Preface
The purpose of this book is to describe the theory of Hankel operators, one of the most important classes of o...
50 downloads
1515 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Preface
The purpose of this book is to describe the theory of Hankel operators, one of the most important classes of operators on spaces of analytic functions. Hankel operators can be defined as operators having infinite Hankel matrices (i.e., matrices with entries depending only on the sum of the coordinates) with respect to some orthonormal basis. Finite matrices with this property were introduced by Hankel, who found interesting algebraic properties of their determinants. One of the first results on infinite Hankel matrices was obtained by Kronecker, who characterized Hankel matrices of finite rank as those whose entries are Taylor coefficients of rational functions. Since then Hankel operators (or matrices) have found numerous applications in classical problems of analysis, such as moment problems, orthogonal polynomials, etc. Hankel operators admit various useful realizations, such as operators on spaces of analytic functions, integral operators on function spaces on (0, ∞), operators on sequence spaces. In 1957 Nehari described the bounded Hankel operators on the sequence space 2 . This description turned out to be very important and started the contemporary period of the study of Hankel operators. We begin the book with introductory Chapter 1, which defines Hankel operators and presents their basic properties. We consider different realizations of Hankel operators and important connections of Hankel operators with the spaces BM O and V M O, Sz.-Nagy–Foais functional model, reproducing kernels of the Hardy class H 2 , moment problems, and Carleson imbedding operators.
vi
Preface
It turns out that for the needs of applications it is also important to consider vectorial Hankel operators, i.e., Hankel operators on spaces of vector functions. We introduce vectorial Hankel operators in Chapter 2, to be used later in the book in control theory, approximation theory, and Wiener–Hopf factorizations (Chapters 11, 13, and 14). In Chapter 3 we introduce another very important class of operators on spaces of analytic functions, the class of Toeplitz operators. They can be defined as operators having infinite matrices with entries depending only on the difference of the coordinates. Though Hankel and Toeplitz operators have quite different properties, Hankel operators play an important role in the study of Toeplitz operators, and vice versa. We also study in Chapter 3 vectorial Toeplitz operators. In Chapter 4 we analyze the singular values of Hankel operators. The main result of the chapter is the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem, which shows that the nth singular value of a Hankel operator is the distance to the set of Hankel operators of rank at most n. Chapter 5 deals with parametrization of solutions of the Nehari problem. In other words, we parametrize the symbols of a Hankel (or a vectorial Hankel) operator that belong to the ball in L∞ of a given radius. In Chapter 6 we describe the Hankel operators that belong to Schatten– von Neumann classes S p as those whose symbols belong to certain Besov classes. We consider various applications of this description. In particular we obtain sharp results on rational approximation in the norm of BM O. In this book we study many different applications of Hankel operators (in approximation theory, prediction theory, interpolation problems, control theory, etc). In Chapters 8 and 9 we use Hankel operators to study regularity conditions for stationary processes. Chapter 10 is an introduction to the spectral theory of Hankel operators. We continue the analysis of the spectral problems of Hankel operators in Chapter 12, where we give a complete description of the spectral properties of the self-adjoint Hankel operators. It turns out that not only are Hankel operators used in control theory, but also the theory of Hankel operators can benefit from methods of control theory. In particular, in Chapter 12 the results on spectral properties of self-adjoint Hankel operators are based on balanced linear systems with continuous time and discrete time, a notion borrowed from control theory. Chapter 11 is devoted to applications of Hankel operators in control theory. We consider linear systems with discrete time and continuous time, the problems of robust stabilization, model reduction, and model matching. In Chapter 13 we study hereditary properties of maximizing vectors of vectorial Hankel operators. In other words, for a broad class of function spaces X we prove that if the symbol belongs to X, then all maximizing vectors belong to the same space X. We give several applications of this result. In particular, we use it to obtain hereditary properties of Wiener– Hopf factorizations.
Preface
vii
In Chapter 14 vectorial Hankel operators are used in the theory of approximation by analytic matrix and operator functions. We introduce the important notion of superoptimal approximation and prove the uniqueness of a superoptimal approximation under certain mild conditions on the matrix function. We obtain certain special factorizations and prove inequalities between the singular values of the corresponding Hankel operators and superoptimal singular values of their symbols. This beautiful theory has been developed during the last decade; it demonstrates the importance of vectorial Hankel operators in noncommutative analysis. One of the most beautiful applications of Hankel operators is given in Chapter 15. The last chapter gives a solution to the famous problem of whether a polynomially bounded operator on Hilbert space must be similar to a contraction. This problem remained open for a long time. In particular, it was one of the problems in a famous paper by Paul Halmos called “Ten problems in Hilbert space”. Recently it has been solved in the negative with the help of vectorial Hankel operators. In this book we discuss only classical Hankel operators (i.e., operators with Hankel matrices or, in other words, Hankel operators on the Hardy class H 2 ). For the last 20 years many interesting results have been obtained about various generalizations of Hankel operators (commutators of multiplications and Calder´ on–Zygmund operators, paracommutators, Hankel operators on Bergman spaces, Hankel operators on function spaces on the polydisk, on the unit ball in Cn , on classical domains, etc). However, it is physically impossible to cover such generalizations in one book, and we restrict ourselves to classical Hankel operators. Even under this constraint it is hardly possible to cover all aspects of Hankel operators and their applications (for example, this book does not include applications of Hankel operators in noncommutative geometry, perturbation theory, or asymptotics of Toeplitz determinants). Each chapter ends with Concluding Remarks, where the reader can find references to some results not included here. Theorems, lemmas, and corollaries (as well as displayed formulas) are numbered lexicographically. Within the same chapter Theorem 3.5 means the fifth item of Section 3. To refer to a result from a different chapter, we use three numbers: Lemma 5.5.4 means the fourth item of Section 5 in Chapter 5. Reference to §6 means Section 6 within the same chapter. Reference to §4.3 means Section 3 in Chapter 4. Displayed formulas have an independent numeration. For convenience we add two appendices in which the reader can find necessary information on operator theory and function spaces. Reference to Appendix 2.5 means Section 5 of Appendix 2. I would like to express my deep gratitude to my colleagues with whom I discussed many aspects of Hankel operators and their applications. I am especially grateful to A.B. Aleksandrov, R.B. Alexeev, E.M. Dyn’kin,
viii
Preface
A.Y. Kheifets, S.V. Khrushch¨ev, S.V. Kislyakov, A.V. Megretskii, N.K. Nikol’skii, S.R. Treil, V.I. Vasyunin, A.L. Volberg, and N.J. Young. Okemos, Michigan May, 2002
Vladimir V. Peller
Notation
Symbols Z, R, C denote the set of integers, real numbers, and complex numbers. def
def
R+ = {x ∈ R : x ≥ 0}, Z+ = {n ∈ Z : n ≥ 0}. def
def
T = {ζ ∈ C : |ζ| = 1}, D = {ζ ∈ C : |ζ| < 1}. z denotes the identity map of C (or a subset of C) onto itself. m is normalized Lebesgue measure on T. m2 is planar Lebesgue measure. ϕ(n) ˆ is the nth Fourier coefficients of ϕ. Lp means the Lp space of functions on T with respect to m, unless otherwise specified. B(X, Y ) for Banach spaces X and Y is the space of bounded linear operadef
tors from X to Y , B(X) = B(X, X). H p is the Hardy class of functions analytic in D (see Appendix 2). If X is a Banach space, Lp (X) and H p (X) denote the X-valued Lp and H p spaces. If E is a subset of R or T, Lp (E) denotes the Lp -space of functions on E; this should not lead to a confusion with the previous notation. H p (C+ ) (H p (C− ), H p (C+ ), or H p (C− )) denotes the Hardy class of functions analytic in the upper (lower, right, or left) half-plane.
x
Notation
If E is a subset of R or T and X is a Banach space, we use the notation Lp (E, X) for the Lp -space of X-valued functions on E. def F is the Fourier transform, (Ff )(t) = R f (s)e−2πist ds, f ∈ L1 (R). span A means the closed linear span of a subset E in a Banach space. 1 is the constant function identically equal to 1. O is the zero in a vector space.
P is the space of trigonometric polynomials of the form cj z j . P + is the space of analytic polynomials of the form cj z j . j≥0
P − is the space of antianalytic polynomials of the form
cj z j .
j<0
If X is a space of functions on T such that X ⊂ L1 (or X is a space of distributions on T), we put def X+ = {f ∈ X : fˆ(j) = 0 for j < 0}
and
def X− = {f ∈ X : fˆ(j) = 0 for j ≥ 0}.
S p is the Scahtten–von Neumann class (see Appendix 1). C = S ∞ is the space of compact operators on Hilbert space. 2Z is the space of two-sided sequences {xn }n∈Z such that |xn |2 < ∞. n∈Z
All Hilbert spaces are assumed separable. Unless otherwise stated, an operator means a bounded linear operator.
Contents
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 1. Bounded Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 2. Hankel Operators and Compressed Shift . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 3. Hankel Operators of Finite Rank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 4. Interpolation Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 5. Compactness of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 6. Hankel Operators and Reproducing Kernels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 7. Hankel Operators and Moment Sequences . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39 8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis . . . 46 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61 1. Completing Matrix Contractions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62 2. Bounded Block Hankel Matrices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66 3. Hankel Operators and the Commutant Lifting Theorem . . . . . 71 4. Compact Vectorial Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 5. Vectorial Hankel Operators of Finite Rank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76 6. Imbedding Theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84 Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .87 1. Basic Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .88 2. A General Invertibility Criterion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 3. Spectra of Certain Toeplitz Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 4. Toeplitz Operators on Spaces of Vector Functions . . . . . . . . . . 103
xii
Contents
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations of Symbols of Fredholm Toeplitz Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 109 6. Left Invertibility of Bounded Analytic Matrix Functions . . . . 119 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 121 Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 1. The Adamyan–Arov–Krein Theorem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 126 2. The Case sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131 3. Finite Rank Approximation of Vectorial Hankel Operators . .135 4. Relations between Hu and Hu¯ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .142 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem . . 147 1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case . . 148 2. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nevanlinna–Pick Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem .173 4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 187 5. Parametrization in the General Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 212 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 228 Chapter 6. Hankel Operators and Schatten–von Neumann Classes 231 1. Nuclearity of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 232 2. Hankel Operators of Class S p , 1 < p < ∞ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239 3. Hankel Operators of Class S p , 0 < p < 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 243 4. Hankel Operators and Schatten–Lorentz Classes . . . . . . . . . . . . 253 5. Projecting onto the Hankel Matrices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257 6. Rational Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 267 7. Other Applications of the S p Criterion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 275 8. Generalized Hankel Matrices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281 9. Generalized Block Hankel Matrices and Vectorial Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 292 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296 Chapter 7. Best Approximation by Analytic and Meromorphic Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 303 1. Function Spaces That Can Be Described in Terms of Rational Approximation in BM O . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 306 2. Best Approximation in Decent Banach Algebras . . . . . . . . . . . . 312 3. Best Approximation in Spaces without a Norm . . . . . . . . . . . . . 316 4. Examples and Counterexamples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 318 5. Badly Approximable Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 338 6. Perturbations of Multiple Singular Values of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 341 7. The Boundedness Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 344
Contents
xiii
8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
Arguments of Unimodular Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 355 Schmidt Functions of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 356 Continuity in the sup-Norm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 359 Continuity in Decent Banach Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 362 The Recovery Problem in Spaces of Measures and Interpolation by Analytic Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 371 1/p 13. The Fefferman–Stein Decomposition in Bp . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 376 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 376 Chapter 8. An Introduction to Gaussian Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 379 1. Gaussian Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 380 2. The Fock Space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 384 3. Mixing Properties and Regularity Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 390 4. Minimality and Basisness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 402 5. Scattering Systems and Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405 6. Geometry of Past and Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 408 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 412 Chapter 9. Regularity Conditions for Stationary Processes . . . . . . 415 1. Minimality in Spectral Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 415 2. Angles between Past and Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 417 3. Regularity Conditions in Spectral Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 420 4. Stronger Regularity Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .424 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 426 Chapter 10. Spectral Properties of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . 431 1. The Essential Spectrum of Hankel Operators with Piecewise Continuous Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 433 2. The Carleman Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 440 3. Quasinilpotent Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 443 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 450 Chapter 11. Hankel Operators in Control Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 453 1. Transfer Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 454 2. Realizations with Discrete Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 457 3. Realizations with Continuous Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .466 4. Model Reduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 472 5. Robust Stabilization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 473 6. Coprime Factorization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 476 7. Proof of Theorem 5.1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 479 8. Parametrization of Stabilizing Controllers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 482 9. Solution of the Robust Stabilization Problem. The Model Matching Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 485 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 487
xiv
Contents
Chapter 12. The Inverse Spectral Problem for Self-Adjoint Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 489 1. Necessary Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 493 2. Eigenvalues of Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 497 3. Linear Systems with Continuous Time and Lyapunov Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 499 4. Construction of a Linear System with Continuous Time . . . . 503 5. The Kernel of Γ h . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 509 6. Proofs of Lemmas 4.1 and 5.2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 516 7. Positive Hankel Operators with Multiple Spectrum . . . . . . . . . 518 8. Moduli of Hankel Operators, Past and Future, and the Inverse Problem for Rational Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 520 9. Linear Systems with Discrete Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 522 10. Passing to Balanced Linear Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 526 11. Asymptotic Stability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 529 12. The Main Construction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 531 13. Proof of Theorem 9.1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 536 14. Proofs of Lemmas 13.2 and 13.5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 542 15. A Theorem in Perturbation Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 548 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 550 Chapter 13. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations and the Recovery Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 553 1. The Recovery Problem in R-spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 554 2. Maximizing Vectors of Vectorial Hankel Operators . . . . . . . . . 555 3. Wiener–Masani Factorizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .557 4. Isometric-Outer Factorizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 560 5. The Recovery Problem and Wiener–Hopf Factorizations of Unitary-Valued Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 561 6. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations. The General Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . 562 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 563 Chapter 14. Analytic Approximation of Matrix Functions . . . . . . . 565 1. Balanced Matrix Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 568 2. Parametrization of Best Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 574 3. Superoptimal Approximation of H ∞ + C Matrix Functions . 578 4. Superoptimal Approximation of Matrix Functions Φ with Small Essential Norm of HΦ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .580 5. Thematic Factorizations and Very Badly Approximable Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 586 6. Admissible and Superoptimal Weights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 592 7. Thematic Indices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .594 8. Inequalities Involving Hankel and Superoptimal Singular Values . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 600 9. Invariance of Residual Entries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 602
Contents
xv
10. Monotone Thematic Factorizations and Invariance of Thematic Indices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 607 11. Construction of Superoptimal Approximation and the Corona Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 615 12. Hereditary Properties of Superoptimal Approximation . . . . . . 618 13. Continuity Properties of Superoptimal Approximation . . . . . . 623 14. Unitary Interpolants of Matrix Functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 636 15. Canonical Factorizations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 643 16. Very Badly Approximable Unitary-Valued Functions . . . . . . . 661 17. Superoptimal Meromorphic Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 662 18. Analytic Approximation of Infinite Matrix Functions . . . . . . . 672 19. Back to the Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization . . . . . . . . 681 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 682 Chapter 15. Hankel Operators and Similarity to a Contraction . . 685 1. Operators Rψ in the Scalar Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 687 2. Power Bounded Operators Rψ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .693 3. Counterexamples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 694 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 703 Appendix 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .705 Appendix 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .717 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 739 Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 776 Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 780
1 An Introduction to Hankel Operators
In this introductory chapter we define the Hankel operators and study their basic properties. We introduce in §1 the class of Hankel operators as operators with matrices of the form {αj+k }j,k≥0 and consider different realizations of such operators. One of the most important realization is 2 def = L2 H 2 . the Hankel operators Hϕ from the Hardy class H 2 to H− We prove the fundamental Nehari theorem, which describes the bounded Hankel operators, and we discuss the problem of finding symbols of minimal norm. We introduce the important Hilbert matrix, prove its boundedness, and estimate its norm. Then we study Hankel operators with unimodular symbols. We conclude §1 with the study of commutators of multiplication operators with the Riesz projection on L2 and reduce the study of such commutators to the study of Hankel operators. In §2 we study relationships between Hankel operators and functions of model operators in the Sz.-Nagy–Foias function model. We present the approach of N.K. Nikol’skii to prove the Sarason commutant lifting theorem. This approach is based on the Nehari theorem for Hankel operators. We also give some related results. Namely, we describe the Hankel operators with nontrivial kernels, the partially isometric Hankel operators, and the Hankel operators with closed ranges. One of the earliest results on Hankel operators is Kronecker’s theorem that describes the Hankel operators of finite rank as the Hankel operators with rational symbols. We give different proofs of Kronecker’s theorem in §3 and we give explicit formulas for Hϕ f when ϕ is rational.
2
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
In §4 we consider classical interpolation problems, the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem and the Carath´eodory–Fej´er interpolation problem. We reduce these interpolation problems to Hankel operators and solve them with the help of Hankel operators. In §5 we find the essential norm of a Hankel operator and we describe the compact Hankel operators. Then we study the problem of the approximation of a given Hankel operator by compact Hankel operators. We show that a best approximation always exists but it is never unique unless our Hankel operator is compact. Then we introduce the notion of local distance and we give a formula for the essential norm of Hankel operators in terms of local distance. Next, we use this result to evaluate the essential norm of Hankel operators with piecewise continuous symbols. We conclude §5 with a factorization theorem for functions in H ∞ + C. In §6 we show that to verify the boundedness or the compactness of a Hankel operator Hϕ , it suffices to consider the norms of Hϕ kζ , where the kζ , |ζ| < 1, are the normalized reproducing kernels of H 2 . Section 7 is devoted to relationships between Hankel operators and moment problems. We prove the Hamburger theorem, which characterizes the positive definite Hankel matrices in terms of moments of positive measures on R. Then we proceed to the study of bounded positive definite Hankel matrices in terms of moment sequences. After that we consider arbitrary bounded Hankel matrices and we characterize their entries as moment sequences of so-called Carleson measures on the unit disk. We also obtain similar results for compact Hankel operators. The final section of this chapter deals with integral operators on L2 (R+ ) with kernels depending on the sum of the coordinates. Such operators look like continual analogs of Hankel operators. However, we show that one can also reduce their study to the study of Hankel operators. We obtain in §8 boundedness, compactness, and finite rank criteria for such integral operators.
