Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Related titles from Woodhead’s food science, technology and nutrition list: Food chemical safety Volume 1: Contaminants (ISBN: 1 85573 462 1) This volume provides comprehensive information about contaminants in the food industry. The book opens with an explanation of risk analysis and analytical methods used for detecting contaminants in food products. This is followed by full details of relevant EU and USA regulations. The second part of the book provides information about specific contaminants. Food chemical safety Volume 2: Additives (ISBN: 1 85573 563 6) This volume provides comprehensive information about additives in the food industry. The book opens with an explanation of risk analysis and analytical methods in relation to the use of additives in food products. This is followed by full details of relevant EU and USA regulations. The second part of the book provides information about specific subjects including flavourings, sweeteners and colourings. Food process modelling (ISBN: 1 85573 565 2) A major trend within the food industry over the past decade has been the concern to measure, predict and control food processes more accurately in search for greater consistency, quality and safety in the final product. This book explores the current trends in modelling, their strengths and weaknesses and applications across the supply chain. It will be a valuable guide for production and technical managers within the food industry. Details of these books and a complete list of Woodhead’s food science, technology and nutrition titles can be obtained by: • visiting our web site at www.woodhead-publishing.com • contacting Customer services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext.30; address: Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge CB1 6AH, England)
If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles in this area, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail:
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry Second edition Edited by
Erika Kress-Rogers and Christopher J. B. Brimelow
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB1 6AH England www.woodhead.publishing.com Published in North and South America by CRC Press LLC 2000 Corporate Blvd, NW Boca Raton FL 33431 USA First published 2001, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC ß 2001, Woodhead Publishing Limited The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publishers. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited or CRC Press LLC for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing Limited ISBN 1 85573 560 1 CRC Press ISBN 0-8493-1223-X CRC Press order number: WP1223 Cover design by The ColourStudio Project managed by Macfarlane Production Services, Markyate, Hertfordshire (e-mail:
[email protected]) Typeset by MHL Typesetting Ltd, Coventry, Warwickshire Printed by TJ International, Padstow, Cornwall, England
Contents
Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . List of contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . List of symbols. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
xi xvii xxvii
1 Instrumentation for food quality assurance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Kress Rogers, ALSTOM, Ratingen 1.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.2 Challenging conditions for sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.3 Interpreting the readings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4 Measurement types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.5 Further reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Measurement types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 1 7 12 17 21 22 25
2 Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Hugi and E. Voirol, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne 2.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 The nature of sensory perception . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Sensory evaluation methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4 Sensory-instrumental relations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Summary and outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.6 Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
31
Part I In-line measurement for the control of food-processing operations . .
61
3 Principles of colour measurement for food . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. B. MacDougall, The University of Reading 3.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Colour vision: trichromatic detection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
63
31 32 36 41 56 58 59
63 64
vi
Contents 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
Influence of ambient light and food structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Colour description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Instrumentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
66 68 72 74 81 82
4 Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. J. B. Brimelow and P. Joshi, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne 4.1 Introduction: food colour and quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Colour measurement principles: brief introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Colour measurement methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Colour measurement of typical food materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
85 85 86 93 101 112 113
5 Sorting by colour in the food industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. M. Low, W. S. Maughan, S. C. Bee and M. J. Honeywood, Sortex Limited, London 5.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 What is a sorting machine? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Assessment of food particles for colour sorting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 The optical inspection system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Completing the sorting system . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 Future trends: computer vision systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.7 Using a colour sorter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.8 Further reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
117
6 Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology I. B. Benson and J. W. F. Millard, NDC Infrared Engineering, Maldon 6.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 Principles of measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 Instrumentation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.4 Applications in the food industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5 The power of process monitoring and trending . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.6 Practical considerations for implementing on-line measurement . . . . . 6.7 Conclusions and the future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
137
7 Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Ridley, Land Instruments International, Dronfield 7.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Radiation thermometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Measurement principles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4 Practical situations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5 Miscellaneous techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.6 Further reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
187
117 117 119 124 129 132 134 135
137 139 145 151 161 166 183 185
187 188 198 203 208 212
Contents
vii
8 In-line and off-line FTIR measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Reh, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2 Food applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3 Calibration and general aspects of routine use . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4 Conclusions and outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.5 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
213
9 Microwave measurements of product variables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Kent, Kent and Partner Scientific Services, Biggar 9.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2 Overview of microwave techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.3 Dielectric properties and their parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.4 Methods for measurement of dielectric properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.5 Dielectric properties and measurement of bulk density and composition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.6 Material structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.7 Apparatus for microwave measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.8 Sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.9 Areas for development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.10 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Some manufacturers of microwave moisture measurement instruments suitable for foodstuffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
233
10 Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control . . . . . . P. G. Berrie, Endress+Hauser Process Solutions AG, Reinach 10.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Pressure measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Temperature measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 General instrument design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.6 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
280
11 Level and flow measurement in food process control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P. G. Berrie, Endress+Hauser Process Solutions AG, Reinach 11.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 Level measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3 Flow measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.4 Process automation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.5 Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.6 Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.7 User organisations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
303
12 Ultrasonic instrumentation in the food industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . N. Denbow, ND Technical Marketing, Alresford 12.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2 Low-frequency techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.3 High-frequency techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.4 Contacts for further information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
326
213 219 227 228 229
233 234 235 245 251 260 261 268 272 273 277
280 281 287 295 299 302
303 303 310 316 322 323 325
326 327 336 352
viii
Contents 12.5 12.6
Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
13 Ultrasound propagation in foods and ambient gases: principles and applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Kress-Rogers, ALSTOM, Ratingen 13.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2 Overview of ultrasound applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.3 Speed of sound . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.4 Acoustic impedance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.5 Attenuation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.6 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.7 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix: Ultrasound measurement applications in and for the food industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
353 353 355 355 356 366 383 385 393 394 400
14 In-line and on-line rheology measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Roberts, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne 14.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.2 Requirements of an in-line or on-line sensor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3 In-line rheometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.4 In-line viscosity measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.5 Capillary (or tube) viscometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.6 Rotational viscometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.7 Vibrational viscometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.8 High-frequency rheometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.9 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.10 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
403
Part II Instrumental techniques in the quality control laboratory . . . . . . . . . .
423
15 Rheological measurements of foods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. M. McKenna and J. G. Lyng, University College Dublin 15.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.2 Relevance of rheological properties of foods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.3 Basic rheology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.4 Measurement systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.5 On-line measurement systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.6 Instrument selection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.7 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
425
16 Water activity and its measurement in food . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W. Ro¨del, Federal Centre for Meat Research, Kulmbach 16.1 Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.2 Significance of water activity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.3 Water activity levels in food and their control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.4 Measuring water activity level . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.5 Measurement techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
453
403 404 405 407 408 413 416 418 419 419
425 426 428 434 447 449 449
453 454 460 464 466
Contents
ix
16.6 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.7 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
474 474
17 Conductance/impedance techniques for microbial assay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. M. Gibson, BIODON International, Aberdeen 17.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2 Rapid microbiological methods: an overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.3 Principles of electrical conductance methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.4 Capacitance versus conductance measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.5 Instrument design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.6 The evaluation of conductance data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.7 Future possibilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
484
18 Modern methods of texture measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Kilcast, Leatherhead Food Research Association 18.1 Introduction: texture and food quality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.2 Perception of food texture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.3 Sensory assessment of texture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.4 Instrumental measurement of texture . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.5 In vivo texture measurement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.6 Future developments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.7 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
518
Part III Chemosensors, biosensors, immunosensors, electronic noses and tongues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Sensors for food flavour and freshness: electronic noses, tongues and testers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Kress-Rogers, ALSTOM, Ratingen 19.1 Introduction to flavour assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.2 Modelling the human nose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.3 The electronic nose . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.4 The electronic tongue . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.5 The marker chemical approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.6 In situ freshness monitor for frying oil (resonant viscosity probe) . . . 19.7 Knife-type meat freshness tester (glucose profiling biosensor) . . . . . . . 19.8 Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.9 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 Chemosensors, biosensors, immunosensors and DNA probes: the base devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Kress-Rogers, ALSTOM, Ratingen 20.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.2 Chemically sensitive semiconductor devices: solid-state sensors for pH, acidity, ions, gases and volatiles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.3 Amperometric, potentiometric and thermometric biosensors . . . . . . . . .
484 485 489 495 496 503 510 512
518 521 522 525 534 541 543 545
551 553 553 554 555 568 574 578 599 614 615 623 623 627 659
x
Contents 20.4 20.5 20.6 20.7
Chemically sensitive optical and acoustic devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Applying sensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Further reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
21 Biosensors for process monitoring and quality assurance in the food industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Schmidt and U. Bilitewski, National Research Centre for Biotechnology Ltd, Braunschweig 21.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.2 Principles of immunoanalysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.3 Detection of microorganisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.4 Microbial toxins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.5 Residue analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.7 Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
675 688 693 694 714 714 715 722 728 729 732 733 733
22 Commercial devices based on biosensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Warsinke, University of Potsdam, Golm and D. Pfeiffer and F. W. Scheller, BST Biosensor Technologie, Berlin 22.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.2 Principles of signal generation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.3 Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.4 Conclusions and future trends . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22.5 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
740
23 New biosensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Tothill, A. Piletsky, N. Magan and A. P. F. Turner, Cranfield University, Bedford 23.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.2 Novel sensing receptors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.3 Sensor arrays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.4 The electronic nose instrument . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.5 Genetically modified food . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.6 Commercial biosensors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.7 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23.8 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
760
Part IV Appendices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Appendix A: Glossary: terms in instrumentation and sensors technology . . Appendix B: Ancillary tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
777 779 800
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
817
740 740 747 756 756
760 761 766 766 768 769 771 771
Preface
The optimization of industrial food processing The enjoyable, everyday food in an industrialized society relies not only on agriculture and fishing but also on efficient food processing. Few people mill their own cereals, preserve and store their fruit and vegetables from harvest to consumption, churn their butter, ferment milk into yoghurt and cereals into beer, turn meat carcasses into joints, sausages and paˆte´s, or pound mustard seeds to prepare meal accompaniments. Few wish to restrict themselves to the local products in season and most prefer instead the variety that modern food production, processing and distribution can offer. Many use readyprepared meals so as to spend their evenings with the children or with friends rather than in the kitchen. In the early stages of the industrialization of food processing, the competition between manufactured goods centred mainly on the price at which they were offered; now quality and safety are in the foreground. A wider range of attractive food products has become affordable for a large proportion of the population through advances in food science and technology together with the development of a diverse range of efficient large-scale processing plant. Many traditional batch processes have now been replaced by automated production methods, helped by the introduction of advanced process control systems in the 1980s. The signal processing and actuating capacity of process control systems is now adequate. The full potential of these systems, however, can be realized only if they are supplied with full and up-to-date information on the process to allow feedback or feedforward control. The development and knowledgeable application of sensors and instruments have become the key elements in meeting the consumer’s expectations in the food industry to provide affordable, enjoyable, safe and nutritious products. This has prompted the development of a wider range of sensors and instruments suitable for on-line and at-line measurements in the food industry, and also of modern instruments for the quality control (QC) laboratory. Many of the new instruments rely on a complex interaction with the food in order to determine properties of the food itself (such as composition) during processing. They extend the range of data inputs for
xii
Preface
‘sensible’ process control (equipped with senses) well beyond the measurement of pressure, temperature, level and flow rate. Other new instruments widen the range of applications for the measurement of the established variables, now allowing the reliable measurement of flow rate or temperature in food processes where this was previously impossible. Progress has also been made in the development of instruments for the assessment of food freshness and food safety, so that results are now often available within a day and a higher proportion of food ingredients and products can be screened to ensure good manufacturing practice. In the choice of instrumentation, an analysis of the processing operation as a whole, together with an overview of the characteristics of the sensors and instruments available for on-line, at-line and QC laboratory measurements, will be the basis of optimum process control design. On-line and off-line instrumentation interlink in guiding process control and are therefore both included here. Calibration samples need to be chosen and correctly prepared, and a representative sampling technique and suitable reference methods must be selected. For the reliable installation, calibration and operation of the new instruments, and for the correct interpretation of their readings, it is essential to understand the principles underlying the functioning of the instruments, the properties of the food and its processing environment, and their interplay. This approach also helps in assessing the many novel sensors and instrumental techniques now emerging to provide better longterm planning of process control optimization.
Special application details for instrumentation Instrument engineers coming from the aerospace, defence, nuclear or petrochemical sectors sometimes underestimate the challenges of designing sensors and instruments for the food industry. They find adequate challenges for their skills when they encounter a wide range of temperatures, pressures and pH values; mixing paddles continuously scraping container walls where a sensor is to be mounted in contact with the product; the rejection of guards around fragile sensor components as germ traps; and a limitation of the choice of engineering materials to those compatible with food hygiene considerations. The occasional fracture of a sensor in the chemical industry may be an inconvenience; in the food industry it is a major incident when any sharp fragments, however small, are lost into the process stream, requiring the screening or safe disposal of many thousands of food product items. A standard procedure for the maintenance of hygienic conditions in food processing is cleaning-in-place (CIP). This may sound harmless enough, but the periodic flushing of the food processing system with hot caustic soda (NaOH) solutions or pressurized steam places restrictions on the design of contacting sensors, particularly in the development of chemical sensors. Instruments based on non-contact methods are especially attractive to the food industry, being both intrinsically hygienic and easy to maintain. Such instruments are covered in the first part of this book. In some applications, hostile conditions and restricted access to the contents of a process vessel are the main challenges, for example in a cooker extruder which allows the continuous production of intricately shaped and textured snack foods at a throughput rate of 400 kg/hour. High pressures, high temperatures, a feed/mixer screw scraping the interior surface of the heavy metal barrel and sometimes abrasive raw materials combine here to render the construction of reliable sensors difficult, even for pressure and food mix temperature.
Preface
xiii
More often, it is the variable and complex nature of the food itself that presents problems in the design and application of instruments. This is the case for non-contact volume and mass flow rate metering of many foods. The most interesting problems arise, however, in the measurement of food properties such as composition or rheology. An interdisciplinary approach is needed here to take account of the interaction between the instrumental method and the chemical and physical properties of the food and its environment (beyond the variables to be determined). This applies also to the assessment of food freshness or conversely to the determination and prediction of changes due to microbial activity or oxidative processes. A further aspect is the perception of the consumer which needs to be represented in instruments for the assessment of appearance and texture. A rapid accurate measurement is often needed to maintain specifications within narrow margins. A pH value or water activity above specifications could lead to food spoilage during storage and distribution; a deviation to lower values could reduce the palatability. Too little preservative could endanger food safety; too much would be unacceptable to many consumers. Too high a water content could be infringing legal requirements or be associated with a water activity above specifications (with implications for food stability); too little water could result in an unattractive texture and an uncompetitive price for the food product. Line speeds in automated continuous food processing and packaging are high, and this is both a motivation for the application of on-line instrumentation (or of rapid at-line methods) and a challenge in the design of instruments for this purpose. A further constraint in the design of instrumentation for the food industry is the fact that the price of the sensor or instrument will be important in the purchasing decision. Whereas the aircraft constructor may well buy the best instruments at any price, the food industry cannot afford to do so.
Instrument types and aspects Instruments relying particularly on an interaction with the food or an environment typical for the food industry are described in this book. Practical applications already established are discussed and newly emerging applications are introduced. The considerations that will allow the best use of the interplay of the instrumental method, the food and the process are outlined as a basis for the successful development and implementation of instrument applications. Both on-line and QC laboratory instruments are included as they have to interlink in guiding process control. Instrument users often wonder why the flood of novel sensors and measurement techniques described in scientific and technical journals or at conference results in a mere trickle of novel commercial instruments. This has been the case particularly in the field of biosensors and chemical sensors based on microelectronic devices where rapid developments have taken place in recent years. Part III of the book illustrates the complex and expensive process of developing a novel instrument from concept to commercial fruition with the help of two examples. The basis of recent commercial instrument developments based on novel chemical sensors and the feasibility of further food applications are also examined there. For each instrument type, the underlying principles are described with emphasis on aspects relevant to food applications. The authors show the significance of the variables to be determined, and identify the variables actually measured (unless identical) and their
xiv
Preface
relation to the desired information about the food product. Considerations in the design, choice, calibration and running of instruments within a given group are discussed and illustrated with examples. Aspects covered include hygienic design (e.g. flush fitting sensor heads or choice of non-contact techniques) or the adaptation of techniques to the variable nature of food ingredients. (In three cases, two chapters deal with different aspects of the same technique.) Factors influencing the accuracy and reliability of the technique (for a particular group of food products if applicable) are spelled out and compared with alternative techniques where applicable. Instrument systems requiring a high computing capacity (such as real-time image acquisition and processing), employing ionizing radiation (such as gamma-ray density gauges) or relying on principles beyond the realms of classical physics are omitted to allow a full description of the instruments covered.
The authors’ background To promote an interdisciplinary understanding, these aspects are discussed here by scientists and engineers from a wide range of backgrounds including electronics, physics, chemistry, microbiology, food science and food technology. Their professional experience spans an equally wide range of areas within the fields of the development and application of instrumental methods for the food industry. The authors have worked in the management and optimization of quality control and quality assurance in the food industry, in the development of new techniques for this area, in applications development or overall management at an instrument supplier’s laboratory, or in a research institute or association in close contact with the food industry. It would be difficult to find a single author with full and detailed knowledge and practical experience in all the aspects of physics, electronics, chemistry, microbiology, food science, food technology and process control that are relevant to instrumentation in the food industry. Nor would it necessarily be helpful to set up a committee of authors to compose a text together. Instead, each chapter reflects the particular expertise of the author(s) based on their scientific or engineering background and their professional experience acquired in the practical application or development of instruments.
Aims and scope For a wide range of established and emerging instrument types, this book treats the underlying principles and their implications for industrial applications. It sets out the complementary roles and characteristics of both the on-line and at-line instrumentation linked to the process control system and of the off-line instruments in the quality control laboratory. The significance of the measured variables for quality assurance and process management and the technical and commercial factors that determine the success or failure of an instrument are considered. The book is intended to assist engineers and managers responsible for process optimization and quality assurance in the food industry in choosing, setting-up and maintaining instruments and in using their readings to best effect. It is also intended for use by engineers in the instrumentation sector who develop new instruments, adapt existing instruments for new applications or liaise with instrument users. In the choice
Preface
xv
and installation of an instrument in a process line, the effective cooperation between instrument supplier and user is essential and this book aims to promote this by facilitating the communication between engineers and managers, from different backgrounds. The chosen approach is also designed to help advanced students of instrument engineering, food science, physics or biochemistry who seek an introduction to instrumentation in the processing industries. Further, the book will be of interest to scientists active in research and pre-commercial development in the fields of process engineering, industrial instrumentation and process control. Erika Kress-Rogers and Chris J. B. Brimelow
This page intentionally left blank
Contributors
Chapters 1, 13, 19 and 20 Dr Erika Kress-Rogers (Alstom) Hamannstr 75 D-40882 Ratingen Germany Tel: +49 2102 51192 Fax: +49 2102 705204 E-mail:
[email protected] Erika Kress-Rogers has a background in experimental solid-state physics (Universita¨t Karlsruhe) and in the physics of semiconductor devices (University of Oxford). She has carried out and coordinated a wide range of interdisciplinary R&D projects in the area of instrumentation and sensors for process control and quality assurance for the food industry while at the LFRA (Leatherhead Food Research Association), an international association that provides R&D, consultancy and technical services to food companies, government bodies and agencies. For seven years, she has served as Member of the International Editorial Board for the journal Food Control. She is the editor of the Handbook of Biosensors and Electronic Noses: Medicine, Food and the Environment and of the first edition of Instrumentation and Sensors for the Food Industry, the first handbook to provide a detailed account of a wide range of on-line and at-line measurement technologies for the determination of physical, chemical and microbial properties in the food industry. Dr Kress-Rogers now works as a Technical Editor for ALSTOM.
xviii
Contributors
Chapter 2 Dr Alain Hugi Nestle´ Research Centre Vers-chez-les-Blanc P.O. Box 44 CH-1000 Lausanne 26 Switzerland E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Alain Hugi heads the Sensory Science Group in the Nestle´ Research Center (Lausanne – Switzerland). Prior to joining Nestle´ in 1996, he spent nine years at the Confectionery R&D Center of Kraft Jacobs Suchard, in Neuchaˆtel (Switzerland), occupying various positions ranging from analytical chemistry to sensory evaluation and to product development. His current interests include sensory texture assessment, the development of novel sensory and consumer testing tools, and sensory-instrumental relations. His academic background is in analytical chemistry (University of Lausanne) Elisabeth Voirol is a sensory analyst at the Nestle´ Research Center (Lausanne – Switzerland). In more than 20 years with Nestle´, she has worked on topics related to sensory perception, product optimisation, development of quality control methods and data acquisition systems. She has experience in a wide range of food products such as milk products, coffee, dehydrated food, pet-food, meat products, cereals, etc. More recently she has focused on sensory analysis of colour and the impact on consumer behaviour. Her background is in biology and neuro-physiology (Universite´ Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris)
Chapter 3 Dr Douglas B. MacDougall School of Food Biosciences University of Reading 4 Japonica Close Wokingham Berks RG41 4XJ England Tel: +44 (0)1189 780174 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Douglas B. MacDougall lectured in sensory analysis at Reading University until his retirement in 2000. His research at Reading concentrated on the use of sensory analysis techniques to quantify food quality and the relationship of instrumental methods of colour measurement with the visual colour/appearance of food. Earlier, he worked in the Consumer Science Section at the AFRC (Agricultural and Food Research Council) in Reading and before that as co-project leader and Head of the Colour Group at the AFRC Meat Research Institute in Langford, Bristol. Projects at the Institute of Food Research included studies of the effects of animal stress and meat processing on the colour appearance, translucency and colour stability of fresh meat; optical instrument development for detection of meat faults; mathematical modelling of the colour and
Contributors
xix
texture of composite meat products and studies on the visual appeal of meat as affected by processing conditions, storage and display illumination. His background is in food science; colour stability of food (Royal College of Science and Technology, now Strathclyde University, Glasgow, Scotland; Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, New Brunswick, USA).
Chapter 4 Dr Pallavi Joshi Nestle´ Research Centre Vers-chez-les-Blanc Case Postale 44 CH-1000 Lausanne 26 Switzerland Tel: +41 21 785 8540 Fax: +41 21 785 8554 E-mail:
[email protected] Pallavi Joshi is a research scientist in the Department of Quality & Safety Assurance, Nestle´ Research Center for Food and Life Sciences, Lausanne Switzerland. Her current research focuses on the use of colour physics and measurement as a tool for product development and quality control within the food industry. Christopher J. B. Brimelow is head of Nestle´ R&D Centre Shanghai Ltd. He was formerly Vice President of R&D at Nestle´/Westreco (Connecticut – USA). He has worked on the on-line and off-line measurement of the compositional and physical properties of foods, particularly colour.
Chapter 5 Dr Sarah Bee Research Co-ordinator R&D Department Sortex Ltd. Pudding Mill Lane London E15 2PJ England Tel: +44 (0)20 8522 5136 Fax: +44 (0)20 8519 3232 E-mail:
[email protected] Sarah C. Bee is Research Co-ordinator for Sortex Limited (London, UK). Sarah has worked in the R&D department for over three years, initially providing technical support for R&D, customer care, applications, production and sales and marketing. She currently initiates and subsequently manages Sortex’s external research interests, either with universities or commercial consultancies. Sarah has a background in radiation physics (University College London), is a Chartered Physicist and Member of the Institute of Physics.
xx
Contributors
Mark J. Honeywood is Sortex’s Technical Director. Through Sortex’s membership of the DTI’s Insider UK Enterprise (IUKE) scheme, Mark has been invited to present at the DTI Successful Product Development Seminars, held across the UK. Mark has first hand experience of implementing ‘fast cycle time’ techniques, including rapid prototyping, concurrent engineering and quality functional deployment. His background is in applied optics (Reading University). Mark is also a Chartered Physicist and a Member of the Institute of Physics.
Chapter 6 Dr Ian B. Benson NDC Infrared Engineering Maldon Essex CM9 4XD England Tel: +44 (0)1621 852244 Fax: +44 (0)1621 856180 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Ian B. Benson joined Ilford films in 1978 as a photographic research chemist. After a period in product development he joined Infrared Engineering as an applications engineer in 1981. After establishing laboratory and development facilities in the company’s head office in Maldon and developing a wide range of measurements he moved into the sales management role and is now Director of Marketing for the Instrument Gauging Business. James Millard studied applied physics at Coventry Lancaster Polytechnic, graduating with an honours degree. Having spent an industrial training year at Infrared Engineering he returned as an applications engineer in 1987 and was seconded to the USA operation in 1990. After managing the Technical Support Group for the global business he has now become a Product Manager for the instrument gauging business.
Chapter 7 Mr Ian Ridley Land Instruments International Limited Dronfield S18 1DJ England Tel: +44 (0)1246 417691 Fax: +44 (0)1246 410585 E-mail:
[email protected] Ian Ridley studied applied physics at Sheffield City Polytechnic and since starting with Land Infrared in 1978 has been involved in the design and development of a wide variety of infrared-based temperature measurement equipment. He is now the Products Group Manager within the New Developments and Applications Department of Land Instruments International Ltd.
Contributors
xxi
Chapter 8 Dr Ing. Christoph Reh Nestle´ Research Centre Nestec Ltd Vers-chez-les-Blanc 1000 Lausanne 26 Switzerland Tel: +41 21 785 8990 Fax: +41 21 785 8553 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Ing. Christoph Reh works within the Nestle´ Research Center (Lausanne – Switzerland).
Chapter 9 Dr Michael Kent Kent and Partners Scientific Services 162 High Street Biggar ML12 6DH Scotland Tel: +44 (0)1899 220305 Fax: +44 (0)1899 220305 E-mail:
[email protected] Mike Kent runs his own consultancy, Kent and Partner. He was formerly Head of Physics Section at the Torry Research Station, Aberdeen, where he carried out work on the dielectric properties of foods and the applications of such properties to compositional measurement.
Chapters 10 and 11 Dr Peter G. Berrie Endress+Hauser Process Solutions AG Christoph-Merian-Ring 23 4153 Reinach BL Switzerland Tel: +41 61715 7340 Fax: +41 61715 7301 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Peter G. Berrie works as Marketing Communications Manager for Endress+Hauser Process Solutions AG, Reinach, Switzerland. A graduate of Imperial College, London, he spent five years in research at Euratom in Karlsruhe, Germany and Loughborough
xxii
Contributors
University, England, before turning to technical communication in 1978. Dr Berrie arrived at Endress+Hauser GmbH+Co, Maulburg, Germany in 1990, as a technical author responsible for digital communication, level and pressure products. In 2000, he moved to his current position, where he is concerned with fieldbus technologies and process solutions that include sensors, monitoring and control. Endress+Hauser has an international reputation in the field of process instrumentation for the food and beverages industries.
Chapter 12 Mr Nicholas Denbow ND Technical Marketing 7 Carisbrooke Close Alresford Hants SO24 9PQ England E-mail:
[email protected] www.nickdenbow.com Nicholas J. Denbow is currently a self-employed consultant in industrial instrumentation, specialising in ultrasonic techniques particularly for liquid level and fluid flow measurement. Previously employed as Marketing Manager for Platon Instrumentation at Basingstoke and Technical Marketing Manager for Solartron Mobrey in Slough, he has worked in industrial instrumentation for the process industries for 25 years.
Chapter 14 Dr Ian Roberts R&D/ QS Nestle´ Research Centre Nestec Ltd. Vers-Chez-Les-Blanc 1000 Lausanne 26 Switzerland Tel: +41 21 785 8469 Fax: +41 21 785 8553 E-mail:
[email protected] Ian Roberts performed his undergraduate and postgraduate studies in the department of Chemical and Biochemical Engineering at the University of Wales, Swansea. Here, he obtained Bachelors and Masters degrees, before focussing on rheology in his PhD entitled ‘Rheometry for Gelling Systems’. Having performed his thesis in collaboration with Nestle´ UK, he then moved to the Nestle´ Research Center in Lausanne, Switzerland in 1997, and now works at the Nestle´ Product Technology Centre in Orbe, Switzerland.
Contributors
xxiii
Chapter 15 Dr James G. Lyng Department of Food Science University College Dublin Belfield Dublin 4 Ireland Tel: +353 (0)1 7067710 Fax: +353 (0)1 7061147 E-mail:
[email protected] Professor Brian M. McKenna is the Head of the Food Science Department at University College Dublin (UCD), and is also the Director of the Food Science Centre at UCD, in addition to being Vice President of UCD and editor of the Journal of Food Engineering. Professor McKenna lectures in physical properties of foods at UCD. His research interests include the freezing and drying of foods, membrane processing, cook-chill products, process modelling, shelf-life prediction and electroheating. Professor McKenna has experience in the measurement of rheological and many other physical properties of foods through his involvement in national and EU-funded food process technology and product property research projects. Dr James Lyng is a lecturer in the Department of Food Science at UCD. In addition to giving courses in food process technology and food engineering, he also lectures in physical properties of food with Professor McKenna. His research interests lie in the area of alternative processing systems for meat and meat products (with particular reference to electroheating) and a large proportion of this work involves the measurement of physical properties of these products particularly their thermal, dielectric and also textural and rheological properties.
Chapter 16 Dr Wolfgang Ro¨edel Director and Professor Federal Centre for Meat Research Amselweg 16 D-95326 Kulmbach Germany E-mail:
[email protected] Wolfgang Ro¨del is Director and Professor at the Federal Centre for Meat Research and Vice Head of the Institute for Microbiology and Toxicology (Kulmbach, Germany). His research interests include development and adaptation of electronic measurement procedures for the determination of the physicochemical parameters (water activity, redox potential, pH, etc.) of meat and meat products within the framework of HACCP and quality control.
xxiv
Contributors
Chapter 17 Dr Donald M. Gibson BIODON International 43 Brighton Place Aberdeen AB10 6RT Scotland Tel/fax: +44 (0)1224 322 777 E-mail:
[email protected] Donald M. Gibson is an independent consultant with his own company, BIODON International, established in 1994. He specialises in food microbiology and technology. He spent 30 years at the Torry Research Station, Aberdeen, latterly as Head of Microbiology, covering many aspects of microbiological food safety and quality. He is a Fellow of the Institute of Food Science and Technology, and a member of the Society for Applied Microbiology and of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists International (AOAC).
Chapter 18 Dr David Kilcast Leatherhead Food Research Association Randalls Road Leatherhead Surrey KT22 7RY England Tel: +44 (0)1372 822321 Fax: +44 (0)1372 836228 E-mail:
[email protected] David Kilcast, BSc, PhD, FIFST is Head of Sensory and Consumer Science at Leatherhead Food Research Association and leads a research team working on the sensory quality and consumer perception of food. Research specialities are the perception and measurement of flavour and texture including flavour release from foods. He is past Chairman of the Sensory and Consumer Science Group of the Society of Chemical Industry, a member of the British Standards Institution Committee on Sensory Analysis and a committee member of the IFST Professional Food Sensory Interest Group.
Chapter 21 Dr Ursula Bilitewski GBF-Ges. Biotechn. Forschung mbH Mascheroder Weg 1 D-38124 Braunschweig Germany Tel: +49 531 6181 390 Fax: +49 531 6181 395 E-mail:
[email protected]
Contributors xxv Dr Ursula Bilitewski is senior scientist in the German Research Centre for Biotechnology (GBF), Braunschweig, Germany and lecturer in biochemistry at the Technical University Braunschweig. In the Division of Biochemical Engineering of the GBF she is responsible for the development and application of bioanalytical methods. She has a long experience with electrochemical methods and has used screen-printing technology for the production of enzyme electrodes to be applied in food and bioprocess analysis. There are also strong activities in the design of automated flowthrough devices, which were used not only for enzyme, but also for immunoanalysis, and included electrochemical as well as optical detection methods. Recent research activities cover the analysis of proteins and protein activities, the analysis of genes and gene expression in combination with the miniaturization of set-ups. Dr Anja Schmidt is a food chemist and was a PhD student and postdoc in Dr Bilitewski’s group.
Chapter 22 Dr Axel Warsinke Department of Analytical Biochemistry Karl-Liebknecht-Str. 24-25 D-14476 Golm Germany Tel: +49 331 977 5124 Fax: +49 331 977 5052 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Axel Warsinke works within the Department of Analytical Chemistry at the University of Potsdam. Professor Dorothea Pfieffer and Dr Frieder Scheller work for BST Bio Sensor Technologie GmbH based in Berlin.
Chapter 23 Dr Ibitsam Tothill Institute of Bioscience and Technology Cranfield Biotechnology Centre Cranfield University Cranfield Bedfordshire MK43 0AL England Tel: +44 (0)1234 754131 Fax: +44 (0)1234 752401 E-mail:
[email protected] Dr Ibtisam E. Tothill is a senior lecturer in biochemistry and MSc Course Director for the MSc in Environmental Diagnostics at Cranfield Biotechnology Centre, Cranfield
xxvi
Contributors
University, Bedfordshire. She has developed strong research activities in immunosensors, affinity sensors, biosensors and diagnostics, which are at the forefront of research into food and environmental analysis. She has established an international and European reputation in these areas and this has enabled her to attract both private and public sector funding. Her recent research activities cover analysis of pesticides and herbicides, algae and cyanobacterial toxins diagnosis, heavy metals detection, bacteria and fungal detection. Dr Tothill has numerous publications and conference papers in the diagnostics and analysis arena. She has received a variety of prizes and awards including the Douglas Bomford Trust Award at the AgEng 2000, Warwick, UK.
Symbols
Chapter 13 c Z T f ! k P M rp V T EM K Y G KS P
cP/cV R B STP
speed of sound dispersive ultrasound phase velocity specific acoustic impedance coefficient of ultrasound attenuation coefficient of transmission through boundary frequency wavelength angular frequency; ! 2f wave vector; k 2= relaxation time density absolute pressure molecular weight coefficient of viscosity radius of suspended spherical particle volume absolute temperature elastic modulus (as appropriate) bulk modulus Young’s modulus shear modulus adiabatic bulk modulus coefficient of expansion at constan pressure ratio of principal specific heats cP/cV specific heats at constant pressure, volume coefficient of thermal conductivity universal gas constant second virial coefficients standard temperature and pressure
xxviii
Symbols
Chapter 15 An Bn d e f G G0 G00 g H h hc h0 I2 K Kn k k0 k 00 L Lo L0o n p Q Rc R1 R2 Rp R T Te t t0 up V
_
_ eff
_ max
_ meas 0
function in equation (15.22) function in equation (15.22) capillary tube diameter distance from bottom of bob to cup or container frequency shear modulus storage modulus loss modulus gravitational constant separation of the two plates difference in levels between liquid in reservoirs of a capillary viscometer end effects correction in concentric cylinder viscometry height of bob for a rotary viscometer Bessel function constant for capillary viscometer root of modifier Navier-Stokes equation apparent viscosity or consistency index for power law fluid constant in Casson equation constant in Herschel-Buckley length of capillary tube sample length before deformation final sample length after deformation power law exponent pressure drop along a capillary tube flow rate radius of cone radius of bob in concentric cylinder viscometer radius of cup in concentric cylinder viscometer radius of the plate (parallel plate systems) R2 R1 torque equivalent torque time (equations (15.8) (15.9) or (15.12)) relaxation time (equation (15.4)) slope of plot of shear stress versus shear rate once yield stress has been exceeded volume of liquid used in a capillary viscometer conical angle relaxation time shear strain
L0o Lo =Lo , dimensionless) shear rate (or rate of shear strain) d /dt effective shear rate shear rate at the outer edge (rim) of the plate measured shear rate phase displacement angle viscosity viscosity at zero shear rate
Symbols p 1 ! b y
xxix
slope of straight line plot of shear stress vs. shear rate (equation 15.17) viscosity at infinite shear rate angular velocity 3.1417 density shear stress shear stress at the bob yield stress
Chapter 17 b c f k l n n0 ns nD n_ _ n/n _ 0 (n/n) r t tg tg0 tD tL A AD CD, R D Cox, R ox Cse G0 Gs K N R fs Rs S S0, S s S
number of bits mass concentration of medium, g ml 1 frequency, Hz initial specific conductivity, S m 1 effective separation of electrodes, m population density, cfu ml 1 inoculum density, cfu ml 1 maximum possible population density, cfu ml 1 arbitrary detection level of population density, cfu ml 1 growth rate, cfu h 1 specific growth rate, h 1 initial specific growth rate, h 1 correlation coefficient time, h generation time, h _ o, h 1/(n/n) time after inoculation at which population density grows to a value nD, detection time, h lag time, h electrode area, m2 conversion gain series capacitance and series resistance due to alignment of polar dipoles in double charge layer in fluid, F,
series capacitance and series resistance resulting from the presence of an oxide layer at the electrode surfaces, F,
lumped electrode capacitances CD and Cox (for R D, R ox R s), F initial conductance of medium in test cell, S subsequent conductance of medium in test cell, S increase in specific conductance associated with production of single bacterial cell, per unit volume, S m 1 (cfu ml 1) 1 number of colonies counted on agar plate full-scale range of resistance,
true resistance of medium in test cell,
substrate mass, g initial and final stationary mass of substrate, g mass of substrate metabolised by one bacterial cell, g
xxx
Symbols
V, i |V|,|i| |Vm|,|im| Xs Xse Y Z
D
instantaneous voltage, current, V, A peak voltage, current, V, A mean voltage, current, modulus, V, A reactance of Cs,
reactance of Cse,
admittance, S impedance of R s and Cs in series,
phase angle number of generations after inoculation at which growth is detected
1 Instrumentation for food quality assurance E. Kress-Rogers, ALSTOM, Ratingen
1.1
Introduction
1.1.1 The role of quality assurance in the food industry Quality control is essential in the food industry, and efficient quality assurance is becoming increasingly important. The consumer expects a wide range of competitively priced food products of consistently high quality. Each food item has to be safe, wholesome and attractive in appearance, taste and texture, and needs to be consistent with the product image. Variations within the same batch or between batches will have to be kept to a minimum as they are often interpreted by the consumer as indicating a fault, even when the differing product is of high quality. The availability, quality and price of raw materials will place conditions on the food manufacturing operation, as will the prevailing structure of the retailing sector. More and more frequently, the product palette has to be adapted to changes in tastes and nutritional ideas, and to the appearance of competing products on the market. In the manufacture of each new product, there is the challenge of getting it right first time. Increasingly, food processing operations are technology-based rather than skill-based. Legislation on food composition and labelling will also play a role. Changes in legislation are driven by consumer demands and by international harmonization. Food processing has a long history (Georgala 1989) and has always had two main purposes. The first is the conversion of agricultural products (or of fished, hunted and gathered foods) into palatable, attractive, digestible and safe foods. Cereals, for example, are virtually inedible without prior milling and cooking or fermenting; some fruits and pulses are toxic without prior cooking; and large proportions of the Asian and African populations can consume lactose only after conversion to lactate by fermentation. The second purpose is the preservation of foods for availability out of season, for years of lean harvests, and for transport to areas distant from agricultural producers. The assessment of food still centres on its taste, aroma, appearance and nutritional value, and on its safety and stability. Optimized process control plays an essential part in maintaining the commercial viability of a food manufacturing operation in the face of changes in the food market and in the structure of the food industry. Advances in
2
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 1.1
Food and drink market sectors in the UK (Bailey et al. 1991)
(a) Market sectors in 1990 by value (£ million) Alcoholic beverages (inc. duty)* 1 Meat and meat products 2 Dairy products (inc. ice cream) 3 Soft drinks 4 Fresh fruit and vegetables 5 Bakery products 6 Confectionery 7 Frozen foods 8 Canned foods 9 Fish and fish products 10 Snack foods 11 Hot beverages 12 Cereal products 13 Oils and fats products 14 Ready meals 15 Meal accompaniments 16 Sweeteners, preserves
21 9 5 5 4 3 3 2 1 1 1 1 1
864 882 884 286 598 790 700 250 686 606 287 281 230 971 715 678 535
(b) Increase of market sector values in the UK from 1989 to 1990 (per cent) Alcoholic beverages* 1 Frozen foods 2 Soft drinks 3 Ready meals 4 Confectionery 5 Fresh fruit and vegetables 6 Snack foods 7 Cereal products 8 Meal accompaniments 9 Hot beverages 10 Dairy products 11 Meat and meat products 12 Fish and fish products 13 Bakery products 14 Oils and fats products 15 Canned foods 16 Sweeteners, preserves
8.2 11.2 10.9 10.5 8.8 8.2 6.5 5.4 4.3 4.0 3.5 3.5 3.3 2.1 1.4 1.1 0.6
Notes: * As much of the market value of the alcoholic beverages sector is the duty, the value has not been used to rank this sector. 1. For the cost/benefit assessment for a potential instrument development, the market values listed here need to be seen together with other factors such as the relative values of raw materials and final product or the growth rate and profit margins in a sector. For snack foods, for example, the added value would, in general, be higher than for canned foods or meat. Additionally, the viability of an instrument development is increased when it is relevant to health and safety (where legislation is linked to the availability of instruments) or to the price of commodities (for example, in the case of the water content of wheat) or where the specifications for the proportional content of an expensive ingredient need to be met. 2. All market sectors increased in value, but not all growth rates exceeded the rate of inflation. 3. Categories are not mutually exclusive.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
3
microelectronics have provided fast data processing and have made efficient process control systems possible. In the 1980s, programmable logic controllers (PLCs) were widely installed in the food industry. Massive control centres were designed earlier for integral plant control; these centres were subsequently replaced by distributed control systems (McFarlane 1983; Vidal 1988). Whichever control system is used, it still has to make do with a small number of continuously updated product variables, and often relies largely on inputs at long time intervals and with long delays depending on the assay time and the distance to the quality control (QC) laboratory. The effective application of both established and novel sensors and instruments will play a key role in gaining the full benefit of the potential that modern control systems offer. Table 1.1 shows the sizes and growth rates of food and drink market sectors in the UK. 1.1.2 On-line, at-line and off-line instrumentation For optimum quality assurance the manufacturer requires cost-effective methods for the rapid assessment, and preferably the on-line measurement, of the chemical and physical properties and the microbial status of raw materials, process streams and end products. Monitoring during the processing operation helps prevent expensive rework or disposal of out-of-specification product. Tight control is needed for variables that influence the stability of the end product towards microbial spoilage or oxidative rancidity. This concerns particularly the monitoring of temperature profiles during heat processing and storage, the control of cleaning-in-place procedures, and the measurement of the pH, water activity, solute concentration and preservative levels of the product. Water activity, usually measured as equilibrium relative humidity (ERH), cannot be measured rapidly. From an on-line measurement of the moisture content, the ERH can be deduced if the isotherm is well defined. The trend towards continuous automated production in place of batch processing necessitates tight feedback loops based on on-line monitoring methods or, failing that, on rapid at-line techniques. Even when a laboratory method provides a result within one hour of taking a sample from the line, over a tonne of product or over 10 000 jars, tins or packs of food may already have passed the production line. The cost of rework or disposal for such a quantity is considerable. Alternatively, excessive safety margins with respect to legal requirements or customer specifications on the minimum content of expensive ingredients will lead to an uncompetitively priced product. Prolonged holding times to await the outcome of assays, as a regular part of the process, lessen the benefits of continuous processing. Nevertheless, holding times of around eight hours are currently observed prior to filling certain sterilized foods, for example, in order to await test results from impedance monitoring for microbial assessment (Chapter 17). Refinements of this technique, based on more sensitive oscillometric detection of impedance changes with microbial growth, for example, have been investigated in order to shorten the assay time (Cossar et al. 1990). The advances in plant for automated continuous production and in the signal processing capabilities of process control systems have stimulated progress in the development of many novel sensors and instruments for the food industry, often by technology transfer from other industrial sectors or from the clinical sector (Kress-Rogers 1985, 1986). These have since matured; sensor concepts have been developed into prototypes, and instrument types already available in the 1980s have become more
4
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
versatile and can now be applied reliably to a wider range of foods and processing situations or determine a wider range of target variables. With the help of these advances in on-line and at-line instrumentation (Fig. 1.1), quality assurance (QA) is employed increasingly in the management of manufacturing operations. The quality control (QC) laboratory supports QA by checking and updating the calibration of on-line and at-line instrumentation and by providing a wide range of analyses and assessments that are not feasible for QA implementation. The variables measured on-line and those measured off-line in the QC laboratory do not necessarily coincide. The process stream at the on-line measurement point will often be quite different from the sample taken to the laboratory, either due to changes during sampling and transporting, or because the laboratory test measures properties of the end product, whereas the on-line instrument measures precursors of these, or other properties of the process stream or the process environment that will determine the relevant properties of the product. When the time taken for a QC laboratory result exceeds a day, as would be the case for many microbiological tests or trace analysis assays for toxins, it is often impractical to hold the food in quarantine during this time, as a perishable food may be well into its shelf-life by the time the result is available. Even when prolonged holding times can be observed, it is not usually possible to provide 100 per cent screening of the product with QC methods, and so a negative result is no absolute guarantee that the whole production volume is ‘clean’. The test then becomes a means of checking that good manufacturing practice (GMP) is being observed, and the process has to be analysed to define the product and process variables that can be monitored and controlled in order to minimize the possibility of manufacturing a product having too high a microbial load, carrying pathogens or containing toxins. This approach is known as hazard analysis critical control point (HACCP) system. For the overall control of the process, the monitoring of level and flow rate as well as pressure and temperature are essential (Chapters 10–13). Important for the stability of foods towards microbial spoilage are product properties such as the water activity and the pH as well as the microbial load and the concentration of preservatives and nutrients (Chapters 16, 17, 20–23). The integrity of the food packaging is also vital, and in modern modified atmosphere packs (MAPs) the initial headspace gas composition and its retention during distribution and storage will be relevant. The adherence to appropriate storage temperatures (and ambient humidities) throughout the shelf-life needs to be ensured. An important process variable influencing the shelf-life is the time-temperature profile of the process stream and, related to this, the excess pressure in the headspace. Also relevant are the concentration and temperature of cleaning liquids and their efficient application to process plant surfaces (Chapters 10, 12, 13). In conventional cooking and canning operations, heating the interior of a solid food item (or a highly viscous liquid) relies on thermal conduction, often resulting in overcooking of the outer layers in order to ensure adequate temperatures in the centre. This is not to say that high surface temperatures are not desirable in processes such as roasting, where the Maillard reaction provides a range of flavours and colours in the presence of reducing sugars and amino acids at elevated temperatures. The flavour changes caused by prolonged boiling are, however, usually considered undesirable. Microwave or radiofrequency waves, on the other hand, can penetrate food and heat deeper layers directly. Direct ohmic heating is also possible by mounting electrodes in contact with a conductive food, and ohmic heaters allowing continuous automated heat processing are available.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
5
With these methods, it is possible to retain more of the flavour and vitamins of the food, and yet to ensure a given minimum temperature to be reached throughout. In order to optimize such processes for the manufacture of products that combine adequate cooking, pasteurization or sterilization (as required for the product) with good flavour retention, analysis of the spatial distribution of the time-temperature profiles is necessary. Several variants of time-temperature integration are used to assess the effect of heat processing on a food. The most common is the F0 value, which expresses the degree of sterilization of a food. The F0 value (expressed in minutes) is obtained by calculating the integral Z F0 L dt where lg L (T Tref)/Z defines the lethality L, and the temperature T has been measured in the coldest part of the food. For F0 evaluation, Tref 121ºC and Z 10. For canned foods and ultra heat treated (UHT) products, F0 values of 3 to 18 are used, depending on the types and numbers of spores present. This treatment results in commercial sterility, that is the remaining microorganisms will not cause spoilage or disease or have a detrimental effect on the product quality during its stated shelf-life (usually in excess of six months) (Lewis 1987). Other values of Tref and Z apply for the loss of nutrients by protein denaturation, vitamin destruction and certain other chemical reactions. A cook value can be defined, in analogy to the sterilization value F0, to quantify the degree of cooking or overcooking and thus predict the loss of quality (flavour, nutrient levels) by heat processing. Figure 1.2 summarizes the roles of on-line, at-line and off-line instrumentation in process management, quality assurance and quality control. Measurements relevant for product safety, stability and quality and for process management are listed in Tables 1.2 and 1.3. Instrument requirements and measurements for special concepts are given in Tables 1.4 and 1.5. 1.1.3 Technology transfer: opportunities and pitfalls Instruments for measurements in quality control and in the control of processing operations in the food industry are often the result of technology transfer from other industries. The history of such new introductions has, in some cases, been characterized by initial successes, followed by a phase of disappointment with the instrument performance when the range of applications was widened. Subsequently, lost confidence had to be regained by defining the range of suitable application areas and by adapting the instrument or the setting-up and running procedures to particular applications. To avoid setbacks, it is necessary to understand both the instrument design and its underlying principles as well as the properties of the food and its processing environment. Problems have, for instance, been experienced with some early applications of ultrasound flow meters in the food industry. These flow meters have the attraction of providing a non-contact measurement which facilitates maintenance and is intrinsically hygienic. However, for certain food process streams, unacceptable errors in the readings were observed until it was recognized that special designs or other types of flow meters were needed for samples with non-Newtonian flow profiles, or containing large particulates with flow rates differing from that of the carrier liquid, or where high attenuation of the ultrasound signal by the food liquid restricted the sampled flow volume to the outer layer (Chapters 12, 13, 15).
6
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 1.1 Sensor configurations: (a) sensors on continuous processing lines (b) sensors on conveyor belts (c) sensors in batch processes (d) handheld sensors. The window material will depend on the instrument principle, for example Teflon for microwave transmission. Conditions for at-line measurements (not on-line, but in the production area) are more stringent than for off-line measurements (in the QC laboratory). At-line instrumentation and accessories should be free of glass components (potential foreign body hazard) and of toxic reagents that are not fully contained at all times. Also, mechanical robustness, tolerance of the processing environment (for example, of steam) and simple and rapid operation are essential.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
1.2
7
Challenging conditions for sensors
1.2.1 Complex and variable samples Many foods are highly complex in their chemical composition and in their physical structure. Gaseous, liquid and solid phases often coexist in the same product. Each phase may incorporate many different chemical compounds. One phase can be finely dispersed in another, or samples can be highly inhomogeneous or even largely separated. Within the
8
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 1.2
Quality assurance (QA) and quality control (QC) in food processing operations.
Actuation of process changes A programmable logic controller (PLC) may be used to operate actuators that cause changes in process conditions in dependence of a measured variable. Where complex relationships exist between the measured variables and the process, an expert system can provide an automatic evaluation of a set of measured values and a decision on corrections to the process conditions. Combined inspection/sorting systems are used to identify and remove, for example, products that contain foreign bodies or that are mis-shaped. In-situ measurements in batch processes The scheme needs to be adapted for industrial batch processing operations, for batch processes in catering establishments and for measurements in food distribution. In-situ measurements with dip- or stab-probes, or with instruments installed during the batch process or permanently in a processing vessel or storage container can be used here.
Calibration The choice of the reference method can influence the calibration. Systematically different values can be obtained, for example, between drying and titration methods for moisture determination in the laboratory.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance Table 1.2
9
Measurements in quality assurance and quality control
Measuring properties relevant for product quality • • • • • •
appearance (colour, gloss, shape) texture, mouthfeel, pouring characteristics flavour (aroma, taste) nutritional value functional properties composition according to specifications
Screening for product safety chemical contamination (agricultural residues, endogenic toxins, . . .) microbial contamination (total load, presence of pathogens and spoilage organisms, . . .) contamination with unwanted genetically modified organisms foreign matter (metal or glass fragments, insects, stones, . . .) unwanted matter (nutshells, fruit calices, . . .) Assessing product stability towards • chemical reactions (such as oxidative rancidity) • microbial growth (due to inappropriate pH, water activity, preservative concentration, either in the product as a whole or in a small region within the product) • microbial or chemical contamination (due to defective or inappropriate packaging) (including the migration of compounds in the packaging material into the food) • migration of water or fat (between pastry shell and filling, between food and environment) • loss of protective atmosphere (due to defective seal) (for products packed under a modified atmosphere designed to suppress microbial growth or oxidation)
liquid portion, fat and water may be combined in an emulsion, or even in a double emulsion. Water can be present as free water or bound in many different ways: as water of crystallization, bound to protein or starch molecules, entrapped in biopolymer networks or absorbed on solid surfaces of porous food powder particles. Active enzymes may be present, either in the tissues of fresh meat or produce, or within the cells of the microbial flora. Table 1.3
Measurements in process management
Objectives • ensure safety and continuity of the processing operation • maintain conditions for in-spec. products • use resources efficiently (labour, raw materials, energy, machinery) • reduce loading of effluents (e.g. of waste water with organic matter) Measurements • pressure • temperature (also spatial distribution of temperature and time integral over temperature), • pH • mass and volume flow rates of liquids and particulate solids • fill levels of liquids and particulate solids bulk density, weight apparent viscosity Also wanted, but more difficult to achieve on-line: • chemical composition (gross and fine) • complex rheological properties (yield value, elasticity, . . .) • particle, droplet, bubble size, (average size and distribution) • volatiles evolved in cooking, baking, roasting, drying operations
10
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 1.4 • • • •
• •
Instrumentation requirements, on-line
hygienic sensing head contaminant-free (no reagents, no microbes) no foreign body hazard (no fragile glass components), robust CIP (cleaning-in-place) tolerant if permanently installed on-line (alternatives for specific chemical measurements: instruments with disposable sensing element which must be easily replaced and inexpensive, or, in certain applications, robust, easily cleanable dip-probes or stabprobes for in situ measurements) reproducibility in accordance with task, reliable, low maintenance effort suitable for complex chemical and physical sample properties total cost (capital, maintenance, running) in good proportion to benefits
Samples in the food industry are, moreover, very diverse and highly variable. The season, the region of origin, the harvesting and storage conditions as well as the processing steps (such as the fermentation of cocoa beans) will all influence the properties of the raw materials. New food-processing technologies are being introduced to provide an ever wider range of food products that require frequent adaptation to changing consumer preferences and market structures. 1.2.2 Hostile conditions and stringent hygiene requirements The pH extends over a wide range, with low values for vinegar or citrus fruit juices and high values for caustic cleaning solutions used regularly in-line. A wide range of pH values is also encountered in the monitoring of effluents, that is waste liquids formed in washing raw materials or in cleaning container surfaces, for example. Table 1.5
Measurements for special concepts
HACCP – Hazard analysis critical control points On-line measurements • pressure, temperature (spatially resolved, time integral) • relative humidity • product pH product solute content • strength and surface coverage of solutions used for periodic cleaning of machinery Off-line measurements • water activity (as equilibrium relative humidity) • pH (spatially resolved) preservative concentration • microbial contamination of ingredients including water • microbial contamination on machinery and on other surfaces in the production area Marker (indicator) approach For the on-line, at-line or in situ assessment of • microbial pre-spoilage status • oxidative rancidity status • level of heat-induced deterioration • progress of ripening or conditioning browning potential • end of heat processing operation Measured are chemical or physical variables that have first been identified as indicative of the complex condition of interest. Usually, a given marker (or indicator) variable will be valid for a particular group of products only. (See Section 1.3.4 and Chapter 19.)
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
11
Temperatures vary from freeze-drying conditions ( 50ºC or lower) to hot frying fat conditions (up to 250ºC) and roasting operations (320ºC or higher). Processing and packaging under vacuum is employed, and excess pressure is used in cooking and canning operations. A retort would typically operate with pressures of 60–600 kPa, that is 0.6–6 bar (McFarlane 1983, see Appendix B, Tables 3 and 4). Particularly severe conditions can prevail in a cooker extruder, where both high pressures (over 10 MPa, that is, over 100 bar) and high temperatures (around 200ºC) can be encountered. Moreover, the inner barrel surface is scraped by the extruder screw, and access to the food mix within the barrel or in the extruder head is certainly restricted. The food mix itself can be quite abrasive in the early part of its passage through the extrusion cooker. Maize grits, for example, may be present, expanding later on in the fashion of popcorn. These conditions present a challenge even for the design of pressure and temperature (p/T) probes. (For a description of extrusion cookers see McFarlane 1983; O’Connor 1987; Wiedmann and Strecker 1988.) Nevertheless, sensors for the measurement of moisture and other variables are under development for this hostile environment. Radiofrequency open-ended coaxial probes have been designed to fit into the openings foreseen for the bolt-type p/T probes designed for extrusion cookers, and a microwave stripline has been constructed for mounting in an extrusion head (Chapter 9). In general, the conditions in the food industry are more favourable than in a cooker extruder. A common challenge for in situ sensors is, however, the cleaning-in-place (CIP) procedures used in many processing systems in the food industry (Kessler and Weichner 1989). These usually involve flushing with hot caustic soda solutions (NaOH) which can corrode probe surfaces, and this is particularly unfavourable for many chemical sensors. High-pressure steam cleaning is another effective CIP procedure; this will challenge the mechanical and thermal stability of a sensing head. The strict hygiene standards in the food industry also demand that in-line probes in contact with the sample must have crevice-free surfaces. This applies both to the sensing head and to the mounting flange area. For aseptic processes, any sensor surfaces in contact with the sample need to be tolerant to CIP procedures. In fermentation processes, the use of a disposable sterilized sensor can be an option. Any danger of chemical contamination of the food by sensor reagents or components of slight solubility must be eliminated. The introduction of foreign bodies, particularly glass or metal fragments, in the case of damage to the sensor, must also be prevented. Food powders with a very low moisture content can accumulate high electrostatic charges, and sensors that may come into contact with such powders (typically starch-based products) must be designed to minimize the risk of a dust explosion. The transducer and electronics may have to withstand exposure to water, steam or airborne dust. Occasionally, they may be enrobed in chocolate or coated with a thin film of condensed polymerized frying oil. Sensors in contact with food or food volatiles are often subject to fouling by proteins, fats or starch particles (Kessler and Weichner 1989). Electromagnetic interference (EMI) will be encountered in industrial microwave ovens or in direct ohmic heating appliances. There will also be electromagnetic noise and mechanical vibrations from pumps, hoppers and other plant. Rotating mixer paddles scraping the walls of a vessel may be in the way of a radiated signal or restrict the positioning of a wall-mounted probe.
12
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
1.2.3 Non-contact techniques and robotic sampling and conditioning Given the often hostile conditions for invasive sensors, either during the processing of foods or during the periodic cleaning operations, and the always stringent hygiene and other food safety requirements, non-contact measurements are particularly attractive to the food industry. These can be based on the interaction of electromagnetic waves, including gamma-rays, light, infrared radiation, microwaves or radiofrequency waves, or of ultrasound signals with the sample. Such methods do, however, require an awareness of the nature of the interaction of the applied signal with the food, its headspace and container. This understanding is needed at all stages of instrument development, in the choice of suitable applications and installation points, during the setting-up and calibration procedures (including the preparation of training samples), in the running of the instrument and in the evaluation of the readings (Chapters 6, 7, 9, 11, 12, 13). To develop the wide range of sensors desirable for in-line measurement in the food industry would be prohibitively expensive. Not only different target variables, but also different analytical ranges and variable chemical and physical environments, would have to be catered for. The recognition of the cost that would be associated with the development of in-line sensors for a wide range of chemical, physical and microbial properties, each for a wide range of diverse applications, has led to an interest in techniques that make the best of the sensors available. Robotic sampling and sample preparation systems allow rapid measurements at short intervals by enabling the use of sensors that would otherwise be confined to laboratory applications. This approach has been implemented particularly in Japan. An example is shown in Fig. 1.3 (see also Chapter 20, Section 5).
1.3
Interpreting the readings
1.3.1 Measured variables and target variables In non-contact measurements, the relationship between the measured variables and the target variables is often complex, so that a given calibration will apply only to a limited range of food products and processing conditions. For instance, a water content measurement based on near infrared reflection analysis will have to rely on a predictable relationship between surface moisture and average bulk moisture content; or, the monitoring of solute concentration by a measurement of ultrasound velocity depends on a
Fig. 1.3 Robotics approach.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
13
constant composition of both the solute and the carrier liquid (and on compensation for temperature changes, as is the case with most measurement methods). Care in the setting up and calibration are essential, as is the choice of appropriate applications. Non-contact in-line techniques will then provide highly reliable continuous measurements that allow process adjustments before an out-of-specification situation arises (Chapters 6, 9, 12, 13). In contact measurements also, the measured variable is not always the target variable. For example, pH is often measured as an indicator of acid concentration (provided that the acid composition is known). Ion activity is often measured in place of ion concentration. Frying oil samples are taken for an at-line measurement of colour or free fatty acid (FFA) content in order to infer the degree of frying-induced polymerization and oxidation. Yet, both colour and FFA-content are highly dependent on other factors such as the oil type, the food fried and the frying conditions. (See Chapters 19 and 20 on oil quality and pH, respectively.) In the QC laboratory, the assay of chemical composition can involve deductions from the proportion (by weight) of sample becoming volatile or dissolved under certain conditions. Clearly, such assay types, and many others, need to take into account the nature of the sample. Indeed, the official methods prescribe sample-specific assay procedures. In addition to these relationships between measured and target variables, the significance of a target variable for the manufacturing operation needs to be considered. This can reside in assuring the safety and stability of the food, the enjoyment in handling and eating it, and the efficiency in producing it or in complying with legal regulations or customer specifications. These aspects are discussed in Section 1.4.1. 1.3.2 Relationship between in-line and QC laboratory methods Differences between the readings of the in-line instrument and the off-line quality control (QC) laboratory results are, at times, unjustly blamed on the in-line method. The QC reference assay can be applied only to a small fraction of the sample volume passing the sampling point, and this alone can lead to a result differing from an in-line method that provides 100 per cent screening. Moreover, different laboratory methods will often give systematically differing results between them for a particular food sample type, even though they may give identical results for other sample types (see, for example, Fig. 1.4). Often, the definition of the measured variable depends on the laboratory reference method used. For example, for an oven-drying procedure, moisture is defined as that part of the sample that will be driven off at the applied temperature and pressure. For a titration procedure, on the other hand, the relevant part of the water is that which can be extracted from the food matrix (or dissolved and dispersed together with food solids) and brought into contact with the reagent. For this reason, official analysis protocols exist for different food types; for accurate results to be achieved, an instrument used in the QC laboratory needs to be calibrated for each food type against the official method. In some situations, the comparison between the on-line reading and the chemical or rheological QC result, for example, is not strictly valid because the sample changes on removal from the line and during the preparation and analysis steps in the QC laboratory. Oxidation, thinning, thickening, fermentation or other changes can occur during this time, and homogenization steps can cause the breaking up of tissue cells, leading to changes in the composition of the juices and also exposing the cell contents to oxidation or other reactions.
14
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 1.4 Comparison of laboratory methods for moisture measurement. Oven drying at 102ºC to constant weight leads to an increased apparent moisture content when non-water volatiles are present. This can be avoided by vacuum drying at a lower temperature. When lactose is present, incomplete dehydration can decrease the apparent moisture content by oven drying. This is avoidable by moistening prior to oven drying. Symbols mark different brands of instant coffee and milk powder (Kress-Rogers and Kent 1986).
When changing from a process control system, updated from time to time by data from the QC laboratory, to a system relying primarily on continuous feedback from in-line instrumentation, the significance of the measured properties for the food processing operation needs to be well defined. It may well be favourable to replace an off-line measurement for a given set of variables with an on-line method determining a different set of variables, at a point upstream from the existing QC sampling point. Feedforward control based on the continuous on-line monitoring of the process stream before and during processing can often provide tighter control of the end product properties than delayed feedback control based on an off-line measurement of the end properties themselves. Based on an analysis of the process as a whole, together with an awareness of the options for on-line and at-line instrumentation, an effective data input system for process control purposes can be designed. A complementary range of laboratory instruments will provide calibration updates and a wider range of measurements (see the last entry in Appendix A). 1.3.3 Data processing approaches When several on-line measurements are carried out simultaneously, there is not necessarily a one-to-one relationship between each measured variable (or a combination of these) and a corresponding control parameter to be adjusted. The design of the
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
15
response pattern of the control system can then be based on a variety of data processing approaches. Ideally, but rarely, there is a mathematical model based on sound physicochemical principles, which links the measured variables to the relevant properties of the end product and to the process parameters that can be adjusted. For other cases, data interpretation based on neural networks (Gardner and Hines 1997, Section 5; Jansson 1991) and control decisions based on fuzzy logic (Berrie 1997; Eerikainen et al. 1988) as well as neuro-fuzzy systems (Theisen et al. 1998; Tilli 1996) have become established. (See also the entries on fuzzy logic and neural networks in Appendix A to this book.) Neural networks in particular have attracted much attention in recent years. Here, several on-line sensors that are not specific for an intended property are combined. Extensive output data from these sensors and associated quality control results are then collected over a period of weeks or months. These data are subjected to analysis with neural networks. This can result in a signal processing mode learnt by the neural network. The output of the educated network will then be indicative of a characteristic of the finished product such as taste or aroma, although none of the contributing sensors necessarily has a well-defined physico-chemical relationship to the characteristic of interest. There is a temptation to employ such systems as a replacement for the development of sensors and instruments that give an output with a well-defined relationship to the process and product. However, the short-term saving in avoiding sensor development can be outweighed by the cost of frequent updating of the signal evaluation procedure for nonspecific measurements. This updating procedure may involve the collection of process measurement data and associated product assessments by QC laboratory tests and taste panels over many weeks, and may be required whenever raw materials or recipes change. When the need for an update is not recognized in time, the system will be unreliable, and the quality of the product will be adversely affected. Although sophisticated data evaluation systems will play an important role in the future, they will be complementary to rather than a replacement for measurement techniques based on sound physicochemical principles. (See also Chapter 20, Section 20.5.2.) A special case is the assessment of aroma and taste. Odours and aromas are usually composed of hundreds of compounds carried in an air stream made up of further compounds. Additive, synergistic, antigonistic and compensative effects can occur between the chemical components contributing to a flavour, that is the aroma and taste as perceived by the human nose and tongue. A sensor that is highly selective for just one chemical compound is not meaningful in the assessment of flavour. The standard approach to flavour analysis in the food industry is the organoleptic panel composed of six or more carefully screened and well-trained panellists and following elaborate procedures (see Chapter 2). Due to the cost and time required for this approach, it is suitable for periodic quality control but not for continuous monitoring or field work. To address this problem, electronic noses and tongues have been developed. These are modelled on the mammalian nose and tongue but of lesser complexity, and each of these systems is intended for a specific range of applications. They are based on arrays of (typically about 20) sensors with broadly overlapping specificities combined with pattern recognition methods including neural networks (Chapter 19; Kress-Rogers 1997). 1.3.4 The marker approach; novel sensors In the case of lengthy tests for properties such as freshness, the progress of microbial or oxidative degradation processes, or taste and texture, efforts are increasingly made to
16
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
identify and measure chemical or physical indicator variables linked to the condition. This can be described as the marker approach. For example, prototype probes for meat freshness and frying oil quality assessment have been developed, based on a biosensor array and a vibrating rod viscometer, respectively. The assessment of meat and fish freshness by indicator gases and volatiles or by compounds involved in the decomposition of ATP have received increasing attention in recent years (Chapters 19, 20, 22). Novel chemical sensors, including biosensors (Turner et al. 1987; Scheller and Schmid 1992; Kress-Rogers 1997), have been developed in the last four decades, and the pace of this development has gained momentum. A sizeable number of biosensors have already been adapted for food applications. Many other sophisticated biosensor adaptations for the food industry are still at the prototype stage. This is consistent with the delay between the research and application stages of clinical biosensors, for example, which have received attention and funding earlier and more lavishly. In the absence of fully optimized biosensors for food applications, many current practical biosensor applications in the food industry employ the robotic approach (see above). Earlier, the microelectronic pH and ion sensors (primarily ion-selective FETs or ISFETs) had a hesitant commercial development. In recent years, however, commercial instruments designed for the food industry have been available and have solved many of the problems experienced with traditional pH and ion probes (hazard of glass membrane, laborious maintenance, etc.). Fibre-optic probes for chemical sensing are continuing to make progress. They are immune to EMI (electromagnetic interference) in microwave ovens, and can be configured as robust and mechanically flexible remote probes. Optical sensors are also the basis of novel immunosensors (Chapter 20). 1.3.5 Instrumentation as an interdisciplinary subject The development and implementation of successful new measurement applications are tasks requiring effective interdisciplinary communication and cooperation. This can be accomplished only when instrument suppliers and users have a common basis of understanding of the interplay between the physical, chemical and microbial properties of the food and its environment on the one hand, and the physics, chemistry and electronics governing the instrument characteristics on the other. An awareness of the nature of the reference method and of the significance of the target variable for the food processing operation is also needed. In moisture measurement, for example, one has to establish whether the total water content is most relevant, or whether only water molecules with a high degree of mobility play a role. This will depend on whether the measurement is undertaken on account of legal requirements regarding the maximum water content of, e.g. margarine, for the price definition of commodities such as wheat, or with a view to the influence of the water content on the product texture or its relationship with the water activity. The lastmentioned factor determines the stability towards microbial spoilage and water migration from pie filling to pie shell, for example. Water activity is usually determined by a measurement of the equilibrium relative humidity of the sample, which by definition cannot be measured instantaneously. Instead, the water content can be measured in-line, and the water activity can then be deduced for a given product with a given processing history. Moisture and microbes are both ubiquitous, and improved instrumentation for their determination has been a prime concern for the food industry for many years (Chapters 6, 9, 12, 13, 16 on moisture and water activity, Chapters 17, 19–23 on specific microbes and microbial load).
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
17
From the instrument engineer’s point of view, it may seem surprising, at first glance, to find methods based on a physical interaction of the sample with the instrument (using visible, near infrared, microwave or ultrasound waves, or employing mechanical stress; Chapters 3–9, 12–15, 18) and those based on chemical interactions (Chapters 19–23) presented together. The food scientist, on the other hand, may prefer to consider instruments for the determination of physical properties (rheology, colour, density, particle size) of the sample separately from those for the assay of chemical or microbiological properties. Process control engineers may wish to separate on-line and at-line instrumentation from off-line instruments. However, in formulating a system of quality assurance and quality control procedures for a food manufacturing process, it is advantageous to be aware of the alternative techniques, each with its own characteristics, for the determination of a particular sample property (for example, for sugars, see Chapters 6, 8, 12, 13, 20–23; for water content see Chapters 6, 9, 12, 13). A number of instrument types allow the measurement of both physical and chemical properties. For example, bulk density and water content can be determined simultaneously by a microwave technique (Chapter 9; Kress-Rogers and Kent 1987); film thickness and composition can be measured with near infrared instruments (Chapter 6). Also, there is often a choice between process control based on measuring a certain set of variables upstream and in-line (for example, pressure, temperature, pH), and that based on measuring another set downstream and off-line (for example, glucose/sucrose ratio). As a further option, some off-line instruments can be used at-line with the help of robotic sampling and sample preparation, thus providing rapid feedback based on a wider range of measured variables. On-line and QC laboratory methods have to interlink in guiding process control, and are therefore presented together in this book, with the emphasis on the interplay between the instrumental method, the food and the manufacturing process.
1.4
Measurement types
1.4.1 Target variables The on-line or rapid at-line measurement of variables relevant to the eating quality, the wholesomeness and the safety of the food product is an increasing concern of the food industry, and this is reflected in the topics covered in this book. Colour and other aspects of the appearance are dominant in determining the first impression and influence the choice of food products by the consumer. Aroma, taste, and texture or mouthfeel influence the enjoyment of the food and determine whether the consumer comes back for more of the product. The rheological properties also affect the handling characteristics of the product both in processing and in the hands of the consumer. All these food properties can be assessed by panels of trained persons, or animals in the case of petfood (Chapter 2). However, for frequent control purposes this is not practical, and instruments for the measurement of colour attributes, of variables related to the chemical composition (either proximate analysis or more specific and sensitive measurements) and of those related to the physical structure of the food (rheology, particle size, new methods in texture assessment) are used if equipment of the desired specifications is available (Chapters 3–5, 6, 8, 14, 15, 18, 20–23). Electronic noses and tongues have been developed in recent years to mimic the human (or pet) sense of smell and taste for specific applications (Chapter 19). The assessment of wholesomeness and safety is not generally possible or advisable with the human senses, and instruments or laboratory tests will always be required for
Table 1.6 The significance of measurements for the manufacturing operation
Colour Sorting by colour Temperature Temperature – time integral Pressure Level and flow rate Particle, droplet or bubble size Solid/liquid ratio and crystal size Bulk density Rheology Texture Water activity Water content Proximates: fat, protein, carbohydrate, ash pH Acidity Sodium, potassium, calcium Specific sugars
Microbial aspects
Chemical aspects
Physical aspects
Nutritional aspects
5
5
6
Texture consistency
Aroma
Taste
Appearance
4
5
4
Ingredients management
3 4 i
4 i
Process management
2
i
Production efficiency
Food quality
Food safety and stability
Compliance Legal conditions
Customer specifications
Labelling regulations
1
1 1
Total reducing sugars Solute concentration Alcohols Preservatives, antioxidants Vitamins, trace minerals Emulsifiers, gelling agents Flavourings, colourings Toxins, residues Volatiles during cooking Volatiles during storage Microbial load, contamination Biomass, functional Chilled meat freshness Frying oil quality
6
6
8
7
8
7 8
7 8
1 1
Key direct link; i strong indirect link; 1 influencing storage conditions or use-by date; 2 influencing packing density; 3 influencing enrobing thickness; 4 governing microbial growth and metabolism as well as chemical reactions and water migration processes, thereby influencing composition and texture; 5 linked to water activity for a given food with a given process history; water content is more easily measured at-line and can be used as an indicator of water activity under controlled conditions; 6 solutes such as sugars or salts reduce water activity and have traditionally been used to preserve foods (for example jam, bacon); 7 at high temperatures, reducing sugars react with amino acids to form a wide range of compounds that flavour and colour roasted and baked products (Maillard reaction); 8 for example, antioxidants reduce the rancidity of oils and the browning of produce. Authenticity assessment. The comparison of the sample’s free fatty acid composition, ultraviolet absorption spectrum or other ‘fingerprint’-type assays with the pattern expected for the claimed food type and origin is used in the authenticity assessment of foods.
20
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
these food properties, including the content of nutrients, microbial load, chemical contaminants, pathogenic microbes and foreign bodies. Not only the current status but also the stability of the product during the intended shelf-life needs to be assessed. (On the shelf-life of foods, see for example Chapter 7 in Stewart and Amerine 1982.) To this end, a determination of the product’s water activity, pH, packaging integrity, existing flora, content of preservatives, antioxidants content and other factors is undertaken. The temperature of a food needs to be monitored in heat processing (such as sterilization), tempering and conditioning and also in storage. Spatial resolution is often needed, particularly information on the hottest and coldest points of the sample. A timetemperature profile including integral, maximum and minimum is also an important measurement target. Remote infrared thermometry has the advantage of providing a noncontact measurement and is also the basis of thermal imaging systems (Chapter 7). A development for depth profiling is the distributed fibre-optic temperature probe. Table 1.6 shows the significance for the manufacturing operation of measurements of a range of variables. 1.4.2 Instrumental methods On-line instruments based on the interaction of electromagnetic waves or ultrasound with the sample are discussed in the first part of the book. In the second part, instruments in the quality control laboratory are treated. In the third part, the expanding range of chemical sensors, including biosensors, is presented. The development of sensors for the identification of an indicator variable that is more amenable to on-line implementation than current chemical reference methods for quality assessment is discussed. The assessment of sensory properties by both sensory panels (composed of humans or pets) and by instruments (optical instruments, electronic noses and tongues, texture analysers) are detailed. Instruments that require an understanding of their interaction with the food and the manufacturing process as a condition for successful application are the subject of this book. In order to provide a useful description of principles and food-industry-specific application details for such instruments, it has been necessary to choose certain instrument types to the exclusion of others. Only instrumental methods that can be understood fully on the basis of classical physics have been included in this book; thus instruments based on nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or electron spin resonance (ESR) are not represented. This is not to imply the lesser importance of these methods. In fact, the development of new applications of NMR and NMR imaging (NMRI) to the food industry has progressed rapidly, and provides the basis for many new instruments (see, for example, Levine and Slade 1991, pp. 405–626). For the recognition of irradiated foods, ESR applications are being developed. Pulsed NMR techniques are already widely used in quality control in the food industry for the determination of water and lipids content and of the solid/liquid ratio of fat. Bench-top instruments for these applications are readily available and are being further optimized for a wider range of food applications (including the investigation of water ‘binding’ to biopolymers) and more convenient operation. Furthermore, research into the NMR characteristics of foods and the development of novel magnet designs for NMR instruments are now underway. This will lead to new application areas for NMR measurement in the food industry. One area is the on-line implementation of bulk NMR measurements as they are currently undertaken in QC laboratories. These are to become feasible for a much wider range of process lines than is possible at present. They will aid
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
21
in the control of many operations in food processing, including baking, drying, concentrating, freezing, thawing and tempering. The other area is the use of NMR imaging in product development and quality control tasks. This latter measurement type will, in the medium term, be restricted to central laboratories owing to the cost and complexity of the equipment. Also omitted in this book are those instruments that rely on ionizing radiation (such as x-ray foreign body detection systems) or on a substantial computing capacity, as, for example, image acquisition and analysis systems. Real-time processing and automatic evaluation of visible light, x-ray, infrared or other images is another area that is expanding rapidly. The underlying principles and application details relevant to the food industry for these systems could best be presented in a book dedicated to this area alone. The appendix to this chapter summarizes measurement types. 1.4.3 Fringe benefits The dielectric properties of food, discussed here in the context of measurements based on microwaves, are also relevant in the application of such radiation at much higher intensities to the processing of foods in industrial and domestic microwave ovens (Ohlsson 1988). Indeed, many dielectric data for foods have been acquired in order to predict microwave heating characteristics. For food scientists, a familiarity with the principles underlying dielectric measurement affords the added benefit of helping in the analysis of processing characteristics. To a lesser extent this applies to ultrasound, which also has applications both as a low-intensity signal used in measurement and as a highintensity irradiation employed in sonoprocessing and sonochemistry. The overlap between the food properties relevant for measurement and those relevant for processing is smaller here. Ultrasound processing is therefore briefly discussed as a separate topic (Section 13.2.7).
1.5
Further reading
The emphasis in this book is primarily on the measurement of food properties as this requires a particular understanding of the interplay between the instrumental method and the food and its environment. However, this understanding is also required in the measurement of certain process variables such as the volume and mass flow rates of food liquids with complex rheologies. Ultrasonic measurement of volume flow rate and of liquid and solid level is discussed in this book (Chapters 11–13). Volume flow rates do not always provide adequate information for materials with uneven aeration or temperature distribution, and are also difficult to measure for nonNewtonian liquids (Chapters 14, 15) or inhomogeneous materials. For materials such as molten chocolate, mass flow rate can now be measured successfully with Coriolis force flow rate meters (developed by Exac and Micromotion). These have the form of a Ushaped tube (or two parallel U-tubes), which can be flanged into the pipeline without restricting the flow. The Coriolis technique has been reviewed by McKenzie (1990), with details on one of the two embodiments. A straight vibrating tube section can be flanged into pipes for measuring the mass density of the process stream. The tube section is isolated vibrationally from the remainder of the pipe by bellows. Another sensor based on mechanical resonance is the vibrating rod probe for the measurement of level, density or viscosity. Such probes are
22
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
available in dipstick form or in flange mountings. This sensor family is represented in the book in the form of a prototype probe for the in situ determination of frying oil quality, based on a measurement of the viscosity of the hot oil by a vibrating tube viscometer (Chapter 19). A review of the principles underlying the function of a wide range of mechanical resonance sensors has been given by Langdon (1985). For the measurement of temperature, both contact methods and a non-contact method that also lends itself to combination with linescan and imaging techniques is presented in this book (Chapter 7, 10). Fibre-optic thermometers and quartz temperature sensors (shear mode resonators or tuning fork devices), which have become available for industrial applications in recent years, are reviewed by Schaefer (1989). Updated overview tables on the specifications of conventional contact thermometers such as thermocouples are published regularly by transducer magazines. This is also the case for strain gauge pressure transducers. Information on special miniature designs for pressure and temperature transducers that can be mounted inside sample cans during heat processing can be obtained from the suppliers. Humidity sensors have been discussed as parts of instruments for the measurement of water activity. Similar sensors can also be used in monitoring ambient humidity in many storage or processing areas. In the latter applications, the required accuracy is less stringent; however, the emphasis is on robustness and long-term stability with minimal maintenance. High temperatures often need to be tolerated, for example in oven flues (McFarlane 1983). Inexpensive miniature humidity sensors based on solid-state devices are now part of a number of domestic appliances (such as some makes of tumble dryers or microwave ovens). An overview of the automatic control of food manufacturing processes is given by McFarlane (1983). He describes processes in the areas of raw materials handling, recipe dispensing, pre-processing, cooking processes, biochemical processes, finishing and packaging. The range and tolerance for the controlled variables are given for each process. There are also books giving details on processing operations in one particular sector such as fish canning (Wheaton and Lawson 1985). Some recent developments in the control and optimization of food processes are presented in symposium proceedings edited by Renard and Bimbenet (1988) and by Spiess and Schubert (1990). A comprehensive compilation of instruments, each described briefly without industryspecific aspects or application details, is available in the form of a handbook on general instrumentation (Noltingk 1988). Often, instrument manufacturers will supply application details and related literature. An introduction to food science and food technology has been given by Stewart and Amerine (1982). Information on the physical properties of foods can be found in the books by Lewis (1987), Jowitt et al. (1987), Singh and Medina (1988) and Okos (1986).
