A NEW LANDLORD AND TENANT
A NEW LANDLORD AND TENANT PETER SPARKES, LL.B., The University of Southampton
HART PUBLISHING OXFORD AND PORTLAND, OREGON 2001
Hart Publishing Oxford and Portland, Oregon Published in North America (US and Canada) by Hart Publishing c/o International Specialized Book Services 5804 NE Hassalo Street Portland, Oregon 97213-3644 USA Distributed in the Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg by Intersentia, Churchillaan 108 B2900 Schoten Antwerpen Belgium
© Peter Sparkes 2001 The author has asserted his right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, to be identified as the author of this work Hart Publishing is a specialist legal publisher based in Oxford, England. To order further copies of this book or to request a list of other publications please write to: Hart Publishing Ltd, Salter’s Boatyard, Folly Bridge, Abingdon Road, Oxford OX1 4LB Telephone: +44 (0)1865 245533 or Fax: +44 (0)1865 794882 e-mail:
[email protected] WEBSITE: http//www.hartpub.co.uk British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data Available ISBN 1–84113–022–2 (hardback) ISBN 1–84113–023–0 (paperback)
Typeset by Hope Services (Abingdon) Ltd. Printed and bound in Great Britain on acid-free paper by Biddles Ltd, www.biddles.co.uk
CONTENTS
Preface
vii
Glossary
xii
Abbreviations
xv
Books Frequently Referred To
xvii
Table of Cases
xix
Court Rules Table of Statutes Table of Statutory Instruments
lxxxiii lxxxv cvii
SHORT RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES 1. RENTING
1
2. CONTRACTUAL DURATION
17
3. SHORTHOLDS
43
4. ALLOCATION AND HOMELESSNESS
65
5. FULL RESIDENTIAL SECURITY
103
6. LIMITED RESIDENTIAL SECURITY
143
7. TIED ACCOMMODATION
185
TERMS OF RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES 8. DOMESTIC PROTECTION
193
9. RESIDENTIAL RENTS
211
10. CONDITION OF RENTED PROPERTY
243
11. RESIDENTIAL ASSIGNMENT AND SUB-LETTING
285
12. PEACEFUL OCCUPATION
309
13. RESIDENTIAL REPOSSESSION
321
LONG RESIDENTIAL LEASES 14. LEASEHOLD HOMES
361
15. INDIVIDUAL ENFRANCHISEMENT
387
16. FLAT SCHEMES
421
vi
CONTENTS
17. COMMONHOLD
467
18. RIGHT TO BUY
493
COMMERCIAL LEASES 19. COMMERCIAL GRANTS
505
20. RENEWABLE BUSINESS LEASES
539
21. TERMINATION WITHOUT RENEWAL
579
22. AGRICULTURAL LEASES
605
TERMS OF COMMERCIAL LEASES 23. FREEDOM OF BUSINESS CONTRACT
631
24. BUSINESS RENTS
639
25. REPAIRS TO BUSINESS PREMISES
671
26. BUSINESS LEASES OF PART
701
27. DEALINGS
723
28. RUNNING OF COVENANTS
745
29. FORFEITURE
793
Index
837
PREFACE
What on earth would Montaigne have made of our current law that governs the relationship of landlord and tenant? More than 400 years ago he stated his ideal as follows:1 “The most obvious laws are those that are fewest, simplest, and most general; and I even think that it would be better to be without them altogether than to have them in such numbers as we have at present.”
Our security of tenure codes create a system which is the exact reverse of his paradigm— hair-splitting, complex and multitudinous—so the question is how to make the subject at once accessible and precise.
This book continues the attempt begun in A New Land Law2 to introduce more workaday terminology to property law. The traditional “ees” and “ors” are a severe impediment to accessibility to students approaching property law afresh, and how much more this must be true of landlords and tenants lacking formal legal training. Good law is law tailored to the needs of people who actually use it, and although modernisation of language alone cannot make the law reach out to its customers, it does help. Except in direct quotations from older sources, this book contains no lessors and no lessees, no demises, and most emphatically no chattels real. The glossary is provided primarily to assist new students, but it should also prove valuable to lawyers with conventional learning. Otherwise the conventions follow A New Land Law—gender neutral terminology (if “he” is accepted to stand for “he or she”) and mortgage-lender in place of a mortgagee. If there is one central truth of this book it is the fundamental distinction between long and short leases. Someone who wants to live in central London may have to pay more than £1 million to buy a lease of a flat and having done so he does not then regard himself as a tenant. His credit rating will be high and he will receive short shrift at the local social security office. So he needs to be treated as an owner, and terminology must be designed to mark out the difference between his position and that of a student renting a bed-sit for a few terms. This book places this distinction right at its centre in two ways. In structural terms the chapters are divided into sections on short residential letting, longer residential ownership leases, and commercial sector letting, of which more shortly. It also marks out the divide linguistically. A short residential letting is described throughout as a tenancy, the parties being a landlord and a tenant. The word “lease” is reserved for longer-term arrangements, and in particular for residential ownership arrangements where the term exceeds 21 years, the parties to such an arrangement being described as a ground-landlord and a leaseholder. One cannot take 21 years as an 1 2
Essays, “On Experience”, (Penguin Books 1958, ed. J.M. Cohen) 345. (Hart, 1999).
viii
PREFACE
absolutely watertight division of the long and short sectors—since, for example, seven years is the crunch point for repairing obligations—but nevertheless 21 years is the most fundamental division. Above it the tenant has enfranchisement rights—that is the right to buy the freehold of a house or to take an extended lease of a flat. Below it, a private sector tenant has no rights to get at the freehold but has to be content with residential security of tenure (full or limited). Coherence would be greatly assisted if this existing schism were marked even more clearly by aligning other statutory regimes with a single cut–off point shorter than the present 21 years. Commercial sector leases form an intermediate group, where the traditional flexibility of term is more marked: some are very long and some very short. Nevertheless most commercial leases are formal in character, and they are described throughout this book as leases—generally renewable business leases or agricultural leases—in defiance of Parliamentary Counsel’s inappropriate choice of “tenancy” to describe this case. This reflects the formality and stability which are the usual characteristics of commercial lettings. In this book the parties are described as landlord and tenant. In both the residential and business sections I have separated out the chapters dealing with the basic structural nature of the term—that is the length of time for which it continues—from the chapters dealing with terms on which the land is held—rent, repairs, and restrictions on dealings. Security of tenure regimes are thus introduced at a much earlier stage than is conventional in most texts, since in my opinion they lie at the very core of the modern subject of landlord and tenant law. At first it seems logical to treat a lease chronologically—commencement, terms, and termination—but this appearance is skin deep; commencement, termination and security are intimately bound up with each other. My structure puts repossession where it should be as a reflection of the forfeiture of commercial leases. Both are means of terminating a lease for breach of its term. Most treatments of tenant law lack a coherent skeleton because of the difficulty of knitting together the common law principles which developed up to the beginning of the twentieth century with the statutory regimes that have characterised the twentieth century. Practitioners texts which predate the twentieth century—such as Woodfall and Hill and Redman—inevitably take the common law principles first and bolt on the statutory regimes. The results are ideally suited to the need of specialists, who already have a good idea where to look for the answers to the questions of detail which interest them. Most of the dozens of shorter landlord and tenant texts adopt some variation on this theme—a general part with common law principles followed by analysis of statutory schemes. The author is not convinced that this approach is helpful to the innocent making a start in the subject. After all, the so–called “common law” principles are largely statutory—the Statute of Marlborough 1267 dealt with repair, the Grantees of Reversion Act 1540 with the running of covenants; modern forfeiture was largely a creation of the eighteenth century Acts and so too was the law of distress; compared to these early Acts the nineteenth century was a period of Victorian tinkering. A less egocentric and broader historical perspective requires us to see ourselves in the middle of a continuous process of statutory development of a single subject. All security of tenure regimes concentrate primarily on extending the duration of a lease—sometimes with superadded rent controls—so it is most appropriate to treat them along with the common law principles.
PREFACE
ix
It follows from what has just been said that this book departs from the mainstream of landlord and tenant books by integrating its general part into the three basic types of tenancy—short residential, longer residential, and commercial—in the hope that this will reveal functions more clearly. It will be objected, and it is in a small part true, that this involves some duplication, but in fact the repetition is much less than one would imagine before the attempt is made. In relation to rent, to take one clear example, the rent regulation schemes have been allocated to the domestic sector, with forfeiture, distress, and rent review all allocated to the commercial—leaving a surprisingly trivial common core of principles. Repair shows even more clearly the domestic/commercial divide since statutory rules allocate to the landlord the cost of major structural work to a rented dwelling, leaving most of the case law on repairing covenants to be discussed in the commercial chapters. The domestic/commercial divide is greatly assisted by the modern perception that forfeiture is primarily an operative consideration in the commercial and longer residential leases, with only passing reference required in the early chapters on short residential tenancies. A stroke of great good fortune has facilitated this reworking. It is a remarkable feature of the year 2000 that there is virtually no divergence of policy between the main political parties about the appropriate treatment of tenants. Potential authors have rarely had the luxury of reflection on a settled structure, without the need to respond to the latest legislative onslaught. This is not, coincidentally, a book about housing policy—it is hoped that the author’s preconceptions have been buried to a sufficient depth to allow an objective examination of the law as it stands. Where reform is discussed it is of the technical kind rather than the political. This unexpected calm has encouraged me to integrate the existing statutory schemes in the private sector. Parliament has inexorably increased the number of schemes and sub-schemes, because the rights of existing tenants cannot easily be reduced. As the regimes have multiplied (and paradoxically at the same time divided) a serious problem of comprehension has developed. One can now enumerate a long list of types of tenancy before one even reaches the agricultural worker in his tied cottage—assured, protected, regulated, secure, assured shorthold, protected shorthold, and introductory. The provisions in the Housing Act 1996 about the last category are a particularly bad example of the legislative technique; 20 complete sections are devoted to the creation of a completely new regime for tenants in the public sector who are on probation for their first year. Surely all that was needed was one or two deft insertions in the public sector secure tenancies scheme? Add to all this the wide variety of tenancies at large in the social sector, and one ends up with more schemes than any one person can reasonably manage. Often a tenant does not know if he is an assured tenant or a regulated tenant. What he may know is that he is having trouble paying his rent. It is like a botanical classification that starts the search for a dandelion by asking whether it is a monocotyledon or a dicotyledon rather than from the point that one has a yellow flower spreading all over the lawn. Coherence requires that we learn—to take one simple example—of the effect of nonpayment of rent, as one simple whole rather than in 10 or 12 parts liberally sprinkled around the text. Even if the details of the grounds for repossession differ between the different regimes, the case law on one may impact upon the others, so that it all needs to
x
PREFACE
be drawn together in one place. Hence this book is based on function rather than upon the operative residential regime. It cannot be said that every issue has fitted comfortably into the structure adopted in this book. No humanly devised system could reduce the law as it stands to order. But is it megalomania to believe, where the law does not fit this book, that it ought to do so? Reform is desperately needed so that simple answers can be given to simple questions.3 Montaigne had it all summed up four and a half centuries ago when he wrote: “What have our legislators gained by picking out a hundred thousand particular cases and deeds, and attaching to them a hundred thousand laws? This number bears no relation to the infinite diversity of human actions. The multiplication of our imaginary cases will never equal the variety of actual examples.”4
We deserve a code, and we need it to be simple. I have attempted to state the law as it stands in the summer of 2000. Reference is made to reform proposals, especially on leasehold enfranchisement, termination of tenancies and commonhold, and the Green Paper published by new Labour. I have gritted my teeth and taken on the challenge of the Woolf reforms of civil justice, have torn up my chapter on licences to incorporate Bruton v. London & Quadrant Housing Association Ltd.5 and another on agricultural leases to adapt to Barrett v. Morgan.6 I have become immune to shock. Fortunately most cases have slotted in more easily—happy examples being Southwark L.B.C. v. Mills7 on soundproofing flats, de Rotschild v. Bell 8 on the continuation of long tenancies, and Metropolitan Police District Commissioners v. Palacegate Properties Ltd.9 on the exclusion of business security. Very late on in the production of this book the Government published a White Paper setting out its proposals for commonhold and leasehold reform,10 and even later on the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill 2000 was introduced into the House of Lords on 22 December 2000. The chapters on long residential leases (Chapters 14 to 17) have been completely rewritten, and it has also been possible to slip in a reference to the homelessness changes in the Homes Bill 2000 and to the House of Lords decision on the rent capping order.11 It remains to be seen whether the reforms will be enacted before the general election expected in May this year. The remainder of the book incorporates material available in Autumn 2000. It has not proved possible to incorporate all the current crop of human rights cases.
3 The problem is acknowledged in the Housing Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) para.5.7. A move towards a single tenure for public and social sectors (both described confusingly as “social” in the Green Paper) has been proposed by the Chartered Institute of Housing and is being considered by the Government: paras. 9.66–9.72. 4 n. 1 above at 345. 5 [1999] 3 All E.R. 481 H.L. 6 [2000] 1 All E.R. 481 H.L. 7 [1999] 4 All E.R. 449 H.L. 8 [2000] Q.B. 33 C.A. 9 [2000] 13 E.G. 187 C.A. 10 Commonhold and Leasehold Reform—Draft Bill and C.P. (Cm 4843, August 2000). 11 See below at p. 233.
PREFACE
xi
The result of all this labour is dedicated to Helen, who has put up with far more than it is reasonable to ask during the making of this book. New Forest January 2001
GLOSSARY
Agricultural holding Agriculture Assignment Assured tenancy Block Business Charter Commercial Common parts Commonhold Control Domestic Dwelling-house Early 1989 Enfranchisement Fair rent Farm business tenancy Flat Fresh tenancy Full security Fully assured
A lease of agricultural land granted before September 1995 and protected under the A.H.A. 1986 Farming and similar activities; these exclude business protection A transfer of an existing lease; contrast a grant A private sector residential tenancy granted since early 1989 under a market rent regime A building containing a number of flats Shops, offices, factories etc, but not agriculture A guarantee issued by the Housing Corporation of the rights of a social sector tenant Non-residential; business or agriculture Parts of a block of flats used communally by a number of tenants A proposed system of flat ownership which will allow flat owners to hold their individual flats freehold whilst regulating the management of the block and common parts A system of rent control for early residential tenancies where rents were a fixed multiple of the rateable value A synonym for residential A building or part of a building which forms a separate home i.e. a house, flat or maisonette but not a caravan or houseboat. 15 January 1989 when the Housing Act 1988 came into force, and assured tenancies replaced Rent Act tenancies The right for a long residential tenant of a house to acquire the freehold ownership, or of a flat to a long extension of his lease. A rent adjusted to remove scarcity value A lease of agricultural land granted since September 1995 and protected under the A.T.A. 1995 A part of a block used as a home and marked out by horizontal divisions as well as vertical ones. A tenancy granted to a tenant which does not follow a tenancy granted to the same tenant Life long security of tenure An assured tenancy with life long security of tenure
GLOSSARY
Grant Ground landlord Ground rent Home House Housing association Landlord Landlord condition Lease Leaseholder Limited security Long residential lease Market rent Premium Pretence Private sector Protected tenancy Public sector Rack rent Rateable value
Registered social landlord
xiii The procedure by which a landowner grants lesser interest in his land e.g. a freeholder grants a lease; contrast a transfer A person who grants a long residential lease; his main right is usually to claim a ground rent. A low rent charged under a long lease, the main value of the property having been taken by a premium when the lease is granted Where a tenant lives, including a dwelling-house, a caravan and a houseboat. A part of a building used as a home marked out by vertical divisions A charity formed to provide low cost housing; most are registered social landlords A person who grants a short tenancy or lease (see also ground landlord); the person entitled to demand rent for the premises Defines public sector landlords, mainly local authorities Not a tenancy; a longer term arrangement A tenant under a long residential lease whose rights equate to ownership e.g. the owner of a leasehold flat Less than lifelong security of tenure A lease initially granted for more than 21 years; when it expires the tenant can continue to occupy as an assured tenant; he may also have the right to enfranchise A rent fixed at the level demanded in an open market A capital sum paid at the start of a lease to “buy” the use of the land A written document which does not reflect accurately the agreement between the parties to it Grants by landlords not satisfying the landlord condition A Rent Act tenancy Grants by landlords satisfying the landlord condition, mainly local authorities Where the full economic value of the land is charged as rent i.e. there is no premium A value attached to an individual property for the purposes of imposing a rate; it was based on the letting value of the land. This now applies to commercial property only, but in the past rateable values were used to determine entitlement to residential security Housing associations and other landlords registered with the Housing Corporation and qualified to receive social housing grants for building new homes
xiv Regulated tenancy Renewable business lease Rent Act tenancy
Residential Reversion Right to buy Service charge Service occupancy Social sector Statutory tenancy Successor tenancy Surrender Tenancy
Tenant Tied Transfer
ABBREVIATIONS
A Rent Act tenancy during a contractual phase A lease of premises occupied for business; when it ends the tenant has the right to a renewal under L.T.A. 1954 part II Strictly a protected tenancy; a tenancy under the Rent Act 1977 usually with life long security and subject to fair rents. They were granted in the private sector until early 1989 A lease of a home The interest of a landlord The right for a public sector tenant to buy the ownership of his home at a discounted price; social sector tenants may have a right to acquire A sum payable by a tenant of communally managed property (e.g. a flat in a block) for maintenance A home occupied by an employee as part of his duties Tenancies granted by housing associations and other registered social landlords A tenancy created by security of tenure legislation, particularly the Rent Act 1977 A tenancy granted to a tenant to replace an existing lease held by him The process by which a tenant gives up his lease to his landlord with the landlord’s agreement, so ending the lease A short lease, especially one granted to a short residential tenant. In this book the term is not used for business leases, though the legislation does refer to “business tenancies” A person who holds a lease; in the case of a long residential lease this is described as a leaseholder. Accommodation provided by an employer The process by which a land owner (freehold or leasehold) passes his entire interest to a new owner; in the case of a lease this is generally described as an assignment
ABBREVIATIONS
A.H.A. A.T.A. B.S. C.C.R. C.Ct. C.O.A. C.P.Am.R. C.P.R. C.P.R. sch.1 R.S.C. C.P.R. sch.2 C.C.R. cond. Div.Ct. F.L.A. H.A. H.Ass. H.C.C.C.J.O. H.R.A. I.A. L.C.A. L.G.H.A. L.P. (M.P.) A. L.P.A. L.R.A. L.R.H.U.D.A. L.R.R. L.Ref.A. L.T.A. L.Tr. Law Com. M.C.A. M.H.A. P.D. P.E.A.
Agricultural Holdings Act Agricultural Tenancies Act Building Society County Court Rules (pre-Woolf) County Court Charging Orders Act Civil Procedure (Amendment) Rules Civil Procedure Rules Rules of the Supreme Court (post-Woolf) County Court Rules (post-Woolf) Condition Divisional Court Family Law Act Housing Act Housing Association High Court and County Courts Jurisdiction Order Human Rights Act Insolvency Act Land Charges Act Local Government and Housing Act Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act Law of Property Act Land Registration Act Leasehold Reform, Housing and Urban Development Act Land Registration Rules Leasehold Reform Act Landlord and Tenant Act Lands Tribunal Law Commission C.P. = Consultation Paper W.P. = Working Paper Matrimonial Causes Act Matrimonial Homes Act Practice Direction attached to the C.P.R. Protection from Eviction Act
xvi R.(Agriculture) A. R.A. R.A.C. R.A.P. R.O. R.S.C. Reg. s. S. S.C.S. S.S. subs. T. T.L.A.T.A.
ABBREVIATIONS
Rent (Agriculture) Act Rent Act Rent Assessement Committee Rent Assessment Panel Rent Officer Rules of the Supreme Court (pre-Woolf) Regulations section Settlement(s) Standard Conditions of Sale (3rd ed.) Secretary of State subsection Trust(s) Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act
BOOKS FREQUENTLY REFERRED TO
Places of publication are in England unless otherwise stated. Aldridge
T. Aldridge, Leasehold Law (Sweet & Maxwell, looseleaf)
Blackstone’s Commentaries
Sir W.E. Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England (chapters refer to any edition)
Bright & Gilbert
S. Bright & G. Gilbert, Landlord and Tenant Law (Clarendon, 1995)
Cheshire & Burn
G.C. Cheshire and E.B. Burn, The Modern Law of Real Property (Butterworths, 15th ed., 1994) Sir E. Coke, Commentaries on Littleton’s Tenures (references are to any edition) M. Davey, Landlord and Tenant (Sweet & Maxwell, 1998) J. Dewar and S. Bright, Land Law—Themes and Perspectives (Oxford, 1998) Sir Peter Millett (ed.), Encyclopædia of Forms and Precedents (Butterworths, 5th ed., 1993 and reissues) P.F. Smith, The Land of Landlord & Tenant (Butterworths, 5th ed. 1997) S. Garner, A Practical Approach to Landlord and Tenant Law (Blackstone, 2nd ed., 1998) K. Gray, Elements of Land Law (Butterworths, 2nd ed., 1993) D.J. Hayton, Registered Land (Sweet & Maxwell, 3rd ed., 1981) W.S. Holdsworth, History of English Law (Methuen, 4th ed. in 15 vols, 1936) Litteton’s Tenures (paras. refer to any edition) Sir R.E. Megarry & Sir H.W.R. Wade, The Law of Real Property (Stevens, 5th ed., 1984) T.B.F. Ruoff and R.B. Roper, The Law of Registered Conveyancing (Sweet & Maxwell, 6th ed., 1996)
Coke on Littleton Davey Dewar & Bright Encyclopædia F.P. Evans & Smith Garner Gray Elements Hayton, Registered Land Holdsworth Litteton’s Tenures Megarry & Wade Ruoff & Roper
xviii Snell’s Equity Sparkes, N.L.L. Wolstenholme & Cherry
Woodfall
BOOKS FREQUENTLY REFERRED TO
E.H.T. Snell, Equity (Sweet & Maxwell, 29th ed. by P.V. Baker and P. St.J. Langan, 1990) P. Sparkes, A New Land Law (Hart, 1999) Wolstenholme & Cherry’s Conveyancing Statutes (12th ed Stevens, eds B.L. Cherry, D.H. Parry & J.R.P. Maxwell, 1932); (13th ed., Oyez, ed. J.T. Farrand, 1972) Landlord and Tenant (Sweet & Maxwell, eds K. Lewison et al., looseleaf).
TABLE OF CASES Leading cases are given in bold type 134 Shirland Road Management Co. Ltd. v. Lester [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 207 L.V.T. .....................................................431 51 Bennington Road, Aston,Re [1993] Times July 21st, Vinelott J. ..........................................................................416 63 Perham Road Ltd. v. Manyfield Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 206 .................................................................................438 99 Bishopsgate Ltd. v. Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 72 C.A. ......................................................664 A. v. A. [1994] 1 F.L.R. 657 ........................................................................................................................................139 A.B.C. Coupler & Engineering Co. Ltd., Re (No.3) [1970] 1 All E.R. 656 ..........................................................597,772 A.C.T. Construction Ltd. v. Customs & Excise Commissioners [1981] 1 W.L.R. 49, [1981] 1 All E.R. 325 C.A., on appeal [1981] 1 W.L.R. 1542 H.L. .........................................................................................................................678 A.G. of Hong Kong v. Humphreys Estate (Queen’s Gardens) Ltd. [1987] A.C. 114 P.C............................................174 A.G. v. Colchester Corporation [1955] 2 Q.B. 207 C.A. .............................................................................................712 A.G. v. Cox (1850) 3 H.L.C. 240, 10 E.R. 893.............................................................................................................597 A.G. for Ontario v. M. (1999) 7 B.H.R.C. 489 ............................................................................................................203 A.G.B. Research Ltd.,Re [1995] B.C.C. 1091, Vinelott J. ...........................................................................................826 A.R.C. Ltd. v. Schofield [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 52, Millett J. ....................................................................................656, 662 Abbey National B.S. v. Cann [1991] 1 A.C. 56 H.L. .............................................................................36,307, 507, 528 Abbey National B.S. v. Maybeech [1985] Ch. 190, Nicholls J., C.A. .......................372, 377, 804, 823–825, 826, 835 Abbeyfield (Harpenden) Society v. Woods [1968] 1 W.L.R. 374 C.A. .......................................................................159 Abbot v. Bayley [1999] L.T.R. 267 C.A. .....................................................................................................309, 313, 314 Abbot’s Park, Re [1972] 1 W.L.R. 598., (No.2) [1972] 1 W.L.R. 1597, Pennycuick V.C. ................................418, 419 Abbott (J.W.) & Co. Ltd.,Re (1913) 30 T.L.R. 13. .....................................................................................................761 Aberdeen Steak House plc. v. Crown Estate Commissioners [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 107 C.A....................................569, 582 Aberfoyle Plantations Ltd. v. Cheng [1960] A.C. 115 P.C...........................................................................................530 Abernethie v. A.M. & J. Kleinman Ltd. [1970] Q.B. 10 C.A.......................................................................................542 Abingdon R.D.C. v. O’Gorman [1968] 2 Q.B. 881 C.A. ............................................................................................652 Abrahams v. MacFisheries Ltd. [1925] 2 K.B. 18 .......................................................................................................799 Abrol v. Kenny [1996] E.G.C.S. 93. .............................................................................................................................526 Adagio Properties Ltd. v. Ansari [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. .......................................................................................797 Adair v. Murrell [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 77, Skinner J. .....................................................................................................241 Adam v. Czech Republic (1997) 1 B.H.R.C. 451 .........................................................................................................201 Adami v. Lincoln Grange Management Ltd. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 58 C.A. ....................................................674, 678, 687 Adams v. Brown [1989] C.L.Y. 2295 ...........................................................................................................................182 Adams v. Clutterbuck (1883) 10 Q.B.D. 403.........................................................................................................24, 515 Adams v. Watkins [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 185 C.A. ..........................................................................................................182 Adams & Kensington Vestry, Re (1883) 24 Ch.D. 199, (1884) 27 Ch.D. 394 C.A. ...................................................537 Addin Investments Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 99, Jacob J. ..........................................657, 659 Addis v. Burrows [1948] 1 K.B. 444 ............................................................................................................................585 Addiscombe Garden Estates Ltd. v. Crabbe [1958] 1 Q.B. 513 C.A. ..........................................................542, 551, 554 Adelphi (Estates) Ltd. v. Christie (1983) 47 P. & C.R. 650 C.A..................................................................................743 Adler v. Upper Grosvenor Street Investment Ltd. [1957] 1 W.L.R. 227, Hilbery J. ....................................................558 AG Securities v. Vaughan [1990] 1 A.C. 417 H.L., reversing [1990] 1 A.C. 419 C.A. ............................................................................................125, 143, 151, 153–158, 170, 178 Agrotexim v. Greece (1996) 21 E.H.R.R. 250 .............................................................................................................207 Ahearn v. Bellman (1879) 4 Ex.D. 201 C.A. ...............................................................................................................584 Ahern (P.F.) & Sons Ltd. v. Hunt [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 74 C.A. .....................................................................................570 Ailion v. Spiekerman [1976] Ch. 158 Div. Ct. ............................................................................................................527 Air India v. Balabel [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 66 C.A. ...................................................................................................733–735 Aircool Installations v. British Telecommunications [1995] C.L.Y. 821 .....................................................................698 Aireps Ltd. v. Bradford City M.C. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 143 C.A. ..........................................................................546, 569
xx
TABLE OF CASES
Aitken v. South Hams D.C. [1995] 1 A.C. 262 H.L. ...................................................................................................719 Akinbolu v. Hackney L.B.C. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 259 C.A. .......................................................................................96, 106 Al Hassani v. Merrigan [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 93 C.A. ....................................................................................................252 Albany Home Loans Ltd. v. Massey [1997] 2 All E.R. 609 C.A. ................................................................................204 Albermarle St.,Re No. 1 [1959] Ch. 531. ....................................................................................................................770 Aldabbagh, Ex parte see R. v. Islington L.B.C. Aldavon Co. Ltd. v. Deverill [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 69 C.Ct. ............................................................................................412 Aldin v. Latimer Clark Muirhead & Co. [1894] 2 Ch. 437.........................................................................................718 Aldridge Estates Investment Co. Ltd. v. McCarthy [1996] E.G.C.S. 167.....................................................................686 Aldrington Garages Ltd v. Fielder (1978) 37 P. & C.R. 461 C.A. .......................................................................155, 157 Alexander v. Inland Revenue Commissioners (1991) 23 H.L.R. 236 C.A...................................................................499 Alexander v. Lambeth L.B.C. [2000] 02 C.L. 386................................................................................................255, 259 Alexander v. Mohamedzadeh [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 161 C.A...........................................................................................350 Alexander v. Springate [1951] 1 K.B. 803, [1951] 1 All E.R. 351...............................................................................164 Alford v. Vickery (1842) Car. & M. 280, 174 E.R. 507. ..............................................................................................127 Ali v. Tower Hamlets L.B. [1993] Q.B. 407 C.A. .......................................................................................................319 Ali v. Westminster C.C. [1999] 1 W.L.R. 384, [1999] 1 All E.R. 450 C.A. .....................................................69, 70, 89 Alinus v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 2987................................................................................................254 Allcock v. Moorhouse (1882) 9 Q.B.D. 366 C.A. ................................................................................................755, 782 Allen v. I.R.C. [1914] 2 K.B. 327 C.A. ........................................................................................................................175 Allen v. Rochdale B.C. [1999] 3 All E.R. 443 C.A. .....................................................................................................596 Allen v. Smith [1924] 2 Ch. 308 ..................................................................................................................................175 Alleyn’s Estate Governors v. Williams (1995) 70 P. & C.R. 67, Nicholls V.C. ..................................................418, 694 Allhusen v. Brooking (1884) 26 Ch.D. 559..........................................................................................................525, 527 Alliance B.S. v. Pinwill [1958] Ch. 788 .........................................................................................................................26 Allied Dunbar Assurance plc. v. Fowle [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 122, Garland J. .........................................................775, 786 Allied London Investments Ltd. v. Hambro Life Assurance plc. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 45 C.A. ......................................788 Allnatt London Properties Ltd. v. Newton [1984] 1 All E.R. 423 C.A.........................................................................558 Alton House Holdings Ltd. v. Calflane (Management) Ltd. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 52, John Mowbray Q.C. .................674 Amaddio v. Dalton (1991) 23 H.L.R. 332 C.A. ..................................................................................................163, 351 Amarjee v. Barrowfen Properties Ltd. [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 133......................................................................................667 Amec Properties Ltd. v. Planning Research & Systems Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 70 C.A...............................................528 American Economic Laundry Ltd. v. Little [1951] 1 K.B. 400 C.A. ....................................................................111, 333 Amika Motors Ltd. v. Colebrook Holdings Ltd. [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 62 C.A. ................................................................567 Amsprop Trading Ltd. v. Harris Distribution Ltd. [1997] 1 W.L.R. 1025, Neuberger J. ...........................................760 Anderson v. Oppenheim (1880) 5 Q.B.D. 602 C.A. ...........................................................................................691, 720 Andrew v. Bridgman [1908] 1 K.B. 596 C.A. .............................................................................................................740 Andrews v. Brewer (1998) 30 H.L.R. 203 C.A...........................................................................27, 47, 48, 253, 256, 550 Anglia B.S. v. Sheffield C.C. [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 57 C.A. ..............................................................................................736 Anon (1533) Bro. N.C. 18, 73 E.R. 854 ......................................................................................................................776 Anon (1577) 4 Leon. 17, 74 E.R. 698 .........................................................................................................................790 Anspach v. Charlton Steam Shipping Co. Ltd. [1955] 2 Q.B. 21 C.A. ........................................................................548 Anstruther-Gough-Calthorpe v. McOscar [1924] 1 K.B. 716 C.A. ............................................................................676 Antoniades v. Villiers [1990] 1 A.C. 417 H.L. reversing [1990] 1 A.C. 437 C.A..............124, 153, 154, 155, 156–158 Appah v. Parncliffe Investments Ltd. [1964] 1 W.L.R. 1064, [1964] 1 All E.R. 838 C.A. .........................................159 Appleton v. Aspin [1988] 1 W.L.R. 410 C.A. ..............................................................................................................348 Application 10390/83 v. U.K. [1986] 8 E.H.R.R. 39. ..................................................................................................208 Apsley Hall Estates Ltd. v. Nottinghamshire R.O. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 187 ..........................................................231–232 Arcwood v. Dow [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3787 ..........................................................................................................................49 Arden v. Pullen (1842) 10 M. & W. 321, 152 E.R. 492, 928 ..............................................................251, 258, 674, 691 Aristocrat Property Investments Ltd. v. Harounoff (1982) 43 P. & C.R. 284 C.A. .....................................................236 Arkwright v. Colt (1842) 2 Y. & C. Ch. Cas. 4, 63 E.R. 2. .........................................................................................757 Arkwright’s S.,Re [1945] Ch. 195 ................................................................................................................................599 Arlesford Trading Co. Ltd. v. Servansingh [1971] 1 W.L.R. 1080 C.A. ......................................................................782 Arnold v. Greenwich L.B.C. [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3618 ......................................................................................................260 Arnold v. National Westminster Bank plc [1991] 2 A.C. 93 H.L. ......................................................................657, 664 Arrondale v. U.K. [1983] 5 E.H.R.R. 118 ...................................................................................................................201 Artesian Residential Developments Ltd. v. Beck [1999] 3 All E.R. 113 C.A. ..................................20, 33, 339, 794, 815 Artizans Labourers & General Dwellings Co. Ltd. v. Whitaker [1919] 2 K.B. 301. ...........................................143, 173
TABLE OF CASES
xxi
Artoc Bank & Trust Ltd. v. Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. [1984] 1 W.L.R. 1181, Falconer J. ........................587, 668 Asco Developments Ltd. v. Lowes Lewis & Gordon [1978] 2 E.G.L.R. 41, Megarry V.C....................................256, 257 Ashburn Anstalt v. Arnold [1989] Ch. 1 C.A. ............................................................................167, 513, 527, 552, 641 Ashdale Land & Co. Ltd. v. Manners [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 5..........................................................................................615 Asher v. S.S. for the Environment [1974] Ch. 208 C.A. ..............................................................................................224 Asher v. Seaford Court Estates Ltd. [1950] A.C 508 H.L.....................................................................................161, 281 Ashgar v. Ahmed (1984) 17 H.L.R. 25 C.A. ...............................................................................................................315 Ashton v. Sobelman [1987] 1 W.L.R. 177, [1987] 1 All E.R. 755...............................................................................823 Ashworth Frazer Ltd. v. Gloucester C.C. (No.1) [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 104 Ch.D.; (No.2) [2000] 12 E.G. 149 C.A. .........................................................................................................................662, 666, 736 Aslan v. Murphy (Nos.1 and 2) and Wynne v. Duke [1990] 1 W.L.R. 766 C.A. ....................151–155, 158, 160, 345 Aspinall Finance Ltd. v. Chelsea [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 103. ............................................................................................545 Associated British Ports v. C.H. Bailey plc. [1990] 2 A.C. 703 H.L...........................................................802, 803, 819 Associated Deliveries Ltd. v. Harrison [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 76 C.A........................................................................682, 806 Associated Electrical Industries Ltd. v. Central Shops Ltd. (1974) 230 E.G. 1123, Plowman J. .........................798, 810 Associated London Properties Ltd. v. Sheridan [1946] 1 All E.R. 20...........................................................................517 Associated Newspaper Properties Ltd. v. Drapers Co. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 88 C.A................................................298, 726 Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v. Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 K.B. 223 C.A. (“Wednesbury”) .............................................................................................70, 88, 238, 319 Atkin v. Rose [1923] 1 Ch. 522. Re ..............................................................................................................................754 Atkinson v. Bettison [1955] 1 W.L.R. 1127 C.A..........................................................................................................571 Atlantic Computer Systems plc., Re [1992] Ch. 505 C.A.....................................................................................772, 830 Attley v. Cherwell D.C. (1989) 21 H.L.R. 613 C.A. ....................................................................................................178 Attorney General see A.G. Atwal v. Courts Garages Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 63.....................................................................................................708 Atyeo v. Fardoe (1978) 37 P. & C.R. 494 C.A. ...........................................................................................................107 Auriol v. Mills (1790) 4 Term. Rep. 94, 100 E.R. 912.................................................................................................776 Austin v. Dick Richards Properties Ltd. [1975] 1 W.L.R. 1033 C.A. ..................................................................390, 396 Australian Blue Metal v. Hughes [1963] A.C. 74 P.C. ................................................................................................525 Auworth v. Johnson (1832) 5 C. & P. 239, 172 E.R. 955.....................................................................262, 263, 673, 674 Averbrian v. Willmalight [1994] C.L.Y. 2799 ............................................................................................................785 Avon C.C. v. Clothier [1977] 1 E.G.L.R. 4 C.A. .........................................................................................609, 613, 614 Awua see R. v. Brent L.B.C. Axa Equity & Law Life Assurance Society plc v. Wootton [1997] E.G.C.S. 30............................................................582 Aylesbond Estates Ltd. v. MacMillan (2000) 32 H.L.R. 1 C.A. ...........................................................................459, 804 Ayling v. Wade [1961] 2 Q.B. 228 ...............................................................................................................................790 Aylward v. Fawaz (1997) 29 H.L.R. 408 C.A..................................................................................54, 61, 327, 579, 583 B. v. M.H.A. Ltd. [1999] 2 C.L. 372 ...........................................................................................................................313 B., Ex parte see R. v. Islington L.B.C. B.L. Holdings Ltd. v. Marcolt Investments Ltd. [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 97 C.A. ................................................................803 B.O.C. Group plc. v. Centeon LLC [1999] 1 All E.R. (Comm.) 970 C.A. .................................................................647 B.R.S. Northern Ltd. v. Templeheights Ltd. [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 182, Neuberger J.......................................................737 B.S.C. Pension Fund Trustees v. Downing [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 4 ..................................................................................624 B.S.E. Trading Ltd. v. Hands [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 214 C.A. .........................................................................747, 786, 790 B.T.E. Ltd. v. Merseyside & Cheshire R.A.C. (1991) 24 H.L.R. 514, Hutchison J. ...................................228, 230, 232 Bacchiocchi v. Academic Agency Ltd. [1998] 1 W.L.R. 1313 C.A. .....................................................................545, 574 Bacon v. Grimsby Corporation [1950] 1 K.B. 272 C.A. .............................................................................................271 Bacon v. Waller (1616) 3 Bulst. 203, 81 E.R. 171 .......................................................................................................598 Badeley v. Vigurs (1854) 4 E.& B. 71, 119 E.R. 28 .....................................................................................534, 597, 758 Bader Properties Ltd. v. Linley Property Investments Ltd. (1968) 19 P. & C.R. 620...........................................733, 801 Bagettes Ltd. v. G.P. Estates Ltd. [1956] Ch. 290 C.A. ................................................................................................548 Baglarbasi v. Deedmethod Ltd. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 71 Ch.D. ..............................................................................560, 806 Bahamas International Trust Co. Ltd. v. Threadgold [1974] 1 W.L.R. 1514 H.L. ............................................613–615 Bailey (C.H.) Ltd. v. Memorial Enterprises Ltd. [1974] 1 W.L.R. 728 C.A. ...............................................................668 Bailey Organisation v. U.K. Temperance & General Provident Institution [1975] 1 E.G.L.R. 61 C.A. ....................667 Bailey v. Supasnaps Ltd. (1995) 70 P. & C.R. 450 C.A. .............................................................................................658 Bailly v. de Crespigny (1869) L.R. 4 Q.B. 180 .............................................................................................................716 Bain v. Brand (1876) 1 App.Cas. 762 H.L. .................................................................................................................697
xxii
TABLE OF CASES
Bairstow Eves (Securities) Ltd. v. Ripley [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A. ...................................................................537, 583 Baker v. Lewis [1946] K.B. 186, [1946] 2 All E.R. 592 ..............................................................................................350 Baker v. McIver (1990) 22 H.L.R. 328 C.A. ................................................................................................................350 Baker v. Merckel [1960] 1 Q.B. 657 C.A. ............................................................................................538, 599, 777, 791 Baker v. Sims [1959] 1 Q.B. 114 C.A ..........................................................................................................................802 Baker v. Turner [1950] A.C. 401 H.L. ........................................................................................................147, 148, 150 Baldock v. Murray [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 70 C.A. ............................................................................................................161 Balfour v. Kensington Gardens Mansions Ltd. (1932) 49 T.L.R. 29. .........................................................................736 Ball v. Cullimore (1835) 2 Cr. M. & R. 120, 150 E.R. 51 ...................................................................................174–175 Balls Brothers Ltd. v. Sinclair [1931] 2 Ch. 325, Luxmoore J.............................................................................692–693 Bally v. Wells (1769) Wilm. 341, 97 E.R. 130 ....................................................................................................759, 770 Balthazar v. Mullane [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 260 C.A........................................................................................................182 Bandar Property Holdings Ltd. v. J.S. Darwen (Successors) Ltd. [1968] 2 All E.R. 305. ...................................465, 686 Bank of Ireland Homes Mortgages Ltd. v. South Lodge Developments Ltd. [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 91 Ch.D. ..................827 Bankes v. Jarvis [1903] 1 K.B. 549 ..............................................................................................................257, 647, 761 Banks v. Kokkinos [1998] E.G.C.S. 187 Ch.D.............................................................................................................659 Banque Financière de la Cité S.A. v. Parc (Battersea) Ltd. [1999] A.C. 229 H.L. ......................................................790 Baptist v. Gray’s Inn [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 136 C.Ct. .....................................................................................................662 Bar v. Pathwood Investments Ltd. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 90 C.A. ............................................................................560, 563 Barakat v. Ealing L.B.C. [1996] 36 R.V.R. 138, Brooke J. .....................................................................38, 40, 597, 601 Barclays Bank Ltd. v. Stasek [1957] Ch. 28, Danckwerts J. ...............................................................................597, 600 Barclays Bank plc. v. Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 44 Ch.D. ...........775, 787, 822, 824, 826, 830 Barclays Bank plc. v. Zaroovabli [1997] Ch. 321, [1997] 2 All E.R. 19, Scott V.C. also reported as Pourdanay v. Barclays Bank plc......................................................................................................................................................307 Bardrick v. Haycock (1976) 31 P. & C.R. 420 C.A. ....................................................................................................163 Barings Securities Ltd. v. D.G. Durham Group plc. [1993] E.G.C.S. 192, Ferris J. ...................................................742 Barking & Dagenham L.B.C. v. Hyatt (1992) 24 H.L.R. 406 C.A. ............................................................................345 Barking & Dagenham L.B.C. v. Saint (1999) 31 H.L.R. 520 .....................................................................................338 Barnes v. Barrett [1970] 2 Q.B. 657 C.A. ...................................................................................................................167 Barnes v. City of London Real Property [1918] 2 Ch. 18 ....................................................................................711, 768 Barnes v. Gorsuch (1982) 43 P. & C.R. 294 C.A. .......................................................................................................163 Barnes v. Sheffield C.C. (1995) 27 H.L.R. 719 C.A. ....................................................................................................272 Barnett v. O’Sullivan [1994] 1 W.L.R. 1667 C.A. ......................................................................................................163 Baron v. Phillips [1978] 2 E.G.L.R. 59 C.A. ................................................................................................148, 390, 395 Barratt v. Richardson [1930] 1 K.B. 686. ....................................................................................................................817 Barret v. Barret (1627) Het. 35, 124 E.R. 321, Richardson C.J. ................................................................................692 Barrett Estate Services Ltd. v. David Greig (Retail) Ltd. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 123 Q.B.D. ............................................658 Barrett v. Lounova (1982) Ltd. [1990] 1 Q.B. 348 C.A...............................................................................195, 243, 632 Barrett v. Morgan[2000] 1 All E.R. 481 H.L., reversing [1998] 4 All E.R. 179 C.A. ..................................................................................23, 37, 298–299, 602, 618–620, 617 Barribal v. Everett [1994] E.G.C.S. 62 C.A. ...............................................................................................................623 Barrie (Joan) Ltd. v. Gus Property Management Ltd. [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A. .....................................................563 Barrow v. Isaacs & Son [1891] 1 Q.B. 417 C.A. ..................................................................................732, 799, 819, 826 Barth v. Pritchard [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A. ...........................................................................................................569 Barton (W.J.) Ltd. v. Long Acre Securities Ltd. [1982] 1 W.L.R. 398, [1982] 1 All E.R. 465 C.A. ............................662 Barton v. Care (1992) 24 H.L.R. 684 C.A. ..................................................................................................................181 Barton v. Finchman [1921] 2 K.B. 291 .......................................................................................................................330 Bartram v. Aldous (1886) 2 T.L.R. 237 ...............................................................................................................250, 251 Barwick v. Kent C.C. (1992) 24 H.L.R. 341 C.A. .......................................................................................................496 Basildon Development Corporation v. Mactro Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 137 C.A. .......................................................708 Basingstoke & Deane B.C. v. Paice (1995) 27 H.L.R. 433 C.A. ......................................................................9, 299, 603 Bass Holdings Ltd. v. Brodie [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 51 Q.B.D. .........................................................................................594 Bass Holdings Ltd. v. Lewis [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 40 C.A. ..............................................................................................364 Bass Holdings Ltd. v. Morton Music Ltd. [1988] Ch. 493 C.A. .........................................526, 530, 537, 583, 797, 800 Bassari v. Camden L.B.C. [1998] E.G.C.S. 27 C.A. ............................................................................................546, 551 Bassetlaw D.C. v. Renshaw [1992] 1 All E.R. 925 C.A. ......................................................................................118, 122 Bassett Road H.A. v. Gough [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3653 ......................................................................................................834 Bassett v. Whiteley (1982) 45 P. & C.R. 87 C.A. ........................................................................................................583 Bastable,Re [1901] 2 K.B. 518 .....................................................................................................................................774
TABLE OF CASES
xxiii
Batchelor v. Murphy [1920] A.C. 63 H.L. ...................................................................................................................537 Bater v. Bater [1999] 4 All E.R. 944 C.A. ..................................................................................128, 130, 501, 502, 504 Bates v. Donaldson [1896] 2 Q.B. 241 C.A. ........................................................................................................735, 738 Bates v. Pierrepoint [1979] 2 E.G.L.R. 69. ..................................................................................................................390 Bath v. Bowles (1905) 93 L.T. 801, Alvestone C.J. .....................................................................................................782 Bathavon R.D.C. v. Carlile [1958] 1 Q.B. 461 C.A. ...........................................................................................224, 582 Bathurst v. Fine [1974] 1 W.L.R. 905 C.A. ................................................................................................................830 Batson v. London School Board (1904) 69 J.P. 9 .........................................................................................................820 Battersea Churches Housing Trust v. Hunte (1997) 29 H.L.R. 346 C.A.....................................................................353 Battlespring Ltd. v. Gates [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 103 C.A. .......................................................................................337, 353 Bavage v. Southwark L.B.C. [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3623......................................................................................................253 Baxendale (Robert) Ltd. v. Davstone (Holdings) Ltd. [1982] 3 All E.R. 496 C.A.......................................................563 Baxter v. Camden L.B.C. (No.1) [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 29 C.A., (No.2) [1999] 1 All E.R. 237 C.A. see Southwark L.B.C. v. Mills H.L. ......................................................................247, 310 Baylis v. Le Gros (1858) 4 C.B.N.S. 537, 140 E.R. 1201. ............................................................................................823 Baylye v. Hughes (1628) Cro. Car. 137, 79 E.R. 720 .................................................................................................753 Bayne v. Walker (1815) 3 Dow. 233, 3 E.R. 1049 H.L. ..............................................................................................689 Baynton v. Morgan (1888) 22 Q.B.D. 74 C.A. ............................................................................................596, 759, 776 Beacon Carpets Ltd. v. Kirby [1985] Q.B. 755, [1984] 2 All E.R. 726 C.A. ...............................................369, 688, 690 Beale v. Sanders (1837) 3 Bing N.C. 850, 132 E.R. 638 ..............................................................................263, 673, 751 Beale v. Worth [1993] E.G.C.S. 135 C.A. ....................................................................................................................735 Beaney v. Branchett [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 115 C.A..........................................................................................................345 Beard v. Williams [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 148 C.A.............................................................................................................569 Bebington’s Tenancy,Re [1921] 1 Ch. 559. ................................................................................................................758 Becker Properties Ltd. v. Garden Court NW8 Property Co. Ltd.[1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 121 L.Tr.....................................438 Becker v. Hill Street Properties Ltd. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 78 C.A. ..................................................................................567 Becton Dickinson U.K. Ltd. v. Zwebner [1989] Q.B. 208, McNeill J. .................................................................778, 787 Bedding v. McCarthy (1995) 27 H.L.R. 103 C.A. ...................................................................................................44, 46 Bedford v. A. & C. Properties Ltd. [1997] E.G.C.S. 108, Lindsay J.............................................................................554 Bedfordshire C.C. v. Clarke (1974) 230 E.G. 1587 ......................................................................................................615 Beebe v. Mason [1980] 1 E.G.L.R. 81 C.A. .................................................................................................................164 Beech’s Application, Re (1990) 59 P. & C.R. 502 L.Tr. ..............................................................................................418 Beechwood Homes Ltd.’s Application,Re (1992) 64 P. & C.R. 535 L.Tr.....................................................................718 Beegas Nominees Ltd. v. B.H.P. Petroleum Ltd. [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 57 C.A. ...............................................775, 784, 785 Beesly v. Hallwood Estates Ltd. [1960] 1 W.L.R. 549 Buckley J., on appeal [1961] Ch. 105 C.A.............................538 Beevers v. Mason [1978] 2 E.G.L.R. 3 C.A. ................................................................................................................623 Begum v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. [1999] Times November 9th C.A. .....................................................................81, 88 Belabel v. Mehmet [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 220 C.A. ...........................................................................................................175 Belaney v. Belaney (1867) L.R. 2 Ch. App. 138 ..........................................................................................................596 Belcher v. M’Intosh (1839) 2 Moo. & R. 186, 174 E.R. 257 .......................................................................................246 Belcher v. Reading Corp. [1950] Ch. 380, Romer J. ...................................................................................................224 Belfield v. Adams (1615) 3 Bulst. 80, 81 E.R. 69 ..................................................................................................38, 599 Belgravia Investments Co. Ltd. v. Meah [1964] 1 Q.B. 436 C.A. ................................................................377, 823, 824 Bell v. Alfred Franks & Bartlett Co. Ltd. [1980] 1 W.L.R. 340, [1980] 1 All E.R. 356 C.A........................................543 Bell v. General Accident Fire & Life Assurance Corp. Ltd. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. .............................303, 565, 667 Bell v. McCubbin [1990] 1 Q.B. 976 C.A. ...................................................................................................618, 625, 626 Bell Street Investments Ltd v. Wood (1970) 216 E.G. 585, O’Connor J. ....................................................................531 Bellamy’s case (1605) 6 Co. Rep. 38a, 77 E.R. 309. ....................................................................................................733 Bello v. Oakins [2000] R.V.R. 207 L.Tr. .....................................................................................................................459 Belvedere Court Management Ltd. v. Frogmore Developments Ltd. [1997] Q.B. 858 C.A. ............282, 428, 429–430 Benedictus v. Jalaram Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 251 C.A. ..............................................................................................667 Benjamin v. Anston Properties Ltd. [1998] R.A. 53. ...................................................................................................668 Bennett Properties Ltd. v. H. & S. Engineering Ltd. [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3683 Q.B.D. ...............................25, 553, 584, 691 Bent v. High Cliff Developments Ltd. [1999] 34 L.S.G. 35, Ch.D. ......................................................370, 456, 693, 702 Berg v. Trafford B.C. (1988) 20 H.L.R. 47 C.A. .........................................................................................................273 Berkeley Leisure Group Ltd. v. Lee (1997) 29 H.L.R. 663 C.A. ..........................................................................182, 734 Berkeley Road (No.88) N.W. 9,Re [1971] Ch. 648, Plowman J. ........................................................................589, 591 Berkley v. Poulett [1977] 1 E.G.L.R. 86 C.A. ......................................................................................................697, 698 Berkshire Capital Funding Ltd. v. Street [1999] Times May 27th C.A.......................................................................307
xxiv
TABLE OF CASES
Berry v. Berry [1929] 2 K.B. 316..................................................................................................................................525 Berrycroft Management Co. Ltd. v. Sinclair Gardens Investments (Kensington) Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A. ....465 Berryman v. Hounslow L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 567 .................................................................................................260 Berthon Boat Co. Ltd. v. Hood Sailmaker Ltd. [1999] 12 C.L. 408 Q.B.D. ................................................................667 Bessa Plus plc. v. Lancaster (1998) 30 H.L.R. 48 C.A. ........................................................................................336, 338 Bessell v. Landesbery (1845) 7 Q.B. 638, 115 E.R. 630................................................................................................601 Betterkey v. Joseph [1991] Independent November 1st ............................................................................374, 808, 828 Betts (J.) & Sons Ltd. v. Price (1924) 40 T.L.R. 589 ....................................................................................................755 Betts v. Penge U.D.C. [1942] 2 K.B. 154 Div.Ct. .......................................................................................................267 Betts v. Vivamat Properties Ltd. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 95, Hodgson J. ...........................................................................234 Betty’s Cafés Ltd. v. Phillips Furnishing Stores Ltd. [1959] A.C. 20 H.L. ........................................................570–571 Bevington v. Crawford (1974) 232 E.G. 191 C.A. .......................................................................................................108 Bhatti v. Berkeley Court Investments Ltd. (1991) 23 H.L.R. 6, Warner J. .................................................................430 Bhogal v. Cheema [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 50, Sir John Vinelott ................................................................39, 221, 600, 646 Bhojwani v. Kingsley Investment Trust Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 70, T. Morison Q.C. ................................798, 822, 827 Bhopal v. Walia (2000) 32 H.L.R. 302 C.A. ...............................................................................................................153 Bickel v. Duke of Westminster [1977] Q.B. 517 C.A. ................................................................292, 396, 735, 738–739 Bickenhall Engineering Co. Ltd. v. Grandmet Restaurants Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 110 C.A. .....................................657 Bickford v. Parson (1848) 5 C.B. 920, 136 E.R. 1141 ..........................................................................................755, 782 Billson v. Residential Apartments Ltd. [1992] 1 A.C. 494 H.L. [1992] 1 A.C. 501 C.A (1990) 60 P. & C.R. 392, Mummery J............................................694, 800–801, 803, 806, 808, 819, 820, 822, 826 Billson v. Residential Apartments Ltd. (No.2) [1993] E.G.C.S. 150, (No.3) [1993] E.G.C.S. 55.......................694, 820 Binions v. Evans [1972] Ch. 359 C.A. .................................................................................................................365, 516 Biondi v. Kirklington & Piccadilly Estates Ltd. [1947] 2 All E.R. 59, Roxburgh J......................................................585 Birkbeck Permanent Benefit B.S.,Re [1913] 2 Ch. 34, Neville J..........................................................................727, 728 Birmingham C.C. v. Ireland (1999) 31 H.L.R. 1078 Div.Ct. .....................................................................................269 Birmingham C.C. v. Oakley (1999) 31 H.L.R. 1070 C.A. ..........................................................................................266 Birmingham D.C. v. McMahon (1987) 19 H.L.R. 452 Div.Ct. ..................................................................................267 Birrell v. Carey (1989) 58 P. & C.R. 184 C.A. ............................................................................................................552 Bishop v. Consolidated London Properties Ltd. (1933) 102 L.J. K.B. 257 ..........................................................253, 707 Bishop of Bath’s case (1605) 6 Co. Rep. 34b, 77 E.R. 303 ..........................................................................509, 512, 518 Bissessar v. Ghosn (1986) 18 H.L.R. 486 C.A......................................................................................................349, 350 Black v. Eton College [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 223 L.V.T. ...................................................................................394, 406, 408 Blackburn v. Hussain [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 77 C.A. .......................................................................................................570 Blackmore v. Butler [1954] 2 Q.B. 171. ......................................................................................................................609 Blackmore v. White [1899] 1 Q.B. 293 ...............................................................................................................263, 673 Blackstone (David) Ltd. v. Burnetts (West End) Ltd. [1973] 1 W.L.R. 1487, Swanwick J. ........................................813 Blackstone Investments Ltd. v. Middleton-Dell Management Co. Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 185 L.V.T. ..............407, 438 Blaiberg v. Keeves [1906] 2 Ch. 175 ............................................................................................................................389 Blake v. Barking & Dagenham L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 963..............................................................................498, 500 Blamires v. Bradford Corporation [1964] Ch. 585 .....................................................................................................364 Bland v. Ingrams Estates Ltd. [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 49, Peter Leaver Q.C. ............................................809, 824, 827, 836 Blane v. Francis [1917] 1 K.B. 252 C.A.......................................................................................................................755 Blanway Investments Ltd. v. Lynch (1993) 25 H.L.R. 378 C.A. .................................................................................286 Blatherwick (Services) Ltd. v. King [1991] Ch. 218 C.A. ...................................................................................281, 393 Blawdziewicz v. Diadon Establishment [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 52 Ch.D. .........................................................................453 Blenheim Leisure (Restaurants) Ltd., Re [1999] Times August 13th C.A...........................................................545, 775 Blewett v. Blewett [1936] 2 All E.R. 188 C.A.......................................................................................................589, 798 Blockbuster Entertainments Ltd. v. Leakcliff Properties Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 28, Neuberger J. .............733, 737, 738 Bloomfield v. Ashwright Ltd. [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 82 C.A. ............................................................................................667 Blue Jeans Sales Ltd.,Re [1979] 1 W.L.R. 362, Oliver J. .............................................................................................830 Blythewood Plant Hire Ltd. v. Spiers [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 103.......................................................................................659 Bocardo S.A. v. S. & M. Hotels Ltd. [1980] 1 W.L.R. 17 C.A. ...................................................292, 302, 558, 730, 740 Boldack v. East Lindsey D.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 41 C.A. .....................................................................................251, 254 Boldmark Ltd. v. Cohen [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A. ............................................................................................458, 703 Bolnore Properties Ltd. v. Cobb (1997) 29 H.L.R. 202 C.A.............................................................................40, 51, 601 Bolton (H.L.) (Engineering) Co. Ltd. v. T.J. Graham & Sons Ltd. [1957] 1 Q.B. 159 C.A. .......................................570 Bolton’s (House Farms) Ltd. v. Oppenheim [1959] 1 W.L.R. 913 ..............................................................................570 Bond v. Rosling (1861) 1 B.& S. 371, 121 E.R. 753 .....................................................................................................521
TABLE OF CASES
xxv
Bonner v. Tottenham & Edmonton P.I.B.S. [1899] 1 Q.B. 161 C.A...........................................................................789 Bonnett v. Sadler (1808) 14 Ves. 526, 33 E.R. 622......................................................................................................694 Booker v. Palmer [1942] 2 All E.R. 674 C.A. .....................................................................................................172–173 Boot v. Wilson (1807) 8 East. 311, 103 E.R. 360 .........................................................................................................782 Boots the Chemist Ltd. v. Pinkland Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 98 C.Ct. ..........................................................................659 Borman v. Griffith [1930] 1 Ch. 493 ..........................................................................................................125, 526, 529 Borthwick-Norton v. Romney Warwick Estates Ltd. [1950] 1 All E.R. 798 C.A.................................................800, 820 Borzak v. Ahmed [1965] 2 Q.B. 320, Fenton Atkinson J............................................................................................806 Bosomworth v. Faber (1992) 69 P. & C.R. 288 C.A. ...................................................................................................389 Bostock v. Bryant [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 101 C.A..............................................................................................................167 Bostock v. De la Pagerie (1987) 19 H.L.R. 358 C.A. ...................................................................................................350 Boston Capital Ltd. v. Chee-A-Tow [2000] 09 C.L. 472 ............................................................................................301 Boswell v. Crucible Steel Co. [1925] 1 K.B. 119 C.A. ..........................................................................................697, 699 Botham v. TSB Bank plc (1997) 73 P. & C.R. D1 C.A. ..............................................................................................698 Botross v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. (1995) 27 H.L.R. 179 Div.Ct. ........................................................267, 268 Botterill v. Bedfordshire C.C. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 82 C.A. ...........................................................................................570 Botting v. Martin (1808) 1 Camp. 317, 170 E.R. 970 ..................................................................................30, 508, 721 Bottomley v. Bannister [1932] 1 K.B. 458 ..................................................................................................................260 Bowes v. East London Waterworks Co. (1821) Jacob 324, 37 E.R. 873 .......................................................................32 Bowes-Lyon v. Green [1963] A.C. 420 H.L. ........................................................................................................551, 565 Bowser v. Colby (1841) 1 Hare 109, 66 E.R. 969 ........................................................................................817, 818, 824 Boxbusher Properties Ltd. v. Graham [1975] 2 E.G.L.R. 58 ...............................................................................800, 813 Boyce v. Rendells [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 146 C.A. .............................................................................................................614 Boyer v. Warbey [1953] 1 Q.B. 234 C.A. .............................................................................................................756, 786 Boyle v. Verrall [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 25 C.A. ............................................................................................................49, 353 Bracey v. Read [1963] Ch. 88, Cross J. ...............................................................................................................544, 551 Braddon Towers Ltd. v. International Stores Ltd. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 209, Slade J. .....................................................712 Bradely v. Chorley B.C. (1985) 17 H.L.R. 305 C.A. ...................................................................................246, 259, 260 Bradford M.C.C. v. McMahon [1994] 1 W.L.R. 52 C.A. ....................................................................................502, 503 Bradshaw v. Baldwin-Wiseman (1985) 17 H.L.R. 260 C.A..........................................................................49, 349, 350 Bradshaw v. Davey [1952] 1 All E.R. 350 ...................................................................................................................697 Bradshaw v. Pawley [1980] 1 W.L.R. 10 ............................................................................................517–518, 533, 567 Braid v. Walsall M.B.C. (1999) 78 P. & C.R. 94 C.A..................................................................................................664 Braithwaite v. Elliott [1947] K.B. 177 C.A. ................................................................................................................185 Branchett v. Beaney [1992] 3 All E.R. 910 C.A. ..........................................................................................................315 Brandon v. Brandon (1862) 31 L.J.Ch. 47...................................................................................................................596 Brann v. Westminster Anglo-Continental Investment Co. Ltd. [1976] 2 E.G.L.R. 72 C.A. .......................292, 737, 738 Brawley v. Wade (1824) M’Clel. 664, 148 E.R. 278 ...........................................................................................303, 742 Breams Property Investment Ltd. v. Stroulger [1948] 2 K.B. 1 C.A. ..............24, 25, 31, 515, 584, 752, 755, 765, 769 Brede,The [1974] Q.B. 233 C.A. .................................................................................................................................646 Brennan v. Lambeth L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 481 C.A. .............................................................................156, 171, 311 Brent L.B.C. v. Botu [2000] E.G.C.S. 34, [2000] Times April 11th C.A. ..................................................................332 Brent L.B.C. v. Carmel (1996) 28 H.L.R. 203 C.A. ....................................................................................................260 Brent L.B.C. v. Charles (1997) 29 H.L.R. 876 C.A. ....................................................................................................185 Brent L.B.C. v. Cronin (1997) 30 H.L.R. 43 C.A. .......................................................................................151, 296, 725 Brent L.B.C. v. Knightley (1997) 29 H.L.R. 857 C.A. .........................................................................................123, 333 Brent L.B.C. v. Marks (1999) 31 H.L.R. 343 C.A. ......................................................................................................338 Brent L.B.C. v. O’Bryan [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 59 C.A .............................................................................................173, 178 Brent L.B.C. v. Sharma (1992) 25 H.L.R. 257 C.A. ...............................................................................................37, 40 Brent v. Brent [1975] Fam. 1, Dunn J. ................................................................................................................132, 136 Bretherton v. Paton [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 172 C.A. .........................................................................................................175 Brett v. Brett Essex Golf Club Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 154 C.A....................................................................................664 Brett v. Cumberland (1619) Cro. Jac. 521, 79 E.R. 446 ..............................................................................776, 782, 788 Brew Brothers Ltd. v. Snax (Ross) Ltd. [1970] 1 Q.B. 612 C.A...................................................................................678 Brewer’s Co. v. Viewplan plc. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 133 .........................................................................................665, 708 Brewster v. Kitchell (1698) 1 Salk. 198, 91 E.R. 177....................................................................................................716 Brickfield Properties Ltd. v. Hughes (1988) 20 H.L.R. 108 C.A. ................................................................................108 Bridewell Hospital Governors v. Fawkner (1892) 8 T.L.R. 637, Kekewich J. .....................................................736, 739 Bridge v. Quick (1892) 67 L.T. 54................................................................................................................................819
xxvi
TABLE OF CASES
Bridgers v. Stanford [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 265 C.A. ................................................................................................560, 585 Brikom Investments Ltd. v. Seaford [1981] 1 W.L.R. 863 C.A. ..................................................................................244 Brillouet v. Landless (1995) 28 H.L.R. 836 C.A. ........................................................................................158, 159, 311 Brimican Investments Ltd. v. Blue Circle Heating Ltd. [1995] E.G.C.S. 18, Chadwick J. .................................657, 658 Bristol & West B.S. v. Marks and Spencer plc. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 57, Hoffmann J. ..................................................708 Bristol & West B.S. v. Turner [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 52, Mummery J. ....................................................................822, 827 Bristol C.C. v. Lovell [1998] 1 W.L.R. 446 H.L. .........................................................................................501, 502, 503 Bristol C.C. v. Mousah (1998) 30 H.L.R. 32 C.A. ..............................................................................................341, 343 Bristol Cars Ltd. v. R.K.H. (Hotels) Ltd. (1979) 38 P. & C.R. 411 C.A. ............................................................561, 564 Britannia B.S. v. Earl [1990] 1 W.L.R. 422 C.A. ........................................................................................................306 Britel Corporation N.V. v. Orbach (1997) 27 H.L.R. 883 C.A. ..........................................................................426, 805 British Airways plc v. Heathrow Airport Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 141, Mummery J. ..................................................664 British Anzani (Felixstowe) Ltd. v. International Marine Management (U.K.) Ltd. [1980] Q.B. 137, Forbes J. ..............................................................................................................257, 647, 651, 706 British Bakeries (Midlands) Ltd. v. Michael Testler & Co. Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 64, Peter Gibson J......................735 British Economical Lamp Co. Ltd. v. Empire, Mile End, Ltd. (1913) 29 T.L.R. 386 ..................................................698 British Empire Mutual Life Insurance Co. v. Cooper (1888) 4 T.L.R. 362 .................................................................694 British Gas Corporation v. Univesities Superannuation Scheme Ltd. [1986] 1 W.L.R. 398, Browne-Wilkinson V.C. ......................................................................................................664 British Gas plc. v. Dollar Land Holdings Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 135, Knox J. ...........................................................664 British Leyland Motor Corporation Ltd. v. Armstrong Patents Co. Ltd. [1986] A.C. 577 H.L...................................718 British Petroleum Pension Trust Ltd. v. Behrendt [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 97 C.A. ....................................................800, 820 British Railways Board v. Bodywright (1971) 220 E.G. 651..........................................................................22, 173, 553 British Railways Board v. Mobil Oil Co. Ltd. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 146 C.A. .................................................................662 British Railways Board v. Ringbest Ltd. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 82, Scott V.C. .................................................................661 British Railways Board v. Smith (A.J.A.) Transport Ltd. [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 69..........................................................560 British Shipbuilding plc. v. V.S.E.L. Consortium plc. [1997] 1 Lloyds Rep. 106 Lightman J. ...................................661 British Telecommunications plc. v. Department of Environment [1996] unreported. ..............................................826 British Telecommunications plc. v. Sun Life Assurance Society plc. [1995] 4 All E.R. 44 C.A............................253, 707 British Union and National Insurance Co. v. Rawson [1916] 2 Ch. 476 C.A. ...........................................................791 Broadgate Square plc. v. Lehman Brothers Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 97 C.A., (No.2) [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 5 Ch.D........664 Brock v. Wollams [1949] 2 K.B. 388 C.A. ..................................................................................................................118 Bromley Park Garden Estates Ltd. v. George [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 95 C.A. ....................................................................300 Bromley Park Gardens Estates Ltd. v. Moss [1982] 1 W.L.R. 1019 C.A. ....................................................733, 737, 738 Brompton Securities Ltd., Re (No.2) [1988] 3 All E.R. 677, Vinelott J. .....................................................................830 Brooker Settled Estates Ltd. v. Ayers (1987) 54 P. & C.R. 165 C.A. ...................................................................151, 155 Brookes v. Harris [1995] 1 W.L.R. 918, Ferris J. ................................................................................................651–652 Brookes v. Iddon [2000] 04 C.L. 431. .........................................................................................................................181 Brown & Root Technology Ltd. v. Sun Alliance & London Assurance Co. Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 39 C.A. ...............................................................................................................................385, 583 Brown v. Brash [1948] 2 K.B. 247 C.A. ..............................................................................................................107, 108 Brown v. Davies [1958] 1 Q.B. 117 C.A. .....................................................................................................264, 337, 677 Brown v. Draper [1944] K.B. 309 C.A. .........................................................................................................................40 Brown v. Gloucester C.C. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 95 C.A. .................................................................................................664 Brown v. Liverpool Corporation [1969] 3 All E.R. 1345 C.A. .....................................................................................245 Brown v. Tiernan [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 11...............................................................................................................608. 614 Brown v. Wilson (1949) 208 L.T.Jo. 144, Hilbery J. ...................................................................................................602 Browne v. Flower [1911] 1 Ch. 219, Parker J. .............................................................................................310, 717, 718 Browne v. Warner (1808) 14 Ves. 156, 33 E.R. 480, Lord Eldon ..................................................24, 32, 514, 516, 521 Bruce v. Worthing B.C. (1993) 26 H.L.R. 223 C.A. ...........................................................................................106, 459 Bruerton v. Rainsford (1583) Cro. Eliz. 15, 78 E.R. 28...............................................................................................725 Bruton v. London & Quadrant Housing Trust [2000] A.C. 406, [1999] 3 All E.R. 481 H.L. reversing [1998] Q.B. 834 C.A .........................................................35, 144, 145, 170, 171, 178–179, 194, 243, 302–303, 566 Bryan v. U.K. (1995) 21 E.H.R.R. 342 ...............................................................................................................204, 207 Bryant v. Best [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 113 C.A. .........................................................................................................163, 165 Bryant v. Hancock & Co. [1898] 1 K.B. 716 C.A., on appeal [1899] A.C. 442 H.L. .........................................725, 777 Bryant v. Portsmouth C.C. [2000] Indep. C.S. July 10th C.A. ....................................................................................341 Brydges v. Lewis (1842) 3 Q.B. 603, 114 E.R. 639.......................................................................................................782 Buchmann v. May [1978] 2 All E.R. 993 C.A. ............................................................................................................168
TABLE OF CASES
xxvii
Buckinghamshire C.C. v. Gordon [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 8 ...............................................................................................627 Buckland v. Butterfield (1820) 2 Brod. & B. 54, 129 E.R. 878 ...........................................................................697, 700 Buckley v. U.K. (1996) 23 E.H.R.R. 101 E.Ct.H.R. ....................................................................................................204 Budd v. Colchester B.C. [1999] Times April 14th C.A. ..............................................................................................267 Budge v. Hicks [1951] 2 K.B. 335 C.A.........................................................................................................................624 Bull v. Bull [1955] 1 Q.B. 234 C.A. .............................................................................................................................125 Bullock v. Domitt (1796) 6 Term Rep. 650, 101 E.R. 752 ..........................................................................................688 Bunn v. Harrison (1886) 3 T.L.R. 146 C.A. ................................................................................................................251 Burch v. Farrows Bank Ltd. [1917] 1 Ch. 606.............................................................................................................583 Burchell v. Hornsby (1808) 1 Camp. 360, 170 E.R. 985 .....................................................................................263, 673 Burdett v. Whithers (1837) 7 Ad. & El. 136, 112 E.R. 422..........................................................................................676 Burford Midland Properties Ltd. v. Marley Extrusions Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 15 .....................................................773 Burfort Financial Investments Ltd. v. Chotard [1976] 2 E.G.L.R. 53, Foster J. .................................................800, 820 Burgoyne v. Griffiths [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 14 C.A. ................................................................................................190, 191 Burke v. S.S. for the Environment (1994) 26 H.L.R. 10 .............................................................................................273 Burnett v. Lynch (1826) 5 B. & C. 589, 108 E.R. 220..................................................................................................789 Burr v. Eyre [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 92 C.Ct. .............................................................................................................399, 413 Burrows v. Brent L.B.C. [1996] 1 W.L.R. 1448 H.L............................................................................................333, 334 Burrows v. Sharp (1989) 23 H.L.R. 82 C.A. ................................................................................................................495 Burt v. Gray [1891] 2 Q.B. 98 .....................................................................................................................................825 Burton v. Barclay (1831) 7 Bing. 745, 131 E.R. 288 ...........................................................................................598, 743 Burton v. Camden L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 991 C.A. [1998] 1 F.L.R. 681 C.A., reversed [2000] 1 All E.R. 943, [2000] 2 W.L.R. 427 H.L.................................................................................................................130, 286, 289, 597 Burton v. Timmis [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ...............................................................................................................623 Busby v. Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 136..........................................................................574 Bush Transport Ltd. v. Nelson [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 71 C.A. ...........................................................................................32 Buswell v. Goodwin [1971] 1 W.L.R. 92 C.A. .....................................................................................................250, 345 Butler Estates Co. v. Bean [1942] 1 K.B. 1 C.A. ..........................................................................................................790 Button’s Lease, Re [1964] Ch. 263 ...............................................................................................................................538 Butuyuyu v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 584 Div.Ct.....................................................267, 268 Byrnlea Property Investments Ltd. v. Ramsay [1969] 2 Q.B. 253 C.A. ...............................................................411, 412 C.B.S. United Kingdom Ltd. v. London Scottish Properties Ltd. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 125.............................................567 C.I.N. Properties Ltd. v. Gill [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 97......................................................................................................733 Cadbury v. Woodward (1972) 23 P. & C.R. 281 (No.2) (1972) 24 P. & C.R. 335 ....................................................418 Cade (J.E.) & Son Ltd.,Re [1992] B.C.L.C. 213, Warner J. .......................................................................................617 Cadle v. Moody (1861) 30 L.J. Ex. 385 ........................................................................................................................597 Cadogan Estates Ltd. v. McMahon [1999] 1 W.L.R. 1689 C.A., approved [2000] Times November 1st H.L. ....................................................................................................20, 115, 346, 829 Cadogan Estates Ltd. v. Shahgholi [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 189 L.Tr. .........................................................................394, 408 Cadogan v. Dimovic [1984] 1 W.L.R. 609 C.A. ..................................................................................................823, 825 Cadogan v. Henthorne [1957] 1 W.L.R. 1 ..................................................................................................................300 Cadogan v. McCarthy & Stone (Developments) Ltd. [1996] E.G.C.S. 94 C.A. .................................................571, 572 Cadogan v. McGirk [1996] 4 All E.R. 643 C.A. ..................................................................................................413, 443 Cadogan v. Morris [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 59 C.A. ............................................................................................387, 413, 423 Caerns Motor Services Ltd. v. Texaco Ltd. [1994] 1 W.L.R. 1249 ......................................................................764, 769 Cairnplace Ltd. v. C.B.L. (Property Investment) Co. Ltd. [1984] 1 W.L.R. 696 C.A..................................................568 Calabar Properties Ltd. v. Stitcher [1984] 1 W.L.R. 287 C.A. ............................................................253, 259, 706, 707 Calcott v. J.S. Bloor (Measham) Ltd. [1998] 1 W.L.R. 1490 C.A. .....................................................................585, 613 Caldwell v. McAteer [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 89 C.A. .........................................................................................................164 Cale v. Assuidoman K.P.S. (Harrow) Ltd. [1996] B.P.I.R. 245 .................................................................................790 Calthorpe Estate, Re (1973) 26 P. & C.R. 120, Foster J. ............................................................................................418 Cam Gears Ltd. v. Cunningham [1981] 1 W.L.R. 1011 C.A. ....................................................................................571 Camden L.B.C. v. Akanni (1997) 29 H.L.R. 845 C.A. .......................................................................................335, 338 Camden L.B.C. v. Alexandrou (No.2) (1998) 30 H.L.R. 534 C.A. .............................38, 123, 124, 293, 294, 597, 598 Camden L.B.C. v. Gilsenan (1999) 31 H.L.R. 81 C.A. ...............................................................................................342 Camden L.B.C. v. Goldenberg (1996) 28 H.L.R. 727 C.A. .................................................................................108, 121 Camden L.B.C. v. Gunby [1999] 4 All E.R. 602 Div.Ct. ............................................................................................267
xxviii
TABLE OF CASES
Camden L.B.C. v. London Underground Ltd. [2000] 01 L.S.G. 25 Div.Ct. .......................................................267, 269 Camden L.B.C. v. Marshall [1996] 1 W.L.R. 1345 Div. Ct. ..............................................................................270, 273 Camden L.B.C. v. McBride [1999] 01 C.L. 284 ..........................................................................................................341 Camden L.B.C. v. Oppong (1996) 28 H.L.R. 701 C.A. .......................................................................................319, 343 Camden L.B.C. v. Sale [1997] C.L.Y. 2718 .................................................................................................................503 Camden L.B.C. v. Shortlife Community Housing (1992) 25 H.L.R. 330, Millett J. .........................151, 171, 172, 179 Camden Nominees v. Forcey [1940] Ch. 352, Simonds J. .........................................................................................256 Camden v. Batterbury (1860) 7 C.B.N.S. 864, 141 E.R. 1055 ....................................................................................767 Campbell v. Chu [1999] 06 C.L. 416 C.Ct. ...................................................................................................................46 Campbell v. Lewis (1820) 3 Barn. & Ald. 392, 106 E.R. 706 ......................................................................................769 Campbell v. Wenlock (1866) 4 F & F. 716, 176 E.R. 760; ..........................................................................................251 Campden Hill Towers Ltd. v. Gardner [1977] Q.B. 823 C.A. ............................................................................245, 246 Campell v. Daramola [1975] 2 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A.........................................................................................................255 Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Bello (1991) 24 H.L.R. 155 C.A. ........................................................19, 513 Cannon Brewery Co. Ltd.,Re (1928) 139 L.T. 384 .....................................................................................................589 Canterbury Cathedral Dean & Chapter v. Whitbread plc. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 82 .......................................174, 213, 641 Canterbury Corporation v. Cooper (1908) 99 L.T. 612, 100 L.T. 597 C.A. ...............................................................599 Capital & City Holdings Ltd. v. Dean Warburg Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 90 C.A. .......................................................796 Capital & Counties Bank Ltd. v. Rhodes [1903] 1 Ch. 631 C.A. ................................................................................596 Capital & Counties Freehold Equity Trust Ltd. v. B.L. plc. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 49 Ch.D.....................................457, 704 Capital & Counties Property Co. Ltd. v. Mills [1966] E.G.D. 96 ...............................................................................819 Capital Prime Plus plc. v. Wills (1999) 31 H.L.R. 926 ................................................................................................338 Caplan (I. & H.) Ltd. v. Caplan (No. 2) [1963] 1 W.L.R. 1247, Cross J. ..........................................................544, 547 Capocci v. Goble [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 102 C.A. ..............................................................................................................571 Caradon D.C. v. Paton [2000] Times May 17th C.A. ........................................................................................105, 168 Cardigan Properties Ltd. v. Consolidated Property Investments Ltd. [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 64, P.J. Cox Q.C.........................................................................................686, 797, 798, 814, 826 Cardiothoracic Institute v. Shrewdcrest Ltd. [1986] 1 W.L.R. 368 ......................................................173, 525, 531, 553 Cardshops Ltd. v. John Lewis Properties Ltd. [1983] Q.B. 161 C.A. ...........................................................................574 Carega Properties S.A. v. Sharratt [1979] 1 W.L.R. 928 H.L..............................................................................118, 119 Carne v. De Bono [1988] 1 W.L.R. 1107 C.A. ............................................................................................................592 Carr v. Hackney L.B.C. (1996) 28 H.L.R. 747 Div.Ct. .......................................................................................267, 268 Carradine Properties Ltd. v. Aslam [1976] 1 W.L.R. 442, Goulding J. ...............................................................27, 580 Carrington Manufacturing Company Ltd. v. Saldin (1925) 133 L.T. 432..................................................................520 Carroll v. Manek (2000) 79 P. & C.R. 173 Ch.D. ......................................................................................................158 Carshalton Beeches Bowling Club v. Cameron [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 80 C.A. ................................................................572 Carson v. Cornwall C.C. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 21 ...........................................................................................................629 Carstairs v. Taylor (1871) L.R. 6 Ex. 217 ...................................................................................................248, 264, 677 Carter v. S.S. for the Environment [1994] 1 W.L.R. 1212 C.A.; ................................................................................180 Carter v. S.U. Carburetter Co. [1942] 2 K.B. 288 C.A. ..............................................................................................169 Castle Phillips Finance Co. Ltd. v. Raja [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3720 C.A.............................................................................259 Cator Art Services Ltd. v. Kenneth Bieber Photography Ltd. [1969] 1 W.L.R. 1226 C.A. .........................................791 Cavalier v. Pope [1906] A.C. 428 H.L. .......................................................................................................................250 Cawley v. Pratt [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 6 C.A. ...................................................................................................................626 Cazaly Irving Holdings Ltd. v. Cancol Ltd. [1995] E.G.C.S. 146, Knox J...................................................................773 Celsteel v. Alton House Holdings Ltd. (No.2) [1986] 1 W.L.R. 666, Scott J., affirmed [1987] 1 W.L.R. 291 C.A. ...............................................................................................................................720, 782 Centaploy v. Matlodge [1974] Ch 1, Whitford J. .................................................................................................24, 515 Central Estates (Belgravia) Ltd. v. Woolgar [1972] 1 Q.B. 48, (No.2) [1972] 1 W.L.R. 1048 C.A...............................................................................................................409, 800, 814, 820 Central Estates Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 239 .............................................................659–660 Central London Property Trust see High Trees Central Street Properties Ltd. v. Mansbrook Rudd & Co. Ltd. [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 33..................................................647 Central Trust & Safe Deposit Co. v. Snider [1916] 1 A.C. 266 H.L. ..........................................................................527 Central Y.M.C.A. H.Ass. v. Goodman (1991) 24 H.L.R. 98 C.A. ..............................................................................171 Central Y.M.C.A. H.Ass. v. Saunders (1991) 23 H.L.R. 212 C.A. .....................................................................147, 171 Centrovincial Estates plc. v. Bulk Storage Ltd. [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 45 ..........................................................................785 Cerex Jewels Ltd. v. Peachey Property Corporation plc. [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A. ...................................................570 Cerium Investments Ltd. v. Evans [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 80 C.A......................................................................................778
TABLE OF CASES
xxix
Chaloner v. Bower [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 4 C.A. ...............................................................................................................614 Chamberlain v. Farr [1942] 2 All E.R. 567 ................................................................................................................175 Chamberlain v. Scalley (1994) 26 H.L.R. 26 C.A. ................................................................................................39, 600 Chambers v. Kingham (1878) 10 Ch. D. 743 .............................................................................................................596 Chancery plc. v. Ketteringham (1995) 69 P. & C.R. 426 Ch.D. ...........................................................................37, 507 Chaplin v. Reid (1858) 1 F. & F. 315, 175 E.R. 743. ...................................................................................................686 Chaplin v. Smith [1926] 1 K.B. 198 C.A. ....................................................................................................................726 Chapman v. Smith [1907] 2 Ch. 97.............................................................................................................................768 Chapman & Hobbs,Re (1885) 29 Ch.D. 1007, Pearson J. .........................................................................................388 Chapman v. Freeman [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1298 C.A. .............................................................................................544, 547 Chapman v. Smith [1907] 2 Ch. 97 ............................................................................................................................711 Chappell v. Gregory (1863) 34 Beav. 250, 55 E.R. 631........................................................................................251, 527 Charles Clements (London) Ltd. v. Rank City Wall Ltd. [1978] 1 E.G.L.R. 47, Goulding J. ....................................568 Charles Frodsham & Co. v. Morris (1972) 229 E.G. 961 ............................................................................................538 Chartered Trust plc. v. Davies [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 83 C.A. ..........................................................................258, 691, 719 Charville Estates Ltd. v. Unipart Group Ltd. [1997] E.G.C.S. 36................................................309, 712, 717, 797, 810 Chassagnou v. France (1999) 7 B.H.R.C. 151 ....................................................................................................204, 206 Chatham Empire Theatre (1955) Ltd. v. Ultrans [1961] 1 W.L.R. 817, Salmon J.....................................................825 Chatsworth Properties Ltd. v. Effiom [1971] 1 W.L.R. 144 ........................................................................................307 Chatterton v. Terrell [1923] A.C. 578 H.L. .................................................................................................................813 Chattey Holdings Inc. v. Farndale [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 153 ..........................................................................................530 Cheapside Land Development Co. Ltd. v. Messels Service Co. see United Scientific Holdings [1978] A.C. 904 H.L. ...............................................................................................................................................657 Chelsea v. Hirshorn [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 90 Ct.Ct. .......................................................................................................411 Chelsea v. Hutchinson [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 61 C.A. (1997) 28 H.L.R. 17 C.A......................................................807, 823 Chelsea v. Muscatt [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 48 C.A......................................................................................................685, 694 Chelsea Estates Investments Trust Co. Ltd. v. Marche [1955] Ch. 328, Upjohn J......................................................824 Chelsea Yacht and Boat Club Ltd. v. Pope [2000] 22 E.G. 139 C.A. ..................................................................183, 696 Chelsfield M.H. Investments Ltd. v. British Gas plc.[1995] N.P.C. 169. ....................................................................710 Cheniston Investments Ltd. v. Waddock [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 136 C.A. ........................................................................235 Cheryl Investments Ltd. v. Saldanha [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1329 C.A. ..............................................301, 544, 550, 551, 559 Cheshire Lines Committee v. Lewis & Co. (1880) 50 L.J.Q.B. 121 C.A. .......................................................24, 514, 516 Chester v. Buckingham Travel Ltd. [1981] 1 W.L.R. 96, [1981] 1 All E.R. 386 .........................................................633 Chester v. Powell (1885) 52 L.T. 722 C.A. ..................................................................................................................251 Chesterfield v. Bolton (1739) 2 Com. 627, 92 E.R. 1241.............................................................................................689 Chester’s Accommodation Agency Ltd. v. Abebrese [1997] Times July 28th C.A. ......................................................322 Cheverell Estates Ltd. v. Harris [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 27, Geoffrey Brice Q.C................................................................783 Chez Gerard Ltd. v. Greene Ltd. [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 79 C.A. ......................................................................................572 Childers (J.W.) Trustees v. Anker [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. .................................................38, 598, 599, 627, 628, 666 Chiltern Court (Baker St.) Residents Ltd. v. Wallabrook Property Co. Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 207 C.A. ..........430, 579 Chin v. Hackney L.B.C. (1996) 28 H.L.R. 423 C.A. ...................................................................................................260 Chiodi v. De Marney [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 64 C.A. ................................................................................................259, 260 Chios Property Investment Co. Ltd. v. Lopez (1988) 20 H.L.R. 120 C.A. ...................................................................119 Chipperfield v. Shell U.K. Ltd. [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 51 C.A. .........................................................................................567 Chiswell v. Griffon Land & Estates Ltd. [1975] 1 W.L.R. 1181 C.A. .................................................................560, 593 Cholmeley’s School v. Sewell [1893] 2 Q.B. 254 ..........................................................................................................823 Chorley B.C. v. Ribble Motor Services Ltd. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 182 C.A. .........................................341, 632, 674, 712 Chrisdell Ltd. v. Johnson [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 123 C.A. ........................................................................................290, 813 Church Commissioners for England v. Al Emarah [1997] Fam. 34 C.A. .........................................123, 139, 140, 141 Church Commissioners for England v. Baines see Wellcome Trust .............................................................................301 Church Commissioners for England v. Nodjoumi (1986) 51 P. & C.R. 155, Hirst J. ........................................813, 821 Church Commissioners for England v. Ve-Ri-Best Manufacturing Co. Ltd. [1957] 1 Q.B. 238 C.A. ................589, 803 Church v. Brown (1808) 15 Ves. 258, 33 E.R. 752 .............................................................................................728, 729 Circle 33 v. Watt [1999] 4 C.L. 355 ............................................................................................................................342 Citron v. Cohen (1920) 36 T.L.R. 560 ................................................................................................................264, 678 City and Capital Holdings Ltd. v. Dean Warburg Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 90 C.A. ....................................................645 City and Metropolitan Properties Ltd. v. Greycroft Ltd.[1987] 1 W.L.R. 1085 ..........................................................754 City Hotels Group Ltd. v. Total Property Investments Ltd. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 253, Judge Paul Baker Q.C...............731 City of London B.S. v. Flegg [1988] A.C. 54 H.L. .......................................................................................................125
