MULTIPLE EMULSIONS TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Edited by
Abraham Aserin
WILEY-INTERSCIENCE A John Wiley & Sons, Inc.,...
233 downloads
2362 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Edited by
Abraham Aserin
WILEY-INTERSCIENCE A John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Publication
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Edited by
Abraham Aserin
WILEY-INTERSCIENCE A John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Publication
Copyright © 2008 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permission. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic formats. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Wiley Bicentennial Logo: Richard J. Pacifico Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: Multiple emulsions : technology and applications / edited by Abraham Aserin. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-0-470-17093-9 (cloth) 1. Emulsions. 2. Emulsions (Pharmacy) I. Aserin, Abraham. TP156.E6.M84 2008 660′. 294514—dc22 2007019893 Printed in the United States of America 10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
CONTENTS
Preface
vii
Introduction
xix
Contributors
xxiii
1. Multiple Emulsion Stability: Pressure Balance and Interfacial Film Strength
1
Jim Jiao and Diane J. Burgess
2. Structure and Rheology of Stable Multiple Emulsions
29
P. Perrin, F. Prigent, and P. Hébraud
3. Visualization of Stability and Transport in Double Emulsions
45
Louise Braud Lawson and Kyriakos Papadopoulos
4. Effect of an Oil-Insoluble Solute on the Stability of Multiple Water-Oil-Water Emulsions
67
Mouhcine Kanouni and Henri Rosano
5. Multiple Emulsions Stabilized by Biopolymers
85
Rachel Lutz and Abraham Aserin
6. Recent Developments in Manufacturing Particulate Products from Double-Emulsion Templates Using Membrane and Microfluidic Devices
121
Goran T. Vladisavljevic´ and Richard A. Williams
7. Recent Developments in O/W/O Multiple Emulsions
165
Axel Benichou and Abraham Aserin
8. Potentialities of W/O/W Multiple Emulsions in Drug Delivery and Detoxification
209
Jean-Louis Grossiord and Moncef Stambouli
9. Surface-Modified Fine Multiple Emulsions for Anticancer Drug Delivery
235
Ajay J. Khopade and N. K. Jain v
vi
CONTENTS
10. Application of Emulsion Technology to Transarterial Injection Chemotherapy for Hepatocellular Carcinoma Using Double-Emulsion Enclosing Vesicles of Anticancer Drug Solution
257
Shushi Higashi
11. Lipiodol W/O/W Emulsion for Transcatheter Arterial Embolization Therapy Prepared with Two-Step Pumping Emulsification Method
275
Tomoaki Hino and Takayuki Ohwaki
12. Multiple Emulsions: Delivery System for Antigens
293
Asuman Bozkir and Ongun Mehmet Saka
Index
307
PREFACE
In Honor of Prof. Nissim Garti’s 60th Birthday
In 2006, Prof. Nissim Garti celebrated his sixtieth birthday. By that time he had had a brilliant scientific career spanning more than thirty-five years. No happier way can be found of celebrating a scientist’s birthday than by issuing a Festschrift in his honor. Such a Festschrift—be it a special issue of a journal or a book—generally contains studies that intend to reflect various topics relating to the putative extensive work and all-round interests of the honoree. Usually only one Festschrift is issued on a particular anniversary. Nissim has justly been awarded two Festschrifts! The first was a special issue of a scientific journal.1 The intervening year before the publication of the present book has served only to enhance the renown of this outstanding scientist and to increase the fervor and esteem with which this tribute is offered. Between the covers of this book are published articles written by colleagues, alumni, and friends in honor of Prof. Garti. They are all one in their affection and esteem for his personality and achievements. Many more would have contributed but for space and schedules. Yet all join us in congratulating Prof. Garti on passing his sixtieth birthday and on amassing a lifetime of work vii
viii
PREFACE
and ground-breaking benchmark accomplishments as one of the most original and innovative scientists in the field of surfactant chemistry. Whereas the literature cited at the end of this Preface demonstrates ramified and diverse research areas—almost every one of which has long interested Prof. Garti—the present book is focused on one subject: multiple emulsions. This topical choice for the Festschrift reflects a challenging area to which Nissim has devoted his talent and efforts over the past two decades, an area in which he pioneered creative ideas and spearheaded and opened up new far-reaching vistas. It is, I trust I may say, the hope of all contributors to this book, that besides being our humble tribute to Prof. Garti, it may stimulate a few readers to pursue the investigation of multiple emulsions. Before delving into some of the most prominent works of Prof. Garti, it is apposite to say something here about Nissim—the man and scientist. In describing the biography of a distinguished scientist, there is always the challenge of balancing the personal aspects with the professional accomplishments. The reader is referred to the Preface of the first Festschrift for a biographical sketch of Prof. Garti, which offers a testimony to his eminence in various facets of surfactant chemistry. It would not be in accord with Jewish ethics to tell all of a man’s praise in his presence—it can be done only in part. This brief Preface is therefore not the place to expand on the personal characteristics of Nissim and the more so as some of them were detailed at the end of this Preface. However, it is still worth reiterating Professor Garti’s deep love for teaching. We know that Nissim, who is not capable of patting himself on the back, will do anything he can to evade premeditated questions intended to highlight his remarkable scientific career. Yet, were we to ask Prof. Garti what would best characterize his life’s work, then, modest as he is about his multifarious achievements, he would undoubtedly prefer to emphasize that at heart he is, first and foremost, a teacher. Presumably two reasons underlie Prof. Garti’s devotion to the arduous task of education. First, learning was prized in Nissim’s household, his parents striving to imbue their children with a yearning for enlightenment. Nissim still remembers that no sacrifice—including the carefree joys of childhood—was too great in the pursuit of learning. Second, Nissim has a deep and abiding respect for the teachers who directed him toward the experimental sciences. Perhaps these two reasons led Nissim to develop a commitment to the teaching profession. In the Preface of the first Festschrift, we have elaborated on the inferior status of the teacher, on the way experimental work has to be done, and on the assistance tendered by Nissim to colleagues and young scientists. In the present Preface we would like to deal with two other points. First, we discuss the seemingly contradictory method of Nissim’s teaching: Prof. Garti is considered a preeminent teacher, beloved by all his students without exception. It seems prima facie rather paradoxical because, after all, Prof. Garti is a very demanding and tough teacher, somewhat reluctant to give compliments or high grades. So what is the magic of Nissim?
PREFACE
ix
It seems that Prof. Garti is the consummate pedagogue who teaches by personal example. Few teachers have given more of themselves to their students than Nissim. He is never too busy to help young scientists, to give them the gift of knowledge, how to proceed on the paths they had embarked upon, always with kindness and a sincere interest in them and their work. Nissim tries to help even low-performing students to cope with the myriad problems they face in their scientific work on an almost daily basis. He provides his assistance, sparing no effort and expecting no recompense. He will juggle his hectic schedule in order to respond to others in need of advice. He is always ready to put his personal library at his students’ disposal and they say that his books are frequently of more value than those of the university library. Any attempt to thank Nissim is usually a source of embarrassment to him. A teacher devoted to his students, Prof. Garti will not cancel a single lesson even if it involves great inconvenience for him. Nissim’s students are impressed with his fairness and integrity, and with his scientific rigor and intellectual grasp. Those who have passed through Prof. Garti’s hands can appreciate his refusal to yield to perfunctory or superficial performance as part of his instruction and research work. Above all, he invigorates his students to launch and conduct their research projects, to raise the proper questions, and to try to gain otherwise unavailable insights by employing innovative measuring techniques. Prof. Garti teaches them repeatedly that investigation yoked too tightly to a specific scientific model is almost always liable to fail. They should therefore seek less trite approaches for their apparent insoluble research problems. In a word, he encourages them to aspire to the highest standards of scientific excellence. The legacy of a scientist is usually measured in the number of his publications. Prof. Garti thinks that the contribution of a true scientist should be valued via the students who came into his circle of influence, who learned from him, and who would be ready to emulate his way even if it is difficult to follow because of its high standards and exacting nature. We know, however, that Nissim, even after meticulously checking and testing his experimental data and their analysis again and again, always thinks that his work still lacks that perfection that would have been possible given more ample leisure. Indeed many a potential scientific paper that could readily be published was postponed or even abandoned by Nissim, since in his opinion just a certain minor point was not sufficiently well-founded. This is the reason why Prof. Garti disdains what might be called tawdry scientific methodology—hastily publishing premature articles that rely on a maze of rather implausible hypotheses with only scant experimental data behind them. Nissim asserts that it would have been salutary if the authors of such papers had noticed that in this way science does not advance in the least. Most educators have failed to study diligently how students use their knowledge and training in out-of-classroom (or lab) settings when these may be the uses that matter most. Nissim, however, initiates his students not only into careful research but also into the practical life of the professional. For example, he instructs them how to acquire the competence and confidence to prepare
x
PREFACE
and submit articles for publication in scientific journals and how to see their works properly through the publishing process, a task that without assistance can be frustrating and discouraging even to a highly motivated student. Even when Nissim himself writes the manuscript of a scientific paper, he feels that every student who has participated in the research work is just as involved and helpful in its completion and getting it published. Moreover Prof. Garti would generously help students and colleagues with their own writing in order to achieve clarity of exposition. The second point relates to science education. The most widely claimed goals of science education are: to produce citizens who are scientifically literate and to support citizens in understanding reports and discussions of science (especially about issues that may be controversial) that appear in the popular media. At the core of science education activity we find also two other tasks: 1. To attack pseudoscience beliefs and ideas that have been gaining ground over the last two decades, mainly because of the entertainment industry. 2. To improve the ability of the general public to distinguish between fact and fiction, since the visual media have blurred the distinction between these two concepts. Nissim’s sense of concern and commitment to the furtherance of science has always extended beyond his own students to include the “educated layman.” So he does his best to achieve these goals. As a part of his endeavor to bring academic interests and scientific achievements to a large audience and to widen the circle of informed readers and listeners, Prof. Garti is always ready to find time, whether to lecture on science to interested groups or to write scientific articles in popular journals. Nissim is endowed with an extraordinary blend of oratorical power and intellectual acuity that, together with his infectious enthusiasm and eloquent writing, almost inevitably enables him to imbue his listeners and readers with a keen interest in science. Moreover Nissim also tries to direct their attention to research findings that are rarely communicated to the general public directly by scientists. Such lectures or papers have to be prepared carefully and thoroughly. Nissim knows how to elucidate points of cardinal significance and how to translate from scientific language into something palpable and meaningful to the “common person.” Indeed Nissim’s limpidity and economy of expression, combined with the restriction of technical material to the minimum, enable him to simplify intricate scientific topics. Prof. Garti also knows how to whet the appetite of his audience for more information. In lectures he succeeds in igniting the interest of his listeners by utilizing highly entertaining and informative presentations communicated in a voluble, exuberant style. Frequently he tells vivid stories about how science works and about the strengths and frailties of prominent scientists. Far from
PREFACE
xi
least, these stories reveal the significance of scientific achievements more than the usual dull reports. It should, however, be noted that Prof. Garti gets far and away the best response from his listeners and readers when he teaches them to be skeptical and to accept as truth only statements that are irrefutable through scientific scrutiny. Nissim’s solution to the prevailing problem of disgruntled listeners who pester the lecturer with questions is very typical and instructive. Most lecturers regard them as too clever by half and needing to be taken down a peg or two. Prof. Garti always tries the opposite attitude toward these smart alecs. Generally, he follows a two-pronged strategy. First, he would treat them with considerable respect and tolerance, never being invidious or talking down to them. Second, he would use his dry and witty sense of humor to relieve tension during his lectures. We now turn to the seminal contributions of Prof. Garti to the study of multiple emulsions. Nissim’s research interests could never be limited to any single scientific problem or theme, and this only becomes fully apparent upon examining the scope of his over 300 refereed publications, invited symposia, book chapters, and reviews. However, for Nissim, multiple emulsions have been a favorite object of investigation ever since the early 1980s, and he has become one of the most active scientists in this burgeoning area. Moreover there is an interesting relation between Prof. Garti’s skills as a scientist and teacher regarding multiple emulsions. It is known that persuading students to be involved in multiple emulsions research is a formidable educational challenge. Far be it for me to argue that such an investigation is too difficult for a graduate student, since the underlying concepts in multiple emulsions science are quite easy to grasp and yet experimental work on these emulsions is undoubtedly one of the most demanding and enervating research tasks students may encounter within surfactant chemistry. This is simply because the continuous, long-term (in the order of weeks and even months!) monitoring need for following up any changes in the multiple emulsion stability, and furthermore in the rate of addendum release, virtually confines the student to the lab as long as such an experiment is going on. Nevertheless, some students have been lured by Nissim’s enthralling descriptions of multiple emulsions, and the main results of their M.Sc. and Ph.D. works are detailed in the following. These multi-compartment liquid dispersions are considered adequate vehicles for controlled and sustained delivery of entrapped addenda, such as drugs. Thus a drug that is dissolved or suspended in the internal aqueous phase of a W/O/W emulsion is forced to diffuse across the oil phase prior to being released into the body fluids. Multiple emulsions have been the subject of numerous investigations due to their importance as an emerging and promising technology for slow and controlled release of active ingredients and as a major scientific challenge regarding the preparation and improvement of the kinetic stability of these inherently thermodynamically unstable entities. As a testimony to the
xii
PREFACE
evolution of the field of multiple emulsions, one may merely peruse the subject matter of the articles in this book. Prof. Garti maintains a preeminent position in the research of multiple emulsions as is manifested by his nearly 40 articles concerning them. These scientific papers exhibit the gripping combination—typical of Nissim’s research work—of brilliant and ingenious insights together with rigorous treatment of even the minutest details, which are acquired by hard and systematic experimental work. Several highlights achieved by Prof. Garti are herewith outlined more or less in chronological order. In 1983 Nissim had already tackled the problem of how to overcome the unpleasant taste of drugs such as chlorpromazine-HCl. Oral administration of a bitter-tasting medication to a child is obviously a cumbersome task. The solution suggested by Prof. Garti was to dissolve the drug in the inner phase and to release it throughout the oil phase in the presence of synthetic gastric juice. A child will swallow medication willfully when the outer water phase contains synthetic flavors that simulate attractive tastes such as that of strawberry or raspberry. It should be noted that the drug release in this case is neither controlled nor targeted.2 The release of electrolytes and drugs from multiple emulsions can, in principle, proceed via two possible mechanisms: 1. The oil layer separating the inner and outer aqueous phases behaves as a semipermeable membrane: The release of solutes from a W/O/W multiple emulsion, for instance, only occurs through breakdown of the multiple droplets as a result of osmotic flow of water to the inner phase and consequent coalescence of the droplets. 2. The oil layer behaves as a permeable membrane and the solute migrates by diffusion from the inner emulsion. Prof. Garti has shown3 that the diffusion mechanism is a predominant factor in the migration of electrolytes from the inner to the outer phase in multiple emulsions. The release of the electrolyte is affected by its hydrophobicity and concentration but not by the viscosity of the internal phase. In another paper, written in collaboration with D. Whitehill,4 it was demonstrated that the addition of NaCl to multiple emulsions causes droplet shrinkage due to loss of internal water. Micelle transport seemed to be the primary mechanism. A kinetic model, adapted from that of Higuchi for release of dispersed drugs from polymeric matrices, was found to be suitable for the release of electrolytes from multiple emulsions. The existence of a diffusion-controlled mechanism was experimentally confirmed. This mechanism is facilitated as the concentration of reverse micelles formed in the oil phase increases.5 In another investigation it was shown that whereas the presence of electrolytes in the outer aqueous phase has no bearing on the control of drug leaching
PREFACE
xiii
from the inner aqueous phase even when there is no osmotic pressure gradient between the two aqueous phases—implying that the system is not controlled solely by this factor—the presence of electrolytes in the internal water phase can retard the drug migration. Electrolytes that can cause salting-in of the emulsifier to the oil phase strengthen the oil–water interface and thereby decrease drug transport.6 Additional milestones in Prof. Garti’s work regarding the stabilization of multiple emulsions should be mentioned: Solid oil (paraffin wax) is superior to liquid oil in formulations of multiple emulsions as a stable rigid oil membrane is formed that hinders the migration of additives from the inner water phase.7 Prof. Garti was among the first scientists to understand the significance of the replacement of monomeric surfactants (usually blends of hydrophobic and hydrophilic amphiphiles) by polymeric emulsifiers. Such multi-anchoring macromolecules provide strong steric stabilization capabilities via the formation of thick and flexible interfacial films. An early highlight of Nissim’s work in this area comprises the utilization of polysiloxane-graft-poly(oxyethylene) to stabilize W/O/W multiple emulsions. Stable, small droplet size W/O emulsions were formed with hydrophobic comb-grafted copolymers adsorbed at the inner interface. The outer interface of the W/O/W multiple emulsions was stabilized by hydrophilic comb-grafted copolymers with similar structures but with highdensity grafting and long poly(oxyethylene) chains. The release rates of additives from such multiple emulsions were very slow.8 Silicone-based surfactants impart unusual mechanical stability to W/O/W multiple emulsions that makes them possible candidates for slow release systems for agricultural applications.9 In addition to synthetically tailor-made polymeric amphiphiles, naturally occurring biopolymers are considered for stabilization of multiple emulsions, especially where these emulsions are needed for food and cosmetic applications. Thus the protein bovine serum albumin (BSA) significantly improves the mechanical and steric stability of W/O/W emulsions when used in a blend with a nonionic surfactant, such as Span 80. It is assumed that the two amphiphiles act synergistically by forming an interfacial complex—presumably a thick, strong gelled film that confers resistance to rupture and elasticity on the inner droplets. Based on Garti’s modification of Higuchi’s model, it was concluded that BSA has a double role:10 1. At the inner phase, BSA provides a mechanical barrier to the release of small molecules from the internal interface. The release proceeds mainly via reverse micellar transport. The presence of BSA reduces the chance of reverse micelle formation and thus decreases the release rate of entrapped addenda within the emulsion droplets. 2. At the outer phase, BSA impedes coalescence via steric stabilization. Stable water in vegetable oil emulsions can serve as basic preparations for food-grade W/O/W multiple emulsions. A novel way of stabilization of such
xiv
PREFACE
systems is to use submicronal α-form, crystallized hydrogenated fat (tristearin) homogeneously dispersed in the oil phase.11 The crystals should be submicronal in size to effectively adsorb and accommodate at the interface. Large crystals flocculate in the continuous oil phase.12 Yet these solid fat particles cannot sufficiently stabilize the W/O emulsion, and they have to be blended with a lipophilic surfactant (polyglycerol polyricinoleate, PGPR). The combination of fat microcrystals and PGPR has the following advantages: 1. Aggregation and flocculation processes are inhibited. 2. PGPR serves as a cross-linker or a bridge between the fat particles and water. 3. PGPR facilitates the anchoring of the fat particles in the oil phase while dangling itself in the water phase. 4. PGPR functions as an α-tending crystal structure modifier. Improved stability can be obtained by utilizing the emulsifier PGPR in the internal water phase and a protein-polysaccharide hybrid (as a substitute for the common nonionic hydrophilic monomeric emulsifiers) in the external interface. For instance, whey protein isolate (WPI) forms soluble complexes with hydrocolloids such as xanthan gums or galactomannans at selected pH values and weight ratios. These hybrids with specific interface recognition capabilities stabilize multiple emulsions mainly via steric interactions at the oil-water external interface. However, at high gum levels, the emulsions become more elasticized, uncomplexed gum migrates to the bulk, and the depletion mechanism will dominate. The stabilizing effect of such hybrids is synergistic. Thus droplets of WPI/xanthan-based multiple emulsions are, respectively, onefourth or one-eighth smaller than those of multiple emulsions based solely on either WPI or xanthan.13 Excellent stability to coalescence was obtained via interaction of WPI with modified pectin.14 The effects of WPI/polysaccharide conjugates on the stabilization of multiple emulsions are the subject of recent studies. It was observed, for example, that the release of vitamin B1, entrapped in the core of W/O/W multiple globules, is hampered due to the biopolymer adducts formed at the interface.15 Similar adducts stabilize O/W/O multiple emulsions and serve as efficient barriers against release of addenda contained in the inner phase.16 In Prof. Garti’s opinion, employing multiple emulsions should not be restricted to pharmaceuticals, nutraceuticals, and cosmetics. He hopes that other promising and exciting applications will be available in near future. The microencapsulation of fine boron particles in W/O/W multiple emulsions may serve as such a feasible example.17 Last, the results of a very recent investigation concerning a novel type of multiple emulsion, dubbed “emulsified microemulsion” (EME), are herewith
PREFACE
xv
shown. Since the kinetic stability of the internal phase is inversely proportional to its droplet size, it is conceivable that nanosized droplets (microemulsions) would improve the system stability. One potential application of such emulsified microemulsions is the formation of submicronal injectable liquid W/O/W preparations for controlled drug release. This concept has barely been implemented before now due to the tedious experimental work necessary to ascertain that the nano-droplets remain intact after the secondary emulsification stage as well as after prolonged storage. Moreover the very fast exchange of the monomeric surfactants between the internal and external interfaces induces concurrent emptying of the core phase and leaching of the inner water phase. This second problem has been solved skillfully in Prof. Garti’s lab by using glycerol monooleate as surfactant, R(+)-limonene/ethanol 1 : 1 (by weight) as the oil phase, and water/glycerol (9.15 : 0.85) (wt/wt) as the water phase. Samples of this microemulsion were further emulsified, utilizing the hydrophobic graft copolymer Pluronic F127 (PEO99-PPO67-PEO99, where PEO stands for polyethylene oxide and PPO for polypropylene oxide). Pulsed-gradientspin-echo NMR has shown that glycerol monooleate and R(+)-limonene are present in the inner phase of the emulsified microemulsion even after the second emulsification process. Electrical conductivity measurements have demonstrated that at least 60 wt% of the internal water phase remained confined after the second emulsification stage. SAXS (small angle X-ray scattering) measurements have shown that the inner microemulsion in the emulsified microemulsion is more ordered than the original L2-phase. This surprising finding may be attributed to the effect of the polymeric surfactant. Cryo-TEM (transmission electron microscopy) images of the emulsified microemulsion provide direct evidence for the existence of spherical globules in the inner phase, having a mean diameter of 250 ± 50 nm in rather good agreement with corresponding results by DLS (dynamic light scattering): approximately 200 ± 50 nm, which is about 10 to 20 times smaller than the size of conventional multiple emulsion globules. The investigated system has remained stable during up to 12 months of storage at ambient temperature. This promising system is now being studied to explore its ability to retain bioactive addenda and release them in a controlled manner.18 It seems appropriate to conclude with a personal note. Prof. Garti is to me a teacher and a mentor. The scope and magnitude of his influence on me are without equal. As a senior member of Nissim’s research team, I have a daily contact with him, and I would like to share some of my impressions with the readers of this Preface. Prof. Garti is now at the pinnacle of his highly variegated scientific achievements. As Nissim enters his seventh decade of life, I can assure the readers that he has not yielded to the demands of age. On the contrary, every year Nissim looks younger. None of his stamina has been lost. His energy and willpower may be likened to an ever-flowing fountain and, more wonderful still, they show no signs of diminishing. Prof. Garti’s
xvi
PREFACE
enthusiasm for work, his alert response to new ideas, and his original insights have remained unblemished and keen. He is always the first person to enter the lab in the morning and the last to leave at night, filling his long day with incessant activity. Nissim never forgets to acknowledge that all his accomplishments and success are due to his wonderful family and, most of all, to his wife, Ricki. She has been standing by Nissim in joy and sorrow, always giving of herself without stint to him and their family. This Festschrift is herewith presented to you, Nissim, as a token of our heartfelt appreciation and admiration. The book is accompanied by our ardent prayer that like our ancient leader, Moses, may “your eyes remain undimmed and your vigor unabated.” It is the fervent hope of your friends, colleagues, and students that you will enjoy good health and continuous creative labor for many years to come. Abraham Aserin, Ph.D. LITERATURE CITED 1. Aserin A. 2006. Honoring Professor Nissim Garti. Adv Colloid Interface Sci (1–3): 128–130. 2. Garti N, Frenkel M, Schwartz R. 1983. Multiple emulsions. Part II: Proposed technique to overcome unpleasant taste of drugs. J Dispers Sci Technol 4(3): 237–252. 3. Magdassi S, Garti N. 1984. Release of electrolytes in multiple emulsions: Coalescence and breakdown or diffusion through oil phase? Colloids Surf 12: 367–373. 4. Garti N, Magdassi S, Whitehill D. 1985. Transfer phenomena across the oil phase in a water-oil-water multiple emulsion evaluated by Coulter counter. 1. Effect of primary emulsifier on permeability. J Colloid Interface Sci 104(2): 587–591. 5. Magdassi S, Garti N. 1986. A kinetic model for release of electrolytes from W/O/W multiple emulsions. J Controlled Release 3(4): 273–277. 6. Garti N, Romano-Pariente A, Aserin A. 1987. The effect of additives on release from W/O/W emulsions. Colloids Surf 24: 83–94. 7. Magdassi S, Garti N. 1986. Formation of water/oil/water multiple emulsions with solid oil phase. J Colloid Interface Sci 120(3): 573–579. 8. Sela Y, Magdassi S, Garti N. 1994. Polymeric surfactants based on polysiloxanes— graft-poly(oxyethylene) for stabilization of multiple emulsions. Colloids Surf A 83(2): 143–150. 9. Sela Y, Magdassi S, Garti N. 1995. Release of markers from the inner water phase of W/O/W emulsions stabilized by silicone-based polymeric surfactants. J Controlled Release 33(1): 1–12. 10. Garti N, Aserin A, Cohen Y. 1994. Mechanistic considerations on the release of electrolytes from multiple emulsions stabilized by BSA and nonionic surfactants. J Controlled Release 29(1–2): 41–51. 11. Garti N, Binyamin H, Aserin A. 1998. Stabilization of water-in-oil emulsion by submicrocrystalline α-form fat particles. J Am Oil Chem Soc 75(12): 1825–1831.
PREFACE
xvii
12. Garti N, Aserin A, Tiunova I, Binyamin H. 1999. Double emulsions of water/oil/ water stabilized by α-form fat microcrystalline particles. J Am Oil Chem Soc 76(3): 383–389. 13. Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2002. Double emulsions stabilized by new molecular recognition hybrids of natural polymers. Polymers Adv Technol 13(10–12): 1019–1031. 14. Garti N, Wicker L. 2005. Pectin methylesterase modified pectin interaction with whey protein isolate and stability of double emulsions. Abstracts of Papers, 229th ACS National Meeting, San Diego, CA, March 13–17, 2005, CELL-119. 15. Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2007. W/O/W double emulsions stabilized with WPI-polysaccharide complexes. Colloids Surf A 294(1–3): 20–32. 16. Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2007. O/W/O double emulsions stabilized with WPI-polysaccharide conjugates. Colloids Surf A 297(1–3): 211–220. 17. Berkovich Y, Aserin A, Garti N. 2004. Practical and mechanistic considerations in the use of W/O/W double emulsions for microencapsulation of fine boron particles. J Dispersion Sci Technol 25(1): 89–99. 18. Lutz R, Aserin A, Wachtel EJ, Ben Shoshan E, Danino D, Garti N. 2007. A study of emulsified microemulsion by SAXS, cryo-TEM, SD-NMR and electrical conductivity. J Dispersion Sci Technol 28(8): forthcoming.
INTRODUCTION TO MULTIPLE EMULSIONS TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS: AN UPDATE
When it was decided to compile a book in honor of Prof. Nissim Garti on the occasion of his sixtieth birthday, choosing an appropriate topic was rather difficult. The diversity of topics investigated by Prof. Garti and his research group in the surface chemistry field is simply amazing. A most conspicuous theme among these topics is the area of multiple emulsions in which Nissim has become a foremost authority. Moreover this attractive subject provides a good prospect for much demand even if the technology is still waiting for a real breakthrough. Since William Seifriz described for the first time in 1925 these intricate liquid systems having ternary, quaternary, or more complex structures that he named multiple emulsions, the literature has been “flooded” every year with tens of new examples demonstrating release patterns and control of active ingredients using these systems. Multiple emulsions, at least in theory, have significant potential in many applications because the internal droplets can serve as an entrapping reservoir for active addenda that can be released by a controlled transport mechanism. Many of the potential applications would be realized in the fields of agriculture, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, and food. In practice, double emulsions consist of large and polydispersed droplets that are thermodynamically unstable, with a strong tendency for coalescence, flocculation, and creaming. Efforts have been made to improve emulsion stability and to control the release of active matter. Almost any possible blend of low-molecular weight emulsifiers, oils, cosolvents, and coemulsifiers have been tested. The nonviscous fluid multiple emulsions were always unstable. Only semisolid multiple emulsions, gelled or thickened systems, have long shelf-life and prolonged stability. Biopolymers, synthetic graft and comb copolymers, and polymerizable emulsifiers impart steric or mechanical stabilization to the multiple emulsions and significant controlled release of additives contained in them. Naturally occurring and synthetic macromolecular surfactants that increase the viscosity of each phase of the multiple emulsion and form complexes with the emulsifiers or the oil can lead to formation of systems that will behave much like microcapsules, microspheres, and mesophasic liquid crystals. This book mostly stresses the recent findings that model the transport phenomena through the different interfaces present in multiple emulsions. It will be useful for each formulator to understand how he can enhance the stability xix
xx
INTRODUCTION TO MULTIPLE EMULSIONS TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
of multiple emulsions. The achievements include (1) new theoretical approaches and modeling to characterize the transport mechanism in multiple emulsions, (2) droplet size reduction and increased shelf-life stability by using polymeric amphiphiles and complex adducts, (3) use of new emulsification techniques to enhance the monodispersibility of the droplets, and (4) potential applications in drug delivery systems where clinical studies have already proved their efficacy. Thus the chapters, which have been contributed by leading authorities in the field, are arranged logically in sections according to their increasing complexity: I—definitions and properties; II—formation and stability; and III— potential applications with a special emphasis on medical and pharmaceutical applications. The first chapter by J. Jiao and D. J. Burgess discusses the thermodynamic instability of multiple emulsions as a result of the excess of free energy caused by the formation of the emulsion droplets. In multiple emulsions consisting of three distinct liquid phases, counteracting the effect of the Laplace pressure by electrolyte addition to the inner dispersed aqueous phase will increase the destabilization of the system owing to osmotic pressure. In addition the authors discuss the effects of both osmotic and Laplace pressure as well as the interfacial rheological properties of these complex systems and their stability. In the second chapter P. Perrin, F. Pringent, and P. Hebraud describe the structure and rheological properties of stable W/O/W multiple emulsions stabilized with polymeric surfactants. By operating confocal microscopy and diffusing wave spectroscopy, they were able to visualize and to study the dynamical properties of the inner dispersed droplets. The next chapter by L. B. Lawson and K. Papadopoulos is an overview of microscopy techniques, including photomicrography, video micrography, capillary microscopy, and electron microscopy, used to study the stability and transport phenomena in multiple emulsions systems. The fourth chapter by M. Kanouni and H. Rosano describes the effect of an oil-insoluble solute on the stability of multiple water-in-oil-in-water emulsions. The authors build a theoretical model based on Laplace and osmotic pressure to interpret the transport phenomena in multiple droplets. Part II focuses on the formation and stabilization of multiple emulsions. R. Lutz and A. Aserin in chapter five develop a new concept to stabilize W/O/W multiple emulsions by using hybrids (complexes) of protein and polysaccharides that were shown to improve the stability of these complex systems and to better control the transport of the entrapped addendum. The next chapter by G. T. Vladisavljevic and R. A. Williams is a comprehensive and systematic review of new techniques of preparation of multiple emulsions, emulsions, and microparticles. The authors envisage the ways to form multiple droplets by using membrane emulsification processes and microchannel and microcapillary devices. They also pay special attention to the preparation of solid microparticles via a double emulsion emulsification method using membrane emulsification and microfluidic devices.
