INTUITION AND THE AXIOMATIC METHOD
THE WESTERN ONTARIO SERIES IN PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE A SERIES OF BOOKS IN PHILOSOPH...
44 downloads
1674 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
INTUITION AND THE AXIOMATIC METHOD
THE WESTERN ONTARIO SERIES IN PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE A SERIES OF BOOKS IN PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, METHODOLOGY, EPISTEMOLOGY, LOGIC, HISTORY OF SCIENCE, AND RELATED FIELDS
Managing Editor WILLIAM DEMOPOULOS
Department of Philosophy, University of Western Ontario, Canada Department of Logic and Philosophy of Science, University of Californina/Irvine Managing Editor 1980–1997 ROBERT E. BUTTS
Late, Department of Philosophy, University of Western Ontario, Canada
Editorial Board JOHN L. BELL,
University of Western Ontario
JEFFREY BUB,
University of Maryland
PETER CLARK,
St Andrews University
DAVID DEVIDI,
University of Waterloo
ROBERT DiSALLE,
University of Western Ontario
MICHAEL FRIEDMAN, MICHAEL HALLETT, WILLIAM HARPER,
Indiana University McGill University
University of Western Ontario
CLIFFORD A. HOOKER, AUSONIO MARRAS,
University of Newcastle
University of Western Ontario
JÜRGEN MITTELSTRASS, JOHN M. NICHOLAS,
Universität Konstanz
University of Western Ontario
ITAMAR PITOWSKY,
Hebrew University
VOLUME 70
INTUITION AND THE AXIOMATIC METHOD Edited by
EMILY CARSON McGill University, Montreal, Canada
and RENATE HUBER University of Dortmund, Germany
A C.I.P. Catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress.
ISBN-10 ISBN-13 ISBN-10 ISBN-13
1-4020-4039-3 (HB) 978-1-4020-4039-9 (HB) 1-4020-4040-7 (e-book) 978-1-4020-4040-5 (e-book)
Published by Springer, P.O. Box 17, 3300 AA Dordrecht, The Netherlands. www.springer.com
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 2006 Springer No part of the material protected by this copyright notice may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the copyright owner Printed in the Netherlands.
Contents
Preface
vii
Acknowledgements
xiii
Part I
Mathematical Aspects
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge ’ Emily Carson The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition Ofra Rechter The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant’s Philosophy of Science, Particularly Geometry Ulrich Majer
3 21
47
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry Ren´e Jagnow
67
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic William Demopoulos
87
G¨odel, Realism and Mathematical ‘Intuition’ Michael Hallett
113
Intuition, Objectivity and Structure Elaine Landry
133
Part II
Physical Aspects
Intuition and Cosmology: The Puzzle of Incongruent Counterparts Brigitte Falkenburg
157
Conventionalism and Modern Physics: a Re-Assessment Robert DiSalle
181
v
vi
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method in Hilbert’s Foundation of Physics
213
Ulrich Majer, Tilman Sauer Soft Axiomatisation: John von Neumann on Method and von Neumann’s Method in the Physical Sciences Mikl´os R´edei, Michael St¨oltzner
235
The Intuitiveness and Truth of Modern Physics Peter Mittelstaedt
251
Functions of Intuition in Quantum Physics Brigitte Falkenburg
267
Intuitive Cognition and the Formation of Theories
293
Renate Huber
Preface
Following developments in modern geometry, logic and physics, many scientists and philosophers in the modern era considered Kant’s theory of intuition to be obsolete. Frege’s and Russell’s logicism seemed to go against Kant’s claim that mathematics is based on synthetic a priori judgments. In any case, according to Russell, the sole reason Kant introduced intuition into his philosophy of mathematics and physics was that he did not have available to him modern logic, i.e., the quantified logic of relations. Following this view, the articulation of the new logic thus rendered Kantian intuition redundant. Moreover, the enormous expansion of modern mathematics in the nineteenth century, an expansion accelerated by the development of the modern abstract theory of sets, appeared to take mathematics out of the reach of Kantian ‘sensible’ intuition. A good deal of this mathematics was also used in various ways in mathematical physics. Even in a relatively concrete case, namely geometry, sensible intuition seemed incapable of deciding between alternative geometrical systems. Many mathematicians and physicists also adopted a version of the ‘axiomatic method’, derived from Hilbert’s work on the foundations of geometry, which allowed that mathematical theories need not have a unique ‘content’ founded in logic or intuition or empirical theories, but that axiomatically presented systems are free to be interpreted as mathematical or scientific requirements dictate. Thus, there is no uniquely correct geometrical theory of space. Moreover, Reichenbach and Carnap in particular argued that special and general relativity disprove Kant’s theories of space and time. Reichenbach and Carnap were two of the most prominent representatives of logical empiricism, which owed much to the work of Frege and Russell. The rise of logical empiricism saw the entrenchment of these views of Kant’s philosophy of mathematics and science. But this only represents one side of the story concerning Kant, intuition and twentieth century science. Several prominent mathematicians and physicists were convinced that the formal tools of modern logic, set theory and the axiomatic method are not sufficient for providing mathematics and physics with satisfactory foundations. All of Hilbert, G¨odel, Poincar´e, Weyl and Bohr thought that intuition was an indispensable element in describing the foundations of science. They had very different reasons for thinking this, and they had very different accounts of what they called intuition. But they had in common vii
viii
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
that their views of mathematics and physics were significantly influenced by their readings of Kant. In the present volume, various views of intuition and the axiomatic method (and their combination) are explored, beginning with Kant’s own approach. By way of these investigations, we hope to understand better the rationale behind Kant’s theory of intuition, as well as to grasp many facets of the relations between theories of intuition and the axiomatic method, dealing with both the strengths and the limitations of the latter; in short, the volume covers logical and non-logical, historical and systematic issues in both mathematics and physics, and also views both sympathetic to, as well as critical of, Kant’s own account and use of intuition. It goes without saying that this collection represents only a modest step in understanding the full impact which Kant’s theory of intuition had on the development of the exact sciences. Part I of this volume deals with the mathematical aspects of the relations between intuition and the axiomatic method, Part II with the physical aspects; the volume thus falls naturally into two parts, although the separation cannot be exact. Both parts begin with detailed investigations of Kant’s own views and of the limitations of what we now call the axiomatic method, and of the ways in which intuition is needed to overcome such limitations. The contributions shed light on modern views of these Kantian topics in the context of modern logic, mathematics and physics. The contributions to Part I deal with Kant’s theory of geometry and arithmetic, with modern interpretations of Kant’s reasons for introducing intuition into the foundations of mathematics, with Husserl’s and G¨odel’s views of the role of intuition in mathematics, and with neo-Fregean logicism and category theory as programmes to replace intuition by the use of formal tools. The distinct approaches show that the role of intuition in mathematics is far from being uncontroversial. Emily Carson sets the stage by considering a traditional correlate of the axiomatic method as it is presented by Locke and the pre-Critical Kant in order to show how Kant’s central notion of pure intuition fills in certain epistemological gaps in Locke’s and the early Kant’s accounts of mathematical knowledge. Ofra Rechter undertakes to shed light on Kant’s Critical philosophy of arithmetic by examining his discussion of the symbolic method of arithmetic in the Prize Essay of 1763. This elucidation of the connection between arithmetical definitions and arithmetical symbolisms serves to clarify the notion of symbolic construction which Kant distinguishes from the ostensive constructions of geometry, and thus to clarify the notion of construction in intuition in general. Ulrich Majer makes the bridge to modern interpretations of Kant’s philosophy of mathematics. In particular, he distinguishes the logical and phenomenological approaches to interpreting Kant’s theory of intuition. According to the former, Kant must appeal to intuition in his account of mathematics because of his restricted conception of logic. According to the latter, however, the appeal to intuition as a non-logical source of knowledge is necessary
PREFACE
ix
regardless of the type of logic available. Majer appeals to Hilbert’s work on the foundations of geometry to argue in favour of the phenomenological approach. Ren´e Jagnow extends the analysis of intuition to Husserl’s account of geometry, which distinguishes between formal, geometric, and intuitive space (the latter being the space of everyday experience). The task here, given these distinctions, is to account for the possibility that the results of the analysis of formal space apply to the space of geometry, and that the results of geometry apply to intuitive space. Jagnow outlines Husserl’s account and argues that its central aim was to guarantee the conceptual continuity between these different notions of space. The applicability of formal inquiry to intuitive space ensures that the former expresses a genuine concept of space. William Demopoulos addresses the idea of founding arithmetic on second-order logic and ‘Hume’s Principle’. In the modern neo-Fregean programme, Hume’s Principle is represented as true by stipulation. Demopoulos argues that we should reject this claim, that it is rather a substantive truth, one that provides the basis for a successful conceptual analysis of our notion of number, deriving the numbers’ theoretically most salient property from the principle underlying their application. This is a partial (but only partial) vindication of Frege’s original project of showing that our knowledge of number has the character of logical knowledge. Among other things, it avoids the assumption that the numbers are ‘given in intuition’. Michael Hallett discusses the respects in which G¨odel’s famous appeal to intuition is based on ideas in Kant. G¨odel thought Kant’s notion of sensible intuition too restrictive for understanding modern mathematical knowledge. What he takes from Kant is rather the idea that there is an underlying conception of physical object through which perception is interpreted. Using this analogy, G¨odel claims that there is a notion of mathematical object through which we interpret mathematical ‘facts’; this notion is given by the iterative concept of set, described by axiomatic set theory. The fundamental incompletenesses of mathematics means the description is essentially open-ended. But G¨odel thinks that the ‘discovery’ of large cardinal axioms extending the iterative hierarchy (thus closing mathematical incompletenesses) represent an unfolding of this concept. Finally, Elaine Landry sketches category theory as a modern mathematical tool that might replace the functions which Kant attributed to intuition in our knowledge of objects, namely the schemata of formal concepts. Part II complements Part I with investigations on the role of intuition in modern physics. The contributions focus on Kant’s pre-Critical worries about the foundations of physical geometry and cosmology, on general relativity and quantum theory, on conceptual analysis and conventionalism, on Hilbert’s and von Neumann’s views of the axiomatic foundations of physics, and on recent views of the role of intuition in modern physics. Brigitte Falkenburg investigates how Kant’s theory of intuition emerged from his use of the analytical method in cosmology. Conceptual analysis of space convinced Kant that the geometrical properties of incongruent counterparts are at odds with Leibniz’s relational account of space, although he always
x
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
adhered to Leibniz’s criticism of Newton’s notion of Absolute Space. Thus, Kant faced a problem, since neither the relational nor the absolute view of space seemed tenable. It is this dilemma which the theory of spatial intuition is used to overcome. The paper also points out that the problem Kant saw with incongruent counterparts reemerges with parity violation and PCT-invariance. Robert DiSalle analyses the conventionalist view of physical geometry. This arose from the confrontation between the Kantian synthetic a priori and two nineteenth century insights: (i) there is no unique set of a priori conditions of the possibility of spatio-temporal experience; and (ii) geometric principles encapsulate the meanings of fundamental concepts, having thus the character of definitions rather than of synthetic claims about nature. Conventionalists inferred that such principles are matters for free choice, guided by pragmatic rather than by epistemic considerations. DiSalle rejects this inference; he suggests that the ‘definitions’ expressed by a priori principles in physics are not chosen for convenience, but arise from conceptual analysis of empirical knowledge and practice. This partially explains why such concepts appeared (e.g., to Kant) to be founded in intuition, and why the separation of physical geometry from intuition in modern physics did not separate its fundamental concepts from empirical knowledge. DiSalle concludes that the conventionalism of the logical empiricists, while rightly emphasizing the role of a priori constitutive principles in science, failed to appreciate the empiricist motivations that such principles embody. Ulrich Majer and Tilman Sauer investigate Hilbert’s view of the axiomatic method in physics and his understanding of Kant’s a priori; they interpret the relation between the a priori and the historical development of physics through a recursive epistemology. According to Hilbert’s account of scientific knowledge, our a priori assumptions about the world are inevitably permeated by anthropomorphic elements which have to be reduced as much as possible; as a consequence, the proportion of the a priori in our overall knowledge of the world shrinks in the course of development of natural science. Mikl´os R´edei and Michael St¨oltzner examine the way in which von Neumann applied the axiomatic method to physics, especially in his famous axiomatization of quantum mechanics. Among some physicists, von Neumann’s method is highly regarded, and is often compared to a kind of mathematical perception. Others, however, consider it to be too pedantic. Indeed von Neumann himself distinguished between the strict, formal axiomatics of mathematics and a less formal, ‘soft’ axiomatization which is required in physics. Brigitte Falkenburg applies central ideas of Kant’s theory of intuition to Bohr’s and Heisenberg’s views of quantum theory. There is no unique axiomatic basis for quantum physics; formal quantum theory has to be supplemented with appeal to semi-classical models and measurement theories. Heisenberg’s generalized correspondence principle establishes semantic bridges between the classical and the quantum domains, and these bridges can be seen as based on intuition in a Kantian sense. Peter Mittelstaedt argues that our Kantian intuition of physical objects, which is tailored to a classical, Newtonian world, is in fact
PREFACE
xi
too highly structured with respect to the notions of simultaneity and substance. He suggests a weaker, non-Kantian account of intuition according to which neither relativity theory nor quantum theory appear as unintuitive. He also emphasizes the point that classical mechanics itself is very unintuitive when seen from the perspective of everyday experience. The collection is completed by a new, consciously non-Kantian theory of intuition developed by Renate Huber. Her theory of intuition is based on an empirically grounded theory of knowledge supported by neuroscience. It sheds new light on various traditional philosophical views of intuition, and it permits the distinction between several kinds of direct or indirect intuitions. These distinctions then give rise to distinctions between directly and indirectly intuitive theories, the latter in contradistinction to non-intuitive theories. The new approach is illustrated with several examples from physics and is also then applied to Poincar´e’s use of intuition in mathematics. The contributions to this volume emerged from a three-year collaboration between Emily Carson, Robert DiSalle, Brigitte Falkenburg, Michael Hallett, Renate Huber and Ulrich Majer. Our project of investigating various facets of intuition and the axiomatic method as they appear in Kant’s work, in mathematics and in physics was generously supported by the GAAC (GermanAmerican Academic Council, TransCoop Program) from 1998 to 2000, and in various ways by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. In addition to individual research contacts between the collaborators, a series of workshops and conferences was held, in Dortmund (1998 and 2000), G¨ottingen (1999) and Montreal (1999). Through these in particular, we learned a great deal, not just from each other, but also from the other invited participants. This volume represents reworkings of some of the papers presented. The Editors of the volume, Renate Huber and Emily Carson, were responsible for its final realization, and exhibited much patience and tolerance with the unwritten, written, and then rewritten versions of the papers. William Demopoulos proposed the publication of the book in the Western Ontario Series in the Philosophy of Science, and has shown great support throughout. Tobias Fox was responsible for most of the technical editing work using LATEX, and Dirk Schlimm dealt with the final round of corrections. Enormous thanks are due to all of them. Dortmund and Montreal, February 2004 Brigitte Falkenburg and Michael Hallett
Acknowledgements
The Editors wish to thank the following: The Journal of the History of Philosophy and the British Journal for the History of Philosophy for permission to use material from the papers by Emily Carson, “Kant on the Method of Mathematics”, Journal of the History of Philosophy, Volume 37 (1999), pp. 629–652, and “Locke’s Account of Certain and Demonstrative Knowledge”, British Journal for the History of Philosophy, Volume 10 (2002), pp. 359–378 [http://www.tandf.co.uk]. The Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic and Philosophical Books for permission to use material from the papers by William Demopoulos, “On the Origin and Status of our Conception of Number”, in Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, Volume 41 (2000), pp. 210–226, and “On the Philosophical Interest of Frege Arithmetic”, in Philosophical Books, Volume 44 (2003), pp. 220–228. The journal Topoi for permission to use material from the paper by Elaine Landry, “Logicism, Structuralism and Objectivity”, Topoi, Volume 20 (2001), pp. 79–95. The journal Noˆus and Blackwell Publishing for permission to reprint the article “Conventionalism and Modern Physics: a Re-Assessment” by Robert DiSalle, which originally appeared in Noˆus, Volume 36 (2002), pp. 169–200.
xiii
I
MATHEMATICAL ASPECTS
LOCKE AND KANT ON MATHEMATICAL KNOWLEDGE Emily Carson McGill University, Canada
Both Locke and Kant sought, in different ways, to limit our claims to knowledge in general by comparing it to our knowledge of mathematics. On the one hand, Locke thought it a mistake to think that mathematics alone is capable of demonstrative certainty. He therefore tried to isolate what it is about mathematics that makes it thus capable, in the hope of showing that other areas of inquiry — morality, for example — admit of the same degree of certainty. Kant, on the other hand, attributed much of the metaphysical excess of philosophy to the attempt by metaphysicians to imitate the method of mathematicians. He therefore sought to limit that excess by examining the mathematical method, like Locke, in order to isolate what is special about mathematics that accounts for its certainty. This paper represents a small part of a larger project relating Kant’s views on mathematics to the emergence of the Critical philosophy. Kant’s recognition of the role of intuition in mathematics had important implications for his theoretical philosophy. What that role is, and what those implications are, however, are controversial questions. I want to approach these questions via Kant’s insistence, even in his pre-Critical work, on a sharp distinction between the method appropriate to mathematics and that appropriate to metaphysics. He often asserted that the application of the mathematical method to metaphysics resulted in flights of dogmatic fancies. An obvious question that arises is why the mathematical method issues in genuine knowledge in the one case, but only results in dogmatic fancies in the other. I argue that a philosophically adequate answer to the question raised by Kant’s pre-Critical account of the mathematical method requires the Critical doctrine of pure intuition. Understanding the development of Kant’s views on mathematics in this way sheds light, I think, on the role of intuition in mathematics for Kant by revealing what questions it is supposed to answer.1
3 E. Carson and R. Huber (eds.), Intuition and the Axiomatic Method, 3–19. © 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
4
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
In this paper, I want to compare Kant’s pre-Critical account of mathematics with Locke’s in order to provide further indirect support for my reading of the role of intuition in the Critical account of mathematics. I argue that Locke offers an account of mathematical knowledge very similar to that offered by Kant in the Prize Essay. In particular, both emphasize what I call the ideality of mathematical knowledge in order to explain its peculiar certainty. But there is a tension between this ideality, on the one hand, and what Locke calls the reality of such knowledge, on the other. This tension is only resolved by Kant’s doctrine of pure intuition. The comparison to Locke is thus intended to bring out the shared concern for the peculiar features of mathematics — that it gives us certain, real, and instructive knowledge — as well as the difficulty of explaining these features. This in turn brings out the importance of Kant’s doctrine of pure intuition for such an explanation. The paper falls into three parts. I will argue, first, that Locke’s account was an inadequate representation of the method of attaining mathematical certainty. Secondly, I will present Kant’s early account of the mathematical method in the Prize Essay of 1763, in which he presents a somewhat improved version of the Lockean account, but fails to give an adequate philosophical foundation for the resulting view. Finally, I want to show that Kant’s notion of pure intuition was the key to the development of an adequate account of the mathematical method and that this, in turn, makes clear why this method was of no use outside of mathematics. I hope to show that Kant’s introduction of the notion of construction in pure intuition was thus not simply an application of the independently-developed Critical apparatus, but rather that it is the natural result of philosophical reflection on a shared conception of the mathematical method.
1.
Locke on mathematical knowledge2
For Locke, there are only two kinds of propositions which we can know with perfect certainty.3 First there are trifling propositions which have mere verbal certainty and are therefore not instructive: for example, a purely identical proposition like ‘A spirit is a spirit’, Locke says, does not advance our knowledge. The other propositions which we can know with perfect certainty are those “which affirm something of another, which is a necessary consequence of its precise complex idea, but not contained in it”. Locke’s stock examples of these propositions are geometrical. For example, since the relation of the outward angle of a triangle to either of the opposite internal angles is no part of the complex idea of triangle, the proposition that the external angle of all triangles is bigger than either of the opposite internal angles is “a real truth, and conveys with it instructive real knowledge”. Locke contrasts this kind of certain knowledge with our knowledge of substances: since the only access we have to ideas of substances is through our senses, “we cannot
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
5
make any universal certain propositions concerning them”. General propositions about substances, insofar as they are certain, are merely trifling; insofar as they are instructive, they are uncertain [4.8.9]. This gives us some idea of why instructive propositions about substances — the subject matter of natural philosophy — cannot be known with certainty. But the question we are concerned with here is why we can have instructive certain knowledge in other areas of inquiry. Knowledge, for Locke, is the ‘perception of the connexion and agreement’ of our ideas, where ideas are whatever is the object of our understanding when we think [4.1.1]. The ideas of which we may have certain knowledge, according to Locke, are those whose agreement or disagreement with each other may be intuitively perceived. These ideas also admit of demonstrative certainty. Demonstration, for Locke, is necessary where we cannot compare two such ideas immediately. In that case, the mind must discover the agreement or disagreement of these ideas by means of intermediate ideas. So a demonstration is really a chain of intuitive perceptions of agreement and disagreement among ideas [4.8.3]. The question we have to concern ourselves with now is what is the special feature of such ideas that allows their agreement or disagreement to be intuitively perceived. This requires a brief reminder of Locke’s account of ideas. Our ideas are either simple or complex. Simple ideas, the materials of all our knowledge, are produced in the mind by means of the operation of objects on our senses. Although the mind is “wholly passive” [2.30.3] with respect to simple ideas, once the understanding has stored them, it has the power to “repeat, compare and unite them” to “an almost infinite variety”, and thereby “can make at Pleasure new complex Ideas” [2.1.2]. So complex ideas are combinations of simple ideas put together and united under one general name. Among complex ideas, Locke distinguishes ideas of substance, which are ideas of something “self-subsisting”, representing “distinct particular things”, from ideas of modes, which are of “dependencies on, or affections of substance”. So ideas of substance are, roughly, ideas of natural kinds of material things, like the idea of lead or of animal. Ideas of modes are best explained in terms of their origin. Whereas ideas of substance, because they purport to refer to self-subsisting things, are combinations of simple ideas which we notice by experience and observation “go constantly together”, ideas of modes are voluntary combinations of ideas. Locke emphasises the free activity of the mind, its power to repeat and join its own ideas “as it pleases” and “without the help of any extrinsical Object, or any foreign suggestion” [2.13.1]. The simple ideas of which ideas of modes are composed are not to be thought of as characteristic marks of any real beings with “steady existence”, but as “scattered and independent Ideas put together by the Mind”. Unlike ideas of substances, they have their origin and existence “more in the Thoughts of Men, than in the reality of things”. To form such ideas “it sufficed that the Mind put the parts of them together and that they were consistent in the Understanding, without considering whether they had any real Being”. For example, although the idea
6
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
of man has no more connection in nature with the idea of killing than does the idea of sheep, we combine the ideas of man and of killing, and make it into a species of action, signified by the word ‘murder’. It is this difference, according to Locke, which underlies the difference between demonstrative sciences like mathematics, and natural philosophy. Ideas of modes, the subject matter of mathematics, are just combinations of simple ideas which the mind puts together arbitrarily, of its own choice, without reference to any “real existence”, and subject only to the condition that the simple ideas be “consistent in the understanding”. Because they have their existence “in the thoughts of men” rather than “in the reality of things”, we can have perfect knowledge of them. On the other hand, ideas of substance, the subject matter of natural philosophy, purport to refer to things as they really exist, and to represent that constitution on which all their properties depend. Thus we can never be sure that we have captured all the various qualities belonging to the thing. Locke formulates the difference in terms of his conception of essence. Recall that for Locke, real essence is “the real internal, but generally in substances, unknown constitution of things, whereon their discoverable qualities depend” [3.3.15]. Nominal essence is not the real constitution of things, but rather “the artificial constitution of genus and species”; it is the “workmanship of the understanding” in ranking things into sorts. In the case of substances, the real essence is different from the nominal essence. The real essence is the unknown, perhaps corpuscular, constitution of a substance, while the nominal essence is a combination of perceptible properties of the substance. In the case of modes, however, the real essence and the nominal essence are the same. Both are the ‘workmanship of the mind’, ‘creatures of the understanding’. To illustrate the difference, Locke compares the idea of triangle with that of gold: . . . a Figure including a Space between three Lines, is the real, as well as nominal Essence of a Triangle; it being not only the abstract Idea to which the general Name is annexed, but the very Essentia, or Being, of the thing itself, that Foundation from which all its Properties flow, and to which they are all inseparably annexed.
In the case of gold, however, the real essence is . . . the real Constitution of its insensible Parts, on which depend all those Properties of Colour, Weight, Fusibility, Fixedness, etc. which are to be found in it. Which Constitution we know not; and so having no particular Idea of, have no Name that is the Sign of it. But yet it is its Colour, Weight, Fusibility, and Fixedness, etc. which makes it to be Gold, or gives it a right to that Name, which is therefore its nominal Essence [3.3.18].
This, finally, is the key difference between ideas of modes and of substances which explains why we have certain knowledge of the one, but not of the other. Because ideas of modes are combinations of ideas which the mind puts together arbitrarily without reference to any real existence outside it, the real essence just is the nominal essence. Because we know the nominal essence
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
7
(we create it), ideas of modes have knowable real essences. Ideas of substances do not. It is upon this ground, Locke says, that he is “bold to think” . . . that Morality is capable of Demonstration, as well as Mathematicks: Since the precise real Essence of the Things moral Words stand for, may be perfectly known; and so the Congruity, or Incongruity of the Things themselves, be certainly discovered, in which consists perfect Knowledge [3.11.16]
In summary, then, it seems that the relevant difference between ideas of substance and ideas of modes is that ideas of modes are in some sense purely ideal. Mathematics is, Locke says, “only of our own Ideas” [4.4.6]. Discourses about morality are “about Ideas in the mind . . . having no external Beings for Archetypes which they . . . must correspond with” [3.11.17]. Two things follow from the ideality of ideas of modes. First, because they do not refer to anything outside the mind, “they have no other reality but what they have in the minds of men”, they “have the perfection that the mind intended them to have”. For example, the idea of a figure with three sides meeting at three angles is, Locke says, a complete idea, requiring nothing else to make it perfect; it contains “all that is, or can be essential to it, or necessary to complete it, wherever or however it exists”. So complete knowledge of the idea amounts to complete knowledge of the object of the idea. Secondly, Locke seems to think that it follows from the fact that these ideas are ‘the Workmanship of the Understanding’ that they are transparent to us: thus, we can have complete knowledge of ideas of modes, and thus of the objects of those ideas. Reformulated in terms of essences, the two important consequences of Locke’s thesis of the ideality of ideas of modes are (1) that the real essence is the same as the nominal essence, and (2) that the real essence is (therefore) knowable. This immediately gives rise to a question regarding what Locke calls the ‘reality’ of such ideas and of our knowledge of them. The problem is that if knowledge consists only in the perception of the agreement or disagreement of our own ideas, then it seems that regardless of “how things are”, the reasoning of a wise person will be just as certain as the most extravagant fancies of an “enthusiast”. Ideas which are mere chimera may be spoken of consistently and coherently, and thus “such Castles in the Air, will be as strong Holds of Truth, as the Demonstrations of Euclid” [4.4.1]. But what value or use is there in such knowledge of our own imaginations? For what “gives value to our Reasonings, and preference to one Man’s Knowledge over another’s, [is] that it is of Things as they really are, and not of Dreams or Fancies” [4.4.1]. Although Locke raises this question with regard to knowledge in general, it seems particularly pressing with respect to his account of our ideas of modes. The content of ideas of substances is easily explained by their reference to “extrinsical objects”. But if ideas of modes really are just voluntary collections of ideas, put together without any consideration as to whether they have ‘real being’, then how can they provide us with real knowledge? What makes our reasoning about squares and circles count as knowledge where our reason-
8
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
ing about mere chimera like harpies and centaurs fails to count as knowledge? How do we distinguish mathematical theories from mere fairy tales about castles in the air? More to the point, how do we distinguish our knowledge of triangles from our knowledge of two-sided rectilinear figures? The problem is that, at least in the case of geometry, we don’t want to say that any combination of simple ideas results in a real idea of a mode. But how does Locke rule out, say, ideas of two-sided rectilinear figures? He says that ideas of modes must be “consistent in the understanding”, but what does this mean? Is it mere logical consistency? We find the answer to this question in Locke’s account of the various modes of space, where he explains how our ideas of geometrical figures are generated by the activity of the mind “repeating its own Ideas and joining them as it pleases”. He describes the power of the mind to join lines of whatever length to other lines of different lengths and at different angles until it encloses a space, and thereby multiply figures both in their size and shape in infinitum. These products of the mind are the subject matter of geometry. What Locke describes here as the generation of complex geometrical ideas is the construction of figures against a spatial background. So it turns out that geometrical ideas have spatial properties built into them. It’s not that the idea of the two-sided rectilinear figure is logically inconsistent: it is rather that those simple ideas cannot be combined in this way, in space. This reading fits with Locke’s example of a geometrical demonstration: since the mind cannot compare the sizes of three angles of a triangle and two right angles immediately, it finds some other angles to which the three angles of the triangle are equal, and then determines that those are equal to two right ones, thereby coming to know the equality of the three angles to two right ones. Ideas here then are to be taken as quasi-sensible images. The problem with this reading is that it doesn’t fit with Locke’s two claims based on the ideality of modes, the two claims that I suggested are essential to his account of why these ideas admit of complete certainty. This problem comes out most clearly when we consider Locke’s claim that mathematics is not the only science capable of demonstrative certainty. In particular, he thinks that our ideas of a supreme being and of ourselves are clear enough to provide “such Foundations of our Duty and Rules of Action as might place Morality amongst the Sciences capable of Demonstration” [4.3.18]. He proceeds to back up this claim by arguing that the proposition that where there is no property, there is no injustice “is a Proposition as certain as any Demonstration in Euclid”. The idea of property, he says, is a right to anything; the idea to which the name ‘justice’ is attached is the invasion or violation of that right. With these names attached to these ideas, the proposition can be known to be true as certainly as any proposition in mathematics. Similarly, if the idea of government is the establishment of society upon certain rules which demand conformity, and the idea of absolute liberty is for any one to do whatever he pleases, then we know with demonstrative certainty the truth of the proposition that no government allows absolute liberty.
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
9
These examples lead one naturally to question the strength of the analogy with geometrical demonstrations. What is striking about geometrical examples, and what struck Locke, is how they provide us with certain, real and instructive knowledge. The same cannot be said of Locke’s examples of demonstrated ethical truths. As Locke presents them, these so-called demonstrations seem to involve nothing more than analyses of complex concepts into their simple constituents. At least one contemporary critic, Henry Lee, pointed out that these demonstrations seem to result only in trifling or vacuous propositions of no use to us.4 On the other hand, they do seem to fit better with Locke’s account of the ideality of modes: these ethical ideas really are arbitrary combinations of simple ideas. They do seem amenable to certain knowledge in virtue of their transparency: we put them together out of simple ideas, and we can therefore break them down to those simple ideas and recombine them. But the resulting propositions are not instructive in the way that geometrical propositions are. As we’ve seen, geometrical ideas are not arbitrary combinations in the same sense. There are some combinations of simple ideas such that if the mind tries to combine them, it will fail. There are external non-logical constraints on the combination of the simple ideas of space: that combination is therefore governed by rules in a way in which the combination of simple ethical ideas appears not to be. The problem with this is that, as I argued above, Locke’s claim that we have certain knowledge of these ideas rests on their ideality: on the fact that they are only ideas in our mind, referring to nothing outside our minds, that we know their real essences. This is supposed to give us privileged epistemic access to them. But the ideas of geometry are not ideal in the relevant sense. The fact that there are external ‘extra-mental’ constraints, that space, in effect, acts as a background theory, shows that this is not the case. In short, Locke’s account of the content of mathematics conflicts with his account of the certainty of mathematics. Locke does acknowledge a disanalogy between geometrical demonstration and ethical demonstration in that there is a special role for figures in geometry. But he takes this to be a merely heuristic role: figures are “helps to the memory” in retaining the many ideas involved in any given demonstration; because the diagrams are copies of the ideas, they have a greater correspondence with the ideas than do words or sounds. What he fails to see is that the role of the diagram reflects an essential difference between these kinds of ideas. On the contrary, he thinks that this disadvantage to ethical ideas can easily be overcome by means of definitions: we simply set down the collection of simple ideas which every term shall stand for and then use the term steadily and constantly for that precise collection. Then presumably, to perceive that two ideas agree involves something like running through the list of simple ideas contained in each. It is hard to see how this results in anything more than what Locke calls trifling knowledge, particularly since we put those ideas there in the first place. The difference in the kinds of demonstration appropriate to ethics and to geometry could not be made clearer.
10
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
In summary, then, Locke’s account of modes is supposed to capture what is different between demonstrative sciences like mathematics and ethics on the one hand, and natural philosophy on the other. Because mathematics and ethics are only of our own ideas, we have certain demonstrative knowledge of them. I have tried to suggest (i) that insofar as geometry is a body of demonstratively certain instructive truths, as Locke describes it, its objects are not arbitrary creations of the mind, and (ii) insofar as the objects of ethics are arbitrary creations of the mind, it does not admit of demonstrative certainty of instructive truths in the way that geometry does. The problem here lies with Locke’s failure to account for the essential role of spatial constructions in geometrical demonstration. More important than the failure of Locke’s analogy between mathematics and ethics, however, is that his account of mathematical knowledge is radically incomplete. The claim is supposed to be that we have privileged knowledge of the properties of geometrical figures because they are only in our minds, we know the real essences. The fact that there are external ‘extra-mental’ constraints — that space, in effect, acts as a background theory — shows that this cannot be the case. In failing to integrate these constraints on the generation of geometrical ideas and our knowledge of these constraints into his account of demonstrative certainty, Locke has failed to explain how we come to have demonstrative certainty even in mathematics.
2.
Kant on the method of mathematics
In the Prize Essay of 1763, Kant takes up the question of whether metaphysics is capable of the same degree of certainty as mathematics. Like Locke, he examines the method of mathematics to determine whether it can be applied in areas other than mathematics. Unlike Locke, however, his conclusion is negative, at least with respect to metaphysics. Indeed, Kant thinks that nothing has been more damaging to philosophy than the imitation of the mathematical method. The primary difference in method that Kant considers in the Prize Essay concerns the role of definition. This difference is summarised in the following passage: In mathematics I begin with the definition of my object, for example, of a triangle or a circle, or whatever. In metaphysics I may never begin with a definition. Far from being the first thing I know about the object, the definition is nearly always the last thing I come to know. In mathematics, namely, I have no concept of my object at all until it is furnished by the definition. In metaphysics I have a concept which is already given to me although it is a confused one. My task is to search for the distinct, complete and determinate concept.5
This is made possible by the fact that “mathematics arrives at all its definitions synthetically, whereas philosophy arrives at its definitions analytically” (2:276). A synthetic definition, according to Kant, is arrived at by “the arbitrary combination of concepts”. The concept thus defined is not given prior to
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
11
the definition, but rather “comes into existence” as a result of the definition. For example, [w]hatever the concept of cone may ordinarily signify, in mathematics the concept is the product of the arbitrary representation of a right-angled triangle which is rotated on one of its sides [2:276].
To take another example, the concept of a square is the result of the arbitrary combination of the concepts four-sided, equilateral, and rectangle.6 This is not the result of an analysis of some concept given in another way — it is not, for example, abstracted from our experience of squares in nature; the concept is, as Kant says, first given by the definition itself. In philosophy, on the other hand, the concepts are always given in some way, but “confusedly or in an insufficiently determinate fashion”. The task of the philosopher is then to discover by means of analysis the characteristic marks in the confused concept in order to arrive at a complete and determinate concept, that is, a definition. Thus Kant says for example, “everyone has the concept of time”. This idea that everyone has must be examined in all kinds of relations, and once the characteristic marks have been made distinct, and then combined together, the resulting concept has to be compared with the concept of time which was originally given in order to determine whether or not it has captured the original idea. If by contrast we tried to arrive at a definition of time synthetically, by arbitrarily combining concepts, it would have been a “happy coincidence” if the resulting concept had been exactly the same as the idea of time which is given to us [2:277]. So in mathematics, we produce concepts by means of synthetic definitions. In philosophy, we analyse given concepts in order to arrive at analytic definitions. In order to appreciate the importance of this methodological distinction, we have to consider Kant’s theory of definition in a bit more detail. He elaborates on this in his lectures on logic from the early 1770’s. A definition is essentially a distinct and complete concept of a thing.7 A concept is distinct insofar as one is conscious of the marks contained in the concept [24:120]. A concept is complete when the marks are sufficient to cognise, first, the difference of the definitum from all other things, and secondly, the identity of it with other things. Kant claims that the synthetic definitions of mathematics are definitions in this sense, and in fact, that mathematical concepts are the only ones that admit of definition. First of all, he says, all fabricated concepts are “produced simultaneously with their distinctness”: I am conscious of each of the marks included in the concept because I put them there in defining the concept, and “one can most easily be conscious of that which one has oneself invented” [24:153]. Similarly, the definition is complete because the mathematician . . . thinks everything that suffices to distinguish the thing from all others, for [it] is not a thing outside him, which he has cognised in part according to certain determinations, but rather a thing in his pure reason, which he thinks of arbitrarily and in conformity with which he attaches certain determinations, whereby
12
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method he intends that the thing should be capable of being differentiated from all other things [24:125].
In other words, if the thing defined is first given by the definition, then the definition is of course complete. This is in sharp contrast to empirical concepts which, Kant says, are capable only of description, not of definition. Since in that case the concept is given, in order to make it distinct I must “enumerate all the marks that I think in connection with the expression of the definitum”. But one can never know that the marks that one has enumerated at any point are “sufficient to distinguish the thing from all remaining things” [24:124]. The most we can hope for is comparative completeness, “when the marks of a thing suffice to distinguish it from everything that we have cognised in experience until now”. Since philosophical concepts, like empirical ones, are also given, “the philosopher cannot so easily be certain that he has touched on all the marks that belong to a thing, and that he has insight into these completely perfectly”; consequently, many marks “may still belong to the thing of which he knows nothing” [24:153]. This suggests that philosophical concepts, like empirical ones, do not in the end admit of definition either. At best, any purported definition will be uncertain. It seems, then, that Kant’s account of the certainty of mathematical knowledge shares the essential features of Locke’s account. What is special about mathematical concepts is that they are given by synthetic definitions — by the arbitrary combination of concepts. Because I defined the concept, I am conscious of each of the marks included in it; because the thing defined is not a thing outside me, but is first given by the definition, then all the marks which I include in the definition of the thing are all the marks that belong to the thing. In other words, to explain the certainty of mathematics, Kant, like Locke, appeals to what I called earlier the ‘ideality’ of mathematical concepts: because we make the concepts of mathematics, we have perfect insight into them. Just as Locke expresses this in terms of his doctrine of real and nominal essences — claiming that since in the case of ideas of modes, the nominal essence is also the real essence, it follows that we can have knowledge of the real essences — Kant, in the lectures on logic, distinguishes between real and nominal definitions. A definition is nominal when its marks are “adequate to the whole concept that we think with the expression of the definitum”; a real definition is one “whose marks constitute the whole possible concept of the thing” [24:132]. Alternatively, nominal definitions “contain everything that is equal to the whole concept that we make for ourselves of the thing”, whereas real definitions “contain everything that belongs to the thing in itself”. In particular, Kant says that all definitions of arbitrary concepts that are made, as opposed to given, are real definitions . . . because it lies solely with me to make up the concept and to establish it as it pleases me, and the whole concept thus has no other reality than merely what my fabrication wants; consequently I can always put all the parts that I name
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
13
into a thing, and these must then constitute the complete, possible concept of the thing, for the whole thing is actual only by means of my will [24:268].