1.6
References
and HILLIAM, M. (1991) The UK food and drinks report: market, industry and new product trends. Leatherhead Food Research Association Special Report, April 1991. BERRIE, P.G. (1997) Fuzzy Logic in the Evaluation of Sensor Data, pp. 469–500 in Handbook of Biosensors and Electronic Noses: Medicine, Food and the Environment, Kress-Rogers E. (ed.), Boca Raton, New York, London, Tokyo, CRC Press Inc. BAILEY, L., BOYLE, C.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
23
and ATKINSON, T.A. (1990) Oscillometric instrument for the non-invasive detection of low-level microbial activity. Biosensors and Bioelectronics, 5, 273–89. EERIKAINEN, T., LINKO, S. and LINKO, P. (1988) The potential of fuzzy logic in optimization and control: fuzzy reasoning in extrusion cooker control, pp. 183–200. In Automatic Control and Optimization of Food Processes, Renard, M. and Bimbenet, J.J. (eds) Elsevier Applied Science, London. GARDNER, J.W. and HINES, E.L. (1997) Pattern Analysis Techniques, pp. 633–52 in Handbook of Biosensors and Electronic Noses: Medicine, Food and the Environment, Kress-Rogers E. (ed.), Boca Raton, New York, London, Tokyo, CRC Press Inc. GEORGALA, D.L. (1989) Modern food processing, in Food Processing, Proceedings of the Ninth British Nutrition Foundation Branch Conference, Cottrell, R.C. (ed.) Parthenon Publishing Group, Carnforth and New Jersey. JANSSON, P.A. (1991) Neural networks: an overview. Analytical Chemistry, 63, 357A– 362A. JOWITT, R., ESCHER, F., KENT, M., MCKENNA, B. and ROQUES, M. (eds) (1987) Physical Properties of Foods Vol. 2, COST 90bis Final Seminar Proceedings. Elsevier Applied Science, London and New York (arranged by the Commission of the European Communities). KESSLER, H.G. and WEICHNER, K. (eds) (1989) Fouling and Cleaning in Food Processing, Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Fouling and Cleaning in Food Processing. Druckerei Walch, Augsburg. Distributed by: Heinz G. Kessler, Institut fu¨r Wissenschaft und Verfahrenstechnik in der Milchverarbeitung, Technische Universita¨t Mu¨nchen, D-8050 Freising-Weihenstephan, Germany; Daryl B. Lund, Department of Food Science, PO Box 231, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ 08903, USA. KRESS-ROGERS, E. (1985) Technology transfer. II: The new generation of sensors. Leatherhead Food Research Association Scientific and Technical Survey, 150. KRESS-ROGERS, E. (1986) Instrumentation in the food industry. Part I: Chemical, biochemical and immunochemical determinands. Part II: Physical determinands in quality and process control. Journal of Physics E: Scientific Instruments, 19, 13–21, 105–9. KRESS-ROGERS, E. (ed.) (1997) Handbook of Biosensors and Electronic Noses: Medicine, Food and the Environment, Boca Raton, New York, London, Tokyo, CRC Press Inc. KRESS-ROGERS, E. and KENT, M. (1986) Two-parameter microwave technique for measurement of powder moisture and density. Leatherhead Food Research Association Research Report, 553. KRESS-ROGERS, E. and KENT, M. (1987) Microwave measurement of powder moisture and density. Journal of Food Engineering, 6, 345–76. LANGDON, R.M. (1985) Resonator sensors – a review. Journal of Physics E: Scientific Instruments, 18, 103–15. LEVINE, H. and SLADE, L. (1991) Water Relationships in Food, Plenum Press, New York and London. LEWIS, M.J. (1987) Physical Properties of Foods and Food Processing Systems. Ellis Horwood, Chichester and VCH, Weinheim. MCFARLANE, I. (1983) Automatic Control of Food Manufacturing Processes. Applied Science Publishers, London and New York. MCKENZIE, G. (1990) Mass flow measurement. Sensor Review, July, 129–32. COSSAR, J.D., BLAKE-COLEMEN, B.C., RAMSAY, C.
24
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
NOLTINGK, B.E. (ed)
(1988) Instrumentation Reference Book. Butterworth-Heinemann,
Oxford. (1987) Extrusion Technology for the Food Industry. Elsevier Applied Science, London and New York. OHLSSON, T. (1988) Dielectric properties and microwave processing, pp. 73–92 in Food Properties and Computer-Aided Engineering of Food Processing Systems, Proceedings NATO Workshop, Porto, Singh, R.P. and Medina, A.G. (eds), Kluwer, Dordrecht, Boston and London. OKOS, M.R. (ed.) (1986) Physical and Chemical Properties of Food. American Society of Agricultural Engineering, Michigan. RENARD, M. and BIMBENET, J.J. (eds) (1988) Automatic Control and Optimization of Food Processes. Elsevier Applied Science, London and New York. SCHAEFER, W. (1989) Temperature sensors: new technologies on their way to industrial application. Sensors and Actuators, 17, 27–37. SCHELLER, F. and SCHMIDT, R.D. (1992) GBF Monograph Biosensors: Fundamentals, Technologies and Applications, Marcel Dekker, New York. SINGH, R.P. and MEDINA, A.G. (1988) Food Properties and Computer-Aided Engineering of Food Processing Systems, Proceedings NATO Workshop, Porto, October 1988, Kluwer, Dordrecht, Boston and London. SPIESS, W.E.L. and SCHUBERT, H. (1990) Engineering and Food, vols 1–3, Elsevier Applied Science, London. STEWART, G.F. and AMERINE, M.A. (1982) Introduction to Food Science and Technology. Academic Press, New York. THEISEN, M., STEUDEL, A., RYCHETSKY, M. and GLESNER, M. (1998) Fuzzy Logic and NeuroSystems Assisted Intelligent Sensors, pp. 29–59 in Sensors Update Volume 3, Baltes H., Go¨pel W. and Hesse J. (eds), Wiley-VCH. TILLI, T. (1996) Building Intelligent Systems with Fuzzy Logic and Neural Networks, John Wiley and Sons, New York. TURNER, A.P.F., KARUBE, I. and WILSON, G.S. (1987) Biosensors: Fundamentals and Applications, Oxford University Press, New York. VIDAL, P. (1988) Automatization and optimization des proce´de`s de l’industrie alimentaire, pp. 3–16 in Automatic Control and Optimization of Food Processes, Renard, M. and Bimbenet, J.J. (eds), Elsevier Applied Science, London. WHEATON, F.W. and LAWSON, T.B. (1985) Processing Aquatic Food Products. Wiley, New York. WIEDMANN, W. and STRECKER, J. (1988) Process control of cooker-extruders, pp. 201–14 in Automatic Control and Optimization of Food Processes, Renard, M. and Bimbenet, J.J., (eds), Elsevier Applied Science, London. O’CONNOR, C.
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
25
Appendix: Measurement types Measurement types discussed in this book Interaction of electromagnetic waves with foods or containers Range description
Order of magnitude of: frequencies (equivalent energy) wavelengths
Measurement applications
Soft ultraviolet, visible, near infrared
1015 to 1014 Hz 100 nm to 1 m
(Authenticity of foods) Sorting by ‘colour’
Visible
1015 Hz 400 to 700 nm
Colour (Optical imaging, for example to identify defective items or to measure dimensions)
Near infrared
1014 Hz (equivalent temperature of radiating black body: 1000 K) 700 to 2500 nm
Water content Fat, protein and carbohydrate content Caffeine contents of 1% m/m or higher Thickness of coated or laminated films on packaging materials
Mid infrared
1013 Hz (equivalent temperature of radiating black body: 100 K) 2.5 to 30 m
Volatiles in headspace Authenticity Identification of ingredients
Near and mid infrared
1 to 15 m
Remote temperature measurement Thermal linescan (Thermal imaging)
Microwaves
1011 to 109 Hz 1 to 10 cm
Water content of powdered or granular material Water content of low- and intermediate-moisture foods Water content of highmoisture foods Simultaneous bulk density measurement Fat content Ratio polar/non-polar liquids content
26
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Radiowaves, upper range
108 to 107 Hz 1 to 10 m
Water content Salt content Particle size, shape, distribution Bulk density
Note: Measurements based on ionizing radiation are not included here (for these see later in this appendix). Some applications involving spectroscopic or imaging techniques (not covered in this book) are given in parentheses in the column ‘Measurement applications’ in the table above. Interaction of ultrasound waves with food or container Common frequency and wavelength, order and magnitude Path through gas: 100 kHz 3 mm Path through liquid: 1 MHz 1:5 mm Path through solid: 10 MHz 0:6 mm Applications: Fill level of liquids or solids Volume flow rate of liquids, gases and steam Flow obstructions Location of interfaces between: liquid and second liquid; or liquid and foam; or fat and lean meat (including the back fat thickness of live animals) Solute content of a liquid Discrimination between two liquids (sensor can even be at a stand-off distance from the closed container) Scan of pipe cross-section for liquids carrying solid items Characterization of sheet-type solid passing on a moving belt Counting of food packs Suspended solids (in liquid) mass fraction Dispersed droplets or bubbles (in liquid) volume fraction Size distribution of dispersed solids, droplets or bubbles (in liquid) Creaming, sedimentation Melting, crystallization Solid/liquid ratio of fats Temperature Density of a liquid (as Z/c: see Chapter 13) Tissue structure Acoustic emission monitoring Range: Audiosound and ultrasound Applications: Powder flow Drying Grinding Foam evolution Cleaning fluid impact Cooker extruder performance
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
27
Interaction with chemical sensors, including biosensors and immunosensors Principle: Ion-sensitive membrane, inorganic catalyst, enzyme, antibody, specific adsorbent, etc. immobilized on base transducer, with electromechanical, optical, thermal or acoustic base. Applications: pH (by ISFET) Inorganic ions (by ISFET) pH (by fibre-optic probe) Acidity (by microtitrator, ISFET-based or by electronic tongue) Gases (by CHEMFET, MeOx or organic semiconductors) Specific sugars, starch, alcohols, amines, organic acids, amino acids, essential fatty acids, lipids, etc. (by biosensors) Vitamins, toxins (bacterial, fungal, algal) and specific microbes (by immunosensors) Residues (pesticides, antibiotics, hormones) by immunosensors Specific microbes (by DNA probes) Genetically modified organisms, transgenic crops (by DNA probes, by immunosensors for novel proteins) Meat species (by immunosensors) Fish freshness (compounds involved in ATP decompostion by biosensors) Under development: biosensors for extreme values of pH, pressure, temperature (based on molecularly imprinted polymers) Electronic noses and tongues, marker approach Aroma (volatiles to which the human or pet nose responds) Taste (sour, salty, bitter, sweet, umami) Titratable acidity Classification by brand, quality, etc. Authenticity Ripeness Freshness Conditioning Fermentation monitoring Monitoring of roasting Sensory properties by human/pet sensory panels and by instrumental methods Method: Determined property: Panel or transmittance, reflectance, Appearance (colour, gloss, shape) particle sizing Panel or electronic noses and tongues Flavour (aroma, taste) Chemical analysis (GC-MS, titration, . . .) Panel or texture analysers or rheology Texture, mouthfeel, pouring characteristics Acoustic emission monitoring Sounds during preparation and consumption (sizzling, crackling, crunching)
28
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Monitoring headspace humidity or broth impedance Method: Determined property: Equilibrium relative humidity (ERH) Water activity (stability towards microbial measurement growth and chemical reactions) Electrical impedance of culture broth (at Microbial load 2–10 kHz) monitoring (as method in rapid microbiology) Properties under mechanical stress Method: Rheological analysis Texture assessment Mechanical resonance dipstick probes Resonating tube section Coriolis force meter Mechanical flow rate meters: Positive displacement flow meter Differential pressure method Turbine flow meter Vortex shedding method Manometric method
Determined property: Viscosity, yield point Changes of the rheological properties with shear rate and time Texture attributes (crisp, juicy, rubbery, mealy, tough, etc.) Level, density, viscosity, flow rate Determination of frying oil quality Mass density of a processing stream Mass flow rate of liquid or gas Liquid volume flow rate Liquid, gas or steam flow Pressure
Monitoring process parameters with AC/DC measurements Sensor/instrument/method: Determined property: Pressure Piezoresistor Strain gauge on diaphragm Capacitive pressure sensor on diaphragm Temperature of the process stream (whether Bimetallic strip the contact measurement is representative RTD (resistance temperature detector) for the bulk of the food will depend on Themocouple probe the thermal conductivity and heating pattern) Strain gauge configured for hydrostatic Level of liquids head measurement Electrical capacitance Liquid level Conductance measurement Electrical capacitance measurement Solids level Electromagnetic flow meter Flow rate of conductive liquids Electrical conductivity measurement CIP cleansing agent concentration Electrical conductivity measurement Water quality (simple electrode pair at 1–5 kHz)
Instrumentation for food quality assurance
29
Further measurement types (not covered in this book) Observation of drying, extraction, reaction and chromatographic separation Method: Analyte: Drying or titration Water content Combustion Ash content Solvent extraction Fat content Acid digestion, distillation, and then Nitrogen ! protein content titration Combustion, and then thermal Nitrogen ! protein content conductivity detection HPLC (High Performance Liquid Specific sugars Chromatography) Ions (nitrite, nitrate, bromide, chloride, sulphate) IC (Ion Chromatography) Sulphite GLC (Gas-Liquid Chromatography) Pesticides GC-MS (Gas Chromatography – Mass Taints, flavours, spoilage indicators, toxins Spectrometry) Interaction of electromagnetic waves with foods or containers Applications using ionizing radiation are listed here. Range description
Order of magnitude of: frequencies (equivalent energy) wavelengths
Measurement applications
Gamma-rays (hard Roentgen rays
1020 to 1019 Hz (equivalent energy: 1 meV to 100 keV) 1 to 10 pm 1018 to 1017 Hz 100 pm to 1 nm ˚) (100 pm 1 A
Density
X-rays (soft Roentgen rays)
Foreign body detection (with linescan or imaging techniques)
Further measurements probing the properties of foods Method: Determined property: Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) Water or fat content Solid/liquid ratio Electromagnetic induction Metallic foreign body Electrical conductivity (multi-electrode Solution strength system or inductive coupling to overcome deposits) Note: The measurement of water content and solution strength is discussed in Chapters 6, 9, 12, 13; that of solid/liquid ratio in Chapter 13. The separation of foreign bodies by optical sorting is described in Chapter 5; impedance monitoring as a rapid microbial method in Chapter 17.
30
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Instruments not interacting with complex food properties Sensor: Determined property: Humidity sensors, based on a Ambient humidity measurement of: polymer or oxide capacitance (not suitable in ovens where ammonia and volatile oils are present) dew point Fibre-optic probe (with fluorescent Temperature compound on tip) Load cell arrangements Container weight Note: Remote thermometry is covered in Chapter 7, ultrasonic flow rate and level metering in Chapters 12, 13, the measurement of equilibrium relative humidity in Chapter 16.
2 Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters A. Hugi and E. Voirol, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne
2.1
Introduction
The human senses have always been used to assess food quality. For centuries they were the only instruments available, until scientific advances in physics, chemistry and biology, as well as the growing demands of the food processing industry, led to the development of analytical techniques aiming at understanding and controlling all aspects of food quality. Although the senses of sight, hearing, taste, smell and touch are used daily in all aspects of our lives, their analytical application to evaluate food properties is relatively recent. Since this discipline is based on the perceptions and judgements of persons, with their inherent inter-individual and temporal variability, it is not surprising that the earliest contributions came from the fields of psychology and statistics. The nineteenth century saw the development of a scientific domain called psychophysics, concerned with the understanding of how people react to external stimuli. The focus was therefore less on the object being evaluated than on the subject evaluating it. Nevertheless, several current sensory test methods stem from that period (Peryam, 1990). Modern sensory evaluation, defined as ‘. . . a scientific discipline used to evoke, measure, analyze and interpret reactions to those characteristics of foods and materials as they are perceived by the senses of sight, smell, taste, touch and hearing.’ (Anon., 1975), really started to grow between the 1930s and the 1950s, with significant advances originating from governmental organisations, scientific or trade associations, and private companies (Peryam, 1990). Since then, sensory scientists have continued to develop new methods and to refine existing ones, but the food industry as a whole has been relatively slow to recognise the usefulness and validity of modern sensory methods. Over the last decades however, increasing competitive pressure has led food companies to pay more attention to consumer needs and preferences. Today, foods from major suppliers usually offer comparable safety and nutritional value. Thus sensory characteristics are increasingly important for consumers as the differentiating factor between foods and brands. As a result, food companies recognise more and more the necessity to measure, optimise and control the sensory properties of
32
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 2.1
Examples of practical questions answered by sensory tests
Is this reduction in viscosity perceivable?
Difference test
What is the effect of modifying the recipe (or the process) on a product’s sensory properties?
Descriptive test
Can we substitute a specific ingredient by another one without affecting the sensory characteristics?
Difference test
What are the differences in sensory terms between our product and its competitors?
Descriptive test
What is the ideal sensory profile for this group of consumers?
Descriptive test combined with consumer test (preference mapping)
Is this product batch within specification?
Quality control test
How long can the product be stored before a significant change in sensory quality is noticeable?
Difference (or descriptive) test
their products. At the same time, the competitive pressure forces companies to master their cost structure, and to be more productive with fewer resources. Sensory evaluation is a good way to save money safely, for instance by shortening the development time of a new product or by reducing the amount of rework in a factory. This pressure on costs implies also a permanent search for efficient sensory methods delivering fast, businessoriented results. Sensory evaluation offers today an array of analytical techniques with wide-ranging applications in research, market surveys, product development, and quality assurance. It is used to answer many practical questions arising in a food company, such as the examples shown in Table 2.1. Given the high demand in time and resources of sensory evaluation, it is of interest to identify instrumental methods to replace it, particularly for routine quality control in a factory environment. Williams (1994) listed a vast array of chemical and physical information that can be related to sensory properties (Table 2.2). What is important to keep in mind is that a direct, causal relation between a physical/chemical measurement and a perceived sensory property cannot be simply assumed, it needs to be assessed and validated by a careful experimental study, carried on within the food product range of interest. While the concentration of sugar in a water solution has a univariate relationship with sweetness perception, this is probably no longer the case as the stimulus system becomes more complex, as in a confectionery bar, for example.
2.2
The nature of sensory perception
2.2.1 Senses as measuring instruments Information from the outside world is received via our senses and processed by our brain to determine our reaction and behaviour in response to these signals. The sense organs, together with their related operational physiology, and neural signal processing systems, are evolved structures which were moulded by natural selection operating on environmental selective pressures (Stoddart, 1999). We are sensitive to two kinds of stimuli, physical (heat, pressure, acoustic waves, and electromagnetic radiation) and
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters Table 2.2
33
Chemical/physical measurements relating to sensory properties (from Williams, 1994)
Measurement Light transmittance/reflectance • visual spectra • tristimulus values • ultraviolet/near infra-red Size and shape • grading • visual analysis Gas chromatography • volatile components Liquid chromatography • non-volatile components Simple chemical/physical measurements • pH, specific gravity, titratable acidity • density, fibre content • alcohol-insoluble solids • moisture • sulphur dioxide Mechanical deformation • shear measurement • compression measurement • puncture measurement Mastication Ultrasonics Molecular characteristics • bond length • spectroscopic information • stereochemistry
Related property Colour Chemical composition, general quality Appearance General quality Aroma, flavour Colour, taste, flavour Taste, general quality Texture General quality Texture General quality Texture Texture General quality Molecular aspects of aroma and taste
chemical. The senses of sight, hearing and touch react to physical stimuli, while taste, smell and trigeminal receptors react to chemical stimuli. 2.2.2 Physical senses Vision The first contact we have with a food product is often visual. Colour and appearance guide us in the purchase of fresh products like fruits or vegetables, and food manufacturers pay due attention to the visual elements of packaging in order to appeal to consumers. In food processing and cooking, colour serves as a cue for the ‘doneness’ of foods and is correlated with changes in aroma and flavour (Lawless and Heymann, 1998). The reader is referred to Chapter 3, by D. B. MacDougall, for detailed information on the physiological basis of colour vision and on the means to measure and communicate colour information. Beside colour, the assessment of food appearance includes many other visual characteristics that are related to physical properties: gloss, transparency, haziness, turbidity, uniformity of colour or surface, size and shape. Hearing This sense is of minor importance for the evaluation of foods, but it is not negligible: the noises of a cork popping out of a wine bottle or of a steak sizzling in the pan are signals
34
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
that we easily recognise and react to, even in absence of other sensory cues. Common noise characteristics of foods are crispiness, crunchiness and squeakiness (Meilgaard et al., 1999). In sensory terms, sounds are characterised by their pitch (frequency, Hz), intensity (loudness, dB) and persistence. Physical vibrations in the air, in the approximate range of 16 Hz to 20 kHz, cause the eardrum to vibrate. The vibrations are transmitted via three distinctively shaped bones in the middle ear to create hydraulic motion in the fluid of the cochlea, in the inner ear. The cochlea is a spiral canal covered in hair cells of various lengths which, when agitated, send neural impulses to the brain. When we masticate foods, a large proportion of the sound travels by bone conduction through the teeth, jaws and bones directly to the cochlea (Vickers and Bourne, 1976). Touch The group of perceptions generally described as the sense of touch can be divided into ‘somesthesis’ (tactile sense, skinfeel) and ‘kinaesthesis’ (deep pressure sense or proprioception), both of which sense variations in physical pressure (Meilgaard et al., 1999). Various types of nerve endings in the skin are responsible for the somesthetic sensations we call touch, pressure, heat, cold, itching, and tickling. The particular sensitivity of the lips, tongue and hands enables us to perceive minute differences in the geometrical (gritty, chalky, fibrous, e.g.) and moisture (juicy, oily, greasy, e.g.) properties of foods. Kinaesthesis is felt through nerve fibres buried in muscles, tendons and joints. We assess the mechanical properties of foods – hardness, cohesiveness, adhesiveness, denseness, springiness – via kinaesthetic perception of the stress exerted by muscles of the hand, jaw, or tongue, and of the resulting strain (compression, shear, rupture) within the food sample being handled or masticated. 2.2.3 Chemical senses Olfaction Olfactory receptors are located in a small patch of specialised epithelium in the roof of the nasal cavity. In this so-called olfactory epithelium, millions of neurones carry on one end several hair-like cilia immersed in mucus. Odour molecules bind to specialised receptor proteins within the ciliary membrane. It has been determined that mammals have around 1,000 different odour receptors, although they are capable of detecting at least 10,000 odours. Consequently, each different receptor must respond to several odour molecules and each odour must bind to several receptors. At the other end of each neurone, a fibre known as an axon runs into the olfactory bulb of the brain. The neurones expressing a given receptor are randomly distributed throughout the epithelium, but project their axons to one or, at most, a few sites called glomeruli, in the olfactory bulb. As the positions of the glomeruli are topologically defined, the olfactory bulb provides a two-dimensional map that identifies which of the numerous receptors have been activated in the nose (Axel, 1995). The dynamic range of olfactory receptors, between the threshold concentration and that producing saturation, is small compared to other senses like hearing and sight. On the other hand, the nose has enormous discriminating power: a trained perfumer can identify 150 to 200 different odour qualities. Moreover, olfactory receptors can be 10- to 100-fold more sensitive to some chemicals (e.g., allyl mercaptan: 6 107 molecules per ml of air) than the most sensitive gas chromatograph (ca. 109 molecules per ml) (Meilgaard et al., 1999).
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
35
Gustation Taste receptor cells are clustered into taste buds, onion-shaped structures embedded within the lingual epithelium in the fungiform, foliate and circumvallate papillae, and found also in the soft palate and the epiglottis (Dulac, 2000). An adult has about 2,000 taste buds, about half of which are situated on the circumvallate papillae (Plattig, 1988). Each taste bud contains 30–50 cells that project small cilia into the salivary mucus covering the oral cavity. We distinguish only five basic taste modalities: sweet, bitter, sour, salty, and umami (the specific taste elicited by monosodium glutamate), even though the molecular diversity of tastants is extreme, ranging from small ions to very large proteins. Thus, in contrast to smell, taste detects but does not discriminate between a large variety of molecules (Dulac, 2000). Because of this diversity, several pathways are thought to be involved in the reception and transduction of tastants, either via binding to receptor proteins (bitterness, sweetness, umami) or by interacting with ion channels in the taste receptor cell membrane (saltiness, acidity) (Laing and Jinks, 1996). The understanding of taste coding and information processing is still very limited, but the recent identification of a large family of 40–80 bitter taste receptors opens the way to significant progress on that topic (Adler et al., 2000). Chemesthesis In addition to taste and smell, there is a more generalised chemical sensitivity in the nose and mouth mediated by the trigeminal nerve, which is designated by the term chemesthesis (Green and Lawless, 1991). Comparatively less experimental effort has been expended in understanding the transduction processes involved in this sensory system, although the presence of several receptor mechanisms, ranging from receptorspecific to non-specific, has been hypothesised (Brand and Bryant, 1994). A variety of flavour experiences arise from trigeminal stimulation: the fizzy tingle from carbon dioxide in soda, the burn from hot peppers, pungency from black pepper or other spices, the cooling effect of peppermint, or the nasal pungency of mustard and vinegar (Lawless and Heymann, 1998). Qualitative distinctions among chemesthetic sensations are not easy, either due to lack of vocabulary or to poor discriminative ability. Another confusing element is that some irritants, e.g. menthol, also have taste or odour properties, while some tastants or odourants, like salt or acetic acid, can produce irritation (Prescott, 1999). 2.2.4 Interactions An important aspect of sensory perception in the context of this book is that foods generate a multitude of stimuli, which are processed more or less simultaneously to produce an integrated, overall impression. Along the way from the food item to the brain response, there are many possibilities for stimuli (particularly chemical ones) or sensory perceptions to interact, resulting in a response that is not simply the sum of individual responses to each independent stimulus. Interactions between stimuli within the same modality have been extensively studied for tastants (see Breslin (1996) and Birch (1996) for reviews), and also for odourants. Inter-modality interactions have been reported, particularly between irritants and tastants, and between irritants and odourants (Lawless and Heymann, 1998). Whether these interactions are physiological (at the receptor site) or psychological (central processing) remains unclear. There is no evidence for a physiological interplay between taste and
36
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
olfaction (Laing and Jinks, 1996), but under normal conditions of real food consumption, there is certainly a cognitive interaction between taste and aroma (Noble, 1996), not to mention the additional influences of texture and appearance.
2.3
Sensory evaluation methods
2.3.1 Discriminative tests Discriminative tests are used to determine whether or not a difference exists among samples. Two or several samples can be compared. Several types of discriminative test exist, each one corresponding to a particular situation. All are ‘forced-choice’ methods. The Triangle test is probably the most universal sensory method. It is a nondirectional difference test, used to detect an unspecified sensory difference between two samples. The panellist is presented with three coded samples: two samples are the same and one is different. He is asked to identify the odd sample, optionally he may comment on the intensity and type of difference. This test is useful in quality control, to check samples from different production batches, and to determine if any change of ingredient or process induces a detectable difference in the product, but it should be limited to relatively homogeneous products. The Duo-trio test is also used to detect unspecified differences between two samples. Three samples are presented: one is labelled as reference and two are coded samples, one being the same as the reference and the other being different. The panellist is asked to identify which of the coded samples matches the reference. This test, similar to the triangle test in its objectives and uses, has the advantage of limiting the number of comparisons (i.e. it is well suited for intensely flavoured products) but it is less powerful due to a higher probability of selecting the correct sample by chance. The above two methods do not require any specific training of the panellists. The Pair comparison test is a directional difference test, used to detect a specified sensory difference between two samples. The panellist is presented with a pair of coded samples and is asked to determine which one is more intense in a particular characteristic. This test is very simple, often used in quality control but its efficacy depends on the relevance of the chosen criterion of comparison. The Ranking test is an extension of the pair comparison test. The panellist is presented simultaneously with a series of coded samples (3–10) and is asked to rank them in order of intensity for a single specific attribute. This test is generally used to screen samples from a large group. It does not give any indication about the magnitude of the difference but only an ordinal evaluation, which is why results from different ranking tests cannot be compared. When these methods are used to assess products, panellists should be selected according to their sensitivity to the attribute of interest. These two methods are also well suited to select and train panellists for descriptive tests. Further to discriminative tests, the sensory analyst is generally interested in obtaining more detailed information about sensory characteristics of the products: descriptive tests aim to identify, measure and compare the sensory attributes of the products. 2.3.2 Descriptive tests The aim of a descriptive test is to describe with a complete and non-redundant set of pertinent attributes the sensory properties of a product and to quantify the perceived intensity of each attribute on a scale. The outcome of this process is referred to as a
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
37
sensory profile. Several types of descriptive tests have been developed. The Flavor profile was the first technique developed (Arthur D. Little Inc., 1958). A small panel of four to six trained assessors analyses and discusses the flavour characteristics in both qualitative and quantitative terms. The products are first analysed individually for aroma, flavour, mouthfeel, after-taste and overall impression or ‘amplitude’, then the assessors sit around a table and discuss their evaluation in group to reach a consensus. Extensive use of reference materials is made to achieve a complete description of the product. The final profile, consolidated by the panel leader, presents the detectable attributes (‘character notes’) in order of detection and their intensity scored on the following scale: 0 = not present )( = threshold 1 or + = slight 2 or ++ = moderate 3 or +++ = strong The final flavour profile being a group consensus, no statistical analysis can be carried out to compare different products. The Texture profileÕ was developed in the 1960s by the General Food Research Center. It is defined as ‘the sensory analysis of the texture complex of a food in terms of its mechanical, geometrical, fat and moisture characteristics, the degree of each present and the order in which they appear from first bite to complete mastication’ (Brandt et al., 1963). The Texture profile is rather similar to a flavour profile approach with panellists discussing results in order to reach a consensus. Each texture attribute is illustrated by references to represent each scale category. The number of scale categories can vary from five to nine, depending on the specific attribute. The reference foods are standardised with respect to brand name, handling procedure, sample size and temperature. The problem of such a method can be the variability of the references and the sensory fatigue due to extensive use of references during the test. Moreover, it is not realistic to separate texture from all other sensory properties because perceptions are interdependent and the exclusion of some other sensory attributes from the profile does not eliminate their perception. The Quantitative Descriptive AnalysisÕ (QDA) was developed by Stone et al. (1974) and is now widely accepted as the standard profiling method by most sensory analysts. It is a time-consuming and complex method but has broad applications such as description of complex products, comparison of products with identification and quantification of their differences, explanation of consumers’ preferences, correlation with instrumental measures. Thus QDA is widely used in product development, quality assurance, shelf life testing, cost optimisation and market survey. Results can be related to instrumental, chemical or physical properties of the products. The set up of this method requires several steps: • • • •
select and train a panel generate the descriptive vocabulary prepare the questionnaire and the glossary create an experimental design taking into account the number of products, number of tasters and number of replicates • organise the evaluation (sample coding, preparation, service, data acquisition) • analyse the results and present them in a synthetic and understandable form.
38
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
The ideal number of panellists is 10 to 12. This number is large enough to avoid too much variability of the results dependent on too few subjects, and small enough to ensure an efficient and homogeneous training of the group. Prior to training, the panellists should be screened according to their familiarity with the type of product considered, to their ability to perceive differences, to verbalise and to work as a group. After selection of the actual range of products to be profiled, the panellists are asked to generate a list of attributes to describe all the products’ sensory properties, grouped by modalities: appearance, aroma, flavour, texture, mouthfeel and after-taste. Sometimes only some sensory aspects are considered, for instance colour and appearance of the product, in which case it is called Appearance Profile Analysis (APA) (Hutchings, 1994). The generation of vocabulary is facilitated by the panel leader who helps in reducing the number of attributes, reaching consensus on the meaning of terms and writing the definitions of the glossary. Usually 100 to 200 descriptors are generated by the panellists, then the vocabulary is reduced to 15–30 key attributes in the final questionnaire. The role of the panel leader is to facilitate the discussion and to organise sessions, but he must refrain from influencing the group. The panellists are then trained with product or ingredient references to illustrate the different sensory characteristics. This training helps them to identify and memorise the attributes and to develop a standardised evaluation procedure. The setting up of the questionnaire includes the choice of a scale to rate the intensity of each attribute. The scale must be homogeneous for the whole questionnaire. Two main techniques are commonly used: • Absolute profiling: the attributes are scored on a structured (numbered) or an unstructured (visual analogue) scale, generally anchored at both extremities by words. The scale is always organised so that the intensity increases from left to right. A 10point scale or a 15-cm continuous/linear scale is most often used. • Relative profiling: the attributes are scored in comparison to a reference sample situated in the middle of the scale. In this case the scale is organised so that the intensity goes from ‘much less’ on the left to ‘much more’ on the right. The relative scale is generally numbered from 5 to +5, with reference at 0. The relative scale is often used to assess deviations from the standard in QA tests or storage tests.
Training is essential to use the scale in a consistent and repeatable way. This is achieved by presenting several times standard samples illustrating the lowest and highest scores for each attribute, and intermediate levels. The complete training of a QDA panel is rather long; about ten 90-minutes training sessions are required to reach reliable and repeatable assessments. Nevertheless, and despite training, the panellists can have different perceptions and a certain amount of variability between them is unavoidable. The experimental design has to take into account: • the total number of products • the number of products presented within a session (4 to 6, depending on the complexity of the products) • the number of replicates (2 to 3) • the number and availability of tasters • the amount of time allowed to run the study.
To fulfil these requirements, products can be analysed according to a complete block design (all tasters analyse all products) or an incomplete block design (each taster analyses only some products). In any case the products must be evaluated independently and blind, with a monadic presentation (or against a reference for comparative profiling),
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
39
according to a balanced order of presentation to avoid bias due to order effect. Statistical treatment requires a complete dataset. Univariate and multivariate methods can be applied to analyse and visualise results: • The basic treatment consists of calculating the mean values and variability for each attribute and product. • Statistical differences between products can be assessed by a two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) on each attribute. This analysis, completed by a multiple comparison test (Duncan, Newman-Keuls, LSD...) allows the identification of significantly different products. Results are visualised graphically by bar charts or profiles (linear or spider webs) as shown on Fig. 2.1. • In a second step, multivariate analysis such as Principal Components Analysis (PCA), Discriminant Analysis (DA) or Partial Least Square Regression (PLS) can be used to reduce the multidimensionality of the data and to look at the relationships between products and attributes. Results are visualised on a biplot graph. An example of PCA mapping of coffees is presented in Fig. 2.2.
Spectrum descriptive analysisTM was developed from the flavour and texture profile methods (Meilgaard et al., 1999). In this case, the panellist scores individually the perceived intensities with reference to pre-learned ‘absolute’ intensity scales in order to obtain profiles universally understandable and usable by everyone. The method provides lexicons of attributes similar to those of QDA; each attribute is illustrated by standards that define a scale of intensity going from 0 to 15. The use of this method requires extensive training, because panellists have to be universal. Free-Choice Profiling is an original technique of free description (Williams and Arnold, 1984). Panellists describe the products with their own words associated to their
Fig. 2.1
Aroma profile of two different soluble coffees presented in bar chart, linear profile and spider web.
40
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 2.2
PCA mapping of eight soluble coffees with varying Arabica/Robusta blend, and varying roasting level.
own scales. The advantage of such a technique is that it saves time since no specific screening or training is needed for the panellists. This method can be applied to all sensory aspects of the products or limited to some characteristics i.e. flavour or texture. Six to ten assessors are generally required. Data are analysed using a Generalised Procrustes Analysis. Free-Choice profiling has been often used in consumer tests, it can be considered as a good communication tool to relate marketing or consumer profiles to traditional QDA. It can be applied in panellist training, for descriptors consensus within a panel, or for agreement between several panels. 2.3.3 Quality control tests The major application of sensory tests in production is to measure product conformity to a standard, in order to ensure quality consistency. A number of tests have been developed or adapted for quality control over the last 30 years, although some of the tests reported in the literature are not recommended for quality control purposes (Mun˜oz et al., 1992). Sound sensory tests for QC share some common and important features: • product standards and specifications based on some consumer input, defining what the product is expected to be and the range of acceptable sensory variability • a sensory panel trained on these specifications, using appropriate reference products • a test methodology allowing quick and unambiguous decisions regarding product release or corrective actions.
The Quality Ratings Method is derived from the early sensory approach relying on ‘experts’ to judge the quality of products, and uses a panel to evaluate daily production on a quality scale ranging from ‘very poor’ to ‘excellent’ (or equivalent designations). Products below a certain quality level or grade are rejected. This method has enjoyed vast
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
41
popularity, even outside the factory environment, and several professional associations have published such methodologies for various types of products (e.g. for dairy products, see Bodyfelt et al. (1988)). Despite its popularity, this method presents several methodological flaws and is recommended only under special conditions (Mun˜oz et al., 1992). Another widely used test is the In/Out Method (Nakayama and Wessman, 1979). A trained panel evaluates daily production as being either within (‘in’) or outside (‘out’) some well-defined sensory specifications. The percentage of panellists who score the product as ‘in’ determines the actions to take, according to decision rules set by the management. Advantages of this method are its simplicity, the direct use of the results and the panellists’ motivation to participate in the decision-making process. Disadvantages are that relatively many panellists are needed to be able to analyse data in a statistical way, and the lack of information on the source of the problem when a product is ‘out’. This can be alleviated by including comments or descriptive ratings in the test, but at the expense of its simplicity and speed. The Difference-from-Control Method (Aust et al., 1985) involves rating on a scale how much different a sample is from a designated reference. Products are rejected if they are beyond a cut-off point on the scale. This method requires a consistent easy-to-hold or easy-to-reproduce control. Like the In/Out method, it is fast to implement and operate, and panel training is relatively easy. However, the test result indicates the amplitude of the difference, not its nature. Here too, adding to the test some attributes rating provides additional information, but that increases also the time needed to train the panel and to execute the test. The most comprehensive approach is the Descriptive Method (Sidel et al., 1983). A well-trained sensory panel evaluates the intensity of several key sensory attributes, known to vary during production and to affect consumer acceptance. Specifications consist of tolerance ranges for each attribute, and a product falling outside any of these ranges is deemed unacceptable. This method provides the most detailed information about what is varying in a product, by how much and in which direction. Obviously, this is also the method requiring the most time for panel training and operation.
2.4
Sensory-instrumental relations
2.4.1 Principles There are frequent occasions when it is desirable to relate sensory and instrumental data. This can be to understand the chemical and physical causes of the sensory properties in a product, or to reduce the sample load on a factory sensory panel by replacing some of the tests with instrumental analyses. Needs will differ in research and in production environments, as will the approaches and means used to address them. In any case, this will require a thoroughly planned and executed ‘sensory-instrumental relation’ study. Definition of the objective The first step is to define clearly and fully the objective of the relation study, i.e. which sensory property(ies) has to be related with which instrumental parameter(s) for which product (type), and to design the experiments to be conducted in view of this objective. This is particularly important with respect to the range and distribution of samples that will be considered (see below). In a factory, a typical objective of such a study is to test instrumental methods that could be used to monitor product sensory quality (e.g., a micrometer for chocolate
42
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
grittiness, or a texture analyser for yoghurt firmness). Another goal can be to measure the physico-chemical characteristics of reference products used in sensory monitoring tests, to prevent them from drifting when they have to be renewed. A particular requirement in that environment is to employ affordable, robust instruments usable by unskilled personnel. In a research context, relation studies are used to investigate the influence of the physico-chemical properties of a product or ingredient on its sensory properties, or to assess the effect of processing parameters (including storage) on them. This may require more sophisticated instruments, but on the other hand, robustness and operator training are not limiting factors. A few examples of research objectives are listed below: • Assess the influence of process parameters (temperature, pressure, energy input, time, etc.) or equipment (size, supplier, etc.) on the sensory properties of a product. • Optimise the processing conditions to achieve a given intensity of a sensory attribute, or to keep it within certain limits. • Explore the potential of a different technology, or test new processing equipment. • Find chemical ‘markers’ to follow the evolution of sensory properties with time (during process, during shelf life, under abuse). • Identify physico-chemical characteristics that are related to key sensory attributes, in terms of consumer acceptance. • Predict the final product sensory profile on the basis of the raw material chemical properties.
Experimental planning Sensory considerations The sample preparation conditions (temperature, type of water, etc.) must be standardised, and appropriate test parameters must be selected (scale, use of a reference, number of replicates, etc.). A balanced presentation design is necessary to eliminate firstposition and carry-over effects. The performance level of the panel must be checked before the study. The trust in sensory data can be reinforced by showing its relationship with analytical data, but the panel performance cannot be assessed by any such relationship, particularly because the sample presentation design used for panellists assessment is different from the one used for samples evaluation. As for any sensory evaluation test, it is essential to ensure that samples are safe (microbiology, contaminants) before serving them to the panel. Instrumental considerations Forethought in method selection can considerably reduce the complexity of subsequent data analysis. The primary criterion for the instrumental method selection is its potential to be related to the sensory attributes identified as important. If several methods exist, only the most efficient should be selected. It is sometimes erroneously assumed that increasing the number of different characterisations reduces variability and increases the amount of information. More data is only potentially more information, but certainly more confusion (and more work). Adding more and more hay to a haystack will only increase the difficulty of looking for the needle in it. In statistical terms, this is referred to as the ‘curse of dimensionality’. Prior method validation is needed to ensure that the performance characteristics of the method meet the requirements of the intended analytical application. The potential of an analytical method can be reinforced by showing its relationship with sensory evaluation,
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
43
but its validity can not be assessed by any such relationship (likewise, the absence of such a relationship does not prove that it is not valid). It is important to follow rigorous procedures during sample preparation and measurements. For instance, make sure the physical properties of interest (in relation to sensory properties) are not masked by the recent thermal or shear history of the sample. Statistical considerations It is generally easy to gather large datasets during factory production or product development, but most samples are not produced for the specific purpose of relating sensory data with instrumental characterisation. A sound experimental design is necessary to obtain a valid model for the sensory-instrumental relation. This implies the three following steps: 1. 2. 3.
Identify the controllable parameters that will be varied (usually, these are compositional or processing parameters). Define the experimental region by determining a range for each parameter that corresponds to its expected variation in real conditions. Cover the defined region as homogeneously as possible, by using appropriate experimental design techniques.
The fundamental question in experimental design is not ‘how many samples are needed?’ but ‘how homogeneously is the experimental region covered?’ Moreover, it is crucial that the sample subsets used for sensory and instrumental characterisations are identical, which requires that samples be produced under stable and controlled processing conditions, and in sufficient quantity for each characterisation technique. Finally, data from any characterisation technique, even the best-mastered one, are never exact. Any measurement has some variability, the amplitude of which has to be known and controlled. Data analysis All available knowledge on individual datasets, and on possible relationships between different datasets, has to be gathered before analysing results. This helps to summarise data correctly and to select the most appropriate statistical methods. Summarising data Although some characterisation techniques (e.g. pH) yield a single value for each measurement, most techniques have a multiple outcome, i.e. they give a series of data points for each measurement. To simplify analysis and to focus on meaningful information, it is desirable to summarise multiple outcomes (Table 2.3). Sometimes pretransformation of data has to be considered. For example, a chromatogram can be taken as it is or standardised according to the odour thresholds of known molecules. Relating data A relation is obtained mathematically by a model that expresses one dataset as a function of another dataset. If two sets of data are related by an existing and accepted deterministic model, no statistical method is needed. Unfortunately, deterministic models are generally not available and empirical model building must be applied, based on the actual observations. Purely empirical models are valid only within the explored experimental region and should not be extrapolated outside of it. Data visualisation and descriptive methods, as well as prior knowledge, can provide hypotheses on the nature of the underlying relations. For instance, if a relation between
44
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 2.3
Data summarising for different types of multiple outcomes
Dataset type
Definition
Signal
A signal can often be summarised by a reduced number of parameters: maximum peak intensity, area under curve, asymptotic behaviour, perimeter of the curve (or the related fractal dimension). Distribution of the values of a single A distribution can often be attribute in several classes. summarised by a reduced number of Example: particle size distribution. parameters: mean, mode, percentiles, standard deviation. Often difficult to summarise Characterisation of a product consisting of many single attributes. because the characterisation is complete only when looking at all Examples: sensory profiles, attributes together. However, some chromatograms. profiles may be composed of subprofiles, like a sensory profile including appearance, odour, flavour and texture.
Distribution
Profile
Summarisation
Characterisation of the product as a function of one variable (e.g. time). Examples: texture analyser, gas sensors.
ice-cream texture and bubble size is investigated, the model is likely to contain the cube (volume) of the mean bubble radius. Knowledge-based models might have some predictive power outside the explored product range. The best approach with empirical model building is to start with a simple model and to increase its complexity only if it becomes more accurate, i.e. if the adjusted R 2 still increases. Finally, the chosen model should be validated. Validation consists of confronting the model – based on a given set of data (the so-called training set) – with another set of data (the validation set). It ensures that the model found not only applies to data from the current products, but also to data from any other product located in the previously defined experimental region. This check is essential whenever the aim of the model is to become a predictive tool. Method transfer If the sensory-analytical relation study aims at building knowledge on specific food products, ingredients or processes, its results will simply be applied within an existing project or prompt a new study. If however the purpose of the study is to set up an analytical method in production, additional steps must be taken to transfer the method to a factory. One frequent pitfall is that a relation study is made with very sophisticated instrumental methods that will never be reasonably transferred to the factory floor. If the objective of the study is to develop a quality-control tool (on-line or off-line), the constraints in terms of cost, complexity, and robustness must be considered in advance. Each quality-control method requires a reference measurement which frequently necessitates a more expensive, high-precision technique, which itself must be validated. This should be considered when establishing a method and its internal control plan. 2.4.2 Examples Colour and gloss in sugar panned confectionery sweets Together with colour, gloss is a key parameter of the aspect of sugar panned
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
45
confectionery sweets and an important factor driving acceptance for young children. For this reason, a study involving sensory analysis and instrumental measurement was conducted to investigate the effect of polishing on the visual appearance of this type of sweets. Sugar panned confectionery sweets consist of a chocolate centre covered with several layers of sugar. The top layers are coloured, then covered with wax and polished in a drum to give a glossy, homogeneous and regular surface. The aim of this study was to optimise the coating process in order to reach the optimum gloss with the minimum polishing time. Different production batches of sweets were sampled directly from a production line every five minutes during the polishing process: from 0 (no polish, no wax) to 20 minutes polishing with wax. These samples were analysed by sensory methods and instrumental measurement with a spectrophotometer. Sensory analysis A panel of 13 trained assessors participated in the study. The colour tests took place in standardised conditions, i.e. in individual viewing booths (Macbeth Spectralight), lit with an artificial daylight source D65. The sweets were analysed using the Appearance Profile Analysis method. Five attributes of colour and appearance were scored on a 10-point scale: chroma, lightness, shininess, colour homogeneity, and surface regularity. As it is difficult to score the colorimetric attributes of colour due to a poor colour memory, the panellists were provided with colour references to anchor the scales of chroma and lightness attributes (colour chips from Munsell Book of Color). A series of sweets of the same colour but with different polishing times were presented according to a randomised-balanced design to avoid bias due to presentation order. The same assessment was carried out independently for the different colours of sweets. Only the results of yellow and orange samples are reported here. Sensory analysis did not demonstrate any significant change in chroma nor degree of lightness with polishing time. However an important increase of shininess is observed at the beginning of the polishing process, i.e. up to about 10–12 minutes for the yellow and orange sweets. After this time the polishing process seems to become inefficient as no increase of shininess can be sensorially observed (Fig. 2.3). The homogeneity of the colour does not change with polishing, and the regular aspect of the surface is slightly increased up to 10 minutes polishing time. Instrumental analysis The colour measurement of sweets was performed with a ‘Macbeth Colour-eye 7000’ spectrophotometer equipped with a CIE standard daylight illumination source D65 (the same as for sensory analysis). A 38-mm view area was chosen. The presence of an adjustable specular port in this type of spectrophotometer allowed the measurement of the surface brilliance of samples by including or excluding the specular component (see Chapter 4 for more detail). Reflectance spectra obtained with specular component included (SCI) and specular component excluded (SCE) were different. Only the SCE mode showed differences due to gloss value. In fact, calculation showed that Lightness (L*) was the parameter most influenced by gloss effect, Lightness increased with gloss in SCE mode, corresponding to a lighter aspect of the colour, while no significant change in L* was measured in SCI mode. The difference between the SCI and SCE reflectance, i.e. E* (SCI SCE), gave only the gloss value by excluding colour parameters. This gloss value could be related to polishing time and to the sensory evaluation of shininess.
46
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 2.3
Increase of shininess as measured by sensory analysis; evaluation on three different batches of yellow and orange sweets.
The colour measurements on sugar panned confectionery sweets were performed with specular component included and an observation angle of 10º. The results presented are the average of 10 measurements. In general, parameters of hue and lightness were not affected by polishing time. Chroma tended to decrease, indicating that the sweets became greyer or less vivid with longer polishing time (Fig. 2.4). This decrease was not visually perceived, but it suggests that there could be a risk of colour alteration if polishing time is too long. For each product colour, gloss increased significantly up to 10–15 minutes polishing time, less afterwards. The sensory scores of shininess were very well related to instrumental ones expressed by E* (SCI SCE) (Fig. 2.5). Conclusion This study shows that most of the visual parameters of panned confectionery: hue, chroma, lightness and gloss can be easily and effectively controlled by instrumental measurements. These methods could be applied for quality control in factories.
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
Fig. 2.4
47
Changes in instrumental hue, lightness and chroma with polishing time; measurement on three batches of yellow sweets.
However, some parameters of appearance such as colour homogeneity and surface regularity can only be examined by human vision, as they result from a multiplicity of stimuli synthesised by the brain as one piece of information. Sensory results, confirmed by instrumental ones, did not show any noticeable difference in colour and appearance between 15 and 20 minutes polishing, suggesting that the polishing time of this specific type of confectionery could be reduced to 15 minutes without affecting visual perception.
48
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 2.5 Sensory-instrumental relationship for gloss; measurement on three batches of yellow and orange sweets.
Colour of UHT milk It is well known that fat content influences the perceived colour of milk. Conversely it has been demonstrated by several authors that visual parameters of milk or dairy products are used as cues for the evaluation of fat content (Tuorila, 1986; Pangborn and Dunkley, 1964). As there is a direct relationship between fat content perception and consumer preference, a change in milk appearance can influence acceptance. It is therefore very important to have a precise control of colour when developing new milk products, in order to maximise consumer liking. A study relating sensory and instrumental analyses of milk colour was conducted, first, to determine the visual tolerance of milk at two different fat levels and secondly, to assess how the colour and appearance attributes of milk vary with the fat level. The samples studied were prepared from two commercial UHT milks: skim milk (0% fat) and whole milk (3.8% fat). All intermediate fat levels were prepared by mixing the two milks in the relevant proportions. A panel of 12 assessors recruited according to their colour vision accuracy was trained for milk analysis using discriminating, ranking and scoring tests. The sensory assessments were performed in individual viewing booths lit with standard daylight source (D65, 300–830 nm, 6500K). The milks were presented in 30ml plastic cylindrical containers, filled up to the edges in order to have an easy view of the surface of the samples. The samples were observed according to standardised viewing geometry 0/45 (standard D1729-89 in ASTM, 1996) i.e., diffused incident light above the surface and viewing angle at 45º, with a distance of about 30 cm from the object. The
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters Table 2.4
49
Fat levels presented in the duo-trio tests, for REF 0% fat and 2% fat respectively
REF 0% fat REF 2% fat
0.1%, 0.2%, 0.3%, 0.4% For lower limit: 0.6%, 0.8%, 1.0%, 1.2%, 1.4%, 1.6% For upper limit: 2.4%, 2.6%, 2.8%, 3.0%, 3.2%, 3.4%
instrumental measurements were performed using a spectrophotometer Macbeth 580, with 10-mm sample depth, D65 illumination and SCE mode to take into account the effects of surface aspect that can influence sensory judgement. Visual tolerance The aim was to define the visual differentiation threshold of UHT milks having different fat levels. Two tolerance areas were measured for 0% and 2% fat. The limits of differentiation were determined by duo-trio tests using respectively 0% fat and 2% fat as reference samples. Table 2.4 indicates the samples presented. The differentiation thresholds were determined at the concentration for which 75% of panellists gave the correct answer to the duo-trio test. They were calculated from the linear regression between percentage of correct answers (transformed into Probits) and level of fat content (Fig. 2.6). The reflectance curves of all milks were measured simultaneously by reflectance spectrophotometry to obtain the E* corresponding to visual limits of discrimination. p E L2 a2 b2 The visual differentiation threshold for skim milk was calculated as 0.2% fat. This means that, up to 0.2% fat, milk is perceived as having the same colour as 0% fat milk. The corresponding E* measured by spectrophotometry is 1.25E* unit. Two
Fig. 2.6
Determination of visual differentiation thresholds: (a) from 0% fat content, (b) around 2% fat content.
50
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 2.7
Delta E* values as measured from both 0% fat and 2% fat standards.
differentiation thresholds were calculated for low-fat milk (2%): 1.2% (lower value) and 3% (upper value). This means that the colour of a milk with a fat content of between 1.2% and 3% will be perceived as that of a 2% milk. The corresponding E*s measured by spectrophotometry are 1.46E* units and 1.25E* units, as shown in Fig. 2.7. Sensory and instrumental measure of colour Milks of varying fat content were profiled using the Appearance Profile Analysis method already described (see previous example). At the same time they were measured by spectrophotometry using standard methodology. Both methods showed that most colour and appearance attributes are affected by fat content. There was good visual discrimination for the three main colour attributes: 1. 2. 3.
Hue changed from greenish to yellowish with increasing fat content. This change was particularly marked up to 2% fat. Chroma or colour saturation decreased as fat content increased, i.e. the green colour of low-fat milks seems more saturated than the yellow colour of high-fat milks. Lightness increased as fat content increased. This means that the green colour of low-fat milks appears darker than the yellow colour of high-fat milks.
The spectrophotometry measurements showed that the reflectance percentage (R%) increased across the whole visible range as fat content increased. This phenomenon is particularly marked at the higher end of the reflectance spectrum (Joshi, 2000). As discussed in Chapter 4, this is due to the higher scattering efficiency of fat droplets at longer wavelengths (Fig. 2.8). Figure 2.9 presents in parallel the changes of colour parameters with increasing fat content, as measured by sensory analysis and by spectrophotometry. Changes were similar and the correlation between sensory and instrumental data was good, particularly for hue and lightness. The correlation was also meaningful for chroma (R 2 0.88), although results showed that increasing instrumental chroma corresponded to decreasing sensory chroma (Fig. 2.9c). This negative relationship can be explained by an increasing sensory perception of whiteness, whereas instrumental chroma measures the deviation from an ‘achromatic white’ towards colour, resulting in an increase in C* (instrumental indices exist to measure specifically whiteness, i.e. ‘CIE Whiteness Index’ mostly used in the paint industry).
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
Fig. 2.8
51
Reflectance spectra of milks with varying fat content.
Conclusion This study demonstrates that sensory analysis is generally a necessary prerequisite to define production standards. In this case, visual differences are determinant to fix tolerance area, and physical values (i.e. E*) can be determined in relation to sensory data. This principle can be extended to other types of perceptions such as texture, taste or flavour. The instrumental methods developed to assess colour of UHT milks are very well related to sensory ones, so they can be used to control and optimise the colour of new milk products. Crispness of fried products Crispness is a desirable quality in many food systems, such as breakfast cereals, confectionery inclusions, savoury snacks, fried products, and so on. Much effort has been spent in academia and industry to develop an instrumental method to measure crispness, in order to understand and improve the crispness of products, and to ensure consistent high quality in production. These developments involved instruments that mimic the senses used to gauge crispness, i.e. tactile and acoustic. Typically, tactile information is obtained from the analysis of force-deformation curves of compressed samples. The acoustic part is analysed from recordings of sounds produced either by actually biting and chewing the product or by mechanical imitation. The following example describes an acousto-mechanical study on the crispness of coated fish products. Samples Five fish finger samples were produced in a pilot coating line with various breadcrumb materials. They were fried in a deep-fat fryer for better reproducibility and colour homogeneity. In order to obtain a broad range of crispness levels, a frying protocol was set up with two oil temperature settings (145º and 180º) and two frying times (3 minutes 10 seconds and 4 minutes 30 seconds). A total of ten samples varying in breadcrumb type, frying temperature and time were produced. Sensory evaluation A trained panel of ten people who had been selected according to their sensory abilities performed the sensory assessment. The training period consisted of 12 sessions of 90 minutes. In the first phase, the panel generated a profiling questionnaire focusing on appearance and texture, whereby panellists agreed upon the definitions and the evaluation
52
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 2.9
Sensory and instrumental measurements of colour parameters: (a) hue (b) lightness (c) chroma.
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
53
procedures, and set the extremes of the scales. Then the panel was trained until its scoring was repeatable and consistent. The questionnaire included 13 sensory attributes describing the appearance (swollen, golden, crumb size, crumb homogeneity, fatty), the texture in hand (crumbly), and the texture in mouth (breading: hard, crispy, fat; fish flesh: juicy, chewy, compact, stringy). Each attribute was scored on a 100-point continuous intensity scale anchored at both ends (not = 0; very = 100). All tasters evaluated products in three replications, according to a balanced experimental design with five samples per session. Samples were fried according to a rigorous procedure, kept in the basket for 30 seconds above the oil bath and served within 2 minutes to panellists, with randomised three-digit codes. Analysis of variance showed that the products differed significantly (p<0.05) on all but one sensory attribute (stringy fish flesh). The difference was highly significant for crispness (p<0.001), with mean scores ranging from 17 to 79 on the 0–100 scale. Between-product significant differences were identified using Duncan’s multiple range test. Acousto-mechanic measurements The mechanical properties of the samples were measured using a TA HDi Texture Analyser (SMS, UK). Two different sets of experiments were performed: in the first one, the fish finger was cut in the middle by a Kramer single blade to mimic the first bite with the incisors; in the second one, a five-blade shear cell was mounted to mimic molar mastication. Both experiments were run in 12 replicates. The force-compression curves were first visualised, sample by sample, in the order of increasing sensory crispness (Fig. 2.10). This gave an overall impression of the results. In
Fig. 2.10
Force-deformation curves for fish fingers, obtained using a Kramer single blade, plotted against average sensory crispness.
54
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 2.11
Spectrogram of fish fingers fried for 4 minutes 30 seconds at different temperatures (top: 180ºC; bottom: 145ºC).
Fig. 2.12 A typical time waveform for a crispy fish finger.
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
Fig. 2.13
Correlation between apparent fractal dimension (AFD) and sensory crispness. Mechanical measurements obtained using a single blade.
Fig. 2.14
Correlation between apparent fractal dimension (AFD) and sensory crispness. Mechanical measurements obtained using a five blade shear cell.
55
56
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
order to establish a quantitative relationship with sensory scores, the apparent fractal dimension (AFD) of the force-compression curves were computed using the Kolmogorov method, with the help of the Fractals software (Russ, 1994). Whilst compressing the sample, the sound emission from the fish finger was recorded with a microphone, digitised using the sound sampling hardware of a personal computer (Power Macintosh 8600; acquisition software: Sound Maker 1.03) and stored directly to the hard disk. A Fast Fourier Transform algorithm was applied to the data, giving a threedimensional spectrogram with time, frequency and intensity as axes (Fig. 2.11). These spectrograms are useful for a qualitative comparison of the samples. For a more quantitative evaluation, the waveforms in the time domain were analysed (Fig. 2.12). A typical crispy fish finger presents moments of low sound intensity interspersed with very short bursts of loud sound (‘cracking events’). The number of such events above a predetermined sound level was thus added up for each experiment. Results The correlation between AFD and sensory crispness is shown in Fig. 2.13 (single blade) and Fig. 2.14 (five blade shear cell). Although a trend for a positive linear relationship can be observed, correlation coefficients are not satisfactory (single blade: r 0.52; five blade shear cell: r 0.65). Interestingly, the AFD for the single blade experiment correlates better with the attribute ‘juicy’ (r 0.7), which seems to indicate that the texture of the fish flesh influences the force-compression curve with this attachment. The AFD for the five blade shear cell experiment correlates best with the attribute ‘hard’ (r 0.75), which is highly correlated with ‘crispy’ for this set of samples. Thus this attachment provides a better indication of the coating texture properties. The correlation between the logarithm of the number of cracking events and sensory crispness is shown in Fig. 2.15 (single blade) and Fig. 2.16 (five blade shear cell). The single blade experiments show an excellent correlation (R 2 = 0.871). For reasons discussed above, acoustic data correlate also very well with the attribute ‘hard’. This study illustrated the use of simultaneous mechanical and sound emission data to evaluate perceived crispness. In the case of fish fingers, acoustic data correlated well with the sensory perception, but the mechanical data (AFD) did not. The converse situation has been observed in other studies (with cereal extrudates, e.g.), where excellent correlation has been found with mechanical data and not with acoustic emission. This confirms earlier findings that our perception of crispness combines tactile and auditory sensations (Seymour and Hamann, 1988), but possibly in different proportions depending on the type of product. Conclusion Even the most promising, a priori, instrumental technique does not always relate well with sensory perception. A technique that works well for a given type of product is not necessarily valid for other product types. A combined acousto-mechanical approach offers the most versatility for measuring crispness in several product types.
2.5
Summary and outlook
This chapter briefly presented how our different sensory organs interact with food stimuli, and described the most commonly used sensory tests. Whether it is to determine if two samples are perceivably different, or to measure the nature and magnitude of
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
57
Fig. 2.15 Linear correlation between sensorially perceived crispness and acoustic emission data from a Kramer single blade experiment.
Fig. 2.16 Linear correlation between sensorially perceived crispness and acoustic emission data from the Kramer five blade experiment.
58
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
sensory differences among two or more products, or to assess the conformity of raw materials and finished products to sensory specifications, sensory evaluation plays a central role in the food industry. It remains the only way to evaluate how a food product is perceived by consumers, regardless of what the product actually is in physical or chemical terms. Clearly, consumers do not judge products solely on their sensory properties, and many other factors influence how they perceive foods: expectation, brand image, previous experiences, context, mood, socio-cultural background, and so on. Nevertheless, sensory quality is one element that a food company can control in order to satisfy and retain consumers. Combining instrumental techniques with sensory evaluation is of great value in at least two areas of industrial food processing. On the one hand, it can be used to develop cheaper and faster instrumental alternatives to sensory tests for quality control, where assessors’ availability, adequate facilities and sample throughput are often limiting factors. On the other hand, this combination can help to improve understanding of how ingredients, composition and processes influence food perception. In this chapter, we underlined the need for careful experimental and statistical methodologies in order to guarantee the validity of the outcome. Sensory science is steadily progressing on several fronts; molecular biologists are characterising the receptor proteins in the gustative and olfactive receptor cells, neurologists identify the processing pathways of the sensory signals by brain-imaging techniques such as fMRI and magnetoencephalography, and experimental psychologists test the influences of memory, emotional context, familiarity and other external cues on sensory perception. On the instrumental side, as well as electronic noses that are discussed later in this book, electronic tongues are now appearing, to measure solutes in liquids. New instrumental techniques are being developed to investigate further what happens during food consumption, either by simulating the mouth in terms of temperature, shearing, salivary environment (Roberts and Acree, 1995), or by direct sampling of volatiles in the nose, or solutes in the mouth, of a subject eating food (Taylor and Linforth, 1996), or by electromyographic recording of the movements of the jaw during chewing (Brown et al., 1998). This naturally leads to exploring the temporal dimension of sensory perception while the food item is processed in the mouth, to deal with physico-chemical aspects of foods such as flavour release, particle size reduction, melting process and interaction with saliva. Dynamic experiments use sensory methods such as time-intensity to track the evolution of a sensory characteristic over time, while time-resolved instrumental techniques monitor physical and/or chemical changes in the mouth and nose. This approach illustrates the complementarity of sensory and instrumental measurements in food research.
2.6
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Mrs F. Pourzand (panned sweets), Mrs P. Joshi (milk) and Messrs S. Livings, P. Visani and M. Baumgartner (fish fingers) for their valuable contributions to this chapter.
Instrumental measurements and sensory parameters
2.7
59
References
and ZUKER C.S. (2000) ‘A novel family of mammalian taste receptors’, Cell, 100, 693–702. ANON. (1975) Minutes of Division Business Meeting. Institute of Food Technologists Sensory Evaluation Division, IFT, Chicago, Illinois (cited in: Stone H. and Sidel J.L. (1993) Sensory Evaluation Practices 2nd edn, San Diego, Academic Press). ARTHUR D. LITTLE, INC. (1958) Flavor Research and Food Acceptance, New York, Chapman & Hall. ASTM STANDARDS ON COLOR AND APPEARANCE MEASUREMENT (1996) ASTM 5th edn, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia. AUST L.B., GACULA M.C., BEARD S.A. and WASHAM II R.W. (1985) ‘Degree of difference test method in sensory evaluation of heterogeneous product types’, J. Food Sci. 50, 511– 513. AXEL R. (1995) ‘The molecular logic of smell’, Scientific American, October 1995, 130– 137. BIRCH G.G. (1996) ‘Towards an improved understanding of sweetener synergy’, Trends Food Sci Technol., 7, 403-4-07. BODYFELT F.W., TOBIAS J. and TROUT G.M. (1988) The Sensory Evaluation of Dairy Products, New York, Van Nostrand Reinhold. BRAND J.G. and BRYANT B.P. (1994) ‘Receptor mechanisms for flavour stimuli’, Food Quality and Preference, 5, 31-40. BRANDT M.A., SKINNER E., and COLEMAN J. (1963) ‘Texture profile method’. J. Food Sci., 28, 404–410. BRESLIN P.A.S. (1996) ‘Interactions among salty, sour and bitter compounds’, Trends Food Sci Technol., 7, 390–399. BROWN W.E., EVES D., ELLISON M. and BRAXTON D. (1998) ‘Use of combined electromyography and kinesthesiology during mastication to chart the oral breakdown of foodstuffs: relevance to measurement of food texture’, J. Texture Stud., 29, 145–167. DULAC C. (2000) ‘The physiology of taste, vintage 2000’, Cell, 100, 607–610. GREEN B.G. and LAWLESS H.T. (1991) ‘The psychophysics of somatosensory chemoreception in the nose and mouth’, in Getchell T.V., Doty R.L., Bartoshuk L.M. and Snow J.B., Smell and taste in health and disease, New York, Raven, 235– 253. HUTCHINGS J.B. (1994) ‘Food Colour and Appearance’, London, Blackie Academic & Professional. JOSHI P. (2000) ‘Physical aspects of color in foods’. Chemical Innovation, February, 19–24. LAING D.G. and JINKS A. (1996) ‘Flavour perception mechanisms’, Trends Food Sci Technol., 7, 387–389 and 422–423. LAWLESS H.T. and HEYMANN H. (1998) Sensory Evaluation of Food. Principles and Practices, New York, Chapman & Hall. MEILGAARD M., CIVILLE G.V. and CARR B.T. (1999) Sensory Evaluation Techniques 3rd edn, Boca Raton, CRC Press. ˜ OZ A.M., CIVILLE G.V. and CARR B.T. (1992) Sensory Evaluation in Quality Control, MUN New York, Van Nostrand Reinhold. Munsell Book of Color, New York, Gretag-Macbeth Instruments Corporation. NAKAYAMA M. and WESSMAN C. (1979) ‘Application of sensory evaluation to the routine maintenance of product quality’, Food Technol. 33, 38–39, 44. ADLER E., HOON M.A., MUELLER K.L., CHANDRASHEKAR J., RYBA N.J.P.
60
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
(1996) ‘Taste-aroma interactions’, Trends Food Sci Technol., 7, 439–444. and DUNKLEY W.L. (1964) ‘Difference-preference evaluation of milk by trained judges’, J. Dairy Science, 47, 1414–1416. PERYAM D.R. (1990) ‘Sensory evaluation The early days’, Food Technol. 44, 86–88, 91. PLATTIG K.H. (1988) ‘The sense of taste’, in Piggott J.R., Sensory analysis of foods, 2nd edn, Barking, Elsevier, 1–23. PRESCOTT J. (1999) ‘Introduction to the trigeminal sense: the role of pungency in food flavours’, in Bell G.A. and Annesley J., Tastes and aromas, the chemical senses in science and industry, Sydney, Blackwell Science, 38–49. ROBERTS D.D and ACREE T.E. (1995) ‘Simulation of retronasal aroma using a modified headspace technique: investigating the effects of saliva, temperature, shearing, and oil on flavor release’, J. Agric. Food Chem., 43, 2179–2186. RUSS J.C. (1994) Fractal Surfaces, New York, Plenum Press. SEYMOUR S.K. and HAMANN D.D. (1988) ‘Crispness and crunchiness of selected low moisture foods’. J. Texture Studies, 19, 79–95. SIDEL J.L., STONE H. and BLOOMQUIST J. (1983) ‘Industrial approaches to defining quality’, in Williams A.A. and Atkin R.K., Sensory quality in foods and beverages: definition, measurement and control, Chichester, Ellis Horwood Ltd., 48–57. STODDART D.M. (1999) ‘The senses: Meeting biological needs’, in Bell G.A. and Annesley J., Tastes and aromas, the chemical senses in science and industry, Sydney, Blackwell Science, 1–11. STONE H., SIDEL J., OLIVER S., WOOLSEY A. and SINGLETON R.C. (1974) ‘Sensory evaluation by quantitative analysis’, Food Technol. 28(1), 24, 26, 28–9, 32, 34. TAYLOR A.J. and LINFORTH R.S.T. (1996) ‘Flavour release in the mouth’, Trends Food Sci Technol., 7, 444–448. TUORILA, H. (1986) ‘Sensory profiles of milks with varying fat content’, Lebensm.Wiss.U.-Technol., 19, 344–345. VICKERS Z. and BOURNE M.C. (1976) ‘A psychoacoustical theory of crispness’, J. Food Sci., 41, 1158–1164. WILLIAMS, A.A. and ARNOLD, G.M. (1984) ‘A new approach to sensory analysis of foods and beverages’, in Adda, J., Progress in Flavour Research, Proc. 4th Weurman Flavour Research Symposium, Amsterdam, Elsevier. WILLIAMS A.A. (1994) ‘Flavour quality – understanding the relationship between sensory responses and chemical stimuli. What are we trying to do? The data, approaches and problems’, Food Quality and Preference, 5, 3–16. NOBLE A.C.
PANGBORN R.M.
Part I
In-line measurement for the control of food-processing operations
This page intentionally left blank
3 Principles of colour measurement for food D. B. MacDougall, The University of Reading
3.1
Introduction
Vision, the most studied of all the human senses, has intrigued investigators for as long as man’s speculations or accomplishments have been recorded. Modern studies into the mechanism of vision and human colour perception began in the seventeenth century with the recognition that the eye’s lens must somehow project an image onto the back of the eye. Newton’s classic experiments on the refraction of light led him to conclude that the rainbow did not possess colour; rather it was the spectrum’s rays that produced the sensation (Wright 1967). The rationality of arranging colours into orderly systems based on Newton’s seven rainbow colours has resulted in many attempts to create colour atlases with equal spacing of adjacent colours; for example, the widely used Munsell system and the newer Swedish natural colour space. The former is based on five hues and the latter on the six unique perceptions of black, white, red, green, yellow and blue (Hard 1970). From the nineteenth-century experiments of Maxwell, Young and Helmholtz in mixing coloured lights (MacAdam 1970), it became clear that people with normal colour vision must have at least three retinal pigments in their eyes. By the late 1920s the eye’s sensitivity to light relative to wavelength was established, the so-called ‘standard observer’ defined (Wright 1980) and the Commission Internationale de l’E´clairage (CIE) system of colour measurement constructed. Since then, considerable improvements have been incorporated into the system to make it nearly visually uniform. With the development of the computer, complex colour measurements and calculations are now routinely used for such industrial processes as paint formulation (Best 1987) and the colour match prediction (Nobbs 1997) and control of the appearance of dyed textiles (McLaren 1986; McDonald 1997). Instrumental colour measurement is increasingly being used for ingredient standardization and product quality control in the food industry. The three interacting factors required to classify, estimate and measure the colour appearance of any object in a scene are an understanding of the human visual process, the effect of light on the environment and the nature of the material observed.
64
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
3.2
Colour vision: trichromatic detection
The sensation of colour vision can be thought of as the sum of the responses recognized in the brain from the signals detected by the eye of the scene viewed. The sensation is perceived as though it were projected out into the world from which it originated. This can lead to the error of imputing to the scene the sensations it generated. Sensations exist in the mind and not in the external world which produces them. Human eyes, with their near circular field of view, are composed of three membranes (Fig. 3.1a). The outer membrane, the sclera, is continuous posteriorly with the sheath of the optic nerve and anteriorly with the cornea. The iris and the ciliary body, which suspends the lens, arise out of the middle layer, the choroid, which contains the capillary network. The inner membrane, the retina, lines the inside of the posterior of the eye. The first step in the visual process is the control of the amount of light entering the eye by the iris. The flux passes through the lens to be focused onto the fovea in the central region of the retina where it is detected. The signal is amplified (Normann and Werblin 1974) and
Fig. 3.1 Detection of light in the eye: (a) structure of the human eye (b) distribution of cones and rods in the temporal side of the retina (nasal side is similar except for the blind spot between 12º and 18º from the fovea).
Principles of colour measurement for food
Fig. 3.1
65
continued. (c) spectral sensitivites of blue (B), green (G) and red (R) cone pigments.
then transmitted through the visual pathway (Rodieck 1979) for interpretation in specific areas of the visual cortex of the brain (Zeki 1980; Zeki 1993; Hubel 1988). The retina has two types of light-detecting receptors, the cones and the rods, so named because of their shape. The ‘photoptic’ colour-detecting cones, which are sensitive to three wavelength ranges, are densely packed in the centre of the fovea, which occupies < 2º of the visual field and is the basis of the so-called CIE 1931 2º standard colorimetric observer. The ‘scotoptic’ colourless detecting rods, which are over 100 times more sensitive to light than the cones, increase in density to 20º from the fovea and then decrease towards the periphery of vision (Fig. 3.1b). The 1964 10º supplementary standard observer was created to accommodate the improvement in colour discrimination as the visual angle increases beyond 2º; some rods are included in the detecting field. Light energy, focused on the retina, is converted into electrical signals by conformational changes in the photopigments in the multifolded disk-shaped structures in the outer segments of the rods and cones (Wald 1968; Hurvich 1981; Jacobs 1981; Stryer 1988). Although only the rod pigment rhodopsin has been characterized, determination of the spectral absorption of the cone pigments has been possible using retinal densitometry with colour-blind observers deficient in one pigment (Smith and Pokorny 1975). The sensitivity curves of human cones determined by Este´vez (1982) are presented in Fig. 3.1c. Rhodopsin absorbs maximally at 505 nm and the so-called blue (B), green (G) and red (R) cone pigments at approximately 440, 540 and 570 nm respectively. The sensitivity range of B marginally overlaps G and R between 450 and 550 nm, whereas the G and R functions substantially overlap, displaced from each other by only 20 to 30 nm. Thus monochromatic light at 580 nm which is near maximum for R appears yellow and not red because of the combined contributions of G and R. Increasing the wavelength to > 600 nm increases the contribution of R relative to G and the perceived colour becomes more red. Cone vision is trichromatic; this means that any coloured light can be matched by a suitable mixture of red, green and blue primary lights, which is what would be expected from a three-receptor system. The actual colour-matching functions depend on the
66
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
wavelengths used as primaries. Although the initial detection of the stimulus is trichromatic, subsequent post-retinal processing gives rise to achromatic lightness/ darkness and coloured red/green and blue/yellow opponent mechanisms (Hurvich 1981; Hunt 1995). The lightness component consists of a weighted summation of all three cone pigment absorptions, whereas it is the degree of differences among the B, G, R absorptions that generates the opponent colour mechanism. However, the neural linkages among the pigment cone signals are not in simple one-to-one opposition. The simplest scheme that can be constructed is that the red/green opponent response is red activated by absorption of B plus R and green activated by G; yellow is activated by G plus R in opposition to blue activated by B.
3.3
Influence of ambient light and food structure
3.3.1 Adaptation and colour constancy Adaptation conditions the visual system to the chromatic nature of the surroundings as affected by the quality and intensity of the illumination. It compensates for changes in the spectral power distribution of the light and serves to keep the eye in balance (Boynton 1979). The magnitude of adjustment that chromatic adaptation has on visual experience is not usually realized because of the limitations of human memory for individual colours and the phenomenon of colour constancy (Brill and West 1986). White objects are recognized as white over a vast range of light intensity, from bright unshaded sunlight to the relatively dim levels of light found in room interiors, while coloured objects tend to have similar, but not necessarily identical, colours under most types of white illumination. Studies into the phenomena of adaptation which elicit this near constancy of colour appearance have been concerned mostly with predicting the changes that occur to colour recognition when lamp type and output are altered (Bartleson 1979a). Lightness and contrast among greys are affected by luminance while colourfulness increases with the level of illumination and varies with the spectral emission of the lamp and its colour temperature (Hunt 1977). This is further discussed in Section 3.6.1 on fresh meat, where the degree of red enhancement of lamp spectra is shown to affect the perception of product attractiveness. Models of cone adaptation response have been used to predict the consequences of changing lamp spectra on object appearance (Bartleson 1979b; Nayatani et al. 1986; Hunt 1987a). The concept of colourfulness has been used to construct grids of constant hue from which other grids can be derived for other illuminants (Pointer 1980, 1982). Such models use logarithmic and hyperbolic functions to mimic the physiological mechanisms involved. Hunt’s (1987a) model can be used to predict the changes that occur in object colours at any level of illumination for a wide range of backgrounds in the realistic situation where the eye’s fixation wanders. These effects of light quality on colour perception illustrate the difficulties in separating the concept of vision from that of appearance. Vision is modulated by the light from the scene, while the characteristics of appearance are modified by the light incident upon the object. Hence systems for classifying appearance and procedures devised for both observing and measuring colour must take account of the nature, quality and quantity of the light as it affects the observer’s perception. The British Standards Institute and the International Standards Organisation have recently produced general guidance and test methods of the assessment of the colour of foods (BSI 1999; ISO 1999).
Principles of colour measurement for food
67
3.3.2 Appearance Colour is usually considered the most important attribute of any food’s appearance (Francis and Clydesdale 1975) especially if it is associated with other aspects of food quality, for example the ripening of fruit or the visible deterioration which occurs when a food spoils. Nearly every food product has an acceptable range of colour, which depends on a wide range of factors which include variability among consumers, their age and ethnic origin, and the physical nature of the surroundings at time of judgement (Francis 1999). However, in addition to colour specification, the nature of internally scattered light and the distribution of surface reflectance are required for a more complete description of appearance. The food’s structure and pigmentation interact to affect both translucency/opacity and colour; for example, small changes in scatter may produce larger changes in colour than are attributable to change in pigment concentration (MacDougall 1982). The characterization of an object’s appearance is accomplished in two stages. The first is physical and the second is psychological. The physical characteristics are the size, shape and uniformity of the object along with the type and degree of pigmentation and the nature of the object’s structure that attenuates light. The physical information is converted to the psychological by translating the object’s reflectance or transmittance spectrum into the tristimulus values and then to a defined colour space. The concept of ‘total appearance’ can be applied to foods (Hutchings 1994). Total appearance is seen to comprise not only the physical appearance characteristics of the food but also includes such social factors as the observer’s culture, memory, preferences and the human appreciation of the product. Foods have an infinite variety of appearance characteristics. Their surfaces may be diffuse, glossy, irregular or flat. They may be transparent, hazy, translucent or opaque and their colour may be uniform or patchy. Hence colour-measuring procedures for foods often have to be modified from those used in the measurement of flat opaque surfaces such as paint and paper for which most colour-measuring instruments are designed. Different instrument optical geometries will lead to difficulties in sample presentation, producing different colour values for the same material. The inclusion or exclusion of surface specular reflection in the measurement depends not only on its importance as a characteristic of the food but also on the design of the detector-sensor unit in the instrument. Lateral transmittance of light through translucent materials affects their reflectance (Atkins and Billmeyer 1966; Hunter and Harold 1988; MacDougall 1988; Hutchings, 1994) and must be allowed for in the assessment of such products as tomato paste (Brimelow 1987) because the ratio of absorption to scatter varies with aperture area and the concentration of components in the product (Best 1987; MacDougall 1987). 3.3.3 Absorption and scatter The reflection of light from opaque and translucent objects depends on the ratio of absorption to scatter as affected by pigmentation, refractive index and the light-scattering properties of the material. The Kubelka-Munk method of separating subsurface absorption and scatter (Kubelka 1948) is fully illustrated by Judd and Wyszecki (1975). It relates reflectivity R 1, i.e. reflectance at infinite thickness, to the coefficients of absorption K and scatter S by K=S
1
R 1 2 =2R 1
68
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
which can be calculated from the reflectance of thin layers on white and black backgrounds. If K and S are required for prediction purposes, the accuracy of their measurement can be improved by appropriate correction factors for surface reflection (Saunderson 1942). Colour calculated from R 1, with separate estimation of the specular component as gloss is usually sufficient information to describe opaque objects, but for translucent materials K and S are also necessary.
3.4
Colour description
3.4.1 The CIE system The CIE system of colour measurement (ASTM 2000; CIE 1986) transforms the reflection or transmission spectrum of the object into three-dimensional space using the spectral power distribution of the illuminant and the colour-matching functions of the standard observer (CIE 1986). The mathematical procedure is given in any standard text on colour, for example Wright (1980); Judd and Wyszecki (1975); Hunt (1995). The system is based on the trichromatic principle but, instead of using ‘real’ red, green and blue primaries with their necessity for negative matching, it uses ‘imaginary’ positive primaries X, Y, and Z. Primary Y, known as luminous reflectance or transmittance, contains the entire lightness stimulus. Every colour can be located uniquely in the 1931 CIE colour space by Y and its chromaticity coordinates x X =
X Y Z and y Y
X Y Z, provided the illuminant and the observer are defined. The original illuminant representative of daylight was defined by the CIE as source C, but it has now been superseded by D65, i.e. an illuminant which includes an ultraviolet component and has a colour temperature of 6500 K. The colour temperatures of lamps and daylight range from approximately 3000 K for tungsten filament lamps and 4000 K for warm white fluorescent to 5500 K for sunlight and 6500 K for average daylight. Because the original 2º colour-matching functions apply strictly only to small objects, i.e.
Fig. 3.2 Colour matching functions of the CIE 10º standard observer.
Principles of colour measurement for food
69
equivalent to a 15 mm diameter circle viewed at a distance of 45 cm, the CIE has added a 10º observer (Fig. 3.2) where the object diameter is increased to 75 mm. The current trend in colour measurement is to use D65 and the 10º observer. The 1986 CIE recommended procedures for colorimetry are included in the ASTM Standards (2000) and also in Hunt (1995) along with the weighting factors for several practical illuminants (Rigg 1987). These include representative fluorescent lamps, of which F2 is a typical lamp at 4230 K but with a low colour rendering index of 64 (Fig. 3.3). The colour rendering index R a is a measure of the efficiency of a lamp at a given colour temperature to render the true
Fig. 3.3 Relative spectral power distributions of preferred CIE representative fluorescent lamps.
70
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
appearance of Munsell colours. The broadband lamp F7 has the same colour temperature (6500 K) and chromaticity coordinates as D65 and, because of its flatter spectrum, it has a high R a of 90. The triband lamp F11 (4000 K) also has a moderately high R a of 80, but its main advantage is its much improved efficiency in energy utilization. 3.4.2 Uniform colour space The original 1931 CIE Y, x, y system of colour measurement is not visually uniform (Fig. 3.4a). Constant hue and chroma are distorted and equal visual distances increase severalfold from purple-red to green. Improved spacing has been accomplished by both linear and non-linear transformations of Y, x, y (Billmeyer and Saltzman 1981). Near uniform colour spaces of practical importance are the Hunter and the CIELUV and CIELAB spaces. In the Hunter (1958) L, a, b colour space the lightness coordinate L is the square
Fig. 3.4 Colour diagrams: (a) CIE 1931 chromaticity diagram showing non-uniformity of spacing of red, yellow and blue unique hues (b) CIELAB uniform diagram showing relationship of red/ green (a*/ ) and yellow/blue (b*/ ) opponent coordinates to lightness L*, chroma C* and hue angle h*.