INTRODUCTION TO MULTIPLE EMULSIONS TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
xxi
A. Benichou and A. Aserin in the next chapter present developments in O/W/O multiple emulsions. The chapter reviews the most recent findings about enhancing stability and reducing droplet sizes for prolonged shelf-life stability. The chapter critically reviews the recent literature and brings some new emerging improvements involving stability and release control issues. Potential applications of O/W/O multiple emulsions in food, cosmetics, and drug delivery are discussed and evaluated. The third part of the book is dedicated to medical and pharmaceutical applications of multiple emulsions. First, J. L. Grossiord and M. Stambouli summarize 15 years of intensive research in this field that has been done by the French team. They mainly report the potential applications of these complex systems in drug delivery and detoxification. A. J. Khopade and N. K. Jain review the anticancer activity of surfacemodified fine multiple emulsions. These systems are characterized by nanosized/micellar internal aqueous phase and highly viscous or solidified oil phase dispersed in an aqueous phase. Surface modification permits new applications in anticancer drug delivery and drug targeting. Chapter 10 by S. Higashi describes the application of multiple emulsions to transarterial injection chemotherapy. By using membrane emulsification, particularly stable multiple emulsions were formed. From clinical trials it was established that multiple emulsions may be an alternative to conventional chemotherapy with a reduction in significant side effects. In the next chapter, T. Hino and T. Ohwaki use a two-step pumping emulsification method to prepare lipiodol W/O/W multiple emulsions for transcatheter arterial embolization therapy. Finally, A. Bozkir and O. M. Saka review the use of multiple emulsions as carriers for delivery systems for antigens and vaccines. We would like to thank John Wiley & Sons Publishing, Inc. and particularly Mrs. Anita Lekhwani, senior acquisition editor, and her editorial assistant, Mrs. Rebekah Amos, for accepting this book for publication. We would also like to acknowledge with gratitude the contributions of authors and co-authors who have taken part in this enterprise. It is our hope that the scientific information compiled herein will modestly contribute to a real updated understanding of multiple emulsions and to an improved comprehension of their current and future promising applications. Abraham Aserin, Ph.D.
CONTRIBUTORS
ABRAHAM ASERIN,
Casali Institute of Applied Chemistry, The Institute of Chemistry, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 91904 Jerusalem, Israel
AXEL BENICHOU,
Casali Institute of Applied Chemistry, The Institute of Chemistry, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 91904 Jerusalem, Israel
ASUMAN BOZKIR,
Ankara University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Department of Pharmaceutical Technology, Tandogan, Ankara, Turkey
DIANE J. BURGESS,
School of Pharmacy, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT
06269, USA JEAN-LOUIS GROSSIORD,
Laboratoire de Physique Pharmaceutique UMR CNRS 8612, Faculté de Pharmacie, 5 avenue Jean-Baptiste Clément, F 92296 Châtenay-Malabry, France
P. HÉBRAUD,
P.P.M.D. ESPCI, UMR 7615, 10 rue Vauquelin, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France
SHUSHI HIGASHI,
Miyakonojo Regional Medical Center, Miyakonojo, Miyazaki,
Japan TOMOAKI HINO,
The College of Pharmacy, Kinjo Gakuin University 2-1723 Ohmori, Moriyama, Nagoya 463-8521, Japan
N. K. JAIN,
Pharmaceutics Research Laboratory, Dr. Harisingh Gour University, Sagar-470003 (M.P.), India
JIM JÍAO,
Pharmaceutical R&D, PGRD, Pfizer Inc, Groton, CT 06340, USA
MOUHCINE KANOUNI,
City College of New York, 300 West 135th, New York, NY
10030, USA AJAY J. KHOPADE,
Sun Pharma Advanced Research Centre, Tandalja, Baroda 390020 Gujarat, India
LOUISE BRAUD LAWSON,
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Tulane University Health Sciences Center, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA
RACHEL LUTZ,
Casali Institute of Applied Chemistry, The Institute of Chemistry, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 91904 Jerusalem, Israel xxiii
xxiv
CONTRIBUTORS
TAKAYUKI OHWAKI,
Formulation Research Lab., Eisai Co., Ltd. 1 Kawashimatakehaya-machi, Kakamigahara City Gifu Pref. 501-6195, Japan
KYRIAKOS PAPADOPOULOS,
Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Tulane University, New Orleans, LA 70118, USA
P. PERRIN,
P.P.M.D. ESPCI, UMR 7615, 10 rue Vauquelin, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France
F. PRIGENT,
I.P.C.M.S. GMO, UMR 7504, 23 rue du Loess, 67034 Strasbourg Cedex, France
HENRI ROSANO,
Hostos Community College, Department of Natural Science, Bronx NY, USA
ONGUN MEHMET SAKA,
Ankara University, Faculty of Pharmacy, Department of Pharmaceutical Technology, Tandogan, Ankara, Turkey
MONCEF STAMBOULI,
Laboratoire de Génie des Procédés et Matériaux, Ecole Centrale Paris, France
GORAN T. VLADISAVLJEVIĆ,
Chemical Engineering Department, Loughborough University, Loughborough, Leicestershire, LE11 3TU, United Kingdom
RICHARD A. WILLIAMS,
Institute of Particle Science & Engineering, School of Process, Environmental & Materials Engineering, Clarendon Road, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, United Kingdom
CHAPTER 1
Multiple Emulsion Stability: Pressure Balance and Interfacial Film Strength JIM JIAO and DIANE J. BURGESS
Contents 1.1 Introduction 1 1.2 Multiple Emulsion Pressure Properties 3 1.2.1 Osmotic Pressure 3 1.2.2 Laplace Pressure 5 1.2.3 Balance between Laplace Pressure and Osmotic Pressure 5 1.3 Interfacial Rheology and Stability 7 1.3.1 Interfacial Film and Film Strength 7 1.3.2 Interfacial Tension and Rheology 9 1.3.3 Multiple Emulsions’ Stability and Interfacial Properties 11 1.3.4 Determination of Interfacial Properties 12 1.4 Conclusions 18 References 19
1.1
INTRODUCTION
Multiple emulsions, or emulsions having ternary, quaternary, or more complex structures, have been studied since their first description in 1925 (Seifriz, 1925). The simplest multiple emulsions, sometimes called “double emulsions,” are in fact ternary systems, having either a water-in-oil–in-water or an oil-in-water– in-oil structure, whereby the dispersed droplets contain smaller droplets of a different phase. Multiple emulsions have a number of potential applications in pharmaceutical, cosmetic, food, and separation sciences. The pharmaceutical applications of multiple emulsions include use as vaccine adjuvants (Gresham et al., 1971), red blood cell substitutes (Zheng et al., 1993), lymphatic drugtargeting vehicles (Yoshioka et al., 1982; Omotosho, 1989), prolonged drug Multiple Emulsions: Technology and Applications, Edited by Abraham Aserin Copyright © 2008 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
1
2
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
delivery systems (Elston et al., 1970; Fukushima et al., 1983; Oza and Frank, 1989; Omotosho, 1990; Vaziri and Warburton, 1994), and sorbent reservoirs in drug overdosage treatment (Frankenfeld et al., 1976; Chiang et al., 1978; Moriomoto et al., 1979, 1982). As is the case for simple emulsions, multiple emulsions are thermodynamically unstable due to the excess free energy associated with the surface of the emulsion droplets. The excess surface free energy arises as a result of the cohesive forces between the molecules of an individual liquid being greater than the adhesive forces between the liquids (Banker and Rhodes, 1979; Martin et al., 1993). On dispersion, the interfacial area of the dispersed phase liquid increases considerably compared to that of the continuous phase liquid. Consider the interfacial free energy (1.1) associated with the interface between two immiscible liquids: ∆G = γ∆A,
(1.1)
where G is the interfacial free energy, γ is the interfacial tension, and A is the total interfacial area of the dispersed phase. The increase in interfacial area results in a thermodynamically unstable system that tends to revert back to the original two-phase system to minimize interfacial area. The dispersed droplets therefore strive to come together to reduce the surface area, which can result in eventual destruction of the emulsion. In order to minimize this effect, a third component, a surfactant, is added to the system to improve its stability. Multiple emulsions are complex systems where both water-in-oil (W/O) and oil-in-water (O/W) emulsion types exist simultaneously. In the case of water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions, the oil droplets have smaller water droplets within them, and the oil droplets themselves are dispersed in a continuous water phase. Oil-in-water-in-oil multiple emulsions, on the other hand, consist of tiny oil droplets entrapped within larger water droplets, which in turn are dispersed in a continuous oil phase. These systems thus differ from the familiar water-in-oil or oil-in-water simple two-phase emulsions in that they have three distinct phases (Pal, 1996). Multiple emulsions typically require two or more emulsifiers, one that is predominately hydrophobic stabilizing the primary W/O emulsion and one that is predominately hydrophilic stabilizing the secondary O/W emulsion. The hydrophobic and hydrophilic emulsifiers are added to the oil and continuous aqueous phases, respectively. The two emulsifiers may interact at the external water/oil interface and interfere with each other’s stabilizing performance (Opawale and Burgess, 1998). In addition the osmotic pressure may affect the stability of W/O/W emulsions that is not observed in simple emulsions. If the osmotic pressure is higher in the internal aqueous phase, water will pass into this phase, with the internal droplets swelling until they rupture and release their contents onto the external phase. Transfer of water from the internal to external aqueous phases can cause shrinkage of the internal droplets to occur if a reverse gradient exists; this can also exert a destabilizing influence (Florence and Whitehill, 1985).
MULTIPLE EMULSION PRESSURE PROPERTIES
3
It has been demonstrated that the Laplace pressure works against the stability of simple emulsions (Davis, 1981). For water-in-oil emulsions, the addition of a small quantity of electrolyte to the disperse phase was determined to have a stabilizing effect as a consequence of counteracting the Laplace pressure effect. In W/O/W emulsions, the osmotic pressure generated by the presence of electrolytes in the inner dispersed water phase can cause swelling and ultimately bursting of the inner dispersed droplets, so the impact on multiple emulsion stability is negative. In order to balance these two effects, the concentration of electrolytes has to be high enough to counteract the Laplace pressure but sufficiently low to avoid osmotic effects. The interfaces are the same in multiple emulsion systems as they are in simple emulsions. For example, one liter of a concentrated emulsion can contain up to 5000 m2 of interface (the equivalent to a football pitch). So the interfacial area can be enormous because of the large number of droplets in the system. The large interface presents challenges and requires a quick migration of surfactants in the system to stabilize the dispersed phase(s). The structure and properties of the interface can therefore affect many aspects of the physical properties of emulsion systems. This is the main reason why interfacial characteristics are an important area of study in emulsions and especially multiple-emulsions systems. It has been shown that the stabilities of both multiple and simple emulsions are dependent on emulsifier interfacial film strength, ionic strength, and the presence of various additives. It has been experimentally proven that the interfacial film strength can be used as a means to predict emulsion stability (Burgess, 1997). In this chapter the effects of pressure balance and interfacial rheological properties on the stability of multiple emulsions are discussed. 1.2 1.2.1
MULTIPLE EMULSION PRESSURE PROPERTIES Osmotic Pressure
For W/O/W multiple emulsions the oil phase can be viewed as a membrane separating the inner and outer aqueous phases at the water/oil interface. The thickness of the oil membrane varies with changes in the multiple emulsion composition. Water can pass through the oily membrane from one aqueous phase to the other depending on the osmotic pressure. A higher osmotic pressure in the internal aqueous phase than in the external continuous aqueous phase causes water to pass into the inner water phase, resulting in swelling of the internal droplets before they eventually burst and release their contents. The reserve also applies: if the osmotic pressure is higher in the external aqueous phase than in the inner aqueous phase, water will transfer from the internal phase to the external aqueous phase, causing shrinkage of the internal droplets. If the osmotic difference across the oil layer is extreme, then the passage of water becomes so rapid that almost immediate rupture of the oil droplets occurs with loss of the internal droplets. When the oil layer ruptures,
4
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
the inner aqueous phase in the multiple oil droplets disappears instantaneously, mixing with the external aqueous phase and leaving simple emulsions. The osmotic pressure effect on stability of multiple emulsions has been investigated for almost four decades. W/O/W emulsions, when given in vivo, break down rapidly at the site of injection, with the consequence that no significant delay in response to the entrapped drug is obtained compared to aqueous solutions of the drug (Collings, 1971). It was determined that the premature breakdown of the emulsions in vivo is due to unequal osmotic pressures between the internal and external aqueous phases. The osmotic pressure in the external environment (body fluids) is higher than the internal phase leading to shrinkage of the internal aqueous droplets and/or rupture of the oil layer. Collings (1971) partially solved the problem by incorporating small amounts of sodium chloride in the internal aqueous phase so that this phase was isotonic with the final external phase. Materials other than electrolytes (e.g., proteins, sugars, and drugs) in the aqueous phase can also exert this effect (Adeyeye and Price, 1990). A variety of materials entrapped in the inner phase of multiple emulsions are found to affect osmotic pressures (Florence and Whitehill, 1982; Cuemen and Zatz, 1988; Garti and Aserin, 1996). The middle phase acts as a semipermeable membrane, and consequently osmotic effects become significant as they control multiple emulsion stability and drug release rates both in vitro and in vivo (Collings, 1971; Davis and Burbage, 1978; Matsumoto and Kohda, 1980; Florence and Whitehill, 1981). Sodium chloride and other electrolytes added initially in the inner or outer aqueous phase of W/O/W multiple emulsions can migrate across the oil layer and get into the other aqueous phase through molecular migration (Collins, 1971; Chilamkurti and Rhodes, 1980). The migration of the electrolytes induces changes in osmotic pressure over time and consequently alters multiple emulsion stability. It has been observed that multiple emulsions stabilized by Span 83 and Tween 80 are more stable with sodium salicylate incorporated in the inner aqueous phase than with sodium chloride (Jiao et al., 2002). The difference in the stability of the multiple emulsions observed can be attributed to a faster migration of sodium chloride from the inner aqueous phase to the outer aqueous phase and a consequent more significant imbalance in the osmotic pressure compared to that with sodium salicylate. The transport mechanism of electrolytes through the oily liquid phase has been the subject of many investigations over the past decades. Nevertheless, there remains a lack of a clear understanding as to what and how various formulation parameters of multiple emulsions affect the kinetics and extent of the migration of electrolytes across the middle phase, and thereby influence the osmotic pressure. Partition coefficient, ionization, charge density, molecular weight, and molecular mobility of electrolytes can have some impact on electrolytes’ ability to cross the oil phase. The association of electrolytes with the surfactant, which may form inverted micelles in the oil phase, has also been considered (Chilamkurti and Rhodes, 1980).
MULTIPLE EMULSION PRESSURE PROPERTIES
1.2.2
5
Laplace Pressure
Laplace pressure arises from the interfacial tension of a mixture of two liquids at a curved interface when one liquid is dispersed as droplets into another liquid. The pressure varies inversely with the radius of curvature and takes the following form: ∆P = γ
(
)
1 1 + , r1 r2
(1.2)
where γ is interfacial tension and r is particle radius. For a spherical particle such as a droplet, r1 = r2, the Laplace equation becomes ∆P =
2γ . r
(1.3)
Hence a spherical droplet having a radius r in an emulsion will exert greater pressure on the inner concave interface than on the convex side, as expressed in equation (1.3), and the larger surface tension constitutes a larger force pushing inward into the droplet. Because the relationship of ∆P and r is inversed, a smaller radius will result in a larger inward force. Therefore this relationship has important consequences for any curved surface as r becomes very small and γ relatively significant. When this relationship is applied to the context of an emulsion in which two droplets with the same surface tension are connected, the smaller droplet can be expected to experience a greater pressure, driving its collapse and pushing all of its contents into the larger droplet. When droplet deformation occurs, the Laplace pressure of the deformed droplet will be a function of the radius along the droplet surface. In the extreme cases, as a droplet becomes elongated and cylindrically shaped, the Laplace pressure is reduced to a half that of the original spherical droplet. For multiple emulsions, the Laplace pressure exists in both the inner and multiple droplets. However, because the size of the inner droplets is much smaller, the Laplace pressure on the stability of the inner droplets is much greater than that on the multiple droplets. The Laplace pressure in the process of emulsification is what causes an emulsion to become thermodynamically inefficient. For an emulsion to form the small, highly curved droplets, extra energy is required to overcome the large pressure that exists in the droplets. 1.2.3
Balance between Laplace Pressure and Osmotic Pressure
Consider a water droplet of radius r containing a certain amount of salt in a solvent (oil phase) in equilibrium at the water/oil flat interface. The film around this water droplet can be assumed (for simplicity) to be impermeable
6
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
to water and capable of preventing coalescence. The Laplace pressure 2γ/r of a droplet containing a salt, dispersed in the solvent, will cause shrinkage of the droplet. However, the osmotic pressure will cause swelling of the droplet, leading to a counterbalanced water diffusion. In the ideal case the osmotic pressure is given by
∏ osm = mRT = mo
( )
3
ro RT , r
(1.4)
where m is the molar concentration of salt and mo refers to the original droplet. The difference between the Laplace pressure and the osmotic pressure can be defined as excess pressure ∆P: ∆P =
( )
r 2γ − mo o RT . r r 3
(1.5)
The condition that must be fulfilled in order to reach the equilibrium is
( ) 1r RT = 0.
2γ d(∆P ) r = − 2 + 3mo o dr r r
3
(1.6)
In words, as r decreases, the excess pressure ∆P decreases and equilibrium is reached. Thus 2 γ = 3mRT.
(1.7)
Equation (1.7) was proposed by Walstra (1996). Walstra’s equation shows that an optimal salt concentration in the internal phase exists between the Laplace and osmotic pressures exerted on the inner aqueous droplets. Stability of W/O/W multiple emulsion containing Span 80 and Tween 80 was evaluated with respect to sodium chloride and sodium salicylate concentrations in the inner water phase (Jiao and Burgess, 2002). In this study we observed that the multiple emulsion droplets deformed and there was coalescence of the inner aqueous droplets as we applied an external force (i.e., a microscopic coverslip) to multiple emulsion samples on a microscope slide. Under certain conditions (e.g., lipophilic surfactant concentration and internal phase osmotic pressure) the destabilized multiple emulsions formed unique metastable structures that had a “dimpled” appearance. The formation of these metastable structures correlated with the real time instability of the W/O/W multiple emulsions investigated. Our study revealed that emulsions with a salt concentrations closer to the optimal value calculated by using (1.7) had maximum stability. The treatment above is only good for a simplified emulsion system where the osmotic and Laplace pressures are the major forces controlling droplet
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY
7
stability. There are other factors such as viscosity that influence the dynamics of droplet growth. We take these factors into consideration using the general Navier-Stokes equation to mathematically describe droplet expansion: ρ
( ∂∂vt + (v •∇)v) − ∇p(γ , t) + η∆v,
div v, − 0,
(1.8)
where p(γ, t) is the total pressure at any given point on the droplet surface. The influence of any other factors can be entered into the equation by way of boundary conditions (Mikhin, Stepanow, and Byakov 2003).
1.3 1.3.1
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY Interfacial Film and Film Strength
Multiple emulsions require surfactants to stabilize both the internal aqueous droplets and the external multiple droplets. The added surfactants adsorb at the water/oil interfaces, reducing interfacial tension and forming an interfacial film that resists droplet coalescence following droplet contact. It has been shown that the stronger this film is, the more stable are the emulsions, and that the interfacial film plays a more crucial role than the reduction of interfacial tension in maintaining long-term emulsion stability to coalescence (Burgess, 1993). The strength of this film, which can be a monolayer, a multilayer, or a collection of small particles adsorbed at the interface, depends on the structure and conformation of surfactant or emulsifier molecules at the interface (Swarbrick, 1997). The structure and conformation can be affected by formulation variables, including surfactant or emulsifier type and concentration, other additives or levels, storage temperature, ionic strength, and pH. For the film to be an effective barrier, it must remain intact when sandwiched between two droplets. If broken, the film has the capacity to reform rapidly. So the film must possess a certain degree of surface elasticity. It has been shown that interfacial elasticity correlates well with interfacial film strength and can be used to predict the stability of multiple emulsions (Opawale and Burgess, 1997). Knowing the relationship between interfacial properties and emulsion stability enables one to rationally approach the research and development of more stable multiple emulsion systems. The only way significant amounts of immiscible fluids can be mixed together is if the interfacial layer surrounding the dispersed droplets is occupied by an adsorbed layer of molecules that keep the droplets from coalescing. Figure 1.1 shows the importance of the interfacial layer in emulsion systems for the two main classes of surface-active molecules, surfactants and proteins, that stabilize them. Low molecular weight surfactants, lipids, and emulsifiers self-assemble at interfaces with the appropriate part of the molecule associating with the appropriate hydrophilic or hydrophobic phases. Proteins, on the other hand,
8
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Surfactant Protein
Figure 1.1 Two classes of surface-active materials in stabilizing emulsions: Surfactant and protein.
Surfactants
Proteins
High mobility
Strong interaction
Figure 1.2
Stability mechanism for surfactants and proteins.
are much larger and more complex macromolecules. Proteins will adsorb at an interface but then proceed to unfold, exposing their hydrophobic groups to the hydrophobic phase. Figure 1.2 shows how these two very different types of molecules stabilize emulsion systems. Surfactants rely on rapid diffusion to dissipate any disturbances to the interface. This rapid motion will drag fluid along into the interlamellar space between droplets, keeping them separated. This activity is known as the Gibbs-Marangoni mechanism. On the other hand, proteins
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY
9
unfold, develop strong interactions with neighboring protein molecules, and effectively form a gel at the interface. The viscoelastic gel can stretch and deform to absorb deformations in the interface, and hence stabilize against coalescence. The main difference between interfaces stabilized by proteins and surfactants is the viscoelasticity of the interface. Therefore interfacial rheology is a useful probe for comparing these two types of interfaces. 1.3.2
Interfacial Tension and Rheology
The interfacial properties exhibited by emulsifier systems are interfacial rheology, tension, and charge (Burgess and Yoon, 1995; Burgess and Sahin, 1997). Interfacial rheology measures the emulsifier film viscosity and/or elasticity and hence the mechanical barrier to droplet coalescence. Interfacial tension is related to emulsion stability through the Gibbs equation (Eq. 1.1). The interfacial charge on emulsion droplets gives a direct measurement of the electrostatic barrier to coalescence. Interfacial rheology, tension, and charge have been used as predictors of emulsion stability (Burgess and Yoon, 1995; Burgess and Sahin, 1997). Cumper and Alexander (1950), Srivastava (1964), and Burgess (1998) have shown that the interfacial rheology of protein films correlates with O/W emulsion stability. Interfacial Tension Lowering of interfacial tension is one way in which the increased surface free energy associated with the formation of droplets can be reduced. Since surfactant molecules continuously adsorb at the interface, interfacial tension will decrease as a function of time until equilibrium is achieved. Reduction of interfacial tension by the addition of a surfactant can serve to preserve the surface area generated during the dispersion process, thus preventing phase separation. Low interfacial tension enhances the formation of smaller emulsion droplets with narrower size distributions and greater kinetic stability (Burgess and Yoon, 1995). The major requirement of a potential surfactant or emulsifier is that it readily form an interfacial film. A rapid decrease in interfacial tension indicates high interfacial activity and a tendency for fast reformation of the surfactant film after rupture. Rapid reformation of a new interfacial film results in increased resistance to droplet coalescence, and hence emulsion stability is improved (Myers, 1988). The dynamic process of adsorption of emulsifiers and the equilibrium state of the interfacial film can be measured by the change in interfacial tension as a function of time. Dynamic interfacial tension techniques exist that measure without disturbing the interface. Various such techniques to measure interfacial tension have been reported in the literature (Addison and Hutchinson, 1949; Padday and Russel, 1960). The Wilhelmy plate technique is preferred over other techniques because the values obtained are more accurate than those obtained using other techniques such as the capillary rise or du Nouy ring methods (Padday and Russel, 1960). In the latter two methods, the long equilibration time (3–60 hours) and difficulties in accurately positioning the
10
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
ring can introduce errors that are not an issue with the Wihelmy plate method. Interfacial Rheology It has been reported that for long-term emulsion stability to coalescence and phase separation, the strength of the interfacial film is more important than reduction in interfacial tension (Myers, 1988; Swarbrick, 1990; Martin, 1993). Interfacial rheology is the study of the mechanical and flow properties of adsorbed layers at fluid interfaces, and it has been used to quantify film strength (Murray and Dickinson, 1996; Opawale and Burgess, 1998). Interfacial film strength characteristics can be described in terms of viscous (liquid-like) or elastic (solid-like) properties (Warburton, 1993). In an emulsion stabilized with surfactant-type emulsifiers forming monomolecular films, coalescence is opposed by the elasticity and cohesiveness of the films sandwiched between the two droplets. Multilayers confer high resistance of emulsions to coalescence, as arises from the mechanical strength of layering (Myers, 1988). For films to be efficient barriers, they must not thin out and rupture when sandwiched between the two droplets. The film must therefore possess enough elasticity to assist in preserving its integrity (Myers, 1988). There are two main methods for measuring the interfacial rheological properties of adsorbed layers. They can be either dilational or shear methods. Figure 1.3 shows the principle underlying each method, without going into too much practical detail. Interfacial dilational rheology is determined by measuring the change in interfacial tension due to a specific change in interfacial area. This is a measure of the resistance to compression and expansion of the adsorbed layer. Interfacial shear rheology, on the other hand, can be a direct measure of the mechanical strength of the adsorbed layer. Here the interface is subject to a shear stress, and the measured strain is recorded. When an element of area covered with soluble material is subject to surface contraction, some of the material escapes into the bulk phase and returns when the interface is expanded in interfacial dilational rheology (Murray and Compress
Dilate
Shear
(a)
(b)
Figure 1.3 Interfacial dilational (a) and interfacial shear (b) rheology.
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY
11
Dickinson, 1996). In such experiments the interpretation of interfacial dilational rheology needs to take into account the dilation processes. However, in interfacial shear rheology, a defined interfacial area is sheared to a first-order approximation and is therefore not altered during the shearing process (Sheriff and Warburton, 1975). The interfacial pressure remains constant during the experiment and the material does not diffuse out of or into the interface as a result of rheological measurements. Consequently interfacial shear experiments are less destructive than interfacial dilational experiments, and measurements can provide information on the intramolecular and intermolecular forces acting at the interface (Warburton, 1993). The kinetics of interfacial film formation can also be studied using this technique. Interfacial shear measurements can be performed by several methods: continuous flow, creep compliance, stress relaxation, and oscillation (Warburton, 1993). It is not possible to study film kinetics, and intra- and intermolecular interactions among interfacial molecules, using interfacial dilational techniques, since the interfacial film is continuously destroyed. Using a MK2 surface oscillatory ring rheometer, which operates in the interfacial shear mode, Opawale and Burgess (1998) were able to determine the kinetics of interfacial film formation of Spans (20, 80, 83, and 85) under various conditions (different temperatures, Span concentrations, salts, and macromolecules such as bovine serum albumin and cholesterol). 1.3.3
Multiple Emulsions’ Stability and Interfacial Properties
As shown in Figure 1.2, emulsions can be stabilized by surfactants or emulsifiers employing the Gibbs-Marangoni mechanism, which has a very low interfacial viscoelastic modulus, or by protein-like molecules, which employ a viscoelastic mechanism with a naturally high viscoelastic modulus. Both mechanisms result in stable systems individually, but in many commercial emulsions there is often a mixture of these two molecule types. Figure 1.4 shows an interface stabilized by a mixture of protein and surfactant type of molecules. The surfactants disrupt the strong interactions developed between neighboring protein molecules, effectively weakening the interface. Because the surfactants rely on rapid surface migration, they are constrained by the presence of protein molecules still at the interface. If the protein component is still in the form of a two-dimensional network, effectively caging the surfactant molecules, it can seriously hamper their motion. The net effect is reduced stabilization of each component, and hence the emulsion is reduced in stability. In principle, it should then be possible to predict the stability of an emulsion system from the interfacial rheology of the continuous phase. Figure 1.5 shows the relative stability to coalescence of an emulsion system stabilized by a protein (beta-lactoglobulin) with increased concentrations of non-ionic surfactant (Tween 20). In this case the presence of surfactants has entirely destabilized the protein emulsion.
12
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Weak interactions and reduced mobility
Figure 1.4 Mixed protein and surfactant interfaces: Weak protein interactions and restricted diffusion of surfactants result in reduced stability and probable film rupture.
1.1
1
Emulsion-1 Emulsion-2
Relative stability
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4 0
1
2
3
4
5
Molar ratio (Tween 20: beta-lactoglobulin)
Figure 1.5 Coalescence stability of protein-stabilized emulsions as a function of surfactant (Tween 20) concentration.
1.3.4
Determination of Interfacial Properties
As was mentioned earlier, there are two basic methods of measuring interfacial rheology: dilational and shear (Murray and Dickinson, 1996). The practical and theoretical aspects underlying these measuring methods are briefly discussed here.
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY
13
Interfacial Dilational Rheology Dilational rheology, as the name suggests, is a method that deals with the expansion and compression of the interface. Simply put, it is a mechanical system that is constructed to allow the interface to be expanded and contracted, usually in a sinusoidal manner, while the interfacial tension is simultaneously monitored. The first such method used a standard Langmuir trough, as shown in Figure 1.6. Barriers normal to the surface are used to gradually compress or expand the interface to control the surface concentration of insoluble monolayers. A small modification to this method allows the barriers to be oscillated sinusoidally, producing small changes in the surface area. Assume that there is no exchange of surfactant occurs between the surface and the bulk, the compression/expansion cycle will cause a change in the surface tension. As the surface is compressed, the effective surface concentration increases, and the interfacial tension will go down. Conversely, expanding the surface will result in an increase in the surface tension. The relationship between surface area and surface tension is shown in Figure 1.7. The surface dilational modulus (|E|) is given as E = A⋅
dγ . dA
(1.9)
The surface dilational modulus is then split into the elastic (E′) and viscous (E″) components. If the surface is purely elastic, then the phase lag (θ) will be zero; if it is viscous, then θ = 90. In practice, the behavior is usually intermediate between the two extremes, and the two components can be calculated as follows: Tensiometer
γ0
Movable barrier
γ
Stationary barrier
Aqueous phase Figure 1.6 Use of a Langmuir trough fitted with oscillating barriers to change the surface area A while simultaneously monitoring surface tension.
14
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
θ
Area
Surface tension
A, γ
dγ
dA
Time Figure 1.7 Time-dependent relationship between area and surface tension during a typical dilational rheology experiment. 14 12
dγ = E AdA
10 8
dγ 6 Nonlinear
4
Linear
2 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
dA Figure 1.8 Relationship between dγ and dA, showing how dγ becomes nonlinear as dA is increased and the surface is stretched beyond its elastic limit.
E ′ = E cos θ, E ′′ = E sin θ.