Empirical concepts, on the other hand, would be capable of at best nominal definition since “I do not define the object but instead only the concept that one thinks in the case of the thing” [24:271]. The difference is that in the case of arbitrary concepts, the marks of the “whole possible concept of the thing” just are the marks of the concept that we think in the case of the thing: in defining the concept that one thinks, one at the same defines the object. Because mathematical definitions are of arbitrary concepts, they are also, by Kant’s lights, real definitions. Kant attributes much mistaken philosophy to the failure to recognise this fundamental methodological difference between philosophy and mathematics: that the one arrives at its definitions by analysis, the other by synthesis. Indeed, it underlies his diagnosis in the Prize Essay of the main problem of philosophy: “nothing has been more damaging to philosophy”, he says, than the imitation of the method of mathematics “in contexts where it cannot possibly be employed” [2:283]. For example, a philosopher could offer a synthetic definition by “arbitrarily thinking of a substance endowed with a faculty of reason and calling it a spirit”. However, this would not be a philosophical definition, but a “grammatical” one, a mere linguistic stipulation, and “no philosophy is needed to say what name is to be attached to an arbitrary concept” [2:277]. Indeed, Kant accuses Leibniz of having made this mistake in imagining “a simple substance which had nothing but obscure representations” and calling it a ‘slumbering monad’. He did not thereby define the monad, “he merely invented it, for the concept of a monad was not given to him but created by him”. This charge immediately gives rise to the question of what licenses this way of drawing the distinction between mathematics and philosophy. Kant claims that his treatise contains nothing but “empirical propositions”, a neutral description of the different methods appropriate to mathematics and to philosophy. But for his prescription against the application of the mathematical method in philosophy to carry any weight, he owes us an account of why the mathematical method is appropriate in the one and not the other. What is the relevant difference between mathematical concepts and metaphysical ones, a difference which accounts for the admissibility of arbitrary concepts in the one but not in the other: why is invention permissible, even required, in mathematics, but not in philosophy? Why is the synthetic definition of a trapezium legitimate, and Leibniz’s invention of the slumbering monad not? After all, both seem to involve the formation of complex concepts from given primitive ones. More to the point, the question arises for Kant just as it did for Locke: why does the synthetic definition of a trapezium issue in a legitimate mathematical concept, while the definition of a figure enclosed by two straight lines does not? In short, Kant is subject to Locke’s worry that reasoning about ‘Castles in the Air’ will be ‘as strong Holds of Truth as the Demonstrations of Euclid’, but Kant has somewhat more to say on this matter than Locke does. The com-
14
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
parison of the role of definitions in metaphysics and mathematics is only part of the general comparison of their respective methods as presented in the Prize Essay. For one thing, unlike Locke, Kant recognises a role for ‘indemonstrable propositions’ in mathematics. Even if they admit of proof elsewhere, he says, “they are nonetheless regarded as immediately certain in this science” [2:281]. These propositions are set up at the beginning of mathematical inquiry “so that it is clear that these are the only obvious propositions which are immediately presupposed as true”. So the following picture emerges from the Prize Essay of the method of mathematics. It begins with a few given concepts, which mathematicians cannot and must not define, such as magnitude in general, unity, plurality and space, and a small number of indemonstrable, immediately certain propositions, such as the propositions that the whole is equal to all its parts taken together, and that there can only be one straight line between two points. Further concepts are built up out of the given ones by arbitrary combination — by synthesis — in accordance with the fundamental propositions. The mathematician then derives further propositions from these complex concepts and the fundamental propositions. Kant has made some progress over Locke because he explicitly distinguishes mathematical demonstration from conceptual analysis; he says little, however, about how the theorems are derived from the complex concepts and fundamental propositions. Nonetheless, we have here the beginnings of an answer to the question about how to rule out the figure enclosed by two straight lines: the figure cannot be defined in accordance with the indemonstrable propositions, for it contradicts the proposition that between two points only one straight line may be drawn. The indemonstrable propositions therefore place constraints on the arbitrary combination of concepts. But this then simply pushes the question onto the indemonstrable propositions. What is their status? It is not enough to presuppose them as true; they must in fact be true, and be known to be true if we are to distinguish the demonstrations of Euclid from mere castles in the air. Kant says that they are immediately certain, but what makes them so? The problem here is that Kant’s description of the mathematical method seems to correspond roughly (the technique of derivation aside) to that appropriate to a formal axiomatic system. But unless some explanation is given of the content of those primitive concepts and propositions and the ground of their certainty, this account collapses into a kind of formalism. Regardless of Kant’s views about formalism as a philosophy of mathematics (and it’s clear that he opposes it), the threat of formalism undermines his attempt to distinguish the methods appropriate to mathematics and metaphysics. If the geometer is simply deducing properties and relations of imaginary or ideal objects given by arbitrary definitions, what is to stop the metaphysician from developing an axiomatic system for slumbering monads in a similar way? In what sense can we say that mathematics is a body of truths, and the theory of slumbering monads is not? More importantly, given Kant’s concern with the relative certainty of
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
15
mathematics and metaphysics, how can we say that we know these truths with certainty? To sum up then, Kant’s account of mathematics in the Prize Essay seems to leave open the question of the relation between the method of mathematics, its content, and its certainty. First of all, it’s not clear how mathematical concepts are anything but arbitrary inventions with no objective content; secondly, mathematical propositions then seem to lose their claims to truth as opposed to mere deducibility from axioms and definitions; and thirdly, it’s therefore not clear that Kant is entitled to the sharp distinction he wants to draw between the certainty of mathematics and that of metaphysics. The key to all of these questions with respect to geometry is the relationship between geometry and space. Like Locke, Kant does recognise a role for symbols in mathematical proofs — drawn figures, in the case of geometry — as “an important device which facilitates thought”. The examples of geometrical proofs in the Prize Essay are clearly diagrammatic proofs. But, again like Locke, he fails to integrate this feature into the general account of the method of mathematics: he tells us that “figures and visible signs” play a role in mathematical proofs, but he fails to explain what that role is and how they fulfill it. Considering that his goal is to contrast the nature of mathematical and philosophical certainty, it would seem that he owes us an account of why the distinguishing features of mathematics are guarantees of the certainty of mathematics. It seems then that the important task is to provide an epistemological grounding for the mathematical method. He has to show that the mathematical method of attaining certainty is in fact a method of attaining certainty.
3.
Construction in pure intuition
Kant undertakes this task in the Critique of Pure Reason. In ‘The discipline of pure reason in its dogmatic employment’ near the end of the Critique, he once again takes up the question of whether the mathematical method of attaining certainty is identical with the method of attaining certainty in philosophy. The answer, again, is negative, but the reasons appear different. The essential difference between these two kinds of knowledge is again a formal difference, that “philosophical knowledge is the knowledge gained by reason from concepts” whereas “mathematical knowledge is the knowledge gained by reason from the construction of concepts”.8 To construct a concept is, for Kant, to “exhibit apriori the intuition which corresponds to the concept”. To take one of his examples, the geometer constructs a triangle “by representing the object which corresponds to this concept either by imagination alone, in pure intuition, or in accordance therewith also on paper, in empirical intuition — in both cases completely apriori, without having borrowed the pattern from any experience”. Although the intuition is a single object, “it expresses universal validity for all possible intuitions which fall under the same concept” because it is “determined by certain universal conditions of construction” [A714/B742]. Contrast
16
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
with this a philosophical concept, like that of cause or reality. “No one can obtain an intuition corresponding to the concept of reality otherwise than from experience; we can never come into possession of it apriori out of our own resources, and prior to the empirical consciousness of reality” [A714/B742]. So far, this is again just a description of the difference: objects corresponding to mathematical concepts can be provided a priori, but this is not the case in metaphysics. Recognising the need for an explanation, though, Kant asks “what can be the reason of this radical difference in the fortunes of the philosopher and the mathematician, both of whom practise the art of reason, the one making his way by means of concepts, the other by means of intuitions which he exhibits apriori in accordance with concepts?” Why is it possible for mathematicians to obtain a priori intuitions corresponding to their concepts, but not for philosophers? The answer, according to Kant, is given by the “fundamental transcendental doctrines” which he has just elaborated. According to these doctrines, there are two elements in the field of appearance: the form of intuition (space and time), and the matter (the physical element). Whereas the material element cannot be given in determinate fashion other than empirically, the formal element, Kant says, “can be known and determined completely apriori”. What does this mean? Objects are given only through intuition. The only intuition given a priori, as Kant argued in the Transcendental Aesthetic, is that of the form of appearances. Because space and time, as the form of appearances, are given a priori, “a concept of space and time as quanta, can be exhibited apriori in intuition, that is, constructed” [A720/B748]. Objects for philosophical concepts, such as that of reality or substance, however, can only be given in empirical intuition, aposteriori. So, Kant concludes, corresponding to two elements in the field of appearance, there is a twofold employment of reason: the mathematical employment of reason through the construction of concepts, and the philosophical employment of reason in accordance with concepts. So it’s clear that the doctrine of pure intuition accounts for the difference between these two methods. But what does this tell us about the role of intuition in the method of mathematics? To answer this question, I want to consider how the account of mathematical method in the Critique of Pure Reason relates to the earlier account given in the Prize Essay. In the Prize Essay, the difference between mathematics and philosophy, between the synthetic and the analytic method, rested largely on the different roles of definitions in each. Similarly in the Critique, Kant attempts to show once and for all that mathematics and philosophy are so different that “the procedure of the one can never be imitated by the other”. He does this by once again considering the means of achieving certainty in mathematics — that is, “definitions, axioms, and demonstrations” — and showing that “none of these, in the sense in which they are understood by the mathematician, can be achieved or imitated by the philosopher” [A726/B754]. I’ll begin with the account of definition in the Critique.
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
17
Again, Kant says that to define means to present the complete and distinct concept of a thing. An empirical concept cannot be defined because the limits of the concept are never assured: for example, new observations remove some properties and add others. Concepts given a priori (such as substance or cause) cannot be defined because the completeness of the analysis will always be only probably, never apodeictally, certain. The only concepts which remain are “arbitrarily invented concepts”. With regard to these, Kant says, . . . a concept which I have invented I can always define; for since it is not given to me either by the nature of understanding or by experience, but is such as I have myself deliberately made it to be, I must know what I have intended to think in using it [A729/B757].
However, he goes on, “I have [not] thereby defined a true object”. If the concept depends on any empirical conditions, “this arbitrary concept of mine does not assure me of the existence or of the possibility of its object”. To borrow Kant’s phrase from the Prize Essay, it would just be a “happy accident” if there were an object corresponding to my invented concept. Mathematical concepts, on the other hand, “contain an arbitrary synthesis that admits of apriori construction”. The constructibility of such concepts in pure intuition assures us of the possibility of the corresponding object. Consequently, only mathematics has definitions proper “for the object which it thinks, it exhibits apriori in intuition, and this object certainly cannot contain either more or less than the concept, since it is through the definition that the concept of the object is given” [A729/B757]. Herein lies the reason why synthetic definitions are admissible in mathematics and not in philosophy: the arbitrary combination of concepts in mathematics admits of a priori construction, which assures us of the existence, or better, the possibility of the objects. It is in this sense, then, that mathematical definitions are also real definitions: a real definition, Kant says, “does not merely substitute for the name of a thing other more intelligible words, but contains a clear property by which the defined object can always be known with certainty” [A242n]. Thus, Kant says earlier in the Critique, a real definition “makes clear not only the concept but also its objective reality”. Because mathematical definitions present the object in intuition, in conformity with the concept originally framed by the mind, they are real definitions. Mathematical definitions are, Kant says, constructions of concepts [A730/B758]. What this amounts to, I think, is a rejection of what I have called the ideality thesis. As a result, Kant is able to distinguish explicitly the two models of demonstration that I suggested Locke conflates in his attempt to uphold the ideality thesis. Kant explains that mathematics is not concerned with analytic propositions because as a mathematician, “I must not restrict my attention to what I am actually thinking in my concept of a triangle”; “this” he says, “is nothing more than the mere definition”. Similarly, he goes on to say that it would be futile for the mathematician to philosophise upon the triangle, to
18
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
think about it discursively, for “I should not be able to advance a single step beyond the mere definition, which is what I had to begin with”. In order to gain mathematical knowledge, instead “I must pass beyond this definition to properties which are not contained in this concept but yet belong to it”. The only way to do this is to “determine my object in accordance with the conditions . . . of pure intuition” [A718/B746]: to construct it. So whereas Locke gave no explanation of how properties not contained in the mathematical concept nonetheless belonged to it, Kant claims that they do so in virtue of the concept’s relation to the conditions of pure intuition: “we can determine our concepts in apriori intuition, inasmuch as we create for ourselves, in space and time . . . the objects themselves”. The doctrine of the form of intuition thus enables Kant to integrate the appeal to spatial construction into his account of the mathematical method. Let me try to make clear now how the doctrine of pure intuition resolves the problems raised above regarding Kant’s early account of mathematical method. That Kant was worried about the formalist possibility left open in the Prize Essay, and that he saw the doctrine of pure intuition as eliminating the possibility, comes out clearly in many passages in the Critique. He says, for example, that geometrical knowledge would be nothing but playing with mere chimeras “were it not that space has to be regarded as a condition of the appearances which constitute the material for outer experience” [A157/B196]. The key idea here is that the content of the arbitrary concepts of mathematics is given a priori, by construction in pure intuition, whereas there is nothing given a priori which could correspond to the concept of a slumbering monad. Pure intuition thus constrains the arbitrariness of the definitions and gives content to the axioms and primitive concepts. The fundamental propositions of geometry assert the “universal conditions of construction” of figures, that is, the conditions imposed by the form of intuition. Construction in pure intuition is then simply construction according to the (Euclidean) postulates. The concept of a figure enclosed by two straight lines is not in accordance with the fundamental propositions (i.e., between any two points only one straight line can be drawn), and thus is not constructible in pure intuition. No similar constraints can be prescribed in advance regarding the existence of the objects corresponding to philosophical concepts. Note, though, that this account requires that those constraints be prescribed in advance. What we’ve got so far is a story about how the fundamental propositions and arbitrary concepts of mathematics have objective content. The mathematician does not simply spin out consequences of arbitrary theories, but rather spins out consequences of true theories. But it’s not enough that these theories simply be presupposed as true; they must be known to be true. Otherwise the door is left open for the axiomatic theory of slumbering monads. For Locke and Kant’s earlier self, the ideality thesis was supposed to explain how we do have certain knowledge of mathematics. Because Kant has rejected the ideality thesis, he now has to provide another explanation of the certainty
Locke and Kant on Mathematical Knowledge
19
of mathematics. It is for this reason, I want to suggest, that Kant must see a role for his doctrine of intuition in explaining not only the content, but our knowledge, of the indemonstrable propositions of mathematics. Only in this way can he achieve what Locke and Kant’s earlier self couldn’t: a coherent account both of the content of mathematics and of the certainty of our knowledge of mathematics.
Notes 1. I argue for this in detail in Carson (1999). 2. This section draws on my paper Carson (2002). 3. Locke, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, 4.8.8. 4. Cited in Schneewind, J., “Locke’s Moral Philosophy” in Chappell, Vere (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Locke. Cambridge University Press, 1994; p. 223. 5. Untersuchung u¨ ber die Deutlichkeit der Grunds¨atze der nat¨urlichen Theologie und der Moral, 2:283. 6. Dohna-Wundlacken logic, 24:757. 7. Blomberg logic, 24:263. 8. Critique of Pure Reason, A713/B742.
References References to the Critique of Pure Reason are given by the standard pagination of the A and B editions. References to Kant’s other writings are given by volume and page number of the Akademie edition of Kants gesammelte Schriften. The English citations from the Critique of Pure Reason follow the translation of Paul Guyer and Allen Wood in the Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant. Citations from the pre-Critical works follow the translation of David Walford in collaboration with Ralf Meerbote in Theoretical Philosophy 1755–1770. Citations from Kant’s lectures on logic follow J. Michael Young’s translation in the Cambridge Edition volume. Carson, E. (1999), “Kant on the Method of Mathematics” in: Journal of the History of Philosophy 37 (4), 629–652. Carson, E. (2002), “Locke’s Account of Certain and Demonstrative Knowledge” in: British Journal for the History of Philosophy 10 (3), 359–378. Kant, I. (1992a), Lectures on Logic, ed. by J. Michael Young, Cambridge University Press. Kant, I. (1992b), Theoretical Philosophy 1755–1770, translated and edited by D. Walford, Cambridge University Press. Kant, I. (1998), Critique of Pure Reason, translated by P. Guyer and A. Wood, Cambridge University Press. Locke, J. (1975), An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, ed. by P. H. Nidditch, Clarendon, Oxford. Schneewind, J. (1994), “Locke’s Moral Philosophy” in: V. Chappell (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Locke, Cambridge University Press, 199–225.
THE VIEW FROM 1763: KANT ON THE ARITHMETICAL METHOD BEFORE INTUITION∗ Ofra Rechter Tel-Aviv University, Israel
1.
Preface
In the Critique of Pure Reason, Kant famously draws a sharp contrast between mathematics and metaphysics, held to be a contrast in “method” or “form” of knowledge (A714/B742). His principal aim is to establish the fallacious and self-defeating character of any attempt on the part of metaphysics to aspire to achieve certainty by way of imitating the methods of mathematics. Metaphysical judgments are drawn “in accordance with concepts . . . and never intuitively”. The mathematical sciences, and specifically, pure arithmetic, comprise “knowledge by reason from the construction of concepts”. On this basis, Kant claims, arithmetical knowledge can be intuitively evident. To construct a concept is to “exhibit” the concept in pure intuition. But this is tantamount to defining it, and “. . . in mathematics we do not have any concepts at all prior to the definitions”. The claims that arithmetical concepts can be defined and can be constructed constitute, therefore, both an epistemic thesis and a thesis about the content of these concepts, just as the term “definition” would suggest. The most systematic presentation of the relation of mathematical knowledge to the “mathematical method” of “definition” and “construction” in the ∗ The
present paper is the first of a bipartite treatment of the subject of neglected continuity between Kant’s views on arithmetic in 1763 and his philosophy of arithmetic in the Critique of Pure Reason. My work on this paper and its sequel were made possible by the generous support of the Edelstein center at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. For the discussion of a talk in which this paper originated I am grateful to members of the audience at the conference on mathematical intuition held at McGill University in 1999. For discussion of earlier versions of this paper I’m grateful to members of the audience at HOPOS 2002, at the conference on Kant in the 20th -Century at Tel-Aviv University in 2002, and at the Edelstein Colloquium 2003, and to Daniel Sutherland, Yaron Senderowicz, William Demopoulos, Mark Steiner, Hilary Putnam, Carl Posy, and Sidney Morgenbesser. I am indebted to Charles Parsons for comments and conversations on earlier versions of this paper and its sequel.
21 E. Carson and R. Huber (eds.), Intuition and the Axiomatic Method, 21–46. © 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
22
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Critique of Pure Reason occurs in the Discipline of Pure Reason in Its Dogmatic Employment, where two forms of mathematical construction are discussed: “ostensive construction” and “symbolic construction”. This presentation does not include an elucidation of these notions in their arithmetical employment.1 “Ostensive construction”, said to be “of the objects themselves”, or their “forms”, is exemplified in geometrical constructions; in “symbolic construction” “mere magnitude (quantitatem)” is constructed. The symbolic construction “entirely abstracts from the constitution of the object”. Of course, the terms “definition” and “construction” have a place in the practice of Euclidean geometry. The absence of an analogous context of use for these notions in arithmetical practice makes the clarification of Kant’s usage of them in his philosophy of arithmetic all the more pressing.2 The Discipline, in effect, omits a connection between the possibility of defining arithmetical concepts and the symbolic method. But textual material that Kant denies us in the Critique he explicitly elaborates in the Inquiry Concerning the Distinctness of the Principles of Natural Theology and Morality, also known as the Prize Essay of 1763. This connection is presented in an argument for mathematical certainty — in a context which is universally recognized for its notable correspondence with the Discipline. Both passages engage a contrast between the mathematical method and the metaphysical method; and, in spite of the profound differences, primary parameters that frame this contrast have survived the Critical turn. Whether or not Kant holds the construction of arithmetical concepts to be a species of symbolic construction is a question on which many interpretive stands have been taken, directly or indirectly. But interpreters hold very different views of the significance of this question.3 The assumption that in arithmetical construction symbols are constructed out of other symbols has recently been contested in the literature.4 Interpretations that make this assumption do not address explicitly the fact that textual evidence for it is anything but direct or that Kant does not state it in the Discipline.5 But if the fact that there is no explicit statement of the symbolic aspects of arithmetical construction in the Critique cannot be ignored in interpreting Kant’s philosophy of arithmetic, neither can we ignore the only published text in which Kant states and articulates a relation between arithmetical concepts and their symbolization. Many interpreters turn for evidence to the Prize Essay. But appeals to the Prize Essay have derived very different conclusions from its comparison with the Discipline. For example, Jaakko Hintikka makes the provocative claim that [T]here is no reason to doubt that Kant’s statement in the Critique of Pure Reason that in mathematical reasoning one typically employs intuitions to represent general concepts is intended to formulate in the first place the very same precritical theory, no matter what superstructure Kant subsequently has built on top of it.6
By contrast, Charles Parsons concludes that [T]he prize essay suggests a position incompatible with the Critique of Pure Reason, namely that since in mathematics signs are manipulated according to rules
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
23
which we have laid down. . . operation with signs according to the rules, without attention to what they signify, is itself a sufficient guarantee of correctness.7
Whereas this comparison leads Hintikka to associate Kant’s early views more closely with logic, Parsons emphasizes the “ostensive” aspects implied by the notion that “symbolic construction is essentially a construction with symbols as objects of intuition” (ibid. p. 137). He argues that “the ‘symbolic’ construction in generating numerals is already enough to settle the question of their reference”.8 Disputed questions about the interpretation of Kant’s philosophy of mathematics in the Critique constitute the background for incompatibilities among appeals to the Prize Essay. But an analysis of its place in relation to the notion of mathematical symbolism in the Discipline — central to the interpretation of Kant’s philosophy of arithmetic — is a substantive but neglected task.9 The task of recovering the connection between arithmetic and the symbolic method in the Prize Essay is the task of this paper. Recovering the connections between arithmetical definitions and arithmetical symbolism — two of the most perplexing notions of Kant’s views on arithmetic — can lay the ground for addressing the question: What can be derived from the Prize Essay for a clarification of Kant’s Critical philosophy of arithmetic?
2.
The Prize Essay and the Discipline: Neglected comparison
The primary site of the Critical discussion of mathematical construction is found in A713–738/B742–766. I reproduce the most relevant passages for our present purposes.10 In [the case of algebra, mathematics] chooses a certain notation for all construction of magnitudes in general (numbers), as well as addition, subtraction, extraction of roots, etc., and, after it has also designated the general concept of quantities in accordance with their different relations, it then exhibits all the procedures through which magnitude is generated and altered in accordance with certain rules in intuition; where one magnitude is to be divided by another, it places their symbols together in accordance with the form of notation for division, and thereby achieves by symbolic construction equally well what geometry does by the ostensive or geometrical construction (of the objects themselves) which discursive knowledge can never achieve by means of mere concepts. (A717/B745) Philosophical cognition, on the contrary, must do without this advantage, since it must always consider the universal in abstracto (through concepts), while mathematics assesses the universal in concreto (in the individual intuition) and yet through pure a priori intuition, where every false step becomes visible. Since they can only be conducted by means of mere words (the object in thought), I would prefer to call the former acoramatic (discursive) proofs rather than demonstrations, which, as the expression already indicates, proceed through the intuition of the object. (A734–735/B762–3)
24
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
The passages above in A717/B745–6, the primary site of a Critical discussion of symbolic construction can be compared with the passages from the First Reflection, § 2 in the Prize Essay: . . . I first of all appeal to arithmetic, both the general arithmetic of indeterminate magnitudes as well as that of numbers, where the relation of magnitude to unity is determinate. In both there are first of all posited not the things themselves but their signs, together with the special designations of their increase or decrease, their relations, etc., thereafter one operates with signs according to easy and certain rules, by means of substitution, combination, subtraction and many kinds of transformation, so that the things signified are completely ignored in the process, until eventually, when the conclusion is drawn, the meaning of the symbolic conclusion is deciphered. (Ak. 2:279)
A contrast between arithmetical signs and the metaphysical use of words made in A734/B762–3 appears also in the Prize Essay, but in more detail. For instance, Kant says that . . . words can neither show in their composition the constituent concepts of which the whole idea, indicated by the word, consists; nor are they capable of indicating in their combination the relations of the philosophical thoughts to each other. (Ak. 2:278–9) . . . since signs in mathematics are sensible means to cognition, it follows that one can know that no concept has been overlooked, and that each particular comparison has been drawn in accordance with easily observed rules, etc. . . . By contrast, the only help which words, construed as the signs of philosophical cognition, afford is that of reminding us of the universal concepts which they signify. (Ak. 2:291–2)
Considerable differences divide the arguably related passages, over and above such differences as manifestly testify to the Critical turn that separate them. Given that the notion of construction is not yet present in the Prize Essay, one cannot simply import pre-Critical theses into the Critical setting.11 Of these differences, I want to point out those which should be kept in mind and referred to throughout the ensuing discussion. 1. The Critical framework, of course, contrasts concepts (in their transformed sense) not with objects but with intuitions. This fundamental difference is intimately linked to the significant difference in the senses in which definitions are held responsible for the content of the concepts of mathematics in 1763 and in the Critique, respectively. In the Prize Essay Kant holds mathematical concepts to have “no other significance [Bedeutung] apart from what is given in their definitions” (2:291). This claim does not reappear in the Discipline. Importantly, it is no longer equivalent to the claim that mathematical definitions “make the concept itself” (Ak. 2:276; 2:281). The latter claim, of course, reappears in A731/B759.12 2. The traditional13 tripartite division of logical moments into concepts, judgments or propositions, and reasoning informs the Prize Essay as well as the Discipline. The Prize Essay compares the methods of metaphysics, geom-
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
25
etry, and arithmetic, in relation to each of its moments: concepts, indemonstrable propositions, and “analyses, proofs and inferences”. Specifically, in the case of the arithmetical method, definitions are associated with our epistemic access to the distinct cognition of arithmetical concepts; the principle that “the whole is equal to all its parts taken together” constitutes the arithmetically relevant of the two indemonstrable propositions provided; and the manipulation of signs in accordance with rules in a notation belongs with the subject of reasoning. Later, in the Critique, the transformed moments appear under the headings “definitions”, “axioms” and “demonstrations”. The question of the role of these moments in arithmetic is now more delicate. Insofar as elementary equalities are concerned, only the first chapter of this method is, strictly, applicable, because “in arithmetic there are no axioms” in the mathematical sense, and equalities are best called “numerical formulae” because they are “indemonstrable”.14 3. Two significant differences divide the pre-Critical and the Critical remarks on symbolic reasoning. First, the perceptual expressions replete in the Prize Essay, whether in their literal or metaphorical employment, deserve a separate discussion. But an important difference has been overlooked between usages of an expression with perceptual connotations in the respective passages on reasoning and should be pointed out here. In the Critical passage A734/B762, evidence analogous to perception “secures all inferences against mistakes by placing each one before one’s eyes”.15 In the Prize Essay Kant also entitles us to assurance in reasoning with symbols and expresses the basis for this with a superficially similar perceptual metaphor. But here, the “degree of assurance characteristic of seeing something with one’s own eyes” is attributed to our knowledge “that one has not left any concept out of account, that every equation has been derived by easy and certain rules, etc.” (2:291).16 That no error is possible — provided that the formalism is employed in accordance with the rules — is a metatheoretical claim about the formalism; our claim to know this is likened to and, strictly, distinguished from perceptual evidence. It is a claim about the sufficiency of the correct use of a system of rules in a system of numerical notation to ensure “that it is impossible for a cognition” established by the method in question that it should “be false” (Ak. 2:290).17 Finally, it should be noted that an allusion to the connection between algorithms for calculations and the arithmetical operations occurs only in A717/B745 and not in the Prize Essay. In the Critique the operations are associated with their symbolic “forms” in an adopted system of notation. The Prize Essay18 lists only rules for the manipulation of signs, such as “substitution”, “combination” or “transposition.” These significant differences go without notice if Kant’s pre-Critical views on mathematics are interpreted on the sole basis of remarks about geometry. In fact Kant’s conception of the basis for arithmetical certainty does not coincide with his conception of certainty in geometry.
26
3.
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Why arithmetic?
Kant’s Inquiry Concerning the Distinctness of the Principles of Natural Theology and Morality is known as “the Prize Essay” because of its “Being an answer to the question proposed for consideration by the Berlin Royal Academy of Sciences for the year 1763”. The Prussian academy’s question was this: One wishes to know whether the metaphysical truths in general, and the first principles of Theologiae naturalis and morality in particular, admit of distinct proofs to the same degree as geometrical truths; and if they are not capable of such proofs, one wishes to know what the genuine nature of their certainty is, to what degree the said certainty can be brought and whether this degree is sufficient for complete conviction.
Kant’s response to the question of the Academy implies that the method of the metaphysicians must undergo substantial reassessment and must accordingly be profoundly transformed if metaphysics is to board a secure path of its own. The knowledge that is derived in the mathematical disciplines can be derived with certainty because the methods of reasoning — “proofs and inferences” (Ak. 2:278–9) — employed are adequate for the particular character of “their concepts” and of “their objects”. In both respects there are substantive differences between metaphysics and the mathematical disciplines. Accordingly, the respective methods of “arriving at these concepts” are dissimilar. (Ak .2:277–9) Kant does not, however, restrict his comparison to metaphysics and geometry, as formulated in the question. Why does Kant introduce a separate comparison with arithmetic? Why bring arithmetic in at all? Two possible reasons can be derived from the literature. I argue that neither is supportable by the texts. a) As is well known, the question of the Academy arises against the background of conflicting approaches — associated respectively with the Newtonian “mathematicians” and the Leibniz-Wolffian “metaphysicians” — to questions about the nature of physical space and of bodies in space. Specifically, the geometrical notion of the infinite divisibility of space conflicts with a presupposition common among the “metaphysicians” about the unity of individual substances, viz. that such substances are simple and indivisible, and are the elements of which the real is composed.19 Kant’s introduction of a place in the essay for arithmetic equal to that allotted to geometry may be thought to have to do with an implicit view about a resolution of the disputes surrounding the labyrinth of the continuum, perhaps because arithmetic deals with discrete magnitudes, or because arithmetical and algebraic combinatory methods were prevalently regarded in the period as more rigorous and therefore possibly more reliable than the constructions of geometry.20 But Kant makes no claim to this effect, as one would have expected had that been his motivation. In the Prize Essay Kant makes no argument from arithmetic to support a stand on these disputes. b) A hypothesis that may have more serious exegetical basis would be that Kant is taking issue with the Leibnizian ideal of universal characteristics.21 In
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
27
his lectures on mathematics of the same period (1762–4) recorded by Herder (Ak. 29:1–1) Kant remarks on Leibniz’s contribution to the rigor associated with arithmetical and algebraic notation, and on the combinatory method.22 These remarks in the lectures mention Leibniz’s “dyadic” system with admiration. But this mention is made in the context of Kant’s elaboration on the ingenuity manifested in the discovery of the generative character of the alphabet and also of various systems of numerical notations and observes that both employ a principle for the generation of indefinitely many distinct combinations on the basis of an initial finite morphology. As we will shortly see, these remarks are very useful in clarifying what is otherwise implicit in the Prize Essay. But they do not include any indication as to Kant’s stand with respect to the Leibnizian ideal rigorization of conceptual analysis.23 Kant’s remarks in the Prize Essay, to the extent that they invoke the Leibnizian project at all, seem rather to have to do with the distinction with which Kant opens the essay: “There are two ways of arriving at a general concept”. The difficulties in “arriving at” a metaphysical concept can be made insurmountable if the metaphysician attempts to employ the mathematical “way of arriving at” a concept, that is, by defining it. Kant is concerned, therefore, with the differences in kind between metaphysical concepts and other types of equally abstract and complex concepts, that will explain the hazards of the imitation of the mathematical method of “arriving at” them. Kant’s question of our cognitive access to concepts is at right angles to the question with which Leibniz’s project is concerned. The allusions aim to bring out a contrast between linguistic representation and arithmetical systems of notation. It is this contrast that explains the place of arithmetic in the Prize Essay. Recall that, in the Prize Essay Kant argues that the obstacles in the way of metaphysical certainty derive from the inapplicability of mathematical methods in metaphysics. I propose that Kant has in mind sources of error in the method employed by the metaphysicians which the comparison with the method of arithmetic, and not with that of geometry, can recover as. I will argue, there are obstacles in the way of attaining metaphysical certainty that cannot be brought out merely by comparing metaphysics with geometry. What is of special interest is that by contrasting the metaphysical method with the arithmetical method as well as with the geometrical method, Kant implicitly advances his views on the nature of arithmetical knowledge. In the First Reflection of the Prize Essay § 2 Kant makes two claims that should be distinguished. His first claim is this: No replacement or proxy for epistemic access to the “things themselves”, the objects and concepts of metaphysics can be forged in the form of a formalized “perspicuous” notation. In the philosophical case, neither figure nor sensible signs are capable of expressing either the thoughts or the relations, which hold between them. Nor can abstract reflection be replaced by the transposition of signs in accordance with rules, the representation of the things themselves being replaced in this procedure by the easier representations of the signs. (Ak. 2:279)
28
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
But Kant is not arguing that no formal symbolic alternative to the representation of such concepts in natural language can be devised that would be sufficient for eliminating vacuity, ambiguity or equivocation. He is pointing out, rather, that the question of such an alternative is irrelevant to the major difficulty in the way of attaining certainty in metaphysics. The latticework of conceptual relations is not transparent to the human mind. The idea of a rigorous procedure for deciding the correctness of judgments could well exploit the mathematical structure of conceptual relations, provided that there is for us a procedure for assessing the correctness of purported conceptual analysis. But analysis is the product of successful reflection the nature of which “is difficult and involved” (Ak. 2:282). Since the presence of ambiguities and equivocations in the usage of natural language can get in the way of getting the word-concept relation right, we need to have access to the distinct concept, even in order to recover these linguistic imperfections or correct them. The second claim introduces a principled distinction between words and numerical expressions. It is the claim that arithmetical signs can do something that words cannot do. . . . words can neither show in their composition the constituent concepts of which the whole idea, indicated by the word, consists; nor are they capable of indicating in their combination the relations of the philosophical thoughts to each other. (Ak. 2:278) . . . since signs in mathematics are sensible means to cognition, it follows that one can know that no concept has been overlooked, and that each particular comparison has been drawn in accordance with easily observed rules, etc.. . . By contrast, the only help which words, construed as the signs of philosophical cognition, afford is that of reminding us of the universal concepts which they signify. (Ak. 2:291–2)
Linguistic representation provides no aid for verifying the correctness of conceptual analysis or of philosophical reflection. Kant argues that the numerical symbolism has the capacity to “show in its composition” enough to rule out the possibilities of ambiguity or equivocation and the possibility of vacuity present in the use of words. Furthermore, mathematical usage, unlike linguistic usage, securely preserves distinct representation. The point is that, in the case of arithmetic, no independent access to contents or “things signified” is required for assessing the correctness of an arithmetical cognition.24 In this, arithmetic is singled out by its contrast with metaphysics. As I will presently show, the contrast of metaphysical concepts with the geometrical concepts is not analogous. Unlike metaphysics, mathematics has no need for “carefully searching out what is certain in one’s object. . . by means of a certain inner experience, that is to say, by means of an immediate and self evident inner consciousness, seek out the characteristic marks which are certainly to be found in the concept of any general property” (Ak. 2:286). But the epistemic advantages of geometrical and of arithmetical “sensible means for cognition” are not the same.25
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
29
The very next section, in which Kant explains why the mathematical employment of “sensible signs” makes redundant any need for comparing the concepts with their purported objects. Kant says: Because we are here treating our propositions only as conclusions derived immediately from our experience, I first of all appeal, with regard to the present matter, to arithmetic. . . ˜In both kinds of arithmetic there are posited first of all not the things themselves but their signs. . . Thereafter, one operates with these signs according to easy and certain rules . . . so that the things signified are completely forgotten in the process, until eventually, when the conclusion is drawn, the meaning of the symbolic conclusion is deciphered. (Ak. 2:278)
Words play a mediating role of directing “attention” to the “immediate inner consciousness” (where one can be found). The “essential and substantive” difference in the role of arithmetical signs is that they are not playing the role of mediators at all. So, our question is, in what way do arithmetical signs serve as “means for cognition”? The general issue raised is the character of the mathematical concepts and the nature of their relations to their representations, or “signs”. In virtue of some properties of either, the mathematical case is free of the obstacles in metaphysical cognitions. Both cases involve highly abstract concepts and connections; in both cases these connections are modal and involve in one form or other an “immense” complexity. The question of certainty in the cognition of such concepts arises for a finite mind. How can such concepts be present to a non-divine mind, and be distinctly present, given that no concept whatever is transparent to the human mind? The core of Kant’s argument is that metaphysical concepts cannot be “defined”. “It is the business of philosophy to analyze concepts which are given in a confused fashion, and to render them complete and determinate” (Ak. 2:278). Now, the method of “arriving” at concepts that can be defined is creative and “synthetic”. A central claim of the Prize Essay is that metaphysical reasoning, reflection or analysis can be nothing other than “false and deceptive”, if it assumes it can “start from definitions”. In contradistinction, for both the mathematical methods of geometry and of arithmetic definitions provide a secure foundation for reasoning. Metaphysical analysis applies to “given” concepts represented by language in use. To say that these concepts are “given” is in the first instance to say that their content, distinctly perspicuous or transparent to a divine consciousness, is something the cognition of which by us cannot be taken for granted. Our epistemic access to the concepts of metaphysics must be possible by means beyond the language “through” which they are confusedly cognized and which we use in analysis and reasoning. Because the “only help which words, construed as the signs of philosophical cognition, afford is of reminding us of the universal concepts which they signify”, it is up to our “attention” to make sure that we do not “take different things to be the same thing” or, alternatively, mistake distinct things for one and the same.
