5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
1U
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
YRQ+*)UDQFLV
$WODQ
$XI7HUUDGHQ:...
5 downloads
327 Views
545KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
1U
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
YRQ+*)UDQFLV
$WODQ
$XI7HUUDGHQ:HOWHQGHV6RODUHQ,PSHULXPVXQGGHQ6WW]SXQNWHQGHU8QLWHG 6WDUV2UJDQLVDWLRQVFKUHLEWPDQ0LWWH0lU]GHV-DKUHVGDVYROOHU*HIDKUHQXQG hEHUUDVFKXQJHQLVW 6HLW GHP 9HUVFKZLQGHQ /RUGDGPLUDO $WODQV GHU EHL HLQHP $OOHLQJDQJ HQW IKUW ZXUGH XQG GHVVHQ 6SXU WURW] ILHEHUKDIWHU 6XFKH QRFK QLFKW HQWGHFNW ZHUGHQ NRQQWH VLQG IU YLHOH 0LWDUEHLWHU GHU 862 XQG GHU 6RODUHQ $EZHKU VFKZHUH :RFKHQ DQJHEURFKHQ 1HEHQGHUJDOD[LVZHLWHQ6XFKHQDFKGHPORUGDGPLUDOJHKWHVGHQ$JHQWHQXQG 6SH]LDOLVWHQ YRU DOOHP GDUXP GHU 8QEHNDQQWHQ KDEKDIW ]X ZHUGHQ GLH GHQ W|GOLFKHQ ³6XGGHQO\(IIHNW´ YHUXUVDFKHQ²HLQ 3KlQRPHQ GDV GLH SO|W]OLFKH $EODJHUXQJ ULHVLJHU SODQHWDULVFKHU7UPPHUPDVVHQDXIDQGHUHQ+LPPHOVN|USHUQEHZLUNW :DV GLH 8UKHEHU GHV 6XGGHQO\(IIHNWV IU HLQHQ =ZHFN YHUIROJHQ LVW GHQ 9HUDQWZRUWOLFKHQ GHU 862 EHUHLWV NODUJHZRUGHQ 'HQQRFK WDSSHQ VLH LP GXQNHOQ ZDV GHQ$XIHQWKDOWVRUWGHUP\VWHUL|VHQ8QEHNDQQWHQDQJHKW 1LFKW VR /RUGDGPLUDO $WODQW (U IOLHJW ]XU =HQWUDOH GHV *HJQHUV XQG GDV 6FKLII GDV LKQ XQG 1XUDP\ VHLQH 0LWJHIDQJHQH WUDQVSRUWLHUW ZLUG ]XP 5$806&+,)) '(5 $02./$8)(5 'LH+DXSWSHUVRQHQGHV5RPDQH
$WODQ²*HIDQJHQHUDQ%RUGGHU$192<
1XUDP\YRQ3RWULQHW²$WODQV0LWJHIDQJHQH
$OG\DQ.DSIDUXQG&LSSDURQ
6¶9DQJRU%UDGG².RPPDQGDQWGHV5DXPVFKLIIVGHU$PRNOlXIHU
&D0LQJRU²%HDXIWUDJWHUGHV³*UDXHQ´
'HU³*UDXH´²'HU'UDKW]LHKHUZLUGXQJHGXOGLJ
&LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
LFKKlWWHPHKU7HUUDQHUDQ%RUGµ .DSIODUVFKOXJPLWGHU¶)DXVWDXIGDV.RQWUROOERUG ³'LHVHU.HUO´VFKLPSIWHHU³,FKN|QQWHLKQXPEULQJHQ¶´ (UJDE
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
+DQGHOVIDKUHU*HOGPDFKHQN|QQHQ´ (UOlFKHOWHSO|W]OLFK ³(LQVRZLFKWLJHU0DQQZLH$WODQPWHXQVHLJHQWOLFKDOOHVEHVFKDIIHQN|QQHQ ZDVZLUEUDXFKHQZHQQHUQXUZLOO´
&D0LQJRUJULIIVLFKDQV+HU] 3O|W]OLFK ZDU GHU ]LHKHQGH 6FKPHU] LP OLQNHQ $UP XQG LQ GHU %UXVW GD 9RU VHLQHQ $XJHQ IOLPPHUWH HV 9ROOHU $QJVW NUDOOWH HU VHLQH +lQGH LQ GLH /HKQH VHLQHV 6HVVHOV (U KlWWH VFKUHLHQ P|JHQ DEHU HU WDW HV QLFKW ZHLO HU VLFK LQVWLQNWLY GDYRU VFKHXWH6¶9DQJRU%UDGGDXIPHUNVDP]XPDFKHQ (U NRQQWH GHQ .RPPDQGDQWHQ QLFKW VHKHQ 'LH 5FNHQOHKQH VHLQHV .RQWXUVHVVHOVYHUEDUJLKQYRUVHLQHQ%OLFNHQ(UZDUIURKGDUEHUGHQQVRNRQQWHDXFK GHU7HIURGHULKQQLFKWEHREDFKWHQ 0LQJRU NlPSIWH PLW VHLQHU )XUFKW XQG PLW VHLQHU 6HOEVWEHKHUUVFKXQJ 'LHV ZDU QLFKW GHU HUVWH $QIDOO ,Q GHQ OHW]WHQ 7DJHQ KDWWHQ VLFK GLH XQDQJHQHKPHQ $Q]HLFKHQ HLQHU EHJLQQHQGHQ $QJLQD SHFWRULV PHKUIDFK HLQJHVWHOOW (U KRIIWH GD DXFK MHW]W ZLHGHUDOOHVVFKQHOOYRUEHLJHKHQZUGHEHYRUMHPDQGDXIPHUNVDPZXUGH /DQJVDPHUKROWHHUVLFK ,Q GHU +DXSW]HQWUDOH OLHI DOOHV QRUPDO DE 'HU .RPPDQGDQW GUHKWH VLFK LKP ]X (UVFKLHQHLQZHQLJEODVVHUDXV]XVHKHQDOVVRQVWDEHUGDVNRQQWHWlXVFKHQ &D 0LQJRU HUKRE VLFK 6HLQH .QLH ]LWWHUWHQ 0KVDP VFKOHSSWH HU VLFK ELV ]XP $XVJDQJVVFKRWW 'RUW EOLHEHU VWHKHQ XQG EOLFNWH ]XUFN (LQLJH 0lQQHU KDQWLHUWHQHLQ ZHQLJ QHUY|VHU DOV VRQVW DQ LKUHQ *HUlWHQ $XI HLQLJHQ 6FKDOWWDIHOQ EUDQQWHQ :DUQOLFKWHUGRFKMHW]WHUORVFKHQVLHQDFKXQGQDFK 2IIHQVLFKWOLFK ZDU GRFK QLFKW DOOHV VR QRUPDO ZLH HU JODXEWH 0LQJRU IKOWH VLFK MHGRFK ]X VFKZDFK XP GHQ 'LQJHQ VRIRUW DXI GHQ *UXQG ]X JHKHQ (U YHUOLH GLH =HQWUDOHXQGVFKZHEWHLQHLQHP$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWELVLQVPHGL]LQLVFKH=HQWUXPKLQDE +DWWD2¶+DUZDUVHKUEHUUDVFKWDOVHUVLFKEHLLKPPHOGHWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³6LH0LQJRU"´VDJWHHU³,FKGHQNH6LHZHUGHQQLHPDOVNUDQN"¶ 'HU 7HUUDQHU OlFKHOWH YHUOHJHQ -HW]W HUVFKLHQ HV LKP JDU QLFKW PHKU VR YHUQQIWLJ ]XP $U]W ]X JHKHQ (U ZQVFKWH HU KlWWH GHQ (QWVFKOX QLFKW VR VFKQHOO JHIDW ³'DV KDEH LFK HLQPDO JHVDJW´ HQWJHJQHWH HU ³$QVFKHLQHQG LVW PHLQH 3XPSH DEHUGRFKQLFKWVR]XYHUOlVVLJZLHLFKLPPHUJHJODXEWKDEH´ 'HU $U]W GHXWHWH DXI HLQHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJVWLVFKXQG EDW 0LQJRU VLFKKLQ]XOHJHQ 'DQQXQWHUVXFKWHHULKQXQGPDFKWHHLQ%HODVWXQJV(.* ³:LH]XHUZDUWHQ´VDJWHHUVFKOLHOLFK³6LHVLQGYROONRPPHQJHVXQG%HL,KQHQ VLQG NHLQH GHJHQHUDWLYHQ 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ IHVW]XVWHOOHQ 'HU =ZLVFKHQIDOO KDW IXQNWLRQHOOH8UVDFKHQ¶ ³0HLQH1HUYHQVLQGYROONRPPHQLQ2UGQXQJ´EHKDXSWHWHGHU7HUUDQHU ³6LHVLQGQLFKWGHUHUVWHKHXWHGHUGDVJODXEW´ 0LQJRUZXUGHDXIPHUNVDP ³:LH VROO LFK GDV YHUVWHKHQ" 6LQG PHKUHUH %HVDW]XQJVPLWJOLHGHU PLW lKQOLFKHQ %HVFKZHUGHQEHL,KQHQJHZHVHQ" 'HUWHIURGLVFKH$U]WQLFNWH ³,FK KDEH HLQLJH VFKZHUH )lOOH JHKDEW PLW 6WHQRVHQ GLH QXU PHGLNDPHQW|V ]X O|VHQZDUHQ'DEHLODJHQLQNHLQHPHLQ]LJHQ)DOORUJDQLVFKH*UQGHYRU &D0LQJRU]QGHWHVLFKHLQH=LJDUHWWHDQ ³'DVLVWHLQK|FKVWVHOWVDPHU=XIDOO´VDJWHHUJHGHKQW +DWWD2¶+DUQLFNWH ³0LUIlOOWHVVFKZHUGDUDQ]XJODXEHQGDDOOHVPLWUHFKWHQ'LQJHQ]XJHJDQJHQ LVW´HUNOlUWHHU³6RHWZDVLVWPLUQRFKQLHPDOV]XYRUEHJHJQHW´ ³,FKIUDJHPLFKQXUZLHHUGDVJHPDFKWKDW´ 'HU$U]WEOLFNWHEHUUDVFKWDXI ³(U"´IUDJWHHU³:HQPHLQHQ6LH"´ ³,FK GHQNH DQ XQVHUHQ *HIDQJHQHQ (U KDW XQV VFKRQ 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ JHQXJ JHPDFKW ,KP ZlUH RKQH ZHLWHUHV ]X]XWUDXHQ GD HU HV PLW *LIW YHUVXFKW :lUH GHQNEDUGDHUDXIGLHVH:HLVHVROFKH=ZLVFKHQIlOOHHUUHLFKHQNDQQ"´ ³'XUFKDXV´HUZLGHUWHGHU7HIURGHU³(VJLEWPHKUHUHH[RWLVFKH*LIWHPLWGHQHQ VRHWZDVEHZHUNVWHOOLJWZHUGHQNDQQ &D0LQJRUHUKREVLFK ³,FK ZHUGH GLH $QJHOHJHQKHLW EHUSUIHQ´ NQGLJWH HU DQ ³:HKH GHP $UNRQLGHQZHQQHUHVWDWVlFKOLFKJHWDQKDW´
³0LU JHKW HV QLFKW EHVRQGHUV JXW´ VDJWH 1XUDP\ YRQ 3RWULQHW ³,FK ZHUGH PLFK HLQZHQLJKLQOHJHQ´ /RUGDGPLUDO $WODQ PDFKWH HLQH XQEHVWLPPWH *HVWH 'LH $NRQLQ JLQJ LQ GHQ 1HEHQUDXP9LHOOHLFKWKDWWHVLHPHKUYRQLKPHUZDUWHWDEHU$WODQZDUQLFKWJHQHLJWDXI VLHHLQ]XJHKHQ=XKlXILJKDWWHVLHLKPLQGHUOHW]WHQ=HLW6FKZLHULJNHLWHQJHPDFKW(U IUDJWH VLFK ZDQQ VLH HV HQGOLFK IHUWLJEULQJHQ ZUGH LKUHQ WLHIYHUZXU]HOWHQ +DJHJHQ LKQ ]X EHUZLQGHQ GHU LKU YRQ GHQ 6SH]LDOLVWHQ GHV DNRQLVFKHQ (QHUJLHNRPPDQGRV HLQJHSIODQ]WZRUGHQZDU:HQQVLHHVVFKDIIWHVLFK]XEHIUHLHQNRQQWHVLHLKUHU/LHEH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
]XLKPQDFKJHEHQ 1DFKGHQ=ZLVFKHQIlOOHQGHUOHW]WHQ=HLWNRQQWHVLHQLFKWPHKUHUZDUWHQGDHU LKURKQH$UJZRKQJHJHQEHUWUDW$EHUQXUVRNRQQWHHULKU]ZHLIHOORVKHOIHQ (U O|VWH VLFK YRQ GHP *HGDQNHQ DQ VLH XQG ZDQGWH VLFK ZLHGHU VHLQHP HLJHQWOLFKHQ3UREOHP]X6HLWHLQLJHQ7DJHQUDVWHGLHVHV5DXPVFKLIIGXUFKGLH*DOD[LV 1DFKWUlJOLFK HLQJHEDXWH WHFKQLVFKH 1HXHUXQJHQ XQG HLQ /LQHDUDQWULHE EHIlKLJWHQ GLHVHVHKHPDOVDUNRQLGLVFKH6FKLII]XKRKHU*HVFKZLQGLJNHLW(UZXWHQLFKWZRKHUHV NDP XQG ZRKLQ GLH 5HLVH IKUWH 6HLW :RFKHQ KDWWH HU QLFKW GHQ JHULQJVWHQ $QKDOWVSXQNW EHU VHLQH 3RVLWLRQ LQQHUKDOE GHU 0LOFKVWUDH EHNRPPHQ N|QQHQ )U ZXWH QRFK QLFKW HLQPDO RE VLH VLFK DXI GHU (DVWVLGH RGHU GHU :HVWVLGH GHU *DOD[LV EHIDQGHQ 6HLQH 2G\VVHHIKUWHGXUFKGDV1LFKWV´XQGGLH=HLWYHUVWULFK RKQHGD HU HWZDV WXQ NRQQWH 'DEHL VWDQGHQ GLH 9|ONHU GHU *DOD[LV YRU UlWVHOKDIWHQ (UVFKHLQXQJHQ GLH ZDKOORV DOOH3ODQHWHQ XQG 6RQQHQ JHIlKUGHWHQ %LVKHU ZDU HV LKP JHOXQJHQ YHUVFKLHGHQH (LQ]HOKHLWHQ ]X GLHVHP 3UREOHPNUHLV KHUDXV]XILQGHQ (U VSUWHGDHU]DKOUHLFKH)lGHQLQGHQ+lQGHQKLHOWGLHHUQXU]XYHUNQSIHQEUDXFKWH XPYLHOOHLFKWVFKRQHLQNODUHUHV%LOGGHV*DQ]HQ]XEHNRPPHQ(UZXWHMHGRFKQLFKW ZLHHUGLH.QRWHQ]XVHW]HQKDWWH 'LH )KUXQJ XQG GLH %HVDW]XQJ GHU $192< ZDUHQ HLQGHXWLJ LQ GHQ )DOO YHUZLFNHOW =XPLQGHVW GLH 2IIL]LHUH XQG &D 0LQJRU ZXWHQ ZDV JHVSLHOW ZXUGH DEHU DXVLKQHQKDWWHHUELVKHUQLFKWVKHUDXVEHNRPPHQN|QQHQ $Q %RUG EHIDQG VLFK HLQ JHKHLPQLVYROOHV *HIl (V JOLFK HLQHP .HJHO XQG ZDU XQWHU JURHQ 9RUVLFKWVPDQDKPHQ LQV 6FKLII JHEUDFKW ZRUGHQ ,PPHU ZLHGHU KDWWH HU VLFKJHIUDJWZDVLQGLHVHPNHJHOI|UPLJHQ %HKlOWHUHQWKDOWHQVHLQNRQQWH(U]ZHLIHOWH QLFKW GDUDQ GD GHU ,QKDOW YRQ DXHURUGHQWOLFKHU %HGHXWXQJ ZDU 'DV ZDU HLJHQWOLFK GDV HLQ]LJH ZDV PLW DEVROXWHU 6LFKHUKHLW IHVWVWDQG *HUDGH GHVKDOE JUEHOWH HU VHLW 7DJHQGDUEHUQDFKZLHHUKHUDXVILQGHQNRQQWHZDVGLH$192<XQWHUVRUlWVHOKDIWHQ 8PVWlQGHQWUDQVSRUWLHUWH 9HUVFKLHGHQWOLFK KDWWH HU YHUVXFKW PLW GHP HLQHQ RGHU DQGHUHQ 2IIL]LHU LQV *HVSUlFK ]X NRPPHQ DEHUPDQDQWZRUWHWH LKPQLFKW PHKU 1LHPDQGVSUDFK PLW LKP 0LQJRU XQG DXFK GHU WHIURGLVFKH .RPPDQGDQW 6¶9DQJRU%UDGG EHKDQGHOWHQ LKQ ZLH /XIW (UNRQQWHVLFKYRUVWHOOHQGDVFKDUIH$QZHLVXQJHQDQGLH%HVDW]XQJHUJDQJHQ ZDUHQ PLW GHQHQ PDQ YHUKLQGHUQ ZROOWH GD HU LUJHQGZR +LOIH IDQG 6HLQH /DJH HUVFKLHQ DXVVLFKWVORV XQG HV VDK JDQ] VR DXV DOV PWH HU ZDUWHQ ELV VLH GDV =LHO HUUHLFKWKDWWHQ'DQQDEHUNRQQWHHVHQGJOWLJ]XVSlWVHLQ 8QUXKLJOLHIHULQGHU.DELQHDXIXQGDE 2KQH8QWHUVWW]XQJYRQDXHQZUGHHUQLFKWZHLWHUNRPPHQ'DVVWDQGIULKQ IHVW 'LH 5lXPH LQ GHQHQ PDQ 1XUDP\ XQG LKQ JHIDQJHQKLHOW ZXUGHQ YRQ .DPSIURERWHUQXQGPHKUHUHQ7HIURGHUQEHZDFKW+LQVLFKWOLFKGHUODVFKHQ'LV]LSOLQZDU HLQLJHVJHVFKHKHQ-HW]WJOLFKGLH$192<HLQHPPLOLWlULVFKVWUDIIJHIKUWHQ6FKLIIXQG GDPLWZDUHQVHLQH&KDQFHQDXIGHQ1XOOSXQNWJHVXQNHQ 6HLQH +RIIQXQJHQ GD GHU UlWVHOKDIWH .HJHO EHL HLQHP $QJULII EHVFKlGLJW ZRUGHQ VHLQ N|QQWH KDWWHQ VLFK QLFKW HUIOOW 'HU 7DNRWD 7DNRWDN KDWWH YHUVXFKW GDV *HIl ]X YHUSLFKWHQ DEHU HU KDWWH GLH 6FKXW]VFKLUPH QLFKW GXUFKVFKODJHQ N|QQHQ LQ GLHHVHLQJHKOOWZDU :HOFKH0|JOLFKNHLWHQEOLHEHQMHW]WQRFK"
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
(UZXWHHVQLFKW (U EOLFNWH DXI DOV GLH 7U VLFK |IIQHWH (LQ 2IIL]LHU WUDW HLQ XQG EUDFKWH IULVFKH :lVFKH GLH VLFK QRFK LQ GHU 9HUVLHJHOXQJ EHIDQG 6LH VWDPPWH DOVR GLUHNW DXV GHP $XWRPDWHQ$WODQQDKPVLHHQWJHJHQXQGZDUIVLHDXIGHQ7LVFK$OVHUDOOHLQZDUJLQJ HULQV%DGXQGGXVFKWHVLFK'DQDFKOHJWHHUGLHQHXH:lVFKHDQ(UYHUOHW]WHVLFKDQ HLQHPZLQ]LJHQ'RUQbUJHUOLFKVDXJWHHUGDVKHUDXVTXHOOHQGH%OXWYRQVHLQHP)LQJHU DE 'DQQVWXW]WHHU 1RUPDOHUZHLVH GXUIWH VLFK QLFKWV LQ GHP ZHLFKHQ 0DWHULDO EHILQGHQ ZDV GHUDUWLJH =ZLVFKHQIlOOH YHUXUVDFKHQ NRQQWH (U XQWHUVXFKWH GLH 6HQGXQJ QRFK HLQPDO JHQDX XQG IDQG HLQH IODFKH 6FKDFKWHO GLH HWZD HLQHQ =HQWLPHWHU ODQJ HLQHQ KDOEHQ EUHLW XQG ]ZHL 0LOOLPHWHU KRFK ZDU 'HU 'HFNHO OLH VLFK YHUVFKLHEHQ 'DUXQWHU VDK HU GLH ZLQ]LJHQ .ULVWDOOH HLQHV $XI]HLFKQXQJVJHUlWHV (V VFKDOWHWH VLFK VHOEVWlWLJ HLQ 5DVFKKLHOWHUHVDQV2KU(UK|UWHHLQHGXQNOHNUlIWLJH6WLPPH ³ ZLU EHUHLW ,KQHQ ]XU )OXFKW ]X YHUKHOIHQ :LU ZLVVHQ GD 6LH HLQ YHUP|JHQGHU 0DQQ´ PLW VHKU JURHQ 0|J OLFKNHLWHQ VLQG (QWVSUHFKHQG VLQG XQVHUH )RUGHUXQJHQ*HEHQ6LHXQVHLQ=HLFKHQRE6LHLQWHUHVVLHUWVLQG5XIHQ6LHJHQDXXP 8KU &D 0LQJRU ]X VLFK XQG EHVFKZHUHQ 6LH VLFK EHU GDV (VVHQ 'DQQ ZLVVHQ ZLU%HVFKHLG:HUIHQ6LHGDV*HUlWMHW]WVRIRUWLQGHQ'HVLQWHJUDWRUVFKDFKW´ $WODQ JHKRUFKWH ZHLO HU YHUPXWHWH GD GHU 0DJQHWNULVWDOO HLQHQ 6HOEVW]HUVW|UXQJVPHFKDQLVPXV HQWKLHOW GHU VLFK HLQVFKDOWHWH ZHQQ GLH $XI]HLFKQXQJDEJHIDKUHQZDU (UUHJXQJHUIDWHLKQ (QGOLFK WDW VLFK HWZDV $XI HLQ GHUDUWLJHV $QJHERW KDWWH HU JHZDUWHW REZRKO HU NDXP]XKRIIHQJHZDJWKDWWHGDVLFKMHPDQGJHJHQ&D0LQJRUXQGYRUDOOHPJHJHQ GHQ JHKHLPQLVYROOHQ ³*UDXHQ VWHOOHQ ZUGH :HQQ GLH 8QEHNDQQWHQ HLQH )OXFKWP|JOLFKNHLW DQNQGLJWHQ GDQQ NRQQWHQ VLH GDPLW QXU HLQH EHYRUVWHKHQGH /DQGXQJ DXI HLQHP 3ODQHWHQ PHLQHQ RGHU DEHU VLH GDFKWHQ DQ HLQHV GHU ]DKOUHLFKHQ UDXPWFKWLJHQ%HLERRWHGLHVLFKLQGHQ+DQJDUVGHU$192<EHIDQGHQ $WODQVHOEVWKDWWHVLFKVFKRQODQJHPLWGHUDUWLJHQ2EHUOHJXQJHQEHIDW%LVMHW]W KDWWH HU MHGRFK NHLQH 0|JOLFKNHLW JHVHKHQ HLQHV GHU NOHLQHQ 5DXPVFKLIIH DOOHLQ ]X IOLHJHQ 6HOEVW PLW +LOIH 1XUDP\V NRQQWH HU QLFKW GXUFK HLQH GHU 6FKOHXVHQ HLQIDFK GDYRQUDVHQ6RUJIlOWLJH9RUEHUHLWXQJHQJHK|UWHQ]XHLQHUVROFKHQ$NWLRQ%HYRUHUVLFK DXIHLQHQ%OLW]VWDUWPLWHLQHP%HLERRWHLQOLHPXWHHUZLVVHQEHUZHOFKHQ$QWULHEHV YHUIJWH:HQQHVQLFKWGLHQRWZHQGLJHQ9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQPLWEUDFKWHGDQQEUDXFKWHQ VLHHVJDUQLFKWHUVW]XYHUVXFKHQPLWVRHLQHP.OHLQUDXPVFKLII]XHQWNRPPHQ%HYRU VLHHLQH DXVUHLFKHQG KRKH *HVFKZLQGLJNHLW HUUHLFKW KDWWHQ ZUGHQGLH*HVFKW]H GHU $192<GLH)OXFKWEHHQGHQ $Q HUVWHU 6WHOOH PXWH DOVR GLH ,QIRUPDWLRQ VWHKHQ 'DQDFK PXWH HLQ $EOHQNXQJVPDQ|YHU HLQJHOHLWHW ZHUGHQ GDV LKQHQ LP HQWVFKHLGHQGHQ 0RPHQW HLQLJH 0LQXWHQ9RUVSUXQJYHUVFKDIIWH $WODQOlFKHOWH 'LH%RWVFKDIWOLHHUNHQQHQGDZHQLJVWHQV]ZHL0lQQHUHLQ*HVFKlIWPLWLKP PDFKHQZROOWHQ0LWLKQHQXQGGHU$NRQLQ]XVDPPHQNRQQWHHUHVVFKDIIHQ (UNOHLGHWHVLFKYROOHQGVDQXQGNORSIWHGDQQDQGLH7U]X1XUDP\.DELQH6LH DQWZRUWHWHQLFKW
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
$WODQNORSIWH VWlUNHU ZHLO HUGDFKWH GD VLHIU HLQH NXU]H :HLOH HLQJHVFKODIHQ VHLQN|QQWH$XFKMHW]WVFKZLHJVLH(UZXUGHXQUXKLJXQGOHJWHVHLQHQ.RSIDQGLH7U 'DV0lGFKHQJDENHLQHQ/DXWYRQVLFK 'HU$UNRQLGH|IIQHWH 'LH$NRQLQODJDXIGHP)XERGHQXQGZlO]WHVLFKZLHLQ.UlPSIHQ,KUH$XJHQ TXROOHQZHLWDXVGHQ+|KOHQ6LHSUHWHGLH+lQGHDXIGHQ/HLE ³1XUDP\´ULHIHU 6LH]XFNWH]XVDPPHQVWUHFNWHVLFKXQGVW|KQWH'DQQVFKODQJVLHGLH$UPHXP GLH%HLQHGLHVLHKRFKDQGLH%UXVW]RJXQGZLPPHUWHOHLVH (U NQLHWH QHEHQ LKU QLHGHU XQG GUHKWH VLH DXI GHQ 5FNHQ KHUXP 0LW EHLGHQ +lQGHQ KLHOW HU LKUH $UPH GLH VLH LKP ZLOG ]X HQWUHLHQ YHUVXFKWH 6LH EL LKP LQ GLH +DQGVRGDHUVLH]XUFNVWLHXQGGDUDXIYHU]LFKWHWHVLHDQ]XIDVVHQ ³1XUDP\":DVLVWGHQQ"´IUDJWHHUEHWURIIHQ 6LHWDWDOVKDEHVLHVHLQH:RUWHQLFKWJHK|UW %HIUHPGHWHUKREHUVLFKHLOWHGDQQ]XP$XVJDQJVVFKRWWXQGGUFNWHGHQ.QRSI %LVKHU KDWWH VLFK GLH :DFKH VWHWV VFKQHOO JHPHOGHW MHW]W DEHU HUVFKLHQ QLHPDQG (U VFKDOWHWH GHQ 7HOHNRP HLQ HU]LHOWH DEHU DXFK KLHU NHLQHQ (UIROJ 1LHPDQG UHDJLHUWH -HW]W WUDW HU PLW GHP )X JHJHQ GDV 6FKRWW ZHLO HU KRIIWH GXUFK GHQ /lUP $XIPHUNVDPNHLW]XHUUHJHQDEHUDXFKGLHVPDOZXUGHHUHQWWlXVFKW (VVFKLHQDOVREHUSO|W]OLFKPLWGHU$NRQLQDOOHLQLQGHP6FKLIIZDU $OVGLH$192<GHQ/LQHDUUDXPYHUOLHJHVFKDKHV &D0LQJRUIKOWHHLQHQ6FKODJ,QVHLQHP.RSIVFKLHQVLFKHWZDVLQGLH 1HUYHQHQGHQ]XYHUNUDOOHQ(USUHWHGLH+lQGHDQGLH6FKOlIHQXQGNlPSIWHJHJHQ GDV)UHPGHLQLKPDQ6HLQ$WHPJLQJVFKZHUXQGHUEUOOWH 'LH.DELQHYHUVFKZDPPYRUVHLQHQ$XJHQ,KPVFKLHQDOVVHLHULQHLQHQ $QWLJUDYVFKDFKWJHVWLHJHQLQGHPHVNHLQWUDJHQGHV(QHUJLHIHOGJDE8QZLGHUVWHKOLFKH .UlIWHULVVHQLKQLQGLH7LHIH:LHEHVHVVHQVFKOXJHUXPVLFKQXUYRQGHPHLQHQ :XQVFKEHVHHOWLUJHQGZR+DOW]XILQGHQ/DQJVDPVFKZDQGHQLKPGLH6LQQH $OVHUZLHGHU]XVLFKNDPKDWWHHUGDV*HIKOVFKZHUHORVLQHLQHPQHEHOKDIWHQ 1LFKWV]XVFKZHEHQLQGHPHVNHLQHQ2ULHQWLHUXQJVSXQNWIULKQJDE(UVWYLHOVSlWHU NOlUWHQVLFKVHLQH6LQQH(UNRQQWHQLFKWVDJHQZLHYLHO=HLWYHUJDQJHQZDU ,UJHQGZDQQNRQQWHHUDXIVWHKHQ 7RUNHOQGJLQJHU]XP(UIULVFKXQJVDXWRPDWHQXQG]DSIWHVLFKHLQDXISXWVFKHQGHV *HWUlQNDE*LHULJWUDQNHUZlKUHQGHUGDV*HIKOKDWWHGDVHLQH/LSSHQYRU 7URFNHQKHLW]HUVSULQJHQPXWHQ'DQDFKOLHHUVLFKHUVFK|SIWLQHLQHQ6HVVHOVLQNHQ %OLFNORVVWDUUWHHUDXIVHLQH+lQGHGLHVFKODIIDXIVHLQHQ2EHUVFKHQNHOQODJHQ6LH ZDUHQEOXWLJXQG]HUVFKUDPPW (UKREGHQ.RSIXQGEOLFNWHVLFKLQVHLQHU.DELQHXP (LQ,UUVLQQLJHUPXWHKLHUJHWREWKDEHQ(VJDENDXPQRFKHLQHQ *HEUDXFKVJHJHQVWDQGGHUQLFKW]HUVFKODJHQZRUGHQZDU (QWVHW]WVW|KQWHHUDXIDOVHUEHJULIIZDVHUJHWDQKDWWH%LV]XGLHVHP =HLWSXQNWZDUHUGDYRQEHU]HXJWJHZHVHQGDHUKLOIORVDXIGHP%RGHQJHOHJHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
