercial utilisation.
2.3.3.5 Dawsonite Dawsonite is the mineral name for sodium aluminium hydroxycarbonate, NaAl(OH)2CO3. It can be produced synthetically in microfibre form, and decomposes at about 300 °C with release of water and carbon dioxide. There has been significant interest in its use as a reinforcing flame-retardant filler but this seems to have waned recently, possibly due to possible toxicity concerns. More information on the material and its performance can be found in an article by Milewski [63].
2.3.3.6 Antimony Oxides Both antimony trioxide (Sb2O3) and pentoxide (Sb2O5) are used in polymers because of their high flame-retardant efficiency when used in conjunction with halogen compounds. The trioxide is the preferred form for most applications and is used widely in the plastics industry. The trioxide is white but the pentoxide is yellow and both have pigmenting properties due to their high refractive indices. They have been used as pigments but have now been largely replaced in this by titanium dioxide. Their pigmenting effect must be allowed for in formulating compounds, but its strength can be controlled to a certain extent by controlling particle size. Antimony trioxide (Sb2O3) is a white crystalline powder. It occurs in nature in two crystalline forms but deposits are impure and virtually all antimony trioxide used in polymers is produced synthetically. Production is mainly by blowing air through molten sulfide ore or metal, when the metal oxide sublimes, and is collected in relatively pure form simply by cooling. Particle size is controlled by the temperature of volatilisation and cooling rate. Nearly all the synthetic antimony oxide is in the senarmontite crystal form. This is of cubic crystal habit with a specific gravity of 5.2 and refractive index of 2.087. While antimony oxide itself has few flame-retardant effects it does, as mentioned above, markedly improve the effectiveness of halogen compounds. This allows overall additive levels to be reduced and lessens the loss in favourable polymer properties that generally accompanies their use. The mechanisms by which the antimony-halogen combinations
95
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites produce enhanced flame retardancy are still the subject of debate. It seems clear that much of the effect is due to the formation of volatile antimony halides, which operate in the gas phase to interrupt flame propagation. Solid-state, char-forming processes may also be significant. As one might expect, the ratio of antimony to halogen in the compound is a critical factor as well as the overall level of additives. Further information on antimony oxides can be found in the article by Touval [64].
2.3.4 Precipitated Calcium Carbonate (PCC) Very small crystalline (<0.1 μm) calcium carbonate can be produced by precipitation. All three crystal forms, aragonite, calcite and vaterite, can, be produced this way, but calcite is by far the most widely used in polymer applications. The production of PCC has been described by Rothon [65]. A variety of precipitation processes may be used, but today the most common involves blowing carbon dioxide through a slurry of calcium hydroxide (milk of lime). The calcium hydroxide is itself produced by calcination of limestone, followed by hydration. The ultimate crystal size, the degree of aggregation and the aggregate strength are important factors in controlling performance in polymer applications. These are, in turn, determined by many factors in the precipitation process, many details of which are proprietary. For polymer application, PCC is usually coated with a fatty acid during manufacture. This not only improves polymer compatibility, but also aids filtration during production and reduces aggregation effects during drying. Conventional coupling agents such as silanes do not perform well with PCC but coupling may be brought about in many instances by carboxylated unsaturated polymers [48]. These may be added during manufacture, like fatty acids, or added during polymer compounding. The traditional areas of use have been as fillers in elastomers and PVC. In elastomer applications they give a unique combination of low modulus, high strength and low set. Today they are widely used as rheological control agents in sealants, especially PVC plastisols.
Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the valuable contributions of Dr D R Brown (Croxton & Garry Ltd, Curtis Road, Dorking, Surrey, RH4 1XA, UK) to the sections on calcium sulfate and wollastonite, of Joseph L Scaries (US Silica Company, PO Box 187, Berkeley Springs, WV 25411, USA) to the section on crystalline silica, and of Mrs Caryl Gould (ECC International, Europe) for the SEM micrographs of mineral fillers.
96
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers
References 1.
J.B. Griffiths, Proceedings of Filplas ’89, Plastics and Rubber Institute/British Plastics Federation Conference, Manchester, UK, 1989, Paper No.1.
2.
Minerals Year Book, US Geological Survey, US Department of the Interior, Reston, VA, USA, 2002.
3.
P.W. Harben, The Industrial Minerals Handbook: A Guide to Markets, Specifications, & Prices, 3rd Edition, Metal Bulletin plc, London, UK, 1999.
4.
Proceedings of the European Symposium of Particle Technology, Description of Comminution, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1980.
5.
F.R. Noble, unpublished results.
6.
L.S. Dent Glasser and D.N. Smith in The Scientific Study of Flint and Chert, Eds., G. de C. Sievaking, and M.B. Hart, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 1986, p.105-109.
7.
P.R.S. Gibson and C.P. Prat, Rubber Journal, 1969, 151, 9, 33.
8.
A.H. Riley, C.D. Paynter, P. McGenity and J.M. Adams, Plastics and Rubber Processing and Applications, 1990, 14, 2, 85.
9.
R.H. Ottewill and J.M. Tiffany, Journal of the Oil Colour Chemists Association, 1967, 50, 844.
10. K. Mitsuishi, Hyomen, 1990, 28, 1, 49. 11. W.B. Jepson, Philosophical Transactions Royal Society London, 1984, A311, 411. (A comprehensive, brief review of kaolin, its occurrence, properties and production). 12. W.M. Bundy, Proceedings of Keller ‘90 Symposium, Columbus, OH, USA, 1990. 13. A.P. Ferris and W.B. Jepson, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 1975, 51, 2, 245. 14. A.P. Ferris and W.B. Jepson, Analyst, London, 1972, 97, 940. 15. B.R. Angel and W.E.J. Vincent, Clays and Clay Minerals, 1978, 26, 263. 16. F.R. Noble and C. Golley, unpublished results.
97
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 17. A.L. Barbour and A. Rice, Proceedings of the 131st ACS Rubber Division Meeting, Montreal, Canada, Spring 1987, Paper No.76. 18. S.J. Monte and G. Sugerman, Modern Plastics Encyclopaedia, 1976, 53, 12A, 161. 19. N.O. Clarke and T.D. Parker, inventors; ECLP Co. Ltd., assignee; GB 630,418, 1949. 20. L.W. Carter, J.G. Hendricks and D.S. Bolley, inventors; National Lead Company, assignee; US 2,531,396, 1950. 21. D.H. Solomon in Physical Chemistry of Pigments in Paper Coating, Ed., C.L. Garey, Tappi Press, Atlanta, GA, USA, 1977. 22. L. Tscheischwili, W. Bussem and W. Weyl, Berichte Deutsche Keramische Gesellschaft, 1939, 20, 249. 23. J. Rocha and J. Klinowski, Physics and Chemistry of Minerals, 1990, 17, 179. 24. Chemistry of Clays and Clay Minerals, Ed., A.C.D. Newman, Longman Scientific and Technical, Harlow, UK, 1987. 25. K.J.D.MacKenzie and co-workers, Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 1985, 68, 293. 26. A.P. Ferris and W.B. Jepson, Proceedings of the 3rd European Clay Conference, Stockholm, Sweden, 1977, 54. 27. D.A. Socha, Proceedings of the Filplas ‘89 Conference on Filled Plastics, BPF/ PRI, Manchester, UK, 1989, Paper No.2. 28. ASTM E1132, Standard Practice for Health Requirements Relating to Occupational Exposure to Respirable Crystalline Silica, 1999. 29. ANSI 288.2, Respiratory Protection, 1992. 30. L. White, European Rubber Journal, 1999, 181, 6, 28. 31. J-B. Donnet, R.C. Bansal and M.J.Wang, Carbon Black, Science and Technology, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 1993. 32. W.M. Hess, K.A. Burgess, F. Lyon and V. Chirico, Kautschuk und Gummi, 1968, 21, 12, 689. 33. G. Kraus, Advances in Polymer Science, 1971, 8, 178.
98
Principal Types of Particulate Fillers 34. W.M. Hess, Reinforcement of Elastomers, Ed., G. Kraus, Interscience Publishers, New York, NY, USA, 1965, Chapter 6. 35. B.B. Boonstra and A.I. Medalia, Rubber Age, 1963, 92, 6, 892. 36. B.B. Boonstra and A.I. Medalia, Rubber Age, 1963, 93, 1, 82. 37. L. White, European Rubber Journal, 1998, 180, 1, 21. 38. R.K. Iler, The Chemistry of Silica, Solubility, Polymerization, Colloid and Surface Properties and Biochemistry, Wiley Interscience, New York, NY, USA, 1979. 39. S.K. Watson in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, Ed., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987, Chapter 9. 40. Precipitated Silicas and Silicates for the Rubber Industry, Degussa AG, Frankfurt, Germany, 1997. 41. P. Cochet, Tire Technology International, 2000, June, 43. 42. P. Cochet, Proceedings of the Functional Tire Fillers 2001 Conference, Intertech, Fort Lauderdale, FL, USA, 2001. 43. I. Sobolev and E.A. Woycheshin in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, Ed., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987, Chapter 16. 44. G.V. Jackson, R.N. Rothon and G.A. Moorman, Proceedings of Filplas ‘92, Manchester, UK, 1992, Paper No.10. 45. P. Hughes, G.V. Jackson and R.N. Rothon, Die Makromolekulare Chemie Makromolecular Symposia, 1993, 74, 179. 46. M.Weber, Proceedings of the Functional Effect Fillers 2000 Conference, Intertech, Berlin, Germany, 2000, Session 2, Paper No.4. 47. R. Sauerwein, Proceedings of the Fire and Materials 2001 Conference, Interscience, San Francisco, CA, USA, 2001, 395. 48. M.B. Evans, R.N. Rothon and T.A. Ryan, Plastics and Rubber Processing and Applications, 1988, 9, 4, 215. 49. R.N. Rothon, J. Schofield, D. Thetford, P. Sunderland, G.C. Lees, C.M. Liauw and F. Wild, Proceedings of the Functional Fillers for Plastics 2002 Conference, Intertech, Toronto, Canada, 2002, Paper No.5.
99
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 50. E. Redondo Grizante, F. Peruzotti, D. Tirelli, A. Zaopo and E. Albizzati, inventors; Pirelli Cavi E Sistemi SPA, assignee; WO 9905688A1, 1999. 51. R.N. Rothon, A.M. Ryder and A.G. Bourke, inventors; DEFPEO, assignee; EP 0,568,488A2, 1993. 52. A. Packter, Crystal Research and Technology, 1985, 20, 3, 329. 53. No inventors; Kyowa Chemical Industry, assignee; GB 1,514,081, 1978. 54. H. Kurisu, T. Kodani, A. Kawase and T. Oki, inventors; Tateho Chemical Industries Co. Ltd., assignees; US 5,766,568, 1998. 55. J. Green, Journal of Materials Science, 1983, 18, 3, 637. 56. P.R. Hornsby and C.L. Watson, Proceedings of the Third Meeting on Fire Retardant Polymers, Turin, Italy, 1989, p.66. 57. S. Miyata, inventor; Kabunshiki Kaisha Kaisui Kaguku Kenkyujo, assignee; EP 0498566A1, 1992. 58. R.N. Rothon, Proceedings of Moffis ‘91, Le Mans, France, 1991, p.37. 59. S. Miyata and M. Yoshii, inventors; Kyowa Chemical Industry Co. Ltd., assignee; EP 0408285A1, 1990. 60. C.C. Briggs, Proceedings of Fillers and Additives in Plastics ‘91 Technical Conference, Lund, Sweden, 1991. 61. G.T. Faust, American Mineralogy, 1953, 38, 4, 24. 62. M. Clemens, M. Doyle, G.C. Lees, C. Briggs and R. Day, Proceedings of Flame Retardants ‘94, London, UK, 1994, p.193. 63. J.V. Milewski in Handbook of Fillers and Reinforcements for Plastics, Eds., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1978, Chapter 24. 64. I. Touval in Handbook of Fillers for Plastics, Eds., H.S. Katz and J.V. Milewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY, USA, 1987, Chapter 15. 65. R.N. Rothon, Advances in Polymer Science, Ed., J. Jancar, Springer Verlag, Heidelberg, Germany, 1999, 139, 103.
100
3
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces David P. Ashton, David Briggs and Christopher M. Liauw
3.1 Introduction It is the constant theme throughout this volume that introducing fillers into polymers can substantially modify the properties and cost of the material. However, in most systems to achieve the full benefits of the effects offered by the filler, the interaction between the filler and the polymer matrix must be optimised. Although, it should be noted that optimising does not necessarily mean maximising the strength of adhesion between filler and matrix, in some instances this causes embrittlement, and then a lesser level of interaction is needed. To achieve the required effects a large range of surface reactive chemicals have been developed. These may have a single functionality which is reactive towards the filler surface, and used to improve the wetting by the polymer, and hence the dispersion within the polymer. Alternatively, the surface-active component may have dual functionality being capable of reaction with the filler surface, and also crosslinking into the polymer matrix to form continuous chemical bonding between the filler particles and the polymer matrix. Examples containing a single and a dual functional reagent are described later in this section to illustrate these functions, although a more comprehensive account of current surface coatings science and technology is provided in Chapter 4. The first example is of the single functionality reagent stearic acid that is commonly used to surface modify calcium carbonate for improving the rheology when filling thermoplastics such as polypropylene. In this system, the inorganic surface of the carbonate particles is incompatible with the polymer matrix, i.e., it is not solvated, and without surface modification would lead to very high viscosity melts. This in turn would require higher mould filling pressures or lower filler concentrations to be used, and the final component may, due to poor wetting, contain voids at the filler-matrix interface with consequences for its mechanical integrity. Whereas, in surface modification of the calcium carbonate with stearic acid, the acid groups react with the surface carbonates to form the stearate salt leaving each filler particle with an outer surface comprised essentially of hydrocarbon chains. This is solvatable by the molten polypropylene and hence is fully wetted, leading to low melt viscosities, low mould filling pressures and maximum filler loadings. In the
101
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites second example, the surface reactive chemical has dual functionality being capable of interacting with the filler surface and crosslinking into the matrix to form continuous chemical bonding from the filler particles through to the polymer matrix. The compound chosen for this illustration is 3-(trimethoxysilyl)propyl methacrylate (MPS), which is widely used as the coupling agent in filled thermoset systems, an example being silica dispersed in methyl methacrylate which is commonly used for moulding into articles such as kitchen sinks, baths and bathroom fitments. In this system the purpose of the silane compound is to obtain strong chemical bonding between the filler and the matrix, and to achieve the improved mechanical properties of the final component and not necessarily to improve the rheology of the system. The methoxy groups attached to the silicon atom in the silane molecule can be hydrolysed to silanols which can then form hydrogen bonds with silanols on the silica surface, or more preferably undergo a condensation reaction with the silanols to produce covalent siloxane bonds between silane and the filler particle. The methacrylate group at the other end of the molecule having a similar reactivity to methyl methacrylate reacts into the matrix during the free radical polymerisation. However, in liquid dispersions such as these there is an additional requirement: that of avoiding, during the pre-cured liquid state, flocculation of the filler particles due to the Van der Waals forces acting between them. Therefore, to achieve the necessary spacing between the silica particles, the coating has a thickness requirement in addition to the solubility requirement. The thickness of this ‘steric barrier’ is dependent upon filler density and particle size, and for practical systems the MPS molecule is too short to achieve a fully deflocculated dispersion of silica in the uncured state. Therefore, to obtain the deflocculated state an additional polymeric or oligomeric dispersant is required, although a similar short-term effect can be obtained using thixotropes. To illustrate the importance of the bonding between filler and matrix on the mechanical performance of the final composite, measurements were carried out by one the authors (DPA) on silica filled polymethylmethacrylate containing silica (50% by volume), and a mono functional polymeric dispersant, with and without MPS. The composite containing the MPS had a flexural failure stress of 115 MPa, whilst the composite with no coupling agent had a flexural failure stress of 65 MPa. The two examples described previously illustrate the importance of a number of factors concerning the surface of the filler and the interface between the filler particles and the matrix. These are summarised next: The surface of the filler must be compatible with the molten polymer or, if a thermoset system, with the uncured system, (i.e., the resin or elastomer), to achieve the optimum rheology and filler dispersion.
