Preventing Talent Loss
Preventing Talent Loss provides a comprehensive model of giftedness and talent for all educator...
93 downloads
1905 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Preventing Talent Loss
Preventing Talent Loss provides a comprehensive model of giftedness and talent for all educators including teachers, counselors, and administrators. By presenting a summary of theory-driven, evidence-based knowledge, Hong and Milgram offer innovative and practical solutions for meeting the challenge of coping with talent loss. This monumental book distinguishes the important difference between expert talent and creative talent. While other books focus on how to improve the process of identifying the gifted and talented, Preventing Talent Loss provides educators with the means to individualize their curriculum and instruction in regular classrooms. Eunsook Hong is Professor of the Department of Educational Psychology at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas (UNLV). Roberta M. Milgram is Professor, Ariel University Center of Samaria, Israel, and Professor Emeritus, Tel Aviv University, Israel.
Preventing Talent Loss
Eunsook Hong Roberta M. Milgram
First published 2008 by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Simultaneously published in the UK by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2011. To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk. © 2008 Taylor & Francis All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Hong, Eunsook. Preventing talent loss / Eunsook Hong, Roberta M. Milgram. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Gifted children–Education. 2. Creative ability. 3. Academic achievement. I. Milgram, Roberta M. II. Title. LC3993.2.H66 2008 371.95–dc22 2007034954 ISBN 0-203-93148-3 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN 10: 0–8058–5712–5(hbk) ISBN 10: 0–8058–5713–3(pbk) ISBN 10: 0–203–93148–3(ebk) ISBN 13: 978–0-8058–5712–2(hbk) ISBN 13: 978–0-8058–5713–9(pbk) ISBN 13: 978–0–203–93148–6(ebk)
For Lonnie Rowell and Noach (Norman) Milgram, in gratitude for their support, patience, and insight
Contents
Preface Part 1
Understanding Talent Loss 1
Preventing Talent Loss: a major challenge facing educators and parents Talent loss Sources of talent loss
2
A New Direction in Conceptualization: a comprehensive model of giftedness and talent Characteristics of a good model A comprehensive model of giftedness and talent
Part 2
xi
1 3 4 5 11 12 13
Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development
21
3
23 23
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development Domain-general and domain-specific analytical-thinking ability
viii • Contents
4
Relationship between analytical-thinking ability and creativity Instruments used to measure analytical-thinking ability Preventing talent loss
24 26 32
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development Domain-general versus domain-specific creative-thinking ability Relationship between domain-general and domain-specific creative thinking Relationship between creative thinking abilities and creative talent Relationship between creative-thinking and analytical-thinking abilities Instruments used to measure creative-thinking ability Preventing talent loss
35
Part 3
Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development 5
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development Self-regulated learning Motivational attributes Learning styles and preferences Preventing talent loss
6
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development Complexity and uniqueness of affective and intrapersonal characteristics Affect: emotion and anxiety Intrapersonal characteristics Preventing talent loss
7
Biological Attributes and Talent Development Genetics and talent development Sex and age: academic, motivational, and emotional characteristics Preventing talent loss
35 37 38 38 40 43
47 49 49 52 56 59 65 66 67 72 76 79 80 83 89
Contents • ix Part 4
Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development
91
8
Schools: part of the problem of talent loss or part of the solution? Assessment and identification Differentiation of curriculum and instruction Special topics Preventing talent loss
93 94 99 108 110
9
School Personnel and Climate Teachers Counselors Preventing talent loss
113 114 116 120
10
Family, Mentors, and Diversity The role of family in talent development The role of mentors in talent development Socio-cultural background and cultural diversity Preventing talent loss
123 123 127 131 134
Part 5
Becoming Talented
149
11
Technology for Preventing Talent Loss The role of computers: then and now Technology as a tool Technology and learning environment Preventing talent loss
137 138 139 144 147
12
Becoming Talented: expert talent and creative talent Expert talent and creative talent: similarities and differences Expert talent and creative talent in children and adults Developmental stages of expert and creative talents Preventing talent loss
151 153 159 161 164
Epilogue Foundational characteristics and attributes for talent development and talent loss Talent development: a continuous process for all individuals
169 170 171
x • Contents Improving identification and selection processes to reduce talent loss Teaching strategies designed to prevent talent loss: differentiation of curriculum and individualization of instruction for all learners Technology-integrated curriculum and instruction Teacher training: preservice and in-service Financial support – redefining priorities A modest proposal
172 172 172 173 173
References Subject index Author index
175 213 227
171
Preface
We have been conducting research and teaching courses on topics of giftedness and creativity for many years. On the basis of this experience, we reached the conclusion that talent loss is one of the major challenges facing parents and educators today. The goals of this book are to contribute to a broad understanding of talent, to illustrate how talent is lost, and to suggest ways to meet the challenge of preventing talent loss. The book consists of 12 chapters and an epilogue and is divided into five parts.
Part 1: Understanding Talent Loss Part 1 includes two chapters. In the first chapter, talent loss is defined, its sources specified, and the goals of the book are presented. In the second, a new comprehensive model of giftedness and talent conceptualized to prevent talent loss is presented and the rationale for the model and its components are illustrated. Many factors are involved in preventing talent loss (e.g., theoretical foundation, identification, programs, individual characteristics). However, the way giftedness is conceptualized influences the process of identification of the gifted and determines the special educational opportunities provided for them. Accordingly, we give a high priority to a new model of giftedness that focuses on preventing talent loss.
xii • Preface
Part 2: Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development Part 2 includes two chapters on cognitive abilities, the major component of giftedness and talent. Chapter 3 discusses analytical-thinking ability and Chapter 4 creative-thinking ability. In each chapter, domain generality and domain specificity of cognitive abilities are clearly distinguished and the constructs are defined theoretically and operationally.
Part 3: Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development Part 3 is divided into three chapters. In Chapter 5, the metacognitive and motivational aspects of self-regulated learning and learning style preferences are discussed. Understanding how these personal–psychological characteristics affect talent loss can prepare educators and parents to provide support and assistance that can contribute to the development of desirable learner characterisitics, increase learning and prevent talent loss. Chapter 6 is devoted to illustrate how affect and personality traits, both positive, such as independence and responsibility, and negative, such as stress and anxiety, affect talent development and loss. We devote Chapter 6 to one topic to which much attention has been given in the literature of giftedness, that is, the effects of sex/gender and age, and one to which little attention is given, that is, the effects of genetics on talent. Interactions among these components are discussed with emphasis on their effects on talent loss.
Part 4: Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development Four chapters are included in Part 4. In Chapter 8 we discuss whether school is part of the problem of talent loss or part of the solution. We summarize and compare the various approaches to identification and the special education services offered by school systems. In Chapter 9 we discuss the roles of teachers and counselors in developing talent and preventing talent loss. In Chapter 10 the critical role of surroundings in talent development is highlighted, including the general socio-cultural setting, the specific family environment, and special influences such as mentors. Chapter 11 presents the historical background and recent advancement of computer technologies as an educational tool, emphasizes the advantages and problems that technology has brought to the field of talent development, and focuses on the major contribution that technology can make to preventing talent loss.
Preface • xiii
Part 5: Becoming Talented In Chapter 12, we present the two different types of talent (expert talent and creative talent) and explain the similarities and differences between the two postulated in the new model. This distinction represents an innovative conceptualization of talent. Understanding talent in this way can not only help identify and develop each type but can also help prevent the loss of talent that is the inevitable consequence of lack of this understanding. Books on giftedness and talent have appeared in the past few decades. Many of them focus on programs and some on theories of giftedness. Although some implications for talent loss have been drawn in these books, none have focused specifically on preventing talent loss. Studies have indicated that the majority of gifted children spend most of their time in regular classrooms, and the majority of these children do not receive proper education to help them realize their potential. This book will propose some solutions to this challenge. The book also directs the attention to the education of all children, focusing on technology-integrated curriculum and instruction that can be used for all levels of learners. The content of the book is comprehensive in that all characteristics and factors that contribute to talent development are covered in the effort to illustrate the need for understanding what shapes, helps, or prevents talent development in all individuals. Thus, the book is commendable for educators and parents as well as researchers and undergraduate and graduate students in special education, elementary and secondary education, and educational psychology. Essentially, the book will be of interest to individuals who are interested in talent development, giftedness, creativity, and gifted education. We thank the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, for support of a sabbatical leave year for the senior author. Eunsook Hong, the senior author, offers her appreciation to Roberta Milgram, who has been a colleague and friend for many years. Our collaborations throughout the years made this book possible. Special thanks go to her husband, Lonnie Rowell, for his love, patience, and support. Roberta Milgram wants to mention three people. She is grateful to her colleague, Eunsook Hong, for sharing her deep wisdom and understanding of all aspects of the development of talent and the challenge of preparing this book. She expresses her deep gratitude to her husband, Noach (Norman) Milgram, for his endless friendship, patience, and support. Finally, whenever she sees the title of this book, she always thinks of her “beautiful boy,” her grandson, Dashiell Ari Knapp, who was taken from us by leukemia at age 17 – a genuine talent loss.
part
1
Understanding Talent Loss
chapter
1
Preventing Talent Loss A major challenge facing educators and parents
We recently picked up a thin volume called Silences by Tillie Olsen (1989). The talented author herself is a high school dropout and an example of talent almost silenced. She presents many moving examples of creative writing talent almost silenced. She dedicated her book to the silenced and the almost silenced as follows: For our silenced people, century after century .€.€. refused respect, recognition; lost For those of us, (few yet in number, for the way is punishing) who begin to emerge into more flowered and rewarded use of our selves in ways denied to them; and by our achievement bearing witness to what was (and still is) being lost, silenced. We call these silences talent loss and have chosen to designate this topic as the major focus of this book. Optimists, it is said, define problems that arise in their lives as challenges and believe that most challenges can be met by applying their own abilities to meeting these challenges in a disciplined and focused manner. We consider talent loss to be one of the major challenges facing parents and educators today. The goals of this book are to contribute
4 • Understanding Talent Loss to a broad understanding of talent, to identify the process by which talent is lost, and to suggest ways to meet the challenge of preventing talent loss. We hope that this book will contribute to creating the opportunity for more of the silenced to be heard.
Talent loss Talent may be defined as extraordinary achievement in a specific domain. If we use this stringent definition, then talent in children and adolescents is a very rare phenomenon. What we observe in some at an early age is the potential for extraordinary achievement in a specific domain. We must be careful not to confuse potential with realized talent. Extraordinary achievement includes accomplishments in the aesthetic domains such as music, art, dance, and drama and also social, political, military, and moral leadership. It includes talent in business endeavors and extraordinary achievement in the realm of education. Societies that do not make every effort to assure that the potential talents of young people are utilized are losing their most valuable natural resource – human capital. The identification and enhancement of potential talents is not to be considered a luxury item when society sets its programming and funding priorities. Talent loss is the failure of individuals to realize the potential talents that they demonstrated in their early years. To realize potential talents means to actualize them by generating real-world products or performances of high quality. Table 1.1 presents four possible outcomes of talent loss or talent realization in adults as a function of identification of potential in youth. Although the talent development trajectory of individuals varies widely – some accomplishing an extraordinary talented achievement in youth – we present the four outcomes in terms of the youth–adult relationship because of its educational utility and practicality. Some potentially talented children are successfully identified by parents and schools and realize their potential as evidenced by positive contributions that bring them personal satisfaction and enrich the societies in which they live. Some succeed in actualizing their potential talent despite the fact that Table 1.1╇ Talent loss: identification and realization of potential Identification of potential talent in youth Realization of talent Not realized in adult Realized
Not identified
Identified
Talent loss
Talent loss
Talent realized
Talent realized
Preventing Talent Loss • 5 their potential was not recognized when they were young. It is likely that this group of individuals have motivation and personality traits (e.g., independent, autonomous, goal-oriented) that propel their talent development without environmental support. Some individuals were actually designated when they were young as potentially talented by school systems, were considered gifted by their parents, yet for a wide variety of reasons never realized their potential. These people may well have experienced enrichment efforts by schools and communities, all to no avail. Some of the complex reasons that might explain this kind of talent loss are suggested in this book. Finally, some individuals were potentially talented as children, were never identified as such, never received special education, and failed to realize their potential talent in any way. The theoretical model presented in this book applies to all four groups, those who actualize their potential talent and those who do not. We will, however, give special attention to talent loss, that is, potentially talented young people, either identified or not identified as such, who do not realize their potential.
Sources of talent loss Cognitive abilities, personal–psychological attributes, and environmental– social factors work interactively in their influence on talent development. These components influence individuals’ talent development in ways that vary widely. Individuals have different strengths and weaknesses in these components. Some people, for example, are influenced greatly by their cognitive abilities, others by strong family support. Educators and parents can influence the process of talent development and help reduce talent loss. One of the goals of this book is to encourage the adoption of changes that will reduce talent loss. We urge that changes adopted be accompanied by research designed to yield reliable information on the relative efficacy of each change in reducing talent loss. Underestimation of the extent of the phenomenon The extent of talent loss is vastly underestimated (Tannenbaum, 1983). One reason for this phenomenon is that stories of highly talented people who overcome all difficulties and succeed in actualizing their potential are much more likely to receive attention in the media than the statistics of actual talent loss. The list of successful and productive gifted adults whose talents were almost lost is legendary. The eminent scientist, Albert Einstein, according to the apocryphal story, failed mathematics in elementary school. Steve Wozniak, the developer of the first Apple home computer, was a high school dropout. Bill Gates, the president of Microsoft, the largest producer of computer software
6 • Understanding Talent Loss in the world, dropped out of Harvard. Boris Yeltsin, the former Russian leader, was expelled from high school for showing leadership in adolescence. He stood up at a school assembly and incited his fellow high school students to rebel against the tyrannical principal. There is a danger in these happyending stories. They confirm the popular prejudice that gifted children will realize their talents without educational intervention. This, however, is not the situation. Many talented youngsters fail to realize their potential abilities. Underestimation of the extent of talent loss means that we are not recognizing talent loss as the serious problem that it represents for our society and our world. If we do not define it as a problem, it is unlikely that we will give it the attention required to develop solutions. Narrow conceptualizations of giftedness The narrow conceptualizations of giftedness that dominated the field for many years are another major reason for talent loss. One could use the landmark work of Lewis Terman (Terman, 1925; Terman & Oden, 1947, 1959) to define three stages which provided the basis for our current understanding of giftedness, that is, pre-Terman, Terman, and post-Terman. In the preTerman stage there were strong negative attitudes and a strong popular bias against “geniuses.” Many people believed that “early ripe, early rot,” that is, high-IQ children were physically weak and prone to problems of social and psychological adjustment. Terman’s work represented a milestone in the development of our understanding of giftedness. He was a psychologist at Stanford University who developed the Stanford–Binet intelligence test for use in the United States and conducted a major longitudinal research study of what he called genius. He launched his study in 1921 and followed over 1,000 research participants with Stanford–Binet IQs of above 135 for more than six decades. The results of the landmark study are reported in a set of five volumes (Terman, 1925; Terman & Oden, 1947, 1959) and in numerous articles published subsequently (e.g., Friedman, Tucker, Schwartz, Tomlinson-Keasey, Martin, Wingard, & Giqui, 1995; Tomlinson-Keasey, Warren, & Elliot, 1986). Terman was the first major researcher to investigate the phenomenon of giftedness, and his work contributed a large amount of information on the characteristics of high-IQ-type gifted children. Terman’s work replaced previously widely held prejudices with facts. His pioneering work provided a large proportion of the information on gifted learners that was available for many years. However, because of the narrow conceptualization of giftedness that guided his work, Terman’s research led to much talent loss.
Preventing Talent Loss • 7 The findings of the Terman study and the methodology of comparing children defined as gifted in terms of high IQ with lower-IQ children dominated the field for many years. This was unfortunate because the Terman research was characterized by two problems, one theoretical and one methodological. The theoretical problem was the limited definition of giftedness, used by Terman. Although his pioneering research yielded much knowledge about high-IQ giftedness, it impeded the expansion of the conceptualization of giftedness and talent for many years. The methodological problem was even more serious. The research participants of the Terman study were first selected on the basis of teacher recommendations and only in subsequent stages was additional information on these research participants gathered. In other words, the Stanford–Binet IQ test was administered to children only if their teachers considered them intelligent. The problems created by using teacher recommendations as a first step in the identification process are discussed later in Chapter 8. This is often referred to as the “fatal flaw” in the Terman research and has led many to question whether findings based upon this non-random and nonrepresentative sample yielded a valid portrait of even the high-IQ gifted. The post-Terman era started in the 1950s and it is marked by the end of the domination of the unidimensional conceptualization of giftedness and the development of multidimensional theories of the phenomenon that continues until the present time. Guilford (1950) delivered a presidential address at the American Psychological Association that had enormous impact on the definition and assessment of giftedness. Guilford’s (1950, 1956, 1967) Structure of Intellect model defined multiple cognitive aptitudes, including divergent or “creative” thinking, that led to the abandonment of the idea that tests of general intelligence could be used to identify all gifted children. Thus, Guilford’s conceptual framework expanded the definition of giftedness to include creativity and educators began to speak of the gifted and talented. Unfortunately, for two decades researchers focused on efforts to define and to assess creative thinking as distinct from intelligence (Wallach, 1970) instead of examining the more important question of how to use the concept of creative thinking to expand our understanding and enhancement of giftedness and to prevent talent loss. Here again there was a fatal flaw in the application of the conceptualization of creative thinking in the work of Torrance (1962), Guilford (1967) and Wallach and Kogan (1965) that actually contributed to the phenomenon of talent loss. Scores on their measures of general creative thinking were frequently considered indices of real-world creativity. In other words, the test scores were confounded with real-world creative behavior. The scores on tests designed to be predictors of creative behavior were used as criteria. For example, in empirical studies of personality characteristics of
8 • Understanding Talent Loss creative people, scores on creative-thinking tests are frequently used as the criterion index of creativity. In the chapters that follow, we will adopt a clear distinction between scores on tests of analytical and creative thinking and the real-world behaviors that reflect these test scores. Potentially talented young people are unidentified The most basic overall explanation for talent loss is probably that young people with high potential talent are unidentified. One important reason for the failure to recognize potential abilities in children and youth that later emerge as remarkable life accomplishment in adults is the difference between what we call remarkable accomplishment in children and in adults. In children, general intellectual ability is frequently considered the major criterion for giftedness. It is assumed to be an indicator of remarkable attainments to come. Children, however, are not expected to generate actual high-quality products in their youth, some protégés notwithstanding. In adults, talent is manifested in a product or performance that reflects not only focused cognitive ability, interest, and effort but also training, practice, and experience. Adults are not “generally” talented, they are specifically talented in something – music, mathematics, languages. In adults talent is realized in a product (a musical score, a scientific breakthrough). Talent loss is affected by this difference between the definition of giftedness in children and in adults because the identification and selection procedures used in most school systems are based on measures of IQ or standardized tests. Children whose potential talent is unconventional, that is, different from the abilities measured by school grades and IQ tests, may not be identified as gifted and not given the opportunities that might help them develop their potential talent. They may be systematically excluded and not provided with special educational experiences that could enhance their potential talent and prevent it from being lost. Individual children’s personal characteristics and backgrounds are ignored in identification and selection of potential talents This practice of not considering what students bring to the learning environment other than cognitive abilities is widespread in gifted education. Without understanding children’s background, how can one understand what they think, how they think, what they do or do not value, and why they behave in a certain manner? What is important to individual children, what are they interested in, what are their aspirations? What culture do they come from, what is their family like, what kind of friends do they associate with? What are their preferred learning styles and motivation levels and are they
Preventing Talent Loss • 9 self-regulating while studying? These are important questions that need to be considered before assigning students to instructional programs. In this book, we present personal–psychological attributes and environmental–social factors that influence talent development. Understanding these key attributes and considering them seriously can help educators and parents contribute to preventing talent loss. Lack of instruments or lack of use of proper instruments to assess different types and levels of giftedness and talent As early as 1972, Marland, who was then Assistant Secretary for Education in the United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, proposed a multifaceted definition that, in addition to high intelligence, included creativity, leadership, and abilities in the performing and visual arts. Marland’s (1972) definition was adopted by the United States Office of Education, and enacted into law by the Congress of the United States in the Gifted and Talented Children’s Act of 1978. This legislation represented an important educational advance because it defined giftedness broadly rather than in terms of IQ alone, and justified the provision of services to gifted children with a wide variety of abilities and potential talents. Research findings encouraged school authorities to search for better screening instruments. There is little evidence that children identified as potentially gifted on the basis of IQ and/or achievement test scores invariably reach the highest occupational levels, achieve outstanding vocational success, or provide professional and community leadership (McClelland, 1973; Milgram & Hong, 1994; Tannenbaum, 1983; Wallach & Wing, 1969). McClelland (1973) summarized convincing evidence that intelligence test scores, when examined separately from educational achievement, did not directly predict occupational success and other important life outcomes. He suggested that tests that assess the competencies involved in the life outcome that we are trying to predict would have better predictive validity. These developments provided the impetus to school authorities to search for instruments that would successfully identify potentially gifted children. The key problem is the difficulty in finding or developing reliable, valid, and practical tests desired by school systems to identify the vast array of component abilities postulated in the newer formulations and required by law. The wide gap between the expanding view of what constitutes potential giftedness in children and the actual selection processes represents a major challenge to those responsible for gifted education. In recent decades, various new instruments have been proposed and made available to the public. However, despite much urging from researchers and authorities on gifted education, evidence of systematic use of new assessment approaches by educators is not
10 • Understanding Talent Loss to be found. In this book, we provide information on various assessment tools that educators may apply in identification and selection of potentially gifted and talented children. Potentially talented young people are underserved The multifaceted definition cited above, which was proposed by Marland (1972) and adopted by the United States Office of Education, firmly established gifted learners as “exceptional,” that is, children whose physical, intellectual, or socio-emotional development differs significantly from the norm and who require special education, that is, services or activities in addition to or in place of those generally offered by the school. Most states in the U.S. enacted legislation, or published regulations or guidelines based, for the most part, upon the U.S. Office of Education definition of giftedness. The exact nature of the services or activities to be provided for gifted learners was not specified by law, but was left instead to the discretion of school administrators and school boards. Accordingly, a wide variety of administrative arrangements were developed to provide special education for gifted and talented learners. Alternative administrative arrangements used in the education of the gifted and implications for talent loss are discussed in Chapter 8. One reason why many potentially talented young people are underserved is because it is virtually impossible to provide the many different programs that would meet the needs of gifted children with wide variations of types and levels of potential talents. As only a small proportion of potentially gifted youngsters can benefit from special programs outside of the school, these children would best be served by mainstreaming or providing special education for the gifted within the regular classroom (Milgram, 1989; VanTassel-Baska, 1995). In Chapter 11 we will explain how the use of technology, as broadly defined, within the regular classroom can better serve the individual needs of each potentially gifted learner, thus decreasing the possibility of talent loss. To sum up, as researchers and educators, the challenge that we face is to identify potential talent and to prevent talent loss. The reasons that explain talent loss are intertwined. Inadequate conceptualization leads to the use of procedures to identify and enhance talent that are unsuccessful. It is easier to curse the darkness than to light a candle. Many are the books that focus on what is wrong – we call that cursing the darkness. In the chapters that follow, we intend to change that emphasis and to focus on what we can do to prevent talent loss, that is, to light a candle. Let us return for a moment to the opening lines of this chapter. Our goal in this volume is to try to understand silenced talent and the process by which the talented are silenced (the punishing way described by Tillie Olsen), in the hope that the work before you will help in a small way to give the opportunity for more of the silenced to be heard.
chapter
2
A New Direction in Conceptualization
A comprehensive model of giftedness and talent In the last chapter we stated that (a) the reduction of talent loss is an enormous challenge to educators and (b) a major goal of this book is to contribute to a broad understanding of talent loss and to its prevention. One reason for talent loss is lack of a basic understanding of potential talent, factors affecting talent development, and different types of realized talent. Lack of knowledge has led to faulty identification of potential talent and to ineffective programs designed to develop talents. Although there has been considerable theoretical advancement in the field of gifted education in recent years, the programs of gifted education have not caught up with these advancements. Some educators have become more knowledgeable and effective in enhancing talent development (e.g., Buchana & Woerner, 2002). Unfortunately, others are unable or unwilling to apply their knowledge to the actual implementation of changes in gifted education (see VanTassel-Baska, 2006). In this chapter we present a comprehensive model of giftedness and talent conceptualized to prevent talent loss. The specific goal of the theoretical model is to provide parents, teachers, counselors, and educators with knowledge and understanding in a form that they will be more likely to use to improve gifted education and to prevent talent loss. The more general goal is to encourage lay and professional people to use the model to
12 • Understanding Talent Loss provide a large proportion of our children and adolescents, gifted and nongifted, with the learning opportunities to realize their potential talent. In the first section of this chapter we list the characteristics of a good model. In the second section, we present our model of giftedness and talent.
Characteristics of a good model Why list the characteristics of a good theoretical model of talent development and talent loss? Many lay and professional people do not appreciate the value of theory in general, and the application of specific theories to their lives and work in particular. Accordingly, we present here the basic definitions and characteristics of a good model. A theoretical model is a simplified representation of a phenomenon. A good model of giftedness and talent provides a better understanding of the phenomenon and a plausible explanation for its development. In education we use models to describe, predict, and improve the teaching–learning process. The concepts of talent development presented in our model provide the conceptual basis required for experimental and nonexperimental investigations. One might say that a model is good (a) when all components of the model and the model as a whole describe the phenomenon of talent development as accurately as possible; and (b) when the model permits modification and amplification over time to generate better explanations and better programs in the field to enhance talent development. A good model of talent development has five major characteristics. 1 A good model is broad in scope in that it is composed of an integrated set of component constructs that explain talent development and talent loss. It acknowledges and reflects a wide range of potential and realized talent (e.g., Marland, 1972; Milgram, 1989, 1991; Renzulli, 1986; Tannenbaum, 1983). The model presented here is in direct contrast to narrow-scope theories that focus on a single dimension, such as cognitive processes (e.g., Cattell, 1971; Guilford, 1959) or aspects of personality (e.g., Helson & Crutchfield, 1971; Piechowski, 1991). The model postulates differential and interactive effects of the various components on talent development, that is, cognitive abilities, personal–psychological attributes, and environmental–social factors. 2 A good model represents a simplified conceptualization of a complex phenomenon and, in the present instance, describes giftedness and talent with as few constructs as possible. A good model provides a succinct explanation of what talent is and what affects its development and realization.