KDWWH-HW]WZXWHHUZLHVHKUHUVLFKLUUWH ,UJHQGHWZDVKDWWHLKQLQHLQHQ$PRNOlXIHUYHUZDQGHOW $WODQ" (UHUKREVLFKXQGKROWHVLFKHUQHXWHWZDV]XWULQNHQ'DQQOHKQWHHUVLFK NRSIVFKWWHOQGDQGLH:DQGQHEHQGHP$XWRPDWHQ 1HLQ²GHU$UNRQLGHPRFKWHYLHOYHUVXFKHQVLFKDXVVHLQHU/DJH]XEHIUHLHQ 9LHOOHLFKWZDUHVLKPWDWVlFKOLFKJHOXQJHQLUJHQGHLQH[RWLVFKHV*LIWHLQ]XVHW]HQDEHU GDPLWNRQQWHHUQXUHLQHYRUEHUJHKHQGH:LUNXQJHU]LHOWKDEHQ,Q]ZLVFKHQZXUGHHU VFKlUIHUDOV]XYRUEHUZDFKW,QVHLQHU.DELQHNRQQWHHU]ZDUWXQXQGODVVHQZDVHU ZROOWHRKQHGDEHLEHREDFKWHW]XZHUGHQ:HQQHUDEHUGLHJHVDPWH%HVDW]XQJGHU $192<YHUJLIWHQZROOWHGDQQPXWHHUVFKRQDXVVHLQHP9HUOLHVKHUDXVNRPPHQXQG GDVZDULKPXQP|JOLFKJHPDFKWZRUGHQ 0LQJRUOlFKHOWH ³0DQVROOGHQ5HVSHNWYRUGLHVHP%XUVFKHQDXFKQLFKWEHUWUHLEHQ´VDJWHHU ZlKUHQGHULQGLH6DQLWlUNDELQHJLQJ(UHQWNOHLGHWHXQGGXVFKWHVLFK'DQDFKVWHFNWH HUVHLQH+lQGHLQGHQ3IOHJHDXWRPDWHQGHUYRP]HQWUDOHQ0HGRFRPSXWHUPLWGHQ QRWZHQGLJHQ0HGLNDPHQWHQEHVFKLFNWZXUGH'HU7HUUDQHUEUDXFKWHNDXPHLQHKDOEH 0LQXWH]XZDUWHQELVVHLQH+lQGHPLWHLQHPWUDQVSDUHQWHQhEHU]XJYHUVHKHQZRUGHQ ZDUHQXQWHUGHPGLH:XQGHQEDOGDEKHLOHQZUGHQ $EVLFKWOLFKEOLHEHULQVHLQHQ5lXPHQ(UZROOWHGHQ.RPPDQGDQWHQDXIJDU NHLQHQ)DOODXIVHLQH9HUOHW]XQJHQDXIPHUNVDPPDFKHQ1DFKGHPHUVLFKGDYRQ EHU]HXJWKDWWHGD6¶9DQJRU%UDGGVHLQHP*HVLFKWQLFKWVDQVHKHQNRQQWHVFKDOWHWH HUGHQ7HOHNRPHLQXQGVWHOOWHHLQH9HUELQGXQJPLWGHU+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOHKHU $XIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNVDKHUGDGLH7HIURGHUVLFKQLFKWDQGHUVYHUKDOWHQKDWWHQ DOVHU'HU2IIL]LHUGHUVLFKPHOGHWHKDWWHYHUTXROOHQH$XJHQXQGEOXWHWHDXVGHU 1DVH ³+DEHQ6LHGLH'LHQVW]HLWGD]XPLEUDXFKWSULYDWH0HLQXQJVYHUVFKLHGHQKHLWHQ ]XNOlUHQ"´IUDJWH0LQJRULURQLVFK 'HU7HIURGHUZLVFKWHVLFKPLWGHP+DQGUFNHQEHUGHQ0XQG ³.HLQHVZHJV´HUZLGHUWHHUPLWHLQHU6WLPPHGLHGHXWOLFKHQbUJHUEHUGLH)UDJH HUNHQQHQOLH³$OVZLUDXVGHP/LQHDUUDXPLQGXQ1RUPDOUDXP]XUFNNHKUWHQEHUILHO HVXQVDOOHKLHULQGHU=HQWUDOHKDWHLQH0DVVHQVFKOlJHUHLVWDWWJHIXQGHQ:LUN|QQWHQ (LQH]HUVFKUDPPWH0lQQHUIDXVWVFKRELKQ]XU6HLWH'DQQHUVFKLHQGDV UDPSRQLHUWH*HVLFKWYRQ6¶9DQJRU%UDGGLP%LOG (UVWDUUWH&D0LQJRUPLW]RUQLJIXQNHOQGHQ$XJHQDQ ³.|QQWHQ6LHPLUYLHOOHLFKWHUNOlUHQZDUXP6LHEHUKDXSWIUDJHQ":LHLFKELV MHW]WKHUDXVJHIXQGHQKDEHJLEWHVQLHPDQGHQDQ%RUGGHUQLFKWIUHLQLJH0LQXWHQ HWZDVY|OOLJ,GLRWLVFKHVJHWDXKDW$OOHZXUGHQLUJHQGZLHJHZDOWWlWLJ:DUXPVLQG6LH ´ 'HU7HUUDQHUVDKHLQGDHVVLQQORVZDUGHQ.RPPDQGDQWHQQRFKPHKU]X UHL]HQ'VWHUOlFKHOQGKREHUVHLQH+lQGH 'HU7HIURGHUZHLWHWHHUVWYHUEOIIWGLH$XJHQGDQQEHJDQQHUDEZHFKVHOQG]X IOXFKHQXQG]XODFKHQ ³6LHODVVHQDEHUDXFKNHLQHQ7ULFNDXV0LQJRU´VDJWHHU³'HU*UDXHZlUH EHVWLPPW]XIULHGHQHUPLWXQVEHLGHQZHQQZLUEHVVHU]XVDPPHQDUEHLWHWHQ´ 0LQJRUQLFNWH$XFKVHLQH0LHQHHQWVSDQQWHVLFK
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³'DVVROOWHQZLUMHW]WZLUNOLFKWXQ´VWLPPWHHU]X³,FKHUZDUWH6LHKLHU´ ³,FKNRPPH´ 'HU7HUUDQHUXQWHUEUDFKGLH9HUELQGXQJ(UVHW]WHVLFKLQHLQHQ6HVVHOGUFNWH HLQHQ.QRSIDQGHU/HKQHXQGOHJWHGLH%HLQHGDQQDXIGDVXQVLFKWEDUH$QWLJUDYIHOG GDVYRULKPDXIJHEDXWZXUGH,QGLHVHUEHTXHPHQ+DOWXQJGDFKWHHUQDFK =XPHUVWHQPDOILHOLKPDXIGDGLHUlWVHOKDIWHQ9HUlQGHUXQJHQHLQJHWUHWHQ ZDUHQDOVGLH$192<YRP/LQHDUUDXPµLQGDV(LQVWHLQ.RQWLQXXP]XUFNJHIDOOHQZDU *HQDX]XGLHVHPµ/HLWSXQNWKDWWHHVMHZHLOVEHJRQQHQ(UUXFNWHKRFKXQGZlKOWH HUQHXWGLH=HQWUDOH6HNXQGHQVSlWHUZXWHHUGDGLH$192<VLFKEHUHLWVZLHGHULP /LQHDUUDXPEHIDQGXQGPLWYLHOIDFKHUhEHUOLFKWJHVFKZLQGLJNHLWGXUFKGLH*DOD[LVUDVWH 'LHVH(QWGHFNXQJZDU]ZDUDOV,QIRUPDWLRQVHKUZLFKWLJEUDFKWHLKQMHGRFKDXFK QLFKWZHLWHU :DUXPWUDWHQGLH9HUlQGHUXQJHQLPPHUQXULP1RUPDOUDXPDXI" -HW]WZDUHUQRFKPHKUDOV]XYRUGDYRQEHU]HXJWGD$WODQPLWGHQ (UHLJQLVVHQQLFKWV]XWXQKDEHQNRQQWHGHQQELVMHW]WKDWWHHUQRFKQLHHWZDVYRQ HLQHP*LIWJHK|UWGDVQXULP1RUPDOUDXPQLFKWDEHULP/LQHDUUDXPZLUNWH $OOHVGHXWHWHGDUDXIKLQGDHVDQ%RUGGHV6FKLIIHVHWZDVJDEZDVHVYRUGHU /DQGXQJDXI)RUPDUQRFKQLFKWJHJHEHQKDWWH:DUHVZlKUHQGLKUHV$XIHQWKDOWVDXI GLHVHP3ODQHWHQLQGHQ5DXPHUJHNRPPHQ",UJHQGMHPDQGNRQQWHHVHLQJHVFKOHSSW KDEHQ 'LH$UWZLHHVGLH0HQVFKHQYHUlQGHUWHOLH0LQJRUVRIRUWDQHLQSDUDSV\FKLVFK EHJDEWHV:HVHQGHQNHQHUVWGDQDFKILHOLKPHLQGDHVQRFKHWZDVLQGHU$192< JDEZDVYLHOOHLFKW(LQIOXDXIVLHQHKPHQNRQQWH'LHVH0|JOLFKNHLWHUVFKLHQLKP MHGRFKVHKUXQZDKUVFKHLQOLFK (UVFKREVLHHEHQIDOOV]XU6HLWH $OVGHU7HOHNRPEOLQNWHJODXEWHHUGHU.RPPDQGDQWZROOHVLFKZLHGHU DEPHOGHQ'HVKDOEZDUHUVHKUEHUUDVFKWDOVHULQGDV*HVLFKW$WODQVEOLFNWH'HQ $UNRQLGHQKDWWHHUY|OOLJYHUJHVVHQ8PVRLQWHUHVVLHUWHUPXVWHUWHHULKQMHW]W ³:DVJLEWHV"´IUDJWHHUXQZLUVFK 'HU*HIDQJHQHYHU]RJGHQ0XQG ³$QXQGIUVLFKLVWHVQLFKWPHLQH$UWPLFKEHU.OHLQLJNHLWHQ]XEHNODJHQDEHU ZDV6LHXQVMHW]W]XPXWHQJHKWGDQQGRFKHLQZHQLJ]XZHLW´ ³:DVLVWORV"5HGHQ6LHVFKRQ,FKKDEHZHQLJ=HLW´ ³6LHVROOWHQHLQPDO]XPLUNRPPHQXQGVLFKGDVDQVHKHQZDVZRKODOV 9HUSIOHJXQJIUXQVJHGDFKWLVW(VLVWXQJHQLHEDU ³6FKRQJXW,FKZHUGHPLFKGDUXPNPPHUQ´YHUVSUDFK0LQJRUXQGVFKDOWHWH DXV'HU.RPPDQGDQWWUDWHLQ(UZDQGWHVLFKLKP]XDEHUVHLQH*HGDQNHQYHUZHLOWHQ LPPHUQRFKEHLGHP$UNRQLGHQ ³:DVLVWORVPLW,KQHQ"´IUDJWH6¶9DQJRU%UDGG ³1LFKWV´HQWJHJQHWHGHU7HUUDQHU³0LUZLOOQXUQLFKWLQGHQ.RSIGDHLQ0DQQ ZLH$WODQVLFKEHUGDV(VVHQEHVFKZHUW'DVSDWQLFKW]XLKP9HUPXWOLFKZLOOHU HWZDVJDQ]DQGHUHV,FKZHUGHHVKHUDXVILQGHQ´ (UERWGHP7HIURGHU3ODW]DQ'DEHLEHWUDFKWHWHHULKQYHUVWRKOHQ'HU .RPPDQGDQWERWHLQHQJHUDGH]XMlPPHUOLFKHQ$QEOLFN0LQJRUYHUPXWHWHGDDOOH 2IIL]LHUHEHULKQKHUJHIDOOHQZDUHQXPLKUH:XWDQLKPDXV]XODVVHQ (UJULQVWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³:HQQZLUKHLODQV=LHONRPPHQZROOHQPVVHQZLUXQVHWZDVHLQIDOOHQODVVHQ´ VDJWHHU
³5HGHQZLURIIHQPLWHLQDQGHU´VFKOXJ&D0LQJRUYRU³:DVZROOHQ6LHZLUNOLFK¶"´ ³%HZHJXQJVIUHLKHLW´DQWZRUWHWH$WODQNQDSS 'LH0LHQHGHV7HUUDQHUVYHUVFKORVLFK ³:R]X"´IUDJWHHU³6LHKDEHQKLHUDOOHQ.RPIRUWGHQ6LHVLFKZQVFKHQN|QQHQ XQG 6LH VLQG DQ GDV 8QWHUKDOWXQJVSURJUDPP GHU $192< DQJHVFKORVVHQ :DV DOVR ZROOHQ6LHQRFK"´ ³,FK VDJWH HV VFKRQ´ HUZLGHUWH GHU $UNRQLGH ³2GHU IUFKWHQ 6LH HWZD LFK DOV HLQ]HOQHU0DQQN|QQHDQ%RUGHWZDVJHJHQ6LHXQG,KUH%HVDW]XQJDXVULFKWHQ"´ 0LQJRUOlFKHOWHXQPHUNOLFK ³,P *UXQGH LVW HV HJDO RE 6LH VLFK IUHL EHZHJHQ N|QQHQ RGHU QLFKW 'DV 6FKLII N|QQHQ6LHVRRGHUVRQLFKWYHUODVVHQ$OVRJXWLFKELQHLQYHUVWDQGHQ6LHNRQQHXVLFK XQJHKLQGHUWXPVHKHQZHQQHV,KQHQ6SDPDFKW'DHVHLQHQYHUERWHQHQ%H]LUNDQ %RUG JLEW ZLVVHQ 6LH MD EHUHLWV (U EOHLEW JHVSHUUW (LQ 5RERWHU ZLUG 6LH VWlQGLJ EHJOHLWHQ 9HUVXFKHQ 6LH DOVR JDU QLFKW HUVW HWZDV JHJHQ XQV ]X XQWHUQHKPHQ :LU ZUGHQVRIRUWLQIRUPLHUWZHUGHQ´ $WODQQLFNWH (UJDEVLFKJHODVVHQXQGWDWDOVKDEHVLFKQLFKWVIULKQYHUlQGHUW7DWVlFKOLFK KDWWH VLFK VHLQH 6LWXDWLRQ VFKODJDUWLJ YHUEHVVHUW 0LQJRU UHFKQHWH QLFKW GDPLW GD HU +HOIHUILQGHQN|QQWHGLHLKQEHLVHLQHU)OXFKWXQWHUVWW]HQNRQQWHQ6RODQJHHULQGHQ .DELQHQ EOLHE NRQQWH HU VLFK QLFKW PLW LKQHQ YHUVWlQGLJHQ 3O|W]OLFK ZDUHQ VHLQH &KDQFHQ HUKHEOLFK JU|HU JHZRUGHQ -HW]W JDOW HV QXU QRFK GDV 3UREOHP GDV VLFK GXUFK GHQ 5RERWHU VWHOOWH ]X EHUZLQGHQ $WODQ YHUPXWHWH GD GHU $XWRPDW DOOHV SHU )XQN HLQHU ]HQWUDOHQ hEHUZDFKXQJVVWHOOH EHUPLWWHOWH ZDV HU ZDKUQDKP $XI GLHVH :HLVHNRQQWH0LQJRUVLFKEHUMHGHQ6FKULWWGHQHUWDWLQIRUPLHUHQ (V NDP QXU DXI GHQ 0DQQ DQ GHU GLH $XI]HLFKQXQJHQ NRQWUROOLHUWH XQG DXVZHUWHWH*HK|UWHHU]XVHLQHQXQEHNDQQWHQ+HOIHUQGDQQKDWWHHUVFKRQVRJXWZLH JHZRQQHQ:DUGDVQLFKWGHU)DOOPXWHHUQDFKHLQHUYHUWUHWEDUHQ/|VXQJVXFKHQ
$OG\DQ .DSIODU XQG &LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
GUHLPDOEHGLHQWZRUGHQZDU 6HLQH +lQGH EHJDQQHQ ]X ]LWWHUQ DOV HU PHUNWH GD $WODQ RGHU GLH $NRQLQ JHQDX]XGHU=HLWHWZDV]XWULQNHQDQJHIRUGHUWKDWWHQDOVHUXQG
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
6FKULWWHUVWHLQPDOJHVFKDIIWKDEHQLVWDOOHVQLFKWPHKUVRVFKOLPP´ &LSSDURQ
$WODQGUHKWHVLFKEHWRQWODQJVDPXPXQGPXVWHUWHGHQ5RERWHU ³,VW GDV ZLUNOLFK QRWZHQGLJ¶"´ IUDJWH HU XQG GHXWHWH DXI GHQ :DIIHQDUP GHU 0DVFKLQH GHU DXI LKQ JHULFKWHW ZDU 'DV 3URMHNWLRQVIHOG OHXFKWHWH ]ZDU QLFKW GDV EHGHXWHWH MHGRFK QLFKW GD GHU $XWRPDW DQJUHLIEDU ZDU (U NRQQWH LQ %UXFKWHLOHQ YRQ 6HNXQGHQ IHXHUQ IDOOV HU GHQ %HIHKO GD]X HUKLHOW RGHU DXI *UXQG VHLQHU 3URJUDPPLHUXQJ ]X GHP 6FKOX NDP GD GLHV QRWZHQGLJ ZDU (U NRQQWH VFKQHOOHU KDQGHOQDOVHLQPHQVFKOLFKHU$QJUHLIHULKQDXVVFKDOWHQNRQQWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³1XUVRGUIHQ6LH,KUH.DELQHYHUODVVHQRGHUEHUKDXSWQLFKW´DQWZRUWHWHGHU :lFKWHU ³1DJXW´VDJWHGHU$UNRQLGH³'DVLVWLPPHUQRFKEHVVHUDOVLQGLHVHQ5lXPHQ ]XHUVWLFNHQ´ (U GHXWHWH PLW GHU +DQG DXI GLH 7U GXUFK GLH HU HEHQ JHJDQJHQ ZDU 1XUDP\ HQWIHUQWH VLFK EHUHLWV YRQ LKQHQ DEHU DQ GHU (FNH GHV *DQJHV EOLHE VLH VWHKHQ 6LH ZXWH VHKU ZRKO ZHOFKH 5HDNWLRQHQ VLH PLW HLQHU XQEHGDFKWHQ +DQGOXQJ EHL GHP 5RERWHUKHUYRUUXIHQNRQQWH6LHZDUWHWHELVGHU/RUGDGPLUDOEHLLKUZDU ³:LU JHKHQ QDFK REHQ´ HUNOlUWH $WODQ ³,FK P|FKWH &D 0LQJRU LQ GHU =HQWUDOH EHVXFKHQ:DVKlOWVWGXGDYRQ"´ ³,FK KRIIWH GX ZUGHVW PLU HLQHQ URPDQWLVFKHQ 6SD]LHUJDQJ LQ GHQ K\GURSRQLVFKHQ*lUWHQDQELHWHQ´HUZLGHUWHVLHVS|WWLVFK ³'RUW IHKOW PLU GDV 0RQGOLFKW /LHEOLQJ´ HQWJHJQHWH HU LQ GHP JOHLFKHQ 7RQIDOO 6LH EL VLFK DXI GLH /LSSHQ XQG EHVFKOHXQLJWH LKUH 6FKULWWH (UVW DP $QWLJUDYVFKDFKW EOLHE VLH ZLHGHU VWHKHQ ELV $WODQ XQG GHU 5RERWHU VLH HUUHLFKW KDWWHQ =XVDPPHQ PLW LKQHQVFKZHEWHVLHQDFKREHQ 'HU$UNRQLGHVFKZLHJ (U ZDU IURK GD HU HWZDV PHKU %HZHJXQJVIUHLKHLW JHZRQQHQ KDWWH 0LQJRU ZUGH GLH .DELQHQ LQ GLHVHQ 0LQXWHQ IUDJORV VHKU VRUJIlOWLJ XQWHUVXFKHQ (U PXWH KHUDXVILQGHQ RE VHLQH *HIDQJHQHQ QLFKW GRFK DQ HLQLJHQ VHKU PHUNZUGLJHQ 9RUJlQJHQDQ%RUGVFKXOGZDUHQ $WODQ KDWWH VLFK DXV GHQ VSlUOLFKHQ ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ GLH HU HUKDOWHQ KDWWH LQ]ZLVFKHQ EHUHLWV HLQ %LOG JHPDFKW (U KDWWH 1XUDP\ EHREDFKWHW XQG GLH 5HDNWLRQHQ LP6FKLIIYHUIROJW'DUDXVNRQQWHHUVHLQH6FKOVVH]LHKHQ 'DV6SLHOEHJDQQLQWHUHVVDQW]XZHUGHQ (LQ8QEHNDQQWHUKDWWHLKPHLQ)OXFKWDQJHERWJHPDFKW:DUHVHKUOLFKJHPHLQW" $XI MHGHQ )DOO UHFKQHWH HLQ 0DQQ ZLH 0LQJRU GDPLW (U ODJ VWlQGLJ DXI GHU /DXHU ,KQ JDOWHV]XEHUOLVWHQ (LQH GULWWH .UDIW ZLUNWH DXV GHP 'XQNHO KHUDXV :HGHU HU QRFK 0LQJRU NDQQWHQ VLH ,PPHU ZLHGHU PXWH $WODQ DQ GDV NHJHOI|UPLJH *HIl GHQNHQ GDV PLW GHP 6FKLII WUDQVSRUWLHUW ZXUGH :DV YHUEDUJ VLFK LQ LKP" (LQH QHXH :DIIH RGHU HLQH JHIlKUOLFKVWUDKOHQGH0DWHULH" (U ZDU IHVW HQWVFKORVVHQ GDV 5lWVHO ]X O|VHQ 'DIU ZDU HU VRJDU EHUHLW VHLQH )OXFKWSOlQH ]XUFN]XVWHOOHQ (U IKOWH ZLH XQJHKHXHU ZLFKWLJ HV ZDU GDV *HKHLPQLV GLHVHV5DXPVFKLIIV]XHQWVFKOHLHUQ 1XUDP\EHI|UGHUWHLKQPLWVDQIWHU*HZDOWDXVGHP6FKDFKW ³:R ELVW GX PLW GHLQHQ *HGDQNHQ"´ IUDJWH VLH $XI PHLQH )UDJHQ DQWZRUWHVW GX QLFKWXQGZRGLH+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOHLVWVFKHLQVWGXDXFKYHUJHVVHQ]XKDEHQ ³2IIHQVLFKWOLFK¶HQWJHJQHWHHUXQGJLQJYRULKUKHU :DVZDULQGHP%HKlOWHU" .DPGHU$QJULIIDXIGLHSV\FKLVFKH.ODUKHLWXQGGLHJHLVWLJH6HOEVWNRQWUROOHYRQ GRUW" (VNRQQWHHLJHQWOLFKNDXPDQGHUVVHLQ =XPHUVWHQPDOGDFKWH$WODQDQ3VL0DWHULH 'LH$NRQLQVWLHLKQDQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³'X VWHKVW YRU GHP 6FKRWW ]XU =HQWUDOH´ VDJWH VLH ³:LOOVW GX KLHU :XU]HOQ VFKODJHQ"´ ³.HLQHVZHJV 1XUDP\´ DQWZRUWHWH HU OlFKHOQG ³,FK EHUOHJWH QXU RE HV QLFKW GRFK LUJHQGZR LP 6FKLII HLQ 3OlW]FKHQ JLEW GDV JHQJHQG 5RPDQWLN IU GHLQ +HU] ELHWHW´ ³0LUZLUGVFKOHFKW´ (U ODFKWH XQG EHWUDW GLH +DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOH &D 0LQJRU EOLFNWH LKP PLW OHLFKW YHUHQJWHQ$XJHQHQWJHJHQ(UVWDQGQHEHQHLQHU,QIRUPDWLRQVVlXOH$WODQJLQJDQLKP YRUEHL(UGHXWHWHEHUVHLQH6FKXOWHU]XUFNDXIGHQ5RERWHU ³0DFKHQ 6LH ELWWH NHLQH XQEHGDFKWHQ %HZHJXQJHQ RGHU %HPHUNXQJHQ GLH PHLQHQ %HJOHLWHU UHL]HQ N|QQWHQ´ VDJWH HU PLW XQEHUK|UEDUHU ,URQLH ³0DQ VDJWH PLU GDHUVHKUVFKQHOO]XU:DIIHJUHLIH 9RUGHPJURHQ3DQRUDPDELOGVFKLUPEOLHEHUVWHKHQ'LH$192<EHZHJWHVLFK PLW KRKHU *HVFKZLQGLJNHLW GXUFK GHQ /LQHDUUDXP ,KUH 3RVLWLRQ ZDU IU $WODQ QLFKW HUNHQQEDU (U KDWWH DXFK QLFKW GDPLW JHUHFKQHW GD PDQ LKP HLQH *HOHJHQKHLW JHEHQ ZUGHVLHKHUDXV]XILQGHQ'DUDXINDPHVLKPLQHUVWHU/LQLHMHW]WDXFKQLFKWDQ)ULKQ ZDUHVZLFKWLJDXVGHU5ROOHGHV8QWHUOHJHQHQKHUDXV]XNRPPHQ(UPXWH&D0LQJRU ]XHLQHP3V\FKRGXHOO]ZLQJHQLQGHPHU%O|HQDXIGHFNHQNRQQWH /DQJVDPGUHKWHHUVLFKXPXQGEOLFNWHGHQ7HUUDQHUDQ,KPILHOVRIRUWDXIGD GHU .RPPDQGDQW VFKUlJ KLQWHU 0LQJRU VWDQG XQG GD HU LKQ PLW ZDFKHQ $XJHQ EHREDFKWHWH 'LH 9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQ ZDUHQ JHJHEHQ 'DV 6SLHO NRQQWH EHJLQQHQ )U $WODQ VWDQG IHVW GD HV HUVW HQGHQ NRQQWH ZHQQ HU ZXWH ZDV LQ GHP NHJHOI|UPLJHQ %HKlOWHUWUDQVSRUWLHUWZXUGH²RGHUZHQQHUGHQ.HJHOLQVHLQH*HZDOWJHEUDFKWKDWWH
&LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³)DEHOKDIW(U]lKOHZHLWHU´ ³:LU PVVHQ QXU GDIU VRUJHQ GD ZLU XQJHVW|UW PLW GHP $UNRQLGHQ VSUHFKHQ N|QQHQ 'DIU PX +DV .DWDU YRP %HREDFKWXQJVSXOW YHUVFKZLQGHQ $P EHVWHQ ZlUH HVZHQQGXVHLQHQ3RVWHQEHUQHKPHQN|QQWHVW´ ³,FKJODXEHGD0LQJRUPLFKHLQVHW]HQZUGHZHQQ.DWDUHWZDVDQGHUHV]XWXQ KlWWH/HLGHUZHLLFKQLFKWZLHLFKLKQYRQVHLQHP3RVWHQYHUWUHLEHQNDQQ´ ³'DIUZLUG$OG\DQ.DSIODUVRUJHQ¶YHUVSUDFKGHU,QJHQLHXU³:LFKWLJLVWQXUGD ZLUXQVGDQQDXIGLFKYHUODVVHQN|QQHQ´ (U EHULFKWHWH ZDV HU XQG .DSIODU SODQWHQ 3HUUD $OND HUNOlUWH VLFK EHUHLW PLW]XPDFKHQXQGVLFKGHU)OXFKWDQ]XVFKOLHHQ
$OG\DQ .DSIODU KDWWH DOOH +lQGH YROO ]X WXQ (U ZDU IURK GD GHU 9LHUWH 3URMHNWLRQVIHOG,QJHQLHXUEDOG]XUFNNHKUWH ³6LHK GLU GDV DQ´ VDJWH HU XQG ZLHV DXI GLH .RQWUROOWDIHOQ GLH GUHL :lQGH GHV JURHQ$UEHLWVUDXPVEHGHFNWHQ³'LH6FKlGHQGLHYRQGHUDPRNODXIHQGHQ0DQQVFKDIW DQJHULFKWHW ZRUGHQ VLQG ]HLJHQ VLFK HUVW MHW]W hEHUDOO VLQG )HKOVFKDOWXQJHQ YRUJHQRPPHQZRUGHQ,QPDQFKHQ%HUHLFKHQZXUGHQJURH7HLOHXQVHUHU$XVUVWXQJ EOLQGZWLJ ]HUVW|UW ,FK PXWH VRJDU GLH 6SHUUEH]LUNH XP GHQ .HJHO YHUNOHLQHUQ ZHLO MHPDQG PLW VHLQHP6WUDKOHU XP VLFK JHVFKRVVHQ XQG GDEHL HLQHQ (QHUJLHIHOGSURMHNWRU ]HUVW|UWKDW0HKUHUH$QWLJUDYVFKlFKWHVLQGDXVJHIDOOHQ(LQLJH.RQYHUWHUDUEHLWHQQLFKW PHKU :HQQ GDV VR ZHLWHUJHKW ZHUGHQ ZLU ]X GHP ZDV ZLU YRUKDEHQ NDXP QRFK NRPPHQ´ ³'XPDFKVW:LW]H´¶HQWJHJQHWH&LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
KHUDXV 6LH JLQJHQ ]XP 6FKDFKW XQG YHUVFKZDQGHQ GDULQ .DSIODU VFKDOWHWH HLQHQ DQGHUHQ %LOGVFKLUP XP :HQLJ VSlWHU NRQQWHQ VLH GLH EHLGHQ *HIDQJHQHQ PLW LKUHP :lFKWHU:LHGHUVHKHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
(UVDKDXIVHLQ&KURQRPHWHUXQGNUDXVWHGLH6WLUQ ³6ROOWHHUQLFKWUHFKW]HLWLJ]XUFNVHLQ3HUUDGDQQEHUQHKPHQ6LHVHLQHQ 3RVWHQELVHUVLFKZLHGHUPHOGHW´ 3HUUD$ONDQLFNWHEHVWlWLJHQG0LQJRUJDELKP]XYHUVWHKHQGDHUVLFKMHW]W ]XUFN]LHKHQPXWH'LH=HLWOLHIDE(VEOLHEHQQXUQRFKZHQLJH6HNXQGHQELV]XGHP 0RPHQWLQGHPVLHDOOHZLHGHUGLH.RQWUROOHEHUVLFKVHOEVWYHUOLHUHQZUGHQ'HU )XQNRIIL]LHUK|UWHGHQ7HUUDQHUIOXFKHQ (UOlFKHOWHXQPHUNOLFK 6FKQHOOJLQJHU]XPHOHNWURQLVFKHQ%HREDFKWXQJVVWDQGGHUELVGDKLQYRQ+DV .DWDUEHUZDFKWZRUGHQZDU(UZXWHGDGHUYHUKDWH9HUWUDXWH0LQJRUVQLFKWPHKU OHEWHGHQQHUKDWWHEHREDFKWHWGDHLQ$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWIUHLQLJH6HNXQGHQ DXVJHIDOOHQZDU (UVHW]WHVLFKYRUGLH%HREDFKWXQJVJHUlWH$XIGHQ%LOGVFKLUPHQN|QQWHHU$WODQ XQGGLH$NRQLQVHKHQ'DV0lGFKHQOlFKHOWHZHLFK(UVFKLHQVLHJHUDGHLQHLQHP $XJHQEOLFNEHUUDVFKW]XKDEHQLQGHPVLHEHUHLQ7KHPDVSUDFKHQGDV0LQJRU EHVWLPPWQLFKWVDQJLQJ 3HUUDEOLFNWHVLFKYRUVLFKWLJXP1LHPDQGDFKWHWHDXILKQ (UGUFNWHHLQH7DVWH ,PJOHLFKHQ0RPHQWVFKDOWHWHQVLFKDOOH*HUlWHDXV'HU5RERWHUHUVWDUUWH 6HLQH%HREDFKWXQJVLQVWUXPHQWHOHLWHWHQQLFKWVPHKU]XU)XQN]HQWUDOHZHLWHU ³:DVLVWGHQQPLWGHP5RERWHUORVIUDJWH1XUDP\EHUUDVFKW3HUUD]XFNWH ]XVDPPHQDOVMHPDQGLKPGLH+DQGDXIGLH6FKXOWHUOHJWH(UKDWWHQLFKWJHPHUNWGD MHPDQGDQLKQKHUDQJHWUHWHQZDU 'HU$WHPVWRFNWHLKPXQGVHLQ+HU]EHJDQQUDVHQGVFKQHOO]XVFKODJHQ,UJHQG HWZDVVFKQUWHLKPGLH.HKOH]X(UZXWHJHQDXZDVHV]XEHGHXWHQKDWWHEHLHLQHP GHUDUWLJHQ9HUUDWEHUUDVFKW]XZHUGHQ0LQJRUKHUUVFKWHPLWEUXWDOHU+DQG $ONDGUHKWHGHQ.RSIODQJVDPKHUXPXQGEOLFNWHKRFK ³'LUVFKHLQWGHU6FKUHFNJDQ]KEVFKLQGLH*OLHGHUJHIDKUHQ]XVHLQ´VDJWH (LNHQRXNHGHU+\SHUIXQNLQJHQLHXU $ONDHUKREVLFK ³$FKGXELVWHV´VDJWHHUHUOHLFKWHUW)RUVFKHQGVDKHUVHLQ*HJHQEHUDQ 'LHVHUVFKPXQ]HOWHXQGQLFNWHLKP]X ³1XU0XW3HUUD'XZLOOVWPLUGRFKHWZDVVDJHQRGHU¶"´ ³1DWUOLFK(LNHQRXNH'XNDQQVWGLUZRKOVFKRQGHQNHQZDVGDV]XEHGHXWHQ KDW"´(UGHXWHWHPLWGHP'DXPHQDXIGDV%HREDFKWXQJVSXOW ³,KUKDEWHQGOLFKHLQH0|JOLFKNHLWJHIXQGHQ"´ ³-D0LW$WODQV+LOIHZHUGHQZLUYHUVFKZLQGHQ8QGGXNRPPVWPLW´ ³1LFKWQXULFKDXFK$VFKDQHLQJXWHU)UHXQGYRQPLU(ULVWDEVROXW]XYHUOlVVLJ´ 'HU)XQNRIIL]LHUHUVFKUDN'HU3ODQNRQQWHQXU(UIROJKDEHQZHQQGHU.UHLVGHU %HWHLOLJWHQVRNOHLQZLHP|JOLFKEOLHE'DVZROOWHHUGHP,QJHQLHXUHUNOlUHQDOVGLH $192<LQGDV1RUPDO.RQWLQXXPEHUZHFKVHOWH'LHEHLGHQ0lQQHUYHUORUHQGLH .RQWUROOHEHUVLFK9RQHLQHU6HNXQGH]XUDQGHUHQYHUZDQGHOWHQVLHVLFKLQWREHQGH .DPSIHU ³:DVLVWGHQQPLWGHP5RERWHUORV"IUDJWH1XUDP\EHUUDVFKW6LHGHXWHWHDXI GHQ$XWRPDWHQGHUVLHJHUDGHDXIJHIRUGHUWKDWWHQLFKWPLWHLQDQGHU]XIOVWHUQ $WODQGUHKWHVLFKXP
