Landolt-Börnstein GROUP VIII: Advanced Materials and Technologies VOLUME 1 Laser Physics and Applications SUBVOLUME C L...
150 downloads
1803 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Landolt-Börnstein GROUP VIII: Advanced Materials and Technologies VOLUME 1 Laser Physics and Applications SUBVOLUME C Laser Applications Title Pages Contributors, Preface, Contents Contributors Preface Contents 1
Fundamentals
1
1.1 1.1.1
Fundamentals of laser-induced processes (H. HÜGEL, F. DAUSINGER) Introduction
3 3
1.1.2
Energy coupling
4
1.1.2.1
Fundamentals
4
1.1.2.2
Optical properties of metals
6
1.1.2.2.1
Temperature effects
9
1.1.2.2.2
Chemical effects
14
1.1.2.2.3
Roughness effects
14
1.1.2.3
Optical properties of ceramics
16
1.1.2.4
Scattering and absorption by particles
18
1.1.2.5
Non-linear absorption
24
1.1.3
Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
25
1.1.3.1
Condensed matter
25
1.1.3.1.1
Heat conduction
25
1.1.3.1.1.1
Fourier heat conduction
25
1.1.3.1.1.2
Two-temperature model
28
1.1.3.1.2
Phase transitions
30
1.1.3.1.2.1
Melting
30
1.1.3.1.2.2
Evaporation
32
1.1.3.1.3
Melt dynamics
34
1.1.3.1.3.1
Origin of driving forces
34
1.1.3.1.3.2
Resulting effects in laser machining
35
1.1.3.2
Interaction mechanisms in the gas and plasma phase
37
1.1.3.2.1
Basic ionization and absorption mechanisms
38
1.1.3.2.1.1
Bound electrons
38
1.1.3.2.1.2
Free electrons
40
1.1.3.2.2
Absorption and refraction effects in laser-induced plasmas
41
1.1.3.2.2.1
Plasma composition and temperature
41
1.1.3.2.2.2
Absorption
47
1.1.3.2.2.3
Refraction
50
1.1.3.2.3
Dynamical effects
52
1.1.4
Simplified dependences in laser processes
56
1.1.4.1
Energy coupling in laser processes
56
1.1.4.1.1
Coupling rate in laser cutting
56
1.1.4.1.2
Coupling rate in laser welding
57
1.1.4.2
Process windows
58
1.1.4.2.1
Power threshold
59
1.1.4.2.2
Factors determining process velocity
60
1.1.4.2.3
Factors determining efficiency
61
References for 1.1
62
2
Production engineering
73
2.1 2.1.1
Surface treatment (H.W. BERGMANN) Laser macro processing
75 75
2.1.1.1
Solid-state hardening
76
2.1.1.1.1
Physical basics
76
2.1.1.1.2
Material science basics
77
2.1.1.1.3
Production-related aspects
78
2.1.1.1.4
Time scheme of the irradiation
79
2.1.1.1.5
Observed degradations and their reasons
79
2.1.1.2
Remelting
81
2.1.1.2.1
Remelting of cast iron
83
2.1.1.2.2
Remelting of aluminum alloys
84
2.1.1.2.3
Remelting of titanium alloys
86
2.1.1.2.4
Remelting of magnesium alloys
88
2.1.1.2.5
Observed degradations of surface-remelted components and their reasons
89
2.1.1.3
Laser cladding
92
2.1.2
Thin-layer technologies
95
2.1.2.1
Laser cleaning
96
2.1.2.2
Laser cleaning and smoothing of cast iron
97
2.1.2.3
Surface alloying
97
2.1.3
Laser shock hardening
98
References for 2.1
101
2.2 2.2.1
Rapid prototyping (A. GEBHARDT) Layer manufacturing
105 106
2.2.1.1
Rapid-prototyping process chain
106
2.2.1.2
Prototypers
107
2.2.1.3
Characteristics of rapid-prototyping processes
108
2.2.1.4
Materials
108
2.2.1.5
Post-processing
113
2.2.1.6
Finishing
113
2.2.1.7
Functional metal parts
113
2.2.1.8
Rapid tooling
113
2.2.1.8.1
Indirect rapid tooling
115
2.2.1.8.2
Direct rapid tooling
116
2.2.2
Application of rapid-prototyping models
117
2.2.2.1
Model characteristics and model properties
117
2.2.2.2
Criteria for the use of rapid-prototyping models
117
2.2.2.3
Examples
119
2.2.2.4
Rapid manufacturing
121
2.2.3
Recent developments and future trends
121
References for 2.2
123
2.3 2.3.1
Thermal bending (M. GEIGER, F. VOLLERTSEN) Principle of laser forming
125 125
2.3.2
Mechanisms
125
2.3.3
Influence parameters
126
2.3.3.1
Threshold energy
127
2.3.3.2
Processing parameters
127
2.3.3.3
Material parameters
128
2.3.3.4
Geometric parameters
130
2.3.4
Bend radii
131
2.3.5
State of the art and trends
132
References for 2.3
133
2.4 2.4.1
Joining (H. HAFERKAMP) Introduction
137 137
2.4.2
Conduction welding
139
2.4.3
Deep-penetration welding
140
2.4.3.1
Capillary formation
142
2.4.3.2
Plasma formation
143
2.4.3.3
Humping effect
144
2.4.4
Material weldability
145
2.4.5
Thermal distortion
146
2.4.6
Tailored blanks
147
2.4.7
Soldering and brazing
149
2.4.8
Diode-laser applications
150
2.4.9
How to avoid quality degradation
151
References for 2.4
156
2.5 2.5.1
Laser separating (W. O'NEILL) Introduction
159 159
2.5.2
Cutting
160
2.5.2.1
Fusion cutting
160
2.5.2.2
Reactive-gas cutting
162
2.5.2.3
Sublimation cutting
163
2.5.3
Cleaning
163
2.5.4
Machining
167
2.5.4.1
Oxidation processes
168
2.5.4.2
Liquid-phase machining
168
2.5.4.3
Vapor-phase machining
168
2.5.5
Drilling
170
2.5.5.1
Piercing
172
2.5.5.2
Multiple-pulse drilling
172
2.5.5.3
Trepanning
173
2.5.5.4
High-speed drilling
175
2.5.6
Non-thermal ablation
176
2.5.7
Marking
177
2.5.8
Comparison with conventional processes
178
2.5.9
How to avoid quality degradation
180
References for 2.5
184
2.6 2.6.1
Cutting: Modeling and data (W. SCHULZ, C. HERTZLER) Diagnostics, monitoring and modeling
187 188
2.6.2
Experiments and diagnostics
189
2.6.3
Mathematical formulation
191
2.6.4
Inertial manifolds
192
2.6.5
Dimension in phase space
193
2.6.6
Spatial one-dimensional model
194
2.6.7
Spatial two-dimensional model and diffusive eikonal
196
2.6.8
Iterative refinement
199
2.6.9
Cutting data
202
2.6.9.1
Laser power
202
2.6.9.2
Modulation of the laser output (gating frequency)
203
2.6.9.3
Beam quality and power density distribution
203
2.6.9.4
Spatial and temporal beam stability
205
2.6.9.5
Polarization
205
2.6.9.6
Output mirrors of the laser unit
205
2.6.9.7
Beam alignment
205
2.6.9.8
Astigmatism
206
2.6.9.9
Deflection mirror
206
2.6.9.10
Focusing lens
206
2.6.9.11
Beam to nozzle alignment
206
2.6.9.12
Shape of nozzle exit
207
2.6.9.13
Cutting speed
207
2.6.9.14
Type of assist gas
207
2.6.9.15
Gas pressure
207
2.6.9.16
Focal position
208
2.6.9.17
Material type and composition
208
2.6.9.18
Thickness
208
2.6.9.19
Surface condition of the sheet metal
208
2.6.9.20
Cut shape
209
2.6.9.21
Kerf width
209
2.6.9.22
Dross formation
210
2.6.9.23
Mean roughness
210
2.6.9.24
Perpendicularity and slant tolerance
211
2.6.9.25
Drag lines
211
2.6.9.26
Pitting
211
2.6.9.27
Heat-affected zone
211
2.6.10
Machining data tables for cutting
212
References for 2.6
215
2.7 2.7.1
Laser systems for materials processing (G. SEPOLD, M. GRUPP) Laser macro systems
219 220
2.7.1.1
Laser sources
221
2.7.1.1.1
CO2-laser
221
2.7.1.1.2
Nd:YAG laser
222
2.7.1.1.3
High-power diode lasers
223
2.7.1.1.4
Fiber lasers and thin disc lasers
224
2.7.1.2
Laser beam guiding
224
2.7.1.2.1
Beam-guiding systems for CO2-lasers
224
2.7.1.2.2
Beam guiding for Nd:YAG-lasers
225
2.7.1.3
Beam-forming elements
226
2.7.1.3.1
Focusing optics
227
2.7.1.3.1.1
Laser cutting heads
228
2.7.1.3.1.2
Welding heads
228
2.7.1.3.1.3
Working heads for surface treatment
229
2.7.1.4
Handling devices
230
2.7.1.4.1
System concepts
230
2.7.1.4.1.1
1-dimensional systems
230
2.7.1.4.1.2
2-dimensional systems
230
2.7.1.4.1.3
3-dimensional systems
232
2.7.1.4.2
New developments
234
2.7.1.4.3
Special systems
235
2.7.1.4.4
Actuation and control of laser systems
236
2.7.1.4.5
Clamping devices
236
2.7.2
Laser microtechnology
237
2.7.2.1
Beam sources
238
2.7.2.2
Beam-guiding and -forming techniques
238
2.7.3
Conclusions and outlook
239
References for 2.7
241
2.8 2.8.1
Process monitoring and closed-loop control (W. WIESEMANN) Introduction
243 243
2.8.2
Basics of process monitoring and closed-loop control
244
2.8.2.1
General
244
2.8.2.2
Process-surveillance objectives and strategies
245
2.8.2.2.1
Support for scientific research by monitoring of process output parameters
245
2.8.2.2.2
On-line treatment fault probability assessment and documentation during serial production
246
2.8.2.2.3
Closed-loop control during serial production
246
2.8.2.3
Treatment quality indicators, span of surveillance
247
2.8.2.4
Process output parameter detection
249
2.8.2.4.1
Theoretical introduction
249
2.8.2.4.2
Radiation emission from the interaction zone
250
2.8.2.4.3
Radiation reflection and transmission at the interaction zone
250
2.8.2.4.4
Radiation detection and sensor arrangement
251
2.8.2.4.5
Two-dimensionally resolved radiation emission
252
2.8.2.4.6
Sound detection
253
2.8.2.4.7
Electrical-charge detection
253
2.8.2.4.8
Multiple-sensor fusion
253
2.8.2.5
Signal assessment methods
254
2.8.2.6
Control actions
256
2.8.3
State of the art of process monitoring and control technology
258
2.8.3.1
Cutting and drilling
259
2.8.3.1.1
General
259
2.8.3.1.2
Scientific research
259
2.8.3.1.2.1
Cutting
259
2.8.3.1.2.2
Drilling, piercing
260
2.8.3.1.3
Industrial applications
261
2.8.3.2
Welding
261
2.8.3.2.1
General and historical
261
2.8.3.2.2
Recent scientific research
262
2.8.3.2.2.1
Optical emissions, photo-diode detection
263
2.8.3.2.2.2
Optical emissions, camera detection
264
2.8.3.2.2.3
Reflected laser radiation
264
2.8.3.2.2.4
Electrical charge collection
265
2.8.3.2.2.5
Multiple sensor schemes
265
2.8.3.2.2.6
X-ray and visible-light shadowgraphy, holography, laser beam probe, ultrasonic inspection
266
2.8.3.2.3
Industrial applications
267
2.8.3.2.3.1
Monitoring systems
267
2.8.3.2.3.2
Closed-loop control systems
268
2.8.3.3
Transformation hardening
268
2.8.3.4
Cladding, alloying
269
2.8.3.5
Cleaning, caving
269
2.8.4
Outlook
270
References for 2.8
272
3
Life science, biological and chemical processing
277
3.1 3.1.1
Lasers in biology and medicine (O. MINET, K. DÖRSCHEL, G. MÜLLER) Light and heat transport in tissue
279 279
3.1.1.1
Light transport and optical parameters
279
3.1.1.2
Heat transport and thermal parameters
282
3.1.2
Laser-tissue interactions
285
3.1.2.1
Laser diagnostics by transillumination and induced fluorescences
285
3.1.2.2
Laser-induced photochemistry
287
3.1.2.3
Photothermal effects
287
3.1.2.3.1
Coagulation
288
3.1.2.3.2
Evaporation of tissue
288
3.1.2.4
Effects of short-pulsed laser radiation
288
3.1.2.4.1
Photoablation
289
3.1.2.4.2
Optical breakdown and plasma formation
290
3.1.2.4.3
Laser-induced shock waves and cavitations
291
3.1.2.5
Laser biostimulation
291
3.1.3
Medical laser systems
292
3.1.3.1
Typical medical lasers
292
3.1.3.2
Laser light delivery
292
3.1.3.2.1
Articulated arm
292
3.1.3.2.2
Light guide
292
3.1.3.2.3
Optical glass fiber
295
3.1.3.2.4
Hollow wave guide
296
3.1.3.3
Applicator systems
296
3.1.4
Laser applications in medicine
296
3.1.5
Medical laser safety
298
3.1.5.1
Medical laser pyrolysis products
298
3.1.5.2
Regulatory requirements for medical laser systems
301
3.1.5.3
Specific aspects of medical laser safety
302
References for 3.1
303
3.2 3.2.1
Laser chemical processing (D. BÄUERLE) Introduction
311 311
3.2.2
Pulsed-laser ablation
313
3.2.2.1
Surface patterning
314
3.2.2.2
The threshold fluence
317
3.2.2.3
Ablation rates
317
3.2.2.4
Material damage
319
3.2.2.5
Influence of an ambient atmosphere
320
3.2.2.6
Instabilities, structure formation
320
3.2.3
Materials etching
320
3.2.3.1
Etching of metals
321
3.2.3.2
Etching of semiconductors and insulators
321
3.2.4
Laser-induced chemical vapor deposition (Laser-CVD)
325
3.2.4.1
Microstructures
325
3.2.4.2
Thin-film formation
327
3.2.4.3
Adsorbed layers, hybrid techniques
329
3.2.5
Deposition from liquids
331
3.2.5.1
Electroless plating
332
3.2.5.2
Electrochemical plating
333
3.2.6
Pulsed-laser deposition (PLD)
333
3.2.6.1
Overview of materials and film properties
334
3.2.6.1.1
Inorganic materials
334
3.2.6.1.2
Organic materials
336
3.2.6.2
Nanocrystalline films
338
3.2.6.2.1
Nanocomposite materials
338
3.2.6.2.2
Size-selective ablation
339
3.2.6.3
Hybrid techniques
339
3.2.6.4
Laser-induced forward transfer
339
3.2.7
Chemical surface transformations
339
3.2.7.1
Doping
340
3.2.7.2
Alloying and synthesis
341
3.2.7.3
Oxidation, nitridation, reduction
341
3.2.7.4
Transformation of organic materials, laser lithography
342
References for 3.2
345
4
Optical data processing
353
4.1 4.1.1
Communication (M. MÖHRLE, H. VENGHAUS) Introduction
355 355
4.1.2
Heterostructures
356
4.1.3
Material systems
359
4.1.4
Diode laser structures
359
4.1.4.1
Ridge-waveguide (RW) lasers
360
4.1.4.2
Buried-heterostructure (BH) lasers
360
4.1.4.2.1
Conventional BH-lasers
361
4.1.4.2.2
Semi-insulating BH-lasers
362
4.1.4.2.3
Buried-Ridge-Stripe (BRS) lasers
362
4.1.5
Laser types
362
4.1.5.1
Multimode devices (Fabry-Perot (FP) lasers)
362
4.1.5.2
Single-mode devices
364
4.1.5.2.1
Distributed-feedback (DFB) lasers
364
4.1.5.2.2
Distributed-Bragg-reflector (DBR) lasers
367
4.1.6
Characteristics of 1.3 µm and 1.5 µm lasers
367
4.1.6.1
Fabry-Perot (FP) lasers
368
4.1.6.2
Distributed-feedback (DFB) lasers
371
4.1.6.2.1
General
371
4.1.6.2.2
Linewidth
373
4.1.6.2.3
HF characteristics
373
4.1.6.3
Lasers for uncooled operation
374
4.1.6.4
Lasers for supervisory channels
375
4.1.7
Fiber-based lasers
375
4.1.7.1
Fiber lasers
375
4.1.7.2
Hybrid Fabry-Perot fiber Bragg grating lasers
376
4.1.8
Integrated laser-modulator
376
4.1.9
Tunable lasers
378
4.1.9.1
Standard devices
378
4.1.9.2
Semiconductor lasers with enhanced tuning range
379
4.1.9.3
Commercial tunable single-chip (SC) lasers
380
4.1.9.4
Linewidth of widely tunable lasers
380
4.1.9.5
Wavelength tunable/selectable fiber laser
380
4.1.9.6
External-cavity laser
381
4.1.10
Monolithic integrations
381
4.1.10.1
Integrated spot size converter
381
4.1.10.2
Integrated multi-wavelength sources
382
4.1.10.3
Integrated mm-wave source
383
4.1.10.4
Transceiver
384
4.1.11
Lasers for advanced optical systems
384
4.1.11.1
Short-pulse sources
384
4.1.11.2
Self-pulsating lasers
384
4.1.12
Pump lasers for optical amplification
385
4.1.12.1
Pump lasers for erbium-doped fiber amplifiers (EDFAs)
385
4.1.12.2
Pump lasers for Raman amplification
386
4.1.13
Vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers (VCSELs)
386
4.1.13.1
Short-wavelength VCSELs
387
4.1.13.2
Long-wavelength (1.3 µm, 1.55 µm) VCSELs
388
4.1.13.2.1
1.3 µm VCSELs
389
4.1.13.2.2
1.55 µm VCSELs
389
4.1.13.3
Tunable VCSELs
392
4.1.14
Reliability
392
References for 4.1
395
5
Metrology
403
5.1 5.1.1
High-precision optical metrology for surfaces (H.J. TIZIANI, M. TOTZECK) Introduction
405 405
5.1.2
Microstructure metrology
407
5.1.2.1
Resolution in optical imaging
407
5.1.2.2
Improving the optical resolution
410
5.1.2.2.1
Decreasing the wavelength
410
5.1.2.2.2
Increasing the numerical aperture (NA)
411
5.1.2.2.3
Decreasing the prefactor κ
411
5.1.2.3
Usage of a-priori information: From model-based imaging to threshold criteria
411
5.1.3
Methods and instrumentation
412
5.1.3.1
High-NA lenses
413
5.1.3.2
Field-measuring microscopy
414
5.1.3.2.1
Intensity microscopy
414
5.1.3.2.2
Microscopy with pupil filters
417
5.1.3.2.3
Interference microscopy
417
5.1.3.2.4
Polarization interferometry
420
5.1.3.3
Confocal microscopy
421
5.1.3.4
Near-field microscopy
425
5.1.4
Large-field metrology
428
5.1.4.1
Interferometry for spherical surfaces
428
5.1.4.2
Aspherics and their testing methods
429
5.1.4.3
Interferometry for aspherical surfaces
429
5.1.4.3.1
The computer-generated hologram (CGH) null
429
5.1.4.3.2
Computation and fabrication of CGH’s
431
5.1.4.3.3
CGH application and error reduction
432
5.1.4.4
Heterodyne interferometry
433
5.1.4.4.1
Principle of external reference
433
5.1.4.4.2
Scanning differential heterodyne interferometry
435
5.1.4.5
Shack-Hartmann sensors
437
5.1.5
A look into the future
438
References for 5.1
439
5.2 5.2.1
Environmental control (M. ULBRICHT) Introduction
443 443
5.2.2
Tunable diode laser spectroscopy (TDLAS)
443
5.2.3
Cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS)
444
5.2.4
Photoacoustic spectroscopy (PAS)
445
5.2.5
Lidar
446
5.2.5.1
Backscatter lidar
446
5.2.5.2
Differential absorption lidar (DIAL)
447
5.2.5.3
Raman lidar
450
5.2.5.4
Fluorescence lidar
451
5.2.5.5
Doppler lidar
451
5.2.5.6
Lidar using intense femtosecond laser pulses
452
References for 5.2
453
6
Laser safety and ecology
457
6.1 6.1.1
Laser safety (H. WELLING) Hazard potentials
459 459
6.1.2
Norms and standards for laser safety
460
6.1.3
Effects of laser radiation and safety measures
461
6.1.3.1
Effects of laser radiation on biological tissue
461
6.1.3.2
Threshold limit values and laser classification
464
6.1.3.3
Safety measures
465
6.1.3.4
Hazard distances
465
6.1.3.4.1
Specular-reflected beam
466
6.1.3.4.2
Diffuse-reflected beam
466
6.1.4
Secondary hazard potentials and safety measures
466
6.1.4.1
Laser system and components
466
6.1.4.1.1
Electrical safety
466
6.1.4.1.2
Optical components
467
6.1.4.1.3
Laser gases
467
6.1.4.1.4
Handling devices
468
6.1.4.2
Secondary radiation
468
6.1.4.3
Explosive atmospheres and fire hazards
469
6.1.4.4
Emission of gases and fumes
469
6.1.4.4.1
Characteristics of laser-generated air contaminants
469
6.1.4.4.2
Extraction systems
473
6.1.4.4.3
Filtration
474
6.1.5
Risk assessment
475
6.1.6
Training and education
476
References for 6.1
477
Index
481
http://www.springer.com/978-3-540-00105-8
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
3
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes H. HÜGEL, F. DAUSINGER
1.1.1 Introduction Laser applications in industrial production are based on definite interactions of the beam with the workpiece. Since the electro-magnetic energy transported by the laser beam is providing the heat source for all the thermal processes, the mechanisms governing the conversion of these energy forms play a decisive role and represent the fundamentals of any laser-induced process. To make material processing an efficient and widely accepted technology, it is of great importance to utilize as much as possible of the energy radiated onto the workpiece. A sound knowledge of the basic phenomena involved and their dependences on laser beam and workpiece properties is decisive for a proper choice of the laser source to be used for a particular application and for the way the process itself should be conducted. The thermal processes of heating, melting or evaporation that will occur in the interaction zone – the area at, in, or above the workpiece where the laser beam directly interacts with material – basically depend on a balance of the heat fluxes released there and those being transported away from there by conduction, convection, or radiation. As a result, the geometry and the thermo-mechanical as well as optical properties of the interaction zone will adjust themselves accordingly. In other words, the phenomena of energy coupling and “the response” of the workpiece are closely interrelated. Consequently, in treating interaction mechanisms the effects of laser beam and material properties as well as geometrical conditions of the interaction zone have to be considered at the same time. Against this background, the fundamentals of energy conversion in laser-induced processes will be treated by answering the central questions: • • •
How much of the energy irradiated onto the workpiece will be released as heat? How does the workpiece “respond” to this energy supply? Are there – on the basis of answers to the first two questions – some generalized conclusions that directly predict the energy coupling in real processes?
Along these lines, this contribution is organized following the order of events generally occurring when a laser beam is focused onto the surface of a workpiece: In the very first instant, the electro-magnetic wave interacts with the electron system of the material. Some fraction of the radiation will be reflected, the rest will propagate into the workpiece experiencing an attenuation. It is the corresponding loss of the wave’s energy that is gained as heat by the material; this aspect is briefly reviewed in Sect. 1.1.2.1 together with methods to calculate reflectivity resp. absorptivity for condensed matter (solid and liquid). Pertinent theoretical and experimental data and figures for metals and ceramics are presented in Sects. 1.1.2.2 and 1.1.2.3. In processes such as cladding or alloying, the interaction of particles with the laser beam will modify the intensity reaching the workpiece surface and the absorption there; this aspect is addressed in Sect. 1.1.2.4. A short reference to non-linear effects concludes this section on energy coupling (Sect. 1.1.2.5). Section 1.1.3 deals with the “response” of the workpiece to heating. The phenomena are addressed according to the state of the material the radiation interacts with. In the first place, therefore, mechanisms governing the energy flux and balance in condensed matter will be treated in Sect. 1.1.3.1. The discussion includes heat conduction (Sect. 1.1.3.1.1), phase transitions (Sect. 1.1.3.1.2), and melt dynamics (Sect. 1.1.3.1.3). Whenever the electro-magnetic energy flux (intensity) is very high, e.g. in drilling or welding processes, the evaporated material will become ionized. In this extended interaction zone along the beam axis absorption and refraction occur (Sect. 1.1.3.2) leading to modifications of the energy cou-
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
4
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
pling. Basic ionization mechanisms are reviewed in Sect. 1.1.3.2.1 and typical plasma properties, absorption and refraction data are presented in Sect. 1.1.3.2.2. Dynamical effects of laser-induced plasmas such as the formation of shock waves are briefly dealt with in Sect. 1.1.3.2.3. In Sect. 1.1.4 an attempt is made to summarize the basic implications of the discussed mechanisms in some generalized formulations.
1.1.2 Energy coupling A description of the propagation of electromagnetic radiation and its interaction with matter can be given by the physical models of particles (photons) and electromagnetic waves. The latter is used in this chapter to discuss reflection, absorption and refraction mechanisms. The influence of various parameters that are of particular interest especially in laser materials processing will be shown.
1.1.2.1 Fundamentals The propagation of electromagnetic waves can be described theoretically on the basis of Maxwell’s equations, see e.g. [86Bor]. A general solution of the wave equation for the time-dependent electric field strength E in the case of a plane wave propagating in z direction is i
ω~ nz
E ( z, t ) = E0 eiω t e c0
where n~ = n + i k .
(1.1.1)
Herein, E0 denotes the amplitude of the electric field, ω the angular frequency, c0 the speed of light in vacuum, and ñ the complex refractive index with n and k representing the index of refraction and extinction, respectively. For k = 0 the amplitude of the electric field and hence the energy contained within the wave remain constant over time which corresponds to the free propagation in vacuum. If, however, k is larger than zero, the wave will be damped and will lose energy upon its propagation within an absorbing medium. This absorbed energy eventually will be transformed into heat and thereby will be available for the laser treatment process. The energy flux of the wave is determined by the Poynting vector whose time-averaged value corresponds to the intensity and can be expressed by the averaged square of the field strength
I = c0 ε 0 E 2 ,
(1.1.2)
with ε0 denoting the electrical permittivity. In absorbing materials, the light intensity decreases along a distance from z = 0 to z according to Beer’s law:
I ( z ) = I 0 e −α z .
(1.1.3)
The absorption coefficient α, which is a function of the vacuum wavelength λ0, can be derived by comparing the exponents resulting from (1.1.1) in conjunction with (1.1.2) with that of Beer’s law (1.1.3):
α=
4 k (λ0 ) . λ0
(1.1.4)
The distance after which the intensity is reduced by a factor of 1/e is called the absorption length or optical penetration depth lα , which is the reciprocal value of the absorption coefficient α :
lα = 1 / α .
(1.1.5)
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
5
The question whether a medium can be regarded as transparent or absorbing is answered by comparing lα with its geometrical dimension in direction of the laser beam propagation. A survey of values for the absorption length and complex refractive index for metals and ceramics at room temperature is given in the following sections. For metals k is larger than unity in the infrared and visible spectral range. Consequently, the absorption length for laser light with such wavelengths is smaller than the wavelength λ0. With lα being many orders of magnitude lower than the typical dimensions of the workpiece (and even that of the interaction zone), the absorbed energy acts as a surface heat source. On the other hand, in cases where lα is comparable to the thickness of the workpiece, e.g. for thin metal films or ceramic plates, volume heating has to be considered. In laser treatment processes the incident intensity I will not be coupled completely into the workpiece. The incident beam intensity is split up into a part reflected at the surface, a part absorbed within the bulk, another one, which is scattered by the material, and a part, which is transmitted through the workpiece. Those fractions can be described by the reflectivity R, the absorptivity A, the scattered fraction S and the transmissivity T, respectively. Due to conservation of energy these contributions have to fulfill the following relationship:
R + A+ S +T =1.
(1.1.6)
The starting value I0 for Beer’s law (1.1.3) is given by the intensity, which actually enters the workpiece, i.e. (1−R) I. The absorbed intensity A⋅I will contribute to the heating of the material and will thereby have a direct impact on the process. If scattering can be neglected this fraction can be evaluated by integrating (1.1.3) over the thickness of the workpiece while the transmissivity T corresponds to the remaining fraction of intensity at the bottom of the workpiece. Otherwise the attenuation and deflection of the beam due to scattering has to be taken into account which will be discussed in Sect. 1.1.2.4. If, additionally, the thickness of the material is much larger than the optical penetration depth lα transmission can be neglected such that A = 1–R. The reflectivity and beam deflection at the interface between two media can be computed as a function of incident angle and polarization by the so-called Fresnel equations. Their general form is given in various optics books (see e.g. [93Ped] or [75Jac]). For the special case of perpendicular incidence on the surface of a beam propagating from an optically thin medium (e.g. air with n ≅ 1) into matter with a complex index of refraction, the reflectivity R can be computed by the following equation: R=
2
2
2
2
( n − 1) + k (n + 1) + k
.
(1.1.7)
For oblique incidence on metals (n2+k2 >>1) and laser light with wavelengths λ longer than 0.5 µm the Fresnel equations can be simplified according to [90Pro] R|| =
(n cos ϕ − 1)2 + k 2 cos 2 ϕ (n cos ϕ + 1)2 + k 2 cos 2 ϕ
R⊥ =
(n − cos ϕ)2 + k 2 (n + cos ϕ)2 + k 2
,
,
(1.1.8)
(1.1.9)
where ϕ is the angle between the surface normal and the incident beam. R|| describes the reflectivity for the electric field vector parallel (p-polarization) to the plane of incidence (defined by the incident beam and the surface normal) whereas R⊥ denotes the reflectivity for its orientation perpendicular (s-polarization) to it. It is obvious that in the limit of perpendicular incidence (ϕ = 0) these expressions reduce to (1.1.7). In the following sections these theoretical findings will be further examined and compared to experimental data. Due to the different optical behavior for opaque and transparent materials this survey is split into separate sections for metals and ceramics.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
6
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
1.1.2.2 Optical properties of metals Various methods have been developed to determine n and k describing the optical behavior of materials and their interfaces [91Pal]. Pure materials at room temperature with clean and smooth surface conditions were preferentially used in most investigations. A rather complete data base, [91Pal] and [81Wea], is at hand for such samples. A survey of data for these optical constants at different laser wavelengths is given in Table 1.1.1. It can be observed that the extinction index k usually is much larger than unity which leads to absorption lengths smaller than the wavelength, see Table 1.1.2.
Table 1.1.1. Optical constants n and k at room temperature for various metals. Ref.
Laser / Wavelength [µm] CO2
CO
Nd:YAG
Diode
Excimer
9.5…11
4.96…5.7
0.992…1.064
0.8…0.826
0.248…0.257
n
k
n
k
n
k
n
k
n
k
Aluminum 25.3
89.8
8.67
48.6
1.21
10.6
2.8
8.45
0.19
2.94
91Pal
25.5
60.9
7.84
35.7
0.98
7.65
1.12
6.0
0.183 2.88
62Lan
31.2
104
8.59
48.2
1.99
7.05
30.4
4.49
15.4
83Ord
Iron 5.81
3.23
4.35
6.26
26.8
4.96
14.58
3.24
4.26
5.81
30.4
4.59
15.4
3.23
4.35
3.19
4.43
0.36
7.22
0.54
6.53
3.05
3.77
1.31
1.95
91Pal
1.01
0.88
62Lan
1.14
1.87
81Wea 85Ord
Steel 1.38
1.87
62Lan
Copper 10.8
47.5
3.81
27.5
9.89
62.4
3.07
32.8
11.6
49
3.6
26.6
8.31
63
3.26
33
0.26
5.26
1.47
1.78
91Pal
0.29
5.18
1.37
1.783
62Lan
0.12…0.26
5.07…5.26
83Ord 85Ord
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
7
Table 1.1.2. Absorption length lα for metals at different wavelengths and room temperature. lα [nm]
Laser / Wavelength [µm] CO2
CO
Nd:YAG
Diode
Excimer
9.5…11
4.96…5.7
0.992…1.064
0.8…0.826
0.248…0.257
8.9
8.2
8.1
7.5
6.7
91Pal
91Pal
91Pal
91Pal
91Pal
26
28.2
19.3
17.4
10.6
85Ord
91Pal
81Wea
81Wea
81Wea
13
15
12
12.7
11.1
85Ord
91Pal
62Lan
62Lan
91Pal
Aluminum
Iron
Copper
Table 1.1.3 summarizes absorptivity values of metals and some alloys at different wavelengths and various surface conditions found in literature. Table 1.1.3. Experimental absorptivity values of metals and some alloys at room temperature for various surface conditions. They are either obtained from measured n and k-data (I) or from direct absorptivity (II), emissivity1) (III), or reflectivity (IV) measurements. A [%]
Ref.
Laser / Wavelength [µm] CO2
CO
Nd:YAG
Diode
Excimer
9.5…11
4.96…5.7
0.992…1.064
0.8…0.826
0.248…0.257
1.41
4.13
13.05
7.6
1.65
3.33…4.03
13.5…15.3
7.55…8.0
Aluminum and Alloys Pure Al
1.15 1.05
1.42 1.7
13.23…13.57 6
12
91Pal (I) 62Lan (IV) 83Ord (I) 80Dec (IV)
1.2
89Bru (I)
2
91Yil (IV)
oxidized, 3 µm rough
5
6
72Tou (III)
oxidized, 115 µm rough
25
25
72Tou (III)
anodized
20…97
polished
2
6.25
93Ste (II)
milled
2.45
7.8…11.25
93Ste (II)
sandblasted
15.5
22.4
93Ste (II)
9…49 2
26…60
72Tou (IV)
(continued) 1
) According to Kirchhoff’s law [93Mod] absorptivity is equal to the spectral emissivity.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
8
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
Table 1.1.3 continued. A [%]
CO2
CO
Nd:YAG
Diode
Excimer
9.5…11
4.96…5.7
0.992…1.064
0.8…0.826
0.248…0.257
7.2
13.4
99Sei (II)
7.8
14.0
99Sei (II)
AlMg5Mn AlMgSi1 AlCu33
Ref.