A New Direction in Conceptualization • 13 3 A good model conceptualizes a wide range of talent manifestation. The model acknowledges that individuals have a different amount and pattern of resources with reference to their cognitive abilities, personal attributes, and the various settings in which these abilities and attributes are nurtured. The model proposes that, due to these differences, individuals differ in the pace and degree in which they develop their potential talent and manifest their realized talent. Some gifted and talented children and youth may develop their potential talent to the fullest, manifesting a profound level of talent, whereas others may not be able to do so. The model postulates that talent development is an on-going process, a process of “becoming.” The model is applicable to all individuals, not just to those with high abilities. 4 A good model builds upon and integrates past and present empirical findings generated by extant theories. The new model presented here is not to be considered a final statement on giftedness and talent. Models change as a function of evidence that supports them as well as evidence that mandates change. A good model generates theoretical and applied research and warrants continuous validation and improvement. 5 A good model is practical. As Kurt Lewin (1951) once said, “There is nothing so practical as a good theory” (p. 169). A good model provides a framework for program implementation that is as practical as possible. Effective implementations are based on good theoretical models. Poor models are not only ineffective but also waste time, creative energy, and funds. A model for preventing talent loss is good only if it helps bring to the field of gifted education new ideas to prevent talent loss.
A comprehensive model of giftedness and talent Theories of giftedness and talent: background and brief history At first, giftedness was defined largely on the basis of general intellectual ability. Research on giftedness began with the effort to understand and assess intelligence. Intelligence has been used widely for identification of students who need special education services. Intelligence has been and is a major component of models and programs of gifted education. The seminal work of Terman (1925) on intelligence and giftedness was described in detail in Chapter 1. Different theories of intelligence have been postulated over the years. The unitary view of intelligence postulates that a single general factor (“g” or general intelligence) accounts for most of our mental ability. This postulation has been highly influential in the conceptualization of giftedness (Jensen, 1998a, 1998b; Spearman, 1927). According to Spearman, a person
14 • Understanding Talent Loss who is grossly deficient in general intelligence would probably not be gifted in any specific domain. The Talent Search program initiated at Johns Hopkins University is an example of a talent development approach that is largely based on this conception of intelligence (Stanley, 1980; Stanley & Benbow, 1981). Thorndike (1927) proposed that intelligence is the sum of specific abilities such as abstract ability, mechanical ability, and social ability. By contrast, Thurstone (1938) contended that there is no general factor in intelligence and regarded intelligence as several primary mental abilities in various areas such as word fluency, verb meaning, number, associative memory, reasoning, space, and perceptual speed. Other earlier theories include Fluid and Crystallized Intelligences (Cattell, 1971) and Structure of Intellect (Guilford, 1959, 1967, 1988). Fluid intelligence is a non-learned trait and can be measured by culture-free intelligence tests (e.g., ability to see relations and patterns). Crystallized intelligence is learned knowledge and measured by achievement tests. Cattell postulates that fluid intelligence is necessary for crystallized intelligence, basically proposing that general intelligence is the foundation for high crystallized intelligence. Guilford hypothesized that human intellect is composed of many intellectual abilities classified on the basis of the material (or content) processed, the processes (or operations) performed with the content, and the forms (or products) of processed information. Since these earlier efforts to understanding intelligence, other scholars have proposed various perspectives on intellectual development including Piagetian, neoPiagetian, cognitive, and contextual perspectives (see Gardner, Kornhaber, & Wake, 1996; Sternberg & Berg, 1992). Educators and researchers in the field of giftedness recognized that intelligence is only one component of giftedness and talent and that a more comprehensive theoretical framework is needed in order to ground their research and practice in gifted education and to advance our understanding of giftedness and talent. Despite the recognition of the need for theory development specific to giftedness and talent by such pioneer thinkers as Ward (1961), Guilford (1967), and Gowan (1972, 1974), it was not until the 1980s that multidimensional conceptualizations of human abilities and giftedness were proposed. Examples of such endeavors include Theory of Multiple Intelligences (Gardner, 1983), Triarchic Theory of Intelligence (Sternberg, 1988), Successful Intelligence (Sternberg, 1996), and Investment Theory of Creativity (Sternberg & Lubart, 1995). Other postulations include various viewpoints from microlevels of organic structure and neurobiology (neuronal dynamics, brain structure) to macrolevels of broad political, cultural, and economic context (see Ambrose, 2005). Several edited volumes appeared summarizing the better known theories (Cohen & Ambrose, 1993; Horowitz & O’Brien, 1985a; Runco & Albert, 1990;
A New Direction in Conceptualization • 15 Sternberg & Davidson, 1986). Theories of giftedness postulated the specific abilities, attributes, and factors that purportedly explain the development of giftedness and talent. Some theories focus on single aspects of development of gifted individuals (e.g., personality). Other formulations are broader in scope and include recognition of the role of environment, experience, and personality in the realization of potential talent. Recent formulations of giftedness propose that (a) both nature and nurture contribute to the realization of gifted potential, creativity, and productivity; and (b) giftedness should be assessed with a wide variety of measures that include indices of personal and environmental elements (e.g., Feldhusen, 1995a; Gagné, 1991, 2005; Piirto, 1999; Renzulli, 1986; Renzulli & Reis, 1985; Sternberg, 2004). In summary, conceptions of giftedness range from a narrow g factor view to more multidimensional views. How giftedness is conceptualized has direct and immense impact on who will be identified as having gifted potential, who will receive special services, and who will have opportunities for talent development. In the next section, we propose a new comprehensive model that postulates a different view of giftedness and talent and the factors that influence talent development. Rationale and the model Theoretical rationale The basic view that led to the development of a new model of giftedness and talent is that the development of talent is based upon the complex relationships between individuals and their environments. An individual’s talent is to be understood in terms of opportunities for action that the environment affords to individuals who have an intention to learn (Gibson, 1986). If individuals do not have an interest or intention to act on the opportunities that the environment affords, then learning would not occur. Thus, particular behaviors become noticed as developing, competent, or talented, when the environment affords and the learner recognizes the possibilities for learning and action (Turvey & Shaw, 1995). The impact of heredity versus environment has been the most discussed issue in understanding ability, intelligence, expertise, giftedness, and talent (see Dai & Coleman, 2005). The formulation presented here reflects the view that nature and nurture interact to produce developmental outcomes, an assertion partly brought by behavioral genetics research and bioecological theory by Ceci (1996; Papierno, Ceci, Makel, & Williams, 2005). Further, nurture compensates nature and vice versa. Although we support the conception that individuals are biologically predisposed to obtain certain information in certain preferred ways and intuitions (Carey & Gelman, 1995), we also support
16 • Understanding Talent Loss the assertion that biological predispositions (e.g., human brain) are influenced by environment, culture, and social context.
na
The new model The Comprehensive Model of Giftedness and Talent (CMGT), as presented in Figure 2.1, is a broad, multidimensional, formulation of giftedness and talent. Two types of manifested talent, one labeled expert talent and the other creative talent, are the major components of this conceptualization of giftedness. These two talents, the culminating manifestation of individuals’ talent development, are discussed in Chapter 12. Either talent is developed based on the three contextual components (outer circle in Figure 1.1) – cognitive abilities, personal–psychological attributes, and environmental–social factors – which are foundations for realizing potential talent. An individual who might have creative potential might demonstrate good analytical-thinking ability and excellent creative-thinking ability. In addition, this individual Comprehensive Model and of Giftedness and Talent (Hong & Milgram, mightAbe highly motivated have fully supportive parents who 2007) recognize
Figure 2.1╇ A comprehensive model of giftedness and talent.
A New Direction in Conceptualization • 17 his/her potential. This individual might have a good chance to demonstrate a creative talent in a domain of his/her interest. The combinations of various factors in the three contextual components are complex and the degree of trait or environment support varies widely (e.g., from highly motivated to not motivated; from participating in special programs to dropping out of high school). The level-of-talent dimension (minimal to profound) represents the continuum of talent development and implies that talent development is a continuous process. Individuals can realize a level of talent that is higher than their current level of talent. These levels are depicted as triangular in shape, hierarchically ordered by degree of difficulty of attainment, with the pointed area indicating the highest accomplishment. The shape also highlights the fact that the higher the level, the fewer the number of people in society who achieve it. The level of talent represents talent manifestations that are qualitatively different. The concept of level or continuum of talent development does not appear in other conceptualizations of giftedness. The inclusion of level in this model underscores our contention that talent development is dynamic instead of static, with the degree of talent manifestation changing as individuals work toward excellence to their fullest. The rate of development is determined by the individuals’ self-awareness of their potential, by their motivation to seek excellence, by deliberate practice, and through environmental supports. Educators should acknowledge that students continue to develop and learn and that, while not all students exhibit a profound level of talent, all should have the opportunities to develop their potential and to achieve as high a level of talent actualization as they possibly can. A practical value of the model is its application in identifying gifted and talented students and in selecting candidates for special programs. Schools require psychometrically based operational definitions of levels for identification and selection procedures. The model postulates that talent manifestation may be categorized into several discrete levels. For example, one might decide to apply four levels, such as minimal, mild, moderate, and profound levels, for the purpose of curriculum development in the school district. As most children and adolescents identified as gifted and talent in schools manifest their talent at minimal to mild levels and a small proportion exhibit moderate to profound levels of talent, the level of talent is an important distinction to consider. The level of talent development is affected by an individual’s cognitive abilities and personal–psychological attributes as well as by environmental– social factors depicted in Figure 2.1. The overlapping influences of these three contextual components are presented in Figure 2.2. This figure represents the interactive influence of the individual’s resources, i.e., cognitive abilities,
18 • Understanding Talent Loss
Cognitive abilities
Personalcognitive
Socialcognitive
Talent development Personal/ psychological attributes
Psychosocial
nitive
Environmental/ social factors
Figure 2.2╇ Context of talent development. Context of Talent Development (Hong & Milgram, 2007)
personal–psychological attributes and environmental–social factors, on talent development. This interaction, unique to each individual, accounts for individual differences in the development of talent. Although cognitive abilities are personal resources, we separated them from personal–psychological attributes, because they play a fundamental role in human learning and development. The concept of level also applies to the three contextual components that affect talent development. Cognitive abilities of the candidates for gifted programs may be distinguished in levels for identification purposes. Some educators have demonstrated their effort to distinguish profoundly gifted learners from other levels, although mostly based on intellectual ability (e.g., Gross, 2000). Livne (2002; Milgram & Livne, 2005) reported a theoretical and empirical example of four levels (low to profound) distinguished in academic and creative mathematics in high school students. Other attributes such as task commitment and self-efficacy (personal attributes) and family support (environmental factors) may be distinguished by levels in efforts to individualize special programs for particular students.
A New Direction in Conceptualization • 19 The Comprehensive Model of Giftedness and Talent was developed in an effort to clarify the diverse components that affect talent development, to help improve practices in gifted education that foster talent development, and to contribute to the reduction of talent loss. In Chapters 3 and 4, we present the two cognitive abilities that are fundamental to talent development: analyticalthinking and creative-thinking abilities. These two represent processing abilities that are required for talent development and are distinct conceptually and operationally from personal–psychological attributes and environmental– social factors. The personal–psychological attributes that influence the realization of expert talent and creative talent are discussed in Chapter 5 (motivational and metacognitive attributes), Chapter 6 (affective attributes), and Chapter 7 (biological attributes). The environmental–social factors are presented in Chapter 8 (school and special programs), Chapter 9 (school personnel and climate), Chapter 10 (family, mentor, and socio-cultural aspects), and Chapter 11 (technology for talent development). Suggested throughout the model description in the following chapters is our contention that individuals’ motivation and/or other personal attributes (e.g., personality, goals) and environment (e.g., school, teacher, family, culture) as well as cognitive abilities play important roles in developing talent (e.g., Amabile, 1983; Feldhusen, 1995b).
part
2
Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development
chapter
3
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development
In the preceding chapter we presented a comprehensive model of giftedness and talent in which analytical-thinking and creative-thinking abilities were postulated as the two basic component constructs of cognitive abilities in giftedness and talent. In this chapter we will discuss analytical-thinking abilities and in the next chapter creative-thinking abilities. Analyticalthinking ability is defined as the ability to think abstractly and to solve problems logically and systematically. It includes analyzing, comparing, choosing, contrasting, evaluating, judging, inducing, deducing, and inferring. Sternberg and Grigorenko (2000) consider critical-thinking ability as part of analytical ability. In examining this construct, it is necessary to distinguish between domain-general and domain-specific analytical-thinking ability.
Domain-general and domain-specific analytical-thinking ability Domain-general analytical-thinking ability is the cognitive ability referred to as general intellectual ability or general intelligence. It is measured by performance on intelligence tests or other measures of general cognitive ability. Performance on intelligence tests has been reported as IQ scores. Domain-general analytical-thinking ability is an essential ability for
24 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development information processing and is involved in such diverse activities as problem solving, creative activities, performing arts, and sports. It is involved in any human activity that goes beyond a simple reflex. The development and realization of potential talent depends upon many factors such as environmental and personal attributes, but cognitive abilities are fundamental to talent development. Many different types of abilities are discussed in the field of giftedness, but intellectual ability or intelligence continues to be the major focus in school. Children high in general intelligence are sometimes considered “school smart.” Domain-specific analytical-thinking ability is analytical aptitude that is specific to a particular domain (e.g., academic disciplines). It is intellectual ability in a given area, such as mathematics, foreign language, music, or science. These abilities in children and adolescents are often, but not invariably, expressed in superior academic performance in school subjects as reflected in specific school grades and achievement tests. Domain-specific analytical-thinking ability is the best predictor of performance in school subjects (Sattler, 1988). For example, a person with high analytical ability in mathematics analyzes and solves mathematical problems skillfully, demonstrating outstanding computational ability based on deep knowledge and understanding of mathematical principles and concepts. Analyticalthinking ability in art is reflected in aesthetic appreciation through critical analysis of the technical aspect of art work. These abilities may produce products that are highly competent, but not necessarily creative or original. Renzulli (1986) was not off the mark when he called students with high specific analytical-thinking ability “schoolhouse gifted.” Researchers have found a moderate correlation between domaingeneral and domain-specific analytical thinking (Hong & Milgram, 1996; Tannenbaum, 1983). Individuals high in the former tend to be successful in school. One reason for this phenomenon is the bi-directionality of the relationship between intelligence and schooling (Worrell & Schaefer, 2004). Learning in school raises IQ scores and IQ contributes to better performance in school work (Ceci, 1991; Ceci & Williams, 1997).
Relationship between analytical-thinking ability and creativity Intelligence and creativity are different cognitive abilities, but they are related. There is a weak to moderate correlation between IQ and creativity scores for people with IQ scores up to about 120. Above 120, the relationship disappears, indicating that IQ is not necessarily related to creativity (Baer & Kaufman, 2005). On the other hand, some researchers have concluded that high
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 25 intelligence is a requisite trait for high-level creative talent (Cox, 1926; Davis, 1997; Simonton, 1988a; Walberg & Herbig, 1991). Simonton (1988a) contends that intelligence fills the brain with images, sounds, phrases, and abstract concepts, and that this filler gives the highly intelligent person a greater chance of forming the novel combinations of ideas, images, and symbols that become a masterpiece. Ward, Saunders, and Dodd (1999) also reason that cognitive abilities used by academically gifted children and creatively gifted children overlap. This overlap explains the high correlations sometimes found between the measure of intelligence or achievement and creative-thinking ability. While there is a consensus that some kind of analytical ability is a necessary condition for the development of creative talent in a specific domain, there is disagreement as to which kind of analytical ability. Renzulli (1978) and Tannenbaum (1983) think in terms of domain-general analytical thinking. Other investigators, however, assert that domain-specific analytical thinking is highly related to domain-specific creative talent, whereas the relationship between general analytical thinking and domain-specific creative talent is weak (Hong & Milgram, 1996). Heid (1983) and Livne and Milgram (2006) have shown that while mathematically gifted children have high intelligence, they are not necessarily highly creative in mathematics. Yager (1989) was able to demonstrate that these relationships are a function of the measures used. He noted that the introduction of exemplary science programs to American high schools resulted in a major change in the distribution of school grades among these students. Learners characterized by high general intelligence used to receive high grades in high school science courses because the requirements for achieving those grades were highly similar to the requirements of most IQ tests. With the modification of science courses to include the requirement for experimentation and innovative thinking (Yager, 1989), many of these learners no longer received high grades. Piirto (1998) reports findings that could support both arguments when she analyzed the biographical and autobiographical essays and reference works of women who became successful creative writers. These women were highly intelligent: many graduated with honors from prestigious colleges, and were given scholarships and fellowships to pursue their academic careers; others were qualified to attend highly competitive schools by virtue of their high school achievements; and still others had risen from humble backgrounds by way of their academic talents. One could argue that analytical thinking was a necessary condition for the development of their creative talent. On the other hand, one could contend that it took a unique combination of domain-general and domain-specific analytical-thinking abilities as well as creative-thinking ability to achieve what these women achieved. Personal and environmental factors, to be discussed in later chapters, also contribute to the development and realization of talent such as these women exhibited.
26 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development To sum up, conflicting evidence exists regarding the relationship between analytical thinking and creativity. The relationship between the two constructs has been rather murky due to the fact that in the past the construct “creativity” was neither conceptually nor empirically clearly defined. The relationship becomes more understandable when creativity is conceptualized clearly by distinguishing creative talent from creative-thinking abilities, which also are distinguished as domain general and domain specific. In subsequent chapters, we distinguish between domain-general and domain-specific creativethinking abilities and specify the role of each in the development of creative talent.
Instruments used to measure analytical-thinking ability Even though educators understand that identification of potential talent should not be limited to intelligence and achievement test scores, they continue to rely heavily on measures of analytical thinking, especially IQ tests and standardized achievement tests, for identification and placement of students in special programs. These measures should be used in conjunction with others that are discussed in subsequent chapters of this book. We have summarized below examples of some of the commonly used instruments that have been used to measure analytical-thinking abilities. Readers interested in using any of the instruments listed are encouraged to consult the original publications. We complete this section by describing examples of a number of non-traditional assessment approaches. Measures for domain-general analytical-thinking ability Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Third Edition (WISC–III, Wechsler, 1991) and Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children – Fourth Edition (WISC–IV, Wechsler, 2003). The WISC-III and WISC-IV are the most widely used psychometric instruments assessing children’s intellectual ability (Donders, 1996; Winner, 2000). The WISC-III and WISC-IV are individual tests and do not require reading or writing. In WISC-III, verbal subtests are oral questions without time limits except for Arithmetic. Performance subtests are non-verbal problems. These subtests are timed and some items allow bonus points for speedy work. Verbal IQ is computed based on Information, Similarities, Arithmetic, Vocabulary, and Comprehension subtests; Verbal Comprehension Factor is based on Information, Similarities, Vocabulary, and Comprehension subtests; and Freedom from Distractibility Factor includes Arithmetic and
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 27 Digit Span. Performance (non-verbal) IQ is computed on the subtest scores in Picture Completion, Coding, Picture Arrangement, Block Design, and Object Assembly; Perceptual Organization (non-verbal) Factor is based on Picture Completion, Picture Arrangement, Block Design, and Object Assembly subtests; Processing Speed Factor is computed using Coding and Symbol Search. The Full Scale IQ is based on the 10 subtests included in the Verbal and Performance IQ scales. The more recent WISC–IV is used to assess general thinking and reasoning skills and has been normed for use with children of ages 6 years to 16 years and 11 months. This test yields a full-scale IQ and four index scores. These are Verbal Comprehension (based on Similarities, Vocabulary, and Comprehension), Perceptual Reasoning (based on Matrix Reasoning, Block Design, and Picture Concepts), Working Memory (based on Letter–Number Sequencing and Digit-Span), and Processing Speed (based on Symbol Search and Coding). A new Wechsler non-verbal scale (Wechsler Non-Verbal Scale of Ability: WNV) was published in 2006 (Wechsler & Naglieri, 2006). A closing comment about the Wechsler scales is appropriate. One should not rely on the full-scale IQ score, which represents general intelligence, without attention to its components. Sweetland, Reina, and Tatti (2006) found that, among intellectually gifted children, each child has a distinct pattern of cognitive strengths, high in some factors and low in others. They found that (a) the verbal scores of their participants were typically higher than the performance scores; and (b) performance scores were only average or slightly above average, with different patterns showing across participants. Raven’s Progressive Matrices (RPM; Raven, 1990) The RPM is another frequently used measure of intelligence. The RPM includes three forms: the Standard Progressive Matrices test (SPM), the Colored Progressive Matrices test (CPM), and the Advanced Progressive Matrices test (APM). The SPM was developed in 1938 and measures a general range of ability. The CPM was introduced in 1947 and was developed for young children and mentally challenged adults (Anastasi, 1982; Matthews, 1988). The APM, introduced in 1947, was developed for individuals with higher intellectual ability. The APM has been used for identification of gifted and talented students. The test is group-administered and assesses non-verbal abstract reasoning; an overall matrix is provided and examinees select one of six or eight pattern pieces that would fit into the overall matrix. The APM consists of 12 exercise items and 36 main items. Problems are arranged sequentially in order of progressive difficulty (Raven, Court, and Raven, 1983a, 1983b). Since the initial development of the RPM in 1938, it has been used around the world (Buros, 1978; Raven & Court, 1989). Recently, national U.S. norms
28 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development and local U.S. school district norms have been published for the Colored and Standard Progressive Matrices (Raven, 1990). The RPM has been used as an alternate or supplementary measure for the identification of gifted and talent students, who do not perform well on traditional measures (Matthews, 1988). Naglieri Non-verbal Ability Tests (NNAT; Naglieri, 1997, 2003) The NNAT is a recently developed non-verbal measure. Students are presented with a pattern formed by shapes organized into a colorful design and instructed to choose an answer that completes the pattern in these figural matrices and then to move on to more difficult patterns. There are two versions of the NNAT – the multilevel form (NNAT-MLF; Naglieri, 1997) and the individual form (NNAT-I; Naglieri, 2003). Each form provides non-verbal evaluation of general ability for children aged 5–17 years. The NNAT-MLF (Naglieri, 1997) is a group-administered test comprising seven levels. Each level contains 38 non-verbal test items specifically designed for brief and accurate evaluation of a child’s ability. Naglieri contends that these instruments are appropriate for students from many cultural and linguistic backgrounds because the content of the test is nonverbal, instructions are brief, and the test questions can be solved using only the information presented in each diagram. Word knowledge, mathematics, and reading skills are not involved in the NNAT; instead the items are figural matrices. The student must first see the patterns formed by shapes organized into colorful designs and then choose an answer that completes the pattern. According to Naglieri, this method of measuring ability without involving questions with verbal, math, or reading skills, and with minimal motor requirements, allows a fair evaluation of ability for children from different cultural and linguistic groups and for those with motor or communication problems. Emphasis is placed on fair assessment of children from diverse populations (i.e., regardless of race or ethnicity, or whether socially or economically disadvantaged, illiterate or semiliterate, bilingual). Naglieri and Ford (2003) reported that the NNAT identified similar numbers of minority children as gifted from a national sample of approximately 20,000 students in grades K-12 who were similar to the U.S. population on several demographic variables. They suggested that the NNAT may be useful as part of a procedure to identify students of diverse backgrounds for gifted education services. By contrast, Mills and Tissot (1995) found large differences in the mean scores of ethnic groups and low correlations of NNAT with scores on the Advanced Progressive Matrices test (APM: Raven, Court, & Raven, 1983b). The findings cited above indicate that caution is required when selecting instruments to assess intelligence or general intellectual ability for the purposes of identification and selection for gifted programs. It would be wise
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 29 to consider studies that compared various instruments. For example, different measures select different children for gifted education (e.g., RPM versus WISC) and some instruments select proportionally more students from various ethnic backgrounds (e.g., NNAT versus RPM versus WISC) (Lohman, 2005b; Naglieri & Ford, 2003). Another example that highlights the caution required in interpreting results of the different tests available is a study in which verbally advanced children were identified as gifted by both RPM and WISC. However, students identified as gifted by the RPM alone were average or below average in school achievement. This might indicate low motivation in these students and suggests that they have a higher risk of not doing well in a gifted program (Saccuzzo, Johnson and Guertin, 1994). Sternberg Triarchic Abilities Test (STAT; Sternberg, 1993, cited in Sternberg, Castejón and Prieto, 2001) The STAT consists of 12 subtests, four subtests each measuring analytical, creative, and practical abilities. Each subtest yields scores for three content areas: verbal, quantitative, and figural. Thus, for analytical abilities, analyticalverbal, analytical-quantitative, and analytical-figural scores are computed. Six corresponding scores are yielded, three each for the quantitative and figural content areas. The test is suitable for group administration, and is intended for use with individuals from kindergarten through college age, and with adults. Measures for domain-specific analytical-thinking ability Standardized test scores and school grades Domain-specific analytical-thinking ability is frequently measured by standardized achievement tests or school grades. A high test score or a high grade in a domain (e.g., literature, mathematics) indicates a high degree of readiness to perform well in that particular domain, increasing the possibility of excelling and developing expertise in the particular domain in the future. Certain information-processing abilities are more applicable in certain domains. For example, analytical thinking in mathematics problemsolving includes identifying and understanding a given problem, organizing information and representing the problem, selecting and using strategies, and evaluating the solution process. On the other hand, analytical-thinking abilities required in learning to play football as a quarterback would be different from those required in mathematical problem solving. To throw a ball to a proper receiver, for example, the player needs to analyze, judge, compare, choose, and evaluate, and then actual throwing would occur after the basic cognitive thinking process had taken place. With more practice, this thinking would not require much time; the footballer would have stored many position patterns, thus thinking could become just a matter of pattern recognition and pattern matching. This process is required for acquiring expertise in the
30 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development particular domain. We will discuss more about expertise, analytical thinking, and deliberate practice in Chapter 12. Lohman (2005a) cites four aptitudes as particularly important for predicting academic excellence in a specific domain – prior achievement in the domain, the ability to reason in the symbol system used to communicate knowledge in the particular domain, interest in the domain, and persistence in the type of learning environments offered for the attainment of expertise in the domain. Lohman (2005b) further asserts that for both minority and non-minority students, verbal and quantitative reasoning abilities are better predictors of academic success than non-verbal, figural reasoning abilities. Non-verbal test scores showed low correlation with academic achievement (Mills & Tissot, 1995). Naglieri and Ford (2005) strongly disagree with Lohman’s conclusions and claim that an emphasis on verbal and quantitative reasoning abilities in the process of identification of intellectually gifted children would result in the exclusion of some gifted children who for reasons that have nothing to do with their intellectual ability happen to have poor academic skills. Non-traditional measures Domain-specific analytical-thinking abilities may be measured with non-traditional assessment approaches. Such approaches are especially useful if the goal is to assess students who are currently underidentified and underrepresented because they do not perform well on standardized achievement tests or classroom tests. Such students are frequently from special racial groups (e.g., Ford, Tyson, & Howard, 2000; Tonemah, 1987), students with limited ability to speak English, children who are of low socio-economic background, or children who live in a confined geographic area such as a rural area, an inner city, or on reservations (Aamidor, 1995). It is important for teachers to recognize students with high potential for success in a certain domain so that they can help provide programs and services designed to develop the potential. Teachers’ observations of individual students exhibiting superior analytical-thinking skills may be recorded to determine if the individuals’ thinking patterns are consistent over time. A portfolio prepared for these students would provide evidence of possible future excellence in the domain. Research has shown that teachers’ rating scales based on actual observable behaviors are fairly accurate (Borland, 1978; Renzulli, Hartman, & Callahan, 1971). Worrell and Schaefer (2004) provide a few scales that focus on students’ behaviors. These scales include measures for intellectual as well as other domains of potential talent. 1 The Gifted Evaluation Scale (GES; McCarney, 1987; GES-2, McCarney & Anderson, 1998). This is a 48-item normative teacher rating scale that can be used to identify potentially talented students in five domains: Intellectual, Specific Academic Aptitude, Leadership Ability, Creativity, and Visual and Performing Arts.
