Lighting Control-Technology and Applications
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Lighting
Control
–
Technology
Applications
Robert S. Simpson
and
CONTENTS
Focal Press An imprint of Elsevier Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP 200 Wheeler Road, Burlington MA 01803 First published 2003 Copyright© 2003, Robert S. Simpson. All rights reserved The right of Robert S. Simpson to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 No part of this publication may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright holder except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London, England W1T 4LP. Applications for the copyright holder’s written permission to reproduce any part of this publication should be addressed to the publisher
Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science and Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax: (+44) (0) 1865 853333; e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also complete your request on-line via the Elsevier Science homepage (www.elsevier.com), by selecting ‘Customer Support’ and then ‘Obtaining Permissions’ British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Simpson, Robert S. Lighting control : technology and applications 1.Electric lighting – Control I.Title 621.3’2 Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress ISBN 0 240 51566 8
For information on all Focal Press publications visit our website at: www.focalpress.com
Printed and bound in Italy
iv
CONTENTS
Contents
Trade marks and disclaimer Acknowledgements Preface
vii viii ix
Part 1 Foundation chapters 1
Electricity and light
1
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10 1.11
Electricity Electrical units and components Electrical distribution Power factor Control of electric power Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) Light The eye, how we see light Measurement of light Color Measurement of color
1 4 15 24 29 36 39 44 45 50 53
2
Lighting electronics
58
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8
Electronic principles The diode The transistor The thyristor, triac and GTO Analog and digital The integrated circuit and ASIC The microprocessor Programmable devices
58 63 68 81 85 93 102 110
Part 2 Lamps 3
Everyday lamps
112
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6
Non-electric lighting The incandescent lamp Tungsten halogen lamps The fluorescent lamp Compact fluorescent lamps Special purpose fluorescent lamps
112 113 115 119 123 124
4
Arc lamps
130
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8
High intensity discharge lamps Mercury vapor lamps Sodium and high pressure sodium lamps Metal halide lamps Compact source metal halide lamps High pressure mercury vapor lamps Xenon arc lamps Arc lamp classification
130 130 133 136 138 139 140 141
5
Special purpose lamps
144
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11
Induction lamps Flat lamps Neon lamps Electroluminescent lamps Light emitting diodes (LEDs) Lasers Ultra-violet lamps Infra-red lamps Flash tubes Fiber optics and lightguides Video displays as lightsources
144 148 149 151 153 159 162 163 164 166 171
Part 3 Lighting components 6
Electromagnetic components
172
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6
172 186 192 204 207
6.7
Principles of transformers and inductors Transformers for lighting Ballasts for fluorescent lamps Ballasts for HID and arc lamps Ignitors and starters Lighting control by transformers and ballasts Power factor correction
7
Electronic components
215
7.1 7.2
Circuit elements Electronic ballasts for fluorescent lamps
215 219
210 211
v
CONTENTS
7.3 7.4 7.5
Electronic ballasts for HID and arc lamps Electronic transformers Lighting control by electronic transformers and ballasts
242 245 248
Part 4 Dimmers and control systems
12
Architectural lighting control systems 374
12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5 12.6 12.7 12.8
“Setting the scene” Manual versus automatic control Single channel control Small multi-channel control systems Large multi-channel control systems Switching systems Centralized versus distributed systems Emergency and safety
374 375 376 377 381 383 390 391
13
The merging of “architectural” and “entertainment” lighting control
396
8
Dimmers
250
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6
Introduction to dimmers Non-electronic dimming Thyristor and triac dimmers Transistor dimmers Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) New developments in electronic dimming
250 252 257 269 272 276
9
Control signals and protocols
280
13.2 13.3
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7
Introduction Analog control Digital control Standard protocols for lighting control Networks and buses Computers in lighting control Cordless control
280 280 283 288 303 332 334
10
Why lighting control?
343
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5
The practical role The esthetic role The energy management role Influence of legislation Lighting design
343 344 345 348 351
11
Stage and entertainment lighting control systems 353
11.1 11.2
Basis of stage lighting control Simple multichannel controls for entertainment Memory consoles Live versus automatic Control of moving lights Control of color Large scale entertainment lighting control
11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7
vi
353 354 356 362 363 370 372
13.1
User demands and the influence of designers Automatic lighting control in public shows and public areas Control of exterior lighting
396 398 400
14
Energy management and building control systems 402
14.1 14.2 14.3
Principles Sensors and timers Switching versus dimming, control algorithms Local versus central control Impact of lighting on HVAC Power quality Integrated versus separate lighting control Monitoring systems
14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7 14.8
402 403 412 417 417 417 418 418
Part 5 Applications 15
Architectural applications
420
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4
The home Integrated home control systems The workplace Meeting rooms, conference centers, and auditoria Places of worship Museums, art galleries and libraries Visitor centers and exhibitions
420 428 431
15.5 15.6 15.7
436 447 449 454
CONTENTS
15.8 Hotels, hospitals and institutions 15.9 Restaurants, bars and pubs 15.10 Illuminated signs
459 463 464
16
Functional applications
469
16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 16.6 16.7 16.8 16.9 16.10
Retail spaces Agriculture and horticulture Manufacturing processes Healthcare Simulation On water In the air On the road On railways Control rooms
469 472 473 474 475 476 481 490 505 508
17
Entertainment applications
17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5
510
Small stages Large stages Television Touring shows Outdoor shows, Son et Lumière, pyrotechnics 17.6 Stadia, arenas, sporting facilities 17.7 Theme parks 17.8 Entertainment within retail 17.9 Discotheques, dancefloors and clubs 17.10 Conclusion
510 514 520 524
Some suggestions for further reading Table of acronyms Index
547 550 552
526 534 539 542 544 546
Trade marks and disclaimer In order to ensure that this book can be of practical use, it has been necessary to mention many commercial products by name. The inclusion or omission of any particular company’s products does not imply any endorsement or comment by the publisher. Where summaries are given of manufacturers of different kinds of equipment, these are intended as examples only, no claim is made that such summaries represent any kind of comprehensive directory. This book is intended as a source of information only. Care has been taken to verify the accuracy of all information contained herein, but neither the author nor the publisher can take responsibility for the consequences of using the information, or for any errors or omissions. Example circuits, devices and techniques may be the subject of patent protection or patent application. Their publication in this book does not imply any license for their use. Any references to standards and protocols (whether public or proprietary) are intended to give readers an introduction to their nature and operation. There is no implication of any license to use them, and current standards specifications and details of any licensing associated with them must be obtained from the sponsoring body concerned. All trade marks are acknowledged. Where known they are identified in the text by TM or ®.
vii
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements
The author acknowledges the help given to him in preparing this book by many industry colleagues from around the world. As far as possible application illustrations and case histories are acknowledged within the text. Unacknowledged diagrams and photographs are mostly from Helvar and Electrosonic. Among the many individuals who have contributed information and help, special thanks are due to to the following, arranged in company alphabetical order: Individual independent consultants
Brian Legge Thomas Baenziger
ADB (aviation lighting) Ira Jackson AIM Aviation (Jecco) Ltd Rolf Startin Anytronics Ltd Bob Hall Artistic License Wayne Howell Art2Architecture Peter Fink Arup Acoustics Sam Wise Arup (Manchester office) John Waite Avolites Richard Salzedo British Library Michael Wildsmith Building Research Establishment Michael Perry Carr & Angier Paul Covell CCT Lighting David Manners Claude Lyons Jim McIlfatrick Color Kinetics Melissa Connor The Deep (Hull, UK) Dr David Gibson Delmatic Stephen Woodnutt Derungs Licht Claudio Roth DHA Lighting Design Adam Grater Dynalite Dannielle Furness ECS Philips Lighting Controls Chris Holder Electrosonic Ltd Yvonne Hegarty, Daniela Simonides ETC Fred Foster Firework Shop John Stapleton Fisher Marantz Stone Scott Hershman Rob Schoenbohm Focus Lighting Inc Paul Gregory Genlyte Controls Jason Moreno Helvar (Finland) Teijo Viljanen, Markku Nohiu Eeva Harjula Helvar (Germany) Ingo Sommer Helvar (UK) Alan Jackson, Trevor Forrest Austen Conway, Dr Scott Wade, Mel Collins Howard Industries Mike Dodds
viii
IBL Leviton Lighting Architects Group
Peter Saunders Breda Potter Jonathan Speirs Mark Major, Iain Ruxton LSI Projects Ltd Nick Mobsby Lumisphere Products Bob Myson Lutron Brian McKiernan MEM and MEM250 Richard Hunt, H. Milligan Osram Hans Jörg Schenkat, Verena Roemer P. Ducker Systems Ltd Richard Thomas Philips Marc Segers, Holger Moench Peter Woodward, John Rothery Pinniger & Partners Miles Pinniger Project Interational Richard Dixon Pulsar Light Cambridge Andy Graves, Paul Marden Pyrodigital Consultants Ken Nixon Quo Vadis Ltd Michael Stott Relco Daria Fossati repas AEG Dirk Buchholz Royal National Theatre Great Britain MikeAtkinson Schott Fibre Optics UK John Meadows Starfield Controls Wayne Morrow Strand Lighting Vic Gibbs, Ivan Myles Sutton Vane Associates Mark Sutton Vane Technical Marketing Ltd Andy Collier Teknoware Jari Tabell Thorlux Lighting Terry Fletcher Tunewell Transformers Derek Price, Glen McGovern Tridonic Stewart Langdown Kate Wilkins Lighting Design Kate Wilkins Vantage Controls Andy North Vari-Lite Europe Ltd Samantha Dean,Colin Brooker Waltzing Waters Douglas Tews, Michael Przystawik The Watt Stopper Inc Joy Cohen WRTL Exterior Lighting Tom Thurrell Wynne Willson Gottelier Tony Gottelier Wybron Inc Brandon James Young Electric Sign Co Graham Beland, Blake Gover In addition, grateful thanks to Paul Ashford for driving “Pagemaker”, Noel Packer (of Helvar UK) and Paul Ashford for drawing most of the diagrams and Maggie Thomas (of Electrosonic) for help thoughout the project. Finally, thanks to the staff at Focal Press for their support over three years.
CONTENTS
Preface
Artificial lighting is part of our daily lives; in the modern world there are few activities which take place without it. While there are many books on the subjects of light and lighting, there are few that cover the subject of lighting control. Those that do look at the subject from a limited perspective, for example that of stage lighting. Within the practical limits set by its size, this book is intended as a review of all methods of lighting control. It covers all the current technologies, and gives application examples from many aspects of our daily lives. It is intended for all those who already work in the lighting industry, for designers and consultants, and for the sophisticated end user. It is also intended as a training resource for those new to the industry. No significant prior technical knowledge is assumed. The book is written for the “intelligent layman”, and mathematics are kept to a minimum. In order to make it a complete resource Part 1 is in the nature of a “foundation course” to give the necessary background to those with limited (or no) knowledge of the basics of light, electricity and electronics. It can be skipped by engineers and technicians who already have this knowledge. Part 2 is a review of light sources. Unless you understand how a particular light source works, you cannot appreciate how to control it. Again much of the information in Part 2 may be well known to some readers, although there could be a few surprises arising from recent developments in traditional sources, and from the arrival of completely new sources.
Most light sources need some kind of “load interface”, for example a ballast or transformer, between them and the electricity supply. Part 3 reviews these “lighting components”, most of which are available in both electromagnetic and electronic form. In recent years there have been major advances in electronic lighting components, and they now form an essential part of many lighting control systems. Part 4 is the technical heart of the book, covering dimmers and control systems. The dimmer or dimming interface is now only part of lighting control. With modern systems often embracing thousands of lighting “channels” spread over a large building complex, a basic knowledge of network and computer technology becomes necessary. Lighting control is used for practical, esthetic and energy management reasons. Part 5 reviews how the technologies described in the first four parts of the book are applied in practice. The aim here has been to cite examples, without attempting to be exhaustive, representing best practice from different parts of the world. Lighting control has been part of my life for over 50 years, from operating slider dimmers for school plays, to being a member of a specifying team for the latest generation of digital dimmers. I hope that my enthusiasm for the subject is reflected in this book, and that even if you are an experienced lighting practioner, you will find something useful or unexpected within it. R.S.S.
ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 1
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Electricity and light Part 1 – Foundation chapters The first two chapters are intended for those who have little or no knowledge of light, electricity and electronics. They include definitions and background technical information which is assumed in the succeeding chapters. Restrictions on space, and the use of only the simplest mathematics, mean that the introduction is cursory, but nonetheless it should help those new to the subject (and those of us who have forgotten our school physics and simple electronics, and just want a reminder!). Readers with a technical qualification in electronics or electrical engineering can safely omit the sections on electricity and electronics, but may still find the sections on light and color useful.
1.1 Electricity Both electricity and light are mysterious. We are well aware of their effect, but, if asked the question “what is electricity?” or “what is light?”, we have difficulty giving a convincing answer. We find it easiest to think in terms of a model, or models, which make it possible for us to understand how an electrical or optical device works. Provided the model, or “mind picture”, is consistent, this is a quite acceptable way to proceed – indeed it is the only way for the layman to get an insight into physical processes. In this chapter we describe the simplest models of electricity and light to the point where the methods of controlling them can be understood. The first model we need is that of the structure of matter. The atomic theory holds that the smallest unit of matter is the atom. In a compound there are several different kinds of atom, but in an element all the atoms are the same. All atoms are themselves made up of fundamental particles. Modern physics has produced an alarmingly long list of these, but for our purposes it is sufficient to know of only three: • the proton, a massive particle which carries a positive electric charge • the neutron which has the same mass as the proton, but has no charge • the electron which carries a negative electric charge equal and opposite to that of the proton.
The model of atomic structure which is sufficient for our purposes imagines that atoms have a planetary structure: a heavy nucleus consisting of a mixture of protons and neutrons, surrounded by orbiting electrons. The resulting atom is electrically neutral since the number of electrons in orbit exactly matches the number of protons. Figure 1.1 gives some examples of elements which are relevant to our subject. An important point to notice is that the electron orbits are not haphazard. The model shows that the electrons occupy “shells”, each one of which can only contain a defined number of electrons. As we move through the elements, from hydrogen the lightest, through to the heavy elements such as uranium, one unit of charge is added for each element. The shells get filled up in sequence, and this has the result that only some elements have a “complete” outer shell. It is the nature of the outer shell of electrons which determines many of the electrical and chemical properties of different elements. When an atom, for example a copper atom, has only a single electron in its outer shell, this electron can be easily dislodged – a so-called “free” electron. Such a free electron can be influenced by an electric charge. Electric charges have as their principal characteristic the fact that like charges repel each other, and unlike charges attract each other. An atom which has “lost” its free electron will itself aquire a
1
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.1 Simplified models of atomic structure. (a) Hydrogen, with one proton and one electron. (b) Carbon, showing two groups of electrons in elliptical orbits. (c) Simplified version of Carbon, showing positive charge of the nucleus balancing the negative charges of the electrons, and the K and L “shells”. (d) Neon, an insulator, with two full K and L “shells” of 2 and 8 electrons. (e) Silicon, a semiconductor, with a partially filled outer M shell having only four out of a possible maximum 18 electrons. (f) Copper, a conductor, with the three inner shells filled, but with the outer N shell having only one electron, out of a possible 32 maximum for this shell.
positive charge and is said to be positively ionized; it will then tend to attract a free electron to balance the charge again. However, free electrons are quite mobile in metals, and if an electric charge is applied across a length of metal, it results in a movement of free electrons; which we now identify as an electric current. Figure 1.2 shows the idea of an electron flow within a metal wire or conductor. The measure of the rate of flow of electric current is the Ampere, often abbreviated to Amp. For our mind picture of electricity it can be thought of as a flow of 6.26 × 10 18 (that is 6.26 multiplied by 1,000,000,000,000,000,000) electrons per second, although for reasons explained later this is not the actual definition of an Ampere.
2
The measure of electrical charge is the Coulomb. It is defined as the charge transferred when a current of one ampere flows for one second. Since the free electrons creating an electric current are themselves charged particles, the coulomb is equal to the total charge carried by 6.26 × 1018 electrons. Next for our model of electricity flow we need to have an idea of what can “push” the free electrons along the conductor. Figure 1.3 shows a simple electrical circuit where a battery is the source of electro-motive force or e.m.f. measured in Volts. When the first electrical discoveries were made, it was a convention that electric current flowed from the positive terminal of a battery to the negative terminal. This convention remains today, even though our “electron flow” model of electricity
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Wire Conductor
POSITIVE CHARGE THIS END attracts electrons
-
+ Electron flow Conventional current flow
= Nucleus with full inner shells and free electron in outer shell
Figure 1.2 The idea of free electron flow creating an electric current. At the positive end of the conductor there is a deficiency of electrons, so the free electrons move to fill the space. Conversely at the negative end, there is a surplus of electrons “pushing”.
shows the free electrons flowing the other way. The more volts applied, the stronger the current. It is also
found that the conductor heats up while the current flows, and that this heating effect is proportional to the square of the current. The tendency for an electrical conductor to restrict current flow is called its resistance and is measured in Ohms. Table 1.4 shows how the Ohm is defined by the amount of heat produced by a current of one Ampere, and how in turn the Volt is defined as the Potential Difference across a resistance of one Ohm when it is carrying a current of one Ampere. The most useful and most easily remembered relationships which link the main electrical units together are: V = IR Ohm’s Law (Volts = Current in Amps × Resistance in Ohms) which can also be expressed: I=
V R
and
R=
V I
and the power dissipated in a resistance: W = I 2R
Figure 1.3 The concept of potential difference down the length of a uniform conductor. At any point in the wire, the potential difference is proportional to the length of wire. On the right a hydraulic analogy shows that water pressure drops in a pipe in a similar way. If the tap is closed, then the level in all the columns would rise to match the level in the tank.
3
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
(Power in Watts = Current in Amps squared Resistance in Ohms)
×
which Ohm’s Law allows us to more conveniently remember as: W = VA
(Power in Watts = Potential Difference in Volts × Current in Amps) Figure 1.3 shows the battery as a source of e.m.f. (measured in Volts) providing a potential difference (also measured in Volts) across the electrical conductor which we can think of as being some kind of heating element. Down the length of the conductor the potential drops in proportion to the length – if you take a Voltmeter to measure the voltage it gets lower along the length of the conductor. A simple hydraulic analogy is shown of water from a header tank losing pressure down the length of a pipe. In the real world the e.m.f of the battery measured on open circuit (nothing connected) only equals the p.d. across the load resistance when connected if the
battery itself has no internal resistance. If it does have internal resistance, then the actual voltage across the load will be lower. An automobile battery is an example of a battery with very low internal resistance; it can deliver a current of several hundred Amperes at 12 Volts to run a starter motor. A battery set for a portable compact disc player may also deliver 12V as an open circuit e.m.f., but its internal resistance limits the current available (and the actual p.d. at the load). See Figure 1.4.
1.2 Electrical units and components 1.2.1 Units Having introduced the concept of the flow of electricity, it is now necessary to be more rigorous about how it is measured. The way in which we measure things depends finally on having agreed reference standards, so that
Figure 1.4 A car battery has negligible internal resistance, so can deliver a full 12V to a lamp load. The same lamp load connected to a small 12V battery might show only half the current flowing through it because of the battery’s internal resistance. (The value shown here has been chosen for simplicity) Thus the p.d. across the load is much less then the e.m.f. of the open circuit battery. The idea that a source of power can itself limit the available current is important.
4
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Quantity Length
Unit Meter
Symbol m
Mass Time
Kilogram Second
kg s
Plane angle
Radian
rad
Solid angle
Steradian
sr
Temperature
Degree Kelvin
K
Defined as The length of the path travelled by light in a vacuum during a time interval of 1/299,792,458 of a second. The mass of the prototype kilogram kept at Sèvres in France 9,192,631,770 periods of vibration of the Caesium 133 atom (formerly 1/86,400 of the mean solar day). The angle subtended at the center of a circle by an arc of equal length to the radius (r). The ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter (which equals 2r) is S. Thus 360° is equivalent to 2S radians, and one radian = approximately 57.3°. The solid angle subtended at the center of a sphere by an area numerically equal to the square of its radius. Since the surface area of a sphere is 4Sr2, a sphere subtends 4S steradians. The temperature scale where each degree is numerically the same size as that on the Celsius scale (i.e. there are 100 degrees between the freezing and boiling points of water) but whose zero point is Absolute Zero (the lowest temperature possible where all molecular movement ceases) 0K = 273°C approximately.
Table 1.1 Fundamental units
there is consistency between different methods of arriving at the same result. For example the heat generated by a gas heater or an electric heater must be measured in the same units; or the power developed by an electric motor must be comparable to the power developed by a gasoline engine. It would be very confusing if we had different units for both, although in practice this can happen! For example most people like to talk in terms of horsepower (derived from “imperial” units of measurement) for the capability of a motor, whereas it is in fact easier to work in kilowatts (derived from metric units) when working as an engineer. Most electrical engineering is now based on SI (Système International d’Unités) units. These are based on the MKS or meter, kilogram, second system, whereby the primary units of length, mass and time are used as the basis of all other units. Thus, while we could define the flow of electric current in terms of the number of electrons passing a particular point per second, it is actually agreed to define it in terms of the mechanical force created by a current carrying conductor, because this way we can relate it back to the MKS primary units. Originally the meter was related to the dimensions of the earth, and represented by a
physical standard of platinum–iridium kept in Paris. Similarly the second was related to the mean solar day. However, the demand for greater accuracy in measurement has resulted in the meter being related to the velocity of light, and the second to the emission of radiation from a particular atom. Table 1.1 lists the fundamental SI or MKS units, and Table 1.3 shows how other commonly required Prefix
Symbol
Multiplier
Example
PicoNanoMicroMilliCentiDeciUnitDekaHektoKiloMegaGigaTera-
p n P m c d da h k M G T
10 -12 10 -9 10 -6 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000 10 6 10 9 1012
Picosecond Nanometer Microfarad Millisecond Centiliter Decibel Hectoliter Kilogram Megawatt Gigahertz Terabyte
Table 1.2 The common unit modifiers.
5
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Quantity Frequency
Unit Hertz
Symbol Hz
Force
Newton
N
Energy (or Work)
Joule
J
Power (or the rate of doing work) Pressure (force per unit area)
Watt
W
Pascal
Pa
Defined as The number of repetitions of a regular occurrence within one second. Formerly cycles per second. The force which, when applied to a mass of one kilogram, gives it an acceleration of one meter per second per second. Force in N = Mass in kg u Acceleration in m/s 2 The work done when a force of one Newton acts for a distance of one meter in the direction of the force. Energy and heat are directly equivalent, so heat is also measured in Joules. (The SI avoids the use of the calorie; but a Kilogram-calorie, beloved of dieticians and the heat required to raise a kilogram of water by one degree Celsius, is found by experiment to equal 4187 Joules.) Work being done at the rate of one Joule per second. (The imperial based horsepower is 550 ft lb/sec, which converts to 746 watts.) When a force of one Newton is applied across an area of one square meter, the force is one Pascal. (One Bar is 10 5 Pa. Comparing with imperial measurement, one Pa is 1.45 u 10 -4 lb/sq. in.)
Table 1.3 Derived units (mechanical).
mechanical units are derived from them. Table 1.4 then shows the main electrical units, and here it can be seen that by relating the unit of electric current to physical force, and the unit of resistance to measurable heat energy, all the electrical units are “tied back” to the SI fundamental units. Many of the standard units are inconveniently big or small for certain types of measurement. They are modified by prefixes denoting powers of ten. Some of particular interest to lighting are frequencies such as kHz and MHz; and short wavelengths such as nanometers. Table 1.2 summarizes these prefixes.
of heat or pressure so that it becomes conducting. This will be discussed further in Chapter 3. Another category is the semi-conductor, the best known example of which is silicon. Pure silicon at room temperature is an insulator. But under certain conditions of heat or local impurities it is possible to detach a free electron from the incomplete M shell, at which point silicon becomes a conductor. Semiconductors are the basis of modern electronics, and are discussed further in Chapter 2.
1.2.2 Conductors and insulators
While we usually want a conductor to conduct electricity as well as possible, and an insulator not to conduct it at all, there are times that we need to limit the current flowing in a circuit. This is done with a resistor, which is simply a device which has a known resistance in ohms. Resistors take many forms (Figure 1.5.) At one extreme a heating element for a cooker or electric fire is a resistor, at the other modern electronic circuits use tiny resistors often with values in the kilohm or megohm range. The size of a resistor will depend on the way in which it is to be used. Because a resistor dissipates heat in direct proportion to its resistance in ohms, and in proportion to the square of the current going through it; it must be designed to get rid of this heat. A resistor in an
In Section 1.1 we identified copper and other metals as being good conductors of electricity, because of the availability of free electrons. Different metals have different conductivity, for example copper, silver and aluminum are good conductors; iron is a conductor, but is poor compared with copper. The opposite of a conductor is an insulator which in theory should not carry any electricity at all. In Figure 1.1 the gas Neon is shown as an insulator, because its electron shells are full and tightly bound to the nucleus. However, the perfect insulator does not exist. A very strong electric field can “break down” an insulator, or alternatively an insulating gas or compound can be ionized under certain conditions
6
1.2.3 Resistors
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Quantity and symbol Electric Current I
Unit Ampere
Unit Symbol A
Electric Charge Q Electric Resistance R
Coulomb
C
Ohm
:
Electric Potential V
Volt
V
Electric Energy E
Joule
J
Electric Power P
Watt
W
Defined as One Ampere is the constant current which, if flowing in two infinitely long parallel conductors, of negligible cross-sectional area, in a vacuum and placed one meter apart, creates between them a force of 2 u 10-7 Newton per meter length. The quantity of electricity transported when a current of one Ampere flows for one second. The resistance of a conductor is one Ohm if a current of one Ampere flowing for one second generates one Joule of heat energy. When a resistance of one Ohm carries a current of one Ampere, the potential difference across the resistance is one Volt. Ohm's Law can be stated as V=IR The physicist James Joule determined that the heating effect in a wire conductor was proportional to the square of the current flowing I, to the resistance of the wire R, and to the time the current flows t, i.e. E vI2Rt (symbol v means “proportional to”) As shown above the definition of the Ohm is based on E = I2Rt when E is in Joules, I is in Amperes and t in seconds One Joule per second, so, from the basis of E above Power in Watts = I2R Applying Ohm's Law, the alternative Power in Watts = Current in Amperes u Potential Difference in Volts
Electric Capacitance C
Farad
F
Electrical Inductance L
Henry
H
Magnetic Flux )
Weber
Wb
Magnetic Flux Density B
Webers per square meter (or Tesla)
Wb/m2 (or T)
Or Watts = Amps u Volts is the more convenient and easiest form to remember. If the potential across the plates of a capacitor rises to one volt as a result of being charged with one coulomb, then its capacitance is one Farad. In practice this unit is too large for most purposes. The microfarad (PF), and nanofarad (nF) are common measures in electronics. A circuit (or coil) has an inductance of one Henry if an e.m.f. of one volt is induced across it when the current changes at the rate of one Ampere per second. Again this is a large unit and mH and PH are widely used. The magnetic flux which, linking a circuit of one turn, produces in it an e.m.f. of one volt as it is reduced to zero in one second at a uniform rate. But more strictly derived from the definition of flux density. A magnetic field has a flux density of one Weber per square meter if a conductor placed at right angles to the field and carrying a current of one Ampere, has a force of one Newton per meter acting on it.
