Operational Oceanography in the 21st Century
Andreas Schiller€•€Gary B. Brassington Editors
Operational Oceanography in the 21st Century
1 3
Editors Dr. Andreas Schiller Centre for Australian Weather and Climate Research CSIRO GPO Box 1538 Hobart 7001, Tasmania Australia
[email protected]
Dr. Gary B. Brassington Centre for Australian Weather and Climate Research Bureau of Meteorology PO Box 1289 Melbourne 3001, Victoria Australia
[email protected]
ISBN 978-94-007-0331-5â•…â•…â•…â•… e-ISBN 978-94-007-0332-2 DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-0332-2 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2011925930 All Rights Reserved for Chapters 21 and 22 © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Cover illustration: Daily mean sea surface height anomaly for the 28th July 2009 as estimated by the operational BLUElink ocean prediction system. Red colors indicate positive height anomalies whilst blue colors represent negative height anomalies. Anomalies represent the estimated sea surface height relative to the model’s dynamic topography of a mean from a multi-year integration forced by reanalysis winds. Shown in the image is the east Indian Ocean with anticyclonic and cyclonic eddies in the mid-latitudes and the South Equatorial Current in the tropics that derives volume flux from the western warm pool in the Pacific Ocean via the Indonesian Throughflow. Image produced by Dr. Justin Freeman. Cover design: deblik, Berlin Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface
In the mid 1990s the research community and operational agencies saw an emerging opportunity for near-realtime ocean forecasts similar to those produced in Numerical Weather Prediction: combining numerical models and observations via data assimilation in order to provide ocean prediction products on various space and time scales. This development was facilitated through an international framework provided by the Global Ocean Data Assimilation Experiment (GODAE). GODAE aimed at advancing ocean data assimilation by synthesizing satellite and in-situ observations with state-of-the art models of global ocean circulation. In the past few years ocean forecasting has matured to a stage where many nations have implemented global and basin-scale ocean analyses and short-term forecast systems that provide routine products to the oceanographic community serving a variety of applications in areas such as marine environmental monitoring and management, ocean climate, defense and industry applications. The authors within this book provide an up to date description of the major components of ocean analyses and forecasting systems. The chapters cover a wide range of topics including, but not limited to, scientific advances and challenges in ocean forecasting, the associated descriptions of the forecasting systems and end user applications. This integrated view of ocean forecasting is the end result of an International Summer School for Observing, Assimilating and Forecasting the Ocean held in Perth, Australia, in January 2010. The flow diagram (Fig. 1) captures the main functional components and sources of inputs implemented under GODAE and required by any ocean forecasting system. These are: the data and product servers, the assimilation centres and the users of the outputs. It captures many of the interactions required to ensure or enhance the quality of the systems and their outputs (Bell et al. 2009). The measurement network and data assembly and processing centres provide the main inputs to the assimilation centres (top centre and right of Fig. 1). In this book Le Traon (2011), Josey (2011), Ravichandran (2011) and Oke and O’Kane (2011) provide concise overviews of the in situ and satellite components of the current global observing system and discuss the continuing work required to sustain and optimise it. The GODAE-sponsored Global High Resolution Sea Surface Temperature (GHRSST) project has resulted in a coordinated network of centres disseminating v
vi
Preface
Fig. 1↜渀 Functional components of operational ocean forecasting systems developed during GODAE
SST data in real-time in a common format to agreed standards from a wide range of microwave and infra-red instruments on polar orbiting and geostationary satellites. Cummings (2011) summarizes the substantial achievements during GODAE in the quality control of observational data and the joint use of in situ and satellite data. Dombrowsky (2011) provides an overview of progress in the capabilities of ocean prediction systems and data and product servers (see left of middle row of Fig. 1). Brassington (2011) examines key properties of the real-time system and their impact on operational system design. They provide an overview of the underpinning concepts and technologies which enable the observed data to be discovered, visualised, downloaded, intercompared and analysed all over the world. Progress in ocean data assimilation (the central item in Fig. 1) is described in a number of papers (Zaron 2011; Moore 2011; Brasseur 2011). The tables and descriptions in Dombrowsky (2011) and Zhu (2011) provide a useful overview of the present modelling and assimilation components of the major systems involved in coastal and basin-scale ocean forecasting. Most centres now operate systems with 1/10° or finer horizontal grid spacing; have a global capability; make use of community ocean models (e.g. HYCOM, MOM4 or NEMO; see Barnier et al. 2011, Chassignet 2011; Hurlburt et al. 2011 and Matear 2011); and assimilate in situ profile data, altimeter data and some form of surface temperature data. Martin (2011) illustrates the skill of the high-resolution systems in forecasting sea surface currents and sea surface temperature.
Preface
vii
Product assessments and interactions with research users (lower right area of Fig. 1) have been key activities since the inception of operational ocean forecasting systems. Hernandez (2011) describes the procedures developed to intercompare forecasts produced by different centres and illustrates the insights these can give into the performance of the systems. Alves et al., (2011) describe some examples of how systems developed for ocean state estimation have been used for climate variability/seasonal forecasting research and how intercomparisons of results from the systems are being used to assess the consistency and uncertainty of the state estimates. Oke and O’Kane (2011) summarise results gathered by observing system design research and outline the exciting prospects for future work. They illustrate the complementarity of the SST, altimeter and profile data for mesoscale prediction, and present statistics on the dependence of the accuracy of 7-day forecasts, real-time analyses and delayed mode analyses on the availability of altimeter data. Wilkin et al. (2011) summarise the wide-ranging coastal applications in ocean forecasting. Finally Matear and Jones (2011) outline a number of categories of potential ecological and biogeochemical applications and discuss the challenges this area poses to the fidelity of the physical models and assimilation schemes and to the measurement technologies. The lower left part of Fig. 1 depicts the information flows to application centres (also known as downstream services) and users. Barras (2011) and King et al. (2011) describe the legal framework and use of ocean forecasting outputs in monitoring and prediction of marine pollution (such as oil spills) and the value of GODAE forecasts for safety and effectiveness of operations at Sea. Woodham (2011) provides examples of the wide variety of information and tactical decision aids generated using GODAE products to assist Naval operations. Ivey (2011) summarises the current operational use of upper ocean heat content information to forecast the intensity of tropical cyclones and current research in this area. Fundamentals and applications of sea-level variability, surface waves and tsunamis are discussed by Pattiaratchi (2011) and Greenslade and Tolman (2011). Huckerby (2011) and Mann (2011) provide an introduction to and overview about the emerging field of ocean renewable energy and the corresponding need for ocean state information to determine the available energy resources as well as the impact of ocean renewable energy on the physical environment. The editors gratefully acknowledge the students and lecturers listed below who actively contributed to the success of the summer school as well as the first round of reviews of the draft manuscripts. Primary support for this summer school was provided by the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), USA, the Bureau of Meteorology, Australia, and the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO), Australia. This support is gratefully acknowledged. The editors would like to thank the speakers for their contributions during the summer school and for providing their manuscripts within a tight time frame. We also express our appreciation to the GODAE OceanView Science Team who contributed in numerous ways to the success of the summer school and this book. We
viii
Preface
thank Charitha Pattiaratchi, Diana Greenslade, Tim Pugh, Roger Proctor, Bernard Barnier, Clothilde Langlais, Fabrice Hernandez, Marie Drevillon and Andy Taylor for preparing and conducting an excellent set of student exercises. We thank all the attendees (see list in Appendix) for participating actively in the lectures and in the lecture review process. Finally, our thanks go to Val Jemmeson, Nick D’Adamo and Charitha Pattiaratchi who spent considerable time with the logistics of the summer school. A special thank goes to Denise McMullen for her help in coordinating the editorial process of the manuscripts. Australia 28 May 2010
Andreas Schiller Gary B. Brassington
List of Lecturers and Students
Lecturers Dr. Oscar Alves╇ CAWCR, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Bernard Barnier╇ HMG, France,
[email protected] Ms. Kathryn Barras╇ Minter Ellison, Australia e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Pierre Brasseur╇ HMG, France, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Gary B. Brassington╇ CAWCR, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Prof. Eric P. Chassignet╇ FSU, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. James A. Cummings╇ NRL, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Eric Dombrowsky╇ Mercator, France e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Maria Drevillon╇ Mercator, France, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Diana Greenslade╇ CAWCR, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Fabrice Hernandez╇ Mercator, France e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. John Huckerby╇ New Zealand, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Harley E. Hurlburt╇ NRL, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Gregory N. Ivey╇ UWA, Australian, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Simon A. Josey╇ NOC, United Kingdom, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Brian King╇ APASA, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Clothilde Langlais╇ CSIRO, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Pierre Yves Le Traon╇ IFREMER, France e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Laurence D. Mann╇ Carnegie, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Matthew Martin╇ UK MetOffice, United Kingdom e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Richard J. Matear╇ CAWCR, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Prof. Andrew M. Moore╇ UCSC, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Prof. Charitha Pattiaratchi╇ UWA, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Roger Proctor╇ UTAS, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Mr. Tim Pugh╇ CAWCR, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] ix
x
List of Lecturers and Students
Dr. Muthalagu Ravichandran╇ INCOIS, India, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Andreas Schiller╇ CSIRO, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Hendrik Tolman╇ NOAA, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Mr. Geoff Wake╇ Woodside, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Assoc. Prof. John L. Wilkin╇ Rutgers University, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Comm. Robert Woodham╇ RAN, Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Edward D. Zaron╇ Portland, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Dr. Jiang Zhu╇ IAP, China, e-mail:
[email protected]
Students Amjadali Amanda╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Andutta Fernando╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Backeberg Bjorn╇ South Africa/Germany, e-mail:
[email protected] Ban Natalie╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Ban Stephen╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Bean Richard╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Beck Elise╇ USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Bluteau Cynthia╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Brushett Ben╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Cheah Wee╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Choi Byoung╇ Korea, e-mail:
[email protected] Choukroun Severine╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Desportes Charles╇ France, e-mail:
[email protected] Divakaran Prasanth╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Downes Stephanie╇ USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Duchez Aurelle╇ France, e-mail:
[email protected] Durrant Tom╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Exarchou Eleftheria╇ Germany, e-mail:
[email protected] Fernandez Mariana╇ Uraguay, e-mail:
[email protected] Ford David╇ England, e-mail:
[email protected] Furner Rachel╇ England, e-mail:
[email protected] Garvey Michael╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Gasparin Florent╇ France/New Cal., e-mail:
[email protected] Geard Simon╇ Australia Hanson Christine╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Hertzel Yasha╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] He Zhongjie╇ China, e-mail:
[email protected] Ishizaki Shiro╇ Japan, e-mail:
[email protected] Joseph Sudheer╇ India, e-mail:
[email protected] Law Chune Stephan╇ France, e-mail:
[email protected] Lesser Giles╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected]
List of Lecturers and Students
Luz-Clara Moira╇ Argentina, e-mail:
[email protected] Macdonald Helen╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Meinvielle Marion╇ France, e-mail:
[email protected] Monteiro Igor╇ Brazil, e-mail:
[email protected] Morales Ruben╇ Mexico, e-mail:
[email protected] Mulet Sandrine╇ France, e-mail:
[email protected] O’Callaghan Joanne╇ New Zealand, e-mail:
[email protected] O’Loughlin Julian╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Prakya Shreeram╇ India, e-mail:
[email protected] Prandi Pierre╇ France, e-mail:
[email protected] Rahaman Hasibur╇ India, e-mail:
[email protected] Rayson Matthew╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Rozman Polona╇ Germany, e-mail:
[email protected] Rousseaux Cecile╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Shimizu Kenji╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Shu Yeqiang╇ China, e-mail:
[email protected] Stevenson Kate╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Subramanian Aneesh╇ USA, e-mail:
[email protected] Summons Nicholas╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Swart Neil╇ South Africa, e-mail:
[email protected] Swart Sebastian╇ South Africa, e-mail:
[email protected] Taebi Sohelia╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Tanajura Clemente╇ Brazil, e-mail:
[email protected] Taylor Andy╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Teixeira Carlos╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Tonbol Kareem╇ Egypt, e-mail:
[email protected] Usui Norihisa╇ Japan, e-mail:
[email protected] Volkov Denis╇ Canada, e-mail:
[email protected] Wakamatsu Tsuyoshi╇ Canada, e-mail:
[email protected] Wedd Robin╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Welhena Thisara╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Weller Evan╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Wood Julie╇ Australia, e-mail:
[email protected] Xie Jiping╇ China, e-mail:
[email protected] Zheng Fei╇ China, e-mail:
[email protected] Zhou Wei╇ China, e-mail:
[email protected]
xi
Contents
Part Iâ•… Introduction 1â•…Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century ����������������������������������尓��������������� â•…â•… 3 Andreas Schiller Part IIâ•… Oceanographic Observing System 2â•…Satellites and Operational Oceanography ����������������������������������尓���������� ╅╇ 29 Pierre-Yves Le Traon 3â•…In-Situ Ocean Observing System ����������������������������������尓������������������������� â•… ╇ 55 Muthalagu Ravichandran 4â•…Ocean Data Quality Control ����������������������������������尓�������������������������������� ╇╅ 91 James A. Cummings 5â•…Observing System Design and Assessment ����������������������������������尓��������� â•… 123 Peter R. Oke and Terence J. O’Kane Part IIIâ•… Atmospheric Forcing and Waves 6â•…Air-Sea Fluxes of Heat, Freshwater and Momentum �������������������������� â•… 155 Simon A. Josey 7â•…Coastal Tide Gauge Observations: Dynamic Processes Present in the Fremantle Record ����������������������������������尓������������������������� â•… 185 Charitha Pattiaratchi 8â•…Surface Waves ����������������������������������尓������������������������������������尓������������������� â•… 203 Diana Greenslade and Hendrik Tolman
xiii
xiv
Contents
╇ 9╇Tides and Internal Waves on the Continental Shelf ���������������������������� ╅ 225 Gregory N. Ivey Part IV╅ Modelling 10╅Eddying vs. Laminar Ocean Circulation Models and Their Applications ����������������������������������尓������������������������������������尓��������������������� ╅ 239 ╇ Bernard Barnier, Thierry Penduff and Clothilde Langlais 11╅Isopycnic and Hybrid Ocean Modeling in the Context of GODAE ���� ╅ 263 ╇ Eric P. Chassignet 12╅Marine Biogeochemical Modelling and Data Assimilation ��������������� ╅ 295 ╇ Richard J. Matear and E. Jones Part V╅ Data Assimilation 13╅Introduction to Ocean Data Assimilation ����������������������������������尓��������� ╅ 321 ╇ Edward D. Zaron 14╅Adjoint Data Assimilation Methods ����������������������������������尓������������������ ╅ 351 ╇ Andrew M. Moore 15╅Ensemble-Based Data Assimilation Methods ����������������������������������尓��� ╅ 381 ╇ Pierre Brasseur Part VI╅ Systems 16╅Overview Global Operational Oceanography Systems ��������������������� ╅ 397 ╇ Eric Dombrowsky 17╅Overview of Regional and Coastal Systems ����������������������������������尓������ ╅ 413 ╇ Jiang Zhu 18╅System Design for Operational Ocean Forecasting ��������������������������� ╅ 441 ╇ Gary B. Brassington 19╅Integrating Coastal Models and Observations for Studies of Ocean Dynamics, Observing Systems and Forecasting ���������������� ╅ 487 ╇John L. Wilkin, Weifeng G. Zhang, Bronwyn E. Cahill and Robert C. Chant 20╅Seasonal and Decadal Prediction ����������������������������������尓����������������������� ╅ 513 ╇ Oscar Alves, Debra Hudson, Magdalena Balmaseda and Li Shi
Contents
xv
Part VIIâ•… Evaluation 21â•…Dynamical Evaluation of Ocean Models Using the Gulf Stream as an Example ����������������������������������尓������������������������������������尓���� â•… 545 ╇Harley E. Hurlburt, E. Joseph Metzger, James G. Richman, Eric P. Chassignet, Yann Drillet, Matthew W. Hecht, Olivier Le Galloudec, Jay F. Shriver, Xiaobiao Xu and Luis Zamudio 22â•…Ocean Forecasting Systems: Product Evaluation and Skill �������������� â•… 611 ╇ Matthew Martin 23â•…Performance of Ocean Forecasting Systems— Intercomparison Projects ����������������������������������尓����������������������������������� â•… 633 ╇ Fabrice Hernandez Part VIIIâ•… Applications, Policies and Legal Frameworks 24â•…Defence Applications of Operational Oceanography ������������������������� â•… 659 ╇ Robert Woodham 25â•…Applications for Metocean Forecast Data—Maritime Transport, Safety and Pollution ����������������������������������尓������������������������� â•… 681 ╇ Brian King, Ben Brushett, Trevor Gilbert and Charles Lemckert 26â•…Marine Energy: Resources, Technologies, Research and Policies ���� â•… 695 ╇ John Huckerby 27â•…Application of Ocean Observations & Analysis: The CETO Wave Energy Project ����������������������������������尓������������������������������������尓������ â•… 721 ╇ Laurence D. Mann 28â•…International Marine Environmental Law (Oil Pollution) ��������������� â•… 731 ╇ Kathryn Barras Index ����������������������������������尓������������������������������������尓������������������������������������尓����� â•… 741
Part I
Introduction
Chapter 1
Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century From the Early Days to Tomorrow’s Challenges Andreas Schiller
Abstract╇ This article provides a brief introduction to the history of oceanography with a focus on elements that laid the scientific foundation of ocean forecasting, i.e. ocean observations, ocean general circulation models and data assimilation tools. It then describes the scientific achievements of the first phase of internationally coordinated efforts in the development of global and basin-scale operational ocean forecasting systems during the Global Ocean Data Assimilation Experiment (1997– 2008). This is followed by a description of the challenges in ocean forecasting in the twenty-first century and a summary and conclusion. This article represents an introduction to the modelling, data assimilation and observing system topics discussed in more detail in the subsequent chapters of this book.
1.1â•…Brief History of Oceanography The focus of this article and this book is on the two branches of oceanography that deal with • Physical oceanography, or marine physics, that studies the ocean’s physical attributes including temperature-salinity structure, mixing, waves, internal waves, surface tides, internal tides, and currents, acoustical and optical oceanography; • and, to some extent, biogeochemical oceanography which involves the scientific study of the chemical, physical, geological, and biological processes and reactions that govern the composition of the natural environment, and the cycles of
Centre for Australian Weather and Climate Research—A partnership between CSIRO and the Bureau of Meteorology; CSIRO Wealth from Oceans National Research Flagship, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia. A. Schiller () CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research, Castray Esplanade, GPO Box 1538, Hobart 7001, Tasmania, Australia e-mail:
[email protected] A. Schiller, G. B. Brassington (eds.), Operational Oceanography in the 21st Century, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-0332-2_1, ©Â€Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011
3
4
A. Schiller
matter and energy that transport the Earth’s chemical components in time and space. Biogeochemical oceanography focuses on chemical cycles which are either driven by or have an impact on biological activity such as carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycles. We first describe briefly the general history that laid the foundation of ocean forecasting. The focus here is not on a comprehensive description of the whole science of oceanography but to focus on those components that are underpinning today’s ocean forecasting systems, in particular the development of an ocean observing system and hydrodynamic numerical modelling. Man first began to acquire knowledge of the waves, tides and currents of the seas and oceans in pre-historic times. During The Age of Discovery (approximately late 1400s to early 1700s) exploration of the oceans was primarily for cartography and mainly limited to its surfaces, although depth soundings were taken by lead line. During the beginning of the scientific voyages (late 1700s to twentieth century) in 1769 Benjamin Franklin published one of the earliest maps of the Gulf Stream (Fig.€1.1).
Fig. 1.1↜渀 Map of the Gulf Stream created by Benjamin Franklin. The Gulf Stream is depicted as the dark gray swath that runs along the east coast of what is now the United States. (Franklin 1769, Courtesy NOAA Photo Library)
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
5
One of the most famous voyages of discovery of this time began in 1768 when HMS Endeavour left Portsmouth, England, under the command of Captain James Cook. Over 10 years Cook led three world-encircling expeditions and mapped many countries, including Australia, New Zealand and the Hawaiian Islands. He was an expert seaman, navigator and scientist who made observations wherever he went. James Rennell and John Purdy wrote the first scientific textbooks about currents in the Atlantic and Indian oceans during the late eighteenth and at the beginning of the nineteenth century (e.g. Rennell and Purdy 1832). The steep slope beyond the continental shelves was not discovered until 1849. Matthew Fontaine Maury’s Physical Geography of the Sea (Fig.€1.2) was the first textbook of oceanography based on his work as superintendant of the Depot of Charts and Instruments of the Navy Department in Washington D.C. (Maury 1855).
Fig. 1.2↜渀 Matthew Maury: “The Physical Geography of the Sea,” which is credited as “the first textbook of modern oceanography.” (Maury 1855)
6
A. Schiller
Fig. 1.3↜渀 Ocean surface currents around Australia from Black and Hall’s Atlas of the World published by A. & C. Black, Edinburgh (1865)
The first comprehensive maps that showed the surface circulation of the global oceans with reasonable accuracy were published by A. and C. Black in 1865 (Fig.€1.3). In 1871, under the recommendations of the Royal Society of London, the British government sponsored an expedition to explore the world’s oceans and conduct scientific investigations. Modern oceanography began with the Challenger Expedition between 1872 and 1876, when Charles Wyville Thompson and Sir John Murray launched the Challenger Expedition. It was the first expedition organized specifically to gather data on a wide range of ocean features, including ocean temperatures, seawater chemistry, currents, marine life, and the geology of the seafloor. They took water samples and temperature measurements, recorded currents and barometric pressures and collected bottom samples. The results of this expedition were published in 50 volumes covering biological, physical and geological aspects (Thompson et€al. 1880–1895). In 1893 Norwegian scientist Fridtjof Nansen allowed his ship Fram to be frozen in the Arctic ice. As a result he was able to collect valuable oceanographic, magnetic, and meteorological information in the Arctic. The rest of his career was equally as distinguished including the invention of a water-sampling bottle that permitted
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
7
isolation of water samples from various depths to measure temperature, salinity and other parameters. Other European and American nations also sent out scientific expeditions (as did private individuals and institutions). The first purpose-built oceanographic ship, the Albatros was built in 1882. The four-month 1910 North Atlantic expedition headed by Sir John Murray and Johan Hjort was at that time the most ambitious research oceanographic and marine zoological project ever, and led to the classic book The Depths of the Ocean (Murray and Hjort 1912). At the beginning of the Age of Modern Oceanography (1900s to mid twentieth century) the first acoustic measurement of sea depth was made in 1914. Between 1925 and 1927 the Meteor expedition surveyed the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and gathered 70,000 ocean depth measurements using an echo sounder. Virtually all civilian ocean research ceased in 1939 with the outbreak of World War II, when scientific resources were mobilised. However, many advances were made in instrumentation, and our understanding of the ocean was greatly improved. For example, there were major advances in predicting wave conditions (important for amphibious invasions). Mapping features of ocean basins was greatly expanded to improve the ability to detect submarines. In 1942, Sverdrup et€al. (1942) published The Ocean which was a major landmark in oceanography. The nineteenth and twentieth century also saw major progress towards quantitative descriptions of observed phenomena. Examples of key areas of progress are (some of which are tightly linked to progress in meteorology): • the rotation of the Earth and associated impact on ocean currents (Coriolis 1835); • the effect of winds on the ocean-atmosphere interface (Ekman 1905); and • the development of vorticity theories and theorems for the ocean as an extension to Newton’s law in a rotating fluid (Ertel 1942; Sverdrup 1947). This enhanced capability to describe the ocean within a mathematical framework allowed the development of numerical models. Consequently, from the 1970s onwards there has been increased emphasis on the application of computers for oceanography to allow numerical simulations and predictions of the state of the ocean. The Mid-Ocean Dynamics Experiment (MODE) was one of the first large-scale and extensively instrumented field experiments carried out by physical oceanographers. Conducted in two phases between November 1971 and July 1973, the experiment explored the role of mesoscale eddy motions in the dynamics of general oceanic circulation (mesoscale eddies are at the centre of attention in today’s largescale ocean forecasting systems). The 1970s and 1980s also saw the development and first applications of socalled inverse methods to oceanographic data (e.g. Wunsch 1978). These methods can be interpreted as simple data assimilation tools that paved the way for the development of more complex data assimilation and model initialization tools used nowadays in ocean forecasting systems and often derived from numerical weather prediction applications.
8
A. Schiller
The Tropical-Ocean-Global-Atmosphere (TOGA) Program began in 1985 and was a ten-year research effort to investigate the global atmospheric response to the coupled ocean-atmosphere forcing from the tropical regions. It was among the first large-scale programs that addressed the predictability of the coupled tropical oceans and global atmosphere by drawing on observations and by recognizing the key role of models for understanding tropical air-sea interactions as a prerequisite for launching successful climate predictions into the future. In the 1980s the TAO/TRITON oceanographic buoy array was established in the Pacific to allow monitoring and ultimately prediction of El Niño events (http:// www.pmel.noaa.gov/tao/proj_over/taohis.html). Enhancements to the in situ and satellite observing system together with the first evolving model lead to the first successful ENSO prediction (Zebiak and Cane 1987). 1990 saw the start of the World Ocean Circulation Experiment (WOCE) which continued until 2002. WOCE was a component of the international World Climate Research Program, and aimed to establish the role of the world ocean in the Earth’s climate system. The WOCE field phase ran between 1990 and 1998 (Fig.€1.4), and was followed by an analysis and modelling phase that ran until 2002. The results are summarised in “Ocean Circulation and Climate: Observing and Modelling the Global Ocean” (Siedler et€al. 2001). Before the 1980s, when satellites became more commonly available, oceanographers were “data poor”. Since then, significant technological and scientific advances in satellite remote sensing provide near-real time measurements of sea surface height anomalies, SST and ocean colour. These key observations have, for the first time, enabled ocean forecasting applications (Fu and Cazenave 2001). The realisation of the network of 3,000 Argo profiling floats freely reporting temperature and salinity profiles to 2,000€m depth in a timely fashion has transformed the in situ ocean measurement network in the new millennia (Fig.€1.5). This allows, for the first time, continuous monitoring of the temperature, salinity, and velocity of the upper ocean, with all data being relayed and made publicly available within hours after collection. Based on significant advances in supercomputing technologies, the 1990s saw the emergence of the first large-scale eddy-resolving models (Semtner and Chervin 1992) and the first ocean-atmosphere coupled climate change projections (see, e.g. IPCC First Assessment Report 1990). More detailed accounts of the history of oceanography can be found in the published literature and, e.g. at http://core.ecu.edu/geology/woods/HISTOCEA.htm.
1.2â•…The Achievements of GODAE (1997–2008) As described in the previous paragraphs, over the last 20 years the global ocean observing system (↜in situ and remote sensing) has been progressively implemented and led to a revolution in the amount of data available for research and forecasting applications. The ocean observing system, primarily designed to serve climate
Fig. 1.4↜渀 WOCE Hydrographic Program One Time Survey (1990–1998) (http://woce.nodc.noaa.gov/wdiu/diu_summaries/whp/figures/whpot.htm)
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century 9
10
A. Schiller
60°N 30°N 0°N 30°S 60°S 60°E
120°E
180°
120°W
60°W
0°
Fig. 1.5↜渀 Status of global Argo float array, December 2009 (http://www.argo.ucsd.edu/)
research, is used as a backbone for most operational oceanography applications. Although significant progress has been made, sustaining the global ocean observing system remains a challenging task (Clark et€al. 2009). This recent progress in the global ocean observing system was complemented by advances in supercomputing technology, allowing the development and operational implementation of eddyresolving (~10€km) basin-scale ocean circulation models. The Global Ocean Data Assimilation Experiment (GODAE) was set up in 1997 with the aims of (i) demonstrating the feasibility and utility of global ocean monitoring and forecasting on the daily to weekly time scale and on eddy-resolving spatial scales and (ii) to assist in building the infrastructure for global operational oceanography (Smith and Lefebvre 1997; GODAE Strategic Plan 2000; Bell et€al. 2009). From its inception in 1997 to its conclusion in 2008, GODAE has had a major impact on the development of global operational oceanography capability. Global modelling and data assimilation systems have been progressively developed, implemented and inter-compared (Dombrowsky et€al. 2009; Cummings et€al. 2009; Hernandez et€al. 2009). In-situ and remote sensing data are now routinely assimilated in global and regional ocean models to provide an integrated description of the ocean state. Observation, analysis and forecast products are readily accessible through major data and product servers (Blower et€al. 2009). There has been increased attention to the development of products and services and the demonstration of their utility for applications such as marine environment monitoring, weather forecasting, seasonal and climate prediction, ocean research, maritime safety and pollution forecasting, national security, the oil and gas industry, fisheries management and coastal and shelf-sea forecasting (Davidson et€al. 2009; Hackett et€al. 2009; Jacobs et€al. 2009). GODAE as an experiment ended in 2008 having achieved most of its goals. It has been demonstrated that global ocean data assimilation is feasible and GODAE has made important contributions to the establishment of an effective and efficient infrastructure for global operational oceanography that includes the required observing systems, data assembly and processing centres, modelling and data assimilation centres and data and product servers.