(1.10)
Care must be taken to ensure that the surface is not overcompressed, or the interfacial layer may collapse. Figure 1.8 shows the relationship between dγ and dA in a typical experiment. The experiments should ideally be conducted
Interfacial shear moduli (mN·m-1)
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY
15
80
P 60
P+S
40
P 20
P+S 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Shear stress (mN·m-1) Figure 1.9 Interfacial shear moduli (elastic = solid lines; viscous = dotted lines) for protein alone (P) and protein + surfactant (P + S) at the oil/water interface.
in the linear region, but the length of the linear region does give information about the resistance of the surface to compression and collapse, the same as the stress dependent data shown in Figure 1.9. A dilational method that has attracted much attention over recent years is the pendant drop method. This method has proved useful for oil/water interfacial rheology. The principle is exactly the same as for standard surface dilational rheology. The interfacial tension is calculated by measuring the size and shape of a liquid drop suspended from a capillary in a less dense fluid. The interfacial area is changed by increasing or decreasing the size of the drop by controlling the liquid flow through the capillary. Changes in the interfacial area and interfacial dilational modules can be calculated. This technique is useful for small sample volumes, for it avoids the hydrodynamic problems encountered when trying to expand/compress the oil/water interface. A limitation of the dilational method is that it is an indirect method of measurement. The rheological information is inferred from interfacial tension values. The interfacial tension can change through adsorption and desorption effects that are stimulated by the expansion and compression of the interface. For example, for a freely soluble surfactant at high concentrations, there will be a rapid rate of exchange between the surface and the bulk, so at low dilation frequencies, lower than the exchange rate, no changes in surface tension will be detected. At lower concentration, with a much lower exchange rate, changes in surface tension will be measured, but these will be dependent on the exchange rate of the surfactant, not the surface rheological properties: The way to solve this problem is to measure at high frequencies using the surface capillary wave technique. Figure 1.10 shows a schematic of the experimental setup. Capillary waves on the surface of a solution can be induced by thermal or mechanical agitation at high frequencies. The presence of a wave on a surface corresponds to an increase in surface area, the shape of the wave is
16
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Wave transducer
Detector
Laser Figure 1.10 Schematic setup for capillary wave-type experiment. The wave transducer excites surface waves. The laser diffraction and detector measure damping of the waves.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 1.11 Typical geometries for measuring interfacial shear rheology: (a) Knife edge for air/water interface; (b) bicone for oil/water interface; (c) Du Nouy ring for sensitive measurements.
monitored by laser diffraction, and the amplitude/damping of the wave as it propagates along the surface is determined by the elastic and viscous moduli of the surface of the solution. The measurement is difficult to do, and the errors are quite large. Nevertheless, the high-frequency regime required for surfactant systems can in this way be accessed. Interfacial Shear Rheology In contrast to the dilational technique, the surface shear methods are direct determinations of the mechanical properties of an interface. The simplest approach is a two-dimensional adaptation of standard three-dimensional viscoelastic measurements performed on a standard rheometer. The only difference is the sensitivity and the geometry. Figure 1.11 shows the geometries commonly used for oil-water interfaces. In interfacial shear rheology, shear stress is applied as a tangential force (F) acting along the interface. Shear stress can be calculated using the equation below,
INTERFACIAL RHEOLOGY AND STABILITY
pxy = Gexy ,
17
(1.11)
where pxy is the interfacial shear stress. The Du Nouy ring, commonly used for measuring interfacial tension, can be specifically designed to measure the surface shear viscoelasticity through a method developed by Sherriff and Warburton. The light construction of this geometry makes it particulary sensitive to interfaces with very low rheological properties. The simplest approach is to apply a standard shear rate, that is, to rotate the geometry at constant speed and measure the induced stress. The geometry is normally held by a torsion wire of known torsion strength, and the rotation between the top and the bottom of the wire allows the stress to be calculated. An variation on this approach is to use the canal viscometer approach. An interface is held between two concentrically circular, rigid walls, and the floor of the vessel is rotated to impart motion of the fluid below the interface. The transmission of motion to the interface from the bulk is measured by following the motion of small Teflon particles at the interface. Although this is a timeconsuming measurement, the rheological properties of the bulk fluid can easily be accounted for. However sensitive the technique, continuous rotation will result in disruption of structures created at the interface. A better approach is to use an oscillatory motion, which, if small enough, should not break down any structures formed at the interface. An oscillating stress with known amplitude is applied, and the resultant strain is measured. The stress and strain relationships are shown in Figure 1.12. The total viscoelastic modulus G* is given as G* =
θ
σ0 , γ0
(1.12)
Stress σ
Amplitude
Strain γ
γ0 Time
σ0
Figure 1.12 Stress–strain relationship for a typical oscillatory surface shear viscoelasticity measurement.
18
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
where σ and γ are the amplitudes of the stress and the strain, respectively (γ should not be confused with the surface tension). The stresses and strains are the effective two-dimensional equivalents of the three-dimensional standard viscosity measurements. So the stress here is the applied force per unit distance, and the strain is the distance moved relative to the gap between the geometry and the outer vessel. Similar to the dilational method, if the phase lag is 0 and 90°, the G* is either totally elastic or viscous, respectively. The elastic (G′) and viscous (G″) moduli can be calculated as follows: G ′ = G* cos θ, G ′′ = G* sin θ
(1.13)
The Sherriff and Warburton is a little more complex. A schematic diagram of the apparatus simplifies the complex electronics involved. Basically a galvanometer is fed with a sinusoidal input voltage to oscillate the ring, imparting a known stress to the interface; then a proximity probe is used to measure the strain. The electronics exploit mechanical resonance so that the sensitivity of the interface can be maximized. The mechanical or rheological properties of the interface affect the resonance of the ring as the electronic feedback system keeps the whole system in resonance. The values of the feedback signals are used to calculate the viscous and elastic components of the interfacial viscoelasticity. The light weight nature of this setup allows assessment of very fragile interfaces. The frequency is also not just limited to the resonant frequency; the feedback loops can be used to shift the measurement frequency over a wide range of values. In summary, measurement of interfacial rheology can take one of two approaches, either dilational or shear. The choice of approach will depend on its suitability to particular applications. The most accurate and reproducible results tend to come from methods that utilize small, reversible applied stresses and strains, thus minimizing any disruption or damage to the interfacial layer.
1.4
CONCLUSIONS
Numerous applications of multiple emulsions in various fields have been reported. More applications need to be realized if multiple emulsions stability is to be fully understood and approaches to stabilize multiple emulsions fully rationalized. The stability of multiple emulsions is influenced by numerous formulation and process variables. As demonstrated in this chapter, long-term multiple emulsion stability is dependent on the osmotic and Laplace pressures of the inner droplets as well as on the pressure balance between them described by the Walstra equation. Stability also equally, in some cases even more, depends on the strength of the interfacial film formed on the interface of droplets of multiple emulsions. This property can be characterized by interfacial rheology.
REFERENCES
19
REFERENCES Annianson EAG, Wall SN. 1974. Kinetics of step-wise micelle association. J Phys Chem 78(10): 1024–1030. Aronson MP, Petko MF. 1993. Highly concentrated water-in-oil emulsions: Influence of electrolyte on their properties and stability. J Colloid Interface Sci 159(1): 134–149. Abraham SM, Vieth RF, Burgess DJ. 1996. Novel technology for the preparation of sterile alginate-poly-lysine microcapsules in a bioreactor. Pharm Dev Tech 1(1): 63–68. Addison CC, Hutchinson SK. 1949. The properties of freshly forced surface. Part XI. Factors influencing surface activity and adsorption rates in aqueous-alcohol solutions. J Chem Soc 61: 3387–3395. Adeyeye CM, Price JC. 1990. Effect of dextrose in the internal aqueous phase on formation and stability of W/O/W multiple emulsions. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 16(6): 1053–1071. Adeyeye CM, Price JC. 1991. Effect of non-ionic surfactant concentration and type on the formation and stability W/O/W multiple emulsions: microscopic and conductometric evaluations. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 17(5): 725–736. Attwood D, Florence AT. 1983. Surfactant system: The Chemistry, Pharmacy and Biology. London: Chapman and Hall, pp 469–650. Banwan AA, Abumalooh A, Sallam E, Abukalaf A, Jawan O. 1985. A sustained release drug delivery system using calcium alginate beads. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 11(2): 239–256. Banker GS, Rhodes T. 1979. Modern Pharmaceutics. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 329–359. Becher P. 1965. In: Emulsions: Theory and Practice, 2nd ed. New York: Reinhold, p 2. Benoy CH, Elson LA, Schneider R. 1972. Multiple emulsions, a suitable vehicle to provide sustained release of cancer chemotherapeutic agents. Br J Pharmacol 45(1): 135–136. Binks BP, Clint JH, Fletcher PDI, Rippon S. 1998. Kinetics of swelling of oil-in-water emulsions. Langmuir 14: 5402. Binks BP, Clint JH, Fletcher PDI, Rippon S. 1999. Kinetics of swelling of oil-in-water emulsion stabilized by different surfactants. Langmuir 15: 4495. Biswas B, Haydon DA. 1962. The coalescence of droplets stabilized by viscoelastic adsorbed films. Kolloid Z 185: 31. Blake JR. 1996. Cavitation and bubble dynamics. J Fluid Mech 316: 376–377. Bodmeiser R, Chen H, Paeratakul O. 1989. A novel approach to the oral delivery of micro or nanoparticles. Pharm Res 6(5): 413–417. Boyd J, Parkinson C, Sherman P. 1972. Factors affecting emulsion stability and HLB concept. J Colloid Interface Sci 41(2): 359–370. Brodin AF, Kavaliunas DR, Frank SG. 1978. Prolonged drug release from multiple emulsions. Acta Pharm Suec 15: 1–10. Brodin AF. 1978. Drug release from oil-water-oil (O/W/O) multiple emulsion systems. Acta Pharm Suec 15: 111–113.
20
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Bungenberg de Jong MG. 1949. In: Colloid Science. II. Reversible Systems, Kruyt GR, eds. New York: Elsevier, pp 335–432. Burbage AS, Davis SS. 1979. The characterization of multiple (W/O/W) emulsions using a radiotracer technique. J Pharm Pharmacol 31: 6. Burgess DJ, Yoon JK. 1993. Interfacial tension studies on surfactant systems at the aqueous/perfluorocarbon interface. Colloid Surf B 1: 283–293. Burgess DJ. 1993. In: Biotechnology and Pharmacy, Pezzuto JM, Johnson ME, Manasse HR, eds. New York: Chapman and Hall, p 116. Burgess DJ, Yoon JK. 1995. Influence of interfacial properties on perfluorocarbon/ aqueous emulsion stability. Colloids Surf 4: 297–308. Burgess DJ, Sahin NO. 1994. Interfacial rheology of ß-casein solution. In: Structure and Flow in Surfactant Solutions, Herb CA, Prud’homme RK, eds. ACS Symp Ser, Washington, DC: ACS, pp 380–393. Burgess DJ, Sahin NO. 1997. Influence of protein emulsifier interfacial properties on oil-in-water emulsion stability. Pharm Dev Tech 3: 21–32. Buscall R, Davis SS, Potts DC. 1979. The effect of long-chain alkanes on the stability of oil-in-water emulsions: the significance of Ostwald ripening. Colloid Polym Sci 257: 636. Chanamai R, Horn G, McClements DJ. 2002. Influence of oil polarity on droplet growth in oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by a weekly adsorbing biopolymer or a nonionic surfactant. J Colloid Interface Sci 247: 167. Chiang C, Fuller GC, Frankenfeld JW, Rhodes CT. 1978. Potential pf liquid membranes for drug overdosage treatment: In vitro studies. J Pharm Sci 67: 63–66. Chilamkurti RN, Rhodes CT. 1990. Transport across liquid membranes: effect of molecular structure. J Appl Biochem 2: 17–24. Collings AJ. 1971. Improvements in or relating to sustained release preparations, British Patent 1,235,667. Criddle DW, Meager Jr AL. 1955. Viscosity and elasticity of oil surface and oil-water interfaces. J Appl Phys 26: 838–842. Csoka I, Eros I. 1997. Stability of multiple emulsions I. Determination of factors influencing multiple drop breakdown. Int J Pharm 156: 119–123. Cueman GH, Zatz JL. 1988. Multiple emulsions. In: Controlled Release Systems: Fabrication Technology, Vol. 2, Hsieh DS, ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press, pp 23–40. Dalgleish D. 1993. Food emulsions. In: Emulsions and Emulsion Stability, Sjoblom J, eds. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 287–325. Davies CK, Nash P, Stevens RN. 1980. Acta Metall 28: 179. Davis SS. 1976. The emulsion-obsolete dosage form or novel drug delivery system and therapeutic agent? J Clin Pharm 1: 11–27. Davis SS, Burbage AS. 1977. Electron micrography of water-in-oil-in-water emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 62(2): 361–363. Davis SS, Burbage AS. 1978. The particle size analysis of multiple emulsions (waterin-oil-in-water). In: Particle Size Analysis, Groves MJ, eds. London: Heyden, pp 395–410. Davis SS, Round HP, Purewal TS. 1981. Ostwald ripening and the stability of emulsion systems: An explanation for the effect of an added third component. J Colloid Interface Sci 80: 508.
REFERENCES
21
Davis SS, Walker I. 1983. Measurement of the yield of multiple droplets by a fluorescent tracer technique. Int J Pharm 17: 203–213. De Luca M, Grossiord JL, Medard JM, Vaution C. 1990. A stable W/O/W multiple emulsion. Cosmet Toilet 105(11): 65–69. Dickinson E, Owusu RK, Tan S, Williams A. 1993. Oil-soluble surfactants have little effect on competitive adsorption of a-lactalbulmin and ß-lactoglobulin in emulsions. J Food Sci 58(2): 295–298. Dickinson E, Evison J, Owusu RK. 1991. Preparation of fine protein-stabilized waterin-oil-water emulsions. Food Hydrocolloids 5: 481–485. Dickinson E, Hong ST. 1994. Surface coverage of ß-lactoglobulin at the oil-water interfaces: Influence of protein heat treatment and various emulsifiers. J Agric Food Chem 42: 1602–1606. Ducoulombier D, Zhou H, Boned C, Peyreleasse J, Saint-Guirons H, Xans P. 1986. Condensed phases and macromolecules—pressure (1–1000 bars) and temperature (20–100°C) dependence of the viscosity of liquid hydrocarbons. J Phys Chem 90: 1692. Economou IG, Heidman JL, Tsonopoulos C. 1997. Mutual solubilities of hydrocarbons and water: III. 1-hexene, 1-octene, C10-C12 hydrocarbons. AIChE J 43: 535. Elbary AA, Nour SA, Ibrahim I. 1990. Physical stability and rheological properties of W/O/W emulsions as a function of electrolytes. Pharm Indus 52(3): 357–363. Elson LA, Mitchley BCV, Collings AJ, Schneider R. 1970. Chemotherapeutic effect of a water-in-oil-in-water of methotrexate on the mouse L1210 leukaemia, Rev Europ Etudes Clin Biol 15: 87–90. Engel RH, Riggi SJ, Fahrenbach MJ. 1968. Insulin: Interstinal absorption as water-inoil-in-water emulsions. Nature 129: 856–857. Eros I, Balazs J, Peter I, Tasci M. 1990. Investigation of drug containing multiphase emulsions. Pharmazie 45: 419–422. Estrada-Baltazar A, Alvarado JF, Iglesias-Silva G. 1998. Experimental liquid viscosity of decane and octane + decane from 298.15 K to 373.15 K and up to 25 Mpa. J Chem Eng Data 43: 441. Ferreira LAM, Seiller M, Grossiord JL, Marty JP, Wepierre J. 1994. Vehicle influence on in vitro release of metronidazole: Role of W/O/W multiple emulsion. Int J Pharm 109: 251–259. Ferreira LAM, Doucet J, Seiller M, Grossiord JL, Marty JP. 1995. In vitro percutaneous absorption of metronidazole and glucose: comparison of O/W, W/O/W and W/O systems. Int J Pharm 121: 169–179. Ficheux MF, Bonakder L, Leal-Calderon F, Bibette J. 1998. Some stability criteria for double emulsions. Langmuir 14: 2702–2706. Florence AT, Whitehill D. 1985. Stability and stabilization of water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions. ACS Symp Ser 272 (Macro- and Microemulsions): 359–380. Florence AT, Law TK, Whateley TL. 1985. Nonaqueous foam structures form osmotically swollen W/O/W emulsion droplets. J Colloid Interface Sci 107(2): 584–588. Florence AT, Rogers JA. 1971. Emulsion stabilization by nonionic surfactants: Experiment and theory. J Pharm Pharmacol 23: 153–169. Florence AT, Whitehill D. 1982. Stabilization of water/oil/water multiple emulsions by polymerization of the aqueous phase. J Pharm Pharmacol 34: 687–691.
22
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Florence AT, Whitehill D. 1982. The formulation and stability of multiple emulsions. Int J Pharm 11: 277–308. Frankenfeld JW, Fuller GC, Rhodes CT. 1976. Potential use of liquid membranes for emergency treatment of drug overdose. Drug Dev Commun 2(4–5): 405– 419. Fukushima S, Juni K, Nakano M. 1983. Preparation of and drug release from W/O/W type double emulsion containing anticancer agents. Chem Pharm Bull 31(11): 4048–4056. Garti N, Aserin A. 1996. Emulsions and microemulsions. In: Drugs and the Pharmaceutical Sciences, Vol. 73, Benita S, ed. Dekker, New York, NY. Garti N, Aserin A, Cohen Y. 1994. Mechanistic considerations on the release of electrolytes form multiple emulsions stabilized by BSA and nonionic surfactants. J Controlled Release 29: 41–51. Geiger S, Jager-Lezer N, Tokgoz S, Seiller M, Grossiord JL. 1999. Characterization of the mechanical properties of a water/oil/water multiple emulsion oily membrane by a micropipette aspiration technique. Colloids Surf A 157: 325–332. Ghaicha L, Leblanc R. 1995. Monolayers of mixed surfactants at the oil-water interface, hydrophobic interactions, and stability of water-in-oil emulsions. Langmuir 11: 585–590. Gresham PA, Barrett M, Smith SV, Schneider R. 1971. Use of a sustained release multiple emulsion to extend the period of radioprotection conferred by cysteamine. Nature 234: 149–150. Griffin WC. 1949. Classification of surface-active agents by HLB. J Soc Cosmet Chem 11: 311–326. Herbert WJ. 1965. Multiple emulsion: A new form of mineral oil antigen adjuvant. Lancet 2: 771. Higuchi WI, Misra J. 1962. Physical degradation of emulsions via the molecular diffusion route and the possible prevention thereof. J Pharm Sci 51: 459. Hou W, Papadopoulos KD. 1997. W1/O/W2 and O1/W/O2 globules stabilized with Span 80 and Tween 80. Colloids Surf A 125: 181–187. Hunter RJ. 1986. Foundations of Colloid Science, Vol. 2. New York: Oxford University Press. Jiao J, Rhodes DG, Burgess DJ. 2002. Multiple emulsion stability: Pressure balance and interfacial film strength. J Colloid Interface Sci 250: 444–450. Jiao J, Burgess DJ. 2003. Rheology and stability of W/O/W multiple emulsions containing Span 83 and Tween 80. AAPS Pharm Sci 5(1): 62–73. Jiao J, Burgess DJ. 2003. Ostwald ripening of water-in-hydrocarbon emulsions stabilized by non-ionic surfactant Span 83. J Colloid Interface Sci 264: 509–516. Jiao J, Burgess DJ. 2005. Characterization and analysis of dispersed systems. In: Drugs and the Pharmaceutical Sciences, Vol. 149: Injectable Dispersed Systems—Formulation, Processing, and Performance, Burgess DJ, ed. Boca Raton: Taylor and Francis Group, pp 77–124. Kabalnov AS, Perrzov AV, Shchukin ED. 1987. Ostwald ripening in emulsions 1. Direct observation of Ostwald ripening in emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 118: 590– 597.
REFERENCES
23
Kabalnov AS, Makarov KN, Perrzov AV, Shchukin ED. 1990. Ostwald ripening in emulsions 2. Ostwald ripening in hydrocarbon emulsions: Experimental verification of equation for absolute rates. J Colloid Interface Sci 138: 98–104. Kabalnov AS, Shchukin ED. 1992. Ostwald ripening theory: Applications to fluorocarbon emulsion stability. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 38: 69–97. Kabalnov AS. 1994. Can micelles mediate a mass transfer between oil droplets? Langmuir 10: 680. Kavaliunas DR, Frank SG. 1978. Liquid crystal stabilization of multiple emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 66: 586–588. Kawashima Y, Hino T, Takeuchi H, Niwa T. 1992. Stabilization of water/oil/water multiple emulsion with hypertonic inner aqueous phase. Chem Pharm Bull 40(5): 1240–1246. Kita Y, Matsumoto S, Yonezawa D. 1977. Viscometric method for estimating the stability of W/O/W type multiple-phase emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 62: 87–94. Kitchener JA, Mussellwhite PR. 1968. The Theory of Stability of Emulsions, Sherman P, ed. London: Academic Press, pp 77–125. Kover T, Csoka I, Eros I. 1997. Formation and stability of multiple phase (W/O/W) emulsions. Part I: Investigation of the primary interface. Pharmazie 52: 166–167. Kover T, Csoka I, Eros I. 1997. Formation and stability of multiple phase (W/O/W) emulsions. Part II: Relationship between primary interface saturation and formation. Pharmazie 52(4): 328. Krog N. 1991. Thermodynamics of interfacial films in food emulsions. In: Microemulsions and Emulsions in Food, El-Nokaly M, Cornell D, eds. Washington, DC: ACS, pp 138–145. Lanier JG, Newman MJ, Lee EM, Sette A, Ahmed R. 1999. Peptide vaccination using nonionic block copolymers induces protective anti-viral CTL responses. Vaccine 18(5–6): 549–557. Laugel C, Chaminade P, Baillet A, Seiller M, Ferrier D. 1996. Moisturizing substances entrapped in W/O/W emulsions: analytical methodology for formulation, stability and release studies. J Controlled Release 38: 59–67. Laugel C, Baillet A, Youenang Piemi MP, Marty JP, Ferrier D. 1998. Oil-water-oil multiple emulsions for prolonged delivery of hydrocortisone after topical application: Comparison with simple emulsions. Int J Pharm 160: 106–117. Law TK, Florence AT, Whateley TL. 1984. Release from multiple W/O/W emulsions stabilized by interfacial complexation. J Pharm Pharmacol 36(suppl): 50. Law TK, Whateley TL, Florence AT. 1986. Stabilization of W/O/W multiple emulsion by interfacial complexation of macromolecules and nonionic surfactants. J Controlled Release 3: 279–290. Li NN, Shrier AL. 1972. Liquid membrane water treating. In: Recent Development in Separation Science, Vol.1, Cleveland: Chem. Rubber Co., pp 163–174. Lifshitz IM, Slyozov VV. 1961. The kinetics of precipitation from supersaturated solid solutions. J Phys Chem Solids, 19: 35. Lin TJ, Kurihara H, Ohta H. 1975. Effects of phase inversion and surfactant location on the formation of O/W emulsions. J Soc Cosmet Chem 26: 121–139.
24
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Lin SJ, Wu WH. 1991. Physical parameters and release behaviors of W/O/W multiple emulsions containing cosurfactants and different specific gravity of oils. Pharm Acta Helv 66(12): 342–347. Magdassi S, Frenkel M, Garti N, Kasan R. 1984. Multiple emulsion II: HLB shift caused by emulsifier migration to external interface. J Colloid Interface Sci 97(2): 374–379. Magdassi S, Frenkel M, Garti N. 1984. On the factors affecting the yield of preparation and stability of multiple emulsions. J Disper Sci Tech 5(1): 49–59. Magdassi S, Garti N. 1984. Release of electrolytes in multiple emulsions: Coalescence and breakdown or diffusion through oil phase? Colloids Surf 12: 367–373. Magdassi S, Garti N. 1986. A kinetic model for release of electrolytes from W/O/W multiple emulsions. J Controlled Release 3: 273–277. Martin A, Swarbrick J, Cammarata N. 1993. Physical Pharmacy, Fourth Edition, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: Lee & Febiger, pp 371–373 and 487–490. Matsumoto S, Kita Y, Yonezawa D. 1976. An attempt at preparing water-in-oil-in-water multiple phase emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 57(2): 353–361. Matsumoto S, Kohda M, Murata S. 1977. Preparation of lipid vesicles on the basis of a technique for providing W/O/W emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 62(1): 149–157. Matsumoto S. 1983. Development of W/O/W type dispersion during phase inversion of concentrated W/O emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 94(2): 362–368. Matsumoto S, Kitayama T, Kohda M. 1985. Some trials in stabilizing W/O/W emulsions under the presence of electrolytes. J Jap Oil Chem Soc 34: 688–695. Matsumoto S, Kohda M. 1980. The viscosity of W/O/W emulsions: An attempt to estimate the water permeation coefficient of the oil layer from the viscosity changes in diluted system on aging under osmotic pressure gradient. J Colloid Interface Sci 73(1): 13–20. Matsumoto S. 1987. W/O/W type multiple emulsions. In: Nonionic surfactant physical chemistry, Schick MJ, eds. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 549–600. May SW, Li NN. 1974. Encapsulation of enzymes in liquid membrane emulsions. Enzyme Eng 2: 77–82. Mikhin KV, Stepanow SV, Byakov VM. 2003. Formation of Ps bubble in liquid media. Radiat Phys Chem 68: 415–417. Mohamed SM, Ghazy FS, Mahdy MA, Gad MA. 1989. Factors affecting the yield of multiple emulsion and drug release. Mans J Pharm Sci 5: 56–71. Morimoto Y, Sugibayashi K, Yamagauchi Y, Kato Y. 1979. Detoxication capacity of a multiple (W/O/W) emulsion for the treatment of drug overdose: drug extraction into the emulsion in the gastro-intestinal tract of rabbits. Chem Pharm Bull 27(12): 3188–3192. Morimoto Y, Yamagauchi Y, Sugibayashi K. 1979. Detoxication capacity of a multiple (W/O/W) emulsion for the treatment of drug overdose. II. Detoxication of quinine sulfate with the emulsion in the gastro-intestinal tract of rabbits. Chem Pharm Bull 27(12): 3188–3192. Murray BS, Dickinson E. 1996. Interfacial rheology and the dynamic properties of adsorbed films of food proteins and surfactants. Food Sci Technol Int 2(3): 131–145.
REFERENCES
25
Myers D. 1988. Surfactant science and technology. New York, NY: VCH Publishers, pp 209–253. Myers SL, Shively ML. 1992. Preparation and characterization of emulsifiable glasses: Oil-in-water and water-in-oil-in-water emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 149(1): 271–278. Nakhare S, Vyas SP. 1996. Preparation and characterization of multiple emulsion based systems for controlled diclofenac sodium release. J Microencapsu 13(3): 281–292. Nakhare S, Vyas SP. 1995. Prolonged release of rifampicin from multiple W/O/W emulsion systems. J Microencapsu 12(4): 409–415. Ng SM, Frank SG. 1982. Formation of multiple emulsions in a four-component system containing nonionic surfactants. J Disper Sci Tech 3: 217. Ohwaki T. 1992. Improvement of the formation percentage of water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions by the addition of surfactants in the internal aqueous phase of the emulsion. Int J Pharm 85: 19–28. Okada H. 1997. One-and three-month release injectable microspheres of the LH-RH superagonist leuprorelin acetate. Adv Drug Deliv Rev 28(1): 43–70. Omotosho JA, Whateley TL, Law TK, Florence AT. 1986. The nature of the oil phase and the release of solutes from multiple (W/O/W) emulsions. J Pharm Pharmacol 38: 865–870. Omotosho JA, Law TK, Whateley TL, Florence AT. 1986. The stabilization of W/O/W emulsions by interfacial interaction between albumin and non-ionic surfactants. Colloids Surf 20: 133–144. Omotosho JA, Florence AT, Whateley TL. 1990. Absorption and lymphatic uptake of 5-fluorouracil in the rate following oral administration of W/O/W multiple emulsions. Int J Pharm 61: 51–56. Omotosho JA. 1990. The effect of acacia, gelatin and polyvinylpyrrolidone on chloroquine transport from multiple W/O/W emulsions. Int J Pharm 62: 81–84. Omotosho JA, Whateley TL, Law TK, Florence AT. 1989. Release of 5-fluorouracil from intramuscular W/O/W multiple emulsions. Biopharm Drug Disp 10: 257– 268. Opawale FO, Burgess DJ. 1998. Influence of interfacial rheological properties of mixed emulsifier films on the stability of water-in-oil-in-water emulsions. J Pharm Pharmacol 50: 965–973. Opawale FO, Burgess DJ. 1998. Influence of interfacial properties of lipophilic surfactant on water-in-oil emulsion stability. J Colloid Interface Sci 197: 142–150. Ostwald W. 1900. Uber die vermeintliche isomerie des rotten und gelben quecksilberoxyds und die oberflachenspannung fester korper. Z Phys Chem 34: 495. Oza KP, Frank SG. 1989. Multiple emulsions stabilized by colloidal microcrystalline cellulose. J Disper Sci and Tech 10(2): 163–185. Padday JF, Russel DR. 1960. The measurement of the surface tension of pure liquids and solutions. J Colloid Sci 15: 503–511. Pal R. 1996. Multiple O/W/O emulsion rheology. Langmuir 12: 2220. Panchal CJ, Zalic JE, Gerson DF. 1979. Multiple-phase emulsions using microbial emulsifiers. J Colloid Interface Sci 68: 295–307.
26
MULTIPLE EMULSION STABILITY
Pandit JK, Mishra B, Chand B. 1987. Drug release from multiple W/O/W emulsions. Indian J Pharm Sci 103–105. Parkinson C, Matsumoto S, Sherman P. 1970. The influence of particle size distribution on the apparent viscosity of non-Newtonian dispersed systems. J Colloid Interface Sci 33(1): 150–160. Raynal S, Grossiord JL, Seiller M, Clausse D. 1993. A topical W/O/W multiple emulsion containing several active substances: Formulation, characterization and study of release. J Controlled Release 26: 129–140. Rosano HL, Gandolfo FG, Hidrot JP. 1998. Stability of W1/O/W2 multiple emulsions: Influence of ripening and interfacial interactions. Colloids Surf A 138: 109–121. Seifriz W. 1925. Studies in emulsions. J Phys Chem 29: 738. Sela Y, Magdassi S, Garti N. 1995. Release of markers from the inner water phase of W/O/W emulsions stabilized by silicone based polymeric surfactants. J Controlled Release 33: 1–12. Sheriff M, Warburton B. 1974. Measurement of dynamic rheological properties using the principle of externally shifted and restored resonance. Polymer 15: 253–254. Sheriff M, Warburton B. 1975. The theory of a universal oscillatory rheometer for the study of linear viscoelastic materials using the principle of normalized resonance. In: Theoretical Rheology. London: Applied Science Publishers, pp 299–316. Shinoda K, Yoneyama T, Tsutsumi H. 1980. Evaluation of emulsifier blending. J Disper Sci Technol 1(1): 1–12. Sherman P. 1953. Studies in water-in-oil emulsions. III. The properties of interfacial films of sorbitan sesquioleate. J Colloid Sci 8: 35–37. Shimizu M, Nakane Y. 1995. Encapsulation of biologically active proteins in a multiple emulsion. Biosci Biochem 59(3): 492–496. Silva-Cunha A, Cheron M, Grossiord JL, Puisieux F, Seiller M. 1998. W/O/W multiple emulsions of insulin containing a protease inhibitor and an absorption enhancer: Biological activity after oral administration to normal and diabetic rats. Int J Pharm 169: 33–44. Singh S, Singh R, Vyas SP. 1995. Multiple emulsion based systems carrying insulin: Development and characterization. J Microencapsul 12(6): 609–615. Smith A, Davis SS. 1973. The role of molecular diffusion in the bulk stability of O/W hydrocarbon emulsions. J Pharm Sci 25: 117. Soma J, Papadopoulos KD. 1996. Ostwald ripening in sodium dodecyl sulfate-stabilized decane-in-water emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 181: 225. Swarbrick J. 1997. Coarse dispersions. In: Remington: The Science and Practice of Pharmacy, 20th ed. Gennaro AR, ed. Mack Publishing Company, Easton, PA. Taylor P, Ottewill RH. 1994. The formation and aging rates of oil-in-water miniemulsions. Colloids Surf A 88: 303. Taylor P. 1995. Ostwald ripening in emulsions. Colloids Surf A 99: 175. Tokgoz NS, Grossiord JL, Fructus A, Seiller M, Prognon P. 1996. Evaluation of two fluorescent probes for the characterization of W/O/W emulsions. Int J Pharm 141: 27–37. Trevino L, Sole-Violan L, Daumur P, Devallez B, Postel M, Riess JG. 1993. Molecular diffusion in concentrated fluorocarbon emulsions and its effect on emulsion stability. New J Chem 17: 275.