102
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces •
The interface is critical to achieving the required mechanical properties from the composite.
•
The thickness, which is usually related to the molecular mass, of the surface coating is important for obtaining the required rheological properties. It may be necessary to use more than one surface modifier to achieve all the effects required of the system.
An extremely important factor not implicitly obvious in the two examples described previously is the specificity of the surface chemistry to each composite system. Of course many surface reactive agents can be used in more than one system, and MPS and stearic acid fall into this category. However, the MPS and stearic acid could not be interchanged between the two examples, not only due to the mono functionality of the stearic acid, but due to the relative lack of reactivity between silanes and calcium carbonate, and stearic acid and silica. In the latter case, the hydroxyl groups, which are formed at the silica crystal surfaces to satisfy valency demands, are acidic in nature and hence do not form strong bonds with the carboxylic acid group. If the silica was substituted, for example, with alumina then the stearic acid would interact with the surface of the filler, as the hydroxyls formed at crystal discontinuities in alumina are basic in character. Interactions between polymer additives such as stabilisers and filler surfaces are also an important consideration as excessive interaction can lead to a loss of stabilisation. Whilst an understanding of these interactions can lead to methods of preventing additive adsorption, it is also important to appreciate that such interactions can be used to advantage in controlled release of stabilisers from filler surfaces. Such an effect can result in improved retention of the stabiliser and hence significantly enhanced stabilisation. This concept can be extended to other functional additives such as biocides and perfumes, etc. Any study of interfaces in filled polymer systems will show that this acid-base interactivity is the constantly recurring driving force for the surface chemistry and its understanding is crucial to predicting melt and composite properties. A theoretical approach to the subject is discussed in some detail in Section 3.2 of this chapter. It can be concluded from this introduction that to obtain the surface modification required to achieve the optimum or desired composite properties an intimate understanding of the chemical nature of the filler surface is required, and of the chemical reactivity of the surface modifier. The ideal situation, of course, would be to have a comprehensive analysis of all the chemical moieties at the filler surface and their precise spatial arrangement, and then to design the surface modifier with functional groups that interact with the surface moieties and which are correspondingly spaced. This ideal is a long way from current scientific capabilities and may never be fully realisable, however, the target is there and huge strides have been made on the road towards this ultimate goal.
103
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Sophisticated techniques have now been developed for characterising and quantifying the chemical nature of material surfaces, and the more important ones, listed below, are discussed in some detail in this chapter: • • • • •
Flow Microcalorimetry Inverse Gas Chromatography X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy Secondary Ion Mass Spectroscopy Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy
FMC IGC XPS SIMS FTIR
In addition, with the use of fast powerful computers, there is significant activity in the modelling of material surfaces. Much can be expected from this work over the coming years, although the spatial characterisation of typical commercial fillers with the added complications of surface contamination and inhomogeneity will remain a challenge for many years to come. However, despite the large chemical differences between even the most commonly used fillers, such as alumina silicates, aluminium hydroxide, calcium carbonate, silica, titanium dioxide, the most active groups at the surface and which dominate the surface chemistry are more often than not hydroxyl groups. These form, as discussed previously, to satisfy valence and electrostatic requirements at the fractured surfaces and discontinuities of the crystal lattices, or amorphous particles. Furthermore, it is often the acidic or basic nature of these hydroxyl groups that determine the chemical properties of the surface, and therefore, which surface modifier is most suitable for the filler. Consequently, much of the characterisation of filler surfaces is confined to measuring the relative acidity or basicity of the active surface sites. It is worth commenting at this point that all superficially chemically similar groups across any filler particle surface will not necessarily have the same acidic or basic character due to variations in the immediate electronic environment of each moiety. It will be more common for a spectrum of sites from acidic through to basic to be present; therefore a simple pH measurement of an aqueous dispersion of the filler will only give a mean value. It requires more sophisticated techniques to determine the spectrum.
3.2 Acid-Base Theory 3.2.1 Introduction In the main introduction to this chapter the importance of acid-base interactions in determining the interfacial chemistry between fillers and matrices in particulate composites was emphasised. In this section, a summary of the more commonly used acid-base theories will be presented.
104
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces There are two main types of molecular interaction: firstly, the non-polar dispersion forces or London-Van der Waals forces caused by the fluctuations in the charge symmetry of the molecules produced by their thermal energy. Few compounds exhibit only dispersion forces, perhaps the most common examples are saturated hydrocarbons. Secondly, there are polar interactions that are due to asymmetric charge distributions across individual molecules, caused by the different electron affinities of the elements within the compound. However, it has been shown that the strengths of these polar interactions are not simply dependent upon the polarity of the molecules, but on their electron accepting or electron donating, e.g., acidic or basic, character. In fact, Fowkes, [1-4] has shown that the strength is independent of the dipole moments of the interacting molecules except when an acid site is interacting with a basic site. Lewis [5] was the first to describe acids and bases in terms of their electron accepting and electron donating properties. Mulliken [6] further refined the understanding of the acid base interactions for which he was awarded the Nobel Prize for Chemistry. His quantum mechanical approach introduced the concept of two contributions, an electrostatic and a covalent, to the total acid-base interaction. Pearson [7] introduced the concept of hard and soft acids and bases, the HSAB principle, based on the relative contributions from the covalent (soft) interaction and the electrostatic (hard) interaction. In his mathematical treatment he defined the absolute hardness of any acid or base in terms of its ionisation potential and electron affinity. Pearson’s is probably the most robust approach, but the approaches in most common use are those developed by Gutmann [8] and Drago [9], who separately developed equations and methods to quantify the acid or basic strength of compounds, from which their heats of interaction could be calculated.
3.2.2 Gutmann Approach The Gutmann approach was to allocate a donor number (DN) for bases, and an acceptor number (AN) for acids, corresponding to the definitions first proposed by Lewis. The DN was determined by measuring in a calorimeter the heat of reaction between the base under investigation and antimony pentachloride in a dilute 1,2 dichloroethane solution. The AN was determined from the 31P NMR shift of triethylphosphine oxide (TEPO) when dissolved in the acid under investigation. The number allocated was determined from a linear scale in which n-hexane was designated as zero and antimony pentachloride was designated as 100. Gutmann then proposed that the heat of reaction between acids and bases (ΔHab) could be calculated using Equation (3.1): ΔHab =
AN × DN 100
(3.1)
105
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites There are a number of weaknesses in the Gutmann donor-acceptor number approach. Firstly, Riddle and Fowkes [10] showed that AN numbers determined from the 31P NMR shift of TEPO using the technique disclosed by Gutmann contained a contribution due to Van der Waals or dispersion interactions. They showed that even n-hexane, a compound with no dipole, caused a shift in the 31P NMR spectra of the TEPO. An adjustment to the AN numbers can be made to account for the contribution from the dispersion forces. Fowkes has described [11] how the choice of a hard base, TEPO, and a soft acid, antimony pentachloride, for the Gutmann test methods give higher values to hard acids and soft bases than if the reverse was chosen; a soft base and a hard acid. This problem of the order of basicity or acidity being dependent upon the test acid is a consequence of trying to reconcile a single acid or base parameter with the two contributions, the ionic and covalent, to acid-base interactions so elegantly presented by Mulliken.
3.2.3 Drago Approach Drago [9] developed his theoretical approach for relating the enthalpy of interaction with the acidity and basicity of the interacting species, by allocating two constants to define the strength of acids and bases. These are the E and C constants which represent the electrostatic and covalent, or hard and soft, contributions to the acidity or basicity of the compound which loosely correspond to those determined by the quantum mechanics treatment of Mulliken. The constants are determined from calorimetric measurements, and are fitted empirically to the acids and bases and do not necessarily relate precisely to the electrostatic and covalent contributions of the acid base interactions. However, this has not prevented the Drago approach from being used with significant success. The relationship is expressed in Equation (3.2): –ΔHab = CACB + EAEB
(3.2)
ΔHab is the enthalpy of reaction between an acidic species A, and a basic species B. CA and CB are the covalent constants for the acid and base, respectively, and EA and EB are the electrostatic constants for the acid and base. This approach is also not without limitation as it assumes that the two interacting species are purely acidic or basic, and does not take into account any interactions due to acid sites on the basic species, or basic sites on the acid.
3.2.4 Use in Characterising Fillers The most significant work to use acid-base theory to understand the surface chemistry of inorganic fillers has been carried out by Fowkes and his co-workers [1-4, 10-12].
106
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces They made use of the Drago Equation (3.2) to characterise a series of particulate inorganic materials, e.g., ferric oxide, silica and titania, and ascribed E and C constants to their surfaces. The method adopted by Fowkes and co-workers was to determine the heat of interaction between the fillers and probes with known Drago constants using calorimetric techniques. Two techniques were adopted for measuring the heats of adsorption. The first used a static Tronac calorimeter in which the filler surface was titrated with an excess of the chosen probe, the integral heat of adsorption was determined from the calorimeter response. Whilst the molar heat of adsorption was calculated by back titrating to quantify the unreacted probe. The second was to use a flow microcalorimeter in conjunction with a high pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) detector, a technique described in detail in Section 3.4.1.3, to determine the molar heat of adsorption (ΔHads) of the probes onto the filler surfaces. These data were then used to produce plots derived from the rearranged Drago Equation (3.3): EA =
⎛C ⎞ –ΔHads − CA ⎜ B ⎟ EB ⎝ EB ⎠
(3.3)
In this example of the rearranged equation the probe is a base with known constants CB and EB and is being used to determine the EA and CA constants of the acid sites on the filler surface. But clearly, the A and B subscripts could be interchanged and an acid probe used to characterise the basic sites on the filler surface. The plots of EA versus CA, of which an example from reference [12] is shown in Figure 3.1, are constructed for each probe base by calculating the intercept on the EA-axis, i.e., –ΔHads/EB when CA is zero, then drawing a line from it with gradient CB/EB. For any given surface only one point on each plot is valid and that is at the EA and CA values corresponding to those of the surface. This point is therefore where the plots produced from the different probes intersect. The example given in Figure 3.1 is produced from data collected from the adsorptions of ethylacetate, pyridine and triethylamine onto silica, the EA and CA constants for the acid silanol sites were determined as 4.4 and 1.1; the source of the silica was not disclosed. This is an extremely powerful method for characterising the acidic and basic sites on filler surfaces and produces data that corresponds, at least qualitatively, with the most sophisticated quantum mechanics analyses of Mulliken. However, it is important to appreciate that the method described [12] only gives an average value for the EA and CA constants, as mentioned earlier different active sites may have quite different characteristics. However, an adaptation to the FMC technique offers an opportunity to obtain a semiquantitative understanding of this surface heterogeneity, this is described in Section 3.4.1.3.
107
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.1 Determination of the Drago E and C parameters for the surface SiOH sites of silica, using heats of adsorption of test bases determined by isothermal microcalorimetry. (Reproduced with permission from F.M. Fowkes, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 1987, 1, 1, 17. Copyright 1987, VSP.)
3.3 Analytical Techniques The analytical techniques have been divided into three groups; the first group contains those techniques that are used to characterise the surface of fillers by understanding their reactivity with probe molecules. These are FMC and inverse gas chromatography (IGC) and are discussed in Section 3.4. The second group of techniques are the spectroscopic techniques that provide elemental and chemical analysis. These are diffuse reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (DRIFTS), XPS, and SIMS. XPS and SIMS probe the first few nanometres of the surface whereas DRIFTS probes an order of magnitude deeper. These techniques are discussed in Section 3.5. The third group of techniques [wide angle X-ray diffraction (WAXS) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC)] are those that are able to examine formation of structural order within adsorbed layers of surface treatments on filler surfaces. These are discussed in Section 3.6.
108
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
3.4 Reactive Techniques 3.4.1 Flow Microcalorimetry Probably the most notable feature associated with the adsorption (or desorption) of any compound onto a solid surface is the change in enthalpy that occurs during the process; and is captured in Drago’s equation (see Equation 3.2). For an adsorption process the enthalpy change is invariably an exotherm, and is a function of the acidic and basic characters of the adsorbate and the adsorbent surface. With modern calorimetric techniques this enthalpy change is relatively easily measured. Furthermore, for adsorptions onto materials with low specific surface areas it can be more accurately measured than the quantities of adsorbate. However, as will be described in more detail, FMC in conjunction with frontal analysis using HPLC detectors offers the ability to measure both the enthalpic changes and the quantities of adsorbate. Many workers have used both static and flow calorimetry for measurement of the enthalpic changes associated with adsorption and desorption processes. Two basic techniques are used in static calorimetry. In the first, the adsorbent and adsorbate are placed in the calorimeter, but in isolation from each other, the two are then mixed, for example by breaking a membrane, and the heat of reaction is measured. In the second, the adsorbent is charged to the calorimeter cell fully wetted with the solvent for the adsorbate, then a solution of the adsorbate is injected into the calorimeter. Static calorimetry would appear to have some advantages for studying batch systems, as the measured enthalpy change would be the integral of all the surface and solution chemistry taking place within the system. However, within the system there may be many interacting equilibria that a single enthalpy change measurement can do little to elucidate. In flow calorimetry the enthalpy change that is measured is that which occurs as the adsorbant changes from being in equilibrium with a known fluid, e.g., pure solvent, to that of a second known fluid, e.g., a solution of an adsorbate in solvent. Therefore, the initial and final states are relatively well defined and the enthalpy can be more easily attributed to known adsorption-desorption processes taking place at the surface of the adsorbent. Further advantages of FMC over alternative techniques include the ability to measure heats of interactions of polymers in solution with solids, i.e., filler surfaces: characterisation of filler surfaces by IGC is limited to reversibly adsorbed volatile molecules. Also, HPLC detectors can be connected in series with the calorimeter and used to determine quantities adsorbed, and hence provide a measure of surface coverage. The technique has been found by the authors to be most useful for gaining insight into adsorption interactions between a range of probe molecules and filler surfaces. Probes have included: polymers, filler surface treatments and polymer additives. In general FMC is an underused technique in this field.