xxx
TABLE OF CASES
City of London C. v. Devlin (1997) 29 H.L.R. 58 C.A. ...............................................................................................319 City of London Corp. v. Bown (1990) 60 P. & C.R. 42 C.A. .......................................................................................113 City of London Corporation v. Fell [1993] Q.B. 589 C.A., [1994] 1 A.C. 458 H.L. ....................................................................................................559, 586, 747, 776, 777, 781 City of London v. Richmond (1701) 2 Vern 421, 23 E.R. 870, on appeal (1702) 1 Bro. Parl. Cas. 516, 1 E.R. 727 H.L............................................................................................................................................................................761 City of Westminster Assurance Co. v. Ainis (1975) 29 P. & C.R. 469 C.A..................................................................825 City Offices (Regent Street) Ltd. v. Europa Acceptance Group Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 63 C.A. .................................677 City Offices plc. v. Bryanston Insurance Co. Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 126, Aldous J. ...................................................664 City Permanent B.S. v. Miller [1952] Ch. 840 C.A. ...............................................................30, 35, 506, 524, 526, 529 Civil Service Co-operative Society Ltd. v. McGrigor’s Trustees [1923] 2 Ch. 347, Russell J. .............................799, 814 Clancy v. Caird [2000] S.L.T. 546 C.S. I.H. ...............................................................................................................205 Clarence Café Ltd. v. Colchester Properties Ltd. [1999] 11 C.L. 331 ..........................................................................830 Clark (W.G.) (Properties) Ltd. v. Dupre Properties Ltd.[1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 59 Ch.D. ................................................831 Clark v. Banks [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3785 C.A....................................................................................................................554 Clark v. Chief Land Register [1994] Ch. 370 C.A. ................................................................................................37, 507 Clays Lane Housing Co-Operative v. Patrick (1985) 49 P. & C.R. 72 C.A. ................................................................794 Clegg v. Hands.(1890) 44 Ch.D. 503 C.A. ..........................................................................................................768, 769 Cleveland Shoe Co. Ltd v. Murray’s Book Sales (King’s Cross) Ltd. (1973) 227 E.G. 987, reversed (1973) 229 E.G. 1465 C.A. ......................................................................................................................................688 Clickex Ltd. v. McCann [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 63 C.A......................................................................................27, 47, 48, 56 Clifford v. Johnson’s P.Rs. [1979] 2 E.G.L.R. 41 C.A. ........................................................................................820, 824 Clift v. Taylor [1948] 2 K.B. 394 C.A. .........................................................................................................................539 Climie v. Wood (1869) L.R. 4 Exch. 328 .....................................................................................................................697 Close v. Wilberforce (1838) 1 Beav. 112, 48 E.R. 881, Landgale M.R. .......................................................................789 Clydesdale Bank plc. v. Davidson [1998] S.C. 51 H.L.................................................................................................595 Coastplace Ltd. v. Hartley Ltd. [1987] Q.B. 948, French J. ........................................................................................537 Coates Bros. plc. v. General Accident Life Assurance Ltd. [1991] 1 W.L.R. 712, Millett J. ........................................667 Coates v. Diment [1951] 1 All E.R. 890.......................................................................................................................626 Coatsworth v. Johnson (1886) 55 L.J.Q.B. 220 C.A.............................................................524, 527, 529, 531–533, 823 Cobb v. Lane [1952] 1 All E.R. 1199 C.A. ..................................................................................................................172 Cobstone Investments Ltd. v. Maxim [1985] Q.B. 140 C.A. ...............................................................................341–342 Coca-Cola Financial Corporation v. Finsat International Ltd. [1998] Q.B. 43 C.A...................................................648 Cock, Re ex p. Shilston (1887) 20 Q.B.D. 343 .............................................................................................................775 Cockburn v. Smith [1924] 2 K.B. 119 C.A. ................................................................................................................674 Cocks v. Thanet D.C. [1983] 2 A.C. 286 H.L. ...............................................................................................................87 Cockson v. Cock (1607) Cro. Jac. 125, 79 E.R. 109 ....................................................................................................768 Cohen v. Popular Restaurants Ltd. [1917] 1 K.B. 480, Rowlatt J. ......................................................................732, 769 Cohen v. Tannar [1900] 2 Q.B. 609 C.A. ...................................................................................................................754 Cohen v. West Ham Corporation [1933] Ch. 814 C.A. ..............................................................................................271 Cole v. Kelly [1920] 2 K.B. 106 C.A.....................................................................................................305, 743, 749, 755 Coles v. William Hill Organisation Ltd.[1999] L.T.R. 14 Ch.D. ................................................................................520 Collier v. Hollinshead [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 14, Scott J. .................................................................................................613 Collier v. Stoneman [1957] 1 W.L.R. 1108 C.A. ........................................................................................................120 Collin v. Westminster [1985] Q.B. 581 C.A. ...............................................................................................411, 412, 526 Collin Estates Ltd. v. Buckley [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 78 C.A. ...........................................................................................780 Collins v. Barrow (1831) 1 M. & Rob. 112, 174 E.R. 38 .............................................................................251, 258, 691 Collins v. Claughton [1959] 1 W.L.R. 145 C.A. ...........................................................................................40, 598, 599 Collins v. Collins (1973) 4 Fam. Law 133 C.A. ..........................................................................................................130 Collins v. Hopkins [1923] 2 K.B. 617 ..........................................................................................................................251 Collinson v. Lettsom (1815) 6 Taunt. 224, 128 E.R. 1020...................................................................................538, 770 Comber v. Fleet Electrics Ltd. [1955] 1 W.L.R. 566, Vaisey J. ....................................................................................740 Commercial Union Life Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Moustafa [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 44, Smedley J. .....................592–593, 783 Commercial Union Life Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Woolworth plc. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 237...............................................664 Commission for New Towns v. R. Levy & Co. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 121 Ch.D...............................................................657 Commissioners for Work v. Hull [1922] 1 K.B. 205 ...................................................................................................832 Compton Group Ltd. v. Estates Gazette Ltd. (1977) 36 P. & C.R. 148 .......................................................................642 Congleton Corporation v. Pattison (1810) 10 East 130, 103 E.R. 725, Bayley J. ............................................................................................711, 766, 768, 769, 770, 771–772
TABLE OF CASES
xxxi
Connaught Restaurants Ltd. v. Indoor Leisure Ltd. [1994] 1 W.L.R. 501 C.A. .........................................................648 Conquest v. Ebbetts [1896] A.C. 490 H.L. ..........................................................................................................682, 683 Constantinou v. Enfield L.B.C. [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 2640 .................................................................................................271 Conway v. Arthur [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 113 C.A. ...........................................................................................................668 Cook v. Shoesmith [1951] 1 K.B. 752 C.A...................................................................................................................728 Cooke (E.D. & A.D.) Bourne (Farms) Ltd. v. Mellows [1982] 2 All E.R. 208 C.A. ...................................................629 Cooke’s case (1582) Moore K.B. 177, 72 E.R. 515 ......................................................................................................697 Coole,Re [1920] 2 Ch. 536 ..........................................................................................................................................596 Coombs v. Parry (1987) 19 H.L.R. 384 C.A. ..............................................................................................................350 Cooper Executors v. Edinburgh City D.C. (1991) 23 H.L.R. 349 H.L.................................................................501, 503 Cooper v. Henderson [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 42 C.A. ........................................................................................................812 Cooper v. Tait (1984) 48 P. & C.R. 460 C.A. ..............................................................................................................163 Co-operative Insurance Society Ltd. v. Argyll Stores (Holdings) Ltd. [1998] A.C. 1 H.L. ..............................684, 712 Co-operative Retail Services Ltd. v. Taylor Young Partnership Ltd. [2000] Independent July 14th .........................788 Co-operative Wholesale Society Ltd. v. National Westminster Bank plc. (1994) 68 P. & C.R. 256 C.A. ...................664 Cooper’s Lease,Re (1968) 19 P. & C.R. 541, Cross J. ..................................................................................................728 Cooper-Smith, see Escalus ................................................................................................................................................. Coppen v. Bruce Smith (1999) 77 P. & C.R. 239 C.A. ...............................................................................567, 570, 571 Cork v. Cork [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 5, Knox J. .........................................................................................................127, 617 Cornillie v. Saha (1996) 28 H.L.R. 561 C.A................................................................................................812, 813, 814 Cornish v. Brook Green Laundry Ltd. [1959] 1 Q.B. 394 C.A...................................................523, 524, 530, 551, 565 Cornwall v. Henson [1899] 2 Ch. 710, Cozens-Hardy J.............................................................................................527 Coronation Street Industrial Properties Ltd. v. Ingall Industries plc [1989] 1 W.L.R. 304 H.L. ...............................................................................................................537, 765, 767, 786 Corpus Christi College v. Rogers (1879) 49 L.J.Q.B. 4 C.A. ..................................................................................38, 599 Corson v. Rhuddlan B.C. (1990) 59 P. & C.R. 185 C.A. .....................................................................................536, 656 Cory v. Bristow [1877] 2 A.C. 262 H.L. ......................................................................................................................183 Costain Developments Ltd. v. Finlay & Co. Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 237 Div.Ct. .......................................................712 Costello v. Costello (1995) 27 H.L.R. 12 C.A. .............................................................................................................495 Costelloe v. Camden L.B.C. [1986] Crim. L.R. 249 Div.Ct. .......................................................................................316 Cottage Holiday Associates v. Customs & Excise Commissioners [1983] Q.B. 735 ..............................................18, 510 Council of the Civil Service Union v. Minister for the Civil Service [1985] 2 A.C. 377 H.L. ........................................88 County Personnel (Employment Agency) Ltd. v. Alan R. Pulver & Co. [1987] 1 W.L.R. 916 C.A. ...........................657 Coupland v. Maynard (1810) 12 East. 134, 104 E.R. 53.............................................................................................600 Courage Ltd. v. Crehan [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 145 C.A. ..................................................................................257, 647, 713 Court v. Robinson [1951] 2 K.B. 60 C.A. ...........................................................................................................543, 550 Cousins v. Metropolitan Guarantee Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 223 L.V.T. .............................................................429, 430 Cousins v. Phillips (1865) 3 H. & C. 892, 159 E.R. 786 .............................................................................................602 Cove v. Smith (1886) 2 T.L.R. 778 .............................................................................................................................593 Covell Matthews & Partners v. French Wools Ltd. [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1477 C.A. .................................................562, 587 Covent Garden Group v. Naiva (1994) 27 H.L.R. 295 C.A. ..............................................................................412, 414 Coventry C.C. v. Cartwright [1975] 1 W.L.R. 845, [1975] 2 All E.R. 99 Div.Ct. ......................................................266 Coventry C.C. v. Cole [1994] 1 W.L.R. 398 C.A. .......................................................................................................500 Coventry C.C. v. Doyle [1981] 1 W.L.R. 1325 Div.Ct. ...............................................................................................269 Coventry C.C. v. Finnie (1997) 29 H.L.R. 658, Scott-Baker J. ...................................................................................343 Coventry C.C. v. J. Hepworth & Son Ltd. [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 C.A. ......................................................................659 Cow v. Casey [1949] 1 K.B. 474 C.A. .........................................................................................................................300 Cowan v. Wrayford [1953] 1 W.L.R. 1340..................................................................................................................622 Cowan (Alexander) & Sons Ltd. v. Acton[1952]SLT.122 ...........................................................................................550 Coward v. Gregory (1866) L.R. 2 C.P. 153 ..................................................................................................................676 Cowell v. Rosehill Racecourse Co. Ltd. [1937] 56 C.L.R. 605, High Ct. of Australia .................................................533 Cox v. Binfield [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 97 C.A. ..........................................................................................................571, 572 Cox v. Bishop (1857) 8 De G.M. & G. 815, 44 E.R. 604 .....................................................................533, 756, 757, 761 Cox v. Husk [1976] 2 E.G.L.R. 1, Griffiths J. ..............................................................................................................614 Craddock v. Hampshire C.C. [1958] 1 W.L.R. 202 C.A. ............................................................................................609 Crago v. Julian [1992] 1 W.L.R. 372 C.A. ...................................................20, 123, 124, 136, 289, 293, 294, 508, 721 Crake v. Supplmentary Benefits Commission [1982] 1 All E.R. 498 ...........................................................................240 Crancour Ltd. v. Da Silvaesa (1987) 52 P. & C.R. 204 ..............................................................................................155 Crane v. Batten (1854) 2 C.L.R. 1696 ........................................................................................................................685
xxxii
TABLE OF CASES
Crane v. Morris [1965] 1 W.L.R. 1104 C.A. ...........................................................................................................22, 26 Crantrave Ltd. v. Lloyds Bank plc. [2000] 4 All E.R. 473 C.A. ..................................................................................788 Crate v. Miller [1947] K.B. 946 C.A. ...........................................................................................................................581 Crawford v. Clarke [2000] E.G.C.S. 33 C.A. ...............................................................................................................820 Crawford v. Elliott [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 13 C.A. ............................................................................................616, 622, 624 Crawford v. Newton (1886) 36 W.R. 54 C.A. .............................................................................................................675 Crawley B.C. v. B. [2000] Times March 28th C.A. ...........................................................................................73, 85, 88 Crawley B.C. v. Sawyer (1988) 20 H.L.R. 98 C.A. .............................................................................................105, 109 Crawley B.C. v. Ure [1996] Q.B. 13 C.A. ............................................................................................................127, 128 Crawley Mansions Ltd.,Re [1994] E.G.C.S. 95 ..........................................................................................................425 Crean Davidson Investments Ltd. v. Cadogan [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 96 C.Ct..........................................367, 291, 435, 443 Crédit Suisse v. Beegas Nominees Ltd. [1994] 4 All E.R. 803, Lindsay J.....................................................................676 Creear v. Fearon [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 12 C.A.................................................................................................................629 Creery v. Summersell [1949] Ch. 751, Harman J. ...............................................................................732, 739, 799, 813 Cremin v. Barjack Properties Ltd. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 30 C.A. .....................................................................................820 Creska Ltd. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 35 C.A................................................................677 Cressingham Properties Ltd., Re [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 117 L.Tr. ............................................................................412, 414 Crewe Services & Investment Corporation v. Silk [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ......................................................682, 683 Cricket Ltd. v. Shaftesbury plc. [1999] 3 All E.R. 283, Neuberger J..........................................................551, 553, 555 Cricklewood Property & Investment Trust Ltd. v. Leighton’s Investment Trust Ltd. [1945] A.C. 221 H.L. ...............................................................................................................222, 713, 714, 715, 716 Crisp v. Fox (1967) 201 E.G. 769 ................................................................................................................................175 Cristina v. Seear [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 128 C.A. ..............................................................................................................547 Crittenden (Warren Park) Ltd. v. Elliott (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 20 C.A........................................................................180 Crockford v. Alexander (1808) 15 Ves. 138, 33 E.R. 707 ...........................................................................................175 Crocker (D.J.) Securities (Portsmouth) Ltd. v. Johal [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 102 C.A. ..............................................108, 109 Croft v. Lumley (1858) 6 H.L.C. 672, 10 E.R. 1459 ...................................................................................................814 Cromwell Developments Ltd. v. Godfrey.[1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 62 C.A. ..................................................775, 806, 809, 829 Cronin v. Rogers (1884) Cab. & El. 348 ......................................................................................................................589 Crosbie v. Tooke (1833) 1 My. & K. 431, 39 E.R. 745, Brougham L.C. .....................................................................727 Crossfield v. Morrison (1849) 7 C.B. 286, 137 E.R. 114 ..............................................................................................791 Crouch & Lees v. Haridas [1972] 1 Q.B. 158 C.A. .....................................................................................................242 Crowhurst Park Ltd.,Re [1974] 1 W.L.R. 583, [1974] 1 All E.R. 991, Goulding J. ..................................................572 Crowley v. Vitty (1852) 7 Exch. 319, 155 E.R. 968 .....................................................................................................599 Crown Estate Commissioners v. Connor (1986) 19 H.L.R. 35, McCowan J...............................................230, 231, 241 Crown Estate Commissioners v. Signet Group plc [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 200 ..........................................................710, 739 Crown Estate Commissioners v. Town Investments Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 61 Off.Rec. ...........................................683 Crown Lands Commissioners v. Page [1960] 2 Q.B. 274 C.A. ............................................................................222, 654 Crown Lodge (Surbiton) Investments Ltd. v. Nalecz [1967] 1 W.L.R. 647 C.A..........................................................149 Croydon (Unique) Ltd. v. Wright[1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 28 C.A...............................................................................824, 836 Croydon L.B.C. v. Buston (1991) 24 H.L.R. 36 C.A...........................................................106, 123, 124, 288, 293–294 Croydon L.B.C. v. Maxon Systems Inc. (London) Ltd. [1999] E.G.C.S. 68, Jowitt J. ........................................554, 669 Croydon L.B.C. v. Moody (1999) 31 H.L.R. 738 C.A. ........................................................................................331, 341 Croydon L.B.C. v. Nana [1997] C.L.Y. 2720 ..............................................................................................................319 Crump v. Temple (1890) 7 T.L.R. 120.................................................................................................................524, 525 Crumpton v. Unifox Properties Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 82 C.A. .................................................................................430 Crusoe d. Blencowe v. Bugby (1771) 2 W. Bl. 766, 96 E.R. 448 ..........................................................................727, 731 Cryer v. Scott Bros. (Sunbury) Ltd. (1988) 55 P. & C.R. 183 C.A. .....................................................................370, 693 Culworth Estates Ltd. v. Society of Licensed Victuallers [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 54 C.A. ..........................................681–683 Cumming v. Danson [1942] 2 All E.R. 653 C.A. ................................................................................................331, 336 Cumshaw Ltd. v. Bowen [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 30 ...........................................................................................................666 Cunliffe v. Goodman [1950] 2 K.B. 237 C.A. .............................................................................................571, 681, 682 Cunningham v. Birmingham C.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 158 Q.B.D. ..............................................................................266 Curl v. Angelo [1948] 2 All E.R. 189 ..........................................................................................................................145 Curtis v. London R.A.C. [1999] Q.B. 92 C.A., on appeal from [1997] 4 All E.R. 842 ...............................................................................................227, 229, 231–232, 233, 238, 239 Curtis v. Wheeler (1830) Moo. & M. 493, 173 E.R. 1235...........................................................................................725 Cusack-Smith v. Gold [1958] 1 W.L.R. 611, Pilcher J. ......................................................................................589, 803 Cuthbertson v. Irving (1859) 4 H. & N. 742, 157 E.R. 1034, (1860) 6 H. & N. 135, 158 E.R. 56 .............304, 566, 750
TABLE OF CASES
xxxiii
Cymru Investments Ltd. v. Watkins [1997] 37 R.V.R. 171 L.Tr. ...............................................................................459 Cynon Valley B.C. v. Secretary of State for Wales and Oi Mee Lan (1987) 53 P. & C.R. 68 C.A. .............................709 D. v. U.K. (1997) 24 E.H.R.R. 423. ..............................................................................................................................97 Daejean Properties Ltd. v. Mahoney [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 75 C.A. .........................................................111, 118, 124, 289 Daejean Properties Ltd. v. Weeks [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 125 L.Tr. ...................................................................................437 DAF Motoring Centre (Gosport) Ltd. v. Hutfield & Wheeler Ltd. [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 59 C.A. ...................................571 Dagger v. Shepherd [1946] K.B. 215 C.A. ...................................................................................................................585 Daiches v. Bluelake Investments Ltd. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 67.........................................................................................452 Dailworth Ltd. v. T.G. Organisation (Europe) Ltd. (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 147 C.A. ...........................................647, 690 Dallhold Estates (U.K.) Property Ltd. v. Lindsey Trust Properties Ltd. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 93 C.A.....460, 590, 591, 623 Dalton v. Pickard [1920] 2 K.B. 545n C.A. .................................................................................................................597 Dalton,Re [1963] Ch. 336 Div.Ct. ..............................................................................................................................652 Dame Margaret Hungerford Charity Trustees v. Beazeley [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 143 C.A. ....................................246, 352 Dance v. Welwyn Hatfield D.C. [1990] 1 W.L.R. 1097 C.A. ......................................................................................502 Daniels v. Walker [2000] Times May 17th C.A. .................................................................................................205, 210 Dando (S.L.) Ltd. v. Hitchcock [1954] 2 Q.B. 317 C.A. .............................................................................................170 Darby v. Williams (1974) 232 E.G. 579 .....................................................................................................................609 Darcy v. Askwith (1618) Hob. 234, 80 E.R. 380. ........................................................................................................692 Darlington B.C. v. Denmark Chemists Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 62 C.A...............................................................818–820 Darlington B.C v. Sterling (1998) 29 H.L.R. 309 C.A. ........................................................................................336, 342 Darlington B.C. v. Waring & Gillow (Holdings) Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 159 Ch.D...................................................658 Darrell v. Wybone (1561) 2 Dyer 206b, 73 E.R. 455...................................................................................................750 Davenport v. R. (1877) 3 App.Cas. 115 P.C................................................................................................................814 Davenport v. Smith [1921] 2 Ch. 270, Astbury J. ...............................................................................................754, 830 Davenport v. Walsall M.B.C. (1996) 28 H.L.R. 754 Div.Ct. ......................................................................................268 Davies v. Benyon-Harris (1931) 47 T.L.R. 424 ...........................................................................................................144 Davies v. Davies (1888) 38 Ch.D. 499, Kekewich J. ...........................................................................................262, 672 Davies v. Peterson [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 121 C.A. ...................................................................................259, 260, 349, 350 Davies v. Property & Reversionary Co. Ltd. [1929] 2 K.B. 222 ..................................................................................652 Davies v. Yadegar [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 70 C.A. ..............................................................................................................693 Davies, Re, ex parte Williams (1872) L.R. 7 Ch.App. 314 ..........................................................................................652 Davis v. Elf Oil U.K. Properties Ltd. [1995] E.G.C.S. 196 ..........................................................................................820 Davis v. Foots [1940] 1 K.B. 116 C.A. ........................................................................................................................260 Davis v. James (1884) 26 Ch.D. 778....................................................................................................................304, 750 Davis v. Johnson [1979] A.C. 264 H.L. .......................................................................................................................140 Davis v. Powell [1977] 1 W.L.R. 258, [1977] 1 All E.R. 471. ....................................................................................628 Davis v. Town Properties Investment Corporation Ltd. [1903] 1 Ch. 797 C.A. .........................................765, 769, 770 Davison v. Gent (1857) 1 H. & N. 744, 156 E.R. 1400 ...............................................................................................600 Davstone Estate Ltd.’s Lease,Re [1969] 2 Ch. 378, [1969] 2 All E.R. 849 ..........................................................458, 705 Dawncar Investments Ltd. v. Plews (1993) 25 H.L.R. 639 C.A. .................................................................................352 Dawnrays Ltd. v. F.G. Minter Ltd. [1971] 1 W.L.R. 1205 C.A...................................................................................647 Day v. Singleton [1899] 2 Ch. 320 C.A. .....................................................................................................................741 Dayani v. Bromley L.B.C. [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 144 Q.B.D. ...........................................................................262, 368, 672 De Brassac v. Martyn (1863) 9 L.T. 287. ....................................................................................................................533 De FalbeRe [1901] 1 Ch. 523 see Leigh v. Taylor H.L.........................................................................................698, 699 De Lassalle v. Guildford [1901] 2 K.B. 215 C.A. .........................................................................................................251 De Nicholls v. Sanders (1870) L.R. 5 C.P. 589 ...........................................................................................................645 de Rothschild v. Bell [2000] Q.B. 33 C.A. ..........................................................................................................392–393 De Soysa v. De Pless Pol [1912] A.C. 194 H.L.............................................................................................................739 De Walden v. Barber (1903) 19 T.L.R. 183, Wright J.................................................................................................768 Deadman v. Southwark L.B.C. [1999] 1 C.L. 281 ......................................................................................................254 Dealex Properties Ltd. v. Brooks [1966] 1 Q.B. 542 C.A. ...........................................................................................124 Dean v. Prince [1954] 1 Ch. 409, [1954] 1 All E.R. 749 .....................................................................................458, 705 Deanplan Ltd. v. Mahmoud [1993] Ch. 151 ...............................................................................................................786 Debtor (No. 21 of 1995),Re [1996] C.L.Y. 3750..........................................................................................................778 Debtor No. 13A-IO-1995,Re [1995] 1 W.L.R. 1127, Rattee J. ...........................................................................814, 830 Debtor No.10 of 1992,Re [1995] B.C.C. 525 Ch.D. ....................................................................................................652 Decca Navigator Co. Ltd. v. Greater London C. [1974] 1 W.L.R. 748 C.A. ...............................................................570
xxxiv
TABLE OF CASES
Deen v. Andrews [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 262, Hirst J. ................................................................................................697, 698 Deerfield Travel Services Ltd. v. Leatherseller’s Company [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 39 C.A. ...............................................695 Delaney v. T.P. Smith Ltd. [1946] 1 K.B. 393 C.A .....................................................................................................312 Dellenty v. Pellow [1951] 2 K.B. 858 C.A. ..................................................................................................................337 Dellneed v. Chin (1987) 53 P. & C.R. 172...................................................................................................................551 Demetri v. Westminster C.C. (2000) 32 H.L.R. 470 C.A. .............................................................................................88 Demetriou v. Panayi [1998] C.L.Y. 3597 ......................................................................................................................47 Demetriou v. Poolaction Ltd. [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 100 C.A. (also v. Robert Andrews (Estate Agencies) Ltd.)..............................................................................................................................545, 588, 671 Demuren v. Seal Estates Ltd [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 102 C.A. ...................................................................................153, 155 Dendy v. Evans [1910] 1 K.B. 263 C.A........................................................................................................806, 818, 821 Dendy v. Nicholl (1858) 4 C.B.N.S. 376, 140 E.R. 1130 .............................................................................................813 Denetower Ltd. v. Toop [1991] 1 W.L.R. 945 C.A. .....................................................................................428, 429, 431 Denman v. Brise [1949] 1 K.B. 22 C.A................................................................................................................222, 716 Dennis see Escalus Dennis v. Elf Oil U.K. Properties Ltd. [1995] E.G.C.S. 196. .......................................................................................554 Dennis v. McDonald [1982] Fam. 63 C.A. .................................................................................................................231 Dennis & Robinson Ltd. v. Kiossos Establishment Ltd. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 133 C.A....................................................662 Denny Mott & Dickson Ltd. v. James B. Fraser & Co. Ltd. [1944] A.C. 265 H.L. .....................................................714 Department of the Environment v. Allied Freehold Property Trust Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 100 C.Ct........................667 Department of the Environment v. Royal Insurance plc. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 83, Falconer J. ..............................545, 574 Department of Transport v. Egoroff [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 89 C.A. ..................................................................................244 Derby & Co. v. I.T.C. Pension Trust Ltd. [1977] 2 All E.R. 890, Oliver J. ................................................................567 Desmond v. Bromley L.B.C. (1996) 28 H.L.R. 518 Q.B.D. ........................................................................................273 Deutsche Bank A.G. v. Ibrahim [1991] Financial Times, December 13th .......................................................................................780 Deverall v. Wyndham [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 57 Div.Ct. ..........................................................................................735, 738 Devonshire Reid Properties Ltd. v. Trenaman [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 45 L.Tr. .................................................426, 456, 702 Dewar v. Goodman [1909] A.C. 72 H.L., [1908] 1 K.B. 94 C.A. ..............................................................712, 765, 770 D’Eyncourt v. Gregory (1866) L.R. 3 Eq. 382 .............................................................................................................698 Di Palma v Victoria Square Property Co. Ltd. [1986] Fam. 150 C.A. .......................................................................817 Dibble (H.E.) Ltd. v. Moore [1970] 2 Q.B. 181 C.A. ..................................................................................................698 Dibbs v. Campbell (1988) 20 H.L.R. 374 C.A. ............................................................................................40, 49, 51, 52 Dickinson v. Boucher [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 12 C.A. ........................................................................................................623 Dickinson v. Enfield L.B.C. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 88 C.A. (1997) 27 H.L.R. 465............................................224, 497, 502 Dickinson v. St Aubyn [1944] K.B. 454 .......................................................................................................................671 Din v. Wandsworth L.B.C. [1983] 1 A.C. 657 H.L. ..............................................................................................78, 79 Dinefwr B.C. v. Jones [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 58 C.A. ........................................................................................................252 Disraeli,Re [1939] Ch. 382 ..........................................................................................................................................626 District Estates Ltd. v. Merseyside & Cheshire R.A.C. [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 3316, Owen J. .......................................232, 238 Divall v. Harrison [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 64 C.A...............................................................................................................589 Dixon v. Allgood [1987] 1 W.L.R. 1689 H.L. .....................................................................................................362, 391 Dixon v. Fisher (1843) 5 D. 775, Lord Cockburn.......................................................................................................698 D’Jan v. Bond Street Estates Ltd. [1993] E.G.C.S. 43 C.A. .................................................................................644, 651 Dobbs v. Linford [1953] 1 Q.B. 48, [1952] 2 All E.R. 827. ........................................................................................812 Dockerill v. Fitzpatrick [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ........................................................................................................613 Dodd Properties (Kent) Ltd. v. Canterbury C.C. [1980] 1 W.L.R. 433 C.A. ..............................................................683 Dodd v. Acklom (1843) 6 Man. & G. 672, 134 E.R. 1063...........................................................................................601 Dodds v. Walker [1981] 1 W.L.R. 1027 H.L. ......................................................................................................563, 581 Dodson Bull Carpet Co. Ltd. v. City of London Corp. [1975] 1 W.L.R. 781, Goff J. ..................................305, 560, 758 Doe d. Aslin v. Summersett (1830) 1 B. & Ad. 135, 109 E.R. 738 ..............................................................................127 Doe d. Beadon v. Pyke (1816) 5 M. & S. 146, 105 E.R. 1005 ..............................................................................299, 603 Doe d. Bedford v. Knightley (1796) 7 Term. Rep. 63, 101 E.R. 856 ...........................................................................580 Doe d. Bridger v. Whitehead (1838) 8 Ad. & El. 571, 112 E.R. 955............................................................................686 Doe d. De Rutzen v. Lewis (1836) 5 Ad. & El. 277, 111 E.R. 1170 .............................................................................814 Doe d. Egremont v. Courtenay (1848) 11 Q.B. 702, 116 E.R. 636 ..............................................................................599 Doe d. Freeman v. Bateman (1818) 2 B. & Ald. 168, 106 E.R. 328 ...................................................................726, 762 Doe d. Goodbehere v. Bevan (1815) 3 M. & S. 353, 105 E.R. 644...............................................................................728 Doe d. Gray v. Stanion (1836) 1 M. & W. 695, 150 E.R. 614 .....................................................................................596 Doe d. Grubb v. Burlington (1833) 5 B. & Ad. 507, 110 E.R. 878 ..............................................................................693
TABLE OF CASES
xxxv
Doe d. Hemmings v. Durnford (1832) 2 Cr. & J. 667, 149 E.R. 280...........................................................................751 Doe d. Henniker v. Watt (1828) 8 B. & C. 308, 108 E.R. 1057...................................................................................799 Doe d. Huddleton v. Johnston (1825) M’Cle. & Yo. 141, 148 E.R. 359......................................................................600 Doe d. Kindersley v. Hughes (1840) 7 M. & W. 139, 151 E.R. 711 ............................................................................127 Doe d. Knight v. Rowe (1826) 2 C. & P. 246, 172 E.R. 111 ........................................................................................815 Doe d. Lansdell v. Gower (1851) 17 Q.B. 589, 117 E.R. 1406.......................................................................................31 Doe d. Mitchinson v. Carter (1798) 8 Term. Rep. 57, 101 E.R. 1264, Kenyon C.J. ..........................................728, 729 Doe d. Morecraft v. Meux (1824) 1 C. & P. 346, 171 E.R. 1225 .................................................................................813 Doe d. Murrell v. Milward (1838) 3 M. & W. 328, 150 E.R. 1170. ............................................................................598 Doe d. Muston v. Gladwin (1845) 6 Q.B. 953, 115 E.R. 359 ......................................................................................687 Doe d. Newby v. Jackson (1823) 1 B.& C. 448, 107 E.R. 166 .....................................................................................175 Doe d. Palk v. Marchetti (1831) 1 B. & Ad. 715, 109 E.R. 953. .........................................................................299, 602 Doe d. Phipps v. Gower (1837) 1 Jur. 794. ..................................................................................................................831 Doe d. Pitt v. Hogg (1824) 4 Dow. & Ry. 226 ............................................................................................................727 Doe d. Pitt v. Shewin (1811) 3 Camp. 134, 170 E.R. 1331 ........................................................................................685 Doe d. Pittman v. Sutton (1841) 9 C. & P. 706, 173 E.R. 1019 ..................................................................................815 Doe d. Rankin v. Brindley (1832) 4 B. & Ad. 84, 110 E.R. 387 ..................................................................................814 Doe d. Rawling v. Walker (1826) 5 B. & C. 111, 108 E.R. 41 .....................................................................................596 Doe d. Read v. Ridout (1814) 5 Taunt. 519, 128 E.R. 792..........................................................................................597 Doe d. Sheppard v. Allen (1810) 3 Taunt. 78, 128 E.R. 32 ........................................................................................814 Doe d. Thomson v. Amey (1840) 12 Ad. & El. 476, 479, 113 E.R. 892.................................................................24, 515 Doe d. Tomes v. Chamberlaine (1839) 5 M. & W. 14, 151 E.R. 7 .....................................................................174, 175 Doe d. Warner v. Browne (1807) 8 East. 165, 103 E.R. 305 ...................................................................24, 32, 514, 516 Doe d. Whitfield v. Roe (1811) 3 Taunt. 402, 128 E.R. 160 ........................................................................................823 Doe d. Worcester v. Rowlands (1841) 9 C. & P. 734, 173 E.R. 1030, Coleridge J. .....................................................683 Doe d. Wyatt v. Stagg (1839) 5 Bing. N.C. 564, 132 E.R. 1217 ..................................................................................597 Doherty v. Allman (1878) 3 App. Cas. 709 H.L..................................................................................................692, 693 Dolgellau Golf Club v. Hett [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 75 C.A................................................................................................572 Dollar Land (Cumbernauld) Ltd. v. C.I.N. Properties Ltd. [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 79 H.L.(Sc.)......................374–375, 828 Dolonay v. Southwark L.B.C. [1999] 12 C.L. 414 .......................................................................................................333 Domer v. Gulf Oil (G.B.) Ltd. (1975) 119 S.J. 392, Megarry J. ..................................................................................545 Donath v. Second Duke of Westminster’s Trustees [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 203 L.V.T. ......................................................438 Donellan v. Read (1832) 3 B. & Ad. 899, 110 E.R. 330.........................................................................................38, 599 Dong Bang Minerva (U.K.) Ltd. v. Davina [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 31 C.A. ..............................................................733, 740 Doorbar v. Alltime Securities Ltd. [1996] 1 W.L.R. 456 C.A. .....................................................................................773 Dorkins v. Wright [1983] C.L.Y. 1364 C.Ct. ...............................................................................................................647 Dossee v. Doe d. East India Co. (1859) 1 L.T. 345 P.C. ................................................................................................22 Doughty v. Bowman (1848) 11 Q.B. 444, 116 E.R. 543 Ex. Ch..................................................................................770 Douglas-Scott v. Scorgie [1984] 1 W.L.R. 716, [1984] 1 All E.R. 1086 .....................................................................245 Dowell v. Dew (1843) 12 L.J. Ch. 158 ........................................................................................................................755 Downer Enterprises Ltd.,Re [1974] 1 W.L.R. 1460 Pennycuick J. .............................................................772, 787, 789 Downie v. Turner [1951] 2 K.B. 112 C.A. ...................................................................................................................812 Drane v. Evangelou [1978] 1 W.L.R. 455............................................................................................................309, 315 Dream Factory Ltd. v. Crown Estate Commissioners [1998] E.G.C.S. 136 Ch.D.......................................................795 Dreamgate Properties Ltd. v. Arnot (1998) 76 P. & C.R. 25 C.A. ........................................................22, 553, 599, 814 Dresden Estates Ltd. v. Collinson [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 45 C.A. ......................................................................................551 Drew-Morgan v. Hamid-Zadeh [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 13 C.A. .....................................................................460, 590, 591 Driscoll v. Church Commissionersof England [1957] 1 Q.B. 330 C.A. .......................................................................806 Driver v. Purbeck D.C. [1999] 10 C.L. 407 .......................................................................................................87, 88, 89 Drummond v. Austin Brown [1986] Ch. 52 C.A. ......................................................................................................574 D’Silva v. Lister House Developments Ltd. [1971] 1 Ch. 17 ...............................................................................543, 551 Dudley & District B.S. v. Emerson [1949] Ch. 707 C.A. ....................................................................................306, 589 Dudley M.B.C. v. Bailey (1990) 22 H.L.R. 424 C.A............................................................................................319, 336 Dugan-Chapman v. Grosvenor Estates [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 96 C.Ct.............................................................................399 Duke v. Porter (1987) 19 H.L.R. 1 C.A. ......................................................................................................................107 Dukeminster (Ebbgate House One) Ltd. v. Somerfield Property Co. Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 125 C.A. ..............664, 666 Dulwich College’s Application, Re (1973) 231 E.G. 845, Walton J. ............................................................................418 Dulwich Estate Trustees’s Appeal, Re (1998) 76 P. & C.R. 484 L.Tr. ........................................................................418 Dumpor’s case (1603) 4 Co. Rep. 119b, 76 E.R. 1110.................................................................................729, 759, 812
xxxvi
TABLE OF CASES
Dun & Bradstreet Software Services (England) Ltd. v. Provident Mutual Life Assurance Association [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 175 C.A..............................................................................................................................................583, 590 Duncan Fox & Co. v. N. & S. Wales Bank (1860) 6 App.Cas. 1 H.L. ........................................................................789 Duncan v. Paki [1976] 2 N.Z.L.R. 563 .........................................................................................................................31 Duncliffe v. Caerfelin Properties Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 38, Garland J...............................................................752, 754 Dunn v. Fidoe [1950] 2 All E.R. 685 ...........................................................................................................................609 Dunnell (R.J.) Property Investments Ltd. v. Thorpe [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 94 C.A. .....................................................49, 52 Dunster v. Hollis [1918] 2 K.B. 795 ............................................................................................................................249 Dunthorne and Shore v. Wiggins [1943] 2 All E.R. 678 .............................................................................................173 Durham City Estates Ltd. v. Felicetti [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 143 C.A. ..............................................................................657 Durley House Ltd. v. Cadogan [2000] 09 E.G. 183 C.A. ....................................................................................665, 695 Durman v. Bell (1988) 20 H.L.R. 340 C.A. ........................................................................................................188, 191 Dyer v. Dorset C.C. [1989] Q.B. 346 C.A. ..................................................................................................................496 Dymond v. Arundel-Timms [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A.....................................................................................396, 411 Dynevor v. Tennant (1888) 13 App. Cas. 279 H.L. ....................................................................................................596 Dyson Holdings Ltd. v. Fox [1976] Q.B. 503 C.A........................................................................................................119 Dyson v. Forster [1909] A.C. 98 H.L., on appeal from Forster v. Elvet Colliery Co. Ltd. [1908] 1 K.B. 629 C.A. ....................................................................................................................................770, 711 Dyson v. Kerrier D.C. [1980] 1 W.L.R. 1205 C.A. .......................................................................................................79 E.W.A. (A Debtor),Re [1901] 2 K.B. 642 C.A.............................................................................................................786 E.W.P. Ltd. v. Moore [1992] Q.B. 460 C.A. ................................................................................512, 543, 607, 609, 614 Eason v. Brewster [1997] 1 C.L.Y 1978 .......................................................................................................................520 East Coast Amusement Co. v. British Transport Board [1965] A.C. 58 H.L. .............................................................539 East Staffordshire B.C. v. Fairless (1999) 31 H.L.R. 677 Div.Ct. ................................................................................269 Easterby v. Sampson (1830) 6 Bing. 644, 130 E.R. 1429 ............................................................................................770 Eastern Counties B.S. v. Russell [1947] 1 All E.R. 500, Hilbery J. .............................................................................781 Eastern Telegraphic Co. v. Dent [1899] 1 Q.B. 835 C.A. ............................................................................................732 Eastleigh B.C. v. Betts [1983] 2 A.C. 613 H.L. ..............................................................................................................91 Eastleigh B.C. v. Walsh [1985] 1 W.L.R. 525 H.L........................................................................................67, 177, 178 Eaton Square Properties Ltd. v. Beveridge [1993] E.G.C.S. 91 C.A. ...........................................................................809 Eaton Square Properties Ltd. v. Ogilvie [2000] 1 E.G.L.R. 73.....................................................................................234 Ebied v. Hopkins see Wellcome Trust...........................................................................................................................301 Eccles v. Mills [1898] A.C. 360 P.C. ............................................................................................711, 764, 768, 777, 782 Ecclesiastical Commissioners for England v. Treemer [1893] 1 Ch. 166, Chitty J. .......................................299, 59, 602 Edell v. Dulieu [1924] A.C. 38 H.L. ............................................................................................................................616 Eden Park Estates Ltd. v. Longman [1982] Conv. 239 ................................................................................................767 Edge v. Pemberton (1843) 12 M. & W. 187, 152 E.R. 1164 ...............................................................................261, 672 Edicron Ltd. v. William Whitely Ltd. [1984] 1 W.L.R. 59 C.A. ..................................................................................574 Edler v. Auerbach [1950] 1 K.B. 359, Devlin J. ..................................................................................................247, 248 Edmunds v. Jones (1952) 213 L.T. 62 C.A. .................................................................................................................120 Edwardes v. Barrington (1901) 85 L.T. 650 H.L. ........................................................................................................726 Edwards (J.H.) & Sons Ltd. v. Central London Commercial Estates Ltd. [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 103 C.A. ......................567 Edwards v. Etherington (1825) Ry. & M. 268, 171 E.R. 1016 ............................................................247, 251, 258, 691 Edwards v. Morgan (1685) 3 Lev. 233, 83 E.R. 666 ....................................................................................................782 Edwards v. Thompson [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 71 C.A. ......................................................................................................571 Edwards v. West (1878) 7 Ch.D 858. ..........................................................................................................................689 Edward’s W.T.,Re [1982] Ch. 30, [1981] 2 All E.R. 941 C.A...............................................................................40, 601 Egerton v. Esplanade Hotels London Ltd. [1947] 2 All E.R. 88, Morris J. ..........................................................800, 821 Egerton v. Jones [1939] 2 Q.B. 702 C.A...............................................................................................................825, 835 Ehlmer v. Hall [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 137 C.A. .................................................................................................................689 El Naschie v. Pitt Place (Epsom) Ltd. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 228 C.A. ..............................................................................430 Electricity Supply Nominees Ltd. v. I.A.F. Group plc. [1993] 1 W.L.R. 1059 .............................................198, 638, 648 Electricity Supply Nominees Ltd. v. London Clubs Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 152 Ch.D. ..............................................662 Electricity Supply NomineesLtd. v. National Magazine Co. Ltd. [1999] 32 E.G. 84. [1998] E.G.C.S. 162 .........................................................................................................................................259, 706 Electricity Supply Nominees Ltd. v. Thorn E.M.I. Retail Ltd. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 46 C.A. ..................................705, 789 Elite Investments Ltd. v. T.I. Bainbridge Silencers Ltd. [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 43, (No.2) [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 50 ................................................................................................................................677, 682, 683
TABLE OF CASES
xxxvii
Elitestone Ltd. v. Morris [1997] 1 W.L.R. 687 H.L. reversing (1997) 73 P. & C.R. 259 C.A. .....................................................................................................179, 183, 696–697, 698, 699 Eller v. Grovecrest Investments Ltd. [1995] Q.B. 272 C.A...................................................................................641, 651 Elliott v. Bishop (1845) 10 Exch. 496, 156 E.R. 534....................................................................................................699 Elliott v. Boynton [1924] 1 Ch. 236 C.A......................................................................................................................807 Elliott v. Johnson (1868) L.R. 2 Q.B. 120 ....................................................................................................................755 Ellis & Son Fourth Amalgamated Properties Ltd. v. Southern R.A.P. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 91, Mann J. ......................234 Ellis v. Allen [1914] 1 Ch. 904, Sargant J. ..................................................................................................................800 Ellis v. Torrington [1920] 1 K.B. 399...........................................................................................................................753 Ellis v. Wright (1897) 76 L.T. 522 C.A. ...............................................................................................................525, 596 Elmcroft Developments Ltd v. Tankersley-Sawyer [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A.............................................249, 679, 680 Elmdene Estates Ltd. v. White [1960] A.C. 528 H.L. ..................................................................................................241 Elpis Maritime Co. Ltd. v. Marti Chartering Co. Inc. [1992] 1 A.C. 21 H.L. .............................................................780 Elsden v. Pick [1980] 1 W.L.R. 898 C.A ........................................................................................................29, 602, 616 Elvidge v. Coventry C.C. [1994] Q.B. 241 C.A. ..........................................................................................................495 Elwes v. Maw (1802) 3 East 38, 102 E.R. 510 ............................................................................................................700 Embassy Court Residents’ Association Ltd. v. Lipman [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 60 C.A. .....................................458, 459, 703 Empson v. Forde [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 131 C.A. .............................................................................................................345 Enfield L.B.C. v. B. [2000] 1 All E.R. 255 C.A.....................................................................................................342, 343 Enfield L.B.C. v. Devonish (1997) 29 H.L.R. 691 C.A.................................................................................................333 Enfield L.B.C. v. French (1985) 49 P. & C.R. 223 C.A. ..............................................................................................354 Enfield L.B.C. v. McKeon [1986] 1 W.L.R. 1007, [1986] 2 All E.R. 730 C.A. ...........................................................502 English Exporters (London) Ltd. v. Elonwall Ltd. [1973] Ch. 415, Megarry J. ..........................................................667 Epping Forest D.C. v. Pomphrett [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 46 C.A. .....................................................................................122 Epps v. Ledger (1972) 225 E.G. 1373 ..........................................................................................................................613 Epsom & Ewell B.C. v. C. Bell (Tadworth) Ltd. [1983] 1 W.L.R. 379 ........................................................................615 Epsom Grand Stand Association Ltd. v. Clarke (1919) 35 T.L.R. 525 .......................................................................301 Eren v. Tranmac Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 211 C.A. ......................................................................................................651 Errington v. Errington [1952] 1 K.B. 290 C.A.............................................................................................170, 172, 175 Escalus Properties Ltd. v. Robinson [1996] Q.B. 231 C.A. Escalus Properties Ltd. v. Cooper-Smith, Walsh, Dennis..........................................................................372, 377, 795, 804, 807, 816, 817, 821, 824, 825, 826 Esdaile v. Lewis [1956] 1 W.L.R. 709 C.A. .........................................................................................................297, 728 Espir v. Basil Street Hotel Ltd. [1936] 3 All E.R. 91 C.A. ............................................................................................682 Esselte A.B. v. Pearl Assurance plc. [1997] 1 W.L.R. 891, [1997] 2 All E.R. 41 C.A. .................................................588 Essex Plan Ltd. v. Broadminster [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 73 Ch.D. .....................................................................................554 Essexcrest Ltd. v. Evenlex Ltd. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. ...........................................................................................556 Esso Petroleum Ltd. v. Fumegrange (1994) 68 P. & C.R. D15 C.A. ...........................................................................554 Estates Gazette Ltd. v. Benjamin Restaurants Ltd. [1994] 1 W.L.R. 1528, [1995] 1 All E.R. 129 C.A. .....................778 Estavest Investments Ltd. v. Commercial Express Travel Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 91 C.A. .........................................169 Établissement Commercial Kamira v. Shiazzano [1985] Q.B. 93 C.A. ......................................................................393 Eton College v. Bard [1983] Ch. 321 C.A. ...........................................................................................................390, 510 Eton College v. Nassar [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 271, Harman J. .........................................................................................418 Euripides v. Gascoyne Holdings Ltd. (1996) 72 P. & C.R. 301 C.A. ...........................................................................661 Europark (Midlands) Ltd. v. Town Centre Securities plc. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 88, Warner J........................................572 European Commission v. United Kingdom Case 416/85 [1988] S.T.C. 456 E.Ct.J. ..................................................642 Euston Centre Properties Ltd. v. H.& J. Wilson Ltd. [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 57, Cantley J. ..............................................665 Evans Construction Ltd. v. Charrington & Co. [1983] Q.B. 810 C.A. .......................................................................563 Evans v. Clayhope Properties Ltd. [1988] 1 W.L.R. 358 C.A. ....................................................................................452 Evans v. Cynon Valley B.C. [1992] E.G.C.S. 3 C.A.....................................................................................................555 Evans v. Davis (1878) 10 Ch.D. 747, Fry J. .................................................................................................531, 805, 814 Evans v. Engelson [1980] 1 E.G.L.R. 62 C.A. .............................................................................................................350 Evans v. Hayward [1995] 2 F.L.R. 511 C.A. ...............................................................................................................495 Evans v. Levy [1910] 1 Ch. 452 ...................................................................................................................................740 Evans v. Roper [1960] 1 W.L.R. 814............................................................................................................................625 Evans v. South Ribble B.C. [1992] Q.B. 757 ...............................................................................................................651 Evans v. Tomkins [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 6 C.A. ...............................................................................................................615 Ewart v. Fryer [1901] 1 Ch. 499 C.A., on appeal Fryer v. Ewart [1902] A.C. 187 H.L. ....................................824, 825 Exall v. Partridge (1799) 8 Term.Rep. 308, 101 E.R. 1405.........................................................................................789 Exchange Travel Agency Ltd. v. Triton Property Trust Ltd. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 50 .............................................829, 830
xxxviii
TABLE OF CASES
Exeter C.C. v. Palmer [2000] 06 C.L. 467 ...................................................................................................................335 Expert Clothing Service & Sales Ltd. v. Hillgate House Ltd. [1986] Ch. 340 C.A. ......................................798, 812, 819 Eyre Estate Trustees v. Saphir [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 123 L.Tr. ........................................................................................403 Eyre Estate Trustees v. Shack [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 213 L.V.T.................................................................................394, 406 Eyre v. Hall [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 95 C.A. ...............................................................................................................114, 773 Eyre v. Johnson [1946] K.B. 481. ........................................................................................................................222, 654 Eyre v. McCracken (2000) 80 P. & C.R. 220 C.A. ......................................................................................................249 Eyre v. Rea [1947] K.B. 567, Atkinson J. ............................................................................................................684, 820 Ezekiel v. Orakpo [1977] Q.B. 260 C.A. ......................................................................................................................830 F.L.C. Management Ltd. v. Ganton House Investments Ltd. [1991] E.G.L.R. 132 C.A. ...........................................655 Facchini v. Bryson [1952] 1 T.L.R. 1386 C.A. .....................................................................................................152, 185 Factors (Sundries) Ltd. v. Millers [1952] 2 All E.R. 630..............................................................................................825 Fairclough (T.M.) & Sons Ltd. v. Berliner [1931] 1 Ch. 60 ........................................................................................834 Fairview, Church St, Bromyard,Re [1974] 1 W.L.R. 579, Megarry J. ...............................................................390, 396 Fairweather v. St Marylebone Property Co. Ltd. [1963] A.C. 510 H.L. ..............................................................602, 751 Family H.Ass Ltd. v. Jones [1990] 1 W.L.R. 779 C.A. ...............................................145, 160, 171, 177, 178, 179, 303 Family Management v. Gray [1980] 1 E.G.L.R. 46 C.A. ............................................................................................683 Farimani v. Gates [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 66 C.A. .....................................................................................................802, 813 Farr v. Ginnings (1928) 44 T.L.R. 249 ........................................................................................................................735 Farrell v. Alexander [1977] A.C. 59 H.L. ....................................................................................................................241 Farrow’s Bank Ltd.,Re [1921] 2 Ch. 164 C.A. ............................................................................................................728 Faulks v. Faulks [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 9, Chadwick J. ....................................................................................................629 Fawke v. Viscount Chelsea [1980] Q.B. 441 C.A. ...............................................................................................667, 668 Featherstone v. Staples [1986] 1 W.L.R. 861 C.A. ....................................................................................126, 597, 617 Federated Homes Ltd. v. Mill Lodge Ltd. [1980] 1 W.L.R. 594 C.A. ..........................................................................764 Fenn d. Matthews v. Smart (1810) 12 East. 444, 104 E.R. 173...................................................................................754 Fennbend Ltd. v. Millar (1988) 20 H.L.R. 19 C.A. ....................................................................................................352 Fenner v. Blake [1900] 1 Q.B. 426. .......................................................................................................................38, 599 Ferguson v. Anon (1797) 2 Esp. 590, 170 E.R. 465 .............................................................................................262, 674 Fernandes v. Parvardin [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 104 C.A. ....................................................................................49, 349, 350 Fernandez v. Walding [1968] 2 Q.B. 606 C.A.............................................................................................................547 Few v. Perkins (1867) L.R. 2 Exch. 92 .........................................................................................................................813 Feyereisel v. Turnridge [1952] 2 Q.B. 29 ....................................................................................................................301 Field v. Leeds C.C. [1999] All E.R. (D) 140, [2000] 12 E.G. 165 C.A. ......................................................................210 Filering Ltd. v. Taylor Commercial Ltd. [1996] E.G.C.S. 95 C.A. ........................................................................40, 601 Filross Securities Ltd. v. Midgeley [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 43 C.A. .....................................................................................646 Finbow v. Air Ministry [1963] 1 W.L.R. 697...............................................................................................................615 Fincar S.R.L. v. Mount St Management Co. Ltd. [1998] E.G.C.S. 173.......................................................................679 Finchbourne Ltd. v. Rodrigues [1976] 3 All E.R. 581 C.A. ...............................................................457, 458, 704, 705 Fine Fare Ltd. v. Kenmore Investments Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 143 Ch.D. ................................................................662 Finegold see Metropolitan Properties Firstcross Ltd. v. East West (Export/Import) Ltd. (1981) 41 P. & C.R. 145 C.A. ...............................................169, 170 Firstcross Ltd. v. Teasdale [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 87, McNeill J. .......................................................................................234 Fischer v. Toumazos [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 204 C.A. .......................................................................................................732 Fisher v. Taylors Furnishing Stores Ltd. [1956] 2 Q.B. 78 C.A. .........................................................................571, 572 Fitzpatrick v. Sterling Housing Association Ltd.[1999] 4 All E.R. 705 H.L.; [1998] Ch. 304 C.A. ........................................................................................................................117–118, 119, 203 Fiveways Properties Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 126 .............................................................666 Flairline Properties Ltd. v. Hassan [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 138...........................................................................................545 Flather v. Hood (1928) 44 T.L.R. 698, Charles J. .......................................................................................................616 Fleet Mortgage & Investment Co. Ltd. v. Lower Maisonette 46 Eaton Place Ltd. [1972] 1 W.L.R. 765 .....................835 Fleetwood v. Engineering Construction Industry Training Board [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3786, May J. ...............................686 Fleetwood v. Hull (1889) 23 Q.B.D. 35 .......................................................................................................................770 Fletcher v. Davies [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 77 C.A. ..............................................................................................................114 Fletcher v. Nokes [1897] 1 Ch. 271, North J. ......................................................................................................797, 798 Fletcher,Re [1917] 1 Ch. 339 C.A................................................................................................................................596 Flexman v. Corbett [1930] 1 Ch. 672 .........................................................................................................................633 Flight v. Bentley (1835) 7 Sim. 149, 58 E.R. 793 ........................................................................................753, 754, 756
TABLE OF CASES
xxxix
Florent v. Horez [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 105 C.A. ..............................................................................................................341 Floyer-Acland v. Osmond [2000] E.G.C.S. 53 C.A. ....................................................................................................626 Follett (Charles) Ltd. v. Cabtell Investments Ltd. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 88 C.A. ....................................................667, 668 Footwear Corporation Ltd. v. Amplight Properties Ltd. [1999] 1 W.L.R. 551, [1998] 2 All E.R. 52, Neuberger J. .........................................................................................................732, 733, 734 Ford Sellar Morris Developments Ltd. v. Grant Seward Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 40, Hoffmann J. .............................683 Ford v. Morrison [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 4245 .......................................................................................................................181 Forebury Estates Ltd. v. Chiltern Thames & Eastern R.A.P. [2000] Times July 11th, Keene J. .................................231 Foreman v. Beagley [1969] 1 W.L.R. 1387 C.A. .................................................................................................106, 121 Forrest v. Greenwich Overseers (1858) 8 E. & B. 890, 120 E.R. 332............................................................................183 Forster v. Elvet Colliery Co. Ltd. [1909] A.C. 72 H.L., [1908] 1 K.B. 629 C.A...................................................766, 772 Foster v. Day (1968) 208 E.G. 495 C.A. .....................................................................................................................245 Foster v. Reeves [1892] 2 Q.B. 255......................................................................................................523, 524, 527, 823 Foster v. Robinson [1951] 1 K.B. 149 C.A. ...............................................................................32, 38, 40, 172, 598, 599 Fowler v. Minchin (1987) 19 H.L.R. 224 C.A. ....................................................................................................185, 329 Fowler v. Radford (1970) 21 P. & C.R. 99...................................................................................................................396 Fox & Widley v. Gurham [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 91, Clarke J. .................................................................................580, 658 Fox v. Jolly [1916] 1 A.C. 1 H.L. .........................................................................................................................797, 800 Fox v. Swann (1655) Sty. 482, 82 E.R. 881 .................................................................................................................728 Fox v. Whitchcocke (1616) 2 Bulst. 290, 80 E.R. 1129, Coke C.J. ..............................................................................799 Fox,Re [1948] Ch. 407 Div.Ct.....................................................................................................................................653 Foxell v. Mendis unrep 1982........................................................................................................................................344 Francis v. Brown (1998) 30 H.L.R. 143 C.A................................................................................................312, 313, 315 Francis v. Cowlcliff Ltd. [1976] 2 E.G.L.R. 54 Ch.D. .........................................................................255, 256, 684, 706 Francke v. Hakmi [1984] C.L.Y. 1906 ........................................................................................................................168 Fraulo (V.G.) & Co. Ltd. v. Papa [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 99 C.A. .............................................................................173–174 Frawley v. Neill [1999] Times April 5th C.A. ....................................................................................................528, 815 Fredco Estates Ltd. v. Bryant [1961] 1 W.L.R. 76, [1961] 1 All E.R. 34 C.A..............................................................296 Freeguard v. Rogers [1998] E.G.C.S. 145 C.A. ............................................................................................................536 Freeman v. Wansbeck D.C. [1984] 2 All E.R. 746 C.A. ..............................................................................................354 Freer v. Unwins Ltd. [1976] Ch. 288, Walton J. ...................................................................................................36, 507 French v. Commercial Union Assurance Co. Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 113 C.A....................................................666, 667 Fresh (Retail) Ltd. v. Emsden [1999] 5 C.L. 455 ........................................................................................783, 788, 791 Friary Holroyd & Healey’s Brewery ltd. v. Singelton [1899] 1 Ch. 86, Romer J., reversed [1899] 2 Ch. 261 C.A...............................................................................................................................526, 537, 756 Friends Provident Life Office v. British Railways Board [1996] 1 All E.R. 336 C.A. ...............................................................................................747, 776, 778, 784, 785, 786 Frish Ltd. v. Barclays Bank Ltd. [1955] 2 Q.B. 541 C.A. ............................................................................................572 Frobisher (Second Investments) Ltd. v. Kiloran Trust [1980] 1 All E.R. 488 .....................................................457, 704 Frost v. Walker [1994] N.P.C. 60 C.A. .......................................................................................................................741 Fryer v. Ewart [1902] A.C. 187 H.L. ...........................................................................................................824, 825, 829 Fuller v. Judy Properties Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 75 C.A. ....................................................589, 796, 798, 810, 819, 827 Fuller’s Theatres & Vaudeville Co. Ltd. v. Rofe [1923] A.C. 435 P.C. ................................................................734, 812 Fussell, Re, ex parte Allen (1882) 20 Ch.D. 341 ..........................................................................................................597 G.M.S. Syndicate Ltd. v. Gary Elliott Ltd. [1982] Ch. 1 Nourse J. .............................................................759, 781, 831 G.R.E. Compass v. Draper’s Co. [1994] E.G.C.S. 97, Lindsay J..................................................................................662 G.S. Fashions Ltd. v. B. & Q. plc. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 62 Ch.D. ...................................................................................806 Gable Construction Co. Ltd. v. I.R.C. [1968] 1 W.L.R. 1426, [1968] 2 All E.R. 968 .................................................599 Gaidowski v. Gonville & Caius College, Cambridge [1975] 1 W.L.R. 1066 C.A. .......................................399–401, 413 Galinski v. McHugh [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A. ...............................................................148, 394, 413, 414, 592, 593 Gardner & Co. Ltd. v. Cone [1928] Ch. 955, Maugham J. .........................................................................................740 Gardner v. Blaxill [1960] 1 W.L.R. 752, [1960] 2 All E.R. 457 ..................................................................................583 Gardner v. Ingram (1889) 61 L.T. 729 .......................................................................................................................517 Garlick,Ex parte [1993] A.C. 509 H.L. see R. v. Oldham M.B.C. ...............................................................................77 Garrud, Re ex parte Newitt (1881) 16 Ch.D. 522 C.A. ..............................................................................................814 Garston v. Scottish Widows’ Fund & Life Assurance Society [1996] 4 All E.R. 282, Rattee J., reversed [1998] 1 W.L.R. 1583 C.A. .................................................................................................................561, 579, 581–582, 587 Gasus Dosier und Fördertechnik GmbH v. Netherlands (1995) 20 E.H.R.R. 403 .....................................................202
xl
TABLE OF CASES
Gates v. W.A. & R.J. Jacobs Ltd. [1920] 1 Ch. 567......................................................................................................592 Gatwick Parking Service Ltd. v. Sargent [2000] 25 E.G. 141 C.A. ..............................................................................573 Gay v. Sheeran [1999] 3 All E.R. 795 C.A. .........................................................................................................138, 139 Gaze v. London Drapery (1900) 44 S.J. 722, Farwell J. ..............................................................................................819 Geanes v. Portman (1594) Cro. Eliz. 314, 78 E.R. 565 ..............................................................................................176 Geen v. Herring [1905] 1 K.B. 152 C.A. .....................................................................................................................819 General Management Ltd. v. Locke [1980] 2 E.G.L.R. 83 C.A............................................................................116, 122 General Share and Trust Co. Ltd. v. Wetley Brick Pottery Co. Ltd. (1882) 20 Ch.D. 260 C.A. .................................830 Gent v. De La Mare (1988) 20 H.L.R. 199 ....................................................................................................................45 Gentle v. Faulkner [1900] 2 Q.B. 267 C.A. .................................................................................291, 583, 724, 727, 731 Germax Securities Ltd. v. Spiegal (1978) 37 P. & C.R. 204 C.A......................................................................27, 48, 580 Ghelani v. Bowie [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 130 C.A. ............................................................................................................350 Gian Singh & Co. v. Naher [1965] 1 W.L.R. 412 .......................................................................................................726 Gibbon v. Payne (1905) 22 T.L.R. 54, on appeal (1907) 23 T.L.R. 250 C.A. ............................................................814 Gibson v. Doeg (1857) 2 H. & N. 615, 157 E.R. 253 ...........................................................................................711, 768 Gibson v. Hammersmith & City Ry Co. (1863) 2 Drew & Sm. 603, 62 E.R. 748, Kindersley V.C. ..........................700 Gibson v. Wells (1805) B. & P. (N.R.) 290, 127 E.R. 473 ..................................................................261, 263, 672, 673 Gilbert Ash (Northern) Ltd. v. Modern Engineering (Bristol) Ltd. [1974] A.C. 689 H.L. ..................................257, 647 Gilbey v. Cossey (1912) 106 L.T. 607 Div.Ct. .....................................................................................................523, 755 Giles v. Spencer (1857) 3 C.B.N.S. 244, 140 E.R. 734 ................................................................................................599 Gill v. Cremadez [2000] 09 C.L. 470 ............................................................................................................................47 Gill v. Lewis [1956] 2 Q.B. 1 C.A.................................................................................................................817, 818, 824 Gilmour Caterers Ltd. v. St Bartholomews Hospital Governors [1956] 1 Q.B. 387 C.A.............................................571 Gisborne v. Burton [1989] Q.B. 390 C.A............................................................................................154, 613, 617, 619 Gladstone v. Bowers [1960] 2 Q.B. 384 C.A. ..............................................................................................................614 Gladyric Ltd. v. Collinson [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 98 C.A. .................................................................................................353 Glass v. Kencakes Ltd. [1966] 1 Q.B. 611, Paull J. ..............................................................................................800, 821 Glaze (R.C.) Properties Ltd. v. Alabdinboni (1992) 25 H.L.R. 150 C.A. ...........................................290, 297, 301, 729 Glendyne v. Rapley [1978] 1 W.L.R. 601 C.A. ...................................................................................................188, 607 Gleniffer Finance Co. v. Bamar Wood & Products Ltd. (1978) 37 P. & C.R. 208.......................................................685 Glofield Properties Ltd. v. Morley [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 113, (No.2) [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 118 C.A...........................658, 661 Gloucester C.C. v. Miles (1985) 17 H.L.R. 292 C.A. .....................................................................................................82 Gloucester C.C. v. Williams (1990) 88 L.G.R. 853 C.A. .....................................................................................568, 708 Gluchowska v. Tottenham B.C. [1954] 1 Q.B. 439 C.A. ............................................................................................236 Glynn v. Mackay [1998] 2 C.L.Y 3649 C.Ct. ......................................................................................................740, 741 Godfrey v. Waite (1951) 157 E.G. 582 ................................................................................................................608, 610 Gofor Investments Ltd. v. Roberts (1975) 29 P. & C.R. 366 C.A. ................................................................................108 Goh Eng Wah v. Yap Phooi Yin [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 148 P.C. ......................................................................................664 Gold v. Jacques Amand Ltd. (1992) 63 P. & C.R. 1, Browne-Wilkinson V.C. .........................................................613 Golden Lion Hotel (Hunstanton) Ltd. v. Carter [1965] 1 W.L.R. 1189......................................................................596 Goldman v. Abbott [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 78 C.A.............................................................................................................740 Goldsack v. Shore [1950] 1 K.B. 708 C.A. ..................................................................................................................613 Goldstein v. Cawley [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 95 L.Tr. .................................................................................................407, 408 Goldstein v. Sanders [1915] 1 Ch. 549, Eve J. .............................................................................................533, 735, 769 Gondal v. Dillon Newsagents Ltd [1998] Times July 29th C.A. ........................................................................728, 810 Gooch v. Clutterbuck [1899] 2 Q.B. 148 C.A. .....................................................................................................760, 791 Good’s Lease, Re [1954] 1 W.L.R. 309, Harman J. ............................................................................................532, 824 Goodaston Ltd. v. F.H. Burgess plc. [1999] L.T.R. 46, Jacob J. ...................................................................599, 780, 784 Goodright d. Hall v. Richardson (1789) 3 Term Rep. 462, 100 E.R. 678 ..................................................................513 Gordon Hill Trust v. Segall [1941] 2 All E.R. 379. C.A...............................................................................................530 Gordon v. Selico Co. Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 71 C.A. ..........................................................................458, 461, 684, 704 Goringe v. Twinsectra Ltd. [1994] 04 L.A.G. Bulletin 11 ...........................................................................................353 Gott v. Gandy (1853) 2 E. & B. 845, 118 E.R. 984 .....................................................................................263, 673, 674 Gough,Re (1927) 96 L.J.Ch. 233 ................................................................................................................................773 Gower v. Postmaster General (1887) 57 L.T. 527, Kay J. ...........................................................................766, 767, 770 Grammer v. Lane [2000] 2 All E.R. 245 C.A...............................................................................................................616 Granada Theatres Ltd. v. Freehold Investment (Leytonstone) Ltd. [1959] Ch. 592 C.A. ...........................................760 Granada TV Network Ltd. v. Great Universal Stores Ltd. (1966) 187 E.G. 391.........................................................736 Grand Junction Co. Ltd. v. Bates [1954] 2 Q.B. 160, Upjohn J. .................................................................................824
TABLE OF CASES
xli
Grant v. Edmondson [1931] 1 Ch. 1 C.A. ...................................................................................................................766 Grant v. Gresham [1979] 2 E.G.L.R. 60 C.A...............................................................................................................543 Gray v. Bonsall [1904] 1 K.B. 601 C.A. ......................................................................................................................823 Gray v. Brown [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 C.A. .................................................................................147, 148, 156, 163, 164 Gray v. Spyer [1922] 2 Ch. 22................................................................................................................31, 524, 527, 823 Gray v. Standard Home & Counties Properties Ltd. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 ..............................................................454 Gray v. Taylor[1998] 1 W.L.R. 1093 C.A. ..........................................................................................................176, 496 Grayless v Watkinson [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 6 C.A. .........................................................................................................624 Graysim Holdings Ltd. v. P. & O. Property Holdings Ltd. [1996] A.C. 329 H.L., [1994] 1 W.L.R. 992 C.A.........................................................................................................................544–546, 549 Graystone Property Investments Ltd. v. Margulies [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 27 C.A. ...................................................456, 703 Great Northern Railway Co. v. Arnold (1916) 33 T.L.R. 114, Rowlatt J....................................................................513 Great Western Rly v. Bishop (1872) L.R. 7 Q.B. 550 ..................................................................................................266 Great Western Rly. Co. v. Smith (1876) 2 Ch.D. 235 C.A., (1877) 3 App. Cas. 165 H.L. ................................601, 823 Greater London C. v. Connolly [1970] 2 Q.B. 100 C.A...............................................................................212, 224, 643 Greater London Property Ltd.’s Lease,Re [1959] 1 W.L.R. 503 ..................................................................................739 Green v. Sheffield C.C. (1994) 26 H.L.R. 349 C.A. ....................................................................................................345 Greenalls Management Ltd. v. Canavan(No.1) [1997] Times May 19th C.A.; (No.2) [1997] Times August 20th C.A. ..............................................................................................................................713 Greenaway v. Adams (1806) 12 Ves. 395, 33 E.R. 149 ...............................................................................................726 Greenaway v. Newport B.C. [1999] 7 C.L. 263 C.Ct. ...................................................................................................87 Greene v. Chelsea B.C. [1954] 2 Q.B. 127 C.A. ..........................................................................................................251 Greene v. Cole (1672) 2 Wms. Saunds 252, 85 E.R. 1037 H.L. .................................................262, 263, 672, 673, 692 Greenfield v. Berkshire C.C. (1996) 28 H.L.R. 691 C.A. ............................................................................................496 Green’s case (1582) Cro. Eliz. 3, 78 E.R. 269. ............................................................................................................814 Greenwich L.B.C. v. Discreet Selling Estates Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A. ...........................................798, 812–814 Greenwich L.B.C. v. Grogan [2000] Times March 28th C.A.......................................................................................331 Greenwich L.B.C. v. McGrady (1982) 46 P. & C.R. 223 C.A.; ...................................................................................127 Greenwich L.B.C. v. Powell [1989] A.C. 995, [1989] 1 All E.R. 65 H.L. ...................................................................182 Greenwich L.B.C. v. Regan (1996) 28 H.L.R. 469 C.A. ..............................................................................................333 Greaves v. Mitchell (1971) 222 E.G. 1395 ...................................................................................................................625 Gregg v. Coates (1856) 23 Beav. 33, 53 E.R. 13...........................................................................................................689 Gregory v. Saddiq [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 237 L.V.T. .........................................................................................................429 Griffin v. Pillet [1926] 1 K.B. 17 .........................................................................................................253, 530, 532, 707 Griffith v. Pelton [1958] Ch. 205 C.A. .................................................................................................................536, 537 Griffiths v. Birmingham City D.C. [1987] C.L.Y. 2172...............................................................................................391 Griffiths v. Cave (W.E. & D.T.) Ltd. [1998] 48 L.S.G. 30 C.A. .................................................................................536 Griffiths v. English [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 96 C.A..............................................................................................................163 Griffiths v. Renfree (1989) 21 H.L.R. 338 C.A.............................................................................................................131 Grimshaw v. Dunbar [1953] 1 Q.B. 408, [1953] 1 All E.R. 350 C.A. .......................................................................332 Groom v. Bluck (1841) 2 Man. & G. 567, 133 E.R. 873 .............................................................................................789 Grosvenor (Mayfair) Estates v. Amberton [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 96 C.A. .........................................................................15 Grosvenor Estates Belgravia v. Cochran [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 83 C.A.....................................................................149, 726 Grosvenor’s S.E.,Re [1932] 1 Ch. 232, Maugham J. ...................................................................................................602 Groundpremium Property Management Ltd. v. Longmint Ltd. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 131 L.V.T. .................................438 Groveside Properties Ltd. v. Westminster Medical School [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 68 C.A. ...............................................549 Grovewood (L.E.) Ltd. v. Lundy Properties Ltd. (1995) 69 P. & C.R. 507, Parker J. .................................................781 Guardian Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Gants Hill Holdings Ltd. [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 36, Mervyn Davies J. .................302, 730 Guestheath v. Mirza (1990) 22 H.L.R. 399 ................................................................................................................169 Guildford B.C. v. Cobb [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 156 ............................................................................................................664 Guillemard v. Silverthorne (1908) 99 L.T. 584, Ridley J.....................................................................................798, 813 Guinan v. Enfield L.B.C. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 456 C.A. .................................................................................................501 Gunter v. Gunter (1857) 23 Beav. 571, 53 E.R. 225. ..................................................................................................596 Guppys Properties Ltd. v. Knott (No.3) [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 85 ....................................................................................293 Gurton v. Parrott [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 98 C.A. ..............................................................................................................550 Gurvidi v. Marget (1972) 116 S.J. 255 ........................................................................................................................410 Gutteridge v. Munyard (1834) 7 C. & P. 129, 173 E.R. 57 .................................................................................675, 679 H. v. P. [1993] Fam. Law 515 .....................................................................................................................................139
xlii
TABLE OF CASES
H.B. Property Developments Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment (1999) 78 P. & C.R. 108 C.A. ...................................583 Habinteg H.Ass. v. James (1994) 27 H.L.R. 299 C.A. ................................................................................................267 Hackney African Organisation v. Hackney L.B.C. [1998] E.G.C.S. 139 ....................................................560, 561, 589 Hackney L.B.C. v. Crown Estate Commissioners (1996) 72 P. & C.R. 233 Ch.D. .....................................................775 Hackney L.B.C. v. Ezedinna [1981] 3 All E.R. 438 Div.Ct. ........................................................................................272 Hackney L.B.C. v. Lambourne (1992) 25 H.L.R. 172 C.A. ........................................................................................319 Hackney L.B.C. v. Mullen [1997] 1 W.L.R. 1103 C.A. ......................................................................................256, 706 Hackney L.B.C. v. Porter (1997) 29 H.L.R. 401 C.A...................................................................................................333 Hackney L.B.C. v. White (1996) 28 H.L.R. 219 C.A...................................................................................................334 Hadjiloucas v. Crean [1988] 1 W.L.R. 1006 C.A. ..............................................................................................152–156 Hafton Properties Ltd. v. Camp [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 67 ......................................................195, 424, 453, 457, 632, 703 Hagee (London) Ltd v. A B Erikson & Larson [1976] Q.B. 209 C.A. .......................................................173, 553, 555 Haines v. Florensa [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 73 C.A. .............................................................................................................693 Haines v. Herbert [1963] 1 W.L.R. 1401 C.A. ............................................................................................................149 Halberstam v. Tandalco Corp. N.V. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 90 C.A. ................................................................................662 Hale v. Hale [1975] 1 W.L.R. 931 C.A........................................................................................................................136 Halesowen Presswork & Assemblies Ltd. v. National Westminster Bank Ltd. [1971] 1 Q.B. 1 C.A., on appeal [1972] A.C. 785 H.L. ...............................................................................................................................................648 Halford’s Executors v. Boden [1953] E.G.D. 329 C.Ct................................................................................................144 Halifax B.S. v. Chamberlain Martin Spurgeon (1995) 27 H.L.R. 123, Arden J. .........................................................11 Halifax v. Coal Commissioners [1945] Ch. 253 ..................................................................................................304, 750 Hall v. Ewin (1887) 37 Ch.D. 74 C.A..................................................................................................................297, 760 Hall v. Howard [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 75 C.A. .................................................................................................................252 Hall v. King (1987) 19 H.L.R. 440 C.A. .............................................................................................................117, 131 Hall v. Kingston upon Hull C.C. [1999] 2 All E.R. 609 Div. Ct. ........................................................................269, 590 Hall v. Manchester Corporation (1915) 84 L.J.Ch. 732 H.L. .............................................................................246, 252 Hall v. Warren (1804) 9 Ves. 605, 32 E.R. 738, Grant M.R. ......................................................................................526 Halliard Property Co. Ltd. v. Jack Segal Ltd. [1978] 1 W.L.R. 377, Goulding J...................................20, 115, 346, 829 Halliard Property Co. Ltd. v. Nicholas Clarke Investments Ltd. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 45 ..............................................677 Hamer v. Drummond (1939) 187 L.T.Jo. 156. ...........................................................................................................688 Hamid v. Jeje [1994] C.L.Y. 2784 C.A. ......................................................................................................................331 Hamilton v. Martell Securities Ltd. [1984] Ch. 266, Vinelott J. ........................................................................683, 803 Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v Tops Shop Centres Ltd. [1990] Ch. 237, Scott J. ......................821, 823, 826, 831 Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v. Brown [2000] 05 C.L. 350 C.Ct. ........................................................................336 Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v. Hill [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 51 C.A. ..........................................................................335 Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v. Monk [1992] 1 A.C. 478 H.L. .................................................21, 23, 28, 126–128, 130, 136, 194, 314, 504, 514, 585, 617 Hammond v. Allen [1994] 1 All E.R. 307, Owen J. ...................................................................................................624 Hammond v. Farrow [1904] 2 K.B. 332 C.A. ..............................................................................................................31 Hampshire v. Wickens (1878) 7 Ch.D. 555 ................................................................................................................633 Hampstead Garden Suburb Institute,Re (1995) 93 L.G.R. 470, Carnwath J. ...........................................................554 Hampstead Way Investments Ltd. v. Lewis-Weare [1985] 1 W.L.R. 164 H.L. ...........................................105, 108, 146 Hanak v. Green [1958] 2 Q.B. 9 C.A...................................................................................................................257, 651 Hancock & Willis v. G.M.S. Syndicate Ltd. [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 76.......................................................................546, 588 Hand v. Blow [1901] 2 Ch. 721 ...................................................................................................................................761 Hand v. Hall (1877) 2 Ex. D. 355 .................................................................................................................................31 Haniff v. Robinson [1993] Q.B. 419 C.A. ...................................................................................................310, 311, 334 Hankey v. Clavering [1942] 2 K.B. 326 C.A........................................................................................................579, 583 Hannaford v. Smallacombe [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 9 C.A..................................................................................................623 Hannon v. 169 Queen’s Gate Ltd. [1999] Times November 23rd Ch.D. ...........................................................426, 702 Hanson v. Newman [1934] Ch. 298 C.A.....................................................................................................................682 Harben Style Ltd. v. Rhodes Trust [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 118 Ch.D. ...............................................................................659 Harding v. Marshall [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A.............................................................................................................624 Hardwick v. Johnson [1978] 1 W.L.R. 683 C.A...........................................................................................................172 Hare v. Elms [1893] 1 Q.B. 604...................................................................................................................................823 Hare v. Groves (1796) 3 Anst. 687, 145 E.R. 1007......................................................................................................689 Haringey L.B.C. v. Jowett (2000) 32 H.L.R. 308 Div.Ct. ...........................................................................................267 Haringey L.B.C. v. Powell (1996) 28 H.L.R. 798 C.A. ................................................................................................338 Haringey L.B.C. v. Stewart [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 252 C.A...............................................................................................336
TABLE OF CASES
xliii