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
11
1.3â•…Key Future Research Priorities in Ocean Forecasting Although there are still major challenges to face (e.g. completing and sustaining the global ocean observing system being an obvious one), global operational oceanography now needs to transition from a demonstration to a permanent and sustained capability. Operational1 data and products are needed for most applications as well as for climate research. This is critical for applications which cannot develop without operational services. In parallel, continuous improvements of operational oceanography systems are needed to satisfy new requirements (e.g. for coastal zone and ecosystem monitoring and forecasting, climate monitoring).
1.3.1 The Challenges for the Next Decade Most national forecasting centres have or are now transitioning towards operational or pre-operational status. Ocean forecasting systems are also evolving to satisfy new requirements just mentioned and must benefit from scientific advances in ocean modelling and data assimilation. International collaboration and coordination of both operational and research activities related to ocean analysis and forecasting must continue during this sustained operational phase. The challenges and expectations are very demanding and can only be achieved through international collaboration. These main challenges and opportunities for the next decade are summarised below. During the last decade new pressing societal issues to which ocean analysis and forecasting can make substantial contributions have evolved. They are now quite diverse and are not limited to open ocean forecasts (although open ocean forecasts will continue to serve major applications areas). The most important are: • The use of data assimilation to provide integrated descriptions of the global ocean state (reanalyses) and to characterise and detect climate change in the ocean; • The application of ocean prediction techniques to the prediction of climate change (so-called decadal prediction); • The assessment and characterisations of specific sources of uncertainty in downscaling of climate and climate-change scenario simulations and predictions in studies of the impact of climate change in coastal regions (e.g. extreme events, flooding, ecosystems); • The development of improved atmospheric and climate forecasts (near coasts, hurricanes/tropical cyclones, monsoons, seasonal); • Real-time forecasting in near-shore / coastal waters (physics, biogeochemistry and ecosystems) and coupling between open ocean and coastal areas; 1╇ Following the GODAE Strategic Plan (2000), “operational” is used here “whenever the processing is done in a routine and regular way, with a pre-determined systematic approach and constant monitoring of performance. With this terminology, regular re-analyses may be considered as operational systems, as may be organized analyses and assessment of climate data”.
12
A. Schiller
• Ecosystem modelling and the development of ecosystem based management of marine resources (influence of physical transports and processes on marine life, modelling up to high trophic levels); • Marine environment monitoring in support of policies (e.g. European Marine Strategy). Continuous improvement of operational oceanography systems and the development of new capability is needed to address these new societal needs. This demands state-of-the art research leadership and calls for dedicated cooperation with international research programs such as CLIVAR, GEOTRACES, SOLAS and IMBER2. In the following paragraphs we address some of the main research topics that operational oceanography faces: high resolution physical modelling, downscaling, biogeochemical and ecosystem modelling, ocean-wave-atmosphere coupling, data assimilation and coupled data assimilation, error estimates, long-term reanalyses and use of new observations. Major developments in the decade will see a maturing of eddy-resolving dataassimilating models, and a stronger integration into coupled numerical weather prediction and climate modelling.
1.3.2 Ocean Modelling The science about turbulent closure schemes is now fairly mature, but there may still be surprises associated with subtle aspects of vertical mixing in the deep ocean that may have important consequences on long time scales. Vertical mixing is also critically important for biogeochemical cycles, because it controls the return of nutrients to the surface euphotic zone, and therefore the magnitude of primary production. Another area where there still is room for improvement concerns the exchanges of heat, momentum and freshwater across the ocean surface. Accuracy, resolution, and extent (in time ahead) of wind forecasts are the primary limiting factors for sea-state and surge forecasting. Likewise, sea surface heat exchange is clearly a determining factor in forecasting ocean mixed-layer depth and ice formation. In both cases, the need for dynamically coupled ocean-wave-iceatmosphere models is an essential element to improve atmospheric forcing. Coastal ocean modelling and forecasting is a major challenge for the scientific community because of the specific and rich dynamics of those regions, and because of the various couplings with the lower atmosphere and exchanges with the near-shore and offshore regions. These issues, needs and challenges have led to the development of a wide range of models of various types. Phenomena of interest include coastal current interactions, coastal meso-scale, tides and storm surges, 2╇ CLIVAR╛=╛World Climate Research Program (WCRP) project that addresses Climate Variability and Predictability. IMBER╛=╛Integrated Marine Biogeochemistry and Ecosystem Research; GEOTRACES╛=╛International study of the global marine biogeochemical cycles of trace elements and their isotopes; SOLAS╛=╛Surface Ocean Lower Atmosphere Study.
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
13 14
60 N
13 58 N 12 56 N 11 52 N 10 50 N 9
48 N
8
44 N
12 W 10 W 8 W
6W
4W 2W
0E
7 °C
Fig. 1.6↜渀 Application of the 2-way grid-refinement software AGRIF to the Bay of Biscay, tested in the framework of the MERSEA project (Cailleau et al. 2008). The large-scale model is a 1/3° (Mercator grid) North Atlantic configuration of the NEMO Ocean general circulation model. The fine-scale model is regional configuration of NEMO at a resolution of 1/15° (Mercator grid). Both models are run simultaneously and interactively for years of simulation on either vector or massively parallel super computers. The computational surcharge induced by the 2-way coupling of the grids is very small (just a few percent). The regional model benefits from the smooth and regular behaviour of the large-scale model at its open boundaries. On longer time-scales, the largescale model benefits from the local improvements brought by the high resolution to the representation of the dynamics in the Bay of Biscay, especially the slope current. The above figure displays a sea surface temperature snapshot on 22 March 1996. One shall notice the fine-scale and the intense eddy field of the fine-grid model, but also the continuity at the limit between the two grids
tsunamis, shoreline change, coastal upwelling, river plumes and regions of freshwater influence, atmosphere-driven processes, surface waves, and sea ice (Fig.€1.6). Coastal ocean systems can have very high spatial gradients in both the vertical and horizontal, especially near river mouths, requiring the use in models of sophisticated mixing schemes, and high order numerics. The key constraints on the accuracy of these models now lie with the specification of input data (bathymetry, bottom roughness, lateral and surface forcing). In these shallow systems, and especially along exposed shorelines, wave-current interactions play an important role. Measuring and predicting exchanges between the underlying sediment and the water
14
A. Schiller
column is critical for coastal biogeochemistry, and is still a key challenge. Sediment models attempt to represent the effects of re-suspension and deposition of particulate material, and their interaction with the circulation, on suspended concentrations (turbidity, important for optical properties and hence primary production) and bed thickness and composition (geomorphology). Models of these processes are still under active development. With respect to biological processes, we are faced with the general problem of biogeochemical and ecosystem modelling (used here synonymously); namely, choosing the right level of abstraction and approximation in describing and predicting the structure and function of a complex system with many nested levels of complexity.
1.3.3 Initialisation and Forecasting There are still some significant challenges in the data-assimilation techniques themselves, and one can expect to see significant improvement there. The assimilation of observations into present-day ocean models is still far from being optimal. Improved estimates of the state of the physical ocean, marine ecosystems and oceanatmosphere interactions will rely upon new cross-cutting research directions in terms of both methods and operational implementations. In meteorology (the history of which predates the evolution of ocean forecasting), the implementation of data assimilation methodology has followed a progressive pace starting with optimal interpolation, followed by sequential approaches and today most larger NWP centres are increasingly investing in 4D-VAR variational approaches with a noticeable increase in interest in ensemble approaches. Operational oceanography is today at the stage of applying sequential approaches but variational methodologies are on the verge of being used, at least for seasonal forecast applications. Because of the specificities of oceanography (e.g. the mesoscale non-linearities) it is still unclear whether 4D-VAR is fully applicable (Luong et€ al. 1998) and further research must be undertaken in this direction. A promising way might be the hybridisation between variational and sequential approaches thus combining advantages of both methodologies (Robert et€al. 2006). However, 4D-VAR systems have not been comprehensively tested for highly non-linear applications. For instance, as we move to higher resolution and longer predictive time scales, the assumptions that underpin VAR systems (e.g. linearity in tangent-linear models) become less valid. The development of data assimilation into physical coastal ocean models has lagged behind its development in basin-scale models, and is still in its infancy. Current methods need to be tested and enhanced for coastal applications. Data assimilation in coastal models has a vital role to play, not only as a tool to provide short-term forecasts, but more importantly for the rigour it brings to the analysis of model error, and to the design of observing systems (see the CSSWG White Paper, De Mey et€al. 2007 for a detailed account).
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
15
Biogeochemical modelling and data assimilation are much less mature than physical modelling. Consequently, there is a strong need for both on-going development and validation of biogeochemical and, ultimately, ecosystem models. The impact of the physical models on the accuracy of the ecosystem models is of particular importance (e.g. Berline et€al. 2007). High horizontal and vertical resolution physical models are required to resolve the physical features that are critical to the ecosystem. Errors in physical models are problematic and can render outputs from ecosystem models meaningless. Vertical velocities are a particular example as they are critical for nutrient transport. In coastal areas correct representation of optical depth is also critical for primary production (Fig.€1.7). This requires accurate suspended sediment concentrations. These requirements for accuracy present a challenge for physical models. A major trend in environmental research in the coming decade will see the development of the next generation weather, climate, and Earth system monitoring, assessment, data-assimilation, and prediction systems (Shapiro et€al. 2008). These
Fig. 1.7↜渀 MODIS image of ocean colour off Australian NW shelf. The figure illustrates the complex processes acting in the coastal zone due to blending of different time/ space scales (e.g. ocean-shelf topographic interaction). Forecasting systems operating in such complex environments require sophisticated multi-scale (nested) models and scale-sensitive observing systems for accurate initialization (Courtesy: CSIRO Marine and Atmospheric Research)
16
A. Schiller
systems will no longer focus on individual components of the Earth system (such as the oceans) but aim at treating the complex physical and biogeochemical components as one system. Coupled data assimilation means that observations in one medium impact the state of the other medium. In 4D-VAR fully coupled assimilation means simultaneous minimization of the cost function of the component models, e.g. atmosphere and ocean. An example of a less complex system is coupled ocean-atmosphere modelling. Ultimately truly coupled physical-biogeochemical initialization systems need to be developed, whereby the ocean, sea-ice, land surface, and atmosphere are initialized in unison. Consequently, a key challenge in data assimilation over the next decade will be the development of data assimilation techniques for Earth system modelling that are fit-for-purpose for a wide range of applications, including ocean-atmosphere weather forecasting, seasonal-to-decadal and climate change prediction.
1.3.4 The Global Ocean Observing System Over the last 10 years, a global ocean observing system (↜in situ and remote sensing) has been progressively implemented. The system, primarily designed to serve climate research, is used as a backbone for most operational oceanography applications. Although significant progress has been made (e.g. Argo and Jason are outstanding successes), sustaining the global ocean observing system remains a challenging task (Freeland et€al. 2010; Wilson et€al. 2010). There is also a pressing need to develop further regional and coastal components and, as discussed above, to extend the measurement capabilities to biogeochemical parameters. This endeavour is clearly beyond the scope of ocean analysis and forecasting teams and involves major international programs or intergovernmental organizations (e.g. WMO and IOC through JCOMM, GOOS and GCOS, GEOSS, CEOS) and research programs (e.g. WCRP, IGBP and SOLAS)3. Nowadays, use is made of observations from satellites, autonomous floats, onshore devices (radar, tide gauges etc.), off-shore moorings, aircraft, AUVs (Autonomous Underwater Vehicles), VOS (Voluntary Observing Ships) and more. Especially in the coastal zone more and better observational data, extending over longer periods, are essential if modelling accuracy and capabilities are to be enhanced (Malone et€al. 2010). International collaboration is an obvious and valuable means of achieving this goal. While international funding supports some satellite programs (although most of these are still regarded as non-operational), synergistic in situ monitoring presently relies on national funding. Examples are the Argo profiling 3╇ WMO╛=╛World Meteorological Organisation; IOC╛=╛Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission; JCOMM╛=╛Joint Committee for Oceanography and Marine Meteorology; GOOS╛=╛Global Ocean Observing System; GCOS╛=╛Global Climate Observing System; GEOSS╛=╛Global Earth Observation System of Systems; CEOS╛=╛Committee on Earth Observation Satellites; WCRP╛=╛World Climate Research Program; IGBP╛=╛International Geosphere-Biosphere Program.
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
17
Fig. 1.8↜渀 Liverpool Bay Coastal Observatory in the Irish sea, indicating simultaneous multiparameter measurements and satellite AVHRR sea surface temperatures. (Courtesy Roger Proctor, Proudman Oceanographic Laboratory, UK)
floats, the TAO/TRITON array in the Pacific (USA and Japan), the PIRATA array in the Atlantic (France, USA and Brazil) and the IndOOS array in the Indian Ocean (India, USA and Japan). These basin-scale observing systems are subject to international coordination whereas design and implementation of coastal ocean observing systems are largely the responsibility of individual national efforts (Fig.€1.8). Despite the limited progress in implementing ocean biogeochemical observing systems there is an increasing user pull for enhanced ocean forecasting capability that includes information about physics, biogeochemistry and ultimately ecosystem components. The biogeochemical and physical systems interact on a variety of processes and scales. Most notable is the impact of biology and associated attenuation depth of light on solar shortwave penetration and thus mixed-layer depth, and the corollary, the impact of suspended material on light scattering and penetration and biological production. Consequently, joint assimilation of physical and ecosystem observations likely will benefit both components though the challenges involved are manifold.
1.3.5 Observing System Design and Adaptive Sampling Ocean analysis and forecasting systems are an appropriate and powerful means to assess the impact of the observing system, to identify gaps and to improve the efficiency/effectiveness of the observing system. An enhanced focus on observing system design and adaptive sampling in data assimilating systems will allow as-
18
A. Schiller
sessments of individual components of the observing system and provide scientific guidance for improved design and implementation of the ocean observing system. OSEs (Observing System Evaluation) assess the impact of existing individual components of the observing system on forecast skills, whereas OSSEs (Observing System Simulation Experiments) are tools for planning new observing systems. OSEs undertaken during GODAE demonstrate that global and regional forecast systems strongly depend on the availability of high resolution altimeter data (e.g. Pascual et€al. 2006). Significant degradation of the performance of these forecasting systems (e.g. forecast skill) and applications (e.g. offshore industry in the Gulf of Mexico) was thus observed when the number of available altimeters was reduced from three to two due to the unavailability of ENVISAT data. OSSEs in the Indian Ocean have provided an estimate of the respective contribution of Argo, XBT and moorings to the observing system in the Indian Ocean (e.g. Sakov and Oke 2008). These are extremely valuable tools to develop an improved understanding of the ocean and to help the design of global and regional observing systems. While OSEs and OSSEs provide an integrated, but methodology-dependent, performance assessment of an observational array, recently proposed approaches based on the representer matrix spectrum (e.g. Hénaff et€al. 2008) focus on the capacity of a given array to detect model errors. This can be achieved independently of any data assimilation method, e.g. from stochastic modelling, or as part of an Ensemble Kalman Filter. An evolving method for optimising observing arrays is adaptive sampling (e.g. Wilkin et€al. 2005). The key idea of adaptive sampling is that the initial estimate or observation can detect correlations in the environment, providing information about the number of future observing platforms needed or to specify the frequency and spatial distribution required for future sampling certain features in the environment (e.g. eddies, fronts etc.). Thus, adaptive sampling can save costs compared to dense, non-adaptive sampling, and, simultaneously, provide high-resolution information where needed.
1.4â•…Scientific Objectives of GODAE OceanView The GODAE OceanView Science Team (GOVST) was established in 2008, with the mission to define, monitor, and promote actions aimed at coordinating and integrating research associated with multi-scale and multidisciplinary ocean analysis and forecasting systems, thus enhancing the value of GODAE OceanView outputs for research and applications. Over the next decade, the science team will provide international coordination and leadership in: • The consolidation and improvement of global and regional analysis and physical forecasting systems. • The progressive development and scientific testing of the next generation of ocean analysis and forecasting systems, covering biogeochemical and ecosys-
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
19
tems as well as physical oceanography, and extending from the open ocean into the shelf sea and coastal waters. • The exploitation of this capability in other applications (weather forecasting, seasonal and decadal prediction, climate change detection and its coastal impacts). • The assessment of the contribution of the various components of the observing system and scientific guidance for improved design and implementation of the ocean observing system. Members as representatives of national ocean forecasting systems of GODAE OceanView adhere to the same principles of free, open and timely exchange of data and products, sharing of scientific results and experience developing applications which were important factors in the success of GODAE. The societal benefits from these systems will only be realised through joint work with other teams of experts. Potential benefits include improvements in the day-to-day management of coastal waters, the management of marine ecosystems, weather prediction from hours to decades ahead, and the expected impacts of climate change on the oceans and coastal waters. The GOVST develops linkages with other groups and reports on its progresses, achievements and recommendations. As GODAE prototype systems transition to operational systems, international collaboration on product standardization and interoperability between systems must be maintained and developed. The WMO/IOC Joint Technical Commission for Oceanography and Marine Meteorology (JCOMM) provides an appropriate intergovernmental mechanism for the coordinating role and has recently established an Expert Team on Operational Oceanographic Forecasting Systems (ET-OOFS) within its Services Program Area for this purpose. GODAE OceanView informally reports to JCOMM and has strong links with JCOMM ETOOFS. GODAE OceanView coordinates the development of new capabilities, in cooperation with other relevant international research programs, through a number of task teams. The initial list of GODAE OceanView Task Teams includes: • Intercomparison and Validation Task Team: The team pursues activities developed during GODAE. It coordinates and promotes the development of scientific validation and intercomparison of operational oceanography systems. Activities include the definition of metrics to assess the quality of analyses and forecasts (e.g. forecast skills) both for physical and biogeochemical parameters and the setting up of specific global and regional intercomparison experiments. Metrics related to specific applications are also defined. The team liaises with the JCOMM ET-OOFS team for operational implementation. • Observing System Evaluation Task Team: One of the aims of GODAE OceanView is to formulate more specific requirements for observations on the basis of improved understanding of data utility. The team is jointly formed by GODAE OceanView and the GOOS Ocean Observations Panel for Climate (OOPC). Through the task team, GODAE OceanView
20
•
•
A. Schiller
and OOPC partners get organized at the international level to provide consistent and scientifically justified responses to agencies and organizations in charge of sustaining the global and regional ocean observing systems used for ocean monitoring and forecasting at short-range, seasonal and decadal time-scales. This activity requires harmonized protocols for observation impact assessment (e.g. OSEs and OSSEs), tools for routine production of appropriate diagnostics using NWP-derived methods, common sets of metrics for intercomparison of results, and objective methodologies which can be used to provide recommendations to the appropriate agencies and organizations. In the longer term consideration will need to be given to an evaluation strategy for identifying observing system requirements for different, possibly user-specific, applications. Coastal Ocean and Shelf Seas Task Team: This task team deals with scientific issues in support of multidisciplinary analysis and forecasting of the coastal transition zone and shelf/open ocean exchanges in relation with the larger-scale efforts. The specific objectives include: (1) discuss and promote the uses of GODAE OceanView products and results for coastal ocean forecasting systems and for coastal applications in a wider community; (2) discuss and foster integration of the varied routine sources of information in coastal ocean forecasting systems: large-scale forecasts, satellite observations, coastal observatories, etc.; discuss and support the development of coastal observing systems in terms of science and technology; (3) discuss the key physical and biogeochemical processes which have the greatest impact on modeling and forecasting quality and their utility for applications; this includes validation and forecast verification; (4) discuss and promote state-of-the-art methodology such as two-way coupling, unstructured-grid modeling, downscaling, data assimilation and array design. Marine Ecosystem Monitoring and Prediction Task Team: The integration of new models and assimilation components for ocean biogeochemistry and marine ecosystem monitoring and prediction will be required to bridge the gap between the current status and new applications in areas such as fisheries management, marine pollution and carbon cycle monitoring. The Task Team has been set up with the goal to define, promote and coordinate actions between developers of operational systems and ecosystem modelling experts, in tight connection with IMBER. The objectives of the task team are (1) to design appropriate ecosystem modelling and assimilation strategies that will be compatible with the functionalities of operational systems; (2) to develop numerical experiments aimed at improving, assessing and demonstrating the value of operational products for marine ecosystem monitoring and prediction; (3) to expand the concept of the “GODAE metrics” to biogeochemical variables and to coordinate intercomparison exercises across international groups to assess implementation progress and performances; (4) to identify the essential sets of physical and biogeochemical observations required to constrain the coupled models and to formulate relevant recommendations to further develop the global ocean observing system; (5) to promote and organise educational activities (summer schools, training workshops, etc.) aimed at sharing experience between young
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
21
scientists, operational oceanographers and marine ecosystem experts. In addition to the link with IMBER, the task team articulates its activities with other relevant international programs such as GEOTRACES and SOLAS.
1.5â•…Summary and Conclusions Over the past 40 years, numerical modelling has developed rapidly in scope (from hydrodynamics to ecology) and resolution (from one-dimensional, 102 elements to three-dimensional, 108 elements) exploiting the contemporaneous development of computing power. Although we have made significant progress with the implementation of the global ocean observing system, concurrent development in observational capabilities has not been achieved yet in areas demanding high spatial resolution such as coastal domains (despite exciting advances in areas such as in remote sensing and sensor technologies). Nowadays, diverse applications involving ocean forecasting systems range from short term prediction of the three-dimensional circulation and density fields, waves, tides and storm surges to coupled ocean-atmosphere-land scenario forecasting of the effects of global climate change on terrestrial, fluvial and ecology over millennia. The accuracy of model simulations depends on the availability and suitability (accuracy, resolution and duration) of both observational and linked meteorological, oceanic and hydrological model data to set-up, force, and assess calculations. Modelling is at a stage where major and sustained investments are required in infrastructure and organisation: e.g. access to supercomputers, software maintenance and data exchange (Shapiro et€al. 2008). Many research approaches developed under GODAE are just at their beginning and will require ongoing international research collaboration and coordination. There are still many challenges related to the development of services and links with end users (which are beyond the scope of this chapter). On the scientific side, many of the fundamental modelling issues that were evoked in the book edited by Chassignet and Verron (1998) are still unresolved. They represent new challenges and require step changes to our current efforts. An incomplete list of scientific challenges follows: • Ocean modeling (for a more comprehensive list about ocean modelling issues see Griffies et€al. 2010): − Mesoscale eddying models can exhibit numerical diapycnal diffusion far larger than is observed. Spurious diapycnal mixing originating from numerical advection remains an issue, with consequences of variable and/or eddyresolving resolutions and dynamical meshes largely unexplored. Reducing the level of spurious diapycnal mixing in models facilitates collaborative efforts to incorporate mixing theories into simulations, which in turn helps to focus observational efforts to measure mixing and determine its impact on ocean circulation. Progress has been made to rectify this problem through improve-
22
A. Schiller
−
−
−
−
−
ments to tracer advection schemes, but further work is needed to quantify these advances. Largely unexplored areas of research involve the local scaling of viscosity and diffusivity coefficients. Lateral viscous friction remains the default approach for closing the momentum equation in ocean models. However, large levels of lateral viscous dissipation used by models do not mimic energy dissipation in the real ocean. The ocean floor should be represented continuously across finely resolve mesh regions to faithfully simulate topographically influenced flows. This property is routinely achieved with terrain following vertical coordinates, yet optimal strategies for unstructured mesh models remain under investigation. Large-scale ocean-waves-atmosphere coupling remains an area of active research. While wind-induced surface waves contribute primarily to mixing through generation of internal waves at the ocean surface, geostrophic motions may also sustain wave induced interior mixing. In addition, tidal waves can affect the whole water column. Submesoscale fronts and related instabilities are ubiquitous, and those active in the upper ocean provide a relatively rapid restratification mechanism that should be parameterized in ocean simulations, even those resolving the mesoscale. The coupling between physical, biogeochemical and ecosystem models in terms of consistency of scales, processes resolved and consistent parameterisations requires further research.
• Observing systems: − The exploration of impact of new types of observations on forecasting systems (e.g. remotely sensed sea surface salinity, high resolution wide swath altimetry) requires dedicated efforts and resources. − In collaboration with international programs such as IMBER and SOLAS research is under way on the implementation of real-time biogeochemical and ecosystem ocean observing systems, e.g. cost-effective sensor-technologies. − An enhanced focus on observing system design and its analogue of adaptive sampling will allow assessments of individual components of the observing system and provide scientific guidance for improved design and implementation of the ocean observing system. • Data assimilation: − Development of data assimilation tools such as coupled atmosphere-ocean initialisation techniques that are fit-for-purpose for a wide range of applications, including short-range, seasonal-to-decadal and climate change prediction (in collaboration with WMO programs) is work-in-progress. − Efficient data assimilation techniques for biogeochemical and ecosystem modules of ocean circulation models are being developed that are fit for operational purposes.
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
23
− Another research focus is the representation of model and data errors using ensemble methods based on various forecasting systems thus delivering more accurate background error estimates. − Multi-scale data assimilation and joint estimation of interior and open boundary solutions in nested systems remain largely unresolved. • Coastal ocean: − Users increasingly demand an extension of the critical path of routinelyavailable global information (satellite and in-situ observations, nowcasts and forecasts) to coastal and littoral applications. − A prerequisite for an enhanced user uptake of coastal ocean forecasts are enhancements to existing systems and development of new coastal ocean forecasting systems that downscale (and upscale, i.e. two-way coupling) the global basin-wide model estimates as part of the local data assimilation problem, resolving the rich scale interactions, tides and high frequencies, and experimenting novel approaches such as coupled modelling and unstructured grid modeling. − These forecasting tools will need to be able to contribute to the objective design of observing systems for the coastal ocean, such as new satellite sensors, coastal observatories, etc.; use of such observations in the local forecasting system and upscaling of the information to the basin-scale systems. Consequently, ocean forecasting in the twenty-first century still faces many challenges with time scales ranging from weather to climate. It is inherently an international issue, requiring broad collaboration to span the global oceans; it is beyond the capability of any one country. Over the past decade, GODAE through its International GODAE Steering Team (IGST) has coordinated and facilitated the development of global and regional ocean forecasting systems and has made excellent progress. GODAE as an experiment has ended in 2008. The next decade will spawn new research activities in ocean forecasting under the auspices of the GODAE OceanView Science Team that will build on the success of GODAE. GODAE OceanView will promote the development of ocean modelling and assimilation in a consistent framework to optimize mutual progress and benefit. It will promote the associated utilization of improved ocean analyses and forecasts and will provide a means to assess the relative contributions of and requirements for observing systems, and their respective priorities. The GODAE OceanView programme will result in the long-term international collaboration and cooperation that is required for the next, sustained, phase of operational oceanography in the twenty-first century. The grand vision and key research challenge is to develop coupled initialisation systems of numerical weather prediction and eddy-resolving ocean models. These systems will contribute to and benefit from recent progress in Earth systems modelling. With increasing computing resources the next decade is also likely to see an even stronger emphasis on “seamless” integrations across time and space scales,
24
A. Schiller
covering global, regional and coastal/near-shore ocean prediction systems and addressing an increasing number of user applications. Acknowledgements╇ This paper was written with inputs from the former members of the GODAE International Science Team, and, more recently, the members of the GODAE OceanView Science Team and their Patrons groups. The author would like to particularly thank Pierres-Yves Le Traon, Mike Bell, Eric Dombrowsky, Kirsten Wilmer-Becker, Pierre Brasseur, Pierre De Mey, Roger Proctor, Jacques Verron, Peter Oke and John Parslow for their contributions through many discussions on issues of relevance to this paper.