109
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
3.4.1.2 Flow Microcalorimeter (a) Description. Almost any calorimeter can be adapted to operate in flow mode by making a flow cell which fits into the standard calorimeter cell. However, the calorimeter which will be described here is an instrument designed and produced by Microscal Ltd. [(79 Southern Row, London, W10 5AL; (www.microscal.com)] as a dedicated flow microcalorimeter, although the method of operation, data collection and interpretation described in later sections would be valid for any flow calorimetry system. A line diagram of the Microscal flow calorimeter and the flow system is presented in Figure 3.2. The instrument contains four highly sensitive thermistors. In the more recent models from Microscal, the two working thermistors are placed behind thin polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) membranes that form the walls of the cell. These are referenced, using a Wheatstone bridge arrangement to two thermistors, positioned about
Figure 3.2 Schematic diagram of a Microscal Flow microcalorimeter. (Reproduced with kind permission from D.P. Ashton and R.N. Rothon in Controlled Interfaces in Composite Materials, Ed., H. Ishida, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrect, The Netherlands, 1990, p.297. Copyright 1990, Kluwer Academic Publishers.)
110
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces half way into the thick PTFE walls of the cell. The circuit can respond to differences in temperature of 1 x 10-5 °C, the response is amplified for measurement with a simple chart recorder, or can be fed into a chromatography data station (as used by the authors). Microscal have produced their own PC based FMC control and data analysis system called Calorimeter Digital Output and Sequencer (CALDOS). This removes the reliance on chromatography data stations and software and hence provides the user with a system designed especially for FMC. (b) Method of Operation. The filler is charged to the calorimeter cell, where it can be pretreated by heating under vacuum, or more usually by equilibrating in a flow of the pure solvent chosen for the experiment. The cell of the Microscal flow microcalorimeter has a volume of 0.15 cm2. As described previously the flow microcalorimeter is used to measure the enthalpy change for the transition between the filler being in equilibrium with fluid A and the filler being in equilibrium with fluid B. Fluid A is normally a pure solvent, and fluid B is normally a dilute solution of the probe compound in the solvent. Syringe No.1, see Figure 3.2, is filled with fluid A, and syringe No.2 is filled with fluid B containing the probe. After completing any pretreatment of the filler, fluid A is continuously passed through the filler in the calorimeter cell at a constant and preset rate until equilibrium is achieved; this is indicated by a constant signal from the bridge amplifier. The four-way valve is then switched to direct the flow of fluid B from syringe No.2 to the calorimeter cell. The flow of fluid B is also constant and at the same preset rate as fluid A during the initial equilibration. Flow is continued until the output signal indicates equilibrium with the solution has been established. When this is achieved, the flow may be switched back to that of the solvent, fluid A, to test for the reversibility of the process. More recently electrically actuated valves have become available and can be integrated into the Microscal CALDOS PC based FMC control and analysis system. This allows the user to leave the FMC unattended for the duration of the entire experiment, as there is no need to return to the instrument and switch the valves over manually (c) Output from Flow Microcalorimeter. As the solution of the probe, fluid B, passes through the filler, the probe adsorbs onto the surface of the filler, the heat of adsorption causes an increase in temperature which is detected by the thermistors and registered by the recorder or data station. Conversely, after switching the flow from solution to solvent, desorption of the probe species will cause a decrease in temperature. Therefore, the output is the millivolt output from the amplifier, which is a linear function of the temperature increase in the calorimeter cell, and this is plotted against time. Examples of the outputs from the adsorption and desorption of methyl methacrylate onto alumina trihydrate are presented in Figure 3.3.
111
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.3 Flow microcalorimeter response during adsorption and desorption of methyl methacrylate onto ATH
The peak areas in the thermal data are proportional to the energy changes that have occurred. The constant of proportionality is determined from calibration peaks that are formed by passage of a known electric current for pre-selected time interval through a coil of resistance wire that is integrated into some models of the FMC cell outlet connector. Further insight into the nature of the interaction between irreversibly adsorbed species and the filler surface can be gained from DRIFTS analysis of the filler sample taken from the FMC cell after completion of the adsorption – desorption cycle. DRIFTS is described in more detail in Section 3.5.4, but in summary, it is an infrared spectroscopic technique, that by virtue of a significant proportion of glancing angle reflections, affords enhanced resolution of filler surface functional groups. The authors have found this technique particularly useful when studying competitive adsorption of polymer stabilisers and carboxylic acids onto silica and metal hydroxides, respectively. (d) Choice of Reagents. In any single experiment there are essentially three reagents to be considered, the filler charged to the calorimeter cell, the solvent, and the probe compound. The filler under investigation will usually be determined by the composite system under study. Sometimes, however, it is equally valid to use model fillers with properties chosen to maximise the accuracy and reproducibility of the technique. The preferred filler properties are good powder flow characteristics to avoid bridging and hence voiding within cell, and a high surface area to maximise the signal and hence signal to noise ratio. Certain very fine fillers such as fumed silica can create other practical problems such as escape of filler though the outlet connector filter. This can be minimised by use of a special purpose fine particle outlet connector featuring a polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF)
112
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces membrane filter. In extreme cases very fine (colloidal) filler particles can pass though or block the PVDF membrane, in such cases a static adsorption experiment can be carried out with only minor modifications to the FMC. The choice of solvent is also important, as the enthalpy measured is essentially that of the displacement of the solvent from the filler surface by the probe molecule. For acidbase characterisation a non-polar solvent such as n-heptane is ideal. However, poor solubility of the desired probe molecule may demand the use of a polar solvent, when this is the case the enthalpy of interaction of the solvent with the filler must be considered when interpreting the results. If the probes in question are only capable of weak physical adsorption, (i.e., not via hydrogen bonding), and are only soluble in highly polar solvents such as tetrahydrofuran and dimethyl formamide, situations can arise where apparently no adsorption occurs. This is due to the solvent having equal or stronger interaction with the substrate than the probe. In such cases the value of performing FMC experiments should be questioned and the use of more soluble model compounds considered. If chemical adsorption of the probe occurs the polarity of the solvent is somewhat less critical, provided the solubility of reaction products is not enhanced. Of further importance is the need to use a consistently pure solvent, with special attention paid to the water content. The authors have found drying of n-heptane over sodium metal or freshly activated molecular sieves (3A or 4A) achieves low and consistent water levels in the solvent. Another factor influencing solvent choice is the solubility of any products formed as a result of chemical adsorption; for example, water and metal carboxylates in the case of studies of adsorption of fatty acids onto metal hydroxides. Toluene is a much better solvent for such salts, and the resulting water, than heptane. Generally it is the salts of branched chain fatty acids that are more soluble due to their reduced ability to pack into an ordered array. This is exemplified in Figure 3.4 [13] where the heat of adsorption of isostearic acid (16-methyl heptadecanoic acid) onto magnesium hydroxide is reduced to a far greater extent, when adsorbed from toluene, than stearic acid (octadecanoic acid). Equivalent adsorption onto aluminium hydroxide shows that this is not merely a solvent displacement effect. Formation of a fully neutralised, and hence potentially soluble carboxylate, is far easier in the case of magnesium hydroxide than aluminium hydroxide. This is due to the greater basicity of the former, and the 2+ charge on the magnesium ion: this enables it to become more easily detached from the ionic lattice. The probe compounds may be chosen as model acids (for example, carboxylic acids or chloroform) and bases (for example, pyridine or ether), with which to measure the acidbase character of the filler surface. However, the probes may be actual interfacial modifiers used in the composite system under investigation, for example an organosilane coupling agent or fatty acid dispersant. Furthermore other interesting interactions have been studied by the authors and include stabiliser – filler interactions during evaluation of controlled release/displacement effects.
113
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.4 FMC data for adsorption of stearic acid and isostearic acid onto Mg(OH)2 and Al(OH)3 from heptane and toluene; ■ adsorption data, ■ desorption data. The dashed lines represent vertically adsorbed theoretical monolayer levels. M: magnesium hydroxide, A: aluminium hydroxide, hept: heptane, tol: toluene. (Reproduced with permission from C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, G.C Lees and Z. Iqbal, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 2001, 15, 8, 899. Copyright 2001, VSP.)
It is this ability to use these ‘real’ components that is the main advantage of this technique. The technique was used by Ashton and Rothon [14] to characterise the interaction between 3-trimethoxysilylpropyl methacrylate and aluminium hydroxide from n-heptane solution.
3.4.1.3 Use of HPLC Detectors (a) Description. Whilst use of the flow microcalorimeter can generate important enthalpic data, the power of the technique is substantially increased when it is used in conjunction with one or more HPLC detectors in series with the calorimeter. These can be used according to the method, described in (b) below, to determine the quantity of the probe adsorbed, and therefore the molar heat of adsorption. In the study of the adsorption of 3-trimethoxysilyl-propyl methacrylate on to aluminium hydroxide from n-heptane solution [14], refractive index (RI) and UV detectors were used, and found to be
114
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
Figure 3.5 Line diagram of flow microcalorimeter in series with HPLC detectors. (Reproduced with kind permission from D.P. Ashton, R.N. Rothon in Controlled Interfaces in Composite Materials, Ed., H. Ishida, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrect, The Netherlands, 1990, p.296. Copyright 1990, Kluwer Academic Publishers.)
complementary allowing different components in the eluent from the FMC to be quantified. A line diagram showing the system containing these detectors is shown in Figure 3.5. (b) Output from HPLC Detectors. The eluant from the FMC is passed through the HPLC detectors, the output from each detector correlates with the RI or UV absorbance at the preset wavelength of the detector. Hence as the flow changes from solvent to solution, a plot of response versus time gives a sigmoidal response as shown by line A in Figure 3.6. However, if the probe is adsorbed onto the filler surface in the FMC, the transition will be shifted to a longer time, as indicated by line B in Figure 3.6. The area marked as C in Figure 3.6 is proportional to the mass of the adsorbed probe. To measure this area requires subtracting the transition that occurs during adsorption of the probe, from a transition when no adsorption takes place, but using the same flow and FMC packing conditions. This subtraction can be handled by most standard chromatography software packages and by the Microscal CALDOS system. The proportionality factor can be determined by injecting pulses of solution, via the calibration loop, shown in Figure 3.5, and measuring the area of the peaks produced in the output signal.
115
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.6 Typical response curves from the HPLC detectors during flow microcalorimetry
In reactive adsorption studies such as that described previously, i.e., adsorption of 3trimethoxysilyl-propylmethacrylate on to aluminium hydroxide from n-heptane [14], or reactions between fatty acids and basic filler surfaces [13], the small molecule split off as a product of the chemisorption reaction, (i.e., methanol and water for the first and second examples, respectively), can affect the differential refractometer response. If the small molecule has a lower refractive index than the carrier solvent and the probe a higher refractive index than the carrier solvent, the calculated level of amount of probe adsorbed will be greater than it really is. If however, both the probe and the small molecule have lower refractive index than the carrier solvent, the amount of probe adsorbed will be smaller than it really is. The extent to which this problem occurs also depends upon the solubility of the small molecule in the carrier solvent. This effect has caused problems in a recent study [13] of adsorption of various carboxylic acids on to metal hydroxides. Figure 3.4 shows both the heat of adsorption and amount of carboxylic acid adsorbed. It is evident that adsorption of stearic acid (octadecanoic acid) and isostearic acid (16-methyl heptadecanoic acid) from toluene affords apparently reduced levels of adsorption, relative to when adsorbed from heptane. This is due to both the probe and the water having lower refractive indices than toluene. DRIFTS analysis of the respective filler samples retrieved from the FMC cell, however, indicates similar levels of adsorption. Only in the case of adsorption from heptane is the level of adsorption in concordance with theoretical values. This is due to reduced solubility of water in heptane, relative to toluene. A further treatment of the output data was used by Joslin and Fowkes [2], in which they time sliced the outputs from the FMC detector and HPLC detector. This technique enables
116
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces the molar heat of adsorption to be calculated as a function of time through the adsorption process, and gives an indication of the heterogeneity of strength of the acid or base adsorption sites on the filler surface. Microscal Limited have developed a variation on Joslin and Fowke’s approach, using the latest Microscal system, controlled additions of the probe solutions are injected into the cell and the reduction in the molar heat of adsorption recorded as a function of amount adsorbed. The injections are carried out under computer control via the Microscal CALDOS software.
3.4.1.4 Use of FMC in Competitive Adsorption Studies Competitive adsorption of components of filler surface modifier systems, stabilisers and lubricants, etc., is an inevitable event that occurs in the vast majority of filled polymer formulations. Such phenomena can lead to inferior product performance in terms of reduced coupling agent efficiency and poor stabilisation. Therefore an understanding of such events is very beneficial if performance is to be optimised. Studies have been carried out using combinations of acrylic acid and isostearic acid in an attempt to produce surface modifier systems that combine effective coupling with good dispersant characterisics [13]. In this study sequential adsorption of isostearic acid and acrylic acid on to magnesium and aluminium hydroxides in the FMC cell indicated that acrylic acid will displace isostearic acid from both fillers, however, isostearic acid will adsorb onto a layer of adsorbed acrylic acid producing a hybrid layer. Combinations of stabilisers, (e.g., a hindered phenolic primary antioxidant, a phosphite secondary antioxidant and a hindered amine light stabiliser) are frequently used. Knowledge of the adsorption activity of a filler towards such additives can indicate what additives can be avoided or how the filler surface may be modified, for example with an epoxy resin or fatty acid, so that it no longer adsorbs the additive [15]. Conversely, it can be argued that the filler surface can be also be used as a reservoir of stabiliser, provided it can be released from the surface in a controlled manner. Liauw and co-workers have examined the effect of incorporation of gel silica (323 m2 g-1) at 0.1% w/w, on the thermal stabilisation (melt and solid state) and UV stabilisation of linear low density polyethylene [16, 17]. The adsorption characteristics of all the stabilisers investigated were examined by FMC [17] and heat stabiliser/UV stabiliser combinations were devised on the basis of relative strength of adsorption. The stabilisation performance was found to be enhanced in the presence of silica only when the more active stabiliser was weakly adsorbed relative to the less active one; this indicated a controlled release mechanism that was associated with displacement of the weakly adsorbing stabiliser
117
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites [16]. This mechanism was confirmed by performing competitive adsorption experiments using the FMC [17]. Figure 3.7 shows FMC data investigating the competitive adsorption of the hindered phenolic antioxidant Irganox 1010 (I1010) and the polymeric hindered amine light stabiliser Chimassorb 944 (C944). These probes are adsorbed from heptane on to silica. Data are shown for adsorption of I1010 followed by C944 and for adsorption of C944 followed by I1010. It is evident that C944 is able to initially adsorb at sites not occupied by I1010 as there is solvent released from the silica. DRIFTS studies on the silica isolated from the cell clearly indicated that C944 totally displaced the I1010. It is evident from Figure 3.7 that I1010 will not displace adsorbed C944 and that the latter will adsorb on to all the sites receptive to I1010.