Harland v. Chadda [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 3254 C.Ct...........................................................................................................315 Harler v. Calder [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 88 C.A. ..........................................................................................................25, 585 Harmer v. Bean (1853) 3 C. & K. 307, 175 E.R. 566 ..................................................................................................743 Harmer (Nnigeria) Tin Areas Ltd. v. Jumbil [1921] 1 Ch. 200 C.A...................................................................718, 721 Harnett v. Maitland (1847) 16 M. & W. 257, 153 E.R. 1184 .............................................................262, 263, 672, 673 Harper v. Bird (1678) T. Jo. 102, 84 E.R. 1167...........................................................................................................782 Harries v. Barclays Bank plc. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 15 C.A..............................................................................................629 Harrington Motor Co.,Re [1928] Ch. 105 C.A. .........................................................................................................791 Harris v. Beavan (1828) 4 Bing. 646, 130 E.R. 918.............................................................................................304, 750 Harris v. Boots the Cash Chemists (Southern) Ltd. [1904] 2 Ch. 376.................................................................380, 790 Harris v. Jones (1832) 1 Mood. & R. 173, 174 E.R. 59 ...............................................................................675, 676, 679 Harris v. Monro (1972) 225 E.G. 1551 C.A. ...............................................................................................................560 Harris v. Plentex Ltd (1980) 40 P. & C.R. 483, Vinelott J. ........................................................................................396 Harris v. Swick Securities Ltd. [1969] 1 W.L.R. 1604 C.A. ................................................................................396, 400 Harrison v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. [1981] 1 W.L.R. 650 C.A. ......................................................9, 112, 172 Harrison v. Malet (1886) 3 T.L.R. 58 .........................................................................................................................251 Harrison v. Wells [1967] 1 Q.B. 263 C.A. ...........................................................................................................303, 566 Harrison v. Wing [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 4 C.A..................................................................................................176, 612, 613 Harrison-Broadley v. Smith [1964] 1 W.L.R. 456 C.A. .............................................................................................614 Harrogate B.C. v. Simpson (1987) 17 H.L.R. 205 C.A........................................................................................117–119 Harrow L.B.C. v. Johnstone [1997] 1 W.L.R. 459 H.L................................................................................................129 Harrow L.B.C. v. Tonge (1992) 25 H.L.R. 99 C.A. ............................................................................................502, 503 Harrow School Governors v. Alderton (1800) 2 Bos. & P. 86, 126 E.R. 1170 ............................................................692 Hart v. Emelkirk Ltd. [1983] 1 W.L.R. 1289, Goulding J. .........................................................................................452 Hart v. Windsor (1843) 12 M. & W. 68, 152 E.R. 1114 .............................................................................247, 248, 251 Hartley v. Larkin (1950) 66 (1) T.L.R. 896 .................................................................................................................819 Harvey v. Pratt [1965] 1 W.L.R. 1025 C.A. ...............................................................................................516, 520, 529 Harvey & Mann,Re (1920) 89 L.J.K.B. 687 C.A. .......................................................................................................630 Hasham v. Zenab [1960] A.C. 316 ..............................................................................................................................529 Haskell v. Marlow [1928] 2 K.B. 45, Talbot J. ...........................................................................262, 264, 672, 677, 678 Hastie & Jenkerson v. McMahon [1990] 1 W.L.R. 1575 C.A. ...................................................................................592 Havant & Waterlooville B.C. v. Norum [1958] 1 W.L.R. 721 C.A.............................................................................224 Havant International Holdings Ltd. v. Lionsgate (H.) Investment Ltd. [1999] 47 L.S.G. 34, [2000] L.T.R. 297, Hart J.................................................................................................................................581, 590 Havenridge v. Boston Dyers Ltd. [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 73 C.A. .......................................................................198, 465, 638 Havens v. Middleton (1853) 10 Hare 641, 68 E.R. 1085 ............................................................................................687 Haviland v. Long [1952] 2 Q.B. 80..............................................................................................................................682 Hawkins v. Sherman (1828) 3 C. & P. 459, 172 E.R. 500...........................................................................................791 Haymen v. Rowlands [1957] 1 W.L.R. 317, [1957] 1 All E.R. 321 C.A. ...................................................................332 Healing Research Trustee Co. Ltd.,Re [1992] 2 All E.R. 481, Harman J. ...........................................................788–790 Heath Estates Ltd. v. Burchell [1979] 2 E.G.L.R. 81 C.A. ...........................................................................................131 Heath v. Drown [1973] A.C. 498 H.L. .......................................................................................................................570 Heathrow Airport Ltd. v. Forte (U.K.) Ltd. [1998] E.G.C.S. 13 Ch.D. ......................................................................666 Hedgedale Ltd. v. Hards [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 118 C.A. ..................................................................................................121 Heglibiston Establishments v. Heyman (1978) 36 P. & C.R. 351 C.A. .......................................................................341 Helby v. Matthews [1895] A.C. 471 H.L. ....................................................................................................................536 Helby v. Rafferty [1979] 1 W.L.R. 13 C.A. .................................................................................................................119 Hellawell v. Eastwood (1851) 6 Exch. 295, 155 E.R. 554............................................................................................698 Helling v. Lumley (1858) 3 De G. & J. 493, 44 E.R. 1358 ...........................................................................................531 Hellings v. Parker Breslin Estates Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 99 Ch.D. ...........................................................................348 Hembry v. Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A. ............................................................367, 391 Hemingway Securities Ltd. v. Dunraven Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 61, Jacob J. ............................................685, 734, 769 Henderson v. Thorn [1893] 2 Q.B. 164. .....................................................................................................................683 Hendry v. Chartsearch Ltd. [1998] Times September 16th........................................................................................732 Hennessey’s Agreement,Re [1975] Ch. 252, Plowman V.C. ................................................................41, 395, 558, 598 Henry Boot Construction (U.K.) Ltd. v. Malmaison Hotel (Manchester) Ltd. [2000] N.L.J. 867 C.A. .....................661 Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees v. Hemmings [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 90, [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 94 C.A. .............................230 Henry Smith’s Charity Trustee v. Awada Trading and Promotion Services Ltd. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 116 C.A. ...........659 Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees v. Bartosiak-Jentys [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 276 C.A. .......................................................345
xliv
TABLE OF CASES
Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees v. Kyriakou [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 110 C.A. ...................................................62, 589, 592 Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees v. Willson [1983] Q.B 316 C.A. .............................................................290, 297, 814 Hepworth v. Pickles [1900] 1 Ch. 108 .........................................................................................................................814 Herbert Duncan Ltd. v. Clutton [1993] Q.B. 589 C.A. ......................................................................................778, 785 Herbert v. Byrne [1964] 1 W.L.R. 519 C.A. ........................................................................................................296, 393 Herbie Frogg Ltd. v. Lee Barnett Needleman [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 3267 C.A.....................................................................564 Hereford C.C. v. O’Callaghan [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3831 ..................................................................................................118 Herongrove Ltd. v. Wates City of London Properties plc. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 82 .................................................560, 581 Heslop v. Burns [1974] 1 W.L.R. 1241 C.A.........................................................................................................151, 173 Hewitt v. Lewis [1986] 1 W.L.R. 444 C.A. .................................................................................................................349 Hewlings v. McLean Homes East Anglia Ltd. [2000] Times August 31st Raferty J. .................................................269 Hibernian Property Co. Ltd. v. Liverpool Corporation [1973] 1 W.L.R. 751, Caulfield J. .........................................681 Hicks v. Downing (1696) 1 Ld. Raym. 99, 91 E.R. 962 ..............................................................................................726 Hicks v. Scarsdale Brewery Co. [1924] W.N. 189 Div.Ct. ..........................................................................................105 Hicks v. Snooks (1928) 27 L.G.R. 175 .........................................................................................................................301 Hickson & Welch Ltd. v. Cann (1977) 40 P. & C.R. 218 C.A. ...................................................................................608 Hide,Re (1871) L.R. 7 Ch.App. 28 .............................................................................................................................774 High Road, (No.88) Kilburn,Re [1959] 1 W.L.R. 279 ................................................................................................567 High Street Investments Ltd. v. Bellshare Property Investments Ltd. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 40 C.A. .......................823, 834 High Trees [1947] K.B. 130, Denning J. see Central London Property ......................................................................647 Higher Education Statistics Agency v. Customs & Excise Commissioners [2000] 25 L.S.G. 8, [2000] S.T.C. 332 .....643 Highett & Bird’s C.,Re [1903] 1 Ch. 287 C.A. ...........................................................................................................377 Highway Properties Ltd. v. Kelly Douglas & Co. Ltd. (1971) 17 D.L.R. (3d) 710 ......................................211, 647, 715 Hildebrand v. Moon [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 100 C.A. .......................................................................................................121 Hi-Lift Elevator Services Ltd. v. Temple (1996) 28 H.L.R. 1 C.A. ......................................................................459, 683 Hill v. Barclay (1810) 16 Ves. 402, 33 E.R. 1037, Lord Eldon L.C. ..........................................255, 531, 684, 705, 818 Hill v. Booth [1930] 1 K.B. 381 C.A. ...........................................................................................................................769 Hill v. East & West India Dock Co. (1884) 9 App.Cas. 448 H.L. ...............................................................................786 Hill v. Grange (1556) 2 Dyer 130b, 73 E.R. 284 ................................................................................................749, 751 Hill v. Griffin [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 81 C.A. ....................................................................................................763, 821–825 Hill v. Harris [1965] 2 Q.B. 601 C.A...................................................................................................................690, 708 Hill v. Rochard [1983] 1 W.L.R. 478 C.A. ..........................................................................................................169, 352 Hill v. Tupper (1863) 2 H. & C. 121, 159 E.R. 51.......................................................................................................554 Hillbank Properties Ltd. v. Hackney L.B.C. [1978] Q.B. 998 C.A.......................................................................250, 270 Hiller v. United Dairies (London) Ltd. [1934] 1 K.B. 57 C.A. ...................................................................................169 Hillgate House Ltd. v. Expert Clothing Services & Sales Ltd. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 65....................................................717 Hillil Property & Investment Co. Ltd. v. Naraine Pharmacy Ltd. (1979) 39 P. & C.R. 67 C.A. ................................544 Hills (Patents) Ltd. v. University College Hospital Board of Governors [1956] 1 Q.B. 90 C.A...................................542 Hilton v. Plustitle Ltd [1989] 1 W.L.R. 149 C.A. ...............................................................................................169, 170 Hindcastle Ltd. v. Barbara Attenborough Associates Ltd. [1997] A.C. 70 H.L....................................................786, 787 Hindley v. Emery (1865) L.R. 1 Eq. 52 ........................................................................................................................685 Historic Houses Hotels Ltd. v. Cadogan Estates Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 117 C.A. ......................................................665 Hockley Engineering Co. Ltd. v. V. & P. Midlands Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 76, Judge Micklem ...............................830 Hodge v. Clifford Cowling & Co. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 89 C.A. ......................................................................................564 Hodges v. Blee (1988) 20 H.L.R. 32 C.A. ....................................................................................................................350 Hodges v. Lawrence (1854) 18 J.P. 347........................................................................................................................651 Hodson v. Cashmore (1972) 226 E.G. 1203, Brightman J. ........................................................................................571 Hoffmann v. Fineberg [1949] Ch. 245, Harman J. .............................................................................................800, 821 Hogarth Health Club Ltd. v. Westbourne Investments Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 89 C.A. .............................................695 Hogg Bullimore & Co. v. Co-Operative Insurance Society Ltd. (1985) 50 P. & C.R. 105, Whitford J. .....................563 Hoggett v. Hoggett (1979) 39 P. & C.R. 121.................................................................................40, 131, 132, 153, 601 Hoggett v. Knox [2000] 05 C.L. 434 C.Ct. ..................................................................................................................460 Holdcroft v. Staffordshire C.C. [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A.............................................................................................629 Holding & Management Ltd. v. Property Holding & Investment Trust plc. [1989] 1 W.L.R. 1313 C.A. ..457, 459, 703 Holiday Fellowship Ltd. v. Hereford [1959] 1 W.L.R. 211 C.A...................................................................................697 Holiday Flat Co. Ltd. v Kuczera [1978] S.L.T. (Sh.Ct.) 47 ........................................................................................161 Holland v. Hodgson (1872) L.R. 7 C.P. 328, Blackburn J. .................................................................................697, 698 Holland & Andrews v. Dowle (1897) 102 L.T.Jo. 347, Judge Stonor.........................................................................523 Holleran v. Daniel Thwaites plc. [1989] 2 C.M.L.R. 917, Peter Gibson J. .................................................................713
TABLE OF CASES
xlv
Holloway Bros. Ltd. v. Hill [1902] 2 Ch. 612 ..............................................................................................................777 Holloway v. Povey [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 115 C.A. ..........................................................................................................345 Holme v. Brunskill (1877) 3 Q.B.D. 495 C.A..............................................................................................................784 Holmes Road, Nos. 55/57, Kentish Town,Re [1959] Ch. 298 .....................................................................................562 Holmes v. Lambeth L.B.C. [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 2643 .......................................................................................................260 Holroyd v. Marshall (1862) 10 H.L.C. 191, 11 E.R. 999 H.L. ....................................................................................527 Holwell Securities Ltd. v. Hughes [1973] 1 W.L.R. 757, Templeman J. ..............................................................28, 592 Homsy v. Searle (1997) 73 P. & C.R. 26 C.A. .............................................................................................................435 Hong Kong & Shanghai Banking Corporation& Co. v. Kloeckner & A.G. [1990] 2 Q.B. 514, Hirst J. ....................648 Hooper v. Clark (1867) L.R. 2 Q.B. 200 ......................................................................................................................772 Hooper v. Eaglestone (1977) 34 P. & C.R. 311 Div.Ct. ..............................................................................................182 Hopkin’s Lease, Re [1972] 1 W.L.R. 372 C.A. ............................................................................................................535 Hopkinson v. Lovering (1883) 11 Q.B.D. 92, Denman J. ..........................................................................................761 Hopwood v. Cannock Chase D.C. [1975] 1 W.L.R. 373, [1975] 1 All E.R. 796 C.A. ................................................245 Hordern v. Viscount Chelsea [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 195 L.V.T. .......................................................................390, 407, 438 Horford Investments Ltd. v. Lambert [1976] Ch. 39 C.A............................................................................................548 Horley v. King (1835) 2 Cr. M. & R. 18, 150 E.R. 8, Abinger C.B. ............................................................................761 Horn v. Beard [1912] 3 K.B. 181 .........................................................................................................................305, 743 Hornsby v. Maynard [1925] 1 K.B. 514 .....................................................................................................................167 Horsefall v. Mather (1815) Holt 7, 171 E.R. 141 ................................................................................262, 263, 673, 674 Horsey Estate Ltd. v. Steiger [1899] 2 Q.B. 79 C.A. ...................................................726, 766, 769, 797, 798, 810, 829 Horsford v. Carnill (1957) 157 E.G. 243, 158 E.G. 287 ..............................................................................................179 Houlder Brothers & Co. Ltd. v. Gibbs [1925] Ch. 575 C.A. ...............................................................729, 735, 738, 739 Hounsleys Ltd. v. Bloomer-Holt Ltd. [1966] 1 W.L.R. 1244 ..............................................................................570, 571 Hounslow L.B.C. v. McBride (1999) 31 H.L.R. 143 C.A. ...................................................................330, 335, 341–343 Hounslow L.B.C. v. Pilling [1993] 1 W.L.R. 1242, [1994] 1 All E.R. 432 C.A...............................................26, 27, 130 House Property & Investment Co. Ltd. v. Bernardout [1948] 1 K.B. 314, Singleton J. .............................................788 House Property & Investment Co. Ltd. v. James Walker, Goldsmith & Silversmith, Ltd. [1948] 1 K.B. 257, Lord Goddard C.J....................................................................................................................................................799 Howard de Walden Estates Ltd. v. Pasta Place Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 79, Morland J. ......................................784, 785 Howard v. Kinvena Homes Ltd. [1999] 25 L.S.G. 30 C.A. .........................................................................................180 Howard v. Lovegrove (1870) L.R. 6 Ex. 43 ..................................................................................................................791 Howard v. Midrome Ltd. [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 58, Warner J. ........................................................................................453 Howard v. Miller [1915] A.C. 318 H.L. ..............................................................................................................527, 530 Howard v. Shaw (1841) 8 M. & W. 118, 151 E.R. 973 ......................................................................................174, 175 Howard v. U.K. (1987) 9 E.H.R.R. 116 ......................................................................................................................204 Howkins v. Jardine 1951] 1 K.B. 614 ..........................................................................................................................610 Howkins & Harrison v. Tyler [2000] Times August 8th C.A. ...................................................................................788 Howson v. Buxton (1928) 97 L.J.K.B. 749 ..................................................................................................................126 Hua Chiao Commercial Bank Ltd. v. Chiaphua Industries Ltd. [1987] A.C. 99 P.C. .....................764, 765, 766, 767 Hugall v. M’Lean (1885) 53 L.T. 94 C.A.............................................................................................................252, 706 Hughes v. Greenwich L.B.C.[1994] 1 A.C. 170 H.L............................................................................................186, 495 Hughes v. Kingston upon Hull C.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 779 Div.Ct. ............................................................................270 Hughes v. Metropolitan Rly. Co. (1877) 2 App. Cas. 439 H.L....................................................................................815 Hughes v. Robotham (1593) Cro. Eliz. 302, 78 E.R. 554 ...................................................................................596, 602 Hughes v. S.S. for the Environment (1996) 71 P. & C.R. 168 ....................................................................................206 Hulme v. Brigham [1943] K.B. 152 ............................................................................................................................697 Hulme v. Langford (1985) 50 P. & C.R. 199 C.A........................................................................................................117 Humble v. Langston (1841) 7 M. & W. 517, 151 E.R. 871, Parke B...........................................................................789 Humphreys v. Miller [1917] 2 K.B. 122 C.A. ..............................................................................................................251 Hunt v. Decca Navigator Co. Ltd. (1972) 222 E.G. 625 .............................................................................................570 Hunter’s Lease,Re [1942] Ch. 124 .......................................................................................................................537, 767 Hunts Refuse Disposals Ltd. v. Norfolk Environmental Waste Services Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 16 C.A. ....................554 Hurstfell v. Leicester Square Property Co. Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 105 C.A. ..............................................................569 Hussain v. Lancaster C.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 164 ........................................................................................................719 Hussain v. Singh [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 70 C.A. ...............................................................................................................590 Hussein v. Mehlman [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 87, Stephen Sedley Q.C. ....................................245, 246, 253, 258, 260, 691 Hussey v. Camden L.B.C. (1995) 27 H.L.R. 5 C.A. ...........................................................................106, 107, 286, 298 Hutchins v. Chambers (1758) 1 Burr. 579, 97 E.R. 458, Lord Mansfield .................................................................652
xlvi
TABLE OF CASES
Hutchinson v. Lambeth [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 75 C.A. ....................................................................................................562 Hutton v. Warren (1836) 1 M. & W. 466, 150 E.R. 517 ............................................................................................692 Huwyler v. Ruddy (1996) 28 H.L.R. 550 C.A. ....................................................................................................159, 160 Hyams,Re (1923) 93 L.J.Ch. 184 C.A. .......................................................................................................................774 Hyde H.Ass. Ltd v. Harrison (1990) 23 H.L.R. 57 C.A. .............................................................................................178 Hyde H.Ass v. Brown [1999] 07 C.L. 328....................................................................................................................336 Hyde v. Pearce [1982] 1 W.L.R. 560, [1982] 1 All E.R. 1029 C.A. ............................................................................175 Hyde v. Pimley [1952] 2 Q.B. 506 ..............................................................................................................................298 Hyde v. Warden (1877) 3 Ex. D. 72 C.A. ....................................................................................529, 596, 743, 759, 762 Hyde v. Windsor (1597) Cro. Eliz. 457, 552, 78 E.R. 710, 798 ..................................................................................751 Hyman v. Rose [1912] A.C. 623 H.L. .................................................................................................................693, 819 Hynes v. Twinsectra Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. ..........................................................................................806, 821 I.T.M. Corporation Ltd.,Re [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 33 .......................................................................................................775 I.V.S. Enterprises Ltd. v. Chelsea Cloisters Management Ltd. [1994] E.G.C.S. 14 C.A. ............................................460 Iatridis v. Greece (2000) 30 E.H.R.R. 97 ....................................................................................................................201 Ibbs v. Richardson (1839) 9 Ad. & El. 849, 112 E.R. 1436..................................................................................213, 641 Ibie v. Trubshaw (1990) 22 H.L.R. 191 C.A. .....................................................................................................348–349 Iceland Frozen Foods plc v. Starlight Investments Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 126 C.A. ..................................................665 Ideal Film Renting Co. Ltd. v. Nielsen [1921] 1 Ch. 575 ............................................................................................734 Immobiliare Saffi v. Italy (1999) 7 B.H.R.C. 256 E.C.H.R. ................................................................200, 201, 202, 205 Imray v. Oakshette [1897] 2 Q.B. 218 C.A..........................................................................................................799, 800 Ind Coope & Co. Ltd.,Re [1911] 2 Ch. 223 .........................................................................................................305, 762 Inderwick v. Leech (1885) 1 T.L.R. 484 C.A. ..............................................................................................................681 Industrial Properties (Barton Hill) Ltd. v Associated Electrical Industries Ltd. [1977] Q.B. 580 C.A. ...............................................................................................175, 303, 521, 525, 528, 534, 566 Ingle v. Vaughan Jenkins [1900] 2 Ch. 368, Farwell J.................................................................................................596 Ingram v. I.R.C. [2000] A.C. 293, [1999] 1 All E.R. 297 H.L., reversing [1997] 4 All E.R. 395 C.A. .....................595 Inland Revenue Commissioners v. (Earl of)Derby [1914] 3 K.B. 1186 ......................................................527, 530, 599 Inntrepeneur Estates (G.L.) Ltd. v. Boyes [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 112 C.A. .......................................................................713 Inntrepreneur Pub Co. (C.P.C.) Ltd. v. Price [1998] Times December 4th, Neuberger J.........................................713 Inntrepreneur Pub Co. (C.P.C.) Ltd. v. Deans [1999] B.P.I.R. 361, David Steel J...............................................39, 600 Inntrepreneur Pub Co. (C.P.C.) Ltd. v. Langton [1999] 44 L.S.G. 39, Arden J. ................................................818, 835 International Drilling Fluids Ltd. v. Louisville Investments (Uxbridge) Ltd. [1986] Ch. 513 C.A. .......................................................................................708, 710, 733–734, 735–736, 737–739 International Military Services Ltd. v. Capital & Counties plc. [1982] 1 W.L.R. 575, Slade J. ..................................574 International Press Centre Ltd. v. Norwich Union Insurance Co. (1986) 36 Build. L.R. 130 ....................................596 Interoven Stove Co. Ltd. v. Hibbard & Painter [1936] 1 All E.R. 263, Hibery J. .......................................................653 Iperion Investments Corporation Ltd. v. Broadwalk House Resident Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 235, [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A.................................................................................................................................459, 812 Ipswich Town F.C. Co. Ltd. v. Ipswich B.C. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 141, Browne-Wilkinson V.C...................................664 Irvine v. Moran [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 261 Thayne Forbes Q.C. ...................................................245, 261, 456, 672, 702 Isaac v. Hotel De Paris Ltd. [1960 1 W.L.R. 239 .........................................................................................................175 Islam, Re [1983] 1 A.C. 688 H.L. see R. v. Islington L.B.C. .........................................................................................81 Islington L.B.C. v. Reeves [1996] C.L.Y. 437 [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 2715 ...................................................................319, 331 Issa v. Hackney L.B.C. [1997] 1 W.L.R. 956 C.A. .......................................................................................................268 Italica Holdings S.A. v. Bayadea [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 70, French J........................................................563, 589, 591, 593 Ive’s case (1597) 5 Co. Rep. 11a, 77 E.R. 64..........................................................................................................38, 599 Ivory Gate Ltd. v. Spetale [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 43 C.A. ..........................................................................................786, 806 Izon v. Gorton (1839) 5 Bing. (N.C.) 501, 132 E.R. 1193...................................................................................258, 691 J. v. J. [1980] 1 All E.R. 156 .........................................................................................................................................140 J. v. J. [1993] 2 F.L.R. 56, Eastham J. .........................................................................................................................139 J.L. Engineering v. S.S. for the Environment (1994) 67 P. & C.R. 354 Div. Ct. .........................................................709 J.T. Developments Ltd. v. Quinn [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 257 C.A......................................................................................564 Jackson v. Pekic [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 104 C.A. ......................................................................................................107, 163 Jackson (Francis) Developments Ltd. v. Stemp [1943] 2 All E.R. 601 ........................................................................173 Jacob v. Down [1900] 2 Ch. 156, Stirling J..........................................................................................................812, 819 Jacobs v. Chaudhuri [1968] 2 Q.B. 470 C.A. .....................................................................126, 393, 547, 560, 589, 834
TABLE OF CASES
xlvii
Jacques v. Harrison (1884) 12 Q.B.D. 165 .................................................................................................................824 Jacques v. Liverpool C.C. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 82 Q.B.D. ...............................................................................................274 Jaison Property Development Co. Ltd. v. Roux Restaurants Ltd. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 357 C.A.................................734 James v. British Crafts Centre [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 139 C.A. ........................................................................................666 James v. Hutton [1950] K.B. 9 C.A. ....................................................................................................................684, 694 James v. Lock [1978] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. .......................................................................................................................613 James v. U.K. (1986) 8 E.C.H.R. 123..........................................................................................200, 201–203, 403–404 Janes (Gowns) Ltd. v. Harlow Development Corporation [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 52 Ch.D. .............................................662 James Jones & Sons Ltd. v. Tankerville [1909] 2 Ch. 440............................................................................................526 Jaquin v. Holland [1960] 1 W.L.R. 258 C.A. ..............................................................................................................682 Jarrett v. Burford Estates & Property Co. Ltd. [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 181 L.Tr. ...............................................................403 Jaskel v. Sophie Nursery Products Ltd. [1993] E.G.C.S. 42 C.A. ................................................................599, 664, 785 Javad v. Aqil [1991] 1 W.L.R. 1007, [1991] 1 All E.R. 243 C.A.........................................................................173, 553 Jeffries v. Stevens [1982] S.T.C. 639.............................................................................................................................167 Jelley v. Buckman [1974] Q.B. 488 C.A...............................................................................................................305, 758 Jenkins v. Gething (1862) 2 John. & H. 520, 70 E.R. 1165 .........................................................................................698 Jenkins v. Jackson (1888) 40 Ch.D. 71, Kekewich J. ...........................................................................................309, 717 Jenkins v. Price [1907] 2 Ch. 229, Swinfen Eady J. .....................................................................................................740 Jenkin R. Lewis & Son Ltd. v. Kerman [1971] Ch. 477 C.A..................................................................................38, 599 Jennings v. Epping Forest D.C. (1991) 25 H.L.R. 241 C.A..................................................................................502, 503 Jeremy v. Lowgar (1594?) Cro. Eliz. 461, 78 E.R. 714.................................................................................................689 Jervis v. Harris [1996] Ch. 195 C.A. ..................................................................................................255, 683, 707, 802 Jessamine Investment Co. Ltd. v. Schwartz [1978] Q.B. 264 C.A. .....................................................................111, 306 Jeune v. Queen’s Cross Properties Ltd. [1974] Ch. 97 .........................................................................256, 684, 705–706 Job v. Job (1877) 6 Ch.D. 562 ......................................................................................................................................525 Joel v. Montgomery & Taylor [1967] Ch. 272 .....................................................................................................175, 530 Joel’s Lease,Re [1930] 2 Ch. 359 .................................................................................................................................607 John v. George [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 7 C.A..............................................................................................305, 610, 626, 759 John Dee Group Ltd. v. W.M.H. (21) Ltd. [1997] B.C.C. 578 Ch.D ..........................................................................648 John Lewis Properties Ltd. v. Chelsea [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 77, Mummery J. ......................................679, 716, 814, 820 John Lyon’s Charity Trustees v. Haysport Properties Ltd. [1995] E.G.C.S. 171, Carnwath J. ................454, 686, 798 John Lyon’s Free Grammar School Governors v. James [1995] 4 All E.R. 740 C.A. (called Jordan at (1995) 27 H.L.R. 727 C.A.) .....................................................................................................................110, 300, 824 John Lyon’s Free Grammar School v. Mayhew [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 88 C.A. ........................................................559, 564 John Lyon’s Free Grammar School v. Secchi [1999] 49 E.G. 100 C.A. .......................................................................411 Johnsey Estates Ltd. v. Lewis & Manley (Engineering) Ltd. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. .....................................777, 790 Johnson v. Davies [1999] Ch. 117 C.A. ..............................................................................................................773, 786 Johnson v. Felton (1994) 27 H.L.R. 265 C.A. .....................................................................................................111, 345 Johnson v. Leicester Corporation [1934] 1 K.B. 638 ...................................................................................................270 Johnson v. Moreton [1980] A.C. 37 H.L..............................................................................................606, 611, 615–617 Johnson v. Sheffield C.C. (1982) 43 P. & C.R. 272 L.Tr..............................................................................................409 Johnston & Sons Ltd. v. Holland [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 264 C.A..............................................................................718, 720 Johnston v. Westminster [1986] A.C. 839 H.L. .........................................................................................366, 367, 391 John Wilmott Homes Ltd. v. Read (1986) 51 P. & C.R. 90 .........................................................................................530 Jolly v. Arbuthnot (1859) 4 De G & J 224, 45 E.R. 87 ................................................................................................524 Jollybird Ltd. v. Fairzone Ltd. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 55 C.A. ...................................................................................458, 704 Jones v. Avon Estates [1996] C.L.Y. 3738 ............................................................................................................412, 414 Jones v. Bernstein [1900] 2 Q.B. 100 C.A. ...................................................................................................................652 Jones v. Bridgman (1878) 39 L.T. 500 .........................................................................................................................599 Jones v. Carter (1846) 15 M. & W. 718, 153 E.R. 1040 .............................................................................................814 Jones v. Chappell (1875) L.R. 20 Eq. 539, Jessel M.R. ...............................................................................................692 Jones v. Christy (1963) 107 S.J. 374 C.A. ............................................................................................................542, 549 Jones v. Cook (1990) 22 H.L.R. 319 C.A. ....................................................................................................................352 Jones v. Gates [1954] 1 W.L.R. 222 C.A. .....................................................................................................................626 Jones v. Gospel [1998] E.G.C.S. 108 ............................................................................................................................180 Jones v. Herxheimer [1950] 2 K.B. 106 C.A. ...............................................................................................................682 Jones v. Hill (1817) Taunt. 392, 129 E.R. 156 ....................................................................................................263, 673 Jones v. Jenkins [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 113 C.A. ................................................................................................................572 Jones v. Jones (1803) 12 Ves. 186, 33 E.R. 71 ..............................................................................................................531
xlviii
TABLE OF CASES
Jones v. Jones [1997] Fam. 59 C.A...............................................................................................................................137 Jones v. Lavington [1903] 1 K.B. 253 C.A. ..................................................................................................................720 Jones v. Lewis (1973) 25 P. & C.R. 375 C.A. .......................................................................................................589, 617 Jones v. Lipman [1962] 1 W.L.R. 832 C.A. ................................................................................................................170 Jones v. Miah (1992) 24 H.L.R. 578 C.A.............................................................................................................313, 314 Jones v. Nelson [1938] 2 All E.R. 171 .........................................................................................................................250 Jones v. Owen [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 5 ..............................................................................................................................615 Jones v. Watts (1890) 43 Ch. D. 574 C.A. ...................................................................................................................527 Jones v. Waveney D.C [1999] 48 L.S.G. 40 C.A. ........................................................................................................240 Jordan v. May [1947] K.B. 427 C.A. ...........................................................................................................................699 Joseph v. Joseph [1967] Ch. 78 C.A..............................................................................................................512, 558, 599 Jourdain v. Wilson (1821) 4 B. & Ald. 266, 106 E.R. 935 ..........................................................................................768 Joyce v. Liverpool C.C. [1996] Q.B. 252 C.A. ..............................................................................................................255 Joyner v. Weeks [1891] 2 Q.B. 31 C.A. ........................................................................................................529, 681–683 Junction Estates Ltd. v. Cope (1974) 27 P. & C.R. 482, MacKenna J. ........................................................................781 K. v. K. [1992] 1 W.L.R. 530 C.A. ..............................................................................................................................139 Kalra v. S.S. for the Environment (1996) 72 P. & C.R. 423 C.A. ...............................................................................709 Kammins Ballrooms Co. Ltd. v. Zenith Investments (Torquay) Ltd. [1971] A.C. 850 H.L. ..............................................................................................................563–564, 587, 812, 815 Kanda v. Church Commissioners for England [1958] 1 Q.B. 332 C.A. ..............................................................589, 803 Kataria v. Safeland plc. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 39 C.A. ...................................................................374, 754, 796, 808, 809 Kaur v. Gill [1995] Times June 15th C.A. ..................................................................................................................315 Kavanagh v. Lyroudias [1985] 1 All E.R. 560 C.A. .....................................................................................108, 146, 352 Kay Green v. Twinsectra Ltd. [1996] 1 W.L.R. 1587 C.A. .................................................................................427, 431 Keates v. Cadogan (1851) 10 C.B. 591, 138 E.R. 234..................................................................................................251 Keats v. Graham [1960] 1 W.L.R. 30 C.A...................................................................................................................681 Keen v. Holland [1984] 1 W.L.R. 251 C.A. ................................................................................................................614 Keeves v. Dean [1924] 1 K.B. 685 C.A. ...............................................................................................................111, 729 Keith Bayley Rogers & Co. v. Cubes (1975) 31 P. & C.R. 412 ....................................................................................582 Kelley v. Dundee City D.C. [1994] S.L.T. 1268 ..................................................................................................494, 498 Kellogg (M.W.) Ltd. v. F. Tobin [1997] L.T.R. 513 Q.B.D. ................................................................................784, 788 Kelly v. Battershell [1949] 2 All E.R. 830 C.A. ...........................................................................................................718 Kelly v. Monklands D.C. [1986] S.L.T. (O.H.) 165 .....................................................................................................76 Kelly v. Norwich Union Fire Insurance Soc. Ltd. [1990] 1 W.L.R. 139 C.A. ..............................................................685 Kelsey H.Ass. v. King (1996) 28 H.L.R. 270 C.A. .................................................................................................55, 318 Kemmis v. Kemmis [1988] 1 W.L.R. 1307 C.A. .........................................................................................................130 Kemp v. Neptune Concrete Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 87 C.A. ........................................................................................657 Kemra Management Ltd. v. Lewis [1999] 10 C.L. 489, Recorder Hayton .........................................................647, 674 Kendall v. Hill (1860) 2 L.T. 717 ................................................................................................................................685 Kened Ltd. v. Connie Investments Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 21 C.A. ............................................................732, 733, 740 Kenny v. Kingston upon Thames R.L.B.C. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 26 C.A. .......................................................................246 Kenny v. Preen [1963] 1 Q.B. 499 .......................................................................................................309, 310, 315, 717 Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. v. Hayden (1984) 17 H.L.R. 114 C.A. .....................................................................171 Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. v. Simmonds (1996) 29 H.L.R. 507 C.A. .................................................................342 Kensington H. Trust v. Oliver (1998) 30 H.L.R. 608 C.A. ..........................................................................332, 335, 343 Kent Coast Property Investments Ltd. v. Ward [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 86 C.A..................................................................550 Kent v. Millmead Properties Ltd. (1982) 44 P. & C.R. 353 C.A..................................................................................235 Keppell v. Bailey (1834) 2 My. & K. 517, 39 E.R. 1042 ......................................................................766, 768, 769, 771 Khalique v. Law Land plc. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 105 C.A. ..............................................................................................662 Khan v. Islington L.B.C.[1999] E.G.C.S. 87 C.A. ...............................................................................................221, 647 Khar v. Delmounty Ltd. (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 232 C.A.......................................................372, 376, 795, 804, 818, 828 Khazanchi v. Faircharm Investments Ltd. (1999) 77 P. & C.R. 29 C.A......................................................650, 651, 652 Kicks v. Downing (1696) 1 Ld. Raym. 99, 91 E.R. 962 ..............................................................................................726 Kidder v. Birch (1983) 46 P. & C.R. 362 C.A..............................................................................................................350 Kiddle v. City Business Properties Ltd. [1942] 1 K.B. 269 C.A....................................................................................248 Killick v. Roberts [1991] 1 W.L.R. 1146, [1991] 4 All E.R. 289 C.A. ................................................................168, 347 Killick v. Second Covent Garden Property Co. Ltd. [1973] 1 W.L.R. 658 C.A............................................................736
TABLE OF CASES
xlix
Kimpton v. Eve (1813) 2 Ves. & B. 349, 35 E.R. 352 Eldon L.C. .......................................................................261, 672 Kinch v. Bullard [1999] 1 W.L.R. 423, [1998] 4 All E.R. 650 ....................................................................................592 King v. Jackson (1998) 30 H.L.R. 541 C.A. .........................................................................................................314, 348 King v. South Northants D.C. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 53 C.A. ..........................................................................................245 King v. Taylor [1955] 1 Q.B. 150 C.A. ........................................................................................................................331 King,Re [1963] Ch. 459 C.A. ..............................................................369, 370, 681, 688, 690, 749, 753, 752, 755, 776 King’s Leasehold Estates Re (1873) L.R. 16 Eq. 521 .............................................................................................32, 516 King’s Motors (Oxford) Ltd. v. Lax [1970] 1 W.L.R. 426, [1969] 3 All E.R. 665.......................................................536 Kingston on Thames R.L.B.C. v. Marlow [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 101 Q.B.D. .........................................258, 691, 805, 806 Kingston on Thames R.L.B.C. v. Prince (1999) 31 H.L.R. 794 C.A. ................................................................9, 76, 121 Kingswood Estates Co. Ltd. v. Anderson [1963] 2 Q.B. 169 C.A. ...............................................................521, 523, 525 Kirklees M.B.C. v. Field (1998) 30 H.L.R. 869 Div.Ct. .......................................................................................267, 269 Kirklinton v. Wood [1917] 1 K.B. 332.........................................................................................................................671 Kirkwood v. Johnson (1979) 38 P. & C.R. 392 C.A.....................................................................................................567 Kisch v. Hawes Brothers Ltd. [1935] Ch. 102, Farwell J..............................................................................................831 Kitney v. M.E.P.C. Ltd. [1977] 1 W.L.R. 981 C.A. .....................................................................................................538 Kleinwort Benson Ltd. v. Lincoln C.C. [1999] A.C. 349 H.L. .............................................................................219, 653 Knapdale (Nominees) Ltd. v. Donald [2000] Times August 22nd.............................................................................616 Knight v. Lawrence [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 143 Ch.D. .......................................................................................................658 Knight v. Peachee (1679) Freem. K.B. 465, 89 E.R. 347 .............................................................................................751 Knight v. Williams [1901] 1 Ch. 256 ..........................................................................................................................600 Knighton Estates Ltd. v. Gallic Management Co. Ltd. (1999) 78 P. & C.R. 52 C.A. ................................643, 781, 788 Knight’s case (1588) 5 Co. Rep. 54b, 77 E.R. 137 .......................................................................................................759 Knightsbridge Estates Trust Ltd. v. Deeley [1950] 2 K.B. 228 ....................................................................................300 Knowsley M.B.C. v. O’Toole (2000) 32 H.L.R. 420 ....................................................................................................268 Kovats v. Trinity House Corporation [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 103, Forbes J.......................................................................228 Kramer (Michael) & Co. Ltd. v. Airways Pension Fund Trustees Ltd. [1978] 1 E.G.L.R. 49 C.A..............................668 Krell v. Henry [1903] 2 Q.B. 740 C.A....................................................................................................................18, 510 Kumar v. Dunning [1989] 1 Q.B. 193 C.A.................................................537, 712, 770–772, 764, 766, 767, 782–784 Kushner v. Law Society [1952] 1 K.B. 264 C.A. .....................................................................................................31, 32 Lace v. Chantler [1944] K.B. 368 C.A. .........................................................................................19, 512, 513, 514, 518 Laconia,The [1977] A.C. 850 H.L. ..............................................................................................................................814 Ladbroke Hotels Ltd. v. Sandhu [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 92, Robert Walker J..........................................................665, 676 Ladies’ Hosiery & Underwear Ltd. v. Parker [1930] 1 Ch. 304 ....................................................................................22 Ladsky v. T.S.B. Bank plc. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 372 C.A. ...................................................................................253, 707 Ladup v. Williams & Glyn’s Bank Ltd. [1985] 1 W.L.R. 851 .....................................................................................824 Ladyman v. Wirral Estates Ltd. [1968] 2 All E.R. 197 ................................................................................................582 Lagens Properties Ltd. v. Baudino [1965] E.G.D. 69 ..................................................................................................393 Laimond Properties Ltd. v. Al-Shakarchi (1998) 30 H.L.R. 1099 C.A. ..............................................40, 143, 301, 353 Laimond Property Investment Co. Ltd. v. Arlington Park Mansions Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 208 C.A. .............459, 646 Lake v. Bennett [1970] 1 Q.B. 663.......................................................................................................................396, 400 Lakshmijit v. Faiz Sherani [1974] A.C. 605 P.C. .......................................................................................................175 Lam Kee Ying Sdn Bhd v. Lam She Tong [1975] A.C. 247 P.C. ................................................................................834 Lambert v. Keymood Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 70, Laws J......................................................................................686, 688 Lambeth L.B.C. v. Rogers [2000] 03 E.G. 127 C.A. ...................................................................................245, 333, 334 Lambeth L.B.C. v. Thomas (1998) 30 H.L.R. 89 C.A. ...............................................................................336, 337, 766 Lambeth L.B.C. v. Udechuka (1980) 41 P. & C.R. 200 C.A. ................................................................................26, 164 Lampard v. Barker [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 11 C.A. ............................................................................................................613 Lancaster & Macnamara,Re [1918] 2 K.B. 472 .........................................................................................................612 Land and Premises at Liss, Hants, Re [1971] Ch. 986...................................................................................22, 556, 612 Land Law plc. v. Sinclair (1991) 24 H.L.R. 57 C.A.....................................................................................................353 Land Reclamation Co. Ltd. v. Basildon D.C. [1979] 1 W.L.R. 767 C.A. ...................................................................544 Land Securities Ltd. v. Metropolitan Police District Receiver [1983] 1 W.L.R. 439, Megarry V.C. ..........695, 802, 803 Land Settlement (Association) Ltd. v. Carr [1944] K.B. 657 C.A. ..............................................................................612 Land v. Sykes [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ...............................................................................................................624, 758 Landau v. Sloane [1982] A.C. 490 H.L. ......................................................................................................................164 Landeau v. Marchbank [1949] All E.R. 172, Lynskey J. .............................................................................................682 Lane v. Cox [1897] 1 Q.B. 415 C.A. ............................................................................................................................250
l
TABLE OF CASES
Langborger v. Sweden (1989) 12 E.H.R.R. 416 ..........................................................................................................638 Langevad v. Chiswick Quay Freeholds Ltd. (2000) 80 P. & C.R. 26 C.A. ...........................................................415, 417 Langford Property Co. Ltd. v. Tureman [1949] 1 K.B. 29 C.A. .................................................................................108 Lansdowne Rodway Estates Ltd. v. Portman Ltd. [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 80. ...................................................................681 Lansdowne Tutors Ltd. v. Younger [2000] 04 L.S.G. 34 C.A. ...............................................................................40, 601 Larkos v. Cyprus (1999) 7 B.H.R.C. 244 E.C.H.R. .....................................................................................................204 Larksworth Investments Ltd. v. Temple House Ltd. (No.2) [1999] B.L.R. 297 C.A....................................................706 Latif v. Hillside Estates (Swansea) Ltd. [1992] E.G.C.S. 75 C.A. ...............................................................................544 Laura Investments Co. Ltd. v. Havering L.B.C. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 155, Hoffmann J., (No.2) [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 124 Ch.D. ........................................................................................................................................................................664 Lavell & Co. Ltd. v. O’Leary [1933] 2 K.B. 200 C.A. ..................................................................................................652 Law Land Co. Ltd. v. Consumers’ Association Ltd. [1980] 2 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A. ................................................664, 666 Lawley,Re [1911] 2 Ch. 530 .......................................................................................................................................790 Lawrance v. Hartwell [1946] K.B. 553, [1946] 2 All E.R. 257 C.A. ..........................................................................144 Lawrence Chemical Co. Ltd. v. Rubinstein [1982] 1 W.L.R. 284 C.A. ...............................................................220, 649 Lawson v. Hartley-Brown (1996) 71 P. & C.R. 242 C.A.....................................................................................309, 717 Layzell v. Smith Morton & Long [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 169. ............................................................................................620 Lazarus Estates Ltd. v. Beasley [1956] 1 Q.B. 702 C.A..................................................................................28, 236, 590 Lea v. Thursby [1904] 2 Ch. 57 ...................................................................................................................................596 Leach v. Thomas (1835) 7 C. & P. 327, 173 E.R. 125 .........................................................................................263, 673 Leather Cloth Co. v. Bressey (1862) 3 Giff. 474, 66 E.R. 496. .....................................................................................685 Leathwoods Ltd. v. Total Oil G.B. Ltd. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 237 C.A. ...................................................................570, 571 Lechmere v. Hawkins (1798) 2 Esp. 626, 170 E.R. 477, Lord Kenyon .......................................................................648 Lee v. K. Carter Ltd. [1949] 1 K.B. 85 C.A. .........................................................................................................292, 738 Lee v. Lee [1999] Times September 22nd C.A.............................................................................................................774 Lee Verhulst (Investments) Ltd. v. Harwood Trust [1973] Q.B. 204 C.A.................................................544, 546, 549 Leech v. Schweder (1874) L.R. 9 Ch.App. 463, 467n ..................................................................................................526 Leeds C.C. v. Harte [1999] 4 C.L. 470 .........................................................................................................................342 Leeds Corporation v. Jenkinson [1935] 1 K.B. 168 C.A...............................................................................................224 Leeds Federated H.Ass.,Re [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 93 Q.B.D. ............................................................................................234 Leeds v Cheetham (1827) 1 Sim. 146, 57 E.R. 533..............................................................................................688, 689 Leeds v. Islington L.B.C. [1998] Env. L.R. 655 C.A. ...........................................................................................269, 590 Leek & Moorlands B.S. v. Clark [1952] 2 Q.B. 788 ....................................................................................127, 596, 597 Lee-Parker v. Izzet [1971] 1 W.L.R. 1688, Goff J................................................................................................257, 647 Lees v. Tatchell [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 10 ..........................................................................................................621, 624–625 Leeward Securities Ltd. v. Lillyheath Properties Ltd. [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 54 C.A. .......................................................738 Legal & General Assurance (Pension Management) Ltd. v. Cheshire C.C. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 102 C.A.....................659 Legal & General Assurance Society Ltd. v. General Metal Agencies Ltd. (1969) 20 P. & C.R. 953 ............................813 Lehmann v. McArthur (1867) L.R. 3 Eq. 746..............................................................................................................738 Leicester C.C. v. Aldwinckle (1991) 24 H.L.R. 40 C.A. ..............................................................................................334 Leigh v. Certibilt Investments Ltd. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R 116............................................................................................662 Leigh v. Taylor [1902] A.C. 157 H.L. .................................................................................................370, 697, 698, 699 Leith Properties Ltd. v. Byrne [1983] Q.B. 433 C.A. ...................................................................................................297 Lemmerbell Ltd. v. Britannia I.A.S. Direct Ltd. [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 67 C.A. .......................................................581, 590 Leslie & Co. v. Cumming [1926] 2 K.B. 417 ..............................................................................................................108 Lester v. Ridd [1990] 2 Q.B. 430, [1989] 1 All E.R. 1111 C.A............................................................................400, 610 Lewin v. American & Colonial Distributors Ltd. [1945] Ch. 225 C.A. .......................................................................769 Lewington v. Society for Protection of Ancient Buildings Trustees (1983) 45 P. & C.R. 336 C.A. ..............................560 Lewis & Allenby (1909) Ltd. v. Pegge [1914] 1 Ch. 782, Neville J. ............................................................................734 Lewis (E.H.) & Son Ltd. v. Morelli [1948] 2 All E.R. 1021 C.A..........................................................................303, 565 Lewis v. Baker [1905] 1 Ch. 46 ...........................................................................................................305, 529, 726, 743 Lewis v. Bond (1853) 18 Beav. 85, 52 E.R. 34 .............................................................................................................531 Lewis v. Lewis [1984] Fam. 79, [1985] A.C. 828 H.L. ...............................................................................................136 Lewis v. M.T.C. (Cars) Ltd. [1975] 1 W.L.R. 457 C.A........................................................................................562, 586 Lewis v. Morelli (1949) 65 T.L.R. 56 C.A. ...................................................................................................................831 Lewis v. Walters [1992] S.T.C. 97................................................................................................................................401 Lewis v. Weldcrest Ltd. [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1107 C.A. ...................................................................................................549 Lewis-Graham v. Conacher [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 111 C.A. ............................................................................................163 Lewisham L.B.C. v. Akinsola (2000) 32 H.L.R. 414 C.A.....................................................................................331, 340
TABLE OF CASES
li
Lewisham L.B.C. v. Masterson [2000] 1 E.G.L.R. 134 C.A. .......................................................................................641 Lewisham L.B.C. v. Ranaweera [2000] 02 C.L. 385....................................................................................................313 Lewisham B.C. v. Roberts [1949] 2 K.B. 608 C.A. ......................................................................................................303 Lewisham L.B.C. v. Simba-Tola (1991) 24 H.L.R. 644 C.A. ......................................................................................342 Lex Services Ltd. v. Johns [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 92 C.A. ..................................................................................563, 592, 593 Liddy v. Kennedy (1871) L.R. 5 H.L. 134 H.L. ...........................................................................................305, 759, 769 Lightcliffe & District Cricket & Lawn Tennis Club v. Walton [1978] 1 E.G.L.R. 35 C.A. .........................................571 Lilleshall Road Housing Co-Operative v. Brennan (1991) 24 H.L.R. 195 C.A...........................................................178 Lilley & Skinner Ltd. v. Crump (1929) 73 S.J. 366, Rowlatt J.....................................................................................693 Lillie v. Legh (1858) 3 De G. & J. 204, 44 E.R. 1247 ...........................................................................................531, 533 Linden v. Department of Health and Social Security [1986] 1 W.L.R. 164, Scott J....................................................549 Linkproud Ltd. v. Ballard [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 181 L.Tr................................................................................................431 Lipton v. Whitworth (1993) 26 H.L.R. 293 C.A. ........................................................................................................350 Lismane v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 427 C.A......................................................................96 Lister v. Lane [1893] 2 Q.B. 212 ..................................................................................................................671, 677–679 Lister,Re [1926] Ch. 149..............................................................................................................................................773 Litre Garages (Green Park) Ltd. v. Mobil Oil Co. Ltd. [1985] unreported ................................................................564 Littlewood v. Rolfe [1981] 2 All E.R. 51.......................................................................................................................621 Liverpool C.C. v. Irwin [1977] A.C. 239 H.L., [1976] Q.B. 319 C.A. ..............................................194, 246, 281, 632 Liverpool Corporation v. Huson [1972] 1 Q.B. 48, see Central Estates (Belgravia) ..................................................409 Liverpool Properties Ltd. v. Oldbridge Investments Ltd. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 111 C.A. ................................................821 Living Waters Christian Centres Ltd. v. Conwy B.C.[1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ..................................................272, 662 Lloyd v. Crispe (1813) 5 Taunt. 249, 128 E.R. 685. ....................................................................................................741 Lloyd v. Dimmack (1877) 7 Ch.D. 398........................................................................................................................790 Lloyd v. Rees [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3725 .............................................................................................................................260 Lloyd v. Sadler [1978] Q.B. 774 C.A...................................................................................106, 124, 125, 126, 393, 834 Lloyds Bank Ltd. v. Bundy [1975] Q.B. 326 C.A. .......................................................................................................638 Lloyds Bank Ltd. v. City of London Corporation [1983] Ch. 192 C.A ................................................................574, 587 Lloyds Bank Ltd. v. Lake [1961] 1 W.L.R. 884 ...........................................................................................................682 Lloyds Bank plc. v. Bowker Orford [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 44 Ch.D. .........................................................................458, 703 Lock v. Pearce [1893] 2 Ch. 271 C.A. ..................................................................................................798, 800, 819, 820 Locobail U.K. Ltd. v. Waldorf Investment Corp. [2000] Times June 13th Evans-Lombe J. Rejected [2000] 2 W.L.R. 870. ..................................................................................................................................................................205, 206 Lofft v. Dennis (1859) 1 E. & E. 474, 120 E.R. 987 .....................................................................................................689 Lohan v. Hilton [1994] E.G.C.S. 83 C.A. ...................................................................................................................350 Lomax Leisure Ltd.,Re [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 37, Neuberger J. ..............................................................772, 774, 829, 830 Lombard Natwest Factors Ltd. v. Sebastian [1999] L.T.L. November 1st,, Hart J. ....................................................324 Lombie v. Thanet D.C. [2000] 32 L.S.G. 39 ................................................................................................................267 London & Associated Investment Trust plc. v. Calow (1987) 53 P. & C.R. 340 .........................................173, 551, 553 London & County (A. & D.) Ltd. v. Wilfred Sportsman Ltd. [1971] Ch. 764 C.A. .................305, 754, 760, 809, 814 London & Leeds Estates Ltd. v. Paribas Ltd. [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 149 C.A....................................................................664 London & Northern Estates Co. Ltd. v. Schlesinger [1916] 1 K.B. 20 C.A. ................................................................715 London & South Western Rly Co. v. Gomm (1882) 20 Ch.D. 562 C.A. .............................................................536, 538 London (N. & D.) Ltd. v. Gadsdon [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 112, Auld J.............................................................................112 London Bridge v. Thompson (1903) 89 L.T. 50 ..........................................................................................................825 London City Council v. Bown (1990) 60 P. & C.R. 42 C.A. .......................................................................................115 London Corporation, Re [1910] 2 Ch. 314, Eve J. ......................................................................................................676 London County Freehold & Leasehold Properties Ltd. v. Wallis-Whiddett [1950] W.N. 180 ...................................681 London County Territorial and Auxillary Forces Association v. Nichols [1949] 1 K.B. 35 C.A. ................................170 London Hilton Jewellers Ltd. v. Hilton International Hotels Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 112 C.A. ..................................571 London Housing & Commercial Properties Ltd. v. Cowan [1977] Q.B. 148. ............................................................236 London Regional Transport v. Brandt (1997) 29 H.L.R. 193 C.A. ..........................................................299, 300, 602 London Underground Ltd. v. Shell International Petroleum Co. Ltd. [1998] E.G.C.S. 97 Ch.D. ..............................702 London v. Nash (1747) 3 Atk. 512, 26 E.R. 1095........................................................................................................678 Long Acre Securities Ltd. v. Electro Acoustic Industries Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 91 C.A..............................................587 Long v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. [1998] Ch. 197, James Munby Q.C. ...................................................32, 518, 529, 559 Longman v. Chelsea [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 242 C.A. .......................................................................................................600 Longmint Ltd. v. Akinlade & Gibbons [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 3292 C.Ct. ............................................................................816 Longrigg Burrough & Trounson v. Smith [1979] 2 E.G.L.R. 42 C.A. .................................................................174, 553
lii
TABLE OF CASES
Lonsdale & Thompson Ltd. v. Black Arrow Group plc. [1993] Ch. 361 .....................................................686, 688, 689 Lopez-Osta v. Spain (1995) 20 E.H.R.R. 277 .............................................................................................................204 Lory v. Brent L.B.C. [1971] 1 W.L.R. 823 ..................................................................................................................614 Louisville Investments [1986] Ch. 513 C.A., see International Drilling Love v. Herrity (1990) 23 H.L.R. 217 C.A. .................................................................................................................314 Lovell see Bristol C.C. Lovelock v. Margo [1963] 2 Q.B. 786 C.A. ..........................................................................................................733, 821 Lovely & Orchard Services Ltd. v. Daejean Investments (Grove Hall) Ltd. [1977] 1 E.G.L.R. 44 ..............................656 Lowe & Sons v. Dixon & Sons (1885) 16 Q.B.D. 455..................................................................................................525 Lower Street Properties Ltd. v. Jones [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 67 C.A. ......................................................50, 51, 54, 56, 318 Lower v. Sorrell [1963] 1 Q.B. 959 C.A. .......................................................................................................24, 585, 622 Lowther v. Heaver (1889) 41 Ch.D. 248 C.A. ............................................................................................525, 530, 531 Lubren v. Lambeth L.B.C. (1988) 20 H.L.R. 165 C.A. .......................................................................................259, 260 Luby v. Newcastle under Lyme [1965] 1 Q.B. 214 C.A. ..............................................................................................224 Lucas v. Commerford (1790) 3 Bro.C.C. 166, 29 E.R. 469, Thurlow L.C. ........................................................678, 756 Luganda v. Service Hotels Ltd. [1969] 2 Ch. 209 C.A. ................................................................................................159 Lumsden v. Burnett [1898] 2 Q.B. 177 C.A. ...............................................................................................................652 Lurcott v. Wakeley [1911] 1 K.B. 905 C.A. ................................................................................671, 675, 676, 677, 678 Luton v. Tinsey [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A.....................................................................................................................614 Luttenberger v. N. Thoresby Farms Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 261 C.A.; [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 3, Ferris J..................622, 623 Luxmore v. Robson (1818) 1 B. & Ald. 584, 106 E.R. 215 .........................................................................................676 Lyle v. Smith [1909] 2 I.R. 58 ......................................................................................................................................771 Lyne-Stephens & Scott-Miller’s C.,Re [1920] 1 Ch. 472 C.A......................................................................................753 Lynnthorpe Enterprises Ltd. v. Sidney Smith (Chelsea) Ltd. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 131 C.A. ..................................664, 666 Lyon & Co. v. London City & Midland Bank [1903] 2 K.B. 135 ................................................................................698 Lyon v. Reed (1844) 13 M. & W. 285, 153 E.R. 118...............................................................................38, 39, 598–600 Lyons (J.) & Co. Ltd. v. Knowles [1943] 1 K.B. 366 C.A.............................................................................................778 Lyons v. Caffery [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 102 C.A. ..............................................................................................................163 Lysaght v. Edwards (1876) 2 Ch.D. 499. ....................................................................................................526, 527, 529 Lyttleton Times Co. Ltd. v. Warners Ltd. [1907] A.C. 476 P.C. .........................................................................718, 720 McAuley v. Bristol C.C. [1992] Q.B. 134 C.A. ...........................................................................................245, 254, 255 McAully v. Chiswich Quay Freeholds Ltd. [1998] E.G.C.S. 163 C.A. ........................................................................414 McCall v. Abelesz [1976] Q.B. 585 C.A. .....................................................................................................................315 McCarrick v. Liverpool Corporation [1947] A.C. 219 H.L. ........................................................................246, 252, 253 McClinton v. McFall (1974) 232 E.G. 707 C.A. .........................................................................................................607 McCoy & Co. v. Clark (1982) 13 H.L.R. 87 C.A. .......................................................................................................260 MacDonald v. Thorn plc. [1999] Times October 15th C.A. .......................................................................................324 MacDonnell v. Daly [1969] 1 W.L.R. 1482 C.A..........................................................................................................352 McDougall v. Easington D.C. (1989) 58 P. & C.R. 201 C.A. ......................................................................248, 255, 679 McDougall’s Catering Foods Ltd. v. B.S.E. Trading Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A. ...........................39, 40, 600, 601 Macfarquhar v. Phillimore [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 89 ........................................................................................................404 McGonnell v. U.K. [2000] Times February 22nd .......................................................................................................205 McGreal v. Wake [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 42 C.A. ..............................................................................................246, 259, 260 McGuigan v. Southwark L.B.C. [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3721 ...............................................................................................267 McHale v. Daneham [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 C.Ct.......................................................................................................168 McInnes v. Clarke [1955] 1 W.L.R. 102 ......................................................................................................................242 McIntyre v. Herring Son & Daw [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 231 ............................................................................................404 McIntyre v. Merthyr Tydfil B.C. (1989) 21 H.L.R. 320 C.A. .....................................................................................503 McLean Homes (North London) Ltd. v. Dace [1997] E.G.C.S. 120, Blackburne J. ...................................................627 McLinton v. McFall (1974) 232 E.G. 707 C.A.............................................................................................................606 McMullen & Sons Ltd. v. Cerone [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 99 ......................................................................................650, 773 McNerny v. Lambeth L.B.C. (1988) 21 H.L.R. 188 C.A. ....................................................................................250, 251 McPhail v. Greensmith [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 228 C.A.....................................................................................................188 M. & P. Enterprises (London) Ltd. v. Norfolk Square Hotels Ltd. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 129 .........................................560 M.E.P.C. Ltd. v. Christian-Edwards [1981] A.C. 205 H.L. ........................................................................................528 M.E.P.C. plc. v. Grosvenor (Mayfair) Estates Ltd. (1991) 64 P. & C.R. 41, Morritt J. ..............................................679 M.E.P.C. plc. v. Scottish Amicable Life Assurance Society [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 93 C.A. ...............................773, 774, 787
TABLE OF CASES
liii
M.P. Services Ltd. v. A Lawyer (1996) 72 P. & C.R. D49 C.A. ...................................................................................780 Mace v. Rutland House Textiles Ltd. [2000] Times January 11th Ch.D. ...................................................................520 Maconchie Bros. Ltd. v. Brand [1946] 2 All E.R. 778 ...................................................................................................22 Magdalene College, Oxford v. Heritage [1974] 1 W.L.R. 441 ....................................................................................623 Mainwaring v. Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees [1998] Q.B. 1 C.A. ..................................................................429, 430 Makin v. Watkinson (1870) L.R. 6 Ex. 25 ..........................................................................................................252, 706 Makins v. Elson [1977] W.L.R. 221, Foster J. .............................................................................................................180 Maliekshod v. Howard de Walden Estates Ltd. [2000] E.G.C.S. 37 C.Ct. .................................................................399 Malpas v. St Ermin’s Property Co. Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A............................................................................400 Mammoth Greeting Cards Ltd. v. Agra Ltd. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 124, Mummery J.....................................................658 Manaton v. Edwards (1985) 18 H.L.R. 116 C.A. .......................................................................................................350 Mancetter Developments Ltd. v. Garmanson Ltd. [1986] Q.B. 1212 C.A. ..............261–263, 371, 671–672, 673, 700 Manchester Bonded Warehouse Co. v. Carr (1880) 5 C.P.D. 507.......................................................................689, 690 Manchester Brewery Co Ltd. v. Coombs [1901] 2 Ch. 608, Farwell J. ......................................524, 527, 755, 757, 769 Manchester C.C. v. Cochrane (1999) 31 H.L.R. 810 C.A....................................................................105, 165, 328, 340 Manchester C.C. v. Lawler (1999) 31 H.L.R. 119 C.A. ..............................................................................................342 Manchester C.C. v. McCann (1999) 31 H.L.R. 770 C.A. ...........................................................................................343 Manchester C.C. v. National Car Parks Ltd. [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 94 C.A. ...................................................................554 Manel v. Memon [2000] Times April 20th C.A. .....................................................................................................49, 61 Manfield & Sons Ltd. v. Botchin [1970] 2 Q.B. 612, Cooke J.............................................................................553, 558 Mann v. Cornella [1980] 1 E.G.L.R. 73 C.A. .............................................................................................................161 Mann v. Gardner (1991) 61 P. & C.R. 1 C.A. ............................................................................................................628 Mann v. Merrill [1945] 1 All E.R. 708 .......................................................................................................................609 Mannai Investments Co. Ltd. v. Eagle Star Life Assurance Co. Ltd. [1997] A.C. 749 H.L. ...................................................................27, 48, 214, 411, 560, 579, 580, 582, 588, 590, 642 Manor House Drive Ltd. v. Shahbazian (1965) 195 E.G. 283.............................................................................457, 703 Manorlike Ltd. v. Le Vitas Travel Agency & Consultancy Services Ltd. [1986] 1 All E.R. 573 C.A. ..........................582 Mansel v. Norton (1883) 22 Ch.D. 769 C.A................................................................................................................767 Mansfield v. Blackburne (1840) 6 Bing. N.C. 426, 133 E.R. 165. ...............................................................................699 Manson v. Westminster [1981] Q.B. 323, [1981] 2 All E.R. 40 C.A. .........................................................................769 Mansukhani v. Sharkey (1992) 24 H.L.R. 600 C.A.....................................................................................................351 Mantz v. Goring (1838) 4 Bing. N.C. 451, 132 E.R. 861 ....................................................................................675, 676 Maraday v. Sturt Properties Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 163 Ch.D. ..................................................................................658 Marath v. MacGillivray (1996) 28 H.L.R. 484 C.A. ....................................................47, 319, 337, 338, 460, 590, 591 March v. Brace (1614) 2 Bulst. 151, 80 E.R. 1025 ......................................................................................................788 Marchant v. Charters [1977] 1 W.L.R. 1181 C.A. .............................................................................................159, 161 Marcroft Wagons Ltd. v. Smith [1951] 2 K.B. 496 C.A. .....................................................................................111, 174 Mardell v. Curtis [1899] W.N. 93, Cozens-Hardy J. ...................................................................................................32 Marjorie Burnett v. Barclay [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 41 ......................................................................................................535 Markou v. Da Silvaesa (1986) 52 P. & C.R. 204 ................................................................................154, 155, 160, 163 Marks v. British Waterways Board [1963] 1 W.L.R. 1008 C.A. .................................................................................589 Marks v. Lilley [1959] 1 W.L.R. 749............................................................................................................................529 Marks v. Warren [1979] 1 All E.R. 29 Browne-Wilkinson J. ............................................................................726, 732 Marrow v. Turpin (1599) Cro. Eliz. 715, 78 E.R. 949 ................................................................................................761 Marsden v. Edward Heyes Ltd. [1927] 2 K.B. 1 C.A. .........................................................................261, 262, 672, 674 Marsh v. Gilbert [1980] 2 E.G.L.R. 44, Nourse J. ...............................................................................................728, 737 Marshall v. Berridge (1881) 19 Ch. D. 233 C.A. ................................................................................................516, 517 Marshall v. Rubypoint Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. ...............................................................................................260 Martin v. Gilham (1837) 7 Ad. & El. 540, 112 E.R. 574.....................................................................................263, 673 Martin v. Maryland Estates Ltd. [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 81 C.A.......................................................................443, 460, 461 Martyn v. Clue (1852) 18 Q.B. 661, Campbell C.J.....................................................................................................767 Martyn v. Williams (1857) 1 H. & N. 817, 156 E.R. 1430..................................................................................750, 767 Maryland Estates Ltd. v. 63 Perham Road Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 198 L.Tr. ....................................................407, 408 Maryland Estates Ltd. v. Abbathure Flat Management Co. Ltd.[1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 100 L.Tr. ...................................438 Maryland Estates Ltd. v. Joseph [1999] 1 W.L.R. 83 C.A............................................................................................816 Mason v. Clarke [1955] A.C. 778 H.L. ...............................................................................................................526, 527 Mason v. Skilling [1974] 1 W.L.R. 1437 H.L. ...........................................................................................227–228, 231 Matania v. National Provincial Bank Ltd. [1936] 2 All E.R. 633 C.A........................................................................720 Mather v. Barclays Bank Ltd. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 254 ..................................................................................................682
liv
TABLE OF CASES
Mather v. Fraser (1856) 2 K. & J. 536, 69 E.R. 895.....................................................................................................697 Matos e Silva Lda. V. Portugal (1996) 24 E.H.R.R. 573 .............................................................................................201 Mattey Securities Ltd. v. Ervin [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 66 C.A. ....................................................................39, 173, 553, 600 Matthews v. Sawell (1818) 8 Taunt. 270, 129 E.R. 387 ..............................................................................596, 600, 777 Matthews v. Smallwood [1910] 1 Ch. 777, Parker J. ..................................................................................................812 Matthews v. Usher [1900] 2 Q.B. 535 C.A. ................................................................................................................762 Matthey v. Curling [1922] 2 A.C. 180 H.L..................................................................................................222, 654, 689 Matures v. Westwood (1598) Cro. Eliz. 599, 78 E.R. 842 ...........................................................................750, 767, 782 Maugham, Re (1885) 14 Q.B.D. 956...........................................................................................................................525 Maunsell v. Olins [1975] A.C. 373 H.L. ......................................................................................................187, 300, 301 Maurice (Leslie) & Co. Ltd. v. Willesden Corporation [1953] 2 Q.B. 1 C.A. .............................................................270 Max Factor Ltd. v. Wesleyan Assurance Society [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 210 C.A. ............................................................583 Mayhew v. John Lyon Free Grammar School (1990) 23 H.L.R. 479 C.A. ..................................................................404 Meadfield Properties Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 39. ....................................................517, 582 Meadows v. Clerical Medical & General Life Assurance Society [1981] Ch. 70, Megarry V.C. ................561, 821, 825 Mears v. Callander [1901] 2 Ch. 388 .........................................................................................................................630 Mehmet v. Dawson [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 74 C.A. ...........................................................................................................560 Mehta v. Royal Bank of Scotland plc. [1999] Times January 25th Q.B.D..................................................................159 Melanesian Mission Trust Board v. Australia Mutual Provident Society [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 128 P.C........................659 Melbury Road Properties 1995 Ltd. v. Kreidi [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 108 .........................................................................443 Melhuish v. Adam [1995] C.L.Y. 3076 C.A. ...............................................................................................................271 Mellacher v. Austria [1990] 1 E.H.R.R. 391 ........................................................................................200, 202, 204, 239 Melles & Co. v. Holme [1918] 2 K.B. 100 Div.Ct................................................................................................253, 707 Mellor v. Watkins (1874) L.R. 9 Q.B. 400, Blackburne J............................................................................299, 603, 619 Melluish v. B.M.S. (No.3) Ltd. [1996] A.C. 454 H.L. .........................................................................................698, 699 Melville v. Bruton (1997) 27 H.L.R. 319 C.A. ............................................................................................................314 Melville v. Grapelodge Developments Ltd. (1979) 39 P. & C.R. 179, Neill J.......................................................257, 648 Merceron v. Dowson (1826) 5 B. & C. 479, 108 E.R. 179 ...........................................................................................759 Mercury Communications Ltd. v. Director General of Telecommuniations [1996] 1 W.L.R. 48 H.L........................661 Metclafe v. Boyce [1927] 1 K.B. 758 Div.Ct. .........................................................................................................39, 600 Methodist Secondary School Trustees v. O’Leary [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 105 C.A. ...........................................185, 543, 548 Methuen-Campbell v. Walters [1979] Q.B. 525..........................................................................................................413 Metrolands Investments Ltd. v. J.H. Dewhurst Ltd. [1986] 3 All E.R. 659 C.A. .........................................................660 Metropolitan Police District Receiver v. Palacegate Properties Ltd. [2000] 3 All E.R. 663 C.A. .............511, 556, 645 Metropolitan Properties Co. (Regis) Ltd. v. Bartholomew [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 82 C.A.........................................784, 785 Metropolitan Properties Co. (F.G.C.) Ltd. v. Good [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 88, Woolf J. ...................................................239 Metropolitan Properties Co. Ltd. v. Cronan (1982) 44 P. & C.R. 1 ............................................................................123 Metropolitan Properties Co. Ltd. v. Cordery (1979) 39 P. & C.R. 10 C.A. .................................................................290 Metropolitan Property Holdings Ltd. v. Finegold [1975] 1 W.L.R. 349 C.A.......................................228, 229–230, 231 Meux v. Cobley [1892] 2 Ch. 253, Kekewich J............................................................................................................693 Meye v. Electric Transmission [1942] Ch. 290 ..............................................................................................................22 Meyer v. Riddick [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 107 C.A...............................................................................................................572 Michaels v. Harley House (Marylebone) Ltd. [1997] 3 All E.R. 446, Lloyd J., [2000] Ch. 104 C.A..........................................................................................................................429, 530, 537, 592 Michaels v. Taylor Woodrow Developments Ltd. [2000] 20 L.S.G. 47, Laddie J. .......................................................429 Michel v. Volpe (1967) 202 E.G. 213 ..........................................................................................................................167 Micrografix v. Woking 8 Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 32, Jacob J. ......................................................................................580 Midanbury Properties (Southampton) Ltd. v. Houghton T. Clark & Son Ltd. [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 88, Woolf J.; ......239 Middleton v. Hall (1913) 108 L.T. 804 .......................................................................................................................260 Middlegate Properties Ltd. v. Gridlow-Jackson (1977) 34 P. & C.R. 4 C.A. .......................................................801, 803 Middlegate Properties Ltd. v. Messiemris [1973] 1 W.L.R. 168 C.A. ..................................................................801, 803 Middlemore v. Goodale (1638) Cro. Car. 503, 79 E.R. 1033 ......................................................................................769 Middleton v. Baldock [1950] 1 K.B. 657 C.A. ..............................................................................................40, 132, 601 Midgley v. Scott [1977] 2 E.G.L.R. 6 C.A. ...................................................................................................................613 Midland Bank plc. v Chart Enterprises Inc. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 59, Popplewell J. .......................................732, 733, 737 Midland Railway Co.’s Agreement,Re [1971] Ch. 725 C.A. ...................................23, 24–25, 509, 513–514, 515, 584 Mikeover Ltd. v. Brady [1989] 3 All E.R. 618 C.A. .....................................................................................155, 157, 158 Milius’ Application, Re (1995) 70 P. & C.R. 427 ........................................................................................................418 Miller v. Eyo (1999) 31 H.L.R. 306 C.A., [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3632 ................................................................147, 148, 311
TABLE OF CASES
lv
Milletts (R. & A.) (Shops) Ltd. v. Leon Allan International Fashions Ltd. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 138 C.A. ...................666 Millichamp v. Jones [1982] 1 W.L.R. 1422..................................................................................................................530 Mills [1999] 4 All E.R. 449 H.L. see Southwark L.B.C. Mills v. Cannon Brewery Co. Ltd. [1920] 2 Ch. 38, P.O. Lawrence J.........................................................................736 Mills v. Edwards [1971] 1 Q.B. 379 C.A. ....................................................................................................................622 Mills v. Griffiths (1876) 45 L.J. Q.B. 771.....................................................................................................................814 Milmo v. Carreras [1946] K.B. 306 C.A. ....................................................................................................294, 725, 726 Milne-Berry v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 229 C.A. .............................................................................501 Milverton Group Ltd. v. Warner World Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 28 C.A. ....................................................................772 Minay v. Sentongo (1983) 45 P. & C.R. 190 C.A. ......................................................................................................349 Minchburn Ltd. v. Fernandez (1987) 19 H.L.R. 29 C.A. ...........................................................................337, 352, 353 Minchin v. Sheffield C.C. [2000] Times April 26th C.A................................................................................................78 Minister of Agriculture Fisheries and Food v. Jenkins [1963] 2 Q.B. 317 C.A. ...........................................................626 Minister of Health v. Bellotti [1944] K.B. 298 C.A. ....................................................................................................173 Ministry of Defence v. Ashman [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 102 C.A. .......................................................................................807 Ministry of Defence v. Thompson [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 107 C.A. ...................................................................................807 Minja Properties Ltd. v. Cussins Property Group Ltd. [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 52 ......................................................677, 685 Minshull v. Oakes (1858) 2 H. & N. 793, 157 E.R. 327 .............................................................................................768 Mint v. Good [1951] 1 K.B. 517 C.A. ..................................................................................................................254, 707 Mira v. Aylmer Square Investments Ltd. (1990) 22 H.L.R. 182 C.A. ................................................................310, 717 Mirza v. Nicola [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 73 C.A...................................................................................................................572 Mistry v. Isidore [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 97 C.A. ................................................................................................................349 Mitas v. Hyams [1951] 2 T.L.R. 1215 C.A. ........................................................................................................525, 599 Mitten v. Fagg [1978] 2 E.G.L.R. 40, Goulding J........................................................................................................740 Mitton v. Farrow [1980] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. .................................................................................................................613 Moat v. Martin [1950] 1 K.B. 175 C.A. ..............................................................................................................735, 739 Mohamed v. Manek (1995) 27 H.L.R. 439 C.A. .........................................................................145, 177, 178, 311, 316 Molton Builders Ltd. v. Westminster C.C. (1975) 30 P. & C.R. 182 C.A....................................................................718 Molyneux-Child v. Coe [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3722 .............................................................................................................717 Monk, see Hammersmith & Fulham Monk v. Noyes (1824) 1 C. & P. 265, 171 E.R. 1189 ..................................................................................................675 Monmouth B.C. v. Marlog (1994) 27 H.L.R. 30 C.A..........................................................................................151, 158 Monson v. Bound [1954] 1 W.L.R. 1321 ....................................................................................................................610 Montague v. Browning [1954] 1 W.L.R. 1039 C.A. ....................................................................................................167 Montague v. Long (1972) 24 P. & C.R. 240, Graham J. .............................................................................................697 Montross Associated Investments S.A. v. Mousaieff [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 55 C.A. .........................................................708 Moodie v. Hosegood [1952] A.C. 61 H.L.....................................................................................................................116 Moore & Hulm’s C.,Re [1912] 2 Ch. 105....................................................................................................................743 Moore v. Escalus Properties Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 200 L.V.T. .................................................................................438 Moore v. Greg (1848) 2 Ph. 717, 41 E.R. 1120, Lord Cottenham L.C. ......................................................................756 Moore v. Ullcoats Mining Co. [1908] 1 Ch. 575. ........................................................................................................814 Moores v. Choat (1839) 8 Sim. 508, 59 E.R. 202 ........................................................................................................756 Morar v. Chauhan [1985] 1 W.L.R. 1263 C.A. ..........................................................................................................572 Morcom v. Campbell-Johnson [1956] 1 Q.B. 106 C.A................................................................................................230 Moreland Timber Co. Pty. Ltd. v. Reid [1946] V.L.R. 237 .........................................................................................533 Morgan & Son Ltd. v. S. Martin Johnson & Co. Ltd. [1949] 1 K.B. 107 C.A. ............................................................834 Morgan v. Liverpool Corporation [1927] 2 K.B. 131 C.A. .........................................................................................253 Morgan v. Stainer [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 73 Ch.D. ...................................................................................................459, 705 Morland v. Cook (1868) L.R. 6 Eq. 252 ......................................................................................................................771 Morley’s (Birmingham) Ltd. v. Slater [1950] 1 K.B. 506, [1950] 1 All E.R. 335 C.A. ...............................................105 Morrells of Oxford Ltd. v. Oxford United F.C. Ltd. [2000] Times August 15th C.A. ................................................764 Morris v. Knight [1999] 2 C.L. 373 .............................................................................................................................313 Morris v. Liverpool C.C. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A. ..........................................................................245, 253, 688, 707 Morris v. Royel Properties Ltd. [1995] C.L.Y. 2963 ....................................................................................................667 Morris v. Wentworth-Stanley [1999] 2 W.L.R. 470 C.A.....................................................................................747, 786 Morrison Jones & Taylor Ltd.,Re [1914] 1 Ch. 50 ......................................................................................................700 Morrisons Holdings Ltd. v. Manders Property (Wolverhampton) Ltd. [1976] 1 W.L.R. 533 C.A. ....................545, 688 Morrow v. Nadeem [1986] 1 W.L.R. 1381 C.A. ...........................................................................................27, 560, 580 Mortgage Corporation Ltd. v. Ubah (1997) 29 H.L.R. 489 C.A. ...............................................................................147
lvi
TABLE OF CASES
Morton v. Woods (1869) L.R. 4 Q.B. 293 Ex.Ch.........................................................................................................303 Moschi v. Lep Air Services Ltd. [1973] A.C. 331 H.L. ................................................................................................780 Mosley v. Cooper [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 124......................................................................................................................418 Mosley v. Hickman [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 161 C.A. .........................................................................................................406 Moss Bros. Group plc. v. C.S.C. Properties Ltd. [1999] E.G.C.S. 47, Neuberger J..............................................710, 733 Moss Empires Ltd. v. Olympia (Liverpool) Ltd. [1939] A.C. 544 H.L.......................................................681, 752, 768 Moss v. James (1878) 38 L.T. 595 C.A.........................................................................................................................601 Moss v. Mobil Oil Co. Ltd. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 71 C.A. ................................................................................................560 Moule v. Garrett (1872) L.R. 7 Exch. 101 Exch. Ch., affirming (1870) L.R. 5 Exch. 132........................777, 788, 789 Mount Cook Land Ltd. v. Hartley [2000] E.G.C.S. 08 Ch.D. .....................................................................................835 Mount Eden Land Ltd. v. Straudley Investments Ltd. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 306 C.A..................................................738 Mountain v. Hastings (1993) 25 H.L.R. 427 C.A. ..............................................................................................318, 337 Mountford v. Hodkinson [1956] 1 W.L.R. 422 C.A. ..................................................................................................616 Mountview Court Properties Ltd. v. Devlin (1970) 21 P. & C.R. 689 C.A..........................................................228, 231 Mucklow (A. & J.)(Birmingham) Ltd. v. Metro-Cammell Weymann [1994] E.G.C.S. 64 ........................................583 Muir Group Housing Association Ltd. v. Thornley (1992) 25 H.L.R. 89 C.A.............................................................503 Mularczyk v. Azralnove Investments Ltd. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 141 C.A. .......................................................................570 Mulholland’s W.T., Re [1949] 1 All E.R. 460..............................................................................................................536 Mullaney v. Maybourne Grange (Croydon) Management Co. Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 70 ................................457, 703 Muller v. Trafford [1901] 1 Ch. 54, Farwell J. ....................................................................537, 751, 752, 764, 765, 782 Mulligan v. Halton B.C. [1999] 12 C.L. 326 ...............................................................................................................259 Multiservice Bookbinding Ltd. v. Marden [1979] Ch. 84 ...........................................................................................638 Multon v. Cardell [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 44 ......................................................................................................................585 Mumford Hotels Ltd. v. Wheler [1964] Ch. 117 Ch.D........................................................................................688, 689 Mumford v. Walker (1901) 71 L.J.K.B. 19, Ridley J. .................................................................................................777 Mundy v. Hook [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 3247 C.Ct., (1998) 30 H.L.R. 551 C.A. ........................................................44, 47, 54 Mundy v. Joliffe (1839) 9 L.J.Ch. 95, 5 My. & Cr. 167 ...............................................................................................533 Munting v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3017 ............................................................................91 Murgatroyd v. Silkstone & Dodsworth Coal & Iron Co Ltd. ex parte Charlesworth (1895) 65 L.J.Ch. 111, Chitty J....................................................................................................................................524, 525 Murphy v. Hurly [1922] 1 A.C. 369 H.L. ...........................................................................................................253, 707 Murray v. Aslam (1994) 27 H.L.R. 284 C.A. ......................................................................................................313, 314 Murray v. Birmingham C.C. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 53 ....................................................................................................246 Murray v. Lloyd [1989] 1 W.L.R. 1060 ..............................................................................................................109, 169 Mustafa v. Ruddock (1998) 30 H.L.R. 495 C.A. .....................................................................................................47, 49 Mutual Place Property Management Ltd. v. Blaquiere [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 28 C.Ct. ...................................................443 Mykolyshyn v. Noah [1970] 1 W.L.R. 1271, [1971] 1 All E.R. 48 C.A. .....................................................................352 Mytre Investments Ltd. v. Reynolds [1995] 3 All E.R. 588 Q.B.D.......................................................................773, 786 N. & D. (London) Ltd. v. Gadson (1991) 24 H.L.R. 64, Auld J..................................................................................229 Nadeem,Re [1990] 1 W.L.R. 48 .................................................................................................................................829 Naish v. Curzon [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 117 C.A. ..............................................................................................................349 Nanda v. Nanda [1968] P. 351 ...................................................................................................................................131 Narcissi v. Wolfe [1960] Ch. 10, [1959] 3 All E.R. 71 ........................................................................................547–548 Narndean Estates Ltd. v. Buckland (1967) 111 S.J. 684 C.A. .....................................................................................817 National & Provincial B.S. v. U.K. (1998) 25 E.H.R.R. 127 E.Ct.H.R. ............................................200–204, 205, 638 National Car Parks Ltd. v. Paterposter Consortium Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 99, Browne-Wilkinson V.C. ...............567 National Carriers Ltd. v. Panalpina (Northern) Ltd. [1981] A.C. 675 H.L. ............................................714, 715–716 National Coal Board v. Naylor [1972] 1 W.L.R. 908 C.A. ........................................................................................625 National Deposit Friendly Society Trustees v. Beatties of London Ltd. [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 59, Goulding J. ..................................................................................................................536, 570 National Electric Theatres Ltd. v. Hudgell [1939] Ch. 553, Morton J. ......................................................................694 National Grid Co. plc. v. M25 Group Ltd. [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A.........................................................................661 National Jazz Centre,Re [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 57 Ch.D. .................................................................................................814 National Provincial Bank Ltd. v. Ainsworth [1965] A.C. 1175 H.L. ..........................................................................502 National Trust v. Knipe [1998] 1 W.L.R. 230 C.A. (leave to appeal refused: [1998] 1 W.L.R. 696 H.L.) .......................................................................................................26, 609, 610–611, 621 National Westminster Bank Ltd. v. Hart [1983] Q.B. 773 C.A. .........................................................................303, 566