Principles of colour measurement for food
71
root of the tristimulus value Y, and a, and b are the red/green and yellow/blue opponent coordinates. In the 1976 CIELUV and CIELAB spaces (Robertson 1977), which were an attempt to reduce the many scales then in use to two, the lightness coordinate L* is the same for both but the spaces use different concepts in their construction. The CIE L*, a*, b* space (Fig. 3.4b), known as CIELAB, has generally replaced the Hunter space for industrial applications. The improvement is due to the non-linear cube root transformation of the 1931 tristimulus values which approximates the visual spacing of the coloured samples in the Munsell system. The formulae are L* 116(Y/Yn)1/3 16 for Y/Yn > 0.008856 L* 903.3(Y/Yn)1/3 for Y/Yn < 0.008856 a* 500[(X/Xn)1/3 (Y/Yn)1/3] b* 200[(X/Xn)1/3 (Z/Zn)1/3] where Xn, Yn, Zn refer to the nominally white object colour stimulus. Newer scales for determining small differences (BSI 1988), as used in the textile industry, are now included in the software of some automatic colour-measuring spectrophotometers. For example, the CMC(l:c) colour difference equation, where weighting factors are applied to the CIELAB L*C*h* data, produces a more uniform colour acceptability scale. 3.4.3 Further terminology Colour terms can be divided into the subjective and the objective (Hunt 1978). The subjective, the psychosensorial, are brightness, lightness, hue, saturation, chroma and colourfulness. Colourfulness, a recently introduced term, is that aspect of visual sensation according to which an area appears to exhibit more or less chromatic colour. Although hue is easily understood as that attribute described by colour names – red, green, purple, etc. – the difference between saturation and chroma is less easily comprehended. Saturation is colourfulness judged in proportion to its brightness, whereas chroma is colourfulness relative to the brightness of its surroundings. A similar difference exists between lightness and brightness. Lightness is relative brightness. Lightness is unaffected by illumination level because it is the proportion of the light reflected, whereas the sensation of brightness increases with increase in illumination. The objective terms, the psychophysical, refer to the stimulus and are evaluated from spectral power distributions, the reflectance or transmittance of the object and observer response. They provide the basis for the psychometric qualities which correspond more nearly to those perceived. For CIELAB space the more important terms are lightness L*, hue h* tan1 (b*/a*) and chroma C* (a*2 + b*2)1/2. Total colour differences E* can be expressed either as the coordinates of colour space or as the correlates of lightness, chroma and hue. Hence E
L 2
a 2
b 2 1=2 or E
L 2
C 2
H 2 1=2 where H* is used rather than h* because the latter is angular. For small colour differences away from the L* axis, if h* is expressed in degrees, then H C h
=180
72
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 3.1
Overview on colour description systems and notation
CIE system (1931) This is based on the imaginary positive primaries X, Y, Z (transformed from real red, green and blue functions of trichomatic stimulus detection which may contain negative values). In CIE space, colour is located (assuming defined illuminant and observer) by (Y, x, y), where Y x, y
luminous reflectance or transmittance (containing the entire lightness stimulus) chromaticity coordinates x X =
X Y Z y Y =
X Y Z
CIE space is not visually uniform. Hunter Lab System (1958) In Lab space, colour is defined by (L, a, b), where L correlate of lightness a, b red/green and yellow/blue opponent coordinate correlates L 10 Y1/2 a 17:5
1:02X Y =Y 1=2 b 7:0
Y 0:847 Z=Y 1=2 CIELAB system (1976) In CIELAB space, colour is defined by (L*, a*, b*), where L visually uniform lightness a, b visually uniform chromaticness coordinates L 116
Y =Yn 1=3 L 903:3
Y =Yn a 500
X =X n1=3 b 200
Y =Yn 1=3
16 for Y =Yn > 0:008856 for Y =Yn < 0:008856
Y =Yn 1=3
Z=Zn 1=3
Where Xn ; Yn ; Zn are the values of X ; Y ; Z for the reference white. Further terms used are h tan 1 (b =a ) hue C
a2 b2 1=2 chroma Other terms, such as adaptation, appearance, vision colourfulness, saturation and brightness, are discussed in Sections 3.3.1, 3.3.2 and 3.4.3.
A comparison of the major colour scales with the associated terminology is given in Table 3.1.
3.5
Instrumentation
Since colour is a psychological phenomenon, its measurement is based on human colour perception. Hence, photoelectric instruments must be corrected for both lighting and human visual response, while visual techniques must use observers with ‘normal’ colour vision under defined lighting. Examples of direct visual assessment are colour atlases for broad definition of the location of colours in colour space, collections or sets of printed or painted coloured papers specific to products or processes, and visual matching instruments
Principles of colour measurement for food
73
which use coloured filters. Typical of the former are the Munsell and Swedish NCS atlases which are structured on uniform colour space, and the Pantone collections of printer’s colours with defined ink mixtures printed from 10 to 100 per cent tinting strength. Probably the best known of the visual matching instruments is the Lovibond tintometer in which the object, under specified illumination, is viewed and matched against a series of coloured filters interposed over a white background by the observer. Photoelectric colour-measuring instruments can be divided into two classes, trichromatic colorimeters and spectrophotometers. The most successful of the early trichromatic colorimeters was developed in the 1940s by Hunter (1958). It comprised a light source and three wideband red, green and blue filters to approximate CIE standard illuminant C and the 2º observer. The tristimulus values obtained were transformed into Hunter L, a, b colour space. Until the advent of the computer and the photodiode such instruments were much less expensive than spectrophotometers and, although absolute accuracy may have been poor, they were very good at measuring the small colour differences demanded for industrial process control (Patterson 1987). The more modern tristimulus instruments are linked to computers with automatic calibration and the provision of a number of colour spaces. Such instruments may be supplied with a selection of sensor heads of different illuminating geometries to allow measurement of a wide range of product types depending on the nature and dimensions of their surfaces. A range of hand-held lightweight colorimeters and miniature diode array spectrophotometers, with optical geometries comparable in function with the larger bench instruments, is now manufactured by several companies. Their compactness is a direct result of the use of high energy pulsed xenon arc lamps combined with filtered silicon detectors and microchip circuitry. The comparative inexpensiveness of such instruments, with their built-in memories and choice of colour scales, has resulted in increased in-line colour measurement in all branches of industry where colour control is necessary or desirable. The most accurate colour-measuring instrument is the spectrophotometer. Reflectance instruments are usually fitted with an integrating sphere with the choice of including or excluding the specular component of reflectance. Care must be exercised in deciding which geometry is appropriate for particular applications. The diffuse component of reflectance from subsurface absorption and scatter is wavelength dependent, whereas the specular component is not. For materials with glossy surfaces the inclusion of the specular will increase measured reflectance which, when translated into colour space, can lead to large discrepancies in the interpretation of visual lightness, as usually viewed, and to a lesser extent of the chromaticness of the colour. For example, highly glossy black tiles used for instrument calibration have tristimulus Y values of approximately 0.3 when the specular is excluded but 4.5 when included. The consequence of this difference in Y of 4 per cent produces a specular excluded uniform lightness L* of 3 and an included L* of > 25. For medium grey and white tiles the excluded to included Y values are approximately 25 to 29 and 78 to 82 repectively, which give L* values of approximately 57 to 61 and 91 to 92 respectively. Hence the near constant effect of 4 per cent on Y from the specular reflectance produces a decreasing effect from black to white from > 20 to about 1 per cent in L*. The CIE recommends that colorimetric specifications of opaque materials should be obtained with one of the following conditions of illumination viewing geometries and should be specified in any report: • 45º/0 or 0º/45º, specular excluded • diffuse/0º or 0º/diffuse, specular included or excluded.
74
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
However, the spectrophotometers most commonly used for measuring colour do not have identical geometries. Three typical instruments have been compared by Patterson (1987), who points out that probably the biggest source of differences among the instruments can be traced to the specular component. Hunt (1987b) suggests that if measurements are to be compared it is better to include the specular because of the considerable variation in the area of gloss traps used in different spheres, but the more nearly correct measurements in relation to practical visual observation is with the specular excluded (Best 1987). For computer match prediction of pigmented materials, e.g. paint formulation, the total reflection (i.e. specular included) is preferred. This restriction does not usually apply to tristimulus colorimeters which normally exclude the specular component of reflectance where the illumination viewing geometry is 45º/0º, as in the classic Hunter bench colorimeter. Another important source of variation among tristimulus colorimeters and spectrophotometers is the area of the viewing aperture and the relative area of the illuminating light spot, which affects both the direction and the amount of light returned from translucent materials. MacDougall (1987) has demonstrated that translucent suspensions of milk exhibit a ten-fold decrease in K/S for an increase in aperture area from 5 to 20mm. Best (1987) states that accurate determination of K and S by measuring thin layers on black and white backgrounds requires that the ratio of the aperture area to the thickness of the sample must be considerably greater than 10, a criterion unlikely to be met for most foods. One further source of potential error, in addition to those associated with instrument geometry and sample structure, is the wavelength interval used to calculate the tristimulus values. Although the CIE (1986) specifies the standard observer at 5 nm intervals from 380 to 780 nm, such accuracy is not required for most practical purposes. For 10 nm accuracy the intermediate 10 nm values from the 5 nn tables should be used. However, the CIE has not yet officially recommended the use of 20 nm intervals, although many modern colour spectrophotometers detect at 20 nm intervals. Tables of weighting functions at 20 nm intervals for both the CIE illuminants and a variety of fluorescent lights have been calculated and are published in the up-to-date colour textbooks cited in this chapter. Errors attributable to wavelength interval are likely to be less important than those from instrument geometry, except when estimating the effects of narrowband emission lamps on materials with several absorption bands. Here the 20 nm interval may prove to be less effiecient.
3.6
Examples
The progress of pigment oxidation in fresh meat and the effects of illumination on orange juice are given as examples of the interaction of absorption and scatter on measured colour and visual appearance. The effect of the illuminant on the calculation of CIELAB from a variety of food specta is presented. 3.6.1 Fresh meat On exposure to air the purple ferrous haem pigment myoglobin on the surface of freshly cut meat oxygenates to the bright red covalent complex oxymyoglobin. During refrigerated display, oxymyoglobin oxidizes to brownish green metmyoglobin (MacDougall 1982; MacDougall and Powell 1997). Twenty per cent of surface oxymyoglobin with metmyoglobin causes the product to be rejected at retail because of its faded colour
Principles of colour measurement for food
75
(Hood and Riordan 1973). The changes in the mean reflectance spectra of over 100 packages of beef overwrapped with oxygen permeable film and held in the light at < 5C over a period of 1 week are shown in Fig. 3.5. As the pigment oxidizes there is an increase in reflectance in the green region of the spectrum as the alpha and beta absorption bands decrease and a distinct loss in reflectance in the red region with development of the metmyoglobin absorption band at 630 nm. The changes in colour, calculated for CIELAB and D65, are shown in Fig. 3.6. As meat fades there is a small loss in lightness L*, accompanied by much greater changes in the chromaticness coordinates a* and b*. The loss in a* and gain in b* can be interpreted as an increase in the hue angle h* in the direction of yellow; however, since it occurs with a concomitant loss in chroma C*, it is recognized as a more grey or dull colour. Dull yellow is perceived as brown. The appearance of meat is greatly affected by the colour rendering properties of the lamps used for display (Halstead 1978). Some fluorescent lamps recommended by the lamp industry for displaying meat have enhanced red emission which tend to maintain the preferred colour of oxymyoglobin and visually shifts the early stages of metmyoglobin development from brown towards red. This effect of red enhancement on meat colours has been shown to elicit a greater visual colour change in making brown appear red than in making red appear more red (MacDougall and Moncrieff 1988). For some people the flattering of red-enhanced lamps may make meat appear too red. The ICS Micro Match spectrophotometer used to measure these samples is equipped with the option of using alternative illuminants to calculate CIELAB. The estimated changes in meat colour attributable to different illuminants after 1 and 4 days’ exposure (Table 3.2) illustrate the effect that light quality has on lightness, hue and chroma. The changes in colour produced by the differences in colour rendering among some of the lamps are
Fig. 3.5 Reflectance spectra of fresh beef during oxidation of oxymyoglobin to metmyoglobin obtained on a diode array spectrophotometer at 20 nm intervals: means of over 100 samples wrapped in oxygen permeable film and stored at <5ºC under 1000 lux fluorescent illumination for 1 week.
76
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 3.6 Progressive changes in lightness L*, hue angle h* and chroma C* calculated from spectra of wrapped fresh beef stored at <5ºC under 1000 lux fluorescent illumination during oxidation of surface oxymyoglobin to metmyoglobin.
equivalent to that which occurs after 4 days’ fading, that is L* 1, C* 4 and h* 7. There was little change in L* on changing illuminant, but the large changes in C* and h* illustrate the effects of decreasing lamp colour temperature, altering flattery and improving fidelity. A decrease in colour temperature from D65, as red emission increases, generally increases C*, that is the colour is perceived as brighter or more Table 3.2 Calculated changes in L ; C and h from D65 to other lamps for the fresh beef spectra shown in Fig. 3.5 Storage time
Difference in colour from D65 A
WWF
NFL
CWF
83
84
2 hours
L C h
2.9 7.3 2.3
2.0 7.1 1.2
0.6 2.2 3.9
2.0 7.1 6.5
2.2 7.6 3.3
1.2 4.9 2.3
4 days
L C h
2.3 5.7 5.9
1.6 5.5 1.9
0.6 2.1 4.5
0.2 0.7 9.1
1.7 6.3 2.8
0.9 3.8 3.5
Tungsten lamp: A. Fluorescent lamps: WWF, warm white; NFL, natural; CWF, cool white; 83, triband at 3000 K; 84, triband at 4000 K.
Principles of colour measurement for food
77
intense with the observer adapted to white, but h* may become more brown (more positive) or more red (more negative) as influenced by both colour temperature and the lamp’s spectral bandwidth which affects fidelity. 3.6.2 Orange juice Translucent suspensions are difficult to measure, and direct unobserved interpretation of instrumental data can lead to confusion because of the way the incident light is dispersed in the sample. Most consistent results are obtained if the instrument aperture is large relative to the incident beam (Kent 1987; MacDougall 1987). The effects of optical geometry on colour and the Kubelka-Munk absorption K (mm 1) and scatter S (mm 1) coefficients for orange juice were studied by MacDougall (1983), who found Y1, the luminous reflectance at calculated infinite thickness, increased by 50 per cent if the aperture diameter was increased from 2 cm to 5 cm while the incident beam was maintained at 1 cm. The effect of dilution of four-fold orange juice concentrate on the reflectance spectra obtained on 4-cm thick samples in thin-walled polystyrene bottles is shown in Fig. 3.7. As can be seen, 4 cm is practically equivalent to infinite thickness. Kubelka-Munk absorption and scatter coefficients were calculated from 2-mm thick samples on black and white backgrounds. On dilution, S decreased for X, Y and Z as the suspension became more translucent. K for Z decreased to approach the much lower near constant values of K for X and Y (Fig. 3.8). This decrease in K for Z is as anticipated for a blue absorbing pigment. The effect of loss of scattering power on dilution was to reduce Y1, and hence lower L*. The most dilute juice, therefore, is instrumentally the darkest, and the most concentrated is the lightest (Fig. 3.9). However, this is not what is perceived. Glasses of orange juice viewed with overhead illumination range from pale yellow for concentrations less than 1 to deep orange at a concentration of 4, which is opposite to that determined instrumentally. For strongly scattering coloured materials in dilute
Fig. 3.7
Reflectance spectra of concentration and diluted orange juice at a path length of 4 cm, equal to infinite thickness: reconstituted juice at normal concentration 1:0.
78
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 3.8 Kubelka-Munk absorption K and scatter S coefficients for tristimulus values X, Y and Z for concentrated and diluted orange juice: values (mm 1) calculated from reflectance spectra obtained from 2 mm path length cells with black and white backgrounds.
suspension, measured colour, even supplemented by information on scatter, is inadequate fully to describe appearance. The instrument does not measure what the observer sees because light is reflected from a limited solid angle, whereas the observer’s perception is influenced by the multidirectionality of illumination which makes coloured translucent materials appear to glow. 3.6.3 Illuminant spectra and uniform colour Although D65 is the illuminant spectrum most used for calculating CIELAB, of the other lamps listed in Table 3.2 the more important for relating food colour measurement to visual colour in practice are A and 83. A is the emission spectrum of tungsten illumination and 83 is that of ‘tri-band’ fluorescent illumination, similar to F11 in Fig. 3.3. However in 83 the red phosphor is increased by >25% over that of F11 and the green phosphor reduced by about 12% giving the lamp a warm appearance
Principles of colour measurement for food
79
Fig. 3.9 Changes in lightness L*, opponent coordinates a* and b*, hue angle h* and chroma C* calculated from reflectance spectra of concentrated and diluted orange juice at 4 cm path length.
(3000ºK) similar to that of tungsten but with a considerable reduction in energy. 83 is now commonly used for food display in supermarkets because of its attractiveness and low heat output. To examine the size of the effect of these lamps on CIELAB colour space, a variety of foods, selected as representative of the major hues, were measured on the ICS Micro Match spectrophotometer (Fig. 3.10). The red hue examples were fresh tomatoes at supermarket readiness, i.e. not excessively ripe but bright attractive red-pink and Wiltshire bacon, typically translucent in appearance. The yellow spectrum was the mean of several bananas, ripe but without any indication of brown spotting. The difference between the two orange samples was that the colour of the peel of entire navel oranges is near opaque and brilliant, whereas the colour of freshly squeezed orange juice is translucent. This results in a large reduction in the juice’s reflectance at the red end of the spectrum compared to that of the peel. The green spectrum was that of the external leaves of a mid to light green cabbage and the brown was that of the surface of a ‘digestive’ biscuit. The near-white spectrum was that of semi-skimmed milk. All samples were measured at infinite thickness.
80
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 3.10
Reflectance (%) spectra of a selection of foods of differing hue.
Principles of colour measurement for food
81
Fig. 3.11 CIELAB a*b* spacing of the food spectra from Fig. 3.10 calculated for the illuminants D65 (Q), A (O) and 83 (V). The L* values for each food are given adjacent to the symbols of the illuminants.
Figure 3.10 shows the average reflectance spectra of the foods and Fig. 3.11 the location of the samples in CIELAB calculated for the three illuminants. The triplets of points for each sample show that D65 has lower b* values, that is more blue as would be expected, and A and 83 are more yellow with A more red than 83 with higher a* values. These results parallel visual observation of the products viewed under tungsten, artificial daylight (D65) and Philips 83 lamps. This study clearly demonstrates that if interpretation of CIELAB is to be related to illumination conditions in practice, then D56 should not be the only illuminant used to calculate food colour.
3.7
Conclusions
This chapter has attempted to present the basics of colour measurement as applied to foods. It is important to realise that the wide variability in the nature of foods and food products, from both their structure and pigmentation, may limit any colourmeasurement technique applicable only to that particular food. This is because the numeracy of the data is unlikely to match the visual experience of equivalent reference atlas colours. In some cases this discrepancy may be large and has to be recognised as an intrinsic property of the food. These differences may arise from the difference of the visual experience of the product when viewed under normal lighting conditions as opposed to the limitations of its optical properties when presentated to the particular
82
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
colour-measuring instrument. This is particularly so in the case of translucent foods. The values of measured lightness, hue and chroma are likely to be quite different from similarly coloured opaque materials. A consequence of this is that, if required for quality decisions, the variability of measured colour for any food over the range of acceptability and unacceptability needs to established relative to real samples judged under appropriate controlled visual judgement conditions. If the foregoing are taken account of, the use of colorimetry is likely to expand in the food industry in the future, especially so as portable instruments, and in-line measurements techniques, become accepted as reliable indicators of product quality.
3.8
References
ASTM (2000) Standards on color and appearance measurement, 6th edn American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia. ATKINS, J.T. and BILLMEYER, F. W. (1966) ‘Edge-loss errors in reflectance and transmittance measurement of translucent materials’. Material Research Standards, 6, 564–569. BARTLESON, C. J. (1979a) ‘Changes in color appearance with variations in chromatic adaptation’. Color Research and Application, 4, 119–138. BARTLESON, C. J. (1979b) ‘Predicting corresponding colors with changes in adaptation’. Color Research and Application, 4, 143–155. BEST, R. P. (1987) ‘Computer match prediction – pigments’. In Colour Physics for Industry, ed. R. McDonald, 186–210, Society of Dyers and Colourists, Bradford. BILLMEYER, F. W. and SALTZMAN, M. (1981) Principles of Color Technology, 2nd edn Wiley, New York. BOYNTON, R. M. (1979) Human Color Vision. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York. BRILL, M. H. and WEST, G. (1986) ‘Chromatic adaptation and colour constancy; a possible dichotomy’. Color Research and Application, 11, 196–204. BRIMELOW, C. J. B. (1987) ‘Measurement of tomato paste color: investigation of some method variables’. In Physical properties of foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 295–317, Elsevier, London. BSI (1988) British Standard method for calculation of small colour differences (BS6923). British Standards Institution, London. BSI (1999) Methods for sensory analysis of food – Part 10: General guidance test method for assessment of the colour of foods (BS 5929-10: 1999). British Standards Institution, London. CIE (1986) Colorimetry, 2nd edn CIE publication 15.2, Commission Internationale de l’E´clairage, Vienna. ´ ESTEVEZ, O. (1982) ‘A better colorimetric standard observer for color-vision studies. The Stiles and Burch 2 color-matching functions’. Color Research and Application, 7, 131–134. FRANCIS, F. J. (1999) Colorants. Eagen Press, St Paul, Minnesota. FRANCIS, F. J. and CLYDESDALE, F. M. (1975) Food Colorimetry: Theory and Applications. AVI, Westport, CT. HALSTEAD, M. B. (1978) ‘Colour rendering: past, present and future’. In AIC 77, 97127, Adam Hilger, London. HARD, A. (1970) ‘Qualitative attributes of colour perception’. In AIC Color 69, vol. 1, 351, Musterschmidt, Go¨ttingen.
Principles of colour measurement for food
83
and RIORDAN, E. B. (1973) ‘Discoloration in pre-packaged beef: measurement by reflectance spectrophotometry and shopper discrimination’. Journal of Food Technology, 8, 333–343. HUBEL, D. H. (1988) Eye, Brain and Vision. Freeman, New York. HUNT, R. W. G. (1977) ‘Specification of color appearance. Effects of changes in viewing conditions’. Color Research and Application, 2, 109–120. HUNT, R. W. G. (1978) ‘Color terminology’. Color Research and Application, 3, 79–87. HUNT, R. W. G. (1987a) ‘A model of colour vision for predicting colour appearance in various viewing conditions’. Color Research and Application, 6, 297–314. HUNT, R. W. G. (1987b) Measuring Colour, Ellis Horwood, Chichester. HUNT, R. W. G. (1995) Measuring Colour, 2nd edn Ellis Horwood, Chichester. HUNTER, R. S. (1958) ‘Photoelectric color difference meter’. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 48, 985–995. HUNTER, R. S. and HAROLD, R. W. (1988) The Measurement of Appearance, 2nd edn Wiley, New York. HURVICH, L. M. (1981) Color Vision. Sinaver, Sunderland, MA. HUTCHINGS, J. B (1994) Food Colour and Appearance Blackie Academic & Professional, London. ISO (1999) Sensory analysis – General guidance and test method for assessment of the colour of foods (ISO 11037: 1999E). International Organization for Standardization, Geneva. JACOBS, G. H. (1981) Comparative Color Vision. Academic, New York. JUDD, D. B. and WYSZECKI, G. (1975) Color in Business, Science and Industry, 3rd edn Wiley, New York. KENT, M. (1987) ‘Collaborative measurements on the colour of lightscattering foods’. In Physical Properties of Foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 277–294, Elsevier, London. KUBELKA, P. (1948) ‘New contributions to the optics of intensely light scattering materials’. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 38, 448–457. MACADAM, D. L. (1970) Sources of Color Science. MIT, Cambridge, MA. MACDOUGALL, D. B. (1982) ‘Changes in colour and opacity of meat’. Food Chemistry, 9, 75–88. MACDOUGALL, D. B. (1983) ‘Instrumental assessment of the appearance of foods’. In Sensory Quality in Foods and Beverages: its Definition, Measurement and Control, eds A. A. Williams and R. K. Atkin, 121–139, Ellis Horwood, Chichester. MACDOUGALL, D. B. (1987) ‘Optical measurements and visual assessment of translucent foods’. In Physical Properties of Foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 319–330, Elsevier, London. MACDOUGALL, D. B. (1988) ‘Colour vision and appearance measurement’. In Sensory Analysis of Foods, ed. J. R. Piggott, 103–130, Elsevier, London. MACDOUGALL, D. B. and MONCRIEFF, C. B. (1988) ‘Influence of flattering and tri-band illumination on preferred redness-pinkness of bacon’. In Food Acceptability, ed. D. M. H. Thomson, 443–458, Elsevier, London. MACDOUGALL, D.B. and POWELL, V.H. (1997) ‘Relative importance of temperature, wavelength and intensity of light on the colour display of fresh and aged beef cuts’. Proceedings of the 43rd International Conference of Meat Science and Technology, New Zealand, 668-669. MCDONALD, R. (1997) ‘Computer match prediction – dyes’. In Colour Physics for Industry, 2nd edn, ed. R McDonald, 209–291, Society of Dyers and Colourists, Bradford. HOOD, D. E.
84
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
MCLAREN, K.
(1986) The Colour Science of Dyes and Pigments, 2nd edn Adam Hilger,
Bristol. and SOBAGAKI, H. (1986) ‘Prediction of color appearance under various adapting conditions’. Color Research and Application, 11, 62–71. NOBBS, J. H. (1997) ‘Colour-match prediction for pigmented materials’. In Colour Physics for Industry, 2nd edn, ed. R McDonald, 292–372, Society of Dyers and Colourists, Bradford. NORMANN, R. A. and WERBLIN, F. S. (1974) ‘Control of retinal sensitivity. 1: Light and dark adaptation of vertebrate rods and cones’. Journal of General Physiology, 63, 37–61. PATTERSON, D. (1987) ‘Instruments for the measurement of the colour of transparent and opaque objects’. In Colour Physics for Industry, ed. R. McDonald, 35–62, Society of Dyers and Colourists, Bradford. POINTER, M. R. (1980) ‘The concept of colourfulness and its use for deriving grids for assessing colour appearance’. Color Research and Application, 2, 99–107. POINTER, M. R. (1982) ‘Analysis of colour-appearance grids and chromatic-adaptation transforms’. Color Research and Application, 7, 113–118. RIGG, B. (1987) ‘Colorimetry and the CIE system’. In Colour Physics for Industry, ed. R. McDonald, 63–96, Society of Dyers and Colourists, Bradford. ROBERTSON, A. R. (1977) ‘The CIE 1987 color-difference formulae’. Color Research and Application, 2, 7–11. RODIECK, R. W. (1979) ‘Visual pathways’. Annual Reviews in Neuroscience, 2, 193–225. SAUNDERSON, J. L. (1942) ‘Calculation of the color of pigmented plastics’. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 32, 727–736. SMITH, C. V. and POKORNY, J. (1975) ‘Spectral sensitivity of the foveal cone photopigments between 400 and 500nm’. Vision Research, 15, 161–171. STRYER, L. (1988) ‘Molecular basis of visual excitation’. Cold Spring Harbour Symposia on Quantitative Biology, 53, 283–294. WALD, G. (1968) ‘The molecular basis of visual excitation’. Nature, 219, 800–807. WRIGHT, W. D. (1967) The Rays Are Not Coloured. Adam Hilger, London. WRIGHT, W. D. (1980) The Measurement of Colour, 5th edn Adam Hilger, London. ZEKI, S. (1980) ‘The representation of colours in the cerebral cortex’. Nature, 284, 412– 18. ZEKI, S. (1993) A Vision of the Brain, Blackwell Scientific Publications, London. NAYATANI, Y., TAKAHAMA, K.
4 Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance C. J. B. Brimelow, Nestle´ R&D Centre, Shanghai and P. Joshi, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne
4.1
Introduction: food colour and quality
The first judgement of a food’s quality is more often than not dependent on its various appearance characteristics, such as colour, surface structure and shape. Colour, in particular, is an important sensory attribute. It may be defined as the sensation experienced when energy, in the form of radiation within the visible spectrum, falls upon the retina of the eye (Francis and Clydesdale 1975). But this definition does not give the full picture. It is known that the brain further processes and conditions the signals received from both the rod-cells and the three different types of cone-cells on the retina, in order to rationalise the colour of an object despite changes in the level and colour of the surrounding lighting. This process of adaptation allows objects to be recognised as having virtually the same colour under very different conditions and is known as colour constancy. Over the last few years, many workers have tried to understand and develop models on constancy but as yet it remains an approximate quality. This is one of the reasons for resorting to instrumental methods for measuring colour under standardised conditions. The food industry uses colour measurement for a number of reasons, all aimed at reducing the variability caused by subjective analysis and providing numerical specification. Firstly, there is a need to ensure a good colour quality in the product going to the consumer. Pangborn (1967) stated that ‘In foods, colours are identified with previously experienced quality and serve as instant indicators of good or bad, according to the product and its intended use.’ Consumers associate an acceptable colour with acceptable flavour, safety, nutrition and level of satisfaction (Christensen 1983). A perceived inferior colour quality or a colour variation from unit to unit of a branded product are factors not well appreciated by the consumer. The manufacturer, therefore, has the difficult task of providing a product of the expected colour quality at perhaps three different times of judgement: at purchase point if the product is packed in a transparent container; at the unpacking point in the kitchen; and at the consumer’s plate after preparation and serving. The first judgement, in the retail outlet, is particularly important because there are often many reference colours available in the form of competitor products, labelling
86
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
decor, advertising graphics, etc. In the case of products unwrapped in the home, colour expectation and colour memory become significant factors in the quality judgement. The colour of the food material on the consumer’s plate is influenced by the manner of inhome preparation, in particular by the cooking procedure. A second use for colour measurement is in the development of new foods or improved versions of existing foods, in cases where the colour is one of the major quality attributes. Here the reference would be the original product, and the aim would be to improve colour either by changing the manufacturing process, or by incorporating better colourimparting ingredients in the recipe, or by reducing colour deterioration during storage. Colour measurement may also be used for the estimation of pigment concentration or tinctorial strength. Clydesdale (1977) has pointed out that in certain situations it is not possible to use optical density readings at absorbance maxima to do this job and that colorimetry often gives a better result. In cases where colour is an important indicator of quality, colour measurement can provide a buying criterion in the purchase of certain raw materials or semifabricates. Examples of this application are in the purchase of tomato paste or citrus juices, where the colour gives an indication both of the original fruit quality and of the efficiency of the manufacturing process. Recent advances in instrumentation have increased the use of colour measurement for quality control and process optimisation. Simple ‘pass/fail’ judgements may be made both during manufacture and on the end product itself. Setting tolerance limits, in combination with sensory studies, allows greater control and, if well managed, can facilitate a greater uniformity of production between batches and even different production sites. Finally, it is possible to monitor a process by careful interpretation of colour measurement results. For example, a batch of ketchup measured more yellow than its target may suggest that it has been cooked for too long a time (Mabon 1993). There are a bewildering variety of methods and instruments available to the food technologist in the field of colour measurement. When one is approaching the subject for the first time or when attempting to devise a method for a material outside the normal experience, the wealth of possibilities available sometimes make the choice difficult. It is the purpose of this chapter to attempt to identify a systematic approach in order to ease the task. The approach is concerned primarily with the use of tristimulus colorimetry and reflectance spectrophotometry.
4.2
Colour measurement principles: brief introduction
For a detailed treatment of the principles of colour measurement, the reader is referred to Chapter 3 in this book by D. B. MacDougall. Here we give a brief, practically oriented introduction to the subject. 4.2.1 Tristimulus colorimetry The scientific basis for the measurement of colour is the existence of three different types of response signals in the human eye. Though four different types of receptor – , and cones, and rods – have been identified, the messages from these are encoded (in a way still not fully understood) to give three types of signal. In historic work carried out in the late 1920s and early 1930s by Wright (1969) and Guild (1931), the performance response characteristics of a standard human eye (the
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
Fig. 4.1
87
Colour matching response functions of the human eye for the original CIE 2º observer.
standard observer) to different spectrum colour light sources were established. This work formed the basis of the Commission Internationale d’E´clairage system (CIE 1931). In order to be able to relate the results obtained from different combinations of primary colour stimuli, linear transformation equations were used to convert Wright and Guild’s curves to more usable functions. This resulted in the definition of three integral primaries, X, Y and Z (see Fig. 4.1). These primaries do not exist as real lights, but they encompass all colours and are, therefore, mathematically very useful. In a tristimulus colorimeter, three or four filters duplicate the response of the standard observer. The filters correspond to the three primary colours in the spectrum (red, green and blue) and they can be combined to match most colours. The more sophisticated instruments carry a fourth filter to simulate the blue part of the CIE [[X bar]] function shown in Fig. 4.1. The other essential parts of a tristimulus colorimeter are a white light source, an array of photometers, and an integral calculator (see Fig. 4.2a). Nowadays, the integral calculator is usually a computer which can also carry out data transformations between CIE and other colour scale systems or between different standard white light sources or white diffusers. Hunter and Harold (1987) give a good summary of the transformation formulae employed. 4.2.2 Reflectance spectrophotometry Unlike the colorimeter’s filter system, a spectrophotometer works by measuring the ratio of reflected light from a sample to that from a known reference standard. Measurements are taken, via an integrating sphere and then a diffraction grating, at many points across the visible range of the electromagnetic spectrum, i.e. between 380nm and 700nm (see Fig 4.2b). Different instruments measure at different wavelength intervals, depending
88
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 4.2
Instruments for colour measurement by reflectance.
upon the nature of the spectral analyser and control electronics; 10nm or 20nm are accepted standards. Since reflectance is calculated by means of the above ratio, it is commonly expressed as a percentage. Thus, a perfectly reflecting diffuser will have a reflectance of 100%. During measurement analysis, however, reflectance is usually expressed as a fraction, with the ideal white tile then having a value of 1. Conversely, a black sample, which absorbs all incident light, will have a reflectance of 0% or 0. In between these two extremes fall the other visible colours. If a sample absorbs all but red light, it will show high reflectance values in the ‘red’ region of the reflectance spectrum. A spectrophotometer ‘captures’ all surface-reflected light across the visible wavelength range and thus can graphically analyse and output what the perceived colour should be. Every surface colour can, thus, be characterised by a reflectance curve. An important characteristic of modern spectrophotometers is their dual-beam nature. The use of the second, or reference beam, is important in ensuring stability and
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
89
minimising error. The reference beam is light from the sphere walls which is collected at a reference port and directed via a mirror to another spectral analyser identical to the first. The resulting reflectance value output from the spectrophotometer, therefore, is a ratio rather than an absolute value and any drift resulting from electronic or physical error will be cancelled out. Measurement error is often encountered during the definition of the measurement geometry, that is to say, the relationship between the incident (source) and reflected (measured) light. Most spectrophotometers are sphere-based instruments that allow the reflected light to be measured either with or without its specular component. As it is the surface properties of the sample which determine the amount of specular reflection, different results will be obtained when measuring a very rough surface as opposed to a highly gloss one. There is particular need for caution if comparing samples measured through a transparent packaging material. Excluding the specular component may result in the nature of the packaging determining the measured colour value. Including the specular light (i.e. keeping it within the integrating sphere) will ensure that only the colour and no surface effects are measured. Despite the greater cost of a spectrophotometer in comparison to the simpler colorimeter, the ability to measure full reflectance curves allows colour-matchings to be made, tolerance volumes to be defined and a more in-depth understanding of many colour change processes to be achieved. Several manufacturers produce their instruments in both bench-top and portable models facilitating both lab analysis and near-line studies. 4.2.3 In-line colour measurement The two commonly used instruments discussed above allow both laboratory and near process line colour measurement. With the advent of almost fully automated lines, true in-line colour measurement would be of great value in many factories. McFarlane (1988) discusses the economic benefits of in-line and closed-loop systems. His paper highlights closer adherence to specifications, minimisation of waste during start-up and product change, as well as an increase in process efficiency and plant throughput as key issues. Work at the laboratory of one of the authors (PJ) has recently focused upon the use of fibre-optic reflectance probes to generate this in-line data. The fibre-optic cables may be bundled so as to provide both an illumination source and collection point in one probe (see Fig. 4.3). This probe is connected to a defined light source, such as a Xenon pulse providing D65, and then output to a spectrophotometer to generate full reflectance curves. The inclusion of a 45º optical window facilitates the 0º/45º viewing geometry. The whole probe is then inserted into a pipe to measure the product during its actual processing. No sampling procedure is required and with the appropriate software, instantaneous CIELAB or XYZ data may be acquired. As with all colour measurement systems, calibration is of key importance, as is the need to ensure that the pipe-fitting provides an adequate optical path-length without the interference of erroneous light. Such in-line systems have been previously used in the petroleum industries but with further investigation and development their routine integration into food processing could be a valuable future tool for both quality control and process validation. 4.2.4 Colour scales and colour difference formulae The now routine integration of a pc means that the data collected from either a colorimeter or spectrophotometer can be transformed to XYZ, CIELAB, HunterLab or
90
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 4.3 A fibre-optic bundle composed of seven fibre-optics encased to make a probe for in-line colour analyses.
other colour system as specified by the user and provided by the software. The initial step from instrument response to XYZ requires the definition of standard observer functions. The first standard observer was defined by the CIE in 1931. This was based upon a series of colour matching experiments carried out four years earlier and involved using a 2º field of view. This was thought to be adequate since in the human eye, the receptor cones, which are responsible for colour vision, were concentrated at 2º around the fovea. It was later established that this was, in fact, quite unrealistic as most visual assessments are done with a field of view much greater than 2º. Thus, in 1964 the CIE introduced the 10º Standard Observer – the 10º encompasses the area in the fovea that contains the rod receptors (responsible for lightness discrimination) and so is closer to human vision. Many earlier studies have been carried out using the 2º observer and so caution must be exercised if comparing these values to those measured using the now more common 10º standard observer. Most software packages have the capabilities to convert data between the two; for those programming their own systems the raw data (chromaticity co-ordinates and colour matching functions) are available in the international standard ISO/CIE 10527 ‘CIE standard colorimetric observers’. The aim of the more popular of the colour scales is to represent colours in a three-dimensional colour space, such that similar visual colour differences are represented by approximately similar distances in the colour space. Such colour scales are known as uniform scales. The original CIE scales, represented diagrammatically in Fig. 4.4, were not intended for identifying the colours of objects and are certainly not uniform in spacing colours according to their visual differences. One of the more popular of the uniform colour scales in use in the food industry is the Judd-Hunter L, a, b solid, depicted in Fig. 4.5. Hunter (1958) elaborated this scale with three purposes in mind; to be able to sense the scale directly with a tristimulus colorimeter; to provide terms which represented the red/ green, blue/yellow and dark/light responses of the human brain; and to give a colour solid
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
Fig. 4.4
91
CIE x, y, chromaticity diagram: locations of illuminants A, B, C, D65 and E (equal energy) are also shown.
Fig. 4.5
Judd-Hunter colour solid.
92
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 4.6
Representation of the hue angle formed in the a* b* plane by the a* axis and the line from the origin to a point (a1 ; b1 ).
with visual uniformity across the solid. The latter aim is probably impossible to achieve, but the L, a, b scale comes close, as has been demonstrated by Hunter and Harold (1987). In the Judd-Hunter solid, a colour can be represented by L (lightness or darkness, 0 perfect black to 100 perfect white), a ( a greenness, a redness) and b ( b blueness, b yellowness). The a and b axes are both scaled from 100 to 100, though higher saturation values are not always achievable in reality. Sometimes, in order to simplify the representation of a colour to two-dimensional space, the a and b values are transformed to , which is the angle between the line joining the point (a1, b1) in JuddHunter space to the origin and the green/red axis. If saturation is neglected, the colour can then be represented by the two independent quantities L and , lightness and hue angle (see Fig. 4.6). Judd proposed that in order to calculate differences between colours in a colour solid, Euclidean geometry could be used such that the ‘Euclidean distances between points are proportional to the size or perceptibility, E, of the colour difference between the colours represented by the points’. In the L, a, b colour solid, therefore, E
L2
a2
b2 1=2
4:1
and across most of the solid a value for E of around unity indicates the maximum acceptable colour difference in the industry. In the 1960s, the Commission Internationale de l’E´clairage (CIE) decided to try to stem the confusion caused by the presence of the many formulae in use and standardise colour space. They managed to combine the opponent chromatic attributes used by Hunter and Schofield, with the MacAdam cube-root simplification of the earlier Judd polynomial. The result was the publication of CIELAB (or CIEL*a*b*) in 1976 (Smith
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
93
1997). At this point, the asterisk superscript was introduced in order to differentiate the CIELAB parameters from other similar ones still in use. Work to create a truly uniform colour space still continues. Following studies by the Colour Measurement Committee (CMC), the CIE94 total colour-difference was defined. Tolerances based on L*, a* and b* terms give too much area out of visual tolerance but within instrumental tolerance. Using lightness, chroma and hue (L*C*h*) attributes allows ellipsoidal tolerance areas to be derived which are much better and easier to describe sensorially than the vague redness-greenness, yellowness-blueness opponent pairs. E*94 is a weighted Euclidean distance using the colour difference components L*, C* and H* " #1 2 2 2 2 L C H E94
4:2 k L SL k C SC k H SH where SL, SC and SH are weighting functions used to account for the variation in perceived colour magnitude and kL, kC and kH are parametric functions which correct for sensitivity with variation in experimental conditions. Under reference conditions these factors are assigned a value of unity, whereas in the textile industry, for example, it is common practice to set the lightness parametric function to 2 (CIE 1995). Use of the CIEL*a*b* and CIE94 is growing in popularity especially when correlation with sensory analysis is required. Relating sensory colour analysis with instrumentally measured data is covered in more depth in Chapter 2 of this book. Of practical note, it is recommended that users comparing data confirm the colour notation and system used – the lightness, and chromaticity co-ordinated used in the Hunter-Judd analysis L, a, b do not correspond exactly with the L*a*b* of CIELAB. Subsequently, it is essential that full specification including colour system, illuminant type and viewing geometry is quoted when publishing colour measurement data. Furthermore, many web-based applications exist within which one can convert data from one colour system to another, e.g. CIELAB to HunterLab to Munsell Chip Notation (www.colorpro.com/info/tools/convert. htm#TOP).
4.3
Colour measurement methodology
Methods for the instrumental measurement of food colour involve four stages: 1. 2. 3. 4.
standardisation of the instrument setting the instrument variables selection, preparation and presentation of the sample to the instrument determination of the colour values.
Bilmeyer (1981) has suggested that deviations from absolute accuracy in colour measurement are caused by, in decreasing order of importance: • • • •
sample preparation and operator variables different reference white standards variation in colour reference standards instrument conditions.
There are many variable factors in each of the four stages of the colour measurement method that can affect the final result. In order to be able to compare results for a
94
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
particular food material, these variables should be recognised and efforts made to eliminate, or at least reduce, their effects. 4.3.1 Standardisation of the instrument Colour standards provide the references against which the colours of materials can be instrumentally compared. They fall into two classes, primary standards and secondary standards. Primary standards are pressed powder tablets of fresh MgO, BaSO4 or halon G–80 (pressed tetrafluoroethylene resin manufactured by the Allied Chemical Corporation) maintained by governmental standards agencies such as the National Bureau of Standards in Washington DC, USA or the National Physical Laboratory in Middlesex, England. These white standards are measured against a theoretical perfect white diffuser by means of an auxiliary sphere to derive an absolute reflectance value. Unfortunately, at the moment there is not a complete consensus between the various standards institutes on the perfect white diffuser values. Secondary standards can be subdivided into a number of groups. Hunter and Harold (1987) have described seven types of secondary standards in the following terms: 1.
2. 3. 4. 5.
6. 7.
Master standards calibrated by reference to primary standards and usually in the form of porcelain or opaque glass panels, ceramic tiles, acrylic painted chips, etc. These are maintained with extreme care, usually at the standards institutes, and are used only to calibrate other secondary standards. Working standards used as a reference for a group of laboratory instrument standards. These are usually ceramic or porcelain tiles. Instrument standards used to calibrate a particular instrument. ‘Hitching-post’ standards which are used in place of a white standard and which are close in colour to that of the samples to be measured. This technique is used to minimise errors caused by scale-interval defects in the instrument. Specific calibration standards which are permanent specimens or standards used for measurements carried out on impermanent products. To derive these standards the impermanent product is first measured on a reference instrument. The product can then be used to calibrate a second instrument on which the permanent standard is also read. This reading then becomes the assigned values of the permanent standard. Diagnostic standards used for instrument checking or fault finding in inaccurate instruments. Material comparison standards, which are usually samples of the materials under examination and provide limiting or target values.
It can be seen that, in all except the last two cases, the colour values of the standards are traceable, via the working and master standards, back to the primary standard. Secondary standards should be treated with care. Colour values can be affected by the presence of dirt, grease, moisture, fingerprints or surface scratches on the viewing area. Ceramic standards should be cleaned carefully and regularly by washing in mild anionic detergent, rinsing in hot distilled water and blotting dry with a lint-free paper towel. When not in use, they should be maintained at a constant standard temperature and away from light in a sealed container. Despite even these precautions, it is known that some surfaces can be attacked by atmospheric pollutants or may undergo changes during storage. Painted or printed colour chips should never be cleaned. Freezer storage is often practised to extend the life of colour chips (Huey 1965).
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
95
Before a standard is used to calibrate an instrument, the instrument should be thoroughly warmed up and stabilised. Colour standards should be placed under the instrument port in the same manner each time a calibration is carried out, to avoid the effects of any surface directionality in the colour layer of the standard on the calibration values. Because some of the colour standards exhibit thermochromicity, i.e. their colour values change as the temperature changes, it is advised that calibration be carried out with rapidity in order to avoid the instrument lamp raising the temperature of the standard. The subject of thermochromicity of the colour standard has been described by Brimelow (1987) with reference to measurement of tomato colour. Kent and Smith (1987) reported the results of an inter-laboratory study on measurement of colour standards. They came to the obvious and important conclusion that in order to transfer and compare colour data from one laboratory to another, which is certainly necessary when colour is being used as a buying criterion, the measuring system and the colour standard have to be carefully defined. Variables inherent in the measuring system will be described in the next two sections. 4.3.2 Selection, preparation and presentation of the samples The sample itself is the key to good colour measurement. In optical terms, samples can be divided into four main classifications: opaque objects, metal-like objects, transparent objects and translucent objects. With opaque objects, a class into which most food materials fall, light is either directly reflected from the surface as a white highlight (gloss) or absorbed, scattered and diffusely reflected from the surface (perceived colour). Opaque materials do not transmit light. The relative amounts of gloss and colour perceived depend, of course, on the surface properties, but also on the viewing angle. In order to compare colour differences independently of the gloss characteristics, the optimal positions of the light source and the detector (e.g. the eye) relative to the sample surface are 45º and 0º or 0º and 45º. This optical arrangement is replicated in many tristimulus colorimeters and, thus, these instruments measure sample colour and not surface effects. Most spectrophotometers, however, provide data either with or without this specular effect and if managed correctly can provide useful information on product shine or packaging influences. In the case of metal-like objects, virtually all the light is reflected as gloss and very little is diffused. Very often the reflectance is at a dominant wavelength, which provides colour gloss, rather than at all wavelengths which would provide white highlights. Foods, though they may sometimes have a high gloss component, rarely fall into this class of metal-like materials. Transparent objects exhibit colour by regular transmission, that is they absorb light and then transmit it preferentially at different wavelengths along the path of the light beam. Some liquid food materials and a few solid food materials are transparent, such as vegetable oils, fruit serums and wines, certain sugar confectionery, fruit jellies, etc. The class of materials between transparent and opaque, to which many food materials belong, is called translucent. Some of the light falling on a translucent object can pass through it in the direction of the light, but the remainder is diffused within it and emerges in different directions. As a consequence, the size of the measurement aperture can greatly influence the amount of collected light (see Fig. 4.7). The light-scattering properties of hazy or turbid food materials is a complex subject which has been covered in some depth by MacDougall (1982; 1983; 1987). It is clear that with this class of material, instrument/object geometry plays a large part in the colour values obtained.
96
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 4.7
Translucent foods diffuse the incident light resulting in lost measurement. Using a larger area viewing aperture allows this trapped light to be measured.
MacDougall (1987) has illustrated this point using concentrated and diluted orange juices as test samples. When reflectance measurements are carried out on opaque or translucent food materials, a number of problems exist in the selection and preparation of the samples. The first is that simply by reason of its presentation method, the sample area as presented to the instrument may not be representative of the bulk of the material under test. Most instruments in common use are designed to accommodate samples which are flat and, therefore, reflect light from one plane only. Most food materials are not flat and some degree of compromise has to be made in order to create viewing areas which are. It is often the case that it is advantageous to deliberately change the surface characteristics of the sample in order to enhance colour differences between specimens. Andre´ and Pauli (1978), for example, pulverised dehydrated pasta into a powder and then tabletted the powder for colour measurement in order to minimise variation caused by differences in the shapes and surface properties of commercially available products. A second important problem is that other factors come into play which may affect surface reflection during the process of creating a flat viewing area. These factors include the ambient conditions of temperature and humidity applied during the process; the variables within the actual method used (e.g. the blade sharpness during cutting, the technique of polishing, the pressure applied during pressing); chemical reactions (e.g. browning effects) or physical reactions (e.g. settling effects) occurring at the surface up to and during the measurement event; and the settlement of vapour, dust or film-forming agents on the surface after its formation. A third problem is the general non-uniformity of the surface colours of foodstuffs. This means that it may be necessary to make repeated measurements in different places on a surface or make measurements of different samples from a bulk in order to achieve statistically significant average values. One ingenious solution to the problem of making
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
97
repeated measurements on a surface was suggested by Francis (1952) for apples. By rotating a single fruit rapidly in a small viewing aperture, an average surface colour was obtained. One further problem is the physical size of the food sample. Some specimens may simply be too small to measure successfully as single items, though recently instruments with very small aperture viewing heads which permit measurements on areas of around 3 mm diameter are available. It is, however, more usual to bulk such samples and then employ large area sample cups and large diameter instrument apertures when making the measurements. When preparing samples it is important that the preparation procedure is strictly adhered to in order to ensure a high repeatability of measurement. Grinding, milling and mixing may all help to create sample uniformity but at the same time it must not be forgotten that such techniques will undoubtedly influence the sample’s light-scattering properties (Giese 2000). In some cases, the physical aspects of the sample can be more influential then the colorant concentration itself. Particle size, size-distribution and component packing may influence the sample optics and hence, the measured colour (Joshi 2000). Apart from considering all of the above, it is also important to recognise that sample preparation and presentation may be influenced by the desired result of the colour measurement. For example, if the goal is to achieve a good correlation with sensory data, then it is essential that the instrumentally measured sample should be in the same state as that seen by the visual panel. If colour measurement is to be used as a buying criterion the trial sample must be presented as was the standard used to set the tolerance limits. Also, if a relationship between colour and some other physical parameter is to be made, e.g. particle-size or water-activity, both samples should undergo the same preparation for each test. Some general rules for the preparation of different types of food materials for reflectance colour measurement are discussed below. Opaque powders, granules and flakes It is usual to make multiple measurements on such materials and average the results. Bulk amounts are normally sieved prior to subsampling in order to reduce errors due to size variation in the particles. Hunter and Harold (1987) have clearly illustrated that the larger the particle size, the less the light is scattered and therefore the more coloured the sample appears. Smaller particles scatter and reflect more incident light and the sample therefore appears lighter (see Fig. 4.8). Many of the errors encountered in comparing the colours of powders and granules relate to particle size effects. One of three methods of sample preparation of powders can be utilised. Samples can be poured into cups with optically flat and transparent bases and measurements made through the base. Alternatively, samples can be poured into a container with sides of equal height and the top can be scraped flat with a straight edge. Measurements are then made from above. Thirdly, a powder compactor can be used. This is a device which can create a disk specimen from a sample of known weight and bulk density by applying a standardised force. In this case measurements can be made from above or below. Opaque particulate or lumpy materials Materials from 5 mm to 20 mm in size can be very difficult to measure with good repeatability, particularly if they are non-regular in shape. As has been mentioned, several instruments have recently appeared on the market with small diameter viewing heads, such as the Minolta CR 121 or the MacBeth ColorEye XTH. Normally, however,
98
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Figure 4.8 Decreasing particle size increases light scattering, causing the sample to appear lighter in colour.
it is the practice to place particulate or lumpy materials into a large container with an optically flat and clear base, trying to ensure that the packing is as solid as possible. Measurements are then usually made from below. An alternative method of presentation has been evolved which is useful in situations when repeated measurements have to be made on solid materials which have a high oil or fat content. These materials may smear or coat the surfaces of a glass cell. The method utilises clear PVC film (e.g. Saran Wrap). The film is stretched across the viewing port of the colorimeter and the sample is placed on the film. Measurement is made from below. After each measurement, the specimen can be quickly wrapped up in the film and discarded, thus eliminating the need for frequent washing of valuable glass sample cups (Mabon 1989). Large area solid foods When colour measurements are made on solid opaque foods, such as whole fruits or thick slices of red meat, the specimen field should be flat and uniform. If a natural flat surface is not available, then it is sometimes acceptable to form such a surface by cutting or pressing. The latter can be achieved by sandwiching the sample between two plates of glass, one of which should be optically flat and transparent. Viewing is carried out through the transparent plate. If the food does not lend itself to cutting or pressing, then one other possibility is to rotate the food object in front of the viewing port of the instrument (Francis 1952). Solid foods often show directionality. When the directionality is obvious, the specimen should be measured in the same orientation for each test. When the directionality is haphazard or undefined, one useful technique is to turn the sample through 90º between the two readings and average the results. Many solid foods are translucent, for example, cheeses, butters, fatty meats and high water content fruits and vegetables. The effects of translucency on colour readings are large, particularly when such materials are being measured in thin slice form (for example, bacon, other sliced meats and sliced fruits). It is essential to standardise the preparation procedures for such samples. Normally a standard white backing plate would be employed and the sample thickness would also be standardised. Specimens are often viewed through an optically clean and flat plate placed on the surface of the solid. Some of the effects of the preparative variables on the colour values of sliced meats have been discussed by MacDougall (1982). A few food solids are transparent and they can be measured by transmittance procedures. Specimens of known thickness are held against the viewing port of sphere-type colorimeters/spectrophotometers for measurement.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
99
Pastes and slurries Food pastes and slurries are normally translucent materials. It is usual with such materials to introduce them into cells with optically clear and flat bases, to such a depth that all the light is trapped and diffused within. Measurements are made from below. In some instances, however, particularly when the aim is to compare lightness values in dark samples or when a standard background is desirable, a special cell equipped with a ring insert of known height is employed. The sample slurry is poured into the cell to fill it to above the ring and a dish with a white diffusing surface is pushed down to nest on the ring. This fixes the light path length of the sample when it is viewed from below. Often it is advisable to cover the specimen cell with a black lined box in order to prevent extraneous room light from passing into the specimen. Care should be taken when introducing pastes and slurries into test cells that no air is entrapped in the sample. When pastes and slurries are prepared by mincing followed by diluting with water, the mincing conditions must be standardised as must the dilution factor. Samples should be well stirred and then measured quickly to reduce the effects of sedimentation and oxidation. Finally, the thermochromic properties of certain food materials should not be forgotten, and sample temperatures should be standardised. The effects of some of these preparative factors – dilution, test temperature and time, presence or absence of a black cover – on the colour values of tomato pastes have been discussed by Brimelow (1987). As already noted, MacDougall (1983) has illustrated the effects of the dilution factor on colour values in the case of orange juices. Liquids Liquids can be translucent (milk, syrups, fruit juices, egg yolk) or transparent (wines, vinegars). Translucent liquids are measured in the same way as translucent slurries and pastes, and once again choosing the correct optical path-length can determine the validity of the measured result. Transparent liquids are measured by pouring into optically clear fixed path length cells with parallel sides and then taking transmission readings in sphere instruments. Deeply coloured liquids such as dark treacles are measured in short path length cells of the order of 2 mm, whilst lightly coloured liquids such as white wines are measured in long path length cells up to 50 mm. Alternatively, using a cell backed with a white tile may permit colour measurements by transreflectance. In such cases the effective path-length becomes twice that of the cell since the illuminant light travels through the sample, reflects from the white tile or mirror backing, and then traverses again through the sample before being measured. 4.3.3 Setting the instrumental variables The instrumental variables include the choice of light source, the measuring geometry and the relative sizes of the specimen area and the illuminated area. When any colour measurements are made, it is necessary to specify the illuminant used as part of the viewing conditions. In 1931 the CIE established various standard illuminants which have characteristics close to natural light sources, but which also can be reproduced easily for use in the laboratory or in instrumentation. Illuminant A represents light close to that given by a tungsten filament lamp, which might for example be operating during subjective assessments of colour in the home. Illuminant B represents direct sunlight, whereas illuminant C represents average daylight from the total sky, which again might be present during assessments in the home. More recently, the CIE (1979) proposed a D series of illuminants which more closely represent daylight than do B or C and also
100
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
incorporate an ultraviolet range. The D series correlates with various daylight colour temperatures; the most commonly used is the D65 illuminant, approximating to a colour temperature of 6500 K. It should always be borne in mind, however, that if a subjective assessment of the colour of a particular food is normally carried out under, say, a tungsten filament light or under direct sunlight, then it may be preferable to carry out the instrumental measurement under similar lighting conditions. It should be noted also that a pair of samples which colour-match another under one illuminant may not match under a different illuminant. This phenomenon is known as metamerism and is of great importance to those in the textile and paint industries. The choice of the remaining instrumental factors, such as measuring geometry and the relative sizes of the specimen viewing area and the illuminated areas, are very much influenced by the optical classification of the specimen. In order to determine the colour values of a product, therefore, it is necessary to decide whether the prepared sample is opaque, translucent or transparent. Transparency is relatively simple to assess; when a clear image of a light source can be seen through the sample it can essentially be considered as transparent. Translucency is more difficult to determine as the dividing line between opacity and some translucency is imprecise. A simple test is to measure the specimen with maximum area of illumination and maximum viewing aperture and then to repeat the measurement using the same viewing aperture but a reduced area of illumination. If there is a large increase in the lightness reading (the L* value in the CIELAB scale), then the product is translucent. Another good indicator is to measure the sample over firstly a black then a white background. If these two measurements are the same, then the sample can be considered to have an infinite optical thickness. The viewing geometry must also be specified as part of the instrumental conditions. It is generally agreed that with food samples most applications can be covered without much compromise using 0º/45º, 45º/0º (source/detector), or specular component excluded (SCE) viewing geometry. This is the preferred geometry when examining the reflected colour of translucent samples. It is also satisfactory for opaque samples, provided the samples being compared are of equal texture or gloss. Even samples with different texture or gloss characteristics can be compared using this geometry, provided that appearance differences rather than simply colour differences are being assessed. SCE geometry should be used for transparent samples or for measuring transmittance through translucent samples. One source of error arising from the viewing geometry occurs through failing to define whether specular reflectance is included or not. With 0º/45º or 45º/0º geometries, very little specular reflectance is included in the total reflected light detected, even with glossy but non-smooth samples. However, with spherical (d/8º) geometry, specular reflectance will be present in the reflected light from glossy samples and the decision has to be made to include it or exclude it. The choice of illuminated area size and aperture size is very dependent on the nature and the optical class of the specimen. Small area illumination is used on small samples, on samples having only small areas of flatness and on highly translucent and uniform samples. In the latter case, Hunter and Christie (1978) have recommended that the small area illumination is used together with large aperture viewing in order to capture that proportion of the light scattered by the sample and then returned to the detector from outside the illuminated area (see Fig. 4.7). As has been mentioned already, particulate solids are best measured using large area illumination and large viewing apertures.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
101
4.3.4 Determination of colour values The last stage in obtaining a colour measurement is the conversion of the raw signal to colour values in one or other of the colour scales. In modern instrumentation, software packages are capable of carrying out these conversions with speed and accuracy, and can even make calculations to predict comparative colour results for different light sources. Since calculations are based on reference white values, it is a point of concern that there are still differences between national standards for the perfect white diffuser.
4.4
Colour measurement of typical food materials
In this section, some typical applications of food colour measurement will be described by reference to practical work in this area. The work will be treated under the headings utilised earlier in the chapter: powders, granules and flakes; particulate and lumpy materials; large area solid foods; pastes and slurries; and liquids. For further details on the preparation procedures, the sample temperature, the sample presentation, the instrument illumination and aperture diameters, the colour standard and the colour scale employed in each case, the reader may refer to Tables 4.1 to 4.5, respectively. The instruments utilised in each case are briefly summarised in Table 4.6 on page 111. 4.4.1 Powders, granules and flakes (Table 4.1) Johnston et al. (1980) reported that several researchers had compared colorimetric values with visual judgements for durum semolina, but that no one had compared colorimetric data with extracted pigment content. They found that semolina reflectance b values were highly correlated with pigment content as determined by pigment extraction and estimation using the standard AACC water-saturated butanol method, particularly when the objective was to segregate highly pigmented semolinas from low pigmented ones. The authors pointed out that reflectance colour measurement in these types of applications could be a genuine timesaving alternative to the lengthy pigment extraction technique. Seakins (1971) developed a method to measure the colour of casein by immersing it in a liquid of similar refractive index in order to overcome the effects of particle size. Reflectance measurement of dry sample preparations resulted in poor separation of colour grades because reflectance increased as particle size decreased. However, when transmittance values were measured on the liquid suspension, the colour grades were clearly differentiated. In order to minimise grind size effects in ground coffees of different roasts, Little and MacKinney (1956) standardised on a very fine grind with maximum lightness value. Berset and Caniaux (1983), working with parsley, found that measurements on the ground leaves gave better reproducibility than measurements on the whole leaves. The authors surmised that grinding the leaves released from interior leaf cells chlorophyll pigments which were of a different type and more highly pigmented than those in the surface cells. It was shown that the hue function correlated highly with extracted chlorophyll a and b content. These workers also suggested that their colorimetric procedures could be utilised in the quality control of parsley drying and storage processes. In order to overcome the problem of colour variation across potato crisps, Habib and Brown (1956) ground them down to a uniform colour and then introduced the size-
Table 4.1
Colour measurement of powders, granules and flakes
Reference
Sample
Preparation
Temperature (ºC)
Presentation (viewed from above/ below)
Illumination/ Standard aperture diameters (mm)
Instrumenta
Johnston et al. (1980)
Durum semolina
Equilibrate to 15% H2O, mill to semolina flour Sieve to 6 different particle ranges. Suspend samples in benzene Beans ground in commercial coffee grinder, sieved to 5 size ranges Leaves ground 1 min in ball grinder, sieved to 80–250 m particles Crisps size reduced by milling 5 min in Oster mill
NM
20 g samples
NM
NM
A(1)
Transmittance standard at 455 run White tile, neutral grey tile
B
%T at 455 mn,
C
Y
Seakins (1971)
Casein
Little and MacKinney (1956)
Coffee beans at different roasts
Berset and Caniaux (1983)
Dried parsley leaves
Habib and Brown (1956)
Potato crisps
Grieder (1989)
Herbs
Mix 5 g herbs with 5 g sand using automated mortar mill
20
Hans and Floros (1998)
Potassium sorbate powder
Ground to a fine powder then baked
0
a
c
Measurementb
b
NM
0.5 cm light path
T
NM
Ground coffee in clear glass cell
NM
NM
NM
NM
NM
D
L*, a*, b* X, Y, Z, X, Y
NM
Viewing cell 89 mm high by 51 mm diameter. Sample depth of 76 mm (below) Black metal cell with glass base, 55 mm diameter by 60 nun deep (below) Glass cell
NM/51
Ivory tile
E
L, a, b
51/55
White tile
A
L, a, b, E, C
NM
NM
A(6)
L,a,b
For instrument codes see Table 4.6; bFor colour scales see Chapter 3, Table 3.1.; cTransmission cell; NM: not mentioned in the reference.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
103
reduced samples into large volume sample cells using a defined tap-down procedure. Colour differences among four different potato varieties and different storage/ conditioning environments were compared over storage time. It was shown by carrying out multiple correlations against Hunter L values that reducing sugars and free amino nitrogen were important in colour formation in the final chips. A novel approach to the preparation of flaky materials for colour measurement has been suggested by Grieder (1989). Working with herbs, he utilised a pulverisation procedure with sand. This aided the dispersion and trapping of oils, pigments and moisture expressed from the interior cells of the test materials during the grinding process. An example of powder colour measurement for process validation is provided by Han and Floros (1998). They modelled the colour change of potassium sorbate during a series of time-temperature varying trials. Statistically significant changes in both L and a values suggest that a potassium sorbate based system may prove a good indicator for processes, such as dry-heat sterilisation, which involve high-temperature heating. 4.4.2 Particulate and lumpy solids (Table 4.2) The subject of colour measurement of dehydrated potato products, such as sliced or diced potato, has been well covered by Bergthaller and his team. In the case of diced potato, for example, Bergthaller et al. (1983) packed the cubes into a dull black aluminium cell with an optically clear glass base. The L, a and b values of the potato cubes were compared with sensory data and a high correlation between the two sets of data was obtained. A number of different food materials were examined by Baardseth et al. (1988) as part of a comparative exercise involving two colour measuring instruments, the Minolta and the HunterLab D25P. One of the subject materials was salami-type dry sausage, which was prepared and sliced thinly for colour measurement. The sausage slices had a varied appearance, with visible fat particles of 1 to 3 mm diameter present on the surface. Correlation coefficients between instruments of over 0.9 were obtained, with much of the residual non-predictability being related to the inconsistencies in the slice surfaces. Lee et al. (1988) investigated frozen cut green beans given various blanch treatments. The beans were boiled, drained and placed in a 10 cm square acrylic measuring cell. Five replicates per treatment were measured. Results revealed that significant differences were found in the Hunter a values, with beans blanched at temperatures above 82ºC showing a greener colour than beans blanched at temperatures below 82ºC. In order to eliminate problems associated with the differences in surface properties and shapes of commercially available dehydrated vermicelli, Andre´ and Pauli (1978) ground the samples down to powders, then formed tablets from the powders using a hydraulic press. The 40 mm diameter by 10 mm thick tablets could be measured directly on the head of the colorimeter. Good correlations were found between colour co-ordinate values and the -carotene content derived from the egg component of the pastas. Pastas made from different flours could also be differentiated in terms of colour values. A non-sacrificial index of peanut kernel maturity has been derived by Miller and Burns (1971) using a colorimeter procedure. Individual cotyledons were placed on the port of a narrow light beam instrument. The half hulls thus acted as miniature hemispherical light-scattering chambers. Ageing of peanuts is accompanied by darkening of the vein cells near the internal hull surface, and this change was measured by a change in the lightness scale readings obtained. Hazelnuts have been evaluated by Ozdemir and Devres (2000). They measured the colour after roasting of both the intact kernel and a ground hazelnut powder. Significant
Table 4.2
Colour measurement of particulate and lumpy solids
Reference
Sample
Preparation
Temperature (ºC)
Presentation (viewed from above/ below)
Illumination/ Standard aperture diameters (mm)
Instrumenta
Measurementb
Bergthaller et al. (1983)
Potato cubes, dried
Commercially available cubes packed into cell to depth of 60 mm
NM
50/NM
White enamel tile
G
y, L, a, b
Baardseth et al. (1988)
Dry sausage, salami type
Slices, 3mm thick
NM
50/50 25/32
White tile
H(1) A(4)
L*, a*, b*
Lee et al. (1988)
Large/NM
White tile
A
L, a, b
NM/10
White enamel tile
G
X, Y, Z x, y
Miller and Burns (1971)
Peanut hulls (internal colour)
NM
Peanut hull halves directly on narrow beam sensor port
Narrow/NM
Porcelain coloured tile
I
Rdc, a, b
Authors’ laboratory (1988)
Fresh pasta, angel hair and tortellini
20/22
White tile and black glass
I(3)
L, a, b
Hazelnuts
Reflectance through glass base. Black cover on cell (below) Direct onto kernel
50/89
Ozdemir and Devres (2000)
Boiled 5 min. from frozen. Drained 1 min. Pasta ground, sieved through 0.28 mesh, 10 g of powder formed to a tablet 40 mm diameter by 10 mm thick Peanuts harvested, shelled, and sorted subjectively into mature or immature categories Pasta portions packed into 89 mm diameter cell to cover optical glass base, flat against glass when possible Whole roasted kernel and ground roasted powder
NM
Andre´ and Pauli (1978)
Frozen green beans Dried vermicelli (of various shapes)
Dull black Al cell 60 mm internal diameter, height 60 mm, with optical glass base 1.2 mm. thick (below) No cover used, measured against black background 10 cm square acrylic cell Faces of tablets measured directly on sensor port
NM
NM
H(3)
L, a, b
a
NM
NM
For instrument codes see Table 4.6; bFor colour scales see Chapter 3, Table 3. ; cLuminosity value for some older instruments. Rd = Y; NM: not mentioned in the reference.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
105
changes occurred in both L and a measured values with differences between whole and ground nut results suggesting that roasting level should not be monitored by considering either of these uniquely. By fitting the data to an Arrhenius type model, the authors established a generalised model describing colour changes as a function of temperature and time. Fresh pasta colour has been measured at the laboratory of one of the authors’ (CB) (1988), the subject materials being spinach and egg varieties of ravioli, fettuccine, angel hair and tortellini. Samples were provided packed under gas atmosphere. It was found that food substances of this type required immediate measurement after removal from the package since surface colour changes started to occur as soon as the specimens were exposed to air. The effect was most noticeable with thinly cut angel hair. Samples were placed quickly into large area glass cells and measured at a large aperture instrument port within 30 seconds of removal from the package. 4.4.3 Large area solid foods (Table 4.3) Sapers and Douglas (1987) measured enzymatic browning effects at cut surfaces of pears and apples, by cutting 22 mm diameter plugs from the samples using a cork borer and then placing the plugs on a glass cell over the instrument port. Browning could then be followed with time by measuring the L and a values. A similar preparation technique has been utilised by Konstance et al. (1988) on beef chuck. In this case, samples were taken from 2.54 cm thick slices of chuck using a cork borer. The cylinders were then inserted in a previously bored rubber stopper placed on a glass cup. Components of the chuck meat such as lean, fat, bone and ligament could be separated in terms of E and colour values. Though many of these examples deal with the subject of tristimulus colorimetry, it is important to recognise that reflectance spectrophotometry is also a useful technique for the measurement of colour changes in certain foods and one that is growing in popularity as the costs of spectrophotometers rival those of colorimeters. One example is the colour change from red to brown occurring in meat due to oxidative/reductive reactions involving myoglobin. This colour change has a direct effect on the marketability of cut meat pieces. Eagerman et al. (1978) have followed the colour change with time in beef semimembranosus muscle. Approximately 1 cm thick slices were placed against the port of a spectrocolorimeter and the reflectance spectra measured between 600 and 650 nm. The formation of a depression in the region of the spectral curve around 632 nm is an indicator of brown metmyoglobin pigment production. The use of transmittance colorimetry on solid materials is illustrated by the work of Freedman and Francis (1984) who have measured the colour of jellies. The jellies were heated sufficiently to pour into 2 cm light path cells. Lightness and hue angle were used to follow the effects of storage time, with or without the presence of ascorbic acid in the formulations. Measurements on whole fruits have been carried out by Nagle et al. (1979) and Reeves (1987) for capsicums, Shewfelt et al. (1989) for fresh tomatoes and Lin et al. (1989) for apples. In all cases the fruits were measured directly on the instruments, taking a number of readings around the circumference of each specimen. High correlations were obtained between colour values of the whole fruit and extracted xanthophyll pigment in red peppers. Shewfelt et al. (1989) showed that for whole tomatoes there was a significant difference between colour values (colour difference DE, and difference in chroma a2 b2 1=2 due to cultivar, storage treatment and evaluation period. Simulated warehouse storage conditions were found to delay ripening colour changes.
Table 4.3
Colour measurement of large solids
Reference
Sample
Preparation
Temperature (ºC)
Presentation (viewed from above/ below)
Illumination/ Standard aperture diameters (mm)
Instrumenta
Measurementb
Konstance et al. (1988) Eagerman et al. (1978) Freedman and Francis (1984) Nagle et al. (1979); Reeves (1987) Shewfelt et al. (1989)
Beef chuck
Sliced 2.54 cm thick
25
Glass cup (below)
NM/19
White plate
I(1)
E, C, YIc
Beef semimembranosus muscle Fruit jellies
Sliced 12 8 1 cm
0
NM
NM
NM
K
Juice-sucrose-pectin jellies
NM
T
Distilled water
A(5)
Whole red peppers Fresh tomatoes
Blanched whole fruit
NM
NM
Colour plate
I(4)
L,
Whole, measured ‘as is’
NM
NM
Pink tile
I(6)
L, a, b , chroma
Lin et al. (1989)
Apples, fresh
Whole, measured ‘as is’
NM
NM
Pink tile
I(6)
L, a, b,
Sapers and Douglas (1987)
Raw apples and pears
20
Large/19
White tile
I(1)
L, a, b, X, Y, Z
Baardseth et al. (1988)
Potatoes, raw
Plug (22 mm diameter) removed from halved fruit. Transverse cut across plug just prior to measurement Cut lengthwise, covered with polyethylene film Cauliflower was measured ‘as is’ directly at port Directly on tomato equator
NM
H(2) H(I) A(4) H(1) A(4) M
L*
Raw cauliflower
8/8 50/50 25/32 50/50 25/32 NM/20
White tile
Baardseth et al. (1988) Hetherington et al. (1990)
4 5 cm transmission cell, 2 cm light path Measured around the shoulder of the fruit Measured at 8 equidistant locations on surface of fruit Measured at 8 equidistant locations on surface of fruit Fresh transverse surface of plug centred over instrument aperture Readings taken immediately through poly film No cover used
R (632, 614 nm) L,
Fresh tomatoes
NM
12
White tile White tile NM
L*, a*, b* L*, a*, b* XYZ, L*, a*, b*
a For instrument codes see Table 4.6 ; bFor colour scales see Chapter 3, Table 3.1; cYellowness index YI = 100/Y (1.277 X- 1.06Z) NM: not mentioned in the reference. T: transmission cell.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
107
Significant red colour loss and increase in browning were detected in modified atmosphere packaged apples by Lin et al. (1989). The unpackaged apples had more yellow colour loss than shrink-wrapped apples. The authors extracted three pigments from apple skin and showed that the highest correlation was obtained between cyanidin3-galactoside and Hunter a values. A useful technique for raw fresh cut potatoes has been employed by Baardseth et al. (1988). The pieces were wrapped in polyethylene film to retard browning and surface drying before placing on the instrument port; slices were then measured immediately. The L* values were compared between two instruments. Significant correlations were obtained between results from the Minolta large measuring area instrument (CR-110) and the HunterLab large measuring area instrument, as well as between the small area Minolta (CR-100) and the HunterLab instrument. Raw cauliflower was also measured by Baardseth et al. (1988). Measurements were made directly without extensive sample preparation using both large area measuring apertures on the Minolta (CR-110) and HunterLab units for comparison. The colour values obtained for cauliflower were found to overlap with mashed potato measurements. The authors suggest that data from these two food commodities could be combined to develop a regression equation that would allow a researcher to predict lightness and yellowness from the onset of treatment. Hetherington et al (1990) made tristimulus colour measurements on whole tomatoes. Using a* data they obtained significant correlation with both a mechanical measure of ripeness (puncture test) and with sensory observations associated with colour changes from green to red. By sectioning the fruit samples (2 mm thickness) and then measuring reflectance data over white and black backgrounds, absorption and scattering coefficients based on Kubelka-Munk theory were also obtained. These provided the necessary link, when combined with colorimetric data, to quantify the aspect of translucency. Ripeness, as used as a harvesting/buying criterion, requires both visual and tactile assessment and so by combining colour, mechanical and sensory testing this study clearly shows the potential for development of on-vine quality control instrumentation. 4.4.4 Pastes and slurries (Table 4.4) This group of materials offers the most problems in colour measurement terms, because of the influence of translucency and light trapping effects on the colour results. Baardseth et al. (1988) reported that the prediction index for yam colour measurements was the least precise in the red/green parameter than for all the other foods evaluated in the paper, such as mashed potato, raw potato and raw cauliflower. The authors suggested that homogeneity was a key factor in obtaining the most precise prediction index, and that in the case of yams, therefore, variations in the fruit pieces may have been a factor in the loss of precision. Nagle et al. (1979) homogenised pepper pods, the seeds and stems having been removed, prior to introduction of the sample into a cup provided with a white backing. Care was taken to allow the pure´es to settle; they were then vibrated to remove air bubbles. Good correlations were obtained between colour values and both xanthophyll and total pigment concentrations. The influence of blueberry content on topping mix colour has been investigated by Francis (1985). Blueberries were added to topping formulations as a pure´e. The formulations were then pasteurised and cooled before conventional measurement in glass cells allowing ‘infinite’ sample thickness.
Table 4.4
Colour measurement of pastes, pure´es and slurries
Reference
Sample
Preparation
Temperature (ºC)
Presentation (viewed from above/ below)
Illumination/ Standard aperture diameters (mm)
Instrumenta
Measurementb
Baardseth et al. (1988)
Mashed potatoes and yams
Commercially available samples
NM
50/50 25/32
White tile
H(1) A(4)
L*, a*, b*
Nagle et al. (1979); Reeves (1987)
Red pepper pure´e
Milled whole fruit
NM
NM
Colour plate
I(4)
L, a, b
Francis (1985)
Blueberry toppings
NM
NM
White tile
I(1)
L,
Clydesdale and Francis (1969)
Spinach pure´e
Pure´ed blueberries incorporated in topping mix with 15% or 30% fruit content. Formulations pasteurized Milled spinach processed to Fo 4.9
Plexiglass cell, 10cm cube with 3 mm quartz glass front Sample cell with white top plate (below) 3 cm depth in 6 cm diameter cell (below)
NM
NM
NM
Grey tile, pressed Ba2SO4
Huang et al. (1970)
Squash pure´e
Commercially available samples
NM
X, Y, Z L, a, b G, R, B X, Y, Z
Silva et al. (1989)
Sweet potato mash
NM
Orange tile
A
L, a, b ; C
Bosset et al. (1986)
Yoghurt
Various potato sizes were canned or steamed, then frozen or canned Commercially available samples
6.4 cm diameter cells, 14/47 sample thickness between 47/47 2 and 8 mm, backed by black or white papers NM NM
A C L L
NM
F(1)
L, a, b
Brimelow (1987)
Tomato paste
Dilute to 12% TSSc
20
Red tile
A(2)
a
NM
500 ml measuring cell, NM yoghurts stirred before measurement 50 mm depth in 62.5 mm 51/51 diameter cell (below). Black cover
Pressed Ba2SO4 pink tile A
a/b
For instrument codes see Table 4.6; bFor colour scales see Chapter 3, Table 3.1;cTSS: total soluble solids (%) measured on the sugar scale; NM: not mentioned in the reference.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
109
Clydesdale and Francis (1969) measured the colour of spinach pure´es formed by blanching fresh spinach, comminuting, deaerating and finally processing to F0 4.9 in glass jars (F0 being the time-temperature sterilisation value, related to minutes at 121ºC). Measurements were made on a tristimulus colorimeter ‘hitched’ to a grey colour tile standard. Squash pure´es have been measured by Huang et al. (1970) using reflectance techniques in conjunction with the Kubelka-Munk concept. In this concept, reflectance measurements of thin layers of material are made over both white and black backgrounds. A reflectance value at infinite thickness can be calculated as well as ratio values for light scattering and absorption. In the work on squash pure´es, a tristimulus colorimeter was employed previously ‘hitched’ to a pink standard. Good correlations were achieved between visual ratings and colour values, and between visual ratings and Kubelka-Munk absorption/scattering ratios. Silva et al. (1989) examined sweet potatoes prepared by various methods. All samples were mashed or pure´ed for chemical and physical analyses. The authors utilised an orange colour tile for ‘hitching’ standardisation of a Hunter D25 instrument. Colour differentiation of the process variables in the L, a, hue angle and saturation or chroma measurements could be used, the authors suggested, in predicting the quality of these types of products. The lower L, a and saturation values of canned samples versus their frozen equivalents were indicative of the more extensive heating which the canned products received. In an extensive study to evaluate the effects of packaging materials, light and storage on solid, whole milk yoghurt, Bosset et al. (1986) measured colour changes in the yoghurt in a specially designed 500 ml capacity cell for the MacBeth Spectrophotocolorimeter. Their results indicated that changes in the L, a and b colour values could be related to exposure to light through the various packages. In particular, the authors reported that Hunter a, b values were sensitive indicators of product changes due to photodegradation. Finally, an exhaustive study of some of the variables affecting the measurement of tomato paste colour has been carried out by Brimelow (1987). The effects of such factors as paste dilution, test duration, instrument aperture size and illumination area, sample temperature, standardisation hitching-post tile temperature, and the presence or absence of extraneous light were all examined. A standard colour measurement procedure was advocated for this important food commodity. 4.4.5 Liquids (Table 4.5) Many clear or lightly translucent liquids are measured by transmission techniques, as already discussed. Thus Francis (1985) measured the colour of blueberry beverages in 2cm cells, Calvi and Francis (1978) measured grape beverages in 1 cm cells, Skrede et al. (1985) measured blackcurrant syrups in 1 cm cells after diluting to 12º Brix, and Pilando et al. (1985) measured strawberry wine in 1 cm cells. The study of Skrede et al. (1985) illustrates how colour measurement can be used to predict the shelf-life of a particular food material. Commercial blackcurrant syrups were packed in various packaging materials with different barrier properties. Storage lives varied between 2 months in high density polyethylene, 12 months in polyester and 18 months in glass. Combinations of Hunter L, a and b values were found to give acceptable predictive abilities for visual colour. Francis (1985) found in the blueberry beverages that an increase of blueberry content from 5 to 12 per cent did not result in a corresponding increase in visual colour. Since the
Table 4.5
Colour measurement of liquids
Reference
Sample
Preparation
Temperature (ºC)
Presentation (viewed from above/ below)
Illumination/ Standard aperture diameters (mm)
Instrumenta
Measurementb
Francis (1985)
Blueberry beverages
NM
2 cm transmission cell
T
Distilled water
I(2)
L,
Francis and Clydesdale (1972) Calvi and Francis (1978)
Egg Yolk
Pure´ed blueberries incorporated in beverage mix with 5% and 12% fruit content. Formulation pasteurized Homogenize
NM
10/NM
NM
A
a, b
Grape anthocyanins incorporated in carbonated beverage formulation Dilution of the syrups 1 to 4 with H2O Thawed berries, sugar and yeast fermented to wine, then racked and bottled with SO2 wine stored in the dark Cell filled with ca 500 ml of liquid Molten solutions
NM
20 mm depth glass (below) 1 cm transmission cell
T
Distilled water
I(5)
a/L
NM
1 cm transmission cell
T
Water
J
L, a, b
NM
Transmission in a 1.0 5.0 5.0 cm lucite cell, with gloss excluded Reflectance in 500 ml sample cell 50ml cuvette with a white tile cover 1,2, 5, 10mm cuvette white and black backing Measuring cell containing over 5 cm depth. Black cover
T
White tile
A(5)
L, a, b
NM
White tile
F(1)
L, a, b
NM
Instrument white and black tiles White tile
N
L, a, b
F(2)
L*a*b*, E*
White tile
A(2)
L, a, b, y
Skrede et al. (1985) Pilando et al. (1985)
Desarzens et al. (1983) Cole and Roberts (1997) Authors’ laboratory (1999) MacDougall (1987)
a
Carbonated grape beverage Blackcurrant syrups Strawberry wine
Liquid milk products Gelatine Liquid milk Evaporated milk, Orange juice, Tomato paste
UHT milk of varying fat content Dilution with distilled water to obtain various specified solids contents, giving opaque to translucent solutions
NM 40 25 NM
510 50 down to 10/50 down to 5
For instrument codes see Table 4.6; bFor colour scales see Chapter 3, Table 3.1; NM: not mentioned in the reference; T: transmission cell.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance Table 4.6
Colour measurement instruments
Code for Tables 4.1–4.5
Instrument
A
HunterLab Color Difference Meter D25 D25A D25M DL25 D25P D25 with transmission D25-PC2 Hilger Biochem Colormaster Differential Colorimeter DU COLOR Color Difference Meter (Neotec) Hunter Color and Color Difference Meter Macbeth Spectrophotometer MS-2000 ColorEye 7000 MOMCOLOR D (MOM Hungarian Optical Works) Minolta Chroma Meter CR-110 CR-100 II Gardner Automatic Color and Color Difference Meter XL-23 XL-23 with transmission Colorguard 2000/45 sensor XL-10A XL-10 with transmission XL-845 Shimadzu 300-UV Bausch & Lamb Spectronic 20 with reflectance attachment GE Recording Spectrophotometer Instrumental Color System Micromatch 2000 BYK-Gardner Color-View Spectrophotometer
B C
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
D E F G H
I
(1) (2)
(1) (2) (3)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) K L M N
NM: not mentioned in the reference.