Figure 3.7 Raw FMC data showing (a) adsorption of Irganox 1010 followed by switch over to Chimassorb 944, and (b) adsorption of Chimassorb 944 followed by switch over to Irganox 1010. (Replotted from C.M. Liauw, A. Childs N.S. Allen, M. Edge, K.R. Franklin and D.G. Callopy, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 1999, 63, 3, 391, p.396. Copyright 1999, Elsevier)
118
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
3.4.2 Inverse Gas Chromatography 3.4.2.1 Introduction This technique [18] has now been in use for a number of years. In inverse gas chromatography (IGC), a pulse of a small quantity of a probe is injected into a stream of gas which passes over the filler which is packed into the separation column of the chromatograph. The time taken for the probe to elute from the column, compared to that of a non adsorbing compound, is a measure of the interaction between the probe and the surface of the filler. A mathematical treatment can then relate this difference in elution time to the free energy change in the adsorption process. The technique can be considered as complementary to FMC, although it is constrained by the need to use volatile probes, a number of experimental factors usually result in more accurate thermodynamic data being obtained. The most important difference between IGC and FMC is that in the former technique, the probe is at infinite dilution, therefore, only the most active sites on the filler surfaces are likely to be probed. As adsorption from the gas phase occurs during IGC, only weakly bound molecules of carrier gas need to be displaced during the adsorption process, it is this aspect that may lead to production of more accurate thermodynamic data. In FMC the probe is at finite dilution and it is likely, in the case of some filler/solvent combinations, that the most active sites will always be occupied by the solvent molecules, therefore these sites may never be probed during the FMC experiment. This will almost certainly be true in cases where the solvent and filler have strong hydrogen bonding activity, i.e., alcohols with silica. However, it can be argued that in a polymer composite, particularly when additive or filler surface modifier adsorption from the matrix melt (or a liquid resin) is considered, the conditions of the FMC experiment are closer to reality. IGC may on the other hand be more useful for analysis of filler-matrix interaction where the matrix chains are essentially displacing nitrogen and oxygen molecules during incorporation. Even in this situation, a question mark still hangs over IGC; in real systems, adsorbed water will certainly be present on a filler surface before it comes into contact with the matrix melt. A significant amount of this water will desorb due to the high temperatures experienced in melt processing, though it is most unlikely that all of the strongly adsorbed water will be totally removed. Under IGC conditions water is usually considered to be completely absent; furthermore, the adsorption of the model compounds may take place at temperatures that are far higher than normally encountered processing temperatures. It is important to appreciate that probes used for IGC must not adsorb on to the filler too strongly as they may take too long to elute from the column, or in extreme cases, may not elute at all. Despite the reservations associated with FMC and IGC these techniques are still valuable for gaining insight in to filler surface chemistry and how this may influence product performance.
119
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
3.4.2.2 Thermodynamic Considerations As described previously the important measurement that is made in this technique is the elution time between injection and elution of the probe. Although more precisely, the value used in the mathematical treatment is the ‘net retention volume’ VN. VN is the additional volume of carrier gas eluted from the chromatograph before elution of the probe, compared to the volume eluted before elution of a non-adsorbing gas, for example methane. VN is calculated using Equation (3.4): VN = kF(tp-tn)
(3.4)
Where, F is the carrier gas flow rate, tp is the retention time of the probe, tn is the retention time of the non-adsorbing gas, and k is a factor which corrects for the drop in pressure of the carrier gas as it passes through the chromatographic column. Equation (3.5) has been used [19] for calculating this pressure change factor: 2 Pi / Po ) − 1 ( k= (Pi / Po )3 − 1
(3.5)
where Pi is the gas pressure at injection, and Po is the gas pressure at the detector. The net retention volume VN is related to the free energy of the acid-base interaction G°ab between the probe and the surface of the filler by Equation (3.6). This relationship is valid only at infinite dilution when interactions between the probe molecules are zero, it is therefore essential that very small volumes of the probe are injected into the carrier stream to get as close to the ideal state as possible. Of course the detector sensitivity dictates the minimum volume, it is usual to operate close to this limit of sensitivity: o ΔGab = RT ln VN + K
(3.6)
where K is a constant which depends [20, 21] upon the chosen reference state. The enthalpy change ΔHab for the adsorption process can be calculated using the Gibbs free energy equation (3.7). o ΔGab = ΔHab − TΔSab
(3.7)
Although the entropy change (ΔSab) is an unknown quantity this can be determined by conducting a series of adsorptions at different temperatures. The entropy change is then calculated from the slope of the plot of ΔG°ab versus absolute temperature.
120
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces Therefore, by measuring the net retention volumes, over a range of temperatures, of a series of acid and base probes with known Drago constants, then fitting the calculated enthalpy data to the Drago Equation (3.2), the acid and base constants for the filler surface are able to be determined. The method is described in Section 3.3 of this chapter and uses plots (see Figure 3.1), derived from the rearranged Drago Equation (3.3). A similar approach was adopted by Schultz and co-workers [22] but using Equation (3.8) derived from the Gutmann Equation (3.1) to characterise the acid base characteristics of carbon fibres using IGC: − ΔHab = AN f DN p + DN f AN p
(3.8)
This method, based on the Gutmann equation, is also preferred by Panzer and Schreiber [23] who believe that the dominant weakness of the Drago approach is its failure to account for the amphoteric nature of the probe.
3.4.2.3 Inverse Gas Chromatography (a) Description. IGC can be carried out on any modern gas chromatograph. The type of detector used is not critical to the application, flame ionisation detectors (FID) and thermal conductivity detectors (TCD) are the more commonly used. The FID is generally a more sensitive detector and therefore permits experiments to be carried out at a greater degree of dilution. However, on modern gas chromatographs the TCD also have high sensitivity and are equally appropriate for IGC. The output can be measured on a traditional chart recorder and retention volumes measured with a rule, or more conveniently using PC based chromatography software that electronically measures the retention time, and can be further programmed to calculate VN, see Equation (3.4). The technique differs from the standard gas chromatography only in the material used for the column packing and the processing of the data. The only additional hardware required are pressure gauges at the injection point and detector, which enable the k factor in Equation (3.4) to be calculated. A schematic diagram of an IGC is shown in Figure 3.8. The critical parameters are a constant and accurately measured gas flow rate, temperature, and injection and detector pressures. A small injection volume of the probe molecule is required, to ensure that the conditions of the thermodynamic treatment are met. (b) Method of Operation. The filler under examination is packed into a standard gas chromatograph column, typically a stainless steel tube 0.5 or 1 m in length, and ~5 mm
121
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.8 Schematic diagram of an inverse gas chromatograph system
internal diameter. The column may be packed with undiluted filler, or the filler may be mixed with a non-interacting low surface area diluent. This would be used where a very high surface area filler caused an excessively long retention time, or where filler packing caused an excessively high pressure drop across the length of the column. The next stage is to find the minimum detection limit of the detector and determine the minimum injection volumes of the probes which still produce well defined peaks, with good signal to noise ratio. Then an injection of a non interacting gas (for example, methane) is made, the retention time of this gas gives the value tn for use in Equation (3.4). The experiments can then be carried out by injecting the predetermined volumes of the probes and measuring their retention times tp. If the enthalpies of the interactions are required, then the injections need to be repeated at different column temperatures to enable the entropy change to be calculated. (c) Example of output. Figure 3.9 is a compilation of typical output plots obtained during an IGC experiment. Time zero corresponds to the time of injection of the sample, a nonadsorbing probe takes time tn to elute from the column, whilst the experimental probe takes time tp to elute. The time difference between tp and tn relates to the strength of adsorption of the probe onto the filler surface. By adsorbing a series of probes with different acidic and basic nature a qualitative characterisation of the filler surface is achieved. Although as described previously by inserting the experimental data into Equations (3.4) to (3.7) it is possible to determine enthalpies of adsorption.
122
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
Figure 3.9 Typical response curves from an IGC experiment, with responses from nonadsorbed control and adsorbed probe superimposed
3.4.2.4 Multiple Probe Temperature-Programmed IGC This variation on traditional IGC has been developed from the McReynolds approach [24], for characterisation of stationary phases, by McMahon and co-workers [25]. It is particularly suited to rapid comparative screening of families of solid surfaces, for example a range of carbon blacks with differing surface chemistry. However, it does not provide quantitative measures of thermodynamic parameters. The multi-probe set includes those specified by McReynolds together with several n-alkanes. Classified groups of these probes can be injected into the column as mixtures. The temperature of the column is increased at a constant rate and the temperature at which the probe elutes is recorded as the retention temperature (TR). The TR values of the probes can be plotted against probe boiling point. For n-alkane probes this relationship is linear but data for other probes will not necessarily coincide with this linear relationship. If the concentration of polar sites on the filler is higher than that of non-polar sites then data for the other probes will fall above the n-alkane line. In the reverse case, i.e., if the concentration of non-polar sites is higher than the concentration of polar sites, the data for the other probes will fall below the n-alkane line. The retention characteristics of the probes can be expressed as Kovats indices (KI), i.e., the carbon number of the n-alkane that will co-elute with a given probe multiplied by 100. The higher the KI, relative to the carbon number of the probe, the greater the strength of interaction between the probe and the filler.
123
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites One of the filler samples can be selected as a reference column and the probe TR values in the sample column can plotted as a function of respective TR values in the reference column. The surface area of filler in each column must be identical. If the surface chemistry of the samples is exactly equivalent a linear plot will result. The direction and magnitude of deviation from linearity provides a measure of the relative strength of interaction. The multiple probe temperature programmed approach to IGC certainly shows potential for rapid screening of fillers and yields data that can be treated using chemometric classification tools such as principle component analysis.
3.5 Spectroscopic Techniques 3.5.1 Introduction Surface modification of filler particles is common and frequently mandatory in order to achieve desirable properties such as dispersability, filler-matrix bonding and even stability. Such modifications can range from the adsorption of less than one monomolecular layer of a surfactant to the precipitation of a coating many nm thick. Surface composition analysis therefore requires methods which posses sampling depths of order 1-10 nm to several μm, and that can characterise both inorganic and organic species, ideally in a fully quantitative manner. Of the variety of ultra-high vacuum (UHV) based surface spectroscopic techniques which have emerged since the late 1960s only two: X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) (also frequently referred to as ESCA), and secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS), come close to meeting the nanometer sampling depth requirements and are discussed briefly here. It is worth noting that Auger electron spectroscopy (AES), which has many of the necessary attributes, fails in this context because of charging problems with highly insulating powders and beam damage to organic materials. For much more detailed descriptions of the techniques the interested reader should consult references [26-28].
3.5.2 X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy 3.5.2.1 Physical Basis In XPS the sample, inside a high vacuum system (pressure <10-5 Pa), is irradiated with soft X-rays, usually Mg Kα (1253.6 eV) or Al Kα (1486.6 eV). The primary event is photoemission of a core (atomic) electron, but relaxation processes also lead to emission of Auger electrons, as shown in Figure 3.10. The emitted electrons are collected by an electrostatic energy analyser and detected as a function of kinetic energy (Ek), producing a spectrum such as that shown in Figure 3.11. The intense, narrow peaks are due to
124
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
Figure 3.10 X-ray photoemission from a 1s core level and subsequent relaxation processes leading to X-ray fluorescence and Auger electron emission
photoelectrons emitted from core orbitals, (e.g., carbon 1s). The binding energies (EB) of these electrons, are obtained from the Einstein relationship (Equation 3.9): EB = hν – Ek – ø
(3.9)
(where hν is the X-ray photon energy and ø the sample work function) are highly characteristic and allow the identification of all elements except hydrogen (and helium). The peak intensities are proportional to the number of atoms sampled, and with the aid of appropriate sensitivity factors, atomic compositions can be calculated, with typical detection limits of 0.1 atom%. The much weaker series of peaks at very low binding energy is due to photoelectron emission from the valence band (molecular orbitals). The other, broader peaks are due to Auger electrons, for which the kinetic energy (Ek) is given by Equation (3.10): Ek(ABC) = EA – EB – EC – ø
(3.10)
where A, B, and C are the photoionised level, the level of the electron that fills this vacancy, and the level of the emitted Auger electron, respectively, (Figure 3.10). These kinetic energy values are also element characteristic, although not all elements produce strong Auger signals under typical XPS conditions, and are obviously independent of hν. The information from XPS is surface specific because the electrons that give rise to the useful peaks in the spectrum have emerged from the material elastically, i.e., without loss of energy. The inelastic mean free path (λm) of electrons of energy E in an inorganic solid is given, approximately, by Equation (3.11): λm =
2170 E
2
+ ( aE) 2
1
(3.11)
125
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.11(a) XPS survey spectra of uncoated commercial TiO2 pigment
where λm is in monolayers and the monolayer thickness, a (nm), is given by Equation (3.12): a3 =
A × 1024 pnN
(3.12)
where A is the atomic or molecular weight, n is the number of atoms in the molecule,
126
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
Figure 3.11(b) XPS survey spectra of coated commercial TiO2 pigment. Note the marked attenuation of Ti 2p signal relative to Figure 3.11(a) following coating.
N is the Avogadro number and p is the bulk density in kg m-3. From this ‘universal curve’ [29] typical values of λm range from ~2 (100 eV) to ~11 (1500 eV) monolayers. Expressed in nm (λn = aλm) this range is from ~6 to ~40 nm. The vertical sampling depth, corresponding to 95% of the measured electron intensity is given by 3λ sin θ where θ is the electron detection angle with respect to the surface (the ‘take-off angle’).
127
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
3.5.2.2 Instrumental Aspects The photon sources commonly used are Mg Kα1,2 and Al Kα1,2; the doublet nature of the X-ray line is not resolved and the line widths are 0.7 and 0.85 eV, respectively. Mg Kα therefore has the advantage for spectral resolution but Al Kα covers a greater energy range (see section 3.5.2.1). Al Kα can also be monochromated using Bragg diffraction from quartz crystals, reducing the line width to ~0.3 eV. In the past this was at the expense of intensity/sensitivity but modern instruments have overcome this problem through more efficient collection of the photoelectrons. Electron energy analysis is achieved by means of an electrostatic concentric hemispherical analyser operating in the fixed analyser transmission mode. All the photoelectrons are retarded to a constant ‘pass energy’ through the analyser; the higher this energy the greater the sensitivity but the lower the energy resolution. Insulating samples charge up under X-ray bombardment due to secondary election emission. With conventional sources, this is counterbalanced by the flood of low-energy electrons emanating from the front face of the window separating the X-ray source from the analysis chamber. With monochromated sources this mechanism is not available and a discrete source of electrons needs to be provided from a low-energy ‘flood gun’.