TABLE OF CASES
lvii
National Westminster Bank plc. v. Arthur Young McClelland Moores [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 13 C.A.; (No.2) [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 141 .....................................................................................................................................................657, 664 Naumann v. Ford [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 70 ......................................................................................................................687 Neale v. Mackenzie (1836) 1 M. & W. 747, 150 E.R. 635...................................................................................305, 742 Nell Gwynn House Maintenance Fund v. Commissioners of Customs & Excise (1996) 72 P. & C.R. 522 C.A. 458, 703 Nelson Developments Ltd. v. Toboada [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 107 C.A.....................................................................159, 161 Nesbitt v. Meyer (1818) 1 Swanst. 223, 226, 36 E.R. 366 ..................................................................................533, 534 Nessa v. Chief Adjudication Officer [1999] 4 All E.R. 677 H.L.....................................................................................93 Network H.Ass. v. Westminster C.C. (1995) 27 H.L.R. 189 Q.B.D. ...................................................................267, 719 Never-Stop Rly (Wembley) Ltd. v. British Empire Exhibition (1924) Inc. [1926] Ch. 877, Lawrence J. ..................696 Neville Long & Co. (Boards) Ltd. v. Firemanaich [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 76 C.A. ..........................305, 544, 560, 588, 758 Neville Russell v. Customs & Excise [1987] V.A.T.T.R. 194 .......................................................................................643 New England Properties Ltd. v. Portsmouth New Shops Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 84 ...................................457, 677, 703 New Hart Builders Ltd. v. Brindley [1975] Ch. 342, Goulding J. ................................................23, 588, 589, 591, 592 New Zealand Government Property Corporation v. H.M.& S. Ltd. [1982] Q.B. 1145 C.A. .....................603, 699, 700 Newbolt v. Bingham (1895) 72 L.T. 852 C.A. .............................................................................................818, 824, 826 Newborough v. Jones [1975] Ch. 90 C.A. ...................................................................................................................592 Newcastle-upon-Tyne C.C. v. Morrison [2000] L. & T.R. 333 C.A. ..........................................................................333 Newey & Eyre v. J. Curtis & Son Ltd. [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 105 Ch.D............................................................................662 Newham L.B.C. v. Patel (1978) 12 H.L.R. 77 C.A. ....................................................................................................246 Newham L.B.C. v. Phillips (1998) 30 H.L.R. 859 C.A. .......................................................................................122, 128 Newlon Housing Trust v. Alsulaimen [1999] 1 A.C. 313 H.L.; [1997] 1 F.L.R. 914 C.A...............17, 21, 23, 129, 137 Newman v. Kay [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 237 L.V.T.....................................................................................................429, 431 Newman v. Keedwell (1977) 35 P. & C.R. 393............................................................................................126, 617, 834 Nicholaou v. Pitt [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 84 C.A. ..............................................................................................................153 Nicholls v. Kinsey [1994] Q.B. 600 C.A...............................................................................................................556, 558 Nicholls v. Wimbledon V.O. [1995] R.V.R. 171 .........................................................................................................182 Nickells v. Atherstone (1847) 10 Q.B.D. 944, 116 E.R. 358. .......................................................................................600 Niemietz v. Germany (1992) 16 E.H.R.R. 97 .............................................................................................................638 Nightingale v. Courtney [1954] 1 Q.B. 399 C.A..........................................................................................................596 Nijar v. Mann (2000) 32 H.L.R. 223 C.A. .........................................................................................................306–307 Nind v. Nineteenth Century B.S. [1894] Q.B. 226 C.A. .....................................................................................801, 826 Nisbet & Potts’ C.,Re [1905] 1 Ch. 391, [1906] 1 Ch. 386 C.A. ................................................................................751 No.1 London Ltd.,Re [1991] B.C.L.C. 501, Hoffmann J. ...........................................................................................787 Noble v. South Herefordshire D.C. (1983) 17 H.L.R. 80 C.A. ......................................................................................73 Nock v. Muck [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 100 ..........................................................................................................................241 Nocton Ltd. v. Walter Hall Group plc. [1997] E.G.C.S. 97 Ch.D. .............................................................................582 Nokes v. Gibbon (1856) 26 L.J.Ch. 433 ......................................................................................................................687 Nolan v. Eagle Wharf Developments Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 223 L.V.T. ...........................................................428, 431 Nolan v. Leeds C.C. (1990) 23 H.L.R. 135 C.A. .........................................................................................................273 Norfolk Capital Group Ltd. v. Kitway Ltd. [1977] 1 Q.B. 506 C.A. ..................................................................396, 738 Normanton v. Giles [1980] 1 W.L.R. 28 H.L. ............................................................................................188, 606, 607 Norris v. Checksfield [1991] 1 W.L.R. 1241 C.A ...................................................................................................26, 185 North British H.Ass. Ltd. v. Sheridan (2000) 32 H.L.R. 346 C.A. ..............................................................................318 Northampton B.C. v. Lovatt (1998) 30 H.L.R. 875 C.A. ............................................................................................342 Northchurch Estates Ltd. v. Daniels [1947] Ch. 117 ..................................................................................................535 Northern Electric plc. v. Addison [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 111 C.A. ............................................................566, 568, 655, 662 Northern Ireland Housing Executive v. McCann [1979] N.I. 39 ................................................................................177 Northumberland & Durham Property Trust Ltd. v. London R.A.C. [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 85, Keene J. ................228, 231 Northumberland Avenue Hotel Company Ltd. Re, Sully’s case (1885) 54 L.T. 76, 79 ...............................................530 Northway Flats Management Co. (Camden) Ltd. v. Wimpey Pension Trustees Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 42 C.A.................................................................................................................................457, 703 Norval v. Pascoe (1864) 34 L.J. Ch. 82. .......................................................................................................................759 Norwich C.C. v. Billings (1997) 29 H.L.R. 679 C.A. ...................................................................................................272 Norwich Union Life Insurance Society v. A.G. [1995] E.G.C.S. 85 P.C......................................................................659 Norwich Union Life Insurance Society v. British Railways Board [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 137, Hoffmann J. ...........665, 679 Norwich Union Life Insurance Society v. Low Profile Fashions Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 86 C.A. ................................788 Norwich Union Life Insurance Society v. Shopmoor Ltd. [1999] 1 W.L.R. 531, [1997] 2 All E.R. 32, Scott V.C. .............................................................................................................732, 733, 738
lviii
TABLE OF CASES
Norwich Union Life Insurance Society v. Trustee Savings Banks Central Board [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 136 ...................664 Notting Hill Housing Trust v. Rakey Jones [1999] L. & T.R. 397 C.A........................................................................139 Nozari-Zadeh v. Pearl Assurance plc. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 91 C.A. ...............................................................................547 Nunn v. Dalrymple (1989) 21 H.L.R. 569 C.A. .........................................................................................................172 Nunn v. Truscott (1849) 3 De G. & Sm. 304, 64 E.R. 490..........................................................................................531 Nurdin & Peacock plc. v. D.B. Ramsden & Co. Ltd. (No.1) [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 119, (No.2) [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 15, Neuberger J..................................................................................................219, 520, 653, 721 Nursey v. P. Currie (Dartford) Ltd. [1959] 1 W.L.R. 273 C.A. ..........................................................................547, 571 Nutt v. Read [1999] Times December 3rd C.A. ..................................................................................55, 179, 312, 347 Nwokorie v. Mason (1994) 26 H.L.R. 60 C.A. ............................................................................................................315 Nynehead Developments Ltd. v. R.H. Fibreboard Containers Ltd. [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 7 Ch.D. ..............258, 691, 719 Oak Property Co. Ltd. v. Chapman [1947] K.B. 886 ..................................................................................................290 Oakacre Ltd. v. Claire Cleaners (Holdings) Ltd. [1982] Ch. 197 ................................................................................529 Oakeley v. Ramsay (1872) 27 L.T. 745........................................................................................................................533 Oakley v. Martin [1993] 06 E.G. 113 L.Tr. ........................................................................................................454, 754 Oak Pits Colliery Co.,Re (1882) 21 Ch.D. 322 C.A. ..................................................................................................772 Oastler v. Henderson (1877) 2 Q.B.D. 575 C.A. .....................................................................................39, 40, 600, 601 O’Brien v. Robinson [1973] A.C. 912 H.L...........................................................................................................252, 253 Ocean Accident & Guarantee Corporation v. Next plc. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 84 Ch.D. .................................................665 Oceanic Village Ltd. v. United Attractions Ltd. [2000] Ch. 234, Neuberger J. .........................................................................711, 712, 745, 747, 748, 757, 770, 771 O’Cedar Ltd. v. Slough Trading Co. Ltd. [1927] 2 K.B. 123 ..............................................................................686, 718 Odunsi v. Brent L.B.C. [1999] 06 C.L. 348. ..................................................................................................................83 Official Custodian for Charities v. Goldridge (1973) 26 P. & C.R. 191 C.A. ..............................................................403 Official Custodian of Charities v. Mackey [1985] Ch. 168, Scott J. (No. 2) [1985] 1 W.L.R. 1308, Nourse J. ............................................................................................................807, 825, 835 Official Custodian of Charities v. Parway Estates Developments Ltd. [1985] Ch. 157 C.A. ...................813, 830, 835 Official Receiver v. Environment Agency [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 21 C.A. .........................................................................773 Official Solicitor v. Thomas [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A..................................................................................................644 Official Trustee of Charity Lands v. Ferriman Trust Ltd. [1937] 3 All E.R. 85 ..................................................724, 751 Ogwr B.C. v. Dykes [1989] 1 W.L.R. 295 C.A.............................................................................................................177 Old Gate Estates Ltd. v. Alexander [1950] 1 K.B. 311 C.A. ..........................................................................40, 132, 601 Old Grovebury Manor Farm Ltd. v. W. Seymour Plant Sales & Hire Ltd. [1979] 1 W.L.R. 263 C.A., (No. 2) [1979] 1 W.L.R. 1397 C.A. ......................................................................................................................589, 796, 799 Oliver & Son Ltd., Re [1999] S.L.T. 1039....................................................................................................................592 Oliver Ashworth (Holdings) Ltd. v. Ballard (Kent) Ltd. [2000] Ch. 12 C.A., [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 60 Ch.D. reversed .............................................................................213, 580, 640–641, 812–813 Olympia & York Canary Wharf Ltd. v. Oil Property Investments Ltd. [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 48 C.A. (No.2) [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 48 C.A. ...............................................................................................258, 532, 583, 691, 738, 830 O’Malley v. O’Malley [1982] 1 W.L.R. 244 C.A. .......................................................................................................132 O’Malley v. Seymour [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 116 C.A........................................................................................................153 Omar Parks Ltd. v. Elkington [1992] 1 W.L.R. 1270 C.A. .........................................................................................181 O’May v. City of London Real Property Co. [1983] 2 A.C. 726 H.L. ................................539, 544, 568, 639, 656, 671 Omnivale v. Boldan [1994] E.G.C.S. 63 C.A. .....................................................................................................622, 627 On Demand Information plc. v. Michael Gerson (Finance) plc. [1999] 2 All E.R. 811 ..............................................826 Onslow v. Corrie (1817) 2 Madd. 330, 56 E.R. 357, Plumer V.C.......................................................................760, 761 Onyx (U.K.) Ltd. v. Beard [1996] E.G.C.S. 55 Ch.D....................................................................25, 515, 552, 554–555 Optilon Ltd. v. Commission for New Towns [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 89. ............................................................................676 Orchid Lodge (U.K.) Ltd. v. Extel Computing Ltd. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 116 C.A. ...............................................665–666 Orgee v. Orgee [1997] E.G.C.S. 152 C.A. .............................................................................................................34, 520 Orgill v. Kemshead (1812) 4 Taunt. 642, 128 E.R. 407 ..............................................................................................788 Orlando Investments Ltd. v. Grosvenor Estate Belgravia (1990) 59 P. & C.R. 21 C.A. ..............................735, 737, 740 Orlik (G.)(Meat Products) Ltd. v. Hastings & Thanet B.S. (1974) 29 P. & C.R. 126 C.A. ........................560, 563, 567 O’Rourke v. Camden L.B.C. [1998] A.C. 188 H.L. ......................................................................................................89 Ortiz v. Westminster C.C. (1995) 27 H.L.R. 364 C.A. .................................................................................................73 Osei–Bonsu v. Wandsworth L.B.C. [1999] 1 W.L.R. 1011, [1999] 1 All E.R. 265 C.A........................................................................................................107, 127, 130, 312, 314 Otter v. Norman [1989] A.C. 129 H.L. .............................................................................................................160–161
TABLE OF CASES
lix
Ove Arup Inc. v. Howland Property Investment Co. Ltd. [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 62 ........................................................574 Overland Shoes Ltd. v. Shenkers Ltd. [1998] 1 Lloyd’s Rep. 498 C.A.........................................................................648 Overton v. Sydal (1597) Cro. Eliz. 555, 78 E.R. 801 ...................................................................................................761 Owen Owen Estate Ltd. v. Livett [1956] Ch. 1 ...........................................................................................................695 Owen v. Gadd [1956] 2 Q.B. 99 C.A. .................................................................................................................310, 717 Oxford’s Earl of case, Re (1615) 1 Ch.Rep. 1 pl.49, 21 E.R. 485.................................................................................522 Oxley v. James (1844) 13 M. & W. 209, 153 E.R. 87 ..................................................................................................725 Ozer Properties Ltd. v. Ghaydi [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 91 .................................................................................................312 P. & O. Property Holdings Ltd. v. International Computers Ltd. [2000] 2 All E.R. 1015, [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 17, Neuberger J. ................................................................................................222, 369, 654, 689 Padbury v. York [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 3 ...........................................................................................................................613 Paddington Churches H.Ass. Ltd. v. Sharif (1997) 29 H.L.R. 817 C.A. .....................................................................338 Paddock Investments Ltd. v. Lory [1975] 2 E.G.L.R. 5 C.A. .......................................................................................626 Page v. Bennett (1860) 2 Giff. 117, 66 E.R. 50 ....................................................................................................686, 819 Page,Re (1884) 14 Q.B.D. 401.....................................................................................................................................772 Pahl v. Trevor [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 22 C.A.....................................................................................................................615 Pain v. Coombs (1857) 1 De G. & J. 34, 44 E.R. 634 ..........................................................................................531, 533 Pakwood Transport Ltd. v. 15 Beauchamp Place Ltd. (1977) 36 P. & C.R. 112 C.A. .....................741, 799, 813, 819 Palethorpe v. Home Brewery Co. [1906] 2 K.B. 5........................................................................................................777 Palisade Entertainments Ltd. v. Collin Estates Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 94 C.A. ..........................................................571 Palmeira Properties Ltd. v. Bennett [1995] C.L.Y. 3037 C.A. ....................................................................................335 Palmeiro, Re [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 27 ..............................................................................................................................810 Palmer v. Edwards (1783) 1 Doug. 187, 99 E.R. 122n ...............................................................................................726 Palmer v. McNamara [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 121 ..............................................................................................................163 Palmer v. Sandwell M.B.C. [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 79 C.A. .............................................................................248, 279, 679 Palser v. Grinling [1948] A.C. 291 H.L. ..............................................................................................................160, 161 Panalpina see National Carriers Panayi v. Roberts (1993) 25 H.L.R. 421 C.A. ...................................................................................................27, 47, 48 Pannell v. City of London Brewery Co. [1900] 1 Ch. 496 ...........................................................................................798 Panther Lead Co.,Re [1896] 1 Ch. 978........................................................................................................................601 Paradine v. Jane (1647) Aleyn 26, 82 E.R. 897 ..................................................................................264, 677, 689, 713 Paramour v. Yardley (1579) 2 Plowd. 539, 75 E.R. 794 ............................................................................................602 Parc (Battersea) Ltd. v. Hutchinson [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 33, Moore-Bick J. ......................294, 551, 556–557, 724, 725 Park Air Services plc., Re [1999] 1 All E.R. 673 H.L., reversing [1997] 3 All E.R. 193 C.A........................................................................................................640, 646, 774, 829, 830 Parker v. Boggon [1947] K.B. 346................................................................................................................................736 Parker v. Jones [1910] 2 K.B. 32 .........................................................................................................................229, 603 Parker v. O’Connor [1974] 1 W.L.R. 1160 C.A. ........................................................................................................244 Parker v. Taswell (1858) 2 De G. & J. 559, 44 E.R. 1106 ..........................................................................520, 521, 531 Parker v. Webb (1693) 3 Salk. 5, 91 E.R. 656......................................................................................................766, 782 Parkes v. S.S. for the Environment [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1308 C.A. ..................................................................................708 Parkes v. Westminster R.C. Diocese Trust [1978] 2 E.G.L.R. 50 C.A. ........................................................................571 Parkins v. Westminster C.C.(1998) 30 H.L.R. 894 C.A. ...........................................................146, 150, 156, 171, 186 Parkside Clubs (Nottingham) Ltd. v. Armgrade Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 96 C.A. ......................................................666 Parkside Knightsbridge Ltd. v. German Food Centre Ltd. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 265 Ch.D. ...........................................661 Parkus v. Greenwood [1950] 1 Ch. 644 C.A................................................................................................................535 Parmenter v. Webber (1818) 8 Taunt. 593, 129 E.R. 515 ...........................................................................................726 Parrish v. Kinsey [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 13 C.A. ...............................................................................................................624 Parry v. Geldard (1999) 77 P & C.R., 440 C.A. ..........................................................................................................536 Parry v. Million Pigs Ltd. [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 1, Ewbank J. .........................................................................................617 Parsons v. Gage [1974] 1 W.L.R. 435 H.L. .................................................................................................399, 400, 404 Parsons v. Parsons [1983] 1 W.L.R. 1390 ...................................................................................................................617 Parway Estates see Official Custodian of Charities Pascall v. Galinski [1970] 1 Q.B. 38 C.A.....................................................................................................................823 Pascoe v. Pascoe (1837) 3 Bing. N.C. 898, 132 E.R. 656 .............................................................................................726 Passley v. Wandsworth L.B.C. (1996) 30 H.L.R. 165 C.A. .........................................................................253, 707, 713 Passmore v. Morland plc. [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 51 C.A. ..................................................................................................713 Patel v. Ali [1984] Ch. 283 C.A. ..................................................................................................................................527
lx
TABLE OF CASES
Patel v. Patel [1981] 1 W.L.R. 1342 C.A. ....................................................................................................................350 Patel v. Peel Investments (South) Ltd. [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 116, Morritt J....................................................................658 Paterson v. Aggio (1987) 19 H.L.R. 551 C.A. .........................................................................................20, 44, 115, 346 Patoner Ltd. v. Alexandrakis [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 124 C.A. ..........................................................................................297 Patoner Ltd. v. Lowe [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 155 ...............................................................................................................297 Paul v. Nurse (1828) 8 B. & C. 486, 108 E.R. 1123.............................................................................................296, 751 Pawson v. Revell [1958] 2 Q.B. 360 C.A. ....................................................................................................................566 Paxton v. Newton (1854) 2 Sm. & G. 437, 440, 65 E.R. 470 ......................................................................................531 Payne v. Barnet L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 295 C.A. .....................................................................................................498 Payne v. Haine (1847) 16 M. & W. 541, 153 E.R. 1304 .....................................................................................675, 676 Pazgate Ltd. v. McGrath (1984) 17 H.L.R. 127 C.A. ..................................................................................................298 Peabody Donation Fund Governors v. Grant [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 37 C.A. ..........................................................116, 120 Peabody Donation Fund Governors v. Hay (1986) 19 H.L.R. 145 C.A. ...................................................................332, Peabody Donation Fund Governors v. Higgins [1983] 1 W.L.R. 1091 C.A. ...............................................122, 286, 287 Peachey Property Corp. Ltd. v. Robinson [1967] 2 Q.B. 543 C.A. .............................................................................337 Peacock v. Penson (1848) 11 Beav. 355, 50 E.R. 854...................................................................................................531 Pearlman v Harrow School [1979] Q.B. 56 C.A. ........................................................................................404, 456, 702 Pearshouse v. Birmingham C.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 756, 768...............................................................................266, 269 Pearson v. Alyo [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 114 C.A.................................................................................................................560 Pearson v. Franklin [1994] 1 W.L.R. 370 C.A. ...........................................................................................................139 Pearson v. Gee [1934] A.C. 272 H.L. ..........................................................................................................................830 Peck v. Anicar Properties Ltd. [1971] 1 All E.R. 517 C.A....................................................................................399, 400 Peckham Mutual B.S. v. Registe (1981) 42 P. & C.R. 186, Vinelott J...........................................................................26 Pelham’s case (1590) 1 Co.Rep. 14b, 76 E.R. 31 .........................................................................................................831 Pellatt v. Boosey (1862) 31 L.J. C.P. 281. ....................................................................................................................814 Pelosi v. Newcastle Arms Brewery (Nottingham) Ltd. [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 36 C.A.......................................................695 Pemberton v. Southwark L.B.C. [2000] 3 All E.R. 924, [2000] 21 E.G. 135 C.A. .............................................207, 333 Pembery v. Lamdin [1940] 2 All E.R. 434 ..........................................................................................................249, 680 Peninsular Maritime Ltd. v. Padseal [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 43 C.A..................................................................................806 Pennell v. Payne [1995] Q.B. 192 C.A. ................................................................................21, 300, 511, 602, 619, 725 Penniall v. Harborne (1848) 11 Q.B. 368, 116 E.R. 514 .....................................................................................686–688 Penton v. Barnett [1898] 1 Q.B. 276 C.A. ...........................................................................................................798, 813 Penton v. Robart (1801) 2 East. 88, 102 E.R. 302 ...............................................................................................699, 700 Perera v. Vandiyar [1953] 1 W.L.R. 672 C.A. ............................................................................................310, 315, 717 Perkins,Re [1898] 2 Ch. 182 C.A. ...............................................................................................................................791 Perry v. Davis (1858) 3 C.B. (N.S.) 769, 140 E.R. 945 ...............................................................................................814 Perry v. Sharon Development Co. Ltd. [1937] 4 All E.R. 390 C.A. .....................................................................251, 690 Perseus Property Co. Ltd. v. Burberry [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 114, Nolan J.......................................................................234 Persey v. Bazley [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 3 C.A. ..................................................................................................610, 627, 758 Pertemps Group Ltd. v. Crosher & James [1999] 07 C.L. 325 ....................................................................................801 Peter Goddard & Sons Ltd. v. Hounslow L.B.C. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 281 C.A. .............................................................571 Peters v. Prince of Wales Theatre (Birmingham) Ltd. [1943] K.B. 73 C.A. ...............................................................245 Pettiward Estates Ltd. v. Shephard [1986] C.L.Y. 1861 C.Ct.. ...................................................................................754 Peyman v. Lanjani [1985] Ch. 457 C.A. ....................................................................................................................812 Phene v. Popplewell (1862) 12 C.B.N.S. 334, 142 E.R. 1171 ......................................................................................601 Philipson-Stow v. Trevor Square Ltd. [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 56, Goulding J. .................................................................561 Phillips v. Lamdin [1949] 2 K.B. 33 ............................................................................................................................697 Phillips v. Mobil Oil Co. Ltd. [1989] 1 W.L.R. 888 C.A..............................................................................................538 Phillips v. Price [1959] Ch. 181, Harman J. ................................................................................................683, 802, 803 Phillips v. Radnor D.C. [1998] E.G.C.S. 30 C.A. ........................................................................................................690 Phipos v. Callegari (1910) 54 S.J. 635, Warrington J..................................................................................................619 Phipps (P.) & Co. (Northampton & Towcester Brewers) Ltd. v. Rogers [1925] 1 K.B. 14 C.A. .................................585 Phipps-Faire Ltd. v. Malbern Construction Ltd. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 129, Warner J. ...................................................659 Pierson v. Harvey (1888) 1 T.L.R. 430 ........................................................................................................................814 Piggott v. Middlesex C.C. [1909] 1 Ch. 134 ................................................................................................................759 Piggott v. Stratton (1859) 1 De G.F. & J. 33, 45 E.R. 271 ...........................................................................................603 Pike v. Eyre (1829) 9 B. & C. 909, 109 E.R. 338..........................................................................................................725 Pimms Ltd. v. Tallow Chandler Co. [1964] 2 Q.B. 547 .....................................................................292, 734, 738, 739 Pinemain Ltd. v. Welbeck International Ltd. [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 91 ............................................................................783
TABLE OF CASES
lxi
Pinero v. Judson (1829) 6 Bing. 206, 130 E.R. 1259. ............................................................................................24, 515 Pinkerton v. Pinkerton [1986] S.L.T. 672 H.L.............................................................................................................595 Piper v. Muggleton [1956] 2 Q.B. 569 C.A..................................................................................................................565 Pips (Leisure Productions) Ltd. v. Walton [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 172 ..............................................................................806 Pistor v. Cater (1842) 9 M. & W. 315, 152 E.R. 134; ...........................................................................................24, 515 Pitcher v. Tovey (1692) 4 Mod. Rep. 71, 87 E.R. 268 .................................................................................................761 Pittalis v. Grant [1989] Q.B. 605 C.A. ................................................................................................................300, 301 Pivot Properties Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment (1979) 39 P. & C.R. 386, Phillips J., on appeal [1980] 2 E.G.L.R. 126 C.A.......................................................................................................................................664 Platt v. Parker (1886) 2 T.L.R. 786 C.A. ....................................................................................................................812 Platts (Fred) Co. Ltd. v. Grigor (1950) 66 T.L.R. 859 C.A..........................................................................................341 Pleasant d. Hayton v. Benson (1811) 14 East. 234, 104 E.R. 590 ......................................................................299, 603 Pleasurama Properties v. Leisure Investments (West End) Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 145 C.A. .....................................665 Pledge & Sons v. Pomfret (1905) 74 L.J.Ch. 357, Joyce J. ..................................................................................304, 750 Plesser (A.) & Co. Ltd. v. Davis [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 70, French J.................................................................................781 Plews v. Samuel [1904] 1 Ch. 464, Kekewich J. ..........................................................................................................527 Plinth Property Investment Co. Ltd. v. Mott, Hay & Anderson [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 17 C.A. ......................................665 Plough Investments Ltd v. Manchester C.C. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 244............................................................................680 Pluck v. Digges (1831) 5 Bli. N.S. 31, 5 E.R. 219 H.L. ...............................................................................................726 Plummer & John v. David [1920] 1 K.B. 326, Lush J. 326 (19) ................................................................305, 602, 760 Plummer v. Ramsey (1934) 78 S.J. 175. ......................................................................................................................681 Plummer v. Tibsco Ltd. [1999] 47 L.S.G. 32, Neuberger J..........................................................................................713 Plumrose Ltd. v. Real & Leasehold Estates Investment Society Ltd. [1970] 1 W.L.R. 52. ..................................535, 536 Plymouth C.C. v. Tollbench Ltd. (1988) 152 L.G.Rev. 809 C.A. ...............................................................................737 Plymouth Corporation v. Harvey [1971] 1 W.L.R. 549, Plowman J. ................................................................599, 797 Pocklington (Thomas)’s Gift Trustees v. Hill (1989) 21 H.L.R. 391 C.A..................................110, 123, 236, 289, 293 Pocock v. Carter [1912] 1. Ch. 663 ..............................................................................................................................512 Pocock v. Steel [1985] 1 W.L.R. 229 C.A. ...................................................................................................................349 Poland v. Cadogan [1980] 3 All E.R. 544 C.A. ...........................................................................................107, 396, 397 Pole-Carew v. Western Counties & General Manure Co. [1920] 2 Ch. 97 C.A. ...............................38, 599, 699, 700 Pollock v. Brook-Shepherd (1983) 45 P. & C.R. 357 C.A. ...........................................................................................404 Pollway Nominees Ltd. v. Croydon L.B.C. [1987] A.C. 79 H.L. .................................................................................271 Polyviou v. Seeley [1980] 1 W.L.R. 55 C.A. ................................................................................................................562 Pomfret v. Ricroft (1671) 1 Wms. Saunds. 321, 85 E.R. 462.............................................................................263, 673 Ponderosa International Development Inc. v. Pengap Securities (Bristol) Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 66, Warner J. .............................................................................................................................735 Ponsford v. H.M.S. Aerosols Ltd. [1979] A.C. 63 H.L. ........................................................................661, 662, 663, 665 Poole & Clarke’s C.,Re [1904] 2 Ch. 173 C.A. ...........................................................................................................790 Poole B.C. v. Carruthers [1994] Independent January 20th. .....................................................................................341 Poole’s case,(1703) 1 Salk. 368, 91 E.R. 320................................................................................................................699 Poppet’s (H.)(Caterers) Ltd. v. Maidenhead B.C. [1971] 1 W.L.R. 69 C.A. ..............................................................351 Port v. Griffith [1938] 1 All E.R. 295 C.A. ..................................................................................................................718 Portavon Cinema Co Ltd. v. Price & Century Insurance Co Ltd. [1939] 4 All E.R. 601 ............................................687 Porter v. Magill (1999) 31 H.L.R. 823 C.A. ..................................................................................................................86 Portman Registrars v. Latif [1987] C.L.Y. 2239. .........................................................................................................121 Portman v. Lattan [1942] W.N. 97 .............................................................................................................................681 Posner v. Scott-Lewis [1987] Ch. 25 ............................................................................................................................684 Post Office Counters Ltd. v. Harlow D.C. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 121 ...............................................................................666 Post Office v. Aquarius Properties Ltd. [1987] 1 All E.R. 1055 C.A. ..........................................................................679 Postel Properties Ltd. v. Boots the Chemist Ltd. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 60, Ian Kennedy J. .....................................458, 703 PosTel Properties Ltd. v. Greenwell [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 130 Ch.D. ......................................................................660, 665 Poster v. Slough Estates Ltd. [1964] 1 Ch. 495, Cross J. .............................................................................371, 547, 700 Potsos v. Theodotou (1991) 23 H.L.R. 356 C.A. .........................................................................................................350 Potts v. Hickman [1941] A.C. 212 C.A. ..............................................................................................................220, 650 Poultney v. Holmes (1720) 1 Strange 405, 93 E.R. 596...............................................................................................726 Pourdanay v. Barclays Bank plc. [1997] Ch. 321 Ch.D. (also Zaroovabli). .........................................................36, 507 Powell v. U.K. (1985) 9 E.H.R.R. 241 ........................................................................................................................201 Powley v. Walker (1793) 5 T.R. 373, 101 E.R. 208 .............................................................................................262, 674 Poyntz v. Fortune (1859) 27 Beav. 393, 112 E.R. 1106 .......................................................................................531, 533
lxii
TABLE OF CASES
Preece v. Corrie (1828) 5 Bing. 24, 130 E.R. 968. .......................................................................................................726 Premier Confectionery (London) Co. Ltd. v. London Commercial Sale Rooms Ltd. [1933] Ch. 904 ................736, 739 Premier Dairies Ltd v. Garlick [1920] 2 Ch. 17 ..................................................................................................630, 700 Presson Plus plc. v. Lancaster [1997] E.G.C.S. 42 C.A. ......................................................................................221, 644 Preston B.C. v. Fairclough (1983) 8 H.L.R. 70 C.A...............................................................................................39, 600 Price v. Evans (1874) 29 L.T. 835 ................................................................................................................................758 Price v. Romilly [1960] 1 W.L.R. 1360, Diplock J. ....................................................................................................623 Price v. Strange [1978] Ch. 337, Goff J. ..............................................................................................................528, 684 Price v. Worwood (1859) 4 H. & N. 512, 157 E.R. 941...............................................................................................686 Priceland Ltd.,Re [1996] E.G.C.S. 188 Ch.D. ............................................................................................................775 Prichard v. Bishop (1975) 31 P. & C.R. 108 C.A.........................................................................................................589 Pridean Ltd. v. Forest Taverns Ltd. (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 447 C.A. .......................................................................34, 520 Primeridge Ltd. v. Jean Muir Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 273 ...........................................................................................705 Prince v. Robinson (1999) 31 H.L.R. 89 C.A. .......................................................................................36, 105, 108, 241 Prior,Re (1927) 43 T.L.R. 784, Roche J. ....................................................................................................................188 Pritchard v. Briggs [1980] Ch. 338 C.A. .....................................................................................................................537 Progressive Mailing House Pty v. Tabali Pty (1985) 157 C.L.R. 17 H.Ct. Aust. ...............................................221, 647 Proma Ltd. v. Curtis [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 117 C.A.........................................................................................................390 Property & Bloodstock Ltd. v. Emerton [1968] Ch. 94 C.A.........................................................................302, 530, 730 Proudfoot v. Hart (1890) 25 Q.B.D. 42 C.A...............................................................................................245, 675, 676 Proudreed Ltd. v. Microgen Holdings plc. [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 89 C.A. ..................................................................39, 600 Provident Mutual Life Assurance Association v. Greater London Employers Association [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 106, Lightman J. ........................................................................................................................587 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. 99 Bishopsgate Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 Ch.D. ..................................................661 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Grand Metropolitan Estate Ltd. [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 153 C.A..................................664 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Gray [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 134 ....................................................................................661 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A., reversed by H.L. [1992] 2 A.C. 386 H.L. ...................................................................19, 22, 24, 25, 512, 513, 514, 515–517, 584, 769 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mount Eden Land Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 37 C.A. ........................................694, 740 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Salisbury Handbags Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 153, Chadwick J................................664 Prudential Property Services Ltd. v. Capital Land Holdings Ltd. [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 128 Ch.D. ................................658 Puhlhofer v. Hillingdon L.B.C. [1986] A.C. 484 H.L. ...................................................................................................82 Pulleng v. Curran (1980) 44 P. & C.R. 58 C.A....................................................................................................550, 551 Purchase v. Lichfield Brewery Co. [1915] 1 K.B. 184 Div.Ct.......................................................................................756 Purser v. Bailey [1967] 2 Q.B. 500 C.A. .....................................................................................................................625 Pwllbach Colliery Co. Ltd. v. Woodman [1915] A.C. 634 H.L. ..................................................................................718 Pym v. Blackburn (1796) 3 Ves. 34, 30 E.R. 878.........................................................................................................689 Pyot v. St John (1613) Cro. Jac. 329, 79 E.R. 281 ...............................................................................................261, 672 Quadrant Visual Communications Ltd. v. Hutchinson Telephone (U.K.) Ltd. [1993] B.C.L.C. 442 C.A. ...............648 Queen’s College Oxford v. Hallett (1811) 14 East. 489, 104 E.R. 689. .......................................................................692 Queensway H.Ass. Ltd. v. Chiltern Thames & Eastern R.A.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 945, Richards J. ...............................................................................................................230–231, 232, 239 Queensway Marketing Ltd. v. Associated Restaurants Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 49 C.A. ..............................................720 Quennell v. Maltby [1979] 1 W.L.R. 318 C.A.............................................................................................................306 Quick v. Taff Ely B.C. [1986] Q.B. 809 C.A. .....................................................................................247, 248, 250, 679 Quigley v. Liverpool H.T. [1999] E.G.C.S. 94, Sedley J. .............................................................................................270 Quilter v. Mapleson (1882) 9 Q.B.D. 672 C.A. ...................................................................................................818–819 Quinlan v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. [1989] R.A. 43 C.A. .............................................................220, 650, 651 R. v. A.M.K. (Property Management) Ltd. [1985] Crim. L.R. 600 C.A ....................................................................316 R. v. Agricultural Dwelling-Houses Advisory Committee ex parte Brough (1987) 19 H.L.R. 367, Hodgson J. .........191 R. v. Agricultural Land Tribunal ex parte Parslow [1979] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 Div.Ct. .......................................................622 R. v. Ahmad (1986) 18 H.L.R. 416 C.A. .....................................................................................................................316 R. v. Barking & Dagenham L.B.C. ex parte Okuneye (1996) 28 H.L.R. 174 Q.B.D.....................................................81 R. v. Barnet L.B.C. ex parte Babalola (1996) 28 H.L.R. 196 Q.B.D. ..........................................................................342 R. v. Barnet L.B.C. ex parte Foran (1999) 31 H.L.R. 708 .......................................................................................68, 76 R. v. Birmingham C.C. ex parte Taj Mohammed (1999) 31 H.L.R. 392 ....................................................................275 R. v. Bloomsbury & Marylebone C.C. ex parte Blackburne [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 157 C.A...............................................41
TABLE OF CASES
lxiii
R. v. Braintree D.C. ex parte Halls [1999] Times July 21st, Jackson J., reversed [2000] Times March 1st C.A.......500 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Awua [1996] A.C. 55 H.L. ..................................................................69, 74, 78–80, 81, 82 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Barise (1999) 31 H.L.R. 50 C.A..........................................................................................79 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Blatt (1991) 24 H.L.R. 319 Div.Ct. .................................................................................113 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte D. (1998) 1 C.C.L.R. 234, Moses J. ....................................................................................97 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Grossett (1996) 28 H.L.R. 9 C.A. .......................................................................................83 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Miyanger (1997) 29 H.L.R. 628..............................................................................67, 85, 87 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Morris (1998) 30 H.L.R. 324 C.A. ...................................................................................279 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte O’Connor (1999) 31 H.L.R. 923, Tucker J. .......................................................................88 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte O’Malley (1998) 30 H.L.R. 328 C.A.................................................................................280 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Omar (1991) 23 H.L.R. 466. ...........................................................................................345 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte S. [1994] 1 F.L.R. 203 C.A. ................................................................................................76 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Sadiq [2000] Times July 27th, Moses J. ............................................................................74 R. v. Brent L.B.C. ex parte Yusuf (1997) 29 H.L.R. 48, Turner J..................................................................................73 R. v. Brighton & Hove B.C. ex parte Harvey (1998) 30 H.L.R. 670 Div.Ct..................................................................80 R. v. Brighton & Hove B.C. ex parte Nacia (1999) 31 H.L.R. 1095 C.A. .....................................................................68 R. v. Bristol C.C. ex parte Bailey (1995) 27 H.L.R. 307, Hidden J. ............................................................................275 R. v. Bristol C.C. ex parte Bradic (1995) 27 H.L.R. 584 C.A. ......................................................................................73 R. v. Bristol C.C. ex parte Everett [1999] 2 All E.R. 193 C.A. ............................................................................267, 268 R. v. Bristol C.C. ex parte Jacobs [1999] Times November 16th, Owen J. .........................................................218, 239 R. v. Bristol C.C. ex parte Johns (1992) 25 H.L.R. 249, Otton J. ............................................................................72, 81 R. v. Bristol Corporation ex parte Hendy [1974] 1 W.L.R. 498 C.A. ..........................................................................345 R. v. Burke [1991] 1 A.C. 135 H.L. .............................................................................................................................317 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Aranda (1998) 30 H.L.R. 76 C.A. .................................................................................80 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Cosmo (1998) 30 H.L.R. 817 Div.Ct. ............................................................................78 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Hersi [2000] Times October 11th ................................................................................76 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Jibril (1997) 29 H.L.R. 785 ...........................................................................................83 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Mohammed (1998) 30 H.L.R. 315, Latham J. ..................................................67, 69, 89 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Pereira (No.2) (1999) 31 H.L.R. 317 C.A. ...................................................................73 R. v. Camden L.B.C. ex parte Rowton (Camden Town) Ltd. (1983) 10 H.L.R. 28 ...................................................272 R. v. Canterbury C.C. ex parte Gillespie (1986) 19 H.L.R. 7...................................................................................70, 71 R. v. Cardiff C.C. ex parte Cross (1980) 6 H.L.R. 1 C.A. ...........................................................................................345 R. v. Chiltern D.C. ex parte Roberts (1990) 23 H.L.R. 387 Q.B.D. ..............................................................................81 R. v. Corby D.C. ex parte McLean [1975] 1 W.L.R. 735 C.A......................................................................................345 R. v. Croydon L.B.C. ex parte Graham (1994) 26 H.L.R. 286 C.A. .............................................................................80 R. v. Croydon L.B.C. ex parte Jarvis (1994) 26 H.L.R. 194; .........................................................................................79 R. v. Croydon L.B.C. ex parte Toth (1988) 20 H.L.R. 576 C.A. ............................................................37, 40, 598, 601 R. v. D.P.P. ex parte Jones [1996] Independent June 12th. Div.Ct. ..........................................................................252 R. v. Davidson-Acres [1980] Crim. L.R. 50 C.A. ........................................................................................................316 R. v. Dudley Magistrates Court ex parte Hollis [1998] 1 All E.R. 759, Moses J..................................................267, 269 R. v. Ealing L.B.C. ex parte Fox [1998] Times March 9th............................................................................................91 R. v. Ealing L.B.C. ex parte Parkinson (1997) 29 H.L.R. 179 Q.B.D............................................................................89 R. v. Ealing L.B.C. ex parte Sidhu (1982) 2 H.L.R. 45, Hodgson J. .............................................................................81 R. v. Ealing L.B.C. ex parte Surdonja (1999) 31 H.L.R. 686; [2000] 2 All E.R. 597 H.L. ............................................85 R. v. East Devon D.C. ex parte Robb (1998) 30 H.L.R. 922. ........................................................................................91 R. v. East Hertfordshire D.C. ex parte Dallhold Resources Management (U.K.) Pty Ltd. (1990) 22 H.L.R. 77, Pill J. .................................................................................................................................................191 R. v. Falmouth & Truro Port Health Authority ex parte S.W. Water Services Ltd. [1999] E.G.C.S. 62, Harrison J. ..............................................................................................................................269 R. v. Forest Heath D.C. ex parte West (1991) 24 H.L.R. 85 C.A. .................................................................................72 R. v. Gateshead M.B.C. ex parte Lauder (1997) 29 H.L.R. 360 Q.B.D. .................................................................71, 72 R. v. Gateshead M.B.C. ex parte Smith (1999) 31 H.L.R. 97, Collins J......................................................................279 R. v. Gravesend C.C. ex parte Patchett [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 125. ..........................................................................667, 668 R. v. Gravesham B.C. ex parte Winchester (1986) 18 H.L.R. 207 .................................................................................85 R. v. Greenwich L.B.C. ex parte Deely (1999) 31 H.L.R. 446 .....................................................................................240 R. v. Greenwich L.B.C. ex parte Dukic (1997) 29 H.L.R. 87 Q.B.D..............................................................................73 R. v. Greenwich L.B.C. ex parte Glen International Ltd. [2000] Times March 29th C.A. .........................................275 R. v. Hackney L.B.C. ex parte Tonnicodi (1998) 30 H.L.R. 916. ..................................................................................76 R. v. Hackney L.B.C. ex parte Ajayi (1998) 30 H.L.R. 473, Dyson J. ...................................................................................................79
lxiv
TABLE OF CASES
R. v. Hackney L.B.C. ex parte Evenbray (1987) 19 H.L.R. 557. .................................................................................272 R. v. Hackney L.B.C. ex parte K. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 760 C.A. .................................................................................92, 97 R. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. ex parte Avdic (1998) 30 H.L.R. 1 C.A. ..........................................................91 R. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. ex parte Damoah (1999) 31 H.L.R. 786, Kay J..........................................77, 93 R. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. ex parte Duro-Roma (1983) 9 H.L.R. 71 Q.B.D. ............................................82 R. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. ex parte Fleck (1998) 30 H.L.R. 679, Sedley J. ....................................69, 73, 89 R. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. ex parte M. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 10 C.A. .............................................................98 R. v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. ex parte Quigley (2000) 32 H.L.R. 379, Ognall J. .........................................140 R. v. Haringey L.B.C. ex parte Karaman (1997) 29 H.L.R. 366, Brooke J. .................................................................83 R. v. Haringey L.B.C. ex parte Sampaio (1999) 31 H.L.R. 1 ........................................................................................84 R. v. Harrow L.B.C. ex parte Fahia [1998] 1 W.L.R. 396, [1998] 4 All E.R. 137 H.L.; (1997) 29 H.L.R. 94 C.A. ......................................................................................................................................................80 R. v. Havant B.C. ex parte Marten (1996) 28 H.L.R. 68 Q.B.D. ..................................................................................79 R. v. Highbury Corner Magistrates Court ex parte Edwards [1995] Crim. L.R. 65 Div.Ct. ......................................268 R. v. Hillingdon L.B.C. ex parte Islam [1983] 1 A.C. 688 H.L. ............................................................................75, 81 R. v. Hillingdon L.B.C. ex parte Streeting [1980] 1 W.L.R. 1425 Div.Ct................................................................81, 96 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Aldabbagh (1995) 27 H.L.R. 271 ................................................................................287 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte B. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 706...................................................................................66, 77, 286 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Bibi (1997) 29 H.L.R. 498 Q.B.D. ..........................................................................79, 81 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Degnan (1998) 30 H.L.R. 723 C.A. ..............................................................................83 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Hinds (1995) 27 H.L.R. 65 Q.B.D., reversed [1995] C.L.Y. 2553 C.A. ......................79 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Okocha (1998) 30 H.L.R. 191........................................................................................84 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Reilly (1999) 31 H.L.R. 651, Richards J........................................................................71 R. v. Islington L.B.C. ex parte Thomas (1998) 30 H.L.R. 111 Q.B.D. ..........................................................................83 R. v. Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Ben-el-Mabrouk (1995) 27 H.L.R. 564 C.A. .......................................82 R. v. Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Byfield (1999) 31 H.L.R. 913, Moses J. ...............................................88 R. v. Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Kihara (1996) 29 H.L.R. 147 C.A. .................................................73, 78 R. v. Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Korneva (1997) 29 H.L.R. 709 C.A. ....................................................96 R. v. Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Kujtim [1999] 4 All E.R. 161 C.A. ...............................................97, 98 R. v. Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Silchenstedt (1997) 29 H.L.R. 728, Tucker J. ..........................67, 85, 87 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte A1 and A2 (1998) 30 H.L.R. 933 Div.Ct. .....................................................................83 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Ashley (1997) 29 H.L.R. 385 ........................................................................................71 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Ekpo-Wedderman (1999) 31 H.L.R. 498; ...............................................................67, 85 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Njomo (1996) 28 H.L.R. 737, Sedley J..........................................................................72 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Pattinson (1996) 28 H.L.R. 214, Louis Blom-Cooper Q.C. ................................66, 286 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Sarhangi (1999) 31 H.L.R. 1022, Kay J. ......................................................................97 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Trabi (1998) 30 H.L.R. 975.........................................................................................287 R. v. Lambeth L.B.C. ex parte Woodburne (1997) 29 H.L.R. 836 ......................................................................286, 287 R. v. Liverpool Crown Court ex parte Cooke [1997] 1 W.L.R. 700 Div.Ct. ................................................................268 R. v. London L.V.T. ex parte Daejan Properties Ltd. [2000] Times October 20th Sullivan J. ..................................461 R. v. London R.A.P. ex parte Cadogan Estates Ltd. [1998] Q.B. 398, Kay J. ......................................................168, 226 R. v. London R.A.P. ex parte Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 34..................................279, 283, 461 R. v. London R.A.P. ex parte Mota (1988) 20 H.L.R. 159...........................................................................................233 R. v. London R.A.P. ex parte Wells (1996) 71 P. & C.R. D4, Turner J. .....................................................................238 R. v. Mansfield D.C. ex parte Ashfield Nominees Ltd. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 805, Harrison J. .........................................271 R. v. Marylebone Magistrates Court ex parte Westminster C.C. (2000) 32 H.L.R. 266..............................................461 R. v. Merton L.B.C. ex parte Sembi (2000) 32 H.L.R. 439, Jowitt J..................................................................67, 68, 88 R. v. Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food ex parte Cox [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 17 Q.B.D. ...................................629 R. v. Mitchell [1994] Crim.L.R. 66 C.A. .....................................................................................................................316 R. v. Newcastle on Tyne C.C. ex parte Thompson (1988) 20 H.L.R. 430, McNeill J..................................................332 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Arab Miah (1998) 30 H.L.R. 691 Q.B.D................................................................76, 84 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Begum [2000] 2 All E.R. 1, Collins J.............................................................................68 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 567. ..............................................................................................98 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Campbell (1991) 26 H.L.R. 183 Q.B.D. ....................................................................334 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Chowdhury (1999) 31 H.L.R. 383 ...............................................................................84 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Dada [1996] Q.B. 507 C.A. ..............................................................................73, 83, 84 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Gorenkin (1998) 30 H.L.R. 278, Carnwath J. .............................................................98 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Hassan (1997) 29 H.L.R. 378. ......................................................................................69 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Khan [2000] Times May 9th Collins J. .......................................................................67
TABLE OF CASES
lxv
R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Larwood (1997) 29 H.L.R. 670 Q.B.D., reversed (1998) 30 H.L.R. 716 C.A. ..............................................................................................................................................83, 84 R. v. Newham L.B.C ex parte Medical Foundation of the Care of Victims of Torture (1998) 30 H.L.R. 955, Moses J. ............................................................................................................................................98 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Miah (1995) 28 H.L.R. 279, Carnwath J. ....................................................................72 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Ojuri (No.1) [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3004 Q.B.D.; (No.2) (1999) 31 H.L.R. 631, Collins J.; (No.3) (1999) 31 H.L.R. 452; (No.5) (1999) 31 H.L.R. 631 ............................................................70, 79, 83, 85, 87 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Plastin (1998) 30 H.L.R. 261 ........................................................................................98 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Smith (1997) 29 H.L.R. 213..........................................................................................90 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Tower Hamlets L.B.C. [1991] 1 W.L.R. 1032 C.A. ......................................................91 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Trendgrove Properties Ltd. [1999] 22 L.S.G. 36, (2000) 32 H.L.R. 424, Dyson J. ..........................................................................................................................................277 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Ugbo (1994) 26 H.L.R. 263; .........................................................................................80 R. v. Newham L.B.C. ex parte Watkins (1993) 26 H.L.R. 434 .....................................................................................72 R. v. North Devon C.C. ex parte Lewis [1981] 1 W.L.R. 328, Woolf J. ........................................................................78 R. v. Northavon D.C. ex parte Ashman [1993] C.L.Y. 2116, Potts J. .........................................................................271 R. v. Northavon D.C. ex parte Smith [1994] 2 A.C. 402 H.L. ......................................................................................76 R. v. Nottingham C.C. ex parte Edwards (1999) 31 H.L.R. 33, Sullivan J............................................................79, 343 R. v. Nottingham R.O. ex parte Allen (1986) 52 P. & C.R. 41, Farquharson J. .........................................................180 R. v. Oldham M.B.C. ex parte Garlick [1993] A.C. 509 H.L. ......................................................................................76 R. v. Oxford C.C. ex parte Crowder (1999) 31 H.L.R. 485 Q.B.D. ...............................................................................85 R. v. Oxford C.C. ex parte Doyle (1998) 30 H.L.R. 506, Tucker J. ...............................................................................76 R. v. Parnell (1831) 14 Cox. C.C. 508 ........................................................................................................................256 R. v. Paulson [1921] 1 A.C. 271 P.C....................................................................................................................377, 815 R. v. Penwith D.C. ex parte Menear (1992) 24 H.L.R. 115 ........................................................................................240 R. v. Peterborough C.C. ex parte Carr (1990) 22 H.L.R. 206, Hutchison J. ................................................................75 R. v. Phekoo [1981] 1 W.L.R. 1117 C.A. ............................................................................................................316, 317 R. v. Plymouth C.C. ex parte Freeman (1987) 19 H.L.R. 328 C.A. ....................................................................126, 496 R. v. Poole B.C. ex parte Cooper (1995) 27 H.L.R. 605 ................................................................................................88 R. v. Port Talbot B.C. ex parte Jones [1988] 2 All E.R. 267, Nolan J. ..........................................................................86 R. v. R.O. of Camden L.B.C. ex parte Plant [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 73 Q.B.D. .................................................................168 R. v. R.O. of Camden L.B.C. ex parte Ebiri [1981] 1 W.L.R. 881 ...............................................................................237 R. v. R.O. of Camden L.B.C. ex parte Felix [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 132, Hutchison J. .............................................126, 237 R. v. R.O. of Kensington & Chelsea R.L.B.C. ex parte Moberly (1986) 18 H.L.R. 189 C.A........................................236 R. v. Reigate & Banstead B.C. ex parte Di Domenico (1988) 20 H.L.R. 153 Q.B.D.....................................................73 R. v. Rushmoor B.C. ex parte Barrett [1989] Q.B. 60 C.A. .........................................................................................499 R. v. S.S. for Health ex parte Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 475 C.A..........................................98 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Enfield B.C. (1988) 86 L.G.R. 549, McNeill J. ..............................................497 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Gosforth Allotments & Gardens Association Ltd. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 117 C.A. .....................................................................................................................................607 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Harrow L.B.C. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 1, Judge J. ................................................207 R. v. S.S. for the Environmentex parte Norwich C.C. [1982] Q.B. 808 C.A. ......................................................497, 501 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Nottinghamshire C.C. [1986] A.C. 240 H.L. ..................................................70 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Shelter [1997] 2 C.L.Y. 2654, Carnwath J. .....................................................98 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Tower Hamlets L.B.C [1993] Q.B. 632 C.A. ..................................................96 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte Walters [1997] Times September 2nd C.A. .................................................280 R. v. S.S. for the Environment ex parte West Oxfordshire D.C. (1993) 26 H.L.R. 417. .............................................496 R. v. S.S. for the Environment, Transport and the Regions ex parte O’Byrne [2000] Times May 25th ......................497 R. v. S.S. for the Environment, Transport & the Regions ex parte Spath Holme Ltd. [2000] 1 All E.R. 884 C.A.; reversed [2000] N.L.J. 1855 H.L........................................................201, 231, 233, 235 R. v. S.S. for the Home Department ex parte Brind [1991] 1 A.C. 696 H.L................................................................206 R. v. S.S. for Wales ex parte Emery [1996] 4 All E.R. 1 on appeal [1998] 4 All E.R. 367 C.A. ..................................205 R. v. Sacupima ex parte Newham L.B.C. [2000] Times January 12th, Dyson J............................................................84 R. v. Sedgemoor D.C. ex parte McCarthy (1996) 28 H.L.R. 607 Q.B.D. ......................................................................81 R. v. Sefton Housing Benefit Review Board ex parte Brennan (1997) 29 H.L.R. 735, Dyson J. ...................................47 R. v. Sefton M.B.C. ex parte Healiss (1995) 27 H.L.R. 34 Q.B.D. ..............................................................................286 R. v. Sefton M.B.C. ex parte Help the Aged [1997] 4 All E.R. 532 C.A.........................................................................98 R. v. Sheffield C.C. ex parte Leek (1994) 26 H.L.R. 669 C.A. .......................................................................................73 R. v. Singh [1999] Times April 17th C.A. ..................................................................................................................252
lxvi
TABLE OF CASES
R. v. Slough B.C. ex parte Ealing L.B.C.[1981] Q.B. 801 C.A. ........................................................................90, 91, 92 R. v. South Herefordshire C.C. ex parte Miles (1983) 17 H.L.R. 82 .............................................................................82 R. v. South Holland D.C. ex parte Baxter (1998) 30 H.L.R. 1069 .........................................................................84, 88 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Anderson [1999] 07 C.L. 259, Moses J. .....................................................................68 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Bediako (1998) 30 H.L.R. 22 .....................................................................................98 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Campisi (1999) 31 H.L.R. 560 C.A. ....................................................................83, 86 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Cordwell (1995) 27 H.L.R. 594 C.A. ...............................................................267, 271 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Hong Cui (1999) 31 H.L.R. 639. ...............................................................................98 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Hughes (1998) 30 H.L.R. 1082, Turner J.................................................................90 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Levy (1983) 8 H.L.R. 1, Brown J. ............................................................................272 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Mason [1999] 4 C.L. 354............................................................................................72 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Melak (1997) 29 H.L.R. 223 .....................................................................................71 R. v. Southwark L.B.C. ex parte Ryder (1996) 28 H.L.R. 56, Dyson J. .........................................................................75 R. v. Sunderland C.C. ex parte Rendezvous Ltd. (1995) 27 H.L.R. 477, Judge J. ......................................................275 R. v. Swale B.C. ex parte Merchant [1999] 1 F.L.R. 1087, Kay J. ..............................................................................240 R. v. Swansea C.C. ex parte Littler [1998] Times September 9th C.A. ......................................................................239 R. v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. ex parte Bradford (1997) 29 H.L.R. 756, Kay J. ..............................................................73 R. v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. ex parte Spencer (1997) 29 H.L.R. 64 Q.B.D. ..................................................................86 R. v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. ex parte Uddin (2000) 32 H.L.R. 391, Keene J. ...............................................................88 R. v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. ex parte Von Goetz [1999] Q.B. 1019 C.A......................................................34, 276, 525 R. v. Wandsworth C.Ct. ex parte Munn (1994) 26 H.L.R. 697, Sedley J............................................................256, 706 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte Crooks (1995) 27 H.L.R. 660 .................................................................................79 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte Dodia (1998) 30 H.L.R. 562, Jowitt J. ...................................................................77 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte Hawthorne [1994] 1 W.L.R. 1442, [1995] 2 All E.R. 331 C.A. ............................78 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte Lawrie (1998) 30 H.L.R. 153 ................................................................................287 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte Mansoor [1997] Q.B. 953 C.A. ..............................................................................69 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte O. [2000] 4 All E.R. 590 C.A. ................................................................................97 R. v. Wandsworth L.B.C. ex parte Wingrove [1997] Q.B. 953, [1996] 3 All E.R. 913 C.A. .........................................81 R. v. Waveney D.C. ex parte Bower [1983] Q.B. 238 C.A.............................................................................................81 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte A. (1997) 1 C.C.L.R. 85 C.A. .....................................................................................97 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Ali (1983) 11 H.L.R. 85 Div.Ct. ................................................................................78 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Ali (1997) 29 H.L.R. 580 ......................................................................................67, 85 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Al’Khorsan [2000] Times January 21st, Latham J. ..................................................72 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Bishop (1997) 29 H.L.R. 546......................................................................................73 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Castelli (1996) 28 H.L.R. 616 C.A. ......................................................................94, 96 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Chambers (1982) 6 H.L.R. 24 Q.B.D. .................................................................83, 84 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte De Souza (1997) 29 H.L.R. 649, Popplewell J...........................................................77 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Elioua (1999) 31 H.L.R. 440 C.A. .......................................................................87, 88 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Ermakov [1996] 2 All E.R. 302 C.A. .........................................................................89 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Hussain (1999) 31 H.L.R. 645, Turner J. ......................................................84, 86, 87 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Kamal (1997) 29 H.L.R. 230 C.A. ............................................................................90 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte N’Dormadingar [1997] Times November 20th. ......................................................78 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Obeid (1996) 29 H.L.R. 389, Carnwath J. ..........................................................78–79 R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Parkins (1995) 68 P. & C.R. 253 C.A. .........................................................8, 319, 320 R. v. Westminster L.B.C. ex parte Jaafer (1998) 30 H.L.R. 698, Scott Baker J. ...........................................................96 R. v. Wigan M.B.C. ex parte Tammadge [1998] 1 C.C.L.R. 581, Forbes J. .................................................................98 R. v. Wimbourne D.C. ex parte Curtis (1985) 18 H.L.R. 79, Mann J. .........................................................................77 R. v. Woking B.C. ex parte Adams (1995) 28 H.L.R. 513 C.A. ...........................................................................270, 271 R. v. Wolverhampton M.B.C. ex parte Watters (1997) 28 H.L.R. 931 C.A. ...........................................................71, 72 R. v. Yuthiwattana (1985) 80 Cr.App.R. 55 C.A. ..............................................................................................316, 317 R.A. Securities Ltd. v. Mercantile Current [1995] 3 All E.R. 581, Jacob J. .................................................................773 R.M.R. Housing Society Ltd. v. Combs [1951] 1 K.B. 486, 493, Evershed M.R. ........................................................115 R.P.H. Ltd. v. Mirror Group Newspapers Ltd. (1992) 65 P. & C.R. 252, Nicholls V.C. ............................................791 Railtrack plc. v. Gojra [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 63 C.A. .......................................................................................562, 590, 593 Rainbow Estates Ltd. v. Tokenhold [1998] 3 W.L.R. 980, [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 34, Lawrence Collins Q.C. .......255, 684 Rajbenback v. Mamon [1955] 1 Q.B. 283 ..................................................................................................................348 Rakhit v. Carty [1990] 2 Q.B. 315 C.A. ......................................................................................................235, 336, 350 Ramage v. Womack [1900] 1 Q.B. 116 Wright J. .......................................................................................................761
TABLE OF CASES
lxvii
Ramdath v. Oswald Daley [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 82 C.A. ...............................................................................................315 Ramsay (W.T.) Ltd. v. I.R.C. [1982] A.C. 300 H.L. ..................................................................................................428 Rankin v. Lay (1860) 2 De G. F. & J. 65, 45 E.R. 546.........................................................................................531, 533 Ratners (Jewellers) Ltd. v. Lemnoll Ltd. [1980] 2 E.G.L.R. 65, Dillon J. ....................................................................668 Ravenseft Properties Ltd. v. Davstone Ltd. [1980] Q.B. 12, Forbes J. ..............................................................249, 680 Ravenseft Properties Ltd. v. Park [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 164 .............................................................................................664 Rawashdeh v. Lane [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A...........................................................................................................568 Rawlance v. Croydon Corporation [1952] 2 Q.B. 803 C.A. .......................................................................................271 Rawlings v. Morgan (1865) 18 C.B.N.S. 776, 144 E.R. 650........................................................................................681 Rayburn v. Wolf (1985) 18 H.L.R. 1 C.A. ..........................................................................................................736, 738 Rayner v. Stone (1762) 2 Eden 128, 28 E.R. 845 ........................................................................................................684 Razzaq v. Pala [1997] 1 W.L.R. 1336, Lightman J. ...................................................................................805, 829, 830 Reckitt v. Cody [1920] 2 Ch. 452, Eve J.......................................................................................................................790 Redleaf Investments Ltd. v. Talbot [1994] Times May 5th, Vinelott J. ......................................................................826 Redmond v. Dainton [1920] 2 K.B. 256 ......................................................................................................................689 Redspring v. Francis [1973] 1 W.L.R. 134 ..................................................................................................................352 Reed Personnel Services plc. v. American Express Ltd. [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 229, Jacob J...............................................583 Reed v. Hastings Corp. (1964) 62 L.G.R. 588. ............................................................................................................272 Rees v. Bennington (1795) 2 Ves. 540, 30 E.R. 765 ....................................................................................................784 Regalgrand Ltd. v. Dickerson (1997) 29 H.L.R. 620 C.A...................................................................125, 312, 313, 315 Regalian Securities Ltd. v. Ramsden [1981] 1 W.L.R. 611 H.L. .................................15, 107, 108, 148, 149, 296, 395 Regalian Securities Ltd. v. Scheuer [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 96 C.A. ...................................................................................109 Regan v. Regan [1977] 1 W.L.R. 84 ....................................................................................................................136, 140 Regent Oil Ltd. v. Gregory (J.A.)(Hatch End) Ltd. [1966] Ch. 402 C.A. ...................................................................769 Regional Properties Co. Ltd. v. Franskenschwerth [1951] 1 K.B. 631 C.A. .................................................................298 Regis Property Co. Ltd. v. Dudley [1959] A.C. 370 H.L. ...................................................234, 262, 264, 672, 677, 678 Regor Estates Ltd. v. Wright [1951] 1 K.B. 689 C.A....................................................................................................769 Reid (J.) (D. & K.) Co. Ltd. v. Burdell Engineering Co. Ltd. (1958) 171 E.G. 281 C.A. ............................................549 Reid v. Dawson [1955] 1 Q.B. 214 ..............................................................................................................................614 Reid v. Smith (1905) 3 C.L.R. 656...............................................................................................................................697 Rellie v. Pyke [1936] 1 All E.R. 345 .............................................................................................................................791 Relvok v. Dixon (1972) 25 P. & C.R. 1 C.A...........................................................................................................40, 601 Remon v. City of London Real Property Co. [1921] 1 K.B. 49 C.A. ...........................................................................111 Rendall v. Westminster (1987) 19 H.L.R. 345 C.A. ....................................................................................................404 Rendell v. Roman (1839) 9 T.L.R. 192 ...............................................................................................................220, 650 Rene Claro (Haute Coiffure) Ltd. v. Hallé Concerts Society [1969] 1 W.L.R. 909 C.A. .............................................565 Rennie v. Proma Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 C.A. ......................................................................................................411 Reohorn v. Barry Corporation [1956] 1 W.L.R. 845 C.A............................................................................................571 Reston Ltd. v. Hudson [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 51 .......................................................................................................457, 703 Restormel B.C. v. Buscombe (1982) 14 H.L.R. 91 C.A. ..............................................................................................177 Retail Parks Investments Ltd. v. Royal Bank of Scotland [1995] S.L.T. 1156. ...........................................................712 Rexhaven Ltd. v. Nurse (1996) 28 H.L.R. 241, Colyer J. ..........................................................372, 458, 704, 804, 824 Reynard v. Arnold (1875) L.R. 10 Ch. App. 386 C.A. ................................................................................................689 Reynolds v. Ashby & Son [1904] A.C. 466 H.L. ..........................................................................................................697 Reynolds v. Phoenix Assurance Co. Ltd. [1978] 2 Lloyds Rep. 440 C.A. ...................................................................687 Rhodes Trust v. Khan [1980] 1 E.G.L.R. 64 C.A. .......................................................................................................332 Rhodes v. Allied Dunbar Pension Services Ltd [1989] 1 W.L.R. 800 C.A. ..........................................................220, 649 Rhone v. Stephens [1994] 2 A.C. 310 H.L. ..................................................................................................423, 486, 701 Rhyl U.D.C. v. Rhyl Amusements Ltd. [1959] 1 W.L.R. 465, Harman J....................................................................600 Richards v. Creighton Griffiths (Investments) Ltd. (1972) 225 E.G. 2104, Plowman J. ............................................536 Richards v. Green [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 104.....................................................................................................................107 Richards v. Richards [1984] A.C. 174 H.L. .................................................................................................................131 Richardson v. Evans (1818) 3 Madd. 218, 56 E.R. 490 ...............................................................................................733 Richmond v. Savill [1926] 2 K.B. 530 C.A. .................................................................................................................597 Richurst v. Pimenta [1993] 1 W.L.R. 159 C.A. ...........................................................................................................658 Rickards v. Loyhian [1913] A.C. 263 P.C. ..................................................................................................................720 Rickett v. Green [1910] 1 K.B. 253...............................................................................................523, 524, 754, 755, 757 Ricketts v. Enfield Churchwardens [1909] 1 Ch. 544, 554, Neville J. .........................................................753, 770, 771 Ridehalgh v. Horsefield (1992) 24 H.L.R. 453 C.A........................................................................................................63
lxviii
TABLE OF CASES
Rider v. Ford [1923] 1 Ch. 541 ...................................................................................................................................537 Ridout v. Fowler [1904] 1 Ch. 658, on appeal [1904] 2 Ch. 93 C.A. .........................................................................527 Riggs,Re [1901] 2 K.B. 16, Wright J. ..................................................................................................................727, 829 Right d. Lewis v. Beard (1811) 13 East. 210, 104 E.R. 350 .........................................................................................175 Riley (E.J.) Investments Ltd. v. Eurostile Holdings Ltd. [1985] 1 W.L.R. 1139 C.A. .........................................563, 581 Rimmer v. Webster [1902] 2 Ch. 163 ..................................................................................................................251, 690 Ritz Hotel (London) Ltd. v. Ritz Casino Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 135 Ch.D. ...............................................................666 Robbins v. Jones (1863) 15 C.B.N.S. 221, 143 E.R. 768 .............................................................................................250 Robbins v. Whyte [1906] 1 K.B. 125............................................................................................................................596 Roberts v. Church Commissioners for England [1972] 1 Q.B. 278 C.A. ......................................................18, 390, 518 Roberts v. Holland [1893] 1 Q.B. 665 .........................................................................................................................758 Roberts v. Macilwraithe-Christie [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 224 C.A. ....................................................................................352 Roberts v. Tregaskis (1878) 38 L.T. 176.......................................................................................................................764 Robins v. Meadows & Moran [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 137 .................................................................................................564 Robinson v. Brent L.B.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 1015 C.A...................................................................................................81 Robinson v. Moody [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 16 C.A. ...........................................................................................................627 Rodenhurst Estates Ltd. v. Barnes Ltd. [1936] 2 All E.R. 3 C.A. ................................................................724, 751, 757 Rodewald v. Rodewald [1977] Fam. 192, [1977] 2 All E.R. 609.................................................................................136 Rodwell v. Gwynne Trusts Ltd. [1970] 1 W.L.R. 327 H.L. .........................................................................................404 Roe d. Bamford v. Hayley (1810) 12 East. 464, 104 E.R. 181, Ellenborough C.J. .....................................................769 Roe d. Berkeley v. York (1805) 6 East. 86, 102 E.R. 1219 ...........................................................................................597 Roe d. Gregson v. Harrison (1788) 2 Term. Rep. 425, 100 E.R. 229 ..................................................................728, 733 Roe v. Russell [1928] 2 K.B. 117 C.A...................................................................................................................111, 296 Rogan v. Woodfield Building Services Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 72 C.A. .............................................................460, 591 Rogers v. Hosegood [1900] 2 Ch. 388 C.A. ..................................................................................................................771 Rogers v. Islington L.B.C. [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 17 C.A. .................................................................................................272 Rogers v. Rice [1892] 2 Ch. 170, Coleridge C.J. ..........................................................................................................819 Rollason v. Leon (1861) 7 H. & N. 73, 158 E.R. 398.....................................................................................................31 Rolls v. Miller (1884) 27 Ch.D. 71 C.A. .....................................................................................................................542 Romain v. Scuba T.V. [1997] Q.B. 887, [1996] 2 All E.R. 377 C.A. ..........................................................................780 Romulus Trading Co. Ltd. v. Comet Properties Ltd. [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 70, Garland J. .............................................718 Romulus Trading Co. Ltd. v. Henry Smith’s Charity Trustees [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 75 C.A., (No.2) [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 95 C.A.................................................................................................................................569, 570 Rookes v. Barnard [1964] A.C. 1129 H.L. ...................................................................................................................315 Ropac v. Inntrepreneur Pub. Co. Ltd. [2000] Times June 7th Neuberger J. ..............................................................818 Ropemaker Properties Ltd. v. Noonhaven Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 50, Millett J. .................................................800, 821 Roper v. Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 5 Q.B.D. ..................................................................624, 677 Rose v. Stavrou [1999] 23 L.S.G. 29, Neuberger J. .............................................................................................710, 737 Rose v. Watson (1864) 10 H.L.C. 672, 11 E.R. 1187 H.L. ..................................................................................526, 527 Rosen v. Campden Charities Trustees [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 213 L.Tr. ...................................................................403, 530 Ross Auto Wash Ltd. v. Herbert [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 95, Fox J......................................................................................546 Ross v. Collins [1964] 1 W.L.R. 425 C.A. ....................................................................................................................119 Ross v. Hestdrive Ltd. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 50.................................................................................................................735 Rous v. Mitchell [1991] 1 W.L.R. 469 C.A. ...................................................................................28, 590, 618, 622, 625 Rousou v. Photi [1940] 2 K.B. 379 C.A. .....................................................................................................................250 Roux Restuarants Ltd. v. Jaison Property Development Co. Ltd. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 357 C.A.................................737 Rowlands (Mark) Ltd. v. Berni Inns Ltd. [1986] Q.B. 211 C.A. .................................................................369, 688–690 Royal Bank of Scotland plc. v. Jennings [1997] 1 E.G.L.R. 101 C.A. ..........................................................................659 Royal British Legion H.Ass. v. East Midlands R.A.P. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 131, Schiemann J. .....................................229 Royal Life Insurance Ltd. v. Phillips [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 135 Q.B.D. ...........................................................................657 Royal Life Saving Society v. Page [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1329 C.A. ............................................................................544, 550 Royal Philanthropic Society v. County [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 109 C.A.............................................................................185 Royal Victoria Pavilion, Ramsgate, Re [1961] Ch. 581 ..............................................................................................764 Royton Industries Ltd. v. Lawrence [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 110, Aldous J. .......................................................................640 Rugby Joint Water Board v. Foottit [1973] A.C. 202 H.L. .................................................................................615, 626 Rugby School v. Tannahill [1935] 1 K.B. 87 C.A., [1934] 1 K.B. 695, Mackinnon J. .............................800, 819, 820 Rumsey v. Owen White & Catlin [1976] 1 E.G.L.R. 99 C.A.......................................................................................564 Rushcliffe B.C. v. Watson (1991) 24 H.L.R. 124 C.A. ................................................................................................347 Rushton v. Smith [1976] Q.B. 480 C.A. ......................................................................................................................525
TABLE OF CASES
lxix
Rushton v. Worcester C.C. [2000] unreported C.Ct. .................................................................................................498 Russell v. Booker [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 86 C.A. ...............................................................................................550, 608, 610 Russell,Re (1885) 29 Ch.D. 254 ..................................................................................................................................791 Rutherford v. Maurer [1962] 1 Q.B. 16...............................................................................................................607, 614 Rutter v. Michael John Ltd. (1966) 201 E.G. 299 ........................................................................................................740 Ryall v. Cubitt Heath [1922] 1 K.B. 275 ....................................................................................................................271 Ryall v. Kidwell & Son [1914] 3 K.B. 135 ...................................................................................................................260 Rycroft’s Settlement, Re [1962] Ch. 263. ....................................................................................................................526 Rye v. Purcell [1926] 1 K.B. 446 .................................................................................................................................755 Rye v. Rye [1962] A.C. 496 H.L...................................................................................................................125, 508, 595 Rye (Denis) Pension Fund Trustees v. Sheffield C.C. [1998] 1 W.L.R. 840 C.A. .......................................................275 S., Re [1998] A.C. 750 H.L. ...........................................................................................................................................93 S.E.D.A.C. Investments Ltd. v. Tanner [1982] 1 W.L.R. 1342, Michael Wheeler Q.C..............................798, 803, 810 S.F.I. Group plc. v. Gosport B.C. [1999] Times April 5th C.A. ..........................................................................267, 269 S.S. for Social Services v. Beavington [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 13 ................................................................................613, 615 S.S. for the Environment v. Associated News Holdings Ltd. [1995] E.G.C.S. 166 C.A. ..............................................658 S.S. for the Environment v. Possfund (North West) Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 56 C.A. .........................................458, 704 S.S. for Transport v. Jenkins (2000) 79 P. & C.R. 118 C.A. .......................................................................................333 Sabella Ltd. v. Montgomery [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A. ..............................................................................................560 Sackey v. Greenwich L.B.C. [1996] C.L.Y. 3784 .........................................................................................................334 Sadlers v. Clements [1995] E.G.C.S. 197 .....................................................................................................................688 Safeway Food Stores Ltd. v. Morris [1980] 1 E.G.L.R. 59, Walton J. .................................................................581, 582 Saga Properties Ltd. v. Palmeira Square Nos.2-6 Ltd. [1995] E.G.L.R. 199 L.V.T.............................................429, 431 Saigol v. Cranley Mansions Ltd. [1996] E.G.C.S. 81 C.A. ..........................................................................................426 Sainsbury (J). plc. v. O’Connor [1990] S.T.C. 516, Millett J., [1991] 1 W.L.R. 963 C.A. .........................530, 536, 537 St Catherine’s College Cambridge v. Dorling [1980] 1 W.L.R. 66 C.A. ...............................................................15, 548 St Ermins Property Co. Ltd. v. Patel (1998) 30 H.L.R. 462 C.A. .......................................................................393, 394 St Giles Hotel Ltd. v. Microworld Technology Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 105 C.A. ...............................556, 557, 565, 568 St Martin’s Property Investments Ltd. v. Citycorp Investment Bank Properties Ltd. [1998] E.G.C.S. 161 C.A. ........................................................................................................................................664 St Marylebone Property Co. Ltd. v. Tesco Stores Ltd. [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 40, Hoffmann J. ......................694, 800, 820 St Thomas’ Hospital v. Richardson [1910] 1 K.B. 271 C.A.........................................................................................772 Sale v. Kitchingham (1713) 10 Mod. 158, 88 E.R. 673 ...............................................................................................768 Saleh v. Robinson [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 126 C.A. ...........................................................................................................241 Salford Van Hire (Contracts) Ltd. v. Bocholt Developments Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 50 C.A. ...................................653 Salisbury v. Gilmore [1942] 2 K.B. 38 C.A..................................................................................................................681 Salisbury v. Marshal (1829) 4 Car. & P. 65, 172 E.R. 609 ..........................................................................................251 Saloman v. Akiens [1993] 1 E.G.L.R. 101 C.A. ..........................................................................................................564 Salt v. Cooper (1880) 16 Ch.D. 544, Jessel M.R..................................................................................................512, 523 Sambrin Investments Ltd. v. Tabourn [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 61, Peter Gibson J.............................................................834 Sampson v. Floyd [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 49 C.A. ......................................................................................................315, 316 Sampson v. Wilson [1996] Ch. 39 C.A. ......................................................................................................................313 Samuel Properties (Developments) Ltd. v. Hayek [1972] 1 W.L.R. 1296 C.A. ..........................................581, 657, 658 Sanctuary H.Ass. v. Baker [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 42 C.A. ................................................................................................741 Sanctuary H.Ass. v. Campbell [1999] 3 All E.R. 460 C.A. ..........................................................................40, 132, 601 Sanderson v. Berwick upon Tweed Corp. (1884) 13 Q.B.D. 547 C.A. ...............................................................691, 720 Sandwell M.B.C. v. Bujok [1990] 1 W.L.R. 1350 H.L.................................................................................................268 Saner v. Bilton (1878) 7 Ch.D. 815, Fry J....................................................................................254, 262, 672, 689, 707 Sarjeant v. Nash Field & Co. [1903] 2 K.B. 304 C.A. .........................................................................................566, 727 Sarson v. Roberts [1895] 2 Q.B. 395 C.A.....................................................................................................................251 Sarum Property Ltd.’s Application, Re [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 131 L.Tr............................................................................460 Saunders v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. [1999] 06 C.L. 347 C.Ct. ......................................................................79 Saunders v. Musgrave (1827) 6 B. & Cr. 524, 108 E.R. 545 .......................................................................................175 Saunders v. Soper [1975] A.C. 239 H.L.......................................................................................................................242 Saunders Trustees v. Ralph [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 1, Jowitt J. ..................................................................................599, 617 Savage v. Dunningham [1974] Ch. 181, Plowman J. ................................................................................................125 Savile S.E.,Re [1931] 2 Ch. 210 ...................................................................................................................................599 Savill v. Goodall (1993) 25 H.L.R. 588 C.A. ...............................................................................................................495
lxx
TABLE OF CASES