Table 1.4 Electrical and magnetic units, showing how they are derived from the mechanical units in Tables 1.1 and 1.3
7
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.5 Examples of resistors. The circuit symbols for resistance, and some simple laws about using resistances in series and parallel. A variable resistor is a two terminal device; a potentiometer has a similar construction but is a three terminal device; a voltage is applied across the ends of the resistance element, and the moving contact has a varying potential difference (voltage) according to its position along the resistance.
Figure 1.6 Resistance varies with temperature. On the left a 100W tungsten lamp has the voltage presented to it changed by a variable resistor. Current through, and voltage across, the lamp are measured by A and V. The resistance can be calculated, and plotted against the voltage, and this shows that at proper operating temperature the filament has more than ten times the resistance it does when cold.
8
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
electronic circuit may only need to dissipate a few microwatts, or at most a watt or so. A resistor for use as a current limiter in a lighting or motor circuit may have to dissipate a kilowatt. There is a complication about resistance which is highly significant in lighting. In most materials it varies with temperature. Figure 1.6 shows a simple experiment in which a 100W light bulb is connected to a 230V mains supply via a suitable variable resistance to change the potential across the lamp. A voltmeter measures the volts across the lamp, and an ammeter measures the current through it. Using Ohm’s law it is possible to calculate the resistance for different voltages. The graph shows that when no current is flowing the lamp has a resistance of 50 ohms – but when the lamp filament is running at its rated operating temperature, its resistance has risen to over 500 ohms. The variation of resistance with temperature is defined by the temperature coefficient of resistance. The resistance of pure metals rises with temperature; whereas the resistance of carbon, silicon and insulating materials drops with temperature. Special alloys (such as Eureka, a 60/40 mixture of copper and nickel) have practically no change in resistance over a wide range of temperature and are used in applications where the resistance must remain constant.
I=
V R
1.2.4 Capacitors A capacitor (also formerly known as a condenser) consists of two conducting surfaces separated by an insulating layer called the dielectric. The plates (or electrodes) can be flat metal plates, and the insulator between them can be air; but as a practical component capacitors usually consist of thin plastic films on which layers of aluminum have been deposited, or are thin metal sheets with an electrochemically derived insulating layer – see Figure 1.7. An “empty” capacitor has no potential difference between its electrodes, but if an electric field is applied across them the capacitor “charges up”. The process is shown in Figure 1.8(a).
Figure 1.7 The principle of a capacitor (a), and (b) a possible construction using metallized film or paper.
9
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
At first the switch S is in a center-off position. There is no voltage across the capacitor C. If the switch is closed to terminal b, a battery is connected to the capacitor through a resistance R. Measurement of the current through the capacitor by ammeter A, and the voltage across it by Voltmeter V, gives the curves shown in Figure 1.8(b) with respect to time. The initial current is high, but as the voltage across the capacitor rises, the current drops to zero. The “charging time” is found to be limited by the resistor R. Double the resistor value, and the initial charging current halves, and the time to full charge is doubled. If the switch is returned to its center-off position, the voltmeter V will continue to show the full battery voltage across the capacitor – and in a perfect capacitor it will hold the charge indefinitely. Now if the switch is turned to the d position, the current and voltage will behave as shown in Figure 1.8(c) as the capacitor discharges. Figure 1.8(d) shows a hydraulic analogy of the operation of a capacitor. In the top cylindrical chamber there is a rubber diaphragm stretched across the cylinder (= the dielectric). In the bottom cylinder the piston can increase the pressure on one side of the diaphragm and move more fluid into the top chamber (= the battery applying an e.m.f.) If the force is removed from the piston, the diaphragm springs back and forces the fluid back again (= capacitor discharging). No fluid can get from one side of the diaphragm to the other under normal circumstances. However, if it is subjected to excessive pressure, it bursts. Exactly what happens when a capacitor is subjected to too high a voltage. Table 1.3 defines the ability to store charge in a way which can be expressed as a simple equation: Capacitance Ch arg e in Coulombs = in Farads Potential Difference in Volts
or
Q =C V
Practical capacitors used in lighting and electronics are usually measured in microfarads or mF. Their capacity can be related to their physical dimensions by the equation: C = ε0 ε r
10
A d
Figure 1.8 Charging and discharging a capacitor. Figure described in the main text.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
where C is the capacitance in Farads, A is the area of the capacitor plates in square meters, and d is the distance between the plates in meters. ε0 is the permittivity of free space (or vacuum) a quantity which can be determined experimentally as having a value of about 8.85 × 10-12 F/m. It relates the electric force, or field strength across the capacitor plates measured in V/m to the electric flux density measured in Coulombs per square meter. (It also has a deeper significance, referred to in Section 1.6.) εr is the relative permittivity of the dielectric material. For a vacuum this is unity (one). For other materials it is higher, for example for paper it is 22.5. Plastic films have a relative permittivity of 4-6. Sometimes ε0εr is shortened to ε and is referred to as the dielectric constant of the material concerned. From an electrical power point of view a most important characteristic of a capacitor is that in any practical circuit containing even the smallest amount of resistance, it is not possible to change the voltage across a capacitor instantaneously. Figure 1.9 gives some more summary information about capacitors.
same happens with magnetic fields produced electrically – a force is produced which causes the affected items to repel or attract each other. The definition of the ampere given in Table 1.4 is based on the idea that any current carrying conductor creates a magnetic field, but also a conductor carrying a current in a magnetic field has a force exerted on it. An inductor consists of a coil of wire, usually, but not necessarily, wound on a core with
1.2.5 Inductors Electricity and magnetism are inextricably mixed. The fundamental discoveries of electromagnetism were: • when a conductor carries an electric current a magnetic field surrounds the length of the conductor. • if a conductor is moved in a stationary magnetic field, then an electric current is induced in it. Conversely if a magnetic field moves with respect to a stationary conductor, an electric current is induced in the conductor. This is the basis of electricity generation. • if a conductor carrying an electric current is placed across a magnetic field, a force is exerted on the conductor. This is the basis of electric motors. Any magnet has a “north” and “south” pole (named after the way small magnets align themselves with the earth’s magnetic field, as in a compass) and we are all familiar, from magnetic toys, with the way that like poles repel, and unlike poles attract. The
Figure 1.9 More about capacitors.
11
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.10 A simple inductor, showing the magnetic field. The field is more intense when there is an iron core, and the iron magnetizes.
ferromagnetic (or iron-like) magnetic properties. The details of different kinds of inductors relevant to lighting control are given in later chapters, for now
it is sufficient to see what happens when an inductor is placed in a simple circuit – in the same way we considered capacitors in 1.2.4 above. Figure 1.10 shows a simple inductor, and the way a magnetic field is created by it. In Figure 1.11(a) a circuit is shown containing an iron cored inductor, arranged in a way that confines the magnetic field largely within the core. The circuit also contains a resistor R and two ammeters, one of which is “center-zero”. Closing the switch S connects the battery to both the resistor and the inductor, and results in the currents shown in Figure 1.11(b). The current through R jumps immediately to the value determined by Ohm’s law. But that through the inductor takes time to reach a steady level (which does indeed reach a value limited by the resistance of the coil – but only when the steady state is reached does Ohm’s law apply as usual). What slows the current rise? The current produces a magnetic flux in the core; but because this flux is changing, it itself introduces an e.m.f. back in the coil. Lenz’s Law states that when this happens, the e.m.f. is always in the opposite direction to that which is creating the flux. This effect limits how fast the current can rise in the coil – in an inductor it is not possible to change the current
Figure 1.11 Experimental circuit showing the effect of inductance in a DC circuit (a). The switch on and switch off currents are shown in (b). IL is the switch-on current through the inductor, and IR the switch-on current through the resistor. Ib is the switch-off current, which goes through the resistor in the opposite direction to IR and arises from the back e.m.f. of the inductor. The magnetic flux in the inductor core builds up during switch-on, and collapses at switchoff.
12
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
instantaneously (compare the capacitor – where it is not possible to change the voltage instantaneously). If switch S is now opened, an interesting thing happens. The original source of e.m.f. has gone, so the current drops in the coil – but this creates a change in flux again and, therefore, an e.m.f. The only way for its resulting current to go is through the resistance R – the center-zero ammeter now shows a decaying current in the opposite direction to that originally flowing through R. What happens if there is no resistance R in the circuit? Opening the switch S produces a rapid current change, therefore a rapid flux change. Therefore, in turn, a big “back e.m.f.” which in practical circuits can result in arcing (sparks!) at the switch. Even in the simplest circuits using inductive components precautions have to be taken to limit the effects of back e.m.f. 1.2.6 Magnetic units In the discussion on capacitors, the concept of permittivity was introduced to describe how different materials are affected by an electric field. A similar idea applies to inductors and magnetism, where permeability is the description of how materials are affected by magnetic fields. Since magnetic properties are fundamental to ballasts and transformers used in lighting control, some understanding of magnetic units is important.
We have described an electric current in a circuit as being due to the presence of electromotive force. In electromagnetism we can postulate that in a magnetic circuit a magnetic flux is created by the presence of magnetomotive force (or m.m.f.) caused by a current flowing through one or more turns in a coil. Since the m.m.f. is proportional both to the current and the number of turns, the unit of m.m.f. in the MKS system is the ampere-turn. Figure 1.12 shows a toroidal coil with T turns carrying a current I. The mean length of the magnetic circuit is l meters. The magnetizing force H is defined as the m.m.f. per unit length, so: H = IT/l
The strength of a magnetic field is termed its magnetic flux density B. This is measured in Webers per square meter, or Tesla, and is defined by relation to the ampere, see Table 1.4. To see how B and H are related we need to do a small thought experiment. Figure 1.13 shows a long thin conductor in a vacuum A. It is carrying current of one ampere in the direction of the paper. Let us suppose that the return path of this current is a long distance away, so any magnetic field the return path generates does not affect things. The magnetic flux created by the current is in the form of concentric circles. What is sometimes referred to as Maxwell’s corkscrew rule says that the direction of the flux is clockwise if the current is flowing away from you as in Figure1.13. In this figure just one line of flux is shown, at a distance of one meter from the conductor. Since the conductor (and its return partner) form one turn, the m.m.f. acting on the flux path is one ampere-turn. The length of the flux path (2πr where r is one meter) is 2π meters. Thus the magnetizing force acting at one meter radius is: H = 1 Amp
× 1 Turn /2π meters
H=1/2π
ampere-turn/meter
or:
Figure 1.12 Defining the magnetizing force H. Here a toroidal inductor has magnetic circuit length L meters, has a coil of T turns and is carrying a current I Amperes.
ampere turns/meter
Now let us imagine a second conductor A´ sited one meter away from A, and also carrying one
13
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
represented by the symbol μ0 and applies not only to vacuum but also to non-magnetic materials. The magnetic flux inside a coil such as that in Figure 1.12 or 1.10 is greatly increased if an iron or other magnetic core is introduced. Magnetic materials are defined by their relative permeability, μr such that: B= μrμ0H
Figure 1.13 Defining the magnetic flux density B. Imagine the conductor A as perpendicular to the paper, with current flowing into the paper. Maxwell’s corkscrew rule says the magnetic flux is in a clockwise direction.
ampere. The definition of magnetic flux density gives us the equation: Force on conductor in Newtons = Flux density in Wb/m2 X length in meters X current in amperes. So for A´ we have: Force per meter = B (Wb/m2) × 1 m
× 1A=B
Newtons
But we know the force acting under these circumstances, because our thought experiment has replicated the conditions which define the ampere (see Table 1.3). The force is 2 X 10-7 N. So now we can say that: the flux density B at one meter radius from a conductor carrying a current of one ampere is 2 × 10-7 Wb/m2. And further, if we compare the flux density at A´ to the magnetizing force at A´, we now have: B 2 × 10 −7 wb / m 2 = H 1 / 2 π ampere − turn / m
or
B = 4 π × 10 −7 H
The ratio B/H for the conditions we have defined is referred to as the permeability of free space. It is
14
While the relative permeability of air and other non magnetic materials is 1, that for special nickel– iron alloys can be as high as 100,000. If measurements are made on different materials of the effect of increasing magnetizing force H on the flux density B, a graph of the kind shown in Figure 1.14 is found. Here it is assumed that the experiments started with unmagnetized material. The increase in flux density follows the curve OAC, but beyond a certain value of H the value of B reaches a limit. The material is said then to be magnetically saturated. If H is now reduced to zero, the value of B does not go down to zero, but retains a remanent flux density OD (usually between 60 and 75% of the maximum). A reverse magnetizing force OE, known as the coercive force is required to return B to zero. If the reverse force is increased, point F can be reached where the material is now saturated in the other direction. If the cycle is continued, by reversing H again, the curve follows FGC. The complete loop resulting from a double reversal of magnetizing force is called the hysteresis loop. The “fatter” the curve, the more effort is needed to take the magnetic material through a flux reversal. 1.2.7 Inductance The unit of measurement of the ability of an inductor to slow down a rise in current, its inductance, is the Henry, defined in Table 1.4. For an air cored coil of the kind shown in Figure 1.12 the inductance is: • proportional to the square of the number of turns of wire T. • proportional to the cross sectional area of the core a.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
same as if the flux varied linearly along FOC, and, therefore, that the inductance of the coil becomes: Induc tan ce L =
μ r × 4 π × 10 −7 × aT 2 Henrys l
1.3 Electrical distribution 1.3.1 Direct current sources
Figure 1.14 The relationship between flux density B and magnetizing force H is not linear, and displays hysteresis.
• inversely proportional to the length of the magnetic circuit l. In fact: Induc tan ce L =
4 π × 10 −7 × aT 2 Henrys l
When the air core is replaced by an iron or other magnetic core, the situation becomes very complicated. The magnetization curve Figure 1.14 shows that the variation of flux is not linearly proportional to the current (which causes the magnetizing force) – so a coil can have a lot of different inductance values depending on the range of current variation. However, our interest in inductance is primarily concerned with alternating current (described in Section 1.3.2) where the current changes direction repeatedly. If μr is the relative permeability of the core material corresponding to the maximum value of the flux (point C on Figure 1.14) and it is understood that the relevant use of the inductance involves repeated flux reversals (to point F) then it is assumed that the value of the inductance is the
In the concepts presented so far, only circuits using Direct Current or DC have been mentioned. With the exception of the changes in current or voltage introduced by capacitors or inductors, the circuits have been “steady state” with current flow conventionally seen as flowing from positive to negative. DC is essential for the operation of most electronic components, and is most familiar to us as being supplied by batteries. A battery is in fact a group of electrochemical cells whose action is to convert chemical energy to electrical energy. Primary cells or batteries are “use once” devices, exemplified by the common zinc/carbon dry battery. Secondary cells are rechargeable devices, where the chemical reactions leading to the generation of electricity can be reversed, and are exemplified by the standard automobile battery.
1.2v 300mAh battery used in cordless control
3.6V 4Ah rechargeable battery used in emergency light fitting
12V 11Ah sealed lead acid rechargeable battery
Figure 1.15 Examples of batteries. Battery capacity is given in ampere-hours, thus a 2Ah battery can sustain a current of 2A for one hour or 500mA for 4 hours.
15
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.15 shows some examples of batteries. The demands of portable electronic equipment, emergency power supplies and electric traction have resulted in considerable developments in battery technology.
DC is also derived by power conversion from AC, and this is described in Chapter 2. It can also be generated by DC generators or dynamos, but this is not now generally relevant to lighting.
Trigonometry In our treatment of electrical units and electricity, we are keeping mathematics to a minimum; using where possible simple algebraic formulae with each symbol clearly defined. In describing alternating current it is necessary to use simple trigonometry. For those who have forgotten the basic relationships, here they are: In the right angled triangle in Figure 1.16 the angle θ is identified, as are the three sides of the triangle: • the hypotenuse which is the longest side opposite the right angle, the length of which is identified here as H. • the adjacent side which is the side next to the angle θ. Identified here as having length A. • the opposite side, which is the side opposite to the angle θ, identified here as having length O.
Figure 1.17 A force F acts on an object at angle θ to the horizontal. If the line OF represents the magnitude and direction of the force; it can be resolved into horizontal and vertical components of forces H and V, represented by the lengths of OH and OV. Conversely, if there are two forces acting on an object, there is a resultant force whose magnitude and direction lies between them.
The following relationships apply: O2 + A2 = H2
(Pythagoras’s Theorem)
The Sine of the angle θ = O/H The Cosine of the angle θ = A/H The Tangent of the angle θ = O/A Sine, Cosine and Tangent are abbreviated to Sin, Cos and Tan in mathematical expressions. A mnemonic for remembering the above is:
Figure 1.16 Simple trigonometry. Defining the sine, cosine and tangent of angle θ.
16
Old Always Other Hands Help Aviators
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
An important use of trigonometry is in “resolving” forces, and in defining the contribution of a vector quantity (a vector quantity is one which has both magnitude and direction) in a particular direction. Figure 1.17 shows the principle of resolving a force into two different components. A force of F Newtons is acting on an object at an angle θ. If we want to know the horizontal and vertical components of the force, we draw the rectangle shown, with the length of the diagonal corresponding to the magnitude of the force. The lengths of the sides of the rectangle now represent the horizontal and vertical components of the force, and it can be seen that:
F cos θ is the horizontal component, and F sin θ is the vertical component But there is an important concept here, which will be appreciated as we look further into how alternating current, described in the next section, behaves. That is that, if you have two vector components acting in two different directions, you have a resultant single vector – and while this is quite easy to appreciate when dealing with a force, it may not be so obvious when you are dealing with an electric current.
1.3.2 Alternating current The electricity which arrives in our home is Alternating Current or AC. The reason for this is that it is both easier to generate, and easier to distribute. To understand why this is so, it is necessary to understand how an alternator (or AC Generator) works. Figure 1.18 shows a rectangular loop conductor rotating in a magnetic field. A conductor cutting magnetic flux generates an e.m.f. but here the conductor is not always cutting the flux at the perpendicular. When the loop is vertical the conductors are parallel with the flux, and no e.m.f. is generated, when the loop is rotated 90° the loop is cutting across the flux and maximum e.m.f. is generated. The instantaneous e.m.f. is proportional to the sine of the angle at which the conductor cuts the magnetic flux. e.m.f. generated in one side of loop = Blv sin θ volts
Where B is the flux in Wb/m2, l is the length of one side of the loop, v is the velocity of the conductor through the flux and sin θ is the resolved component of that velocity perpendicular to the magnetic field. Without needing to worry too much about the details of this equation, it is clear that the more and longer conductors there are, and the faster the loop rotates, the more volts will be produced.
Figure 1.19 shows how a sine wave is produced by this action. It also shows another “mind picture” of how a rotating vector produces the sine wave. A vector quantity is one which has both magnitude and direction (for example speed is a scalar quantity, having magnitude only, whereas velocity is a vector quantity which must always be specified in both magnitude and direction). The magnitude in both cases can be km/hour or m/s or m.p.h. as appropriate. Notice here how the use of angular velocity ω, measured in radians per second simplifies the mathematics, since there are 2π radians in each revolution. A version of the device shown in Figure 1.18 could be used for generating AC by connecting pickup brushes to both ends of the conducting loop as shown in the diagram. (Indeed a very rough DC could be derived by having a “commutator” arrangement which switched the direction of current to the outgoing circuit every half revolution.) However “real” alternators of any size work the other way round. They have static conductor coils, which are then easily connected to the outside world without the need for any pick up brushes; and the moving magnetic field is produced by rotating electromagnets. These are powered by DC, traditionally generated by a dynamo on the same shaft as the main alternator, but now also derived by converting from AC.
17
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.18 Creating an alternating current. On the left a loop conductor being rotated in a magnetic field (shown in the position of rotation θ=90°). On the right it is shown that maximum e.m.f. is generated when the conductor cuts the flux at right angles (rotation angle 90°) and no e.m.f. is generated when the conductor is moving in the same direction as the flux lines (rotation angle 0°).
Figure 1.19 If the value of r sin θ is plotted at equal increments along an axis, a sine wave is the result, as shown on the left. On the right we see the idea of a rotating vector producing a sine wave. The horizontal axis can represent both the angle of rotation and time (if the angular velocity is known). If the vector length represents a current of maximum value IM the waveform is that of an alternating current.
18
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.20 The single phase alternator. The left hand diagram shows the principle with a single 2-pole magnet. The right hand diagram shows an 8-pole magnet system. In a real alternator the magnets are electromagnets fed by a DC supply.
Figure 1.20 shows the principle of an alternator. AC does not have to be sinusoidal (sine wave shaped) and many other waveforms exist, especially in electronics. But for power distribution it is the most efficient waveform, so alternators are designed to give a sinusoidal output. (To be technically correct it should be noted that the alternator construction implied by the two arrangements shown in Figure 1.20 would not give sinusoidal output without some refinement.) To make better use of the alternator frame, and to assist with power distribution, AC is often produced in three phase form. Here the alternator simultaneously produces three different sine waves, but each of these is timed to peak at different times. The idea is shown in Figure 1.21, and a real alternator is shown in Figure 1.22. In the USA, electricity is generated at 60Hz (cycles per second) in Europe it is generated at 50Hz.
1.3.3 AC circuits In Section 1.2 many of the basic rules about electricity were given in relation to DC circuits. Unfortunately they need some “tweaking” when applied to AC. First we need to know if Ohm’s law and the simple power calculation rules still apply. Clearly it is no use taking “average” current and voltage, since these are both zero if the waveform is symmetrical. The way forward is to say that the effective value of an alternating current is that which produces the same heating effect in a resistance as does a direct current of the same numerical value. We can do a comparison by “slicing up” an AC waveform. In Figure 1.23 we show n instants at which current is measured in a half cycle. The instantaneous heating effect at each instant is in2R. So we can say
19
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.21 The principle of the 3-phase alternator. The top diagram shows how the three sets of stator coils are set at 120° (or 2π/3 radians) apart, the bottom diagram shows the relationship of the three waveforms.
In words, the current equals the square root of the mean of the squares of the current. The r.m.s. or root mean square values of current and voltage are used whenever AC supplies are specified. Ohm’s Law and the relationship Watts = Amps × Volts both work when applied to resistive loads. Some other aspects of the sine wave are shown in Figure 1.24. An interesting point arises with 3-phase AC. Usually each phase can be considered as an independent supply, requiring two wires. In most electrical systems one side of the supply is connected to earth or “ground”. It is referred to as the Neutral connection, and the other side is called the Live (or “Hot”) connection. You get an electric shock off the live connection, but not off the neutral connection (provided it is well bonded to earth) because the neutral is at the same potential as you are if you are standing on the ground. In a 3-phase system the three neutrals are obviously joined together if they are all to be at ground potential. If you look carefully at a 3 phase waveform as in Figure 1.21 you can see that at any instant the three currents add up to zero – for example if at any one moment there are two positive currents and one negative, the sum of the two positives
that the average heating effect over the whole half cycle is: 2
2
2
2
i 1 R + i 2 R + i 3 R + .......... ....... + i n R n
Now if we say that I amperes is the Direct Current through the same resistance R which gives the same heating effect as the average heating effect of the AC, we have: 2
I 2R =
2
2
2
i1 R + i2 R + i3 R + .......... ....... + in R n
Therefore: 2
I =
20
2
2
i 1 + i 2 + i 3 + .......... ....... + i n n
2
Figure 1.22 A power station generator under construction. This one is from Siemens AG, and is rated at 1,000 MVA, with output at 27 kV. It uses hydrogen cooling to achieve a comparatively small frame size. The rotor carrying the rotating electromagnets is being inserted into the stator assembly, the coils of which collect the induced alternating current.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.23 Finding the heating effect of AC. Imagine the sine wave to be divided into many small sections, of current value i1 i2 i3 and so on to in. Each little chunk of current will make its own i2R heating contribution.
exactly equals the negative. The vector representation of currents helps make this clear. A 3-phase system with common neutral is referred to as a “star” or “Y” system, and its feature is that if the load on all phases is equal there is no neutral current. Power system design usually calls for balancing the load on the three phases in order to minimize or preferably eliminate neutral current. This is of great significance in lighting systems. While the r.m.s value of the voltage on a single phase in a 3-phase system is the same for each phase
Figure 1.24 Peak, r.m.s. and half wave average values of a sine wave. For all symmetrical waveforms the form factor is the ratio of r.m.s value to average value (1.11 for a sine wave) and the crest or peak factor is the ratio of the peak value to r.m.s. value (1.414 for a sine wave).
Figure 1.25 3-phase electricity. (a) shows the concept of three simultaneous rotating vectors, 120° apart. (b) shows a 3-phase alternator with Y output and Y connected loads; and (c) shows a 3-phase alternator with delta output (ǻ) and delta connected loads.
21
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
(for example 230V in Europe and 115V in USA in the home) the voltage across phases is much higher (and more dangerous). The r.m.s voltage across two phases is √3 × the single phase voltage (about 398V when the single phase voltage is 230V). There is another way of distributing 3-phase AC, arising from the fact that the vector sum of the e.m.f.’s is zero. This is to do away with the “neutral” connection altogether, and connect the alternator windings in a “mesh” or “delta” format. Figure 1.25 shows the idea. Vector considerations of the current show that the current in each load line is √3 times the current in the phase winding of the alternator. The arrangement is particularly suitable for powering big electrical motors. It is also encountered in some electical distribution systems (for example in Norway and on board many ships) and this has some consequences for lighting control systems. 1.3.4 Transformers In any simple electrical system, the power delivered to the load is the product of the voltage and the current. If we want to transfer 10kW of power, we can do it in several ways:
The voltage conversion process is done by a transformer. A transformer extends the principle of the inductor described earlier. A typical construction is shown in Figure 1.26. A coil is wound on an iron core and is fed from an AC supply. A second coil is mounted on the same core. When the current changes in the first coil or primary winding, it produces a change in magnetic flux, and this flux change must cut the conductors of the second coil. A current is, therefore, induced in the secondary winding, through mutual inductance – the process where two coils share the same magnetic flux. In the description of the inductor in Section 1.2.5 its behavior was discussed in relation to the application or removal of a direct current. This showed that the current reached a steady value and the coil circuit obeyed Ohm’s law once the steady state was reached. If we were to apply DC to a transformer, the same thing would apply. The current induced in the secondary would be momentary, and all that would happen is that the transformer would cook due to the high current and low coil resistance of the primary.