3.5.2.3 Information Levels The main source of information is the core levels. With Mg or Al Kα sources at least one core level electron is excited from all atoms in the periodic table except hydrogen. The peak positions are highly element specific with relatively few overlap problems allowing straightforward elemental analysis. As noted previously the peak intensity data is inherently quantitative. The appropriate ‘sensitivity factors‘ can be calculated from theoretical cross-sections and known instrumental factors, but are often best determined empirically using pure stoichiometric standards. Core level binding energies (BE) vary slightly (typically over a range of few eV) depending on oxidation state, electronegativity of attached ligands/chemical environment, etc., (chemical shift effect). This allows more detailed structural interpretation. Thus in the example shown in Figure 3.11, from the BE of the appropriate core levels the oxidation states of the elements aluminium, phosphorus, titanium and zirconium could be established. For organic systems the C ls, etc., chemical shifts reveal information about functionality as illustrated in Figure 3.12. Often this information can be augmented via use of the Auger peaks (from the same element) to give a number, the Auger Parameter, independent of charging effects, that is characteristic of that chemical state (the Auger peaks also suffer chemical shifts as a consequence of Equation 3.10). These data can be very material
128
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces specific and large tabulations of chemical shift and Auger Parameter data are available [30]. By using higher energy X-ray sources, (e.g., Ag Lα at ~3 keV) to excite deeper core levels more Auger Parameters can be measured.
Figure 3.12 C 1s spectra from filler surfaces following interaction with MPS. (a) Alumina after treatment (solid line), alumina before treatment multiplied by (1–x), where x is the calculated coverage by MPS, subtraction (broken line); (b) Subtraction spectrum obtained as in (a) for MPS on quartz and fitted with three components representing C-C/C-H, C-O and C(-O)= functionalities (increasing order of binding energy). These components have relative intensities of ~5:1:1 in agreement with the structure of MPS. (Reproduced with permission from F. Garbassi, E. Occhiello, C. Bastioli, G. Romano, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 1987, 117, 1, 266. Copyright 1997, Elsevier.)
129
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Bonding electrons are also photoemitted and these appear in the ‘valence band’ between, say 0-30 eV BE. Emission from many closely spaced levels with different cross-sections gives rise to a complex spectrum, often rich in structure, which in principle contains more direct structural information than the core level peaks. The spectrum is rather low in intensity (typically only a few percent that of major core lines) but with higher power instruments it is routinely accessible. The ‘fingerprint’ utility of the valence band is increasingly being augmented by full interpretations based on theoretical calculations. A range of carbon black samples of varying degree of oxidation and sulfur content were examined using XPS by Pena and co-workers [31]. In this study the O 1s spectra (543523 eV) and S 2p spectra (177-157 eV) were used to determine the relative amounts and the nature of oxygen and sulfur containing functional groups, respectively. The surface chemistry of the carbon black samples was very well resolved by XPS and was related to FMC data for adsorption of a wide variety of polymer stabilisers and relevant model compounds [31-34]. The multi-probe temperature programmed IGC study by McMahon [25] used two of the same carbon black samples as in [31-34]. The latter IGC data fitted in well with the XPS and FMC data obtained (note CB-1 and CB-2 in [25] are CB-B and CB-A, respectively in [31]).
3.5.3 Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry 3.5.3.1 Physical Basis In SIMS the sample, inside an ultra-high vacuum system (pressure <10-7 Pa) is bombarded with a primary ion beam, (e.g., Ar+, Cs+, Ga+, O2+) of energy 1-30 keV. Of the fragments of material ejected (sputtered) from the surface a few percent are charged either positively or negatively. These are extracted into a mass analyser to yield, separately, positive or negative secondary ion mass spectra. The fragments can be single elemental ions or clusters of atoms with a collective, usually single, charge. An immediate distinction needs to be made between dynamic and static SIMS experiments. In the former, a primary ion current density of typically > 10 μA cm-2 is used and this leads to rapid sputtering of material. The surface is eroded at a rate of order nm s-1 and by following the intensity of chosen peaks in the mass spectrum as a function of time, a concentration depth profile can be constructed. In this mode SIMS can be very sensitive, with trace element detection limits in the ppm-ppb range. However, quantification is not straightforward. Secondary ion intensities are strongly matrix-dependent and extensive calibration procedures involving closely related standards of known composition and under identical experimental conditions must be used to extract quantitative concentrations. In static SIMS, on the other hand, the aim is to reduce sputtering to the absolute minimum whilst obtaining a spectrum of adequate intensity. For inorganic systems a primary ion
130
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces dose of ~1014 ions cm-2 may be tolerated, resulting in the sputtering of ~10% of the uppermost monolayer. For organic systems, ion-induced damage leads to loss of spectral integrity more quickly and so a maximum dose of 1012-1013 ions cm-2 is permissible. The spectra obtained under these ‘static’ conditions provide a molecular fragmentation pattern representative of the surface molecular structure. Figure 3.13 shows the positive and negative ion mass spectra from the same pigment examined by XPS in Figure 3.11(b). The negative ion spectrum is dominated by fragments from one or more organic species on the surface - either contamination from sample handling/storage or preparation for analysis (powder deposited onto glass from methanol slurry). The pattern of intensities represents a fingerprint as in conventional gas phase mass spectrometry (but the ionisation/fragmentation processes are different). The sampling depth in SIMS is only 1-2 monolayers (~10 Å).
Figure 3.13(a) ToF SIMS spectra from coated pigment giving XPS spectrum of Figure 3.9(b): positive ion spectrum; annotated peaks are due to Na+ (m/z 23), Al+ (27), Ti+ (48), TiO+ (64), TiO(OH)+ (81), ZrO+ (106) and ZrO(OH)+ (123). See next page for Figure 3.13(b)
131
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.13(b) ToF SIMS spectra from coated pigment giving XPS spectrum of Figure 3.9(b): negative ion spectrum; annotated peaks are due to PO2- (63), PO3- (79), H2PO4- (97) all other peaks are molecular fragments from organic species.
132
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
3.5.3.2 Instrumental Aspects Since dynamic SIMS is principally a tool for trace element analysis and depth profiling it will not be considered further here. In static SIMS the major instrumental differences are related to ion sources and mass analysis. Early experiments involved the combination of a noble gas (electron impact) ion source with a quadrupole mass spectrometer. Typically 4 keV Ar+ or Xe+ ions in either a raster-scanned focussed spot or a broad stationary spot would be used. Either way a current density in the 1 nA cm-2 regime is the prerequisite for static SIMS analysis. The quadrupole mass spectrometer (QMS) is a compact device with the advantage of a large collection area, suited to the above ion bombardment conditions. A good QMS will have a mass range of 0-1000 atomic mass units (amu) and a transmission of ~0.1% (ions detected:ions ejected). However, transmission decreases with mass (Tα M-1 to M-2) and mass resolution is poor (typically, close to 1 amu over the mass range covered). During the last decade time-of-flight (ToF) mass analysers have completely eclipsed the QMS to the extent that the terms static SIMS and ToF - SIMS have become synonymous [28]. ToF analysers give much greater transmission (>10%, mass independent) and extended mass range (up to 10,000 amu). In ToF - SIMS the primary ion beam is pulsed and all the secondary ions are detected in parallel between each pulse. In contrast the QMS is a serial device, the mass range being scanned. Thus ToF - SIMS instruments are ~104 times more sensitive than QMS instruments and this allows them to perform static SIMS analysis of much smaller areas. Liquid metal ion sources (Ga+) giving small probe diameters (~400 Å) are ideal for imaging at high spatial resolution. ToF instruments also give high mass resolution (of the order of 10,000) which greatly enhances the analytical power of the technique through the resolution of ions with the same nominal mass (a trivial case is a metal ion having the same nominal mass as an organic fragment). Intense Cs+ sources, but with spot sizes of order 30 μm, are used to increase data acquisition rates when high spatial resolution is not required. Insulating samples charge up under ion bombardment and this effect must be prevented during SIMS analysis. With QMS systems a stationary ‘flood’ of relatively low energy electrons is used to ‘charge neutralise’. In ToF systems where the primary ion beam is pulsed at high frequency the electron flood takes place between individual ion pulses when the secondary ion flight times are being measured. Because the pulse averaged current density is also much lower than with a QMS system, this is a much more effective solution to the problem.
3.5.3.3 Comparison of XPS and SIMS The fingerprint quality of static SIMS spectra has already been noted. Identification of surface species is aided by the existence of an expanding library of static SIMS spectra
133
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites with a search engine [35] and the use of accurate mass measurement to assign empirical formulae to chosen peaks. Because of the high surface sensitivity, surface coverage of the substrate by organic molecules is somewhat easier to judge than by XPS. The cluster ion spectra of inorganics are similarly reflective of structure but much less work has been done in this area. SIMS can be much more sensitive to elemental species than XPS, particularly to highly electro-positive or -negative elements. The two techniques are very complementary in respect of quantification, structural insight and sampling depth. In situations such as filler surface analysis, where layered systems involving both organic and inorganic components are involved, SIMS is a valuable adjunct to XPS.
3.5.3.4 Examples There are relatively few detailed studies of particulate fillers by surface analysis and space limitations preclude a review. The interested reader is encouraged to study a series of papers by Johansson and co-workers [36-39] that address the characterisation of coated TiO2 pigments. These discuss in considerable detail the relationship between data from XPS, SIMS and X-ray fluorescence as well as relating surface analytical information to other methods of pigment surface characterisation and to pigment behaviour.
3.5.4 Diffuse Reflectance Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy 3.5.4.1 Background Infrared spectroscopy is a technique that gives intimate structural detail of the molecules under examination. The infrared radiation is absorbed by changes in the vibrational state of the molecule, that is the bending or stretching of the bonds within the molecule. Consequently, the interpretation of the spectra not only gives the chemical groupings present in the molecule but information about the environment of each of the groupings and hence the structure of the molecule. The reader should refer to [40] and [41] to gain a more fundamental understanding of the science. The basic transmission infrared spectroscopy technique has been a workhorse for chemical analysis for many years. As computers and computing techniques became more advanced (FTIR) spectrometers were developed. The introduction of FTIR revolutionised infrared (IR) spectroscopy because for the first time weak signals could be cleared of noise thanks to co-addition and Fourier analysis of many scans. The ability to produce high quality spectra from weak signals led to new sampling techniques, such as diffuse reflectance and microscopy, that simply could not be used with the older dispersive IR spectrometers. The advent of FTIR therefore brought about
134
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces a step change in the resolution and ease of use of IR spectroscopy. FTIR is now no longer the preserve of prestigious university and industrial research laboratories, now quality instruments can be purchased for as little as £12,000. This enhanced sensitivity and ability to subtract spectra with precision led to many adaptations of the technique. One of these adaptations was DRIFTS. This technique was designed to enable spectra of powders to be analysed without the need for grinding and elaborate preparation that can of course modify the chemical nature of the material. The added benefit of DRIFTS is that it is also far more surface specific than transmission IR due to a significant proportion of low and glancing angle reflections though filler surface layers. This effect was effectively demonstrated by Gilbert and co-workers [42] who showed that stearic acid in physical mixtures with various fillers gave very weak IR absorbance in DRIFTS spectra, relative to equivalent amounts of stearic acid that had been adsorbed on the filler surface. FTIR data analysis software enables spectral data for the uncoated filler to be subtracted from that of the coated specimen, thus creating a difference spectrum that enhances absorption bands associated only with the surface treatment. It is important to point out that subtraction does not always yield additional information, especially when a small absorption associated with a surface treatment is obscured by a large absorption associated with the filler. Spectral changes relative to the unbound surface treatment/additive provide insight into the nature of interaction with the surface. Examples of use of DRIFTS are described in Section 3.5.4.4. DRIFTS spectra can be quantified provided sample preparation/presentation and representation of the data is correct.
3.5.4.2 Comparison of DRIFTS and XPS It is important to appreciate that whilst DRIFTS is an IR spectroscopy method that has significant surface specificity, it is by no means an exclusively surface analytical technique as is the case with XPS and SIMS, which have penetration depths in the order of nanometres. The penetration depth in DRIFTS is an order of magnitude higher, i.e., micrometres. However, the high proportion of low and glancing angles of incidence afford the high degree of surface specificity that is the key advantage of the technique. Sutherland [43] has found that with a 20 m2 g-1 calcium carbonate filler, detection limits of less than 0.05 monolayers can be achieved. Rather surprisingly this level of sensitivity was higher than that achievable using XPS on the same series of samples. This can be explained, however, by the greater sampling depth of DRIFTS that enables resolution of surface modifier within pores in the filler surface. The different sampling depths available using these techniques have been exploited by Gilbert and co-workers in more recent studies of fatty acid treated fillers [44].
135
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
3.5.4.3 Sample Preparation It is possible to analyse the filler in an undiluted state using DRIFTS, however, specular reflection and excessively strong absorption can lead to poor quality spectra featuring negative peaks. It is now widely accepted that the filler sample must be diluted with an IR transparent powder such as KBr or KF. The latter must be finely ground and ideally the same batch of ground diluent must be used for a whole sample series. The level of dilution should be such that there is no compression or saturation of the spectrum. This can be observed by comparison of the DRIFTS spectrum with a transmission spectrum of the untreated filler in a KBr disk. Usually 1-10% w/w filler in the diluent will give uncompressed spectra. It is also very important that the ground KBr and filler are not mixed roughly, i.e., by grinding, as the surface layers will be disrupted and non-representative data will be generated; the two components should be mixed by a gentle folding motion with a micro-spatula.
3.5.4.4 Description of DRIFTS Cell A simplified line diagram of a cell is shown in Figure 3.14. The essential features of the cell are mirrors and optics to focus the incident infra-red beam onto the surface of the powdered filler which is held in the sample holder. The reflected radiation that is now scattered across a wide angle, due to the random orientation of the surfaces of the filler
Figure 3.14 Schematic diagram of a typical DRIFTS cell
136
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
Figure 3.15 Schematic diagram of DRIFTS sample holder with specular reflection blocker
particles from which it is reflecting, is captured by the elliptical output mirror. The mirror refocuses the radiation back into a beam that is further corrected by the output optics before passing through to the detector. A further refinement of the sample holder has been the introduction of a specular reflection blocker. Specular reflection is the radiation that is reflected from the front surface of the sample and has not penetrated the powder. This can occur if the filler sample is not sufficiently diluted with KBr or KF. Specularly reflected radiation can render some data transformations invalid and can therefore potentially reduce the accuracy of any quantitative measurements. To overcome this problem blocker devices have been developed that are adaptations of the sample holder. The most basic type is illustrated in Figure 3.15, this simply introduces a physical barrier to the specularly reflected radiation. Correct dilution of the filler powder with finely ground KBr or KF can, however, eliminate the vast majority of specular reflection components without recourse to the blocker. The authors have found that the blocker also removes a significant fraction of the diffuse reflection components and can therefore needlessly weaken the signal.