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 31 2 The Scale for Rating the Behavioral Characteristics of Superior Students (SRBCSS; Renzulli, Tyson, & Howard, 1971; Renzulli, Smith, White, Callahan, Hartman, & Westberg, 2002). The most recent version of this scale, the SRBCSS-R2 (Renzulli, Smith, White, Callahan, Hartman, & Westberg, 2002), consists of 38 items divided into four subscales: Learning, Creativity, Leadership, and Motivation. 3 The Gifted and Talented Evaluation Scales (GATES; Gillian, Carpenter, & Christenson, 1996). This is a 50-item scale for the identification of the potential talent in five domains: Intellectual Ability, Academic Skills, Creativity, Leadership, and Artistic Talent. 4 The Learning Behaviors Scale (LBS; McDermott, Green, Francis, & Stott, 1999). This 29-item teacher-rating instrument was developed to assess the learning behaviors of students in the classroom setting. It is particularly useful for assessing the learning behaviors of students who are not performing well academically. The LBS scores were found to discriminate between students identified as both gifted and talented and those not so identified even though they were also characterized by high IQ (McDermott, 1999; Worrell & Schaefer, 2004). For a thorough description and critique of the instruments cited above that focus on teachers ratings, see Worrell and Schaefer (2004). Think-aloud methods to understand analytical-thinking process When the goal is to examine thinking processes and cognitive structures of individual students, one can use think-aloud protocols. This method involves students thinking aloud while they are performing a specific task (e.g., math problem-solving, reading comprehension). Students are asked to say what they are thinking, feeling, and doing, as they are performing the task. The thinkaloud sessions are often audio and/or video taped for in-depth analyses. When mathematics problem-solving processes were analyzed by this method, Hon, Sas, Sas, Speer, Pullabhota, and Richardson (2005) found that most of the students followed the steps such as understanding, representing, and solving the problem, followed by generating solutions. However, individual students differed in how they went about each step. For example, high achievers planned for solution strategies and monitored the progress, whereas low achievers tended not to use such strategies. Low achievers spent much less effort to understand the problem and did not represent the problem correctly. The students’ problem-solving procedures revealed through the think-aloud protocol help understand students’ analytical-thinking processes. The thinkaloud session allows us to observe why and how students approach problems and how their approach leads them to engage in particular problem-solving behaviors. It is a challenge for classroom instructors to implement think-aloud problem-solving sessions to understand students’ analytical-thinking ability
32 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development in a domain. It is more difficult to develop instructional strategies to be used for individual students according to the findings from think-aloud protocols. However, the benefits that will accrue from occasional use of this practice would be great, especially for those students who are not properly identified as gifted through standardized tests and grades.
Preventing talent loss Improve procedures for identification of potential talent A major source of talent loss is the exclusion of minority and other underidentified groups of children who do not perform well on intelligence tests, standardized achievement tests, or classroom tests. These include students from certain racial groups, immigrant children with limited ability to speak English, children of low socio-economic background, or children who live in geographic areas that limit their experiential opportunities. The information provided in this chapter is designed to provide educators with information and suggestions that will improve the procedures used to identify analytical thinking in all children, but it is of special use with underidentified children. Utilizing approaches to identify potential talent such as teacher observation scales and portfolios along with standard achievement test scores and school grades in particular domains can reduce substantially the number of gifted children who are not identified by traditional tests. Readers should keep in mind that portfolios and other subjective measures, unfortunately, lack high levels of objectivity, reliability, and predictive validity (Saccuzzo, Johnson, & Guertin, 1994). Given the fact that traditional tests are more objective than subjective measures, Saccuzzo, Johnson, and Guertin (1994) recommended that when using traditional standardized tests for the identification of gifted potential, local-ethnic norms may be used in “creative ways.” Understand students’ implicit theory of intelligence Some students believe that ability or intelligence is fixed (entity theory) whereas others believe that ability is malleable and changeable (incremental theory) (Dweck, 2000). These theories that students implicitly form are related to other educational constructs such as attribution theory (e.g., Hong, Chiu, & Dweck, 1999; Stipek & Gralinski, 1996). While both entity and incremental theorists recognize the importance of ability in task performance, students who hold an incremental theory also stress effort. When these students are faced with unsatisfactory performance, they put forth more effort to improve. On the other hand, students who hold an entity theory are more concerned with demonstrating their ability or avoiding revealing their lack of ability
Analytical-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 33 and attribute their failure to lack of ability rather than effort (Hong, Chiu, & Dweck, 1999). Gifted students tend to hold an incremental view of ability (Feldhusen & Dai, 1997). However, in another study (Kurtz & Weinert, 1989), gifted children attributed academic success to ability more than effort, and average children tended to attribute their success to effort rather than ability. These findings may not be contradictory because some gifted children may conclude from comparing their own effort and success with that of average children on routine school subjects that they have more ability than average children. On the other hand, with school subjects that are manifestly difficult, the relationship of theory to behavior may change. Children – gifted or not gifted – who espouse malleability will try harder than before, while children who espouse a fixed view of intelligence will simply give up, become selfdegrading and depressed, feel helpless, blame themselves, and not make the effort required for improvement. Parents, teachers, and counselors should make concerted efforts to understand students’ implicit theory of intelligence and help them understand the nature of intelligence and adopt the view that intelligence is amenable to change. Help students understand what test scores mean and the importance of sustained effort Educators and parents should also help students understand that their IQ or other cognitive ability test scores indicate current intellectual ability, and that is not what really matters. What does matter is the sustained effort to be made by students to actualize their potential in their areas of interest. Only through sustained effort will students come to realize that they can meet immediate goals and eventually ultimate goals. Provide individualized and differentiated special education for talent development Sustained effort is admirable but it is not enough. Students who show potential for high levels of accomplishment should be provided with education that is both differentiated and individualized. Students need different levels of challenges continuously to improve their intellectual capacities. Once they reach the level of challenge represented by a certain educational goal, another level of challenge should be provided. Students should also be helped to find their own challenges. Without such provision, we can predict more talent loss than talent development. More information on curriculum and instructional differentiation is presented in Chapter 8.
34 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development Use teaching strategies to develop analytical-thinking ability Teachers can help students develop their analytical-thinking abilities by using strategies designed to develop problem-solving skills. Have students define what the problem is; encourage students to ask questions; gather and organize information necessary to represent the problem before they attempt to solve the problem; strategize problem-solving sequence by planning the sequence and selecting proper strategies; when solving the problem, check if the strategies selected are successful; and evaluate the strength and weakness of the solution. Examples of these teaching strategies can be found in Sternberg and Grigorenko (2000). These are generalized problem-solving strategies. However, they can be adopted for any particular domain to increase domainspecific analytical-thinking ability.
chapter
4
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development
Creative-thinking ability is the cognitive ability to generate ideas that are unusual and of high quality. Creative thinkers discover or produce ideas that are imaginative, clever, elegant, or surprising (Guilford, 1967; Mednick, 1962). They perceive and define problems differently and notice things that others ignore (Wallach, 1970). They store and retrieve information differently as well. As a consequence of these basic differences, they produce unique and imaginative solutions. Torrance (1962) alluded to some of these abilities when he defined creative thinking as “the process of sensing gaps or disturbing missing elements; forming ideas or hypotheses concerning them; testing these hypotheses; and communicating the results; possibly modifying and retesting the hypotheses.” (p. 16). Creative-thinking abilities are essential for the development of creative talent. Numerous studies have shown positive relationships between creative-thinking ability and creative accomplishment (e.g., Hong & Milgram, 1996; Livne & Milgram, 2006; Milgram & Livne, 2006; Okuda, Runco, & Berger, 1991).
Domain-general versus domain-specific creative-thinking ability Until recently, creativity was considered domain general, that is to say that creative-thinking ability can be applied across domain and individuals scoring
36 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development high on general creative-thinking ability would be able to generate original ideas in a wide variety of domains. In fact, the very term, creative thinking, is used to refer to domain-general creativity (Wallach, 1970). Recently, scholars have produced evidence to the contrary, that is, that creative thinking is domain or content specific (e.g., Amabile, 1996; Baer, 1998). In a recent volume, Kaufman and Baer (2005) presented an authoritative summary of the controversy that surrounds this issue. In our model of giftedness and talent, we distinguish between domaingeneral and domain-specific creative-thinking abilities and postulate the relationship between the two. We have developed reliable and valid instruments to measure these two types of creative-thinking abilities. Studies conducted using these instruments and others have provided considerable empirical support for the postulated relationship between domain-general and domain-specific creative-thinking abilities. We summarize the evidence that confirms two dimensions of creative-thinking abilities, the relationship of each to analytic thinking, and the influence of the two on the development of creative talent. Creative thinking as domain-general cognitive ability The view of domain generality of creative thinking has been supported by evidence of (a) the predictive power of tests of creative thinking (e.g., Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking, 1974, 1999) on subsequent creative achievement (e.g., Cramond, 1994a; Torrance, 1981) and (b) the reliability and validity of self and other ratings (e.g., teachers) of an individual’s general creativity (e.g., Creative Personality Scale) (e.g., Plucker, 1999a). Chen, Himsel, Kasof, Greenberger, and Dmitrieva (2006) provide evidence of domain generality of creative thinking by examining three different domains (mathematics, artistic, and verbal) and demonstrating a high-order factor (creativity) and its relationship to three lower-order factors representing the three domains. Based on internal consistencies, model fit, and factor loadings, they concluded that creative thinking is domain general. However, the same evidence also supports domain specificity as the factor structure they tested included three distinct domain-specific factors. Creative thinking as domain-specific cognitive ability Whereas domain-general creative-thinking ability is typically measured by ideational fluency-based tests of divergent thinking (e.g., Torrance, 1974), domain-specific creative-thinking ability is measured by instruments assessing ideational fluency in a specific domain such as engineering (e.g., Claphan, Cowdery, King, & Montang 2005). For example, when creative
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 37 thinking is applied to mathematics, the person thinks mathematically and asks or generates unusual questions or solutions in mathematical terms. In science, it is the ability to generate hypotheses in science, that is, to think like a scientist instead of just acquiring an increasing knowledge base in a specific area of science. Artists process information using their artistic thinking skills in the process of producing art products or developing artistic performance. Baer (1993, 1996) goes even further in contending that creativity is “task” specific within a domain. Baer asserts that training in creative thinking does not enhance creative performance on different tasks within a given domain to the same degree. Plucker and Runco (1998) disagree and attribute these findings to methodological artifacts. The methods used by researchers to assess creative thinking favor task specificity, and subsequent findings are a direct function of this task specificity. However, they do support both domain generality and specificity of creative thinking (e.g., Okuda, Runco, & Berger 1991; Plucker & Beghetto, 2004).
Relationship between domain-general and domain-specific creative thinking The relationship between domain-general and domain-specific creativethinking abilities was investigated in a series of studies and is summarized later in this chapter. Instruments were developed to measure ideational fluency of real-life creative problem-solving in a wide variety of domains (i.e., domainspecific creative-thinking abilities). The findings demonstrated that domaingeneral creative thinking was strongly associated with original or unique solutions in social leadership and successful social interaction in children and adolescents across a wide age range from preschool to high school and across Arab and Israeli elementary school-age children. General creative thinking had a strong correlation with the ability to solve academic and personal problems (domain specific) among students with various backgrounds (Arab, Israeli, and Ethiopian students, students with learning disabilities, hearingimpaired students). The strong predictor–criterion relationship was evidenced across different life areas and ages (children, adolescents, and adults). Young mothers, working mothers, and women students in their first pregnancy with a high score in general creative-thinking ability were all found to be better able to meet the daily problematic challenges of their lives (indicated by their problemsolving in particular areas). The same relationships were found for Ethiopian immigrants to Israel, salesmen, managers in an R & D company, and men and women in the armed forces. The magnitude of the relationship between general creative-thinking ability and original problem-solving in a relevant
38 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development sphere of their lives was moderate to high, ranging from .40 to .91 with the median of .59 in the 24 studies. A moderate correlation (r€=€.57) was found between general creative-thinking ability and the ability to generate creative solutions to mathematical problems that are regarded as highly similar to the other real-life problem-solving tasks reported above (Livne & Milgram, 2006; Milgram & Livne, 2005). Taken together, the findings reported above clearly demonstrated that domain-general creative-thinking ability has a strong relationship with domain-specific creative thinking and that these are important abilities in real-life problem-solving in many domains across a wide age range.
Relationship between creative thinking abilities and creative talent Previous research indicated that divergent thinking tests can predict creative performance. Both concurrent and longitudinal studies that used criteria such as ratings of creative products and/or creative achievements supported this conclusion (Cramond, 1994a; Hong, Milgram, & Gorsky, 1995; Milgram & Hong, 1994; Plucker, 1999b; Torrance, 1972, 1981). However, in other studies, the relationships were only weak to moderate (Amabile, 1983; Hong & Milgram, 1996). In addition, earlier studies provided conflicting findings. In an extensive review of the literature, Barron and Harrington (1981) cited 70 studies in which a positive relationship was reported between measures of ideational fluency and real-world indices of creative behavior. However, Wallach (1985) summarized the results of a number of studies indicating that general creative thinking is not related to any significant degree to specific real-world creative performance. Other studies show that domain-specific creative-thinking abilities are more strongly correlated with creative talent than domain-general creativethinking ability (Okuda, Runco, & Berger, 1991), even after the effects of intelligence and expertise were controlled (Mumford, Marks, Connelly, Zaccaro, & Johnson, 1998; Vincent, Decker, & Mumford, 2002). For example, divergent thinking tests developed for specific occupations, such as military leaders, predicted leadership behaviors, career progress, and achievement (Mumford, Marks, Connelly, Zaccaro, & Johnson, 1998).
Relationship between creative-thinking and analyticalthinking abilities In the previous chapter, we discussed the relationship between analyticalthinking ability and creativity, with a caveat that earlier studies did not clarify whether creativity represented domain-general or domain-specific creative-
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 39 thinking ability or creative thinking or creative talent. We hope that discussion in this chapter so far has clarified these relationships. The creative-thinking processes involve both analytical- and creativethinking abilities and as such are the essential abilities for developing talent in any domain. For instance, if students do not possess well-developed analyticalthinking ability, they will not be able to judge (analyze and evaluate) whether creative ideas generated during the process of ideational fluency are useful solutions for the problem at hand. The pioneer theorists who provided the theoretical base for all future research in creativity understood this principle very well. In his landmark Structure of Intellect model, Guilford (1956, 1967) not only distinguished between convergent and divergent thinking in problem-solving but also postulated the evaluation of quality of the ideas as essential in both processes. The intricate integration between analytical and creative thinking that is required to produce expert talent and creative talent (see Chapter 12) was not specifically dealt with in prior theories. Systematic research is required to investigate the nuances of this relationship. The kind of research we are discussing will lead to a deep understanding of the process of talent development and highlight ways to prevent talent loss. Let us use music as an example of analytical- and creative-thinking abilities integrated in their influence on talent development. Most creative musicians learn to read music scores using their analytical-thinking abilities. Other factors (e.g., strong interest, aesthetic appreciation, sensory motor skills, family support) also facilitate the development of the creative talent. However, these other factors do not diminish the role of analytical-thinking abilities required to understand music (Shuter-Dyson, 1999) and they are of little consequence if superior analytical and creative thinking are not present. Studies indicate that creative- and analytical-thinking abilities are related, yet empirically distinguishable (Hong & Milgram, 1996; Wallach, 1970, 1971). In Hong and Milgram’s study (1996), domain-general creative-thinking ability showed a weak to moderate relationship with domain-general analyticalthinking ability and with domain-specific analytical-thinking ability in literature. These findings support the contention that analytical thinking is an important part of the creative-thinking process. Domain differences in the use of analytical thinking and creative thinking are found during the creative process. For example, science-oriented students report more analytical thinking during the insight stage than art-oriented students, and differences vary according to the time period of the creative process (Feist, 1991). The presence of high intelligence in young children may be a strong clue for identifying high creative potential. Conversely, creatively gifted people may excel in the analytical-thinking processes of problem definition, selective encoding, selective combination, and selective comparison skills. In addition, gifted children who have high analytical-thinking abilities score higher
40 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development than their non-gifted peers on problem-finding behavior and on a variety of processes involved in the creative-thinking process such as idea generation, insight tasks, divergent thinking, and the process of selective combination (e.g., Runco & Nemiro, 1993; Shore, 1986).
Instruments used to measure creative-thinking ability It is difficult to measure demonstrated talent. It is even more difficult to measure potential, not yet realized, talents. Some measures of domaingeneral creative-thinking ability have been developed and are widely used. By contrast, measures of domain-specific creative-thinking abilities are only currently emerging. In assessing potential creative talent, we must always bear in mind that we are measuring indicators of creative potential. Exactly how and to what extent children actually exhibit and ultimately realize their creative potential depends on the complex interaction of the factors cited in the Comprehensive Model of Giftedness and Talent described in Chapter 2. Creative thinking or divergent thinking is not synonymous with creative achievement. Tests of general divergent thinking ability may estimate potential for creative performance, but do not guarantee creative talent. These tests must not be used as a criterion of creative ability (Hong & Milgram, 1991). With these caveats in mind, we proceed in this section to discuss measures of domain-general and domain-specific creative-thinking abilities. Measures of domain-general creative-thinking ability Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking (TTCT; Torrance, 1974) The TTCT was initially published in 1966 and revised in 1999 (Torrance, 1999). The TTCT is a standardized, paper and pencil measure that is typically group administered. It consists of two forms – one verbal and one figural. Each form comes in two equivalent versions (A and B). The verbal form (“Thinking creatively with words”) comprises seven subtests: Asking, Guessing Causes, Guessing Consequences, Product Improvement, Unusual Uses, Unusual Questions, and Just Suppose. The figural form (“Thinking creatively with pictures”) consists of three subtests: Picture Construction, Picture Completion, and Parallel Lines/Circles. The verbal and figural forms take about 45 and 30 minutes to complete, respectively. The cognitive abilities assessed by the TTCT are ideational fluency, flexibility, originality, and elaboration. Fluency is based on the number of relevant responses an individual can generate. Flexibility is based on the number of different categories an individual’s responses can be sorted into.
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 41 Originality refers to uncommon responses. Elaboration refers to the ability to elaborate or add details to an idea. Reasonable reliability and adequate evidence of validity has been reported for the TTCT, thus justifying its use in research applications (e.g., Treffinger, 1985). Some investigators have reported inter-rater reliability greater than .90 (e.g., Sweetland & Keyser, 1991). Torrance also demonstrated predictive validity of the TTCT in several longitudinal studies. For example, TTCT data collected during high school showed significant relationships to creative accomplishments and occupational choices 12 years later (Torrance, 1972). A 22-year follow-up study of TTCT scores obtained during elementary school showed significant relationships with high school and post-high school creative accomplishments, and with ratings of quality of creative accomplishments and aspirations (Torrance, 1981). Tel Aviv Creativity Test (TACT; Milgram & Milgram, 1976) This instrument was developed based on the work of Guilford (1950, 1956, 1967), Torrance (1962), Mednick (1962), and Wallach and Kogan (1965). It measures creative thinking defined as a cognitive process of problem-solving by means of which original solutions of high quality are generated. Original is defined as unusual, that is, statistically infrequent. High quality is defined as productive, valuable, or worthwhile. Creative-thinking ability was defined operationally in terms of ideational fluency. The test assesses the ability to generate a large number of unusual, high-quality responses to a stimulus. The test has been translated into six languages and used over the years in Israel and other parts of the world (Milgram, Dunn, & Price, 1993) with research participants ranging from children aged 3 years (Moran, Milgram, Sawyers, & Fu, 1983; Milgram, Moran, Sawyers, & Fu, 1987) to adults across a wide age range (Milgram & Hong, 1994; Milgram & Livne, 2006). Scores for quantity and quality of response are computed for each research participant by means of a two-stage process. Each test response is first scored as either popular or unusual, the latter a response given by less than 5% of the participants in the research study being conducted. Second, three scores are computed: (a) quantity or the number of popular responses, (b) quality or the number of unusual/original/creative responses, and (c) total number of discrete popular and original responses. Consistent findings confirmed the strong relationship between non-overlapping scores of quality and quantity (Hong & Milgram, 1991; Milgram & Rabkin, 1980). Accordingly, ideational fluency was used as the single index of creative-thinking ability in many subsequent studies. The TACT has shown evidence of long-term predictive validity with measures of adult accomplishment (Milgram & Hong, 1994).
42 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development Structure of the Intellect Learning Abilities Test: Evaluation, Leadership, and Creative Thinking (SOI: ELCT; Meeker, 1985) The SOI: ELCT is based on Guilford’s (1967) Structure of Intellect model of intelligence. It measures nine cognitive activities connected with creativity, all of them involving divergent thinking applied to three content areas: symbolic, figural, and semantic. Each content area is examined in three subtests (units, relations, and transformations). Each subtest yields scores on fluency, flexibility, and originality. Factor analytic studies indicate the construct validity and inter-rater reliabilities to be very high (Cropley, 2000). Scores of this test correlate well with those of the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking (Guillory & Kher-Durlabhji, 1995). Measures for domain-specific creative-thinking ability The development of measures of domain-specific creative-thinking ability requires collaboration between test developers and people with expert and/or creative talent in the particular domain. Most of the domain-specific creativethinking tests are not standardized due to the newness of this approach, and there is a need to develop specific tasks to measure domain-specific creative thinking in specific situations. We present some examples of tests designed to assess domain-specific creative-thinking ability. Readers who are interested in using certain tests are encouraged to review the relevant literature. Creative Real-Life Problem-Solving (RLPS; Milgram, 2004) The RLPS was developed to measure creative-thinking ability in various domain-specific problem-solving situations. Each RLPS measure represents a particular domain and consisted of a minimum of four items involving reallife problem-solving. Each item describes a problem situation that frequently arises in the specific domain under investigation. In each instance the test items represent the world of experience of the research participants. For example, one set of items describe problems of social interaction of elementary school-age children, another mathematical problems that have more than one possible answer. Items on this instrument can consist of problems faced by teachers at different levels, or problems faced by victims of terror or natural disaster. Participants are asked to generate as many solutions as they can to each real-life problem presented. Three scores are computed for each research participant – quantity, quality, and total number of discrete responses – as defined earlier for scoring quantity and quality of general creative thinking. Owens Creativity Test (OCT; Owens, 1960) This test is developed to assess mechanical ideation. The OCT consists of two subtests: the Power Source Apparatus test and the Applications of Mechanisms
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 43 test. The Power Source Apparatus test asks test takers to generate as many solutions as possible (divergent thinking) to a series of mechanical problems (domain specific). Test takers are presented with diagrams of mechanical movements, and are asked to draw various ways of producing each of these movements. This subtest produces two scores: the total number of solutions and the number of workable solutions. The second subtest, the Application of Mechanisms test, asks test takers to generate as many ideas as possible for the use of a series of mechanical devices. Test takers are provided with a picture of a device and are asked to report responses in writing. One score is produced by this subtest – the total number of ideas. The OCT had acceptable levels of reliability and validity when applied to engineers in mechanically related jobs (Owens, 1969). Real-World Divergent Thinking Test (Okuda, Runco, & Berger, 1991) Okuda and colleagues (1991) developed this test based on their postulation that responses from real-world discovered problems would be the best predictors of creative activity and accomplishment in the real world. The score from this test is used as predictor of real-world creative achievement. The predictor score is the number of ideas generated in response to real-world “discovered” problems presented. Discovered problems are those which allow the children to “define” a problem before they generate ideas. Scores on this test contributed to the prediction of creative activity and accomplishment above and beyond the prediction reported for more typical divergent thinking tasks. The criterion measure used in their study was a self-report checklist of real-world creative activity filled in by each research participant. However, other authentic criterion measures can be used if one desires to examine the relationship (e.g., ratings of actual creative performance or products). Chand and Runco (1993) extended the work of Okuda and colleagues (1991) allowing examinees to select one of the problems they had themselves thought of and then think of solutions to it. Chand and Runco (1993) argued that the discovered problem tests were best viewed as problem generation tests, and they suggested that allowing examinees to select one of their own problems allows intrinsically motivated performances. This is important because intrinsic motivation seems to maximize creative thinking (Amabile, 1990; Hennessey, 1989). For more creativity-related measures, see Fishkin and Johnson (1998); they emphasized that in order to identify children with the potential to be creatively productive adults, it is important to consider information derived from multiple sources.
44 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development
Preventing talent loss Although the identification of students with potential or demonstrated talent in the non-cognitive domain has been included in federally legislated definitions of giftedness or talent since 1972 (Marland, 1972), talent identification has focused mainly on students with high general intelligence as measured by IQ and achievement test scores. For example, Haroutounian (1993, 1995) found that only 15 of 1,200 locations included specific procedures for identification of talent in the performing arts. We list a few pointers for identifying potential creative talents in an effort to reduce talent loss. Understand creative potential and creativity Identifying creative potential can be difficult and prone to error because of the inherent complexity of the task. Davis (1989, 1992) illustrated a few dimensions of this complexity, which can afflict identification of creative potential. We list a few of them, recognizing that these might help prevent talent loss. 1 Creativity involves logical and analytical thinking as well as irrational and unrestrained fantasy. 2 Many aspects must combine to orient students toward creative thinking. Examples are cognitive and non-cognitive traits such as intellectual abilities, attitudes, personality traits, motivation, opportunities, and experiences. There are different levels or degrees of creative manifestation in childhood and adolescence. All should be recognized and assisted for full development. Both small-scale creative insights such as a child’s poem and large-scale creative productivities such as high school play production are signs of creative talent. 3 Creative talent may be attained through lengthy hard work and planning. It also happens in sudden inspirations and insights. 4 Individuals can be creative in any part of their personal, educational, and professional lives. Creative personality for identifying creative potential Although this chapter emphasizes creative-thinking ability, the personality characteristics of creative persons must also be taken into consideration in order to recognize and to help develop their creative potential. Creative individuals are more likely to be: aware of their own creativity (values originality), original (imaginative, flexible), independent (self-confident, individualistic), risktaking, energetic (enthusiastic, excitable, impulsive), curious (questioning), humorous (playful), attracted to complexity (asymmetry, novelty), artistic, open-minded, need alone time, and intuitive (perceptive) (Davis, 1992).