Geometry
Illuminant source
45º/0ºC 45º/0º Circumferential 45º/0º Circumferential 45º/0º Integrating sphere 0º/d Transmission 45º/0º Transmission Tristimulus reflectance
C C C NM C NM NM NM C
Circumferential illumination
NM
Tristimulus reflectance
NM
Integrating sphere 0º/d Integrating sphere d/8º Tristimulus colorimeter
C D65 C
d/0º d/0º Tristimulus colorimeter Tristimulus colorimeter
C C NM NM
Tristimulus colorimeter Transmission Circumferential 45º/0º
C NM C
NM Transmission Tristimulus colorimeter Transmission NM
C NM NM C NM
NM
NM
d/8º
D65
NM
NM
111
112
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
berries are highly pigmented, he surmised that a much greater increase in pigment would be required to achieve an observable change in the beverage colour. Calvi and Francis (1978) were able to correlate the anthocyanins content of the extracted concord grape filter trim with the a/L index of grape beverages at various storage temperatures. Pilando et al. (1985) found that both anthocyanin content and Hunter L values were highly correlated with sensory panel judgements when assessing the colour quality of strawberry wine. Translucent liquids have been measured by Francis and Clydesdale (1972) (egg yolks), Desarzens et al. (1983) (liquid milk products), MacDougall (1987) (evaporated milk, orange juice) and others. These materials are measured by conventional reflectance techniques, ensuring usually that samples are at ‘infinite’ thickness. Work in the authors’ laboratory (JP) (1999) has used a path-length variability technique to get a quantitative measure of translucency in milk samples of varying fat content. By using cuvettes of systematically increasing thickness (1 mm–10 mm) and measuring over black and white backgrounds, samples could be characterised with the results comparing favourably to those obtained by sensory analysis. Cole and Roberts (1997) used a different approach for their measurement of translucent molten gelatine solutions. Considering that the light which reaches the human eye during visual assessment of gelatine samples comprises both reflected and transmitted light, Cole and Roberts used a spectrophotometer and a transreflectance presentation of the samples. In such cases, it is essential that the scatter within the sample (in this case caused by molecular gelatine) is small in comparison to that from the white background tile. Tristimulus Hunter L data was found to correlate to colour values ascribed via Beer’s law and a DCU index often used in the gelatine industry. The authors suggest that such a reference instrumental method of measurement could overcome many of the problems which occur as a result of the numerous ‘in-house’ colour grading systems currently in use. Francis and Clydesdale (1972) urged that egg yolks should be homogenised before colour measurement. This is because yolks are formed in a layered manner and poultry feed variations can, therefore, cause colour variations within each yolk. Desarzens et al. (1983) had a large capacity sample cell especially made to use with the MacBeth MS2000 for liquid milk products. In a study of several types of liquid milk products, the authors were able to establish a relationship between measured colour changes in the products and a decrease of riboflavin content during storage exposure to light. MacDougall (1987) has shown that instrumental variables, such as aperture size and illumination area, have a large effect on the colour values obtained for a number of translucent liquids.
4.5
Conclusions
It is clear that to be able to compare colour measurements on different samples of the same food materials, either within a laboratory or between different laboratories, the experimental procedure must be carefully defined and standardised. Despite the obviousness of this statement, it is surprising how little information is given in much of the available literature on colour measurement, concerning the following essential areas: • the choice of the viewing geometry and illumination type (which is associated with the selection of the instrument)
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance • • • •
the the the the
113
calibration of the instrument, including defining the calibration standards selection of the instrument variables of aperture and illumination areas selection, preparation and presentation of the samples defining of other relevant details of the test procedure, such as the temperature.
Hunter (1987) has given a very useful checklist, in standardised format, which can be used as a reminder when documenting the variables in an experimental procedure for measuring the colour of a food material. When at a loss as to how to proceed with a new problem in food colour measurement, it may be as well to keep in mind a number of pieces of good advice given by Francis and Clydesdale (1975): 1. 2. 3.
To measure the visual impact of a food sample, the golden rule is to perform the measurement on the sample as the consumer sees it, with as little sample preparation as possible. To predict the content of a chemical colour component in a food material by colorimetry, it is best to ensure when setting up the predictive curve that the only variable is the colour component. Having obtained a good correlation between a particular colour function and the visual judgement in one application it is not safe to assume, without further visual testing, that the colour function will give an equally good correlation in the case of another food material.
With advancing technology and decreasing hardware costs, colour reflectance measurement is becoming a much more accessible tool for the whole of the food industry. Using instrumental colour measurement in combination with sensory analysis and other physical measurements can provide insights into many phenomena associated with food manufacture. The ever-growing choice of instruments on the market means that the best purchase choice can be made depending upon the samples to be measured and the desired results. Finally, the advent of in-line analysis facilitates the advent of colour measurement as an important tool for quality control and process monitoring in the future.
4.6
References
and PAULI, P. (1978) ‘The objective testing of dehydrated vermicellis with reference to colour and -carotene content’. Hungarian Scientific Instruments, 42, 7– 12. BAARDSETH, P., SKREDE, G., NAES, T., THOMASSEN, M. S., IVERSEN, A and KAABER, L. (1988) ‘A comparison of CIE (1976) L*a*b* values obtained from two different instruments on several food commodities’. Journal of Food Science, 53 (6), 1737–1742. BERGTHALLER, W., KEMPF, W. and SCHALLER, A. (1983) ‘Instrumental measurement and sensory evaluation of the colour of dried potato cubes’. Internationale Zeitschrift fuer Lebensmittel-Technologie und Verfahrenstecknik, 34 (3), 174, 177–178, 180, 182–183. BERSET, C. and CANIUAX, P. (1983) ‘Relationship between color evaluation and chlorophyllian pigment content in dried parsley leaves’. Journal of Food Science, 48, 1854–1857, 1877. BILLMEYER, Jr., F. W. (1981) In: Golden Jubilee of Colour in the CIE (Commission ANDRE´, L.
114
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry Internationale de l’Eclairage), Proceedings of a Symposium held by The Colour Group (GB), Imperial College, London.
BOSSET, J. O., DAGET, N., DESARZENS, C., DIEFFENBACHER, A., FLUCKIGER, E., LAVANCHY, P., NICK, B., PAUCHARD, J. P. and TAGLIAFERRI, E. (1986) ‘The influence of light
transmittance and gas permeability of various packing materials on the quality of whole natural yoghurt during storage’. In Food Packaging and Preservation: Theory and Practice, ed. M. Mathlouthi, 235–270, Elsevier, London. BRIMELOW, C. J. B. (1987) ‘Measurement of tomato paste colour: investigation of some method variables’. In Physical Properties of Foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 295–317, Elsevier, London. CALVI, J. P. and FRANCIS, F. J. (1978) ‘Stability of concord grape (V. labrusca) anthocyanins in model systems’. Journal of Food Science, 43 (5), 1448–1456. CHRISTENSEN, C. M. (1983) ‘Effects of color on aroma, flavor and texture judgements of foods’. Journal of Food Science, 48, 787–790. CIE (1931) Proceedings of the Eighth Session, Cambridge, England, Bureau Central de la CIE, Paris. CIE (1979) Colorimetry. CIE Publication 15 (E1.3.1), Bureau Central de la CIE, Paris. CIE (1995) Industrial Colour-Difference Evaluation, CIE Technical Report (116-1995), CIE Central Bureau, Vienna. CLYDESDALE, F. M. (1977) ‘Color measurement’. In Current Aspects of Food Colorants, ed. T. E. Furia, 1–17, CRC, West Palm Beach, FL. CLYDESDALE, F. M. and FRANCIS, F. J. (1969) ‘Colorimetry of foods. 1: Correlation of raw transformed and reduced data with visual rankings for spinach pure´e’. Journal of Food Science, 34, 349–352. COLE, C.G. and ROBERTS, J.J. (1997) ‘Gelatine Colour Measurement’. Meat Science, 45 (1), 23–31. DESARZENS, C., BOSSET, J. O. and BLANC, B. (1983) ‘La photo de´gradation de lait et de quelques produits laitiers. Part I: Alte´rations de la couleur, de gouˆt et de la teneur en quelques vitamines’. Lebensmittel-Wissenschaft und Technologie, 17, 241–247. EAGERMAN, B. A., CLYDESDALE, F. M. and FRANCIS, F. J. (1978) ‘A rapid reflectance procedure for following myoglobin oxidative or reductive changes in intact beef muscle’. Journal of Food Science, 43, 468–469. FRANCIS, F. J. (1952) ‘A method for measuring the skin colour of apples’. Proceedings of the American Society of Horticultural Science, 60, 213–220. FRANCIS, F. J. (1985) ‘Blueberries as a colorant ingredient in food products’. Journal of Food Science, 50, 754756. FRANCIS, F. J. and CLYDESDALE, F. M. (1972) ‘Colour measurement of foods. XXXV: Miscellaneous. Part V: egg yolks’. Food Products Development, Aug./Sept., 47, 48, 55. FRANCIS, F. J. and CLYDESDALE, F. M. (1975) Food Colorimetry: Theory and Applications, Chapter 1. AVI, Westport, CT. FREEDMAN, L. and FRANCIS, F. J. (1984) ‘Effect of ascorbic acid on color of jellies’. Journal of Food Science, 49, 1212–1213. GIESE, J. (2000) ‘Color measurement in foods as a quality parameter’. Food Technology, 54 (2), 62–63. GRIEDER, H. (1989) Personal communication. GUILD, J. (1931) ‘The colorimetric properties of the spectrum.’ Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, A230, 149-87. HABIB, A. T. and BROWN, H. D. (1956) ‘Factors influencing the color of potato chips’. Food Technology, 7, 332–336.
Colour measurement of foods by colour reflectance
115
and FLOROS, D. (1998) ‘Modelling the change in colour of potassium sorbate powder during heating’. International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 33, 199–203. HETHERINGTON, M.J., MARTIN, A., MACDOUGALL, D.B., LANFLEY, K.R. and BRATCHELL, N. (1990) ‘Comparison and physical measurements with sensory assessment of the ripeness of tomato fruit’, Lycopersicon esculentum, Food Quality and Preference , 2, 243–253. HUANG, I. L., FRANCIS, F. J. and CLYDESDALE, F. M. (1970) ‘Colorimetry of foods. 2: Color measurement of squash pure´e using the Kubelka-Munk concept’. Journal of Food Science, 35, 315–317. HUEY, S. J. (1965) ‘Low temperature storage of color standards panels’. Color Engineering, 3, Sept./Oct., 24–27. HUNTER, R. S. (1958) ‘Photoelectric color difference meter’. Journal of the Optical Society of America, 48, 985–995. HUNTER, R. S. (1987) ‘Objective methods for food appearance assessment’. In Objective Methods in Food Quality Assessment, ed. J. G. Kapsalis, 137–153, CRC, Boca Raton, FL. HUNTER, R. S. and CHRISTIE, J. S. (1978) ‘Geometrical factors in colour evaluation of pure´es, pastes and granular food specimens’. Journal of Food Protection, 41 (9), 726–729. HUNTER, R. S. and HAROLD, R. W. (1987) The Measurement of Appearance. Wiley, New York. JOHNSTON, R. A., QUICK, J. S. and DONNELLY, B. J. (1980) ‘Note on comparison of pigment extraction and reflectance colorimeter methods for evaluating semolina colour’. Cereal Chemistry, 57 (6), 447–448. JOSHI, P. (2000) ‘Physical aspects of color in foods’. Chemical Innovation, February, 19–24. JUDD, D. B. (1939) ‘Specification of uniform color tolerances for textiles’. Textile Research, IX (7), 171 (8). KENT, M. and SMITH, G. C. (1987) ‘Collaborative experiments in colour measurement’. In Physical Properties of Foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 251–276, Elsevier, London. KONSTANCE, R. P., HEILAND, W. K. and CRAIG, Jr., J. C. (1988) ‘Component recognition in beef chuck using colorimetric determination’. Journal of Food Science, 53 (3), 971– 972. LEE, C. Y., SMITH, N. L. and HAWBECKER, D. E. (1988) ‘Enzyme activity and quality of frozen green beans as affected by blanching and storage’. Journal of Food Quality, 11 (4), 279–287. LIN, T. Y., KOHLER, P. E. and SHEWFELT, R. L. (1989) ‘Stability of anthocyanins in the skin of starkrimson apples stored unpackaged, under heat shrinkable wrap and in-package modified atmosphere’. Journal of Food Science, 54 (2), 405–407. LITTLE, A. C. and MACKINNEY, G. (1956) ‘On the color of coffee’. Food Technology, 10, 503–506. MABON, T. (1989) BYK-Gardner. Personal communication. MABON, T. (1993). ‘Color measurement of food’. Cereal Foods World, 38, 21–25. MACDOUGALL, D. B. (1982) ‘Changes in the colour and opacity of meat’. Food Chemistry, 9, 75–88. MACDOUGALL, D. B. (1983) ‘Instrumental assessment of the appearance of foods’. In Sensory Quality in Foods and Beverages: its Definition, Measurement and Control, eds A. A. Williams and R. K. Atkin, 121–139, Ellis Horwood, Chichester. HANS, J.H.
116
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
(1987) ‘Optical measurements and visual assessment of translucent foods’. In Physical Properties of Foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 319330, Elsevier, London. MCFARLANE, I. (1988) ‘In-line measurement and closed loop control of the color of breakfast cereals’. Cereal Foods World, 33 (12), 978–980. MILLER, O. H. and BURNS, E. E. (1971) ‘Internal color of Spanish peanut hulls as an index of kernel maturity’. Journal of Food Science, 36, 669–670. NAGLE, B. J., VILLANON, B. and BURNS, E. E. (1979) ‘Color evaluation of selected capsicums’. Journal of Food Science, 44 (2), 416–418. OZDEMIR, M. and DEVRES, O. (2000) ‘Kinetics of colour changes of hazelnuts during roasting’. Journal of Food Engineering 44, 31–38. PANGBORN, R. H. (1967)‘ Some aspects of chemo-reception in human nutrition’. In The Chemical Senses and Nutrition, eds M. R. Kane and O. Mailer, Chapter 4, Johns Hopkins, Baltimore. PILANDO, L. S., WROLSTAD, R. E. and HEATHERBELL, D. A. (1985) ‘Influence of fruit composition, maturity and mold contamination on the color and appearance of strawberry wine’. Journal of Food Science, 50, 1121–1125. REEVES, M. J. (1987) ‘Re-evaluation of capsicum color data’. Journal of Food Science, 52 (4), 1047–1049. SAPERS, G. M. and DOUGLAS, Jr., F. W. (1987) ‘Measurement of enzymatic browning at cut surfaces and in juice of raw apples and pear fruits’. Journal of Food Science, 52 (5), 1258–1262, 1285. SEAKINS, J. M. (1971) ‘Colour evaluation of transparent dairy products in powder form’. New Zealand Journal of Dairy Science and Technology, 6 (1), 2425. SHEWFELT, R. L., BRECHT, J. K., BEVERLY, R. B. and GARNER, J. C. (1989) ‘Modifications of conditions at wholesale warehouse to improve quality of fresh-market tomatoes’. Journal of Food Quality, 11 (5), 397–409. SILVA, J. L., YAZID, M. D., ALI, M. D. and AMMERMAN, G. R. (1989) ‘Effect of processing method on products made from sweet potato mash’. Journal of Food Quality, 11 (5), 387–396. SKREDE, G. (1985) ‘Color quality of blackcurrant syrups during storage evaluated by Hunter L, a, b values’. Journal of Food Science, 50, 514517, 525. SMITH, K.J. (1997) ‘Colour-order systems, colour spaces, colour difference and colour scales’. In Colour Physics for Industry, 2nd edn, ed. R. McDonald, 121–208, Society of Dyers and Colorists, Bradford. WRIGHT, W. D. (1969) The Measurement of Colour, 4th edn Van Nostrand Reinhold, London. MACDOUGALL, D. B.
5 Sorting by colour in the food industry J. M. Low, W. S. Maughan, S. C. Bee and M. J. Honeywood, Sortex Limited, London
5.1
Introduction
Food has colour, and good food is often a different colour from bad food. This in itself is not a very remarkable statement but its implications for the food industry are very significant. The human perception of colour has proved very effective in the determination of quality in many foods, and the sorting of food particles using the human eye and hand has been, and still is, widely practised. Machines designed to replace the hand sorter obviously need to duplicate some of the functions of the human eye, brain and hand. Automatic colour sorting is often referred to as ‘electronic sorting’, as it was the advent of electronics that made possible the duplication of the eye and brain functions. Experiments with automatic sorting equipment started immediately after World War II and colour sorting machines gained early acceptance in the food industry. Demand for automatic sorting machines continues to increase owing to the escalating costs of hand sorting coupled with the higher quality requirements being imposed on food producers. There is also an increasing realisation of the importance of sorting in the reduction of health hazards arising from contaminated food, whether due to the food itself or the presence of foreign bodies such as stones or wood, and the avoidance of associated product liability claims which are escalating dramatically in both number and value.
5.2
What is a sorting machine?
Colour sorters generally consist of four principal systems, as shown in Fig. 5.1: 1.
2.
A feed system, which presents food particles to the subsequent systems in a controlled manner. Figure 5.1 shows a feed system which involves a conveyor belt to align the particles and ensure that they pass through the machine at a constant velocity. However, feed systems can also be based upon inclined chutes, contrarotating rollers and different combinations of these features. An inspection system, which measures the reflectivity of each particle. The inspection components are housed in an optical chamber, through which or past
Fig. 5.1
Sorting machine systems.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
3. 4.
119
which the particles travel. Particles do not come into contact with any part of the optical chamber and are separated from it by glass screens or windows. The optical chamber contains one or more lens and detector units, depending on the number of directions from which the particles are viewed. Lamp units, designed to provide even and consistent illumination of particles, are also usually contained within the optical chamber. A signal processing system, in which electrical signals from the detectors are amplified and fed to decision-making circuitry which classifies particles as either ‘accept’ or ‘reject’. A separation system, capable of physically separating particles classified as reject from those classified as accept. Usually, separation takes place while the particles are in free fall; accept particles are allowed to continue along their normal trajectory, and rejects are deflected from it into a receptacle. Deflection is usually achieved by emitting short bursts of compressed air through nozzles aimed directly at the rejects, although large or heavy particles may require some sort of piston-operated device to deflect the rejects.
The size, cost and complexity of sorting machines varies depending on the size range of particles to be handled, the throughput requirement and the complexity of optical measurement. Machines are employed in sorting particles as small as mustard seeds; however, rice grains are among the smallest particles to be sorted on a large commercial scale. At the other end of the size range are vegetables and fruit such as potatoes and peaches. Seeds are usually sorted on a single- or double-chute machine at a throughput of 60 to 600 kg/hour. A higher throughput can be achieved on a multi-chute or a conveyor belt machine; rice at 16 tonnes/hour (320,000 objects/sec) and peas at up to 16 tonnes/hour are typical examples. The simplest type of optical measurement is taken from one direction and is of a single wavelength band. More complicated optical measurements involve two or more wavebands and may be made from several directions around the particle. The products that can be handled by today’s automatic sorting machines include seeds, coffee, rice, breakfast cereals, nuts and pulses; fresh, frozen and dehydrated vegetables; cherries and tomatoes; and biscuits and confectionery. Foreign material such as stones, sticks and organic matter can be removed, as well as particles with defects such as discoloration and damaged skin. Figures 5.2 and 5.3 show two typical sorting machines.
5.3
Assessment of food particles for colour sorting
5.3.1 Spectrophotometry To determine whether a particulate food product is suitable for colour sorting, and which type of sorting machine and optical configuration is most suitable, samples of both acceptable and unacceptable produce must be measured and assessed in the laboratory. Actually the term ‘colour sorting’ is a misnomer, possibly arising from the effect on the product of sorting. The criterion used when assessing food particles for sorting, and what the sorting machine measures when it inspects the product, is spectral reflectivity at particular wavelengths, rather than the colour as a whole. Figures 5.4 and 5.5 illustrate typical spectral curves obtained from a product. Intensity varies from black (0) to white (100), and wavelength covers the visible spectrum (400 to 700 nm) and extends into the
120
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 5.2 Sortex 90000 is a gravity chute machine, designed for bulk sorting of dry products such as coffee, or rice. The machine is just under 2 m in height, 1.5 m wide by 2.5 m deep.
Fig. 5.3 Sortex ‘Niagara’ is a broad belt sorting machine, designed for simultaneous colour and shape sorting, of frozen or fresh vegetables. Niagara is just over 1.5 m in height, 2 m wide by 3 m long.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
Fig. 5.4
121
Spectral curves – monochromatic sorting; response curves for — ‘accept’ samples, – – – ‘reject’ samples.
near infra-red. Ideally there will be a part of the spectrum where intensity values for all acceptable produce are either higher or lower than values for all unacceptable material; if so, this part of the spectrum can be used as a basis for sorting. In practice the spectrum is normally restricted to a narrow waveband in the sorting machine by the use of optical filters. Conventional spectrophotometry in the food industry involves the measurement of carefully prepared surfaces under standard optical conditions and illumination. However, practical industrial sorting machines must deal with naturally occurring surfaces viewed under non-ideal light conditions. To obtain the best possible result for a given product, special computerised reflection spectrophotometers have been developed which enable the appropriate characteristics of the naturally occurring surfaces to be measured. Diffuse
Fig. 5.5
Spectral curves – bichromatic sorting; response curves for — ‘accept’ samples, – – – ‘reject’ samples
122
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
spherical broadband lighting is used to illuminate uniformly the particle under test. The reflected light is then passed through a computer controlled scanning monochromator, which splits the light into its constituent wavelengths. The output is measured using a suitable detector and the data are fed into the computer. When the equipment is appropriately calibrated, the results can be plotted showing the variation of reflectivity with wavelength for both acceptable and defective product. 5.3.2 Monochromatic sorting Sorting that uses the form of optical measurement described in the preceding section is known as monochromatic sorting. It is so called because it is based on the measurement of reflectivity in a single isolated band of wavelengths. For it to be effective, there must be a distinct difference in reflectivity within the selected waveband between all the acceptable particles and all the reject particles (see Fig. 5.4). Removing dark, rotten peanuts and removing black speck from rice are typical applications of monochromatic sorting. 5.3.3 Bichromatic sorting Unfortunately, it is not always possible to find a single section of the spectrum where the intensity levels of accept and reject material are clearly separated, and in these cases it is necessary to resort to a more complicated procedure. This is known as bichromatic sorting, and involves measurement in two different wavelength bands. Figure 5.5 shows two sets of spectral response curves obtained from green arabica coffee. One set of curves (solid curves) represents the lightest and darkest of acceptable beans, the other (dashed curves) represents the lightest and darkest of discoloured beans; clearly, there is no wavelength where there is a complete separation of the two sets of curves. However, it can be seen that between 510 nm and 660 nm the difference in the gradients of the two sets of curves is at its greatest. If measurement A is taken at 540 nm and measurement B is taken at 660 nm, and the ratio A:B is calculated, then this will give an unambiguous separation of the two particle types. (In principle, measurement A could be taken at 510 nm, but this would yield a lower signal intensity.) Bichromatic sorting involves duplication of optical and detection components, the addition of light-splitting devices and more complex signal processing. Therefore it is used only when a simple monochromatic measurement is unable to give a satisfactory result. 5.3.4 Dual monochromatic sorting A third type of measurement, similar to bichromatic in that two wavebands are observed but without employing the ratio of the two measurements, is known as dual monochromatic. As its name implies, this system sorts monochromatically in each of two separate wavebands. This type of sorting is used when it is necessary to reject two types of defect or, for instance, defects and foreign material, each of which exhibit different spectral characteristics. An example of dual monochromatic sorting is found with white beans; maize is rejected by detecting blue reflectance, and white stones are rejected using near infra-red. Some practical separations require both monochromatic and bichromatic decisions for the successful removal of all defects. Therefore automatic sorting machines are available which are capable of making both types of measurement simultaneously.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
123
5.3.5 Trichromatic sorting Bichromatic sorting techniques are clearly extendable to trichromatic measurement. The information gained from the third band-pass filter is often used for detection of gross defects such as the presence of foreign material, including glass, stones, thistle heads, caterpillars and mice! Trichromatic sorting almost always uses either green, red and infra-red band pass wavelengths, or less typically for the food industry, red, green and blue. Trichromatic sorting allows objects to be sorted according to their size or shape, by suitable modifications to the sorting algorithm. In this way objects of the same colour, but differing shapes can be separated. For example, pea pod can be distinguished from peas and green stalks, or green caterpillars from green beans. Under or over sized objects along with mis-shaped objects, with holes or cracks can also be detected and effectively removed. The Sortex Niagara machine is capable of simultaneously sorting for both colour and shape at a rate of 40,000 objects/second. 5.3.6 Fluorescence techniques Of course, not all bad food is a different colour from good food. It has been found that certain non-visible defects (bacteria for example) fluoresce when irradiated with longwave ultraviolet light (350 nm), and this property may be used as a basis for sorting. This technique was originally developed for removing ‘stinkers’ from green arabica coffee beans, but has found applications in sorting peanuts, almonds and cranberries. 5.3.7 Infra-red techniques Over the last decade, the wavelength range used by sorting machines has been extended from the visible, further into the infra-red region. Here, both water absorption and other chemical effects play an important part in determining the reflectivity characteristics of food particles. Bichromatic infra-red machines are proving particularly effective in removing shell fragments from a variety of tree nuts. 5.3.8 Optical sorting with lasers Incorporating the use of lasers into bulk food sorting is a technique that is still in its relative infancy. A laser beam is used to illuminate the product and the degree of reflected light is affected by the amount of laser light that is either scattered from the surface, or diffused within an object. Since the laser produces narrow beams of coherent light at a single wavelength, there is no need to use optical band pass filters. However, the principal difficulty with this technique is in maintaining the high capacity demanded by the bulk sorting industry, in conjunction with the necessary resolution to detect defects accurately. The linear scan rate of the laser across the width of the view and the velocity of the product determine the vertical resolution. To date, laser scanning is limited to approximately 2000 scans per second. For product travelling at 4 m/s, the vertical resolution is therefore of the order of 2 mm. By comparison, line scan CCD technology can offer a resolution of 0.3mm. There are additional problems associated with the drop in illumination intensity and therefore, signal-to-noise levels that result by fanning out the laser beam across a line of sight. It can be quite a design challenge to scan a laser reliably and mechanically by say, a rotating polygon mirror, in the hostile temperature and debris ridden environments that are often encountered in food processing plants.
124
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
To a limited extent, some successful sub-surface and texture inspection can be carried out on certain soft fruits and berries with laser light. In fact, the technique has already been commercially deployed for some product areas in the food industry, notably for dried fruits like raisons, or certain vegetables, nuts and tobacco. There is certainly scope for further study and possible wider exploitation of the technique.
5.4
The optical inspection system
5.4.1 Introduction At any given wavelength, the characteristics of the electrical signal from the detector will depend on the particle reflectivity and size, the light source, the properties of any filters fitted and the nature of the detector itself. The range of wavelengths measured by the machine is defined by the choice of these last three elements. Traditionally the light source and detector in a given machine were fixed, but the filters could be changed to accommodate different produce. In modern equipment it is often possible to fit lighting with different spectral characteristics and even to change the type of detector, as well as easily exchange filters. Once the spectral feature or features which are to be used as a basis for separation have been identified, the relevant wavelength bands must be isolated by selection of appropriate filters and illumination. A primary objective of selecting filters and lighting is to obtain the maximum possible signal-to-noise ratio from the detector at the required wavelengths, and the minimum possible signal at all other wavelengths. 5.4.2 Illumination When dealing with irregularly shaped particles, uniform diffuse illumination is necessary to minimise the occurrence of highlights and shadows, as these would obviously detract from the measurement of true surface reflectivity. Ideally, at the point of measurement, the particle should be surrounded by a spherical surface of uniform brightness; in practice, however, a number of factors preclude the attainment of this ideal. Firstly, if the inspection chamber is designed so that the product particles pass through it, there must be provision for entry and exit ports. Secondly, the position of the optical components will result in areas of different brightness compared with the main chamber wall. Thirdly, the use of light sources of finite size leads to non-uniform illumination. A further problem that can arise, even with a perfect diffuse illumination sphere, is that of specular reflection. If a particle with a diffuse reflective surface is placed in such a sphere then its true colour will be observed. However, if the particle surface is not diffuse, specular reflection will occur, giving highlights which do not exhibit the true colour of the surface. Clearly the highlights can adversely affect the optical system and hence result in the incorrect classification of a particle. In practice, illumination is provided by either fluorescent tubes or incandescent filament bulbs, or a combination of both. A number of lamps are arranged to give as uniform a distribution of light as possible; with incandescent lamps, screens are often positioned to diffuse the high-intensity point of light emitted by the filament. Fluorescent tubes can be produced with different spectral characteristics, extending from the ultraviolet to the far red, as shown in Fig. 5.6. The advantages of the fluorescent tube are its cool operation, long life and diffuse light. Its disadvantages are low red emission and the need for a special power supply to prevent flicker.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
Fig. 5.6
125
Spectral characteristics of fluorescent tubes.
Incandescent lamps inherently have a wide spectral range from blue to the near infrared, as shown in Fig. 5.7. These lamps have the advantage of wide spectral emission and DC operation, but suffer from being point sources which dissipate large amounts of heat. In general, the use of fluorescent tubes is favoured except in cases where a deep red or
126
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 5.7
Spectral characteristics of an incandescent lamp.
near infra-red measurement is required. The wider spectral range required for bichromatic machines necessitates the use of incandescent lamps. 5.4.3 Background and aperture Having arranged for the particle to be illuminated in the optimum manner, it is necessary to consider the best optical arrangements for obtaining the necessary data. The simplest form of inspection system views the particles against an illuminated background and through a small aperture. The brightness of the background is adjusted so that the optical system measures the same average value with or without product. This is known as a ‘matched’ background because it matches the average brightness of product, including any defects. The advantage of matching the background is that measurement of reflectivity is independent of particle size. For example, consider the case of a stream of particles containing rejects which are darker than accepts. If a matched background is used then whenever a defect passes across the aperture a decrease in signal amplitude will result, but a light particle will cause an increase in amplitude; thus an unambiguous decision can be made by the electronics. If, on the other hand, a background lighter than all particles were to be used, then all particles would give a decrease in signal; in particular, small dark defects could give signals identical to those of large light particles and hence the two could not be separated. Note that the brightness of the light reflected from a particle through the aperture is the product of the size of the particle and its reflectivity, including any area of discoloration. The background may be either an opaque surface reflecting light from suitably located lamps, or a translucent surface transmitting light from rearmounted lamps or LEDs. The aperture takes the form of a rectangular slit, as shown in Fig. 5.8. The width of the slit must be sufficient to allow for scatter in the trajectories of the particles and for the range of particle sizes. The height of the slit is kept to a minimum, consistent with
Sorting by colour in the food industry
127
Fig. 5.8 Viewing aperture.
sufficient signal, in order to give maximum resolution and for accurate timing of the delay between detection of a defect and rejection of a particle. 5.4.4 Optical filters A wide range of coloured glass and interference optical filters are available, making it a simple matter to select suitable filters. Three basic classes of filter are used: • low pass, transmitting only below a certain wavelength • high pass, transmitting only above a certain wavelength • bandpass, transmitting only within a band of wavelengths.
Figure 5.9 illustrates the response of typical filters used in sorting machines. 5.4.5 Detectors For a number of years the photomultiplier tube was the best detector of visible radiation. It has a good signal-to-noise ratio which enables detection of low light levels, and a satisfactory blue response. However, it has the disadvantages of fragile mechanical construction, limited life, high operating voltage and poor deep red and near infra-red response. Following photomultiplier tube technology, the optical sorting industry moved on to use solid-state photodiodes as detectors. The photodiode has the advantages of comparative cheapness, mechanical robustness and an indefinite life. However, it has a poor blue response when compared with the photomultiplier. Modern optical sorting machines typically use high-speed line scan CCD (Charge Coupled Device) technology. The silicon CCD offers the advantages of high spatial resolution, good quantum efficiency, high sensitivity and broad band response (400 to 1000nm). Despite being an analogue sensor, the output of a CCD is readily convertible to a digital form. This allows exploitation of state-of-the-art, low-noise, high-speed digital processors for subsequent signal processing. Unfortunately, CCDs still suffer from relatively poor response in the blue wavelengths (400 to 500 nm). Other detector materials are often utilised in order to extend the detection range into the infra-red domain. Germanium and other materials are used for detection of foreign matter, up to approximately 1700nm. Historically, single photodiodes were used, however, Germanium linear arrays are commonplace and generally used in combination with silicon CCDs.
128
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 5.9
(a) Low-pass filter (b) high-pass filter.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
Fig. 5.9
5.5
129
continued. (c) bandpass filter.
Completing the sorting system
5.5.1 Feed A product feeding system in a sorting machine has to provide three functions: 1. 2.
3.
Metering, to ensure that the optimum number of particles per unit time is presented to the inspection system. Acceleration to a constant presentation speed. The time taken for particles to travel from the inspection point to the separation point must be constant in order for the operation of the separation device to be accurately timed. Presentation speeds can be as high as 4 m/s and the delay between detection and separation lies between 0.5 and 100 ms. Alignment, to ensure a controlled trajectory through the inspection and separation points.
In practice, the metering requirement is met by a vibrating tray feeder mounted below the output of a holding hopper. A variety of systems have been developed for providing the acceleration and alignment requirements, and the following are commonly used: • • • • •
inclined chute narrow grooved belt contra-rotating rollers flat belt single layer inclined belt single layer.
The first three methods above channel and separate the particles, allowing an all-round view of their surface. The flat belt system presents the particles in a single layer, restricting the view but enabling a much higher throughput of product to be achieved. Throughput is increased in channel feed systems by providing two or more channels. With conveyor belt feed systems the inspection components may be mounted above the belt, with the belt serving as the background, or after the end of the belt so that the
130
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
product is viewed in free fall as in channel systems. The latter arrangement also enables the product to be viewed from multiple positions. 5.5.2 Separation The usual form of separating device is the high-speed solenoid or piezoelectric valve which releases short bursts of compressed air through a nozzle. These devices exhibit the essential features of rapid action, reliability and mechanical strength; the fastest (a Sortex patented piezoelectric design) operates at a frequency of 1 kHz, firing a pulse of air for 1 to 3ms. Ejectors operate at input pressures between 200 to 550 kPa, depending on the size of the product. It is usual to arrange for the separation point to be outside the inspection area so as to minimise the effect on the optics, because the action of the air blast on a reject could cause dust particles and skin fragments to be blown around. The necessary time delay between inspection and separation is generated by the electronic circuits. Accurate timing of the delay time to coincide the ejector air blast with that of the object to be ejected as it falls in front of the ejector, relies on the product having constant velocity. In practice the variation in product velocity is about 5%. The trajectory of each particle also becomes harder to predict, the greater the distance between the viewing point and the ejection point. It can become a major design challenge to position the optical inspection and ejection system as close to the foot of the chute as possible. The operational lifetime of the ejectors must be in the region of at least a billion or more cycles. Food processing is usually a 24 hour-a-day, all-year-round operation. Operators cannot afford to regularly shut down a machine for even a few minutes to replace faulty ejectors. Under these circumstances, machine reliability and stability of operation are critical. For certain large or heavy objects a solenoid valve may be used to control a pneumatically operated flap or plunger to deflect the reject. Specialised ejectors for product pulp remove rejects by suction and are mounted above a flat belt, downstream from the inspection unit. 5.5.3 Cleaning and dust extraction The application of optical techniques in a dusty, dirty or wet industrial environment poses major difficulties for designers. Considerable effort has gone into designing sorting machines suitable for use in such conditions. To protect the optical components from dirt or moisture, they are separated and sealed from the inspection point through which product passes by a glass window. The position of this window in the optical path should be such that any small particles, which may settle on the surface, are out of focus and therefore cause the minimum of disturbance to the optical signal. Nevertheless, it is essential that this window is kept as clear as possible and a number of facilities to achieve this may be provided on the machine. Firstly, the product being fed to the machine should be as dry and dust free as possible. However, the action of storing it in a hopper and feeding it on a vibrating tray may well create some dust and therefore a dust extraction nozzle may be fitted at the end of the vibrating tray. In the case of a chute feed, the top of the chute may be perforated so that air can be passed through the product stream to remove dust particles. Secondly, the actual window can be cleaned by means of compressed air jets which (a) provide a continuous curtain of air to prevent particles settling on the surface and/or (b) a periodic high-pressure blast which removes any particles that have managed to reach the window.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
131
Thirdly, a pneumatically actuated blade or brush may periodically wipe the window. In more advanced machines this may be combined with an air blowdown facility. Finally, any dirt created by the action of the ejector blast on the particles, may be drawn away from the window area by the provision of a dust extraction nozzle below the optical box. Similar precautions may be taken where a wet product is to be sorted, with water jets and wiper blades being fitted to the optical window. 5.5.4 Electronic systems The electronic systems in sorting machines have progressed from the simple analogue circuits of the early machines to the sophisticated digital microprocessor based circuits found in the present generation of machines. The digital microprocessor machine exhibits two important advantages over its predecessors in that it is very much easier to set up and that it will maintain a consistent level of performance without the need for periodic operator intervention. Digital electronics are not subject to performance drift as a consequence of thermal or environmental change, in the same way that analogue electronics are affected. The signal-to-noise level is also greatly improved by using digital electronics, along with ease of subsequent data processing and transportation. Most of the setting up of the sorting parameters can be done by the machine itself including in some cases the ability of the machine to ‘learn’ the differences between good and bad product. However, the operator is always given the opportunity to fine-tune the final result. If required the machine will track the average colour of the product so that, even though the product colour may change with time, the machine will continue to remove only the predefined abnormal particles. Alternatively the machine may be provided with a calibration plate which is periodically placed in the optical view so that the machine is able to correct for any measurement drift that has occurred. These facilities result in a much more stable performance when compared with that of machines that require periodic human attention. Once a machine has been set up for a particular product then all the settings can be stored in memory. This can be repeated for a number of different products and then, at a later time, the machine can be made ready to sort any of these products simply by recalling the appropriate settings from the memory. As the machine has a memory capability this can be utilised to provide useful information, such as the number of rejects that have occurred in a certain time, to the operator and where appropriate to the plant monitoring computer. Information can also be provided to assist with preventative maintenance. As a consequence of the greatly increased signal processing available, the sorting decision can be based on other parameters as well as reflectivity. For example, the minimum size of the discoloration necessary for a particle to be classed as defect can be defined. As well as providing signals to external monitoring devices, the machines can be controlled via a computer link from a remote position. User interfaces Microprocessor control and visual display devices have greatly simplified the procedure for setting up and operating sorting machines, as well as enabling more comprehensive fault information to be displayed to the user. A typical machine will have either a keypad and a display unit, or more commonly a touch-screen user interface (Fig. 5.10) which will enable the operator to set up and control the machine by means of a series of menus.
132
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 5.10
Niagara touch screen user interface.
Nowadays, it is becoming common practice for the user interface to employ touch-screen technology. In addition the display unit will provide the operator with information regarding the settings of the machine while it is sorting, together with details of any faults that may occur. Mapping techniques The conventional bichromatic sorting machine using two wavelength bands, say green and red, made a decision based on the ratio of the two signals as well as the intensity of the individual signals. The situation can be represented by a two-dimensional map as shown in Fig. 5.11(a). Clearly, the defined accept region is triangular in shape whilst the actual region is not and therefore it is impossible to set the machine without some accept or reject product being on the wrong side of the lines. However, it is also possible to define the boundary between accept and reject to match the true shape of the actual product colour distribution as shown in Fig. 5.11(b). This method enables the microprocessor machine to remove a far greater range of defects, more accurately, without the penalty of removing a large amount of accept product. Obviously, these techniques can be extended into three dimensions for trichromatic colour sorting.
5.6
Future trends: computer vision systems
Computer vision systems are being used increasingly in general manufacturing, but the demands of the food industry are generally much greater. At present, there is only a limited range of computer vision equipment available for use in the food industry. However, in the future this is likely to change. Two factors are limiting the rate at which computer vision systems are being introduced to the food industry: 1.
The data-processing rates required in a high-speed food sorting machine are very much higher than those in a similar inspection machine for manufactured items.
Sorting by colour in the food industry
Fig. 5.11
2.
133
(a) Conventional map (b) microprocessor map.
The development of improved material handling and separation systems is not keeping pace with the dramatic advances being made in computer technology.
The computerised sorting system of the future may comprise a TV camera and a computer with a large capacity for information storage. Some form of interface would connect the computer to a series of robot graders and sorters. Items to be inspected and sorted would pass along a belt where they would be viewed by the camera. The computer would identify the individual items and could assess them according to several criteria, including colour, shape and size. Devices would then be actuated to separate the items into size and quality grades.
134
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
A computer vision system potentially offers many benefits over a conventional colour sorter. The ability to sort food on the basis of several different criteria would be a primary advantage. Flexibility is another distinct advantage of such a system. A machine, which is busy sorting potatoes, could easily be reprogrammed to examine oranges, or indeed anything else that could pass along the conveyor. Different products could be accommodated by simple software changes instead of major adaptations to hardware. However, for the immediate future, the most likely application of advances in computer technology is the improvement in performance of the present generation of sorting machines.
5.7
Using a colour sorter
There is a common misconception that a colour sorter can remove all defects from a given batch of product. In practice this is impossible. A colour sorter will reduce the concentration of defective product, but it can never be 100 per cent effective. All colour sorters are bound to remove some acceptable product and fail to remove some of the defective product. There are a number of possible causes for this limitation. In some cases, the physical size or the colour difference of the individual defect may be too small for the machine to be able to see. The defective item will then be allowed to pass through the machine as if it were unblemished. In other cases, the machine may detect a defect Table 5.1
Typical machine performance figures
Product
Whole green beans
Machine
Niagara – Trichromatic colour sorter, 1m wide belt Green coffee 90003Bi – 48 channel, gravity chute bichromatic sorter Parboiled rice 90004 mono – 128 channel, 4 gravity chute, monochromatic sorting machine Frozen peas Niagara – Trichromatic colour sorter, 1m wide belt Mixed vegetables Niagara – Trichromatic colour sorter, 1m wide belt Frozen Niagara – lingonberries Trichromatic colour sorter, 1m wide belt
Purpose
Throughput (tonnes/hour) per machine
Typical efficiency (removal of defects)
Remove attached 8 stems and blemish
Shape 80% Colour 60–70%
Remove defective 3 to 6 beans and foreign material
99.5% (input contamination 6%)
Remove spotted, 5 to 10 discoloured rice and foreign material (stones, glass, paddy, etc.) Remove foreign 10 to 16 material, pea pod, sticks, etc. by colour and shape. Remove foreign 6 material
Black 90% Brown 90% Rojo’s 80% Yellow 70% Bites 60% Foreign material 98% Blemish 70–80%
Remove green, white, pink and blue berries
4
80–90%
80–90%
Sorting by colour in the food industry
135
and remove the item, only for it to bounce back into the accept stream after it has been ejected. Machines can be adjusted to optimise their performance. However, changing a given parameter may have some disadvantages in addition to the intended benefits. There is normally a compromise between achieving a high sorting efficiency and the amount of good material that is rejected. Sensitivity is one of the principal parameters that the operator can change. Increasing the sensitivity will result in the machine rejecting more defective material but a great proportion of good product will also be rejected as the sensitivity threshold approaches the average product colour. There are limits to throughput within which a colour sorter should work. If the product flow is increased above the upper limit, or decreased below the lower limit, optimum performance cannot be obtained. Within these limits a general rule can be applied. Increasing the flow of product through the machine will result in more good product being lost. The colour sorter will normally achieve its best performance if the product to be sorted has been properly cleaned and size-graded prior to sorting. Size-grading product prior to sorting will allow a more precise setting of the ejection system and will allow better accept quality without increasing the amount of good product rejected. Proper cleaning of the product prior to sorting will reduce the build up of dust on optical surfaces and should improve performance between periodic cleaning of the machine. Table 5.1 illustrates some typical performance figures for a variety of products sorted on different machines. The throughputs are quoted in ranges, since the throughput increases as the level of input contamination decreases.
5.8
Further reading
(1981) ‘Sorting frozen commodities electronically’, Quick Frozen Foods International, 167. ANON. (1982) ‘It grades Japanese white rice at 800 million grains an hour’, Food Processing Industry, 18. ANON. (1987) ‘Electronic sorting reduces labour costs’, Food Technology in New Zealand, 47. BEE, S. C., ‘Physics sorts the wheat from the chaff’, Physics World, June 2000, pp. 24-26, vol. 13, No. 6. ASASENT D., TALUKDER A. and LEE H. W., ‘X-ray Agricultural product inspection: segmentation and classification’, September 1997, SPIE Vol. 3205, pp. 46–55. DOWNING, D. L., ‘A complete course in canning and related processes’, 13th edition, CTI Publications Inc., 1996. GAFFNEY, J. J. (1976) Quality Detection in Foods, American Society of Agricultural Engineers, St Joseph, Michigan. ‘Good Processing Practice Using Colour Sorting’, Food Technology Europe, October 1997 pp. 54–58. JANSON- SMITH, D. (1988) ‘Minder machines for flawless food’, New Scientist, 120, 19. KUBIAK A. and KUTZBACH H. D., ‘The application of an artificial intelligence system in the automatic recognition of wheat by the nonlinear approximation technique’, 12th International Congress of Chemical and Process Engineering CHISA, Praha, Czech Republic, 25–30th August, 1996. P9.55 [490]. KUBIAK A. and OJCZYK T., ‘The automatic recognition of different varieties of wheat grain with the application of the non-linear approximation method’, 12th International ANON.
136
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Congress of Chemical and Process Engineering CHISA, Praha, Czech Republic, 25– 30th August, 1996. P9.56 [489]. MAUGHAN, W. S. (1974), ‘Automatic Optical Sorting Machines’, Electro-Optical Equipment in Mechanical Handling and Sorting, 27, Institute of Mechanical Engineers, London. MCCLURE, W. F. (1975) ‘Design of a high speed fibre optic blueberry sorter’, Transactions of the ASAE, 487, USA. MOHSENIN, N. N. (1984) ‘Electromagnetic Radiation Properties of Foods and Agricultural Products’, 201, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, New York. NAGATA, M., CAO, Q. X., ‘Study on grade judgement of fruit vegetables using machine vision’, JARQ-Japan Agricultural Research Quarterly, October 1998, 32: (4) pp. 257–265. NAKAMURA O., KOBAYASHI M., KAWATA S., ‘Nondestructive inspection of Phaseolus coccineus L. soya beans by use of near-infrared lasers’, Applied Optics, April 1999, vol. 38, No. 12, pp. 2724–2727. PEARSON T. C. SCHATZ, I. and THOMAS F. ‘Superior sorter selects stain free nuts’, Agricultural Research, January 1997, p. 18. SORENSEN J., ‘Color-grain scanner yields higher-value products’, Electronics and Computer Technology, September 1990, pp. 41–42. STANLEY, et al. (1987) ‘Fiber optic colour grading of whole peeled tomatoes’, Can. Inst. Food Sci. Technology, 20, No 1, 38. SWIENTIK, R. J. (1987)‘ Machine Vision Systems’, Food Processing, 68. TELFORD, A. P. ‘Control of aflotoxins in peanuts by segregation and sorting’, Food Technology in Australia*, May 1982, 34, pp. 214–215. (*in September 1988, this journal became Food Australia). WEN, Z. Q., TAO, Y., ‘Brightness-invariant image segmentation for on-line fruit defect detection’, Optical Engineering, November 1998, 37: (11) pp. 2948–2952. WOLFE R. R. and SANDLER W. E., ‘An algorithm for stem detection using digital image analysis’, Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers (ASAE), 1985, pp. 641–644. Internet Sortex homepage: www.sortex.com
6 Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology I. B. Benson and J. W. F. Millard, NDC Infrared Engineering, Maldon
6.1 Introduction Near infra-red (NIR) measurement technology offers an amazingly diverse capability for the analysis of many different constituents or properties of food products. Moisture, fat, protein and sugar content are perhaps the most well known applications in products such as grain, flour, cereals, dairy products, snacks and coffee but NIR has also found application for the measurement of chocolate thickness on refiner rollers, the thickness of sausage casings, the alcohol content of beverages, the maturity of peas and even the quality of fruit juices. The technique can also provide food technologists with information regarding the thickness of critical barrier layers in multi-layer packaging films, protective coatings applied to plastic, paper or metal food packaging materials which all can impact on food storage properties if not controlled. The emphasis today, and for the future, is towards on-line measurement and control of food manufacturing processes and NIR lends itself extremely well to this. It is fast, continuous, non-destructive and can be applied relatively simply in many industrial processes. However, for it to be of value in an increasingly automated world the control loop needs to be closed and the emphasis nowadays has to be on robust, easy to apply measurement solutions, which can be depended upon. Achieving these goals is the major preoccupation of both instrument suppliers and users. To date the food processing industry has generally been slow, with few exceptions, on the uptake of on-line NIR measurement in terms of closed-loop process control. Many factors have contributed to this such as confidence in the reliability of the technique, obtaining access to the product to allow a reliable measurement (e.g. for products transported in pneumatic or gravity fed ducts), the fact that many processes are batch operations where the product is batch analysed prior to processing and the willingness or ability to invest in automation. This situation is changing as with the demand for ever more efficient manufacturing of the highest quality, consistent product becomes the norm along with legislative demands for food product constituents to be traceable. This in turn has necessitated instrument manufacturers developing product solutions that can be depended upon and has required serious effort in the re-education of potential users that the technique indeed has a place in modern industry.
138
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
NIR measurement is a well-established analytical technique, and many examples of its applications can be found in the literature going back as far as the 1950s and before. Specifically, early laboratory applications of NIR concentrated upon quantitative and qualitative studies of liquids and solvent mixtures, and such applications are cited in a review by Kaye in 1954. From the same era McCallum (1961) and Miller et al. (1949) provide extensive general coverage of NIR spectroscopy, while Willis (1979) reviews industrial analytical applications of the technique. The most significant and active area of development over the last twenty years has been the application of NIR for the compositional analysis of solids, particularly cereals and foodstuffs where the product is analysed by a reflectance type measurement. The chemical complexities of most foodstuffs or natural products, however, have necessitated the accompanying development of a variety of statistical and mathematical signal-processing methods. These techniques have enabled useful measurements to be obtained from spectral reflectance data, which characteristically show many overlapping, broad absorption features of seemingly low information content. The uses of NIR within the food and cereals industries are far too numerous to be comprehensively listed, and therefore a selection of references to pertinent reviews and papers is given (Star et al. 1981; Norris and Hart 1965; Osborne and Fearn 1986; Norris and Williams 1987; Hunt et al. 1977; Biggs 1979). These generally refer to laboratorybased analysis, although on-line analysis is discussed in other reports (Edgar and Hindle 1971; Bruton 1970; Benson 1989). NIR measurement has broadly evolved on two fronts, these being laboratory and online application of the technique. This division has resulted from the very different demands that the two approaches place upon the instrument design and specification. Laboratory measurement has the benefit of offering very controlled measurement conditions. The product can be appropriately prepared; for example it can be ground to a specific particle size and consistently presented to the instrument, usually in some form of windowed cell. Also an acceptable time for each measurement may be 30 seconds or more, which is obviously faster than the laboratory wet chemical equivalent, but slow in terms of a continuous on-line analysis. The on-line NIR gauge must operate very much more quickly, making many measurements each second. For an on-line measurement, product presentation can rarely be controlled. The distance of the product from the gauge will almost certainly fluctuate, and the quantity of product passing the point of measurement may vary. The form of the product is rarely uniform; there may be variations in the appearance or particle size of powders and fibrous materials. The ambient conditions are also rarely controlled with variations in product or ambient temperature, humidity and lighting levels being commonplace. The on-line gauge must therefore be designed to ignore such variations and be sufficiently robust to survive the rigours of the factory environment. The application requirements for off-line and on-line measurement have also widely differed over the years. The most active areas of on-line analysis have been concerned with measurements where, if the component concentration changes, a corrective action can be taken in the process. The most obvious example is moisture, where dryers or conditioners can be readily controlled. Off-line analysis, on the other hand, has tended to concentrate upon providing a rapid replacement for some of the time consuming, wet chemical analyses such as those for protein, fat or carbohydrates. The authors’ expertise and interest have been strongly biased towards on-line measurement and the following text will therefore concentrate on this area. However, offline measurement possibilities will be discussed and a novel approach to the concept of
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
139
NIR laboratory analysis, using many of the key features derived from an on-line philosophy, will be described. While moisture measurement remains a dominant on-line requirement, food industry needs are developing and the possibility of controlling, in real time, parameters other than moisture is becoming a requirement. The fat content of meat, protein levels in flour or the oil content of snacks are such examples. Additionally, quality traceabilty issues place demands upon manufacturers to show that the other product constituents have been measured and quantified. On-line instrumentation has undergone significant development and improvement and is now capable of offering far more than the early analysers. Many of the conventional laboratory-based NIR analyses can be performed online at least as well as in the laboratory. Theory and instrumentation are discussed, often illustrated with details for moisture measurement, but equally applicable to other component analysis. Emphasis has been placed upon describing the characteristics and limitations of the NIR technique, and providing the reader with many actual examples of its application in the food industry for both moisture and non-moisture applications.
6.2
Principles of measurement
6.2.1 Theory behind NIR measurement Infra-red light is part of the broad spectrum of energy known as electromagnetic radiation. Figure 6.1 shows the relative wavelengths and energies in the electromagnetic spectrum that are used in spectroscopy. While X-rays are of extremely high energy, capable of promoting inner electron transitions in high atomic number elements, the infra-red region is of relatively low energy and upon interaction with molecules, causes inter-atomic vibrations. Near infra-red spectroscopy is concerned with a specific region of the infra-red, namely the 1–2.5 micrometres (m) (10,000 to 4,000 cm 1) range, adjacent to the red end of the visible spectrum. The frequency of this wave oscillation in the infra-red region is about 1013 1014 Hz, which is of the same order as the natural mechanical vibrational frequencies of many
Fig. 6.1 Electromagnetic spectrum.
140
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
chemical groups. (The wavelength (m) of electromagnetic radiation is related to the frequency v (Hz) by c v, where c 3 108 m s 1 is the velocity of light.) The water molecule is one of the best known examples of an NIR absorber and exhibits several distinct vibrational modes which relate to infra-red absorption at well-defined wavelengths or frequencies. The frequency of oscillation of any mode is dependent upon the atomic masses and bond strengths of the OH group. Provided that the vibration in question results in a change in dipole moment at its extremes of movement, NIR radiation at the appropriate frequency will be absorbed by the group, causing it to vibrate at this same frequency. Energy is thus taken from the radiation field and is dissipated as heat by frictional or collision damping. The mechanism described is known as infra-red absorption and is covered comprehensively in other texts (Banwell 1983; Herzberg 1945). These fundamental or natural vibrations are the basis of the familiar mid-infra-red spectroscopy commonly used by chemists in qualitative analysis. The mid-infra-red is, however, generally unsuitable for on-line compositional analysis for a number of reasons. In particular, the extremely low reflectivity of most solids above 2.5 m results in unusable signal-to-noise levels for meaningful interpretation. While Fourier transform infra-red (FTIR) analysis in the mid-IR has been demonstrated to be a useful technique, this method does not lend itself to on-line analysis (Benson et al. 1988). Secondly, the absorption bands in the mid-IR are extremely intense and often display considerable fine structure, both being features that do not lend themselves to quantitative analysis. The NIR spectral region, on the other hand, deals with absorptions, which are a result of vibrations at harmonic or combination frequencies of the fundamental absorptions. The NIR region is therefore often referred to as the overtone region. The types of absorption that dominate the NIR are hydrogenic absorptions such as OH, NH and CH vibrations. These types of absorption are displayed by moisture and virtually all other major constituents of foodstuffs. Since these different molecular groups are made up of atoms of different masses and bond strengths, each one exhibits a unique set of absorptions at specific vibrational frequencies or wavelengths. This absorption specificity of the technique is one of the most important features in increasing the scope of its application in the food industry, allowing the analysis of various product constituents independently and simultaneously. The amount of infra-red absorption due to a particular absorber relates in a welldefined way to the quantity of absorber present. The change in absorption with an increase in moisture within a material is illustrated in Fig. 6.2, which shows diffuse reflectance spectra for milk powder at two different moisture levels. Such spectra for solid food products are obtained using a diffuse reflectance NIR scanning spectrophotometer. The spectral information shown in Fig. 6.2 is a plot of percentage reflectance as a function of wavelength. Water shows three principal absorptions in the near infra-red at 1.45, 1.94 and 2.95 m. The most commonly used water absorption band at 1.94 m is evident in Fig. 6.2, and as the moisture content increases there is a corresponding deepening of the band, that is a reduction in reflectivity consistent with increased infra-red absorption. The absorption of infra-red energy by solids approximates to the Beer-Lambert exponential law for transmission, of the form It I0 exp
kx where x is the path length of the radiation, k is the absorption coefficient, I0 is the incident infra-red energy and It is the transmitted infra-red energy. This can be written as
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.2
141
Milk powder NIR reflectance spectra at two different moisture contents.
log
Io =It kx
1
Therefore there is a simple linear relationship between the amount of absorber and the logarithm of the ratio of incident and transmitted energies. Making use of this principle requires a design of instrumentation capable of accurately measuring absorption changes at a number of wavelengths in the NIR corresponding to the absorber to be measured. Various techniques have been devised over the years to achieve this in both hardware design and the subsequent mathematical evaluation of the signal as discussed in Section 6.3. For reflectance measurements, while potentially complicated by light-scattering effects, a similar logarithmic relationship can be applied successfully in many instances. With some applications where light scattering plays a significant role, it will be shown that a more sophisticated approach is necessary to compensate for the effects that changes in the scattering characteristics of a product can have upon a measurement. The reflectance spectra of milk powder in Fig. 6.2, in addition to the absorption bands due to water at 1.45 and 1.94 m, show the presence of many other overlapping absorption bands. These are due to the various OH, NH and CH stretches associated with the lactose, casein and fats present in typical milk powders. Although these can complicate a measurement of water content, requiring correction for the effects that their variation may have on the moisture measurement, they also provide an opportunity to measure these other constituents in addition to moisture. 6.2.2 Characteristics of NIR technology The measurement range of the NIR is well suited to the needs of food processing since a wide range of different constituents may need to be measured, such as moisture, fat, sugar caffeine, oil and protein. In the NIR the most important and prominent absorptions are due to the OH, NH and CH groups. These absorption features are very specific to the constituent in question as discussed above and so the technique readily lends itself to quite detailed discrimination of the constituent parts of a foodstuff. In addition the
142
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
technique has one further important strength, that of a choice of absorption sensitivities for a given constituent. Each of the absorbing groups characteristically exhibits three main absorption bands in the NIR. For water, these absorptions occur at 1.45, 1.94 and 2.95 m as is shown in Fig. 6.3, which is a transmission spectrum of pure water. The relative intensities for the three bands are 1:3:90 respectively. Fats or oils show corresponding absorptions at 1.7, 2.3 and 3.4 m with a similar range of relative intensities to water. To generate the spectrum of water in Fig. 6.3 a cell path length of 150 m was used. Clearly with this quantity of water the absorption at 2.95 m is of no use in practice because it exhibits total absorption, whereas both absorption bands at the shorter wavelengths would provide usable changes if the cell path length was changed. This means that a wide range of moistures can be measured in the NIR by selecting the appropriate absorption band, which shows the greatest level of change at the product moisture level. The NIR effectively provides a huge range of absorption sensitivities that can be selected to meet the application requirement. For example, with products at extremely low moistures, perhaps less than 0.5 per cent moisture, use might be made of the highly sensitive 2.95 m absorption band. On the other hand for a ‘wet’ material of around 80 per cent moisture, e.g. sugar beet pulp, the weak 1.45 m absorption would be more appropriate, to provide an adequate absorption change as a function of water content at these high moisture levels. This is a real strength of the technique, enabling an instrument to be tailored for the application. As stated above, the same characteristic holds true for CH or NH absorptions of materials such as fats or proteins; they each exhibit at least three regions of absorption in the NIR of different intensities and, importantly, at wavelengths different from the OH absorptions of water. The choice of the absorption band to use for a particular application depends upon many considerations. The degree of penetration into the product and the way in which it is scattered will affect the ‘path length’ of the radiation in the material and hence the amount of absorption. While the classical Beer-Lambert absorption law ignores scatter characteristics, in fact many food products where measurement is required are solids and the scatter characteristics become equally or more important. The scatter/absorption
Fig. 6.3
Near infra-red transmission spectrum of water.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
143
models proposed by Kubelka and Munk (1931) show that the effective Beer Lambert equivalent absorption coefficient for an absorber in a solid matrix is better described as per the following equation: p Keff 2Kact S Where: Keff the effective absorption coefficient, Kact the water absorption coefficient (in the case of moisture) and S the scatter coefficient for the product. The choice is not always obvious. For example granulated sugar moisture, which is required to be dried below 0.1% moisture, has to be measured at 1.94m because there is a tremendous level of absorption in a reflectance measurement due to the high penetration and scatter characteristics of the product. Similarly, breakfast cereals around 2–3% moisture require the use of the weak, 1.45m band because the moisture absorption characteristic is so intense. For the determination of water contents between the levels discussed above, it is usually a matter of selecting the band that shows the greatest absorption change with a given change in moisture content. The absorption of NIR energy follows an exponential characteristic and therefore the maximum rate of change of absorption occurs at reflectance levels of around 60 per cent. This means that there is a point for a given moisture level above which greater sensitivity would be obtained by using a weaker absorption band. For food applications, the most commonly used water absorption is the 1.94 m band. Apart from the ‘anomalous’ examples cited above, this band can generally be used for moisture levels between 1 and 30 per cent. These subtleties require the skills of applications engineering specialists correctly to configure an on-line instrument so that a user gets a suitable solution for the application in question. It is important, as discussed in Section 6.6, that such capabilities are looked for when selecting a potential supplier of on-line NIR instrumentation. 6.2.3 Technologies for implementing NIR measurement There have been a variety of concepts and technologies tried over the years for implementing NIR technology and this probably remains one of the interesting areas for development in instrument hardware. The theme of this chapter is very much on-line measurement and to date the authors firmly believe that the fixed filter based technology as discussed in the next section, still leads the field in meeting the requirements for most applications, especially in light of some of the recent advances in instrument design and detector technology. Since fixed filter technology receives detailed coverage in the next section the following provides an overview of interesting and/or promising, alternative technology. The use of LEDs for generating the necessary infra-red wavelengths is of great interest because this approach would eliminate the issues of source lamp life. For example, a solid state device designed by McFarlane employed infra-red light-emitting diodes (IREDs) to generate the relevant NIR wavelengths for the measurement. These IREDs, however, emit a broad band of NIR energy and therefore fixed interference filters are still necessary to produce narrow bands of infra-red light. The physical displacement between the devices (one for each wavelength) also makes even illumination of the sample under analysis optically difficult. A more serious drawback for IREDs is that their spectral outputs change with temperature, which clearly, without sophisticated compensation, would have dire effects upon calibration stability. The wavelength range of operation of IREDs is perhaps the most severe limitation at the moment, since they are only
144
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
economically available up to the 1.45 m water absorption, thus missing the principal 1.94 m band. In their favour, IREDs can be rapidly switched, thus providing a highspeed measurement in a modulated form without any moving parts but the very poor signal-to-noise ratio all but eliminates this benefit. The German Rembe GmbH company offers an LED-based device for the measurement of minerals and building products. However, in its current form it requires to be operated at very long response times with sophisticated signal processing to interpret the signals. For many food applications this speed of response issue and implied lack of precision would be a problem. Solid-state laser diodes offer another potentially interesting means of wavelength selection with a narrower band of emission of NIR energy. However, they are still affected by some of the limitations described above. Another concept of potentially great interest is the use of acousto-optical tunable filters (AOTFs) to generate the relevant NIR wavelengths. The technique relies upon polarised light being diffracted by optically active materials under the influence of high-frequency acoustic waves. The radiation transmitted through such a material is preferentially polarised at a certain wavelength dependent upon the acoustic frequency. Thus, by using a polariser on the outgoing light beam, it is possible to select any number of wavelengths very quickly and without any moving parts. The technology is currently expensive and the concept is physically complex to implement, especially on line. There are also issues about the lifetime of the crystal used and the effects of vibration. Finally, containment of the high-energy RF emissions used in the generation of the acoustic wave present a challenge in meeting the containment requirements of the CE directives on EMC. However, systems are commercially available particularly for laboratory use. Some of these have been adapted for on-line use where product is essentially presented to an adaption of a laboratory device (e.g. Brimrose). No doubt with time this technology will become more practical and cost-acceptable in its implementation. Various forms of spectrometer-based products are available which operate by generating full spectrum data. These may be based upon grating systems or Fourier transform technology. The price of such technology has been radically reduced over the years but the concept still has significant shortcomings in terms of signal-to-noise performance and therefore measurement observation times need to be lengthy (many seconds) to achieve useful results. The whole subject of whether full spectrum analysis offers benefits over fixed filter systems is outside of the scope of this discussion but is covered in detail elsewhere (Hindle and Smith 1996). It is the contention of the authors that many so-called full spectrum analytical techniques actually use various data reduction techniques such as partial least squares (PLS), principal components analysis (PCA) or neural networks resulting in only partial use of the spectral information relevant to the product and constituents in question. The fixed filter approach as discussed in Section 6.3 is highly practical because in most on-line measurement situations the user knows what measurement is required and therefore the application is well defined and the appropriate wavelengths for the measurement are few and easily accommodated by such a device. To date, the fixed filter technology provides the best signal-to-noise ratio solution, important when looking at providing a dynamic measurement, with a need to reveal instantaneously short- and longterm information about the inherent variation in a process.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
6.3
145
Instrumentation
6.3.1 On-line NIR Instrumentation For an on-line NIR measurement to be acceptable in most industrial processes, severe constraints are imposed on the instrument design. For example, while most off-line analysers require the product to be carefully presented, pressed against a glass cell window, this is not practical in an on-line situation where a non-contacting system is much more appropriate. An on-line gauge must also be able to tolerate variations in operating conditions. Ambient temperature, relative humidity and the level of factory lighting are all factors that will change with time, yet they should not influence a measurement. Additionally, while certain processes may be impeccably clean and dust free, this is not usually the case; therefore instrument design must take into account the need to be able to operate in a mixture of dusty, damp, steamy and oily conditions! Figure 6.4 shows a schematic drawing of the MM710 back scatter on-line NIR Gauge (NDC Infrared Engineering Ltd), which is designed for use in a diversity of applications in food constituent measurement. A quartz halogen lamp provides a broad spectrum of visible and infra-red light. The source is underrun to prolong its life, and is optically prealigned in a lamp holder to ensure maximum energy throughput. The light from the lamp is collected by an off-axis mirror which ensures maximum energy throughput. The focused light passes through a rotating filter wheel, which contains optical interference filters (McCloud 1986). The wheel also contains visible light-transmitting filters to allow the light beam patch of the instrument to be seen. The interference filters are designed to transmit infra-red energy at the wavelengths chosen for the measurement. Typically, filters with bandwidths of between 1 and 5 per cent of the centre wavelength may be used. The number of wavelengths needed for a measurement is
Fig. 6.4
MM710 optical sensing head schematic (NDC Infrared Engineering Ltd).
146
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
dependent upon the application, as will be discussed later. These ‘colour’ filters take the form of thin glass disks, about 10mm square, upon which multi-layer dielectric coatings have been vacuum deposited. The major benefits of using these devices for wavelength isolation are their compactness and efficiency with respect to energy throughput at the chosen wavelength. They are also robust elements and offer extremely good long-term stability, both mechanically and in terms of their transmission, centre wavelength and bandwidth characteristics, all of which are important for long-term instrument stability. The rotation rate of the filter wheel depends upon instrument design but in the case of the new generation gauge such as the MM710, is up to 8000 rpm providing for an extremely fast measurement. This high-speed performance is very important for number of reasons. In general a faster measurement is desirable because by high-speed sampling of the product the accuracy achievable is enhanced p through making more measurements in a given time. Accuracy will be improved a n factor sopif a product is sampled say 10 times more than another instrument there will be a potential 10 fold (i.e., 3 times) improvement in accuracy and reduction therefore in measurement noise. This means that the faster gauge is able to provide far more detailed information about a process and its variation and is not likely to be the limiting factor in the ability to control a process or monitor it using normal SPC procedures. In applications where the product flow is discontinuous, such as biscuits, the high-speed nature of the gauge in conjunction with an optical gating system allows analysis of the individual pieces as they pass under the gauge. These characteristics should be considered when choosing an on-line gauging system. Immediately prior to the filtered light leaving the gauge, the secondary lead sulphide detector, located behind the beam splitter, samples a small percentage. The secondary detector monitors the optical characteristics of the instrument, in particular those of the lamp and interference filters. The lamp emission decreases with time while interference filters show changes in transmission with temperature variation. Both changes will be detected by the secondary detector, thus providing for subsequent correction. The importance of this concept becomes clearer shortly. The majority of the light passes from the gauge and lands on the product to be analysed. Some of the radiation is absorbed by the product while the remainder is scattered. The multi-faceted, concave collecting mirror in the gauge is arranged so as to collect a portion of the back scattered light and to focus it onto the primary lead sulphide detector. The lead sulphide photoconductive device is ideal for NIR applications since its detectivity peaks at wavelengths of about 2 m at room temperature, and it is a fast responsive element offering good signal-to-noise performance. Advances in detector technology, patented by the authors’ company, allow the device to be run at incredibly high speeds offering the benefits of greater product sampling and the chance to measure discontinuous product more meaningfully as discussed above. Because the primary and secondary detectors are matched in sensitivity and kept at the same temperature, when the two sets of detector signals are ratioed an instrument output will be obtained that is self-compensated for the effects of temperature on the sensing head optical components and for the ageing (colour temperature change with time) of the lamp. For example, a drop in lamp emission at one of the measuring wavelengths would be detected by both primary and secondary detectors and seen as the same percentage change in signal level, cancelled by ratioing the detector outputs. The ability to design an instrument that is unaffected by temperature variation is vital because in practical situations temperature changes occur with daytime and seasons. To date the sensor design described above has been the most successful all-round approach for meeting the requirements of an on-line NIR process analyser. However,
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
147
other techniques have been developed, as discussed in Section 6.2, which, if advances in technology permit, are likely to make an impact on basic gauge design. Consideration of equation (1) suggests that, irrespective of the optical system, to make use of NIR absorption requires a knowledge of the incident and reflected energies at the measuring wavelength. In practice it is not possible to measure how much energy falls on to the measured sample, that is the incident radiation. Therefore for on-line measurement, in the simplest case, this is approximated by making a two-wavelength measurement. Figure 6.5 shows a schematic diagram of the technique and takes moisture as an example. One wavelength would be centred on the 1.94 m absorption band of moisture. The other would be chosen from a part of the spectrum where there is little or no absorption due to moisture; commonly, a wavelength close to 1.80 m is chosen as this reference. The ratio of the reflected signals at the two wavelengths provides a measure of the peak height of the absorption. The logarithm of the ratio will relate linearly to moisture content as follows: logsig ref =abs / H2 O
2
where sig (ref) is the signal at the reference wavelength, sig (abs) is the signal at the absorption wavelength and [H2O] is the moisture content. Clearly, as moisture content increases the absorption increases, there is a corresponding reduction in sig (abs), and thus the overall term increases. The infra-red detector, which is a photoconductive device, generates signals that are proportional to the reflected intensities at each wavelength in an alternating current (a.c.)
Fig. 6.5 Schematic of a two-length measurement with reference to the product NIR spectrum.
148
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
form. In the MM710 gauge, which is an intelligent sensor, these signals are processed and a calibrated output is provided direct from the gauge itself. The MM710 is pre-calibrated for the application under consideration thus greatly reducing the effort required by users to get the device commissioned and operational. The final gauge output of a simple twowavelength measurement would be of the form Output a b log sig ref =abs where a is the offset or zero adjustment and b is the gain or span adjustment. The measurement ratio calculation fulfils another fundamental requirement for on-line measurement. Many factors such as product-to-sensor distance (pass height variation) or dust build-up on external optical surfaces cannot be controlled. Changes in such factors would affect the size of the detected signals. However, both reference and absorption signals will be affected equally, and therefore the integrity of the ratio is maintained and the measurement is unaffected. The description above concentrates on a simple two-wavelength measurement. This approach was used in the early days of NIR gauging but it quickly became apparent that to achieve greater calibration robustness or to measure more than one component, more infra-red wavelengths were necessary and even the format of the algorithm needed to be more sophisticated. This will be discussed in the next section with application examples. Earlier on-line instrumentation was based upon analogue electronic design with limited mathematical processing facilities. However, modern instruments such as the MM710, based upon microprocessor electronics and with greater sophistication in optical design allow far greater capability and the opportunity to develop calibrations based upon more sophisticated algorithm models. The information generated by the on-line infra-red gauge nowadays needs to be output in a format that can be used by modern factory control systems. In addition to the traditional analogue outputs (e.g. 4–20 mA current loop proportional to the parameter being measured) connectivity to a process computer is now provided by any of the commonly used databus protocols such as ProfiBus, DeviceNet, ModBus or Ethernet TCPIP. This connectivity allows the user to use the gauge to perform some form of automatic feedback control to a dryer or a moisture conditioning process via the factory computer DCS system. The main thrust in instrument design by the authors’ company is towards simplifying the implementation of a measurement system and ensuring that it is easy to use. Modern manufacturing facilities do not have the time or resources to apply to developing measurements and calibrating a gauge. For this reason the MM710 gauge is provided precalibrated for the application. In this way the gauge can be used virtually straight from the box without lengthy laboratory testing and configuration – a major time saver. Generally for proven applications, all that will be required is a simple offset correction to the laboratory reference method favoured by the user. This aspect is discussed in greater detail in Section 6.6. The instrument described above is designed for the measurement of powders, flaky or fibrous solids yet NIR measurement technology can be applied to liquids measurement. In this case a transmission gauge is more suitable. Figure 6.6 shows a fibre optic based analyser known as Liquidata which has been used in applications in the beverage industry for the measurement of alcohol and original gravity in beers, lagers and ciders. In this instrument the generation of NIR light and the appropriate measurement wavelengths still makes use of the interference filter concept described above but the light is passed
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.6
149
Schematic of a liquid analyser (Liquidata NDC Infrared Engineering Ltd).
through fibre optics to a transmission cell which forms part a probe which is inserted into a pipeline. There are severe design requirements for this type of device in the food industry, namely the need for its tolerance to the aggressive clean in place (CIP) regimes that the industry uses (e.g. caustic soda cleaning at 80ºC). Such instruments have proven capability and provide highly accurate measurements in a liquid stream. 6.3.2 Laboratory NIR instrumentation The principles and functions of a laboratory analyser will clearly be similar to those of on-line devices, albeit with less emphasis being placed upon the tolerance to varied sample presentation and operating conditions, as discussed in the introduction. However, the techniques that have been and are being used for wavelength selection, detection and subsequent signal handling can differ. Benson et al. (1988) discuss the various techniques that have been employed for both off-line and on-line analysers, describing the relative merits of each approach. For laboratory-based analysers, optical filter technology is also used; however, clearly this restricts the choice of wavelengths, especially for a device that may be used for research and development. Full spectrum analysers are commonly used; these are based upon scanning monochromators or Michelson based interferometers. In many cases for
150
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
solids measurement the optical configuration is based on reflectance. However, devices do exist which operate in transmission mode at wavelengths short of 1.5 m; these have been principally used for analysing whole cereal grains, meat and liquids or slurries. They incorporate silicon detectors for greater sensitivity at the extremely short wavelengths (0.8–1.0 m) necessary to achieve penetration (or forward scatter) through the sample. The schematic diagram of a typical laboratory reflectance analyser in Fig. 6.7 shows the key elements of the device and the difference in the collection of reflected radiation. The signal processing methodology after data collection has been the area where the greatest energies have been devoted over the years. While on-line analysers tend to be based upon log (reflectance) mathematics or variants approximating more closely to Kubelka-Munk scattering equations (Kubelka and Munk 1931; Kubelka 1948), the offline analysers have also been configured to perform first- and second-derivative spectral analysis; more recently, Fourier transformation has been proposed as a useful way of analysing the spectral data collected by a scanning instrument (Giesbrecht et al. 1981; McClure et al. 1984). The latest areas of interest for data analysis include principal component analysis (Cowe and McNicol 1985), Mahalonobis distances (Mark 1986) and partial least squares analysis (Martens and Martens 1986). The concepts behind these ideas are discussed in a short review by Davies (1987). With all of the above instrumentation, the biggest criticism is the need, in most cases, for careful sample preparation and presentation, especially for materials, which are not in a powdered form. This inevitably leads to the result potentially showing a high degree of operator dependence, since it is unlikely that different individuals will carry out the test in exactly the same way. For certain materials, especially those at higher moistures such as cheese, this would prevent a reliable measurement because of the impracticalities of grinding damp materials. Also the size of the sample analysed is commonly only a few grams, and this must raise the question of how representative this would be when a process producing many tonnes of product per hour is monitored for quality control purposes. This problem is of course not restricted to off-line NIR
Fig. 6.7
Typical laboratory NIR analyser optical configuration.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
151
analysis but to any laboratory analytical technique which is being used to track a manufacturing process. A novel approach to overcome many of these shortcomings has been introduced in the form of a laboratory instrument which incorporates many of the lessons learnt from an on-line analytical background. One such device is the Infralab (NDC Infrared Engineering), which is a filter based instrument built exactly according to the technology described in the previous section. Importantly, the instrument uses a large sample tray (140 mm 140 mm square) containing 50 grams or more of sample material, which the instrument then scans automatically, taking many readings and providing an average value for the variable being measured. As a consequence, sample presentation is no longer critical; the height of the product in the tray need not be controlled, and the sample does not require any specific preparation. The speed of measurement of the on-line sensor technology used in this instrument means that multiple measurement can be carried out rapidly, providing results, even for a large sample area, within 15 seconds. Since the instrument scans a large sample area, it effectively provides statistical information (mean and standard deviation of the multiple measurements) about that sample. It thus helps in judging its quality and reliability as a representative sample from the product flow, and minimises the need for replicate analyses. Digital multi-wavelength instrumentation, as for on-line analyses, simplifies the operation of off-line instrumentation. However, principally because of the better control of off-line measurement conditions (temperature, humidity) and the length of time available for a measurement, complex multi-component analysers have been in use for many years. Finally, and very important conceptually, an approach in which the sample is automatically scanned provides a measurement which is no longer operator dependent.