REFERENCES
27
Tsonopoulos C. 1999. Thermodynamic analysis of the mutual solubilities of normal alkanes and water. Fluid Phase Equilib 156: 21. Tsonopoulos C. 2001. Thermodynamic analysis of the mutual solubilities of hydrocarbons and water. Fluid Phase Equilib 186: 185. Ugelstad J, Mork PC, Kaggerud KH, Ellingsen T, Berge A. 1980. Swelling of oligomerpolymer particles: New methods of preparation of emulsion and polymer dispersions. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 13: 101. Vaziri A, Warburton B. 1994. Slow release of chloroquine phosphate from multiple taste-masked W/O/W multiple emulsions. J Microencapsul 11(6): 641–648. Walstra P. 1996. Emulsion stability. In: Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology, Vol. 4, Becher P, ed. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 1–62. Warburton B. 1993. In: Techniques in rheological measurement, Collyer AA, (Ed). London: Chapman and Hall, p 55. Welin-Berger K, Bergenstahl B. 2000. Inhibition of Ostwald ripening in local anesthetic emulsions by using hydrophobic excipients in the disperse phase. Int J Pharm 200: 249–260. Weiss J, Herrmann N, McClements DJ. 1999. Ostwald ripening of hydrocarbon emulsion droplets in surfactant solutions. Langmuir 15: 6652. Weiss J, Cancelliere C, McClements DJ. 2000. Mass transport phenomena in oil-inwater emulsions containing surfactant micelles: Ostwald ripening. Langmuir 16: 6833. Wilke CR, Chang D. 1955. Correlation of diffusion coefficients in dilute solutions. Am Inst Chem Eng J 1: 264. Yoshioka T, Ikeuchi K, Hashida M, Muranishi S, Sezaki H. 1982. Prolonged release of bleomycin from parenteral gelatin sphere-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsion. Chem Pharm Bull 30(4): 1408–1415. Yoshioka T, Sternberg B, Florence AT. 1994. Preparation and properties of vesicle (niosomes) of sorbitan monoesters (Span 20, 40, 60, 80) and a sorbitan triester (Span 85). Int J Pharm 105: 1–6. Zheng S, Zheng Y, Beissinger RL, Wasan DT, McCormick DL. 1993. Hemoglobin multiple emulsion as an oxygen delivery system. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 1158: 65–74.
CHAPTER 2
Structure and Rheology of Stable Multiple Emulsions P. PERRIN, F. PRIGENT and P. HÉBRAUD
Contents 2.1 Introduction 29 2.2 Preparation of Multiple Emulsions 31 2.3 Structure of Stable Multiple Emulsions 32 2.3.1 Static Structure: Direct Microscopic Observations 32 2.3.2 Dynamical Properties: DWS Probe of the Dynamics of Inner Droplets 33 2.4 Rheology of Concentrated Multiple Emulsions 36 2.4.1 Concentrated Inverse Emulsions 37 2.4.2 Concentrated Multiple Emulsions 37 2.4.3 Characteriation of the Interfaces 40 2.5 Conclusion 41 References 41
2.1
INTRODUCTION
Emulsions are dispersions of two immiscible fluids, such as water and oil. Simple emulsions are of two different kinds: direct emulsions (O/W) are dispersions of oil into water, whereas inverse emulsions (W/O) are dispersions of water into an oil continuous phase. Multiple emulsions of water in oil in water (W1/O/W2) are direct emulsions (oil in W2) where the dispersed oil phase is replaced by an inverse emulsion (W1/O) (Garti, 1997). One thus obtains a dispersion of water droplets inside oil globules. Amphiphilic molecules adsorbed at oil water interfaces are used to improve emulsion metastability. Several empirical rules—Bancroft rule (Bancroft, Multiple Emulsions: Technology and Applications, Edited by Abraham Aserin Copyright © 2008 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
29
30
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
1913), hydrophilic lipophilic balance (HLB) rule (Tadros et al., 1997; Grossiord, 1998), for instance—aim at predicting the nature (direct or inverse) and stability of an emulsion from the thermodynamic equilibrium properties of solutions of surfactants used to stabilize their interfaces. Thus, according to Bancroft’s rule, stabilization of direct and inverse emulsions requires the use of a surfactant with high and low HLB, respectively. Such systems are characterized by the existence of two opposite interfaces, of different radii of curvature. These interfaces are not thermodynamically stable. Control of the metastability of multiple emulsions is a key parameter in their applications. In general, two surfactants are used, one of low HLB, and the other one of high HLB, to stabilize the internal (W1/O) and external (W2/O) interfaces, respectively (Florence et al., 1981). The presence of these two different surfactants is a major source of instability of multiple emulsions (Ficheux et al., 1998; Wen and Papadopoulos, 2000; Pays et al., 2001). Indeed the lifetime of the emulsions is considerably shortened by the rapid diffusion of the more water-soluble small-molecule surfactants toward the droplets interface. Among other mechanisms, the formation of inverse micelles allows the diffusion of molecules through the oil phase (Pays et al., 2000). Nevertheless, a general understanding of emulsion metastability is still lacking. It requires precise understanding of the droplets properties, such as their dynamics and their interaction with globules’ interfaces. Such a study is inherently difficult, due to the finite lifetime of multiple emulsions. In a first step toward a more general understanding of multiple emulsions stability and dynamics, in this chapter we study extremely stable multiple emulsions. We show how to conveniently and precisely probe the droplets’ properties. Additionally we describe the structural and rheological properties of such stable multiple emulsions. To prepare stable multiple emulsions that can be studied over a long time, we use amphiphilic copolymers instead of small molecular surfactants as the globule interface stabilizers (Sela et al., 1994; Garti, 1998; Benichou et al. 2004; Michaut et al. 2003, 2004a). However, the interface of inverse droplets is stabilized either with a small tensioactive molecule or with a polymeric surfactant. We are interested in exploring two questions: •
•
What are the interactions between the inner surfaces of large globules and the outer surface of small inverse droplets, What is the composition of both interfaces? Do the surfactants migrate from one to the other (Pays et al., 2000)?
We can answer the first question by direct observation of the inner droplets using confocal microscopy. The dynamics of the inner droplets can be observed by a light diffusion technique suited to turbid media, diffusing wave spectroscopy (DWS). Both observations show that attractive interactions—either depletion or van der Waals interactions—occur between the droplets and the
PREPARATION OF MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
31
inner surfaces of the globules, and lead to an increase of the local concentration of droplets close to the globules’ interface. The consequence is a slowdown of droplets’ dynamics, as can be readily observed. To answer the second question, we use a rheological means of observation. We prepare concentrated multiple emulsions, in which both globules and droplets are more concentrated than a random close-packing concentration. The rheological properties of the system are controlled by both interfaces, as it is well known in the case of simple emulsions (Princen and Kiss, 1986). Nevertheless, the quantity of interfaces of small droplets is much higher than that of large globules, and rheological properties are dominated by the interfacial properties of small droplets. Thus rheology is a unique in situ probe of the interfacial properties and likewise, as we will see, of the chemical composition of inner droplets. In our case, diffusion of the polymeric surfactant from the globules interface toward the droplets surface does not occur, so the stability of the multiple emulsions is enhanced. 2.2
PREPARATION OF MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
The amphiphilic polyelectrolyte used to stabilize the globules interfaces is a hydrophobically modified poly(sodium acrylate) having the chemical structure shown in Figure 2.1a. The molecular weight of the polymer is 50,000 g · mol−1. The hydrophobic side chains are randomly distributed along the negatively charged backbone. Details of the synthesis have been reported in Wang et al. (1988). This polymer will be referred to as 10Cn, meaning 10% mol of n-alkyl chains onto the poly (sodium acrylate) backbone. The length of grafted alkyl chains is varied between 8 and 16. In this range the copolymer is soluble in water and exhibits surfactant properties. The inner droplets are stabilized either by the commercial sorbitan monooleate (Span 80) or by a polymeric surfactant, Admul Wol 1407 (Quest International); see Figure 2.1b.
Figure 2.1 Chemical structure of (a) the hydrophobically modified poly(sodium acrylate) and of the sorbitan monooleate, Span 80, used as a stabilizer of (b) the inverse droplets.
32
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Multiple emulsions of W1/O/W2 are prepared following a two-step emulsification process that allows the control of the concentration of both the primary (W1/O) and the multiple emulsions. Concentrated emulsions are obtained by swelling the dispersed water phase. In the following discussion, φd refers to the volume fraction of the droplets relative to the oil phase, φg is the volume fraction of the globule phase, and φ that of the droplet phase, relative to the total sample volume. We thus have the relationship φ = φg φd. In the first step of sample preparation, water is dispersed in a 15% (w/v) Span 80/dodecane solution using a rotor-stator homogenizer (Heidolph DIAX 900) at 26,000 rpm for 5 minutes. An inverse emulsion with a dispersed phase volume fraction φd up to 68% is obtained. The second step consists in the dispersion of the inverse emulsion in an aqueous phase containing 1% (w/v) of 10Cn, using the same homogenizer at 8000 rpm for 10 seconds. The volume fraction of the direct emulsion, φg may be varied from 6% to 25%. Indeed we observed that following this two-step procedure, multiple emulsions with φg higher than 25% are destroyed during the emulsification process. Nevertheless, as we added NaCl in the aqueous phase, in the first preparation step, an osmotic stress was created between the dispersed and the continuous aqueous phases. Thus, once the multiple emulsion was prepared, the inverse droplets swelled to reach a pseudoequilibrium. The concentrated multiple emulsions then showed total droplet volume fractions ranging from φ = 60% to 80%, and globule volume fraction φg from 70% to 90%. By this protocol, and by varying the amount of salt introduced, we could prepare multiple emulsions at any concentration, below or above random close packing, of droplets, globules, or both.
2.3 2.3.1
STRUCTURE OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS Static Structure: Direct Microscopic Observations
To begin, let us consider the spatial distribution of the inner droplets inside globules. As we did in the first step, we can doserve this distribution using confocal microscopy. Confocal microscopy allows us to image slightly turbid systems with a very good axial resolution (Pawley, 1995). It has been used to observe the structure of simple emulsions by rendering the interfaces fluorescent (Brujic et al. 2003; Zhou et al., 2006). In the subsequent experiments we will make droplets themselves visible by dissolving a fluorescent probe in the droplets. In order to avoid migration of this marker from the droplets toward the outer continuous aqueous phase, we have to use a neutral polysaccharide (dextran), of molecular weight 10,000, grafted with rhodamine B. This fluorescent probe is inserted inside the inner droplets with a concentration of 1 mg · ml–1. With confocal microscopy, a succession of slices is obtained inside the sample. The radius of the globules is of the order of 15 µm, which is much larger than the optical thickness of the slices (of the order of 500 nm). We can then prepare multiple emulsions in which the globules’ interface is stabilized
STRUCTURE OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
(a)
33
(b)
Figure 2.2 Confocal slices of two multiple emulsions. (a) The globules’ interfaces are stabilized by a modified polyacrylic acid, 10C12, and the inner droplets’ interfaces are stabilized by a polymeric surfactant, Admul. (b) The globules’ interfaces are also stabilized by the grafted polyacrylic acid, 10C12, whereas the inner droplets’ interfaces are stabilized by a small surfactant molecule, Span 80.
by a grafted polyacrylic acid polymer, 10C12. In the first system, the inner droplets are stabilized by a small surfactant (Span 80), and in the second system, by a surfactant polymer (Admul). As shown in Figure 2.2, the inner droplets distributions are very different: •
•
When the inner droplets are stabilized by a small surfactant molecule, the droplets are adsorbed against the inner interface of the globules. In the case of a polymeric stabilization, the volume distribution of the droplets inside the globules is homogeneous.
The observations in Figure 2.2 can be made quantitatively by averaging the droplets’ density as a function of their distance from the center of a globule, over the large number of globules (Figure 2.3). It clearly appears that, in the case of Span 80 stabilized molecules, droplets concentration exhibit a marked peak close to the inner globule interfaces. This attractive interaction between the globules interface and the inverse droplets may be attributed to depletion interactions of inverse micelles of Span 80 in the oil phase. 2.3.2 Dynamical Properties: DWS Probe of the Dynamics of Inner Droplets Diffusing wave spectroscopy (DWS) is a light-scattering technique that allows the measurement of the dynamics of turbid systems (Weitz and Pine, 1993; Pine et al., 1990). A thick sample of multiple emulsions is illuminated with an enlarged laser beam. This sample diffuses light, and both backscattered and
34
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Figure 2.3 Radial distribution of the inverse droplets inside the globules, deduced from averaging over 100 globule slices observed by confocal microscopy. Hollow circles: The droplets are stabilized with Span 80. Filled circles: The droplets are stabilized with Admul. In both cases the globules are stabilized with the modified polyacrylic acid 10C12. The distance to a globule’s center is given in a globule’s radius unit.
transmitted light are collected through monomode fibers. Each signal is amplified by two photomultipliers to get rid of the high-frequency noise from each photomultiplier. Then the cross-correlation of these two amplified signals is computed with the real-time correlator, which obtains g 2 (t ) =
I (τ)I (τ + t ) I (τ)
2 τ
τ
,
(2.1)
the correlation function of the diffuse light. g2(t) is a function of the dynamics of the diffusing particles and of the photon transport mean free path (l*) in the sample. We independently measured the transmittance of the sample that is directly related to the photon transport mean free path when the diffusing particles are not interacting. From the field autocorrelation function, g1(t ) = g2(t ) − 1, we were able to deduce the mean square displacement ∆r2(t) of the diffusing particles. In the case of backscattering geometry, the field autocorrelation function is linked to the mean square displacement of the particles through
(
)
(
)
2 L L 4 L ∆r 2(t ) cosh ∆r 2(t ) + sinh ∆r 2 (t ) − 1 + − 1 3 l l l * 3 * * g1(t ) = L 1 8t 4 L L − 1+ ∆r 2(t ) cosh sinh ∆r 2(t ) ∆r 2(t ) + l* l* 3 l* 3 3τB (2.2)
(
)
STRUCTURE OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
35
Before measuring the droplet dynamics, the multiple emulsions were centrifuged to immobilize the globules. Whereas the concentration of the inner droplets relative to the globules’ volume was 20%, the globules’ volume fraction was much higher than the random close packing, such that their motion was extremely slow. More precisely, we checked that diffuse light was completely decorrelated by the rapid motion of small droplets, and that we were not sensitive to the slow motion of large globules. Under these experimental conditions, the DWS technique is only sensitive to the motion of the droplets. As we noted above, as viewed by direct confocal microscopy, they are located in the vicinity of the globules’ interfaces. We next probe the dynamics of the inner droplets close to immobilized globules interfaces, and compare this dynamics to that of an inverse O/W emulsion. In the inverse emulsion, the mean square displacement of the droplets is proportional to time (〈∆r2(t)〉 = 6Dt, where D is the diffusion coefficient) over the entire time scale, which conforms with Brownian motion. In multiple emulsions, the dynamics of the droplets inside the globule are subdiffusive (〈∆r2(t)〉 ∝ tα with α < 1) over almost three decades of time (from t < 1 ms to 0.1 ms) before returning to the Brownian motion at larger time scales with a smaller diffusion coefficient than that of the inverse emulsion (Figure 2.4). By changing the length of grafted alkyl chains of amphiphilic polymeric surfactants, we could fine-tune the interactions between the globules interface and the droplets. We thus varied the number of carbon of the grafted chain between 8 and 16, in a range in which the polymer exhibit surfactant properties but remains soluble in the aqueous phase. We could observe that the shape of the diffusing curves 〈∆r2(t)〉 remains the same whatever the alkyl chain’s length (Figure 2.5). With either polymer stabilizing the globule, a subdiffusive motion
Figure 2.4 Mean square displacement of inverse droplets: In an inverse emulsion (dashed line); in globules of a multiple emulsion (continuous line). Straight lines, of slopes 1 and 3/4, are guides for the eye.
36
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Figure 2.5 Mean square displacement of inverse droplets stabilized by a modified polyacrylic acid with grafted alkyl chains of lengths varying from n = 8 to n = 16. The continuous lines, of slopes 1 and 3/4, are guides for the eye.
was observed at short times, followed by a Brownian dynamics at longer times. As the pendant chain length increased, the diffusion coefficient of the Brownian dynamics decreased (Figure 2.5, bottom right insert). The droplets are submitted to a greater friction coefficient when longer chains cover the interface. In the subdiffusive regime the mean square displacement 〈∆r2(t)〉 is always written 〈∆r2(t)〉 ∝ tα, where α < 1. For the different polymers studied, the value of α (Figure 2.5, top left insert) was always 0.75, which shows that changing the polymer hydrophobic length (and hence the nature of the interactions) does not qualitatively affect the dynamics in the subdiffusive regime. From these structural studies we can conclude that when a small molecular surfactant is used to stabilize inverse droplets’ inside the globule phase, the inverse droplets are submitted to attractive interaction toward the droplets’ inner interface, and slowly diffuse along the surface of the globules. A single droplet thus spends an increased amount of time close to the globules’ interface. This phenomenon appears to decrease the stability of multiple emulsions.
2.4
RHEOLOGY OF CONCENTRATED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
At concentrations lower than random close packing of hard spheres (63%), simple emulsions are viscous liquids. Multiple emulsions behave in the same way. Nevertheless, it has been observed that attractive interactions between
RHEOLOGY OF CONCENTRATED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
37
the globules lead to a shear-thinning behavior at volume fractions close to (but lower than) the random close-packing concentration (Pal, 1996). Then, at volume fractions larger than the random close-packing concentration, emulsions become mainly elastic systems. In the following, we analyze the origin of this elastic behavior in multiple emulsions. 2.4.1
Concentrated Inverse Emulsions
Before discussing the rheological properties of concentrated multiple emulsions, let us recall some fundamentals. Simple emulsions exhibit a transition from a viscous fluid to an elastic solid at dispersed phase volume fractions close to that of the random close-packing volume fraction, φc. At droplet concentrations lower than φc, there is almost no effect of the interfacial films on the rheological properties of the fluid, which is essentially viscous. However, at concentrations higher than φc, emulsions become elastic. The energy required to deform the system is stored within the films separating the close-packed droplets (Princen, 1983; Princen and Kiss, 1986). Thus the elasticity scales are measured as γ/Rd, where γ is the interfacial tension and Rd the droplet radius. Mason et al. (1995, 1998) empirically determined the following dependence of the elastic modulus, G′, on the droplet volume fraction, φ: G′ = α
γ φ(φ − φc ), Rd
(2.3)
where φc is close to the random close-packing volume fraction and α is an empirical coefficient. We will consider first the dynamical rheological properties of concentrated inverse emulsions (stabilized by Span 80 in dodecane) for various volume fractions φ. The experimental results are given in the form of the plot G′Rd/φ in relation to φ (Figure 2.8, hollow symbols). From the value of the interfacial tension, γ = 3.5 mN · m−1, measured by tensiometry, and using 3, we calculate values for α and φc equal to 1 and 0.66, respectively. We will therefore use this measured value of α in the subsequent analysis of concentrated multiple emulsions. 2.4.2
Concentrated Multiple Emulsions
Once highly swollen multiple emulsions have reached pseudo equilibrium between salted droplets and the continuous aqueous phase is achieved, as detailed in Section 2.1, the amount of work W, needed to strain the multiple emulsion is the amount of work needed to increase the surface of both droplets and globules (Michaut et al., 2004b). The elastic modulus as a function of frequency is displayed in Figure 2.6. The work needed to strain a droplet of surface tension γ with a shear amplitude ε is W ≈ εΠV ≈ εγR2, where Π is the Laplace pressure of the droplet, V
38
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Figure 2.6 Variation of the elastic plateau G′ (filled symbols) and loss G″ (open symbols) moduli as a function of frequency, measured at a shear rate of 0.2% for multiple emulsions stabilized by Span 80 (15% w/v in dodecane) and 10C12 (1% w/v in the aqueous phase). The volume fraction of the globules φg is 69% (䉬), 72% (▼), 78% (▲), 82% (■), and 90% (●). In that state, both the droplets and globules volume fractions are larger than φc.
is its volume, and R is its radius. Then the work needed to shear a globule of radius Rg and surface tension γg containing N droplets of radius Rd and surface tension γd, is Wtot = ε ( γ g Rg2 + N γ d Rd2 ) .
(2.4)
Because the droplets are close packed inside the globule, the total number of droplets in a globule is of the order N(Rg/Rd)3. This means that the ratio of the work Wd needed to deform the droplets over the work Wg needed to deform the globule is the product of two terms:
( )
Rg γ d Wd = . Wg Rd γ g
(2.5)
In our experiments, the radii ratio, Rg/Rd, is kept constant and equal to 60. The value of the second term depends on the surfactant system. The surface tension of the droplets is larger than that of the globule. We find that the globule interface separates an aqueous phase with 1% 10C12 surfactant and an oil phase with 15% Span 80 surfactant. At this concentration, which is nec-
RHEOLOGY OF CONCENTRATED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
(a)
39
(b)
Figure 2.7 Gibbs isotherm of water/dodecane interface. (a) The water phase contains 1% 10C12, and the Span 80 concentration in the oil phase is increased from 10−5% to 10−1%. (b) The oil phase contains 2% Span 80, and 10C12 in the water phase is increased from 10−7% to 2.10−2%.
essary to stabilize the inverse droplets, the tension of the globule interface reached its plateau value, lower than 0.1 mN · m−1 (Figure 2.7a). We do not know a priori the surface tension of the droplets interface, since we do not know the exact composition of the dispersed aqueous phase. We thus measure the interfacial tension of water (10C12) in relation to that of the interface (dodecane/Span 80) as a function of the 10C12 concentration. Whatever the 10C12 concentration, we find that the interfacial tension is comprised between 1 and 3.5 mN · m−1 (Figure 2.7b). Thus, in our system, the interfacial tension of the globule interface is smaller than the interfacial tension of the droplets’ interface. As a consequence the work needed to strain a concentrated emulsion is stored by the droplets’ interfaces. Rheology then becomes a tool to probe the interfacial properties of droplets’ interfaces. Using Mason’s equation, let us therefore consider G′Rd/φ in terms of φ (Figure 2.8, open symbols), where φ = φgφd is the droplet volume fraction calculated over the total sample volume and Rd the droplet radius. We observe a sharp linear increase of G′Rd/φ above a volume fraction close to random close-packing concentration, in agreement with the Mason equation. From the linear regression, we get the value of the interfacial tension, γd = 3.6 mN · m−1, between droplet and oil. The verification of the Mason equation for the multiple emulsions has several consequences: •
•
It confirms that the elasticity of concentrated multiple emulsions is governed by the internal droplets solely. The values of G′Rd/φ for inverse emulsions and for multiple emulsions superimpose (Figure 2.8). Thus the interfaces between the droplets and
40
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Figure 2.8 Mason’s plot of the rescaled elastic modulus of concentrated emulsions as a function of the volume fraction: ⵧ: inverse dodecane in water emulsion stabilized with Span 80; ■: multiple emulsion W/O/W stabilized by Span 80 and modified polyacrylic acid 10C12. The straight line is a linear fit to the multiple emulsions’ data.
globules, in multiple emulsions, have the same interfacial tension as the interface between droplets and continuous phase in the corresponding inverse emulsion. We proceed next to study the implications of this result on the composition of the inner droplet/globule interface. 2.4.3
Characterization of the Interfaces
Let us consider the droplets interface in the concentrated multiple emulsion. A priori we do not know the quantity of 10C12 that migrated from the continuous water phase into the dispersed water. We studied the interface by tensiometry (2% Span 80 in dodecane)/(10C12 in water). For a detailed description of the tensiometry measurements, as a function of salt concentration the reader is referred to Michaut et al. (2004b). We varied the concentration of 10C12 in the aqueous compartment. When it does not contain any 10C12, the measured value of the interfacial tension is 3.5 mN · m−1. Upon addition of 10C12, the interfacial tension decreases. Eventually it drops and reaches a plateau value of 1.6 mN · m−1 (Figure 2.7b). The value of the interfacial tension (γ = 3.6 mN · m−1) deduced from rheological experiments performed on concentrated swollen emulsions is very close to that measured by tensiometry, at zero concentration of 10C12. As a consequence the surface of the droplets is essentially covered with Span 80 molecules when 10C12 is used to cover the external interface.
REFERENCES
41
In conclusion, rheological measurements show that the two interfaces in multiple emulsions are different in composition: the interface between the droplets and the oil phase is mostly covered with Span 80 molecules while the outer interface is a mixed 10C12/Span 80 interface. Indeed Span 80 molecules dispersed in the oil phase can easily diffuse toward the globule interface. As we mentioned in the introduction to this chapter, the migration of the hydrophilic emulsifier from the outer interface to the inner one is an important source of destabilization of multiple emulsions. It is in fact the adsorption of an increasing number of hydrophilic emulsifier molecules at the surface of the droplets that increases the value of the spontaneous curvature of the (mixed) amphiphile layer and creates a condition favorable to the coalescence of both the droplet/droplet and droplet/globule (Ficheux et al., 1998). 2.5
CONCLUSION
The use of an amphiphilic copolymer as a surfactant allows for an increase of the lifetime of multiple emulsions. The structural properties emulsions should thus be precisely studied. We performed direct confocal microscopy observations as well as light-scattering experiments in order to investigate the dynamics of the inverse droplets inside oil globules. Depending on the emulsion formulation, we showed that droplets are either uniformly distributed inside direct globules, or they are depleted toward the inner surface of the globules. These structural differences appear to play a key role in the destabilization and release processes. Moreover, we used rheology to determine the interface composition of inverse droplets, which is difficult to measure otherwise. The elastic modulus of a concentrated emulsion is directly linked to the interfacial tension of the droplets interfaces. We showed that the measurement of the elastic modulus of a concentrated multiple emulsion leads to the value of the interfacial tension of the droplets interfaces. We were thus able to access the composition of these interfaces in situ. When applied to multiple emulsions during their destabilization these techniques should lead to a better understanding and control of the destabilization and release mechanisms. REFERENCES Bancroft WD. 1913. The theory of emulsification. V. Journal of Physical Chemistry 17: 501–519. Benichou M, Aserin A, Garti N. 2004. Double emulsions stabilized with hybrids of natural polymers for entrapment and slow release of active matters. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 108–109: 19–41. Brujic J, Edwards SF, Hopkinson I, Makse HA. 2003. Measuring the distribution of interdroplet forces in a compressed emulsion system. Physica A, 3–4: 201–212.
42
STRUCTURE AND RHEOLOGY OF STABLE MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Ficheux MF, Bonakdar L, Leal-Calderon F, Bibette J. 1998. Some stability criteria for double emulsions. Langmuir 14: 2702–2706. Florence AT, Whitehill D. 1981. Some features of breakdown in water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci, 79: 1, 243–256. Garti N. 1997. Double emulsions—Scope, limitations and new achievements. Colloids Surf A 123–124: 233–246. Garti N. 1998 A new approach to improved stability and controlled release in double emulsions, by the use of graft-comb polymeric amphiphiles. Acta Polym 49: 606–616. Grossiord JL, Seiller M. 1998. Multiple Emulsions: Structure, Properties and Applications. Editions de Santé. Paris. Mason TG, Bibette J, Weitz DA. 1998. Yielding and flow of monodisperse emulsions. J Colloids Interface Sci 179: 439–448. Mason TG, Bibette J, Weitz DA. 1995. Elasticity of compressed emulsions Phys Rev Lett 75: 2051–2054. Michaut F, Hébraud P, Perrin P. 2003. Amphiphilic polyelectrolyte for stabilization of multiple emulsions. Polym Int 52: 594–601. Michaut F, Hébraud P, Lafuma F, Perrin P. 2004a. A new oil-associative polymer for stabilizing inverse emulsions: strategy, synthesis, and physicochemical properties. Langmuir 19: 10086–10094. Michaut F, Perrin P, Hébraud P. 2004b. Interface composition of multiple emulsions: Rheology as probe. Langmuir 20: 8576–8581. Pal R. 1996. Multiple O/W/O emulsion rheology. Langmuir 12: 2220–2225. Pawley J. 1995. Handbook of Confocal Microscopy. New York: Plenum Press. Pays K, Giermanska-Kahn J, Pouligny B, Bibette J, Leal-Calderon F. 2000. Double emulsions: How does release occur? J Control Release 79: 193–205. Pays K, Giermanska-Kahn J, Pouligny B, Bibette J, Leal-Calderon F. 2001. Double emulsions: A tool for probing thin-film metastability. Phys Rev Lett 87: article 178304. Pine DJ, Weitz DA, Maret G, Wolf PE, Herbolzheimer E, Chaikin PM. 1990. Dynamical correlations of multiply scattered light. In: Light Scattering and its Applications, P. Sheng, ed. Singapore: World Scientific, pp 312–372. Princen HM. 1983. Rheology of foams and highly concentrated emulsions. 1. Elastic properties and yield stress of cylindrical model system. J Colloid Interface Sci 91:160–175. Princen HM, Kiss AD. 1986. Rheology of foams and highly concentrated emulsions: 3. Static shear modulus. J Colloid Interface Sci, 112: 427–437. Sela Y, Magdassi S, Garti N. 1994. Polymeric surfactants based on polysiloxanes— Graft-poly (oxyethylene) for stabilization of multiple emulsions. Colloids Surf A 83: 99. Tadros TF, Dederen C, Taelman MC. 1997. Preparation of double emulsions. Cosme Toilet 112: 75–85. Wang KT, Iliopoulos I, Audebert R. 1988. Viscometric behavior of hydrophobically modified poly(sodium acrylate). Polym Bull 20: 577–582.
REFERENCES
43
Weitz DA, Pine DJ. 1993. In: Diffusing-wave Spectroscopy, Brown W, ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp 652–720. Wen L, Papadopoulos KD. 2000. Visualization of water transport in W1/O/W2 emulsions. Colloids Surf A 174: 159–167. Zhou J, Long S, Wang Q, Dinsmore AD. 2006. Measurements of forces inside a threedimensional pile of frictionless droplets. Science 312: 1631–1633.