References Bell MJ, Lefèbvre M, Le Traon P-Y, Smith N, Wilmer-Becker K (2009) GODAE: the global ocean data assimilation experiment. Oceanog Mag 22(3):14–21 (Special issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Berline L, Brankart JM, Brasseur P, Ourmières Y, Verron J (2007) Improving the physics of a coupled physical–biogeochemical model of the North Atlantic through data assimilation: impact on the ecosystem. J Mar Syst 64(1–4):153–172 Black A, Hall S (1865) Black’s general atlas of the world. A&C Black, Edinburgh Blower JD, Blanc F, Clancy M, Cornillon P, Donlon C, Hacker P, Haines K, Hankin SC, Loubrieu T, Pouliquen S, Price M, Pugh TF, Srinivasan A (2009) Serving GODAE data and products to the ocean community. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):70–79 (Special issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Cailleau S, Fedorenko V, Barnier B, Blayo E, Debreu L (2008) Comparison of different numerical methods used to handle the open boundary of a regional ocean circulation model of the Bay of Biscay. Ocean Model 25(1–2):1–16. doi:10.1016/j.ocemod.2008.05.009 Chassignet EP, Verron J (1998) Ocean modeling and parameterization. In: Chassignet EP, Verron J (eds) Proceedings of the NATO advanced study Institute on ocean modeling and parameterization, Kluwer Acadamic, Dordrecht, p€451. Les Houches, France, 20–30 Jan 1998 (NATO ASI Series C, 516) Clark C, In Situ Observing System Authors, Wilson S, Satellite Observing System Authors (2009) An overview of global observing systems relevant to GODAE. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):22–33 (Special issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Coriolis G (1835) Memoire sur le equations du movement relative des systems de corps. J de l’Ecole Royale Polytechnique 15:142 Cummings J, Bertino L, Brasseur P, Fukumori I, Kamachi M, Martin MJ, Mogensen K, Oke P, Testut CE, Verron J, Weaver A (2009) Ocean Data Asimilation Systems for GODAE. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):96–109 (Special issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Davidson FJM, Allen A, Brassington GB, Breivik Ø, Daniel P, Kamachi M, Sato S, King B, Lefevre F, Sutton M, Kaneko H (2009) Applications of GODAE ocean current forecasts to search and rescue and ship routing. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):176–181 (Special issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) De Mey P, Craig P, Kindle J, Ishikawa Y, Proctor R, Thompson K, Zhu J (2007) Towards the assessment and demonstration of the value of GODAE results for coastal and shelf seas and forecasting systems. GODAE White Paper, GODAE Coastal and Shelf Seas Working Group (CSSWG), 2nd ed, p€79 Dombrowsky E, Bertino L, Brassington GB, Chassignet EP, Davidson F, Hurlburt HE, Kamachi M, Lee T, Martin MJ, Mei S, Tonani M (2009) GODAE systems in operation. Oceanogr
1â•… Ocean Forecasting in the 21st Century
25
Mag 22(3):80–95 (Special Issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Ekman VW (1905) On the influence of the earth’s rotation on ocean currents. Arkiv för Matematik. Astronomi och Fysik 2(11):52 Ertel H (1942) Ein neuer hydrodynamischer Erhaltungssatz. Naturwissenschaften 30:543–544 Franklin B (1786) A letter from Dr. Benjamin Franklin, to Mr. Alphonsus le Roy, member of several academies at Paris. Containing sundry maritime observations. At sea, on board the London packet, Capt. Truxton, August 1785. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, held at Philadelphia, for Promoting Useful Knowledge II: 294–329. Includes chart and diagrams. Held by NOAA Central Library, Silver Spring, MD Freeland H et€al (2010) Argo—a decade of progress. In: Hall J, Harrison DE & Stammer D (eds) Proceedings of OceanObs’09: sustained Ocean Observations and Information for Society, vol€2, Venice, Italy, 21–25 Sept 2009. ESA Publication WPP-306 Fu LL, Cazenave A (2001) Satellite altimetry and earth sciences. A handbook of techniques and applications. Academic, San Diego Griffies S et€al (2010) Problems and prospects in large-scale ocean circulation models. In: Hall J, Harrison DE & Stammer D (eds) Proceedings of OceanObs’09: sustained Ocean observations and information for society, vol€2, Venice, Italy, 21–25 Sept 2009. ESA Publication WPP-306 Hackett B, Comerma E, Daniel P, Ichikawa H (2009) Marine oil pollution prediction. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):168–175 (Special Issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Hernandez F, Bertino L, Brassington G, Chassignet E, Cummings J, Davidson F, Drévillon M, Garric G, Kamachi M, Lellouche J-M, Mahdon R, Martin MJ, Ratsimandresy A, Regnier C (2009) Validation and intercomparison studies with GODAE. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):128–143 (Special Issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) € International GODAE Steering Team (2000) The Global Ocean Data Assimilation Experiment Strategic Plan, GODAE Report No. 6 IPCC First Assessment Report (1990) Scientific Assessment of Climate Change—Report of Working Group I, 1, Houghton JT, Jenkins GJ, Ephraums JJ (eds) Cambridge University Press, UK, p€365 Jacobs GA, Woodham R, Jourdan D, Braithwaite J (2009) GODAWE applications useful to Navies throughout the World. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):182–189 (Special Issue on the Revolution of Global Ocean Forecasting—GODAE: 10 years of achievement) Le Hénaff M, De Mey P, Marsaleix P (2008) Assessment of observational networks with the Representer Matrix Spectra method—application to a 3-D coastal model of the Bay of Biscay. Ocean Dyn 59(1):3–20 (Special Issue, 2007 GODAE Coastal and Shelf Seas Workshop, Liverpool, UK) Luong B, Blum J, Verron J (1998) A variational method for the resolution of a data assimilation problem in oceanography. Inverse Probl 14:979–997 Malone T, DiGiacomo P, Muelbert J, Parslow J, Sweijd N, Yanagi T, Yap H, Blanke B (2010) Building a global system of systems for the coastal ocean. In: Hall J, Harrison DE, Stammer D (eds) Proceedings of OceanObs’09: sustained ocean observations and information for society, vol€2, Venice, Italy, 21–25 Sept 2009. ESA Publication WPP-306 Maury MF (1855) Physical geography of the sea. Harper & Brothers, New York Murray JS, Hjort J (1912) The depths of the ocean: a general account of the modern science of oceanography based largely on the scientific researches of The Norwegian Steamer Michael Sars in The North Atlantic. Macmillan, London Pascual A, Faugere Y, Larnicol G, Le Traon P-Y (2006) Improved description of the ocean mesoscale by combining four satellite altimeters. Geophys Res Lett 33:L02611. doi:10.1029/2005GL024633 Rennell J, Purdy J (1832) An investigation of the currents of the Atlantic Ocean, and of those which prevail between the Indian Ocean and the Atlantic. In: Purdy J (ed). Nabu Press, London
26
A. Schiller
Robert C, Blayo E, Verron J (2006) Comparison of reduced-order sequential, variational and hybrid data assimilation methods in the context of a tropical Pacific ocean model. Ocean Dyn 56(5–6):624–633 Sakov P, Oke PR (2008) Objective array design: application to the tropical Indian Ocean. J Atmos Ocean Technol 25:794–807 Semtner AJ, Chervin RM (1992) Ocean general circulation from a global eddy resolving model. J Geophys Res 97:5493–5550 Shapiro M, Shukla J, Hoskins B, Church J, Trenberth K, Béland M, Brasseur G, Wallace M, McBean G, Caughey J, Rogers D, Brunet G, Barrie L, Henderson-Sellers A, Burridge D, Nakazawa T, Miller M, Bougeault P, Anthes R, Toth Z, Palmer T (2008) The socioeconomic and environmental benefits of a revolution in weather, climate and earth-system prediction: a weather, climate and earth-system prediction project for the 21st century. Group on earth observations, Tudor Rose, Geneva, pp€136–138 Siedler G, Church J, Gould J (eds) (2001) Ocean circulation and climate: observing and modelling the Global Ocean. Academic Press, San Diego Smith N, Lefebvre M (1997) Monitoring the oceans in the 2000s: an integrated approach The Global Ocean Data Assimilation Experiment (GODAE). International Symposium, Biarritz Sverdrup HU, Johnson MW, Fleming RH (1942) The oceans: their physics, chemistry, and general biology. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, p€1087 Sverdrup HU (1947) Wind-driven currents in a Baroclinic Ocean; with application to the equatorial currents of the Eastern Pacific. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 33:318–326 Thompson Sir Wyville, Sir John Murray, George S. Nares, and Frank Tourle Thompson (1880– 1895) Report on the scientific results of the voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873–76 under the command of Captain George S. Nares, R.N., F.R.S. and the late Captain Frank Tourle Thomson, R.N./prepared under the superintendence of the late Sir C. Wyville Thompson, and now of John Murray; published by order of Her majesty’s Government. H.M. Stationery Office Wilkin JL, Arango HG, Haidvogel DB, Lichtenwalner CS, Glenn SM, Hedstrom KS (2005) A regional ocean modeling system for the long-term ecosystem observatory. J Geophys Res 110, C06S91. doi:10.1029/2003JC002218 Wilson S, et€al (2010) Ocean surface topography Constellation: the next 15 years in satellite altimetry. In: Hall J, Harrison DE, Stammer D (eds) Proceedings of OceanObs’09: sustained ocean observations and information for society, vol€ 2, Venice, 21–25 Sept 2009. ESA Publication WPP-306 Wunsch (1978) The North Atlantic general circulation west of 50°W determined by inverse methods. Rev GeophysSpace Phys 6(4):583–620 Zebiak SE, Cane MA (1987) A model of El Nino—southern oscillation. Mon Weath Rev 115:2262– 2278
Part II
Oceanographic Observing System
Chapter 2
Satellites and Operational Oceanography Pierre-Yves Le Traon
Abstract╇ The chapter starts with an overview of satellite oceanography, its role and use for operational oceanography. Main principles of satellite oceanography techniques are then summarized. We then describe key techniques of radar altimetry, sea surface temperature, ocean colour satellite measurements. This includes measurement principles, data processing issues and the use of these data for operational oceanography. SAR, scatterometry, sea ice and sea surface salinity measurements are also briefly described. Main prospects are given in the conclusion.
2.1â•…Introduction There are very strong links between satellite oceanography and operational oceanography. The development of operational oceanography has been mainly driven by the development of satellite oceanography capabilities. The ability to observe the global ocean in near real time at high space and time resolution is indeed a prerequisite to the development of global operational oceanography and its applications. The first ocean parameter to be globally monitored from space was the sea surface temperature on board meteorological satellites in the late 1970s. It is, however, the advent of satellite altimetry in the late 1980s that led the development of ocean data assimilation and global operational oceanography. In addition to providing all weather observations, sea level from satellite altimetry is an integral of the ocean interior and provides a strong constraint on the 4D ocean state estimation. The satellite altimetry community was also keen to develop further the use of altimetry and this required an integrated approach merging satellite and in-situ observations with models. GODAE demonstration was thus phased with the Jason-1 and ENVISAT altimeter missions (Smith and Lefebvre 1997). Satellite oceanography is now a major component of operational oceanography. Data are usually assimilated in ocean models but they can also be used directly for P.-Y. Le Traon () IFREMER, Centre de Brest, Technopôle Brest Iroise BP70, 29280 Plouzané, France e-mail:
[email protected] A. Schiller, G. B. Brassington (eds.), Operational Oceanography in the 21st Century, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-0332-2_2, ©Â€Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011
29
30
P.-Y. Le Traon
applications. An overview of satellite oceanography will be given here focusing on the most relevant issues for operational oceanography. The chapter is organized a follows. Section€2.2 provides an overview of satellite oceanography, its role and use for operational oceanography. Main operational oceanography requirements are summarized. The complementary role of in-situ observations is also emphasized. Main principles of satellite oceanography and general data processing issues are described in Sect.€2.3. We then detail key techniques of radar altimetry and gravimetry, sea surface temperature, ocean colour satellite measurements in Sects.€2.4, 2.5 and 2.6. This includes measurement principles, data processing issues and the use of these data for operational oceanography. SAR, scatterometry, sea ice and the new sea surface salinity measurements are briefly described in Sect.€2.7. Main prospects are given in the conclusion.
2.2╅Role of Satellites for Operational Oceanography 2.2.1 T he Global Ocean Observing System and Operational Oceanography Operational oceanography critically depends on the near real time availability of high quality in-situ and remote sensing data with a sufficiently dense space and time sampling. The quantity, quality and availability of data sets directly impact the quality of ocean analyses and forecasts and associated services. Observations are required to constrain ocean models through data assimilation and also to validate them. Products derived from the data themselves can also be directly used for applications (e.g. in the case of a parameter observed from space at high resolution). This requires an adequate and sustained global ocean observing system. Climate and operational oceanography applications share the same backbone system (GOOS, GCOS, JCOMM). Operational oceanography has, however, specific requirements for high resolution measurements. Operational oceanography requirements have been presented in the GODAE strategic plan and in Le Traon et€ al. (2001). They have been refined and detailed in Clark and Wilson (2009) and Oke et€al. (2009).
2.2.2 The Unique Contribution of Satellite Observations Satellites provide long-term, continuous, global, high space and time resolution data for key ocean parameters: sea level and ocean circulation, sea surface temperature (SST), ocean colour, sea ice, waves and winds. These are the core variables observations required to constrain global, regional and coastal ocean monitoring
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
31
and forecasting systems. They are also needed to validate them. Only satellite measurements can, in particular, provide observations at high space and time resolution to partly resolve the mesoscale variability and coastal variability. Satellite data can also be directly used for applications (e.g. SAR for sea ice and oil pollution monitoring, ocean colour for water quality monitoring). Sea surface salinity is a new and important parameter that could be operationally monitored from space; the demonstration is underway with the European Space Agency SMOS mission (and later on with the NASA/CONAE Aquarius mission).
2.2.3 Main Requirements The main requirement for operational oceanography is to have a long-term, continuous and near real time access to the core operational satellite observations of sea level, SST, ocean colour, sea ice, wave and winds. For a given parameter, this generally requires several satellites flying simultaneously to get sufficient space and time resolution. The main requirements can be summarized as follows (e.g. Le Traon et€al. 2006; Clark and Wilson 2009): • In addition to meteorological satellites, a high precision (AATSR-class) SST satellite is needed to give the highest absolute SST accuracy. A microwave mission is also needed to provide an all weather global coverage. • At least three or four altimeters are required to observe the mesoscale circulation. This is also useful for significant wave height measurements. A long-term series of a high accuracy altimeter system (Jason satellites) is needed to serve a reference for the other missions and for the monitoring of climate signals. • Ocean colour is increasingly important, in particular, in coastal areas. At least two satellites are required. • Two scatterometers are required to globally monitor at high spatial resolution the wind field. • Two SAR satellites are required for waves, sea-ice characteristics and oil slick monitoring. These minimum requirements have been only partly met over the past ten years. Long-term continuity and transition from research to operational mode remains a major challenge (e.g. Clark and Wilson 2009). Specific requirements for altimetry, SST and ocean colour are discussed in the following sections.
2.2.4 Role of In-Situ Data Satellite observations need to be complemented by in-situ observations. First, in-situ data are needed to calibrate satellite observations. Most algorithms used
32
P.-Y. Le Traon
to transform satellite observations (e.g brightness temperatures) into geophysical quantities are partly based on in-situ/satellite match up data bases. In-situ data are then used to validate satellite observations and to monitor the long term stability of satellite observations. The stability of the different altimeter missions is, for example, commonly assessed by comparing the altimeter sea surface height measurements with those from tide gauges (Mitchum 2000). Other examples includes the validation of altimeter velocity products with drifter data (e.g. Pascual et€al. 2009), the systematic validation of satellite SST with in-situ SST from drifting buoys and the use of dedicated ship mounted radiometers to quantify the accuracy of satellite SST (Donlon et€al. 2008). The comparison of in-situ and satellite data can also provide useful indication on the quality of in-situ data (e.g. Guinehut et€al. 2008). The comparison of in-situ and satellite data is also useful to check the consistency between the different data sets before they are assimilated in an ocean model (e.g. Guinehut et€al. 2006). In-situ data are also (and mainly) mandatory to complement satellite observations and to provide measurements of the ocean interior. Only the joint use of high resolution satellite data with precise (but sparse) in-situ observations of the ocean interior has the potential to provide a high resolution description and forecast of the ocean state.
2.2.5 Data Processing Issues Satellite data processing includes different steps: level 0 and level 1 (from telemetry to calibrated sensor measurements), level 2 (from sensor measurements to geophysical variables), level 3 (space/time composites of level 2 data) and level 4 (merging of different sensors, data assimilation). Processing from level 0 to level 2 is generally carried out as part of the satellite ground segments. Assembly of level 2 data from different sensors, intercalibration of level 2 products, and higher level data processing is usually done by specific data processing centers or thematic assembly centers. The role of these data processing centers is to provide modelling and data assimilation centers with the real time and delayed mode data sets required for validation and data assimilation. This also includes uncertainty estimates that are critical to an effective use of data in modelling and data assimilation systems. Links with data assimilation centers are needed, in particular, to organize feedback on the quality control performed at the level of data assimilation centers (e.g. comparing an observation with a model forecast), on the impact of data sets and data products in the assimilation systems and on new or future requirements. High level data products (level 3 and 4) are also needed for applications (e.g. a merged altimeter surface current product for marine safety or offshore applications) and can be used to validate data assimilation systems (e.g. statistical versus dynamical interpolation) and complement products derived through modelling and data as-
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
33
similation systems. It is important, however, to be fully aware of limitations of high level satellite products (e.g. gridded SST or sea level data sets) when using them.
2.2.6 Use of Satellite Data for Assimilation into Ocean Models This is discussed at length in other chapters. Three important issues are emphasized here: 1. There can be large differences in data quality between real time and delayed mode (reprocessed) data sets. Depending on applications, trade-offs between time delay and accuracy often need to be considered. 2. Error characterisation is mandatory for data assimilation and a proper characterisation of error covariance can be quite complex for satellite observations. Data error covariance should always be tested and checked as part of the data assimilation systems. 3. It is much better in theory and for advanced assimilation schemes to use raw data (level 2 or in some cases level 1 when the model can provide data needed for level 1 processing). The data error structure is generally more easily defined. The model and the assimilation scheme should also do a better high level processing (e.g. a model forecast should provide a better background than climatology or persistence). However, in practice, this is not always true. Some data high level processing (e.g. correcting biases or large scale errors, intercalibration) is often needed as it cannot be easily done within the assimilation systems.
2.3╅Overview of Satellite Oceanography Techniques 2.3.1 Passive/Active Techniques and Choice of Frequencies There are two main types of satellite techniques to observe the ocean1. Passive techniques measure the natural radiation emitted from the sea or from reflected solar radiation. Active or radar techniques send a signal and measure the signal received after its reflection at the sea surface. In both cases, the propagation of the signal through the atmosphere, the emission from the atmosphere itself must be taken into account to isolate the sea surface signal. The intensity and frequency distribution of the radiation that is emitted or reflected from the ocean surface allows the inference of its properties. The polarization of the radiation is also often used in microwave remote sensing. 1╇ Gravimetry satellites (e.g. GRACE, GOCE) which measure the earth gravity field and its variations do not enter into these two categories.
34
P.-Y. Le Traon
Satellite systems operate at different frequencies depending on the signal to be derived. Visible (400–700€nm) and infra-red (0.7–20€μm) frequencies are used for ocean colour and SST measurements. Passive (radiometry) microwave systems (1– 30€cm) are used for SST in cloud situations, wind, sea ice and sea surface salinity retrievals. Radars operate in the microwave bands and provide measurements of sea surface height, wind speed and direction, wave spectra, sea ice cover and types and surface roughness. Radar pulses are emitted obliquely (15°–60°) (SAR, scatterometer) or vertically (altimetry). The choice of frequencies is limited by other usages (e.g. radio, cellular phones, military and civilian radars, satellite communications). Those are particularly important at microwave frequencies in the range 1–10€GHz which puts strong pressures on the frequencies used for earth remote sensing. The atmosphere also greatly affects the transmission of radiation between the ocean surface and the satellite sensors. The presence of fixed concentrations of atmospheric gases (e.g. O2, CO2, O3) and of water vapor means that only a limited number of windows exist in the visible, infra-red and microwave for ocean remote sensing. Even at these frequencies, the propagation effects through the atmosphere must be taken into account and corrected for. Propagation effects through the ionosphere must also be taken into account. Clouds are a strong limitation of visible and infrared measurements. There are also technological constraints for the choice of frequencies. The resolution of a given sensor is generally related to the ratio between the observed wavelength (↜λ) and the antenna diameter (D). For antenna diameters of a few meters, typical resolution around 1€ GHz (wavelength of 30€ cm) is about 100€ km while at 30€GHz (wavelength of 1€cm), resolution is about 10€km. Radar altimeters use pulse limited techniques (that are much less sensitive to mispointing errors). Their footprint size is related to the pulse duration and is much smaller than for a beam limited sensor. Synthetic Aperture Radar uses the motion of the satellite to generate very long antenna (e.g. 20€km for ASAR) and thus to provide very high resolution measurements (up to a few meters).
2.3.2 Satellite Orbits and Measurement Characteristics Orbits for ocean satellites are geostationary, polar or inclined orbits. A geostationary orbit is one in which the satellite is always in the same position with respect to the rotating Earth. The satellite orbits at an elevation of approximately 36,000€km because that produces an orbital period equal to the period of rotation of the Earth. By orbiting at the same rate, in the same direction as Earth, the satellite appears stationary. Geostationary satellites provide a large field of view (up to 120°) at very high frequency enabling coverage of weather events. Because of the high altitude, spatial resolution is of a few km while it is of 1€km or less for polar orbiting satellites. Because a geostationary orbit must be in the same plane as the Earth’s rotation, that is the equatorial plane, it provides distorted images of the polar regions. Five or six geostationary meteorological satellites can provide a global coverage of the earth (for latitudes below 60°).
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
35
Polar-orbiting satellites provide a more global view of Earth by passing from pole to pole, observing a different portion of the Earth with each orbit due to the Earth’s own rotation. Orbiting at an altitude of 700–800€km these satellites have an orbital period of approximately 90€ min. These satellites usually operate in a sun-synchronous orbit. The satellite passes the equator and any given latitude at the same local solar time each day. Inclined orbits have an inclination between 0° (equatorial orbit) and 90° (polar orbit). They are used, in particular, to observe tropical regions (e.g. TMI on TRMM mission). High accuracy altimeter satellites such as TOPEX/Poseidon and Jason use higher altitude and non synchronous orbits to reduce atmospheric drag and (mainly) to avoid aliasing of the main tidal signals. Depending on instrument types (along-track, imaging or swath), frequencies and antennas (see above), the sampling pattern of a given satellite will be different. In addition, in the visible and infrared frequencies, cloud cover can strongly reduce the effective sampling.
2.3.3 Radiation Laws and Emissivity 2.3.3.1â•…Radiation from a Blackbody Planck’s law describes the rate of energy emitted by a blackbody as a function of frequency or wavelength. A blackbody absorbs all the radiation it receives and emits radiation at a maximum rate for its given temperature. Planck’s law gives the intensity of radiation Lλ emitted by unit surface area into a fixed direction (solid angle) from the blackbody as a function of wavelength (or frequency). The Planck Law can be expressed through the following equation: Lλ = 2hc2 /λ5 [exp(hc/λkT ) − 1]
where T is temperature, c the speed of light (2.99â•›·â•›10−8€m€s−1), h the Planck’s constant (6.63â•›·â•›10−34€ Jâ•›⋅â•›s), k the Boltzmann’s constant (1.38â•›·â•›10−23 J€ K−1) and Lλ the spectral radiance per unit of wavelength and solid angle in W€m−3€sr−1. The Planck law gives a distribution that peaks at a certain wavelength; the peak shifts to shorter wavelengths for higher temperatures. The Wien displacement law and the Stefan-Boltzmann law are two other useful radiation laws that can be derived from the Planck law. The Wien law gives the wavelength of the peak of the radiation distribution (↜λmaxâ•›= 3€╛·â•›107/T) while the Stefan-Boltzmann law gives the total energy E being emitted at all wavelengths by the blackbody (Eâ•›=╛╛·â•›T4). Thus, the Wien law explains the shift of the peak to shorter wavelengths as the temperature increases, while the Stefan-Boltzmann law explains the growth in the height of the curve as the temperature increases. Notice that this growth is very abrupt, since it varies as the fourth power of the temperature. The Rayleigh-Jeans approximation (↜Lλâ•›=â•›2kcT/λ4) holds for wavelengths much greater than the wavelength of the peak in the black body radiation form. This approximation is valid over the microwave band.
36
P.-Y. Le Traon
2.3.3.2â•…Graybodies and Emissivity Most bodies radiate less efficiently than a blackbody. The emissivity e is defined as the ratio of graybody radiance to the blackbody. It has a non dimensional unit and is comprised between 0 and 1. The emissivity generally depends on wavelength (↜λ) and polarization and has a directional dependence. e can be considered as a physical surface property and is a key quantity for ocean remote sensing. A blackbody absorbs all the energy it receives. A graybody absorbs only part of it and the remaining part is reflected and/or transmitted. The absorptivity is equal to the emissivity as a surface in equilibrium must absorb and emit energy at the same rate (Kirchoff’s law). Similarly the reflectivity is equal to 1â•›−â•›e. The brightness temperature (BT) is defined as BTâ•›=â•›eâ•›·â•›T where T is the (physical) temperature. In the microwave band, it is proportional to the radiation Lλ. 2.3.3.3â•…Retrieval of Geophysical Parameters for Microwave Radiometers The brightness temperature is an integrated measurement that includes all surface and atmosphere emitted power. Depending on frequency, it is more sensitive to a given parameter. Physical retrieval algorithms for geophysical parameters, such as the sea surface temperature, sea surface wind speed, sea ice or sea surface salinity are derived from a radiative transfer model (RTM), which computes the brightness temperatures that are measured by the satellite as a function of these variables. The RTM is based on a model for the sea surface emissivity and a model of microwave absorption in the Earth’s atmosphere. The ocean sea surface emissivity (or reflectivity see above) depends on the dielectric constant ε (which is a function of frequency, water temperature and salinity), small scale sea surface roughness, foam as well as viewing geometry and polarization. The retrieval of a given parameter is possible through the inversion of a set of brightness temperatures measured at different frequencies and/ or at different incidence angles. Inversion methods minimize the difference between measured and simulated (through a RTM) brightness temperatures. Statistical or empirical inversions are also often used given uncertainties in RTMs. They use a regression formalism (e.g. parametric, neural network) to find the best relation between brightness temperatures and the geophysical parameter to be retrieved.
2.4╅Altimetry 2.4.1 Overview Satellite altimetry is the most essential observing system required for global operational oceanography. It provides global, real time, all-weather sea level measurements (SSH) with high space and time resolution. Sea level is directly related to ocean circulation through the geostrophic approximation (see Sect.€2.4.5). Sea level is also an integral of the ocean interior and is a strong constraint for inferring the
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
37
4D ocean circulation through data assimilation. Altimeters also measure significant wave height, which is essential for operational wave forecasting. High resolution from multiple altimeters is required to adequately represent ocean eddies and associated currents (the “ocean weather”) in models. Only altimetry can constrain the 4D mesoscale circulation in ocean models which is required for most operational oceanography applications.