30
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Metaphysics “is constrained to represent the universal in abstracto without being able to avail itself of that important device which facilitates thought and which consists in handling individual signs rather than the universal concepts of the things themselves” (Ak. 2:279). Kant is not denying that the metaphysical depends on the use of signs. The point is that “the signs employed in philosophical reflection are never anything other than words . . . [h]ence, in reflection in this kind of cognition, one has to focus one’s attention on the things themselves” (ibid.). Both “kinds of cognition” present some dependence of cognition or reflection on the use of “signs”. However, not every “sign” is a “means for cognition”. Specifically, the words, which we use in metaphysics, are not, although they are signs. Words are ever at an epistemological remove from the objects of thoughts and the relations among thoughts (e.g., Ak. 2:280). The core obstacles in the way of metaphysical knowledge are in the reflection, which, if successful, may lead to the analysis of a concept. Kant does not believe that the language we use in the process of this reflection can yield a standard for the assessment of this success. Rather, what “immediate cognition” we have of conceptual or logical relations is available to us by a kind of “immediate experience” in “inner sense”.26 Kant discerns features of arithmetical formalism that are paralleled neither in the resources of metaphysical reflection nor by geometrical “synthetic” representation. We want to know: what is it that “essentially and substantively” distinguishes the abstract and complex concepts of arithmetic or their signs, and rules out the sources of error to which metaphysical cognition is vulnerable? What is numerical symbolism sufficiently perspicuous of ? What are the “things themselves” that can be replaced by arithmetical “signs”? Are these the things that the signs “show in their composition”? What does the fact that these signs are “sensible” have to do with securing our epistemic access to “the significance of” these signs? Kant offers no direct answers. A step toward answering these questions on Kant’s behalf will be made by articulating his views on mathematical definitions and by clarifying the difference between arithmetical definitions and geometrical ones.
4.
Mathematical definitions in general
In mathematical definitions something new is introduced. Kant says that mathematical definitions are real definitions, that defined concepts that are “created” have “no other significance” beyond what the definitions express.27 Kant’s usage of the phrases “an individual sign” and “the [distinct] object of my concept” seem virtually interchangeable. As I explained above, Kant is interested in the certainty of mathematical knowledge, which he assumes we have, and he assumes that it is obtained by the methods of geometry and arithmetic. His question is: how are the methods of mathematics so related to the objects and concepts to which this knowledge
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
31
pertains that they can yield the certainty that is characteristic of mathematical knowledge? Kant is not aiming to justify the truths established in mathematics or to account for the character of the subject matter of these disciplines over and above what is required for discerning the basis for the illicit practice of imitating mathematics in metaphysics. Leaving to one side other sources of error for metaphysics or its imitation of mathematics, the discussion of definitions should clarify their role in ruling out in mathematics the possibility of error that metaphysics owes to its illicit employment of definitions. I will show that mathematical definitions are responsible for assuring us cognitive access to the objects of the concepts of mathematics.28 By characterizing the general form of mathematical definitions we will be able to isolate the differences between the respective relations of geometrical and arithmetical concepts and the “distinctness” of their objects. In order to clarify these differences we need to recover a distinction implicit in Kant’s terminology.
4.1
Defining and positing
In the Critique of Pure Reason A730/B758 Kant says29 that there is only one German word (Erkl¨arung) for “exposition”, “explication”, “declaration”, and “definition”, and, hence, German usage does not sustain linguistic intuition for distinguishing precisely these different senses and does not always manifest the strictness of the requirement that philosophical Erkl¨arungen be denied the “honorific title” of ‘Definitionen’.30 But “philosophical definitions are never more than expositions of given concepts, mathematical definitions are constructions of concepts. . . therefore mathematical definitions make their concepts [whereas] in philosophical definitions concepts are only explained”. (A730/B758; Ak. 4:479) Strictly speaking, then, there really are no philosophical definitions.31 These remarks in the Critique have their root in much earlier lectures on logic and are consistent with the views in the Prize Essay. It is therefore highly plausible that Kant made a systematic distinction between his uses of the terms Erkl¨arung and Definition in 1763 as well, even if his usage is less than entirely consistent. Analysis, then, really amounts to making confused cognitions distinct. The composition of cognition, however, or synthesis, is helpful and useful simply and solely to produce something new and at the same time, all at once, to make it distinct. (Blomberg Logic § 139, Ak. 24:131, dated in the early 1770s.)32 In mathematics I begin with an exposition [Erkl¨arung] of my object, for example, of a triangle or a circle, or whatever. In metaphysics I may never begin with a definition. . . . . In mathematics, namely, I have no concept of my object at all until it is furnished by the definition. In metaphysics I have a concept, which is already given to me although it is a confused one. (Ak. 2:283)
Philosophical expositions (Erkl¨arungen) are explications of (given) concepts that purport to elucidate concepts in use and not to define them. In mathematics
32
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
there is no use for this sort of explication because these would be the “last thing I know” of a concept given for analysis, and in mathematics concepts are not given at all, but made. In definitions of concepts something new is introduced. Mathematical definitions “create a distinct concept”. Unlike the illusory purportedly “analytic definitions” for which Kant criticizes the dogmatists, mathematical definitions are neither mere grammatical stipulations33 nor mere inventions.34 . . . mathematics. . . can say with certainty that what is not intended to be represented in the object by means of the definition does not belong to that object. (Ak. 2:291)
However, that a definition “creates” a new, distinct concept does not make it mathematical. All mathematical synthetic definitions are real. Real definitions do not merely “contain everything that is equal to the whole concept that we make for ourselves of the thing”, like nominal definitions. A real definition contains “everything that belongs to the thing in itself” (Ak. 24:269). Kant does not purport in the Prize Essay to establish his thesis that any mathematical concept is definable or that any mathematical definition is real. Given a definition of a mathematical concept, that the definition is real is manifested in the sufficiency of the posited signs for establishing mathematical cognition with certainty. An explanation of the reality of the synthetic mathematical definitions would have to account for the sense in which such definitions are sufficient for verifying their own adequacy and how they provide for their own “objects”. The fact that no analogous device can be relied on for the attaining the aims characteristic of metaphysical cognition is the basis for Kant’s denial that definitions can be used analogously in a secure metaphysical method. The character of this adequacy and, accordingly, the contribution of mathematical expositions of “signs” for mathematical certainty in arithmetic and in geometry are not the same. We can see how this distinction is manifested in Kant’s geometrical examples.
5.
Geometrical definitions
Consider the following example of what Kant calls a definition. “Think arbitrarily of four straight lines enclosing a plane such that the opposite sides are not parallel to each other. Let this figure be called a trapezium” (Ak. 2:276). In accordance with the singularized version of a Euclidean definition,35 a concept is assigned to a figure by a performative act of ostension.36 Now the statement “a trapezium is a four-sided figure. . . etc.” would be true, and any and all diagrams constructed according to the instructions would be instances. Such a statement would presumably be an example of “the first thought I can have of my object”. We can now see how the reality of the concept can be guaranteed and how the mathematical definition is “real” in that it is sufficient for “its own correctness” — for the true thought that can be formulated to express it. A particular figure “posited”, or drawn, is regarded as a prototype or exemplar for any instance falling under the defined concept. Such an exposition
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
33
exploits the fact that the figure, having been drawn in accordance with the concepts combined in the definition, exhibits the properties sufficient for it to count as an instance. The figure is individuated as the product of the exposition. That it exhibits the properties in question is a consequence of its configuration as a construction-dependent object. The product of an exposition is a spatial product of a rule-governed activity: paradigmatically, a geometrical figure. However, the fairly clear sense in which such a figure plays the role of a “means for cognition” is one that seems to draw on the individuality and the “concreteness” of the figure, not in the first instance on its “sensibility”.37 Let me clarify. For Kant, early and late, in mathematical definitions “the universal” can be considered “in concreto”, as is well known. But Kant has two logical senses in which, invoking a figure, a concept can be considered in the concrete, neither of which imply the exhibition of a concept in a sensible presentation. The first sense in which a concept can be considered in concreto does not even imply the individuality of that in which the concept is considered, which is as general as the concept so considered, but simply stands to that concept as species to genus. A figure represents a concept that is “lower” in the conceptual hierarchy than the geometrical concept under which it mediately falls. Its concept, for instance, the concept of an isosceles triangle, is a species relative to the geometrical concept of a triangle. So considered, the higher concept is considered in the lower one “in concreto”. In another sense that is logical, the individual figure “under” which its concept “is considered” is concrete relative to that general concept’s plurality of possible instances, for which the figure stands as an exemplar. “. . . in order, for example, to discover the properties of all circles, one circle is drawn; and in this one circle. . . two lines only are drawn. . . and the universal rule, which governs the relations holding between intersecting lines in all circles whatever, is considered in these in concreto” (Ak. 2:278). In the geometrical method the “lower” concepts is considered “under” the individual figure that its constructive definition “posits”.38 This sense of “in concreto” does imply the individuality of that in which the universal is considered: the individuality of an instance of a concept. What, if anything, is the contribution of the sensibility of figures to the certainty of the geometrical method? As can be seen from Kant’s claim that words are not “sensible” in their capacity as signs, it is not in the mere perceptibility of the inscribed diagram that the contribution of its “sensible” character is to be sought.39 But it does, I believe, have to do with its spatiality. Kant contrasts the “sensible cognition” of mathematical signs and figures with the immediate evidence of “inner sense”. As Kant’s examples show, the grasp of a concept entails the capacity to reflect on concepts or to “compare” them, which can be expressed by means of judgments. But the reflective ability necessary for carrying out the analysis of concepts has no resources for the individuation of its objects over and above its own “activity”. By contrast, the recognition of conceptual differences in geometry is not limited in this way, but depends on the grasp of spatial relations, because the recognition of spatial
34
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
properties and relations exhibited by figures underwrites our capacity to draw geometrical judgments. Our cognitive access to the distinctness of metaphysical concepts mandates the recognition of conceptual differences independently of the individuative contribution of space.40 It is in any case not in doubt that the properties cognized and attributed in geometrical judgments are spatial. In “setting up definitions at the beginning of proofs and inferences” the geometer’s assurance of the reality or the correctness of her definitions is free not only from faithfulness to “whatever the concept of a cone might ordinarily signify”,41 but also from metaphysical dependence on a relation between concept and construction-independent object. Geometrical definitions purportedly guarantee that no characteristic mark that does not belong to the object can be inferred to belong to it, and that no characteristic mark that belongs to the thing can thereby be denied of it. In this sense geometry is not open to the error of the metaphysician who misleadingly and deceptively takes “certain knowledge of a predicate of a thing” for a definition (Ak. 2:293). Kant is not claiming that “until now” no metaphysical knowledge has ever been established, but that no metaphysical system has been established on a secure path of its own. “Mistakes are made” when one takes something one knows to be a definition when it is in fact not fit to serve as one (Ak. 2:284).
6.
Arithmetical definitions
Kant does not offer an example of a definition in arithmetic in the Prize Essay. We find something answering to the name in his lectures on mathematics of the same period (1762–4), recorded by Herder (Ak. 29:1–1). In the lectures Kant remarks in some detail on the ingenuity manifested in the discovery of the generative character of the alphabet and also characteristic of the principles for the generation of numerical signs. Both employ a principle for the generation of indefinitely many distinct combinations on the basis of an initial finite morphology. He then goes on to present the arithmetical formalism. “Definitions” are given only for the initial 9 numerals of the decimal Arabic notation. They are 1 + 1 = 2, 2 + 1 = 3, 3 + 1 = 4 . . . 8 + 1 = 9. Thereafter Kant gives what look like proofs for such formulae as 8 + 4 = 12. This seems to conflict with the Critical statement that such propositions as 7+5 = 12 are immediately certain and indemonstrable (A163/B204). They are, in the Critical period, regarded as postulates or as “numerical formulae” based on postulates, which are “immediately certain practical judgments . . . requiring no resolution or proof” (J¨asche Logic, Ak. 112. § 38). Had Kant changed his view?42 Let us consider these “proofs” in the context in which they are set forth. First, is it significant to observe that proofs are given only for the function m+n with arguments 1–9? These “proofs” in effect establish a connection between the ordering of the initial elements by the operation “+1” and equalities for n + m = k for n, m ≤ 9.43 Thereafter, one is to proceed according to the
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
35
usual grade-school algorithms for computation.44 The “proofs” are really an articulation of the (morphological) basis for the appeal Kant has alluded to in the preceding sections to “Einmaleines”, where Kant observes the elimination of the table in Leibniz’s Dyadik.45 In the text immediately preceding the section in which the “proof” is found (§ 38), Kant remarks on the binary notation and proceeds to offer a detailed elaboration of the properties of the decimal system, emphasizing its positional character. (§§ 32–37 are entirely devoted to the description of alternative systems of numerical notation.) The discussion reflects what we learn in grade school. We memorize the sums for arguments less than 10 and then learn an algorithm for computing the sum given any pair of Arabic numerals. If we put this in deductive form we can deduce an arbitrary equation m + n = k from the cases with arguments ¡ 10, using rules for equality, associativity, commutativity and a rule that allows inference from p + q = r, where p, q, r are individual numerals, to p 0 + q 0 = r 0, where “p 0” is the concatenation of the numeral p with 0.46 But Kant does not seem to envision a quasi-axiomatic system. He emphasizes the “ingenious” generative character of numerical languages. In the language in question, the initial 9 elements of the Arabic numerals are ordered by the definitions and the rest generated by the iterated application of the algorithm for producing numerical strings out of previously generated ones in accordance with these principles. This way of conceiving of the generation of the numerals associates calculation in this language with two sets of rules for calculation: the primitive recursive operations of addition and multiplication, and the algorithms that constitute the formation rules for well-formed expressions in the language. Then, in carrying out the algorithms for calculation we employ auxiliary heuristics in which visual aspects like the graphic arrangement of a configuration of numerals play a role. In this procedure . . . there are posited not the things themselves but their signs. . . .thereafter one operates with these signs according to easy and certain rules. . . [applying] all kinds of transformations, so that the things symbolized are completely forgotten in the process, until eventually, when the solution is drawn, the meaning of the symbolic deduction is deciphered. (Ak. 2:278, § 2)
In ordinary calculations in our canonical system of Arabic numerals, we place longer strings above the shorter ones to be added or multiplied, for instance, and begin to calculate individual components of the strings one by one from right to left. Whenever the result is greater than 9 we carry a digit and then add what we “carried” to the result of that next set. In so proceeding we appeal to the memorized table. Eventually, after a series of intermediate such steps, we arrive at a single string — the solution of our original problem. Deciphering the “significance” of a symbol is tantamount to locating its position in the series of numerals. But we have yet to clarify what “locating the position” is taken to involve.
36
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
It is quite clear that the claim, that when we arrive at the symbolic solution there remains something to “decipher”, does not mean that in carrying out calculations we consider only meaningless strings of signs, mere syntactic entities and then have yet to verify what they signify against some “things signified”. In fact, in the procedure just described we apply the primitive recursive arithmetical operations of addition and multiplication, and these are defined for the numbers. We take the numerals before us to present these numbers. What we completely forget or ignore in the process is the original problem. In most of these steps we have to take numerals in isolation and hence as representatives of different numbers from those they stand for in the original strings to be multiplied. Thus, in multiplying n and m I am “ignoring” that in “n 0 0” the number signified by “n” is n × 102 . The heuristics of the calculation exploits the following properties of the formalism. The morphological composition of our canonical system of Arabic notation is such that, idealizing from the zero in initial position, no combination of numerals is ill-formed47 and well-formedness is sufficient for nonvacuity. Numeral strings preserve well-formedness under arbitrary transformation of order, but the position of a constituent numeral in a numeral string is a factor in determining its significance, along with the positions of numerals in the sequence. Moreover, the formation rules guarantee that no two combinations can be generated by the same rule. The composition of strings form singular numerical expressions only. In arithmetical calculation a numerical symbol is what an algorithm for calculation can be applied to. In the present context this comes to the claim that the signs used as arithmetical symbols are possible objects for the application of the rules for calculation — objects that we can calculate with.48 To spell this out in terms of Kant’s present apparatus we need to clarify the sense in which the arithmetical definitions “create distinct concepts” and are sufficient for “rendering distinct” the cognition of their “objects”. To this aim we should first consider the distinction between the arithmetical expositions and definitions. We have established that the mastery of the symbolism and of the rules for manipulating symbols is held sufficient for “distinctness” because the formalism exhibits the following properties: (1) no expression is ambiguous, (2) every expression generated is significant (3) no two expressions have the same significance. What do the definitions of the arithmetical concepts owe to these properties of the formalism?
6.1
Defining and positing in arithmetic
How does the distinction between definition and exposition apply in this case? How does the application of the distinction between defining and positing to the arithmetical example accommodate their stipulative and yet creative character? As expositions (Erkl¨arungen), 1 + 1 = 2, 2 + 1 = 3 etc. are stipulations of signs. Assuming an initial element49 , and an operation “+1”, they
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
37
assign the numeral “2” as the value of “n + 1” for n = 1. The expression “+1” expresses the “positing” for any sign so generated, a next. Kant, recall, takes definitions to be the “first thought I can have of my object”, and therefore they express truths. It is by means of the arithmetical expositions that “the thought of my object first becomes possible” (2:280). Considered as meta-linguistic stipulations, the signs “posited” are really mentioned. But the numerals will appear in use as numeral names in formulae in use50 . So, putting the question of the individuation of numerical symbols to one side, we could for the moment grant that definitions may be sufficient to account for our grasp of the symbolic numerical expressions. But to account for the thoughts — for our cognition of the truths that these signs are used for expressing — is another matter. This leaves us with an ambiguity in the account of definitions: between cognizing the distinct sign and cognizing the truth of a “thought” that the “composition” of signs purportedly “shows”. This ambiguity corresponds to an ambiguity in the notion of the “reality” of definitions. A “real definition”, recall, contains “everything that belongs to the thing in itself” (Ak. 24:269). But this is also supposed to make the real definitions sufficient for our confidence in their correctness, so that we “can say with certainty that what is not intended to be represented in the object by means of the definition does not belong to that object” (Ak. 2:291). A normative sense of syntactic well-formedness will not yield the sense of correctness we need if the notation is to deliver its promise to “show in its composition” the concepts it purportedly defines. The question posed earlier: “What do the signs ‘show”’? can now be made more precise. That on Kant’s view the posited signs cannot be held to be mere pawns in a syntactic game is already indicated in our discussion of calculation. One might have taken Kant’s view to suggest that they are, because Kant holds that the mathematical “significance” of our arithmetical “concepts” is exhausted by their definitions51 and because the operations “+1” and the equality sign are “significant” only for individual arguments presented by numeral signs or by (essentially singular) functional numerical expressions. However, that Kant’s view does not render otiose the notion that the signs refer is evident from his allusion to the “things signified” by these signs. On the one hand, there are the “things signified” for which the generated signs are mere “representatives” or “replacements”. But, on the other hand, these “things” seem to make no contribution to the basis for the correctness of our “symbolic conclusions”; in calculation the signs play the role of representatives for “things signified”. Nor does Kant seem to render the notion that numerals refer moot by identifying the “object of the concept” with the posited sign, regarding its reference reflexively, as it were. What Kant had said was that it is sufficient to replace these things with signs in order to establish correct results by calculation. Kant, therefore, does not deny the notion that these signs behave like names. Now, Kant uses the term “an arithmetical object” for something of whose complexity we have a distinct grasp [Faßlichkeit] or understanding [verstanden]. He does
38
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
not say what an arithmetical object is. But he does say that distinct arithmetical cognition involves “understanding an arithmetical object” and he does have something to say about what “understanding an arithmetical object” involves. Where does what we have recovered thus far leave us? Kant assumes that our only epistemic access to arithmetical concepts rests on the mastery and use of the formalism. Fundamental characteristics of the arithmetical symbolism play a role in the function of arithmetical “signs” as “means for cognition”. The generative principles of the notation guarantee that any well-formed numeral string is (uniquely) significant and that any sequence of such strings generated will be isomorphic with the sequence for which it purportedly stands. Numerical symbols owe their relation to that for which they stand to the structure to which they belong because they can be generated only in accordance with principles governed by a certain form. Numerals are singular representations partly in the sense that they can be correlated with a unique position in that structure; for the same reason they can also serve to model what they symbolize. What fixes the place of a numeral in a symbolic system, as indicated above, are the principles for generating symbols out of other symbols. These principles, in turn, are sufficient for “understanding52 an arithmetical object” distinctly, and this understanding really consists of “understanding a relation of a multiplicity to unity”, for example, the relation of a trillion to unity” (Ak. 2:280). But of course this doesn’t mean that the “object” is identified with such relations. Symbolic composition must (at least) be adequate for representing sameness of “position” for different expressions, for the employment of the symbolism in the practice of calculation seems to turn precisely on this. As the above discussion of the role allotted to “visible signs” as symbolic configurations in calculation suggests, Kant’s pre-Critical notion of a numeral-name “occupying” or being assigned a position in a structure seems to trade on an ambiguity between a spatial and a logical, notion of position.53 Kant’s discussion in the Prize Essay proceeds on the premise that we possess arithmetical knowledge and purports to account for the conceptual cognition involved in this knowledge by the methodology of definition. Kant states that what the definitions define are “concepts”. But the texts provide insufficient basis for a description of what these concepts might be the concepts of. Would the arithmetical definitions be sufficient to yield a mathematical definition of the concept of number in general? If not, does this force the view that the general concept of number is a metaphysical concept? Would this imply that this concept must be held to stand to the defined concepts of the numbers as genus to species? Do the concept arithmetically defined include the concepts of the arithmetical operations? Kant clearly includes among concepts arithmetically defined the concepts of the individual numbers. Kant’s usage seems, however, to equivocate between what would be the “objects of” these concepts, the referents for numerical equalities — of the arithmetical “thoughts”, and the “things signified”, on the one hand, and between (any of
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
39
these) and “things” which are not what the concepts defined signify, but to which they may apply. One difficulty arises from the fact that, notwithstanding the mention of the notion of counting in the lectures, the remarks seem to leave out of account the notion of cardinality. The account of a system of numerals exploits the successive composition of the generated strings of the notation-system. But Kant’s later emphasis on successive addition is entirely absent from the view from 1763. It is not clear how much we can derive from Kant’s words toward a resolution of the ambiguities to which they seem to give rise or to the questions posed. Here, however, is a suggestion that we can make. Because the numeral system in question in fact also provides a source of models for the numbers, forming, as it does, the standard order-type of the successor function, we could regard the numerals as mere sign-types for which “deciphering” the significance by verifying their reference is required, for example, by counting numerals.54 In this sense an arithmetically significancant structure is instantiated by systems of signs.55 In arithmetic we can take the generative procedure to be that which is employed in the articulation of a canonical system of notation — a system of numeral names — for the numbers. This may bridge the ambiguity between our grasp of the “object” and our cognition of the arithmetical truths because the numeral-types we construct must themselves form a model of the arithmetical truths (for us, of the axioms).
7.
Conclusion
In establishing that the introduction of arithmetic into Kant’s response to the Academy’s question in the Prize Essay serves to uncover obstacles in the way of achieving metaphysical certainty — in contrast to mathematical certainty — obstacles that could not be uncovered if metaphysics were contrasted only with geometry, I emphasized those aspects of “method” which are shared by geometry and metaphysics, but not by arithmetic. Specifically, in geometry and in metaphysics, our access to concepts turns — in one sense or another — on the “comparison” of a representation with something else. In metaphysics concepts are “compared” with other concepts or with compounds thereof. In geometry what individuates a figure is the recipe for its construction, but Kant also introduces the notion that the geometrical figure or sign “is similar to the things signified”, and this notion must play a role in our cognition of the adequacy of this recipe. This is also indicated in the logical form of the “first thoughts I can have of my object” — the linguistic articulation of the definitions in geometry, which are purportedly true predications. But in arithmetic the definitions are formulae in a notation. These formulae belong with the principles that constitute the notation. However, the correctness of the definitions or of the results of calculation does not depend on correspondence between signs and these things. The signs posited in arithmetic owe their perspicuity not to shared properties between sign and object, but rather to an affinity in their manner of generation.
40
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
In an important sense there would seem to be much in common between the “ostensive” aspects of geometrical and arithmetical signs. The generated figure, or “symbolic form”, is representative of precisely the procedures that are responsible for its individuation. In both cases what is “placed before the eyes” is imbued with the constructive principles to which its function as a sign or a representative is due. Of course, a geometrical figure stands in for an indefinite plurality of possible instances of the concept of, say, a triangle whereas a numeral is one of indefinitely many possible symbolic representations of the same number. That the arithmetical individual signs hold an inverse relation to what would be their “object” and the respective mathematical “signs” may now be construed in terms of a notion of mathematical form. For that is a result of mathematical facts about the respective content or subject matter of these disciplines. The relevant mathematical fact is that Euclidean space is homogeneous; every point is like every other. Given two congruent triangles, there is an automorphism of the space that takes one to the other.56 But in arithmetic the only automorphism is the identity. In considering the relation of this view to Kant’s position about arithmetical knowledge in the Critique of Pure Reason many questions remain open. The leading question is how Kant might take us from a conception of the finite ordinals qua positions in a sequence (the grasp of which he associates with the grasp of an arithmetical object, whose cognition is availed by symbolic composition, and consists of understanding a relation of a multiplicity to unity) to the Critical claim that the elementary numerical equalities are singular judgments. But the bounds of this paper are met in concluding that these connections should be explored.
Notes 1. A712/B740 to A738/B766. 2. Construction is not mentioned explicitly in the Critical passages on arithmetic, e.g., B14–16, A164– 165/B205–206, A240/B299, or A140–141/B179–180. For allusions to arithmetic in the Discipline see A724/B752; A720/B748. But the remarks on symbolic construction mention algebra. As is well known, the relation between algebra and arithmetic in Kant’s view is a matter of dispute. These disputes do not center on the relevance of the relationship between the languages of arithmetic and algebra. 3. Examples include leading interpretations of Kant’s philosophy of mathematics, notably Charles Parsons (1969); Michael Young (1984); Charles Parsons (1984); Michael Friedman (1992); C. D. Broad (1941), (1978); Manley Thompson (1972–3); E. W. Beth (1956–7); Jaakko Hintikka (1973); Philip Kitcher (1975). I should note that the claim that arithmetical construction involves the construction of numerals does not settle the question whether arithmetical construction is “symbolic” or “ostensive”. The considerations that enter are essential for appreciating the connection between Kant’s views on the arithmetical “method” in the Discipline and his Critical views on the concepts of the numbers and on arithmetical equalities (and inequalities). For different ways of conceiving the relation between symbolic and ostensive notions of arithmetical construction see Parsons (1969), Young (1984), Parsons (1984). I can at most gesture here toward issues I address in the sequel to this paper. 4. This assumption was recently contested by Lisa Shabel (1998). Whether or not Shabel is right, her criticism brings out the difficulties in the way of advancing a direct exegetical argument for this assumption solely on the basis of textual evidence from the Critique of Pure Reason. 5. A713–738/B741–766. 6. Hintikka (1973), p. 145.
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
41
7. Parsons (1969), p. 138 of Parsons (1983); in Posy (ed.) (1992), p. 66. 8. I will not address the much discussed questions that divide Parsons’ and Hintikka’s approaches. Support can be found in what follows for Parsons’ observation that a “connection to the senses by way of symbols” is already made in the Prize Essay. (See Parsons (1969), p. 183 of Parsons (1983), or Posy (ed.) (1992), p. 66.) Such a connection is, in fact, made in several forms which I will distinguish and explore. 9. Even in such a focused discussion of the evolution of the Critical views on the mathematical method from the Prize Essay as is found in Carson (1999), the specific relation between the respective discussions of the symbolic methods of arithmetic in 1763 and in the Critical period is not addressed. Carson argues that in the Prize Essay Kant does not explain why definitions in mathematics are “real” and cannot be mere inventions. Whether or not this criticism is correct, it does not affect Kant’s conception of arithmetical definitions. 10. The different aspects of their comparison will call them to our attention as we proceed. 11. Pace Hintikka. 12. The Critique’s qualification that the “sense” [Sinn] and the “significance” [Bedeutung] of mathematical concepts and the standing of the knowledge discussed in the Discipline depends on the claim that the pure intuitions in which these concepts are exhibited are the pure forms of sensible intuitions of objects of possible experience is essential for appreciating the difference between the pre-Critical and the Critical conceptions of the mathematical method and on the relation between definitions and mathematical concepts. See particularly (A240/B299). For a discussion of the significance of this qualification for Kant’s Critical philosophy of arithmetic, see Parsons (1984), reprinted in Posy (ed.) (1992). 13. In the standard traditional source of the Logic of Port Royal, the three moments are “ideas”, “judgments” and “reasoning”. 14. A163–165/B204–206. 15. In these much discussed remarks, Kant emphasizes that the epistemological value of “symbolic construction in which one displays by signs in intuition the concepts, especially the relations of quantities” goes beyond its heuristic advantages. 16. Compare Friedman (1992) p. 85. 17. It associates the license for certainty in combinatory operations to our mastery of the notation and command of the operations performed. 18. Ak. 2:279. See also Ak. 2:278. In the context, the “subtraction” included in the detailed list evidently means the elimination of signs or symbols concatenated or otherwise “combined”. 19. Kant’s own contribution to these and related controversies in his early writings as well as the transformations of his views are the subjects of extensive study. These debates, in turn, have had notable impact in propelling the evolution of his pre-Critical thought. 20. For a helpful survey and discussion, see Pycior (1997). 21. This suggestion is made by Gottfried Martin (1985), p. 67. Martin reads Kant in the Prize Essay as “brusquely rejecting” the “approach” presented in “Leibniz’s projection of the ars characteristica universalis, at least in the form in which Kant was acquainted with it through Lambert”. As evidence he cites the passage I quote next, (Ak. 2: 278). The passage does not extend an argument and Martin does not use it to motivate one. Compare New Elucidation of the First Principles of Metaphysical Cognition (Ak. 1:385–416) of 1755 and Concerning the Ultimate Foundation of the Distinction of Directions in Space (Ak. 2:375–83), of 1768. Gottfried Martin reads the Critical passages at A724/B752 as making a similar allusion. 22. I will turn to these remarks and to the lectures in what follows. I use material Kant used in teaching to illustrate and clarify his statements in the published Prize Essay. In general, it should be borne in mind that what we have as interpretive evidence is notes for the lectures, and these may not be entirely faithful to them. 23. Pace Martin. See n. 21 above. 24. The clarification of this point and of the basis Kant has for claiming it, will engage us in what follows. 25. The difference is that the correctness of geometrical cognition does, whereas arithmetical cognition does not, depend on the relations among “characteristic marks. . . to be found in the concept”. This will shortly be clarified by turning to the differences in Kant’s conception of the respective notions of definition. 26. The subject of Kant’s conceptions in 1763 of “inner sense”, “inner experience” and the data or evidence that might be derived from them cannot be addressed here in any way beyond what will directly bear on the present topic. But see False Subtlety (Ak. 2:60–1). See also Negative Magnitudes (Ak. 2: 190–3).
42
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
27. At Ak. 2:284, Kant says that “die Bedeutung der Zeichen” is certain [sicher], and then at Ak. 2:291 that defined concepts have “keine Bedeutung als die, so ihn die Definition gibt”. The German term translated as “significance” in the Cambridge Edition is, consistently, “Bedeutung”. Kant uses this term in the mathematical cases consistently. For the geometrical case, see especially Ak. 2:276 and Ak. 2:292. The former passage distinguishes what “the concept of a cone may ordinarily signify (bedeuten)” and the significance of the concept of a cone “arrived at” in the mathematical way. The latter passage makes the claim that “in geometry, the signs are similar to the things signified”. Kant in some contexts uses Bedeutung in relation to metaphysical concepts, e.g., Ak. 2:291–2. 28. In what follows I propose that, whereas the account may be sufficient for showing why definitions cannot synthesize — and can therefore not “define” — empty concepts, they fall short of establishing the conceptual character of their product, let alone its mathematical character. To put the matter in Kantian terms, the account of “the universal” purportedly considered in and under the “synthesized” concrete sign is significantly incomplete. It is worth pointing out that a difficulty in accounting for the notion of a numberconcept reappears in the interpretation of the philosophy of arithmetic of the Critique. 29. The translators of the Cambridge Edition appeal to A729–730/B757–758 in support of their translation of both “Definition” and “Erkl¨arung” by the English “definition”. But this passage seems to me to go against their claim that “in the Prize Essay Kant uses the terms. . . as synonyms” (n.6˜ to the Glossary in Kant (1992b)), if it can be used as evidence for such a matter at all. 30. Some technical delicacy would be expected if the Latin cognates were introduced late in the day into the German philosophical jargon. 31. The distinction recovered in this section is relevant to Mirella Capozzi’s analysis in Capozzi (1980), pp. 423–452. I regret that these views cannot be addressed in this paper. 32. There seem to me to be reasons for questioning the basis on which the translators of the Cambridge Edition date the Blomberg Logik around 1770. Briefly, since these are compiled transcripts, the “internal evidence”, for instance, that a passage from the Dissertation is found in them, is not sufficient for a conclusive verdict about the whole batch. The transcripts are attributed to Blomberg because they were found in his possession and his name appears on the title page. The translator’s comments suggest that they came into his possession, but it is not implausible that parts of them originated with him. Blomberg himself had completed his studies in 1764. On this basis, the translators conclude that the presence of later material entails that he could not have been responsible for the transcripts himself. But it is also acknowledged that the lectures on which the transcripts are based are earlier. It does seem to follow that his lecture notes cannot be taken to constitute everything that is included in the compiled text, since the transcripts include Dissertation material. But the evidence taken together, as well as the contents of the lectures, suggests that the transcript compiles material from various periods, including earlier than 1770. 33. Pace Polonoff, who takes Kant to hold that in mathematics definitions play the role of grammatical stipulations. According to Polonoff “the mathematician is expected to say with certainty that whatever his definition did not intend to represent in the concept of the object defined is not included in the concept of the object as far as his discussion is concerned.” (1973, p. 186) But the relevant passage says that “what is not intended to be represented in the object by means of the definition does not belong to that object” (Ak. 2:291). Polonoff is, however, clearly aware of the incompatibility of the weaker claim he attributes to Kant with Kant’s claim that the mathematical definition “is the first thought I can have of my object”. He concludes that for Kant in the Prize Essay “the definition is neither true nor false but merely stipulated” (ibid.). 34. “A case in point would be that of a philosopher arbitrarily thinking of a substance endowed with the faculty of reason and calling it a spirit. My reply, however, is this: such determinations of the meaning of a word are never philosophical expositions (Erkl¨arungen). If they are to be called expositions at all they are merely grammatical expositions. For no philosophy is needed to say what name is to be attached to an arbitrary concept. Leibniz imagined a simple substance, which had nothing but obscure representations, and he called it a slumbering monad. But, in doing so he merely invented [erdacht] it.” (Ak. 2:277) 35. Kant’s example is an interesting choice if, as it seems, it is taken from Euclid’s Definition 22 (Elements, Book 10) with significant alterations. First, Kant emphasizes the ostensive and singular, and in Euclid the trapezium is one of the few figures whose concept occurs in a definition in the plural. Second, Euclid’s definitions are characteristically stated in subject-predicate form. Definition 22 is this: Of quadrilateral figures, a square is that which is both quadrilateral and right-angled; an oblong that which is right-angled but not equilateral; a rhombus that which is equilateral but not right-angled; and a rhomboid that which has its opposite sides and angles equal to one another but is neither equilateral nor right-angled. And let quadrilaterals other than these be called trapezia.
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
43
36. Compare Beweisgrund (Ak. 2:95–6). 37. In Blomberg Logic § 157, Kant distinguishes between two types of connection between certainty and the senses. “Sensible certainty must be distinguished from certainty of the senses. Sensible certainty. . . does not really arise through actual intuition of objects by means of our senses but rather merely through the fact that we make cognitions distinct, convincing and capable of insight more easily and with less effort”. 38. It is often overlooked that it is not analytic to the “consideration of a concept in concreto” that it be considered in the individual. See, for example J¨asche Logic § 16, Notes 1 and 2. In the Critique, it is a substantive claim that the concept is exhibited in concreto in intuition. In the Prize Essay, however, it is also in the individual that a concept is considered in concreto. This is what Kant emphasizes by contrasting the consideration of a universal concept merely “through” words but — in the mathematical cases — under signs. 39. It is, of course, one thing to hold Kant to be making a connection between the mathematical use of signs and the senses; it is quite another to hold him to be making such a connection between these signs and sensibility. We cannot pursue either direction here any further. 40. Kant had already rejected the Leibnizian principle of the identity of indiscernibles (New Elucidation of the First Principles of Metaphysical Cognition, Proposition XI, § 2, Ak. 1:409–410) and asserted that “things which are distinguished at least in virtue of place are not one and the same thing at all” (Ak. 1:409; see also Friedman (1992), p. 8, note 11). I do not, of course, consider this sufficient evidence for the supposition that Kant came close to attributing to space the individuation of construction-dependent objects, for this would be very close to holding space to provide the grounds for the claim that constructions can be carried out. 41. Ak. 2:276. 42. Beatrice Longuenesse views the Critical contention that in arithmetic “there are no axioms” as arising from a disillusionment with a Leibnizian conception of definitions, which she attributes to the preCritical Kant. See Longuenesse (1998), pp. 277–278. Gottfried Martin proposed that the discovery that such proofs as Leibniz’s of 2 + 2 = 4 from definitions in Leibniz (1765; 1996), Book IV, ii § 10, presuppose synthetic principles like the principle of associativity of addition convinced Kant of the syntheticity of arithmetic. But the premise of these views does not seem to find its support in the lectures. 43. Similarly for multiplication, subtraction and division. 44. Kant formulates a few general schematic principles for the operation signs “+”, “−”, “×” and “:”. 45. Leibniz and Wolff are known to have considered the binary system in a certain sense superior to the canonical decimal system with respect to its revelatory character. Kant does not seem to share such a view. See, e.g., remarks quoted in Martin (1995), pp. 90–91. The issues raised by these comparisons are important for the topic of this paper, but they cannot be pursued here. 46. We would only have to introduce the distributive law to deduce this if we define p 0 as p × 10, assuming a number like 165 is defined as 100 + 60 + 5. 47. Assuming that we have a criterion for sameness of numeral-type. 48. There may be an ambiguity in what I just said which I want to dispel. I am not raising the question of the constraints on individuating occurrences of numerical symbols, something that is surely necessary for clarifying the idea of the application of “substitutions and transformations” etc., but a different question. The relevant question is how the distinctness of the symbol might be construed so that we may conceive of the operations with these symbols in accordance with the rules of a specific system of notation as yielding the cognition of the results of arithmetical calculation. 49. In the lectures Kant indicates that Einheit is taken as primitive (Ak. 29:1-1, 52). 50. Kant’s pre-Critical usage of “positing” or posisiones, associated with definitions by arbitrary combination (e.g., Blomberg Logic § 190, Ak. 230, Beweisgrund, False Subtlety), is used ambiguously in other pre-Critical contexts. 51. See Ak. 2:276, 2:284, 2:291 resp. 52. Compare Blomberg logic § 143: “. . . to understand something [is] to cognize something distinctly through the understanding”. The Cambridge Edition translators use “understanding” for “Faßlichkeit” as well as for “verstanden”. The former is used in relation to the grasp of “an arithmetical object, which contains an immense multiplicity”. The latter is used for the grasp of the “relation of a trillion to unity” which amounts to the distinct cognition of that immense multiplicity “contained in” the arithmetical object of cognition. 53. This suggests that Kant’s resources for conceiving the mathematical notion of the iteration of a mechanical operation do not by themselves encourage the appeal to the sensible signs, but rather that the basis for the assurance that distinct applications of the same rule to the same argument necessarily yield the same value.