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
(UVDKGDGLH8EHUZDFKXQJVPDVFKLQHHLQH+DOWXQJHLQJHQRPPHQKDWWHGLH LQVWDELODXVVDK(VVFKLHQDOVVHLHUPLWWHQLQGHU%HZHJXQJDXVJHVFKDOWHWZRUGHQ 'HU$UNRQLGHVWXW]WH:DUGDVHLQH)DOOH" 'DVZlUHZHQLJVLQQYROODQWZRUWHWHVHLQ([WUDKLUQVRIRUW 0LQJRUPXWHGRFKHLQHEHVWLPPWH$EVLFKWYHUIROJHQZHQQHUGHQ5RERWHU GHVDNWLYLHUWH 1LFKWVGHXWHWGDUDXIKLQGDGHU7HUUDQHUHVJHWDQKDWHUNOlUWHGDV([WUDKLUQ 'DVZDUULFKWLJ $WODQJLQJHLQHQZHLWHUHQ6FKULWWDXIGHQ$XWRPDWHQ]XDOVHUHLQHQOHLFKWHQ 'UXFNLQGHU0DJHQJHJHQGIKOWH,KPZXUGHHLQZHQLJEHODEHUGDVJDEVLFKVRIRUW ZLHGHU'HU9RUIDOONRQQWHQXUEHGHXWHQGDGLH$192<LQGHQ1RUPDOUDXP ]XUFNJHNHKUWZDU(UEHUOHJWHGDHU1XUDP\QLFKWXQEHREDFKWHWODVVHQGXUIWHGRFK HVZDUEHUHLWV]XVSlW 'LH$NRQLQVSUDQJLKQYRQKLQWHQDQ,KUH+DQGNDQWHQVFKOXJHQDXIVHLQH 6FKXOWHUQKHUDE,QVWLQNWLYKDWWHHUVHLQHQ+DOVPLWHLOLJKRFKJHULVVHQHQ+lQGHQLP OHW]WHQ0RPHQWJHVFKW]W'HQQRFKEUDFKHUKDOEZHJVEHWlXEWLQGLH.QLH(UOLHVLFK ]XU6HLWHIDOOHQ :LHHLQEODXHU6FKDWWHQVFKR1XUDP\EHULKQKLQZHJ,KUH)lXVWHYHUIHKOWHQ LKQQXUJDQ]NQDSS$WODQYHUVXFKWHHLQ%HLQKRFK]XUHLHQXQGVLHDXVGHP *OHLFKJHZLFKW]XEULQJHQDEHUVLHUROOWHVLFKEHUGLH6FKXOWHUZHJXQGVSUDQJZLHGHU DXIGLH)H:lKUHQGHUQRFKJHJHQGLH6FKPHU]HQLQVHLQHQ6FKXOWHUQDQNlPSIWH ZDUIVLHVLFKHUQHXWDXILKQ 6LHZDUHLQHKHUYRUUDJHQGJHVFKXOWH.lPSIHULQGLHLQGHQ7UDLQLQJVODJHUQGHV DNRQLVFKHQ(QHUJLHNRPPDQGRVDOOH7ULFNVJHOHUQWKDWWHPLWGHQHQPDQRKQH:DIIHQ HLQHQ*HJQHUDXVVFKDOWHQNRQQWH6LHZDULKPPLQGHVWHQVJOHLFKZHUWLJ 'LH+lQGHN|QQHQW|GOLFKH,QVWUXPHQWHVHLQZHQQVLHULFKWLJHLQJHVHW]WZHUGHQ 'DV0lGFKHQZXWHVHKUJHQDXZLHVLHVLHJHEUDXFKHQPXWH $WODQHQWJLQJLKUHP$QJULIIQLFKWJDQ]:LHGHUXPWUDIVLHLKQDQGHU6FKXOWHU *HSHLQLJWVFKULHHUDXI 6LHEHZHJWHVLFKUDVHQGVFKQHOO6LHWREWH1LFKWVEUHPVWHLKUH$JUHVVLYLWlW'LH XQEHNDQQWH0DFKWGLHVLHEHHLQIOXWH]ZDQJVLHLKUH.UlIWHKHPPXQJVORV]X HQWIDOWHQ'LH$NRQLQDEHUVXFKWHGHQWRWDOHQ(LQVDW],KUHXQJHVWPH:LOGKHLWPDFKWH VLHGRSSHOWJHIlKUOLFK $WODQ]ZHLIHOWHQLFKWGDUDQGDVLHLKQW|WHQZROOWH-HGHU*ULIIGHQVLHDQVHW]WH XQGMHGHU6FKODJOLHHQGDVHLQGHXWLJHUNHQQHQ 6LHZXWHQLFKWZDVVLHWDW6LHZDUQLFKWPHKUVLHVHOEVW .HXFKHQGUROOWHVLHEHUGHQ%RGHQ8QHUZDUWHWJHODQJHVLKULKUHQ$UPXP VHLQHQ+DOV]XOHJHQ6LHHUNDQQWHLKUH&KDQFHXQGGUFNWHPLWYROOHU*HZDOW]X$WODQ PHUNWHVRIRUWGDLKPQXUQRFK6HNXQGHQEOLHEHQVLFKDXVGLHVHU8PNODPPHUXQJ]X EHIUHLHQ'DQDFKZUGHHV]XVSlWVHLQ'HU6DXHUVWRIIPDQJHOPXWHVLFKVHKUVFKQHOO VSUEDUPDFKHQ (UULFKWHWHVLFKDXIXQG]RJGDV0lGFKHQEHUVHLQH6FKXOWHUQKLQZHJXPGHQ 5LQJXPVHLQHQ+DOVVR]XVSUHQJHQ'RFK1XUDP\OLHQLFKWORV,KUH0XVNHOQ VSDQQWHQVLFKQRFKXQGSDFNWHQLKQQRFKIHVWHU-HGHUDQGHUH.DPSIHUKlWWHLKQLP OHW]WHQ$XJHQEOLFNIUHLJHJHEHQXPVLFKEHLGLHVHPhEHUVFKODJQLFKWVHOEVWGLH .QRFKHQ]XEUHFKHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
'LH$NRQLQJDEQLFKWQDFK$WODQPXWHGHUhEHUVFKODJEHZHJXQJIROJHQZHQQ HUVLFKQLFKWGDV*HQLFNEUHFKHQZROOWH*H]LHOWUDPPWHHULKUGLH(OOHQERJHQLQGLH 6HLWHQGRFKVLHZLFKHOHJDQW]XUFNXQGQDKPGHQ6FKOlJHQGDPLWGLHJU|WH:XFKW 'DV7HPSRGHV.DPSIHVVWHLJHUWHVLFK]XPOHW]WHQPDO'LH$NRQLQXQGGHU 8QVWHUEOLFKHZlO]WHQXQGUROOWHQVLFKGXUFKGLH.DELQHELVHUHQGOLFKLKUH)LQJHU HUZLVFKWH(UULVLHDXVHLQDQGHU²XQGMHW]WVFKULHGDV0lGFKHQJHOOHQGDXI6LH NRQQWHLKQQLFKWPHKUKDOWHQ 0LWHLQHPZHLWHQ6DW]VSUDQJHUYRQLKUZHJVWU]WHXQGGUHKWHVLFKVRIRUW ZLHGHUKHUXPGDPLWVLHLKQQLFKWDEHUPDOVEHUUDVFKHQNRQQWH (UPXWHDOV6LHJHUDXVGLHVHP'XHOOKHUYRUJHKHQ-HW]WKDWWHHUHLQHHLQPDOLJH &KDQFHGLH.DELQHQ]XYHUODVVHQXQGVLFKLQGHU$192<XP]XVHKHQ'HU5RERWHU ZDUGHVDNWLYLHUWZRUGHQ6REDOGGDV6FKLIIGLHQlFKVWH/LQHDUHWDSSHDQWUDWZUGHHU VHLQH%HREDFKWXQJVDXIJDEHZLHGHUDXIQHKPHQ'DQQZDUHV]XVSlW $XFKGUDXHQZUGHQLHPDQGVHLQHZDKUHQ$EVLFKWHQHUNHQQHQ9LHOOHLFKW ZUGHPDQLKQDWWDFNLHUHQ'DVZROOWHHULQ.DXIQHKPHQZHQQHUGDEHLQXUPHKUEHU GDV6FKLIIXQGVHLQHJHKHLPQLVYROOH)UDFKWKHUDXVILQGHQNRQQWHDOVELVKHU 1XUDP\UDIIWHVLFKQRFKHLQPDODXI 9ROOHU+DVWDUUWHVLHLKQDQZlKUHQGVLHDXIGHP%RGHQNDXHUWHXQGQDFK $WHPUDQJ6LHYHUVXFKWHQLFKWLKQ]XWlXVFKHQ'D]XZDUVLHQLFKWLQGHU/DJH,UJHQG HWZDV]ZDQJVLHLKQDQ]XJUHLIHQRKQHVLFKGDEHLLQLKUH.DPSIPHWKRGH HLQ]XPLVFKHQ'DV8QEHNDQQWHJDEQXUGHQ$JJUHVVLRQVLPSXOVXQGEHUOLHHVLKU GDPLWIHUWLJ]XZHUGHQ :LHGHUERWGLH$NRQLQDOOH.UlIWHDXI $XVGHU+RFNHKHUDXVVFKQHOOWHVLHVLFKDXIGHQ$UNRQLGHQ,KUH)LQJHUVWDFKHQ QDFKVHLQHQ$XJHQ,KU+DHQWOXGVLFKLQHLQHPXQPHQVFKOLFKHQ6FKUHL 9LHOOHLFKWLVWGDVJXWVRPHOGHWHVLFKVHLQ([WUDKLUQ6RKDWVLHHLQH&KDQFHVLFK YRQGHQ%HIHKOHQ]XEHIUHLHQGLHPDQLKUJHJHEHQKDW $WODQYHUQDKPGLH:RUWHRKQHVLHYHUDUEHLWHQ]XN|QQHQ(UPXWHVLFKYROODXI GLH$NRQLQNRQ]HQWULHUHQ0LWWOHUZHLOHKDWWHHUVLFKZHLWJHKHQGHUKROW6LHNRQQWHMHW]W QLFKWPHKUGLH9RUWHLOHQXW]HQZLHYRUKHU$WODQV6FKODJNDPVRVFKQHOOGDVLHLKP QLFKWPHKUDXVZHLFKHQNRQQWH(UWUDIGDV1HUYHQ]HQWUXPDXIGDVHUJH]LHOWKDWWH :LHYRP%OLW]JHWURIIHQVDQN1XUDP\LQVLFK]XVDPPHQ $WODQKREVLHDXIGLH$UPHXQGWUXJVLHLQGLH1HEHQNDELQHZRHUVLHDXIHLQH $QWLJUDYOLHJHEHWWHWH(UVFKlW]WHGDVLHHWZDHLQH6WXQGHEHZXWORVEOHLEHQZUGH XQGHUJODXEWHGDGLHVH=HLWIULKQDXVUHLFKWH'HQQRFKOHJWHHULKU)HVVHOQDQ 6FKQHOONHKUWHHULQVHLQH.DELQH]XUFNXQGPDFKWHVLFKDP7UVFKRWW]X VFKDIIHQ(UEUDXFKWHQXUZHQLJH0LQXWHQXPVLH]X|IIQHQ,QNDPSIEHUHLWHU+DOWXQJ WUDWHUDXIGHQ*DQJKLQDXVDEHUGRUWEHIDQGVLFKQLHPDQGGHUVLFKLKP HQWJHJHQVWHOOWH$XVJU|HUHU(QWIHUQXQJK|UWHHUGLH6FKUHLHHLQLJHU0HQVFKHQGLH RIIHQVLFKWOLFKGLH.RQWUROOHEHUVLFKVHOEVWYHUORUHQKDWWHQ (UEUDXFKWHVLFKQLFKWPHKU]XRULHQWLHUHQGHQQVFKRQEHLVHLQHPHUVWHQ $XVIOXJKDWWHHUVRUJIlOWLJUHFKHUFKLHUW6RZXWHHUMHW]WLQZHOFKH5LFKWXQJHL]X JHKHQKDWWHXPVRVFKQHOOZLHP|JOLFKLQGHQ%H]LUN]XNRPPHQLQGHPGHU%HKlOWHU PLWGHPJHKHLPQLVYROOHQ,QKDOWJHODJHUWZXUGH0LWVFKQHOOHQ6FKULWWHQHLOWHHUEHUGLH *lQJH+LQXQGZLHGHUVWLHHUDXIHLQHQ7HIURGHUGHUDXIGHP%RGHQODJ(LQ XQWHUVHW]WHU0DQQKLHOWVLFKLQGHU1lKHGHV$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWHVDXI(UVWLHUWHLKQPLW
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
EOXWXQWHUODXIHQHQ$XJHQDQ'LH.Q|FKHOVHLQHU+lQGH]HLJWHQ$EVFKUIXQJHQ 2IIHQVLFKWOLFKODJHLQNUl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|OOLJDXIGHQ$XWRSLORWHQ YHUODVVHQ'LHVHUQDKPMHW]WHLQH1HXRULHQWLHUXQJLP5DXPYRULQGHPHUGLH3RVLWLRQ IHVWVWHOOWHXQGVLHPLWGHPHLQSURJUDPPLHUWHQ=LHOSODQYHUJOLFK$EZHLFKXQJHQZXUGHQ DXVJHJOLFKHQXQGGHU.XUVQHXSURJUDPPLHUW´*OHLFK]HLWLJZXUGHQGLH0DVFKLQHQXQG GLHJHVDPWHHOHNWURQLVFKHXQGSRVLWURQLVFKH$XVUVWXQJEHUSUIW)HKOHUZXUGHQ EHVHLWLJWXQGGDV6FKLIIVRIUGHQQlFKVWHQ)OXJGXUFKGHQ/LQHDUUDXPYRUEHUHLWHWLQ GHPLKPZLHGHUHLQHDEVROXWH+|FKVWOHLVWXQJDEYHUODQJWZXUGH $OV$XHQVWHKHQGHUNRQQWH$WODQQRFKQLFKWHLQPDODEVFKlW]HQZLHODQJHGLHVH $UEHLWHQGDXHUQZUGHQ=XYLHOH.RPSRQHQWHQZDUHQ]XEHUXFNVLFKWLJHQ9RUKHUOLH VLFKQLHPDOVVDJHQZLHYLHO=HLWEHQ|WLJWZXUGHXPDXIJHWUHWHQH)HKOHUXQG $EZHLFKXQJHQ]XNRUULJLHUHQ $WODQHQWVFKORVLFKGHQ:HJQDFKXQWHQ]XZlKOHQZHLOHUKRIIWHKLHU VFKQHOOHUYRUDQ]XNRPPHQ8QWHULKPODJHQGLH+DOOHQPLWGHQHQHUJHWLVFKHQ *URDQODJHQGHQ.RQYHUWHUQXQGGHQ8PZlO]HUQ'RUWYHUPXWHWHHUQXU ZHQLJH7HIURGHU (UEHKLHOWUHFKW(UWUDIDXIHLQLJH0RQWHXUHXQG,QJHQLHXUHGLHMHGRFKHUVFK|SIW XQGDSDWKLVFKDXIGHP%RGHQNDXHUWHQXQGLKQQLFKWDXIKLHOWHQ6RNDPHUXQJHKLQGHUW ELV]XHLQHPEUHLWHQ*DQJGHUGLUHNWLQV=HQWUXPGHV6FKLIIHVIKUWH$XILKPNRQQWHHU VFKQHOOELVLQGLH1lKHVHLQHV=LHOHVNRPPHQ$OVHUVFKRQJODXEWHHVJHVFKDIIW]X KDEHQOLHIHUJHJHQHLQHXQVLFKWEDUH:DQG6LHVSDQQWHVLFKTXHUEHUHLQHQ*DQJ YRQPHKUHUHQ0HWHUQ%UHLWH:HQLJH6FKULWWHZHLWHUEHIDQGVLFKHLQ6FKRWWPLWHLQHU $XIVFKULIWGLHHUQLFKWHQW]LIIHUQNRQQWH .RQ]HQWULHUWEHUOHJWHHUZLHHUZHLWHUNRPPHQNRQQWH+DWWH&D0LQJRUGHQ (QHUJLHIHOGSURMHNWRUDXIGLHVHU6HLWHRGHUDXIGHUDQGHUHQDXIJHVWHOOW"$WODQYHUPXWHWH GDHUDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHVWDQGXQGSHU)XQNUHJXOLHUWZHUGHQNRQQWH(LQHDQGHUH 0|JOLFKNHLWNRQQWHHVQLFKWJHEHQ$PRNODXIHQGH7HIURGHUELOGHWHQHLQH]XJURH *HIDKUIUGDVJHKHLPQLVYROOH7UDQVSRUWJXW (UNDP]XGHP6FKOXGDGLH)XQNVWHXHUXQJQXUYRQGHU+DXSWOHLWRGHUYRQ GHU)XQN]HQWUDOHDXVJHKHQNRQQWH'DVEHGHXWHWHGDHVVLQQORVZDULQDQGHUHQ %HUHLFKHQGHV6FKLIIHV]XVXFKHQ(UYHUVFKZHQGHWHQXU=HLW 0LWDXVJUHLIHQGHQ6FKULWWHQHLOWHHU]XUFN'LH6FKRWWH]XU1RWWUHSSHJOLWWHQ ]XUFN(UZROOWHKLQGXUFKJHKHQDOVHUHLQ*HUlXVFKKLQWHUVLFKK|UWH %OLW]VFKQHOOGUHKWHHUVLFKXPXQGHUVFKUDN (LQZHLKDDULJHU7HIURGHUVWDQGKLQWHULKP'HU0DQQZDUXUDOW'DV+DDU UHLFKWHLKPELVDXIGLH6FKXOWHUQKHUDE(VZDUGQQXQG]HU]DXVW'DV*HVLFKWZLUNWH ZLHHLQH7RWHQPDVNH7LHIH)DOWHQXPUDKPWHQGLHJODQ]ORVHQ$XJHQXQGGHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
OLSSHQORVHQ0XQG 'LHJHEHXJWHGUUH*HVWDOWWUXJHLQJUQH.RPELQDWLRQGLHYHUZDVFKHQ DXVVDKXQGORVHXPGHQDEJHPDJHUWHQ.|USHUIODWWHUWH 'LH(UVFKHLQXQJVHOEVWZlUHDQXQGIUVLFKNHLQ*UXQGIULKQJHZHVHQ HUVFKUHFNW]XVHLQ'RFKGHU7HIURGHUWUXJHLQH:DIIHLQGHU+DQGXQGHUPDFKWHJDQ] XQGJDUQLFKWGHQ(LQGUXFNHLQHV0DQQHVGHVVHQ*HLVWVLFKXQWHUGHP(LQIOXHLQHU XQEHNDQQWHQ0DFKWYHUZLUUWKDWWH,P*HJHQWHLO'LHVHU$OWHVFKLHQJHLVWLJVHKUNODU]X VHLQ $WODQEHZHJWHVLFKQLFKW (UEHUOHJWHILHEHUKDIWZDVHUWXQVROOWH(UZXWHGDHUGLHVHQ0DQQVR VFKQHOOZLHP|JOLFKEHUUXPSHOQXQGXQVFKlGOLFKPDFKHQPXWH&D0LQJRUGXUIWHDXI JDUNHLQHQ)DOOHUIDKUHQGDHUVLFKQRUPDOLP6FKLIIEHZHJHQNRQQWHZlKUHQGGLHVHV VLFKLP(LQVWHLQ.RQWLQXXPEHIDQG)DQGHUHVKHUDXVGDQQZUGHHUVHLQHQ *HIDQJHQHQIUDJORVVRVWUHQJIHVVHOQGDHUVLFKVLFKHUQLFKWPHKUVHOEVWEHIUHLHQ NRQQWH0LQJRUNRQQWHHVVLFKHLQIDFKQLFKWHUODXEHQLKQXQJHKLQGHUWLQGHU$192< KHUXPJHKHQ]XODVVHQZlKUHQGHUVHOEVWKDQGOXQJVXQIlKLJZDU $WODQOlFKHOWHXQPHUNOLFK(UKREGLHUHFKWH+DQGXQGJUWH ³+DOOR´VDJWHHU 'HU$OWHDQWZRUWHWHQLFKW$WODQIUDJWHVLFKZDUXPHUQLFKWDXFKGHPUlWVHOKDIWHQ (LQIOXHUODJ:DUGLHVHU0DQQPHQWDOVWDELOLVLHUWVRZLHHUVHOEVWDXFK"/DJKLHU EHUKDXSWHLQH6WUDKOXQJRGHUHWZDVbKQOLFKHVYRUGLHDXVVFKOLHOLFKDXIGDV*HKLUQ ZLUNWH"%LVMHW]WZXWHHUSUDNWLVFKQRFKQLFKWV ³+DOOR´ZLHGHUKROWHHU 6HLQ*HJHQEHUDQWZRUWHWHQRFKLPPHUQLFKW'HU0DQQVFKLHQ]XEHUOHJHQ,Q VHLQHP*HVLFKWDUEHLWHWHHV'DQQOHXFKWHWHQGLH$XJHQSO|W]OLFKDXI6LHVFKLHQHQDXV GHQJUDXHQ+|KOHQ]XTXHOOHQ'HU$UNRQLGHEHJULIIGDGHU7HIURGHUHLQHQ YHUKlQJQLVYROOHQ(QWVFKOXJHIDWKDWWH(UZDUIVLFKQDFKYRUQDEHUHUNDPVFKRQ]X VSlW 'HUDXVJHPHUJHOWH)LQJHUOHJWHVLFKDXIGHQ$XVO|VHUGHV3DUDO\VDWRUV$WODQ IKOWHGHQ0XVNHOVFKRFN0LWGHPOHW]WHQ5HVWVHLQHVNODUHQ9HUVWDQGHVEHJULIIHUGD HUQXQPHKUVHLQHOHW]WH&KDQFHYHUVSLHOWKDWWH(U]ZHLIHOWHQLFKWGDUDQGDGHU$OWH &D0LQJRUXQGGHQWHIURGLVFKHQ.RPPDQGDQWHQEHULKQLQIRUPLHUHQZUGH'LH DQGHUHQ0lQQHUGHQHQHUEHJHJQHWZDUKDWWHQLQ]ZLVFKHQYHUJHVVHQGDVLHLKQ JHVHKHQKDWWHQ'LHVHU$OWHDEHUZUGHVHLQH0HOGXQJPDFKHQN|QQHQ $WODQVSUWHGDHUDXIGDV*HVLFKWVWU]WH'DQQZXUGHHVGXQNHOXPLKQ (UZXWHQLFKWZLHYLHO=HLWYHUJDQJHQZDUDOVHUZLHGHU]XVLFKNDP=XQlFKVW ILHOHVLKPVFKZHUVLFK]XRULHQWLHUHQ(UODJQRFKLPPHUDXIGHP*HVLFKWDEHUHV GDXHUWHODQJHELVHUGDVEHJULII1XUJDQ]DOOPlKOLFKNOlUWHVLFKVHLQ9HUVWDQG6HLQ .|USHUVFKPHU]WHEHUDOO(UIKOWHGLH1DFKZLUNXQJHQGHV3DUDO\VHVFKRFNVVHKU GHXWOLFK$OVHUYHUVXFKWHVLFK]XEHZHJHQEHUPDQQWHQLKQGLH6FKPHU]HQ.DXP KDWWHHUGHQ.RSIJHKREHQDOVVLFKVHLQ1DFNHQXQGVHLQ5FNHQYHUNUDPSIWHQ(U EUDFK]XVDPPHQXQGZXUGHHUQHXWRKQPlFKWLJ 'DQDFKVSUWHHU]XQlFKVWGDV3RFKHQGHV=HOODNWLYDWRUVDXIVHLQHU%UXVW'DV *HUlWDUEHLWHWHPLWHUK|KWHU$NWLYLWlWXPZLHGHUQRUPDOH9HUKlOWQLVVHKHU]XVWHOOHQ $WODQKWHWHVLFKGDYRUDEHUPDOV]XIUKDXIVWHKHQ]XZROOHQ(UEOLHEVROLHJHQZLHHU ODJXQGZDUWHWHDE8PLKQKHUXPZDUHVVWLOO,P1HEHQUDXPK|UWHHU6FKULWWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
-HPDQGJLQJXQUXKLJDXIXQGDE 1XUDP\" (UIDQGHV]XQlFKVWQLFKWKHUDXV 9RUVLFKWLJZlO]WHHUVLFKDXIGLH6HLWHXQGGDQQDXIGHQ5FNHQ (UEHIDQGVLFKZLHGHULQVHLQHU.DELQH,QGHU(FNHVWDQGGHU5RERWHU(U EHZHJWHVLFKQLFKW1LFKWVGHXWHWHGDUDXIKLQGDHUZLHGHUDNWLYLHUWZRUGHQZDU$EHU GDVNRQQWHWlXVFKHQ'HU$XWRPDWZUGHHUVWGDQQRIIHQEDUHQLQZHOFKHP %HIHKOV]XVWDQGHUVLFKEHIDQGZHQQHUJHIRUGHUWZXUGH ³+H5RE+LOIPLUDXI´NHXFKWH$WODQ (UHUVFKUDNDOVGLH0DVFKLQHVLFKYRQVHLQHP3ODW]O|VWHXQG]XLKPNDP%LV MHW]WKDWWHHULPPHUQRFKJHKRIIWGDGLH$192<VLFKQRFKLP1RUPDONRQWLQXXP DXIKLHOW'HU*ULIIPLWGHPGHU5RERWHULKPDXIKDOIEHZLHVLKPGDGHU5DXPHU EHUHLWVZLHGHUPLWYLHOIDFKHU/LFKWJHVFKZLQGLJNHLWIORJ(UUDVWHGXUFKGHQ/LQHDUUDXP 'DPLWKDWWHVLFKDQ%RUGEHUHLWVDOOHVZLHGHUQRUPDOLVLHUW $WODQZDUIURKGDGHU$XWRPDWLKQ]XVHLQHP/DJHUEHJOHLWHWH(UKlWWHQRFK QLFKWGLH.UDIWJHKDEWVLFKVHOEVWGRUWKLQ]XVFKOHSSHQbFK]HQGVDQNHUDXIGHU/LHJH ]XVDPPHQ6HLQH0XVNHOQVFKPHU]WHQXQG]XFNWHQ (UIUDJWHVLFKZDVJHVFKHKHQVHLQPRFKWH +DWWH&D0LQJRULKQGUDXHQJHIXQGHQXQGGDQQLQGLH.DELQH]XUFNEULQJHQ ODVVHQ":DUXPKDWWHHULKQGDQQQLFKWJHIHVVHOW"2GHUZROOWHHUGDPLWZDUWHQELVGLH $192<GDVQlFKVWH0DOLQGHQ1RUPDOUDXP]XUFNNHKUWH²YLHOOHLFKWGDVOHW]WH0DOYRU LKUHP=LHORGHUGLUHNWLP=LHO" $XIGDVZDVZLUNOLFKSDVVLHUWZDUNDPHUQLFKW'LHVH0|JOLFKNHLWZlUHLKP DXFK]XXQZDKUVFKHLQOLFKHUVFKLHQHQ (UPHUNWHHUVWHLQLJH6WQGHQVSlWHUGDLKPMHPDQGHLQHQ=HWWHODP+DOV XQWHUGLH.RPELQDWLRQJHVFKREHQKDWWH6RIRUWZXWHHUZDVGDV]XEHGHXWHQKDWWH(U HUKREVLFKXQGJLQJHLQLJH6FKULWWHDXIXQGDE-HW]WIKOWHHUVLFKVFKRQZRKOHUELVHU VLFKGDUDQHULQQHUWHZDVHUPLWGHU$NRQLQJHPDFKWKDWWHEHYRUHUVHLQH.DELQH YHUODVVHQKDWWH(UVWU]WHI|UPOLFKDXIGDV9HUELQGXQJVVFKRWW]XXQGZDUWHWH XQJHGXOGLJELVHVVLFKJH|IIQHWKDWWH 1XUDP\ODJDXIGHP%RGHQ6LHZDUQRFKLPPHUJHIHVVHOW0LWKHUYRUTXHOµ OHQGHQ$XJHQVWDUUWHVLHLKQDQ,KUH/LSSHQZDUHQZHL ³:UGHVWGXPLUELWWHHUNOlUHQZDVGDV]XEHGHXWHQKDW"´IUDJWHVLHPLWHLQHU 6WLPPHGLHRKQPlFKWLJHQ=RUQHUNHQQHQOLH $WODQHULQQHUWHVLFKEXFKVWlEOLFKLPOHW]WHQ$XJHQEOLFNGDUDQGDVHLQH:RUWH LUJHQGZRLP6FKLIIDEJHK|UWZXUGHQ'HU5RERWHUZDULKPJHIROJW(UVWDQGGLFKWKLQWHU LKP6HLQH0LNURSKRQHQDKPHQMHGHQ/DXWDXIXQGHLQ)XQNJHUlWLQVHLQHP,QQHUQ OHLWHWHDOOHVZHLWHU ³,FKKDEHNHLQH$KQXQJZLHGDVSDVVLHUWLVW¶ EHKDXSWHWHGHU$UNRQLGH³:HU KDWGLFKJHIHVVHOW",FKKDEHEHUKDXSWQLFKWEHPHUNWGDMHPDQGKLHUZDU",FKZDU EHZXWORV ³'DVJODXEHLFKQLFKW´¶ULHIVLHZWHQG³'XOJVW´ (UO|VWHLKUH)HVVHOQ 6LHEOLFNWH]XU:DQG$OVVLHIUHLZDUVWLHVLHVHLQH+lQGH]XU6HLWH ³/DPLFKDOOHLQ´EHIDKOVLHKHIWLJ ³$EHUJHUQGRFK´HQWJHJQHWHHUPLWLURQLVFKHP8QWHUWRQXQGNHKUWHLQVHLQH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