• at 10 Volts, we would need a current of 1,000A • at 200 Volts, the current is a reasonable 50A • at 10,000 Volts, the current is only 1A High currents mean very big conductors if there is not to be significant heat loss in the conductor due to the conductor’s resistance. The heat effect is proportional to the square of the current, so a cable resistance of one ohm would result in 2,500W being dissipated by the 50A current, but only 1W by the 1A current. Thus for electrical distribution the power generated at the power station’s alternator at around 20,000 Volts (20kV) is “stepped up” for primary distribution to as much as 400kV. Local distribution may be done at 11kV or 33kV, requiring a “step down”. Final distribution to the home and office requires a further step down to 230V or 115V depending on where you live. Figure 1.26 Construction of a transformer.
22
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.27 Example of a transformer used for lighting – a step-down transformer for low voltage tungsten halogen lamps. (Photo from Relco.)
But with AC the current, and, therefore, the magnetic flux, is constantly changing. There is a continuous back e.m.f. limiting the current in the primary, and the current in the secondary follows that of the primary. In a perfect transformer (and in fact most power transformers are quite efficient) all power put into the primary can be extracted from the secondary. For reasons explained in Section 1.4, transformer ratings are always given in VA (or VoltAmps). Figure 1.27 shows a 300VA transformer intended for use for lighting operating at 12V. This means that if it is fed with AC at 230V, the primary current is 300/230 = 1.3A. At the secondary, rated for 12V, there is a total of 300/12 = 25A available. The Ampere/Turns must be the same for the primary and secondary (clearly the transformer cannot actually create energy). Therefore:
In the example transformer, the 230V primary winding might have 400 turns, thus to give 12V at the secondary, the secondary winding needs only 21 turns. The turns ratio determines the voltage ratio. Good transformer design confines most of the magnetic flux close to the transformer core, so all of it is used to induce e.m.f.’s into the conductors. Power transformers working at 50 or 60Hz use special transformer iron alloy to provide the core. Being metal, this is a conductor – therefore the moving magnetic flux must induce electric current into it. The current so induced is called an eddy current because it circulates within the metal. Eddy currents cause heating, like any other current, and could be responsible for serious losses in transformers (and, of course, other electromagnetic devices, including alternators and motors). The problem is solved, if not entirely eliminated, by using a laminated construction for the transformer core. See Figure 1.28. The laminations are insulated from one another, and in this way any eddy current is confined to a single lamination. An example illustrates how effective the technique is. Suppose we substitute a single core piece with ten laminations: • the e.m.f. per lamination is only one tenth of that generated in the solid core.
Primary × Primary Secondary × Secondary turns amps = turns amps
But also: Primary × Primary Secondary × Secondary volts amps = volts amps
So: Secondary volts =
Secondary turns × Primary volts Primary turns
Figure 1.28 Electromagnetic devices working at 50/60Hz use iron alloy laminations to minimize the effect of eddy currents.
23
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.29 The autotransformer has only a single tapped winding.
• the cross sectional area is also reduced to one tenth, so the resistance goes up ten times; this reduces the current by a further factor of ten. The current per eddy path is thus reduced to 1/100th of what it would be in the solid core. In fact the eddy current loss is proportional to the square of the thickness of the laminations, so within reason the aim is to use the thinnest laminations practicable. An important feature of most transformers is that primary and secondary windings are completely separate; the power transfer is achieved entirely by induction. For many applications this is essential for safety or signal isolation reasons. In an autotransformer only a single tapped winding is used (Figure 1.29). Transformers used at high frequencies work on the same principle but use a different construction, described in Chapters 6 and 7. The iron alloy used in low frequency transformers has pronounced hysteresis, making it unsuitable for high frequency operation.
In an AC circuit with a resistive load, the current in the load is exactly in phase or “in step” with the applied voltage. But this is not the case with capacitance and inductance. Figure 1.30 shows a sine wave of current flowing through a pure inductance. The instantaneous value of current is Imax sin ωt. Now the voltage across an inductance is given by the inductance multiplied by the rate at which the current is changing. Mathematically this can be stated as: e =− L
di dt
Where e is the voltage, L the inductance in Henrys, and di the change of current in small time dt. The negative sign arises because the induced e.m.f. is in the opposite direction to the applied current. The rate at which the current is changing at any instant corresponds to the instantaneous slope on our sine wave current curve. If we plot the value of this
1.4 Power factor 1.4.1 Reactance The description of the transformer has introduced the idea that some loads may behave differently to simple resistances when connected to an AC supply. If we consider what happens when a pure inductance (i.e. an inductor with no resistance and no capacitance) or a pure capacitance (a capacitor with no inductance and no resistance) is connected to an AC supply we find the voltage and current get “out of phase”.
24
Figure 1.30 AC flowing through an inductance. The top sine wave is the current. The bottom curve is a plot of the gradient (or slope, or rate-of-change, whichever you find easiest to imagine) of the current sine wave. It turns out to be a cosine wave, which is simply another sine wave 90° (or π/2 radians) out of phase with the first one.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
slope against time, we find we get another curve looking the same, but out of phase with the current curve. It is a cosine curve, which is exactly the same as a sine curve, but 90° (or π/2 radians) out of phase. It is at its maximum when the current is zero, and at zero when the current is at its maximum. This sounds counter-intuitive, but what is happening is that the external AC supply puts energy into the inductance, but the induced e.m.f. puts the energy back into the supply. A mechanical analogy is that of the pendulum – when the pendulum bob is stationary, as it is changing direction at its highest point, it has maximum potential energy (voltage) but no movement (current); and as it passes through its lowest point, it is moving fastest (highest current) but has no potential energy (voltage). What limits the current through a perfect inductor? Is there an equivalent of resistance? There is, it is called the inductive reactance with symbol XL. It is the ratio of r.m.s. voltage to r.m.s. current, and is, therefore, measured in ohms. We can derive the formula for reactance in several ways, but the easiest is using simple calculus. Start with the equation: i = I max sinωt
Which is the description of our current sine wave. Differentiate this with respect to time to obtain the slope of the curve at any time (remember this is the rate of change of current with time). di = ȦI max cos Ȧt dt
(This is a mathematical shorthand for describing the lower curve in Figure 1.30. It says that any point on the curve representing a particular value of di/dt, or rate of change of current, can be calculated by the instantaneous value of ωImax cos ωt.) Going back to the equation e = - L di/dt, we can substitute the general expression for rate of change with the curve value (ignoring the - sign): e = −L
di = ω LI max cos ω t dt
For any angle θ, Cosine θ = Sine (θ + 90°) so we can write: e = ωLImax sin( ωt + 90° )
But in magnitude terms we know that Imax sin (ωt + 90°) is the same as Imax sin ωt (but advanced by 90°) and this equals the instantaneous current i. So we have in magnitude: e = ωLi
We have defined the inductive reactance XL as e/i so we have: XL =
e ωLi = = ωL i i
Now ω is the angular velocity of the current vector in radians per second, but this is the same as 2πf, where f is the frequency of the supply. Even if you have not followed the mathematics completely, the end result X L = 2πfL
is interesting. It tells us that the reactance is not simply proportional to the inductance, but also to the frequency of the AC supply. The higher the frequency, the higher the reactance. The same kind of analysis can be applied to a pure capacitance. This time we start with the equation: i=C
dv dt
That is to say, the instantaneous current equals the capacitance multiplied by the rate of change of voltage dv/dt. This time it is easiest to start with the voltage sine wave, and create the the current waveform from it (by the same procedure of plotting the new curve of instantaneous dv/dt). We find that, whereas with inductance the current lags the voltage by 90°, with a capacitance the current leads the voltage by 90°, and that the capacative reactance XC is defined by:
25
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Xc =
1 1 ( ohms ) = ωC 2πfC
Again the reactance depends on frequency. This time, however, it is inversely proportional – the higher the frequency the lower the reactance. Our “mind picture” of what is happening with reactive loads such as capacitors and inductors must not get carried away. It is easy to think of a capacitor “carrying” current through itself, but actually charge is building up cyclically on either side and then falling away. With an inductor, current flows in, to be returned by the back e.m.f. Both devices are temporary stores of energy, and in their pure form do not take heat energy from the supply. The fact that in both cases the current is 90° out of phase with the voltage means that average VA product is zero. Pure inductive and capacitive loads are sometimes referred to as “wattless”. 1.4.2 Impedance In any real circuit there is no such thing as a pure inductor or a pure capacitor. Any such device, including any real-world connections to it, includes resistance. Depending on the frequency of operation, an inductor may include significant, in the sense of reactive, capacitance and a capacitor may exhibit some inductance. The combination of the reactance and resistance in a circuit is referred to as impedance, and is frequency dependent. It is represented by symbol Z. The rules for calculating impedance, and for calculating currents in an AC circuit are more complicated than for simple DC circuits. We could use several different mathematical treatments to explain them, but the simplest way to visualize what is happening is the vector method. Let us start with the problem of adding two AC voltages, which are not in phase, but separated by a phase difference of angle φ. What is the resultant voltage? In the vector model we imagine two rotating vectors, each generating a sinusoidal AC voltage. We draw a line OE1 representing the first voltage. The length of the line represents the peak voltage E1, and the instantaneous voltage we designate e1. Figure 1.31(a) shows the idea. (At this stage we are
26
Figure 1.31 Adding two vector quantities (AC voltages) by the parallelogram method. (a) shows the principle for two rotating voltage vectors with phase difference φ. (b) shows an r.m.s. vector diagram, where V = 0.707E, and the vectors are stationary because time is not involved with r.m.s. values.
not bothered about the instantaneous phase situation of e1 but at any time e1 = E1 sin θ, where θ is the instantaneous phase angle.) Now we do the same for the other voltage, which we envisage as having a peak value of E2 and an instantaneous value of e2. The instantaneous sum of the two voltages can be expressed as: e = e1 + e 2 If we create a parallelogram from the two original vectors, we see that the diagonal of the parallelogram has an instantaneous value corresponding to e. Therefore we can say that the resultant voltage has a peak value E, corresponding to the length OE of the
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
We can generalize this approach for r.m.s. voltages and currents. Figure 1.31(b) shows the corresponding r.m.s. vector diagram (where r.m.s. values are 0.707 of peak) and the vectors are considered stationary. In practice an inductor is a device that has both inductive reactance and resistance, and can be considered as an inductance and resistance in series as shown in Figure 1.32(a). Figure 1.32(b) shows the vector relationship between the resistive voltage (which must be in phase with the current) and the pure inductive voltage, which lags 90° behind it. The line voltage V is the diagonal of the rectangle, and leads the current by φ°. The figure may be re-drawn as a “voltage triangle” as Figure 1.32(c). But we know in each case that the relationship between voltage and current is V = IR for a resistance, V = IX for a reactance and V = IZ for the circuit impedance. Pythagoras’ theorem gives us: (IZ)2 = (IR)2 + (IX)2 which can be restated as: Z2 = R2 + X2 or Z = √ (R2 + X2) From the above, the “voltage triangle” idea applies equally to impedance, as Figure 1.32(d). 1.4.3 Power factor
Figure 1.32 (a) shows a resistance and inductance in series. (b) shows the applied voltage V being made up of V1 across the resistance, in phase with the current; and V2 across the inductance, 90° ahead of the current. (c) shows the corresponding voltage triangle, from which we can derive the impedance triangle (d).
diagonal. Its phase relationship to the constituent voltages clearly depends on both their respective magnitudes and the phase relationship between them, and can be measured directly from the parallelogram model.
In a typical AC circuit with reactance present, a vector calculation of the resultant current and voltages done on the basis of Figure 1.32 will usually yield a VA product which is higher than the power in watts being delivered to the resistive load. The power factor in an AC circuit is defined as: watts r .m .s .Volts × r .m .s . Amps
or power factor =
watts VA
But watts = I2R and VA = I2Z.
27
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Table 1.5 Impedance formulae and power factors.
So power factor = R/Z, and from the impedance triangle we can see that: Power factor = cos φ where φ is the phase angle difference between current and voltage. When the current follows, or lags, the voltage, there is said to be a lagging power factor – as is the case with inductive loads. A leading power factor applies for capacitive loads. Table 1.5 shows the impedance and power factor for the common circuit elements. Any circuit involving inductance, especially electric motors and electromagnetic fluorescent lamp ballasts, will have a poor power factor of, typically, around 0.5. Why “poor”? Electric utilities companies don’t like low power factors because it means that their generation and distribution plant must be rated for the maximum VA product taken, but their customers only pay for the watts actually used. In practice inductive loads, with lagging power factor,
28
are the problem – and the problem is solved by applying power factor correction using capacitors to restore the power factor to near unity. This is an important technique for most kinds of discharge lighting. Today the term “power factor” is used to cover all “wattless” activity. As will be discussed later, many modern power control systems introduce harmonics onto the power line, or, looked at another way, they switch the power on and off very rapidly. The power company only gets paid for the “on” time, and cannot divert the resource during the “off” time which is measured in milliseconds. So they don’t like harmonics, any more than they like their fundamental sinusoidal current and voltage being out of phase. These factors are highly significant in lighting. When cos φ is quoted on a piece of electrical equipment (typically a fluorescent lighting ballast) it is defining power factor in the traditional way described above, related to a standard power frequency of 50 or 60Hz. The alternative power
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
factor symbol is λ which is the ratio of watts to all wattless components however they arise.
mechanically power assisted, and have arrangements for arc quenching.
1.5 Control of electrical power
Where there is to be a repeated switching action at comparatively high frequency (for example in animating an electric sign) the ordinary switch is no longer appropriate. Before the advent of electronic switches the best that could be done was the use of motor diven switches with “brushgear” contacts or of mercury switches where connection was made through a “liquid contact” of mercury. Today all high speed switching is done by power electronic components such as the thyristor or power transistor, described in Chapter 2.
The control of electric power is divided into two: • at its simplest to be able to connect power to a device (whether it be a giant electric motor, an electric kettle or a bedside lamp) and, just as important, the ability to disconnect it. • at a more sophisticated level, the ability to regulate a power flow. In this case we may want to adjust the speed of the motor, adjust the temperature of the water in the kettle, or the brightness of the lamp. In this section we review some of the control elements which are relevant to lighting. 1.5.1 Switches The humble light switch is the most familiar electrical control device. It is no more than a device which makes a physical break in the electrical circuit. However: • The switch contacts must not only be able to carry the running current, they may have to absorb an “inrush” current on switching on (and, indeed, must be able to withstand a short circuit current matching the rating of the fuse or circuit breaker protecting it) and, more importantly, suffer some arcing when switching off. This is particularly the case for DC, and also for inductive AC loads like fluorescent lamps and motors. • The switch contact must have negligible resistance. If it gets corroded by arcing, its resistance goes up, I2R heating sets in, and its resistance goes up still further. Eventually it fails, but it may have caused a fire in the meanwhile. For this reason switch contacts are usually made with precious metal alloys, and are constructed with a “wiping” action to assist maintaining a clean connection. A spring “snap action” is also included to make a fast circuit break. • High power switches used in electrical distribution have their contacts immersed in an insulating oil; or are mounted in an inert or otherwise controlled atmosphere. Any “open air” switches are
1.5.2 Fuses and circuit breakers All electrical circuits require protection against faults which might either damage equipment or injure people. Fault protection is divided into different types: Short circuit protection. This protects against short circuits. For example a stage lighting dimmer needs good short circuit protection if a badly wired temporary cable creates a “short”. Short circuits can result in very high currents, so must be cleared quickly.
Figure 1.33 Power factor correction capacitors, as used in fluorescent and high intensity discharge lamp circuits.
29
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Overload protection. This is to protect against conditions where the actual load is greater than that for which the circuit or control device is designed. For example where someone puts a 3kW lamp load onto a 2kW dimmer, or where a fault like a “shorted turn” develops in a transformer, which could lead to a fire if not detected. Life safety protection. This is a form of protection against lethal electric shock. In this case the equipment may be functioning correctly, but someone may have inadvertently touched a “live” part of it. The best known protection device is the fuse, and this is based on the simple principle of having a deliberately weak link in a circuit which is destroyed under fault conditions. A simple fuse is a single strand of thin tinned copper wire. When a particular current is exceeded, the I2R heating effect melts the wire, and the circuit is broken. When the wire breaks an arc develops between the two pieces of wire, so the circuit is not actually broken until the arc is extinguished through further destruction of the wire. The simple fuse is, therefore, an imprecise device, especially as it changes its characteristics with age due to oxidation of the wire. Typically a wire fuse blows at about 200% rated carrying capacity. It is therefore acceptable for short circuit protection, but not for overload protection. Fuses on their own do not provide protection against electric shock. The high rupturing capacity or HRC fuse is a more satisfactory device. For power circuits it is housed in a strong ceramic body to withstand the thermal and mechanical stresses arising from both normal running and fault conditions. The body is filled with granulated quartz, and the fuse element is silver. When the fuse blows the arc is immediately quenched because the silver and quartz together yield a high resistance compound. HRC fuses are precision devices. They can run at 100% rated current capacity continuously, but in some versions can be relied upon to blow at only 120% rated current. When HRC fuses are subjected to short circuit, they have a “clearing time” consisting of the time taken to melt (“pre-arcing” time) and the time taken for the arc to extinguish (“arcing time”). Their
30
5x20mm glass fuse rating 100mA - 10A Breaking capacity 35A@250V
5x20mm sand filled ceramic body fuse rating 100mA - 10A Breaking capacity 1500A@250V Panel mounted fuse holder for 5x20mm fuses; used in electronic and electrical equipment Consumer HRC fuse ceramic body rating 5A - 45A Breaking capacity 16.5kA@250V General purpose European style fuse ratings 1A - 63A in different sizes Breaking capacity up to 50kA@500V Industrial HRC fuse rating 2A - 200A in different sizes Breaking capacity up to 80kA@660V
Industrial HRC fuse carrier
Figure 1.34 Examples of fuses and their carriers.
characteristic is shown in Figure 1.35. It is obviously important that the “cut-off” current which is let through is lower than that which can be withstood by the equipment being protected. Usually the assymetric cut-off current is appreciably less than the prospective r.m.s. short circuit current. For
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
example a 60A fuse encountering a prospective short circuit of 50,000A should in practice cut off at 7,000A. All distribution systems need protection devices which have discrimination. Thus when protection is cascaded so, for example, one big fuse is used to protect a distribution panel with several lower rated fuses, it is important that the correct fuse blows when there is a fault. Thus the bigger fuse must have a higher cut-off current than the smaller one, otherwise a failure in a sub-circuit will blow the master fuse instead of the circuit fuse. (The same argument applies to circuit breakers.) When overcurrents involve fusing times of less than 10ms on a 50Hz supply, a different rating is used. This is based on the let-through energy measured as I2t, where I is the current in Amps and the time in seconds. In order to have correct discrimination, a family of fuses should have separated I2t, as shown in Figure 1.36. Small fuses are widely used for the protection of electronic equipment, both in the high voltage supply side and on the low voltage side. They represent the lowest initial-cost form of protection, but, of course, they are destroyed when they blow. In most cases a fuse failure in such equipment is a signal that something is seriously amiss.
Figure 1.35 The clearing time of a fuse.
Figure 1.36 Fuse discrimination measured by I2t in a family of fuses.
In power circuits fuses are used in primary protection, for example at the power intake to a house, and in some circuit protection (for example in the UK where the 13A portable appliance plug has a ceramic bodied fuse in it). Fuses are also widely used for the short circuit protection of electric motors. However, the majority of electrical distribution for lighting is based on circuit breakers. A circuit breaker is an automatic switch which automatically switches itself off when there is an overload. Circuit breakers use two different principles of operation. A thermal circuit breaker uses the heat of the current passing through it to heat a bi-metallic strip. Bi-metallic strips bend when heated due to the different rates of thermal expansion of each metal (the same action as in a thermostat). The strip triggers a spring release mechanism when it has heated up sufficiently. Thermal circuit breakers are useful for long term overload protection, but are imprecise because their tripping characteristic can depend on the load being carried and on ambient temperature. Magnetic circuit breakers rely on electromagnetic action. A coil carrying the fault current exerts a force on a plunger to trigger the release. This action can be very fast, resulting in nuisance tripping on loads which have an inrush current. This can be avoided by damping the plunger action hydraulically.
31
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.37 The miniature Circuit Breaker or MCB. Diagram from MEM Circuit Protection and Control (Delta Electrical Ltd.)
In lighting systems local cicuit protection is usually by miniature circuit breakers or MCBs. These have a combined thermal and magnetic action to deal with both short circuits and long term overload. An electrical distribution panel will usually have a group of MCBs connected to a bus bar, a solid copper or aluminum conductor which in turn derives its supply from a larger circuit breaker. The larger breaker will usually be what is known as a moulded case circuit breaker or MCCB. It is of a much heavier construction than the MCB and is intended for interrupting higher fault currents. Some MCCBs have adjustments permitting fine adjustment of the overload and short circuit trip currents, and trip times. Distribution panels may be single phase or three phase. Most work on 3-phase + neutral supplies, so the neutral conductors for all the loads are connected to a common bus bar, and protection is only single pole in the “live” conductor. There is always a requirement to “balance” 3-phase loads, i.e. to ensure that each phase takes the same load and neutral current is minimized. However in some countries like the UK there is also a safety requirement that limits the proximity of circuits on different phases (in the home, for example).
32
Sometimes “isolators” are fitted to electrical equipment. These are physically similar to MCBs or MCCBs, but have no trip element. They do, however, isolate both the live and neutral connection. The Residual Current Device or RCD is the device used for interrupting circuits for reasons of safety. It results in the RCB and the RCBO, or Residual Current Breaker, and Residual Current Breaker with Overload Protection. The principle of the RCD is that in any circuit the current flowing in the two wires (i.e. “live” and “neutral” in an AC system) should be equal. If it is not, then it is assumed that some current has “gone missing” – maybe through someone’s body. The RCD has current sensing coils in both legs of the supply, if it detects an imbalance, it trips. The principle is shown in Figure 1.39. The current which the human body can withstand without severe physical effect or even death is small, so individual RCDs are usually set to a current of around 30mA. There is a problem about RCDs in lighting control. Most systems have some unavoidable current imbalance, often a “leakage to ground”. (RCDs used to be called earth leakage trips by some.) This is quite often to do with the suppression of RFI (radio interference), or it may have to do with signalling circuits, or even the nature of the lamp load. While it is not a problem for single circuits,
Figure 1.38 Examples of Moulded Case Circuit Breakers or MCCBs. Some of these devices allow the user to set the tripping parameters. Photo from MEM.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
As an aside it has to be said that designers of power control equipment based in the 115V areas of the world sometimes under-estimate quite how “stiff” a European 230V supply can be. Conversely European designers can be mean in their provision of the high current connections needed for 115V, and sometimes don’t allow for the much wider percentage voltage swings met in practice. 1.5.3 Relays and contactors
Figure 1.39 Principle of the Residual Current Device or RCD.
since it is easy to set the RCD to a safe value while still permitting the required out-of-balance current; it does become a problem in multi-channel systems. These may require RCDs on each channel or small group of channels. If RCDs are to be used in cascade the back-up RCD must clearly have a much higher trip current than that of the subcircuit RCDs. The RCBO combines a thermal overload trip with an RCD, so it can be used for complete circuit protection. Power supplies can differ greatly, and this can have an influence on the effectiveness of protection systems especially where electronic power control devices are being used. Supplies are popularly characterized by their stiffness. A stiff supply is one with a low source impedance – typically one near the step-down transformer, and most likely to be found in large buildings with their own sub-station. With stiff supplies the prospective short circuit currents are much higher, whereas a “soggy” supply, usually involving long supply cables, cannot deliver high fault currents. Stiff supplies are to be preferred because the supply voltage does not change with load and the performance of protection equipment is more predictable. Soggy supplies can result in significant volt drop as more load is added – the “brown out” phenomenon.
In the home it is quite satisfactory to have a switch which is directly in the power line to control a lamp. But wherever there is a requirement to control high power, to provide multiple control points, or have remote control, there is a need for something different. A relay is the simplest remote switching device. Figure 1.41 shows that it consists of a switch contact which is actuated by an electromagnet. A small current through the coil causes the core to magnetize and attract the switch actuator. Removing the current causes demagnetization and the opening of the switch. The important principle is that the control signal can be completely isolated from the power it is controlling and usually, but not necessarily, is of much lower power than the power being controlled. Figure 1.42 shows some examples of relays. Some points worth noting are:
Figure 1.40 The “Memshield” MCB shown here can be converted to a Residual Current Breaker with Overload Protection or RCBO by the addition of auxiliary module.
33
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.41 The principle of the relay.
• relays can have AC or DC coils. Obviously the DC coil relays must have a high resistance because once the coil is magnetized the control circuit is only resistive. In an AC relay the coil is an inductive load, so the aim is the lowest practicable impedance to limit heating in the coil. • relays are not limited to single contacts. They can have multiple contacts in “Normally Open”, “Normally Closed” and “Changeover” configurations. • special relays are available for switching very low currents and high frequency signals (e.g. data signals, audio and video signals). Their construction is quite different to those used for power switching. • most DC relays use a magnetic core with low remanence to ensure quick demagnetization when current is removed. Some relays have high remanance, or are polarized with a permanent magnet, to provide bistable operation – i.e. even if the control power is removed, the relay stays operated. This usually involves the use of two coils, one to operate the relay, the other to release it. • in lighting control relays are usually being controlled by some electronic circuit. This means that they are typically operated with 24V DC coils. When the power is removed from the coil, the back e.m.f. may be sufficient to destroy the control electronics, so relay coils are usually fitted with suppression diodes. The diode (see Section 2.2) can
34
carry current only one way, so in normal operation carries no current. The current from the back e.m.f. being in the opposite direction to the main control current is then fed back into the coil where it dissipates as heat. See Figure 1.43. • AC relay coils are not so bad, but again can produce a voltage “spike” which can both create interference, and damage the control circuit. With AC the direction of the current is indeterminate, so a “snubber” RC (resistor-capacitor) network is used. An alternative is a device called a voltage dependent resistor which normally has a high resistance, but goes low resistance when it is subjected to a voltage above a certain threshold. • it is not only the relay coil which can cause voltage spikes. Clearly the switching contact will usually be producing even bigger ones. Assuming that the load being controlled is AC, then an RC Reed relay, used for switching low level control signals. 5V DC coil, 500mA 50V single pole contact.
24V DC coil, single pole 20A 230V AC contact, used for circuit isolation in a professional automatic dimmer.
24V DC coil, 1A 100V dual changeover contacts. Used for control signal isolation in show control equipment.
Plug in general purpose power relay. Twin changeover contacts 10A 230V AC. Choice of AC (24230V) or DC (12-24V) coils.