44
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
54. That Kant omits mention of counting in the Prize Essay is, of course, one of the pivotal contrasts with the Critical interest in the concept of number, but does not distinguish the Prize Essay from the Critical bounds of the remarks in the Discipline on the subject of symbolic construction. The omission is important for the pre-Critical identification of the arithmetical method with the use of signs within a canonical notation. In the lectures Kant makes clear that numerieren is not counted among the rules of the notation [52]. This underscores his concern with the notation-specific algorithms. 55. Albeit only an ordinal structure. 56. Though not of the plane; then they have to be oriented in the same way.
References All references to Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason are given by the standard pagination according to the original (A for first edition [1781], B for second edition [1787]). All references to Kant’s writings except the Critique of Pure Reason are given by volume and page number of the Akademie edition of Kants gesammelte Schriften (Berlin, 1902–). The English citations of the Critique of Pure Reason follow the translation of Paul Guyer and Allen Wood, in the Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant. All citations of pre-Critical works follow the translation of David Walford in collaboration with Ralf Meerbote in Theoretical Philosophy 1755–1770, in the Cambridge Edition. All citations from Kant’s lectures on logic follow J. Michael Young’s translation in the Cambridge Edition. Works of Immanuel Kant Kant, I. (1902–), Kants gesammelte Schriften, edited by the Royal Prussian (later German) Academy of Sciences (later the G¨ottingen Academy of Sciences), G. Reimer, subsequently Walter de Gruyter & Co., Berlin. Kant, I. (1992a), Lectures on Logic, translated by J. Michael Young, The Cambridge Edition of the works of Immanuel Kant, Cambridge. Kant, I. (1992b), Theoretical Philosophy, 1755–1770, translated by D. Walford in collaboration with R. Meerbote, The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant, Cambridge. Kant, I. (1998), Critique of Pure Reason, translated by P. Guyer and A. Wood, The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant, Cambridge. Kant, I. (1999), Correspondence, translated and edited by A. Zweig, The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant, Cambridge. General Bibliography Arnauld, A. and P. Nicole (1996), Logic or the Art of Thinking, edited and translated by J. V. Buroker, Cambridge. Baumgarten, A. G. (1779), Metaphysica, seventh edition, Halle. Beiser, F. C. (1992), “Kant’s Intellectual Development: 1746–1781” in: The Cambridge Companion to Kant, edited by P. Guyer, Cambridge, 26–61. Broad, C. D. (1941), “Kant’s Theory of Mathematical and Philosophical Reasoning” in: Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 42, 1–24. Broad, C. D. (1978), Kant: an Introduction, edited by C. Lewy, Cambridge University Press. Capozzi, M. (1980), “Kant on Mathematical Definition” in: Italian Studies in the Philosophy of Science, edited by M. L. Dalla Chiara, Reidel, Dordrecht, 423–452. Carson, E. (1999), “Kant and the Method of Mathematics” in: Journal of the History of Philosophy 37 (4), 629–652. Frege, G. (1884), The Foundations of Arithmetic, translated by J. L. Austin, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1974. Friedman, M. (1992), Kant and the Exact Sciences, Harvard, Cambridge. Grier, M. (2001), Kant’s Doctrine of Transcendental Illusion, Cambridge University Press.
The View from 1763: Kant on the Arithmetical Method before Intuition
45
Hintikka, J. (1967), “Kant on the Mathematical Method” in: The Monist 5, 352–375; reprinted in Hintikka, Knowledge and the Known: Historical Perspectives in Epistemology, Reidel, Dordrecht, 1974, 160–183. Hintikka, J. (1973), Logic, Language Games and Information: Kantian Themes in the Philosophy of Logic, Clarendon, Oxford. Kitcher , P. (1975), “Kant and the Foundations of Mathematics” in: The Philosophical Review 84, 23–50; reprinted in Posy (1992), 109–134. Martin, G. (1985), Arithmetic and Combinatorics: Kant and His Contemporaries, translated and edited by J. Wubnig, Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale. Leibniz, G. W. (1765), New Essays on Human Understanding, translated and edited by P. Remnant and J. Bennett, Cambridge, 1996. Longuenesse, B. (1998), Kant and the Capacity to Judge: Sensibility and Discursivity in the Transcendental Analytic of the Critique of Pure Reason, translated by C. T. Wolfe, Princeton. Mancosu, P. (1996), Philosophy of Mathematics & Mathematical Practice in the Seventeenth Century, Oxford. Parsons, C. (1969), “Kant’s Philosophy of Arithmetic” in: Philosophy, Science and Method: Essays in Honor of Ernest Nagel, edited by S. Morgenbesser, P. Suppes, and M. White, St. Martins, New York, 1969; reprinted, with Postscript, in Parsons (1983); reprinted in Posy (ed.) (1992), 43–79. Parsons, C. (1983), Mathematics in Philosophy: Selected Essays, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York. Parsons, C. (1984), “Arithmetic and the Categories” in: Topoi 3, 109–121. Polonoff, I. (1973), Force, Cosmos, Monads and Other Themes of Kant’s Early Thought, KantStudien Erg¨anzungshefte 107, Bouvier, Bonn. Posy, C. (1984), “Kant’s Mathematical Realism” in: The Monist 67, 115–134; reprinted in Posy (ed.) (1992), 293–313. Posy, C. (ed.) (1992), Kant’s Philosophy of Mathematics: Modern Essays, Kluwer, Dordrecht. Pycior, H. M. (1997), Symbols, Impossible Numbers, and Geometric Entanglements, Cambridge. Shabel, L. (1998), “Kant on the ‘Symbolic Construction’ of Mathematical Concepts” in: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 29A (4), 589–621. Schultz, J. (1791), Erl¨auterungen u¨ ber des Herrn Professor Kant Critik der reinen Vernunft, Hartung, K¨onigsberg; reprinted in Aetas Kantiana. Bruxelles: Culture et Civilisation, 1968, 160–161; translated by J. C. Morrison and published as Philosophica series 47, University of Ottawa Press, 1995, 159. Schultz, J. (1792), Pr¨ufung der kantischen Kritik der reinen Vernunft, Hartung, K¨onigsberg 1789 (vol. I); 1792 (vol. II). Sch¨onfeld, M. (2000), The Philosophy of the Young Kant: The Precritical Project, Oxford. Thompson, M. (1972), “Singular Terms and Intuitions in Kant’s Epistemology” in: Review of Metaphysics 26, 1972–3, 314–343; reprinted in Posy (1992), 82–101. Tonelli, G. (1959a), “Der Streit u¨ ber die Mathematische Methode in der Philosophie in der ersten H¨alfte des 18 Jahrhunderts und die Erststehung von Kants Schrift u¨ ber die “Deutlichkeit”” in: Archive f¨ur Philosophie 9, 37–66. Tonelli, G. (1959b), Elementi Metodologici e Metafisici in Kant dal 1745 al 1768, Torino. Wolff, C. (1713), Elementa Matheseos Universae, 2 vols., Halle, 1713–15; English trans. of selected parts by J. Hanna, A Treatise of Algebra, London, 1739. Wolff, C. (1719), Vern¨unftige Gedanken von Gott, der Welt und der Seele des Menchen, auch allen Dingen u¨ berhaupt, Halle; also in Gesammelte Werke, edited by J. Ecole et al., George Olms, Hildesheim, 1960–. Young, M. (1982), “Kant on the Construction of Arithmetical Concepts” in: Kant-Studien 73, 17–46. Young, M. (1984), “Construction, Schematism and Imagination” in: Topoi 3; reprinted in Posy (1992), 159–176.
46
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
de Vleeschauwer, H. J. (1939), The Development of Kantian Thought, translated by A. Duncan, London 1962.
THE RELATION OF LOGIC AND INTUITION IN KANT’S PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, PARTICULARLY GEOMETRY Ulrich Majer Universit¨at G¨ottingen, Germany
In his so-called dissertation of 1770 “De mundi sensibilis atque intelligibilis, forma et principiis” Kant put forward for the first time his celebrated distinction between the world of sense and intellect, between sensible intuition and thinking. This distinction, although by no means new and original, became not only the basis of his critical philosophy but also the object of heated disputes about its legitimacy. The reasons for these disputes rest to my mind not so much in the ambiguity of the distinction, but in Kant’s epistemological assertion that the two principal forms of intuition — space and time — not only are, but necessarily must be recognised as among the a priori sources of our empirical knowledge (of nature). This opinion was refuted almost immediately after it had been asserted by the development of the so-called non-Euclidean geometries by Gauß, Bolyai and Lobachevsky, that is by geometries in which the axiom of parallels does not hold, although these geometries are logically consistent. Nonetheless many scientists and philosophers still believe that there is a grain of truth in Kant’s epistemological assertion that we need besides pure thinking (logic) another non-empirical source of knowledge, called pure intuition, in order to understand how empirical knowledge is possible at all. So far so good. The difficult question is, however, what type of intuition it is that can or could serve as an a priori foundation for our empirical knowledge, which has experienced a very rapid growth during the last two centuries. A certain rough, yet unshakable answer can be given almost immediately: Because mathematics1 plays not just a pre-eminent but an indispensable role2 in our scientific understanding of nature, the kind of intuition we are looking for must be related somehow to our knowledge of mathematics.3 Unfortunately, however, this reflection alone does not suffice to determine precisely the type of intuition we are looking for. It only indicates that we have to take 47 E. Carson and R. Huber (eds.), Intuition and the Axiomatic Method, 47–66. © 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
48
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
at least two further considerations into account in order to answer our main question. First, we have to ask: How do we come to know mathematics and the descriptive content of its different branches? Is it just a particular kind of reasoning (as Dedekind and Frege assumed), or do we rely in addition on some special type or form of intuition? Secondly, how is mathematics with its different branches related to our understanding of nature? Is it just a question of trial and error which branch of mathematics has to be applied in the analysis and presentation of certain natural phenomena or is there a more intimate relationship between mathematics and its different branches on the one hand, and our understanding of nature and its phenomena on the other? Both questions, in my view, have not been satisfactorily answered — neither by the scientists themselves, nor by the philosophers of science. In this essay I will concentrate on the first question and postpone the second. I will treat the first question by engaging in a certain debate about Kant’s philosophy of mathematics, in particular his account of geometry and the kind of intuition, which he supposes to be the foundation of our geometrical knowledge.
1.
Logical versus phenomenological interpretations of Kant
In the last two decades, a discussion has taken place about the correct, or perhaps better, the most “intelligent”, interpretation of Kant’s distinction between ‘sensibilia’ and ‘intelligibilia’ in general and the relation between intuition and logic in particular and their respective role in and influence on Kant’s epistemology of science. Two principal lines of interpretation can be discerned. The first line — put forward mainly by E. Beth, J. Hintikka and M. Friedman — argues that Kant’s concept of logic was so restricted that he needed to suppose (in addition to his narrow notion of logic) a second source of knowledge, the famous outer intuition of space, in order to present geometry in a logical deductive form as Euclid had exemplified. Yet today — and this is, of course, the main point of this line of interpretation — we have a much more powerful form of logic, namely mathematical logic, such that we can avoid any recourse to intuition. I have to say more about this line of interpretation, but first let me sketch the second line.4 The second line has been articulated as an alternative interpretation to the first line by Charles Parsons and Emily Carson. It is best characterised by the observation that geometry cannot be “reduced” to logic, at least not completely, because it has a descriptive content, which is more specific than the content of logically valid sentences (which are ‘true’, semantically speaking, in every correct interpretation of their descriptive vocabulary). In this sense, geometry goes definitely beyond first-order logic and discursive thinking in general abstract concepts, if we understand by the latter any conservative extension of first-order logic by introducing new concepts and relations. Consequently, Kant was right to insist on a second non-logical source of knowledge
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
49
(alongside logic and discursive thinking) which ensures us that the sentences of Euclidean geometry are true with respect to something non-logical with which we are acquainted as sensible beings and not just as consequences of a deductive system of axioms. The intricate question is, however, what this non-logical something is in respect to which the truth of geometrical sentences has to be judged. One answer is, of course, straightforward; it’s the empiricist answer that the truth of geometry has to be judged with respect to the results of geometrical measurements of angles, distances, etc. But this is, of course, not Kant’s answer, because this answer, despite its obvious circularity, could only corroborate but never demonstrate the truth of Euclidean geometry.5 For this reason we have to look for something quite different, something which renders the truth of Euclidean geometry intelligible. Kant calls this non-logical something “the form of our outer intuition”. But this is only a phrase, and the difficult point is therefore to spell out what Kant means by this phrase, in particular, what he means by “intuition”. This is the hard core of the recent debate. What I want to do is roughly the following. I will develop an argument in connection with Hilbert’s foundations of geometry which favours the second line of interpretation more than the first. I hope this will help to balance the debate, because I think the present state of the discussion is too much in favour of the first position. To begin with, let me stress that the difference between the two lines of interpretation is not the necessity of intuition in geometry — in this respect both parties agree in their Kant interpretation — but the reason why intuition is necessary on Kant’s view of a sound foundation of geometry. According to Friedman, intuition is necessary only because Kant’s conception of logic is too restricted: he cannot deal with sentences of the form ∀x ∃y xRy, in which a universal quantifier governs an existence claim. Such sentences are, however, crucial for an axiomatic, i.e. a deductive presentation of geometry (as I’ll show in a moment). For Parsons and Carson, on the other hand, recourse to intuition would remain necessary, even if Kant had had a more powerful logic than he in fact had. That is to say even if Kant had modern predicate logic available (with two- and more place relations, instead of monadic Aristotelian syllogistic) the recourse to intuition would remain necessary in order to recognise the truth of Euclidean geometry, in particular the truth of the axioms. In other words, the difference between the two lines of interpretation is one of relative versus absolute necessity. The first line deems intuition to be only relatively necessary, depending on the type of logic one uses for an axiomatic presentation of geometry. The second line takes intuition to be absolutely necessary, i.e. independent of the type of logic Kant (or anyone else) uses for an axiomatic presentation of geometry.
50
2.
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Friedman’s interpretation of Kant and his notion of intuition
In this section I will deal with the first line of interpretation, more precisely with Friedman’s interpretation of Kant’s view of spatial intuition as outlined in his paper “Geometry, Construction, and Intuition in Kant and his Successors”.6 The second line of interpretation, as I understand it, will then emerge automatically in the next section as soon as I begin to develop my own and, I hope, more reasonable interpretation of Kant in the light of Hilbert’s foundational work in geometry. In his paper Friedman tries to defend his view of Kant’s theory of intuition as a stopgap in Kant’s deductive approach to geometry against some of the objections that were raised by Parsons and Carson (henceforth P&C) in respect of his constructivist interpretation of Kant’s notion of spatial intuition.7 Friedman’s strategy of defence, as I understand it, is roughly the following: First he accepts the criticism of P&C that there is a “second component” in Kant’s notion of spatial intuition, namely the immediate acquaintance with objects given in spatial intuition, which is not captured or sufficiently reflected in his own constructivist interpretation of the role of spatial intuition as a logical stopgap in Kant’s deductive theory of geometry. At this junction I should perhaps be more precise about the central idea behind Friedman’s logical interpretation. Kant introduced the notion of “intuition” according to Friedman in conscious opposition to the notion of “concept” just because Kant recognised correctly that Aristotelian syllogistic is not sufficient for an axiomatic foundation of geometry. In particular, Aristotelian syllogistic cannot deal with quantified sentences of the form ∀x ∃y xRy, in which the existence claim is dependent on the universal claim. Such sentences are, however, indispensable in an axiomatic presentation of geometry. Take for example Hilbert’s axiom II 2: “For any two points A and C there is always at least one point B on the line AC, such that C lies between A and B.”8 This is by no means the only example of a universal-existential claim; Hilbert’s Foundations of Geometry is in fact replete with such sentences. Now, if Kant could not handle such sentences in logical deductions (because he had only Aristotelian syllogistic at his disposal), he had to find a substitute in order to close the gap. Hence, Kant introduced — according to Friedman — the notion of “intuition” (in addition to that of concepts), which permitted him to construct singular objects recursively, piece by piece, in the pure intuition of space, instead of making “universal-existential claims”, such as Hilbert did in axiom II 2. In other words, Friedman regards Kant as an inadvertent representative of a constructive in distinction to an axiomatic approach to geometry in the modern sense of this opposition.9 This becomes particularly clear in the following consideration. Friedman refers to a passage in Kant’s handwritten notes (Ak. 20, pp. 419– 421) in which Kant distinguishes between two examinations of space: space as “generated” by geometry, and space as “given originally” in metaphysics.
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
51
The interesting point is now that Friedman, although he admits that Kant’s metaphysical consideration of space is “congenial to the phenomenological approach”, he nevertheless favours the geometrical approach as more fundamental and intelligible than the phenomenological approach. The reason for this rather puzzling interpretation is the circumstance, I presume, that Friedman wants to put Kant’s approach to geometry in close parallel to his view on arithmetic, which is a good deal more constructivistic than Kant’s approach to geometry. I think however one should not overemphasise this parallel, because in Kant’s time nobody had any idea what an axiomatic presentation of arithmetic would look like, and for this simple reason Kant was forced (like Leibniz) to take a more “genetic” or “constructive” route in the presentation of arithmetic than in geometry. Kant himself, by the way, was completely aware of this, because he stresses repeatedly that arithmetic has no axioms (because their number would have to be infinite, which makes no sense) but only postulates or “Zahlformeln” (CPR, B206). It would be very tempting to dig deeper into the differences between arithmetic and geometry, but I return instead to Friedman’s line of defense. As already mentioned, Friedman seems first to accept the criticism of P&C that there is a second important aspect in Kant’s notion of intuition, which is not reflected by the role of intuition as a logical stopgap in geometry, namely the remarkable fact that spatial intuition is the only way in which we become immediately acquainted with external objects, whereas concepts lead only to an indirect cognition of objects. Hence, outer intuition (and not concepts) makes us acquainted with spatial features of objects like form, size, dimension, etc. So far at least Friedman seems to agree with the phenomenological interpretation of Kant’s notion of spatial intuition. But suddenly, in a rather unexpected move, Friedman begins to attack the phenomenological approach as inferior to his own interpretation, instead of accepting both interpretations as complementary. In order to make this point clear beyond any possible doubt let me quote the decisive passage in full: So far, then, the basic ideas of the phenomenological approach appear to be vindicated. The crucial question, however, concerns how exactly metaphysical space — “the pure form of the mode of sensible representation of the subject as a priori intuition” [Ak. 20, pp. 419–21] — is supposed to accomplish this grounding [of geometrical space]. Is the given infinity of space as a pure form of sensible intuition supposed to be directly seen, as it were, in a simple act of perceptual or quasi- perceptual acquaintance? Are we supposed to have a direct perceptual or quasi-perceptual access to such infinity entirely independent of geometry? Both of these ideas appear to be very doubtful. For we are certainly not perceptually presented with an infinite space as a single given whole; and since the visual field is always finite, it does not even appear to be true that any perceived spatial region is directly given or perceived as part of a larger such region. The idea of independently given phenomenological facts capable of somehow grounding or justifying the possibility of geometrical construction can quickly appear to be absurd.10
52
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
After this warning-shot towards the phenomenological position that the problem of the infinity of space (and the justification of the corresponding geometrical axioms such as Hilbert’s axiom II 2) is not straightforward, Friedman proceeds basically towards his final goal in two main steps: the demonstration of the superiority of the logical over the phenomenological interpretation.11 First, Friedman launches his own reading of Kant’s notion of “external intuition” by quoting at length a number of remarkable passages, in which Kant explains what he understands by “figurative synthesis”, and how this is linked with the geometrical constructions of objects in space such as a straight line or a triangle. The quotations given by Friedman are indeed all very impressive because they show that Kant had a dynamical conception of “figurative synthesis” and not merely a static notion of representation of external objects.12 But whether the quotations show what Friedman wants them to show, namely, that geometrical space and, hence, geometry as the theory of space is the result of a dynamical process of our imagination, called figurative synthesis, this is quite another question, one to which I will return at the end of the paper. In the second half of his paper, Friedman shows that some of the successors of Kant in nineteenth century, in particular the mathematicians Helmholtz, Poincar´e and Lie (HLP), developed a view with respect the foundations of geometry, which is very similar to Kant’s “constructive” approach as presented in the dynamical conception of “figurative synthesis”. This is, in my view, the most interesting and convincing part of Friedman’s paper because he makes clear that the group-theoretical approach to geometry, as it was developed and ramified by HLP is in two respects very similar to Kant’s characterization of the “figurative synthesis” as a dynamical process in our imagination. First, the group-theoretical approach takes “linear transformations” of rigid bodies, i.e. translations and rotations, as the basic operations on which the theory of space has to be built. Quite similarly, Kant takes the “drawing of a straight line” and “the rotating of such a line around a fixed point” as “first constructions”, as he says, on which all other constructions of figures have to be built or to which they have to be reduced. The second point in which the group-theoretical approach comes close to Kant’s dynamical characterization of the figurative synthesis is the problem of understanding the infinity of space. According to the group-theoretical approach the infinity of space is not just a factum brutum of our outer intuition, but the result of an operation, which can be repeated without any limit. This sounds very similar to what Kant said about the figurative synthesis of a straight line: I can represent no line to myself, no matter how small, without drawing it in thought, that is gradually generating all its parts from a point . . . On this synthesis of the productive imagination in the generation of figures is based the mathematics of extension (geometry) together with its axioms, which express the conditions of a priori sensible intuitions under which alone the schema of a pure concept of outer appearance can arise. (A162–162/B203–204)
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
53
From this remark it seems to be only one step to the conclusion that the infinity of space is — like the infinity of the sequence of natural numbers — the result of an iterated operation, a successive synthesis in imagination, which can be repeated, at least in principle, without limit. This is basically, I suppose, what Friedman suggests when he relates Poincar´e’s approach to arithmetic to the group-theoretical approach to geometry, because one aspect of the analogy is quite certain. The infinity of the number-sequence rests — according to Poincar´e — on the principle of simple induction, the “immer noch eins” as Weyl calls it, and this iteration is an intuition par excellence, which can not be reduced to pure logic. Consequently, if the same iteration is at work in the figurative synthesis of the productive imagination, then it is almost certain that the infinity of space does not rest on an immediate perceptual intuition, as the phenomenological view supposes, but is the result of a constructive procedure, which generates all geometrical objects piece by piece, instead of perceiving them at a single glance. In a final move Friedman links the group-theoretical approach of HLP to his own dynamical interpretation of Kant and his notion of (geometrical) space as the result of an iterated construction. By this, Friedman suggests, he has shown two things. First, he has shown that the dynamical interpretation is superior to the phenomenological one in at least two respects: (1) it makes all those pieces in Kant’s texts intelligible, in which Kant favours obviously a more constructive or genetic approach — not only with respect to arithmetic, but also to geometry; (2) it renders the infinity of space not a mere “mystery” — like the phenomenological approach, which supposes that we can somehow perceive the infinity of space in an act of contemplating the pure form of outer intuition — but makes it the result of an inner process, an iterative synthesis, which is still “rational”, insofar as it is constructive, although it transcends the capacities of our conceptual thinking. Second, Friedman thinks he has shown that, and in what sense, a recourse to a pure form of outer intuition was not only necessary in Kant’s time but also reasonable and justified from a more modern point of view — although it could be dismissed in principle, as soon as a more powerful logic than Aristotelian syllogistic was available. Kant’s successors, Helmholtz, Lie, and in particular Poincar´e had made it evident that the role of our outer intuition is a constructive one in the dynamical sense that certain groups of transformations generate spaces of constant curvature, spaces in which rigid bodies can move freely in every direction. In other words “free mobility of rigid bodies” is the fundamental intuition on which geometry has to be built, and this is precisely what Friedman maintains at the end of part I: The spatial intuition grounding the axioms of geometry is fundamentally kinematical, in my view, and it is expressed in the formal structure of translational and rotational motion (in modern terminology, the structure of the group of Euclidean motions).
54
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Now let’s come to the main question: How shall we judge this retrospective interpretation? What should we think of this chain of systematic reasoning? It is, of course, very enchanting and very interesting as a reconstruction of the development of geometry and its philosophical implications since Kant. But is it also compelling as an interpretation of Kant’s philosophy regarding the epistemological foundations of geometry? Is Kant really an inadvertent but nonetheless pure constructivist, as Friedman’s interpretation suggests? Precisely in this respect a number of doubts and objections have been raised. What I intend to do in the second half of this paper is to add just another objection — a rather unexpected one, I believe — and to use its systematic core in support of the phenomenological interpretation.
3.
In favour of the phenomenological interpretation
In order to prepare the ground for my objection, I have to point out that the story of the development of geometry after Kant, as it is told by Friedman, is by no means the only story one can tell; it is not even the most important and interesting one. There are indeed many different stories, or to express my point more appropriately, the one real history of modern geometry since Kant has many more facets and is a good deal more complex than Friedman suggests. In fact, if there is a lesson to be drawn from the history of modern geometry then it is exactly this: that there are several competing schools, different approaches, many distinct points of view, and last but not least that some schools and traditions died out and new ones emerged. This is not the place to recapitulate the history of modern geometry,13 but I have to draw a few broad strokes in order to make my point plausible that there exists another approach favouring the phenomenological interpretation. The nineteenth century witnessed one of the most, if not the most complex development of geometry since Euclid. The reasons for the complexity have to be traced back to the eighteenth century. In it, two schools of geometrical research dominated the development: analytical and projective geometry. This promoted towards the end of the eighteenth century a reconsideration of the problem of parallels, which then led to the discovery and exploration of nonEuclidean geometries. So far, I think, the history is well-known. What is not so well-known is the fact that afterwards several rather different research programs emerged regarding the unification and foundation of the different branches of geometry. Of these we have to consider in the present context only the two most prominent and fundamental ones: 1. the so called “Erlanger Programm” of Felix Klein and 2. the axiomatic approach by Pasch, Hilbert and the “Italian school”.14 These two research programs (or schools) stood — the friendly relation between Klein and Hilbert notwithstanding — in strong competition or even opposition to each other. And it’s this opposition that I have to explain in order to make the phenomenological interpretation of Kant more intelligible.
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
55
The “successors” of Kant whom Friedman presents as standing in close relation to Kant’s constructive approach to geometry all belong, of course, more or less immediately to the Erlanger Program of F. Klein: Helmholtz — having studied Riemann’s work — opened the door, Klein designed the program, Lie executed it to a large extent, and Poincar´e unveiled its philosophical implications. This is not the place to analyze the historical relations between the members of this school; it suffices to know that they all favoured a purely group-theoretical approach to geometry, based on the notion of “free mobility of rigid bodies”. But what about the competing program? How could the members of the axiomatic approach sympathise with the phenomenological interpretation taking space as (more or less immediately) given in intuition, as they in fact did? How could they support such an obsolete view? Was it not one of the cornerstones of Hilbert’s Foundations of Geometry that intuition plays no role in the axiomatic presentation of geometry? Before I explain why Hilbert’s position in fact favours the phenomenological interpretation much more than it does Friedman’s dynamical reconstruction of Kant, I have to clear away some popular prejudices regarding Hilbert’s axiomatic approach — prejudices which prevented a clear comprehension of what Hilbert had achieved in geometry. Next, I’ll compare the group-theoretical with Hilbert’s axiomatic approach and show, in what sense the latter penetrates more deeply into the epistemological foundation of geometry than the former. Once this is clarified, the essential argument in favour of the phenomenological interpretation can be easily stated. Finally, I will indicate, where Friedman went wrong (according to my view) in his interpretation of Kant’s philosophy of space and his corresponding meta-theory of geometry. By far the worst prejudice is the opinion that Hilbert was a formalist in the sense that one can choose the geometrical axioms arbitrarily, “at will” so to speak; the only constraint on this kind of freedom is the request for consistency that the axioms do not contradict each other, more properly speaking, that the resulting axiom system (including a deductive logic) does not entail any contradictions. This opinion is reinforced by a second prejudice, which is almost as absurd as the first: We have the freedom of choice in geometry just because geometrical expressions like “point”, “straight line”, and “plane” have no meaning in the sense that these expressions do not denote anything specific, which is determined independently of our will. We have the freedom to determine their meaning as we like, and we achieve this by choice of an appropriately designed system of axioms — “axioms” which are taken as “implicit definitions” of the respective geometrical expressions. That this is not Hilbert’s point of view should be evident to anybody who has ever taken a serious look into Hilbert’s book Grundlagen der Geometrie. Unfortunately, however, Hilbert did not always express his point of view regarding geometry clearly and unambiguously. Frequently he wanted to stress the new, exciting aspects of his axiomatic approach, which seduced him, quite naturally, into underemphasising the traditional Euclidean aspects of his ax-
56
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
iomatic approach. But as we know from the lectures which immediately preceded the publication of the Grundlagen, he was a great admirer of Euclid and had no intention at all of abandoning Euclid. On the contrary, he wanted to improve Euclid’s Elements by supplementing Euclid’s approach with a new systematic means to prove the logical independence of axioms and other metalogical properties of axiom systems such as consistency and completeness. This means is the famous “axiomatic method”. I’ll turn to it in a moment. But first let me point out (in a somewhat dogmatic fashion) what Hilbert’s point of view is by introducing a terminological distinction which cannot explicitly be found in Hilbert’s writings, at least not in full strength, although it is implicitly present. For Hilbert, geometry has a descriptive content, and this content has to be presented somehow, either in a “genetic” or in an “axiomatic” form. Hilbert prefers, for reasons which I’ll discuss later, the axiomatic form. Every such presentation of a content I will call an “axiomatic presentation” in clear and sharp distinction to the term “axiomatic method”, which denotes, as its name says, a method of inquiry into the logical relations among the axioms of an axiom system. An axiomatic presentation of a certain content has to fulfill, of course, certain requirements such as logical consistency, “material” adequacy and logical transparency, to name only the most important. Of these, only the first and third requirement can be investigated by means of the axiomatic method, whereas the second, the material adequacy of the presentation of a given content, has to be judged on a completely different ground. Which ground this is and in what it consists, is in the case of geometry a difficult question, a question which I will come back to in the next section. But first I have to point out what the axiomatic method is (in distinction to the axiomatic presentation of a given content). In which way, for example, can it be used to prove the logical independence of the axiom of parallels from the remaining axioms of Euclidean geometry? If we can answer this question, we have understood the central way in which Hilbert improved upon Euclid. The basic idea is this: the axiom of parallels is replaced by one of its two negations; if the resulting axiom system has a “model” (in the modern technical sense of the term), then the new system is relatively consistent. If that is the case, then the axiom of parallels is logically independent of the remaining axioms of Euclid, just because there is a “world”, in which its negation (together with the other axioms of Euclid) is valid.15 In other words the axiomatic method is a deliberate variation of a system of axioms in order to see whether a certain sentence is logically independent of the other sentences of the system in question. Although it cannot actually be separated from the axiomatic presentation of a content, because it is the optimal procedure for enhancing the logical transparency of an axiomatic presentation, it has to be distinguished painstakingly from the presentation itself in order to avoid total confusion between means and goal. Having clarified the worst misconceptions regarding Hilbert’s axiomatic approach to geometry let us turn to the main question in the present context: What
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
57
is the ground of our geometrical knowledge — insofar as not only logic and conceptual thinking are involved? What’s the source of our knowledge, if we know, let’s say, Pasch’s axiom?16 Hilbert’s principal answer is straightforward: it is our “spatial intuition”, or to quote Hilbert’s formulation in the introduction to the Grundlagen: Setting up the axioms of geometry and investigating their interconnections is a task that has been discussed in numerous excellent treatises in the mathematical literature since Euclid. This task amounts to a logical analysis of our spacial intuition.17
I admit that this formulation is not as clear and distinct as one would wish, but this is no reason to ignore it completely, as most modern interpreters of Hilbert’s axiomatic approach to geometry do. Instead, one should try to clarify it and to make it more precise. In order to begin with the obvious, let me stress that Hilbert’s task of “establishing the axioms of geometry” is precisely what we have called the “axiomatic presentation of geometry” in conscious distinction to the axiomatic method, which is nothing but a tool for performing the “logical analysis of our spatial intuition”. This means that the task of “establishing the axioms of geometry” according to Hilbert’s point of view, has to have recourse to our “spatial intuition” and to analyze this intuition logically by means of the axiomatic method in order to recognise the logical connections between these axioms. So far, I think, there can be no doubt or debate about Hilbert’s intentions. The decisive and difficult question however is: What does Hilbert mean by “spatial intuition”? In the rest of this paper, I’ll try to give an answer to this subtle question and argue that it is more in favour of the phenomenological than the constructive approach. In a first preparatory step I’ll compare Hilbert’s axiomatic point of view, i.e. his logical analysis of our spatial intuition (as presented in the Grundlagen) with the group-theoretical approach of HLP.
4.
Hilbert’s axiomatic versus the group-theoretical approach of HLP
Fortunately, Hilbert himself prepared the ground for a profound comparison of the two approaches, which reveals their different epistemological stances. This facilitates my task considerably. In a long, sophisticated and ingenious ¨ essay “Uber die Grundlagen der Geometrie” (GG) of 1902, which has been ignored almost totally by philosophers (some remarkable exceptions notwithstanding18 ) Hilbert points out the fundamental differences between his and the group-theoretical approach. The opening section of this essay is worth quoting in full, because it entails a sketch of the essential points of divergence between the two approaches. Hilbert begins the essay with a very careful and polite but in the end fundamentally critical remark: The investigations of Riemann and Helmholtz on the foundations of geometry prompted Lie to attack the problem of an axiomatic treatment of geometry by
58
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method using the group concept as starting point, and they led this astute mathematician to a system of axioms of which he proved, on the basis of his theory of transformation groups, that they are sufficient for the development of geometry.
This was the polite part. Hilbert goes on: Now, in the development of his theory of transformation groups Lie always assumed that the functions which define the groups are differentiable, and thus it remains undiscussed in Lie’s work whether the assumption of differentiability is indeed unavoidable when we ask what ought to be taken as axioms for geometry, or rather whether it appears that the differentiability of the functions concerned is just a consequence of the group concept together with the other geometrical axioms. Because of his way of proceeding, Lie is also compelled explicitly to adopt the axiom that every group of motions is generated by infinitesimal transformations. These requirements . . . can be expressed by purely geometrical means only in a contrived and complicated way, and moreover they appear to be required only by the analytic method used by Lie rather than by the problem itself. (In Hilbert (1899), Anhang IV, pp. 178–179.)19
The politeness in the first part of the remark cannot obscure the fact that Hilbert’s attitude towards Lie’s group-theoretical approach to geometry is highly critical. Nonetheless, two comments seem to be appropriate in order to avoid any misunderstanding. First, and most important, the remark is not so much an attack on the use of group theory in geometry, but a critique of the intuition underlying the approach. This becomes clear if one realises what Hilbert does in the paper. He shows that one can set up a system of axioms “which likewise rests on the concept of group, but which entails only simple and geometrically perspicuous assumptions and in particular in no way presupposes the differentiability of the functions that mediate the motions.” In other words, the whole idea of basing geometry on the intuition of differentiable transformation functions, namely infinitesimal rotations and translations of rigid bodies, presupposes from a strictly logical point of view much too much, and should be replaced by an approach which avoids the idea of motion [as a primitive concept of geometry] altogether and works instead with “pure geometrical” concepts and relations. This is exactly what Hilbert does in the paper, because he uses — besides group theory — only Jordan’s theorem according to which any continuous, closed curve in a plane without ‘Doppelpunkte’ (points of intersection) separates the plane into an inner and an outer domain. Before I go on to explain what Hilbert means by “geometrically perspicuous assumptions” (and why the differentiability of the transformation functions is not such an assumption), let me make a second remark. The “kind of representation” of geometry by means of group theory which Hilbert developed in his essay represents by no means his own axiomatic point of view as it is presented in the book Foundations of Geometry, but is already a compromise between the group-theoretical approach of Lie and his own axiomatic point of view, which includes — this is important to note — a logical analysis of our spatial intuition. This is made crystal clear by the conclud-
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
59
ing remark of the essay, in which Hilbert stresses the crucial difference between the “foundation [Begr¨undung]” of geometry in the essay and that in the monograph.20 In the essay, the assumption of continuity is put in the first place before all other axioms. In the monograph, the order is exactly the opposite. Here the two axioms of continuity are quite consciously the last ones, so that one can recognise which of the well-known sentences of elementary geometry are logically independent of the assumption of continuity and which are not, e. g., Pascal’s theorem. Furthermore, only the (two) axioms of continuity turn the preceding axiom system into a “complete” theory, as Hilbert calls it, i.e., a theory whose domain of objects cannot be expanded while consistently maintaining all the other axioms. In modern terms, the axioms of continuity turn geometry into a “categorical” theory that has (up to isomorphism) exactly one model. Bearing both remarks in mind, let us come to the question of what Hilbert means by “geometrically perspicuous assumptions” or to put it more explicitly: Why is the (kind of) intuition underlying the group-theoretical approach of HLP not the best choice from Hilbert’s perspective? The answer to this question depends, of course, on the goal that one wants to achieve with an axiomatic presentation of geometry. If one wants to reveal the close inner relationship between geometry and physics (in particular with the kinematics of pre-relativistic physics) then the motions of rigid bodies, their infinitesimal rotations and translations, are presumably the best choice for an axiomatic presentation of geometry. 21 But if the goal is a totally different one, if the goal is an analysis of the logical dependence and independence of geometrical concepts and sentences, as in the Grundlagen, then the best choice is a different one. We have to strip off all non-geometrical properties and relations and concentrate our logical analysis on the “pure” geometrical facts. But which are the pure geometrical facts? Hilbert’s answer is straightforward: the geometrical facts are the facts of our “spatial intuition”, as he calls it. But this answer seems to be question-begging. Consequently, I have to explain why it is not, or to put it differently, I have to point out what Hilbert understands by spatial intuition in such a way that it becomes evident that motions (of rigid bodies) do not belong to geometry proper.