3.5.4.5 Treatment of Data for Quantitative Analysis Treatment of diffuse reflectance IR data normally involves the Kubelka-Munk (KM) Equation (3.13) that takes account of scattering and absorption characteristics [45]. The constants s and k are used to describe the scattering and absorption properties, respectively, and R∞ is the reflectivity of an infinitely thick sample:
137
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites k (1 − R ∞ ) = 2R ∞ s
2
(3.13)
This relationship is only valid if there are no specular reflection components. Sutherland [43], however, has compared plotting of ratioed data both in absorbance and in KM units as a function of added surface treatment level. As linear relationships were obtained in both cases it was therefore considered that there was no advantage to be gained in using the KM equation. In transmission IR spectroscopy, using a constant path length, absorbance is proportional to concentration; this relationship (the Beer-Lambert law) will only be true for DRIFTS if the nature of dispersion of filler particles in the diluent does not change with the level of surface treatment. Such an ideal condition will rarely be realised. Therefore it is essential to use internal standards within spectra and ratio variable absorptions to these internal standards. Use of absorbance peak area is preferable to the absolute absorbance value (peak height) as area takes the overall energy of the absorbance into account and thus accounts for changes in peak width. The internal standard should be selected carefully as it should not be affected by treatment level. For example with metal hydroxide fillers the OH stretching bands at 3750-3070 cm-1, (depending on actual hydroxide) are a convenient internal standard. This may at first seem surprising considering the fact that many surface modifiers react with the OH groups/ions of the filler, but the reasoning behind use of these bands is clear when the micrometre penetration depth of DRIFTS sampling is considered. The surface area of most mineral fillers for polymers is relatively low (< 30 m2 g-1) therefore the reactive groups on the filler surface are insignificant in number relative to those in the bulk of the filler particles. Hence under such circumstances it can be considered valid to use the IR absorbance of surface treatment reactive groups as internal standards. However, in the case of filler with high surface area, i.e., some grades of silica, the latter argument is not valid. This therefore requires the use of a truly non-reactive IR absorbing group as the internal standard, for example the siloxane related adsorption of silica, centred at 800 cm-1.
3.5.4.6 Examples The following examples illustrate the power of the DRIFTS technique for analysis of interaction between fillers and surface treatments or polymer additives. The first example examines the adsorption of maleanised polybutadiene (MPBD) onto aluminium hydroxide (ATH) and magnesium hydroxide. These are two very effective flame retardant fillers, ATH is the most commonly used, but magnesium hydroxide with
138
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces its higher decomposition temperature has become established in some sectors of the market. MPBD is an effective dispersant and coupling agent, both in thermoset composites or rubber compounding. The spectra (Figures 3.16, 3.17 and 3.18) are presented in transmittance mode and not Kubelka-Munk units as discussed previously. However, the purpose of this investigation was to understand the chemical reactions taking place at the filler surface and not to make any quantitative measurements. Figure 3.16 shows the spectrum of MPBD. The sample was prepared by coating a film onto a sodium chloride disc and the spectrum was measured in transmission mode. The key features are the peaks at 1860 cm-1 and 1781 cm-1 corresponding to the symmetric and asymmetric carbonyl stretching frequencies. Figure 3.17 contains the difference spectrum between ATH and ATH which had been coated, from solution, with the same grade of MPBD. In this spectrum relatively weak adsorptions at 1860 cm-1 and 1781 cm-1 are present indicating some unreacted MPBD, but in addition a strong peak at 1700 cm-1 exists which corresponds to the absorption frequency of the carbonyl stretch in the carboxylic acid. Clear evidence that the anhydride has hydrolysed, but the lack of a strong peak at 1580 cm-1, the carbonyl stretching frequency of the salt, shows that the acid had not reacted with the surface of the ATH to form salt bridging between the polybutadiene backbone and the filler surface.
Figure 3.16 Transmission infra-red spectrum of MPBD
139
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.17 DRIFTS difference spectrum of ATH subtracted from ATH coated with MPBD
Figure 3.18 DRIFTS infra-red difference spectrum of magnesium hydroxide subtracted from magnesium hydroxide coated with MPBD
Figure 3.18 is also a difference plot, but between magnesium hydroxide and magnesium hydroxide coated in MPBD by the same solution coating procedure used for the ATH. In this spectrum there are again relatively weak absorptions at 1860 cm-1
140
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces and 1781 cm -1 from unreacted MPBD, but now only a very weak absorption at 1700 cm-1 from carboxylic acid. However, a strong absorption at 1580 cm-1 shows that the MPBD had reacted with the magnesium hydroxide to form the salt, to fully couple the butadiene backbone with the filler surface. The second example shows how DRIFTS can give insight into the environment in which adsorbed species reside and how this environment changes with addition level [46]. Figure 3.19 shows the carbonyl region of substrate subtracted DRIFTS spectra of magnesium hydroxide that has been treated with varying levels of stearate (from ammonium stearate).
Figure 3.19 Substrate subtracted DRIFTS spectra for the carbonyl region of magnesium hydroxide treated with increasing amounts of ammonium stearate. (a) 10 mg g-1, (b) 20 mg g-1, (c) 30 mg g-1, (d) 45 mg g-1, (e) 60 mg g-1, (f) 90 mg g-1, (g) magnesium stearate and (h) stearic acid. (Reproduced with permission from C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, G.C Lees and W.C.E. Schofield, Journal of Adhesion, 2002, 78, 7, 603. Copyright 2002, Taylor & Francis).
141
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Interesting changes are evident in both the asymmetric and symmetric carboxylate carbonyl stretching frequencies (1580-1550 cm-1 and 1420-1360 cm-1, respectively). It is evident that the asymmetric stretching frequency increases to a limiting value somewhere between 30 mg g-1 (the monolayer coverage) and 45 mg g-1. Changes in the symmetric stretching vibration frequency relative to the asymmetric vibration can provide insight in to the degree of coordination of the magnesium ion [47]. At a stearate level of 10 mg g-1 adsorption is via the monocarboxylate (C17H35COOMgOH) (here the wavenumber difference between the symmetric and asymmetric stretching frequencies are greater than in pure magnesium stearate). Increasing the addition level to 20 mg g-1 led to to mixed adsorption via the monocarboxylate and dicarboxylate (the symmetric stretching vibration is now split in two). Increasing the level to 30 mg g-1 and beyond indicated exclusive production of the dicarboxylate. Formation of the dicarboxylate on top of the first monolayer is manifested as attainment of a limiting value of the asymmetric stretching frequency at an addition level greater than the monolayer level, i.e., between 30 and 45 mg g-1. The fact that the limiting value of the asymmetric stretching vibration frequency is identical to that in pure magnesium stearate indicates that the adsorbed layers are only weakly associated with the filler surface.
Figure 3.20 Infrared absorption peak area ratio (C-H stretch [from AS] (A(C-H)s)/O-H stretch [from Mg(OH)2] (A(O-H)s), obtained from DRIFTS spectra of ammonium stearate treated magnesium hydroxide. (Reproduced with permission from C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, G.C Lees and W.C.E. Schofield, Journal of Adhesion, 2002, 78, 7, 603, Figure 3. Copyright 2002, Taylor & Francis)
142
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces Continual adsorption beyond the monolayer level is confirmed by plotting the C-H deformation band to OH deformation band area ratio versus the addition level. Whilst there is a linear increase in the peak area ratio up to the monolayer level, there is still a progressive increase beyond it. The ability of IR spectroscopy to probe the environment in which bonds vibrate allows it to be used to examine structural ordering of surface modifier molecules. If alkyl chains for example are in a liquid-like state of disorder the dispersion forces of attraction between chains are not maximised and vibration of the C-H bonds is influenced almost solely by the bond stiffness. If on the other hand the chains are in an ordered crystalline array, dispersion forces are maximised. This causes the C-H bonds to become very slightly longer (and therefore weaker) than when in the liquid state. This reduction in stiffness causes the asymmetric C-H stretching vibration frequency of a C18 alkyl chain to reduce by 3-5 cm-1. Such frequency shifts have been used by Kellar and co-workers [48] to investigate ordering of oleic acid monolayers and by Liauw and co-workers [13, 49]. Vaia and co-workers [50] have also used this approach to examine the order of alkyl chains of quaternary alkyl ammonium intercalants in organo-clays for nanocomposite applications. The third example shows how DRIFTS can be used to gain further insight into what interactions occur in the FMC cell. A study of the adsorption of isostearic and acrylic acids on to aluminium and magnesium hydroxide, was carried out with the intention of evaluating mixed surface modifier systems that possess dispersant and coupling capabilities. Figure 3.21(a) shows a DRIFTS spectrum of a sample of magnesium hydroxide recovered from the FMC cell (and air-dried) after adsorption and desorption of isostearic acid followed by adsorption and desorption of acrylic acid. Figure 3.21(c) shows a DRIFTS spectrum of filler obtained after the reverse experiment, i.e., adsorption and desorption of acrylic acid followed by adsorption and desorption of isostearic acid. Figures 3.21(b) and 3.21(d) shows DRIFTS spectra after adsorption and desorption of acrylic and isostearic acids, respectively. It is evident that acrylic acid will completely displace isostearic acid, however, isostearic acid will adsorb onto a layer of adsorbed acrylic acid. It is envisaged that mixed isostearate and acrylate binary salts may form during the latter adsorption process but not when adsorption of isostearic acid is followed by adsorption of acrylic acid. This is likely to be due to the higher acidity of acrylic acid and magnesium isostearate being more soluble in the toluene carrier solvent than magnesium acrylate. Further examples of application of DRIFTS, and other surface analytical techniques, to organosilane treated fillers and interphase characterisation in organosilane modified composite, have been reviewed by Suzuki and Ishida [51].
143
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
Figure 3.21 DRIFTS spectra of magnesium hydroxide recovered from the FMC cell after adsorption from toluene of: (a) isostearic acid followed by acrylic acid, (b) acrylic acid, (c) acrylic acid followed by isostearic acid and (d) isostearic acid. (Reproduced with permission from C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, G.C Lees and Z. Iqbal, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 2001, 15, 8, 908. Copyright 2001, VSP)
3.6 Methods for Examining Structural Order in Filler Coatings Whilst structural order within adsorbed layers of surface modifier molecules is usually considered to be confined to linear chain fatty acids, it is important to appreciate that silane-based treatments can also undergo a degree of structural ordering under certain conditions. Gähde [52] may have indirectly observed such structural ordering with MPS adsorbed on glass, as the latter gave rise to preferred orientation of polyethylene chains. In a study of adsorption of MPS on to lead oxide, Miller and Ishida [53] attributed a shift in the Si—O—Si asymmetric stretching band (in DRIFTS spectra (see Section 3.5.4))
144
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces to structural ordering as polysilsesquioxane ladder polymers absorb in the same region. In this last section, brief details of other suitable analysis methods that may confirm the presence of structural order are given.
3.6.1 Wide Angle X-Ray Diffraction By virtue of the conveniently sized wavelength diffraction/scattering of X-rays is a long established tool for probing the structure of materials. X-ray diffraction (or WAXS) can be used to measure distances between planes in crystalline structures. For a review of the concepts and methods of WAXS the reader is referred to Cullity’s book [54]. The authors [13, 49] have found WAXS useful for establishing if any structural order is present in fatty acid coatings on filler surfaces. Gilbert and co-workers [55] have also found the technique useful for analysis of fillers treated with fatty acids and fatty acid salts. Stearic acid adsorbed from heptane solution on to magnesium hydroxide (as magnesium stearate) was shown to exhibit structural order [49]. This was manifested as a reflection that became apparent at coverage levels at and beyond monolayer. The d-spacing of the reflection corresponded to the short spacing of magnesium stearate. Isostearic acid and oleic acid adsorbed under the same or similar conditions as the stearic acid showed no evidence of structural order due to the inability of the alkyl/alkenyl chains to pack into an ordered structure [13]. WAXS has become the one of the main techniques for analysis of organoclays and polymer layered silicate nanocomposites. These aspects have been thoroughly reviewed by Vaia [56].
3.6.2 Differential Scanning Calorimetry DSC can be used to observe phase transitions in materials such as melting behaviour (first order transitions) and second order transitions that are associated with the glass transitions of polymers [57]. In essence DSC measures the energy required to maintain a constant temperature in the sample relative to an inert reference. Therefore processes that lead to a change in heat capacity, i.e., melting and glass transitions can be observed, as can endothermic or exothermic chemical reactions. DSC instruments are now extremely sensitive and are quite capable of resolving phase transitions of adsorbed surface modifiers. For analysis of fillers dynamic DSC is most useful. In this mode, the difference in electric power input required to keep the reference pan at the same temperature as the sample pan (i.e., the heat flow), is recorded as a function of steadily increasing (or decreasing) temperature. A typical dynamic DSC analysis may consist of a heat-cool-heat cycle.
145
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites The same stearic acid treated magnesium hydroxide samples, discussed in Section 3.6.1 showed evidence of melting of stearic acid and/or magnesium stearate even at the monolayer level. Use of heat-cool-heat cycles can indicate structural changes that occur as a result of further reaction of a surface modifier with the substrate. This effect occurred with magnesium hydroxide that had been treated with 2.5 monolayers of stearic acid [13]. DSC data from the first heat segment of the cycle showed evidence of free stearic acid but data from the second heat segment showed that this may have become magnesium stearate (Figure 3.22) [58]. Coatings derived from oleic and isostearic acids showed no melting endotherm peaks and were thus considered amorphous, in concordance with the WAXS data.
Figure 3.22 First heat (upper) and second heat (lower) DSC data (from a heat–coolheat cycle) showing the change in structure within adsorbed layers of (a) stearic acid and (b) isostearic acid on magnesium hydroxide, together with untreated magnesium hydroxide (c). Note change in heat flow scale from first to second heat. (Reproduced with data from C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, G.C Lees and Z. Iqbal, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, VSP, 2001, 15, 8, 896. Copyright 2001, VSP.)
146
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces
3.7 Summary This chapter has described how the most important property of a particulate filler, with regard to its reactivity, is the acidic or basic character of its surface sites. Furthermore, that the surface of a single filler particle can have sites ranging from strongly acidic to strongly basic. It has been shown that techniques for characterising filler surfaces can be broadly divided into three groups. In the first, the reactivity of the filler surface to well defined probe molecules is observed. Of these, FMC is perhaps the more powerful, giving the ability to measure heat of adsorption directly and using the polymers, coupling agents or additives of interest. IGC is more instrumentally developed, but generally requires the use of model probes because of the need for them to be volatile and reversibly adsorbed. The second group, XPS and SIMS, are the analytical techniques that are capable of determining the chemical composition of filler surfaces, as opposed to the bulk. DRIFTS has a greater penetration depth than XPS or SIMS but in many cases, such as when the filler has a porous surface, this is advantageous. The DRIFTS examples clearly demonstrated how insight into the nature of interactions between surface modifiers and filler surfaces could be acquired. The third group of techniques (WAXS and DSC) can be used to establish the existence of structural order in adsorbed layers of surface modifiers. DSC in particular can be linked to FTIR if a suitable DSC hot stage is used on an infrared microscope, this combination has exciting potential for following the reactions between fillers and surface modifiers. The fact that certain fillers are now valuable functional additives for polymers is a testament to the ever-increasing importance of surface characterisation. Insight into the surface chemistry of fillers opens the door to surface modification; a technology that in-turn leads to high added value products. The emergence of nanocomposite technology places even more emphasis on the filler surface by default due to the fact that the interfacial region in a fully exfoliated nanocomposite forms a very significant fraction of the composite volume. In such systems there is huge potential for modification of the interfacial region by modification of the platelet surfaces. Therefore improvements on the techniques described here will be inevitable and will be driven by an ever-increasing quest to use filler surfaces to promote unique composite properties. It is highly likely that data from these improved techniques may help in creation of improved computer models of surfaces, leading to advanced modelling of adsorption interactions.