1. Bounded Hankel Operators Hankel operators can be defined in many different ways; they admit different realizations. Such a variety of realizations is important in applications, since in a concrete case we can choose a realization that is most suitable for the problem under consideration. We begin with the matricial definition of Hankel operators.
1. Bounded Hankel Operators
An infinite matrix is called α0 α1 α2 α3 .. .
3
a Hankel matrix if it has the form α1 α2 α3 · · · α2 α3 α4 · · · α3 α4 α5 · · · , α4 α5 α6 · · · .. .. .. . . . . . .
where α = {αj }j≥0 is a sequence of complex numbers. In other words, the Hankel matrices are the matrices whose entries depend only on the sum of the coordinates. If α ∈ 2 , we can consider the operator Γ : 2 → 2 with matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 that is defined on the dense subset of finitely supported sequences. In other words, if a = {an }n≥0 is a finitely supported sequence, then Γa = b ∈ 2 , where b = {bk }k≥0 is defined by bk = αj+k aj , k ≥ 0. j≥0
We call such operators Hankel operators. We say that Γ is a bounded operator if it extends to a bounded operator on 2 .
The Nehari Theorem The following theorem, which characterizes the bounded Hankel operators on 2 , is due to Nehari. Theorem 1.1. The Hankel operator Γ with matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 is bounded on 2 if and only if there exists a function ψ in L∞ on the unit circle T such that ˆ αm = ψ(m),
m ≥ 0.
(1.1)
In this case ˆ = αn , n ≥ 0}. Γ = inf{ψ∞ : ψ(n) ˆ Recall that ψ(n) is the nth Fourier coefficient of ψ. ˆ Proof. Let ψ ∈ L∞ and αm = ψ(m), m ≥ 0. Given a = {an }n≥0 and b = {bk }k≥0 finitely supported sequences in 2 , we have αj+k aj ¯bk . (1.2) (Γa, b) = j,k≥0
Let f=
j≥0
aj z j ,
g=
k≥0
¯bk z k .
4
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Then f and g are polynomials in the Hardy class H 2 . Put q = f g. It follows from (1.2) that (Γa, b)
=
j,k≥0
=
ˆ + k)aj ¯bk = ψ(j
ˆ ψ(m)
aj ¯bm−j
j=0
m≥0
ˆ ψ(m)ˆ q (m) =
m
¯ ψ(ζ)q(ζ)dm(ζ). T
m≥0
Therefore |(Γa, b)| ≤ ψ∞ qH 1 ≤ ψ∞ f H 2 gH 2 = ψL∞ a2 b2 . Conversely, suppose that Γ is bounded on 2 . Let L be the linear functional defined on the set of polynomials in H 1 by Lq = αn qˆ(n). (1.3) n≥0
Let us show that L extends by continuity to a continuous functional on H 1 and its norm L on H 1 satisfies L ≤ Γα .
(1.4)
By the Hahn–Banach theorem this will imply the existence of ψ in L∞ that satisfies (1.1) and ψ∞ ≤ Γα . Assume first that α ∈ . In this case the functional L defined by (1.3) is obviously continuous on H 1 . Let us prove (1.4). Let q ∈ H 1 and q1 ≤ 1. Then q admits a representation q = f g, where f, g ∈ H 2 and f 2 ≤ 1, g2 ≤ 1. We have 1
Lq
=
αm qˆ(m) =
m≥0
=
m≥0
αm
m
fˆ(j)ˆ g (m − j)
j=0
g (k) = (Γa, b), αj+k fˆ(j)ˆ
j,k≥0
where a = {aj }j≥0 , aj = fˆ(j) and b = {bk }k≥0 , bk = gˆ(k). Therefore |Lq| ≤ Γ · f 2 g2 ≤ Γ which proves (1.4) for α ∈ 1 . Assume now that α is an arbitrary sequence for which Γ is bounded. Let 0 < r < 1. Consider the sequence α(r) defined by (r)
αj
= rj αj ,
j ≥ 0,
and let Γr be the Hankel operator with matrix
(r) αj+k
see that Γr = Dr ΓDr , where Dr is multiplication by
. It is easy to
j,k≥0 {rj }j≥0
on 2 . Since
1. Bounded Hankel Operators
5
obviously Dr ≤ 1, it follows that the operators Γr are bounded and Γr ≤ Γ, Clearly, α
(r)
0 < r < 1.
∈ and so we have already proved that 1
Lr H 1 →C ≤ Γr ≤ Γ, where def
Lr q =
αn(r) qˆ(n),
q ∈ H 1.
n≥0
It is easy to see now that the functionals Lr being uniformly bounded converge strongly to L (i.e., Lr ψ → Lψ for any ψ ∈ H 1 ), which proves that L is continuous and satisfies (1.4). Theorem 1.1 reduces the problem of whether a sequence α determines a bounded operator on 2 to the question of the existence of an extension of α to the sequence of Fourier coefficients of a bounded function. By virtue of the work of C. Fefferman on the space BM O of functions of bounded mean oscillation (see Appendix 2.5 for definitions) it has become possible to determine whether Γ is bounded in terms of the sequence α itself. Recall that it follows from Fefferman’s results that a function ϕ on the unit circle belongs to the space BM O if and only if ϕ admits a representation ϕ = ξ + η˜, ξ, η ∈ L∞ , where η˜ is the harmonic conjugate of η (see Appendix 2.5). Recall also that BM OA is the space of BM O functions analytic in D, i.e., BM OA = BM O ∩ H 1 . Theorem 1.2. The operator Γ with matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 is bounded on 2 if and only if the function ϕ= αm z m (1.5) m≥0
belongs to BM OA. Proof. If Γ is bounded, then by Theorem 1.1 there exists a function ψ def ˆ in L∞ such that ϕ = P+ ψ (recall that P+ ψ = ψ(m)z m ). The fact that m≥0
ϕ ∈ BM O follows from the identity 1 ˆ P+ ψ = (ψ + iψ˜ + ψ(0)) 2 (see Appendix 2.1). Conversely, let ϕ ∈ H 1 and ϕ = ξ + η˜, ξ, η ∈ L∞ . Then η (0)) ϕ = P+ ϕ = P+ ξ + P+ η˜ = P+ (ξ − iη + iˆ (see Appendix 2.1). Clearly, Γ is a bounded operator if the function ϕ defined by (1.5) is bounded. However, the operator Γ can be bounded even with an unbounded ϕ. Let us consider an important example of such a Hankel matrix.
6
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
The Hilbert Matrix Let αn =
1 n+1 ,
n ≥ 0. The corresponding Hankel matrix 1 1/2 1/3 1/4 · · · .. 1/2 1/3 1/4 . . . . Γ = 1/3 1/4 .. 1/4 . .. .. . .
is called the Hilbert matrix. Clearly, the function 1 zn n+1 n≥0
is unbounded in D. However, Γ is bounded. Indeed, consider the function ψ on T defined by ψ(eit ) = ie−it (π − t),
t ∈ [0, 2π).
It is easy to see that 1 , n ≥ 0, n+1 and ψL∞ = π. It follows from Theorem 1.1 that Γ is bounded and Γ ≤ π. In fact, Γ = π (see §1.5, where we shall prove a stronger result). ˆ ψ(n) =
Hankel Operators on the Hardy Class We are going to consider another realization of Hankel operators. Namely, we define Hankel operators on the Hardy class H 2 of functions on the unit circle. This realization is extremely important in applications. Let ϕ be a function in the space L2 on the unit circle. We define the 2 def Hankel operator Hϕ : H 2 → H− = L2 H 2 on the dense subset of 2 polynomials in H by Hϕ f = P− ϕf,
(1.6)
2 (clearly, where P− is the orthogonal projection from L2 onto H− P− = I − P+ ). The function ϕ is called a symbol of the Hankel operator Hϕ (as we shall see below a Hankel operator has many different symbols). z j }j≥1 If we consider the standard orthonormal bases {z k }k≥0 in H 2 and {¯ 2 in H− , then Hϕ has Hankel matrix {ϕ(−j ˆ − k)}j≥1,k≥0 in these bases: (Hϕ z k , z¯j ) = ϕ(−j ˆ − k). Theorem 1.1 admits the following reformulation.
1. Bounded Hankel Operators
7
Theorem 1.3. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . The following statements are equivalent: (i) Hϕ is bounded on H 2 ; (ii) there exists a function ψ in L∞ such that ˆ ψ(m) = ϕ(m), ˆ
m < 0;
(1.7)
(iii) P− ϕ ∈ BM O. If one of the conditions (i)–(iii) is satisfied, then ˆ = ϕ(m), ˆ m < 0}. Hϕ = inf{ψL∞ : ψ(m)
(1.8)
Equality (1.7) is equivalent to the fact that Hϕ = Hψ . Thus (ii) means that Hϕ is bounded if and only if it has a bounded symbol. Thus the operators Hϕ with ϕ ∈ L∞ exhaust the class of bounded Hankel operators. If ϕ ∈ L∞ , then (1.8) can be rewritten in the following way: Hϕ = inf{ϕ − f ∞ : f ∈ H ∞ }.
(1.9)
In other words, the norm of Hϕ is the distance from ϕ to H ∞ . That is why the problem of approximation of an L∞ function by bounded analytic functions is called the Nehari problem.
Symbols of Minimal Norm Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Consider the infimum on the right-hand side of (1.9). It is attained for any ϕ ∈ L∞ . Indeed, let {fn }n≥1 be a sequence of functions in H ∞ such that lim ϕ − fn ∞ = Hϕ . n→∞
Clearly, {fn }n≥1 is a bounded sequence. So there is a subsequence {fnk } that converges to a function f in H ∞ in the weak topology induced by L1 . Then ϕ − f ∞ ≤ lim ϕ − fn ∞ = Hϕ . n→∞
On the other hand, it follows from Theorem 1.3 that ϕ − f ∞ ≥ Hϕ . Such a function f is called a best approximation of ϕ by analytic functions in the L∞ -norm. Thus we have proved that for any bounded Hankel operator there exists a symbol of minimal norm (equal to the norm of the operator). A natural question arises of whether such a symbol of minimal norm is unique. We shall see soon that it is not the case in general. However, in the case when the Hankel operator attains its norm on the unit ball of H 2 , i.e., Hϕ g2 = Hϕ · g2 for some nonzero g ∈ H 2 , we do have uniqueness as the following result shows.
8
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Theorem 1.4. Let ϕ be a function in L∞ such that Hϕ attains its norm on the unit ball of H 2 . Then there exists a unique function f in H ∞ such that ϕ − f ∞ = distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ ). Moreover, ϕ − f has constant modulus almost everywhere on T and admits a representation ¯ h ϕ − f = Hϕ · z¯ϑ¯ , h
(1.10)
where h is an outer function in H 2 and ϑ is an inner function. Proof. Without loss of generality we can assume that Hϕ = 1. Let g be a function in H 2 such that 1 = g2 = Hϕ g2 . Let f be a best approximation of ϕ, i.e., f ∈ H ∞ and ϕ − f ∞ = 1. We have 1 = Hϕ g2 = P− (ϕ − f )g2 ≤ (ϕ − f )g2 ≤ g2 = 1. Therefore the inequalities in the above chain are in fact equalities. The fact that P− (ϕ − f )g2 = (ϕ − f )2 2 means that (ϕ − f )g ∈ H− and so
Hϕ g = Hϕ−f g = (ϕ − f )g.
(1.11)
The function g being in H 2 is nonzero almost everywhere on T (see Appendix 2.1), and so Hϕ g f =ϕ− . g Hence, f is determined uniquely by Hϕ (the ratio (Hϕ g)/g does not depend on the choice of g). Since ϕ − f ∞ = 1, the equality (ϕ − f )g2 = g2 means that |ϕ(ζ) − f (ζ)| = 1 a.e. on the set {ζ : g(ζ) = 0}, which is of full measure because g ∈ H 2 . Thus ϕ − f has modulus one almost everywhere on T. Consider the functions g and z¯Hϕ g in H 2 . It follows from (1.11) that they have the same moduli. Therefore they admit factorizations g = ϑ1 h,
z¯Hϕ g = ϑ2 h,
where h is an outer function in H 2 , and ϑ1 and ϑ2 are inner functions. Consequently, ¯ ¯ Hϕ g z¯ϑ¯2 h h ϕ−f = = = z¯ϑ¯1 ϑ¯2 , g ϑ1 h h which proves (1.10) with ϑ = ϑ1 ϑ2 .
1. Bounded Hankel Operators
9
Remark. Under the hypotheses of Theorem 1.4 the best approximant f can be expressed in the form f =ϕ−
Hϕ g , g
(1.12)
where g is a maximizing function (i.e., Hϕ g2 = Hϕ · g2 , g = O). The function on the right-hand side does not depend on the choice of g. Corollary 1.5. Suppose that ϕ satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem 1.4 and the Fourier coefficients ϕ(n) ˆ are real for n < 0. Let f be the unique best uniform approximation of ϕ by bounded analytic functions. Then all Fourier coefficients of ϕ − f are real. z ))/2, we may assume that all Proof. By replacing ϕ with (ϕ(z) + ϕ(¯ Fourier coefficients of ϕ are real. It is easy to see that if f is a best uniform approximation of ϕ, then f (¯ z ) is also a best approximation. It follows now z ). from Theorem 1.4 that f (z) = f (¯ Corollary 1.6. If Hϕ is a compact Hankel operator, then the conclusion of Theorem 1.4 holds. Indeed any compact operator attains its norm. The following example shows that in general a function in L∞ can have many best approximations by analytic functions. Example. Let Ω be the Jordan domain defined by
|1 − ζ| <1 . Ω = ζ ∈ C : |ζ| + 2 It is easy to see that 1 ∈ ∂Ω. Let ω be a conformal map of D onto Ω such that ω(1) = 1 (since Ω has smooth boundary, the conformal map extends to a homeomorphism of T onto ∂Ω; see Goluzin [1], Ch. X, §1). Let B be a Blaschke product such that 1 is an accumulation point of the zeros of B. ¯ has different best approximations by analytic functions. Then ϕ = Bω Let us first show that distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ ) = 1. Indeed, ϕL∞ ≤ 1 and if f ∈ H ∞ , then ϕ − f ∞ = ω − Bf ∞ = sup |ω(ζ) − B(ζ)f (ζ)| ≥ 1, ζ∈D
since |ω(ζn )| → 1, where the ζn are the zeros of B. Let now f = (1 − ω)/2. Then f ∈ H ∞ and 1 ϕ − f ∞ = ω − Bf ∞ = sup ω(ζ) − B(ζ)(1 − ω(ζ)) 2 ζ∈D 1 ≤ sup |ω(ζ)| + |1 − ω(ζ)| ≤ 1, 2 ζ∈D since ω(ζ) ∈ Ω. Therefore O and (1 − ω)/2 are different best approximants to ϕ.
10
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
It will be shown in §5.1 that in the case when there are at least two best approximations to ϕ there exists a best approximation g such that ϕ−g has constant modulus on T and a parametrization of all best approximations will be given. We shall also see in §5.1 that there are functions ϕ in L∞ for which there exists only one best approximation f in H ∞ but ϕ − f does not have constant modulus on T.
Unimodular Symbols The following theorem gives a simple sufficient condition for a Hankel operator to have a unimodular symbol (i.e., symbol whose modulus is equal to one almost everywhere). Theorem 1.7. Let Hϕ be a Hankel operator such that Hϕ < 1. Then there exists a function u such that |u(ζ)| = 1 for almost all ζ in T, z u, H ∞ ) = 1. Hu = Hϕ , and distL∞ (¯ Proof. Without loss of generality we may assume that ϕ∞ < 1. Let t ≥ 0. Consider the function ϕt = ϕ + t. Clearly, distL∞ (ϕ0 , zH ∞ ) ≤ ϕ∞ < 1
and
lim distL∞ (ϕt , zH ∞ ) = ∞.
t→∞
Hence, there exists s > 0 such that distL∞ (ϕs , zH ∞ ) = 1. Consider the Hankel operator Hz¯ϕs . Clearly, z ϕs , H ∞ ) = distL∞ (ϕs , zH ∞ ) = 1. Hz¯ϕs = distL∞ (¯ On the other hand, Hz¯ϕs e ≤ Hz¯ϕs −s¯z = Hz¯ϕ ≤ ϕ∞ < 1. By Theorem 1.4, there exists a unique function f ∈ H ∞ such that ¯ z ϕs − f ∞ = 1 and |¯ z ϕs − f | = 1 almost everywhere on T. Put u = ϕs − zf = ϕ + sz − zf . Clearly, u is unimodular, Hu = Hϕ , and distL∞ (¯ z u, H ∞ ) = 1. Remark. It follows easily from Corollary 1.5 and from the construction given in the proof of Theorem 1.7 that if under the hypotheses of Theorem 1.7 the Fourier coefficients ϕ(n) ˆ are real for n < 0, then there exists a unimodular function u with real Fourier coefficients such that Hu = Hϕ and distL∞ (¯ z u, H ∞ ) = 1.