.DELQH]XUFN'HU5RERWHUEOLHELKPDXIGHQ)HUVHQ$WODQEHWUDWGHQ6DQLWlUUDXPXQG OLHGLH7UYRUGHP$XWRPDWHQ]XIDKUHQ ³(VJLEWJHZLVVH3OlW]HGLHVRJDUGHU([LPSHUDWRUYRQ$UNRQJHUQDOOHLQ DXIVXFKW´VDJWHHU (UUHJWJULIIHUQDFKGHP=HWWHOXQWHUVHLQHU.RPELQDWLRQ(UHQWIDOWHWHLKQ:LH HUZDUWHWHQWKLHOWHUHLQH%RWVFKDIW ³&D0LQJRUZHLELVMHW]WQRFKQLFKWGD6LH,KUH.DELQHYHUODVVHQKDEHQ´ VFKULHEGHU8QEHNDQQWHGHUGLH=HLOHQQLFKWXQWHU]HLFKQHWKDWWH³$EHUZLUZHUGHQHV LKPPLWWHLOHQIDOOVZLUHVDOVQRWZHQGLJDQVHKHQVROOWHQ(UZLUGVLFKVLFKHUOLFKGDIU LQWHUHVVLHUHQZHVKDOE6LHJHLVWLJQRUPDOEOHLEHQZHQQ²IDVW²DOOHDQGHUHQDQ%RUG DPRNODXIHQ´ 1DFKGLHVHUGURKHQGHQ(LQOHLWXQJIROJWHQGLH9RUVFKOlJHXQGGLH)RUGHUXQJHQ GHU8QEHNDQQWHQGLHLKPXQG1XUDP\HLQH)OXFKWDXVGHP6FKLIIHUP|JOLFKHQZROOWHQ 6LHYHUODQJWHQQLFKWVhEHUUDVFKHQGHV(UVROOWHLKQHQHLQQHXHVbXHUHVYHUVFKDIIHQ XQGVLHPLWHLQHPYROODXVJHUVWHWHQ5DXPVFKLIIDXVVWDWWHQ'DIUZROOWHQVLH JDUDQWLHUHQGDHULQQHUKDOEZHQLJHU7DJHPLWHLQHP%HLERRWGHU$192<]XMHGHP =LHOGDVHUDQJDEIOLHJHQNRQQWH 'HUOHW]WH6DW]ODXWHWH³(VIROJHQQRFK]ZHL/LQHDUHWDSSHQ´ $WODQYHUQLFKWHWHGLH%RWVFKDIWXQGNHKUWHGDQQLQVHLQH.DELQH]XUFNZR 1XUDP\PLWEHUJHVFKODJHQHQ%HLQHQLQHLQHP6HVVHOVD,KUH)LQJHUWURPPHOWHQ QHUY|VDXIGLH/HKQHXQGLKUH$XJHQEUDXHQEHIDQGHQVLFKLQQLFKWZHQLJHUXQUXKLJHU %HZHJXQJ ³'HU5RERWHUPDFKWPLFKNUDQN´JHVWDQGVLH³.|QQHQZLULKQQLFKWORVZHUGHQ ³9HUPXWOLFKQLFKW´HQWJHJQHWHHU³'DVNOHLQH0lGFKHQZDUOHLGHULQGHUOHW]WHQ =HLWVRXQJH]RJHQGDGHU.RPPDQGDQWHVIUEHVVHUKLHOWHVYRQHLQHP6SH]LDOLVWHQ EHUZDFKHQ]XODVVHQ'DVLVWHU (UGHXWHWHDXIGHQ$XWRPDWHQ 'LH:DQJHQGHU$NRQLQU|WHWHQVLFK6LHVFKWWHOWHYHUZLUUWGHQ.RSI ³,FKHULQQHUHPLFKVFKZDFKGDUDQGDLFKPLWGLUJHNlPSIWKDEH´VDJWHVLH ³DEHULFKZHLQLFKWPHKUJHQDXZDVHLJHQWOLFKSDVVLHUWLVW9HUPXWOLFKKDVWGXZLHGHU HLQPDOHLQLJHUHFKWGXPPH%HPHUNXQJHQJHPDFKW´ ³9HUPXWOLFK´ (UOlFKHOWH 6LHHUKREVLFKXQGJLQJ]XLKP ³:DVKDVWGXYRU"IUDJWHVLH ³2KQLFKWVZHLWHU,FKKlWWHQLFKWEHO/XVW0LQJRUJHJHQGHQ.RPPDQGDQWHQ DXV]XVSLHOHQDEHUGDVVFKHLQWZHQLJVLQQYROO]XVHLQ´ ³:DUXPQLFKW"´ ³'HU7HUUDQHUNULHFKWRKQHKLQYRUGHP7HIURGHUDXIGHP%RGHQKHUXP´ (UEOLFNWH]XP5RERWHUKLQEHUZHLOHUHUZDUWHWHGD0LQJRUVLFKSURYR]LHUHQ OLHXQGVLFKPHOGHWH'HU7HUUDQHUHQWWlXVFKWHLKQMHGRFK:HQQHUGLH:RUWH WDWVlFKOLFKDEK|UWHVROLHHUVLFKGDGXUFKQLFKWKHUDXVIRUGHUQ $WODQVHW]WHVLFKLQHLQHQ6HVVHO(UEHUOHJWH *HUQKlWWHHU1XUDP\LQVHLQH3OlQHHLQJHZHLKWDEHUGDVZDJWHHUQLFKWZHLOHU QLFKWZLVVHQNRQQWHZLHVLHVLFKLQGHQQlFKVWHQ6WXQGHQEHQHKPHQZUGH8QWHUGHP (LQIOXGHUXQEHNDQQWHQ6WUDKOXQJNRQQWHVLHDOOHVP|JOLFKHWXQ6LHZDUHEHQVR
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
XQEHUHFKHQEDUZLHMHGHUDQGHUHDQ%RUG²GHUJHKHLPQLVYROOH$OWHHLQJHVFKORVVHQ $WODQKDWWHODQJHEHUGLHVHQ0DQQQDFKJHGDFKWRKQH]XHLQHP(UJHEQLV]X NRPPHQ(UZXWHQLFKWZDVHUYRQLKPKDOWHQVROOWH*HK|UWHHU]XMHQHU*UXSSHYRQ 5HEHOOHQJHJHQ&D0LQJRUGLHYRQ%RUGIOLHKHQZROOWHQXQGLKPGHVKDOELKUH+LOIH DQERWHQ"6LFKHUOLFK:HQQHVVRZDUZHVKDOEKDWWHHULKQGDQQDEHUSDUDO\VLHUWXQGLQ GLHVHP=XVWDQGLQGLH.DELQH]XUFNJHEUDFKW":HVKDOEZDUHUGD]XGDV5LVLNR HLQJHJDQJHQLKPVHLQH$EVLFKWHQDXIHLQHP=HWWHOPLW]XWHLOHQREZRKOHUGRFKZLVVHQ PXWHGDGLHVHUYRQ0LQJRUXQGVHLQHQ6FKHUJHQJHIXQGHQZHUGHQNRQQWH" (VZlUHGRFKYLHOHLQIDFKHUIUEHLGH3DUWHLHQJHZHVHQZHQQVLHGLUHNW PLWHLQDQGHUJHVSURFKHQKlWWHQ$OOHUGLQJVKlWWHHUGDQQYLHOOHLFKWQLFKWQXUGHQ$OWHQ JHVHKHQVRQGHUQDXFKGLHDQGHUHQ0lQQHUGLHVLFKGD]XHQWVFKORVVHQKDWWHQVLFK YRQGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQDE]XVRQGHUQ]XGHUGLH$192<JHK|UWH,KU9HUKDOWHQOLH HUNHQQHQGDGLHK|FKVWHQ6FKDOWVWHOOHQGLHVHU,QWHUHVVHQJHPHLQVFKDIWPLW 3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQEHVHW]WZDUHQGLHLKUH=LHOHPLWHLVNDOWHU%UXWDOLWlWYHUIROJWHQ:HU VLFKLKUHP%HIHKOXQWHUVWHOOWKDWWHPXWHHLQHQJDQ]EHVWLPPWHQ*UXQGGDIUKDEHQ 1LHPDQGVFKORVLFKHLQHUSDUDPLOLWlULVFKHQ2UJDQLVDWLRQDQXQGXQWHUZDUIVLFKGDPLW HLQHUVHKUDQIHFKWEDUHQ'LV]LSOLQZHQQHUVLFKQLFKWJDQ]EHVRQGHUH9RUWHLOHGDYRQ YHUVSUDFK $WODQEOLFNWHGHQ5RERWHUQDFKGHQNOLFKDQ 6HLQH6LWXDWLRQKDWWHVLFKUDSLGHYHUVFKOHFKWHUWVHLWGHPHUYRQGLHVHU0DVFKLQH EHUZDFKWZXUGH%LVKHUKDWWHHUQDFKGHP*UXQGVDW]]XKDQGHOQYHUVXFKWGD$QJULII LPPHUQRFKGLHEHVWH9HUWHLGLJXQJZDU6HLQH&KDQFHQZXUGHQMHGRFKVWlQGLJ JHULQJHU=ZDUZXWHHUHLQHQ0DQQLUJHQGZRLP6FKLIIGHUGHQ5RERWHUQRWIDOOVHLQLJH =HLWDXVVFKDOWHWHDEHUGDPLWZDULKPQLFKWYLHOJHKROIHQZHLOHUNHLQHQGLUHNWHQ .RQWDNWKDWWH(UZDUYRQGLHVHP8QEHNDQQWHQYLHO]XDEKlQJLJXQGZXWHQLHREHU LKPYHUWUDXHQNRQQWHRGHUREHUYRQLKPZLHHLQH0DULRQHWWHLQHLQHP6SLHOJHIKUW ZXUGH :DUHUZLUNOLFKVRIUHLZLHHUVLFK]HLWZHLOLJZlKQWH"2GHUWDWHUQXUGDVZDV GLHDQGHUHQZROOWHQZlKUHQGHUJODXEWHGD)OXFKWYRUEHUHLWXQJHQIULKQJHWURIIHQ ZXUGHQ" 'LH6LWXDWLRQEHKDJWHLKPQLFKW 1LFKWHUZDUHVGHUGLH6SLHO]JHEHVWLPPWHVRQGHUQMHPDQGDQGHUHVGHQHU QLFKWNDQQWHXQGYRQGHPHUQXUZXWHGDHUH[LVWLHUWH(UVHOEVWZDUELVMHW]WQLFKW PHKUDOVHLQH6FKDFKILJXUGLHKLQXQGKHUJHVFKREHQZXUGHRKQHGDEHLZLUNOLFKHQ (LQIOXDXIGDV*HVFKHKHQQHKPHQ]XN|QQHQ (UZDU]XJOHLFKEHU]HXJWGDYRQGDHUGLHVHQ=XVWDQGlQGHUQNRQQWHZHQQ HVLKPJHODQJYRQVLFKDXVGHQULFKWLJHQ=XJLQGLHVHP6SLHOPDFKHQ(UVSUWH I|UPOLFKGDHUQXUHLQHQJDQ]EHVWLPPWHQ6FKULWW]XWXQEUDXFKWHXPGHUDUWDQ *HZLFKW]XJHZLQQHQGDHUYRP%DXHUQ]XP.|QLJZXUGH 'XPXWGHQ.HJHOYHUQLFKWHQDQWZRUWHWHGDV([WUDKLUQDXIGLH XQDXVJHVSURFKHQH)UDJH´ )DEHOKDIWDQWZRUWHWHHULQ*HGDQNHQ(VLVWMDDXFKQLFKWVOHLFKWHUDOVGDV )UGHQGHUEHUOHJWXQGNOXJKDQGHOWQLFKW'DVLVWULFKWLJ (UIKOWHGDLKPGDV%OXW]X.RSIVWLHJ +DWWHHUQLFKWEHUOHJWJHKDQGHOW" .HLQHVZHJVVWHOOWHGHU/RJLNVHNWRUIHVW(VIHKOWDQ(LJHQLQLWLDWLYH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
9LHOHQ'DQN 'DVZDUNHLQH%HXUWHLOXQJVRQGHUQHLQH)HVWVWHOOXQJ 1DWUOLFK'DVKDEHLFKEHUVHKHQ(VJHKWQLFKWXP.ULWLNVRQGHUQXP/RN 'DV([WUDKLUQYHU]LFKWHWHGDUDXIDXIGLHVH)HVWVWHOOXQJ]XDQWZRUWHQ /RJLVFKZlUHDOVRGHQ5RERWHUµUDXV]XVFKPHLHQ6ROOLFKGDVVHOEVWPDFKHQ RGHUEHUODVVHLFKHVGHUOLHEHQ1XUDP\" 'DV6RQGHUKLUQDQWZRUWHWHSURPSW (VLVWQLFKWQRWZHQGLJ%HOHKUXQJHQEHU/RJLN]XHUWHLOHQ.ULWLNHPSILQGOLFKNHLW KDWQLFKWVPLWORJLVFKHQ'HQNYRUJlQJHQVRQGHUQEHUWULHEHQHU(PSILQGVDUQNHLW]XWXQ $XIGLHVH:HLVHOHUQWPDQGRFKLPPHUQRFKGD]X $WODQZlUHLQGLHVHP$XJHQEOLFNIURKJHZHVHQZHQQVHLQ([WUDKLUQVLFKQLFKW LPPHUZLHGHUJHPHOGHWKlWWH'RFKJHUDGHMHW]WVFKZLHJHVQLFKW0LWHLVNDOWHU/RJLN ]HUSIOFNWHHVVHLQH*HGDQNHQJlQJHXQGOHJWHEORZDVHULP*UXQGHVFKRQOlQJVW HUNDQQWKDWWHXQGQXUQRFKQLFKW]XJHEHQZROOWH9RUVLFKVHOEVWNRQQWHHUMHGRFKQLFKWV YHUEHUJHQ (VZlUHIDOVFKGHQ5RERWHUDQ]XJUHLIHQXQG]XHOLPLQLHUHQ5LFKWLJGDJHJHQ ZlUHHVGLHVHJHJHQGLFKJHULFKWHWH:DIIHXP]XNHKUHQXQGVLHVHOEVW]XQXW]HQ (U]XFNWHZLHQDFKHLQHPNRUSHUOLFKHQ6FKODJ]XVDPPHQ 'DHUGDUDQQLFKWJHGDFKWKDWWH &LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
XQYHUPHLGOLFK (UJLQJDXI.DSIODU]X 'HU (UVWH 3URMHNWLRQVIHOG,QJHQLHXU KRE GHQ .RSI XQG QLFNWH LKP GDQQ ]X (UDUEHLWHWHUXKLJZHLWHU ³+DVHGXHWZDVHUUHLFKW´"´IUDJWHHUZlKUHQGHUHLQLJH.RQWDNWHDXVZHFKVHOWH ³1DWUOLFK´DQWZRUWHWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
+DQG LQ +DQG ]XVDPPHQDUEHLWHQ (V LVW QXU HLQ ZHQLJ XQJHZRKQW IU PLFK GDUDQ ]X GHQNHQ GD PHLQ HLJHQHV 6FKLFNVDO MHW]W YRQ GHU (KUHQKDIWLJNHLW XQG GHU =XYHUOlVVLJNHLWYRQVRYLHOHQ0HQVFKHQDEKlQJLJLVW:DVPDFKHQZLUZHQQDXFKQXU HLQHLQ]LJHU9HUUlWHUGDEHLLVW"´ &LSSDURQ
0LQJRUYHUVXFKWH2UGQXQJ]XVFKDIIHQ :lKUHQG 6¶9DQJRU%UDGG GHP &KDRV PLW HLQHU JHZLVVHQ *OHLFKJOWLJNHLW JHJHQEHU]XVWHKHQVFKLHQNlPSIWHGHU7HUUDQHUXPGLH'LV]LSOLQ=XQlFKVWEHJHJQHWH HU GHP .RPPDQGDQWHQ KRFKIDKUHQG XQG DEZHLVHQG ELV HU PHUNWH GD DXFK GHU 7HIURGHU PLW LKP DP JOHLFKHQ 6WUDQJ ]RJ QXU DXI HLQH HWZDV DQGHUH :HLVH DOV HU 'DQDFKEHUXKLJWHHUVLFKZLHGHUHWZDV'HU.RPPDQGDQWKDWWHLP*UXQGHGDVJOHLFKH 3UREOHP ZLH HU 6LH PXWHQ GHQ .HJHO D¶ OLHIHUQ 'HU 7UDQVSRUW GXUIWH DXI JDU NHLQHQ )DOOJHIlKUGHWZHUGHQ %LV MHW]W NRQQWH MHGRFK QRFK QLHPDQG VDJHQ ZLH GLH OHW]WH 3KDVH GHV )OXJHV DEJHZLFNHOW ZHUGHQ VROOWH %LV ]XU /DQGXQJ ZUGH GHU $XWRSLORW DOOHV OHQNHQ DEHU JUXQGVlW]OLFKH (QWVFKHLGXQJHQ PXWHQ GHQQRFK YRQ GHU 6FKLIIVIKUXQJ JHWURIIHQ ZHUGHQ %HVRQGHUV EHXQUXKLJWH 0LQJRU GD HU ZHUWYROOH 0lQQHU YHUORUHQ KDWWH (LQHU VHLQHU]XYHUOlVVLJVWHQ0LWDUEHLWHUZDU+DV.DWDUJHZHVHQ6HLQHhEHUUHVWHKDWWHPDQ LP$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWJHIXQGHQ -HW]WVDHLQ0DQQDXIGHP%HREDFKWXQJVSRVWHQGHQ0LQJRUHLJHQWOLFKQLHVHKU YLHO EHDFKWHW KDWWH REZRKO HU LPPHU LQ VHLQHU 1lKH JHZHVHQ ZDU 3HUUD $OND ZDU LPPHUHLQVHKU]XYHUOlVVLJHU0LWDUEHLWHUJHZHVHQGHUGLHPHLVWHQZLFKWLJHQ$XIJDEHQ VFKRQHUOHGLJWKDWWHEHYRUGHU%HIHKOGD]XHUJDQJHQZDU -HW]W IUDJWH VLFK 0LQJRU SO|W]OLFK RE GLHVHU 7HIURGHU ZLUNOLFK VR XQEHLUUW ]X LKP VWDQG ZLH HU LPPHU JODXEWH :DV ZUGH 3HUUD $OND WXQZHQQ HU SO|W]OLFK JH]ZXQJHQ ZXUGHVLFKIULKQ0LQJRURGHUIUGHQ.RPPDQGDQWHQ]XHQWVFKHLGHQ" 6¶9DQJRU%UDGGNDP]XLKP ³6LHE]HKQ 0lQQHU XQG ]ZHL )UDXHQ VLQG YHUXQJOFNW DOV ZLU LP 1RUPDOUDXP ZDUHQ´ EHULFKWHWH HU ³6LH VLQG DOOH WRW 'DUEHU KLQDXV KDEHQ ZLU QRFK HWZD ]ZDQ]LJ PHKU RGHU PLQGHU VFKZHU 9HUOHW]WH 6LH ZHUGHQ GXUFKNRPPHQ =ZHL (WDSSHQ OLHJHQ QRFKYRUXQV'DQQZLUGXQVHU)OXJLP1RUPDOUDXPHQGHQ:DVSDVVLHUWGDQQ"´ ³,FK ZHL HV QLFKW YHUGDPPW´ HQWJHJQHWH GHU 7HUUDQHU ³,FK KDEH DQJHRUGQHW GD GLH $192< ELV LQ GHQ OHW]WHQ :LQNHO KLQHLQ GXUFKVXFKW ZLUG (V PX GRFK HWZDV ]XILQGHQVHLQGDVIUGLHVHYHUUFNWHQ=ZLVFKHQIlOOHYHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVW´ ³8QGZHQQHVGHU.HJHOLVW"´ 'LHEHLGHQ0lQQHUEOLFNWHQVLFKDQ0LQJRUVDK9HU]ZHLIOXQJLQGHQ$XJHQGHV 7HIURGHUV DXINRPPHQ 'D HUNDQQWH HU GD GLHVHU GHQ (UHLJQLVVHQ LP *UXQGH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
JHQRPPHQ JHQDXVR KLOIORV JHJHQEHUVWDQG ZLH HU VHOEVW ,KP ZXUGHNODUGD VLH ]XVDPPHQDUEHLWHQ PXWHQ ZHLO VLH HV VLFK HLQIDFK QLFKW OHLVWHQ NRQQWHQ JHJHQHLQDQGHU]XNlPSIHQ ³(V JLEW QXU HLQH /|VXQJ´ VDJWH 0LQJRU QDFK HLQHU ODQJHQ 3DXVH ³:LU KDEHQ IHVWJHVWHOOW GD 5RERWHU QLFKW EHHLQIOXW ZHUGHQ 6LH EOHLEHQ QRUPDO XQG YROO KDQGOXQJVIlKLJ $OVR PVVHQ ZLU LKQHQ GLH $XIJDEHQ EHUWUDJHQ GLH ZLU VRQVW HUOHGLJHQ6LHPVVHQGDIUVRUJHQGDZLUXQVQLFKWJHJHQVHLWLJXPEULQJHQ´ ³/HLGHUKDEHQZLUQLFKWJHQJHQG5RERWHUDQ%RUG´DQWZRUWHWH6¶9DQJRU%UDGG ³$EHUYLHOOHLFKWUHLFKWHVGHQQRFKZHQQZLUDOOHDNWLYLHUHQ´ (U VDK VLFK LQ GHU +DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOH XP =DKOUHLFKH 3RVLWURQLN,QJHQLHXUH ZDUHQ GDPLWEHVFKlIWLJW6FKlGHQ]XEHKHEHQGLHGXUFK)HKOVFKDOWXQJHQHLQJHWUHWHQZDUHQ ,Q GHQ DQGHUHQ 7HLOHQ GHV 6FKLIIHV VDK HV NDXP DQGHUV DXV 1DKH]X GLH JHVDPWH %HVDW]XQJ DUEHLWHWH DQ GHU :LHGHUKHUVWHOOXQJ GHV 6FKLIIHV 6LH ZXUGH GDGXUFK EHVRQGHUV VWDUN EHKLQGHUW GD VLH JHUDGH LQ GHU DXJHQEOLFNOLFKHQ )OXJSKDVH UHODWLY ZHQLJ DXVULFKWHQ NRQQWH 'DV 6FKLII EHIDQG VLFK LP /LQHDUUDXP LQ GHP GLH JHVDPWH .DSD]LWlWDXVJHQXW]WZHUGHQPXWH ³:HQQGLHVH9RUIlOOHLP1RUPDO.RQWLQXXPQLFKWJHZHVHQZlUHQGDQQZlUHQZLU PLWHQWVFKHLGHQGZHQLJHU/LQHDUHWDSSHQDXVJHNRPPHQ´VDJWHGHU.RPPDQGDQW³'LH JHVDPWH$NWLRQZlUHOlQJVWDEJHZLFNHOWJHZHVHQ-HW]WIUDJHLFKPLFKREHLQ6FKDGHQ DQGHP%HKlOWHUHQWVWDQGHQLVWRGHUREZLUGLH6FKZLHULJNHLWHQXQVHUHPSURPLQHQWHQ *HIDQJHQHQ]XYHUGDQNHQKDEHQ´ ³$WODQ"´ 0LQJRUVFKWWHOWHHQWVFKLHGHQGHQ.RSI ³,FKKDEHLKQXQWHU.RQWUROOH(UNDQQQLFKWVJHJHQXQVWXQ´ ³'DV KDEH LFK DXFK QLFKW YRU PHLQH +HUUHQ´ HUNOlUWH GHU $UNRQLGH GHU VLFK LKQHQ XQEHPHUNW JHQlKHUW KDWWH ³'D LFK ,KUH DXHURUGHQWOLFKH *DVWIUHXQGVFKDIW JHQLHHIKOHLFKPLFKYHUSIOLFKWHWPLFKGDQNEDU]XHUZHLVHQ´ &D 0LQJRU IXKU UXFNDUWLJ KHUXP 6HLQH :DQJHQ U|WHWHQ VLFK DOV HU GDV KHUDEODVVHQGH/lFKHOQ$WODQVVDK'HU$UNRQLGHVWDQGLQJHORFNHUWHU+DOWXQJYRULKP 'LH +lQGH YHUVFKUlQNWH HU KLQWHU GHP 5FNHQ 'HU 7HUUDQHU IKOWH VLFK KHUDXVJHIRUGHUWZHLOHUVLFKGLHVHLQ0DQQXQWHUOHJHQZXWH'HU/RUGDGPLUDOJDEVLFK VR DOV ZHUGH HU QDFK $EVFKOX GHU EHYRUVWHKHQGHQ 9HUKDQGOXQJHQ GHU 6FKLIIVHLJQHU VHLQ 6HOWVDPHUZHLVH YHUVWlUNWH GHU 5RERWHU GHU KLQWHU $WODQ VWDQG GLHVHQ (LQGUXFN QRFK 'HU 7HUUDQHU HPSIDQG LKQ DOV 'URKXQJ REZRKO HU JHQDX ZXWH GD GLH 0DVFKLQH OHGLJOLFK GHQ $XIWUDJ KDWWH GHQ $UNRQLGHQ LQ VHLQHQ $NWLRQVP|JOLFKNHLWHQ HLQ]XHQJHQ ³:LHLFKVHKHKDEHQ6LH3UREOHPH´VDJWH$WODQXQGGHXWHWHDXIGLH,QJHQLHXUH LQ GHU =HQWUDOH ³(LQH DXV DOOHQ )XJHQ JHUDWHQH 0DQQVFKDIW VFKHLQW KLHU HLQLJHQ 6FKDGHQDQJHULFKWHW]XKDEHQ'DUIPDQIUDJHQZDVIUGHQ$PRNODXIGHU0lQQHUXQG )UDXHQYHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVW"0HLQH%HJOHLWHULQKlWWHPLFKIDVWXPJHEUDFKW=XQlFKVWKLHOW LFKGDVIUHLQHQEHVRQGHUHQ$XVGUXFNYRQ7HPSHUDPHQWMHW]WDEHUVHKHLFKGDGLH JHVDPWH%HVDW]XQJHLQZHQLJVHOWVDPUHDJLHUW´ 0LQJRUXQGGHU.RPPDQGDQWEOLFNWHQVLFKNXU]DQDQWZRUWHWHQMHGRFKQLFKW ³(V WXW PLU OHLG ZHQQ LFK GHQ NHJHOI|UPLJHQ %HKlOWHU EHVFKlGLJW KDEHQ VROOWH ,FK NRQQWH MD QLFKW DKQHQ GD GHU $QJULII PHLQHV HLQJHERUHQHQ )UHXQGHV GHUDUWLJH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
)ROJHQKDEHQZUGH´ 0LQJRUOlFKHOWHXQPHUNOLFK ³0DFKHQ 6LH VLFK QXU NHLQH 6RUJHQ 'HU 7HOHSRUWHU KDWWH EHVWLPPW NHLQHQ (UIROJ´ $WODQNUDXVWHGLH6WLUQ'DQQOlFKHOWHHUHEHQIDOOV1DWUOLFKKDWWHHUQLFKWGDPLW JHUHFKQHWGD0LQJRUVLFKXEHUUXPSHOQODVVHQZUGH'DVZDUMHGRFKNHLQ*UXQGIU LKQJHZHVHQDXIVHLQH)UDJH]XYHU]LFKWHQ ³'DQQ ZLVVHQ 6LH LQ]ZLVFKHQ ZHU RGHU ZDV GDIU YHUDQWZRUWOLFK LVW GD DOOH :HOWKLQXQGZLHGHUYHUUFNWVSLHOW"´ ³:LU KDEHQ ]X WXQ´ HUZLGHUWH 0LQJRU DEZHLVHQG ³:UGHQ 6LH GDUDXI ELWWH 5FNVLFKW QHKPHQ" 6RQVW VHKH LFK PLFK JH]ZXQJHQ 6LH ZLHGHU LQ ,KUH .DELQH ]XUFN]XVFKLFNHQ(QWVFKHLGHQ6LHVHOEVWZLHEHTXHP6LHHVDQ%RUGKDEHQZROOHQ´ $WODQGHXWHWHHLQH9HUEHXJXQJDQ(UOlFKHOWHVS|WWLVFK ³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lKUHQG GHV /LQHDUIOXJVNHLQH$PRNOlXIHU]XEHIUFKWHQZDUHQ'DVHUNDQQWHGHU7HUUDQHULQGLHVHQ 6HNXQGHQXQGHUEHJULIIDXFKZHOFKH.RQVHTXHQ]GLHVH7DWVDFKHKDEHQPXWH &D0LQJRUVFKZLHJ (UKDWWHNHLQH%HZHLVHIUVHLQH$QQDKPHXQGHUZROOWHNHLQH'LVNXVVLRQHQPLW 6¶9DQJRU%UDGG6LHEUDFKWHQMHW]WGRFKQLFKWVHLQ :RUWORVZHFKVHOWHHULQGLH)XQNOHLW]HQWUDOHKLQEHU8QZLOONUOLFKDWPHWHHUDXI DOVHU3HWUD$ONDYRUGHQ0RQLWRUHQVLW]HQVDK-HGHU6FKULWW$WODQVZXUGHEHUZDFKW ³,VWHWZDV$XIIlOOLJHVSDVVLHUW"´IUDJWHHUNKO ³1LFKWV´HQWJHJQHWHGHU)XQNRIIL]LHU³(UEHQLPPWVLFKDEHUDOVJHK|UHLKPGDV 6FKLII´ (UODFKWHNRSIVFKWWHOQG ³'DV 9HUEOIIHQGH LVW GD GLH PHLVWHQ 0lQQHU VFKQHOOHU XQG NRQ]HQWULHUWHU DUEHLWHQZHQQHUDXIWDXFKW´ 0LQJRUOlFKHOWHJHTXlOW ³'DV OLHJW YHUPXWOLFK GDUDQ GD VLH VLFK GDQQ GXUFK XQV EHREDFKWHW ZLVVHQ´ VDJWHHUDEHUHUVSUWHGDHVQLFKWVRZDU$OOHZXWHQZHUGLHVHU$WODQZDU(VZDU HLQ )HKOHU YRQ LKP JHZHVHQ GLHVHQ 0DQQ IUHL LP 6FKLII KHUXPODXIHQ ]X ODVVHQ -HW]W ZDUHV]XVSlWGLHHLQPDOHUWHLOWH*HQHKPLJXQJUFNJlQJLJ]XPDFKHQ ³9LHOOHLFKW ZlUH HV JDQ] JXW LKQ ZLHGHU LQ GLH .DELQH ]X VFKLFNHQ´ VDJWH HU QDFKGHQNOLFK³$FKWHQ6LHQRFKJHQDXHUDXIGDVZDVHUPDFKW:HQQHUXQVLUJHQGZR EHKLQGHUWGDQQLQIRUPLHUHQ6LHPLFKVRIRUW´ ³,FKZHUGH,KQHQDXJHQEOLFNOLFK%HVFKHLGJHEHQ´ 0LQJRUQLFNWHGHP2IIL]LHU]XXQGNHKUWHLQGLH=HQWUDOH]XUFN (UZDUXP6HNXQGHQ]XIUKJHJDQJHQVRQVWKlWWHHUHWZDVEHPHUNWZDVLKP
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
LQWHUHVVDQWH$XIVFKOVVHEHUVHLQHQ*HIDQJHQHQKlWWHJHEHQN|QQHQ
$WODQERJLQHLQHQODQJHQ*DQJHLQGHUYRQGHP$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWDXIGHP'HFN ELVDQGLH3HULSKHULHGHV6FKLIIHVIKUWH(WZDIQI]HKQ0lQQHUDUEHLWHQKLHUGDUDQ 6FKlGHQ ]X EHKHEHQ GLH GDGXUFK HQWVWDQGHQ ZDUHQ GD MHPDQG PLW HLQHP (QHUJLHVWUDKOHUXPVLFKJHVFKRVVHQKDWWH 'HU $UNRQLGH EOLHE VRIRUW VWHKHQ DOV HU HUNDQQWH GD HU DQ GLHVHQ 7HIURGHUQ QLFKW YRUEHLNDP RKQH VLH DXI]XKDOWHQ (U GUHKWH VLFK XP XQG ZROOWH ]XP $QWLJUDYVFKDFKW]XUFNNHKUHQDOVVHLQ%OLFNLQGHQJHJHQEHUOLHJHQGHQ*DQJILHO (LQH DEJHPDJHUWH *HVWDOW NDXHUWH GRUW DXI GHP %RGHQ GHQ YHUNUPPWHQ 5FNHQ JHJHQGLH :DQG JHOHKQW 6LH WUXJ HLQHJUQH .RPELQDWLRQ GLH LKU YLHO]XZHLW ZDU'LH+lQGHVWULFKHQLPPHUZLHGHUGXUFKGDVZHLH+DDU 5DVFKJLQJHUDXIGHQDOWHQ]X (UEOLFNWH]XP5RERWHU]XUFN'HU$XWRPDWVFKLHQQLFKWJHPHUNW]XKDEHQGD HUVLFKDQGHUVHQWVFKLHGHQKDWWH(UULFKWHWHVHLQH/LQVHQLPPHUQRFKLQGHQ*DQJLQ GHPGLH7HIURGHUDUEHLWHWHQ $WODQEHJULII 'HU XQEHNDQQWH /HQNHU GHU 0DVFKLQH JDE LKP VR VHKU GHXWOLFK ]X YHUVWHKHQ GDHUMHW]WXQEHREDFKWHWZDU 9RUGHP$OWHQNQLHWHHUQLHGHU ³+DOOR´VDJWHHUOHLVH 'HU 0DQQ UHDJLHUWH QLFKW 8QXQWHUEURFKHQ IXKU HU VLFK PLW GHQ )LQJHUQ GXUFKV +DDU6HLQH/LSSHQEHZHJWHQVLFKHLQZHQLJ ³+DOOR$OWHU´ZLHGHUKROWH$WODQ*OHLFK]HLWLJOHJWHHU GHP7HIURGHUGLH+DQGDQ GLH 6FKXOWHU -HW]W KRE GHU *UHLV GHQ .RSI 'LH $XJHQ VWDUUWHQ LKQ QLFKW DQ VRQGHUQ VFKLHQHQ GXUFK LKQ KLQGXUFK LQ XQHQGOLFKH )HUQH ]X VHKHQ 'HQQRFK JHZDQQ GHU $UNRQLGH GHQ (LQGUXFN GD GHU 0DQQ VLFK LQWHQVLY EHPKWH VLFK DXI LKQ ]X NRQ]HQWULHUHQ ,Q GHP DOWHQ *HVLFKW DUEHLWHWH HV GHXWOLFK 9HUHLQ]HOWH KDOEHUVWLFNWH /DXWHXQWHUVWULFKHQGHQ(LQGUXFN :DVLVWGHQQ"IUDJWHGHU8QVWHUEOLFKH³$OWHUVLHKPLFKDQ´ (UJULIIQDFKGHP.LQQGHV7HIURGHUVXQGKREVHLQHQ.RSI'DQQEHJULIIHU'HU $OWH ZDU QLFKW LQ GHU /DJH VLFK QRUPDO ]X YHUKDOWHQ (U XQWHUODJ HLQHP (LQIOX GHU VHLQHJHVXQGHQJHLVWLJHQ$QODJHQHUGUFNWH ,UUWXP PHOGHWH VLFK GDV ([WUDKLUQ (V LVW JHQDX XPJHNHKUW 'LHVHU 0DQQ LVW JHLVWHVNUDQN(UEHQ|WLJWGDVZDVGLHDQGHUHQDPRNODXIHQOlWXPZLHHLQ*HVXQGHU UHDJLHUHQ]XN|QQHQ $WODQ ULFKWHWH VLFK DXI /DQJVDP JLQJ HU ]X VHLQHP 5RERWHU (V KDWWH NHLQHQ 6LQQ PLW GHP .UDQNHQ UHGHQ ]X ZROOHQ (U GXUIWH NHLQ XQQ|WLJHV 5LVLNR HLQJHKHQ 9LHOPHKU PXWH HU VWlQGLJ GDPLW UHFKQHQ GD GHU /HQNHU GHV 5RERWHUV LQ MHGHP 0RPHQWGD]XJH]ZXQJHQVHLQNRQQWHGLH%HREDFKWXQJVLQVWUXPHQWHZLHGHUDXILKQ]X ULFKWHQ 6REDOG &D 0LQJRU EHL LKP DP 0RQLWRU HUVFKLHQ NRQQWH HU QLFKW PHKU VR KDQGHOQ ZLH HU ZROOWH 'HU 7HUUDQHU EUDXFKWH DEHU QLFKW XQEHGLQJW ]X EHPHUNHQ ZHOFKH%HREDFKWXQJHUJHPDFKWKDWWH $WODQGDFKWHDQGLH(UHLJQLVVHGHUOHW]WHQ:RFKHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