Creative-Thinking Ability and Talent Development • 45 Use multiple sources to identify potential creative talent Several different types of measures may be used, including divergent thinking tests; product assessments; teacher, parent, peer, and self-rating; personality and interest assessments; and in-school and out-of-school activities. Develop student profiles based on these resources. Creativity training and programs Provide creativity training to increase both domain-general creative thinking and domain-specific creative-thinking ability in the domain of interest and creative potential. Include critical thinking and evaluative thinking in creativity training (Baer & Kaufman, 2005) as there are important aspects of analytical thinking required during the creative process. Enrichment and other types of differentiated programs should be provided for children with creative potential. Individuals with different types and levels of creative potential require differentiated enrichment programs. They require different levels of challenge as they gradually develop their capacity to realize their potential in their area of creative interest. Praise creative effort, not the person Restrain from saying “you are a creative person.” Praising specific efforts that students put in to generate creative ideas and products will further motivate them in such endeavors. Help them build confidence that they can develop creative capacity. That is, help them become self-efficacious by providing a challenging environment that provides successful experiences in creative endeavor. Don’t make quick judgments Refrain from making critical evaluations on children’s creative efforts and ideas; rather make an effort to appreciate them. Young children generate creative ideas routinely, but as they grow older, their natural creativity diminishes as they are forced or encouraged to conform to rules in family, classrooms, and society. Think how we can encourage creative thinking. Make the effort to be creative It is important that teachers make efforts to be creative thinkers themselves. Creative teachers are likely to recognize and foster creative students and to develop innovative instructional techniques that reflect new concepts in teaching.
46 • Cognitive Abilities and Talent Development Theory into practice A major positive impact on the phenomenon of talent loss would occur if the role of creative thinking in the educational process were understood and steps taken to adjust curriculum and instruction. We cite a pioneering effort of Livne, Livne, and Wright (2006), researchers at the University of Utah who recognize the importance of the distinction between academic and creative abilities in mathematics and have instituted a unique program of instruction based upon this understanding. Their program involves the development of computerized units designed to teach mathematics to high school students preparing for university study (http://ruready.utah.edu/RUReady/front/index. jsp). Similar efforts should be made in other subject matter areas to prevent talent loss.
part
3
Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development
chapter
5
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development
In the previous two chapters, we discussed cognitive abilities, one of the three major components that affect talent development. In the present chapter, we turn to personal–psychological attributes that have significant effects on learning and development. There is a paucity of research on selfregulation and motivation specifically geared to individuals with potential talent. However, overall findings with high versus low achievers indicate that understanding and attending to these constructs is crucial in preventing talent loss. The chapter is divided into four sections: (a) self-regulated learning, (b) motivational attributes, (c) learning styles and preferences, and (d) summary recommendations to prevent talent loss.
Self-regulated learning Learning occurs when students’ cognitive abilities, social values, beliefs, affect, and learning strategies are properly aligned with their study practices and behaviors. Various theoretical perspectives have been proposed to describe how students become responsible learners by regulating their own learning (e.g., Bandura, 1977, 1986; Borkowski, 1996; Zimmerman, 1990). Self-regulated learners use diverse metacognitive strategies that include planning learning
50 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development activities, monitoring learning processes, and deciding which cognitive strategies and learning environments to use and when to use them (Pintrich, Wolters, & Baxter, 2000). Self-regulated students view many learning tasks as important, interesting, and useful (Pintrich 2000; Wigfield, 1994). As a consequence they become motivated to regulate their efforts, to persist when they encounter difficulty, and to complete these tasks (Corno, 2001; Wolters, 2003). When students are motivated toward a task (e.g., intrinsic value), they tend to use cognitive and metacognitive strategies to learn (Boekaerts, 1997; Schunk, 2001). Thus, students who acquire self-regulatory skills become more independent learners and assume responsibility for their own learning. There are different theories and perspectives of self-regulated learning, but consideration of metacognitive, motivational, and behavioral dimensions in self-regulated learning is common. Bandura (1993) asserts that self-directed learning requires motivation as well as cognitive and metacognitive strategies. Zimmerman (1990) in his social-cognitive theory posits that a student’s use of cognitive and metacognitive strategies enhances self-efficacy, which in turn provides the motivational basis for further self-regulation during learning. Motivation is essential for self-regulated learning. Both intrinsic motivation and self-efficacy have positive effects on academic self-regulation (Garcia & Pintrich, 1991). In the next two subsections, we present the two important aspects of self-regulated learning – metacognition and motivation. Metacognition Metacognition entails conscious awareness and monitoring of one’s own learning processes through activities such as planning or goal setting, monitoring, self-evaluation, and selecting appropriate strategies to achieve the goal (e.g., Flavell, 1979; Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1988). If students’ self-monitoring process is inadequate, progress in learning or performance is restricted because they are not able to recognize the need for adjustments to their learning behaviors. The monitoring process not only applies to actions being taken but also includes conditions under which learning occurs as well as the outcomes of the process (Zimmerman & Paulsen, 1995). Self-regulated learners plan strategies before they attempt to solve problems. Low- and high-achieving students use different planning strategies for solving problems. For example, when solving an arithmetic problem, low achievers tend to base their solution plan on the numbers and keywords that they select from the problem (Hegarty, Mayer, & Monk, 1995). On the other hand, high achievers construct a model of the situation described in the problem and base their solution plan on that model. These models are kept in working memory and used to monitor the solution process. Students who plan test strategies before tests and/or during tests perform better than those who do not (Kitsantas, 2002).
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 51 Self-monitoring strategies allow learners to keep track of learning processes and help plan subsequent steps. A basic form of self-awareness involved in problem-solving tasks is awareness of knowing what you know and what you do not know (Brown, 1978). Students who use monitoring strategies determine if they recognize the problem, whether they understand what is to be found, whether they are following a successful strategy that leads to a solution, and, if not, what to do about it, and whether their answer makes sense (Baker & Brown, 1984). Self-regulated learners select, use, and adjust strategies when involved in various tasks (Margolis & McCabe, 2004; Winne, 2001). When facing a complicated test item, some students break it down into manageable parts and number each part so they can check quickly to make sure they have answered all the parts (Kesselman-Turkel & Peterson, 2003). For certain hard questions, some students work backwards to find the answer. Strategies such as recopying problems to represent the problem in an easier format (e.g., drawing a picture) are also helpful to some students in solving test items (Carter, Wehby, & Hughes, 2005). Effects of metacognition in achievement Use of metacognitive strategies helps students learn and perform better. High-achieving students use these strategies more often than low achievers (Hong, O’Neil, & Feldon, 2005; Kitsantas, 2002). Gifted students, compared with non-gifted students, tend to be more strategic (Montague & Applegate, 1993; Shore & Dover, 1987), are more likely to have conscious control over the solution process (Shore & Carey, 1984), use more strategies for organizing and transforming information (Zimmerman & Martinez-Pons, 1990), use learning strategies more effectively, transfer these strategies to novel tasks when trained to do so (Risemberg & Zimmerman, 1992), and use more rereading, inferring, analyzing, predicting, and evaluating strategies (Fehrenbach, 1991). When creatively talented students in mathematics were compared with academically gifted or non-gifted students, creatively talented students used more self-regulated strategies (Hong & Aqui, 2004). Giftedness is often associated with greater knowledge of strategies, quicker problem-solving, and the ability to use strategies more appropriately. Gifted and average-ability children differ in their patterns of strategy development and use; gifted children take more time to plan and execute their strategies and make better use of information learned from mistakes (Steiner, 2006). Students who use metacognitive strategies not only achieve their goals better than those who do not (Obach, 2003; Zimmerman & Kitsantas, 1997, 1999), they also select and use effective study strategies (Hong, Sas, & Sas, 2006; Sundre & Kitsantas, 2004). For example, high achievers might use rehearsal strategies for tasks that involve memorization, but they utilize elaboration strategies for tasks that require understanding (Weinstein & Mayer, 1986).
52 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development While high achievers use both surface and deep strategies, they use deep strategies more frequently than low achievers (Holschuh, 2000). Metacognitive training Students with high self-regulatory traits tend to get involved in self-regulatory activities in various learning situations. However, levels of self-regulatory activities that students apply are different across subject matter areas, indicating that self-regulation is also situation specific (Hong, 1998b). This suggests that self-regulation is malleable and trainable. Metacognitive training helps increase students’ knowledge of metacognition, helps them use strategies flexibly, and increases learning (e.g., Jausovec, 1994). Evidence indicates that students who receive lessons on self-regulation use more planning strategies, improve their scores on tasks, and display more interest than the students who do not receive such lessons (Azevedo & Cromley, 2004). College students also benefit from training; Butler (1998) provided tutoring sessions to students with learning disabilities and found that these sessions improved their perceived self-efficacy and task performance and increased metacognition about the tasks and use of sophisticated learning strategies.
Motivational attributes Various theories have been advanced to understand how motivation affects learning and creativity. In general, self-regulated learners are highly motivated to learn. They view learning tasks as valuable, useful, or interesting (e.g., Pintrich, 2000; Wigfield, 1994) and display high self-efficacy and extraordinary effort and persistence during learning and problem solving (Zimmerman, 1990). High achievers also have a tendency to be mastery goal oriented (Dweck & Leggett, 1988). In this section we discuss task value, selfefficacy, and achievement goals as motivational characteristics related to learning, achievement and creativity. Achievement value and task value Achievement value or task value is an essential motivational mediator of selfregulatory behaviors such as effort and persistence. Achievement values are “the incentives or purposes that individuals have for succeeding on a given task” (Wigfield, 1994, p. 102). The value that individuals place on the outcome and their perceived probability of success determine how much effort they will apply to complete the task successfully. The motivating potential of anticipating outcomes is largely determined by the subjective value that the person places on the attainment (Bandura, 1997). People may put forth effort when they value the outcome, even when they believe that their probability of success is quite low.
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 53 Task value is the motivational belief of students that the task (e.g., homework) is important and useful (utility value) or interesting and enjoyable (intrinsic value) (Wigfield & Eccles, 1992). Tasks that are valued, especially those intrinsically valued, are related to high levels of learning and achievement (Greene, DeBacker, Ravindran, & Krows, 1999; Hong & Aqui, 2004). Low achievers, in general, value their school work less than do high achievers (Hong, Peng, & Rowell 2006; Lepper, Corpus, & Iyengar, 2005). A similar pattern is revealed with regard to tests and test-taking. Students’ perceptions of the importance or usefulness of tests are significantly related to students’ test-taking motivation and test performance (Wolf & Smith, 1995). Whether test utility value has an effect on test performance is of interest in the test-intensive society. Students who hold stronger test utility value report having regulated their motivation by putting forth effort and being persistent while preparing for tests. Moreover, they use metacognitive strategies more than those who hold weaker test value (Hong & Peng, 2006). Whether the motivation is intrinsic or extrinsic makes a difference. Intrinsically motivated individuals are curious about, interested in, and enjoy the tasks in which they are engaged. By contrast, extrinsically motivated individuals engage in tasks with the goal of seeking rewards such as money, praise, or high grades. Intrinsic motivation influences perceived competence, and competence, in turn, influences academic achievement (Goldberg & Cornell, 1998). Gifted students tend to be more intrinsically motivated and seek challenges more than their non-gifted peers (Dai, Moon, & Feldhusen, 1998). Creatively talented people are intrinsically motivated. They exhibit high interest and enjoyment in what they choose to do (Amabile, 1996; Winner, 1996a). Intrinsic motivation has been viewed as beneficial to creativity whereas extrinsic motivation has been considered detrimental (Amabile, 1983, 1990). However, extrinsic motivators (e.g., awards) can be used as additional incentives if sufficient intrinsic motivation already exists (Hennessey, Amabile, & Martinage, 1989). Gagné (1995) asserts that motivation plays a crucial role in initiating the process of talent development, guiding it, and sustaining it through obstacles, boredom, and occasional failure. Self-efficacy and its relationship to effort and persistence Self-efficacy beliefs contribute to motivation in determining “the goals people set for themselves, how much effort they expend, how long they persevere in the face of difficulties, and their resilience to failures” (Bandura, 1993, p. 131). High achievers report having higher self-efficacy whereas low achievers and underachievers are often described as being more anxious and less self-
54 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development efficacious (Risemberg & Zimmerman, 1992). Low achievers tend to set lower academic goals, to lack persistence, and to engage in maladaptive academic behaviors (Borkowski & Thorpe, 1994). Self-regulatory skills become insignificant if students do not utilize the skills in a persistent manner in the face of difficulties, distractions, and stress. How individuals attribute the success or failure of their actions influences motivation and performance (Weiner, 1994). These attributions have an effect largely through the mediational role of self-efficacy (Bandura, 1997; Schunk, 1991). Students who are confident of their ability intensify their efforts when failure occurs and persist until they succeed (Pajares, 1996). Students with high self-efficacy attribute failure to insufficient effort or deficient knowledge that can be acquired (Bandura, 1993). Gifted students perceive themselves as more competent than non-gifted students, and they are also less likely to attribute failure to lack of ability and think that school success depends on their effort rather than ability or luck (Chen, 1996). However, other studies (e.g., Kurtz & Weinert, 1989) found the opposite trend; gifted children attributed academic success to high ability while average children attributed success to effort. These conflicting findings may reflect situation-specific attributional beliefs in gifted children (e.g., task difficulty, domain specificity). Adolescents academically or creatively talented in mathematics reported being more self-efficacious than their non-gifted peers (Hong & Aqui, 2004). Further, both types of talented students in mathematics perceived themselves as highly able in math (e.g., “I have a mathematical mind”), valued their math class (e.g., “it is important for me to learn the course material in this math class”), and were confident in mathematics (e.g., “I expect to do well in this math class”). Motivation to study hard for tests as evidenced by effort and persistence has a positive effect on test performance (Hong & Peng, 2006; Wise & DeMars, 2005). Achievement goals: goal orientation and goal setting Goals provide the framework within which a person interprets and responds to events and result in a unique pattern of cognition, behavior, and affect (Dweck & Leggett, 1988; Elliott & Dweck, 1988). Achievement goal theorists construe motivation in education with reference to the qualitative goal orientations adopted by students as they engage in learning activities (Brophy, 2005). Two types of goal orientations have been discussed widely – mastery/ learning goal orientation and performance goal orientations. Goal orientation is also described in terms of “approach” (i.e., a person is motivated by the desire to approach success) or “avoidance” (i.e., a person is motivated by the desire to avoid failure) (e.g., Elliot & McGregor, 2001).
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 55 Students with learning goal orientations define success as learning or mastering something new and focus on increasing their levels of competence by acquiring knowledge or skills (Midgley & Urdan, 1995). Students with performance-approach orientations want to demonstrate their ability relative to others by outperforming them and publicly displaying their task-relevant knowledge or skills. Students with performance-avoidance orientation focus more on not being seen as incompetent compared with their peers. Performance-avoidance orientation is presumed to develop as a result of fear of failure (Speirs-Neumeister & Finch, 2006). Some theorists assert that performance goals (approach or avoidance) have detrimental effects on learning and achievement (Dweck & Leggett, 1988). However, others found that although performance-avoidance goals negatively predicted academic efficacy and strategy use, performance-approach goals emerged as a positive predictor of these outcomes (Middleton & Midgley, 1997). In general, students who adopt a learning or mastery goal orientation increase perceptions of selfefficacy and use effective learning strategies (Ames & Archer 1988; Middleton & Midgley, 1997). When gifted students adopt performance goals and are motivated to outperform others, it may result in unprofitable achievement-related behaviors such as avoiding challenging tasks. Although some researchers (e.g., Ziegler, Heller, & Broome, 1996) observe no difference in goal orientation between the gifted and non-gifted students, others (e.g., Ainley, 1993; Schunk & Swartz, 1993) find that gifted students score high on mastery goal orientations as well as performance goal orientations. Students’ implicit theory of ability is related to goal orientation. Students holding incremental theory of ability (i.e., ability is malleable) predominantly adopt learning goals focusing on developing their ability, view effort as a positive thing, attribute their failure to low ability less frequently, and report strategy use to increase effort and persistence instead of effort withdrawal (Dweck & Leggett, 1988; Molden & Dweck, 2006). Goal specificity may be important for promoting effort. When people are asked to do their best (instead of giving them a specific goal), they tend not to do so. Locke and Latham (2002) suggest that this is because do-your-best goals have no external referent, thus allowing a wide range of acceptable performance levels. Individuals with high self-efficacy tend to set higher goals and commit themselves to assigned goals, use better strategies to attain the goals, and respond more positively to negative feedback than do individuals with low self-efficacy (Locke & Latham, 1990). One can assign goals or allow individuals to set the goals. When individuals are allowed to set the goals, the goals might be perceived as more important to them because they, in part, are self-assigned. This assertion, however, is
56 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development supported only partially. Whereas some studies supported this theory (Erez, 1986), other studies did not find a difference between the other-assigned and self-assigned goals (e.g., Latham & Marshall, 1982). Whether or not students value the goal may have something to do with the conflicting findings, along with other attributes such as perception of the person assigning the goals. To summarize what has been said thus far, the following variables are likely to increase self-confidence, self-efficacy, expenditure of effort and persistence, and as a consequence, lead to high achievement: (a) high value versus low value attached to task or performance; (b) intrinsic over extrinsic motivation; (c) high over low self-efficacy; (d) a mastery/learning goal over performance goal; (e) an approach or success-seeking orientation over a failure-avoidance orientation; (f) goal specificity over goal generality and vagueness; and (g) an incremental theory of ability over an entity theory. There are other important psychological variables that are not discussed in this volume. For example, beliefs about learning (e.g., epistemological beliefs) are important to understand as they influence how students intake and process information and are related to creative behavior. Understanding the relationships of these variables to learning and creative behavior would help students, educators, and parents prevent possible loss of academic or creative talent.
Learning styles and preferences Learning styles also contribute to individual differences in learning and achievement and to the degree of talent realization or talent loss. Learning style refers to the specific set of conditions favorable for an individual to concentrate on a given task and to absorb, process, and retain new or difficult information and skills. Learning style develops as a consequence of hereditary factors, previous learning experiences, and the demands of the present environment (Kolb, 1976). As a result of these variables, most people develop preferred learning styles. There is some disagreement about the stability of learning styles over time. Davidman (1981), Hong and Suh (1995), and Reid (1987) found that learning styles – even though relatively stable – change in individuals over time due to biological and psycho-social maturation, cultural changes, and the introduction of new environmental stimuli. Others contend that learning styles remain constant, regardless of changes in the learning environment or in the subject matter being taught (Kalous, 1990; Restak, 1979). Learning styles in the classroom Some learning style proponents have demonstrated that students achieve better and demonstrate higher motivation to learn if they are taught, at least
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 57 initially, in a manner that is consistent with their learning style (e.g., Dunn & Dunn, 1993). Accordingly, if students are to have the best opportunity to learn, it becomes important to identify students’ learning styles and to develop instructional strategies congruent with these styles. This approach recommends that teachers adapt instructions and/or adjust the learning environment, rather than retraining students to adopt new learning styles. It emphasizes the importance of creating a variety of learning environments, multiple resources, variable instructional methodologies, and flexible teaching to accommodate individual differences in learning style (Keefe, 1982). This level of individualized instruction is not easily achieved. Another approach acknowledges students’ individual differences in learning style preferences, but stresses the need of students to adapt on many occasions to an imposed learning environment (DeBello, 1990; Hong & Milgram, 2000). That is, although students may prefer to use their own learning style, they should be encouraged to use others if the learning environment or task instructions demand otherwise. Under these circumstances, initial learning may not be as efficient as when students use their preferred learning style, but encouragement of this adjustment will lead them to expand their repertoire of learning styles. This approach emphasizes matching instruction to individual preferences when learning involves new and difficult materials and supplementing students’ preferences with varied instructional strategies and materials so as to make them more capable of modifying their learning style when necessary. Zhang (2002) distinguishes two kinds of thinking style that underlie the various learning styles – a holistic thinking style and the more traditional analytic thinking style. He found that creative and complex thinking and learning styles are related to a holistic mode of thinking, whereas the conforming and simplistic thinking styles are related to the analytic mode. Sternberg and Grigorenko (1993) acknowledge the importance of learning style in gifted education. They state that decisions about identification, instruction, and programming for gifted students need to take into account not only the abilities of the students but also their styles of thinking and learning. Group differences in learning styles of gifted and regular students have been found (e.g., Hong & Milgram, 2000; Milgram, Dunn, & Price 1993). We provide a few examples. 1 Academically gifted, when compared with regular, students are more teacher motivated, do not need to move about the classroom as much while learning, and prefer to learn visually. This pattern of preferences is consonant with the kinds of attitudes that lead to successful performance in most conventional classrooms. 2 Creative thinkers (i.e., high in general ideational fluency) differ from their low-creative-thinking age peers in tactile and kinesthetic learning
58 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development styles, suggesting that they profit from active involvement in experiential learning as well as from the opportunity to explore and handle a wide variety of materials as they learn. 3 Creative thinkers prefer less structure in their school tasks, a situation that would allow them to define, interpret, and work on the tasks in more than one way; they also prefer an informal learning environment, possibly with carpets, soft furniture, and the like. On the other hand, they are less persistent and less comfortable in the presence of authority figures than the low-creative-thinking group. These findings substantiate some widespread views about creative-thinking children. Homework learning style Studies on homework learning style complement studies on learning style in the classroom (Hong, 2001a; Hong & Lee, 2000). Research findings include: 1 High achievers are more self-motivated and motivated by their parents and teachers than their age peers. These differences are not surprising in that high achievers are distinguished from low achievers by scores on tests given in the classroom that reflect the receptiveness of gifted students to these sources of motivation. While high teacher-rated achievement was more closely associated with high scores on the teacher-motivated element, the self-perception of work accomplishment at home was more positive in those students who were highly motivated by parents as well as teachers. 2 When compared with low achievers, high achievers are more persistent, organize their homework in an order of their choosing, and prefer specific instructions. They prefer to do homework alone, in a brightly lit room. Low achievers tend to prefer to eat or drink or move about while doing homework more so than high achievers. There were no differences between high and low achievers on preferred or actual perceptual sensitivity (i.e., auditory, visual, tactile, kinesthetic). Caveat. One should keep in mind that learning styles of individuals within each group vary widely. If educators or parents wish to use learning style information for accommodating instructional environment to individual learners, it is important to gain information about the particular child’s learning style. That is, individual differences in learning styles are more important than the findings on group differences; the latter give only the baseline understanding, which could be helpful when individual treatment cannot be rendered and group-based considerations are the only option.
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 59 Adaptive instruction or adaptive learners Earlier we illustrated different instructional approaches based on learning styles. As might be expected, students’ learning preferences are not always honored in the classroom or at home. There are many students who do not do their homework according to their individual learning style preferences (Hong & Lee, 2000; Hong & Milgram, 1999). Some of the disparity between preferred and actual styles of learning can be remedied by parents with simple accommodations. For example, parents may provide more light or allow their children to dim the light, have some background music, or permit their children to move around while doing homework, if they prefer to study that way. Not surprisingly, students’ achievement scores and parental awareness of their children’s learning style are positively related. Likewise, a narrow gap between preferred and actual learning styles is related to high achievement. Interestingly, the preferred–actual disparity was not found in children of high creative-thinking ability (Ohayon, 1999). They were apparently able to find ways to persuade their parents to accede to their preferences or to find other ways to have their preferences met. Creative thinkers, by definition, are able to generate more unusual and high-quality solutions to a wide variety of problems that occur in life. How they handled the circumstances in which they did their homework is another example of their skill in problem-solving. That each child has his or her own learning preferences is no longer a subject for debate. There is disagreement, however, whether efforts should be made to change or expand students’ learning preferences to conform to classroom instructions, or to adapt instructions to match students’ preferred modes of learning. Some educators or parents may disagree as to how to treat these learning differences in classrooms and in home learning situations, but all appreciate the impact of these differences on effective learning.
Preventing talent loss Students who show academic promise do not always fulfill this promise, and they experience a sense of frustration, as do their teachers and parents. Gifted and talented achievers and underachievers differ in their self-regulated learning, motivation, and valuation as well as in their attitudes toward school and teachers (McCoach & Siegle, 2003). Understanding self-regulated learning and motivation theories provides us with some of the recommended practices that can promote student achievement. Student knowledge of cognitive and metacognitive strategies is helpful, and this knowledge is a necessary condition for fulfilling promise; however, it is not enough. Underachieving students need to be motivated to use this knowledge. To prevent talent loss, educators need to go beyond teaching content material and to attend to students’ self-
60 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development regulation and motivation level. Recommendations relevant to these topics are presented below. Self-regulated learning for preventing talent loss Provide self-regulatory strategy instructions and encourage students to use them Although gifted achievers utilize self-regulatory learning strategies more frequently than regular and gifted underachievers, some do not use them and others fail to use them consistently (Carr, Alexander, & Schwanenflugel, 1996). All students can be trained to understand and use self-regulatory strategies as well as to transfer these strategies to novel tasks or situations (Risemberg & Zimmerman, 1992). From elementary to college student level, it is evident that students can learn to use metacognitive strategies. Metacognitive awareness helps students recognize what they know and what they do not know, and metacognitive strategies help them use planning, self-monitoring, and selfevaluating processes for all learning purposes. Combine various strategies Metacognitive training enhances performance on solving problems that require analytic thinking for solution better than it facilitates solving open problems calling for creativity (Jausovec, 1994). If we intend to enable students to enhance their creative-thinking ability, it becomes necessary to include other types of instructions such as brainstorming or problem-finding exercises along with metacognitive training (Shore & Dover, 1987) (see Chapter 12 for creativity training). Use high-order strategies for teaching and learning Strategies that involve understanding are used by high achievers more often than by low achievers (Sundre & Kitsantas, 2004). Some surface strategies, such as simply repeating reading or reviewing notes without relating or connecting information to already learned material, are not sufficient. Rote rehearsal does not guarantee learning or subsequent retention (Mayer, 1996). Examples of effective strategies include self-quizzing, organizing, elaborating, taking notes, comparing class notes with textbook, and transcribing notes (e.g., Holschuh, 2000; Kitsantas, 2002). Learning activities that do not contain some of these strategies may not lead to higher achievement. Develop curriculum materials with embedded self-regulated learning strategies To encourage learners to use self-regulated learning strategies, curriculum and instructions should be designed to combine metacognitive and motivational strategies and content material; for example, students are asked to answer questions that activate their use of strategies. Although there are some
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 61 textbooks that provide such questions for similar purposes, a more effective way to develop such instructional materials can be achieved by utilizing technologies (see Chapter 11). Develop learner-based metacognitive instruction Gifted underachievers or gifted students with learning disabilities have special needs and may require more assistance in acquiring self-regulated learning strategies than others. Although gifted students with learning disabilities monitor their reading, use evaluation, paraphrase, and metacognitive strategies, many do not acquire proficiency in these strategies (McGuire & Yewchuk, 1996). An early childhood metacognition program for gifted underachievers might include teacher and peer modeling of self-regulatory strategies such as think-aloud, behavioral demonstration, and prompting steps to follow to complete tasks efficiently (Manning, Glasner, & Smith, 1996). Individualize instruction according to the individual needs as often as possible It is a challenge for teachers to provide individualized instruction. However, different kinds of students (e.g., gifted achievers and underachievers, gifted with learning disabilities, regular achievers, and underachievers) require different instructional content, delivery, and strategy. Some individualized instructional approaches have demonstrated positive effect. A process-based instruction program (Ashman, Wright, & Conway, 1994) that was developed for enhancing the metacognitive skills of academically gifted students in mainstream classrooms can also be adapted to students with diverse abilities. This type of teaching approach enables teachers to individualize instruction by involving all students in developing plans for curriculum and learning activities. Environmental management Self-regulated students select, structure, and create environments that optimize learning (Sternberg & Grigorenko, 2000; Zimmerman, 1990). These students adjust their thinking and/or behavior to adjust better to the learning environment in which they learn, function, perform, or to change the learning environment to meet their learning and performance requirements. Some students require a quiet environment in order to do their homework; accordingly they may turn off the television, move away from it, or go to the library. Other students require background music as a filter (i.e., background noise filters task-irrelevant thinking) during their academic study. Something as simple as having a good breakfast on the day of a test is a good strategy for many students (King, 2000). Creative learners might have additional requirements in finding an optimizing environment. In short, selecting an optimizing environment is an important self-regulated learning strategy for success in school or in any human endeavor.