2.4.2 Measurement Principles An altimeter is active radar that sends a microwave pulse towards the ocean surface. Precise clock on board measures the return time of the pulse from which the distance or range (d) between the satellite and the sea surface is derived (dâ•›=â•›t/2c). The range precision is of a few centimeters for a distance of 800–1,300€km. The altimeter also measures the backscatter power (related to surface roughness and wind) and significant wave height. An altimeter mission generally includes a bifrequency altimeter radar (usually in Ku and C or S Band) (for ionospheric corrections), a microwave radiometer (for water vapor correction) and a tracking system for precise orbit determination (Laser, GPS, Doris) that provides the orbit altitude relative to a given earth ellipsoid. Altimeter missions provide along-track measurements every 7€km along repetitive tracks (e.g. every 10 days for the TOPEX/Poseidon and Jason series and 35 days for ERS and ENVISAT). The distance between tracks is inversely proportional to the repeat time period (e.g. about 315€km at the equator for TOPEX/Poseidon and 90€km for ERS/ENVISAT). The main measurement for an altimeter radar is the sea surface height (SSH) relative to a given earth ellipsoid. The SSH is derived as the difference between the orbit altitude and the range measurement. SSH precision depends on orbit and range errors. Altimeter range measurements are affected by a large number of errors (propagation effects in the troposphere and ionosphere, electromagnetic bias, errors due to inaccurate ocean and terrestrial tide models, inverse barometer effect, residual geoid errors). Some of these errors can be corrected with dedicated instrumentation (e.g. dual frequency altimeter, radiometer). For a comprehensive description of altimeter measurement principles, the reader is referred to Chelton et€al. (2001).
2.4.3 Geoid and Repeat-Track Analysis The sea surface height SSH(x,t) measured by altimetry can be described by: SSH(x, t) = N(x) + η(x, t) + ε(x, t)
N is the geoid, the dynamic topography and are measurement errors. The quantity of interest for oceanographer is the dynamic topography (see next section).
38
P.-Y. Le Traon
Present geoids are not generally accurate enough to estimate globally the absolute dynamic topography except at long wavelengths. The variable part of the dynamic topography ′(↜╛−â•›<>) (or SLA for sea level anomaly) is, however, easily extracted using the so-called repeat track method. For a given track, ′ is obtained by removing the mean profile over several cycles, which contains the geoid N and the mean dynamic topography <>: SLA(x, t) = SSH(x, t) − < SSH(x) > t = η(x, t) − < η(x) > t + ε (x, t)
To get the absolute signal, one has thus to use a climatology or to use existing geoids together with altimeter Mean Sea Surface (MSS) (or both). One can also rely on a model mean. Gravimetric missions (CHAMP, GRACE) are now providing much more accurate geoids, GOCE should almost “solve” the problem. Even with GOCE, however, repeat-track analysis will still be needed because of the small scales of geoid (below 50–100€km) will not be precisely known. GOCE will be used with an altimetric MSS to derive <>t that can then be added to ′.
2.4.4 High Level Data Processing Issues and Products The SSALTO/DUACS system is the main multi-mission altimeter data center used today for operational oceanography. It aims to provide directly usable, high quality near real time and delayed mode (for reanalyses and research users) altimeter products to the main operational oceanography and climate centers in Europe and worldwide. Main processing steps are product homogenization, data editing, orbit error correction, reduction of long wavelength errors, production of along track and maps of sea level anomalies. Major progress has been made in higher level processing issues such as orbit error reduction (e.g. Le Traon and Ogor 1998), intercalibration and merging of altimeter missions (e.g. Le Traon et€al. 1998; Ducet et€al. 2000; Pascual et€al. 2006). The SSALTO/DUACS weekly production moved to a daily production in 2007 to improve timeliness of data sets and products. A new real time product was also developed for specific real time mesoscale applications. The mean dynamic topography (MDT) is an essential reference surface for altimetry. Added to the sea level anomalies, it provides the absolute sea level and ocean circulation (see previous section). After a preliminary MDT computed in 2003, a new MDT, called RIO-05, was computed in 2005. It is based on the combination of GRACE data, drifting buoy velocities, in-situ T,S profiles and altimeter measurements. The MDT was tested and is now used by several GODAE modelling and forecasting centers. It has a positive impact on the ocean analysis quality and forecast skill. An updated version was recently delivered (CNES-CLS09). Major improvement is expected soon with the use of data from the GOCE mission.
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
39
2.4.5 Sea Level Measurement Content Satellite altimetry provides measurements of the dynamic topography (i.e. sea level relative to the geoid). Assuming geostrophy and hydrostatic balance, one has:
1 ∂P fv = ρ0 ∂x 1 ∂P −f u = ρ0 ∂y
(2.1) f = 2 sin θ
(2.2)
∂p = −ρg ∂z
(2.3)
with u, v zonal and meridional currents, P pressure and f the Coriolis parameter. At the surface Pâ•›=╛╛·â•›gâ•›·â•› (↜╛=â•›sea surface topography relative to the geoid), thus there is a direct relationship between the dynamic topography and the surface (geostrophic) current: ∂η fv = g ∂x (2.4) ∂η −f u = g ∂y Taking the derivative of (2.3), one gets the thermal wind equation. It means that density horizontal variations are associated with vertical shear (baroclinic motions):
f
∂v −g ∂ρ = ∂z ρ0 ∂x
(2.5)
The integration of (2.5) from z0 to z1 yields: g z1 1 ∂ρ v(z) = v(z0 ) − dz f z0 ρ0 ∂x
g ∂ηs or v(z) = v(z0 ) + with ηs (z0 , z1 ) = − f ∂x
(2.6)
z1
z0
ρ dz ρ0
s is the steric height. s is generally defined as s (bottom, surface). At the surface, one has: g ∂ηs g ∂η v(z0 ) + f ∂x = f ∂x Pz0 ⇒ η = ηs + ρ0 g 1 ∂Pz0 with v(z0 ) = f ρ0 ∂x
(2.7)
(2.8)
P.-Y. Le Traon
40
The dynamic topography (measured by altimetry) is thus the sum of a steric height term (integral of density anomalies which is generally referred to the baroclinic component) and a bottom pressure term (barotropic component). Sea level is thus more than a « surface » measurement. It corresponds to a signal over the full depth of the ocean and provides a strong constraint for inferring (together with in-situ measurements) the 4D ocean structure through data assimilation.
2.4.6 Operational Oceanography Requirements Le Traon et€al. (2006) have defined the main priorities for altimeter missions in the context of the European GMES (Global Monitoring for Environment and Security) Marine Core Service. Their Tables€2.1 and 2.2 give the requirements for different applications of altimetry and characteristics of altimeter missions. The main operational oceanography requirements for satellite altimetry can be summarized as follows: 1. Need to maintain a long time series of a high accuracy altimeter system (Jason series) to serve a reference mission and for climate applications. It requires one class A altimeter with an overlap between successive missions of at least 6 months. 2. The main requirement for medium to high resolution altimetry would be to fly three class B altimeters in addition to the Jason series (class A). Most operational oceanography applications (e.g. marine security, pollution monitoring) require high resolution surface currents that cannot be adequately reproduced without a high resolution altimeter system. Recent studies (e.g. Pascual et€al. 2006) show Table 2.1↜渀 User requirements for different applications of altimetry Application area Accuracya Spatial resolution (cm) (km) 1.╇Climate applications and 1 300–500 reference mission 2.╇Ocean nowcasting/forecasting for 3 50–100 mesoscale applications 3 10 3.╇ Coastal/local a For the given resolution b Limited by feasibility Table 2.2↜渀 Altimeter mission characteristics Class Orbit Mission characteristics A
Non-sun synchronous
B
Polar
High accuracy for climate applications and to reference other missions Medium-class accuracy
Revisit time (days) 10–20
Priority
7–15
High
1
Lowb
High
Revisit interval (days) 10–20
Track separation at the equator (km) 150–300
20–35
80–150
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
41
that, at least three, but preferably four, altimeter missions are needed for monitoring the mesoscale circulation. This is particularly needed for real time nowcasting and forecasting. Pascual et€al. (2009) showed that four altimeters in real time provide similar results as two altimeters in delayed mode. Such a scenario would also provide an improved operational reliability. Moreover, it would enhance the spatial and temporal sampling for monitoring and forecasting significant wave height. In parallel, there is a need to develop and test innovative instrumentation (e.g. wide swath altimetry with the NASA SWOT mission) to better answer existing and future operational oceanography requirements for high to very high resolution (e.g. mesoscale/submesoscale and coastal dynamics). There is also a need to improve nadir altimetry technology (resolution, noise) and to develop smaller and cheaper instruments that could be embarked on a constellation of small satellites. The use of the Ka band (35€Ghz) allows, in particular, a major reduction in the size and weight of the altimeter. It will be tested for the first time with the CNES/ISRO SARAL satellite scheduled for launch in late 2011.
2.5╅Sea Surface Temperature 2.5.1 S ea Surface Temperature Measurements and Operational Oceanography Sea surface temperature (SST) is a key variable for operational oceanography and for assimilation into ocean dynamical models. SST is strongly related to air-sea interaction processes and provides a means to correct for errors in forcing fields (heat fluxes, wind). It also characterizes the mesoscale variability of the upper ocean (eddies, frontal structures) at very high resolution (a few km). SST data are often directly used for operational oceanography applications. They provide useful indices (e.g. climate changes, upwelling, thresholds). SST data can also be used to derive high resolution velocity fields (e.g. Bowen et€al. 2002). Accurate, stable, well resolved maps of SST are essential for climate monitoring and climate change detection. They are also central for Numerical Weather Prediction for which the role of high resolution SST measurements has been recently evidenced (e.g. Chelton 2005).
2.5.2 Measurement Principles Infrared radiometers operate at wavebands around 3.7, 10.5 and 11.5€ μm where the atmosphere is almost transparent. The brightness temperature measured from infrared radiometers differs from the actual temperature of the observed surface because of non-unit emissivity and the effect of the atmosphere. Emissivity at IR
42
P.-Y. Le Traon
frequencies is between 0.98 and 0.99 (close to a black body). Atmospheric correction is based on multispectral approach, when the differences between brightness temperatures measured at different wavelengths are used to estimate the contribution of the atmosphere to the signal. At 10€μm, the solar irradiance reaching the top of the atmosphere is about 1/300 of the sea surface emittance. At 3.7€μm, the incoming solar irradiance is the same order as the surface emittance. As a result, this wavelength can be used during nighttime only. Different algorithms are thus used for nighttime and daytime. There is no IR way of measuring SST below cloud. The first priority is thus to detect cloud through a variety of methods. For cloud detection, the thermal and near-infrared waveband thresholds are used, as well as different spatial coherency tests. Consequences of poor cloud detection are low biases in SST climatic averages and “false hits” of cloud that can hide frontal and other dynamical structures. Geostationary infra-red sensors can see whenever the cloud breaks. Microwave sensors operate at several frequencies. Retrieval of SST is done at 7 and/or 11€GHz. Higher frequency channels (19–37€GHz) are used to precisely estimate the attenuation due to oxygen, water vapor, and clouds. The polarization ratio (horizontal versus vertical) of the measurements is used to correct for sea surface roughness effects. The great advantage of microwave measurements compared to infra-red ones is that SST can be retrieved even through non-precipitating clouds, which is very beneficial in terms of geographical coverage.
2.5.3 SST Infra-Red and Microwave Sensors Infra-red radiometers such as the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) on board operational meteorological polar orbiting satellites offer a good horizontal resolution (1€km) and potentially a global coverage, with the important exception of cloudy areas. However, their accuracy (0.4–0.5€ K derived from the difference between collocated satellite and buoy measurements) is limited by the radiometric quality of the AVHRR instrument and the correction of atmospheric effects. Geostationary satellites (e.g. GOES and MSG series) are carrying radiometers with similar infrared window channels as the AVHRR instrument. Their horizontal resolution is coarser (3–5€km), but their great contribution comes from their high temporal sampling. Pre-operational demonstrators for advanced measurement of SST suitable for climate studies include the Along Track Scanning Radiometer ((A) ATSR) series of instruments that have improved on board calibration, and make use of dual views at nadir and 55° incidence angle. The along track scanning measurement provides an improved atmospheric correction leading to an accuracy of better than 0.2€K (O’Carroll et€al. 2008). The main drawback of these instruments is their limited coverage, due to a much narrower swath than the AVHRR instruments. Several microwave radiometers have also been developed and flown over the last 10 years (e.g. AMSR, TMI). The horizontal resolution of these products is around 25€km and their accuracy around 0.6–0.7€K.
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
43
2.5.4 Key Developments in SST Data Processing During the past ten years, a concerted effort to understand satellite and in situ SST observations has taken place leading to a revolution in the way we approach the provision of SST data to the user community. GODAE, recognizing the importance of high resolution SST data sets for ocean forecasting, initiated the GODAE High Resolution SST Pilot Project (GHRSST-PP) to capitalize on these developments and develop a set of dedicated products and services. There have been key developments in data processing of SST data sets over the last 10 years. As a result, new or improved products are now available. A full description of the GHRSST-PP is provided in Donlon et€ al. (2009). Data processing issues are summarized in Le Traon et€al. (2009). A satellite measures the so-called skin temperature, i.e. at a depth from a few tens of microns (infra-red) up to a few mm only (microwave). Diurnal warming changes the SST over a layer of 1–10€m. The effect can be particularly large in regions of low wind speed and high solar radiation. GHRSST has defined the foundation SST as the temperature of the water column free of diurnal temperature variability. A key issue in SST data processing is to correct satellite SST measurements for skin and diurnal warming effects to provide precise estimations of the foundation SST. Night and day SST data from different satellites can then be merged through an optimal interpolation or a data assimilation system. Several new analyzed high resolution SST products have been produced, in particular, in the framework of GHRSST-PP. These high resolution data sets are estimated by optimal interpolation methods merging SST satellite measurements from both infrared and microwave sensors. The pre-processing consists mainly in a screening and quality control of the retrieved observations from each single datasets and in constructing a coherent merged multi-sensor set of the most relevant and accurate observations (level 3). The merging of these observations requires a method for bias estimate and correction (relative to a chosen reference, currently AATSR). The gap free SST foundation field is finally computed from the merged set of selected observations using an objective analysis method. The guess is either climatology or a previous map.
2.5.5 Operational Oceanography Requirements Table€2.3 from Le Traon et€al. (2006) summarises weather, climate and operational oceanography requirements for sea surface temperature. In order to meet the key requirements for SST no single sensor is adequate. To remedy this, GHRSST-PP has established an internationally accepted approach to blending SST data from different sources that complement each other (see previous section). For this to work effectively, there must be an assemblage of four distinct types of satellite SST missions in place at any time, as defined in Table€2.4 (from Le Traon et€al. 2006).
P.-Y. Le Traon
44 Table 2.3↜渀 User requirements for SST provision Application area Temperature accuracy (K) 0.2–0.5 1.╇ Weather prediction 2.╇ Climate monitoring 0.1 3.╇ Ocean forecasting 0.2
Spatial resolution (km) 10–50 20–50 1–10
Revisit time
Priority
6–12€h 8€day 6–12€h
High High High
Table 2.4↜渀 Minimum assemblage of missions required to meet the need for operational SST SST mission type Radiometer Nadir Swath width Coverage/ wavebands resolution revisit 3 thermal IR ~2,500€km Day and night ~1€km A.╇Two polar orbiting (3.7, 11, meteorological satellites global 12€μm), 1 with infra-red radiometers. coverage Generates the basic global by each near-IR, 1 Vis coverage satellite ~1€km ~500€km Earth coverB.╇Polar orbiting dual-view 3 thermal IR age in ~4 (3.7, 11, radiometer. SST accuracy days 12€μm), 1 approaching 0.1€K, used as near-IR, 1 reference standard for other Vis, each types with dual view Requires chanC.╇Polar orbiting microwave ~1,500€km ~50€km Earth covernels at ~7 and radiometer optimised for (25€km age in 2 ~11€GHz SST retrieval. Coarse resodays pixels) lution coverage of cloudy regions Sample Earth disk 2–4€km D.╇ Infra-red radiometers on 3 thermal IR interval from (3.7, 11, geostationary platforms. <30€min 36,000€km 12€μm), 1 Spaced around the Earth near-IR, 1 Vis altitude
The priority expressed by the international SST community, through GHRSST, is to continue to provide a type B (ATSR class) sensor. Its on-board calibration system and especially its dual-view methodology allow AATSR to deliver the highest achievable absolute accuracy of SST, robustly independent of factors such as stratospheric aerosols from major volcanic eruptions or tropospheric dust, which cause significant biases in other infra-red sensors. Because its absolute calibration (for dual view) is better than 0.2€K it is used for bias correction of the other data sources before assimilation into models or analyses. A type C sensor (microwave) is also required beyond AMSR-E on Aqua.
2.5.6 Conclusions Satellite SST observations are essential observations for operational oceanography, weather and climate forecasting. SST data are systematically used for global and
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
45
large scale observations for climate applications and to correct for large scale biases in ocean models (due to forcing field errors). Thanks to GHRSST, major improvements in data processing issues and use of different types of sensors have occurred. New high resolution products (from level 2 to level 4) are now available and used by ocean analysis and forecasting systems. High resolution SST data provide unvaluable information on mesoscale and submesocale phenomena. There is still a lot to do, however, to fully use the high resolution information content of SST observations in ocean models. This is an area of active research.
2.6â•…Ocean Colour 2.6.1 O cean Colour Measurements and Operational Oceanography Over the last decade, the applications of satellite-derived ocean colour data have made important contributions to biogeochemistry, physical oceanography, ecosystem assessment, fisheries oceanography and coastal management (IOCCG 2008). Ocean colour measurements provide a global monitoring of chlorophyll (phytoplankton biomass) and associated primary production. They can be used to calibrate and validate biogeochemical, carbon and ecosystem models. Progress towards assimilation of ocean colour data is less mature than for SST or SSH, but there are already convincing examples of assimilation of Chla in ocean models. Use of K and PAR (see below) is needed to define the in-water light field that drives photosynthesis in ocean ecosystem models and that is required to model and forecast the ocean surface temperature. Data products needed to support ocean analysis and forecasting models of open ocean biogeochemical processes are the concentration of chlorophyll-a (Chla), total suspended material (TSM), the optical diffuse attenuation coefficient (↜K) and the photosynthetically available radiation (PAR). Ocean colour is a tracer of dynamical processes (mesoscale and submesoscale) and this is of great value for model validation. It also plays a role in air-sea CO2 exchange monitoring. At regional and coastal scales, there are many applications that require ocean colour measurements: monitoring of water quality, measurement of suspended sediment, sediment transport models, measurement of dissolved organic material, validation of regional/coastal ecosystem models (and assimilation), detection of plankton and harmful algal blooms, monitoring of eutrophisation…. Use of ocean colour data in coastal seas is, however, more challenging as explained below.
2.6.2 Measurement Principles The sunlight is not merely reflected from the sea surface. The colour of water surface results from sunlight that has entered the ocean, been selectively absorbed,
46
P.-Y. Le Traon
scattered and reflected by phytoplankton and other suspended material in the upper layers, and then backscattered through the surface. The subsurface reflectance R(↜λ) (ratio of subsurface upwelled or water-leaving radiance on incident irradiance) that is the ocean signal measured by a satellite is proportional to b(↜λ)/[a(↜λ)â•›+â•›b(↜λ)] or b(↜λ)/a(↜λ) where b(↜λ) is the backscattering and a(↜λ) the absorption of the different water constituents. Sunlight backscattered by the atmosphere (aerosols and molecular/Rayleigh scattering) contributes actually to more than 80% of the radiance measured by a satellite sensor at visible wavelengths. Atmospheric correction is calculated from additional measurements in the red and near-infrared spectral bands. Ocean water reflects very little radiation at these longer wavelengths (the ocean is close to a black body in the infra-red) and the radiance measured is thus due almost entirely to scattering by the atmosphere. Unlike observations in the infrared or microwave frequencies for which emission is from the sea surface only, ocean colour signals in the blue-green can come from depths as great as 50€m. Sources of ocean colour variations include: • Phytoplankton and its pigments • Dissolved organic material − Coloured Dissolved Organic Material (CDOM or yellow matter) is derived from decaying vegetable matter (land) and phytoplankton degraded by grazing or photolysis. • Suspended particulate matter (SPM) − The organic particulates (detritus) consist of phytoplankton and zooplankton cell fragments and zooplankton fecal pellets. − The inorganic particulates consist of sand and dust created by erosion of landbased rocks and soils (from river runoff, deposition of wind-blown dust, wave or current suspension of bottom sediments). Colour can tell us about relative and absolute concentrations of those water constituents which interact with the light. Hence we measure chlorophyll, yellow substance and sediment load. It is difficult to distinguish independently varying water constituents: • Case 1 waters are where the phytoplankton population dominates the optical properties (typically open sea). Only one component modulates the radiance spectrum backscattered from the water (phytoplankton pigment). Concentration range is 0.03–30€mg€m−3. Water in the near IR is nearly black for blue water. Atmospheric correction that is based on IR frequency measurements is thus relatively simple. Using green/blue ratio algorithms for chlorophyll, of the form Chlaâ•›=â•›A(R550/R490), provides an accuracy for Chla of ~±30% in open ocean. • Case 2 waters are where other factors (CDOM, SPM) are also present. There are multiple independent components in water, which have an influence on the backscattered radiance spectrum. The retrieval procedure has to deal with these
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
47
multiple components, even if only one should be determined. At high total suspended matter concentrations, problems also occur with atmospheric correction. More complex algorithms (e.g. neural network) and more frequencies are thus required. Although this remains a challenging task, much progress has been made over the past five years. Useful estimations of Chla and SPM can thus be obtained in the coastal zone (e.g. Gohin et€al. 2005). Ocean colour can also provide information on phytoplankton functional types as changes in phytoplankton composition can lead to changes in absorption and backscattering coefficients. This is an area of active research but first results are already promising. An ocean colour satellite should have a minimum number of bands from 400– 900€nm. The role of the various bands is: • 413€nm: Discrimination of CDOM in open sea blue water. • 443, 490, 510, 560€nm: Chlorophyll retrieval from blue-green ratio algorithms. • 560, 620, 665€nm and others: Potential to retrieve water content in turbid Case 2 waters using new red-green algorithms. • 665, 681, 709€nm and others: Use of fluorescence peak for chlorophyll retrieval. • 779, 870€nm for atmospheric correction plus another above 1,000€nm to improve correction over turbid water.
2.6.3 Processing Issues The processing transforms the Level-1 data, normalized radiances observed by the ocean colour radiometer, into geophysical properties corrected from atmospheric effects. Level 2 products include water leaving radiances at different wavelengths, chlorophyll-a concentration of the surface water (usually with case 1 and case 2 algorithms), total suspended matter (TSM), coloured dissolved and detrital organic materials (CDOM), diffuse attenuation coefficient (K) and PAR. Merging of several ocean colour satellites is needed to improve the daily ocean coverage. This requires combining data from individual sensors with different viewing geometries, resolution and radiometric characteristics (Pottier et€al. 2006; Mélin and Zibordi 2007; IOCCG 2007). The availability of merged datasets allows the users to exploit a unique, quality-consistent, time-series of ocean colour observations, without being concerned with the performance of individual instruments.
2.6.4 Operational Oceanography Requirements The needs and the broad classes of colour sensor are summarised in Tables€ 2.5 and 2.6 from Le Traon et€al. (2006). They distinguish categories of use between the needs of the open ocean forecasting models, the finer scale shelf sea and local
P.-Y. Le Traon
48 Table 2.5↜渀 User requirements for ocean colour data products Category of use Optical class Minimum set Accuracy (%) of water of satellitederived variables needed Case 1 Chlor 30 1.╇Assimilation into operational open ocean K 5 models PAR 5 Lw(↜λ) 5 2.╇Ingestion in operaCase 2 K 5 tional shelf sea and PAR 5 local models 5 Lw(↜λ) Chlor 30 TSM 30 CDOM 30 Case 2 K 5 3.╇Data products used directly by marine PAR 5 managers in shelf seas Lw(↜λ) 5 Chlor 30 TSM 30 CDOM 30 Chlor 10–30 4.╇Global ocean climate Case 1 monitoring K 5 PAR 5 5.╇Coastal ocean climate Case 2 Chlor 10–30 monitoring TSM 10–30 CDOM 10–30 PAR 5 K 5 5 Case 2 Lw(↜λ) 6.╇Coastal and estuarine water quality monitoring Table 2.6↜渀 Classes of ocean colour sensor Class Orbit Sensor type A
Polar
B
Polar
C
Geostationary
Spatial resolution (km)
Revisit time
2–4
1–3 days
0.5–2
1 day desired, but 3–5 days useful
0.25–1
1 day desired, but 3–5 days useful
5–10
8 day average
5
8 day average
0.1–0.5
0.5–2€h
Revisit time Spatial resolution 3 days 1€km
SeaWiFS type multispectral scanner, 5-8 Vis-NIR wavebands Imaging spectrometer 3 days (MERIS/MODIS type) Radiometer or spectrometer— 30€min feasibility to be determined
0.25–1€km
Priority High High
100€m–2€km Medium
models, and those operational end users who analyse the data directly rather than through assimilation into a model system. There is a variety of additional products desired in coastal waters depending on the local water character. These include the coloured dissolved organic material (CDOM) and the discrimination of different
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
49
functional groups of phytoplankton. Some operational users prefer to use directly the atmospherically corrected water leaving radiance, Lw(↜λ) (defined over the spectrum of given wavebands), applying their own approach for deriving water quality information or for confronting a model. Climate applications (categories 4 and 5) are envisaged to be derived from the operational categories 1 and 2 respectively, trading spatial and temporal resolution for improved accuracy. Category 6 is included in Table€2.5 to represent those users needing to monitor estuarine processes in fine spatial detail and to resolve the variations within the tidal cycle. This is a much more demanding category than the others. A Class A simple SeaWiFS-like instrument with a resolution of 1€km and a set of 5 or 6 wavebands would be adequate for user categories 1 and 4, to monitor global chlorophyll for assimilation into open ocean ecosystem models and for monitoring global primary production. It would fail to meet the main requirement to monitor water quality in coastal and shelf seas represented by user categories 2 and 3. These require a Class B imaging spectrometer sensor. In order to satisfy the ocean colour measurement requirements for operational oceanography, the minimum requirement is for one Class B sensor and at least one other sensor (Class A, B or C). The Class C sensor corresponds to an imaging spectrometer on a geostationary platform. As well as uniquely serving the user category 6 by resolving variability within the tidal cycle, it also serves other user categories in cloudy conditions by exploiting any available cloud windows that occur during the day.
2.6.5 Conclusions While ocean colour is now more and more used for operational applications (e.g. water quality), the development lags behind other remote sensing methods. This is because it is inherently difficult to retrieve ocean variables accurately and confidently. The potential of ocean colour measurements to calibrate or improve global, regional and coastal biogeochemical models is, however, considerable. The information content is very rich. This is a scientific and technical challenge. We are just beginning to use ocean colour products in ocean models. This is a challenging subject and it should be a high priority research topic for operational oceanography.
2.7â•…Other Techniques 2.7.1 Synthetic Aperture Radar SAR is an active instrument that transmits/receives electromagnetic radiation. It operates at microwave (or radar) frequencies. Wavelengths are in the range of 2–30€cm corresponding to frequencies in the range of 15–1€GHz. It works in the presence
50
P.-Y. Le Traon
of clouds, day and night. Synthetic aperture principle is to generate a very long antenna through the motion of the platform. For ASAR the length of the synthetic antenna is approximately 20€km. This leads to very high resolution. The surface roughness is the source for the backscatter of the SAR signal. The signal that arrives at the antenna is registered both in amplitude and phase. Although the SAR sees only the Bragg waves (↜λBâ•›=â•›λ/2 sin , where is the incidence angle, λ the radar wavelength and λB the resonant Bragg wavelength) these waves are modulated by a large number of upper ocean and atmospheric boundary layer phenomena. This is the reason why SAR images express wave field, wind field, currents, fronts, internal waves and oil spill. They also provide high resolution images of sea ice (see next section).