Laser / Wavelength [µm]
3
91Fre (II)
Al alloy 6061-T6 chem. milled
1.0
1.0
5.0
9.0
72Tou (IV)
sandblasted
22.5
35.0
58.5
46.0
72Tou (IV)
2.4
6.7
35.3
8.5
35
38.5
83.8
62Lan (ns)
3.2
8.0
35.9
39.8
56.5
81Wea (I)
2.4
6.8
35.1
Iron and Alloys Pure Fe
3.5 5
91Pal (I)
85Ord (I)
33.0
47Pri (III)
33.2
95Ste (II)
35 polished
57.3
38
99Sei (II)
9
72Tou (IV)
2 µm rough
40
46
72Tou (IV)
15 µm rough
49
54
72Tou (IV)
oxidized
90.5
90
72Tou (IV)
35CD4 35NCD16
4.4
29.9
5.2
8.5
11
7
St1403/FeP04
95Ste (II)
29…31
95Ste (II) 00Sch1 (II)
38
45
99Sei (II)
Copper and Alloys Pure Copper
1.8
2.0
3.6
63.4 62.3
1.8
1.98
2.67
1.78…4.0
1.32
0.87…1.98
2.4
1.78
0.82
1.18
4.78
91Pal (I) 62Lan (IV) 83Ord (I) 85Ord (I)
0.8
89Bru (I) 4.5
5.5
11.0
17.0
72Tou (IV)
47.0
77.5
72Tou (IV)
CuZn37
5.2
5.8
99Sei (II)
CuSn6
5.3
6.2
99Sei (II)
2.52 polished oxidized
2.5
99Sei (II) 91Yil (IV)
3.0
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
9
In Fig. 1.1.1 the calculated absorptivity of iron, aluminum, and copper at room temperature for perpendicular incidence following (1.1.7) is shown. With increasing wavelength a nearly steady decrease is observed, interrupted only by some local maxima. According to (1.1.8) and (1.1.9), for light which is not normally incident the effect of the orientation of polarization becomes important. In Fig. 1.1.2 this dependence is shown for iron. For higher angles p-polarization leads to an increasing absorptivity with a maximum at the so-called Brewster angle, whereas s-polarization shows a steady decrease. The Brewster maximum is shifted towards larger angles for longer wavelengths. For circular polarization the absorptivity values correspond to the arithmetic mean value of p- and s-polarization, i.e. Ac = (A||+A⊥)/2.
II
ϕ Fig. 1.1.1. Dependence of absorptivity A on wavelength for Fe (I), Al (II) and Cu (III) at normal incidence; n, k-data from [91Pal, 81Wea].
Fig. 1.1.2. Angular dependence of absorptivity A for linearly polarized laser light for Fe at different laser wavelengths; n, k-data from [91Pal].
1.1.2.2.1 Temperature effects An early attempt to calculate absorptivity at elevated temperatures on the basis of the close relation of electronic and optical properties of the materials was made in [1903Hag]: A= 2
4 ⋅ f ⋅ ε0 , σ 0 (T )
(1.1.10)
where σ0(T) denotes the temperature-dependent dc electrical conductivity and f the optical frequency. This so-called Hagen-Rubens approximation is restricted to the long wavelength range. The limit of validity is shifted towards shorter wavelengths with decreasing conductivity. In the case of iron, (1.1.10) yields acceptable values at the wavelength of CO- and CO2-lasers, see e.g. [95Dau]. Since in metals the conductivity decreases with increasing temperature an even better coincidence of (1.1.10) with experimental data can be expected at higher temperatures such as the melting temperature. Calculations of optical constants or absorptivity as functions of temperature from elementary electron theory of metals were made by [1900Dru, 55Rob, 65Seb, 59Rob, 93Dau, 94Hue]. A short historical survey of this development is given in [93Dau]. The various approaches differ in the way by which the two mechanisms relevant for the absorption of laser radiation in metals are taken into account. First, the electrons in the conduction band are accelerated by the electric field of the wave and their movement is damped by collisions with other electrons or lattice vibrations and imperfections. Here, the interdependence of electrical conductivity and optical properties becomes obvious. This absorption mechanism is Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
10
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
often referred to Drude [1900Dru]. The acceleration can also be described as an increase of the energy of the electron respectively a lift to a higher energy level within an electronic band and, therefore, this absorption mechanism is called intraband absorption. Second, at higher excitation energies, the electron can overcome the bandgap and can be lifted from the valence band into the conduction band. This mechanism shows a resonance character [71Ash] with local maxima at definite wavelengths and is called interband absorption (see e.g. absorption peak at 800 nm for Fe in Fig. 1.1.1). Upon irradiation by a laser beam the surface temperature of a workpiece will undergo a considerable increase. Depending on the process, the surface may reach values just below melting temperature (martensitic hardening) to melting temperature (cutting, remelting) or up to vaporization temperature (welding, drilling). As a consequence, the thermophysical properties of the material, including absorptivity, will vary. With respect to a reliable description of energy coupling the temperature dependence of absorptivity has to be known. Temperature influences the intraband as well as the interband absorption. Generally speaking, the first mechanism increases with temperature because of an increase of the collision frequency of the free electrons. On the other hand, the interband absorption leads via an increase of damping due to the rise in temperature to a decrease of the maximum and to a broadening of the local absorptivity peak. At the melting point, band structures can change which can result in a vanishing of the interband absorption. Detailed investigations on the wavelength dependence of the optical constants for the liquid phase of several metals have been described in [69Mil] and [72Com]. In [69Mil] a vanishing of the 840 nm absorption peak for Al upon melting was observed, whereas in [94Hue] an intraband behavior was calculated even for temperatures far above the melting point. The temperature dependence of absorptivity for Fe and steel at 1.06 µm (Nd:YAG laser), 5 µm (CO laser) and 10 µm (CO2 laser) is shown in Fig. 1.1.3. At Nd:YAG-wavelength a negative gradient with temperature was obtained which is due to the influence of an interband transition. At higher wavelengths, absorptivity can be described by a pure intraband characteristic, which causes the positive temperature dependence. In case of Al a predominant influence of the interband absorption at 1.06 µm is not observed, which yields a positive temperature dependence for Nd:YAG and CO2-wavelength up to the melting point, as shown in Fig. 1.1.4. 10
35 30
8
25 6
20
4
15 10
2
5 0
200
600 1000 1400 Temperature T [°C]
1800
Fig. 1.1.3. Measured temperature dependence of absorptivity A at Nd:YAG- (squares), CO- (triangles) and CO2-wavelength (circles) of polished iron (I, V) and polished steel 35NCD16 (II, III, IV); exp. data [95Ste].
0 0
100
200 300 400 500 Temperature T [°C]
600
700
Fig. 1.1.4. Measured temperature dependence of absorptivity A at Nd:YAG- (squares) and CO2wavelength (circles) for polished Al 99.5; exp. data [95Ste].
The temperature dependence of absorptivity for alloys is influenced by the fact that, even at low alloying contents, the collision frequency of the “free” electrons is changed. It is expected that the interband absorption is less influenced than the intraband part. At higher alloying grade the band structure is changed distinctively and, hence, a simplified theoretical calculation of the absorptivity cannot describe the experimental findings very well [93Dau] (see Fig. 1.1.5). Calculated temperature dependences for different steels and Al-alloys reveal that, in case of a low alloying grade, absorptivity is not remarkably
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
11
influenced. For higher alloying grade (see Fig. 1.1.5, stainless steel 304) a coincidence of experimental and calculated data could not be obtained. An extension of Drude’s theory was performed in [76Wie] being in good coincidence with experimental values of stainless steel at wavelengths longer than 10 µm. Towards shorter wavelengths an increasing deviation was observed. In Fig. 1.1.6 the calculated temperature dependence for pure Al and some alloys at 1.06 µm and 10.6 µm wavelength is shown. For the solid as well as for the liquid phases the absorptivity of alloys is increased compared to the pure material. 15 c b a
13 Absorptivity A [%]
Absorptivity A [%]
15
10
5
11 9 7 5
c b a
II
3 1
0 0
600 200 400 800 Temperature T [°C]
1000
Fig. 1.1.5. Temperature dependence of absorptivity A at 10.6 µm; experimental (symbols) [90Ste] and calculated (lines) [93Dau] values for Fe (I), steel Ck45 (II), steel 35NCD16 (III) and stainless steel 304 (IV).
I 0
200 400 600 Temperature T [°C]
800
Fig. 1.1.6. Temperature dependence of absorptivity A at 10.6 µm (I) and 1.06 µm (II) for Al (a), AlMgSi1 (b) and AlMg5 (c), calculated data [95Dau].
Experimental and theoretical data for the temperature dependence of absorptivity of Al, Fe, Cu and steel of various authors are shown in Tables 1.1.4 and 1.1.5. The figures for the temperature dependence (∆A/∆T) represent a linear fit of the measured or calculated dependences and merely give a rough indication of the change in absorptivity for the indicated temperature range. The experimental results agree reasonably with each other for all materials shown. In [91Yil] values for Al and Cu have been obtained, which deviate – due to the influence of oxidation during the experiment – about one order from that of other authors. Theoretical models yielded values, which are in agreement with each other and with experimental values in case of CO2 wavelength. For Nd:YAG wavelength the values spread slightly. The only exception is the approach in [72Uji] considering a Drude term with a temperature dependence of the electron-phonon collision; for Al it yields a strong deviation from other theoretical and experimental data (except for Nd:YAG values in [91Yil]).
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
12
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
Table 1.1.4. Experimental results for the temperature dependence of absorptivity. Material
T-range
∆A/∆T
[°C]
[% / 100°C]
CO2
25…630
CO2
Laser
Surface
Method
Ref.
0.11
polished
calorimetric
93Ste
25…544
1.55
polished to 2.5 µm
reflectometric
91Yil
CO2
25…660
0.28
polished
ellipsometric
89Bru
Nd:YAG
25…630
0.16
polished
calorimetric
93Ste
CO2
25…1200
0.875
polished
calorimetric
95Ste
CO2
600…950
1.036
not specified
not specified
62Lan
Nd:YAG
25…700
–0.457
polished
calorimetric
95Ste
Nd:YAG
1200…1580
–0.526
2 µm RMS
emissivity
72Tou
CO2
25…550
0.27
polished
reflectometric
76Wie
CO2
25…1000
0.3
polished
calorimetric
95Ste
CO2
25…1000
0.55
polished
calorimetric
95Ste
CO
25…1000
0.65
polished
calorimetric
95Ste
Aluminum
Iron
Steel SS304 35NCD16
Ck45
Nd:YAG
25…1000
–0.35
polished
calorimetric
95Ste
CO2
25…1100
0.36
polished
calorimetric
93Ste
Nd:YAG
25…1100
–1.05
polished
calorimetric
93Ste
CO2
25…790
3.27
polished to 2.5 µm
reflectometric
91Yil
CO2
25…1100
0.16
polished
ellipsometric
89Bru
Nd:YAG
1160…1456
0.0005
liquid
ellipsometric
90Kri
Copper
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
13
Table 1.1.5. Theoretical results of the temperature dependence of absorptivity. Material
Laser
T-range
∆A/∆T
[°C]
[% / 100°C]
25…660
1.27
Model
Remarks
Ref.
Aluminum CO2
Nd:YAG
25…660
3.6
CO2
25…660
0.3
CO2
Tm…1600
0.11
Drude + temp.dep. el.-phonon coll. frequency
72Uji
72Uji good agreement with [95Dau, 89Bru] and [84Arn]
94Hue
94Hue
Nd:YAG
25…660
0.38
94Hue
Nd:YAG
Tm…1600
0.235
94Hue
CO2
25…Tm
0.3
CO2
Tm…1900
0.13
Nd:YAG
25…Tm
0.455
95Dau
Tm…1900
0.23
95Dau
CO2
25…660
0.326
CO2
660…1600
0.246
CO2
0…700
0.638
see above
95Dau
CO2
700…Tm
0.439
see above
95Dau
temp.-dep. Drude + temp.-dep. interband absorption
95Dau
95Dau
Drude + temp.dep. conductivity
84Arn 84Arn
Iron
CO2
Tm…3000
0.1
see above
95Dau
Nd:YAG
0…700
–0.98
see above
95Dau
Nd:YAG
700…Tm
0.082
see above
95Dau
Nd:YAG
Tm…3000
0.18
see above
95Dau
35NCD16
CO2
25…1000
0.687
see above
95Dau
35NCD16
CO
25…1000
0.547
see above
95Dau
35NCD16
Nd:YAG
25…1000
–0.57
see above
95Dau
Ck45
CO2
25…1000
0.698
see above
95Dau
Ck45
CO
25…1000
0.579
see above
95Dau
Ck45
Nd:YAG
25…600
–0.586
see above
95Dau
CO2
25…1000
0.39
see above
84Arn
CO2
25…1100
0.9
see above
72Uji
Nd:YAG
25…1100
2.45
Steel
Copper
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
72Uji
14
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
1.1.2.2.2 Chemical effects In most practical applications of laser processing, materials are not pure elements with smooth and clean surfaces but alloys with oxidized and, in general, rough surfaces. The more the technical surface conditions deviate from the physically clean ones, the less information about optical constants is available. In literature only few investigations are concerned with the influence of oxidation as the most important chemical process modifying surface properties and absorptivity. Oxidation processes can be divided into two groups, the natural oxidation and the laser or temperature induced oxidation. Metals kept in air are always covered with a so-called native oxide layer with a thickness of 10…50 nm [97Nan]. On the other hand, as oxidation is a time as well as a temperature-controlled process, with elevated temperatures caused by e.g. direct laser irradiation or heat conduction from the interaction zone, the oxide layer grows faster. As reported in [90Pro] for copper foils and steel, oxidation starts when the temperature is high enough for activation. Absorption then increases strongly and, moreover, shows an “oscillatory” character (see Fig. 1.1.7). This effect can be explained as follows. According to [90Pro, 97Nan] there is a direct effect of oxide layer thickness ξ on absorptivity due to interference of the incident and reflected beams at the metal-oxide interface. The change in absorptivity with oxide layer thickness dA/dξ can have a negative as well as a positive sign, which results in “oscillations”. Oxide layers in most cases do not consist of just one single oxide type. The oxide layer on copper is made up of two components, CuO/Cu2O, whereas on iron a three-component layer of FeO/Fe3O4/Fe2O3 is present. Data for optical constants of these oxides are given in [91Pal, 79Tan, 82Kar] and for emissivity values in [80Ise, 79Neu]. In [95Ste] the change in absorptivity during the growth of oxide layers on a ground steel (35NCD16) by heating the sample with a CO2-laser in atmospheric ambience is described. Applying simultaneously an Nd:YAG- and a CO2-probe laser, oscillations have been observed. In [94Jun] a detailed description of the influence of oxidation in the laser hardening process of C60 steel is given. A review of the interdependence of oxide formation on metal surfaces and roughness is given in [62Eub]. 1200
Cu
Absorptivity A [%]
0.6 0.5
1000 T
0.4
800 A
600
0.3
400
0.2
200
0.1 68
70 72 74 Irradiation time t [s]
Temperature T [°C]
0.7
Fig. 1.1.7. Influence of oxidation on absorptivity of Cu at CO2-wavelength [90Pro].
1.1.2.2.3 Roughness effects Although roughness of surfaces plays an important role in laser materials processing, not much information is found concerning this effect. A theoretical investigation on the influence of random and regular roughness for cases when the Root Mean Square (rms) of the roughness is much smaller than the wavelength of the laser radiation is given in [82Els]. The contribution of the so-called Roughness-Induced Absorption (RIA) is compared to the intrinsic absorptivity of the material. For p-polarization the RIA for
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
15
randomly rough surfaces contributes to 1…2 % of the intrinsic value whereas for periodically rough surfaces it can reach the same order as the intrinsic value. The absorptivity of p-polarization is characterized by peaks following sin ϕ = 1 – N λ/∆, where ∆ is the peak-to-peak periodicity of the roughness. This indicates the stimulation of surface plasmon2) resonances which was described by various authors [82Els, 82Bar]. In case the wavelength is of the order of or below the dimensions of characteristic surface structures, multiple reflection respectively multiple absorption within such a groove or depression occurs which increases energy coupling. A model calculating the absorptivity of a depression considering multiple reflection of radiation is presented in [68Aga] and yields
A=
RS 1 1 + ( − 1) Ai
(1.1.11)
with Ai being the intrinsic absorptivity of the material (the value for a smooth surface), RS the surface roughness factor, which is defined by the ratio of the surface of a depression and its projected area. For a single cavity at given width the absorptivity increases with RS, i.e. with increasing depth of the depression. A survey of absorptivities (which are according to Kirchhoff’s law equal to emissivities) in dependence of roughness calculated using (1.1.11) for various forms of cavities (cylindrical, conical, hemispherical) is given in [68Aga, 79Neu]. Some experimental results of absorptivity of randomly rough samples of steel and aluminum alloys are shown in Figs. 1.1.8 and 1.1.9. A tendency of increasing absorptivity with increasing roughness can be recognized with peaks occurring around particular values of roughness. Comparing the absorptivity of steel and Al-alloys in Fig. 1.1.9 the latter is characterized by a stronger influence of roughness, which is in accordance to [80Loe] showing a stronger influence of roughness for metals with low absorptivity. A varying influence of roughness depending on temperature is reported in [95Ste] and shown in Fig. 1.1.10.
Absorptivity A [%]
Absorptivity A [%]
60 55 50 45 40 35 II 30 I 25 20 15 10 5 0 0.5
III III III
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 Roughness Ra [µm]
3.5
4.0
Fig. 1.1.8. Dependence of absorptivity A on roughness Ra (average peak to valley height) for 35NCD16 at Nd:YAG- (squares), CO- (triangles) and CO2wavelength (circles), polished (I), ground (II) and milled (III) samples; exp. data [95Ste].
2
50 40 30 20 10 0
2
4
10 12 6 8 Roughness Rz [µm]
16
Fig. 1.1.9. Dependence of absorptivity A on roughness Rz (peak to valley height) at 808 nm for steel St1403 (squares), AlMg0.6Si1.2 (full circles) and AlMg5Mn (open circles); exp. data [99Sei]; all samples ground.
) Plasmons are collective longitudinal vibration states of an electron gas.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
14
16
1.1.2 Energy coupling
Absorptivity A [%]
50 40
[Ref. p. 62
VI V
30 IV 20 10
III
Fig. 1.1.10. Temperature dependence of absorptivity A for Ck45 at Nd:YAG- (squares) and CO2wavelength (circles); polished (I, IV), ground (II, V) and sandblasted surfaces (III, VI); exp. data [93Ste].
II I 0
200
400 600 800 1000 1200 Temperature T [°C]
The influence of roughness on the dependence of absorptivity at λ = 808 nm on the angle of incidence was investigated in [98Sei] for steel and aluminum samples. Even polished samples with only a few remaining scratches showed a reduced or less pronounced angular dependence compared to the one calculated with given n, k data. This can be explained by the fact that on the wall of a depression the angle of incidence and the polarization state (s- or p-polarization) differ from the macroscopically adjusted one. A manifold of angles and polarizations occur which lead to an averaging effect of the polarization influence. Theoretical considerations on the influence of roughness on polarization effects are given for example in [83Pop], showing a decrease of the angular dependence with increasing roughness.
1.1.2.3 Optical properties of ceramics Some data of optical properties of pure ceramics can e.g. be found in [85Pal] and are summarized in Tables 1.1.6 and 1.1.7. The reflectivities obtained from these data are typically much lower than those of metals. As can be seen from Fig. 1.1.11 its value for parallel polarization reaches, in contrast to metals, almost zero at the Brewster angle. Another important difference compared to metallic materials is found concerning the absorption lengths which are usually much larger for ceramics. Figure 1.1.12 shows the dependence of this optical penetration depth on wavelength for two ceramic materials. It is remarkable that in the spectral range between 0.5 and 10 µm the penetration depth can be up to three orders of magnitude larger than the wavelength. Table 1.1.6. Optical constants n, k at room temperature. Laser
Ref.
CO2 n
CO k
n
Nd:YAG k
n
Diode k
n
Excimer k
n
k
2.598
3.16
0.259
91Pal
2.08
2.278
0.0048
91Pal
SiC-crystal 0.0593
1.21
2.467 8.75×10–4
non-crystalline Si3N4
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
17
Table 1.1.7. Absorption length for ceramics at different wavelengths and room temperature. lα [nm]
Laser CO2
Ref. CO
AlN (Aluminum nitride)
Nd:YAG
Diode
208 000
182 000
Excimer
99Rai
SiC crystal
31
455
76
91Pal
4028
91Pal 99Rai
Si3N4 non crystalline technical
40 000…160 000
37 000…130 000
I
I
II
Fig. 1.1.11. Angular dependence of the Fresnel reflectivity of Si3N4 at different wavelengths. For 0.5 µm wavelength both parallel (||) and perpendicular (⊥) polarizations are shown, for all other wavelengths only parallel polarization. Calculation based on pure material data [85Pal].
Fig. 1.1.12. Optical penetration depth of SiC and Si3N4 (pure materials) in dependence on the wavelength, derived from experimental data in [85Pal].
For a detailed description of the energy coupling of ceramics, besides the absorptivity of pure crystalline material, the structure of the ceramic has to be taken into account. Technical ceramics consist of grains embedded in a glass phase both having different optical properties. Radiation thus is multiply scattered at the grain boundaries as well as at impurities. This results in smaller absorption lengths compared to those in pure materials. Hence, the scattered fraction in (1.1.6) can no longer be neglected. Scattering therefore decreases transparency and penetration depth but does not necessarily increase absorption. The reflectivity and the penetration depth of some technical ceramics are shown in Fig. 1.1.13 [99Rai]. The values are measured at low intensity and ambient temperature with a Fourier spectrograph. The various species of Si3N4 differ in grain size and sinter-additives. Compared to the values of reflection and penetration depth shown in Fig. 1.1.12, a marked reduction in penetration depth is observed.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
α
18
a
b
Fig. 1.1.13. (a) Reflectivity and (b) penetration depth of some technical ceramic materials measured at ambient temperature [99Rai]. Sinter-additives (MgO for 1225 whereas Al2O3+Y2O3 for 1253 and 1254) and mean grain size (0.59 µm, 0.82 µm and 0.36 µm for 1225, 1253 and 1254, respectively) vary for the three different Si3N4 ceramics.
These values, measured at room temperature, are only valid and relevant at the beginning of the heating process. At process temperature the optical properties can be totally different. Optical properties such as transmission and reflection at high temperature are reported in [97Gar]: In the case of AIN reflectivity and optical penetration depth decrease with increasing temperature, whereas the values for Si 3N4 are nearly constant over a broad range of temperatures (see Fig. 1.1.14). At a certain temperature, a steep increase in reflection is observed. It has been shown that this temperature corresponds to the value where decomposition of the ceramic starts [99Rai].
Fig. 1.1.14. High-temperature reflectivity and penetration depth of technical AlN and Si3N4 ceramic samples in air atmosphere [97Gar].
1.1.2.4 Scattering and absorption by particles In most practical cases of material processing the laser beam propagates through a more or less well defined “atmosphere” above the workpiece before it reaches the solid or liquid surface. Depending on the process itself as well as on the way it is being conducted, this atmosphere consists of e.g. pure gas, gas mixtures or gases containing particles. These particles can be produced by condensation of clusters within a plasma plume [94Kar, 96Sch1, 98Cal, 98Luk], by melt expulsion [97May], phase explosion [96Kel] or can be provided to the interaction zone by an external flow of powder, e.g. in the case of laser cladding. Here, the influence of particles will be reviewed.
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
19
If multiple scattering is negligible the intensity of a beam is exponentially attenuated according to a relation similar to (1.1.3) with a coefficient resulting from the absorption and scattering in all directions by the particles. Although both processes occur simultaneously, one or the other may dominate, depending on the density of particles and their properties like chemical composition, size, shape and orientation, on the ambient atmosphere and on the properties of the incident beam. The extinction is the combined effect of absorption and scattering, the extinction coefficient αext is expressed as the sum of absorption coefficient αabs and scattering coefficient αsca :
αext = α abs + αsca = N (Cabs + Csca ) = NCext
(1.1.12)
with N denoting the number of particles per unit volume. Equation (1.1.12) also defines Cabs and Csca , the absorption and scattering cross sections, and Cext the resulting “effective” extinction cross section. The cross sections indicate the amount of energy absorbed or scattered by a particle per unit irradiation intensity and area. These cross sections are normalized to the geometrical cross section G of the particle, generally, which leads to dimensionless values:
Qext =
Cext C C , Qabs = abs , Qsca = sca , G G G
(1.1.13)
which are called the efficiency factors for extinction, absorption and scattering and indicate the absorption and scattering capability of an irradiated particle. The efficiency factors of spherical particles of arbitrary size and refractive index can be calculated by the Mie theory [57Hul, 83Boh]. They depend on two parameters: the complex refractive index n~ and the size parameter x x=
⋅d , λ
(1.1.14)
where d is the diameter of the particles and λ is the wavelength of the beam. The intensity of the scattered light I at a large distance R from the particle must be proportional to the intensity of the incident light I0 and R–2: I = I0
λ2 F (θ , ϕ ) , 4 2R2
(1.1.15)
where θ is the scattering angle measured from the forward direction of the light and ϕ is an azimuth angle. The dimensionless function F(θ,ϕ) defines the angular distribution of the scattered light and can be written for the special case of incident linearly polarized light and spherical particles:
F (θ ,ϕ ) = S 2 (θ ) cos 2 ϕ + S1 (θ ) sin 2 ϕ , 2
2
(1.1.16)
where Si(θ ) are the amplitude functions for the two lateral electric field components. For spherical particles the two complex amplitude functions depend only on the scattering angle θ and are functions of the size parameters x and the complex refractive index n~ [57Hul]. The efficiency factors can be calculated from:
Qsca =
π
1 dθ x 2 ∫0
{ S (θ ) 1
4 Qext = 2 Re{S (0)} . x
2
+ S 2 (θ )
2
} sin θ
,
(1.1.17)
(1.1.18)
For forward scattering the amplitude functions have the same value, i.e. S1(0) = S2(0) = S(0). Using the amplitude function F(θ ) = 1/2{⎜S1(θ )⎜2 + ⎜S2(θ )⎜2} the angular distribution of unpolarized light scattered by a particle can be calculated as well. In Fig. 1.1.15 examples of F(θ) for different size parameters according to [94Han] are shown; the incident light is at 180°. It is seen that the angular de-
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
20
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
pendence of the scattering is a strong function of the particle size parameter x. The angular dependence of the scattering becomes very strongly forward-directed for the range of x >> 1. This suggests that strong forward scattering of laser radiation may occur during laser cladding with blown particles, where powders with typically d > 40 µm are applied. Small particles, which appear during penetration welding, will scatter laser radiation away from the beam axis and in some cases, back towards the laser [94Han]. 400 300 200
120
90
60
150
x = 5.928
30
100 0 100 200
180
0
330
210
300 400
240
120
270
90
300
60
x = 1.186
60
30
0
180
330
210 240
120
270
90
300
x = 0.593 60
0.075 150
30
0.050
150
30
0.025 180
0
0
180
0
0.025
1 2
90
150
0.100
1 0
0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 1.25
120
x = 1.778
3 2
1.25 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0
330
210
3 240
270
300
0.050 0.075 0.100
330
210 240
270
300
Fig. 1.1.15. Angular distribution F(θ) of the light scattered by Fe-particles at λ = 10.6 µm for four different size parameters according to [94Han].
For particular values of the size parameter x and the refractive index n~ , the Mie theory can be simplified. In Fig. 1.1.16 the two main limiting cases are shown. For very small particles (x << 1), the Rayleigh approximation can be applied and the power of the scattered light occurs in terms of order d 6 . For large particles (x >> 1) the power of the scattered light is proportional to the geometrical cross section of the particle and the geometrical-optics approach can be applied. In between these two limiting cases the more complex Mie theory has to be applied [87Ruc].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
~d
21
2
log ( PS )
Mie theory Rayleigh approximation
~d
geometrical optics approximation
6
small
medium
Fig. 1.1.16. Power of the scattered light PS =
very large
∫ I dA versus A
particle diameter [87Ruc].
log ( d )
For welding and cutting with Nd:YAG- and CO2-lasers the particles fulfill the conditions underlying the Rayleigh approximation. In that case the absorption and scattering cross sections are given by [83Boh]
⎧⎪ m 2 − 1 ⎡ 4 x 3 n~ 3 ⎛ m 2 − 1 ⎞⎤ ⎫⎪ 1 ⎟⎟⎥ ⎬ ⇒ Cabs ∝ , Im ⎜⎜ 2 Cabs = d 2 x n~ Im⎨ 2 ⎢1 + λ 3 ⎪⎩ m + 2 ⎣ ⎝ m + 2 ⎠⎦ ⎪⎭ C sca
2 d 2 4~4 m2 −1 = x n 3 m2 + 2
2
⇒ C sca ∝
1 λ4
(1.1.19)
(1.1.20)
with the relative refractive index m
n~ , m= ~ nM
(1.1.21)
where n~ and n~M are the refractive indices of the particle and the medium, respectively. The scattering cross section in (1.1.20) is proportional to d 6 as shown in Fig. 1.1.16. If (m2–1)/(m2+2) is only weakly dependent on wavelength (which is not true e.g. for metallic particles) then the radiation scattered by a sphere under the condition of small x is proportional to 1/λ4. This approximation can be used for sufficiently small spheres with a refractive index not strongly dependent on wavelength over the region of interest [83Boh]. As can be seen from (1.1.19) and (1.1.20), scattering is increasing stronger than absorption for decreasing wavelengths. Depending on the properties of the particles the dominance of one mechanism over the other can change. For particle sizes in a region in between the two limiting cases, Rayleigh and geometrical optics, rather complex formulas have to be applied. Near the transition to the geometrical-optics approach the Mie theory yields the efficiency factor for extinction (the limiting value)
Qext = 2 ,
(1.1.22)
which corresponds to a cross section twice as large as its geometrical area. This paradox that, according to the Mie theory, a large particle removes twice the energy that is incident on it, is a consequence of some simplifying assumptions [83Boh]. Geometrical optics leads to value of exactly Qext = 1. In the process of laser cladding and alloying the laser beam may interact with a stream of powder in some region above the workpiece surface. This interaction leads to an attenuation of the energy flux
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
22
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
within the beam, a change in absorptivity as particles come to lie on the surface and to a heating of the particles due to the absorbed part of energy before they hit the workpiece surface. For the process of laser cladding and alloying depending on the particle diameter, refractive index and wavelength the Mie theory or geometrical-optics approach can be applied. The efficiency factors for Fe and Cu particles are calculated e.g. in [89Lag] according to the Mie theory. The considered wavelength is 10.6 µm and the powder diameters are between 5 and 115 µm. With this data one can estimate the extinction during the laser cladding process where usually powder diameters are between 40 and 150 µm. The assumed refractive index for Fe is n~ = 5.95 – 32i and for Cu n~ = 9 – 65.9i, respectively. As shown in Table 1.1.8 the scattering at Fe and Cu particles is dominating over absorption, in this case. Table 1.1.8. Efficiency factors for absorption and scattering for Fe and Cu particles at λ = 10.6 µm [89Lag]. Iron (Fe) d [µm] 5
15
25
35
45
55
65
75
85
95
105
115
Qabs
0.0468 0.0377 0.0350 0.0330 0.0330 0.0326 0.0322 0.0320 0.0318 0.0317 0.0316 0.0316
Qsca
2.2311 2.1534 2.1049 2.0779 2.0617 2.0505 2.0435 2.0377 2.0328 2.0290 2.0270 2.0270
Copper (Cu) d [µm] 5
15
25
35
45
55
65
75
85
95
105
115
Qabs
0.0169 0.0135 0.0126 0.0121 0.0119 0.0326 0.0116 0.0115 0.0114 0.0114 0.0113 0.0113
Qsca
2.1810 2.1393 2.0953 2.0718 2.0568 2.0505 2.0409 2.0358 2.0319 2.0287 2.0271 2.0271
1.0
1.0
0.9
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6 0.5
a
Transmission T [%]
Transmission T [%]
Using the extinction factors for Fe following from Table 1.1.8 the transmission through a powder stream applied using a lateral nozzle was calculated in [93Gas], the results are presented in Fig. 1.1.17a. In Fig. 1.1.17b, the transmission through a stellite powder stream is seen which has been calculated according to [92Mar] by a geometrical approach. The attenuated power is calculated by assuming that the laser beam and powder stream are two intersecting cylinders. The results show that the attenuation is proportional to the powder feed rate and inversely proportional to the powder size. One can see in Fig. 1.1.17 that both methods yield similar results of the transmission.