$XI .RHWDQRU'HOS HLQHP HQWIHUQWHQ 3ODQHWHQ ZDUHQ DXV GHP 1LFKWV KHUDXV 7UPPHUPDVVHQ HUVFKLHQHQ GLH GLH 'LPHQVLRQHQ YRQ JDQ]HQ *HELUJV]XJHQ KDWWHQ 8QWHULKUHP(LQIOXKDWWHHUGLH.RQWUROOHEHUVLFKVHOEVWYHUORUHQ,UJHQGHWZDVKDWWH VLFK EHU VHLQHQ *HLVW JHOHJW XQG GLH '\QDPLN VHLQHU 3HUV|QOLFKNHLW HUVWLFNW (U ZDU QLFKWPHKULQGHU/DJHJHZHVHQVRDNWLYXQGORJLVFKZLHVRQVW]XKDQGHOQ'LH0DVVHQ YRQ.RHWDQRU'HOSKDWWHQLKQOHWKDUJLVFKJHPDFKW 5HDJLHUWH GLH 0DQQVFKDIW GHU $192< QLFKW LQ YHUJOHLFKEDUHU :HLVH DOOHUGLQJV JHQDXNRQWUlU" :LHGHUXPPXWHHUDQ36,0DWHULHGHQNHQ /RJLVFK VWLPPWH VHLQ ([WUDKLUQ ]X 'LH 5HDNWLRQHQ YRQ .RHWDQRU'HOS XQWHUODJHQ GHQ %HGLQJXQJHQ GHV 1RUPDO.RQWLQXXPV GLH DXI GHU $192< GHQHQ GHV /LQHDUUDXPV $WODQ VWLHJ LQ GHQ $QWLJUDYVFKDFKW (LQ 0DQQ GUlQJWH VLFK LKP ]X EHYRUGHU 5RERWHU IROJHQ NRQQWH 'DEHL GUHKWH HU VLFK KDOE ]X GHP :lFKWHU ]XUFN =XUFNEOLFNHQG EHPHUNWH GHU $UNRQLGH GD GHU $XWRPDW DEHUPDOV DXI GHP 3ODW] YHUKDUUWHXQGVLFKQLFKWGDUXPNPPHUWHGDHUVLFKYRQLKPHQWIHUQWH ³(QGOLFK´ VDJWH GHU 0DQQ QHEHQ LKP ³,FK KDWWH ]LHPOLFKH 0KH ELV LFK 6LH LQ HLQHU YHUWUHWEDUHQ 6LWXDWLRQ HUZLVFKWH 0HLQ 1DPH LVW
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³6LH PHLQHQ GLH 7DWVDFKH GD ZLU DOOH YHUUFNW VSLHOHQ VREDOG GLH $192< LP 1RUPDONRQWLQXXPLVW"´ ³6LHKDEHQHVHUUDWHQ´ ³,UJHQGZLHZHUGHQZLUGDV3UREOHPO|VHQ/DVVHQ6LHGDVXQVHUH6RUJHVHLQ´ ³6LHLUUHQVLFK
&D0LQJRUXQG6¶9DQJRU%UDGGIXKUHQ]XVDPPHQLQGHQJU|WHQ7UDQVSRUWUDXP KLQXQWHU XP GLH ,HW]WHQ .RQWUROODUEHLWHQ GHU :LVVHQVFKDIWOHU XQG OQJHQLHXUH ]X YHUIROJHQ $OVVLHGLH+DOOH EHWUDWHQ YHUVWXPPWHQ GLH5XIHGHU0lQQHU0LQJRUEHDFKWHWH VLH QLFKW (U EOLFNWH DXI GDV PDWW VFKLPPHUQGH (QHUJLHIHOG GDV GHQ NHJHOI|UPLJHQ %HKlOWHU XPVFKOR 'HXWOLFK NRQQWH HU GDV 2EMHNW VHKHQ GDV LKQHQ VRYLHO .RSI]HUEUHFKHQPDFKWH (LQHU GHU :LVVHQVFKDIWOHU NDP ]X LKQHQ (V ZDU HLQ KDJHUHU 7HIURGHU PLW WLHIOLHJHQGHQGXQNOHQ$XJHQ ³:DVKDEHQ6LHKHUDXVJHIXQGHQ"´IUDJWHGHU7HUUDQHU ³1LFKWV´HQWJHJQHWHGHU6SH]LDOLVW³(VVLHKWJDQ]VRDXVDOVZlUHDOOHVQRFKLQ 2UGQXQJ0LWXQVHUHQ,QVWUXPHQWHQOlWVLFKMHGHQIDOOVNHLQ6FKDGHQIHVWVWHOOHQ´ ³'DQQZUGHQ6LHDOVRVDJHQ'D+DI¶NDWKGDKLHUDOOHVLQ2UGQXQJLVW"´IUDJWH GHU.RPPDQGDQW 'HU:LVVHQVFKDIWOHUVHQNWHEHVWlWLJHQGGHQ.RSI ³:LUZLVVHQ]XZHQLJXP%HZHLVHHUEULQJHQ]XN|QQHQ´HUNOlUWHHU³-HGHQIDOOV VLQG GLH 6FKXW]KOOHQ QLFKW EHVFKlGLJW ZRUGHQ 8QVHUH 8QWHUVXFKXQJHQ EHVWlWLJHQ GDGLHVHV'LQJPLWGHQ$PRNOlXIHQQLFKWV]XWXQKDEHQNDQQ:LUKRIIHQDOOHGDZLU
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
XQVQLFKWJHLUUWKDEHQ´ ³:LHKRFKLVWGLH:DKUVFKHLQOLFKNHLWGD,KUH$XVVDJHULFKWLJLVW¶"´ ³,FK ZUGH VDJHQ HWZD VLHE]LJ 3UR]HQW´ HUZLGHUWH GHU ,QJHQLHXU DXI GLH )UDJH VHLQHV.RPPDQGDQWHQ³0HKUQLFKWDEHUDXFKQLFKWZHQLJHU´ &D 0LQJRU ZDQGWH VLFK PUULVFK DE (U ZDU XQ]XIULHGHQ 6HLQHU 0HLQXQJ QDFK ZDUGDV5HVXOWDWGHUODQJHQ8QWHUVXFKXQJHQZHUWORV'DPLWEOLHEZHLWHUKLQRIIHQZDV GLH 2UGQXQJ DQ %RUG GHU $192< GXUFKHLQDQGHUEUDFKWH VREDOG VLH GHQ /LQHDUUDXP YHUOLH (UEOLFNWHDXIVHLQ&KURQRPHWHU
1RFK]HKQ0LQXWHQ'DQQZUGHGDV&KDRVHUQHXWEHJLQQHQ
$WODQEHREDFKWHWH1XUDP\VHKUJHQDX (UZROOWHQLFKWQRFKHLQPDOEHUUDVFKWZHUGHQ(UZXWHGDGLH$192<EDOG ZLHGHULQGHQ/LQHDUUDXPJHKHQZUGH'DQQZUGHVLFKDXFKGDV9HUKDOWHQGHV 0lGFKHQVZLHGHUlQGHUQ (UEOLFNWHDXIVHLQ&KURQRPHWHU (V]HLJWHGHQ0lU]DQhEHU]HKQ7DJHZDUHVMHW]WVFKRQKHUVHLWGHP VLHYRQGHP3ODQHWHQ)RUPDUJHVWDUWHWZDUHQ 3O|W]OLFKEHZHJWHVLFKGHU5RERWHULQGHU(FNH ³=ZHL0LQXWHQQRFK´VDJWHHUODXWXQGGHXWOLFK³,FKZHUGHGHQ5REVWLOOHJHQ GDPLWQLFKWVSDVVLHUW´ 8QZLOONUOLFKGUHKWHVLFK$WODQ]XGHU0DVFKLQHXP6LHVWDQGXQEHZHJOLFKLP 5DXP1LFKWVDQLKUOLHHUNHQQHQLQZHOFKHP=XVWDQGVLHVLFKEHIDQG+DWWHGHU %HREDFKWHULQGHU)XQN]HQWUDOHVFKRQGHQ%HIHKOJHJHEHQDXIGHQHUZDUWHWH" (UYHUIROJWHGHQ6HNXQGHQ]HLJHUDXIVHLQHP&KURQRPHWHU'LH0HOGXQJZDU NRUUHNWJHZHVHQ$OVGLH]ZHL0LQXWHQDEJHODXIHQZDUHQYHUZDQGHOWHVLFKGLH$NRQLQ VFKODJDUWLJLQHLQHDQJULIIVOXVWLJH.lPSIHULQ(UVDKZLHVLFKLKU.|USHUVWUDIIWHXQGZLH GLH0XVNHOQVLFKVSDQQWHQ%HYRUVLHVLFKMHGRFKDXILKQZHUIHQNRQQWHKDWWHHULKU VFKRQGLH'DXPHQDQGHQ+DOVJHVHW]W0LWHLQHPHQWVFKORVVHQHQ5XFNEORFNLHUWHHU GLH1HUYHQEDKQHQ6HXI]HQGVDQNGDV0lGFKHQLQVHLQHQ$UPHQ]XVDPPHQ (UYHUORUNHLQH=HLW(UOHJWHVLHDXIHLQH6FKZHEHXQGYHUVXFKWHGDQDFKVRIRUW GLH7U]X|IIQHQ$OVHUHVEHLQDKHJHVFKDIIWKDWWHIORJVLHYRQVHOEVWDXI 'HU$OWHGHULKQSDUDO\VLHUWKDWWHVWDQGYRULKP8QGZLHGHUXPKLHOWHUHLQH :DIIHLQGHQ+lQGHQ%HYRU$WODQHWZDVVDJHQNRQQWHZDUIHULKPGHQ%ODVWHU]X ³6FKQHOO´VDJWHGHU$OWHNHXFKHQG³6FKQHOOJHKHQ6LH]XU=HQWUDOHKLQDXI'LH $192<UDVWDXIHLQH6RQQH]XXQGGDREHQLVWQLHPDQGGHUVLHMHW]WQRFKUHWWHQ N|QQWH'LH,GLRWHQPDFKHQDOOHVIDOVFK´ $WODQ]XFNWH]XVDPPHQ 'HU7HIURGHUNRQQWHQLFKWZLVVHQGDHUDOOHLQDXFKNHLQH0|JOLFKNHLWKDWWHHLQ 6FKLIIYRQGHQ'LPHQVLRQHQGHU$192<]XOHQNHQ2KQHHLQJHVSLHOWH0DQQVFKDIWZDU HVXQP|JOLFKHLQHQVROFKHQ.ROR]XVWHXHUQ:HQQGHU$XWRSLORWHVQLFKWVHOEVW VFKDIIWHZDUHQVLHYHUORUHQ(UNRQQWHVLFKOHGLJOLFKEHPKHQ)HKOVFKDOWXQJHQ]X YHUKWHQXQGEHUHLWVHLQJHOHLWHWH)DOVFKSURJUDPPLHUXQJHQUFNJlQJLJ]XPDFKHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³,FKNPPHUHPLFKGDUXP´YHUVSUDFKHUXQGOLHIDQGHP$OWHQYRUEHL'DQQ EOLHEHUQRFKHLQPDOVWHKHQXQGGUHKWHVLFK]XLKPXP³8QGNRPPHQ6LHQLFKWQRFK HLQPDODXIGHQ*HGDQNHQPLFKQLHGHU]XVFKLHHQ'DVZUGH,KQHQQLFKWJXW EHNRPPHQ´ 'HU7HIURGHUNLFKHUWHDOVKDEH$WODQHLQHQ:LW]JHPDFKW(UVFKLHQEHUKDXSW QLFKW]XEHJUHLIHQZRYRQGHU$UNRQLGHJHVSURFKHQKDWWH0LWWUEHQ$XJHQEOLFNWHHU LKPQDFKDOVHU]XP$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWVWUPWH$WODQNRUULJLHUWHVHLQHQHUVWHQ(LQGUXFN 'HU*UHLVZDULP/LQHDUUDXPQLFKWY|OOLJQRUPDODEHUHUZDUEHGHXWHQGZHQLJHUJHVW|UW DOVLP(LQVWHLQ.RQWLQXXP $P$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWVWDQGHLQ5RERWHU $WODQV*OFNZDUGDHUVHLQHQ6WUDKOHUEHUHLWVVFKXEHUHLWHUKREHQKDWWHDOV HUVLFKLKPQlKHUWHGHQQSO|W]OLFKUXFNWHQGLH:DIIHQDUPHGHV$XWRPDWHQQDFKREHQ 'HU$UNRQLGHIHXHUWHVRIRUW 'HU(QHUJLHVWUDKOWUDIGDVSRVLWURQLVFKH=HQWUXPGHV5RERWHUVQDFKGHPHUGLH ]XVFKZDFKHQHQHUJHWLVFKHQ6FKUDQNHQGDYRUGXUFKVFKODJHQKDWWH'HU 0HWDOOHQHPDFKWHHLQLJHXQJHOHQNH%HZHJXQJHQEHXJWHVLFKGDQQQDFKYRUQXQGUDVWH PLWGHP.RSI]XHUVWJHJHQHLQH:DQG'DPLWJDEHUVLFKVHOEVWGHQ5HVW(UILHODXI GHQ%RGHQ6HLQHNXU]JHVFKORVVHQHQ6FKDOWXQJHQ]ZDQJHQLKQ]XHLQHU5HLKHYRQ VLQQORVHQ%HZHJXQJHQ $WODQVFKZHEWHLP6FKDFKWQDFKREHQ :HLWXQWHUVLFKEHPHUNWHHUHLQLJH0lQQHUGLHDXIHLQDQGHUHLQVFKULHQ(UNRQQWH LKUH:RUWHQLFKWYHUVWHKHQ ,QQHUKDOEZHQLJHU0LQXWHQHUUHLFKWHHUGLH+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOH$OVHUGXUFKGDV JURH(LQJDQJVVFKRWWWUDWVSUDQJLKQHLQXQWHUVHW]WHU7HIURGHUDQ(UZDUDXIHLQHQ GHUDUWLJHQ$QJULIIJHIDWXQGNRQQWHLKQGDKHUVRIRUWSDULHUHQ0LWHLQHP'DJKRU*ULII HUOHGLJWHHUGHQ*HJQHU.DXPKDWWHHUGDVJHVFKDIIWDOVHLQ]ZHLWHU0DQQPLWHLQHP (QHUJLHVWUDKOHUDXILKQVFKR 'HU(QHUJLHVWUDKO]XFNWHVHQJHQGKHLDQVHLQHU6FKXOWHUYRUEHL $WODQVSUDQJPLWHLQHPPlFKWLJHQ6DW]LQGLH=HQWUDOHKLQHLQ+LQWHULKPJOLWWHQ GLH6FKRWWH]XVDPPHQ'HUQlFKVWH6FKXOLHVLHDXIJOKHQXQGWHLOZHLVH ]HUVFKPHO]HQHUKDWWHNHLQH=HLWVLFKGDUXP]XNPPHUQGHQQGLH=HQWUDOHJOLFK HLQHP7ROOKDXV2IIL]LHUHXQG$GMXWDQWHQEHNlPSIWHQHLQDQGHU(LQLJH0lQQHUXQWHU LKQHQ&D0LQJRUYHUVXFKWHQDQGHUHYRQGHQ6FKDOWXQG.RQWUROOElQNHQIHUQ]XKDOWHQ 6¶9DQJRU%UDGGEHPKWHVLFKYHUJHEOLFKGHQ3LORWHQDXVVHLQHP6LW]]X]HUUHQ$OV LKQHLQ6FKODJDP.RSIWUDIVDFNWHHULQGLH.QLH ³=XUFNLQGHQ/LQHDUUDXP´IRUPXOLHUWHHUNHXFKHQGXQGNDXPYHUVWlQGOLFK ³/LQHDUUDXP´ 'LHXQKHLOYROOH0DFKWGLHGDV6FKLIIXQGVHLQH%HVDW]XQJEHHLQIOXWHHUZLHV VLFKDOVVWlUNHU'HU.RPPDQGDQWUROOWHEHUGHQ%RGHQXQGKlPPHUWHPLWGHU)DXVW JHJHQHLQ7LVFKEHLQ(UPHUNWHQLFKWGDHUVLFKGDEHLGLH.Q|FKHOEOXWLJVFKOXJ $XIHLQHQ%OLFNHUNDQQWH$WODQZLHZLFKWLJHVZDUGHQ.XUV]XlQGHUQ'LH $192<UDVWH]ZDUQLFKWPLWWHQLQHLQH6RQQHKLQHLQDEHUDXILKUHP.XUVODJHLQ6WHUQ GHPVLHEHGURKOLFKQDKHNRPPHQZUGHZHQQQLFKWHWZDVJHVFKDK (UZROOWHDXIGLH]HQWUDOH6WHXHUXQJ]XHLOHQXPGHQ$XWRSLORWHQ]XEHUSUIHQ DOVKLQWHUHLQHU6lXOHHLQ.DPSIURERWHUKHUYRUWUDW(LVLJHU6FKUHFNHQGXUFKIXKULKQDOV GLH:DIIHQDUPHKRFKUXFNWHQ2EZRKOHUVHLQHQ6WUDKOHULQGHU+DQGKDWWHPXWHHU
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
JHJHQGLHVH0DVFKLQH]XODQJVDPVHLQ (UQXW]WHGLHHLQ]LJH&KDQFHGLHHUKDWWH(UOLHVLFK]X%RGHQIDOOHQXQGJHULHW GDPLWLQGLH'HFNXQJHLQHV&RPSXWHUV'HU$XWRPDWYHU]LFKWHWHXQWHUGLHVHQ 8PVWlQGHQGDUDXIVRIRUW]XIHXHUQ$WODQK|UWHVHLQH6FKULWWHGLHVLFKLKPVFKQHOO QlKHUWHQ6RVFKQHOOZLHHUQXUNRQQWHNURFKHU]XUDQGHUHQ6HLWHZHJUROOWHVLFK GDQQXPHLQH(FNHKHUXPXQGJHULHWHLQHP7HIURGHU]ZLVFKHQGLH)H'HU0DQQ VFKULHDXIZDUIGLH$UPHKRFKXQGVWROSHUWHXEHULKQKLQZHJ 'HU$UNRQLGHQXW]WHGHQZLQ]LJHQ9RUWHLO(UVFKQHOOWHVLFK]XHLQHP.DUWHQWLVFK KLQEHUXQGJLQJKLQWHULKPLQ'HFNXQJ0LWEHEHQGHQ+lQGHQPDFKWHHUVHLQH:DIIH VFKXEHUHLW'DQQULFKWHWHHUVLFKDXIXQGVFKR 'HU.DPSIURERWHUHQWGHFNWHLKQ]XVSlW'HU(QHUJLHVWUDKOWUDILKQXQGO|VWHLQ VHLQHP,QQHUQJHUDGH]XHLQ*HZLWWHUYRQHOHNWULVFKHQ(QWODGXQJHQDXV%ODXH 6WLFKIODPPHQVFKRVVHQNQDWWHUQGGXUFK6SDOWHQLQVHLQHU3DQ]HUXQJ (LQHUGHU2IIL]LHUHNDP$WODQ]XU+LOIH²VLFKHUOLFKXQJHZROOW(UO|VWHVHLQH:DIIH HEHQIDOOVDXIGHQ5RERWHUDXVXQGHUOHGLJWHGHQ5HVW$WODQVDKGDV=XFNHQXQG /HXFKWHQLP*HVLFKWGHV0DQQHV0LWHLVLJHP6FKUHFNHQHUNDQQWHHUGDGLHVHU 2IIL]LHUNHLQHUOHL.RQWUROOHEHUVLFKVHOEVWKDWWH,PQDFKVWHQ$XJHQEOLFNNRQQWHHU DXFKLKQDQJUHLIHQ $WODQEOLFNWH]XGHQ.RQWUROOVFKLUPHQKLQEHU 'HU.XUVGHU$192<KDWWHVLFKOHLFKWJHlQGHUW'DV6FKLIIVWUHEWHDXIGLH6RQQH ]X6LHUFNWHODQJVDPDEHUVWHWLJDXIGHQ=LHOSXQNWDXIGHQ%LOGVFKLUPHQ]X(LQH JDQ]H.DVNDGHYRQURWHQ:DUQOLFKWHUQEHUVFKZHPPWHGLH6WHXHUElQNH´ :HQQQLFKWEDOGHWZDVJHVFKDKZDUHV]XVSlW (UYHUOLHVHLQH'HFNXQJXQGQl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|UWH REZRKOLKPVFKLHQGDVLFKLKP6FKULWWHQlKHUWHQ(UHQWVFKORVLFK]XP$QJULIIXQG VSUDQJVRIRUW'LH:DIIHUXFNWHKHUXP)UHLQHQ6HNXQGHQEUXFKWHLOVWDUUWH$WODQLQGDV 3URMHNWLRQVIHOG'DQQIXKUVHLQH)DXVWKRFKXQGVFKOXJGHQ%ODVWHU]XU6HLWH6HLQH JHVWUHFNWHOLQNH+DQGVWDFKGHP*HJQHULQGLH0DJHQJUXEH(UWUDIGHQULFKWLJHQ3XQNW XQGVFKDOWHWHGHQ0DQQGDPLWDXV'LHKHUDEIDOOHQGH:DIIHQDKPHUDXIXQGVFKREVLH LQVHLQHQ*UWHO'DQQHUVWGUHKWHHUVLFKXP (UOHLFKWHUWDWPHWHHUDXI 'LHPHLVWHQ2IIL]LHUHVFKLHQHQVLFKEHUHLWVDXVJHWREW]XKDEHQ(LQLJHVWDQGHQ QRFKDXIGHQ%HLQHQXQGNlPSIWHQPLWVLFKXQGGHUIUHPGHQ0DFKWGLHLKQHQGDV &KDRVDXI]ZLQJHQZROOWH$WODQHULQQHUWHVLFKGDUDQGDHVLKPVHOEVWDXFK
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
ZHLWJHKHQGJHOXQJHQZDUGLH$SDWKLH]XEHUZLQGHQGLHLKQDXI.RHWDQRU'HOS EHUIDOOHQKDWWH%LV]XHLQHPJHZLVVHQ*UDGHKDWWHHUVLFKKDOWHQN|QQHQGDQQDEHU ZDUGLH6WUDKOXQJVWlUNHUJHZRUGHQXQGHUZDU]XVDPPHQJHEURFKHQ (QWVFKORVVHQHLOWHHUDXIGLH.RQWUROOElQNH]X(UYHUVXFKWHVLFK]XRULHQWLHUHQ -HOlQJHUHUVLFKEHPKWHHLQHJHZLVVH2UGQXQJ]XILQGHQGHVWRJHULQJHUZXUGHVHLQH +RIIQXQJGDV6FKLIIQRFKDEIDQJHQ]XN|QQHQ%OLQGZWLJKDWWHQGLH2IIL]LHUHDOOH .Q|SIHJHGUFNWGLHVLHKDWWHQILQGHQN|QQHQ:DKUVFKHLQOLFKKDWWHQVLHGDPLWHLQHQ JURHQ7HLOGHUSRVLWURQLVFKHQ$XVUVWXQJ]HUVW|UW'HU$XWRSLORWDUEHLWHWHQLFKWPHKU GDHUNHLQH$QZHLVXQJHQHUKDOWHQKDWWHGHQHQHUIROJHQNRQQWH(UNRQQWHGDV6FKLII QLFKW]XJOHLFKLQPHKUHUHHQWJHJHQJHVHW]WH5LFKWXQJHQOHQNHQ'HUDUWZLGHUVSUFKOLFKH %HIHKOHNRQQWHHUQXUGDGXUFKEHDQWZRUWHQGDHUVLFKVHOEVWDXVVFKDOWHWH $WODQGUFNWHHLQH5HLKHYRQ.Q|SIHQXQG7DVWHQ(UOHJWHHLQLJH+DXSWKHEHO XPGLHHUDOV]HQWUDOH'LULJHQWHQLGHQWLIL]LHUHQNRQQWH(UKRIIWHGDGLHDQIlQJOLFKH +DXSWSURJUDPPLHUXQJQLFKWDXFKJHO|VFKWZRUGHQZDU6ROOWHGDVGHU)DOOVHLQKDWWHQ VLHSUDNWLVFKNHLQH&KDQFHPHKU(UNRQQWHYHUVXFKHQGHQ$XWRSLORWHQZLHGHU]X DNWLYLHUHQXPPLWVHLQHU+LOIHGLH$192<DQGHU6RQQHYRUEHL]XEULQJHQ*HODQJHV LKPQLFKWGLHVHQSRVLWURQLVFKHQ3DUWQHU]XILQGHQGDQQNRQQWHHUJOHLFKDXIJHEHQ(LQ DFKWKXQGHUW0HWHUGXUFKPHVVHQGHV5DXPVFKLIINRQQWHXQWHUJDUNHLQHQ8PVWlQGHQ YRQHLQHPHLQ]LJHQ0DQQJHIORJHQZHUGHQ ,PPHUZLHGHUEOLFNWHHU]XGHQ%LOGVFKLUPHQDXI'LH$192<QlKHUWHVLFKGHU 6RQQHLQHLQHUVWHLOHUZHUGHQGHQ.XUYH'LH$EZHLFKXQJYRQLKUHPXUVSUQJOLFKHQ .XUV]HLFKQHWHVLFKYRQ0LQXWH]X0LQXWHGHXWOLFKHUDE=XJOHLFKVFKLHQVLFKLKUH *HVFKZLQGLJNHLWLPPHUPHKU]XYHUULQJHUQ $OOPlKOLFKJHZDQQ$WODQHLQHQEHVVHUHQhEHUEOLFN'LH/DJHQRUPDOLVLHUWHVLFK ODQJVDP'LH)OXWGHUURWHQ/LFKWHUHUORVFKXQGGDPLWZDUGLHHUVWHXQGJU|WH.ULVH ]XQlFKVWEHUZXQGHQ (UEOLFNWHVLFKHUQHXWXP &D0LQJRUVWDQGHLQLJH6FKULWWHKLQWHULKP(UVWW]WHVLFKDQHLQHQELV]XU'HFNH UDJHQGHQ&RPSXWHU0LWEOXWXQWHUODXIHQHQ$XJHQVWDUUWHHULKQDQ(UPDFKWHGHQ (LQGUXFNHLQHV%HWUXQNHQHQ 'HU$UNRQLGHHUNDQQWHGDGHU7HUUDQHUDQJUHLIHQZROOWH(VZUGHMHGRFKQRFK HWZDV=HLWYHUJHKHQELVHUGD]XLQGHU/DJHZDU$WODQQXW]WHGLH)ULVWXPHLQLJH lXHUVWZLFKWLJH6FKDOWXQJHQYRU]XQHKPHQ,PPHUZLHGHUEOLFNWHHUKRFK,P VSLHJHOQGHQ0DWHULDOHLQLJHU,QVWUXPHQWHNRQQWHHU0LQJRUVHKHQ(QGOLFKIODPPWHGDV EODXH/LFKWGHV$XWRSLORWHQDXI6HNXQGHQVSlWHUEUDQQWHQ]DKOUHLFKHJUQH/lPSFKHQ DXIGHP.RQWUROOERUG(UKDWWH]XPLQGHVWGHQHUVWHQZLFKWLJVWHQ6FKULWWJHVFKDIIW-HW]W NDPDOOHVDXIGLHXUVSUQJOLFKH3URJUDPPLHUXQJDQ6WLPPWHVLHQLFKWPHKUZDUDOOHV XPVRQVWJHZHVHQ 'DJULII0LQJRUDQ$WODQUHDJLHUWHHLQHQNXU]HQ0RPHQW]XVSlW'HU7HUUDQHU ODQGHWHDXIVHLQHP5FNHQXQGZDUILKQPLWVHLQHP*HZLFKW]X%RGHQ6HLQH+lQGH JUXEHQVLFKPLWIUFKWHUOLFKHU*HZDOWLQVHLQHQ+DOV0LQJRUVFKLHQVHLQHJDQ]H.UDIW DXIGLHVHQ*ULII]XNRQ]HQWULHUHQDOVREVHLQ/HEHQGDUDQKLQJH $WODQERJLKPGLH)LQJHUDXVHLQDQGHU1RUPDOHUZHLVHJHQJWGDVHLQHVROFKH $WWDFNHDE]XZHKUHQ0LQJRUOLHVLFKMHGRFKQLFKWEHHLQGUXFNHQ (UVFKLHQGHQ6FKPHU]QLFKW]XIKOHQ $WODQNUPPWHVLFK]XVDPPHQUROOWHVLFK]XU6HLWHXQGKHEHOWHVLFKIUHL'HU
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
7HUUDQHUVFKRZLHHLQ%QGHOJHEDOOWH(QHUJLHYRP%RGHQKRFKXQGSDFNWHLKQ HUQHXW-HW]WDEHUZDUGHU$QJULIIYLHO]XGXUFKVLFKWLJXPHLQHQ0DQQZLH$WODQ JHIlKUGHQ]XN|QQHQ0LWHLQHPEOLW]VFKQHOODQJHVHW]WHQ'DJKRU*ULIIEHUZDQGHUGHQ IHWWHQ7HUUDQHU (UVDKHLQGDHVZHQLJ6LQQKDWWHGDV6FKLIIDXIGHQULFKWLJHQ.XUV]XEULQJHQ ZHQQJOHLFKGDQDFKHLQDPRNODXIHQGHU7HIURGHUDOOH$UEHLWZLHGHU]XQLFKWHPDFKWH 'HVKDOE|IIQHWHHUHLQ6HLWHQVFKRWWGHU=HQWUDOHGDV]XHLQHP.DUWHQ]HQWUXPIKUWH 'DULQZDUJHQXJHQG3ODW](UNHKUWH]XUFNSDFNWH0LQJRUXQGHLQHQDQGHUHQ EHZXWORVHQ7HWURGHUXQGVFKOHSSWHEHLGHKLQDXV'DQDFKVDPPHOWHHUQRFKYLHU ZHLWHUH0lQQHUDXIGLHVLFKJHJHQVHLWLJQLHGHUJHVFKODJHQKDWWHQXQGEHWlXEWHGDQQ PLWVHLQHUDXI3DUDO\VHZLUNXQJXPJHVFKDOWHWHQ:DIIHGLHDQGHUHQ2IIL]LHUH'LHVH 0lQQHUKLHOWHQVLFK]ZDUQRFKLQGHU+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOHDXIDEHUVLHZDUHQQLFKWPHKU DNWLRQVIlKLJ6LHODJHQNDXHUWHQRGHUVDHQDXIGHP%RGHQRGHULQGHQ6HVVHOQ KHUXPZRVLHQDFKLKUHUHUVWHQDJJUHVVLYHQ$NWLRQHUVFK|SIW]XVDPPHQJHEURFKHQ ZDUHQ 'DQQHQGOLFKNRQQWHVLFKGHU/RUGDGPLUDOY|OOLJXQJHVW|UWDXIGLH/HQNXQJGHV 6FKLIIHVNRQ]HQWULHUHQ/lQJVWKDWWHHUEHPHUNWGDGHU7HIURGHUGHULKQQRFKYRUGHU =HQWUDOHDQJHJULIIHQKDWWHVHLQH9HUVXFKHDXIJHJHEHQKDWWHGLH(LQJDQJVVFKRWWH]X ]HUVFKLHHQ9RQGRUWKHUGURKWHNHLQH*HIDKUPHKU 'LH$192<KLHOWQRFKLPPHU.XUVDXIGLH6RQQH -HW]WDEHUEUDFKWH$WODQHQWVFKHLGHQGH2UGQXQJLQGDV6WHXHUXQJVV\VWHP(U KREZLGHUVSUFKOLFKH%HIHKOHDXIXQGJDEQHXH$QZHLVXQJHQHLQELVGHU$XWRSLORW HQGOLFKUHDJLHUWH$WODQDWPHWHDXIDOVHUVDKZLHGLH6RQQHODQJVDPDXVGHP 0LWWHOSXQNWGHU%LOGVFKLUPHUFNWH (UKDWWHHVJHVFKDIIW =XGLHVHP=HLWSXQNWK|UWHHUHQGOLFKGLH6WLPPHGLHDXVHLQHPGHU]DKOUHLFKHQ /DXWVSUHFKHUNODQJ6LFKHUKDWWHHUVLHLP/lUPQLFKWEHDFKWHW -HW]WDEHUZDUHVUXKLJHULQGHU+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOH8QGGHVKDOEZDUGLH6WLPPH DXFKYHUQHKPEDU $WODQEOLFNWHVLFKXP=XQlFKVWXEHUVDKHUGHQ%LOGVFKLUP(UVWDOVHUQlKHUDQ LKQKHUDQWUDWZXUGHHUDXILKQDXIPHUNVDPZHLOHLQURWHV.RQWUROOSQNWFKHQXQWHULKP OHXFKWHWH-HW]WPHUNWHHUGDGLH6WLPPHDXVGHP/DXWVSUHFKHUGLHVHV*HUlWVNDP :DUHVEHVFKlGLJW")XQNWLRQLHUWHGLH%LOGHLQKHLWQLFKW" (UVFKDOWHWHNXU]HQWVFKORVVHQDXIHLQHQDQGHUHQ%LOGVFKLUPXPDXIGHPVLFK ELVGDKLQQRFKGLH6RQQHDEJH]HLFKQHWKDWWH'DV%LOGHUORVFKEHUJDQJVORV'LH 6FKHLEHZXUGHJUDX 'DPLWZXUGHNODUGDGHU6SUHFKHUVLFKQLFKW]HLJHQZROOWH $WODQGUFNWHHLQH7DVWHDQGHU8QWHUVHLWHGHV*HUlWHVZHLOHUGLH6WLPPHQLFKW PHKUK|UWH%LVMHW]WKDWWHHUQLFKWVYRQGHPYHUVWDQGHQZDVGHU8QEHNDQQWHPLWWHLOHQ ZROOWHZHLOHUVLFKQLFKWJHQJHQGDXILKQNRQ]HQWULHUWKDWWH1XQDEHUVFKZLHJGHU DQGHUH ³+LHULVWGLH$192<´VDJWH$WODQ³:HUVSULFKW":UGHQ6LH"³ (UZXUGHXQWHUEURFKHQ'LH6WLPPHNODQJXQDQJHQHKPXQGVXJJHVWLY ³(VZLUGDOOPlKOLFK=HLWGDVLFKMHPDQGPHOGHW(UNOlUHQ6LHPLUVRIRUWZDV JHVFKHKHQLVW´ 'LHVH:RUWHKDWWHQHLQHQDXVJHVSURFKHQGURKHQGHQ.ODQJ$WODQOlFKHOWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