5.
Hilbert’s notion of spatial intuition and the phenomenological interpretation of Kant
The task of making Hilbert’s notion of “spatial intuition” explicit is simultaneously easy and difficult: easy, in that only the structure of our spatial intuition is at stake; but difficult, if we wish to reveal the real reasons why Hilbert held such an apparently antiquated view, why he was not convinced that the HLP approach was a more appropriate, and therefore also the more modern,view. Regarding the question of the structure of our spatial intuition, the answer can be stated in one sentence: the form or structure of our spatial intuition is the same as the structure of the (infinite) 3-dimensional Euclidean space, which
60
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
is (up to isomorphism) the unique model of Euclidean geometry if, as Hilbert assumes, Euclidean geometry includes the “Vollst¨andigkeitsaxiom”. This is in perfect harmony with Kant’s view that the form of our outer intuition is the 3-dimensional space of Euclidean geometry. But there is, of course, a methodological difference: whereas Kant was acquainted only with Euclidean geometry22 and, hence, had no choice but to take Euclidean space as the form of outer intuition, Hilbert was in a completely different position: he, of course, knew a large number of models of all “kinds” of geometry (non-Euclidean, non-Archimedean, etc.) and could therefore choose among different models as representing the form of our outer intuition. Taking this into account, his choice of Euclidean space as the canonical form of our spatial intuition is much more astonishing than Kant’s. This brings me to the more difficult task of explaining the reasons for Hilbert’s apparently outmoded choice. In his later writings Hilbert became a bit more explicit regarding the role of spatial intuition in the foundations of geometry than he was in his monograph Grundlagen der Geometrie of 1899. As I understand these later writings, Hilbert presents at least three distinct reasons for basing geometry on intuition, and in particular for taking Euclidean space as the structure of our outer intuition. The reasons are very different in style and character, but each can be taken as an implicit argument for not following the HLP approach and, hence, as an argument against Friedman’s constructive Kant interpretation. The first reason concerns the question of the validity or invalidity of Euclidean geome try. At first glance, this question seems so simple that one may wonder what it has to do with our main concern of what kind of intuition geometry should be based on, if it is to be based on intuition at all, and not simply taken as an empirical matter. In another contribution to this volume, written in collaboration with Tilman Sauer (in Part II of this volume), we deal with this question at length, and show that it is much trickier and subtler than the stubborn empiricist believes. Here it must suffice to remind the reader that at least until 1919 the question of the objective validity of Euclidean geometry was not settled, because the observations were not sufficiently precise to refute Euclidean geometry. Why is this relevant for our present concern? The answer is simple. If the observational means were not sufficiently precise to refute Euclidean geometry, then our knowledge of geometry (be it Euclidean or another one) must have a source different from mere observation and measurement. This “non-empirical” source,23 by which we have more or less “immediate” contact with external objects like houses and trees, is called “spatial intuition” by Hilbert, and on it rests our knowledge of geometry — not only in everyday life, but also in science. So much for the role of intuition in geometry. But why should we not follow the HLP approach and take our awareness of motions of rigid bodies as the primary intuition on which geometry should be built? Let me summarise the argument of my other paper: Hilbert shows that Poincar´e’s so-called conventionalism with respect to geometry is the result of a conceptual confusion, namely, taking as simple what, in fact, is more compli-
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
61
cated. What is Hilbert’s argument? It is this: “free mobility” of rigid bodies is no presupposition for the application of geometry to the external world. Consequently the alleged “freedom of choice” among different “spaces of constant curvature” and the inherent possibility of choosing Euclidean geometry as the simplest case, is nothing but a conceptual illusion. The real reason for the choice of Euclidean space is this: the observed deviations from the structure of Euclidean space are so incredibly small that nobody could conceive how we could ever improve the precision of our instruments in such a way that we could measure these minute differences. Poincar´e’s view that it is simpler to stick to Euclidean geometry and to explain possible deviations by introducing appropriate force-functions is conceptually mistaken, because to explain such deviations by the introduction of force-functions is in fact much more complicated than to have no need for an explanation at all, as is the case if we are prepared to choose another, a non-Euclidean geometry. (For more details, see the paper by Majer and Sauer in Part II of this volume.) It is important to note that Hilbert’s critique of Poincar´e’s conventionalism and his adherence to free mobility of rigid bodies as a methodological presupposition for the application of geometry to the external world is not totally new. Already in 1901, in his lecture before the Royal Academy of Science in G¨ottingen, Hilbert had criticised Lie’s group-theoretical approach to geometry for introducing “superfluous” elements: On the basis of Riemann and Helmholtz Lie set up a system of axioms which differs fundamentally from those systems that are developed according to the Euclidean model. Lie’s axioms contain function-theoretic parts since he requires motion to be expressed by differentiable functions. . . . The question arises whether the function-theoretic components are only necessary because of the desire to apply this (group-theoretic) method, or whether they are foreign to the subject matter itself and are thus superfluous. It turns out that in fact they are. Thereby we once again draw closer to the old Euclid, insofar as we don’t need to impose the additional infinitesimal properties on the concept of motion which Lie still thought necessary. Instead, the elementary postulates which are already contained in the Euclidean concept of congruence suffice, a concept with which we are all familiar, due to the theorems about the congruence of triangles known from school.24
There are two further reasons for Hilbert to base geometry, in principle, on spatial intuition in general and on Euclidean space in particular. In his later lectures on geometry (after 1899 until 1927) he always points out that his way of doing and presenting geometry is neither analytic nor synthetic but different from both. If we understand the reasons for this “neither-nor” we see much better why Hilbert does not follow the HLP approach, but is much closer to the phenomenological view according to which our spatial intuition is the unlimited, all-embracing form of extension, through which we (more or less) immediately become aware of external objects. Consequently, we have to ask: what are the reasons Hilbert has for rejecting not only analytic but also synthetic geometry? Let’s begin with analytic geometry.
62
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
In analytic geometry one presupposes the concept of numbers and the laws of arithmetic in order to move as quickly as possible to the different applications of geometry in the quantitative sciences. But this is exactly the reverse of what Hilbert wants to achieve: namely, a detailed logical analysis of the deductive relations between the principles and theorems of geometry. Such a logical analysis is seriously hampered (if not totally blurred) by introducing numbers into geometry right at the beginning, as is done in analytic geometry. Furthermore, numbers don’t intrinsically belong to geometry;25 they are, in fact, rather different from points on a line: each number has its own unmistakable character; almost exactly the opposite is true of geometrical points; they are as mere points indistinguishable, and can be discerned only by their relative position; numbers in geometry are like intruders from an alien star, the star of “counting and calculating” or, more generally, “recursive” reasoning. This means that it has to be shown that and how they can be incorporated into geometry without contradiction. For this reason, numbers should be introduced into geometry after and not before the logical analysis of spatial intuition has been accomplished, i.e., at the end and not at the beginning of an axiomatic presentation of geometry. The fundamental reason for this is that the two kinds of “infinity” are conceptually distinct, and rest on fundamentally different intuitions: The infinity of the natural number sequence is rooted in the “immer noch eins”, as Weyl calls the recursion which is the foundation of counting. The infinity of space, on the other hand, has nothing to do with such inductive procedures, but is rather the expression of a “part-whole” relation of our spatial intuition: every straight-line segment is part of a larger straight-line segment, or to put the same point another way: every straight-line segment can be expanded ad infinitum, i.e., in principle without any limit. In order to recognise that this relation has absolutely nothing to do with induction, we express it in a way that shows it has no inner connection with time: to any pair of points A, B on a straight line α there exists another point C on α, which does not lie between A and B. Although this axiom, first stated by Pasch, is not sufficient to prove the infinity of straight lines, it is nonetheless the core of it. We need only the axiom of Archimedes that a fixed segment of a straight line has an invariable length (speaking intuitively), in order to obtain the desired result. These reflections have, I think, made it clear that the assertion that the infinity of space rests on the same kind of induction as that from which the infinity of the number sequence results, as Friedman appears to believe, is purely wishful thinking. This has, of course, consequences for his Kant interpretation, to which I’ll come in a moment. First let me discuss Hilbert’s rejection of synthetic geometry. Why does Hilbert not accept synthetic geometry? This ought, it would seem, accord far more closely to his fundamental view of geometry. Hilbert’s reasons for rejecting synthetic (and not just analytic) geometry are much more subtle and, hence, more intricate to explain. The subtlety has to do with an im-
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
63
plicit switch in the methodological point of view. In synthetic geometry spatial intuition, or an aspect of it (like operations with ruler and compass) is used to “construct” geometrical objects like lines, circles, triangles, etc. But this is not Hilbert’s point of view — at least not in an axiomatic presentation of geometry. He, instead, wants to analyze our spatial intuition, not to use it. This is important. It means that he makes intuition the object of his investigation, not the instrument, as in synthetic geometry. This change in perspective has dramatic consequences, quite similar to those changes in physics, when the instruments themselves were made the objects of physical inquiry, as happened to some extent in the theories of quantum mechanics and special relativity. The most dramatic consequence is, of course, that Hilbert does not rely, and does not need to rely as in synthetic geometry, on the validity of our spatial intuition. More precisely, he doesn’t need to rely on the unlimited validity of our spatial intuition in the sense that it represents up to an arbitrary degree of precision the objective structure of physical space. There may be utterly small differences between both structures, which have not been, and (as far as we know) cannot be, accounted for in the sense that we can find causes for these differences in the form of ‘special forces’ or such like. This gives us the freedom to study our spatial intuition for its own sake, just as we do with other faculties of our mind, like thinking and reasoning, which we can also make, and have made, an object of inquiry. The method of inquiry is even in both cases the same: namely, a deliberate “variation” of the basic principles, in the case of geometry, the axioms of (Euclidean) geometry. By means of the axiomatic method we can bring the sentences of geometry into a logical order — an order reflecting the deductive strength. In this way we recognise which axioms are more central, and which more peripheral. This order should reflect the robustness of our spatial intuition. Let me conclude with a remark regarding Friedman’s constructive interpretation of Kant. First, Friedman points out that Kant distinguished between two examinations of space, a metaphysical and a mathematical one. Next, he concedes that Kant’s metaphysical examination is “congenial to the phenomenological approach” of P&C. Secondly, he nonetheless sides with the mathematical examination, because in the light of the HLP approach Kant’s “explanation” of the infinity of space by “figurative synthesis” makes more sense than the metaphysical explanation of the phenomenological approach. However, I think, that Hilbert’s rehabilitation of the Euclidean view, which does not invoke “free mobility” of bodies, shows that the metaphysical explanation of the infinity of space is at least as reasonable as that in the constructive approach. I suspect that the deeper reason for Friedman’s rejection of the phenomenological approach has to do with his tendency throughout the paper to assimilate spatial intuition to spatial perception and vice versa. This, I think, is a serious mistake. But this is another topic, one that needs careful examination.
64
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Notes 1. By “mathematics” I mean here not only arithmetic and analysis, but also geometry and topology, as well as all other branches of modern mathematics, like algebra and probability theory. 2. This has been questioned by some philosophers, such as Hartry Field. This position is, however, to my mind completely untenable and misguided. Field holds that numbers are not genuinely part of nature, but an “invention” of the human mind and, for this reason, have in the end to be eliminated from any description of nature. But this has to be realised in a completely different way, not by dispensing with mathematics, but rather by analyzing its relation to nature. 3. Here (and in the rest of this essay) I take it for granted that mathematics, in each of its branches, is not a purely logical but a substantive discipline, with a descriptive content going beyond first-order predicate logic and its conservative extensions. 4. This is more difficult, because this line was first articulated as a distinct position in reaction to the first line, although it is presumably much older than the first line. Indeed, it is almost the original interpretation, or something close to it, as I will show. 5. The distinction between corroboration and demonstration is meant to capture Kant’s distinction between contingent empirical and necessary universal truths. 6. This paper was not yet published when I presented my “second thoughts” on it for the first time at the conference “Intuition in Mathematics and Science” in Montreal in 1999. It has meanwhile been published as Friedman (2000). 7. See Carson (1997) and Parsons (1992). The characterization of Friedman’s view as “constructivist” is my own. P&C don’t use it, although it reflects Friedman’s Kant interpretation very well, as I am going to show. They restrict their critique to the point that Friedman’s interpretation of Kant’s notion of intuition is too one-sided and propose instead to supplement it by a more ‘contemplative’ view of intuition. This is again my term, and I’ll later explain the difference (respectively, contrast) the two expressions are intended to capture. 8. “Zu zwei Punkten A und C gibt es stets wenigstens einen Punkt B auf der Geraden AC, so daß C zwischen A und B liegt” (Hilbert (1899)). Lehrsatz 8 in Pasch’s Vorlesungen u¨ ber neuere Geometrie (1882) has the same logical form. In fact Hilbert took Pasch’s Lehrsatz 8 and made it his Axiom II 2 in the Foundations of Geometry. 9. There is a striking resemblance between Weyl’s criticism of the axiomatic approach and Friedman’s Kant interpretation. Both take universal-existential sentences to be the core of the problem. The difference, however, is that Weyl regards them as senseless if they are not supported by a construction according to a corresponding law, whereas Friedman seems to think that Kant would have accepted them, if he had had modern logic. In any case, Friedman does not recognise that Kant might have rejected universal-existential sentences for very similar reasons as Weyl did. See Majer (1988). 10. Friedman (1999), p. 189. 11. For the sake of brevity, I have to omit the details in the exposition of Friedman’s position and to concentrate on the main points in his sophisticated chain of reasoning. 12. Imagination and representation are, according to the quotations, two quite distinct capacities of our mind. 13. There are many good books on this subject; let me mention just three, Kolmogorow and Yushkevich (1996), Hartshorne (2000), and Scriba and Schreiber (2002). 14. For the sake of simplicity, I will neglect the Italian school of geometry and concentrate on the development in Germany. 15. The burden of proof of the logical independence of a sentence is, as one can infer from the above formulation, transmitted to the proof of the existence of a “model”. The inauguration of something like model theory is one of Hilbert’s achievements. 16. Pasch’s axiom says that a straight line cutting one of the sides of a triangle also cuts one of the two opposite sides of the same triangle if the trivial yet necessary conditions are fulfilled that the straight line and the triangle lie in the same plane, and the line does not pass through the third vertex. 17. “Die Aufstellung der Axiome der Geometrie und die Erforschung ihres Zusammenhanges ist eine Aufgabe, die seit E UKLID in zahlreichen vortrefflichen Abhandlungen der mathematischen Literatur sich er¨ortert findet. Die bezeichnete Aufgabe l¨auft auf die logische Analyse unserer r¨aumlichen Anschauung hinaus.” 18. To my knowledge, Husserl was one of the few philosophers who took notice of Hilbert’s essay and recognised its epistemological significance; see my forthcoming paper Majer (2003).
The Relation of Logic and Intuition in Kant
65
19. “Die Untersuchungen von Riemann und Helmholtz u¨ ber die Grundlagen der Geometrie veranlaßten Lie, das Problem der axiomatischen Behandlung der Geometrie unter Voranstellung des Gruppenbegriffs in Angriff zu nehmen, und f¨uhrten diesen scharfsinnigen Mathematiker zu einem System von Axiomen, von denen er mittels seiner Theorie der Transformationsgruppen nachwies, daß sie zum Aufbau der Geometrie hinreichend sind. Nun hat Lie bei der Begr¨undung seiner Theorie der Transformationsgruppen stets die Annahme gemacht, daß die die Gruppe definierenden Funktionen differenziert werden k¨onnen, und daher bleibt in den Lieschen Entwicklungen uner¨ortert, ob die Annahme der Differenzierbarkeit bei der Frage nach den Axiomen der Geometrie tats¨achlich unvermeidlich ist oder ob die Differenzierbarkeit der betreffenden Funktionen nicht vielmehr als reine Folge des Gruppenbegriffes und der u¨ brigen geometrischen Axiome erscheint. Auch ist Lie zufolge seines Verfahrens gen¨otigt, ausdr¨ucklich das Axiom aufzustellen, daß die Gruppe der Bewegungen von infinitesimalen Transformationen erzeugt sei. Diese Forderungen, . . . lassen sich rein geometrisch nur auf recht gezwungene und komplizierte Weise zum Ausdruck bringen und scheinen u¨ berdies nur durch die von Lie benutzte analytische Methode, nicht durch das Problem selbst bedingt.” 20. That this final remark is crucially important for a correct understanding of the essay (that the essay doesn’t represent Hilbert’s position) is made clear by the fact that in the first reprinting of the essay (in the second edition of the monograph), Hilbert points immediately to the final remark in a footnote to the title. 21. Even this assumption can be debated in the light of the General Theory of Relativity. 22. Some interpreters have argued that Kant was aware of geometries other than Euclidean. It is true that he speculated about the possibility of non-Euclidean geometry, but I would hesitate to call this knowledge. In any case, he did not know any models of non-Euclidean geometry and, hence, could not choose any such model as the form of our outer intuition. 23. By “non-empirical” I don’t want to exclude the possibility that our spatial intuition is the result of an evolutionary process over many generations, shaped by natural selection and cultural inheritance. All I want to exclude is the empiricist’s assertion that it is exclusively the result of individual experience and learning. 24. “Fussend auf Riemann und Helmholtz hat nun Lie ein Axiomensystem aufgestellt, welches sich von den nach Euklidischem Muster entwickelten Systemen wesentlich unterscheidet. Lie’s Axiome enthalten funktionentheoretische Bestandteile, indem Lie verlangt, dass die Bewegung durch differenzierbare Funktionen vermittelt wird. . . . Es fragt sich, ob die Funktionsbestandteile nicht bloß wegen des Wunsches diese (gruppentheoretische) Methode anzuwenden n¨othig waren und nicht vielmehr der Sache selbst fremd und deswegen u¨ berfl¨ussig sind. Es zeigt sich, dass sie es in der Tat sind. Wir n¨ahern uns dadurch wieder dem alten Euklid, insofern wir dem Begriff der Bewegung nicht die weitergehenden infinitesimalen Eigenschaften, die Lie noch n¨otig hatte, brauchen aufzuerlegen, sondern mit den elementaren Postulaten auskommen, die bereits in dem Euklidischen Begriff der Kongruenz enthalten sind, und die uns allen aus den von der Schule her bekannten S¨atzen u¨ ber die Kongruenz von Dreiecken gel¨aufig sind.” 25. By this assertion I do not mean that there is no structural similarity between the points on a line and the sequence of numbers. In fact there is such a structural similarity, even an identity in the order of points and numbers. But this does not imply that points and numbers, taken individually, are similar objects.
References Carson, E. (1997), “Kant on Intuition in Geometry” in: Canadian Journal of Philosophy 27, 489–512. Friedman, M. (1999), “Geometry, Construction, and Intuition in Kant and His Successors” in: Between Logic and Intuition, edited by G. Sher and R. Tieszen, Cambridge University Press, 2000. Hartshorne, R. (2000), Geometry: Euclid and Beyond, Springer, New York. Hilbert, D. (1899), Grundlagen der Geometrie, Thirteenth Edition, Stuttgart, Leipzig, 1987. ¨ Hilbert, D. (1902), “Uber die Grundlagen der Geometrie”, Anhang IV in: Hilbert (1899). Kolmogorov A. N. and A. P. Yuskevich (eds.) (1996) Mathematics of the Nineteenth Century, Birkh¨auser, Basel. ¨ Majer, U. (1988), “Uber eine bemerkenswerte Differenz zwischen Brouwer und Weyl” in: Exacte Wissenschaft und ihre philosphische Grundlegung, edited by Deppert et al., Lang, Frankfurt am Main. Majer, U. (2003) “Husserl and Hilbert on Geometry”, forthcoming.
66
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Majer, U. and T. Sauer (2005) “Intuition and Axiomatic Method in Hilbert’s Foundation of Physics”, this volume. Pasch, M. (1882), Vorlesungen u¨ ber neuere Geometrie, Teubner, Leipzig. Parsons, C. (1988), “The Transcendental Aesthetic” in: The Cambridge Companion to Kant, edited by P. Guyer, Cambridge University Press, 1992. Scriba, C. J. and P. Schreiber (2002), 5000 Jahre Geometrie, Springer, Berlin.
EDMUND HUSSERL ON THE APPLICABILITY OF FORMAL GEOMETRY Ren´e Jagnow Middlebury College, Vermont, U.S.A.
1.
Introduction
In his Grundlagen der Geometrie, David Hilbert treated the axioms of geometry in a radically new way.1 In the context of his investigation, he suggested that we understand axioms not in the traditional sense as sentences stating fundamental facts about spatial intuition, but rather as logical forms devoid of intuitive content. Accordingly, geometric terms like ‘point,’ ‘line,’ and ‘plane’ did not refer to intuitable objects, but rather functioned as purely syntactic elements whose interrelations were determined by the axioms. This view on the axioms of Euclidean geometry changed how mathematicians and philosophers of mathematics understood this science: pure geometry came to be seen as a formal deductive system. Edmund Husserl was well acquainted with Hilbert’s view, as he showed, for example, in the excerpts he copied out from the Hilbert-Frege correspondence, where he remarked: “Frege does not understand the meaning of Hilbert’s ‘axiomatic foundation’ of geometry, namely that it is concerned with a purely formal system of conventions, which is identical in form with the Euclidean.”2 For Husserl, one of the most important questions arising from Hilbert’s approach to geometry was whether such purely formal inquiry had any relevance beyond a pure theory of deductive systems. In his last work Die Krisis der europ¨aischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Ph¨anomenologie, Husserl demanded that we recover the original intention or meaning that lead to the formation and development of the various mathematical sciences.3 He believed that the abstract and formal character of the modern sciences posed the danger of them becoming mere formal games; only by philosophically elucidating these sciences’ origins in the life-world could scientists assure that they were engaging in a meaningful practice. In the Krisis, Husserl suggests undertaking this task as a means of guiding us towards a phenomenological investigation into the constitution of the life-world. 67 E. Carson and R. Huber (eds.), Intuition and the Axiomatic Method, 67–85. © 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
68
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Nevertheless, it is difficult to see why such an inquiry into the origins of the sciences is necessary. After all, Husserl admits that the sciences function well and make highly successful predictions. Husserl could simply say that formal geometry as established by Hilbert is a meaningful practice because it is successfully applied in physics. I think, however, that Husserl found such an answer insufficient, because, on its own, the mere application of a given formal science in physics does not ensure its conceptual continuity with the life-world. It is possible that a given formal concept of space, say an axiomatic system describing a non- Euclidean space, will not have any connection to our pre-scientific concept of space. If this were to be the case, we would lose any justification for saying that physics expresses a genuine concept of space. According to Husserl, we can give such a justification only by showing how the formal concept of space is grounded in a pre-scientific concept of space, that is, how the former applies to the latter. Thus, the formal sciences raise two applicability problems — one of explaining how a given formal concept can be applied in the physical sciences, and the other of showing how formal inquiry applies to pre-scientific experience. The inquiries into these two problems serve two radically different purposes: Whereas the first ensures the correctness of certain scientific results, and is thus mathematical or physical, the second secures the meaningfulness of our formal concepts, and is thus essentially philosophical. I believe that one can reconstruct Husserl’s second applicability problem and his answer to it by diverting one’s attention from the Krisis and toward some of his early writings, specifically I am referring to his notes to his socalled Raumbuch.4 In the following, I will use these writings in order to outline Husserl’s view on the relationship between formal inquiry and the life-world in respect to formal geometry. I will begin by describing the specific form the problem of the applicability of geometry took on within Husserl’s genetic approach to the concept of space. I then show that Husserl was involved in answering two questions. He had to show first how the results of formal inquiry could apply to the space of geometry, and second, how the results of geometry could apply to intuitive space, i. e., the space of everyday experience. In the Krisis, Husserl addressed the second question. After outlining his answer to this question, I will argue that Husserl’s notion of the definite manifold answers the first question, since it was originally intended as a condition that, if fulfilled, would guarantee the relevance of the results of formal geometry for geometric space.5
2.
The problem of the applicability of formal geometry
In the early 1890s, Husserl intended to write a book about space. In his notes to this so-called Raumbuch, he distinguished between different concepts of space — the space of intuition (which he also called “space of everydaylife”), the space of pure geometry (or simply, geometric space), the space of applied geometry (which Husserl also called “space of natural science”), and
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
69
the space of metaphysics.6 After becoming acquainted with Hilbert’s approach to geometry, Husserl also used the concept of formal space.7 According to the typology of spaces he was developing at that time, the problem of the applicability of formal geometry had to be framed as a question about the relationship between formal inquiry and different concepts of space. More precisely, Husserl’s typology raised the two questions of (i) how formal geometry related to intuitive space (i. e., the space of everyday experience); and of (ii) how formal geometry related to physical space, that is, to the space constituted by the natural sciences. Yet because Husserl later abandoned the Raumbuchproject in favour of his transcendental phenomenology, he never dealt with these questions extensively. In spite of this, his notes and the Krisis contain enough material to enable us to understand his general position with respect to the first question, that is, the applicability of formal geometry to intuitive space. In order to outline his answer to it, we have to consider not only formal and intuitive space, but also the space of pure geometry (which I will call in the following just “geometric space”). I will justify this way of proceeding in due course. Both in his early investigations into descriptive psychology and his later phenomenological research, Husserl believed that any given entity was intelligible only as a correlate of a particular type of experience. In order to define clearly the different kinds of space, Husserl, therefore, had to analyse the experiences or forms of consciousness in which a subject became aware of them. Husserl provided us with the following characterization of intuitive space: By representation of space we may first mean the space of intuition, that is, the space of extra-scientific experience, the space which everyone, children or adults, scholars or laymen, are able to experience in lived perception and fantasy.8
Husserl here determines intuitive space as the spatial correlate of everyday experience, or, as he calls it alternatively, of everyday consciousness, which is the primary mode in which any person (independently of age or education) experiences the world. Husserl distinguishes everyday from other kinds of consciousness, notably from scientific and ethical consciousness, by the attitude, or interest a person takes towards the world.9 In contrast to the attitude of scientific consciousness, that of everyday experience takes the life-world unreflectively as an unanalysed whole. For pre-scientific consciousness space is an integral part of a larger array of experiences. As an intentional correlate of certain pre-scientific experiences, intuitive space has an objective character. Although Husserl elaborates this view more fully only in his lecture course Ding und Raum from 1907, in which he develops a theory of the constitution of intuitive space, some fundamental aspects of it are already present in his notes to the Raumbuch.10 There, Husserl remarks that one important general feature of intuitive space is that its elements, spatial objects like houses, trees, and landscapes, for example, are not entirely intuitively accessible. These spatial objects can be given to consciousness only as a continuous series of partial intuitions, with the objects themselves as the
70
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
ideal limits. The elements of intuitive space are, therefore, ideal objects — unities of conceptual and intuitive elements.11 The same is true of intuitive space as a whole: it is an ideal object correlating to certain features of everyday consciousness. Husserl writes: “The space of ‘intuition’ is rather a complex of intuitions united, made into an identical unity, by [a] judgement, which accompanies uniform types of processes, thus fixing them.”12 In sum, intuitive space is a set of ideal objects and relations that are part of a larger spatial structure that in turn forms an integral part of everyday consciousness. According to Husserl, the space of intuition is distinguished from geometric space, which he describes as “a conceptual construct produced through logical treatment of the representation of space present in pre-scientific consciousness.” Geometric space is therefore no longer “represented in intuition or intuitable, but rather only thinkable.”13 The concept of geometric space is expressed by an axiomatic system that results from two idealizing processes: The origin of a geometric concept of space already presupposes the origin of basic geometric concepts. Because only on the basis of these idealizations of original concepts of objects, as we find them in intuition, can we make such quasi-inductions, which we can also call idealizations. The ideal concept that we call ‘geometric space,’ however, is defined though ideal concepts and ideal propositions.14
The first type of idealization constitutes the basic geometric concepts, whereas the second constitutes the axioms of a geometric theory such as Euclid’s. The first process of idealization departs from everyday perception, which enables human beings to form pre-geometric concepts such as points, lines, and planes, etc., through a process of partitioning: We can divide a physical body in fantasy multiple times, without destroying its unity. . . . Since each body is a physical part of the total space, it has to have a border to the remaining space. This border is its “surface.” Similarly, we can divide planes physically. We can divide each plane into two planes, which do not have any parts in common, without destroying the unity of the original plane. The spatial object, which is common to both of them, and “by means of which” they border on each other, is called a “line.” In the same way, the physical partition of lines leads to borders, which we call “points.” Points cannot further be divided spatially.15
The concepts resulting from the partitioning are inexact. Husserl later calls them “morphological” in order to distinguish them from geometric concepts, which he understands as ideal boundaries.16 Thus, the geometer must idealize the correlating morphological concepts in order to form the basic concepts of Euclidean geometry. This, Husserl believes, can be accomplished only by ascribing continuity to the space of everyday experience.17 Since we cannot actually see the continuity of a given extension, say, of a given line segment, in the sense relevant to geometry, Husserl concludes that continuity is an ideal concept constructed on the basis of certain perceptual processes familiar to everybody. He gives as his example the situation of two visible points bordering on each other. One can focus more sharply on these points by using
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
71
instruments or by diminishing the distance between oneself and the points. By improving viewing conditions in this way, one can discover a visible distance between the points that can then be filled in with a further point. Since this process can be repeated over and over again, we can arrive at the general rule that it is always possible to place a further point between any two points under ideal conditions of observation. Although one cannot actually complete an infinite process of adding further points, one can stipulate ideal limits as the products of such an infinite division and add them to the line. As a result, the points can be understood as extensionless, and the line which they are a part of as continuous.18 According to Husserl, this example shows us how the process of idealization departs from the objects and relations of intuitive, i. e., experiential, space. It ends up constituting a completely new kind of object, however: geometric objects like points, lines, and planes that cannot be perceived, but rather only thought.19 Once the basic concepts of geometry have been constituted in this manner, the geometer can construct an axiom system, thus constituting the geometric concept of space. This construction is guided by experience and based on the observation of relations between empirical objects. These facts do not justify the axioms, however: Pure deduction is a matter of pure theory. Deduction never asks where the basic assumptions come from, it assumes them. One may disagree about the cognitive value of the basic concepts of geometry and the basic assumptions; the geometric sentences are beyond suspicion. Naturally so, since their validity has no meaning other than the correctness of the consequences drawn from the basic geometric assumptions.20
The geometer accepts the axioms, which for the early Husserl include axioms of existence and axioms defining properties of the objects postulated by them, simply on the basis that they are independent of each other and that the resulting theory is consistent.21 Finally, in order to establish the concept of formal space, the geometer has to formalize the axiomatic system of geometry, substituting representations of concrete objects with representations of objects as such: In the highest and most comprehensive sense, mathematics is the science of theoretical systems as such; and, in abstraction, a science of that which is being theorized in the given theories of the various sciences. If in any given theory or deductive system, we abstract away from its material, or from the unique species of objects that it seeks to control, and if we substitute materially determined object representations with mere formulas, that is, with representations of the objects controlled by theories of such a kind, then we will have accomplished a generalization, which considers the given theories as a mere special case of a theory class, or, rather, of a theory-form (Theorienform).22
What does Husserl mean in this quote by representations of objects as such, or what he often calls ‘object-forms’? The following quote gives us a clue: This (the object-forms) is a domain, which is solely determined by the fact that it is governed by a theory of this form, that is, its objects can be connected only ac-
72
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method cording to certain relations, which follow certain basic laws of a predetermined form. These objects are completely undetermined in respect to their matter — in order to indicate this, the mathematician speaks preferably of ‘Thought-Objects.’ They are neither determined directly as individual or specific singularities, nor indirectly through their inner kinds or species; but rather exclusively through the form of the relations prescribed to them.23
Object-forms are abstract objects whose properties are determined through the relations defined in the axiomatic system. As such object-forms are completely void of any material content. Yet Husserl also believes that an object-form in the sense of categorial form corresponds to the formal theory in its entirety: If we understand space as the categorial form of the space of the world (Weltraum) and, correlatively, geometry as the categorial theory-form (kategoriale Theorienform) of geometry in the common sense, then space is being subsumed under a species of categorially determined manifolds that is delimited by laws, in relation to which one will naturally speak of space in a broader sense.24
The phrase ‘space as [a] categorial form’ here simply means that the object ‘space’ is determined only by its relational properties. Accordingly, formal space is the correlate of a formal axiomatic system and has the ontological status of a general individual. Since the formal theory represents only the deductive form of the material theory from which it departed, it is not a theory in the proper sense, but rather a theory-form (Theorienform). This form can be common to an infinite number of material theories.25 Husserl draws two important consequences from his view. First, the fact that a formal theory constitutes its own domain allows the mathematician to ignore the material science and to restrict his/her interest to formal inquiry. Once mathematical inquiry has reached the formal level, it is free from its genetic roots in intuition. At this level, the mathematician is not only delivered from the responsibility of paying attention to content, but also from the constraints of the process by which the formal theory was generated. This freedom from the material domain finds its expression in the fact that it is legitimate to change the formal theory by adding or eliminating axioms that define new operations. In Husserl’s words: Once one ascends to the pure system of operations, leaving the original real domain of objects, be it line-segments or numbers, behind and considering in most general generality a domain as such which is determined by these forms of operation, one is able to modify the idea of such a system in various ways, in the sense of an extended or restricted system of operations, or of axioms.26
Second, the fact that the formal theory exhibits the form of a material discipline allows the geometer to consider the former a meta-theory of the latter. Considering the axiomatic form of a theory independently of content facilitates the process of optimizing its logical structure. In this sense, “mathematics is, according to its highest idea, theory of theories, the most general science of deductive systems in general.”27 In order for a deductive theory to have an optimal form, it had to fulfil a number of conditions. All the facts had to follow
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
73
from the axioms, and the axioms themselves had to be consistent and independent of each other.28
3.