CHAPTER 3
Visualization of Stability and Transport in Double Emulsions LOUISE BRAUD LAWSON and KYRIAKOS PAPADOPOULOS
Contents 3.1 Introduction 45 3.2 Micrography of Double Emulsions 46 3.2.1 Photomicrography 46 3.2.2 Video Micrography 50 3.2.3 Capillary Microscopy 51 3.2.4 Electron Microscopy 52 3.3 Instability in Double Emulsions 52 3.3.1 Visualization of Transport 52 3.3.2 Coalescence Events 59 3.4 Conclusion 61 References 62
3.1
INTRODUCTION
Double emulsions show potential for a variety of industrial, environmental, and medical applications. For practical design of these systems, a thorough understanding of their structure, response to external stimuli and long-term storage, the role of various components on this response, and many other factors is essential. A number of experimental techniques are useful for assessing these features in double-emulsion systems. Changes in rheological properties can indicate changes in the relative volume of the external phase due to release of the internal droplets. Conductivity measurements are commonly used to detect release of electrolytes from the globules’ internal phase. Lightscattering and granulometric analyses can quantify changes and/or variations Multiple Emulsions: Technology and Applications, Edited by Abraham Aserin Copyright © 2008 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
45
46
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
in droplet-size distributions due to different preparation conditions, external stimuli, or inherent instabilities over time. In many investigations of the properties of double-emulsion systems, the use of microscopic visualization in conjunction with the experimental techniques mentioned above has correlated the information gained and in many cases enhanced the understanding of detected mechanisms. In other investigations, visualization techniques alone provide direct detection of changes in the stability and properties of double-emulsion systems. This chapter provides an overview of microscopy techniques applied in investigations of stability and transport in double-emulsion systems.
3.2 3.2.1
MICROGRAPHY OF DOUBLE EMULSIONS Photomicrography
The ability to capture direct images of double-emulsion globules enables verification of the actual existence of the complex, three-phase system. The importance of visualization of double emulsions is seen in the work of Matsumoto and coworkers (1976) and their early success in developing a technique for preparation of stable double-emulsion systems. Similarly Kavaliunas and Frank (1978) used photomicrography to detect the structure of emulsions prepared with a water, p-xylene, and nonylphenol diethylene glycol ether system. As a result the authors were able to determine conditions favorable for the preparation of multiple emulsions, as shown in Figure 3.1. With polarized microscopy, the authors detected diffuse birefringence in multiple emul-
Figure 3.1 Photomicrograph of a p-xylene, water, nonylphenol diethylene glycol ether w/o/w emulsion (450×). Reprinted from Kavaliunas and Frank (1978) with permission from Elsevier.
MICROGRAPHY OF DOUBLE EMULSIONS
47
sion systems, which indicated the existence of a liquid crystalline phase at both the internal and external oil/water interfaces of these emulsions. In addition to verifying the formation of double emulsions, much information about their preparation and the role of different components in the preparation of double emulsions was gained through microscopic investigations since the 1980s. Visualization of different double-emulsion systems yielded information about the role of different components of the system in promoting emulsion stability. Garti and coworkers (Frenkel et al., 1983) employed optical microscopy to determine droplet size of emulsions prepared with various surfactants. From these observations, the investigators correlated droplet size with the likelihood of a water/oil/water emulsion inverting over time to form a simple oil/water emulsion as well as the surfactant properties that favored inversion. Larger droplet size and appropriate weighted HLB surfactants, which accounts for the HLB of the surfactants used in each phase of the emulsion and the relative concentration of each, promoted stability in the emulsion systems. With microscopic observations, Omotosho et al. (1986) detected the difference in droplet size when various hydrocarbon oils; the variation in droplet size was due to the differences in interfacial tensions with each hydrocarbon. Photomicrography has continued to be used in understanding multipleemulsion systems. Detection of an interesting, complex four-phase water/oil/ water/oil system (Figure 3.2) was detected at specific mixing conditions (Goubault et al., 2001). Pal (1996) investigated oil/water/oil emulsions and their stability over a period of more than two days. Changes in droplet size
10 µm
10 µm
(a)
(b)
Figure 3.2 (a) Complex structures obtained when the incorporation of the primary inverted water/oil emulsion in the external water phase is too fast giving a W/O/W/O emulsion composed of water and dodecane. (b) Microscopic image of a typical W/O/W emulsion. Reprinted from Goubault et al. (2001) with permission from American Chemical Society.
48
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
due to coalescence of the emulsion globules were detected microscopically; these changes were reflected in an increase in the viscosity of the dispersion. Laugel et al. (1998) used optical microscopy to ensure multiplicity of oil/water/ oil emulsions developed for potential use in drug delivery. The destabilization of water/oil/water double-emulsions in response to shear force was also assessed microscopically (Oliveiri et al., 2003). Comparison at different temperatures provided information for developing a system that exhibits enhanced release properties at body temperature for potential applications with cosmetics or therapeutic drugs. Different techniques have been applied for observing double emulsions with photomicrography. For example, immersion microscopy allowed direct detection of the structure of emulsion globules (Cournarie et al., 2004). Matsumoto and coworkers [Matsumoto et al., 1976] used a glass slide having a small depression at its center to contain the liquid dispersion for microscopic observation. An example of a micrograph obtained with this method is shown in Figure 3.3. Zheng et al. (1991, 1993) worked with double emulsions for potential use as a red-blood cell substitute in which the internal phase consisted of an aqueous solution of human hemoglobin. Emulsion samples were diluted into a gelatin solution, yielding a homogeneous dispersion for detection of the internal droplet size and stability of multiple emulsions with phasecontrast microscopy. Phase-contrast optical microscopy of liquid dispersions has been used in recent investigations as well to visualize double-emulsion globules for droplet-size and globule stability determinations over long-term and short-term time periods (Doucet et al., 1998; Pays et al., 2001, 2002), as seen in Figures 3.4 and 3.5. Phase-contrast and dark-field microscopy enhanced detection of very thin oil films separating the inner and outer aqueous phases
Figure 3.3 Photomicrograph of a freshly prepared W/O/W emulsion with liquid paraffin as the oil phase. Reprinted from Matsumoto et al. (1976) with permission from Elsevier.
MICROGRAPHY OF DOUBLE EMULSIONS
49
Figure 3.4 Phase-contrast optical microscopy of a water/oil/water emulsion. The oil phase is composed of vaseline oil and cetearyl octanoate. Reprinted from Doucet et al. (1998) with permission from Blackwell.
(a)
(b)
(c)
10 µm
Figure 3.5 Progression from a W/O/W emulsion to a simple O/W emulsion detected with phase-contrast microscopy over time (a) 60 minutes after preparation, (b) 250 minntes after preparation, and (c) 850 minutes after preparation. Reprinted from Pays et al. (2001) with permission from American Chemical Society.
when the internal droplets exhibited extreme swelling (Florence et al., 1985). Burgess and coworkers (Jiao et al., 2002) placed double-emulsion samples onto a glass slide. Subsequent pressure created with the application of a coverslip led to deformation or disruption of the globule structure, depending on the composition of the system. The double-emulsion system’s ability to withstand the pressure induced by the coverslip indicated stability in the interfacial film and correlated with long-term stability. Sealing the edges of the coverslip prevented liquid evaporation over time. In instances where pressure from a coverslip is not desirable, this deformation or disruption is avoidable, as shown by Kanouni and coworkers (2002).
50
3.2.2
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
Video Micrography
Video micrography allows observation of emulsion systems with images of the same dispersion sample captured at regular time intervals. Sequential microscopic imaging was applied in the early 1980s by Florence and Whitehill (1981) to study double-emulsion stability using cinemicrography at various capture rates. This early investigation provided direct evidence of the occurrence of instability by mechanisms that had previously been proposed but not detected or differentiated. Micrography enabled the detection of changes in the mean droplet diameter and droplet size distribution, changes in ratio of single- to double-emulsion globules, and changes in the average number of internal droplets over periods of several weeks in addition to dynamic changes within individual globules in spans as short as 1/18 second. Video-enhanced microscopy and confocal microscopy verified the stability of double-emulsions encapsulating fluorescent markers within the internal phase and to determine the globule size of different formulations (Hai and Magdassi, 2004). An immersion microscope equipped with a video camera allows direct visualization of double emulsions in a bulk system immediately after preparation and over time without having to transfer or otherwise disrupt the dispersion (Tedajo et al., 2001). Observation of the response to experimental changes in the system is also feasible with immersion micrography (Jager-Lezer et al., 1997). Figure 3.6 shows the swelling in a double-emulsion system with a higher concentration of MgSO4 in the internal phase than the external phase conditions captured with immersion microscopy. For long-term observation of emulsion systems, video micrography with a rectangular cuvette with height of 200 µm and length and width of 3 cm and 4 mm was used. The top view and side view images of the emulsion globules were captured over periods of typically several hours (Gonzalez-Ochoa et al., 2003). Video tracking of emulsion globules was used to determine the type of instability caused by mechanical
(a)
(b)
Figure 3.6 Micrograph of a W/O/W emulsion (a) immediately after dilution of the continuous phase to create an osmotic pressure gradient between the inner and outer aqueous phases with a higher concentration of MgSO4 in the internal phase and (b) one hour after dilution. Reprinted from Jager-Lezer et al. (1997) with permission from Elsevier.
MICROGRAPHY OF DOUBLE EMULSIONS
51
agitation of double-emulsion systems containing various surfactants. Microscopic video observation along with macroscopic visual detection of phase separation in water/oil/water systems upon stirring allowed detection of two types of instability. These were either breakup of internal aqueous droplets within the oil phase or breakup of the water/oil globules dispersed in the continuous aqueous phase, leading to formation of a single oil/water emulsion or separation of the oil and water continuous phases (Kanouni et al., 2002). 3.2.3
Capillary Microscopy
While many of visualization techniques assess the structure of emulsion globules in a bulk system, a technique developed by Papadopoulos and coworkers in the 1990s offers the capability of observing the dynamic behavior over time of an individual emulsion globule from the moment of its preparation. The formation of individual double-emulsion globules within thin-walled capillaries of diameters of 150 to 200 µm enabled direct observation of their behavior in a series of investigations (e.g., Hou and Papadopoulos, 1997; Wen and Papadopoulos, 2000b; Villa et al., 2003). Globules are prepared directly within a capillary filled with the continuous outer phase upon injection of each the oil phase and the internal water droplets with separate pipettes inserted into the capillary as shown in Figure 3.7. Capturing images at a high frame rate and over extended periods of time (over 24 hours in some cases) of an individual globule is possible due to the limited mobility of the globule within the confines of the capillary that would not exist in a bulk system. To study the mechanism of transport of water in these emulsions, micropipettes were inserted within the capillary, and this facilitated precise control of the location, size, and number of internal droplets. Different transport mechanisms of water from the internal phase of water/oil/water systems were distinguishable when the inner droplet was in contact or not with the outer phase. These mechanisms
Figure 3.7 Preparation of a double-emulsion globule recorded with capillary microscopy.
52
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
were detectable within the thin-walled capillary as the droplets’ position within the oil phase was manipulable (Wen and Papadopoulos, 2000b). To better understand the conditions that favor a stable system, the interactions between the inner droplets and the external phase and among internal droplets were enhanced with video observation of globules prepared within a capillary. Events leading to instability immediately upon preparation were also detected (Hou and Papadopoulos, 1996; Lawson and Papadopoulos, 2004) 3.2.4
Electron Microscopy
Electron micrography provides a method for visualizing droplets and capturing the fine details a double emulsion. One of the limitations of optical micrography is the visualization of fine droplets smaller than a few micrometers in diameter, as noted by Zheng et al. (1991, 1993). Another limitation is the inability to discriminate between water droplets covered by an oil globule and those dispersed within the oil phase (Matsumoto et al., 1980). DiStefano et al. (1983) captured micrographs of oil/water/oil emulsion globules as small as 0.05 µm in diameter and internal oil droplets 0.02 µm in diameter with transmission electron micrography. Also noted were the variations in number of internal droplets at different mixing speeds during emulsion preparation. Freeze-fracturing of water/oil/water emulsion globules provides a technique for droplet-size determination without distortion by the oil phase and with higher resolution of small droplets (Davis and Burbage, 1977). An example of the micrographs obtained is shown in Figure 3.8. More recently Okochi and Nakano (2000) employed scanning electron micrography to confirm the preservation of W/O/W structure after one week of storage.
3.3
INSTABILITY IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
Visualization techniques have not only been useful in confirming the existence of double emulsions but also in improving our understanding of various phenomena occurring in these complex systems. Microscopic techniques have enabled identification of mechanisms that were more difficult to detect with other indirect methods of investigation, yielding information that is beneficial in the design of double-emulsion systems for practical applications. 3.3.1
Visualization of Transport
The use of microscopy techniques to investigate transport in double emulsions has brought some insight about mechanisms that can lead to migration of water and/or solutes within these systems. Optical microscopy was used to assess swelling in the internal aqueous phase of W/O/W emulsions due to migration of water in the presence of an osmotic pressure gradient (Matsumoto et al., 1980). Quantification of the rate of water migration in dif-
INSTABILITY IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
53
Figure 3.8 Electron micrograph of a W/O/W emulsion with light liquid paraffin in the oil phase. Bar = 1 µm. Reprinted from Davis and Burbage (1977) with permission from Elsevier.
ferent oils based on droplet-size measurements taken as a function of time was used to determine the permeation coefficient of different oils. The concentration of surfactant in the oil phase also plays a role in the degree of swelling in a water/oil/water emulsion. The degree of swelling varies, but can increase the size of emulsion globules significantly, as seen in Figure 3.6. In some cases the extent of swelling leads to eventual breakdown of the oil phase of a water/oil/water emulsion (Jager-Lezer et al., 1997). Such extreme swelling causes extensive thinning in the oil film separating the aqueous phases. Without adequate stabilizers, this can lead to rupture of the thin film and thus release of the swollen droplets to the external phase (Florence et al., 1985). One of the mechanisms by which water is transported across the oil phase is by reverse micellar transport. Sela et al. (1995) provides evidence of this mechanism in assessing water solubility by reverse micelles in the oil phase of water/oil/water systems. Microscopic observation of collected oil-phase samples ensured that no water droplets were present in the oil phase and that any water detected via titration methods was solubilized in the oil. The migration of water from an internal droplet to the continuous aqueous phase,
54
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
resulting in a decrease in the droplet size, was visualized and quantified in a series of investigations. Capillary microscopy was used in determining the effects of the osmotic pressure gradient (Wen and Papadopoulos, 2001) and surfactant concentrations in each phase of the emulsion (Wen and Papadopoulos, 2000a) on the rate of water transport (see Figure 3.9). Transport of water molecules to the outer saline aqueous phase by spontaneous emulsification of the internal pure water droplets, a previously unobserved mechanism, was detected (Wen and Papadopoulos, 2000b) and is shown in Figure 3.10. Spontaneous emulsification was evident by the formation of many tiny aqueous droplets dispersed within the oil phase. The decrease in the diameter of the internal aqueous droplet indicated the overall migration of water molecules to the outer aqueous phase.
L t = 0 min
L t = 0 min
L t = 0 min
IL t = 3 min
IL t = 10 min
IL t = 10 min
IL t = 5 min
IIL t = 20 min
IL t = 30 min
IV.t > 7 min (a)
IV.t = 720 min (b)
IV.t = 24 hr (c)
Figure 3.9 Water migration from the internal aqueous droplet to the outer continuous aqueous phase with different salt concentrations in the internal phase and nhexadecane in the oil phase and 5.0 M NaCl in the external aqueous droplet. (a) Pure water in the internal aqueous phase; (b) 0.1 M NaCl in the internal aqueous phase; (c) 2.5 M NaCl in the internal aqueous phase. Reprinted from Wen and Papadopoulos (2001) with permission from Elsevier.
INSTABILITY IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
55
Figure 3.10 Spontaneous emulsification in a W/O/W system with pure water in the internal water phase, n-hexadecane in the oil phase, and 5 M NaCl in the outer aqueous phase. Reprinted from Wen and Papadopoulos (2000a) with permission from Elsevier.
The effect of Ostwald ripening as a factor in emulsion instability in water/ oil/water systems was noted through the use of video microscopy (Rosano et al., 1998). The curvature at the internal water/oil interface is greater than that at the interface separating the outer aqueous phase from the oil phase. Thus the solubility of water is greater at the interface of the internal droplets, leading to a net transfer of water from the internal aqueous phase to the external phase. Transport due to Laplace pressure differences between the internal and external aqueous phases of water/oil/water systems can be balanced by inducing an osmotic pressure gradient in the opposite direction. Emulsions containing NaCl in the internal aqueous phase but not the external phase were more stable than those with no electrolyte in the internal phase. In other investigations of molecular transport from the internal phase of a double-emulsion system, video-recorded behavior of double-emulsion systems over time support the occurrence of molecular transport across the middle phase of the emulsion without release of internal droplets through coalescence between the internal and external phases. Magdassi and Garti (1984) noted this type of release from an otherwise stable emulsion; factors that affected the rate of release of electrolytes from the internal phase included the concentration of electrolyte and its hydrophobicity. In a later investigation, microscopic observation indicated that there was no detectable change in internal droplet size or number within the system despite the release of various salts and active agents from the inner phase; this indicated the ability of the molecules to migrate through the oil phase without any disruption in the structure of double emulsions (Sela et al., 1995). In this study emulsion samples were assessed periodically over a period of one month. Similarly Hai and Magdassi (2004) visualized double-emulsion globules over time and confirmed that
56
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
release of fluorescent markers from the internal phase was not due to release of the entire droplets; stable emulsions were detected after 24 hours, while significant release of the fluorescent marker was detected within 2 hours of preparation. Rojas et al. (2006) also noted release of a fluorescent dye dissolved in the internal aqueous phase of an otherwise stable double-emulsion system. By contrast, when the dye was encapsulated within nanohydrogel particles in the internal aqueous phase, it was not released to the external phase. Release of dye from these particles, however, could be triggered by in situ addition of hydrochloric acid to the emulsion system. The nanohydrogel particles remained encapsulated within the emulsion globule as the stability of the globule was maintained. Addition of HCl to either the internal or external aqueous phase prompted release of the dye from the internal phase particles (Figure 3.11), indicating ionic transport of HCl through the oil phase; transport of the dye to the external phase was indicated by an increased fluorescence in the external phase.
(a)
50 µm
(b)
Figure 3.11 Activation of fluorescent dye release from nanohydrogel particles within the internal aqueous phase of a W/O/W globule prompted by continuous injection of a 0.2 M HCl aqueous solution into the external aqueous phase. The oil phase is composed of n-hexadecane and Span 80. (a) Initially after globule preparation; (b) 90 seconds after the onset of acid injection. Bright field microscopy images are in the left column while fluorescence microscopy images are in the right column. Reprinted from Rojas et al. (2006) with permission from Elsevier.
INSTABILITY IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
57
In an investigation by Garti et al. (1994), the release of NaCl from a water/ oil/water emulsion was affected by the presence of protein in the inner phase of the emulsion but not by the addition of protein to the external phase. However, the addition of protein to either phase enhanced emulsion stability, as indicated by the visualization of stable emulsions containing protein in the outer aqueous phase after seven days of storage (Figure 3.12). Similarly the addition of a polysaccharide, along with protein, in the external aqueous phase enhanced globule stability, as was indicated by confocal scanning laser microscopy over time and the long-term (seven-day) encapsulation of vitamin B1 from the internal aqueous phase over time. Encapsulation or release of vitamin B1 was noted with confocal scanning laser microscopy due to its fluorescence properties (Benichou et al., 2007). A recent study compared the rate of transport of different ions across the oil phase of a water/oil/water double emulsion. NaCl and AgNO3 were added to separate aqueous phases of the emulsion system. AgCl deposition observed within an individual globule through the use of capillary video microscopy enabled detection of the ionic transport rate (see Figure 3.13), which was a result of reverse micellar transport and was faster for Ag+ than for Cl− (Cheng et al., 2007). In the investigations mentioned here, the visualization of stable emulsion globules over time indicated that release from the internal phase could occur without coalescence of the internal droplets to the external phase but rather by diffusion or facilitated transport across the middle phase. These findings are useful in design of controlled-release systems in that the choice of surfactants, oil, and other components can be used to tailor the rate at which release occurs.
Figure 3.12 Microscopic observation of a W/O/W containing albumin protein in the external aqueous phase and light mineral oil in the oil phase (a) immediately after preparation and (b) seven days after preparation. Reprinted from Garti et al. (1994) with permission from Elsevier.
58
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
52 µm18 µm O
W1
W2
40 µm t=0s
52 µm
68 µm
40 µm t = 25 s
52 µm
55 µm
40 µm t = 50 s
Figure 3.13 Transport of Ag+ through the oil film of a W/O/W globule indicated by AgCl deposition in the internal aqueous phase. The internal aqueous phase is a 2.5 M NaCl solution, the oil phase contains hexadecane and Span 80 while the external aqueous phase contains AgNO3. Reprinted from Cheng et al. (2007) with permission from Elsevier.
INSTABILITY IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
3.3.2
59
Coalescence Events
In the past decade microscopic detection of specific types of coalescence within double-emulsion droplets has contributed to a better understanding of these mechanisms in order to control their occurrence. Three types of coalescence events have been identified in double-emulsion systems. These include coalescence between contacting inner droplets (internal coalescence), coalescence of interior droplets with the outer continuous phase (external coalescence), and coalescence between contacting two-phase emulsion globules. Direct evidence of each type of coalescence has been collected for double emulsions with microscopic visualization. The type and concentrations of surfactants in each phase of the water/oil/water double emulsions are critical in controlling the occurrence and type of coalescence (Ficheux et al., 1998; Villa et al., 2003; Hou and Papadopoulos, 1996; Hou and Papadopoulos, 1997; Pays et al., 2001). Coalescence between contacting multiple emulsion globules was seen within the first weeks after preparation of a bulk water/oil/water system and was directly detected with high-speed cinemicrography (Florence and Whitehill, 1981). Within minutes or hours of preparation, internal coalescence has also been detected microscopically (Ficheux et al., 1998; Pays et al., 2001). A clear picture of coalescence between contacting internal droplets, namely internal coalescence, was captured with capillary video microscopy, as seen in Figure 3.14. Over time internal coalescence leads to a reduction in the number of internal droplets and an increase in their size, as seen in the sequence in Figure 3.15 (Villa et al., 2003). In these investigations the influence of surfactants in preventing or promoting internal coalescence has become more clear.
Figure 3.14 Micrograph capturing the occurrence of internal coalescence in a W/O/W globule with n-hexadecane as the oil phase. Reprinted from Villa et al. (2003) with permission from American Chemical Society.
60
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
20 µm
t = 0 min (a)
t = 1 min (b)
t = 2 min (c)
Figure 3.15 Internal coalescence followed by external coalescence in a W/O/W globule with n-hexadecane as the oil phase. Reprinted from Villa et al. (2003) with permission from American Chemical Society.
a
b
c
d
e
f
10 µm
Figure 3.16 External coalescence in a W/O/W emulsion with fluorescein in the internal aqueous phase and dodecane in the oil phase. Images were captured at a rate of 30 fps. Reprinted from Gonzalez-Ochoa et al. (2003) with permission from American Chemical Society.
External coalescence leads to release of internal droplets and their contents to the outer continuous phase. The release of a fluorescent label from the internal aqueous phase of a water/oil/water double emulsion was visualized with fluorescence microscopy and indicated the occurrence of external coalescence (Figure 3.16) (Gonzalez-Ochoa et al., 2003). External coalescence was directly detected in bulk water/oil/water systems (see Figure 3.17) (Pays et al.,
CONCLUSION
61
Figure 3.17 External coalescence in a W/O/W system. Time interval between images is 1 second. Reprinted from Pays et al. (2001) with permission from American Chemical Society.
2001). This study provides information about the effects of different surfactant concentrations and volume fractions of each phase on the progression from a double emulsion to a simple emulsion due to coalescence. With direct visualization of individual water/oil/water double-emulsion globules containing various concentrations of surfactants in the oil and external aqueous phases, the differing rate at which external coalescence occurred was quantified (Lawson and Papadopoulos, 2004). An example sequence of images indicating progressive release of internal droplets is shown in Figure 3.18. In emulsions containing chemical substances for controlled release, the concentration and type of surfactant dictates whether release will be dominated by external coalescence or by transport of the substance across the middle phase as discussed above. Visualization of the emulsion systems over time is a useful technique for differentiating between these two release mechanisms (Pays et al., 2002). Through direct visualization the effect of internal droplet size on instability has also been explored (Ficheux et al., 1998). Similarly Hou and Papadopoulos (1997) systematically assessed the effects of pH, ionic strength, and surfactant type and concentration on instability in double emulsions. From the experimental results collected with capillary microscopy, a theoretical model of the interactions among internal water droplets and between internal water droplets and the external phase was developed (Hou and Papadopoulos, 1996).
3.4
CONCLUSION
Various microscopic techniques have been used to explore double emulsions, including electron microscopy, video microscopy, capillary microscopy, among many others. At the most fundamental level the use of such techniques
62
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
20 µm
(c) t = 0 s
20 µm
(c) t = 11 s 20 µm
(c) t = 1 min 8 s
20 µm
(c) t = 1 min 48 s
Figure 3.18 External coalescence in a W/O/W emulsion with n-hexadecane in the oil phase. Reprinted from Lawson and Papadopoulos (2004) with permission from Elsevier.
provides direct evidence of the existence of the complex, multi-phase doubleemulsion globules. However, dynamic mechanisms leading to instability and/or release have been identified and better understood through microscopic visualization. In many cases the mechanisms recorded visually would be difficult or nearly impossible to detect with other more indirect methods. One such example is distinguishing transport through the oil phase of a water/oil/water system with or without release of the entire internal droplets. When used in conjunction with other analysis tools, such as conductivity or rheological measurements, visualization of the behavior of multiple-emulsion systems provides unique information and, in many cases, a more thorough description of the mechanisms taking place.
REFERENCES Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2007. W/O/W double emulsions stabilized with WPIpolysaccharide complexes. Colloids Surf A 294(1–3): 20–32.
REFERENCES
63
Cheng J, Chen J-F, Zhao M, Luo Q, Wen L-W, Papadopoulos KD. 2007. Transport of ions through the oil phase of W1/O/W2 double emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 305: 175–182. Cournarie F, Savelli M-P, Rosilio V, Bretez F, Vauthier C, Grossiord J-L, Seiller M. 2004. Insulin-loaded W/O/W multiple emulsions: Comparison of the performances of systems prepared with medium-chain-triglycerides and fish oil. Eur J Pharmaceut Biopharm 58: 477–482. Davis SS, Burbage AS. 1977. Electron micrography of water-in-oil-in-water emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 62(2): 361–363. DiStefano FV, Shaffer OM, El-Aasser MA, Vanderhoff JW. 1983. Multiple oil-in-waterin-oil emulsions of extremely fine droplet size. J Colloid Interface Sci 92(1): 269–272. Doucet O, Ferrero L, Garcia N, Zastrow L. 1998. O/W emulsion and W/O/W multiple emulsion: physical characterization and skin pharmacokinetic comparison in the delivery process of caffeine. Int J Cosmet Sci 20: 283–295. Ficheux M-F, Bonakdar L, Leal-Calderon F, Bibette J. 1998. Some stability criteria for double emulsions. Langmuir 14(10): 2702–2706. Florence AT, Law TK, Whateley TL. 1985. Nonaqueous foam structures from osmotically swollen W/O/W emulsion droplets. J Colloid Interface Sci 107(2): 584–588. Florence AT, Whitehill D. 1981. Some features of breakdown in water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 79(1): 243–257. Frenkel M, Shwartz R, Garti N. 1983. Multiple emulsions I. Stability: Inversion, apparent and weighted HLB. J Colloid Interface Sci 94(1): 174–178. Garti N, Aserin A, Cohen Y. 1994. Mechanistic considerations on the release of electrolytes from multiple emulsions stabilized by BSA and nonionic surfactants. J Controlled Release 29: 41–51. Gonzalez-Ochoa H, Ibarra-Bracamontes L, Arauz-Lara JL. 2003. Two-stage coalescence in double emulsions. Langmuir 19(19): 7837–7840. Goubault C, Pays K, Olea D, Gorria P, Bibette J, Schmitt V, Leal-Calderon F. 2001. Shear rupturing of complex fluids: Application to the preparation of quasimonodisperse water-in-oil-in-water double emulsions. Langmuir 17(17): 5184– 5188. Hai M, Magdassi S. 2004. Investigation on the release of fluorescent markers from w/o/w emulsions by fluorescence-activated cell sorter. J Controlled Release 96: 393–402. Hou W, Papadopoulos KD. 1996. Stability of water-in-oil-in-water type globules. Chem Eng Sci 51(22): 5043–5051. Hou W, Papadopoulos KD. 1997. W1/O/W2 and O1/W/O2 globules stabilized with Span 80 and Tween 80. Colloids Surf A 125: 181–187. Jager-Lezer N, Terrisse L, Bruneau F, Tokgoz S, Ferreira L, Clausse D, Seiller M, Grossiord J-L. 1997. Influence of lipophilic surfactant on the release kinetics of water-soluble molecules entrapped in a W/O/W multiple emulsion. J Controlled Release 45: 1–13. Jiao J, Rhodes DG, Burgess DJ. 2002. Multiple emulsion stability: Pressure balance and interfacial film strength. J Colloid Interface Sci 250: 444–450.
64
VISUALIZATION OF STABILITY AND TRANSPORT IN DOUBLE EMULSIONS
Kanouni M, Rosano HL, Naouli N. 2002. Preparation of a stable double emulsion (W1/O/W2): Role of the interfacial films on the stability of the system. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 99: 229–254. Kavaliunas DR, Frank SG. 1978. Liquid crystal stabilization of multiple emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 66(3): 586–588. Laugel C, Baillet A, Piemi MPY, Marty JP, Ferrier D. 1998. Oil-water-oil multiple emulsions for prolonged delivery of hydrocortisone after topical application: Comparison with simple emulsions. Int J Pharmaceut 160: 109–117. Lawson LB, Papadopoulos KD. 2004. Effects of a phospholipid cosurfactant on external coalescence in water-in-oil-in-water double-emulsion globules. Colloids Surfaces A 250: 337–342. Magdassi S, Garti N. 1984. Release of electrolytes in multiple emulsions: Coalescence and breakdown or diffusion through oil phase? Colloids Surf 12: 367–373. Matsumoto S, Inoue T, Kohda M, Ikura K. 1980. Water permeability of oil layers in W/ O/W emulsions under osmotic pressure gradients. J Colloid Interface Sci 77(2): 555–563. Matsumoto S, Kita Y, Yonezawa D. 1976. An attempt at preparing water-in-oil-in-water multiple-phase emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 57(2): 353–361. Okochi H, Nakano M. 2000. Preparation and evaluation of w/o/w type emulsions containing vancomycin. Adv Drug Deliv Rev 45: 5–26. Oliveiri L, Seiller M, Bromberg L, Besnard M, Duong T-N-L, Grossiord J-L. 2003. Optimization of a thermally reversible W/O/W multiple emulsion for shear-induced drug release. J Controlled Release 88: 401–412. Omotosho JA, Whateley TL, Law TK, Florence AT. 1986. The nature of the oil phase and the release of solutes from multiple (w/o/w) emulsions. J Pharm Pharmacol 38: 865–870. Pal R. 1996. Multiple O/W/O emulsion rheology. Langmuir 12(9): 2220–2225. Pays K, Giermanska-Kahn J, Pouligny B, Bibette J, Leal-Calderon F. 2001. Coalescence in surfactant-stabilized double emulsions. Langmuir 17(25): 7758–7769. Pays K, Giermanska-Kahn J, Pouligny B, Bibette J, Leal-Calderon F. 2002. Double emulsions: How does release occur? J Controlled Release 79: 193–205. Rojas EC, Sahiner N, Lawson LB, John VT, Papadopoulos KD. 2006. Controlled release from a nanocarrier entrapped within a microcarrier. J Colloid Interface Sci 301: 617–623. Rosano HL, Gandolfo FG, Hidrot JP. 1998. Stability of W1/O/W2 multiple emulsions: Influence of ripening and interfacial interactions. Colloids Surf A 138: 109–121. Sela Y, Magdassi S, Garti N. 1995. Release of markers from the inner water phase of W/O/W emulsions stabilized by silicone based polymeric surfactants. J Controlled Release 33: 1–12. Tedajo GM, Seiller M, Prognon P, Grossiord JL. 2001. pH compartmented W/O/W multiple emulsions: A diffusion study. J Controlled Release 75: 45–53. Villa CH, Lawson LB, Liu Y, Papadopoulos KD. 2003. Internal coalescence as a mechanism of instability in water-in-oil-in-water emulsions. Langmuir 19(2): 244–249. Wen L, Papadopoulos KD. 2000a. Effects of surfactants on water transport in W1/O/W2 emulsions. Langmuir 16(20): 7612–7617.