A Commutation Relation We show here that the Hankel operators can be characterized as the operators that satisfy a certain commutation relation. We also establish an important property of the kernel of a Hankel operator. 2 Theorem 1.8. Let R be a bounded operator from H 2 to H− . Then R is a Hankel operator if and only if it satisfies the following commutation
1. Bounded Hankel Operators
11
relation: P− SR = RS,
(1.13)
where S is the shift operator on H and S is bilateral shift on L . Proof. Let R = Hϕ , ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then 2
2
P− SRf = P− zHϕ f = P− zPϕf = P− zϕf = Hϕ zf. Suppose now that R satisfies (1.13). Let n ≥ 1, k ≥ 1. We have (Rz n , z¯k )
=
(RSz n−1 , z¯k ) = (P− SRz n−1 , z¯k )
=
(SRz n−1 , z¯k ) = (Rz n−1 , z¯k+1 ).
z k }k≥1 Therefore R has Hankel matrix in the bases {z n }n≥0 of H 2 and {¯ 2 of H− . It follows from Theorems 1.1 and 1.3 that R = Hϕ for some ϕ in L∞ . Corollary 1.9. Let R be a Hankel operator on H 2 . Then Ker R is an invariant subspace of S. The result follows immediately from (1.13). Note that the fact that the kernel of a Hankel operator is S-invariant also follows directly from the definition of a Hankel operator on H 2 .
Commutators of Multiplication Operators and the Riesz Projection We consider here operators that play an important role in harmonic analysis. For a function ϕ in L2 let Mϕ be the multiplication operator defined on the dense subset of trigonometric polynomials P in L2 by def Mϕ f = ϕf , f ∈ P. Consider now the commutator Cϕ = [Mϕ , P+ ] defined on P by Cϕ = [Mϕ , P+ ]f = ϕP+ f − P+ ϕf. We are going to obtain a necessary and sufficient condition for Cϕ to be bounded on L2 . Let us obtain a more explicit formula for Cϕ f . First we find a formula for P+ f . Suppose first that f is a smooth function (e.g., a trigonometric polynomial). We claim that
f (τ ) 1 (P+ f )(ζ) = p.v. dm(τ ) + f (ζ), (1.14) 1 − τ ¯ ζ 2 T where
f (τ ) f (τ ) def p.v. dm(τ ) = lim dm(τ ) ε→0 1 − τ ¯ ζ 1 − τ¯ζ T |τ −ζ|>ε (“p.v.” stands for “principal value”). Indeed,
f (τ ) f (τ ) − f (ζ) 1 p.v. dm(τ ) = dm(τ ) + f (ζ) p.v. dm(τ ). 1 − τ ¯ ζ 1 − τ ¯ ζ 1 − τ¯ζ T T T
12
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Clearly,
p.v. T
1 dm(τ ) 1 − τ¯ζ
= = =
1 dm(τ ) 1 − τ¯ T 1 1 + dm(τ ) 1 − τ¯ 1 − τ Im τ >0
1 2 dm(τ ). Re 1 − τ Im τ >0
p.v.
1 It is easy to see that for τ ∈ T \ {1} we have Re 1−τ = 12 , and so
1 1 dm(τ ) = . p.v. ¯ζ 2 T 1−τ
On the other hand, it is easy to verify that for f = z n we have
f (τ ) − f (ζ) 0, n ≥ 0, dm(τ ) = −ζ n , n < 0. 1 − τ¯ζ T Therefore
p.v. T
f (τ ) 1 1 dm(τ ) = −(P− f )(ζ) + f (ζ) = (P+ f )(ζ) − f (ζ), 1 − τ¯ζ 2 2
which implies (1.14). In fact, for any function f in L2 the integral
f (τ ) p.v. dm(τ ) ¯ζ T 1−τ exists for almost all ζ ∈ T and determines a bounded linear operator on L2 (see Stein [2], Ch. II, §4). Hence, (1.14) holds for any function f in L2 and for almost all ζ ∈ T. Obviously, (1.14) implies the following formula for Cϕ :
ϕ(ζ) − ϕ(τ ) f (τ )dm(τ ), f ∈ P. (1.15) Cϕ f = p.v. 1 − τ¯ζ T The following theorem gives a boundedness criterion for Cϕ . Theorem 1.10. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . The commutator Cϕ is bounded on L2 if and only if ϕ ∈ BM O. def
def
def
def
Proof. Put f+ = P+ f , f− = P− f , ϕ+ = P+ ϕ, and ϕ− = P− ϕ. We have Cϕ f
= ϕP+ f − P+ ϕf = ϕ+ f+ + ϕ− f+ − ϕ+ f+ − P+ ϕ− f+ − P+ ϕ+ f− = P− ϕ− f+ − P+ ϕ+ f− = Hϕ− f+ − (Hϕ+ )∗ f− .
It is easy to see now that Cϕ is bounded if and only if both Hankel operators Hϕ− and Hϕ+ are bounded. The result now follows from Theorem 1.3.
2. Hankel Operators and Compressed Shift
13
2. Hankel Operators and Compressed Shift We begin this section with the study of the commutant of compressions of the shift operator on H 2 to its coinvariant subspaces. We prove Sarason’s theorem that describes this commutant in terms of a functional calculus. We use an approach suggested by N.K. Nikol’skii that is based on Hankel operators and the Nehari theorem. Then we establish an important formula that relates functions of such a compression with Hankel operators. We also describe the kernel and the closed range of Hankel operators, the partially isometric Hankel operators, and the Hankel operators with closed ranges. Let ϑ be an inner function. Put Kϑ = H 2 ϑH 2 . By Beurling’s theorem (see Appendix 2.2) any nontrivial invariant subspace of the backward shift operator S ∗ on H 2 coincides with Kϑ for some inner function ϑ. Denote by S[ϑ] the compression of the shift operator S to Kϑ : S[ϑ] f = Pϑ zf,
f ∈ Kθ ,
(2.1)
where Pϑ is the orthogonal projection from H 2 onto Kϑ . It is easy to see that ∗ = S ∗ |Kϑ . S[ϑ]
Since multiplication by ϑ is a unitary operator on L2 , it follows that the orthogonal projection onto ϑH 2 is given by ¯ f → ϑP+ ϑf,
f ∈ L2 .
Therefore ¯ = ϑP− ϑf, ¯ Pϑ f = f − ϑP+ ϑf
f ∈ H 2.
(2.2)
Note that S[ϑ] is the so-called model operator in the Sz.-Nagy–Foias functional model. Any contraction T for which lim T ∗n = O in the strong n→∞ operator topology and rank(I − T ∗ T ) = rank(I − T T ∗ ) = 1 is unitarily equivalent to S[ϑ] for some inner function ϑ (see Sz.-Nagy and Foias [1] and N.K. Nikol’skii [2]). The operator S[ϑ] admits an H ∞ functional calculus. Indeed, given ϕ ∈ H ∞ , we define the operator ϕ(S[ϑ] ) by ϕ(S[ϑ] )f = Pϑ ϕf,
f ∈ Kϑ .
(2.3)
Clearly, this functional calculus is linear. Let us show that it is multiplicative. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ H ∞ . We have ((ϕψ)(S[ϑ] ))f = Pϑ ϕψf = Pϑ ϕPϑ ψf + Pϑ ϕ Qϑ ψf,
(2.4)
14
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
where Qϑ is the orthogonal projection from H 2 onto ϑH 2 . Since Qϑ ψH 2 ∈ ϑH 2 , it follows that ϕ Qϑ ψf ∈ ϑH 2 and so Pϑ ϕ Qϑ ψf = O. Therefore it follows from (2.4) that (ϕψ)(S[ϑ] ) = ϕ(S[ϑ] )ψ(S[ϑ] ). It follows from (2.4) that ϕ(S[ϑ] ) commutes with S[ϑ] , ϕ ∈ H ∞ , and ϕ(S[ϑ] ) ≤ ϕH ∞ (von Neumann’s inequality). The following theorem, which is due to Sarason, describes the commutant of S[ϑ] . It is a special case of the commutant lifting theorem due to Sz.-Nagy and Foias (see Appendix 1.5). Theorem 2.1. Let T be an operator that commutes with S[ϑ] . Then there exists a function ϕ in H ∞ such that T = ϕ(S[ϑ] ) and T = ϕH ∞ . To prove the theorem, we need a lemma that relates operators in the commutant of S[ϑ] with Hankel operators. Lemma 2.2. Let T be an operator on Kϑ . Consider the operator 2 A : H 2 → H− defined by Af = ϑ¯ T Pϑ f. (2.5) Then T commutes with S[ϑ] if and only if A is a Hankel operator. Proof. A is a Hankel operator if and only if P− zAf = Azf,
f ∈ H 2,
(see (1.13)), which means ¯ Pϑ f = ϑT ¯ Pϑ zf, P− z ϑT
f ∈ H 2,
which in turn is equivalent to ¯ Pϑ f = T Pϑ zf, ϑP− ϑzT
f ∈ H 2.
(2.6)
(2.7)
We have by (2.2) ¯ Pϑ f = Pϑ zT Pϑ f = S[ϑ] T Pϑ f. ϑP− ϑzT Since obviously the left-hand side and the right-hand side of (2.7) are zero for f ∈ ϑH 2 , it follows from (2.1) that (2.6) is equivalent to the equality S[ϑ] T f = T S[ϑ] f,
f ∈ Kϑ .
Proof of Theorem 2.1. By Lemma 2.2, the operator A defined by (2.5) is a Hankel operator. By the Nehari theorem, there exists a function ψ in L∞ such that ψ∞ = A and Hψ = A, i.e., P− ψf = ϑ¯ T Pϑ f, f ∈ H 2 . It follows that P− ψf = O for any f ∈ ϑH 2 . That means that Hψϑ = O. ¯ We have Put ϕ = ψϑ. Clearly, ϕ ∈ H ∞ and ψ = ϑϕ. ¯ f ∈ Kϑ , ϑ¯ T f = P− ϑϕf,
2. Hankel Operators and Compressed Shift
15
so ¯ = Pϑ ϕf = ϕ(S[ϑ] )f, T f = ϑ P− ϑϕf
f ∈ Kϑ .
(2.8)
Obviously, T = A = ψ∞ = ϕ∞ , which completes the proof. Remark. Formula (2.8) implies the following remarkable relation between Hankel operators and functions of model operators. Let ϑ be an inner function, ϕ ∈ H ∞ , then ϕ(S[ϑ] ) = Mϑ Hϑϕ ¯ |Kϑ ,
(2.9)
where Mϑ is multiplication by ϑ. This formula shows that ϕ(S[ϑ] ) has the same metric properties as Hϑϕ ¯ (e.g., compactness, nuclearity, etc.; we shall discuss that later). Formula (2.9) relates the Hankel operators of the form Hϑϕ ¯ with functions of model operators. The following theorem describes the Hankel operators of that form. Theorem 2.3. Let ψ ∈ L∞ . The following are equivalent: (i) Hψ has nontrivial kernel; 2 (ii) Range Hψ is not dense in H− ; ¯ (iii) ψ = ϑϕ for some inner function ϑ and some function ϕ in H ∞ . Proof. (i)⇒(iii). Suppose that Ker Hψ = {O} and Hψ = O. Then Ker Hψ is a nontrivial invariant subspace of the shift operator S (see Corollary 1.9). By Beurling’s theorem (see Appendix 2.2), Ker Hψ = ϑH 2 for some inner function ϑ. So P− ψϑf = O for any f in H 2 . Therefore Hψϑ = O ¯ and so ϕ = ψϑ ∈ H ∞ . Hence, ψ = ϑϕ. ¯ (iii)⇒(ii). For g = z¯ϑ we have ¯ ¯ = (f, z¯ϕ) z¯ϑ) ¯ =0 (Hϑϕ ¯ f, g) = (ϑϕf, for any f ∈ H 2 , and so g ⊥ Range Hψ . 2 ¯ , g ⊥ Range Hψ , and g = O. Then g = z¯h, (ii)⇒(i). Suppose that g ∈ H− 2 2 where h ∈ H . Then for f ∈ H we have ¯ = (f, ψ¯ ¯z h), ¯ 0 = (Hψ f, g) = (ψf, z¯h) ¯z h ¯ ∈ H 2 , i.e., ψh ∈ H 2 , which means that h ∈ Ker Hψ . and so ψ¯ − Let us now describe the kernel and the closure of the range of Hankel ∞ and ϑ is inner. Recall that two operators of the form Hϑϕ ¯ when ϕ ∈ H p H functions are called coprime if they have no common nonconstant inner divisors. Theorem 2.4. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ and let ϑ be an inner function such that ϕ and ϑ are coprime. Then 2 Ker Hϑϕ ¯ = ϑH
and
2 ¯ 2. clos Range Hϑϕ ¯ = H− ϑH −
16
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
2 Proof. Obviously, if f ∈ ϑH 2 , then Hϑϕ ¯ f = O. Suppose that f ∈ H 2 2 ¯ and Hϑϕ ¯ f = O. Then ϑϕf ∈ H , and so ϕf ∈ ϑH . Since ϕ and ϑ are coprime, it follows that f is divisible by ϑ, i.e., f ∈ ϑH 2 . 2 ¯ 2 . Let us It follows immediately from (2.9) that Range Hϑϕ ¯ ⊂ H− ϑH − 2 ¯ 2 . Suppose that h ∈ H 2 and show that Range Hϑϕ ¯ is dense in H− ϑH − − 2 h ⊥ Hϑϕ ¯ g for every g ∈ H . Then
¯ ¯ dm, g ∈ H 2 . gϕϑ¯h 0 = (P− ϑϕg, h) = (ϕg, ϑh) = T
1 2 Hence, ϕϑh ¯ ∈ H− . Since ϕ and ϑ are coprime, it follows that ϑh ∈ H− , 2 ¯ i.e., h ∈ ϑH− . The following result shows that the Hankel operators involved in (2.9) form a dense subset in the space of bounded Hankel operators. Theorem 2.5. The set ¯ : ϑ is inner, ϕ ∈ H ∞ } {ϑϕ
is dense in L∞ . Proof. Let E ⊂ T, 0 < mE < 1. Consider the function u in L∞ defined by
−1, ζ ∈ E, u(ζ) = 1, ζ ∈ E. u). Then fn ∈ H ∞ and |fn | is separated away Let fn = 1 + exp n(u + i˜ from zero on T. Indeed, |fn (ζ)| ≥ 1 − e−n for ζ ∈ E and |fn (ζ)| ≥ en − 1 for ζ ∈ E. So fn admits a factorization fn = ϑn hn , where ϑn is an inner function and hn is an outer function invertible in H ∞ . The result now follows from the obvious fact that fn−1 = ϑ¯n h−1 n converges uniformly to the characteristic function of E. Let us now describe the Hankel operators that are partial isometries. Recall that an operator V from a Hilbert space H to a Hilbert space K is called a partial isometry if the restriction of V to (Ker V )⊥ maps isometrically (Ker V )⊥ onto Range V . The subspace (Ker V )⊥ is called the initial space of the partial isometry V while the subspace Range V is called the final space of the partial isometry V . 2 is a partial isometry Theorem 2.6. A Hankel operator from H 2 to H− if and only if it has the form Hϑ¯ for an inner function ϑ. The initial space 2 ¯ 2. ϑH of Hϑ¯ is Kϑ while the final space of Hϑ¯ is H− − Proof. Let us first show that Hϑ¯ is a partial isometry. If f ∈ ϑH 2 , then ¯ ∈ H 2 , and obviously, Hϑ¯f = O. On the other hand, if f ⊥ ϑH 2 , then ϑf − so Hϑ¯f 2 = f 2 . It remains to observe that ¯ 2 H 2 = H 2 ϑH ¯ 2. H ¯(H 2 ϑH 2 ) = ϑH ϑ
−
−
Consider now an arbitrary partially isometric Hankel operator. Since obviously, Hψ z n → 0 for any ψ ∈ L∞ , a Hankel operator cannot be an isometry. Thus a partially isometric Hankel operator must have nontrivial
2. Hankel Operators and Compressed Shift
17
kernel. By Theorem 2.3, it has the form Hϑϕ ¯ , where ϑ is an inner function and ϕ ∈ H ∞ . Since Hϑϕ ¯ ≤ 1, we may assume that ϕ∞ ≤ 1. We may 2 also assume that ϑ and ϕ are coprime. By Theorem 2.4, Ker Hϑϕ ¯ = ϑH . Since Hϑϕ ¯ is a partial isometry, it follows that multiplication by ϕ is an isometric map of Kϑ into itself. In particular, if f ∈ Kϑ , we have
2 |ϕf | dm = |f |2 dm. T
T
Since |f | > 0 almost everywhere on T, it follows that |ϕ| = 1 almost everywhere, i.e., ϕ is an inner function. Let us show that ϕ is constant. Suppose that f is a nonzero function in Kϑ . Then ϕn f ∈ Kϑ for any n ∈ Z+ , i.e., ¯ g) = 0 (ϕn f, ϑg) = (ϕn ϑf, ¯ ∈ H 2 , and so ϕ¯n ϑ¯ z f¯ ∈ H 2 , n ∈ Z+ . Put for any g ∈ H 2 . Hence, ϕn ϑf − 2 n 2 ¯ h = ϑ¯ z f ∈ H . Then ϕ¯ h ∈ H for any n ∈ Z+ , i.e., h is divisible by ϕn , which is impossible unless ϕ is constant. This completes the proof. We conclude this section with a description of the Hankel operators with closed ranges. First we determine when functions of model operators S[ϑ] are invertible. We say that H ∞ functions g1 and g2 satisfy the corona condition if there exists δ > 0 such that |g1 (ζ)| + |g2 (ζ)| ≥ δ,
ζ ∈ D.