6.4
Applications in the food industry
6.4.1 Moisture measurements in foodstuffs On-line NIR moisture measurement has and is being widely used in the food industry for a wide range of products. The concept is very successful and with the improved sophistication in instrumentation and calibration models it can easily provide the performance required today and can be dependably used in closed-loop process control. There are many examples that the authors will draw upon which is proof of how NIR measurement is successfully applied. However, it is also accepted that the technology does carry a lot of history with it and this has led to levels of scepticism in the industry about its usefulness. This has arisen through the way the technology has evolved and how the early NIR solutions were simply not adequate to describe the product to be measured. Also the technology has suffered in some cases through naı¨ve claims by certain instrument suppliers that the technique was without issues and real experience proved otherwise thus distancing some users from the technology. The technology generally has moved forward to a degree where it is possible to achieve real process control and quality benefits. It is still of course necessary when choosing a supplier to make sure that they can demonstrate the thoroughness of understanding of the technology and its application. The first NIR on-line analysers applied in the food industry used two wavelengths and very simple models to provide a moisture measurement. These gauges were soon shown to be affected by product variations other than moisture and so to apply the technique either the user had frequently to check the validity of the calibration or accept inaccuracy
152
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
and use the instrument merely for trending moisture changes without risking implementing closed-loop control. Parameters that affected early NIR gauges were things like particle size, colour variation and subtle compositional changes. Colour changes, for example, could be brought about by changes in drying conditions or subtle compositional variation in the product characteristic of many natural products. Various techniques have been developed to make the NIR calibration more robust that are not affected by such product variables. The first significant step was to use additional wavelengths and better calibration models to more accurately represent the spectral background characteristic of the product allowing elimination of background changes that would be responsible for the changes in the calibration. As stated before, a reflectance measurement is equally dependent upon the moisture absorption characteristic and the scattering properties of the product. The latter variable is wavelength dependent and its subtle variation, if not corrected for, will affect a moisture measurement. To understand the reasons for the shortcomings of the two-wavelength instrument, it is necessary to consider the influence such variables have on a product’s reflectance spectrum. Figure 6.8 shows schematically the reflectance spectra of milk powder at two different particle sizes but at the same moisture content. The spectral differences are exaggerated for clarity, but it is clear that the regions on each side of the water band suffer reflectance changes with particle size. With a two-wavelength gauge, the reference wavelength signal is no longer stable and cannot be reliably used to provide a measurement of the absorption band peak height. The balanced reference method first employed by NDC Infrared Engineering is depicted in Fig. 6.9, where a third wavelength is used as an additional reference point in the product spectrum. Interpolation between the two references is then required to establish the spectral background characteristic at the water band and so provide a measurement that is independent of these slope changes. The success of this technique is clearly demonstrated
Fig. 6.8
Influence of milk powder particle size on the NIR reflectance spectrum and its adverse effect on a two-wavelength measurement.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.9
153
The benefit of using additional NIR reference wavelengths in compensating for particle size effects.
in Fig. 6.10, which shows the calibration characteristics for skim milk powder for both a two-wavelength and a three-wavelength, balanced reference gauge. The single calibration for all milk powder particle sizes provided a measurement accuracy of ±0.1 per cent moisture (2). The particle size variation cited in this example typically ranged from returns from the cyclone separators to the agglomerated materials produced after a multi-stage spray and fluid bed drying process. As Fig. 6.10 illustrates, it is possible completely to eliminate particle size influence upon a calibration by the use of additional wavelengths and a better calibration model. The changes in the reflectance spectra can be accounted for by the way in which the scattering properties of the milk powder have been modified by a particle size change. The simple Beer-Lambert exponential law describing the absorption of energy (equation (1)) does not take scattering into account, and therefore new models are required so that the spectral characteristics of the product can be described accurately enough for the moisture measurement to be of practical use. In most cases it is unusual to need more than three wavelengths for moisture measurements. Another example of the success of this approach is the measurement of moisture in maize grits, used in the snack industry for the production of corn based products such as tortilla chips. The twowavelength model was shown to be sensitive to variations in the supply origin of the maize. However the three-wavelength model completely eliminates this sensitivity, which would otherwise render the measurement unusable the comparison being shown in Fig. 6.11. Over the years the sophistication of calibration modelling science has evolved considerably and it is clear that the simple Beer Lambert approach or variants thereof are not adequate and the science of Chemometrics has allowed this area to develop tremendously as mentioned earlier. In particular technology has allowed robust calibrations to be developed. Robust refers to the ability of a calibration model to remain valid with time and to enable accuracy of measurement to be retained for years without the need for instrument adjustment – a fundamental requirement if the gauge is to be used in a closed-loop control situation.
154
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 6.10
NIR calibrations on milk powder using two and three wavelengths.
Good examples of the way the technology is able to handle more difficult applications include the measurement of hard cheese moisture and fat content. A calibration has been developed by the authors’ company, which not only is stable with time but also is equally applicable to cheeses from New Zealand, Holland, Eire, UK and the USA! The benefit here to users is obvious. An instrument can be provided pre-calibrated thus minimising user involvement to get a system operational in the process.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
155
Fig. 6.11 NIR calibrations on maize grit using two and three wavelengths.
The same is true for measurements of starch powder, at first sight a seemingly simple, white powder which should be a trivial application. In reality the product shows immense variability in its scatter properties for a given variant and is produced in a variety of forms for different food applications. However, with the appropriate calibration model which now takes scatter properties into account, it is practical to measure all variants on a single calibration. Of course additional infra-red wavelengths are required but with the new multi-wavelength analysers available this is now practicable. In certain products, natural variation of another constituent can have an adverse effect on the moisture measurement. Milk powder again provides a good example of this, where the fat level or even the fat type (vegetable or animal) can vary depending on the product type. This can alter the optical properties of the powder, and hence the moisture calibration may be affected. However, by monitoring the fat absorption characteristics it is possible to compensate for fat contents of up to at least 30 per cent and provide a fat-independent moisture calibration. The ability to monitor fat content implies that this constituent can be measured, and this will be discussed in the following sections.
156
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Another interesting illustration of the successful and demanding application of NIR is provided by moisture measurement in finished, crystalline sugar. The product moisture content needs to be maintained below 0.1% or even less in some cases otherwise the product fuses together and can cause serious blockages in the process, which are very expensive to correct. The product granulometry can vary considerably and there are deliberate variants of widely differing particle size such as granulated and castor sugars. A sophisticated model correcting for scatter has been devised and the measurement can be performed on all sugar types regardless of product format and allows accuracies of better than 0.005% moisture against a Karl Fischer reference to be achieved on line. The comparison of a simple model and the final multi-wavelength scatter compensating algorithm are shown in Fig. 6.12. One of the currently most successful NIR applications on-line is that of snack food moisture measurement where again calibrations have had to be derived unaffected by potato crop or type, potato sugar content, oil content or oil type! There are currently more than 700 analysers being applied worldwide on this type of application. Moisture measurement in biscuits or cookies presents another entirely different product format yet one which is amenable to NIR gauging on-line, despite the limited penetration of NIR radiation as discussed in Section 6.6. Even though a biscuit is very thick (relatively) and the product has just emerged from an oven with a huge moisture gradient from outside to inside, the relationship of internal to surface moisture is well enough defined to allow a useful control signal to be derived from an on-line measurement. At the time of writing there seems to be a resurgence of interest in this application to allow manufacturers to achieve consistent product quality. NIR then can have application over an extremely diverse range of products. Generally, the common denominator is that the material must be of powder, crystalline, fibrous or flaky form, although pelletised or bulky products of a wide range of particle sizes are amenable to this method providing their surface is representative of the material as a whole. The acceptable moisture range is wide, this flexibility being a consequence of the range of absorption sensitivities available in the NIR. For example, at the low moisture end, materials such as citric acid crystals with moisture contents below 1 per cent can be analysed using the 1.94 m band, whereas cottage cheeses and spent wash syrups from distillery wastes, both of around 80 per cent moisture, can be tackled using the weak 1.45 m water band. Table 6.1 provides a representative list of well-proven applications suitable for NIR measurement, and the typical accuracies obtainable are also given. The measurement of moisture or other components in liquid streams is occasionally required. The main proviso here is that the liquid has an infra-red ‘window’ at the constituent’s absorption band, and that the constituent is homogeneously distributed through the liquid, or miscible with it. For instance, measurement of alcohol in beer or cider although a very demanding NIR application, is entirely possible whereas moisture in vegetable cooking oils could present a problem if the moisture is present in a heterogeneous distribution. These applications need to be measured in transmission and so a specialised instrument configuration such as that shown in Fig. 6.6 would be required. Yet another different example of the use of a transmission NIR instrument is the measurement of the casing material used for enclosing sausages, including salami-like meat products. The cellulose or collagen-based tube is flattened at certain stages of the process and provides an ideal presentation for measurement of moisture and possibly other constituents.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.12
157
Sugar calibrations using (a) two-wavelength and (b) multi-wavelength scatter correction algorithms.
6.4.2 Multi-component analysis of food products While on-line moisture measurement remains the principal need within the food industry, other measurements are becoming increasingly important for a number of reasons. Legislation and product in-pack specification issues are becoming ever more important. The continuing trend to produce low fat/oil products means measurement of this
158
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 6.1
A selection of on-line moisture measurement applications in the food and feed industry
Application Animal meals (fish, meat, etc.) Biscuits Breadcrumbs Cereals, breakfast Cheese Chocolate crumb Cocoa powders Chocolate Coffee, instant Coffee, ground Coffee, roast/green beans Flour Grass and forage Herbs, dried Grain products: wheat, barley, oats spent grains, malted grains Maize products: grits, flakes, powders Milk powders: skim, fat filled, replacer formulae, infant feed Non-dairy creamers Potato flakes and powders Salt Snack foods: potato chips, tortillas, pretzels, extrudeds Soy meals, flakes Starch Sugar, granulated finished Sugar beet Tea: instant, final dried to leaf Yeast powders
Moisture range (%)
Accuracy (% absolute)
0–5 0–10 0–5 30–50 0–2 0–5 0–5 0–5 2–10 5–10 10–15 5–80 5–15 5–15 5–15 0–5 0–5 0–10 0–2 0–2 5–15 5–10 0–0.1 5–15 0–80 5–20
+/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/ +/
0.1 0.15 0.1 0.3 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.1 0.1 to +/ 1.0 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.05 0.1 0.2 0.1 0.005 0.2 0.1 to +/ 1.0 0.2
parameter is more important. While moisture control is practical through more or less drying in a process and therefore the benefit of measurement is obvious the ability continually to adjust other parameters is possible in some cases and this demands ability to measure them on-line. Traditionally, many of these other parameters would have been measured off line possibly using NIR on the basis of the belief that their variation was limited enough to make batch testing representative enough. In reality there is variation in most process streams and so on-line measurement is the only way to be certain that the product is adequately quantified. In processes where a constituent other than moisture can be adjusted, on-line measurement offers tremendous potential to reduce production costs through not over-specifying and optimising product quality. In most cases such measurements will be required simultaneously with moisture since this allows dry weight calculations to be performed in instances where another component may be added to a process stream. For example, in chocolate manufacture cocoa butter which is very expensive may be added to the bulk. The requirement in these instances is for a multi-constituent NIR analyser which can provide measurement of more than one component. The MM710 from NDC Infrared Engineering, described in Section 6.3 is able to provide a measurement of up to four constituents simultaneously. This capability now allows food technologists and processors to implement on-line NIR measurements that in the past would have been
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
159
restricted to laboratory instruments. While non-moisture measurements are generally more demanding because their infra-red absorptions are weaker and less well defined, current on-line instrumentation, as described, is more than capable of achieving high accuracy on a wide range of different components. The only word of warning on multi-component measurements is to constrain oneself to the realms of measurements based upon sound chemical/physical rationale. Despite the explosion of interest in NIR applications for almost any constituent in food products using laboratory analysers there is, in the authors’ view, need for caution in deciding which applications may be successfully tackled on-line. The need of a production facility is to have a measurement which is robust with time and which does not require constant attention or adjustment especially if the measurement output is to be used in closed-loop control. In a laboratory environment it may be acceptable with skilled personnel to accept that frequent calibration correction is part of a procedure. In practice this means that measurement calibrations with correlation coefficients of less than 0.95 just will not stand up to the test of time in a production environment. The subtleties of measurement development are outside the domain of this discussion and are handled in other articles (Honigs 1985), but a broad understanding of the topic is important to those considering the use of NIR multi-component instrumentation in a new application. The quality and robustness of a calibration, that is, the long-term dependability of the measurement, will be strongly related to the soundness of this initial approach. The authors and their colleagues strongly favour an approach where the measurement is based upon sound chemical/physical principles. There are instances described in the literature where NIR measurement of a component, not existent in the material, is apparently being made, probably because of a correlation with some material in the natural product within the sample set collected for the analysis. The measurement of the ash content of wheat, the tar content of cigarette tobacco, the bakeability of bread (Hagburg factor) and the sensory qualities of peas are such examples. These measurements would be unlikely to succeed as on-line applications in the long term, and frequent recalibration of an instrument would be symptomatic of this lack of robustness. Examples of the on-line multi-component applications that are successful are plentiful. Those that have been selected for discussion highlight the breadth of the technique and should provide a theme for consideration of others, which may not have been developed to date. Fat/oil and moisture measurements in products probably is the most commonly applied multi-component measurement with snack foods such as potato chips, tortilla chips, extruded snacks and pretzels being the most significant examples. These are demanding measurements principally due to the environment where the ambient temperature is extremely high and the atmosphere laden with oil mist and humidity. Nonetheless, on-line instruments can be designed to handle such hostile locations in a process. Fat and moisture in chocolate processing is a very successful and important application at most stages of the process from cocoa nib though to finished chocolate. An interesting application arising from this capability has been the use of on-line NIR to measure the thickness of chocolate on the refiner rollers to ensure correct product texture. The fat measurement provides the basis for measuring layer thickness, which relates to the roller gap and therefore the creaminess of the chocolate. Milk powder can also be measured comprehensively with on-line NIR gauging, moisture fat and protein and perhaps lactose being four measurements that virtually characterise a formulation. Protein content in flour can be an important on-line
160
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 6.2
A selection of on-line multi-component measurements in the food industry
Product
Components
Animal meals: fish, meat, soya Biscuits Chocolate products Cocoa powders Cheese Flour Grain products Maize products: meal, flakes Milk powders Non-dairy creamers Olive pulps and other pressed oil seeds Meat minced (beef, pork, turkey, chicken, lamb) Snack foods, all types
Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture, Moisture,
fat, protein oil fat fat fat, protein protein protein protein fat protein fat oil fat, protein oil
measurement in cases where a mill adjusts protein level through gluten addition. Low levels of constituents can be measured such as the caffeine content in coffee. While decaffeinated product would be difficult to quantify to an adequate accuracy, the 1–2% levels in beans is practical with an on-line gauge. Oil extraction applications provide another example of where on-line measurement is of great potential benefit to a user. In the production of extra virgin olive oil the olive pulp is pressed in a centrifuge and extraction efficiency has a great economic impact on the process. Extraction efficiency depends upon the decanter performance and this is affected by pulp moisture content as well. On-line NIR is being successfully applied to measure residual oil content at levels around 1–4% and simultaneously moisture at about 60%. The technique may be applicable to other oil extraction processes such as palm, soya, rape and sunflower oils. The fat content in ground meats is another area of considerable interest again due to the potential cost savings and quality improvements through better control of the process. On-line NIR measurement has been successfully deployed in measuring ground meats such as beef, turkey pork and chicken. Typically the process involves the blending of lean and fatty cuts with the aim of achieving a specified fat level. The on-line measurement allows control of this blending process to a high degree of accuracy. The cheese measurement mentioned earlier is principally concerned with moisture measurement but fat and protein may also be measured simultaneously. Its application to date has been ‘at-line’ mainly but the purpose has been to control the production process and its speed has eliminated the need for the expensive, time consuming and somewhat hazardous wet chemistry techniques. A list of on-line multi-component applications is provided in Table 6.2 to illustrate the current status in the market. However, there are certain to be other requirements and hopefully the examples mentioned above highlight the possibilities and scope of the technique. 6.4.3 Quality control for food packaging materials A number of the food industry’s activities overlap with operations in other industries which provide materials for use by food producers. Many of these associated industries may already be making NIR measurements of their products to control the quality;
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
161
however, the food technologist may be unaware of this occurring or even of the availability of such means to test these product specifications. The most important area must be that of general packaging materials. This encompasses a huge range of products including paper, board, plastic packaging films and metal foils. Many of the associated industries are actively using on-line NIR measurement continuously to monitor and control the manufactured product. Many food products are packaged with one or more of these materials and they can influence taste, shelf life or appearance of the foodstuff. For example, board is laminated with polyethylene (PE) to provide a moisture barrier for the packaging of milk or other liquids, while board/aluminium foil/PE laminates are frequently used to package fruit juices. Similarly, wax-coated papers are used to package anything from cheese to hamburgers, providing again a means of keeping in moisture but also avoiding grease migration. Aluminium foils are coated with thin layers of vinylic, PVC, or epoxy and other lacquers a few micrometres thick and then used to provide tops for yoghurts, wraps for cheese, can stock for beverages and a host of other similar applications. All of these materials involve a coating operation, and the thickness of the deposited layer can be readily measured by on-line NIR instrumentation. It would equally be possible to use NIR in an off-line configuration to assess the quality of incoming packaging, in terms of both moisture content and coat weight. Multi-layer packaging films are commonly used to protect and pack foodstuffs providing inert atmospheric environments or gas/moisture barriers. Bacon and other meats are often packaged in nylon/polyethylene structures, while very oxygen-sensitive foodstuffs such as fish and fresh meats may be kept in a PE/EVOH/PE type composite (where EVOH stands for ethylene vinyl alcohol and PE for polyethylene). Since the NIR technique is very selective it is possible to measure the critical thicknesses of these layers individually. While these applications may at first sight seem rather remote from the food technologist’s needs, it could be important to realise their existence either for the setting up of an incoming product screening method, or perhaps to insist that a supplier undertakes these measurements for greater security of product quality in such a vital area of health concern.
6.5
The power of process monitoring and trending
6.5.1 Introduction It may be true that if you cannot measure it you cannot manage it, but a series of isolated measurements do not provide serious benefits until the measurements are presented in such a way that a meaningful conclusion can be drawn about the process or the product. An on-line gauge will almost certainly have some form of digital display showing the current reading or average reading. The current reading is only a small snapshot and in relation to a large process is unlikely to mean very much. An average reading, say over a few seconds or perhaps several tens of seconds, will have more relevance since its value can be associated with an approximate mass or volume of material in process. The quantity of product to which the reading relates may even be known exactly if the mass flow characteristics are also monitored. The process controls that initiate and terminate batch operations can be used to start and stop the batch averaging cycle of an on-line gauge. Batch averages provide a step further in the interpretation of digitised values. One can ask if this batch is bigger or smaller or does it have a larger spread (for this you need the deviation as well as the mean value).
162
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
The benefits of on-line gauging have been widely explored elsewhere and it should be clear that the full potential cannot be realised until some form of process monitoring is put in place. Without continuous on-line gauging, manufacturers are restricted to sampling from the process, analysing, reporting and some time later taking action. With SPC techniques it is possible to make some process advances even with off-line monitoring. In some instances the process may not lend itself to on-line gauging but maybe a rapid, at-line technique (see reference to Infralab in Section 6.3.2) can be used to provide reasonably timely information. In this section, several different processes have been chosen to illustrate how trended data, even from off-line measurements, can be utilised to improve process profitability and/or product quality. Process monitoring software, such as SCADA systems, present the gauge data in the form of a time series. The scaling of the time base over different time frames permits the viewing of detailed process characteristics or longer-term trends. By monitoring several different measurements on one screen, the relationship between them can easily be spotted. It really is not until the data is presented graphically that it begins to come alive and the conclusions are easily substantiated. There are countless ways of visualising measurement data and the examples here are presented in a variety of ways to help explain the added value that can be gained from choosing the best type of data plot. In most cases, a simple trend of the measured variable against time is sufficient to begin with. More information may be gained by plotting the spread of measured results. Most well behaved processes tend to oscillate about their mean value and a simple trend plot may not reveal underlying characteristics. By viewing the spread in the results as a frequency distribution it may be possible to interpret more factors that are influencing the process. The normal distribution curve is the basis of so many aspects of on-line gauging and the typographical description in Fig. 6.13 illustrates this in more ways than one. In many processes the mean value can be controlled using a feedback loop. Further effort is required to understand reasons for the spread in the results and effort is being concentrated here where consistency is a major quality driver. On-line gauging provides real benefits in several different ways, which should ultimately be quantified to calculate a ‘return on investment’. The different benefit areas lend themselves to different ways of plotting the data. The following examples illustrate the various ways of visualising the data as well as illustrating different benefit The NORMAL law of error stands out in the experience of mankind as one of the broadest generalisations of natural philosophy O It serves as the guiding instrument in researches in the physical and social sciences and in medicine agriculture and engineering O It is an indispensible tool for the analysis and the interpretation of the basic data obtained by observation and experiment. Fig. 6.13
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
163
areas. To set the scene for the examples it is useful to remember why users invest in gauging: • yield and productivity • quality • product development through understanding the process.
It is virtually impossible to achieve these benefits without some kind of reference to historical data. Firstly, let us look at yield, since it is here that the justification for purchase is made easily. The most obvious ways of improving yield in foodstuffs is to increase the moisture content up to the maximum legislative or quality limit. 6.5.2 Cheese yield improved through off-line moisture measurement In developing cheesemaking on an industrial scale, manufacturers have driven the need for characterisation of this natural process. Once considered a dark art, only practised on the farms which provide the raw ingredient, it is now scrutinised to extract maximum profitability. A rather dispassionate chemical engineering view of cheese as a protein matrix containing a distribution of moisture and fat provides the insight into yield optimisation. The number of available cheese types is increasing, essentially due to consumer demand, conveniently providing manufacturers plenty of scope to utilise available milk optimally. In the manufacture of cheese (see Section 6.4) the principal concern is moisture measurement although the fat content is also important. The allowed moisture range of cheese types is specified within acknowledged standards, aiming to define policy on labelling, etc. Through the late 1980s and early 1990s, the authors’ company developed a series of at-line measurements, using the Infralab, for the cheese industry. The performance of these measurements was monitored over a number of years to ensure that natural variations did not affect the calibration of the Infralab. In milk, the protein to fat ratio is affected by seasonal variations in the grass used to feed the cows and these variations have been themselves caused by seasonal weather changes. If this seasonal variance were to change the resulting cheese in such a way as to cause errors in the measurement, a great deal of the benefits would be lost. To ensure that this was not the case, data from several years of measurements were collected and examined. The original performance of the various measurements across a variety of cheese types was proved to be stable and repeatable. The data also revealed something else; that the mean moisture level for certain cheese types had increased significantly over the time period. This may well be explained by consumer demand for lower-fat products or a concern by the manufacturer that ever-higher moisture should be used to check the integrity of the measurements, but either way the increments have clearly indicated the potential for increased profitability. These increases are often very small but with huge production volumes and acceptable investment periods the results are visible and desirable. Mozzarella cheese has experienced huge growth as the popularity of pizza has grown. Conveniently, the desire for low-fat products gives manufacturers the opportunity to develop new products with higher moisture content. Obviously, there is an upper limit for most specified cheese types, Cheddar cheese, for example, must not contain any more than 39% moisture. At 39% moisture it would be a very mild variety, at 35% it would be extra strong or mature. Since the introduction of the Infralab as the preferred measurement device, manufacturers have been able to get to know and develop their processes and products and to increase their yield. Given that the total production figures for cheese in the EU in
164
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
1997 was over 6 million tons, a fractional increase in yield or productivity would make sound economic sense. 6.5.3 Snack food process development and product quality Quality, as a motivation for on-line measurement, can often be related to the consistency of a final product. In the case of fried snack foods, the oil content has a highly distinguishing taste effect and the drive to minimise variations is present in the development of products and processes. Most processes operate with a uniform spread about their mean value. The data can be presented by the mean and the standard deviation. This assumes that the data is ‘normally distributed’, i.e it follows the characteristic bell-shaped curve known as a normal distribution. However, there are processes that can tend to skew the distribution and these require a different way of looking at the data, plotted as the frequency distribution. Within the snack food fryer, the mean frying time is adjusted on the basis of exit moisture measurements. As each piece passes through the fryer its moisture decreases and its oil content increases. Unlike a solid belt conveyor, the pieces of snack food are conveyed by the flow of oil through the fryer and the flow characteristics result in some pieces being cooked for longer than others, giving rise to a broader distribution of oil contents. Figure 6.14 shows a typical oil distribution characteristic for a large continuous corn-chip fryer. The key characteristic is the skew of the distribution on the high end. This is consistent with some chips emerging some time after others that had entered the fryer at the same time. These stragglers picked up extra oil, which can only really be seen once the data is plotted as a frequency distribution. A simple trend plot would mask the effect. Changes to the design of the oil flow within the fryer can affect this distribution and a drive for consistency in the finished product would need to characterise the data in this way. The average oil content of potato crisps can show an interesting cyclic variation that can be traceable to the state of the blades in the potato slicers. The high-speed knives are chipped or worn down to a point where, after about two hours they need sharpening. As the slicers become worn, they begin to tear the potato’s cell structure, so that it picks up more oil as it passes through the fryer. The mean exit oil content can be monitored as a
Fig. 6.14
Typical snackfood oil distribution.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
165
trend and the slicer blades replaced in a timely fashion. This corrective action minimises oil consumption. 6.5.4 On-line sugar The sugar production process lends itself to the measurement and control of moisture at several stages, from cane or beet processing right through to the final granulated product (see Section 6.4.1). Sugar refineries can suffer problems of sugar handling and storage if moisture content in the final product is too high. This can be the formation of small lumps in the sugar, solved by re-drying before shipment. In the worst case, an entire storage silo or tanker of sugar could form into a single lump, with costly consequences. On-line moisture measurement at critical stages of the process provide the line operators with a continuous read-out of the current moisture content. In addition, the values are recorded and trended, against time, using a computer system. The staff can see at a glance exactly what the moisture content is, and can control the process machinery accordingly. The result is a more efficient process where the operators are able to take full responsibility for quality control on the line. The sugar refinery measurement solution combines results from two measuring points. The first is installed to measure the moisture content of the ‘wet’ sugar being discharged from fugals – fine mesh centrifuges used to remove free moisture from the raw sugar slurry. Moisture content at this point is between 0.5 and 1.3%, depending on the product and grain size. After the fugal, sugar is conveyed to a warm air dryer, controlled by an operator on the basis of moisture content, humidity and temperature. The target moisture content at the exit of the dryer, between 0.025 and 0.070% depending on the product, is the second measurement point. Alarms can be set to activate if moisture increases above a certain level. If an alarm occurs, the operators can take action to bring the moisture back into specification. In one such instance the refinery operators found that the alarms occurred very frequently and began to suspect that there was a problem with the measuring system. On inspection of the trend data that had been recorded, a spike was seen to occur approximately every 2.5 minutes. This frequency was found to be the same as the cycle time of the fugal. The fugal was investigated, a problem fixed and the moisture alarms stopped. In situations where operators have not had access to such real-time measurement data, it is likely that the integrity of the measuring system that will be questioned before the possibility of a process problem is acknowledged. 6.5.5 Sugar coated confectionery The hard sugary coating on many types of confectionery is applied in layers that are built up in a continuous coating operation. The particular sweets often have a chocolate centre that has been cast or pressed into the desired shape, typically an ellipsoid. Whatever the centre, the coating must be applied uniformly and efficiently to produce a high quality product at maximum process efficiency. Product quality is affected since over drying can cause the coating to crack, under drying will cause non-uniformities. Between these limits lies the end-point of each coating operation; hence productivity is also a factor. The absolute moisture content of the coating is not important, as it is very low relative to the weight of each piece. This provides the benefit of not having to check the calibration of the gauge against a laboratory method. The coating operation involves the
166
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 6.15
Typical process trend for sugar-coated confectionery.
sequential addition of moisture and powdered sugar in a rotating drum. Hot air is passed through the drum and a NIR gauge views the tumbling sweeties. Valuable information is gained about the progress of each coating operation; through the monitoring the moisture trend information enables the operator to control the timing of the moisture and coating addition. Figure 6.15 illustrates the relative change in the gauge output over a few typical coating cycles. 6.5.6 Alfalfa Although grass is not a human food, in a sense it is the precursor to cheese so an example is included here. The trend plot in Fig. 6.16 shows a cyclic trend over 4.5 minutes, presumably a characteristic of the dryer operation. The variation in moisture shown has an effect on the protein content expressed as a percentage of the wet weight. As the moisture content increases the protein content decreases because of the diluting effect of the additional water.
6.6 Practical considerations for implementing on-line measurement 6.6.1 NIR measurement characteristics, advantages and disadvantages When considering the possibility of using the NIR technique to solve a particular measurement problem, it is necessary to appreciate both its scope and its limitations. The non-contact characteristic is considerably attractive, since the measurement will not normally interfere with product flow. Also, for food processing, non-contact measurements are favoured by hygiene considerations. The non-destructive nature of the technique minimises product wastage associated with conventional laboratory methods and for some high cost products, this feature alone can justify the use of an instrument if it can replace the majority of quality assurance testing. On-line NIR gauges provide a continuous or near-continuous output that varies in real time according to the variations in the constituent being measured. The speed of the rotating filter wheel, see Section 6.3.1, and hence the resulting measurement time is very fast when compared to the speed of products conveyed by the more usual methods (ranging from belt conveyors to pneumatically conveyed powders. This is ideal for
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.16
167
Typical alfalfa dryer characteristics.
control purposes because all the product viewed by the gauge is sampled and the average moisture (for example) derived can be extremely representative of the product stream, even at very fast response times (second to second). NIR measurement is unaffected by changes in the electrical properties of foodstuffs, for example electrical conductivity or dielectric behaviour; such parameters can easily change if the salt or other ionic material content varies. This provides a distinct advantage over alternative methods of on-line moisture measurement based upon monitoring the electrical properties of the product, such as capacitance or conductance which can be related to moisture content. For carefully constructed algorithms, (see Section 6.3), product density does not generally influence the measurement but will certainly affect techniques based upon monitoring electrical capacitance properties. Similarly, product temperature will not directly influence NIR measurement whereas electrical techniques are temperature sensitive. Although there will be an increase in infra-red emission from the product with temperature, this will be a relatively small change at the operational wavelengths and a continuous emission of DC form. It will therefore be ignored by a properly designed AC coupled detection system in an NIR instrument. However, if temperature variations in the process cause compositional changes in the product it is possible that the NIR gauge would register this as a change in the calibration of the gauge. It seems ironic that an NIR gauge can measure moisture precisely but when compared to a technique that essentially measures volatiles it will appear to have product type/ variation sensitivity. The effect that is being observed is that the non-moisture volatile materials present in the product are also removed to a lesser or greater extent during oven testing. These losses contribute to the apparent moisture content. This can be avoided to a great degree by comparing NIR measurements to water specific tests such as Karl Fischer. In the application of NIR to moisture determination, the response to free or associated moisture and bound water (water of crystallisation) should be appreciated. In most materials, the difference in wavelength between the absorption bands for these two forms of moisture is very small and therefore they cannot usually be treated separately. Whether this is an advantage or a drawback depends on the requirements of the individual application. For example, with whey powders the moisture content will be distributed between free and bound moisture, the latter being present as water of crystallisation in the
168
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
alpha-lactose. However, the storage stability of whey is only influenced by the free moisture and therefore an NIR measurement is of limited value. Whether an infra-red gauge is sensitive to changes in ambient lighting levels is critically dependent on the instrument design. The form of the blocking filter, which shields a detector from visible and irrelevant parts of the infra-red spectrum, plays an important role in reducing the influence of ambient lighting. Signal processing techniques are able to eliminate ambient lighting completely, but if ambient lighting changes are found to affect the measurement it is always possible to shield the measuring area from those changes. This shield is an additional expense and invariably cause access problem to the measuring unit. There are huge variations in atmospheric moisture or relative humidity (RH) in any food-processing environment. The effect of variations in RH should not cause any measurement problems for a carefully constructed algorithm. Condensing steam or water vapour is different and any moisture gauge will require installation away from sources of condensing water. This does not usually present a problem due to the flexibility of mounting orientations and the use of effective air purge windows. Inspection of Fig. 6.17, which shows the transmission spectra of liquid water relative to water vapour, shows that although the bands overlap, they do absorb at different wavelengths. Any overlap can be compensated for by careful wavelength selection and appropriate cross correction within the algorithm. The major limitation of the NIR measurement is the limited penetration of the infrared radiation into the product. Although this is dependent upon the water absorption band chosen (shorter wavelength radiation is more penetrating), it usually amounts to no more than a few tenths of a millimetre into the material. The scattering characteristics of the product primarily determine the level of light penetration in a given wavelength region. Fortunately in many practical applications this does not present a problem since the bulk of the foodstuff, especially if made up of fine particles (powders, granulates, etc.), is well represented by its surface layer. For example, in milk powder with particle sizes ranging from below 50 m to over 200 m, the individual particles are adequately penetrated by
Fig. 6.17
Water spectra.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
169
the radiation to give a meaningful moisture measurement. However, it is important that the surface of the product bed viewed by the gauge is representative of the bulk of the material which will not be seen. If the surface material tends to dry off relative to the bulk, because of long periods of exposure to the air or from having emerged hot from a dryer, precautions must be taken. The particulate product must be turned over prior to measurement, by installing the gauge at a point where a change in conveyors occurs or even by ploughing the surface, this latter method being particularly suitable for fine powders. The concern for materials with large particle size, especially those that have recently been dried or steam conditioned, is whether the surface moisture represents the internal condition. Indeed, it is frequently the case in drying processes that the surface and internal moisture levels of bulky materials differ. In many situations, this potential difficulty is not a problem because there is some form of relationship between the surface and total moisture content which can be exploited to provide a measurement. It is often the relatively constant conditions employed to dry a foodstuff that ensure this assumption is valid! The classic example of this is the on-line measurement of biscuit moisture. After oven drying, the surface moisture content of biscuits is very low, and will even vary across the surface, while the internal moisture is at a higher level. However, the oven drying characteristics are very consistent and therefore the on-line measurement of surface moisture provides the biscuit producer with useful information for a process control system. It is sensible to question whether very large particle size materials are suitable because of the almost certain difference in surface characteristics from the interior condition. Block or slab materials such as finished chocolate or even freshly baked bread provide extremely doubtful examples. NIR measurements specific to foods are discussed in Section 6.4. Microwave measurement can be a useful alternative technique when the limited penetration of an NIR measurement is a problem. However, apart from the difficulties of engineering a microwave emitter/receiver on-line, often in intimate contact with the product, the technique is still susceptible to product temperature and density variations unless appropriate signal correction is applied. Sophisticated instruments are available which take these difficulties into account. The range of moistures over which a microwave system operates can be very limited owing to excessive attenuation of the microwave radiation by water. However, new techniques utilising stripline or coaxial gauges can in part overcome these shortcomings. (See Chapter 12 for a detailed discussion of microwave measurement.) Of course, there are instances where NIR measurement may not be successful. Backscatter gauges work on the absorption characteristics and if they are subject to specular energy from shiny surfaces the measurements can become noisy and ultimately worthless. The light directly reflected has no absorption information and products such as caramels, syrups and fondants fall into this category. In these instances it is possible to consider a special optical arrangement for the gauge to ignore specular light, or even to use a transmission configuration. 6.6.2 Installation in the food industry The ideal optical configuration for most on-line NIR measurements will be based upon a back scatter (reflectance) configuration of the gauge, this being the most suitable approach to the analysis of powdered, granular or flaky materials. Backscatter measurement is non-contact, the gauge being mounted some 250 mm away from the
170
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
product surface. Careful optical design and the characteristic of the ratio measurement can eliminate the non-uniformity of NIR detectors to the point where quite large variations in the product pass height can be tolerated. Variations in height of ±100 mm will not cause problems and in fact larger ranges can be acceptable, especially if they are short term and random rather than systematic over longer periods of time. Installation is therefore simple and requires only a continuous flow of product so that the gauge does not view the conveyor belt. In instances where this is not possible, such as in biscuit production, a special version of the on-line gauge with electronic gating is available. For powdered, granular or flaky materials the alternatives for maintaining a continuous product stream include product ploughs to create a build-up or sampling devices to capture a representative sample, presenting it to the gauge and returning it to the product flow. Since the diffuse reflectance technique depends upon the gauge measuring light that has interacted with the product and has been partially absorbed, the measurement of shiny materials needs special consideration, especially when the amount of reflected light reaching the gauge is changing appreciably. In these instances the gauge must be arranged to avoid seeing the large surface reflected light component, which of course contains no absorption information. Locations meeting these relatively undemanding requirements can be found on most plants. Open band conveyors are ideal especially after the transition from one conveyor to the next, where a fresh representative surface minimises errors in providing a representative reading. On occasions it is necessary to monitor the product through a window in a duct. The use of toughened glass or sapphire allows this and, provided it is kept clean and a moving flow of product is maintained against the window, the window will not affect the measurement. Maize grits and meals, soya meals, coffee powders and milk powder are examples of products which have been successfully measured through viewing windows. One of the aims in processing is to eliminate dust from the open plant environment, making access to the product somewhat challenging. Powders are often conveyed within a pneumatic system or enclosed ducting. A simple viewing window would be sufficient if it was always completely covered by fresh product. Usually the product flow will be intermittent and consistent presentation of the product to a viewing window cannot be guaranteed. Devices exist that perform a sample and hold routine on the product, within the enclosed conveying system. Figure 6.18 shows NDC Infrared Engineering’s PowderVision system, which was designed to meet these challenges. Products in a screw conveyor may be measured without interference from the screw blade by removing a small section of the blade and mounting the gauge away from the axis screw shaft. This usually gives a product presentation with minimal height variation and no interference from the metal parts of the screw. It is worth restating the need for the gauge to be viewing a surface that is truly representative of the bulk moisture content of the product. This consideration should also be extended to include the need for careful positioning of a static gauge on a wide band of food product. The chosen point for such an application must be where the gauge provides an output that correlates well with the average moisture content irrespective of any profile that may exist across the width of product. Alternatively the gauge may be scanned automatically. Whatever location is chosen, the point must always enable access for sample collection close by and immediately downstream from the gauge for the inevitable cross-checking of the instrument with the laboratory test. This will be particularly important in the early commissioning stages after installation. Calibration is discussed in Section 6.6.4 and 6.6.5.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.18
171
NDC Infrared Engineering PowderVision system.
In many cases, the food industry demands certain hygienic standards to be met; given the often dusty and high humidity environments or even the aggressive nature of some food products, the gauges must be designed accordingly. Since the optical gauge is a self-contained device connected only by a single cable to the outside world, this is relatively simple to achieve. Gauges are available in stainless steel with flush fitting joints to avoid harbouring dirt. For high temperature operations methods of cooling using air or water can be applied to allow the unit to operate within its specified working temperature. As far as protection against dust or moisture ingress is concerned, an online gauge is usually built to standards such as the recognised IP65 or NEMA4 ratings. In steamy or dusty environments it is necessary to keep the optical windows clean, and this can be achieved by using an air purge system. The air purge device is attached to the gauge window. The purge is made up of two concentric tubes, the inner one being porous. Compressed air is passed through an aperture in the outer tube and this creates a steady flow of air through the inner tube, keeping the optical window clean. If it is necessary to install the gauge where there is an explosion hazard, a purge and pressurisation system can be used to ensure explosive vapour or dust is kept away from the electronics. If the pressure within the purge system falls below a set point, the equipment is shutdown safely. One of the attractions of the on-line NIR gauge is the variety of seemingly adverse environments it can tolerate. This is largely attributable to the ruggedness of the design and the fact that the optics can be built from materials such as glass or quartz rather than the more fragile components usually associated with the longer wavelength mid-infra-red region. It is only necessary to ensure that the instrument is not subject to excessive vibration, as with any optical system. The response time of the gauge is usually an exponential time constant, effectively providing a running average of the moisture content of the product stream. By definition, this type of response time is the interval during which the gauge will have made a 63 per cent change towards the new value
172
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 6.19
Effect of response time on gauge readings.
following a step change in moisture. The longer the chosen value, the more slowly the gauge will respond to a sudden change in moisture. The chosen response time therefore depends on how variable is the product moisture, and is usually derived empirically by adjustment until a sufficiently stable output is obtained for practical use. For the control of a dryer, where the time needed to provide a change in drying conditions may be of the order of minutes, a gauge response time of perhaps 10 or 20 seconds would be appropriate. However, on a potato crisp productionline, where it can be important to quickly identify ‘wet’ batches of product so that they can be immediately diverted, a shorter response time of 2 to 5 seconds might be used to maximise the ability to detect the out-of-specification product. The ideas expressed above are schematically shown in Fig. 6.19. Using the shorter response time, the amplitude of the process variations is reduced and the peak values are shifted in time. These effects minimise, or possibly eliminate, the ability to detect out-of-specification product. 6.6.3 Sampling procedures for cross-checking In the ideal world a pre-calibrated instrument or one that has been calibrated off-line, should be operational on-line immediately. However, this is not often the case principally because many products may have emerged from a dryer and are not moisture equilibrated. Although other reasons such as the fact that the on-line gauge may have to look through a viewing window or even operate at a much greater distance from the product than was used off-line. Whatever the reason, it is highly likely that a gauge calibrated off-line will need to be checked on-line once installed. Applications engineers are very familiar with the sensitivity requirement for the many possible applications and it is a reasonable assumption at this stage is that any calibration correction needed will only be an intercept adjustment. Even if this is not strictly correct and there is a small error in the slope, this will not adversely affect an on-line calibration if a product is being made to a target moisture. Figure 6.20 illustrates this. To correct for any intercept error in the calibration requires the collection of physical samples from the production-line, and the recording of gauge readings for comparison with a subsequent set of reference tests. The mean difference in reading can then be used with confidence to correct the on-line calibration. The importance of correct sampling methods cannot be overemphasised, since only when they are carried out properly will the user have any chance of assessing the gauge’s performance.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
173
Fig. 6.20 The negligible effect of a small slope error.
The moisture in a product stream can vary enormously in the short term about a reasonably consistent average value. This is, for instance, particularly true for spray drying operations. Superimposed on this short-term variation will be the longer-term overall changes caused perhaps by a real change in moisture of the material input to the dryer. It is the longer-term trends that can be corrected for by process control, but it is important for the user to be aware of the short-term variations because of the effect they will have when comparing the gauge and laboratory methods if they are not taken into account. Typically the laboratory analysis will be based upon very small samples, about 5–10g of product, while the gauge will be providing an average value of many kilograms or even tonnes of product! The instrument, dependent upon the response time chosen, will take these shortterm variations into account but will not show the troughs or peaks of every short-term deviation from the mean moisture value. In these instances, a single laboratory sample is very unlikely to agree with the average value shown by the gauge at any one time. The sampling regime must therefore be devised to ensure that the samples collected are likely to be representative of the average moisture content. This can be achieved either by taking a large bulk of sample over a period and immediately subdividing it for multiple testing, or by collecting many small samples over the same period. Both ways will show the short-term moisture variation and will enable a meaningful average moisture value to be calculated. If the standard deviation associated with the variation within these samples is derived, this will provide an estimate of the likely sampling error that can be expected in the particular process. There are a variety of automated methods for sample data collection, leaving the operator free to collect the physical samples. One such device, the Sample Display Unit, from NDC Infrared Engineering, can be used to calculate the mean and standard deviation over user-definable time periods. The standard deviation figure is very useful for determining whether the process has been varying unusually during the sampling
174
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
period, if this is the case the sample can be rejected, thus minimising the sampling errors. When one is assessing the actual performance of the infra-red gauge, this error must be taken into account. The period chosen for sampling should be between two and three times the chosen response time for the instrument, and samples should be collected only while the gauge output is steady with no obvious large changes in product moisture occurring. These guidelines should assist in setting up procedures for comparative testing, not only for moisture but also for any other components being measured by this technique. Having collected on-line data and associated samples it is possible to analyse the data for the purposes of calibration or assessment of measurement performance. 6.6.4 Calibration of on-line NIR instruments Pre-calibration of gauges is now a common claim by gauging companies and the quality of these must be evaluated prior to use. Gauge to gauge variability on a given sample set will principally depend upon the filter characteristics. However, it is not an unreasonable expectation that the gauge is supplied to the user in a pre-calibrated condition. In this case the gauge should be installed in the process before any adjustments are made and its response to ‘real’ product determined. This approach forms the basis of the SpeedCal concept as used by the authors’ company. The consistency of filters and detectors used within the Series710 gauges, make this possible. Calibration is the process of scaling the output of an instrument that already shows a linear response with moisture variation, but does not agree with the absolute values as obtained from the accepted reference method for analysis. The important point is that an uncalibrated gauge can still show relative changes in moisture content very precisely and repeatably because the algorithm should be designed to provide a linear response to changes in moisture content. Examples of measurements where relative and absolute calibration are given in Section 6.5. Most NIR gauges have a linear response to the constituent to be measured over a specific range of values and calibration is the adjustment of controls that scale the output in recognisable units. The creation of the initial linear response is invariably the domain of applications engineers working for the instrument design companies. The user accepts the responsibility for the subsequent adjustment of calibration parameters. This division of responsibility is a natural one, since the constituents to be measured can be expressed in different units, be defined by differences in laboratory methods such as time or temperature and ultimately be dependent on the product under test. This final point gives rise to an aspect of calibration that has caused many users to give up on NIR as a viable technology. However, if the limitations are understood and a practical strategy is adopted the benefits that can be achieved are enormous. The general principles behind calibration of any instrument and the objective of calibration are very simple concepts but ones which can cause great anxiety amongst users. The reasons behind this may in some cases be a poor understanding of the operation of the instrument but more commonly it is the practical difficulty of accurately assessing the instrument once it is installed on line. For this reason it is convenient to divide the calibration of an NIR instrument into two stages: 1.
Verifying the pre-calibration, offered by the supplier with the gauge as delivered, relative to a chosen reference method. For certain gauges and applications a high degree of confidence can be built up and this step becomes unnecessary.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology 2.
175
Installing the instrument on line and deciding on an appropriate robust and realistic strategy to cross-check its performance with the conventional laboratory analysis.
If stage 1 is required (such as first purchase or evaluation of a new model) it is best carried out with pre-prepared samples under laboratory conditions. The samples should extend well beyond the normal on-line measurement range to enable the correct setting of the sensitivity. To minimise sampling and referencing errors (see Section 6.7) multiple measurements are needed. A convenient way of achieving this with the gauge readings is to present each sub-sample to the gauge on a rotating dish. To achieve good results in the laboratory measurements, again, multiple sub-samples will eliminate most random errors. Stage 1 can often follow a clearly defined, unambiguous procedure whereas stage 2 very much depends upon the application, the degree of flexibility in the particular process for allowing plant changes, and a good understanding of the actual short- or medium-term variation of moisture or another component in the process, since these will obviously influence the cross-checking strategy. This latter point is the most important aspect within stage 2, and the one that is the potential stumbling block, since in comparative tests the laboratory samples must be representative of that material ‘seen’ by the instrument. This subject of sampling, as it is known, will be discussed after practical calibration principles have been described. 6.6.5 Practical aspects of calibration and calibration methods If the SpeedCal concept is accepted, then the calibration is considered ‘innocent until proven guilty’ i.e., assume the calibration is valid for all products and then implement a system that attempts to prove them invalid. If it is possible to do this then there will be a firm set of data that can be used to correct the SpeedCal for the new product. At that stage the amount of correction required will be known and it becomes trivial to enter this as a distinct recipe in whatever system is used for storing different product calibration parameters. However, if there is a need to perform a full calibration, pairs of data are required and the relationship between them needs to be quantified. Data can be plotted graphically or directly entered into a regression program within the NIR instrument. The most common way of analysing data is to use a spreadsheet such as Microsoft ExcelTM. If the calibration calculation is performed without plotting the data there is a risk that the calibration constants will be disproportionately affected by one or two outliers. In all instances the calculations derive the best fit regression-line which provides a value for the slope and intercept of the calibration-line so that any corrections can be made to give the ideal calibration y x. Section 6.5 illustrated the usefulness of representing measured data in different ways and with paired data for calibration purposes it is equally important to plot data. In Anscombe’s (1973) quartet, the four data sets can be represented by the same linear model, but the XY plots reveal a very different story (see Table 6.3 and Fig. 6.21). The number of samples required for this operation depends upon the type of product and its particle size, both of which may affect the variability of the reading obtained on the samples. For a fine powder, such as coffee or milk powder, very good calibrations can be achieved with just five samples, whereas with large flaky materials fifteen to twenty samples may be needed. Generally this is an area that should not be skimped, and therefore as many good-quality samples as are practical (over a wide moisture range) should be used in the initial calibration. This will result in the derivation of a calibration that can be used with greater confidence. A more robust method for determining the correct number of samples to use is shown in Section 6.6.6.
176
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 6.3 I X 10.00 8.00 13.00 9.00 11.0 14.00 6.00 4.00 12.00 7.00 5.00
Anscombe’s Quartet Y
II X
Y
III X
Y
IV X
Y
8.04 6.95 7.58 8.81 8.33 9.96 7.24 4.26 10.84 4.82 5.68
10.00 8.00 13.99 9.00 11.00 14.00 6.00 4.00 12.00 7.00 5.00
9.14 8.14 8.74 8.77 9.26 8.10 6.13 3.10 9.13 7.26 4.74
10.00 8.00 13.00 9.00 11.00 14.00 6.00 4.00 12.00 7.00 5.00
7.46 6.77 12.74 7.11 7.81 8.84 6.08 5.39 8.15 6.42 5.73
8.00 8.00 8.00 8.00 8.00 8.00 8.00 19.00 8.00 8.00 8.00
6.58 5.76 7.71 8.84 8.47 7.04 5.25 12.50 5.56 7.91 6.89
Statistical analysis: N 11 mean of X 9.0 mean of Y 7.5 regression equation: Y 0:5X 3 standard error of estimate of slope 0.118 t 4.24 sum of squares X X bar 110:0 regression sum of squares 27:50 residual sum of squares Y 13:75 correlation coefficient 0:82 r squared 0:67
Fig. 6.21
Anscombe’s Quartet.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
177
6.6.6 Data analysis and the accuracy of an on-line gauge Having adopted good practice for collecting data and samples it is necessary to determine the validity of any calibration changes that are suggested by the data. The user should be aware of the accuracy of the laboratory test against which the NIR gauge will be compared and the potential errors that can arise if the test is badly performed. Having this information in advance will allow a realistic measure of the accuracy of the gauge to be derived. The accuracy of a laboratory test is best assessed by multiple testing of subsamples taken from a bulk of equilibrated product and by calculating the average moisture content and associated standard deviation. The reliability of this figure will be improved if the test is carried out blind, that is without the knowledge of the operator. If it is large, this error could once again easily obscure the true performance of the infra-red instrument. The perceived accuracy of an on-line gauge can often be very different from the reality, simply because sampling and reference methods errors can mask the true performance of the gauge. The accuracy quoted will often be a ‘standard error of estimate’ (SEE) or similar figure calculated from the paired data. This figure is a total error i.e. it is a composite figure (see equation in Fig. 6.22) that does not attempt to distinguish between the various errors that are combined within it. Having established the accuracy and selectively removed only the explainable outliers, simple t-tests can be used to determine whether a calibration change is statistically significant. PC based calibration software programs can calculate the significance of any suggested calibration change and help the user determine whether a simple bias is required, or if a full recalibration of the sensitivity and bias is needed. Given the difference that must be detected, one can also use the t-test to determine the number of samples required. Clustered data will probably occur when a process is operating well within its alarm/ control limits and will present a fundamental problem to users if the recommendations are based on the linear regression without any scrutiny of the uncertainty in the calculated slope. If the range of values is narrow, there should be no attempt to adjust the sensitivity. The data should be sufficient to calculate a bias. One should bear sampling and reference errors in mind since they can be large for any industrial process that has plenty of shortterm variability that cannot be removed. This short-term variability may well be within alarm limits and certainly within the control limits but still be hugely significant with respect to the available photometric precision. Sometimes it may be better not to change calibration parameters, but to monitor their performance over a longer time until a clear pattern of correlation can be observed. The concept of innocence until proven guilty is very useful here. This obviously requires faith in the gauge performance but can avoid wasting resources by continuously recalibrating a gauge based on insufficient data. 6.6.7 Comparative testing and vendor choice Purchase decisions must be based upon a range of factors in order that the right choice is made. It should be clear that simply choosing the cheapest products is not a winning strategy and the most expensive may well be less of a cost burden in the longer run. Users
Fig. 6.22
Total error is a composite figure.
178
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
of on-line gauging will have justified the purchase on the basis of some kind of payback through the benefits of owning such equipment. The total costs must be offset against the returns achieved when calculating the overall return on investment (ROI). To characterise the ideal gauge for an application, the following points must be considered: • measurement performance characteristics • cost of ownership • supplier characteristics.
The balance of each of these factors in the final decision-making process can vary considerably and it is almost impossible to be prescriptive about the best approach. However, the purpose here is to highlight the factors that contribute to each element of the equation and these can be described in detail. Tangibles Firstly, the measurement performance characteristics must be determined to enable a broad calculation of the possible ROI. Comparative evaluations of on-line gauges can be fraught with problems and the results often unhelpful for the original purpose – i.e. vendor choice. This may seem like a strange comment but it is inevitable that a gauge will be placed on-line and data from it compared to the laboratory or to some other online gauging. The other gauge may be of the same technology, e.g. NIR or it may be completely different, e.g. microwave. In the case of comparisons with the laboratory method it is often the case that this method lacks the same precision as the on-line gauge or is not as repeatable or reproducible. All this before one considers the effect of sampling, i.e. when data is taken from an on-line gauge it represents a continuous stream of information that has been processed to give a rolling average result. The sample removed for laboratory testing is a purely a snapshot of the process and can bear little relation to the real variation seen by the on-line gauge. What follows refers to the tangible data that can be gathered from well-conducted evaluations of measurement performance. In order to differentiate between gauges it is necessary to conduct many different kinds of tests. The reason is simply that most gauges do actually respond to changes in the constituent of interest, typically moisture, but also to changes in other parameters. It is interesting to note that perhaps the gauge’s ability to not measure certain things is more important. Firstly, the gauge must not measure changes in the ambient conditions, e.g. temperature, ambient lighting (sunlight, or artificial), the gauge must not measure physical changes in the way the product is presented, e.g. variation in pass height, belt speed. All techniques have their good and bad points and these should be examined in turn, avoiding interference from other correlating variables. Consider a test for tolerance to changes in product pass height. By increasing the distance from the gauge to the target material, not only is the distance changing, but the amount of atmospheric water (humidity) changes also. Depending on the detailed design of the instrument, one of these variables could mask the effect of the other, hence for a rigorous experiment it is important to isolate the variables to be tested. A significant factor in choosing a gauge should be reproducibility or consistency between instruments, since for multi-gauge installations this can have a significant impact on the calibration/re-calibration burden placed upon the user. Instruments with highly repeatable characteristics can quickly be put into service and provide a rapid return, whereas those that vary will need to be monitored and corrected on a individual basis. The characteristic where this is most
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
179
notable is sensitivity to the measured constituent, this should be the same for all gauges measuring a given product. It is the NIR optical filters that govern this factor and it is only companies with complete control (i.e., they do it themselves) over filter design and manufacture that can offer the highest level of ‘gauge-to-gauge’ repeatability. Typical variables that should not affect the performance of an on-line gauge include: • • • • • •
compositional changes ambient lighting temperature humidity product pass height electrical supply variations.
In addition, linearity over the measurement range and stability should also be examined carefully. Some effects may appear as random noise that may be removed by operating at longer response times. It may be important to differentiate between random and systematic effects since in many cases random effects can be averaged out. Either way, the ability to measure the true variation should be tested and if it becomes necessary to operate at long response times care should be taken that this does not mask the real variations that are occurring in the process. Intangibles The supplier organisation should be considered in terms of after-sales support, both field service and technical, and the long-term goals of the company must be understood. The experience and knowledge of the people who sell and support the products is somewhat difficult to quantify but surely must play a part in the overall decisionmaking process. NIR gauging is truly an applications intensive business and although the concepts behind gauge design are not too difficult to understand, the complex process of development is not based on hard and fast rules. The combined applications experience of people within a supplier organisation will be used to evaluate measurement possibilities and minimise the risk to customer and supplier alike, of offering NIR for inappropriate applications. The ‘experience’ factor, both applications and product development, plays a big role for food manufacturers who want to drive NIR further into their processes. A trusting partnership between a customer and supplier pays dividends when new products and processes are so dependent on the successful implementation of on-line measurement and control solutions. This will not happen if on-line gauging becomes a commodity, where purchase price is the only factor considered. Maintenance and the installed base On-line NIR gauging is now widespread in many food manufacturing plants and over time it is not uncommon to consider upgrading to newer models that offer better features or a lower cost of ownership. Depending on the level of satisfaction with the current supplier, the number and type of installed units can play a role in the decision-making process. Where the existing choice creates a potential barrier to switching vendors there are several factors to be considered. The two main factors that influence such decisions are usually maintenance and operator training. Traditionally, ‘maintenance’ includes spares holdings and training needs to manage an effective preventative maintenance policy. This should be less of a factor nowadays since it is possible for users to operate gauges 24 hours a day for many years before any of the consumable items need replacing
180
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
and in most cases the vendor may well offer service plans that will take care of all servicing issues through the life of the gauge. In terms of operator training requirements, the really important aspects of using an online gauge are quite independent of the model in use. This section is dedicated to the practical aspects of on-line gauging and the advice given would be same for any make or model. Essentially the user needs to know only how to collect data and how to determine if a calibration change is valid. Conclusions Thorough comparative testing is characterised by an understanding of the factors that may influence the performance of the on-line gauge and the ability to isolate these parameters in order to measure their effect. Having established the true performance and the magnitude of the deviations from the ideal situation there are a number of more subjective characteristics that should be assessed before making a supplier choice. It is the authors’ belief that far too many purchase decisions are based on purchase price alone. Whilst purchase price is important, the overall cost of ownership must be taken into account when making such decisions and its influence on the outcome can be significant. 6.6.8 Digital connectivity Introduction For several years now, there has been a move in the process control industry to distribute the intelligence of control systems into plant, right down to sensor level. This has been coupled with significant advances and to some extent standardisation in the types of electronic interface between plant control systems and gauging equipment. Control systems have become more integrated and capable of greater levels of automation through the use of intelligent industrial communications. For instance, it is now very commonplace to have several gauges networked together, interfacing with the plant control system through a communications link. Given this, the plant control system can ensure that the correct calibration for the product is being applied by the gauge, can monitor the gauge output for control purposes and can check if the gauge is functioning correctly – all without manual intervention. This makes the traditional user interface virtually redundant along with its discrete outputs such 0 to 10V, 4–20mA and digital alarms. The different and increasingly diverging standards used in process control make the choices somewhat bewildering. Some attempts have been made by various organisations to introduce some kind of standardisation, notably the introduction of Worldfip Protocol Standard, although this has been adopted by only a small minority. The consequence of this is that the most popular communication standards in the process control industry are those made available from the control system vendors as part of their own products. The most popular being those from the largest vendors such as: • Siemens with Profibus • Allen Bradley with Devicenet • Modicon with Modbus Plus.
Recently there have been some moves away from this, mainly due to the advent of the Internet and the need to link management systems to the plant control systems. This has resulted in Ethernet TCP/IP being a common requirement driven by the user. To meet
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
181
these diverse requirements for communication interfaces, NDC Infrared Engineering have developed a number of optional plug-in gateways that enable a 710 gauging system through its own network, based on the Lonworks technology to be connected to a variety of other network systems. This gateway effectively converts one protocol (set of communication rules) into another. Communication protocol A communication protocol is a set of rules to enable data to be passed between devices/ equipment that are connected through a communications medium (i.e. twisted-pair cable). The protocols used in industrial control networks are optimised to pass small packets of data in a quick, secure and reliable manner and sometimes referred to as ‘Databus’. Note that many of these networks can be and are used to control the process right down to opening and closing of valves. Fully describing a communication protocol needs to covers many aspects, from the media itself (coax/twisted-pair/fibre optic) through to electrical signal levels, sharing the media, forming data from electrical signals, data format, routing the data to the intended device, error checking/correction, etc. right up to the application level. Ideally, the protocol should be fully described as per the OSI model that breaks the protocol down into a number of layers describing each aspect of the protocol in an ascending order, as shown in Fig. 6.23. Therefore to implement any communications system, each of these layers needs to be considered and provided for in one form or another with compatible interfaces between each. Some of the protocols already mentioned integrate a number of these levels into the single protocols that are published as open standards, but in the main they leave out the presentation and applications layers which need to be provided for elsewhere.
Fig. 6.23
OSI seven layer model.
182
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 6.24
Plant control network.
Networking applications Typically there are two main user applications for the networking interface of the on-line gauges. The first is where the on-line gauges are connected to the plant control network as described on pages 180–1 through a suitable gateway as shown in Fig. 6.24. Here the Siemens PLC (Programmable Logic Controller) will have either a built-in or a plug-in card that enables it to interface with devices that support the Profibus protocol. Siemens provide all the necessary programming tools that make it relatively easy for the PLC to interface with these devices. The second application is where the gauges are connected to an application running on a PC, again through a suitable gateway but with a DDE (Dynamic Data Exchange) server acting as a software interface, as shown in Fig. 6.25. This outline is shown with the NDC Series 7 DDE server and an external gateway, which converts the data from the PCs RS232 port into that conforming to the Lonworks protocol for the gauge. The DDE server simplifies the task of passing data to and from the gauges to a Windows-based application, provided the application supports DDE. Such applications include Microsoft Office tools such as Excel and industrial monitoring and control (SCADA) software such as Wonderware, FixDmacs, etc. Summary As more gauging is brought on line there will be a growing demand for the various databus interfaces on offer. There is no doubt that they offer advantages over conventional connectivity, but at this time they are not adopted as standard within food-processing environments. It is for this reason that most on-line gauging within the food industry still utilises the well-understood current loop as the means for connecting on-line gauging to the outside world.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
Fig. 6.25
6.7
183
DDE server.
Conclusions and the future
NIR measurement has been shown by examples in the foregoing text to be a very powerful technique for food analysis of both moisture and other constituents in a hugely diverse range of applications. Emphasis has been placed upon the way on-line NIR technology has evolved over the years in terms of how the technology is evolving to make its application simpler and the measurements more robust. It is shown how the technology in some instances has not met user expectations and how this has led to a lack of belief in the technique. The reasons for this are candidly discussed and hopefully readers will now be able to make an informed judgement and carefully select the right supplier and to remain open to the technology and what it can do for them. The main effort nowadays from leading NIR instrument manufacturers is to concentrate on making the supplied solution ever simpler to implement and to try to minimise the need for users to become involved in calibration work, a major weakness of the technique in the past. It is clear that users nowadays do not have time to devote to the niceties of checking on-line instruments and furthermore need as much assistance as possible about comparative checking methods and informative methods for decisionmaking about whether a calibration indeed needs correction or should be just left alone. This chapter has highlighted the sort of hardware and software products available to
184
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
achieve such goals and in particular offers solutions to overcome the nightmare of ‘calibration hunting’. The benefits of on-line measurement have been highlighted and in particular the information that can be gained about a process demonstrated with typical examples. It will be clear now that on-line measurement should be implemented wherever possible in favour of batch/historic off-line analysis because of the need for continuous real-time information about a process and the far more representative nature of the information about a batch of product that is gained. While moisture measurement has been the historically important NIR measurement, on-line examples in the text show how this is evolving and that other parameters can be successfully controlled and product quality improved by their measurement. The future for the application of on-line NIR technology looks very good with increasing opportunity for its application as the food industry becomes ever more concerned with accurate process control. Moisture is likely to remain the principal application for an on-line gauge because it has such obvious possibilities for control and has far-reaching impact upon on product quality, keeping characteristics, yield optimisation and process energy usage. However, other parameters such as oil or fat where their control can be affected are and will continue to become more important. In the days of increasing specification of packaged foods composition it is clear that to have traceability through on-line measurement is going to be ever more important. In the words of process personnel in one key international food manufacturer: ‘We are just waiting for our board to direct that product will be monitored routinely for its key constituents.’ For instrument manufacturers the need is to continue to strive to simplify the implementation of on-line measurement. While some significant steps towards this have been achieved by the authors’ company with instrument precalibration, there is still scope for even simpler implementation. The holy grail would have to be a moisture gauge which was able just to measure moisture without recalibration or configuration for whatever product was being measured! With advances in scattering theory and the continual improvements in microprocessors this may be attainable one day! Instrument technology continues to develop even in areas where it was previously thought that significant improvements could not be made. Alternative technologies for the wavelength generation and detection are continuously under investigation. Techniques such as AOTF and even the Michelson Interferometer, which can generate NIR full-spectrum information with good signal-to-noise ratios may become commercially viable and open up even greater capability on-line. Having said this it is contended by the authors that for a given constituent and the multi-wavelength nature of the modern filter gauge this is a difficult approach to beat due to its high speed and excellent signalto-noise performance. We shall see! New measurements will continue to evolve and it is hoped that this chapter has provided stimulus to its readers to consider NIR technology as at least a potential approach for a newly arising application. Finally, all things that were confined to laboratory NIR analysis should be viewed as contenders for on-line NIR measurement but preferably with the cautions described in the text being borne in mind. Remember the online gauge has to perform day in day out and without calibration drift for whatever reason so that it can be depended upon for control of a process. Provided this basic philosophy of measurement is remembered the technology has a great future and a strong contribution to make to the developing needs of food technologists and manufacturers worldwide.
Food compositional analysis using near infra-red absorption technology
6.8
185
References
(Sources for cheese production figures: ZMP, National Statistics; USDA; FAO; EUROSTAT. European Commission.) ANSCOMBE, F. J. (1973) ‘Graphs in Statistical Analysis,’ American Statistician, 27 Feb. 1973, 17–21. BANWELL, C. N. (1983) Molecular Spectroscopy (3rd edn), McGraw Hill. BENSON, I. B. (1989) ‘Industrial applications of NIR for the measurement of moisture’, Measurement & Control, 22, 45. BENSON, I. B., EDGAR, R. F. and FEDERLE, H. (1988) ‘On-line multi-component analysis of solid materials using NIR instruments’. In Process Optical Measurements, SPIE, Vol. 1012, 155–162. BIGGS, D. A. (1979) ‘Performance specifications for infra-red milk analysis’, Journal of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists, 62, 1211–1214. BRUTON, D. C. (1970) ‘Measurement of moisture and substance by infra-red radiation’, Measurement and Control, 3. COWE, I. A. and MCNICOL, W. H. (1985) ‘Principal component analysis’, Applied Spectroscopy, 39, 257. DAVIES, A. M. C. (1987) ‘Near infra-red spectroscopy: time for the giant to wake up’, European Spectroscopy News, 73. EDGAR, R. F. and HINDLE, P. H. (1971) ‘Infrared gauging’, Optics and Laser Technology, February, 5. GIESBRECHT, F. G., MCCLURE, W. F. and HAMID, A. (1981) ‘Fourier analysis of NIR spectra’, Applied Spectroscopy, 35, 210. HERZBERG, G. (1945) Infrared and Raman Spectra, D. Van Nostrand, New York. HINDLE, P. H. and SMITH, C. R. R. (1996) ‘A comparison of calibration robustness relating to different data treatments of a standard set of spectra’, J. NIR Spectroscopy, 4, 119– 28. HONIGS, D. E. (1985) ‘Near infra-red analysis’, Analytical Instrumentation, 14, (1), 1–62. HUNT, W. H., FUNK, D. W., ELDER, B. and NORRIS, K. H. (1977) ‘Collaborative study on infrared reflectance devices for determination of protein in hard red winter wheat and for protein and oil in soybeans’, Cereal Foods World, 22, 534–538. KAYE, W. (1954) ‘Spectral identification and analytical applications’, Spectrochimica Acta, 6, 257. KUBELKA, P. and MUNK, F. (1931) ‘Ein Beitrag zur Optik der Farbanstriche’ (A contribution to the optics of paints), Zeitschrift fu¨r Technische Physik, 12, 593. KUBELKA, P. (1948) ‘New contributions to the optics of intensely scattering materials’, Journal of the Optical Society of America, Part 1, 38, 448. MARK, H. (1986) ‘Qualitative NIR reflectance analysis using Mahalonobis distances’, Analytical Chemistry, 58, 379. MARTENS, M. and MARTENS, H. (1986) ‘NIR Reflectance determination of the sensory quality of peas’, Applied Spectroscopy, 40, 303. MCCALLUM, J. D. (1961) ‘Limitations and design philosophy in ultraviolet, visible and near-infra-red spectrophotometers’, Trans. New York Academy of Sciences, 24, 140– 157. MCCLOUD, H. A. (1986) Thin Film Optical Filters, 2nd edn, Adam Hilger. MCCLURE, W. F., HAMID, A., GIESBRECHT, F. G. and WEEKS, W. W. (1984) ‘Fourier analysis enhances NIR diffuse reflectance spectroscopy’, Applied Spectroscopy, 38, (3), 322. MILLER, W. C., HARE, G., STRAIN, D. C., GEORGE, K. P., STICKNEY, M. E. and BECKMAN, A. O.
186
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
(1949) ‘A new spectrophotometer employing a glass Fery prism’, Journal of the Optical Society of America, 39, 377–388. NORRIS, K. H. and HART, J. R. (1965) Principles and Methods of Measuring Moisture in Liquids and Solids, Vol 4, Reinhold, New York. NORRIS, K. and WILLIAMS, P. (1987) Near Infrared Technology in the Agricultural and Food Industries, American Association of Cereal Chemists Inc, St Paul, Minnesota, USA. OSBOURNE, B. G. and FEARN, T. (1986) Near Infrared Spectroscopy in Food Analysis, Longman Scientific and Technical, Harlow. STAR, C., MORGAN, A. G. and SMITH, D. B. (1981) ‘An evaluation of near infra-red reflectance analysis in some plant breeding programmes’, Journal of Agricultural Science, Camb., 97, 107–118. WILLIS, H. A. (1979) ‘Industrial plant applications of infra-red and Raman spectroscopy’, Advances in Infrared and Raman Spectroscopy, 2, 81–139.
7 Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry I. Ridley, Land Instruments International, Dronfield
7.1
Introduction
All objects emit electromagnetic radiation, the quantity of emitted energy and its distribution in wavelength are strong functions of temperature. The filament of a light bulb emits a great deal of radiation in the visible part of the spectrum. To achieve this emission of light, the temperature of the filament is typically raised to well over 2000ºC. A household heating radiator is normally operated at around 70ºC, but our skin can detect the heat from it even without touching. The energy we feel is infra-red radiation. Infra-red thermometers are devices that collect and detect infra-red radiation and deduce a temperature for the source. The inherent feature of infra-red thermometry is measurement at a distance – non-contact, non-invasive and non-contaminating. They are widely used throughout process industry, particularly where the measurement of a moving solid material, such as steel in a rolling mill or meat pies on a conveyor, is needed. Infra-red thermometers come in two fundamental forms, portable ‘hand held’ and installed ‘fixed on-line’ systems. The hand-held devices span from low cost ‘guns’, which measure a single spot, to highly advanced thermal cameras, capable of mapping the temperature of the target object. Installed ‘fixed systems’ also include both single-spot and imaging types, and in addition line-scanning types where a single spot is repeatedly scanned along a line over the surface of a moving object to produce profiles or once again a two-dimensional mapping. There is a misconception that infra-red thermometry is applicable only at high temperatures; in reality, with modern equipment, measurements below 0ºC are quite common. In many circumstances the measurement can be very accurate indeed. Fibreoptics cables can in some situations be used to help access products in hostile conditions and measurements inside closed vessels are possible with suitable infra-red transmitting windows. The use of infra-red technology within the food industry has so far been limited, the reasons usually cited are: • high costs when compared to traditional insertion probe equipment • a perceived need to measure core or centre temperatures • a lack of really suitable equipment available.
188
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
All three comments have some justification, but food technologists, like the metallurgists of the steel industry before them, will discover that a continuous measurement of surface temperature is much more useful for process control than an intermittent, manual, centre reading, and new instrument developments are improving the suitability situation. Certain developments within the food industry provide strong incentives for transition to infra-red methods. Specific examples are microwave heating, which has problems associated with the use of conventional thermometers, and the rapid increase in chilled prepared foods, with the associated need for rapid, non-contaminating temperature checks. More particularly, movement from batch production methods to continuous processing favours non-contact techniques which can provide continuous on-line temperature monitoring and control. There is little published on the practicalities of infra-red thermometry, particularly at lower temperatures. It is hoped that this chapter goes some way to filling that gap.
7.2
Radiation thermometers
A radiation thermometer (Fig. 7.1) comprises three essential elements: • an infra-red energy collection system • an infra-red detector and dedicated precision electronics • a display usually with some electronic signal processing.
Other topics in this section are housings and configurations, linescanning and thermal imaging cameras. 7.2.1 Collection The infra-red wavelengths of interest in radiation thermometry (1 to 15 m) are not so very much longer than the wavelengths of visible light (0.4 to 0.7 m). As a result, infrared thermometers look like optical instruments, rather than the plumbing or antennae of microwave or radio frequency equipment, and they operate according to simple laws of ray optics.
Fig. 7.1
Schematic diagram of an infra-red thermometer.
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
189
A well designed instrument collects radiation only from within a precisely defined field of view; Fig. 7.2 shows a typical example. In this example the field is axially symmetrical and necks down from 25 mm diameter at the lens of the thermometer to 10 mm at the best focus point, diverging thereafter. The object to be measured need not be at this best focus point, and a thermometer will measure any object which intersects this cone of vision. In the example shown, an object just 400 mm in front of the thermometer would need to be larger than the 19 mm diameter of the cone for reliable measurements. If the object to be measured does not completely fill the cone, then some radiation will be collected from other items behind the intended target, and the thermometer will measure a weighted average of all those objects in view. Thus, for a well-designed instrument the measurement is independent of object distance. In particular, the focus point has no significance to the user beyond being the point at which the target spot is at its smallest, in relation to distance. The measurement is also insensitive to obliquity of the target surface, typically for angles up to 50º off normal. We all know glass is transparent to visible light, so the use of a thermometer collecting energy near the visible spectrum to measure a glass object would be fruitless. In this case the instrument would look straight through the glass and measure whatever was behind the glass object. Fortunately, the vast majority of materials are highly opaque in the infrared part of the spectrum. The emitted energy originates only just beneath the target surface. Penetration depths are typically reckoned in micrometres and the temperature measured is, to all intents and purposes, a surface temperature. Many instruments have adjustable focus. Typically, the angular field of view is preserved, at least approximately, while the focus distance changes. For example, the instrument of Fig. 7.2 might be adjustable to a 5 mm target spot at a distance of 500 mm or a 30 mm spot at 3000 mm. Most instruments incorporate some form of aiming system to allow the user to identify the target being measured. Typically this takes two forms: • Visual sighting, in which a through-the-lens optical arrangement allows the user to view the target through an eyepiece. A circular graticule built into the eyepiece provides a visual definition of the actual target being measured. • Laser pointers, in which a low-power laser beam is projected from the thermometer onto the target surface. In some cases this is a single beam which simply illuminates the centre point of the target. More usefully, other designs have the laser beam scanned to draw a circular outline of the cone of view onto the target.
Fig. 7.2
Schematic diagram of thermometer field of view.
190
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Where access to the object to be measured is restricted the collection optics can be decoupled from the detector by a fibre optics light guide. This allows smaller optical systems, which are capable of withstanding more extreme environments. 7.2.2 Detectors The detector transduces the collected infra-red energy to an electrical signal. Typically, this signal is very small and the detector must be combined with precision electronics to achieve a more usable level. The detector usually incorporates a spectral filter that defines the range of infra-red wavelengths sensed by the thermometer. We shall see in the next section that the operating waveband has a critical influence on instrument accuracy and practical performance. Details of detector operation need not concern the instrument user, but some appreciation of the available types and their performance limitations is valuable. Table 7.1 lists the operating waveband and detector combinations most commonly used in industrial general-purpose thermometers, together with the target temperature ranges over which they are most useful. Note that the emitted radiation both increases rapidly and shifts to shorter wavelengths as temperature increases. An infra-red thermometer must inevitably view a target through the intervening atmosphere, so the infra-red transmission of this atmosphere must be considered. Many of the wavebands listed in Table 7.1, correspond to atmospheric transmission ‘windows’ (Fig. 7.3), i.e. regions of the infra-red spectrum where the atmosphere is highly transparent. Atmospheric absorption primarily derives from carbon dioxide and water vapour; symmetrical molecules (O2, N2, etc.) have no absorption bands in the infra-red region. A thermometer with a poorly chosen waveband will give readings that depend on target distance and also on humidity. The potentially very useful 3 to 5 m window is widely used in linescanners and thermal imagers (see Sections 7.2.5–7.2.6), and recent developments have seen the adoption of this waveband for spot thermometers with capability to measure down to 0ºC. The silicon photovoltaic diode is a superb detector of infra-red near 1 m wavelength. The detection mechanism is electron-hole pair generation by photons absorbed in a p–n junction. The signal current is linear with incident energy to better than 1 per cent over Table 7.1 Operating wavebands and detector types for commonly available infra-red thermometer types Operating waveband (m)
Detector types
Most useful range (ºC)
0.7 to 1.0
Silicon
400+
1 to 1.7
InGaAs Germanium
200+
1.8 to 2.5
InGaAs Lead Sulphide
50 to 600
3 to 5
Lead Selenide
0 to 500
8 to 14
Thermopile Pyroelectric
50 to 300
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
Fig. 7.3
191
Spectral transmission of the atmosphere: 300 m path length at sea level with 5.7 mm precipitable water at 26ºC (Wolfe and Zissis 1978).
four to five decades. With careful amplifier design, drift is negligible. The effective gain varies with ambient temperature, but in a predictable manner which can be accurately compensated. There are no significant ageing mechanisms and fast (microsecond) response times are achievable. Silicon’s usefulness is limited to target temperatures above about 400ºC; the amount of 1 m energy available for detection falls away very rapidly at lower temperatures. Efforts to squeeze lower temperature measurements by use of elaborate amplification schemes run into problems with reflected daylight. Germanium operates in a similar fashion to silicon, but has a smaller bandgap, allowing absorption of lower energy, longer wavelength photons. It has all of silicon’s attributes provided it is kept reasonably cool. Industrial germanium thermometers are typically specified to 50ºC ambient but, in practice, benefit from the use of a water cooling jacket. Germanium is useful for target temperatures above about 200ºC. Developments in semiconductor materials have yielded a new type of infra-red detector based on an alloy of indium, gallium and arsenic (InGaAs). These are again photovoltaic diodes with a bandgap slightly wider than germanium, yielding detection of photons at slightly shorter wavelengths. These detectors are somewhat more tolerant to high ambient temperatures than germanium and offer excellent linearity over many decades of signal range. Derivatives of these InGaAs detectors are now available where the bandgap has been stretched by introducing other materials to the alloy, producing sensitivity at wavelengths as long as 2.4 m. Lead sulphide is a photoconductor, the detection mechanism being photon-induced resistance change in the bulk semiconductor. It is very sensitive but unstable. It is a practical necessity to modulate the incoming infra-red radiation and amplify the resultant a.c. signal. Modulation is invariably accomplished with some form of mechanical chopper, introducing issues of instrument reliability and service life. The detector sensitivity is subject to ageing and hysteresis effects, so good handling practices are
192
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
required during assembly and calibration. Good thermometer designs incorporate lead sulphide only as a sensitive element and not as a calibrated device. Regrettably, many instruments have been marketed which ignore this principle; they exhibit serious calibration drifts and have a tendency to ‘remember’ past illumination. Lead sulphide is useful down to target temperatures of around 50ºC. With good design it is the basis of the most accurate thermometers at these temperatures. Lead selenide is another type of photoconductor and has very similar operating characteristics to the lead sulphide detector described above. The high sensitivity of lead selenide extends to a longer range of wavelengths allowing the minimum measured temperature to reach down to below 0ºC. Thermopiles and pyroelectrics are thermal detectors whose sensitivity extends over all wavelengths. In general, the sensitivity of thermal detectors is significantly lower than that of the photon detectors described above. Thermopiles are easy to use and form the basis of a wide variety of simple and generally trouble-free thermometers. The response times are typically limited to about 50 ms. Pyroelectric detectors are somewhat more sensitive and faster (a few milliseconds) but a chopped radiation input is fundamental to the detection mechanism. Pyroelectrics are common in portable (i.e. intermittent use) thermometers, but the absence of moving parts is a powerful argument in favour of thermopiles for continuously used installed systems. Used with an 8 to 14 m filter, thermal detectors allow measurement down to room temperature and below. 7.2.3 Processing electronics The signals generated by the detectors are both non-linearly related to temperature and subject to the influence of target emissivity. The prime function of any processing electronics is to generate a temperature value by performing an algorithm of the general form: T f
; Ti ; S Where the inputs , Ti, S are, respectively, a user-set ‘emissivity’ factor, the thermometer internal temperature, and the detector signal. The target temperature T is typically output as an analogue signal (e.g. 4 to 20 mA) plus a digitally displayed value. The fast response of most infra-red thermometers allows the measurement of fleetingly brief intermittent events, such a objects falling through the view of the thermometer. The second major function of the processing electronics is to extract usable control parameters from the raw measured values, using real-time signal processing. Microprocessor-based electronics conventionally take the form of a panel-mounted unit, remote from the sensor, with digital temperature display and user keypad. These units are very flexible, and many processing functions may be available beyond the basic derivation and display of target temperature. For example, the user may be able to select peak or valley picking of the output signal with adjustable decay times; sample/hold actuated by an external trigger signal; high/low alarm activation with adjustable limits; on/off, PID (proportional integral differential) or more complex forms of control with adjustable set-point and other parameters. The microprocessors range from 8 to 32 bit single-chip microcomputers with the program stored in EPROM and keypad set parameters stored in NOVRAM. A very high level of noise immunity is an essential feature for industrial use, particularly in heavy plant, requiring careful attention to both hardware design and software self-checking.
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
193
Analogue processors continue to play an important role and there are good reasons for this in terms of both performance, and cost-effectiveness. Digital processors are often more expensive, power hungry, and too slow for some applications. It should be noted that, at short wavelengths, analogue to digital conversions with dynamic ranges equivalent to 20+ bits, are typically needed to accommodate the extreme non-linear radiance/temperature relation. The best of the analogue systems display elegance bordering on genius and accommodate, with just a few components, enormous dynamic ranges in radiance with response times down to a few microseconds, or power requirements down to a few hundred microwatts. Virtually drift-free performance is achievable with good design. Analogue processing has retained a firm place for ‘in sensor’ processing. However, it cannot match microprocessors for the ever increasing need for flexibility and today digital processing is more frequently found embedded within the sensor. 7.2.4 Housings and configurations As stated earlier, infra-red thermometers come in two basic forms: • portable ‘hand held’ devices including low cost ‘guns’, high-quality thermometers with ‘through the lens’ sighting and thermal imagers, capable of temperature mapping of the target object. • installed ‘fixed systems’ also including single spot and imaging types, and in addition linescanning types.
Figure 7.4 shows a high-specification, portable radiation thermometer (Cyclops 33). This instrument covers the range 50 to +1000ºC. It has an 8 to 14 m operating waveband and uses a pyroelectric detector. The optics define a one degree field of view, with focus adjustable from 750 mm to infinity. Through the lens visual sighting is included. The measured temperature is displayed in the viewfinder and is also available as a digital output. Power is from a single PP3 9V battery. A host of accessories are available, including a data logger, printer and D/A converter. The instrument shown is one of a range offering various temperature spans and operating wavelengths within similar mechanical configurations. This range actually derives from a manufacturing agreement between a company specialising in infra-red thermometry (Land) and a household-name camera manufacturer (Minolta). The success of this arrangement has, in recent years, spawned several such collaborations and
Fig. 7.4
High-specification portable radiation thermometer Cyclops 33. (Courtesy of Land Infrared Ltd).