2.7.2 Sea Ice Passive microwave (PM) data from the SSM/I instrument is the backbone of operational sea ice observations. Daily Arctic and Antarctic analysis of ice concentration are delivered in near real time from operational centers such as NCEP and the OSI SAF. These types of datasets are today assimilated in operational ocean model systems. Improved resolution and more detailed ice edge estimates are obtained by use of scatterometer data (e.g. QuickScat) and new PM data from AMSR-E. Ice drift information based on successive satellite passages from these instruments are also assimilated in ocean/ice models. High resolution sea ice information is derived from SAR data and images from optical and IR instruments. Operational services for offshore industry, shipping and safety in polar regions rely on regular iceberg detection and sea ice type, extent and deformation monitoring at a spatial resolution (~50–100€m) that is only feasible with spaceborne SAR. Although ice coverage and ice motion is well observed there is still lack of regular information about the variation in ice volume. The ice thickness measurements from the advanced altimeter on Cryosat-II are thus very much welcomed (launched in April, 2010).
2.7.3 Satellite Winds Scatterometers (e.g. Seawinds/Quickscat, ASCAT/MetOp) are radars operating at C or Ku bands. The main ocean parameters measured is the wind speed and direction. They also provide useful information on sea ice roughness. Principle is based on the resonant Bragg scattering. For a smooth surface, oblique viewing of the surface with active radar yields virtually no return. When wind increases, so does surface roughness and the reflected signals towards the satellite sensor. The wind direction can be derived because of the azimuthal dependence of the reflected signal with respect to the wind direction.
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
51
To enhance the spatial and temporal resolutions of surface wind, several attempts have been made to merge the remotely sensed data to the operational NWP wind analyses over the global oceans. More details about data and processing methods can be found in Bentamy et€al. (2007).
2.7.4 A New Challenge: To Estimate Sea Surface Salinity from Space At L-band (1.4€GHz), brightness temperature (BT) is mainly affected by ocean surface emission (atmosphere is almost transparent): BTâ•›=â•›eâ•›·â•›SSTâ•›=â•›(1-R) SST where BT is brightness temperature an e sea surface emissivity. R (θ, SSS, SST, U…) is the reflexion coefficient (see Sect.€2.3). R depends on sea water permittivity and thus on sea surface salinity. Sensitivity is maximum at L-band. It is, however, very low (0.2–0.8 K/psu) and increases with sea surface temperature. The SMOS satellite was launched in November 2009. It is an L-band radiometer that measures of brightness temperature at different incidence angles (0–60°). SMOS is a synthetic aperture radiometer which provides a high spatial resolution (∼40€km precision 1€psu). SSS accuracy of 0.1–0.2€psu over 200â•›×â•›200€km and 10 days areas is achieved through averaging of individual measurements. The Aquarius satellite will be launched in 2011. It is a conventional L-band radiometer operating at 3 incident angles. Aquarius includes a L-band scatterometer to correct for sea surface roughness effects.
2.8â•…Concluding Remarks The chapter provides only a very brief summary of ocean remote sensing measurement principles. More information can be found in Fu and Cazenave (2001), Robinson (2004) and Martin (2004) books. Satellite data play a fundamental role for operational oceanography. They are mandatory to constrain ocean models through data assimilation and they provide directly useable data products for applications. Over the past 10 years, new and improved data sets and products needed by the modeling and data assimilation systems and for applications have been developed. Accuracy and timeliness of products have been improved. This has resulted in a larger and more systematic assimilation of satellite data into ocean models. Sampling and error characteristics, measurement content must be well understood, however, for a proper use in ocean models. In-situ data are also mandatory to calibrate, validate and complement satellite observations. There are still a series of advances in satellite oceanography that are expected to impact operational oceanography and its applications: • Continuous data processing improvements are needed so that data sets and products evolve according to requirements from modeling and data assimilation systems (including error characterization).
52
P.-Y. Le Traon
• New satellite missions for SSS (SMOS, Aquarius) and gravity (GOCE) and high resolution altimetry (SWOT) will likely have a major impact on operational oceanography. • Better management of the huge amount of data coming from various instruments is needed. We need to exploit the data in an efficient way. New tools to search, process and visualize data from different sources are required. • We are not fully exploiting the information content of satellite observations. Most observations are not yet sufficiently explored and used in ocean models. Synergy between observations (satellite, in-situ), models and new theories should be developed further. This is needed, in particular, to better exploit the high resolution information in satellite observations (e.g. Isern-Fontanet et€al. 2006).
2.9â•…Useful URLs This is a non exhaustive list of WWW sites where general information, data sets and products, softwares and toolboxes for satellite oceanography missions can be obtained. Information on existing and future satellite missions: CEOS WWW site: http://www.eohandbook.com/ Satellite altimetry: http://www.aviso.oceanobs.com http://topex-www.jpl.nasa.gov Ocean colour: http://www.ioccg.org http://oceancolour.gsfc.nasa.gov http://www.globcolour.info Sea surface temperature: http://www.ghrsst.org http://www.remss.com Multi-mission satellite data processing and distribution centers or facilities: http://www.aviso.oceanobs.com/ http://podaac-www.jpl.nasa.gov/ http://www.myocean.eu.org/ http://cersat.ifremer.fr/ http://www.osi-saf.org/ Software and toolboxes: • The European Space Agency has developed a series of toolboxes to facilitate the visualization and processing of satellite observations (ocean colour, SST, altimetry, SAR, gravimetry). http://earth.esa.int/resources/softwaretools
2â•… Satellites and Operational Oceanography
53
• SeaDAS is a NASA comprehensive image analysis package for the processing, display, analysis, and quality control of ocean colour data. http://oceancolour. gsfc.nasa.gov/seadas • Supported by UNESCO, Bilko is a complete system for learning and teaching remote sensing. http://www.noc.soton.ac.uk/bilko
References Bentamy A, Ayina H, Queffeulou P, Croize-Fillon D, Kerbaol V (2007) Improved near real time surface wind resolution over the Mediterranean sea. Ocean Sci 3(2):259–271 Bowen M, Emery WJ, Wilkin J, Tildesley P, Barton I, Knewtson R (2002) Extracting multi-year surface currents from sequential thermal imagery using the maximum cross correlation technique. J Atmos Ocean Technol 19:1665–1676 Chelton DB (2005) The impact of SST specification on ECMWF surface wind stress fields in the eastern tropical Pacific. J Clim 18:530–550 Chelton DB, Ries JC, Haines BJ, Fu LL, Callahan P (2001) Satellite altimetry. In: Fu LL, Cazenave A (eds) Satellite altimetry and earth sciences. Academic Press, San Diego Clark C, Wilson W (2009) An overview of global observing systems relevant to GODAE. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):22–33 (Special issue on the revolution of global ocean forecasting—GODAE: ten years of achievement) Donlon C, Robinson IS, Reynolds M, Wimmer W, Fisher G, Edwards R, Nightingale TJ (2008) An infrared sea surface temperature autonomous radiometer (ISAR) for deployment aboard Volunteer Observing Ships (VOS). J Atmos Ocean Technol 25:93–113 Donlon CJ, Casey KS, Robinson IS, Gentemann CL, Reynolds RW, Barton I, Arino O, Stark J, Rayner N, LeBorgne P, Poulter D, Vazquez-Cuervo J, Armstrong E, Beggs H, Llewellyn-Jones D, Minnett PJ, Merchant CJ, Evans R (2009) The GODAE high-resolution sea surface temperature pilot project, Oceanogr 22(3):34–45 Ducet N, Le Traon PY, Reverdin G (2000) Global high resolution mapping of ocean circulation from the combination of TOPEX/POSEIDON and ERS-1/2. J Geophys Res 105(C8):19477– 19498 Fu LL, Cazenave A (2001) Satellite altimetry and earth sciences. Academic Press, San Diego Gohin F, Loyer S, Lunven M, Labry C, Froidefond JM, Delmas D, Huret M, Herbland A (2005) Satellite-derived parameters for biological modelling in coastal waters: illustration over the eastern continental shelf of the Bay of Biscay. Remote Sens Environ 95(1):29–46 Guinehut S, Le Traon PY, Larnicol G (2006) What can we learn from global altimetry/hydrography comparisons? Geophys Res Lett 33, L10604. doi:10.1029/2005GL025551 Guinehut S, Coatanoan C, Dhomps A-L, Le Traon PY, Larnicol G (2008) On the use of satellite altimeter data in argo quality control. J Atmos Ocean Technol 26(2):395–402 IOCCG (2007) Ocean colour data merging. In: Gregg WW (ed) with contribution by Gregg W, Aiken J, Kwiatkowska E, Maritorena S, Mélin F, Murakami H, Pinnock S, Pottier C IOCCG monograph series, report no. 6. p€68 IOCCG (2008) Why ocean colour? The societal benefits of ocean-colour technology. In: Platt T, Hoepffner N, Stuart V, Brown C (eds) Reports of the International Ocean-Colour Coordinating Group, No.€7. IOCCG, Dartmouth, p€141 Isern-Fontanet J, Chapron B, Lapeyre G, Klein P (2006) Potential use of microwave sea surface temperatures for the estimation of ocean currents. Geophys Res Lett 33, L24608. doi:10.1029/2006GL027801 Le Traon PY, Ogor F (1998) ERS-1/2 orbit improvement using TOPEX/POSEIDON: the 2€cm challenge. J Geophys Res 103:8045–8057 Le Traon PY, Nadal F, Ducet N (1998) An improved mapping method of multisatellite altimeter data. J Atmos Ocean Technol 15:522–533
54
P.-Y. Le Traon
Le Traon PY, Rienecker M, Smith N, Bahurel P, Bell M, Hurlburt H, Dandin P (2001) Operational oceanography and prediction—a GODAE perspective. In: Koblinsky CJ, Smith NR (eds) Observing the oceans in the 21st century. GODAE project office, Bureau of Meteorology, Melbourne, pp€529–545 Le Traon PY, Johannessen J, Robinson I, Trieschmann O (2006) Report from the Working Group on space infrastructure for the GMES marine core service. GMES Fast Track Marine Core Service Strategic Implementation Plan. Final Version, 24/04/2007 Le Traon PY, Larnicol G, Guinehut S, Pouliquen S, Bentamy A, Roemmich D, Donlon C, Roquet H, Jacobs G, Griffin D, Bonjean F, Hoepffner N, Breivik LA (2009) Data assembly and processing for operational oceanography: 10 years of achievements. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):56–69 (Special issue on the revolution of global ocean forecasting—GODAE: ten years of achievement) Martin S (2004) An introduction to ocean remote sensing. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ISBN-13: 9780521802802, ISBN-10: 0521802806 Mélin F, Zibordi G (2007) An optically-based technique for producing merged spectra of water leaving radiances from ocean colour remote sensing. Appl Opt 46:3856–3869 Mitchum GT (2000) An improved calibration of satellite altimetric heights using tide gauge sea levels with adjustment for land motion. Mar Geod 23:145–166 O’Carroll AG, Eyre JR, Saunders RW (2008) Three-way error analysis between AATSR, AMSRE, and in situ sea surface temperature observations. J Atmos Ocean Technol 25:1197–1207 Oke PR, Balmaseda MA, Benkiran M, Cummings JA, Fujii Y, Guinehut S, Larnicol G, Le Traon PY, Martin MJ, Dombrowsky E (2009) Observing system evaluation. Oceanogr Mag 22(3):144–153 (Special issue on the revolution of global ocean forecasting—GODAE: ten years of achievement) Pascual A, Faugere Y, Larnicol G, Le Traon PY (2006) Improved description of the ocean mesoscale variability by combining four satellite altimeters. Geophys Res Lett 33(2), L02611, doi:10.1029/2005GL024633 Pascual A, Boone C, Larnicol G, Le Traon PY (2009) On the quality of real time altimeter gridded fields: comparison with in situ data. J Atmos Ocean Technol 26:556–569 Pottier C, Garçon V, Larnicol G, Sudre J, Schaeffer P, Le Traon PY (2006) Merging SeaWiFS and MODIS/aqua ocean colour data in north and equatorial Atlantic using weighted averaging and objective analysis. IEEE Trans Geosci Remote Sens 44:3436–3451 Robinson I (2004) Measuring the oceans from space: the principles and methods of satellite oceanography. Springer, Berlin, p€669 Smith N, Lefebvre M (1997) The global ocean data assimilation experiment (GODAE). Paper presented at Monitoring the Oceans in the 2000s: an integrated approach. Biarritz, France, 15–17 Oct 1997
Chapter 3
In-Situ Ocean Observing System Muthalagu Ravichandran
Abstract╇ Ocean Observing systems consist of in-situ and satellite based technique to detect, track, and predict changes in physical, chemical, geological and biological processes. In-situ observing systems have both Eulerian (based on fixed locations) and Lagrangian (whose location varies with time) systems. The elements of in-situ observing system in terms of their principle, capability to observe the ocean, technology and some of the applications pertaining to physical variables are described. A brief status on Indian Ocean Observing system (IndOOS) is also described. The strengths and weaknesses of each platform and the need for integrating different observational platforms/sensors are highlighted.
3.1â•…Introduction The knowledge of the ocean is essential for many stakeholders dealing with climatology, fisheries, ports and harbours, coastal zone management, navy and coast Guard organizations, public health institutions, environmental agencies, tourism industry, weather forecasters, offshore mining and oil industries and climate research. Ocean observing systems has a central role to deliver ocean services to the society. However, data produced by these systems need to be translated into ocean information services by analysis systems and also assimilated in ocean general circulation models to deliver past, present and future state of the ocean and also different products required by user agencies. A distributed or centralized data management system is critical to timely delivery of Ocean services. Ocean observation systems consist of (a) in-situ measurements, using sensors mounted on ships, buoys, moorings, coastal stations to capture changes in time and depth at specific points or tracks and (b) remote sensing systems such as satellites, aircraft, radar, M. Ravichandran () Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Services (INCOIS), Ministry of Earth Sciences, Post Box No. 21, IDA Jeedimetla, Hyderabad 500055, India e-mail:
[email protected] A. Schiller, G. B. Brassington (eds.), Operational Oceanography in the 21st Century, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-0332-2_3, ©Â€Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011
55
56
M. Ravichandran
etc to capture the spatial and temporal variations synoptically, as manifested at the surface. Remote sensing in general and satellite measurements in particular (Le Traon PY, this volume) provide horizontal distribution of surface variables, such as temperature, sea surface height, ocean color, as well as several meteorological parameters for the calculation of air-sea momentum, heat and fresh water fluxes (Masumoto et€al. 2009). These satellite data enable studies of phenomena across a very wide range of time scales, from intraseasonal to decadal and complement the in-situ observing systems. Ocean observations also help answering some fundamental research questions, such as identified by National Science Foundation (NSF) reports (NSF 2001; Koblinsky and Smith 2001). They are (a) determining the role of ocean on climate and climate change, (b) quantifying the exchange of heat, water, momentum and gases between the ocean and atmosphere, (c) determining the cycling of carbon in the oceans and the role of the oceans in moderating the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide, (d) improving models of ocean mixing and large-scale ocean circulation, (e) understanding the patterns and controls on biological diversity in the oceans, (f) determining the origin, development and impact of episodic coastal events such as harmful algal blooms, (g) assessing the health of the coastal ocean, (h) determining the nature and extent of microbial life in the deep crustal biosphere, (i) studying subduction zone thrust faults that may result in large, tsunamigenerating earthquakes and (j) improving models of global earth structure and core-mantle dynamics. Climate research became a major focus of scientific debate/discusstion by the latter half of the twentieth century, especially after the identification of the impact of green house gases and global warming on Earth’s climate system. Many countries, both the developed and developing ones, are spending considerable amount of their resources for climate research so that governments and society can take appropriate steps in planning and development. A sustained observation program to detect, track, and predict changes in physical, chemical, geological and biological systems and their effects is needed to measure the impacts of humans on the ocean as well as the impact of the human activity. The ocean, comprising over 70% of the surface of the planet, is currently monitored far less effectively and completely than terrestrial systems, yet humans depend strongly on the sea as a source of food and for transportation and trade, among many other uses. Further, the ocean strongly affects large-scale weather patterns, such as El-Niño and Sothern Oscillation (ENSO), Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD), etc. In order to understand and ultimately predict how the ocean-atmosphere interaction affects weather and climate, and how human activities affect both the physical system and living marine resources, an integrated ocean observing system is needed to monitor the ‘state’ of the ocean. Just as continuous measurements of weather and climatic conditions are maintained on land, similarly sustained measurements of the ocean are required to monitor change and to assist in understanding and predicting its impacts. There are two different classes of in-situ observing systems—those based on fixed points (Eulerian) and those whose location varies with time (Lagrangian). Fixed point observations are made either from moorings or from repeated occu-
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
57
pation of stations. Observations whose location varies with time are made from platforms that move as a result of the motion of the ocean or of a moving vessel. Some moving platforms are thought to follow the motion of water parcels fairly well. Successful operation of a global in-situ observing system requires that there be coordination of activities on a number of levels. Sensors and best practices learned from other experiences need to be agreed. Deployment opportunities need to be identified and instruments delivered to take advantage of them; where no opportunistic deployment is feasible, timely provision of special deployment efforts needs to be made. The data coverage of the system needs to be monitored along with sensor lifetimes and provision made to anticipate where gaps will appear so that deployment can be arranged. Successful implementation depends fundamentally upon near-real time transmission of both observations and relevant metadata. Given that a number of nations participate in each of the observing networks and both ‘operational’ and ‘research’ programs are involved, this monitoring/system management function is non-trivial and critical (Clark and Wilson 2009). Though some of the ocean processes can be addressed and described using local observations, many processes need to be addressed using observations from other locations since remote forcing may play an important role. Accounting for remote forcing effects would require observing all basins. But no country can afford to have observations in all basins. Hence, many national and regional programs are networked through the United Nations. The Global Ocean Observing System (GOOS) is an oceanographic component of Global Earth Observing System of Systems (GEOSS). It is a system of programmes, each of which is working on different and complementary aspects, for establishing an ocean observation capability for all of the world’s nations. UN sponsorship and UNESCO assemblies assure that international cooperation is always the first priority of the Global Ocean Observing System. GOOS is designed to (1) monitor, understand and predict weather and climate, (2) describe and forecast the state of the ocean, including living resources, (3) improve management of marine and coastal ecosystems and resources, (4) mitigate damage from natural hazards and pollution, (5) protect life and property on coasts and at sea and (6) enable scientific research. GOOS is sponsored by the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission (IOC), the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP), the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO) and the International Council for Science (ICSU), and implemented by member states via their government agencies, navies and oceanographic research institutions working together in a wide range of thematic panels and regional alliances. More detail about GOOS can be found at http://www.ioc-goos.org/. The Joint Technical Commission for Oceanography and Marine Meteorology (JCOMM) of the WMO and IOC provides coordination at the international level for oceanographic and marine observations from all in-situ observing systems. The present status of location of different elements of in-situ observing system is available at http://wo.jcommops. org/cgi-bin/WebObjects/JCOMMOPS. An in-situ observing system consists many elements such as tide gauges, ship based marine meteorology from Voluntary Observing Ships(VOS), Ships of Opportunity (SOOP) based XBT/XCTD sections, repeat hydrography, drifting and
58
M. Ravichandran
moored buoys, acoustic tomography, argo profiling floats, gliders, etc. Each element has some advantages and disadvantages in terms of temporal and spatial resolutions. Integrating all the elements, sustaining and improving the different components of observing system to meet the evolving needs for societal benefits is an imperative need for ocean observing system. Though the sensors used in these platforms/elements records primarily physical variables, the time has come to have multi-disciplinary approach to understand the total system. In the following sections, the elements of different observing systems pertaining to physical variables are explained in terms of its capability to observe the ocean, technology and some of its applications. The implementation plan for one of the poorly observed Indian Ocean is briefed in Sect.€3.3. The strengths and weaknesses of each platform and the final concluding remarks emphasizing the requirement of optimal mix of different in-situ platforms to deliver meaningful information are presented in Sect.€3.4.
3.2â•…Elements of Observing System 3.2.1 Tide Gauges The measurement of changes in sea level to understand the mechanisms responsible for phenomena such as the tides and the catastrophic floods due to storms and tsunami was performed by the observers of the Ocean from ancient times. It is now realized that sea level changes are important on all timescales from seconds (due to wind waves) through to millions of years (due to the movement of continents). The devices employed to make sea level changes (relative to the level of the land where the instrument is located) are usually called tide gauges. It is based on the principles of well-known float gauge in a stilling well, the measurement of subsurface pressure, or of the time-of-flight of a pulse of sound, or of a pulse of radar. The classical and most reliable method of measuring the sea level is by tide staff, but it is prone to manual errors. Subsequently, the float based tide gauges have been used extensively for long time. However, such systems require supporting structures, shelters and regular maintenance. The other commonly used types are pressure sensor gauges (differential/absolute) in which sensors are mounted directly in the sea. However, this require knowledge of atmospheric pressure (in case of absolute pressure sensor), seawater density and gravitational acceleration to make the conversion from pressure to sea level. In spite of the above lacuna, the instruments have many practical advantages as sea level recorders. In late 1990s, radar devices, which were mainly used in process technology, were introduced into hydrometry. Though satellite based altimeter provides mean sea level anomaly in the open ocean with coarse temporal resolution, the information from gauges is essential for understanding local mean sea level trends and extremes. Also, gauges data are required to provide precise calibration of radar altimetry. Apart from this, tide gauges have a long history and healthy future (IOC manual 2006) with many applications both in operational and scientific research.
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
59
The observed sea level consists of periodic geophysical forces such as mean sea level, a tidal signal and meteorological residuals. Each of these components is controlled by separate physical processes and the variations of each part are essentially independent of the variations in the other parts. Tides are the periodic movement of the seas which have coherent amplitude and phase relationship to some periodic geophysical force. The dominant forcing is the variation in the gravitational field on the surface of the earth due to the regular movements of the earth-moon and earthsun systems. These cause gravitational tides. There are also weak tides generated by periodic variations of atmospheric pressure and on-shore/off-shore winds which are called atmospheric tides. Meteorological residuals are the non-tidal components of sea level which remain after removing the tides by analysis. They are irregular, as are the variations in the weather. Sometimes the term “surge residual” is used but more commonly surge is used to describe a particular event during which a very large non-tidal component is generated. Mean sea level is the average level of the sea, usually based on hourly values taken over a period of at least a year. For geodetic purposes the mean sea level may be taken over several years. More elaborate techniques of analysis allow the energy in seal level variations to be split into a series of frequency or spectral components. The main concentration of energy is in the semidiurnal and diurnal tidal bands, but there is a continual background of meteorological energy which becomes more important for longer periods or lower frequencies. The Global Sea Level Observing System (GLOSS) (http://www.gloss-sealevel. org/) was established in 1985 by IOC to provide oversight and coordination for global and regional sea level networks in support of oceanographic and climate research. GLOSS remains under the auspices of the IOC and is one of the observing components of JCOMM. GLOSS is an example of a global coastal observing network and has the largest participation of member states (~70) among the existing observing elements in GOOS. Tide gauge data from the GLOSS networks are assembled and archived at two data centers (Merrifield et€ al. 2009). The British Oceanographic Data Center (BODC, http://www.bodc.ac.uk/) is responsible for delayed mode datasets. The main archive for historic, monthly-averaged, sea level records from tide gauges from around the world is available at Permanent Service for Mean Sea Level (PSMSL, http://www.pol.ac.uk/psmsl/) (Woodworth and Player 2003). Figure€3.1 shows the present status of reporting of the sea level gauges in the GLOSS Core Network (Merrifield et€al. 2009). Estimates of twentieth century sea level rise are primarily based on the historical tide gauge data maintained by the PSMSL. Church et€al. (2004) estimated monthly distributions of large scale sea level variability and change over the period 1950–2000 using historical tide gauge data and altimeter data sets. Annual averages of the global mean sea level (millimeter) as derived from analyses of tide gauges shows a global rise of 1.8â•›±â•›0.3€mm/year during 1950–2000. Tide gauges have also been used to monitor the stability of satellite altimeter sea surface height observations, long term sea level trends at coastal stations, navigation, hydrography, flood warning, tsunami warning and other coastal engineering applications.
60
M. Ravichandran
Fig. 3.1↜渀 Status of reporting of the sea level gauges in the GLOSS Core Network in 2009. Near real-time stations (↜blue) provide data typically within 1€h of collection; fast delivery (↜green) within one month. Delayed mode low frequency data within 5 years (↜yellow) or greater (↜orange) include monthly averages provided to the Permanent Service for Mean Sea Level (PSMSL). (Source: Merrifield et€al. 2009)
3.2.2 Voluntary Observing Ships The Voluntary Observing Ships (VOS) scheme is an international programme comprising member countries of the WMO/IOC that recruit ships to take, record and transmit marine meteorological observations whilst at sea. The VOS Scheme is a core observing programme of the Ship Observations Team (SOT) in the Observations Programme Area of JCOMM. There are three types of ships in the VOS Scheme such as selected ships, supplementary ships and auxiliary ships. A selected ship is equipped with sufficient certified meteorological instruments for making observations, transmits regular weather reports and enters the observations in meteorological logbooks. Most of the VOS are selected ships. A supplementary ship is equipped with a limited number of certified meteorological instruments for making observations, transmits regular weather reports and enters the observations in meteorological logbooks. An auxiliary ship is without certified meteorological instruments and transmits reports in a reduced code or in plain language, either as a routine or on request, in certain areas or under certain conditions. Auxiliary ships usually report from data-sparse areas outside the regular shipping lanes. Currently, VOS typically report every six or three hours interval, and make observations of surface wind speed and direction, air temperature, humidity, sea surface temperature (SST), atmospheric sea level pressure (SLP), cloud (including type, amount and height), wave and swell parameters and weather (including
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
61
visibility) information. The data are sent to a meteorological service as soon as they are obtained, either by radio telephony to a coastal radio station, by telex over radio, or by INMARSAT-C. Around 5,000 ships are presently reporting marine meteorological parameters. Observations, such as sea ice and precipitation can also be reported. The temperature (air and SST), humidity and SLP are measured in-situ by meteorological instruments, whilst waves, clouds and weather types are estimated visually. Wind reports are a mixture of measurements and visual estimates. The observations are transmitted in real time and also recorded in paper or, with increasing frequency, electronic logbooks. The electronic logbook software is also used to format manual observations, calculate more uniformly (e.g. dewpoint, true wind) and perform simple quality control (Kent et€al. 2009). Automated weather stations (AWSs) are being installed on VOS in increasing numbers, resulting in more frequent observations. However, a systematic programme of intercomparison with the traditional observations to ensure data continuity in keeping with GCOS monitoring principles is presently lacking. Moreover, a full high-quality AWS is expensive and some national services install low cost systems making only a subset of the normal range of observations, typically SLP and one or two other variables. Some elements of the VOS report require manual input, typically the visual estimates. Convincing the observers that supplementing the reports with this vital information is worthwhile has proved challenging, and the introduction of AWSs has led to a marked decline in the proportion of reports containing these parameters. Adding the capability for manual input adds to both the cost and complexity of the systems and is not always judged to be cost-effective. The surface ocean observing system has evolved rapidly over the past half century, from being primarily VOS-based through the 1960s, to comprising increasing numbers of moored and drifting buoy observations starting in the 1970s and particularly dominating the last decade. Kent et€al. (2009) show an example of how the number of in-situ observations available in the International Comprehensive Ocean-Atmosphere Data Set (ICOADS) has changed over time for selected variables, with the impact of the drifting buoys clearly visible for SST. These in-situ observations have been complemented by satellite measurements that began in the late 1970s. To meet the needs of applications such as weather forecasting, VOS observations are transmitted in real time to the National Meteorological and Hydrological Services (NMHSs) who then share the observations with other services using the Global Telecommunications System (GTS). Some NMHSs keep an archive of the data extracted from the GTS, however, these can differ between services due to differences in data conversion and storage formats and the way in which the data are retrieved from the GTS. VOS data contain fairly large random uncertainties, but in many regions the mean uncertainty due to poor sampling is much larger (Kent and Berry 2008; Gulev et€al. 2007). In well-sampled regions the random uncertainties in gridded datasets will be small as many observations can be averaged. Sampling by multiple platforms gives the potential for extensive quality assurance, including near neighbour “buddy checks” and analysis of outliers. Typically VOS grid box averages contain observations from multiple platforms, allowing random uncertainty and also ship-to-ship biases to be reduced by the averaging process.