By the Carleson corona theorem (see Appendix 2.1), g1 and g2 satisfy the corona condition if and only if there exist functions ψ1 and ψ2 in H ∞ such that ψ1 (ζ)g1 (ζ) + ψ2 (ζ)g2 (ζ) = 1, ζ ∈ D. Theorem 2.7. Let ϑ be an inner function and let ϕ ∈ H ∞ . The operator ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is invertible if and only if ϕ and ϑ satisfy the corona condition. Proof. Suppose that ϕ and ϑ satisfy the corona condition, and u and v are functions in H ∞ such that ϕu + ϑv = 1. Then ϕ(S[ϑ] )u(S[ϑ] ) + ϑ(S[ϑ] )v(S[ϑ] ) = I, and since obviously, ϑ(S[ϑ] ) = O, it follows that ϕ(S[ϑ] )u(S[ϑ] ) = u(S[ϑ] )ϕ(S[ϑ] ) = I, i.e., ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is invertible. Assume now that ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is invertible, and ϕ and ϑ do not satisfy the corona condition. Then there exists a sequence {ζn }n≥0 of points in D such that lim (|ϕ(ζn )| + |ϑ(ζn )|) = 0. n→∞
Define the H ∞ functions ϕn and ϑn by ϕ − ϕ(ζn ) = bn ϕn
and ϑ − ϑ(ζn ) = bn ϑn ,
18
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
where the elementary Blaschke factor bn is defined by def bn (z) = (z − ζn )(1 − ζ¯n z)−1 .
Consider the normalized reproducing kernels kn defined by kn (z) = (1 − |ζn |2 )1/2 (1 − ζ¯n z)−1 def
(see §6 for more details). Clearly, kn 2 = 1. Finally, we define the functions fn in Kϑ by fn = Pϑ kn ϑn . Let us show that lim inf fn 2 > 0, n→∞
while
lim ϕ(S[ϑ] )fn 2 = 0,
n→∞
which will complete the proof. We have ¯ n ϑn = (ϑ − ϑ(ζ ))k ϑ fn 2 = P− ϑk P − n n n 2 = P−¯bn ϑ¯n kn ϑn 2 = P−¯bn |ϑn |2 kn 2 ≥ P−¯bn kn 2 − P−¯bn (|ϑn |2 − 1)kn 2 .
2
It is easy to see that P−¯bn kn = (1 − |ζn |2 )1/2 P−
1 1 = (1 − |ζn |2 )1/2 , z − ζn z − ζn
and so P−¯bn kn 2 = 1. On the other hand, P−¯bn (|ϑn |2 − 1)kn ≤ (|ϑn |2 − 1)kn = (|ϑ − ϑ(ζn )|2 − 1)kn 2 2 2 ≤ |ϑ − ϑ(ζn )|2 − 1∞ ≤ 3|ϑ(ζn )| → 0, n → ∞, and so the norms of fn are separated away from 0. Finally, we have ¯ ¯ ¯ ϕ(S[ϑ] )fn = P− ϑϕϑP − ϑkn ϑn 2 = P− ϕϑkn ϑn 2 2 = P− (ϑ − ϑ(ζn ))ϕkn ϑn + ϑ(ζn )ϕϑn
2
= P− (ϑ − ϑ(ζn ))ϕkn ϑn = P−¯bn ϕkn |ϑn |2 2 2
≤ P−¯bn ϕkn 2 + P−¯bn ϕkn (|ϑn |2 − 1)2 . Since lim |ϑn |2 − 1∞ = 0, it follows that n→∞
lim P−¯bn ϕkn (|ϑn |2 − 1)2 = 0.
n→∞
3. Hankel Operators of Finite Rank
19
On the other hand, P−¯bn ϕkn ≤ P−¯bn (ϕ − ϕ(ζn ))kn + |ϕ(ζn )| · P−¯bn kn 2 2 2 = P−¯bn ϕn bn kn 2 + |ϕ(ζn )| · ¯bn kn 2 = |ϕ(ζn )| → 0
as
n → ∞.
This completes the proof. Now we are in a position to obtain a description of the Hankel operators with closed ranges. 2 Theorem 2.8. A Hankel operator Hψ has closed range in H− if and ∞ ¯ only if ψ = ϑϕ, where ϕ ∈ H , ϑ is an inner function such that ϕ and ϑ satisfy the corona condition. 2 Proof. Since Hψ z n 2 → 0 as n → ∞, Range Hψ = H− . Thus by ¯ where ϑ is inner and ϕ ∈ H ∞ . Theorem 2.3, we may assume that ψ = ϑϕ, We may also assume that ϑ and ϕ are coprime. By Theorem 2.7, it remains to prove that ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is invertible if and only 2 if Hϑϕ ¯ has closed range in H− . If ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is invertible, it follows immediately from (2.9) that Hϑϕ ¯ has closed range. Suppose now that Hϑϕ ¯ has closed range. By Theorem 2.4, Hϑϕ ¯ is a 2 2 ¯ one-to-one map of Kϑ onto H− ϑH− . Clearly, multiplication by ϑ maps 2 ¯ 2 onto Kϑ . It follows now from (2.9) that ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is invertible. H− ϑH −
3. Hankel Operators of Finite Rank One of the first results about Hankel matrices was a theorem of Kronecker that describes the Hankel matrices of finite rank. Let r = p/q be a rational function where p and q are polynomials. If p/q is in its lowest terms, the degree of r is, by definition, deg r = max{deg p, deg q}, where deg p and deg q are the degrees of the polynomials p and q. It is easy to see that deg r is the sum of the multiplicities of the poles of r (including a possible pole at infinity). We are going to describe the Hankel matrices of finite rank without any assumption on the boundedness of the matrix. We identify sequences of complex numbers with the corresponding formal power series. If a = {aj }j≥0 is a sequence of complex numbers, we associate with it the formal power series a(z) = aj z j . j≥0
20
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
The space of formal power series forms an algebra with respect to the following multiplication: m (ab)(z) = aj bm−j z m , a = aj z j , b = bj z j . j=0
m≥0
j≥0
It is easy to see that a(z) =
j≥0
aj z j is invertible in the space of formal
j≥0
power series if and only if a0 = 0. Consider the shift operator S and the backward shift operator S ∗ defined on the space of formal power series in the following way: aj z j = aj+1 z j . (Sa)(z) = za(z), S ∗ j≥0
j≥0
Let α = {αj }j≥0 be a sequence of complex numbers that we identify with the corresponding formal power series: α(z) = αj z j . (3.1) j≥0
Theorem 3.1. Let Γα be a Hankel matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 . Then Γ has finite rank if and only if the power series (3.1) determines a rational function. In this case rank Γα = deg zα(z). Proof. Suppose that rank Γα = n. Then the first n + 1 rows are linearly dependent. That means that there exists a nontrivial family {cj }0≤j≤n of complex numbers (i.e., not all the cj are equal to zero) such that c0 α + c1 S ∗ α + · · · + cn S ∗n α = O.
(3.2)
It is easy to see that S n S ∗k α = S n−k α − S n−k
k−1
αj z j ,
k ≤ n.
(3.3)
j=0
It follows easily from (3.2) and (3.3) that O = Sn
n
ck S ∗k α =
k=0
n
ck S n S ∗k α =
k=0
n k=0
ck S n−k α − p, (3.4)
where p has the form p(z) =
n−1
pj z j .
j=0
Put q(z) =
n j=0
cn−j z j .
(3.5)
3. Hankel Operators of Finite Rank
21
Then p and q are polynomials, and it follows from (3.4) that qα = p. Note that cn = 0, since otherwise the rank of Γ would be less than n. Thus we can divide by q within the space of formal power series. Hence, α(z) = (p/q)(z) is a rational function. Clearly, deg zα(z) ≤ max (deg zp(z), deg q(z)) = n. Conversely, suppose that α(z) = (p/q)(z), where p and q are polynomials such that deg p ≤ n − 1 and deg q ≤ n. Consider the complex numbers cj defined by (3.5). We have n cj S n−j α = p. j=0
Therefore (S ∗ )n
n
cj S n−j α =
j=0
n
cj (S ∗ )j α = O,
j=0
which means that the first n + 1 rows of Γ are linearly dependent. Let m ≤ n be the largest number for which cm = 0. Then (S ∗ )m α is a linear combination of the (S ∗ )j α with j ≤ m − 1: (S ∗ )m α =
m−1
dj (S ∗ )j α,
dj ∈ C.
j=0
Let us show by induction that any row of Γ is a linear combination of the first m rows. Let k > m. We have m−1 dj (S ∗ )k−m+j α. (3.6) (S ∗ )k α = (S ∗ )k−m (S ∗ )m α = j=0
Since k − m + j < k for 0 ≤ j ≤ m − 1, by the inductive hypothesis each of the terms on the right-hand side of (3.6) is a linear combination of the first m rows. Therefore rank Γ ≤ m which completes the proof. Let us reformulate Kronecker’s theorem for Hankel operators Hϕ on H 2 . Corollary 3.2. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . The Hankel operator Hϕ has finite rank if and only if P− ϕ is a rational function. In this case rank Hϕ = deg P− ϕ.
(3.7)
It is easy to derive this result from Theorem 3.1. However, here we give a different proof, which is also instructive. Another proof. As we have already noticed, Ker Hϕ is an invariant subspace of the shift operator (Corollary 1.9). By Beurling’s theorem, Ker Hϕ = ϑH 2 , where ϑ is an inner function. Clearly, Hϕ has finite rank if and only if dim(H 2 ϑH 2 ) < ∞ and the latter coincides with rank Hϕ . So rank Hϕ < ∞ if and only if ϑ is a finite Blaschke product, and rank Hϕ = deg ϑ (see Appendix 2.2). It follows that rank Hϕ < ∞ if and only if Hϑϕ = O, i.e., ϑϕ ∈ H ∞ for a finite Blaschke product ϑ.
22
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
It is easy to see that P− ϕ is a rational function of degree n if and only if there exists a Blaschke product ϑ of degree n such that ϑϕ ∈ H ∞ (the zeros of the Blaschke product are the poles of P− ϕ counted with multiplicities). This proves that rank Hϕ < ∞ if and only if P− ϕ is a rational function and that (3.7) holds. Corollary 3.3. Hϕ has finite rank if and only if there exists a finite Blaschke product B such that Bϕ ∈ H ∞ . Note, however, that the first proof of Kronecker’s theorem is universal; it works for any Hankel matrices without any additional assumption, while the second proof assumes that the Hankel operator is bounded on H 2 . Remark. Let Hϕ be a finite rank operator. In this case Hϕ f can be computed explicitly. Indeed, P− ϕ is a rational function. Consider first the case when 1 (P− ϕ)(z) = , λ ∈ D. z−λ We have f (λ) f (λ) f − f (λ) f = P− + = , f ∈ H 2. Hϕ f = P− z−λ z−λ z−λ z−λ (3.8) If (P− ϕ)(z) =
1 , (z − λ)k
λ ∈ D, k ≥ 1,
then f P− (z − λ)k
= P− +
=
f − f (λ) − f (λ)(z − λ) − · · · −
f (k−1) (λ) (k−1)! (z
− λ)k−1
(z − λ)k
k−1
k−1
1 f (j) (λ) 1 f (j) (λ) = k−j j! (z − λ) j! (z − λ)k−j j=0 j=0 k−1 f (ζ) ∂ z−ζ 1 (z, λ), f ∈ H 2 . (k − 1)! ∂ζ k−1
Therefore in the general case (P− ϕ)(z) =
mj n j=1 k=1
we obtain (Hϕ f )(z) =
mj n j=1 k=1
cjk (k − 1)!
∂ k−1
cjk (z − λj )k
f (ζ) z−ζ
∂ζ k−1
(z, λj ),
f ∈ H 2.
4. Interpolation Problems
23
4. Interpolation Problems We consider here certain classical interpolation problems and discuss their connections with Hankel operators.
Nevanlinna–Pick Interpolation Problem Let ζj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, be distinct points in the unit disc and let wj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, be complex numbers such that |wj | < 1, 1 ≤ j ≤ n. The problem is to find out under which conditions there exists a function f in H ∞ such that 1 ≤ j ≤ n;
f (ζj ) = wj ,
f H ∞ ≤ 1.
(4.1)
If the problem (4.1) has a solution, then we can ask a question how to describe all solutions of the problem (4.1) and find a solution of minimal norm. We are going to reduce the problem (4.1) to a problem about Hankel operators. Let g be an arbitrary function in H ∞ for which g(ζj ) = wj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n. Such a function can easily be constructed. For example, we can put g=
n j=1
wj Bj , Bj (ζj )
where B is the Blaschke product with zeros ζj , B=
n
bj ,
bj (z) =
j=1
z − ζj , 1 − ζ¯j z
and
B . bj Then a function f in H ∞ interpolates the values wj at ζj if and only if f has the form f = g − Bh, h ∈ H ∞ . Hence the problem (4.1) is solvable if and only if ¯ − h∞ : h ∈ H ∞ } = HBg inf{g − Bh∞ : h ∈ H ∞ } = inf{Bg ¯ ≤1 Bj =
by the Nehari theorem. Later (see §7.1) we shall discuss properties of the solution of minimal norm (it is unique since HBh ¯ has finite rank (see Corollaries 1.6 and 3.3)). We shall also describe the set of solutions in the case it contains at least two different ones (see §5.2). Let us reformulate the condition HBg ¯ ≤ 1 in terms of the interpolation data. Theorem 4.1. The interpolation problem (4.1) is solvable if and only if the matrix
1−w ¯j wk 1 − ζ¯j ζk 1≤j,k≤n
24
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
is positive semi-definite. 2 Proof. It is easy to see that HBg ¯ BH = O, so HBg ¯ = HBg ¯ KB . Consider the following basis in the (n-dimensional space KB (see §2)): fj (z) =
B(z) , z − ζj
1 ≤ j ≤ n.
Clearly, HBg ¯ ≤ 1 if and only if ∗ HBg ¯ ≤ I. ¯ HBg
(4.2)
Inequality (4.2) means that for any complex numbers cj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, n
cj c¯k (HBg ¯ fj , HBg ¯ fk ) ≤
j,k=1
n
cj c¯k (fj , fk ).
(4.3)
j,k=1
We have HBg ¯ fj = P−
g g(ζj ) wj = = z − ζj z − ζj z − ζj
(see (3.8)). Therefore
¯k (HBg ¯ fj , HBg ¯ fk ) = wj w Clearly, (fj , fk ) =
B B , z − ζj z − ζk
1 1 , z − ζj z − ζk
=
¯k = wj w
1 1 , z − ζj z − ζk
=
1 . 1 − ζ¯k ζj 1 . 1 − ζ¯k ζj
Thus (4.3) is equivalent to the following inequality: n j,k=1
cj c¯k
1 − wj w ¯k ≥0 1 − ζj ζ¯k
for any complex numbers cj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n. This completes the proof. In a similar way one could consider Nevanlinna–Pick problem with an infinite data set. Indeed, we can reduce the case of infinitely many interpolating points to the case of finitely many points by considering a limit process. It is also possible to consider multiple interpolation problem where not only the values of f at the ζj are prescribed but also its derivatives up to certain orders. We shall consider here a very special case of multiple interpolation problem.
Carath´ eodory–Fej´ er Interpolation Problem Let c0 , c1 , · · · , cn be complex numbers. The problem is to determine whether there exists a function f in H ∞ such that fˆ(j) = cj ,
0 ≤ j ≤ n;
f H ∞ ≤ 1.
(4.4)
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators
Let g =
n
25
cj z j . Clearly, a function f in H ∞ satisfies fˆ(j) = cj , 0 ≤ j ≤ n,
j=0
if and only if f = g + z n+1 h, h ∈ H ∞ . So (4.4) is solvable if and only if inf{g + z n+1 h∞ : h ∈ H ∞ } = Hz¯n+1 g ≤ 1. Theorem 4.2. The interpolation problem (4.4) is solvable if and only if the operator norm of the (n + 1) × (n + 1) matrix cn−1 . . . c0 cn cn−1 cn−2 . . . 0 .. .. .. . . . . . . 0 ... 0 c0 is less than or equal to one. Proof. This is an immediate consequence of the Nehari theorem.
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators In this section we shall establish the compactness criterion for Hankel operators which is due to Hartman. Moreover we shall compute the essential norm of a Hankel operator and study the problem of approximation of a Hankel operator by compact Hankel operators. We shall also establish some useful properties of the algebra H ∞ + C and compute the norm of the Hilbert matrix.
The Essential Norm We begin with the computation of the essential norm for a Hankel operator. Recall that the essential norm T e of an operator T from a Hilbert space H1 to a Hilbert space H2 is, by definition, T e = inf{T − K : K is compact}.
(5.1)
To compute the essential norm of a Hankel operator, we have to introduce the space H ∞ + C. Definition. The space H ∞ + C is the set of functions ϕ in L∞ such that ϕ admits a representation ϕ = f + g, where f ∈ H ∞ and g ∈ C(T). Theorem 5.1. The set H ∞ + C is a closed subalgebra of L∞ . To prove the theorem, we need the following elementary lemma, where as usual CA = H ∞ ∩ C(T); see Appendix 2.1. Lemma 5.2. Let ϕ ∈ C(T). Then distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ ) = distL∞ (ϕ, CA ).
(5.2)
26
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Proof. The inequality dist(ϕ, H ∞ ) ≤ distL∞ (ϕ, CA ) is trivial. Let us prove the opposite one. For f ∈ L∞ we consider its harmonic extension to the unit disk and keep the same notation for it. Put fr (ζ) = f (rζ), ζ ∈ D. Let ϕ ∈ C(T), h ∈ H ∞ . We have ϕ − h∞
≥ =
lim (ϕ − h)r ∞ ≥ lim (ϕ − hr ∞ − ϕ − ϕr ∞ )
r→1
r→1
lim ϕ − hr ∞ ≥ distL∞ (ϕ, CA ),
r→1
since ϕ − ϕr ∞ → 0 for continuous ϕ. Proof of Theorem 5.1. Equality (5.2) means exactly that the natural imbedding of C(T)/CA in L∞ /H ∞ is isometric and so C(T)/CA can be considered as a closed subspace of L∞ /H ∞ . Let ρ : L∞ → L∞ /H ∞ be the natural quotient map. It follows that H ∞ + C = ρ−1 (C(T)/CA ) is closed in L∞ . This implies that H ∞ + C = closL∞ (5.3) z¯n H ∞ . n≥0
It is easy to see that if f and g belong to the right-hand side of (5.3), then so is f g. Hence, H ∞ + C is an algebra. Now we are going to compute the essential norm of a Hankel operator. Theorem 5.3. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then Hϕ e = distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C). 2 Lemma 5.4. Let K be a compact operator from H 2 to H− . Then
lim KS n = 0.
n→∞
Proof of Lemma 5.4. Since any compact operator can be approximated by finite rank operators, it is sufficient to prove the assertion for rank 2 . We have one operators K. Let Kf = (f, ξ)η, ξ ∈ H 2 , η ∈ H− KS n f = (f, S ∗n ξ)η and so KS n = S ∗n ξ2 η2 → 0. Proof of Theorem 5.3. By Corollary 3.2, Hf is compact for any trigonometric polynomial f . Therefore Hf is compact for any f in C(T). Consequently, distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) =
inf Hϕ − Hf ≥ Hϕ e .
f ∈C(T)
2 On the other hand, for any compact operator K from H 2 to H− we have
Hϕ − K
≥ (Hϕ − K)S n ≥ Hϕ S n − KS n = Hzn ϕ − KS n = distL∞ (ϕ, z¯n H ∞ ) − KS n ≥ distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) − KS n .