194
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 7.5
Low cost portable infra-red thermometers.
something of a revolution in the cost and quality of portable radiation thermometers. Figure 7.5 shows low-cost portable instruments (Mini Laser and Mini View) which are attracting interest in the food industry. They offer many of the features of the first instrument at a fraction of the cost. Fixed instruments can be broadly divided into stand-alone and thermometer plus processor configurations. Figure 7.6 shows a family of thermometers and processors that can be combined to give the functions and features needed. The optical collection, detector and associated amplification are housed in a precision die-cast metal body which is connected, via a cable, to a remote processor and display unit. The sensors shown include a normal (focusable) optical type with through the lens sighting and a fibre optics version. These are both from the same family (System 4) which includes various wavebands and temperature spans in a common format. These sensors may be connected without any re-calibration to any one of a family of processors offering different levels of features and performance. For example, one model (LMG) provides graphical display of temperature to show trends and variances. Figure 7.7 shows a stand-alone thermometer (SOLO 3). Here the collection, detection and processing are all contained within a single housing. The instrument shown is an 8 to 14 m thermopile type measuring 0 to 250ºC. Again it is one of a range. Stand-alone instruments are typically available in ‘two-wire’ and ‘four-wire’ configurations. In fourwire types there are separate connections for power-input and for signal output. In the
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
Fig. 7.6
195
Family of interchangeable sensors and processors.
increasingly popular two-wire loop arrangement there are just two connections and the signal current is superimposed on the current drawn from the power supply. Usually it is arranged for the loop current to be 4 mA at the bottom of the measurement range and 20 mA at the top, with linear interpolation in between. Clearly, the whole of the thermometer’s internal electronics must operate on less than 4 mA, and this results in performance limitations.
Fig. 7.7 Stand-alone bolt-on infra-red thermometer SOLO 3. (Courtesy of Land Infrared Ltd).
196
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
For special applications, infra-red thermometers can be built in a multitude of shapes and sizes. For example, Fig. 7.8 shows a developmental miniature unit for use in commercial microwave ovens. An essential part of any range of infra-red thermometers is a selection of mounting fixtures, water and air cooling jackets, and air purge attachments. The latter in particular have reached an advanced state of development and are capable of maintaining clean thermometer optics over very extended periods, even under the most appalling conditions in heavy industrial plants.
Fig. 7.8 Developmental miniature infra-red thermometer for microwave ovens, and same fitted to oven ceiling: the spigot allows purge air derived from the oven fan to enter the probe. (Courtesy of Land Infrared Ltd).
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
Fig. 7.9
197
Linescanning thermometer.
7.2.5 Linescanning thermometers A linescanning thermometer measures a temperature profile across the target’s surface. It is essentially an infra-red thermometer, whose field of view is scanned, in one dimension, by some rotating mirror arrangement, see Fig. 7.9. So far, few applications have called for a hand-held version and those available have very limited spatial resolution. Typically a scanner is used to produce a two-dimensional map of a continuous stream of product in sheet form, such as hot rolled steel sheet or extruded pastry on a conveyor. With scan repetition rates of up to one hundred lines per second and up to one thousand measured samples per scan line, large amounts of data are generated and in most cases the output signal is processed by a computer to produce a temperature/position trace. Highly elaborate data processing schemes are available, for example, allowing detection of differences between a stored ‘ideal’ profile and the live data from the scanner, or the determination of temperature time trends at prescribed positions across the scanned target. Line scans measuring down to room temperature operate at 3 to 5 m using thermoelectrically cooled photoconductors – lead selenide or mercury cadmium telluride. A typical specification might be 10 scans per second with a spatial resolution of onehundredth of the separation of the instrument from the target. In terms of accuracy of temperature measurement, exactly the same factors apply as for a single-spot thermometer. 7.2.6 Thermal imaging cameras In a thermal imager the field of view is scanned in a two-dimensional raster and each point in the image plane is handled in the same way as a thermometer target point. Image data is generated with the temperature of each point indicated on a density (grey) scale or
198
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 7.10
Thermal imager for fixed installation.
false colour temperature contour map. Modern industrial thermal imagers operate at 3 to 5 m using thermoelectrically cooled mercury cadmium telluride. Good quality (200+ lines) images are generated at twenty frames per second with minimum resolvable temperature difference a tenth of a degree Celsius. Integration of successive frames allows temperature differences below 0.1ºC to be resolved. Devices used in research and medicine and by the military achieve superior performance using detectors cooled with liquid nitrogen; both 3 to 5 m and 8 to 14 m wavebands are used. Thermal imaging cameras are most commonly found in portable, hand-held forms, with the image data viewed directly by the user. Initially developed as military search tools, these devices have primarily found applications in maintenance and inspection roles, where hand-held or portable devices have been ideal. Recently, several applications have required the permanent installation of thermal imaging cameras linked to powerful image processing software, to provide continuous monitoring of things as diverse a bulk coal storage, or combustion chamber safety monitoring. Instruments specifically designed for continuous on-line use are now available (see Fig. 7.10). Historically, thermal imager development has focused on spatial and temperature resolution, to the detriment of the absolute radiance calibration, which is a prerequisite for accurate temperature measurement. However, recent devices claim temperature accuracy comparable with that of single-spot thermometers of similar operating wavebands.
7.3
Measurement principles
An infra-red thermometer directly measures infra-red energy, specifically the radiance of the target. From this radiance measurement a target temperature is deduced, using a model, based on device characteristics, linking temperature and radiance. Formulation of a satisfactory model can be trivial or practically impossible, dependent on often quite
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
199
subtle aspects of the measurement situation. Herein lies much of the fascination of infrared thermometry and the source of its reputation as something of a black art. One should recognise that the need for an interpretative model is not unique to infrared techniques. Consider a mercury-in-glass thermometer: if the ‘target’ is a stirred liquid then there is little problem in interpreting the measured height of the mercury column in relation to the liquid temperature. However, if the bulb is merely pressed against the outside of a plastic bottle of indifferent conductivity, perhaps in a draught and with some incident radiation, then concluding what, if anything, the thermometer is telling us about the bottle temperature less still the liquid inside, is far from simple. The essence of contact thermometry is thermalisation; the allowance that the sensor must reach the same temperature as the object to be measured. For infra-red thermometry the black body radiator is the equivalent. One can view a ‘black’ target as exhibiting perfect radiative coupling to the thermometer; the thermometer signal is then determined solely by target temperature. Real-world non-black body targets exhibit imperfect coupling and the thermometer couples partly to the target and partly to the surroundings. In this latter case, unravelling the target temperature from the thermometer signal requires some knowledge of the coupling factor (emissivity) and background radiance (conveniently expressed as a mean background temperature). 7.3.1 The Planck function and black bodies The basic law for thermal radiation was derived by the eminent physicist Max Planck, whose equation relating emitted radiance of a black body to wavelength and temperature, known universally as the Planck equation, is given below. JT C1 5 fexp
C2 =T
1g
1
1
Figure 7.11 shows this function evaluated over a range of wavelengths and temperatures. It can clearly be seen that both the quantity and spectral distribution of the energy vary markedly with temperature. An infra-red thermometer viewing a black body target receives radiant energy L and produces a proportional detector signal, S: S / L f
T
2
where the calibration function f(T) is the Planck equation integrated over the thermometer operating waveband: Z 2 f
T JT S d
3 1
If, for simplicity, we consider a thermometer with a narrow waveband at wavelength , then: L C1 5 fexp
C2 =T
1g 1
4
where C1 1.191 10 16 and C2 1.438 10 2 in SI units, and T is in Kelvin. The inherent sensitivity of any instrument is the rate of change of the measured parameter, in this case radiance L, with respect to the intended measured variable, here temperature, T. For infra-red thermometers this is often expressed as fractional change thus:
200
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 7.11
Spectral distribution of infra-red energy.
L 1 exp
C2 =T 2 T L
5
Table 7.2 gives f(T) evaluated for narrow band thermometers operating at various wavelengths together with inherent sensitivity, expressed in per cent change in radiance L required to produce a one degree change in indicated target temperature. For any given temperature this per cent per degree (%/ºC) indicates much higher inherent sensitivity at shorter wavelengths. 7.3.2 Non-black targets and emissivity The Planck function describes the emission from an idealised perfect surface, known as a black body. Laboratory targets are readily constructed which are almost perfectly black. Real objects to be measured emit only a fraction of that from a black body at the same temperature, and this fraction, known as emissivity, is commonly represented by the Greek letter . Emissivity can theoretically vary between unity for black body emitters and zero for perfect reflectors. Many common materials – for example, anything containing enough water – are very close to black. Others, like aluminium, are very far from black, emitting only some 5 per cent of the energy of a black body. Care should be taken over the interpretation of the word black, as the colour of an object as seen by our eyes in the visible part of the spectrum often has little bearing on its emissivity in the infra-red. For a non-black target, equation (2) becomes: S / L f
T
1
f
T
6
where the first term represents emission from the target and the second represents radiation originating in the surroundings and reflecting off the target spot into the thermometer, is the emissivity factor. T is an effective background temperature, a formalism for describing a potentially very complex reflection situation. To resolve equation (5) it is necessary to ascribe values to and T.
Table 7.2
Calibration function f (T ) in arbitary units and rate of change of F (T ) for varous narrow-band thermometers.
Target temperature (ºC)
f(T)
-20 0 20 40 60 80 100 150 200 300 400 500 600 800 1000
– – – – – – – 6.65E-03 – 1.48E-03 6.18E-02 9.82E-01 8.28E-00 1.79E+02 1.47E+03
1 m
1.6 m
%/ºC
f(T)
– – – – – – – 5.1 – 4.5 3.2 2.4 1.9 1.3 0.9
– – – – – – – 4.46E-01 6.29E-02 1.74E-00 1.79E+01 1.01E+02 3.82E+02 2.60E+03 9.72E+03
2.2 m
%/ºC
f(T)
– – – – – – – 3.7 4.1 2.8 2.0 1.5 1.2 0.8 0.6
– – – 1.95E-03 6.83E-03 2.08E-02 5.61E-02 2.36E+01 2.29E-00 2.55E+01 1.39E+02 4.89E+02 1.29E+03 – –
4 m
%/ºC
f(T)
– – – 6.9 6.1 5.4 4.8 2.0 3.0 2.0 1.5 1.1 0.9 – –
– 2.21E-01 5.42E-01 1.19E-00 2.37E-00 4.37E-00 7.54E-00 4.11E+01 5.80E+01 2.19E+02 5.58E+02 1.12E+03 – – –
10 m
%/ºC
f(T)
%/ºC
– 4.9 4.3 3.7 3.3 2.9 2.6 0.8 1.6 1.1 0.8 0.6 – – –
4.05E+00 6.16E+00 8.84E+00 1.21E+01 1.60E+01 2.06E+01 2.57E+01
2.3 2.0 1.7 1.5 1.3 1.2 1.1
5.97E+01 1.05E+02 – – – – –
0.7 0.5 – – – – –
202
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Most thermometers incorporate a means to input an emissivity value based on prior knowledge. Emissivity is primarily a function of target material and surface condition, but also depends on wavelength and, to a small extent, on temperature. In high-accuracy thermometry it must be regarded as an empirically determined parameter and most reputable suppliers of infra-red thermometers offer emissivity determination as a service at modest cost. Given the repetitive nature of modern manufacturing processes and the (usual) emphasis of measurement repeatability over absolute accuracy, it is the effect of fluctuations in emissivity that need to be carefully assessed. Various tabulations of emissivity values exist, but need to be treated with great care. Sometimes the values quoted are wide-band, i.e. integrated over all wavelengths, appropriate to heat transfer calculations but useless for thermometry. Sometimes values relate to laboratory-pure specimens which bear little resemblance to target surfaces found in the real world. Some generic examples appropriate to a wavelength of 10m and low temperatures are as follows. Water is extremely black near 10m, and anything with a wet surface film – slurries, pastes, flesh – may be expected to have an emissivity approaching 0.99. Many fat-based products – e.g. chocolate – have high emissivities of about 0.85. A vast number of organic or fibrous materials have emissivities of around 0.8. Most paints, varnishes, etc. have an emissivity of about 0.8, irrespective of visible coloration. Opaque plastics typically have an emissivity of 0.96; rubber 0.9; glass 0.85; wood 0.85; asbestos 0.9; most building materials, i.e. brick, cement etc., 0.7–0.9; paper and cardboard 0.8–0.95; cloth 0.75. Black oxidised metals typically have high stable emissivities, e.g. steel 0.85, copper 0.8, brass 0.7. Carbon, soot, etc. typically have an emissivity of 0.85–0.95. There is a somewhat fallible rule of thumb that anything that is dirty enough has an emissivity of 0.8. By far the most difficult target materials are clean, bright metals. Here emissivities are very low (0.1) and may vary wildly with small amounts of surface oxidation. Highaccuracy thermometry on bright metals is always demanding. In many situations the measurement is rendered insensitive to moderate errors in emissivity setting by the choice of the shortest possible operating wavelength. For any given uncertainty in emissivity setting, the resulting uncertainty in temperature measurement is set by the inherent sensitivity of the thermometer. Table 7.2 shows this expressed in per cent change in radiance L required to produce a one degree change in indicated target temperature; the higher values at shorter wavelength clearly indicate lower errors for any given emissivity error or uncertainty. 7.3.3 Background temperature When higher temperatures are being measured, and the effective background is much cooler than the target temperature, then the background radiance is very much lower, and the second term in equation (6) approaches zero and is frequently ignored. When measurements are made of lower temperatures, the effective background radiance is often significant in comparison with the target radiance. In this case both terms in equation (6) must be evaluated. Some thermometers allow a background temperature value T to be ‘dialled’ in, but a more common practice is for T to be taken equal to the internal temperature of the thermometer. A number of thermometer systems allow T to be input on-line from an auxiliary sensor such as a thermocouple. A special case exists when the surrounding temperature is very close to that of the target, and a different approach can be taken, for when T T equation (6) reduces to:
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry L f
1
gf
T f
T
203
7
i.e., the black body condition is recovered. If the thermometer emissivity control is now set to unity, a correct temperature reading is obtained irrespective of the actual emissivity or of the background temperature adopted. Techniques exist to stimulate artificially this ‘isothermal cavity’ condition (see Section 7.5.1).
7.4
Practical situations
When applying infra-red thermometers the following issues must always be considered: • Access to the target – can a clear view be obtained? Is the target in a controlled atmosphere? How big is the target? Is there any possibility of interference in the sight path, for example by smoke or steam? • Uncertainties in the emissivity of the target – is the emissivity known? Is it high? How variable might it be? • Contributions from the background surrounding the target – is the background hotter than the target? Is it similar to the target? Is it much colder than the target? How much does it vary?
To put the somewhat abstract discussion above into a practical context we consider three examples. 7.4.1 Hot targets in a cold background Firstly, we consider a warm target in a background at a lower temperature, for example a food product having emerged from a cooking process. An example would be loaves of bread being air cooled on a conveyor (Fig. 7.12), where they must be below, say, 100ºC before entering a packaging machine. In this case access to the target is open and a thermometer can simply be placed above and to the side of the conveyor to obtain a clear view and avoid the hot air rising from the bread. At a distance of, say, 1.5 m from the bread a thermometer with a cone of vision as shown in Fig. 7.2 would measure a spot of 27.5 mm diameter, easily accommodated on a loaf of bread. The background is the room walls and ceiling and both are likely to be much cooler than the loaves. A thermometer should reach approximately the same temperature as the room. Typical emissivity values for bread are not known to the author, but thought likely to be high at >0.8. Table 7.3 gives measurement errors as a function of target emissivity and various background temperatures for two thermometer operating wavelengths. The centre column applies when the emissivity ‘control’ is correctly set; adjacent columns apply to ±0.03 mis-settings. The calculations are based on a monochromatic thermometer at 20ºC which adopts its own temperature as the background temperature; they give a good indication of the errors expected from commercial lead sulphide (2.2 m) and thermopile or pyroelectric (10 m) instruments. The advantage of short wavelength operation is very apparent. 7.4.2 Hot targets in a hot background Secondly, we consider a hot target in a background at a similar high temperature, for example a food product nearing the end of a cooking process. An example would be loaves
204
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 7.12
Thermometer viewing bread on exit from oven.
of bread during baking inside an oven, where they must reach say 180ºC before leaving the oven (see Fig. 7.13). Here, access to the target is limited and a hole, possibly covered with a suitable infra-red window, will have to be provided in the oven wall in order to obtain a view of the target. At a distance of, say, 0.8 m from the bread a thermometer with a cone of vision as shown in Fig. 7.2 would measure a spot of 13 mm diameter, again easily accommodated on most loaves. The background is now the inside of the oven walls and likely to be similar to that of the loaves. In this case the thermometer, outside the oven, will be much cooler then the background surrounding the target. Table 7.3 Measurement errors (Kelvin) for 100ºC target as a function of errors in set emissivity and assumed background temperature, for a true emissivity of 0.8. Operating wavelength (m)
2.2
10
Error in background temperature (ºC)
Emissivity 0.77
0.8
0.83
0 10 20 30 40 50
0.77 0.78 0.81 0.86 0.95 1.12
0.04 0.02 0 0.05 0.14 0.31
0.81 0.8 0.77 0.73 0.64 0.47
0 10 20 30 40 50
0.15 1.06 2.4 3.9 5.5 7.2
2.5 1.3 0 1.4 3 4.7
4.7 3.5 2.3 0.85 0.68 2.3
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
205
Fig. 7.13 Thermometer viewing bread inside oven.
In this near isothermal case the reflected energy is from objects at the same temperature as the target and the black body conditions are recreated as shown in equation (6). Table 7.4 gives measurement errors as a function of actual target emissivity and mismatch between background and target temperatures, for two thermometer operating wavelengths. The calculations are based on a monochromatic thermometer with its emissivity control set to 1; they give a good indication of the errors expected from commercial lead sulphide (2.2 m) and thermopile or pyroelectric (10 m) instruments. The advantages of operation at the shorter, 2.2 m, wavelength are more marginal. Considering emissivity effects, the measurement is independent of emissivity when the background and the target are exactly the same. As the background temperature falls below that of the target, then the shorter wavelength thermometer has smaller errors. When the background temperature rises above the target then the longer wavelength thermometer has the smaller errors. 7.4.3 Warm targets in a hot background Lastly, we consider a warm target in a background at a higher temperature, for example a food product starting a cooking process. Continuing the bakery theme the example would be
206
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 7.4 Measurement errors (Kelvin) for 180ºC target in near isothermal conditions as a function of background temperature and target emissivity, assuming a set emissivity of 1 Operating wavelength (m)
Background temperature (ºC) 0.9
Emissivity 0.8
0.7
2.2
150 160 170 180 190 200 210
2.1 1.6 0.9 0 1.1 2.6 4.3
4.3 3.2 1.8 0 2.2 4.9 8.1
6.6 4.9 2.7 0 3.3 7.2 11.6
10
150 160 170 180 190 200 210
2.9 1.9 1 0 1 2.1 3.1
5.8 3.9 2 0 2 4.1 6.2
8.7 5.9 3 0 3 6.1 9.3
of bread dough having just entered the oven; in this case measurement may be required to prevent overheating during the early part of the bake. Again, access to the target is limited and the installation arrangement would be similar to that shown in Fig. 7.14. In this case the humidity in the oven is likely to be high and the operating wavelength should be chosen to avoid the absorption effects of the water vapour in the sight path of the thermometer. The background is again the inside walls of the oven, which at, say, 100ºC are warmer than the bread dough at, say, 60ºC. Once again, the thermometer, outside the oven, will be much cooler then the background surrounding the target. In this case the reflected energy is from objects hotter than the target and the second term in equation (5) for the reflected radiance can be larger than that emitted from the dough. One solution for this situation is a measurement system that takes both the thermometer signal and the background temperature from, for example, a roof thermocouple, and calculates and applies a correction for the background radiation. This interpretative model assumes that the thermocouple is so positioned as to truly represent the mean background temperature (T) of the surroundings. When, as is likely in the oven, the wall and roof will be at the same temperature this positioning is trivial. However, when temperature gradients are present great care may be needed to position the thermocouple correctly. Table 7.5 gives measurement errors as a function of emissivity and errors in measured background temperature for two thermometer operating wavelengths. Calculations are done for a true emissivity of 0.8 and the centre column applies when the emissivity ‘control’ is correctly set; adjacent columns apply to ±0.03 mis-settings. The calculations are again based on a monochromatic thermometer which is using a secondary input as the background temperature. The advantage of operation at the longer, 10 m, wavelength is very apparent. Considering emissivity effects, uncertainty of between 0.77 and 0.83 result in only ±1.8ºC errors with the correct background, compared with +4, 5.5ºC for a 2.2 m thermometer. Considering errors in the mean background value, we again see a significant benefit for the longer wavelength with less than ±4ºC error, as compared with possible out-of-range readings for a 2.2 m thermometer. These background correcting
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
Fig. 7.14
207
Thermometer viewing dough inside oven.
Table 7.5 Measurement errors (kelvin) for 60ºC target in a 100ºC background as a function of errors in measured background temperature and set emissivity, for true 0:8 Operating wavelength (m)
Error in background temperature (ºC)
2.2
10 5 2 0 2 5 10
10
10 5 2 0 2 5 10
Emissivity 0.77 8.8 3.7 1 5.5 12 38 unresolved 1.9 0.1 1 1.8 2.6 3.8 5.9
0.8 10.1 6.2 2.9 0 3.8 12.5 unresolved 3.1 1.6 0.6 0 0.7 1.6 3.4
0.83 11.3 8.4 6 4 1.6 3.3 20 4.2 2.9 2.2 1.7 1.1 0.3 1
208
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 7.15
Thermometer viewing dough through water-cooled sight tube.
systems can provide good temperature measurements when applied and installed with care, and have yielded very significant fuel savings in large furnaces. Note: Two values for the 2.2 m thermometer are marked unresolved, this is caused by the higher than true background measurement producing an overestimation of the correction, so that when it is applied (subtracted) the actual radiance is completely swamped giving an indication below 0K. A second solution is artificially to create a cooler background by installing a cooled shield near the measurement point as indicated in Fig. 7.15, thereby re-creating the cold background model discussed in Section 7.4.1. The approach has been widely and successfully used in situations where continuous strip or sheet materials are being processed.
7.5
Miscellaneous techniques
In this section we look firstly at simple means of enhancing emissivity, then at some techniques which avoid the need to know emissivity in specific conditions, and finally at ways of measuring inaccessible targets.
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
209
7.5.1 Enhancing emissivity A simple way to improve the emissivity of, say, a bright metal target is to paint it. Paint with high (~0.9) stable emissivities are available, permitting accurate temperature measurement in virtually any background conditions. Another, though somewhat restricted, approach is to create an isothermal cavity within the body to be measured, for example by drilling a hole. A hole six times deeper than its diameter, will produce an effective emissivity close to unity, especially if the walls are roughened and the bottom is conical rather than square to the axis. Cracks, grooves or existing cavities on the target surface can also achieve similar effects. These can be particularly useful in measuring products on a conveyor belt, when a small target spot is used and the very fast responding thermometer output signal is peak picked to measure the high radiance values from these high emissivity features. The effect of the isothermal cavity can be simulated by surrounding the target spot with a high reflectance enclosure, the background now becomes a reflection of the target and appears to be at the target temperature thereby re-creating the black body conditions of equation (6). The first product to use this technique was designed in the 1950s and comprised a gold (highly reflective in the infra-red) plated hemisphere with a small hole through which the measurement is made. The ‘gold cup’ was placed within the periphery of the hemisphere on the target surface and temperature measurements virtually independent of the surface emissivity were possible. The exclusion of background radiation also simplified the mathematical model used for interpretation of results. This highly successful product lasted many years but in requiring surface contact, it lost the inherent non-contact feature of infra-red thermometry, and made it ever more unsuitable for modern continuous processes. Several similar approaches have been used where the reflector is fixed close to a moving target to form a wedge-shaped cavity with the target surface. One creative approach for strip or sheet products is to use the naturally occurring wedges formed where target material spools off a shiny reflective roller. This has been proven to provide very reliable measurements even when target emissivity is quite low. An interesting variation is created by allowing the reflector temperature to be close to the target, in this case the precise reflectance value of the reflector becomes non-critical as isothermal conditions are recreated. Recently, the spherical geometry of the gold cup has been reviewed with the aim of removing the requirement to contact the surface, and new designs allow clearance gaps of approximately half the reflector diameter whilst maintaining high degrees of emissivity enhancement on many low-emissivity target surfaces. 7.5.2 Avoiding the need to know emissivity The Holy Grail of infra-red thermometry will always be a truly emissivity independent measurement technique. Over the 50+ years since the first practical infra-red thermometers were built, a number of techniques have been used which claim to have found this Holy Grail. In truth they avoid the need for known emissivity only at the expense of some other assumption about the target surface. They have value, but tend to work only in very specific conditions. Unfortunately, the general image of infra-red thermometry has been tarnished by overly aggressive marketing of some of the following methods. A definitive instance is ratio (two-colour) thermometry. Here radiance is sensed in two separate wavebands and a signal is derived which is proportional to the ratio of the
210
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
respective energies. The argument is that, while the energy in each waveband depends on emissivity, this cancels out the ratio, rendering the ratio signal a function only of temperature. This is true only for a grey target, whose emissivity is independent of wavelength. In general the ratio signal depends on the ratio of the respective emissivities in the two wavebands. Moreover, a ratio thermometer is typically several times more sensitive to a mis-setting of emissivity ratio than is a conventional thermometer to a missetting of emissivity. Ratio thermometers are actually more useful for coping with a partially obstructed or unfilled field of view, the ratio signal being unaffected as long as attenuation is identical in both wavebands. Certain two-colour thermometers derive calibrated radiances in two wavebands in addition to the ratio. This additional information can, in certain very specific circumstances, be used to deduce emissivity on-line. A variety of reflection methods exist which derive emissivity on-line. Looking back to equation (5), if the background temperature T can be oscillated between two known values then the value for 1 and hence emissivity can be deduced from the a.c. ripple on the thermometer signal. This is practicable only for highly specular targets, where a reasonably small variable temperature source at the specular angle suffices. If the background source is varied slowly and a polarising filter is rotated rapidly in front of the thermometer, an a.c. ripple is produced (due to variation of emissivity with polarisation) which falls to zero when the background temperature equals the target temperature. Simultaneous monitoring of background source temperature and thermometer output ripple thus permits an emissivity-free measurement. The requirement for high specularity is eased if one can assume that non-specular reflection is unpolarised. Recently, thermometers have been promoted which incorporate a laser reflectometer. A laser beam illuminates the target, and the fraction of beam power reflected back into the instrument is monitored. If this can be related to the total beam power reflected – i.e. over all angles – then emissivity is derivable from the relationship: emissivity equals one minus total reflectance. Clearly this entails a model relating reflectance into the solid angle subtended by the instrument’s collecting aperture to total (i.e. 2 solid angle) reflectance – a point not overemphasised by some vendors of the equipment. In practice the assumption made is pure diffuse reflection. The scope of validity of this assumption is not yet well documented. A two-wavelength version allows the emissivity ratio to be derived given only that the collected to total reflectance ratio is the same at both wavelengths. 7.5.3 Inaccessible targets As discussed earlier, the measurement of targets whilst in the middle of processes is often required in order to provide the best parameters for control of the process. If the product is a liquid flowing in a pipe, then measurement by thermocouple fitted through the tube wall, can give accurate steady state data. However, it may take several seconds for the protective sheath and hence the sensor within to respond to process changes. As soon at the product is a solid or individual product item then non-contact infra-red thermometry is needed. To allow the instrument to access the target within the process, infra-red transmitting windows may be used to provide a viewing port to the product. With suitable materials and design, very high pressures (~200 atmospheres) can be contained by these windows, even permitting measurements in extruders. The majority of window materials conventionally used are of doubtful applicability in food processes on grounds of toxicity, solubility or propensity to shatter into sharp
Practical aspects of infra-red remote thermometry
211
fragments. Probably the most suitable material, by a considerable margin, is synthetic sapphire (single-crystal alumina). The relevant properties of sapphire are given in Table 7.5. It is a relatively inexpensive material in window diameters up to 25 mm or so. Fixture is generally via a suitable gasket or O-ring, but sapphire can also be brazed to Nilo or titanium. Sapphire is highly transparent from the visible out to wavelengths of about 5m, restricting its use as a window to shorter wavelength thermometer types. Windowing the longer wavelength, 8 to 14 m, types is much more problematical. Recent developments have allowed the measurement of temperatures below freezing point with 3 to 5 m thermometers, thereby extending the range of processes measurable through a sapphire window, see Table 7.1 for the corresponding temperature ranges. The usual materials – germanium, zinc sulphide, barium fluoride – are very doubtful for the reasons given above. Polyethylene transmits reasonably well, but only in thin films (0.1 mm). Targets that are inaccessible due to high ambient temperature, vibration or radio frequency (RF) fields, can sometimes be measured using fibre optics. The infra-red collection assembly is separated from the detector unit with a flexible optic fibres. This allows the sensitive detector unit to be fixed in a benign environment. Collection assemblies can be built very tough, for example to withstand ambient temperatures over 400ºC. Figure 7.6 on page 195 shows a typical instrument. The use of fibre optics, with commonly available glass and silica fibre, is limited to moderately short wavelength thermometers, owing to the transmission characteristics of the fibre. Once again recent
Fig. 7.16
Vanguard thermometer for chilled packaged foods.
212
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
developments have allowed measurements as low as 50ºC with a 2.2m instrument using quartz fibre bundles. Typically, fibre lengths of a few metres are supplied, but much longer lengths are technically possible. A product combining several of these features has recently been developed to measure the temperature of finished food items within their packaging (Fig. 7.16), without destroying the product. This uses a gold cup type reflector to minimise the effects of package emissivity variations. It still measures the package outer surface and therefore has been arranged so as to view upwards to the bottom surface of the target so that gravity keeps the content and package in contact. It also utilises a sapphire window to protect the reflector, made possible by a moderately short wavelength thermometer. Trials in food distribution have shown excellent correlation to the traditional destructive method of inserting a thermocouple type probe through the package.
7.6
Further reading
and JONES, C. H. (eds) (1988) Applications of Thermal Imaging. Adam Hilger, Bristol. DEWITT, D. P. and NUTTER, G. D. (eds) (1988) The Theory and Practice of Radiation Thermometry. Wiley, New York. TOULOUKIAN, Y. S., (series ed.) HO, C. Y. (series technical ed.) Thermo-physical Properties of Matter Touloukian, Y. S. and DeWitt, D. P. (1970) Vol. 7. Thermal Radiative Properties – Metallic Elements and Alloys. Touloukian, Y. S. and DeWitt, D. P. (1972) Vol. 8. Thermal Radiative Properties – Nonmetallic Solids. Touloukian, Y. S., DeWitt, D. P. and Hernicz, R. S. (1972) Vol. 9. Thermal Radiative Properties – Coatings. IFI Plenum, New York. WOLFE, W. L. and ZISSIS, G. J. (eds) (1978) The Infra-Red Handbook. Office of Naval Research, Department of Navy, Arlington, VA. BURNAY, S. G., WILLIAMS, T. L.
8 In-line and off-line FTIR measurements C. Reh, Nestle´ Research Centre, Lausanne
8.1
Introduction
Infra-red (IR) spectroscopy measures the absorption of different frequencies of infra-red radiation by the matrix being measured. IR spectroscopy was first discovered by Herschel in 1800, who used a prism to create a spectrum from white light and measured the temperature with a thermometer. He then noted an increase of the temperature beyond the visible spectrum related to the infra-red radiation. Infra-red radiation is electromagnetic energy, located in the wavelength range between the visible light (800 nm) and the shorter microwaves (100 m). The area of infra-red light is generally divided into nearinfra-red (0.8–2.5 m), mid-infra-red (2.5–15 m) and far infra-red (15–100 m). In terms of food applications near infra-red is the most frequently used wavelength range and it is applied in almost all areas of the agriculture and food industry. Applications were first developed in the 1970s in the rapid quantitative determinations of moisture, protein and fat in cereal grains, which is still today one of the major applications. Molecular absorption of electromagnetic radiation in the infra-red range relates to the uptake of energy. Infrared radiation promotes the transition to rotational or vibrational levels from the ground electronic energy state. Different types of vibrations and rotations result in absorption of energy at different wavelengths. Additionally the vibrational energy relates directly to the strength of the bond and the mass of the molecular system. This means that each measured absorption relates to a typical molecular structure and is therefore typical for each molecule as it also relates to the overall molecular mass of molecule. This is the reason why mid-infra-red (IR) spectroscopy is well known for the identification of chemical or especially pharmaceutical compounds and most of the traditional applications had been qualitative. In Table 8.1 some typical wavenumber ranges for food compounds are given. The vibrating molecular functional group is first excited from the lowest fundamental level to the first excited level by radiation of the frequency that is identical to the initial frequency of the vibration of the bond. This frequency is generally referred to as fundamental absorption. Additionally, molecules can absorb radiation to be moved to higher excited states. These absorptions are called overtones and measured by near infra-red spectroscopy. Due to the lower probability of
214
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 8.1 Some typical wavenumber ranges for the most common functional groups in food analysis Functional group
Wavenumber range in cm
Protein
Amid -N-H Amid -C=O Amid -N-H
3300 1650 1550
Fat
cis -C=CEster -C=O -C=C-C=Ctrans -C=C-
3050–3000 1700–1750 1670–1620 1390 968–960
Carbohydrates
-O-H -O-H
4000-3000 1600–600
1
occurrence, the level of energy of these overtones occurs at an order of magnitude weaker than fundamental modes. As already mentioned, all spectroscopical signals of a molecular group are strongly influenced by neighbouring molecular groups. Furthermore, other substances in a mixture can influence the signal due to changes of the dipole moment. This results in signal shifts due to different food matrixes and we will later discuss the effect of this phenomenon on the calibration procedure and the precautions which have to be taken. The main element of all traditional applications has been the use of high-resolution diffraction monochromator instruments based on gratings and prisms. This results in extremely long measurement times for the determination of a complete spectrum, as the wavelengths are measured one after the other. When applying the interferometer in Fourier transform infra-red spectroscopy (FTIR) all wavelengths are measured simultaneously. A complete spectrum can be collected very rapidly and many scans can be averaged in the time a single spectrum has been taken with a dispersive spectrometer. 8.1.1 Fourier transform infra-red spectroscopy (FTIR) A more sophisticated form of infra-red analysis, FTIR has been available to scientists since the early 1970s. FTIR differs fundamentally from diffraction technology, since it is based on interferometry, which makes use of the entire source spectrum. All wavelengths are recorded simultaneously. Interferometry is based on the use of a beam splitter to divide the IR radiation into two beams: one beam is reflected to a fixed mirror and the other beam to a moving mirror. The two beams undergo constructive and destructive interference as they recombine at the beam splitter, due to the path difference between the two mirrors. Fluctuations in the intensity of the energy reaching the detector are digitised using a real-time data acquisition system, and result in an interferogram that contains the spectral information related to the sample. The interferogram is converted into a conventional spectrum using the Fourier transform algorithm. This calculation requires substantial computing power. The rapid development of FTIR applications is mainly due to the improvement of computer technology. Further progress has been made regarding the signal-to-noise ratio due to the simultaneous detection of all frequencies (multiplexing), and also in reduced scanning times, higher energy throughput, superior
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
215
spectral resolution and wavelength accuracy. The wavelength accuracy is principally achieved by the use of an internal reference laser and is a key element for subsequent data manipulations. In Fig. 8.1 the functionality of the Michelson spectrometer can be seen. The essential part of this type of spectrometer is the system for splitting the beam of the infra-red radiation into two and then recombining the two beams after introducing a path difference. This recombined beam then passes through the sample or is reflected from the surface of the sample depending on the sample presentation used in the chosen instrumental set-up. Then the light is measured by the detector. The division of the beam is achieved with a beamsplitter, which in the optimum case transmits about 50 per cent and reflects about 50 per cent of the radiation. One part of the radiation is reflected onto a fixed mirror whereas the other part goes to a moving mirror. This moving mirror introduces a difference of pathlength compared to the fixed mirror. The major difference between instruments from different suppliers is generally the construction of the moving mirror. This part is quite critical for the noise level in the final spectra, as moving parts are traditionally more sensitive to outside vibrations. Due to the path difference, a variation in the interference pattern is obtained after the beams are recombined. This recombination has to be done with high precision and all optical elements of the interferometer have to be aligned in order to achieve a uniform path difference across the beam. This alignment has to be kept throughout the complete measurement and vibrations from the environment can disturb the measurement. The majority of the available instrumentation is therefore used in a laboratory environment where the disturbances can be limited. Nowadays, there are good possibilities for miniaturising instrumentation and several instruments are in the development stage. These instruments will be less sensitive to outside influences and will allow application of the technique under more robust conditions. It should even be possible to apply the technique for online measurement purposes. In the area of near infra-red several applications are already currently applied as due to the higher signal and the lower requirements for wavelength accuracy the available technology provides sufficient performance.
Fig. 8.1
Schematic drawing of the Michelson interferometer (Perkin-Elmer Ltd).
216
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
For improving the signal-to-noise ratio several interferograms are generally averaged. For this purpose all successive interferograms have to be measured at exactly the same point. The wavenumber scale of the interferometer is based on the application of a HeNe laser which has a known wavelength of 632.99 nm. This wavenumber is very stable and allows an extremely accurate wavenumber calibration, which additionally guarantees the long-term stability of the measurements on the FTIR spectrometer. It is one of the strengths of the interferometer technique that extremely high wavelength accuracy can be provided. Especially in the context of calibration transfer for quantitative applications and long-term instrument stability, this fact has great importance. The second element for calibration transfer is then the stability of the instrument in measuring the absorption. This depends strongly on the performance of the light source, the detector and the optical set-up of the instrument. Reference samples or standards are used to assess the absorbance scale of the spectrometer. Interferometers are used by first recording a background reading and then measuring the sample. Both spectra are then rationed in order to eliminate all parts of the signal outcome related to the optical set-up of the spectrometer and the environment. Figure 8.2 gives an example for this rationing procedure. Rationing is necessitated by the fact that interferometers operate in a single-beam mode in contrary to the classical double-beam spectrophotometers. This results in the need for appropriate and stable design of the instrumentation and it also accounts for the different performance of instruments of different makes. The signal-to-noise ratio is here one of the most appropriate parameters for comparing instrumentation. Comparison is also influenced by the user’s application. In the majority of the cases spectral normalising is used to eliminate the disturbances caused by the air present in the optical path. In particular carbon dioxide and water strongly interfere. It is quite difficult to keep the level of the background air very stable and to guarantee the complete elimination of the effects. For this purpose large parts of the spectrometer are purged with dried carbon dioxide free air or dry nitrogen. Other solutions are based on sealed and desiccated units.
Fig. 8.2
Spectra of background (2), polymer film with background (3) and polymer film after mathematical treatment (1).
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
217
8.1.2 Sample presentation techniques The sample presentation is one of the key elements of any successful application of spectroscopic techniques. It is important to present a representative sample of the chosen food to the spectrometer. The limitation of the available instrumental solution is therefore one of the principal reasons for the limited use of FTIR spectroscopy in the food industry. The majority of the food matrixes, which are measured in the mid-infra-red region, are normally highly homogeneous. Liquids are most commonly measured by applying transmission cells with typical pathlengths of 0.01 to 1 mm. The distance between the two windows can be one parameter for optimising the level of absorption achieved. By increasing the amount of sample in the optical path the level of absorption can be increased. Due to the relatively low intensities of IR sources and the relatively low sensitivities of infra-red detectors, an optimum exists for the optical pathlength. Because quartz and glass absorb mid-infra-red radiation these materials cannot be used as optical cell material. Most commonly cell windows based on halide or sulfide salts are used which unfortunately often are soluble in water. This gives particular trouble when working with aqueous sample matrixes. Transmission cells are also used for the measurement of gases. In this case the sample volume has to be larger due to the lower number of molecules present in the cell. Typically sealed cells are used with pathlengths of 2 to 10 cm and IR transparent windows. For trace analysis multiple-pass cells are available, where the IR beam is reflected several times forward and backwards. This permits an increase of the optical pathlength up to several metres and reduces significantly the detection limit. This allows the sample to interface a FTIR detection system with gas chromatographs or thermobalances in order to measure and identify released substances. By applying GCFTIR, even stereoisomers can be identified due to the very characteristic molecular vibration pattern of each isomer. This technique is for example used for the identification of isomers in the separation of fatty acids. Another application for gas measurements by FTIR spectroscopy is the emission measurement of burner houses. In this application a wide range of gases can be measured even down to trace levels including carbon dioxide, water, carbon oxide, nitric oxide, nitric dioxide and hydrocarbons. The most traditional sample presentation technique has been the use of potassium bromide (KBr) pellets. This has been the most widely used sample presentation technique when using the diffractive infra-red spectrometer for identification of substances. In order to prepare the pellet the ground sample has to be very well mixed with the potassium bromide. Then the pellet is pressed under high pressure and inserted into the optical beam with a special sample holder. This technique is principally used for the qualitative identification of chemically and physico-chemically clearly defined food ingredients. In the context of the increased legal demand for raw material control and traceability, this use might be of increasing interest. Quantitative measurements on a routine basis are not advisable with this technique, as it is extremely difficult to control the quantity of substance in the optical path. Another sample presentation technique used for the identification of substances is based on disposable cards in which a Teflon foil is mounted in the optical path. This technique allows the measurement of organic liquids or finely dispersed solid material, which are fixed on the foil. The Teflon foil does not absorb infra-red radiation strongly and is therefore ideal for this type of application. A frequently used sample presentation technique is attenuated total reflectance (ATR), which is available for obtaining spectra from all types of sample matrixes. ATR devices measure the total reflected energy from the surface of a sample in contact with an IR transmitting crystal. The radiation penetrates a short distance into the
218
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
sample before it is reflected back into the crystal. The reflected energy is reduced by the energy absorbed by the sample, which allows the determination of the sample spectra as already described for the transmission principle. The most critical parameter to control is the contact area between the sample and the crystal. In the case of solid powdered products the particle size distribution is the main product characteristic which must be controlled and a milling step may be necessary. ATR is more successfully used for liquid products. Even quantitative applications have been possible using this technique, as we will describe in more detail in the application part. The majority of the available ATR devices apply multiple reflection plates, which are commonly from 1 to 10 cm long and allow somewhere between 10 to 30 reflections. In Fig. 8.3 a heated single bounce attenuated total reflectance unit from SPECAC is shown. In contrary to the mentioned multiple reflection units this device applies a single reflection and the infra-red radiation is distributed on a slightly larger measurement area. This unit has a relatively high energy throughput which results in a good signal-to-noise ratio. Nevertheless, good contact between the crystal and the sample matrix is still the critical parameter to watch. This technique is also not advisable for low absorbing materials and substances where the surface is not characteristic for the composition of the material. This second point must be taken care of in all optical spectroscopical techniques, as the penetration depth of the radiation may not allow the measurement of the material in a representative manner. Another type of device used principally for powders is diffuse reflectance. The method is often referred as DRIFT (diffuse reflectance infra-red Fourier transform) spectroscopy. The infra-red light is directed onto a sample cup, the reflected light is collected by a mirror and measured by the detector. As reference, normally a sample of potassium bromide (KBr) is measured. The advantage of this method is that for fine powdered material no sample preparation is needed. The field of application is principally the identification of compounds which cannot be evaluated well using the KBr pellet method.
Fig. 8.3 Single-beam HATR-unit from Specac.
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
219
Fibre-optics have found increased use in infra-red spectroscopy as prices have dropped due to the progress of material science. These fibre-optics are used to construct transmission cells for on-line measurements or reflection probes which can be either used on line or for rapid in-line applications. Up to now more use of fibre-optics is made in FT-NIR spectroscopy, which can be explained by the lower cost of the fibre-optics in the near infra-red range. When used for raw material reception care should be taken that the fibre-optics are not bent too much. This limits the lifetime of the fibre-optic and bending might additionally influence the quality of the measured spectra. Recently the coupling of a microscope and a FTIR spectrometer has been developed. In this instrumental set-up the infra-red beam can be focused through the microscope on a special spot of the sample and an infra-red spectrum can be taken at the specific spot. Up to now this instrumental set-up is used for the identification of polymer layers in multilayer packaging. Other applications can be the identification of foreign bodies or the study of the chemical composition of parts of a product. This is only an overview of the most commonly used sample presentation techniques for food applications. There are a number of companies, who develop individual solutions for customers. When developing a special sample presentation the principal question has to be answered: does the instrumentation measure in a representative way the parameter under question?
8.2
Food applications
Review articles cite the possibilities of FTIR spectroscopy within the food area (Van de Voort and Ismail 1991; Wilson 1990). In principle, fat, protein, carbohydrate and moisture can be readily analysed if the sample is prepared appropriately. However, a method applicable to the food industry should meet three criteria: 1. 2. 3.
Instrumentation must be operationally simple and dedicated. Sample preparation and handling have to be standardised. Standard calibration procedures have to be developed along with pre-formulated and pre-analysed calibration standards.
Aside from the milk industry, where mid-IR has been used for several years with increasing success, a wider use can be identified for the meat industry, for sugar analysis (Kemsley et al. 1992; Heisz 1990) and for the analysis of edible fats and oils. Following the literature, the analysis of edible fats and oils has been performed for many years and has a potential for wider application. In more recent literature several authors reported on studies relating to the authenticity of food products such as fats and oils (Lai et al. 1994, 1995), soluble coffee (Briandet et al. 1996; Downey et al. 1997), green coffee (Suchanek et al. 1996) and fruit preparations (Defernez et al. 1995; Defernez and Wilson 1995; Kemsley et al. 1996; Wilson et al. 1993). These types of studies require the use of complex chemometric based software and databases. The published studies are based often on a selected field of samples and the applications tend to show increasing numbers of outliers as the databases become larger. Nevertheless, samples with significant differences in the principal composition can be identified as adulterated. It has to be seen if improvement of these systems can be achieved via further development of instruments and software. Nevertheless, the problem of adulteration of foodstuffs is not only an analytical problem and requires a complete understanding of all product characteristics and transformations the product undergoes in
220
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
the food chain. This chapter does not allow a treatment of this subject in more depth and the reader is advised to consult the available literature. 8.2.1 Applications for edible fats and oils The analysis of edible fats and oils by infra-red spectroscopy is widely discussed in the literature and several review articles have been written over the years (O’Connor 1956; Chapman 1964; Freeman 1968; Cast 1995). In this chapter we want to concentrate on the development of quantitative applications and the improvement of the procedures due to the technical improvements of FTIR spectroscopy. Certain determinations have been extensively examined and the overview indicates that there is a focus on typical process related parameters and raw material related quality parameters. The determination of trans unsaturation has assumed a particularly important place and is often reported in literature (Firestone and Sheppard 1992; Dutton 1974; Belton et al. 1988; Lanser and Emken 1988; Sleeterand Matlock 1989; Van de Voort et al. 1995; Mossoba et al. 1996; Adam et al. 1998). A standard method for trans unsaturation in fatty acids and their esters is given by the American Oil Chemists Society (AOCS 1993) which employs the trans alkene band at 965 cm 1. The method of the (Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC) 1990) includes corrections for triglyceride and methylester absorption near the trans unsaturation band. Belton et al. 1988 used first FTIR with ATR (Attenuated Total Reflectance) for the determination of isolated trans isomers in margarine. The measurements were done without special sample preparation in the form of a CS2 solution without sample thermostatisation. The standard solutions were obtained by mixing methylelaidate or trielaidin with pure soybean oil. Lanser and Emken (1988) measured the solutions of the fatty acids methyl ester (FAMES) in CS2 by FTIR using a transmission cell. Sleeter and Matlock (1989) have chosen a similar approach. Their principal modifications have been the use of a very thin transmission cell and the elimination of CS2 as solvent. The approach has been further developed by Ulberth and Harder (1992), and Ulberth and Henninger (1994) by using chemometrics for the evaluation of the data. It is clear that methods based on the use of toxic solvents do not find a wide application in the food industry. The general trend is to develop methods where the sample can be tested as such and a minimum of sample preparation is needed. Therefore Van de Voort et al. (1995), Sedman et al. (1997), Ali et al. (1995) and Mossoba et al. (1996) optimised the method by avoiding derivatisation to FAMES and the use of solvents. Van de Voort’s methodology principally relies on the use of heated transmission cell and the application of a PLS-based calibration model. Mossoba’s approach is based on the use of a heated single beam HATR-equipment (Heated Attenuated Total Reflectance) and the calculation of the results versus reference samples which are prepared with standards. The determination of the trans content has been studied in a collaborative study (Adam et al. 2000) towards installation of an AOCS method, Cd 14d-99. We, as one of the participating laboratories, have been using a PERKIN-ELMER 2000 FTIR spectrometer. As accessory we used a single bounce heated ATR from SPECAC heated to 70ºC. The data evaluation has been done by using the PERKIN-ELMER Spectrum software. This instrumental set-up is standard and principally all commercially available FTIR spectrometers can be used for this determination. Some other suppliers are NICOLET, BIO-RAD and BRUKER for FTIR spectrometers and HARRICK, PIKE and SPECTRA-TECH for accessories, to name only a few. Method AOCS Cd 14d-99 has everything a method needs to be used in a production
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
221
environment. No chemicals are required and the parameter is determined in less than five minutes without any major sample preparation. The calculation of the result based on the peak at 966 cm 1 is done by simple procedures of rationing and integration and can be easily automated by a macro. Some compromise is necessary for the accuracy of the method, but for trans levels larger than 1.0 per cent the accuracy is absolutely satisfactory for process control or raw material reception purposes. We have seen in our own additional experiments that satisfactory results can be achieved for iodine value and sapofinication number. According to our experience, calibrations tend to be better when they are developed for a single fat or oil. The estimation of free fatty acid content in oils by a method involving deconvolution of absorption bands over the region 1600-2000 cm 1 in order to distinguish the otherwise overlapping bands at 1710 cm 1 for free acid and 1746 cm 1 for triglyceride ester has been described (Lancer et al. 1991). Calibration against a titration method resulted in good results for the estimation of free fatty acid in damaged soybean oil. HATR and FTIR have been used by Ismail et al. (1993) to determine free fatty acid in fats and oils. The calibration curves were prepared by adding oleic acid to the oil chosen for analysis and measuring the C=O band at 1711 cm 1 after rationing the sample spectrum against that of the same oil free of fatty acid. The method was tested for an analytical range between 0.2–8 per cent FFA on a HATR and with flow-cells. Lipid oxidation, one of the key deteriorative reactions affecting edible oils, is another field of interest for applying infra-red spectroscopy. One parameter is the determination of hydroperoxides, which are formed as primary products when the autoxidation commences. The standard AOCS PV determination is based on the stoichiometric release of molecular iodine by hydroperoxides when exposed to potassium iodide in an acidic environment. Ma et al. (1997) applied FTIR by using a heated transmission cell. The measurement was based on the determination of triphenylphosphine oxides, which are the reaction products of triphenylphosphine with hydroperoxides. The triphenylphosphine oxide shows an intense absorption band at 542 cm 1, which is used to perform the determination. It was possible to measure PV between 0 and 15 with a standard deviation of ±0.05 PV and a reproducibility of ±0.18 PV. In earlier works Van de Voort et al. (1994) worked on the determination of PV by either calibrating against the official AOCS method or using different standards for the calibration curve. Lipid oxidation is also investigated in several other studies (Dubois et al. 1996; Kersting et al. 1995; Fukuzumi and Koboyashi 1972; Ismail et al. 1993) using different types of approach. Kersting et al. (1995) characterised a mixture of soybean oil and epoxidised soybean oil by FTIR-ATR. Several regions of the spectra were identified as being typical for lipid oxidation. The epoxidised soybean oil showed strong absorbance in the region between 3600 cm 1 and 3150 cm 1 due to the hydroxyl group. Further differences can be found near 3009 cm 1 for the unsaturation bands, at 1655 cm 1 for the saturation bands and several peaks between 700 cm 1 and 1200 cm 1 indicating bands of the CH-bands which are modified due to the changes in levels of unsaturation. Dubois et al. (1996) used the determination of the anisidine value (AV) to evaluate thermally stressed oils by FTIR. A transmission flow cell has been used at 80ºC. The calibration has been done using synthetically prepared standard solutions and comparing to a calibration based on AV-values measured in thermally stressed oils by the reference method. In principle, positive results have been achieved. Iodine value (IV) and saponification number (SN) have been determined by Van de Voort et al. (1992b) using a heated ATR device at 60ºC. Both parameters were calibrated by using the PLS method and the results of the chemical methods using AOCS
222
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
methodology. The models were tested by predicting samples, which were not included in the calibration set. This is important to allow a proper validation of the calibration model. IV was predicted in a range of 0 to 180 with a standard error of prediction of ±2.87. SN has been calibrated between 180 and 480 and the prediction showed a standard error of prediction of ±2.04. Solid fat index (SFI) has been calibrated by Van de Voort et al. (1996) using a PLS calibration model. The reference measurements were done using dilatometry. SFI has been calibrated between 0 and 50 and the calibration model predicted independent samples with a standard error of prediction of approximately ±0.7. The FTIR measurements were done using a heated flow cell. Several other FTIR applications regarding fat analysis have been published lately relating to industrial applications. Safar et al. (1994) characterised edible oils, butter and margarine by using ATR. The principal aim had been to classify these products according to their unsaturation. This is an application of large interest for the hydrogenation plants of edible fat and oil producers. All these studies and the growing interest of the oil and fat producing industry have led to the development of industrial edible oil analysers. This equipment has been available in the market since the late 1990s. This illustrates the rapid development of instrumentation and the efforts of the suppliers in providing easy to use instrumentation. This includes the presence of chemometric software, which can be used by a nonstatistician. The use of this type of software became possible due to the rapid performance increase of the computer. It is a fact that without the huge increase in calculating power, spectroscopical routine applications are difficult to imagine. One of these dedicated instruments, shown in Fig. 8.4, is the PERKIN-ELMER FTIR edible oil analyser, which provides precalibrations for free fatty acids (FFA), iodine value (IV) and trans unsaturation for major commodity vegetable oils including soybean and rape/canola oils. The instrument is based on a standard FTIR system and uses a heated sipper to pump the sample into a 100 m potassium chloride cuvette. The cuvette is cleaned with a
Fig. 8.4 Edible oil analyser (Perkin-Elmer Ltd).
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
223
sufficient amount of the next sample. BOMEM Inc. in Canada has released an oil and fat analyser based on the FT-NIR principle. The instrument has a precalibration for the iodine value and other calibrations are in the stage of development. These are two examples of instrument suppliers developing ready to use solutions of a still quite sophisticated analytical technique. It has to be seen if interferometer technology will be more successful using the mid infra-red or near infra-red region. In a study on frying oil deterioration Engelsen (1997) compared several analytical techniques such as FTIR, fluorescence spectroscopy, NIR, Raman spectroscopy and UVVIS spectroscopy to evaluate their potential in following the chemistry of oil in frying processes. FTIR spectroscopy has been shown as a valuable method of following these changes. This study has been one of the few where FTIR is used as a process-monitoring tool. In the chemical, petrochemical and pharmaceutical industry these type of controls are more often applied. This can be partially explained by the fact that food matrixes are generally more complex than chemical matrixes. Additionally the added value of processing in the food industry is normally smaller. The affordability of instrumental equipment is therefore strongly related to the price of the instrumentation. It can be expected that when the price for instrumentation drops due to ongoing miniaturisation the number of applications will increase strongly. The measurement of parameters in homogeneous matrixes such as fats and oils is one of those areas where the strongest growth can be expected, as knowledge of the applications is already quite advanced. It is surely imaginable that hand-held equipment will enter the market that will allow the chemical quality of an oil to be judged in less than a minute. Other equipment should allow connection directly to the process line, for example to an industrial fryer, and the monitoring of changes occurring in real time. The availability of fibre-optics, which are already used for some applications will even allow multiplexing. 8.2.2 Applications for the dairy industry Mid-infra-red spectroscopy is a proven technology in the dairy industry and an industry standard for raw milk reception. The measurement of fat, protein, lactose and total solids is widely discussed in literature and instruments have been improved over the years to highly performing status. The milk analyser is a proven industrial application (Van de Voort 1980; Smith et al. 1993a,b; Lynch et al. 1995) allowing the determination of the principal composition of milk. All major milk reception centres have used this technique for years and even highly automated equipment is available to handle large sample numbers. Fat, protein and total solids have been determined for several years by so called milk analysers which employ the mid infra-red transmission principle. The liquid or liquefied sample is transferred in an infra-red inactive cuvette through which infra-red light is passed. It is important that the sample is highly homogeneous and forms a stable, finely distributed emulsion. Milk, ice cream, yoghurt and similar products are the main fields of application. There is a limit regarding the viscosity the pumping system can handle. In certain cases a dissolution step is necessary. The detection system of these milk analysers is based on fixed filters which are specific for fat or other constituents like protein or carbohydrates. The fat measurement is based on the absorption measurement at 5.73 m and 3.40 m. The first filter is called fat A filter and represents the absorption of the ester groups. The absorption is calculated versus a reference wavelength at 5.50 m. The filter at 3.40 m is called fat B filter and measures principally the C-H bonds. The reference wavelength is located at 3.60 m. The calibration is done by employing multiple linear regression (MLR). It is known that the
224
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
season influences the calibration and normally different calibrations are applied. The measuring accuracy is typically at 0.02 weight per cent for liquids up to 10 per cent and 0.10 weight per cent for liquids above 10 per cent. Another parameter influencing the performance of the milk analysers is the homogenisation degree of the milk (Smith et al. 1994, 1995; Remillard 1993). The control of a constant homogenisation of the milk is therefore required. Most of the milk analysers are equipped with an integrated homogeniser which, according to experience, strongly improves the results. The homogeniser is the part of the milk analyser equipment which needs the most attention during service in order to guarantee constant performance. In recent years, IR spectroscopy has made enormous progress due to micro-electronics and electronic data processing for spectra manipulation, evaluation and identification. This has enabled instrument suppliers to use interferometry and subsequent Fourier transformation (FTIR) (Nathier-Dufour et al. 1995; De Jong et al. 1996; Van de Voort et al. 1992; Hansen 1998; Hewavitharana and Brakel 1997). The technique has been used to further develop the milk analyser systems (Lefier 1996; Lanher 1996). As these systems are able to measure the complete mid-infra-red spectra, additional information is available to improve measurement accuracy and to permit measurement of additional parameters. Lanher (1996) has shown the advantages of FTIR technology versus filterbased milk analysers when testing the Aegys MI 600. Experience has shown that the influence of the season on the calibration is strongly reduced (Lefier 1996). The free choice of the measurement wavelength resulted in improved accuracy for the determination of vegetable fats in ice cream or infant products compared to the filter systems. Several suppliers have introduced milk analysers based on FTIR in the late 1990s. This technology allows measurement of the complete infra-red spectrum, which can be employed to calibrate parameters in milk, ice cream, milk-based beverages, yogurt, infant products, etc. Basic parameters are total fat content, total protein content, total solids, lactose and total carbohydrate content. Additional parameters like citrate, urea (Hansen 1998) and casein (Hewavitharana 1997) can be measured quantitatively or semi-quantitatively. Urea is important for feeding and herd control whereas the determination of casein is of importance for standardisation purposes. Up to a certain extent it is possible to identify milk adulteration. In a short study on ice-cream premixes we have been testing the performance of the FOSS ELECTRIC FT 120. The reference analysis for the fat measurement has been based on the Ro¨se Gottlieb method and for the total solids determination on the measurement by an infrabalance. The precalibation provided by the supplier has been improved by adding a few samples with results distributed over the whole range of measurement. Then a series of samples has been predicted for the two parameters. As illustrated in Fig. 8.5 the results are extremely promising. All samples have been predicted with high accuracy, which is typical for the FTIR technique, when laboratory and production line are working under stable conditions. Several studies give confidence that milk analysers based on FTIR technology are very valuable aid when used in an operational environment. The equipment and software are generally easy to use and the calibration can generally be very rapidly adapted to local conditions. An additional feature of FTIR milk analysers is the possibility to transfer calibrations from one machine to another. Instrument-ready calibrations reduce the costs incurred after equipment is bought and calibrations have to be developed. Assuming that a stable calibration is based on a minimum of 30 samples for a single parameter it is obvious that a significant amount of money can be saved if the calibration has to be adapted only to the local conditions.
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
Fig. 8.5
225
Prediction of total fat in ice cream premixes by milk analyser FT120.
8.2.3 On-line standardisation in dairy processes On-line standardisation has been tried within the dairy industry with different degrees of success. These instrumentations have been based on automated filter-based milk analyser systems. The systems work in the standardisation line using a by-pass stream after the different product streams have been mixed. The sampling is done by a pumping system, and this means the replacement of parts on a regular basis and continuous demand for service. It is always better for any on-line control instrumentation to be independent of any influences of the sampling system and to measure directly the flowing product stream. Up to today this has not been achieved and the majority of the applications are still using by-pass solutions. The reason is principally the need to guarantee standard conditions for the measurement. The majority of the applications require a more or less constant product flow in the measurement cell, a completely homogeneous product that requires sometime the application of a homogenisation step and a narrow temperature range. New instrumentation based on the FTIR principle is being tested in the market for the standardisation of dairy processes. The advantages of performing on-line standardisation compared to traditional batch processes are obvious. Time and labour involved in poststandardisation is eliminated. One problem of batch standardisation has always been the inaccuracy of the sampling procedures. Holding tank capacity can be reduced which results in lower investments in plant. The major advantage is probably the higher production output combined with better product consistency. Due to increased measurement speed, higher measurement accuracy and higher frequency of measurements, sudden variations in the composition are more quickly detected and corrected. In a plant using this technique, where almost real-time data flow of information is combined with a well engineered control and dosing set-up, a considerable reduction of the variation of the final product composition will be observed. In an ideal case batch-tobatch differences will be reduced and the target values can be moved closer to the limits which will relate to improved product quality and financial savings. The principal parameters measured in this application are the total fat content, the total solids content, the solid-non-fat (SNF) content and the total protein content. Due to the application of the FTIR principle, measurement of other parameters is also possible like individual or total sugars. One advantage, which has been mentioned earlier, is the transferability of the calibrations. This allows, with a minimum of optimisation work, transfer of the calibrations from one production line to another and helps especially in the start-up
226
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
phase. Typical products related to these standardisation processes are cheese, milk powders, condensed milk, UHT milk, pasteurised milk and cream. 8.2.4 Applications in the wine industry Wine making is a typical example for the use of instrumental analytical techniques in the food industry. For centuries the making of wine has been based on the experience of the wine maker. Only in recent decades has science also entered the field of wine making. Over the years more and more parameters have been found to be useful for measurement, in order to optimise the final quality of wine. Instrumentation for a series of those parameters has been available and due to the increased size of vinyards and the existence of cooperatives the use of these techniques has become more and more common. Typical analytes are ethanol, pH, volatile acids, total acid, tartaric acid, malic acid, lactic acid, acetic acid, glucose, fructose and reducing sugars. Additionally, wine standards continue to advance and have to be measured. As in all industries fast reliable analytical techniques to monitor and screen compounds are needed for process control and routine analysis. It has been therefore only a matter of time until FTIR spectroscopy has been applied for the determination of parameters in wine. The instrumentation is based, like the milk analysers, on the transmission principle. It allows measuring a series of parameters within one instrument. One measurement takes only 30 seconds and all major parameters are determined without using any reagents. As already mentioned for the milk analyser, wine-testing instrumentation can be combined with autosampler and barcode reader and can therefore be employed for measuring a larger series of samples. The most advanced instrument having applicability in a routine environment is the FOSS Electric WineScan FT 120 shown in Fig. 8.6. This instrument is principally a derivative of the MilkoScan FT 120 instrument. The instrument is also based on a transmission cell, but due to the more simple sample matrix the homogenisation unit of the milk analysers is not necessary. A series of calibrations is available for different types of wine. Basic calibrations when provided with an instrument tend to be more robust it they include a certain variation in the samples included in the calibration. In one of the basic calibrations for red wine available for the equipment, wines of different origin such as South Africa, New Zealand, Australia, United States, Spain, France, Italy and Germany are included. Different varieties of wine contain different compounds that may interfere with the signals of other compounds. If they are not accounted for in the calibration, often higher values of concentration are observed for the standard compounds. Including a wide range of different varieties gives an important level of robustness to the calibration. Starting from these calibrations the user will analyse some of his own samples by the reference method and include the samples in the calibration set. A more precise calibration can be even obtained for a particular variety such as rose, sherry or eiswein. Using the chemometric software the calibration can be optimised for local use. The gain in accuracy will be compromised by a reduction in the range of applicability. The majority of the calibrated parameters can be measured with quite good accuracy. Ethanol can be measured with accuracy better than 1.0 per cent whereas for total acids values will be better than 3.5 per cent. In the study (Patz 1999) attempts have been made to measure sulphur dioxide and the total phenol content. Despite the wine matrix being extremely homogeneous, it has not been possible to determine sulphur dioxide properly. This is related to the relatively narrow range of the parameter, the comparatively low concentration (30–200 mg/l) and
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
Fig. 8.6
227
FTIR wine analyser WineScan FT120 (Foss Electric).
some occurring interactions with other compounds present in the wine. The unsatisfactory results for total phenol can be explained by some limitations of the reference method and the fact that the individual phenols can be quite different in molecular structure depending on the variation of the wine. This shows the typical limitations of indirect methods dependent on the performance of the reference method. In certain cases even the reference method should be questioned. Often parameters like total acids and total sugars are measured and the parameter is taken for making decisions for production, even the individual classes of acids or sugars vary quite significantly.
8.3
Calibration and general aspects of routine use
The most critical step in using FTIR spectroscopy successfully is to develop and maintain good calibration. After having made the choice of the equipment the next step is to understand the parameters which have to be measured. In a first step samples have to be taken and measured by the reference methodology. It should be pointed out that an indirect method such as FTIR spectroscopy should never be calibrated with another indirect method. The calibration set of samples has to include all expected components possible in the food product. The samples should also include the range of physicochemical appearance, which can occur. Finally the samples should be as independent from each other as possible. For example to take two samples from a production line does not normally add sufficient information to a calibration. Variation in the samples can be caused by different raw materials, within five minutes, different production parameters, different sampling point or different climatic conditions. It is obvious that in the case of a calibration of several parameters and a relatively wide range of physical aspects quite a large number of samples may be necessary. This illustrates the value of instruments where precalibrations are available. Based on the sample set and the results of the reference methods the calibration is developed.
228
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Normally a chemometric software package comes with the instrument and it should be used for developing several calibration models. The best of these models should then be used for performing a validation with an independent set of samples. When the best calibration is identified it should be used as routine with the necessary care. It is advisable to reanalyse some samples on a regular basis to check the accuracy of the application and to improve the calibration. The use of the statistical tools of statistical process control, such as control charts, can be an important help in performing this control. Additionally, it can be the basis for making an adequate tool for identifying the necessity of changing the bias or slope of the calibration. Another important aspect of maintaining constant performance of the equipment is regular control by an auto-control procedure. All suppliers propose generally a system based on either check cells, ceramic plates or reference samples. This data should also be evaluated using statistical software and provides important information about the performance of the instrument. As a last important point it should be mentioned that an adequate training of staff using this type of equipment is needed. Especially, the person who is organising the sampling and who is following the calibration process requires training in laboratory techniques, sampling procedures, product knowledge, instrumental understanding and statistics.
8.4
Conclusions and outlook
It has been shown that FTIR spectroscopy, as with most of the other spectroscopical techniques, allows the measurement of important parameters in food products within a short period of time. The technique is non-invasive and non-destructive, which allows online control without loss of product. Due to the vast amount of information created by the molecular vibrations of the individual ingredients in the food matrix, a large set of parameters can be measured. All these parameters are measured simultaneously which allows a significant gain of time. Once calibrated, typically results are obtained within minutes, seconds or even less. This technique is therefore extremely suitable for use in processing plants and is not just a sophisticated analytical technique for a remote special laboratory. Due to the greater frequency of the data acquisition decisions can be made in real time for line control purposes. We will see in future more applications in the area of product standardisation especially when the instrumentation gains in robustness and is less sensitive to external influences. The future will bring more instruments for on-line measurements on one side and more dedicated instrumentation with integrated precalibration on the other side. In all cases the use of FTIR spectroscopy results in significant savings which can be achieved in the short, medium and long term. In the short term some effort has to be put into the calibration of the instrumentation and a number of samples have to be measured by the reference methodology. Additionally, the investment in the instrument has to be calculated. As a short-term gain the increased frequency and the normally better reliability of instrumental techniques gives an advantage by reducing the amount of outof-norm product. In the middle and long term the savings become quite important. The necessary input of labour will be significantly reduced and the consumption of chemicals will drop due to the lower number of reference analyses. Especially in the food industry, reduction of toxic reagents has been always requested. FTIR spectroscopy allows the performance of analysis in a production environment which otherwise would have to be done in a remote central laboratory.
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
8.5
229
References
AOAC OFFICIAL METHOD 965.34,
AOAC Official Methods of Analysis, 15th edn (1990). (1993) ‘Isolated trans-Isomers, Infrared Spectrophotometric Method’, Cd 14-61 Revised, 1-3. ADAM M., CHEW M., WASSERMANN S., MCCOLLUM A., MCDONALD R.E. and MOSSOBA M.M. (1998) ‘Determination of trans fatty acids in hydrogenated vegetable oils by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy: two limited collaborative studies’, proposed for JAOCS, 353–358. ADAM M., MOSSOBA M M. and LEE T. (2000) ‘Rapid determination of total trans fat content by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy: an international collaborative study’, JAOCS 77, 5. ALI L.H., ANGYAL G., WEAVER C.M., RADER J.I. and MOSSOBA M.M. (1996) ‘Determination of total trans fatty acids in foods:comparison of capillary-column gas chromatography and single bounce horizontal attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 73, 1699–1705. BELTON P.S., WILSON R.H., SADEGHI-JORABCHI H., and PEERS K.E. (1988) ‘A rapid method for the estimation of Isolated Trans double bonds in oils and fats using fourier transform infrared spectroscopy combined with attenuated total reflectance’, Lebensm. Wiss u. Technol. 21, 153–157. BRIANDET R., KEMSLEY E.K. and WILSON R.H. (1996) ‘Approaches to Adulteration Detection in Instant Coffee using Infrared Spectroscopy and Chemometrics’. J. Sci Food Agric. 71, 359–366. CAST J. (1995) ‘Infrared spectroscopy of lipids’, in Hamilton Developments in Oil and Fats 224–266. CHAPMAN D. (1964) ‘Infrared Spectroscopy of Lipids’, JAOCS 42, 353–371. DE JONG E. and KAPER J. (1996) ‘Second-derivative FTIR spectroscopy, an alternative approach in milk and dairy product testing a model study’, Netherlands Milk & Dairy Journal 50, 35–51. DEFERNEZ M. and WILSON R.H. (1995) ‘Mid-Infrared Spectroscopy and Chemometrics for Determining the Type of Fruit Used in Jam’. J. Sci Food Agric. 67, 461–467. DEFERNEZ M., KEMSLEY E.K. and WILSON R.H. .(1995) ‘Use of Infrared Spectroscopy and chemometrics for the authentication of Fruit Purees’. Food Chem. 43, 109–113. DOWNEY G., BRIANDET R., WILSON R.H. and KEMSLEY E.K. (1997) ‘Near- and Mid-Infrared Spectroscopies in Food Authentification: coffee varietal identification’. J. Agric. Food Chem. 45, 4357–4361. DUBOIS J., VAN DE VOORT F.R., SEDMAN J., ISMAIL A.A. and RAMASWAMY H.R. (1996) ‘Quantitative fourier transform infrared analysis for anisidine value and aldehydes in thermally stressed oils’, JAOCS 73, 787–794. DUTTON H.J. (1974) ‘Analysis and Monitoring of Trans-Isomerization by IR Attenuated Total Reflectance Spectrophotometry’, JAOCS 51, 407–409. ENGELSEN S.B. (1997) ‘Explorative spectrometric evaluations of frying oil deterioration’, JAOCS 74, 1495–1508. FREEMAN N.K. (1968) ‘Applications of Infrared Absorption Spectroscopy in the Analysis of Lipids’, JAOCS 45, 798–809. FIRESTONE D. and SHEPPARD A. (1992) ‘Determination of trans fatty acids’ in Advances in Lipid Methodology 1, 274–289. FUKUZUMI K. and KOBOYASHI E. (1972) ‘Quantitative determination of method octadecadienoate hydroperoxides by infrared spectroscopy’ JAOCS 49, 162–165. AOCS OFFICIAL METHOD
230
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
(1988) ‘Urea determination in milk using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and multivariate calibration’, Milchwissenschaft 53, 5, 251–255. HEISZ O. (1990) ‘FTIR in der Lebensmitteluntersuchung’, ChromatographieSpektroskopie 90, 105–107. HEWAVITHARANA A. and VAN BRAKEL B. (1997) ‘Fourier transform infrared spectrometric method for the rapid determination of casein in raw milk’, The Analyst 122 July, 701–704. ISMAIL A.A., VAN DE VOORT F.R., EMO G. and SEDMAN J. (1993) ‘Rapid quantitative determination of free fatty acids in fats and oils by fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 70, 335–341. KEMSLEY E.K., HOLLAND J.K., DEFERNEZ M. and WILSON R.H. (1996) ‘Detection of Adulteration of Raspberry Purees Using Infrared Spectroscopy and Chemometrics’. J. Agric. Food Chem. 44, 3864–3870. KEMSLEY E.K., ZHUO L., HAMMOURI M.K. and WILSON R.H. (1992) ‘Quantitative analysis of sugar solutions using infrared spectroscopy’. Food Chemistry 44, 299–304. ¨ MMEL J. and FLECHTNER U. (1995) ‘Untersuchungen zur KERSTING H-J., WARNECKE H-J., KU Charakterisierung des Mischsystems Sojaol/epoxidiertes Sojaolmittels FTIR/h-ATRSpectroskopie’, Fat Sci. Technol. 97, 60–64. LAI Y.W., KEMSLEY E.K. and WILSON R.H. (1994) ‘Potential of Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy for the Authentication of Vegetable Oils’. J. Agric. Food Chem. 42, 1154–1159. LAI Y.W., KEMSLEY E.K. and WILSON R.H. (1995) ‘Quantitative analysis of potential adulterants of extra virgin olive oil using infrared spectroscopy’. Food Chemistry 53, 95–98. LANHER B. (1996) ‘Evaluation of Aegys MI 600 Fourier Transform Infrared Milk analyser for analysis of fat, protein, lactose and solids nonfat: A compilation of eight independent studies’, J. of AOAC Int., 79, 6, 1388–1399. LANSER A.C. and EMKEN E.A. (1988) ‘Comparison of FTIR and capillary gas chromatographic methods for quantitation of trans.unsaturation in fatty acid methyl esters’, JAOCS 65, 1483–1487. LANSER A.C., LIST G.R., HOLLOWAY R.K. and MOUNTS T.L. (1991) ‘FTIR estimation of free fatty acid content in crude oils extracted from damaged soybeans’, JAOCS 68, 448– 449. LEFIER D., GRAPPIN R. and POCHET S. (1996) ‘ Determination of fat, protein and lactose in raw milk by Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy and by analysis with a conventional filter-based milk analyser’, J. of AOAC Int., 79, 3, 711–717. LYNCH J., BARBANO D., FLEMING J. (1995) ‘Evaluation of commercially available milk powders for calibration of mid-infrared analysers’, J. of AOAC Int., 78, 5,1219–1224. MA K., VAN DE VOORT F.R., SEDMAN J. and ISMAIL A.A. (1997) ‘Stoichiometric determination of hydroperoxides in fats and oils by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 74, 897–906. MOSSABA M.M., YURAWECZ M.P. and MCDONALD R.E. (1996) ‘Rapid determination of the total trans content of neat hydrogenated oils by attenuated total reflection spectroscopy’, JAOCS 73, 1003–1009. NATHIER-DUFOUR N., SEDMAN J. and VAN DE VOORT F. (1995) ‘A rapid ATR/FTIR quality control method for the determination of fat and solids in sweetened condensed milk’, Milchwissenschaft 50, 8, 462–466. O’CONNOR R.T. (1956) ‘Application of infrared Spectrophotometry to Fatty Acid Derivatives’, JAOCS 33, 1–15. HANSEN P.
In-line and off-line FTIR measurements
231
(1999) ‘Wine analysis with FTIR Spectrometry’, Vinicultural and Ecological Science 54, 80–87. REMILLARD N., ROBIN O., MARTEL R. and PAQUIN P. (1993) ‘Influence of homogenisation efficiency on milk fat content determination by infrared analysis’, Int. Dairy Journal 3, 197–208. SAFAR M., BERTRAND D., ROBERT P., DEVAUX M.F. and GENOT C. (1994) ‘Characterization of edible oils, butters and margarines by fourier transform infrared spectroscopy with attenuated total reflectance’, JAOCS 71, 371–377. SEDMAN J., VAN DE VOORT F.R. and ISMAIL A.A. (1997) ‘Upgrading the AOCS Infrared trans method for analysis of neat fats and oils by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 74, 907–913. SLEETER R.T. and MATLOCK M.G. (1989) ‘Automated quantitative analysis of isolated (non conjugated) trans isomers using Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy incorporating improvements in the procedure’. JAOCS 66, 121–127. SMITH E., BARBANO D., LYNCH J. and FLEMING J. (1993a) ‘A quantitative linearity evaluation method for infrared milk analysers’, J. of AOAC Int., 76, 6, 1300–1308. SMITH E., BARBANO D., LYNCH J. and FLEMING J. (1993b) ‘Performance of homogenisers in infrared milk analysers: a survey’, J. of AOAC Int., 76, 5, 1033–1041. SMITH E., BARBANO D., LYNCH J. and FLEMING J. (1994) ‘Effect of infrared analyser homogenisation efficiency on repeatability of uncorrected fat A and fat B signals’, J. of AOAC Int., 77, 5, 1217–1223. SMITH E., BARBANO D., LYNCH J. and FLEMING J. (1995) ‘Infrared analysis of milk: effect of homogeniser and optical filter selection on apparent homogenisation efficiency and repeatability’, J. of AOAC Int., 78, 5, 1225–1233. SUCHANEK M., FILIPOVA H., VOLKA K., DELGADILLO, DAVIES A.N. (1996) ‘Qualitive analysis of green coffee by infrared spectrometry’. J. Anal. Chem. 354, 327–332. ULBERTH F. and HAIDER H-J. (1992) ‘Determination of Low Level Trans Unsaturation in Fats by Fourier Transform Infrared spectroscopy’, Journal of Food Science 57, 1444–1447. ULBERTH F. and HENNINGER M. (1994) ‘Quantitation of trans fatty acids in milk/fat using spectroscopic and chromatographic methods’, Journal of Dairy Research 61, 517– 527. VAN DE VOORT F. (1980) ‘Evaluation of Milkoscan 104 Infrared Milk Analyser’, J. Assoc. Off. Anal. Chem 63, 5, 973–980. VAN DE VOORT F.R. and ISMAIL A.A (1991) ‘Proximate analysis of foods by mid–FTIR spectroscopy’, Trends in FS&T 13–17. VAN DE VOORT F.R., ISMAIL A.A. and SEDMAN (1995) ‘A rapid, automated method for the determination of cis and trans content of fats and oils by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 72,8, 873–880. VAN DE VOORT F.R., MEMON K.P., SEDMAN J. and ISMAIL A.A. (1996) ‘Determination of solid fat for index by fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 73, 411–416. VAN DE VOORT, F.R., SEDMAN J., EMO G. and ISMAIL A. (1992a) ‘Assessment of Fourier Tranform Infrared Analysis of Milk’, J. of AOAC Int., 75, 5, 780–785. VAN DE VOORT F.R., SEDMAN J., EMO G. and ISMAIL A. (1992b) ‘Rapid and direct lodine value and saponification number determination of fats and oils by attenuated total reflectance/fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 69, 1118–1123. VAN DE VOORT F.R., SEDMAN J., EMO G. and ISMAIL A. (1994) ‘Monitoring the oxidation of edible oils by fourier transform infrared spectroscopy’, JAOCS 71, 243–253. PATZ C.-D.
232
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
(1990) ‘Fourier transform mid-infrared spectroscopy for food analysis’. Trends in Analytical Chemistry, vol. 9, no. 4, 127–131. WILSON R.H., SLACK P.T., APPLETON G.P., SUN L. and BELTON P.S. (1993) ‘Determination of the fruit content of jam using Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy’. Food Chemistry 47, 303–308. WILSON R.H.
9 Microwave measurements of product variables M. Kent, Kent and Partner Scientific Services, Biggar
9.1
Introduction
Microwave electromagnetic radiation has been used in the determination of water content of various materials for at least four decades. It was applied following the germinal ideas of a number of workers in different parts of the world (Freymann 1954; Nedzvecki 1955; Watson 1957; Walker 1958). In spite of its successful use in subsequent years, there were also frequent failures, which of course remained unpublished. Many of those failures arose from a lack of understanding of the nature of the method. Part of the objective of this chapter is to help the would-be user avoid the pitfalls by providing some necessary insight. As a first step one should be aware of what is meant by ‘microwave’. The usual loose definition includes all electromagnetic radiation within a broad frequency range from 108Hz to 1011Hz (100MHz to 100GHz) or in wavelength terms from 3m down to 3mm. Historically most commercial instruments have operated in the so-called S and X bands, which cover the approximate frequency ranges 2–4 GHz and 8–12 GHz. The frequency of operation is nowadays restricted to such bands due to international agreements on electromagnetic interference. In the beginning however, I suspect that for those developing the method the choice was dictated by the availability of surplus military equipment, which operated in those bands due to arbitrary decisions regarding waveguide dimensions. The power levels of such instruments were, and remain, extremely low, typically a few milliwatts, so there is certainly no health hazard and in most circumstances little chance of interacting with other equipment. Because of the wavelength range being used by these methods we are always dealing with potentially serious scattering and interference problems arising from the similarity of the wavelengths to both the sample dimensions and the dimensions of any discontinuities within the sample (e.g. grain boundaries in measurement of corn). Too often this has been ignored and the power transmission through the sample has been interpreted in terms of scalar quantities or linear optics, in direct comparison with optical density measurements. In many cases such an approach is useful only as a first approximation and can sometimes be a very poor approximation indeed. Despite these potential problems however, much of the earliest successful work (see for example Ince
234
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
and Turner 1965) used the simple property of absorption of a beam of microwave power passing through a sample, relating this to the water content. Many of the subsequent applications used a similar approach but, as this chapter will show, this is far from the limit of the technique’s capability. Reference to the review and bibliography published by Kraszewski (1980b) shows how few applications of microwave measurement techniques in the food industry had been published up to then. Out of 400 publications recorded a mere handful referred specifically to foods, although there were known successful applications of the method with a diverse range of foodstuffs; grain, butter, margarine, cakes, nuts, breakfast cereals, extrusion cooked products, meat products, starch, pasta, sugar-beet products, chips, cheese, confectionery and many others. The last decade has changed all that. The same author writing recently, (Kraszewski 2000) cited 400 references for 1990–1998 alone, of which at least 110 referred to measurements on foods and agricultural produce. Many of the latter it must be admitted were from that author’s own laboratory but nevertheless it still reflects the large growth of interest in the method. Before discussing the applications in more detail it is perhaps a good idea to know a little more in general about the actual mechanisms involved in microwave power transmission and absorption since it is in this area that many of the pitfalls lie. For example, choice of measurement frequency is often crucial in avoiding perturbing effects of dissolved ions. Equally, the wrong choice of frequency could result in the measured microwave transmission loss decreasing with increasing water content where the reverse was expected. To avoid these and other problems it is useful to understand how, for a particular foodstuff, process variables such as temperature, composition etc., affect the dielectric properties over a wide frequency range. Such spectral information may be considered crucial. It is advisable to make dielectric measurements over a wider range of variables than might be experienced in practice. At the very least some indication of the dielectric properties may be found in compilations of such properties (Kent 1987). However for many materials, particularly those in the low moisture range, say below 30% m/m the problems encountered will be easily tackled. The most usual will be variations of calibration with temperature, bulk density (of granular materials) and particle shape. Before we tackle the fundamental science of the methodology however, let us first examine its advantages and disadvantages.