40
5 g/min 10 g/min 15 g/min 20 g/min 25 g/min
100 60 80 Particle diameter d [µm]
0.8
0.7
0.6 0.5 40
120
b
5 g/min 10 g/min 15 g/min 20 g/min 25 g/min
100 60 80 Particle diameter d [µm]
120
Fig. 1.1.17. Dependence of the transmission through a powder gas stream on the particle size and powder feed rate at λ = 10.6 µm by using (a) Fe powder [93Gas] and (b) stellite powder [92Mar].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
23
In [03Kin] and [96Haa] approaches were made for studying the absorption of particles, primarily. Starting from the described dependence of the Fresnel absorption on the angle of incidence and the orientation of the polarization of the laser light in Sect. 1.1.2.1, the average absorptivity of a sphere has been calculated in [03Kin]. For the calculation it has been assumed that a collimated laser beam is incident on the spherical particles. Taking into account the angle of incidence at the surface of the sphere, the total absorptivity of the sphere can be calculated. In Table 1.1.9 the absorptivity of a plane surface for perpendicular incidence of the beam is compared to the average absorptivity of a sphere. It can be seen, that the absorptivity is higher in the case of the sphere than at a plane surface [03Kin]. Table 1.1.9. Calculated absorptivity of Fe and Al for wavelengths of 1.064 µm and 10.6 µm [03Kin]. Wavelength
1.064 µm (Nd:YAG)
10.6 µm (CO2)
Substrate
Fe
Fe
Al
Al
Temperature [°C]
25
1227
25
1227
25
1227
25
1227
Absorptivity on a plane surface [%]
36.0
31.2
5.7
11.3
3.3
12.1
2.3
5.6
Absorptivity on a sphere [%]
37.7
33.1
6.6
13
4.1
14.4
3.0
7.0
Percentile changing [%]
4.9
6.1
15.6
15.6
25.6
19.0
28.3
24.8
In [96Haa] the absorption characteristic of a metal powder bed under CO2-laser irradiation was investigated. Calorimetric absorption measurements were carried out for different powder materials Al, Cu, Fe and Ti3Al with a particle size range between 75 µm and 200 µm. The experimental results showed that no dependence between absorption and particle size could be observed. The measured absorptivity at low laser intensities of the order of 1 to10 W/cm² ranged between 28 % and 43 %. The Ti3Al powders lead to the highest absorptivity, the Al powders to the lowest. As laser intensity was increased (laser power up to 230 W), the Cu and Fe powders showed strong signs of oxidation when irradiated in air (Fig. 1.1.18). Along with the oxidation, absorptivity of these powders rose up to 70 %. Neither oxidation nor increased absorptivity was observed when helium was used as shielding gas. 100
100
Copper
Iron 90
80
Absorptivity A [%]
80
Absorptivity A [%]
90
air argon helium
70 60 50
70 60 50
40
40
30
30 20 0
20 0
a
50
100 200 150 Laser power P [W]
250
b
air argon helium
50
100 200 150 Laser power P [W]
250
Fig. 1.1.18. Absorptivity at 10.6 µm versus laser power for (a) Fe and (b) Cu particles with a particle size < 100 µm [96Haa].
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
24
1.1.2 Energy coupling
[Ref. p. 62
1.1.2.5 Non-linear absorption In the previous sections only “linear” absorption has been considered where the index of refraction is basically independent of laser intensity. With increasing electric field in the material also non-linear absorption mechanisms may become important. In this case the energy coupling will be a function of intensity. Two basic non-linear absorption mechanisms are impact ionization and photoionization like multiphoton and tunnel ionization. Impact ionization is the inverse process of Auger recombination. Collisons of high energetic free or conduction electrons with valence electrons can yield additional low-energetic conduction electrons. In a sufficiently high electric field these electrons will then be accelerated again such that upon the next collision the process can be repeated. This will increase the density of conduction electrons exponentially if losses due to recombination can be compensated. The resulting electron avalanche leads to a heavily absorbing microplasma and finally to an explosive material damage known as “optical breakdown” even in the case of initially weakly absorbing dielectrics. Impact ionization is almost independent of laser wavelength [87All1]. Such an avalanche is only possible if initially a sufficient density of seed electrons is available. For metals this is always true whereas in dielectrics conduction electrons have to be generated first. Such seed electrons can be provided e.g. either by energetically unfavorable but statistically possible highly excited electrons or by defects and impurities [98Shi]. This would result in a stochastic nature of material damage concerning both threshold and localization, which, in fact, has been observed experimentally [97Liu]. Another possible mechanism for seed electron generation in dielectrics is multiphoton absorption. Due to the lack of conduction electrons, insulators can only absorb photons by the electronic system at deep temperatures if the provided energy is larger than the bandgap. For typical laser wavelengths this is only possible if several photons are simultaneously absorbed. Since the probability for this process decreases rapidly with the number of necessary photons, multiphoton absorption is only important for very high intensities. In contrast to impact ionization it shows a strong dependence on laser wavelength and is nonstochastic. Furthermore, this absorption mechanism is basically instantaneous in time whereas typical build-up times for electron avalanches in insulators are of the order 0.1…1 ns [87All1]. For pulse lengths longer than about 1…10 ps, impact ionization alone is sufficient to explain the onset of material damage in insulators and plasma breakdown [99Tie, 96Stu, 98Ret, 96Du, 93Maz]. If pulse lengths are too short to induce optical breakdown by impact ionization from background carriers alone, multiphoton absorption can provide the necessary additional seed electrons. This behavior is confirmed in Fig. 1.1.19, which shows calculated values of fluence where material damage occurs (this threshold is a measure for the onset of effective absorption) as a function of pulse duration together with the contributions of impact and photoionization only. The observation of significant multiphoton absorption can be shifted towards shorter pulse lengths for higher background carrier density or more frequent electron collisions [99Tie, 96Du]. These theoretical predictions are in good agreement with experimental observations as shown in Fig. 1.1.20 for SiO2. For longer pulses the ablation threshold is roughly proportional to the square root of the pulse duration, which has also been predicted by simplified models [95Nie].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes impact ne = 1015 cm-3 impact ne = 2.2 × 1012 cm-3 impact ne = 10 8 cm -3 multiphoton total
Fluence [J cm-2 ]
10
1 10 -14
10 -11 10 -13 10 -12 Pulse duration tH [s]
10 -10
Fig. 1.1.19. Damage threshold as a function of laser pulse length τH (measured at FWHM) for different background electron densities ne in SiO2 [99Tie]. Contributions of impact and multiphoton ionization have been denoted by symbols and dashed line, respectively.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
100 Fluence [J cm-2 ]
Ref. p. 62]
25
Du et al. (800 nm) Stuart et al. (1053 nm) Lenzner et al. (800 nm) Tien et al. (800 nm)
10
1 10 -15 10 -14 10 -13 10 -12 10 -11 10 -10 10 - 9 10 - 8 Pulse duration tH [s]
Fig. 1.1.20. Experimental results for damage threshold in SiO2 taken from various references [99Tie, 96Stu, 96Du, 98Len].
62
References for 1.1
References for 1.1 (1/2) 1900Dru
Drude, P.: Ann. Physik 1 (1900) 566.
1903Hag Hagen, E., Rubens, H.: Ann. Physik 11 (1903) 873. 47Pri
Price, D.J.: Proc. Phys. Soc. London 47 (1947) 131.
55Rob
Roberts, S.: Phys. Rev. 100 (1955) 1667.
57Hul
Hulst, H. van de: Light Scattering by Small Particles. New York: Wiley, 1957.
59Rob
Roberts, S.: Phys. Rev. 114(1) (1959) 104.
62Eub 62Lan
Eubanks, A.G., Moore, D.G., Pennington, W.A.: J. Electrochem. Soc. 109 (1962) 211. Landolt, H., Börnstein, R.: 6. Aufl., Berlin: Springer, 1962.
65Seb
Seban, R.A.: J. Heat Transfer (1965) 173.
68Aga
Agababov, S.G: High Temperatures – High Pressures 6(1) (1968) 76.
69Mil
Miller J.C.: Phil. Mag. 20 (1969) 1115.
71Ash
Ashcroft, N.W., Sturm, K.: Phys. Rev. 3 (1971) 1898.
72Com 72Tou 72Uji
Comins, N.R.: Phil. Mag. 25(4) (1972) 817. Touloukian, Y.S., DeWitt, D.P.: The Macmillan Company, New: IFI/Plenum, 1972. Ujihara, K.: J. Appl. Phys. 43 (1972) 5.
75Jac
Jackson, J.D.: Classical Electrodynamics, 2nd ed., New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons, 1975.
76Wie
Wieting, T., Schriempf, T.: J. Appl. Phys. 47 (1976) 4009.
79Neu 79Tan
Wörner, B., Neuer, G.: High Temperatures – High Pressures 11(4) (1979) 383. Tanaka, T.: Jap. J. Appl. Phys. 18(6) (1979) 1043.
80Dec
Decker, D.L., Hodgkin, V.A.: Laser Induced Damage in Optical Materials 1980, Proceedings of a Symposium (NBS-SP-620), Washington, DC: NBS (1981) 190. Isetti, C., Nannei, E.: High Temperature 12 (1980) 307. Löfving, S.: Appl. Phys. Lett. 36(8) (1980) 632.
80Ise 80Loe 81Wea
Weaver, J.H., Krafka, C., Lynch, D.W., Koch, E.E.: Karlsruhe: Fachinformationszentrum Energie – Physik – Mathematik, 1981.
82Bar
Barbarino, S., Grasso, F., Guerriera, G., Musumeci, F., Scordino, A., Giulitti, D., Lucchesi, M.: Lettre al Nuovo Cimento 33(13) (1982) 417. Elson, J.M., Sung, C.C.: Appl. Opt. 21(8) (1982) 1496. Karlsson, B., Ribbing, C., Roos, A., Karlsson, T.H.: Physica Scripta 25 (1982) 826.
82Els 82Kar
References for 1.1 83Boh
63
83Pop
Bohren, C.F., Huffmann, D.R.: Absorption and Scattering of Light by Small Particles, New York: Wiley, 1983. Ordal, M.A., Long, L.L., Bell, R.J., Bell, S.E., Bell, R.R., Alexander, R.W., Jr., Ward, C.A.: Appl. Opt. 22(7) (1983) 1099. Popova, O.R.: High Temperature 21(2) (1983) 199.
84Arn
Arnold, G.: Appl. Opt. 23(9) (1984) 1434.
85Ord
Ordal, M.A., Bell, R.J., Alexander, R.W., Jr., Long, L.L., Querry, M.R.: Appl. Opt. 24(24) (1985) 4493. Palik, E.D.: Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids, Vol. 1, Orlando, FL: Academic Press, 1985.
83Ord
85Pal 86Bor
Born, M., Wolf, E.: Principles of Optics, 6th ed., Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1986.
87All1
Allmen, M. van: Laser-Beam Interactions with Materials, Materials Science 2, Berlin: Springer, 1987. Ruck, B.: Laser-Doppler-Anemometrie: Eine berührungslose optische Strömungsgeschwindigkeitsmeßtechnik, Stuttgart: AT-Fachverlag, 1987.
87Ruc 89Bru 89Lag
Brückner, M., Schäfer, J., Uhlenbusch, J.: J. Appl. Phys. 66(3) (1989) 1326. Lagain, P.: Contribution experimentale aux traitements de surface par laser avec apport de poudre, Ph.D. thesis, Université Aix-Marseille, France, 1989.
90Kri
Krishnan, S., Hansen, G.P., Hauge, R.H., Margrave, J.L.: High Temperature Science 29 (1990) 17. Prokhorov, A.M., Konov, V.I., Ursu, I., Mihailescu, I.N.: Laser heating of metals, Bristol: Hilger, 1990. Stern, G.: Proc. 3rd European Conf. on Laser Treatment of Materials ECLAT '90 (Erlangen, Germany). In: Bergmann, H., Kupfer, R. (eds.): Coburg: Sprechsaal Publ. Group (1990) 25.
90Pro 90Ste 91Fre 91Pal 91Yil
Frenk, A., Hoadley, A., Wagniere, J.: Metallurgical Transactions B 22B (1991) 139. Palik, E.D.: Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids, Vol. 2, Orlando, FL: Academic Press, 1991. Yilbas, B.S., Danisman, K., Yilbas, Z.: Meas. Sci. Technol. 2 (1991) 668.
92Mar
Marsden, C. F., Frenk, A., Wagniere, J.-D.: In: Mordike, B.L. (ed.): Laser Treatment of Materials, ECLAT '92, Oberusel: DGM Informationsgesellschaft Verlag (1992) 375.
93Dau 93Gas
Dausinger, F., Shen, J.: ISIJ International 30(9) (1993) 925. Gasser, A.: Oberflächenbehandlung metallischer Werkstoffe mit CO2-Laserstrahlung in der flüssigen Phase, Ph.D. thesis, TH Aachen, Germany, Wissensschaftsverlag, 1993. Mazhukin, V.I., Gusew, I.V., Smurov, I., Flamant, G.: In: Denney, P., Miyamoto, I., Mordike, B.L. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '93 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 77 (1993) 213. Pedrotti, F.L., Pedrotti, L.S.: Introduction to optics, 2nd ed., Englewood Cliffs, NJ: PrenticeHall International, 1993. Stern, G.: Absorption kontinuierlicher CO2- und Nd:YAG-Laserstrahlung durch verschiedene Metalllegierungen, Anwendungen im Bereich der Laserbehandlung, Report for European Project EUREKA EU194, 1993.
93Maz 93Ped 93Ste
64 94Han 94Hue 94Jun 94Kar 95Dau 95Nie 95Ste
References for 1.1 Hansen, F., Duley, W.W.: J. Laser Appl. 6(3) (1994) 137. Hüttner, B.: J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 6 (1994) 2459. Jung, R.: Untersuchungen zur Erzeugung gleichmässiger Oxidschichten und deren Einfluss auf den Absorptionsgrad beim Festphasenhärten mit Laserstrahlung, Diploma thesis, Fraunhofer Institut für Lasertechnik, RWTH Aachen, Germany, 1994. Kar, A., Mazumder, J.: Phys. Rev. E 49(1) (1994) 410. Dausinger, F.: Strahlwerkzeug Laser: Energieeinkopplung und Prozeßeffektivität. Habilitation thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany. Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1995. Niemz, M. H.: Appl. Phys. Lett. 66 (1995) 1181. Stern, G.: Société Française des Mécaniciens SFM (ed.): Proc. Deutsch-Französische Tagung Mechanik und Optik: Hochleistungslaser im Maschinenbau (Saint-Louis, France), Courbevoie: SFM (1995) 393.
96Du 96Haa 96Kel 96Sch1 96Stu
Du, D., Liu, X., Mourou, G.: Appl. Phys. B 63 (1996) 617. Haag, M., Hügel, H., Albright, C.E., Ramasamy, S.: J. Appl. Phys. 79(8) (1996) 3835. Kelly, R., Miotello, A.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 96–98 (1996) 205. Schittenhelm, H., Callies, G., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 29 (1996) 1564. Stuart, B.C., Feit, M.D., Hermann, S., Rubenchik, A.M., Shore, B.W., Perry, M.D.: Phys. Rev. B 53 (1996) 1749.
97Gar
Garnov, S.V., Konov, V.I., Tsarkova, O.G., Dausinger, F., Raiber, A.: Proc. SPIE 2966 (1997) 149. Liu, X., Du, D., Mourou, G.: IEEE J. Quant. Electron. 33 (1997) 1706. Mayerhofer, R.: Mikromaterialbearbeitung mit Kupferdampflasern: Prozeßcharakterisierung und Werkstoffabhängigkeit des Abtrags, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1997. Nanai, L., Vajtai, R., George, T.: Thin Solid Films 298 (1997) 160.
97Liu 97May 97Nan 98Cal 98Len 98Luk 98Ret 98Sei 98Shi 99Rai 99Sei 99Tie
Callies, G., Schittenhelm, H., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 134. Lenzner, M., Krüger, J., Sartania, S., Cheng, Z., Spielmann, C., Mourou, G., Kautek, W., Krausz, F.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 80 (1998) 4076. Luk’yanchuk, B.S., Marine, W., Anisimov, S.I.: Laser Physics 8(1) (1998) 1. Rethfeld, B., Kaiser, A., Vicanek, M., Simon, G.: Proc. SPIE 3343 (1998) 388. Seibold, G., Brandner, M., Dausinger, F., Hügel H.: In: Mordike, B.L. (ed.): Proc. European Conf. on Laser Treatment of Materials ECLAT '98 (Hannover, Germany), Frankfurt: Werkstoff-Informationsgesellschaft (1998) 189. Shirk, M.D., Molian, P.A.: J. Laser Appl. 10 (1998) 18. Raiber, A.: Grundlagen und Prozeßtechnik für das Lasermikrobohren technischer Keramiken, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1999. Seibold, G., Dausinger, F., Hügel, H.: In: Kujanpää, V., John, I. (eds.): 7th Nordic Conference in Laser Processing of Materials NOLAMP (Lappeenranta, Finland), Acta Universitatis Lappeenrantaensis 84 (1999) 526. Tien, A.-C., Backus, S., Kapteyn, H., Murnane, M., Mourou, G.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1999) 3883.
00Sch1
Schellhorn, M.: CO-Hochleistungslaser: Charakteristika und Einsatzmöglichkeiten beim Schweißen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Munich: Herbert Utz Verlag, 2000.
03Kin
Kindler, H.: Optische und gerätetechnische Entwicklungen zum Laserspritzen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Munich: Herbert Utz Verlag, 2003.
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
25
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response” 1.1.3.1 Condensed matter 1.1.3.1.1 Heat conduction As has been described in Sect. 1.1.2 in detail, laser energy is initially absorbed only by electrons leading to a non-thermal electronic distribution. Due to subsequent electron-electron collision the electrons then return to a thermal Fermi distribution within a characteristic relaxation time of the order τe ≈ 100 fs [98Ret]. Energy transfer to the lattice by electron-phonon interaction is usually much slower. Only for timescales considerably longer than the electron-phonon relaxation time τph, the system can be described by just one temperature value and classical heat conduction. For shorter laser pulses, at least the temperatures for electrons and phonons have to be regarded separately and, for pulse durations of the order of electronic relaxation times or shorter, it is not possible to characterize the system by any thermal distribution. 1.1.3.1.1.1 Fourier heat conduction The classical Fourier heat conduction can be applied for times of interest longer than about 100 ps because in such cases temperature equilibrium between electrons and phonons is reached (see also Table 1.1.12). The continuity equation for the heat flux can then be written in terms of the local material temperature T(x, t):
ρcp
∂ T ( x, t ) − ∇ ⋅ (λ th ∇T ( x, t ) ) = q& ( x, t ) . ∂t
(1.1.23)
Here ρ, cp, and λth represent density, specific heat capacity, and thermal conductivity respectively whereas q& has been included to account for a volumetric heat source. Together with the boundary condition
λ n ⋅ ∇TS = (1 − R ) I 0 − hc (TS − T∞ ) − ε σ (TS4 − T∞4 ) Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
(1.1.24)
26
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
at the surface and an initial temperature distribution, this equation is sufficient to describe the transient temperature within a material. Herein n denotes a unit surface normal vector, ε the emissivity factor, σ the Stefan-Boltzmann constant, and T∞ is the ambient temperature. In this equation a surface heat source of intensity I0 has been included taking a reflectivity R at the surface into account. Typical values of intensities used in laser materials processing are in the order of 104…1014 W cm–2. Losses due to heat convection and re-radiation at the surface as described by the last two expressions in (1.1.24) can be roughly estimated: Using a typical convective heat transfer coefficient for a sonic jet of hc ≈ 200 W m–2 K–1, a difference of 3500 K between surface temperature TS and the flow would lead to a surface cooling intensity of 70 W cm–2 [97Mod]. On the other hand a black body of the same surface temperature would emit about 850 W cm–2 [70Chu]. Both fluences are considerably lower than the absorbed values and can, therefore, be neglected for most applications. Since (1.1.23) is linear in temperature for constant thermophysical properties it can be solved for many cases analytically [90Car, 72Dab, 96Eng]. A frequently used expression is the one-dimensional case for constant laser intensity, which can be either applied as a surface heat source as in (1.1.24) or a volumetric source according to Lambert-Beer’s law of absorption: q ( z , t ) = α (1 − R ) I 0 e −α z .
(1.1.25)
Due to the small values of lα both descriptions, the surface and the volume heat source, yield basically the same result for metals while for insulators (1.1.25) should be used. Depending on the ratio between the thermal diffusion length lth = 2 κ t and the absorption length lα = α–1 (where κ = λth/(ρcp) represents the thermal diffusivity) l th ≈ 2α κ t lα
(1.1.26)
one obtains for the time-dependent surface temperature: ⎧ 2 (1 − R) I 0 κ t ⎪ T∞ + ⎪ λth TS (t ) = ⎨ α ( 1 − R) I 0 ⎪ T∞ + t ρ cp ⎪⎩
for lth >> lα
,
for lth << lα
.
(1.1.27)
Here, the two important limiting cases for metals and insulators have been considered. For metals and pulse lengths of at least several nanoseconds the ratio of thermal to optical penetration depth (1.1.26) is usually much larger than unity since typical values of thermal diffusivities κ are of the order of 10–5 m2 s–1. Values for the absorption length lα for metals can be found in Table 1.1.2. On the other hand, the temperature distribution in dielectrics is dominated by Lambert-Beer’s law rather than heat conduction for timescales smaller than some 10 µs. In this case the surface temperature is initially only a function of absorbed energy density. In Tables 1.1.10 and 1.1.11 typical thermophysical data of selected metals and semiconductors and of selected ceramics, respectively, at room and melting temperature can be found. A one-dimensional description of the heating process is only valid if the lateral dimensions of a rather homogenous heat source are much larger than the penetration depth. Otherwise the heat conduction equation (1.1.23) has to be solved including lateral heat losses. If laser beams with Gaussian or top-hat spatial distribution of radius w and peak intensity I0 are incident on a metal surface the maximum temperature in the center of the laser spot is given by [00Sch1] where ierfc(x) denotes the indeterminate integral over the complementary error function: TSGauss (t ) = T∞ + TSTop − Hat (t ) = T∞ +
⎛ 2 2κ t ⎞ (1 − R) I 0 w ⎟ arctan⎜ ⎜ w ⎟ λth 2 ⎝ ⎠ 2 (1 − R) I 0 λth
κ t ⎧⎪ ⎨1 − ⎪⎩
,
⎛ w ⎞ ⎫⎪ ⎟ ierfc⎜ ⎜ 2 κ t ⎟ ⎬⎪ ⎝ ⎠⎭
(1.1.28) .
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
27
Table 1.1.10. Typical thermophysical data of selected metals and semiconductors at room and melting temperature taken from [92Smi, 88Wyb]. Material
Al
Cu
Fe
Si
melting temperature Tm [K]
933
1356
1809
1683
boiling temperature Tb[K]
2793
2833
3133
–1
–1
5
5
3543 5
1.8×106
latent heat of melting Lm [J kg K ]
3.9×10
latent heat of evaporation Lv [J kg–1 K–1]
1.1×107
4.8×106
6.1×106
1.4×107
2700
8960
7870
2340
2385
8000
7015
2510
238
394
78
139
density ρ [kg m ] at RT –3
density ρ [kg m ] at Tm –3
thermal conductivity λth [W m K ] at RT –1
–1
2.1×10
2.7×10
thermal conductivity λth [W m K ] at Tm
94
166
30
22
spec. heat capacity cp [J kg–1 K–1] at RT
904
389
450
729
spec. heat capacity cp [J kg–1 K–1] at Tm
1086
495
750
–1
–1
viscosity η [N s m ] at Tm –2
1.3×10
surface tension σ [N m ] at Tm –1
–3
0.914
4×10
–3
1.285
5.5×10
1040 –3
1.872
9.4×10–4 0.865
Table 1.1.11. Typical thermophysical data of selected ceramics at room and melting temperature taken from [92Smi, 61Bar, 90Kos, 70Stu, 99Rai, 97Whi]. In general, data of these materials may vary considerably with composition. Material
AlN
Al2O3
SiC
decomposition temperature Td [K]
2500
2320
2970
–1
–1
latent heat of decomposition Ld [J kg K ] density ρ [kg m ] at RT –3
1.7×10 3260
6
1.1×10 3970
6
1.6×10 3170
Si3N4 2170 6
3200
thermal conductivity λth [W m K ] at RT
90
39
42
35
spec. heat capacity cp [J kg–1 K–1] at RT
737
781
676
713
spec. heat capacity cp [J kg–1 K–1] at Td
1246
1385
1400
1325
–1
–1
Figure 1.1.21 shows the dependence of absorbed laser intensity on the time necessary to reach boiling temperature for metals. For Gaussian and top-hat beams a deviation to the one-dimensional model can be observed for small radii w or long interaction times. Due to the assumption of temperature-independent material properties and the uncertainty in some of these data, values obtained by (1.1.28) should only be regarded as estimates. Since for typical beam radii the deviations occur only for pulse lengths longer than several microseconds, the one-dimensional case yields good results for dielectrics within the validity of the assumption that thermal diffusion can be neglected compared to optical penetration. Here, heating times for a given absorbed intensity are typically two or three orders of magnitude longer than in the case of metals.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
A
R I
28
−7
−8
−9
−6
−5
H
−4
−3
−2
t
Fig. 1.1.21. Absorbed laser intensity as a function of time to reach boiling temperature for Gaussian and top-hat beams with different beam radius w and onedimensional limit. For Cu and Al only the situation for a Gaussian profile and w = 10 µm is shown; all other curves correspond to Fe. Constant material properties at room temperature have been assumed.
A general solution to (1.1.23) in an infinite medium can be expressed in terms of Green’s function for a point heat source [90Car]: T (x, t ) = T∞ + ∫
t t ’= 0
∫∫∫ 8ρ c
2 ⎞ ⎛ ⎜ − x − x’ ⎟ d 3 x’ dt ’. exp 3 ⎜ 4κ (t − t ’) ⎟ κ (t − t ’) ⎠ ⎝
q (x’, t ’) p
(1.1.29)
Isothermal boundary conditions can be introduced by applying the method of image heat sources, further simplifications are possible for symmetric heat sources [72Pae]. Equation (1.1.29) has been used by many authors e.g. to describe heat distribution for welding [41Ros, 73Swi, 88Ste, 00Cha]. It is a very powerful method to solve heat conduction for arbitrary spatial heat sources. This is demonstrated in Fig. 1.1.22, which shows a comparison of experiment and calculation (in the same scale) for the case of welding with the dual focus technique in AlMgSi1. 0
Depth [mm]
1 2 3 4 5 -4 a
-3
-2
-1 0 1 Distance [mm]
2
3
4 b
Fig. 1.1.22. (a) Cross section of calculated heat affected zone and melt pool geometry and (b) experimental result for laser welding of AlMgSi1 with dual focus technique (Nd:YAG Laser with two foci of 2 kW 1 mm apart and welding speed 2 m/min) [00Cha].
1.1.3.1.1.2 Two-temperature model As mentioned above, the results of the previous section are only valid as long as lattice and electrons are in thermal equilibrium with each other. With growing interest in shorter laser pulses for precise machining, several models adequate for the description of picosecond laser pulse interaction have been proposed [74Ani, 93Qiu, 92Kar1, 97Koe, 97Maz, 96Hue]. Common among these is the description of the solid by separate temperatures Tph and Te for lattice and electrons respectively. Both subsystems itself are assumed to be thermalized which is only justifiable if the pulse duration is much longer than the electronic relaxa-
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
29
tion time τe. After introduction of a coupling constant G for the two subsystems, heat conduction can be described by a set of coupled rate equations C e (Te )
∂ Τe = −∇ ⋅ Qe − G (Te − Tph )+ q ∂t
∂ Τph
C ph (Tph )
∂t
= G (Te − Tph )
,
(1.1.30)
,
with Ce and Cph being the electron and the phonon heat capacity, respectively, and Qe the electronic heat flux. The lattice heat conduction has been neglected compared to the electronic one. Typical coupling constants for metals are listed in Table 1.1.12. Table 1.1.12. Relaxation times and transport properties for selected metals taken from [96Hue] and estimated using data from Table 1.1.10 and [86Kit, 76Ash, 87All2, 87All3, 83Zie]. Due to some crude assumptions on data these values should only be regarded as a rough orientation. Metal
Al
Cu
Fe
Pb
Nb
electron-electron relaxation time τe [ps]
0.067
0.467
0.030
0.377
0.0135
electron-phonon relaxation time τph [ps]
4.27
57.5
0.5
11.2
–3
5.7 × 10
–1
coupling constant G [W m K ] electron heat capacity to temperature ratio Ce/Te [J m–3 K–2] phonon heat capacity Cph [J m–3 K–1] electron thermal conductivity λe [W m K ] –1
–1
17
6 × 10
16
7 × 10
18
1.3 × 10
1.33 17
1.7 × 1018
127
93
700
163
767
2.43 × 106
3.45 × 106
3.5 × 106
1.45 × 106
2.26 × 106
238
401
78
38
54
There have been many discussions on the question of a proper choice for the electronic heat flux Qe [89Jos, 90Jos]. A diffusion-like expression
Qe = −λ th ∇Te
(1.1.31)
will lead to a parabolic differential equation which can have an unphysical infinite propagation speed. Models based on this assumption are usually called parabolic two-step models. Another approach uses a kind of relaxation formulation
Qe = − ∫
t
t ’=0
⎛ t − t ’⎞ λth ⎟⎟ ∇Te dt ’ exp⎜⎜ − τe ⎝ τe ⎠
(1.1.32)
guaranteeing finite heat propagation in a wave-like differential equation and is called hyperbolic two-step model. Both descriptions reduce to the classical one-step model if coupling constants are large and hence electronic relaxation times τe =
Ce G
(1.1.33)
short. In Fig. 1.1.23 experimental transient surface temperatures for femtosecond laser pulses are compared with predictions of the different theoretical models. The deviation from the classical approach is clearly observable.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
N
30
T
t
[Ref. p. 62
Fig. 1.1.23. Transient surface temperature after irradiation of Au with a 96 fs laser pulse of 10 J m–2 fluence. Experimental results are compared to results obtained by parabolic (PTS) and hyperbolic (HTS) two-step and classical one-step (POS) heat conduction [93Qiu].
1.1.3.1.2 Phase transitions As the material is heated to high temperatures, it usually passes through several phase transitions like structural changes, melting and evaporation. Usually these are first order transitions with discontinuities in thermodynamic potentials leading to a latent heat L. Typical values for this quantity are listed in Tables 1.1.10 and 1.1.11.
1.1.3.1.2.1 Melting When crystalline material is heated beyond the melting point the long range atomic order is lost which can result in a considerable change in material properties such as absorptivity, thermal conductivity and heat capacity. A collection of thermophysical material data for temperatures beyond the melting respectively decomposition points can e.g. be found in [92Smi, 70Stu] and Tables 1.1.10 and 1.1.11. If constant material properties are applied, (1.1.27) can be used for an estimate of the time necessary to reach the melting point, and in a similar way also cooling rates can be deduced [90Car, 92Bas]. Figure 1.1.24 shows measured and calculated heating and melt duration times for silicon and germanium as a function of the deposited energy density. Here, a numerical code including temperature-dependent material properties has been employed. Depending on energy input, melt has sometimes been detected for several hundreds of nanoseconds after the 38 ns laser pulse. A simple estimate for the melt thickness in metals can be obtained from the thermal diffusion length lth (see (1.1.26)) with the laser pulse duration τH = t. As can be expected from this formula, melt thickness decreases for shorter laser pulses which is also confirmed in the numerical calculation of Fig. 1.1.25 for silicon where nano- and femtosecond pulses are compared. Again, for ultrashort pulses the considerations of the previous section have to be employed. Calculations show that contrary to the suggestion of (1.1.26) melt thickness can not be decreased infinitely by using shorter pulses which is depicted in Fig. 1.1.26 [97Koe].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes 350
40 Si Ge
300
Melt duration [ns]
30
Melt onset [ns]
31
20
250 200 150 100
10
50 0 0
a
0.5 1.5 1.0 Energy density [J/cm 2 ]
0 0
2.0
b
0.5 1.5 1.0 Energy density [J/cm 2 ]
2.0
M
Fig. 1.1.24. Time for (a) melt onset and (b) duration for Si and Ge as a function of deposited energy density. Symbols correspond to measured data whereas lines represent results of a numerical simulation using temperaturedependent material properties (KrF-laser; 38 ns pulse width) [86Jel].
Fig. 1.1.25. Calculated dependence of melt thickness in Si on laser fluence for 7 ns and 100 fs pulse duration [97Liu].
M
F
P
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Fig. 1.1.26. Calculated melt depth in Cu as a function of pulse duration at a fluence value of H = 1 J cm–2 [97Koe].
32
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
If, simultaneously, material is ablated with a velocity u, then for constant laser intensity and long interaction times the temperature decreases in the one-dimensional case exponentially within the material yielding a melt thickness of d=
κ ⎛ TS − T∞ ⎞ , ln ⎜ ⎟ u ⎝ Tm − T∞ ⎠
(1.1.34)
where TS, Tm and T∞ are surface, melting and room temperature, respectively [76All]. Most industrially used ceramics decompose at high temperatures into a metallic melt layer and an evaporated volatile component. Si3N4 for example forms a silicon rich surface layer at about 2150 K, thereby loosing its characteristic dielectric material properties [98Ohm, 99Rai].