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators
27
Therefore in view of Lemma 5.4, Hϕ e ≥ distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C).
Compactness Criterion Now we can easily obtain the Hartman compactness criterion. Theorem 5.5. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . The following statements are equivalent: (i) Hϕ is compact; (ii) ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C; (iii) there exists a function ψ in C(T) such that Hϕ = Hψ . Proof. Obviously, (ii)⇔(iii). Suppose that ϕ ∈ H ∞ +C. Then Hϕ e = 0 by Theorem 5.3, which means that Hϕ is compact. Thus (ii)⇒(i). Let us show that (i)⇒(ii). If Hϕ is compact, then by Theorem 5.3, distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) = 0, which together with Theorem 5.5 yields ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Corollary 5.6. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then Hϕ e = inf{Hϕ − Hψ : Hψ is compact}.
(5.4)
In other words, to compute the essential norm of a Hankel operator we can consider on the right-hand side of (5.1) only compact Hankel operators. Corollary 5.7. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Then for any ε > 0 there exists a function ψ in C(T) such that Hψ = Hϕ and ψ∞ ≤ Hϕ + ε. Proof. Without loss of generality we can assume that ϕ ∈ C(T). By Theorem 5.3, Hϕ = distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ ). On the other hand, by Lemma 5.2, distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ ) = distL∞ (ϕ, CA ). This means that for any ε > 0 there exists a function h ∈ CA such that ϕ − h ≤ Hϕ + ε. Thus ψ = ϕ − h does the job. Remark. However, it is not always possible for a compact Hankel operator to find a continuous symbol whose L∞ -norm is equal to the norm of the operator. Indeed, let α be a real-valued function in C(T) such that a ˜ ∈ C(T), where α ˜ is the harmonic conjugate of α. Put ϕ = z¯eiα˜ . Then α+iα ˜ −α ϕ = z¯e e . Clearly, eα+iα˜ ∈ H ∞ and e−α ∈ C(T). It follows from Theorem 5.1 that ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C and so Hϕ is compact. Let us show that Hϕ = 1. Put 1 h = exp (−α − i˜ α). 2 ¯ 2 = h2 . Hence, Hϕ = ϕ∞ = 1. By z h Then h ∈ H 2 and Hϕ h2 = ¯ Corollary 1.6, ϕ + f ∞ > 1 for any nonzero f in H ∞ . It is also clear that ϕ ∈ C(T). This proves the result. In §1 we have given a boundedness criterion for a Hankel operator Hϕ in terms of P− ϕ. That criterion involves the condition P− ϕ ∈ BM O. We can give a similar compactness criterion if we replace BM O by the space V M O of functions of vanishing mean oscillation (see Appendix 2.5).
28
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Theorem 5.8. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . Then Hϕ is compact if and only if P− ϕ ∈ V M O. The result can be derived from Theorem 5.5 in the same way as it has been done in Theorem 1.2 if we use the following description of V M O: V M O = {ξ + η˜ : ξ, η ∈ C(T)} (see Appendix 2.5). Theorem 5.8 allows us to obtain a compactness criterion for the commutators Cϕ defined in §1 (see (1.15)). The following theorem can be deduced from Theorem 5.8 in exactly the same way as Theorem 1.10 has been deduced in §1 from Theorem 1.3. Theorem 5.9. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . The commutator Cϕ is a compact operator on L2 if and only if ϕ ∈ V M O. The Hartman theorem also allows us to obtain a compactness criterion for functions ϕ(S[ϑ] ) of the model operator S[ϑ] (see §2). Theorem 5.10. Let ϑ be an inner function and S[ϑ] the compressed shift on Kϑ . If ϕ ∈ H ∞ , then the following statements are equivalent: (i) ϕ(S[ϑ] ) is compact; ¯ ∈ H ∞ + C; (ii) ϑϕ ¯ ∈ V M O. (iii) P− ϑϕ The result follows directly from Theorems 5.5 and 5.8, and from formula (2.9). Consider now the partial case of this situation when ϑ = B is an interpolating Blaschke product (see Appendix 2.1). In this case KB has an unconditional basis that consists of eigenvectors of S[B] . Namely, let fj (z) = (1 − |ζj |2 )1/2
B , z − ζj
(5.5)
where the ζj , j ≥ 1, are the zeros of B. Then it is easy to see that S[B] fj = ζj fj and ϕ(S[B] )fj = ϕ(ζj )fj for any ϕ ∈ H ∞ . Since {fj }j≥1 is an unconditional basis, there is an invertible operator V on Kϑ such that {V fj }j≥1 is an orthogonal basis of Kϑ (see N.K. Nikol’skii [2], Lect. VI, §3). Therefore ϕ(S[B] ) is compact if and only if ϕ(ζj ) → 0 as j → ∞. This together with Theorem 5.10 implies the following assertion. Theorem 5.11. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ and let B be an interpolating Blaschke product with zeros {ζj }j≥1 . The following statements are equivalent: (i) ϕ(S[B] ) is compact; ¯ ∈ H ∞ + C; (ii) Bϕ ¯ ∈ V M O; (iii) P− Bϕ (iv) ϕ(ζj ) → 0 as j → ∞. The above facts about the bases of eigenvectors of S[B] can be found in N.K.Nikol’skii [2], Lect. III, §7.
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators
29
Approximation by Compact Hankel Operators In connection with (5.4) a natural question arises of whether the infimum in (5.4) is attained. This is equivalent to the existence of a best approximation from H ∞ + C for any bounded function. This question turns out to be more difficult than in the case of best approximation from H ∞ since the compactness argument does not work here. Another question arising in this connection is whether such a best approximation is unique (if it exists). The following theorem answers these questions. Theorem 5.12. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ \ (H ∞ + C). Then there exist infinitely many different functions f in H ∞ + C such that ϕ − f ∞ = distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C). By Theorems 1.3 and 5.5, Theorem 5.12 is a consequence of the following theorem. Theorem 5.13. Let Γ be a noncompact Hankel operator on H 2 . Then there exist infinitely many different compact Hankel operators Υ such that Γ − Υ = Γe . We establish a more general result. First we need the following lemma. Lemma 5.14. Let H1 and H2 be Hilbert spaces and T : H1 → H2 a bounded operator. If {An }n≥1 is a sequence of operators from H1 to H2 such that An → O and A∗n → O in the strong operator topology, then for any ε > 0 there exists a positive integer N such that T + AN ≤ ε + max(T , T e + AN ). Proof of Lemma 5.14. Clearly, without loss of generality we can assume that H1 = H2 = H. Put ρn = max(T , T e + An ). Suppose that for any n there exists xn ∈ H, xn = 1, such that (T + An )xn > ε + ρn .
(5.6)
By passing to a subsequence, if needed, we may assume that xn → x ∈ H in the weak topology. Let yn = xn − x. Then (T + An )xn = T x + T yn + An yn + An x.
(5.7)
Let Kn be a sequence of finite-dimensional subspaces of H such that Kn ⊂ Kn+1 and Kn is dense in H. Denote by Pn the orthogonal projecn≥1
tion onto Kn and by Qn the orthogonal projection onto Kn⊥ . Then Qn → O in the strong operator topology. Therefore for any compact operator K on H we have Qn K → 0. Since T − K ≥ Qn (T − K) ≥ Qn T − Qn K,
30
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
it follows that Qn T → T e . Let δ be a positive number that we specify later. Fix a positive integer M such that QM T x < δ, QM x < δ, and QM T < T e + δ. Since T yn → 0 weakly, it follows that QM T yn < δ for large n. Since PM is compact and A∗n → O in the strong operator topology, it follows that PM An → 0 and so PM An yn < δ for large n. We have from (5.7) (T +An )xn = PM T x+QM (T yn +An yn )+An x+QM T x+PM (T yn +An yn ). Since An → O in the strong operator topology, we have An x < δ for large n. Thus for large n (T + An )xn ≤ PM T x + QM (T yn + An yn ) + 4δ.
(5.8)
Since PM T x is orthogonal to QM (T yn + An yn ), we obtain PM T x + QM (T yn + An yn )2
= PM T x2 + QM (T yn + An yn )2 ≤
T 2 x2 + (QM T + An )2 yn 2
≤ ρ2n x2 + (T e + δ + An )2 yn 2 ≤ (ρn + δ)2 (x2 + yn 2 ). It follows from the fact that yn → 0 weakly that PM yn < δ for large n. Hence, x2 + yn 2
= PM x2 + QM x2 + PM yn 2 + QM yn 2 ≤
PM x2 + QM yn 2 + 2δ 2 = PM x + QM yn 2 + 2δ 2
= x − QM x + yn − PM yn 2 + 2δ 2 2
≤ (xn + QM x + PM yn ) + 2δ 2 ≤ (1 + 2δ)2 + 2δ 2 . Thus we have
PM T x + QM (T yn + An yn )2 ≤ (ρn + δ)2 (1 + 2δ)2 + 2δ 2 .
This together with (5.8) yields 1/2 + 4δ (T + An )xn ≤ (ρn + δ) (1 + 2δ)2 + 2δ 2 for large n. Now we can choose δ so small that the right-hand side of the last inequality is less than ρn + ε, which contradicts (5.6). Corollary 5.15. Under the hypotheses of Lemma 5.14, for any ε > 0 there exists a positive integer N such that T + βAN ≤ ε + max(T , T e + βAN ) for any β ∈ [0, 1].
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators
31
Proof. Suppose that for any n there exists βn ∈ [0, 1] such that T + βn An > ε + max(T , T e + βAn ). But βn An → O, (βn An )∗ → O in the strong operator topology, which contradicts Lemma 5.14. Theorem 5.16. Let H1 and H2 be Hilbert spaces, T : H1 → H2 a noncompact bounded operator. Let {Tn }n≥1 be a sequence of compact operators from H1 to H2 such that Tn → T and Tn∗ → T ∗ in the strong operator topology. Then there exist sequences {an }n≥1 and {bn }n≥1 of nonnegative real numbers such that an = bn = 1 n≥1
n≥1
and
where K1 =
T − K1 = T − K2 = T e , an Tn and K2 = bn Tn . Moreover, K1 = K2 .
n≥1
(5.9)
n≥1
Proof. Let us first find {an }n≥1 . Let An = T − Tn . Clearly, lim An = n→∞ lim A∗n = O in the strong operator topology.
n→∞
Let us show that there exist an increasing sequence {nk }k≥1 of positive integers and a sequence {αk }k≥1 of positive real numbers such that ∞
αk = 1,
(5.10)
k=1
m αk Ank = T e − εm ,
(5.11)
k=1
for any m ≥ 1, where εm = 3−m T e . We proceed by induction. Put n1 = 1 and choose α1 > 0 so that α1 A1 = T e − ε1 . Clearly, α1 < 1. Suppose that we have chosen m αk < 1 and (5.11) holds. We n1 , · · · , nm and α1 , · · · , αm such that k=1
can choose nm+1 > nm such that
R + βAnm+1 ≤ εm+1 + max R, Re + βAnm+1 , (5.12)
for any β in [0,1], where R =
m k=1
αk Ank . This is clearly possible by Corol-
lary 5.15. Consider µ(α) = R + αAnm ,
α ≥ 0.
32
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
m Clearly, µ(α) → ∞ as α → ∞ and µ(0) = αk Ank = T e − εm k=1 by the inductive hypothesis. Therefore there exists αm+1 > 0 such that µ(αm+1 ) = T e − εm+1 . m+1 αk < 1. We have Let us show that k=1
T e −εm+1
m+1 m+1 m+1 = µ(αm+1 ) = αk T − αk Tnk ≥ αk T e , k=1
so
m+1
k=1
k=1
αk < 1.
k=1
Put β = αm+1 in (5.12). Suppose that the first term under the maximum on the right-hand side of (5.12) is greater than the second. Then m+1 m αk Ank ≤ εm+1 + αk Ank . k=1
k=1
Therefore by (5.11) T e − εm+1 ≤ εm+1 + T e − εm , which implies εm ≤ 2εm+1 , which contradicts the definition of εm . Consequently, (5.12) with β = αm+1 turns into m+1 m αk Ank ≤ εm+1 + αk Ank + αm+1 Anm+1 k=1 k=1 m e αk T e + αm+1 Anm+1 . (5.13) = εm+1 + k=1
Let m → ∞, it follows from (5.11) and (5.13) that ∞ ∞ T e = αk Ank ≤ αk T e , k=1
k=1
which implies ∞
αk ≥ 1,
k=1
and since we have already proved that
m
αk < 1, the sequences {αk } and
k=1
{nk } satisfy (5.11) and (5.13). We can define the sequence {an }n≥1 in the following way: ank = αk and an = 0 if n does not coincide with any nk . We have K1 =
∞ n=1
an Tn =
∞ k=1
αk Tnk = T −
∞ k=1
αk Ank ,
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators
33
∞ T − K1 = αk Ank = T e . k=1
It remains to construct {bn }n≥1 . Let T˜ = T − K1 , T˜n = Tn − K1 . Then ˜ Tn → T˜ and T˜n∗ → T˜∗ in the strong operator topology. Let O be a convex neighborhood of T˜ in the strong operator topology whose closure does not contain O. Since T˜n → T˜ strongly, we can assume that T˜n ∈ O for all n. As we have just proved, there exists a sequence {bn }n≥1 of nonnegative ∞ bn = 1 and numbers such that n=1
˜ = T˜e = T e , T˜ − K ∞ ∞ ∞ ˜ ˜ = bn Tn ˜ bn Tn = bn Tn − K1 . Thus K2 = K1 + K where K = n=1
n=1
n=1
˜ is an infinite convex combination of the T˜n , we have satisfies (5.9). Since K ˜ ˜ K ⊂ O. Thus K = O and K1 = K2 . Now we are in a position to deduce Theorem 5.13 from Theorem 5.16. Proof of Theorem 5.13. Let Γ = Hϕ . Let ϕn = ϕ ∗ Kn be the C´esaro means of the partial sums of the Fourier series of ϕ (see Appendix 2.1). Then Hϕn is compact. Let us show that Hϕn → Hϕ in the strong operator topology. Let f ∈ H 2 . We have (Hϕ − Hϕn )f 22
= P− (ϕ − ϕn )f 2 ≤ (ϕ − ϕn )f 22
= |ϕ(ζ) − ϕn (ζ)|2 |f (ζ)|2 dm(ζ) → 0, T
since ϕn ∞ ≤ ϕ∞ and ϕn (ζ) → ϕ(ζ) a.e. on T (see Appendix 2.1). 2 Using the fact that Hϕ∗ n g = P+ ϕg, ¯ g ∈ H− , one can prove in the same way ∗ ∗ that Hϕn → Hϕ strongly. It follows from Theorem 5.16 that there are distinct compact Hankel operators Υ0 and Υ1 (infinite convex combinations of Hϕn ) such that Γ − Υ0 = Γ − Υ1 = Γe . It remains to observe that if Υ1 and Υ2 are best compact Hankel approximations to Γ, then so is Υs = (1 − s)Υ0 + sΥ1 with s ∈ [0, 1].
The Local Distance Let f and g be functions in L∞ , λ ∈ T. The local distance distλ (f, g) between f and g at λ is by definition distλ (f, g) = lim (f − g) |{ζ ∈ T : |ζ − λ| < ε} ∞ . ε→0
If K is a subset of L∞ , the local distance from f to K is defined by distλ (f, K) = inf{distλ (f, h) : h ∈ K}.
34
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
It is easy to see that the function λ → distλ (f, K) is upper semicontinuous and so it attains a maximum on T. Theorem 5.17. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then Hϕ e = max distλ (ϕ, H ∞ ). λ∈T
Proof. Clearly, by Theorem 5.3, we have to show that distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) = max distλ (ϕ, H ∞ ). λ∈T
It is evident that distλ (ϕ, H ∞ ) ≤ distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) for any λ ∈ T. Let us show that distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) ≤ max distλ (ϕ, H ∞ ). λ∈T
(5.14)
Let M be the right-hand side of (5.14) and let ε > 0. For each λ we can find hλ in H ∞ such that distλ (ϕ, hλ ) < M + ε. Since the function ζ → distζ (ϕ, hλ ) is upper semi-continuous, it follows that for any λ there is an open interval Iλ such that distζ (ϕ, hλ ) < M + 2ε for ζ ∈ Iλ . We can choose a finite cover Iλ1 , · · · , Iλn of T. Let wj ∈ C(T), 1 ≤ j ≤ n, be a partition of unity subordinate to the cover {Iλj }, i.e., n supp wj ⊂ Iλj , wj ≥ 0, and wj = 1. Put h =
n j=1
j=1
wj hλj . Since H ∞ + C is an algebra, it follows that
h ∈ H ∞ + C. Let λ ∈ T. We have n n wj ϕ, wj hλj distλ (ϕ, h) = distλ j=1
≤ =
n j=1 n
j=1
distλ (wj ϕ, wj hλj ) =
n
distλ (wj (λ)ϕ, wj (λ)hλj )
j=1 n
wj (λ) distλ (ϕ, hλj ) ≤
j=1
wj (λ)(M + 2ε),
j=1
since distλ (f, hλj ) ≤ M +2ε for λ ∈ Iλj and wj (λ) = 0 if λ ∈ Iλj . Therefore distλ (ϕ, h) ≤ M + 2ε, which proves that distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) ≤ M . Let us now compute Hϕ e for piecewise continuous functions ϕ. Denote by P C the class of piecewise continuous functions on T. A function ϕ on T is said to belong to P C if for any ζ ∈ T the limits def
ϕ(ζ + ) = lim ϕ(ζeit ), t→0+
ϕ(ζ − ) = lim ϕ(ζeit ) def
t→0−
5. Compactness of Hankel Operators
35
exist. Since we identify functions that differ on a set of zero measure, we can assume that for ϕ ∈ P C ϕ(ζ + ) = ϕ(ζ),
ζ ∈ T.