Husserl’s solution to the problem of the applicability of formal geometry
Let me now return to my original question of the relevance of formal geometry for intuitive space. We have seen that formal inquiry can function as meta-theory. Yet Husserl claims that formal inquiry achieves more; it is an instrument of mathematical discovery developed to replace material inquiry. He writes: Formal mathematics claims to be an instrument of concrete mathematical discovery. In the same way as the old mathematics of quantities was the instrument of research in the natural sciences, that is, the instrument of deductive theoreticization of the various domains of inquiry in physics (for which induction had derived the appropriate theorems), so the new formal mathematics does not only want to achieve the same, but much more. Formal mathematics wants to create methods of infinitely higher generality and power which render all methodical inquiries in real mathematics superfluous.29
Since formal geometry is a method of higher generality, its axioms can be changed so that new operations define new elements. Taking this into consideration, how is it still possible for the results of formal geometry to apply to intuitive space? According to Husserl, this question has to be answered in two steps. First, we have to explain how the results of formal inquiry can apply to geometric space, and then how the results of the geometry that constitutes geometric space can apply to intuitive space. We cannot apply the results of formal inquiry directly to intuitive space, because, for Husserl, the latter is not a model of the formal axiomatic system. In contrast to the objects and relations of geometric space, the objects and relations of intuitive space are not represented by ideal, but rather by inexact morphological concepts.30 As a result, if we were to interpret formal axioms and theorems with intuitive objects, we would produce falsehoods. Therefore, there is no direct path leading from abstract to intuitive space. Rather, we must proceed from formal through geometric to intuitive space. I will first consider the relationship between geometric and intuitive space. Although Husserl addressed this problem in the Krisis, he gave only a very sketchy idea of what he understood this relationship to be. In his historical analysis of the genesis of modern science, he argued that geometry originated from the practice of land surveying (Feldmeßkunst). He wrote: Geometry (of idealities) was preceded by the practice of land surveying which was not concerned with idealities. Such pre-geometric achievement, however, was a foundation for the meaning of geometry, a foundation for the important invention of idealization.31
74
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Husserl’s dictum that land surveying represented the ultimate source of meaning for geometry implies that, at least historically, geometry was intended to improve surveying techniques in order to achieve more adequate results. Thus, he pointed to a cultural practice as the original field of application of geometry. It is important to note that, according to Husserl, the technique of land surveying remained entirely within the limits of the intuitive world, because it applied only morphological concepts of everyday language. Husserl viewed the relation between geometry and the intuitive world as one of approximation. Since geometric concepts were constituted in a process of idealization, they can be applied to intuitive space only by reversing the process. For Husserl, the possibility of applying the conclusions of geometric reasoning to the intuitive world was thus a result of transforming the technique of land surveying. He wrote: By affiliating itself with the art of measurement and by now governing this art, mathematics has shown that one can have universally an objective-real knowledge of a completely new kind about the things of the intuitive world. This kind of knowledge also accords with its special interest as mathematics of forms in which all things participate, namely a form of knowledge, which is related through approximation to its own idealities. Thus, mathematics must descend again from the world of idealities to the empirical intuitive world.32
The development of geometry transformed the practice of land surveying into an essentially mathematical technique that specified its own conditions of application. Husserl mentions two ways in which this was accomplished. On the one hand, the surveyor establishes certain rules that allow him/her to interpret the measurements in such a way that they approximate the idealized constructions of geometry. On the other hand, the surveyor strives to improve constantly his/her measuring-techniques to gain results that will approach as closely as possible those predicted by geometry. Unfortunately, Husserl does not elaborate this suggestion any further. The central notion in Husserl’s solution to the problem of the applicability of formal geometry to geometric space was his concept of a definite manifold, which he defined in Ideen I, Formale und transzendentale Logik, and in the Krisis. In these works, he intended this notion to characterize the ideal of a formal scientific theory, which consisted of sentences that formed a universal nomological or explanatory connection; that is, all the theorems of the ideal theory followed logically from a finite number of axioms. In Husserl’s words: The axiomatic system which defines a [definite manifold] is characterized by the fact that every sentence (sentence-form) which can be constructed by means of logic alone from the concepts (concept-form) of this manifold is either “true,” that is, an analytic (purely deductive) consequence of the axioms, or “false,” that is, an analytic contradiction: tertium non datur.33
According to Husserl, the property of definiteness of an axiomatic system had a consequence for its domain, that is, as he says, “its manifold.” If the axiomatic system is definite, then the elements in its domain are fully determined in re-
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
75
spect to their mutual formal relations. We can say that, according to Husserl, an ideal formal theory defines a definite manifold. The context in which Husserl introduced the notion of a definite manifold in his major works, however, is partly misleading, since he originally introduced it as a condition ensuring the connection between formal and material arithmetic.34 In order to be able to appreciate the full significance of the definite manifold for the applicability of formal geometry, we have, therefore, to look at this context. Husserl developed the notion of a definite manifold in the lecture at the G¨ottingen Mathematical Society that I mentioned in the introductory section of this paper. In the following, I will first reconstruct the argument of this lecture with respect to arithmetic.35 Then, I will show that Husserl considered his results as a solution to the problem of the applicability of formal geometry. In his G¨ottingen lecture, Husserl was concerned with what he called the “problem of imaginary magnitudes” (imaginary mathematical objects). This problem has to do with the fact that in mathematics we are able to define imaginary objects such as negative, real, and irreal numbers. These objects are intuitively contradictory; that is, they are not part of an arithmetic that is based on the intuitive apprehension of numbers (Husserl uses the term Anzahlenarithmetik).36 Nevertheless, we can use these objects in our calculations and achieve results that are valid in such an arithmetic. This happens in all those cases in which the final results do not contain any of these imaginary objects. Husserl states the problem of the imaginary numbers as follows: Let us say, we are presented with a domain of objects in which the specific nature of the objects determines forms of connections and relations which are expressed in a certain axiomatic system. Certain forms of connection have no real meaning; that is, they are contradictory, due to this system, that is, because of the specific nature of the objects. On what grounds can we apply the contradictory in our calculations; on what grounds can we treat the contradictory in axiomatic systems as non-contradictory. How can we explain, that we can operate with the contradictory according to rules, and that, if the contradictory later disappears from the sentences thus gained, these sentences are true?37
Let me illustrate Husserl’s problem of imaginary objects by means of an example. In Anzahlenarithmetik we cannot solve the following system of equations: (a) 7 + x = 2; (b) 6 + x = y. The reason for this is that x < 0 and thus not a number, but rather an imaginary object. Yet, in Anzahlenarithmetik, we can give a partial solution and solve this system for y. Since x = 2 – 7, y = 6 + (2 – 7), i. e., y = (6 + 2) – 7, i. e., y = 1. If we admit the negative numbers into our system of arithmetic, we can solve the system of equations in a different way. We get x = (–5) and again y = 1. What Husserl wants to explain is how it is possible that this application of imaginary objects yields a result that is valid in Anzahlenarithmetik. So far this problem seems to have no connection to our question about the relation between formal and material arithmetic. Yet, Husserl established this connection in the course of explaining why previous theories were unable to justify the use of imaginary or contradictory mathematical objects in obtaining
76
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
valid arithmetic results. He believed that previous theories had misconstrued the process by which these objects were constituted. Husserl wrote: It is clear that we cannot extend the concept of number (Anzahlbegriff) arbitrarily. Yet, we can leave the concept of number and define a new purely formal concept of positive numbers through the formal system of definitions and operations which hold for numbers (Anzahlen). And this formal concept of positive numbers, just as it is defined by definitions, is able to be extended by new definitions, that is, extended without contradiction.38
In contrast to other mathematicians, Husserl thought that the construction of imaginary mathematical objects was a complex process, which involved a transition to formal arithmetic.39 More precisely, this process consisted of two steps. First, the material arithmetic of numbers (Anzahlenarithmetik) was formalized and thereby a new domain of formal objects — the positive integers — constituted. Second, the resulting system was consistently extended so as to include the negative numbers. Accordingly, the problem of imaginary mathematical objects had now to be stated as a problem of the relation between formal and material arithmetic. Husserl was asking in his G¨ottingen talk how it was possible for the results of calculations in this extended formal system to be true in material arithmetic. In order to answer this question, Husserl needed to consider only the relation between unextended and extended formal theories. As we have seen, the unextended formal axiomatic system represented for him the logical form of material arithmetic, which could be consistently axiomatized. As a result, all the logical consequences of the unextended formal axiomatic system were true sentences in material arithmetic. The important question then is under what condition the results of the extended theory could also be true sentences (i. e., logical consequences) of the unextended axiomatic system, and thus of the material discipline. We can specify this question even more precisely by looking at Husserl’s concept of the extension of an axiomatic system. In a fragment published as “Zur formalen Bestimmung einer Mannigfaltigkeit,” Husserl considered several ways in which an axiomatic system could be extended. Among them was the ideal of an axiomatic system that could not be extended by the introduction of a further independent axiom if it was to keep its domain of objects fixed.40 Husserl identified this type of definiteness with Hilbert’s notion of completeness. A perfect axiomatic system of this kind defined its elements exhaustively with respect to their mutual formal relations. Husserl further stated that such an axiomatic system could only be extended by adding axioms in such a way that the consequences of the unextended system would form a subset of the consequences of the extended system.41 He wrote: The concept of extension entails, if we relate it to the axioms, that the new axioms comprise the old axioms and that the new axioms in addition to this admit operations excluded by the old axioms.42
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
77
Under the assumptions that (i) material arithmetic could be consistently axiomatized and that (ii) the formal theory derived from material arithmetic was perfect (in the sense that it could only be extended by further axioms that defined new relations between its elements), Husserl now asked what conditions the unextended formal axiomatic system would have to fulfill to guarantee that all those consequences of the extended formal theory, which contained only concepts defined in the unextended system, were derivable in it. In other words, Husserl was looking for a condition that would make a formal theory perfect to such a degree that it could only be extended conservatively.43 In order to find this condition, Husserl first considered the following justification for the applicability of the imaginary: We are allowed to apply the imaginary [that is, the formal theory is definite]: if the imaginary is formally definable in a consistent extended deductive system and if 2) the original domain of deduction has the property that, if we formalize it, every sentence which falls into its domain is either true according to the axioms or false, i. e., contradicts the axioms.44
Since consistency is already entailed in Husserl’s concept of extension, the part relevant for us here is the second condition that demands completeness with respect to the original domain of an axiomatic system.45 In Anzahlenarithmetik, the original domain are the numbers (Anzahlen). Thus, Husserl demands that all sentences about the numbers be either true or false in the fomalized axiomatic system of Anzahlenarithmetik. He calls this particular type of completeness “relative definiteness” and defines it as follows: “A system of axioms is ‘definite’ in a relative manner if any sentence that is meaningful in it is decided in the limits of the domain of this system.”46 As a number of commentators have pointed out, this notion of definiteness is identical to the contemporary concept of semantic completeness, which states that an axiomatic system is semantically complete, if all true sentences about its domain follow from the axioms.47 This property of relative definiteness, however, does not solve the problem of imaginary magnitudes. Even if the unextended formal axiomatic system was definite relative to its domain of formal objects, this would not guarantee that every sentence derived in the extended system that is meaningful in the unextended system would also be a theorem in it. Since the extended system contains new objects and operations, it may allow a mathematician to derive sentences that are not provable in the unextended system, even if they are meaningful in it. In order to illustrate how this can happen, I will adapt an example given by Da Silva.48 Let us take formal arithmetic restricted to the positive integers as the unextended system A and an arithmetic containing the whole numbers as its extension B. In B we can prove the sentence “For any n, there is an m such that n + m = 0.” This does not hold in A, where we can show that no number is smaller that 0, i. e., “if n = 0, then there is no m such that n + m = 0.” In order to exclude cases like this one, Husserl introduces a second, more comprehensive, notion of completeness by demanding that “if a
78
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
sentence is meaningful according to the axioms [of the unextended system], then the axioms also decide whether it is true or false.”49 He calls this concept of completeness “absolute definiteness.”50 As Da Silva has pointed out, absolute definiteness is not identical with the syntactic completeness of an axiomatic theory. Rather, absolute definiteness is a property of the domain of a formalized theory, a domain containing formal objects, which has the consequence that every grammatically correct sentence that can be formulated in the language of the theory is decided by its axioms. We can now summarise Husserl’s solution by saying that any extension of a formal axiomatic theory, which defines a manifold that is definite in the absolute sense, is a conservative extension. Under the conditions defined by Husserl this solution is indeed correct. In order to justify this, let us call the unextended axiomatic system (theory) A and its extension B. Husserl presupposes that A is perfect and can only be extended in such way that the theorems of A form a subset of the theorems of B. Since B is a consistent theory, none of its theorems can contradict any of the theorems of A; that is, theories A and B are consistent with each other. As a result, all of B’s theorems either follow from the axioms of A or are left undecided by them. Finally, Husserl’s demand that A be definite in the absolute sense guarantees that A leaves undecided only those sentences that are meaningless in it. Consequently, an axiomatic system, which defines a definite manifold, can only be extended conservatively; this means that all the consequences of the extended axiomatic system, which are meaningful in the unextended system, will also be theorems in it and thus express truths about the formal objects of its domain.51 Up to this point, I have dealt with Husserl’s notion of definiteness only in the context of arithmetic. However, he also believed that this notion provided a solution to the problem of the applicability of formal geometry. A first indication for this is that even in his notes to his G¨ottingen lecture he spoke about geometry and described Euclidean geometry as a special case of a broader concept of a formal space, namely, of Riemannian space. He wrote: Euclidean geometry is a concrete theory which becomes, if formalised, the theory-form, which we call theory of a threefold Euclidean manifold, and which in turn is only a special case of the systematically connected class of manifolds with variable curvature.52
Further, as we have already seen, in the Prolegomena to his Logische Untersuchungen Husserl uses geometry in order to elucidate the distinction between material and formal theories.53 Finally, in the second study of his “Drei Studien zur Definitheit,” he dealt almost exclusively with geometry and gave an example that showed that he did not restrict his search for definiteness to arithmetic. Let me outline this example here. Assume that a three-dimensional Euclidean manifold (ME ) is an extension of the manifold consisting of a plane and a given line, not lying in that plane (M0 ). Thus, ME consists of the elements of M0 plus additional elements contained by all the lines that are parallel to the given line. Husserl then demands: “The extension to ME must not disturb M0
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
79
as that what it is, and, above all, must not specialize it, i. e., the defined determinations of ME must be a mere extension of those of M0 .”54 In other words, ME is an extension of M0 only if a reduction of ME to M0 contains only those relations between the elements of M0 that belonged to it before the extension. Therefore, the elements of M0 have to be defined in such a way that an extension to ME does not add further determinations. For Husserl, this is the case if M0 is a definite manifold. We can thus conclude that the notion of a definite manifold solves Husserl’s problem of the application of formal geometry. The results of any extended formal geometry will be valid for formalized Euclidean geometry and thus also for Euclidean geometry itself, if they are meaningful therein. G¨odel’s incompleteness results restrict the applicability of Husserl’s notion of the definiteness of a manifold to relatively simple systems and renders it wrong if applied to the whole of arithmetic or plane geometry. As many of his commentators have pointed out, Husserl’s solution to the problem of the applicability of the results of formal to material inquiry is thus only partly satisfactory. However, I think that, independent of his solution, Husserl’s genetic approach to geometry has two very interesting results. First, by raising the question of the applicability of formal geometry as one about the relationship between formal inquiry and intuitive space, he made plausible the idea that the applicability of formal geometry is not restricted to the space of physics. Rather, formal geometry can also tell us something about the structure of intuitive space. Thus, the standard answer that applied geometry is an interpretation of formal geometry solves only part of the applicability-problem connected to formal geometry. Second, by introducing his notion of the definiteness of a manifold, Husserl drew a distinction between concepts of space that were actually related to intuitive space and those that were not; only spaces that were defined by axiomatic systems that were extensions of the definite manifold of Euclidean geometry were spaces proper.55 According to this criterion, many axiomatic systems that contemporary mathematicians believe to define spaces are actually just mathematical constructs and do not express genuine concepts of space. Again, given G¨odel’s incompleteness results, Husserl’s criterion fails. Nevertheless, asking at which point formal geometry moves from a literal to a metaphorical sense of the term ‘space’ is still important, if one does not want to give up a genetic relation between the different concepts of space. In sum, in this paper, I have reconstructed Husserl’s view on the relationship between formal inquiry and the life-world. I think that this allows us to make plausible the thesis that the problem of the meaningfulness of the formal sciences as it is put forward in the Krisis is identical with the problem of the applicability of the formal sciences to the life-world. As we have seen, for Husserl this problem had to be framed as a twofold question about the relationships between formal inquiry and Euclidean space and between Euclidean geometry and intuitive space. Husserl’s remarks concerning the relation between intuitive space and Euclidean geometry were too sketchy to be properly evaluated. Likewise, Husserl’s notion of a definite manifold was not success-
80
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
ful in saving the applicability of formal to material geometry. Nevertheless, it should be valued as an attempt to give a criterion that secures the connection between concepts of space at different levels of abstraction.
Notes 1. David Hilbert, Grundlagen der Geometrie, Leipzig: B. G. Teubner, 1899. 2. [“Ich merke dazu an. Frege versteht nicht den Sinn der Hilbertschen ‘axiomatischen Begr¨undung’ der Geometrie, n¨amlich daß es sich um ein rein formales System von Konventionen handelt, das sich der Theorieform nach mit dem Euklidischen deckt.”], Husserl’s commentary to a passage excerpted from a letter from Frege to Hilbert from 27/XII/99. Edmund Husserl, Philosophie der Arithmetik. Mit Erg¨anzenden Texten (1890–1901), Lothar Eley (ed.), Husserliana XII, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1970, p. 448. All translations in this paper are my own. It must be pointed out here that Husserl’s view on the nature of a formal axiomatic system was not identical with Hilbert’s. As I will argue in the first part of this paper, according to Husserl, a formal axiomatic theory was about formal objects. 3. Edmund Husserl, Die Krisis der europ¨aischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Ph¨anomenologie (1936), Walter Biemel (ed.), Husserliana VI, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1954. 4. These notes are published in: Edmund Husserl, Studien zur Arithmetik und Geometrie: Texte aus dem Nachlaß (1886–1901), Zweiter Teil. Philosophische Versuche u¨ ber den Raum (1886–1901), Ingeborg Strohmeyer (ed.), Husserliana XXI, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1983, p. 261–311. 5. Husserl originally developed the notion of a definite manifold in a lecture given at the G¨ottingen Mathematical Society in the winter term 1900/1 and in a number of studies. He never published the text of this lecture and it cannot be found in its final version in the Husserl archive. However, some materials containing notes and sketches of this lecture are published. See Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik, Husserliana XII, pp. 431–451 and Drei Studien zur Definitheit und Erweiterung eines Axiomensystems, Ibid., pp. 452– 461. Husserl’s materials concerning his G¨ottingen lecture have also been published in a more complete and accurate form. Cf. Elisabeth Schuhmann and Karl Schuhmann, “Husserls Manuskripte zu seinem G¨ottinger Doppelvortrag von 1901,” Husserl Studies 17 (2001), 87–123. That Husserl ascribed a great significance to the ideas developed in this lecture is indicated by the fact that in both Ideen zu einer reinen Ph¨anomenologie und ph¨anomenologischen Philosophie and Formale und transzendentale Logik he mentions this unpublished text. See Edmund Husserl, Ideen zu einer reinen Ph¨anomenologie und ph¨anomenologischen Philosophie, Husserliana III, Walter Biemel (ed.), The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1950, p. 137, Footnote 1, and Edmund Husserl, Formale und transzendentale Logik, Husserliana XVII, P. Jansen (ed.), The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1974, p. 85. 6. Edmund Husserl, Mehrfache Bedeutung des Terminus Raum, Husserliana XXI, p. 270–274, p. 270. 7. He wrote, for example: “If we conceive of the elements and their relations as formally defined by their laws and their points of relation as not further specified, then we have a formal geometry, i. e. the form of a geometry.” [“Denken wir uns die Elemente und ihre Relationen formell durch ihre Gesetze definiert und die Beziehungspunkte im u¨ brigen unbestimmt, so haben wir eine formale Geometrie, d.i. die Form einer Geometrie.”], Edmund Husserl, Das Gebiet eines Axiomensystems/Axiomensystem-Operationssystem, Husserliana XII, pp. 470–488, p. 486. In the Prolegomena to his Logische Untersuchungen, Husserl calls the space defined by a formal theory a “categorial form.” Edmund Husserl, Logische Untersuchungen: Erster Band. Prolegomena zur reinen Logik (1900), E. Holenstein (ed.), Husserliana XVIII, The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1975, p. 251. 8. [“Unter Raumvorstellung kann f¨urs erste gemeint sein der Raum der Anschauung, ich meine den Raum des außerwissenschaftlichen Bewußtseins, den Raum, wie ihn alle, ob Kinder oder Erwachsene, ob Gelehrte oder Laien, in lebendiger Wahrnehmung und Phantasie vorfinden.”], Edmund Husserl, Mehrfache Bedeutung des Terminus Raum, Husserliana XXI, p. 271. 9. Husserl uses the term ‘attitude’ (Einstellung) in Ideen zu einer reinen Ph¨anomenologie und ph¨anomenologischen Philosophie, Husserliana III, see, in particular, §27, pp. 49–50; In his notes to the Raumbuch, Husserl uses the term ‘interest’ (Interesse). Husserliana XXI, p. 264. 10. Edmund Husserl, Ding und Raum: Vorlesungen 1907, Ulrich Cleasges (ed.), Husserliana XVI. Husserl describes the constitution of the space of experience as an ideal object in chapter 13. 11. Husserl writes: “We called landscapes, trees, houses, and so on spatial unities and showed that they were not contents of momentary intuitions, but rather ideal objects.” [“Wir nannten Landschaften, B¨aume, H¨auser usw. r¨aumliche Einheiten und wiesen nach, daß sie nicht Inhalte von Momentanschauungen, sondern ideelle Objekte sind.”], Edmund Husserl, Der anschauliche Raum, Husserliana XXI, pp. 275–284, p. 281.
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
81
12. [“Der Raum der ‘Anschauung’ ist vielmehr ein Komplex von Anschauungen, geeinigt, zu einem identisch Einen gemacht, durch <ein> Urteil, welches sich an gleichf¨ormige Weisen von Prozessen anschließt, sie fixiert.”], Husserliana XXI, p. 308. 13. [“Von diesem Raum der Anschauung ist zu scheiden der Raum des wissenschaftlichen Denkens, der geometrische Raum, ein begriffliches Gebilde logischer Bearbeitung der Raumvorstellung des außerwissenschaftlichen Bewußtseins, von dem nicht mehr gesagt werden kann, daß es anschaulich vorgestellt oder vorstellbar sei, sondern nur denkbar.”], Edmund Husserl, Mehrfache Bedeutung des Terminus Raum, Husserliana XXI, pp. 270–274, p. 271. 14. [“Der Ursprung der geometrischen Vorstellung vom Raume setzt bereits den Ursprung der geometrischen Grundbegriffe voraus. Denn erst durch diese Idealisierungen der urspr¨unglichen Begriffe von Gebilden, wie wir sie in der Anschauung finden, sind jene Quasi-Induktionen, die wir auch Idealisierungen nennen k¨onnen, m¨oglich. Der Idealbegriff, den wir auch geometrischen Raum nennen, ist aber definiert durch die Idealbegriffe und Ideals¨atze.”], Ibid. 15. [“Ein K¨orper l¨aßt sich, ohne seine Einheit zu verlieren, in Wirklichkeit oder Phantasie mannigfach teilen . . . Da jeder K¨orper physischer Teil des Gesamtraumes ist, so muß er gegen¨uber dem u¨ brigen Raum eine Grenze besitzen. Dies ist seine ‘Oberfl¨ache.’ In a¨ hnlicher Weise wie K¨orper lassen auch Fl¨achen physische Teilungen zu. Wir k¨onnen jede Fl¨ache, ohne ihre Einheit zu st¨oren, in zwei Fl¨achen zerst¨uckt denken, welche also keinen Fl¨achenteil gemein haben. Das R¨aumliche, das ihnen gemeinsam ist, und ‘wodurch’ sie aneinandergrenzen, heißt ‘Linie.’ Ebenso f¨uhrt die physische Teilung von Linien auf Grenzen, die man ‘Punkte’ nennt. Punkte sind r¨aumlich unteilbar. Edmund Husserl, Der anschauliche Raum, Husserliana XXI, pp. 275–284, p. 278. 16. Cf., Edmund Husserl, Ideen zu einer reinen Ph¨anomenologie und ph¨anomenologischen Philosophie. Erstes Buch, Husserliana III, pp. 138–140. 17. Husserl writes: “Wir schreiben dem Raum, so wie den r¨aumlichen Gebilden, Linien, Fl¨achen, ferner Richtungs¨anderungen, Abst¨anden, ‘innere Unendlichkeit’, d.h. ‘Stetigkeit’ zu.” [“We ascribe ‘inner infinity’, i. e. ‘continuity’ to space, as well as to spatial forms, lines, planes, changes in direction, and distances.”], Edmund Husserl, Zur Entstehung der idealen r¨aumlichen Vorstellung, Husserliana XXI, pp. 286–290, p. 286. 18. I want to point out that continuity in the sense of denseness is not sufficient for Euclidean geometry. 19. Husserl writes: “Admittedly, one can doubt whether one can have actual intuitions of geometric objects; or, rather, it is certain that this is not the case. Intuition and the empirico-spatial attitude contain points of departure and leading motives for the geometric formation of concepts. Yet, the abstract objects belonging to the concepts and the attributes of these concepts are not to be obtained simply through ‘abstraction’ (in the presently common sense of attentively emphasizing singular features) from intuitions. The concepts are not embedded in intuition like the seen shape in the seen ‘plane.’ The triangle as an intuited abstract object is not a geometric figure. The triangle serves the geometer as mere symbol whose characteristic type possesses dispositional connection in the geometer’s mind with the correlating pure concept and its ideal, merely ‘thought’, object.” [“Freilich wird man es bezweifeln d¨urfen, ob von den geometrischen Objekten in Wahrheit Anschauung m¨oglich ist, oder vielmehr ist es sicher, daß dies nicht der Fall ist. Die Anschauung und die empirisch-r¨aumliche Auffassung enth¨alt die Ausgangspunkte und die leitenden Motive f¨ur die geometrische Begriffsbildung, aber die den Begriffen zugeh¨origen abstrakten Gegenst¨ande und deren Attribute sind nicht einfach durch ‘Abstraktion’ (in dem jetzt u¨ blichen Sinn aufmerksamer Pointierung von Einzelz¨ugen) aus den Anschauungen zu gewinnen, sie liegen in diesen nicht eingebettet wie die gesehene Gestalt in der gesehenen ‘Fl¨ache.’ Das Dreieck als angeschautes Abstraktum ist keine geometrische Figur, es dient dem Geometer als bloßes Symbol, dessen charakteristischer Typus in seinem Geist dispositionelle Verkn¨upfung besitzt mit dem zugeh¨origen reinen Begriff und seinem idealen und bloß ‘gedachten’ Gegenstand.”], “Intentionale Gegenst¨ande,” (1894) Edmund Husserl, Aufs¨atze und Rezensionen (1890–1910), Husserliana XXI, Bernhard Lang (ed.), The Hague/Boston/London: Martinus Nijhoff, 1979, pp. 269–348, p. 327. 20. [“Sache der reinen Theorie ist die reine Deduktion. Sie fragt u¨ berall nicht, woher die Grunds¨atze ¨ kommen, sie assumiert sie. Uber den Erkenntniswert der geometrischen Grundbegriffe und Grunds¨atze mag Streit bestehen, die geometrischen S¨atze sind u¨ ber jeden Streit erhaben. Ganz nat¨urlich, da ihre G¨ultigkeit keine andere Bedeutung hat als die Triftigkeit der Konsequenz aus den geometrischen Grundannahmen.”], Edmund Husserl, “Assumption der Axiome in Geometrie, Mannigfaltigkeitslehre und reiner Mechanik,” in Edmund Husserl, Aufs¨atze und Rezensionen (1890–1910), Husserliana XXI, pp. 430–431, p. 431.
82
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
21. Husserl expresses this in the following passage: “[The] geometer simply accepts the axioms and draws his consequences. At most, he restricts the number of basic concepts and axioms and attempts to fix a minimal number of them that are independent of each other and able to carry the entire system of deductions.” [“[Der] Geometer . . . nimmt die Grunds¨atze einfach hin und zieht seine Konsequenz. H¨ochstens, daß er die Zahl der Grundbegriffe und Grunds¨atze beschr¨ankt und eine Minimalzahl zu fixieren sucht, welche, voneinander deduktiv unabh¨angig das ganze System der Deduktionen zu tragen verm¨ogen.”], Ibid., p. 431. It is interesting to contrast Husserl’s view here with that of Moritz Pasch in his Vorlesungen u¨ ber neuere Geometrie from 1882. Pasch believed that the geometric axioms were rational extensions of statements about observable facts. In his construction of geometry he therefore first formulated certain fundamental observational statements about visible objects, which he called “nuclear sentences” (Kerns¨atze). Nuclear sentences were about physical bodies. For example, the term ‘point’ referred to a physical body whose subdivision into parts is incompatible with the limits set by perception. On the basis of these nuclear sentences, Pasch then constructed an axiomatic system whose justifications, logical derivations, were entirely independent of the original meanings of these terms. By doing so, he changed the meanings of the original terms. They became relational concepts that were exhaustively defined by the axioms. No appeal to perception was required in order to justify the theorems. In other words, the extension of the nuclear sentences to the axioms of a geometric theory rendered the latter a formal theory similar to Hilbert’s. Such a formal theory could then be applied to physical reality by interpreting its terms with the original objects. Husserl also thought that the construction of a geometric axiomatic system began with observations of perceptual objects. Yet, in contrast to Pasch, he did not believe that the idealization, and thus the subject matter of geometry, was a result of the axiomatization. Rather, according to Husserl, the subject matter of geometry (in the sense of material geometry) had to be constituted, at least partly, before one could construct an axiomatic theory that captured its properties. For Pasch’s view see his Vorlesungen u¨ ber neuere Geometrie, Leipzig: B.G. Teubner, 1882. 22. [“Mathematik im h¨ochsten und umfassendsten Sinn ist die Wissenschaft von den theoretischen Systemen u¨ berhaupt und in Abstraktion von dem, was in den gegebenen Theorien der verschiedenen Wissenschaften theoretisiert wird; abstrahieren wir bei irgendeiner gegebenen Theorie, bei irgendeinem gegebenen deduktiven System von seiner Materie, von den besonderen Gattungen von Objekten, auf deren theoretische Beherrschung sie es abgesehen hat, und substituieren wir den materiell bestimmten Objektvorstellungen die bloßen Formeln, also die Vorstellung von Objekten u¨ berhaupt, die durch solch eine Theorie, durch eine Theorie dieser Form beherrscht wird, so haben wir eine Verallgemeinerung vollzogen, welche die gegebenen Theorien als einen bloßen Einzelfall einer Theorie-Klasse auffaßt oder vielmehr einer Theorienform.”], Edmund Husserl, “Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik,” Husserliana XII, pp. 430–440, p. 430. 23. [“Es ist also ein Gebiet, welches einzig und allein dadurch bestimmt ist, daß es einer Theorie solcher Form untersteht, d.h. daß f¨ur seine Objekte gewisse Verkn¨upfungen m¨oglich sind, die unter gewissen Grundgesetzen der und der bestimmten Form (hier das einzig Bestimmende) stehen. Ihrer Materie nach bleiben die Objekte v¨ollig unbestimmt — der Mathematiker spricht, dies anzudeuten, mit Vorliebe von ‘Denkobjekten.’ Sie sind eben weder direkt als individuelle oder spezifische Einzelheiten, noch indirekt durch ihre inneren Arten oder Gattungen bestimmt, sondern ausschließlich durch die Form ihnen zugeschriebener Verkn¨upfungen.” Edmund Husserl, Logische Untersuchungen, Erster Band, Husserliana XVIII, p. 250. The same passage is also to be found in: Edmund Husserl, Formale und transzendentale Logik, Husserliana XVII, p. 94. 24. [“Nennen wir Raum die bekannte Ordnungsform der Erscheinungswelt, so ist nat¨urlich die Rede von ‘R¨aumen’, f¨ur welche z.B. das Parallelenaxiom nicht gilt, ein Widersinn. Ebenso die Rede von verschiedenen Geometrien, wofern Geometrie eben die Wissenschaft vom Raume der Erscheinungswelt genannt wird. Verstehen wir aber unter Raum die kategoriale Form des Weltraums und korrelativ unter Geometrie die kategoriale Theorienform der Geometrie im gemeinen Sinn, dann ordnet sich der Raum unter eine gesetzlich zu umgrenzende Gattung von rein kategorial bestimmten Mannigfaltigkeiten, mit Beziehung auf welche man dann naturgem¨aß von Raum in einem noch umfassenderen Sinne sprechen wird.”], Edmund Husserl, Logische Untersuchungen. Erster Band. Prolegomena zur reinen Logik (1900), p. 251. 25. Cf. Logische Untersuchungen. Erster Band, Husserliana XVIII, p. 249; Formale und transzendentale Logik, Husserliana XVII, p. 95. 26. [“Erhebt man sich zum reinen Operationssystem, verl¨aßt man das urpr¨ungliche reale Objekt-Gebiet, ob es Strecken oder Anzahlen sind, und faßt in allgemeinster Allgemeinheit ein Gebiet u¨ berhaupt ins Auge, das durch solche Operationsformen definiert ist, dann kann man die Idee eines solchen Gebietes verschiedentlich modifizieren, bald im Sinn eines weiteren, bald in dem eines engeren Operationssystems bzw. Axiomensystems.”], Edmund Husserl, Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik, Husserliana XII, p. 430– 440, p. 437. See also Husserl’s concept of Erweiterung eines Axiomensystems, ibid., p. 439.
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
83
27. Husserl writes: “Mathematik ist also ihrer h¨ochsten Idee nach Theorienlehre, die allgemeinste Wissenschaft von den deduktiven Systemen u¨ berhaupt.” Ibid., p. 431. 28. Ibid., p. 431. The distinction between three different concepts of space — intuitive, geometric, and formal — is also still present in the Krisis. Cf., Edmund Husserl, Die Krisis der europ¨aischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Ph¨anomenologie (1936), Husserliana VI, pp. 54–56. 29. [“Die formale Mathematik will das Instrument konkret mathematischer Entdeckungen sein; wie die alte Quantit¨atsmathematik das Gr¨oßeninstrument der naturwissenschaftlichen Forschung, n¨amlich das Instrument deduktiver Theoretisierung der verschiedenen Gebiete physischer Erkenntnisse, f¨ur welche die Induktion die passenden Lehrs¨atze geliefert hatte, so will die neue formale Mathematik nicht nur dasselbe, sondern sehr viel mehr leisten. Sie will Methoden von unvergleichlich gr¨oßerer Allgemeinheit und Kraft schaffen, welche alle methodischen Arbeiten real mathematischer Art entbehrlich macht.”], Edmund Husserl, Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik, pp. 430–440, p. 432. 30. Husserl writes: “Pure geometry is a purely a priori science. Whether it can find some application depends on whether an empirical concept of space can be correlated to, or rather, subsumed under, its pure concept of space. But, in fact, this is actually impossible. Among the objects of our experience there is no such thing as a point in the sense of pure geometry, that is, something that is spatially indivisible.”[“Die reine Geometrie ist eine reine apriorische Wissenschaft. Ob sie nun irgendeine Anwendung finden kann, das h¨angt davon ab, ob ihrem reinen Raumbegriff ein empirischer gegen¨ubergestellt oder vielmehr subsumiert werden kann. Das ist aber tats¨achlich nicht m¨oglich. Einen Punkt im Sinne der reinen Geometrie, also ein r¨aumlich Unteilbares gibt es nicht unter den Objekten unserer Erfahrung.”], Edmund Husserl, Philosophische Versuche u¨ ber den Raum (1886–1901), Husserliana, XXI, p. 296. 31. [“Der Geometrie der Idealit¨aten ging voraus die praktische Feldmeßkunst, die von Idealit¨aten nichts wußte. Solche vorgeometrische Leistung war aber f¨ur die Geometrie Sinnesfundament, Fundament f¨ur die große Erfindung der Idealisierung.”], Die Krisis der europ¨aischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Ph¨anomenologie, Husserliana, VI, p. 52. 32. [“In Konnex mit der Meßkunst tretend und nunmehr sie leitend, hat die Mathematik — damit von der Welt der Idealit¨aten wieder zur empirisch anschaulichen Welt herabsteigend — gezeigt, daß man universal an den Dingen der anschaulich-wirklichen Welt, und zwar auch nach der sie als Gestaltenmathematik allein interessierenden Seite (an der alle Dinge notwendig teilhaben), eine objektiv-reale Erkenntnis von einer v¨ollig neuen Art, n¨amlich eine approximativ auf ihre eigenen Idealit¨aten bezogene, gewinnen kann.”], Ibid., p. 33. 33. [“Das eine [definite Mannigfaltigkeit] definierende axiomatische System ist dadurch ausgezeichnet, daß jeder aus den in diesem auftretenden Begriffen (Begriffsformen nat¨urlich) rein logisch-grammatisch zu konstruierende Satz (Satzform) entweder ‘wahr’, n¨amlich eine analytische (rein deduktive) Konsequenz der Axiome, oder ‘falsch’ ist, n¨amlich ein analytischer Widerspruch: tertium non datur.”], Edmund Husserl, Formale und transzendentale Logik, Husserliana VXII, p. 100. 34. Cf., Ulrich Majer, “Husserl and Hilbert on Completeness,” Synthese 110 (1997), pp. 37–56. 35. My exposition of Husserl’s notion of a definite manifold relies on Jairo Jose Da Silva and Ulrich Majer. See Jairo Jose Da Silva, “Husserl’s Two Notions of Completeness,” Synthese 125 (2000), pp. 417– 438 and Ulrich Majer, “Husserl and Hilbert on Completeness.” 36. The problem of imaginary mathematical objects, thus, arises from Husserl’s earlier project in Philosophie der Arithmetik of providing an intuitive foundation for arithmetic. The connection between Husserl’s original project and his G¨ottingen lecture is analyzed in Ulrich Majer’s article “Husserl and Hilbert on Completeness.” 37. [“Es sei ein Gebiet von Objekten gegeben, in welchem durch die besondere Natur der Objekte Verkn¨upfungs- und Beziehungsformen bestimmt sind, die sich in einem bestimmten Axiomensystem aussprechen. Aufgrund dieses Systems, also aufgrund der besonderen Natur der Objekte haben bestimmte Verkn¨upfungsformen keine reale Bedeutung, d.h. es sind widersinnige Verkn¨upfungsformen. Mit welchem Recht darf das Widersinnige rechnerich verarbeitet, mit welchem Recht kann also das Widersinnige in deduktiven Systemen verwandt werden, als ob es Einstimmiges w¨are. Wie l¨aßt sich erkl¨aren, daß sich mit dem Widersinnigen nach Regeln operieren l¨aßt, und daß, wenn das Widersinnige aus den S¨atzen herausf¨allt, die gewonnenen S¨atze richtig sind.”], Edmund Husserl, Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik, Husserliana XII, pp. 430–447, p. 433. 38. [“Daß wir nicht den Anzahlbegriff willk¨urlich erweitern k¨onnen, ist sicher. Aber wohl k¨onnen wir den Anzahlbegriff verlassen und durch das formale System der f¨ur Anzahlen geltenden Definitionen und Operationen einen neuen, rein formalen Begriff definieren, den der positiven ganzen Zahlen. Und dieser formale Begriff der positiven Zahlen l¨aßt sich, so wie er selbst durch Definition abgegrenzt ist, durch neue Definitionen, und zwar widerspruchsfrei, erweitern.], Ibid., p. 435. 39. Husserl considers the explanations of mathematicians like Boole and Dedekind.
84
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
40. Edmund Husserl, Zur formalen Bestimmung einer Mannigfaltigkeit, Husserliana XII, p. 493–500. In particular, p. 495. 41. “The system of axioms is kept fixed for the old domain of objects. Yet, new objects are being defined and a new system of axioms is being constructed in such as way that if we restrict it to the old domain of objects, it transforms into the old axiomatic system. But we do not need to demand a perfection in which such extension is not possible.” [“Das Axiomensystem wird festgehalten f¨ur das alte Gebiet. Es werden aber neue Objekte definiert und ein Axiomensystem so konstruiert, daß dasselbe bei Beschr¨ankung auf das alte Gebiet in das alte u¨ bergeht. Aber Perfektion in dem Sinn, daß eine solche Erweiterung nicht m¨oglich sein soll ist nicht zu fordern.”], Husserliana XII, p. 474. 42. [“Im Begriff der Erweiterung liegt, wenn wir ihn auf die Axiome beziehen, daß die neuen Axiome die alten mitumfassen, und daß die neuen zudem Operationsf¨alle zulassen, welche die alten ausschließen.”], Edmund Husserl, “Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik”, pp. 430–440, p. 439. 43. Let A and B be theories in the languages L and L’. Then B is a conservative extension of A if B ∩ L = A (i. e. all theorems of B in the language of A are already theorems of A). See, for example, Dirk van Dalen Logic and Structure, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York, Tokyo: Springer Verlag, 1983, p. 107. 44. [“Ein Durchgang durch das Imagin¨are ist gestattet: 1) wenn das Imagin¨are sich in einem konsistenten umfassenden Deduktionssystem formal definieren l¨aßt und wenn 2) das urspr¨ungliche Deduktionsgebiet formalisiert die Eigenschaft hat, daß jeder in dieses Gebiet fallende Satz entweder aufgrund der Axiome dieses Gebietes wahr oder aufgrund derselben falsch, d.i. mit den Axiomen widersprechend ist.”], Ibid., p. 441. 45. Ibid. 46. [“Relativ definit ist ein Axiomensystem, wenn jeder nach ihm sinnvolle Satz in Beschr¨ankung auf sein Gebiet entschieden ist.”], Ibid., p. 440. 47. See, for example, Dieter Lohmar, Ph¨anomenologie der Mathematik: Elemente einer ph¨anomenologischen Aufkl¨arung der mathematischen Erkenntnis, Dordrecht/Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1989. 48. Jairo J. Da Silva, “Husserl’s Two Notions of Completeness,” p. 422. 49. [“Hat ein Satz Sinn gem¨aß den Axiomen, dann ist er durch die Axiome in Wahrheit oder Falschheit entschieden.”], Edmund Husserl, Drei Studien zur Definitheit und Erweiterung eines Axiomensystems, Husserliana XII, pp. 452–461, p. 454. 50. [“Absolut definit ist ein Axiomensystem dann, wenn jeder nach ihm sinnvolle Satz u¨ berhaupt entschieden ist.”], Edmund Husserl, “Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik”, pp. 430–440, p. 440. 51. For a more explicit account of Husserl’s solution to the problem of imaginary magnitudes see Ulrich Majer, “Husserl and Hilbert on Completeness,” p. 47. 52. [“Die Euklidische Geometrie ist eine konkrete Theorie, welche formalisiert die Theorieform ergibt, die wir als dreifache Euklidische Mannigfaltigkeit bezeichnen, und diese wieder ist nur ein Einzelfall aus der systematisch zusammenh¨angenden Klasse der Mannigfaltigkeit von variablem Kr¨ummungsmaß.”] Edmund Husserl, “Das Imagin¨are in der Mathematik”, pp. 430–440, p. 431. 53. Edmund Husserl, Logische Untersuchungen. Erster Band. Prolegomena zur reinen Logik, Husserliana XVIII, pp. B150–51. 54. [“Die Erweiterung zu ME soll M0 als das, was es ist, nicht st¨oren, und vor allem nicht spezialisieren, d.h. die definitorischen Bestimmungen f¨ur ME m¨ussen eine bloße Erweiterung sein f¨ur diejenigen von M0 .”], Edmund Husserl, “Drei Studien zur Definitheit,” Husserliana XII, pp. 452–469, p. 460. 55. This is particularly important for Husserl’s analysis of the a priori structure of intuitive (perceptual) space. In Ding und Raum, for example, he argues that the fact that intuitive space is constituted in a kineasthetic system necessitates its a priori structure. We can intuit “thing-like” objects only if the space in which they are located affords movement without deformation. And this is possible, according to the Helmholtz-Lie theorem, only if the space has a constant curvature. But since the Helmholtz-Lie theorem is based on an abstract concept of space, namely on the Riemannian manifold, this argument requires that the latter express a genuine concept of space, and be more than just a formal construct. See Edmund Husserl, Ding und Raum. Vorlesungen 1907, Husserliana XVII, p. 243.