62 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development Teacher training Teachers undoubtedly practice self-regulation, but they may be unaware of it and unable to transmit these strategies to their students. All teachers will profit from workshops in this area and some will require special training if they are to introduce a self-regulated learning program into their students’ curriculum. Enhancing motivation for preventing talent loss Motivate before teaching When students lack interest and motivation in a given lesson or assignment (“I am bored”; “I hope to get by”), they will not apply effective self-regulatory strategies that are within their repertoire (Hong, Sas, & Sas, 2006). To promote student engagement in strategy application, one may address motivational concerns such as effort, value, interest, self-efficacy, and/or goal-setting. Many teachers do not do so because of their concern that the scheduled curriculum must be covered, even if most of the students are not listening. If teachers do not understand motivational issues in general and the motivational problems of individual students, and make no effort to deal with them, their efforts to instruct will be wasted and student learning will not meet anyone’s expectation, not the teachers’, the students’, or their parents’. Motivate underachieving students by helping them experience success Many motivational characteristics exacerbate students’ learning problems (Borkowski & Thorpe, 1994). Underachieving students have low self-efficacy about their academic performance, are anxious, have fear of failure, do not make the effort to learn, or give up easily when facing difficulties. Even though they know that they have to try harder, many do not regulate themselves to put forth the needed effort. If teachers provide assignments that match current ability level, these students will enjoy a rare experience of success that will raise their immediate expectations of success and ultimately their long-term aspirations. If teachers help students set proper short-term goals, high enough to challenge and not too high to cause failure, students will expend more effort to achieve these goals. When students make an effort to face challenges, teachers should focus as much on the effort as on the result, and praise both. Pay attention to task or achievement value before teaching content Even when students have self-regulated learning skills, they will not make an effort to learn if they do not value learning, in general, or the specific course material, in particular. Educators are in a position to inspire students to value education, to value acquisition of knowledge and the means to acquire knowledge, and to value doing well on achievement tests. On a day-to-day
Self-regulation, Motivation, Learning Style, and Talent Development • 63 basis, it is the responsibility of the teacher to relate the course material to the valued concerns and interests of their students. Sometimes students do not see the value because of the way the material is being presented, but alert and creative teachers are able to bridge the gap. Help students set goals and develop a sense of self-efficacy Students should be encouraged to work to achieve specific goals with predetermined levels, not simply to “do their best.” When students achieve a predetermined level of a specific goal, they will “raise the bar” and try to achieve a higher level. The development of self-efficacy is based on a succession of successes and expectations of further successes. Teachers are in an ideal position to foster students’ self-efficacy about their school-relevant abilities. Provide an environment where creativity can thrive Students are intrinsically motivated to pursue activities that are moderately novel, interesting, and optimally challenging. When tasks are too difficult, students become anxious or frustrated; when they are too easy, students become bored (Deci & Ryan, 1985). Teachers should try to create a classroom environment that fosters intrinsic motivation by providing students with opportunities to engage in interesting, personally relevant, and challenging activities. Several principles are relevant to enhancing creativity in students: (a) encourage them to be proud of their effort and good work rather than reward them with material gifts and gratuities; (b) minimize the number of competitive situations in which their work is compared with that of others; (c) encourage them to practice self-regulation in the course of a project on which they are working; (d) provide latitude for choice of project and how to go about and do the project; (e) convey to them that you appreciate and value highly creative efforts and products; (f) show them by personal examples that you personally are an intrinsically motivated adult who enjoys thinking creatively; (g) give them opportunities for free play with diverse materials; and (h) allow them to engage in fantasy and flights of imagination in order to stimulate rich imagery and spatial abilities (e.g., Hennessey & Amabile, 1987; Lubart, 1994). Understand students’ implicit theories about ability If students hold an entity theory about human abilities (ability is fixed), they are likely to settle for their current level of achievement despite evidence or the possibility that the level could be far higher. They will tell themselves that they are not smart enough to do better and will be reluctant to contradict self-fulfilling expectations of failure if they try. Conversely, if they come to believe that they can do better if they make more effort in an expeditious manner, they will be inspired to increase their goals and try to achieve newly set goals. Holding to the entity belief is detrimental even for gifted students who attribute their current success to their high ability; when challenged in
64 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development the future to excel under more competitive circumstances than before, these students may choose not to make the effort required. Recognize learning styles and utilize them to maximize learning Understand and accommodate individual differences Teachers must understand learning styles and preferences and help students identify their learning styles and understand the practical implications of these styles. By the same token, teachers should recognize their own learning and teaching styles and the implications for their personal and professional lives. Teachers are called upon to create a learning environment that accommodates the learning preferences of the majority of students and to find ways to help the minority whose learning styles do not match. Help students attain favorable learning style Some students show signs of potential for academic excellence but do not realize their potential due to their tendency to work impulsively and without reflection. When impulsivity becomes habitual, it becomes an obstacle for meeting achievement goals. This happens because students cannot use their full intellectual resources to bear on a problem due to their tendency to jump to conclusions. Sternberg and Grigorenko (2000) suggest that teachers encourage students to control their impulses by rewarding them when they do exercise control. Teachers can ask students to reflect before they come up with solutions or ideas. Seek assistance when needed One way to encourage passive learners to become engaged in learning activities is to provide an environment in which help-seeking is viewed as constructive and is encouraged. As shown by some of the high achievers, seeking assistance from more knowledgeable others might be an effective strategy that passive learners may adopt (e.g., Kitsantas, 2002). Adaptive helpseeking (Newman, 2002) can prevent possible failure, maintain engagement, and lead to autonomous and successful learning.
chapter
6
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development
In the previous chapter we discussed motivational, cognitive and metacognitive, and learning style aspects of the personal–psychological component of the Comprehensive Model of Giftedness and Talent in an effort to inform readers how they differ among individuals and what can be done to reduce talent loss by attending to those aspects. The topic of this chapter is the affective attributes of personal–psychological components. We discuss how various affective characteristics differ among children and how they affect talent development. We hope that understanding these relationships will enable readers to become partners in the solution to talent loss. We selected several important affect and intrapersonal constructs to present in this chapter. Some of them are emotion related such as mood, stress, and anxiety; others are attitude related; and still others deal with personality traits that influence the make-up of talent, such as independence, responsibility, commitment, tolerance, conformity, and risk-taking. We conclude this chapter with several suggestions for preventing talent loss focusing on these affective constructs.
66 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development
Complexity and uniqueness of affective and intrapersonal characteristics In an effort to understand how giftedness might contribute to life adjustment, Neihart (1999a) reviewed the literature and offered two contrasting views. Giftedness can be viewed as (a) enhancing resiliency in individuals or (b) increasing vulnerability. The first perspective assumes that gifted children are able to understand themselves and others due to their high intellectual capacities, and are, therefore, able to cope better with stress, conflict, and developmental challenges than their non-gifted peers. Numerous studies support this view that gifted children as a group are better adjusted than are children of average ability (Baker, 1995; Nail, 1998). However, some studies indicate that the gifted advantage applies to certain academic domains but not to all academic domains or non-academic domains (Little, 2005; Schneider, 1987). Some gifted individuals such as gifted underachievers or highly creative people are prone to maladjustment (Bruns, 1992; Kwan, 1992). They have higher rates of depression, manic–depressive disorder, or suicide. This phenomenon is more pronounced among creative individuals who have achieved eminence (Jamison, 1993; Richards, 1989; Rothenberg, 1990). This contradiction may be understood if we consider a number of reservations: (a) there are demographic differences between studies of gifted and non-gifted groups and between different types of giftedness (e.g., creatively or intellectually gifted); (b) there are differences of domain (art versus science) from which the gifted are selected for research; (c) there are differences between studies in the criteria by which these groups were constituted; (d) a few maladjusted individuals may be found within gifted groups that tower above comparison groups in overall mental health; (e) maladjustment in gifted individuals draws inordinate attention in the popular press, while similar emotional difficulties among non-gifted people are ignored; and (f) any one person, gifted or non-gifted, possesses positive as well as negative personal traits and either can be used to support pre-existing stereotypical bias about gifted children and adults. Differences of affective characteristics found across domains as well as within a domain attest to these contradictory phenomena. Piirto’s (1998) study on successful female creative writers provides a good example of contradicting personality attributes. As a group, these creative writers were independent, courageous, risk-taking, resilient, frank, introverted, empathetic, humorous, intuitive, and perceptive. On the other hand, some of them were depressed, alienated and marginalized, envious, and self-destructive. Thus, giftedness appears to introduce some uniformity as well as variability in the developmental trajectory of individuals due to the complex and unique characteristics and traits that individuals bring to the developmental equation.
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development • 67
Affect: emotion and anxiety Emotion, mood, and stress Research in psychology, cognitive science, and neuroscience has demonstrated that emotion is central and essential for human endeavors including learning, memory, motivation, and psychological and physical health (Lewis & Haviland-Jones, 2004). In their review of the role of emotion in human learning, Pekrun, Elliot, and Maier (2006) note that emotion influences learning and performance by changing brain dopamine levels, affecting longterm memory, inducting and sustaining student interest in learning material, and facilitating or impeding students’ self-regulation in learning and performance (Krapp, 2005; Pekrun, Titz, Goetz, & Perry 2002). Moreover, emotion has an impact on learning by directing attention and the use of cognitive resources, and by triggering different models of information processing and problem-solving (Meinhardt & Pekrun, 2003). Whereas some emotions have a positive effect on learning, others, such as boredom, shame, and anxiety, have a negative effect (e.g., Hong, 2001b; Turner & Schallert, 2001). However, an emotional trait (e.g., despair) could have a positive effect on certain talent development (e.g., creative talent) for some individuals but not for others depending how these people handle such emotion during the developmental years (e.g., Simonton, 1992). Intellectually gifted children may experience unevenness in various aspects of human development (Neihart, Reis, Robinson, & Moon, 2002). Their intellectual development may well exceed their socio-emotional maturity, and such asynchronous development can cause intra- and interpersonal difficulties. Gifted adolescents, for example, may struggle more with issues of autonomy, independence, intensity, self-perception, and social acceptance than their non-gifted peers (Neihart, Reis, Robinson, & Moon, 2002; Solow, 1995). Creative characteristics add additional uniqueness to the developmental equation. Reciprocal influences between emotion and creativity have been discussed in the literature, including the effect of emotion on creativity, the link between emotion-centered psychopathology and creative work, the role of individualized emotions in forming creative associations, and affect produced as a result of creative effort (Wolfe, 1985). Getz and Lubart (1998) and Lubart and Getz (1997) identify ways in which the relationship between emotion and creativity may be conceived: 1 Experiencing and expressing emotions stimulates creativity and can be a resource for creative work. Creative work is often viewed as a means of expressing one’s idiosyncratic emotions and affective response to the world.
68 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development 2 Emotional experience or mood may place the individual in a heightened mental state that influences creativity. People put in a mildly positive emotional state interpret stimuli in novel ways or generate novel solutions to complex problems. A negative or strongly positive emotional state, however, could have a negative influence on creativity, problem-solving, making judgments, or divergent thinking. Negative mood could also have a facilitating effect on problem-finding and -solving and making judgments. These findings indicate the intricate and complex interactions between creative personalities and environmental stimuli (Feist, 1994; Getz & Lubart, 1998; Isen, 1987; Russ, 1993). 3 Emotion may stimulate specific concepts or images. Affective experiences become attached to concepts or images representing objects, people, and events in memory. Emotional states provide an associative bridge between cognitively remote concepts representing objects, persons, or events in memory. Russ (1993) suggested that access to affect-laden thoughts may contribute to divergent thinking and free association. 4 Emotions may accompany or be a consequence of creative work (Feist, 1994). The emotion resulting from one step may spark or mediate a following step in a dynamic multistep creative process. Likewise, creative work elicits emotional responses in various forms during and after the production/performance stages. People with eminent creative talents reported needing time to be by themselves when they were children (Ochse, 1990; Olszewski-Kublius, 2000), probably because aloneness gave them the opportunity to read, practice, or acquire skills in the area in which they were interested in producing creative work (Winner, 1996b). Csikszentmihalyi, Rathunde, and Whaen (1993) also underscore the importance of aloneness during the adolescent formative years. In many areas of creativity, reading in childhood is an important characteristic of creative individuals as it provides the necessary knowledge base from which their creativity emerges (Simonton, 1994). People with creative talent are often withdrawn even when they are with others and often make deliberate attempts to seek solitude (Ochse, 1990). The inclination of gifted and/or creative children to seek solitude can be a source of concern for parents who believe that one should make friends. Concerned parents may berate their children for being alone and pressure them unduly to spend time with others. Balance is important in this aspect, as with other life aspects, and parents should allow these children to follow their own inclinations. Highly creative individuals also seek tension from asynchrony, discordance, and risk taking. These situations provide the kinds of tension that creative individuals are comfortable with (Feldman, 1994; Gardner, 1994). Situations
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development • 69 that provoke high levels of anxiety and tension may even be preferable to these individuals (Gardner, 1994); they seek the pleasure that results from the reduction of tension or the anticipated reduction of tension. These proclivities, like being alone, may disturb parents, teachers, and counselors, as well as age peers, and introduce unwarranted tension, self-devaluation and alienation in their interpersonal development. Although concerns that gifted and creative children are predisposed to emotional instability were voiced by respected authorities decades ago (Jung, 1954; Lombroso, 1891), these assertions were based on anecdotal evidence at best. When these children’s social and emotional adjustment levels were assessed and compared with those of their age peers, gifted children scored more positively (Lehman & Erdwins, 1981) and reportedly exhibited fewer behavioral problems (Ludwig & Cullinan, 1984). These contradicting assertions may be challenged because children with behavioral problems might have been screened out of the gifted programs. Stress caused by environmental factors (e.g., tasks, situations, or people) has a detrimental effect on cognitive function. In stressful situations, more mental effort is required to process information. It is difficult to sustain concentration on the task at hand when surrounding situations are perceived as unfavorable or threatening. For example, when students need to make a choice among many alternatives under stressful situations, they do not adequately evaluate all possible choices before responding, and the frequency of incorrect responses vary with the magnitude of stress (Keinan, 1987). This conclusion, based on isolated stressful episodes of short duration and limited impact, does not exclude the possibility that comprehensive stressful episodes of long-term duration and strong impact may have other effects. The short- and long-term effects of stressful life circumstances and environments during childhood on the development of creative talent have been discussed. The following adverse circumstances during childhood create stressful conditions: parental loss, parental conflict, parental neglect, strict discipline, rejection by parents or other children, overprotection, loneliness, loss of a cherished sibling, insecurity due to poverty, or physical disabilities or deformities. Such experiences might impair children’s cognitive and psychological–emotional development and prevent them from realizing potential they might otherwise have reached in adult life. At the same time the same experiences may have positive consequences for some children (Albert, 1993; Ochse, 1990; Olszewski-Kublius, 2000). A disruptive environment in childhood compels some children to seek out and find a pursuit, environment, and level of tension that are consistent with a potential talent in their behavioral repertoire (Gardner, 1994). They might seek self-sufficiency and independence or withdraw and isolate themselves from people. These circumstances can be
70 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development motivators for creative development for some children (Olszewski-Kublius, 2000), especially when they maximally exploit the freedom gained from the isolation and divert their energies to the development of creative potential (Simonton, 1992). Anxiety Depression and anxiety are indicators of socio-emotional maladjustment. In general, students identified as gifted in school have lower anxiety and depression than average students (e.g., Bracken & Brown, 2006). Accordingly, one might conclude that gifted students are reasonably well adjusted. However, other studies on anxiety report different results. When gifted students are also perfectionists, their fixation on making mistakes limits their work behaviors and achievement (Schuler, 2000). This fixation results in a constant state of anxiety, creating a vicious cycle with negative impact on their psychological health. Competitiveness also provokes anxiety in gifted children. Gifted adolescents in regular classes report lower test anxiety, higher academic self-concept, and more positive perceptions of their giftedness, than do gifted students in homogeneous gifted classes (Zeidner & Schleyer, 1999). This finding is not surprising. When gifted students compare themselves with fellow students, the comparison is far more anxiety provoking in a classroom filled with other gifted students than in a heterogeneous classroom. However, the gifted students in homogeneous classes are more satisfied with school environment than those in regular classes. The question of which factor (anxiety versus attitude toward school) has a stronger impact on life achievement is worthy of investigation, especially in longitudinal studies. Gifted underachievers, compared with other groups of students, are more anxious or depressed (Clark, 1992; Mandel & Marcus, 1988; Van Boxtel & Mönks, 1992). Some report no difference in anxiety between gifted and nongifted groups (e.g., Nail, 1998) and between highly versus moderately gifted students (Norman, Ramsey, Martray, & Roberts, 1999). In performing arts, performance anxiety is of concern. During talent development, many children become handicapped by performance anxiety and need support from their teachers or professional people outside of school in order to cope with it (Fehm & Schmidt, 2006). Performance anxiety persists in some individuals even after they become highly accomplished performers. Many educators and parents of gifted children are concerned that children who go through accelerated programs will become anxious and insecure. A study that examined the effect of early acceleration of students in mathematics on anxiety indicated that acceleration does not have a negative effect and the
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development • 71 pattern of anxiety rate was similar between accelerated and non-accelerated students (Ma, 2003). Most studies on anxiety in children are related to testing situations. Test anxiety is a major block to children’s optimal test performance and can lead to failure in school. As can be expected, test anxiety is adversely related to test performance (e.g., Cassady & Johnson, 2002; Hong, 2001b). Students with high test anxiety tend to avoid difficult items and are not persistent when facing difficulties (Hill & Wigfield, 1984). Students who have performance-avoidance goal orientation tend to have high test anxiety (Middleton & Midgley, 1997; Sideridis, 2005). However, students with mastery goal orientation also show significant test anxiety (Linnenbrink, 2005). In factorial studies of test anxiety, different components of test anxiety were extracted. Among others, the worry versus emotionality distinction (Liebert & Morris, 1967) and their differential effects on performance have been discussed widely (e.g., Benson & Tippets, 1990; Zeidner & Nevo, 1992). Worry refers to cognitive concern about test-taking and performance, such as negative expectations, preoccupation with performance, and potential consequences. Emotionality refers to perceived physiological reactions, that is, autonomic arousal and somatic reactions to testing situations such as nervousness and tension (Liebert & Morris, 1967; Morris, Davis, & Hutchings, 1981). While worry and emotionality are strongly correlated due to the testing situations that contain elements related to the arousal of each, worry is the anxiety component that has shown a consistent and strong inverse relationship with performance, whereas emotionality has a weak inverse or no relationship with performance (e.g., Kim & Rocklin, 1994; O’Neil & Abedi, 1992; Zeidner & Nevo, 1992). The cognitive-attentional view of test anxiety (Wine, 1980) may explain the negative role of worry in performance. Highly anxious individuals pay more attention to task-irrelevant cues than task-relevant cues, and their performance suffers due to this division of attention (Sarason, 1988). Anxiety could impede talent development, especially when it interacts with other traits (e.g., stress). Anxiety-provoking environments can be detrimental to individuals who suffer from anxiety. Students who are high in trait test anxiety tend to be highly anxious in various testing situations. However, different subject matter areas have differential effects on the level of test anxiety. In addition, individual students’ manifestations of test anxiety change across time even within the same subject matter (Hong, 1998c). These findings indicate that test anxiety is treatable even for those students with high trait test anxiety. Treatments such as relaxation therapy (Hembree, 1988), systematic desensitization (Kennedy & Doepke, 1999), and cognitiveattentional training (Wine, 1980) have proven effective in reducing anxiety.
72 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development
Intrapersonal characteristics Attitude Understanding students’ attitude toward school is important because this affects learning and creative behavior in class. To make matters worse, the relationship of attitude toward school with learning and achievement is reciprocal. Students who do well in school tend to be interested in learning and have positive attitudes toward school. The positive attitude toward school, in turn, helps them to learn and achieve better. Studies have shown that underachievers tend to show more negative attitudes toward school or have more problems with teachers and school personnel than high achievers (Bruns, 1992; Diaz, 1998; Ford, 1996). Gifted underachievers tend to be aggressive, resentful, hostile, or rebellious (Diaz, 1998; Emerick, 1992; Rimm, 1995). High-ability male dropouts tended to be more assertive, independent, rebellious, cheerful, expressive, frank, and talkative than a comparable group of males who did not drop out (Lajoie & Shore, 1981). School pressures for conformity, rather than a lack of interest in school, might influence dropout. This has important implications for teachers and counselors; it is their responsibility to understand the potential causes of dropout and to use this understanding to prevent dropout by adjusting the school environment as required. A student may drop out for reasons that cannot be handled by school personnel; however, providing a safe and welcoming environment for these students would be one way to prevent dropout and potential talent loss. When their creative needs are not met, creative students are at risk of becoming underachievers. The behaviors often observed in creative underachievers are rebellion or disruption. Creative underachievers resent excessive rules and regulations in class, tend to challenge and question teachers, sometimes indiscreetly, and fail to follow directions (Whitmore, 1980). Inattentive behaviors are another characteristic of creatively gifted students. This tendency of students with creative potential causes some confusion for educators in determining whether the behavior is related to creativity, attention deficit disorder, or both (Hartnett, Nelson, & Rinn, 2004; Reis & McCoach, 2002). Consequently, these students tend to be placed in a situation where they become alienated from teachers and/or peers, which, in turn, influences subsequent behaviors such as withdrawal and isolation, lack of interest in school, or dropout. Because many teachers prefer students who are highly intellectual rather than highly creative (Cropley, 2006), educational needs for creative children may not be met in classrooms. Not surprisingly, other variables mediate the effect of attitudes toward school on academic achievement. Student attitude toward school affects
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development • 73 achievement motivation, which in turn affects academic achievement. Attitudes toward school are related to parental involvement (Clemons, 2006). It is important to understand these and other affective and motivational variables as they work collaboratively. With more understanding, school personnel and parents will be better equipped to help students develop positive attitudes toward school and to prevent potential talents from being lost. Independence, responsibility, and conformity Independence and sense of responsibility contribute to achievement. There are various teaching strategies and programs that can be used to foster independence and responsibility in students when it is absent. For example, teachers can provide students with opportunities to select their own assignments or other learning activities. One way to foster students’ responsibility is to encourage them to initiate their own learning and selfevaluate outcomes. Gifted learners tend to be autonomous learners or prefer autonomous learning (Chan, 2001). High-ability students who perceive themselves as lacking autonomy exhibit more negative affect and withdrawal behaviors than students who are highly autonomous (Miserandino, 1996). In an exemplary program that fosters autonomy, independence, and responsibility (e.g., Mulcahy, 1991), students were given the responsibility for determining what strategies are appropriate and how to generate, implement, and evaluate the strategies to maximize problem-solving. The effectiveness of such programs was demonstrated in a 3-year longitudinal study with gifted as well as regular students and students with learning disabilities (Miserandino, 1996). Students can also develop their sense of responsibility and independence through community service. The experiences gained through these activities provide gifted students with opportunities to grow academically, intellectually, personally, creatively, and socially. Terry (2001) indicates that through their participation in this type of project, civic awareness is developed as well as the students’ sense of responsibility toward their community and each other. Students learn to work cooperatively and creatively in these settings. These experiences will help students of all levels become more attentive to social and global issues, and eventually help them become leaders in their field of interest. Conformity implies compliance, acquiescence, or obedience. Conformists focus on how they are perceived by others. As might be expected, highly creative individuals have difficulties with conformity. In response to conformist pressures, non-conformity can become a drive in highly creative individuals whose thought processes can lead to exploring concepts and methods that diverge greatly from the norm (Whitmore, 1980). Teachers, especially the
74 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development conformists, may feel annoyed or threatened by highly creative students when they express their creative ideas. Some consider creative students insistent, aggressive, or disruptive of the normal flow of class. Students’ creative ideas are too often ignored, discouraged, or even punished (Cropley, 2006). With repeated reactions based upon conformity from people in their environment, children’s creativity will likely be suppressed and their behaviors may turn negative. Other elements of conformity that have a negative impact on creativity are abundant. Examples include gender role expectation. A strong relationship has been found between androgyny and creativity (Hittner & Daniels, 2002; Norlander, Erixon, & Archer, 2000). Some children give up their creativity to preserve their masculinity or femininity (Torrance, 1960, 1962). Non-assertiveness or shyness may be related to creatively gifted students not being recognized in the classroom (Whitmore, 1980). These children could become excessively conforming, lack confidence in their own thinking, and acquire low self-esteem. These findings indicate that talent loss can happen unwittingly. Commitment and tolerance In the three-ring conception, Renzulli (2002) includes three important traits as necessary for individuals to succeed: above-average ability, task commitment, and creativity. These traits work interactively and no one trait is more important than the others. Renzulli defines task commitment as capacity for high levels of interest; hard work and determination in a particular area; selfconfidence and drive to achieve; ability to identify significant problems within an area of study; and setting high standards for one’s work. Task commitment, supportive parents and teachers, and high self-esteem are important contributing factors to children’s achievement (Lee-Corbin & Denicolo, 1998). Task commitment is also an important characteristic of resilient people, along with desire to learn, reflectiveness, maturity, and self-understanding (Bland, Sowa, & Callahan, 1994). Feldhusen (1995a) suggests that young people need to commit themselves to developing their potential talent. They should make a long-range commitment by identifying personal and career goals and striving to accomplish these goals. Providing challenging tasks is important for encouraging commitment. Although gifted achievers, compared with other groups of students, put forth more efforts by investing more time and committing themselves to getting the task done, if goals or tasks are not challenging, these students will likely lose their interest in the work and talent loss may be more likely. Torrance (1993) describes as “Beyonders” individuals who demonstrate outstanding creative achievement. In a 30-year follow-up study of creative
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development • 75 achievement he presented the top 10 characteristics that identify Beyonders: (1) delight in deep thinking, (2) tolerance of mistakes, (3) love of one’s work, (4) clear purpose, (5) enjoying one’s work, (6) feeling comfortable as a minority of one, (7) being different, (8) not being well-rounded, (9) sense of mission, and (10) courage to be creative. Tolerance was listed as the second entity that identified creative achievers. Acknowledging and accepting mistakes is difficult for many people, but when individuals tolerate mistakes, learn from mistakes, and commit to work, positive outcomes are more likely than not. Waldrop (1990) suggests “affective education” be provided for creative young children having conflict with teachers and peers due to high energy levels, low tolerance, sensitivity, and perfectionism. Waldrop outlines three levels to focus on in affective education: (1) the routine activities of the student’s encounter with the school environment; (2) the blending of affective and cognitive objectives in the curriculum; and (3) the pursuit of affective goals independent of the curriculum. Understanding these characteristics and providing affective education for students having difficulties in school will help students stay on a proper developmental trajectory. Risk-taking Taking risks means taking chances, trying new approaches when the consequences or outcomes are not predictable. Neihart (1999b) asserts that risk-taking is an important skill for gifted children to acquire; inability to take risks may compromise their potential to be highly successful or creative. Gifted children, especially those who adopt performance goal orientation, are likely not to take on the risk of challenging tasks when they are not sure they will win against their peers. Some gifted students define success as getting a high grade; these students will likely choose easy work over challenging work that might require higher-order thinking and creativity to secure the high grade, thus closing down opportunities for in-depth learning. Creativity and risk-taking are closely related. Creative risk-takers are not only tolerant of uncertainty of consequences, but also risk other elements that induce creative thinking and creative production. They elicit and release psychological and emotional conflicts from childhood in their creative endeavor or take risks challenging conventions and status quo (Maddi, 1975). Highly creative individuals, compared with highly intellectual ones, are more curious and enjoy risks. Wickes and Ward (2006) found that gifted students perceive risk-taking as an important component of their own creativity and also observed that beliefs about risk-taking and creative behaviors are positively related. These findings encourage us to suggest that instructions for healthy risk-taking would be
76 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development beneficial to gifted children. Neihart (1999b) provides six steps to systematic risk-taking: (1) understand the benefits of systematic risk-taking; (2) selfassess initial risk-taking categories; (3) identify personal needs; (4) determine a risk to take; (5) take the risk; and (6) process the risk experience. The outcomes of risk-taking experiences can be increased confidence about one’s ability to take on a challenge, increased sense of control in life, enhanced skills for managing anxiety and fear of failure, increased opportunities to practice important decision-making, and increased motivation to develop the habit of taking planned risks (Bland, Sowa, & Callahan, 1994; Neihart, 1999b). Willingness to take risks is an important element in producing novelty items. Work places and communities often provide opportunities for risk-taking but if individuals do not take the opportunity, there will be less creative productivity even if they are highly intellectual and knowledgeable. One should also assess and determine when to stop if there seems to be no end in sight and when to pack up and move on, otherwise, risk-taking combined with stubbornness will likely lead to destruction. Education to increase healthy risk-taking contributes to talent development.