62
M. Ravichandran
Datasets and analyses based on ICOADS are highly cited in the literature and form an important resource for climate researchers, especially those interested in large-scale estimates of ocean-atmosphere exchange of heat, freshwater and momentum and multidecadal climate variability. Datasets using VOS observations— in many cases based on the ICOADS collection include SST, sea level pressure, air temperature and humidity, surface fluxes and surface waves. In addition, it should be noted that atmospheric model reanalyses, which are widely used for climate analysis, are heavily dependent on the assimilation of ship observations (Trenberth et€al. 2009). National and international assessments of climate change, most prominently by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), use VOS SST data in the assessment of global mean surface temperature changes. Confidence in the SST trend is increased by its consistency with the marine surface air temperature trend, which is an independent measurement. VOS are the major source of air temperature information over the ocean and also contribute to the monitoring of climate change, for example in the bias-adjustment of infrared satellite estimates of SST (e.g., Reynolds et€al. 2005). VOS also provide a consistent record of cloud changes since 1949 and have been used to derive a century-long analysis of wave information. The continuing move to produce data products in a timely manner from VOS data should allow an enhanced climate monitoring role for the VOS, if sampling can be maintained or improved. However, VOS datasets are currently underutilized for calibration and validation. New higher-resolution datasets characterised by uncertainty estimates should have wide applications for calibration and validation.
3.2.3 Ships of Opportunity The primary objective of the Ship-of-Opportunity Programme (SOOP) is to fulfill the XBT upper ocean data requirements established by the international scientific and operational communities, which can be met at present by measurements from ships of opportunity. The annual assessment of transect sampling is undertaken by the Joint WMO-IOC Technical Commission for Oceanography and Marine Meteorology (JCOMMOPS) on behalf of the Ship Of Opportunity Programme Implementation Panel (SOOPIP). Data management is taken care of through the Global Temperature Salinity Profile Programme (GTSPP) (Goni et€al. 2009). The SOOP is directed primarily towards the continued operational maintenance and co-ordination of the XBT ship of opportunity network but other types of measurements are also being made (e.g. TSG, XCTD, CTD, ADCP, pCO2, phytoplankton concentration). This network in itself supports many other operational needs (such as for fisheries, shipping, defense, etc.) through the provision of upper ocean data for data assimilation in models and for various other ocean analysis schemes. One of the continuing challenges is to optimally combine upper ocean thermal data collected by XBTs with data collected from other sources such as mooring arrays, Argo, and satellites (e.g. AVHRR, altimeter, etc.). However, it is considered most important
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
63
to have the SOOP focused on supporting climate prediction in order to ensure the continued operation of the present network. XBT (Expendable BathyThermograph) is an expendable temperature and depth profiling system. It is typically comprised of an acquisition system onboard the ship, a launcher, and a expandable temperature probe. The falling probe is linked to the acquisition system through a thin insulated conductive wire which is used to transmit the temperature data back to the acquisition system in real time. Depth is deduced from elapsed time using a well calibrated fall rate equation (about 6.5€m/s). Processed profile data can be transmitted in real-time through satellite. The realtime data is being archived at Coriolis data center, Brest, France and the delayed mode data at GTSPP managed by NOAA/NODC. Profiles as deep as 1,000€ m and comprising (T, D) data points every meter can be made although with usual probes depths range from 500 to 800€m. Accuracy is normally better than 5€m for depth, and better than 0.05°C for temperature. The Global XBT network containing OceanObs’99 recommendations and current proposed transects recommended in OceanObs’09 is shown in Fig.€3.2. The scientific and operational communities deploy approximately 23,000 XBTs every year. In a typical year, 50% are deployed in the Pacific Ocean, 35% in the Atlantic Ocean and 15% in the Indian Ocean. Profiles from about 90% of the XBT deployments are transmitted in real-time, which represent around 25% of the current real-time vertical temperature profile observations (not counting the continuous temperature profiles made by some moorings). XBT operates three modes of deployment: (a) High Density (HD): 4 transects per year, 1 XBT deployment every approximately 25€km (35 XBT deployments per day with a ship speed of 20€kts), (b) Frequently repeated (FR): 12–18 transects per year, 6 XBT deployments per day (every 100–150€km) and (c) Low Density (LD): 12 transects per year, 4 XBT deployments per day. The HD transects extend from ocean boundary (continental shelf) to ocean boundary, with temperature profiling at spatial separations that vary from 10 to 50€km in order to resolve boundary currents and to estimate basin-scale geostrophic velocity and mass transport integrals. PX06 (Auckland to Fiji), which began in 1986, is the earliest HD transect in the present network with more than 90 realizations. Some transects are being assessed for their contribution in this mode. For example, the CLIVAR IOP noted that further work is required to assess the value of IX10, which transects the openings of the Bay of Bengal and the Arabian Sea. Scientific objectives of HD sampling and examples of research targeting these objectives are outlined in Goni et€al. (2009). The FR transects cross major ocean current systems and thermal structures. In some cases, for currents near a continental boundary an extra profile that crosses the 200€m depth contour is made to mark the inshore edge of the current. The FR transects are selected to observe specific features of thermal structure (e.g. thermocline ridges), where ocean atmosphere interaction is strong. Estimates of geostrophic velocity and mass transport integrals across the currents are made by low pass mapping of temperature and dynamical properties on the section. The proto-types of FR transects are IX01 and PX02, which now have time series extending more than
64
M. Ravichandran
Fig. 3.2↜渀 (↜top) XBT network containing OceanObs’99 recommendations and (↜bottom) proposed transects in OceanObs’09. XBT observations transmitted in (↜red) real and (↜blue) delayed-time in 2008. (Source: Goni et€al. 2009)
20 years. The earliest transect from Fremantle to Sunda Strait (Indonesia) began in 1983, has been sampled at 18 times per year after 1986. IX01 crosses the currents between Australia and Indonesia, including the Indonesian Throughflow and has been used in many studies of the Throughflow and the Indian Ocean Dipole. The FR sampling produces well resolved monthly time series of thermal structure along transects. Using IX01, Meyers et€al. (1995) shown the mean thermal structure generally westward flow in the deeper part of the thermocline and eastward shear in the shallow (<150€m) layer. Also, brought out the strongest variability in temperature is at the northern end of the transect near Indonesia. The temperature sections were used to understand the relationship of interannual variation in transport of Indonesian Throughflow to ENSO (Meyers 1996). Further, the time-variation of
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
65
temperature at the north end of IX01 clearly shows the strong, subsurface upwelling associated with the start of the IOD events of 1994 and 1997, before the start of surface cooling. These and the other FRX time series have been used to understand how subsurface thermal structure varies across the Indian Ocean during IOD events (e.g. Rao et€al. 2002; Feng and Meyers 2003). The use of FR lines in the Indonesian region to study the Indonesian Through-flow is discussed in the Indian Ocean white paper (Masumoto et€al. 2009). Low density transects have both operational and scientific objectives, such as investigate intraseasonal to interannual variability in the tropical oceans, measuring temporal variability of boundary currents, and investigating the historical relationship between sea surface height and upper ocean thermal structure. Many illustrative examples of applications of XBT observations, primarily from LD mode, are presented in the XBT white paper (Goni et€al. 2009).
3.2.4 Drifting Buoys For several years, oceanographers and meteorologists have deployed satellitetracked drifting buoys in support of their research and operational programmes. These two bodies of users have, however, sought different capabilities from their drifters: the oceanographers have mainly looked for designs which accurately follow water parcels at a given depth, whereas the meteorologists have equipped their drifters with air-pressure sensors to collect real-time observations for weather forecasting. Despite efforts by both user groups to develop combined programmes, these two main requirements have been largely incompatible, particularly in respect to the size and above-surface exposure of the drifter. The success of the low-cost WOCE Surface Velocity Programme (SVP) oceanographic drifter, with its accurately quantified water following characteristics and proven longevity, prompted renewed interest in the development of a low cost met-ocean drifter capable of satisfying the needs of both user communities. The result is the SVP Barometer (SVP-B) drifter, whose design and use is described in the DBCP Report (Sybrandy et€al. 2009). This design, refined over several years and after extensive testing, further develops the original SVP drifter by inclusion of a novel barometer port. This inexpensive but stable pressure sensor combined with a data filtering algorithm removes pressure spikes resulting from the repeated immersion of the drifter by waves. Drifting buoys normally measure sea surface temperature (SST) and air pressure, and by tracking their positions the surface currents (resultant current arising from Ekman and geostrophic) can be determined. Some drifters also have sensors to measure wind, temperature profile and salinity. The buoys are battery powered and typically last for one to two years. The buoys are disposable and can be deployed at sea by regular ship crews. Measurements are normally made hourly and the data are transmitted by satellite. Most drifters use the ARGOS satellite system for data transmission and positioning, although new systems such as Iridium are currently being evaluated as a pilot programme. At present, users can access web
66
M. Ravichandran
pages at both ISDM (http://www.meds-sdmm.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/isdm-gdsi/drib-bder/ index-eng.htm) and AOML (http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/phod/dac/gdp.html), where products and data are available. Integrated Science Data Management (ISDM) in Canada became a Responsible National Oceanographic Data Centre (RNODC) for Drifting Buoy Data on behalf of JCOMMOPS. The present status of global drifters as on November 09, 2009 is shown in Fig.€3.3. Drifting buoys, along with Voluntary Observing Ships, provide the primary source of air pressure data over the oceans that are needed to run global and regional weather forecasting models. The SST data provided by drifting buoys are important for climate data sets. The key application of surface drifter data is reduction of the bias error in satellite SST measurements, mapping large scale surface currents and identifying their role in heat transports and the generation of SST patterns and variability. They are invaluable as an independent validation tools for model and satellite derived currents (ekmanâ•›+â•›geostrophic), synthesized with altimetry and satellite winds to estimate absolute sea surface height (Niiler et€al. 2003; Rio and Hernandez 2003) and used to understand the role of surface transport in the genesis of the El Niño (Picaut et€al. 2002; Lagerloef et€al. 2003; McPhaden 2004). Maximenko et€al. (2008) compared the drifter-sensemble averaged velocities and a sum of time averaged geostrophic and Ekman currents, and concluded that one drifter per 5â•›×â•›5° grid is not adequate to capture/resolve most of the surface current features. Dohan et€al. (2009) describes the data quality from drifters and the principal scientific insights during the last decade. There are numerous direct uses of sea surface velocity, such as for navigation and drift trajectories, advection calculations of ocean properties, spills, and Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) operations, etc. Also, drifting buoy data are used for many applications such as to study physical characteristics and climatology of sea ice within the Antarctic sea ice zone. These data are also used for many applications such as to trace the seasonal pathways of freshwater plumes (Sengupta et€al. 2006), improving the surface current climatology (Shenoi et€al. 1999), etc.
3.2.5 Acoustic Tomography The ocean is largely transparent to sound, but opaque to electromagnetic radiation. Underwater sound is therefore a powerful tool for remote sensing of the ocean interior. This technique is used in Ocean Acoustic Tomography. It is used to measure temperatures and currents over large regions of the ocean (Munk et€al. 1995). On ocean basin scales, this technique is also known as acoustic thermometry. The technique relies on precisely measuring the time it takes sound signals to travel between two instruments, acoustic source and a receiver, by distance within the range of 100–5,000€km. If the locations of the instruments are known precisely, the measurement of time-of-flight can be used to infer the speed of sound, averaged over the acoustic path. Changes in the speed of sound are primarily caused by changes in the temperature of the ocean; hence the measurement of the travel times is equivalent to a measurement of temperature. A 1°C change in temperature corresponds to about
Fig. 3.3↜渀 Present status of global drifters and Moorings as on August 2010 (closed circle-drifting buoys; square-moored buoys). (Source: JCOMMOPS)
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System 67
68
M. Ravichandran
4€m/s change in sound speed. An oceanographic experiment employing tomography typically uses several source-receiver pairs in a moored array that measures an area of ocean. Sound is widely used for remote sensing of the ocean on small scales (e.g., acoustic Doppler current profilers), but acoustical measurements have been underexploited in regional and global ocean observations relative to in-situ instruments and electromagnetic radiation (Dushaw et€al. 2009). This technique integrates temperature variations over a large region hence the smaller scale turbulent and internal-wave features that usually dominate point measurements are averaged out and we can better determine the large-scale dynamics. For example, measurements by thermometers (i.e., moored or Argo floats) have to contend with this 1–2°C noise, so that large numbers of instruments are required to obtain an accurate measure of average temperature. For measuring the average temperature of ocean basins, therefore, the acoustic measurement is quite cost effective. Tomographic measurements also average variability over depth as well, since the ray paths cycle throughout the water column. Basinwide and regional tomography were accepted as part of the ocean observing system by OceanObs’99 (Koblinsky and Smith 2001; Dushaw et€ al. 2001). Since then, a decade of measurements of basinscale temperature using acoustic thermometry have been completed in the North Pacific Ocean. In this project acoustic sources located off central California (1996–1999) and north of Kauai (1996–1999, 2002–2006) transmitted to receivers distributed throughout the northeast and north central Pacific. The result shows that the interannual, seasonal, and shorter period variability was large; as compared to the long term decadal trends. Acoustic traveltime data have been used previously in simple data assimilation experiments, and they can now be compared to assimilation products from state-of-the-art models from the ECCO (Estimating the Circulation and Climate of the Ocean) Consortium. Not surprisingly, comparisons between measured travel times and those predicted using Ocean models, constrained by satellite altimeter and other data show significant similarities and differences. Measured acoustic travel times have uncertainties much less than the differences between two model implementations by the ECCO Consortium. The acoustic data ultimately need to be combined with upper-ocean data from Argo floats and, sea surface height data from satellite altimeters to detect changes in abyssal ocean temperature and to quantitatively determine the complementarity of the various data types (Dushaw 2003). Apart from this, the passive acoustics can be used for a variety of purposes such as: tracking, counting and studying the behavior of vocalizing marine mammals and fish; assessing and monitoring the ecological impacts of ocean warming and acidification on marine ecosystems and biodiversity; detecting nuclear tests; detecting and quantifying tsunamis; measuring rainfall (Riser et€al. 2008); measuring the properties of undersea earthquakes (e.g., de GrootHedlin 2005) and volcanoes; monitoring the sound produced by high latitude sea ice; monitoring anthropogenic activities in marine protected areas and also in commercial use. The acoustic measurements supporting these projects can be real time and provide information about local ambient noise sources such as shipping, wind, rain, as well as noise from offshore wind farms.
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
69
3.2.6 Repeat Hydrography and Carbon Inventory Despite numerous technological advances over the last several decades, ship-based hydrography using research vessel remains the only method for obtaining highquality, high spatial and vertical resolution measurements of a suite of physical, chemical, and biological parameters over the full water column (Hood et€al. 2009). It is worth mentioning here that VOS and SOOP collect data while cruising, whereas research vessel stops at different locations and collect surface and subsurface data upto full vertical resolution. Ship-based hydrography is essential for documenting ocean changes throughout the water column, especially for the deep ocean below 2€km (52% of global ocean volume). Hydrographic measurements are needed to (a) reduce uncertainties in global freshwater, heat, and sea-level budgets, (b) determine the distributions and controls of natural and anthropogenic carbon (both organic and inorganic), (c) determine ocean ventilation and circulation pathways and rates using chemical tracers, (d) determine the variability and controls in water mass properties and ventilation, (e) determine the significance of a wide range of biogeochemically and ecologically important properties in the ocean interior, and (f) augment the historical database of full water column observations necessary for the study of long-timescale changes. Shipboard hydrographic data provide the quality standard against which the data from floats and other autonomous platforms and XBTs are compared, to assess their accuracy and for detection and correction of systematic errors. The high cost of shipboard hydrography is balanced against its broad and unique capability to measure many parameters that cannot be measured by other means, and to measure those that can with highest accuracy. Cost factors limit the global hydrographic survey to less than 103 profiles per year from the ocean surface to the bottom, while Argo floats deliver 105 thousand temperature/salinity profiles per year in the upper 2€km. The recommended hydrographic sections for the sustained decadal survey is shown in Fig.€3.4. Due to the increasing amount of Argo profiling floats in the ocean and to their moving nature, Argo floats cannot be recovered and their sensors cannot be recalibrated at the end of their lifetime. The main problem concerns the conductivity sensor that may drift or show an offset due to biological fooling and other problems. To ensure the quality of data, salinity drift in the conductivity sensors are adjusted by comparison of Argo salinity to nearby high-quality salinity/temperature data (Wong and Owens 2009). In addition to salinity drift, systematic errors in float pressure measurements are also an ongoing concern (e.g. Willis et€al. 2008). For both of these issues, the process of identifying and correcting systematic errors is dependent on, and its effectiveness is limited by, the volume and spatial distribution of recent shipboard CTD profiles. The requirements have not yet been established for high quality reference CTD data needed to validate and correct Argo. Similarly, shipboard CTD data are used to assess systematic changes over time in temperature versus depth errors from XBTs, for example to estimate and adjust the instrument’s fall rate (Wijffels et€al. 2008). Other parameters are required to be collected since
70
M. Ravichandran
90°N 60°N 30°N EQ 30°S 60°S 90°S
90°E
180°W
90°W
0°
Fig. 3.4↜渀 Recommended hydrographic sections for the sustained decadal survey (↜solid lines) and high-frequency repeat lines (↜dashed lines)
future Argo floats are likely to carry sensors for dissolved oxygen, chlorophyll-A, particulate organic carbon, and possibly others. The CLIVAR and Carbon Hydrographic Data Office (CCHDO) is the repository and distribution center for global CTD, hydrographic, carbon, and tracer data of the highest quality. These data are a product of WOCE, CLIVAR, the International Ocean Carbon Coordination Project (IOCCP), and other oceanographic research programs—past, present and to come. Hydrographic data acquired by investigators are pooled, verified, assembled and disseminated to users in different formats. The CCHDO’s primary window to the research community is via its web site (http:// cchdo.ucsd.edu).
3.2.7 Moorings Moorings are capable of measuring some of the key variables needed to describe, understand and predict large-scale ocean dynamics and ocean–atmosphere interactions. Marine meteorological variables include those needed to characterize fluxes of momentum, heat and fresh water across the air–sea interface, namely, surface winds, SST, air temperature, relative humidity, downward short and long-wave radiation, barometric pressure and precipitation. Physical oceanographic variables include upper-ocean temperature, salinity and horizontal currents. From these basic variables, derived quantities, such as latent and sensible heat, net surface radiation, penetrative shortwave radiation, mixed-layer depth, ocean density, and dynamic height (the baroclinic component of sea level) can be computed. The array design focuses on these marine meteorological and physical oceanographic variables,
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
71
though not all moorings will measure all variables. The moorings can also support sensors to measure CO2 concentrations in air and sea water, nutrients, bio-optical properties and ocean acoustics (International Clivar Project Office 2006). The Global Tropical Moored Buoy Array (GTMBA) is a multi-national effort to provide meteorological and ocean observational data in real-time for climate research and forecasting (McPhaden et€ al. 2009a). The buoys are used to collect oceanographic and meteorological data for monitoring forecasting, and climate research, particularly for ENSO studies. The array consists of the Tropical Atmosphere Ocean/Triangle Trans-Ocean Buoy Network (TAO/TRITON) in the Pacific, the Prediction and Research Moored Array in the Tropical Atlantic (PIRATA), and the Research Moored Array for African-Asian-Australian Monsoon Analysis and Prediction (RAMA) in the Indian Ocean. These observing systems were designed and implemented within the framework of GOOS and GCOS. The primary objectives are to study intraseasonal to decadal time scales including ENSO and the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) in the Pacific, the meridional gradient mode and equatorial warm events in the Atlantic, the IOD and the Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO) in the Indian Ocean, the mean seasonal cycle, including the Asian, African, Australian, and American monsoons and trends in all three basins that may be related to global warming. However, these observations will complement other in-situ and satellite observational components of Global observing systems. The GTMBA is built primarily around the Autonomous Temperature Line Acquisition System (ATLAS) moorings of NOAA’s Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory (PMEL) and TRITON moorings of Japan Agency for Marine-Earth Science and Technology (JAMSTEC). The Schematic diagram of the ATLAS moorings with the locations of different sensors fitted on the buoys and on the moorings is available in PMEL website. These moorings have special attributes that make them a valuable technology for tropical climate studies. In particular, (1) they can be instrumented to measure both upper ocean and surface meteorological variables involved in ocean-atmosphere interactions; (2) they provide time series measurements at fine temporal resolution (minutes to hours) to resolve high frequency oceanic and atmospheric fluctuations that would otherwise be aliased into the lower frequency climate signals of primary interest; (3) they can be deployed and maintained on a fixed grid of stations, so that measurements do not distort the variability in time and space. The data from surface moorings are transmitted to shore via ARGOS satellite in real-time, which ensures (a) use of these data for operational weather, Ocean, and climate forecasting and (b) retrieval of data even if a mooring is lost. The data are posted daily and made freely available on the NOAA/Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory GTMBA web site (http://www. pmel.noaa.gov/tao/global/global.html) as well as several web sites maintained by partner institutions around the world. Service Argos inserts the data on the GTS several times a day. Details about different types of moorings used in the GTMBA, including subsurface ADCP and deep ocean moorings, can be found in McPhaden et€ al. (2009a). Mooring sensor specifications (accuracy, resolution, range), sensor calibration procedures, and data quality control for both real-time and delayed
72
M. Ravichandran *OREDO7URSLFDO0RRUHG%XR\$UUD\
1
7$2
75,721
1 6 6
6ROLG 2SHUDWLQJ 2SHQ 3ODQQHG
5$0$ (
(
6WDQGDUG0RRULQJ )OX[5HIHUHQFH6LWH )OX[DQG&2(QKDQFHG
:
3,5$7$ :
(
&2(QKDQFHG &2DQG%LR±&KHP(QKDQFHG
Fig. 3.5↜渀 The Global tropical moored buoy array in October 2009. (Source: McPhaden et€al. 2009a)
mode data streams are available from websites maintained by PMEL and JAMSTEC website. The present status of GTMBA array in the Global ocean is shown in Fig.€3.5. TAO/TRITON data have been used in over 600 refereed journal publications since its inception in 1985. TAO/TRITON has been the dominant source of upper ocean temperature data near the equator over the past 25 years. The data show that depth average temperature in the upper 300€m, an index for upper ocean heat content, leads Niño3.4 SST (area-average SST anomalies between 5°N–5°S and 170°–120°W) typically by 1–3 seasons. A build up of heat content at the end of this record, followed by rising Niño3.4 SSTs, indicates development of the current 2009 El Niño event. This relationship between upper ocean heat content and SST not only validates recharge oscillator theory, but also highlights the role of heat content as the primary source of predictability for ENSO. The simple relationship has motivated the inclusion of upper ocean heat content as a predictor in some statistical ENSO forecast models (e.g., Clarke and van Gorder 2003; McPhaden et€al. 2006), analogous to the assimilation of upper ocean temperature in dynamical ENSO forecast models (e.g., Latif et€al. 1998). PIRATA data have been very influential in identifying the causes of the observed SST variations in the tropical north Atlantic over the past 10 years (McPhaden 2008). Year-to-year swings in tropical north Atlantic SST appear to be principally related to wind-evaporationSST feedbacks (Chang et€al. 2001) with contributions from shortwave radiation and horizontal advection. RAMA, even in the initial stages of development, is providing valuable data for describing and understanding variability in the Indian Ocean. For example, a pronounced semiannual cycle in upper-ocean temperature, salinity, and zonal velocity is evident in the first three years of data from near-equatorial moorings at 90°E (Hase et€al. 2008). The semi-annual velocity variations are referred to as Wyrtki Jets and their zonal mass transports are largely governed by wind-forced linear dynamics (Nagura and McPhaden 2008). They are also strongly modulated on 30–50 day intraseasonal time scales related to the MJO (Masumoto et€al.
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
73
2005). Variations in meridional velocity on the equator in contrast are dominated by higher frequency 10–20 day period oscillations, which are evident not only in the upper 400€m but also at depths greater than 2,000€m (Murty et€al. 2006; Ogata et€ al. 2008). Sengupta et€ al. (2004) identified these oscillations as wind forced mixed Rossby-gravity waves. RAMA data indicate that subsurface temperature variations lead those at the surface by a season near the equator in eastern basin, suggesting that upper ocean thermal structure may be a source of predictability for the IOD as in the Pacific for ENSO (Horii et€al. 2008). Moored buoy data are routinely used in ocean state estimation, operational ocean analyses, operational atmospheric analyses and reanalyses. These data have also been used extensively for model validation, and for satellite validation of surface winds, SST, rainfall, and shortwave radiation. Further, in order to build and maintain a multidisciplinary global network for a broad range of research and operational applications, the new program “OceanSITES” is evolving (Send et€al. 2009). The OceanSITES program is the global network of open-ocean sustained time-series measurements, called ocean reference stations, being implemented by an international partnership of researchers. OceanSITES provides fixed-point time series of various physical, biogeochemical, and atmospheric variables at different locations around the globe, from the atmosphere and sea surface to the seafloor. OceanSITES moorings are an integral part of the Global Ocean Observing System. They complement satellite and other in-situ data by adding the dimensions of time and depth. All OceanSITES data are publicly available. More information about the project is available at http://www.oceansites.org.