1.1.3.1.2.2 Evaporation When the lattice temperature, i.e. atomic velocity, is high enough to overcome cohesion, single atoms or clusters can be evaporated. Under the simplifying assumptions of an ideal gas, negligible volume of the liquid phase compared to the gaseous and temperature-independent latent heat of evaporation, the equilibrium vapor pressure above the material can be expressed according to the integral form of ClausiusClapeyron’s law [74Gob]
⎛ L p(T ) = pamb exp ⎜ − v ⎜ R Sp ⎝
⎡ 1 1 ⎤⎞ ⎢ − ⎥ ⎟⎟ , ⎣ Tb T ⎦ ⎠
(1.1.35)
where Tb and Lv represent boiling temperature at ambient pressure pamb and latent heat of evaporation, respectively. The specific gas constant RSp corresponds to the ratio of universal gas constant and molar mass. Under the assumptions of a thermal Maxwellian distribution of evaporated atoms on the surface and an ideal gas law the continuity of evaporated mass m per area A yields the Hertz-Knudsen formula for the mass flux density j [74Mar]: j (T ) =
p (T ) − pamb m . = ρ u =α A 2 RSpT
(1.1.36)
In most calculations the ambient pressure pamb is taken to zero corresponding to evaporation into an ideal vacuum. The assumption of a thermal Maxwellian distribution for the velocities of evaporated atoms just above the surface is, in general, not true since they will need some collisions to reach equilibrium first. This non-equilibrium zone of several mean free paths’ width is called „Knudsen layer“. After collisions some atoms will be scattered back to the surface reducing thereby the net evaporated mass flux which is accounted for in (1.1.36) by introducing a factor α smaller than unity. Macroscopic models have been proposed to estimate changes in thermodynamic properties across the Knudsen layer [68Ani, 79Kni]. Although this is, strictly speaking, not possible with an equilibrium based thermodynamics and some assumptions have to be introduced, nevertheless, the predictions show reasonable agreement with microscopic Monte Carlo simulations [91Sib]. Contrary to macroscopic models, molecular dynamical simulations are well suited for the description of the evaporation process itself. Although these calculations require still long computational times, they are at least applicable to ablation of small geometries on short time scales. Several results for ablation characteristics in various materials have been published [97Zhi1, 98Her1, 96Ohm]. Figure 1.1.27 shows a calculated example for the desorption of an organic solid after a laser pulse of 15 ps duration. At a certain threshold fluence a transition from pure surface evaporation yielding individual molecules to a volume process in which clusters are desorbed can be observed.
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
33
10
10
Small clusters (4 molecules or less)
80
3
Fraction [%]
Number of desorbed molecules
100
60
40
2
20
total yield monomers
Large clusters (10 molecules or more)
0 0.4
a
0.6
1.0 0.8 Fluence [mJ/cm 2 ]
1.2
0.4
b
0.6
1.0 0.8 Fluence [mJ/cm 2 ]
1.2
Fig. 1.1.27. (a) Desorption yield and (b) plume composition vs. fluence in a molecular dynamical simulation of the evaporation process for an organic solid (laser pulse length 15 ps) [97Zhi2].
Equation (1.1.36) describes evaporation for a superheated surface which sometimes is called normal vaporization. For slow heating it is also possible that within the melt bubbles form at special nucleation sites like inclusions. In the case of this so-called heterogeneous bubble nucleation or normal boiling the surface temperature remains almost fixed at boiling temperature [96Kel]. For shorter laser pulses this process is unlikely since bubble nucleation is slow at low superheating and the number of such nucleation sites is finite. Nevertheless, for very fast and high energy input a considerable superheating of the liquid is possible leading to homogeneous bubble nucleation: At temperatures of about 90 % of the critical temperature, instabilities within the liquid may produce very fast a significant number of vapor bubbles leading to what is called “phase explosion” or spinodal decomposition [74Mar, 96Kel]. Since for evaporation the attractive energy barrier corresponding to the latent heat has to be overcome by the atoms they will be slowed down and the surface is thereby cooled. This cooling is sometimes included by theoretical models in the surface boundary condition (1.1.24) which leads especially for transparent materials to a considerable superheating within the material compared to the surface [94Maz1]. Other authors have pointed out that extending the cooling over a distance as small as a few interatomic spacings would reduce this superheating considerably thereby making it, at least for metals, a minor effect [96Kel]. For long laser pulses the temperature distribution within the solid will reach, after the initial heating period, a steady state with respect to the moving ablation front, finally. In this case the absorbed power density AI is balanced by the one removed with evaporated atoms: A I = ρ u (TS ) {Lv + c p (TS − T∞ )} .
(1.1.37)
The expression in parenthesis on the right hand side represents the specific enthalpy of the evaporated atoms and can be extended to include latent heats for other phase transitions, kinetic energy of atoms or, when writing it as an integral over specific heat capacity cp, also temperature-dependent material properties. Figure 1.1.28 shows the dependence of this upper limit of ablation velocity u on absorbed intensity for several materials. The differences between them are rather small which is a consequence of (1.1.37) being independent of absorption length and thermal conductivity. This formula can be solved directly for the ablated mass flux if in a first order approximation enthalpy is evaluated at boiling temperature Tv rather than at the actual surface temperature TS [65Rea]. The result is depicted in Fig. 1.1.28 for the case of aluminum by a dashed line.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
A
u
34
A
Fig. 1.1.28. Calculated stationary ablation velocities for Al, Cu, Fe and Si using (1.1.37). The dashed line denotes the linearized case for aluminum where the enthalpy in this equation has been evaluated always at boiling temperature.
1.1.3.1.3 Melt dynamics The existence of molten material in or around the interaction zone has consequences on both the energy balance and the resulting quality of the particular laser processing technique: For example in welding, the flow in the melt pool will primarily affect the energy flow by transporting thermal energy and modifying the keyhole geometry (as a consequence, of course, the seam geometry will be directly influenced). On the other hand, in drilling, especially at shorter pulse lengths, the primary concern will be questions regarding the exactness of the bore. Therefore, the actual role of melt dynamics has to be discussed in connection with the particular process; here, only few general remarks will be given.
1.1.3.1.3.1 Origin of driving forces During laser machining melt will be accelerated, deformed or expulsed due to several process forces acting on it. The most important among these are ablation or gas dynamical pressure as well as surface tension. The balance of these forces with hydro-dynamical pressures determines the characteristics of the melt flow. Several authors have measured and calculated the momentum transferred to the material during ablation [74Low, 73Het, 99Sia, 76Ste]. Figure 1.1.29 shows an example of experimental values for ablation of aluminum with a CO2 laser. Values for the peak pressure in the order of some 107 Pa depending on laser intensity are typical for this process which can also be deduced from the vapor pressure as described by (1.1.35). For a detailed theoretical description of momentum transfer a thorough examination of evaporation and gas expansion beneath the surface including backscattering and shock formation is necessary. Estimations of the ablation pressure may also be obtained by theoretical models describing the shock formation during ablation (see Sect. 1.1.3.2.3). Shear forces induced e.g. by assist gas are in the case of drilling probably negligible whereas for cutting they are necessary for melt removal [92Kar2, 98Zef]. Frictional forces due to ejected vapor jets from a weld keyhole are likely to accelerate the surface melt layer considerably [98Mat, 93Ber]. According to Laplacian’s formula, pressure due to surface tension is inversely proportional to the main local radius of curvature. In laser micromachining structures can be smaller than some 10 µm leading to considerable pressures of the order of 105 Pa. Typical curvatures occurring during laser welding are usually larger leading to of at least one order of magnitude smaller pressures [95Dum]. Since surface tension also shows considerable variations with alloy composition and temperature, such local gradients can induce additional acceleration which is called Marangoni effect and has been shown to be of importance for laser welding [99Fuh, 98Mat]. Due to the continuity of mass within a stationary melt pool, resulting hydrodynamic forces can be fairly large close to geometric obstacles like keyholes in welding. Here the flow of melt around the vapor capillary will lead to high fluid velocities at its side walls which has been demonstrated by calculations [95Dum, 92Bec]. Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
35
220
Peak pressure [bar]
180
140
100
60
20 0
1
2 8
3 2
Initial power density [10 W/cm ]
Fig. 1.1.29. Peak pressure on aluminum target as a function of laser power density (CO2 laser with 100…700 J) [73Het].
In contrast to the so far mentioned forces, buoyancy and radiation pressure are for most laser applications negligible [98Mat, 96Olf].
1.1.3.1.3.2 Resulting effects in laser machining In the case of cutting and drilling a thorough melt removal is usually desirable for reasons of efficiency and precision. Melt ejection will even exceed material evaporation for laser drilling with longer pulses of low intensity. Figure 1.1.30 shows analytically calculated ablation rates for aluminum and iron as well as the contributions of melt and vapor using the stationary model of [76All]. Liquid expulsion will dominate at low intensities whereas vaporization takes over at higher. Similar results have also been obtained by other authors [87Cha]. Nevertheless, for shorter pulses melt acceleration cannot be neglected which is illustrated in the experiment depicted in Fig. 1.1.31. For short pulses evaporation dominates due to the fast heating compared to slower fluid acceleration whereas, here, for more than about 100 µs pulse duration almost 90 % of material is ejected by melt. Sometimes substantial melt ejection has not been observed experimentally for pulses shorter than milliseconds [92Bas]. In laser drilling melt from the hot central spot is accelerated towards the crater boundary forming recast which can been seen in the simulation result of Fig. 1.1.32. If the acceleration of melt near the surface is large, instabilities can lead to droplet formation [97Wil]. Experimentally observed droplets have typically a minimum speed of 1…10 m s–1 and appear after a time delay of some 100 µs [78Zhi, 71Kar]. In laser deep welding the ablation pressure is responsible for creating and maintaining an open vapor capillary. Several authors have examined the pressure balance between vapor, surface tension and hydrodynamic fluid flow around the vapor cavity to determine its form [95Dum, 94Kap, 76Kle, 92Bec]. Due to the material feed the keyhole is slightly asymmetric and inclined with respect to the beam axis. Figure 1.1.33 shows a calculated example for the transient evolution of the vapor capillary in pulsed welding [96Gri, 98Hue]. In cw-welding, the pressure inside the keyhole is of the order of several 100 mbar and can reach up to 1 bar during the formation of the capillary [93Ber, 95Dum, 98Fab]. The evaporative losses in common laser welding applications are rather small [96Bec1]. Simulations for high speed welding demonstrate that melt velocity is largest at the side of the keyhole where fluid has to flow around the cavity and that it can be considerably larger than welding speed itself. An example for such a calculation is shown in Fig. 1.1.34. Above a certain welding speed a fast jet towards the end of the weld pool is formed which is assumed to be responsible for process instabilities like humping [92Bec].
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
36
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
Removal rate [m s −1]
80
total vapor liquid
60
Al Fe
40
20
1×10 7 1×10 8 Absorbed intensity Al [ W cm−2 ]
Fraction of melt to total removal [%]
100
100
0 1×10 6
[Ref. p. 62
80
60
40
20
0
Fig. 1.1.30. Calculated total removal rate together with contributions from melt (dashed) and vapor (dotted) for Al and Fe.
Al Cu Mo Ni
100 300 400 200 Laser pulse duration [µs]
Fig. 1.1.31. Fraction of melt to total removal as a function of pulse duration (Nd-Glass laser with 107 W cm–2) [70Chu].
Depth [µm]
50
0
− 50
−100
0
50
200 150 100 Hole radius R [µm]
250
Fig. 1.1.32. Numerical simulation of a hole profile for drilling of Hastelloy-X with a single microsecond pulse of Gaussian temporal and spatial distribution after 200 µs (3.5×109 W m–2 peak intensity, 70 µs FWHM) [96Gan].
In addition to the keyhole shape and feed rate also local variations of the surface tension due to gradients in temperature and melt composition will determine the melt flow for laser welding. It has been shown that already small amounts of surface active alloying components can alter by this so-called Marangoni effect the resulting weld geometry significantly [99Fuh]. Figure 1.1.35 shows typical 3dimensional flow field simulations for two different surface tension temperature gradients.
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
37
t
a
b
Fig. 1.1.33. Calculation of transient keyhole formation for welding (P = 4 kW, w = 0.19 mm) [96Gri, 98Hue]. Arrow t denotes increasing time.
a
Fig. 1.1.34. Streamlines for laser welding simulation of Fe with (a) 5 m/min and (b) 15 m/min feeding rate [92Bec].
b
Fig. 1.1.35. Melt pool geometry and velocity field for (a) negative and (b) positive temperature gradient of surface tension (feeding rate 2 m/s). Low-alloyed steel [99Fuh].
1.1.3.2 Interaction mechanisms in the gas and plasma phase At high incident intensities a plasma can develop close to or above the interaction region at the workpiece. Depending on the particular process, ionization occurs in the evaporated material, in the ambient gas or in both. The resulting interaction between radiation and plasma as well as gas-dynamic effects have consequences on central issues of materials processing, namely on energy coupling and the quality of the process results. Therefore, they were investigated by many groups around the world applying a variety of theoretical models [70Rai, 73Ani, 78Pir, 79Kni, 93Ani, 99Arn] and experimental techniques: Imaging techniques such as shadow and Schlieren photography [68Bas, 85Mat, 90Ven, 95Cal, 97Jan], resonance
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
38
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
absorption [91Gil, 92Ven, 98Sch2], streak photography [69Hoh, 90Fab, 91Sok], luminescence and LIF photography [73Ste, 91Sap, 93Geo, 95Wit, 96Al, 98Pur], and interferometry [68Bas, 88Aut, 94Lu, 94Lin, 97Hug, 97Sch1, 98Vog, 98Sch3] were used as well as spectroscopic [87Pop, 88Sok, 89Sok, 90Ber, 93Meh, 95Her, 96Sch2, 97Hug, 98Doy] or time-of-flight techniques [87Lar, 91Che, 91Wie, 92Koo, 98Pin].
1.1.3.2.1 Basic ionization and absorption mechanisms A plasma can interact with laser radiation via several mechanisms, such as reflection, absorption, refraction, or scattering [65Rai, 86Miy, 87All1, 93Ade, 93Bou, 93Maz, 96Mat], which in detail depends mainly on the temperature and the electron number density of the plasma. These properties in turn are governed by the characteristics of the laser beam, i.e. pulse duration, pulse intensity, laser power and wavelength. The “starting point” of all these mechanisms is the interaction between electrons and the electric field of the radiation which leads to an energy transfer from the radiation field to the plasma. As this energy transfer is both a dominant source of plasma generation and heating and – on the other hand – a cause for attenuation of a laser beam during materials processing, the ways by which energy can be absorbed in plasmas are of primary interest. Since the electron number density and the temperature are the key parameters, the absorption mechanisms will be discussed in order of increasing electron density or temperature of the plasma. •
•
For low temperatures, line absorption (bound–bound), multiphoton absorption (bound–free I) and photoionization from excited states (bound–free II) have to be considered [86Miy, 95Bul, 98Lun, 98Sch1]. For high temperatures or high electron densities, inverse bremsstrahlung is of special importance [70Hor, 73Mul, 84Pop, 85Bey, 90Mat].
1.1.3.2.1.1 Bound electrons Bound–bound absorption (line-absorption). Within the material vapor, line absorption can occur if the incident laser photon energy is in resonance with the energy equivalent of an electronic or vibrational transition within the molecules, atoms, or ions. Therefore, this absorption mechanism strongly depends on the energy level distribution of the considered species. The corresponding absorption bands are typically narrow and rarely coincide with the wavelengths used in laser materials processing, so this mechanism does not play a very dominant role. For further details regarding bound–bound absorption it is referred to [66Zel]. Bound–free absorption I (Multi-Photon Ionization, MPI). Multiphoton ionization or multiphoton absorption can occur if a number of photons is available for interaction within the lifetimes of virtual energy levels of a particle species such that the sum of the energy of these photons is sufficient to ionize the species. This mechanism is important for very high photon fluxes, e.g. for ultra-short laser pulses in the ps- and fs-pulse duration range. The probability of a multiphoton ionization process depends on the number of photons which is necessary for an ionization act. Resonant as well as non-resonant MPI is possible. If a particular level within the energetic system of the species can be excited resonantly by one photon, the multiphoton ionization probability increases drastically due to the longer lifetime of the excited level compared to the virtual energy level in the non-resonant case. A comparison of resonant and non-resonant MPI, e.g. for aluminum and iron [84Pop], shows an eightfold higher absorption coefficient for 248 nm radiation (KrF-laser) in iron vapor than in aluminum vapor. For very high laser intensities direct field ionization is also possible. A comparison between the MPI and field ionization regimes is shown in Fig. 1.1.36 and indicates that for “traditional” laser treatment processes this mechanism will not occur.
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
10
15
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes Wavelength λ [ µm] 10
100
39
1
Intensity I [W/cm2 ]
Fieldionization KrF-laser 10
13
Nd-YAG-laser
10
11
CO2-laser
Multiphoton Ionization
10
9
10
13
14
15
10 10 Frequency ω [ 1/s]
10
16
Fig. 1.1.36. Comparison of MPI and field ionization versus radiation frequency [84Pop].
Bound-free absorption II (PhotoIonization, PI). At higher temperatures excited states in the species become more and more populated (Boltzmann distribution) so that a single photon may provide enough energy for an ionization process. The absorption coefficient for PI can be described on the basis of Kirchhoff’s laws. The absorption coefficient for hydrogen-like atoms is given by [66Zel] ∞ Z 4e10 me 1 N1 λ03 ∑ 3 e α PI = 5 6 4 j 48 3 ε 0 h c0 j = j*
1
−
E1 ⎛⎜ 1 ⎞⎟ 1− k bT ⎜ j 2 ⎟ ⎝ ⎠
,
(1.1.38)
Absorption coeff. α PI
where e and me denote the elementary charge and the electron mass, h and kb are Planck’s and Boltzmann’s constants. Z is the effective charge number of the atomic species and N1 and E1 are the neutral atoms’ number density in the ground state and their ionization energy. Finally, j* denotes the number of the lowest ionizable electronic level. Due to the quantization of the energy level the absorption coefficient shows a saw-tooth-like dependence on wavelength as shown in Fig. 1.1.37. Towards shorter wavelengths, whenever the energy of the photons is sufficient to liberate electrons from the next lower – and more densely populated – energy level, the number of excitable electrons increases all of a sudden and consequently a sharp increase is observed for the absorption coefficient.
3
∝λ 0
Wavelength λ 0 Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Fig. 1.1.37. Schematic dependence of the photoionization (PI) absorption coefficient on the wavelength. Contributions of each single electronic level (dashed) and total absorption coefficient (solid) [66Zel]. The PI absorption follows a λ30 -dependence within the contribution of each electronic level.
40
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
1.1.3.2.1.2 Free electrons For high temperatures or high electron number densities of the plasma, inverse bremsstrahlung is an important mechanism. It is initiated by the presence of free electrons in the plume which are accelerated in the electrical field of the incident radiation. Via collisions with partners such as neutral atoms or ions their energy is transferred to the heavy particle system. The absorption coefficient for inverse bremsstrahlung based on a semi-classical analysis of free electron motion in the Coulomb field of an ion and on the principle of detailed balancing (Kirchhoff’s law) is given by [54Mae, 66Zel]: 1
⎞ 2 Z 2e6 3 + ⎛ 2 4 ⎟ ⎜ α ib = λ0 N N e 3 ⎜ 3( 4 ε 0 ) ⎝ 3me k b T ⎟⎠ h c04 me
⇒ α ib
∝ N e λ03 ,
(1.1.39)
with N+ and Ne denoting the number densities of the single ionized ions and the free electrons. Using the Saha equation for the first stage of ionization which describes the dependence of the electron density Ne on temperature in thermal equilibrium: 1
E
1 N + N e ⎛ 2 m e k b T ⎞ 2 u + − k bT ⎟ e , = ⎜⎜ ⎟ u N h2 ⎝ ⎠
(1.1.40)
the inverse bremsstrahlung absorption coefficient can be further simplified when for moderate plasma temperatures multiple ionization can be neglected:
α ib =
1
Z 2 e 6 k bT
12 3 ε 0 h 4 c04 3
Nλ e 3 0
−
E1 k bT
(1.1.41)
.
The neutral atom number density is given by N and u, u+ are the electronic partition functions of the atom and of the ion, respectively. The absorption coefficients described by (1.1.39) through (1.1.41) are purely atomic properties. Socalled effective absorption coefficients α ib ’ that include the effect of re-emission of radiation due to − hν k T
b induced emission are obtained by multiplication of αib by a factor of 1 − e [66Zel, 80Wen]. Comparing photon energy with kinetic energy, two limiting cases can be developed for the effective absorption coefficient which exhibit different wavelength dependence. While the behavior indicated by (1.1.39) and (1.1.41) holds true also for α ib ’ for hν >> k bT , a weaker dependence is found for hν << k bT
where α ib ’∝ λ20 . The inverse bremsstrahlung absorption coefficient can also be calculated on the basis of the classical Lorentz oscillator model where collisions between electrons and heavy particles are considered to be responsible for the damping thus causing the energy transfer [73Mul, 87All1]. The absorption coefficient is then given by 1
⎡ 2 ⎞ ω 2 2 ⎢ ⎛⎜ − 1− 2 p 2 ⎟ + α ib = ⎢ ⎜ λ0 ω + ν c ⎟⎠ ⎢⎣ ⎝
2
⎛ ω p ⎞⎟ ⎛⎜ ν c ω p ⎞⎟ ⎜1 − + ⎜ ω 2 +ν 2 ⎟ ⎜ ω ω 2 +ν 2 ⎟ c ⎠ c ⎠ ⎝ ⎝ 2
2
2
⎤2 ⎥ , ⎥ ⎥⎦
(1.1.42)
with νc being the total collision frequency consisting of contributions by electron–atom (νea) and electron–ion collisions (νei) [67Tan]:
ν c = ν ea + ν ei , ν ea =
8 3 π
σc N
(1.1.43)
2 k bT , me
(1.1.44)
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
ν ei =
(
e 4 ln 12 N e−1 2 e −3 (ε 0 k b T )
32
3ε
2 0
me
) (2
(
41
)
k b T ) −3 2 N + + N + + + .
(1.1.45)
Here, σc describes the classical collisional cross section between particles with radii r1 and r2 according to c = (r1 + r2 ) 2 and N+, N++, ... denote the number densities of singly-, doubly-, ... -ionized ions. Electron–atom collisions dominate for low-temperature plasmas whereas collisions with ions prevail at higher temperatures. The so-called plasma frequency ωp, finally, which is an important figure characterizing plasmas, is determined by the free electron density Ne according to:
ω p2 =
N ee2 . ε 0 me
(1.1.46)
For λ << 2 c ω p which holds for all practical cases of materials processing with lasers the inverse 0
bremsstrahlung absorption coefficient according to (1.1.42) exhibits a λ 20 -dependence.
1.1.3.2.2 Absorption and refraction effects in laser-induced plasmas 1.1.3.2.2.1 Plasma composition and temperature The plasma properties are varying in a broad range and primarily depend on the characteristics of the laser radiation and on the properties of the irradiated material. The most important property characterizing a plasma is the free electron density Ne which depends strongly on the plasma temperature. This is shown exemplarily in Fig. 1.1.38 for plasma conditions that are typical for laser beam welding, i.e. for mixtures of metal vapor and shielding gases. The influence of the wavelength on the resulting plasma temperature – and consequently on its electron density – is demonstrated by the experimental data presented in Fig. 1.1.39 [97Sch3, 00Sch1].
1E18
Number density N [cm −3 ]
Number density N [cm −3 ]
1E17
1E18
Ntotal
He I
Ne
Al I CO-laser
1E16
Al II
1E15
Al III
CO2-laser He II
Ntotal
Ar I 1E17
1E16
Ne
Al I
CO-laser CO2-laser
Al II Al III Ar II
1E15
Al IV 1E14 5000
a
15000 20000 10000 Temperature T [K]
Al IV 1E14
25000
5000
b
15000 20000 10000 Temperature T [K]
25000
Fig. 1.1.38. Number densities of species in (a) Al/He and (b) Al/Ar plasmas in dependence on temperature. Shielding gas content (He resp. Ar) 80 % [00Sch1].
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
42
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
20000
Temperature T [K]
Aluminum 16000
12000
Fig. 1.1.39. Spectroscopically measured temperatures within welding plasmas for aluminum and steel at different laser wavelengths. The effect of a variation of the shielding gases lies within the error bars, temperatures measured with Ar as shielding gas range in the upper part of the margins, with He shielding in the lower range. Nd:YAG: 1.06 µm, 5×106 W/cm2; CO: 5 µm, 5×107 W/cm2; CO2: 10.6 µm, 5×106 W/cm2 [97Sch3, 00Sch1].
Steel 8000
4000 0
2
4 8 10 6 Laser wavelength λ [µm]
12
25 Temperature
2.0
2+
from Al -lines
3.5
+
from Al -lines
1.5
3.0
1.0 0.5
2.5
Ne Laser pulse
0
100 200 Time t [ns]
2.0 1.5
300
Fig. 1.1.40. Temporal evolution of plasma temperature and electron density determined by spectroscopy of the spatially integrated luminance of Nd:YAG-laser induced plume: 1064 nm, 4 mJ, 120 ns pulse width, 2×108 W/cm2 [96Wit].
Electron density Ne [10 16 cm − 3 ]
2.5 Electron density Ne [10 17 cm − 3 ]
Electron temperature Te [eV ]
The knowledge of the temporal evolution of the electron density in a laser-induced plasma during and after the pulse can be used to optimize the process. This is particularly important for high repetition rate machining where subsequent laser pulses may experience absorption in the plasma plumes induced by previous pulses. The temporal evolution of electron densities has been determined experimentally for different processing conditions. Examples for various timescales and wavelengths are shown in Figs. 1.1.40–43 [96Wit, 98Her2, 99Agu, 00Sch2].
Air Ar He
20
15
10
5
0
5
10
20 15 Time t [µs]
25
30
35
Fig. 1.1.41. Spectroscopically determined evolution of integral electron density of Nd:YAG-laser induced plume in different atmospheres at atmospheric pressure: steel target, 1064 nm, 4.5 ns pulse width, 3.8×1010 W/cm2 [99Agu].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
Electron density Ne [ cm − 3 ]
Ref. p. 62]
43
10 19
0.5 mm 1.0 mm 1.5 mm 2.0 mm 3.0 mm 4.0 mm 6.0 mm
10 18
10 17
a
10 16
4 1.0 mm 2.5 mm 3.5 mm 5.5 mm
Ne
kTe [eV ]
3 2 1
b
0
400
0
Fig. 1.1.42. Temporal evolution of electron densities at various locations within an excimer-laser induced plume: aluminum target, 248 nm (KrF), 25 ns pulse duration, 1.5×109 W/cm2 [00Sch2].
800 Time t [ns]
1200
1600
Fig. 1.1.43. Temporal evolution of (a) electron density and (b) temperature of an excimer-laser induced plume in 100 Pa nitrogen atmosphere at various distances from a titanium target: 308 nm (XeCl), 25 ns pulse duration, 5×108 W/cm2 [98Her2].
Table 1.1.13 presents a summary of experimentally obtained electron densities and temperatures for plasmas generated during pulsed and cw laser material treatment, showing the effects of laser wavelength and power density, ambient gas species and pressure, and of work piece material (see also [98Dul]). Table 1.1.13. Experimentally determined plasma properties. h is the height above the surface of the target; t is the time after the begin of the laser irradiation. Laser (cw/pulsed)
Material
Power / Pulse energy
Power density [W/cm²]
Gas (flow [l/min])
Ne [cm–3]
Te [K]
Remarks
Ref.
CO2 (cw)
Fe
15 kW
5×106 max. 1×106 max. 5×106 max.
He (50)
3…8.2×1016
5500…6700
92Pou, 93Pou
Ar/air
3…7×1016
5200…6250
Ar
1.7…2×1017 max. 0.7…4×1016
15100
1.2 m/min, h = 5…0 mm 1.2 m/min, h = 1…0 mm 1.2 m/min, h = 5…0 mm 25…800 hPa
1 kW 15 kW CO2 (cw)
Fe
CO2 (cw)
mild steel
CO2 (cw)
steel
Ar
10.5 kW
He
20 kW
5450…6200
17
1.4×106
air
1…1.5×10 max. values 2.8×1015
4×106
air
1.2×1016
7650
air
1…31×1017
9600…12100
6400
95Ver
95Ohj 0.5…10 m/min spatially res. deg. of ionization 88Sok 48 % deg. of ionization 89 % in keyhole
(continued)
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
44
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
Table 1.1.13 continued. Gas (flow [l/min])
Ne [cm–3]
2 kW
Ar (10)
2 kW
Ar (30)
0.7…2.8 ×1017 0.7…2×1017
Laser (cw/pulsed)
Material
Power / Pulse energy
CO2 (cw)
steel
CO2 (cw)
CO2 (cw)
CO2 (cw)
steel
steel
stainless steel
CO2 (cw)
stainless steel
CO2 (cw)
Al
CO2 (pulsed, 0.2 µs)
Al
Power density [W/cm²]
CO2 (cw)
AlMgSi1
Ti
Remarks
Ref.
0.5 m/min spatially res. 0.5 m/min spatially res.
92Miy
2 kW
Ar
3 kW
Ar (30)
1…2×1016
3 kW
Ar (30)
2×1017
13000
0.6 m/min inside 95Mai plume in keyhole
10 kW
Ar (20)
1.0×1017
12900
h = 0…10 mm
10 kW
Ar (20)
1.3×1017
13500
h = 30…40 mm
10 kW
Ar (20)
6.5×1016
12000
h = 60…70 mm
2.5 kW
He (15)
3…6.1×1016
6900…8800
h = 2…0 mm
2.5 kW
He (40)
1.8…4×1016
6100…8000
h = 2…0 mm
2.5 kW
Ar (40)
8000…12000
7200…8600
h = 2…0 mm
2 kW
Ar (10)
9000…10800 (Fe I and II) 6400…7800 (Fe I) 17400
2 m/min h= 1.25…0 mm
9500
4×106
N2 (60)
3.5…8.5 ×1016 9…11×1016 (Ar lines) 3.5…7×1016 (Fe lines) 6.5×1016
4×106
He (30)
4.6×1016
16100
4×106
O2 (40)
6.2×1016
17100
70 mJ
17
94Sei
94Szy
97Szy
89Sok
Ar
2.7×10
He
1×1017
He (30)
18100…18700
6 m/min
Ar (20)
3.3…3.2 ×1016 7.4…7×1016
19400…20000
6 m/min
He (40)
4×1015 max.
6000…6800
h = 2…0 mm
2.5 kW
Ar (40)
3.2…3.8 ×1016 1…1.2×1017 (Ar lines)
7000…8700
h = 2…0 mm
8800…11400 (Ti I and II) 13500 (Ti II) <8000 (Ti I)
4 m/min h = 1…0 mm
97Szy
6 m/min spatially res.
95Ohj
70 mJ CO2 (cw)
Te [K]
2.5…4 kW 2.5…4 kW 2.5 kW
6
6×10 max. 6×106 max.
h = 1.2 mm
90Mic
h = 1.2 mm 97Sch2
94Szy
CO2 (cw)
Ti
2 kW
Ar
CO2 (cw)
Sn
2.5 kW
Ar (2)
0.5…1.5 ×1017
TEA CO2 (pulsed) (80 ns + 8 µs) TEA CO2 (pulsed) (90 ns + 2 µs) TEA CO2 (pulsed) (80 ns + 8 µs)
Al
750 J
1.25×109 + 3.5×108
vacuum
1017 …5×1017
19000…35000
88Aut
Al
5.5 J
5×109 + 8×108
vacuum
3×1017
22700
96Wit
C
750 J
1.25×109 + 3.5×108
vacuum
2×1017 …2.5×1017
60000…100000
88Aut
(continued)
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
45
Table 1.1.13 continued. Laser (cw/pulsed)
Material
Power / Pulse energy
Power density [W/cm²]
Gas (flow [l/min])
Ne [cm–3]
Te [K]
TEA CO2 (pulsed) (90 ns + 2 µs) TEA CO2 (pulsed, 0.9…5 µs)
C
5.5 J
5×109 + 8×108
vacuum
1.8×1018
33100
metals, semiconductors
1J max.
1×109 max.
air
1×1017 max.
8000…19000
var. of height above target
77Mal
CO (cw)
AlMgSi1
2.5…4 kW 2.5…4 kW
7×107 max. 7×107 max.
He (30)
4.7…4.8 ×1016 4.3…5.4 ×1016
14400…15300
6 m/min
97Sch2
15100…18600
6 m/min
5300 4800
h = 0 mm h = 1.3 mm
Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 5 ms) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (cw) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 5 ms) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 7 ms) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 120 ns) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 21 ms) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 3 ns) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 120 ns) Nd 1.06 µm (pulsed, 12 ns) Nd:YAG 1.06 µm (pulsed, 12 ns) Dye 583 nm (pulsed, 2 µs)
Nd:YAG 532 nm (pulsed, 8 ns)
Ar (20)
Fe
2 kW
air
steel
3 kW
4.2×106
3 kW
4.2×106
He
3×1016
Ref.