Preventing talent loss Feldhusen (1995a) states that the development of human talents is a process carried out not only in schools but also in many places and under diverse circumstances. Parents, teachers, and society all have some responsibility in the process. Nevertheless, and most important, it is a responsibility of the gifted and talented students to recognize and nurture their own potential talents. The current chapter has dealt with various affective and intrapersonal characteristics related to giftedness, creativity, talent development, and talent loss. The impact of affect on human development is pervasive. Children who are maladjusted and do not have surrounding environments that support and lead them in the right direction are those in danger of talent loss. We provide a few suggestions to help educators and parents recognize and understand the importance of these characteristics in the developmental process and prepare to assist children who are in need of help in these domains. Recognize affective characteristics of creative children and support their talent development Creative students tend to annoy teachers, expressing various experimental ideas that seem wild and which challenge the status quo. Negative reactions received by creative students from teachers and at times from their peers and parents are not unusual. Parents and teachers, who see creative behaviors as
Affective and Intrapersonal Attributes and Talent Development • 77 inconvenient or as management problems, may respond to them by harsh discipline or punishment that discourages creativity in children. Peer pressure is not to be taken lightly either. Teachers who themselves have a creative attitude toward life tend to understand students’ creative behaviors, are able to foster creativity, and help children realize their potential. Teachers and parents should make an effort to learn about creativity. Wittingly or unwittingly, they might cause cognitive and psychological damages to creative students instead of supporting talent development. Recognize and provide support to isolated students Isolation or loneliness is sometimes a problem for both intellectually and creatively gifted students. Providing opportunities for these children to be with peers who are of a similar level of intellectual capacity or creative inclination is something teachers and counselors can do. Gifted students can be bullied or ridiculed in some classrooms. Teachers should strive to prevent these deleterious behaviors from happening and help create a culture in which all individuals are accepted. Creative students may need extra help. Because they tend to produce unique and noble ideas, which at times are viewed as strange, finding someone who would be tolerant or interested in listening to them may not be an easy task. High school students are also keen to maintain their images; thus, they might give up producing and pursuing creative ideas at the expense of fulfilling their desire to belong. The astute and judicious evaluation of the behaviors of these children by teachers can create an environment in which the talent of these children can thrive rather than be lost. Various approaches to increase independence in students The following classroom activities might increase student independence and autonomy. Help students: select their own topics for assignments or projects; select their own class activities; establish their own goals in a self-selected interest area (e.g., for individual projects); plan and manage their project independently; correct their own mistakes; answer questions on their own before solutions are given; set up their own rules for various functions (e.g., projects, activities); work both by themselves and cooperatively; and selfevaluate their own performance. Help students initiate and commit to work Students with intellectual and creative potential can thrive only when they use their abilities. Those who seek safe paths to get high grades or to belong to a group of friends who are not interested in challenging themselves to pursue their interests might lose opportunities to develop their talent. Teachers
78 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development and parents may help students who are afraid to fail in a number of ways: allow children to make errors and do not punish them with low grades or withdrawing privileges as long as they put effort into the work; help build confidence by rewarding ideas and effort; give another chance to learn from mistakes and to present improved work or behaviors. Make efforts to assure that assigned goals or tasks are challenging. It is difficult for gifted students to maintain their commitment if tasks are too easy and require no effort. Help students increase tolerance of their own mistakes Although highly intelligent and creative individuals tend to come up with brilliant or creative ideas, some have very little tolerance for error and sometimes they give up when they find a little mistake. Some students do not commit to projects out of fear of failure, thus risking talent loss. Teachers and parents should present a model of tolerant behaviors by showing tolerance for children’s mistakes and sharing their experiences of failure and success. Provide positive feedback for effort and progress and give opportunities to adjust the process when needed and to experience success of completion. Learn to tolerate ambiguity and to take risk Creative ideas sometimes come suddenly but sometimes slowly, little by little. Inability to tolerate uncertainty will lead individuals to jump to quick conclusions without using time to reflect their intellectual or creative ability. At the beginning of the creative process, things may look uncertain, unpromising, or unsure, but one needs to tolerate the uncertainty and try until ideas begin to improve. When students take risks, ask unusual questions, or present a creative idea, do be careful not to inadvertently dismiss the question. Take sensible risks and take responsibility for actions taken Almost all individuals encounter challenges in their lives. When they take the challenges and overcome them, they become sensible, highly successful risk-takers. Provide challenges for students by creating an environment that requires risk-taking (e.g., finding challenging problems and trying to solve them). When the outcome does not meet the expectation, evaluate and make a decision whether to continue with some adjustment or decide to change the course of action all together. It is important for the gifted to understand that commitment and perseverance are important virtues but that the ability to determine when to continue, change direction, or take a new challenge is also an important human quality.
chapter
7
Biological Attributes and Talent Development
In this chapter, we discuss the relationship of the biological attributes – heredity, sex, and age – to talent development. The effects of cognitive abilities and sex/gender on talent development have received considerable attention in the professional literature of educational psychology and gifted education over the years. By the same token, the relative importance of genetic endowment and environment in human development, labeled by Francis Galton (1874) as the nature–nurture issue, has been debated since the early nineteenth century. Because technological developments make it possible to examine biological processes more closely, their effects are a topic of growing interest in many fields including giftedness, talent, and creativity (e.g., Delisle, 2003). Although the gifted field no longer subscribes to the “either nature or nurture” conceptualization (Feldhusen, 1994), the degree of impact of the two and their role in talent development model is still discussed (e.g., Gagné, 2005). Simonton’s (1999) seminal article “Talent and its development: An emergenic and epigenetic model” and a recent special issue on the nature–nurture issue in giftedness by Dai and Coleman (2005) are good examples that highlight the continuing controversy on this issue among researchers in giftedness and talent.
80 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development
Genetics and talent development Heredity On the basis of data on physical sizes of human heads and family backgrounds of eminent people, Galton argued for the prevailing impact of nature over nurture on the development of eminence (Galton, 1883). Nowadays, advanced brain scanning devices such as positron emission tomography (PET) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can measure not only the brain size and structure but also how the brain functions in reaction to various stimuli. In the brain of gifted, precocious individuals, there seems to be an unique cortical substrate that mediates their superior intellectual abilities (O’Boyle, & Gill, 1998). Delisle (2003) reported a correlation between brain size and IQ of .45, supporting Galton’s age-old observations. However, the moderate correlation also means that there are determinants of talent development other than heredity. Delisle (2003) cited other evidence of the impact of nature on giftedness such as event-related perceptions (ERPs) as a measure of speech perception; auditory ERPs recorded within 36 hours of birth can predict the reading performance of children 8 years later (Molfese & Molfese, 1997). Studies of adoptive children and identical twins reared apart have consistently shown the impact of nature on human development. Identical twins reared in separate environments tend to become more similar with age, and adoptive children reared separately resemble their biological siblings whom they have never met (Plomin, 1990; Scarr & McCartney, 1983). Gottfredson (2003) demonstrated that the impact of nature on intelligence increases with age, from 20 percent in infancy, to 60 percent by adolescence, to 80 percent by adulthood. Also, the quantitative trait loci associated with gifted-level general intelligence (“g” factor) is traceable in human chromosomes (Chorney, Seese, Owen, Daniels, McGuffin, Tompson, Detterman, Benbow, Lubinski, Eley, & Plomin, 1998). This evidence seems to support the view that the impact of nature on talent development is not debatable. Genetic factors determine potential strengths in individuals (e.g., intelligence, sensory–motor) and talent emerges as a result of supporting environmental experiences and personal–psychological attributes (motivation, affects, styles). Still remaining is the question of how the gifted potential in children can best be supported by an environment that will help them develop their potential. Impact of heredity on talent development We hear about child geniuses from time to time. Some maintain their genius and grow up to be successful. The violinist Sarah Chang began her violin studies at
Biological Attributes and Talent Development • 81 age 4 and trained in the Juilliard School of Music. She played violin at concerts as a child and matured into a gifted violinist as an adult. On the other hand, we hear of prodigies who did not continue to perform at a high level as adults. What could be the cause of this talent loss? The family environment in which the potentially gifted child grew up may not have recognized the talent; or the family could not support the child due to financial difficulties. The family may even have interfered with talent development. The promising youngster may have decided not to continue developing the potential, possibly because of the arduous practice that is required for such development or because other activities seemed more interesting. Sometimes the opportunity to develop talent comes only once; at other times, there are continuing possibilities. Many who dropped out of the rigorous training required to realize talent potential disappeared from the public eye. However, their inherited talent is not lost. It is just not fully developed and becomes mediocre. According to Simonton (1999), such talent loss can result from genetically controlled development. Examples could be a child who has potential talent but is also endowed with a gene that causes Asperger’s disorder, attention deficit disorder, or another genetic disorder. According to Wikimedia (n.d.), a genetic disorder (or hereditary disease) is a condition caused by abnormal expression of one or more genes resulting in a clinical phenotype (e.g., Down syndrome, Huntington’s disease). Genetic disorders may be complex or polygenic, that is, disorders of this type are likely associated with the effects of multiple genes in combination with lifestyle and environmental factors (e.g., autism, diabetes). Although complex disorders tend to run in families, they do not have a clear-cut pattern of inheritance. Genetic diseases such as those cited above interfere with education and affect talent development. Most affected are those potential talents in areas that require systematic and intense training and practice such as gymnastics or music. Illness may not have as grave an effect in other areas such as science. Stephen Hawking, well known in the fields of cosmology and quantum gravity, fell ill when he was attending university. Symptoms of the disorder (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis) appeared and the final diagnosis was made when he was 21. He is now almost completely paralyzed, talking through a computer system attached to his wheelchair and his glasses. Throughout his 40-year career, he has been extremely productive, representing a genius talent in spite of a disorder. Gagné (1995, 2005) differentiates between gifts and talents and asserts that the starting point of the developmental process is represented by natural abilities in various domains. These abilities appear spontaneously during the early years of children’s development and show individual differences without any clear evidence of any systematic learning, training, or practice.
82 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development Gagné acknowledges the genetic origin of these abilities, at least in part, as well as in other traits such as temperamental dispositions. These hereditary predispositions and acquired styles of behavior (e.g., attitudes and personal characteristics) have a positive impact on talent development by supporting or stimulating development, or a negative impact by slowing down or even blocking development. Psychometric instruments measuring interests, values, or personality used to establish profiles of accomplished individuals (e.g., Cattell & Butcher, 1968; Eysenck, Nias, & Cox, 1982) have provided some evidence of genetic linkages in these scales defining the profiles (e.g., Eysenck, 1995, cited in Simonton, 1999). Interactive influences of heredity and environment How and by how much these endowed abilities and predispositions affect talent development is difficult, if not impossible, to quantify. However, it is plausible that some individuals may have considerable advantages for developing talent. Explaining the emergenic model of talent development, Simonton (1999) argues that the impact of innate factors may be correspondingly determined as a whole rather than as isolated parts. If one component is lacking, the talent may not emerge. For example, former United States president Bill Clinton has traits such as verbal ability, assertiveness, attractiveness, and selfconfidence, which are important leadership characteristics. If he lacked, say, self-confidence, he might have not risen to the presidency. Explaining the epigenetic model, Simonton (1999) maintains that traits may have a genetic foundation, but it does not mean that the traits appear simultaneously. Rather many traits take years to emerge. The examples of the impact of nature on intellectual ability given earlier (i.e., increased impact with age) (e.g., McGue, Bouchard, Iacono, & Lykken, 1993) are a consequence of the epigenetic progression shown even after the impact of environment has increased when one becomes older. Even the differential timing of the developmental events often has a genetic component (Bouchard, 1995; Plomin, 1986). Heredity determines individual differences to some extent, affecting not only the final manifestation of an attribute but also the developmental trajectory by which that attribute emerges, especially during the transition from early to middle childhood (Fulker, Cherny, & Cardon, 1993). In summary, the evidence from various types of data (psychometric, neurological) on the impact of genetics on giftedness and talent indicates that heredity plays an important role in the production of talent. On the other hand, evidence also suggests the strong impact of environment on talent development. Whereas some aspects of biology are difficult to change, others are more malleable to environmental influences (Ericsson, Nandagonal, & Roring, 2005). For example, a musician’s brain adapts and changes structurally and functionally with his or her cognitive development (Schlaug, 2001).
Biological Attributes and Talent Development • 83 The average height of a nation’s children changes through environmental intervention (children of a new generation in a country may eat better or more food), although it would take decades to see the noticeable change. Thus, nature and nurture work together in their contribution to talent development. To optimize talent development, we must understand more about biological and environmental requirements in each domain. Understanding biology for improving teaching and learning Various efforts have already taken place. For instance, based on research findings in cognitive neuroscience and work on the involvement of the right and left cerebral brain hemispheres during information processing, O’Boyle and Gill (1998) suggest what might work for teaching gifted students. The utilization of classroom techniques that appeal to a gifted learning style may be a good way to intervene in classroom instruction. For example, information about the specialized contributions of the right and left hemispheres to skill acquisitions can be utilized when preparing instruction for gifted students. With advanced technology (see Chapter 11) and further neuroscientific research, it might not be too long before we see how reading or mathematics can be taught more effectively by understanding brain function. As educators, we are aware that the learning environment affects human development. High-quality instruction with an appropriate level of content along with skillful delivery and classroom management contributes to learning and development. It is, however, also important to understand that there are individuals with special strengths and weaknesses, and it is the teacher’s responsibility to identify and place learners in the type and level of instruction that is most beneficial for them. More research is still needed to provide accurate and succinct lists of qualities and manifestations of potential talent in each domain for teachers to use in their classrooms. We look forward to research and practical information becoming available from behavioral genetics, ecological genetics, neurosciences, psychology, and gifted education to help reach this goal.
Sex and age: academic, motivational, and emotional characteristics Most research and literature that have examined sex differences have used the words sex and gender interchangeably. The two words are usually not distinguished to implicate the biological and social connotation of sex and gender, respectively. Thus, this section includes gender or sex differences and age differences in comparing high and low achievers or gifted and averageability students. Many of these differences are results of interaction effects between environmental and biological influences. Even if we discuss group
84 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development differences (i.e., gender and age level differences), readers are again reminded that a great many individual differences exist within each gender and each age level. We discuss gender/sex and age differences in three areas – academic, motivational, and emotional characteristics. Academic characteristics Gender differences exist in various education variables. The differences may be partly attributable to social or gender-role stereotypes (e.g., math is for boys; girls are good at language arts), prolonging gender differences in educational outcomes. Although the gap in academic achievement test scores across gender has been decreasing in the regular student population, the gender gap still exists among the top 10 to 20 percent of high performers (Callahan & Reis, 1996). Males are better at quantitatively oriented subject matters and females choose subjects that are considered less challenging such as language arts (Callahan & Reis, 1996; Lubinski, Benbow, & Sanders, 1993). Gifted females are more influenced by social pressures than gifted males in their choice of subject matter, are exposed to fewer adult role models, and receive much less early practice in sciences (Heller & Ziegler, 1996). Girls often think that they must decide between academic subjects and what is valued socially (Noble & Smyth, 1995). Females identified as gifted fail to actualize their potential because they hide their high ability in order to socialize with their peers. This is often a priority for many adolescent females (Bilsker, Schiedel, & Marcia, 1988). Teachers and parents make little effort to change the situation, possibly because they do not expect girls to excel, particularly in mathematics and the sciences (Siegel & Shaughnessy, 1991). Parents interact with and treat young children differently based on gender (Bem, 1981; Markus & Oyseman, 1989). Parents appear to favor and support young boys’ interest and attitude toward science and mathematics (Kahle, 1990), possibly encouraging and providing more opportunities for the formation of interest and aptitudes in those subjects (e.g., sending boys to math camps more so than girls). Evidence of the negative impact of parental and teacher expectations and attitudes toward children, as well as media influences on females’ development has been provided even in recent years (e.g., Noble, Subbotnik, & Arnold, 1999; Pipher, 1994; Wilgosh, 2001). Thus, corrective actions are needed to change these practices. Among underachieving youngsters there are more academically gifted girls than boys (Nolden & Sedlacek, 1997; Reis & Dobyns, 1991). Although about half of the students at the elementary level identified as highly able are girls (Noble, 1987), by junior high school, the number of girls so identified declines (Dunne & Rose, 1989; Sadker & Sadker, 1994). The differences in attitudes toward science, participation in science, and science-related experiences are
Biological Attributes and Talent Development • 85 noticeably different between high-ability females and high-ability males, favoring males (Farenga & Joyce, 1998, 2000). Not surprisingly, when the intended majors of college-bound seniors were examined in 1998, males were three to four times more likely to pursue a degree in physical science, computer science, mathematics or engineering than females, while females selected health professions or biological sciences more than males. This trend continued in 2005 and 2006, although females took more advanced mathematics courses in high school (algebra, geometry, trigonometry, precalculus, AP/Honors courses) than males. Male students still scored higher in SAT mathematics, and the intended college majors in mathematics, physical sciences, engineering, and computer sciences showed a wide gender gap, with males showing higher percentages than females (College Board, 2007a, 2007b, 2007c). The cultural gender effects on attitudes toward sciences effectively excluded gifted females from colleges and academic opportunities (Kerr, 2000). On the other hand, the results of analyses across hundreds of studies have shown that gender differences in mathematics and language abilities are “so small as to be virtually non-existent for all practical purposes” (Golombok & Fivush, 1994, p. 177); the measurable sex differences in aptitude are due to “a complex interaction between small biological differences and larger gender differences in socialization experiences” (p. 176). In mathematics specifically, research findings on gender differences at the elementary and secondary levels vary widely, from a significant gender difference favoring males (Cahan & Ganor, 1995; Seegers & Boekaerts, 1996) to no significant difference (Caporrimo, 1990; Hyde, Fennema, & Lamon, 1990; Senk & Usiskin, 1983). At the college level, some studies have shown a lack of significant relationship between gender and mathematical ability (Cooper & Robinson, 1989; Hong & Karstensson, 2002). In an international review of research on gender differences in math and sciences, Heller and Ziegler (1996) failed to find any reliable evidence that girls are inherently less able than boys. As discussed above, however, adolescents generally select courses that follow gender stereotypes, with males generally preferring mathematics and science, even if there is no sizable sex differences in their aptitude (Wilson, Stocking, & Goldsten, 1994). In reviewing teachers’ instructional behaviors (Siegle & Powell, 2004), it has been observed that teachers spend more time interacting with male students and face males more often when talking to the class (Mann, 1994; Sadker & Sadker, 1994). Teachers give male students more detailed instructions than they do females (Olivers & Rosenthal, 1992). By contrast, Siegle and Powell (2004) found that teachers did not differ in their ratings of mathematics and reading across gender, suggesting that the emphasis on equal opportunity regardless of gender may be starting to show its impact.
86 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development We hope that researchers continue to make efforts to understand why gender stereotypes persist in perception of academic behaviors, what specific approaches are effective in removing stereotypes, and how to implement more effective approaches to narrow the gap in the current decade. Motivational characteristics Gender differences in motivation change with age. At the elementary school level, gender differences are not found in motivation and perceived selfconfidence (Vallerand, Gagné, Senécal, & Pelletier, 1994). In junior high school, females in general report higher motivation than males (TallentRunnels, Olivárez, Lotven, Walsh, Gray, & Irons, 1994). In high schools, males report stronger self-efficacy than females in mathematics (Junge & Dretzke, 1995; Malpass, O’Neil, & Hocevar, 1999), whereas females report stronger self-efficacy expectations in areas that involve stereotypical female activities. Academically gifted females, compared with academically gifted male students, report expending more effort on general tasks (e.g., working as hard as possible on all tasks) as well as on mathematics (e.g., putting forth best efforts when solving mathematics problems) (Hong & Aqui, 2004). These studies indicate that gender differences in motivation can be complex depending on the type of giftedness (creatively or analytically gifted). The gender difference found among academically gifted students indicates a tendency of female adolescents to meticulously examine their work even when they achieve highly in school mathematics. On the other hand, male high achievers might believe that they can do well in school mathematics without exerting much effort. Interestingly, however, both male and female “creatively” talented students (measured by out-of-school activities and accomplishment) reported high levels of effort in general as well as in mathematics, possibly because out-of-school activities are chosen based on their own interest and require a higher level of commitment and sustained effort to excel (Hong & Aqui, 2004). Studies examining gender differences in self-regulation are relatively few. Zimmerman and Martinez-Pons (1990) observed that females demonstrate greater use of monitoring, environmental structuring, goal setting, and planning, but at the same time report lower self-efficacy than males. Females also demonstrate a significantly stronger mastery orientation, although no difference is found for performance orientation (Ablard & Lipschultz, 1998). Further, females’ overall measure of self-regulated learning is higher than that of males, and females utilize strategies that optimize the immediate environment and personal regulation. Gender differences are observed in valuing certain subject matter areas. Research findings have been consistent in most areas except for mathematics. Male students believe sports to be more useful and important than do females,
Biological Attributes and Talent Development • 87 whereas females believe to be reading and instrumental music are more useful and important than do males (Wigfield, Eccles, Yoon, Harold, Arbreton, Freedman-Doan, & Blumenfeld, 1997). Females have higher interest in learning language than do males (Eccles, Wigfield, Harold, & Blumenfeld, 1993; Watt, 2004). Findings on mathematics vary, however. In some studies male and female students are similar in their ratings of either intrinsic or utility value regarding mathematics (e.g., Eccles, Wigfield, Harold, & Blumenfeld, 1993). In other studies, males report higher intrinsic value in mathematics (Siann, Lightbody, Stocks, & Walsh, 1996; Watt, 2004) or score higher on utility value than do female students (Forgasz, 1995). Overall, females in general seem to use more self-regulated approaches in learning and espouse more desirable goal orientation than males. One would expect that these desirable traits would translate into academic outcome. However, gender discrepancies in achievement and aspiration do not support female superiority and, in fact, males are still favored in sciences. This partly indicates that there are other significant factors that influence female students’ thinking that impedes their performance. Social expectation and gender-role socialization may explain some of these results. Why is females’ self-efficacy low even when they are mastery-learning oriented? Teachers and parents should help deter the influence of stereotypes. Age differences are found in motivational regulation, showing declines in older students. Effort attributions for academic achievement decrease in the middle level over grades 5 through 8 (Moely, Obach, Cassell, & Tonglet, 1995). Persistence level also declines from grade 5 to grade 8 in homework (Hong & Milgram, 2000). When self-regulation and motivation in homework were studied in Chinese students, the overall perceived self-regulation in homework declined from middle school to high school (Hong, Peng, & Rowell, 2006). Older Chinese students perceived homework as less useful, enjoyed it less, expended less effort, persisted less when they encountered homework difficulties, and perceived that they engaged in planning and self-checking less than did younger students. These findings replicate previous research that found a similar pattern of declines in valuing school work in general (e.g., Lepper, Sethi, Dialdin, Drake, 1997; Wigfield, Eccles, Yoon, Harold, Arbreton, Freedman-Doan, & Blumenfeld, 1997). This negative trend is also manifested in students’ motivation about tests. Older students value testing less than younger students, and older students disagree more than younger students that test scores differentiate good students from poor students (Paris, Lawton, & Turner, 1991). In addition, more older than younger students believe that test results do not have immediate or remote consequences and perceive tests as less valid or less important (Hong & Peng, 2006; Urdan & Davis, 1998). The decline of motivation with age is of serious concern, especially as the trend seems to be prevalent across nations. Educators need to take a hard look
88 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development at the education system. Is it time to undergo another education reform? What might be able to actually change this trend? Although these questions have no immediate answers, we must all be aware and beware of these problems and seek strong leadership that can lead the effort to make changes in education of all children and eventually to prevent talent loss. Emotional characteristics The importance of self-esteem for adolescent females cannot be overemphasized. Girls, especially white and Hispanic females, exhibit a precipitous drop in self-esteem between elementary and high school. While male adolescents also show a decline, it is not nearly as dramatic (American Association of University Women, 1991). Gifted girls’ perceived confidence declines progressively from elementary grades through high school, especially those who suffer from perfectionism as they grow older. This, in turn, affects their emotions negatively, with some gifted female students showing symptoms such as depression and anxiety (Kline & Short, 1991a). Gender differences in test anxiety persist, with females in general reporting higher anxiety than males (Benson, Bandatos, & Hutchinson, 1994; Lussier, 1996). In a study of high school science students, males reported similar levels of worry and emotionality, whereas females demonstrated disproportionately high levels of worry anxiety (Williams, 1996). When gifted students were compared with non-gifted students, gifted males were less worried than gifted females (Malpass, O’Neil, & Hocevar, 1999). Gifted males show a different trajectory in their social and emotional development than gifted females. In their early schooling years, they are likely to have lower self-perception in academic competence than gifted females (Kline & Short, 1991b). Most males might have been raised to be aggressive and self-reliant at home. The predominance of female teachers, especially those who demand conformity and obedience from students, may be the reason for males having lower self-perceptions. In junior high school, female students report higher self-perceptions in general than males (TallentRunnels, Olivárez, Lotven, Walsh, Gray, & Irons 1994). Kline and Short (1991b) indicated that hopelessness and discouragement among male students peak at junior high school age, and the pattern changes in high school, when they focus on career choice. In general, girls – gifted and non-gifted – show more emotional difficulties. Males, on the other hand, seem to improve later in their school years, even in those areas in which they started with difficulties (e.g., self-esteem). The same questions that we had about academic and motivational characteristics above still remain: why are females having more difficulties than males in school? The academic, motivational, and emotional factors that cause problems
Biological Attributes and Talent Development • 89 experienced by many female students, might come from common sources. Continued research is needed to determine these sources. Educators and parents should be aware and make efforts to improve these difficulties.