9.2
Overview of microwave techniques
9.2.1 Advantages If, as has been hinted, there are problems with the application of microwave dielectric measurements then the question must be asked as to what its advantages are. Consider the following: • Unlike infra-red measurements, the microwave technique can measure the bulk properties of the material and not just its surface. This is particularly important for inhomogeneous materials. • It can be non-destructive. • It can be non-invasive so presents no great problems for hygienic design and allows for cleaning in place. • It is non-hazardous, using very low power levels of microwave radiation of the order of a few milliwatts.
Microwave measurements of product variables
235
• Many of the variables that interfere with the accurate determination of the moisture content can in fact be eliminated or even simultaneously determined. • The measurement is not usually influenced by the presence of dust or vapours, although condensation must be avoided, as must excessive accretion of dust deposits. • The accuracy of the technique can be as good as or better than other conventional methods, although obviously it can never be better than the method used to calibrate it. Typically figures of 0.25% water content at levels of 10% are quoted for simple attenuation measurements (see Section 9.4.1) but by judicious use of multi-variable measurements this can be reduced to a theoretical level of perhaps 0.05% (KressRogers and Kent 1987). Apart from the limitation of the calibration the measurement of the microwave variables of phase and attenuation is subject to limiting accuracies. (Typically attenuation can be measured to 0.1dB and phase to within a degree or two but see Section 9.4 for explanation of these terms). The sensing heads are robust and multiplexing of sensing heads is a possibility allowing use of a single instrument that can be installed at some remote, less hazardous spot (for the instrument) if required.
9.2.2 Disadvantages • It is expensive especially if all the features to be discussed later are incorporated. • Applications often require careful design of sensing heads, which can be very dependent on the properties of the material to be measured. For example the most common form of sensing head involves transmitting and receiving horn antennae (Section 9.8.1) and care is needed in choosing the dimensions of the measuring cell to avoid errors. • The method is not absolute so requires calibration against some accepted standard method, e.g., oven drying, Karl-Fischer titration, etc. This in itself can introduce systematic errors as has been discussed in the literature (Kress-Rogers and Kent 1987). This is true of course for many other indirect methods of in-line moisture measurement. 9.2.3 Applications overview As will be seen later in this chapter, whatever method is used the correct choice of the measurement technique and applicator must be based on an awareness of the relevant food properties. This is necessary in order to apply microwave composition measurement successfully and benefit from the above advantages of this method. Most of the currently available methods are suitable for on-line application, for example the control of moisture content in margarine and dairy products during production, control of the sugar boiling process or measuring comminuted meat products. Such applications can be seen throughout this chapter. A summary of the various methods currently available and their range of applicability is shown in Table 9.1.
9.3
Dielectric properties and their parameters
9.3.1 Polarisation It is commonly understood that the atoms and molecules of matter comprise negatively charged particles (electrons) in some sort of orbit around positively charged nuclei (consisting of protons and neutrons). When a static electric field is applied to a material
Table 9.1
Microwave methods and their applicability
Method
Sensor
Transmission
Frequency
Advantages
Disadvantages
Applications
Closed Narrow-band, fixed waveguide frequency; limited by waveguide dimensions e.g. S-band, X-band
Geometrically well-defined sample. Density dependence can be compensated by complex 2variable vector methods
Density dependence generally unsuitable for on-line applications. Sample thickness limited for high loss materials
Laboratory measurements of low to medium moisture samples. On-line measurement of sheet materials
Stripline
Broad-band but usually operated at a single frequency
Can be used with high moisture foods
Possibility of errors due to air Fish, meat products, dairy gaps, sample inhomogeneity, products non-uniform surface
Antennae
Narrow-band limited by antennae dimensions
Non-contacting Maximum sample breadth unrestricted Density dependence can be compensated by complex 2variable vector methods
Density dependence. Sample thickness limited for high loss materials and minimum breadth limited due to diffraction around sample edges
Cut-off Broad-band but much of the Geometrically well defined sample waveguide information contained within a narrow variable band
Low to intermediate moisture fluids on-line, sheet materials, powders, grains, butter, cream cheese, confectionery, sugar solutions
Fluids, pastes and comminuted Density dependence. Possibility of errors due to air products e.g., margarine, spreads, cheese, meat products gaps
Reflection
Resonance
Antenna
Narrow-band limited by antennae characteristics
Non-contacting Sample breadth and thickness unrestricted
Coaxial sensor
Very wide band. High Sample breadth and thickness frequency limit due to coax unrestricted. Complex diameter spectroscopic approach yields other information and variables
Sample homogeneity important. Errors due to nonuniform surface
Sheet materials, powders, grains, butter
Possibility of errors due to air gaps and internal reflections. Sample homogeneity important. Errors due to nonuniform surface.
Fluids, pastes and comminuted products, e.g., margarine type spreads, meat products, and fish products. Authenticity
Open: Narrow band coaxial or waveguide
Compact: requires only scalar measurements for 2-variable compensation for density
Low penetration depth
Slurries, granular materials
Open: stripline
Narrow band
Compact: requires only scalar measurements for 2-variable compensation for density
Low penetration depth
Slurries, granular materials
Closed: Narrow band waveguide
Compact: requires only scalar measurements for 2-variable compensation for density
Sample size extremely limited Fluids e.g. butter margarine for medium to high loss samples
238
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
then the electric charges in that material tend to separate, the negative charges moving towards the positive electrode and the positive charges towards the negative electrode. If the charges were free, as in an electrical conductor, the applied field would cause a current to flow. In the case of a perfect dielectric material, where the charges are not mobile in this way, such a current occurs only briefly until equilibrium is established within the material. This equilibrium will occur when the effect of the field created by the separation of the two types of charge is equal and opposite in direction to that of the field applied. This redistribution of charge is called dielectric polarisation. For the case of a dielectric whose charge is uniformly distributed on each molecule, this polarisation merely results from the distortion of the charge distribution, and takes place almost instantaneously on applying the electric field. Such dielectrics are termed ‘non-polar’. In ‘polar’ materials positive and negative charges are distributed in such a way as to effectively form a small permanent electric dipole, analogous to a small bar magnet. Dipoles such as this can exist when the centres of mass (and hence the centres of charge) of the two charge distributions in the molecule (the orbiting electrons and the charged nuclei) do not coincide. In the presence of the applied field the movement of charge occurs through both additional polarisation effects and, more importantly, through rotation of the polar molecule and its dipole to a position of minimum potential energy in the field. This form of polarisation is distinguished from the distortional type by being termed ‘orientational’. 9.3.2 Dielectric dispersion The re-orientation in the field is not instantaneous and is characterised by a time interval referred to as the relaxation time, . It is better understood from the reverse situation, when the steady applied field is removed. The relaxation time is a measure of the time taken for the dipoles to return to a random distribution of orientations through exchange of angular momentum by collisions with other molecules. The relaxation time is thus temperature dependent. In the static field case we can assign a property to the material known as the ‘dielectric constant’, s, and this is a measure of how well the material can polarise. If the field is made to vary with time then a different situation develops. A polar dielectric, which in the static field case could have been considered perfect (i.e., dissipated no energy) will now exhibit a form of conduction loss. In an a.c. circuit a capacitor filled with such a dielectric would be effectively a capacitive reactance with a parallel resistance. For a low-frequency sinusoidal variation of the field the dipoles may be able to align and realign exactly in phase with the field. In this case the capacitor would have purely reactive impedance. As the period of the oscillation is decreased and approaches the magnitude of the relaxation time it becomes increasingly difficult for the polarisation to become complete. As this happens, the apparent dielectric constant or permittivity begins to fall. At periods even shorter than the relaxation time only the distortional polarisation contributes to the dielectric properties and the dielectric becomes effectively non-polar. The net result of all these effects is a high dielectric constant, s, at low frequencies and a low dielectric constant, 1 , at high frequencies. This frequency-dependent behaviour, which is characteristic of polar materials, is known as dispersion. For later reference it should also be noted that at any frequency there is a relationship between the permittivity and the more commonly known refractive index n which is written,
Microwave measurements of product variables p n
239
1
At high frequencies, especially for non-polar materials, the optical refractive index can be virtually identical to n in the absence of other effects. The nature of polar materials is best understood in terms of a complex permittivity, that is a permittivity having both real and imaginary terms. This is expressed thus, 0
j00
2
where the real part or permittivity, 0 , is the component of the dielectric properties which represents the ability of the dielectric to store energy, and the imaginary part or lossfactor, 00 , is that part which relates to its ability to dissipate energy. As will be shown later, the microwave transmission variables of attenuation and phase are directly related to the complex permittivity (Section 9.4.1). The ratio of 00 /0 is called the loss tangent, written as tan . Power dissipation in a material is proportional to this. The loss-factor 00 behaves in a somewhat different manner to the permittivity, 0 , in that it passes through a peak value as the frequency is swept. This peak occurs at the relaxation or critical frequency, fc given by, fc
1 2
3
How 0 and 00 depend on frequency is shown in Fig. 9.1 for a typical polar dielectric. It is also informative to plot 00 versus 0 . For such a relaxation spectrum a semi-circle results with its centre on the 0 axis and intercepting this axis at s, at low frequencies and 1 at high frequencies (Fig. 9.2). This is known as a Cole-Cole plot, Argand diagram or complex plane plot.
Fig. 9.1
Typical Debye dispersion showing frequency dependence of permittivity and loss factor: the frequency is shown as a ratio of frequency to critical frequency.
240
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.2
Typical Debye dispersion plotted in the complex plane: often referred to as a Cole-Cole plot.
Water is a very good example of a polar molecule. The spatial configuration of two hydrogen atoms with each oxygen atom is such that the orbiting negatively charged electrons have a centre of mass slightly displaced from the centre of mass of the positively charged nuclei, with the net result that a permanent electric dipole is formed. In fact the strength of this dipole, for the size of the molecule, is exceptional, and the dielectric dispersion is of quite a large magnitude: at room temperature s is 80 in relative units (relative to the permittivity of empty space) and 1 is approximately 5.0. The peak loss factor of 37 occurs at around 17GHz at room temperature and it is all these factors which make water so easily detectable at microwave frequencies. As a comparison a material such as vegetable oil has, at microwave frequencies, a permittivity of 2.6, a loss factor of less than 0.2 and no significant dispersion. This comparison however should be taken only as a general comment since water in foods at low concentrations can be expected to behave differently to a greater or lesser degree (see Section 9.4 and observe the non-linearity in Fig. 9.5 on page 244). A point to note is that water is not the only polar molecule of interest to the food industry and that other important food constituents may display dispersion with the loss factor peaking at some particular critical frequency. This raises the question of whether dielectric spectroscopy could be used to identify and measure compounds in materials containing a range of polar compounds. Alcohols for example, have relaxation frequencies ranging from MHz to GHz. Unfortunately, mixtures of polar molecules do not have well resolved spectra, as say in the infra-red spectrum, the dispersion and absorption spectrum of each covering a decade or two of frequency and overlapping considerably (see for example Bao et al. 1996). Synergistic effects also occur yielding a single relaxation time for mixtures. All is not hopeless however, and certain techniques of statistical analysis may help as will be seen later in Section 9.5.4. 9.3.3 Dielectric dispersion of water in foodstuffs Water molecules hindered in their rotation, by solutes or proteins for example, have a lower relaxation frequency than pure water and may even have a distribution of relaxation times. This tends to broaden even further the frequency range of the dispersion. For a Gaussian distribution of relaxation times about some mean value, the semi-circular complex plane plot shown in Fig. 9.2 becomes instead a segment of a circle with the
Microwave measurements of product variables
241
centre of radius lying below the permittivity axis. It is more frequently the case however that the distribution is skewed or even discontinuous and the spectrum in such a situation becomes more difficult to interpret. Relaxation times are influenced by a number of factors such as viscosity, binding at specific sites on other molecules, temperature or by change of state. Figure 9.3 shows the
Fig. 9.3
Effects of concentration of sucrose solution at 50ºC on (a) its permittivity relaxation spectrum, (b) its loss factor.
242
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
effect of concentration on the dielectric spectrum of sucrose solutions at constant temperature. The changes are directly attributable to changes in viscosity. Similarly, change in temperature shifts the relaxation frequency as Fig. 9.4 shows for the case of a 70% sucrose solution. This is a consequence of the fact that relaxation is assisted by molecular collisions and obviously these increase in rate as the temperature increases.
Fig. 9.4
Effects of temperature of a 70% sucrose solution on (a) its permittivity relaxation spectrum, (b) its loss factor.
Microwave measurements of product variables
243
Any rotational hindering of the dipoles will increase the relaxation time. Ice at microwave frequencies is effectively a non-polar material, its relaxation frequency being in the audio frequency range. The consequences of this for other applications of microwave energy such as heating/thawing are fairly profound. In thawing of foodstuffs by microwaves practically all the power dissipation is in the unfrozen fraction of water. Most foodstuffs, if not all, contain such a fraction, even at temperatures well below the freezing point of water. It is partly the relaxation properties of this water and the presence of dissolved ions (see later) which enable microwave thawing to succeed. Ice is essentially transparent to microwaves: hence the renowned inverse ‘Baked Alaska’ or ‘Norwegian Omelette’, which consists of meringue (microwave heated and cooked) encased in ice cream (low temperature and icy) instead of the normal configuration. On the other hand the presence of liquid water on the surface, or a thawed layer in the case of a foodstuff which has been allowed to take up heat from warmer surroundings, completely alters this and can screen the interior of the material from microwave energy by both absorbing and reflecting it. 9.3.4 Temperature effects Water therefore strongly influences the dielectric properties of foods. However, microwave studies of low moisture materials at room temperature, such as protein powders, show very little evidence, if any, of the water dispersion (Kent and Meyer 1984). As the temperature and moisture content are increased a high frequency relaxation appears but this is still very different in many aspects from the normal unhindered water relaxation. For any polar system increasing the temperature almost inevitably increases the relaxation frequency as we have seen in Fig. 9.4. For a frequency of measurement lying below the relaxation frequency, the measured loss-factor will decrease as the temperature increases and the dispersion moves up in frequency further from the measurement point. This would be the case for pure water if measurements were being made at 10GHz for example. In contrast, for materials where the measurement frequency is above the relaxation frequency, the temperature coefficient is positive until the relaxation frequency passes through the measurement point and thereafter is negative. A very wide variety of materials fall into this category at the measurement frequencies used for microwave applications. It is particularly true for low moisture materials. Some effect of all the perturbing influences may be seen in the temperature coefficients of the dielectric loss-factor of certain water bearing materials particularly organic materials such as foods. For such heterogeneous systems however, the wide distribution of relaxation times smears out the dielectric spectrum as described above. One consequence of this, which is to the advantage of the would-be user, is that no effects are seen of shifting peak loss with temperature as could be seen in the sucrose solution example in Fig. 9.4. In that example the loss factor could increase or decrease as the concentration or the temperature increased, giving dubiety to any measurements made at a single frequency. In heterogeneous materials, on the other hand, the temperature dependence is more predictable. A typical example of the dielectric properties of low moisture material is shown in Fig. 9.5. The data refer to measurements made at 9.4GHz on fishmeal, which being proteinaceous contains many sites at which water may be bound. The strength of binding depends on the site and the final result is a distribution of relaxation times with greatly hindered rotation of water molecules. There are of course alternative views of the reasons for this hindering which both broadens and shifts any relaxation spectrum to a lower
244
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.5
Loss factor 00 for fishmeal at 9.4 GHz as a function of temperature and hydration (from Kent 1970).
frequency range. Whatever the explanation however, it is inescapable that water dipoles are hindered in their rotation and at this microwave frequency a positive temperature coefficient for 00 results. 9.3.5 Bulk density Relationships derived in the 19th century by Beer (1853) and Gladstone and Dale (1863) were based on observations in various materials of the dependence on density of the absorption and refraction of light. Apart from temperature variation, the effects of which are relatively easy to compensate, the first users of microwave attenuation methods found that measured power losses also depended very much on bulk density. This is not at all surprising when it is considered that the dielectric properties are dependent on the number of dipoles within a given volume. Assuming no interactions between dipoles, it could be assumed that the losses of energy were directly proportional to density. It is possible to construct simple empirical equations connecting the bulk density and the complex permittivity. These take the form 0 A2 B 1
4
00 C2 D
5
where A, B, C and D are constants (Kent 1977). This bulk density problem has exercised the minds and ingenuity of many workers but principally a group in the USA dealing largely with the dielectric properties of grains and seeds. They have explored various empirical relationships between complex permittivity and density which, have involved not only quadratic type functions like equations 4 and 5 above but also cubic relationships. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to describe them
Microwave measurements of product variables
245
in detail but the reader is referred to Trabelsi and Nelson (1998). One of the problems associated with the measurement method is that each material to be monitored can have a unique calibration, which makes life difficult both for the user and the supplier of the equipment. This same group at the USDA has now published a unified calibration method for particulate materials. (Trabelsi et al. 1999). Density measurement and density compensation in moisture measurement are discussed for some food industry examples in Section 9.5.1. 9.3.6 Conductivity In addition to the dipolar loss in a material some contribution to the observed loss factor also arises from any d.c. conductivity possessed by the material. The effective loss factor associated with the conductivity is inversely proportional to frequency and may be written 00
2f 0
6
where is the d.c. conductivity (siemens.m 1), f is the frequency (Hz) and 0 is the permittivity of free space (farads.m 1). If ionic salts are present in a material the effective loss factor due to conductivity may mask any dipolar contribution from water, especially at low frequencies. This is another reason why microwave ovens are able to heat foodstuffs. At one typical operating frequency of ovens (915 MHz) the dipolar loss of pure water is very small at room temperature (tan is 0.05) and even smaller as the temperature rises. Only dissolved salts and the effects of rotational hindering of some water dipoles, (for example, due to the binding of water to a food matrix which, as we have seen, shifts their relaxation peak down in frequency) enable significant proportions of power to be absorbed by the foodstuff. For typical high moisture foods at 915 MHz tan is 0.4 at room temperature, an order of magnitude higher than that for pure water. At the higher oven frequency of 2.45 GHz the difference between conductive and dipolar losses is less but still important. As the temperature rises the difference becomes greater, the conductivity having a positive temperature coefficient and that for dipolar loss of pure water at these frequencies being negative. Returning to the problems of analysis however, it is well known that salt content can be estimated from the d.c. conductivity of materials. What should now be noted is that this conductivity can be obtained from the frequency dependence of the dielectric loss, adding a further dimension to the potential of dielectric measurements. It would be an advantage to have one instrument capable of simultaneous determinations of several composition-related variables using non-contacting and non-invasive methods. As will be seen in the following section, such a microwave instrument is a real possibility today.
9.4
Methods for measurement of dielectric properties
9.4.1 Attenuation measurements Frequent reference has been made to ‘attenuation’ of microwaves but to what exactly does this refer? It is the absorption of microwave power by a material and historically it was the basis for the earliest uses of microwaves in moisture measurement. The dielectric loss in a material can be measured from the attenuation and velocity of a plane wave
246
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
passing through the material. A plane wave is defined as a wave for which the phase is equal at any point in a plane perpendicular to the direction of propagation. The attenuation is a direct consequence of Beer’s law (Beer 1853) which is expressed as I I0 e
x
7
where I0 is the power incident on some plane within the material, I is the power at a plane distance x further into the material and is a constant known as the attenuation per unit length. Note that if we talk in terms of wave amplitudes rather than power then an additional factor of 2 must appear in the exponent. Note also that this equation takes no account of the wave nature of the radiation and by considering conditions only within the material it ignores effects of reflective power losses at the material boundaries. The attenuation, , is a function of the dielectric properties and can be written q 2 0 1
00 =0 2 2
12 1 nepers.m
1
8
where is the free space wavelength in metres. For many low-moisture materials tan << 1 so equation (8) reduces to
p0 tan nepers.m 2
1
9
At the same time because of the difference in refractive index of the material compared to free space and therefore as a result of the reduction of velocity of the wave in the material, we can write 0 q 12 ! 2 2 00 0 1
= 1 1 radians.m 1
10 2 which again, when tan << 1 becomes
2 p0
1 radians.m
1
11
which is the phase shift that such a wave undergoes passing through the material relative to that it would have had through the same distance of free space. For medium to high water contents, say above 30%m/m, the value of becomes very large even for short path lengths in the material. At 10 GHz for example, 50dB of power attenuation is readily achieved by a few millimetres of pure water, i.e. a reduction in power by a factor of 105. This makes the presentation of the material to the sensing head extremely difficult since the thickness of such samples needs to be restricted to keep the attenuation measurable. Typically 30dB should be considered maximal. Equations (8) to (11) refer only to transmission within a material. They do not take into account reflections at boundaries due to changes in impedance at those boundaries, nor the standing wave effects created by those reflections. Equation (8) however was the basis, albeit implicit, for all the microwave transmission applications up until the early 1970s. The effects of reflected power could be minimised by the expedient of matching the impedance of the microwave applicator or sensor to that of the sample. However, when the permittivity of a material is high the use of simple attenuation and phase is often precluded because it becomes extremely difficult to achieve this matching. Even if it
Microwave measurements of product variables
247
were achieved for a particular sample composition, any deviation from this would produce sufficiently large changes in the permittivity for the impedance no longer to be matched. For the case of low moisture content powders this is not a problem because the permittivity of those powders usually never deviates far from 2.0, matching is easily maintained, and in any case the reflection losses are slight (Brodwin and Benway 1980). This is even more so if the measurement system is incorporated into a loop controlling the composition. If transmission measurements are attempted without matching then the simple expressions for intrinsic phase shift and attenuation (equations (9) and (11)) do not apply. What is measured in fact is a variable called the transmission scattering parameter. It is not necessary to dig deeply into the theory of scattering networks to explain this new variable. Rather, suffice it to say that any device handling electromagnetic signals can be represented by a matrix of so-called scattering parameters S11, S12, S22, S23 etc., which are complex variables describing the signal at each input and output port of the device. A two-port system such as the dielectric sample in a transmission line can be described by four such S-parameters, which completely describe the reflected and transmitted signals at each of the two faces. When the reverse path through the system is physically identical to the forward path then this symmetry reduces these four parameters to two, S21 for the transmission and S11 for the reflection. It is S21 that interests us here. For a sample of permittivity and thickness d, at a wavelength , this may be written as 2
expp
z 1
12 2 exp
2pz p where p j2d=; z and
1 z=
1 z. In practical situations, the microwave power is usually transmitted through dielectric windows (see Fig. 9.12) which, unless arranged to be completely transparent at the wavelength of measurement (achieved by either making them a multiple of half wavelengths thick or very thin), introduce their own reflections of the power. This modifies S21 significantly, and it now has to be written S21
S21
1
1
1 1
2
expp2
z2 2 exp
2p z 2 2 2
1D E
13
where D and E are complex factors incorporating the thicknesses and dielectric properties of the windows and the sample 2 and 1 respectively (with corresponding z1 and z2) and z2 =
z1 z2 . 2
z1 As already discussed, all transmission methods are limited in use to moisture contents below about 30 per cent. This is simply because as water content increases then so does the measured attenuation, which means that the power levels being detected become impractically small. To avoid this problem a thinner sample may be used, but often this is also impractical for mechanical reasons. In addition, the thinner the sample the more precisely must the thickness be known, since the variables are also dependent on this dimension. The problem can further be reduced by the choice of a lower operating frequency (longer wavelength) if that is indicated as a possibility from all the other considerations.
248
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
9.4.2 Resonator methods Another set of dielectric property dependent variables that might be considered as suitable for application are those which characterise a resonant system. A typical resonator is essentially a metal box the dimensions of which cause standing waves to form, analogous to an organ pipe. A dielectric material introduced into this resonator causes its properties to change, notably its resonant frequency and its ability to resonate and store energy. Such devices have a long pedigree for dielectric measurements, both off and on-line (e.g. Birnbaum and Fremeau 1949, Bilbrough 1968, Risman et al. (1971), Kaatze 1973, Henry and Berteaud 1980, Kraszewski and Nelson 1994 amongst many others). Recently the tendency has been to develop open resonators that are placed in contact with a large bulk of material of interest. This type of resonator is coupled loosely to the material through fringing fields and thus tends to avoid the excessive power dissipation as described for transmission through very lossy materials such as pure water. They will be discussed in more detail in Section 9.7. Commercial devices based on resonators exist and have been used for dairy produce as one example. The usual variables measured are the resonant frequency of the resonator and its Qfactor (see Fig. 9.6). The latter is a ratio of the energy stored to that dissipated and as such is obviously conceptually similar and in fact is a function of the reciprocal of tan . By careful design of the system the resonant frequency is usually arranged to be linearly dependent almost entirely on the real part of the permittivity. f
f0 f0
1 Q
1
0 2
1 00 :F Q0
1:F
14
15
where F is a filling factor derived from the sample geometry and the field distribution in or adjacent to the resonator, Q0 and f0 are the Q-factor and resonant frequency with no sample present, while Q and f are those with the sample in place. Although resonator methods have been used for high moisture foodstuffs the same problem is encountered as in the attenuation methods (Section 9.4.1), though in a different guise. In this case, too large a sample with too high a loss factor can reduce the Q so much that it is impossible to measure either resonant frequency or Q-factor. Such problems can be avoided by ensuring that the filling factor is small and this can be achieved by weak coupling to the field. Within a resonant cavity the standing waves will have nodes at which the fields are zero, and for some limited distance on either side are only a small fraction of the maximum field. The interaction with these limited volumes of field can allow the use of relatively high loss materials but the dimensions remain restricted e.g. 5–10 mm diameter for a moist foodstuff. In open resonators only that fringing field occupying the space in the immediate vicinity of the open end is coupled to the sample, so once again the effective filling factor is low. Such resonators can be, for example, coaxial resonators with one end open and in contact with the sample and the other terminated with a reflecting plane. In this case although the filling factor is small the sample dimensions can be large. Provided the properties of the sample are uniform, the fact that the measurement is of only a small volume at the surface is of no consequence. Such a sensor is readily used in on-line applications.
Microwave measurements of product variables
Fig. 9.6
249
Definition of Q-factor and resonant frequency f with reference to the frequency response of a resonant microwave cavity impedance.
9.4.3 Reflectance measurements When a transmission line, be it waveguide, coaxial line or whatever, is terminated with a dielectric material, then because of impedance mismatch at the interface partial reflection of the incident wave occurs (see Section 9.4.1; in equation 12). This mismatch is a direct consequence of the difference in dielectric properties between the medium filling the transmission line and the material. The combination of the reflected and incident waves creates a standing wave in the line. The impedance of the dielectric can be found either by measuring the position and magnitude of this standing wave or by measuring the magnitude and phase of the reflected wave. From this impedance its dielectric properties can be computed. This is another two-variable method with which water content and another factor could be determined. Although a waveguide can be used in this mode a potentially more useful form of sensor can be constructed from an open ended coaxial line as described by Burdette et al. (1980) and many others. Kno¨chel and Meyer (1981) proposed the use of such a sensor for the measurement of the water content of slurries and Chouikhi and Wilde (1986) adopted it for moisture measurement in extrusion cookers. Its potential however lies in its broadband nature. Unlike waveguide, for which transmission cannot occur below a certain cut-off frequency determined by its dimensions (see Section 9.4.4 below), coaxial line can transmit all wavelengths. It has limitations above a certain high frequency, where its dimensions must be small to eliminate the propagation of waveguide type modes, but it is generally useful throughout the frequency range that might be considered for moisture measurement. This also makes such measurements amenable to spectroscopic approaches where as much of the dielectric spectrum as is needed can be used. This will be discussed later in Section 9.7.5. Because the measurement is made on one face of the material and not through it, like open resonators, reflection methods do not have the same limitations as transmission methods in respect of high water contents or high loss samples. In this case the reflected power increases as the water content increases though not in a convenient linear manner. The limiting condition of reflection is clearly when all the power is reflected and the reflection coefficient has a magnitude of 1. As the permittivity of the sample increases this limit is approached asymptotically. In addition, the limiting phase shift of the reflected wave is , so for high frequencies and high water contents relatively large
250
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
changes in moisture (permittivity) cause small changes in the magnitude and phase of the reflected wave. At lower frequencies the problem is much less and the changes are easier to measure accurately. In this frequency range however, the effects of dissolved ions on the loss factor are stronger and if the concentration is too high can cause errors due to problems of power loss and due to the phase shift approaching the limiting value of . The termination admittance at frequency f of such a probe in contact with a material of complex permittivity r is given by: 5
y0
f ; r r Gn 2r
16
where Gn is the radiation conductance of the probe found by the use of known calibration impedances and given by Gn
41 32 4 42 13 3 43 21 2 5
5
5
41 32 24 42 13 23 43 21 22
17
where the jks are the differences between the measured raw reflection coefficients of the calibration standards j and k. Determination of the unknown permittivity requires the use of numerical methods so, as with many methods in use today, some computing power is necessary. Some examples of such probes are shown in Fig. 9.7. 9.4.4 Guided microwave spectrometry Although the use of waveguide has limitations due to its fairly narrow frequency band of microwave power transmission, a recent development has exploited this fact. This fairly new technique is known as guided microwave spectroscopy (GMS) and as its name suggests it is a broadband approach (Jean et al. 1995). For convenience a rectangular cross-section waveguide is used, through which both the microwave power and the product to be measured pass in perpendicular directions. Because of its dimensions the waveguide cannot transmit power below a certain cut-off frequency given by fc
c p 2a
18
where c is the speed of light in free space, a is the separation distance between the critical sides of the waveguide and is the permittivity of the material filling the waveguide. By sweeping the frequency from well below cut-off to well above it, a spectrum of the
Fig. 9.7
Open-ended coaxial sensors for reflectance measurements (courtesy of R. Kno¨chel and Christian Albrechts University of Kiel).
Microwave measurements of product variables
251
magnitude of the transmission coefficient is obtained. This factor changes abruptly as the cut-off frequency is approached rising over a range of a few hundred MHz by some 60 dB. The position of the spectrum, its shape and amplitude, all depend on the various dielectric parameters that were discussed in Section 9.2 namely conductivity , low frequency permittivity s and relaxation time . In order to extract these data from the measurement transmission spectrum the calculated response of an ideal polar dielectric is fitted, i.e. one with only a single relaxation time. Although there is a mathematical function describing the response of the waveguide cell in terms of the dielectric properties of the material in it, the numerical fitting approach is faster and requires fewer computations. It was also assumed that the variation of the product around the desired composition would be small enough that this simplification would work. In fact an accuracy of better than 0.1% moisture content is claimed. The method has been successfully implemented on-line for measurement of salt and moisture in dough and batter, composition of meat, poultry, seafood and dairy products and sugar content of sweets. In a study of processed cheese the method determined water content to 0.16%, lactose (0.11%), fat (0.18%), salt (0.015%), and protein (0.065%). This method will be discussed again in Section 9.5.4.
9.5 Dielectric properties and measurement of bulk density and composition 9.5.1 Density measurement and compensation in moisture measurement It has always been recognised that some form of compensation for the bulk density of materials was necessary when attempting to measure moisture content in particulate materials by dielectric means (see Section 9.3.5). The usual solution was to incorporate some subsidiary means of density measurement, such as c-ray absorption (Mladek 1973, Zehnder 1967). This was an effective, if somewhat expensive method, which was often considered unsuitable for the food industry because of its employment of radioactive sources. It is still widely used however, and several commercially available systems incorporate it for density compensation (Klein 1996). For many applications the density problem was ignored and installations ran on the assumption that a reasonably constant density was maintained. Any variation in density likely to be encountered was considered tolerable and probably averaged to the same mean for a given water content. The errors engendered were thus absorbed into the overall inaccuracy of the system. Another approach adopted, in particular for building materials, involved compressing the material into a solid block to ensure minimum density variation from sample to sample. (Gooding and Bird 1963). In seminal work, the Polish workers Stuchly and Kraszewski (1965) and Kraszewski and Kulinski (1976) were the first to recognise the full potential of the microwave technique for density independent moisture determination without recourse to either of these solutions. They developed a system which, by measuring both phase shift and attenuation of microwaves, enabled density to be eliminated as a variable. Unfortunately this approach was ahead of its time. If modern data processors had been available then, nothing would have stood in the way of its implementation, but at that time the existing limited computing systems for on-line application plus the cumbersome electromechanically operated microwave variable components militated against proper commercialisation of the technique. It is also true to say that the assumed linear dependence of the measured variables on the moisture content in general is valid only over a narrow range of water content. The
252
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
dielectric properties of most food materials show distinct non-linear dependence on hydration, particularly at low levels in what might be termed the ‘dry’ range. For many process control applications, however, this is not a problem since if the control system is working properly the moisture content is restricted to a narrow band of desired values. It was some years before advances were made in the solution to this problem but the work of Jacobsen et al. (1980) Meyer and Schilz (1980 and 1981) opened up new possibilities. With a more sophisticated device to measure phase and attenuation the proposition was made that a simple ratio of attenuation to phase, R, would provide adequate density compensation for many materials. Experimental trials were carried out on tobacco and later Kent and Meyer (1982) examined the use of the method with a very heterogeneous material, namely fishmeal. Despite a wide range of density, particle size and shape this technique promised great advances. Not only was the ratio R reasonably density independent but it also seemed independent of the structure of the material. Part of the reason for its success in eliminating density dependence can be seen in the figurative diagram in Fig. 9.8. When the dielectric properties of the material are plotted in the complex plane then it is seen that for many materials the locus generated by varying the density is a straight line. For different moisture contents these loci all intersect the abscissa at the point (1,0). This should not be a surprise since these are the dielectric properties of free space and zero density of the material must be precisely that. The less trivial property is that for some materials the gradients of these lines can be density invariant and have the value, tan 00 =
0
1
19
It is a relatively simple matter using equations (8) and (10) to demonstrate that for low loss materials tan is very close to the simple ratio of attenuation to phase. Thus, providing the dielectric properties behaved in this very useful manner, then a density independent, moisture dependent variable could be obtained either from direct use of the measured transmission variables or from the derived dielectric properties. The latter opens up the possibility for the similar exploitation of other measurement techniques that yield the dielectric properties and these will be dealt with later. Powell, et al. (1987) found that for wheat the simple ratio R of attenuation to phase was far from independent of density. The work of Nelson (see Trabelsi and Nelson 1998) has already been mentioned in relation to the development of models for the dependence of the dielectric properties on density. He had shown that 0 1/3 was a slightly better linear function of density than equation (4) and that (00 e)1/3, where e is a small constant error term, seemed also to be linearly dependent on density. Powell et al. (1987) therefore arbitrarily replaced 0 and 00 in equation (19) by these alternative functions and improved matters slightly, reducing the overall variation in the ratio from around ±15 per cent to ±10 per cent for a density variation of ±40 per cent. When Kress-Rogers and Kent (1987) looked at the method of Meyer and Schilz (1980; 1981) in relation to coffee and milk powders, they too found slight but significant deviation from the simple result of equation (19). They also noted that for these fairly dry materials the phase measurement was virtually moisture independent while retaining density dependence. Such dependence on water content as appeared to exist was largely in respect of the fact that the density itself depended on the moisture content. This almost clear-cut separation of the two unknown variables led to the proposition that by some suitable calibrations against both density and water content, iteration between the two
Microwave measurements of product variables
253
Fig. 9.8 Typical complex plane diagram of variation of complex permittivity with density at a constant temperature and water content: the loss angles 1 ; 2 ; 3 , are shown for corresponding densities 1 ; 2 ; 3 and the density independence of is clearly seen (after Kent and Meyer 1982).
would not only refine the accuracy of the water determination but would also yield a result for the density. As could be seen in some of the author’s earlier work (Kent 1977) the complex dielectric properties occupy a regular space when plotted in the complex plane with moisture and density as parameters, with no crossing or folding of the curve within each family. This is shown in Fig. 9.9 using results obtained on milk powder taken from Kress-Rogers and Kent (1987). It is obvious that any measurement of 0 and 00 represents a unique solution for a given pair of variables, such as in this case moisture content and density.
Fig. 9.9 Dielectric properties of milk powder at 25ºC and 10 GHz as a function of moisture content and density: the heavy lines indicate the range of experimental data, while the thinner lines show the fitted extrapolated range based on equations (4) and (5) (after Kent 1989; Kress-Rogers and Kent 1987).
254
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.10
Ratio R versus phase for the data shown in Fig. 9.9 (after Kent 1989).
In practice the complex permittivity is never measured directly; rather other variables are measured which are related to this complex quantity. We have seen examples of these in Section 9.4. Such variables can also be complex and a choice exists as to which to use. For example, the use of intrinsic attenuation and phase shift has already been discussed as described in the work of Meyer and Schilz (1980). The density and the moisture content also occupy a very uniform space in the plane of the ratio R and phase, as can be seen in Fig. 9.10 which relates to the same milk powder data as Fig. 9.9. Bearing in mind the effects of errors in both phase and attenuation measurements it seems unnecessary to take the step of calculating R, which must be of greater relative uncertainty than attenuation alone. However, calculation of equation (19) from the resonator functions of equations (14) and (15) would eliminate both the filling factor F and the effects of density variation. Both of these approaches are available in commercial instruments. 9.5.2 Fat and water In all the work described in this chapter, whether it be density and water determination or this work on fat and water, one fundamental principle underlies the measurements. That is, that to measure variables with n degrees of freedom, one needs at least n independent measurements. When dealing with systems of two degrees of freedom, such as ternary compositions, or the problem of density and water, any pair of variables related to the dielectric properties satisfies this condition. (Remember that in ternary systems, knowledge of the proportions of two of the components determines the third.) These pairs could be phase and attenuation, or resonant frequency and Q factor, or reflection coefficient phase and magnitude. The problem of density and moisture can itself be regarded as one of ternary mixtures, the components being air, dry matter and water. Ohlsson et al. (1974) have published a great deal of data obtained at 2.8 GHz concerning the dielectric properties of ternary mixtures of fat, water and meat protein. The possibility of determining the composition of such mixtures from complex permittivity
Microwave measurements of product variables
255
measurements was mooted, but for triangular composition diagrams with the dielectric properties superimposed as contours of constant value, in some areas the loci of constant 0 and 00 were parallel or very nearly so. This meant that without any intersection there could be no solution in terms of the composition. These data can be replotted in Cartesian form to reveal more of the dependence of the complex permittivity on the composition. In Fig. 9.11 it can be seen that over quite a large region of the graph a unique solution obtains for any pair of permittivity values. Unfortunately, there is an area of confusion where the curves overlap, occurring when both fat and water content are low. This probably arises because of the non-linear dependence of the dielectric properties on the water content due to rotational hindering of water at lower fractions. It might even be considered that the water content could be separated into the two well-used and often abused fractions of ‘free’ and ‘bound’ water, or maybe even ‘natural’ and ‘added’. This would make the system quaternary rather than ternary and would require the measurement of at least three variables to remove the degeneracy. The addition of a fourth major component such as carbohydrates would also cause this problem. When transmission measurements are attempted without proper matching then, as discussed in Section 9.4.1, what is actually measured is the transmission scattering parameter S21. In practical situations, the microwave power is usually transmitted through dielectric windows (see Fig. 9.12) so S21 has been calculated from equation (13) using the data for the meat mixtures and assuming that the windows are constructed of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) 20 mm in thickness. The sample is also assumed to be 20 mm thick and the propagation through the sample is assumed to be a plane wave. The results of these calculations are shown in Fig. 9.13, where it can be seen that useful separation of the variables is obtained. The phase angle here requires some adjustment and m has been subtracted, where m = 0, 1, etc. according to how many wavelengths were reckoned
Fig. 9.11
0 and 00 at 2.8 GHz as a function of water and fat content for meat emulsions (after Kent 1989, data taken from Ohlsson et al. 1974).
256
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.12
Arrangement for microwave transmission measurements. Typically the horns are located at some distance from the windows.
to be contained within the sample thickness. Phase of course can only be measured and distinguished within the range to . Larger phase shifts must be inferred from a knowledge or estimate of the dielectric properties of the material and consequent modification of the observed phase shift. Clearly, even without impedance matching a useful calibration may be obtained as Fig. 9.13 demonstrates. In cases where only one component is known to change, e.g. the addition of fat to meat products or the changes of fat and oil content in certain fish species, then a reasonable estimation of the fat content can be obtained from a measurement of the water content. This was the basis of the development of the microwave fat meter seen in Fig. 9.27 (Kent et al. 1993b).
Fig. 9.13
Computed transmission variable S12 at 2.8 GHz for meat emulsions, assuming plane wave propagation.
Microwave measurements of product variables
257
9.5.3 Sugar solutions Having introduced the possibility of using microwave methods for more than simple moisture determination (see also Kent 1989), it is now necessary to explore these other regions of potential usefulness. One such could be in the on-line monitoring of the concentrations of hot sugar solutions. Published dielectric data of aqueous sucrose solutions (Kent and Kress-Rogers 1987) can be used to demonstrate this potential application. The data concern a concentration range from 20 to 60 per cent by weight at temperatures from 30 to 90ºC. The same arrangement has been adopted as for the meat mixtures, but in this case a sample thickness of only 10 mm was assumed. The results are plotted in Fig. 9.14 in the plane of transmission loss |S12| versus phase S^12. In this example, because of the smaller thickness of the sample, no further adjustment of phase was necessary except for the convenience of plotting. It is immediately clear that in this case the two unknown variables that can be obtained are concentration and temperature. Given that temperature can readily be measured by other means, then in fact only phase needs to be measured to yield the concentration. Use of the transmission loss alone would give ambiguous results owing to the curvature of the isotherms yielding two values of concentration for a given temperature and loss. This has been at the root of some problems encountered by the industry in the past in trying to apply transmission methods to this system. However, this type of transmission measurement may be unsuitable for this particular problem since sugar boiling is a batch process. An alternative is the use of some reflection technique and the coaxial probe already introduced could be the answer. 9.5.4 Multivariate approaches All the materials discussed so far have been mixtures containing water as the polar constituent, but this is not a necessary condition. As already alluded to, the method is applicable to any mixtures of polar and non-polar materials. Several publications have
Fig. 9.14 Computed transmission phase and loss at 3.05 GHz for sucrose solution as a function of concentration and temperature sample is assumed to be 10 mm thick between 20 mm thick PTFE windows.
258
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
appeared which contain data for mixtures of various alcohols with or without water (Mudgett et al. 1974; Dutuit 1980; Bao et al. 1996). These data show that composition measurement by the methods described here is feasible. No data are known concerning ternary mixtures of alcohols, but they are certainly worthy of investigation considering the problems encountered in recent years with adulterated wines. In addition, microwave methodology can be applied to more complex systems and problems than this. For example the dielectric spectrum contains information not only about the water present but also about its interactions with other variables such as fat, protein, salt etc. The spectrum over a two to three decade range of frequencies can tell us something unique about the material (Kent and Anderson 1996; Hall et al. 1994) but until recently such data were not utilised. Water added to foodstuffs, whether accidentally or deliberately by the addition of polyphosphates for water binding, can have quite different effects on the shape of the dielectric spectrum. In the native state the water has a particular range of relaxation frequencies dictated by its interactions at the molecular level with other constituents in the tissue. As water is added other constituents, notably ionic salts, become diluted and these can also diffuse into the exterior water if the foodstuff is immersed in it. This causes a fall in loss factor, 00 , at low frequencies because the dielectric losses depend on both polar and ionic d.c. conduction effects (Section 9.3.6), the latter increasing with decreasing frequency. On the other hand polyphosphate or NaCl solutions add conducting ions as well as water and the resultant spectrum is quite different showing a markedly increased loss factor at low frequencies (see Fig. 9.15). These apparently qualitative changes can be exploited. A technique, common in infrared spectroscopy, which can be used with these spectra, is the multivariate approach of principal component analysis (PCA). The raw data (say the complex spectral values and the temperature) are mean centred and standardised (divided by their standard deviations) to produce a set of variables with unit variance. This ensures that no single variable dominates the analysis. PCA then applies a linear transformation to the set of correlated variables to produce a new set of uncorrelated and standardised variables called ‘principal
Fig. 9.15 Two examples of measured spectra of prawns at 3ºC plotted in the complex plane. Each point represents a measurement at a given frequency. The lowest frequency (rhs) is 0.2 GHz and the highest (lhs) is 12.5 GHz. The treated sample was immersed in water and the result is both an increase in the dispersion at high frequencies and a reduction in conductivity by dilution (after Kent et al. 2000b).
Microwave measurements of product variables
259
components’, (PCs) (see Martens and Naes 1989). These components or scores are a linear combination of the original variables expressed as follows, Yj a1j X1 a2j X2 . . . aij X1 . . . apj Xj
20
where Yj is the jth PC, the Xi s are the original variables and the coefficients in the eigenvector aij are constants referred to as ‘loadings’. These loadings are calculated in sequence by maximising the variance of each PC. Often the first few PCs account for all of the total variance of the original set of variables. If this is the case, they may be used to summarise the original data and as an input to further analyses. The information on the proportion of the variance associated with each PC is given by eigenvalues associated with the eigenvectors. One purpose of PCA is to reduce a large number of variables to a smaller number containing almost the same amount of information. A further important result is that the transformed variables are orthogonal and uncorrelated and can thus be used in regression equations independently. The reduction in variables is achieved without the more scientifically rigorous but computer intensive procedure of attempting to fit spectral parameters of constituents to the dielectric spectra. The functions required for the latter are far from linear, unlike these PC transformations, and there is usually no adequate physical model to use. The emphasis is changed in this approach from trying to identify each polar constituent to that of using the overall change in shape of the spectrum. At this level the PC scores become shape descriptors. Where for any particular object the shape descriptors might be length, breadth, height, here the PCs act as independent variables describing the shape of the spectra. The subtle changes in shape of the spectra, as samples are treated with various solutions, are quantified by these PCs and they may even be used to discriminate different treatments, e.g. fresh or frozen, water added or not (Kent et al. 2000a). An example of the discrimination of prawns with added water using just 3 PCs is shown in Fig. 9.16. Having obtained the PCs or scores of the spectra, the various composition variables can then be regressed against those that are associated with most of the variance and calibration equations obtained (Kent et al. 2000b). In this kind of work most of the
Fig. 9.16 Three-dimensional plot of principal components of prawn spectra, demonstrating the separation into groups on the basis of just three principal components. The open circles are untreated samples while the full spheres are those samples with added water.
260
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
variance is usually associated with the first seven PCs. In general, although increasing the number of scores in the regression appears to improve the performance there is a danger of over-fitting. It is normal that the number of PCs used should be no more than one-third of the number of observations. With the calibration equation the scores for some unknown spectrum can be obtained by multiplying the new data (standardised with the calibration data means and standard deviations) by the PC loadings of the calibration set. These new scores are then used in the normal way with the calibration equation to generate predicted values of the appropriate variables. Using this method one can measure certain composition variables with an accuracy comparable to that of the proximate analysis used to calibrate the system. The variables for which this is true are liquid uptake (or added water), fat, protein, water and NaCl. Although this work has yet to be commercialised there is no doubt that in many instances it could be applied on line. Even without the broadband spectroscopic approach the open-ended coaxial sensor has been used in such a manner. Because it is a broadband approach, PCA can also be used to advantage with the GMS method described in Section 9.4.4. The spectrum here contains information about the dielectric properties of the material under investigation and their dependence on composition. This information is transformed in a particular way by the transmission properties of the waveguide at and around the cut-off frequency. PCA enables the original sources of variation, i.e. the compositional variables, to be extracted from this convoluted function without rigorous mathematical deconvolution. Apart from PCA, other multivariate approaches applied to dielectric spectroscopic data so far have been those utilising Partial Least Squares (PLS) (Lawrence et al. 1998) and Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) (Bartley et al. 1997). Both these applications are concerned with moisture measurement in grain.
9.6
Material structure
9.6.1 Particle shape and distribution The description of dielectric properties and their interaction with electromagnetic radiation in terms of composition may be inadequate in some cases. One of the most significant material properties, other than bulk density, to affect the reflection and absorption of microwave power is the shape of individual particles. This fact is demonstrated by a simple experiment (Chaloupka et al. 1980) in which water droplets are formed on a glass plate which is then placed in an electromagnetic field with its plane parallel to the electric field. The attenuation at a frequency of 16 GHz of this arrangement is found to be of the order of 0.5 dB. If another glass plate is brought into contact with the droplets, forming a sandwich, and the droplets are squeezed out into a continuous or semi-continuous film, then this attenuation leaps to around 20 dB. This is a consequence only of the change in structure of the water layer and is not due to any other influence. The same effect is seen in measurements on wet polyfoam as small quantities of detergent are added. The surface tension of the water decreases and the film formed on the foam surface becomes thinner. The principal factor governing this effect in particulate materials can be described in terms of ellipsoids of revolution and a shape-dependent depolarisation factor. If we consider uniform ellipsoids of water held in some dry material of permittivity m with a quite random distribution of orientation in space, then the effective permittivity is given by Van Beek (1967) as
Microwave measurements of product variables 1 eff m VW
W 3
m
X
1 1
A = r m
W ra;b;c
m
261
21
where w is the permittivity of pure water, Vw is its volume fraction and Ar is the shapedependent depolarisation factor. Ar takes values from 0 for needles to 1 for disks, with spherical particles having a value of 13. The ellipsoidal principal axes are represented by r = a, b and c. Clearly this example, with all the particles having equal shape, represents an idealised situation, but Chaloupka et al. (1980) have dealt with the more general case where the particles are of different shapes and have an arbitrary distribution. The outcome of their study is the description of a structure-independent variable derived from linear combinations of real and imaginary parts of the dielectric constant at different frequencies, and also the determination of a mean depolarisation factor A0. This is very interesting, especially for materials which do not absorb or bind the water and for which the water is essentially in its pure form. However, this is not generally the case with foods and, as has already been noted, binding of water significantly alters its relaxation properties. Thus in equation (21) the value of w required may be much closer to m, in which case the effects of Ar become very much less significant. The results of Kraszewski (1989) for wheat and grain confirm that calibration seems independent of grain type. 9.6.2 Particle size Particle size may be important as well, though Kress-Rogers and Kent (1987) found very little difference between ground and unground milk and coffee powders once the results were compensated for density changes. Such effects as were observed were attributed to thermal damage during grinding. However, finer particles of non-food materials have been observed to differ in properties (Dube 1970). Where d.c. conductivity is present, i.e. where a continuous conducting path exists, the increase in number of inter-particle contacts as the particle size is reduced can account for some increase in observed loss factor.
9.7
Apparatus for microwave measurement
9.7.1 Attenuation Having discussed at some length the dependence of various microwave variables on dielectric properties, now we need to know how these variables are measured. Commercial instruments for the measurement of microwave variables exist and are usually applied to the problem of water determination alone (see appendix for list of manufacturers). For an excellent categorisation and description of the various techniques the reader is referred to King (1999). Microwave circuits for the measurement of attenuation can be fairly simple in operation. The most basic is as shown in Fig. 9.17a. Here a microwave source, 1, feeds power through an isolator, 2, and then via a waveguide or a coaxial line to a horn antenna which irradiates the sample, 3. The function of the isolator is to prevent reflected power reaching the source and interfering with its operation. On the other side of the sample a horn antenna receives the unabsorbed power which is then detected by a crystal detector, 4. The signal at the detector clearly diminishes as the water content in the material increases and more power is absorbed. The signal is calibrated against the water
262
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.17 Methods for transmission measurement (attenuation): 1 microwave source; 2 isolator; 3 sample head and sample; 4 detector; 5 log amplifier; 6 output; 7 directional coupler; 8 feedback amplifier; 9 amplitude modulation and control; 10 reference attenuator; 11 difference amplifier. The black arrowheads represent flow of microwave power while open arrowheads indicate lower frequency connections.
content. There are some disadvantages with this type of system. Firstly, fluctuations in the power output of the source are wrongly interpreted as moisture variations. This can be avoided by signal levelling (Fig. 9.17b), that is adding an additional detector and feedback circuit, 8, to control by some means the power output. Secondly, the response is not linear, and for large values of attenuation changes in the water content have considerably less effect than the same absolute change would have at a lower attenuation. This could be avoided by displaying a logarithmic function of the detected current. A better solution is shown in Fig 9.17c. This is a dual-path system where the power from the source is divided by a power splitter, 7, or directional coupler into a reference arm and a measurement arm. The signals in each arm are detected separately and a signal proportional to the logarithm of the ratio is obtained electronically, 11. In this case, fluctuations in the source output appear equally in both arms and the ratio represents a true measurement of the transmitted power fraction. By using logarithms the results can be expressed directly in decibels. The slight drawback with this system is that the detectors must always be working within a square law such that the output voltage is proportional to the detected power level. This is not a problem if results from different instruments are not to be compared, but for transferable calibration it is essential that the detectors operate with the same response. Too high a power at the detector will take it out of its square law response into a linear region where the output is proportional to the field strength and not the power. All the systems described so far have involved straightforward d.c. detection and amplification. Some devices have been constructed with the addition of amplitude
Microwave measurements of product variables
263
modulation of the source power at a few kilohertz, followed by detection and amplification at this frequency. The advantages are simply that spurious signals or drift currents in the detectors and electronic circuits are not interpreted as fluctuations due to the sample. Alternatively, a single antenna can be used as both transmitter and receiver, the power passing through the sample and being reflected back through it to the antenna by a reflecting plate. The reflector’s position can be modulated thus modulating the received attenuated signal. This has the advantage of eliminating some of the unwanted reflected power from the surfaces of the sample. An available example of this type of system is shown in Fig. 9.26. 9.7.2 Phase Measurement of phase alone has not been explored widely but there are situations where it is eminently suitable. One example is the determination of sugar concentration discussed in Section 9.5.3, where coupled with temperature measurement, it provides a more readily interpreted result than attenuation. Phase measurement has also been applied to the on-line monitoring and control of butter (Shiinoki et al. 1998) (see Fig. 9.18). It has already been used for the measurement of the water content of tobacco (Ozamiz and Hewitt 1979) and the water content of coal (Klein 1996). The circuit devised by Ozamiz and Hewitt (1979) is shown in Fig. 9.19. This is a heterodyne system with both a signal source, 1, and a reference source, 6, in which the power in the reference and sample arms is down-converted from 1.25 GHz to an intermediate frequency of 160 MHz. This is the difference frequency between the two microwave sources. It is easily demonstrated that the phase difference between the two intermediate frequency (IF) signals is the same as in the microwave case. These signals are amplified and clipped to form a pseudo-square wave and then fed to a phase detector, 10. 9.7.3 Simultaneous phase and attenuation It is relatively simple to build a manually operated bridge for the determination of both phase and attenuation, and the early device of Kraszewski and Kulinski (1976) was
Fig. 9.18
A typical sample cell and its installation in a process line. This has been used for butter and other similar products. (Courtesy of Berthold GmbH & Co. KG).
264
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.19 Method of phase measurement (after Ozamiz and Hewitt 1979): 1 microwave source; 2 isolator; 3 power splitter; 4 sample head and sample; 5 phase shifter; 6 local microwave oscillator; 7 attenuator; 8 mixer detector; 9 amplifier; 10 phase detector; 11 output. The black arrowheads represent flow of microwave power while open arrowheads indicate lower frequency connections.
basically a mechanical version of that. Kalinski (1976) has devised several variations of a homodyne circuit which proved useful for phase compensation in glass water content measurements during glass production. Powell et al. (1987) have described a simple device for phase and attenuation measurements (Fig. 9.20). Microwave power is divided in the standard way into two arms, one feeding through the sample. After the sample the signal is further split, one half being mixed in the first mixer with half of the reference signal from a further quadrature splitter. The other half is mixed with the other phase of the reference signal in the second mixer. The result of these various divisions and mixing is to produce outputs from the two mixers proportional in the one case to the attenuation, 8, and in the other to the phase, 9. Departures from true quadrature power splitting need to be corrected by incorporation of phase shifters, 5, at the appropriate places. All of the systems described above can be replaced by the more advanced homodyne network analyser, which will be described later. Shiinoko et al. (1998) have used both a network analyser and a commercial moisture meter to demonstrate the applicability of this method to the on-line monitoring of butter production. 9.7.4 Resonant systems The types of resonators most commonly used have been (a) resonant waveguide cavities and (b) open ended transmission lines coupled in such a way as to enable resonance to occur. For the determination of the resonator variables many of the principles already employed for transmission measurements can be used. The change in transmitted power at resonance is a direct measure of change in Q-factor and tan . The frequency shift can be measured readily by a feedback circuit designed to maintain the source frequency at the resonant frequency of the loaded cavity. Alternatively, for small deviations of resonant frequency the source can be at a fixed frequency and the phase of the transmitted power can be monitored. For a narrow range around resonance this can be a reasonably linear function of permittivity (Bosisio et al. 1970).
Microwave measurements of product variables
265
Fig. 9.20 Method for phase and attenuation measurement (after Powell et al. (1987)): 1 microwave source; 2 isolator; 3 power splitter or directional coupler; 4 sample head and sample; 5 phase shifter; 6 hybrid splitter; 7 mixer detector; 8 attenuation output; 9 phase output. The black arrowheads represent flow of microwave power while open arrowheads indicate lower frequency connections.
Frequency measurement is crucial and with the advent of fast digital signal processors and waveform synthesisers the approach can become digital. A block diagram of a device described by Kno¨chel (1999) is shown in Fig. 9.21. The microwave generator is a phaselocked loop, 3, (PLL) stabilised synthesiser operating between 2.4 and 2.5 GHz. The device is controlled by a digital signal processor, 6, (DSP), via a suitable interface, 12. A reference signal for the PLL is provided by a numerically controlled oscillator, 2, (NCO),
266
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.21 Digital resonator system (after Kno¨chel 2000): 1 quartz crystal oscillator; 2 numerically controlled oscillator; 3 phase locked loop synthesiser; 4 low-pass filter; 5 resonant sensor; 6 digital signal processor; 7 analogue to digital converter; 8 detector; 9 switch; 10 20 dB amplifier; 11 variable attenuator; 12 interface. The black lines represent flow of microwave power while grey lines indicate lower frequency connections.
which is also controlled by the DSP. The NCO is capable of rapidly incrementing the frequency in small steps while the PLL is tuned more coarsely. The output from the PLL is thus incremented rapidly in frequency. The low pass filter, 4, shown is to reduce the effects of unwanted spurious signals and harmonics from the oscillator in the PLL. The resonator, 5, is a fringe-field capacitive sensor (Fig. 9.22), based on an openended quarter wave coaxial line and used in the transmission mode. The signal detection circuit after the resonator is straightforward. The attenuator, 11, is controlled by the DSP and exists both to maintain the power levels such that the detector always operates in its square-law region and to adjust the dynamic range of the device. Typically, for many modern devices which require to be used remotely, the system communicates with a central computer via a radio-frequency link, for which a small antenna is provided. One problem that emerges with such digital devices is that because the frequency is incremented the resonant frequency of the sensor is unlikely to coincide exactly with one of the frequencies generated. It thus becomes necessary to undertake some curve fitting or other data analysis to obtain parameters for calibration against moisture content. Daschner et al. (1999) have looked at several algorithms in respect of speed and computing effort in order to optimise the system. The worst approach appears to be that of attempting to fit a non-linear Lorentzian curve to the resonance curve. Far better was to forget the actual resonance parameters of Q and frequency and resort to principal component analysis as described in Section 9.6 using the first two PCs as variables in the calibration. This approach also enabled factors such as density variation to be accounted for. 9.7.5 Reflectance A basic reflectometer set-up for measuring the magnitude of the reflection coefficient would be as shown in Fig. 9.23. Here power is fed to the sensor in the normal way and the
Microwave measurements of product variables
267
Fig. 9.22 Hand-held microwave resonator moisture measurement system operating at around 2.45 GHz. (Courtesy of R. Kno¨chel and Christian Albrechts University of Kiel.)
reflected power is detected by means of a directional coupler or circulator, 3. Thereafter techniques similar to transmission methods may be used to obtain the required data. If magnitude and phase are to be measured simultaneously then the use of commercially available vector voltmeters or impedance meters allows for immediate acquisition of these two variables (Chouiki and Wilde 1986). The use of reflectance methods has become much more widespread in the last ten years. This is principally due to the wider availability of automatic network analysers (ANA): instruments that can measure the scattering parameters (see Section 9.2.2) in a broadband mode. A recent project on the microwave determination of composition of foods, funded by the EU also had as one of its objectives the production of a simple, dedicated ANA. The reflectometer developed uses the homodyne detection principle. That means only one RF source is used for generating the signal that is transmitted to the probe. The basic concept of a homodyne network-analyser is displayed in Fig. 9.24. A measurement stimulus and a reference signal are both derived from the same source, 1. The measurement signal is then frequency shifted by 86 kHz in a single-sideband
Fig. 9.23 Basic reflectometer for reflection measurement: 1 microwave oscillator; 2 isolator; 3 directional coupler or circulator; 4 reflection sensor; 5 detector; 6 vector voltmeter, impedence meter or network analyser.
268
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 9.24 Homodyne NWA (after Daschner et al. 1999): 1 microwave source; 2 power splitter; 3 single sideband generator; 4 directional coupler; 5 mixer; 6 matched load; 7 sensor and sample.
generator (SSG), 3. The SSG employs a special control loop in order to suppress the unwanted sideband and the rest of the original carrier by more than 40 dB, in order to improve the measurement accuracy. A signal of 3000 MHz is generated directly, 6000 MHz by frequency doubling and lower frequencies by heterodyning them in a mixer with a fixed frequency oscillator. The whole frequency generation is under control of a signal processor, which self-calibrates the SSG and the required sideband suppression at prescribed time-intervals in order to achieve the desired stability. The reflection from the coaxial probe is separated with a directional coupler, 4, as in Fig. 9.23, mixed down to the shifting frequency of 86 kHz, 5, converted from an analogue to a digital signal and then filtered and processed digitally. The instrument itself is shown in Fig. 9.25. Here the typical reliance of many modern systems on a computer is seen. The whole device is menu driven and data are displayed in a variety of forms on the computer screen. The tasks of the software are to provide a user interface, to perform the signal processing, to display and store the measurement results and to communicate with the network-analyser.
9.8
Sensors
9.8.1 Horn antennae Now that both the microwave measurement techniques available and the basic construction of the microwave circuits involved have been described, a few words are called for on the subject of sensors. The term ‘sensor’ in this context means the interface between the microwave apparatus and the material being measured. Two such interfaces have already been met, the horn antenna and the coaxial probe. There are other possibilities, however, and these will now be considered. The horn type of antenna itself requires a little further discussion in order to comprehend both its use and its misuse. Basically, a horn is an attempt to match the impedance of a waveguide to that of free
Microwave measurements of product variables
Fig. 9.25
269
Composition monitor developed under the EC FAIR programme, project no. CT3020. (Courtesy of R. Kno¨chel and Christian Albrechts University of Kiel.)
space, at the same time increasing the directivity of the radiation. A typical system using horns is shown in Fig. 9.26. The device shown here is a monostatic transmission system. Antennae for three different frequency bands are shown. A sudden transition between a waveguide and free space, or indeed any material, results in a large reflection of power back into the waveguide owing to the impedance mismatch that occurs. By flaring the waveguide into the shape of a horn, this mismatch is reduced and a greater efficiency of transmission of power occurs. Horns that taper
Fig. 9.26 Monostatic transmission apparatus operating at a fixed frequency between 3 and 12.5 GHz. Three of the available antenna are shown. (Courtesy of Ray King and KDC Technology Corp., California.)
270
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
gradually in a curved longitudinal section are better than the standard straight tapered horns. Antennae are distinguished by certain interesting and relevant variables. The first of these, referred to as the ‘gain’, is a measure of the efficiency of such a device in directing power in a certain direction with reference to a perfect isotropic radiator, and is related both to its aperture size and the spread of the beam. In simple terms the beamwidth can be visualised as the cone of radiation emitted or received by such a device. Thus a short horn with a given aperture will have a much wider beam than a longer horn of the same aperture. The beamwidths are different for the two perpendicular planes of the electric and magnetic components of the wave. A typical horn, 4 wavelengths long, with an aperture 3 wavelengths square would have beamwidths between 15º and 20º in the respective electric and magnetic planes. In general however, because such horns are used in what is termed their ‘near-field’ beam width and gain are irrelevant being defined for the ‘far-field’. The far field is at distances greater than 2D2/, where D is the largest aperture dimension and is the wavelength. As we move away from the central axis the far-field strength diminishes continuously, the pattern of field strength versus angle being an elongated pear shape or lobe with several side lobes. The side lobes result from the effects of interference and diffraction of the wave. The existence of these lobes means that it is possible for the antenna to pick up signals, albeit of low response, from places far off axis. This is not a great problem in the measurements described here unless the criteria discussed below are not adhered to. Mladek and Beran (1980) have shown that certain critical dimensions must be achieved for a successful application of even such a simple sensor. These dimensions depend very much on the material properties and are chosen so as to minimise errors from standing waves, reflections at the side boundaries of the material, and diffraction of waves around the sample to the receiver rather than through it. Thus for wheat, say with a moisture content of 5 per cent at a measurement frequency of 10 GHz, a layer at least 15 cm thick is required. To avoid reflections from the boundaries of the sample it should then be at least 1.5 times wider than this thickness. The dimensions of the horns are also critical in the reduction of reflections. It has been calculated that, when measuring wheat at this frequency, a 14 cm thick sample should be at least 28 cm wide with rectangular horn antennae apertures of 4.5 7.0 cm. In this way, the anticipated error resulting from the shape and size of the sample could be reduced to less than 1 per cent. Many improvements can be made to the simple horn antenna, all of which add to its expense. For example, microwave absorbent material can be used to line the boundary of the aperture or Fresnel lenses may be fitted to more clearly collimate the beam, i.e. narrow its width. Perfect pencil beams, however, are impossible to achieve with apertures that are only a few wavelengths in size; interference effects always operate to produce side lobes. Even longer horns cannot achieve much better than roughly 10º beamwidth within the limits of size dictated by practicality. This fact should never be ignored. The propagation from horns is usually considered to be a plane wave. This is not actually the case, especially close to the antenna, and small errors occur in the near-field region if equations such as (17) which are derived assuming plane wave propagation are assumed to apply exactly. This is not important, however, and merely means that real calibrations will yield slightly different results from the theoretical ones discussed in Sections 9.4 and 9.5.
Microwave measurements of product variables
271
9.8.2 Stripline sensors A transmission line known as stripline or microstrip has been described in several publications (Kent 1972; Kent and Price 1979) for use as a sensor for transmission microwave measurements. Applications to both rice and grain (Miyai 1978), to oil palm fruits (Khalid and Abbas 1996) and to milk products, (Kent et al. 1993a) have since been described. An instrument using the sensor for the measurement of fat content in fish and meat (Kent 1990 and Kent et al. 1993b) has also been on the market for several years (see Fig. 9.27). The sensor can best be visualised by beginning with a coaxial line, which is then split lengthwise, opened out and flattened. The result is a dielectric sheet or slab with a conducting ground plane on one side, and a conducting strip on the other. When another dielectric material is placed on top of the strip, the measured transmission loss of the line increases. This can be calibrated against permittivity or water content, whatever is required. The phase shift is also found to be dependent on the properties of the second material and so can also be used for composition measurements, as Ozamiz and Hewitt (1979) have done with tobacco. The advantage of this type of sensor over normal transmission measurements is that, like the open resonator, higher water contents can be measured. In this case of simple transmission, as we have seen in Section 9.4, the losses measured in high water content foods are high even for very short path lengths in the material. The stripline sensor is a much less sensitive device and can cope with a much larger bulk of material. Its low sensitivity, however, is only an advantage in that respect. One of its problems is that in contrast to the normal transmission measurements this sensor requires contact with the material of interest. Because of its structure it can be constructed to dip into liquids and so is useful for batch processes but given the highly corrosive cleaning agents that are used in modern cleaning-in-place practices, for example, severe design constraints are placed on the materials of the sensor.
Fig. 9.27 A simple attenuation device operating at 2 GHz and using a stripline sensor. Although the sensor responds to the amount of water present, in situations such as this where the meter is being used on unprocessed fish, then this response can also be related to the fat content. (Courtesy of Distell Industries Ltd, Scotland.)
272
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
9.8.3 Stripline antennae The use of stripline as a microwave sensor has just been described, and its operation could be described in terms of radiative power loss from the strip in the presence of a second dielectric above it. Stripline can be constructed however, to radiate more efficiently into free space, and such stripline antennae could be very useful in the kinds of applications that we are discussing here. Basically such an antenna consists of a very broad strip or patch or even of a hole in a patch. The instantaneous distribution of charge on the patch and its movement excite radiation. Numerous variations can be devised. Kno¨chel (1999) has described the use of such patch antennae. The crucial aspect is that they are far cheaper to manufacture than even the simplest horn antenna. The performance could not be expected to be as good as the horn, with poorer directivity and radiation pattern, but these are problems that could be reduced by careful use. Horns are expensive items to construct, whether they be electroformed or constructed piecemeal. The use of a stripline antenna offers a very cheap alternative. 9.8.4 Open-ended transmission lines For the measurement of reflectance a number of different sensors can be considered. The impedance mismatch that is minimised in the use of horn antennae can be put to good advantage if the reflected power is used as a measure of the material’s properties. Similarly, open-ended coaxial sensors have been described in Section 9.4.3 for use as reflection sensors. This type of configuration can be considered in terms of the fringe capacitance that exists at the open end of the line. This capacitance is changed by the presence of a dielectric material and so the measured reflectance changes. This simple structure can be modified by extending the centre conductor into the material, where it acts as a monopole antenna radiating power into the sample. The antenna impedance is modelled in effect by the following equation: p :0 Z
! Z
!;
22 0 where Z is the impedance, ! is the angular frequency (2f ), is the permittivity, 0 is the relative permittivity of free space, is the intrinsic impedance of the material and 0 is the impedance of free space. Such antennae have been widely used for measurements of biological tissues (Burdette et al. 1980). The special case when the monopole is of zero length is otherwise recognised as the open-ended coaxial line probe (Section 9.4.3).
9.9
Areas for development
During the 10th European Microwave Conference held in Warsaw in 1980, some of the few individuals working in the field that has been called ‘microwave aquametry’ were able to meet and discuss its development. It is instructive to see both the transcript of that discussion and the answers to a questionnaire circulated before the meeting. They can be found in a special issue of the Journal of Microwave Power edited by Andrzej Kraszewski (see Kraszewski 1980a; 1980b). There have been several similar workshops since then and what has become clear is that there has been a trend towards the multivariate approach to which the author alluded in the last edition of this book and which is described in more detail in this edition. This trend has been driven in part by the
Microwave measurements of product variables
273
fact that today personal computers offer the opportunity to analyse and manipulate data in ways that were not possible 20 years ago. This is true not only in the use of microwave spectroscopy but also in other techniques. The personal computer has also been adopted to drive the instrument, to calibrate it and to correct for errors. As has been shown, the microwave technique need not stop at one or two variables alone and the most important requirement now is that instruments become available using multi-variable measurements for the implementation of the kind of methods of composition analysis described above. The advent of intelligent instruments renders calibration a simpler task, and techniques of continuous recalibration can improve the accuracy of the output.
9.10
References
BAO, J-Z, SWICORD, M. L.
and DAVIS, C. C. (1996) ‘Microwave dielectric characterisation of binary mixtures of water, methanol and ethanol’. Journal of Chemical Physics, 104, 74–83. BARTLEY, P.G., MCLENDON, R.W. and NELSON, S.O. (1997) ‘Moisture determination with an artificial neural network from microwave measurements on wheat’ IEEE Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, 2, 1238–1243. BEER, A. (1853) ‘Einleitung in die ho ¨ here Optik, 1st edn. Brunswick. BILBROUGH, J. (1968) Microwave apparatus for measuring moisture content. UK Patent 1, 111, 384. BIRNBAUM, G. and FREMEAU, J. (1949) ‘Measurement of the dielectric constant and loss of liquids and solids by a cavity perturbation method’ Journal of Applied Physics, 20, 817–818. BOSISIO, R. G., GIROUX, M. and COUDERE, D. (1970) ‘Paper sheet moisture measurements by microwave phase perturbation techniques’ Journal of Microwave Power, 5, 25–34. BRODWIN, M. and BENWAY, J. (1980) ‘Experimental evaluation of a microwave transmission moisture sensor’ Journal of Microwave Power, 15, 261–265. BURDETTE, E. C., CAIN, F. and SEALS, J. (1980) ‘In-vivo probe measurement technique for determining dielectric properties at VHF through microwave frequencies’ IEEE Transactions, MTT-28, 414–427. CHALOUPKA, H., OSTWALD, O. and SCHIEK, B. (1980) ‘Structure independent microwave moisture-measurements’ Journal of Microwave Power, 15, 221–231. CHOUIKHI, S. M. and WILDE, P. J. (1986) ‘Reflection of an open-ended coaxial line and application to moisture content measurement’ Proceedings of the International Measurement Conference on Tests and Transducers, vol. 2, 251–264. ¨ CHEL, R. and KENT, M., (1999) ‘Resonator-based microwave moisture DASCHNER, F., KNO meter with optimised digital processing’ Third Workshop on Electromagnetic Wave Interactions with Water and Moist Substances, USDA-ARS, Athens, GA, USA. DUBE, D. C. (1970) ‘Study of Landau-Lifshitz-Looyenga’s formula for dielectric correlation between powder and bulk’ Journal of Physics D, Applied Physics 3, 1648–1652. DUTUIT, Y. (1980) ‘Construction of a time domain spectrometer. A contribution to the improvement of methods of analysis of dielectric relaxation spectra and application’ PhD thesis, University of Bordeaux I. FREYMANN, R. (1954) Procedure and apparatus for determining the water content and the properties of free and bound water contained in various materials. French Patent 1,102,199.
274
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
and DALE, T. P. (1863) ‘Researches on the refraction, dispersion and sensitiveness of liquids’ Philosophical Transactions, 153, 317–343. GOODING, R. G. and BIRD, D. (1963) ‘An apparatus for continuous measurement of water content of foundry sand’ BICRA Journal, 11, 641–661. HALL, M., ZHUO, L. and GABRIEL, C. (1994) ‘Spectroscopic investigation of the dielectric properties of some foods and food components’ Microwave Science Series, no 8, Ministry of Agriculture Fisheries and Food London, UK. HENRY, F. and BERTREAUD, A. J. (1980) ‘New measurement technique for the dielectric study of solutions and suspensions’ Journal of Microwave Power, 15, 233–242. INCE, A. D. and TURNER, A. (1965) ‘The determination of moisture in plain cakes by a microwave attenuation technique’ The Analyst, 90, 692–696. JACOBSEN, R., MEYER, W. and SCHRAGE, B. (1980) ‘Density independent moisture meter at X-band’ Proceedings of the 10th European Microwave Conference, Warsaw, 526. JEAN, B. R., WARREN, G .L. and WHITEHEAD, F. L. (1995) US Patent 5455516, 3. KAATZE, V. (1973) ‘A cavity resonator method for measuring the complex permittivity of small amounts of liquids in the frequency range 0.7–25 GHz’ Applied Physics, 2, 241–246. KALINSKI, J. (1976) ‘Automatic phase control system for microwave industrial on-line moisture-attenuation-voltage (MAV) convertor’ IEEE Transactions, IECI25, 425– 427. KENT, M. (1972) ‘The use of strip-line configuration in microwave moisture measurement’ Journal of Microwave Power, 7, 185–193. KENT, M. (1977) ‘Complex permittivity of fishmeal; a general discussion of temperature, density and moisture dependence’ Journal of Microwave Power, 12, 341–345. KENT, M. (1987) Dielectric and Electrical Properties of Foodstuffs. Science and Technology Publishers, London. KENT, M. (1989) ‘Application of two-variable microwave techniques to composition analysis problems’ Transactions of the Institute of Measurement and Control, 11, 58–62. KENT, M., (1990) ‘Hand-held instrument for fat/water determination in whole fish, Food Control. 1, 47–53. KENT, M. and PRICE, T. E. (1979) ‘Compact microstrip sensor for high moisture content measurement’ Journal of Microwave Power, 14, 363–365. KENT, M. and MEYER, W. (1982) ‘A density-independent microwave moisture meter for heterogeneous foodstuffs’ Journal of Food Engineering, 1, 31-42. KENT, M. and MEYER, W. (1984) ‘Complex permittivity of protein powders as a function of temperature and hydration. Journal of Physics D, Applied Physics, 17, 1687–1698. KENT, M. and KRESS-ROGERS, E. (1987) ‘The COST90bis collaborative work on the dielectric properties of foods. In Physical Properties of Foods, vol. 2, eds R. Jowitt, F. Escher, M. Kent, B. McKenna and M. Roques, 171–197, Applied Science Publishers, Elsevier, London. KENT, M., ELDER, B., LEONARD, C., LEES, A. and CHRISTIE, R. H. (1993a) ‘An on-line microwave instrument to monitor the solids contents of milk products during processing.’ J. Society of Dairy Technology, 46, 96–99. KENT, M., LEES, A. and CHRISTIE, R. H, (1993b) ‘Estimation of the fat content of minced meat using a portable microwave fat meter’ Food Control, 4, 222–225. KENT, M. and ANDERSON, D. (1996) ‘Dielectric studies of added water in poultry meat and scallops’ Journal of Food Engineering 28: 239–259. ¨ CHEL, R. and DASCHNER, F. (2000a) KENT, M., MACKENZIE, K., BERGER, U-K., KNO GLADSTONE, J. H.
Microwave measurements of product variables
275
‘Determination of prior treatment of fish and fish products using microwave dielectric spectra’ Eur Food Res Technol 210 6, 427–433. ¨ CHEL, R., DASCHNER, F. and BERGER, U-K. (2000b) ‘Composition of foods KENT, M., KNO using microwave dielectric spectra’ Eur Food Res Technol. 210 5, 359–366. KHALID, K. B. and ABBAS, Z. B. (1996) ‘Development of microstrip sensor for oil palm fruits’ in Microwave Aquametry, ed. A Kraszewski, pp239–248, IEEE Press, Piscataway, New Jersey, USA. KING, R. J. (1999) ‘On-line industrial applications of microwave moisture sensors’ in Sensors update, pp 109–170, eds. H. Baltes, W. Go¨pel and J. Hesse, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim. KLEIN, A. (1996) ‘On-line moisture measuring with ‘Micromoist’, in Microwave Aquametry, ed. A Kraszewski, pp 363–371, IEEE Press, Piscataway, New Jersey, USA. ¨ CHEL, R. and MEYER, W. (1981) ‘Continuous moisture determination in fluids and KNO slurries’ Proceedings of the 1981 IMPI Symposium on Microwave Power, Toronto, 193–195. ¨ CHEL, R. (1999) ‘Technology and signal processing of dielectrometric microwave KNO sensors for industrial applications’, in Sensors update, pp 65–105, eds H. Baltes, W. Go¨pel and J. Hesse, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim. KRASZEWSKI, A. (1978) ‘A model of the dielectric properties of wheat at 9.4 GHz’ Journal of Microwave Power, 13, 293–296. KRASZEWSKI, A. (1980a) Microwave Aquametry – a review’ Journal of Microwave Power, 15, 209–220. KRASZEWSKI, A. (1980b) Microwave aquametry – a bibliography 1955–1979’ Journal of Microwave Power, 15, 298–310. KRASZEWSKI, A. (1989) ‘Moisture monitoring of moisture content in grain further considerations’ Journal of Microwave Power, 23, 236–246. KRASZEWSKI, A. (2000) ‘Recent bibliography on moisture sensing: 1990–1998 (Sensors, methods, Applications)’ in Sensors update, pp 393–414, eds H. Baltes, W. Go¨pel and J Hesse, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim. KRASZEWSKI, A. and KULINSKI, S. (1976) ‘An improved microwave method of moisture content measurement and control’ IEEE Transaction, IECI-23, 364–370. KRASZEWSKI, A. W. and NELSON, S.O. (1994) ‘Microwave resonator for sensing moisture content and mass of single wheat kernels’ Canadian Agricultural Engineering, 36, 231–238. KRESS-ROGERS, E. and KENT, M. (1987) ‘Microwave measurement of powder moisture and density’ Journal of Food Engineering, 6, 345–376. LAWRENCE, K.C., WINDHAM, W.R. and NELSON, S.O. (1998) ‘Wheat moisture determination by 1 to 110 MHz swept frequency admittance measurements’ Trans ASAE, 41, 135– 142. MARTENS, H. and NÆS, T. (1989) ‘Multivariate Calibration’, Chichester, UK, John Wiley and Sons, pp. 254–258. MEYER, W. and SCHILZ, W. (1980) ‘A microwave method for density independent determination of the moisture content of solids’ Journal of Physics D, Applied Physics, 13, 1823–1830. MEYER, W. and SCHILZ, W. (1981) ‘Feasibility study of density-independent moisture measurement with microwaves’ IEEE Transactions, MTT29, 732–739. MIYAI, Y. (1978) ‘A new microwave moisture meter for grains’ Journal of Microwave Power, 13, 213–218.