96Wit
3500
97Lac
97Sch3
Ar
3700
air
6700 5300
h = 0 mm h = 1.3 mm
97Lac
1.6×106
Ar
3400
weak intens. dependence
87Pee
4 mJ
2×108
vacuum
2×1017
14500
80 J
1×106
air
1.85×1013
3280
h = 1 mm
95Mat
0.4…1.2 ×109
–
5000…12000
water confinement
92Fab
stainless steel
2 kW
Al
400 W
Al
Al–Mg alloy Cu
C
4 mJ
2×108
vacuum
2.8×1018
C
10 J
8×1011
vacuum
0.4…2×1019
Si3N4
5 mJ
1×1011
air
2…4.5×1019
Al 2024
105 J/cm2
5.3×107
vacuum
3.3×1017
2
7
Al
Remarks
16
96Wit
28400
8100
96Wit
spatially resolved spatially resolved
68Bas
h = 1.27 mm
87Knu
105 J/cm
5.3×10
8×10
7000
h = 5 mm
26 J/cm2
1.3×107
3.5×1017
7660
h = 1.27 mm
880 mJ
4×1010
0.8×1017
12800
vacuum
99Bre
96Wit
(continued)
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
46
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
Table 1.1.13 continued. Laser (cw/pulsed)
Material
Power / Pulse energy
Power density [W/cm²]
Gas (flow [l/min])
Ne [cm–3]
Te [K]
Nd:YAG 532 nm (pulsed, 40 ps) Nd:YAG 532 nm (pulsed, 8 ns) Nd:YAG 532 nm (pulsed, 40 ps) Nd:YAG 532 nm (pulsed, 12 ns)
Al
25 mJ
5×1011
vacuum
0.5×1017
13400
96Wit
C
880 mJ
4×1010
vacuum
1.5×1018
19200
96Wit
C
25 mJ
5×1011
vacuum
1.1×1018
22600
96Wit
Si3N4
2 mJ
9.3×1010
air
2.2…3.5 ×1019
spatially resolved
99Bre
Nd:YAG 355 nm (pulsed, 12 ns)
Si3N4
1.1 mJ
9.5×1010
air
1…2×1019
spatially resolved
99Bre
Excimer 308 nm (pulsed, 40 ns) Excimer 308 nm (pulsed, 20 ns)
Al
2J
1×109
vacuum
1.2×1018
18600
Al
0.5 J max.
9×108
vacuum
4.5×1018 …2×1017
29000…9000
tempor. res. t = 50…150 ns
91Gai
0.5 J max.
6×108
vacuum
23000…27000
3.0…9.5 ×108
vacuum
16000…29000
h= 1.25…0.1 mm h = 0.2 mm
91Gai
0.5 J max.
4×1016 …5×1017 2×1017 …1.8×1018
2…3.8 J/cm2
0.7…1.3 ×108
vacuum
2.5 ×1017…1019
23000…46000
h < 0.5 mm
93Meh
2…3.8 J/cm2 12 mJ
0.7…1.3 ×108 1.2×109
vacuum
~1018
23000…28000
h > 1 mm
air
4…9×1019
spatially resolved
12 mJ
1.2×109
He
2…7×1019
spatially res.
12 mJ
9
1.2×10
Ar
6…8×1019
spatially res.
Al
600 mJ
1×109
vacuum
5×1017
18600
C
600 mJ
1×109
vacuum
1.1×1019
25500
Excimer 248 nm (pulsed, 30 ns)
Excimer 248 nm (pulsed, 30 ns)
Excimer 193 nm (pulsed, 20 ns)
Al
Al
Remarks
Ref.
96Wit
91Gai
00Sch2
96Wit
The spatial distribution of the electron density within the plasma plume reveals regions where the incident laser energy is absorbed and where refraction will occur predominantly. This information is therefore essential for any quantitative description of the interaction mechanisms. As an example, a typical distribution of Ne for pulsed laser processing is shown in Fig. 1.1.44 [99Bre]. Under these particular conditions the regions with the highest absorption are close the target surface and at the tip of the induced shock wave.
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
47
Fig. 1.1.44. Electron density distribution in a Nd:YAG-laser induced plasma plume: silicon nitride, 5 mJ, 1200 J/cm², pulse width 12 ns, 15 ns after pulse beginning [99Bre].
1.1.3.2.2.2 Absorption For cw-laser processing, e.g. laser beam welding, the electron densities in the plasmas are in general lower than those in plasmas induced by pulsed laser irradiation in ablation and drilling applications due to the lower intensity values and lower evaporation rates that result therefrom. Furthermore, a relatively free expansion of the material vapor away from the interaction zone allows better dilution of the plumes. Nevertheless, even the drastically lower electron density of cw-laser induced plasmas can cause considerable absorption due to the wavelength dependence of inverse bremsstrahlung absorption when mid-IR lasers are used (CO, CO2). In Fig. 1.1.45 calculated values of the absorption coefficient are shown. Typical values of the total absorption in welding plasmas are summarized in Table 1.1.14. In most cases of pulsed interaction a combination of several of the mechanisms discussed in Sect. 1.1.3.2.1 is responsible for the absorption. A comparison of the wavelength dependence of these phenomena is plotted in Fig. 1.1.46, calculated in [00Sch2] for a special set of parameters using a model described in [90Mat]. The relative importance of the involved absorption mechanisms, inverse bremsstrahlung and photoionization is presented in Fig. 1.1.47 for a calculation performed by [96Cha] on the basis of experimentally measured values for a copper-laser induced plasma.
Absorption coefficient α [cm −1 ]
1 10 10 10 10 10 10
−1
−2
−3
−4
−5
Fe-Ar plasma p total = 1 atm pure Ar p Fe = 0.001 atm p Fe = 0.01 atm pFe = 0.1 atm pure Fe
−6
5000
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
10000 Temperature T [K]
15000
Fig. 1.1.45. Calculated absorption coefficients in dependence of the temperature for Fe/Ar plasmas for CO2-laser welding, λ = 10.6 µm [94Szy].
48
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
Table 1.1.14. Typical values of overall absorption in welding plasmas. Laser (cw/pulsed)
Material
Power [kW]
CO2 (cw)
steel, titanium
2
Overall absorption
Conditions
Reference 94Szy, 97Szy
6%
Ar 40 l/min
2%
He 40 l/min
CO2 (cw)
steel
2
up to 23 %
Ar 10 l/min, spatially resolved
92Miy
CO2 (cw)
steel
15
20…25 %
He atmosphere
92Fab
up to 50 %
Ar atmosphere
CO2 (cw)
iron
15
20±10 %
He atmosphere
15
50…65 %
Ar atmosphere
92Pou, 93Pou
1
8±5 %
Ar/air atmospheres
CO2 (cw)
aluminum
5
21 %
Ar atmosphere
7
31 %
CO2 (cw)
–
2.8…4.3
58…68 %
freely burning Ar-plasma 96Tsu
CO2 (cw)
steel
0.6
42…15 %
Ar 1…8 l/min
0.4
–3
Nd:YAG (pulsed)
aluminum
<10 %
Absorption coefficient α [cm −1 ]
α
3
10 2
Photoionization
10
1
10
10
Inverse bremsstrahlung −1
−2
0
Fig. 1.1.46. Comparison of the order of magnitude of absorption coefficients due to different mechanisms. The parameters have been chosen to match the start of plasma formation for typical processes of pulsed laser ablation with 30 ns pulses of a KrF-laser at 109 W/cm2: T = 8000 K, N = 4×1019 cm–3, Ne = 4×1018 cm–3; particle/cluster radius 5 nm and particle/cluster number density 3×1014 cm–3 [90Mat, 00Sch2].
90Mil 87Pee
10
λ
87Roc
2 6 4 8 2 Laser intensity I [GW/cm ]
10
Fig. 1.1.47. Comparison between IB and PI absorption for an aluminum vapor plume generated by a pulsed Cu-vapor laser: 511 and 578 nm, 40 ns pulse duration, 40 mJ max. pulse energy [96Cha].
Photoionization, as well as Mie absorption by particles within the plume, can act as a starting mechanism for producing free electrons at the beginning of the interaction between laser-induced material vapor and laser radiation. This initial production of free electrons may lead to the start of the absorption via inverse bremsstrahlung [94Ade, 98Amo, 98Lun, 99Cal, 00Sch2]. Using (1.1.39) or (1.1.42) the inverse
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
49
α
α
bremsstrahlung absorption coefficient can be calculated for a variety of conditions. An example for this procedure based on the Lorentz oscillator model in (1.1.42) is given in Fig. 1.1.48 for a regime typical in drilling and ablation applications. Experimental values were obtained by transmission and reflection measurements [00Sch2] and are shown in Fig. 1.1.49 for several materials and energy densities. Very high values are reached that can lead to an absorption within the plume of up to nearly 100% of the incident laser pulse energy.
Fig. 1.1.48. Calculated absorption coefficients versus temperature at 10 MPa and for different wavelengths in an aluminum plasma during drilling/ablation [99Cal].
Fig. 1.1.49. Absorption coefficients in an excimer-laser induced plume during ablation of several materials in air at 0.1 MPa; estimated absorption length within plume 150 µm, λ = 248 nm (KrF-laser) [00Sch2].
For very high intensities, the combination of the absorption mechanisms described above can induce a considerable amount of absorption within the material vapor or the ambient gas leading to a gas breakdown [66Zel]. Such a breakdown may cause a partial or complete shielding of the workpiece. A theoretical treatment of this phenomenon is to be found in [01Maz]; the main result is given in Fig. 1.1.50. The consideration of the electronic level system yields a considerable decrease of the breakdown threshold compared to the classical approach dominated by inverse bremsstrahlung. One of the chief mechanisms is photoionization from excited states within the aluminum vapor. The drastic drop in the threshold (for instance at 394 nm) is caused by a resonant ionization process of the aluminum atoms (see also (1.1.38) and Fig. 1.1.37).
Laser intensity I [W/cm2 ]
10
9
Ar
10
8
10
7
10
6
10
5
10
4
10
3
10
2
XeCl
KrF
ArF
1
HeNe GaAs Nd II Nd Rubin
HD CO 2
10
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
2
1 Wavelength λ [µm]
0.1
Fig. 1.1.50. Intensity necessary to initiate breakdown in an aluminum vapor under consideration of inverse bremsstrahlung (1) and further mechanisms such as photoionization (2) [01Maz].
50
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
1.1.3.2.2.3 Refraction In addition to the absorbing effect of laser induced plasmas a refracting influence is observed that, in view of conducting a well defined process, might be even more detrimental. Due to a generally inhomogeneous density distribution of the interacting particles the refractive index inside the plasma also shows an inhomogeneous distribution which may act like a lens for the incident radiation. Two mechanisms contribute to the resulting index of refraction: the polarizability of heavy particles and the presence of free electrons. The latter will be dominating for laser radiation with wavelengths in the infrared region and for high electron densities. The index of refraction, which is an important property of the plasma, can be calculated according to [65Wha, 86Kit]:
n ( λ0 ) = 1 +
1 2ε 0
∑ α k ( λ0 ) N k − k
e2 2 λ Ne , 2 2 0 8 ε 0 me c 0
(1.1.47)
with Nk and αk(λ) beinLieg the number density of the heavy particles of species k and the corresponding polarizability. The dependence of the refractive index on temperature and composition is exemplarily shown in Fig. 1.1.51 for various plasmas of pure gases or vapors at CO2-laser wavelength [95Bec].
Fig. 1.1.51. Calculated index of refraction for plasmas consisting of various pure gases or metal vapors in dependence of the plasma temperature at constant pressure for the CO2-laser wavelength λ = 10.6 µm [95Bec].
The way how an inhomogeneous distribution of the index of refraction affects the beam propagation through a plasma is demonstrated in Figs. 1.1.52 and 1.1.53. For the welding process with high-power CO2-lasers, in addition to the change of intensity by a varying spot diameter on the workpiece, the laser beam will be laterally deflected when an asymmetry occurs in the plume. In view of the high practical relevance of these effects, they were extensively investigated theoretically [92Duc, 92Pou, 95Bec, 00Sch1], see e.g. Fig. 1.1.52, as well as experimentally [87Roc, 97Jue, 99Ker, 99Sch, 00Sch2], Fig. 1.1.53. It should be emphasized that, depending on the particular electron density distribution, the beam might also experience a focussing [01Sud].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
51
Fig. 1.1.52. Modeled defocusing effect of a plasma plume in dependence of the plume length zpl for Nd:YAG, COand CO2-laser radiation at 3 kW laser power and for two different plume temperatures Tpl. Plasma composition: 20 % Al vapor, 80 % He or Ar shielding gas [00Sch1].
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
52
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
a
[Ref. p. 62
b
.
c
.
Fig. 1.1.53. Calculated beam deflection and defocusing on the basis of an experimental refractive index distribution obtained by interferometry. CO2-laser at 3.6 kW on steel, beam diameter in the focus 200 µm [99Sch, 00Sch2].
1.1.3.2.3 Dynamical effects At sufficiently high intensity the workpiece material starts to evaporate very fast (see Sect. 1.1.3.1.2.2). As the vapor emits from the surface it displaces the ambient gas resulting in a shock wave which propagates in the surrounding atmosphere [68Ani, 73Ani, 90Ade, 92Ade, 93Smu, 94Maz2]. The strength of the shock is given by the evaporating mass flux and can be calculated by the Rankine–Hugoniot relations. In the case of strong evaporation, where the vapor leaves the Knudsen layer with sonic velocity, a centered rarefaction fan appears additionally, connecting the shock wave and the Knudsen layer. In a by now “traditional” theoretical approach of laser-supported absorption waves (LSA), the laser induced shock waves are classified in two different regimes: the laser-induced combustion waves (LSC) and the laser-induced detonation waves (LSD) as shown in Fig. 1.1.54. The distinctive feature is the location of the energy absorption: in the case of LSC waves the energy is deposited in a region close to the surface whereas in LSD waves most of the incident laser energy is absorbed within a narrow region behind the shock front shielding the workpiece from energy supply [73Ste, 75Fow, 78Pir, 80Mah, 84Dan, 84Woo]. Recent investigations, however, indicate that mixtures of these pure forms of LSA waves occur that require a more detailed description according to the particular processing parameters. A main parameter determining the character of the shock waves is the processing wavelength. As shown in Fig. 1.1.55 for Nd:YAG- and excimer-laser induced plumes a LSD-type shock wave is formed in the case of IRradiation, representing the absorption of the laser radiation at the very tip of the shock wave. With shorter wavelengths the plumes are changing their expansion behavior towards a more spherical shock wave shape. This change in morphology correlates to a shift in the regions where the main absorption takes place [01Bre], close to the surface for short wavelengths and more towards the wave’s front for longer wavelengths (see also Fig. 1.1.44). The development of a LSD wave in dependence on intensity is displayed in Figs. 1.1.56 and 1.1.57. Numerical simulations of the expansion based on the Euler equations provide the flow field, the shape and other properties of the shock, see Fig. 1.1.58. This approach identifies details such as areas of different particle density or areas where condensation of particles can occur [68Ani, 73Ani, 73Pro, 79Kni, 87Cha]. On the other hand, classical gasdynamic theories do provide useful insight into the basic behavior of laser-induced shock waves [59Sed, 65Rai, 69Hoh, 73Pir, 94Lu, 94Pra, 95Cal, 96Nic, 97Ade, 99Jeo], Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
53
see for example Fig. 1.1.59. In particular, they allow to calculate the high pressures at the workpiece’s surface, see Fig. 1.1.60. Experimentally deduced values are presented in Fig. 1.1.61. They are of practical interest insofar as they may cause severe damage to the workpiece during an ablation process. On the other hand, these high values can also be utilized in gaining higher efficiency of the treatment process, for example by melt expulsion during drilling. Another effect caused by the increase in pressure is the increase of the evaporation temperature which is described by the Clausius-Clapeyron theory (see (1.1.35)).
a
Fig. 1.1.54. Characteristic features of the simplified models of (a) LSC and (b) LSD waves [73Ste, 75Fow, 78Pir, 80Mah, 84Woo, 84Dan].
b
Fig. 1.1.55. Morphology of laserinduced shock waves for different processing wavelengths. Aluminum target. Nd:YAG (1064 nm, 532 nm, 355 nm): 12 ns pulse duration, 1011 W/cm2; KrF-Excimer (248 nm): 25 ns pulse duration, ca. 109 W/cm2 [01Bre, 00Sch2]. 100 LSD
Evaporation
Shock front velocity [km/s]
LSC
ν LSD
20 Pa 10 2 Pa 3 10 Pa
10
5
Shock wave
10 Pa 5
10 Pa 1 3
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
30 5 2 Power density [10 7/cm ]
50
Fig. 1.1.56. Development of laser-induced shock wave expansion for excimer-laser ablation. Evaporation, LSC and LSD regimes: 308 nm (XeCl), copper target [93Sch1].
54
1.1.3 Thermophysical and dynamical “response”
[Ref. p. 62
Fig. 1.1.57. Shadowgraphs of laserinduced shock waves in ambient air atmosphere at different intensities 30 ns after pulse beginning: Si3N4 target, 532 nm (Nd:YAG), 12 ns pulse duration [01Bre].
Fig. 1.1.58. Calculated pressure distribution and flow field in an LSD-wave sustained by a CO2-laser beam at (a) 0.66 µs (b) 1.63 µs (c) 2.19 µs. Pressure scale in 106 erg/cm3: 1: 1.8; 2: 3.6; 3: 7.2; 4: 14.4; 5: 28.8; 6: 57.6; 7: 115. Power density: 10 MW/cm2, spot diameter 0.22 cm [75Nie].
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
55
1.6 original Sedov theory modified Sedov theory measured values
Distance [mm]
1.2
0.8
0.4
0 10 2
10
10 3
Time t [ns]
Fig. 1.1.59. Comparison of shock front expansion data (copper target, λ = 248 nm (KrF), 30 ns (FWHM), 30 J/cm², 8.4 mJ/pulse) [95Cal] to models based on the Sedov theory of gasdynamic shock waves [59Sed]. The modification of the Sedov theory accounts for the temporal evolution of the laser pulse. Energy content of the shock wave 80 %.
Surface pressure p [bar]
10 4
10 3
10 2 Pirri Sedov Raizer
10
1 0
10 2
10
10 3
Time t [ns]
Fig. 1.1.60. Calculated temporal evolution of the surface pressure during pulsed laser ablation of aluminum with H = 47 J/cm2 [93Cal]. Comparison of the shock wave expansion described by a modified Sedov theory (dashed) [59Sed] (compare also Fig. 1.1.59), a 1DLSD wave theory (dash-dotted) [77Rai], and a twodimensional LSD wave model (solid) [73Pir] where a transition occurs from a 1D- to a 2D-expansion in dependence on the illuminated spot diameter (190 µm) at 9 ns.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
0.1
1
10
Fig. 1.1.61. Vapor pressure at various locations of a laser-induced shock wave deduced from experimental shock and vapor velocities via hydrodynamic relations of adiabatic shock front expansion. Pulsed Cu-vapor laser: 511 and 578 nm, 40 ns pulse duration, 40 mJ max. pulse energy. Target: aluminum [96Cha].
56
1.1.4 Simplified dependences in laser processes
[Ref. p. 62
1.1.4 Simplified dependences in laser processes 1.1.4.1 Energy coupling in laser processes The energy coupling to a workpiece during a laser process is defined by the coupling rate: ηA =
PA , PL
(1.1.48)
i.e. by the ratio of power absorbed and released as heat to the laser power that is supplied to the workpiece. It can be determined straightforwardly by measuring the heat input calorimetrically. If one, on the other hand, wants to calculate it from the optical constants reviewed in Sects. 1.1.2.2 and 1.1.2.3, one has to know in addition to the beam properties the • • •
geometry of the interaction zone, e.g. keyhole shape, cutting front, intensity distribution in the interaction zone (generally modified by reflections there) including angles of incidence and polarization, temperature distribution of the surface hit by the laser beam. In cases where plasma effects play a significant role like welding and drilling
• •
the interaction of the laser beam with the laser induced plasma above and in the workpiece and the energy transfer from plasma to workpiece
have to be taken into account, additionally. Complex process models are required to calculate energy coupling in a self-consistent way. For first estimations and for demonstration of the most important dependences simplified models as described in the following sections are sufficiently informative, however.
1.1.4.1.1 Coupling rate in laser cutting The interaction zone hit by the laser beam in cutting can be simplified by a half cylinder with diameter df inclined with an angle α relative to the beam path. For estimating α it is a useful choice to relate it to the focal diameter df and the sheet thickness s:
tan α =
s . df
(1.1.49)
Calculations in [95Dau] for a laser beam assumed to have a top hat intensity profile and to impinge on the half cylinder totally and only once yield results that are depicted in Fig. 1.1.62. The following trends become obvious: • • •
higher coupling efficiency for linear polarization parallel to cutting direction, higher coupling rate for shorter wavelengths at low aspect ratios (s/df), higher coupling rate for longer wavelengths at high aspect ratios.
Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
57
100 Fe CO2 , par. CO2 , circ.
Coupling rate ηA [%]
80
Nd:YAG, par. Nd:YAG, circ.
60
40
20
10 20 Aspect ratio s /d t
0
Fig. 1.1.62. Energy coupling efficiency in laser cutting.
1.1.4.1.2 Coupling rate in laser welding In welding the keyhole produced by the recoil pressure of vaporization acts as an efficient “absorber” by forcing the impinging laser beam to multiple reflections (and absorptions) before parts of it may escape. The total absorption in a keyhole can be estimated with a formula deduced by [45Gou] for “black cavities”. Assuming a conical keyhole with opening diameter df and depth s one obtains approximately [95Dau]: 2 ⎛d ⎛d ⎞ ⎞ 1 + (1 − A) ⎜ f − ⎜ f ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ 2s ⎝ 2s ⎠ ⎟ ⎝ ⎠ . ηA ≈ A df ⎞ df ⎛ A ⎜1 − ⎟ + ⎝ 2s ⎠ 2s
(1.1.50)
By taking values for the intrinsic absorptivity A at boiling temperature averaged over all possible angles of incidence and polarizations the results shown in Fig. 1.1.63 have been obtained. They are in good agreement with results from a self-consistent keyhole model [95Dau, 96Bec2]. It is obvious that the coupling rate strongly depends on the aspect ratio, especially if it is below 10. As in cutting, aluminum shows a lower coupling rate, compared to iron. At very high aspect ratios the differences vanish. The influence of plasma on energy coupling in a keyhole was investigated in [96Bec2]. Figure 1.1.64 shows the following main points for CO2-laser wavelength: • • •
the influence of plasma absorption increases with welding depth, the contribution of plasma absorption is larger at materials with lower absorptivity, e.g. Al, up to a quite high penetration depth Fresnel absorption is the dominating mechanism.
Towards lower wavelengths the interaction beam/plasma decreases strongly following approximately a λ2 to λ3 behavior, see Sect. 1.1.3.2.1.2. It can be expected, therefore, that in welding with Nd:YAGlasers the influence of plasma on energy coupling will be less important.
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
1.1.4 Simplified dependences in laser processes
[Ref. p. 62
ηA
58
Fig. 1.1.63. Energy coupling efficiency in keyhole welding with lasers.
Fig. 1.1.64. Influence of plasma absorption on keyhole welding with CO2-lasers.
1.1.4.2 Process windows An exact modeling of laser processes could not be achieved, up to now. For making the choice of laser types, layout of systems, and for process development with respect to a particular application it is sufficient, however, to have simple formulas at hand describing the basic dependences. A prerequisite for starting a laser process is to choose the power level beyond a threshold. Above it the yield of process (velocity, depth, width) increases with power, generally. This is true until a region is reached where nonlinear effects start to disturb the process either by reducing the output or the quality. Figure 1.1.65 illustrates the situation for keyhole welding. The lower limit of the process window is caused by the onset of deep penetration, the upper one by plasma effects. Inside the process window it is useful to estimate the maximum achievable velocity, the efficiency of the process and the most important parameters determining these values. In the following, simple formulas are collected describing threshold, velocity and thermal efficiency.
λ
λ
λ
2
Fig. 1.1.65. Processing window in keyhole welding. The lower limit, i.e. the threshold, is determined by the onset of deep penetration. The threshold value for the ratio power P over focus diameter df increases with thermal conductivity λth, boiling temperature Tb, and decreasing absorptivity A of the material to be welded. The upper limit of the process window is caused by the onset of plasma effects, which are governed by the ionisation potential Ei of the atmosphere and the metal vapor, respectively. Due to the influence of the laser wavelength on the absorptivity of the workpiece material and the absorption coefficient of the plasma the process window gets wider with decreasing wavelength. Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
59
1.1.4.2.1 Power threshold The minimum power Pth – the threshold value – required for a laser process is determined by a geometrical factor (G), a numerical factor (B) influenced by the beam intensity distribution as well as by material (M) and velocity / interaction time (V) related terms through a general expression:
Pth = B ⋅ M ⋅V . G
(1.1.51)
The various terms can be calculated from approximations and are collected in Table 1.1.15. A set of material properties appears in the combination
M =
TP ⋅ λth ηA
(1.1.52)
in all cases. The process temperature TP is characteristic for the processes under consideration and is, e.g., the melting temperature for cutting. Whenever in the η A column the absorptivity A is addressed, it is recommended to take values for perpendicular incidence averaged between room and process temperature (see Sects. 1.1.2.2 and 1.1.2.3). In other cases the coupling rate values calculated by coupling models have to be taken (see Sect. 1.1.4.1.2). An example may illustrate the general dependences: For keyhole welding (1.1.51) was deduced in the following form [96Bec2]:
P = df
⋅
Tb ⋅ λ th A
v ⋅ df + 1.1 . 4κ
(1.1.53)
In this case, the relevant geometrical factor G is the focus diameter df. The factor B having the means that a Gaussian beam is considered. Since for deep penetration welding the metal vapor value is needed to keep the keyhole open, the boiling temperature Tb is the appropriate choice for the process temperature. The velocity-related expression shows a weak dependence on welding velocity v which can be neglected in a first approximation, especially at low velocities (related to temperature diffusivity κ). Table 1.1.15. Constituent terms of (1.1.51) and (1.1.52). The cases of ablation and welding correspond to Gaussian intensity distributions, the expressions for cutting have been derived for line sources.
Process
Case
G
B
TP
ηA
V
ablation
One-temperature model (τ >> τph)
df
1.97 Tb
A
1/arctan( 2 2 lth / df)
0.89 Tb
A
1 / lth
d f2 / 4
df
Tb
A
low velocity
df
Tb
A
~1
2.5
Tm
ηA
~1
95Dau
2
Tm
ηA
~1
88Pet
0.5
Tm
ηA
~1
95Dau
s s df
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
96Bec2
general
inert gas cutting
oxygen cutting
(1.1.28) (1.1.27)
One-temperature model, one-dimensional limit: df >> lth >> lα keyhole welding
Reference
steel
s
v d f / 4κ + 1.1
60
1.1.4 Simplified dependences in laser processes
[Ref. p. 62
For ablation, the onset of vaporization is taken as the start of material removal. Vaporization can be the dominant material removal process at very high pulse power, but even at processes dominated by melt expulsion is it necessary to create a driving force by the recoil pressure of vapor production and expansion. It is important to note, however, that in drilling the threshold increases with penetration depth [99Dau]. In most cases the threshold shows up in terms of power divided by focus diameter. For cutting, the minimum power scales with the sheet thickness s, mainly. Only in the case of ablation with short pulses, the intensity is the right measure for the threshold. If for the cases of ablation and welding other intensity distributions than Gaussian are considered, the factor B needs to be modified. Table 1.1.16 gives correction factors for top hat and Airy profiles, the latter being representative for unstable resonators, the first for beams homogenized e.g. transmitted by glass fibers. The correction factors depend on the dimensionality of heat flux and are given for the two limiting cases characterized by the ratio between the thermal diffusion length and the focal diameter. Table 1.1.16. Correction factors for B in case of non-Gaussian beams [00Sch1].
l th / d f >> 1
l th / d f << 1
Gaussian
1
1
Top hat
1.25
2
Airy
0.61
Profile
1.1.4.2.2 Factors determining process velocity Above the threshold the velocity v of laser processes follows an approximately linear behavior of the form [95Dau]: v ≈ −a1
η P κ + a2 A ⋅ L . df H P s df
(1.1.54)
The first term takes into account heat losses, the second one is a result of the energy balance between absorbed laser power (according to (1.1.48)) and the specific enthalpy H P required to heat the material volume to be treated to the required process temperature. The latter can be calculated from density ρ , latent heat values of phase transitions L, specific heat cp, and the process and room temperatures Tp and T∞: H P = ρ (∑ L +
TP
∫c
p
(1.1.55)
dT ) .
T∞
Table 1.1.17. Coefficients of (1.1.54). Process
a1
a2
Reference
ablation
stationary
~0
1
Sect. 1.1.3.1.2.2
keyhole welding
0.6 < vb / κ < 12
1.05
0.53
95Dau
v b / κ > 12
0
0.483
95Dau
~2
~0.76
95Dau
inert gas cutting
In ablation processes the calculation of the process enthalpy is impeded by the difficulty to know the phase composition and temperature of the removed material ranging from just molten to superheated at temperatures above boiling point, see Sects. 1.1.3.1.2.2 and 1.1.3.1.3.2. Lando lt -Bö rnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
Ref. p. 62]
1.1 Fundamentals of laser-induced processes
61
Table 1.1.17 gives summaries of the coefficients a1 and a2 taken from approximative models. The values for keyhole welding have been obtained from a two-dimensional model [73Swi, 95Dau]. It has to be distinguished between two velocity regimes, the confining value being determined by the so-called Peclet number which relates the velocity v to the melt width b and the thermal diffusivity κ . For inert gas cutting a linear approximation to the models of [93Sch2, 93Ros] was used to calculate the coefficients.
1.1.4.2.3 Factors determining efficiency The efficiency of laser processes is determined by the coupling rate η A (1.1.48) discussed in Sect. 1.1.4.1.2 and by the thermal efficiency η th according to:
η P = η A η th .
(1.1.56)
The thermal efficiency describes to what extent the absorbed power (released heat) produces the desired effect on the workpiece, e.g. the melt in welding:
η th ≡
vbsHP . ηA P
(1.1.57)
An analysis on the basis of analytic approximations [95Dau] showed that, for a given process, the thermal efficiency depends on the following parameter combination, mainly,
X ≡
η A PL ⋅ . λth TP s
(1.1.58)
It is worth to note, that the combination of material parameters in (1.1.58) is simply the inverse of the factor M in (1.1.52) which determines the threshold value. Figure 1.1.66 shows for four different metals the values of thermal efficiency calculated on the basis of [73Swi]. It demonstrates that e.g. for welding of aluminum at least 2 kW per millimeter of welding depth are necessary to achieve a satisfying efficiency level.
Thermal efficiency η th [%]
100
80
Experimental Al 6110; sandblasted Al 6110; untreated Al 5182; untreated
Calculated Ti Fe Al Cu
60
40
20
0
3 5 1 2 4 Power/welding depth P/s [kW/mm]
Lando lt -Börnst ein New Ser ies VIII/1C
6
Fig. 1.1.66. Thermal efficiency in 2D-keyhole welding. Experimental data for several Al-alloys together with curves calculated according to [73Swi] using the following values of C = ηA/L⋅Tm [kW/mm]. Ti: 24, Fe: 10, Al: 4, and Cu: 1.5.
62
References for 1.1
References for 1.1 (2/2) 41Ros
Rosenthal, D.: Welding J. 20 (1941) 220s.
45Gou
Gouffé, A.: Rev. Optique 24 (1945) 1.
54Mae
Maecker, H., Peters, T.: Z. Physik 139 (1954) 448.
59Sed
Sedov, L.I.: Similarity and Dimensional Methods in Mechanics. London: Cleaver–Hume Press, 1959.
61Bar
Bartels, J., Borchers, H., Ten Bruggencate, P., Hausen, H., Hellwege, K.-H., Schäfer, K., Schmidt, E. (eds.): Landolt-Börnstein II/4, Berlin: Springer, 1961.
65Rai 65Rea 65Wha
Raizer, Yu P.: Sov. Phys. JETP 21(5) (1965) 1009. Ready, J.F.: J. Appl. Phys. 36 (1965) 462 Wharton, C.B.: Microwave Techniques. In: Huddlestone, R.H., Leonard, S.L. (eds.): Plasma Diagnostic Techniques. New York, NY: Academic Press, 1965.
66Zel
Zel’dovich, Ya B., Raizer, Yu P.: Physics of Shock Waves and High-Temperature Hydrodynamic Phenomena I, New York, NY: Academic Press, 1966.
67Tan
Tanenbaum, B.S.: Plasma Physics, New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 1967.
68Ani 68Bas
Anisimov, S.I.: Sov. Phys JETP 27(19) (1968) 182. Basov, N.G., Gribkov, V.A., Krokhin, O.N., Sklizkov, G.V.: J. Sov. Phys. JETP 27(4) (1968) 575.
69Hoh
Hohla, K., Büchl, K., Wienecke, R., Witkowski, S.: Z. Naturforsch. 24a (1969) 1244.
70Chu 70Hor 70Rai 70Stu
Chun, M.K., Rose, K.: J. Appl. Phys. 41 (1970) 614. Hora, H., Wilhelm, H.: Nuclear Fusion 10 (1970) 111. Raizer, Yu P.: Sov. Phys. JETP 31(6) (1970) 1148. Stull, D.R., Prophet, H.: JANAF Thermochemical Tables, US Dept. of Commerce, 1970.
71Kar
Karasev, I.G., Kirillov, V.M., Norskii, V.E., Samoilov, V.I., Ulyakov, P.I.: Sov. Phys. Techn. Phys. 15 (1971) 1523.
72Dab 72Pae
Dabby, F., Paek, U.-C.: IEEE J. Quant. Electron. 8 (1972) 107. Paek, U.-C., Gagliano, F. P.: IEEE J. Quant. Electron. 8 (1972) 112.
73Ani 73Het 73Mul
Anisimov, S.I., Rakhmatulina, A.Kh.: Sov. Phys. JETP 37(3) (1973) 441. Hettche, L.R., Schriempf, J.T., Stegman, R.L.: J. Appl. Phys. 44 (1973) 4079. Mulser, P., Sigel, R., Witkowski, S.: Physics Reports (Section C of Physics Letters) 6(3) (1973) 187. Pirri, A.: The Physics of Fluids 16(9) (1973) 1435. Prokhorov, A.M., Batanov, V.A., Bunkin, F.V., Fedorov, V.B.: IEEE J. Quant. Elec. 9(5) (1973) 503. Stegman, R.L., Schriempf, J.T., Hettche, L.R.: J. Appl. Phys. 44(8) (1973) 3675.
73Pir 73Pro 73Ste
References for 1.1
63
73Swi
Swift-Hook, D.T., Gick, A.E.F.: Welding J. 52 (1973) 492s.