Figure 1.42 Examples of relays.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
network across the contact can be used for suppression. This is good practice in any large system, and wherever sensitive electronic equipment is installed; but it has to be admitted that in many installations no such snubbing network is installed. Big relays, switching high currents are, for some reason, referred to as contactors. These usually, but not necessarily, have AC coils working at line voltage. They are often used as part of lighting control systems for primary power switching. They are also the basis of conventional electric motor control (outside the scope of this book, but often requiring three phase operation with a switch from star to delta connection of the motor windings as the motor runs up to full speed). 1.5.4 Power control Power control for lighting is reviewed in detail in Parts 3 and 4 of this book, so here a simple summary of the possibilities will suffice. Clearly any power control system must vary the current passing through the “load”. At this stage it is easiest to think only in terms of a resistive load like a tungsten filament lamp.
Figure 1.43 The suppression diode reduces the high voltage back e.m.f. from relay coils. An RC network is often used to suppress interference from relay switching contacts.
Figure 1.44 Examples of contractors suitable for lighting control from MEM Circuit Protection and Control.
Figure 1.45 summarizes the possibilities for AC. A variable impedance can be introduced into the circuit to vary the current. At its simplest this could be a variable resistance, but this is wasteful and another possibility is a variable inductance. A means of providing a variable voltage could be provided. For example an autotransformer with a sliding contact tapping. A high speed switching device could be imagined which worked so fast that it could vary the electric power simply by switching it on and off. We would not see the effect of this because the thermal inertia of the lamp filament would keep it glowing even when the power is disconnected. This method, unlikely as it may seem, is the basis of most dimming systems today. The AC waveform is “chopped” to deliver as much or as little power as needed. The load receives continuous power at full on, no power at off and 100 or 120 (depending on
35
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.45 Control of AC power.
where you live) bursts of power per second of a variable duration for any setting in between. An electronic power converter could be used. There might be an advantage in having a device which could not only regulate the current, but could in fact change the power regime. For example a 230V 50Hz supply on the input might be changed to a variable 0-24V 50Hz supply on the output; or a 115V 60Hz supply on the input converted to a controlled output at 100V 30kHz. Electronic power conversion is now an important part of lighting control.
or even when an old automobile passes near by. The fact that such interference is actually much less noticeable today than it was some years ago is largely due to concerted international efforts to reduce or eliminate its effects. The huge proliferation in electrical and electronic devices has led to a realization that all such equipment must be “compatible”, in that the safe and effective operation of one device must not itself lead to the unsafe or unreliable operation of another. The term electromagnetic compatibility, often abbreviated to EMC is used to describe this hopedfor harmonious relationship. The compatibility must be of various kinds: • any electrical device must not itself emit interference (in practice above a certain minimum level) • notwithstanding this, any electrical device must itself be immune to interference (again, in practice, below a certain maximum level) • the emission and immunity must apply both to conducted and radiated interference. Conducted interference is fairly easy to understand. This is any interference which comes up the power line, or comes into to equipment by virtue of a wired control connection. The description of inductance given in earlier sections shows that it can create back e.m.f.s which can result in high voltages leading to switch arcing and other undesirable effects. An “unsuppressed” inductive load can, on switch-off, create a voltage “spike” with
1.6 Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) Most of us are familiar with the effects of electrical interference. Maybe your computer has “crashed” after a lightning strike, or when you unplugged another electrical device on the same circuit. Or you have noticed your radio or TV has a buzz or crackle when certain other electrical devices are operating,
36
Figure 1.46 The concept of the electromagnetic wave. It consists of simultaneous electric and magnetic fields exhibiting a transverse wave motion. The electric field E is orthogonal (at right angles) to the magnetic field B. Here the graph x axis is time, the y axis is the momentary value of E and the z axis the momentary value of B.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
In words, the velocity of the wave motion is related to the relative permeability and the relative permittivity of the medium it is passing through (see Sections 1.2.4 and 1.2.6). Here the power -½ is the same as the reciprocal of the square root -1/√x. In the special case of free space or vacuum, the velocity is denoted by c, and: c = (μ0ε0)-½
Figure 1.47 Transverse wave motion, and the definition
a peak which might be more than double the normal line voltage peak. No wonder your computer objects. Conducted interference is not necessarily due to disturbance on the power line. Interference can be induced into control cables, even when there is no direct electrical connection. Radiated interference arises from the indiscriminate generation of radio waves. It might be wondered what radio waves have to do with switches and dimmers, but, in fact any electrical device is involved in some way or another with electromagnetic radiation – a posh name for radio waves (and other kinds of radiation). When the fundamental discoveries about electricity and magnetism were made in the nineteenth century the experimentally observed results were codified into a number of mathematical equations. Around 1865 James Clerk Maxwell compared Gauss’ theorems as applied to electrostatics (electric fields, like those found in capacitors) and magnetic fields, with Faraday’s and Lenz’s laws of electromagnetic induction and Ampère’s law for magnetomotive force. He realized that the presence of both an electric field and a magnetic field would result in a wave motion. The electromagnetic wave which he predicted was demonstrated experimentally by Heinrich Hertz about 20 years later. Maxwell showed that the velocity v of the wave motion in would be: v = (μμ0εε0)-½
Substituting the actual values of μ0 and ε0 gives value for c of around 299,790 km/second (about 186,000 miles per second) which had already been determined experimentally as the velocity of light. Maxwell realized, therefore, that his as yet undemonstrated electromagnetic waves were probably related to light. Any wave motion has the relationship: v = fλ where v is the velocity, f the frequency (number of oscillations per second) and λ is the wavelength, or the distance between successive “in phase” points on the wave – see Figure 1.47. Radio waves are generally defined as that part of the electromagnetic spectrum where the frequency runs from 1–10 12 Hz, and wavelengths from kilometers to fractions of a millimeter. AM Radio works around 1MHz, FM radio around 90MHz, UHF Television around 600MHz, and digital mobile phones in the GHz region. If lighting control is normally concerned with controlling power at 50 or 60Hz, why does this have relevance to equipment operating at much higher frequencies? Most electrical waveforms, especially those occurring in electronic control equipment, are not sinusoidal. However, Fourier showed that any complex waveform could be synthesized by adding together a number of different sine waves. A harmonic of a fundamental sine wave is one which has twice, three times or any multiple of the fundamental frequency. Figure 1.48 shows what happens when harmonics are added to a fundamental.
37
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.48 The harmonics of a fundamental wave motion. Only the second and third are shown, but the principle applies to any multiple of the fundamental. Complex waveforms can be analyzed into the sum of a large number of sine waveforms. Square and sawtooth waveforms are widely used as current and voltage waveforms in electronics and are rich in harmonics.
Fourier’s bad news was that when there is a steeply rising waveform, as might happen when a sine wave voltage is switched at its peak, there can be a huge number of harmonics generated. Digital computers and microprocessors depend for their operation on square waves where current is being switched on and off as fast as possible. Fourier says that a real square wave would have an infinite number of harmonics. Any electrical or electronic equipment can produce electromagnetic radiation by virtue of the fact that the components and conductors within it produce electric and magnetic fields. If the waveform is complex, the resulting radiation could be high frequency even if the fundamental frequency of operation is low (as in AC power systems). The problem is to design the equipment so that the resulting electromagnetic radiation is minimized. Many components can be designed so that stray fields are minimized. In transformer design the aim is always to keep the magnetic field within the core material. Electric fields can be contained by electrostatic shielding, which in simple terms is no more than a conducting surface, for example a metal can or a metallic conducting paint on a plastic surface. The way in which cables are constructed is
38
critical; twisted pair signal cables can be constructed so that fields from the two conductors cancel out and radiation is minimized. Most power control equipment requires RFI suppression components to be included in their design. Radio Frequency Interference suppression usually involves the use of small capacitors and inductors which have a low or high impedance at the high frequencies concerned. These can be used either to “short out” the high frequencies, for example by capacitor coupling to ground (earth) or reduce high frequency currents by inductive impedance, for example by using ferrite rings round the cable. The lumps you see in cables connecting a personal computer to peripheral equipment are an instance of this technique. Conducted interference signals can be measured in volts, so standards for limiting them, or for defining immunity to them can be laid down in terms of the voltage at different frequencies. Radiated signals can be defined both by their electric field strength and by their magnetic field strength. It is more usual to use the electric field strength E, measured in volts per meter (V/m, or its multiples, like μV/m) since the voltage developed in an antenna (aerial) is directly related to E, and can be measured
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
directly. However, magnetic field strength H, measured in amperes per meter (A/m) is one of the signals measured in EMC tests. The full requirements for EMC cover not only electromagnetic phenomena, but also magnetic fields, inrush currents, electrostatic discharge and other quantities. EMC is of great importance in lighting control equipment, and is referred to in the appropriate sections of this book. In particular a review of the main legal requirements is given in Section 8.5.
1.7 Light 1.7.1 The nature of light In some ways light is more mysterious than electricity. While a simple introduction to electricity allows us to use a single model or mind picture, light needs different models depending on the aspect of interest. Isaac Newton proposed that light existed as “corpuscles”. These would be radiated in straight lines by luminous bodies, and would act on the eye’s retina. Straight line optics work well for some aspects of optical design, especially when the components are large, like mirrors and lenses. So the idea was not without merit. Huygens, backed by experimental results from Young and others, demonstrated that light must have a wave nature. Observed effects like diffraction could not be explained any other way. The wavelengths were found to be very short. At the time there was a problem in describing what the waves travelled in – we can understand waves as ripples on water, or pressure waves in air, but how did the waves travel through a vacuum? It was proposed that an all pervading substance called the “ether” was the carrying medium. The wave theory received a big boost, and the problem of the ether disappeared, when James Clerk Maxwell proposed that light was a form of electromagnetic radiation as described in Section 1.6. Electromagnetic radiation is seen as having a very wide spectrum, and visible light occupies only a small part of it as shown in Figure 1.49.
Figure 1.49 The electromagnetic spectrum.
However Einstein, Planck and others showed that the photo-electric effect, where light falling on certain substances could cause an electric current to flow, could only be explained by a 20th century variation of the corpuscular theory. This new version was proposed as the quantum theory of radiation, because it requires that energy only travels in defined packets or quanta. The quantum of light was, and is, called a photon. Modern physics brings together both the quantum and wave theories by stating that every moving
39
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
particle of mass has associated with it a wave whose length is given by: wavelength = h/mu where h is Planck’s constant (6.626 × 10-34 Joule seconds) m is the mass of the particle, and u is the velocity of the particle. The equation comes with the not altogether helpful rider that you cannot actually determine all the properties of a particle simultaneously. Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle tells us that if you know where something is, then you cannot know its precise mass – or if you know its mass, you don’t know where it is. If you try and apply the equation above to everyday objects, you obtain meaningless results; but when applied on the atomic scale things begin to make sense. A dual “mind picture” or model of light is needed: • for most practical applications, the wave nature of light, expressed as part of the electromagnetic spectrum, is the simplest model. • for some aspects of the behavior of light, the quantum or photon model is needed, on the understanding that the photon itself has a defined wavelength. The photon model becomes more comprehensible when the model of the atom described in Section 1.1 is recalled. What happens if an electron jumps from one shell, or orbit, to another? The idea that such a move can only happen between one defined energy level and another fits well with the quantum concept. The idea emerges that: • when an electron drops from a high energy level to a lower one, a photon is emitted. • similarly a quantum of energy can be absorbed, and when this happens an electron moves from a lower orbit to a higher one. Sometimes referred to as moving from a normal orbit to an excited orbit. The energy of a photon is defined as: E2 - E1 = hν where: E2 is the energy associated with the excited orbit,
40
E1 is the energy associated with the normal orbit, h is Planck’s constant, ν (Greek letter nu, NOT our letter V) is the frequency of the radiation emitted as the electron moves from Level 2 to Level 1. E2 - E1 is conveniently measured in electron-volts. An electron-volt (eV) is the work required to move an electron through a potential difference of one volt. It is equal to 1.603 × 10-19 Joules. In lighting we are concerned with the wavelength of the emitted light, since this will determine whether or not the radiation is visible. Since we know that: c = νλ where c is the velocity of light (approximately 3 × 108 m/sec) λ is the wavelength, and ν the frequency; we can, by putting in the value of Planck’s constant, re-write the photon energy formula in the form: Wavelength λ in nm = 1239.76/energy in eV An example relevant to lighting is the fact that electrons surrounding mercury atoms (when in vapor form) can be made to emit photons with energy 4.89 eV. The formula shows us that this results in radiation of wavelength 254nm, well in the ultra-violet part of the spectrum. 1.7.2 Wavelength conversion Concepts which are needed to understand how the lightsources described in Part 2 work include the ideas of wavelength conversion and blackbody radiation. The energy needed to raise the energy level of electrons can be imparted in several ways. One significant way is from heat. Heat within an object is rapid motion of its atoms; the energy from this motion can change the energy levels of the outer electrons. Another way is by the application of an electric field; and yet another is by bombardment with electromagnetic radiation. An example of this last case in action is the fluorescent lamp (described in more detail in Chapter 3.) In this lamp the invisible 254 nm radiation from
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
example is sodium. Low pressure sodium vapor emits a characteristic monochromatic yellow light (actually two “lines” very close together at 589.0 and 589.6 nm) and this can be seen if salt is dropped on a flame, or in the low pressure sodium street lamp. Individual atoms have characteristic spectra. In order to get useful light for illumination purposes, it is necessary to have a source giving multiple lines, or, ideally, a continous spectrum. 1.7.3 Blackbody radiation Figure 1.50 Concept of transitions between different energy states. On the left, transitions between normal and different excited states. On the right, transitions between different excited states only.
mercury is directed at a phosphor, which is excited by the radiation. The excited electrons in the phosphor then drop back to a lower level; but the drop is not as great as the 4.89 eV of the original photon. It is more like 2.3 eV, resulting in visible radiation around 545nm. (Note that this is just an example – phosphors emit a band of radiation over a range of wavelengths.) This is an example of “wavelength conversion” whereby an efficient method of producing an invisible electromagnetic radiation (in this case UV) is used to stimulate the production of visible radiation, via, in this case, a phosphor. The outer electrons of atoms can have several excited states. Figure 1.50 shows in simplifed form what can happen. Electrons can be raised from their normal state to one of several excited states. But in addition there can be transitions between excited states. The result of this is that any atom has a characteristic absorption spectrum and emission spectrum. Each transition, whether between different excited levels, or between an excited level and normal level, is associated with a given frequency and corresponding wavelength (approximately 254 nm in the case of the mercury example already given). In lighting our interest is in those transitions which result in visible radiation. Reference is often made to spectral lines. This is because, when light from a source is analyzed using a spectroscope, it is seen as a series of colored lines. A well known
A metal heated to a high temperature glows; it emits visible radiation. A blackbody radiator is one whose intensity and spectral properties are dependent solely on its temperature. In fact the blackbody radiator is also a blackbody absorber – in that it absorbs all incident radiation of all wavelengths. It does not reflect any incident radiation. The blackbody is an ideal concept; it radiates more total power and more power at any given wavelength than any other lightsource operating at the same temperature. Figure 1.51 shows blackbody radiation curves for a variety of temperatures. From the curves it can be seen that a blackbody needs to be at a temperature of above 2,000K to give out useful quantities of visible radiation. Its important attribute is that the output spectrum is continuous. Note that for any given temperature there is a radiation peak at a particular wavelength, which gets shorter as the temperature rises. Also, as the temperature rises, the total amount of radiation increases. Real sources of radiation can never achieve the performance of a blackbody; but the blackbody is used as a performance reference. The spectral emissivity of a radiator is a wavelength dependent quantity which is the ratio of the output of the radiator at a particular wavelength, to the output of a blackbody at the same wavelength. Figure 1.52 shows the comparative performance of the perfect blackbody and tungsten (used in filament lamps) at 3,000K. The color temperature of a radiator (for example a tungsten filament) is the temperature at which a blackbody would have to be for its output to match
41
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
control, and for which it is useful to have a basic understanding. While the blackbody absorbs all radiation falling on it, all real surfaces reflect some or most incident radiation. Some definitions are: Specular reflection is where light is reflected in the manner of a mirror. Specular reflectance is the proportion of light reflected expressed as a percentage of the incident light. Specular reflection obeys the Laws of Reflection illustrated in Figure 1.53. Specular reflectance can range from around 7% for a normal sheet of glass (which transmits most light) to 95% for a surface aluminized mirror. Polished stainless steel and chromium plate have reflectances of around 60%. Diffuse reflection arises when the surface is rough. In this case the light is scattered in many directions. A special case is the perfect diffuse reflector which reflects any incident light equally in all directions. A matt white painted surface is an example of a near perfect diffuse reflector. Most
Figure 1.51 Blackbody radiation curves at different temperatures.
as closely as possible that of the chosen radiator. The concept works well for any continuous spectrum source, for example an incandescent filament or sunlight, but breaks down when applied to sources with discontinuous spectra. Examples of color temperatures are: Typical tungsten filament lamp: Noon sunlight: Cloudy sky; average daylight:
2,850K 4,900K 6,700K
1.7.4 The behavior of light The subject of optics is beyond the scope of this book, but nonetheless there are aspects of the behavior of light which are of importance in lighting
42
Figure 1.52 Comparison of the radiation from a blackbody at 3,000K, and the corresponding performance of tungsten.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
surfaces exhibit a combination of diffuse and specular reflection. Refraction describes what happens when light passes from one transparent medium to another; for example when going from air into or out of glass, or from either into or out of water. Figure 1.54 shows light passing through a transparent glass prism. Light which does not arrive normal (at right angles) to the surface is bent or refracted. The following apply: • The angle of incidence (i in the figure) is the angle which the incoming ray of light makes with normal; similarly the angle of refraction (r) is the refracted ray in the new medium. Assuming the ray is going from a less dense medium to a denser one, r is less than i. • Refractive index μ is defined by
μ = Sin i / Sin r • The refractive index applies to different pairs of media, but the refractive index vacuum/glass is almost exactly the same as that of air/glass; so in practice it is common to refer to the refractive index of a material referred to air. • The wave theory of light shows that in fact the refractive index is the ratio of the velocity of light in Figure 1.54 Light being refracted through a prism (a). The dispersion of light into its different colors by a prism (b). The critical angle at the glass/air surface within a prism (c).
Figure 1.53 The Laws of Specular Reflection (Snell’s Laws). The incident ray, reflected ray and the line at right angles (normal) to the surface are all in the same plane; and the angle of incidence equals the angle of reflection.
a material to the velocity of light in a vacuum (or air, where the slowing down of light is negligible). • Within most materials there is a slight difference in the velocity of light for different wavelengths. This is why a prism can be used to split light into its different wavelengths or colors, because the bending effect is different for each color. • Transparent materials have a critical angle. From Figure 1.54 it can be seen that the emerging ray diverges from normal (i.e. gets closer to the prism surface). The internal ray can finally be at an angle (the critical angle) where theoretically the emerging ray would correspond to the plane of the glass surface. Beyond this angle the light is internally
43
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
reflected, with the exit glass/air surface acting as a mirror. In binoculars and camera viewfinders prisms are used to reflect light. Glass and certain plastic materials such as acrylic and polycarbonate sheets are made to be transparent; but may also be made translucent. Here either surface treatment or the nature of the material itself causes multiple scattering of the light. In luminaire manufacture such material is used as a diffuser to increase the apparent size of a light source (and reduce its point brightness). Typical luminaires make use of reflection, refraction and diffusion in order to make the best use of the light from a particular source. Figure 1.55 shows examples. The wave theory of light predicts the possibility of interference. If two wave motions of identical wavelength meet, then their individual amplitudes can be added together. This means that if the wave motions are in phase they reinforce each other, but if they are out of phase, they cancel each other out.
ceiling tile luminaire with prismatic panel (refraction)
ceiling luminaire using both reflection (center) and diffusion (either side round tubes)
luminaire using aluminum reflectors
An anti-reflection coating is a practical manifestation of interference. Such coatings are used to minimize specular reflections in showcase glass, or to increase light transmission through lenses. The principle is shown in Figure 1.56. This shows the specular reflection off the first surface being cancelled out by a second wave exactly half a wavelength out of phase. The second wave has been refracted into the thin film, reflected off its other internal surface, and refracted out again – the film thickness being such that by the time it emerges, it is out of phase with the initial reflection. A thin film of different thickness could augment the reflection instead of destroying it. Multi-layer coatings are used to improve transmittance or reflectance. For example a 4-layer coating on a surface coated mirror (designed to increase reflectance) can raise reflectance above 99%; conversely triple coated lenses for cameras have a reflectance of less than 1%. The same technique can be used to create interference filters. By using multiple thin films (each layer of a different refractive index, and different thickness) it is possible to create a filter. A high pass optical filter passes high frequency (short wavelength) light, and reflects long wavelength light. A low pass optical filter does the opposite. In the lighting field such filters are important. They make available hot and cold mirrors, as found in some reflector spotlights and projection devices. A cold mirror reflects the full visible spectrum, but transmits infra-red radiation, which in the example spotlight application, would go out the back of the reflector instead of on to the illuminated object. Dichroic filters are efficient filters with a very sharp transition between transmission and reflection • for example having a transmittance band of 400– 500nm blue, and reflectance band 500–700nm yellow.
1.8 The eye, how we see light Figure 1.55 A luminaire using a fluorescent lamp may well make use of a combination of reflection, refraction and diffusion to make the most effective use of the light from the tube.
44
The human eye is an incredible device – but the eye on its own is only a light collecting mechanism, it requires the brain to make sense of what is received.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.56 Principle of the anti-reflection coating.
Figure 1.57 is a much simplified diagram of the eye, and identifies: • the cornea, the transparent outer layer which, with the tear layer, protects the eye, but also provides the first refractive element of the eye. • the iris, which regulates the amount of light entering the eye, by changing diameter. It does this in the range of about 2-8mm, representing a range of 16:1. This alone is not sufficient to cover the huge range of illumination encountered. Our eyes also have to “adapt” to the lighting condition, but this takes time, whereas the iris acts instantaneously. • the lens, which focuses light onto the retina. By use of the ciliary muscle the lens can change focal length, depending on whether it is looking at a near or distant object. • the retina, which receives the imaged light. It contains the receptors for light and produces the electrical signals for the brain to process. • the fovea, more or less at the center of the retina. This is the part of the eye by which we see most detail, but represents a very small part of our overall field of view. • the optic nerve. This communicates the information received by the retina to the brain. Because it occupies a small part of the retina, we have a “blind spot” at this point.
The retina is found to have two different kinds of light receptors, identified as rods and cones. Rods provide us with scotopic or night vision, and are very sensitive to light. There are no rods in the fovea. All rods contain the same photopigment, so they see in “monochrome”. Photopic or day vision is done by the cones. Of six million of these, more than one million are located at the center of the fovea, representing only a 1° field of view. All these have an individual connection to the brain. The remainder are spread across the retina, and, like the rods, report to the brain in groups. The cones are in three classes, each with a different photopigment. Figure 1.58(a) shows the spectral response of the eye as a whole, and here it is clear that the scotopic and photopic responses peak at different wavelengths. Figure 1.58(b) shows that for the three different kinds of cone there is a significantly different response. It seems that, between them, the cones deliver to the brain achromatic (non-color) information and separate hue information (not unlike a color TV).
1.9 Measurement of light In the same way that we needed objective methods of measuring electrical quantities, there is a need
Figure 1.57 The eye.
45
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
(a)
(b)
Figure 1.58 Spectral response of the eye.
for the objective measurement of light. In fact the measurements can still be based on the MKS system, but it is necessary to introduce one more fundamental unit, and the SI system uses the Candela as that unit. A major problem about measuring light is the practical necessity of relating the measurement to
46
human vision. As shown in Figure 1.58 the human eye has a different response to different wavelengths of light. By experiment it was found that the wavelength of maximum luminous efficiency, that is the wavelength which produces the maximum response in the eye for the minimum power input, is approximately 555nm. At all other wavelengths our eyes have a lower photopic spectral luminous efficiency V(λ), where λ is the wavelength. If V(λ) is unity (1) at 555nm, then it is found to be about 0.5 at 510 and 610nm, and as little as 0.00006 at 385 and 760nm. The Candela, the SI unit of luminous intensity is today linked to the human eye’s peak response, and is tied back to the power radiated in Watts; its official definition is given in Table 1.6. (Note that Table 1.6 also gives the definitions of total power radiated, independent of the eye’s response.) Our appreciation of the brightness of a light source is defined by its luminance, expressed in Cd/ m2. The definition is given in Table 1.6 – the bit about orthogonal projection is telling us that you get a different brightness if you view the source at an angle. Luminance figures are very important in lighting design and in the specification of electronic displays. Table 1.7 gives some examples of luminance. The lumen is the unit of luminous flux. This is a unit which many lay people have heard of (especially from salesmen who probably have no idea what it means) but which in fact is one of the more difficult units to understand fully. At 555nm, the lumen is fairly easy – since it is tied directly to the candela (see the definition in Table 1.6) – a one candela point source emits 4π lumens. At 555nm it is easy to calculate the number of lumens which can be derived from a given power (or Watt) input. But what happens at other wavelengths? The efficacy of a light source is defined in two ways. The luminous efficacy of radiant flux is measured in Lumens/Watt, and is the ratio of the luminous flux in lumens to the total radiant flux in Watts. More useful in the lighting business is the luminous efficacy of a source of light, also measured in Lumens/Watt, and the ratio of the luminous flux in lumens to the total lamp power input.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Quantity and symbol Luminous Intensity I
Unit
Luminance (or "Photometric brightness") L Luminous Flux F
Candela per square meter (also known as the "nit") Lumen
Cd/m2
Illuminance E (also Illumination) Radiant Intensity Ie Radiance
Lux
lx
Watts per steradian Watts per steradian per square meter Watts
W/sr
Radiant Flux )e Irradiance E
Candela
Watts per square meter
Unit Symbol Cd
lm
W/(sr.m2) W W/m2
Defined as The luminous intensity of a 555.016nm (or 540 u 1012 Hz) source which has a radiant intensity in a given direction of 1/683 Watts per steradian, when measured in that direction. (Formerly defined as 1/60 of the intensity of a square centimeter of a blackbody at the temperature of solidification of platinum.) The intensity of a source in a given direction, divided by its orthogonally projected area in that direction. An isotropic (one which emits radiation equally in all directions) point source of intensity one Candela produces a total luminous flux of 4S lumens. But see also main text which describes how, when related to input power, lumens are wavelength dependent. The concentration of luminous flux falling on a surface. One Lux is is one Lumen per square meter. Radiant power emitted by a point source in a given direction. The radiant intensity of a source in a given direction, divided by its orthogonally projected area in that direction. Radiant power of a source at all wavelengths Radiant power incident on a surface. (Compare Illuminance)
Table 1.6 The measurement of light. Radiant intensity, radiant flux, radiance and irradiance are physical units based on power and apply to all wavelengths. Luminous intensity, luminous flux, luminance and illuminance are luminous units, which are wavelength dependent and based on the human eye’s response. They are tied back to physical units through the Candela.