Preventing talent loss Some educators will not see the discussion about nature–nurture as useful because one cannot do much about heredity. However, knowledge about the influence of the nature–nurture interaction on talent development is helpful, and educators and teachers should acquire it and use it in educating youngsters. Gender differences are pervasive, although there are signs of the gap narrowing in some areas. The trend of age differences, especially in the decline of motivation, is troubling. Here are some suggestions for preventing talent loss. Continue researching and understanding the effects of the nature–nurture relationship on human development Talent development occurs in a complex manner. Researchers should continuously study which biological and environmental factors are most influential in the development of talent in various domains. As Simonton (1999) asserts, a complete picture of talent development demands that the effects of nature be integrated with the effects of nurture. Educators and parents should pay attention to new information for continuous understanding of the inner workings of these influences and utilize the knowledge in helping children in school and at home to maximize their development. Focus on environmental support for talent development Gaining knowledge of the nature–nurture phenomenon is useful; however, until research and technology together produce easy-to-use curricular materials, educators must focus more on effective nurturing. Providing a nurturing educational environment and using effective educational strategies should be high priority for educators and parents in order to foster potential talents. Keep in mind that biological studies (e.g., neuroscience) provide tangible facts that could be helpful for understanding gifted behaviors and making the required accommodations to foster the development of gifted children. Help female students and find role models for them Teachers and parents should be aware that gifted female students who are interested in sciences may be pressured socially by their female peers not to
90 • Personal–Psychological Attributes and Talent Development pursue this interest. When this phenomenon is detected, teachers and parents should encourage gifted girls to pursue the sciences by linking them to a mentor. Female science teachers may serve as role models. Alter stereotypes The gender gap in science and mathematics persisits in gifted students. Teachers and parents should make efforts to maintain vigilance to assure that perceptions and expectations determined by gender do not become a factor influencing the career choice of gifted girls. Unless adults alter stereotypes, it would be difficult to prevent loss of female talents in sciences. There are other Madame Marie Curies out there. Monitor teaching behavior Teachers should be more self-aware about their classroom behaviors (e.g., spending more time interacting with boys). Although there may be good reasons for this trend, for example boys tend to be more disruptive in class and thus need more attention, teachers need to monitor their unintended biases and treat both boys and girls fairly, giving equitable learning opportunities. Be aware of pattern of gender differences As shown in studies of motivation, gender differences are not consistent across different types of giftedness. Although female academically gifted high school students generally put forth more efforts than gifted males, creatively gifted males’ effort levels are higher than academically gifted students. This is evidence that differences exist between academically and creatively talented students. Teachers should make efforts to adjust their teaching strategies to gender differences in motivation in various types of gifted children. Decline of motivation across age Students’ motivation for school tasks has been shown to decline in older students. This negative trend seems to be ubiquitous across countries. Educators and parents should understand what it means for students to go through the school system having lower interest and seeing less value in learning over time. Curriculum and instruction, school and classroom climate, peer relationships in and out of school, family background, media, social expectations, and other factors might affect this trend of declining motivation. Educators and parents should tackle this problem and do their best to raise the motivation of children in school.
part 4
Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development
chapter
8
Schools
Part of the problem of talent loss or part of the solution?
The Comprehensive Model of Giftedness and Talent postulates the school experience to be one of the major environmental factors that influence the development and degree of realization of potential expert and creative talents. Schools could and should play a major role in preventing talent loss. Unfortunately, there is little evidence that regular schools succeed either in identifying potential giftedness and talent or in contributing to its realization. When interviewed after having achieved eminence in their fields, very few gifted adults mentioned their schools and teachers as important influences in the development of their giftedness (Bloom, 1985). Highly intellectually gifted young people, selected from the entire population of high school seniors in Israel for a special program, were asked about their experience in special education programs during their elementary or high school years. Surprisingly, only half of these people had been identified as gifted in their early school years (Gabbay, 1998; Milgram & Hong, 1999a). This finding highlights the problematic approaches used to identify gifted potential for participation in the special programs offered by schools. Very recently, VanTassel-Baska (2006) reported the results of seven gifted program evaluation studies conducted in 20 different school districts. She suggests that the field of gifted education may be vulnerable to losing
94 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development its infrastructure at local levels if enhanced program development in key areas does not occur over the next few years. Attention to various areas of program development including identification, curriculum, program design, staff development, parental involvement, and special counseling needs is called for. Assessment and evaluation are required to improve the quality of gifted programs. Knowledge exists about effective approaches and programs; however, its value ultimately depends upon whether or not this knowledge is used properly in schools. The goal of this chapter is to bring evidence-based information on each of these important topics in a concentrated form to those who can use it to improve gifted education.
Assessment and identification The policies and procedures used for identification of gifted students are fundamentally important in gifted education because they reflect the school’s definition of “what” giftedness is and “who” receives special services. The transition from unidimensional (Terman, 1925) to multidimensional conceptualizations of giftedness (e.g., Marland, 1972; Renzulli, 1986) has had some impact on the field of gifted education. There has been a shift in policy from identifying youngsters with high intellectual ability to discovering and providing special education opportunities to young people with a wide variety of specific talents. Two special issues of Roeper Review: A Journal on Gifted Education (1995, Volume 18, No. 2, and 2000, Volume 22, No. 2), the first edited by Feldhusen (1995b) and the second by Milgram (2000), were devoted entirely to talent development as the new direction in gifted education. These issues gave recognized national and international authorities in the field the opportunity to support this view. One would have expected this policy change to have resulted in program changes by now. Unfortunately, the reality observed in schools is far from what we hoped. Procedures currently used for identification of gifted and talented students In this section we summarize the procedures most frequently used for the identification of students with potential talents. In the next section we will suggest alternative approaches that might improve these procedures. Issues related to using cognitive ability tests One reason for the failure of schools to identify potentially talented learners may be the heavy emphasis on IQ scores and grades to reflect school achievement that most school districts use in the process of screening and selecting participants for special educational programs. This emphasis continues despite continual findings over the years that attest to the
Schools • 95 limitations of such an approach. IQ-based scores or other cognitive ability tests provide information about the individual’s analytical-thinking abilities. Although this is very valuable information, when used by itself, it is not the best identification tool for assessing multidimensional talent potential (e.g., leadership; performing arts). Issues related to using standardized achievement tests School achievement is frequently assessed by grades on classroom performance or standardized achievement test scores (e.g., the Iowa Test of Basic Skills, the California Achievement Tests, the Terra Nova). The major problem in using one of these standardized tests in the identification process is that scores may have low validity because they do not reflect what students learned in the classroom. As with cognitive ability tests, standardized tests are heavily verbally loaded. Heavy reliance on standardized test scores as the initial screening instrument in the identification procedure will effectively eliminate many potentially gifted and talented learners. Such a procedure might well exclude students from rural, inner-city, or economically disadvantaged backgrounds, minority students, and those who are culturally and ethnically different from the mainstream gifted population (Aamidor, 2005; Lee & Olszewski-Kubilius, 2006; VanTassel-Baska, 1995). Issues related to teacher nomination Teacher nomination is another frequently used identification tool (Coleman & Gallagher, 1995) along with standardized tests. Teacher nomination has been criticized because it is used frequently as a gateway to overcome before consideration for additional testing and selection for gifted programs (Miller, 2005). Teachers’ implicit theory of giftedness might prevent them from identifying students who are potentially gifted. For example, teachers may have a bias against certain behaviors often characteristic of students with creative potential (e.g., challenging status quo, unusual questions). Some studies of teacher nomination of gifted students have yielded the finding that the accuracy of identification is poor (Ashman & Vukelich, 1983). Problematic aspects of teacher nominations identified are: nominations are determined primarily by students’ performance in class, class attendance, or conformity to teachers’ demands and expectations in the classroom (Hadaway & Marek-Schroer, 1992); nomination pays little attention to creativity, leadership, and motor skills (Hunsaker, Finley, & Frank, 1997); and classroom teachers are more inclined than gifted specialists to focus on student weaknesses, rather than student strengths (Siegle & Powell, 2004). On the other hand, some studies support the value of teacher nominations. Gagné (1994) found that teacher nominations were as effective as most other sources of information. According to Worrell and Schaefer (2004), the inaccuracy
96 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development of teacher nomination was due to the way it was calculated. That is, many of the rating scales used were not based on actual student behavior. Instead, teachers were required to make inferences about what gifted students are like. When teachers are provided with specific criteria, with clearly spelled out characteristics to be used for nomination, the nominations became more accurate (Kolo, 1999). Teachers should be encouraged to use multiple sources for their nominations and to go beyond standardized test scores and course grades. They could use student portfolios (Renzulli & Reis, 1998; Reyes, Fletcher, & Paez, 1996), observation forms (Passow & Frasier, 1996), and information about student background (e.g., socio-economic status, diversity) in the nomination process. Recommended procedures for identification of gifted and talented students: use of multiple identification measures A number of instruments that assess analytical- and creative-thinking abilities were presented in Chapters 3 and 4. The selection process should begin by using these basic tools, but this should not be the end of the process. Those charged with the responsibility of creating batteries designed to identify potentially gifted and talented children to participate in gifted programs should study available instruments carefully. Then they should select the instruments that provide the best possibility of valid and reliable identification and selection of students who will benefit most from the specific programs being offered. It is not a “one-size-fits-all” operation. The characteristics of the student population plus those of the programs being offered determine the selection of the tools most likely to produce the desired successful identification and selection. Performance and product evaluation The potential problems cited above in using test scores have resulted in calls to use multiple identification tools (e.g., Maker, 1996). Reis (2004) stated that fair identification systems use “multiple assessment measures that respect diversity, accommodate students who develop at different rates, and identify potential as well as demonstrated talent” (p. xii). Potential in creative talent in youth can be assessed by evaluating actual creative performance and products. The evaluation may involve rating scales or checklists relevant to particular domains (e.g., visual arts, performing arts, technology, or leadership) as screening procedures, perhaps by classroom teachers. For example, in efforts to identify potential talent in art, specialized assessment may include assessments by artists or artists/teachers who have expertise in recognizing potential talent in the domain (e.g., Haroutounian, 1995; Uszler, 1992). Haroutounian (1995)
Schools • 97 suggests that the assessment should include observation of students over a period of time in order to view developing work. Observation by a team of two or three observers is recommended, including at least one art specialist who is acquainted with the purpose and process of talent identification (e.g., ArtsConnection, 1992). A portfolio that contains a student profile is especially useful for identifying students with creative potential. The folio may contain questionnaires, checklists, rating scales, and evidence of performances and products including prizes and awards. The information may be collected from students themselves, teachers, counselors, parents, peers, specialists, and/or mentors. Haensly (1999) suggested that when observing competence in young children, observational methods that extract more information than test scores are better tools for identification. Observation of children in their natural settings in their encounters with peers and significant caregivers, engaged with the objects and events occurring there, would be more accurate than test scores. Activities and accomplishment inventory (AAI; Milgram & Hong, 2002) The AAI assesses the current activities and accomplishment in talent domains and predicts future creative talent (Hong, Milgram, & Whiston, 1993; Milgram & Hong, 1994). Current activities and accomplishment in children and adolescents may represent the beginning stage of creative talent manifestation, thus likely showing mild or moderate level of talent. When the AAI is used in adults, the results would present the accomplishment and realized talent at the time. The AAI should be used in conjunction with other authentic measures; the results found from the AAI assessment could be used to screen candidates for subsequent authentic assessments. The AAI is based upon the earlier work of Milgram (1983, 1990) and has been used in forms adjusted for age with children as young as 7 (Hong, Milgram, & Gorsky, 1995), adolescents who represent a wide range of intellectual abilities (Milgram & Hong, 1994), and highly intellectually gifted young adults (Milgram, Hong, Shavit, & Peled, 1997). These inventories are self-report measures of activities and accomplishments in various specific domains. The activities in which gifted and talented children and youth engage are often highly intellectual in nature and are done to satisfy their own curiosity and interests, rather than to achieve high grades or to satisfy the needs of teachers and parents. We define two distinct categories of leisure activities, non-challenging and challenging. The former are non-intellectual (e.g., watching TV) out-of-school activities. They are passive, repetitive, require little involvement or effort from the person, and are an end in and of themselves. Challenging leisure activities, by contrast, are unusual and of high quality. They are intrinsically motivated, intellectual, and creative endeavors
98 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development (e.g., computer programming, conducting scientific experiments, composing music, writing poetry, organizing peers to advocate social change) that may lead to accomplishments in a specific domain in young people. Challenging leisure activities are pursued actively and enthusiastically, and generally require serious involvement and effort. They are more likely to be stimulating than relaxing. The enjoyment experienced while pursuing challenging leisure activities is viewed not as an end in and of itself, but rather as a means to an end. Challenging leisure activities lead to creative accomplishment, that is, to the generation of unusual and high-quality products in a specific domain. Nonchallenging activities do not. The tenacious pursuit of challenging activities in a specific domain as a child or adolescent may be a good predictor of realworld creative accomplishments in that domain as an adult. Children who spend many hours reading, practicing an instrument, painting, or working in their “laboratories” reflect not only intellectual abilities but task commitment, and other cognitive and personal–social attributes that strongly determine life outcomes. One might argue that leisure activities outside school are more stable and valid indicators of potential talent than IQ scores and school grades. Over the years studies have provided moderate to strong evidence of the construct validity of AAI scores (Hong & Milgram, 1996; Hong, Whiston, & Milgram, 1993). Two longitudinal studies provided evidence of the predictive validity of this instrument – an 18-year follow-up of the students of an entire senior class characterized by a wide range of intellectual abilities (Hong, Milgram, & Whiston, 1993; Milgram & Hong, 1994) and a 13-year follow-up (Milgram, Hong, Shavit, & Peled, 1997) of highly intellectually gifted young people selected from the entire student population of Israel. Both studies demonstrated the efficacy of out-of-school activities and accomplishments as predictors of career choice and accomplishment. In both studies the results demonstrated that the performance of creative leisure activities in adolescence was a better predictor of career choice and accomplishment later in life than intelligence or school grades. Furthermore, there was evidence of a match between the domain of adolescent leisure activities and the domain of adult occupational choice. This match was found in 45 percent of the intellectually gifted who participated in these longitudinal studies. In addition, in both studies, when activities and career choice domains were matched, career achievement was higher than when it was not. Other identification tools Bracken and Brown (2006) propose that the Clinical Assessment of Behavior (CAB; Bracken & Keith, 2004) is another tool that can be used to identify students for gifted and talented programs. This behavior rating scale can be
Schools • 99 completed by teachers and/or parents for children across a wide range of ages (2 to 18 years), for exceptional children such as those with attention deficit disorder, autistism, mental retardation, and learning disabilities, as well as potentially gifted and talented children. They reported that the gifted and talented have better overall adjustment than non-gifted students as indicated by teacher ratings on the CAB, total scale score (CAB Behavioral Index), and other subscales (e.g., anxiety, depression). Bracken and Brown (2006) assert that the CAB may be useful not only for identifying the gifted and talented, but to better investigate the social and emotional needs of identified students. Some researchers in gifted education stress the importance of including personality characteristics such as motivation and commitment in the identification process (Gottfried & Gottfried, 1996; Renzulli, 1986). Ackerman (1997) proposed that, for gifted adolescents, Dabrowski’s (1964, 1972) overexcitabilities, particularly psychomotor, emotional, and intellectual overexcitabilities, should be considered in the identification process. Lee and Olszewski-Kubilius (2006) recommend parent nomination as a feasible alternative to standardized achievement tests for talented students, especially for those who are not native English speakers or those who would not be identified as gifted using traditional identification tools.
Differentiation of curriculum and instruction One important reason why school districts fail to contribute to the realization of the potential talents in youngsters has to do with the administrative arrangements used to provide special educational programs for them. In the 1970s a multidimensional definition of giftedness was adopted by the United States Office of Education (Marland, 1972). It included children and youth who give evidence of high performance capability in a wide variety of intellectual and creative areas. This definition firmly established gifted learners as similar to the other exceptional learners such as the partially sighted, blind, deaf, learning-disabled, and retarded. In order to maximize their potential achievement in school, they, like other exceptional children, require special education, that is, services or activities in addition to or in place of those generally offered by the school. Despite this lofty goal, the large majority of gifted and talented students across the nation spend all but 2 or 3 hours per week in regular classrooms and do not receive special education services (e.g., Cox, Daniel, & Boston, 1985; Torrance & Sisk, 2001). The recent educational reform movement stressing equity in education has resulted in a reduction in the number of pullout or resource room programs for gifted students, and these youngsters spend even more hours in regular classrooms (Gallagher, 1997). One of the many problems these students
100 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development face is the lack of challenge in the work they are assigned in the classroom (Archambault, Westberg, Brown, Hallmark, Zhang, & Emmons, 1993). In order to meet the widely different needs of gifted and talented students in regular classrooms, the curriculum and instruction needs to be differentiated. Differentiated curriculum Curriculum differentiation means that what is learned in school is modified or tailored to match the specific type and level of cognitive abilities and the unique pattern of abilities of the individual gifted child. In real-world terms this means that, although the gifted learner is learning in a group situation, the material that he/she learns is modified specifically for a particular type and level of abilities. For the most part, gifted learners do not require that the curriculum be adapted for them individually in all school subjects. Most will profit from learning the same curriculum materials as the other learners in the class for most subjects. However, if the curriculum is modified to reflect the specific area and level of ability and interest of the gifted learner, the chances are that his or her achievement will be better than without such modification. It is also reasonable to assume that such differentiation of curriculum will result in stronger motivation to learn and more positive attitudes toward the learning process. Learners may be gifted in specific academic or creative domains. For example, a learner may be gifted in mathematics or in foreign languages but not in other academic subjects. Similarly, a learner’s creative abilities may focus in drama, art, business, or political leadership. A learner may differ from the norm of his/her class not only in kind of specific ability but also in the level at which the giftedness obtains. Despite the recognition by most educators of the desirability of differentiation of curriculum in terms of individual type and level of ability, the implementation of such differentiation remains largely in the realm of an “impossible dream.” The considerable development of technology has made it possible for students and teachers to have access to curriculum materials and resources (see Chapter 11). Television, computers, use of the Internet for distance learning, access to libraries, and email are only examples of how technology can be used to differentiate curriculum. Individualization Individualization of instruction means that the school experience is customized in terms of the unique personal–psychological needs and preferences of the individual gifted child. Teaching strategies can be modified and individualized in terms of the interests and preferences of each learner. In addition, the pace
Schools • 101 as well as the amount of feedback that the learner receives can all be adjusted for the individual through the use of technology. Individualized programs can be provided via the Internet, compact disk, and a host of other means (e.g., distance education). We have devoted Chapter 11 to describing in detail how technology can be used to develop a wide variety of teaching materials and strategies to individualize instruction. Teaching gifted and talented learners in regular classrooms Although the effects of providing differentiated education to the gifted in the regular classroom have been shown to be positive (e.g., Barnett & Durden, 1993; Gentry & Owen, 1999), modification and differentiation of instructional activities in general classrooms have not been practiced as widely as in specialized gifted programs (e.g., Archambault, Westberg, Brown, Hallmark, Zang, & Emmons, 1993). With many gifted and talented students being educated in regular classrooms, a focus on appropriate instructional practices that go beyond the typical enrichment approach employed in the past is required (Torrance & Sisk, 2001). Regular classrooms: current situation Regular classroom teachers do not find it feasible to modify the curriculum and instructional practices to accommodate the needs of gifted and talented students in their classes (Schumm & Vaughn, 1991). Teachers very infrequently use higher-order thinking questions with these students in their classrooms (Westberg, Archambault, Dobyns, & Slavin, 1993). Although teachers may be willing to provide encouragement and support for the gifted and talented in their classrooms, they are less willing to make specific modifications to their teaching strategies, to use differentiated curricular materials, or to provide a classroom environment specifically adjusted to meet the needs of mainstreamed gifted students. That is, the majority of gifted learners in regular classrooms do not receive challenging material, challenging work, or advanced instruction (Reis, Gubbins, Briggs, Schreiber, Richards, Jacobs, Eckert, & Renzulli, 2004). Even well-meaning teachers find it difficult to organize special experiences for gifted students because they often lack the training, resources, time, and administrative support required to adjust and enrich the regular classroom experience of gifted and talented learners (Gallagher, 1997). Suggested solutions As pullout programs decrease in number, more gifted and talented students are served in regular classrooms. VanTassel-Baska (1995) advocates a more inclusive approach to talent development (an integrated curriculum approach) and the provision of curriculum for all learners at appropriate levels of
102 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development challenge so that talent may be discerned and encouraged from a broader range of students in the classroom. She contends that as an integrated curriculum represents a total curriculum package in an area of learning rather than an add-on curriculum, it provides the needed differentiation within traditional areas of learning for which schools are accountable. She further stresses that this approach is related to a shift of emphasis in the field from the focus on the individual gifted learner to the process of collective talent development for all learners. The Schoolwide Enrichment Model (Renzulli & Reis, 1985, 1998) was originally designed for academically gifted students; however, it is currently used to develop gifts and talents of a much wider pool of students. The Total Talent Portfolio, one of the schoolwide enrichment model components, focuses attention on student interests and learning-style preferences. The model can be applied in the regular classroom. It can be combined with enrichment, subject area acceleration, and curriculum compacting and can be used to challenge gifted students in regular classrooms. Enrichment experiences provide gifted students with opportunities to investigate topics of interest in much greater detail than is possible through the standard curriculum. Subject-matter acceleration provides gifted students with learning experiences usually provided to older children (e.g., Gallagher & Gallagher, 1994). Curriculum compacting is an approach for compressing instruction into short time periods and thus speeding up the pace of instruction (Reis & Renzulli, 1992). These approaches have been documented as beneficial to high-ability students, for example enhanced self-esteem, increased decisionmaking skills, and positive academic effects (Bailey, 1992; Renzulli & Reis, 1985; Winebrenner, 2003). Parents also reported positive views on enrichment programs (e.g., Olszewski-Kubilius & Lee, 2004). Need for teacher training As the effectiveness of teaching gifted and talented learners within the framework of regular classrooms is entirely dependent upon regular classroom teachers, the teachers must have in-service training. The need for training has been stressed (VanTassel-Baska, 1995; Westberg. Archambault, Dobyns, & Slavin, 1993). Teacher-consultants (e.g., gifted-education teachers) should be available to cooperate with the regular classroom teacher in meeting the challenge presented by gifted learners in their classrooms. Furthermore, curriculum materials designed for use with gifted students in the classroom must be prepared and made available to the teachers. Reanalysis of the data on grouping (Kulik & Kulik, 1992) indicates that when the curriculum is modified for gifted students, the positive effects of ability grouping for instruction become more prominent. The advantage of ability grouping is greater in homogeneous classes (pullout) than in regular
Schools • 103 classrooms (e.g., Hong, Greene, & Higgins, 2006). Thus, in-service training should include learning how to use grouping judiciously. It should also include acquiring an understanding of the value of carefully planned teaching strategies and clear goals in the mainstreamed class. Ebmeier, Dyche, Taylor, and Hall (1985) studied the impact of an in-service program in which regular classroom teachers were trained to use curriculum materials with gifted students. The results indicated that the gifted students taught by regular teachers achieved similar cognitive gains to those students taught by gifted specialists. Conclusions Teaching gifted and talented children in regular classrooms has a number of unique advantages that should be considered: 1 As gifted children are rarely gifted equally in all subjects, individualization of instruction offers special education exactly where it is required. This approach can provide for the needs of gifted and talented learners of all types, levels, and ages. Technology can be used to provide an early and an equal opportunity to systematically develop interests, abilities, and talents that diverge from the norm. 2 The methods and materials used by teachers to enrich and/or accelerate the education of children by providing a differentiated curriculum and individualized learning experiences are immediately beneficial to other children in the classroom. The teacher who learns how to individualize instruction for the fast learner is at the same time learning how to best deal with the problems of the slow learner. Teachers cannot be expected to develop the differentiated curriculum materials required to serve the needs of learners who differ widely in type and level of abilities and interests. It must become a major goal of state educational authorities to fund the development of the required materials and to provide the avenues to make them available to regular classroom teachers. Needless to say, it is the vast development in technology that must be harnessed in order to serve the needs of learners with the full range of abilities. 3 Some gifted children are underserved because of where they live. More special education is being provided for children who live in the large urban areas than for those who live in rural areas. Here again, the use of technology to make it feasible to differentiate curriculum and instruction to meet the needs of isolated learners in regular classrooms is one method of redressing this imbalance in opportunities.