XQEHHLQGUXFNW ³'HU%LOGVFKLUPIXQNWLRQLHUWQLFKW¶HQWJHJQHWHHUJHODVVHQ 'HUDQGHUHYHUVWXPPWHIUHLQHQNXU]HQ0RPHQW'DQQPHOGHWHHUVLFKZLHGHU LQHLQHPHLVNDOWHQ7RQGHUMHGHPDQGHUHQYHUPXWOLFKHLQHQ6FKDXHUGHU)XUFKWEHU GHQ5FNHQJHMDJWKlWWH ³+LHUVSULFKWGHU*UDXH,FKHUZDUWHVRIRUWNODUH,QIRUPDWLRQHQGDUEHUZDV JHVFKHKHQLVW6HLW7DJHQELQLFKRKQH1DFKULFKW6LHZLVVHQJHQDXGDGLH/LHIHUXQJ EHUHLWVEHUIlOOLJLVW´ ³'DVLVWPLUEHZXW´ ³:HLWHUH9HU]|JHUXQJHQZHUGHLFKMHW]WQLFKWPHKUKLQQHKPHQ³ ³'DVLVWEHGDXHUOLFK:LUN|QQHQQLFKWVWXQ:LUPHOGHQXQVZLHGHUZHQQGLH 6W|UXQJHQDQ%RUGEHKREHQVLQG´ (UVFKDOWHWHGDV*HUlWDXVXQGQDKPVHLQHQ)LQJHUYRQGHU2SWLN(UOlFKHOWH 'HUJHKHLPQLVYROOH*UDXHKDWWHLKQHEHQVRZHQLJJHVHKHQZLHHULKQ9HUPXWOLFKKDWWH HUVLFKVHKUJHZXQGHUW(UPRFKWHHLQHGHUDUWLJH+DOWXQJQLFKWJHZRKQWVHLQ $WODQZDUVLFKGDUEHUNODUGDVHLQH)ULVWDEOLHI1DFKGLHVHP*HVSUlFKZUGH GHU*UDXHHLQ9RUDXVNRPPDQGRVFKLFNHQGDVEHUSUIHQVROOWHZDVKLHUJHVFKHKHQ ZDU=XGLHVHP(QWVFKOXZlUHHUYHUPXWOLFKDXFKGDQQJHNRPPHQZHQQ$WODQVLFK QLFKWJHPHOGHWKlWWH 'LH$192<ZDUDOVRQLFKWPHKUZHLWYRQLKUHP=LHOHQWIHUQW'HU*UDXHPXWH GLHXQJHIlKUH3RVLWLRQGHV6FKLIIHVNHQQHQGHQQVRQVWKlWWHHUHVQLFKWSHU+\SHUIXQN HUUHLFKHQN|QQHQ $WODQQDKPHLQLJHZHLWHUHZLFKWLJH6FKDOWXQJHQDQGHQ6WHXHUJHUlWHQYRU'LH 6RQQHZDQGHUWHDXVGHQ%LOGVFKLUPHQ'DPLWZDUNODUGDGLH$192<GLHJHIlKUOLFKH .ULVHEHUZXQGHQKDWWH-HW]WNRQ]HQWULHUWHHUVLFKDXIGLH6XFKHQDFKZLFKWLJHQ'DWHQ LQGHU3RVWWURQLN(UZROOWHZLVVHQZRGLH$192<VLFKEHIDQGXQGREHVHLQH 0|JOLFKNHLWJDEWHUUDQLVFKH+LOIVNUlIWH]XLQIRUPLHUHQ(UHUNDQQWHVHKUVFKQHOOGDHU QLFKWRKQHZHLWHUHVKHUDXVILQGHQZUGHZDQQGHU$XWRSLORWGLHVH)OXJSKDVHEHHQGHQ XQGLQGHQ/LQHDUUDXP]XUFNNHKUHQZUGH(UVDKDXFKNHLQH0|JOLFKNHLWGHQ)OXJ JDQ]]XEHHQGHQ'D]XKlWWHHUZLHGHUXP+LOIVNUlIWHEHQ|WLJW 'LH'DWHQEDQNZDUIHLQH$Q]HLJHDXV(UQDKPVLHDXIXQGODVVLHGXUFK'LH $192<KDWWHVHLWLKUHP6WDUWYRQ)RUPDU/LFKWMDKUHEHUEUFNW (UEHUOHJWH -HW]WPXWHHUVLFKHQWVFKHLGHQ (UNRQQWHYHUVXFKHQHQWZHGHUGDVJDQ]H6FKLIIODKP]XOHJHQRGHUGHQ.HJHOLQ GHQ5DXPKLQDXV]XEHI|UGHUQRGHUYRQGHU)XQNOHLW]HQWUDOHDXV7HUUD]XYHUVWlQGLJHQ (LQHVNRQQWHHUQXU]XU=HLWWXQ(UVWZHQQHUZHQLJVWHQV]ZHLGLHVHU$XIJDEHQHUOHGLJW KDWWHNRQQWHHU1XUDP\]XHLQHP%HLERRWEULQJHQXQGPLWGLHVHPVWDUWHQ2KQH ,QIRUPDWLRQEHULKUHDQQlKHUQGH3RVLWLRQLQQHUKDOEGHU*DOD[LVORV]XIOLHJHQZDU DEVROXWVLQQORV'LHSRVLWURQLVFKHQ(LQULFKWXQJHQGHU%HLERRWHYHUIJWHQQLFKWEHUGDV 'DWHQPDWHULDOGHU+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOHRKQHGDVHUQLFKWVDQIDQJHQNRQQWH 'XUFKHLQ6HLWHQVFKRWWNDPHQ]ZHLEHZDIIQHWH0lQQHUKHUHLQ,KUH8QLIRUPHQ ZDUHQ]HUIHW]W6LHEOXWHWHQDQGHQ+lQGHQXQGLP*HVLFKW
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
'LH EHLGHQ 0lQQHU NLSSWHQ XUSO|W]OLFK QDFK YRUQ 6LH ILHOHQ DXI GDV *HVLFKW RKQHGHQ9HUVXFK]XPDFKHQVLFKDE]XIDQJHQ ,QGHU7UHUVFKLHQGLHJHEHXJWH*HVWDOWGHV*UHLVHV (UJULQVWH$WODQIUHXQGOLFK]X0LWHLQHU+DQGEDODQFLHUWHHUHLQ7DEOHWWGDVDXV HLQHP 6WFN 3ODVWLNPDWHULDO EHVWDQG GDV LUJHQGZR DXV GHU 'HFNHQYHUNOHLGXQJ KHUDXVJHEURFKHQZDU'DUDXIVWDQGHQ]ZHL7DVVHQPLWHLQHUGDPSIHQGHQ)OVVLJNHLW 'HU$OWHQlKHUWHVLFK$WODQPLWWDX]HOQGHQ6FKULWWHQ ³/RUGDGPLUDO´ VDJWH HU NLFKHUQG ³1DFK JHWDQHU $UEHLW VROO PDQ VLFK HUIULVFKHQ 'DUILFK,KQHQHLQHQ6FKOXFNEHVWHQWHUUDQLVFKHQ.DIIHHVDQELHWHQ"´ ³'DQNHJHUQ´ 'HU$UNRQLGHQDKPHLQH7DVVHHQWJHJHQ'HU*UHLVOLHGDV³7DEOHWW¶IDOOHQXQG IKUWHGLHDQGHUH7DVVHDQVHLQHYRUVLFKWLJJHVSLW]WHQ/LSSHQ(UWUDQNODXWVFKOUIHQG 'DEHL OHJWH HU GLH IUHLH +DQG DQ GHQ 3DUDO\VDWRU DQ VHLQHP *UWHO (U NORSIWH EHGHXWXQJVYROO JHJHQ GLH :DIIH XQG ]HLJWH GDQQ DXJHQ]ZLQNHUQG DXI GLH EHLGHQ EHZXWORVHQ0lQQHUDP(LQJDQJ'DQQUOSVWHHUXQGOLHGLHHQWOHHUWH7DVVHDFKWORV DXIGHQ%RGHQIDOOHQ'HU5HVWGHUKHLHQ)OVVLJNHLWVSULW]WHLKPEHUGLH)HDEHU GDVVFKLHQHUQLFKW]XEHPHUNHQ ³:HUVLQG6LHPHLQ)UHXQG"IUDJWH$WODQGHUVLFK]XU5XKH]ZLQJHQPXWH'LH =HLW EUDQQWH LKP DXI GHQ 1lJHOQ (U ZROOWH GHQ $OWHQ MHGRFK QLFKW YHUlUJHUQ ZHLO HU IUFKWHWH GD GLHVHU LKQ DXV GHP +LQWHUKDOW KHUDXV SDUDO\VLHUHQ ZUGH 'DV DEHU NRQQWHHUVLFKDXIJDUNHLQHQ)DOOPHKUOHLVWHQ(VJLQJXPMHGH0LQXWHGHQQHUNRQQWH VLFKYRUVWHOOHQGDGHU*UDXHGDV9RUDXVNRPPDQGRVRVFKQHOOVFKLFNHQZUGHZLHHU HVVFKDIIHQNRQQWH 'LH $192< ZDU MHGRFK QRFK QLFKW DP =LHO XQG GDULQ ODJ VHLQH &KDQFH 1RFK HLQPDO PXWH VLH LQ GHQ /LQHDUUDXP JHKHQ XP HLQH JU|HUH 'LVWDQ] EHUZLQGHQ ]X N|QQHQ 'LHVHV 6RQQHQV\VWHP LQ GHP VLH VLFK MHW]W EHIDQGHQ ZDU GLH OHW]WH =ZLVFKHQVWDWLRQ -H OlQJHU HU VLFK KLHU KDOWHQ NRQQWH GHVWR EHVVHU ZDUHQ VHLQH $XVVLFKWHQ ³,FK ELQ $QYRU´ ULHI GHU *UHLV PLW VFKDOOHQGHU 6WLPPH $WODQ WUDW XQZLOONUOLFK HLQHQ6FKULWW]XUFN'DV*HVLFKWGHV$OWHQU|WHWHVLFKXQGVHLQH+lQGH]LWWHUWHQKHIWLJ =RUQ OHXFKWHWH DXV GHQ $XJHQ (WZDV OHLVHU IXKU HU IRUW ³,FK ELQ GHU YRUKHULJH .RPPDQGDQW GHV 6FKLIIHV 6¶9DQJRU%UDGG GLHVHU 7HXIHO KDW PLFK YHUUDWHQ 6LH KDEHQPLFKJHIROWHUWXQGPHLQHQDUPHQ.RSIGDEHLJHTXlOW´ (UYHUVWXPPWH6HLQH$XJHQZHLWHWHQVLFK ³0LU LVW DOOHV GXUFKHLQDQGHU JHNRPPHQ´ VDJWH HU IOVWHUQG ³,FK ZDU JDQ] ZLUU DEHULFKZHLJHQDXGD6¶9DQJRU%UDGG0LQJRUXQGDOOHDQGHUHQJHVDJWKDEHQLFK VHLYHUUFNW%LQLFKGDV$WODQ"´ 'HU$UNRQLGHVFKWWHOWHGHQ.RSI(UOlFKHOWHEHJWLJHQG ³1DWUOLFK QLFKW $QYRU´ HUZLGHUWH HU 'HU $OWH WDW LKP OHLG 6HLQ =XVWDQG OLH HUNHQQHQ ]X ZHOFKHQ 8QWDWHQ GLH 7HIURGHU XQG GLH VLH EHIHKOLJHQGHQ 7HUUDQHU IlKLJ ZDUHQ³1DWUOLFKELVWGXQLFKWYHUUFNW'DVVLHKWPDQGRFK´ ³1LFKW ZDKU"´ IUDJWH GHU *UHLV HLIULJ (U ]HLJWH PLW EHEHQGHU +DQG DXI GLH EHZXWORVHQ 0lQQHU ³8QG GDV EHKDXSWHQ DXVJHUHFKQHW GLH GD GUDXHQ 'LH VLQG HV GRFK GLH GXUFKJHGUHKW VLQG +DEHQ 6LH VFKRQ HLQPDO VRYLHOH 9HUUFNWH DXI HLQHQ +DXIHQJHVHKHQ"´ (UODFKWHELVLKPGLH7UlQHQLQGLH$XJHQVFKRVVHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³'D EHKDXSWHW HLQHU YRQ GHP DQGHUHQ GD HU YHUUFNW VHL´ VFKULH HU PLW EHUNLSSHQGHU6WLPPH³DEHULFKZHLJDQ]JHQDXGDGLHDQGHUHQHVVLQGXQGQLFKW LFK+DWPDQMHPDOVVRHWZDVHUOHEW"´ (UEHDFKWHWH$WODQQLFKWPHKUXQGVFKOXUIWHNLFKHUQGKLQDXV$EXQG]XEOLHEHU VWHKHQXQGODFKWHVFKDOOHQGDXI 'HU $UNRQLGH ZDUWHWH ELV HU YHUVFKZXQGHQ ZDU 'DQQ YHUVXFKWH HU HUQHXW GLH =LHOSURJUDPPLHUXQJ]XILQGHQ$XVGLHVHUDOOHLQZUGHHUDEOHVHQN|QQHQZLHYLHO=HLW LKPQRFKEOLHE6HKUVFKQHOOPHUNWHHUMHGRFKGDHUDXFKMHW]WQLFKWPHKUZHLWHUNDP ³'DQQ EOHLEW QXU HLQH 0|JOLFKNHLW´ VDJWH HU ]X VLFK VHOEVW ³'HU %HKlOWHU PX¶UDXV´ (UEHUOHJWH :R NRQQWHQ GLH 6FKDOWXQJHQ IU¶ GLH 6FKXW]VFKLUPH VHLQ" ,UJHQGZR LQ GHU +DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOH RGHU LQ GHU )XQN]HQWUDOH PXWH HV HLQ hEHUZDFKXQJVLQVWUXPHQW JHEHQYRQGHPDXVGHU(XHUJLHIHOGULQJXPGHQ.HJHOEHKlOWHU]HQWUDOJHVWHXHUWZXUGH (U JLQJ ODQJVDP DQ GHQ 3RVLWURQLNHQ HQWODQJ XQG KRIIWH GDEHL DXV GHQ %HVFKULIWXQJHQ XQWHU GHQ .Q|SIHQ 7DVWHQ XQG .LSSKHEHOQ HWZDV HUIDKUHQ ]X N|QQHQ (UKDWWHNHLQ*OFN'LH6FKXW]VFKLUPHGLHGDV6FKLIIHLQKOOWHQKlWWHHUPKHORVHLQ XQGDXVVFKDOWHQN|QQHQ'DVZlUHNHLQ3UREOHPJHZHVHQ,QQHUKDOEGHU$192<VDK DOOHVDQGHUVDXV 1LHPDQG NRQQWH LKP KHOIHQ $XHU GHP $OWHQ ZDU NHLQ 7HIURGHU EHL 9HUVWDQG 'LHJHVDPWH%HVDW]XQJXQWHUODJGHP6WUDKOHQHLQIOX+LHUZXUGHMHGHUVHLQHVHLJHQHQ :LOOHQV EHUDXEW GHU QLFKW PHQWDOVWDELOLVLHUW ZDU ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X .RHWDQRU'HOOW ZR QXUGLH0HQWDOVWDELOLVLHUWHQDXIGLHSVLRQLVFKH(QHUJLHDQJHVSURFKHQKDWWHQ -H PHKU HU EHU GDV 3UREOHP QDFKGDFKWH GHVWR PHKU NDP HU ]X GHU hEHU]HXJXQJ GD VLFK EHL GHP .HJHO QXU XP 36,0DWHULH KDQGHOQ NRQQWH $XFK ]ZHLIHOWH HU QLFKW PHKU GDUDQ GD GHU %HKlOWHU IU GLH 9RUJl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lFKHOWH &D0LQJRUZDUQLFKWXQJHVFKLFNWDEHUDXFKQLFKWJHVFKLFNWJHQXJYRUJHJDQJHQ 'LH6RQGHUHLQULFKWXQJZlUHYLHOEHVVHUYHUERUJHQJHZHVHQZHQQVLHRKQHEHVRQGHUH .HQQ]HLFKQXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHQDQGHUHQ*HUlWHQLQVWDOOLHUWZRUGHQZlUH 'HU $UNRQLGH YHUWLHIWH VLFK LQ GDV 6WXGLXP GHU 6FKDOWXQJHQ (U PXWH ]LHPOLFK JHQDXZLVVHQZDVHU]XWXQKDWWHEHYRUHUGLH(QHUJLHIHOGHUDEEDXWH0DFKWHHUHLQHQ )HKOHU NRQQWH HU XQWHU 8PVWlQGHQ GDGXUFK EHZLUNHQ GD GLH 6WUDKOXQJ GXUFKVFKOXJ XQGLKQVHOEVWNDPSIXQIlKLJPDFKWHRGHUVRJDUW|WHWH (U HULQQHUWH VLFK GDUDQ ZLH DXHURUGHQWOLFK EHKXWVDP &D 0LQJRU XQG VHLQH 0lQQHU GHQ NHJHOI|UPLJHQ %HKlOWHU LQ GLH $192< JHEUDFKW KDWWHQ 6LH KDWWHQ VLFK
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
EHQRPPHQDOVWUDQVSRUWLHUWHQVLHHLQH$WRPERPEHGLHEHLGHUOHLVHVWHQ(UVFKWWHUXQJ H[SORGLHUHQ NRQQWH $XV GLHVHP 9HUKDOWHQ PXWH HU VFKOLHHQ GD GHU 8PJDQJ PLW GHP.HJHOQLFKWXQJHIlKUOLFKZDU $WODQ PHUNWH GD VHLQH $XJHQ ]X WUlQHQ EHJDQQHQ 'LH (UUHJXQJ ZROOWH LKQ EHUPDQQHQ(UVXFKWHLQVHLQHPWRWRJUDILVFKHQ*HGlFKWQLVQDFKHLQHU(ULQQHUXQJGLH LKPKHOIHQNRQQWHMHW]WGDV5LFKWLJH]XWXQ,UJHQGZDQQLQVHLQHPODQJHQ/HEHQKDWWH HUlKQOLFKH6LWXDWLRQHQGXUFKOHEW :DV KlWWH HU VHOEVW JHWDQ ZHQQ HU YRU GHP JOHLFKHQ 3UREOHP ZLH 0LQJRU JHVWDQGHQKlWWH" 'XKlWWHVWHLQ6FKDOWPXVWHUDQJHIHUWLJWPHOGHWHVLFKVHLQ([WUDKLUQ $WODQOlFKHOWH6HLQH%OLFNHULFKWHWHQVLFKDXIGHQ'DWHQVSHLFKHUGHUXQPLWWHOEDU QHEHQ GHP .RQWUROOSXOW LQVWDOOLHUW ZRUGHQ ZDU (U WLSSWH GLH %XFKVWDEHQ $192< LQ GLH7DVWDWXU:LHHUZDUWHWZDUIGDV*HUlWHLQH5LNDUWHDXV(UQDKPVLHDXIXQGVDK VLH VLFK VRUJIlOWLJ DQ 'HU %H]LUN LQ GHP GHU .HJHO XQWHUJHEUDFKW ZDU WUXJ GLH %H]HLFKQXQJ,9XQGVLHEHQ=XVlW]HDXVGHP,QWHUNRVPR$OSKDEHW 'HU $UNRQLGH ZDU EHU]HXJW HQGOLFK GHQ 6FKOVVHO IU GLH 6FKXW]IHOGHU JHIXQGHQ]XKDEHQ(UZDQGWHVLFKZLHGHUGHP3XOW]XXQGMHW]WJHODQJHVLKPVLFK]X RULHQWLHUHQ $OVHUGLH +DQG KREXPGLH HUVWH7DVWH]X GUFNHQVSUWHHUGDHWZDV JHVFKDK(LQNDXPPHUNOLFKHU5XFNJLQJGXUFKGDV6FKLII (UEOLFNWHDXIXQGEHJULII 'LH$192<ZDULQGHQ/LQHDUUDXP]XUFNJHNHKUW 'LH6WLPPH&D0LQJRUVKDOOWHGXUFKGLH=HQWUDOH$WODQNRQQWHVLHGHXWOLFK K|UHQ(UVWDQGDXIUHFKWLQHLQHP6FKUDQNLQGHQHUVLFKPLWJU|WHU0KH KLQHLQJH]ZlQJWKDWWH'XUFKZLQ]LJH6SDOWHQNDPHLQZHQLJIULVFKH/XIWKHUHLQ=ZHL 6FKXW]DQ]JHQDKPHQGHQPHLVWHQ3ODW]LQGHUNOHLQHQ.DELQHHLQGLH JOFNOLFKHUZHLVHZHQLJVWHQVKRFKJHQXJIULKQZDUVRGDHUQLFKWPLWHLQJHNQLFNWHQ %HLQHQGDULQVWHKHQPXWH 'LH:RUWHGHV7HUUDQHUVEHUUDVFKWHQLKQQLFKWDEHUVLHHUOHLFKWHUWHQLKQ GHQQRFK ³(VEOHLEWGDEHL´HUNOlUWHHUPLWVFKZHUHU=XQJH(UNlPSIWHRIIHQVLFKWOLFKLPPHU QRFKPLWGHQ1DFKZLUNXQJHQGHU%HHLQIOXVVXQJ³:LUJHKHQDXIV*DQ]H6ROOGHU *UDXHVHKHQZLHHUXQVXQGGHQ.HJHOKHUDXVKROW$OOHLQVFKDIIHQZLUHVGRFKQLFKW´ $WODQVSlKWHGXUFKGLH/XIWVFKOLW]HQDFKGUDXHQ(UVDKGDGHU7HUUDQHUGHP .RPPDQGDQWHQDXIGLH%HLQHKDOI'LHEHLGHQ0lQQHUPDFKWHQHLQHQVHKU JHVFKZlFKWHQ(LQGUXFN ³'LH=HQWUDOHZLUGJHUlXPW´EHIDKO6¶9DQJRU%UDGG³=ZHL5RERWHUEOHLEHQDOV :DFKHKLHU´ 'LH6WLPPHQYHUNODQJHQ$WODQK|UWHKDVWLJH6FKULWWH'DQQQlKHUWHQVLFK 5RERWHU(LQHUYRQLKQHQEOLHEXQPLWWHOEDUYRUGHP6FKUDQNVWHKHQLQGHPHUVWHFNWH ³,FKELQJDQ]VLFKHUGDLFKLKQJHVHKHQKDEH´HUNOlUWH&D0LQJRUGHUJHUDGH ZLHGHULQGLH+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOHNDP³$WODQZDUKLHUXQGHUZDUDNWLRQVIlKLJ,KPPDFKW GLH6WUDKOXQJRGHUZDVGDVDXFKLPPHUZDUQLFKWVDXV´
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
´:LUVROOWHQLKQVXFKHQEHYRUZLUHUQHXWLQGHQ1RUPDOUDXP]XUFNNHKUHQ´ VDJWHMHPDQGGHVVHQ6WLPPHGHU$UNRQLGHQLFKWNDQQWH ³'DVN|QQHQZLUOHLGHUQLFKW´HQWJHJQHWH0LQJRU³:HQQZLU]XODQJHLP /LQHDUUDXPEOHLEHQVFKLHHQZLUXP/LFKWMDKUHEHUXQVHU=LHOKLQDXVXQGGDQQNDQQ XQVQLHPDQGPHKUKHOIHQ'HU*UDXHZWHQRFKQLFKWHLQPDOZRHUXQV]XVXFKHQ KlWWH1HLQZLUPVVHQDOOHVDXIHLQH.DUWHVHW]HQ'HQ$UNRQLGHQKROHQZLUXQV VSlWHU´ 'LH6FKRWWHJOLWWHQ]X$WODQK|UWHQXUQRFKGDV:LVSHUQGHU]DKOUHLFKHQ*HUlWH (UYHUVXFKWHP|JOLFKVWOHLVH]XDWPHQ'LH5RERWHUZDUHQDXIPHUNVDP-HGHV *HUlXVFKGDVQLFKW]XU6]HQHULHJHK|UWHZUGHVLHDNWLYLHUHQXQG]XP$QJULII YHUDQODVVHQ 'LH=HLWVFKLHQHQGORVODQJVDP]XYHUVWUHLFKHQ'XUFKGLH6FKOLW]HNRQQWHGHU /RUGDGPLUDODXIGLH%LOGVFKLUPHXQGGLHhEHUZDFKXQJVLQVWUXPHQWHVHKHQ(QGOLFK HUW|QWHGHU6XPPWRQGHUGHQEHYRUVWHKHQGHQ:HFKVHODQNQGLJWH8QPLWWHOEDUGDUDXI JOLWWGLH$192<LQGHQ1RUPDOUDXP $WODQVWLHGLH7UDXIXQGVFKR'HQHUVWHQ5RERWHUWUDIHUVRIRUW'HU]ZHLWH (QHUJLHVWUDKODXVVHLQHU:DIIHVWUHLIWHGHQDQGHUHQMHGRFKQXUDP.RSIXQGULGLH $QWHQQHQZHJ$WODQIHXHUWHHUQHXWZlKUHQGHUPLWHLQHPJHZDOWLJHQ6DW]]XU6HLWH GHPJHJQHULVFKHQ%HVFKX]XHQWNRPPHQVXFKWH(LQH+|OOHQJOXWVFKLHQEHULKP ]XVDPPHQ]XVFKODJHQ(UIKOWHGLH+LW]HDQVHLQHQ+lQGHQXQGDP.RSI'DQQ H[SORGLHUWHGHU+IWJHOHQNWUDIRGHV$XWRPDWHQ(LQH6WLFKIODPPHVFKOXJLQLKPXQGDQ LKPKRFKVRGDHUSO|W]OLFKPLWWHQLP)HXHU]XVWHKHQVFKLHQ$WODQNRQQWHNHLQH 5FNVLFKWDXIGLHNRFKHPSILQGOLFKHQ,QVWUXPHQWHLQGHU=HQWUDOHQHKPHQ(UO|VWH VHLQHQ(QHUJLHVWUDKOHUQRFKHLQPDODXVXQGKRIIWHGDEHLGDHVQLFKWQRFKHLQH ([SORVLRQJHEHQZUGH(UWUDIGDVSRVLWURQLVFKH6WHXHU]HQWUXPGHU0DVFKLQHXQG OHJWHVLHGDPLWODKP6LHNLSSWHQDFKKLQWHQZHJZlKUHQGLKUH*\URVVFKULOODXIMDXOWHQ XQGVFKOXJNUDFKHQGDXIGHQ%RGHQ (UVWMHW]WZXUGH$WODQEHZXWGDDXIGHQ*lQJHQYRUGHU=HQWUDOHZLHGHU JHNlPSIWZXUGH(LQLJHUDVHQGH7HIURGHUWURPPHOWHQPLWVFKZHUHQ*HJHQVWlQGHQ JHJHQGLH6FKRWWHXPVLH]X|IIQHQ 'HU$UNRQLGHZHFKVHOWHHLOLJLQGLH)XQN]HQWUDOHKLQEHU(UZXWHGDMHW]WGLH OHW]WHQ0LQXWHQRGHUGRFK]XPLQGHVWGLHOHW]WH6WXQGHDQJHEURFKHQZDU$XIHLQHPGHU %LOGVFKLUPHKDWWHHUHLQH6RQQHJHVHKHQ'LH$192<ZDUELVLQGLHXQPLWWHOEDUH1lKH LKUHV=LHOHVJHNRPPHQ6HKUVFKQHOOZUGHPDQPHUNHQGDVLFKGLH6LWXDWLRQDQ %RUGQLFKWJHlQGHUWKDWWH'DV9RUDXVNRPPDQGRZUGHEDOGHLQWUHIIHQXQGGDQQJDE HVNHLQH0|JOLFKNHLWPHKUGLHHLQPDOJHIDWHQ3OlQH]XYHUZLUNOLHKHQ $WODQVDKLQGHP.HJHOHLQH:DIIHXQGIUFKWHWHGDVLHGHU(UGHXQGGHQ 0HQVFKHQLUJHQGZDQQHLQPDOVHKUJHIlKUOLFKZHUGHQNRQQWH,KUHXQKHLOYROOH:LUNXQJ ]HLJWHVLFKMDVFKRQKLHUDQ%RUGREZRKOVLHYRQ]DKOUHLFKHQ(QHUJLHVFKLUPHQ DEJHGHFNWZXUGH (UGUFNWHHLQLJH7DVWHQXQG.Q|SIH%ODXH/LFKWHUOHXFKWHWHQDXI6RQVW JHVFKDKQLFKWVZHLWHU(UDWPHWHDXI'LHlXHUHQ6FKXW]VFKLUPHZDUHQJHIDOOHQ-HW]W ZXUGHQXUQRFKGHU.HJHOYRQ(QHUJLHVFKLUPHQXPVSDQQWGLHHLQHQ'XUFKPHVVHUYRQ QLFKWPHKUDOV]HKQ0HWHUQKDWWHQ(U]HUULGHQ6FKDOWSODQXQGZDUIGLH5HVWHLQGHQ 0OOVFKDFKWZRVLHVRIRUWYHUEUDQQWZXUGHQ'DQQEHUSUIWHHUVHLQH:DIIHXQGVWHOOWH VLHDXI3DUDO\VHZLUNXQJXP'LHDQGHUHODJQRFKLPPHUGRUWZRHUVLHKLQJHOHJWKDWWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