REFERENCES
65
Wen L, Papadopoulos KD. 2000b. Visualization of water transport in W1/O/W2 emulsions. Colloids Surf A 174: 159–167. Wen L, Papadopoulos KD. 2001. Effects of osmotic pressure on water transport in W1/O/W2 emulsions. J Colloid Interface Sci 235: 1–7. Zheng S, Beissinger RL, Wasan DT. 1991. The stabilization of hemoglobin multiple emulsion for use as a red blood cell substitute. J Colloid Interface Sci 144(1): 72–85. Zheng S, Zheng Y, Beissinger RL, Wasan DT, McCormick DL. 1993. Hemoglobin multiple emulsions as an oxygen delivery system. Biochim Biophys Acta 1158: 65–74.
CHAPTER 4
Effect of an Oil-Insoluble Solute on the Stability of Multiple Water-Oil-Water Emulsions MOUHCINE KANOUNI and HENRI ROSANO
Contents 4.1
Model for Behavior of Two W/O Droplets, or G/W Bubbles Containing a Solute 67 4.1.1 Flux of Water due to Laplace Pressure between Two Droplets in a Solvent 68 4.1.2 Flux of Water between Two Water Droplets due to Osmotic Pressure 69 4.1.3 Total Flux of Water between Two Droplets Containing an Insoluble Solute in Terms of Laplace and Osmotic Fluxes 71 4.1.4 Role of the Concentration of the Insoluble Substance on the Equilibrium between Droplets 71 4.2 Predicting Change in Bubble-Size Distribution due to Interbubble Gas Diffusion in Foams 74 4.2.1 Lemlich’s Theory 74 4.2.2 Lemlich’s Theory Applied to Bubble Containing Insoluble Gas 76 4.2.3 Numerical Simulation 77 4.2.4 Stable Equilibrium Condition 82 4.3 Equilibrium of W/O Droplet Containing Salt 82 4.4 Conclusion 83 References 83
4.1 MODEL FOR BEHAVIOR OF TWO W/O DROPLETS, OR G/W BUBBLES CONTAINING A SOLUTE This model covers both the case of two water-in-oil droplets (W/O) and that of two gas-in-water bubbles (G/W) containing a solute (or a gas) insoluble in Multiple Emulsions: Technology and Applications, Edited by Abraham Aserin Copyright © 2008 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
67
68
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
the continuous phase. For simplicity, we present the model as applied to the case of two droplets of saline solution dispersed in a solvent.
4.1.1 Flux of Water due to Laplace Pressure between Two Droplets in a Solvent We consider two water droplets of radii r1 and r2, r1 < r2, dispersed in a solvent (the continuous phase), and we assume that water is only sparingly soluble in this solvent. Let γ equal the interfacial tension (assumed to be constant) and Cm the concentration of solvent in the continuous phase. Kabalnov and Shchukin (1965) used a Kelvin equation to express the increase in solubility of a substance inside spherical particles as the size of these particles diminishes: C (r ) = C (∞)e 2 γVm
RTr
(
≈ C (∞ ) 1 +
)
2 γVm , RTr
(4.1)
where C(r) is the solubility of the dispersed solvent in the continuous phase at the surface of a droplet of radius r, C(∞) is the solubility of this same solvent in the continuous phase but with a flat interface, and Vm is the molar volume of the solvent (water). Due to the Laplace pressure, the solubility of water in the interfacial region around the smaller droplet (r1) is larger than the solubility of water in the solvent between the two droplets. A water gradient of concentration is created in the continuous phase. After a certain time the concentration of water in the continuous phase is larger than the concentration of the water at the interface of the larger droplet (r2), and water enters the larger droplet. After a while the flux of water leaving the smaller droplet equals the flux entering the larger one. Using Fick’s law at the interface of each droplet, as Princen (1965) and Kralchevsky, Danov, and Denkov (2002) did for the diffusion of a gas in a soap film, we can express the relation between the gradient of concentration at the surface of each droplet and the radii: J1 = J 2
with
J i = −4 πri2 D
∂c ∂r
( Fick’s law),
(4.2)
r = ri
∂c ∂c = −4 πr22 D , ∂r r =r ∂r r =r ∂c ∂c = r22 , r12 ∂r r =r ∂r r =r
−4 πr12 D
1
1
2
(4.3)
2
where r1 and r2 represent the radii of the two droplets and D is the water diffusion coefficient in the continuous medium.
MODEL FOR BEHAVIOR OF TWO W/O DROPLETS, OR G/W BUBBLES
69
If the gradient of the water concentration in the interfacial region (of thickness δ) decreases linearly. We can assume the same value of δ for the two droplets, so the gradient can be expressed as follows: ∂C ∂r
r =r1
=
(C
m
− C (r1) δ
)
∂C ∂r
and
r =r2
=
( C(r )δ− C ). 2
m
(4.4)
From equations (4.3) and (4.4), the equality of the two fluxes may be expressed as r12
( C(r )δ− C ) = r ( C 1
m
2 2
m
)
− C (r2 ) , δ
(4.5)
and Cm can be expressed as a function of the two radii r1 and r2: Cm =
r12C (r1) + r22C (r2 ) . r12 + r22
(4.6)
Therefore the flux of water going through the interfacial regions surrounding the two droplets can be expressed as J L = −4 πr12 D
(Cm − C (r1)) δ
(4.7)
using equation (4.6). After C(r1) and C(r2) are replaced by their values found through Kabalnov’s equation (1.1), the Laplace flux becomes JL =
4 πr12 r22 DαC (∞) 1 1 − r1 r2 δ(r12 + r22 )
(4.8)
with α = 2γVm/RT (which has the dimension of length). Because the radius r1 is smaller than the radius r2, JL, as written above, takes a positive value. 4.1.2 Flux of Water between Two Water Droplets due to Osmotic Pressure If the two droplets contain, in a concentration of m0 (moles/liter), a solute soluble in the dispersed phase but totally insoluble in the continuous phase (in the present case NaCl), we can conceive a difference in osmotic pressure between the two droplets. We know that the smaller will decrease in size and the larger will increase because of the Laplace pressure effect. The solvent separating the two droplets can be considered to be a homogeneous liquid membrane. The flux, per unit of interface, due to the osmotic pressure can be expressed as follows:
70
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
J 0 = − L0 (∆P ) = − L0 RT (∆C ),
(4.9)
where L0 is an overall permeability constant (consistent with the definition given by Lemlich (1978), of the permeability of the continuous phase). L0 is a result of the resistance across the two interfaces and across the liquid lamella separating the two droplets (we assume, as in Section 4.1.1 above, that the resistance to the migration of water of the membrane of the liquid lamella, compared to that of the interfaces, is negligible, because of the greater gradient of concentration in the interfaces). ∆P is the difference between the osmotic pressures of the two droplets. Replacing ∆P by the Van’t Hoff expression for the osmotic pressure, we find that the concentration of the solute in a droplet is equal to the initial number of moles present divided by the volume of the droplet at a time t: C=
m0 × (4 πr03 / 3) r3 = m0 × 03 , 3 rt 4 πrt / 3
(4.10)
where r0 is the initial radius of a droplet and rt is the radius at a later time t. From equations (4.9) and (4.10) we can express the flux between the two droplets of radius r1 and r2, r1 < r2, as r3 r3 J 0 = − L0 RT (C1 − C2 ) = − L0 RTm0 031 − 032 , r1 r2
( )
r J 0 = − L0 RTm0 r032 01 r02
3
1 1 − 3 , 3 r1 r2
where r01 and r02 are the initial radii of the droplets 1 and 2. If we set θ equal to the ratio of the radii of the two droplets, we obtain a final expression:
(
J 0 = − L0 RTm0 r032 θ 3
1 1 − r13 r23
)
with θ =
r01 ≤ 1. r02
(4.11)
We can consider the surface of the smaller droplet to be the limiting surface for the osmotic flux. Then we can express the total flux due to the osmotic pressure as
(
J 0T = 4 πr12 J 0 = −4 πL0 RTm0 r032 r12 θ 3
)
1 1 − . r13 r23
(4.12)
As the size of the smaller droplet decreases and the size of the bigger one increases, C1 is superior to C2, and the osmotic flux, as written, takes a negative value.
71
MODEL FOR BEHAVIOR OF TWO W/O DROPLETS, OR G/W BUBBLES
4.1.3 Total Flux of Water between Two Droplets Containing an Insoluble Solute in Terms of Laplace and Osmotic Fluxes Using the separate expressions for Laplace and osmotic fluxes that we established in equations (4.8) and (4.12), we can write the total flux of water containing an insoluble solute (NaCl) dispersed in a continuous phase as follows: JT = J L + J 0T , JT =
(
)
(
)
4 πr12 r22 DαC (∞) 1 1 1 1 − − 4 πL0 RTm0 r032 r12 θ 3 3 − 3 . 2 2 r1 r2 δ(r1 + r2 ) r1 r2
(4.13)
We can abbreviate the coefficient of each term in (4.13) in order to simplify the writing of this equation: KL =
4π Dα C (∞) δ
and K0 = 4π L0 RTm0 r 032 .
Because of conservation of matter, the quantity Cm + V0, where V0 is the total initial volume, is constant. Assuming that the quantity of water dissolved in the continuous phase is very small and varies little, we can express the conservation of matter for the system by considering only the total volume of the two droplets. So, at any instant, the state of the system is V0 =
4 πr031 4 πr032 4 πr13 4 πr23 + = + . 3 3 3 3
The radius r2 can thus be expressed as a function of r1 only: r2 = 3 Ω − r13
with Ω =
3V0 . 4π
And equation (4.13) becomes JT = K L
r12 (Ω − r13 )2 / 3 r12 + (Ω − r13)2 / 3
1 1 1 − 2 3 1 r1 (Ω − r13 )1/ 3 − K0 r1 θ r13 − (Ω − r13 ) .
(4.14)
4.1.4 Role of the Concentration of the Insoluble Substance on the Equilibrium between Droplets Determining the Parameters KL, K0 We have KL = 4πDαC(∞)/δ, or about 1.25 * 10−20 mol·cm−1·s−1 if we assign the following values to the different constants:
72
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
D = the diffusion coefficient at the interfaces, = 10−5 cm2·s−1. α = 10−7 cm (2). C(∞) = the solubility of the dispersed phase in the continuous one, = 10−15 mol·cm−3. δ = the length of the diffusion layer, = 10−6 cm. K0 = 4 πL0 RTm0 r023 , or about 1.25 * 10−20 mol·cm·s−1. In calculating L0, the overall permeability of the interbubble medium (diffusion coefficient divided by a thickness and divided by RT), we set the diffusion coefficient D to about 10−5 cm2·t−1 and use a thickness of about 10−5 cm. Then we have L0 = about 10−2. We set the variable m0 to about 10−6 mol·cm−3 and r02 to about 10−5 cm. We cannot, of course, know the exact values of these two parameters, but by setting the approximations above, we can assign very similar values to them. We end up treating the evolution of the total flux of water between the two droplets as a function solely of the radius of the smaller droplet. It is obvious that equilibrium will be reached when the total flux is equal to zero. In turn the zero value of the flux gives us the radius of the smaller droplet at equilibrium. Evolution of the Total Flux between the Two Droplets as the Radius r1 Diminishes The three curves plotted in Figure 4.1 correspond to three different initial droplet–radius ratios. As the initial difference between the sizes of the droplets increases, the initial flux—essentially the resulting difference in Laplace pressure—increases. We find that the greater the initial difference,
Relative flux (total flux/initial flux)
1.2 1 0.8 0.6 θ = 0.3
0.4
θ = 0.5
θ = 0.8
0.2 0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Radius (r1) (10–5 cm)
Figure 4.1 Evolution of the relative flux of water (total flux of water divided by the initial flux) versus the radius (r1), for different initial radius ratios. K0 is taken to be equal to Kl.
MODEL FOR BEHAVIOR OF TWO W/O DROPLETS, OR G/W BUBBLES
Relative flux of water
4
K0 = 1
73
K0 = 10
2 0 –2 K0 = 0.1
K0 = 0
–4 0
0.2
0.4 Radius (r1)
0.6
0.8
1
(10–5 cm)
Figure 4.2 Evolution of the relative flux of water (as in Figure 4.1) versus the radius r1, for different values of K0, that is, different concentrations of insoluble solute.
the smaller the droplet will be at equilibrium. This is because the system requires a greater evolution in size to permit the osmotic flux to counterbalance the initial Laplace flux. Because K0 is proportional to the concentration of the solute in the dispersed phase, we can visualize the effect of the concentration on the evolution of the system just by considering the flux as a function of r1, for different values of K0. When K0 is equal to zero, we have the disappearance of the smaller bubble or droplet due to the Laplace pressure difference. When we take a nonzero value for K0, we find a zero flux for a nonzero radius r1, the equilibrium radius. The plots for K0 = 1 and K0 = 10 (Figure 4.3) show the tremendous effect of the concentration on the final size of the droplet. Indeed the equilibrium radius will be 0.4r01 for K0 = 1 and 0.9r01 for K0 = 10. Limits of the Model For the simulation we assume that the system is in steady state. This implies that the variation of Cm is not important and does not create a large gradient of concentration in the continuous medium. Figure 4.3 allows us to verify that the steady state is valid only in cases where the droplet does not disappear. The exponential included in expression (4.6) for the solubility at the interface of the smaller droplet is now predominant and induces a rapid increase in Cm. However, equation (4.14) cannot be used to compute the disappearance of the droplet because, in this case, the exponential of the Kelvin equation cannot be given a first-order approximation. Such other physical events as the desorption of the surfactant from the interface must be taken into account. To sum up, as shown in Figure 4.3, we can apply the model if we consider a diminution in size down to, but not beyond, a radius of a few nanometers.
74
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
1.0060
Cm, in C(∞) unist
1.0058 1.0056 1.0054 1.0052 1.0050 0
20
40
60
80
100
Radius (r1) (nm)
Figure 4.3 Evolution of the mean concentration of the dispersed solvent in the continuous phase, with a diminution of the size of the smaller droplet.
The model then corresponds to the evolution of the system balanced by osmotic pressure as shown in Figures 4.2 and 4.3.
4.2 PREDICTING CHANGE IN BUBBLE-SIZE DISTRIBUTION DUE TO INTERBUBBLE GAS DIFFUSION IN FOAMS 4.2.1
Lemlich’s Theory
At least two distinct spontaneous phenomena can change an existing distribution of bubble sizes in a liquid foam: the rupture of the lamellae between bubbles and the transfer of gas between bubbles by diffusion. While some liquid foams are extremely resistant to rupture, none are resistant to diffusion of gas. The following treatment of interbubble gas diffusion and the resultant change in bubble-size distribution builds on the work of Lemlich (1978). Lemlich’s approach, instead of viewing the gas as diffusing directly from bubble to bubble, interprets the phenomenon as first diffusing into the liquid region midway between the bubbles. The concentration of gas in this liquid can be considered as being equivalent (by Henry’s law) to a gas pressure in the liquid. Then, by virtue of the law of Laplace and Young, this gas-pressure equivalent can be considered to be the gas pressure that would exist within a fictitious spherical bubble of radius ρ. Thus the pressure difference ∆PLap between a bubble of any radius r and the liquid is 1 1 ∆PLap = 2 γ − , ρ r where γ is the surface tension.
(4.15)
PREDICTING CHANGE IN BUBBLE-SIZE DISTRIBUTION
75
The molar rate of gas transfer S(r, t) from a bubble to the liquid is assumed to be given by S(r, t ) = − JA∆PLap ,
(4.16)
where J is the effective permeability of the continuous phase to the transfer and A is the surface area through which the transfer takes place. If n is the number of moles of gas in the bubble, by the conservation of moles we have S(r, t) = −dn/dt. If we approximate A by 4πr2, equations (4.15) and (4.16) yield dn r2 = 8 π J γ − r . dt ρ
(4.17)
We can assume that the conservation of gaseous moles occurs throughout the foam as a whole, ∑idn/dt = 0. The summation can then be taken over all the bubbles. So, using (4.17), we get ri − r = 0, i ρ
∑ ni i
2
(4.18)
where ni is the number of bubbles of radius ri. Lemlich carried this calculation further and considered an average effective ρ independent of r but varying with time. Thus, by Lemlich’s approach, (4.18) gives ∞
∑ ni ri2 ∫ r F (r, t)dt ρ= i or ρ = 0 ∞ , ∑ i ri ∫0 rF (r, t)dt 2
(4.19)
where F(r, t) is the frequency distribution function of r at time t. Furthermore, as the pressure in a bubble is only slightly higher than the surrounding pressure Pa, which is typically the atmospheric pressure, from the ideal gas law and the formula for the volume of a sphere, we have n=
4 πPa r 3 , 3RgT
(4.20)
where Rg is the ideal gas constant and T is the absolute temperature. Combining Equations (4.17), (4.19), and (4.20), Lemlich deduced that the rate of change of the radius of a bubble over time is given by ∞
dr 2 J γRgT ∫0 rF (r, t )dt 1 = − , dt Pa ∫ ∞ r 2 F (r, t )dt r 0
(4.21)
76
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
or more succinctly,
(
)
dr 1 1 =K − , dt r21 r ∞
where K = 2JγRgT/Pa and r21 = ∫ r 2 F (r, t )dt 0
(4.22)
∫
∞
0
rF (r, t )dt. Thus bubbles with
r > r21 grow in size, whereas bubbles with r < r21 shrink in size and eventually disappear. For the sake of generality and utility in simulations, Equation (4.22) is recast in a dimensionless form as
(
1 1 dR = − dY R21 R
)
with R =
r Kt ,Y = 2 , rc rc
where rc is some convenient characteristic radius such as the average initial radius of the distribution. 4.2.2 Lemlich’s Theory Applied to Bubble Containing a Insoluble Gas As the bubbles change in size, osmotic pressure will develop between gas bubbles that contain a certain amount of gas that is totally insoluble in the continuous phase. If we consider the phenomenon with two bubbles of different initial radii, initially the concentration of the insoluble vapor is constant and only the Laplace pressure acts on the bubbles. The smaller bubble shrinks as a result, and the larger one increases in size. With the changes in size, the concentration of insoluble gas increases in the smaller bubble and decreases in the larger one, giving rise to an osmotic pressure that opposes the Laplace pressure. The osmotic pressure difference ∆Posm that drives the flux of the soluble gas opposing the flux driven by the Laplace pressure difference can be written as ∆Posm = RgT ∆m, where Rg is the gas constant, T the absolute temperature, and ∆m the difference in concentration of the insoluble gas between the fictitious bubble of radius ρ and a bubble of radius r. Using m0 as the initial concentration of insoluble gas, and r0 and ρ0 as the initial radii of the bubble and the fictitious bubble, respectively, we get
( )
r ∆Posm = m0 RgT 0 r
3
ρ − 0 . ρ 3
(4.23)
PREDICTING CHANGE IN BUBBLE-SIZE DISTRIBUTION
77
Recalling Equation (4.16), we have S(r, t ) = − JA(∆PLap + ∆Posm ).
(4.24)
The conservation of the total number of moles of the soluble gas gives 2 ri − r + m0 RgT i ρ 2γ
∑ ni i
3 3 ri 0 − ρ0 r 2 = 0. i ri ρ3
∑ ni i
(4.25)
In the case where ρ is independent of r but varies with time, (4.25) would yield a cubic equation for ρ as a function of the initial radius and at time t. Without pursuing this line of reasoning, we note only that ρ is initially equal to r21, and for the purpose of the following discussion we will assume that ρ has this value. From (4.23) and (4.24), following Lemlich, we derive the rate of change of the radius time:
( ) − ( rr ) .
dr 2 J γRgT 1 1 m0 RgT r0 = − + 2 γ r dt Pa r21 r
3
3
210
(4.26)
21
For the sake of generality and utility in simulations, Equation (4.26) is recast in a dimensionless form as
( ) ( )
1 1 dR R = − +Φ 0 dY R21 R R
3
−
R210 R21
3
(4.27)
with R=
2 J γRgT t m0 RgTrc r , Y= , Φ= , 2 rc Pa rc 2γ
where rc is some convenient characteristic radius, such as the average initial radius of the distribution. 4.2.3
Numerical Simulation
Values for R21 and F For values typically found in familiar liquid foams— m0 = 0.01 mol/L, γ = 30 dynes/cm, T = 298 K, and rc = 1 µm—we have Φ = 0.4. With this convention in mind, we see that a reasonable range of values to investigate for Φ is between 0.01 and 1. Beginning with the empirical distribution of de Vries and the MaxwellBoltzmann distribution of Bayens, we can determine the following initial values of R21 : 1.48 for the distribution of de Vries and 1.18 for the distribution of Bayens (see Figures 4.4 and 4.5).
78
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
0.8
Frequency function
0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4.0
3.5
4.0
Dimensionless radius R
Figure 4.4
Distribution of de Vries.
Frequency function
1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
Dimensionless radius R
Figure 4.5
Distribution of Bayens.
Curves of dR/dY as a Function of R Using equation (4.27), and assuming that R21 is a constant equal to its initial value, we can plot dR/dY as a function of R if we know the initial value of the radius of a bubble. Figure 4.6 shows one such plot for R0 < R21. We start with an initial radius (R0) of 0.6. At this radius dR/dY is negative, so the radius will decrease. This initial decrease is due to the Laplace pressure. As the minimum value of dR/dY is reached, the osmotic pressure becomes more significant, equaling and then exceeding the Laplace pressure, with a resultant rapid decrease in dR/dY to a value of 0. This equilibrium is a stable one, since, if the bubble continues to shrink, dR/dY will become positive and the radius will increase again.
PREDICTING CHANGE IN BUBBLE-SIZE DISTRIBUTION
79
Radius at equilibrium dR/dY = 0
dR/dY 1
Initial radius R0 = 0.6
0 –1 –2 Osmotic > Laplace
Laplace > Osmotic
–3 Osmotic = Laplace –4
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
Dimensionless radius R
Figure 4.6 Plot of dR/dY as a function of the radius R for Φ = 0.05, and R21 = 1.5, and R0 = 0.6.
dR/dY 1 0 R0 = 1.3
–1
R0 = 0.9
–2 –3 –4
R0 = 0.6 0
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 1 Dimensionless radius R
1.2
1.4
Figure 4.7 Plot of dr/dt for several initial radii (R0) and with Φ = 0.05 and R21 = 1.5.
Figure 4.7 shows the difference in the initial rate of shrinkage for bubbles with different initial radii. We see that the smaller the bubble, the greater is the Laplace pressure. For initial radii of 0.6, 0.9, and 1.3, the equilibrium radii are 0.107, 0.204, and 0.378, respectively. Influence of the Amount of Insoluble Gas Figure 4.8 shows the effect of increasing the osmotic pressure on dr/dt. As can be seen, an increase of Φ reduces the effect of the Laplace pressure, and the equilibrium radius increases as well. Figure 4.9 shows that an increase in Φ leads to an equilibrium radius closer to the initial radius.
80
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
dR/dY 0
Φ=5
–2 –4 –6 –8
Φ = 0.01 0
0.1
0.2 0.3 Dimensionless radius R
0.4
Figure 4.8 Effect of increasing the osmotic pressure (Φ = 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 1, 5) for R21 = 1.5 and R0 = 0.4.
Radius at stable equilibrium
2
1 Φ0 = 0.5
Φ0 = 0.05 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Initial dimensionless radius R0
Figure 4.9 Radius at equilibrium versus initial radius R0.
Variation of the Radius as a Function of Time As Monsalve and Schechter (1984) showed, if we assume R21 to be constant, then the equation of Lemlich (4.22), which is equation (4.26) with = 0, can be integrated to give R − R21 Y = R21 R − R0 + R21 ln . R0 − R21 We can then plot Y as a function of R (and vice versa, R as a function of Y) as shown in Figure 4.10.
PREDICTING CHANGE IN BUBBLE-SIZE DISTRIBUTION
81
Dimensionless radius R
0.8 0.7 Φ = 0.5
0.6 0.5
Φ = 0.2
0.4 0.3
Φ = 0.05
0.2 0.1
Φ=0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Dimensionless time Y
Figure 4.10 Curves of radius versus time for a bubble with and without an osmotic pressure, with R0 = 0.8, R21 = 1.5, and Φ = 0, 0.05, 0.2, 0.5.
1 0
dR/dY
–1 –2 –3 –4 –5 –6
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
Dimensionless radius r
Figure 4.11 Plot of dR/dY for different R21 (1.5, 1.7, 2) and Φ = 0.05, R0 = 0.5, and R210 = 1.5.
If take into consideration the contribution of an osmotic pressure (i.e., Φ ≠ 0), we integrate the equation numerically (using Mathematica) and plot R as a function of time; see Figure 4.10. As the figure shows, adding a small amount of insoluble compound prevents the bubble from disappearing, and an equilibrium radius is attained. Is the Hypothesis of Constant R21 Reasonable? As can be seen from Figure 4.11, a change in R21 has very little effect on the curves for dR/dY. Thus the hypothesis of constant R21 is tenable, at least for R0 < R21.
82
4.2.4
EFFECT OF AN OIL-INSOLUBLE SOLUTE
Stable Equilibrium Condition
The conditions necessary for one bubble of radius r to reach a stable equilibrium are (i) that dr/dt = 0 and (ii) that d2r/dt2 ≤ 0. Let us expand the second condition, taking into consideration the fact that r21 is a function of time.
( )
m0 RgT r210 d2r 1 = K− 2 + 3 r21 dt 2 2γ r21
3
1 dr21 . r21 dt
As dr21/dt ≥ 0, the condition 3m0 RgTr2120 2 γ ≤ r212 must be fulfilled.
4.3
EQUILIBRIUM OF W/O DROPLET CONTAINING SALT
We consider a water droplet of radii r containing a certain amount of salt, in a solvent (oil phase). We assume that the film around this water droplet prevents coalescence but is not impermeable to water. The Laplace pressure 2γ/r of a droplet containing a salt, dispersed in a solvent, will increase the shrinkage of the droplet, while the osmotic pressure will increase as well. In turn the diffusible solvent (water in the present case) slows in activity, and thus stimulates the backdiffusion of the solvent. In the ideal case the osmotic pressure is given by
∏osm = mRT = m0
( ) RT , r0 r
3
where m is the molar concentration of salt and m0 refers to the original droplet. We can write the excess pressure ∆P in the droplet as ∆P =
( ) RT
2γ r − m0 0 r r
3
At equilibrium, we should have
( ) 1r RT = 0.
d(∆P ) 2γ r = − 2 − 3m0 0 dr r r
3
Thus 2 γ ≤ 3 mRTr.
(4.28)
Using equation (4.28), which was proposed by Walstra (1996), we can calculate the minimum percentages difference of NaCl required (for various
83
REFERENCES
TABLE 4.1 Estimates of the minimum salt concentration required for various g = 10 mN/m and r to prevent Ostwald ripening in a water/oil emulsion Radius (r) nm 10 100 200 400
γ (mN/m)
m(mol/m3)
%NaCl
10 10 10 10
2.69 0.269 0.134 0.067
0.016 0.0016 0.0008 0.0004
values of the radius of the droplet and a surface tension of 10 mN/m.) to counterbalance the Ostwald ripening between two droplets; these values are listed in Table 4.1. Another condition is that m has to be greater than 2γ/3RTr. It is apparent that very small quantities of a suitable solute will suffice to stop Ostwald ripening.
4.4
CONCLUSION
From of our model, which is greatly simplified, it is clear that the presence of a small quantity of an insoluble solute in a water-in-oil dispersion (or an insoluble vapor in the case of a foam) can prevent the destabilizing effect of the Ostwald ripening phenomenon. It appears that with changes to the radii of two bubbles, a difference in salt concentration on the order of 0.0016% to 0.0004% for a radii of 100 to 400 nm is sufficient to stop Oswald ripening (when γ = 10 mN/m).
REFERENCES Kabalnov AS, Shchukin ED. 1965. Ostwald ripening theory: Applications to fluorocarbon emulsion stability. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 38: 69–97. Kralchevsky PA, Danov KD, Denkov ND. 2002. Chemical physics of colloid systems and interfaces. In: Handbook of Surface and Colloid Chemistry, Birdi KS ed. New York: CRC Press, pp 166–243. Lemlich P. 1978. Prediction of changes in bubble size distribution due to interbubble gas diffusion in foam. Ind Eng Chem Fundam 17(2): 89–93. Monsalve A, Schechter RS. 1984. The stability of foams: dependence of observation on the bubble size distribution. J Colloid Interface Sci 97(2): 327. Princen HM, Mason SG. 1965. The permeability of soap films to gases. J Colloid Interface Sci 20: 353–375. Walstra P. 1996. Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology, Vol. 4, Becher P, ed. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 1–62.
CHAPTER 5
Multiple Emulsions Stabilized by Biopolymers RACHEL LUTZ and ABRAHAM ASERIN
Contents 5.1 Introduction 85 5.2 Stability Considerations 87 5.3 Nonionic and Polymeric Surfactants 87 5.4 Steric Stabilization by Polymer 88 5.4.1 Steric Stabilization 88 5.4.2 Depletion Stabilization 90 5.4.3 Electrostatic Stabilization 91 5.5 Instability Considerations 91 5.5.1 Depletion Flocculation 92 5.5.2 Bridging Flocculation 93 5.6 Creaming Phenomenon 95 5.7 Biopolymer as Stabilized Multiple Emulsions 95 5.7.1 Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Proteins 97 5.7.2 Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Hydrocolloids 100 5.7.3 Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Hybrid of Protein and Hydrocolloid 106 5.8 Conclusions and Future Perspectives 114 References 116
5.1
INTRODUCTION
Multiple (or double) emulsions are complex liquid dispersion systems known also as emulsions of emulsions, in which the droplets of one dispersed liquid (water in oil or oil in water) are further dispersed in another liquid (water or
Multiple Emulsions: Technology and Applications, Edited by Abraham Aserin Copyright © 2008 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
85
86
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Figure 5.1 Schematic representation and microscopic image of W/O/W multiple emulsion.
oil, respectively), producing W/O/W or O/W/O. The inner dispersed droplets (hereafter called inner droplets or just droplets, while the droplets of the multiple emulsion will be termed, for simplicity, the globules) in the multiple emulsion are separated from the outer liquid phase by a layer of another phase. A schematic representation and microscopic image of a W/O/W multiple emulsion globule is shown in Figure 5.1. W/O/W multiple emulsions are the most studied system because they have the potential to become commercial products—mainly in food systems but also in cosmetics and pharmaceuticals (Garti and Benichou, 2001; Garti and Lutz, 2004). For close to 60 years, multiple emulsions were considered an emerging technology and a major scientific challenge (see Seifriz, 1925, for the first report), but in practice, only a few industrial products based on multiple emulsions exist in the marketplace. The main use of multiple emulsion systems is as confinement and protection systems for controlled release of active compounds. In the food industry (Matsumoto, 1986; Yoshida et al., 1999) W/O/W multiple emulsions can improve the solubility of certain active matter, solubilize oil-insoluble materials, serve as protective liquid reservoirs for molecules sensitive to external environmental reactivity such as oxidation, light, and enzymes, and serve as entrapment reservoirs for masking undesired flavors and odorants. Applications in the cosmetics industry (Kim and Lee, 1999; Gallarate et al., 1999) include aqueous preparations that provide a good “feel” and slow release of active materials or flavors, deposition of water-soluble agents onto the skin from wash-off systems. Most applications are related to the pharmaceutical industry (Okochi and Nakano, 2000; Shima et al., 2006; Vasiljevic et al., 2006), such as enhancing the chemotherapeutic effect of anticancer drugs, drug immobilization, treatment of drug overdoses, and protecting insulin from enzymatic degradation. In the agriculture industry the potential applications (Versteeg, 1978) are sustained release systems for fertilizers and pesticides, and in the fuel industry (Lin and Wang, 2003) as alternative fuel for diesel engines. This chapter deals mainly with the food industry.