Denote by κζ (ϕ) the jump of ϕ at ζ: κζ (ϕ) = ϕ(ζ) − ϕ(ζ − ). It is easy to see that for any ε > 0 the set {ζ ∈ T : |κζ (ϕ)| > ε} is finite. Theorem 5.18. Let ϕ ∈ P C. Then Hϕ e =
1 max |κζ (ϕ)|. 2 ζ∈T
(5.15)
Proof. In view of Theorem 5.17 it is sufficient to show that 1 |κζ (ϕ)| = distζ (ϕ, H ∞ ). 2 It is easy to see that distζ (ϕ, H ∞ ) ≤ distζ (ϕ, c) =
1 |κζ (ϕ)|, 2
where c is the constant function equal to 12 (ϕ(ζ) + ϕ(ζ − )). Let us show that 12 |κζ (ϕ)| ≤ distζ (ϕ, H ∞ ). By multiplying ϕ by a constant and adding to it a constant function if needed, we can assume without loss of generality that ϕ(ζ) = 1 and ϕ(ζ − ) = −1. We have to show that distζ (ϕ, H ∞ ) ≥ 1. We can also assume that ζ = 1. Suppose that there exists an f in H ∞ such that dist1 (ϕ, f ) < 1. It follows that there exists δ > 0 such that Re f (eit ) > δ,
0 ≤ t ≤ ε;
Re f (eit ) < −δ,
−ε ≤ t ≤ 0, (5.16)
for some ε > 0. Let h(ζ) = Re f (ζ), ζ ∈ D. Then ˜ f (ζ) = h(ζ) + ih(ζ) + i Im f (0), ˜ is the harmonic conjugate to h (see Appendix 2.1). Then h ˜ is where h bounded on D. We have ˜ iϑ ) = (h ∗ Qr )(eiϑ ), h(re where Qr is the conjugate Poisson kernel (see Appendix 2.1). Let us show ˜ that |h(r)| → ∞ as r → 1. It is easy to see that
h(eit )Qr (t)dt ≤ const . {|t|≥ε}
36
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
On the other hand, it follows easily from (5.16) that ε
ε sin t 1 it it h(e )Q (e )dt ≥ const δ dt ≥ const · log , r 2 1 − 2r cos t + r 1 − r −ε 0 ˜ is where the constant depends on δ and ε. This contradicts the fact that h ∞ bounded. Thus dist1 (ϕ, H ) = 1 and the proof is completed. Remark. Clearly the right-hand side of (5.15) is equal to distL∞ (ϕ, C(T)). So for ϕ ∈ P C we have distL∞ (ϕ, C(T)) = distL∞ (ϕ, H ∞ + C) = Hϕ e . Now we are in a position to compute the norm and the essential norm of ˆ = 1/n, the Hilbert matrix. Let ψ(eit ) = i(t − π), t ∈ [0, 2π). Then ψ(−n) n = 0, and Hψ has Hilbert matrix. Corollary 5.19. Let ψ be as above. Then Hψ e = Hψ = π. Proof. We have established in §1 that Hϕ ≤ π. Since ϕ ∈ P C, we have Hψ e = π by Theorem 5.18. The result follows now from the obvious inequality Hψ e ≤ Hψ .
A Factorization Theorem We conclude this section with the following elegant property of H ∞ + C. Theorem 5.20. Let f ∈ L∞ . Then there exist a Blaschke product B ¯ and a function ϕ in H ∞ + C such that f = Bϕ. Proof. By Theorem 2.4, there exist sequences {ϑn }n≥1 of inner functions and {gn }n≥1 of H ∞ -functions such that lim f − ϑ¯n gn ∞ = 0. n→∞
By Frostman’s theorem (see Appendix 2.1), each inner function is a uniform limit of Blaschke products. Therefore there exists a sequence of Blaschke products {Bn }n≥1 such that ¯n gn ∞ = 0. lim f − B n→∞
(1)
(2)
(1)
Let us decompose each Bn as follows: Bn = Bn Bn , where Bn is a finite Blaschke product and the product Bn(2) B= n≥1
converges in D. Then
¯ (1) hn ∞ → 0, Bf − B n
where hn = gn
m =n
(2) Bm ∈ H ∞.
6. Hankel Operators and Reproducing Kernels
37
¯n(1) hn ∈ H ∞ + C. Hence, Bf ∈ H ∞ + C by Theorem 5.1. Clearly, B
6. Hankel Operators and Reproducing Kernels In this section we show that to verify the boundedness (or compactness) of a Hankel operator, we can consider the action of the operator on the so-called reproducing kernels of H 2 . Let ζ ∈ D. Put 1 Kζ (z) = ¯ . 1 − ζz Then Kζ ∈ H 2 and for any f ∈ H 2 (f, Kζ ) = f (ζ). Because of this property the functions Kζ are called the reproducing kernel functions (or simply kernel functions) of H 2 . It is easy to see that Kζ 2 = (1 − |ζ|2 )−1/2 . The functions kζ defined by kζ (z) =
(1 − |ζ|2 )1/2 , ¯ 1 − ζz
ζ ∈ D,
are called the normalized kernel functions. Obviously, for any bounded operator A on H 2 the norms Akζ are uniformly bounded. It is easy to see that kζ → O weakly as |ζ| → 1. Therefore Akζ → 0 as |ζ| → 1 for any compact operator A on H 2 . We show in this section that for Hankel operators the converse is also true. We shall work here with the Garsia norm on BM O (see Appendix 2.5). Let Pζ be the Poisson kernel, Pζ (z) =
1 − |ζ|2 2 ¯ 2 = |kζ (z)| . |1 − ζz|
Given ϕ ∈ L2 , we denote by ϕ# its harmonic extension to the unit disc:
ϕ# (ζ) = ϕ(τ )Pζ (τ )dm(τ ), ζ ∈ D. T
The Garsia norm of ϕ is defined by 1/2
2 ϕG = sup |ϕ(τ ) − ϕ# (ζ)| Pζ (τ )dm(τ ) . ζ∈D
T
Then · G is a norm on BM O modulo the constants which is equivalent to the initial norm (see Appendix 2.5).
38
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Theorem 6.1. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . The Hankel operator Hϕ is bounded on H if and only if 2
sup Hϕ kζ 2 < ∞.
(6.1)
ζ∈D
Proof. Let ψ = P− ϕ. We have P− ϕ z¯P− ϕ ψ Hϕ Kζ = P− ¯ = P+ 1 − ζ z¯ = P+ z − ζ . 1 − ζz Clearly, P+
ψ ψ − ψ(ζ) 1 ψ − ψ(ζ) = P+ + ψ(ζ)P+ = . z−ζ z−ζ z−ζ z−ζ
Therefore
Hϕ kζ 2
1/2 |ψ(τ ) − ψ(ζ)|2 (1 − |ζ|2 ) dm(τ ) |τ − ζ|2 T
1/2 2 = |ψ(τ ) − ψ(ζ)| Pζ (τ )dm(τ ) . =
T
It follows that sup Hϕ kζ 2 = ψG , ζ∈D
which proves that (6.1) is equivalent to the fact that P− ϕ ∈ BM O, which in turn means that Hϕ is bounded (see Theorem 1.3). To prove the compactness criterion in terms of kernel functions, we need the following characterization of V M O. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . Then ϕ ∈ V M O if and only if
lim |ϕ(τ ) − ϕ(ζ)|2 Pζ (τ )dm(τ ) = 0 |ζ|→1
T
(see Appendix 2.5). Theorem 6.2. Let ϕ ∈ L2 . The Hankel operator Hϕ is compact on H if and only if 2
lim Hϕ kζ = 0.
|ζ|→1
(6.2)
Proof. The same argument as in the proof of Theorem 6.1 shows that (6.2) is equivalent to the condition
|ψ(τ ) − ψ# (ζ)|2 Pζ (τ )dm(τ ) = 0, lim |ζ|→1
T
which means that P− ϕ ∈ V M O, which in turn is equivalent to the compactness of Hϕ (Theorem 5.8).
7. Hankel Operators and Moment Sequences
39
7. Hankel Operators and Moment Sequences In this section we see that Hankel matrices appear naturally in connection with power moment problems. We are going to solve the Hamburger moment problem, and characterize the bounded and compact positive semidefinite Hankel matrices. We also characterize arbitrary bounded and compact Hankel matrices in terms of moment sequences of Carleson (vanishing Carleson) measures. Let {αj }j≥0 be a sequence of complex numbers. The classical Hamburger moment problem is to find a positive measure µ on R satisfying
|t|j dµ(t) < ∞, j ≥ 0, (7.1) R
and such that its moments coincide with the αj , i.e.,
tj dµ(t), j ≥ 0. αj =
(7.2)
R
In this case µ is called a solution of the power moment problem with data {αj }j≥0 . The Hamburger theorem (Theorem 7.1 below) gives a solvability criterion in terms of positive semi-definiteness of the corresponding Hankel matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 . (The matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 is called positive semi-definite if αj+k xj x ¯k ≥ 0 (7.3) j,k≥0
for any finitely supported sequence {xj }j≥0 of complex numbers.) Theorem 7.1. Let {αj }j≥0 be a sequence of complex numbers. The Hamburger moment problem with data {αj }j≥0 is solvable if and only if the Hankel matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 is positive semi-definite. It is very easy to prove the “only if” part. To prove the “if” part we need some facts from the extension theory of symmetric operators. We are going to deal with (possibly unbounded) densely defined operators on Hilbert space. We review briefly some basic notions and facts and refer the reader to Birman and Solomjak [1] for a detailed presentation of the theory. Let H be a Hilbert space. We consider linear transformations (operators) T whose domain D(T ) is a dense linear manifold in H and whose range is a subset of H. The operator T is called closed if its graph {x⊕T x : x ∈ D(T )} is closed in H ⊕ H and it is called closable if the closure of its graph in H ⊕ H is a graph of a linear operator. If T1 and T2 are densely defined linear operators, we say that T2 is an extension of T1 if D(T1 ) ⊂ D(T2 ) and T2 x = T1 x for x ∈ D1 . If T is a densely defined closable linear operator, we define its adjoint operator T ∗ as follows. The domain D(T ∗ ) consists of those vectors y in H for which the linear functional x → (T x, y), x ∈ D(T ), extends to a bounded linear functional. Since T is closable, D(T ∗ ) is dense in H. For y ∈ D(T ∗ ) we define T ∗ y by the equality (T x, y) = (x, T ∗ y).
40
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
A densely defined linear operator A is called symmetric if A∗ is an extension of A or, in other words, x, y ∈ D(A).
(Ax, y) = (x, Ay),
The operator A is called self-adjoint if A∗ = A, i.e., A is symmetric and D(A∗ ) = D(A). With a symmetric operator operator A we can associate the deficiency indices n− (A) = dim(Range(A + iI))⊥ ,
n+ (A) = dim(Range(A − iI))⊥ .
The symmetric operator A has a self-adjoint extension if and only if n− (A) = n+ (A). If A is a cyclic self-adjoint operator (i.e., there exists a vector x0 such that An x0 ∈ D(A) for all n ∈ Z+ and span{An x0 : n ∈ Z+ } = H), then it follows from the spectral theorem that there exists a positive Borel measure µ on R such that A is unitary equivalent to the operator Aµ of multiplication by the independent variable on L2 (µ), i.e.,
D(Aµ ) = f ∈ L2 (µ) : |f (t)|dµ(t) < ∞ , (Aµ f )(t) = tf (t). R
Moreover, if x0 is such a vector, the unitary equivalence can be chosen to send x0 to the constant function 1 identically equal to 1. We are ready now to prove Theorem 7.1. Proof of Theorem 7.1. It is very easy to prove that if there exists a measure µ satisfying (7.1) and (7.2), then the matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 satisfies (7.3). Indeed,
αj+k xj x ¯k = xj x ¯k tj+k dµ(t) j,k≥0
j,k≥0
R
2
j xj t dµ(t) ≥ 0. = R j≥0
Let us prove now the sufficiency of (7.3) for the solvability of the moment problem (7.2). Let H0 be the set of polynomials on R. For p, q ∈ H0 define the following pairing: p, q =
m n
pj q¯k αj+k ,
(7.4)
j=0 k=0
where p(t) = p0 + p1 (t) + · · · + pm tm and q(t) = q0 + q1 t + · · · + qn tn . We consider separately two cases. Case 1. The form (7.4) is nondegenerate, i.e., p, p = 0 for any nonzero p ∈ H0 . Let H be the completion of H0 with respect to the inner product (7.4). Then H is a Hilbert space.
7. Hankel Operators and Moment Sequences
41
Consider the operator A0 with domain H0 defined by (A0 p)(t) = tp(t),
p ∈ H0 .
It is easy to see that A is symmetric. We claim that A has a self-adjoint extension. Let J0 be the operator on H0 defined by J0 p = p¯. Clearly, J0 is conjugatelinear and isometric. So it extends by continuity to a conjugate-linear isometry J of H onto itself. It is also easy to see that J Range(A0 + iI) = Range(A0 − iI). Therefore n− (A0 ) = n+ (A0 ). Let A be a self-adjoint extension of A0 . Clearly, span{An 1 : n ∈ Z+ } = H. By the spectral theorem there exist a positive Borel measure on R and a unitary operator U from H to L2 (µ) such that U 1 = 1 and U AU −1 is multiplication by the independent variable on L2 (µ). Obviously, U p = p for any p ∈ H0 . It is easy to see that µ is a solution of our moment problem. Case 2. There exists a nonzero polynomial p for which p, p = 0. We can choose a polynomial p minimal degree with this property. Let n = deg p. We now identify polynomials q and r if q − r, q − r = 0. We can consider now the finite-dimensional Hilbert space H of equivalence classes endowed with inner product ·, · = 0. Let us show that if q is a polynomial such that q, q = 0, then Aq, q = 0. Let m = deg q. Suppose that q(t) = q0 + p1 t + · · · + qm tm and q, q = 0. Let Γ be the Hankel matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 . Consider the matrix ΓN = {αj+k }0≤j,k≤m+N and the vector q0 q1 .. . m+1+N x= . qm ∈ C O . .. O Since q, q = 0, it is easy to see that (ΓN x, x) = 0, where (·, ·) is the standard inner product in Cm+1+N . Since the matrix ΓN is positive semidefinite, it follows that ΓN x = O for any N ∈ Z+ . Now it is easy to see that O q0 q1 .. = O, . Γ qm O .. .
42
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
and so Aq, Aq = 0. Thus we can consider the operator A as a self-adjoint operator on the n-dimensional Hilbert space H. Now the same reasoning as in Case 1 allows us to construct a measure µ (in this case it consists of at most n atoms), which solves our moment problem. Remark. It is easy to see that the deficiency indices n− (A0 ) and n+ (A0 ) are either both equal to 0 or both equal to 1. In the case n− (A0 ) = n+ (A0 ) = 0 there is only one solution of the moment problem, since there is only one self-adjoint extension of A0 . If n− (A0 ) = n+ (A0 ) = 1, there are infinitely many solutions of the moment problem, since there are infinitely many self-adjoint extensions of A0 . Moreover in the last case one can obtain other solutions of the moment problem by considering so-called minimal self-adjoint extensions of A0 in Hilbert spaces larger than H. Let us proceed now to positive semidefinite Hankel matrices Γα = {αj+k }j,k≥0 that are bounded on 2 . We are going to describe such matrices in terms of solutions of the corresponding moment problems. We are going to use the Carleson imbedding theorem, which says that a measure µ on D is a Carleson measure if and only if sup I
where
|µ|(RI ) < ∞, |I|
RI =
ζ ∈I ζ∈D: |ζ|
and
(7.5)
1 − |ζ| ≤ |I| , def
the supremum is taken over all subarcs I of T, and |I| = m(I) (see Appendix 2.1). Note that for µ supported on (−1, 1) condition (7.5) means that |µ|(1 − t, 1) ≤ const · t,
|µ|(−1, −1 + t) ≤ const · t.
Theorem 7.2. Let Γ = {αj+k }j,k≥0 be a nonnegative Hankel matrix. The following statements are equivalent: (i) Γ determines a bounded operator on 2 ; (ii) there exists a positive measure µ on (−1, 1) such that
1 tn dµ(t) αn = −1
and µ is a Carleson measure (as a measure on D); (iii) |αn | ≤ const(1 + n)−1 . Proof. By Hamburger’s theorem there exists a measure µ on R that satisfies (7.1) and (7.2). Suppose that Γ is bounded on 2 . Then αn → 0 as n → ∞ and it is easy to see that this implies that µ is supported on [−1, 1]. It is also easy to see that µ({1}) = µ({−1}) = 0.