(UQDKPVLHDXIOLHVLHDEHUDXI(QHUJLHVWUDKOZLUNXQJXPDXFKHLQHP5RERWHUDQJULII EHJHJQHQ]XN|QQHQ (UOLHGDV$XVJDQJVVFKRWWDXIIDKUHQ =ZHL7HIURGHUVWU]WHQVLFKDXILKQ(VZDUDOVREVLHQXUGDUDXIJHZDUWHW KDWWHQGDHUQDFKGUDXHQNDP(UOLHVLFKDXINHLQHQ.DPSIHLQVRQGHUQVFKRFNWH VLHVRIRUW hEHULKUHUHJXQJVORVHQ.|USHUKLQZHJVWLHJHULQGHQ$QWLJUDYVFKDFKW(U VFKZHEWHQDFKXQWHQZREHLHULQEHLGHQ+lQGHQGLH:DIIHQKLHOW'DEHLEHUOHJWHHU REHUZLUNOLFKDOOHVDOOHLQVFKDIIHQNRQQWHZDVHUVLFKYRUJHQRPPHQKDWWH'LH %HIUFKWXQJVWLHJLQLKPDXIGD0LQJRUVLFKDXIHLQHQGHUDUWLJHQ6FKODJYRUEHUHLWHW KDEHQN|QQWH $XI'HFNYHUOLHHUGHQ6FKDFKW(USDVVLHUWHHLQH6WHOOHDQGHUYRUKHUHLQ (QHUJLHVFKLUPJHZHVHQZDU-HW]WJDEHVNHLQ+LQGHUQLVPHKU /DQJVDPJLQJHUZHLWHU +LQWHUGHQJHSDQ]HUWHQ:lQGHQZXWHHUGLHVFKZHUHQ.RQYHUWHUGLHGDV6FKLII ]XUEHUOLFKWVFKQHOOHQ)DKUWEHIlKLJWHQ$XFKGRUWJDEHV7HIURGHUGLHMHW]WXQWHUGHP (LQIOXHLQHUZLOOHQVYHUlQGHUQGHQ0DFKWVWDQGHQ²IDOOV&D0LQJRUQLFKWNOXJJHQXJ JHZHVHQZDUGLHVHQ%HUHLFKGHU$192<QXUPLW5RERWHUQ]XEHVHW]HQ (LQ6FKRWW|IIQHWHVLFKYRULKPXQGHUNRQQWHGHQNHJHOI|UPLJHQ%HKlOWHUVHKHQ GHULQGHU0LWWHGHU+DOOHVFKZHEWH=ZHL.DPSIURERWHUVWDQGHQYRUGHQVFKLPPHUQGHQ (QHUJLHIHOGHUQGLHGHQ.HJHOVFKW]WHQ6LHUHDJLHUWHQQLFKWDXIVHLQ(UVFKHLQHQDEHU GDVZUGHVLFK]ZHLIHOORVVHKUVFKQHOOlQGHUQ $WODQK|UWHGDV5DXVFKHQHLQHV]XVWDUNDXIJHGUHKWHQ/DXWVSUHFKHUV(U ZDUWHWHZlKUHQGHUEHUOHJWHZLHHUGLHEHLGHQ.DPSIPDVFKLQHQEHUZLQGHQNRQQWH (VZlUHVLQQORVJHZHVHQVLHDQ]XJUHLIHQGHQQVLHKlWWHQJHVFKRVVHQEHYRUHUVHLQH :DIIHDXIVLHULFKWHQNRQQWH ³2KYHUGDPPW´VDJWH$QYRUPLWNHXFKHQGHU6WLPPH³,FKKDEHDOOHVYHUJHVVHQ ,FKZHLQLFKWPHKUZLHGDVJHPDFKWZLUG,FKELQHLQ7URWWHO´ (UVSUDFKLUJHQGZRLP6FKLIILQHLQ0LNURSKRQXQGVHLQH:RUWHKDOOWHQMHW]W GRQQHUQGDXVGHQ/DXWVSUHFKHUQ ³,FKNDQQ6LHVHKHQ$WODQ´IXKUHUIRUW'DEHLVWHXHUWHHUGLH*HUlWHHLQZHQLJ EHVVHUDXV ³:RVLQG6LH$QYRU"´ =XQlFKVWHUKLHOWHUNHLQH$QWZRUW'HU$OWHVFKLHQEHUUDVFKW]XVHLQGDHULKQ PLWVHLQHP1DPHQDQJHVSURFKHQKDWWH0HKUPDOVVHW]WHHU]XHLQHU(QWJHJQXQJDQ VFKDIIWHHVDEHUQLFKWVLHEHUGLH/LSSHQ]XEULQJHQ ³,FKEUDXFKH,KUH+LOIH$QYRU´ (QGOLFKPHOGHWHVLFKGHU*UHLVZLHGHU ³6HLWJHUDXPHU=HLWYHUVXFKHLFK6LH]XXQWHUVWW]HQ$WODQZHLOLFKGLHVH7HXIHO YRQPHLQHP6FKLIIYHUWUHLEHQP|FKWH,FKEHILQGHPLFKLQGHU5RERWHUVWHXHU]HQWUDOH 'LH3URJUDPPRIIL]LHUHPXWHLFKSDUDO\VLHUHQ6LHOLHJHQDXIGHP%RGHQ.RPLVFK VHKHQVLHDXV,FKZHUGH´ ³$QYRU´GUlQJWH$WODQ³:DVZROOWHQ6LHLQGLHVHU=HQWUDOH"´ ³,FKPXGRFKGLHEHLGHQ.DPSIURERWHULQGHU+DOOHDXVVFKDOWHQ´HUNOlUWHHU GDQQ$WODQZDUIURKLKQDXIGHQXUVSUQJOLFKHQ*HGDQNHQ]XUFNJHIKUW]XKDEHQ ³'DQQWXQ6LHHV´
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³,FKKDEHYHUJHVVHQZLHPDQHVPDFKW´ 'LHEHLGHQ5RERWHUPDUVFKLHUWHQDXIHLQH:DQG]X,KUH%HZHJXQJHQZDUHQ XQJHOHQN,KUH:DIIHQDUPHUXFNWHQKRFK6LHVFKRVVHQDXIHLQHQXQVLFKWEDUHQ*HJQHU $WODQEHJULII$QYRUYHUVXFKWHVLH]XVWHXHUQEHNDPVLHDEHUQLFKWLQGHQ*ULII (UVFKRDXIHLQHGHUEHLGHQ0DVFKLQHQ'HU(QHUJLHVWUDKOGXUFKVFKOXJGHQ 6FKXW]VFKLUPGHV$XWRPDWHQXQGWUDIVHLQHQ.RSI6HNXQGHQODQJVFKLHQHVDOVKDEH HUNHLQH:LUNXQJHU]LHOWGDQQDEHUNLSSWHGHU5RERWHUXPXQGILHODXIGHQ%RGHQ$WODQ JDEHLQHQ]ZHLWHQ6FKXDE:lKUHQGGLHVHU=HLWEHKLHOWHUGHQDQGHUHQ:lFKWHULQ GHQ$XJHQ6RODQJHGLHVHULKQLQVHLQHP%OLFNIHOGKDWWHZDJWHHUHVQLFKWLKQ DQ]XJUHLIHQ$OVHUVLFKDEZDQGWHHUOHGLJWHHULKQPLWGUHL%OLW]HQDXVVHLQHU:DIIH (UDWPHWHDXI6HW]WKDWWHHUHVJHVFKDIIW (LOLJWUDWHUQlKHUDQGLH6FKXW]VFKLUPHKHUDQGLHGHQ.HJHOXPJDEHQ(U HUNDQQWHVRIRUWGDLKU'XUFKPHVVHUHWZDVJU|HUZDUDOVGHUGHV*DQJHVGHU]XGHQ +DQJDUVDQGHU3HULSKHULHGHV6FKLIIHVIKUWH(UKDWWHGHQ6FKDOWSODQHLQZHQLJ]XIUK YHUQLFKWHW 9RUVLFKWLJWUDWHUDQHLQHQGHUGUHL3URMHNWRUHQKHUDQGLHGLFKWEHUGHP%RGHQ VFKZHEWHQ(UVDKGDGLH0DVFKLQHQQXUPLW6SH]LDOVFKOVVHOQEHGLHQWZHUGHQ NRQQWHQ,KUH6FKDOWXQJHQZDUHQEORFNLHUWZRUGHQ 1DFKGHQNOLFKJLQJ$WODQXPGDVNXJHOI|UPLJH)HOGKHUXP(VKDWWHHLQHQ5DGLXV YRQHWZDIQI0HWHUQ'HXWOLFKNRQQWHHUVHKHQGDLQLKPQRFKGUHLZHLWHUH (QHUJLHIHOGHUEHVWDQGHQGLHYRQLQVJHVDPWQHXQ)HOGSURMHNWRUHQHUULFKWHWZXUGHQ 1LFKWVNRQQWHGHXWOLFKHUGRNXPHQWLHUHQZLHZLFKWLJ0LQJRUGLHVHU.HJHOZDU1LHPDQG NRQQWHGLHVH%DUULHUHEHUZLQGHQZHQQHUNHLQHQ6FKOVVHOIUGLH3URMHNWRUHQKDWWH 'HU$UNRQLGH|IIQHWHHLQJURHV6FKRWWGDV7UDNWRUV\PEROHWUXJ(UODFKHOWHDOV HUGLHVFKZHUHQ0DVFKLQHQEHUEOLFNHQNRQQWHGLHLQGHP6HLWHQUDXPGHU+DOOH XQWHUJHEUDFKWZDUHQ6LHVWHOOWHQJHQDXGDVGDUZDVHUMHW]WEUDXFKWH0LWZHQLJHQ *ULIIHQDNWLYLHUWHHUHLQHQGHU7UDNWRUVWUDKOJHQHUDWRUHQXQGGLULJLHUWHLKQLQGLH+DOOH 9RUVLFKWLJEDXWHHUGDV'UXFNIHOGDXIXQGULFKWHWHHVJHJHQGHQ%HKlOWHULQGHQ (QHUJLHIHOGHUQ:LHHUKRIIWOLHHQHUXQGGLH3URMHNWRUHQVLFKZHJVFKLHEHQ 6HNXQGHQVSlWHUVFKRQHUUHLFKWHGLHIOLPPHUQGH.XJHOGDVJURH $XVJDQJVVFKRWW$WODQVFKDOWHWHGHQ7UDNWRUDXVHLOWHXPGLH(QHUJLHIHOGHUKHUXPXQG |IIQHWHHV'DQQULFKWHWHHUGLH6FKXENUDIWZLHGHUJHJHQGHQ.HJHO=XQlFKVWJHVFKDK EHUKDXSWQLFKWV'DVJDQ]H2EMHNWZDU]XJUR(VSDWHQLFKWGXUFKGDV7RU'DQQ DEHUJDEHQGLH6HLWHQZlQGHXQGGLH'HFNHNQLUVFKHQGQDFK6LHEHXOWHQVLFKVWDUN DXVELVGHU*DQJNUHLVUXQGJHZRUGHQZDU$WODQYHUVWlUNWHGHQ'UXFN.UDFKHQG SODW]WHQGLH9HUNOHLGXQJXQG6WW]HQDOVGDV.XJHOIHOGVLFKZHLWHUYRUVFKRE $WODQVFKREGHQ5HJOHUVHLQHV7UDNWRUVWUDKOHUVDXI+|FKVWOHLVWXQJ,PPHU VFKQHOOHUERKUWHVLFKGLH(QHUJLHNXJHOLQGHQ*DQJXQGKLQWHUOLHHLQ7UPPHUIHOG'HU $UNRQLGHDUEHLWHWHVLFKYRUVLFKWLJYRUDQ'HU%RGHQXQWHUVHLQHQ)HQERWNHLQH 6LFKHUKHLWPHKU(UIUFKWHWHGDGHU6FKXEVWUDKOHULQHLQHQGHUHQWVWDQGHQHQ5LVVH UXWVFKHQXQGLQGLH7LHIHYHUVFKZLQGHQN|QQWH 'DHQWGHFNWHHUSO|W]OLFKGUHL0lQQHULP*DQJ6LHVWDQGHQXQVLFKHUYRUGHP KHUDQQDKHQGHQ'UXFNIHOG1RUPDOHUZHLVHKlWWHQVLHGLHXQJHKHXUH*HIDKUHUNDQQWLQ GHUVLHVFKZHEWHQMHW]WDEHUZDUHQVLHZLHEOLQG6LHZLFKHQQLFKW]XUFN $WODQVWRSSWHGLH0DVFKLQH(UZROOWHGLH7HIURGHUQLFKWXPEULQJHQ5DVFK VFKDOWHWHHUVHLQHQ%ODVWHUDXI3DUDO\VHZLUNXQJXPXQGVFKRDXIGLH0lQQHUGRFKVLH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
UHDJLHUWHQQLFKWGDUDXI'LH(QHUJLHVFKLUPHQHXWUDOLVLHUWHQGLH6WUDKOHQ 6FKQHOONHKUWHGHU$UNRQLGHLQGLH+DOOH]XUFN(UZDQGWHVLFKGHPQlFKVWHQ $XVJDQJ]XDOVSO|W]OLFKGUHL0lQQHUDXVGHU'HFNXQJHLQHV0DVFKLQHQEORFNVKHUDXV DXILKQORVVSUDQJHQXQGLKQXPNODPPHUWHQ(UVWU]WHXQWHULKUHP*HZLFKW]X%RGHQ ,KUH)lXVWHWURPPHOWHQJHJHQVHLQHQ+LQWHUNRSI(LQHUKLHOWVHLQH%HLQHIHVWGHU DQGHUHVHW]WHVLFKULWWOLQJVDXILKQ(UZROOWHLKPGLH:DIIHDEQHKPHQ $WODQUHDJLHUWHEOLW]VFKQHOO(UHUNDQQWHZLHNULWLVFKGLH6LWXDWLRQZDU'LH 7HIURGHUZDUHQXQEHUHFKHQEDU-HW]WNDPHVDXI6HNXQGHQEUXFKWHLOHDQ(QWVSUHFKHQG UFNVLFKWVORVNlPSIWHHU,KPEOLHENHLQHDQGHUH:DKO(UZlO]WHVLFKNUDIWYROOKHUXP GDQQVFKOXJHQVHLQH)lXVWH]X'LHGUHL0lQQHUZHKUWHQVLFKZWHQGDEHUVLHKDWWHQ VLFKYLHO]XZHQLJXQWHU.RQWUROOH$OVGHUHUVWHYRQLKQHQ]XVDPPHQEUDFKKDWWHQGLH EHLGHQDQGHUHQNHLQH&KDQFHPHKU 'HU$UNRQLGHKLHOWVLFKQLFKWODQJHPLWLKQHQDXI(UUDQQWHGXUFKGDV6FKLIIELV ]XPQlFKVWHQDE]ZHLJHQGHQ*DQJ$XILKPXQWHUOLHIHUGDV.XJHOIHOGELVHUGLHGUHL 7HIURGHUVHKHQNRQQWHGLHUDWORVYRUGHP%HKlOWHUVWDQGHQ(USDUDO\VLHUWHVLHEHYRU VLHLKQHQWGHFNWKDWWHQXQGVFKOHSSWHVLHLQHLQHQ6HLWHQUDXPZRHUVLHKLQWHUHLQLJH $JJUHJDWHOHJWHGDPLWVLHYRQDEVSOLWWHUQGHQ.XQVWVWRIIWHLOHQQLFKWJHWURIIHQZHUGHQ NRQQWHQ 'DQQKHW]WHHU]XUFN :LHGHUEHJDQQGHU7UDNWRUVWUDKOHU]XDUEHLWHQ(U]ZDQJGDV.XJHOIHOGPLWGHP .HJHOZHLWHULQGHQ*DQJKLQHLQ'LH=HLWYHUUDQQ$WODQEOLFNWHDXIVHLQ&KURQRPHWHU 'HU0lU]ZDUVFKRQIDVWDEJHODXIHQ,Q]ZLVFKHQZUGHVLFKGHU*UDXHGHU$192< EHUHLWVQlKHUQ'DUDQ]ZHLIHOWHHUQLFKW'HU:HWWODXIPLWGHU=HLWKDWWHEHJRQQHQ-HW]W NDPHVQXUQRFKGDUDXIDQZHUVFKQHOOHUZDU $XVGHQ/DXWVSUHFKHUQDXIGHP*DQJKDOOWHQ6WLPPHQ(UNRQQWHVLH]XQlFKVW QLFKWYHUVWHKHQ]XPDOHUVLFKDXFKQLFKWGDUXPEHPKWH'DQQK|UWHHUVHLQHQ1DPHQ KHUDXV(UEOLHEVWHKHQZlKUHQGGDV.XJHOIHOGYRQGHP7UDNWRUVWUDKOHUZHLWHUGXUFK GDV6FKLIIJHWULHEHQZXUGH ³+DOWHQ6LHHLQ$WODQ´EHVFKZRULKQHLQ7HIURGHUGHULUJHQGZRLP6FKLIIYRU HLQHP0LNURSKRQVDXQGLKQEHUHLQHYHUVWHFNWH2SWLNEHREDFKWHQNRQQWH³6LH N|QQHQQLHPDOVVFKDIIHQZDV6LHVLFKYRUJHQRPPHQKDEHQ´ (UPXWHVLFKVHKUVFKDUINRQ]HQWULHUHQXP]XHUIDVVHQZDVGHU8QEHNDQQWH PHLQWHGDGLHVHUJU|WH0KHKDWWHGLH:RUWH]XDUWLNXOLHUHQ2IIHQVLFKWOLFKNlPSIWH HUPLWDOOHU.RQ]HQWUDWLRQJHJHQGLH0DFKWGHV.HJHOVDQ'HU$UNRQLGHHULQQHUWHVLFK GDUDQZLHHUVLFKDXI.RHWDQRU'HOSJHJHQGLHVWUDKOHQGHQ0DVVHQJHZHKUWKDWWHXQG ZLHZHQLJLKPVHLQ:LGHUVWDQGJHQW]WKDWWH(UIUFKWHWHQLFKWGDGLH%HVDW]XQJVLFK ]XHLQHPJHVFKORVVHQHQ.DPSIJHJHQLKQDXIUDIIHQNRQQWH ,PPHUKLQVFKDIIWHQHLQLJH0lQQHUHV5RERWHUJHJHQLKQHLQ]XVHW]HQ$WODQVDK GLH0DVFKLQHQNRPPHQ(UOlFKHOWHGHQQVLHEHIDQGHQVLFKDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHGHV (QHUJLHIHOGEDOOHV6LHVFKRVVHQDXVLKUHQ(QHUJLHVWUDKOHUQ(UPXWHGLH$XJHQ VFKOLHHQXPQLFKWJHEOHQGHW]XZHUGHQ(LQH)HXHUIOXWVFKZDSSWHGHPNHJHOI|UPLJHQ %HKlOWHUHQWJHJHQGRFKVLHNRQQWHGLH6FKXW]VFKLUPHQLFKWGXUFKGULQJHQ(QHUJLVFK WULHE$WODQGLHXQEHNDQQWH:DIIHZHLWHUYRU$OVHUGHQ%HUHLFKEHWUDWLQGHPGLH 5RERWHUJHVFKRVVHQKDWWHQPXWHHU]XUFNEOHLEHQ'HU%RGHQJOKWH]XP7HLOQRFK XQGHLQHXQHUWUlJOLFKH+LW]HVFKOXJLKPHQWJHJHQ'LH0DVFKLQHQZLFKHQYRUGHP .HJHO]XUFN6LHNRQQWHQVLFKJHJHQGLH(XHUJLHVFKLUPHQLFKWEHKDXSWHQDEHUVLH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
VFKRVVHQLPPHUZHLWHU $WODQHLOWHELVLQGLH+DOOH]XUFNDXVGHUHUGHQ.HJHOHQWIKUWKDWWH+DVWLJUL HUHLQLJH6FKUlQNHDXIELVHUHLQHQ6FKXW]DQ]XJIDQGGHQHUVLFKREHUVWUHLIHQNRQQWH (UOHJWHVLFKHLQ)OXJJHUlWDQXQGJOLWWDXIXQVLFKWEDUHQ$QWLJUDYIHOGHUQZLHGHULQGHQ *DQJKLQHLQ'LH$XWRPDWHQKDWWHQLKU)HXHUQRFKLPPHUQLFKWHLQJHVWHOOWREZRKOVLH GDPLWGLH*HIDKUHLQHVZHLWHUXPVLFKJUHLIHQGHQ%UDQGHVKHUDXIEHVFKZRUHQ'DV VFKLHQHQVLHXQGLKUHXQEHNDQQWHQ'LULJHQWHQMHGRFKQLFKW]XVHKHQ'DQQ]HLJWHVLFK EHUUDVFKHQGGDLKU(LQVDW]DXFK9RUWHLOHIUGHQ$UNRQLGHQKDWWH'HU7UDQVSRUW QlKHUWHVLFKGHP*DQJHQGHGDVGXUFK]ZHLJURH3DQ]HUVFKRWWHDQJH]HLJWZXUGH $WODQEHUOHJWHEHUHLWVZLHHUHV|IIQHQNRQQWH(UEHUHLWHWHVLFKGDUDXIYRUGDV .XJHOIHOGDEHUPDOVXPNUHLVHQ]XPVVHQDOVGLH5RERWHUELVDQGLH6FKRWWH ]XUFNZLFKHQXQGGLHVHVHOEVWDXIIXKUHQ'DKLQWHUODJHLQ+DQJDU$WODQV+RIIQXQJHQ KLHUDXIHLQNOHLQHV5DXPVFKLII]XVWRHQZXUGHQHQWWlXVFKW 'LH5RERWHUZLFKHQ]XGHQ6HLWHQDXV-HW]WEUDXFKWHQVLHQXUQRFK]XZDUWHQ ELVHUDXVVHLQHU'HFNXQJKHUDXVNDPXPLKQZLUNXQJVYROODQJUHLIHQ]XN|QQHQ 'RFKGDQQ]HLJWHVLFKZLHGHUXPGDGLH/HQNHUGHU$XWRPDWHQQRFKLPPHU XQWHUGHP(LQIOXGHV.HJHOVVWDQGHQ6LHNRQQWHQQLFKWNODUJHQXJGHQNHQ$OVGHU (QHUJLHEDOOLQGLH+DOOHKLQHLQVFKRSUDOOWHHUPLWHLQHPGHU5RERWHU]XVDPPHQ'LH 0DVFKLQHH[SORGLHUWH'LHGDYRQUDVHQGHQ7UPPHUVWFNHWUDIHQHLQHQ]ZHLWHQXQG ]HUVW|UWHQLKQHEHQIDOOV'LHGULWWHXQGYLHUWH0DVFKLQHYHUQLFKWHWH$WODQPLWJH]LHOWHQ (XHUJLHVFKVVHQ (UYHUORUNHLQH=HLWGDPLWVLFKLP+DQJDU]XRULHQWLHUHQ=ZLVFKHQGHQ ]DKOUHLFKHQKLHUDEJHVWHOOWHQ0DVFKLQHQXQG)DKU]HXJHQNRQQWHVLFKOHLFKWHLQH JU|HUH=DKOYRQ*HJQHUQYHUEHUJHQ,KPEOLHEMHW]WMHGRFKNHLQH=HLWPHKUVLFKY|OOLJ DE]XVFKLUPHQ %HPXKWLQGHU'HFNXQJYRQ&RQWDLQHUQXQG0DVFKLQHQ]XEOHLEHQIORJHUELV]X GHQ6FKOHXVHQVFKRWWHQ(UOLHVLH]XU6HLWHUROOHQ'DQQNHKUWHHU]XGHP 7UDNWRUVWUDKOHU]XUFNXQGVFKREGLH.HJHOYRUVLFKWLJLQGLH6FKOHXVHKLQHLQ-HW]W GXUIWHHUQLFKWVPHKUEHVFKlGLJHQ (WZDGUHLLJ0HWHUYRQLKPHQWIHUQWNDXHUWHQYLHU0lQQHUDXIGHP%RGHQ6LH VFKLHQHQLKQMHGRFKQLFKW]XEHPHUNHQXQGYHUVXFKWHQDXFKQLFKWLKQDQ]XJUHLIHQ 2IIHQVLFKWOLFKKDWWHQVLHJHQXJPLWVLFKVHOEVW]XWXQ $WODQJOLWWLQGLH6FKOHXVHQNDPPHU 6HLQH$XJHQEHJDQQHQ]XWUlQHQ(UKDWWHHVJHVFKDIIW-HW]WNRQQWHLKQ HLJHQWOLFKQLFKWVPHKUDXIKDOWHQ 0LWHLQHUHQWVFKORVVHQHQ%HZHJXQJYHUULHJHOWHHUVHLQHQ5DXPKHOP(U EHUSUIWHDOOH,QVWUXPHQWHXQGVWHOOWHIHVWGDDOOHVLQ2UGQXQJZDU ³$WODQEOHLEHQ6LHDQ%RUG´NDPHLQHEHVFKZ|UHQGH6WLPPHDXVVHLQHQ +HOPODXWVSUHFKHUQ6LHNODQJYHU]HUUWXQGVFKLHQYRQHLQHP%HWUXQNHQHQ]XVWDPPHQ ³7XQ6LHQLFKWZDV6LHYRUKDEHQ'HU*UDXHZLUG6LHYHUQLFKWHQZHQQ6LHGHQ.HJHO QDFKGUDXHQEULQJHQ%HLDOOHQ6WHUQHQJHLVWHUQEOHLEHQ6LHKLHU´ (UVFKDOWHWHVHLQ)XQNJHUlWDXV'DQQGUFNWHHUGLH.Q|SIHIUGLH $XHQVFKRWWH/DQJVDPJOLWWHQVLH]XU6HLWH 'DVJUHOOH/LFKWHLQHU6RQQHILHOLQGLH.DPPHU'LH6FKXW]EOHQGHVFKLUPWHVHLQH $XJHQDEGHQQRFKPXWHHUVHLQH/LGHUIDVWVFKOLHHQ'LH$192<EHIDQGVLFK DEHUPDOVLQXQPLWWHOEDUHU1lKHHLQHU6RQQH9RQVHLQHU3RVLWLRQDXVNRQQWHHUQLFKW
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
HUNHQQHQZLHVFKQHOORGHUZLHODQJVDPGDV6FKLIIDQLKUYRUEHLJOLWWRGHUREHVVLFKLKU JDUQlKHUWH(U]|JHUWH 'DQQVDJWHHUVLFKGDGLHVVHLQHEXFKVWlEOLFKOHW]WH&KDQFHZDUGHQ.HJHO]X ]HUVW|UHQ(UVHW]WHGHQ7UDNWRUVWUDKOHUZLHGHUHLQXQGWULHEGLH:DIIHGHV*UDXHQLQ GHQ5DXPKLQDXV'DQQNODPPHUWHHUVLFKDQGDV7ULHEZHUNXQGIROJWHGHU.XJHO(U PXWHVLHP|JOLFKVWZHLWYRQGHU$192<ZHJEULQJHQ 0LWVWlQGLJZDFKVHQGHU*HVHKZLQGLJNHLWHQWIHUQWHVLHVLFKYRP6FKLII (UKlWWHVLFKJHUQEDOGYRQGHP.RQYRLJHWUHQQWDEHUGDVNRQQWHHUQLFKWZHLO GHU7UDNWRUVWUDKOHURKQHLKQYRP.XJHOIHOGDEJHJOLWWHQXQGLQV1LFKWVGDYRQJHIORJHQ ZlUH,PPHUZLHGHUEOLFNWHHU]XUFN'DV5DXPVFKLIIZDUEDOGQXUQRFKDOVNOHLQH 6LFKHO]XHUNHQQHQ (UEUDFKWHGHQ'UXFNVWUDKOHUQRFKHLQPDODXI+|FKVWOHLVWXQJXQGVWLHVLFKGDQQ YRQLKPDE-HW]WVWHXHUWHHUVHLQHLJHQHV$QWLJUDYDJJUHJDWKRFKXPVRVFKQHOOZLH P|JOLFKZLHGHULQV6FKLII]XUFNNRPPHQ]XN|QQHQ ,KPZDUGXUFKDXVNODUGDVLFKGLH6LWXDWLRQDQ%RUGLQ]ZLVFKHQDEHUPDOV HQWVFKHLGHQGJHlQGHUWKDWWH0LWMHGHU0LQXWHGLHYHUVWULFKZXUGHQVHLQH (UIROJVDXVVLFKWHQJHULQJHU &LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³:LUPVVHQ]XQlFKVW$WODQXQGGLH$NRQLQKROHQ´HUNOlUWHHUIHVW .DSIODUQLFNWH]XVWLPPHQG =XVDPPHQYHUOLHHQGLHEHLGHQ0lQQHUGLH.DELQH6LHHLOWHQEHUGLH*lQJH hEHUDOOEHJHJQHWHQVLHDQGHUHQ7HIURGHUQGLHVLFKDOOPlKOLFKYRQLKUHP6FKRFN HUKROWHQGRFKQLHPDQGZDUELVMHW]WVFKRQVRZHLWZLHVLHVHOEVW
'LH $192< ZXUGH VFKQHOO JU|HU (U KDWWH NHLQH 6FKZLHULJNHLWHQ VLFK LKU ]X QlKHUQ'DVGHXWHWHGDUDXIKLQGDVLFKDQ%RUGQRFKQLFKWYLHOJHlQGHUWKDWWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
$OV$WODQELVDXIHLQHQ.LORPHWHUDQGDV6FKLIIKHUDQJHNRPPHQZDUILHOLKPDXI GD NHLQ /LFKW PHKU DXV GHU 6FKOHXVH NDP GXUFK GLH HU GHQ .HJHO KLQDXVJHGUlQJW KDWWH:DUVLHJHVFKORVVHQZRUGHQ" (UYHUVXFKWHQRFKHWZDVVFKQHOOHU]XIOLHJHQDEHUGDV*HUlWJDEEHUHLWVVHLQH K|FKVWH/HLVWXQJDE 0LWWOHUZHLOH KDWWH HU VLFK GDYRQ EHU]HXJHQ N|QQHQ GD GLH $192< LQ DXVUHLFKHQGJURHU(QWIHUQXQJDQGHU6RQQHYRUEHLJOLWW6LHZDUQLFKWJHIlKUGHW(LQHQ 3ODQHWHQ NRQQWH GHU $UNRQLGH DXVPDFKHQ 'DV 6FKLII ODJ DXI GHP .XUV ]X LKP 9RQ GRUW KHU MDJWH MHW]W DXFK HLQ 5DXPHU PLW GHP *UDXHQ XQG VHLQHQ /HXWHQ KHUDQ 6LH ZROOWHQNOlUHQZDVVLFKDQ%RUGGHU$192<HUHLJQHWKDWWH (UPXWHVFKQHOOHUVHLQDOVVLH (UPXWHGHQ.HJHOPLW+LOIHGHU%RUGJHVFKW]H]HUVWUDKOHQ $OVHU VLFK GHP 6FKLIIELV DXI ]ZHLKXQGHUW0HWHUJHQlKHUW KDWWHJDE HV NHLQHQ =ZHLIHO PHKU ,UJHQG MHPDQG KDWWH GLH 6FKOHXVH JHVFKORVVHQ (U ZDU DXVJHVSHUUWZRUGHQ 9RUVLFKWLJ VWHXHUWH $WODQ VLFK DQ GLH $192< KHUDQ (U KDWWH *OFN LP 8QJOFN ZHLO QRFK QLHPDQG DXI GHQ *HGDQNHQ JHNRPPHQ ZDU GLH 6FKXW]VFKLUPH HLQ]XVFKDOWHQ (U KLHOW VLFK DQ HLQHP GHU 6FKRWWH IHVW XQG EHUOHJWH ZLH HU LQV 6FKLII NRPPHQ N|QQH ,Q VHLQHQ +HLPODXWVSUHFKHUQ NQDFNWH XQG UDXVFKWH HV (U UHJXOLHUWH GDV)XQNJHUlWQHXHLQ 'DQQ K|UWH HU HLQH YHU]HUUWH 6WLPPH =XQlFKVW NRQQWH HU VLH QLFKW YHUVWHKHQ GRFK GDQQ ZXUGH VLH GHXWOLFKHU -H PDQG IRUGHUWH GHQ .RPPDQGDQWHQ GHU $192< HQHUJLVFKDXIHLQhEHUQDKPHNRPPDQGRDQ%RUG]XODVVHQ 6¶9DQJRU%UDGG DQWZRUWHWH (U KDWWH JURH 0KH VHLQH :RUWH ]X DUWLNXOLHUHQ )UGLH0lQQHULQGHP%HLERRWGDVVLFKLKQHQQlKHUWHPRFKWHHVVLFKVRDQK|UHQDOV REHUXQWHU$ONRKROHLQIOXVWQGH 'HU .RPPDQGDQW GHV NOHLQHQ 5DXPHUV HUNOlUWH GD HU GLH $192< EHIHKOLJHQZHUGH ³/DVVHQ 6LH XQV DQ %RUG NRPPHQ VDJWH HU ³:LU ZHUGHQ GDV 6FKLII QDFK 7ROYWDPXUEULQJHQ´ $WODQ KDWWH GLHVHQ 3ODQHWHQQDPHQ QRFK QLH ]XYRU JHK|UW (U YHUULHW LKP EHUKDXSW QLFKWV ,Q]ZLVFKHQ KDWWH HU VLFK LPPHU ZLHGHU XPJHVHKHQ XP DXV GHU .RQVWHOODWLRQGHU6WHUQHHWZDVHUNHQQHQ]XN|QQHQGRFKHLQHHFKWH,QIRUPDWLRQKDWWH HU QLFKW HUKDOWHQ (U JODXEWH DQQHKPHQ ]X N|QQHQ GD HU VLFK DXI GHU :HVWVLGH GHU *DOD[LVEHIDQG (U KDWWH EHUOHJW RE HU HV ZDJHQ N|QQH ]XVDPPHQ PLW GHP %HLERRW LQ GLH $192<HLQ]XGULQJHQKDWWHGLHVHQ3ODQMHGRFKZLHGHUYHUZRUIHQ(UZDUYLHO]XULVNDQW (U ZDU PLW GLHVHP 6FKLIIVW\S JXW YHUWUDXW 6FKOLHOLFK ZDU GLH $192< HLQ DOWHV DUNRQLGLVFKHV 6FKLII (V PXWH DQGHUH 0|JOLFKNHLWHQ JHEHQ ZLHGHU LQ GDV 6FKLII ]X NRPPHQ /DQJVDP OLH HU VLFK EHU GLH .XJHOIOlFKH WUHLEHQ ,PPHU ZLHGHU NODQJ GLH 6WLPPH GHV %HLERRWNRPPDQGDQWHQ LQ VHLQHQ +HOPODXWVSUHFKHUQ DXI $XFK GLHVHU 0DQQ VFKLHQ XQWHU HLQHU KDUWHQ %HODVWXQJ ]X VWHKHQ RGHU GDV )XQNJHUlW ZDU QLFKW LQ 2UGQXQJGHQQVHLQH%HIHKOHZXUGHQYRQ0LQXWH]X0LQXWHVFKZHUHUYHUVWlQGOLFK $WODQEOLFNWHLQGDV$OOKLQDXV(UNRQQWHGHQNHJHOI|UPLJHQ%HKlOWHUMHGRFKQLFKW PHKU VHKHQ (U ]ZHLIHOWH DEHU QLFKW GDUDQ GD GLH 7HIURGHU LP %HLERRW DOOPlKOLFK LQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