74Ani 74Gob 74Low 74Mar
Anisimov, S.I., Kapeliovich, B.L., Perel’man, T.L.: Sov. Phys. JETP 39 (1974) 375. Gobrecht, H.: In: Bergmann-Schaefer: Lehrbuch der Experimentalphysik, Vol. I, Berlin: de Gruyter (1974) 712 Lowder, J.E., Pettingill, L.C.: Appl. Phys. Lett. 24 (1974) 204. Martynyuk, M.M.: Sov. Phys. Tech. Phys. 19 (1974) 793.
75Fow 75Nie
Fowler, M.C., Smith, D.C.: J. Appl. Phys. 46(1) (1975) 138. Nielson, P.E.: J. Appl. Phys. 46(10) (1975) 4501.
76All 76Ash
Allmen, M. van: J. Appl. Phys. 47 (1976) 5460. Ashcorf, N.W., Mermin, N.D.: Solid State Physics, Fort Worth: Saunders College Publishing, 1976. Klemens, P. G.: J. Appl. Phys. 47 (1976) 2165. Steverding, B., Dudel, H.P.: J. Appl. Phys. 47 (1976) 1940.
76Kle 76Ste 77Mal 77Rai
Malz, D., Vogler, K.: Exp. Technik Physik 25(6) (1977) 555. Raizer, Yu P.: Laser-induced Discharge Phenomena, Studies in Soviet Science, New York: Consultants Bureau, 1977.
78Pir 78Zhi
Pirri, A.N., Root, R.G., Wu, P.K.S.: AIAA Journal 16(12) (1978) 1296. Zhiryakov, B.M., Popov, N.I., Samokhin, A.A.: Sov. Phys. JETP 48 (1978) 247.
79Kni
Knight, C.J.: AIAA J. 17(5) (1979) 519.
80Mah 80Wen
Maher, W.E., Hall, R.B.: J. Appl. Phys. 51(3) (1980) 1338. Wende, B.: Das Plasma. In: Gobrecht, H. (ed.): Bergmann-Schaefer: Lehrbuch der Experimentalphysik Vol. IV: Aufbau der Materie, Part 2, 2nd ed., Berlin: de Gruyter, 1980.
83Zie
Ziesche, P., Lehmann, G.: Ergebnisse in der Elektronentheorie der Metalle, Berlin: Springer, 1983.
84Dan 84Pop
Dan‘shchikov, E.V., Lebedev, F.V., Ryazanov, A.V.: Sov. J. Plasma Phys. 10(2) (1984) 225. Poprawe, R.: Materialabtragung und Plasmaformation im Strahlungsfeld von UV-Lasern, Ph.D. thesis, Germany: TH Darmstadt, 1984. Woodroffe, J.: In: Onorato, M. (ed.): Proc. Fourth Intl. Symposium on Gas Flow and Chemical Lasers GCL '82 (Stresa, Italy), New York, NY: Plenum Press (1984) 97.
84Woo 85Bey 85Mat
Beyer, E.: Einfluß des laserinduzierten Plasmas beim Schweißen mit CO2-Lasern, Ph.D. thesis, TH Darmstadt, Germany, Düsseldorf: DVS, 1985. Matsunawa, A.: In: Albright, C. (ed.): Proc. Laser Welding, Machining, and Materials Processing, Proc. ICALEO '85 (San Francisco, CA), Berlin: Springer (1986) 41.
86Jel 86Kit 86Miy
Jellison, G.E., Lowndes, D.H., Mashburn, D.N., Wood, R.F.: Phys. Rev. B 34 (1986) 2407. Kittel, C.: Introduction to Solid State Physics, 6th ed., New York, NY: Wiley, 1986. Miyamoto, I., Maruo, H., Arata, Y.: Proc. SPIE 668 (1986) 11.
87All1
Allmen, M. van: Laser-Beam Interactions with Materials, Materials Science 2, Berlin: Springer, 1987.
64 87All2 87All3 87Cha 87Knu 87Lar 87Pee 87Pop 87Roc
References for 1.1 Allen, P.B.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 59(13) (1987) 1460. Allen, P.B.: Phys. Rev. B 36(5) (1987) 2920. Chan, C.L., Mazumder, J.: J. Appl. Phys. 62(11) (1987) 4579. Knudtson, J.T., Green, W.B., Sutton, D.G.: J. Appl. Phys. 61(10) (1987) 4771. Larciprete, R., Stuke, M.: Appl. Phys. B 42 (1987) 181. Peebles, H.C., Williamson, R.L.: In: Arata, Y. (ed.): Proc. Intl. Conf. on Laser Advanced Materials Processing LAMP '87 (Osaka, Japan), Osaka: High Temperature Society of Japan (1987) 19. Poprawe, R., Wehner, M., Brown, G., Herziger, G.: Proc. SPIE 801 (1987) 191. Rockstroh, T.J., Mazumder, J.: J. Appl. Phys. 61(3) (1987) 917.
88Aut 88Pet 88Sok 88Ste 88Wyb
Autric, M., Vigliano, P., Astic, D., Bournot, P., Dufresne, D.: Proc. SPIE 1020 (1988) 103. Petring, D., Abels, P., Beyer, E., Herziger, G.: Feinwerktechnik & Meßtechnik 96 (1988) 364. Sokolowski, W., Herziger, G., Beyer, E.: Proc. SPIE 1020 (1988) 96. Steen, W.M., Dowden, J., Davis, M., Kapadia, P.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 21 (1988) 1255. Wybourne, M.N.: In: Properties of Silicon, EMIS Data Review Series 4, London: INSPEC (1988) 37.
89Jos 89Sok
Joseph, D.D.: Rev. Mod. Phys. 61 (1989) 41. Sokolowski, W., Herziger, G., Beyer, E.: Proc. SPIE 1132 (1989) 288.
90Ade 90Ber 90Car 90Fab
Aden, M., Beyer, E., Herziger, G.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 23 (1990) 655. Bermejo, D., Fabbro, R., Sabatier, L., Leprince, L., Orza, J.M.: Proc. SPIE 1279 (1990) 118. Carslaw, H.S., Jaeger, J.C.: Conduction of heat in solids, 2nd ed., Oxford: Clarendon, 1990. Fabbro, R., Bermejo, D., Orza, J.M., Sabatier, L., Leprince, L., Granier, V.: Proc. SPIE 1276 (1990) 461. Joseph, D.D., Preziosi, L.: Rev. Mod. Phys. 62 (1990) 375. Kosolapova, T.I.: Handbook of high temperature ceramics, New York: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, 1990. Matsunawa, A.: Proc. Laser Materials Processing ICALEO '90 (Boston, MA). In: Ream, S.L., Dausinger, F., Fujioka, T. (eds.): Orlando, FL: LIA 71 (1991) 313. Michaelis, A., Schäfer, J.-S., Uhlenbusch, J., Viöl, W.: Proc. SPIE 1276 (1990) 231. Miller, R., DebRoy, T.: J. Appl. Phys. 68(5) (1990) 2045. Ventzek, P.L.G., Gilgenbach, R.M., Sell, J.A., Heffelfinger, D.M.: J. Appl. Phys. 68(3) (1990) 965.
90Jos 90Kos 90Mat 90Mic 90Mil 90Ven 91Che 91Gai 91Gil 91Sap 91Sib 91Sok 91Wie 92Ade 92Bas 92Bec
Cheung, N.H., Zheng, Q.Y., Kwok, H.: J. Appl. Phys. 69(9) (1991) 6349. Gaidarenko, D.V., Leonov, A.G., Chekhov, D.I.: Sov. J. Plasma Phys. 17(8) (1991) 534. Gilgenbach, R.M., Ventzek, P.L.G.: Appl.. Phys. Lett. 58(15) (1991) 1597. Sappey, A.D., Gamble, T.K.: Appl. Phys. B 53 (1991) 353. Sibold, D., Urbassek, H. M.: Phys. Rev. A 43 (1991) 6722. Sokolowski, W.: Diagnostik des laserinduzierten Plasmas beim Schweißen mit CO2-Lasern, Ph.D. Thesis, TH Aachen, Germany, Aachen: Verlag der Augustinus-Buchhandlung, 1991. Wiedeman, L., Helvajian, H.: J. Appl. Phys. 70(8) (1991) 4513. Aden, M., Beyer, E., Herziger, G., Kunze, H.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 25 (1992) 57. Basu, S., DebRoy, T.: J. Appl. Phys. 72 (1992) 3317. Beck, M., Berger, P., Nagendra, P., Dantzig, J.A.: In: Waidelich, W. (ed.): Laser in der Technik – Proc. 10th Intl. Congress Laser '91 (Munich, Germany), Berlin: Springer (1992) 429.
References for 1.1 92Duc 92Fab 92Kar1 92Kar2 92Koo 92Miy 92Pou 92Smi 92Ven 93Ade 93Ani 93Ber 93Bou 93Cal 93Geo 93Maz 93Meh 93Pou 93Qiu 93Ros 93Sch1 93Sch2 93Smu
94Ade 94Kap
65
Ducharme, R., Kapadia, P.: In: Farson, D., Steen, W.M., Miyamoto, I. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Symposium ICALEO '92 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 75 (1992) 188. Fabbro, R.: In: Matsunawa, A., Katayama, S. (eds.): Proc. Intl. Conf. on Laser Advanced Materials Processing LAMP '92 (Nagaoka, Niigata, Japan), Osaka: High Temperature Society of Japan (1992) 305. Kar, A., Chan, C.L., Mazumder, J.: Trans. ASME 114 (1992) 14. Kar, A., Rockstroh, T., Mazumder, J.: J. Appl. Phys. 71 (1992) 2560. Kools, J.C. , Baller, T., Zwart, T.D., Dieleman, J.: J. Appl. Phys. 71(9) (1992) 4547. Miyamoto, I., Maruo, H.: In: Matsunawa, A., Katayama, S. (eds.): Proc. Intl. Conf. on Laser Advanced Materials Processing LAMP '92 (Nagaoka, Niigata, Japan), Osaka: High Temperature Society of Japan (1992) 311. Poueyo, A., Deshors, G., Fabbro, R., de Frutos, A.M., Orza, J.M.: In: Matsunawa, A., Katayama, S. (eds.): Proc. Intl. Conf. on Laser Advanced Materials Processing LAMP '92 (Nagaoka, Niigata, Japan), Osaka: High Temperature Society of Japan (1992) 323. Smithells, C.J.: In: Brandes, E.A. (ed.): Smithells metals reference book, 7th ed., Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1992. Ventzek, P.L.G., Gilgenbach, R.M., Ching, C.H., Lindley, R.A.: J. Appl. Phys. 72(5) (1992) 1696. Aden, A., Kreutz, E.W., Voss, A.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 26 (1993) 1545. Anisimov, S.I., Bäuerle, D., Luk’yanchuk, B.S.: Phys. Rev. B 48(16) (1993) 12076. Berger, P., Griebsch, J., Beck, M., Hügel, H.: In: Geiger, M., Hollmann, F. (eds.): StrahlStoff-Wechselwirkung bei der Laserstrahlbearbeitung: Ergebnisse des Schwerpunktprogramms der DFG 1991 bis 1992, Bamberg, Germany: Meisenbach (1993) 15. Boulmer-Leborgne, C., Hermann, J., Dubreuil, B.: Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. 2 (1993) 219. Callies, G.: Experimentelle Untersuchungen der physikalischen Wechselwirkung zwischen Material und Laserstrahl beim Abtragen mit gepulsten Hochleistungslasern, Diploma thesis, Inst. f. Strahlwerkzeuge, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, 1993. Geohegan, D.B., Puretzky, A.A., Hettich, R.L., Zheng, X.Y., Haufler, R.E., Compton, R.N.: Trans. Mat. Res. Soc. Jpn. 17 (1993) 349. Mazhukin, V.I., Gusew, I.V., Smurov, I., Flamant, G.: In: Denney, P., Miyamoto, I., Mordike, B.L. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '93 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 77 (1993) 213. Mehlman, G., Chrisey, D.B., Burkhalter, P.G., Horwitz, J. , Newman, D.A.: J. Appl. Phys. 74(1) (1993) 53. Poueyo-Verwaerde, A., Fabbro, R., Deshors, G., de Frutos, A.M., Orza, J.M.: J. Appl. Phys. 74(9) (1993) 5773. Qiu, T.Q., Tien, C.L.: J. Heat Transfer 115 (1993) 835. Rossmann, A., Simon, G.: Theorie zum Laserstrahlschneiden. In: VDI-Technologiezentrum Physikalische Technologien (ed.): Schneiden mit CO2-Lasern, Düsseldorf, Germany: VDIVerlag, 1993. Schutte, K.: Prozeßdiagnostik und technologische Untersuchungen zur Materialbearbeitung mit Excimerlasern, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1993. Schulz, W., Becker, D., Franke, J., Kemmerling, R., Herziger, G.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 26(9) (1993) 1357. Smurov, I., Aksenov, L., Flamant, G.: In: Denney, P., Miyamoto, I., Mordike, B.L. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '93 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 77 (1993) 242. Aden, M.: Plasmadynamik beim laserinduzierten Verdampfungsprozeß einer ebenen Metalloberfläche, Ph.D. thesis, TH Aachen, Germany, Aachen: Shaker Verlag, 1994. Kaplan, A.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 27 (1994) 1805.
66 94Lin 94Lu 94Maz1 94Maz2 94Pra 94Sei 94Szy 95Bec 95Bul 95Cal 95Dau 95Dum 95Her 95Mai 95Mat 95Ohj 95Ver 95Wit 96Al 96Bec1 96Bec2 96Cha 96Eng 96Gan 96Gri 96Hue 96Kel 96Mat 96Nic 96Ohm 96Olf
References for 1.1 Lindley, R.A., Gilgenbach, R.M., Ching, C.H., Lash, J., Doll, G.L.: J. Appl. Phys. 76(9) (1994) 5457. Lu, J., Ni, X.-W., He, A.-Z.: Proc. SPIE 2004 (1994) 100. Mazhukin, V.I., Smurov, I., Flamant, G., Dupuy, C.: Thin Solid Films 241 (1994) 109. Mazhukin, V.I., Samarskii, V.V.: Surv. Math. Ind. 4 (1994) 85. Prat, C., Sarnet, T., Autric, M., Inglesakis, G.: Proc. SPIE 2502 (1994) 701. Seidel, B., Beersiek, J., Beyer, E.: Proc. SPIE 2207 (1994) 290. Szymanski, Z., Kurzyna, J.: J. Appl. Phys. 76(12) (1994) 7750. Beck, M., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 28 (1995) 2430. Bulgakov, A.V., Bulgakova, N.M.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 28 (1995) 1710. Callies, G., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 28 (1995) 794. Dausinger, F.: Strahlwerkzeug Laser: Energieeinkopplung und Prozeßeffektivität. Habilitation thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany. Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1995. Dumord, E., Jouvard, J.M., Grevey, D.: In: Mazumder, J., Matsunawa, A., Magnusson, C. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '95 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 80 (1995) 951. Hermann, J., Thomann, A.L., Boulmer-Leborgne, C., Dubreuil, B., Giorgi, M.L.D., Perrone, A., Luches, A., Mihailescu, I.N.: J. Appl. Phys. 77(7) (1995) 2928. Maiwa, T., Miyamoto, I., Mori, K.: In: Mazumder, J., Matsunawa, A., Magnusson, C. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '95 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 80 (1995) 708. Matsunawa, A., Kim, J.-D., Takemoto, T., Katayama, S.: In: Mazumder, J., Matsunawa, A., Magnusson, C. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '95 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 80 (1995) 719. Ohji, T., Shiwaku, T., Kirimura, K., Hirata, Y.: In: Mazumder, J., Matsunawa, A., Magnusson, C. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '95 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 80 (1995) 729. Verwaerde, A., Fabbro, R., Deshors, G.: J Appl. Phys. 78 (1995) 2981. Witke, T., Lenk, A., Schultrich, B., Schultheiss, C.: Surface Coatings and Technology 74/75 (1995) 580. Al-Wazzan, R.A., Hendron, J.M., Morrow, T.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 96–98 (1996) 170. Beck, M.: In: Dausinger, F., Bergmann, H.W., Sigel, J. (eds): Proc. 6th European Conf. on Laser Treatment of Materials ECLAT '96 (Stuttgart, Germany), Wiesbaden, Germany: AWT (1996) 61. Beck, M.: Modellierung des Lasertiefschweißens, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1996. Chang, J.J., Warner, B.E.: Appl. Phys. Lett 69(4) (1996) 473. Engin, D., Kirby, K.W.: J. Appl. Phys. 80 (1996) 681. Ganesh, R.K., Bowley, W.W., Bellantone, R.R., Hahn, Y.: J. Comp. Phys. 125 (1996) 161. Griebsch, J.: Grundlagenuntersuchungen zur Qualitätssicherung beim gepulsten Lasertiefschweißen, PhD thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1996. Hüttner, B., Rohr, G.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 103 (1996) 269. Kelly, R., Miotello, A.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 96–98 (1996) 205. Matsunawa, A., Kim, J.D., Katayama, S., Semak, V.V.: In: Duley, W.W., Shiabata, K., Poprawe, R. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '96 (Detroit, MI), Orlando, FL: LIA 81 (1996) B58. Nicolas, G., Autric, M.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 96–98 (1996) 296. Ohmura, E., Fukumoto, I.: Int. J. Jap. Soc. Prec. Eng. 30 (1996) 128. Olfert, M., Duley, W.W.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 29 (1996) 1140.
References for 1.1 96Sch2 96Tsu 96Wit
97Ade 97Hug 97Jan 97Jue 97Koe 97Lac 97Liu 97Maz 97Mod 97Sch1 97Sch2 97Sch3 97Szy 97Whi 97Wil 97Zhi1 97Zhi2 98Amo 98Doy 98Dul 98Fab 98Her1 98Her2 98Hue 98Lun 98Mat 98Ohm 98Pin
67
Schellhorn, M., Eichhorn, A.: Optics & Laser Technology 28(5) (1996) 405. Tsukamoto, S., Hiraoka, K., Asai, Y., Irie, H.: In: Duley, W.W., Shiabata, K., Poprawe, R. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '96 (Detroit, MI), Orlando, FL: LIA 81 B76. Witke, T.: Optische Plasmaspektroskopie und Kurzzeituntersuchungen an gepulsten Laser-, Bogen und Kanalfunkenplasmen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Dresden, Germany, Aachen: Shaker Verlag, 1996. Aden, M., Kreutz, E.W., Schlüter, H., Wissenbach, K.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 30 (1997) 980. Hugenschmidt, M., Schmitt, R., Althaus, M.: Proc. SPIE 2869 (1997) 1017. Jandeleit, J., Russbüldt, P., Urbasch, G., Hoffmann, D., Treusch, H.G., Kreutz, E.W.: Proc. SPIE 3092 (1997) 481. Jüptner, W., Franz, Th., Sikau, J., Sepold, G.: Laser Physics 7(1) (1997) 202. Körner, C.: Theoretische Untersuchungen zur Wechselwirkung von ultrakurzen Laserpulsen mit Metallen, PhD thesis, Univ. of Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1997. Lacroix, D., Jeandel, G.: J. Appl. Phys. 81(10) (1997) 6599. Liu, X., Du, D., Mourou, G.: IEEE J. Quant. Electron. 33 (1997) 1706. Mazhukin, V. I., Nosov, V. V., Callies, G., Schittenhelm, H., Berger, P.: Proc. 15th IMACS World Congress (Berlin) Vol. III, Berlin: Wiss. u. Technik Verlag (1997) 271. Modest, M. F.: J. Laser Appl. 9 (1997) 137. Schittenhelm, H., Callies, G., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 109/110 (1997) 493. Schellhorn, M., Eichhorn, A.: Proc. SPIE 3092 (1997) 522. Schellhorn, M., Eichhorn, A., Hohenberger, B.: Frühjahrstagung der DPG (Mainz, Germany), Verhandl. DPG (VI) 32 (1997) 221. Szymanski, Z., Kurzyna, J., Kalita, W.: J Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 30 (1997) 3153. White, G.K., Minges, M.L.: Int. J. Thermophysics 9 (1997) 1269. Willis, D.A., Xu, X., Poon, C.C., Tam, A.C.: In: Fabbro, R., Kar, A., Matsunawa, A. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '97 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 83 (1997) A71. Zhigilei, L.V., Kodali, P.B.S., Garrison, B.J.: J. Phys. Chem. B 101 (1997) 2028. Zhigilei, L.V., Kodali, P.B.S., Garrison, B.J.: Chem. Phys. Lett. 276 (1997) 269. Amoruso, S., Armenante, M., Berardi, V., Bruzzese, R., Velotta, R., Wang, X.: Appl. Surf. Sci 127–129 (1998) 1017. Doyle, L.A., Martin, G.W., Al-Khateeb, A., Weaver, I., Riley, D., Lamb, M.J., Morrow, T., Lewis, C.L.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 716. Duley, W.W.: Laser Welding, New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons, 1998. Fabbro, R., Chouf, K., Sabatier, L., Coste, F.: In: Beyer, E., Chen, X., Miyamoto, I. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '98 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 85 (1998) F179. Herrmann, R.F.W., Gerlach, J., Campbell, E.E.B.: Appl. Phys. A 66 (1998) 35. Hermann, J., Vivien, C., Carricato, A.P., Boulmer-Leborgne, C.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 645. Hügel, H., Berger, P., Dausinger, F.: In: Beyer, E., Chen, X., Miyamoto, I. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '98 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 85 (1998) G141. Lunney, J.G., Jordan, R.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 941. Matsunawa, A., Seto, N., Mizutani, M., Katayama, S.: In: Beyer, E., Chen, X., Miyamoto, I. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '98 (Orlando, FL), Orlando, FL: LIA 85 (1998) G151. Ohmukai, M., Takigawa, Y., Kurosawa, K.: J. Appl. Phys. 83 (1998) 3556. Pinho, G.P., Schittenhelm, H., Duley, W.W., Schlueter, A., Jahani, H.R., Mueller, R.E.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 983.
68 98Pur 98Ret 98Sch1 98Sch2 98Sch3 98Vog 98Zef 99Agu 99Arn 99Bre 99Cal 99Dau 99Fuh 99Jeo 99Ker 99Rai 99Sch 99Sia 00Cha 00Sch1 00Sch2 01Bre 01Maz 01Sud
References for 1.1 Puretzky, A.A., Geohegan, D.B.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 248. Rethfeld, B., Kaiser, A., Vicanek, M., Simon, G.: Proc. SPIE 3343 (1998) 388. Schittenhelm, H., Callies, G., Straub, A., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 31 (1998) 418. Schittenhelm, H., Callies, G., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: J. Thermophys. Aeromech. 5(2) (1998) 255. Schittenhelm, H., Callies, G., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 922. Vogel, N., Kochan, N.: Appl. Surf. Sci. 127–129 (1998) 928. Zefferer, H.: Dynamik des Schmelzschneidens mit Laserstrahlung, PhD thesis, RWTH Aachen, Germany, Aachen: Shaker Verlag, 1998. Aguilera, J.A., Aragon, C.: Appl. Phys. A 69 (1999) S475. Arnold, N., Gruber, J., Heitz, J.: Appl. Phys. A 69 (1999) S87. Breitling, D., Schittenhelm, H., Berger, P., Dausinger, F., Hügel, H.: Appl. Phys. A 69 (1999) S505. Callies, G.: Modellierung von qualitäts- und effektivitätsbestimmenden Mechanismen beim Laserabtragen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1999. Dausinger, F., Abeln, T., Breitling, D., Radtke, J., Konov, V., Garnov, S., Klimentov, S., Kononenko, T., Tsarkova, O.: LaserOpto 31(3) (1999) 78. Fuhrich, T., Berger, P., Huegel, H.: In: Christensen, P., Denney, P., Miyamoto, I., Watkins, R. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '99 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 87 (1999) E166. Jeong, S.H., Greif, R., Russo, R.E: J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 32 (1999) 2578. Kern, M.: Gas- und magnetofluiddynamische Maßnahmen zur Beeinflussung der Naht-qualität beim Laserstrahlschweißen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1999. Raiber, A.: Grundlagen und Prozeßtechnik für das Lasermikrobohren technischer Keramiken, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Stuttgart: B.G. Teubner Verlag, 1999. Schittenhelm, H., Müller, J., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: In: Christensen, P., Denney, P., Miyamoto, I., Watkins, R. (eds.): Proc. Laser Materials Processing Conf. ICALEO '99 (San Diego, CA), Orlando, FL: LIA 87 (1999) E195. Siano, S, Pini, R., Salimbeni, R.: Appl. Phys. Lett. 74 (1999) 1233. Chang, C.-L.: Berechnung der Schmelzbadgeometrie beim Laserstrahlschweißen mit Mehrfokustechnik, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Munich: Herbert Utz Verlag, 2000. Schellhorn, M.: CO-Hochleistungslaser: Charakteristika und Einsatzmöglichkeiten beim Schweißen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Munich: Herbert Utz Verlag, 2000. Schittenhelm, H.: Diagnostik des laserinduzierten Plasmas beim Abtragen und Schweißen, Ph.D. thesis, Univ. of Stuttgart, Germany, Munich: Herbert Utz Verlag, 2000. Breitling, D., Schittenhelm, H., Berger, P., Dausinger, F., Hügel, H.: Proc. SPIE 4184 (2001) 534. Mazhukin, V.I., Nosov, V.V., Smurov, I., Nickiforov, M.G.: In: German Scientific Laser Society WLT (ed.): Proc. First Intl. WLT-Conf. on Lasers in Manufacturing 2001 (Munich, Germany), Stuttgart, Germany: AT-Fachverlag (2001) 199. Sudnik, W., Erofeew, W., Radaj, D., Berger, P., Hügel, H.: Simulation der Fügetechniken – Potentiale und Grenzen: Beiträge zum DaimlerChrysler-Technologiekolloquium 2001 (Wiesensteig, Germany). In: Pollmann, W., Radaj, D. (eds.): DVS-Berichte 214, Düsseldorf, Germany: Verl. für Schweißen und Verwandte Verfahren, DVS (2001) 94.
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
75
2.1 Surface treatment H.W. BERGMANN
Based on the fundamentals of interaction between laser radiation and substrate material, which are described in Part 1, Chap. 1, the present chapter reports on the technical application of laser surface treatment. The great advantage of the laser beam compared to other heat sources for surface treatment is its flexibility which allows an effective and locally defined treatment with good process control. Generally, these processes can use gaseous, liquid or solid additives and supporting media like shielding gases and coatings for improvement of the absorption. Laser surface treatment is used to change the material properties (e.g. surface hardening or impulse strengthening), to change the material and the geometry of the workpiece (e.g. coating, thermal spraying or LPVD/LCVD – laser physical/chemical vapor deposition – processes) or to change the system properties (e.g., cleaning and smoothing, changing the stress state and structuring). Depending on the desired effects, the mechanisms are either thermal, mechanical or chemical. However, an exact separation of mechanisms is difficult, because all of them interact somehow (Fig. 2.1.1). The different laser surface techniques can be divided into laser macro processing and thin-film technologies (Fig. 2.1.2).
Laser surface treatment Laser macro processing
Thin layer technology
CO2-lasers, Nd:YAG-lasers
Q-switched Nd:YAG, Excimer
cw / ms-pulsed / 0.1 ms-pulsed layer thickness: 0.05 − 10 mm
pulse duration 0.1 − 200 ns layer thickness: 0.05 − 50 µm
Surface hardening Remelting / alloying Coating
Cleaning and smoothing Alloying Coating Shock hardening
Fig. 2.1.1. Different mechanisms of influence to the material.
Fig. 2.1.2. Subdivision of laser surface treatments.
2.1.1 Laser macro processing The technique of laser macro processing is limited to thin-layer techniques with an affected depth of typically 50 µm and is usually performed with CO2- or Nd:YAG-lasers, operating either in the cw or
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
76
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
millisecond pulsed mode (see Fig. 2.1.2). Examples for these processes are surface hardening of ironbased materials (solid-state hardening), remelting of cast iron or alloying techniques using a liquid phase.
2.1.1.1 Solid-state hardening Surface hardening of steels using laser radiation is a multipurpose process for generating hard, wearresistant layers on tools and components and is applicable to transformable iron-based materials [86Bra]. The surface of the workpiece is heated up to a temperature above the Ac3 temperature (end of austenization for hyper- and hypoeutectique steels) using the laser beam as a heat source (short-time austenitization, see also Sect. 2.1.1.1.2). The cold workpiece behaves as a very efficient heat sink and therefore no external quenching is necessary (self-quenching). Due to the rather short dwell time in the austenite phase region (several seconds), the peak temperature (control temperature) has to be higher than the austenitizing temperature used for conventional hardening to guarantee a complete transformation and a sufficient homogenization of the austenite. One of the great advantages of the laser beam hardening process is the relatively low distortion of the workpiece. A schematic drawing of the process is given in Fig. 2.1.3.
Fig. 2.1.3. Schematic drawing of the laser hardening process.
2.1.1.1.1 Physical basics When laser light is incident on a metallic workpiece a proportion of the radiation is reflected while the rest is absorbed by the surface and transformed into heat. This leads to heating of the workpiece in the absorption layer and, through heat conduction, to a heating of deeper layers [83Kou, 83Rot, 88Gei]. Controlling factors are the laser beam intensity, the interaction time and the material properties of the workpiece as already discussed in Part 1, Chap. 1. This can be summarized in two basic equations which describe on the one hand energy transfer and on the other mechanical changes which occur through thermal expansion: ∂T – ∇ (λ ∇ T) = Q ∂t with
(2.1.1)
T: temperature, λ: thermal conductivity, Q: heat source,
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
ρ with
2.1 Surface treatment
∂ 2ui ∂t
2
–
∂ σij = ρ Fi ∂x j
77
(2.1.2)
ρ: density, ui: movement of a volume element, σij: component of the stress tensor, Fi: force acting on a volume element.
The material's reaction is thus a function of both, temperature and stress fields, as long as the heating rates are relatively moderate (power densities < 105 W/cm2). The changes caused by the temperature field and the thermodynamic properties of the material are bound to intrinsic time constants [94Kör]. The phase reactions that occur during the thermal cycle of the hardening process of steels are summarized in TTT (Time-Temperature-Transformation) and TTA (Time-Temperature-Austenization) diagrams [54Wev, 72Ros, 73Ohr, 76Ohr]. The efficiency of optical to thermal energy transformation depends on the optical properties of the material for the wavelength of the incident radiation. Within the range of wavelengths commercially available high-power lasers provide (CO2 lasers 10.6 µm, Nd:YAG lasers 1.064 µm, diode lasers 800…940 nm), metals normally show relatively low absorption coefficients (see e.g. Part 1, Chap. 1, Table 1.1.2 with the absorption coefficient α = 1/lα according to Part 1, Chap. 1, (1.1.5)). The absorption coefficients vary with increasing temperature and depend on the surface structure of the workpiece. Several possibilities exist to enhance the absorption [88Dau, 88Rud, 92Jas]: -
thermochemical reactions between the substrate and the surrounding gas atmosphere, absorbing coatings, use of polarized laser light.
2.1.1.1.2 Material science basics Heating of a steel above the Ac1 temperature (begin of austenization) leads to a phase transformation from the iron bcc (body centered cubic) crystal structure, called ferrite, into a fcc (face centered cubic) structure, called austenite. Between Ac1 and Ac3 (see above) (and Acm – complete austenization for hypereutectique steels, dissolution of carbides) the iron carbide decomposes and the carbon dissolves into the austenite which has a high solubility for carbon. The carbon concentration gradient established after a certain time is defined by diffusion coefficients which are both temperature and concentration dependent. At high heating rates, a maximum temperature well above the Ac3 or Acm point is necessary to get a homogeneous distribution of carbon. Due to the temperature gradient, this can only be reached within the outer surface layers. With increasing distance from the surface, decreasing effects of austenitization can be observed [91Fri, 91Lep]. When the laser irradiation ends, the surface layer is cooled down rapidly by heat conduction into the core of the workpiece, which remains cold. This effect is called self-quenching. The resulting transformed microstructure depends on the cooling rate, the chemical composition and the final temperature of the surface [85Wis]. Figure 2.1.4 shows calculated time-temperature curves for laser beam hardening with typical CO2 lasers. Typical hardness-depth profiles for laser beam hardening of a 0.45 % carbon steel are displayed in Fig. 2.1.5 [91Bac].
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
78
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
Fig. 2.1.4. Calculated time-temperature curves for laser beam hardening with a typical CO2 laser (cross section of the laser beam: 10 × 10 mm2, feed rate: 0.3 m/min.) [96Mor], z: depth below the surface, 1: z = 0 mm, 2: z = 0.5 mm, 3: z = 1.1 mm, 4: z = 2.0 mm, 5: z = 3.7 mm, 6: z = 6.6 mm, 7: z = 20 mm.
Fig. 2.1.5. Hardness-depth profiles hardening of 0.45 % carbon steel. temperatures (feed rate: 0.3 m/min.) 1200 °C, 2: Tc = 1250 °C, 3: Tc = 1350 °C.
[Ref. p. 101
for laser beam Different control [91Bac]: 1: Tc = 1300 °C, 4: Tc =
In addition to microstructural and property changes, the temperature field causes thermal expansion (according to the different expansion coefficients of ferrite and austenite) and volumetric changes due to phase transformation. This results in a transient stress field. The temperature dependent material properties (particularly the flow stress) and the hysteresis of the α → γ, γ → α phase transformation (α – body centered cubic (ferrite), γ – face centered cubic (austenite) iron) lead to elastic and plastic deformations and cause dimensional changes, distortions and residual stresses. A functional design and a locally defined heat treatment help to minimize distortions and to generate compressive residual stresses within the critical, high-strained areas of the workpiece. This helps to improve fatigue strength and therefore leads to an extended fatigue lifetime [96Mül].