Savva v. Houssein [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A......................................................................................373, 799, 800, 820 Saxby v. McKinley (1997) 29 H.L.R. 569 C.A. ...........................................................................................................314 Scala House & District Property Co. Ltd. v. Forbes [1974] Q.B. 575 C.A...........................................................799, 800 Scarlett v. Halcrow Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 219 L.V.T. ...............................................................................................438 Scene Estates Ltd. v. Amos [1957] 2 Q.B. 205 .............................................................................................................614 Schalit v. Joseph Nadler Ltd. [1933] 2 K.B 79 ............................................................................................................761 Scheggia v. Gradwell [1963] 1 W.L.R. 1049 ...............................................................................................................741 Schnabel v. Allard [1967] 1 Q.B. 627 C.A. ..................................................................................................................563 Scholl Manufacturing Co. Ltd. v. Clifton (Slim-Line) Ltd. [1967] Ch. 41 C.A. .........................................559, 582, 586 Scollo v. Italy (1996) 22 E.H.R.R. 514 ................................................................................................................202, 205 Schon v. Camden L.B.C. (1987) 53 P. & C.R. 361 Div.Ct. ........................................................................................317 Schwab (E.S.) & Co. Ltd. v. McCarthy (1975) 31 P. & C.R. 196, Oliver J. ..........................................................39, 600 Scollo v. Italy (1996) 22 E.H.R.R. 514 ................................................................................................................202, 205 Scott v. U.K. 41 Decisions of Commission 226 .........................................................................................................201 Scottish Amicable Life Assurance Society v. Middleton (1995) 69 P. & C.R. 475, Arden J. .......................................664 Scottish Mutual Assurance plc. v. Jardine Public Relations Ltd. [1999] E.G.C.S. 43 Q.B.D. .....................................680 Scott-James v. Chehab [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 61 C.A. ......................................................................................................332 Scrimgeour v. Waller [1981] 1 E.G.L.R. 68 C.A. ................................................................................................167, 185 Sear v. House Property & Investment Society (1880) 16 Ch.D. 387, Hall V.C. .........................................................734 Seaward v. Drew (1898) 67 L.J.Q.B. 322.....................................................................................................................597 Second W.R.V.S. Housing Society Ltd. v. Blair (1986) 19 H.L.R. 104 C.A. ...............................................................338 Sector Properties Ltd. v. Meah (1973) 229 E.G. 1097 C.A. ..........................................................................................22 Sefton Holdings Ltd. v. Cairns (1988) 20 H.L.R. 124 C.A. .................................................................................118, 119 Selim Ltd. v. Bickenhall Engineering Ltd. [1981] 3 All E.R. 210, Megarry V.C. .....................................805, 827, 830 Sella Holdings Ltd. v. Mears (1989) 21 H.L.R. 147 C.A..............................................................................................459 Selous Street Properties Ltd. v. Oronel Fabrics Ltd. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 50, Hutchison J.............................785, 789–790 Serle,Re [1898] 1 Ch. 652, Kekewich J........................................................................................................................797 Sevenoaks Maidstone & Tunbridge Rly Co. v. London Chatham & Dover Rly Co. (1879) 11 Ch.D. 625 C.A. ........509 Sewell v. Angerstein (1868) 18 L.T. 300.......................................................................................................................698 Shanly v. Ward (1913) 29 T.L.R. 714 C.A. .................................................................................................................735 Sharma v. Knight [1986] 1 W.L.R. 757 C.A. ..............................................................................................................575 Sharp v. Milligan (1857) 23 Beav. 419, 53 E.R. 165 ...................................................................................................689 Sharpe v. Duke Street Securities NV. (1987) 55 P. & C.R. 331 C.A............................................................................400 Shaw v. Groom [1970] 2 Q.B. 504, [1970] 1 All E.R. 702 C.A...................................................................................223 Shaw v. Kay (1847) 1 Exch. 42, 154 E.R. 175 ............................................................................................................676 Shaw v. Lomas (1888) 59 L.T. 477 ..............................................................................................................211, 597, 646 Sheerness Steel Co. plc. v. Medway Ports Authority [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 133 C.A.........................................................664 Sheffield C.C. v. Jackson [1998] 1 W.L.R. 1591 C.A. .........................................................................................459, 501 Sheffield C.C. v. Jepson (1993) 25 H.L.R. 299 C.A. ....................................................................................................345 Sheldon v. West Bromwich Corporation (1973) 25 P. & C.R. 360 C.A. .....................................................................245 Shelley v. London C.C. [1949] A.C. 56, [1948] 2 All E.R. 898 H.L. .............................................................................70 Shelley v. United Artists Corp. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 103 C.A. .......................................................................530, 537, 565 Shell-Mex & B.P. Ltd. v. Manchester Garages Ltd. [1971] 1 W.L.R. 612 C.A. ..................................................152, 554 Shepherd v. Lomas [1963] 1 W.L.R. 962 ....................................................................................................................623 Shepherds Bush H.A. Ltd. v. Hats Co-Operative (1991) 24 H.L.R. 176 C.A. .............................................................179 Shepping v. Osada [2000] Times March 23rd C.A. ............................................................................................116, 347 Sherrin v. Brand [1956] 1 Q.B. 403 ............................................................................................................................333 Sherwood Close, Re [1972] Ch. 208, Goulding J. .......................................................................................................418 Sherwood v. Moody [1952] 1 All E.R. 389...........................................................................................................618, 625 Shiloh Spinners Ltd. v. Harding [1973] A.C. 691 H.L. ..............................................................712, 726, 762, 763, 820 Shina v. Elghanian [1999] 48 E.G. 147 L.Tr. .............................................................................................................408 Shire Court Residents Ltd. v. Registrar of Companies [1995] B.C.C. 821, Carnwath J. ............................................425 Shires v. Brock [1978] 2 E.G.L.R. 153 C.A. .................................................................................................................741 Shocked v. Goldschmidt [1998] 1 All E.R. 372 C.A. ....................................................................................................332 Short Bros (Plant) Ltd. v. Edwards [1979] 1 E.G.L.R. 5 C.A. .....................................................................................614 Short v. Greeves [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ...................................................................................................................607 Short v. Kalloway (1839) 11 Ad. & El. 28, 113 E.R. 322.............................................................................................791 Shortlands Investments Ltd. v. Cargill plc. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 51 Off.Rec...........................................................681, 682 Shrewsbury & Atcham B.C. v. Evans (1998) 30 H.L.R. 123 C.A. ..............................................................331, 340, 347
TABLE OF CASES
lxxi
Shrewsbury’s case (1600) 5 Co. Rep. 13b, 77 E.R. 68..........................................................................................263, 673 SI Pension Trustees Ltd. v. Peru [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 119 ..............................................................................................665 Siddiqi v. Rashid [1980] 1 W.L.R. 1018 C.A. .............................................................................................................352 Sidebotham v. Holland [1895] 1 Q.B. 378 C.A. ............................................................................................38, 581, 599 Sidnell v. Wilson [1966] 2 Q.B. 67 C.A. .....................................................................................................683, 801–803 Siew Soon Wah v. Yong Tong Hong [1973] A.C. 836 P.C. .........................................................................................513 Sight & Sound Educational Ltd. v. Books etc. Ltd. [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 45 Ch.D........................................................574 Signet Group plc. v. Hammerson U.K. Properties Ltd. (1998) 75 P. & C.R. D33 C.A. ..............................................563 Silverman v. A.F.C.O. (U.K.) Ltd. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 51 C.A. ............................................................................806, 827 Silvester v. Ostrowska [1959] 1 W.L.R. 1060...............................................................................................................798 Simmons v. Norton (1831) 7 Bing. 640, 131 E.R. 247 ...............................................................................................693 Simmons v. Pizzey [1979] A.C. 37 H.L. ......................................................................................................................272 Simonite v. Sheffield C.C. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 105 ...............................................................................................546, 668 Simons v. Associated Furnishers Ltd. [1931] 1 Ch. 379. .............................................................................................583 Simpson v. Scottish Union Insurance Co. (1863) 32 L.J. Ch. 329 ..............................................................................688 Sinclair Gardens Investments (Kensington) Ltd. v. Franks (1998) 76 P. & C.R. 230 L.Tr. .......................................438 Sinclair Gardens Investments (Kensington) Ltd. v. Walsh [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 23 C.A. ...............................................824 Singh v. Beggs (1996) 71 P. & C.R. 120 C.A................................................................................................................526 Sinnott v. Bowden [1912] 2 Ch. 414............................................................................................................................687 Sked v. Towngran Developments Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 216 L.V.T. .........................................................................438 Skeet v. Powell-Sheddon [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 112 C.A. .........................................................................................571, 572 Skilleter v. Charles [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 73 C.A......................................................................................................458, 703 Skinner v. Cooper [1979] 1 W.L.R. 666 C.A. .............................................................................................................188 Skinner v. Geary [1931] 2 K.B. 546 C.A..............................................................................................................105, 106 Skinners Co. v. Knight [1891] 2 Q.B. 542 C.A. ...................................................................................................801, 819 Skipton B.S. v. Clayton (1993) 66 P. & C.R. 223 C.A. ........................................................................................153, 632 Sleafer v. Lambeth M.B.C. [1960] 1 Q.B. 43 C.A................................................................................................195, 632 Slipper v. Tottenham & Hampstead Junction Rly (1867) L.R. 4 Eq. 112 ...................................................................728 Slough see R. v. Slough B.C. Slough B.C. v. Robbins [1996] C.L.Y. 3832 .................................................................................................................318 Slough Picture Hall Co. Ltd. v. Wade (1916) 32 T.L.R. 542 .......................................................................................602 Smalley v. Quarrier [1975] 1 W.L.R. 938 C.A. ...................................................................................................111, 114 Smart (J.W.) (Modern Shoe Repairs) Ltd. v. Hinkley & Leicester B.S. [1952] 2 All E.R. 846 C.A.............................571 Smedley v. Chumley & Hawke Ltd. (1982) 44 P.& C.R. 50 C.A.........................................................................249, 680 Smiley v. Townshend [1950] 2 K.B. 311 C.A. .....................................................................................................682, 683 Smirk v. Lyndale Developments Ltd. [1975] Ch. 317 C.A. .........................................................................................599 Smith & Stott,Re (1883) 29 Ch.D. 1009n ..................................................................................................................389 Smith v. Blackmore (1885) 1 T.L.R. 267 .....................................................................................................................601 Smith v. City Petroleum Co. [1940] 1 All E.R. 260 .....................................................................................................700 Smith v. Day (1837) 2 M. & W. 684, 150 E.R. 931.....................................................................................................743 Smith v. Draper (1990) 60 P. & C.R. 252 C.A. ...........................................................................................................560 Smith v. Eggington (1874) L.R. 9 C.P. 145 .........................................................................................................755, 782 Smith v. Grayton Estates Ltd. [1960] S.C. 349 ...........................................................................................................127 Smith v. Howell (1851) 6 Ex. 730, 155 E.R. 739, Pollock J. ...............................................................................790–791 Smith v. Kinsey [1936] 3 All E.R. 73 ...........................................................................................................................758 Smith v. Lawson (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 466 C.A. ..........................................................................................................647 Smith v. Marrable (1843) 11 M. & W. 5, 152 E.R. 693 ..............................................................................251, 258, 691 Smith v. McGoldrick [1977] 1 E.G.L.R. 53 C.A. .........................................................................................................336 Smith v. Northside Developments Ltd. (1988) 55 P. & C.R. 164 C.A. .......................................................................554 Smith v. Overseers of St Michael, Cambridge (1860) 3 El. & El. 383, 121 E.R. 486 ...................................................554 Smith v. Peat (1853) 9 Exch.161, 156 E.R. 69 ............................................................................................................790 Smith v. Roberts (1892) 9 T.L.R. 77 C.A. ..............................................................................................................40, 601 Smith v. Seghill Overseers (1875) L.R. 10 Q.B. 422, Mellor J. ....................................................................................185 Smith v. Smith (1636) 1 Rep. Ch. 108, 21 E.R. 521....................................................................................................597 Smith, Ex parte see R. v. Northavon D.C. Smith’s Lease,Re [1951] 1 All E.R. 346, Roxburgh J. .........................................................................................292, 740 Smith (Colin) Music Ltd. v. Ridge [1975] 1 W.L.R. 463 C.A. ....................................................................................105 Smith (W.H.) Ltd. v. Wyndham Investments Ltd. (1995) 70 P. & C.R. 21. ..............................................................787 Snipper v. Enever Freeman & Co. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 270, Sheen J. ...........................................................................411
lxxii
TABLE OF CASES
Snook v. London & West Riding Investments Ltd. [1967] 2 Q.B. 786 C.A. ...............................................................153 Snook v. Schofield [1975] 1 E.G.L.R. 69 C.A. .............................................................................................................560 Solent Pines Residents Association Ltd. v. Campbell [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 213 L.V.T. ...................................................438 Somerset (Duke of) v. Fogwell (1826) 5 B. & C. 875, 108 E.R. 325. .............................................................................30 Somma v. Hazelhurst [1978] 1 W.L.R. 1014 C.A. ............................................................153–154, 155–156, 157–158 Sonnethal v. Newton (1965) 109 S.J. 333 C.A.............................................................................................................736 Sood v. Barker [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 87 C.A. ...................................................................................................................820 Sopwith v. Stutchbury (1985) 17 H.L.R. 50 C.A. .......................................................................................131, 236, 336 Soteri v. Pyslides [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 138 C.A. ..............................................................................................................818 Sotheby v. Grundy [1947] 2 All E.R. 761.............................................................................................................249, 680 South Glamorgan C.C. v. Griffiths (1992) 24 H.L.R. 334 C.A....................................................................................496 South Holland D.C. v. Keyle (1985) 19 H.L.R. 97 C.A. .............................................................................................177 South Northants D.C. v. Power [1987] 1 W.L.R. 1433 C.A........................................................................................120 South of England Dairies Ltd. v. Baker [1906] 2 Ch. 631, Joyce J. .....................................................................297, 760 South West Water Authority v. Palmer [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 5 C.A. .............................................................................614 Southampton Community Health Services N.H.S. Trust v. Crown Estate Commissioners [1997] E.G.C.S. 155 .................................................................................................................................152, 551, 596 Southcomb v. Bishop of Exeter (1847) 6 Hare 213, 67 E.R. 1145 ...............................................................................528 Southern Depot Co. Ltd. v. British Railways Board [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 39, Morritt J. ...............................................820 Southport Old Links Ltd. v. Naylor [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 66 C.A....................................................................................560 Southwark L.B.C. v. Bente [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 2986 .......................................................................................................259 Southwark L.B.C. v. Camacho [2000] 06 C.L. 468 .............................................................................................195, 247 Southwark L.B.C. v. Edem [1999] 07 C.L. 264 C.Ct. .........................................................................................245, 334 Southwark L.B.C. v. Kennedy [1998] 2 C.L.Y 2988 ....................................................................................................341 Southwark L.B.C. v. Logan (1997) 29 H.L.R. 40 C.A. ...............................................................................172, 173, 174 Southwark L.B.C. v. Mills [1999] 4 All E.R. 449 H.L. ..............................................247, 248, 250, 251, 267, 277, 309, 310, 690, 691, 717, 718, 719, 720, 721 Southwark L.B.C. v. Sarfo [1999] 12 C.L. 413 C.A. ...........................................................................................335, 338 Southwark L.B.C. v. Simpson (1999) 31 H.L.R. 725 Div.Ct. .............................................................................266, 268 Southwark L.B.C. v. Tornaritis [1999] 07 C.L. 330 C.Ct............................................................................................461 Southwell v. Scotter (1880) 49 L.J.Q.B. 356 C.A. .......................................................................................................602 Sovmots Investments Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1979] A.C. 144 H.L. .............................................................417 Sparkes v. Smart [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 245 C.A..............................................................................................602, 619–620 Sparkle Properties Ltd. v. Residential Developments Ltd. [1998] unreported. ...........................................................453 Spark’s Lease,Re [1905] 1 Ch. 456, Swinfen Eady J. ..................................................................................................740 Spath Holme Ltd. v. Greater Manchester & Lancashire R.A.C. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 80 C.A. ..............................................................................................228–229, 231, 232, 233, 239 Speedwell Estates Ltd., Re [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 121 L.Tr........................................................................................412, 414 Spencer’s case (1583) 5 Co. Rep. 16a, 77 E.R. 72 ...............................295, 712, 749, 750–751, 752, 755, 757, 764–770 Spirit Motorsport Ltd., Re [1996] 1 B.C.L.C. 684, Laddie J. ......................................................................................786 Spiro v. Glencrown Properties Ltd. [1991] Ch. 537, Hoffmann J. .............................................................................536 Spook Erection Ltd. v. British Railways Board [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 76 C.A...................................................................571 Spoor v. Green (1874) L.R. 9 Exch. 99 ........................................................................................................................720 Sporrong v. Sweden (1982) 5 E.H.R.R. 35 ..................................................................................................................201 Sport International Bussum B.V. v. Inter-Footwear Ltd. [1984] 1 All E.R. 376 C.A., on appeal [1984] 1 W,L,R, 776 H.L. ...............................................................................................................................531, 532 Sportoffer Ltd. v. Erewash B.C.[1999] E.G.C.S. 37, Lloyd J. ......................................................................................710 Springfield Investments Ltd. v. Bell (1990) 22 H.L.R. 441 C.A. .................................................................................185 Spyer v. Phillipson [1931] 2 Ch. 183 C.A. ..................................................................................................370, 697–699 Stacey v. Hill [1901] 1 Q.B. 660 C.A. .................................................................................................................786–787 Stafford v. Charnwood B.C. (2000) 32 H.L.R. 289 .....................................................................................................273 Staines Warehousing Co. Ltd. v. Montague Executor and Trustee Co. (1987) 54 P. & C.R. 302 C.A. ......................660 Stait v. Fenner [1912] 2 Ch. 504 .................................................................................................................................597 Standard Life Co. Ltd. v. Greycoat Devonshire Square Ltd. [2000] E.G.C.S. 40, [2000] Times April 10th..........................................................................................................................................666 Standard Life Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Unipath Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 121 C.A. .................................................658, 659 Standard Pattern Co. Ltd. v. Ivey [1962] Ch. 432, Wilberforce J.......................................................................816, 817 Standen v. Christmas (1847) 10 Q.B. 135, 116 E.R. 53 ..............................................................................................755 Stanhope Pension Trust Ltd. v. Registrar of Companies [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 118 Ch.D. .............................380, 775, 786
TABLE OF CASES
lxxiii
Stanhope v. Haworth (1886) 3 T.L.R. 34 C.A. ...................................................................................................817, 826 Stanley v. Compton [1951] 1 All E.R. 859 C.A............................................................................................148, 176, 496 Stanley v. Towgood (1836) 3 Bing N.C. 4, 132 E.R. 310.............................................................................................675 Stanton v. Southwick [1920] 2 K.B. 642......................................................................................................................246 Stapel v. Bellshore Property Investments Ltd. [2000] 08 C.L. 477 ..............................................................................462 Star Rider Ltd. v. Inntrepreneur Pub Co. Ltd. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 53...........................................................198, 638, 648 Starkey v. Barton [1909] 1 Ch. 284 .............................................................................................................................583 Starrokate Ltd. v. Burry [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 56 C.A. ..........................................................................................373, 802 Starside Properties Ltd. v. Mustapha [1974] 1 W.L.R. 816 C.A..................................................................................835 Staszewski v. Maribella Ltd. [1998] 1 E.G.L.R. 34 C.A.......................................................................................431, 443 Staves v. Leeds C.C. (1990) 23 H.L.R. 107 C.A. .........................................................................................................245 Stavrides v. Manku [1997] E.G.C.S. 58 Ch.D. ............................................................................................................657 Stedman v. Midland Bank plc. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 146 C.A.........................................................................................655 Steeds v. Steeds (1889) 12 Q.B.D. 531 .........................................................................................................................525 Steele v. McMahon [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 114 C.A. .................................................................................................241, 289 Stening v. Abrahams [1931] 1 Ch. 470........................................................................................................................726 Stent v. Monmouth B.C. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 59 C.A. ..................................................................................249, 250, 680 Stephens v. Bridges (1821) 6 Madd. 66, 56 E.R. 1015 .........................................................................................596, 743 Stephenson (Robert) & Co.,Re [1915] 1 Ch. 802 ........................................................................................................764 Stephenson & Son v. Orca Properties Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 129...............................................................................592 Stephenson Poole & Co. Ltd.,Re [1915] 1 Ch. 802, Sargant J. ....................................................................................769 Sterling Estates Ltd. v. Pickard U.K. Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 33 Ch.D. .......................................................................775 Stevens & Cutting v. Anderson [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 95 C.A. .........................................................................................564 Stevens v. Sedgeman [1951] 2 K.B. 434 ..............................................................................................................607, 609 Stevenson & Rush (Holdings) Ltd. v. Langdon (1978) 28 P. & C.R. 208 C.A. ...................................................558, 568 Stevenson v. Lambard (1802) 2 East. 575, 102 E.R. 480, Ellenborough C.J. .............................................................759 Steyning & Littlehampton B.S. v. Wilson [1951] Ch. 1018 ........................................................................................613 Stile Hall Properties Ltd. v. Gooch [1980] 1 W.L.R. 62 C.A........................................................................................562 Stiles v. Farrow [1977] 1 E.G.L.R. 5. ..........................................................................................................................627 Stimpson v. Smith [1999] N.L.J. 414 C.A. ..................................................................................................................747 Stockdale v. Ascherberg [1904] 1 K.B. 447 C.A. .................................................................................................218, 668 Stockley v. Knowsley M.B.C. [1986] 2 E.G.L.R. 141 C.A. ..........................................................................................254 Stock Gayland Estate Co. v. Rendell [2000] 02 C.L. 374 .............................................................................................589 Stokes v. Costain Property Investments Ltd. [1983] 1 W.L.R. 907, Harman J., [1984] 1 W.L.R. 763 C.A. ..............698 Stone v. Whitcombe (1980) 40 P. & C.R. 296 C.A. ....................................................................................................614 Stone (J. & F). Lighting and Radio Ltd. v. Levitt [1947] A.C. 209 H.L. ....................................................................166 Stoneman v. Brown [1973] 1 W.L.R. 459 C.A. ..........................................................................................................623 Storehouse Properties Ltd. v. Ocobase Ltd. [1998] Times April 3rd, Rimer J. ...........................................727, 735, 812 Strand & Savoy Properties Ltd., Re [1960] Ch. 582 ....................................................................................................537 Strand Securities Ltd. v. Caswell [1965] Ch. 958 C.A. ................................................................................................383 Stratford on Avon C. v. Parker [1914] 2 K.B. 562 ......................................................................................................751 Stratford v. Syrett [1958] 1 Q.B. 107 C.A. ..................................................................................................................303 Strathford East Kilbride Ltd. v. Film Design Ltd. [1997] S.C.L.R. 877. [1997] Times December 1st .......251, 679, 690 Stratton (R.J.) Ltd. v. Wallis Tomlin & Co. Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 104 C.A. ...........................................................559 Straudley Investments Ltd. v. Mount Eden Land Ltd. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 306 C.A..................................................737 Stream Properties Ltd. v. Davis [1972] 1 W.L.R. 645, Pennycuick V.C.....................................................................667 Street v. Mountford [1985] A.C. 809 H.L., reversing (1985) 49 P. & C.R. 324 C.A. ....................................................143, 149–150, 151, 152, 154–159, 170–171, 175, 177, 179, 185, 302, 551, 552, 613 Stretch v. West Dorset D.C. [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 62 C.A. ...............................................................294, 302, 536, 547, 725 Stribling v. Wickham [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 35 C.A. ........................................................................................144, 153–157 Strong v. Stringer (1889) 61 L.T. 470 ..................................................................................................................531, 823 Stroud B.S. v. Delamont [1960] 1 W.L.R. 431 ............................................................................................................307 Stuart v. Joy [1904] 1 K.B 362 C.A. ....................................................................................................................750, 782 Stubbs v. Hartnell (1977) 74 P. & C.R. D36 ...............................................................................................................183 Stuchbery v. General Accident Fire & Life Assurance Corporation Ltd. [1949] 2 K.B. 256 .......................................540 Sturcke v. S.W. Edwards Ltd. (1971) 23 P. & C.R. 185, Goff J. .................................................................................683 Sturgess v. Farrington (1812) 4 Taunt. 614, 128 E.R. 471 .........................................................................................788 Sturloson & Co. v. Mauroux (1988) 20 H.L.R. 332 C.A. ...................................................................229, 260, 262, 674
lxxiv
TABLE OF CASES
Sturolson & Co. v. Weniz [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 121 C.A. .......................................................................................153–157 Stylo Barratt Properties Ltd. v. Legal & General Assurance Society Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 116 Ch.D. ....................664 Sudbrooke Trading Estate Ltd. v. Eggleton [1983] A.C. 444 H.L. ...............................................................................536 Summerfield v. Hampstead B.C. [1957] 1 W.L.R. 167, Harman J. ............................................................................224 Summers v. Salford Corporation [1943] A.C. 283 H.L. ..............................................................................246, 252, 253 Summerson, Re [1900] 1 Ch. 112n .............................................................................................................................814 Sumnall v. Statt [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 4 C.A. ..................................................................................................................624 Sun Alliance & London Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Hayman [1975] 1 W.L.R. 177, [1975] 1 All E.R. 248 C.A. ...............................................................................................................................560, 561 Sun Insurance Office v. Galinsky [1914] 2 K.B. 545....................................................................................................688 Sun Life Assurance Society plc. v. Tantofex (Engineers) Ltd. [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 135 Ch.D........................................786 Sunflower Services Ltd. v. Unisys N.Z. Ltd. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 112 ........................................................................659 Surrey C.C. v. Lamond [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 32 C.A.......................................................................................................186 Surzar Overseas Ltd. v. Ocean Reliance Shipping Co. Ltd. [1997] 1 C.L.Y. 906, Toulson J.......................................648 Sussex Investments Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1997] Times December 29th C.A. .........................................182 Sutherland Orphan Asylum v. River Wear Commissioners [1912] 1 Ch. 191 ....................................................304, 750 Sutton (Hasloe) H.Ass. Ltd. v. Williams [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 56 C.A. ..........................................................................459 Sutton Housing Trust v. Lawrence (1987) 19 H.L.R. 520 C.A. ..................................................................................345 Sutton L.B.C. v. Morgan Grenfell & Co. Ltd. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 608 C.A. ...................................................................11 Sutton L.B.C. v. Swann (1985) 18 H.L.R. 140 C.A. ............................................................................................502, 503 Sutton v. Dorf [1932] 2 K.B. 304, Acton J...........................................................................................................111, 115 Sutton v. Temple (1843) 12 M. & W. 52, 152 E.R. 1108 ...................................................................................251, 690 Swain v. Ayres (1888) 21 Q.B.D. 289 C.A. .................................................................524, 526, 527, 529, 531, 532, 823 Swain v. Hillman [1999] Times November 4th C.A. .................................................................................................324 Swann v. White [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 99 L.Tr. ........................................................................................................412, 414 Swanbrae v. Elliott (1987) 19 H.L.R 86 C.A. ..............................................................................................................121 Swansea C.C. v. Hearn (1991) 23 H.L.R. 284 C.A................................................................................................26, 145 Swansea Corporation v. Thomas (1882) 10 Q.B.D. 48, Pollock B. ............................................................................758 Swanson v. Forton [1949] Ch. 143 C.A. ..............................................................................................................292, 738 Sweet & Maxwell Ltd. v. Universal News Services Ltd. [1964] 2 Q.B. 699 C.A..........................................................633 Swift (P. & A.) Investments v. Combined English Stores group plc. [1989] A.C. 632 H.L. ...............................................................................764, 766, 767, 771, 772, 780, 782, 783, 787 Swift v. Dairywise Farms Ltd. [2000] 1 All E.R. 320, Jacob J. ....................................................................................629 Swift v. Macbean [1942] 1 K.B. 375, Birkett J.....................................................................................222, 512, 518, 716 Swiss Bank Corporation v. Lloyds Bank Ltd. [1979] Ch. 548, [1982] A.C. 584 H.L. .................................................526 Swordheath Properties Ltd. v. Tabet [1979] 1 W.L.R. 285 C.A. .................................................................................807 Syed Hussain v. A.M. Abdullah Sahib & Co. [1985] 1 W.L.R. 1392 Div.Ct .............................................................330 Syed v. Syed (1980) 1 F.L.R. 129..................................................................................................................................131 Sykes v. Land [1984] 2 E.G.L.R. 8 C.A. .......................................................................................................................617 System Floors Ltd. v. Ruralpride Ltd. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 48 C.A.................................................................................631 T. v. S. [1994] 2 F.L.R. 883 .........................................................................................................................................139 T.C.B. Ltd. v. Gray [1987] Ch. 458, [1988] 1 All E.R. 108 C.A. ...............................................................................781 Taber v. Macdonald (1999) 31 H.L.R. 73 Div.Ct. ......................................................................................................461 Tabor v. Ginns [1995] E.G.C.S. 183 C.A.....................................................................................................................526 Tadema Holdings Ltd. v. Ferguson [1999] Times November 25th C.A. ......................27, 28, 226, 319, 580, 591, 592 Tadman v. Henman [1893] 2 Q.B. 168 ......................................................................................................................565 Taggart v. Leeds C.C. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 693, Richards J. ...........................................................................................270 Tagro v. Cafane [1991] 1 W.L.R. 378 C.A. ........................................................................................................313, 314 Tailby v. Official Receiver (1888) 13 App. Cas. 523 H.L. ...........................................................................................527 Taj v. Ali [2000] Times April 28th C.A. ....................................................................................................................337 Take Harvest Ltd. v. Liu [1993] A.C. 552 P.C. ....................................................................................38, 597–598, 599 Talbot v. Ford (1842) 13 Sim. 173, 60 E.R. 66 .......................................................................................................526 Tandon v. Spurgeons Homes Trustees [1982] A.C. 755 H.L. ......................................................................................400 Tandridge D.C. v. Bicker [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 31 C.A....................................................................................................503 Tanham v. Nicholson (1872) L.R. 5 H.L. 561 H.L......................................................................................................592 Tapsell v. Cemery (1995) 27 H.L.R. 114 C.A. ............................................................................................................182 Target Home Loans Ltd. v. Iza Ltd. [2000] 02 E.G. 117 C.Ct. ..........................................376, 803, 809, 817, 824, 829 Targett v. Torfaen B.C. [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 275 C.A. ...........................................................................................251, 690
TABLE OF CASES
lxxv
Tarjomani v. Panther Securities Ltd. (1983) 46 P. & C.R. 32, Gibson J.....................................................................558 Tarr v. Tarr [1973] A.C. 254 H.L. ..............................................................................................................................131 Tatem v. Chaplin (1793) 2 H.Bl. 133, 126 E.R. 470 ...................................................................................................768 Taylor v. Beal (1591) Cro.Eliz. 222, 78 E.R. 478 .......................................................................................................257 Taylor v. Caldwell (1863) 3 B. & S. 826, 122 E.R. 309 .......................................................................................553, 713 Taylor v. Courage Ltd. [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 127 C.A. ....................................................................................................543 Taylor v. Ellis [1960] Ch. 368, [1960] 2 All E.R. 549 .................................................................................................307 Taylor v. Knowsley B.C. (1985) 17 H.L.R. 376 C.A. (1988) ...............................................................................259, 260 Taylor v. Newham L.B.C. [1993] 1 W.L.R. 444 C.A...................................................................................................502 Taylor v. Okey (1806) 13 Ves. 180, 33 E.R. 263, Lord Erskine L.C. ..........................................................................648 Taylor v. Twinberrow [1930] 2 K.B. 16.......................................................................................................................751 Taylor v. Walsall & District Property Investment Co. Ltd. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 1062 Div.Ct. .......................................270 Taylor v. Webb [1937] 2 K.B. 283 C.A. ..............................................................................................................264, 678 Taylor’s Fashions Ltd. v. Liverpool Victoria Trustees Co. Ltd. [1982] Q.B. 133, Oliver J. .........................................538 Tea Trade Properties Ltd. v. C.I.N. Properties Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 155, Hoffmann J...........................................666 Teasdale v. Walker [1958] 1 W.L.R. 1076 C.A............................................................................................544, 545, 546 Teeside Indoor Bowls Ltd. v. Stockton-on-Tees B.C. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 87 C.A..........................................................571 Tegerdine v. Brooks (1978) 36 P. & C.R. 261 C.A. ...............................................................................................47, 560 Televantos v. McCulloch [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 123 C.A. ................................................................................257, 336, 647 Teltscher Bros. v. London & India Dock Investments Ltd. [1989] 1 W.L.R. 770 .......................................................560 Templiss Properties Ltd. v. Hyams [1999] E.G.C.S. 60 ...............................................................................................520 Tenbry Investments Ltd. v. Peugeot Talbot Motor Co. Ltd. [1992] S.T.C. 791 Ch.D. .......................................218, 645 Tennant v. Field (1857) 8 E. & B. 336, 120 E.R. 125 ..................................................................................................652 Tennant Radiant Heat Ltd. v. Warrington Development Corporation [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 41 C.A.............................674 Terra Woningen v. Netherlands (1997) 24 E.H.R.R. 456 ...........................................................................................205 Terrell v. Murray (1901) 17 T.L.R. 570. Div.Ct. ................................................................................................264, 678 Terroni & Necchi v. Corsini [1931] 1 Ch. 515, Maugham J. .....................................................................................682 Texaco Ltd. v. Benton & Bowles Holdings Ltd. [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 62 Falconer J. ......................................................667 Thackray (Robert)’s Estate v. Kaye [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 127 C.A. ................................................................................107 Thalmann v. Evans [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3788 ...................................................................................................................549 Thames Heliport Ltd. v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. (1997) 74 P. & C.R. 164 C.A. ..........................................................708 Thames Manufacturing Co. Ltd. v. Perrotts (Nichol & Peyton) Ltd. (1985) 50 P. & C.R. 1 C.A. .............................777 Thatcher v. C.H. Pearce & Sons (Contractors) Ltd. [1968] 1 W.L.R. 748, Simon P. ...............................818, 821, 822 Thellusson v. Liddard [1900] 2 Ch. 635 .....................................................................................................................596 Theodore Goddard v. Fletcher King Services Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 131 Q.B.D. .......................................................659 Thetford v. Tyler (1845) 8 Q.B. 95, 115 E.R. 810 ...............................................................................................212, 641 Thomas v. Cadawallader (1744) Willes. 496, 125 E.R. 1286 .....................................................................................671 Thomas v. Cook (1818) 2 B. & Ald. 119, 106 E.R. 310 ...............................................................................................600 Thomas v. Hammond-Lawrence [1986] 1 W.L.R. 456 C.A. ......................................................................................667 Thomas v. Hayward (1869) L.R. 4 Ex. 311 ........................................................................................................712, 770 Thompson v. Elmbridge B.C. [1987] 1 W.L.R. 1425 C.A. ................................................................132, 141, 312, 333 Thompson v. Stimson [1961] 1 Q.B. 195 Div.Ct.........................................................................................................581 Thompson v. Thompson [1976] Fam. 25 C.A. ............................................................................................136, 137, 140 Thompsons (Funeral Furnishers) Ltd. v. Phillips [1945] 2 All E.R. 49 C.A. ................................................................22 Thorn v. Woollcombe (1832) 3 B. & Ad. 586, 110 E.R. 213........................................................................................726 Thornton (J.W.) Ltd. v. Blacks Leisure Group plc. (1987) 53 P. & C.R. 223 C.A. ......................................................571 Thrasyvoulou v. Hackney L.B.C. (1986) 18 H.L.R. 370 .............................................................................................272 Thursby v. Plant (1669) 1 Lev. 259, 83 E.R. 359 (1669) 1 Saund. 230, 85 E.R. 254..........................................750, 781 Tichborne v. Weir [1892] 67 L.T. 735 C.A. .................................................................................................................751 Tickner v. Buzzacott [1965] Ch. 426, Plowman J. ......................................................................................................824 Tickner v. Hearn [1960] 1 W.L.R. 1406 .............................................................................................................107, 108 Tideway Investment & Property Holdings Ltd. v. Wellwood [1952] Ch. 791 C.A. ....................................................693 Tidey v. Mollett (1864) 16 C.B. N.S. 298, 143 E.R. 1143............................................................................................521 Tinsley v. Milligan [1994] 1 A.C. 340 H.L. .................................................................................................................525 Tilling v. Whiteman [1980] A.C. 1 H.L. ....................................................................................................163, 348, 349 Tingey v. Sutton [1984] 1 W.L.R. 1154 C.A. ..............................................................................................................238 Tito v. Waddell (No.2) [1977] Ch. 106, Megarry V.C................................................................................................683 Tokenhold see Rainbow Estates Toleman v. Portbury (1872) L.R. 7 Q.B. 344 Exch.Ch. .............................................................................................814
lxxvi
TABLE OF CASES
Tolhurst v. Associated Portland Cement Manufacturers (1900) Ltd. [1903] A.C. 414 H.L. ......................................528 Tollbench Ltd. v. Plymouth C.C. [1988] 1 E.G.L.R. 79 C.A........................................................................................710 Tomlinson v. Millins [1998] E.G.C.S. 178 Ch.D.................................................................................................536, 689 Tomlinssons (R.H.) (Trowbridge) Ltd. v. S.S. for the Environment [1999] Times August 31st C.A..........................322 Tooker v. Smith (1857) 1 H. & N. 732, 156 E.R. 1396..........................................................................................24, 515 Tormes Property Co. Ltd. v. Landau [1971] 1 Q.B. 261 C.A. ............................................................................228, 231 Torminster Properties Ltd. v. Green [1983] 1 W.L.R. 676 C.A. .................................................................................597 Torrens v. Walker [1906] 2 Ch. 166, Warrington J. ..........................................................................252, 671, 677, 706 Torriano v. Young (1833) 6 C. & P. 8, 172 E.R. 1123 .......................................................................262, 263, 673, 674 Torridge D.C. v. Jones (1985) 18 H.L.R. 107 C.A. .............................................................................................319, 336 Total Oil Great Britain Ltd. v. Thompson Garages (Biggin Hill) Ltd. [1972] 1 Q.B. 318 C.A...........................258, 691 Tottenham Hotspur Football & Athletic Co. Ltd. v. Princegrove Publishers Ltd. [1974] 1 W.L.R. 113 ................................................................................................................520, 525, 529, 534, 556 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Abadie (1990) 22 H.L.R. 264 C.A.; ....................................................................................332 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Abdi (1992) 25 H.L.R. 80 C.A. ..............................................................................8, 319, 320 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Ayinde (1994) 26 H.L.R. 631 C.A.................................................................................39, 600 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Azad (1998) 30 H.L.R. 241 C.A..................................................................................331, 335 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Kellum [2000] 06 C.L. 466 C.Ct. ........................................................................................341 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Long (2000) 32 H.L.R. 219 C.A. .........................................................................................343 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Miah (1992) 24 H.L.R. 199 C.A. .......................................................................................171 Town Investments Ltd. v. Department of the Environment [1978] A.C. 359 H.L. ..................................541, 542, 546 Town Investments Ltd.’s Underlease,Re [1954] Ch. 301, Danckwerts J.....................................................726, 737, 739 Toyota (GB) Ltd. v. Legal & General Assurance (Pensions Management) Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 123 C.A. .....................................................................................................................................664 Trane (U.K.) Ltd. v. Provident Mutual Life Assurance [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 33 ....................................................522, 583 Trans-Britannia Properties Ltd. v. Darby Properties Ltd. [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 151 C.A. .............................................546 Transworld Land Co Ltd. v. J. Sainsbury plc. [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 255 .........................................................................712 Travers v. Gloucester Corporation [1947] K.B. 71, [1946] 2 All E.R. 506, Lewis J. ..................................................260 Tredegar v. Harwood [1929] A.C. 72 H.L. ........................................................................................685, 737, 738, 739 Treloar v. Bigge (1874) L.R. 9 Ex. 151.................................................................................................................734, 799 Treseder-Griffin v. Co-Operative Insurance Ltd. [1956] 2 Q.B. 127 C.A. .................................................................644 Troop v. Gibson [1986] 1 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A....................................................................................................................657 Truscott v. Diamond Rock Boring Co. (1882) 20 Ch.D. 251 C.A. .............................................................................675 Tsao v. S.S. for the Environment (1996) 28 H.L.R. 259 Q.B.D. .................................................................................273 Tulapam Properties Ltd v. De Almeida [1981] 2 E.G.L.R. 55 Q.B.D. ........................................................................820 Tummon v. Barclays Bank Trust Co. Ltd. (1979) 39 P. & C.R. 300 ..........................................................................627 Tunstall v. Steigmann [1962] 2 Q.B. 593 C.A.............................................................................................................572 Turley v. King [1944] 2 All E.R. 489 Div.Ct. .............................................................................................................267 Turley v. Panton (1975) 29 P. & C.R. 397 ..................................................................................................................126 Turner & Bell v. Searles(Stanford-le-Hope) Ltd. (1977) 33 P. & C.R. 208 C.A. .......................................................568 Turner v. Allday (1836) Tyr. & Cr. 819. ............................................................................................................211, 645 Turner v. Clowes (1869) 20 L.T. 214, Malins V.C. .....................................................................................................533 Turner v. Lamb (1845) 14 M. & W. 412, 153 E.R. 535 .............................................................................................682 Turner v. Walsh [1909] 2 K.B. 484 C.A. ....................................................................................................................762 Turner v. Wandsworth L.B.C. [1994] 1 E.G.L.R. 134 C.A..................................................................................570, 571 Turner v. Watts (1928) 97 L.J.K.B. 403 C.A. .............................................................................................................596 Turone v. Howard de Walden Estates Ltd. (No. 2) [1983] 2 E.G.L.R. 65 C.A. ..........................................................567 Tustian v. Johnston [1993] 2 E.G.L.R. 8 C.A. ............................................................................................................624 Twinsectra Ltd. v. Jones [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 129 L.Tr...................................................................................................431 Twogate Properties Ltd. v. Birmingham Midshires B.S. (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 386 C.A. .....................................603, 810 Twynam v. Pickard (1818) 2 B. & Ald. 105, 106 E.R. 305..........................................................................................758 Tyler v. Kensington & Chelsea R.B.C. (1991) 23 H.L.R. 380 C.A...............................................................................494 Tyler v. Woodspring D.C. [1991] J.P.L. 727 ...............................................................................................................180 U.D.S. Tailoring Ltd. v. B.L. Holdings Ltd. [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 61 C.A. ......................................................................667 Uddin v. Birmingham C.C. (1990) 59 P. & C.R. 341..................................................................................................409 Ujima H.Ass. v. Ansah (1998) 30 H.L.R. 831 C.A. ..............................................................................45, 105, 107, 346 Ujima H.Ass. v. Jones (1998) 30 H.L.R. 831 C.A. .........................................................................................................54 Ujima H.Ass. v. Richardson [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3771, Graham J. ....................................................................................56
TABLE OF CASES
lxxvii
Ultraworth Ltd. v. General Accident Fire & Life Assurance Corporation plc. [2000] E.G.C.S. 19..............................683 Unchained Growth III plc. v. Granby Village (Manchester) Management Co. Ltd. [1999] Times November 4th C.A. ..........................................................................................................461, 648, 706 Uniproducts (Manchester) Ltd. v. Rose Furnishers Ltd. [1956] 1 W.L.R. 45, [1956] 1 All E.R. 146 .........................254 United Dairies Ltd. v. Public Trustee [1923] 1 K.B. 469, Greer J. ..............................................................................759 United Dominions Trust v. Shellpoint Trustees [1993] 4 All E.R. 310 C.A. ......................................................816, 826 United Scientific Holdings Ltd. v. Burnley B.C. [1978] A.C. 904 H.L.......................211, 639, 650, 655, 657, 659, 668 Universities Superannuation Scheme Ltd. v. Marks & Spencer plc. [1999] 1 E.G.L.R. 13 C.A. ................458, 704, 705 University College, Oxford v. Durdy [1982] Ch. 413, [1982] 1 All E.R. 1108 C.A. ..................................................628 University of Reading v. Johnson-Houghton [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 113...........................................................................551 Upjohn v. Hitchens [1918] 2 K.B. 48 C.A. .................................................................................................................685 Uratemp Ventures Ltd. v. Collins [1999] Times December 10th C.A. ...............................................................145, 146 Uxbridge v. Staveland (1747) 1 Ves. Sen. 56, 27 E.R. 888 ..........................................................................................766 V.C.S. Car Park Management Ltd. v. Regional Railways North East Ltd. [2000] 1 All E.R. 403 C.A. ......................572 Vacher v. France (1997) 24 E.H.R.R. 482 ..................................................................................................................205 Vale of White Horse D.C. v. Allen & Partners [1997] Env. L.R. 212, Bell J. .............................................................268 Vale of White Horse D.C. v. Mirmalek-Sani (1993) 25 H.L.R. 387 Div.Ct. ..............................................................182 Van Haarlam v. Kasner [1992] 2 E.G.L.R. 59, Harman J. ................................................................................592, 820 Vandersteen v. Agius (1992) 65 P. & C.R. 266 C.A. ...........................................................................................159, 820 Vasilescu v. Romania [1999] 28 E.H.R.R. 241. ..........................................................................................................201 Vaudeville Electric Cinema Ltd. v. Muriset [1923] 2 Ch. 74.......................................................................................698 Vaughan-Armatrading v. Sarsah (1995) 27 H.L.R. 631 C.A. ....................................................................................174 Vaux Group Ltd. v. Lilley [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 60, Knox J. ..................................................................302, 378, 730, 740 Vedmay,Re (1995) 69 P. & C.R. 247...........................................................................................................................775 Venetian Glass Gallery Ltd. v. Next Properties Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 42, Harman J. ......................................735, 740 Venus Investments Ltd. v. Stocktop Ltd. (1997) 74 P.& C.R. D23 C.A.......................................................................554 Verkan & Co. Ltd. v. Byland Close (Winchmore Hill) Ltd. [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 139 L.Tr............................................437 Vernon v. Smith (1821) 5 B. & Ald. 1, 106 E.R. 1094 ........................................................................686, 768, 770, 771 Verrall v. Farnes [1966] 1 W.L.R. 1254, Cross J. ...............................................................................................613, 615 Verrall v. Great Yarmouth B.C. [1981] Q.B. 202 C.A. ...............................................................................................534 Vibart v. Coles (1890) 24 Q.B.D. 364..........................................................................................................................525 Vickers v. Stichtenoth Investments Pty. Ltd. (1989) 52 S.A.S.R. 90, Bollen J......................................................221, 615 Vickery v. Martin [1944] K.B. 679 C.A. .....................................................................................................................301 Victor Blake (Menswear) Ltd. v. Westminster C.C. (1979) 38 P. & C.R. 448.............................................................667 Vieniet Ltd. v. W. Williams & Sons (Bread St.) Ltd. [1958] 1 W.L.R. 1267...............................................................734 Vignaud v. John Lyons Free Grammar School Governors [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 179 L.Tr. .............................................407 Viking Property Co. Ltd. v. Rawlinson [1999] 08 C.L. 440 .........................................................................106, 108, 244 Villiers v. Oldcorn [1903] 20 T.L.R. 11........................................................................................................................777 Vincent v. Godson (1853) 1 Sm. & G. 384, 65 E.R. 168 Stuart V.C. on appeal (1854) 4 De G.M. & G. 546, 43 E.R. 620 Lord Cranworth L.C....................................................................................................................524, 526 Visionhire Ltd. v. Britel Fund Trustees [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 128 ...................................................................................659 Vitale, Ex parte re Young (1883) 47 L.T. 480. .............................................................................................................534 Voisey, Ex parte (1882) 21 Ch. D. 442 C.A. ..................................................................................................21–32, 518 Vuong v. Hoang [1999] 05 C.L. 384 ...........................................................................................................................136 Vural Ltd v. Security Archives Ltd (1990) 60 P. & C.R. 258 ...............................................................................687, 688 Vyvyan v. Arthur (1823) 1 B. & C. 410, 107 E.R. 152. ......................................................................766, 770–771, 781 Wadsley,Re (1925) 94 L.J.Ch. 215...............................................................................................................................774 Wagle v. Henry Smith’s Charity Kensington Estate Trustees [1990] 1 Q.B. 42 C.A. ..................................................550 Wainwright v. Leeds C.C. [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 67 C.A. .................................................................................244, 249, 679 Waite v. Jennings [1906] 2 K.B. 11 C.A. .............................................................................................................365, 740 Waitt v. Morris [1994] 2 E.G.L.R. 224 L.V.T. ............................................................................................................408 Wakefield (Tower Hill Trinity Square) Trust v. Janson Green Properties Ltd. [1998] E.G.C.S. 95 Ch.D..................657 Walgrave v. Somerset (1587) Goulds. 72, 75 E.R. 1002......................................................................................261, 672 Walker v. Arkay Caterers Ltd. [1997] E.G.C.S. 107 ...................................................................................................708 Walker v. Badcock [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 163 C.A. ..........................................................................................................181 Walker v. Bartlett (1856) 18 C.B. 845, 139 E.R. 1604.................................................................................................789 Walker v. Crocker [1992]] 1 E.G.L.R. 29 ....................................................................................................................629
lxxviii
TABLE OF CASES
Walker v. Hatton (1842) 2 Dowl. N.S. 263, 152 E.R. 462 ..........................................................................................676 Walker v. Hobbs & Co. (1889) 23 Q.B.D. 458 ...........................................................................................................250 Walker v. Ogilvy (1974) 28 P. & C.R. 288...................................................................................................................108 Walker v. Richardson (1837) 2 M. & W. 882, 150 E.R. 1616 .....................................................................................600 Walker’s case (1587) 3 Co. Rep. 22a, 76 E.R. 676 .......................................................................597, 766, 776, 781, 782 Wallace v. C. Brian Barratt & Son Ltd. [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. .....................................................................615, 726 Wallace v. Manchester C.C. [1998] 3 E.G.L.R. 38 C.A. ....................................................................................259, 706 Wallace v. Patton (1846) 12 Cl. & Fin. 491, 8 E.R. 1501 H.L. ...........................................................................534, 597 Wallis v. Hands [1893] 2 Ch. 75, Chitty J.....................................................................................................39, 598, 600 Wallis v. Semark (1951) 2 T.L.R. 222 C.A. .................................................................................................................516 Walrond v. Hawkins (1875) L.R. 10 C.P. 342 ............................................................................................................812 Walsh see Escalus Walsh v. Fussell (1829) 6 Bing. 163, 130 E.R. 1243. ..................................................................................................772 Walsh v. Griffith-Jones [1978] 2 All E.R. 1002 ...................................................................................................154, 155 Walsh v. Lonsdale (1882) 21 Ch.D. 9 C.A...........................................34, 144, 212, 276, 508–509, 520, 521, 523–534, 640, 643, 651, 755, 756 Walter v. Maunde (1820) 1 Jac. & W. 181, 37 E.R. 344 .............................................................................................758 Walters v. Northern Coal Mining Co. (1855) 5 De G.M. & G. 628, 43 E.R. 1015 .....................................524, 533, 761 Walters v. Roberts (1980) 41 P. & C.R. 210.........................................................................................................175, 613 Waltham Forest L.B.C. v. Thomas [1992] 2 A.C. 198 H.L..........................................................................................120 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Atwell [1995] 1 W.L.R. 95 C.A..................................................................27, 28, 319, 589, 591 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Fadayomi [1987] 1 W.L.R. 1473 C.A. ...........................................................................332, 354 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Griffin [2000] 26 E.G. 147 L.Tr. .....................................................................................460, 461 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Hargreaves (1995) 27 H.L.R. 142 C.A. ...................................................................................342 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Singh (1991) 62 P. & C.R. 216 C.A. .......................................................................542, 544, 546 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Winder [1985] A.C. 461 H.L. ........................................................................................224, 320 Wang v. Wei (1975) 119 S.J. 492 (1976), cited by A. Waite (1980) 130 N.L.J. 939, 941. .................................154, 546 Wansbeck D.C. v. Charlton (1981) 79 L.G.R. 523 C.A. ..............................................................................................502 Wansbeck D.C. v. Marley (1988) 20 H.L.R. 247 C.A. ................................................................................................351 Ward v. Day (1864) 5 B. & S. 359, 122 E.R. 865 ........................................................................................................812 Ward v. Warnke (1990) 22 H.L.R. 496 C.A................................................................................................................172 Warder v. Cooper [1970] Ch. 495, Stamp J. ...............................................................................................................311 Ward-Lee v. Lineham [1993] 1 W.L.R. 754, [1993] 2 All E.R. 1006 C.A. ................................................................563 Warmington v. Miller [1973] Q.B. 877 C.A................................................................................................524, 530, 532 Warner v. Sampson [1959] 1 Q.B. 297 C.A., [1958] 1 Q.B. 404 Ashworth J. ...........................................805, 831, 832 Warnford Investments Ltd. v. Duckworth [1979] 1 Ch. 127, Megarry V.C........................................................787, 791 Warren v. Keen [1954] 1 Q.B. 15 C.A. ...............................................................................261, 262–263, 671, 673, 674 Warren v. Marketing Exchange for Africa [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 247 ..............................................................................736 Warsame v. Hounslow L.B.C. (2000) 32 H.L.R. 335 C.A. ...........................................................................................87 Warwick D.C. v. Freeman (1994) 27 H.L.R. 616 C.A.................................................................................................240 Waters v. Weigall (1591) 2 Anst. 575, 145 E.R. 971 ...................................................................................................257 Wates Estate Agency Services Ltd. v. Bartleys Ltd. [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 87 C.A. ...................................................572, 710 Watkins v. Elmslie [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 81 C.A. ............................................................................................................564 Watkins,Ex parte (1873) L.R. 8 Ch.App. 520 .............................................................................................................653 Watkins v. Milton-next-Gravesend Overseers (1868) L.R. 3 Q.B. 350 .......................................................................554 Watney v. Boardley [1975] 1 W.L.R. 857, Goulding J........................................................................................559, 596 Watson v. Lambeth L.B.C. [2000] 06 C.L. 388..............................................................................................................83 Watson v. Lucas [1980] 1 W.L.R. 1493 C.A................................................................................................................119 Watson v. Saunders-Roe Ltd. [1947] K.B. 437 C.A.............................................................................................213, 641 Watson,Re [1904] 2 K.B. 753. .....................................................................................................................................653 Watts v. Yeend [1987] 1 W.L.R. 323 C.A....................................................................................................................614 Wax v. Chelsea [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 80 ..........................................................................................................127, 411, 430 Weatherall v. Gearing (1806) 12 Ves. 504, 33 E.R. 191 .............................................................................................532 Weatherall v. Smith [1980] 1 W.L.R. 1290 C.A..................................................................................................607, 608 Weaver v. Mogford [1988] 2 E.G.L.R. 48 C.A. ...................................................................................................777, 812 Webb v. Barnet L.B.C. [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 49 C.A........................................................................................................550 Webb v. Frank Bevis Ltd. [1940] 1 All E.R. 247 C.A...................................................................................................696 Webb v. Russell (1789) 3 Term Rep. 393, 100 E.R. 639, Kenyon C.J. .......................................................596, 753, 762 Webb v. Sandown Sports Club Ltd. [2000] E.G.C.S. 13, Arden J. ..............................................................................574
TABLE OF CASES
lxxix
Webber v. Smith (1689) 2 Vern. 103, 23 E.R. 676 ......................................................................................................823 Wedd v. Porter [1916] 2 K.B. 91 C.A. ................................................................................................263, 673, 749, 753 Weddell v. Capes (1836) 1 M. & W. 50, 150 E.R. 341. ...............................................................................................597 Wednesbury see Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v. Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 K.B. 223 C.A. Weeding v. Weeding (1861) 1 J. & H. 424, 70 E.R. 812 ..............................................................................................536 Weeton v. Woodcock (1840) 7 M. & W. 14, 151 E.R. 659 ..........................................................................................700 Weg Motors Ltd. v. Hales [1962] Ch. 49 C.A. .....................................................................................................537, 755 Weinbergs Weatherproofs Ltd. v. Radcliffe Paper Mill Co. Ltd. [1958] Ch. 437, Harman J. .....................................587 Welby v. Casswell [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 1 C.A. ................................................................................................................621 Welch v. Birrane (1974) 29 P. & C.R. 102, Lawson J. ................................................................................738, 799, 813 Wellcome Trust Ltd. v. Hamad [1998] Q.B. 638 C.A. ......................................................................187, 234, 301, 549 Wellcome Trust Ltd. v. Romines [1999] 3 E.G.L.R. 229 L.Tr..............................................................................412, 414 Welsh v. Greenwich L.B.C. [2000] 27 L.S.G. 40, [2000] Times August 4th, C.A. ....................................................249 Welton v. North Cornwall D.C. [1997] 1 W.L.R. 570 C.A. .......................................................................................273 Wentworth Securities Ltd. v. Jones [1980] A.C. 74 H.L. ............................................................................................415 West Country Cleaners (Falmouth) Ltd. v. Saly [1966] 1 W.L.R. 1485, [1966] 3 All E.R. 210 C.A..................537, 583 West Ham Central Charity Board. v. East London Waterworks Ltd. [1900] 1 Ch. 624 ............................................692 West Horndon Industrial Park Ltd. v. Phoenix Timber Group plc. [1995] 1 E.G.L.R. 77 Ch.D. ..............................785 West Kent H.Ass. Ltd. v. Davies (1999) 31 H.L.R. 415 C.A. ..............................................................................341, 342 West Layton Ltd. v. Ford [1979] Q.B. 593 C.A. .........................................................................................292, 737–739 West Middlesex Golf Club Ltd. v. Ealing L.B.C. (1995) 68 P. & C.R. 461 Ch.D. .......................................................537 West v. Gwynne [1911] 2 Ch. 1 C.A. ..........................................................................................................................740 West v. Rogers (1888) 4 T.L.R. 229 Div.Ct..................................................................................................................819 West Wiltshire D.C. v. Snelgrove (1998) 30 H.L.R. 57 C.A. ......................................................167, 177, 311, 316–317 Westacott v. Hahn [1918] 1 K.B. 495 C.A...................................................................................................................671 Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale v. Islington L.B.C. [1994] 4 All E.R. 890, 945, Hobhouse J., on appeal [1996] A.C. 669 H.L. ..............................................................................................................................................646 Western v. Pim (1814) 3 Ves. & B. 197, 35 E.R. 453 ..................................................................................................533 Western Heritable Co Ltd. v. Husband [1983] 2 A.C. 849 H.L. .........................................................................228, 231 Westminster C.C. v. Basson (1990) 23 H.L.R. 225 C.A. ...............................................................................39, 172, 600 Westminster C.C. v. British Waterways Board [1985] A.C. 676 H.L..........................................................................572 Westminster C.C. v. Clarke [1992] 2 A.C. 288 H.L. ..........................................................145, 146, 171, 176, 179, 572 Westminster C.C. v. Peart (1991) 24 H.L.R. 389 C.A. ............................................................................................31, 39 Westminster C.C. v. Select Managements Ltd. [1985] 1 E.G.L.R. 245 C.A. ...............................................................692 Westminster C.C. v. Woodbury [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 173 C.A. ......................................................................................183 Westminster (Duke of) v. Birrane [1995] Q.B. 262 C.A. ............................................................................................399 Westminster (Duke of) v. Guild [1985] Q.B. 668 C.A. 688 C.A. ................................................195, 310, 632, 674, 691 Westminster (Duke of) v. Oddy (1984) 128 S.J. 316 C.A. ...................................................................................396, 397 Westminster (Duke of) v. Swinton [1948] 1 K.B. 524, Denning J. .....................................................................694, 819 Westside Nominees Ltd. v. Bolton M.B.C. [2000] E.G.C.S. 20, Neuberger J..............................................................664 Westropp v. Elligott (1884) 9 App. Cas. 815 H.L. ......................................................................................................690 Westwood v. Heywood [1921] 2 Ch. 130, Astbury J. .................................................................................................596 Wetherall v. Smith [1980] 1 W.L.R. 1290 C.A. ..........................................................................................................607 Wharfland v. S. London Co-operative Building Co. Ltd. [1995] 2 E.G.L.R. 21 Q.B.D. ............................................652 Wheeler v. Birmingham Chamber of Commerce Pension Funds & Trustees Co. [1954] C.L.Y. 1803 C.Ct. .............771 Wheeler v. Mercer [1956] 1 Q.B. 274 C.A., [1957] A.C. 416 H.L. ......................................................22, 173, 175, 553 Whelton Sinclair v. Hyland [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 158 C.A..............................................................................517, 562, 586 White v. Bijou Mansions Ltd. [1938] Ch. 351 C.A. ....................................................................................................383 White v. Hay (1895) 72 L.T. 281 ........................................................................................................................532, 742 White v. Jones (1993) 26 H.L.R. 477 C.A. ..................................................................................................................349 White v. Southend Hotel Co. [1897] 1 Ch. 767 C.A. ..................................................................................................769 White v. Wareing [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 271 C.A. .....................................................................................................29, 228 Whitehall Court Ltd. v. Ettlinger [1920] 1 K.B. 680....................................................................................222, 715, 716 Whiteley v. Wilson [1953] 1 Q.B. 77 ..........................................................................................................................301 Whiteminster Estates Ltd. v. Hodges Menswear Ltd. (1974) 232 E.G. 715 ................................................................736 Whitham v. Bullock [1939] 2 K.B. 81 C.A. .................................................................................................................789 Whittingham v. Whittingham [1979] Fam. 9 Fam.D, [1979] Fam. 19 C.A. ............................................................130 Whitton v. Peacock (1836) 2 Bing. (N.C.) 411, 132 E.R. 161 ....................................................................................756
lxxx
TABLE OF CASES
Whitty v. Scott-Russell [1950] 2 K.B. 32 C.A. ............................................................................................................609 Whyfe v. Michael Cullen & Partners [1993] E.G.C.S. 193 C.A. .................................................................................657 Wigglesworth v. Property Holding & Investment Trust [1984] 1 E.G.L.R. 93, McCullough J. .................................234 Wigley v. Leigh [1950] 2 K.B. 305 ..............................................................................................................................108 Wilkes v. Goodwin [1923] 2 K.B. 86 C.A. ..................................................................................................................161 Wilkes v. Spooner [1911] 2 K.B. 473 C.A. ...................................................................................................................603 Wilkins v. Horrowitz [1990] 2 E.G.L.R. 217 L.V.T.....................................................................................................430 William Boyer & Sons Ltd. v. Adams (1975) 32 P. & C.R. 89, Templeman J. ..........................................................546 William Hill (Football) Ltd. v. Willen Key & Hardware Ltd. (1964) 108 S.J. 482 ....................................211, 597, 646 William Hill (Southern) Ltd. v. Waller [1991] 1 E.G.L.R. 271 C.A. ..........................................................................583 William Skelton & Son Ltd. v. Harrison & Pinder Ltd. [1975] Q.B. 361 Ch.D. ......................529, 560, 588, 725, 758 Williams & Glyn’s Bank Ltd. v. Boland [1981] A.C. 487 H.L. ..................................................................................125 Williams v. Bosanquet (1819) 1 Brod. & Bing. 238, 129 E.R. 714 ............................................................................761 Williams v. Cheyney (1796) 3 Ves. 59, 30 E.R. 893 ....................................................................................................531 Williams v. Cynon Valley D.C. [1980] 01 L.A.G. Bulletin 16 .....................................................................................81 Williams v. Earle (1868) L.R. 3 Q.B. 739 ............................................................................................699, 751, 767, 769 Williams v. Greatrex [1957] 1 W.L.R. 31 C.A. ...........................................................................................175, 528, 530 Williams v. Hayward (1859) 1 E. & E. 1040, 120 E.R. 1200 ......................................................................................726 Williams v. Heales (1874) L.R. 9 C.P. 177 .................................................................................................................751 Williams v. Hillcroft Garage Ltd. (1971) 22 P. & C.R. 402 C.A. ................................................................................563 Williams v. Khan (1982) 43 P. & C.R. 1 C.A. .............................................................................................................230 Williams v. Mate (1983) 46 P. & C.R. 43 C.A. ..........................................................................................................164 Williams v. Portman Family S.E. Trustees [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 217 L.V.T. .........................................................407, 408 Williams v. Southwark L.B.C. [2000] Times April 5th, Lightman J. .................................................................283, 465 Williams v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. [2000] 08 C.L. 387 C.A. ........................................................................................69 Willingale v. Global Grange Ltd. [2000] 18 E.G. 152 C.A. ........................................................................................437 Willis v. Association of Universities of the British Commonwealth [1965] 1 Q.B. 140 C.A. ..............................542, 572 Willison v. Cheverell Estates Ltd. [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 116 C.A. ....................................................................559, 586, 656 Willmott v. Barber (1880) 15 Ch.D. 96 ...............................................................................................................532, 815 Wilson v. Finch-Hatton (1877) 2 Ex.D. 336 ...............................................................................................251, 258, 691 Wilson v. Fynn [1948] 2 All E.R. 40, Denning J. ........................................................................................................739 Wilson v. South Kesteven D.C. [2000] 4 All E.R. 577 ................................................................................................651 Wilson v. Stone [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 155 L.V.T. ............................................................................................................460 Wilson v. Twamley [1904] 2 K.B. 99 C.A....................................................................................................................777 Wimbush v. Cibulia [1949] 2 K.B. 564 C.A. ..............................................................................................................145 Windmill Investments (London) Ltd. v. Milano Restaurants Ltd. [1962] 2 Q.B. 373, [1962] 2 All E.R. 680, Megaw J. ..............................................................................................................................813 Windsor Life Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Austin [1996] 2 E.G.L.R. 169 L.T. .....................................................................403 Wine Shippers (London) Ltd. v. Bath House Syndicate Ltd. [1960] 1 W.L.R. 613, Buckley J., reversed [1960] 1 W.L.R. 989 C.A. .......................................................................................................................................562 Winfrey & Chatterton’s Agreement,Re [1921] 2 Ch. 7 ...............................................................................................734 Winter’s case (1572) 3 Dyer 308b, 73 E.R. 697 ...........................................................................................................759 Witham v. Collins [1976] 2 E.G.L.R. 183 ...................................................................................................................403 Woking B.C. v. Bistram (1995) 27 H.L.R. 1 C.A. .......................................................................................................341 Wolf v. Crutchley [1971] 1 W.L.R. 99 C.A. .................................................................................................398, 399, 413 Wolfe v. Hogan [1949] 2 K.B. 194 C.A. ......................................................................................................301, 543, 550 Wolff v. Waddington [1989] 2 E.G.L.R. 108 C.A. ......................................................................................................163 Wollaston v. Hakewill (1841) 3 Man. & G. 297, 133 E.R. 1154 .................................................................................726 Wolverhampton Corporation v. Emmons [1901] 1 K.B. 515 ..............................................................................530, 684 Wolveridge v. Steward (1833) 1 Cr. & M. 644, 149 E.R. 557......................................................................................790 Wong v. Beaumont Property Trust Ltd. [1965] 1 Q.B. 173 C.A. ................................................................................417 Wood v. Beard (1876) 2 Ex.D. 30 ...................................................................................................................30, 32, 516 Wood v. South Western Co-operative H.A. Ltd. (1982) 44 P. & C.R. 198 C.A. ........................................................494 Woodall v. Clifton [1905] 2 Ch. 257 C.A. ..........................................................................................................537, 538 Woodhouse v. Walker (1880) 5 Q.B.D. 404, Lush J. ..........................................................................................262, 672 Woodridge Ltd. v. Downie [1997] 2 E.G.L.R. 193 L.Tr...............................................................................................428 Woodruff v. Hambro (1991) 62 P. & C.R. 62 C.A. .....................................................................................................411 Woodspring D.C. v. Taylor (1982) 4 H.L.R. 95 C.A. .................................................................................................337 Woodtrek Ltd. v. Jezek [1982] 1 E.G.L.R. 45 ......................................................................................................458, 704
TABLE OF CASES
lxxxi
Woodward v. Docherty [1974] 1 W.L.R. 966 C.A.......................................................................................................161 Woodward v. Dudley [1954] Ch. 283..........................................................................................................................126 Woolcock v. Dew (1858) 1 F. & F. 337, 175 E.R. 753. ................................................................................................676 Woolwich B.S. v. Dickman [1996] 3 All E.R. 204 ...............................................................................................306, 307 Woolworth (F.W.) plc. v. Charlwood Alliance Properties Ltd. [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 53 C.A. ................................712, 739 Woolworth (F.W.) & Co. Ltd. v. Lambert(No.1) [1937] Ch. 37 C.A. (No.2) [1938] Ch. 883 C.A..........................................................................................................290, 370, 692–693, 730, 740 Worcester C.C. v. A.S. Clarke (Worcester) Ltd. (1995) 69 P. & C.R. 562 ..................................................................664 Wordsley Brewery Co. v. Halford (1903) 90 L.T. 89 ...................................................................................................743 Wright v. Burroughes (1846) 3 C.B. 685, 136 E.R. 274.......................................................................................743, 759 Wright v. Howell (1947) 204 L.T.Jo. 299 C.A.............................................................................................................548 Wright v. Lawson (1903) 19 T.L.R. 510 C.A. ..............................................................................................................679 Wright v. Mortimer (1996) 28 H.L.R. 719 C.A. .........................................................................................................550 Wright,Re [1949] Ch. 729 ...........................................................................................................................................728 Wroe v. Exmos Cover Ltd. [2000] 15 E.G. 155 C.A. ...................................................................................................564 Wrotesley v. Adams (1560) 1 Plowd. 189, 75 E.R. 290 .........................................................................................38, 598 Wycombe Health Authority v. Barnett [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 35 C.A...............................................................245, 262, 672 Wykes v. Davis [1975] Q.B. 843 C.A. .........................................................................................................................623 Wyndham Investments Ltd. v. Motorway Tyres & Accessories Ltd. [1991] 2 E.G.L.R. 114 C.A. ...............................666 Wyness v. Poole B.C. [1979] 07 L.A.G. Bull. 166. .........................................................................................................91 Wynne v. Duke see Aslan v. Murphy X, Y, Z v. U.K. (1997) 24 E.H.R.R. 143.......................................................................................................................203 Xey S.A. v. Abbey Life Assurance Co. Ltd. [1994] E.G.C.S. 190..................................................................................786 Yamaha-Kemble Music (U.K.) Ltd. v. Arc Properties Ltd. [1990] 1 E.G.L.R. 261, Aldous J. ....................................560 Yankwood Ltd. v. Havering L.B.C. [1999] E.G.C.S. 75, Neuberger J. .......................................................647, 674, 718 Yarmarine,Re [1992] B.C.L.C. 276, Millett J. ............................................................................................................786 Yates Building Co. Ltd. v. R.J. Pulleyn & Sons (York) Ltd. [1976] 1 E.G.L.R. 157 C.A. ...................................588, 592 Ye Old Cheshire Cheese v. Daily Telegraph [1988] 1 W.L.R. 1173, Browne-Wilkinson V.C....................................543 Yeandle v. Reigate & Banstead B.C. [1996] 1 E.G.L.R. 20 C.A. .........................................................................581, 616 Yelland v. Taylor [1957] 1 W.L.R. 459 C.A. ...............................................................................................................337 Yellowly v. Gower (1855) 11 Exch. 274, 156 E.R. 833 ........................................................................262, 263, 672, 673 Yewbright Properties Ltd. v. Stone (1980) 40 P. & C.R. 402 C.A. ..............................................................................352 Yolande Ltd. v. Reddington [1982] 2 E.G.L.R. 80 C.A................................................................................................352 York v. Casey [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 25 C.A. ...............................................................................................................27, 48 Yorkbrook Investments Ltd. v. Batten [1985] 2 E.G.L.R. 100 C.A. .....................................................458, 461, 704, 790 Yorkshire Metropolitan Properties Ltd. v. Co-operative Retail Services Ltd. [1997] E.G.C.S. 57 ...............................813 Young Austen & Young v. British Medical Association [1977] 1 W.L.R. 881 .............................................................587 Young v. Ashley Gardens Property Investment Ltd. [1903] 2 Ch. 112 C.A.........................................................733, 736 Young v. Raincock (1849) 7 C.B. 310, 137 E.R. 124....................................................................................................720 Young v. S.S for the Environment [1983] 2 A.C. 662 H.L. .........................................................................................709 Young v. Spencer (1829) 10 B. & C. 145, 109 E.R. 405 ..............................................................................................693 Young, Re ex. parte Vitale (1882) 47 L.T. 480.............................................................................................523, 524, 599 Youngmin v. Heath [1974] 1 W.L.R. 135 C.A. ..........................................................................................................213 Zimbler v. Abrahams [1903] 1 K.B. 577 C.A. ......................................................................................................32, 516 Zionmor v. Islington L.B.C. (1998) 30 H.L.R. 822 C.A.................................................................................39, 106, 600
COURT RULES
C.C.R. 1981 S.I. 1981/1687 Order 3 r.2 (revoked in 2000) .................................................................................................................................321 Order 13 ...................................................................................................................................................................503 Order 43 ...........................................................................................................................................................557, 575 Order 49 r.6A ............................................................................................................................................................57 C.P.R. 1999 S.I. 1998/3132 ............................................................................................................................................57 C.P.R. 1.............................................................................................................................................................324, 835 C.P.R. 2 .......................................................................................................................57, 322, 330, 331, 335, 576, 832 C.P.R. 3 (amended by C.P.Am.R 2000) ............................................................88, 209, 323, 324, 332, 335, 503, 835 C.P.R. 4 ....................................................................................................................................................................334 C.P.R. 6 (amended by C.P.Am.R. 2000).........................................................................................................593–594 C.P.R. 7 ....................................................................................................................................................321, 593, 834 C.P.R. 8.1 ..................................................................................................................................................575, 832, 834 C.P.R. 8.2..................................................................................................................................................................832 C.P.R. 8.3..........................................................................................................................................................323, 833 C.P.R. 8.4..................................................................................................................................................................834 C.P.R. 8.5 ..................................................................................................................................................322, 832, 833 C.P.R. 8.6 .................................................................................................................................................................322 C.P.R. 8.7..................................................................................................................................................................834 C.P.R. 8.9 ...........................................................................................................................................62, 324, 576, 835 C.P.R. 9 ............................................................................................................................................................209, 323 C.P.R. 12 (as amended in 2000)......................................................................................................................209, 834 C.P.R. 13 (as amended in 2000)..............................................................................................................................209 C.P.R. 14...................................................................................................................................................................834 C.P.R. 15...........................................................................................................................................................209, 323 C.P.R. 16...................................................................................................................................................................209 C.P.R. 19 (as amended in 2000)..............................................................................................................................836 C.P.R. 20 (as amended in 2000)..............................................................................................................................324 C.P.R. 22 .....................................................................................................................................................59, 576, 833 C.P.R. 23 ..........................................................................................................................................................332–335 C.P.R. 24 ..........................................................................................................................................323, 324, 577, 834 C.P.R. 25 (as amended in 2000)..............................................................................................................................685 C.P.R. 26 ..................................................................................................................................209, 210, 315, 324, 835 C.P.R. 27 ..................................................................................................................................................256, 259, 835 C.P.R. 29...........................................................................................................................................................556, 835 C.P.R. 30 ...................................................................................................................................................557, 832, 835 C.P.R. 31...................................................................................................................................................................562 C.P.R. 34 – 39 ..........................................................................................................................................322, 324, 835 C.P.R. 40 (as amended in 2000) .....................................................................................................................330, 332 C.P.R. 50.....................................................................................................................................................................57 C.P.R. 51 .....................................................................................................................................................62, 324, 836 C.P.R. 52 (inserted by C.P.Am.R. 2000 sch.5) .......................................................................................................210 C.P.R. sch.1 R.S.C. Order 10 r.4 ......................................................................................................................................................323, 596 Order 45 r.3 .............................................................................................................................................................334 Order 46 ..................................................................................................................................................................334 Order 97 ...................................................................................................................................................557, 575, 832 Order 113 .........................................................................................................................................................327, 832 C.P.R. sch.2 C.C.R. ....................................................................................................................................................557 Order 3 r.4 (revoked in 2000) .................................................................................................................................557
lxxxiv
COURT RULES
Order 4 ............................................................................................................................................................557, 832 Order 6 r.3 ........................................................................................................................................322, 331, 833, 835 Order 7 r.15 .....................................................................................................................................................323, 594 Order 24 ...........................................................................................................................................................327, 328 Order 25 r.3 (amended in 2000) .......................................................................................................................61, 593 Order 26 ..........................................................................................................................................................334, 335 Order 37 (revoked in 2000).............................................................................................................................332, 335 Order 43 ...........................................................................................................................................................557, 575 Order 49 r.6 .....................................................................................................................................................325–327 Order 49 r.6A ......................................................................................................................................................56–61 Order 49 r.6B ...................................................................................................................................................343, 344 Order 49 r.8 –r.9 .....................................................................................................................................................412 Order 49 r.13 ............................................................................................................................................................181 C.P.Am.R. 2000 S.I. 2000/221 .............................................................................................................................326, 331 r. 3 .............................................................................................................................................................................835 r. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................................209 r. 32 .....................................................................................................................................................................61, 593 sch. 1 .........................................................................................................................................................................593 sch. 2 .........................................................................................................................................................................836 sch. 8 .........................................................................................................................................................................332 C.P.Am. (No.4) R. 2000...............................................................................................................................................325 Chancery Division P.D. 7. ...........................................................................................................................................334 Chancery Division Practice Statement [1973] 1 All E.R. 796....................................................................................556 Practice Direction [1990] 1 All E.R. 255.....................................................................................................................418 Practice Direction (issued with C.P.R.) P.D. 2B .....................................................................................................................................................323, 324, 327 P.D. 4 .........................................................................................................................................................57, 322–326 P.D. 4 Tables 1–3........................................................................................................................57, 557, 575, 832, 833 P.D. 5 ................................................................................................................................................................593, 594 P.D. 6 .......................................................................................................................................................................594 P.D. 7 ........................................................................................................................................................209, 321, 593 P.D. 8 ...............................................................................................................................................324, 575, 832, 835 P.D. 8.A.............................................................................................................................................................327, 832 P.D. 8.B (amended in 2000) ..............................................................56, 315, 321–325, 412, 557, 575, 576, 832–833 P.D. 8B Tables 1–2 ..................................................................................................................................325, 557, 575 P.D. 16 .............................................................................................................................................................322, 325 P.D. 22 .......................................................................................................................................................59, 323, 576 P.D. 23 ......................................................................................................................................................................335 P.D. 26 .....................................................................................................................................................................324 P.D. 27 .....................................................................................................................................................................210 P.D. 39 ........................................................................................................................................................62, 322, 324 P.D. 51 ................................................................................................................................................62, 324, 577, 836 R.S.C. Order 14 ............................................................................................................................................................834
TABLE OF STATUTES
Accommodation Agencies Act 1953 c.23 ...................................................................................................................242 Administration of Estates Act 1925 c.23 ....................................................................................................................727 Administration of Justice Act 1985 c.61 .............................................................................................................816, 817 Agricultural Holdings Act 1948 c.63...........................................................................................................................605 Agricultural Holdings (Amendment) Act 1990 c.15..................................................................................................626 Agricultural Holdings Act 1984 c.41...........................................................................................................................621 Agricultural Holdings Act (A.H.A.) 1986 c.5 ....................................................................................................605, 637 s. 1 (1) .......................................................................................................................................................609, 612, 615 s. 1 (2) ...............................................................................................................................................................607–609 s. 1 (3)–(5)........................................................................................................................................................607–610 s. 2 ....................................................................................................................................................................613–615 s. 3 .....................................................................................................................................................................612, 617 s. 5 ....................................................................................................................................................................615, 617 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................................616 s. 7 .....................................................................................................................................................................617, 624 s. 10 ..........................................................................................................................................................................700 s. 12 ...................................................................................................................................................................627, 628 s. 13 ...........................................................................................................................................................................627 s. 16 ..................................................................................................................................................................616, 650 s. 25 (1) .............................................................................................................................................................615–617 s. 25 (2) .............................................................................................................................615, 618, 621, 622, 625, 666 s. 25 (5) .....................................................................................................................................................................616 s. 26 ...................................................................................................................................................................616, 622 s. 27 ...................................................................................................................................................622, 623, 625, 627 s. 28 ..........................................................................................................................................................................624 s. 30 ..........................................................................................................................................................................615 ss. 31–33 ...................................................................................................................................................................627 ss. 35–58 ...................................................................................................................................................620–621, 624 ss. 60–69 ...........................................................................................................................................................629, 630 s. 70 ...........................................................................................................................................................................630 ss. 74–78 ...................................................................................................................................................................629 s. 83 ...........................................................................................................................................................................628 s. 93 ...........................................................................................................................................................................591 s. 96 ...................................................................................................................................................................606, 607 sch. 1 ........................................................................................................................................................................616 sch. 2 ........................................................................................................................................................................627 sch. 3 ........................................................................................................................................................621–625, 629 sch. 5 ........................................................................................................................................................................615 sch. 6 .........................................................................................................................................................................621 schs. 7–9............................................................................................................................................................629, 630 sch. 12 ......................................................................................................................................................................605 sch. 14 ......................................................................................................................................................................300 Agricultural Tenancies Act (A.T.A.) 1995 c.8............................................................................................................606 s. 1(2) ........................................................................................................................................................607, 608, 610 s. 1(3)–(4) ........................................................................................................................................................608, 610 s. 1(7)–(8) ................................................................................................................................................................608 s. 2 ............................................................................................................................................................................605 s. 3 ....................................................................................................................................................................605, 608 ss. 5–7 ...............................................................................................................................................................611–612