GHQ (LQIOXEHUHLFK GLHVHU :DIIH NDPHQ ZlKUHQG GLH %HVDW]XQJ GHU $192< VLFK HLQ ZHQLJ IDQJHQ NRQQWH 'LH (QWIHUQXQJ ]ZLVFKHQ LKU XQG GHP .HJHO ZDU VSUEDU JHZDFKVHQ (V ZLUG =HLW PHOGHWH VLFK GDV ([WUDKLUQ :HQQ VLFK GLH 7HIURGHU QRFK PHKU HUKROHQLVWHV]XVSlWIUGLFK (U IDQG GHQ $XVWULWWVVFKDFKW GHU .OLPDDQODJH QHEHQ GHU HLQH NOHLQH (LQPDQQVFKOHXVH ODJ $WODQ EHUOHJWH NXU] (U PXWH GLH 9HUVFKOVVH ]HUVFKLHHQ ZHQQHUGLH6FKRWWH|IIQHQZROOWH,QGHP5DXP GDKLQWHUZUGHGHU'UXFNVFKODJDUWLJ DEIDOOHQ'DVEHGHXWHWHGDMHGHUGRUWLQW|GOLFKHU*HIDKUVFKZHEWHIDOOVHUQLFKWHLQHQ 6FKXW]DQ]XJWUXJ (U SUIWH GHQ 6DXHUVWRIIYRUUDW hEHUUDVFKW VWHOOWH HU IHVW GD HU QXU QRFK EHU VHKUJHULQJH5HVHUYHQYHUIJWH -HW]W EOLHE LKP NHLQH DQGHUH :DKO PHKU (U NRQQWH HV VLFK QLFKW OHLVWHQ QDFK DQGHUHQ (LQWULWWVP|JOLFKNHLWHQ ]X VXFKHQ (U O|VWH VHLQHQ %ODVWHU DXV 'HU ,QQHQGUXFN VSUHQJWHGLH 6FKRWWH(LQ EUHLWHU6SDOWHQWVWDQG GXUFK GHQ GLH/XIWHQWZLFK$WODQ]RJ VLFKGXUFKGLHg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lQQHU]XU6HLWHXQGEUDFKVRMHGHQ:LGHUVWDQGGHUVLFKLKPERW (LQLJH 7HIURGHU VDKHQ LKQ DXI VLFK ]XNRPPHQ 6LH JULIIHQ ]X LKUHQ :DIIHQ XQG YHUVXFKWHQLKQPLW(QHUJLHVFKVVHQ]XW|WHQGRFKEHYRUVLHVFKLHHQNRQQWHQZDUHU VFKRQEHLLKQHQXQGUHPSHOWHVLHXP 8QDQJHIRFKWHQHUUHLFKWHHU HLQHQ$QWLJUDYVFKDFKW,Q GLHVHPVFKZHEWHHU QDFK REHQ ELV 'HFN 0HKUHUH 2IIL]LHUH HUZDUWHWHQ LKQ (U VDK LKUH KRFKURWHQ *HVLFKWHU XQG LKUH YHUGUHKWHQ $XJHQ 6LH YHUULHWHQ LKP GD GLHVH 0lQQHU NHLQHVZHJV ZXWHQ ZDVVLHWDWHQ(UQDKPNHLQH5FNVLFKW(UVFKRPLWGHP3DUDO\VDWRUDXIVLHXQGIlOOWH HLQLJHYRQLKQHQ=ZHLDQGHUH7HIURGHUSDFNWHQLKQDQGHQ6FKXOWHUQ6LHVFKOXJHQPLW GHQ.ROEHQLKUHU6WUDKOHUDXILKQHLQHU]LHOWHQMHGRFKQXUHLQHJHULQJH:LUNXQJGDGLH PHLVWHQ+LHEHJHJHQGHQJHVFKORVVHQHQ+HOPJLQJHQ (LQ ,QJHQLHXU ZDUI VLFK YRQ KLQWHQ JHJHQ VHLQH %HLQH XQG EUDFKWH LKQ ]X )DOO 6RIRUW VWU]WHQ VLFK GLH DQGHUHQ 0lQQHU DXI LKQ (U NRQQWH VHLQH :DIIH QLFKW PHKU HLQVHW]HQZHQQHUVLFKQLFKWVHOEVWJHIlKUGHQZROOWH6REHPKWHHUVLFKGLH*HJQHU PLWJH]LHOWHQ)DXVWVFKOlJHQ]XYHUWUHLEHQ-HW]WKLQGHUWHLKQGHU5DXPDQ]XJ .RVWEDUH=HLWYHUVWULFK ,Q MHGHU 6HNXQGH WULHE GHU .HJHO ZHLWHU YRQ GHU $192< IRUW 'DPLW YHUULQJHUWH VLFK VHLQH 0DFKW LPPHU PHKU $WODQ VSUWHHV DQ GHQ 5HDNWLRQHQ GHU 7HIURGHU 3DQLN NDPLQLKPDXI:HQQHVLKPQLFKWJHODQJVFKQHOOLQGLH)HXHUOHLW]HQWUDOHYRU]XGULQJHQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
ZDUYLHOOHLFKWDOOHVXPVRQVWJHZHVHQ 'HLQHWHFKQLVFKH$XVUVWXQJELHWHWGLUDOOH0|JOLFKNHLWHQHUNOlUWHGDV([WUDKLUQ :DUXPQXW]WGXVLHQLFKW" 6HLQH+DQGJHULHWDQGLH5HJHOVFKUDXEHGHV$QWLJUDYV(UGUHKWHVLHYROOKHUXP XQGVWLHJJHJHQGLH 'HFNHGHV9RUUDXPHV'LH7HIURGHUWURSIWHQI|UPOLFK YRQLKPDE (U SUDOOWH PLW GHP 5FNHQ DXI XQG EOLHE EHU VHLQHQ *HJQHUQ DQ GHU 9HUVFKDOXQJ KDIWHQ 6LH NRQQWHQ LKQ KLHU QLFKW PHKU HUUHLFKHQ DEHU HU NRQQWH VLH PLW JH]LHOWHQ 3DUDO\VDWRUVFKVVHQDXVVFKDOWHQ $OV DOOH 0lQQHU UHJXQJVORV DXI GHP %RGHQ ODJHQ OLH HU VLFK ZLHGHU KHUDEVLQNHQ (U O|VWH GHQ +HOP YRP $Q]XJ XQG ZDUI LKQ ZHJ 'DQQ HLOWH HU ZHLWHU DQ GHQ +DXSWVFKRWWHQ GHU =HQWUDOH YRUEHL ]X GHP 6RQGHUVFKDFKW GHU GLUHNW ELV 'HFN KLQDXIIKUWH (U YHUOLH VLFK QLFKW DXI GHQ $QWLJUDY GHV /LIWHV VRQGHUQ EHQXW]WH VHLQ HLJHQHV *HUlW PLW GHP HU VFKQHOO DXIVWLHJ 1RFK HLQPDO ZROOWH HU VLFK QLFKW EHUUDVFKHQ ODVVHQ (U QDKP VHLQH :DIIH LQ GLH +DQG XQG ULFKWHWH VLH DXI GLH (QG|IIQXQJGHV6FKDFKWHVGRFKMHW]WHUZDUWHWHLKQQLHPDQG (U VSUDQJ LQ GHQ 9RUUDXP KLQDXV XQG EOLFNWH VLFK XP 6HLQ $WHP JLQJ VFKQHOO XQG KDVWLJ XQG VHLQH $XJHQ WUlQWHQ 'LH (UUHJXQJ GURKWH LKQ ]X EHUPDQQHQ (U EHIDQGVLFKLQHLQHP7ROOKDXVLQGHPVLFKQLFKWVEHUHFKQHQOLH :DVZDUDXV1XUDP\JHZRUGHQ" :R ZDUHQ &LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
VLFK VFKRQ HLQPDO PLW +LOIH VHLQHV $QWLJUDYV JHUHWWHW KDWWH $EHUPDOV YHUVXFKWH HU VHLQHQ $QJUHLIHUQ DXI GLHVH :HLVH ]X HQWNRPPHQ (U VWLHJ VHQNUHFKW QDFK REHQ -HPDQG KLHOW VHLQH %HLQH IHVW (U VWUDPSHOWH VR NUlIWLJ ZLH HU JHUDGH NRQQWH XQG EHIUHLWH VLFK GDGXUFK =XJOHLFK NODPPHUWHQ VLFK GLH )LQJHU VHLQHU UHFKWHQ +DQG XP VHLQH:DIIHXQGO|VWHQVLHLPPHUZLHGHUEOLQGDXV(UNRQQWHQLFKWVPHKUVHKHQ(LQLJH 6FKOlJH WUDIHQ LKQ DQ GHQ +IWHQ XQG DQ GHQ %HLQHQ GDQQ HQGOLFK HQWNDP HU GHQ 2IIL]LHUHQ 'HU =HOODNWLYDWRU SXOVLHUWH XQJHZ|KQOLFK KHIWLJ ZlKUHQG $WODQ XP VHLQ %HZXWVHLQ NlPSIWH :LHGHU XQG ZLHGHU O|VWH HU GHQ 3DUDO\VDWRU DXV ZlKUHQG HU YHU]ZHLIHOWKRIIWHGDQLHPDQGYRQGHQ7HIURGHUQEHUHLQHQ(QHUJLHVWUDKOHUYHUIJWH $OOPlKOLFK NOlUWHQ VLFK VHLQH %OLFNH DEHU GLH 7DXEKHLW DXI VHLQHU OLQNHQ 6HLWH EOLHE (U VDK GD HLQLJH 0lQQHU 6HVVHO KHUDQUROOWHQ 2IIHQVLFKWOLFK ZROOWHQ VLH KLQDXIVWHLJHQXPLKQVRHUUHLFKHQ]XN|QQHQ(UVFKRPLWGHP3DUDO\VDWRUDXIVLH 6HNXQGHQQXUGDXHUWHGHU.DPSIGDQQJODXEWHHUDOOH*HJQHUDXVJHVFKDOWHW]X KDEHQ (U OLH VLFK DXI GHQ %RGHQ KHUDEVLQNHQ XQG EOLFNWH VLFK VXFKHQG XP hEHUDOO ODJHQ7HIURGHUDXIGHP%RGHQ.HLQHUYRQLKQHQEHZHJWHVLFKQRFK'DV+DXSWVFKRWW VWDQG RIIHQ (U KLQNWH KLQEHU XQG VFKOR HV ZHLO HU QLFKW EHUUDVFKW ZHUGHQ ZROOWH 'DQQHLOWHHU]XGHQ)HXHUOHLWElQNHQXQGEHUSUIWHVLH'DV,QVWUXPHQWDULXPJDELKP NHLQH5lWVHODXI(UNRQQWHOHLFKWPLWLKPIHUWLJZHUGHQ 'LH2UWXQJVVFKLUPHIODPPWHQDXI 6RIRUW HQWGHFNWH HU GDV %HLERRW GDV VLFK VHKU VFKQHOO GHU $192< QlKHUWH (U VFKlW]WHGDHVK|FKVWHQVQRFK]HKQ.LORPHWHUYRQLKUHQWIHUQWZDU6HNXQGHQVSlWHU IDQGHUDXFKGHQ%HKlOWHU(UZDUEHUHLWVDFKW]LJ.LORPHWHUDEJHWULHEHQ (U ]ZDQJ VLFK GD]X UXKLJ XQG JOHLFKPlLJ ]X DWPHQ 0LW GHP +DQGUFNHQ ZLVFKWH HU VLFK GLH VW|UHQGHQ 7UlQHQ DXV GHQ $XJHQ (U PXWH MHW]W UXKLJHU ZHUGHQ XQGGLH(UUHJXQJHLQGlPPHQ 6RUJIlOWLJ ULFKWHWH HU GUHL (QHUJLHVWUDKOHU DXV 'LH $XIJDEH HUZLHV VLFK DOV ZHLWDXV VFKZLHULJHU DOV HU HUZDUWHW KDWWH GHQQ GLH $192< IORJ QLFKW UXKLJ VRQGHUQ VFKZDQNWHOHLFKW 6RZDQGHUWHGHU.HJHOLPPHUZLHGHUDXVGHU=LHORSWLN $WODQ K|UWH GLH 6WLPPHQ YRQ PHKUHUHQ 0lQQHUQ GLH VLFK GHU )HXHU]HQWUDOH QlKHUWHQ(UNRQQWHQLFKWHUPLWWHOQDXVZHOFKHU5LFKWXQJVLHNDPHQ (QWVFKORVVHQIHXHUWHHUGLH(QHUJLHNDQRQHQDE =XIUKVWHOOWHGDV([WUDKLUQQFKWHUQIHVW+DVWVFKDGHWQXU ³$XIGHQ*HGDQNHQZlUHLFKQLHJHNRPPHQ´JDE$WODQZWHQG]XUFN 'XKDVWGLH$XVJOHLFKVHOHNWURQLNEHUVHKHQVDJWHGDV([WUDKLUQ $WODQVFKDOWHWHGDV+LOIVJHUlWHLQ-HW]WSHQGHOWHQVLFKGLH(QHUJLHNDQRQHQHLQ 'UHL(QHUJLHEDONHQ]XFNWHQLQGDV$OOKLQDZ &LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
$XJHQ]HUULVVHQ(UNRQQWHZLHGHUNODUHUGHQNHQ1RFKZDUHUQLFKWJDQ]IUHL(UVSUWH GLHXQVLFKWEDUHQ)HVVHOQGHXWOLFKGRFKVLHVDHQOlQJVWQLFKWPHKUVRIHVWZLHYRUKHU 6LHEHODVWHWHQLKQNDXPQRFK (UEOLFNWH]XUFN 'LHDQGHUHQ0lQQHUGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQVWDQGHQQRFKLPPHU]XVDPPHQPLW $OG\DQ.DSIODUDQGHU6SDFH-HW6LH]|JHUWHQ'LHPHLVWHQVFKLHQHQJHQXJPLWVLFK VHOEVW]XWXQKDEHQXQGQLFKWLQGHU/DJH]XVHLQVLFKMHW]WPLWZLFKWLJHQ$XIJDEHQ]X EHIDVVHQ(UKRIIWHGDGHU(UVWH3URMHNWLRQVIHOG,QJHQLHXUGLH,QLWLDWLYHDQVLFKUHLHQ ZHUGH(UYHUOLHGHQ+DQJDUXQGHLOWHDXIHLQHQ*DQJKLQDXV :RNRQQWH$WODQVHLQ" 6HLQH*HGDQNHQEHUVFKOXJHQVLFKXQGHUZXQGHUWHVLFKZLHNODUXQGORJLVFK HUGHQNHQNRQQWH(UVWLHJLQHLQHQ$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWXQGOLHVLFKQDFKREHQWUDJHQ 1DFKZHQLJHQ0LQXWHQHUUHLFKWHHUGLH+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOH:LHHUZDUWHWKHUUVFKWHKLHU HLQKHNWLVFKHV'XUFKHLQDQGHU6¶9DQJRU%UDGGXQG&D0LQJRUEUOOWHQLKUH%HIHKOH GXUFKHLQDQGHU'HU7HUUDQHUWREWH
$WODQ NRQQWH QLFKW HUNHQQHQ RE HV LKP JHOXQJHQ ZDU GDV =LHOREMHNW ]X ]HUVW|UHQ (U ZXWH GD HU HV JHWURIIHQ KDWWH -HW]W EHZHJWH HV VLFK PLW KRKHU *HVFKZLQGLJNHLWDXIGHQ3ODQHWHQ]XGHQGHU8QEHNDQQWH7ROYWDPXUJHQDQQWKDWWH ,Q DOOHU (LOH YHUVXFKWH HU GLH =LHORSWLN HUQHXW ]X MXVWLHUHQ GRFK MHW]W KDWWH HU ZHQLJHU*OFN'HU.HJHORGHUGDVZDVYRQLKPEULJJHEOLHEHQZDUOLHILPPHUZLHGHU DXVGHP(UIDVVXQJVNUHX] 'LH 6FKRWWH |IIQHWHQ VLFK $WODQ K|UWH GD PHKUHUH 0lQQHU LQ GLH )HXHUOHLW]HQWUDOHNDPHQ(UOLHVLFKDXVGHP6HVVHOIDOOHQLQGHPHUJHVHVVHQKDWWH 'DEHL VDK HU GD GUHL 7HIURGHU DXI LKQ ]XVWUPWHQ 6LH KLHOWHQ LKUH :DIIHQ LP $QVFKODJ (UVFKRVRIRUW'DQQUROOWHHUVLFK]XU6HLWHXQGO|VWHGLH:DIIHDEHUPDOVDXV 'LHGUHL0lQQHUVDQNHQEHWlXEW]X%RGHQ (U HUKRE VLFK 1RFK LPPHU IKOWH VLFK HLQH 6HLWH WDXE DQ 6R ILHO LKP MHGHU¶
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
6FKULWWVFKZHUGDLKPZHGHU$UPHQRFK%HLQHZLHJHZRKQWJHKRUFKWHQ $XIGHQ%LOGVFKLUPHQNRQQWHHUGDV%HLERRWYRQ7ROYWDPXUGHXWOLFKDXVPDFKHQ (V JLQJ OlQJVVHLWV (LQH 6FKOHXVH |IIQHWH VLFK *HJHQ GHQ KHOOHQ +LQWHUJUXQG KREHQ VLFK GLH 6LOKRXHWWHQ ]ZHLHU 0lQQHU GHXWOLFK DE 6LH O|VWHQ VLFK YRQ GHU -HW XQG VFKZHEWHQ DXI GLH $192< ]X $Q GHQ .RQWUROODQ]HLJHQ NRQQWH $WODQ YHUIROJHQ GD HLQHGHUJURHQ6FKOHXVHQGHV6FKLIIHVYRQGHU+DXSWOHLW]HQWUDOHDXVJH|IIQHWZXUGH 1RFK HLQPDO YHUVXFKWH HU HLQH GHU ,PSXOVNDQRQHQ ]X MXVWLHUHQ 0KVDP JOLWWHQ VHLQH +lQGH EHU GLH .RQWUROOHQ-HGH %HZHJXQJ NRVWHWH LKQ XQJHKHXUH$QVWUHQJXQJHQ (U PXWHHVVFKDIIHQ (LQ)UHLOLFKWOHXFKWHWHDXI $WODQO|VWHGLH,PSXOVNDQRQHDXV9ROOHU6SDQQXQJEOLFNWHHUDXIGLH%LOGVFKLUPH 'LH (QHUJLHEDKQ JOLWW LQ GDV 1LFKWV KLQDXV XQG ZHLW YRQ GHU $192< HQWIHUQW IODPPWH HV HUQHXW DXI (LQ ZHLHU %DOO EUHLWHWH VLFK DXV +DWWH HU HLQHQ 7UHIIHU HU]LHOW RGHU VDK HU QXU GDV 7REHQ GHU HQHUJHWLVFKHQ *HZDOWHQ LQ GHQ 6FKXW]VFKLUPHQ GHV .HJHOEHKlOWHUV" ³6WHKHQ6LHDXIXQGOHJHQ6LHGLH+lQGHDXIGHQ.RSI´VDJWHMHPDQGKLQWHULKP PLW EHKHUUVFKWHU NKOHU 6WLPPH ³:HQQ 6LH QLFKW JHKRUFKHQ VHKH LFK PLFK JH]ZXQJHQ6LH]XW|WHQ´ (UEOLFNWHEHUGLH6FKXOWHU]XUFN +LQWHU LKP VWDQG HLQ 2IIL]LHU GHQ HU QLH ]XYRU JHVHKHQ KDWWH 'DV *HVLFKW GHV 0DQQHV YHUULHW HLVNDOWH (QWVFKORVVHQKHLW 'LH $XJHQ ZDUHQ NODU XQG OLHHQ KRKH ,QWHOOLJHQ]HUNHQQHQ ³'DV ZDU GDV 3UREOHP´ HUZLGHUWH GHU $UNRQLGH XQG HUKRE VLFK ODQJVDP RKQH GLH +lQGH ]X HUKHEHQ ³6RODQJH LFK GHQ .HJHO XQEHKHOOLJW OLH NRQQWH PLU HLJHQWOLFK QLFKWYLHOJHVFKHKHQ-HW]WVFKHLQWHVGDLFKLKQ]XPLQGHVWDQJHVFKODJHQKDEHDEHU GDPLW VLQG 6LH ZLHGHU ]X NODUHP 9HUVWDQG JHNRPPHQ XQG PHLQH &KDQFHQ VLQG JHVFKZXQGHQ´ ³6ROOWHVLFK]HLJHQGD6LHGHQ.HJHOWDWVlFKOLFKYHUQLFKWHWKDEHQZHUGHQ6LH GDV]XEHQKDEHQ´ ³'DVZHUGHLFKZRKODXFKVR´HQWJHJQHWH$WODQJHODVVHQ (U HQWGHFNWH &LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
VFKRQYLHOJHZRQQHQ´ 8QJHUQ QDKP $WODQ GLH HUQHXWH 9HU]|JHUXQJ LQ .DXI DEHU HU ZXWH GD HV NHLQH DQGHUH 0|JOLFKNHLW JDE VLFK YRQ GHU $192< DE]XVHW]HQ 6LH PXWHQ GLH 7HIURGHUGDUDQKLQGHUQGLH)HXHUOHLW]HQWUDOH]XEHWUHWHQXQGGLHVFKZHUHQ%RUGZDIIHQ JHJHQVLHHLQ]XVHW]HQ1XUGDQQKDWWHQVLHHLQH&KDQFH $WODQVDKGD&LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
IODFNHUQ'LH EHLGHQ0lQQHUEOLHEHQ VWHKHQ 6LHEHIDQGHQVLFK LQ HLQHUHOHNWURQLVFKHQ :HUNVWDWW +LHU DUEHLWHWHQ VRQVW GLH ,QJHQLHXUH XQG )DFKHOHNWURQLNHU GLH GHQ WHFKQLVFKHQ $SSDUDW GHU )HXHUOHLW XQG )XQN]HQWUDOH DQJHVFKORVVHQHQ (OHNWURQLN XQG 3RVLWURQLN EHUZDFKWHQ XQG QRWIDOOV UHSDULHUWHQ $XFK KLHU ]HLJWHQ VLFK 6SXUHQ YRQ VLQQORVHQ.lPSIHQ ³$FKWXQJKLHUVSULFKWGHU.RPPDQGDQW¶EHJDQQ6¶9DQJRU%UDGGZlKUHQGVHLQ *HVLFKW DXI GHQ %LOGVFKLUPHQ HUVFKLHQ ³'LH .ULVH LVW EHUVWDQGHQ :LU EUDXFKHQ MHW]W QLFKW PHKU GDPLW ]X UHFKQHQ GD HV QRFK HLQPDO ]X lKQOLFKHQ 9RUIlOOHQ ZLH LQ GHQ OHW]WHQ 7DJHQ NRPPW $OOH %HVDW]XQJVPLWJOLHGHU NHKUHQ MHW]W VRIRUW DQ LKUH 3OlW]H ]XUFN 'DUEHU KLQDXV ULFKWH LFK PHLQH :RUWH DQ GHQ $UNRQLGHQ $WODQ GHU YHUVXFKW VLFKXQV]XHQW]LHKHQ'DVLVWMHW]WMHGRFKQLFKWPHKUP|JOLFK,FKIRUGHUH6LHGDKHUDXI $WODQ HEHQIDOOV DXJHQEOLFNOLFK LQ GLH ,KQHQ ]XJHZLHVHQH .DELQH ]XUFN]XJHKHQ 6LH N|QQHQ VLFK DXI GLHVHP 6FKLII QLFKW YRU XQV YHUEHUJHQ :LU ZHUGHQ 6LH ILQGHQ QRFK EHYRUZLUXQVHUQlFKVWHV=LHOHUUHLFKWKDEHQ ,FK HUZDUWH GD 6LH VLFK LQQHUKDOE GHU QlFKVWHQ IQI 0LQXWHQ PHOGHQ 6ROOWHQ 6LHHVQLFKWWXQKDEHQ6LHGLH.RQVHTXHQ]HQ]XWUDJHQ:LUGHQNHQQLFKWPHKUGDUDQ ,KQHQLUJHQGZHOFKH)UHLKHLWHQDQ%RUG]XJHZlKUHQ´ ³:DVZHUGHQ6LHWXQ6LU"´IUDJWH&LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
YRP$QWLJUDYVFKDFKWDXVQLFKWVHKHQNRQQWH 'UHL ,QJHQLHXUH WUDWHQ XQPLWWHOEDU QHEHQ LKQHQ DXV GHU gIIQXQJ 6LH WUXJHQ GLH JUQOLFKHQ 8QLIRUPHQ GHU :DIIHQVSH]LDOLVWHQ +HIWLJ GLVNXWLHUHQG HLOWHQ VLH DXI HLQ 6FKRWW]X6LHEOLFNWHQVLFKQLFKWXP $WODQKLHOWVHLQHQ%ODVWHULQGHU+DQG(UKlWWHLKQDXI3DUDO\VHZLUNXQJJHVWHOOW $QJHVSDQQW ZDUWHWH HU 4XlOHQG ODQJVDP |IIQHWH VLFK GHU 'XUFKJDQJ 'LH ,QJHQLHXUH JLQJHQZHLWHUXQGGLH6FKRWWHVFKORVVHQVLFKZLHGHUKLQWHULKQHQ $WODQDWPHWHDXI (UZROOWHQLFKWVFKLHHQ-HGHU=ZLVFKHQIDOOZUGHVLHYHUUDWHQ ³:LHZHLWKDEHQZLU¶VQRFK"´IUDJWHHU ³1RFK]ZHL'HFNV´DQWZRUWHWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
³1LFKWV LVW LQ 2UGQXQJ 'DIU KDEHQ ZLU JHVRUJW 1RFK NDQQ PDQ XQV QLFKW DEVFKLHHQ:LUEUDXFKHQQXU]XVWDUWHQ´ 'LH 7HIURGHU IKUWHQ GHQ /RUGDGPLUDO ]XP 6FKLII $WODQ ZXQGHUWH VLFK GDUEHU GD HU VHOEVW VR UXKLJ XQG JHODVVHQ ZDU =XP HUVWHQPDO VHLW ODQJHU =HLW ERW VLFK LKP HLQH KHUYRUUDJHQGH )OXFKWP|JOLFKNHLW 'LH &KDQFHQ ZDUHQ DXVUHLFKHQG GD GLH 7HIURGHUJXWH9RUDUEHLWJHOHLVWHWKDWWHQ9RQMHW]WDQZUGHQQXUQRFKZHQLJH6WXQGHQ YHUJHKHQELVHUPLWGHU862.RQWDNWDXIQHKPHQNRQQWH$OOHVZHLWHUHZUGHVLFKGDQQ YRQVHOEVWHUJHEHQ (U EHWUDW GLH -HW GXUFK GLH %RGHQVFKOHXVH ,P $QWLJUDYVFKDFKW JOLWW HU ELV ]XU =HQWUDOHKRFK hEHUUDVFKWVDKHUGDVLFKHWZD]HKQ0lQQHUKLHUDXIKLHOWHQ6LHVWDQGHQGLFKW JHGUlQJWXQGUHGHWHQHUUHJWGXUFKHLQDQGHU(LQVFKDUIHU=XUXI&LSSDURQ
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
EHU]HXJW ZDU GD 0LQJRU VHLQHQ HLJHQHQ 0DQQ QLFKW XPEULQJHQ ZUGH 6¶9DQJRU %UDGGDEHUNDPHVYHUPXWOLFKVRJDUJHOHJHQGD+DV.DWDUYHUVFKZDQG´ ³6RLVWHV&LSS´EHVWlWLJWH.DSIODU 'HU 3LORW GUFNWH HLQLJH .Q|SIH XQG 7DVWHQ .DSIODU OLH LKQ UXKLJ JHZlKUHQ 6FKOLHOLFK HUKRE VLFK GHU 3LORW EOLFNWH
5DXPVFKLIIGHU$PRNOlXIHU
M
$WODQ
ZHLWGRFKLQMHGHUJXWHQ(KHVROOWHHVKLQXQGZLHGHUHLQHQKDQGIHVWHQ.UDFKJHEHQ 1XQKDEHQZLUGLHVH)RUGHUXQJEHUHLWVIUHLQLJH-DKUHLPYRUDXVHUIOOW:LHZlUHHV ZHQQZLUQXQHQGOLFKDXFKHLQPDO]XGHQDQJHQHKPHQ'LQJHQNRPPHQZUGHQ´ 6LH EOLHE VWHKHQ 6LH KDWWHQ LKUHQ .DELQHQWUDNW HUUHLFKW 'LH 7HIURGHU |IIQHWHQ GDV(LQJDQJVVFKRWW ³,FK KlWWH QLFKW EHO /XVW GLU GXUFK HLQ SDDU 2KUIHLJHQ ]X ]HLJHQ ZDV LFK YRQ GHLQHP9RUVFKODJKDOWH´VDJWHVLHZWHQG (UOlFKHOWH ³6LHKVWGXGDVPHLQWHLFK´HUZLGHUWHHUXQGJLQJDQLKUYRUEHLLQVHLQH.DELQH 6LH IROJWH LKP +LQWHU LKQHQ JOLWWHQ GLH 6FKRWWH ]X (U VHW]WH VLFK LQ HLQHQ 6HVVHO XQG ]QGHWHVLFKHLQH=LJDUHWWHDQ ³,FKELQEHU]HXJWGDYRQGDLQGHP.HJHO36,0DWHULHHQWKDOWHQZDURGHULVW´ VDJWHHUEHUJDQJVORV 6LHZDUQRFKPLWJDQ]DQGHUHQ*HGDQNHQEHVFKlIWLJWXQGEUDXFKWHHLQLJH=HLW XPXPGHQNHQ]XN|QQHQ=XQlFKVWZROOWHVLHQRFKHWZDV]XVHLQHQYRUKHULJHQ:RUWHQ VDJHQ GDQQ MHGRFK VDK VLH HLQ GD HU GDIU MHW]W QLFKW PHKU DQVSUHFKEDU ZDU 9HUlUJHUW JLQJ VLH LQ¶ LKUH .DELQH KLQEHU NDP MHGRFK VFKRQ VHKU EDOG ZLHGHU ]XUFN XQGVHW]WHVLFKLKPJHJHQEHULQHLQHQDQGHUHQ6HVVHO ³:DVLVWJHVFKHKHQ"´IUDJWHVLHQFKWHUQ $WODQEHULFKWHWH ³8QGGXJODXEVWGDGXGHQ.HJHO]HUVW|UWKDVW"´ (UVFKWWHOWHGHQ.RSI ³-HOlQJHULFKGDUEHUQDFKGHQNHGHVWRPHKUNRPPHLFK]XGHUhEHU]HXJXQJ GDLFKHVQLFKWJHWDQKDEH1XUDP\:DKUVFKHLQOLFKKDEHLFKLKQQXUEHVFKlGLJW´ ³(UWUHLEWMHW]WDXIGLHVHQ3ODQHWHQ7ROY]X"´ ³7ROYWDPXUMD´ ³'DQQ KDW GLH %HY|ONHUXQJ QLFKWV *XWHV ]X HUZDUWHQ :HQQ GHU .HJHO DXI GHQ 3ODQHWHQ VWU]W EULFKW GRUW GDV &KDRV DXV +RIIHQ ZLU GD GX GDV 'LQJ GRFK ]HUVW|UW KDVW´ ³'DVZHUGHQZLUZRKOVHKUEDOGHUIDKUHQ'LH$192<IOLHJWQDFK7ROYWDPXU´ 6LHEOLFNWHQVLFKDQ (1'( /HVHQ6LHQlFKVWH:RFKH$7/$1H[FOXVLY1U
)OXFKWDXVGHP7DUNLKO
YRQ&ODUN'DUOWRQ 'LH+lVFKHUGHV,PSHUDWRUVNRPPHQ² VLHIRUGHUQGHQ.RSIGHV.ULVWDOOSULQ]HQ