Everyday examples of the latter are around 14 lm/W for an ordinary tungsten lamp and 85 lm/W for a fluorescent lamp. To derive the luminous efficacy of a source which is emitting many wavelengths, it is necessary to add the contribution at each wavelength. For photopic vision the formula is:
770
Lumens = 683 Σ PλVλΔλ 380
where the Σ sign is telling us to “sum for all wavelengths between 380 and 770nm”; and:
47
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Source
Ft. lambert
Nit
482,000,000 Sun at meridian 1,750,000 Sun at horizon 600 – 2,300 Sky, typical 2,600 Fluorescent lamp 150 TV screen (CRT) 14-18 Motion picture screen
1,700,000,000 6,000,000 2,000 – 7,800 8,800 500 48-62
Table 1.7 Examples of luminance.
Pλ is the spectral power in watts of the source at wavelength λ. Vλ is the photopic luminous efficiency at wavelength λ. Δλ is the interval over which the spectral power is measured. To be really thorough these “photopic” lumens should be added to a separate calculation for “scotopic” lumens. In this case the initial multiplier is 1,700, the wavelength range is 300 to 770nm, and there is a quite different set of values for scotopic luminous efficiency. In practice scotopic vision is only of importance at very low light levels, so is not usually considered when discussing electric lighting. There is a maximum theoretical efficacy for an “ideal” white light source. This is a source which radiates light at constant power over the complete visible part of the spectrum, but does not radiate power outside it. The maximum efficacy is approximately 220 lm/W. An important measurement in lighting design is illuminance – this is a measure of how much light is falling on a surface per unit area. Today the accepted measure is the Lux or Lumen per square meter. However, some industries still use measurements based on imperial units where the illuminance is measured in Footcandles (or lumens per square foot) and luminance is measured in FootLamberts (where a surface emitting one lumen per square foot is said to have a luminance of one FtL). Table 1.8 shows the relationship between the imperial and metric units. Figure 1.59 may help visualize the units. It shows a sphere of radius r, where we know that the surface area of the sphere is
48
4πr2. At the center of the sphere is a point source of one candela, which we know is emitting 4π lumens. Let us assume the inside of the sphere is totally absorbing, so the inside surface is ONLY illuminated by the point source, and not by any cross-reflection. If the radius of the sphere is one meter, then the flux falling on one square meter of its surface (= r2) must be one lumen, and the illuminance on that square meter one lumen/square meter or one lux. Another way of looking at it is that the flux density is 1 lm per steradian, which applies whatever the radius of the sphere. Thus if the sphere radius is only one foot, the illuminance on the inside surface will be one lumen per square foot or one footcandle. It would be very tedious if, every time we wanted to measure luminous flux or illuminance, we had to do it at many different wavelengths. Fortunately this is not necessary. Most light measurements are now made using solid state detectors based on silicon. The principle is that the absorption of a photon creates a free electron to contribute to an electric current. By having a detector of a known area, it is possible to measure the incident illuminance. Detectors respond to radiation in the visible spectrum (and, if required, either side of it). The detector is usually “corrected” so that its response closely matches the Photopic Luminous Efficiency characteristic of the eye. This means that the complete instrument or Photometer can directly read out in Lux, see example in Figure 1.60.
Quantity Luminance Illuminance To convert Nit to Ft Lambert Ft Lambert to Nit Lux to Ft Candle Ft Candle to Lux
Metric
Imperial
Nit or Cd/m2 Lux or lm/m2
Ft Lambert Ft Candle or lm/ft2 Multiply by 0.2919 3.426 0.0929 10.76
Table 1.8 Relation between metric and imperial units.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.59 Derivation of units of illuminance.
A Luminance Photometer is similar, but it includes an optical system, like a telescope, which focuses a source onto the detector. The Commission Internationale de l’Éclairage or CIE is the body which lays down how lighting measurements are made. Their publications not only define how instruments are calibrated with reference to the SI standards, they also include the agreed luminous efficiency curves. One problem characteristic of illumination is glare. This does not lend itself to easy measurement because its effects are subjective. In practice it is a significant factor in lighting design, so various efforts have been made to codify its effect. We see things not only by their brightness, but also by their contrast relative to their surroundings. We can easily see black lettering on a white background, but making out white lettering on a white background is difficult if not impossible. Generally the higher the illumination, the better we see things; but if luminance levels vary greatly, for example when driving in the dark and having to contend with oncoming headlights, a high luminance relative to the surroundings causes our perception to break down. Discomfort glare is when the lighting situation is uncomfortable, disability glare is when the lighting situation means that it has become impossible to do
the intended task. Usually both apply at once. For example low winter sun streaming into an office can be both uncomfortable and make carrying out a normal office task impossible. Glare can arise in all lighting schemes. A person sitting in a low ceilinged office may have a well illuminated desk from an overhead luminaire, but also be distracted by the glare from an overhead luminaire some distance in front of him. Specular reflections in VDU screens arising from sources of relatively high brightness can make the screens impossible to use. Various methods are used to quantify the effects of glare, to assist lighting designers eliminate its effects. They are all related to defining the highest levels of luminance for a given source size, which can be tolerated within a given level of illumination for a particular activity. The USA use the Visual Comfort Probability (VCP) system, the UK the Glare Index system and the CIE has introduced the Unified Glare Rating (UGR). Glare is relevant in lighting control, because its effects can sometimes negate the intended results of a control scheme.
Figure 1.60 Example of a photometer used for making illuminance measurements.
49
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
1.10 Color 1.10.1 Introduction Sections 1.8 and 1.9 above have warned us that the eye does not work in an obvious way. Different wavelengths of light are seen with a different sensitivity; and the eye sees the visible spectrum with three different receptors. Worse still, our perception of color varies according to the field of view (i.e. the angle subtended at our eye by the object.) This means that any measurement of color must take into account how the eye works, and cannot be based on simple power spectrum measurements alone. In practice the situation is made much worse because the apparent color of an object will depend not only on its own properties, but on the spectral distribution of the source. As an extreme example an object which is seen as blue in daylight looks black or gray when illuminated by a low pressure sodium lamp (with its monochromatic yellow light). This section describes some color phenomena, and gives definitions of color attributes. Section 1.11 describes how color is measured. 1.10.2 Primary and secondary colors The way the eye/brain combination sees color has the interesting result that the simultaneous presentation of two colors makes the brain think it is seeing a third. For example if separate red and green spotlights are both directed at the same surface, the eye sees the surface as yellow. Figure 1.61 shows how three primary colors, red, green and blue can be mixed: red + green = yellow green + blue = cyan blue + red = magenta red + green + blue = white The two-color combinations so derived are called the secondary colors, they each represent “white minus a primary color”:
50
yellow = white - blue cyan = white - red magenta = white - green This phenomenon is the basis of all aspects of color manipulation. Additive color mixing is where primary colors are mixed to achieve a desired color. There are many everyday examples related to lighting and display: • color television depends wholly on additive color mixing. The TV screen consists of a large number of small dots which, at a normal viewing distance, the eye integrates into a single image. The dots are in red, green and blue triads. Each small zone on the screen has its own color value determined by the mix of red, green and blue. • a stage backcloth can be illuminated by cyclorama floodlights in sets of three, each set red, green and blue. By setting different proportions of each, any color (within the gamut of the primaries) can be achieved. • lamps can be “tuned” to have an appropriate output. Thus, for example, a fluorescent lamp might be deemed to be too “cold”. This can be corrected by adding a phosphor which emits in the red part of the spectrum. The red will not be seen separately, but only as a “warming” of the white. Color mixing can also be subtractive. In additive mixing, light of different colors is added (to “black”) with the result that the perceived light is brighter than its constituents. Subtractive color mixing works the other way, it takes light away from white, so the result is darker than its constituents. The mixing of color paints, and the color printing process are examples of subtractive color mixing. The use of color filters is another subtractive process. A theatre spotlight with a tungsten filament lamp gives “white” light; a color filter removes all colors other than the wanted color. A problem can arise when filters are applied to light sources with uneven spectral output. Putting a red filter round a fluorescent tube may only go to show how little red there is in the light it is emitting.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Standards, the Optical Society of America, British Standards and DIN have developed alternative systems to Munsell, but use similar principles. This type of system is practical for many real world tasks; but does not relate color directly to physically measurable quantities. However, it is possible to relate Munsell (and similar) color descriptions to their equivalent CIE Chromaticity value, described in Section 1.11. Figure 1.61 Primary and secondary colors.
1.10.4 Color temperature
1.10.3 Aspects of color, the Munsell system
Color temperature was defined in Section 1.7.3. Strictly the term applies only to light sources with continuous spectra, and which lie on the blackbody radiation curve or planckian locus described in Section 1.11 below. However it is convenient to use it for other sources, and in this case it is referred to as the correlated color temperature or CCT. The CCT is the temperature of a blackbody whose chromaticity (defined in Section 1.11 below) most closely matches that of the source concerned. Computer programs and graphs are available which give “isotemperature” lines on the chromaticity chart, so if the chromaticity of the source is known, it is possible to derive its CCT. However, the further away from the blackbody locus the source lies, the less meaningful the derived CCT. Lamp manufacturers refer to lamps being “warm” or “cold” according to their CCT. For example:
An early attempt to quantify color was made in 1915 by the American teacher, Albert Munsell. It is still in use because in practice it provides an easy method for architects and designers to compare colors. In the Munsell system, color is defined by three attributes: Hue: this is simply defining the perceived color as being near to a principal color like red, green, blue, yellow or to a mixture of any two. The Munsell system defines five principal and five intermediate hues, but allows 100 hue steps in all. Value (also brightness): This expresses whether the surface is reflecting (emitting) more or less light. It can also be considered as the “whiteness” of the color, and is measured on a scale of 0 (black) to 10 (white). Chroma (or Saturation): is a measure of the “colorfulness” or intensity of the color. Munsell allows 20 (or more) steps from neutral through to highly saturated. The Munsell system is represented both by a three-dimensional “color atlas”, and by a collection of carefully standardized color chips. The ideas behind the Munsell system are illustrated by Figure 1.62, but note that this is for illustrative purposes only and cannot show the actual colors. Color matching using Munsell color chips can only be done with a standardized source (preferably daylight) but, of course, such chips can also be used to judge the performance of different light sources. Other institutions, including The Inter-Society Color Council working with the National Bureau of
CCT less than 3,300K is “warm” (example, tungsten lamp) CCT 3,300–5,300K is “intermediate” (example, cool white fluorescent lamp) CCT greater than 5,300K is “cold” (example “daylight” fluorescent and some metal halide lamps) The effect of color temperature is quite dramatic. If you are in a room lit by tungsten lighting, a small fluorescent fixture fitted with a “daylight” lamp looks very blue; conversely, if you are in a daylit space, an ordinary lamp looks somewhat orange. The effect is particularly notable in photography and television. A film intended for outdoor use is usually “balanced”
51
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
52
MIRED filter corresponds to a change of 1,800K. But it is easy to work out that a +100 MIRED filter applied to a 10,000K source, makes a 5,000K change in color temperature.
1/
2/
4/
Chroma 6/ 8/
10/ 12/
14/
9/ 8/ 7/ 6/ Value
for 5,500K; that is to say that it will give faithful reproduction of colors if the scene is, in fact, illuminated by daylight, or its artificial equivalent with the same color temperature. If the film is used on a studio set illuminated with tungsten lighting at 2,800–3,200K, everything comes out very orange. While films balanced for studio tungsten lighting (at around 3,200K) are available, it is often the case that film and TV lighting cameramen must make use of filters to modify the color temperature of studio luminaires. Figure 1.51 showed the characteristics of blackbody radiation. Mathematically the graphs illustrate: • the Stefan–Boltzmann Law which states that the amount of radiation emitted by a blackbody is proportional to the fourth power of the temperature (so the amount of radiation increases enormously with temperature). • the Wien Displacement Law which states that the wavelength of peak emission is inversely proportional to the temperature. The latter leads to the observation that perceived equal changes in color are more accurately expressed by a measure of the reciprocal of the color temperature (i.e. 1/T). In order to have manageable units, the reciprocal megakelvin is used. This is simply 1,000,000 divided by the color temperature. The same unit is also known as the micro reciprocal degree or MIRED. Thus, for example, a source of 4,000K has a MIRED value of 250. If you just specified a color temperature correction filter as, for example, “blue” to correct a low temperature source, you would not be able to predict easily what its effect would be, since it would be quite different on each source. But if you specify a filter by its MIRED value, it is easy to calculate exactly what its effect will be – regardless of the color temperature of the source to be modified. As an example; suppose the available source is 5,000K (=200 MIRED) and it is required to apply a filter to convert to 3,200K (=312 MIRED), the filter has to be +112 MIRED. A filter to go from 3,200K to 5,000K would correspondingly, have to be a -112 MIRED filter. For this particular color temperature change, a 112
5/ 4/ 3/ 2/ 1/
Figure 1.62 The Munsell system of color classification. The diagram shows the main hue classification and the way in which value and chroma apply to a single hue.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
CIE Color Rendering Index Ra >90 8090 6080 4060
2040
Typical Application
intervals, in practice 5nm. The most commonly used sources are:
Where accurate color matching is required; e.g. print inspection Where good color judgement is required, or where appearance is important; e.g. retail display Where moderate color rendering is required; e.g. commercial premises Where color rendering is not important but where a marked distortion of color is unacceptable; e.g. warehouses Where color rendering is of no importance, and a marked distortion of color is acceptable; e.g. some road lighting
Standard Illuminant A: Representing tungsten at a color temperature of 2,856K. Standard Illuminant B: Representing noon sunlight at a color temperature of around 4,870K (now superseded by Standard Illuminant D50) Standard Illuminant C: Representing average daylight (cloudy sky) with an average color temperature of 6,700K (now superseded by Standard Illuminant D65)
Table 1.9 The CIE Color Rendering Index.
1.10.5 Color rendering There is a need for different kinds of lamp to be classified according to their color rendering abilities. Clearly the monochromatic low pressure sodium yellow lamp has non-existent color rendering ability; and a tungsten filament lamp has quite good color rendering. The most common method of classifying color rendering is that of the CIE, the Color Rendering Index or CRI, designated Ra. The method uses sample surfaces of eight or fourteen Munsell test colors (described in 1.10.3 above.) Each surface is illuminated in turn by a standard reference source, and then by the source under test. At each stage the spectral reflectance (i.e. the reflectance at different wavelengths) of the test color is measured. The reference source is deemed to have a CRI of 100, and the test source is rated against it for each part of the spectrum. The problem here is, clearly, “what is the reference source?” The CIE have defined several in terms of their spectral power distribution. To be of any use in practice this has to be done to quite fine
Spectral power distribution tables are also available for other “daylight” illuminants, such as D55 and D75. Table 1.9 gives examples of CRI. Clearly the fact that different reference sources can be used to determine CRI means that a user must know which reference has been used.
1.11 Measurement of color 1.11.1 CIE Chromaticity Diagram The achievement of a desired color by mixing primary or secondary colors leads to the idea that any color can be described numerically as three tristimulus values. However, simply relating color to, for example, three spectral lines corresponding to optimized red, green and blue is not sufficient. The reasons can be summarized as: • such an arrangement cannot easily describe spectral colors (other than the three primary colors chosen). This is intuitive, since additive color mixing is always “lightening” the illuminated object. A simple analysis shows that any system based on this idea would need “negative” color values; which might be an acceptable mathematical trick (and can, in fact, be used in electronic analogs of color) but is not satisfactory for real world work. • the gamut of colors which can be described by three “real” primaries is limited. This can be seen by drawing an imaginary color triangle as in Figure 1.63. Points R G B represent the primaries, and any
53
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
point within the triangle represents colors which can be produced by mixing them. Point W in the middle represents the white light (equal energy of each of Red, Green and Blue). Colors which might exist outside the triangle (including pure spectral colors) cannot either be created by the chosen primaries, nor be described purely with reference to them. The CIE got round this problem with their Chromaticity Diagram, originally produced in 1931. The idea here is to postulate three imaginary primary colors denoted X, Y and Z. Any color is then defined by the proportions it contains of each, the values for any color being denoted by the chromaticity coordinates, designated x, y and z. Because it is always the case that: x+y+z=1 any color is, in fact, defined by its x and y coordinates on the diagram. Figure 1.64 shows the basis of the diagram. It starts with the spectrum locus which is the horseshoe shaped curve. On this curve appear the pure spectral colors, and the principal wavelengths are identified in the figure. The line across the bottom of the horseshoe represents the magentas and purples (which are not spectral colors, but mixtures of blue and red). The outer lines of the diagram represent saturated colors.
Figure 1.63 Simple color triangle
54
Figure 1.64 The CIE chromaticity diagram showing the spectrum locus, and how an individual color is defined.
To help understand the diagram, it is shown in various forms. Figure 1.65 shows it in color. Here it can be seen that hue is dependent on the position relative to the spectrum locus, and saturation is dependent on how near the edge of the diagram the color is. Superimposed on it are two color triangles. Points R, G and B correspond approximately to the phosphors used in cathode ray tubes (CRTs) to produce a color TV picture. The triangle RGB defines the limit of the colors which can be reproduced. As a matter of interest earlier CRTs used more widely spaced primaries, theoretically giving a wider color gamut. However, today’s phosphors have been chosen as the best compromise in respect of overall image brightness and color range. Points R’, G’ and B’ correspond approximately to the triangle available in a theatrical luminaire used for color wash effects. In this case the color filters used are dichroic. Figure 1.66 shows the diagram with the planckian, or blackbody, locus superimposed. This line represents the appearance of a blackbody at increasing color temperatures. It clearly shows how
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.65 The CIE chromaticity diagram in color. Obviously this is an approximation, limited by the printing process. See main text for description of the triangles.
Figure 1.67 Some examples of isotemperature lines shown on the CIE chromaticity diagram. The number against them is in MIRED or recripocal MK.
“red” tungsten filament lighting is when compared with other “hotter” sources. Figure 1.67 shows examples of isotemperature lines, used to derive correlated color temperatures (see Section 1.10.4). 1.11.2 Luminance, metamers, color spaces It would be correctly argued that the introduction of the CIE chromaticity diagram in 1.11.1 has oversimplified matters. The diagram as it stands is twodimensional. While it correctly deals with hue and saturation, it does not properly deal with brightness or luminance. A more rigorous understanding of tristimulus values is needed for this. The aim is to define the light from a source, or from a reflective surface, with tristimulus values which uniquely describe its strength and color. The chromaticity co-ordinates x, y, and z are defined by:
Figure 1.66 The CIE chromaticity diagram showing the planckian, or blackbody, locus.
x = X/(X + Y + Z) y = Y/(X + Y + Z) z = Z/(X + Y + Z)
55
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Figure 1.68 The CIE primary color matching functions. The figure is an approximation. CIE issue two different sets or figures depending on field of view. Each set is given for a range of standard illuminants. Note here that the colors used to show x , y and z are simply to distinguish them in the figure.
X, Y and Z are the amounts of the imaginary primary colors needed to match a specified color. They are defined by equations which in words can be summed up, as: X is the sum for all wavelengths between 380nm and 780nm of the measured spectral energy, multiplied by the spectral tristimulus value x. Similarly for Y and Z. The values of, x, y and z for different wavelengths are shown graphically in Figure 1.68 assuming an equal power spectrum (i.e. the maximum power at all wavelengths is equal). The CIE issues a table
56
giving precise values at 5nm intervals. In practical applications (for example in the film studio) X, Y and Z can be measured by portable instruments like the one shown in Figure 1.69. This does the necessary calculations to show the results in various ways in addition to tristimulus values – for example the x and y co-ordinates on the Chromaticity Diagram, with a separate reading for brightness. Color matching is bedevilled by the fact that it depends not only on the source, but also on the characteristics of the object being illuminated. Two visually indistinguishable lightsources with the same spectral compositions are said to have a spectral match. But two observed lights may appear to be visually indistinguishable despite having quite different spectral compositions. Such a color match is called metameric, and is conditional. For example two items illuminated by a tungsten lamp may appear to have an identical color; however, when illuminated by daylight they appear to have different colors by virtue of their different spectral reflectances. This phenomenon is of great importance in lighting design. For example, a stage or interior lighting designer can only do his or her job with the actual dress or furnishing fabrics to be used. “Rehearsal” dresses might look quite different in color terms under the final intended lighting, even
Figure 1.69 A portable tri-stimulus color meter from Minolta. This one shows luminance, the x and y color coordinates, and also temperature.
ELECTRICITY AND LIGHT
Figure 1.70 Adding a third axis to the chromaticity diagram allows luminance to be included.
if the “rehearsal” and “real” fabrics looked the same under daylight. The y function in Figure 1.68 corresponds to the photopic response of the eye. Thus the Y value is a measure of the brightness (luminance) of the source or illuminated object. A third axis can be added to the chromaticity diagram as shown in Figure 1.70. Here lighter colors appear above the point representing their chromaticity at a height representing their lightness. The Y axis “touches down” at the point representing the chromaticity coordinates of the illuminant. Figure 1.70 illustrates the concept of color space, a three dimensional representation of both color and luminance. Its problem is that it does not correlate all that well with perceived color differences, in that regions of apparent small color difference use up a lot of space, and some areas of major perceived difference are all “bunched up”. To get over this, in 1976 the CIE introduced other color spaces known as CIELAB and CIELUV. In both systems L* (lightness index) and either the a*,b* or u*,v* chromaticness indices (the way in which the perceived color appears more or less chromatic) are related to X, Y and Z by a set of equations. In industry the two systems co-exist because CIELAB has been found most suitable for
describing the color of objects, while CIELUV is used for emissive devices like TV screens. Figure 1.71 shows in diagramatic form the CIELAB color space. Notice that black now has a defined place on the map, at the origin. The L* , a* and b* axes can be considered as representing “white”, “blue-yellow” and “green-red” respectively. The alternative CIELUV is similar (L* is the same for both) but uses a different set of transform equations. In many practical systems (especially those concerned with electronic display and printing) somewhat simpler color models are used. These are normalized so that, for example, measurement of red, green and blue primaries (for display) or cyan, magenta, yellow secondaries (for printing) is weighted. This is so that each can be scaled from 0–1 or 0–100%, yet still sensibly yield a full color gamut on a simple incremental basis. The weighting is tied back to the CIE color spaces. Color, and the many different attempts to describe it, is a complex subject. This brief review can do no more than introduce it, and give a first insight as to why lighting in practice often gives surprising results. The reading list includes books that give more comprehensive coverage.
Figure 1.71 The CIELAB color space. The color of the point P is described by three quantities. Lightness L* measured on the vertical axis; Chroma C*ab measured as a*, b* co-ordinates, and Hue, measured as the angle h.
57
Chapter 2
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Lighting 2.1 Electronic principles 2.1.1 Introduction In this chapter the intention is to give sufficient background information to understand the basics of electronics as applied to lighting control. We build on the ideas of Chapter 1. Electronics differ from electrical engineering mainly in the power levels and frequencies involved. Traditional electrical engineering and electromechanical systems involve items such as motors, generators, switches, relays, transformers etc. all operating at something similar to mains frequency alternating current. Electronic engineering, on the other hand, is normally characterized by having no moving parts (other than items such as isolating switches) although sometimes the electronic device is itself connected to a “traditional” electromechanical unit such as a relay or motor. Most electronics operate at low voltages, and with comparatively low currents. They may also operate at high frequencies. For example a microprocessor may work from a 3.3V supply, consume only a few milliamps, and operate at a frequency of many MHz. In lighting control we encounter power electronics which is where electronic techniques are used to handle significant electrical power. The principle is usually that all the “clever stuff”, for example logic and control, is done at low power, i.e. in the normal electronic environment, but that this is connected to various electronic power devices which translate the intelligence into brute power. The range of power electronics is very wide. At the low end a small inverter to operate a fluorescent lamp from a battery may only be controlling a few watts. At the high end the motor controllers used on modern trains are electronic inverters handling more than a Megawatt. In lighting control we do not usually get into the Megawatt range for a single control channel; light-
58
electronics ing electronics is mainly concerned with power control in the range 5W–10kW (for a single channel). Complete systems may, indeed, handle Megawatts, but always as multi-channel systems. 2.1.2 Some basic electronic operations Electronics are highly complex, but can be thought of as being based on a “building block” principle. However, in the same way that all electric motors work on similar principles, yet a 1MW train motor is significantly different in construction to a sewing machine motor; so the electronic building blocks, such as electronic switches, may start from the same principles, yet require very different designs to realize for different applications. Without, yet, considering how we are going to either create or use the devices concerned, let us postulate some items which could be useful. For example: The electronic switch. Section 1.5.3 introduced the idea of the relay, where a small signal current is used to control a bigger current. In the relay the action is electromechanical – there is still a physical means of breaking the circuit. In the electronic switch the principle is similar to that of the relay, except that the switching element is solid state, it has no moving parts, and no contact gap. Comparing the electronic switch to its relay equivalent might well raise the following questions: How is the control signal isolated from the power it is controlling? Typically transformers are used to provide signal isolation. Opto-electronic components are also used. Is it possible to have an electronic switch with no resistance? Obviously if there is a voltage drop across the switching element, heat will develop within it. There always is a drop, but in the best devices it is small. Most power devices need mounting on a heat sink to take away the excess heat. Is the “off” position of the switch really off? where safety is concerned any leakage could be dan-
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
(a)
High current Load
Low current signal
Electronic switch
Large AC signal through loud speaker
(b)
Amplifier
Small A.C. Signal
Figure 2.1 (a) shows the concept of the electronic switch, where a low voltage, low current signal is used to instruct the electronic switch to apply full power to the load. Although shown for DC switching, the principle also applies to AC. (b) shows an amplifier, where a small varying voltage is amplified to a larger voltage.
gerous. Most systems have a separate isolating switch which is used when complete isolation is required. Does the switch work faster than its electromechanical equivalent? Yes, and this is its main advantage. It can switch millions of times without wearing out, and it can switch very fast indeed. The amplifier. The concept of an electronic am-
plifier is similar to the electronic switch. In the switch a small signal of fixed magnitude “lets through” a current which is only limited by the circuit impedance. In Figure 2.1(a) the switched current through the load will be determined by the voltage V, and by the total resistance represented by the load, the switch itself, and the internal resistance of the battery supply. (If it was an AC circuit we would be talking about impedances instead of resistances.) In Figure 2.1(b), the electronic switch is replaced by an amplifier. In this device the current let through is not constant, but varies in proportion to the control signal. No input signal, no output. 20% input signal, 20% output current, 100% input signal, 100% planned output current. Amplifiers are normally used with varying or alternating currents, the most obvious manifestation being audio equipment where very small signals derived from radio detectors, phonograph pick-ups or CD decoders are amplified so we can hear them when converted back to acoustic energy by a transducer, for example a headphone or a loudspeaker. The rectifier. There is often a need to turn AC into DC. Most electronic equipment (or at least its control and logic side) works from DC, so it is either battery powered, or is powered from a step-down transformer whose AC output is converted to DC. The start of the conversion process is by the rectifier. This can be thought of as a special kind of switch, which does not require any signal to operate, but only lets current through in one direction. Figure 2.2 shows the action. The output of a simple rectifier is DC, but is the result of half wave rectification. In practice it needs cleaning up. A full wave rectifier can be constructed in several ways, but the most common method is the bridge rectifier. Figure 2.3 shows how four rectifying elements are used. The positive going part of the AC waveform goes through one rectifier, then the load, and out through a second rectifier. The other two rectifiers provide a blocking action to ensure that the current only goes through the load in one direction. When the negative going part of the AC waveform arrives, the rectifier pairs exchange roles. Rectified AC has a high ripple content. In order to make it suitable for circuits needing a DC supply,
59
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Anode
Anode
Cathode
Cathode
Rectifier
Rectifier
Load
Load
Load
AC Supply
AC supply
Waveform at Current flow positive half cycle Anode
Waveform at anode
Waveform at cathode
Negative half cycle Waveform at Cathode Waveform at load
Figure 2.3 The most common full wave rectifier, the bridge rectifier. Figure 2.2 The half wave rectifier. Pulses of DC flow through the load.
it must be smoothed, and the simplest way of doing this is to add a capacitor. The capacitor value is chosen to minimize the ripple, but precautions have to be taken to ensure that the initial charging current does not exceed the rating of the rectifier. Figure 2.4 shows the idea. The oscillator. Electricity as described so far has come in two flavors, DC and AC. We have also admitted that there may be electrical signals used for carrying information or control instructions in the form of continually varying voltages. In some circuits there may be a need for a high frequency AC signal. This might be needed either because it was intended to operate an electrical device at a much high frequency than normal mains frequency, or because a precise means of timing was required by virtue of the accuracy of the signal. For this purpose we need some kind of oscillator. Electronic oscillators played an important part in the development of radio, producing sinusoidal waveforms. Today they still play an important role in electronics, but techniques have changed considerably.