lxxxvi
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 8 ....................................................................................................................................................................630, 700 ss. 9–14 .............................................................................................................................................................628, 630 ss. 15–27 ...........................................................................................................................................................615, 630 sa. 28–30 ...........................................................................................................................................................628–630 s. 34 ...........................................................................................................................................................................628 s. 36 ..........................................................................................................................................................................591 s. 37 ...........................................................................................................................................................................612 s. 38 ...................................................................................................................................................606–607, 611–612 sch. ...................................................................................................................................................187, 543, 607, 609 Agriculture Act 1947 c.48 ............................................................................................................................................605 Agriculture (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1976 c.55 ..............................................................................................620 Agriculture Act 1986 c.49 ....................................................................................................................................628–629 Allotments Acts 1908–1950 ........................................................................................................................................607 Apportionment Act 1870 c.35.....................................................................................................................211, 597, 646 Arbitration Act 1996 c. 23 ...........................................................................................................................................660 Asylum and Immigration Act 1996 c.49 .................................................................................................................92, 95 Asylum and Immigration Appeals Act 1993 c.23 ..................................................................................................96, 97 British Nationality Act 1981 c.61 .................................................................................................................................92 Caravan Sites Act 1968 c.52 ................................................................................................................................180–181 Caravan Sites and Control of Development Act 1960 c.62 ..............................................................................180–182 Children Act 1989 c.41 ...................................................................................................................................73, 76, 139 Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978 c.47 .............................................................................................................788 Common Law Procedure Act 1852 c.76 ss. 210–214 .........................................................522, 796, 807, 816, 817, 821 (Draft) Commonhold Bill 1996 .................................................................................................................................485 cl.1.............................................................................................................................................................478, 481, 485 cl.2.....................................................................................................................................................473, 478, 479, 485 cl.3.....................................................................................................................................................................470, 474 cl.4.............................................................................................................................................................................485 cl.5 ............................................................................................................................................................................491 cls.10–11 ..................................................................................................................................................................477 cl.12 ..................................................................................................................................................................474, 481 cl.15...........................................................................................................................................................................481 cl.16 ..........................................................................................................................................................................481 cl.18...........................................................................................................................................................................484 cl.24...........................................................................................................................................................................491 cl.27...........................................................................................................................................................................481 cl.28...........................................................................................................................................................................481 cls.29–31 ..................................................................................................................................................................482 cl.32...........................................................................................................................................................................482 cls.32–41 ...................................................................................................................................................................489 cl.33...................................................................................................................................................................490–491 cl.35...........................................................................................................................................................................491 cls.36–37 ..................................................................................................................................................................491 cl.42...........................................................................................................................................................................456 cl.48...........................................................................................................................................................................481 cl.53 ..........................................................................................................................................................................470 sch.1 ........................................................................................................................................................................486 sch.2 .........................................................................................................................................................................484 sch.3 ..........................................................................................................................................................................481 sch.5 ..........................................................................................................................................................................488 sch.7 ..........................................................................................................................................................................481 sch.9 ........................................................................................................................................................................491 Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill 2000 ....................................................................x, 388, 421, 432, 467, 469 cl.1.....................................................................................................................................................471, 478–479, 485 cl.2.....................................................................................................................................................469, 471–473, 482 cl.3.....................................................................................................................................................................469–472 cl.5.....................................................................................................................................................................473, 478 cl.6 ....................................................................................................................................................................473–474 cl.7.............................................................................................................................................................472, 474, 485
TABLE OF STATUTES
lxxxvii
cl.8.....................................................................................................................................................................474–475 cl.9.....................................................................................................................................................472, 474, 477, 485 cl.10...........................................................................................................................................................................472 cl.11...................................................................................................................................................................477, 478 cl.12...................................................................................................................................................................479, 483 cl.13 ..........................................................................................................................................................................479 cl.14...........................................................................................................................................................................487 cls.15–16 ...........................................................................................................................................................479, 480 cls.17–19 ..................................................................................................................................................480, 481, 487 cl.20...........................................................................................................................................................................480 cl.21...................................................................................................................................................................479, 480 cl.22–23.....................................................................................................................................................478, 484–485 cl.24...........................................................................................................................................................................485 cl.25...................................................................................................................................................................485–488 cl.26...................................................................................................................................................................484–485 cl.27...................................................................................................................................................................484–486 cl.28...........................................................................................................................................................................486 cl.29...................................................................................................................................................................484–485 cls.30–32 ...........................................................................................................................................................483–489 cl.33...........................................................................................................................................................................482 cl.34...........................................................................................................................................................................487 cl.35 ..................................................................................................................................................................484, 491 cl.36...................................................................................................................................................................487–489 cl.37 ..................................................................................................................................................................488, 489 cl.38...................................................................................................................................................................488, 490 cl.39...........................................................................................................................................................................474 cl.40...........................................................................................................................................................475, 484–486 cls.41–46 ...........................................................................................................................................475, 484, 489, 491 cls.47–51 ...........................................................................................................................................................489–490 cls.52–54 ...................................................................................................................................................474, 488–491 cl.55...........................................................................................................................................................................471 cls.56–57 ...................................................................................................................................................................475 cl.58 .................................................................................................................................................................479–480 cl.59...........................................................................................................................................................481, 487–488 cl.60...........................................................................................................................................................................471 cl.62...................................................................................................................................................................471, 473 cl.63...................................................................................................................................................................470–472 cl.66...........................................................................................................................................................479, 482, 487 cl.68 ..........................................................................................................................................................................444 cl.69 .................................................................................................................................................445–446, 451–452 cl.70...........................................................................................................................................................446, 447, 451 cl.71...................................................................................................................................................................446–447 cl.72...................................................................................................................................................................446–447 cls.73–74 ..........................................................................................................................................................445–446 cls.75–86 ...................................................................................................................................................446–449, 451 cls.87–91 ...................................................................................................................................................................449 cls.92–100 .........................................................................................................................................................449–451 cls.95–96 ...................................................................................................................................................................450 cl.101.........................................................................................................................................................................449 cl.103.........................................................................................................................................................................450 cl.104.........................................................................................................................................................................444 cl.106.........................................................................................................................................................................446 cl.108.........................................................................................................................................................................448 cl.109.........................................................................................................................................................445, 446, 450 cls.112–116 .......................................................................................................................................................434–435 cls.117–121 .......................................................................................................................................436, 438, 440–442 cls.122–124 .......................................................................................................................................................437, 439 cls.126–128 ...............................................................................................................................................392, 397–398 cls.130–132 ...............................................................................................................................................................408
lxxxviii
TABLE OF STATUTES
cls.133–137 .......................................................................................................................................402, 405–406, 416 cls.138–140 ......................................................................................................................................................462–463 cl.142.........................................................................................................................................................367, 376, 795 cls.143–144 .......................................................................................................................................................375–376 cl.145.................................................................................................................................................283, 375, 376, 804 cl.146.........................................................................................................................................................................462 cls.147–150 ...............................................................................................................................................408, 414, 440 cl.156.........................................................................................................................................................................468 sch.1. .........................................................................................................................................................472–473, 482 sch.2 .........................................................................................................................................................470–473, 478 sch.3 .........................................................................................................................................................472, 482–483 sch.4 .........................................................................................................................................................................475 sch.5 ..................................................................................................................................................................479, 481 sch.6 .........................................................................................................................................................445, 451–452 sch.7 .................................................................................................................................................................450–451 sch.8 ..........................................................................................................................................................440, 443–444 sch.9 ..........................................................................................................................................................................462 sch.10 ...............................................................................................................................................................464–465 sch.11 ................................................................................................................................................................414, 440 sch.12 ................................................................................................................................................................419, 440 sch.13 ........................................................................................................392, 408, 416, 435–436, 440, 443–444, 454 Companies Act 1985 c. 6 .....................................................................................................................482–483, 773, 775 Consumer Protection Act 1987 c.43 s. 46. .................................................................................................................252 Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 c. 31 ...........................................................................................760, 781 Conveyancing Act 1881 c.41 .......................................................................................................................365, 532, 751 s. 3 .............................................................................................................................................................................596 s. 10 ..........................................................................................................................................750, 753, 755, 762–763 s. 11 ...................................................................................................................................................................752–753 s. 12 ...................................................................................................................................................................742, 758 s. 14 ...........................................................................................................................................................373, 796, 799 s. 50 ..........................................................................................................................................................................595 s. 65 ..........................................................................................................................................................................388 s. 67 ...................................................................................................................................................................588, 591 Conveyancing Act 1882 c.39 s. 11 ...............................................................................................................................388 Conveyancing and Law of Property Act 1892 c. 13 s. 2 .............................................................................................................................................................................829 s. 3 .............................................................................................................................................................................740 s. 4 .....................................................................................................................................................373, 796, 823, 825 Conveyancing Act 1911 c.37 s. 2 .................................................................................................................750, 754, 763 Cost of Leases Act 1958 c.52................................................................................................................................568, 633 Counter Inflation Act 1973 c.9 s. 11 ...........................................................................................................................233 County Courts Act 1934 c.53 s. 180. ..........................................................................................................................816 County Courts Act 1984 c.28 s. 21 ...........................................................................................................................................................................321 s. 23 ..................................................................................................................................................................523, 833 s. 88 ..........................................................................................................................................................................335 s. 89 ..........................................................................................................................................................................652 s. 138 .................................................................................................................................................339, 794, 817, 826 s. 138 (1) ...........................................................................................................................................................816–817 s. 138 (5) ...................................................................................................................................................................821 s. 138 (9A)–(9C)...............................................................................................................................817, 818, 826, 835 s. 138 (10) ................................................................................................................................................................826 s. 139 ........................................................................................................................................................................822 s. 140 .........................................................................................................................................................................826 County Courts Act 1856 c.106 ...................................................................................................................................816 Crime and Disorder Act 1998 c.37 s. 1 .......................................................................................................................343 Criminal Law Act 1977 c.45 .......................................................................................................312, 317, 328, 374, 808 Data Protection Act 1999 c.35.......................................................................................................................................89 Defective Premises Act 1972 c.35................................................................................................................254, 260, 450
TABLE OF STATUTES
lxxxix
Deserted Tenements Act 1817, 57 George 3, c.52 ......................................................................................................807 Disability Discrimination Act 1995 c.50 ....................................................................................................................696 Distress for Rent Act 1689, 2 W. & M., c.5. ...............................................................................................214, 650, 651 Distress for Rent Act 1737, 11 George 2, c.19 ...........................................................................213, 641, 651, 652, 807 Electricity Act 1989 c.29 ..............................................................................................................................................218 Environmental Protection Act 1990 c.43 ss.79–81 ...........................................................................................266–268 Environment Act 1995 c.25.........................................................................................................................................590 Finance Act 1963 c.25 s.55. .........................................................................................................................................381 Finance Act 1986 c.41 s.102A .....................................................................................................................................595 Finance Act 1994 c.9 ss.240–240A ......................................................................................................................380–381 Finance Act 1995 c.4 ss.39–40 .............................................................................................................................218, 645 Finance Act 1998 c.36 ....................................................................................................................................................24 Finance Act 1999 c.16 .................................................................................................................................380–382, 595 Finance Act 2000 c.17 s.128.........................................................................................................................................380 Finance Bill 2001 .........................................................................................................................................................380 Family Law Act (F.L.A.) 1996 c.55 s. 30 ...................................................................................................................................117, 130–132, 136, 221, 824 s. 31 ..........................................................................................................................................................117, 130–132 s. 32 ..........................................................................................................................................................................117 s. 33 ..................................................................................................................................................................133–137 s. 35 ...........................................................................................................................................................................132 s. 36 ..................................................................................................................................................................134, 138 s. 37 ..........................................................................................................................................................................134 s. 39 ..........................................................................................................................................................................133 ss. 40–44............................................................................................................................................................134, 135 ss. 45–46 ...................................................................................................................................................................133 s. 47 ...................................................................................................................................................................133–134 s. 49 ...........................................................................................................................................................................133 s. 53 ..........................................................................................................................................................................140 s. 59–60 ....................................................................................................................................................................135 s. 62 ...................................................................................................................................................................134–135 s. 63–64 ....................................................................................................................................................................131 sch. 4 .................................................................................................................................................................130–132 sch. 7 ................................................................................................................................................................136–140 sch. 8. .......................................................................................................................................................................332 Fires Prevention (Metropolis) Act 1774, 14 George 3, c.78 s. 83 ......................................................................369, 687 Gas Act 1986 c.44 .........................................................................................................................................................218 General Rate Act 1967 c.9 s. 115. ................................................................................................................................214 Government of Wales Act 1998 c.38 s. 143 .................................................................................................................11 Grantees of Reversions Act 1540, 32 Henry 8, c.24 ...........................................................295, 749–757, 763, 776, 782 Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 c.37 ...........................................................................................................692 Homes Bill 2000.....................................................................................................................................................99–101 Housing Act 1935 c.40 ..................................................................................................................................................72 Housing Act 1957 c.56 ........................................................................................................................................249, 270 Housing Act 1961 c.65 ss. 32–33.................................................................................................................................243 Housing Act 1969 c.33 s. 82 ........................................................................................................................................403 Housing Act 1974 c.44 s. 1 ....................................................................................................................10, 255, 404, 406 Housing Act 1980 c.51 ........................................................................................................................................164, 327 part I .............................................................................................................................................................................493 s. 1 ....................................................................................................................................................................145–146 s. 21 ...........................................................................................................................................................................143 s. 30 ..........................................................................................................................................................................311 s. 52 .............................................................................................................................................44, 45, 49, 52, 54, 146 s. 53 .............................................................................................................................................................................44 s. 55 .............................................................................................................................................................................49 s. 62 ............................................................................................................................................................................51 s. 64 ..............................................................................................................................................................................3 s. 65 ..........................................................................................................................................................................164 s. 73 ..............................................................................................................................................................................4
xc
TABLE OF STATUTES
ss. 81–82 ...................................................................................................................................................................252 s. 88 ...........................................................................................................................................................................176 s. 89 ..........................................................................................................................................................................331 s. 114 ........................................................................................................................................................................176 s. 141 .................................................................................................................................................................390, 396 sch. 1 ........................................................................................................................................................................496 sch. 2 .........................................................................................................................................................................390 sch. 8 .............................................................................................................................................................................4 sch. 21 .......................................................................................................................................................................396 sch. 25 .......................................................................................................................................................................234 Housing Act 1985 c.68 ................................................................................................................................104, 115, 637 s. 1 ................................................................................................................................................................................9 s. 7A, 7B ...................................................................................................................................................................279 s. 9 ................................................................................................................................................................................9 s. 16 ..............................................................................................................................................................................9 ss. 20–26 .......................................................................................................................................70, 73, 224, 225, 279 ss. 27–27B .........................................................................................................................................................279, 286 s. 32–44 .............................................................................................................................................................302, 500 s. 45 ..........................................................................................................................................................................145 ss. 58–78 (homelessness) ...............................................................................................................................73, 74, 78 ss. 79–117 part IV (secure tenancies)......................................................................................................................494 s. 79 ....................................................................................................................................67, 145, 146, 148, 171–172 s. 80 ..................................................................................................................................8, 10, 12, 113, 170, 269, 493 s. 81 ..............................................................................................................................13, 14, 104–106, 109, 125, 397 s. 82 ....................................................................................................................................20, 113, 269, 310, 333, 501 s. 83 ....................................................................................................................................................29, 318, 319, 343 s. 83A .......................................................................................................................................................140, 318, 344 s. 84 ...........................................................................................................................................................................358 s. 85 ..................................................................................................................................................115, 135, 331, 332 s. 86 .............................................................................................................................................................29, 115, 128 s. 87 ..........................................................................................................................................................116–117, 120 s. 88 ..........................................................................................................................................................................122 s. 89 .....................................................................................................................................................63, 117, 122, 330 s. 90 ...................................................................................................................................................................122, 269 s. 91 .....................................................................................................................................................31, 115, 286, 287 s. 92 ...........................................................................................................................................................................287 s. 93 ..................................................................................................................................................................286, 298 s. 94 ...................................................................................................................................................................286, 298 s. 95 ...........................................................................................................................................................................285 ss. 99A–99B ..............................................................................................................................................................225 s. 101 ........................................................................................................................................................................265 s. 102 .........................................................................................................................................................224, 225, 279 s. 103 .........................................................................................................................................................113, 224, 279 ss. 104–106A.....................................................................................................................................................279, 280 s. 108 .........................................................................................................................................................................224 s. 109A .........................................................................................................................................................................9 s. 110 .................................................................................................................................................................321, 523 s. 112 ..........................................................................................................................................................14, 145, 609 s. 113 ........................................................................................................................................................................117 s. 114 ............................................................................................................................................................................8 ss. 118–188 part V (right to buy) ......................................................................................................................13, 493 s. 118 ........................................................................................................................................................................495 s. 119 ........................................................................................................................................................................494 s. 121 .........................................................................................................................................................................502 s. 123 .................................................................................................................................................................495, 503 s. 124 .........................................................................................................................................................................500 s. 125 ........................................................................................................................................................459, 497, 500 ss. 126–131 .................................................................................................................................................10, 497, 498 s. 137 ........................................................................................................................................................................493
TABLE OF STATUTES
xci
ss. 138–141........................................................................................................................................................501, 502 ss. 143–153 ...............................................................................................................................................................500 s. 153A ......................................................................................................................................................................501 s. 154 .........................................................................................................................................................................501 s. 155 ........................................................................................................................................................................499 s. 156 ........................................................................................................................................................................499 s. 157 .................................................................................................................................................................418, 497 ss. 158–163..................................................................................................................................................66, 497, 499 ss. 164–170 ...............................................................................................................................................................501 s. 171A–171H ...........................................................................................................................................................494 ss. 174–175........................................................................................................................................................390, 496 ss. 176–177 ...............................................................................................................................................................500 s. 179 .........................................................................................................................................................................501 s. 183–185 .........................................................................................................................................................494, 496 ss. 189–208 part VI (repairs notices) ......................................................................................................270–271, 275 ss. 191–208 ...............................................................................................................................................................271 ss. 239–263 part VIII ...................................................................................................................................................9 ss. 264 –323 part IX .............................................................................................................................................9, 270 ss. 324–344 part X ............................................................................................................................................345, 346 s. 345–400 part IX ...........................................................................................................................................272–273 ss. 346–351 ...............................................................................................................................................................273 ss. 352–357........................................................................................................................................................273, 274 ss. 358–364 ...............................................................................................................................................................273 ss. 365–368 .......................................................................................................................................................273, 274 ss. 375–378 ...............................................................................................................................................................273 ss. 379–394 ...............................................................................................................................................................274 ss. 401–420 part XII .................................................................................................................................................272 ss. 450A–459.............................................................................................................................................................462 ss. 523–526 part XV ........................................................................................................................................275, 276 ss. 527–577 part XVI ...............................................................................................................................................497 s. 604 ................................................................................................................................246, 249, 270, 274–275, 278 s. 612 ........................................................................................................................................................................345 ss. 621, 621A .....................................................................................................................................................296, 462 sch. 1 ..................................................................................................................99. 166, 168, 176–178, 186, 494–496 sch. 2 ................................................................................................................331, 336, 347, 351, 353, 354, 358, 359 sch. 3 ........................................................................................................................................................................287 sch. 4 .........................................................................................................................................................493, 495, 498 sch. 5 ................................................................................................................................................................493, 496 sch. 6 ........................................................................................................................................................................500 sch. 6A ......................................................................................................................................................................500 sch. 20 .......................................................................................................................................................................497 Housing Act 1988 c.50.............................................................................................................................................4, 131 s. 1 .........................................................................................................................................................5, 177, 223, 394 s. 1(1) .............................................................................................................4, 14, 103, 105, 106, 109, 125, 146, 170 s. 1(2)–(2A) .............................................................................................................................................................166 s.2 ..............................................................................................................................................................................609 s. 3 ....................................................................................................................................................................147–148 s. 4 ............................................................................................................................................................................148 s. 5 ...................................................................................20, 29, 43, 45, 50, 53, 55, 111–112, 115, 306, 310, 326, 794 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................................112 s. 7 .....................................................................................................................................................331, 339, 395, 794 s. 8 .................................................................................................................................29, 55, 192, 318, 319, 326, 332 s. 9 ............................................................................................................................................................................331 s. 11 ...........................................................................................................................................................................351 s. 13 ...........................................................................................................................................................190, 226, 237 s. 14 ...................................................................................................................................................................190, 226 ss. 14A, 14B ..............................................................................................................................................................226 s. 15 ...........................................................................................................................................................228, 289, 291 s. 16 ..................................................................................................................................................................245, 683
xcii
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 17 ............................................................................................................................50, 116, 117, 120, 122, 125, 190 s. 18 ..................................................................................................................................................................296, 299 s. 19 ...................................................................................................................................................................220, 650 s. 19A..........................................................................................................................................18, 43, 45, 46, 50, 104 s. 20 .............................................................................................................................43–46, 50–51, 58, 61, 145–146 s. 20A ..........................................................................................................................................................................46 s. 21 ........................................................................................................................................................50, 54–56, 187 s. 22 .............................................................................................................................................................52, 188, 227 s. 23 ...................................................................................................................................................................152, 188 s. 24 ..........................................................................................................................................................116, 187–189 s. 25 ..................................................................................................................................................................188–192 s. 27 ..................................................................................................................................................................312–315 s. 28 ...........................................................................................................................................................................313 s. 29 ...................................................................................................................................................................315–316 s. 30 ..................................................................................................................................................................191, 311 s. 31 ..........................................................................................................................................................................311 s. 32 .............................................................................................................................................................................26 s. 34 ..............................................................................................................................................4, 5, 44, 51, 103, 188 s. 35 .................................................................................................................................................................4, 12, 103 s. 36 ..................................................................................................................................................................163, 164 s. 37 ..............................................................................................................................................................................5 s. 39 .....................................................................................................................................................................50, 116 s. 40 ....................................................................................................................................................................56, 321 ss. 41–42 ...................................................................................................................................................................237 s. 41A ........................................................................................................................................................................226 s. 45 ....................................................................................................................................................44, 125, 296, 794 ss. 46–59..................................................................................................................................................11, 44, 45, 306 ss. 63–92 .....................................................................................................................................9, 10, 12–13, 104, 225 s. 114 ...........................................................................................................................................................................11 ss. 115–121 .......................................................................................................................................113, 238, 241, 255 s. 124 .........................................................................................................................................................................501 s. 140 ..................................................................................................................................................................12, 104 s. 141 ...........................................................................................................................................................4, 5, 43, 144 s. 200 .........................................................................................................................................................................91 sch. 1 ...................................................................................................................................................................99, 190 sch. 1 para. 1.................................................................................................................................................4, 103, 143 sch. 1 para. 2 ....................................................................................................................................................168, 169 sch. 1 paras. 3, 3A, 3B ......................................................................................................166, 187, 189, 223, 392, 428 sch. 1 paras. 4–7 ......................................................................................................................................189, 549, 609 sch. 1 paras. 8–10 .............................................................................................................................................163, 168 sch. 1 para. 11 .....................................................................................................................................11, 170, 188, 329 sch. 1 para. 12 .................................................................................................................................8, 11, 176, 188, 329 sch. 1 para.13..................................................................................................................................................5, 11, 143 sch. 1 para.17............................................................................................................................................................163 sch. 1 para.22............................................................................................................................................................163 sch. 1A ........................................................................................................................................................................45 sch. 2 ...................................................................................................................47, 336, 337, 347, 348, 351, 354, 355 sch. 2 ground 1 ........................................................................................................................................................395 sch. 2 ground 2 ........................................................................................................................................................306 sch. 2 ground 3 ........................................................................................................................................................168 sch. 2 ground 4.........................................................................................................................................................168 sch. 2 ground 5 ........................................................................................................................................................185 sch. 2 ground 6.........................................................................................................................................................395 sch. 2 grounds 10–11 ...............................................................................................................................................395 sch. 2 ground 16 ......................................................................................................................................................395 sch. 2A ..............................................................................................................................................6, 46, 51, 165, 187 sch. 3 ........................................................................................................................................................188, 191, 395 sch. 4 ........................................................................................................................................116–118, 120, 122, 124 sch. 17 ......................................................................................................................................................................136
TABLE OF STATUTES
xciii
sch. 18 ................................................................................................................................................................12, 104 Housing Act 1996 c.52...................................................................................................................................86, 188, 795 ss. 1–7....................................................................................................................................................................11, 12 ss. 8–15 .....................................................................................................................................................................497 ss. 16–17..............................................................................................................................................................13, 494 ss. 18–29..........................................................................................................................................................6, 12, 165 ss. 30–55 ...............................................................................................................................................12, 13, 209, 281 ss. 56–64 ...............................................................................................................................................................11, 12 ss. 65–80 .....................................................................................................................................................12, 272, 273 s. 81 ...........................................................................................................................................283, 372, 376, 461, 804 s. 82 ...................................................................................................................................................283, 372, 461, 804 s. 83 ...................................................................................................................................283, 318, 372, 459–461, 465 s. 84 ..................................................................................................................................................283, 450, 460, 462 ss. 85–88 ...................................................................................................................................................283, 452–458 s. 89 ..................................................................................................................................................................427, 429 s. 90 ..................................................................................................................................................................116, 427 s. 91 ..........................................................................................................................................................140, 427, 430 s. 92 ..................................................................................................................................................................427, 431 s. 93 ..........................................................................................................................................................223, 431, 452 s. 96 .............................................................................................................................................18, 43, 45, 46, 50, 265 s. 97 ....................................................................................................................................................................46, 265 s. 98 .....................................................................................................................................................................54, 265 s. 99 .....................................................................................................................................................................50, 265 ss. 99A–99B .............................................................................................................................................................265 s. 100 ..........................................................................................................................................................................52 s. 101 .........................................................................................................................................................................337 s. 102 ........................................................................................................................................................................347 s. 103 ........................................................................................................................................................................187 ss. 105–107........................................................................................................................................391, 392, 405, 435 ss. 108–110................................................................................................................................................407, 437, 438 ss. 111–113........................................................................................................................................397, 398, 435, 436 ss. 114–117................................................................................................................................391, 412, 414–415, 442 s. 118 .................................................................................................................................................................418, 419 s. 119 ........................................................................................................................................................412, 414, 437 ss. 124–143 .................................................................................................................................................................70 ss. 124, 125 .......................................................................................................................................................112, 165 ss. 127–130 .......................................................................................................................................104, 112, 165, 328 ss. 131–133........................................................................................................................................................116, 122 ss. 136–137........................................................................................................................................................265, 279 ss. 138–139 ...............................................................................................................................................................497 s. 144 ........................................................................................................................................................................341 s. 145 ................................................................................................................................................................140, 344 s. 146 ........................................................................................................................................................................347 s. 147 ........................................................................................................................................................318, 343, 344 ss. 148–151................................................................................................................................140, 318, 319, 341, 344 ss. 152–158 .......................................................................................................................................................343–344 s. 153A ......................................................................................................................................................................501 ss. 159–174 part VI (allocation) s. 159 ...............................................................................................................................................................65, 66, 71 s. 160 ...................................................................................................................................................................65, 140 s. 161 .........................................................................................................................................................71, 92, 94–95 s. 162–166 .............................................................................................................................................................71, 86 s. 167 ....................................................................................................................................................................71, 72 s. 168–170 .....................................................................................................................................................66, 71, 348 s. 171 ........................................................................................................................................................................348 ss. 175–218 part VII (homelessness).........................................................................................................................74 s. 175 ....................................................................................................................................................................81, 82 s. 176 ..........................................................................................................................................................................75 s. 177 ..............................................................................................................................................................75, 81, 82
xciv
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 183 ........................................................................................................................................................66, 67, 85, 86 s. 184 .....................................................................................................................................................................87, 91 s. 185 ...............................................................................................................................................................92, 94, 96 s. 186 ....................................................................................................................................................................96, 97 s. 188 .....................................................................................................................................................................67, 89 s. 189 ..........................................................................................................................................................................73 s. 190 .....................................................................................................................................................................74, 80 s. 191 .....................................................................................................................................................................78–79 s. 193 .....................................................................................................................................................................68, 84 s. 194 ..........................................................................................................................................................................68 ss. 195–196 ...........................................................................................................................................................67, 85 s. 197 .....................................................................................................................................................................68, 84 ss. 198–201 .....................................................................................................................................................67, 90–91 s. 202 ..........................................................................................................................................................................87 s. 204 ...............................................................................................................................................................70, 88–89 ss. 205–209 .............................................................................................................................................51, 68, 83, 177 s. 210 ....................................................................................................................................................................74, 80 s. 211 ..........................................................................................................................................................................80 s. 216 .........................................................................................................................................................................177 s. 219 .........................................................................................................................................................................225 s. 230 ..........................................................................................................................................................................11 sch. 1 ..............................................................................................................................................................11, 12, 67 sch. 2 ...................................................................................................................................................................13, 209 sch. 2A .......................................................................................................................................................................46 sch. 4 .........................................................................................................................................................................455 sch. 5 .................................................................................................................................................................452, 453 sch. 6 .........................................................................................................................................................423, 429–431 sch. 7 ..................................................................................................................................................................46, 187 sch. 8 ..............................................................................................................................................................44, 46, 51 sch. 9 ........................................................................................................................................................391, 392, 435 sch. 10 ...............................................................................................................................................................432, 440 sch. 11 ......................................................................................................................................................395, 412, 414 sch. 17 .........................................................................................................................................................................67 sch. 18 ......................................................................................................................................................................499 sch. 19 ................................................................................................................................................................47, 279 Housing and Planning Act 1986 c.63............................................................................................82, 406, 459, 494, 498 Housing Associations Act 1985 c.69 ...........................................................................................................................11 Housing Finance Act 1972 c.47...............................................................................................................................10, 12 Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 c.53 ..............................................................270, 274–277 Housing (Homeless Persons) Act 1977 c.48 ................................................................................................................74 Housing of the Working Classes Act 1885 c.72..........................................................................................................249 Housing of the Working Classes Act 1890 c.70..............................................................................................................7 Housing Rents & Subsidies Act 1975 c.6 ....................................................................................................................233 Housing Repairs and Rents Act 1954 c.53..................................................................................................................301 Human Rights Act 1998 c. 42 .............................................................................................................200, 206, 239, 403 s. 2 .............................................................................................................................................................202, 206, 208 s. 3 .............................................................................................................................................................................206 s. 4 .............................................................................................................................................................................206 s. 5 .............................................................................................................................................................................206 s. 6 .....................................................................................................................................................................207, 208 s. 7 .....................................................................................................................................................................207, 208 s. 8 .............................................................................................................................................................................208 s. 9 ....................................................................................................................................................................208, 209 s. 10 ..........................................................................................................................................................................207 ss. 11–13 ...................................................................................................................................................................206 s. 19 ...................................................................................................................................................................206, 207 s. 21 ..................................................................................................................................................................206, 207 s. 22 ...........................................................................................................................................................................200 sch. 1 .................................................................................................................................................................200, 206
TABLE OF STATUTES
xcv
Immigration Act 1971 c.77 ......................................................................................................................................92, 94 Immigration Act 1988 c.14 ...........................................................................................................................................94 Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 c.33 ss. 1–17 .......................................................................................................................................................................95 ss. 69–70 .....................................................................................................................................................................97 ss. 95–99................................................................................................................................................................98, 99 ss. 115–116 .................................................................................................................................................................95 s. 118 .....................................................................................................................................................................92, 95 schs. 8, 9, 14................................................................................................................................................................99 Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1988 c.1 s. 42A..........................................................................................218, 645 Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (Restrictions) Act 1920 c.17 ..............................................................301, 306 Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (War Restrictions) Act 1915 c.97 ..........................................................3, 549 Industrial and Provident Societies Act 1965 c.12 ........................................................................................................11 Inheritance (Provision for Family & Dependents) Act 1975 c.63.............................................................................117 Insolvency Act 1985 c.65 ............................................................................................................................................830 Insolvency Act 1986 c. 45 ...........................................................................................................................................489 s. 11 ...........................................................................................................................................................................650 s. 112 .........................................................................................................................................................................830 ss. 122–123 ...............................................................................................................................................................489 s. 178 .................................................................................................................................................................773–774 ss. 179–182 ......................................................................................................................................................773–775 s. 252 .........................................................................................................................................................................650 s. 283 .................................................................................................................................................................113, 393 s. 308A .............................................................................................................................................................113–114 s. 309 ........................................................................................................................................................................114 s. 315 .........................................................................................................................................................114, 773–774 ss. 316–317 ..............................................................................................................................................114, 773–774 ss. 318–321................................................................................................................................................114, 773, 775 s. 336 .........................................................................................................................................................................131 s. 383 .................................................................................................................................................................805, 829 Judicature Act 1873 see Supreme Court of Judicature Act Land Compensation Act 1973 c.26 .....................................................................................................................345, 440 Landlord and Tenant Act 1730 c.28 ss. 2–4 ...............................................................................................................................................................796, 816 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................299, 602, 618 s. 8 .............................................................................................................................................................................648 Landlord and Tenant Act 1737 (Distress for Rent Act), 11 George 2, c.19 .............................................214, 650, 652 Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 (L.T.A.) c.36 ....................................................................................540, 549, 731, 779 Part I .................................................................................................................................................................575, 694 s. 1 ............................................................................................................................................................................695 s. 2 .............................................................................................................................................................293, 695, 732 ss. 3–17........................................................................................................................................................41, 694, 695 s. 18 ..................................................................................................................................................195, 635, 680, 684 s. 18(1) ......................................................................................................................................................369, 681, 682 s. 18(2) ..............................................................................................................................................373, 591, 593, 801 s. 19 ............................................................................................................50, 288, 289, 291, 292, 635, 727, 731, 739 s. 19(1) ......................................................................................................................291, 292, 378, 694, 730, 734, 739 s. 19(1A)–(1E) ..................................................................................................................................378, 730, 741, 779 s. 19(2)–(4) ..............................................................................................................................252, 370, 693, 709, 731 s. 21 ...........................................................................................................................................................................695 s. 23 ............................................................................................................................................27, 588, 589, 591–593 s. 25 ..........................................................................................................................................................291, 543, 731 Landlord and Tenant Act (L.T.A.) 1954 c.56.............................................................................................................148 s. 1–22 part I (long tenancies) .................................................................................................................................388 s. 2 .............................................................................................................................................................148, 392–395 s. 3 ....................................................................................................................................................................392–395 s. 4 .............................................................................................................................................................................395 s. 5 ............................................................................................................................................................................395
xcvi
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 6–10 .......................................................................................................................................................281, 393, 687 s. 12 ...........................................................................................................................................................................395 ss. 13–21 ...........................................................................................................................................................393, 395 s. 22 ...................................................................................................................................................................149, 394 ss. 23–46 part II (business lease renewal) ...............................................................................................................540 s. 23(1) ..............................................................................................................................................541, 544, 546–551 s. 23(2) ......................................................................................................................................................................541 s. 23(3)–(4) ..............................................................................................................................................542, 547, 567 s. 24 ...................................................................................................................................................559, 575, 588, 598 s. 24A ................................................................................................................................................................567, 667 s. 25 ...................................................................................................................................559, 561–563, 582, 586, 695 s. 26 ...........................................................................................................................................560, 561, 563, 667, 695 s. 27 ...................................................................................................................................................................561, 587 s. 28 ...................................................................................................................................................................562, 566 s. 29 ...................................................................................................................................................560, 562, 563, 566 s. 30 ..................................................................................................................................................561, 562, 568, 572 s. 30(1)(d).................................................................................................................................................................569 s. 30(1)(f)..........................................................................................................................410, 545, 569, 570, 582, 589 s. 30(1)(g) .................................................................................................................................................................571 s. 31 .........................................................................................................................................................................................................................569, 570 s. 31A .......................................................................................................................................................................570 s. 32 ...........................................................................................................................................................544, 566, 567 s. 33 ...................................................................................................................................................................566, 567 s. 34 ...........................................................................................................................................566, 656, 661, 664, 665 s. 34A ........................................................................................................................................................................570 s. 35 ..................................................................................................................................................566, 567, 568, 656 s. 36 ..................................................................................................................................................................562, 566 s. 37 ..................................................................................................................................................................573, 574 s. 38 ...........................................................................................................................................................558, 573, 575 s. 38(4) .....................................................................................................................................555, 556, 558, 575, 598 s. 40 ..........................................................................................................................................................................562 s. 41 ..................................................................................................................................................................547, 572 s. 41A .......................................................................................................................................................547, 566, 568 s. 42 ...........................................................................................................................................................................572 s. 43 ...................................................................................................................................................543, 555, 607, 609 s. 43A .......................................................................................................................................................................566 s. 44 ..........................................................................................................................................................................565 s. 46 ..........................................................................................................................................................................543 s. 47–50 Part III ................................................................................................................................................694, 695 s. 51 ...................................................................................................................................................................682, 802 s. 54 ..........................................................................................................................................................................809 s. 55 ...........................................................................................................................................................................573 s. 57–60B ..........................................................................................................................................................543, 573 s. 63 ...................................................................................................................................................393, 523, 575, 695 s. 64 ...........................................................................................................................................................392, 395, 661 s. 65 ..........................................................................................................................................................559, 565, 586 s. 67 ..........................................................................................................................................................................565 s. 69 ..........................................................................................................................................................505, 551, 565 s. 83 ..................................................................................................................................................................370, 693 schs. 1–5 (long) ................................................................................................................................................393, 395 schs. 6–8 (business)..........................................................................................................................................543, 565 Landlord and Tenant Act (L.T.A.) 1985 c.70 ....................................................................................................249, 282 ss. 1–3........................................................................................................................................195, 223, 367, 450, 452 s. 3 ............................................................................................................................................304, 367, 431, 452, 748 s. 3A .................................................................................................................................................................223, 452 ss. 4–7 ...............................................................................................................................................................195, 429 ss. 8–10......................................................................................................................................190, 246, 249, 250, 451 ss. 11–17 .............................................................................................................................................34, 195, 243, 368 s. 11 ...........................................................................................................243, 245, 246, 254, 255, 261, 262, 302, 451
TABLE OF STATUTES
xcvii
s. 12 ...........................................................................................................................................................................261 s. 13 ..........................................................................................................................................................................244 s. 14 ..........................................................................................................................................................................244 s. 15 ...........................................................................................................................................................................244 s. 16 ...................................................................................................................................................................243–245 s. 17 ...................................................................................................................................................................255, 256 s. 18 ..................................................................................................................................................372, 460, 462, 804 ss. 18–30 ...........................................................................................................................................196, 283, 450, 460 s. 19 ...................................................................................................................................................................460–462 s. 20 ..................................................................................................................................................................460, 462 ss. 20A–20C ......................................................................................................................................................459, 460 ss. 21–30 ...................................................................................................................................279, 460, 461, 464, 689 s. 30A ...............................................................................................................................................................450, 465 s. 30B.........................................................................................................................................................283, 450, 461 s. 31 ...........................................................................................................................................................227, 232, 233 ss. 31A–31C .............................................................................................................................................................459 s. 32 ...........................................................................................................................................................................243 sch. ...................................................................................................................................................450, 465, 466, 689 Landlord and Tenant Act (L.T.A.) 1987 c.31.............................................................................................................282 ss. 1–20 part I (first refusal).............................................................................................................223, 282, 426, 452 s. 1 .....................................................................................................................................................282, 427, 428, 434 s. 2 ....................................................................................................................................................................282, 428 s. 3 .............................................................................................................................................................................428 s. 3A ..........................................................................................................................................................................431 s. 4 .....................................................................................................................................................................428, 429 s. 4A .........................................................................................................................................................................429 s. 5 .............................................................................................................................................421, 427, 429, 430, 450 ss. 5A–5D..................................................................................................................................................................429 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................................430 s. 7 .............................................................................................................................................................................430 ss. 8–9B .....................................................................................................................................................................430 s. 10A .......................................................................................................................................................................430 ss. 11–17 ...........................................................................................................................................................429–431 s. 11A .......................................................................................................................................................................431 ss. 12A–12C .............................................................................................................................................................431 s. 18 ..........................................................................................................................................................................431 ss. 18A–19.........................................................................................................................................................430, 431 s. 20 ..........................................................................................................................................................................462 ss. 21–24 managers etc .............................................................................................................283, 452, 453, 455, 465 ss. 25–34 ...........................................................................................................................................................283, 454 ss. 35–40....................................................................................................................................................283, 450, 454 ss. 41–45 ..........................................................................................................................283, 450, 460, 461, 463, 465 ss. 46–49 (Part VI)....................................................................195, 223, 269, 367, 448, 450, 452, 460, 465, 590, 623 s. 50 ...................................................................................................................................................................367, 452 s. 58 ...........................................................................................................................................................282, 427, 453 sch. ...........................................................................................................................................................................465 Landlord and Tenant Act (L.T.A.) 1988 c.26 ............................................................................................635, 637, 731 s. 1(1) ................................................................................................................................................290, 302, 727, 731 s. 1(2) .......................................................................................................................................................................293 s. 1(3)........................................................................................................................................292, 293, 732–734, 740 s. 1(4) ........................................................................................................................................................................740 s. 1(5) ................................................................................................................................................................734, 739 s. 2 ............................................................................................................................................................................732 s. 4 .....................................................................................................................................................................293, 734 s. 5 ....................................................................................................................................292, 533, 591, 727, 731, 732 s. 6 ............................................................................................................................................................................293 s. 7 ............................................................................................................................................................................731 Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 c.30 .............385, 537, 556, 636, 637, 686, 728, 742, 745, 747, 753, 776 s. 1 ............................................................................................................................................................295, 304, 747