3.2.8 Argo Profiling Floats The Argo “oceanographic radiosonde” is a revolutionary concept that enhances the real time capability for the measurement of temperature and salinity through the upper 2,000€m in the ice free global Ocean. The exclusion of the high latitudes was due to the inability of early floats to sample under sea-ice. However, technological advances in float design in recent years now give us this capability. Advancements have come through re-design of hardware (i.e. armoured ice floats with ice-hardened antennae), software (ice-avoidance algorithms and open-water test) and communications (Iridium), allowing the transmission of stored winter profiles. Following the geostrophic principles, along with reference level velocities of the ocean, it contributes to the global description of the variability of the upper ocean thermohaline structure and circulation on seasonal and inter-annual time scales. Under a unique, internationally coordinated effort, it has been established as a global array of about 3,000 floats at a spatial resolution of 3°â•›×â•›3° grids. The data from these floats have helped to study the state of the upper ocean and the patterns of ocean climate variability, including heat and freshwater storage and transport (Freeland et€al. 2009). The data are collected by Argo floats that spend most of their working life drifting with the currents at depth (they are stabilized at
74
M. Ravichandran
a constant level by being less compressible than sea water) of 1,000 or 2,000€m. At typically 10 day intervals, the floats pump fluid into an external bladder and rise to the surface (taking about 6€h) and measure a profile of temperature and salinity. On surfacing the data are downloaded to the satellites (ARGOS or Iridium) which also obtains a series of float positions. When this task is completed the bladder deflates, the float thus returns to its original density and returns to depth to drift until the (usually 10 day) cycle is repeated. Data from Argo floats are available to users through two streams—real time (with only gross errors corrected or flagged) and delayed-mode (where corrections to salinity values have been estimated by experts familiar with the particular geographical environment). At present the delayed mode data delivery system has yet to be fully implemented. The real time data are placed on the GTS that delivers (mostly meteorological) data to operational centers throughout world. They are also available through two linked Argo Global Data Centres (GDACs) in Brest, France (Coriolis) and Monterey, California (US GODAE server). The global distribution of floats reporting on the Argo system as on Sept 2010 is shown in Fig.€3.6. Argo floats bridge the complementary nature of the direct and remote observing systems, filling the large gaps that exist in the global sampling network, and providing essential information for sub surface ocean state estimation. The combination of Argo and satellite altimetry has enabled a new generation of applications. Global maps of sea level, on time scales of weeks to several years, will be interpreted with full knowledge of the upper ocean stratification. Global Ocean and climate models can be initialized, tested and constrained with a level of information hitherto not available. The drift estimates from such an array would in addition provide useful estimates of deep pressure fields (reference level). Altimeters, together with the sea level gauge network, provide accurate measurements of time-varying sea surface height (SSH) globally every 10 days. On seasonal and longer time-scales, SSH is dominated by changes in subsurface density. The cause of mean sea level change is mainly due to change in volume and shape of the ocean basins at comparatively long time scales. The change in volume is caused by the changes in sea water density (steric) and mass (eustatic). The change in temperature (thermosteric) and salinity (halosteric) of the water column can change sea water density, whereas melting of glaciers in land and Artic and Greenland ice will change the mass of the water in the Ocean. The shape of the ocean basin changes due to vertical land movement, which is associated with local tectonic activity and post glacial rebound of land. The contribution of the steric and eusatic for the total sea level rise can be quantified using Argo profiling floats and GRACE respectively and which can indirectly compared to altimeter sea level data. On global scales, Argo and Jason, together with satellite gravity measurements, partition global sea level rise into its steric and mass-related components (Willis et€al. 2008; Cazenave et€al. 2009; Leuliette and Miller 2009; Wunsch et€al. 2007). Applications of Argo data are numerous and varied, including initialization of ENSO forecast models, initialization of short-range ocean forecasts, routine production of high-quality global ocean analyses, and studies of predictability on interannual and decadal time scales. A substantial improvement in seasonal forecast skill
Fig. 3.6↜渀 The global distribution Argo profiling floats locations reporting on the Argo data system as on December 2010. (Source: JCOMMOPS)
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System 75
76
M. Ravichandran
due to Argo profile data has been demonstrated (Balmaseda and Anderson 2009), even during the period prior to full deployment of the Argo array. The combination of Argo (provides spatial coverage) and moorings provides the high temporal resolution needed for equatorial wave propagation and intra-seasonal variability and also for observing tropical variability at greater depth (Matthews et€al. 2007), and beyond the equatorial band and in all oceans (Cai et€al. 2005). Data from Argo and RAMA were used to illustrate air-sea interaction contributing to the growth of the devastating 2008 tropical cyclone Nargis (McPhaden et€al. 2009c). Heat and fresh water are fundamental elements of climate, and climate variability can be quantified by tracking heat and fresh water as they are transported and stored, and exchanged between, the atmosphere, oceans, land, and cryosphere. The temperature and salinity profile measurements over the global ocean provides the estimates of both the storage and large-scale transport of heat and freshwater (Freeland et€al. 2009 and reference therein). Although Argo is able to provide information on the ocean’s role in the planetary heat and water budgets, the important contributions of boundary currents (Send et€al. 2009) in ocean heat transport and of the abyssal oceans in heat storage are not yet adequately observed since the boundary currents, fronts, and eddies require finer resolution in the observing sampling rages. The most direct effect from the ocean comes from the surface effect i.e. sea surface temperature as well as sea level variability. Satellites provide global views of sea surface temperature and, in future, sea surface salinity. These data require in-situ measurements for calibration purposes, and for their interpretation. Argo can help satisfy both of these requirements. For example, Uday Bhaskar et€al. (2009), using satellite and in-situ data, have shown that Argo near surface temperature (5 or 10€m) can be used as SST in the Indian Ocean. Argo’s observation of surface layer structure globally, contributes to studies of atmosphere-ocean interactions (Freeland et€al. 2009 and references therein). Ocean salinity is an important component (indicator) of the “global water cycle” variability. It provides information on the exchange of freshwater with the atmosphere (e.g., evaporation, precipitation) and with the terrestrial and cryospheric components of the global climate system, and on storage within the ocean. Ocean salinity is a fundamental ocean state variable and a tracer of ocean circulation—an important dynamical ocean process that governs the uptake and redistribution of ocean heat and carbon, which are critical elements of the global climate system. Thus to understand and predict the global water cycle in the context of global climate change it be only be fully realized with the understanding of the marine branch of the hydrological cycle. Also ocean salinity changes have a direct impact on the exchange of CO2 between ocean and atmosphere and may affect marine species and ecosystems. Current knowledge of ocean salinity variability is hampered by a lack of enough long-term salinity records. Available observations indicate that remarkable changes of ocean salinity are underway in some regions. Unfortunately, it is unclear if these changes are attributable to natural variations, what processes may be involved, how they may or may not be consistent with changes in other components (e.g., precipitation) of the global water cycle, how long such changes have been underway, or how widespread they might be. The Argo float observation network is a critical component of a global salinity observing system.
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
77
3.2.9 HF Radar Real-time surface current information is a valuable supplement to understanding coastal air-sea interaction and dynamical processes at the coastal scales. Coastal surface current information may be correlated to winds and tidal currents among other physical phenomena. High-frequency (HF) radars have been used for measuring surface current fields and ocean-wave spectra. The physics behind HF radar is based on backscattering from a moving rough sea surface. The Radar transmits electromagnetic waves of 6–30€MHz (50–10€m wavelength), which travel along the sea surface beyond the horizon by ground wave propagation and are scattered back from ocean waves of half the electromagnetic wavelength (Bragg scattering). The scattered signals are measures of the Doppler spectrum caused by moving waves and speed of the surface currents carrying the ocean waves. Guided propagation along the conductive sea surface (ground wave) allows measurements beyond the horizon. It can also be inferred Ocean wave height and the wave directional spectrum using second-order sea echos of the Doppler spectrum. The Doppler shift of the backscattered signal is used for measuring the radial current speed relative to the radar site. If the two radar sites measure the radial velocity of a patch of water from two different angles, it is possible to calculate the two horizontal components of the surface velocity. The surface current measured is a horizontal mean over several km in both range and azimuth, over approximately the upper 0.5–1.0€m of the ocean (penetration depth of scattering ocean waves), and over some 10€min measuring time. These radar sites provide coastal-ocean surface current and wave information offshore out to 300€km. More detailed descriptions of the theory of HF radar can be found in numerous articles (e.g., Gurgel et€al. 1999; Barrick et€al. 1985). As part of the integrated ocean observing system (IOOS), the US has installed a number of HF radars on the west and east coasts of US. Prototype real-time data architecture, initially developed through funding from the National Science Foundation (NSF), is now being integrated by the Coastal Observing Research and Development Center (CORDC) at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography with existing HF radar data networks through a joint development program administered and managed by the National Data Buoy Center (NDBC) and the National Ocean Service (NOS), with oversight provided by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s (NOAA) IOOS program office (Terrill et€al. 2006). An excellent online reference containing an introduction to the principles of HF Radar can be found on the Rutgers University Coastal Ocean Observation Lab (RUCOOL, http:// marine.rutgers.edu/cool). The coastal radar locations on the east/west coast of the US and daily average values of surface currents (6€km) derived from HF Radar along the coast of the US are available at http://cordc.ucsd.edu/projects/mapping/maps/. The validation of both wave with moorings and current observations with surface drifters are explained in detail by Kohut et al. (2008). Surface current observations using HF Radar and its assimilation into the NewYork Harbour observing and prediction system has been reported by Gopalakrishnan (2008). There are many coastal ocean radars that have been installed all around the coastal stations. The data
78
M. Ravichandran
provided by the coastal ocean Radar is already useful for many operational applications and Research use (http://www.codar.com/bib_05-present.htm).
3.2.10 Gliders Gliders are small autonomous underwater vehicles which were developed to carry out in-situ observations of the upper 1€km of the ocean. They enhance the capabilities of profiling floats by providing some level of maneuverability and hence position control. They perform saw-tooth trajectories from the surface to depths of 1,000€m, along reprogrammable routes (using two-way satellite link). There is around ~2–6€km between surfacing when diving to 1€km depth. They achieve vertical speeds of 10–20€cm/s and forward speeds of 20–40€cm/s and can be operated for a few months before they have to be recovered (Davis et€al. 2002). They can record temperature, salinity, pressure data and depending on the model some biogeochemical data, such as dissolved oxygen and fluorescence/optical backscattering at various angles/wavelengths (Chl-a, CDOM, phycoerythrin, turbidity, etc.). They can also be equipped with acoustic modems and hydrophones for underwater positioning and underwater data telemetry. Gliders can “fly” underwater along slightly inclined paths without propeller. A change in volume (generated by filling an external oil bladder) creates positive and negative buoyancy. Because of the fixed wings, the buoyancy force results in forward velocity as well as vertical motion. So gliders move on a sawtooth pattern, gliding downward when denser than surrounding water and upward when buoyant. Pitch and roll can be controlled by modifying the internal mass distribution and gliders automatically align the positions of the center of buoyancy and the center of gravity to achieve desired angle of ascent/descent. Either a rudder or a roll control is used for navigation through lists of waypoints. The high efficiency of the propulsion system enables gliders to be operated for several months during which they may cover thousands of kilometers. Davis et€ al. (2008) have operated gliders over many years in the eastern pacific to perform repeat sections. Similar long sections along the coasts of the USA in the Pacific, and in the Atlantic (Castelao et€al. 2008; Glenn et€al. 2008; Perry et€al. 2008) demonstrated the capacity of gliders to carry out, over years, measurements of the local vertical structure of the ocean over 0–200 or 0–1,000€m from the near-shore environment (10–100€m depth) to the open sea (hundreds of kilometer offshore). Other important aspects of gliders are (1) the longest glider section ever done with one set of batteries is 6,000€km long (Eriksen and Rhines 2008) and (2) crossing very high currents is possible (such as the Gulf Stream, Nevala 2005). The€Australian National facility of ocean Gliders (ANFOG) under IMOS uses gliders to observe the boundary currents and shelf processes around Australia. Glider technology is advancing quickly, and will be ideal for monitoring water masses and currents in a variety of oceanic regimes. In regions of divergence zones and the boundary currents near the continental slope or steep topographic features, gliders contribute immensely to measuring sub surface parameters. This will also
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
79
facilitate in understanding meso and sub-meso scale processes. Presently, the assimilation of glider data is already operational for T-S, in regional and global models (Testor et€al. 2009). The real time data are being archived at the Coriolis Data Center, Brest, France.
3.3â•…Basin Scale Observing System—IndOOS Of the three major oceans—Pacific, Atlantic, and Indian—the Indian Ocean has is the only one that is not open to the northern subtropical regions. This is a consequence of the presence of the Asian landmass restricting the Indian Ocean to south of about 25°N and hence it cannot transport heat gained in the tropics to the higher northern latitudes, as the Pacific and Atlantic oceans do, mainly via their western boundary currents. Furthermore, the Indian Ocean is the only ocean with a low-latitude opening in its eastern boundary and gains additional heat from the tropical Pacific via the Indonesian Throughflow. The unique geography has important implications for the oceanic circulation physics, and consequently for climate and the biogeochemistry of the ocean, giving the Indian Ocean many unique features. Heat is carried southward along the western coast of Australia toward the southern subtropics. The Indian Ocean consequently has a unique system of three-dimensional currents and interactions with the atmosphere that redistribute heat to keep the ocean approximately in a long-term thermal equilibrium (International Clivar Project Office 2006). Further, the strong influence of monsoon systems generates distinct seasonal variations in the upper ocean. Also, previous attempts to measure and simulate the ocean variability reveals rich spectrum of variability spanning from intraseasonal to interannual, decadal, and much longer time-scale phenomena. Combination and interaction among these phenomena cause significant climate variability over and around the Indian Ocean. Despite such an important role of the Indian Ocean such as monsoons, climate variability and its impact on global climate change through atmospheric and oceanic teleconnections, a long-term, sustained observing system in the Indian Ocean had not been started. This had left the Indian Ocean as the least observed ocean among the three major basins. Recognizing this observation-gap, an enthusiastic spirit emerged after the OceanObs’99 meeting, resulting in the development of a plan for the Indian Ocean Observing System (IndOOS) under the coordination of the CLIVAR/GOOS Indian Ocean Panel (Meyers and Boscolo 2006). The schematic diagram of IndOOS and the regional Observing system is shown in Fig.€3.7. The outstanding research issues that need to be addressed with observations to advance the understanding of the role of the Indian Ocean in the climate system and its predictability are (1) Seasonal monsoon variability and the Indian Ocean, (2) Intraseasonal variability, (3) Indian Ocean zonal dipole mode and El Niño–Southern Oscillation, (4) Decadal variation and warming trends in the upper Indian Ocean, and (5) Southern Indian Ocean and climate variability, (6) Circulation and the Indian Ocean heat budget (Indonesian Throughflow, shallow and deep overturning cells), (7) Biogeochemical cycling in the Indian Ocean and (8) Operational oceanography. The status of each element of IndOOS is briefed below.
80
M. Ravichandran Indian Ocean Observing System (IndOOS)
30N
ASEA
20N
BOB Satellite
10N MISMO
Eq. CORDIO
InaGOOS CIRENE
INSTANT
10S LOCO
20S
ASCLME
30S 30E
IMOS
50E
RAMA
ARGO float array
PS
Process Studies
70E XBT / XCTD lines
90E
110E
130E
Surface drifting buoy array
Real-time and near real-time tide gauge network (including the tsunami buoy network) ROOS
Regional Ocean Observing Systems
Fig. 3.7↜渀 Schematic chart of IndOOS. Fixed location in-situ observations of IndOOS are indicated in detail, the argo and surface drifters scatter widely within the Indian Ocean, and the satellite measurements cover surface observation of the whole area
3.3.1 Moorings The basin-scale mooring array is essential for understanding and identifying their limits of predictability of the role of the ocean in the Monsoon Intraseasonal oscillation (MISO) and Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO), which are long lasting weather patterns that evolve in a systematic way for periods of four to eight weeks. The intense, long-lasting weather conditions associated with MISO and MJO interact strongly with the temperature and salinity structure of the ocean mixed layer, but the physics is not yet understood nor is it fully built into coupled models. The role of surface currents in the evolution of intraseasonal variation is not known. The air–sea heat and freshwater fluxes are poorly known. The array will provide vital
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
81
information on these processes. It is also needed to understand the mixed-layer dynamics and the role of currents in interannual variations, such as the IOD. Operational ocean-state estimation, such as the production of daily maps of currents and thermal structure for marine industry and defence, is not possible without the array. While this report is primarily concerned with oceanographic measurements, the meteorological measurements (particularly at moorings) will be extremely valuable to data assimilation issues concerned with weather forecasting and reanalysis efforts. The sub surface mooring array, called the Research moored Array for AfricanAsian-Australian Monsoon Analysis and prediction (RAMA) (McPhaden et€ al. 2009b) consists of a total of 46 moorings, of which 38 are ATLAS/TRITON-type surface moorings. Seven of these surface moorings are selected as surface flux reference sites, with enhanced flux measurements. The surface mooring system can measure temperature and salinity profiles from the surface down to 500€m depth as well as the surface meteorological variables, and the observed data is transmitted in real-time via Argos satellites. In addition to these surface buoys, there are five subsurface ADCP moorings along the equator to observe current profiles in the upper equatorial ocean, and three deep current-meter moorings with ADCPs in the central and eastern equatorial regions. The RAMA array design was evaluated and supported by observing system simulation experiments (Oke and Schiller 2007; Vecchi and Harrison 2007). The array has been implemented rapidly in recent years, largely through bi-national activities involving Japan, India, USA, Indonesia, China, France, Holland and South Africa. Early observations of this mooring provide invaluable data set for analyses on the Indian Ocean variability (Masumoto et€al. 2009 and references therein). For example, a long-term current observation at 90°E on the equator reveals that there is significantly large amplitude intraseasonal variability both in the zonal and meridional components as well as the well-known semiannual and annual variations. Also, RAMA mooring data used to capture subsurface evolution of the three consecutive Indian Ocean Dipole event from 2006 to 2008, with clear negative temperature anomaly at the thermocline depth that appeared a few months before the surface signatures of the IOD events. Mooring data were also used to observe the oceanic response to cyclone “Nargis”, which made landfall in Myanmar on 2 May 2008. Intense ocean mixing and significant turbulent heat loss from the ocean surface (~600°W/m2) occurred as Nargis passed near RAMA buoy at 15°N, 90°E in the Bay of Bengal (McPhaden et€al. 2009c). Surface moorings from the RAMA array also allowed process studies of the strong upper ocean response to the MJO in the Seychells-Chagos Thermocline Ridge region (Vialard et€al. 2008).
3.3.2 Argo Profiling Floats Argo floats are another revolutionary change in in-situ ocean observing in the Indian Ocean. The build-up began in 2003 as part of the global description of the variability of the upper ocean thermohaline structure and circulation on seasonal and
82
M. Ravichandran
inter-annual time scales. Data from these floats, together with the satellite basedand other in-situ observations, would enhance the understanding of the ocean circulation pattern and its influence on the global climate variability and would contribute to improve prediction skills of seasonal climate variability. The Indian Ocean (north of 40°S) requires 450 floats to meet the Argo design of one float per 3°â•›×â•›3° grid. Around 441 floats are active as on October 31, 2009. Still there are some gaps and other places where more than required floats are present. The Argo program’s unprecedented spatial and temporal coverage of density and geostrophic current is opening new perspectives on circulation-research. The new observations combined with a hierarchy of models are likely to address many unanswered questions. Argo observations in the Indian Ocean are creating many new insights by many different authors studying many aspects of the Indian Ocean. Thus Argo enables a new understanding of the upper ocean variability of Arabian sea, such as summer cooling during contrasting monsoons, temporal variability of the core-depth of Arabian Sea High Salinity Water mass (ASHSW), buoyancy flux variations and their role in air sea interaction, identification of the low-salinity plume off the Gulf of Khambhat, India, during post-monsoon period, mixed layer variability of western Arabian Sea, seasonal variability of the observed barrier layer, the importance of upper ocean temperature and salinity during cyclones, to reveal a pronounced westward propagation of subsurface warming in the southern tropical Indian Ocean associated with Rossby waves on the sloping thermocline, intense cooling of the sea surface at intraseasonal time scales in the southern tropical Indian Ocean during austral summer, etc. Also these data are used to study the the impact of assimilation in simulating temperature and salinity in the Indian Ocean (Masumoto et€al. 2009 and references therein).
3.3.3 SOOP/XBT Lines Several SOOP XBT lines obtain frequently repeated and high-density section data. The frequently repeated lines in the Indian Ocean are narrow shipping routes allowing nearly exact repeat sections. At least 18 sections per year are recommended in order to avoid aliasing the strong intraseasonal variability in this region. The CLIVAR/GOOS Indian Ocean Panel reviewed XBT sampling in the Indian Ocean and prioritized the lines according to the oceanographic features that they monitor (International CLIVAR Project Office 2006). The highest priority was on lines IX1 and IX8. The IOP recommended weekly sampling on IX1 because of the importance of throughflow in the climate system. IX8 monitors flow into the western boundary region, as well as the Seychelles-Chagos Thermocline Ridge, a region of intense ocean-atmosphere interaction at inter-annual time scales. IX8 has proven to be logistically difficult to implement, so an alternate line may be needed. More than 50 papers have been published based wholly or in part on the frequently repeated XBT lines in the Indian Ocean. The research results include to understand the seasonal, interannual and decadal variation of volume transport of
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
83
major open ocean currents, characterization of seasonal and interannual variation of thermal structure and its relationship to climate and weather (e.g. the IOD, tropical cyclones), surface layer heat budget to identify the relationship between sea surface temperature, depth of the thermocline and ocean circulation at interannual to decadal timescales, Rossby and Kelvin wave propagation and validation of variation of thermal structure and currents in models (Masumoto et€al. 2009 and references therein).
3.3.4 Drifting Buoys The surface drifting buoys in the Indian Ocean to meet the design of one buoy in every 5-degree box. As of November 2009, 62 drifters are active in the Indain Ocean north of 40°S and only ten drifters are in the North Indian Ocean. A problem in the Indian Ocean is that the strong Asian summer monsoon winds drive drifters out of the North Indian Ocean. Considering that the drifters are following the flow, the possible option for keeping the required number of drifters are (1) the criteria should be readdressed, (or) (2) a different measuring platform need to be implemented in these regions or (3) a more frequent seeding program is needed to maintain the 5-degree sampling. The design sampling density is to support calibration of satellite SST and to build surface current climatology. To our knowledge, the sampling density required to map surface currents at say monthly time scale has not been determined, but should be to validate surface currents in models and reanalyses.
3.3.5 Data Management The data portal for the Indian Ocean data collected in support of IndOOS is available at http://www.incois.gov.in/Incois/iogoos/home_indoos.jsp, which relies on a distributed network of data archives. The main idea is to provide a one-stop shop for Indian Ocean-related data and data products. The core of the system is a web portal maintained at INCOIS, providing direct binary access to the data via OPeNDAP and ftp protocols. Web-based browsing and data discovery are handled through custom-designed web tools and currently available on servers such as the Live Access Server (LAS). The distributed data archives are maintained by the individual groups at their institutes and made available to the community via the web portal. The portal contains data from basin-scale observations using mooring arrays, Argo profiling floats, expendable bathythermographs (XBT), surfacedrifters and tide gauges, as well as the data from regional/coastal observation arrays (ROOS) to observe boundary currents off Africa (WBC), in the Arabian Sea (ASEA) and Bay of Bengal (BOB), the Indonesian throughflow (ITF), off Australia (EBC) and deep equatorial currents. Satellite derived gridded data sets such as sea surface temperature (TMI), sea surface winds (QuikSCAT) and sea surface height anomaly (merged altimeter products) are also available. The agencies con-
84
M. Ravichandran
tributing to the IndOOS are committed to follow the CLIVAR data policy (http:// www.clivar.org/data/data_policy.htm). IndOOS provides the backbone for a number of planned process studies associated with international programs such as Vasco-Cirene, MISMO (Mirai Indian Ocean Cruise for the Study of the MJO-Convection Onset), TRIO (Thermocline Ridge of the Indian Ocean), CINDY2011 (Cooperative Indian Ocean experiment on intraseasonal variability in the Year 2011), DYNAMO (Dynamics of the MaddenJulian Oscillation), and the Year of Tropical Convection. IndOOS also supports the various regional observing systems around the Indian Ocean, which further link IndOOS. Incorporation of observations for bio-geochemical parameters will be a necessary future step forward to enhance interdisciplinary research in the Indian Ocean sector. A new satellite that measures surface salinity distribution would be another significant challenge in the Indian Ocean, where the large salinity contrast between the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal play an important role in the climate system of the surrounding regions.
3.4â•…Summary Analysis and interpretation of the ocean observational data require the knowledge of different time and space scales over which each processes characterizes: from the turbulent eddies with durations of few seconds and spatial scales of centimeters (high frequency) to wind-forced and thermodynamically driver ocean currents with time scales of days to centuries and spatial scales of tens to thousands of kilometers (low frequency). The exchange of momentum, heat, salt and other tracers within the ocean and across the air-sea interface occurs in these space and time scales. The observing system should resolve timescales of seconds to decades by measuring continuously without much gap and the spatial scales as close as possible. These observations have to withstand and provide good quality of data during disturbed or extreme weather events. Also these observational data needs to be available to operational agencies in real-time. Research advances and paradigm shifts in oceanography have often been stimulated by observations of various processes; in particular, theories and models have typically been developed to explain, quantify, incorporate, or parameterize these processes using balance equations. Examples of this chronology include Ekman transport, western intensification of boundary currents, and seasonal phytoplankton blooms. Limitations of oceanographic data persist in terms of raw numbers and diversity of variables. This is not surprising considering the spatial scale of the oceanic setting and the time scales of interest, both of which can span over ten orders of magnitude and the complexity of the biology, chemistry, and physics of the oceans. Progress in addressing ocean sampling deficiencies using interdisciplinary, multiplatform sampling is best reviewed by Dickey (2003). Ocean models have become increasingly useful as new processes have been incorporated or parameterized in formulations, numerical techniques have been improved, and
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
85
more powerful computing capabilities have allowed increasing spatial and temporal resolution and range as well as greater numbers of variables and balance equations. Interestingly, as more data have been collected, analyzed, and interpreted, and as computer model simulations have become more realistic. Observationalists and modelers have become more cognizant of and dependent upon each other for making scientific advances. The culmination of this cultural change is epitomized by two methodologies: inverse methods and data assimilation (Dickey 2003). Though platforms represent the backbone of the observational component of any data assimilation system, integrated multiplatform approaches have been adopted by several major oceanographic process and time series studies in order to take advantage of the specific sampling capabilities of individual platforms, which generally can carry a variety of interdisciplinary sensors and systems and often have telemetry capabilities. The strengths and weaknesses of each platform are shown in Table€3.1. In order to maximize value of the observing system as a whole, it is critical for a set of core variables to be selected including some that are common to repeat hydrography and autonomous instruments—moorings, floats, and gliders. If deep ocean floats are developed and deployed in Argo, then validation and correction, requiring repeat hydrography, will be needed for those instruments as well as for the upper ocean ones. In the event that a deep float array is not deployed, then the observation of deep ocean changes in heat, freshwater, and steric sea level would rest entirely with the repeat hydrography program. Because there are gaps in the planned global sampling, of scale 5,000€km errors in estimation of global integrals would be substantial. Studies are needed to assess the likely errors in global ocean heat content with and without a deep float array (Roemmich et€ al. 2009; Hood et€al. 2009). The individual networks of the present Sustained Ocean Observing System for Climate including tropical moorings, XBTs, surface drifters, ship-based meteorology, tide gages, Argo floats, repeat hydrography, and satellite observations have developed largely independently of one another. Progress will now come from integration across the networks since the next big observational challenges—including boundary currents, ice zones, the deep ocean, biological impacts of climate, and the global cycles of heat, freshwater, and carbon—demand multiplatform approaches and because exploiting the value of ocean observations is intrinsically an activity of integration and synthesis (Roemmich et€ al. 2009). Also, discussed the synergies of the observing system on which improved integration will be built, and key infrastructures that will underpin an integrated global observing system, potential developments and improvements in the different in-situ platform networks. The time is now appropriate to consider integrating these observational programs, with a view to facilitating the effective direct application of the knowledge and predictive capacities that are and will continue to be gained from these studies (Masumoto et€al. 2009). The largest increments to be gained over the present global observing system will come from expanding the sampling domains of autonomous platforms, from addition of multi-disciplinary measurements, and from integrating developments in data quality, coverage, and delivery.
86
M. Ravichandran
Table 3.1↜渀 Strengths and weaknesses of different in-situ platforms Platforms Strengths Weaknesses Tide gauges −╇Long term measurement −╇Only one parameter −╇Simple technology −╇Along the coast −╇Easy to maintain −╇Tracks not always where VOS −╇Surface marine met parameters data required −╇High resolution along repeat tracks −╇Do not stop −╇Sampling at remote oceanic region −╇No sub surface SOOP −╇Temperature profile (760€m) and surface −╇Tracks not always where salinity data required −╇High resolution along repeat tracks enabling −╇Do not stop spatial-time series −╇Sampling at remote oceanic region −╇Deployment of autonomous sampling platforms Repeat hydrog- −╇Deploying sophisticated/heavy instruments −╇Inability to produce synraphy/ −╇Time series measurements of a many optic data sets research parameters (physical, chemical, biological, −╇Very sparse sampling, expensive vessel geological…) −╇Reach remote areas, high resolution along the repeat tracks Acoustic −╇Measuring and understanding the behavior −╇Temperature, heat content tomography of meso scale and large scale features assoand other variables are ciated with general circulation interpreted with technique −╇Space-time variability −╇Not measured directly −╇Biofouling Surface drifters −╇Horizontal spatial domain from meters −╇data storage volume for to the basin-scale telemetry measurements −╇Data from remote regions only at the surface −╇Global coverage −╇Avoid some regions −╇Rapid sampling in time −╇Limited variables −╇Low-cost −╇Robust technology Moorings −╇Inter disciplinary time series data to mea−╇Cannot provide horizontal sure changes in the ocean on time scales spatial information from minutes to years −╇Mixed temporal-spatial −╇Coastal and open ocean variability is measured and thus partitioning of −╇To sample at multiple depths local versus advective −╇Harsh environment effects requires comple−╇Real-time data availability mentary spatial data sets −╇Vandalism −╇Biofouling Floats −╇Horizontal spatial domain from meters to the basin-scale −╇Profiling frequency −╇Data from remote regions −╇Data storage volume for −╇Sub-surface information telemetry −╇Coarse X,Y,T resolution −╇Rapid sampling in time −╇Robust technology −╇Limited variables −╇Low cost and hence large numbers feasible −╇Avoid some regions
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System Table 3.1╇ (continued) Platforms Strengths Gliders −╇Good sampling along tracks −╇Free choice of track −╇Can be steered −╇Different sensor suite feasible HF Radar −╇Good x,y,t resolution near the coast −╇Land based
87
Weaknesses −╇Very slow speed −╇Limited depth range and variables −╇Expensive −╇Limited variables and places −╇Limited coverage only surface currents and wave
Acknowledgements╇ Most of the work described above is based on the Community White Paper, OceanObs’09. Highest appreciation is placed on record for the excellent compilation by several authors and organization for their Community White Paper, it would have been difficult without these White papers. The encouragement and the facilities provided by the Director, INCOIS is acknowledged. Also acknowledged Wee Cheah, University of Tasmania, Sabastiaan Swart, University of Cape Town and unknown reviewer for critically going through the manuscript to improve it.