2.1.1.1.3 Production-related aspects According to DIN EN ISO 11145, a system for laser beam hardening comprises a laser source, an optical arrangement for beam guiding and shaping, and a machine for manipulation of the workpiece (or the laser beam). For surface hardening of larger areas, high-power lasers in the multi-kilowatt range are necessary. The electrical overall efficiency and other properties for common laser types are given in Table 2.1.1. The laser-beam-hardening process can be performed either power- or temperature-controlled. In the first case, the output power of the laser and the time of irradiation is controlled (kept constant). In the second case, the temperature of the surface is measured within the hot zone of the laser spot (for example by pyrometric measurement) and, via a closed loop system kept at a predetermined level through control of the output power [88Ber, 93Gei]. To achieve an appropriate depth of the hardened zone, a power density of 104...105 W/cm2 and irradiation times between 0.1 s and 3 s are required. Different optical systems and components are available to generate a beam profile with the desired shape and intensity distribution [88Jüp, 90Pie, 90Rud, 90Tön1, 90Tön2, 92Ber, 94Agr]. Large areas of the surface can be hardened by movement of the laser spot (hardened tracks). If those tracks are overlapping, the first track is tempered by the second one, accompanied by changes in microstructure and properties. This should be avoided by choosing suitable hardening strategies [91Gei, 95Mül].
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
79
Table 2.1.1. Properties of common laser types for surface hardening. Laser type CO2 lasers
Properties gas laser, very high output powers available wavelength: 10.6 µm (absorption coating is necessary) beam guiding and shaping via cooled mirrors electrical overall efficiency < 12 %
Nd:YAG lasers
solid-state laser wavelength: 1064 nm beam guiding via glass fibers, beam shaping via lenses electrical overall efficiency < 5 %
Diode lasers
semiconductor laser, arrays of many single diodes wavelength: 800…940 nm electrical overall efficiency > 20 % small in size and weight
2.1.1.1.4 Time scheme of the irradiation The effect of pulsed irradiation on the resulting microstructures, properties and hardness depths has been discussed in [97Ber]. Different hardness-depth profiles attained using either cw or pulsed radiation with various frequencies are shown in Fig. 2.1.6. The results are generally similar, but using the pulsed mode, a slight increase of the hardening depth can be achieved. On the other hand, by using pulsed radiation with frequencies below 50 Hz, the risk of surface melting increases, while the desired compressive residual stress is not achieved [95Dom].
Fig. 2.1.6. Hardness-depth profiles for laser beam hardening in the cw and pulsed mode with different pulse frequencies (Nd:YAG-laser, feed rate: 0.3 m/min.) [97Ber]: 1: cw, 2: 100 Hz, 3: 50 Hz, 4: 25 Hz, 5: 12.5 Hz.
2.1.1.1.5 Observed degradations and their reasons Table 2.1.2 gives possible degradations which can be observed occasionally (also in classical surface hardening) and their metallurgical and/or process-related reasons.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
80
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
Table 2.1.2. Degradations of laser-surface-hardened parts and their metallurgical and process-related reasons [96DIN1]. Characteristic feature 1 surface hardness too low
Reason conditional on the heat treatment Relevant fault during surface hardening 1.1
untransformed ferrite, pearlite, or too less carbides dissolved
a) b)
1.2 proportion of martensite too low 1.2.1 due to formation of bainite and/or a) pearlite and/or ferrite b) c) d) e) 1.2.2 due to retained austenite a) b) c) d)
1.3
e) martensite too soft (also locally a) defined) b) c)
austenitizing temperature too low time of irradiation too short
austenitizing temperature too low time of irradiation too short (self-)quenching effect too low severe oxidation of the surface decarburization austenitizing temperature too high (overheating) time of irradiation too long (oversoaking) not, too late or not adequately tempered not, too late or not adequately subzero-treated carburization due to coatings tempering temperature too high tempering time too long tempering because of overlapping tracks not tempered or too late tempered tempering temperature too low tempering time too short
1.4
proportion of retained austenite a) too high and/or too less carbide b) precipitated c)
2 surface hardness too high
2.1
martensite within the surface a) layer too hard b) c)
not tempered tempering temperature too low not tempered a sufficient number of times
3 insufficient depth of hardening
3.1
spatially incomplete austenitiza- a) tion b) proportion of martensite too low a)
austenitization temperature too low time of irradiation too short insufficient quenching rate
4 depth of harde- 4.1 ning too high
depth of austenitization too high
austenitizing temperature too high time of irradiation too long
5 too much distortion
(thermal and/or transformation a) induced) internal stresses too high or too asymmetric b) c)
3.2
5.1
a) b)
too rapidly or too unsteadily heated and austenitized unsuitable fixture of the workpiece unfavorable size/shape of the heattreated area
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
81
Table 2.1.2 continued. Characteristic feature 6 cracks
Reason conditional on the heat treatment Relevant fault during surface hardening 6.1
(thermal and/or transformation a) induced) internal stresses too high (fracture toughness ex- b) ceeded) c) d) e)
too rapidly or too unsteadily heated and austenitized not tempered tempering temperature too low tempering time too short overlapping tracks
7 deviations in the shape of edges and/or surfaces
7.1
partial melting
temperature too high time of irradiation too long power flux density of the beam too high overheating of an edge
a) b) c) d)
2.1.1.2 Remelting In contrast to solid-state hardening, the surface is heated up to a temperature above the melting point. The aim of laser surface melting is to generate a surface layer with better properties than the substrate material resulting from rapid solidification. The quenching rates that can be obtained can be as high as those achieved in completely different techniques, like melt spinning or powder atomization. These extremely high cooling rates determine the nature and stability range of phases, their distribution, size and morphology [96Mor]. The solidification process can be characterized by three important parameters: -
the quenching rate ε = dT/dt, the solidification velocity R = υ • n (velocity of the solidification front), the temperature gradient G = n ∇ T across the liquid/solid interface.
These parameters are related by the equation
ε = R G .
(2.1.3)
As Fig. 2.1.7 illustrates, these parameters depend on the shape of the melt pool [93Her], which is determined by the laser parameters, the material properties and the melt dynamics due to convection within the pool [84Böt, 86Rap, 90Kre]. Laser v C
A R
α
Gx
α
L
time of melt pool existence: τ = L/υ, temperature gradient: Gz = dT , Gx = dT ,
v
Gz
Fig. 2.1.7. Schematic drawing of the melting pool and definition of the characteristic parameters of the solidification process:
dz
dx
solidification velocity: R = υ cos α, B
TM
cooling rate: dT = ε = R G
dt
(cooling rate corresponds to quenching rate).
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
82
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
u eq
ia
x
d
rit
ic
10 =
4
ε
10 2
ed
d en
[Ref. p. 101
10
2
K/
s
0
rit de
nd
10 0
−2
10
Solidification velocity R [mm/s]
ic
10
10
−2
r
la
lu el
10
10
c −4
pl
an
ar
−4
10 −1
10 0 10 1 10 2 Temperature gradient G [K/mm]
10 3
Fig. 2.1.8. Influence of the solidification velocity R and the temperature gradient G on the solidification morphology [86Kur].
The actual values of the variables ε , R and G determine the resulting microstructure [81Kur, 83Cly, 83Sah], which can be epitaxial, dendritic, planar, cellular or even amorphous. The relationship is given in Fig. 2.1.8 [86Kur]. Remelting can be performed without additives on cast iron and steels and with or without additives on several nonferrous metals. If additives are used, they can either be pre-deposited on the surface of the workpiece (two-step process), see Fig. 2.1.9a, or they can be supplied continuously during the melting process (one-step process), see Fig. 2.1.9b. In the one-step process, the additives can either be supplied in backhand or forehand direction (Fig. 2.1.9c and d).
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
83
Fig. 2.1.9. Different methods of laser surface remelting: (a) two-step process, (b) one-step process, (c) backhand remelting, (d) forehand remelting.
2.1.1.2.1 Remelting of cast iron Iron-carbon alloys can solidify according to the metastable Fe-Fe3C phase diagram or the Fe-graphite equilibrium phase diagram. The relative stability of cementite (Fe3C) and graphite is effected by alloying elements. Generally, the stability of graphite increases with increasing content of carbon and silicon (gray cast iron). Rapid cooling favors the formation of cementite. This effect is used in laser surface treatment of cast iron. If the surface of gray cast iron is melted, the extraction of the heat into the bulk substrate leads to resolidification and a self-quenching effect of the surface layer. The melt solidifies as ledeburite, an eutectic mixture of Fe3C and austenite. The mechanical properties of this layer differ dramatically from those of the gray cast iron, especially the hardness and wear resistance is improved. Figure 2.1.10 gives an example for a hardness-depth profile of a laser-remelted camshaft made of GGL 25. The hardness of the resolidified layer reaches between 800 and 900 HV 0.1. A remarkable spread of the values within the transition area is due to microstructural effects (primary Fe-dendrites and ledeburite) [92Mül]. Typical hardness values for different alloyed cast irons obtained after laser surface melting are given in Table 2.1.3. Table 2.1.3. Hardness of various remelted cast irons in the as-quenched state [85Ber]. Cast-iron composition [wt.-%] C Si Mn 3.5 2.0 ... 3.5 0.5 ... 2.5 1.7 ... 3.0 2.4 6.0 2.1 5.0 ... 2.7 0.3 ...
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Hardness [HV] P 1.0 2.0 ... ... ... ...
Cr ... ... ... 12.0 ... 28.0
Ni ... ... 33.0 ... ... ...
1100...1200 1100...1200 450...550 450...550 600...650 600...650
84
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
Fig. 2.1.10. Hardness-depth profile of a laser surface remelted camshaft of lamellar gray cast iron (GGL25) [92Mül]; material: lamellar gray cast iron (GGL25), laser output power: 8 kW, intensity profile: line (16 mm × 1.5 mm), feed rate: 0.8 m/min., shielding gas: CO2, pre-heating: 480 °C, after-process treatment: 580 °C/30 min.
[Ref. p. 101
Fig. 2.1.11. Influence of the laser output power and the feed rate on the depth of the molten zone [92Mül]; material: ductile cast iron (GGG60), intensity profile: line (15 mm), surface preparation: phosphate, initial surface roughness: Rz = 15 µm.
The depth of the melt typically varies between 0.5 and 1.5 mm. Figure 2.1.11 demonstrates the influence of the laser output power and the feed rate on the depth of the molten zone [92Mül]. The effect of the surface roughness before surface melting on the melting depth can be neglected. The roughness of the surface after laser surface melting is in the magnitude of about 10 µm and depends on process parameters and supply of the shielding gas [88Gil]. The properties of the heat-affected zone between the surface layer and the unaffected substrate depend on the microstructure of the matrix. This is an important factor in deciding upon the layer specifications to meet the requirements of the component in service.
2.1.1.2.2 Remelting of aluminum alloys One of the main difficulties in surface remelting of aluminum and aluminum alloys is the poor absorption of infrared laser light (see e.g. Part 1, Chap. 1, Table 1.1.3 and Fig. 1.1.1). The absorption can be improved by grinding or sand blasting of the surface, providing higher roughness, but usually coatings are used to get satisfactory results. Furthermore, use of shielding gas is necessary to prevent reactions between the melt and the atmosphere (for example oxygen in the atmosphere). A significant increase of the surface hardness and therefore of wear resistance can be achieved by the following mechanisms: -
grain refinement, precipitation hardening, dual phase hardening / dispersion hardening.
An example for laser surface remelting of nonferrous metals without using additives is the surface treatment of eutectic or near eutectic Al-Si-alloys (e.g. pistons for automotive engines). Due to rapid quenching, laser surface remelting results in a very close-grained microstructure, which has better wear resistance than the cast structure, although the hardness of the surface layer is not enhanced significantly [96Mor]. The range of the solid solubility in binary aluminum alloys can be extended significantly by rapid quenching. This leads to a combination of solid solution hardening and/or precipitation hardening. The strength of Al-alloys at room temperature and at elevated temperatures can be improved by precipitation
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
85
hardening. For an efficient precipitation hardening process a high solid solubility of the 2nd element in the Al-rich crystal at higher temperatures is desired, simultaneously with almost no solid solubility at room temperature. If in addition high-temperature strength is required, it is necessary that stable intermetallic phases with high melting point precipitate. Table 2.1.4 gives various examples for alloying elements, their solid solubility and the melting point of the intermetallic compounds, which can be precipitated.
Table 2.1.4. Solid solubility of transition metals in binary aluminum alloys and some of their intermetallic compounds. Alloying elements
Solid solubility Intermetallic Melting in rapid compound temperature of solidification the inter[at. %] metallic compound [°C] 1.9 5.0 6.0 CrAl7 725 940 Cr2Al11 1010 CrAl4 1170 CrAl3 4.4 FeAl3 1160 9.0 MnAl6 710 822 MnAl4 880 MnAl3 7.7 NiAl3 854 1133 Ni2Al3
Ce Co Cr
Solid solubility in conventional solidification [at. %] 0.01 0.01 0.38
Fe Mn
0.03 0.70
Ni
0.02
Ti Zr V
0.74 0.08 0.20
2.0 3.0 2.0
W Mo
0.02 0.07
1.9 1.0
TiAl3 ZrAl3
1340 1580
Comments
rarely used improvement of corrosion resistance
suitable for Al-Si-alloys, formation of extremely hard Mn-silicides very fine eutectic with good strength and ductility suitable alloying element suitable alloying element extremely high hardness, but inhomogeneous layers extremely high hardness, but inhomogeneous layers
Laser remelting allows to disperse hard particles into the surface layers. These particles have to meet the following conditions: -
thermal stability within the temperature range of application, chemical stability against the liquid metal (e.g. no oxides that can be reduced by aluminum), higher hardness than the wear partner of the component, no porosity (explosion under the laser irradiation), within a suitable density range (otherwise sedimentation or floating of the powders).
Table 2.1.5 gives examples for hard particles which can be dispersed in aluminum alloys.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
86
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
Table 2.1.5. Properties of ceramic components for dispersion in an Al-matrix. Density [g/cm3]
Hardness [GPa]
Melting / decomposition temperature [°C]
Price / availability
Comments
3.97 5.8 2.3
18...23 10...15 10...13
2050 (melt.) 2700 (melt.) 1723 (melt.)
++ + +++
not chemically attacked not chemically attacked
SiC
3.2
20...30
2300 (decomp.)
++
dissociated, if the particle size is too small
TiC Cr2C3 B4C diamond
4.9 6.7 2.51 3.5
approx. 28 10...18 approx. 30 –
3140 (melt.) 1980 (melt.) 2450 (melt.) decomp. dep. on heating rate
0 – + ––
Si3N4
3.18
8...19
1900 (decomp.)
+
TiN AlN
5.4 3.2
16...20 approx. 12
2930 (melt.) 2235 (decomp.)
– ++
4.5
15...28
2900 (melt.)
–
Material
Oxides Al2O3 ZrO2 SiO2 Carbides
Nitrides reaction products around the particles
Borides TiB2
The appropriate particle size is between 5 µm and 50 µm (for a layer thickness of some 100 µm). If the particles are too large, they sometimes contain thermal cracks. Smaller particles are inefficient barriers to plastic deformation, hence wearing out of the surface can occur. A volume fraction of 10...30 % of hard particles within the surface layer has shown good results. 2.1.1.2.3 Remelting of titanium alloys Titanium alloys have inherent advantages of high strength combined with low density. Their tribological behavior is characterized by high friction coefficients and poor wear resistance. The hardness values are typically 300...350 HV. TiN, which is formed by the reaction Ti + ½ N2 → TiN, has a hardness of about 2400 HV. Thus it can be used to generate hard and wear-resistant surface layers on titanium and titaniumalloy components. Conventional solid-state treatments (e.g. annealing within a nitrogen atmosphere or plasma heat treatment) depend on diffusion processes and therefore on a parabolic law for the increase of the layer thickness. Within reasonable times, a layer thickness of some 10 µm can be reached. Laser remelting of the surface within a reactive atmosphere (“gaseous laser alloying”) is an alternative treatment for titanium and Ti-alloys. It can provide a layer thickness of typically 0.5...1 mm. If the layer is too thick, it tends to crack. The hardness of the surface depends on the laser parameters and on the composition of the atmosphere (Fig. 2.1.12). With pure nitrogen, a surface hardness of ∼900 HV can be reached [86Ber]. Table 2.1.6 Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
87
gives examples of the properties of gaseous laser-alloyed TiAl6V4 (IMI318) for different thermochemical treatments. Dispersing of particles (e.g. TiC) into titanium alloys is also possible [90Gas], but the extreme reactivity of titanium melts restricts the number of appropriate powders.
Fig. 2.1.12. Hardness-depth profiles of laser-nitrided TiAl6V4: (a) Influence of the laser output power; CO2-laser, cw-mode, feed rate: 1 m/min., pre-heating: none, atmosphere: N2, 1: 700 W, 2: 600 W, 3: 500 W, 4: 400 W, 5: 300 W, 6: 200 W. (b) Influence of the atmosphere (nitrogen content); CO2-laser, cw-mode, feed rate: 1m/min., preheating: none, atmosphere: 1: 100 % N2, 2: 90 % N2, 3: 75 % N2, 4: 50 % N2, 5: 25 % N2, 6: 10 % N2.
Table 2.1.6. Properties of gaseous laser-alloyed TiAl6V4 (IMI318) for different thermochemical treatments. Treatment
Color
Microstructure
Phases
as received
silver
equiaxial grains
α', β-Ti
remelted under N2
golden
TiN-dendrites in α'-matrix
α'-Ti + TiN
dense layer
remelted under CH4 + Argon
gray
TiC-precipitates in α'-matrix
α'-Ti + TiC
inhomogeneous layer
repeatedly remelted under CH4 + Argon
silver
TiC-dentrides in α'-matrix
α'-Ti + TiC
homogeneous, dense layer
remelted under O2
dark gray
massive oxide
TiO + TiO2
inhomogeneous layer thickness
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Comments
88
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
2.1.1.2.4 Remelting of magnesium alloys Due to their very low specific densities (1.75...1.85 g/cm3), magnesium alloys are of great interest for some technical application, but the poor wear and corrosion properties cause some restrictions. Table 2.1.7 summarizes the chemical composition of some commonly used Mg-alloys and the microhardness that can be reached by laser surface remelting without additives, due to grain refinement and microstructural changes [94Gal]. A significant increase of the surface hardness can be obtained by laser alloying with powders of elements that can form hard and stable intermetallic phases with magnesium. Table 2.1.8 gives some examples. The results of laser-alloying experiments are summarized in Table 2.1.9 [94Gal, 95Gal]. Table 2.1.7. Chemical composition (wt.%) of common Mg-alloys and their microhardness after laser surface remelting. Alloy
Condition Al
cp Mg Al 80 AZ 61 AZ 91 WE 54
as cast extruded extruded
Zn
0.8 6.0 9.0
Mn
1.0 1.0
Y
Zr
RE
Mg
2.9
99.9 rem rem. rem. rem.
0.3 0.3
cast, T6
5.1
0.5
Hardness of substrate [HV 0.1] 35
Hardness of laser track [HV 0.1] 45
60 70 95
75 115 75 (85 after precipitation hardening)
Table 2.1.8. Alloying elements and their intermetallic compounds with magnesium. Alloying element
Melting point [°C]
Max. solubility [at. %]
Intermetallic compound
Al Cu
660 1083
11.5 0.013
Ni Si
1453 1410
0.04 0.01
Mg17Al12 Mg2Cu MgCu2 Mg2Ni Mg2Si
Melting point of the compound [°C] 402 568 819 760 (peritectic) 1085
Table 2.1.9. Results of laser-alloying experiments on Mg-alloys. Substrate
Alloying element Al Al Al
Alloying content [at. %] 29 16 26
cp Mg cp Mg AZ 91
Hardness HV 0.1 200 100 180
cp Mg Al 80 AZ 61 AZ 91 WE 54
Cu Cu Cu Cu Cu
41 33 30 45 31
180 230 220 180 230
WE 54
Cu
38
220
Structure of the intermetallic compound compact eutectic fibers compact
Comments
compact oriented dendrites dendrites compact needle shaped dendrites needles
resulting microstructure strongly dependent on the alloying elements of the substrate
relatively low increase of hardness, above 34 at. % Al completely intermetallic compound due to extended solubility after rapid quenching
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
89
Table 2.1.9 continued. Substrate
Alloying element Ni Ni Ni Ni
Alloying content [at. %] 32 28 36 32
cp Mg Al 80 AZ 91 WE 54
cp Mg AZ 61 AZ 61 WE 54
Hardness HV 0.1 300 250 320 300
Si Si Si Si
23 22 28 27
260 220 300 280
Structure of the intermetallic compound oriented dendrites oriented dendrites dendrites needle shaped dendrites
Comments
dendrites dendrites dendrites dendrites
hardness values up to 750 HV are possible with a Si content of ∼55 at. % (primary Si with Si-Mg2Sieutectic)
hardness can be enhanced by higher Ni contents, but the resulting embrittlement leads to cracking
2.1.1.2.5 Observed degradations of surface-remelted components and their reasons Table 2.1.10 gives possible degradations which can be observed occasionally on surface-remelted components of cast iron and their metallurgical and/or process-related reasons. An overview of the degradations on surface-remelted components (with additives) of nonferrous alloys is given in Table 2.1.11. Table 2.1.10. Occasionally complained degradations on surface-remelted components of cast irons and their metallurgical and process-related reasons [96DIN2]. Characteristic feature 1 too many pores within the surface layer
Reason conditional on the heat treatment 1.1 overheating of the melt
Relevant fault during surface hardening a) time of irradiation too long or intensity too high
2 graphite within the 1.2 incomplete melting of the surface a) molten layer layer
time of irradiation too short or intensity too low
3 melted depth too low
3.1 line energy too low
a) b)
energy flux density too low feed rate too high
4 melted depth too high
4.1 line energy too high
a) b)
energy flux density too high feed rate too low
5 surface hardness too low
5.1 carbide content within the surface layer too low
a)
5.2 content of retained austenite too high within the surface layer
a)
solidification rate too high, due to too high energy flux density and too short time of irradiation inadequate cooling rate below the Ac1-temperature not or insufficiently tempered
b) 6 surface hardness too high
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
6.1 carbide content within the surface layer too high
a)
6.2 content of martensite too high within the surface layer
a)
solidification rate too low, due to too less energy flux density and too long time of irradiation cooling rate below the Ac1temperature too high
90
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
Table 2.1.10 continued. Characteristic feature 7 too much distortion
Reason conditional on the heat treatment 7.1 thermal and transformation induced stresses too high or too asymmetric
7.2 displacement of the melt too large
8 cracks
8.1 thermal and transformation induced stresses too high or too asymmetric (fracture toughness exceeded)
Relevant fault during surface hardening a) too rapidly or too unsteadily heated and remelted b) unsuitable fixture for the workpiece c) unfavorable size/shape of the heat-treated area a) inhomogeneous energy distribution b) inadequate position of the workpiece a) b) c) d) a)
8.2 too much deformation in the incompletely solidified state (hot cracking) b) c)
9 deviations in the shape of edges and/or surfaces
9.1 surface of the melt deforms too much
a) b) c) d) e)
pre-heating temperature too low too rapidly or too unsteadily heated and remelted too rapid or too unsteady cooling not or insufficiently tempered inadequate energy distribution of the beam unsuitable fixture of the workpiece unfavorable size/shape of the heat-treated area time of irradiation too long energy flux density too high inhomogeneous intensity distribution inadequate position of the workpiece unfavorable size/shape of the heat-treated area
Table 2.1.11. Occasionally complained degradations on surface-remelted components of nonferrous metals (with additives) and the metallurgical and process-related reasons [96DIN2]. Characteristic feature 1 too many pores in the surface layer
Reason conditional on the heat treatment 1.1 overheating of the melt
Relevant fault during surface hardening a) time of irradiation too long or intensity too high
2 washing-in of the substrate material
1.2 incomplete melting of the surface a) layer
time of irradiation too short or intensity too low
3 melted depth too low
3.1 line energy too low
energy flux density too low feed rate too high insufficient pre-deposition or feed rate of the additive material too low
3.2 content of additives too low
a) b) a)
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
91
Table 2.1.11 continued. Characteristic feature 4 melted depth too high
Reason conditional on the heat treatment 4.1 line energy too high 4.2 content of additives too high
5 surface hardness too low
5.1 content of hard particles within the surface layer too low
Relevant fault during surface hardening a) energy flux density too high b) feed rate too low a) excessive pre-deposition or feed rate of the additives too high a)
b) c)
6 surface hardness too high
6.1 content of hard particles within the surface layer too high
a)
b) c) 7 too much distortion
7.1 thermal and transformation induced stresses too high or too asymmetric
a) b) c)
7.2 displacement of the melt too large
a) b)
8 cracks
8.1 thermal and transformation induced stresses too high or too asymmetric (fracture toughness exceeded) 8.2 too much deformation in the incompletely solidified state (hot cracking)
a) b) c) a) b) c)
9 deviations in the shape of edges and/or surfaces
9.1 surface of the melt deforms too much
a) b) c) d) e)
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
inadequate solidification rate due to unsuitable choice of energy density and irradiation time inadequate cooling rate after the resolidification insufficient pre-deposition or feed rate of the additive material too low inadequate solidification rate due to unsuitable choice of energy density and irradiation time inadequate cooling rate after the resolidification excessive pre-deposition or feed rate of the additives too high too rapidly or too unsteadily heated and remelted unsuitable fixture of the workpiece unfavorable size/shape of the heat-treated area inhomogeneous energy distribution inadequate position of the workpiece too rapidly or too unsteadily heated and remelted too rapid or too unsteady cooling not or insufficient tempered inadequate energy distribution of the beam unsuitable fixture of the workpiece unfavorable size/shape of the heat-treated area time of irradiation too long energy flux density too high inhomogeneous intensity distribution inadequate position of the workpiece unfavorable size/shape of the heat-treated area
92
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
2.1.1.3 Laser cladding Laser cladding is used to generate a surface layer of an alloy different from the substrate material to improve the wear and/or corrosion properties of a component [86Maz, 89Wu]. Laser cladding can be performed either in a one-step process [90Lug1, 92Lug, 94Lug] or in a two-step process (pre-deposited material method) [90Mar1] (compare with Fig. 2.1.9a and b). Furthermore, the two-step process can be performed either in a free-cladding or in a shape-determined way using a crucible (Fig. 2.1.13) [94Lan, 95Lan].
Fig. 2.1.13. Different methods of laser cladding: (a) free cladding, (b) shape-determined cladding using a crucible.
In contrast to the remelting processes like alloying and dispersing (Sect. 2.1.1.2), the amount of molten substrate material is very low only ensuring a metallurgical bond between the substrate and the layer. The major part of the clad is built up by the deposited material. Therefore final shape of the workpiece is defined by the thickness and shape of the layer. Using the two-step process, different forms of pre-deposition can be taken into account, depending on the application, like -
powders, pastes, foils, wires, thermally sprayed coatings.
In the application, the one-step process is often preferred, because it is easier to control. The most common method of laser surface cladding is to inject the material in form of powder or wire [89Bur] through a nozzle into the laser/material interaction zone. If a powder is used, a certain amount of the powder, which does not hit the molten pool, gets lost. Powder efficiency and surface quality are very sensitive to the geometrical arrangement. The influence of the incident direction of the powder stream on the powder efficiency is discussed in Fig. 2.1.14. Alternatively, a coaxial powder feed nozzle can be used, promising best results and avoiding directional effects on the shape of the clad bead [96Lin].
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
93
100
N
oz
zl
e
−
Position of the nozzle
80
+
Efficiency [%]
Laser
40
10
θ1
60
Y axis
20
Sample displacement
a
0
10 20
60 50
−
θ 2-0°
Position of the nozzle
+
+θ 2
b
X axis
Efficiency [%]
− θ2
θ 2 -180°
30 40 50 60 70 80 90 θ 1 [degrees]
40 30 20 10 0 -180
-90
0 θ 2 [degrees]
90
180
Fig. 2.1.14. Influence of the incident direction of the powder stream on the powder efficiency [90Mar1]: (a) influence of angle θ1 (θ2 = 0°), (b) influence of angle θ2 (θ1 = 55°). Substrate: mild steel (St37), powder: Stellite 6, laser output power: 1500 W, beam diameter: 2 mm, speed: 0.8 m/min., step: 0.6 mm, powder flow rate: 6 g/min., gas flow rate: 1.3 l/min.
Using a mixture of different powders, in which one component has a high melting point and low absorption coefficient, a dual phase layer containing hard particles can be generated [84Tuc] (e.g. for cutting tools). Taking into account that both components may differ severely in density, it has to be considered that floating or sedimentation of the particles may occur. A vertical cladding position is an alternative method to prevent this effect [95Lan]. Crack-free cladding is essential for satisfactory corrosion resistance. The different thermal expansion coefficients of the substrate and the coating often result in tensile residual stresses within the cladded coating. As a consequence, cracking can occur even after the process but prior to the application of any additional load. Pre-heating of the component and/or post-annealing can help to reduce the residual stresses [86Dek]. Examples for laser cladding on different substrate materials and possible applications are given in Table 2.1.12.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
94
2.1.1 Laser macro processing
[Ref. p. 101
Table 2.1.12. Examples of laser cladding on different substrate materials. Substrate material Cladding various NiCrBSi
mild steel
NiCrBSi NiCrTaB 50 vol.-% TiC, 50 vol.-% Stellite 6 Co-base alloy with TIC or WC FeCrAlY
CoCrAlY
mild steel (St37) mild steel (St37) mild steel (St37)
steels
Stellite 6 45Fe-55Cr Fe-12.5Cr-9.5P1.7Y Fe-12.5Cr-9.5P1.7Y Ni-25Cr-5.2Al2.7Si-0.5Y NiCrBSi
steels
NiCr(Nb,Ta)B
45NiCr6
Stellite 21
GGG40
Ni
14CrMoV6-9 NiCr20AlTi
Mo-alloy NiCrAlY
pure Ni IN738
mild steel (St52)
Al2O3/TiO2 (97/3) Al2O3/TiO2 (87/13) mild steel (St52) + Al2O3/TiO2 (97/3) bondcoat Ti (laser remelting) mild steel (St52) ZrO2/Y2O3 (92/8) X6CrNiTi18-10 Al2O3/TiO2 (97/3) X6CrNiTi18-10 Al2O3/TiO2 (87/13) X6CrNiTi18-10 PSZ: ZrO2/Y2O3 (92/8) X6CrNiTi18-10 Al2O3 X6CrNiTi18-10 Cr2O3 X6CrNiTi18-10 Cr2O3/SiO2/TiO2 (90/5/3)
Method two-step (pre-placed paste) blown powder blown powder blown powder
Comments Ref. superior wear properties to 79Bel plasma-sprayed coatings, esp. at high pressures
good metallurgical bonding WC superior to TiC
two-step (pre-placed powder) two-step (pre-placed powder) blown powder blown powder blown powder
84Tuc
excellent oxidation resistance 83Liu at 1000...1200 °C excellent oxidation resistance 83Liu at 1000...1200 °C, but cracking problems 90Mar2 90Mar2 90Mar2
blown powder
90Mar2
blown powder
90Mar2
one-step / two-step better corrosion resistance than austenitic steel and Nimonic 75 one-step / two-step better corrosion resistance than austenitic steel Nomonic 75 and NiCrBSi coatings two-step, repairing of dies coaxial-nozzle remelting of transport containers for plasma-sprayed nuclear application layer one-step extruder parts, 780...1130 HV one-step exhaust valves of large diesel engines one-step no sufficient bondage! one-step no sufficient bondage! one-step improved wettability of metal to ceramic
90Lug2
one-step one-step one-step one-step one-step one-step one-step
cracks and pores free of pores and cracks free of pores and cracks Y freely soluble in Zr2O3 cracks and pores <100 µm crack free wide range of parameters possible
90Lug2
96Gas 96Gas
96Gas 88Ame 94Lug 94Lug 94Lug
94Lug 94Lug 94Lug 94Lug 94Lug 94Lug 94Lug
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
95
2.1.2 Thin-layer technologies Thin-film technologies require either q-switched Nd:YAG-lasers or excimer radiation. With a pulse duration between 0.1 and 200 ns, a layer thickness of typically 0.05 up to 50 µm can be generated. In the following examples different thin-film technologies, such as cleaning, smoothing and surface alloying are reported. According to the surface characteristics of a technical material, different absorption mechanisms are involved, e.g. for organic contaminations, oxide films, deformed layers or the bulk substrate. Varying the energy density a different response of the material is observed. This is illustrated in Fig. 2.1.15, where the typical change in properties (e.g. the surface roughness) as a function of the excimer laser intensity is shown for metal surfaces as an example. Low intensities do not change the substrate, whereas a slight increase in energy density causes cleaning by evaporation of organic or inorganic (desoxidation) contaminants. Higher intensities cause etching effects followed by smoothing or roughening (in case of exceeding plasma level). The highest densities may be used for alloying [89Sch] or for thermal removal of thin layers. This behavior can be explained by the typical structure of a technical metal surface (Fig. 2.1.16). Above the non-deformed base material a whole series of layers with different deformation or oxidation states follows. The surface region contains the fingerprints of each production step, so that organic contaminations, oxides or residues of grinding materials will be present, followed by regions of different deformation caused by turning, grinding or polishing. This detailed description of a technical surface is necessary, because the short interaction time and the high pulse energy allows only modifications in depth regions between 0.1 and 1 µm in single-pulse experiments (with multiple-exposure treatments up to 20 µm are possible). The temperature gradient produced does not lead to any thermal influence in a substrate depth of 1 µm while the surface is at plasma temperature [90Ber]. The necessary intensity to produce plasma formation is different for organic adsorbates, oxide layers and the real substrate. This explains the different processing results obtained with various energy densities.