NONIONIC AND POLYMERIC SURFACTANTS
87
The formation of a multiple emulsion requires only two simple consecutive emulsification steps, yet close examination of the results of such simple preparations reveals that the unsolved technical problems are not easy to overcome. In recent decades researchers have contributed information on the selection of different ingredients such as various blends of emulsifiers (mostly nonionic), oils, and viscosity agents. These reviews provided new ideas on novel analytical tools and advanced preparation techniques to better understand the nature of the instability of multiple emulsions and to control release pathways (Garti and Benichou, 2001; Grossiord and Seiller, 2001; Bibette et al., 2002; Garti and Lutz, 2004).
5.2
STABILITY CONSIDERATIONS
Because of their large droplet sizes, multiple emulsions, even more than regular emulsions, are inherently thermodynamically unstable. In addition the release of active material from the inner phase to the outer phase is mostly uncontrolled. Many studies have dealt with these two major problems (Garti and Benichou, 2001; Jiao et al., 2002; Garti and Lutz, 2004; Wang et al., 2006). The stability mechanisms have been extensively studied in empty multiple emulsions, but most recent investigations look at the emulsion containing entrapped solutes. In these systems it is very difficult to distinguish between stability and release mechanisms because the two phenomena occur in parallel and are sometimes derived from the same driving forces. The osmotic pressure gradient affects and motivates the release of ingredients from the core, and must be controlled. Many researchers loaded the multiple emulsions with active ingredients in the presence of salts, glucose, and other osmotic pressure regulators.
5.3
NONIONIC AND POLYMERIC SURFACTANTS
During years of investigation to improve stability and to control, sustain, and/ or prolong the release of active materials, monomeric surfactants have been progressively replaced by polymeric emulsifiers as outer or inner interface stabilizers. Low-molecular-weight emulsifiers (monomeric) can migrate from the W/O interface to the oil phase, and hydrophilic surfactants can be transported to the inner interface and alter the required hydrophilic/hydrophobic balance of each of the phases. Most of the studies between 1970 and 1985, searched for monomeric emulsifier blends of hydrophilic and hydrophobic surfactants with the best ratios for optimal stabilization. Matsumoto et al. (1976, 1985) established an empirical weight ratio of 10 for the internal hydrophobic to the external hydrophilic emulsifiers. Garti et al. (Magdassi and Garti, 1986; Benichou et al., 2002a) proved that free exchange between the internal and
88
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Figure 5.2 Schematic representation of monomeric and polymeric surfactant adsorption on interface.
external emulsifiers required calculation of an effective HLB value of emulsifiers to optimize the stabilization of the emulsion. In most cases the internal emulsifiers are used in great excess relative to the external emulsifiers. The nature of the emulsifiers also dictated the number of compartments and the internal volume that the inner phase occupies. Among the most promising emulsifiers for making multiple emulsions are synthetic polymeric amphiphiles and naturally occurring biopolymers (proteins or hydrocolloids). Polymeric amphiphiles are known to be multi-anchoring amphiphiles with irreversible adsorption capabilities that can improve the droplets’ interfacial coverage during emulsification since they provide strong steric stabilization capabilities (Figure 5.2). The gain in free energy by such adsorption is much greater than that of the absorbed monomeric surfactants (Ortega-Vinuesa et al., 1996). The polymeric amphiphiles form thick and flexible films that are strongly anchored into the oil-water interface in most cases. 5.4
STERIC STABILIZATION BY POLYMER
There are three main mechanisms of stabilization with polymeric amphiphiles: 1. Steric stabilization resulting from hydrophobic interactions among adsorbed polymers. 2. Depletion stabilization by nonadsorbing macromolecules that prevent collision between particles (droplets) and provide elasticity to the system. 3. Electrostatic repulsion between two droplets carrying the same charge. 5.4.1
Steric Stabilization
The main contribution to the stability of macromolecular-stabilized emulsions is related to droplets reaching a distance where compression due to polymer
STERIC STABILIZATION BY POLYMER
89
to polymer interactions occurs. Such polymer to polymer interactions are the basis for steric stabilization by two contributions: osmotic pressure effects and entropic or volume restriction. If there are polymeric chains covering the external surface of the droplets, (the average thickness of such polymeric layer is δ), then increasing in the local concentration will leads to different in the osmotic pressure between the solution and the overlap zone (Figure 5.3). Osmotic pressure effect will occur when the two particles are closer than a distance equal to 2δ (Figure 5.3a). The osmotic pressure of the solution in the overlap zone will be less than that in the regions external to it, leading to a driving force for the spontaneous flow of solution into the overlap zone; that force pushes the particles apart. However, if the two particles are closer than a distance equal to δ (Figure 5.3b), at least some of the polymer molecules will undergo elastic compression. Thermodynamically the compression corresponds to a net loss in configurational entropy, lose of certain degree of freedom. Hence, in order to regain the lost entropy, the droplets must move to obtain more freedom of movement. The net energy (Gi) of the droplets interaction will be including the attractive van der Waals forces (∆Ga) and the repulsive steric interaction (∆Gs).
(a)
(b)
Figure 5.3 repulsion.
Schematic representation of steric effects: (a) Osmotic effect; (b) elastic
90
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Gi
Gmix
Gvr
Gi
δ
2δ
d
Ga
Figure 5.4 Different free energies involved in the steric stabilization mechanism as a function of distance (d).
∆Gi = +∆Gs – ∆Ga. ∆Gs, is composed of volume restriction—termed Gvr and from the osmotic effect mixing—Gosm, thus the steric free energy is ∆Gs = ∆Gosm + ∆Gvr (Figure 5.4). The nature of the surfactant/droplet affinity and the nature of the continuous phase will dictate the overall repulsion or attraction interactions leading to droplet repulsion or coalescence. In cases of “poor” solvent or the bulk solvency decreasing toward the dispersed phase, a significant minimal value of the total free energy of interaction can be reached. Steric stabilization becomes a dominant factor when polymeric amphiphiles are used as surfactants. The polymeric chains act to cover and stabilize mainly the globules by adsorbing onto the external interface (Ortega-Vinuesa et al., 1996; Myers, 1998a; Benichou et al., 2002a). 5.4.2
Depletion Stabilization (Myers, 1998a)
Depletion force is expected to occur whenever nonadsorbing polymer is added to a colloidal dispersion. A polymer chain in solution will keep, on average, a configuration that is entropically most favorable. The polymer may approach a surface to a distance such that its farthest segments just meet the surface. To approach more closely, the polymer must adopt a less favorable conformation with a resulting loss of configurational entropy and also loss of system stability. The distance between two droplets or colloidal dispersion determines the depletion force as well. A gradient of polymer segmental concentration exists in the surface area. Depletion attraction arises when the depletion layers, each of thickness ∆ (or Rg), associated with two surfaces, overlap. Theoretically, at large separations (D > 2∆ ), the segment concentration increases from zero at the surface to that of the bulk solution in the middle of the gap between the surfaces. However, at smaller separations (D < 2∆), the concentration at the midplane falls below that of the bulk. As a result the pressure in the bulk solution is greater than that in the gap, and there is an attractive osmotic force between the surfaces (Kuhl et al., 1998).
INSTABILITY CONSIDERATIONS
91
The first researchers to relate particle flocculation in the presence of nonadsorbing macromolecules were Asakura and Oosawa (1954). They proposed that the destabilization is due to a differential osmotic pressure setup once the macromolecules are excluded from the region between the particles. Other researchers contributed to understanding the depletion stability. Vincent et al. (Fleer et al., 1984) interpreted the destabilization of colloidal dispersions that occurs at high polymer concentrations to be due to a decrease in the depletion layer thickness, resulting in a weakened attraction. Some years earlier Feigin and Napper (1980) had attributed depletion stabilization to a repulsive force due to the high energy cost of demixing the solution prior to the onset of the attractive regime. Walz and Sharma (1994) later predicted a repulsive barrier at separations between one and two diameters of the excluded macromolecule due to excluded volume effects when second-order interactions are taken into account. Mao et al. (1995a, b) and more recently Mezzenga et al. (2004) have shown that excluded volume considerations can lead to a repulsive force regime between particles in semidilute concentrations of smaller nonabsorbent particles. When the excluded particles are rod shaped, the repulsive barrier is greatly enhanced, leading to kinetic stabilization. 5.4.3
Electrostatic Stabilization
The electrostatic stabilization mechanism is well documented for simple O/W emulsions (Myers, 1998a). Multiple emulsion droplets are much larger in size, and therefore the repulsive electrostatic forces are less pronounced (Figure 5.5).
5.5
INSTABILITY CONSIDERATIONS
In addition to the common instability of multiple emulsions, there are two instabilities related to polymeric surfactants. The common destabilization mechanisms are demonstrated in Figure 5.6 and include aggregation, flocculation, and coalescence (Mezzenga et al., 2004).
Figure 5.5
Multiple emulsion repulsive electrostatic forces.
92
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Figure 5.6 Schematic representation of possible instabilities occurring in W/O/W multiple emulsions (Mezzenga et al., 2004).
The other destabilization mechanisms are related, for example, to uncontrolled transport of the inner phase, the inner emulsifiers, and the inner addenda. Water as well as solubilized molecules can be transported across the oil layer (in W/O/W emulsions) from the inner phase to the outer phase or in the opposite direction, depending on the osmotic pressure gradient between the two aqueous phases (Wen and Papadopoulos, 2001). Water transported from the inner phase empties the inner droplets, and turns the W/O/W multiple emulsion globules into a simple O/W emulsion. Transport of water from the continuous phase to the inner phase may cause an internal “explosion” of the aqueous phase. In addition, the use of polymeric amphiphiles may be beneficial but is mostly problematic because of two additional possible typical destabilization pathways that can occur in these systems, namely depletion and bridging flocculation. 5.5.1
Depletion Flocculation
Polymeric amphiphiles, even when they are not adsorbed to the droplet interfaces, provide an entropic effect that can expressed as a change in viscosity. Depletion flocculation occurs because the center of mass of the depleting agent (the polymers) will not approach the droplet more closely than its effective radius (as mentioned before). Hence there is an area around the droplet that is not accessible to the polymer because of its reduced entropy. If the total depletion volume of the droplets is reduced by the overlap of their depletion zones, the excluded volume is decreased, and the volume accessible to the polymer is increased, increasing its entropy. The attractive force that appears
INSTABILITY CONSIDERATIONS
a
93
h Rg or ∆ (a)
(b)
Figure 5.7 Schematic diagram illustrating depletion flocculation. (a) Two large spheres (radius a) separated by a surface. Surface distance h possesses a depletion layer (∆) with a thickness of the order of the radius Rg of the nonadsorbed species (dashed circle). (b) Osmotic pressure of the external medium pushes the large spheres together in the directions of the arrows. For clarity, this diagram is not to scale: the size ratio of large spheres to nonadsorbed species is typically considerably greater (Radford and Dickinson, 2004).
between the droplets leads to their flocculation. The force holding the flocs together is weak and reversible, however, and the flocculation can be readily redispersed by mixing (Figure 5.7) (Jerdjev et al., 2006). Droplets that are flocculated will not coalesce but can aggregate into flocs and will have a strong tendency to cream. 5.5.2
Bridging Flocculation
If a very high molecular weight polymer is added to the dispersion system, the various possible points of attachment can encounter two different droplets rather than attaching themselves to the same droplet. That is especially the case where there is a large excess of droplets relative to the concentration of polymer. Attachment of the same polymer chain to two droplets essentially bridges them, resulting in droplet flocculation (Figure 5.8) (Myers, 1998b).
94
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
(a)
(b)
Particle
Polymer
(c)
Figure 5.8 Schematic representation of three alternative effects of the adsorption of stiff hydrocolloid polymers on the surface of spherical emulsion droplets, depending on the hydrocolloid concentration and the nature of the hydrocolloid–protein interaction: (a) A sterically stabilized system, (b) an emulsion gel, and (c) a system flocculated by macromolecular bridging (Dickinson, 2003).
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Figure 5.9
5.6
95
Illustration of creaming phenomenon.
CREAMING PHENOMENON
Other instabilities in W/O/W multiple emulsions are related to the creaming phenomenon—creaming of the oil globules in the continuous aqueous phase (Figure 5.9). The creaming phenomenon depends on oil droplet size, continuous aqueous phase viscosity, and density differences, according to Stocks law. For monodispersed droplets, creaming rate is depicted by v = 2gr2(ρ1 – ρ2)/9η, and for polydispersed droplets v = [Σ8π/27ηV] [gnir5(ρ1 – ρ2)], where g is the gravimetric constant, r is the radius of the droplets, ρ1 – ρ2 is the density difference between the dispersed phase and the continuous phase, and η is the viscosity of the continuous (dispersion) phase (Shields et al., 2001). Reducing the oil globule size, increasing the continuous aqueous phase viscosity, and reducing density differences will minimize the creaming phenomenon. The most common solution for creaming is the use of polymeric amphiphile or polymeric nonadsorbing compounds that increase the viscosity of the external aqueous phase and retard (or slow down) creaming of the W/O globules.
5.7
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Synthetic amphiphilic polymers are not food-grade systems, and therefore naturally occurring biopolymers must be utilized. Proteins, lipoproteins, and polysaccharides are food-grade molecules and can be used as emulsifiers as well as depletion stabilizers. Various proteins have been utilized for several decades as emulsifiers. Some of the more common are bovine serum albumin (BSA), casein, egg albumin,
96
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
TABLE 5.1 General characteristics and differences between proteins and polysaccharides as functional biopolymers in food systems Protein
Polysaccharides Similarities Natural polymers Widespread in food colloids Environmentally friendly polymer Used in pharmaceuticals, cosmetic, personal products Complicated structure Complex aggregation behavior Gelling/stabilizing agents Differences
Wide-ranging structures Reactive Monodisperse Many segment types Linear chain Flexible chain Medium molecular weight Small molecular volume Amphiphilic Surface active Polyelectrolyte Emulsifying/foaming Temperature sensitive Strong surfactant binding
Similar structures Unreactive Polydisperse Few segment types Linear or branched Rigid chain High molecular weight Large molecular volume Hydrophilic Not surface active Non-ionic or charged Thickening/water holding Temperature insensitive Weak surfactant binding
Source: Dickinson (2003).
whey proteins, soy proteins, and lysozyme, most of which have been used in both simple O/W emulsions and in multiple emulsions. Hydrocolloids are high-molecular-weight hydrophilic biopolymers used as functional ingredients in the food industry for the control of viscosity, gelation, microstructure, texture, flavor, and shelf-life. The term hydrocolloid encompasses all the polysaccharides that are extracted from plants, seaweeds, and microbial sources, as well as gums derived from plant exudates, and modified biopolymers made by chemical or enzymatic treatment to be soluble or dispersible in water. The general molecular and functional properties of proteins and polysaccharides are compared in Table 5.1. In the formulation of emulsion systems, one normally distinguishes between two types of ingredients: proteins are considered to be the emulsifying agent (or emulsifier) and hydrocolloids are considered to be stabilizers. There is a debate in the literature as to whether hydrocolloids can serve as emulsifying agents. Several authors claim that except for some specific hydrocolloids (e.g.,
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
97
gum arabic, and acetylated pectin), most serve as stabilizers, and those that exhibit surface activity contain proteins at various levels, or even as traces, that are the hydrophobic part of the emulsifier (Bergenstähl, 1997). Others claim that some hydrocolloids, despite their hydrophilicity and structural rigidity, can under certain conditions adsorb onto oil droplets and serve as emulsifiers. These authors are genuinely convinced that this surface activity is an intrinsic property of the polysaccharide itself (Garti and Reichman, 1994; Garti et al., 1997). 5.7.1
Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Proteins
The use of proteins as macromolecular amphiphiles was adopted long ago by scientists exploring the stability of multiple emulsions. Gelatin (Zhang et al., 1992), whey proteins (Cornec et al., 1998), bovine serum albumin (BSA) (Dickinson et al., 1991; Fredrokumbaradzi and Simov, 1992), human serum albumin (HSA), caseins, and other proteins have been evaluated. In many cases the proteins were used in combination with other monomeric emulsifiers, especially when proteins were used in the internal phase. However, whether the adsorption is competitive or complementary remains a controversial question (Wilde and Clark, 1993; Kerstens et al., 2006). Research on the use of protein to improve the stability of multiple emulsions deals with proteins present (or adsorbed) in the inner phase as a surfactant or as encapsulating agent, or at the outer aqueous phase as a surfactant. Omotosho et al. (1986) were the first to study the influence of BSA with a nonionic surfactant in the inner aqueous phase to stabilize W/O/W emulsions. They concluded that interfacial complexation between BSA and the non-ionic surfactant occurs at the inner W/O interface. This complex membrane has been found to enhance the stability of multiple emulsions and to slow down release of solute entrapped within the emulsion droplets. BSA has been investigated as a replacement for some of the monomeric surfactants in the inner phase and found to provide good stabilization for W/O/W multiple emulsions (Fredrokumbaradzi and Simov, 1992; Evison et al., 1995). Koberstein-Hajda and Dickinson (1996) incorporated unmodified faba protein into the inner aqueous phase using sorbitan monooleate (Span 80) as a hydrophobic emulsifier and sodium caseinate as a hydrophilic emulsifier. The authors concluded that encapsulation of the inner phase with caseinate and a small quantity of Span 80 did not improve stability of the multiple emulsion, while increasing the protein and the Span 80 content improved both yield and stability. Maydani (1994) have used lysozyme with monomeric emulsifiers, in both the inner and the outer interfaces. The multiple emulsions with lysozyme tend to coalescence and not create a sealed interfacial layer, probably because lysozyme is considered a small protein, and it can anchor well at the interface between oil and water (Maydani, 1994). The authors of this review (Garti et al., 1994) also investigated the use of BSA along with monomeric emulsifiers, in both the inner and the outer
98
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
interfaces (in low concentrations of up to 0.2 wt%). They found significant improvement in stability and a delay in release of markers, compared to multiple emulsions stabilized by BSA as an external phase emulsifier alone. It was postulated that although BSA has no stability effect at the inner phase, it has a strong effect on the release of the markers. On the other hand, BSA, when utilized as an external emulsifier together with small amounts of monomeric emulsifiers (or hydrocolloids), was found to be a good steric stabilizer and to improve the stability and shelf-life of the multiple emulsions, and to slow down the release of the markers through the external interface. The release of the marker was found to take place mainly via reverse micellar transport. It was concluded that BSA reduces the chance of reverse micelle formation in the oil phase, thus reducing the release rate. It was concluded that BSA can play a double role in multiple emulsions; it is a film-former, enhancing steric stabilization and providing a barrier to the release of small molecules from the internal interface, and a steric stabilizer at the external interface. Su et al. (2006) recently investigated the influence of polyglycerol polyricinoleic acid (PGPR) alone and in combination with sodium caseinate as emulsifier for primary water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions and caseinate as the sole emulsifier for secondary W/O/W emulsion. It was proposed that casein forms either an extra film around the internal water droplets or a complex with the existing emulsifiers. An improved preparation yield, higher stability, and unchanged W/O/W emulsion droplet size were reported. It was suggested that synergistic effect could have stabilized the primary W/O emulsion interface against coalescence in the presence of both PGPR and sodium caseinate as hydrophobic emulsifiers. A reduction in droplet size was observed upon increasing the caseinate concentration from 0.03 to 1% (w/v) (Figure 5.10). At 0.03% (w/v) caseinate some of the oil droplets were outside the range of the Mastersizer, indicating coalesced oil droplets greater than 50 µm. Confocal microscopy showed the presence of several flocculated droplets in the W/O/W emulsion prepared at low concentrations of caseinate (Figure 5.11a and b), while flocculation was not observed in W/O/W emulsions prepared with 0.5% (w/v) caseinate in the external aqueous phase (Figure 5.11c and d). The droplet size of all W/O/W emulsions showed no significant change after storage for four weeks at 20°C. Inserting 0.5% (w/v) caseinate to the inner phase allowed reduction of the PGPR content from 8 to 2 wt% without affecting the yield or the stability of the multiple emulsion. The use of casein allowed replacement of part of the PGPR (which is nonfriendly in food applications) by caseinates. The combination of PGPR and caseinate may produce a more viscoelastic adsorbed layer, thereby preventing the release of the dye from the internal aqueous phase to the external aqueous phase, as investigated by the authors. This conclusion is in good agreement with Garti et al. in the BSA study (Su et al., 2006). Dickinson et al. (1994) also prepared stable food grade W/O/W emulsions with, sodium caseinate and the polyglycerol ester of polyricinoleic acid (PGPR) as the hydrophobic emulsifier. They showed that when caseinate concentration
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
99
1.8 1.6
d32 (µm)
1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 Concentration of sodium caseinate in external aqueous phase (%, W/V)
Figure 5.10 Effect of sodium caseinate concentration in external aqueous phase on droplet size (d32) of W/O/W emulsions prepared with 2 (■), 4 (▲), and 6% w/v () PGPR in the oil phase. Error bars represent standard deviation (Su et al., 2006).
(a)
(c)
(b)
(d)
Figure 5.11 (a, b) Confocal microscopy images of freshly prepared W/O/W emulsions at 0.09% w/v caseinate at the external phase; (c, d) confocal microscopy images of freshly prepared W/O/W emulsions at 2% (w/v) caseinate at the external phase. Scale bar represents 5 µm (Su et al., 2006).
100
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
was increased from 0.125 to 1 wt%, the droplet size decreased from around 1.4 to around 0.85 µm, and resulted in a finer emulsion that was more stable against creaming. From the release curves it seems that the marker transport is more controlled. Proteins cannot completely replace hydrophobic monomeric emulsifiers in the inner phase of multiple emulsions (Dickinson et al., 1994). However, proteins in combination with other stabilizers do have the capacity to enhance the stability of multiple emulsions, mainly by encapsulating the inner phase and thereby substantially reducing the hydrophobic emulsifier concentration. Protein in the external phase can enhance the multiple emulsion stability without the addition of any emulsifier or stabilizer. Multiple emulsion stability was significantly improved in the presence of amphiphilic proteins because of two important factors. First, the multianchoring flexible macromolecules act to improve the steric stabilization by forming a thick multilayered coating on the droplets. Second, the proteins used in the inner phase create a mechanical film barrier that prevents uncontrolled release of the entrapped ingredients.
5.7.2
Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Hydrocolloids
Most often hydrocolloids are added to the multiple emulsion in order to increase the viscosity of the inner or the outer phase. Florence and Whitehill (1985) suggested three pathways to reduce the mobility of ingredients in multiple emulsions: 1. Use of highly viscous oil to prevent diffusion of water/surfactant/active material from the inner phase. 2. Gelation of the oily or aqueous phase, also known as the encapsulated method. 3. Polymerization of the interfacial adsorbed surfactant molecules. The two first pathways essentially involve depletion stabilization, whereas the interfacial polymerization of the third pathway involves some steric stabilization. All three options are found to form semisolid or gel-like formulations. The most common gel-like multiple emulsions are primarily those used in cosmetic creams, and are not applicable in nonviscous diluted emulsions such as beverages. Use of High Viscosity Oil Recently Weiss et al. (2005) investigated the possibility of using a semicrystalline oil phase in W/O/gel to control the release of encapsulated hydrophilic compounds from polysaccharide gels with multiple emulsions. Various lipid phases prevent the diffusion of water/surfactant/ active material from the inner phase and also gelation of the oily or aqueous phase. For example, MCT-oil and various vegetable fats were investigated for
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
101
Figure 5.12 Relative release of tryptophan (%) from emulsion gels compared to gels prepared without multiple emulsions of Witocan (Wit), Chocosine (Choc), Crokcool (Crok), and Hardstock (Hard) (=100% during a period of 24 hours). Effects of the lipid phase were observed at environmental temperatures of 7°C and 23°C (Weiss et al., 2005).
their ability to act as a hydrophobic barrier in the oil phase. The content PGPR (hydrophobic surfactant) in the inner W/O emulsions was varied. In order to create W/O/gel, the W/O/W was homogenized in a Ca2+-alginate gel containing maltodextrin as bulking agent. An increase in encapsulation efficacy was observed when various lipids were used for multiple emulsion preparation, rather than pure water; even the system containing pure MCT-oil (including 2% PGPR) showed a comparably lower relative release of the marker (94%) (Figure 5.12). The cumulative release of tryptophan from multiple emulsion gels varying in composition, recorded over a storage period of 24 hours in pure water, is summarized in Figure 5.12. At 23°C, the lowest release rate was observed in Witocan (Wit) and the highest melting point in fat (Figure 5.12). Reducing the temperature from 23°C to 7°C caused a reduction in the release rate of the marker. A significant reduction in encapsulation efficiency was obtained by increasing the oil phase content. Gelation of the Outer Aqueous Phase (W/O/Gel) Most of the additives inserted in the multiple emulsions under study are not permitted in foods. Viscosities were found to be enhanced by cellulose derivatives such as hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC), hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose (HPMC), hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC), and the natural hydrocolloids, such as xanthan, guar gum, and carrageenan. The viscosity or gelling agents can affect some of the multiple emulsion properties such as entrapping yields, stability, droplet size, consistency, and skin feel (Ozer et al., 2000).
102
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
An interesting study by Muguet et al. (2001) in which multiple emulsions were stabilized by viscosity-increasing agents or gelling agents, such as hydroxypropyl cellulose in the outer aqueous phase, has shown that the release process is moderated by these agents but the globules will still break under shear. The emulsifiers were fit to a Taylor theoretical framework so that the bursting mechanisms of the globules under shear were the same for any composition of multiple emulsions. This way stability and release could be controlled by the shear. In a recent study by Kanouni et al. (2002), Abil EM90 (polysiloxane, cetyldimethicone copolyol) was used in the inner water phase. The outer phase contained betaine and SDS in combination with hydrophilic surfactants, and xanthan gum served as the stabilizer (viscosity agent). From microscopic observations along with surface isotherms linked to rheology measurements, Kanouni and colleagues concluded that in the inner phase, it is essential to use a low-HLB surfactant so that the resulting expandable and compressible interfacial layers are irreversibly adsorbed. Long-term stability requires, in addition, a balance between Laplace and osmotic pressures between W1 droplets and the oil phase. Small quantities of salt in the inner phase can balance the excess pressure. As for the outer phase, it was concluded that the presence of thickener in the W2 phase is necessary in order to reach a viscosity ratio (permeability ≈ 1) between W1/O and W2 that allows dispersion of the viscous primary emulsion into the W2 aqueous phase. Because the interactions between the low- and high-HLB emulsifiers at the O/W2 interface do not destabilize the films, they suggested using the high-HLB surfactant (betaine derivative) in combination with an anionic surfactant (SLES, sodium lauryl ether sulfate) as the blend of emulsifiers for the external interface. The thick interfacial layer and the viscous or gelled aqueous phase might have some advantages when protection of sensitive addenda is required. Kim et al. (2003) treated the internal aqueous phase with hydroxypropyl-betacyclodextrin (to make the internal aqueous phase more hydrophilic) and introduced kojic acid (5-hydroxy-2-(hydroxymethyl)-4-pyrone) as a model antioxidant. The multiple emulsions were also stabilized sterically by addition of xanthan gum into the external aqueous phase. The authors found improved stability against coalescence and improved chemical stability. The stability of kojic acid could be maintained at 90% for 10 weeks (Figure 5.13). Polymerization of the Interfacial Adsorbed Surfactant Molecules Chitosan has surface activity that seems to stabilize W/O/W emulsions. Chitosan reacts with anionic emulsifiers such as SDS at certain ratios to form a water-insoluble complex that has strong emulsification capabilities. Chitosan solution was used to form multiple emulsions of O/W/O as intermediates from which, by a simple procedure of striping the water, the authors formed interesting porous spherical particles of chitosan (Schulz et al., 1998; Adachi et al., 1999). Cyclodextrins (α, β, and γ) (Figure 5.14) have been shown to be potential stabilizers for O/W/O emulsions (Yu et al., 1999). The advantages of the
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
103
Figure 5.13 Stability of kojic acid over time under different conditions: Emulsion formulation, concentration, and storage temperature. The pH of the formulation was adjusted to 3.7 with lactic acid (Kim et al., 2003).
(a)
(b)
Figure 5.14 Chemical representation of a glucopyranose unit of a CD molecule. (a) The secondary hydroxyls at the 2- and 3-positions exist on the secondary face, and the primary hydroxyls at the 6-position exist on the primary face. (b) Schematic representation of a CD cross section with carbon atom numerotation (Shan-Chen et al., 2003).
104
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
cyclodextrins are their ability to complex with certain oil components at the oil/water interface, and so no additional surfactant is needed. It appears that the stabilization efficacy depends on the nature of the oil and the type of cyclodextrin (α > β > γ). The presence of any active matter in the inner phase destabilizes the emulsion. However, only the α-cyclodextrin yielded stable emulsions because the interfacial interaction between the components present at the interface changed the HLB and caused a destabilization effect. So this elegant idea of interfacial complexation between the oil components and the surfactant cannot be a universal solution. The idea suffers from very severe intrinsic disadvantages as each different additive is included in the emulsion. For every additive at any concentration, an adjustment must be made; a given cyclodextrin or complexing agent is not necessarily totally fit. In a more recent article, Shan-Chen et al. (2003) encapsulate camphor (CA) in oil/water/oil multiple emulsions prepared with cyclodextrin (CD). The O/ W/O stabilized by CD/CA as an emulsifier was not perfectly stable. After storage of 20 days at 20°C, only the α-CD emulsion without CA was perfectly stable (Table 5.2). O/W/O multiple emulsions can be prepared in the absence of classical surfactants, and by using appropriate α and β CD. The conditions of emulsion stability in the presence of a lipophilic active ingredient, or any additive, depend on possible competition between the lipophilic molecule and the fatty acid residues of triglycerides to enter the CD cavity. Vaziri and Warburton (1994) investigated the effects of different combinations of surfactants (Span 80 and Tween 80) and hydrocolloids (acacia and gelatin) on the release rate and stability of multiple emulsions. The combination of surfactants produced stable systems and more prolonged release because a better interfacial film was formed by the emulsifiers compared with that of the multiple emulsions in which each surfactant was employed individually (see Figure 5.15 and Table 5.3). The enhanced stabilization can also be attributed to the protein content in the acacia gum. The protein provided strong adsorption interaction with the oil-water interface during emulsification. Mechanical Stabilization by Microcrystalline Cellulose Some attempts have been made to improve the shelf-life of multiple emulsions by incorporating small solid particles in the surfactant formulations. The idea was to allow the particles to adsorb onto the oil droplets so that they can provide a mechanical barrier against coalescence (Aveyard et al., 2003). Oza and Frank (1989) were the first to develop the concept by using colloidal microcrystalline cellulose (MCC) instead of water-soluble surfactant in W/O/W emulsions containing oil-soluble hydrophobic surfactants (Spans). Emulsions, stable for up to 1 month, contained a network of MCC particles adsorbed at the outer oil–water interface. Kim et al. (2005) improved the storage stability of antagonistic microorganisms by encapsulating them in W/O/W multiple emulsions stabilized by MCC. MCC was very useful in obtaining a multiple emulsion with excellent stability, exhibiting better storage stability. The activity of the antagonistic microorganism was better than in trials without multiple emulsions.