References Balmaseda M, Anderson D (2009) Impact of initialization strategies and observations on seasonal forecast skill. Geophys Res Lett 36, L01701. doi:10.1029/2008GL035561 Barrick DE, Lipa BJ, Crissman RD (1985) Mapping surface currents with CODAR. Sea Technol 26(10):43–47 Cai W, Hendon H, Meyers G (2005) Indian Ocean dipole-like variability in the CSIRO Mark 3 coupled climate model. J Climate 18:1449–1468 Castelao R, Glenn S, Schofield O, Chant R, Wilkin J, Kohut J (2008) Seasonal evolution of hydrographic fields in the central Middle Atlantic Bight from glider observations. Geophys Res Lett 35, L03617. doi:10.1029/2007GL032335 Cazenave A, Dominh K, Guinehut S (2009) Sea level budget over 2003–2008: a reevaluation from GRACE space gravimetry, satellite altimetry and Argo. Glob Planet Change 65(1–2):83–88 Chang P, Ji L, Saravanan R (2001) A hybrid coupled model study of tropical Atlantic variability. J Climate 14:361–390 Church JA, White NJ, Coleman R, Lambeck K, Mitrovica JX (2004) Estimates of the regional distribution of sea level rise over the 1950 to 2000 period. J Climate 17:2609–2625 Clarke AJ, Van Gorder S (2003) Improving El Niño prediction using a space-time integration of Indo-Pacific winds and equatorial Pacific upper ocean heat content. Geophys Res Lett 30(7):1399. doi:10.1029/2002GL016673 Clark C, Wilson S (2009) An overview of global observing systems relevant to GODAE. Oceanography 22(3):22–33 Davis R, Eriksen C, Jones C (2002) Autonomous buoyancy-driven underwater gliders. In: Griffiths G (ed) The technology and applications of autonomous underwater vehicles. Taylor and Francis, London Davis R, Ohman MD, Rudnick DL, Sherman J, Hodges B (2008) Glider surveillance of physics and biology in the southern California current system. Limnol Oceanogr 53(5, Part 2):2151–2168 de GrootHedlin CD (2005) Estimation of the rupture length and velocity of the Great Sumatra earthquake of December 26, 2004 using hydroacoustic signals. Geophys Res Lett 32, L11303. doi:10.1029/2005GL022695
88
M. Ravichandran
Dickey TD (2003) Emerging ocean observations for interdisciplinary data assimilation systems. J Marine Syst 40–41:5–48 Dohan K et€ al (2009) Measuring the global ocean surface circulation with satellite and in-situ observations. Community White Paper, Oceanobs’09 Dushaw BD et€al (2001) Observing the ocean in the 2000’s: a strategy for the role of acoustic tomography in ocean climate observation. In: Koblinsky CJ, Smith NR (eds) Observing the oceans in the 21st century. GODAE Project Office and Bureau of Meteorology, Melbourne, pp€391–418 Dushaw BD (2003) Acoustic thermometry in the North Pacific, CLIVAR Exchanges No. 26, March 2003. International CLIVAR Project Office, Southampton, UK Dushaw B et€ al (2009) A global ocean acoustic observing network. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Eriksen CC, Rhines PB (2008) Convective to gyre-scale dynamics: seaglider campaigns in the Labrador Sea 2003–2005. In: Dickson R, Meincke J, Rhines P (eds) Arctic-subarctic ocean fluxes: defining the role of the northern seas in climate. Springer, Dordrecht (Chapter€25) Feng M, Meyers G (2003) Interannual variability in the tropical Indian Ocean: a two-year timescale of Indian Ocean Dipole. Deep Sea Res Part II: Top Stud Oceanogr 50:2263–2284 Freeland H et€al (2009) Argo—a decade of progress. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Glenn S, Jones C, Twardowski M, Bowers L, Kerfoot J, Kohut J, Webb D, Schofield O (2008) Glider observations of sediment resuspension in a Middle Atlantic Bight fall transition storm. Limnol Oceanogr 53(5, Part 2):2180–2196 Goni G et€al (2009) The ship of opportunity program. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Gopalakrishnan G (2008) Surface current observations using high frequency radar and its assimilation into the New York harbor observing and prediction system. PhD Thesis, Stevens Institute of Technology, Castle Point on the Hudson, Hoboken, NJ 07030 Gulev SK, Jung T, Ruprecht E (2007) Estimation of the impact of sampling errors in the VOS observations on air-sea fluxes. Parts: I and II. J Climate 20:279–301, 302–315 Gurgel KW, Essen HH, Kingsley SP (1999) High-frequency radars: physical limitations and recent developments. Coast Eng 37(3–4):201–218 Hase H, Masumoto Y, Kuroda Y, Mizuno K (2008) Semiannual variability in temperature and salinity observed by Triangle Trans-Ocean Buoy Network (TRITON) buoys in the eastern tropical Indian Ocean. J Geophys Res 113, C01016. doi:10.1029/2006JC004026 Hood M et€al (2009) Ship-based repeat hydrography: a strategy for a sustained global program. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Horii T, Hase H, Ueki I, Masumoto Y (2008) Oceanic precondition and evolution of the 2006 Indian Ocean dipole. Geophys Res Lett 35, L03607. doi:10.1029/2007GL032464 IOC, Manual on Sea Level Measurement and Interpretation (2006) Volume IV: an update to 2006, JCOMM technical report No. 31, WMO/TD. No. 1339 International CLIVAR Project Office (2006) Understanding the role of the Indian Ocean in the climate system—implementation plan for sustained observations. ICPO Publication Series 100; GOOS report No. 152; WCRP informal report No. 5/2006, International CLIVAR Project Office, South Hampton, UK, p€60, 30 figures Kent EC, Berry DI (2008) Assessment of the Marine Observing System (ASMOS): final report, NOCS research and consultancy report No. 32, p€55 (available electronically from the authors) Kent E et€ al (2009) The Voluntary Observing Ship (VOS) scheme. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Koblinsky C, Smith N (eds) (2001) Ocean observations for the 21st century. GODAE Office/BoM, Melbourne Kohut J, Roarty H, Licthenwalner S, Glenn S, Barrick D, Lipa B, Allen A (2008) Surface current and wave validation of a nested regional HF radar Network in the Mid-Atlantic Bight, Current Measurement Technology (CMTC). Proceedings of the IEEE/OES 9th working conference on 17–19 March 2008, pp 203–207. doi:10.1109/CCM.2008.4480868 Lagerloef GSE, Lukas R, Bonjean F, Gunn JT, Mitchum GT, Bourassa M, Busalacchi AJ (2003) El Niño Tropical Pacific Ocean surface current and temperature evolution in 2002 and outlook for early 2003. Geophys Res Lett 30(10):1514. doi:10.1029/2003GL017096
3â•… In-Situ Ocean Observing System
89
Latif M, Anderson D, Barnett T, Cane M, Kleeman R, Leetmaa A, O’Brien J, Rosati A, Schneider E (1998) A review of the predictability and prediction of ENSO. J Geophys Res 103:14375– 14394 Leuliette EW, Miller L (2009) Closing the sea level rise budget with altimetry, argo, and GRACE. Geophys Res Lett 36, L04608 Masumoto Y, Hase H, Kuroda Y, Matsuura H, Takeuchi K (2005) Intraseasonal variability in the upper layer currents observed in the eastern equatorial Indian Ocean. Geophys Res Lett 32, L02607. doi:10.1029/2004GL021896 Masumoto Y et€ al (2009) Observing systems in the Indian Ocean. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Matthews A, Singhruck P, Heywood K (2007) Deep ocean impact of a Madden-Julian oscillation observed by argo floats. Science 318(5857):1765–1769 McPhaden MJ (2004) Evolution of the 2002/03 El Nino. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 85(5):677–695 McPhaden MJ (2008) Evolution of the 2006–07 El Niño: the role of intraseasonal to interannual time scale dynamics. Adv Geosci 14:219–230 McPhaden MJ, Zhang X, Hendon HH, Wheeler MC (2006) Large scale dynamics and MJO forcing of ENSO variability. Geophys Res Lett 33(16), L16702. doi:10.1029/2006GL026786 McPhaden MJ et€ al (2009a) The global tropical moored buoy array. Community White Paper, Oceanobs’09 McPhaden MJ et€al (2009b) RAMA: the research moored array for African-Asian-Australian monsoon analysis and prediction. Bull Am Meteorol Soc 90:459–480 McPhaden MJ, Foltz GR, Lee T, Murty VSN, Ravichandran M, Vecchi GA, Vialard J, Wiggert JD, Yu L (2009c) Ocean-atmosphere interactions during cyclone Nargis. EOS 90:53–54 Maximenko NA, Melnichenko OV, Niiler PP, Sasaki H (2008) Stationary mesoscale jet-like features in the ocean. Geophys Res Lett 35, L08603. doi:10.1029/2008GL033267 Merrifield M et€ al (2009) The global sea level observing system (GLOSS). Community White paper, Oceanobs’09 Meyers G (1996) Variation of Indonesian throughflow and the El Niño—southern oscillation. J Geophys Res 101:12255–12263 Meyers G, Bailey R, Worby T (1995) Volume transport of Indonesian throughflow. Deep Sea Res Part I Oceanogr Res Pap 42:1163–1174 Meyers G, Boscolo R (2006) The Indian Ocean Observing System (IndOOS). CLIVAR Exch 11(4):2–3, International CLIVAR Project Office, Southampton, UK Munk W, Worcester P, Wunsch C (1995) Ocean acoustic tomography. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. ISBN 0-521-47095-1 Murty VSN, Sarma MSS, Suryanarayana A, Sengupta D, Unnikrishnan AS, Fernando V, Almeida A, Khalap S, Sardar A, Somasundar K, Ravichandran M (2006) Indian moorings: deep-sea current meter moorings in the eastern equatorial Indian Ocean. CLIVAR Exch 11(4):5–8, International CLIVAR Project Office, Southampton, UK Nagura M, McPhaden MJ (2008) The dynamics of zonal current variations in the central equatorial Indian Ocean. Geophys Res Lett 35, K23603. doi:10.1029/2008GL035961 Nevala A (2005) A glide across the Gulf Stream. WHOI Oceanus, March 2005 Niiler PP, Maximenko NA, McWilliams JC (2003) Dynamically balanced absolute sea level of the global ocean derived from near-surface velocity observations. Geophys Res Lett 30(22): 2164–2167 NSF (2001) Ocean sciences at the new millennium. National Science Foundation, Arington Ogata T, Sasaki H, Murty VSN, Sarma MSS, Masumoto Y (2008) Intraseasonal meridional current variability in the eastern equatorial Indian Ocean. J Geophys Res 113, C07037. doi:10.1029/2007JC004331 Oke PR, Schiller A (2007) A model-based assessment and design of a tropical Indian Ocean mooring array. J Climate 20:3269 Perry MJ, Sackman BS, Eriksen CC, Lee CM (2008) Seaglider observations of blooms and subsurface chlorophyll maxima off the Washington coast. Limnol Oceanogr 53(5, Part 2): 2169–2179
90
M. Ravichandran
Picaut J, Hackert E, Busalacchi AJ, Murtugudde R, Lagerloef GSE (2002) Mechanisms of the 1997–1998 El Nino-La Nina, as inferred from space-based observations. J Geophys Res 107(C5). doi:10.1029/2001JC000850 Testor P et€ al (2009) Gliders as a component of future observing systems. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Rao SA, Behera SK, Masumoto Y, Yamagata T (2002) Interannual variability in the subsurface tropical Indian Ocean with a special emphasis on the Indian Ocean dipole. Deep-Sea Res Part 2: Top Stud Oceanogr 49:1549–1572 Reynolds RW, Smith TM, Liu C, Chelton DB, Casey KS, Schlax MG (2005) Daily high-resolution-blended analyses for sea surface temperature. J Climate 20:5473–5496 Rio MH, Hernandez F (2003) High-frequency response of wind-driven currents measured by drifting buoys and altimetry over the world ocean. J Geophys Res 108(C8):3283–3301 Riser SC, Nystuen J, Rogers A (2008) Monsoon effects in the Bay of Bengal inferred from profiling float-based measurements of wind speed and rainfall. Limnol Oceanogr 53(5): 2080–2093 Roemmich D et€al (2009) Integrating the ocean observing system: mobile platforms. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Send U et€al (2009) A global boundary current circulation observing network. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Shenoi SSC, Saji PK, Almeida AM (1999) Near surface circulation and kinetic energy in the tropical Indian Ocean derived from lagrangian drifters. J Mar Res 57:885–907 Sengupta D, Bharath Raj GN, Shenoi SSC (2006) Surface freshwater from Bay of Bengal runoff and Indonesian throughflow in the tropical Indian Ocean. Geophys Res Lett 33, L22609. doi:10.1029/2006GL027573 1999 Sengupta D, Senan R, Murty VSN, Fernando V (2004) A biweekly mode in the equatorial Indian Ocean. J Geophys Res 109, C10003. doi:10.1029/2004JC002329 Sybrandy et€ al (2009) Global drifter programme: barometer drifter design and refrence. DBCP report No. 4, Revision 2.2. Data Buoy Cooperation Panel Terrill E, Otero M, Hazard L, Conlee D, Harlan J, Kohut J, Reuter P, Cook T, Harris T, Lindquist K (2006) Data management and real-time distribution for HF Radar national network. MTS/ IEEE Oceans 2006, Boston, Paper 060331-220 Trenberth K et€al (2009) Atmospheric reanalyses: a major resource for ocean product development and modeling. Community White Paper, OceanObs’09 Udaya Bhaskar TVS, Rahman SH, Pavan ID, Ravichandran M, Nayak S (2009) Comparison of AMSR-E and TMI sea surface temperature with Argo near-surface temperature over the Indian Ocean. Int J Remote Sens 30(10):2669–2684 Vecchi GA, Harrison MJ (2007) An observing system simulation experiment for the Indian Ocean. J Climate 20:3300–3319 Vialard J, Foltz G, McPhaden M, Duvel J-P, de Boyer Montégut C (2008) Strong Indian Ocean sea surface temperature signals associated with the Madden-Julian oscillation in late 2007 and early 2008. Geophys Res Lett 35, L19608. doi:10.1029/2008GL035238 Wijffels SE, Meyers G, Godfrey JS (2008) A twenty year average of the Indonesian throughflow: regional currents and the inter-basin exchange. J Phys Oceanogr 38(8):1–14 Willis J, Chambers D, Nerem R (2008) Assessing the globally-averaged sea level budget on seasonal to interannual time scales. J Geophys Res 113, C06015. doi:10.1029/2007JC004517 Wong APS, Owens WB (2009) An improved calibration method for the drift of the conductivity sensor on autonomous CTD profiling floats by Θ-S climatology. Deep Sea Res Part I: Oceanogr Res Pap 56:450–457. doi:10.1016/j.dsr.2008.09.008 Woodworth P, Player R (2003) The permanent service for mean sea level: an update to the 21st century. J Coastal Res 19(2):287–285 Wunsch C, Ponte RM, Heimbach P (2007) Decadal trends in sea level patterns: 1993–2004. J Clim 20:5889–5911
Chapter 4
Ocean Data Quality Control James A. Cummings
Abstract╇ Automated ocean data quality procedures are presented. The procedures are logically grouped into four stages of processing, which when taken together form a complete sensor-to-prediction quality control system. The main features of the different ocean observing systems assimilated by GODAE are presented along with sources and types of errors that can occur in the data. Specific quality control procedures are described that test for these errors as well as more general procedures that estimate the consistency of the data across observing systems. Performance of the external data checks in the U.S. Navy real-time ocean data quality system is described. Finally, the importance of real-time ocean data quality control as an observing system monitoring tool is emphasized, and some specific examples are given of new quality control techniques developed in numerical weather prediction that have direct applicability in ocean data assimilation and forecasting systems.
4.1â•…Introduction Observation data quality control is a fundamental requirement of GODAE ocean data assimilation systems. Using or accepting erroneous data can cause an invalid conclusion to be made or an incorrect analysis. Alternatively, rejecting extreme, but valid, data can miss the detection of important events. The goal of quality control, therefore, is to reduce or eliminate making the wrong decisions. Quality control must correctly identify observations that are obviously in error, as well as the more difficult process of identifying measurements that fall within valid and reasonable ranges, but nevertheless are erroneous. It is likely that decisions made at the quality control step affect the success or failure of the entire analysis/forecast system. Ocean data quality control is best performed in stages. The first stage consists of a series of preliminary data sensibility checks. Observations failing any one of J. A. Cummings () Oceanography Division, Naval Research Laboratory, Monterey, CA, USA e-mail:
[email protected] A. Schiller, G. B. Brassington (eds.), Operational Oceanography in the 21st Century, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-0332-2_4, ©Â€Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011
91
92
J. A. Cummings
these tests are considered to have gross errors and are removed from further consideration. The second stage is based on a complex quality control procedure where observations are subjected to a series of tests. Observations are not rejected after immediately failing any one of the quality control tests; rather the final quality control decision is based on simultaneous consideration of results from all of the tests. This process uses a decision-making algorithm where the ultimate fate of the observation in the analysis/forecast system is decided (accept, reject, schedule for manual intervention). The outcome of the decision-making algorithm represents the likelihood an observation contains a random error. The third stage of ocean data quality control is performed by the analysis system itself. At this point, the gross and random error characteristics of the observations have been determined, and observations considered acceptable for the analysis have been selected. The third stage of the quality control is designed to protect the analysis from marginally acceptable data that have, for unknown reasons, passed the earlier stages of the quality control. A final fourth stage of the quality control is done after the analysis and the forecast have been completed as part of a system that performs routine assessment of the impact of assimilating observations on the reduction of model forecast error. Figure€ 4.1 illustrates these different stages of ocean data quality control and the flow of information through the fully automated, real-time system operated by the U.S. Navy. In this paper, various approaches, procedures, and algorithms used to quality control ocean observations are described. The emphasis is on real-time, fully automated ocean data quality control. It is beyond the scope of this paper to discuss the wide variety of delayed-mode or manual intervention quality control efforts that have been implemented (e.g., Boyer and Levitus 1994). The paper is organized as follows. Section€2 describes the real-time ocean observing systems, and Sect.€3 gives the stand alone, gross error quality control procedures that are applied to ocean observations. Section€4 provides descriptions of external quality control data checks and brief overviews of specific sources of error in ocean observing systems. Section€5 describes how the various independent external quality control data checks can be combined in a quality control decision-making algorithm and gives some performance results from the U.S. Navy real-time ocean data quality control system. Section€6 outlines the internal consistency checks that are used in the assimilation system itself, while Sect.€7 describes some possible quality control outcomes from the data impact system. Finally, Sect.€8 provides a summary and gives some conclusions on the interactions between ocean data quality control and observation monitoring.
4.2â•…Ocean Observing Systems A wide variety of observation data types are used in GODAE assimilation systems. The data include both in situ and remotely sensed measurements from space. As will be discussed, each observing system has its own unique data issues and
4â•… Ocean Data Quality Control
93
Stage 1: Preliminary data sensibility error checks
Ocean Obs SST: NOAA (GAC, LAC), METOP (GAC, LAC), GOES, MSG, AATSR, AMSR-E, Ship / Buoy Profile Temp/Salt: XBT, CTD, Argo Float, Fixed / Drifting Buoy
Stage 2: External data error checks
Ocean Data QC
Innovations Stage 3: Internal data error checks
Altimeter SSH: Jason-1, Joson-2, ENVISAT Sea Ice: SSM / l, SSMIS Glider: Slocum, Sea-Glider, Spray CTD Adaptive Sampling Data Impacts
Stage 4: Adjoint sensitivities
3DVAR
Forecast Fields + Prediction Errors
Analysis Components (QC + 3DVAR)
Increments
HYCOM First Guess
Forecast Component
Fig. 4.1↜渀 Chart showing flow of ocean observations through the different stages of ocean data quality control in the U.S. Navy global HYCOM system. Stage 1 sensibility error checks are performed on the raw data; stage 2 external data checks are performed in the fully automated ocean data QC module; stage 3 internal data checks are performed by the iterative solver in the variational assimilation; and stage 4 adjoint sensitivity calculations are done after the forecast before the next QC data cut (see text for details). Note feedback of the HYCOM forecast model fields and prediction errors into the ocean data QC for use as background fields in the next execution of the stage 2 external data error checks
quality control requirements. Sources of operational ocean data are described in this section. Most GODAE assimilation centers receive in situ ocean observations over the Global Telecommunication System (GTS). At the current time, data transmitted via the GTS are coded in specific data type formats which use, at most, two decimal places for measurements of temperature and salinity. Further, the existing formats do not allow for additional information about the data in the form of quality flags. However, observational data on the GTS are moving to a new binary format based on BUFR (Binary Universal Form for the Representation of data—a data format maintained by the World Meteorological Organization). In this format, data values can be transmitted with more precision than the existing text-based data formats, and local tables can be added to the message that contain value added or quality assurance information from the data provider. The move to BUFR on the GTS is a long process, scheduled to be completed for all ocean data types in 2016. In addition
94
J. A. Cummings
to the GTS, Argo float data are also available at two global data assembly centers (GDAC): one in the United States at the Naval Research Laboratory, Monterey, California; and the second in France at the Coriolis Data Center, Brest. There is no standard way satellite oceanographic observations are distributed to GODAE assimilation systems. In some cases, there is a dedicated push from the data provider to the center. In other cases, data are placed on dedicated servers where the observations are then pulled by the center. For example, the GODAE High Resolution SST pilot project has been instrumental in setting up data servers where satellite SST data providers transmit their SST retrievals in near-real-time in a common format (Donlon et€al. 2007). This effort has made the availability of SST data from a wide variety of satellite systems commonplace.
4.2.1 Ship and Buoy Sea Surface Temperature and Salinity Ship sea surface temperature (SST) observation data types are identified as engine room intake, hull contact sensor, or bucket temperatures based on type codes contained in the ship reports received over the GTS. Buoy SST data types are also received from the GTS and consist of fixed and drifting buoy reports. Observing systems that report both in situ SST and sea surface salinity (SSS) include thermo-salinograph observations from ships are sent over the GTS in TRAKOB reports.
4.2.2 Satellite Sea Surface Temperature There are many sources of satellite SST observations. Infrared satellite sensors include the NOAA and METOP Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) polar orbiter 4-km resolution global area coverage (GAC) and 1-km resolution local area coverage (LAC) data. Note that METOP LAC retrievals are global, while NOAA LAC retrievals are restricted to certain coastal areas, mainly in the northern hemisphere. The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES) infrared data have a resolution of 4-km and are available from the GOES-10, GOES-11, and GOES-12 satellites. The Meteosat Second Generation (MSG) is also a geostationary infrared satellite that provides 4-km resolution data centered over Europe. The Advanced Microwave Sensor Radiometer Earth (AMSR-E) on board the NASA Aqua satellite provides global coverage of 25km resolution microwave SST. The Advanced Along-Track Scanning Radiometer (AATSR) instrument on board the European ENVISAT satellite provides the first routine measurements of a true skin SST at 1-km resolution. Typically, radiance data in adjacent pixels are averaged into 2â•›×â•›2 (NOAA and METOP AVHRR) or 3â•›×â•›3 (GOES, MSG) bins before making the SST retrieval in order to reduce sat-
4â•… Ocean Data Quality Control
95
ellite sensor noise and produce a more accurate SST. This process necessarily reduces the resolution of the sensor data listed above to 2-km LAC, 8-km GAC, and 12-km geostationary retrievals. SST retrievals from the NOAA, METOP, and GOES satellites are available from the Naval Oceanographic Office (May and Osterman 1998; May et€al. 1998). SST retrievals from AATSR (Corlett et€al. 2006) and MSG (Merchant et€al. 2008, 2009) are available from Meteo-France and obtained from the GHRSST data server at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, USA (Donlon et€al. 2007).
4.2.3 Sea Ice Concentration The Special Sensor Microwave Imager (SSM/I) and the Special Sensor Microwave Imager/Sounder (SSMIS) on board the Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (DMSP) series of satellites provide routine observations of sea ice concentration at approximately 25€km resolution. At the present time there are 3 SSM/I (F11, F13, F15) and 3 SSMIS (F16, F17, F18) satellites providing sea ice data.
4.2.4 Temperature and Salinity Profiles Profile observations are reported from both fixed and moving platforms. Most profile observations report only temperature, such as expendable bathythermographs (XBT) and some fixed buoys, but profiling floats (Argo), conductivity-temperature-depth (CTD) sensors, and an increasing number of fixed buoys report both temperature and salinity. Profile observations are also available from gliders that measure temperature and salinity at varying depths and positions along a dive. A glider dive consists of a descending and an ascending profile in which the latitude, longitude positions and times of the observations change with depth. The presence of temperature and salinity in some reports and the unique sampling characteristics of ocean gliders present new challenges to the quality control of ocean profile data. There are common approaches to the quality control of the various profile observing systems, but there are also unique instrumentation specific error checks that are performed.
4.2.5 Altimeter Sea Surface Height At the present time, sea surface height anomaly (SSHA) observations are available from satellite radar altimeters on board the Jason-1, Jason-2, and ENVISAT satellites. Historically, satellite altimeters have been flown on Topex/Poseidon, Geo-
96
J. A. Cummings
sat and Geosat Follow-on, and the European Remote Sensing series of satellites (ERS-1 and ERS-2).
4.2.6 Altimeter and Buoy Significant Wave Height Each satellite radar altimeter also provides significant wave height (SWH) and wind speed observations. SWH observations are also available from many fixed buoy locations, mainly in the northern hemisphere. SWH observations are assimilated into wave models.
4.3â•…Preliminary Data Sensibility Checks Several preliminary data sensibility error checks are performed prior to the quality control of the observed values. Observations failing any one of these preliminary data checks are considered to have gross errors and are discarded or flagged for rejection. In some cases the preliminary data checks are performed by the data provider and the observations are simply not distributed. The preliminary data checks and logic for accepting/rejecting observations at this stage of the quality control process are described below.
4.3.1 Land/Sea/Fresh Water Test All observation locations are checked against a global, high-resolution land/sea database. Observation locations surrounded by water in all directions are accepted, and observation locations surrounded by land in all directions are discarded. For observations very near the coast a fuzzy land/sea boundary check is used. Observation locations are accepted if, in any one direction, the otherwise over-land location is next to a water point. Relaxation of the land/sea discrimination allows for resolution errors of the land/sea database and precision errors in the reporting of observation latitude and longitude positions over the GTS. Fuzzy land/sea tests are useful when ships provide observations while parked at a dock, or when instruments are deployed on piers very close to the coast. Note that the land/sea test must also distinguish observation locations in fresh- and seawater locations. Lake surface temperatures are routinely provided in remotely sensed satellite data streams, and in situ fixed buoys are located in many large lake systems,