Fig. 2.1.15. Typical change in properties (e.g. the surface roughness) as a function of the excimer laser intensity for metal surfaces [90Ber].
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
96
2.1.2 Thin-layer technologies
[Ref. p. 101
Fig. 2.1.16. Typical structure of a technical metal surface [90Ber].
Treating ceramics, a sealing effect combined with reduced roughness occurs at energy densities above the plasma level. The strategy in ceramics processing is completely different to the machining of metals. Due to their brittleness ceramic materials are extremely sensitive to tensile and shear stresses, because they cannot diminish them by plastic deformation. Another crucial factor for the lifetime is the sensitivity for cracks. Once a crack is present, it will propagate very fast and result in brittle failure of the component, so that crack initiation determines lifetime. To improve ceramics, the size of the largest occurring crack or defect has to be reduced. Crack propagation will occur if a crack is already present (micro-cracks) or has been initiated at a surface defect, like machining marks, pores or simply grain boundaries. Such defects can be reduced by remelting the surface using an excimer laser. This positive effect however is accompanied by the generation of internal stresses during irradiation. If no phase transformation occurs, the thermal cycle by laser heating will always result in tensile stresses. This effect is adverse to the lifetime prolongation caused by smoothing and may overweigh the improvement caused by the excimer laser treatment of the ceramic device.
2.1.2.1 Laser cleaning A review of laser cleaning in the application of art restoration is given in [96Wat]. Laser cleaning has the following advantages over conventional mechanical or chemical methods: -
physical process which ends shortly after the laser pulse, selective process which can be tuned for the removal of specific substances, non-contact process that can be automated, surface relief is preserved, versatile process by selection of operating conditions, controllable process, since a specific thickness can be removed.
The appropriate laser parameters (wavelength, pulse length, power density) and the cover fluid (air, argon, water nitrogen etc.) depend on the substrate material and the surface impurities that have to be removed. The following mechanisms of interaction are proposed: -
selective evaporation, scouring of the surface by the action of rapidly expanded vapors, thermal and photo decomposition of superficial layers, removing of small adherent particles as a result of selective excitation of the particles of the substrate, delamination of superficial deposits as a result of thermal expansion mismatch with the substrate, spallation induced by laser induced shock-wave.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
97
2.1.2.2 Laser cleaning and smoothing of cast iron Excimer lasers can be used for the surface finishing treatment of cast iron, for example within the cylinder walls of automotive combustion engines. The irradiation causes a cleaning and smoothing effect while the surface becomes nitrided within a 1 µm thin surface layer and the graphite lamellae of the cast iron are opened. Using this technique, friction and wear of the cylinder surface, which determine oil consumption, energy loss, airtightness and lifetime of the engine, can be improved. For the treatment of large surfaces it is necessary to move either the laser beam or the workpiece. In the case of cylindrical holes, rotating of the workpiece results in much better stiffness of the beam handling system. While the whole cylinder crankcase is rotating with up to 120 rpm, a carriage is used to move the rotating axis from one cylinder to another so that only one acceleration is necessary for each engine, resulting in a reasonable process speed [98Ber].
2.1.2.3 Surface alloying As an example of thin-film laser surface alloying, the nitriding of aluminum alloys is reported. The resistance of aluminum-alloy substrates against abrasive wear and corrosion can be improved by generating a thin layer containing aluminum nitride (see Table 2.1.13). This can be reached by UV exposure within a nitrogen atmosphere [96Bar]. The process consists of several steps: -
removal of the Al2O3 diffusion barrier, formation of atomic nitrogen within the laser-induced plasma, melting of a thin surface film (up to 20 µm), dissolution of atomic nitrogen within the melt, quenching-in of the nitrogen during resolidification of the melt (quenching rate 107...1011 K/s), precipitation of aluminum nitride.
The influence of the process parameters energy density, number of pulses and nitrogen pressure on the percentage of aluminum nitride within the surface layer is given in Fig. 2.1.17. A significant increase of the surface hardness is reached due to -
dispersion hardening, solid-solution hardening, grain refinement.
This results in a significant reduction of the friction coefficient for dry gliding, reducing the wear rate up to one third, compared to the plain substrate material [98Bar].
Table 2.1.13. Comparison of the properties of AlN and Al [98Bar]. Property thermal conductivity λ [W/m K] thermal expansion coeff. [K–1] melting point Tm [°C] density [kg/m3] electrical resistivity [Ωm] Vickers hardness [N/mm2]
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
AlN 285 4.9 ⋅ 10–6 1750 (decomposition) in vacuum 2750 (decomposition) in 100 atm. N2 3.26 ⋅ 103 1013 ... 1015 1230
Al 238 23 ⋅ 10–6 660 2.7 ⋅ 103 2.6 ⋅ 10–8 < 100
98
2.1.3 Laser shock hardening
[Ref. p. 101
Fig. 2.1.17. Influence of the process parameters on the phase proportion of aluminum nitride within the surface layer: (a) influence of the energy density, (b) influence of the number of pulses, (c) influence of the nitrogen gas pressure.
2.1.3 Laser shock hardening Laser shock hardening (laser impulse strengthening) is an almost cold (non-thermal) process to increase the hardness and wear resistance of metals in the surface region, generating compressive residual stresses even in deeper zones underneath the surface [96Keu]. The effect of impulse strengthening is based on mechanical deformation and can be compared to mechanical treatments like shot peening. Two different methods of performing the laser shock hardening process are shown in Fig. 2.1.18 [98Eis]. Using a free-expanding plasma method, a dense plasma is ignited on the surface of the workpiece. Due to the hydrodynamic flow of the ionized metal vapor a momentum transfer to the surface is implemented. As the power flux densities are very high, thermal effects damaging the surface cannot be avoided [95Mas]. The second method, using a confined plasma, is carried out with a double-layer system on the surface. This layer system consists of a confining film which is transparent for the irradiating laser wavelength, inhibiting the hydrodynamic flow of the plasma, and an additional absorbing layer which is used to separate the thermal from the mechanical effects preventing damaging the surface. Using the confined-plasma method, the applied pressure is much higher (up to one magnitude) than for freeexpanding plasma techniques [90Fab, 90Kre, 93Dev, 95Pey, 96Eis]. This is demonstrated in Fig. 2.1.19, where the resulting pressure, measured on the backside of the specimen, is compared for both cases (note the different scales for both curves!).
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 101]
2.1 Surface treatment
99
Fig. 2.1.18. Different methods of performing the laser shock hardening process: (a) freeexpanding plasma, (b) confined plasma.
Fig. 2.1.19. Measured pressure at the backside of the sample: 1: free-expanding plasma technique, 2: confined-plasma method.
The resulting pressure pulse at the surface induces elastic and plastic shock waves (supersonic pressure pulses), which travel into the material. An extremely short rise time of the laser pulse is necessary to produce a sufficient pulse pressure (several kilobars, i.e. several 108 Pa, minimum), whereas the pulse duration has no substantial influence on the development of the microstructural properties of the material (Fig. 2.1.20). If the resulting pressure exceeds the flow stress of the substrate material, plastic deformation occurs, generating microstructural changes like twinning and resulting in compressive residual stresses. Figure 2.1.21 displays measured residual stress-depth profiles for two different steel substrates and different numbers of pulses. The maximum values observed reached up to 70...80 % of the yield strength of the substrate material. The depth of the zone with compressive residual stresses increases with the total number of pulses until a saturation is reached. For substrates with higher yield strength more pulses are necessary to reach saturation.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
100
2.1.3 Laser shock hardening
[Ref. p. 101
Fig. 2.1.20. Signal of the laser pulse and pulse pressure at the backside of the sample [98Eis]: (a) long rise time, (b) short rise time; 1: signal of the laser pulse, 2: pressure measured at the backside of the sample.
Fig. 2.1.21. Residual stress-depth profiles for two different steel substrates and different numbers of pulses; power density: 1 GW/cm2, confined plasma with absorption layer, excimer laser XP 2020. (a) 34CrAlNi7 (yield strength 650 MPa), (b) X2Cr11 (yield strength 380 MPa); 1: 4 pulses, 2: 16 pulses, 3: 64 pulses.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
References for 2.1
101
References for 2.1 54Wev
Wever, F., Rose, A.: Atlas zur Wärmebehandlung der Stähle, Teil 1, Stahleisen, 1954.
72Ros
Rose, A., Haugardy, H.: Atlas zur Wärmebehandlung der Stähle, Bd. 2, Stahleisen, 1972.
73Ohr
Ohrlich, J., Rose, A., Wiest, P.: Atlas zur Wärmebehandlung der Stähle, Bd. 3, Stahleisen, 1973.
76Ohr
Ohrlich, J., Pietrzeniuk, H.-J.: Atlas zur Wärmebehandlung der Stähle, Bd. 4, Stahleisen, 1976.
79Bel
Belmondo, A., Castagna, M.: Thin Solid Films 64 (1979) 249.
81Kur
Kurz, W.: In: Sahm, P.R.: Proc. of the workshop on solidification, Gießerei Institut, Aachen, Germany (1981) 57.
83Cly
Clyne, T. W.: In: Sahm, P.R.: Proc. of the workshop on solidification, Gießerei Institut, Aachen, Germany (1983) 96. Kou, S., Sun, D.K., Lee, Y.P.: Metallurgical Transactions 14A (1983) 643. Liu, C.A., Humphries, M.J., Krutenat, R.C.: Thin Solid Films 197 (1983) 269. Rothe, R., Chatterjee-Fischer, R., Sepold, G.: In: 3rd Int. Colloquium on Welding and Melting by Electrons and Laser Beams, CIS FFEL, Lyon, 1983. Sahm, P.R.: In: Sahm, P.R.: Proc. of the workshop on solidification, Gießerei Institut, Aachen, Germany (1983) 5.
83Kou 83Liu 83Rot 83Sah
84Böt 84Tuc
Böttinger, W.J., Coriell, S.R.: Mat. Sc. Eng. 65 (1984) 27. Tucker, T.R., Clauer, A.H., Wright, I.G., Shopky, J.T.: Thin Solid Films 118 (1984) 73.
85Ber 85Wis
Bergmann, H.W.: Surface Engineering 1(2) (1985) 137. Wissenbach, K.: Ph.D. Thesis, TH Darmstadt, Germany, 1985.
86Ber 86Bra 86Dek 86Kur 86Maz 86Rap
Bergmann, H.W.: Opto Elektronik Mag. 2(3) (1986) 224. Bransden, A.S., Gazzard, S.T., Inwood, B.C., Megaw, J.H.P.C.: Surface Eng. 2(2) (1986) 107. Dekumbis, R.: 6th Int. Conf. on Lasers in Manufacturing, Birmingham, 1989. Kurz, W., Fisher, D.J.: Fundamentals of Solidification, Trans Tech Publ., 1986. Mazumder, J., Singh, J.: In: Laser Surface Treatment of Metals, Boston (1986) 287. Rappaz, M.: Proc. of ECLAT'86.
88Ame 88Ber 88Dau 88Gei 88Gil 88Jüp 88Rud
Amende, W.: Laser Mag. 3 (1988) 8. Bergmann, H.W., Geissler, E.: Proc. of ECLAT'88 (1988) 109. Dausinger, F., Rudlaff, T.: Techn. Rundschau 37 (1988) 44. Geissler, E., Bergmann, H.W.: Opto Electronic Magazin 4 (1988) 4. Gillner, A., Wissenbach, K., Kreutz, E.W.: Opto Elektronik Mag. 4(1) (1988) 57. Jüptner, W.P.O., Becker, R., Sepold, G.: SPIE 957 (1988) 82. Rudlaff, T., Dausinger, F.: Proc. of ECLAT'88, 1988.
89Bur 89Sch 89Wu
Burchards, D., Hinse, A., Mordike, B.L.: Mat.-wis. u. Werkstofftech. 20 (1989) 305. Schubert, E., Bergmann, H.W.: Opto Elektronik Mag. 5 (1989) 6. Wu, W., Streiff, R., Wang, M.: Mat. Sc. Eng. A 121 (1989) 499.
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
102 90Ber 90Fab 90Gas
References for 2.1
90Kre 90Lug1 90Lug2 90Mar1 90Mar2 90Pie 90Rud 90Tön1 90Tön2
Bergmann, H.W., Schubert, E.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 813. Fabbro, R.: J. Appl. Phys. 68(2) (1990) 775. Gasser, A., Kreutz, E.W., Krönert, W., Lohmann, K., Wissenbach, K., Zografou, C.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 651. Kreutz, E.W., Pirch, N.: SPIE Proc. 1276 (1990) 343. Lugscheider, E., Bolender, H.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 111. Lugscheider, E., Oberländer, B.C., Meinhardt, H.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 555. Marsden, C.F., Frenk, A., Wagnière, J.-D., Dekumbis, R.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 535. Marsden, C.F., Houdley, A.F.A., Wagnière, J.-D.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 543. Pierce, R.L.: J. of Laser Appl. 1 (1990) 18. Rudlaff, T., Dausinger, F.: Proc. of ECLAT'90 (1990) 251. Tönshoff, H.K., Meyer-Kobbe, C.: Laser Mag. 4 (1990) 23. Tönshoff, H.K., Meyer-Kobbe, C., Homburg, A.: Laser Mag. 5 (1990) 29.
91Bac 91Fri 91Gei 91Lep
Bach, J., Damaschek, R., Geissler, E., Bergmann, H.W.: HTM 46(2) (1991) 97. Fritsch, H.U., Bergmann, H.W.: HTM 46(3) (1991) 145. Geissler, E., Bergmann, H.W.: HTM 46(2) (1991) 91. Lepski, D., Luft, A., Reitzenstein, W.: Opto Elektronik Mag. 7(4) (1991) 304.
92Ber
Bergmann, H.W., Endres, T., Anders, R., Freisleben, B., Müller, D.:Proc. of ECLAT'92 (1992) 363. Jaschek, R., Taube, R., Schutte, K., Bergmann, H.W.: Proc. of ECLAT'92, 1992. Lugscheider, E., Bolender, H., Krappitz, H.: Proc. of ECLAT'92 (1992) 369. Müller, D., Domes, J., Bergmann, H.W.: HTM 47(2) (1992) 123.
92Jas 92Lug 92Mül 93Dev 93Gei 93Her
Devaux, D.: J. Appl. Phys. 74(4) (1993) 2268. Geissler, E.: Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1993. Herziger, G., Loosen, P.: Werkstoffbearbeitung mit Laserstrahlung, Hanser-Verlag, München, 1993.
94Agr 94Gal 94Kör
Ågren, J.: Mat. Sc. Forum 163–165 (1994) 3. Galun, R., Weisheit, A., Mordike, B.L.: Proc. of ECLAT'94, DVS (1994) 421. Körner, C., Müller, K., Domes, J., Damaschek, R., Bergmann, H.W.: Proc. 15th Int. Symp. on Mat. Sc., Roskilde (1994) 381. Lang, A., Waldmann, H., Bergmann, H.W.: Proc. of ECLAT'94 (1994) 456. Lugscheider, E., Bolender, H., Hochmuth, K., Herziger, G., Gasser, A., Wissenbach, K. Bitterlich, R., Pirch, N.: Proc. of ECLAT'94 (1994) 213.
94Lan 94Lug
95Dom
95Pey
Domes, J.: Die Ausbildung von Makroeigenspannungen beim Randschichthärten mit Laserstrahlung und anderen Verfahren der Lasermaterialbearbeitung, Ph.D. Thesis, ErlangenNürnberg, 1995. Galun, R., Weisheit, A., Mordike, B.L.: Proc. of ICALEO'95, LIA 80 (1995) 69. Lang, A.: Laserstrahlspritzen von Schneidbelägen, Ph. D. Thesis, Univ. Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1995. Masse, J.-E., Barreau, G.: Surface and Coatings Technology 70 (1995) 231. Müller, D.: Beitrag zum Randschichthärten für kraftübertragende Komponenten im Motorenbau, Shaker Verlag, Aachen, 1995. Peyre, P., Fabbro, R.: Optical and Quantum Electronics 27 (1995) 1213.
96Bar 96DIN1 96DIN2 96Eis
Barnickel, J., Schutte, K., Bergmann, H.W.: Proc. of ECLAT'96 (1996) 547. E DIN 17022-5: Verfahren der Wärmebehandlung – Teil 5: Randschichthärten, 1996. E DIN 30950: Schmelzhärten, 1996. Eisner, K., Lang, A., Schutte, K., Bergmann, H.W.: SPIE 2789 (1996) 274.
95Gal 95Lan 95Mas 95Mül
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
References for 2.1 96Gas 96Keu 96Lin 96Mor 96Mül 96Wat
103
Gasser, A. Wissenbach, K., Hoffmann, E., Schulte, G., Beyer, E.: Proc. of ECLAT'96 (1996) 287. Keusch, C., Hintz, G., Tkotz, R., Negendanck, M., Christiansen, J., Bergmann, H.W., Eisner, K., Schutte, K.: Proc. of ECLAT'96, 1996. Lin, J., Stehen, W.M.: Proc. ICALEO'96 (1996) 27. Mordike, B.L.: Proc. of ECLAT'96 (1996) 253. Müller, K., Körner, C. Bergmann, H.W.: HTM 51(1) (1996) 19. Watkins, K.G., Larson, J.H., Emmony, D.C., Stehen, W.M.: In: Mazumder, J. et. al.: Laser Processing – Surface Treatment and Thin Film Deposition, Kluver Publishing, Netherlands (1996) 907.
97Ber
Bergmann, H.W., Bohner, F., Stiele, H.: HTM 52(2) (1997) 108.
98Bar
Barnickel, J.: Nitrieren von Aluminiumwerkstoffen mit UV-Laserstrahlung, Ph.D.-Thesis, Univ. Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1998. Bergmann, H.W.: Proc. of EKLAT'98, 1998. Eisner, K.: Prozeßtechnische Grundlagen zur Schockverfestigung von metallischen Werkstoffen mit einem kommerziellen Excimerlaser, Ph.D.-Thesis, Univ. Erlangen-Nürnberg, 1998.
98Ber 98Eis
Landolt-Börnstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 123]
2.2 Rapid prototyping
105
2.2 Rapid prototyping A. Gebhardt
The method of building scaled physical models by layer manufacturing, also called generative manufacturing or additive manufacturing, is commonly named “Rapid Prototyping (RP) (technology)”. In contrast to traditional manufacturing such as grinding or milling, the desired shape is obtained by adding material instead of removing it. Using so-called prototypers, RP models are generated in a couple of hours directly from 3D CAD. Only 3D data but no model-dependent tools are needed. Since 1987 when the first prototyper, the Stereolithography Apparatus (SLA), was introduced by 3D-Systems (CA, USA), more then 50 different machines have been presented using more then 10 basic processes. Most of the models are made of plastic materials, but also foundry sands, ceramics and metals are available. Due to the direct interaction of the RP and CAD process, RP models are just facsimiles of the 3D-data set and consequently can be obtained at all stages of product development. For many years making prototypes has been the main application of the RP technology but since the middle of the 90’s RP has also been used for making tools and even final products. This is why an appropriate nomenclature is under discussion. Today (2003) people tend to name the layermanufacturing technology “rapid technologies” or “rapid technology” while the main applications are named rapid prototyping (including solid imaging and functional prototyping), rapid tooling and rapid manufacturing. Figure 2.2.1 describes this relation. Rapid prototyping is used to obtain samples for the evaluation of selected product characteristics mainly in the area of geometry, surface, fit and function. The major fields are: – Solid imaging or concept modeling enables men to “touch” a virtual 3D data set. The models are sometimes called “show-and-tell” models as well to indicate that they are important for communication especially during the very first stage of product development. – Functional prototypes support the evaluation of one or more isolated properties (fit and function) of the later series product.
Technology
Rapid Technology
Manufacturing of Concept Models
Solid Imaging Rapid Prototyping Application / Technique / Strategy
Manufacturing of Functional Prototypes
Functional Prototyping
Manufacturing of Tools and Tool Inserts
Rapid Tooling
Manufacturing of Final Parts
Rapid Manufacturing great
small Distance to Series Quality
Fig. 2.2.1. Rapid prototyping in the context of rapid prototyping technology and its applications.
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
106
2.2.1 Layer manufacturing
[Ref. p. 123
Rapid tooling is called the making of tools either directly by using a prototyper or from RP masters. Rapid tooling therefore bridges the gap between prototyping and manufacturing. Rapid manufacturing means the use of layer-based processes for making final parts – (series-) manufacturing. In order not to confuse the reader by a too sophisticated nomenclature in the following text only the commonly accepted and the widely spread name “Rapid Prototyping” is used to name the layer-manufacturing technology and the basic process as well as its application for making prototypes.
2.2.1 Layer manufacturing 2.2.1.1 Rapid-prototyping process chain To obtain physical models by rapid prototyping, the whole process chain has to be taken into account. Figure 2.2.2 shows the entire rapid-prototyping build process and its adjacent process steps. The first one is to create a 3D data set which completely describes the whole volume. In the field of industrial product development it is the result of a 3D CAD design but it can also be obtained from measurements or scanning procedures. In the field of medical applications mostly Computerized Tomography (CT) scanners (CT-scans) and a subsequent 3D reconstruction are used. The 3D data are transmitted to the so-called “front end” of the RP system using standard interfaces, such as STL SLC IGES VDA STEP
Stereolithography interface based on triangles, Stereolithography interface based on Contours, Initial Graphics Exchange Specification – CAD data exchange interface, German Association of Automotive Manufacturers CAD data exchange interface, Standard for the Exchange of Product model data
and others. Even if the contour-orientated SLC format leads to better results, the much more easy-to-handle STL format, which is based on a triangulation of the model’s surface (tessellated surface), has gained some kind of a quasi-industrial standard. The front end mainly consists of the
Parameters for Machine Control
Generating the CAD-Model l
Interface (e.g. STL, SLC)
Process-related Transformation of Geometric Data
Generating Physical Model
PostProcessing
Finishing
Auxiliary Geometries ( Supports, ...) CAD Software
Rapid-Prototyping Software
Build Process
Manual Finishing
Fig. 2.2.2. Rapid-prototyping-process data flow.
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 123]
2.2 Rapid prototyping
107
so-called rapid-prototyping software, that comes either from the manufacturer or from third parties. Beside the data handling it allows simple operations such as positioning, orientation, cutting and rearranging of models as well as the design of support structures, if needed. The build data set that controls the entire build process is derived from the geometric data and some process-related data to be added by the operator. From the build process a physical model is obtained, that has to be finished due to the process’s special requirements. Stereolithography for example needs cleaning, post-curing and the removal of the supports. Finally, all RP processes need a non-process-dependent surface treatment that is called finishing. In most cases RP models do not meet the customers’ requirements because of their lack of surface quality, material properties or quantity. The results can be improved by using the RP models as masters for copying (or cloning) procedures such as Room Temperature Vulcanization (RTV), see Sect. 2.2.1.8.1.
2.2.1.2 Prototypers Rapid-prototyping processes are characterized by the layer-orientated manufacturing of the models, as can be seen in Fig. 2.2.3. The volumes defined by the 3D data set are sliced into layers with even thickness (internal cross sections, virtual layers). The contour data of each layer is transmitted to the prototyper. The entire RP build process consists of two main steps: 1. manufacturing of each single layer, e.g. by cutting it from sheet material or by cladding discrete volumes (voxels) adjacent to each other, 2. joining each layer on top of the partly finished model to obtain a solid, thus growing the model from the bottom to the top. These process steps can be seen very clearly in Fig. 2.2.3 that shows the principle in comparison to a special rapid-tooling process (see Sect. 2.2.1.8) based on laser cutting and sheet or diffusion welding.
3D-CAD-Model
Slicing of Internal CrossSections (Layers)
Fig. 2.2.3. Rapid-prototyping process steps. Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
RP-Process
Physical Model (Solid)
108
2.2.1 Layer manufacturing
[Ref. p. 123
Rapid-prototyping processes consequently differ mainly from each other by: 1. 2. 3. 4.
the the the the
physical principle of converting virtual into physical layers, characteristics of the contour generating element (i.e. laser, extruder), material the layers are made of, physical principle how the adjacent layers are joined to a solid.
Frequently, the generation and the joint of the layers are based on the same physical process and therefore both steps are done simultaneously. It is a common practice to classify rapid-prototyping procedures due to the state of the build material. This leads to fundamental physical principles how to make solid layers (Fig. 2.2.4) and to the basic RP processes listed below. Beneath the bold horizontal line the most established industrial processes and their manufacturers are listed. Beneath the thin line some more are mentioned that are either under development or on the threshold of their industrial application. They will be discussed briefly in Sect. 2.2.3 below. Further details can be found in [03Geb].
2.2.1.3 Characteristics of rapid-prototyping processes Based on the systematics of Fig. 2.2.4, in more then 15 years that passed since the introduction of the first prototyper a huge amount of different systems has been presented, but only 5 families of prototypers could establish themselves as industrial applicable systems due to their good performance and widely spread acceptance. Table 2.2.1 gives a short description of the most important industrial-used RP processes. It describes each basic process including the working principle, its pros and cons, the materials that can be used and the follow-up processes that are needed to obtain short-run series of different materials. Table 2.2.1 also contains the name of some manufacturers and of the commercialized process (abbreviation). For further details see [03Geb] and the internet addresses listed in Table 2.2.2. Figure 2.2.5 shows a typical stereolithography machine (3D-Systems) and Fig. 2.2.6 shows a laser-sintering machine (EOS).
2.2.1.4 Materials There is a very limited number of materials available for RP applications. The reason is that RP materials are process-related in two ways: On the one hand, they first have to serve the process. For example, stereolithography materials must be photo-curable. All other properties, such as durability, elasticity or thermal stability have to be put into the background. On the other hand, the materials are mostly related to one machine and consequently to the manufacturer. The upcoming laser-based metal processes, such as “laser cusing” (Concept Laser, D) “selective laser melting”, (Fockele&Schwarze, D), “LENS” (Optomec, USA) or even the onecomponent EOS laser-sintering process have the potential to overcome these limits and open up the possibility to use any kind of industrial available metal powder [03Ove]. RP materials simulate the properties of the corresponding engineering materials, even if the brand name or the chemical composition are identical the same. Table 2.2.3 shows a selection of plastic and metal RP materials in comparison to engineering materials.
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
Wax Process, Generis.
FDM, Stratasys. ModelMaker, Solidscape.
(Selective) Laser Sintering (SLS)
Local Melting and Solidification
Layer Laminate Manufacturing (LLM)
Cutting and Joining
Foil
Lamp
GS 1500 (Sand), Generis.
Laser Lamp
Eden 300, Objet. Invision, 3D Systems.
Opto 15/400 ...90/800, 3D Systems.
Paste Polymerization
PhotoPolymerization
Resin-Flour Mixture
Paste
Printing and PhotoPolymerization
Stereo- Solid Ground Polyjet Curing Lithography Droplet (SGC) Polymerization (SL)
Laser
Direct PhotoPolymerization
Liquid Resin
LOM, Z3..., Z 8..., Vanguard, 3D Systems. SLA, 3D-Systems. EOSint, EOS. Cubic Technologies. Z-Corporation. Perfactory, SLM, F&S. Stratoconception, Prometal, Envision Tec. M3 linear, Concept. CIRTES. Extrude Hone. LENS, Optomec. LMC, Zimmermann.
3D-Printing (3DP)
Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM)
Ballistic Particle Manufacturing (BPM)
Solidification by Binder
Local Melting and Solidification
One- or MultiComponent Powder
Fluid
Fig. 2.2.4. Physical principles of rapid-prototyping layer generation due to the state of the build material, industrial rapid-prototyping processes, industrial (commercial) prototypers and future industrial prototypers.
Future Prototypers
Industrial Prototypers
Industrial Process
Physical Principle of Layer Generation
Filament
Solid
Rapid Prototyping - Layer Manufacturing Techniques
Ref. p. 123] 2.2 Rapid prototyping 109
Description
Cutting layer from foil and laminating.
Layer-laminate manufacturing (LLM)
) RTV – Room-Temperature Vulcanization.
In case of models with high volume: Quick and cheap.
Quick and cheap. Local solidification of Colored models powders by injecting possible. binder fluid. Post-process infiltration required.
3D-Printing (3DP)
Wider range of materials. Acceptable thermal and quite good mechanical properties.
Extrusion of thermoplastic material by heated nozzles. Solidification by cooling down.
1
Poor thermal and mechanical properties.
Cons
Short-run series made of plastic by
Less details than stereolithography. Anisotropic properties.
Very rough surfaces; poor details.
Cubic Techn. / LOM
RTV possible. Paper, (plastic) (Metal) (Ceramics)
Investment casting from wax copies.
Not recommended. Investment casting ZCorporation RTV possible. after wax infiltration. / 3DP
Investment casting Stratasys from directly / FDM extruded wax parts.
3D Systems / SLS EOS / LS
3-D Systems / SLA
3D-Keltools. Investment casting.
Direct sintering of metal parts. Investment casting.
Manufacturer / industrial process
Short-run series made of metal by
Starch Plaster
Rougher surface Polyamide Direct extrusion Polyester of plastic parts. and less details ABS, PPSF RTV possible. than stereolithography.
Direct sintering of plastic parts. RTV possible.
Epoxy resin Vaccum casting Acrylate (RTV1 )). Composite tools.
Materials
Local melting of plastic Acceptable thermal Rougher surface Polyamide than Metal powder. Solidification and quite good stereolithography. Sand by cooling down. mechanical properties.
Very good surface quality. Fine details.
Pros
Extrusion / fused-layer manufacturing (FLM)
Laser sintering (LS / SLS)
Stereolithography Solidification of (SL, SLA) liquid resin by photopolimerization.
Process
Table 2.2.1. Industrial rapid-prototyping processes – overview.
110 2.2.1 Layer manufacturing [Ref. p. 123
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 123]
2.2 Rapid prototyping
111
Table 2.2.2. Manufacturer and supplier of prototypers and related products. Company
Products
URL
3D Systems DSM SOMOS Cubic Technologies CP-GmbH EOS GmbH FhG-IPT FhG-ILT Fockele & Schwarze Generis Materialise MCP-HEK GmbH, Germany
Manufacturer of prototypers Supplier of SL materials Manufacturer of prototypers Rapid-prototyping service bureau Manufacturer of prototypers Research institute Research institute Manufacturer of prototypers Manufacturer of prototypers Supplier of RP software Supplier for materials for RTV and low-melting-point alloy molding; SLM-realizer metal prototyper Manufacturer of prototypers Manufacturer of prototypers Manufacturer of prototypers Manufacturer of prototypers Manufacturer of prototypers Layer-milling sofware and systems Manufacturer of pharmaceutica Supplier of SL materials Manufacturer of prototypers Manufacturer of milling machines for model shops
www.3dsystems.com www.dsmsomos.com www.cubictechnologies.com www.cp-gmbh.de www.eos-gmbh.de www.ipt.fhg.de www.ilt.fhg.de www.fockeleundschwarze.de www.generis.de
MicroTech Objet Optomec Roeders Stratasys Stratoconception Therics Vantico Z-Corporation Zimmermann
Fig. 2.2.5. Stereolithography prototyper (3DSystems, USA).
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
Fig. 2.2.6. GmbH, D).
www.mcp-group.de
www.microtec-d.com www.objet.co.il www.optomec.com www.roeders.com www.stratasys.com www.stratoconception.fr www.therics.com www.tooling.vantico.com www.zcorp.com www.zimmermann. de
Laser-sintering
prototyper
(EOS-
Unit MPa
MPa % MPa MPa
kJ/m
Property Tensile strength
Tensile modulus Elongation at break Flexural modulus Flexural strength
Impact strength
2
2400-2600 6-15 2400-2600 83-104
42-62
0.5
3296 5.4 3054 99
77
Renshape SL5510 SL7560
Epoxy resin
Stereolithography
Process
Material Type Brand name
Vantico
Company
3D Systems
13
2413 91
2345
69
PPSF
2
2517 >10 2657 66
35
P400
ABS
Fused deposition modeling
Stratasys EOS
1600 22 1430
4.8
1700 20
45
Dura-form PA2200 PA
Polyamide
Laser sintering
3D Systems
Rapid-prototyping material
Plastics
ABS
15-20
8-12
1600-2000 2000-2600 50-200 20 2400 88
50-65
PA66
Injection molding
Engineering material
Table 2.2.3. Rapid-prototyping and engineering materials – samples for plastics and metals.
Laserform ST100
bronze infiltrated
326
12
587
EOS
1 without; 2 with infiltration
182*10 14 300-400 (1,2) 327 + / - 53
3
120-200 (1,2) 495 + / - 135
Direct-metal 50-V2
Steel 1.4404
Fockele&Schwarze MCP-HEK Selective laser melting
Metal powder
Laser sintering
3D Systems
Rapid-prototyping material
Metals
>190
3
200*10 > 40
490 - 690
Steel 1.4404
Milling, turning, ...
Engineering material
112 2.2.1 Layer manufacturing [Ref. p. 123
Landolt-B¨ ornstein New Series VIII/1C
Ref. p. 123]
2.2 Rapid prototyping
113
2.2.1.5 Post-processing Rapid-prototyping models are semi-finished products when they leave the prototyper. They show the exact geometry, but they lack surface quality. Due to the RP process additional work has to be done, e.g. supports have to be removed. This process-related procedure is called “post-processing”. It requires additional skilled staff and equipment for manual after-treatment (post-processing). After post-processing one obtains a 3D physical model (facsimile) of the 3D data set. It shows process-dependent properties, such as accuracy, surface quality, physical properties and others (see also Table 2.2.4).
2.2.1.6 Finishing In most cases the quality of RP models does not meet the user’s particu