147
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
References 1.
F.M. Fowkes, Journal of Adhesion, 1972, 4, 155.
2.
S.T. Joslin and F.M. Fowkes, Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Product Research and Development, 1985, 24, 3, 369.
3.
F.M. Fowkes, D.C. McCarthy and D.O. Tischler in Molecular Characterisation of Composite Interfaces, Eds., H. Ishida and G. Kumar, Plenum Press, New York, NY, USA, 1985, 401.
4.
F.M. Fowkes, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1984, 57, 2, 328.
5.
G.N. Lewis, Journal of the Franklin Institute, 1938, 226, 293.
6.
R.S. Mulliken, Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1952, 56, 801.
7.
R.G. Pearson, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1963, 85, 22, 3533.
8.
V. Gutmann, A. Steininger and E. Wychera, Monatshefte für Chemie, 1966, 97, 460.
9.
R.S. Drago and B.B. Wayland, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1965, 87, 16, 3571.
10. F.L. Riddle and F.M. Fowkes, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1990, 112, 9, 3259. 11. F.M. Fowkes, Acid-Base Interactions: Relevance to Adhesion Science and Technology, Eds., K.L. Mittal and H.R. Anderson, Jnr., VSP Publications, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 1991, 93. 12. F.M. Fowkes, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 1987, 1, 1, 7. 13. C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, G.C. Lees and Z. Iqbal, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 2001, 15, 8, 889. 14. D.P. Ashton and R.N. Rothon in Controlled Interphases in Composite Materials, Ed., H. Ishida, Elsevier, New York, NY, USA, 1990, 295. 15. J. Wolfschwenger, A. Hauer, M. Gahleitner and W. Neissl, Proceedings of Eurofillers 97, Manchester, UK, 1997, p.375. 16. C.M. Liauw, A. Childs, N.S. Allen, M. Edge, K.R. Franklin and D.G. Collopy, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 1999, 65, 2, 207.
148
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces 17. C.M. Liauw, A. Childs, N.S. Allen, M. Edge, K.R. Franklin and D.G. Collopy, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 1999, 63, 3, 391. 18. A.V. Kiselev and Y.I. Yashin, Gas-Adsorption Chromatography, Plenum Press, New York, NY, USA, 1969. 19. D.R. Williams in Controlled Interphases in Composite Materials, Ed., H. Ishida, Elsevier, New York, NY, USA, 1990, 219. 20. C. Kembell and E. K. Rideal, Proceedings of the Royal Society, London, 1946, A187, 53. 21. L. Lavielle and J. Schultz, Langmuir, 1991, 7, 5, 978. 22. J. Schultz, L. Lavielle and C. Martin, Journal of Adhesion, 1987, 23, 1, 45. 23. U. Panzer and H.P. Schreiber, Macromolecules, 1992, 25, 14, 3633. 24. W.O. McReynolds, Journal of Chromatographic Science, 1970, 8, 685. 25. A.W. McMahon, D.G. Kelly and P.J. McLaughlin, The Analyst, 2002, 127, 1, 17. 26(a) Practical Surface Analysis, Volume 1: Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, Second Edition, Eds., D. Briggs and M.P. Seah, Wiley, Chichester, UK, 1990. 26(b).Practical Surface Analysis, Volume 2: Ion and Neutral Spectroscopy, Second Edition, Eds., D. Briggs and M.P. Seah, Wiley, Chichester, UK, 1992. 27. Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, Eds., D. Briggs and J.T Grant, SurfaceSpectra/IM Publications, Manchester, UK, 2003. 28. ToF-SIMS: Surface Analysis by Mass Spectrometry, Eds., J.C. Vickerman and D. Briggs, SurfaceSpectra/IM Publications, Manchester, UK, 2001. 29. M.P. Seah and W.A. Dench, Surface and Interface Analysis, 1979, 1, 2. 30. The NIST X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy Database, http://srdata.nist.gov/xps. 31. J.M. Pena, N.S. Allen, M. Edge, C.M. Liauw, F. Santamaria, O. Noiset and B. Valange, Journal of Materials Science, 2001, 36, 12, 2885. 32. J.M. Pena, N.S. Allen, M. Edge, C.M. Liauw, O. Noiset and B. Valange, Journal of Materials Science, 2001, 36, 18, 4419. 33. J.M. Pena, N.S. Allen, C.M. Liauw, M. Edge, B. Valange and F. Santamaria, Journal of Materials Science, 2001, 36, 18, 4443.
149
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites 34. J.M. Pena, N.S. Allen, M. Edge, C.M. Liauw and B. Valange, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 2001, 72, 1, 31 35. The Static SIMS Library (version 3), Eds., J. C. Vickerman, D. Briggs and A. Henderson, SurfaceSpectra, Manchester, UK, 2002. 36. L-S. Johansson and T. Losoi, Surface and Interface Analysis, 1991, 17, 5, 230. 37. L-S. Johansson, Surface and Interface Analysis, 1991, 17, 9, 663. 38. L-S. Johansson, T. Losoi and J. Jukanoja, Surface and Interface Analysis, 1993, 20, 2, 155. 39. L-S. Johansson, Surface and Interface Analysis, 1993, 20, 4, 304. 40. G.M. Barrow, Introduction to Molecular Spectroscopy, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, USA, 1962. 41. C.N. Banwell, Fundamentals of Molecular Spectroscopy, 2nd Edition, McGrawHill, New York, NY, USA, 1972. 42. M. Gilbert, I. Sutherland and A. Guest, Proceedings of Filplas 92, Manchester, UK, 1992, Session 1, Paper No.3 43. I. Sutherland, Proceedings of Eurofillers 97, Manchester, UK, 1997, p.93. 44. M. Gilbert, I. Sutherland and A. Guest, Journal of Materials Science, 2000, 35, 2, 391. 45. P. Kubelka and F. Munk, Zeitschrift Für Technische Physik, 1931, 12, 593. 46. R.N. Rothon, C.M. Liauw, G.C. Lees and W.C.E. Schofield, Journal of Adhesion, 2002, 78, 603 47. P.J. Thistlethwaite and M.S. Hook, Langmuir, 2000, 16, 11, 4993. 48. J.J. Kellar, C.A. Young, K. Knutston and J.D. Miller, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 1991, 144, 2, 381. 49. C.M. Liauw, R.N. Rothon, S.J. Hurst and G.C. Lees, Composite Interfaces, 1998, 5, 6, 503. 50. R.A. Vaia, R.K. Tuekolsky and E.P. Giannelis, Chemistry of Materials, 1994, 6, 7, 1017.
150
Analytical Techniques for Characterising Filler Surfaces 51. N. Suzuki and H. Ishida, Macromolecular Symposia, 1996, 108, 19. 52. J. Gähde, Plaste und Kautschuk, 1975, 22, 8, 626. 53. J.D. Miller and H. Ishida, Proceedings of the SPE 40th Annual Conference of the Reinforced Plastics and Composites Institute, Atlanta, GA, USA, 1985, Session 17-B, p.1. 54. B.D. Cullity and S.R. Stock, Elements of X-ray Diffraction, 3rd Edition, Prentice Hall, London, UK, 2001. 55. M. Gilbert, P. Petiraksakul and I. Mathieson, Materials Science and Technology, 2001, 17, 11, 1472. 56. R.A Vaia in Polymer-Clay Nanocomposites, Eds., T.J. Pinnavaia and G.W. Beall, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, USA, 2000. 57. Calorimetry and Thermal Analysis of Polymers, Ed., V.B.F. Mathot, Hanser Publishers, Munich, Germany, 1993. 58. R.N. Rothon, C.M. Liauw and C.G. Lees, Proceedings of Eurofillers 99, British Plastics Federation, Lyon, France, 1999, Session 4, Paper No. 44.
151
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
152
4
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers Roger N. Rothon
4.1 Introduction As described in the earlier chapters, the filler surface plays a vital role in determining the processing behaviour and properties of composites. The main methods for characterising filler surfaces were discussed in the previous chapter. This chapter covers the use of additives to beneficially modify the surface of fillers, and thus optimise composite processing and properties. A wide range of such surface modifiers are offered and used commercially, ranging from the inexpensive fatty acids, to silanes, titanates and zirconates and all are discussed. Reference is also made to non-commercial treatments, such as borates and phosphates.
4.2 Reasons for Using Surface Modifiers With the notable exception of carbon blacks, the natural surfaces of most particulate fillers are less than optimum for dispersion into, and interaction with, polymers. Surface modifiers can frequently improve this, and other filler properties. Sometimes materials which are effective surface modifiers will be found to have been added for filler manufacturing reasons. The main reasons for finding surface modifiers present are: •
Improved filler production. Thus, they can be used as milling aids and to improve filtration and reduce hardness development during drying.
•
Protection of the filler in storage and in the end application. Thus, they can reduce water pick up and protect fillers such as magnesium hydroxide from attack by atmospheric carbon dioxide.
•
Improved processing. Surface modification often improves the rate of incorporation into the polymer and reduces the viscosity of the mix. This can lead to significant savings in energy, or to faster throughput. Indeed, some form of surface modification is often essential when high filler loadings are used.
153
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites •
Reduced adsorption of expensive additives, notably curatives and anti-oxidants. Resulting improvements in curing can also lead to improved properties.
•
Improved composite properties. These can include: increased strength and stiffness, better impact strength, increased abrasion resistance, reduced adsorption and less swelling in the presence of water and other fluids.
It should also be noted that the presence of surface modifiers can also influence other properties. This includes properties such as bulk density, powder flow and dustiness. They can also have unexpected effects on properties such as thermal stability, fire retardancy and ageing. These effects may be positive or negative.
4.3 General Principles of Surface Modification Virtually all treatments in commercial use are chosen to chemically bond an organic species to the filler surface, thus improving compatibility with organic polymers. The most common functionalities used for this are acids or acid precursors, such as anhydrides (for basic or amphoteric fillers) and alkoxy-silanes (for fillers with metal hydroxyls present, especially siliceous fillers). Organo-titanates and related compounds are also proposed for use with a wide variety of fillers. Two distinct types of surface modifier can be recognised: non-coupling and coupling. The non-coupling types have a chemical bond to the filler surface, but no strong bonding to the polymer matrix. The widely used saturated fatty acids are typical of this class. The coupling types, usually described as coupling agents, have both a chemical bond with the filler surface, and some means of strong interaction with the polymer matrix. This interaction with the polymer is usually due to some chemical functionality, which can react with it. In some instances, it is due to the anchored species having long enough chains to entangle, or co-crystallise, with the matrix. Where the matrix polymer undergoes a polymerisation, or crosslinking process, during composite formation; then it is fairly simple to choose a suitable polymer reactive group (e.g., a carbon=carbon double bond). However, with polymers such as the polyolefins, this can be difficult. Highly reactive functionalities, such as azides, are sometimes used in this case. It is also possible to pre-functionalise a part of the polymer matrix, by grafting on a species such as an acid, anhydride or alkoxy-silane, in a separate process.
154
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers
4.4 Methods of Using Surface Modifiers Modification of the surface of fillers may be brought about in a variety of ways. The most appropriate will depend on many factors, including: the nature of the filler and the process used in producing it, the nature of the additive, and of the polymer and the composite processing conditions. The first differentiation is into pre-coating and ‘in situ’ methods. In the latter, the coating agent is added during compounding, making its way to, and reacting with, the filler surface during this process. The main advantages and disadvantages of the two procedures are summarised in Table 4.1. The relative importance of the various factors will vary depending on the nature of the coating and filler and on the composite processing conditions. In some cases, especially where some new surface may be generated during processing, a combination of the two approaches may give optimum results.
Table 4.1 A comparison of the pre-coating and in situ methods of filler treatment Pre-coating
In situ
Usually requires an expensive additional step, but is claimed to give more efficient use of the additive.
Usually less expensive, but may require higher additive levels.
Volatile by-products such as alcohols are easily dealt with.
Volatile by-products can be a problem.
Essential where improved filler processing and stability are sought. Surface reaction and coverage can be strictly controlled. Interference from other compounding additives can be minimised.
Surface reaction is very much at the mercy of processing conditions, including competition from other additives. Residual, unreacted, additive more likely to be present and may cause problems.
Unable to treat fresh surface generated during compounding.
Opportunity to treat fresh surface generated during compounding.
Interpenetration of coating and matrix may be limited.
Greater opportunity for coating/matrix interpenetration.
Limited flexibility for adjusting the formulation.
Greater formulation freedom, although the additive must have some degree of ‘solubility’ in the polymer.
155
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites Where the filler is pre-coated, various methods may be used, depending on the nature of the filler, the coating, and the filler preparation procedure. When the filler is produced from aqueous solution, such as by precipitation, it is often advantageous to add a water dispersible or soluble, form of the coating, prior to filtration and drying. If the coating is carefully chosen, it can actually aid filtration and reduce caking during drying. Fatty acid treatments fulfil such a role on precipitated calcium carbonates. In most cases however, the cost of solvent removal makes solution coating uneconomic, and dry coating is favoured wherever possible. Dry coating is often achieved during a milling process, or by use of a suitable mixer. In the dry milling procedures, the conditions must be carefully chosen to ensure complete coverage and surface reaction. The best form of mixer will depend on the filler. In most instances, a high shear mixer is used to ensure rapid de-agglomeration and coating. Such mixers usually generate a significant amount of heat, which can be useful, especially where the additive has to be melted, or a reaction product like water or alcohol has to be removed. With shear sensitive fillers, such as acicular grades of wollastonite, low shear mixers are necessary to avoid excessive degradation of the filler. In such cases, coating times are longer and external heating may be needed with some types of additive. Coating methods are returned to in the sections dealing with specific additive types.
4.5 Choice of Coating Level After deciding on the types of modifier to use, one has to decide on the amount that is needed. Many modifiers are relatively expensive, so it is important not to waste any. Moreover, excess amounts can sometimes lead to deleterious effects. The optimum level will depend on the effects that are being sought, as well as factors such as: how the modifier reacts with the surface, how well it covers that surface, what the thickness and structure of the coating layer are, and how it interacts with the matrix. Some useful guidelines exist to enable an approximate level to be decided on, but final optimisation usually requires trial and error. The most important theoretical concept is probably that of the mono-layer. By this is meant the amount of additive required to just produce a surface layer, one coating molecule in thickness. This appears to be a straightforward concept, but there are quite a few complications in practice. Theoretical mono-layer amounts can be calculated using factors such as the density of reactive sites and the area occupied by a molecule of coating. The smoothness and accessibility of the surface also has to be taken into account. Some of the main issues that can arise are summarised in Figure 4.1.