7. Hankel Operators and Moment Sequences
43
Let I be the imbedding operator from H 2 to L2 (µ) which is defined on the set of polynomials by If = f (−1, 1). (7.6) ˆ Let f = f (j)z j be a polynomial. It is easy to see that j≥0
(If, If )L2 (µ) = Γα {fˆ(j)}j≥0 , {fˆ(j)}j≥0 . 2
(7.7)
It follows that Γ is bounded on 2 if and only if I is a bounded operator from H 2 to L2 (µ). Thus the equivalence (i)⇔(ii) follows from the Carleson imbedding theorem. Let us show that (ii)⇒(iii). We have µ((t, 1)) ≤ c(1−t) for some constant c. Then
1
1 tn dµ(t) = µ((0, 1)) − ntn−1 µ((0, t))dt 0
0
nt
=
1 n−1
µ((t, 1))dt ≤ c
0
1
ntn−1 (1 − t)dt ≤ 0
c . n+1
0 One can prove in the same way that −1 tn dµ(t) ≤ const(1 + n)−1 . The fact that (iii) implies (i) follows easily from the boundedness of the Hilbert matrix. Indeed, let ξ = {ξj }j≥0 and η = {ηk }k≥0 be finitely supported sequences. We have αj+k ξj η¯k |(Γα ξ, η)| = j,k≥0 |ξj | · |ηk | ≤ πξ2 η2 , ≤ |j + k + 1| j,k≥0
since the norm of the Hilbert matrix is equal to π (see Corollary 5.19). Let us characterize the compact nonnegative Hankel matrices in terms of vanishing Carleson measures (see Appendix 2.1). Theorem 7.3. Let Γ = {αj+k }j,k≥0 be a nonnegative Hankel matrix. The following statements are equivalent: (i) Γ determines a compact operator on 2 ; (ii) there exists a positive measure µ on (−1, 1) such that
1 tn dµ(t) αn = −1
and µ is a vanishing Carleson measure (as a measure in D); (iii) lim αn (1 + n) = 0. n→∞
Proof. We identify H 2 with 2 in the following natural way: f → {fˆ(n)}n≥0 ,
f ∈ H 2.
44
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
It follows from (7.7) that the operator I defined by (7.6) satisfies Γ[µ] = I ∗ I, and so Γ[µ] is compact if and only if I is, which proves that (i)⇔(ii). Suppose that µ is a vanishing Carleson measure. Then for any ε > 0, µ admits a representation µ = µ1 + µ2 , where µ1 is supported on (−r, r) for some r < 1 and µ2 satisfies µ2 ((1 − r, 1)) ≤ εt,
µ2 ((−1, −1 + r)) ≤ εt.
The proof of the implication (ii)⇒(iii) in Theorem 7.1 gives the estimate 1 2ε n . t dµ2 (t)dt ≤ n+1 −1 It is easy to see that
r −r
tn dµ1 (t) ≤ const rn .
This proves that (ii)⇒(iii). (n) (n) To show that (iii)⇒(i) we can represent Γ[µ] as Γ1 + Γ2 , where (1) Γ1 = αj+k , Γ2 = Γ − Γ1 , j,k≥0
(1)
(1)
= αj for j ≤ n, αj
(n)
has finite rank and (n) the proof of the application (iii)⇒(i) in Theorem 7.1 shows that Γ2 → 0, which completes the proof. Note that (ii) in Theorem 7.3 means that
and αj
lim
t→0+
= 0 for j > n. Then Γ1
µ((1 − t, 1)) µ((−1, −1 + t)) = lim = 0. t→0+ t t
Let now µ be a finite complex measure on D. As in the case of measures on [−1, 1] we can define the Hankel matrix Γ[µ] as follows:
j+k Γ[µ] = ζ dµ(ζ) . D
j,k≥0
As before we can identify 2 with H 2 and consider Γ[µ] as the matrix of an operator on H 2 . It is easy to see that for any polynomials f and g in H 2
¯ (Γ[µ]f, g) = f (ζ)g(ζ)dµ(ζ). (7.8) D
Theorem 7.4. If µ is a complex Carleson measure, then Γ[µ] is bounded on H 2 . If Γ = {αj+k }j,k≥0 is a bounded Hankel matrix, then there exists a complex Carleson measure µ such that
αj = ζ j dµ(ζ). D
7. Hankel Operators and Moment Sequences
45
Proof. If µ is a Carleson measure, then it follows from (7.8) that for any polynomials f and g in H 2
1/2
1/2 ¯ 2 d|µ|(ζ) |(Γ[µ]f, g)| = |f (ζ)|2 d|µ|(ζ) |g(ζ)| D
D
≤ const f H 2 gH 2
by the definition of Carleson measures. So Γ[µ] is bounded. To prove the converse, we need the fact that any function in BM O can be represented as the Poisson balayage of a Carleson measure (see Appendix 2.5). Suppose that {αj+k }j,k≥0 is a bounded matrix on 2 . By Theorem 1.2, def ϕ = αj z j ∈ BM OA. j≥0
Then there exists a Carleson measure µ whose Poisson balayage coincides with ϕ, that is,
Pλ (ζ)dµ(λ) for almost all ζ ∈ T, ϕ(ζ) = D
where Pλ is the Poisson kernel. It is easy to see that
αj = ϕ(j) ˆ = ζ j dµ(ζ), j ≥ 0. D
In a similar way one can prove the following compactness criterion. Theorem 7.5. If µ is a complex vanishing Carleson measure, then Γ[µ] is compact on H 2 . If Γ = {αj+k }j,k≥0 is a compact Hankel matrix, then there exists a complex vanishing Carleson measure µ such that
ζ j dµ(ζ). αj = D
To conclude this section, we evaluate the Hankel matrices Γ[m1−1 ] and Γ[m10 ] , where m1−1 is Lebesgue measure on [−1, 1] and m10 is Lebesgue measure on [0, 1]. It is easy to see that 2
1 j+1 , j is even, j x dx = 0, j is odd. −1 Hence,
Γ[m1−1 ]
1 0 1 3 = 2 0 1 5 .. .
0 1 3
0 1 5
0 .. .
1 3
0 1 5
0 1 7
.. .
0 1 5
0
1 5
0 1 7
1 7
0
0 .. .
.. .
1 9
··· ··· ··· ··· ··· .. .
.
(7.9)
46
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
On the other hand,
1
xj dx = 0
and so
Γ[m10 ]
1
1/2
1 , j+1
1/3
1/2 1/3 1/4 = 1/3 1/4 .. 1/4 . .. .. . .
1/4 ..
.
··· .. .
(7.10)
is the Hilbert matrix (see §1). Corollary 7.6. The matrices on the right-hand sides of (7.9) and (7.10) are bounded positive semi-definite matrices. Proof. This is an immediate consequence of Theorem (7.2).
8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis In this section we consider integral operators on the space L2 (R+ ) of functions on the semi-axis R+ with kernels depending only on the sum of the variables. We show that such operators are unitarily equivalent to Hankel operators on 2 introduced in §1 and this will allow us to reduce the study of such operators to the study of Hankel operators on 2 . For a function k ∈ L1 (R+ ) consider the operator Γ k on L2 (R+ ),
∞ k(s + t)f (s)ds. (8.1) (Γ k f )(t) = 0
Below we shall see that Γ k is a bounded operator on L2 (R+ ). The definition of Γ k is similar to the definition of Hankel operators as operators with matrices whose entries depend only on the sum of the coordinates (see §1). We are going to define the operator Γ k in a much more general case where k does not necessarily belong to L1 (R+ ). We shall see that Γ k can be bounded for certain distributions. We shall find in this section boundedness, compactness, and finite rank criteria for Γ k , and we establish the unitary equivalence between operators Γ k and Hankel operators on 2 . We call operators Γ k Hankel operators on L2 (R+ ). It will be slightly more convenient for us to deal with the following integral operators. Let q ∈ L1 (R− ). We define the integral operator Gq from
8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis
L2 (R+ ) to L2 (R− ) by
∞
(Gq f )(t) =
q(t − s)f (s)ds,
t < 0.
47
(8.2)
0
Clearly, (Γ k f )(t) = (Gq f )(−t),
k(t) = q(−t),
t ∈ R+ .
(8.3)
We can assume for convenience that q ∈ L (R) and q(t) = 0 for t > 0, since the right-hand side in (8.2) does not depend on the values of q on R+ . Denote by P+ and P− the operators of multiplication by the characteristic function of R+ and R− , respectively. We can also identify the spaces L2 (R+ ) and L2 (R− ) with subspaces of L2 (R). Then P− and P+ are the orthogonal projections of L2 (R) onto L2 (R− ) and L2 (R+ ) respectively. It is easy to see that Gq can also be defined by 1
Gq f = P− (q ∗ f ),
f ∈ L2 (R+ ),
where the the convolution ϕ ∗ ψ of functions ϕ and ψ on R is defined by
(ϕ ∗ ψ)(t) = ϕ(s)ψ(t − s) ds. R
It is easy to see now that Gq is bounded for q ∈ L1 (R). We have Gq f 2 = P− (q ∗ f )2 ≤ q ∗ f 2 ≤ q1 f 2 ; the last inequality is well known and can be proved elementarily.
Digression. Distributions To define the operators Gq and Γ k in a more general context we need the notion of distributions (see Schwartz [1] for more detailed information). Let D be the space of infinitely differentiable functions on R with compact support. The space D is endowed with the natural topology of inductive limit. Without entering into detail let us mention the following. A sequence {fj }j≥0 converges in D to f if and only if there is a compact set K in R (m) such that supp fj ⊂ K for any j and all derivatives fj converge uniformly on K to the derivatives f (m) , m ≥ 0. A linear operator T from D to a locally convex space X is continuous if and only if for any sequence {fj }j≥0 converging to O in D, the sequence {T fj }j≥0 converges in X to O. For convenience we define the space of distributions D as the space of continuous antilinear functionals on D, i.e., def
¯ < g, f >, < g, λf > = g(λf ) = λ
f ∈ D,
g ∈ D ,
λ ∈ C;
< g, f1 + f2 >=< g, f1 > + < g, f2 >, f1 , f2 ∈ D, g ∈ D . If g is a locally summable function on R, it can be interpreted as a distribution that acts on D as follows:
g(t)f (t)dt, f ∈ D. (8.4) < g, f >= R
48
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
For g ∈ D , we define its support supp g as the minimal closed set F for which < g, f >= 0 for any f ∈ D with support in R \ F . If Ω is an open set in R, we can consider in a similar way the space D(Ω) of infinitely smooth functions with compact support in Ω and we can define the space of distributions D (Ω). We need the important subclass of D , the space of tempered distributions. Let S be the space of infinitely differentiable functions f on R such that for any m, n ∈ Z+ sup f (m) (t) (1 + |t|)n < ∞. (8.5) t∈R
The topology on S is determined by the system of seminorms on the lefthand side of (8.5). As in the case of the space D we define the space S of tempered distributions as the space of continuous antilinear functionals on S. Note that if g is a measurable function on R such that
|g(t)| dt < ∞ (1 + |t|)n R for some n ∈ Z+ , then g can be considered as a tempered distribution that acts on S as in (8.4). Recall that the Fourier transform Ff of a function f in L1 (R) is defined by
(Ff )(s) = e−2πits f (t)dt. R By Plancherel’s theorem F L1 (R) L2 (R) extends to a unitary operator on L2 (R) and the inverse Fourier transform F −1 = F ∗ is defined on L1 (R) L2 (R) by
(F ∗ f )(t) =
e2πits f (t)ds. R
It is easy to see that F ∗ S = S, which allows us to define the Fourier transform on the space of tempered distributions S by < Fg, f > = < g, F ∗ f >, def
f ∈ S, g ∈ S .
Recall one more elementary identity: F ∗ (f ∗ g) = (F ∗ f )(F ∗ g),
f ∈ L1 (R), g ∈ L2 (R).
(8.6)
Boundedness, Compactness, and Finite Rank Criteria Now we are in a position to define the operators Gq and Γ k in a more general situation. If q ∈ L1 (R), it is an elementary exercise to see that
def ¯ q(s)(f¯◦ ∗ g)(s)ds, f ∈ L2 (R+ ), g ∈ L2 (R− ), (Gq f, g) = (q, f◦ ∗ g) = R (8.7) def
where f◦ (s) = f (−s).
8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis
49
Formula (8.7) suggests the following definition of Gq for some distributions q in D (−∞, 0). Put def (Gq f, g) = < q, f¯◦ ∗ g >,
f ∈ D(0, ∞), g ∈ D(−∞, 0) (8.8)
(we identify in a natural way D(0, ∞) and D(−∞, 0) with the subspaces of functions in D with support in (0, ∞) and (−∞, 0), respectively). We say that Gq is bounded on L2 (R+ ) if |(Gq f, g)| ≤ const · f 2 g2 . In this case for f ∈ D(0, ∞) we define Gq f as the function in L2 (R− ) such that (Gq f, g) =< q, f¯◦ ∗ g > for g ∈ D(−∞, 0). We can define now the operator Γ k by (8.3) in the case when the operator Gq is bounded. The identity k(t) = q(−t), t ∈ R, means that < k, f >=< q, f◦ >,
f ∈ D.
The following result characterizes the bounded operators Gq . Theorem 8.1. Let q ∈ D (−∞, 0). The operator Gq defined by (8.8) is bounded on L2 (R+ ) if and only if there exists a function κ ∈ L∞ (R) such that Fκ (−∞, 0) = q. Moreover, Gq = inf κ∞ : κ ∈ L∞ (R), Fκ (−∞, 0) = q . (8.9) (By Fκ (−∞, 0) = q we mean that < Fκ, g >=< q, g > for any g ∈ D(−∞, 0)). To prove Theorem 8.1 we need the notion of Hankel operator on the Hardy class H 2 (C+ ) of functions in the upper half-plane (see Appendix 2.1). Recall that the Paley–Wiener theorem allows us to identify H 2 (C+ ) with the following subspace of L2 (R): H 2 (C+ ) = f ∈ L2 (R) : Ff (−∞, 0) = O . Similarly, the Hardy class H 2 (C− ) of functions analytic in the lower halfplane can be identified with the subspace of functions in L2 (R) whose Fourier transforms vanish on R+ . Clearly, under this identification L2 (R) = H 2 (C+ ) ⊕ H 2 (C− ). Recall that the unitary operator U on L2 (T) defined by 1 (f ◦ ω −1 )(t) (Uf )(t) = √ , t+i π
t ∈ R,
(8.10)
is a unitary operator from L2 (T) onto L2 (R) and U(H 2 ) = H 2 (C+ ) (see Appendix 2.1). Here ω is the conformal map ω of D onto C+ defined by ω(ζ) = i
1+ζ , 1−ζ
ζ ∈ D,
ω −1 (w) =
w−i , w+i
w ∈ C+ .
and
50
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
ˆ \ clos D onto C− , where C ˆ def Note that ω also maps conformally C = C ∪ ∞. To prove Theorem 8.1 we need the following lemma. Lemma 8.2. Let q be a distribution on (−∞, 0) such that the operator 2 Gq defined by (8.8) is bounded on L2 (R+ ). Then the operator Γ : H 2 → H− defined by Γ = U ∗ F ∗ Gq FU
(8.11)
is a Hankel operator on H 2 . Proof. In view of the commutation relation (1.13) it suffices to show that (P− zΓξ, η) = (Γzξ, η)
(8.12)
2 for ξ in a dense subset of H 2 and η in a dense subset of H− . We have
(Γzξ, η) = (Gq FUzξ, FUη). Put def
F = Uξ,
def
G = Uη,
We have by (8.10) (Uzξ)(t) = F (t)
def
f = FF,
def
g = FG.
1 t−i . = F (t) 1 − 2i t+i t+i
Put α(t) = 2i/(t + i), t ∈ R. Clearly, α ∈ H 2 (C+ ). Let h = Fα ∈ L2 (R+ ). It follows from (8.6) that F ∗ (f ∗ h) = F α. Therefore (Γzξ, η) = (Gq f, g) + (Gq (h ∗ f ), g). ∗¯
¯ and so we can obtain in a similar way Clearly, F h◦ = α ¯ ◦ ∗ g). (P− zΓξ, η) = (Γξ, z¯η) = (Gq FUξ, FU z¯η) = (Gq f, g) + (Gq f, h Therefore to prove (8.12) it is sufficient to show that ¯ ◦ ∗ g) (Gq (h ∗ f ), g) = (Gq f, h
(8.13)
for any functions f ∈ D(0, ∞), g ∈ D(−∞, 0) and any h ∈ L2 (R+ ). In view of (8.8) equality (8.13) is equivalent to the following one: ¯ ◦ ∗ g). (h ∗ f )◦ ∗ g = f¯◦ ∗ (h The latter follows from the following identity, which can be verified elementarily: (h ∗ f )◦ = h◦ ∗ f◦ . Before we proceed to the proof of Theorem 8.1 we define Hankel operators on the Hardy class H 2 (C+ ). Denote by P + and P − the orthogonal projections from L2 (R+ ) onto H 2 (C+ ) and H 2 (C− ). It follows from the Paley–Wiener theorem that P + = F ∗ P+ F,
P − = F ∗ P− F.