60
2.1.3 Resonance, tuned circuits and filters In Chapter 1 we encountered capacitors and inductors in isolation. Now we consider what happens when the two meet. Figure 2.5 shows an AC circuit with Addition of smoothing capacitor
Load
Waveform at load
Ripple
Original Smoothed
Figure 2.4 Using a capacitor to “smooth” the output of a sine wave rectifier.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
R
L
C
I
The nett result of the two reactances, since they are in direct opposition, is OB-OC, and is shown as OD. The supply voltage V must be the vector sum of OA and OD, shown as OE on the diagram. A little bit of Pythagoras shows: OE2 = OA2 + OD2 = OA2 + (OB-OC)2
V
If we convert the vectors into the corresponding electrical quantities: V2 = (RI)2 + (ωLI - I / ωC)2
B
Factor out the current I to give: Voltage Vector
V = I √ [R2 + (ωL - 1 / ωC)2]
D
E
Restate as: I = V / √ [R2 + (ωL - 1 / ωC)2]
O
I
I
A
But I = V / Z where Z is the circuit impedance. Therefore in the series circuit shown, the combined
Current Vector
1
C
Q=
resistance, capacitance and inductance. If V and I are the r.m.s. values of the voltage and current respectively, we can say that the voltage across the resistance R is RI volts, shown as OA in the vector diagram, and is in phase with the circuit current I. We know that the voltage across the inductance is ωLI (i.e. the inductive reactance multiplied by the current) and that it is 90° in front of the current, and shown as OB in the diagram. Similarly the voltage across the capacitor is I/ωC but lagging the current by 90°, and shown as OC in the diagram. For the purposes of the diagram OB is considered greater than OC.
| 100
R Low Q | 10
Current I/I R
Figure 2.5 At the top an AC circuit containing resistance, inductance and capacitance in series. Below is the corresponding vector diagram. OD is the voltage across L and C combined. OA is the voltage across R and is in phase with current I.
High Q
Z2 L
0.5
0 0.5
1.0
Frequency f/f0
1.5
Figure 2.6 Current in a series resonant circuit. Maximum current possible is that due to the resistance only IR. The Q of a resonant circuit can be shown to equal the ratio of inductive reactance at resonance to the resistance. In the diagram f0 is the resonant frequency
61
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
R C L I
fo
Figure 2.7 In a parallel resonant circuit resonance is achieved when φ equals zero; impedance is then at a maximum, and current at a minimum.
reactance arising from the inductance and capacitance is ωL - 1/ ωC, or inductive reactance minus the capacitive reactance An interesting thing happens when we juggle the values of L, C, and ω (i.e. the frequency) such that the two reactances cancel out. The current in the circuit is now limited only by the resistance, and it is possible for the voltages in the circuit to be many times the nominal supply voltage. When this condition arises the circuit is in resonance. The resonant frequency of the circuit is given by the condition that the two reactances cancel out, i.e.:
ωL - 1/ωC = 0 or ω2 = 1/LC but ω , the angular frequency, = 2πf where f is the frequency, so the resonant frequency is: f = 1/2π√(LC) The current carried by a circuit such as that of Figure 2.5 varies with frequency in the manner shown by Figure 2.6. The narrowness of the current peak and the ratio of the maximum to minimum current represent the Q of the circuit.
62
If a similar analysis is carried out on a circuit where the inductance is in parallel with the capacitance, an interesting result is found. Again there is a resonant condition, and the formula for the resonant frequency turns out to be exactly the same. However, whereas in the series resonant circuit, the total impedance is at a minimum at resonant frequency; in the parallel resonant circuit the impedance is at a maximum at the resonant frequency. See Figure 2.7. The resonance phenomenon is widely used in electronics. Tuned circuits are used in radio – for example a circuit containing an inductance and a variable capacitor is used to “tune in” to a particular frequency – if the circuit has a “high Q”, it will accept the signal at the required frequency, and ignore signals either side of it. LC combinations can also be used as the basis of oscillators. While an LC combination on its own cannot maintain a continuous electrical output because of the inevitable resistance in the circuit; it can be the determinant of an oscillator frequency. A transistor is used to pulse energy into the circuit, but the transistor itself is triggered by the resonance. However, it is difficult to make frequency-accurate oscillators this way, and most oscillators used in lighting control, for example as the master timing element for a microprocessor, are based on quartz crystal oscillators. These use the natural mechanical resonance of the crystal as their basis. Finally LC combinations can form the basis of filters. In fact some filtering can be done using only RC combinations, for example simple low pass and high pass filters – but LC filters are more specific and effective for particular frequencies. They can use both series and parallel arrangements – for example a parallel arrangement can block a particular frequency, or a series arrangement can be used to divert or short-circuit unwanted signals. Such filters are of great importance in lighting control and power electronics. 2.1.4 Active and passive components In electronic circuits components are broadly categorized as being active or passive. Passive devices are those which require no energy to operate, other than
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
the applied voltage or “signal”. They generally present an impedance, and are represented by inductors, resistors and capacitors. Active devices are those which change the nature of an electrical signal or waveform, and allow the realization of the building blocks described above. They require an external energy source; examples are the transistor and the thyristor. The diode is a special case; although it is usually a passive component, certain types of diode or diode circuit make it an active component.
2.2 The diode 2.2.1 Background The diode is a two terminal device which provides the function of the rectifier described in 2.1.2 above. In the early days of electronics low current, high frequency diodes, as used in radio sets, were constructed as vacuum tubes (valves to the Brits) or as point contact crystal diodes (used in “crystal sets”). Medium power, low frequency diodes, as used in battery chargers, were made using selenium or copper oxide rectifiers; and high power diodes, suitable for providing DC for traction purposes (e.g. the London Underground) used mercury arc rectifiers. However, for all but highly specialist or replacement purposes, these have all been superseded by the semiconductor junction diode. It is this component, first realized in germanium, but now mainly in silicon, which is of importance to lighting electronics. 2.2.2 Semiconductors Most active electronic components start with extremely pure crystalline silicon, produced by growing a big crystal of silicon from a seed crystal, and then zone refining it. This is a local heating process where the heating is progressively moved down the length of the crystal; it has the effect of making all the impurities move down to one end. The impure end is cut off, and the remainder sliced up into wafers for further treatment. Figure 1.1 showed that the silicon atom has four electrons in its outer orbit. On its own, this is an un-
Si +4
Si +4
Si +4 Spare Electron
Si +4
+5 P
Si +4
Si +4
Si +4
Impurity Atom
Si +4
Valency Bond
Figure 2.8 An impurity within a silicon crystal lattice can provide an extra electron for conduction.
stable state and stable crystalline silicon arises from a sharing of the outer valency electrons. Covalent bonds between neighboring atoms result in each atom having eight electrons in its outer orbit, which is a stable state. Electrical charge neutrality is maintained because the additional electrons are only “borrowed”, and there is no nett change in electrical charge. Crystalline silicon at room temperature is an insulator. If extra energy is given to a silicon atom, for example in the form of heat, it is possible for an electron to break away from its valency bond, and become a free electron able to conduct electricity. However, the atom left behind now has a positive charge. This is referred to as a hole, and the movement of holes, arising from free electrons jumping from one atom to another in succession, is another form of conduction – in the opposite direction to the electron flow. Silicon (a Group IV element in the chemical periodic table; Group IV also includes carbon and germanium) is referred to as tetravalent because of its four valency electrons. Group III elements, such as aluminum, gallium and indium, are trivalent with three valency electrons, and Goup V elements, such as phosphorus and arsenic, are pentavalent with five valency electrons. Silicon’s ability to conduct electricity is changed dramatically if it has a few atoms of another element
63
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
dispersed within it. By deliberately adding impurities, it is possible to create two different kinds of conducting silicon. n type silicon is silicon doped with a very small amount a Group V element. n stands for “negative” where conduction is predominantly by negative electrons. Figure 2.8 shows that the effect of a pentavalent impurity is to provide a free electron which can wander round the crystal lattice. p type silicon is achieved by doping with a trivalent impurity, creating additional holes which provide “positive” conduction. In both types of conducting silicon electrical neutrality is maintained overall. In the one case a lot of fixed positively charged nuclei are balanced by the same number of wandering negatively charged electrons, and in the other a lot of fixed negatively charged nuclei are balanced by the corresponding number of holes. In any real silicon conduction is by both electrons and holes. However, in n type silicon the majority carrier is the electron, with the hole being the minority carrier. In p type silicon the situation is reversed.
P-type
n-type
+++ +++ +++
- - - - - - -
++ - + - ++ - + - ++ - + - ++ ++ ++ -
+ - + - + - -
(a)
(b)
(c)
Depletion Layer
p
n
Holes
Electrons
2.2.3 The semiconductor junction diode An interesting thing happens when a connection is made between n silicon and p silicon – a so-called pn junction. At the junction, free electrons on the n side are enticed into occupying holes on the p side, and vice versa. This has the effect of creating a depletion layer where there are no mobile current carriers. A barrier potential difference is set up, this is about 560mV for silicon. What happens if we try and pass a current through such a junction? Figure 2.9 shows that if the positive terminal of a battery is applied to the p side, the holes are pushed back across the junction; in fact provided the external voltage exceeds 560mV the depletion layer is eliminated and current can flow. On the other hand, if the battery connection is reversed, the migration effect at the junction is enhanced, and in effect the depletion layer gets wider, preventing current flow. Figure 2.10 shows the diode characteristic, where forward and reverse currents are plotted against ap-
64
+
- >0.6V
(d)
Current Flow
(e)
-
+
No Current Flow
Figure 2.9 The p-n junction. (a) shows the separate p and n type silicon, each with its mobile carriers. (b) shows that when they are placed together the carriers at the junction migrate across it. This has the effect of creating a depletion layer which has no carriers (c). If a battery of greater than 560mV is connected to forward bias the junction, the depletion layer is broken down and current flows (d). But if the battery is connected the other way round, the depeletion layer is made wider (e) and no current flows.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
Current
Reverse Voltage -40
0.5
1
Forward + Voltage
Reverse Breakdown
Figure 2.10 The silicon diode characteristic curve. The negative voltage scale is condensed; the actual reverse breakdown voltage depends on the diode construction. It might be 40V as shown, or several hundred volts.
plied voltages. From this we can derive a number of important parameters. Most of these parameters are just as important for transistors and thyristors, and are highly relevant to the practical realization of lighting control electronics. Forward voltage drop. This arises because of a combination of the depletion layer voltage and the additional resistance of the junction material and connection to it. In any power component the aim is to keep this voltage to an absolute minimum. In operation any voltage drop at the device will result in a V2/R heating effect. Reverse leakage current. A p-n junction is not a perfect rectifying device. There is always a small reverse leakage current arising from several causes. As the temperature rises minority carriers can diffuse into the depletion region. In a real diode there are practical problems at the physical edges of the junction where surface contaminants can cause unwanted conduction. Finally the main cause is intrinsic conduction within the depletion layer; this is the conduction by silicon’s own free electrons. This is highly temperature dependent, since it is the thermal energy which creates the free electrons – the current can double for every 10°C rise in temperature. In
power electronics the aim is always to minimise the leakage current. Reverse breakdown voltage. Figure 2.10 shows that when the applied reverse voltage exceeds a certain value, the current rises very fast – a so-called avalanche effect. The effect of the electric field is to increase the velocity of the mobile carriers; when this exceeds the thermal drift velocity they have enough energy to knock otherwise stable valency bond electrons into conduction, creating hole-electron pairs. These pairs can then themselves create further pairs, leading to the avalanche. Any real semiconductor device is rated to ensure that it does not break down. Real world ratings are derived from the above characteristics of the device; they are usually given in graphical form, because most are temperature dependent and/or inter-dependent. Examples are: Maximum reverse voltage. This must be considerably less than the breakdown voltage. It is shown as three different values all related to temperature; one is a continuous value, which the device can withstand indefinitely. The second is peak repetitive voltage, higher than the continuous voltage, but limited as to the percentage of time it can be applied. For example it might correspond to the peak value of an AC waveform. The third is an absolute maximum voltage which can only be allowed occasionally in the life of the device, for example a transient voltage surge. Maximum current. Again this is specified three ways. Maximum continuous current is that which can be carried continuously at a specified temperature. Peak repetitive current applies for a limited time. A combination of these two ratings is used to derive the achievable performance in an AC circuit (for example a bridge rectifier) and the result is then expressed as an “average” or “r.m.s.” rating. The current waveform has a significant bearing on the achievable result. The absolute maximum rating is for occasional events, and, in the case of power diodes (and power transistors and thyristors) is used for determining the correct method of protection against short circuit and overload.
65
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Power dissipation. A diode or other power electronic device dissipates heat according to the current being carried and the voltage drop across the device. For example in a bridge rectifier, the current has to go through two diodes in each half of the sine wave cycle. The total drop might be around 1.1V, and if the bridge is carrying 5A r.m.s, the total dissipation will be 5.5W. The heat must go somewhere, and power devices dissipating more than a very few watts are normally mounted on a heatsink to dissipate the heat. Thermal resistance. In respect of a diode rectifier, the junction to case thermal resistance is a measure of the difference between the junction temperature and the external temperature of the casing. It is measured in °C/W. Thus, for example, if the junction temperature is 120°C, the case temperature is 100°C, and the device is dissipating 5W, it has a thermal resistance of 4 °C/W. This information is needed when designing heatsinks, or determining the actual ambient temperature at which it is safe to run a device. The junction diode is available in a huge range of ratings and packages – from small high frequency, low voltage diodes carrying milliamperes to giant power devices carrying thousands of amps at high voltage. Some examples are shown in Figure 2.11. 2.2.4 The zener diode In addition to the standard diode mainly used as a rectifier, there are a number of special purpose diodes. The first of these is the zener diode. This name has now been given to all kinds of voltage reference diodes, although, strictly, it should apply only to diodes showing the zener effect. Voltage regulation diodes work as normal diodes in the forward direction, but have a precisely defined breakdown voltage in the reverse direction. i.e. they do not carry current in the reverse direction until a particular voltage is reached, whereupon they conduct. Varying the concentration of n and p carriers in the junction varies the width of the depletion layer. Heavy doping results in a narrow depletion layer, and this results in a very high electric field across the
66
a) small signal diode
c) four diodes in same package to make a bridge rectifier
b) individual low power diode used in electronic ballast or transformer
d) stud mounted power diode
Figure 2.11 Examples of silicon diodes and their packaging.
junction. The zener effect is when this field is so great that it gives electrons sufficiently high energy to break away from their valency bonds and become conducting electrons. It happens below about 5V. If the p and n layers are lightly doped, the depletion layer is wide, and the critical field for the zener effect cannot be reached. However, the diode still suffers from the avalanche effect. Figure 2.12 shows the difference between the avalanche and zener effects in reverse biased junctions. Voltage reference diodes are diodes made with precisely known avalanche breakdown or zener voltages. If they are placed across a supply, they will “clamp” the voltage. Such diodes are made in the range 1–300V. The low voltage diodes are based on zener effect only. Those between 5 and 7 volts on a combination of zener and avalanche effect, and those above 7V on avalanche effect. The zener voltage decreases with temperature, while the avalanche voltage increases with temperature. Voltage regulation diodes around 5.6V combining both effects have negligible variation with temperature since the effects cancel out, and are, therefore, particularly useful in providing a stable voltage reference.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
Current Symbol for Zener diode
Ca5V Voltage Avalanche
Zener
Zener slope is more gentle
Figure 2.12 The zener characteristic is more gentle than the avalanche. The symbol for a voltage reference diode is the same, whichever mechanism is used.
Zener diodes are used in power supplies to ensure correct output voltages. For example in an automobile the output of the alternator is rectified to DC, but then regulated by a zener diode to ensure that the battery does not receive an excessive charging voltage. Clearly if a zener diode “clamps” a supply, the excess energy has to go somewhere. Zener diodes are, therefore, often power semiconductors, designed to dissipate heat. A special application of the voltage regulation principle is in voltage surge suppression. If two zener diodes are placed back to back across an AC supply, no current passes through the diodes if the peak voltage of the supply does not exceed the diode rating. If a voltage “spike” comes along, then the diode pair conducts – one half conventionally, the other by breakdown, and the load is protected. Clearly the pair must be designed to absorb the energy of the spike. 2.2.5 The light emitting diode Chapter 1 introduced the idea that if an electron changes energy level, then a quantum of energy is absorbed if the new level is higher, or is emitted if the new level is lower. At a semiconductor junction, electron/hole recombination results in a quantum of
energy being released as an electron drops from its conduction band energy level to the valence band. In silicon this mechanism does not produce any visible light; however in the compound semiconductor Gallium Arsenide (GaAs) it does. The wavelength of light produced varies according to the dopant used. Nearly pure GaAs emits in the near infra-red region, but doping with phosphorous, zinc oxide or nitrogen can produce visible red, green and yellow radiation. Light emitting diodes or LEDs are important in lighting control for several reasons. • The infra-red LED is used as the light source in opto-couplers. It is also used as the radiator in some cordless remote control systems. • The conventional colored LED is widely used as an indicator lamp in control panels and mimic diagrams and within indicating switches and pushbuttons. • LEDs of more complex construction than the simple junction diode are now available to give a wide range of colors with respectable conversion efficiency. They are becoming valid sources of light to take their place alongside conventional lightsources. 2.2.6 The photo-diode In the same way that a semiconductor junction can emit radiation (i.e. an electric current is converted into visible light) so the reverse is possible. The absorption of a photon can raise an electron to the conduction band, so light can be converted to an electric current. Silicon p-n diodes respond to visible and infrared radiation, and can be used as light detectors and as the basis of light measuring instruments. When modulated light is to be used (for example in infrared remote control systems) the speed of response of the simple diode is not fast enough due to capacitance effects, so in this case a p-i-n or PIN construction is used. Here the simple p-n junction is separated by a thin layer of intrinsic conduction (pure or very lightly doped) silicon. Photodiodes normally work in the reversed biased mode, the reverse current in excess of leakage current being directly proportional to the incident radiation. However, if they are operated in forward
67
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
individual LED in clear housing for general purpose indication
7 bar LED indicator used for channel number indication in dimmers and moving lights
2.3 The transistor 2.3.1 The Bipolar Transistor The Bipolar Junction Transistor has two different constructions, p-n-p and n-p-n. The principle is that of placing two semiconductor junctions together as The p-n-p Transistor
high power cluster of LEDs used in signs and video displays
photo transistor fitted in light level sensor unit
p-type
Emitter E
photo thyristor used to provide isolation in professional dimmers
conducting mode an e.m.f. of about 0.5V is developed, creating a solar cell. This alerts us to the fact that photo-sensitivity is an inherent property of silicon semiconductor devices, so unless it is a required function, all silicon electronic devices must be protected from light (or other electromagnetic radiation) An opto coupler is created when an LED is packaged next to a photodiode (or, more often, a phototransistor or photothyristor; however, the principle is similar) within a lightproof housing. In this case an electrical signal fed to the LED will be replicated as another electrical signal coming from the photo-detector. This method gives total electrical isolation between input and output. It is widely used in lighting control to separate low voltage control signals from high power/high voltage circuits. Figure 2.13 shows some opto-electronic components.
68
p-type
Base B
E
Figure 2.13 Examples of opto-electronic components.
n-type
C
Collector C
E
C
Symbols
B
B
The n-p-n Transistor
n-type
p-type
Emitter E
n-type
Base B
E
C
B
Collector C
E
Symbols
C
B
Figure 2.14 The bipolar junction transistor. The circuit symbols with the circle are used for discrete components. Those without the circle are used when the transistor is built in to an integrated circuit, usually with many other transistors.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
Narrow emitter-base depletion layer due to forward bias
Wide base-collector depletion layer due to reverse bias
Emitter
Base
Collector
Hole Flow n-type
p-type
IE
>0.6v For Conduction
p-type
IB
IC
VBE +
-
VCB +
-
Figure 2.15 The operation of the p-n-p transistor showing the biasing arrangement. In an n-p-n transistor all voltages and current flows are reversed, and main current is carried by electrons instead of holes.
shown in Figure 2.14. Both types of bipolar transistor work in a similar manner. The reason they are called bipolar transistors is that they depend on both positive and negative majority carriers for conduction – holes in the p type silicon and electrons in the n type silicon. The bipolar transistor is usually just referred to as a transistor, whereas other types are always referred to with some additional description. It has three electrodes, the emitter, the base, and the collector. Its importance lies in the mechanism of current gain, whereby a small current in the base results in a big current in the collector. Figure 2.15 shows how a p-n-p transistor is biased. (The description which now follows also applies to n-p-n, but then the biasing arrangements would be reversed in polarity, and all references to holes would become references to electrons, and viceversa.) In the diagram batteries are shown as the power supplies for simplicity, and the direction of current is shown conventionally as flowing from positive to negative. Back in the mid – 19th Century, Kirchhoff set out laws about what happens when different electric currents meet at a point; and his first
law states that if several conductors meet at a point, then the total current flowing towards that point is the same as that flowing away from it. It is intuitive that this is so, since if it was not, the meeting point would accumulate an electric charge – and apart from no such charge being measured in practice, it is not easy to visualize how such a charge could be held. Applying the law to the transistor circuit, we have: IE = IB + IC i.e. the current flowing through the emitter connection equals the sum of the currents through the base and collector. The transistor is special because IB is very small compared with IC, and in use the effect is that small changes in IB make big changes in IC. The effect of forward biasing the emitter-base junction is to narrow its depletion layer; whereas the reverse biasing of the collector-base junction is to widen its depletion layer. The description of the p-n diode showed that if VBE exceeds 0.6V, the depletion layer between emitter and base reduces to zero width. The positive potential on the emitter repels the surplus positive holes
69
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
PNP Transistor
IC
IC
Current carrying limit
Imax
IB
50
VCE VBE
Power dissipation limit
IE
25 %Duty Cycle
75 100
Breakdown voltage limit
Secondary breakdown limit IC mA
Vmax
gm at P is slope of graph at P
Figure 2.17 The safe operating area for a transistor. Note that it changes with duty cycle.
IC
P
5
VBE 0 550
600
650
mV
VBE
hFE = IC /IB is the large signal or DC current gain; important for switching applications. hfe = 'IC/'IB is the small signal or AC current gain; where ' signifies a small change; important for audio amplifiers etc. gm = 'IC/'VBE is the transistor mutual conductance (measured in Siemens or mho, reciprocal ohms) relating small changes in base-emitter voltage to collector current. VCEO(SUS) is the maximum collector-emitter voltage which can be sustained without breakdown, measured with open circuit base. (Breakdown voltages are also specified with other base biasing conditions.) ICEO is the collector-emitter leakage current when there is no base current. It is highly temperature dependent. VBE(SAT) the base-emitter saturation voltage, and VCE(SAT) the collector-emitter saturation voltage are the respective voltage drops at the point when increasing the base current gives no further increase in collector current. The conditions under which they are measured must be specified. PD is the maximum power dissipation of the device (at a specified temperature) in principle the product of VCE and IC. But in fact transistors must operate in their safe operating area see Figure 2.17.
Figure 2.16 Some parameters relating to the bipolar transistor. The diagrams relate to p-n-p transistors.