105
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
TABLE 5.2
Multiple emulsion without CA Multiple emulsion with CA
Multiple emulsion stability after storage for 20 days, at 4°C, 20°C, and 40°C α−CD Multiple Emulsion
β−CD Multiple Emulsion
γ−CD Multiple Emulsion
4°C
40°C
4°C
20°C
40°C
4°C
20°C
40°C
20°C
Stable
Stable
3% WPS
Stable
Some oil exuded
5% WPS*
Stable
Some oil exuded
2% WPS
Stable
3% oil phase exuded
11% WPS
Stable
Some oil exuded
9% WPS*
Stable
Some oil exuded
2% WPS
Source: Shan-Chen et al. (2003). Note: At WPS (waxy phase separation) of the total multiple emulsions the liquid state at 40°C becomes solid at 20°C.
Figure 5.15
Release of chloroquine diphosphate from W/O/W emulsions (Vaziri and Warburton, 1994).
TABLE 5.3 Formulation of olive oil W/O/W multiple emulsion containing chloroquine diphosphate (Vaziri and Warburton, 1994) Oily Phase Surfactant
Inner Aqueous Phase Symbol
Outer Aqueous Phase
Gelatin
Acacia
Tween 80
Span 80
Gelatin
Acacia
Tween 80
+ + − − + +
− − + + + +
− + − + − +
+ + + + + +
+ + − − + +
− − + + + +
− + − + − +
106
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Garti et al. (1999) used the submicron crystalline fat particle α form of triglycerides as hydrophilic emulsifiers in the outer interface of W/O/W emulsions in combination with other surfactants and achieved a significant improvement in stability over systems that contained just the emulsifiers. Hydrocolloids significantly improve the stability of multiple emulsions because they help encapsulate better the inner aqueous phase, preventing uncontrolled release of the entrapped ingredients. Stabilization of the multiple emulsion is achieved mainly by depletion stabilization. However, hydrocolloids significantly affect viscosity and the rheology of a multiple emulsion.
5.7.3 Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Hybrid of Proteins and Hydrocolloids W/O/W Under certain conditions some proteins and polysaccharides form hybrids (complexes) with enhanced functional properties compared to the proteins and polysaccharides alone. Conversely, electrostatic complexing between oppositely charged proteins and polysaccharides allows better anchoring of the newly formed macromolecular amphiphile onto the oil–water interfaces. Interaction between Protein and Hydrocolloids in an Aqueous Solution Mixing two aqueous solutions of biopolymer may yield one of the structures depicted in Figure 5.16. Interactions between the two polymers can be segregative or associative. For instance, for very dilute solutions the proteins and polysaccharides form a solution-like aqueous system. With increasing concentrations of each component, the system becomes unstable; in some cases biopolymer mixtures tend to segregate. For polymers of similar and extended structures, this trend is usually attributed to repulsive interactions among the polymer segments. For polymers with dissimilar shape and structure, segregation leads to a local reduction in concentration of one of the polymers in the area of the second one, due to a decrease of conformational entropy of macromolecules at the interface boundary (depletion phenomenon). Segregation has also been observed under associative interaction between the two biopolymers. In this case the polysaccharide molecules can adsorb onto protein and even bridge several protein molecules (complex coacervation). In an aqueous solution, electrostatic attraction causes complex coacervation between two oppositely charged polymers. For instance, the complexation between the proteins and anionic polysaccharides occurs below the protein isoelectric point and at low ionic strengths. Factors that influence compatibility and complex formation are protein/polysaccharide ratio, pH, ionic strength, and the nature of the polymers (molecular weight, net charge, ternary structure, and flexibility of chains). Under certain conditions proteins and polysaccharides form hybrids (complexes) with enhanced interfacial properties compared to the proteins
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
Protein
107
Hydrocolloid
Mixing (ionic strength, pH, ratio) Complex
Onephase system
Twophase system
Incompatibility
Onephase system
Twophase system
Figure 5.16 Illustration of water–protein–polysaccharide mixtures describing the different types of interactions between the protein and the polysaccharide in aqueous medium.
and polysaccharides alone, where uncomplexed blends of biopolymers are formed. Electrostatic complexation between oppositely charged proteins and polysaccharides allows better anchoring of the newly formed macromolecular amphiphile onto oil/water interfaces (Grinberg and Tolstoguzov, 1997; Tolstoguzov, 2003; Benichou et al., 2004). Numerous articles have been written on the interaction between proteins and hydrocolloids in aqueous solution and research aspects of this technology (Grinberg and Tolstoguzov, 1997; Tolstoguzov, 2003; Benichou et al., 2004; Ibanoglu, 2005; Ribotta et al., 2005; Uruakpa and Arntfield, 2006; Nunes et al., 2006). Multiple Emulsion Stabilized by Hybrid of Protein (WPI) and Hydrocolloids In our most recent studies (Benichou et al., 2002b), we demonstrated that proteins (BSA, WPI, caseins) are capable of forming soluble complexes (hybrids) with certain hydrocolloids (xanthan, guar, LBG).
108
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
The complex is an amphiphilic macromolecule that strongly adsorbs onto the oil/water outer interface and upon severe shear forms smaller globules with improved stability over multiple emulsions stabilized by protein alone. Benichou et al. (2002b) were the first to study the influence of WPI and xanthan hybrids on multiple emulsion stability. Additional information on the advantages of such systems will be published shortly. Effect of WPI/Hydrocolloid Ratio on the Multiple Emulsion The ratio between proteins and hydrocolloids is one of the factors that influences the formation of the hybrid. Phase diagrams are constructed (data not shown) to determine various compositions along the isotropic clear regions; the best ratio for hybrid formation is 4 parts of WPI to 0.5 parts of hydrocolloid, by weight. The effect of the WPI/xanthan or WPI/modified pectin (MP) (Garti and Wicker, 2005) ratio on stability of W/O/W multiple emulsions was examined (Tables 5.4 and 5.5) Addition of hydrocolloids caused significant improvement, mainly to the multiple emulsion droplet sizes. The droplets were smaller in comparison to droplets of multiple emulsions prepared solely with WPI. Multiple emulsion droplets stabilized with WPI and pectins are one-third the size
TABLE 5.4 Globule size distribution of multiple emulsions made with WPI (whey protein isolate), xanthan gum, LBG (locust bean gum), and blends (hybrids) of the gums with WPI at their optimum ratios WPI 4 wt%
Xanthan Gum 0.5 wt%
LBG 0.5 wt%
WPI/Xanthan 4/0.5
WPI/LBG 4/0.5
12.0 10.8
23.4 19.8
28.4 23.6
3.3 3.1
4.8 4.0
d43 (µm) d90 (µm)
Source: Benichou et al. (2002b). Note: d90: average droplet diameter of 90% of the droplets; d43: average droplet diameter r, which is calculated as d(4, 3) = Σ i ni di4 Σ i ni di3 .
TABLE 5.5 Globule size distribution of multiple emulsions made with WPI (whey protein isolate), modified pectin, and blends (hybrids) of the gums with WPI at their optimum ratios External Phase t = 0 (µm) t = 20 days (µm) 25°C
WPI/MP 4 : 1 (wt/wt)
WPI/MP 4 : 0.5 (wt/wt)
WPI/MP 4 : 0.1 (wt/wt)
WPI/MP 4 : 0 (wt/wt)
4.6 5.6
4.6 6.6
4.7 7.2
14.5 10.6
Source: Garti and Wicker (2005). Note: The internal phase in all the systems consists of 30 wt% water (17 wt% glucose) at pH 6, 10% PGPR, and 60% R(+)-limonene.
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
109
of droplets stabilized with only WPI (ca. 5 µm for WPI/pectin and ca. 14.5 µm for WPI). Systems based on WPI/xanthan yielded multiple emulsions with droplets one-fourth smaller in comparison to droplets derived from WPI alone and one-eighth smaller compared to multiple emulsions prepared from xanthan alone. Emulsions can behave like microcapsules, microspheres, or mesophasic lyotropic liquid crystals, since the interfacial film is rather thick and, in most cases, multilayered. Increasing the xanthan content in the WPI/xanthan system to 1 wt% in the external aqueous phase decreases droplet diameter from 11.8 to 3.1 µm (Figure 5.17), but no significant improvement in droplet size occurs between ratios of 4 to 0.5 and 4 to 1. It was also found that by increasing the protein-to-polysaccharide ratio, the multiple emulsion droplets were smaller and stability was increased. The WPI/pectin droplet sizes immediately after preparation were not independent of the WPI/pectin ratio and were around 5 µm in size. Similarly no significant droplet size change was observed after aging, independent of the ratio of the protein to the gum, indicating that the droplets were well protected from coalescence. On the other hand, in multiple emulsions stabilized with WPI alone, the droplet size decreased with time from 14.6 to 10.5 µm after 20 days, probably due to internal aqueous phase explosion. As the ratio WPI/MP decreases (e.g., to a 4 to 0.1 wt ratio), the multiple emulsion droplet size can increase from 4.7 to 7.2 µm after 20 days. Lack of exhibited hydrocolloid is attributed to the weakness of the emulsifier film adsorbed onto the external oil-water interface, as reported in the case of multiple emulsions stabilized with pure WPI (Uruakpa and Arntfield, 2005).
Figure 5.17 WPI/xanthan gum ratio (wt/wt) influence on the droplet diameter (µm) of multiple emulsion droplets, immediately after preparation (Benichou et al., 2002b).
110
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Integral light transmission (%)
50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
1000
2000
3000 Time (s)
4000
5000
6000
Figure 5.18 Integral light transmission as a function of time (seconds), as measured by LUMiFuge, in multiple emulsions stabilized with 70 wt% of WPI/MP at different ratios: 4/0.1 wt/wt (), 4/0.5 wt/wt (), and 4/1 wt/wt (+), at pH 6, after preparation. 30 wt% of the inner emulsion contains 30 wt% water (17 wt% glucose), pH 6, 10 wt% PGPR, 60 wt% R(+)-limonene (Garti and Wicker, 2005).
At a biopolymer content greater than that required for complex formation, the addition of one of the two biopolymers will only slightly affect the multiple emulsion droplet stability, and will add only a small depletion stabilizing effect to the emulsion droplets. In WPI/pectin, complex formation occurs at a 4 to 0.1 ratio; in WPI/xanthan, the hybrid formation is at a 4 to 0.5 ratio. Thus there is no change in the multiple emulsion droplets in the WPI/pectin ratio from ratio 4/0.1, while in the WPI/xanthan there is change only at a 4/0.5 ratio. The improved stability of the multiple emulsion is related to depletion stabilization, meaning there is less creaming. Stability against creaming, as measured by LUMiFuge, is significantly influenced by the WPI/pectin ratio (Figure 5.18), which describes a set of integrals of light transmission through the sample as a function of time. There is no change in the integral light transmission over 6000 seconds at 2500 rpm for multiple emulsions stabilized with WPI/MP ratios of 4/0.5 and 4/0.1. On the contrary, there is a rapid increase in the integral transmission in the system stabilized with a 4/0.1 ratio. In the 4 to 0.1 wt ratio system, the serum layer thickness is about 30% (Figure 5.18). At low pectin levels, the system is very unstable with respect to creaming and creams immediately after preparation. However, multiple emulsions stabilized with WPI/pectin in ratios of 4/0.5 and 4/1 are stable to creaming. Creaming stability depends on the type of conjugated WPI/pectin, as studied above, and also the viscosity of the multiple emulsion systems and specific gravity differ-
Viscosity (Pa*s)
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
0
10
20
30
40
111
50
Gp (1/s)
Figure 5.19 Viscosity as a function of shear rate in multiple emulsions stabilized by various ratios of WPI/MP multiple emulsion: 4/0.1 (), 4/0.5 (), and 4/1 (), at pH 6, 20°C. The inner emulsion contains 30 wt% water (17 wt% glucose), pH 6, 10 wt% PGPR, and 60 wt% R(+)-limonene (Garti and Wicker, 2005).
ences between the droplets. Multiple emulsion viscosity as a function of shear rate is summarized in Figure 5.19. The viscosities of all the systems decrease with the shear rate, which is typical of non-Newtonian flow behavior of multiple emulsion systems (Jiao and Burgess, 2003). Increasing the modified pectin content leads to an increase in multiple emulsion viscosity, producing a shear rate of 0 to 50 s−1. For a shear rate of 10 s−1, the viscosity of multiple emulsion stabilized with a 4 to 0.1 ratio is 3.21 Pa·s. For a 4 to 0.5 ratio, the viscosity is 9.25 Pa·s, and for a 4 to 1 ratio, the highest viscosity measured is 10.16 Pa·s. This trend is seen throughout the shear rate range – increasing the viscosity of multiple emulsions stabilized the multiple emulsions by depletion stabilization. Increasing levels of the modified pectin in the blends stabilizes the multiple emulsion. This is probably due to steric stabilization, resulting from the formation of strongly conjugated WPI/modified pectin in addition to the depletion stabilization. This is evidenced by the viscosity enhancement of the outer phase of the multiple emulsion. Rheological studies can provide useful information on the stability and internal microstructure of the multiple emulsions. Some attention was given to this subject in recent years, and the results help clarify certain aspects of stability and release properties of the multiple emulsions (Benichou et al., 2002b). Oscillatory dynamic tests and steady-state analyses, and parameters such as shear or complex modulus (G*), the lag phase between stress and strain (δ), the storage modulus (G′), and the loss modulus (G″), provide quantitative characterization of the balance between the viscous and elastic properties of the multiple emulsions. Oscillatory measurements generally indicate that multiple emulsions are predominantly viscous in that the loss modulus
112
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
falls above the storage modulus over the entire frequency range investigated. Upon aging, the storage and loss moduli of the multiple emulsions show a significant increase. Rheological measurements were performed on multiple emulsion droplets stabilized with WPI-xanthan gum hybrids. The phase angle δ was defined as Arctan(G″/G′), where G′ is the storage modulus, G″ is the loss modulus, and tan(δ) = G″/G′. It was found that at low levels of gum (0.1 wt%), the emulsions had high viscosity, with phase angle (δ) close to 90°, indicating self-assembly of the two biopolymers onto the external oil–water interface. It was suggested that the emulsion droplets are mainly stabilized by steric interactions between the macromolecular recognition hybrids that are adsorbed onto the oil. Conversely, at high levels of gum (0.3–1 wt%), the emulsions exhibit more elasticity— regarded as a physical property derived from a depletion stabilization mechanism. Protein will preferentially adsorb onto the oil–water external interface; the uncomplexed gum will migrate to the bulk and contribute to the stabilization by a depletion mechanism (Figure 5.20). The protein-to-gum weight ratio of 4/0.5, at which maximum complexation occurred between the protein and the gum, corresponds to the intermediary viscoelasticity of the system. At gum concentration of 0.5 wt%, the protein concentration does not affect the rheological behavior of the multiple emulsion. The emulsion conserves its elasticity properties at all ratios, with phase angle (δ) values being approximately 25° at all protein contents. Knoth et al. (2006) and Fechner et al. (2006) investigated the stabilization of multiple emulsion in two systems. The first system was based on whey protein as the external emulsifier and carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) as the
Figure 5.20 WPI/xanthan gum ratio (wt/wt) influence on the phase angle δ (degrees) of multiple emulsion droplets, immediately after preparation. The phase angle δ was defined as arctan(G″/G′), where G′ is the storage modulus, G″ is the loss modulus, and tan(δ) = G″/G′ (Benichou et al., 2002b).
BIOPOLYMER AS STABILIZED MULTIPLE EMULSIONS
113
stabilizer, at pH 4. Addition of the CMC significantly reduced the droplet size, prevented aggregation, improved the release rate, and changed the rheological behavior of the multiple emulsion. The second multiple emulsion, stabilized by sodium caseinate-dextran, was also found to be an improved multiple emulsion. The droplet sizes were smaller with a more narrow size distribution when the conjugated sodium caseinate and dextran were used (compared to multiple emulsions stabilized solely by caseinate). Protein-polysaccharide blends seem to provide improved multiple emulsion properties, such as reducing droplet size, reducing distribution of droplet size, preventing the instability related to the multiple emulsion, and better encapsulating the inner droplets that contribute to controlling the release rate. With the protein polysaccharide blend, the viscosity and rheological properties of the multiple emulsion change; the multiple emulsion became generally more viscous with increased elastic properties. These properties are gains due to the addition of hydrocolloids that create strong multianchoring of flexible macromolecules forming a thick multilayered coating on the droplets. O/W/W A number of researchers have prepared a new type of multiple emulsion termed O/W/W, based on the thermodynamic incompatibility of mixed biopolymer solutions. For example, oil-in-water-in-water (O/W/W) emulsions can be prepared by mixing an O/W emulsion with a W/W emulsion. W/W emulsion is created when the free energy of mixing two biopolymers is positive (becoming thermodynamically incompatible)—the system separates into two phases without special properties. In other cases phase separation includes certain changes in the morphology of the solution that contribute to special properties such as rheology and lower interfacial tension. This type of thermodynamic incompatibility often occurs in systems where one or both of the biopolymers are uncharged or where the biopolymers have similar electrical charges. These phase separations form a water-in-water (W/W) emulsion that consists of water droplets dispersed in continuous water (Antonov et al., 2004; Capron et al., 2001). Kim et al. (2006) showed that various types of multiple emulsions can be prepared by mixing an O/W emulsion with a mixed biopolymer solution that separates into two phases and creates a W/W emulsion. Under certain conditions the biopolymers formed a two-phase system consisting of an (HD-heat denaturated) HD-WPI-enriched lower phase (W1) and a pectin-enriched upper phase (W2), which was attributed to thermodynamic incompatibility of the two biopolymers. Water-in-water emulsions (W1/W2 or W2/W1) could be formed by blending incompatible upper (U) and lower (L) phases at different ratios (Figure 5.21). Whey protein stabilized oil droplets preferentially partition into the HD–WPI rich phase of two-phase biopolymer systems. This enabled preparation of multiple emulsions by mixing a whey protein stabilized O/W emulsion with incompatible upper and lower phases. The multiple emulsions were either of the oil-in-water-in-water (O/W1/W2) type or the mixed oil-in-water–waterin-water (O/W1–W2/W1) type, depending on the initial biopolymer composition
114
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
0 min
3 min
12 min
Figure 5.21 Evolution of the microstructure of a phase-separated biopolymer mixture consisting of one part upper phase (rich in pectin) and three parts lower phase (rich in whey protein) after being placed on a microscope slide. It is proposed that this system forms a W2/W1 emulsion, where W1 is HD-WPI rich and W2 is pectin rich (Kim et al., 2006).
of the system. These kinds of multiple emulsions may prove useful for the creation of food emulsions with improved physicochemical properties or for the development of novel delivery systems (Figure 5.22).
5.8
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PERSPECTIVES
In the past, multiple emulsions were considered extremely promising systems for slow and controlled release of entrapped active matter from the inner phase to the outer continuous phase. Multiple emulsions have numerous potential applications in almost all areas of life. The preparation methods are simple and inexpensive. Thus multiple emulsions have been extensively studied in the last 20 years. Much has been done in developing new and advanced methods of preparation of multiple emulsions. One of the most impressive technologies is the use of specific separation membranes. However, intrinsic stability and release problems discouraged scientists and technologists and these promising formulations were almost abandoned. In early research, low-molecular-weight emulsifiers were used to stabilize multiple emulsions, but they did not solve these problems. Much progress has been made with the introduction of amphiphilic macromolecules as emulsifiers. This multianchoring of flexible macromolecules can improve the steric stabilization by forming a thick multilayered coating on the droplets and by depletion (and mechanical) stabilization. Coalescence of the inner phase is now minimized by reducing the droplet sizes, better coating of the interface, and use of polymeric amphiphiles. Gelation or viscosifying the inner phase are additional options. Steric stabilization, mechanical stabilization, and depletion stabilization can improve stability considerably. Most of the amphiphilic macromolecules or surfactant polymers that have been used are not allowed in the food industry. Their use in proteins or hydro-
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PERSPECTIVES
115
(a)
3 min
6 min
20 min
8 min
15 min
(b)
4 min (c)
3 min
5 min
12 min
Figure 5.22 (a) Evolution of microstructure of phase-separated biopolymer mixtures (1U : 3L) containing 0.5 wt% WPI-stabilized droplets after being placed on a microscope slide. The large circles are the water droplets, and the small circles are the oil droplets. It is proposed that this system forms a W2/W1-O/W1 emulsion, where O is oil, W1 is HD-WPI rich, and W2 is pectin rich. (b) Evolution of the microstructure of phaseseparated biopolymer mixtures (2U : 2L) containing 0.5 wt% WPI-stabilized droplets after being placed on a microscope slide. It is proposed that this system forms an O/W1/W2 emulsion, where O is oil, W1 is HD-WPI rich, and W2 is pectin rich. (c) Evolution of microstructure of phase-separated biopolymer mixtures (3U : 1L) containing 0.5 wt% WPI-stabilized droplets after being placed on a microscope slide. It is proposed that this system forms an O/W1/W2 emulsion, where O is oil, W1 is HD-WPI rich, and W2 is pectin rich (Kim et al., 2006).
colloids causes the breakdown in stability of multiple emulsion. Blends of hydrocolloids and protein can create a variety of hybrid complexes that significantly improve the stability of each biopolymer separately. These molecules can considerably improve the stability and slow the release rates of multiple emulsions. Multiple emulsions are much more stable, with smaller globule size and smaller inner droplet size, more monodispersed and more viscous compare to multiple emulsions stabilized with monomeric surfactant. Today’s multiple emulsions can retain the solute for longer periods of time on the shelf.
116
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
The best multiple emulsions are likely to be prepared by the separation membrane technique, with polymeric amphiphilic, viscosity-enhancing agents, emulsified microemulsions, and proper selection of the amphiphilic blends of biomacromolecules (proteins and hydrocolloids) in each of the interfaces. The main goal remains to obtain submicron multiple emulsion droplets with longterm stability, possibly by replacing the inner emulsion with a microemulsion that is thermodynamically stable (emulsified microemulsions). Better control of the release pattern from the inner phase is still far from being achieved.
REFERENCES Adachi T, Ida J, Wakita M. 1999. Preparation of spherical and porous chitosan particles by suspension evaporation with O/W/O multiple emulsions. Polym J 31: 319–323. Antonov YA, Van Puyvelde P, Moldenaers P. 2004. Interfacial tension of aqueous biopolymer mixtures close to the critical point. Int J Biol Macromolecules 34: 29–35. Asakura S, Oosawa F. 1954. Interaction between two bodies immersed in a solution of macromolecules. J Chem Phys 22: 1255–1256. Aveyard R, Binks BP, Clint JH. 2003. Emulsions stabilized solely by colloidal particles. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 100–102: 503–546. Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2002a. Protein-polysaccharide interactions for stabilization of food emulsions. J Dispersion Sci Technol 23: 93–123. Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2004. Double emulsions stabilized with hybrids of natural polymers for entrapment and slow release of active matters. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 108: 29–41. Benichou A, Aserin A, Garti N. 2002b. Double emulsion stabilized by new recognition hybrids of natural polymers. Polym Adv Technol 13: 1019–1031. Bergenståhl B. 1997. Physiochemical aspects of emulsifier functionality. In: Food Emulsifiers and Their Applications, Hasenhuettl GL, Hartel RW, eds. New York: Chapman and Hall, pp 142–147. Bibette J, Leal-Calderon F, Schmitt V, Poulin P. 2002. Double emulsions. In: Emulsion Science Basic Principles—An Overview. New York: Springer, pp 117–136. Capron I, Costeux S, Djabourov M. 2001.Water in water emulsions: Phase separation and rheology of biopolymer solutions. Rheolog Acta 40: 441–456. Cornec M, Wilde PJ, Gunning PA, Mackie AR, Husband FA, Parker ML, Clark DC. 1998. Emulsion stability as affected by competitive adsorption between an oilsoluble emulsifier and milk proteins at the interface. J Food Sci 63: 39–43. Dickinson E. 2003. Hydrocolloids at interfaces and the influence on the properties of dispersed systems. Food Hydrocolloids 17: 25–39. Dickinson E, Evison J, Owusu RK. 1991. Preparation of fine protein stabilized waterin-oil-in-water emulsions. Food Hydrocolloids 5: 481–485. Dickinson E, Evison J, Owusu RK, Williams A. 1994. Protein stabilized water-inoil-water emulsions. In: Gums and Stabilizers for the Food Industry, Vol. 7, Phillips GO, Williams PA, Wedlock DJ, eds. Oxford: IRL Oxford University Press, pp 91–101.
REFERENCES
117
Evison J, Dickinson E, Owusu R, Williams A. 1995. Formulation and properties of protein-stabilized water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions. In: Food Macromolecules and Colloids, Dickinson E, Lorient D, eds. Cambridge: Royal Society of Chemistry, pp 235–243. Fechner A, Knoth A, Scherze I, Muschiolik G. 2006. Stabilization of multiple emulsion by milk protein-polysaccharide interaction conjugate. Abstracts of Papers of the Food Colloids: Self-assembly and Material Science, Montreux, Switzerland, The University of The Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland 23–26 April, B24. Feigin RI, Napper DH. 1980. Depletion stabilization and depletion flocculation. J Colloids Interface Sci 75: 525–541. Fleer GJ, Scheutjens JHMH, Vincent B. 1984. The stability of dispersions of hard spherical particles in the presence of non-adsorbing polymer. In: Polymer Adsorption and Dispersion Stability, Goddord E, Vincent B, eds. ACS Symp. Ser. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society, pp 245–263. Florence AT, Whitehill D. 1985. Stability and stabilization of water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsion. In: Macro-and Microemulsions: Theory and Application, Shah DO, ed. ACS Symp. Ser. Washington, DC: American Chemical Society, pp 359–380. Fredrokumbaradzi E, Simov A. 1992. Effect of bovine serum albumim (BSA) on release of sulfacetamide sodium from multiple W/O/W emulsions. Pharmazie 47: 388–389. Gallarate M, Carlotti ME, Trotta M, Bovo S. 1999. On the stability of ascorbic acid in emulsified systems for topical and cosmetic use. Int J Pharmaceut 188: 233–241. Garti N, Lutz R. 2004. Recent progress in double emulsions. In: Interface Science and Technology, Vol. 4. Emulsions: Structure Stability and Interactions, Petsev DN, ed. Oxford: Elsevier, pp 557–605. Garti N, Benichou A. 2001. Double emulsions for controlled-release applicationsProgress and trends. In: Encyclopedic Handbook of Emulsion Technology, Sjöblom J, ed. New York: Marcel Dekker, pp 377–407. Garti N, Reichman D. 1994. Surface-properties and emulsification activity of galactomannans. Food Hydrocolloids 8: 155–173. Garti N, Madar Z, Aserin A, Sternheim B. 1997. Fenugreek galactomannans as food emulsifiers. Food Science and Technology—Lebensmittel-Wissenschaft and Technologie 30: 305–311. Garti N, Aserin N, Cohen Y. 1994. Mechanistic considerations on the release of electrolytes from multiples emulsions stabilized by BSA and nonionic surfactants. J Controlled Release 29: 41–51. Garti N, Aserin A, Tiunova I, Binyamin H. 1999. Double emulsions of water-in-oil-inwater stabilized by alpha-form fat microcrystals. Part 1: Selection of emulsifiers and fat microcrystalline particles. J Am Oil Chemists Soc 76: 383–389. Garti N, Wicker L. 2005. Pectin methylesterase modified pectin interaction with whey protein isolate and stability of double emulsions. Abstracts of Papers of the American Chemical Society, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC 229. U295-U296 119-CELL Part 1. Grinberg VY, Tolstoguzov VB. 1997. Thermodynamic incompatibility of proteins and polysaccharides in solutions. Food Hydrocolloids 11: 145–158. Grossiord JL, Seiller M. 2001. W/O/W multiple emulsions: a review of the release mechanisms by break-up of the oily membrane. STP Pharma Sci 11: 331–339.
118
MULTIPLE EMULSIONS STABILIZED BY BIOPOLYMERS
Ibanoglu E. 2005. Effect of hydrocolloids on the thermal denaturation of proteins. Food Chem 90: 621–626. Jerdjev AM, Hunter RJ, Beattie JK. 2006. Self-depletion flocculation of tetralin oil-inwater emulsions. Langmuir 22: 84–87. Jiao J, Rhodes DG, Burgess DJ. 2002. Multiple emulsion stability: Pressure balance and interfacial film strength. J Colloid Interface Sci 250: 444–450. Jiao J, Burgess DJ. 2003. Rheology and stability of water-in-oil-in-water multiple emulsions containing Span 83 and Tween 80. AAPS Pharm Sci 5 Art. No. 7. Kanouni M, Rosano HL, Naouli N. 2002. Preparation of a stable double emulsion (W1/O/W2): role of the interfacial films on the stability of the system. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 99: 229–254. Kerstens S, Murray BS, Dickinson E. 2006. Microstructure of β-lactoglobulin-stabilized emulsions containing non-ionic surfactant and excess free protein: Influence of heating. J Colloid Interface Sci 296: 332–341. Kim SY, Lee YM. 1999. Lipid nanospheres containing vitamin A or vitamin E: Evaluation of their stabilities and in vitro skin permeability. Ind Eng Chem Res 5: 306–313. Kim JW, Kang HH, Suh KD, Oh SG. 2003. Stabilization of water-soluble antioxidant in water-in-oil-in-water double emulsions. J Dispersion Sci Technol 24: 833–839. Kim HJ, Cho YH, Bae EK, Shin TS, Choi SW, Choi KH, Park J. 2005. Development of W/O/W multiple emulsion formulation containing Burkholderia gladioli. J Microbiol Biotechnol 15: 29–34. Kim HJ, Decker EA, McClements DJ. 2006. Preparation of multiple emulsions based on thermodynamic incompatibility of heat-denatured whey protein and pectin solutions. Food Hydrocolloids 20: 586–595. Koberstein-Hajda A, Dickinson E. 1996. Stability of water-in-oil-in-water emulsions containing faba bean proteins. Food Hydrocolloids 10: 251–254. Knoth A, Scherze I, Kramer M, Muschiolik G. 2006. Influence of milk protein-polysaccharide interaction on the properties of W/O/W multiple emulsions. Abstracts of Papers of the Food Colloids: Self-assembly and Material Science, Montreux, Switzerland, 23–26 April, B23. Kuhl TL, Berman AD, Hui SW, Israelachvili JN. 1998. Part 1. Direct measurement of depletion attraction and thin film viscosity between lipid bilayers in aqueous polyethylene glycol solutions. Macromolecules 31: 8250–8257. Lin CY, Wang KH. 2003. The fuel properties of three-phase emulsions as an alternative fuel