xcviii
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 2 .....................................................................................................................................295, 304, 711, 747, 748, 765 s. 3 ............................................................................................................295, 297, 304, 711, 747, 757, 760, 764, 768 s. 4 ............................................................................................................................................................757, 763, 823 s. 5 .............................................................................................................................................................379, 748, 778 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................304, 379, 748 s. 7 ....................................................................................................................................................................304, 379 s. 8 ............................................................................................................................................................304, 379, 749 ss. 9–10 .....................................................................................................................................................................757 s. 11 ...........................................................................................................................................295, 379, 748, 749, 757 s. 12 ..........................................................................................................................................................424, 765, 771 s. 13 ...........................................................................................................................................................................747 s. 14 ..................................................................................................................................................................748, 790 s. 15 ..........................................................................................................................................................761, 762, 764 s. 16 ...................................................................................................................................................................779, 780 s. 17 ..........................................................................................................................................593, 783, 784, 787, 788 s. 18 ...................................................................................................................................................................785, 786 ss. 19–20 ...................................................................................................................................................................787 s. 21 ...........................................................................................................................................................757, 763, 823 s. 22 ...................................................................................................................................................................378, 730 s. 23 ...........................................................................................................................................295, 304, 748, 753, 763 s. 24 ..........................................................................................................................................295, 711, 748, 749, 753 s. 25 ..................................................................................................................................................................778, 780 s. 26 ..........................................................................................................................................................................757 s. 27 ..................................................................................................................................................................593, 741 s. 28 ...........................................................................................................711, 741, 747, 748, 749, 755, 757, 778, 780 sch. 1. .......................................................................................................................................................568, 661, 656 Landlord and Tenant (Licensed Premises) Act 1990 c.39 ................................................................................543, 573 Land Registration Act 1925 (L.R.A.) c.21 s. 2 ............................................................................................................................................................382, 505, 529 s. 8 ....................................................................................................................................................382–384, 505, 566 s. 13 ..........................................................................................................................................................................384 s. 19 .....................................................................................................................................................................36, 507 s. 22 ....................................................................................................................................................................36, 507 s. 24 ...........................................................................................................................................................380, 748, 790 s. 38 ..........................................................................................................................................................................385 s. 48 .....................................................................................................................................................................36, 507 s. 59 ..........................................................................................................................................................................499 s. 70(1)(g) .............................................................................................................................33, 36, 307, 507, 528, 530 s. 70(1)(k) .....................................................................................................................................30, 35, 307, 506, 526 s. 82 ..................................................................................................................................................................474, 479 s. 123 ........................................................................................................................................................383, 384, 506 Land Registration Act 1986 c.26 ...........................................................................................................35, 382, 384, 505 s. 2 .....................................................................................................................................................382, 383, 505, 506 s. 3 ......................................................................................................................................................37, 382, 384, 507 s. 4 ...............................................................................................................................................................36, 506, 508 Land Registration Act 1997 c. 2...................................................................................................................384, 404, 506 Late Payment of Commercial Interest Act 1999 c.1...................................................................................................645 Law Commissions Act 1965 c.22.................................................................................................................................196 Law of Distress Amendment Act 1888 c.21........................................................................................................651–652 Law of Distress Amendment Act 1895 c.24........................................................................................................651–652 Law of Distress Amendment Act 1908 c.53................................................................................................220, 649, 653 Law of Property Act 1922 c.16 s. 145, sch. 15.....................................................................................534, 535, 537, 635 Law of Property Act 1925 (L.P.A. 1925) c.20 ....................................................................305, 635, 752, 758, 763, 823 s. 1(1) ....................................................................................................................................................18, 35, 363, 529 s. 1(2) ................................................................................................................................................417, 721, 762, 823 s. 1(6) ................................................................................................................................................................121, 425 s. 36 ...................................................................................................................................................................125, 425 s. 40 .............................................................................................................................................................32, 536, 598 ss. 40 to 54(1) ............................................................................................................................................................30
TABLE OF STATUTES
xcix
s. 44 ..................................................................................................................................................................383, 384 s. 45 ...................................................................................................................................................................377, 383 s. 48 ..........................................................................................................................................................................378 s. 52 ...............................................................................................................30, 37, 123, 293, 377, 508, 520, 721, 742 s. 54 ...........................................................................................................21, 30, 31, 36, 144, 153, 194, 305, 506, 518 s. 55 ...................................................................................................................................................................479, 487 s. 56 ...................................................................................................................................................711, 760, 771, 781 s. 61 ..........................................................................................................................................................................581 s. 62 ..................................................................................................................................................................125, 417 s. 72 ..........................................................................................................................................................................595 s. 77 ...........................................................................................................................................................380, 748, 790 s. 78 ..........................................................................................................................................................................747 s. 79 ..................................................................................................................................................747, 764, 768, 777 s. 82 ...........................................................................................................................................................................595 ss. 85–87....................................................................................................................................379, 509, 727, 743, 761 s. 99 ...........................................................................................................................................................................306 s. 100 ...................................................................................................................................................................37, 596 s. 139 ................................................................................................................................299, 300, 502, 602, 618, 635 s. 140 .................................................................................................................304, 305, 560, 588, 627, 742, 758, 759 s. 141 ................................................................................304, 305, 747, 750, 752, 758, 762, 763, 765, 776, 782, 823 s. 142 ........................................................................................................304, 747, 750, 752, 754, 755, 765, 776, 782 s. 143 .................................................................................................................................................................759, 812 s. 144 .........................................................................................................................................................291, 635, 740 s. 146 .........................................................................................................................373, 376, 532, 671, 796, 804, 831 s. 146(1)............................................................................................................................................................797–800 s. 146(2) ............................................................................................................................................................686, 824 s. 146(3) ....................................................................................................................................................................801 s. 146(4) ....................................................................................................................................377, 825, 826, 831, 835 s. 146(5) ............................................................................................................................................................532, 823 s. 146(7) ....................................................................................................................................................................797 s. 146(8)–(10) ...........................................................................................................................374, 799, 823, 830, 831 s. 146(11)–(12).........................................................................................................................................795–797, 810 s. 147 ................................................................................................................................................................373, 801 s. 149 (1) ...................................................................................................................................................................519 s. 149 (2) ...................................................................................................................................................................529 s. 149 (3) ...................................................................................................................................................................518 s. 149 (6) ...............................................................................................17, 32, 364, 365, 390, 393, 514, 516, 521, 612 s. 150 .........................................................................................................................................................299, 602, 618 s. 152 .........................................................................................................................................................................566 s. 153 .........................................................................................................................................................................388 s. 154 ........................................................................................................................................................................755 s. 185 .........................................................................................................................................................................596 s. 190 .........................................................................................................................................................................535 s. 196 .............................................................................................................................................27–28, 319, 588–592 s. 205(1)(xxiii) .........................................................................................................................................740, 755, 804 s. 205(1)(xxvi) ..........................................................................................................................................................364 s. 205(1)(xxvii) ................................................................................................17, 19, 21, 35, 364, 365, 509, 510, 511 Law of Property Act 1969 c.59 ...................................................................................................................................637 part I .........................................................................................................................................................................541 s. 2 .....................................................................................................................................................................566, 661 s. 5 .....................................................................................................................................................................534, 555 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................................568 s. 7 ...........................................................................................................................................................................570 s. 9 .....................................................................................................................................................................547, 566 s. 11 ...........................................................................................................................................................................573 Law of Property Amendment Act 1859 c.35 .............................................................................................595, 686, 759 Law of Property Amendment Act 1860 c.38 .............................................................................................................812 Law of Property (Amendment) Act 1929 c.9 ....................................................................................................823, 831 Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 c.34
c
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 1 .......................................................................................................................................................................33, 508 s. 2 ...................................................................................................................................33, 34, 38, 518, 519, 536, 598 Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) A. 1994 c.36 .......................................................................................385 s. 1 .............................................................................................................................................................................415 s. 4 .............................................................................................................................................................................384 s. 14–18 .....................................................................................................................................................................589 Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 c.40 ....................................................................................................716 Leasehold Property (Repairs) Act 1938 c.34...............................255, 369, 373, 680, 682, 684, 707, 802, 804, 810, 824 Leasehold Reform Act 1967 (L.Ref.A.) c.88 ...............................................................................203, 367, 389, 393, 398 s. 1 .............................................................................................................................390, 391, 396, 399, 400, 404, 413 s. 1A ..................................................................................................................................................................404, 405 s. 1AA........................................................................................................................................................................405 s. 2 .............................................................................................................................................................399, 400, 413 s. 3 .....................................................................................................................................................363, 389, 390, 398 s. 4 ............................................................................................................................................................367, 390, 391 s. 4A .................................................................................................................................................................391, 405 s. 5 ....................................................................................................................................................409, 412, 414, 415 s. 6 ............................................................................................................................................................................397 s. 7 .............................................................................................................................................................................397 s. 8 .............................................................................................................................................................410–412, 417 s. 9 .............................................................................................................................................403–406, 409, 412–414 ss. 10–12 ...........................................................................................................................................................413–415 s. 14 ...................................................................................................................................................................401–402 s. 15 ...........................................................................................................................................................401, 402, 687 s. 16 ..........................................................................................................................148, 394, 398, 401, 402, 405, 406 ss. 17–19....................................................................................................................................................405, 410, 418 s. 20 ...................................................................................................................................................410, 412, 414, 523 s. 21 ...........................................................................................................................................................412, 414, 416 s. 22 ..........................................................................................................................................................................400 s. 23 ..........................................................................................................................................................................410 ss. 25–31 ...................................................................................................................................................................415 s. 27 ...........................................................................................................................................................................416 ss. 28–33A.................................................................................................................................................390, 409, 410 s. 35 ...........................................................................................................................................................................400 s. 37 ...................................................................................................................................................................396, 409 sch. 1 .........................................................................................................................................................................415 sch. 2 ........................................................................................................................................................................410 sch. 3 ........................................................................................................................................................400, 409, 411 sch. 4 .........................................................................................................................................................................393 sch. 4A ......................................................................................................................................................................390 sch. 9 ........................................................................................................................................................................405 Leasehold Reform Act 1979 c.44.................................................................................................................................415 Leasehold Reform, Housing, and Urban Development Act (L.R.H.U.D.A.) 1993 c.28 ................265, 389, 404, 424 s. 1–38 part I chap.I (collective) ......................................................................................................................398, 432 s. 1 .............................................................................................................................................................432, 433, 440 s. 2 .............................................................................................................................................................................440 s. 3 ............................................................................................................................................................................432 s. 4 .............................................................................................................................................................432–435, 440 ss. 4A–4C ..................................................................................................................................................................440 s. 5 ....................................................................................................................................................................433, 435 s. 6 ....................................................................................................................................................406, 433, 435, 436 s. 7 .....................................................................................................................................................363, 389, 390, 435 s. 8 .............................................................................................................................................................367, 391, 435 s. 8A ..........................................................................................................................................................................435 s. 9 .............................................................................................................................................................396, 412, 415 s. 10 .................................................................................................................................................................434, 435 ss. 11–12A.................................................................................................................................................440, 442, 443 s. 13 ...................................................................................................................................................435–437, 440–444 ss. 14–16 ...................................................................................................................................................................440
TABLE OF STATUTES
ci
s. 17 ...........................................................................................................................................................................440 s. 18 ...........................................................................................................................................................................440 s. 19 ...........................................................................................................................................................................415 ss. 20–29 ...................................................................................................................................412, 434, 437, 440, 444 s. 30 ..................................................................................................................................................................434, 440 s. 31 ...........................................................................................................................................................409, 434, 440 s. 32 ...................................................................................................................................................413, 414, 437, 440 s. 33 ...................................................................................................................................................................438, 440 ss. 34–38 ...................................................................................................................................................396, 440, 443 ss. 39–62 part I chap.II (individual)........................................................................................................................398 s. 39 ..................................................................................................................................................392, 397, 406, 407 s. 40 ..................................................................................................................................................................412, 415 s. 41 ...........................................................................................................................................................................440 s. 42 ...........................................................................................................................................392, 398, 411, 413, 414 s. 43 ..........................................................................................................................................................................412 s. 45 ..........................................................................................................................................................408, 412, 414 s. 47 ...................................................................................................................................................................410, 412 s. 48 ...................................................................................................................................................................413, 441 s. 49 ...................................................................................................................................................................412, 414 ss. 50–51............................................................................................................................................................412, 416 ss. 52–55....................................................................................................................................409, 412–414, 440, 443 s. 56 ..................................................................................................................................................................413, 414 s. 57 ...........................................................................................................................................................411, 415, 417 s. 58 ..................................................................................................................................................................414, 454 s. 58A .......................................................................................................................................................................415 s. 59 ..........................................................................................................................................................148, 394, 398 s. 60 ...................................................................................................................................................................413, 414 s. 61 ...........................................................................................................................................................................410 s. 62 ...........................................................................................................................................................................408 ss. 63–65 ...................................................................................................................................................................405 ss. 66–68............................................................................................................................................................406, 409 ss. 69–75............................................................................................................................................279, 418, 419, 440 ss. 76–84 ...................................................................................................................................................283, 455, 462 s. 85 ...........................................................................................................................................................................454 s. 86 ..........................................................................................................................................................................454 s. 87 ...........................................................................................................................................279, 283, 453, 455, 460 s. 91 ...........................................................................................................................................................392, 408, 440 s. 93 ..................................................................................................................................................................410, 440 s. 93A ................................................................................................................................................................435, 440 s. 94 ...................................................................................................................................................................392, 409 s. 95 ..........................................................................................................................................................................409 s. 96 ..........................................................................................................................................................................409 ss. 97–99....................................................................................................................................................408, 412, 440 s. 100 .................................................................................................................................................................225, 436 s. 101 .................................................................................................................................................................225, 401 ss. 104–106 .......................................................................................................................................................390, 496 s. 107 ................................................................................................................................................................499, 500 s. 120 ................................................................................................................................................................499, 500 ss. 121–125 ...............................................................................................................................................225, 265, 279 ss. 131–132 ...............................................................................................................................................................279 ss. 133–136........................................................................................................................................................280, 500 s. 152 .........................................................................................................................................................................279 sch. 1 .........................................................................................................................................................415, 432, 440 sch. 2 .........................................................................................................................................................................415 sch. 3 .........................................................................................................................................................440, 443, 444 sch. 6 ................................................................................................................................................................437–439 sch. 7 .................................................................................................................................................409, 438, 442, 443 sch. 13 .......................................................................................................................................................406–409, 415 sch. 14 .......................................................................................................................................................................410
cii
TABLE OF STATUTES
sch. 15 ......................................................................................................................................................................406 sch. 17 .......................................................................................................................................................................407 sch. 21–22 .................................................................................................................................................................501 Limitation Act 1980 c.58 .......................................................................................................................32, 222, 646, 780 Local Government Act 1988 c.9 ..................................................................................................................................276 Local Government Finance Act 1992 c.14 .........................................................................................................214–217 Local Government and Housing Act 1989 c.42 s. 101–138 .................................................................................................................................................................275 s. 74–77 .....................................................................................................................................................................224 s. 149 .........................................................................................................................................................................574 s. 164 .........................................................................................................................................................................496 parts IV, VI...................................................................................................................................................................224 part VII ...........................................................................................................................................................................9 sch. 7 .............................................................................................................................................................367, 391, 574 sch. 9 ............................................................................................................................................................................249 sch. 10 ..........................................................................................................................................................................395 Local Government Finance Act 1988 c.41 .................................................................................................................668 Local Government, Planning & Land Act 1980 c.65 .....................................................................................................9 Matrimonial Causes Act (M.C.A.) 1973 c.18 s. 24 ..........................................................................................................................................................136, 139, 140 s. 25A ........................................................................................................................................................................137 s. 37 ...................................................................................................................................................129, 130, 137, 504 Matrimonial Homes Act 1967 c.75 .....................................................................................................................130, 136 Matrimonial Homes Act (M.H.A.) 1983 ...................................................................................................................117 s. 1 ............................................................................................................................................................131, 133, 221 s. 2 .....................................................................................................................................................................131, 132 s. 7 ....................................................................................................................................................................136, 140 s. 10 ...........................................................................................................................................................................131 s. 33, 40 .....................................................................................................................................................................133 sch. 1 ...................................................................................................................................................................136, 140 Matrimonial Homes and Property Act 1981 c.24 ......................................................................................................136 Mobile Homes Act 1975 c.49 ......................................................................................................................................180 Mobile Homes Act 1983 c.34 ..............................................................................................................................180–182 National Assistance Act 1948 c.29 s. 21. .................................................................................................................97, 98 National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990c.19 s. 47. .....................................................................97–98 New Towns Acts 1946, 1959, 1981, cc.68, 62, 64 ...........................................................................................................9 Noise and Statutory Nuisance Act 1993 c.40 .............................................................................................................719 Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 1964 c. 55.........................................................................................................537 Protection from Eviction Act 1964 c.97 .....................................................................................................................315 Protection from Eviction Act (P.E.A.) 1977 c.43.........................................................................54, 164, 195, 316, 610 s. 1(1), (1A) .........................................................................................................................................................26, 81 s. 1(2)–(3B) ..............................................................................................................................................312, 315, 316 s. 2 .......................................................................................................................................................20, 311, 374, 808 s. 3 ............................................................................................................................................................311, 374, 808 s. 3A .........................................................................................................................................................................311 s. 4 ....................................................................................................................................................................191, 311 s. 5 ..................................................................................................................................22, 26, 53, 110, 127, 223, 585 s. 7 ..............................................................................................................................................................................12 Protection from Harassment Act 1997 c. 40 ..............................................................................................................315 Public Health Act 1936 c.49 .......................................................................................................................................266 Race Relations Act 1976 c.74 ........................................................................................................................71, 292, 736 Rating Revaluation Act 1999 c.6 ................................................................................................................................668 Real Property Act 1845 c.106 s. 3 ..............................................................................................................................................................34, 507, 520 s. 5 .............................................................................................................................................................................771 s. 9 .............................................................................................................................................................299, 602, 618 Recorded Delivery Service Act 1962 c.27 .....................................................................................................28, 592–593 Rent Act 1965 c.75 ..................................................................................................................................................3, 549 Rent Act 1974 c.51 ...............................................................................................................................................146, 161
TABLE OF STATUTES
ciii
Rent Act (R.A.) 1977 c.42 .................................................................4, 44, 108, 109, 113, 115, 131, 145, 150, 158, 637 part IV.................................................................................................................................................................52, 190 part VI.........................................................................................................................................................................12 part VIII ...................................................................................................................................................................234 s. 1 ...............................................................................................................................14, 109, 143, 145, 146, 300, 394 s. 2 .................................................................................................................................14, 29, 105, 110, 116, 121, 310 s. 3 .................................................................................................................................................26, 29, 111, 170, 318 ss. 4–16A.....................................................................................................................................................................45 s. 4 ............................................................................................................................................................................169 s. 5 ............................................................................................................................................................166, 223, 392 s. 5A ............................................................................................................................................................................11 s. 6 .............................................................................................................................................................................609 s. 7 .....................................................................................................................................................................160–161 s. 8 ............................................................................................................................................................................168 s. 9 ............................................................................................................................................................................168 s. 10 ..................................................................................................................................................................187, 609 s. 12 ..................................................................................................................................................................163, 433 ss. 13–16 .....................................................................................................................................................................11 s. 18A ...................................................................................................................................................................3, 234 s. 19 ...................................................................................................................................................................164, 168 s. 20 ...........................................................................................................................................................................164 s. 21 ..................................................................................................................................................................147, 164 s. 22 ..........................................................................................................................................................147, 148, 296 s. 23 ..........................................................................................................................................................................148 s. 24 ..................................................................................................................................................................301, 549 s. 26 ...........................................................................................................................................................................609 ss. 44–47 ...........................................................................................................................................................235, 236 s. 49 ..........................................................................................................................................................................236 s. 51 ..................................................................................................................................................................235, 236 s. 54 ..........................................................................................................................................................................236 s. 57 ..................................................................................................................................................................223, 236 s. 58 ...........................................................................................................................................................................223 ss. 62–64A ................................................................................................................................................................237 s. 66 ..........................................................................................................................................................................237 s. 67 ..................................................................................................................................................................235–237 s. 67A ........................................................................................................................................................................233 s. 70 ...........................................................................................................................................................228–231, 233 s. 71 ..........................................................................................................................................................................234 s. 72 ..........................................................................................................................................................................236 s. 72A ........................................................................................................................................................................233 s. 73 ..................................................................................................................................................................235–237 ss. 77–82 ...................................................................................................................................................................238 ss. 87–96 ...................................................................................................................................................................234 s. 98 .............................................................................................................................................................41, 351, 356 s. 99 ...........................................................................................................................................................................191 s. 100 ........................................................................................................................................................................332 s. 102 ........................................................................................................................................................................329 ss. 102A–106A .........................................................................................................................................................165 s. 116 ........................................................................................................................................................................234 ss. 119–128........................................................................................................................................114, 238, 241, 289 s. 137 ........................................................................................................................................................297, 299, 301 s. 138 .................................................................................................................................................................297, 299 s. 139 ........................................................................................................................................................................300 s. 140 ........................................................................................................................................................................252 s. 141 .................................................................................................................................................................321, 523 s. 143 .........................................................................................................................................................................232 s. 147 ................................................................................................................................................................220, 656 s. 148 .................................................................................................................................................................254, 707 s. 151 ...................................................................................................................................................................28, 591
civ
TABLE OF STATUTES
s. 152 ................................................................................................................................................................296, 306 sch. 1 part 1 ..............................................................................................................................................110, 116, 191 sch. 1 paras. 2–7 .......................................................................................................................................................121 sch. 1 para. 3.....................................................................................................................................................121, 124 sch. 1 paras. 5–6 ..............................................................................................................................................118, 121 sch. 1 para. 7 ....................................................................................................................................................120–124 sch. 1 para. 10 ..........................................................................................................................................................122 sch. 1 paras. 12–14 ............................................................................................................................62, 111, 241, 289 sch. 2 ................................................................................................................................................117, 163, 164, 234 sch. 4 .........................................................................................................................................................................163 sch. 10 .....................................................................................................................................................................238 sch. 11 ..............................................................................................................................................................237–238 sch. 14 ......................................................................................................................................................................234 sch. 15 ..............................................................................................................................................298, 336, 356–357 sch. 15 case 1 ............................................................................................................................................................115 sch. 15 case 5 ..........................................................................................................................................................348 sch. 15 cases 11–12 ......................................................................................................................................63, 64, 349 sch. 15 cases 13–15 ..........................................................................................................................................168, 185 sch. 15 cases 16–18 ..................................................................................................................................................185 sch. 15 case 20 .....................................................................................................................................................63, 64 sch. 16 ......................................................................................................................................................................191 sch. 17 ..................................................................................................................................................................3, 234 sch. 18 ......................................................................................................................................................................241 sch. 20 .......................................................................................................................................................................252 Rent (Agriculture) Act 1976 c.80........................................................................................................................188, 191 s. 1 ............................................................................................................................................................................606 s. 2 ............................................................................................................................................................................189 s. 3 .............................................................................................................................................................................190 s. 4 ............................................................................................................................................................116, 189, 190 s. 5 ............................................................................................................................................................................188 s. 6 .....................................................................................................................................................................191, 318 s. 7 ............................................................................................................................................................................191 s. 8 ....................................................................................................................................................................220, 650 ss. 11–14 ...................................................................................................................................................................190 s. 23 ...................................................................................................................................................................188, 189 s. 26 ...........................................................................................................................................................................523 ss. 27–29 ...................................................................................................................................................................191 sch. 2 ................................................................................................................................................................187, 189 sch. 3 ........................................................................................................................................................................188 sch. 4 ........................................................................................................................................................................191 Rent (Amendment) Act 1985 c.24 ..............................................................................................................................349 Rentcharges Act 1977 c.30 ..........................................................................................................................................642 Sale of Goods Act 1979 c.54 .......................................................................................................................................645 Settled Land Act (S.L.A.) 1925 c.18 ............................................................................................................................365 Sex Discrimination Act 1975 c.65 ................................................................................................................71, 292, 736 Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992 c.4...................................................................................239–241 Stamp Act 1891 sch.1 c.39 ..........................................................................................................................218, 380–381 Statute of Frauds 1677, 29 Charles 2, c.3 .......................................................................................30–34, 507, 508, 780 Statute of Marlborough 1267, 52 Henry 3, c.23 ................................................................262–264, 368, 651, 672, 677 Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1873 c.66 ..............................................................522, 523–525, 640, 697, 756, 799 Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1873 Amendment Act 38 & 39 Vict. c.77 ...........................................................522 Supreme Court of Judicature (Consolidation) Act 1925 c.49 ..................................................................................817 Supreme Court Act 1981 c.54 s. 38 ............................................................................257, 523, 524, 647, 817, 821, 832 Town and Country Planning Act (T.C.P.A.) 1990 c.8 ......................................................................................708–709 Tribunal and Inquiries Act 1992 c.53 .................................................................................................................238–239 Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act (T.L.A.T.A.) 1996 c.47 .......................................................176, 365 Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 c.50 ................................................................................................................198, 638 Validation of War Time Leases Act 1944 c.34....................................................................................................512, 514 Value Added Tax Act 1994 sch.10 c.23 ......................................................................................................................642
TABLE OF STATUTES
cv
Water Industry Act 1991 c.60 .....................................................................................................................................219 Water Industry Act 1999 c.9 .......................................................................................................................................219
TABLE OF STATUTORY INSTRUMENTS (excluding commencement orders)
S. R. & O. 1925/857 Renewable Leaseholds Regs .......................................................................................................534 S. R. & O. 1925/1093 Land Registration Rules (L.R.R.) 1925 r. 76 ..........................................................................................................................................................................385 r. 115 .........................................................................................................................................................................385 r. 199 ...................................................................................................................................................................36, 507 r. 200 ........................................................................................................................................................................597 r. 201 ........................................................................................................................................................................507 r. 206 .........................................................................................................................................................................596 sch. 1 ........................................................................................................................................................................385 sch. 2 ........................................................................................................................................................................385 S.I. 1953/1702 Distress for Rent R. .............................................................................................................................651 S.I. 1954/1255 L.T. (Determination of R.V. Procedure) R........................................................................................574 S.I. 1957/1157 L.T. (Notices) Regs..............................................................................................................................395 S.I. 1967/1879 L.Ref. (Enfranchisement and Extension) Regs. .................................................................410, 412, 415 S.I. 1971/1065 R.A.C. (England & Wales) Regs. ................................................................................................238, 239 S.I. 1973/1473 Ag. (Maintenance etc of Fixed Equipment) Regs......................................................................624, 685 S.I. 1978/69 Housing (Homeless Persons)(Appropriate Arrangements) O. ..............................................................92 S.I. 1980/1407 Secure Tenancies (Designated Courses) Regs. ..................................................................................168 S.I. 1980/1696 Regulated Tenancies (Procedure) Regs..............................................................................................237 S.I. 1980/1697 Rent Act (Forms etc) Regs. .........................................................................................................236–237 S.I. 1980/1698 Rent Regulation (Cancellation of Registration of Rent) Regs. ................................................235–237 S.I. 1980/1700 R.A.C. (England and Wales) (Rent Tribunal) Regs. ........................................................................238 S.I. 1980/1707 Protected Shorthold Tenancies (Notice to Tenant) Regs. ..................................................................49 S.I. 1981/139 R.A. (C.Ct. Proceedings for Possession) R. ...................................................................................63, 327 S.I. 1981/1493 R.A.C. (England and Wales)(Rent Tribunal) (Am.) Regs. ..............................................................238 S.I. 1981/1576 Houses (Means of Escape from Fire in H.M.O.s) O. ...............................................................273–274 S.I. 1981/1578 Protected Shorthold Tenancies (Rent) Regs........................................................................................52 S.I. 1981/1579 Protected Shorthold Tenancies (Notice to Tenants) Regs..................................................................49 S.I. 1982/1474 Rent Book (Forms of Notice) Regs. ..................................................................................................223 S.I. 1983/133 L.T.A. 1954 Part II (Notices) Regs. ......................................................................................395, 559, 561 S.I. 1983/748 Mobile Homes (Commissions) O. .......................................................................................................182 S.I. 1984/1301 A.L.T.s (Succession to Ag. Tenancies) O. .........................................................................................621 S.I. 1986/797 Defective Dwellings (Mortgagees) Regs...............................................................................................497 S.I. 1986/1187 R.S.C. (Am. No.2) O. ..........................................................................................................................835 S.I. 1986/1530 Milk Quota (Calculation etc) O. ......................................................................................................629 S.I. 1986/1925 Insolvency R. .......................................................................................................................489, 773, 774 S.I. 1986/2194 Housing (Right to Buy) (Prescribed Forms) Regs. ...........................................................................500 S.I. 1986/2195 Housing (Right to Buy) (Service Charges) O. ..................................................................................459 S.I. 1987/265 Protected Shorthold Tenancies (Rent Registration) O. ..................................................................49, 52 S.I. 1987/710 A.H. (Arbitration on Notices) O. ................................................................................................622, 626 S.I. 1987/711 A.H. (Form of Notice to Pay Rent or to Remedy) Regs. ....................................................................623 S.I. 1987/755 Secure Tenancies (Notices) Regs. ................................................................................................318, 319 S.I. 1987/764 Town & Country Planning (Use Classes) Order ................................................................272, 708, 709 S.I. 1987/1919 Insolvency (Am.) R. ...........................................................................................................................773 S.I. 1987/1971 Housing Benefit (General) Regs. ........................................................................................................240 S.I. 1988/281 Ag. (Maintenance of Fixed Equipment) (Am.) Regs. .........................................................................624 S.I. 1988/884 Housing Defects etc. O. ........................................................................................................................497 S.I. 1988/1265 Housing (Right to Buy) (Prescribed Forms)(Welsh Forms) Regs. ..................................................500 S.I. 1988/1284 Service Charge Contributions (Authorised Investments) O. ..........................................................461
cviii
TABLE OF STATUTORY INSTRUMENTS
S.I. 1988/1285 Service Charge (Estimates and Consultation) O. ..............................................................................460 S.I. 1988/2050 Distress for Rent R. .............................................................................................................................651 S.I. 1988/2199 Assured Tenancies and Ag. Occupancies (Rent Information) O. ...................................................237 S.I. 1988/2201 Notices to Quit etc (Prescribed Information) Regs.............................................................................26 S.I. 1988/2203 Assured Tenancies and Ag. Occupancies (Forms) Regs. ........................................................46, 47, 61 S.I. 1989/513 Housing (Right to Buy)(Maximum Discount) O. ..............................................................................498 S.I. 1989/1548 L.T.A. 1954 Part II (Notices)(Am.) Regs. ..................................................................................559, 561 S.I. 1989/2390 Supply of Beer (Tied Estate) O. ..........................................................................................................713 S.I. 1990/363 L.T.A. 1954 (Appropriate Multiplier) O. ............................................................................................574 S.I. 1990/434 References to Rating (Housing) Regs. .........................................................168, 190, 367, 391, 404, 405 S.I. 1990/830 Housing (Management of H.M.O.s) Regs. .................................................................................273–274 S.I. 1990/1532 Assured Tenancies and Ag. Occupancies (Forms)(Am.) Regs. .........................................................46 S.I. 1990/1730 Housing (Prescribed Forms)(No.2) Regs. .................................................................................271, 273 S.I. 1991/724 High Court and County Courts Jurisdiction Order (H.C.C.C.J.O.) ..........................56, 209, 219, 256, 313, 321, 559, 561, 575, 648 S.I. 1991/982 H.M.O.s (Charges for Registration Schemes) Regs.............................................................................273 S.I. 1991/1247 Family Proceedings R. ................................................................................................................139, 140 S.I. 1991/1943 Protection from Eviction (Excluded Licences) O. ............................................................................311 S.I. 1992/446 Housing Defects (Expenditure Limits) O. ..........................................................................................497 S.I. 1992/548 Council Tax (Discount Disregards) O. ................................................................................................217 S.I. 1992/549 Council Tax (Chargeable Dwellings) O. ..............................................................................................214 S.I. 1992/551 Council Tax (Liability of Owners) Regs...............................................................................................217 S.I. 1992/552 Council Tax (Additional Provisions for Discount Disregards) O. .............................................217, 218 S.I. 1992/558 Council Tax (Exempt Dwellings) O.............................................................................................215, 218 S.I. 1992/613 Council Tax (Administration and Enforcement) Regs. .....................................................214, 215, 217 S.I. 1992/1703 Housing (Right to Buy)(Prescribed Persons) O. ..............................................................................498 S.I. 1992/3023 Council Tax (Prescribed Classes of Dwellings)(Wales) Regs. ..........................................................217 S.I. 1993/207 Furniture & Furnishing (Fire) (Safety) (Amendment) Regulations 1993 ........................................252 S.I. 1993/651 Local Government Finance etc. O. ......................................................................................................226 S.I. 1993/653 R.A.Cs. (England and Wales) (Am.)Regs. ...........................................................................................237 S.I. 1993/654 Assured Tenancies and Ag. Occupancies (Forms)(Am.) Regs. ............................................................46 S.I. 1993/2175 C.Ct. (Am. No. 3) R. ............................................................................................................................57 S.I. 1993/2240 Housing (Extension of the Right to Buy) O. ....................................................................................493 S.I. 1993/2241 Housing (Preservation of the Right to Buy) Regs. ...........................................................................494 S.I. 1993/2407 L.Ref (Collective Enfranchisement and Lease Renewal) Regs. ................................412, 415, 432, 443 S.I. 1993/2408 R.A.C.s (England and Wales) (L.V.T.) Regs. ....................................................412, 414, 431, 437, 443 S.I. 1994/133 Secure Tenants etc (Right to Repair) Regs. .........................................................................................265 S.I. 1994/613 Secure Tenants etc. (Compensation for Improvements) Regs. ..........................................................265 S.I. 1994/627 Housing (Right to Manage) Regs. .......................................................................................................279 S.I. 1994/1886 Gas Supply (Installation and Use) Regs. ............................................................................................252 S.I. 1994/2932 Housing (Right to Buy(Prescribed Forms) (Welsh Forms) Regs.....................................................500 S.I. 1994/3159 Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1994 ........................................................198–199 S.I. 1995/377 L.R. (Implied Covenants for Title) R. .................................................................................................385 S.I. 1995/418 T.C.P. (General Permitted Development) O. .....................................................................................709 S.I. 1995/1804 Units of Measurement Regs................................................................................................................654 S.I. 1995/2644 Statutory Nuisance (Appeals) Regs. ...................................................................................................267 S.I. 1995/2964 L.T. (Covenants) A. 1995 (Notices) Regs...................................................................304, 748, 757, 783 S.I. 1995/3153 L.R. (No.3) R. .....................................................................................................................................790 S.I. 1995/3154 L.R. (Overriding Leases) R. ................................................................................................................787 S.I. 1996/254 Gas Supply (Installation and Use) (Am.) (No.1) Regs........................................................................252 S.I. 1996/337 Ag.H. (Fee) Regs....................................................................................................................................622 S.I. 1996/592 Housing Associations (Permissible Additional Purposes) etc O. ........................................................11 S.I. 1996/1982 Housing Accommodation and Homelessness (Persons Subject to Immigration Control) O. ........92 S.I. 1996/2256 Social Landlords (Permissible Additional Purposes etc.) O. ............................................................11 S.I. 1996/2305 R.A.C. (England and Wales) (L.V.T.) (Am.) Regs. ...........................................................412, 414, 459 S.I. 1996/2325 H.A. 1996 (Consequential Provisions) O. ...................................................................................12, 311 S.I. 1996/2371 Tenants’ Rights of First Refusal (Am.) Regs. ............................................................................430–431 S.I. 1996/2541 Gas Safety (Installation and Use) (Am.)(No.2). Regs. ......................................................................252 S.I. 1996/2651 Housing (Right to Buy)(Prescribed Persons)(Am.) O......................................................................498
TABLE OF STATUTORY INSTRUMENTS
cix
S.I. 1996/2753 Allocation of Housing Regs. ..................................................................................................72, 92, 286 S.I. 1996/2754 Homelessness Regs ...............................................................................................................................92 S.I. 1996/2839 Approval of Codes of Management Practice (Residential Property) O. .........................283, 453, 460 S.I. 1996/3122 Allocation of Housing and Homelessness (Review Procedures and Am.) Regs. ..............................86 S.I. 1996/3204 Homelessness (Suitability of Accommodation) O. ......................................................................82, 83 S.I. 1997/71 Secure Tenancies (Notices)(Am.) Regs. ................................................................................................318 S.I. 1997/72 Introductory Tenants (Review) Regs. ................................................................................70, 86, 112, 165 S.I. 1997/194 Assured Tenancies and Ag. Occupancies (Forms) Regs. ....46, 47, 51, 61, 112, 190, 192, 226, 237, 318 S.I. 1997/227 Housing (Enforcement Procedures for H.M.O.s) O. .........................................................................272 S.I. 1997/228 Housing (Recovery of Expenses of s.352 Notice) O. ..........................................................................273 S.I. 1997/229 H.M.O. (Fees for Registration Schemes) O. ........................................................................................273 S.I. 1997/230 Housing (Fire Safety in H.M.O.s) O. ..........................................................................................273–274 S.I. 1997/377 Secure Tenancies (Notices)(Am.No.2) Regs. ..............................................................................318, 319 S.I. 1997/483 Allocation of Housing (Procedure) Regs. ..............................................................................................86 S.I. 1997/569 Housing (Right to Acquire) (Discount) (Wales) O. ...........................................................................498 S.I. 1997/619 Housing (Right to Acquire) Regs. ........................................................................................494, 496, 497 S.I. 1997/619 Housing (Right to Acquire) Regs. ...............................................................................................494, 498 S.I. 1997/631 Allocation of Housing and Homelessness (Am.) Regs. ............................................................71, 72, 86 S.I. 1997/640 L.Ref. (Notices) Regs. ..................................................................................................187, 411, 412, 414 S.I. 1997/656 Council Tax (Chargeable Dwellings etc.) (Am.) Regs. .......................................................................214 S.I. 1997/685 L.Ref. & Housing (Excluded Tenancies) (Designated Rural Areas)(Wales) O. ........................409, 497 S.I. 1997/797 Homelessness (Isles of Scilly) O. ............................................................................................................91 S.I. 1997/872 Housing (Prescribed Forms)(Am.) Regs. ...........................................................................................273 S.I. 1997/1431 Distress for Customs Duties etc. Regs. .....................................................................................220, 650 S.I. 1997/1741 Homelessness (Suitability of Accommodation) (Am.) O. .................................................................68 S.I. 1997/1837 C.Ct. (Am.) R. ..............................................................................................................................57, 343 S.I. 1997/1838 C.Ct. (Forms) Am. R...........................................................................................................................343 S.I. 1997/1852 L.V.T. (Fees) O. ..........................................................................................................................452, 459 S.I. 1997/1853 L.V.T. (Service Charges etc Applications) O. ...........................................................................452, 459 S.I. 1997/1854 R.A.C. (England and Wales)(L.V.T.)(Am.) Regs. .....................................................372, 452, 459, 804 S.I. 1997/1893 Family Proceedings (Am. No.3) Regs. ..............................................................................130, 139, 140 S.I. 1997/1902 Allocation of Housing (Reasonable and Additional Preference) Regs. .......................................72, 74 S.I. 1997/1903 Housing (Prescribed Forms) (Am.)(No.2) Regs. ..............................................................................272 S.I. 1997/1962 A.H. (Units of Production) O. ............................................................................................................72 S.I. 1997/1965 L.T. (Am.) R. .......................................................................................................................................459 S.I. 1997/1984 Rent Officers (Housing Benefit Functions) O. .........................................................................238, 239 S.I. 1997/2046 Allocation of Housing and Homelessness (Am.)(No.2) Regs. ...........................................................72 S.I. 1997/3005 Long Residential Tenancies (Supplemental Forms) Regs.................................................................394 S.I. 1997/3007 R.A.C. (England and Wales)(Am.) Regs. ..........................................................................................394 S.I. 1997/3008 Long Residential Tenancies (Principal Forms) Regs.........................................................................394 S.I. 1997/3037 L.R.R. ...................................................................................................................................................385 S.I. 1998/105 Council Tax (Prescribed etc. Dwellings) (Wales) Regs. ...................................................................217 S.I. 1998/106 Approval of Codes of Management Practice (Residential Property) O. ............................................................................................279, 283, 453, 455, 459, 460 S.I. 1998/265 Ag. Tied Cottage (Earnings)(Notice Form) Regs. ...............................................................................192 S.I. 1998/1578 Homelessness (Decisions on Referrals) O. .........................................................................................92 S.I. 1998/1812 H.M.Os. (Charges for Registration Schemes) Regs...........................................................................273 S.I. 1998/1967 Assured and Protected Tenancies (Lettings to Students) Regs. .......................................................168 S.I. 1998/2203 Ag. Workers (Forms) O. .............................................................................................................187, 190 S.I. 1998/2997 Housing (Right to Buy)(Limits on Discount) O. ..............................................................................498 S.I. 1999/6 Rent Acts (Maximum Fair Rent) Order ..................................................................................................232 S.I. 1999/61 Government of Wales Act 1998 (Housing)(Ams.) O. ............................................................................11 S.I. 1999/68 Housing Renewal Grants (Common Parts) O. .....................................................................................276 S.I. 1999/71 Allocation and Housing and Homelessness (Review Procedures) Regulations .............................86–87 S.I. 1999/128 L.R.R. 1999.............................................................................................................................................507 S.I. 1999/292 Housing (Right to Buy)(Limits on Discount)(Wales) O. ..................................................................498 S.I. 1999/359 Insolvency Am.R. .................................................................................................................................773 S.I. 1999/584 National Minimum Wage Regs. ...........................................................................................................186 S.I. 1999/985 Social Landlords (Additional Purposes of Objects) O. ........................................................................11
cx
TABLE OF STATUTORY INSTRUMENTS
S.I. 1999/1135 Housing (Right to Acquire)(Discount) O. ...............................................................................494, 498 S.I. 1999/1206 Social Landlords (Additional Purposes etc) (No.2) O. ......................................................................11 S.I. 1999/1213 Housing (Preservation of the Right to Buy)(Am.) Regs. .................................................................494 S.I. 1999/1307 Housing (Right to Acquire or Enfranchise) (Designated Rural Areas) O. ......................................497 S.I. 1999/1541 Relocation Grants (Form of Application) (Am.) Regs. ....................................................................277 S.I. 1999/1758 Protection from Eviction Act (Excluded Licences) (etc.) O. ...........................................................311 S.I. 1999/1803 Assured and Protected Tenancies (Letting to Students) (Am.) Regs. .............................................168 S.I. 1999/2083 Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regs. 1999. ...................................................198, 258, 638, 648 S.I. 1999/2268 Assured and Protected Tenancies (Lettings to Students)(Am.) (No.2) (England) Regs. ..............168 S.I. 1999/2360 Distress for Rent (Amendment) R. ...........................................................................................650–651 S.I. 1999/2403 Administration of the Rent Officer Service (England) O. 1999 .......................................................237 S.I. 1999/2564 Distress for Rent (Am.)(No.2) R. ..............................................................................................650–651 S.I. 1999/2766 Home Repairs Assistance (Extension) (England) Regs. ..................................................................277 S.I. 1999/3028 Housing (Right to Acquire) (Discount)(Am.) O. ....................................................................494, 498 S.I. 1999/3057 Housing Accommodation (Persons Subject to Immigration Control)(Am.)(England) O. ............92 S.I. 1999/3084 Home Repairs Assistance (Extension) (Wales) Regs. .......................................................................277 S.I. 1999/3126 Homelessness (Asylum–Seekers)(Interim Period) (England) O. ......................................................99 S.I. 1999/3462 L.R. (No.3) R. .............................................................................................................................384, 385 S.I. 2000/1 R.O. (Housing Benefit Functions) (Am.) O. ...........................................................................................238 S.I. 2000/424 Council Tax (Exempt Dwellings)(Am.) (E.)O. ..................................................................................215 S.I. 2000/701 Homelessness Regs .....................................................................................................................69, 90–97 S.I. 2000/702 Allocation of Housing (England) Regs. ..................................................................66, 71–74, 86, 92–96 S.I. 2000/706 Persons Subject to Immigration Control (Housing Authority Accommodation and Homelessness) O. ...........................................................................................................................................92 S.I. 2000/1071 Access to Justice 1999 (Destination of Appeals) Order 2000 ...........................................................238 S.I. 2000/1079 Homelessness (Wales) Regs..........................................................................................69, 90, 92–95, 97 S.I. 2000/1984 A.H. (Units of Production)(England) O. .........................................................................................621
1 RENTING Housing tenure. Long and short leases. Full private sector security: controlled tenancies. Rent Act tenancies. Assured tenancies. Limited private sector security, Shortholds, Private landlords. Public housing, Public landlords. The social sector. Residential accommodation.
A. HOUSING TENURE Three out of every ten dwellings are rented: of the 24 million dwellings in England and Wales in the year 2000 there are 17 million owner-occupiers, a term embracing both freeholders and long leaseholders, but this still leaves 7 million or so rented properties. Ireland and Spain have a substantially higher proportion of owners, but there are proportionately more tenants in other parts of Europe such as France and Germany. This is particularly true of the private rented sector.1 Ownership in England and Wales has increased, from 10 per cent at the end of the First World War to 70 per cent at the end of the twentieth century, leaving the rented sector still accounting for 30 per cent of homes. A residue of households will never buy, either because they do not wish for the commitment involved or because they will be never be able to afford to buy—the pool of potential renters is estimated at 30 per cent of the total of households. If this is a fair guess, it seems to suggest that there is currently an equilibrium between owners and renters. Renting is divided between three sectors, according to the type of landlord making the accommodation available. Legislative controls developed first for the private sector (1915), were extended successively as a replacement for council tenancies in the public sector (1980) and to registered social landlords (present scheme 1996). Until the First World War 90 per cent of homes were rented from private landlords, but the proportion of property rented in this way declined markedly throughout the twentieth century.2 Local authorities held a negligible role before that War (less than 1 per cent) but the promise to those returning from the trenches of the Western Front that they would have “homes fit for heroes” was largely met by public sector provision, the dominant position of councils being reinforced by the building programme before and after the Second World War. Public tenure is concentrated, predictably enough, in the urban areas of London, Yorkshire, Manchester and Merseyside, the West Midlands, the 1
Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All; The Housing Green Paper (D.E.T.R., April 2000) para.5.2. Bright & Gilbert chs.1–2; Davey 189–205; D. Englander, Landlord & Tenant in Urban Britain 1838–1918 (Clarendon, 1983); J. Burnett, A Social History of Housing (Methuen, 2nd ed. 1985). 2
2
1. RENTING
North East and South Wales. A period of public sector provision of new homes drew to a close in 1980 as the catastrophic social effects of 1960s estates and tower blocks became apparent and as a result of the Government’s economic policies. Enactment of the right to buy in 1980 resulted in the removal of 1.5 million of the best homes from the public sector during the last 20 years of the twentieth century. Housing associations were first formed in the 1860s, but they had a small role in the English housing market until 1980 or so, when the government decided to stimulate the social sector in a deliberate attempt to curtail local authority power by reducing the role of councils as the providers of public housing. Between 1991 and 1996 the social sector grew by 65 per cent. Housing associations still predominate, but legislation in 1996 allowed grants for the provision of social housing to be made to other corporate landlords, so that the social sector now consists of lettings by registered social landlords. Figure 1 Table of housing tenure3 Housing stock tenure % of landlords by category
Owner-occupiers Public Social Private rented
1914
1957
1971
1981
1991
1996
10 0.2
31 17
52 29
90
52
19
58 28 2 11
68 19 3 10
69 17 5 9
This table conceals the scandalous fact that almost 4% of all homes lie empty.4 B. SHORT AND LONG LEASES Residential leases are either long or short. The basic characteristic of the short residential sector is that the tenant is renting, usually paying the full value of the land monthly or weekly, and the landlord is an investor exploiting a house that he does not require for his own occupation to realise its market letting value. The parties to such an arrangement are called in this book the landlord and the tenant and their agreement is described as a tenancy. Long residential leases are totally distinct in function, since the lease is a form of ownership much more akin to a freehold than to renting; the “tenant” pays a substantial capital sum to buy the lease and only a minimal rent (a “ground rent”) to retain his ownership. Indeed, this form of tenure is under attack and is gradually being converted to freehold ownership through statutory rights of enfranchisement and the introduction of commonhold tenure, though the process may take centuries to complete. In this book 3 4
English House Condition Survey (D.E.T.R., 1996) ch.1. para 1.13.
FULL PRIVATE SECTOR SECURITY
3
the parties to such an arrangement (called a lease) are referred to as the ground landlord and the leaseholder. This is intended to differentiate them from a tenant who is renting from a landlord. The two sectors are formally distinguished by the length of the initial contractual grant; a long lease is one for a term exceeding 21 years or for life; the precise definition is considered in later chapters of this book.5 C. FULL PRIVATE SECTOR SECURITY Security of tenure implies protection against contractual termination of an existing tenancy. The landlord must serve notice to quit, take court proceedings and prove a ground for possession.6 Full security implies that a tenant who pays the rent punctually and otherwise behaves himself will usually be entitled to stay indefinitely. 1. Control and decontrol In order to curb the tendency towards inflation during war-time, rent controls were introduced as an emergency measure by the first “Rent Act”—the Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (War Restrictions) Act 1915. Peacetime saw the development of rent controls twinned with security of tenure—the now familiar statutory tenancy was devised by the Increase of Rent and Mortgage Interest (Restrictions) Act 1920. Controls were reduced successively in 1923 and 1933, but a new system of control was extended to most unfurnished lettings in 1938. In the period after the Second World War, Labour governments saw the retention or strengthening of control, while decontrol took place during Conservative governments, notably in 1957. No new controlled tenancies were allowed after 1965 when the more modern system of regulated Rent Act tenancies was introduced. Controls were bitterly opposed by landlords because the rent, set as a multiplier of the Rateable Value of the property, was very restrictive, and to their collective delight controlled tenancies were finally abolished in 1980.7 These pre-modern Rent Acts bequeathed to us the basic structure of the modern residential tenancy legislation—including the restriction to self-contained residential accommodation and the concept of the statutory tenancy to step in when the landlord terminates the contractual arrangement—as well as much of the basic case law. These old Rent Acts presided over a period in which the proportion of homes rented from private landlords declined from 90 per cent to 30 per cent. It would not be fair to conclude from that statistic alone that the legislation was misconceived, since the main operative factors were the rise of owner-occupation and the provision of superior council accommodation. However, what the rent restriction legislation did was to reduce the economic return to the landlord to such an extent that it ceased to be worthwhile to make property available to rent. 2. Rent Act tenancies The modern scheme of regulated tenancies based on fair rents was introduced by the Rent Act 1965, the subsequent legislative history including a consolidation in 1968, the 5 6 7
See below Chapters 14 and 15. See below Chapter 13. H.A. 1980 s.64. The terms of converted controlled tenancies are regulated by R.A. 1977 s.18A, sch.17.
4
1. RENTING
inclusion of furnished tenancies balanced by the exemption of resident landlord tenancies in 1974, and the present consolidation in 1977. The Crown Estate and Duchies were moved into control in 1980.8 A Rent Act tenancy is one granted by a private sector landlord before early 19899 and operating as a protected tenancy under the Rent Act 1977.10 During the contractual period it is called a regulated tenancy; after termination of contractual protection it becomes a statutory tenancy; both classes together are described as protected tenancies. In this book the description “Rent Act tenancy” is used. A protected tenant enjoys “lifelong” security of tenure and succession rights. Most Rent Act tenants are now elderly, because new protected tenancies are not permitted after the Housing Act 1988.11 The shift to assured tenancy in early 1989 made little difference to the security of tenure available, but it had a fundamental impact on the rent regime: a Rent Act tenant can insist on registration of a fair rent, a procedure which imposes a cap on the recoverable rent. At first, market rents under the new assured system were dramatically higher, but Rent Act fair rents have gradually increased since early 1989 so that the gap has narrowed.12 “Full” security of tenure under the two schemes was broadly comparable, though there is an increasing likelihood that a grant will only be for a short hold.13 Succession rights sometimes allow a surviving spouse or other family member to take over the tenancy on the death of the previous tenant. Two schemes apply, according to the date on which the tenancy was granted, with the tenant’s rights being reduced in early 1989.14 3. Fully assured tenancies Given the century long game of tug of war played out between the two main political parties over housing policy, it is a remarkable fact that there is no longer any significant difference in the housing policy of the two potential parties of government. The fundamental tenets are straightforward. Private sector tenancies are short-term rental arrangements (shortholds) with no security of tenure beyond that agreed contractually between the parties. Rents are fixed by the market, the only intervention with free market economics being to prevent excessive claims to housing benefit. However, when this Thatcherite settlement was reached by the Housing Act 198815 it was on the basis that pre-existing security would remain unaffected. Hence the vital significance of the watershed when that Act came into force on January 15th 1989—throughout this book referred to as “early 1989”. Only if a fresh contractual grant was made after that date will
8
H.A. 1980 s.73, sch.8, as from November 28th 1980. See below p. 4 n. 14–p. 5 n. 17. 10 Woodfall ch.23; Davey 249–286; Evans & Smith (5th) ch.17; Garner (2nd) ch.13. 11 H.A. 1988 s.35; Woodfall 24.080–24.087. 12 See below pp. 227–234. 13 See below Chapter 3. 14 H.A. 1988 s.141(3); see below at pp. 115–123. 15 H.A. 1988 ss.1(1), 34, sch.1 para.1; D. Hoath [1989] J.S.W.L. 339; [1990] J.S.W.L. 18; M. Davey (1989) 52 M.L.R. 6611; C.P. Rodgers [1988] Conv. 122; W. Hickman [1993] N.L.J. 1271. 9
LIMITED PRIVATE SECTOR SECURITY
5
a tenant fall, reluctantly, into the assured tenancy16 regime;17 he is then subject to a market rent regime. If it is fully assured (as opposed to a shorthold), the tenant will enjoy “lifelong” security of tenure, broadly comparable to that under the Rent Acts, though succession rights are markedly inferior for post-1989 tenancies.18 4. Successor tenancies Human rights principles prevent retrospective interference with property rights, so that new legislative schemes have left existing tenants to enjoy their existing security rights.19 If tenancy 1 was Rent Act protected, so are replacement tenancies 2, 3 and 4,20 so that contractual renewals do not affect security regimes provided that they all involve the same landlord, the same tenant and the same property.21 It is necessary to trace the tenancy back to the date of the original grant in order to discover which security of tenure regime applies. A break in the chain is possible if the tenant gives up his tenancy to his landlord by agreement (in technical terms a surrender of the existing tenancy) where this is followed by a regrant of a new tenancy. In this way a Rent Act tenancy could be replaced by an assured tenancy either a fully assured or an assured shorthold. Tenants are protected against harassment and threats used to secure an agreement to give up a tenancy,22 but only fraud can invalidate a completed transaction by which a tenant has signed away his right to full security. Failure to give a warning is not fraud. Figures suggest a decline in Rent Act protected tenancies from 1 million in 1988 to just over 300,000 in 1994–5, with a 40 per cent drop in the first year alone.23 So it is clear that many tenants did indeed surrender existing security rights. D. LIMITED PRIVATE SECTOR SECURITY 1. Shortholds The long period of Conservative government between 1979 and 1997 saw a progressive reduction in security of residential tenure, so that it is now abnormal for a tenant in the private sector to enjoy life-long security.24 In 1980 it became possible to limit the security of a private sector tenant to a fixed contractual period of one year—a form of tenancy called a protected shorthold—and this became increasingly popular in the years from 1980 to early 1989.25 At that date, a new scheme of assured shortholds was 16 An old model of assured tenancies introduced in 1980 for purpose built properties or purpose built conversions by approved landlords. Very few were created, and any that were have been converted to assured tenancies of the new model: H.A. 1988 ss.1(3), 37. 17 Woodfall ch.24; Bright & Gilbert 233–257; Davey 206–248; Evans & Smith (5th) ch.18; Garner (2nd) ch.18. 18 H.A. 1988 s.141(3). 19 J. Driscoll [1991] 36 L.S.G. 17. 20 Thalmann v. Evans [1996] 2 C.L.Y. 3788. 21 H.A. 1988 s.34(1)(b) (grants after early 1989 to existing Rent Act tenants); s.34(1)(c) (where alternative accommodation ordered by court). The categories are exclusive: sch.1 para.13. 22 See below Chapter 12. 23 J. Driscoll [1996] N.L.J. 1699, 1700, citing Green, Thomas, Iles and Dawn, Housing in England 1994/95 (H.M.S.O., 1996). 24 J. Morgan [1996] J.S.W.F.L. 445. 25 See below Chapter 3.
6
1. RENTING
introduced. These confer security for a short fixed period of at least six months but no long-term security. As from early 1997 a landlord has to elect positively to create anything other than a shorthold by giving notice.26 It is unlikely that a private sector landlord will do so. Security is limited to any contractually agreed term of occupation, with a minimum of six months, and rents are charged at market rents. 2. Limited residential security Full security follows only when a tenant has exclusive rights to self-contained accommodation. Without that occupiers have strictly limited security of tenure, including people sharing accommodation, and people whose accommodation is serviced or supported by nursing and welfare staff: these are licensees like hotel guests or residents in hostels. Some tenants also have limited rights including students in halls of resident or people renting holiday accommodation. So too do occupiers of caravans, houseboats and shacks that do not form a part of a building.27 E. PRIVATE LANDLORDS The assured tenancy scheme introduced in early 1989 is based on limited private sector security and market rents. Has it been a success? It is submitted that it can be given only qualified approval. Clearly one basic objective was to make renting more attractive to private landlords, and in that it has indubitably succeeded. The fair rent regime and long term security of the Rent Acts severely depressed the capital value of rented properties and so acted as a disincentive to invest in houses to rent. After all, a landlord sees any tenanted property primarily as a source of income, and if the returns are improved then more will choose to make property available for letting. For one thing the assured tenancy regime has stimulated the creation of a flourishing sub-sector for lettings of premium quality accommodation. For another it seems to have encouraged investors to come into the normal letting market. When the Rent Act 1977 gave way to the Housing Act 1988, one survey28 found that the majority (63 per cent) of private landlords were individuals not resident themselves at the property they were renting out, one tenth were property companies (9 per cent), a small percentage were individuals who were letting out part of their own house (though other surveys give much higher percentages), and 21 per cent were employers. A similar survey today would find a much larger group of commercial and institutional investors. Their presence is essential to revitalise the market and establish a healthy market in the long term,29 and for this reason the new Labour Government is committed to the retention of the assured tenancy regime it inherited from the Conservatives, aiming to improve the incentives for institutional investment.30 During 26
H.A. 1988 s.19A, sch.2A. See below Chapter 6. 28 Rauta & Pickering, Private Renting in England 1990 (H.M.S.O., 1992). 29 According to the Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) para.5.9, roughly half of landlords own seven houses or less and a quarter have only one; many people become landlords by inheritance or other accident. 30 The Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) paras.5.18–5.22. 27
PUBLIC LANDLORDS
7
the early 1990s Business Expansion Schemes provided an input of investment to the sector. Buying property to let suddenly became cool in the later 1990s, because when interest rates settled at an historically low level it became realistic to borrow money to buy a house which could then be let out at a rent that exceeded the instalments needed to repay the mortgage. The Association of Residential Letting Agents scheme launched in 1996 identified a panel of lenders prepared to lend on the same terms to landlords as to owner-occupiers and the number of lenders prepared to lend on these terms has increased considerably since then. There is a government sponsored arbitration scheme to resolve disputes between landlords and their letting agents.31 It is said that in 1999, the average gross yield (that is the aggregate rents) was 8–9 per cent of the cost of the house, even in a static rental market, with a net yield 2 per cent lower. Clearly the returns fluctuate from time to time. Rental yields might be 1.3 times the monthly mortgage instalments. From this margin has to be deducted income tax and capital gains tax, and the cost of maintenance to the standard that is required by the market. Letting agents reduce the risks by conducting credit checks on tenants, dealing with maintenance, and keeping close control of void periods when the property is not let. The fee for these services is typically 10–15 per cent of the gross rent. Buying to let is a dangerous short-term investment, but in the medium term a landlord who has chosen a property wisely may expect to see the property increase in value along with the general inflation in house prices. Any increase will be subject to capital gains tax when it is realised. For a short time in 1999 it seems that tenants were in the driver’s seat, since the influx of property on to the market through buy to let schemes had created an excess of supply, especially as many potential tenants took advantage of the low interest rates to buy. However, booming house prices throughout 1999–2000 seem likely to lead to a further distortion to the market, since the returns from renting will be much reduced if the capital value of the property increases, and it will be easy to evict insecure shorthold tenants in order to sell. In short the market rent regime has bonded the private rental sector even more tightly to fluctuations in the housing market. It provides high quality flats at high rents, but is not a sustainable way to provide affordable housing to those who are unable to buy. The assured tenancy regime may prove to be only a short-term fix for the problems of the private rented sector. The Government is considering whether tax changes could stimulate the private rented sector further.32 F. PUBLIC LANDLORDS 1. Public provision The Housing of the Working Classes Act 1890 gave power to local authorities to build houses for renting, but in the absence of financial assistance from the government few had been built by the outbreak of the First World War in 1914: there were only 28,000 public homes. Large-scale building occurred between the Wars (900,000) with a further 31 32
National Approved Letting Scheme launched by the Minister, Hilary Armstrong, in January 1999. The Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) paras.5.23–5.25.