276
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
(1973) ‘Determination of the moisture content of granular materials by a microwave method’ Zemedelska Technika, 19, 453–458. MLADEK, J. and BERAN, Z. (1980) ‘Sample geometry, temperature and density factors in the microwave measurement of moisture’ Journal of Microwave Power, 15, 243– 250. MUDGETT, R. E., WANG, D. I. C. and GOLDBLITH, S. A. (1974) ‘Prediction of dielectric properties in oil-water mixtures at 3000 MHz, 25ºC based on pure component properties’ Journal of Food Science, 39, 632–635. NBS (1958) Tables of dielectric dispersion data for pure liquids and dilute solutions. National Bureau of Standards circular 589, US Department of Commerce, Washington DC. NEDZVECKI, Y. E. (1955) ‘Electrical determination of moisture content in non-conducting materials and arrangement for its realisation’ USSR Patent 107, 977. NELSON, S.O. (1994) ‘Measurement of microwave dielectric-properties of particulate materials’ Journal of Food Engineering, 21, no.3, pp. 365–384. OHLSSON, T., HENRIQUES, M. and BENGTSSON, N. E. (1974) ‘Dielectric properties of model meat emulsions at 900 and 2800 MHz in relation to their composition’ Journal of Food Science, 39, 1153–1156. OZAMIZ, J. M. and HEWITT, S. J. (1979) ‘Microwave moisture measurement system’ Proceedings of the 9th European Microwave Conference, Brighton, UK, MS2, Microwave Exhibition and Publishers, UK. POWELL, S. D., MCLENDON, B. D., NELSON, S. O. and ALLISON, J. M. (1987) ‘Use of a density independent function and microwave measurements system for grain moisture measurements’ Paper 873053, Meeting of ASEA, Baltimore. RISMAN, P. O. and BENGTSSON, N. E. (1971) ‘Dielectric properties of foods at 3 GHz as determined by a cavity perturbation technique’ Journal of Microwave Power, 6, 107–123. SHIINOKI, Y., MOTOURI, Y. and ITO K. (1998) ‘On-line monitoring of moisture and salt contents by the microwave transmission method in a continuous salted butter-making process’ Journal of Food Engineering, 38, no. 2, pp. 153–167. STUCHLY, S. and KRASZEWSKI, A. (1965) ‘Method for the determination of water content in solids, liquids and gases by means of microwaves and arrangement for application of this method’ Polish Patent 51,731. TRABELSI, S. and NELSON, S. O. (1998) ‘Density independent functions for on-line moisture meters: a general discussion’ Meas Sci Technol vol. 9 570–578. TRABELSI, S., KRASZEWSKI, A. W. and NELSON S. O. (1999) ‘A unified calibration method for moisture sensing in particulate materials’ Electronics Letters, 35, No. 16, pp. 1346– 1347. VAN BEEK, L. K. H. (1967) ‘Dielectric behaviour of heterogeneous systems’ Progress in Dielectrics, 7, 69–114. WALKER, C. W. (1958) ‘Apparatus and method for measurement of moisture content’ US Patent 3,079,551. WATSON, A. (1957) ‘Improvements in and relating to the determination of moisture content’ UK Patent 897,956. ZEHNDER, C. B. (1967) ‘Application of the combination microwave-gamma ray gauge to wood chip weight and moisture measurement’ Pulp and Paper Magazine of Canada, no. 10, 678–688. MLADEK, J.
Microwave measurements of product variables
277
Appendix: Some manufacturers of microwave moisture measurement instruments suitable for foodstuffs ABB Industrietechnik AG 68002 Mannheim, Germany Tel +49-621-381-1838; Fax +49-621-381-1615 Agrichem Inc 155760 Lincoln St NE/Suite 5, Ham Lake NM 55304-5535, USA Tel +1-612-434-6755; Fax +1-612-434-1577 Agri-Tronix Corp 2001 North US 31, Franklin IN 46131, USA Tel +1-317-738-4474;Fax +1-317-738-9877 Alkon Corporation 5168 Blazer Parkway, Dublin OH 43017-1339, USA Tel +1-614-799-6650; Fax +1-614-793-0608 Applications Nouvelles des Techniques Electromagnetiques (ANTEM) 40 rue Jean Jaures, 94000 Creteil Cedex, France Tel/Fax +33-1-42-07-16-26 Aqua Measurement Instrument Co 1712 Earhart Court, PO Box 3, LaVerne CA 91750-0369, USA Tel +1-909-392-5833;Fax +1-909-392-5838 Berthold GmbH & Co. KG Calmbacher Str.22 75323 Bad Wildbad Germany Tel +49 7081 177-0; Fax +49 7081 177-100 Datec GmbH 203 Alte Salzdahlumer Strasse 38124 Braunschweig, Germany Tel +49-531-26408-0; Fax +49-531-26408-20 David Manufacturing Co Inc 1600 12 St NE, Mason City IA 50401-2543, USA Tel +1-515-423-6182;Fax +1-515-423-0234
278
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Dickey-John Corp 5200 Dickey-John Road, Auburn IL 62615, USA Tel +1-800-637-2952;Fax +1-217-438-6539 Distell Industries Ltd Old Levenseat, Fauldhouse West Lothian EH47 7AD, UK Tel +44-1501-770124; Fax +44-1501-772424 Epsilon Industrial 2215 Grand Avenue Parkway, Austin TX 78728, USA Tel +1-512-251-1500; Fax +1-512-251-1593 Farmex Inc 1205 Danner Dr, Aurora OH 44202, USA Tel +1-800-821-9542;Fax +1-330-562-7403 HF-sensor GmbH 67 Weissenfelserstrasse, 04229 Leipzig, Germany Tel +49-341-4926-0; Fax +49-341-49726-22 Kay-Ray/Sensall Inc 1400 Business Center Drive, Mount Prospect IL 60056, USA Tel/Fax +1-708-803-5100; Fax +1-708-803-5466 Kawasaki Kiko Co Ltd 810-1 Datega, Kagkegawa City Shizuoka Pref. 436, Japan Tel +81-537-27-1725; Fax +81-537-27-1716 Keam Holden Associates Ltd 27 Gillies Ave, Newmarket, PO Box 408 Auckland, New Zealand Tel +64-9-520-5020;Fax +64-9-520-5030 KDC Technology Corp 2011 Research Drive, Livermore CA 94550, USA Tel +1-925-449-4770; Fax +1-925-852-4084 Kett US (JP Associates) 17853 Santiago Blvd/ Suite 107-330, Villa Park CA 92667, USA Tel +1-800-638-8739;Fax +1-714-630-5105
Microwave measurements of product variables Microwave Moisture Technology 26 Via V, Veneto, 26010 Pianengo (CR), Italy Tel +39-373-74994; Fax +39-373-74335 Pacific Automation Instruments Ltd 105-3980 Inlet Crescent, North Vancouver (BC), Canada Tel +1-604-273-4498; Fax +1-604-273 8082 Pfeuffer GmbH 70 Flugplatzstrasse, 97318 Kitzingen, Germany Tel +49-9321-93690;Fax +49-9321-936950 Seedburo Equipment Co 1022 West Jackson Blvd, Chicago IL 60607-2990, USA Tel +1-312-738-3700; Fax +1-312-738-5329 Sensortech Systems Inc 268101-I Oak Avenue, Santa Clarita CA 91351, USA Tel +1-805-252-1103; Fax +1-805-252-6194 Sinar CSC Scientific C Inc, 2810 Ol Lee Highway, Fairfax, VA 22031, USA Tel +1-703-876-4030; Fax +1-703-280-5142 Strandberg Engineering Labs Inc 1302 N O Henry Blvd, Greensboro NC 27405, USA Tel +1-336-274-3775; Fax +1-336-272-4521 Societe d’Applications Technologiques de l’Imagerie Micro Onde (SATIMO) Le Pin, rue de la Terre de Feu, Z.A. de Courtaboeuf 91952 Les Ulis Cedex, France Tel +33-1-69-29-02-47; Fax +33-1-69-29-02-27 Tripett & Renaud Av. Marcelin Berthelot, Z.I. du val de Seine 92396 Villeneuve-la-Garenne Cedex, France Tel +33 14-79-44-021; Fax +33-14-79-47-074
279
10 Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control P. G. Berrie, Endress+Hauser Process Solutions AG, Reinach
10.1
Introduction
Chapters 10 and 11 are concerned with the measurement of process variables that are important to the manufacturing of food. Although not giving a direct indication of product quality, accurate measurements contribute to better process control. This in turn affects the reproducibility of the manufacturing process, its economy, and the durability of the final product. Here we shall be concerned primarily with the variables pressure, temperature, flow and level, but other measurements may also be required for full control. Thus trace moisture sensors are essential for monitoring the water content of blanket gases or dry air, and humidity control is required in the conditioning of products such as stored fruit, meat or other raw materials. In-line pH measurements are often encountered in the manufacture of milk products and conductivity measurements are required in the production of pure water. Occasionally, Redox and turbidity measurements may also be employed. As no further details will be given in this chapter of the methods used to measure these variables, the interested reader is referred to other literature on the subject [1]. This chapter covers the fields of temperature and pressure measurement, two process variables that account for over 80% of the measuring points in the processing industries. Over the years a great many instruments have been developed to measure them, but in this book only those that might be met in a food production facility will be considered. Hygiene is an ever-present factor in food production, and a number of guidelines have been developed to assure the quality of the end product. Those especially applying to process instrumentation are discussed in Section 10.4. Here, instrument design is considered from the aspects of process connections, materials and cleaning-in-place. Finally, Section 10.5 looks at a few typical applications for temperature and pressure instruments. These include descriptions both of food processing chains and ancillary processes, since a food manufacturing plant not only produces the end product but must also make provision, e.g. for compressed air, refrigeration, steam heating as well as pure and waste water.
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
10.2
281
Pressure measurement
In food processing, pressure measurements are required in piping, across filters, as well as in closed tanks. For piping in particular, the instruments must be designed to withstand overload pressures far beyond their normal operating range. As liquids or solids are pumped along the pipe, the pumping action causes regular surges in pressure. When valves are opened and closed, the pressure may increase to the normal operating pressure of the pump. If a valve closes abruptly, as is often the case, high pressure peaks are generated – a particular problem in the low pressure region. Finally, pressure instruments must be immune to vibration and be able to withstand the temperatures and stresses induced by internal and external cleaning. Pressure measurement devices are categorised according to the type of pressure they measure: absolute, gauge and differential pressure. • Absolute pressure devices measure the actual pressure acting on the sensor. For atmospheric pressure, therefore, they display approximately 1000 millibar. • Gauge pressure devices measure the pressure relative to atmospheric pressure. In this case, atmospheric pressure would produce a reading of 0 millibar – lower pressures are registered as negative values. • Differential pressure devices measure the pressure difference between two tapping points, e.g. in a pipeline or a tank. They are usually used to measure level and flow.
10.2.1 Measurement methods As far as the measuring principle is concerned, practically all pressure gauges fall under the category force-type pressure devices. The way in which the force resulting from the acting pressure is sensed leads to a further subdivision into: • Manometer-type measurement devices • Mechanical-type measurement devices • Electrical pressure transducers.
Of these methods, electrical measurements are most suited to automation, although the other types are still encountered in many plants. 10.2.2 Manometer-type instruments A manometer, see Fig. 10.1, comprises a U-tube filled with a so-called manometric fluid (water, oil or mercury), one limb being connected to acting pressure and the other being open, closed or otherwise connected to an indicating, registering or recording mechanism. The pressure to be measured acts upon the liquid in one limb of the manometer, pushing it into the other limb. The liquid continues to be displaced until the forces acting in both limbs are equal. For a gas, the difference in the liquid levels in the two limbs of the manometer gives a reading of acting pressure. So-called well or J-tubes indicate pressure directly. Here the diameter of the pressure limb is much greater than the measuring limb, so that a minimal change in level causes a large change on the measuring side. Where small pressure differences are to be measured, the tube may be inclined to give more accurate readings. Other designs use a float and mechanical assembly which operate a pointer when the manometric fluid level changes. In addition to classical manometers, there are numerous more sophisticated variations, e.g. balance hollow ring, bell chamber or bellows. In these devices, the manometer fluid
282
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 10.1
Manometer-type pressure measurement devices.
is used to separate the pressure limb from the measuring limb, on which acts a reference pressure. The difference in pressure is transmitted by a mechanical assembly to a dial gauge. In view of their simplicity, manometers are still a common sight in many plants, where they provide an optical control of the pressure. They are, however, losing ground to the other measurement methods. Classical manometers are also sensitive to temperature changes and must therefore be used within a fairly strict temperature range. Considering that the manometric fluid is in direct contact with the process, they are not suitable for sterile applications. 10.2.3 Mechanical-type measurement devices Mechanical-type measuring devices translate the pressure acting upon them into a mechanical displacement. There are various designs of measuring element, of which diaphragms and (Bourdon) tubes are more likely to be met with in the food industry, see Fig. 10.2. • A diaphragm element is a thin, flexible metal plate that separates the chamber connected to the pressure being measured from the atmosphere. It may be flat, corrugated or in the form of an introverted capsule. When both sides of the diaphragm are exposed to the same pressure, the diaphragm is in its equilibrium position. If a negative pressure is applied (less than atmospheric) the diaphragm is pulled in, if a positive pressure is applied, it is pushed out. The maximum displacement occurs at its centre.
Fig. 10.2
Mechanical-type pressure measurement devices.
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
283
• A Bourdon tube element comprises a thin flattened metal tube, sealed at one end, which is connected to the pressure being measured. The tube is bent into a circlar or helical form, or may simply be twisted. When positive pressure is applied, the tube will tend to straighten out, producing a linear or radial deflection that is proportional to the acting pressure.
By the use of a suitable mechanical assembly this displacement or deflection can be used to give an indication of pressure, e.g. on a dial. If the dial is fitted with electrical contacts, pressure limits can monitored. The pointer and dial display is easy to read and gives a quick indication of pressure. In automated plant, however, most serve only as an optical back-ups to electrical pressure transmitters. 10.2.4 Electrical pressure transducers The majority of electrical pressure transducers use a flexible diaphragm as the pressure transmitting element. Unlike mechanical-type devices, the diaphragm is not a part of a pressure chamber connected to the process, but forms the front isolating element of a sensing chamber. Thus, by using the appropriate process connection, it is possible to produce flush mounted pressure devices that have no cavities and that are easy to clean. Figure 10.3 shows six typical measuring cell designs for absolute/gauge and differential pressure measurement. • Type A is a resistive gauge/absolute pressure cell. The pressure acting on the isolating metal diaphragm is transmitted by a push rod onto the flexible beam, which deflects. Strain gauges located on the beam generate an electrical signal proportional to the acting pressure. The absolute cell is evacuated, the gauge cell is filled with fill fluid. • Type B is a resistive gauge/absolute pressure cell. The pressure acting on the isolating metal diaphragm is transmitted by a fill fluid to a second, flat, sensing diaphragm. The sensing diaphragm is also deflected, whereby the degree of deflection is greatest at its centre. Strain gauges or piezoelements on its surface produce an electrical signal proportional to the acting pressure. If the diaphragm is overloaded it sets back on the sensor body, avoiding any mechanical damage. The absolute cell is evacuated, the gauge cell is filled with fill fluid. • Type C is a capacitive gauge/absolute pressure cell. Two annular electrodes are to be found on the body, a third on the inner face of the diaphragm. When the diaphragm deflects, the capacitance between the inner body and diaphragm electrode changes in proportion to the acting pressure. Since there is virtually no movement towards the outer body electrode, this outputs a constant reference signal. If the diaphragm is overloaded it sets back on the sensor body, avoiding any mechanical damage. The cell is completely dry. The absolute pressure sensor is sealed and evacuated. • Type D is a twin-chamber capacitive differential pressure cell. It comprises two corrugated isolating diaphragms on the low and high pressure sides. To prevent damage on overload, these lie back on a similarly formed substrate. The space between the substrate and isolating diaphragm as well as the entire sensing capsule is filled with fluid. Capillaries lead from the front to the centre of the cell, where a sensing diaphragm separates the two sides. Metal electrodes are deposited on the diaphragm and capsule walls, forming the capacitor which measures the pressure when the sensing diaphragm deflects.
Fig. 10.3
Measurement cells for electrical pressure transmitters.
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
285
Inductive cells have a similar design, whereby the metal sensing diaphragm has two ferrite discs fixed to each side. These together with two fixed magnetic coils on each side of the sensing capsule body form a differential transformer. When the sensing diaphragm deflects, there is a change in inductivity that is proportional to the acting pressure. • Type E is a twin-chamber resistive cell for differential pressure. The construction of the cell is essentially the same as the twin-chamber capacitance cell, with the exception that additional capillaries lead to an external sensing capsule. Any deflection at the isolating diaphragms is transmitted by the fill fluid to the external sensing diaphragm. Strain gauges or piezoelements then produce a pressure proportional electrical signal. • Type F is a single-chamber capacitive cell for differential pressure cell. The two sides of the cell are connected by a capillary and a fill fluid transfers the pressure from one side to another. The cell body and diaphragms are ceramic, each side of the cell having its own set of capacitance electrodes, which deliver an electrical signal which is a function of the pressure. Since the two sides are connected, it is possible to build a self-monitoring cell. As the temperature increases, the volume of the fill fluid increases and the capacitance of the sensor changes. Since the expansion coefficient of the fill fluid is known, this gives an indirect measurement of temperature. By comparing this temperature with an independent measurement of the sensor temperature, it is possible to detect whether the sensor is faulty.
There are many other transducers on the market, e.g. resonance-wire or vibratingbeam, but these are often associated with a particular vendor and are beyond the scope of this book. There is also a further subdivision within the resistive type cells which relates to the sensing element. • So-called metallic sensors use strain gauges of various types. Foil strain gauges are made from resistive alloys such as Konstantan that have been rolled into thin foils a few m thick, coated with an isolating organic substance and stuck to a metal diaphragm. Thin-film strain gauges are produced by vapour deposition, spluttering or chemical vapour deposition techniques. • Piezoresistive sensors are based on semiconductors that have pressure-dependent electrical properties. There are two basic types of element. Polysilicon sensors are manufactured in the same way as metallic thin-film strain gauges and are doped to produce the desired electrical properties. Monosilicon sensors are made of pure silicon and are anisotropic, i.e. their resistance is direction-dependent, allowing them to produce highly sensitive sensors. • Thick-film strain gauges are produced by silk-screen printing techniques. The individual layers required to produce the desired sensor geometry are built up on a ceramic substrate using several different masks.
10.2.5 Summary Table 10.1 summarises the typical operating conditions of the various measurement methods. The accuracy of measurement is not quoted since it depends on the individual transmitter: in general it comprises the measured error, the hysteresis and reproducibility measured at a reference temperature, usually 20ºC. Often all three are quoted as an ‘overall’ accuracy. Also to be considered is the temperature effect, which indicates by how much the accuracy changes for a given temperature rise. This can be quite
Table 10.1 Typical operating conditions of various process pressure devices. The values are guidelines only, for specific values see the manufacturer’s data sheets. For electrical transmitters, the measuring range can often be ‘turned down’ by 40:1 or more Type Manometer
Diaphragms
Temperature range 10ºC to 60ºC
Up to 100ºC
Min./max. pressure range
Differential pressure range
Remarks
0 mbar to 1 mbar 0 bar to 20 bar
–
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
– –
Range depends on manometric fluid. Inaccurate if not operated within the rated temperature range. Significant temperature effect Up to 5 overload (max 40 bar) Significant temperature effect
–
Significant temperature effect
Up to 3 bar for static pressures up to 140 bar
Actual pressure and temperature range depend on cell design. Usually resistant to vibration and overload. Actual pressure and temperature range depend upon cell designs. Resistant to vibration and overload. Ceramic cells are more corrosion resistant and selfmonitoring. Actual pressure and temperature range depend upon cell designs. Resistant to vibration and overload.
mbar to 10 mbar bar to 25 bar mbar to 2.5 mbar mbar to 600 mbar mbar to 600 mbar bar to 4000 bar mbar to 1 bar bar to 400 bar
Capsule
25ºC to 60ºC
Bourdon gauges
20ºC to 60ºC
Electrical resistive
30ºC to 200ºC
Electrical capacitive
30 ºC to 200ºC
0 mbar to 400 mbar 0 bar to 40 bar (ceramic) 0 bar to 600 bar (metal)
Electrical inductive
20ºC to 120ºC
0 mbar to 100 mbar 0 bar to 160 bar
Up to 3 bar for static pressures up to 420 bar (ceramic) Up to 500 bar for static pressures up to 500 bar (metal) Up to 160 bar for static pressures up to 210 bar
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
287
considerable for certain fill fluids or if the sensor is operating a with diaphragm seal (an extension which allows flush mounting) or a remote seal and capillaries. The overload pressure indicates the ability to withstand pressure peaks without mechanical damage to the sensor; a re-calibration may be necessary, however. More information on the testing of pressure and other process transmitters can be obtained from IEC Standard 61298, Parts 1 to 4 and DIN 16086 [2, 3].
10.3
Temperature measurement
Temperature is by far the most frequently measured variable in process engineering. In food production, the monitoring and control of temperature is an important factor in assuring the quality of the end product. Two examples illustrate why this is so: • Storage silos are often monitored, because any unaccountable rise in temperature may be the first indication that the raw material in store is deteriorating. • The maintenance of a wrong temperature during the manufacture of dairy and other products seriously affects their shelf-life.
Although there are many applications for temperature measurement in food processing, the process conditions to be encountered are not particularly hostile. Thus, the temperatures to be met range from about 50ºC in cold storage to +150ºC in sterilisation-in-place applications. Only in steam generation will higher temperatures be found. Accuracy is very important, and of course, hygiene is essential – see Section 10.4. 10.3.1 Measurement methods Temperature measuring devices may be divided into three different categories according to the method of measurement they employ: force temperature devices, electrical temperature devices and radiation pyrometer temperature devices. Standard pyrometers are usually encountered in high temperature applications, e.g. in furnaces, so will not be considered further in this chapter. More on infra-red thermometry can be found in Chapter 7. 10.3.2 Force temperature devices Force temperature devices (FTDs) can be further divided into bimetallic FTDs and filled thermal system FTDs, see Fig. 10.4. They make use of the fact that the length or volume of a given mass of matter changes as its temperature increases. The change in length or volume with unit temperature is dependent upon the material and is characterised by a socalled coefficient of expansion. Bimetallic strip thermometers A bimetallic strip comprises two strips of metal with different coefficients of expansion that are bonded together, e.g. by riveting. When the temperature rises, each metal expands by a different amount causing the whole strip to bend. The amount of deflection is an indication of temperature. By a suitable mechanical assembly, this deflection can be used to give a continuous indication of temperature at a graduated display or to make contact with a switching element.
288
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 10.4
Temperature measurement device designs.
Bimetallic strip gauges are inexpensive and good designs provide reasonable accuracy (±2% ±3% of full scale (FS)). They are built for specific temperature ranges. Continuously reading bimetallic thermometers are often used as optical back-ups to resistance thermometers and in applications where temperature is not used as a control variable. Bimetallic switches are often found in two-point temperature controls. Filled thermal systems Filled thermal systems make use of the thermal expansion of liquids to provide a direct indication of temperature. In the most common of all, the glass bulb thermometer, the bulb acts as a reservoir for the liquid and is connected to a graduated capillary tube. As the temperature rises, the liquid within the bulb expands into the capillary; the height of the liquid column indicates the current temperature. The liquids used are, e.g. coloured alcohol or mercury. Thermometers are designed to measure over a specific range, usually between 0ºC to 100ºC (or the Fahrenheit equivalent). If the flow of liquid back to the bulb is restricted, e.g. by a kink in the capillary, they can also be designed to give more accurate measurements over smaller ranges. Should a glass-bulb thermometer break, glass splinters and alcohol or mercury would enter the process and contaminate the product. For this reason, thermometers are mounted in protective metal sheaths. Here it is essential that there is good thermal contact between the bulb and the sheath, otherwise the temperature indication is inaccurate and the response slow. Alternatively metal bulb thermometers might be used. The accuracy of a glass-bulb thermometer depends on the graduated scale and observer, but is generally within ±1ºC. It is essentially built for the human observer and does not lend itself easily to automation. For this reason its use today is limited to optical back-up of electrical systems or applications in which the temperature is not a control variable. Liquid spring thermometer A variation of the glass-bulb thermometer is the liquid spring thermometer. Here the metallic bulb and capillary are completely filled with liquid. As the temperature of the system increases, so does its pressure. The pressure changes are transmitted via a metal diaphragm to an elastically deformable spring with pointer, thus giving a direct reading of temperature. The latest versions of this type of thermometer are now coupled directly to a pressure sensor, which allows them to be integrated into process control systems.
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
289
10.3.3 Electrical temperature devices Due to the ease with which they can be integrated into control systems, electrical devices are the preferred method of temperature measurement in process control. They use the dependency of electrical properties of particular materials on temperature to provide a measurement, see Fig. 10.4. There are four different types: semiconductors, resistance temperature detectors (RTDs), thermocouples and silicon resistors, whereby only RTDs and thermocouples are of real interest in the production of food. Resistance temperature detectors Resistance temperature detectors (RTDs) or resistance thermometers are the most common type of temperature sensor to be found in process engineering. They comprise a thin-film or wire resistor with a standard resistance of 100 , 500 or 1000 . The resistor material may be platinum or nickel, the standardised designations being Pt100, Pt500, Pt1000 or Ni100. The sensors are very stable, have a wide operating range from 200ºC to +850ºC depending upon type and exhibit a well defined relationship between resistance and temperature. As a consequence they are interchangeable over a wide temperature range. RTDs may have a relatively slow time response and offer only a small change in resistance per unit increase in temperature. To limit or avoid errors in the determination of such small changes in resistance for measuring points where the sensing element and the evaluating electronics are separated by some distance, three- or even four-wire measurement technology must be used. RTDs are also sensitive to vibration and shock, so that care must be in their design. Thermocouples If two wires of different metals are joined together at their ends and the two junctions are at different temperatures, a potential difference is created that causes a current to flow around the loop. The difference in potential arises because the magnitude of the contact potential at each junction is dependent upon the temperature. If one of the junctions is kept at a constant temperature, the magnitude of the current that flows is a measure of the temperature at the other. Although thermocouples have a wide operating temperature range, in Europe they are usually only used in preference to RTDs for temperatures above 600ºC. In America, however, they are being increasingly used for lower temperature ranges. They can measure up to 1800ºC depending upon the type and conductor diameter, and usually have a faster response than RTDs but a worse accuracy. They are simple, rugged, inexpensive and require no external power supply. On the other hand, the signal is nonlinear, they exhibit low sensitivity and have relatively low stability. A reference junction is required and they must be compensated. Moreover, metallurgical changes and ageing sometimes causes a loss of performance. A more serious problem is that the low voltage output is susceptible to electromagnetic interference. 10.3.4 Design and assembly of RTDs Since RTDs are the temperature sensors most likely to be found in the food industry, their design, assembly and use will be examined in more detail. The design has features in common with other electrical temperature devices, since most comprise the sensing element in its protective sheath, a thermowell for introducing the sensor to the process and a head or remote transmitter for evaluating and processing the incoming signal as
290
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
well as providing power to the sensor circuit. The use of a thermowell is also common practice for force temperature devices. Sensing element There are various designs of Pt100 sensing elements. • The traditional sensing element is the ceramic Pt 100 element which comprises a spiral of extremely fine platinum embedded in ceramic powder (frit) within capillaries of extremely pure alumina. Two platinum wires provide the contacts to the connecting wires. • The glass Pt 100 element comprises an extremely thin platinum tape wound around a glass mandrel. The element is protected by a glass sleeve which is fused to it. Platinum wires provide the contacts to the connecting wires. Due to the fusion of the sheath and element, this design has the advantage of a high vibration resistance. • For the thin film Pt 100 element, an extremely thin layer of platinum is evaporated onto a 0.5 mm thick ceramic substrate. By using a laser or etching technique, platinum is removed selectively from the surface in order to create a meander with a nominal resistance of 100 at 0ºC. The platinum coated connecting wires and thin film are protected by a fused glass coating.
Table 10.2 lists the nominal operating temperature ranges for the three types of Pt 100 sensing element. The resistance measured by the RTD sensing element is converted to a temperature by using the tables in European Standard EN 60 751 ( IEC 60 751) [4]. These values have been determined on the basis of the International Temperature Scale ITS90 [5], and can be calculated by using a polynomial equation, the coefficients of which are exactly known for each sensor element type, i.e. for Pt100, Pt500, Pt1000 and Ni100. The standard further defines two accuracy (tolerance) classes for Pt 100 sensing elements: • Class A: accuracy in ºC 0.15 0.002 (t) • Class B: accuracy in ºC 0.30 0.005 (t)
where (t) is the unsigned numerical value of the temperature in ºC. This classification is often not adequate for industrial users and it is common to meet fractions or multiples of the classes. For example, Class 1/3 B would correspond to an accuracy in ºC of 0.10 0.005 (t) and 2 B to 0.60 0.005 (t). For fractional B classes, the temperature dependent part of the tolerance (0.005 (t)) sometimes has a lower value, thus assuring greater accuracy. Type of connection RTD sensing elements are manufactured by a few specialist firms around the world. The top five deliver products of comparable high quality to most of the major instrument manufacturers. It is only in the design beyond the element, that differences are to be Table 10.2
Nominal operating temperatures of Pt100 sensing elements
Type
Dimensions
Design
Isolation
Pt100 Pt100 Pt100
2.5 mm dia 35 mm 2.5 mm dia 35 mm 10 mm 2 mm 0.5 mm
Wound Wound Thin film
Ceramic Glass Glass/ceramic
Temperature range 200ºC to 850ºC 200ºC to 600ºC 50ºC to 400ºC
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
Fig. 10.5
291
Types of connection for RTDs.
found. The two connecting wires of the sensing element carry the signal to the evaluating circuit which in its simplest form might comprise a constant current source and a means of measuring the resistance. For process instrumentation this circuitry is usually found in a head or remote transmitter. Since the evaluating circuit and sensing element are always removed from one another, the gap has to be bridged by connecting wires. If the whole sensing assembly is to be removable, e.g. for replacement in the event of a failure of one component, then it is usual that these wires end in terminals. Connecting leads are then required to carry the signal to the evaluating circuit. The connecting wires, leads and terminals may all be sources of error in the final measurement. For this reason, two-, three- and four-wire circuits are to be found, see Fig. 10.5. For a two-wire circuit, the resistance of the connecting wires, leads and terminals must be added to the resistance of the sensing element. The longer the leads, the higher the resistance and the larger the resulting error. For this reason two-wire circuits should be used only when the transmitter is located close to the sensing element. This is particularly critical for Pt100 and Ni100 RTDs. In a three-wire circuit, an additional wire is connected to one side of the sensing element. This is connected to the transmitter and acts as a reference for the lead resistance. Provided the leads are of identical material and length, this reference value can be subtracted from the detected resistance to provide a measurement that is influenced only by the terminal resistance. The remaining error is roughly 0.1% of the measured value, which provides sufficient accuracy for most industrial applications. The four-wire circuit is used for very accurate measurements. Two connecting wires on each side of the sensing element are connected to the transmitter. A constant current is supplied to the element via one pair of wires, whilst the other pair are used to measure the resulting voltage. By using this type of voltage compensation, unbalanced wires and leads, and their associated resistances, have no effect on the measurement. Intrinsic warming (self-heating) In order to measure temperature, an RTD must be supplied with a constant current. This current also causes the device to heat up. The degree of heating is dependent upon the design, and is particularly critical for thin-film elements. It is extremely difficult to determine the extent of this so-called intrinsic warming or self-heating, however, for a Pt100 sensor operating at 10 mA it is typically 0.02 K to 0.4 K in water and 0.9 K in air. For this reason it is usual to operate the RTD at a constant current of 1 mA, making the intrinsic warming effect negligible in comparison to the standard accuracy.
292
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 10.6
Contruction of sensor insert for RTDs and thermocouples; 1 leads with ceramic isolation, 2 metal or ceramic sheath, 3 alumina powder.
Sensor insert Before the sensing element can be used in an industrial application, it must be protected against shorting and vibration. To this end, it is built into an exchangeable sensor insert (or inset). The insert comprises a metal sheath, usually AISI 316 stainless steel, containing the sensing element and connection wires, see Fig. 10.6. To prevent them from shorting, the connection wires are threaded through thin ceramic tubes. The whole assembly is then packed in alumina powder to protect it against vibration. A more advanced insert manufacturing technique uses magnesium oxide cables, i.e. extruded metal tubes that contain the connecting wires isolated by compressed MgO powder. This method has the advantage of providing excellent electrical isolation and provides protection against environmental humidity. Furthermore the insert is flexible, vibration-proof and can be operated at high temperatures. The top of the insert may be of two different types. Either the connecting wires are led out via ceramic sockets to a set of terminals or they are connected directly to a head transmitter which contains the evaluating circuits. The number of terminals depends upon the type of connecting circuit used. Thermowells For most applications, the sensor insert is not suitable for direct contact with the process. This is the case for food manufacture, where the external surface might offer conditions for bacterial contamination. The insert is therefore operated within a thermowell, which is often an integral part of the sensor assembly, see Fig. 10.7. For food processing, this comprises a highly polished, closed, stainless steel tube with a process connection or welding neck. In order to ensure the best possible transfer of heat, the sensor insert is usually in contact with the well bottom or set into a thermoconductive paste and often tapers towards the end to provide better heat transfer. Head or remote transmitter The transmitter is the brains of the sensor and converts the signal from the sensing element into a standardised output. It also powers the sensor where necessary. Modern transmitters are equipped with a microcontroller which provides a direct conversion of resistance (or voltage) to temperature for output at a local display or to a fieldbus system,
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
Fig. 10.7
293
Construction of a temperature sensor, here shown with sensor insert with terminal connections.
as well as compensation functions, e.g. for non-linearity of the sensor signal. Alternatively, a simple temperature-proportional 4...20 mA or 0...10 V signal with freely assignable temperature range end values may be provided. It is usual that either RTDs, thermocouples or voltage signals can be connected to the same transmitter. If the transmitter is to be found in the sensor assembly, it is known as a head transmitter. If on the other hand, the transmitter is not an integral part of the sensor, i.e. it is located in a nearby control cabinet or in the control room, it is known as a remote transmitter. Since the sensing element of all electrical temperature devices outputs an electrical signal, it is also possible to make a direct connection to an output device such as a chart or data recorder which has the facilities to handle temperature signals. Housing The housing of a temperature device must protect the sensor insert, the terminals and, where appropriate, the head transmitter from the ingress of water and dust. It must also provide good access to the terminals and sufficient space for the wiring. The size therefore varies according to type of transmitter. The connecting leads to the sensor are lead through a cable gland into the inside of the housing. All housings have either an IP or NEMA rating which indicate the degree of protection they allow when the lid is firmly clamped or screwed into position and the cable gland screwed tight, see Section 10.4. For food applications, housings are often made of stainless steel, although polypropylene (FDA approved) is often encountered in North America. Standardised housings are to be found in DIN 43 729, whereby Type B is the one most often used [6]. 10.3.5 Installation conditions Even the most accurate temperature sensor will deliver incorrect measurements if it is not properly installed. As mentioned previously, for food applications electrical temperature devices will usually be installed in thermowells. These in turn will be built into the pipes and tanks where the medium to be measured is flowing or stored. Since the conditions to be met at the measuring points are different, e.g. gases, liquids or solids, flowing or stationary, various designs of thermowell are available for different measurement tasks.
294
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
For measurements in a flowing medium, the thermowell will have been designed for a particular range of flowrates. It is beyond the scope of this book to discuss thermowell design further, but more information is available from vendor’s catalogues. Heat transfer Electrical temperature devices must always be in good thermal contact with the medium to be measured so that any change in temperature is recorded as quickly as possible. Since the heat transfer coefficients of solids, liquids and gases differ considerably, each application requires the thermowell to installed in a different way. Adequate heat transfer is assured by ensuring that a certain length of the thermowell, the so-called immersion depth, is exposed to the medium. If the immersion depth is too shallow, heat may be dissipated to the pipe or tank, resulting in an incorrect measurement. This phenomenon is enhanced when the sensing element is placed close to the process connection; the metallic mass radiates heat to the external environment. To avoid measurement errors, therefore, the minimum immersion depth should be at least 15 times the diameter of the thermowell tip, whereby, if possible 20 times the diameter should be used. In all cases, the technical data sheets and standards governing thermowells should be consulted. Response time A second important factor in temperature measurement is the speed with which a change in temperature is registered by the sensing element. Since this also depends on the rate of heat transfer and the thickness of the thermowell tip, tests are made under standard conditions. The characterising variable in EN 60751 is the response time [4], also called the settling time in the instrument test standards series IEC 60770 and IEC 61298 [7, 2]. The response time is the time the sensor output requires to reach a certain percentage of its final steady-state value after a step rise in the input temperature. The times are designated 0.5 for 50% steady-state value and 0.9 for 90%. The response time is determined under two sets of conditions: • In air flowing at a velocity of 3 m/s, immersion depth 15 the diameter of the thermowell tip plus the sensor element length, start temperature between 10ºC and 30ºC, temperature jump between 10ºC and 20ºC. • In water flowing at a velocity of 0.4 m/s, immersion depth 5 the diameter of the thermowell tip plus the sensor element length, start temperature between 5ºC and 30ºC, temperature jump not greater than 10ºC.
Table 10.3 lists reference values for typical thermowell thicknesses. The response time decreases with increasing flowrate and vice versa. Mounting position Table 10.3 shows clearly the relationship between response time, thermowell diameter and immersion depth: the thinner the thermowell, the smaller the immersion depth and the quicker the response. On the other hand, the thermowell acts as a resistance to air or liquid flow and is subject to mechanical stresses and vibration. In some cases, it might also be subject to abrasion or chemical attack. These factors have to be weighed against each other when selecting a suitable thermowell. The choice of mounting position may also influence this decision by producing more favourable conditions. When temperature sensors are mounted in pipes, then a position or orientation should be chosen that reduces the surface area facing the direction of flow. This reduces the
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control Table 10.3
295
Response times under standard conditions for various thermowell thicknesses
Diameter of tip
In water at 0.4 m/s 0.5 0.9
0.5
In air at 3 m/s 0.9
9 mm 10 mm 11 mm 12 mm 13 mm
30 34 38 44 50
133 144 154 180 205
s s s s s
s s s s s
80 s 103 s 125 s 143 s 160 s
390 398 405 430 455
s s s s s
mechanical load on the thermowell. Since the sensor produces turbulence in the downstream flow, care should be taken that it is not positioned too close to any other instrumentation in the pipe. • The ideal position is in a pipe elbow. This offers the smallest cross-section and least mechanical load. • Where the pipe is wide enough, the sensor can be mounted vertically. • The sensor can be angled towards the oncoming flow if the pipe diameter does not allow vertical mounting. • For very small pipes, the sensor can be mounted on a nozzle which is wide enough to allow fluid to flow around the thermowell.
For tanks, the situation is somewhat better, in that there is usually space for vertical or horizontal mounting. The temperature sensor must be positioned such that it is covered with medium at all times when the signal is required. Care should be taken not to position it too close to moving parts such as agitators, pumps or valves, however, since the forces generated by the movement of fluid may exceed the mechanical strength of the thermowell or lead to increased abrasion or corrosion.
10.4
General instrument design
The production of food is one of the most carefully controlled areas of industrial activity. In addition to being strictly controlled by government agencies, the industry itself has set up its own watchdogs to monitor advances in production engineering and make recommendations regarding safe, modern practice. The aim, of course, is to protect the consumer from exposure to unsafe products, resulting from the presence of e.g. foreign bodies, chemical contaminants or bacteria. The use of instrumentation manufactured according to these guidelines is a step towards safe food production. 10.4.1 Design factors When choosing instrumentation for food production, it is always wise to bear in mind that it is not the normal operation of a device that gives problems, but rather the unexpected event. Thus, the risk of chemical contamination can be eliminated by using a suitable material for the wetted parts of the device. The risk of bacterial contamination can be reduced by regular cleaning and the use of suitably designed process connections. The introduction of foreign bodies, however, is only partially covered by the adoption of a high degree of protection. The case where equipment in direct contact with the product fails,
296
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
producing debris or releasing contaminants, must also be considered. Here it is essential that the user is warned and/or that the released products are not dangerous to health. 10.4.2 Wetted parts The wetted parts of a device are those parts which are in contact with the medium being measured. For temperature measurement this might be the thermowell, for pressure measurement the isolating diaphragm and for a contacting level measurement the sensing element itself. Even so-called non-contact devices must be considered to have wetted parts when they intrude into the pipeline or tank. Here it is not so much the contact with the medium, but crevices and their exposure to high temperatures and vapours which has to be considered. The positioning of the measurement device must also be examined. Flowing gases, liquids or solids may cause abrasion or generate high mechanical forces, which combined with high temperature or vibration enhance electrochemical attack or mechanical fatigue. Moreover, the wetted parts must be able to withstand the forces and temperatures generated during cleaning or sterilisation-in-place procedures. Materials In addition to the normal mechanical design factors, the toxicological and bacteriological compatibility of the materials used for wetted parts must also be taken into consideration. As far as the toxicological properties are concerned, a material approved by the USA Federal Drug Administration (FDA approval) or equivalent regulating body must be used. The bacteriological factor is a different matter. Although regular cleaning and gap-free design reduce the broad risk of infection, the proper design and finishing of the wetted parts is just as important. This basically means flowing contours and clean welding, no nooks and crannies, and no obstructions that might cause the product to gather and rot. Usually all components in the tank are of highly polished stainless steel to prevent the product from sticking. Not to be forgotten is the corrosion resistance of the wetted parts. This is not simply a matter of their resistance to the products and cleaning agents. Under high temperatures, strong vibration and mechanical stress, electrochemical corrosion or intergranular corrosion may be enhanced. The one results in surface pitting, providing an ideal breeding place for bacteria, the other in the depletion of the nickel and chromium at the grain interfaces, which means the component will rust. Table 10.4 lists some stainless steels suitable for the food industry. 10.4.3 Process connections The majority of process instruments are installed in pipes or tanks by means of threaded connections or flanges. Neither of these methods is suitable for food manufacture since both offer crevices and gaps where the product can accumulate and rot. In addition, the mounting and dismounting takes considerable effort, so cleaning becomes difficult. Ideally, a process connection should offer no gaps where the product can become trapped. One solution is to weld the instrument in place and then grind and polish the inside of the connection. Unfortunately this means that the instrument cannot be exchanged should it fail. For thermowells, where the sensor insert is easily replaced, and for flowmeters, however, it is quite feasible and is often encountered. Process instruments are generally installed by means of so-called sanitary couplings. These combine the need for a gap-free mounting with that of easy mounting and
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control Table 10.4
297
Stainless steels suitable for the food industry
Material AISI*
Properties
1.4301
304
1.4404
316L
1.4435 1.4571
316L 316 Ti
Good resistance against organic acids at moderate temperatures Good resistance against salt and alkalis at moderate temperatures Increased resistance against non-oxidising acids such as acetic acid, tartaric acid, phosphoric acid Increased resistance against pitting and intercrystalline corrosion Better corrosion resistance than Type 1.4404 Increased corrosion resistance against particular acids and salt water Resistance against pitting corrosion
* The AISI steels are equivalents but do not have identical compositions
dismounting, allowing them to be quickly removed for cleaning. Over the years a number of different designs have come onto the market, a selection of which are summarised in Table 10.5. 10.4.4 Ingress and explosion protection Just as important as the wetted parts and process connection is the design of the housing of a process instrument. Depending upon the instrument type, this may contain only the Table 10.5
Sanitary couplings for the food industry
Type
Use
Description
Dairy coupling (to DIN 11851)
Pipes and tanks
Aseptic coupling (to DIN 11864)
Pipes Tanks in preparation
VariventÕ coupling
Pipes
APV coupling SMS coupling
Pipes Pipes and tanks
IDF coupling Tri-clampÕ coupling
Pipes and tanks Pipes and tanks
Reasonably priced coupling that is frequently found in the food industry. Its weakness lies in the hygienic adaptation to the process which does not allow flush mounting. The coupling is made by a threaded boss and slotted sleeve. A conical seating and tapered nozzle with sealing ring comprise the process seal. Introduced in 1998 as a replacement for the dairy coupling. Designed to EHEDG recommendations, see Section 10.4.5, offering better hygiene thanks to a flush sealing construction. The mechanical coupling is via bolts or a threaded sleeve, the seal being flush with the pipe wall. In-line housing that allows the flush mounting or the sensor, which is attached to the housing by means of a screw clamp. Three housing types cover a wide range of pipe diameters. For the majority of process sensors Type 3, for pipes of DN 40 upwards, is required. This facilitates the exchange of instruments. In-line housing of similar construction to the Varivent coupling. The sensor, however, is bolted in position. Reasonably priced, Scandinavian standardised screw coupling which is also used in France. Its weakness lies in the hygienic adaptation to the process which does not allow flush mounting. International Diary Federation screw coupling standardised in ISO Sanitary coupling with bevel seating produced by the Tri-Clover Company in America. Instruments are quickly mounted and fixed with snap-on clamps. The couplings find widespread use in America.
298
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
connecting terminals or the entire evaluating electronics. In both cases it must provide protection: • from the ingress of dust or moisture from the outside • when the sensor is used in an explosion hazardous area, from the egress of a spark or flame from the inside to the outside.
The former can be ensured by a suitable degree of protection, the latter by a suitable type of protection. Ingress protection As far as the ingress of dust and moisture is concerned, the world is divided into two camps. One half uses the IP standard (IEC 60 529) [8] and the other the American NEMA Standard No. 250. Nowadays, however, many manufacturers quote both in their technical specifications. The IP standard is a description of the measures designed for the protection of the housing and the equipment within the housing. The degree of protection is indicated by a two-part code, e.g. IP 65. The first number is concerned with the protection from the ingress of solid matter, the second with water. As can be seen from Table 10.6, in order to withstand the frequent cleaning in a food production facility, housings with ratings of IP 65 or better are required. The NEMA standard comprises 14 type codes which deal with practical requirements on housings suitable for indoor and outdoor use. It also makes a statement about the protection from external influences and conditions such as mechanical impact, corrosion, humidity, mould, pests, dust etc. As can be seen from Table 10.7, which lists only a selection of codes, a NEMA 4X enclosure is best suited to the requirements of the food industry. Explosion protection In comparison to the chemical industry, there is less need for explosion protection in the production of food. If flammable liquids or easily ignitable gases are present, however, then the instrumentation must be approved for use in explosion hazardous areas. Powders can also be a problem, since clouds of dust are easily combustible under certain conditions. For milling, storage, conveyance and bagging operations, therefore, the DustEx equipment should be used. The types of explosion protection are standardised in EN 50 014 [9]. Table 10.8 lists and explains the ones of interest to food processing.
Table 10.6
Ingress protection categories to IEC 60 529
Code
Ingress protection against solids
Code
Ingress protection against water
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Not protected 50 mm diameter, e.g. hand 12.5 mm diameter, e.g. finger 2.5 mm diameter, e.g. tool 1 mm diameter, e.g. wire Protected from dust Dust-proof
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Not protected Vertical dripping Dripping (15º inclination) Water spray Splash water Jet of water Strong jet of water Temporary submersion Total submersion
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control Table 10.7
Degree of protection of enclosures as per NEMA Standard 250 (selection)
Type
Indoor
1 2 3
yes yes
4 4X
yes yes
5
yes
6
yes
Table 10.8
299
Outdoor
yes yes yes
yes
Degree of protection Protection against contact with equipment within the housing Protection against a specified quantity of water droplets and dirt Protection against blown dust, rain, sleet, rain and snow, and external ice formation Protection against blown dust, jets splashes and jets of water Protection against corrosion, blown dust, jets splashes and jets of water Protection against dust falling, dirt and lubricating non-corrosive fluids Protection against water penetration during occasional temporary submerging in limited depth
Types of protection to EN 50 014
Type of protection
Significance
Intrinsic safety ‘i’
Favoured by European manufacturers. The protection is achieved by limiting the current flowing in the device circuits. This means that there are restrictions regarding the installation and cabling. The electronics are designed such that high temperatures and sparking cannot occur during normal operation. This type of protection is met, e.g. in 4-wire devices and power supplies. The entire electronics of the device are potted, so that no spark can enter the surounding atmosphere The enclosure (housing) is designed such that any spark or explosion is retained within it. Frequently met in America where the entire cabling is routed in conduits. Also used in Europe for Dust-Ex protection
Enhanced safety ‘e’ Encapsulated ‘m’ Explosion-proof ‘d’
10.4.5 Standardisation authorities As mentioned previously, the food industry is regulated by both government and industrial bodies. When choosing equipment, therefore, it pays to check whether a corresponding approval or authorisation has been granted. Table 10.9 lists several bodies which are of particular importance to safe food manufacture.
10.5
Applications
The production of food involves many processes. Each requires the measurement of particular process variables to ensure optimum operation conditions. The three examples here illustrate how the various components act together to produce the desired control. 10.5.1 Two-point temperature control The majority of food manufacturing processes require at some point or other controlled heating or refrigeration. Two-point temperature control aims to keep the temperature of a
300
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 10.9
Some regulatory bodies and associations important to process instrumentation
Body
Field of activity
3-A sanitary standards
Test and authorise process instrumentation regarding its fitness for use in food production, in particular the diary industry. The use of 3-A standards is entirely voluntary, but the quality is such that 3-A authorisation is accepted worldwide. Issues guidelines on hygiene, tests and certifies equipment and publicises state-of-the-art technologies. An EHEDG approval means that the equipment at hand has been successfully tested with respect to its suitability for food applications Issues licences for products, whereby the processes, constituents, materials and constructional details are subject to examination. The use of an FDA-approved material, e.g. a stainless steel or elastamer, is a guarantee that the component concerned will not be attacked by the food product. Lay down the permissible levels of trace organic and inorganic substances in food products. Since this is an area of permanent research, it is possible that regulations vary from country to country. Responsible for standards and recommendations in the diary industry which are often published as ISO standards.
European Hygienic Equipment Design Group (EHEDG) US Food and Drug Administration
National Governmental Agencies International Diary Federation
product within a specified range. The temperature sensor is built into the pipeline or tank where the product is to be found. The sensor measures the temperature and outputs either the temperature itself or an electrical signal from which it can be derived. What happens next, depends upon the measuring system. In older analogue control systems, the signal is monitored by the controller. When the temperature drops below or exceeds the desired range, the controller acts to bring it back into range, e.g. by opening and closing valves. Modern transmitters and sensors with fieldbus output can often monitor up to four limits (HI_HI, HI, LO and LO_LO); violations are signalled by means of a bit array. The controller no longer has to monitor the limits, but reacts to a change of bit status. Alternatively the sensor itself takes over the control task and manipules the valves via a suitable control algorithm. 10.5.2 Pressure control in pipelines Where food processing is based on liquid raw materials, e.g. milk or oil, or the final product is liquid, e.g. vegetable juices or yoghurt, then the transport through the plant must be carefully controlled. Milk, for instance, should be transported at a flowrate no greater than 2.5 m/s, otherwise the mechanical forces acting on it damage the product quality. As pressure drops in pipelines and across valves and manifolds are not constant, pressure control devices must be installed in the pipelines. In general, pressure control is achieved by running the pumps at their operating speed and deciding on a pressure setpoint. The pressure sensor detects the actual pump pressure and passes the information on to the controller. This compares the actual value with the setpoint value and computes the setpoint deviation, which ideally is zero. If the deviation is not zero, the controller then sets the valves accordingly, so that the set pressure is maintained.
Pressure and temperature measurement in food process control
301
Fig. 10.8 Process instrumentation required for the control of an industrial refrigeration unit. FI = Flow indication, PI = Pressure indication, QI = Quality indication (pH), QIR = Quality indication and registration (pH), TI = Temperature indication.
10.5.3 Refrigeration plant Refrigeration is required in many food processes, either during production or for the storage of the ingredients and end products. The standard ammonia gas refrigeration plant, see Fig. 10.8, comprises a compressor/condenser and vaporisor/heat exchanger together with valves to control the flow of ammonia around the refrigeration circuit. A pump, operating at its rated speed, pumps ammonia into the compressor which comprises a bundle of pipes that are cooled by a continuous flow of water. The pump pressure P1 is monitored and controlled by the valve at the outlet side of the vaporiser. The cooled, pressurised ammonia liquefies in the condenser and flows through a second valve into the vaporiser. This comprises a cooling coil which is surrounded by the cooling medium, usually saltwater or a glycol/water mixture. As the ammonia enters the vaporiser it suddenly expands, changes from liquid to gas and as a result removes heat from its surroundings. The pressure of the liquid and gaseous ammonia P2 and P3 at both sides of the inlet valve is monitored, so that the pressure drop across the inlet valve can be optimised. The cooling medium is pumped from the refrigerator to the various refrigeration coils in the plant. Its temperature is checked both at the outlet and the back flow inlet, the resultant information being used to control the refrigeration circuit. A pressure sensor
302
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
monitors the pumping circuit to ensure flow control as described in Section 10.5.2. The two pH sensors in the cooling circuit are used to monitor any ammonia leaks in the cooling coil by monitoring the difference between the pH at the inlet and outlet. A leak of a few parts per million causes a change of approximately 1 pH unit.
10.6
References
[1] Food and Beverages, Measurement and Automation, ed. M. Baur, EndressHauser, CH-4153 Reinach, Switzerland. [2] IEC Standard 61 298, Parts 1–4, Process measurement and control devices, General methods and procedures for evaluating performance. Part 1 (1995) General considerations. Part 2 (1995) Tests under reference conditions. Part 3 (1998) Tests for the effects of influence quantities. Part 4 (1995) Evaluation report content. [3] DIN 16 086, Electrical pressure measuring instruments; pressure sensors, pressure transmitters, pressure measuring instruments; concepts, specifications on data sheets, Beuth Verlag, Berlin, May 1992. [4] IEC standard 60 751 (1983), Industrial platinum resistance thermometer sensors (currently under review). [5] The International Temperature Scale of 1990 (ITS-90), see e.g. www.its-90.com. [6] DIN 43 729, Electrical temperature sensor; connection heads for thermocouplethermometers and resistance thermometers. [7] IEC Standard 60 770, Transmitters for use in industrial-process control systems. Part 1 (1999) Methods for performance evaluation. Part 2 (1989) Guidance for inspection and routine testing (under review). [8] IEC Standard 60 529, Degrees of protection provided by enclosures (IP code). Issued 1989, Amendment (1999) [9] EN 50 014, Electrical apparatus for potentially explosive atmospheres – General requirements.
11 Level and flow measurement in food process control P. G. Berrie, Endress+Hauser Process Solutions AG, Reinach
11.1
Introduction
This chapter deals with the measurement of level and flow. These variables differ slightly from temperature and pressure, in that they are used not only for control, but also the information they supply can be used at the enterprise level of a company. Here the quantities measured may be used in the planning of production, optimisation of the plant or simply to generate invoices for amounts bought and sold. Section 11.2 deals with standard methods to measure level, either as a limit in overspill or pump protection or as a continuous measurement for the determination of content. Section 11.3 deals with flow measurement. Section 11.4 is a general introduction to process control and the methods by which instrumentation can be integrated into the control hierarchy. This chapter also applies to temperature and pressure measurements. Finally, Section 11.5 gives a few examples of flow and level measurement in practice.
11.2
Level measurement
Level is one of the basic process variables that contribute to the efficient running of a processing facility. It is required, e.g. to monitor the contents of storage and buffer tanks or to signal full and empty states in filling operations. Table 11.1 classifies the methods discussed in this chapter according to application. Devices such as buoyancy, displacement or bubbler sensors have not been included, since the presence of moving parts is not conducive to hygiene. Many continuous liquid measuring points encountered in the food industry are either of the hydrostatic or the differential pressure type. There are still, however, a substantial number of capacitance points where hot, sticky pastes have to be measured. Ultrasonics may also be used to measure liquids and solids level, and microwave measurement is only just beginning to make its impact. The microimpulse method for solids is also relatively new, but promises to complement the ultrasonic method when it comes to measuring powders, e.g. flour or similar. In limit detection, the vibration method reigns
304
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Table 11.1
Classification of level devices according to measurement task and method
Limit switch Continuous measurement
Liquid measurement
Solid measurement
Vibration Capacitance Conductance Hydrostatic Microwave Ultrasonics Capicitance
Vibration Capacitance
Contact Contact
Ultrasonics Microimpulse
Non-contact Contact
Contact Contact Contact Contact Non-contact Non-contact Contact
supreme, capacitance or conductivity switches only being used where the process conditions preclude its use. In the following, each of the methods will be examined in more detail, whereby the microwave, microimpulse and ultrasonic methods are to be found under the rubric ‘timeof-flight methods’. Figures 11.1 and 11.2 show the the various methods for liquids and solids measurement together with the positions of the sensors in the tank or silo. 11.2.1 Capacitance method The capacitance method may be used for both continuous level measurement and level limit detection as well as for both conducting and non-conducting liquids. For capacitance measurement in electrically conductive liquids an insulated steel rod or rope probe is used. The probe and tank wall act as a capacitor. As the liquid rises in the tank, there is a proportional change in capacitance. The capacitance also depends upon the medium and the probe insulation material. As the insulation materials are specially selected, the capacitance changes are relatively large. FDA approved materials are available for food applications. Capacitance level measurement in electrically non-conductive materials is simpler, because the probes do not need to be insulated. A probe and conductive vessel wall, or probe and counter-probe, combine to form the capacitor, the capacitance of which varies due to the medium between them. The capacitance measurement principle is suitable for practically all liquids. For bulk solids its use is restricted nowadays to limit detection, whereby the maximum grain size is around 30 mm. The method is suitable for pressures up to 500 bar and in the temperature range 200 ºC to 500 ºC. It is also insensitive to pressure surges caused by stirrers and the like. In the case of non-conducting media, the measurement is dependent upon dielectric constant. This has no effect on limit detection, but for continuous measurement it means that the sensing system has to be calibrated, and that a subsequent change in medium will require a re-calibration. If it is known that the product changes frequently a self-calibrating system can be built using a limit switch or second reference probe. This requires a special transmitter which combines the signals from the two sensors to correct the level reading. 11.2.2 Conductance method Conductance measurement is used for limit detection in conductive liquids. The sensing element comprises a stainless steel rod that is mounted in the top or the side wall of the vessel. The switching position is determined by the length or the mounting point of the sensor respectively.
Fig. 11.1
Installation of various types of liquid level measurement sensors.
306
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
Fig. 11.2
Installation of various types of solid level measurement sensors.
The sensor is operated at constant voltage and the electrical resistance or current flowing between it and the conductive wall of the vessel is measured. If the tank wall is non-conductive, a counter-probe is used. When liquid comes into contact with the sensing element there is a sudden drop in resistance (or rise in current) which signals that the limit level has been reached. The signal can be used to switch a relay, NPN- or PNP-transistor, or to provide a switching signal to a remote transmitter. The probes are essentially the same as capacitance probes. The operating conditions are also the same, whereby a change in the conductivity of the liquid has no effect on the switching. 11.2.3 Hydrostatic method The hydrostatic method is used for continuous measurement of liquid level and is the most commonly used principle in food manufacture. It makes use of the fact that a head of liquid exerts a pressure proportional to its height. In the case of an open vessel, where atmospheric pressure is acting on the head of liquid, a gauge pressure cell can be used to measure the level. The measurement is dependent on the density, but this can either be entered as a calibration parameter or eliminated by calibrating at, e.g. the desired 0% and 100% levels. For closed vessels two sensors are required. The level sensor is installed at the bottom of the vessel and the head pressure sensor in the roof. The difference between the two measurements then gives the level. Measurements can be made with either a differential pressure transmitter or two gauge pressure transmitters. Differential pressure transmitters For open tanks the transmitter is installed in the tank by means of a diaphragm seal, the other side of the transmitter being left open to the atmosphere. For closed tanks, remote seals with capillaries can be used or pressure piping can be run to the head pressure tapping point. Although it can be fitted with sanitary fittings, a differential pressure transmitter is seldom designed solely for level measurement. For closed tanks there is a certain advantage in having a direct reading of level. This is outweighed, however, by the unfavourable temperature effect (due to fill fluid in the long piping or capillaries) and the fact that the head pressure is often required as a control variable.
Level and flow measurement in food process control
307
Hydrostatic pressure transmitters A good hydrostatic pressure sensor is designed specifically for level measurement. It will operate continuously at temperatures up to 100 ºC, is insensitive to build-up of product and will withstand CIP temperatures of up to 130 ºC over short periods without permanent damage or the need for readjustment. A substantial overpressure range (20) prevents damage due to pressure surges caused, e.g. by stirrers. The fill fluid must be suitable for food applications, and the housing requires a rating of IP 65 or above. For closed vessels the differential pressure must be calculated electronically. This might be done in a remote transmitter or in the controller itself. In 4 . . . 20 mA instruments, see Section 11.4, there is no possibility of displaying the level at the instrument itself, so a separate display must be used. In the latest generation of fieldbus instruments, however, the corrected level can be can be transmitted back from the controller and displayed at the device. If the product in the tank changes frequently, then it is advantageous to have automatic density correction. This is usually done by a remote transmitter that has an additional input for a second pressure sensor or limit switch mounted a third of the way up the tank. The density is corrected when the second transmitter is covered by the liquid. Depending on remote transmitter, the density may also be available as a process value. 11.2.4 Time-of-flight methods Although radically different in their mechanical implementation, see Fig. 11.1, the ultrasonic, microwave (or radar) and guided microwave principles are all time-of-flight measurement methods. A time-of-flight instrument comprises evaluating electronics and a sensor which acts as both a transmitter and receiver. In a transmitting phase, a pulse is launched towards the product. The pulse interacts with the product surface, producing an echo that travels back towards the sensor. The sensor, now acting as a receiver, passes on the echoes it receives to the evaluating electronics. This analyses the echoes received over a fixed period of time and identifies the level echo. The distance d of the product surface from the sensor is then calculated from the time it took for the pulse to travel to the product surface and back, i.e. its time-of-flight t, according to the following formula: d c t=2 where c is the velocity of sound for ultrasonics and the velocity of light for microwaves. Provided the distance of the empty level (0%) from the sensor is known to the electronics, it is an easy matter to derive the level. This information, together with the desired 100% level, is simply entered into the instrument during commissioning; there is no requirement the vessel be specially filled or emptied. There is some advantage in having an empty vessel at the start of commissioning, however, because depending upon the conditions of measurement, the sensor may also receive echoes from other objects in the pulse’s path, e.g. fittings. With an empty vessel, an echo map of the entire vessel can be made. All spurious echoes are then identified and suppressed by the electronics during normal measurement. Ultrasonic level measurement The ultrasonic principle is non-contact and uses ultrasonic waves that are generated by a piezoelectric pile which drives a flexible diaphragm (see also Chapter 12). The measuring system comprises either a compact unit or a separate sensor and transmitter. The
308
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
transmitter is then located in a control room or field enclosure. The sensor itself should not be positioned in the centre of the vessel, since this causes double echoes. Neither should it be positioned too near the side walls, in the filling stream or directly in line with internal fittings. Liquid measurement If liquids are to be measured, the sensor must be directed perpendicular to the product surface. The measurement is independent of the liquid properties but dependent upon the velocity of sound; thus the measurement is affected by the medium between the sensor and liquid surface. Under constant operating conditions, this effect can be eliminated by entering a sonic velocity parameter. If there is a density gradient above the liquid surface e.g. due to outgassing or evaporation, the microwave method is to be preferred. In general the ultrasonic method can be used for pressures from 0.8 bar to 3 bar (sensor dependent); the diaphragm can withstand temperatures up to 80 ºC. Measuring ranges up to 40 m are possible. Bulk solids In order to measure bulk solids, the surface of the material must reflect a significant proportion of the emitted pulse. An instrument will operate independently of the angle of the filling cone or the slope of the discharge chute if a diffuse reflection can be produced. This is generally the case if the granularity of the surface is greater than 1/4 of the wavelength used (>3 mm–8 mm, depending on sensor). If the granularity is less than 1/6 of the wavelength, then the surface texture comes into play. This means that, e.g. dry and free-flowing solid has completely different reflection characteristics to moist solid, which tends to form patterned surfaces. If the surface has no pronounced texture, it will act as a mirror and the sensor receives an echo which has travelled back via the silo walls. Under these circumstances, level cannot be measured accurately and the microimpulse method should be used. The operating conditions are identical to those for liquids. Depending upon sensor, measuring ranges of up to 70 m are possible. Dusty conditions, however, may temporarily reduce this value by up to 25%. Microimpulse level measurement The microimpulse method is a contacting method in which the sensing element is a steel rope probe. An extremely short electromagnetic pulse is launched onto the probe rope and guided, practically free of attenuation, to the product surface. Here it is reflected and travels back along the probe rope to the evaluating electronics, which then determines the level from its time of flight. The microimpulse method is suitable for fine-grained bulk solids, grain size up to 20 mm, that have a minimum dielectric constant of 1.8. Above this threshold, the method measures independently of dielectric constant. The power loss in dusty or wet atmospheres is low, so that powdery solids present no problems. The measurement is also independent of temperature and the pressure fluctuations which can occur during the filling and emptying of the silo. Measurements up to 150 ºC present no problems. Generally, a rope thickness of 4 mm suffices for silos up to 10 m and of 8 mm for silos up to 20 m high. The stainless steel rope and process connection required for food applications, is able to withstand forces of up to 1 tonne in the first case, and of up to 4 tonnes in the second. Naturally, the silo roof must also be designed to withstand the same forces.
Level and flow measurement in food process control
309
Microwave level measurement The microwave (or radar) principle is a non-contacting method for measuring liquid level, the sensor being mounted in the vessel roof. The systems on the market use one of two methods: frequency modulated continuous wave (FMCW) or pulsed wave time-offlight. In both methods, the microwaves are launched into the vessel via an antenna which may be a horn, parabolic dish or rod. For food applications, the latter is preferred. The FMCW method was developed for tank-gauging where level changes are relatively slow. The level is determined from a phase shift between emitted and received microwaves which is proportional to the distance travelled. The time-of-flight method operates as described at the start of this section. Since microwaves travel at the speed of light, however, it is not possible to make one measurement per pulse cycle. Instead, tiny portions of the received echo are successively sampled resulting in a retarded copy of the received echo profile. The extended echo profile still has a repetition frequency some ten times faster than the FMCW method, and can be processed in a similar manner to an ultrasonic echo. The microwave method is suitable for practically all liquids encountered in food manufacture. Depending upon sensor, levels up to 30 m can be measured at temperatures up to 250 ºC and pressures up to 64 bar. From a practical standpoint, the measurement is uninfluenced by a change in pressure, temperature or by the existence of gas/vapours above the product to be measured. Build-up on tank walls is ignored or eliminated by smart filtering of received signals. 11.2.5 Vibration method The vibration method is used for limit detection and since its introduction over fifteen years ago has been installed in well over one million measuring points. In the original design, a sensor in the form of a tuning fork is forced to vibrate at a set frequency. Other designs use rods. When liquid or solid comes into contact with the fork tines, the frequency changes, and a switching signal is output. This might switch a relay or transistor output built in the sensor itself or be passed on to a separate switching unit. For food applications, the sensor normally comprises a single stainless steel casting welded to the process connection to provide gap-free mounting. The fork tines are designed to provide maximum sensitivity whilst at the same time allowing the medium to flow quickly away when the product level falls. The material must be FDA approved and all wetted parts ground and highly polished so that there is no danger of residues collecting in cavities. Typical operating temperatures are 40 ºC to 150 ºC for the wetted parts and 40 ºC to 70 ºC for the electronics. Higher temperatures can be withstood for short periods without damage to the sensor, e.g. when cleaning or sterilising in place. The vibration method can be used in all liquids having a viscosity of 10 000 cSt or less and for solids with grain size up to 10 mm. Within these restrictions, the measurement is unaffected by changes in physical properties of the product, including viscosity as well as in process conditions such as turbulence, foam, build-up, gas bubbles or solid suspensions. The process pressure limits are well defined; up to 25 bar at 150 ºC and up to 40 bar at 100 ºC. The sensor requires no calibration and maintenance is negligible.
310
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
11.3
Flow measurement
Flow, like level measurement, is used both to control the process and to deliver quantity information to the plant operators. There are a large number of methods available, so that the choice between them is sometimes difficult. The selection must take into account many different factors such as accuracy, line size, environment, purchase costs and installation. Hygiene is also an important factor, since the flowmeter, as an in-line instrument, is always in contact with the medium to be measured. The wetted parts must be manufactured from suitable materials, which are smooth and easy to clean, see Section 10.4. Design must concentrate on minimising dead spaces and the meter should be able to withstand the temperatures met in CIP or SIP procedures. If the instrument cannot be cleaned in situ, it must be easily dismantled to facilitate cleaning. Fluid properties such as high viscosity and entrained solids call for non-obstructive measurement. Products such as hydrogenised oils, which solidify at relatively high temperatures, may require that the flowmeter is heated. If chilled products are to be measured, then the degree of protection of the sensor housing must be sufficient to prevent the ingress of condensation. Ideally the flowmeter should have no moving parts, thus reducing maintenance and improving long-term performance and reliability. Despite the latter requirement, two mechanical measurement methods, positive displacement and turbine meters are often encountered in the food industry and are included here together with more modern methods such as electromagnetic and Coriolis principles. Table 11.2 indicates the areas of application of each measuring principle. For flow measurement purposes a conductive liquid is considered to have a minimum conductivity of 5 S/cm for externally powered flowmeters and 50 S/cm for looppowered devices. Examples are tap water, fruit juices, yoghurt, milk, beer as well as acids, alkalis and water-based emulsions. Non-conductive liquids generally have a conductivity below the range of 1 to 50 S/cm. Examples are fuel oils, solvents and demineralised water. 11.3.1 Positive displacement method The positive displacement meter, see Fig. 11.3, comprises a number of fixed volume chambers arranged so that they rotate about an axis within the meter housing. As liquid flows into the meter it fills the inlet chamber causing the device to rotate. This pushes Table 11.2
Areas of application for flow measurement methods Medium
Principle
Conductive liquids
Nonconductive liquids
Positive displacement Turbine Electro-magnetic Coriolis Vortex Ultrasonic Differential pressure Thermal mass
x x x x x x x
x x x x x x
Gases
Steam
x
x
x x x x x
x x x
Level and flow measurement in food process control
311
Fig. 11.3 Principle of operation of the positive displacement meter (rotary piston oval gear meter).
liquid out of outlet chamber into the line. The rotation drives mechanical linkages and gears, which counts the discrete volumes of liquid flowing through the meter. The liquid volume is displayed by a simple counter mounted on the instrument head. Alternatively, the signal is converted electromechanically to a rate-of-flow indication or the pulse is tranmitted to an external counter or control system. There are many designs of positive displacement meter ranging from rotary piston, oval gear meters to reciprocating piston and bi-rotor meters. The type used is dependent both upon the application and the performance required. PD meters need no auxiliary energy, no straight lengths to ensure unobstructed flow into the meter, and work very well on a range of product viscosities, even at low flow rates. It is still popular within the industry, with installation in a wide variety of applications from tanker loading meters to batch control meters for liquids such as edible oil, syrups, etc. The wetted parts of the meter are generally high-grade stainless steel and a wide range of hygienic, if relatively expensive, designs are available. The device can be cleaned only by dismantling the chamber system, and the moving parts are subject to mechanical wear, which means the meter must be re-calibrated at regular intervals. Since there is a noticeable pressure drop across the meter, attention must be paid to back pressure when the meter is installed if cavitation is to be avoided. 11.3.2 Turbine meters The turbine meter comprises a bladed rotor which converts free stream energy into rotary motion. It is designed to create minimal disturbance to the flow. Ideally it cuts through the fluid in a helix, so that every revolution of the helix represents one complete axial length of the screw and hence a length or volume of fluid. The blade movement is detected by a pick-up coil, generally located on the outside of the meter. The coil generates an electrical pulse on each blade revolution that represents a discrete unit of volume, established during calibration. When correctly used, the meter provides high accuracy, whereby the absolute accuracy is affected by flow profile and fluid swirl. For this reason it must be installed well away from upstream fittings. Often the turbine meter is fitted with integral flow conditioning devices to smooth the flow. As for the PDs, back pressure must also be considered. It is generally suitable for low viscosity products only and therefore complements the PD meter in its application area. Typically it can be found in dairy and beverage industries, monitoring products including milks, beers and water, and in its simplest form provides good performance at an attractive cost. Several designs are available and
312
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
hygienic versions with stainless-steel wetted parts can be obtained for a reasonable cost. The units can be cleaned in place, provided care is taken not to overspeed the rotor, which would cause a significant reduction of meter life and accuracy. Due to the moving parts, the meter must be regularly maintained and re-calibrated. 11.3.3 Electromagnetic method The electromagnetic flow meter, see Fig. 11.4, makes use of Faraday’s law of electromagnetic induction. This states that when an electrical conductor moves in a magnetic field a voltage is induced. In the meter, the fluid is the electrical conductor, and the magnetic field is generated by coils mounted on the outside of the pipe carrying the fluid. The voltage induced as the fluid flows through the magnetic field is detected by two electrodes, mounted on opposite sides of an electrically insulated pipe wall. The signal produced is proportional to the flowrate and independent of changes in fluid density, viscosity, pressure and temperature, thus forming the ideal basis for the measurement of all conductive liquids. As the meter presents itself to the fluid as a section of straight pipe, no restriction occurs at the point of measurement. Consequently, as well as monitoring beer, water, and milk it can also accurately determine the flow rate of complex products such as yoghurt, molasses or rice pudding without damaging them. The meter is suitable for a variety of
Fig. 11.4
Principle of various electromagnetic flowmeters; (a) Electromagnetic method, (b) Coriolis method, (c) Vortex shedding method.
Level and flow measurement in food process control
313
applications from high-speed batching of final product into containers, to custody transfer meters for milk delivery vehicles or incoming liquid reception. For food applications the wetted parts are usually transfer-moulded PFA/PTFE, ceramic and stainless steel. The meter can be cleaned in place with hot cleaning fluid or steam at temperatures up to 180 ºC. It can be installed in virtually any position in the pipeline, requiring a straight run of only 3 to 5 pipe diameters upstream of the meter. The device is generally insensitive to flow profile and swirl, but like most meters gives best results when operating in the turbulent flow regime. Empty pipes will cause the meter to output random values, but a good meter will offer empty pipe detection to inhibit this. Often in food process plant when monitoring high viscosity products the flow regime may be laminar or transitional, and in this instance the absolute accuracy of the meter may suffer although the repeatability will be good. 11.3.4 Coriolis method The Coriolis mass flow meter, see Fig. 11.4, comprises a balanced oscillating system, whereby two metering tubes oscillate at their natural frequency. A sensor is mounted at both the inlet and outlet side of the meter. Under no-flow conditions, the oscillations monitored by the sensors are exactly in phase with each other. As the mass of fluid starts to flow through the meter, a distortion of the meter geometry occurs, resulting in a phase difference between inlet and outlet sensor. This phase difference is directly proportional to the mass flow rate of the fluid. Since the resonant frequency of the tubes is directly related to the mass of fluid in the tubes, it is also possible to measure density. The tube temperature is also monitored. On-board software also allows calculation of foodindustry specific units (ºBrix for example). These many possibilities make the Coriolis mass flow meter a valuable measurement device in the food industry. Various tube designs are available, however, the technique employed is the same. The straight tube design is ideal for the food industry, as it is compact, fully drainable, easily cleaned and requires no special installation aids. Coriolis meters offer very high accuracy, have no requirement for up- and downstream lengths and operate independently of changing fluid properties such as viscosity, density, temperature, etc. Since a Coriolis meter indicates in mass units, e.g. pounds or kilograms, it has a fundamental advantage in continuous blending and process monitoring, particularly in situations when the final product is to be sold on a weight basis. The device will measure viscous media, and gives good results for complex products such as soup, chocolate, honey and mayonnaise. Although the measurement is independent of viscosity, the meter does create a slight pressure loss, which increases with viscosity for a given flow rate. On products which readily cavitate, therefore, a slight back pressure will be required. Normally this can be achieved by mounting a control valve or restriction after the meter. The device can be cleaned in place, and steam-sterilised at temperatures up to 200 ºC. 11.3.5 Vortex shedding method The Vortex flow meter uses the phenomenon of the Karman vortex street, see Fig. 11.4. When a fluid flows against a non-streamlined bluff body in a pipe, the layers of the fluid near the body cannot follow its contours. They separate from its surface and form vortices that are swept downstream with the fluid. This vortex stream is called the Karman vortex street. The vortices are shed alternately from either side of the bluff body. The movement of the bluff body associated with the shedding of each vortex is detected, e.g. by a
314
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
capacitive sensor. By counting the number of vortices shed per second (their frequency), the mean flow velocity of the fluid can be measured. When sized correctly, the meter will provide a linear output, low pressure loss and high accuracy over a wide flow range for low viscosity liquids, steam and gas. Turndowns of up to 50:1 are possible, i.e. the flowmeter can be set up to measure across a range that is 1/50th of nominal. When the minimum prescribed flow rate is reached, however, the device will cut off, i.e. the output drops to zero. This should be considered during initial design stages. Modern meters offer cost-effective measurement. A single unit can supply process information including instantaneous flow rate, totalised flow, plus alarm status. The device has no moving parts, and inserts directly into the pipeline, making installation straightforward. The combination of these advantages has seen an increasing use of vortex meters, particularly for steam flow measurement. 11.3.6 Ultrasonic method The ultrasonic method is an in-line, non-contact method of flow measurement. In principle there are two measurement methods: the Doppler method and the time-of-flight method. The Doppler method measures flow by detecting the change in frequency that occurs when an ultrasonic pulse is reflected by a bubble or particle in a flowing medium. It is used in the food industry for a few special applications (see Chapter 12). The time-of flight method uses two sensors that both emit and receive ultrasonic pulses, see Fig. 11.5. These are placed on the same side of the pipe, a small distance away from each other. The electronics register the time-of-flight of an ultrasonic pulse from one sensor to the other, both in the direction and against the direction of flow. Under no-
Fig. 11.5
Principle of time-of-flight ultrasonic flow-measurement.
Level and flow measurement in food process control
315
flow conditions, the time-of-flight is the same in both directions, otherwise the difference is proportional to the flow rate. The time-of flight method is suitable for fluids with no or very little solid content. The sensors can be in-line or clamp on. By using additional sensors a multi-path measurement can be made, which allows unsymmetrical and laminar flows to be accurately measured. This makes it suitable for highly viscous fluids and very low flowrates. 11.3.7 Differential pressure systems The food industry uses differential pressure measurement almost exclusively for flow measurement in service systems, e.g. steam or compressed air lines. The overriding factors here are the high operating pressures and temperatures that can be encountered, plus the simplicity of the device. Flow is measured by means of a so-called primary element. This is simply a restriction within the pipe which produces a pressure drop proportional to the square of the fluid velocity as the fluid flows through it. The transmitter monitors the pressure across the primary element and gives a direct reading of flow rate. A wide variety of primary elements exist, but by far the most common is the orifice plate. Other elements tend only to be selected when pressure losses in the line need to be kept to a minimum, e.g. Pitot tubes. All differential pressure system primary elements have a square law output characteristic which restricts their useful flow range. A 5:1 change in flow rate corresponds to a 25:1 change in differential pressure. Combine this with the limiting range of the differential pressure cell, and the effective operating flow range of the system tends to be in the region of 4:1. A reasonable performance can be achieved, but wear of the orifice edge will quickly reduce the meter’s absolute accuracy. Repeatability, however, remains good and they are well suited to the measurement and control of essentially constant flow rates. This technique is popular because of its robustness and simplicity, combined with a wealth of independent data surrounding operation and installation. 11.3.8 Thermal dispersion techniques The thermal mass flowmeter is used to measure the mass flow rate of gases. In its simplest form it consists of two sensors comprising matched resistance thermometers. One senses the temperature of the gas, whilst the other is heated to main a constant differential to the gas temperature by passing a current through it. As gas flows past, it cools the heated sensor. There is a thermodynamic relationship between the gas mass flow rate, the power provided to the heater and the temperature difference. Hence by controlling and measuring the power fed to the sensor, it is possible to measure the gas mass flow rate. The thermal meter has many advantages for gas measurement. It has a wide turndown, up to 100:1, and a good design has negligible pressure loss. It measures mass flow rate directly without a need for additional temperature or pressure compensation. It can be used extensively in process gas measurement, including CO2 distribution, nitrogen gas distribution and purge flows, natural gas metering and compressed air with excellent results. The thermal properties of the gas must be taken into account when specifying the meter.
316
Instrumentation and sensors for the food industry
11.3.9 Bulk solids Within certain sectors of the food industry, a need exists to monitor the transportation of bulk solids to various parts of the plant. This might include coffee, salt, potatoes, tea, cereals, fruit and vegetables, etc. The requirement may be a simple switch to determine that a product is no longer falling from a conveyor belt, to a continuous measurement, e.g. the flow of crisps to a flavour drum, to ensure the correct ratio of the flavouring. The switching may often be done by microwave barriers, which signal either the presence of absence of product between their transmitter and receiver units. Alternatively a Gunn diode can be used to determine whether a product is moving or not. This emits a continuous signal which is reflected back to the sensor, and uses the Doppler effect to determine the movement. Impact plate weighers, in which the product falls onto a sensing plate can be used to measure the bulk flow of free flowing solids. The fall height must be at least 800 mm, the measuring range is from 30 kg/h to 120 kg/h. The alternative is to use a load cell mounted under a conveyer belt. After calibration with the empty belt, such belt weighing systems are capable of accuracies of 0.25% to 2%, depending upon design.
11.4
Process automation
Process automation is one of the most important aspects of modern plant management. When a new plant is planned or an existing plant is extended or revamped, once the basic engineering has been settled (what is to be produced, what equipment is required, where is the piping to run), the next thing to be decided is the automation concept. This comes before any instrumentation is bought and details which process variables are to be measured and for what they are to be used. Limit signals are used to actuate or shut off pumps, valves, solenoids, etc. Quantity measurements may also serve the same purpose, but the information they carry is often required to manage the plant. Just how the signals from the sensors are transmitted to the actuators or carried to upper levels of a control system depends upon the automation concept chosen. Ten years ago, the choice lay between pneumatic and 4 . . . 20 mA systems. Today, the digital fieldbus is becoming increasingly important. In ten years time, we may all be sitting in our armchairs controlling the plant from our mobile phones. Such is the pace of change, that the technology and possibilities change from year to year. In describing process automation, therefore, the concepts and opportunities have been given priority over the facts and figures. These can be obtained from the list of user organisations in Section 11.7. A more neutral assessment can be had from the instrumentation manufacturers, since most support a range of technologies. 11.4.1 The automation pyramid A good place to start when discussing process automation is the so-called automation pyramid, see Fig. 11.6. This comprises five levels that are considered in more detail in the following sections: 1. 2. 3.
field level input/output level (I/O level) process control level
Level and flow measurement in food process control
Fig. 11.6
4. 5.
317
The automation pyramid.
plant control or human-machine interface (HMI) level enterprise level.
It must be stressed, however, that the concept of a five-level control hierarchy as described in the following is already out of date. Modern fieldbus devices are equipped with the capability to drive control loops, so that the difference between control, I/O and field level is sometimes blurred. In addition, the shape of the pyramid suggests that most of the effort and cost is at the field level. This is not true. The enterprise l