References van Dalen, D. (1983), Logic and Structure, Springer, Berlin. Da Silva, J. J. (2000), “Husserl’s Two Notions of Completeness” in: Synthese 125, 417–438. Hilbert, D. (1899), Grundlagen der Geometrie, Teubner, Leipzig.
Edmund Husserl on the Applicability of Formal Geometry
85
Husserl, E. (1886–1901), Studien zur Arithmetik und Geometrie. Texte aus dem Nachlaß (1886– 1901). Zweiter Teil. Philosophische Versuche u¨ ber den Raum (1886–1901), Husserliana XXI, I. Strohmeyer (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1983. Husserl, E. (1890–1901), Philosophie der Arithmetik. Mit Erg¨anzenden Texten (1890–1901), Husserliana XII, L. Eley (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1970. Husserl, E. (1890–1910), Aufs¨atze und Rezensionen, Husserliana XXI, B.Lang (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1979. Husserl, E. (1900), Logische Untersuchungen. Erster Band. Prolegomena zur reinen Logik, Husserliana XVIII, E. Holenstein (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague 1975. Husserl, E. (1907), Ding und Raum. Vorlesungen 1907, Husserliana XVII, U. Claesges (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1973. Husserl, E. (1936), Die Krisis der europ¨aischen Wissenschaften und die transzendentale Ph¨anomenologie, Husserliana VI, W. Biemel (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1954. Husserl, E. (1950), Ideen zu einer reinen Ph¨anomenologie und ph¨anomenologischen Philosophie, Husserliana III, W. Biemel (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1950. Husserl, E. (1974), Formale und transzendentale Logik, Husserliana XVII, P. Jansen (ed.), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1974. Lohmar, D. (1989), Ph¨anomenologie der Mathematik: Elemente einer ph¨anomenologischen Aufkl¨arung der mathematischen Erkenntnis, Kluwer, Dordrecht/Boston. Majer, U. (1997), “Husserl and Hilbert on Completeness” in: Synthese 110, 37–56. Pasch, M. (1882), Vorlesungen u¨ ber neuere Geometrie, Teubner, Leipzig. Schuhmann, E. and K. Schuhmann (2001), “Husserls Manuskripte zu seinem G¨ottinger Doppelvortrag von 1901” in: Husserl Studies 17, 87–123.
THE NEO-FREGEAN PROGRAM IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF ARITHMETIC∗ William Demopoulos University of Western Ontario, Canada
1.
The methodology of Fregean logicism
Traditional “Fregean” logicism held that arithmetic would be shown to be free from any dependence on intuition once its basic laws were seen to follow from logic together with explicit definitions. It would then be clear that our knowledge of arithmetic is knowledge of the same character as our knowledge of logic, since an extension of a theory (in this case the “theory” of second order logic) by mere definitions cannot have a different epistemic status from the theory of which it is an extension. If the original theory consists of analytic truths, so also must the extension; if our knowledge of the truths of the original theory is for this reason a priori, so also must be our knowledge of the truths of its definitional extension. The uncontroversial point for traditional formulations of the doctrine is that a reduction of this kind secures the sameness of the epistemic character of arithmetic and logic, while allowing for some flexibility as to the nature of that epistemic character. Thus, it is worth remembering that in Principles (p. 457), Russell concluded that a reduction of mathematics to logic would show, contrary to Kant, that logic is just as synthetic as mathematics.1 The methodology underlying this approach to securing the aprioricity of arithmetic by a traditional logicist reduction has been questioned. For example, Paul Benacerraf,2 who focuses on Hempel’s3 classic exposition, tells us that . . . logicism was. . . heralded by Carnap, Hempel. . . and others as the answer to Kant’s doctrine that the propositions of arithmetic were synthetic a priori. . . . in reply to Kant, logicists claimed that these propositions are a priori because they are analytic — because they are true (or false) merely “in virtue of” the meanings of the terms in which they are cast. ... ∗I
wish to thank the Social Sciences and Research Council of Canada for support of my research.
87 E. Carson and R. Huber (eds.), Intuition and the Axiomatic Method, 87–112. © 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
88
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method According to Hempel, the Frege-Russell definitions. . . have shown the propositions of arithmetic to be analytic because they follow by stipulative definitions from logical principles. What Hempel has in mind here is clearly that in a constructed formal system of logic (set theory or second-order logic plus an axiom of infinity), one may introduce by stipulative definition the expressions ‘Number,’ ‘Zero,’ ‘Successor’ in such a way that sentences of such a formal system using these introduced abbreviations and which are formally the same as (i.e., spelled the same way as) certain sentences of arithmetic — e.g., ‘Zero is a Number’ — appear as theorems of the system. He concludes. . . that these definitions show the theorems of arithmetic to be mere notational extensions of theorems of logic, and thus analytic. He is not entitled to that conclusion. Nor would he be even if the theorems of logic in their primitive notations were themselves analytic. For the only things that have been shown to follow from the theorems of logic by [stipulative definitions] are the abbreviated theorems of the logistic system. To parlay that into an argument about the propositions of arithmetic, one needs an argument that the sentences of arithmetic, in their preanalytic senses, mean the same (or approximately the same) as their homonyms in the logistic system. That requires a separate and longer argument.
Benacerraf is questioning whether the logicist can claim to have established any truth of arithmetic on the basis of a successful reduction. What is required, according to Benacerraf, is a supplementary argument showing that the logicist theorems have the preanalytic meanings of their ordinary arithmetical analogues. But Benacerraf’s demand for a further argument is not justified. To successfully dispel the belief that the laws of logic cannot have an arithmetical content it suffices to show that the concepts of logic allow for the explicit definition of notions which, on the basis of logical laws alone, demonstrably satisfy the basic laws of arithmetic. The philosophical impact of the discovery that the concepts and laws of logic have an arithmetical content in this sense would not in any way be diminished by the observation that the preanalytic meanings of the primitives of arithmetic are not the same as their logicist reconstructions. The sense in which the logicist thesis must be understood in order to be judged successful cannot therefore be the one for which Benacerraf claims Hempel must argue. Notice also that independently of one’s view of meaning and truth in virtue of meaning, it must be conceded that traditional logicism would have provided a viable answer to Kant if it had succeeded in showing that the reconstruction of arithmetical knowledge requires only an extension of logic by explicit definitions. Hempel’s appeal to these notions addresses a different issue: Frege left the problem of securing the epistemic basis of the laws of logic largely untouched. Benacerraf’s Hempel should be understood as proposing to fill this gap by suggesting that the laws of logic are true in virtue of the meanings of the logical constants they contain. Like Frege, Hempel sought to secure the aprioricity of arithmetic by an argument that proceeds from its analyticity. But Hempel’s version of logicism differs from Frege’s (for whom ‘analytic’ merely meant belonging to logic or a definitional extension of logic) by providing a
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
89
justification for the analyticity of logical laws: logical laws are analytic, not by fiat as on Frege’s account, but because they are true in virtue of the meanings of the logical terms they contain. From this it would follow that if logical laws are true in virtue of meaning, so also is any proposition established solely on their basis, where ‘established solely on their basis’ is intended to encompass the use of explicit definitions. The clarity of the thesis that the laws of logic are true in virtue of meaning is therefore central to Hempel’s presentation of the view. Also central is the substantive and further claim that the basic laws of arithmetic can be recovered within a definitional extension of logic. The implied criticism of Hempel’s appeal to truth in virtue of meaning gains its force from the difficulties that stand in the way of establishing the traditional logicist thesis that arithmetic is reducible to logic in the original sense of the doctrine. Certainly, the failure to sustain this thesis led to more ambitious applications of the notion of truth in virtue of meaning. But if the basic laws of arithmetic had been recovered as a part of logic — not merely shown to have analogues that are part of some formal system or other, but to be part of logic — what more would be needed to infer that they share the epistemic status of logical laws? Once Hempel is not represented as seeking to secure the truth of the basic laws of arithmetic by an appeal to the derivability of mere formal analogues or a blanket appeal to the notion of truth in virtue of meaning, it is clear that he simply doesn’t owe us the argument Benacerraf claims he does. The difficulties that attend traditional logicism are therefore not the methodological difficulties Benacerraf advances, but the simple failure to achieve the stated aim of showing arithmetic to be a definitional extension of logic. This point is obscured by Benacerraf’s suggestion that the reduction might proceed from second order logic with an axiom of infinity or from some version of set theory. Neither theory supports the truth in virtue of meaning account that underlies Hempel’s formulation of logicism. On the most natural interpretation, a reduction to second order logic with Infinity would mean a reduction to a system augmented with an axiom like Whitehead and Russell’s; but no one ever thought such a system was true in virtue of meaning. As for a reduction to set theory, set theory is properly regarded as the arithmetic of the transfinite. Why should a reduction of the natural numbers to set theory be regarded as a means of establishing its aprioricity on a less synthetic footing? The only coherent logicist methodology would therefore seem to be the one just outlined: to reduce arithmetic to a theory like Begriffsschrift’s. Unfortunately, such a theory is either too weak, or in the presence of Frege’s theory of classes, inconsistent.
2.
The neo-Fregean alternative
In Frege’s Conception of Numbers as Objects,4 Crispin Wright showed that it is possible to extract from Frege’s Grundlagen a valid second-order proof of
90
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
the Dedekind infinity of the natural numbers using only a suitable formalization of the following “partial contextual definition” for numerical identity: For any concepts F and G, the number of Fs is identical with the number of Gs if and only if the Fs and the Gs are in one-one correspondence.5 Wright argued that this proof can form the basis of a defensible, if modified, formulation of Frege’s philosophy of arithmetic, one that relies on Frege’s thesis that numbers are objects, but makes no use of the problematic theory of classes. Bob Hale’s Abstract Objects,6 which appeared in 1987, is perhaps the next important landmark in the elaboration of a “neo-Fregean” philosophy of arithmetic along the lines of Frege’s conception. In an influential series of papers, George Boolos clarified and extended Wright’s discussion and its relation to the central mathematical argument of Grundlagen. Boolos’s designation of the partial contextual definition as “Hume’s principle” has since become established in the literature,7 as has his suggestion that the theorem that the second-order theory whose sole axiom is Hume’s principle (“Frege arithmetic”) has a definitional extension which contains Peano Arithmetic, be called “Frege’s theorem.” The neo-Fregean program of Wright and Hale seeks to imbed this logical discovery into a philosophically interesting account of our knowledge of arithmetic by subsuming Hume’s principle under a general method for introducing a concept by an “abstraction principle.”This program explains the epistemological interest of the discovery that arithmetic is a part, not of second order logic, but of Frege arithmetic, by the program’s account of conceptintroduction by abstraction. The key to achieving this goal is the idea that abstraction principles have a distinguished status: they are a special kind of stipulation. Their stipulative character shows them to be importantly like explicit definitions even if their creativeness suggests an affinity with axioms; and it is a central tenet of neo-Fregean logicism that abstraction principles are sufficiently like definitions to yield an elegant explanation, along traditional lines, of why arithmetical knowledge is knowledge a priori. By an “abstraction principle”, the neo-Fregean means the universal closure of an expression of the form Σ(X) = Σ(Y ) ↔ X Y , where is an equivalence relation, the variables X and Y may be of any order, and the function Σ may be of mixed type. In the case of Hume’s principle, the equivalence relation is the (second order definable) relation on concepts of one-one correspondence, and the “cardinality function” is a map from Fregean concepts to objects. As we will see in greater detail later, it is important for this program that concept formation by means of an abstraction principle should be distinguished from the ordinary practice of axiomatization and, indeed, that the case be made that not all cases of concept formation by an abstraction principle are on a par.
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
91
In the case of Hume’s principle, the basic idea appears to be the following: Hume’s principle is a stipulation which gives truth conditions for a restricted class of statements of numerical identity, namely, those of the form, the number of F s is identical with the number of Gs. Although the specification of truth conditions is partial — it concerns only a restricted class of statements of numerical identity — the resulting explanation of the concept of number is complete in so far as it suffices for the (second order) derivation of the basic laws of arithmetic. As Wright has emphasized,8 whether or not Hume’s principle counts as an analytic truth is entirely subordinate to its status as a stipulation governing our application of the concept of number. Since concept formation by Hume’s principle, like concept formation in accordance with any other abstraction principle, involves the introduction of a new concept, it would be a mistake to view the principle as analytic of the concept of number in the way in which the notion analytic of has traditionally been understood. Rather, the idea is that Hume’s principle is a trivial consequence of the nature of the concept of number because it is a stipulation governing the introduction of that concept (rather than the analysis of a pre-existing concept). The stipulative character of the principle is important, since it is this feature which allows it to fulfill (albeit in a restricted and modified sense) logicism’s promise to deliver the aprioricity of arithmetic from logic plus some species of stipulation — i.e., from assumptions that will uncontentiously secure arithmetic as a priori. Wright originally called his view “number-theoretic logicism” because it derives the basic laws of arithmetic from a stipulation governing the concept of number without, however, providing an explicit definition of the individual numbers or of immediately precedes on the basis of a purely logical vocabulary. Although number-theoretic logicism falls short of the goal of explicitly defining the vocabulary of arithmetic in purely logical terms, it proceeds on the basis of a single stipulation, and the “explanation” of numerical identity by Hume’s principle is achieved in terms of a concept of pure (second order) logic. There can be no question of the importance of Hale’s and Wright’s contributions and of the vitality they have imparted to a subject long regarded as having at most historical interest. Wright’s rediscovery of Frege’s theorem has been the major impetus to the reevaluation of Frege’s philosophy of arithmetic, and his and Hale’s defense of a modified form of Fregean logicism has elicited a critical reaction that has prompted a substantial clarification of the neo-Fregean position.9
3.
Is Hume’s principle correctly represented as a stipulation?
For reasons that will soon become evident, the first class of objections that have been urged against the neo-Fregean program are known as “bad company” objections. Wright addresses two such bad company objections to his
92
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
position. First, concept introduction by an abstraction principle can fail, and can fail spectacularly, as the case of the abstraction principle expressed by Grundgesetze’s Basic Law V showed. But (the objection goes) how can we accept a view which invites us to rely upon a methodology which is known to be seriously flawed? And secondly, given our freedom to stipulate one or another abstraction principle, it is necessary to supplement the account with a criterion capable of governing the choice of one abstraction over another.10 Apropos of the first objection, Wright makes a convincing case that the fact that a methodology sometimes leads to flawed conclusions does not mean that it is itself irremediably flawed, and he reminds us that Hume’s principle is consistent relative to analysis.11 Why should it be necessary to show that the procedure will work whatever abstraction principle is employed? One difficulty with this response is that it tends to assimilate concept introduction by abstraction to the case of ordinary axiomatization, and this makes it difficult to appreciate Wright’s insistence that what he is proposing is sharply different from what he calls “the mere axiomatic stipulation of existence.” The contrast with axiomatic stipulation is important and I will return to it. However, the consistency of Hume’s principle fails to settle the second “bad company” objection which effectively raises the question whether, and in what sense, it is true. For suppose we grant that Hume’s principle stipulates or lays down the truth conditions for certain statements of numerical identity. Is the truth of Hume’s principle merely a matter of stipulation? That this is how Wright intends to be understood is suggested by several passages: . . . [a] state of affairs is initially given to us as the obtaining of a certain equivalence relation. . . ; but we have the option, by stipulating that the abstraction is to hold, of so reconceiving such states of affairs that they come to constitute a new kind of thing. . . (p. 277).
That Wright views abstraction principles as stipulations is reinforced by a contrast he draws between the basis for our knowledge of the truth of Hume’s principle and our knowledge of the existence of the numbers: abstract objects are not creations of the mind, brought into being by a kind of stipulation. What is formed — created — by such an abstraction is rather a concept: the effect is merely to fix the truth conditions of identity statements concerning a new kind of thing, and it is quite another question whether those truth conditions are ever realized (p. 278).
According to Wright, the representation of Hume’s principle as a kind of stipulation does not prejudice the question whether the existence of the numbers is a matter of stipulation. In fact, Wright maintains that the existence of the numbers is something discovered rather than stipulated, while holding that our a priori knowledge of their necessary existence is ultimately derived from a principle whose truth is a matter of stipulation. This is entirely credible as a view of conventional explicit definitions, but it cannot be so easily maintained in the case of a contextual definition like Hume’s principle. It is precisely because ordinary definitions are not creative
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
93
that we can say that anything, expressed in unabbreviated notation, which is established or discovered on their basis does not really depend on them, and, in consequence, does not share the conventional character of their epistemic basis. But even if Hume’s principle can be regarded as a stipulation, it is certainly not a stipulation of this character, since it is creative over the theory to which it is added.12 Indeed, this is precisely the point where the analogy between “concept introduction via an abstraction principle” and the methodology of concept introduction by ordinary explicit definition can break down, with the result that concept introduction by abstraction becomes difficult to distinguish from axiomatic stipulation. Hale and Wright13 emphasize the difference between treating Hume’s principle as a stipulation — something which they hold to be unproblematic — and treating the existence of the numbers as a matter of stipulation, which they agree is problematic. Their point is that Hume’s principle merely lays down partial satisfaction conditions for the relation of numerical identity, thereby establishing the existence of the relation in analogy with the use of axioms as implicit definitions of the terms they introduce. Hale and Wright insist that it is not part of their position that the stipulation of such satisfaction conditions should secure the existence of the objects related by the relation of numerical identity; rather, their existence is secured by a proof, the proof that there are objects related by the relation thus introduced. Indeed, the discovery of this proof gives the sense in which they hold that the existence of the numbers is “discovered.” Thus understood, their methodology differs from the “axiomatic stipulation of existence” that is embodied in, for example, the set-theoretic practice of simply laying down a comprehension axiom and claiming, on its basis, to have secured the existence of whatever sets — whatever “objects” — the axiom allows, while excluding whatever sets the axiom disallows. But the methodology Hale and Wright are here reporting is a straightforward variation on another thoroughly familiar and unexceptionable set-theoretic practice. In standard axiomatic set theory, we freely lay down a defining condition and then proceed to verify — to prove, on the basis of our axioms of set existence — that our definition is not vacuous and that we have not simply redefined the empty set. For example, we are free to define the power set of a set A by the familiar use of class-abstract notation, P (A) = {B : B ⊆ A}. But the proof that the set we have defined is the intended one and not just the empty set requires an axiom — the power set axiom, ∃B ∀C (C ∈ B ↔ C ⊆ A) — to ensure the existence of the appropriate set. It should be clear that in the absence of an account of our basis for believing the set-theoretic axioms, this methodology does not give — and does not pretend to give — an account of the basis for our beliefs about the existence of sets with the intended membership, so that if the set-theoretic axioms are represented as stipulations, this is naturally assumed to transfer to the basis for our belief in the sets whose exis-
94
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
tence and non-vacuousness we are able to prove on their basis. In the absence of Hume’s principle, we can, following Frege, lay down defining conditions for all of the individual numbers. What we cannot do without Hume’s principle is prove that the numbers we have defined are distinct from zero and from one another. Now except for the fact that they are working in Frege arithmetic rather than Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory, this is exactly the methodological situation described by Hale and Wright. Why should their claim to have given us an account of the basis for our belief in the numbers be viewed any differently? In particular, if the set theoretic situation supports the idea that the basis for our belief in the existence of sets with the intended membership is the same as the basis for our believing the truth of the axioms — the same, that is, in the sense that by stipulating the truth of the axioms, we leave the existence of the intended sets resting on a stipulation, — then if Hume’s principle is represented as a stipulation, the existence of the numbers must also be regarded as resting on a stipulation. Perhaps the stipulative character of Hume’s principle should be thought of on the model of a reference-fixing stipulation, after the manner of Saul Kripke’s example of the introduction of a term like ‘meter.’ The idea would be that we stipulate that at time t, bar b is a meter long, from which it follows that at t, the length of b falls under the concept meter. Although we have laid down a stipulation (a reference-fixing stipulation), in doing so we have also succeeded in making a factual assertion, namely that b has a particular length at t — something that obtained before the convention was laid down, and something that will continue to obtain even if the convention is withdrawn. Might not something similar hold for concept introduction by an abstraction, so that it, too, may be seen to consist in laying down a stipulation while at the same time having a factual content? Couldn’t Wright argue that the opposition — fact vs. convention — has been overdrawn, obscuring the fact that the stipulative character of Hume’s principle, on which he has correctly insisted, does not preclude it from having a factual character as well? The difficulty with this response is that while Kripke’s model of reference-fixing may suffice to show that it is not in general true that stipulations are incapable of a factual content which is independent of the stipulations themselves, it is of no help in clarifying how the stipulative character of concept-introduction by an abstraction is capable of accommodating the factual content of a principle like Hume’s. This is because the factual content of the assertion that bar b is a meter long is carried by the possibility of displaying or ostending, independently of the reference-fixing stipulation, the length to which the concept of a meter is to be applied. But this possibility is precisely what is lacking in the account of the number-theoretic case in terms of concept introduction by abstraction. The idea that the truth of Hume’s principle is a matter of a stipulation that is unconstrained by any “antecedently determinate truth” allows Wright to sidestep the difficulties which confront showing that it is true or that it correctly captures our pre-analytic notion of numerical identity. However this comes at
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
95
a cost: the problem is that there are many abstractions, all of them satisfiable, but relative to certain assumptions, not necessarily mutually satisfiable. For example, in “The Standard of Equality for Numbers,” Boolos introduced several sentences with very different model-theoretic properties from one another, but with an equal claim to being treated as abstraction principles that introduce a class of abstract singular terms. In “On the Philosophical Significance of Frege’s Theorem,” Wright considers a modification of one of Boolos’s examples in order to motivate a constraint on “admissible” abstraction principles. The example involves a type-lowering function which takes two concepts to the same object just in case their symmetric difference is finite. I.e., the mapping n from concepts to objects satisfies the condition: n(F) = n(G) if and only if [x: x is F but not G or G but not F] is finite. It can be shown that the resulting abstraction principle, which Wright calls NP (for Nuisance Principle), holds in finite domains but fails if the domain of individuals is infinite and the range of the concept variables is the full power set of this domain.14 To see the difficulty that such a “bad company” example poses, assume (for whatever reason) that we are committed to a standard interpretation of second order logic. Then were we to adopt the stipulation embodied in NP, we would be restricted to models having only finitely many objects. Since Hume’s principle holds only in infinite domains, our adoption of NP would preclude us from stipulating that numerical singular terms should be used in accordance with Hume’s principle. But if we take seriously the idea that abstraction principles are merely stipulations governing the use of the singular terms they introduce — i.e., that they are conventions which we freely lay down — we might easily defeat the truth of Hume’s principle by an “incorrect” initial choice of abstraction principle, one satisfiable only in finite domains. This would occur if, for example, we had first chosen the stipulation embodied in NP. But if abstraction principles are stipulations, and thus, Hume’s principle just one stipulation among many, how can we make sense of the idea that there is a right initial choice? If the truth of an abstraction is a matter of stipulation, then the existence of a domain sufficiently large to contain the numbers would seem to depend upon which abstraction happened to be laid down first, so that whether the domain of objects contains a sub-domain capable of modeling the basic laws of arithmetic would come to rest on an arbitrary decision of ours. This is clearly a conclusion Wright and Hale do not wish to endorse and they recognize that what might be called the “quasi-conventionalist” features of their approach make it incumbent upon them to articulate a principled division among abstractions. One proposal Wright has explored — there are many other conditions which Wright and Hale have investigated in their insightful search for a theory of good abstractions — is that an abstraction is acceptable only if it satisfies a “conservativeness” requirement according to which an abstraction principle is acceptable if it does not constrain the cardinality
96
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
of concepts with whose introduction it is not itself explicitly concerned. But to know that Hume’s principle constrains only the cardinality of the numbers, we must know of the cardinality function, not only that it associates concepts with objects, so that, in particular, non-equinumerous concepts are associated with distinct objects, we must also know that the objects thus associated are numbers. Otherwise, how are we to maintain, in accordance with the conservativeness condition, that it constrains only the numbers?15 The problem of demarcating Hume’s principle from “bad” abstraction principles on the basis of conservativeness would seem to presuppose a solution to the problem of demarcating the numbers from other objects on the basis of principles internal to number-theoretic logicism — the so-called “Julius Caesar problem.” Wright could respond16 to this charge by observing that it assumes we possess an unreconstructed concept of number to which Hume’s principle is responsible. But the whole point of concept introduction by abstraction, he will say, is to explain how numbers may be introduced without admitting to any such responsibility. There is therefore a certain internal coherence to Wright’s program that makes it resistant to criticisms of this sort. Nevertheless, even if it should turn out to be possible to draw a principled division between good and bad abstractions, the point of developing a theory of good abstractions rests on the assumption that an abstraction principle as rich as Hume’s is adequately represented as a stipulation.17 Recall that the key philosophical idea of Grundlagen — the idea that underlies the revival of Frege’s program — is the notion that numerical singular terms are “referential” because with Hume’s principle we are in possession of a clear criterion by which we can say when the same number has been “given to us” in two different ways, as the number of one or another concept. Once the truth of this criterion of identity has been secured, we are entitled by the context principle (Only in the context of a sentence does a word have reference [Bedeutung]) to infer that numerical singular terms refer. Our “access” to the numbers is therefore mediated by our recognition of the truth of Hume’s principle, and this same principle also serves as the only substantive premise in the proof of their infinity. Frege’s account of our access or reference to the numbers thus relies fundamentally on our recognition of the truth of Hume’s principle. What is needed to make this account viable is a satisfactory explanation of the sense in which Hume’s principle is true, and an account of how it is known to be true, since this is what is required to infer, by the context principle, that numerical singular terms refer. To my mind, number-theoretic logicism has not adequately addressed the consequences of treating Hume’s principle as a stipulation which we freely lay down. Instead it has concentrated on the question whether the surface grammar of the left-hand side of the principle can be taken seriously, whether, in other words, the apparent deployment of numerical singular terms as singular terms is justified. As Wright puts it, one has “to read the left-hand sides of the appropriate abstraction principles not merely as notational variants of the
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
97
right-hand sides, but in a way which is constrained by their surface syntax” (p. 271). Once this is established, Wright argues, no further question can arise over whether such terms genuinely refer, and there is “no good sense in which their reference could be stigmatized as semantically idle” (p. 270). But the difficulty, as I see it, is with the transition from the characterization of the truth of Hume’s principle as a simple stipulation to its deployment as a truth having significant existential implications. Since it is the latter characterization of Hume’s principle that its use in conjunction with the context principle relies upon, this transition is clearly required; nevertheless, it is deeply perplexing and constitutes the chief stumbling-block to accepting neo-Fregean logicism’s claim to have secured or explained the reference of numerical singular terms.
4.
Has the neo-Fregean explained the aprioricity of arithmetic?
The neo-Fregean program has a methodological dimension that parallels the role of the theory of definition in traditional logicism. Frege accords a statement the status of a proper definition if it meets conditions of eliminability and conservativeness. The classical Fregean theory of definition is supplemented by the neo-Fregean methodology of good abstractions. Thus, the theory of definition mandates that a definitional extension must be conservative in the familiar sense of not allowing the proof of sentences formulated in the unextended vocabulary which are not already provable without the addition of the definitions which comprise the extension. But “extensions by abstraction” need not be conservative in this sense; indeed interesting extensions are interesting precisely because they are not conservative in the sense of the theory of definition. The neo-Fregean theory of good abstractions allows for classically non-conservative extensions — extensions which properly extend the class of provable sentences — but imposes a constraint on the consequences an extension by good abstraction principles can have for the ontology of the theory to which they are added. This methodology is constrained and principled, it is just not constrained in the same way as the classical theory of definition. We can, perhaps, put the difference by saying that the constraints the classical theorist imposes on definition have a more purely epistemic motivation than do the constraints the neo-Fregean imposes on good abstractions. The reticence of the classical theory of definition to allow a mere definition to properly extend the theory to which it is added is well-founded, and it is at least arguable that it should also inform the epistemic basis of a principle as rich as Hume’s. But suppose we put these doubts to one side and ask whether the neo-Fregean account of Hume’s principle as a kind of stipulation can support the epistemological claim of neo-Fregeanism to have secured the aprioricity of our arithmetical knowledge as a consequence of its resting on a stipulation. The matter is taken up by Hale and Wright in their paper “Implicit Definition and A Priori Knowledge” — and by Wright in his “Is Hume’s Prin-
98
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
ciple Analytic?” which, notwithstanding its title, is not concerned to secure the analyticity of Hume’s principle in any of several traditional senses of the notion but to address the question of its epistemic status within the neo-Fregean program and the light this can shed on our arithmetical knowledge. Wright and Hale use the stipulative character of Hume’s principle as a premise in an argument for the aprioricity of our arithmetical knowledge. In acquiring the concept of number, we acquire a criterion of identity for number — a criterion for saying when the same number has been given to us in two different ways as the number of one or another concept. This criterion of identity — Hume’s principle — is the only non-logical premise needed to derive the basic laws of arithmetic. Our arithmetical knowledge is secured, therefore, with our grasp of the concept of number and is based on nothing more than what we acquire when we are introduced to the concept. But since this knowledge rests on a stipulation, it is knowledge a priori. This is essentially the same account of the epistemological interest of Frege arithmetic that is elaborated by Fraser MacBride in two thoughtful papers18 that address the issue. For MacBride the neo-Fregean explanation of the aprioricity of our knowledge of arithmetic runs as follows: We first stipulate a criterion of identity for a special kind of objects; call them cardinal numbers. That certain fundamental truths about these objects are established on the basis of a stipulation guarantees that our knowledge of those truths is knowledge a priori. This is to be contrasted with an account which would seek to infer the aprioricity of our knowledge of arithmetic from theses about meaning or truth in virtue of meaning. The neo-Fregean account does not depend on a traditional notion of analyticity; since neo-Fregeanism demands only the relatively uncontentious concession of the aprioricity of a stipulation, it can claim that its explanation of the aprioricity of arithmetic need not address the difficulties associated with defending traditional conceptions of analyticity. The fact that the reduction to Frege arithmetic requires more than a merely definitional extension of second order logic suggests an objection to neo-Fregean logicism that is closely related to the one we saw Benacerraf urge against to Hempel: how, one might ask, does the neo-Fregean account of the character of our knowledge of Frege arithmetic bear on our knowledge of ordinary arithmetic? In so far as the epistemological issues are issues concerning ordinary arithmetic, have they even been addressed by the neo-Fregean? There are two neo-Fregean answers to this objection. The first holds that it is because ordinary arithmetic can be “modeled” in Frege arithmetic that the epistemological status of the truths of Frege arithmetic is shared by the truths of ordinary arithmetic. Wright remarks (p. 322) that this answer is too weak. And although MacBride does not endorse this response, neither does he reject it as altogether unlikely. Nevertheless, I think it is worth recording exactly why such a straightforward answer, couched in terms of the relatively unproblematic relation of modeling, can’t be right.
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
99
It is clearly possible to stipulate the conditions that must obtain for the properties of a purely hypothetical and imaginary “abstract” physical system to hold without in any way committing ourselves to the existence — or even the dynamical possibility — of such a system. Our knowledge that such abstract systems are configured in accordance with our stipulations is no less a priori than our knowledge that, for example, the four element Boolean algebra has a free set of generators of cardinality one. But it sometimes happens that abstract configurations “model” actual configurations, in the sense that there is a correspondence between the elements of the two systems that preserves fundamental properties. It is clear that in such circumstances we take ourselves to know more than that an imaginary example has the properties we stipulate it to have: if the example is properly constructed, we know the dynamical behavior of a part of the physical world. But of course the fact that an actual system is “modeled” by our imaginary system, together with the fact that our knowledge of the properties of our imaginary system is a priori knowledge because it depends only on our free stipulations, are completely compatible with the claim, obvious to pre-analytic intuition, that our knowledge of the dynamical behavior of the actual system is a posteriori. Whatever role stipulation may have in fixing the properties of the abstract system by which the behavior of some real process is modeled, it lends no support to the idea — and would never be regarded as lending support to the idea — that our knowledge of the real process is knowledge a priori. There is a disanalogy between the number-theoretic case and our example that might seem to undermine its effectiveness as a criticism. In the numbertheoretic case the existence of the correspondence between ordinary numbers and the “Frege-numbers” that model them is known a priori. But the correspondence between the abstract system of our example and the actual system is not known a priori; it depends on the a posteriori knowledge that there are in reality configurations of particles having the postulated characteristics. This is of course entirely correct. However it is of no use to the neo-Fregean, since to know a priori that there is a mapping between the ordinary numbers and the Frege-numbers it is necessary to have a priori knowledge of the existence of the domain and co-domain of the mapping. To be of any use to the neo-Fregean, the fact that the Frege-numbers model the ordinary numbers therefore requires that our knowledge of the ordinary numbers be a priori. But if the modeling of the ordinary numbers by the Frege-numbers presupposes that our knowledge of the ordinary numbers is a priori, it cannot be part of a non-circular account of why ordinary arithmetic is known a priori. The general point may be put as follows: the fact that M models N , so that for any sentence s, s is true in M if and only if s is true in N , does not entitle us to infer that because the sentences true in M are known a priori, the sentences true in N are known a priori. Indeed it is perfectly possible that (with the obvious exception of the logical truths) our knowledge of sentences true in N is wholly a posteriori. So even if we grant that an assumption rich
100
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
enough to secure an infinity of objects is correctly represented as a stipulation, it remains unclear how the neo-Fregean can use this fact to answer the question which motivates his account of arithmetical knowledge — it remains unclear how it yields an account of our knowledge of the numbers, knowledge that we have independently of the neo-Fregean analysis. Let us turn now to the second neo-Fregean reply. This is an alternative to the response based on modeling. Here the idea is that since Frege arithmetic captures the “patterns of use” exhibited by our ordinary number-theoretic vocabulary, both in pure cases and in applications, we are justified in inferring not merely that the Frege-numbers model the ordinary numbers but that the Fregenumbers are the ordinary numbers, and that, therefore, the epistemic status of Frege arithmetic can illuminate the epistemic character of ordinary arithmetic. Frege arithmetic is justified as a reconstruction if it captures the fundamental features of the judgements — pure and applied — that we make about the numbers. But to support the epistemological claim of the neo-Fregean, the reconstruction must not only capture arithmetical concepts by recovering the patterns of use to which they conform, it must also illuminate the epistemic status of our pure arithmetic knowledge. Having the status of a stipulation is not, of course, a characteristic of Hume’s principle that is recoverable from our use of our arithmetical vocabulary, but is something the neo-Fregean reconstruction imposes on the principle in order to illuminate the basis for our knowledge of the propositions derivable from it. But it is unclear what follows from having captured the pattern of use of an expression by a principle that, in the reconstruction of the knowledge claims in which that expression figures, is regarded as a stipulation. The implicit — and undefended — neo-Fregean assumption is that we may suppose that the epistemological characteristics of a stipulation are shared by the knowledge claims that are reconstructed as following from it. But to establish that the epistemic basis for our unreconstructed arithmetical judgements resides in the stipulative character the neo-Fregean analysis assigns to Hume’s principle, it is not enough to show that Frege arithmetic captures patterns of use. The essential point is not all that different from what we have already noted when discussing the response based on modeling and can be appreciated by an example that is not all that different from the one cited in that connection. To see this, suppose the world were Newtonian. We could then give a reconstruction of our knowledge of the mechanical behavior of bodies by laying down Newton’s laws as stipulations governing our use of the concepts of force, mass and motion.19 But the fact that in our reconstruction the basic Newtonian laws have the status of stipulations would never be taken to show that they are in any interesting sense examples of a priori knowledge. Why then should the fact that the neo-Fregean represents Hume’s principle as a stipulation be taken to show that arithmetic is known a priori? The neo-Fregean reconstruction of the patterns of use of expressions of arithmetic leaves the epistemic status of the basic laws of arithmetic as unsettled as
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
101
it was on the suggestion that Frege arithmetic merely models ordinary arithmetic. Neither reconstruction supports the epistemological claim of the neoFregean to have accounted for the aprioricity of our knowledge of arithmetic. Whether that account is put forward as a theory within which ordinary arithmetic can be modeled, or whether it is said to capture the patterns of use of our number-theoretic vocabulary, it fails to have the direct bearing on the epistemic basis of our arithmetical knowledge that the neo-Fregean supposes it to have. Showing that Hume’s principle is correctly represented as a stipulation may be one route to securing it as a truth known a priori, but it is questionable whether, proceeding in this way, the task of revealing the proper basis for the aprioricity of arithmetic is made any easier than it would be by general reflection on why its basic laws are plausibly represented as known truths. Hale and Wright have replied to this argument: Let ‘Newton’ denote the conjunction of Newton’s laws as ordinarily understood, and ‘NewStip’ denote the (perhaps typographically indistinguishable) conjunction of the corresponding stipulations taken as introducing certain concepts of force, mass and motion. Then Demopoulos’s claim is — or ought to be, if the parallel is to be damaging — that while we may, by laying down NewStip, acquire some a priori knowledge (in some sense, knowledge about (some things we are calling) force, mass and motion), we obviously do not thereby acquire a priori knowledge of Newton — as we ought to do, if we can, in just or essentially the same fashion, acquire a priori knowledge of truths of ordinary arithmetic by stipulating Hume’s Principle, etc. . . . [But clearly,] the mere possibility of regarding (the sentences which formulate) Newton’s laws as stipulations introducing concepts of force mass and motion (as distinct from generalisations to which bodies conform) does not, and cannot, by itself justify the claim that NewStip ‘captures a pattern of use’ exhibited by ‘ordinary’ statements of Newtonian dynamics.20
But it was never claimed that regarding Newton’s laws as stipulations is what justifies the contention that NewStip captures a pattern of use. Since what justifies the contention that Frege arithmetic preserves a pattern of use is that it recovers the deductive structure of a body of pure and applied unreconstructed knowledge claims, the point at issue is whether, by representing certain principles as recoverable from a stipulation, a reconstruction sheds any light on their epistemic status. The comparison with the Newtonian case makes it transparent that from the fact that we can recover a pattern of use from a stipulation, nothing follows regarding the aprioricity or otherwise of our knowledge of the principles being reconstructed. The situation is, of course, entirely different if, in accordance with the methodology of Fregean logicism, it had proved possible to recover arithmetic from logic plus explicit definitions.