70
VCE
which are attracted by the negative base region. The base-collector junction is reverse biased by the larger potential VCB – so the collector is negative with respect to the base. The widened depletion layer effectively prevents holes in the collector crossing to the base, but does not stop the flow of holes in the other direction, since they are attracted by the heavily negatively charged collector. Once conduction has started, the great majority of the holes starting from the emitter make it through to the collector, but a small proportion combine with free electrons in the base region, to form a small base current. The fundamental property of the transistor is the static current gain, or common emitter forward current transfer ratio designated hFE where: hFE = IC /IB Typical transistor gains are in the range 100–300. From a “mind picture” point of view, you can think of a small base current being “amplified” to a large collector current; or a small base current controlling the larger collector current flow. Actually it is the base emitter bias voltage which determines the collector current, and hFE which in turn determines the base current. Figure 2.16 lists some of the common parameters relating to a transistor. It is important to understand that many parameters are inter-dependent and temperature dependent. Figure 2.17 shows the idea of a the safe operating area for a transistor. For any particular tempera-
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
Lamp Load
+12V I C=120mA
I B=1mA ON 0.75V
OFF
hfe =120
0V
Figure 2.18 The transistor as a switch. The 1mA control signal switches 120mA through the n-p-n transistor.
ture the device will break down due to excessive voltage Vmax or excessive current Imax. There would normally be a straight line maximum power dissipation curve, but in a transistor there can be an uneven distribution of current, arising from temperature variations across the device and irregularities in construction. This can lead to secondary breakdown arising from local thermal runaway; so the safe operating area is less than expected. Many applications of transistors in power circuits require the transistor to operate without carrying current continuously; its duty cycle is less than 100%. In this case the safe operating area is increased as shown in the figure. From the description of how a transistor works, we can see that it could be used to make some of the building blocks referred to in 2.1.2. Figure 2.18 shows the transistor being used as a switch, where a very small current is used to switch a large current on and off. In practice the low power switch shown in the circuit would most likely itself be another, smaller, transistor being driven by some kind of logic circuit – possibly being driven very fast to provide fast on/ off switching. In practice if we want to use a transistor as a switch, we want the voltage across it to be the full line voltage when it is “off”, and to be as little as possible when “on” – since any remaining voltage will result in heat being dissipated within the transis-
tor. To achieve the minimum voltage requires the transistor to be driven to saturation which is the point at which an increase in base current produces no more increase in collector current. Figure 2.19 shows a transistor being used as a current regulator. Here the base bias voltage is simply being varied between the point at which the transistor is just not conducting, to the point at which it is passing maximum current. The problem here is that the transistor is now operating as a variable resistance – it is not in saturation. Figure 2.20 shows the transistor being used as a voltage amplifier. Here the idea is to produce an output which is a magnified but perfect copy of the the original input signal. The input is applied to the base of the transistor, and here shown as a 0.05V swing, superimposed on the base bias voltage (which must be there, otherwise there would be no conduction at all.) The output is shown as a varying voltage at the collector, arising from the change in collector current. The collector is biased at well below the maximum collector voltage to allow a voltage swing to develop. For a typical “discrete” transistor the 0.05V input voltage swing might produce a 7.5V swing in the collector voltage – corresponding to an amplifier voltage gain of 150. Notice that the output voltage is out of phase with the input, the higher the collector current, the lower the collector voltage.
Lamp Load
Rotary 0.8V Potentiometer
+12V
IC Varies with change in VBE
0.65 0.6V
VBE 0V
Figure 2.19 Replacing the input switch with a rotary potentiometer gives a current regulator. A resistor network ensures that the potentiometer only operates in the active range 0.6–0.8V.
71
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
VCC
IC
VRC=ICRC
RC
VC VOUT=VCC-ICRC VIN=VBE
IE
Input 0.07
VBE=
VIN
VBE 0.65
mon to both input and output. RB1 and RB2 set the bias voltage at the base, and are chosen to carry enough current such that the base signal current is insignificant compared to it, and therefore does not itself affect the bias voltage. CIN and COUT are capacitors which block the DC bias, but have a low AC impedance at the frequencies of the signal being amplified, they simply isolate the wanted signals from the amplifier. RE biases the emitter (which in turn implies an increase in the needed base bias). This is done so that if there is an unwanted rise in collector current due to high temperature, the voltage drop across RE increases, and has the effect of reducing the base-emitter voltage and, therefore, the collector current. CE is needed as a decoupling capacitor to pass the amplified AC current, which would otherwise be limited by RE.
Base Bias
IC
+VCC
RC C OUT
RB1
0
Time
C IN V OUT
Output 12
V IN
CE
RB2 RE
V
CC
0V
VC 6
0
Collector Bias
VC=
VOUT
IC Collector current with no input
Figure 2.20 The transistor as a voltage amplifier. Note that all values are examples only. Vb
2.3.2 Amplifiers 2.3.2.1 Class A and Class B amplifiers Figure 2.21 shows the components needed to surround a transistor to make it work as a Class A audio amplifier stage in a common emitter configuration. This simply means that the emitter terminal is com-
72
V IN Figure 2.21 The Class A amplifier. The transfer characteristic is linear, because the transistor is biased to ensure this is the case.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
The Class A amplifier has low distortion; that is to say the output voltage waveform closely matches the input waveform; but it is inefficient because current must flow at all times. The transistor is biased so that the relationship between the base input signal and collector output is linear. The inefficiency does not matter in small signal work, or in low power audio amplifiers; but it matters a lot in high power amplifiers and power conversion equipment. A Class B amplifier works with minimum quiescent current (by biasing transistors to cut-off) and, as a result, can have high efficiency. Such amplifiers work in push-pull mode, where one transistor operates in the positive half cycles, and another one in the negative. Figure 2.22 shows the principle of the Class B amplifier. The output transistors are a complementary pair, one being p-n-p, and the other n-p-n. The variable resistor VR sets the bias condition for both
Nett input
(V IN- B VOUT) V IN
A
B
V OUT = A (V IN
-
BV OUT)
-BV OUT
Figure 2.23 The concept of negative feedback applied to an amplifier.
output transistors so that for zero input signal, no collector current flows. The diodes D1 and D2 provide compensation for the variation of VBE with temperature. Note how the output waveform is distorted, arising from the crossover distortion arising from using both transistors on the non linear part of their characteristic curve. 2.3.2.2 Negative feedback; Classes C and D
+ VCC TR1
VR D1 D2
C OUT
V IN
TR2 0V
IC
I OUT
In real audio amplifiers a hybrid Class AB approach is used, not as efficient as Class B, but much more efficient than Class A. Real power amplifiers also make use of negative feedback to stabilize the gain and reduce distortion. Figure 2.23 shows an amplifier with open loop gain (the gain with no feedback) A. A proportion B of the amplifier output is subtracted from the input, therefore the actual input voltage becomes VIN - BVOUT; so now the actual output voltage becomes A(VIN - BVOUT ). System gain is the actual output voltage divided by the original input voltage, and can be stated as:
VB2 VB1
V IN
Figure 2.22 The Class B amplifier. The transfer characteristic is non linear, because both transistors operate both in their linear regions and in their non-linear cut-off regions.
Overall Gain = A/(1 + AB) This expression is known as the closed loop gain. It has an interesting result. If A is 100, and B is 0.1, the overall gain is 9.1; if A is 200 and B remains 0.1, the gain only changes to 9.5. Practical power amplifers are built with A very large, in which case the approximation; Closed loop gain = 1/B
73
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Signal IN
High speed switch
Output power transistors
Filter V OUT
Output waveform before filter
Minimum output
Maximum signal output
Intermediate output
Figure 2.24 The concept of the Class D amplifier.
applies; i.e the gain is independent of the actual gain of the underlying amplifier, and depends only on the feedback ratio. Feedback also reduces distortion. If an amplifier has distortion N% in its open loop state, negative feedback reduces this to: Distortion = N/(1 +AB) % However, this only applies if the distortion does not, itself, affect amplifier gain. Unfortunately crossover distortion falls into this category. Efficient Class C amplifiers are used in radio frequency applications. In this case the transistor is biased so far “off”, that only the peaks of the input waveform are amplified. Tuned loads restore the input waveform. Of more relevance to power control is the Class D amplifier. In Class D the transistor(s) act only as a switch, i.e they are on (saturated condition with minimum volt drop) or off. To work as an amplifier this requires that the switching frequency is far higher than the frequency being amplified. One possibility is to use a square wave of constant frequency with variable mark to space ratio. For example the full
+VCC
RB
width wave represents 100%, and the narrowest “spike” represents zero. Figure 2.24 shows the idea. The high speed switch generates a train of pulses of varying width, depending on the strength of the input signal. These are amplified by the output power transistors, and the result is filtered to eliminate the high frequency components and restore the original waveform. 2.3.2.3 The emitter follower There are a number of other amplifier terms which can be encountered in lighting control electronics, and a few of them are summarized here. The emitter follower is used as a buffer amplifier in signal distribution. Instead of being in the common emitter configuration used in the circuits described so far, the transistor is used in the common collector configuration shown in Figure 2.25. In such a circuit the output follows the input in phase and amplitude. That means that, as a voltage amplifier, the emitter follower (so called because the emitter voltage follows the base input voltage) has unity gain, so it might well be asked what use it is. Its virtue lies in the fact that it has a very low output impedance. Conversely it has a high input impedance. In practice this means that it does not load, and thus distort, its source; but itself can tolerate a wide range of loading. 2.3.2.4 The Darlington pair In power electronics conventional transistors suffer from the fact that at high currents they have low gain. This means they need large base currents, and, as a C
B
TR1
1
~
D1
Input high Z
D2
OUTPUT RB2
Low Z
Figure 2.25 The emitter follower.
TR2
~
RE 0V
74
R1
R2 E
Figure 2.26 The Darlington pair.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
ts tf IC
90%
10% td
tr OFF
ON Turn on time
Turn off time
Figure 2.27 Turn-on and turn-off times in a transistor. td is a delay in start of collector current due to collector and emitter depletion capacitance; tr is the rise time, determined by junction capacitances and the carrier transit time in the base region. ts is the storage time, the time needed for excess charges in base and collector regions to recombine as the transistor comes out of saturation. tf is the fall time, determined by junction capacitance and negative base current.
result, complex base drive circuits. The Darlington pair shown in Figure 2.26 goes some way to solving the problem. TR1 is used as the base driver for TR2 . The practical circuit includes resistors R1 and R2 to prevent the transistors amplifying their own leakage current. Diode D2 protects the output transistor from reverse voltages. Diode D1 removes the charge carriers stored in the base of the output transistor, and thus speeds up its turn-off. Turn-off and turn-on times in switching transistors are critical, since they result in slow operation and heat dissipation. They are caused by charge storage and capacitance effects, as shown in Figure 2.27. While “power Darlingtons” can be made up from discrete components, they are usually supplied as a single semiconductor structure.
identical in charactersistic and in variations with temperature (achieved in practice by them both being in the same integrated circuit and encapsulation). The fact that all changes due to temperature etc are equal, and that emitter current is shared in R3 (the “tail”) means that any changes affect both transistors equally. The long tail pair amplifies the difference between the two inputs V1 and V2 . If V1 = V2 then it is clear from the figure that Vout is zero. As an example suppose V1 = 0.12mV and V2 = 0mV, and that the measured output Vout = 60mV. Then the amplifier is said to have a differential gain of: Ad = 60/0.12 = 500 Now suppose there is an unwanted noise signal of 1mV which affects both inputs simultaneously. Such a signal is referred to as being common mode. Now it is the case that V1 = 1.12mV and V2 = 1mV. It might be that now the output, instead of being 60mV has risen to 62mV. The common mode gain, which refers only to the extra 1mV signal is: Ac = (62 – 60)/1 = 2 The measurement of an amplifier’s ability to amplify differential signals while rejecting common mode signals is referred to as its common mode rejection ratio (or CMRR) and equals Ad/Ac. In the example its value is 250. In integrated circuits much higher values are achieved, so great that it is inconvenient to represent them as simple numbers. A typical “op-amp” (to be described in Section 2.6) has a CMRR of over 30,000 – a figure so big that it is easier to use a logarithmic measure, the dB; for example +VCC R1
VOUT TR1
TR2
V1
2.3.2.5. The long tail pair; differential amplifiers The long tail pair or differential amplifier is at the heart of DC amplifiers and many AC control signal amplifiers. The bipolar transistor version is shown in Figure 2.28. The two transistors TR1 and TR2 are
R2
IN
V2 R3 0
Figure 2.28 The long tail pair.
75
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
VGS
+ Gate G p
VIN n
Source S
p
Figure 2.29 A center-tapped transformer producing a balanced signal.
90dB. (The dB or deciBel is described in Section 2.5.) A differential amplifier is fed in one of two ways. A “single ended” input could be applied as V1, whereas V2 could be tied to 0V. Alternatively a balanced input could be provided to both inputs simultaneously. Similarly at the output there is a choice of an in-phase (from TR2), or out-of-phase (TR1) output signal, or a balanced signal. A balanced signal is one where the same signal is fed on two wires, but each half is exactly out of phase. A “traditional” way of achieving a balanced signal is to use a center-tapped transformer as in Figure 2.29. The term common mode referring to an unwanted signal affecting two input wires simultaneously is of considerable significance in lighting control, especially with reference to EMC and digital control signals. 2.3.3 The Unipolar Transistor 2.3.3.1 The JFET Unipolar transistors depend for conduction on only one type of carrier. They are also called field effect transistors or FETs. This is because the current flow is determined by electric field – in practice just a voltage. In a bipolar transistor the gate current can be significant, whereas in a unipolar transistor it is negligible. Unipolar transistors come in several varieties. Figure 2.30 shows the standard biasing arrangement for an n-channel junction field effect transis-
76
Drain D
+
VDS
Depletion regions
S
G
D
p n channel p Substrate
JFET
+ D
G
G
D
p Channel
+
S
S n Channel
+
C
B
C B
n-p-n
E
p-n-p
E
+
BIPOLAR
Figure 2.30 The n-channel JFET. The concept (top), the principle of construction (center), and the comparison of JFET circuit symbols with those of the bipolar transistor (bottom).
tor, or n-channel JFET. A p-channel JFET, would, like its bipolar counterpart, simply have n and p regions reversed, and the biasing reversed. Figure 2.30
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
also shows the symbols for JFETs and compares them with those for bipolar transistors. The channel is the conduction channel between the source and drain electrodes. The gate electrode is shown as being either side of the channel. Being of the opposite polarity to the channel, it sets up a depletion region at its junctions with the channel. As the source–drain voltage is increased, the depletion region gets bigger, until a point is reached when both halves meet – the pinch-off voltage. At this point the current through the channel is limited to those electrons which can sweep through the depletion layer – so there is no further increase in current with increase in source-drain voltage. (Other than when a gatechannel breakdown occurs.) Figure 2.31 shows the characteristic of the JFET for different levels of bias. 2.3.3.2 The MOSFET The fact that the FET works by the influence of an electric field raises the possibility that there need be no actual conduction path from the gate electrode. The Insulated Gate Field Effect Transistor (IGFET) uses this idea; in practice its manifestation being the Metal-Oxide Silicon Field Effect Transistor (MOSFET). In the manufacture of semiconductor devices, there are a number of processes used. The process starts with the wafer of pure silicon (Section 2.2.2) ID
VDS PINCH IDSS
VGS=0 -1V -2V -4V
Gate to channel breakdown
VDS
Figure 2.31 The JFET characteristic showing variation of drain current with drain to source voltage for different levels of gate bias. The dotted line shows the pinch-off voltage.
but this can then be treated in several different ways: Oxide growth. If the silicon is exposed to oxygen or steam it oxidizes, producing a layer of Silicon Dioxide (SiO2). This is an insulating and protecting layer. It can be grown and removed (by acid etching) at various stages of production. Epitaxial growth. This is growing more silicon crystal on the existing base. It is done by exposing the silicon to Silicon Tetrachloride vapor (SiCl4) which disocciates when it meets the hot silicon. If the vapor also includes an impurity (for example Phosphorus Trichloride) then an n or p type silicon is grown. Diffusion. The introduction of impurities as part of epitaxial growth is really only applicable to large areas. If small areas are to be treated, then the impurities enter the silicon by diffusion. The silicon is held near its melting point so the impurity atoms from the vapor can easily enter the crystal lattice. Areas which are not to be diffused are protected by an SiO2 layer, which itself is put down using a photolithographic process. Metal formation. In this part of the process metal is evaporated or sputtered on to the silicon to provide interconnection between parts of the semi conductor device, or to provide connection to the outside world. Again photolithography is used to create the protective layer needed to ensure the metal only goes where it is needed. From this brief description, the construction of the JFET shown in Figure 2.30 can be appreciated. So can the fact that SiO2 , being an insulator, allows the idea of a gate electrode which acts through an insulating layer to be realized. The MOSFET is, in reality, made in two ways, shown in Figure 2.32. This identifies two kinds of MOSFET. The depletion mode version, with a narrow channel, works in the same way as the JFET, but has a much higher input impedance. In the alternative (and, in practice, standard) enhancement mode version there is no continuous n-channel; if there is no bias on the gate, no current flows. Forward bias must be increased to a threshold voltage before conduction starts. At the threshold voltage an inversion layer is created under the gate electrode and (in the figure example) an nchannel is created.
77
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
S
G
D
Si02
G
p Substrate
Channel S
Sub S
Sub G
DRAIN CURRENT
D
n
D
Si02 n
D
n
G
p
Sub S
Sub
Figure 2.32 The top figure shows the construction of the depletion mode MOSFET and its symbol. The bottom diagram shows the enhancement mode MOSFET. Note how the symbols clearly show the absence of direct connections.
MOSFETs have a number of advantages over bipolar transistors: • Because they do not have minority carriers (i.e. all the current is carried by electrons or holes, but not by a mixture) there is no minority carrier storage effect, which delays switching times (see Figure 2.27). MOSFETs are therefore faster than bipolar transistors. • MOSFETs are voltage controlled, with negligible gate current. Their gain is much higher than that of bipolar transistors. • MOSFETs do not suffer from secondary breakdown effects; their safe operating area can be extended to be solely power limited. • This is because as the temperature increases, the bulk resistivity increases, so there is no thermal runaway. This has the subsidiary benefit that devices can be connected in parallel to increase current capacity,
78
GATE TO SOURCE VOLTAGE
Figure 2.33 Example transfer characteristics of an n-channel enhancement mode power MOSFET. The linear relationship between gate voltage and drain current make them ideal amplifiers. T is the junction temperature.
without the need for any kind of current sharing components. All these considerations mean that the MOSFET is the preferred device for power electronics. Figure 2.33 shows their transfer characteristic. The linear characteristic and high mutual conductance make MOSFETs excellent amplifiers, and their fast switching speed makes them good switches. The high gate impedance of MOSFET devices makes them susceptible to damage from electrostatic discharge. Some devices are fitted with internal protection, using back-to-back zener diodes. But in most cases it is necessary to ensure that they cannot be subjected to static electricity. 2.3.3.3 Power MOSFETs The construction of the standard MOSFET shown in Figure 2.32 results in a thin “horizontal” conductive channel with limited current carrying ability. It also has a low breakdown voltage, largely dependent on the thickness of the insulating SiO2 layer. While the construction is suitable for small signal work, power MOSFETs use a different construction shown in Figure 2.34. The inversion layer, and current flow, is
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
“vertical”. Because the conducting channel is formed within both p and n diffusions, devices of this kind are also referred to as being double diffused or DMOS devices. The figure also shows that this construction of MOSFET provides a drain-source p-n junction diode between the n epitaxial layer and the p layer. If this diode is forward biased (i.e the transistor is reverse biased) it conducts. Some circuit designs take advantage of this parasitic diode, especially for the diversion of reverse voltage surges. One of the most important MOSFET parameters is RDS(ON) this is the drain-source resistance when the device is switched fully on. In any high current application a high value of RDS(ON) results in inefficiency and a lot of heat. A number of different strategies are used to limit this internal resistance. Each construction can have some additional benefit, for example higher frequency operation, or the use of less silicon in its manufacture. In practice MOSFETs intended for power control are made up of thousands of MOSFET cells, all operating in parallel. The concept works because the positive temperature coefficient of resistance of the conducting channels ensures equal current sharing.
G
n channel
S
p+
n+
n epitaxy
n+ substrate
D Conduction by electrons
Inversion layer
D
G S
Figure 2.34 In power MOSFETs the conduction channel is vertical. The symbols + or - applied to n and p mean heavy or light doping with impurities. The figure shows an n channel MOSFET with conduction by electrons. Note that conventional current flow is in opposite direction to electron flow.
Source metallization
Silicon gate
Si02
P
P n epitaxy + n
y ax pit e n +
n
D
Silicon gate
Drain metallization
Parasitic diode p-n junction D
Figure 2.35 Power MOSFETs are made with a cellular structure. Examples are TMOS® (originally from Motorola, who no longer participate in this market) that uses rectangular cells (left), and the HEXFET® construction from International Rectifier with hexagonal cells (right.)
79
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
2.3.4 The Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor
G S
p+
An objective, which has only been realized practically in the last few years, has been to create a device which combines the virtues of the MOSFET, such as negligible input current drive and a wide safe operating area, with those of the bipolar transistor – in particular that of low saturation voltage. Such a device is known as an insulated gate bipolar transis-
n+
-
n epitaxy
p
p
Construction
D
Inversion layer
Conduction by electrons
Figure 2.36 CoolMOS® from Infineon (formerly Siemens) uses a different diffusion pattern to reduce the sourcedrain resistance. RDS(ON) rises linearly with blocking voltage, not exponentially as is the case with conventional MOSFET.
The gate connection is made of poly-crystalline silicon instead of metal; this is possible because the gate operates at high impedance anyway. Manufacturers use different cell geometries, and different cell sizes and spacing to achieve their claimed best result, but the principle is the same for all of them. Figure 2.35 illustrates typical cell construction. A problem with MOSFETs is that at high forward voltages the epitaxial layer must be thick. RDS(ON) rises exponentially with blocking voltage, which has limited the application of MOSFETs. A recent development, exemplifed by Infineon’s CoolMOS® shown in Figure 2.36, is the introduction of vertical p stripes into the epitaxial drift region. This has the effect of providing blocking not only in the vertical direction, but also horizontally, which in turn allows the layer to be made thinner. The construction is claimed to make the relationship between RDS(ON) and blocking voltage linear instead of exponential, resulting much smaller devices for a given power handling. MOSFETs made this way are claimed to offer competition to the IGBT described in the next section.
80
G
E
n+ substrate
p+
n+
n epitaxy
p+ substrate
D Conduction by electrons Conduction by holes Symbol
C G E C
Equivalent Circuit
G
E
Figure 2.37 The IGBT. The figure emphasises the point that conduction is by both majority and minority carriers. The equivalent circuit shows that the device is in principle a p-n-p transistor driven by an n-channel MOSFET, but that the construction introduces other parasitic devices.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
tor or IGBT. The idea is similar to that of the Darlington pair, where one device is used to control another – in this case a MOSFET input transistor driving a bipolar transistor. The construction, symbol and equivalent circuit is shown in Figure 2.37, drawn to emphasize that conduction is bipolar. In practice the manufacture of IGBTs is a similar process to that of making MOSFETs. One manufacturer points out that simply by changing the starting materials and varying some process steps, it is possible to make IGBTs with the same photolithographic mask set as is used for making power MOSFETs. The IGBT is fast to switch on, but slower to switch off, with a current “tail”, due to minority carrier storage in the epitaxial layer.
At the individual component level there are exotic high frequency transistors used in RF applications, and special low noise transistors which are well outside the scope of this book. A useful variant encountered in lighting control is the photo-transistor, a close relative of the photodiode described in Section 2.2.6. By having a transistor as part of the diode circuit it becomes easier to set minimum reponse levels – for example the phototransistor can be biased so that it does not conduct at low light levels.
2.4 The thyristor, triac and GTO 2.4.1 The thyristor 2.4.4.1 Basic construction
2.3.5 Other transistors It is clear that transistors exist in many forms. Each of the major types can be made in several different ways to match a particular application. Many small and medium power devices include additional circuitry for protection or more sophisticated control. Such circuitry can be added by the manufacturing process – for example by diffusing on more conducting and insulating layers to make additional active components.
small signal transistor used in control circuits
MOSFET power transistor used in electronic ballast
Figure 2.38 Examples of transistors used in lighting control.
The MOSFET and IGBT have made big inroads into the power control business, especially where high frequency is concerned. However, the workhorse of electronic power control is the thyristor. The full name of the main variant is the reverse blocking triode thyristor. It is particularly significant in lighting control as the basis of electronic dimmers. The thyristor was invented at General Electric (USA) in 1957, some ten years after the invention of the transistor at Bell Laboratories. It was originally called the Silicon Controlled Rectifier, and the acronym SCR is still widely used. Figure 2.39 shows that the thyristor is a four layer device, with three electrodes anode, cathode and gate. Its symbol gives a clue as to how it behaves. In the reverse current connection (positive voltage applied to the cathode) no current flows, exactly as would be the case for a conventional diode. If the reverse voltage is greatly increased, then avalanche breakdown can occur, again exactly as for a diode. If the thyristor is forward biased, but no gate signal is present, no current passes under normal operation. If the forward blocking voltage is exceeded, the device will, however, go into conduction. The thyristor will also conduct if there is a positive gate current. Once the thyristor goes in to forward conduction, it continues to conduct, even without a gate signal, unless one of the following happens:
81
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
Anode
Anode
A
p n
G
Gate
Gate
p n
K
Cathode Cathode
Two transistor Model
A p
n
p
n
p
K n
current flow between anode and cathode is limited to the transistor leakage current. If a current IG is introduced at the gate, and if the gain in the basecollector loop of T1 and T2 exceeds unity, the loop current is maintained regeneratively, driving both transistors into saturation. At this point the thyristor is said to be latched. The gains of the transistors are current dependent, so once the gate current has started the regenerative action, the anode current increases sufficiently that the gate current IG can be removed without the transistors coming out of saturation. Thyristors are bipolar devices. They have the advantage of very low on-state voltage. However, minority charge carriers must be removed before the thyristor can block an applied voltage, so switching times are long compared with, for example, MOSFET transistors. This means that in practice thyristors are used at mains supply frequencies.
G
A
2.4.4.2 Ratings
T2
Figure 2.41 shows the characteristics of a thyristor. All thyristor parameters are temperature dependent, so, as with transistors and diodes, device data is given as a set of graphs showing how the device behaves at different temperatures. Section 2.2.3 introduced a number of parameters relevant to power control devices, a few more are introduced here. The rate of change of voltage or current, denoted by the differential calculus symbols dV/dt and dI/dt
G
T1
IG K
Figure 2.39 The thyristor. Construction, symbol and twotransistor model.