156
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers
Figure 4.1 Different idealised structures for surface mono-layers on a filler surface
Figure 4.1c shows the ideal situation: where the surface is smooth and its reactive sites are spaced at just the right distance for a tightly packed surface layer to be formed. While this situation may be thought unlikely, it seems that stearic acid coatings on calcium carbonate come very close to it, which may explain their great success with this filler. Figure 4.1a shows a situation where the surface sites are widely spaced. Only part of the surface layer can now be strongly bound and the layer is unable to pack so tightly. Small molecules such as water could easily penetrate to the surface. Figure 4.1b shows the reverse case: the reactive sites are too closely spaced for complete reaction. Again, small molecules could reach the surface and possibly destabilise the bonding. A further area of confusion is in assessing molecular orientation at the surface. Most molecules have a number of possible orientations, which makes calculation of geometric coverage difficult. This is especially true of some organo-silane coupling agents, where the functionality intended to react with the matrix may in some circumstances be strongly adsorbed onto the filler surface, resulting in flat, or bridged, rather than vertical orientation (see Section 4.7). Even long chain carboxylic acids may adsorb flat rather than vertically at low coverages. This situation is illustrated in Figure 4.1d. Loopy adsorption such as is illustrated in Figure 4.1e is possible when multifunctional adsorbates are used.
157
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites A further factor not usually taken into account is the surface topography. Thus, while good packing of adsorbed species may well be achieved on a molecularly flat surface such as glass or mica, most particulate mineral fillers will have a rough surface which may prevent such densely packed layers forming. Ishida and Koenig have reported on the effects of surface topography on the structure of some silane coupling agents [1]. Finally, it must be realised that adsorption onto a surface may not be uniform. There may be patches, several molecules thick, in some places and bare surface in others. While the issues discussed previously may seem academic, they are of great practical importance. This is particularly so with regard to the durability of coating effects under humid conditions, where the ability of the surface to adsorb water, which may hydrolyse surface bonds, is a key issue. In general, properties start to change well before complete surface coverage is reached and in some applications, full coverage may not be essential. In many cases, the maximum effect is often found at about the mono-layer level, but multi-layers are found to be beneficial in some instances, particularly where they are able to interpenetrate with the matrix polymer. A good example of the effect of additive level on a wide number of properties of a magnesium hydroxide filled ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) co-polymer can be found in work by Rothon and co-workers [2]. This includes effects on flame retardant properties and on ageing. The latter is particularly interesting, as it was found that excess of the fatty acid led to a significant decrease in ageing resistance. This was most marked when a commercial blend of fatty acid was used, but was still very significant with pure stearic acid.
4.6 Techniques for Determining the Amount of Coating Present, and Assessing the Amount Needed for Mono-layer Coverage The main techniques for characterising the structure of filler surfaces have been covered in detail in the previous chapter. This section deals with methods for determining the amount present on a filler surface and for obtaining an indication of the amount of additive needed for mono-layer coverage.
4.6.1 Determination of Amount of Additive and it’s Distribution A number of analytical methods are possible, depending on the chemical nature of the filler and additive, and the techniques available. Some of the main ones are described
158
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers next. One of the problems with many techniques is in differentiating between additive that is actually on the filler surface, and that which is merely present as a physical mixture with the filler.
4.6.1.1 Chemical Analysis Methods These can be used where the additive has an element that is clearly different from the filler, and where the amount of additive is sufficient for the sensitivity of the technique being employed. Thus, carbon analysis can be used for many additives on silica surfaces, and titanium analysis is possible for organo-titanates on many fillers. This approach does not distinguish between surface and admixed additive though.
4.6.1.2 Pyrolysis This can also be used with success in many cases providing any weight loss from the filler itself is corrected for. Again, it does not distinguish between surface and admixed amounts.
4.6.1.3 Infra-red Methods These are particularly useful where, as often happens, the additive has at least one characteristic spectral band that is clearly different from the filler. The hydrocarbon bands present in many additives usually provide a good marker. Pre-calibration is necessary, using fillers with known amounts of additive, and it helps if it is possible to use a strong filler peak as an internal standard. Transmission methods will detect both surface and admixed additive, while reflectance methods such as diffuse reflectance Fourier transform infra-red spectroscopy (DRIFTS) [3] are surface sensitive, and thus provide a method for assessing how much additive is actually on the filler surface. As described in the previous chapter, these techniques can also often give information concerning the way in which the additive has reacted with the filler surface. High quality equipment is relatively inexpensive and infra-red methods are well worth considering for quality control.
4.6.1.4 Adsorption Methods Various adsorption methods, including dye adsorption (see Section 4.6.2.3), can be used to determine the amount of uncoated surface remaining. This provides an indirect estimate of the amount of coated surface present.
159
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
4.6.2 The Monolayer and it’s Determination A number of relatively simple methods are used to find out what the apparent monolayer level is. The most common ones are described in the rest of this section.
4.6.2.1 Theoretical Calculation The amount of additive needed to cover unit area of surface has been determined experimentally, or calculated from molecular models, for many common additives. This enables the theoretical mono-layer amount to be calculated, if the specific surface area of the filler is known. As described previously, factors such as surface irregularity and additive orientation have to be taken into account. The reported coverage for a number of common surface modifiers is given in Table 4.2. As demonstrated by the data for the two vinyl silanes, the nature of the alcohol has a major effect on the covering power of these additives.
Table 4.2 Approximate surface coverage of some modifiers Modifier
Coverage (m2 of available surface, per gram of additive)
γ-Aminopropyltriethoxysilane
360
γ-Mercaptopropyl trimethoxysilane
350
Vinyltrimethoxysilane
525
Vinyltrimethoxyethoxy silane
280
γ-Methacryloxypropyltrimethoxysilane
315
Lauric acid (C12)
690 vertical
Stearic acid (C18)
420 vertical, 1,800 horizontal
Oleic acid (unsaturated C18)
940 vertical, 1,800 horizontal
4.6.2.2 Viscosity Reduction or Settling Volume of a Suspension of the Filler in a Simple Organic Liquid It is frequently observed that a minimum viscosity or settling volume is reached at about the mono-layer level.
160
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers
4.6.2.3 Dye Adsorption This is an old fashioned technique, cheap and easy to perform, and not given the attention it warrants in determining levels of geometric coverage. The principle is simple, and adapted from that used to determine surface area [4, 5]. A dye is used which strongly adsorbs on the uncoated filler surface, but not onto coated areas, and the level of adsorption relative to uncoated filler is then used to assess the amount of untreated surface. An example of the use of this method follows, and also shows the potential for combining ultrasonics with adsorption techniques in studies related to the use of coated fillers in composites. Dye adsorption curves for congo red (CI: 22120) on various precipitated calcium carbonates are presented in Figure 4.2. The carboxylated polybutadiene coated sample is seen to give a much lower dye adsorption than the uncoated filler, as would be expected. When subjected to an ultrasonic probe treatment, slurries of both the coated and uncoated fillers show a marked rise in dye adsorption. This is assumed to be due to break up of filler aggregates exposing fresh uncoated surface. Similar results were obtained with a stearate coated filler. Such generation of uncoated surface might also be expected when fillers of this type are subjected to high shear mixing processes.
Figure 4.2 Use of the dye adsorption technique to follow the effect of ultrasonic treatment on the amount of bare surface in both uncoated and coated precipitated calcium carbonates (congo red dye adsorbed from aqueous solution)
161
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites
4.6.2.4 Adsorption Isotherms Simple adsorption isotherm studies are widely used to assess the amount of coating that is needed to fully treat a filler surface. The isotherms may be determined by a number of techniques; for example following either the reduction in solution concentration (gravimetrically, spectroscopically, titrimetrically, etc.), or the build up on the filler after isolation and washing. Reversibility of adsorption may also be studied. The main use of the technique has been to assess the amount of coating needed for full coverage without necessarily understanding how the coating is adsorbed, whether it reacts with the surface, and what full coverage means. In some instances, the shape of the adsorption isotherm and reversibility studies can provide information concerning the degree of surface reaction as opposed to physical adsorption. Combination of adsorption studies with calorimetry can be more informative, as in the flow microcalorimeter methods discussed in the previous chapter. Typical isotherms for the adsorption of a carboxylated polybutadiene onto an aluminium and a magnesium hydroxide filler of similar surface areas are presented in Figure 4.3. The isotherms were determined by using infra-red to follow the decrease in solution
Figure 4.3 Adsorption isotherms for a carboxylated unsaturated polymer on to aluminium and magnesium hydroxides. Determined by the change in toluene solution concentration method and normalised to the specific surface area of the aluminium hydroxide (7 m2g-1)
162
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers concentration of the additive in the presence of filler. The isotherm for magnesium hydroxide is typical of very strong filler polymer interaction, with the filler initially removing virtually all of the polymer from solution. With aluminium hydroxide, the interaction appears less strong, but the equilibrium adsorption level is about twice that for magnesium hydroxide. When adsorption levels were determined gravimetrically, by recovering and washing the filler, then the value for the magnesium hydroxide was unchanged but that for aluminium hydroxide was reduced to a similar level, confirming that considerable reversible adsorption appeared to occur with this filler.
4.6.3 Effects of Processing on the Coating Structure Before leaving this section it is essential to remind the reader that, while studies on coated fillers give useful information, great caution must be taken when extrapolating to real coating layers in composites. Marked changes in these layers may well occur due to the processing conditions and the presence of polymer and other additives. Unfortunately ‘in situ’ characterisation of polymer/filler interfaces is still in its infancy. Some progress is currently being made in instrumental techniques and considerable advances can be expected in this area.
4.7 Surface Modifier Types 4.7.1 Monomeric Organic Acids and their Salts Acidic groups provide a convenient method for anchoring organic species to basic and amphoteric fillers, and have been widely studied for filler surface modification. Both non-coupling and coupling structures can be envisaged, depending on the organic group used. Saturated fatty acids are examples of non-coupling types, while unsaturated and amino-acids can be thought of as possible coupling types. Some comment on terminology is needed here, as it is particularly difficult and potentially misleading in this area. The treating agent is usually the free acid, but its bonding to the filler surface is thought to be through the formation of a partial salt, which is bound to the filler. The literature often refers to coatings as, for example, stearic acid or stearate, when it more properly means the product of the reaction of the acid with the filler surface. It would, on the other hand, be inappropriate, to simply refer to salt coatings, as this implies that the salt has been used to carry out the coating. This may be possible, but may also lead to weakly bound material with no partial salt link to the filler surface. To further complicate matters, the actual structure of the coating on the surface has frequently not been elucidated and could be a mixture of free acid, part salt and free salt. In the following discussions,
163
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites acid refers to the species used to produce the filler treatment, with the coating being the product of the reaction of this with the surface, whatever form this may take.
4.7.1.1 Saturated Fatty Acids Saturated fatty acids are the classic non-coupling additive, and are the workhorse surface treatment used on calcium carbonate and other basic fillers, with which the acid group can give strong surface interaction. This type of coating is easily applied, inexpensive and can give a range of useful effects, including easier processing and reduced water adsorption. Under favourable circumstances, dispersion can also be improved, but under other conditions, this may actually be made worse due to the decreased shear during compounding. The fatty acids most used consist mainly of straight, saturated, hydrocarbon chains 1618 carbon atoms long, and with even numbers of carbon atoms. (For reasons associated with their natural product origin, fatty acids with odd numbers of carbon atoms are rare, and there has been little or no study of their effects). The chain lengths used are too short to entangle with a polymer matrix. They also have no means of chemically reacting, and so coatings are generally weakly interacting, and produce low bond strengths between filler and matrix. This results in filler de-bonding at relatively low stress levels. The consequences of this are usually marked stress whitening and a decrease in ultimate strength, although there can sometimes be significant improvements in properties such as elongation and toughness. Indeed fatty acid coated calcium carbonate is widely used in polypropylene because of the excellent impact strength obtainable. While there has doubtless been a great deal of industrial study of the effect of hydrocarbon chain length and structure, there is very little useful work reported in the scientific literature. The work of Ivanishchenko and Gladkikh, referred to again later, indicated that maximum hydrophobicity is obtained at about 14 carbon atoms [6]. Similar results were obtained by Cave and Kinloch for straight chain hydrocarbon derivatives of alkoxysilanes [7]. There is good evidence that, at least on smooth surfaces, chain lengths of about 14 carbon atoms are needed if a tightly packed, crystalline, layer is to be obtained and this is probably important for hydrophobic effects. Liauw and co-workers have reported evidence for crystalline order in stearic acid coatings on magnesium hydroxide [8]. Haworth and Raymond [9] reported no differences in the processing behaviour and property improvements obtained in polypropylene homo-polymer filled with calcium carbonate, whether they used C10 or C22 fatty acid treatment at the mono-layer level. On the other hand, Haworth and Birchenough [10] reported significant differences related to chain length in the same range, when working with magnesium hydroxide in polypropylene. Strength and stiffness were found to increase, but toughness to decrease, with increasing chain length. The work of Tabtaing and Venables [11] discussed in the
164
Surface Modification and Surface Modifiers section on unsaturated acids, indicates that a chain length of C10 is sufficient to lead to significant improvements in ductility of a calcium carbonate/polypropylene composite, as determined by elongation and impact properties. They found no marked additional effect up to chain lengths of C20. Fatty acids are most economically derived from natural sources, where they occur as complex mixtures in both animal and vegetable matter. In practice, economics rules, and fatty acids with about 18 carbons are used, as they are the most readily available and of lowest cost. Some of the shorter chain acids also have extremely unpleasant odours, which is not desirable. Fortunately, it does seem that the C18 chain length is somewhere near the optimum in terms of building a stable, hydrophobic layer. Economics also dictates that blends of acids are normally used industrially, as separating out pure components can be quite costly. These blends can be very complex, containing a number of different chain lengths, and even small amounts of unsaturated chains and non-acid material. The composition of the fatty acids used in pre-coating fillers is rarely specified and can vary markedly, making accurate scientific comparisons very difficult. Fatty acids are usually pre-coated onto fillers and two methods of coating are generally used: wet coating and dry blending. In the wet coating process, a hot concentrated aqueous solution of a salt of the fatty acid is added to an aqueous slurry (usually also hot) of the filler. Under these conditions, rapid reaction with the surface of fillers such as calcium carbonate occurs. (Note, there is some evidence that precipitation may occur first). As mentioned earlier, this procedure can aid product isolation and handling. While sodium salts are often used for convenience, this can lead to undesirable levels of sodium in the final product, unless extensive washing is carried out. Ammonium salts are used to overcome this problem. In the dry coating procedure, filler and fatty acid are usually reacted together in a high shear mixer. The conditions have to be carefully selected and controlled if complete surface coverage and reaction is to be achieved. Most fatty acids are solids, and unless a solvent is used, they have to be melted before coating can take place. In some cases the mixer generates enough heat, but it is often necessary to supply external heating. It is also possible to coat from organic solutions of the fatty acid but, although sometimes used in laboratory work, this is usually too expensive for commercial use. It can also give false results, especially where the salt of the acid is soluble in the organic solvent. The chemistry of fatty acids is far more complex than might be imagined from this brief description, with features such as micellisation in aqueous solution and dimerisation in organic solvent being important factors likely to affect coating behaviour. Unfortunately these aspects have largely been overlooked in this context. For a
165
Particulate-Filled Polymer Composites comprehensive treatment of the propert