5.
Securing the truth of Hume’s principle
However sound the contrast of the methodology of concept introduction by an abstraction principle with ordinary axiomatization, the characterization of a fundamental principle like Hume’s as a kind of stipulation is certainly reminiscent of Hilbert’s account of his axioms as implicit definitions. In his correspon-
102
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
dence with Hilbert and in (the first of) his series of essays on the foundations of geometry,21 Frege argued that by treating axioms as definitions Hilbert precluded taking them to express truths in the intended and “generally accepted” sense, since if Hilbert’s axioms are genuine axioms, and therefore for Frege, are not merely true but known to be true, then the reference of their constituent expressions must be settled independently of the axioms themselves. Hilbert’s response consisted in resisting the notion that his axioms express truths, arguing that they need only be susceptible of an interpretation under which (as we might say) “they come out true.”22 A curious feature of this debate is that Frege’s own suggestion for approaching the question of reference to abstract objects in terms of the context principle and the use of one or another contextual definition seems vulnerable to the same circularity with which he charged Hilbert over the matter of treating axioms as implicit definitions.23 There is even a sense in which Frege’s application of the context principle to contextual definitions, requiring, as it does, that contextual definitions are true simpliciter — “absolutely true,” as opposed to merely “true under an interpretation”— is a more appropriate target of these criticisms than Hilbert’s use of the doctrine of implicit definition. And indeed, the role of Hume’s principle in Frege’s ana lysis of our reference to the numbers appears no less ambiguous than the role Hilbert assigned to axioms. Frege had argued, against Hilbert, that treating axioms as definitions puts us in the position of having a single equation with two unknowns; but we might equally well ask, regarding a comparable circularity inFrege’s own methodology, how it is possible to know of Hume’s principle that it is true if we have not first specified the reference of its constituent expressions. The difficulty confronting a development of Frege’s philosophy of arithmetic which relies on the contextual definition and the context principle is that it requires Hume’s principle to fulfill roles that are typically in tension with one another. It must, first of all, be a substantive truth, one which implies the basic laws of arithmetic and forms the philosophical basis of our knowledge of them, a point which may be put by saying that it is the principle’s account of our application of the numbers in cardinality judgements which underlies our knowledge of their infinity. Secondly, it is supposed to give the sense of the cardinality operator — a function usually reserved for definitions, or, in any case, for sentences which are stipulated or laid down. I believe there is a way of understanding the truth of Hume’s principle which addresses both the ambiguity of its status as a stipulation vs. a substantive claim and the apparent circularity in Frege’s methodology — without, however, having to accept the conventionalist features of Hale and Wright’s account. In order to motivate this suggestion, it will be worthwhile to reflect, for a moment, on a feature of our ordinary model-theoretic analysis of logical truth, according to which a logical truth is one that is true in all models. Even though this analysis appeals to truth-in-a-model, and therefore assumes the notion of interpretation or reference, in the case of the logical truths this dependence turns out to be inessential, since the holding of a logical truth in
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
103
some particular model does not distinguish that model from any other structure. By contrast, an ordinary mathematical truth, such as the commutative law of group theory, holds precisely in those structures which are commutative groups. Hence, the truth-in-a-model of a mathematical law, as opposed to a logical law, depends essentially on the reference of (at least one of) its constituent expressions. Thus, even though the use of the model-theoretic framework to explain the truth(-in-a-model) of a statement requires the notion of reference, it allows that the situation is importantly different according to whether we are considering logical or non-logical truths; briefly put, the logical truths make no “special” demands on reference. This is one way of spelling out the topic-neutrality of logical truth in a model-theoretic setting. To put the point another way: the referential demands of the logical truths are reflected in the model-theoretic framework as a whole, rather than in any part of it. It is in this sense that the topic-neutrality of the logical truths shows them to have a special status vis a´ vis the existential commitments of the model-theoretic framework: the account of the logical truths requires only the minimal existential commitment that any model would meet. Logical truths are sometimes said to be “constitutive principles” in the sense that, together with principles of inference, they are constitutive of the meanings of the logical operators. But the topic-neutrality of the logical truths that emerges within our model-theoretic setting affords a slightly different and somewhat more traditional way of viewing their a priori character. Since the logical truths fail to distinguish one model from another — since every model is constrained to satisfy them — their truth is independent of the particular model in which the truth or otherwise of sentences of whatever character is being evaluated. In particular, the holding of the logical truths in a structure is independent of whether or not it models the facts of experience. The aprioricity which the topic-neutrality of the truths of logic supports can be plausibly extended to the epistemic status of Hume’s principle without, however, requiring that we take a stand on the vexed question of whether Hume’s principle is a logical truth. Although there are of course models in which Hume’s principle fails, we will simply assume that any model which contains sortal concepts, interrelated as our sortal concepts are, allows for the “unrestricted” application24 of the cardinality operator, thereby generating the “skeleton” of concepts deployed by Frege in the proof of his theorem. By a skeleton of concepts we mean any family of sortal concepts F defined over a domain D together with an assignment to each F in of an element of D (“F ’s number”) such that The concepts under which the numbers assigned to concepts themselves fall belong to ; is closed under finite concepts, where the notion of finiteness may be any one of the several weak notions of finiteness (e.g., Kuratowskifiniteness) adapted to the case of concepts;
104
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
For any concepts F and G belonging to , the number of F s is the same as the number of Gs if and only if F and G are in one-one correspondence. Any model containing a skeleton of concepts also contains “the” cardinal numbers and the concepts associated with them in the development of Frege’s proof of his theorem. Even if we never achieve a complete specification of the model which the world comprises, it would suffice, so far as this account of our knowledge of arithmetic is concerned, that we should know of any candidate that it is constrained in this way. Under these circumstances Hume’s principle is true — not just consistent, not just true in some model or other, but true in that model, truth in which coincides with truth. But Hume’s principle is not merely true in a model that represents our absolute concept of truth: it would be true in any model containing a skeleton of concepts. Its generality consists in the fact that it holds in every such structure, whether or not the structure models the facts of experience. The correctness of Frege’s analysis of numerical identity in terms of the cardinality operator and the relation of oneone correspondence is a feature of every family of sortal concepts belonging to a possible model for our conceptual structure. Hume’s principle therefore enjoys a status in the class of models containing such skeletons of concepts which is entirely analogous to the status of the truths of logic in the class of all models. Just as a logical truth makes no demand on truth and reference which is not already implicit in every other truth, the referential demands of the truth of Hume’s principle are held in common by every truth, and in analogy with the truth of the laws of logic and the model-theoretic framework, its truth is reflected in our conceptual framework as a whole. It might be thought that if Hume’s principle is true, we are justified, by the context principle, in holding to a limited realism concerning the cardinal numbers. But the realism to which we are entitled fails to be a complete vindication of Frege’s program because the basic laws of arithmetic derivable from Hume’s principle allow us to capture the natural numbers at most only up to isomorphism; in particular, using only the resources of the context principle and the contextual definition, we are unable to characterize “the” cardinal numbers. There is therefore a sense in which the realism concerning the numbers which these considerations vindicate is attenuated relative to that which attaches to realism regarding the physical world: we do not think of the furniture of the world as specifiable only up to isomorphism but regard it as something we will have captured uniquely, should we succeed in characterizing the model which the physical world comprises. Frege seems also to have partially conceded this qualification when he sought an account of the numbers that would single out one natural sequence of numbers25 from all the rest by characterizing the numbers as extensions which comprehend all their applications. But if the numbers are captured only “structurally,” there is a certain conventionalism which attaches to the assertion of their existence: as far as the basic laws of arithmetic derived from Hume’s principle are concerned, any ω-sequence
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
105
will serve as the sequence of natural numbers; but this is a feature without parallel in our conception of the constituents of the physical world. A complete vindication of Fregean realism would require being able to distinguish “the” natural numbers, something demanding resources going beyond the contextual definition.26 Nevertheless, we have achieved something more than the conclusion that the contextual definition is merely true-in-a-structure. We have explained how it might be seen as true; as such, it would have a distinguished status among mathematical principles, as would the referential commitments of its constituent expressions.
6.
The philosophical interest of Frege Arithmetic
Leaving aside the historical question of Frege’s view in Grundlagen, I am claiming that a novel and plausible philosophy of arithmetic is at least suggested by the work, one which is both separable from his logicism and free of the conventionalism of later developments. On this interpretation of Hume’s principle, the significance of Frege’s theorem is this: the contextual definition is a constraint on the classes of models that are capable of adequately representing the structure of our sortal concepts, the relation of numerical identity and our absolute notion of truth, a constraint which bears a direct analogy to that imposed by the logical truths on the class of all structures. It is not, however, a constraint which is arbitrarily laid down, like a stipulation governing the introduction of a new concept. Rather, the sense in which the contextual definition is “definitional” is that it advances an analysis of a concept in use, namely our preanalytic notion of numerical identity. The argument for the correctness of this analysis depends on several important and non-trivial intermediate conclusions which are argued for throughout the course of Grundlagen. The most significant of these are: (i) the fundamental thought of §46, according to which a statement of number involves the predication of something of a concept; (ii) the assumption that the numbers are arguments to concepts of first level and that the cardinality operator is therefore properly interpreted by a type-lowering function; and (iii) the contention that as many as and, therefore, sameness of number are to be understood in terms of one-one correspondence. By Frege’s theorem, in order for any such structure to satisfy Hume’s principle, it must contain “the” numbers. The existence of the numbers — the “limited realism” of this view — is justified to the degree that we are justified in assuming the correctness of this analysis and of the supposition that our notion of truth is modeled by a structure in which it is reflected. Putting to one side the problem of establishing the aprioricity of arithmetic on a correct basis, a compelling argument that Frege arithmetic captures preanalytic intuitions about the numbers can be marshaled: Since the DedekindPeano axioms codify our pure arithmetical knowledge, their derivability constitutes a condition of adequacy which any account of our knowledge of number should fulfill. By Frege’s theorem, Frege arithmetic fulfills this condition
106
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
of adequacy. But what makes Frege arithmetic an interesting analysis of the concept of number is that it not only yields the Dedekind-Peano axioms, it derives them from an account of the role of the numbers in our judgements of cardinality — from our foremost application of the numbers. As such, it is arguably a compelling philosophical analysis of the concept of number.27 Once the project of securing a correct analysis is divorced from the project of securing a body of truths as analytic or a priori, neither the fact that Frege arithmetic satisfies our condition of adequacy nor the fact that it connects the pure theory of arithmetic with its applications — essential as each is to securing it as a correct analysis of number — directly addresses the question of the epistemic status of our knowledge of arithmetic. This conclusion is not particularly surprising. The neo-Fregean program of Hale and Wright is a variant on the methodology of reconstruction associated with Carnap. For Carnap the thesis that arithmetical knowledge is non-factual, and therefore, a priori, was not in serious doubt. Since the aim of a Carnapian reconstruction is simply to delimit more precisely the extension of a predicate, it cannot be expected of such a reconstruction of our arithmetical knowledge that it will in any way justify the claim that our knowledge of arithmetic is a species of a priori knowledge. It is precisely in respect of their epistemological significance that Fregean logicism and neo-Fregean logicism — reduction to logic by explicit definition vs. the Hale-Wright reconstruction in which Hume’s principle occurs as a non-definitional stipulation — come apart. Although I have appealed to the notion analytic of, arguing that Hume’s principle is analytic of the notion of numerical identity, I have said nothing of its status as an analytic truth. Indeed, I have conceded that Hume’s principle need not be regarded as a truth of logic and have thereby renounced one means of securing its analyticity. I have also argued that it is not a mere convention because it fails to possess the triviality of a stipulation — something which the traditional use of the doctrine of analyticity was supposed to support. On the present account, Hume’s principle is a general truth, not just in the sense that it holds universally of everything in the relevant domain of quantification, but in the stronger sense that it is true in every “world,” i.e. in every model which is capable of representing our conceptual structure. While it is possible to introduce a notion of analyticity according to which a principle like Hume’s would come out analytic insofar as it satisfies this notion of generality, it is unclear what would be gained from doing so. Certainly there is nothing in such a notion of analyticity that would justify the usual conclusions that have been thought to follow from such a characterization: e.g., it would not follow that the principle is trivial and it would not follow that it is without existential commitment or “factual content.” The plausibility of the idea that Hume’s principle is analytic of the concept of numerical identity depends on the plausibility of a conceptual analysis; but the truth of the principle that expresses this analysis depends on the presuppositions of the framework of which the analysis is an analysis. These presuppositions are rather strong, and it is on
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
107
their satisfaction, rather than its analyticity of the relation of numerical identity, that the truth of Hume’s principle depends. How, then, are we to answer the question, ‘Is Hume’s principle analytic’? We should answer “Yes,” if our goal is to emphasize that the principle expresses the result of a conceptual analysis. The significance of such a positive answer is that it vindicates an important methodology, the method of analysis exhibited in Grundlagen, the first great work of the analytic tradition. If, however, the point of the question is to suggest that the principle is distinguished in some manner other than what is implied by its generality — that it is a convention of language or without significant existential presupposition — our answer must be “No.”
7.
A foundation for arithmetic?
By way of conclusion, it might be appropriate to address a concern Dummett has expressed, if only to further clarify what is and is not achieved by the view defended here. According to Dummett, Frege’s approach to the numbers is fundamentally misguided. Russell’s discovery of the contradiction in Frege’s theory of classes served only to bring the difficulty into sharper focus. But Frege’s basic approach would have been problematic even if no inconsistency had been discovered, since there is an unacceptable circularity in Frege’s procedure: the abstraction principle which introduces the numbers contains an implicit first order quantifier, so the numbers introduced on the left occur within the range of the (first order) variables bounded on the right in the explicit definition of one-one correspondence. Moreover, this feature is essential if Hume’s principle is to support the proof of the infinity of the number sequence, since that proof turns on the possibility of forming, for each n, a concept under which the numbers up to (and including) n all fall. But this is possible only if the numbers fall within the range of the first order variables, otherwise we will not have allowed for the formation of the concepts on which the success of the argument depends. Hence, if it is to support the proof of Frege’s theorem, Hume’s principle would seem to require that the numbers are “given to us” independently of the abstraction principle or contextual definition which introduces them — contrary to the promise of the neo-Fregean’s “abstractionist” methodology that it would replace the metaphor of the numbers as something “ostended in intuition” with an altogether different and nonmetaphorical account of our knowledge of them. Dummett concludes28 that not only Frege, but also neo-Fregeans who have succeeded him, are unable to solve the two problems to which logicism originally directed its attention: to secure the existence of the objects of number theory, and to show what our conception of a countably infinite domain rests upon, without in either case relying on an appeal to intuition or the facts of experience. Does our account fare any better? To see in what sense it does, it is necessary to distinguish two rather different ways of viewing the significance of Frege’s theorem. If we think of the proof as exhibiting a “construction”29 of the numbers, then in order to avoid circularity,
108
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
it would be illegitimate to assume at an “earlier” stage of the construction the existence of numbers which arise only at some “later” stage of the construction. If, however, we view the proof less ambitiously, as a verification that Hume’s principle implies the Dedekind infinity of the numbers, so that we are therefore justified in claiming of it both that it captures a central feature of our notion of number and that it reveals the assumptions on which our conception of their infinity may be based, then there can be no circle. In fact, we may take the practice of recovering a central feature of a concept in use by revealing the assumptions on which our use of the concept depends as a characterization of what traditionally passes for a conceptual analysis. Thus understood, Frege’s theorem confirms that his analysis of numerical identity in terms of Hume’s principle is a compelling solution to the second of the two problems Dummett poses, that of explaining how we attain the concept of a countably infinite domain. Of course the Dedekind infinity of the numbers can be obtained directly from Dedekind’s and Peano’s well-known axiomatizations. Indeed, if the concepts over which the variables of Hume’s principle range are restricted to (the Kuratowski-) finite concepts, Frege arithmetic is equivalent to the DedekindPeano axiomatization. What is the advantage of Frege’s development of arithmetic from Hume’s principle? The answer, I think, is that by contrast with Dedekind and Peano, Frege derives the number-theoretic or pure properties of the numbers from an analysis of our applications of them in judgements of cardinality. By being based on the fundamental thought — the thought that a statement of number involves the predication of something of a concept — Frege’s account shows how a mathematical analysis such as Dedekind’s or Peano’s arises out of the most common everyday applications we make of the numbers. Such an account ties our conception of the numbers to our conception of families of sortal concepts and the interconnections of which they are capable, and in so doing, locates the origin of our conception of number in the character of our conceptual framework. But what of Dummett’s first problem? Have we given up on securing the existence of the numbers? If Hume’s principle is regarded as a conceptual analysis of our arithmetical knowledge, it presupposes rather than vindicates the existential commitments of what we take ourselves to know. Such an analysis can clarify the nature and extent of those commitments, and it can clarify the assumptions from which they derive, but it may still fall short of persuading someone who, for whatever reason, denies the existence of the numbers. We have simply not addressed the question whether it is coherent to deny the existential assumptions which, on the analysis on offer, the analysandum presupposes. Our account does not yield what Dummett has called a “suasive argument”30 for the existence of the numbers. At best, it affords an explanation of how it is possible to arrive at a conception of the natural number sequence, an explanation that is based on our applications of numbers to concepts. It is only in this sense that our account affords a foundation for arithmetic, a sense
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
109
which falls short of one that would secure our arithmetical knowledge against someone who would question the existential commitments it presupposes. But although such an explanation falls short of the traditional foundational justification Dummett is demanding, it may be said in its defense that it is not at all clear how anything stronger could be achieved.
Notes 1. In this connection, see J. Alberto Coffa, “Russell and Kant,” Synthese 46 (1981) 247–263. 2. “Frege: The Last Logicist,” reprinted in my collection Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics, pp. 42 and 46. 3. C. G. Hempel, “On the Nature of Mathematical Truth,” Hilary Putnam and Paul Benacerraf (eds.), The Philosophy of Mathematics: Selected Readings, second ed. (Cambridge University Press, 1983). 4. Wright (1983). 5. This had been observed by Charles Parsons about 20 years earlier in his paper “Frege’s Theory of Number,” reprinted in his Mathematics in Philosophy, Cornell University Press, 1983 and in Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics. So far as I am aware, the terminology “partial contextual definition” originates with Parsons. 6. Hale (1987). 7. So-called because in Grundlagen §63, Frege quotes from Hume: We are possest of a precise standard, by which we can judge of the equality and proportion of two numbers; and according as they correspond or not to that standard, we determine their relations without any possibility of error. When two numbers are so combin’d as that one has always an unite answering to every unite of the other, we pronounce them equal; and ‘tis for want of such a standard of equality in extension, that geometry can scarce be esteem’d a perfect and infallible science (Treatise I, iii, I para. 5).
It should be noted that Hume used ‘unite’ in roughly our sense of element; and by “combining” (comparing) two numbers, Hume meant what we would today call the comparison of two sets; to “pronounce them equal” is therefore to pronounce the two sets equal in size (rather than to assert their identity). (Many thanks to John Corcoran for these observations.) This may remove some of the irony of calling so fundamental a principle of Grundlagen, “Hume’s principle,” since it would show that Hume was not committed to the “featureless units” theory of numbers attacked in Grundlagen §§29–39. However, this use of ‘number’ (in the sense of ‘plurality’) is not an exact match of our use of ‘set’ since, at the very least, it misses the empty set and singletons and is therefore subject to an objection exactly analogous to one raised (in Grundlagen §28) to the thesis that numbers, in our sense of ‘number,’ are sets, in the sense of ‘plurality.’ ‘Hume’s principle’ should, therefore, be taken with a grain of salt. 8. “Is Hume’s Principle Analytic?” (Wright (1999), reprinted in The Reason’s Proper Study (Hale and Wright (2001)). Unless otherwise indicated, page references to Hale and Wright are to this volume. 9. In particular, both George Boolos and Michael Dummett have advanced a number of criticisms of the neo-Fregean program, prompting important clarifications of its interpretation of Hume’s principle and of the methodology of concept formation via “abstraction principles,” of which Hume’s principle and our concept of number are the primary examples. (References are given below.) Wright’s responses, “On the Philosophical Significance of Frege’s Theorem,” “On the Harmless Impredicativity of N= (‘Hume’s Principle’),” and “Response to Dummett,” are reprinted in The Reason’s Proper Study. 10. The first bad company objection was urged by Dummett in Frege: Philosophy of Mathematics, Harvard University Press, 1991; it is elaborated in his “Neo-Fregeans: In Bad Company?” (in Matthias Schirn (ed.), Philosophy of Mathematics Today (Oxford University Press, 1998). The second (as well as the first) was presented by Boolos in “The Standard of Equality of Numbers” (reprinted in Boolos’s Logic, Logic and Logic, Harvard University Press, 1998, and in my collection). 11. As shown by Boolos in “The Consistency of Frege’s Foundations of Arithmetic,” reprinted in Logic, Logic and Logic and Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics. 12. Whether this is the theory of pure second order logic or the theory of second order logic with a single function symbol N of mixed type, one whose intended interpretation is that of a map from concepts to objects. It is Hume’s principle that makes N a cardinality function capable of supporting definitions of immediately precedes and zero which satisfy the basic laws of arithmetic.
110
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
13. “Implicit Definition and the A Priori,” reprinted in The Reason’s Proper Study. 14. See Wright (pp. 289–293). The restriction to the full power set is necessary, since there is a Henkin model with an infinite domain in which NP is true; in this model the domain of the concept variables is also countable: Take as domain the natural numbers N and (identifying a concept with its extension) let the domain S(N) of the concept variables be {F: F is a finite or cofinite subset of N}. Observe, by the way, that S(N) is a field of sets just like P(N) — the power set of N. Now define n(F) by the condition n(F) = 0 if F is finite and n(F) = 1 if F is cofinite. Clearly the equivalence relation of NP — F and G are equivalent if their symmetric difference is finite — makes F and G equivalent if and only if F and G are both finite or both cofinite, so they will be assigned different values by n only when one is finite and the other is cofinite. (Proof: Obvious that if F and G are both finite or cofinite, F and G are equivalent, since in both cases we are dealing with a union of intersections, each of which is finite. For the contrapositive, take F finite and G cofinite. Then the complement of F is cofinite. But the intersection of two cofinite sets is cofinite, and the union of a cofinite set with any set is infinite. Hence F and G are inequivalent, and thus must be assigned distinct objects.) 15. Essentially the same point has been made by Boolos — although in a different context — in his “Is Hume’s Principle Analytic?” (in Richard Heck (ed.) Language, Thought and Logic: Essays in Honour of Michael Dummett (Oxford University Press, 1998); see especially, p. 253). 16. See, for example, “Is Hume’s Principle Analytic?,” p. 318. 17. In this connection, compare the penultimate paragraph of Wright’s “Is Hume’s Principle Analytic?” 18. “Finite Hume,” Philosophia Mathematica 8 (2000) 150–159, and “Can Nothing Matter?,” Analysis 62 (2002) 125–134. 19. There are of course well-known historical examples along these lines. Cp. Ernst Mach’s The Science of Mechanics (Open Court: 1960, sixth American edition, translated by Thomas J. McCormack), whose famous definition of mass (p. 266) even has the form of an abstraction principle. Thanks to Peter Clark for calling my attention to Mach’s rational reconstruction of Newtonian mechanics. 20. “Responses to Commentators,” Philosophical Books 44 (2003) 245–263, pp. 248–249. 21. “On the Foundations of Geometry: First Series,” translated by Eike-Henner W. Kluge, and collected in Gottlob Frege: Collected Papers on Mathematics, Logic, and Philosophy, Brian McGuinness (ed.), Basil Blackwell, 1984. 22. See Hilbert to Frege, 29.xii.99, draft or excerpt by Hilbert. In Brian McGuinness (ed.), Gottlob Frege: The Philosophical and Mathematical Correspondence, Hans Kaal, tr., University of Chicago Press, 1980. For a discussion of the issues raised by this correspondence, see my paper, “Frege, Hilbert, and the Conceptual Structure of Model Theory,” History and Philosophy of Logic 15 (1994) 211–225. 23. This point is made by Dummett in Frege: Philosophy of Language, Duckworth and Harvard University Press, 1973, p. 654. 24. I.e., restricted in its application only by the demand that the concepts to which it applies are sortal concepts. 25. For Frege, the natural sequence of numbers is the sequence, 0, 1, . . . ℵ0 , which is contrasted with the sequence of natural numbers, 0, 1, . . . . 26. As is well-known, this is what led to Frege’s explicit definition of the numbers in terms of classes of equinumerous concepts. 27. Wright has observed that one can show that the Frege-number of Fs = n if, and only if, there are, in the intuitive sense of the numerically definite quantifier, exactly n Fs. See The Reason’s Proper Study, p. 251 and pp. 330ff. 28. See Dummett, “Neo-Fregeans: In Bad Company?,” pp. 369 and 381. 29. Perhaps after the manner of the method of “domain extension” which Mark Wilson has argued was suggested to Frege by the work of von Staudt and others. See his “To Err is Humean,” Philosophia Mathematica Series III 7 (1999) 247–257. The historical background is developed more fully in his “Frege: The Royal Road to Geometry,” reprinted in Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics. 30. “The Justification of Deduction,” in Truth and Other Enigmas, Harvard University Press, 1978, 290–318, cf. esp. pp. 295ff.
References Benacerraf, P. (1995), “Frege: The Last Logicist,” in: Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics, W. Demopoulos (ed.), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 41–67.
The Neo-Fregean Program in the Philosophy of Arithmetic
111
Boolos, G. (1987), “The Consistency of Frege’s Foundations of Arithmetic,” in: On Being and Saying: Essays in Honor of Richard Cartwright, J. Thomson (ed.), The MIT Press, Cambridge, 3–20; reprinted in Boolos (1998) and Demopoulos (1995). Boolos, G. (1990) (ed.), “The Standard of Equality of Numbers,” in: Meaning and Method: Essays in Honor of Hilary Putnam, Cambridge University Press, 261–277; reprinted in Boolos (1998) and Demopoulos (1995). Boolos, G. (1997), “Is Hume’s Principle Analytic?,” in: Language, Thought, and Logic, R. G. Heck, Jr. (ed.) , Oxford University Press, New York, 245–261; reprinted in Boolos (1998) and Demopoulos (1995). Boolos, G. (1998), Logic, Logic, and Logic, Harvard University Press, Cambridge. Demopoulos, W. (1994), “Frege, Hilbert, and the Conceptual Structure of Model Theory,” in: History and Philosophy of Logic 15, 211–225. Demopoulos, W. (1995) (ed.), Frege’s Philosophy of Mathematics, Harvard University Press, Cambridge. Demopoulos, W. (1998), “The Philosophical Basis of our Knowledge of Number,” in: Noˆus 32, 481–503. Dummett, M. (1978), Truth and Other Enigmas, Harvard University Press, Cambridge. Dummett, M. (1991), Frege: Philosophy of Mathematics, Harvard University Press, Cambridge. Dummett, M. (1993), “Neo-Fregeans: In Bad Company?,” in: The Philosophy of Mathematics Today, M. Schirn (ed.), Clarendon Press, New York, 1998, 369–405; with a reply by C. Wright. Frege, G. (1950), Die Grundlagen der Arithmetik. Eine Logisch Mathematische Untersuchung u¨ ber den Begriff der Zahl, Basil Blackwell, Oxford. Frege, G. (1980), Philosophical and Mathematical Correspondence, University of Chicago Press. Frege, G. (1984), Collected Papers on Mathematics, Logic, and Philosophy, Basil Blackwell, Oxford; translated by M. Black, V. Dudman, P. Geach, H. Kaal, E. Kluge, B. McGuinness, and R. Stoothoff. Hale, B. (1987), Abstract Objects, Oxford University Press. Hale, B. and C. Wright (2001), The Reason’s Proper Study, Oxford University Press. Hale, B. and C. Wright (2003), “Responses to Commentators,” in: Philosophical Books 44, 245–263. Heck, R. G., Jr. (1999), “Grundgesetze der Arithmetik I §10,” in: Philosophia Mathematica 7, 258–292. Hempel, C. G. (1983), “On the Nature of Mathematical Truth,” in: The Philosophy of Mathematics: Selected Readings, second ed., H. Putnam and P. Benacerraf (ed.), Cambridge University Press, 377–393. Mac Bride, F. (2000), “Finite Hume,” in: Philosophia Mathematica 8, 150–159. Mac Bride, F. (2002), “Can nothing matter?,” in: Analysis 62, 125–134. Mach, E. (1960), The Science of Mechanics, sixth American edition, translated by T. J. McCormack, Open Court, New York. Parsons, C. (1983), Mathematics in Philosophy, Cornell University Press, Ithaca. Russell, B. (1903), The Principles of Mathematics, Allen and Unwin, London. Wilson, M. (1998), “To Err is Humean,” in: Philosophia Mathematica, 7, The George Boolos Memorial Symposium, Notre Dame IN, 247–257. Wright, C. (1983), Frege’s Conception of Numbers as Objects, Aberdeen University Press. Wright, C. (1997), “On the Philosophical Significance of Frege’s Theorem,” in: Language, Thought, and Logic; Essays in Honour of Michael Dummett, R. G. Heck, Jr. (ed.), Oxford University Press, New York, 201–244; reprinted in Hale and Wright (2001). Wright, C. (1998a), “On the Harmless Impredicativity of N= (‘Hume’s Principle’),” in: The Philosophy of Mathematics Today, M. Schirn (ed.), Clarendon Press, New York, 339–368; reprinted in Hale and Wright (2001).
112
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
Wright, C. (1998b), “Response to Dummett,” in: The Philosophy of Mathematics Today, M. Schirn (ed.), Clarendon Press, New York, 389–406; reprinted in Hale and Wright (2001). Wright, C. (1999), “Is Hume’s Principle Analytic?,” in: Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 40, 6–30; reprinted in Hale and Wright (2001). Wright, C. and B. Hale (2000), “Implicit Definition and the A Priori,” in: New Essays on the A Priori, P. Boghossian and C. Peacocke (ed.), Oxford University Press, 286–319; reprinted in Hale and Wright (2001).
¨ GODEL, REALISM AND MATHEMATICAL ‘INTUITION’∗ Michael Hallett McGill University, Montreal, Canada
G¨odel is perhaps the most notable modern mathematician whose writings on the philosophy of mathematics appeal both to a notion of mathematical intuition and also to the Critical Philosophy of Kant. (The others are Hilbert and Poincar´e, whose views will not be treated here.) The aim of the present programmatic remarks is to approach answers to two questions: the first is to establish more clearly what role, for G¨odel, ‘intuition’ is meant to play; the second is to establish, and perhaps delimit, the connection to Kant’s philosophy, about which G¨odel is at best enigmatic. Part of the point of the present paper is to make clear what G¨odel’s notion of intuition is not. In particular, it is important to say at the outset that, despite his use of the term ‘mathematical intuition’, what G¨odel is appealing to is not Kantian sensible intuition or an extension of it; neither is G¨odel (not to speak of this essay) attempting to provide a ‘reading’ of Kant’s Critical Philosophy. In particular, the important and interesting question of how precisely what G¨odel says fits in with Kant’s theory of mathematics or knowledge in general will not be addressed. Various remarks G¨odel makes (especially in his Dialectica paper of 1958 and its revision of 1972) show clearly that he regards Kantian sensible intuition (for example, in the way it was employed by Hilbert) as much too restrictive to be of service in attempting to understand the full scope of knowledge of modern mathematics. Furthermore, G¨odel can hardly be described as a transcendental idealist in Kant’s sense, but is rather a straightforward realist about mathemat∗A
relative of this paper was presented twice in the spring of 1983, at Oxford University and the former Chelsea College in the University of London, and then, in the spring of 1984, at McGill University. A version of the present incarnation was presented at the Dortmund Conference ‘Intuition in Mathematics and Physics’ in April, 2000. For comments, help and encouragement over the years, I am grateful to John Bell, Donald Gillies, Daniel Isaacson, Mosh´e Machover, Ian Gold, Olivia Hallett, Alison Laywine and Emily Carson. For comments at the Dortmund Conference, I am indebted to Robert DiSalle, Brigitte Falkenburg, Friedrich Fulda and Ulrich Majer. I wish to thank the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada for their generous support of my work.
113 E. Carson and R. Huber (eds.), Intuition and the Axiomatic Method, 113–131. © 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
114
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
ics in a fairly clear sense. G¨odel’s appeal to Kant is meant to underpin this realism, not to provide an alternative to it, and to this end he suggests extracting and modifying a particular element which he sees in Kant. Nevertheless, what G¨odel says is only loose and suggestive, and the main task here is to make a little more sense of it.
1.
G¨odel’s realism
The first part of our expository task will be to clarify the nature of G¨odel’s realism.1 G¨odel described himself as having been some form of ‘realist’ throughout his career. As against this, as Parsons has pointed out (Parsons (1995), 46), the explicit appeal to a relatively powerful notion of intuition does not emerge until much later in G¨odel’s philosophical writings, in fact in 1964 in the Supplement to the revised version of the famous paper on the continuum problem, i. e., G¨odel (1964), a revision of G¨odel (1947). Intuition itself is hardly mentioned before that point, although realism, in one form or another, is ever present. However, we will see that the guiding idea behind the appeal to Kantian notions in 1964 exists already in the central discussion of Russell published in 1944. G¨odel often presents realism in a fairly standard way. Consider these statements from his famous Gibb’s lecture of 1951, published only posthumously as G¨odel (*1951). (1) ‘[M]athematical objects and facts (or at least something in them) exist independently of our mental acts and decisions’ (p. 311); (2) ‘. . . the objects and theorems of mathematics are as objective and independent of our free choice and our creative acts as is the physical world’ (ibid., p. 312); (3) the concepts in a mathematical proposition ‘form an objective reality of their own, which we cannot create or change but only perceive and describe’ (ibid., p. 320); and lastly (4), this time from the revised version of the paper on the continuum problem, i. e., G¨odel (1964): ‘[T]he set-theoretical concepts and theorems describe some well-determined reality, in which Cantor’s conjecture must be either true or false’ (pp. 263–264, p. 260 in G¨odel (1990)). Note that these statements defend what one might call conceptual realism, as well as realism about ‘mathematical objects’. One thing that I will attempt to stress as the paper proceeds is that G¨odel’s views on intuition are meant in particular to play a role supplementary to this aspect of his realism. By way of a first elucidation of G¨odel’s realism, it is worth pointing out what he was reacting most strongly against. Perhaps the most important point of opposition in G¨odel’s conception is to the strong constructivist tendency to be found in Russell (especially Principia Mathematica), according to which most of mathematics is concerned with objects which we construct and which are not built into the fabric of the universe. (According to Russell’s Axiom of Infinity, there are infinitely many individuals, but the numbers and other mathematical objects are constructed by us in the hierarchy of types.) This opposition comes out (in 1944) in his attitude to ‘the’ Vicious Circle Principle, which G¨odel takes as correct only for one who
G¨odel, Realism and Mathematical ‘Intuition’
115
regards the objects of mathematics as being constructed. It is false, he argues, for one who, like himself, believes that the objects exist independently of us and who sees the purpose of mathematics as the description of the structures these objects partake in. This position is also opposed to the more general, although less precise, views of nineteenth century writers on the foundations of mathematics who promoted the view that mathematics is the result of our ‘free creation’. Certainly both Cantor and Dedekind come to mind. Neither of these writers saw themselves as constrained by what we would now call constructivist principles, although Cantor in particular always recognised certain constraints. In any case, the ‘free creation’ conception, vague as it is, does stress that the content of mathematical theories is in some sense created by us, that we have ‘free choice’ over it. To this, G¨odel was certainly opposed. Another important strand in G¨odel’s realism is hinted at in the second brief passage cited above, namely the comparison of mathematics with physics. One of the most striking (and famous) passages in G¨odel’s philosophical writings is the following from his essay on Russell which states G¨odel’s own view in opposition to Russell’s: Classes and concepts may, however, also be conceived as real objects, namely classes as “pluralities of things” or as structures consisting of a plurality of things and concepts as the properties and relations of things existing independently of our definitions and constructions. It seems to me that the assumption of such objects is quite as legitimate as the assumption of physical bodies, and there is quite as much reason to believe in their existence. They are in the same sense necessary for a satisfactory system of mathematics as physical bodies are for a satisfactory theory of our sense perceptions and in both cases it is impossible to interpret the propositions one wants to assert about these entities as propositions about the “data”, i. e., in the latter case the actually occurring sense perceptions. (G¨odel (1944), p. 137, p. 220 of Benacerraf and Putnam (eds.) (1964), or p. 128 of G¨odel (1990))
It is precisely with respect to this last view (the indispensability of the abstract notion of mathematical object) that G¨odel’s appeal to intuition plays a significant role, as we will see. Note that G¨odel’s realism is of a very strong form; if we ask ‘Realism with respect to which range of statements?’, the answer is: ‘Across all of set theory’, where G¨odel clearly regards set theory as embracing all of contemporary mathematics. When put together with what G¨odel says about facts existing ‘independently of us’, it is clear that, for G¨odel, any meaningful mathematical (set-theoretic) statement has a definite truth-value independently of our knowledge of that value. Let us call this, for want of a term, the phenomenon of completeness in truth-value. Not surprisingly, given this, G¨odel’s realistic attitude emerges most clearly with respect to incompleteness phenomena, i. e., with respect to statements which are demonstrably (or plausibly) neither provable nor refutable in very basic axiom systems (say, axiom systems for set theory or for arithmetic), in other words, the problem presented by basic axiom systems whose conse-
116
Intuition and the Axiomatic Method
quence relation does not match completeness in truth-value. Incompletenesses are basically of two sorts, consistency statements on the one hand, and, on the other, statements concerning genuinely unresolved mathematical questions like that surrounding the Continuum Hypothesis. Incompletenesses surrounding consistency statements were first discovered by G¨odel himself at the beginning of the 1930s; G¨odel showed that no standard mathematical system containing a certain (specifiable) modicum of number theory can demonstrate its own consistency. Why is this a surprise? G¨odel showed that, under these conditions, it is always possible (and this will be true even for highly complex and powerful systems, for example, the standard system for set theory) to code basic meta-mathematical notions (being a formula, being a proof) concerning the theory into basic arithmetic, and when this is done, one can easily form a statement which asserts its own unprovability in that theory. This statement, G¨odel showed, will be neither provable nor refutable in that theory, but will nevertheless be an arithmetical statement of a rather simple form, namely: ¬∃x[r = t], where r and t are quantifier free terms standing for natural numbers, and x is a variable over n-tuples of natural numbers. For these systems, therefore, no matter how powerful, there will always be simple arithmetical statements the correctness of which they will not be able to decide. Thus, G¨odel in effect showed that incompleteness phenomena of a very basic kind are virtually ubiquitous in mathematics. Secondly, the meta-mathematical statement of the consistency of a system T (call it ConsT ) also becomes an arithmetical one, closely related to the statement of self-unprovability. G¨odel’s Second Incompleteness Theore