8
1. RENTING
massive expansion after the Second World War. In 1979 some 32 per cent of all English33 homes were in local authority ownership. Unfortunately many of these were on shoddy estates or in system built blocks of flats. Large estates have failed as basic units of social organisation. It has become apparent that much cheap housing had been thrown up without consideration of its habitability, and many estates have had to be knocked down; Glasgow is just one authority straining under the debts incurred in building homes which are no longer standing. Local authority ownership declined through the period of Conservative government which stretched from Mrs Thatcher’s rise to power in 1979 to 1997. Partly this was the result of restrictions on capital spending which limited new building. Problems were exacerbated by the fact that the “Right to Buy”34— however valuable to those tenants who have acquired their homes under it—has stripped the public sector of all its desirable homes since 1980, leaving behind properties that are unsaleable and unlettable. The Housing Green Paper gives us a snapshot of the position in early 2000.35 Of those living in social housing (including tenants of public sector council landlords) it shows that only 23 per cent are in full time employment, the majority being retired (38 per cent), unemployed (8 per cent) or otherwise economically inactive.36 One million fewer people now live in social housing than in 1977 as a result of the depletion of the stock by the right to buy.37 So it has now become a tenure of last resort.38 2. Secure tenancies and the “landlord condition” Until recently local authorities had enormous power by virtue of their position as monopoly providers of low cost housing, which was free of any judicial intervention, for example in the removal of tenants. This supreme power has been broken: controls have been introduced over the initial allocation of public housing,39 and administrative law has been developed to allow judicial review of almost any step taken by a housing authority. However termination of a lease or a licence40 is a private law decision not susceptible to public law control. Private and public sectors are distinguished by the landlord condition,41 which apportions grants of rented accommodation between two discrete sectors. Within it, public sector landlords grant secure tenancies under the Housing Act 1985 that confer “life-long” security of tenure, whilst outside it lie private landlords who grant assured shorthold tenancies and social landlords.42 This provision of security of tenure has caused a marked shift in power towards tenants. 33
Scotland has a much higher proportion of public housing: H.W. Wilkinson [1980] Conv. 302. See below Chapter 18. 35 Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All; The Housing Green Paper (D.E.T.R., April 2000) paras.6.1–6.11. 36 para.6.2. 37 para.6.5. 38 para.6.12 39 See below Chapter 4. 40 Tower Hamlets L.B.C. v. Abdi (1992) 25 H.L.R. 80 C.A.; R. v. Westminster C.C. ex parte Parkins (1995) 68 P. & C.R. 253 C.A. 41 ss.80, 114; Woodfall ch.25; Bright & Gilbert 257–269; Davey 307–333; Evans & Smith (5th) ch.19; Garner (2nd) ch.19. 42 R.A. 1977 s.14; H.A. 1988 sch.1 para.12. 34
PUBLIC LANDLORDS
9
Legislation in 198043 first created the concept of the secure tenancy, which applied to all new grants by public sector landlords and also tenancies which existed when the legislation was introduced,44 though excluding any tenancy that had been terminated contractually on the commencement date of the new legislation.45 Clearly it was felt that the courts provided the proper forum for decisions about the loss of housing.46 The current consolidation of the secure tenancy scheme is in part IV of the Housing Act 1985.47 Most housing authorities are district councils or London borough councils.48 They have a general oversight of housing standards and power to take action against unfit, overcrowded, and substandard housing. They also have powers to build new housing stock49—widely and unwisely exercised in the past, but rarely exercised at all today because capital spending restrictions make it difficult for authorities to find the funds for building. However, the primary focus of this book is on the role of authorities as providers and allocators of housing.50 Authorities select their own tenants, granting secure tenancies from their own housing stock, and they also nominate tenants to social landlords. If a grant is originally in the private sector, it will switch to become a public sector secure tenancy if events occur which mean that the immediate landlord fulfils the landlord condition, for example where a private landlord is himself a tenant and he surrenders his lease to a local authority as the head landlord.51 Three special solutions to particular housing problems also fall within the public sector as defined by the landlord condition. New Town Corporations are set up to build such communities as Milton Keynes and remain large-scale owners of public housing provision.52 Urban development corporations control areas of towns and cities designated for large-scale urban renewal, current ones are in London Docklands, Merseyside, the Black Country, Teeside, Trafford Park, Manchester, Tyne & Wear, Sheffield, Cardiff Bay, Birmingham Heartlands and Plymouth.53 Housing Action Trusts (H.A.T.s) are established by ministerial order54 to take over ownership of the public housing stock55 and the role of public sector landlords in run down areas56—the object being to secure the repair and management of the housing stock, and the improvement of living conditions of the tenants;57 planning, public health, and highway functions are often 43
H.A. 1980 part I ch.2. Kingston on Thames L.B.C. v. Prince (1999) 31 H.L.R. 794 C.A. (letting in 1979 became secure in 1980). 45 Harrison v. Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. [1981] 1 W.L.R. 650; P.H. Kenny [1981] Conv. 89. 46 At 666, Waller J. 47 Law Com. No.144 (1985) (consolidation); Woodfall ch.25. 48 H.A. 1985 s.1. 49 s.9. The council may build houses out of its own district, though overspill from London requires ministerial approval: s.16. 50 A further separation of the authorities’ wider strategic role and their role as public sector landlords is proposed by the Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) paras.3.1–3.6. It envisages the creation of management companies operating at arm’s length from the local authority with power to borrow, more borrowing by local authorities, and the continuation of the private funding initiative. 51 s.109A; Basingstoke & Deane B.C. v. Paice (1995) 27 H.L.R. 433 C.A. 52 New Towns Acts 1946, 1959, 1981. 53 Local Government, Planning & Land Act 1980 pt.XVI. 54 H.A. 1988 part III ss.63–86. 55 ss.74–79. 56 The local authority itself controls housing action areas, general improvement areas, slum clearance areas (H.A. 1985 parts VIII–IX) and renewal areas (L.G.H.A. 1989 part VII). 57 H.A. 1988 s.63. 44
10
1. RENTING
transferred to the H.A.T.58 They have not proved to be popular. Tenants of housing cooperatives will fall back into the public sector if the landlord ceases to be registered as a social landlord.59 3. Right to buy Public sector tenants have the right to buy their homes at a discount. The right was first given in 1980, and now appears in the 1985 consolidation of the housing legislation.60 The right to buy has proved a great boon to tenants living in desirable housing who are both qualified and able to afford to buy: more than 1.6 million homes were sold at knockdown prices, raising £7 billion for the Treasury.61 However, its tendency has been to concentrate single parents and the poor in residual unsaleable accommodation,62 and local authorities have not benefited from the capital raised. 4. Introductory tenancy The Housing Act 1996 made a number of changes of detail to the public sector scheme, and one that is more fundamental. Local authorities may choose to adopt the introductory tenancy scheme for their area, and if they do so new tenants are effectively put on probation for one year. During that time the local authority may decide the tenant is unsuitable and if it does the court is bound to order his eviction, though there are administrative procedures to challenge such a decision.63 G. SOCIAL SECTOR Registered social landlords currently control property assets worth £22 billion and have 1.3 million tenants.64 They will never be able to take over all responsibility for the provision of cheap housing, but their role is ever increasing. Public grants are provided for new building and conversion of existing housing, but the Government also envisages large-scale transfers of derelict estates to the social sector. 1. Housing associations These are the most common form of social landlord. Some associations were formed in the mid nineteenth century, but their collective significance as a sub-sector of the letting market developed when housing association rents were controlled in 1972 and statutory definition soon followed.65 A few large professionally organised housing associations (8 per cent) control large numbers of properties (75 per cent), but there are innumerable small associations with fewer than 25 units. 58
ss.66–69. H.A. 1985 s.80(1), (3), (4). 60 See below Chapter 18; tenants of registered social landlords may have a right of acquisition. 61 The Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) paras.4.34–4.36, gives the figure of 1.3 million sales in England and Wales; it says that the cost to the state was roughly £10,000 for each property. 62 The pace of sales has slackened now that most of the desirable homes have gone. 63 H.A. 1985 ss.127–128; Manchester C.C. v. Cochrane (1999) 31 H.L.R. 810 C.A.; see below p. 319. 64 Regulating a Diverse Sector (Housing Corporation, October 1999) para. 2.2. 65 H. Finance A. 1972; H.A. 1974 s.1; Bright & Gilbert 40–47. 59
SOCIAL SECTOR
11
A housing association must be a corporate body or a body of trustees with the object of providing, constructing, improving or managing housing accommodation.66 It must not trade for profit, and registration as a social landlord will only be allowed to a body already registered as a charity.67 Many housing associations are fully mutual, so that membership is restricted to tenants, and any person wishing to become a tenant must first become a member of the association. Co-operative housing associations (a category including many self build societies) are also registered as industrial and provident societies.68 Registered social landlords are entitled to seek state assistance with the cost of providing housing. 2. Other social landlords Individuals are not eligible to receive social housing grants, but the Housing Act 199669 extends the social sector beyond housing associations and industrial and provident societies; now included for the first time are charitable corporations, so that they may qualify for social housing grants and this is intended to facilitate the provision of new build social housing. A problem currently exercising the Housing Corporation as regulator is how to ensure that activities do not become too diverse.70 The core functions of any registered social landlord should be provision of low-cost housing, including general needs housing, use of short life property for the homeless, the management of local authority housing stock, community regeneration, running residential care homes or social care services, or providing low cost home ownership. Other activities are accepted if they do not exceed 5 per cent, but beyond that threshold of diversity the Housing Corporation will wish to ensure a business strategy is in place to regulate additional functions. Regulations71 prescribe the activities that are permitted which include the provision of loans to people wishing to buy,72 and now also the provision of services and amenities to non-residents as well as residents.73 3. Registered social landlords Social landlords are registered by the Housing Corporation.74 In Wales, the corresponding function has been transferred from Housing for Wales to the housing “minister” of the Welsh Assembly.75 Registration is a necessary precursor to applications for 66
H. Associations A. 1985 ss.1, 2; H.A. 1996 s.230; J. Driscoll (1996) 140 S.J. 1224; J. Alder (1997) 1 J.H.L. 35. H.A. 1996 s.2(1)(a). 68 Industrial and Provident Societies Act 1965; J. Alder [1988] Conv. 187, 254. This is no longer essential; H.A. 1996 s.57. 69 ss.2(1)(b)–(c), 57; conditions are set out in s.2(2)–(3). 70 Regulating a Diverse Sector (Housing Corporation, October 1999). 71 H.A. 1996 s.2(4); S.Is. 1996/592, 1996/2256; Halifax B.S. v. Chamberlain Martin Spurgeon (1995) 27 H.L.R. 123, Arden J. 72 S.I. 1999/985; C. Handy & J. Alder [1998] 1 J.H.L. 133; the S.I. reverses Sutton L.B.C. v. Morgan Grenfell & Co. Ltd. (1997) 29 H.L.R. 608 C.A. 73 S.I. 1999/1206. 74 H.A. 1996 ss.1–5, sch.1; this replaces H. Associations A. 1985 part II. See also R.A. 1977 ss.13–16, s.5A; H.A. 1988 sch. 1 paras.11–13. 75 Government of Wales Act 1998 s.143; S.I. 1999/61; H.A. 1988 s.46 (old law). 67
12
1. RENTING
social housing grant.76 Something like 50 per cent of the cost of social housing is provided by the Government. Funding is conditional upon some degree of public control over the housing stock provided with it and in particular the local authority has nomination rights over the allocation of 50 per cent of new tenants.77 Current rules prevent the payment of benefits and the provision of accommodation to board members, employees, and their relatives.78 However, it is arguable that the current rules are too strict, and consultation is under way on a possible relaxation to allow board members and relatives to be given homes—provided that they meet the letting criteria and do not participate in the allocation decision, and that no suitable alternative accommodation is available.79 The Housing Corporation has a general supervisory power over the constitution of registered social landlords, their accounts, audit procedures, and insolvency,80 as well as power to conduct special inquiries.81 There are disclosure requirements, league tables,82 controls, and ministerial guidance.83 4. Housing association tenancies (1974 to early 1989) Housing association tenants never enjoyed full Rent Act security of tenure,84 but the Housing Finance Act 1972 imposed fair rent controls.85 In 1980 this was supplemented by full public sector security of tenure, since housing associations were public landlords and their tenants became secure tenants. Tenancies remain secure if originally granted before 1989 even if there is a contractual regrant; such tenants also enjoy rights under the Secure Tenant’s Charter.86 In early 1989 future grants of housing association tenancies were prohibited87 at which time there were 1⁄2 million fair rent units held from 2,672 housing associations. Many have now been regranted in the social sector. 5. Grants by social landlords since early 1989 For the purposes of security of tenure, housing associations were shifted from the public to the private sector early in 1989.88 Fresh tenancies granted by social landlords after 1989 are assured, but with additional rights under the Assured Tenant’s Charter. This is because the “landlord condition”89—which defines the public sector—now excludes any tenancy held from a registered social landlord, though the fact that this condition is applied continuously makes it possible for a tenant to move back into the public sector when a co-operative housing association ceases to be registered, or otherwise into the purely private sector. The Housing Corporation dictates the tenure, the rents, and other 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89
H.A. 1996 ss.18–21, 27–28. See below p. 66. s.7 and sch.1 part I; ss.56–64 (definitions). Consultation Document (Housing Corporation, August 1999). H.A. 1996 ss.39–50. ss.3–6 and sch.1 parts II–IV. ss.30–35. ss.36–38, 52–55. R.A. 1977 s.15. Now R.A. 1977 part VI; Davey 195, 299–301. Housing Corporation, 1998. H.A. 1988 s.35; some successor tenancies are also secure. H.A. 1988 s.140(2) sch.18; Housing White Paper Cm 214 (1987) para.4.6. H.A. 1985 s.80 as amended by H.A. 1988 s.83 and S.I. 1996/2325.
RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL LEASES
13
rights of social tenants, and in particular insists that registered social landlords should grant tenancies with a full assurance, that is full security of tenure.90 Assured shortholds are acceptable in short life property only where a person is being assessed for suitability for a long-term grant91 and licences only for serviced accommodation where a private landlord could legitimately make such a grant. The theoretical market rent regime92 is moderated by the expectation that social landlords should charge “affordable” rents— roughly 20 per cent below market rents—so as to be accessible to people on low income including those in low paid employment,93 but with the rider that social landlords must balance costs. A voluntary ombudsman scheme (H.A.T.O.) to deal with complaints has now been made statutory.94 6. Large scale voluntary transfers Not even the homeless will live on some of the worst public sector estates. The best solution is often to transfer the estate out of the public sector to a housing association, possibly formed for the purpose, which is then encouraged to renovate the estate with social grants. New Labour is pressing authorities to accelerate the speed at which failing estates are hived off,95 and the rate of transfers is increasing.96 7. Right to acquire Removal of housing association tenancies from the public sector early in 1989 did not affect the right of existing tenants, who remain secure tenants and have the right to buy their homes.97 When homes are removed from the public sector under a voluntary stock transfer, rights to buy are preserved.98 There is also a right of acquisition conferred on a social tenant occupying a home newly built, bought or converted in or after April 1997.99 H. RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL LEASES 1. Commercial sectors Residential tenancies need to be distinguished from commercial leases, and the two subsectors—business and agricultural. A particular lease falls into one or other of these three groups.100 Although some businesses own freehold property from which they trade, it is the usual practice to lease premises for use as offices, shops, or for industrial 90
Housing Applicant’s Charter (Housing Corporation, 1998) Section 4. Code of Practice on Tenure (Housing Corporation, October 1999) para.4.1. 92 H.A. 1985 s.81(1) as amended by H.A. 1988 s.83. 93 Assured Tenant’s Charter (Housing Corporation, 1998) Section 3. 94 H.A. 1996 s.51, sch.2; also the Charters e.g. Assured Tenant’s Charter (Housing Corporation, 1998) Section 10; Grammer v. Lane [2000] 2 All E.R. 245 C.A. 95 Guardian, November 10th 1999. 96 R. Brown [1999] 06 L.G.C. Supp. 4–5. The Green Paper, Quality and Choice: A Decent Home for All (D.E.T.R., April 2000) paras.7.11–7.34, proposes improvements in the process and stamp duty relief, and sets a target of 200,000 transfers each year. 97 H.A. 1985 part V; Secure Tenant’s Charter (Housing Corporation, 1998) Section 8. 98 A preserved right to buy; Assured Tenant’s Charter (Housing Corporation, 1998) Section 8. 99 A right of acquisition: H.A. 1996 ss.16–17; Assured Tenant’s Charter (Housing Corporation, 1998) Section 8. 100 See below Chapters 20 and 22. 91
14
1. RENTING
uses. Business tenants have much less protection than is given to residential tenants, but the one important protection is the right to a renewal at the market rental when their lease expires. This ensures that landlords cannot exploit the value attached to trading from a particular business address, that is the goodwill built up by a business. Trevor Aldridge calls such a lease a “renewable business lease”101 and that terminology is adopted in this book. A lease of a shop is clearly commercial, but the chapters on business leases also include discussion102 of the problems that arise from mixed lettings: is a lease of a shop with a flat above residential or commercial? Also considered in that context are leases of domestic property used for commercial ends, such as a lease of an entire block of flats for commercial exploitation by the tenant by renting out single flats to individual tenants. Agricultural leases are distinct from residential. Leases of farms, grazing land, orchards and market gardens are clearly agricultural, but again there is an area of mixed letting where a house is let with a small paddock or orchard; these problems are discussed in the context of agricultural leases.103 There are also highly technical provisions about tied cottages let to former agricultural workers.104 2. Residential tenancies The residential category embraces shortholds, public sector secure tenancies, full security in the private sector, as well as arrangements with restricted security such as licences, the common characteristic being that the property is used as the tenant’s home. But if a lease is commercial in character, the tenant will be excluded from residential security; his lease will be a renewable business lease, an agricultural holding, or a farm business tenancy. There are many gaps, so that a particular tenancy may fall between all stools, and in the absence of security of tenure legislation the tenancy is left to terminate under common law principles. Thus if a householder rents a garage near his house in which to park a private car, the lease is neither residential nor commercial. There is no neat definition of the residential sector. One boundary is put in place by the requirement that the lease should affect a dwelling house.105 Another factor is the purpose of letting, since the property must be let as a dwelling,106 though residential protection may accrue where the use becomes residential with the authorisation of the landlord. In addition, there is the requirement that the tenant must maintain residential occupation.107 Dispute is particularly likely where a property is used for a mixed purpose that includes both residential and commercial elements, for example a lease of a shop and flat above, or a cottage set on farmland. Broadly, the schemes for residential and commercial letting are exclusive and in this book the allocation of mixed lettings is considered in the commercial context.108 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108
Leasehold Law (Oyez, 1989). See below pp. 549–551. See below Chapter 7. See below Chapter 7. R.A. 1977 s.1; H.A. 1985 s.112; H.A. 1988 s.1(1). R.A. 1977 s.1 etc, as above. R.A. 1977 s.2; H.A. 1985 s.81; H.A. 1988 s.1(1)(b); see below pp. 104–109. See below pp. 549–551.
RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL LEASES
15
3. Lettings of multiple units A lease of a block of flats or a terrace of houses is obviously commercial in character. It is not intended that the tenant should occupy them all as his home, but rather that he should exploit the property let to him by renting out individual units to residential subtenants. In general, therefore, a lease of property consisting of multiple dwellings does not attract residential security, but falls within the business lease scheme. Thus if a head landlord lets a whole block of flats, the tenant enjoys no security. When he begins to divide the block by sub-letting individual flats, then the residential security legislation may bite, since security is afforded to a tenant who rents an individual residential unit, though full protection for the sub-tenant will depend upon the division being authorised by the head lease.109 There could be no policy justification for protecting a lease of a group of houses or of a block of flats which does not form the tenant’s home but is a form of investment vehicle, and such a lease is commercial in character.110 Exclusion from the residential scheme is a result of the requirement that a residential lease must involve a lease of a separate dwelling. Thus the tenancy should be intended to provide one (and only one) unit of habitation.111 Identification of the unit should take place as at the date of the tenancy, so that a lease of a whole building divided into multiple units will not attract statutory protection, whereas a lease of one house that is later divided may do so.112
109
See below Chapter 11. See below pp. 549–551. 111 St Catherine’s College Cambridge v. Dorling [1980] 1 W.L.R. 66 C.A. (no protection for furnished house divided to provide separate accommodation for 5 undergraduates); Grosvenor (Mayfair) Estates v. Amberton [1983] 1 E.G.L.R. 96 C.A. (letting of 2 flats, one occupied by 3 licensees; not let as a single dwelling.) 112 Regalian Securities Ltd. v. Ramsden [1981] 1 W.L.R. 611, 614, Lord Russell. 110
2 CONTRACTUAL DURATION Fixed term tenancies. Periodic tenancies. Informal short-term tenancies. Longer formal tenancies. Proprietary status. Overriding interests. Surrender.
According to Lord Hoffmann, leases and other interests in land are four dimensional. This chapter explores the fourth dimension—time.1 A. FIXED TERM CONTRACTUAL SECURITY 1. Long leases and leases for life The short residential sector is demarcated by the short term of the initial grant. If it exceeds 21 years, a legal lease is registrable2 and a residential tenant may enjoy enfranchisement rights,3 whereas shorter tenancies fall into the various regimes for residential security of tenure. Any lease granted for life or determinable with life or until marriage is converted by statute into a 90-year term and hence falls into the long residential sector.4 2. Fixed terms Tenants are commonly given rights to their home for a fixed initial period—perhaps a month, six months, one academic year, or several years. During this time the tenant does not need to rely on security of tenure, since his right to retain occupation of the home is based on his contract with his landlord.5 Of course, the same holds good in reverse: a tenant is bound to pay rent for the duration of the contractually agreed term. English law is remarkable for the flexibility it allows in the creation of a lease. Provided only that a maximum duration is specified, the law imposes no limit on how long it may be. Or how short. The “term of years absolute” includes a “term for less than a year or for a . . . fraction of a year . . .”.6
1 2 3 4 5 6
Newlon H.T. v. Alsulaimen [1999] 1 A.C. 313, 317C, Lord Hoffmann. See below pp. 382–385. See below Chapter 15. L.P.A. 1925 s.149(6). Bright & Gilbert 122–126; Davey 17–21. L.P.A. 1925 s.205(1)(xxvii).
18
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
The fraction could be a few months, or weeks, a holiday letting for a week,7 or even a timeshare for one week each year,8 and why not a lease for one day to watch a Royal procession or a concert?9 3. The commencement date Short residential tenancies are usually worded to start on the day on which the tenant is to take occupation, though commercial leases commonly run from an earlier date.10 Residential codes of security will generally take as their basis of calculation the actual length of the tenant’s enjoyment of the land.11 4. Shortholds Many private sector tenancies created since early 1989 have been assured shortholds.12 Statutory protection is provided for a fixed period of six months from the date of the initial grant, a period which the landlord is not able to break during the good behaviour of the tenant. But this short period runs only once and it is not renewed by a contractual regrant. Additional security can be negotiated by an agreement to grant a fixed term exceeding the six months or by a renewal of an existing term. Until 1997 a landlord could only take advantage of the guaranteed right of repossession at the end of a shorthold if he granted an initial contractual term of at least six months, but this requirement is now removed for a section 19A shorthold13 so that under current law an assured shorthold can be for one month, or three months, or even weekly or monthly. For the first six months the contractual rights of the tenant are supplemented by his right to a short hold. Any fixed term security in the public sector has to be negotiated with the landlord—since there is no concept of a shorthold—but most tenancies in the public sector are periodic. 5. Certainty Legal status is reserved by section 1(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925 for leases creating a term of years absolute. The force of the word “absolute” is to require that the maximum duration of a tenancy (like any other lease) must be fixed in time. The end might be a fixed date or fixed by reference to an event which is certain in the sense that the latest date on which the event can take place is known when the lease is to take effect in possession. Thus: To T for 2 years; or To T until the next General Election. If statute provides for a General Election every five years, this last has a maximum term, though the tenancy may well not last for the full five years. However, any tenancy is 7
In this case the tenant will not have any additional security; see below pp. 167–168. Cottage Holiday Associates v. Customs & Excise Commissioners [1983] Q.B. 735; M. Haley (1995) 24 AngloAmerican 236. 9 Licences have generally been used: Krell v. Henry [1903] 2 Q.B. 740 C.A. 10 See below pp. 517–518. 11 Roberts v. Church Commissioners for England [1972] 1 Q.B. 278 C.A. (enfranchisement tests). 12 For details see below Chapter 3. 13 H.A. 1988 s.19A, inserted by H.A. 1996 s.96; see below pp. 45–46. 8
TERMINATION OF FIXED CONTRACTUAL SECURITY
19
invalid if the term is not marked out with certainty. Both prospective and retrospective certainty may create problems. The former is the greater vice. It must be clear in advance when a lease is granted how long the lease is to last, so that English law does not accept a grant for undefined periods of time, such as: To T until England achieves world domination at football; or (more likely in practice) To T (a builder) until he has been paid for renovation work.14 Lace v. Chantler concerned a tenancy “furnished for duration”—that is for the duration of the Second World War—which was held to be uncertain and void.15 When it was granted, say in 1940, no one could know for how many years the war would last. The House of Lords has now unanimously approved this same test in Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body, in which a lease to continue until land was required for widening Walworth Road in South London was held to be uncertain and void.16 The rule is discussed at length in the commercial context.17 B. TERMINATION OF FIXED CONTRACTUAL SECURITY A valid fixed term tenancy is created if the maximum duration of the lease is stated and, provided that this is so, legal status is not removed simply because the term may be cut short. A term of years is absolute despite being: “liable to determination by notice, re-entry, operation of law, or by a provision for cesser on redemption, or in any other event (other than the dropping of a life or the determination of a determinable life interest) . . .”.18
Few leases are so “certain” that the term is fixed rigidly in advance, and almost all residential tenancies allow early termination in stated circumstances. 1. Break clauses Landlords may reserve the right to terminate a fixed contractual term by notice, but such provisions are rare and of limited value in residential tenancies, since a break merely brings into play the tenant’s security of tenure. However, there may be a value in allowing a break where the landlord will have a ground for possession, for example if he intends to reconstruct a property let on an assured tenancy.19 Most modern residential tenancies are assured shortholds, with a guaranteed holding for six months, and a break would not be allowed within the first six months. There is more sense in allowing a tenant to break a long fixed term, especially one who has no right to transfer his tenancy, since he could then end his liability to rent by notice, and the landlord could relet. Break 14 Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Bello (1991) 24 H.L.R. 155 C.A. (holding this term to be valid) was overruled in Prudential Assurance below. 15 [1944] K.B. 368 C.A.; (1944) 60 L.Q.R. 219. 16 [1992] 2 A.C. 386 H.L.; P. Sparkes (1993) 109 L.Q.R. 93; P.F. Smith [1993] Conv. 461; S. Bridge [1993] C.L.J. 26; S. Bright (1993) 13 L.S. 38; D. Wilde (1994) 57 M.L.R. 117; M. Biles [1994] N.L.J. 156; M. Haley (1995) 24 AngloAmerican 236. 17 See below pp. 512–517. 18 L.P.A. 1925 s.205(1)(xxvii). For leases for life see below pp. 363–365. 19 See below p. 351.
20
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
clauses are much more common in commercial leases and are considered in that context.20 2. Termination for misconduct by the tenant Where a tenant is given a contractual grant for a fixed period it is important to include a provision that the tenancy can be ended if the terms of the agreement are not observed—this will certainly include non-payment of rent and service charge, annoyance of neighbours, failure to observe restrictions on use, and unauthorised sub-letting and dealings. It is also common to provide for the landlord to be able to recover possession on the tenant’s bankruptcy—and this seems to be effective as a termination event despite the inconvenient effects on the residential bankruptcy code.21 Hostile termination of a commercial fixed term lease requires a forfeiture,22 but with a residential tenancy forfeiture is rarely a useful description of the act of terminating a lease for breach of a covenant, and is often positively inaccurate. A distinction has to be drawn between Rent Act tenancies and assured tenancies. A fixed term Rent Act tenancy must contain a provision for it to be ended on breach of the particular covenant—so a contractual termination event is essential. Termination can occur by proceedings,23 in the course of which a ground for possession is proved and a reason is shown why the court should exercise its discretion to order possession. Contrast the process of forfeiture under which the landlord shows a breach of a forfeiture clause, obtains an order for possession, and the court then has a discretionary power to grant relief to the tenant. So with the Rent Acts, the procedure is essential for residential repossession, but this may be laid over an underlying forfeiture, so that in some circumstances a tenant may have two defences to a repossession: he may be able to claim a stay of forfeiture proceedings or (if he loses that) have the right to stay in his home under a suspended possession order because it is not reasonable to make an outright order.24 During a fixed term of an assured tenancy, termination can only occur if the lease provides for termination on the particular event,25 but if so the procedure followed is that for residential repossession, and it is not a forfeiture.26 Special provision is made for the forfeiture in the public sector of a fixed term secure tenancy: an order for forfeiture becomes an order for termination which brings to an end the fixed term and gives rise to a periodic tenancy;27 the landlord would then have to prove a ground of possession. These more modern schemes described in this paragraph are more satisfactory than what went before.
20
See below pp. 582–583. Halliard Property Co. Ltd. v. Jack Segal Ltd. [1978] 1 W.L.R. 377; Paterson v. Aggio [1987] 2 E.G.L.R. 127 C.A.; Cadogan Estates Ltd. v. McMahon [1999] 1 W.L.R. 1689 C.A. [2000] Times 1 November H.L. 22 See below pp. 113–115 23 P.E.A. 1977 s.2. 24 See below pp. 330–331, 815–829. 25 H.A. 1988 s.5(1); termination must be by court order: s.5(2). No periodic tenancy arises if the tenant has some other contractual right, such as an option for renewal: s.5(4). 26 Artesian Residential Developments Ltd. v. Beck [1999] 3 All E.R. 113 C.A. 27 H.A. 1985 s.82(3). 21
PERIODIC TENANCIES
21
3. Effluxion of time and holding over If a tenancy of a home is not cut short and so continues until the period of years reserved by the lease has run out, it ends by effluxion of time,28 but this will merely trigger the statutory security of tenure.29 C. PERIODIC TENANCIES 1. Express creation Many residential leases are periodic tenancies. The term of years absolute is defined30 so that it “includes a term . . . from year to year”. A yearly tenancy is initially granted for one year, but on the basis that the tenancy can continue to grow by one year at a time, indefinitely,31 subject always to the possibility that it can be brought to an end by a proper notice. Older authorities took one year as the archetypal period, no doubt because that was normal for agricultural tenancies, but monthly or weekly tenancies are usual in the residential sector and any longer or shorter period could be used. Negotiation might lead to an expressly created period of a calendar month or periods of 28 or 30 days, or indeed some random time such as 47 days. If the period is stated expressly it is not relevant to consider how the rent is calculated. Oral creation of the tenancy is allowed provided the initial period of the lease is for less than three years.32 It is also common to combine a fixed contractual period with a periodic successor so that, for example, a tenancy for a year and so on from year to year is for a minimum duration of two years—the one year of the fixed term followed by the first year of an annual tenancy. 2. Implied creation Periodic tenancies are most often implied from the fact that rent is paid and accepted while a tenant is allowed possession of land to the exclusion of the landlord without any other arrangement. While the holding is against the wishes of the landlord, the tenancy is at sufferance—that is it is a tolerated trespass—but acceptance of the tenant by the landlord converts the tenancy to one at will. According to Littleton:33 “Tenant at will is where lands or tenements are let by one man to another, to have to hold to him at the will of the lessor, by force of which lease the lessee is in possession . . . the lessee is called a tenant at will because he hath no certain or sure estate, for the lessor may put him out at what time it pleaseth him.”
28
Woodfall 17.002–17.007; Newlon H.T. v. Alsulaimen [1999] 1 A.C. 313, 317E, Lord Hoffmann. See below pp. 109–113. 30 L.P.A. 1925 s.205(1)(xxvii); Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v. Monk [1992] 1 A.C. 478, 483–484, Lord Bridge. 31 Hence the odd rule that a yearly tenant can create a sub-lease for 99 years: Pennell v. Payne [1995] Q.B. 192 C.A.; query whether this is logical, given that the tenancy is only for a single year when looked at prospectively. 32 L.P.A. 1925 s.54(2); longer periods call for a deed; see below pp. 33–34. 33 Littleton, Tenures, book I, ch. VIII. 29
22
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
Without a contractually agreed term, the tenant is always vulnerable, as indeed the name of the tenancy at will suggests, to a change in the whim of the landlord. It seems that a tenancy at will may enjoy residential protection from eviction.34 Even if tenancies at will may be created expressly,35 they much more commonly arise after a prospective tenant has been let into occupation without any formal arrangement or while negotiations for a full lease proceed. Modern case law suggests that a commercial tenancy may continue to be at will even after the tenant has offered rent and the landlord has accepted it,36 but whether residential security of tenure can be avoided during negotiations in this way is more doubtful; it seems likely that a tenancy at will is itself a form of tenancy protected by the Rent Act and the more modern residential codes.37 Normally at least, the consequence of the payment of rent38 would be to create a periodic tenancy when the money was accepted by the landlord, acting deliberately,39 and this will ensure that a tenant who did not hitherto enjoy security of tenure will do so in future. Contracts to evade security of tenure are prohibited.40 Creation of a tenancy may be inferred from a demand for rent or the payment and acceptance of rent by reference to a particular period, where the payment has no other explanation. A tenant holds for four years if he enters the property let to him and begins to pay rent calculated quarterly as prescribed by his lease but, if no particular term had been agreed, payment of rent in this way would lead to the implication of a quarterly tenancy. Periodic tenancies also arise where a person is allowed exclusive occupation of land with no fixed term, where a lease fails because of want of formality, or after a grant for an uncertain fixed term.41 What period is implied if none is expressly agreed? Early authorities suggested that it was always a yearly tenancy, but this doctrine has now been refined so that, today, the period implied follows the method by which the rent is calculated. In Ladies’ Hosiery & Underwear Ltd. v. Parker the example was given, obiter, of a tenant holding over at the expiration of a three-year term at rent of £2 per week, which, in Maugham J.’s opinion, led to a weekly tenancy.42 Conversely Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body 43 was calculated at the yearly rate of £30, payable quarterly, an arrangement which led to the creation of a yearly tenancy.
34 P.E.A. 1977 s.5 (which requires 28 days’ notice to quit a dwelling) does not apply: Crane v. Morris [1965] 1 W.L.R. 1104 C.A. 35 Wheeler v. Mercer [1957] A.C. 416 H.L.; pretences can be ignored or reformed: British Railways Board v. Bodywright (1971) 220 E.G. 651. 36 See below pp. 173–174. 37 See below pp. 109–113. 38 Isolated payments may be ignored: Thompsons (Funeral Furnishers) Ltd. v. Phillips [1945] 2 All E.R. 49 C.A. 39 Not if rent is accepted by mistake: Maconchie Bros. Ltd. v. Brand [1946] 2 All E.R. 778; Sector Properties Ltd. v. Meah (1973) 229 E.G. 1097 C.A. Nor from a computer generated demand issued in error: Dreamgate Property Ltd. v. Amot (1998) 76 P. & C.R. 25 C.A. 40 Re Land and Premises at Liss, Hants [1971] Ch. 986. 41 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body [1992] 2 A.C. 386 H.L.; Blackstone’s Commentaries (1st ed., 1766) vol.2, 147; Dossee v. Doe d. East India Co. (1859) 1 L.T. 345 P.C.; Meye v. Electric Transmission [1942] Ch. 290. 42 [1930] 1 Ch. 304, 325 (a tedious and complex case despite its promising name); the point was left open on appeal. 43 [1992] 2 A.C. 386 H.L.
TERMINATION OF PERIODIC TENANCIES
23
3. Certainty of periodic tenancies Uncertainty is inherent in the very nature of a periodic tenancy. Initially for only one period, it will roll on from period to period until one or other of the parties takes action to bring it to an end by notice. Looked at in retrospect a monthly tenancy may have lasted for 50 years, but for the future it is for one month only.44 Nevertheless an element of certainty can be discovered in the fact that the maximum commitment of either party can be fixed at any moment by the service of notice. As Professor Gray has said: “each occupational unit of time, as it is added to the preceding unit of time, is itself of strictly defined duration.”45
Hence a periodic tenancy was perfectly valid at common law and continues to be so in modern law. D. TERMINATION OF PERIODIC TENANCIES 1. Nature of notice to quit A periodic tenancy has no set length when it is created, since it can be allowed to run on indefinitely, the parties being content to start on the basis that either of them may end the tenancy by notice at any time in the future. Every periodic tenancy must be terminable by notice.46 The effect of giving notice is that when the period of notice ends the tenancy ends with it by effluxion of time, since this is the end of the time for which both parties are prepared to continue it; the notice is not dispositive.47 The nature of a notice to quit has recently been considered in Barrett v. Morgan, a case which requires detailed consideration in the context of agricultural leases and also in the context of notices to quit head tenancies and their effect on sub-tenants.48 Lord Millett said49 that: “A periodic tenancy comes to an end on the expiration of a notice to quit served by the landlord on the tenant or by the tenant on the landlord. [I]t comes to an end by effluxion of time. In each case the tenancy is determined in accordance with its terms. [T]he parties have agreed at the outset on the manner of its determination. The parties and their successors in title, including those who derive title under them, are bound by their agreement.”
The House of Lords drew a sharp distinction between a notice to quit which is nonconsensual and a surrender which is. This is because a notice to quit operates under the terms of the original tenancy agreement and does not require the agreement of the other party. If the landlord gives notice it is called a notice to quit. Sometimes the landlord genuinely wants possession, but at other times the notice to quit is simply a vehicle to secure 44
Re Midland Railway Co.’s Agreement [1971] Ch. 725, 732F–G. Elements of Land Law (1987) 437; Hammersmith and Fulham L.B.C. v. Monk [1992] 1 A.C. 478, 484E, Lord Bridge; Bacon’s Abridgment (7th ed.) vol.4, 839. 46 Woodfall 17.196–17.269; Davey 127–134; Evans & Smith (5th) 232–236. 47 Newlon H.T. v. Alsulaimen [1999] 1 A.C. 313, 317E, Lord Hoffmann. 48 [2000] 1 All E.R. 481 H.L.; see below at pp. 298–301, 618–620. 49 At 484j–485a. 45
24
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
a rent increase or a variation in the terms, so there is no objection to a notice to quit containing an offer of a new tenancy.50 In theory a notice by the landlord ends the tenancy at the time set out in the notice, but very frequently a landlord’s notice will not be effective to give him a right to possession because its only effect will be to trigger statutory security of tenure. Service of a notice to quit by the landlord is a binding election to terminate, rather like a decision to forfeit, and the notice cannot be withdrawn unilaterally.51 If the tenant wishes to leave, he may give a notice of his intention to quit. 2. Restrictions on notice to quit: repugnancy and uncertainty Some periodic tenancies provide that the landlord may not serve notice until a particular condition is satisfied. Such a clause gives rise to twin concerns of repugnancy and uncertainty. A particular term may be rejected because of an inconsistency with the nature of the periodic tenancy of which the term forms a part (that is repugnancy), whether the term is express or implied. At first no term could relate to a time after the end of the very first period of the tenancy. Thus a yearly tenancy could not include a covenant to paint every three years,52 or to give two years’ notice to quit,53 or to do substantial repairs.54 Modern law takes this view only in prospect, when looking forward at the beginning of the periodic tenancy. After the lease has lasted for a number of years, terms can be enforced if they apply to the time when the tenant has actually been in occupation, including all terms at the end of the tenancy.55 Notice provisions are forward looking, so that logically it should not be possible to require a longer period of notice than the period of the tenancy.56 But Breams Property Investment Co. Ltd. v. Stroulger,57 allowed a provision restricting service of notice for a fixed term of three years even though this was longer than the basic period of the lease, and this novelty is now confirmed by the Court of Appeal58 and by Lord Templeman in the House of Lords.59 The result is convenient, but a clause still becomes repugnant if the landlord can never terminate the lease.60 However any fetter has to be for a fixed period of weeks, months or years. Prudential Assurance61 swept away any doubts expressed in Re Midland Railway Co.’s Agreement62 and reasserted the need for certainty of a periodic term. The decision to the reverse in the Midland Railway case has since been overruled. Prospective certainty was,63 50
Ahearn v. Bellman (1879) 4 Ex.D. 201 C.A. Lower v. Sorrell [1963] 1 Q.B. 959 C.A.; R.E. Megarry (1963) 79 L.Q.R. 178; D.G. Barnsley (1963) 27 Conv. (N.S.) 335; A. Dowling [1994] Conv. 437 (prefers the Irish view which permits withdrawal). 52 Tooker v. Smith (1857) 1 H. & N. 732, 156 E.R. 1396. 53 Pinero v. Judson (1829) 6 Bing. 206, 130 E.R. 1259. 54 Doe d. Thomson v. Amey (1840) 12 Ad. & El. 476, 479, 113 E.R. 892. 55 Pistor v. Cater (1842) 9 M. & W. 315, 152 E.R. 134; Adams v. Clutterbuck (1883) 10 Q.B.D. 403, 406. 56 Tooker v. Smith (1857) 1 H. & N. 732, 156 E.R. 1396. 57 [1948] 2 K.B. 1; D.C. Potter (1948) 11 M.L.R. 342. 58 Re Midland Railway Co.’s Agreement [1971] Ch. 725 C.A. 59 Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body [1992] 2 A.C. 386, 395A. 60 Centaploy v. Matlodge [1974] Ch 1, Whitford J.; Midland Railway [1971] Ch. 725, 733F, Russell L.J. 61 [1992] 2 A.C. 386, 395G, Lord Templeman. 62 [1971] Ch. 725 C.A.; D. Macintyre [1971] C.L.J. 198; (1973) 89 L.Q.R. 457. 63 Browne v. Warner (1808) 14 Ves. 156, 158, 33 E.R. 480, Lord Eldon; Doe d. Warner v. Browne (1807) 8 East. 165, 103 E.R. 305; Cheshire Lines Committee v. Lewis & Co. (1880) 50 L.J.Q.B. 121, 138, Brett L.J. 51
TERMINATION OF PERIODIC TENANCIES
25
is,64 and always will be, a requirement for periodic tenancies. Thus in Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body a single term was held to be uncertain because it was to endure until land was required for road widening. A tenant who entered under that void tenancy, paid rent yearly, and had this rent accepted became a yearly tenant. This was terminable by notice in the normal way because, as the Lords held, it was not permissible to imply an uncertain provision restraining termination until the land was required for the purposes of road widening.65 Rather the implied yearly tenancy could be terminated by a half year’s notice66 at the end of any period of the tenancy. 3. Length of notice to quit The period of notice to quit required is determined, first, from any express agreement, that is from any provision in the tenancy agreement stating what period is required. The notice need not be of the same length as the period of the tenancy. That it may be shorter is demonstrated by Re Midland Railway Co.’s Agreement which accepted the validity of a six-monthly tenancy terminable by three months’ notice.67 Express agreement can also require a longer period of notice, despite theoretical problems with repugnancy, so long as the period of notice is of certain duration. Thus a quarterly tenancy may provide for three years’ notice of termination—the effect being to give a rolling period of contractual security for three years.68 Failing an express agreement, the length of notice required to terminate a periodic tenancy is determined by implication from the tenancy’s period. A yearly tenancy can be terminated by half a year’s notice that must expire on an anniversary date of the commencement of the tenancy.69 A yearly tenancy arising by implication from payment of rent on October 10th could be terminated at the end of October 9th in any subsequent year providing that the notice is given on or before 9 April in the year of termination.70 If the decision to terminate was taken at the worst moment in the cycle, termination may be delayed for up to 18 months, better than the period of two years which would be the maximum if the law had insisted upon a full year’s notice. With periods other than a full year, the length of notice required is one full period of the tenancy. Although it is possible to contract out of this rule,71 notice must normally terminate at the end of a full period of the tenancy. Where the creation date of the tenancy is unknown, the term date may be assumed to be the date on which rent is paid. Thus a whole month’s notice is needed to terminate a monthly tenancy:72 a tenancy 64 Prudential Assurance [1992] 2 A.C. 386, 394F, Lord Templeman; Onyx (U.K.) Ltd. v. Beard [1996] E.G.C.S. 55 Ch.D. 65 [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 47 C.A., reversed by H.L. [1992] 2 A.C. 386, 394H. 66 See below p. 515. 67 [1971] Ch. 725 C.A. 68 Breams Property Investments Ltd. v. Stroulger [1948] 2 K.B. 1 C.A.; D.C. Potter (1948) 11 M.L.R. 342; approved in Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd. v. London Residuary Body [1992] 2 A.C. 386 H.L. 69 Bennett Properties Ltd. v. H. & S. Engineering Ltd. [1998] 2 C.L.Y. 3683 Q.B.D. 70 If the tenancy was created on a traditional quarter day (December 25th, March 25th, June 24th and September 29th) two quarters’ notice is required, but otherwise the corresponding date rule is applied; see below p. 581. 71 Harler v. Calder [1989] 1 E.G.L.R. 88 C.A. 72 But see E. Cooke [1992] Conv. 263.
26
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
created on July 15th could be terminated by notice expiring on the 14th of August, September, October, or any subsequent month. The corresponding date rule ensures that a calendar month runs from any given date to the same day in subsequent months, and the same rule applies to years; this is discussed in detail in the commercial section.73 For a weekly tenancy the period of notice required is one week. However, a residential occupier of a dwelling has additional rights to protection from eviction (explained immediately below): he is entitled to receive 28 clear days’ notice, a period running from the date of the notice and unrelated to the period of the tenancy. In commercial leases there is a developing principle that notices should not be served too long in advance,74 and it would seem to be beneficial to develop the law of residential tenancies in the same direction. 4. Protection from eviction The Protection from Eviction Act 197775 regulates residential notices to quit. It applies to leases76 and also to periodic licences,77 but not to excluded tenancies granted after early 1989 nor to excluded licences78 wherever granted. Duration is governed by the rule that notice relating to an inhabited house must be of at least 28 days or four weeks, but time runs immediately from the date of the notice and is independent of the period of the tenancy.79 This rule applies whichever side gives the notice: a tenant who wishes to quit his accommodation is liable for four weeks’ rent.80 So far as the form of notice is concerned, notice to quit a dwelling81 must contain prescribed information,82 warning the tenant of his rights. Essential elements are a statement of the need for due process of law and reference to listed people who can advise tenants, such as solicitors and citizens’ advice bureaux. The current form was prescribed in 198883 though an out of date form which carries the same information may be accepted as valid.84 This information is irrelevant in the case of an agricultural lease.85 5. Errors in notices It is surprisingly difficult to draft an accurate notice stating the correct period of notice and terminating at the end of a period of the lease. Until recently many notices to quit 73
See below p. 581. See below p. 585. 75 P.E.A. 1977 s.5, as amended by H.A. 1988 s.32. 76 Excluding attornment clauses in mortgages: Alliance B.S. v. Pinwill [1958] Ch. 788; Peckham Mutual B.S. v. Registe (1981) 42 P. & C.R. 186, Vinelott J. 77 P.E.A. 1977 s.5(1A). The single period from employment to termination of employment is not a periodic licence: Norris v. Checksfield [1991] 1 W.L.R. 1241 C.A. (4 weeks’ notice not required); on earlier legislation see Crane v. Morris [1965] 1 W.L.R. 1104 C.A. 78 P.E.A. 1977 s.1(1)(1A). 79 s.5. 80 Hounslow L.B.C. v. Pilling [1993] 1 W.L.R. 1242 C.A. In the case of Rent Act statutory tenant, notice must be a contractual period or, if none, 3 months: R.A. 1977 s.3(3). 81 Including a public sector tenancy: Lambeth L.B.C. v. Udechuka (1980) 41 P. & C.R. 200 C.A. (even though S.I. did not cover the public sector). 82 P.E.A. 1977 s.5(1). 83 Notices to Quit etc (Prescribed Information) Regs. 1988, S.I. 1988/2201. 84 Swansea C.C. v. Hearn (1991) 23 H.L.R. 284 C.A. 85 National Trust v. Knipe [1998] 1 W.L.R. 230 C.A.; C. Rodgers [1998] J.H.L. 123, 138. 74
TERMINATION OF PERIODIC TENANCIES
27
were defective and invalid, though very often defects are waived—whether by ignorance or design. There are also numerous cases of defective shorthold notices.86 In Mannai Investments Co. Ltd. v. Eagle Star Life Assurance Co. Ltd.87 the House of Lords decided by a bare majority to allow more flexibility in the interpretation of commercial break clauses. The basis of the decision is to introduce the concept of the reasonable recipient. Goulding J. expressed the test in this way in Carradine Properties Ltd. v. Aslam:88 “Is the notice quite clear to a reasonable tenant reading it? Is it plain that he cannot be misled by it?”
Where a notice contains an error but it would be obvious to a reasonable person receiving it what was intended by it, the defect is overlooked and the obvious meaning is applied. If the flaw in a notice is such that there is a genuine ambiguity it is still destructive of the validity of the notice. The young life of the Mannai principle has already yielded a large crop of cases on defects in commercial break clauses.89 Cases on residential shorthold notices reveal examples both of evident errors90 and also of major ambiguity.91 The issue with shortholds is not quite the same as with break clauses, since a relaxation designed to aid tenants seeking to break a burdensome lease works against a shorthold tenant facing eviction; Mannai removes one of the few defences available. This is also the case with a common law notice to quit, though again here the Mannai principle applies. A notice designed to end the lease must communicate this intention unambiguously and indicate the right of determination being exercised, whether given by the landlord or the tenant.92 Similar principles apply to other types of warning notice, and the courts are also taking a more relaxed view of the use of out of date forms.93 6. Form and parties The form of a notice must follow any contractual term94 and must be in writing;95 unfortunately this last requirement only applies to notices relating to a document about property, and no form is laid down for notices to end a periodic tenancy where the term about the length of the notice to quit is merely implied from the payment and acceptance of rent.96 A landlord has a common law duty of honesty, so that if a landlord is
86
See below pp. 47–48. [1997] A.C. 749 H.L.; see below pp. 579–581. 88 [1976] 1 W.L.R. 442, 444, Goulding J.; approved in Germax Securities Ltd. v. Spiegal (1978) 37 P. & C.R. 204, 206 C.A.; Morrow v. Nadeem [1986] 1 W.L.R. 1381 C.A. 89 See below pp. 579–581. 90 Panayi v. Roberts (1993) 25 H.L.R. 421, 425, Mann L.J.; York v. Casey [1998] 2 E.G.L.R. 25 C.A.; Andrews v. Brewer (1998) 30 H.L.R. 203 C.A. 91 Clickex Ltd. v. McCann [1999] 2 E.G.L.R. 63 C.A. 92 Mannai [1997] A.C. 749,768F–H, Lord Steyn. 93 Tadema Holdings Ltd. v. Ferguson [1999] Times , November 25th, Peter Gibson L.J. 94 Mannai Investment Co. Ltd. v. Eagle Star Life Assurance Co. Ltd. [1997] A.C. 749, 776B, Lord Hoffmann. 95 L.P.A. 1925 s.196(1); New Hart Builders Ltd. v. Brindley [1975] Ch. 342, Goulding J.; L.T.A. 1927 s.23(1). 96 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Atwell [1995] 1 W.L.R. 95 C.A.; J.E. Adams [1995] Conv. 186; J. Montgomerie (1952) 16 Conv. (N.S.) 98, 107. 87
28
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
required to state particular facts in his notice—for example that rent is in arrears—the notice is void if the landlord knows that his statements are false.97 Parties are also important: validity of a notice depends upon service by the correct landlord on the correct tenant. In Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v. Monk 98 the House of Lords held that a joint periodic tenancy held by two or more joint tenants may be determined at common law by notice given by any one of them without the concurrence of the others. The implications and subsequent case law must be considered later. 7. Service Service is the delivery of a document to a particular person.99 Notices relating to property are regulated by section 196 of the Law of Property Act 1925,100 where the notice is required by that Act or by any post-1925 document affecting property, though again there is an unfortunate gap where a tenancy has no express term about the length of a notice to quit.101 Rent Act tenants may give notice to the landlord’s agent or any other person receiving rent.102 Postal service of notices by registered post or recorded delivery is most common and most convenient103 though ordinary post will not do.104 Rules about the service of court proceedings are considered elsewhere.105 E. STATUTORY PROTECTION In Hammersmith & Fulham L.B.C. v. Monk Lord Bridge said that:106 “For a large part of this century there have been many categories of tenancies of property occupied for agricultural residential and commercial purposes, where the legislature has intervened to confer upon tenants extra-contractual rights entitling the tenant to continue in occupation without the consent of the landlord, either after the expiration of a contractual lease for a fixed term or after a notice to quit given by the landlord to determine a contractual periodic tenancy.”
So security of tenure is essentially a lengthening of the contractual duration of a lease. Unfortunately slightly different techniques are adopted by each of the main residential codes.
97 Rous v. Mitchell [1991] 1 W.L.R. 469 C.A.; Lazarus Estates Ltd. v. Beasley [1956] 1 Q.B. 702 C.A.; see below p. 622. 98 [1992] 1 A.C. 478 H.L.; see below pp. 124–130. 99 Tadema Holdings Ltd. v. Ferguson, [1999] Times, November 25th, Peter Gibson L.J. The case shows that a mental patient can be served in the same way as any other person. 100 For more detail, see below pp. 591–593. 101 Wandsworth L.B.C. v. Atwell [1995] 1 W.L.R. 95 C.A.; J.E. Adams [1995] Conv. 186; J. Montgomerie (1952) 16 Conv. (N.S.) 98, 107. 102 R.A. 1977 s.151. 103 L.P.A. 1925 s.196(4); Recorded Delivery Service Act 1962 s.1. 104 Holwell Securities Ltd. v. Hughes [1973] 1 W.L.R. 757, Templeman J. 105 See below pp 593–594. 106 [1992] 1 A.C. 478, 483–484.
STATUTORY PROTECTION
29
1. Holding over When a commercial fixed term tenancy ends, a periodic renewal may be implied from the payment and acceptance of rent,107 and it is also possible that there may be a tenancy at will during negotiations.108 The position of a residential tenant is complicated by the impact of the security of tenure legislation since a residential tenant with security of tenure is entitled to a statutory continuation of his tenancy.109 The landlord has no choice but to accept the rent so acceptance of rent continues the old tenancy rather than creates a contractual novation.110 2. Contractual periodic tenancy Many residential tenancies will be periodic tenancies. In the past private sector tenants generally had an initial fixed period of at least six months (the assured shorthold) following which the tenant could hold over as a periodic tenant, but since early 1997 it has been possible to grant a shorthold which is periodic throughout.111 Public sector tenancies are usually periodic, either by initial grant or because an initial fixed term has run out.112 A Rent Act tenancy was usually periodic, either in its initial form or from holding over after a fixed term. Notice to quit is required. This will remove contractual security (that is the protected tenancy) and will lead to statutory protection (that is a statutory tenancy).113 No notice to quit is required during a statutory phase.114 So long as the tenancy remains in its contractual phase, it is necessary to terminate this periodic tenancy before proceedings can be taken for possession. Notice to quit is required.115 Landlords are obliged to give notice of the correct duration and in the correct form, though subject to waiver by the tenant.116 3. Statutory phase Contractual protection is removed if the tenancy has been converted into a statutory tenancy; usually by a notice to quit. Protection depends entirely upon the appropriate regime of residential security, and no notice to quit will be needed.117 Conversion from a contractual to a statutory phase usually arises from a notice to quit, though also possibly from some rent agreements.118 After a long period of occupation, it is reasonable to assume that a tenancy is statutory and that contractual protection has ended.119
107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119
See below pp. 173–174. A residential tenancy at will would be protected; see below p. 144. See below pp. 109–113. Woodfall 23.044. See above p. 43. H.A. 1985 s.86. R.A. 1977 s.2(1)(a). S.3(4). As to joint tenancies see below pp. 124–130. Elsden v. Pick [1980] 1 W.L.R. 98 C.A. R.A. 1977 s.3(4); H.A. 1988 ss.5(3)(e), 8(4); H.A. 1985 s.83(5). See below pp. 236–237. White v. Wareing [1992] 1 E.G.L.R. 271 C.A. (Rent Act tenancy).
30
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
4. Warning notices Both the assured and the secure schemes120 require a warning notice before a landlord takes repossession proceedings. If the tenancy is periodic this will meet the period needed to end the periodic tenancy and also the 28-day period needed by the protection from eviction legislation. F. INFORMAL SHORT-TERM TENANCIES Leases are generally “void for the purpose of conveying or creating a legal estate” unless made by deed.121 Short leases of actual land122 have been exempted from the need for full formality in creation since 1677,123 but the exemption now appears in section 54(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925 after some amendments of detail in these terms: “Nothing in the foregoing provisions of this part of this Act124 shall affect the creation by parol of leases (1) taking effect in possession (2) for a term not exceeding three years (whether or not the lessee is given power to extend the term) (3) at the best rent which can reasonably be obtained without taking a fine.”
Excepted short leases can be created purely orally125 though full formality is required for a transfer of any existing lease.126 It is important to note that oral leases suffer some disadvantages, most notably that the accelerated procedure for repossession is not available to a landlord against an assured shorthold tenant127 and there are obvious advantages in having the terms of any agreement recorded in writing. 1. Best rent The 1677 original required the lease to be at a rent at least two thirds of the full improved value.128 Its modern equivalent is that the tenancy should reserve the best rent, so that a deed is required to create any lease reserving a fine.129 2. Term not exceeding three years The test for informal creation of a fixed term tenancy is whether the term exceeds three years. Hence a legal lease for three years certain can be written or oral, but a legal lease for three years and one week certain must be by deed.130 A fixed term is valid only if the 120
See below pp. 318–319. This is not necessary for Rent Act tenancies. L.P.A. 1925 s.52(1); see below p. 37. 122 Megarry & Wade (6th ed.) 770 n.84; Duke of Somerset v. Fogwell (1826) 5 B. & C. 875, 108 E.R. 325. 123 Statute of Frauds 1677 s.2. 124 i.e. ss.40 to 54(1); the last mentioned subs. specifies that a lease not in writing is to be a tenancy at will only. The numbering in the text is supplied by the author. 125 P. Sparkes [1992] Conv. 252, 337; Bright & Gilbert 212–222; Davey 22–32; Evans & Smith (5th) ch.4; Garner (2nd) ch.3. 126 Botting v. Martin (1808) 1 Camp. 317, 170 E.R. 970; Crago v. Julian [1992] 1 W.L.R. 372 C.A.; see below pp. 293–294. 127 See below at pp. 56–62. 128 Wood v. Beard (1876) 2 Ex.D. 30. 129 City Permanent B.S. v. Miller [1952] Ch. 840, 846 (similar wording of the original form of L.R.A. 1925 s.70(1)(k)). 130 At 848. 121
INFORMAL SHORT-TERM TENANCIES
31
maximum duration is fixed, and that is the duration which should be taken for formality purposes,131 though one ignores the possibility of forfeiture, extension of the term by the tenant by exercise of an option,132 or its curtailment by the exercise of a break clause whether by the tenant133 or the landlord.134 The test is applied to the natural length of the lease assuming that it is not broken. Periodic tenancies qualify for informal creation if they are yearly, monthly,135 or weekly, and also where there is some restriction on the service of notice for a fixed period that does not exceed three years.136 Even in the public sector it is possible to create a secure tenancy orally. 137 The court which heard Hammond v. Farrow138 decided without much difficulty that a tenancy from week to week determinable by a week’s notice by either side was for a “term not exceeding three months” under the terms of the rating legislation, and so it would obviously also qualify for informal creation. A legal tenancy from leap year to leap year (with a period of four years) would equally clearly require full formalities. That many yearly periodic tenancies outlast three years, and that every one of them could potentially last for ever, does not remove the possibility of informality in creation. Formality tests have to be applied as if each party had served notice at the earliest possible moment, the duration being the longest time that the tenancy can last in those circumstances. Unfortunately Ex parte Voisey139 decided upon a different test. It concerned a tenancy arising under an attornment clause in a mortgage that was to arise on default by the borrower, a manure manufacturer, and then to continue from month to month unless terminated by the lender. Money was lent over 14 years and the actual default occurred after six years, but still informal creation was allowed!140 Sir George Jessel M.R. said141 that this was not obnoxious to the Statute of Frauds “because we do not know how long it may last, because it may not last for three years or for one year.”
This dictum states authoritatively that the shortest possible duration can be taken. The flaw is obvious, since if a lease is not definitely limited so as not to exceed three years it ought to fall within the main provision requiring a deed. In Kushner Lord Goddard C.J. explained Voisey in this way: 131 Not the minimum period: Hammond v. Farrow [1904] 2 K.B. 332, 335, Wills J., as explained in Kushner v. Law Society [1952] 1 K.B. 264, 273, Goddard L.C.J. 132 L.P.A. 1925 s.54(2); Hand v. Hall (1877) 2 Ex. D. 355; Gray v. Spyer [1922] 2 Ch. 22, 38–39; Rollason v. Leon (1861) 7 H. & N. 73, 158 E.R. 398. 133 Kushner v. Law Society [1952] 1 K.B. 264 C.A. (lease for 14 years terminable by the tenant at the end of any year had to be made by deed); earlier cases explained are: Ex parte Voisey (1882) 21 Ch. D. 442, 456, 459, 464; Hammond v. Farrow [1904] 2 K.B. 332, 335, Lord Alverstone C.J. 134 Kushner at 266, 274, Lord Goddard; this despite Hammond v. Farrow [1904] 2 K.B. 332, 335, Lord Alverstone C.J. 135 Including a tenancy of indefinite duration terminable by either party by a month’s notice: Doe d. Lansdell v. Gower (1851) 17 Q.B. 589, 117 E.R. 1406. 136 Breams Property Co. Ltd. v. Stroulger [1948] 2 K.B. 1, 7, Scott L.J. (landlord restricted for exactly 3 years). 137 H.A. 1985 s.91(3)(c); Westminster C.C. v. Peart (1991) 24 H.L.R. 389 C.A. 138 [1904] 2 K.B. 332, 335, Wills J.; Duncan v. Paki [1976] 2 N.Z.L.R. 563, 565; Megarry & Wade (6th ed.) 771. 139 (1882) 21 Ch. D. 442. 140 The lender (landlord) had not executed the mortgage deed. 141 At 456, 458, Brett L.J., 464, Cotton L.J.
32
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
“The fact that [a monthly or weekly or yearly] tenancy may go on for a great number of years does not make the tenancy one which becomes invalid if it is not in writing, nor, because it has lasted for more than three years, must it be by way of deed.”142
Otherwise, as counsel said,143 one reaches conclusions “contrary to all the experience and practice of conveyancing”. Voisey is now limited to periodic tenancies, even though this inevitably creates anomalies and dubious characterisations in borderline cases. It should be overruled. A lease for life is uncertain in duration, and, although anyone might die within three years, it is axiomatic that a lease for life required a deed at common law.144 Most leases for life are now converted to terms of ninety years by statute,145 and it is assumed that a deed is still required. 3. Taking effect in possession An important change in the law occurred in 1925. Until then the rule was that a lease required a deed unless the term was limited to “three years from the making thereof ”,146 time being counted from the date of the grant. So a term to start in one year’s time and then to last for one year could be oral. Foster v. Reeves 147 demonstrates the need for full formality for a lease granted in May for three years from June 24th following. Section 54(2) of the Law of Property Act 1925 introduced a new requirement for tenancies granted after 1925—that the term should be in possession. In consequence a term for one month arising in one year’s time,148 or on a contingency,149 cannot be legal without a deed.150 Between 1925 and 1989 an oral lease that failed at law (because it was not in possession) might also fail as a contract for a lease (because not evidenced in writing).151 Long v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C.152 concerned a claim to adverse possession, which would be defeated if the former tenant’s lease was created in writing,153 but which succeeded if his lease was oral. The crux was a letter written on September 4th1975. In it the landlord’s agent confirmed that his client was prepared to grant him a quarterly tenancy to commence on September 29th 1975, and indeed he did move in on this date and began to pay rent for a few years, but later he remained for 18 years without paying any rent. He sought a declaration of his squatter’s title. Since the grant was made on the 4th to take effect on the 29th of one particular month, the letter did not grant a tenancy in 142
At 274. [1952] 1 K.B. 265, 270, Cumming-Bruce L.J. 144 Doe d. Warner v. Browne (1807) 8 East 165, 166, 103 E.R. 305; Warner v. Browne (1808) 14 Ves. 156, 158, 33 E.R. 480, Lord Eldon L.C.; Re King’s Leasehold Estates (1873) L.R. 16 Eq. 521; Zimbler v. Abrahams [1903] 1 K.B. 577, 581, Vaughan Williams L.J.; Mardell v. Curtis [1899] W.N. 93. 145 L.P.A. 1925 s.149(6). 146 Statute of Frauds 1677 s.2; Wood v. Beard (1876) 2 Ex.D. 30, 34. 147 [1892] 2 Q.B. 255 C.A.; query the dictum of Cotton L.J. in Ex parte Voisey (1882) 21 Ch.D. 442, 464. 148 Bowes v. East London Waterworks Co. (1821) Jacob 324, 330, 37 E.R. 873, Lord Eldon (lease on 20th to take effect on 25th is in reversion). 149 Ex parte Voisey is not legal today. 150 Bush Transport Ltd. v. Nelson [1987] 1 E.G.L.R. 71, 73; the impact of contracts was not considered. 151 L.P.A. 1925 s.40; however taking of possession by the tenant was a part performance which would usually make the contract enforceable. 152 [1998] Ch. 197, 210–219, James Munby Q.C.; J. Perkins (1997) 113 L.Q.R. 394. 153 Limitation Act 1980 sch.1 para.5(1). 143
FORMAL RESIDETIAL TENANCIES
33
possession,154 could not operate at law, and did not prejudice his adverse possession claim, so he was given his declaration. Susan Bright155 was right to say that the decision flies in the face of the accepted understanding, but it is also unquestionably correct. Changes in the contract formalities made by the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989156 removed the need for writing for a contract for a short lease. A short lease that fails as a legal lease, because not in possession, may now operate as an informal contract for the creation of a legal lease without the need for any writing.157 For security purposes an equitable tenancy under a specifically performable contract is just as good as a legal tenancy that does not require specific performance. Hence a distinction has to be drawn between three closely similar tenancies: (1) A lease from today for three years and two weeks requires a deed at law. (2) A lease from two weeks’ time for a term of three years requires a deed to operate at law; but it might operate as a contract for a short lease even without writing; it is a contract for a term which will come into possession, and when possession is taken the term will not exceed three years. (3) A contract to execute a lease in one week’s time to take effect in possession one week later for a term of three years. Here the contract does not fall within the short lease exception because the lease when created will not be in possession. A deed is required for a valid legal lease, and writing for a valid contract. The present law creates wide scope for future burdens of an indeterminate category and the pre-1926 law was altogether more satisfactory. G. FORMAL RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES The preceding discussion demonstrates that three years is a crucial cut off point, with longer leases requiring a deed158 before they are able to operate at law. Until recently almost all residential leases were for less than three years since Rent Act tenancies had to be at a rack rental given the prohibition of premiums. Until early 1989 there was only one exception to this principle: since the Crown was allowed to charge a premium for short residential leases, it was possible to create a lease for (say) 15 years, charging a premium and a reduced rent. Introduction of the assured tenancy scheme in early 1989 led to an increased use of longer residential terms.159 This is because it is now possible to reserve a premium on the grant of an assured tenancy, so it becomes feasible to grant a tenancy in the private sector for a fixed term with a down payment and a lower rental payment. From the point of view of the tenant it is vitally important to ensure that this form of tenancy is assignable so that the tenant is able to realise his economic outlay. It is also important to appreciate the significance of the seven year cut off point: where the initial grant is for less than seven years, the landlord carries the obligation to maintain 154
P. Sparkes [1992] Conv. 337, 340–341. [1998] Conv. 229, 235. 156 s.2(5)(a). 157 The distinction is of particularly little consequence if the landlord’s title is registered since an equitable tenant acquires an overriding interest by taking actual occupation: L.R.A. 1925 s.70(1)(g). 158 L.P.(M.P.) A. 1989 s.1, in force July 31st, 1990; Sparkes, N.L.L. 216–222. 159 Artesian Residential Developments Ltd. v. Beck [1999] 3 All E.R. 113 C.A. (10 year term). 155
34
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
the structure of the dwelling-house and the installations within it.160 So if the landlord makes an initial contractual grant for seven years or any longer fixed term, liability for these expensive items can be transferred by covenant to the tenant. From the point of view of the landlord it is important to include provisions in any fixed term tenancy that enable him to end the contractual term if there is a breach of covenant. This is similar to a forfeiture, though if there is an assured tenancy (that is if the tenant is in residential occupation) the procedure is a residential repossession rather than a forfeiture.161 A deed is necessary to create a legal tenancy exceeding three years. However it may not matter much if the legal formalities are overlooked provided that there is a sufficient written contract. An equitable tenancy can be created under the doctrine of Walsh v. Lonsdale 162 using contract formalities.163 Today all the terms expressly agreed must be reduced to writing and signed by both parties, either on a single document or in contractual parts which are exchanged. Equitable rights generally prevail over legal rights provided that they have priority. Hence in Walsh v. Lonsdale itself, Lonsdale had a lease for seven years under the terms of his contract rather than a yearly periodic tenancy that was the extent of his common law entitlement. Equitable leases are discussed in the context of commercial leases164 where they are more common, but all residential security regimes accept equitable rights as sufficient to attract security of tenure. So in R. v. Tower Hamlets L.B.C. ex parte Von Goetz165 a 10-year shorthold created by a tenancy agreement in writing gave rise to a sufficient interest in the land to qualify the tenant to apply for an improvement grant. Equitable interests remain vulnerable on a sale of the reversion unless there is a protective registration.166 Tightening of the contract formalities in 1989 increased the likelihood that an agreement for a tenancy may fail to qualify as a land contract. Ultimately resort may be required to the doctrine of proprietary estoppel. All estoppels are based on an expectation in the mind of the putative tenant that he will be entitled to a tenancy created (that is, induced) by the putative landlord. Leasehold creation requires a proprietary estoppel, so that the tenant must establish a detriment incurred in reliance on the landlord’s promise.167 Many cases show that estoppel is a perfectly viable method of creating valid tenancies, both in commercial cases168 and especially also when considering the impact of residential security of tenure.
160
L.T.A. 1985 ss.11–16; see below pp. 243–251. See below p. 359. 162 (1882) 21 Ch.D. 9 C.A. 163 L.P.(M.P.) A. 1989 s.2, replacing Statute of Frauds 1677 s.4 (writing) and Real Property Act 1845 s.3 (upgrade to deed). 164 See below pp. 521–524. 165 [1999] Q.B. 1019 C.A. 166 See below p. 520. 167 Sparkes N.L.L. ch. 11. 168 Orgee v. Orgee [1997] E.G.C.S. 152 C.A.; M. Pawlowski (1998) 114 L.Q.R. 351; Pridean Ltd. v. Forest Taverns Ltd. (1998) 75 P. & C.R. 447 C.A. 161
PROPRIETARY STATUS
35
H. PROPRIETARY STATUS When a tenant is seeking to enforce his rights against his original landlord it is not necessary to show that his tenancy has proprietary status.169 But if the landlord’s interest is sold, the tenant will have rights he can assert against the purchaser only if he can show that he has a property right, and one with priority over the new landlord. 1. Unregistered reversion A short residential tenancy qualifies as a term of years absolute170 and hence for legal status.171 Whether or not a buyer of the land has notice of the tenancy is irrelevant since legal rights bind the world. Where a tenancy is continued in force by the security of tenure legislation this extension, if not strictly a legal estate under all residential codes, is at least sufficiently legal to be capable of binding the land irrespective of notice. The results can be capricious. A tenant given an oral weekly tenancy may in some circumstances attract full life-long security of tenure—if the landlord is in the public sector, if a social sector landlord chooses to allow it, or if a private sector grant was first made before early 1989—and his tenure will bind the land and anyone who buys it indefinitely. Most residential tenants occupy the dwelling—and qualifying occupation is often necessary to preserve security of tenure172 so that a purchaser has an informal “notice”, but security may in certain circumstances continue through periods of non-occupation, and if so the tenancy nevertheless retains its binding status. Equitable tenancies based on contractual rights will require a protective land charges registration, and tenancies created by estoppel depend for their proprietary force on notice doctrine.173 2. Registered reversion The original scheme for leases of registered land was confused and fragmentary174 so that the greater coherence introduced by the Land Registration Act 1986175 was badly needed. Even so the law remains unsatisfactory. It would be neither practicable nor desirable to keep a complete register of all residential tenants, since they come and go, and any register would inevitably fall out of date. For this reason most short leases and tenancies are treated as being overriding so that they take effect and bind purchasers off the register. The paragraph (k)176 overriding interest is constituted by “leases granted for a term not exceeding 21 years”.
This embraces almost all leases that are not substantively registrable. However, the force of the word “granted” needs careful appreciation since it is not immediately apparent that this restricts paragraph (k) to legal leases. City Permanent B.S. v. Miller177 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177
Bruton v. London & Quadrant Housing Trust [2000] A.C. 406 H.L. L.P.A. 1925 s.205(1)(xxvii). s.1(1)(b). See below pp. 104–109. Sparkes N.L.L. ch. 11. Hayton’s Registered Land (Sweet & Maxwell, 3rd ed., 1981) ch.3. In force January 1st 1987, following Law Com. No.125 (1983). L.R.A. 1925 s.70(1)(k), as amended. [1952] Ch. 840 C.A.
36
2. CONTRACTURAL DURATION
concerned an oral agreement to create a lease for three years and then from week to week (that is for a minimum term of three years and one week) which was not a legal lease and so was held not to be a paragraph (k) overriding interest. It seems to follow from the course of discussion in Miller that had the tenancy been one week shorter and so qualified for informal legal creation178 it would have fallen within paragraph (k). It now makes no difference whether the lease is at a rack rent, reserves a fine, or is purely gratuitous.179 Protection adheres without any requirement that the tenant be in occupation, so that a short-term tenancy may be a totally undiscoverable incumbrance.180 For example in Prince v. Robinson181 it was recognised in an obiter discussion that a Rent Act tenancy could be an overriding interest that would bind a purchaser of the reversion even though the flat to which the tenancy had attached had been completely reconstructed and no longer existed in its original form. Existence of paragraph (k) protection is dependent upon the existence of the lease at the date of registration of a later dealing with the reversionary title.182 The grant of a paragraph (k) tenancy is deemed to be by way of registered disposition,183 so that a short lease defeats unprotected minor interests, and the tenant is bound exclusively by register entries and pre-existing overriding interests.184 A tenant who fails to secure protection under paragraph (k) may still fall back on an overriding interest under paragraph (g) by virtue of actual occupation or through receipt of net rents where a sub-tenant is in occupation.185 This may also provide a second layer of protection for a paragraph (k) tenant, giving fortuitous protection to options and also to future leases held by a person who happens to be in occupation under some other right. Protection is lost, of course, under the express terms of paragraph (g) if enquiry is made of the occupier and the lease is not disclosed, and also if the tenant is not in occupation at the time of the completion of some later transaction.186 Some leases may be protected against the landlord’s title by a protective entry, in which case the lease is a minor interest and the proprietary force is dependent upon that entry.187 Protection by notice requires either the consent of the landlord or a court order, but a caution may be used for non-consensual entries.188 The land registry will refuse to make an entry if the lease is substantively registered or if it is both overriding and obvious.189 This means that protective notice is left to apply to a limited range of leases:
178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 188 189
L.P.A. 1925 s.54(2). Amendments by L.R.A. 1986 s.4. The same is of course true of a legal lease of unregistered land. (1999) 31 H.L.R. 89 C.A. Pourdanay v. Barclays Bank plc [1997] Ch. 321 Ch.D. (also known as Zaroovabli). L.R.A. 1925 s.19(2). Freer v. Unwins Ltd. [1976] Ch. 288. L.R.A. 1925 s.70(1)(g). Abbey National B.S. v. Cann [1991] 1 A.C. 56 H.L.; P. Sparkes [1986] Conv. 309. L.R.A. 1925 s.48(1). A restriction is another possibility: J.E. Adams [1994] Conv. 200. L.R.A. 1925 ss.19(2)(a), 22(2)(a); L.R.R. 1925 r.199.
SURRENDER
37
(1) certain pre-1987 leases: leases for 21 years or less at a fine; leases for 21 years or less without any rent; and any lease made before 1986190 with an absolute prohibition on assignment; (2) agreements for leases;191 and (3) future leases. Longer leases with 21 years remaining unexpired at the time of a dealing require substantive registration. I.
SURRENDER
Many residential tenancies end by surrender.192 The tenant offers to give up his lease to the landlord, and the landlord accepts it.193 The very essence of a surrender is the consent of both parties, based on an intention to s