104 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development Special replacement programs for gifted and talented children: during the school day Most states in the United States have enacted legislation or published regulations and guidelines designed to provide special education for gifted learners. The exact nature of the services to be provided was not specified by law, but was left, instead, to be decided by local school administrators and school boards. This resulted in the development of a wide variety of alternative programs, with teachers, counselors, and administrators left with the task of selecting the program options that would be offered in their area. No one program option is obviously the most desirable and an individual approach should be used to determine how best to meet the needs of a particular gifted child. In the pages that follow we will summarize the program options that are most frequently offered in school systems. This section is meant to be a source of information to parents and educators who may not be familiar with the large number of alternative educational programs that already exist in gifted education. Special programs offered in and out of school use various instructional approaches. The special education offered to gifted students in any one of the administrative arrangements summarized below may include enrichment, accelerated or advanced instruction, curriculum compacting, or an interdisciplinary approach. For example, acceleration, which provides gifted students with learning experiences usually provided to older children, fast-paced instruction where academic-year courses are condensed into shorter time periods, or advanced placement courses, offering students the opportunity to learn courses that can lead to college credits, might be used more in one setting than in another. However, in principle there is no connection between curriculum, teaching strategies, and any particular administrative arrangement. The administrative arrangements listed below are designed to provide special education for gifted and talented children during the regular school day. These programs replace, for time periods that can range from 1 hour to a full day, the teaching–learning experience of the regular classroom with experiences designed specifically to meet the special needs that result from giftedness. Differentiation of curriculum and individualization of instruction in the regular classroom This option was described in detail in the previous section of this chapter. The regular classroom teacher, in some instances supplemented by advice and support from a teacher with special training in individualized instruction
Schools • 105 for the gifted, provides for the individual needs of gifted children within the setting of the regular classroom. Special classes: pullout programs Gifted students receive most of their instruction in heterogeneous classrooms and are “pulled out” to study with other gifted children in a special class for a portion of the school day or week. The children may meet with the special education teacher in resource rooms in their own school building, where they are provided with individual and/or small-group instruction, or they may travel by bus to the part-time special class held in a central location. Children may spend from 1 hour to a full day each week in the pullout class. Teachers of these part-time special classes are expected to encourage students to work independently at their own pace and apply hands-on activities and those requiring higher-order thinking processes. These teachers were indeed found to be more enthusiastic about the content they were teaching than were teachers of the regular classroom (Hertzog, 2003; Hong, Greene, & Higgins, 2006). Although teachers of the gifted are expected to incorporate accelerated content and problem-centered curricula more than those of regular students, Avery, VanTassel-Baska, and O’Neil (1997) observed few differences with regards to curricular and instructional strategies. Special classes This is sometimes referred to as the satellite school-within-a-school approach. One or more classes within a regular school are designated for the exclusive purpose of providing special education for children of high intellectual ability and scholastic achievement. These classes are generally full-time at the elementary-school level and similar to special schools in philosophy and practice. They are generally characterized by selective admissions based mainly upon high intelligence test scores and grades. The degree of participation of gifted students with the regular school varies from almost total to nearly none, with the norm being participation in social events and non-academic subjects. At the secondary school level, special classes are frequently offered on a parttime basis. For example, advanced placement and fast-paced classes would fall into this category. Full-time special schools An entire school is designated for the exclusive purpose of providing special education for children of high intellectual ability and scholastic achievement. These schools are usually characterized by selective admissions based mainly
106 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development upon high intelligence, standardized achievement test scores, and grades. Some full-time special schools allow for continuous progression and/or are non-graded. Gifted learners advance as they master curriculum content and skills, and frequently traditional age-grade labels are not used. Full-time specialized school These schools are often referred to as magnet schools. They are designed to offer special opportunities for enrichment and/or acceleration to children of high ability in a specific academic discipline (e.g., mathematics, science, computing) or with special talents (e.g., music, drama, art). These are special, often single-purpose, schools characterized by selective admissions based upon specific criteria. Full- and part-time special schools: residential An entire residential school is designated for the exclusive purpose of providing special education for gifted and/or talented children. This is most commonly found on university campuses during the summer. Home schooling Home schooling has been used by families with gifted children. Rivero (2002) suggests that home schooling environments for gifted learners can be creative, progressive, and self-directed. Reasons for home schooling cited by parents include: schools are unable or unwilling to meet the intellectual needs of highly able or asynchronous learners; some children require a smaller and more comfortable environment in which to develop social and emotional skills; home-based education can address the needs of the whole child and integrate the child’s individual learning style, pace, and rhythm into the curriculum; for exceptional and profoundly gifted children, home schooling is a last resort after families’ other available schooling options have been exhausted without success (Rivero, 2002). Kearney (2005) warns that although home schooling is an excellent alternative for many gifted children, not every parent should consider home schooling for a gifted child. Special supplementary programs for gifted and talented children: outside school and in addition to the school day We next present a summary of special out-of-school programs designed to provide for talent development in a given domain. Special out-of-school programs include weekend and summer programs (either university based
Schools • 107 or community based) for various subject matters (e.g., mathematics camp, summer intensive physics course), mentoring programs, study-abroad programs, contests and competitions, distance-learning programs, and internship programs (Olszewski-Kublius & Limburg-Weber, 2002). These programs can constitute supportive environments created by peers, teachers, and mentors (Feldman, 1986; VanTassel-Baska, 1995). It is important that gifted individuals be exposed to various opportunities such as those described below. Many eminent adults reported that competition was available for them and it helped them develop their talent (Bloom, 1985). Supplementary educational services such as Saturday or weekend programs or summer programs can foster talent development by providing needed academic challenge (Feldhusen, 1997; Goldstein & Wagner, 1993; Olszewski-Kubilius & Lee, 2004; Renzulli, 1987a; VanTassel-Baska, 1988). Special out-of-school programs can not only enhance gifted students’ selfconfidence, motivation to achieve, and personal responsibility for learning, but also provide social networks that gifted children can benefit from (e.g., instrumental assistance, emotional support, and guidance) (OlszewskiKubilus & Grant, 1996; Olszewski-Kubilus, Grant, & Seibert, 1994). Some of the special out-of-school programs that might offer these opportunities are listed below. Concurrent or dual university enrollment Students who are profoundly gifted in a specific academic discipline, perhaps mathematics or science or a foreign language, are offered the opportunity for radical acceleration in that discipline by means of enrollment in one or more university courses. This system is referred to as dual or concurrent because the students are enrolled in the university part-time while still enrolled full-time in a regular or special class setting. Classes sponsored by universities These are classes offered during afternoon, weekend, summer, or vacation periods. They are designed to provide the opportunity for enrichment and/or acceleration for children of high intellectual ability or scholastic achievement, and/or for children of high ability in a specific academic discipline (e.g., mathematics, science, computing). Classes in public settings Similar to the special classes described above, these classes are also offered during, afternoon, weekend, summer, or vacation periods. Classes are designed
108 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development to provide the opportunity for enrichment and/or acceleration for children of high intellectual ability or scholastic achievement, and/or for children of high ability in a specific discipline. These classes often meet in public schools or other municipal facilities and are under the administrative responsibility of the local school district or the municipality. Internships and mentor programs This is a system of providing practical career and real-world experience in a setting outside the classroom. Internships are domain-specific, careeroriented apprentice experiences in which the learner has the opportunity to receive guidance and supervision as he/she performs specific learning tasks. Mentorship, by contrast, is a more general relationship between a young learner and a wise and trusted friend. It also involves real-world career experience, but may not be limited to specific tasks, subject matter, or situations. The mentor–mentee relationship is more generalized and pervasive. The mentor– intern approach has been cited as particularly promising by Cox, Daniel and Boston (1985). Many highly gifted adults have attributed great importance to mentor influences (Albert & Runco, 1986, 1987; Bloom, 1985; Cox, Daniel, & Boston, 1985). Nevertheless, very little use has actually been made of the approach with the gifted. One of the main reasons the approach, seen as so promising, is actually rarely used in practice is the administrative difficulty of implementing mentor programs. The special contribution of mentor programs to helping disadvantaged or underachieving gifted youngsters realize their potential abilities is discussed in the next chapter.
Special topics Topics relevant for school-related issues in gifted education not included in this chapter are numerous. We include two important issues in this section: gifted with learning disabilities and ability grouping. Gifted with learning disabilities Special populations among the gifted students such as gifted with learning disabilities or gifted with attention deficit disorder require special services that may be provided either within or outside the regular classroom. Dole (2000) states that gifted learners with learning disabilities may have ability in one or more areas, either realized or potential, but also experience specific academic problems as a result of underlying processing deficits. These children also have a paradoxical combination of abilities (Tannenbaum & Baldwin, 1983). For example, they are able to synthesize difficult information or understand
Schools • 109 complex mathematics concepts while they may be unable to master basic skills, such as spelling simple words or doing basic computations (Silverman, 1989). Often these children receive remediation for basic skills, but not advanced instruction for their giftedness. It is recommended that their identified potential strengths should be developed along with effort to alleviate the effects of their academic deficits (West, 1991). Nielsen and Mortorff-Albert (1989) found that when these learners focused on their strengths, their self-concept scores closely resembled the scores of gifted students. Howard (1994) recommended some instructional strategies that can be used with this population: use of computer technology, mnemonic techniques, graphic organizers, the integrative strategy instruction model, and seminar instruction. Ability grouping Although grouping is something that can be used in any of the approaches discussed in this chapter (except for individualized instruction), due to the controversy surrounding grouping practices, we provide a few research findings. Grouping practices have been controversial as to the relative advantages of grouping gifted and talented students homogeneously or heterogeneously (mixed ability) for learning and achievement (Benbow & Stanley, 1996; Feldhusen & Moon, 1992; Kulik & Kulik, 1997). Mixed-ability grouping provides gifted students with an environment that benefits their social development. Regular students also benefit from the mental stimulation and increased motivation to learn that comes from the association with highability students (Oakes, 1985; Slavin, 1987). There are socialization benefits to both groups from the heterogeneous learning group arrangement (Robinson, 1990; Silverman, 1993a). By contrast, some investigators view homogeneous grouping as providing gifted students with academic, social, and emotional benefits (Feldhusen & Moon, 1992; Kulik & Kulik, 1997). Advocates of homogeneous grouping claim that gifted children must be given opportunities to learn with their intellectual peers to share the benefits of their knowledge (e.g., Davis & Rimm, 1994). Negative experiences in heterogeneous classrooms (e.g., teasing and bullying) can be detrimental to gifted students (Gross, 1989; Moon, Nelson, & Piercy, 1993). Lack of academic challenge can lead them to boredom (Baker, Bridger, & Evans, 1998). Negative experiences such as those mentioned can lead them to feel frustrated, isolated, or depressed (Clasen & Clasen, 1995; Silverman, 1993a). Students’ perceptions of the two types of grouping resulted in mixed findings (Adams-Byers, Whilsell, & Moon, 2004). Students perceived
110 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development homogeneous grouping more positively with respect to academic outcomes (e.g., learn more in the more challenging environment), had mixed feelings about which setting better met their social needs (e.g., enjoyed helping less able students), and valued both having similar peers in homogeneous classes and the social diversity of heterogeneous classes. A few performance goaloriented gifted students preferred heterogeneous classes because they were easier and enabled them to attain a high class ranking with little work. Studies on cooperative learning yielded similar findings with the two grouping types discussed above. The concerns have been that gifted students are likely to feel that the curriculum used in cooperative learning is not challenging enough for them, whereas others contend that cooperative learning environments will help them develop higher self-esteem by being team leaders (e.g., Elmore & Zenus, 1994). Attitudes of gifted students toward school subjects were most positive when cooperative learning was used sparingly (Ramsay & Richards, 1997).
Preventing talent loss We believe that all individuals, young and old, have the ability to learn and actualize their potential. People with high intellectual ability, or with other unique strengths, can develop their potential. How high one can achieve is determined by one’s cognitive abilities and various personal–psychological attributes, along with supportive environment. Unfortunately, high-ability students are often considered as not having any difficulties in developing their gifts and are thought to have capacities to help themselves in all aspects of their lives. However, one can observe and read the pervasive literature of underachievement and of once-promising youngsters with high creative ability being stifled in classrooms. By providing a supportive environment that identifies individual students’ strengths and by placing them in a proper learning environment, schools can help prevent talent loss. Know each child’s strength and entry knowledge and skill level All individuals, including gifted learners, have different strengths in different areas. Flexibility in placing each student in special services, in the provision of curricular materials, and on providing proper levels of challenge will help students remain involved and interested in learning and schooling. On-going assessments of knowledge and skills of gifted individuals are essential for establishing the current status and learning rates for proper instruction. Assessment of interest in subject matter and in life would help educators determine which areas the particular students should pursue to
Schools • 111 acquire in-depth knowledge. Without assessment at the individual level, one would not be able to set goals. The success rate of any endeavor will increase if teachers understand the individual students’ entry-level knowledge and skills in the domain and are flexible in preparing instructions utilizing various strategies (e.g., flexible grouping). Provide differentiated instruction If schools and districts do not support the differentiation of curriculum and of instruction, it is difficult, if not impossible, for teachers to implement these strategies. Some schools provide multi-age classes based on students’ intellectual abilities. Other schools may focus on individualizing instruction within the regular classroom for students with different levels of strengths. Although teachers may develop their own instructional materials for their classroom teaching, teachers should be provided with proper curricular and instructional materials at the district level. Teacher training is required for gifted education Preservice and in-service teacher training is essential for providing regular classroom teachers with the skills and knowledge required for equipping them for the task of providing special education for gifted and talented learners. Use multiple assessments for identification For identification of the gifted for special services, multiple assessment measures and tools should be utilized to identify different types of potential talents. Difficulties with some types of assessment measures have been discussed (e.g., cognitive ability tests), especially for identifying economically disadvantaged and limited English speakers. Reis (2004) suggests that in the final decision for selecting the gifted for special services, it is the thoughtful judgment of knowledgeable professionals, not cutoff scores, that should guide selection decision. This behooves educators to be knowledgeable about human potential and giftedness and talent. Without proper identification, potential talents will not see the light and talent loss is predictable. Challenging out-of-school activities are essential for talent development Exposure to various activities, programs, and competitions is an avenue for developing potential. Out-of-school activities and accomplishments have been an excellent predictor for future attainment. Thus, teachers, counselors, and parents may encourage students to get involved in challenging activities in the area of their interest to help them develop their potential talent.
chapter
9
School Personnel and Climate
The school and classroom environments are the chief psychological determinants of academic learning and they have a powerful impact on the social and emotional development of learners as well. Students’ perceptions about their classes affect not only their interest and engagement in learning subject matter but also acquisition of essential social skills. School and classroom environments that are friendly and warm as well as challenging will produce learners who are interested in learning, responsible, and respectful of both school personnel and their age peers. This situation bodes well for the future for all students; one can expect that students educated in these environments will become healthy and productive citizens in the future. School environments that are operated by school personnel who are controlling and demand conformity might stifle students’ independence, creativity, and socio-emotional growth. School personnel have a tendency to think that gifted children will succeed without special attention or opportunities. This is not so, and when their needs are not met in school, the result may be boredom, behavioral problems, or disconnection from school (Pfeiffer & Stocking, 2000).
114 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development
Teachers Teachers’ knowledge and beliefs Teachers’ knowledge and beliefs play an important role in their teaching (Borko & Putnam, 1996). Teachers’ own past school experiences are most influential in determining their beliefs and behaviors. When preservice teachers were asked how they would teach a word problem and why they prefer that approach, many of them responded that they teach certain ways because that’s how they were taught to solve word problems. Although some preservice teachers showed conceptual changes after the instruction they received in the course, the findings, in general, indicate that most teachers have implicit theories of teaching and learning and of how students should behave at school even before they begin teaching (Hong, 1998a). Teachers are encouraged to examine their beliefs periodically to understand whether their beliefs and practices match effective instructional theories and approaches and to modify them as necessary. Teachers’ beliefs about learning and gifted learners determine whether teachers can successfully provide learning opportunities to gifted learners. Classroom teachers need to believe that students learn at different rates and possess different types and degrees of abilities, interests, and styles of learning. VanTassel-Baska and Stambaugh (2005) stated that teachers who do not have these basic assumptions about student learning may not see the need to differentiate. Teachers’ beliefs about their role should be in line with current learning theories. Teachers of both gifted and regular students need to believe that students can learn independently or in groups without teachers’ direct instruction. Although teachers engage in direct instruction, they should be capable facilitators of learning, encouraging students to be independent, responsible, self-regulated learners. Teachers’ lack of subject knowledge is a critical issue. It is difficult to imagine a teacher teaching mathematics without the necessary knowledge and problem-solving skills of basic mathematics (Hong, 1995a). Although teacher knowledge is important for all students, it becomes critical for teachers working with gifted students due to the precocity of such learners in subject matter content and their superior thinking abilities. Without proper levels of knowledge and skills, teachers working with gifted students cannot provide differentiated curriculum and instruction. Teachers who lack knowledge of the specific subject matter required by gifted students in their class may expand their knowledge base through professional development. If professional development is not readily available, a more immediate solution to this challenge would be to seek assistance from content specialists in the school district, or help gifted students find content mentors (VanTassel-Baska & Stambaugh, 2005).
School Personnel and Climate • 115 Teachers’ attitude toward creative students and creative instruction Many investigators found that teachers prefer intellectually gifted children who are low in creativity to those who are highly creative and unconventional (e.g., Davis & Rimm, 1994; Rudowicz, 2003). Teachers see creative children as a source of interference and disruption (Scott, 1999). Moreover, energetic and unconventional students may be mistakenly identified as having attention deficit hyperactivity disorder by teachers who desire conformity (Cramond, 1994b). Gifted underachievers are particularly sensitive to teachers who are critical, rigid, officious, and unsympathetic (Fine, 1967; McCoach & Siegle, 2003). Observations of elementary school teachers’ classroom instruction indicated that the majority of teachers do not implement any strategies that foster student creativity, especially in classrooms with high proportions of minority and low-performing students (Schacter, Thum, & Zifkin, 2006). In advocating an innovation-friendly climate in the classroom, Cropley (2006) contends that the climate affects what group members (e.g., peers) regard as normal, how much and what kind of deviation from the normal (novelty) they will tolerate, and what rewards or sanctions they impose on those who introduce novelty (e.g., punishment or reward, ridicule or respect, encouragement or discouragement, high or low status of intellectual). The creativity-facilitating classroom climate involves a general feeling that creative thinkers are respected, students would tolerate new ideas, conformity is not imposed, and diversity in ideas will be encouraged and appreciated. Further, students in this climate are provided with choices, different ideas are accepted, self-confidence is enhanced, and students’ strengths and interests are emphasized (de Souza Fleith, 2000). Stein and Poole (1997) challenge teachers to question their teaching practices and views concerning student learning. They recommend that teachers create the environment to meet gifted individuals’ interests and needs, design curriculum to ensure open-ended activities, and utilize real-life contexts for assessing and reporting learning outcomes. Treffinger (1995) also stresses the importance of establishing a constructive environment for creativity and productivity. In schools with such a climate, both disciplined engagement and creative energy are valued and evident, and students’ accomplishments and success will not be judged by test scores only. Runco (1986) and Runco and Okuda (1991) reported that originality of both gifted and non-gifted students improved after they received explicit instructions to increase creative thinking. Even a simple “be creative” instruction increased performance in creative problem-solving (e.g., Chen, Himsel, Kasof, Greenberger, & Dmitrieva, 2006). By the same token, creativity training techniques are found to increase creative thinking in university students (Cheung, Roskams, & Fisher, 2006). Teacher educators and
116 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development prospective teachers generally value creativity. In light of these findings, one wonders why the topic of creativity is not part of the curriculum in teacher education. Unfortunately, however, efforts to promote the understanding and enhancement of creativity as an important addition to teacher education programs have not been successful (Fasko, 2001). Storm and Storm (2002) recommend teacher training in creativity as a method of schools enhancing creative behavior in students. Teacher attitudes toward highly creative students are influenced by the training they receive and their understanding of creativity. By the same token, training reportedly reduces sex role stereotyping (Murphy, Jenkins-Friedman, & Tollefson, 1984). Teachers with a background in gifted education responded differently to gifted students (Hanninen, 1988). This was attributed to exposure to knowledge of creativity and giftedness as part of their teacher training. In addition, such training helps teachers be more open to creative students as well as allows themselves to learn to be creative.
Counselors Little attention has been devoted to counseling potentially talented children and adolescents when the broad and inclusive definition of talent as presented in this book is adopted. Many people think it unnecessary to consider the counseling needs of gifted children and youth at all. In light of the enormous needs of children disadvantaged in a variety of ways it seems quite unjust to devote effort and budget to counseling the gifted. It is believed by many that these fortunate children excel in school, grow up with few adjustment problems, and achieve academic and vocational success as adults quite naturally. The major goal of this book has been to demonstrate that this is simply not so and that talent loss is a major challenge for parents and educators. Children with potential talents do not automatically realize them as adults. Although estimates among authorities vary as to what proportion of children identified as IQ-based gifted do not realize their potential gifts when they become adults, there is agreement that failure to actualize one’s abilities is a significant problem (Marland, 1972; Tannenbaum, 1983). The estimates, as distressing as they are, are a minimal estimate of the scope of the problem of talent loss. Many highly gifted and talented learners whose abilities are not reflected in IQ scores are unidentified during their school years, are not included in the estimates, and they are even less likely to actualize their potential. This section is devoted to counseling potentially talented children and adolescents. These learners share the same basic guidance needs as other children. They require ongoing developmental guidance and counseling in order to fully realize their abilities. In addition, they differ in the type and level
School Personnel and Climate • 117 of their analytical and creative cognitive abilities as well as in their personal– psychological and environmental–social characteristics. Accordingly, they require differentiated guidance and personalized counseling. There is a gap between the need for counseling services and research about counseling potentially talented individuals, on the one hand, and the limited availability of such services and knowledge, on the other (Myers & Pace, 1986; Yoo & Moon, 2006). Such services and knowledge could make a major contribution to preventing talent loss. Cognitive–academic needs Counselor involvement in student academic development has often focused on interventions with students whose personal and/or social difficulties interfere with their capacities to perform well academically. At the middle school and high school levels, counselor involvement with course scheduling and testing, both strongly identified with the academic development domain, often constitute a significant portion of counselors’ workload. More recently, however, school counselors have been challenged to broaden their perspectives regarding contributions in the academic development domain (Roels, 1998; Sink & Stroh, 2003). Classroom guidance and individual or small-group counseling activities focused on assisting students to acquire the knowledge, skills, and attitudes needed for successful completion of schoolwork can be a relevant component of school counselors’ involvement in student academic development. Specific academic problems that frequently arise with various types of learners (gifted, regular, or students with learning disabilities) can be helped by school counselors. For example, when students are identified by classroom teachers as having chronic homework problems for various reasons, school counselors can provide individual or group counseling to help these students overcome the difficulties (Rowell & Hong, 2002). Gifted learners require knowledge about themselves and about their academic and career opportunities. They require complete and accurate information about options currently available within the school system. Moreover, details about the specific requirements for admission to higher education institutions and positive versus negative features of universities and vocations that they might consider in the future, would be particularly useful. These learners need to understand the overall nature of giftedness and talent in terms of the model of giftedness and talent presented in this book. In addition, they need specific information about their own unique combination of abilities and the implications of these distinctive strengths for academic, personal, and career development.
118 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development Social–emotional needs Guidance should be directed to helping gifted children become aware of their special abilities, feelings, attitudes, values, and interactions with their family, age peers, teachers, and other adults. Gifted students need school counselors who are trained in the social and emotional needs of gifted students and whose schedules reserve time for meeting with these students singly or in small groups to discuss issues unique to their exceptionalities (Adams-Byers, Whitsell, & Moon, 2004). Some personality characteristics that are common to some gifted students, such as perfectionism, sensitivity, intensity, or idealism (Silverman, 1993b; Sowa, McIntire, May, & Bland, 1994), may create difficult situations in traditional school settings. Accordingly, gifted students may develop unique socio-emotional needs and can benefit from differentiated counseling that addresses those needs (Robinson, Reis, Neihart, & Moon, 2002). Bullying (e.g., name-calling, teasing about appearance) is of concern for gifted students in school (Peterson & Ray, 2006). School counselors as well as gifted education and regular classroom teachers should be alert to this kind of bullying, attempt to prevent it, and respond to it when it occurs. Careful scheduling of courses for gifted students is needed so they have opportunities to interact with their intellectual peers as well as students in regular classrooms. In addition, when appropriate, providing classroom teachers with information on the traits and needs of gifted and talented students would be beneficial (Adams-Byers, Whitsell, & Moon, 2004). Yoo and Moon (2006) provided a review of the literature on the characteristics of gifted children that was designed specifically for the use of counselors. Readers are encouraged to read Yoo and Moon (2006) for in-depth understanding and references for further reading. We offer some of the major points of their review. Early childhood One of the distinguishing traits of gifted children in the preschool years is precocious language acquisition, greater self-awareness, and being more socially advanced than their peers. They have cooperative play patterns, select older playmates, and seek the companionship of adults. Giftedness in the early years promotes social–emotional adjustment. However, it also creates differences from peers that can create social–emotional problems in the preschool years. Preadolescence Academic achievement and positive peer relationships can begin to conflict with each other in this period. Some gifted preadolescents adopt egodefense mechanisms and performance goal orientation, and others begin to suppress or hide their giftedness and creativity and become underachievers.
School Personnel and Climate • 119 Gifted preadolescents indicate that they can be hurt by classmates who tease them for being smart, are confused by their abilities, are distressed by high expectations of self and others, and are bored and distracted most of the time in school. They need specialized counseling services to provide them with better understanding of themselves and help them cope with their stressors. By contrast, some researchers report that gifted elementary students have fewer behavior problems than their less gifted peers. They are as well or better adjusted than their age-level peers but may suffer social–emotional distress when placed in inappropriate school environments. Adolescence There are two conflicting views. First, gifted individuals are better adjusted than the less gifted. Cognitive capacities such as adaptive-thinking skills enable them to cope with stressors better, and academically gifted adolescents have fewer emotional problems or maladjustments and higher self-confidence than less gifted adolescents. On the other hand, others find gifted adolescents to be more vulnerable, to face greater risk of socio-emotional problems, and to have higher anxiety levels. Academically gifted adolescents tend to exhibit perfectionism more than their non-gifted peers. Some gifted adolescents exaggerate their similarities to their non-gifted peers in an effort to increase social acceptance in school. The findings of Yoo and Moon (2006) on parental views of counseling needs indicate that for all age groups, parents perceive their child’s greatest counseling need to be educational planning. For children older than six, parents add psycho-social concerns as important counseling needs. For adolescents, career planning is foremost in parents’ view. This list does not include the difficulties that creative students encounter (see above). Whereas school counselors should be aware of these common attributes, unique characteristics of individuals should be assessed, as each child has unique needs for counseling services. Career counseling needs Greene (2003) lists the importance of career counseling in the process of career development. High school and college programs for gifted students, however, focus mainly on addressing their academic needs (Gladieux & Swail, 2000; Peterson, 2000). According to Greene (2003), career counseling helps students reflect about self and choices, restructure their beliefs, and deepen their personalities to answer the “Who am I?” question. Transition and change over time play prominent roles in career development and should also be emphasized in career counseling for gifted and talented students. Although multipotentiality is cited as a primary concern for the gifted and talented in career planning (Clark, 1992; Perrone, 1997), little empirical
120 • Environmental–Social Factors and Talent Development research supports this view. Milgram and Hong (1999b) found that gifted students are more unipotential than multipotential. Achter, Benbow, and Lubinski (1997) also indicated that only 5 percent of the gifted students among their research participants reported multipotentiality. The problem facing gifted students in their career planning may not be multipotentiality, but the lack of decision-making skills (Berger, 1989). Students who work with career counselors, take career exploration courses, and discuss future plans with significant adults are much more likely to identify clear career directions (Chickering & Reisser, 1993). To sum up, counselors need to be aware that many parents of gifted children think that their children need differentiated, professional guidance from counselors with training in working with gifted children, especially in the areas of educational assessment, career counseling, and relationships with peers and family. School counselors are encouraged to seek training to skillfully manage these topics. Adolescents may be a particularly important age group to target for both career counseling and individual/family counseling focused on socio-emotional concerns, such as pressure to meet expectations, a sense of being different, perfectionism, hypersensitivity, low self-esteem, and depression. For gifted students at risk, especially for low-income and culturally diverse youth, Kitano and Lewis (2005) suggest a comprehensive counseling approach. The comprehensive counseling may focus on: enhancing the quality of interactions among various people such as teachers, counselors, parents, relatives, or peers; encouraging a sense of self-efficacy and optimism; validating students’ experiences with bias; and supporting pride in heritage. Students who may possess c