• either the current through the device drops below a minimum holding current. • or the voltage across the device is changed in polarity, when it will block the reverse voltage. Notice that, unlike a transistor, the gate has no effective proportional control of the current. If the gate signal is above a minimum, the thyristor goes to full conduction, with current limited only by the circuit impedance. Figure 2.39 also shows that the thyristor can be thought of as a pair of transistors, one n-p-n and the other p-n-p. They are connected such that the base current from one transistor is derived from the collector current of the other. If there is no gate current,
82
40A thyristor used in professional dimmer encapsulated module containing two thyristors triac used in consumer dimmer
heavy duty triac used in professional equipment Figure 2.40 Examples of thyristor and triac construction.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
Iforward
ON
IL
IG>0
IH
Vreverse
IG=0 Vforward
Avalanche breakdown
Vbreakover
Ireverse
Figure 2.41 Thyristor characteristics.
respectively can be important. dV/dt, measured in Volts/Second, or, more usefully, V/μs, is relevant, since a thyristor can be forced into conduction by high dV/dt. This arises because p-n junctions have a capacitance, and with a change of voltage a capacative charging current flows: iC = C × dV/dt If dV/dt is high, the charging current may be high enough to trigger the thyristor on. When a thyristor is turned on, the whole active area cannot be turned on simultaneously. The area nearest the gate connection turns on first and conduction “spreads” across the device. If the anode to cathode current rises too quickly, only part of the thyristor may be conducting, and this causes localized heating, possibly followed by device failure. So an excessive rate of forward current change dIf /dt can damage a thyristor. On the other hand, provided gate ratings are not exceeded, a high rate of change of gate current dIG /dt helps a thyristor to turn on quickly. The protection of a thyristor by fuse or circuit breaker is determined by its I2t capability, a measure of its ability to let through energy (see also Section 1.5.2). For reasons which will become clear, the figure is usually quoted with reference to the duration of one half cycle of alternating current (i.e. 10ms for 50Hz or 8.3ms for 60Hz). For example, if a thyristor is quoted as having an I2t of 26A2 seconds on the
8.3ms basis (a typical figure for an 8A thyristor), then it could let through an average √3132 = 56A for a half cycle of 60Hz mains. This leads to another important characteristic which is the peak forward surge current. This is the maximum peak current that the device can stand as a single non repetitive event, and again is usually quoted with reference to a half cycle of mains current. For example the 8A device referred to in the previous paragraph might be able to stand a peak of 80A within a half cycle of 60Hz (provided that, over the whole half cycle, the I2t rating was not exceeded.) This is an important parameter for lighting control, because tungsten lamps have a low cold resistance, resulting in inrush currents which can be 10–14 times running current. While the major ratings of the thyristor are related to the anode-cathode current path, the gate has its own set of ratings in respect of maximum and minimum gate voltage and current; maximum and average gate power etc. 2.4.4.3 Control of AC power The most commonly used arrangement for thyristor AC power control is the back-to-back pair shown in Figure 2.42. If neither thyristor has any gate signal, then the pair block any current from going through the load. If both thyristors have a permanent gate “on” signal, then the load will receive maximum current – the current being limited by circuit impedance and the nature of the load itself, and only very slightly by
AC Supply
Firing control Circuit
Load e.g. Lamp
Figure 2.42 AC power control using a pair of thyristors.
83
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
V
Voltage across thyristor
Supply voltage
Current through thyristor
I
Trigger angle G
Conduction angle
Normalized voltage power fraction
Figure 2.43 Conduction angle in AC power control by thyristor.
1.4 1.2
Peak
1.0 RMS
0.8 0.6
2.4.4.4 The triac Average
0.4 0.2
0
20
40
60
80 100 120 140 160 180 Conduction angle
Figure 2.44 Variation of peak, r.m.s. and average voltage with firing angle for AC power control by a thyristor pair. The voltage scale is normalized to r.m.s. sine wave voltage, so to get an actual voltage, multiply by 230 for European supplies and 115 for USA supplies. The red line shows power output for a resistive load.
84
the thyristors (which have a forward voltage drop of 1 – 2V). One thyristor carries the positive going half cycle, and the other carries the negative going. If the gate signal is discontinuous, and is applied at some point in the half cycle, the appropriate thyristor starts by blocking current, but then switches on. The thyristor continues to conduct for the remainder of the half cycle, but then, as the polarity of the AC waveform changes, self commutates, i.e. it ceases to conduct because of the polarity reversal. The second thyristor similarly controls the other half cycle. Assuming that both thyristors are symmetrically controlled, it becomes possible to continuously vary the power to the load by changing the point in the AC cycle at which the gate “on” signal is given. This firing point is defined by the delay or trigger angle δ and the conduction angle α as shown in Figure 2.43. The “angles” relate to the rotating vector described in Figure 1.19. Figure 2.44 shows how peak, r.m.s. and average voltage varies with firing angle. It also shows how power output varies for a fixed resistive load. Note, however, that, a tungsten lamp does not have a fixed resistance, so a tungsten lighting power curve would be a little different. Nonetheless the fact remains that the majority of the power change happens between conduction angles 30° and 150°. Details of thyristor power control and firing circuits are given in Section 8.3.
The triac, also known as the bidirectional triode thyristor or the TRIode AC semiconductor switch is a five layer device as shown in Figure 2.45. It can be considered equivalent to a back-to-back thyristor pair in a single package. Because it can conduct current in both directions, reference to an anode or cathode would be meaningless, so the main terminals are designated MT1 and MT2. The triac can be triggered by current flowing into (+) or out of (-) the gate terminal. This results in there being four possible operating quadrants for the triac as shown in Figure 2.46. In practice quadrants 1 and 3 are the most sensitive. Quadrant 4 requires a higher
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
2.4.4.5 The GTO and other special thyristors MT1 n
Gate
MT1 n
p
Gate
n p n
MT2 MT2
Figure 2.45 The triac.
gate current than the others, so is not used. Many practical circuits operate with quadrants 2 and 3, since then a negative going trigger pulse is used for both halves of the AC sine wave. While triacs are convenient low power control devices, they are not as robust as the equivalent thyristor pair. There can be problems in recovering blocking capability, especially at higher temperatures or with high dV/dt.
+
2
+
MT2+
1
The conventional thyristor and the triac are widely used for lighting control and their application is discussed in more detail in Chapter 8. There are a number of other “special” thyristors or thyristor-like devices, which have application in other areas. A brief summary of some of them is as follows: • The gate turn-off thyristor or GTO has a gate arrangement whereby positive current into the gate switches the thyristor on, and negative current taken from the gate switches it off. In the two transistor model, the arrangement can be thought of as being one where taking current from the gate breaks the regenerative cycle. GTOs have good forward blocking, but relatively poor reverse blocking capability. • The photothyristor uses light to trigger the thyristor – in effect a p-n junction is used as a photodiode to provide the gate current. Such thyristors are ideal for high power work in electrically noisy environments. At the other extreme small photothyristors have taken over from transformers as control isolation components in medium power applications (including dimmers.) • The insulated gate controlled thyristor like its transistor counterpart, has reduced gate drive requirements while maintaining low forward volt drop at high voltages.
2.5 Analog and digital 2.5.1 Analog
IG
-
-
IG
G-
G+
IG 3
+
MT2-
+
IG
Figure 2.46 The operating quadrants of the triac.
4
It is already clear that, for lighting control, electronics can do two things for us. Power electronics can be used for the direct control of electric power, generally by using high speed switching techniques. In turn the power electronic devices can be controlled by very low power electronic control devices or systems. These help make practical systems by, for example, allowing long distance remote control, or by bringing some “intelligence” to the control. A dictionary definition of “analogy” is the “agreement or correspondence between two things otherwise different”. In analog electronic control the
85
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
correspondence is between an electrical quantity, usually current or voltage, and some other physical quantity. An example already cited is that of an audio amplifier; where the chain is: • a transducer (in this case a microphone) which turns sound pressure level into a varying electrical voltage. The voltage is thus the analog of the sound. • an amplifier which increases the electrical signal. In this case it is clear that the amplification process must be one which does not distort the signal. • another transducer (in this case a loudspeaker) which turns the amplified electrical signal back into an audible sound. The power output of the amplifier can be controlled by a simple variable resistance at the input, which directly limits the strength of the signal reaching the amplifier. But a more sophisticated method would be to have a voltage controlled amplifier or VCA at the input. Such a device would then allow long distance remote control of the sound level, without the need to take the sound signal itself to the level regulating control. The small DC signal controlling the amplifier is an example of an analog control signal (representing the sound volume) controlling another analog signal (representing the sound signal itself.) In lighting control we can use the same idea; where a small remote control potentiometer carrying a tiny current, might produce a voltage variation of 0–10V representing the desired lighting level. This is then applied to an electronic dimmer, sited at a place most convenient for electrical power distribution, which does the actual power control using components like thyristors or IGBTs. 2.5.2 Digital The analog signal is continuously variable between limits set only by the nature of the apparatus concerned. Our 0–10V signal can, if the equipment is of sufficient precision, be set to any fractional voltage required, for example 5.467V. The nature of a digital signal, on the other hand, is that it can only adopt discrete values. For example, the 0–10V signal might only be available in integral voltages, 0, 1, 2, 3...V etc.
86
Despite the marketing man’s hype of all things digital, we actually live in an analog world. Our senses of sight, sound, smell and touch work on a continuous basis. In any practical digital system the divisions between the discrete levels must be so small that we cannot detect them. For example, on today’s CD (compact disc) 65,536 discrete sound levels are recorded between zero and maximum output in order to fool our ears that the sound pressure variation is continuous. In practice all digital electronic equipment works by using only TWO discrete levels. This has a number of advantages. In any form of signal processing, the analog signal can suffer in many ways: • electrical noise can be added to the signal, thus degrading its quality (resulting in noisy sound or flickering lights). • the signal can suffer from distortion. The description of transistors showed that their transfer characteristics are not always linear, so this is easy to understand. • the signal can suffer lack of precision due to the processing device. For example the transistor control circuit for a dimmer might give a different output at different temperatures (since all transistor characteristics vary a lot with temperature.) However, if only two signal levels are used, let us say 0V and 5V (OFF and ON; or 0 and 1), there is little likelihood they will be confused. If the detector of the ON signal is set to look for anything over, say 4V as ON, and anything else as OFF, it means that the cable carrying the signal can have a lot of noise on it without impairing the information carried. Distortion and precision (in level) are not an issue, because we are only looking for two quite discrete states. Many of the principles of digital electronics were understood in the 1920s and 30s; and early computers based on vacuum tubes were based on them. However it was the advent of the high frequency transistor and the integrated circuit which made digital electronics practical. The transistor’s ability to block a voltage on the one hand, and then to go to a saturated switched-on condition on the other, is the key to achieving the 0 and 1 conditions required by digital signals.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
2.5.3 Binary “Digital” is derived from digit, our fingers or toes. It implies a method of expressing numbers or counting to base 10. Our normal numbering system is referred to as being of decimal notation, where each “digit” in a number can assume only one of ten values 0–9. Although not wholly impossible, it would be difficult to make a precision electronic device able to adopt ten different states. With a transistor this might involve working the transistor in inefficient intermediate states between off and saturation, resulting in the dissipation of a lot of heat. To eliminate this kind of complication, digital electronics uses the binary notation for counting, where each digit can assume only one of two values 0 or 1. Binary digits are referred to as bits. Table 2.1 shows the relationship between binary and digital notation. It also introduces the idea of resolution. For some tasks low resolution is quite sufficient; for example many lighting control systems are based on 8-bit resolution (256 separate levels.) However, if moving lights are digitally controlled, and are working over a 180° arc, 8-bit resolution results in noticeable “jumps” as the device moves; after all, each step is nearly a degree. Therefore a higher resolution is needed. In the CD referred to earlier 16-bit resolution is used; a new generation of audio disc (based on DVD technology) is using 24-bit. Digital signals can be presented in two ways. Parallel data presents all the bits simultaneously on the requisite number of separate signal cables. Computers usually have a parallel bus architecture, for example 8, 16, 32 or 64-bit, requiring the corresponding number of connecting wires between each part of the computer. Data is transferred between the different parts of the computer in small chunks referred to as bytes. In small computer and microprocessor work, 8-bit bytes are used and references to memory capacity in bytes assumes 8-bit bytes. In a computer, however, the architecture could use a 32-bit parallel bus for either single 32-bit bytes, or for four 8-bit bytes. Parallel operation is fine for use within the confines of a computer. It requires very precise timing, so the bus structure includes a clock line. This car-
ries a clock signal which defines the moment at which the main bus should be examined for data. It is not practical to extend parallel signal buses for any distance, because the timing between different bus lines can vary so much. For this reason any longer distance communication is done using serial data signals. Here the bits are transmitted in sequence, with some identifying signal to show the start of each byte. Groups of bytes are referred to as words. It is now clear that all digital electronics is based on numbers. If we need to process any information, or measure a physical quantity, or control any device, we must do it by numbers. Examples of code jargon that is frequently encountered in electronics are as follows. Binary Coded Decimal or BCD is a coding technique sometimes used for input and output devices. Here any number is stored as decimal, with one 8-bit byte allocated to each decimal digit. Only the first ten binary numbers, 0000 to 1001 are used. This is obviously wasteful for computing, but is convenient for some applications. For example illuminated number displays, like those used on petrol pumps or train indicators, might use BCD for each decimal
Decimal and binary equivalents 0 0000 1 0001 2 0010 3 0011 4 0100 5 0101 6 0110 7 0111 8 1000 9 1001 10 A 1010 11 B 1011 12 C 1100 13 D 1101 14 E 1110 15 F 1111
Each power of 2 adds one bit 1 bit = 21 2 2 bits = 22 4 3 bits = 23 8 4 bits = 24 16 5 bits = 25 32 6 bits = 26 64 7 bits = 27 128 8 bits = 28 256 9 bits = 29 512 10 bits = 210 1024 For example “10 bit resolution” can represent 1024 different levels
Table 2.1 The relationship between binary and decimal notation. The letters A-F against decimal 10-15 are the hexadecimal equivalent (see text).
87
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
digit section of the display. Hexadecimal Code. Here all binary numbers 00000000 through 11111111 (0–256 Decimal) can be represented by a two digit number to base 16 (0– FF hexadecimal). Decimal 0–9 are designated as normal, decimal 10–16 are designated by letters A–F. Hexadecimal or “hex” is used by computer programmers as a shorthand for describing 8-bit bytes. It is much easier to recognize, and less prone to transcription error, than the equivalent binary string of 1s and 0s. ASCII Code (American Standard Code for Information Interchange). In its original form this represents: • the digits 0–9 • the letters A–Z upper case • the letters a–z lower case • punctuation marks • some symbols (e.g. +, $, %, @ etc). • 32 commands and identifying symbols. The symbols include items like STX or “start of text”. The commands include printer commands like CR or “carriage return”. All fit into only 7 bits (128 different characters.) So, as an example, the letter “Z” (upper case) has the code 1011010. (This binary number is also equivalent to decimal 90 and hexadecimal 5A.) ASCII code has been extended in both standardized and non-standard ways to cope with different alphabets and frequently used symbols. 2.5.4 Analog to Digital Conversion. ADCs and DACs Because the real world is analog many digital systems need a method whereby an analog signal is turned into its digital equivalent and vice-versa. For example a digital audio system must, at some point, create a signal suitable for connecting to a loudspeaker; or a light sensor detecting light levels may be required to convert its analog output signal into a digital signal suitable for computer processing. The devices required are called analog to digital converters (ADCs) and digital to analog converters (DACs). The ADC’s job is to turn a continuously varying
88
analog waveform into a series of numbers. The process is illustrated in Figure 2.47. The idea is to end up with a set of numbers which, if plotted as a graph against time, would reconstruct the original analog waveform. The ADC process is to sample the waveform at frequent intervals, and convert the measured signal level (usually voltage) to the nearest digital value which can be stored; a process called quantization. It is clear from the figure that if only a few samples are taken per second, and if only a few values are allowed (e.g. only 4-bit quantization), and then a graph is plotted from these figures, the result is a “staircase” version of the original. This may be satisfactory for some applications, but is usually unacceptable. The performance of the quantization process is determined by two factors. The sampling frequency and the quantizing level. The quantizing level is the same as bit resolution described in 2.5.3. The requirement will depend on the application – many bits for critical applications like audio, less for lighting and video. The sampling frequency determines the highest frequency that can be sampled. It is intuitive that if one wants to sample an audio frequency of, say 9kHz, it will be necessary to use a sampling frequency which is higher than 9kHz – but how much higher? Successive digital bytes OUT
Analog In
1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0
ADC
1 1 0 1 0 1 1 0
1 1 0 1 1 1 0 0
t
t 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0
1 0 0 1 1 0 1 1
1 1 0 1 0 1 1 0
1 0 0 1 1 0 1 1
1 1 0 1 1 1 0 0
DAC
Successive digital bytes IN
Figure 2.47 Principle of the ADC and DAC.
Analog Out
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
Signal IN analog
Read clock
Reference voltage
R 1 R 255 to 8 encoder
Potential divider
2
R 254 R 255
Digital out 8 bit
Differential comparators
Figure 2.48 One of the methods of creating an ADC. This is the “flash” converter.
Nyquist’s theorem shows that the the Nyquist frequency, the highest frequency which can be accurately sampled, is half the sampling frequency. Therefore a sampling frequency of at least 18kHz would be needed to convert the 9kHz audio. In fact, in the CD system, a sampling frequency of 44.1 kHz is used to achieve an audio bandwidth of 20kHz. In a lighting control system, where one might be using an analog device such as a slider or sensor, as input, the sampling frequency could be comparatively low. In a video system requiring digital video, the sampling frequencies are much higher (e.g. 13.5MHz). An ADC is a complex device which can only be realized practically as an integrated circuit. An example which is easy to understand (but uses the most circuitry) is the flash converter shown in Figure 2.48. The principle is that the incoming voltage is compared to a known voltage. An 8-bit (256 level) converter has a reference voltage source which is fed to
a chain of 256 resistors. Therefore the voltage at the end of each resistor is known. The device then contains no less than 255 differential comparators. These are not unlike the differential amplifier described in Section 2.3.2.5. They have two inputs, and in this case are designed only to give an output if the sampled voltage exceeds the reference voltage. As can be seen from the figure, the sampled voltage is fed to one input of all the comparators. The other input of each comparator is connected to one of the 255 reference voltages. The result is that, if a continuously varying waveform is fed to the device, there is a continuously varying pattern of “on” signals appearing at the outputs of the comparators. In fact each comparator is fitted with a switch controlled by a clock signal, so that the outputs are only “read” at the fixed sampling frequency. It is then a comparatively simple matter to convert the pattern of 255 comparator outputs to an 8-bit digital signal. The digital output is normally stored in some kind of output register, so it can be extracted when required by the device which is processing the data. The flash converter has been described because the concept is simple. “Slower” ADCs use “sample and hold” techniques (and much less circuitry) where the incoming voltage is momentarily sampled and “held” in a capacitor. The “held” voltage is then measured by using a single comparator and measuring the time taken for the capacitor to discharge to a reference voltage. The counter that does the timing produces a digital signal as output. DACs work on similar principles, but in reverse. For example by having available a number of binary weighted currents which are switched into a common load according to the digital signal. The selected currents are summed, and together represent the analog of the digital signal, Figure 2.49. This abbreviated description of DACs and ADCs is not intended to be definitive, but rather to illustrate how circuit building blocks can be used to meet a particular function. Both DACs and ADCs are widely used in electronics, but use significantly different constructions according to the bandwidth and accuracy required. Their use in lighting control is one of the less demanding applications.
89
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
R R
R
R
R
R
R
R
OUT ANALOG
2R
2R 2R
0
1
2R 2R
0
0
2R 2R 2R 2R
1
1 0
Transistor switches operate as 8 bit signal
importance in lighting. Some light sources cannot be continuously controlled; for example attempting to vary the light output of an LED by simply varying the applied voltage does not work very well. However, LEDs can be switched on and off very fast. Human eyesight has the attribute of persistence of vision whereby, above Modulating waveform
AM
1
Resistor network gives binary weighting to current flow
Reference voltage
Figure 2.49 One of the methods of creating a DAC.
Constant frequency carrier
2.5.5 Modulation The word modulation in an electronic context refers to the means by which source information is modified or encoded in order to match the means of transmission or storage. An easy example to understand is amplitude modulation as used by AM radio. An AM radio signal may be transmitted by an electromagnetic wave of, for example, 600kHz. Clearly a continuous transmission imparts no information, but by modulating the 600kHz carrier, information can be conveyed. In AM radio this is done by the simple expedient of varying the strength or amplitude of the carrier by the analog of the audio signal to be transmitted. The problem with AM is that the signal strength must vary in order to send the information. More efficient use of transmission power, and a better signal, can result from methods whereby the signal strength is constant. One way of achieving this is by frequency modulation or FM. It is intuitive that, for such a system to work, the carrier mean frequency must be much higher than the modulating frequencies. Another possibility is to use some form of pulse modulation. One frequently used example is pulse width modulation or PWM. This is used in Class D amplifiers (Section 2.3.2.2). Again the pulse frequency must be much higher than the frequency of the signal to be transmitted. PWM is of considerable
90
Frequency varies as moulating signal
FM
Constant amplitude carrier
Original waveform PAM
t Pulse amplitude corresponds to instantaneous value of original waveform, sampled at interval t
1
0
- Measure amplitude at intervals - Convert to binary code - Send as serial digital signal
PCM
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
t 1st sample
Figure 2.50 Methods of modulation.
1
0
1 1
2nd sample
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
a certain frequency, our eye/brain combination integrates successive light stimuli. This is the basis on which film and television works, whereby, for example, 30 frames are presented each second and we see a continuous image variation. The same principle can be used to, apparently, vary the intensity of light. Clearly if the pulse frequency is too low, we just see successive flashes of light. At intermediate frequencies we see flicker which is extremely uncomfortable. The subjective effect of flicker is not only dependent on frequency, but also on other factors such as ambient light level, contrast etc, but once the switching frequency is high enough, we simply see an apparently steady source of illumination. For lighting control purposes the effective use of PWM depends on the source being used, but would usually need a minimum frequency of 120Hz. An intermediate system of modulation is pulse amplitude modulation or PAM where the source analog waveform is sampled at discrete intervals. Instead of transmitting the complete analog waveform, sample pulses only are transmitted. In fact, such a method is rarely used, but it does form the basis of the commonly used pulse code modulation or PCM. In PCM the magnitude of each pulse is converted into a binary number – exactly the process already described for the ADC. Once we are in the digital domain, all kinds of modulation systems become possible; for example delta modulation uses only the differences between successive amplitude values in order to reduce the required bandwidth. Highly sophisticated methods are used to eliminate errors, and ingenious methods used to increase the data throughput of any transmission channel. But most digital modulation systems start with PCM, whatever method is then used to attach the resulting signal to the carrier medium.
Volt). Even more confusing, it seems to turn up in unlikely places. Most people are aware of it as a measure of sound, but, less obviously, it turns up as a measure of radiated signal strength and as a measure of performance of data cables, both of which are relevant to lighting control. Sound levels may also be relevant, especially if control equipment is fitted with noisy fans, or emits a buzz. The decibel or dB is a measurement of ratios. It was originally applied to sound where, because our hearing is logarithmic, it was easier to express changes in sound levels using the logarithm of the ratio of two powers. It is best to start with the acoustic definition. The Bel was the original unit, where: B = log10 (P2/P1) and P1 is the reference power P2 is the new power. log10 is the common (base 10) logarithm, where numbers are expressed as their equivalent as the power of 10. In practice the Bel was found to be too big for sound intensity (defined as the energy passing through one square meter normal to the direction of propagation) so the unit used is the decibel where: Sound Intensity in dB = 10 log10 (P2/P1) Here the power is in Watts/m2, and the reference power P1 is taken as the threshold of hearing, the lowest sound intensity which a healthy young human being can detect. It is usually taken as 10-12 W. Sound intensity is a difficult quantity to measure, so it is more usual to measure sound pressure level or SPL. But this is proportional to the square root of the intensity, so the equation becomes: SPL in dB = 20 log (ρ/ρr)
2.5.6 The decibel A unit frequently encountered in electronics and audio is the decibel. It is often wrongly treated as though it was a physical quantity, which can be measured in physical terms related to fundamental units (like a
Where ρ is the pressure and ρr is the reference pressure corresponding to the threshold of hearing – taken to be 20μPa. Table 2.2 gives some examples of sound pressure levels. The log10 of one is zero (i.e. 100 equals 1) so when ρ = ρr = 20μPa, we have a reference SPL of
91
LIGHTING CONTROL – TECHNOLOGY AND APPLICATIONS
SPL in dB 0 20 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 140
Actual Example SP 20PPa Threshold of hearing 200PPa Background in recording studio. Quiet countryside. 2000PPa Whisper at 2m Average suburban area 6310PPa Conversation at 1m General office 0.02Pa Restaurant, store 0.063Pa Radio/TV in the home 0.2Pa Busy street 0.63Pa Heavy truck at 6m Symphony orchestra fff 2Pa Disco 6.31Pa Pneumatic drill at 1m 20Pa Modern aircraft at takeoff 200Pa Military jet at take off at 30m Threshold of pain
Table 2.2 Sound pressure levels.
0dB. It is now easy to see why the logarithmic method of measurement is convenient. The 140dB range of sounds covers our normal experience, with quite easy reference points over a reasonable scale – especially when you consider that we can only just detect a 2dB change in SPL. However 140dB represents a range of sound pressures with the ratio 10,000,000:1. Note that without a reference level, a dB figure cannot give us an absolute value for a quantity. As with the human eye, the human ear does not hear all frequencies equally. The phon is the unit of loudness. At 1kHz one phon is equivalent to 1dB SPL; so if SPLs are only measured at 1kHz, the loudness in phons is the same as SPL in dB; but at all other frequencies they are different. The phon is, therefore, analagous to the lumen, in that its value depends on a human attribute (sensitivity to wavelength of sound, instead of wavelength of light). The fact that our ear response to sound varies with frequency means that using linear measurements of sound is misleading. Noise and sound pressure level measurements are weighted to be meaningful. The
92
most commonly used weighting curve is the A weighting curve shown in Figure 2.51. Measurements made using it are referred to as dBA. Where noise is an issue for lighting control equipment (e.g. in ballasts) it is usual to see the noise figure quoted in dBA. Early designers of audio amplifiers realized that when analog electric currents and voltages were used to represent sound, the dB notation was useful. In this way the effect of, for example, a 6dB change in signal level, gives a good idea of the aural effect, in a way which a statement of increase in voltage or power would not. When dB are applied to electrical quantities the relationship only holds good if the circuit impedance is the same for both values. Also, as with the acoustic dB, the relationship is Power ratio in dB = 10 log10 (P2/P1) where P1 is the reference power; but, because both current and voltage are proportional to the square root of the power, voltage or current ratios are defined by: Voltage ratio in dB = 20 log (V2/V1) Current ratio in dB = 20 log (I2/I1) A Weighting dB +10 0 -10 -20
-30 -40 -50 -60 10
20 30
50
100
500 1000
5000 10000 Hz
Figure 2.51 The A weighting curve for acoustic measurements.
LIGHTING ELECTRONICS
The dB has been found to be useful for electrical and electromagnetic quantities other than those directly related to sound. So it is common to see figures for the attenuation of all kinds of signals down a cable being referred to in dB. Likewise measurements of electric field strength are conveniently referred to dB. “Electrical dB” must, like their acoustic counterparts, have a reference level. Some of these are shown in Table 2.3.
2.6 The integrated circuit and ASIC 2.6.1 Introduction Many electronic circuits are made up of discrete components. Often, in order to get a workable circuit, the circuits become quite complex. This is because a realworld circuit needs additional components; for example to compensate for variations in temperature, to eliminate the effects of voltage spikes, or to stabilize a power supply. When high powers are involved it is generally necessary to use discrete components, but when a circuit is only required to operate at low power, the idea of an integrated circuit becomes realizable.
Notation dBV dBmV dBPV/m dBW
dBm
Reference Level 1V (for v