8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis
51
Let ψ ∈ L∞ (R). The Hankel operator Hψ : H 2 (C+ ) → H 2 (C− ) is defined by Hψ F = P − ψF, F ∈ H 2 (C+ ). Clearly, Hψ is a bounded operator on H 2 (C+ ). def
Lemma 8.3. Let ψ ∈ L∞ (R) and ϕ = ψ ◦ ω ∈ L∞ (T). Then Hϕ = U ∗ Hψ U. 2 . We have Proof. Let f ∈ H 2 , g ∈ H−
(Hϕ f, g) = (ϕf, g); (U ∗ Hψ Uf, g) = (Hψ Uf, Ug) = (ψUf, Ug) = (Uϕf, Ug) = (ϕf, g) by (8.10). Corollary 8.4. Let ψ ∈ L∞ (R). Then Hψ = distL∞ (R) (ψ, H ∞ (C+ )). The next result gives a compactness criterion for Hankel operators Hψ . ˆ is by definition the space of continuous functions on R The space C(R) which have equal limits at ∞ and −∞. Corollary 8.5. Let ψ ∈ L∞ (R). Hψ is compact if and only if ˆ ψ ∈ H ∞ (C+ ) + C(R). Clearly, Corollary 8.5 is an immediate consequence of Lemma 8.3. Now we are in a position to prove Theorem 8.1. Proof of Theorem 8.1. Suppose that Gq is bounded. Then by Lemma 8.2, the operator Γ defined by (8.11) is a bounded Hankel operator on H 2 . So Γ = Hϕ , where ϕ ∈ L∞ (T) and ϕ∞ = Gq . It follows from (8.11) and from Lemma 8.3 that UHϕ U ∗ = Hψ = F ∗ Gq F, where ψ = ϕ ◦ ω −1 . Hence, Gq = FHψ F ∗ . Put r = Fψ ∈ S . Let us show that FHψ F ∗ = Gr . We have def
(FHψ F ∗ f, g)
(ψF ∗ f, F ∗ g) =< ψ, F ∗ f · F ∗ g > = < r, F(F ∗ f · F ∗ g) >=< r, f¯◦ ∗ g >, =
f ∈ D(0, ∞),
(8.14)
g ∈ D(−∞, 0).
Therefore Gq = Gr . Since the set of functions f¯◦ ∗ g,
f ∈ D(0, ∞), g ∈ D(−∞, 0),
is obviously dense in D(−∞, 0), it follows that q = r (−∞, 0) = Fψ (−∞, 0) and Gq = ψ∞ , which proves that Gq is greater than or equal to the right-hand side of (8.9).
52
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
If q = Fψ (−∞, 0) and ψ ∈ L∞ (R), then the same reasoning proves that Gq = FHψ F ∗ ,
(8.15)
which implies that Gq ≤ ψ∞ = κ∞ . In the case of functions on T we can represent any bounded function ϕ as ϕ = P+ ϕ + P− ϕ and the Hankel operator Hϕ depends only on P− ϕ. However, in the case of functions on R the projections P + and P − are not defined on L∞ (R). Instead we define on L∞ (R) the operators P + and P − by P + ψ = (P+ (ψ ◦ ω)) ◦ ω −1 , def
P − ψ = (P− (ψ ◦ ω)) ◦ ω −1 , def
ψ ∈ L∞ (R).
We shall also use the notation ψ + = P + ψ, ψ − = P − ψ. Clearly, ψ = ψ + + ψ − . Note that P + and P − are unbounded on L∞ (R). Lemma 8.6. Let ψ ∈ L∞ (R). Then supp Fψ + ⊂ [0, ∞) and supp Fψ − ⊂ (−∞, 0]. Proof. Let g ∈ S, supp g ⊂ R− . Let us show that < Fψ + , g >= 0, which would mean that supp Fψ + ⊂ R+ . The proof of the fact that supp Fψ − ⊂ R− is similar. We have
+ + ∗ < Fψ , g >=< ψ , F g >= ψ + (t)(F ∗ g)(t)dt = 0 R
(F ∗ g)
∈ H (C+ ) (see Appendix 2.1). since ψ We can obtain now an analog of Theorem 1.2 in terms of the space BM O(R) of functions on R (see Appendix 2.5). Recall that ψ ∈ BM O if and only if ψ can be represented as ψ = ξ + P + η, for some ξ and η in L∞ (R). As in the case of functions on the unit circle the following result follows easily from Theorem 8.1. Corollary 8.7. Let q ∈ D (−∞, 0). Then Gq is bounded on L2 (R+ ) if and only if q = r(−∞, 0) for some r ∈ S such that supp r ⊂ R− and F ∗ r ∈ BM O(R). Let us now obtain the boundedness criterion for Γ k . Theorem 8.8. Let k ∈ D (0, ∞). The following statements are equivalent: (i) Γ k is bounded on L2 (R+ ); (ii) there exists a function κ in L∞ (R) such that Fκ (0, ∞) = k; (iii) there exists r ∈ S such that k = r(0, ∞), supp r ⊂ R+ , and F ∗ r ∈ BM O(R). If Γ k is bounded, then Γ k = inf{κ∞ : κ ∈ L∞ (R), Fκ R+ = k}. +
1
Proof. It remains to prove that (ii) implies (iii); everything else follows immediately from of Γ k . Let κ ∈ Theorem 8.1 and the definition (0, ∞) = k. Define r by r = FP + κ. By Lemma 8.6, such that Fκ L∞ (R) k = r(0, ∞) and supp r ⊂ R+ . Clearly, F ∗ r = P + κ ∈ BM O(R).
8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis
53
The operator Γ k defined by (8.1) is a continual analog of a Hankel matrix. The next result shows that a bounded operator Γ k is unitarily equivalent to a Hankel operator on 2 (i.e., an operator with Hankel matrix). Theorem 8.9. If Γ k is a bounded operator, then the operator U ∗ F ∗ Γ k FU on H 2 has Hankel matrix in the basis {z n }n≥0 . Proof. Let q(t) = k(−t), t ∈ R. Then Gq is bounded and so by (8.15) Gq = FHψ F ∗ for some bounded function ψ on R. Put ϕ = ψ ◦ ω ∈ L∞ (T). def
Let ξn = Uz n , n ∈ Z+ . We have (U ∗ F ∗ Γ k FUz n , z m ) = (Γ k Fξn , Fξm ) = (Gq Fξn , (Fξm )◦ ) = (Gq Fξn , F ∗ ξm ) = (F ∗ Gq Fξn , (F ∗ )2 ξm ) = (Hψ ξn , (ξm )◦ ) . It is easy to see that (ξm )◦ ∈ H 2 (C− ) and so (Hψ ξn , (ξm )◦ ) = (ψξn , (ξm )◦ ). Therefore
1 (t − i)n+m ψ(t) dt (U ∗ F ∗ Γ k FUz n , z m ) = (ψξn , (ξm )◦ ) = − π R (t + i)n+m+2 n+m+1
dt t−i 1 ψ(t) = − π R t+i |t + i|2
= − ϕ(ζ)ζ n+m+1 dm(ζ) = −ϕ(−n ˆ − m − 1), T
which proves the result. Remark. Theorem 8.9 says that Γ k has Hankel matrix in the orthonormal basis {FUz n }n≥0 of the space L2 (R+ ). Using the residue theorem, one can show that √ (FUz n )(t) = −2 πiLn (4πt)e−2πt , t > 0, where the functions Ln are the so-called Lageurre polynomials, 1 s d n Ln (s) = n! e ds (e−s sn ); see Szeg¨o [1]. To proceed to compactness criteria, we need the space V M O(R) (see Appendix 2.5 for the definition). Note that there are several possible definitions of V M O(R) and ours differs from the one in Garnett [1]. The space ˆ V M O(R) consists of functions of the form ξ + P + η with ξ, η ∈ C(R). It is easy to obtain from Corollary 8.5 and formula (8.15) a compactness criterion for Gq . We state instead the following compactness criterion for Γ k. Theorem 8.10. Let k ∈ D (0, ∞). The following statements are equivalent: (i) Γ k is a compact operator on L2 (R+ ); ˆ such that Fκ (0, ∞) = k; (ii) there exists a function κ in C(R) (iii) there exists r ∈ S such that supp r ⊂ R+ , k = r(0, ∞), and F ∗ r ∈ V M O(R).
54
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
We have started this section with the operators Γ k for k ∈ L1 (R+ ) and observed that such operators are bounded. In fact it follows immediately from Theorem 8.10 that they are compact. Corollary 8.11. Let k ∈ L1 (R+ ). Then Γ k is compact on L2 (R+ ). ˆ by the Riemann–Lebesgue lemma, the result Proof. Since F ∗ k ∈ C(R) follows directly from statement (ii) of Theorem 8.10. Let us now characterize the finite rank operators Γ k . It is easy to see from Lemma 8.3 that Hψ has finite rank if and only if P − ψ is a rational function and rank Hψ = deg P − ψ. This implies the following result. Lemma 8.12. Let Γ k , k ∈ D (0, ∞), be a bounded operator and let r be a tempered distribution such that supp r ⊂ R+ and k = r(0, ∞). Then Γ k has finite rank if and only if F ∗ k is a rational function. In this case rank Γ k = deg F ∗ k. It is easy to see that if supp r ⊂ R+ , then F ∗ r is rational if and only if r admits a representation r(t) =
j −1 n m
cj,l tl eλj t ,
t > 0,
j=1 l=0
where the λj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, are complex numbers satisfying Re λj < 0. This implies the following finite rank criterion. Theorem 8.13. Let Γ k , k ∈ D (0, ∞), be a bounded operator and let r be a tempered distribution such that supp r ⊂ R+ and k = r|(0, ∞). Then Γ k has finite rank if and only if r(t) =
j −1 n m
cj,l tl eλj t ,
t > 0,
(8.16)
j=1 l=0
where Re λj < 0. If the operator Γ k has finite rank and cj,mj −1 = 0 in (8.16), then n mj . rank Γ k = j=1
The Carleman Operator def
Consider the operator Γ = Γ k on L2 (R+ ), where k(t) = 1/t, t > 0. It is called the Carleman operator. Here we interpret k as an element of D (0, ∞). Let us show that Γ is bounded. By Theorem 8.8 it suffices to find a function χ ∈ L∞ (R) such that Fχ|(0, ∞) = k. Define χ as follows:
πi, t > 0, χ(t) = −πi, t < 0.
8. Hankel Operators as Integral Operators on the Semi-Axis
Let us prove that
∞
< Fχ, f >= 0
f (t) − f (−t) dt, t
which would imply that Fχ|(0, ∞) = right-hand side belongs to L1 ). Put πi, −πi, χn (t) = 0,
f ∈ D,
55
(8.17)
k (note that the integrand on the 0 < t < n, −n < t < 0, otherwise,
where n > 0. Clearly, χn → χ in the weak topology σ(D, D ). Thus it remains to prove that < Fχn , f > converges to the right-hand side of (8.17) for any f ∈ D. We have n
0 1 − cos 2πnt −2πits −2πits (Fχn )(t) = πi e ds − e ds = . t 0 −n It follows that
< Fχn , f > =
f (t)(1 − cos 2πnt) dt t
R ∞
=
0
(f (t) − f (−t))(1 − cos 2πnt) dt, t
which tends to the right-hand side of (8.17) by the Riemann–Lebesgue lemma. By Theorem 8.9, Γ has Hankel matrix in the basis {Fξn }n≥0 . Let us find its entries. Put ψ = −χ. Then it follows from (8.14) that Gq = FHψ F ∗ , where q(t) = k(−t), t < 0. By Theorem 8.9, (Γ Fξn , Fξm ) = −ϕ(−n ˆ − m − 1), where ϕ = ψ ◦ ω. Clearly,
ϕ(ζ) = It is easy to see that
πi, Im ζ > 0, −πi, Im ζ < 0.
2 j,
j odd, 0, j even. Thus Γ has the following matrix in the basis {Fξn }n≥0 : 1 0 13 0 15 · · · 0 1 0 1 0 ··· 1 3 1 5 1 3 01 5 01 7 · · · 2 0 . 1 5 01 7 01 · · · 5 0 7 0 9 ··· .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . . ϕ(j) ˆ =
Clearly, this is the matrix on the right-hand side of (7.9).
(8.18)
56
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
Theorem 8.14. Let Γ be the Carleman operator. Then Γ = Γ e = π. Proof. Clearly, Γ = Hϕ and Γ e = Hϕ e , where ϕ is defined by (8.18). The result now follows from Theorem 5.18.
Concluding Remarks Hankel matrices appeared in the paper by Hankel [1] who studied determinants of finite Hankel matrices. They were used on numerous occasions in the study of moment problems, orthogonal polynomials (see Akhiezer [1], Szeg¨ o [1]). The modern period of the study of Hankel operators begins with the paper Nehari [1], where the bounded Hankel matrices were characterized (see Theorem 1.1). The Fefferman characterization of BM O found in Fefferman [1] (see also Fefferman and Stein [1]) shed a new light on Hankel operators. Theorem 1.4 is taken from Adamyan, Arov, and Krein [1]. Note that earlier several authors studied the problem of best approximations of continuous functions on T by bounded analytic functions in D. S.Ya. Khavinson [1] proved that for a continuous function on T the best approximation is unique. We also mention here the paper Rogosinski and Shapiro [1] in which the authors rediscovered the results of Khavinson and constructed a function with different best approximations. The example of a function with different best approximations given in §1 is taken from J.L. Walsh [1], Ch. X, §3 (see also Sarason [1]). Commutators Cϕ were studied by many authors, see e.g., Coifman, Rochberg, and Weiss [1], where the authors considered commutators in the case of several variables. We also mention here the paper Treil and Volberg [1], where a fixed point approach to the Nehari problem was given. Theorem 2.1 is due to Sarason [1]. It is a special case of the Sz.-Nagy– Foias commutant lifting theorem (see Appendix 1.5). The approach given in §2 is due to N.K. Nikol’skii (see N.K. Nikol’skii [1]). Formula (2.9) is also due to N.K. Nikol’skii [1]. Theorem 2.5 is a special case of the Douglas– Rudin theorem (Douglas and Rudin [1]); it can be found in Douglas [2]. The description of the partially isometric Hankel operators (Theorem 2.6) is taken from Power [2]. Theorem 2.7 was obtained by Fuhrmann [1], [3]. Theorem 2.8 is due to Clark [3]. The characterization of the finite rank Hankel matrices was obtained in Kronecker [1]. The second proof is taken from Sarason [5]; it was suggested by Axler. The Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem was studied independently by Nevanlinna [1] and Pick [1]. The Carath´eodory–Fej´er problem was studied in Carath´eodory and Fej´er [1].
Concluding Remarks
57
The Hartman theorem (Theorem 5.5) was obtained in Hartman [1]. Theorem 5.1 was obtained in Sarason [1]. It is amusing that the fact that H ∞ +C is closed in L∞ follows immediately from the Hartman theorem and the fact that the set of compact operators is closed in the space of bounded linear operators. However, in this book we use the Sarason theorem to prove the Hartman theorem. The essential norm of a Hankel operator (see Theorem 5.4) was computed in Adamyan, Arov, and Krein [1]. The equivalence of (i) and (ii) in Theorem 5.10 was established in Sarason [1]. The class V M O was introduced in Sarason [4]. Theorem 5.11 is essentially due to Clark [2]. The results on approximation by compact Hankel operators were obtained in Axler, Berg, Jewell, and Shields [1]. These results give a complete solution to a problem posed in Adamyan, Arov, and Krein [5]. Another solution to the Adamyan–Arov–Krein problem (based on the notion of M -ideal) was given by Luecking [1]. Theorem 5.17 was found in Douglas and Sarason [1], while Theorem 5.18 was obtained in Bonsall and Gillespie [1]. The factorization theorem for L∞ functions (Theorem 5.20) is due to Axler [1]. Theorems 6.1 and 6.2 were published in Bonsall [1], [2], though they were known before to some experts. The Hamburger theorem (Theorem 7.1) was established in Hamburger [1]. The approach based on self-adjoint extensions of symmetric operators can be found in Akhiezer [1]. Our approach is taken from Sarason [6]. Theorems 7.1 and 7.2 are obtained in Widom [3]. Theorems 7.4 and 7.5 can be found in Power [2]. The equivalence of the operators Γ k and the Hankel operators is well known; see Power [2] for some related results and see Devinatz [2] for similar results on Wiener–Hopf operators. The Carleman operator was studied in Carleman [1]. In connection with the material of §8 we would like to offer the following exercise. Exercise. Let k(x) = e−x /x, x > 0. Prove that Γ k is bounded on L2 (R+ ) and is unitarily equivalent to the Hankel operator with Hilbert matrix. Let us mention here the following boundedness criterion for Hankel operators (see Bonsall [4], and Holland and D. Walsh [1]). For ζ ∈ T consider the following polynomials: un,ζ = n−1/2 def
n−1
ζ j zj ,
j=0
Then the following are equivalent: (i) Hϕ is bounded; (ii) sup Hϕ un,ζ < ∞; n>0, ζ∈T
(iii)
sup n>0, ζ∈T
Hϕ vn,ζ < ∞.
vn,ζ = n−1/2 def
2n−1 j=n
ζ j zj .
58
Chapter 1. An Introduction to Hankel Operators
In Bonsall [1] it was shown that for a sequence {aj }j≥0 of nonnegative numbers the Hankel matrix {αj+k }j,k≥0 is bounded if and only if n−1 2 ∞ 1 sup αj+k < ∞. n>0 n j=0 k=0
This is also equivalent to the condition n−1 2 ∞ αjn+k < ∞. sup n>0
j=1
k=0
The fact that thej last inequality for nonnegative αj is equivalent to the condition αj z ∈ BM O is an unpublished theorem of C. Fefferman; its j≥0
proof is contained in Bonsall [1]. We would like to mention here a series of papers by Arocena, Cotlar, and Sadosky (see Arocena [1], Arocena and Cotlar [1], Cotlar and Sadosky [1], and Arocena, Cotlar, and Sadosky [1]). In those papers the authors develop an interesting theory of generalized Toeplitz kernels which generalizes the Nehari theory for Hankel matrices. Let K : Z × Z :→ C be a Toepliz kernel, i.e., K(i + 1, j + 1) = K(i, j), i, j ∈ Z, which is positive semidefinite, i.e., K(i, j)xi x ¯j ≥ 0 i,j∈Z
for any finitely supported sequence {xj }j∈Z of complex numbers. Then by the F. Riesz–Herglotz theorem (see Riesz and Sz.-Nagy [1], §53) there exists a positive Borel measure µ on T such that µ ˆ(n) = K(j + n, j), j ∈ Z. Suppose now that K is a positive semidefinite generalized Toeplitz kernel, i.e., K(i + 1, j + 1) = K(i, j), i, j ∈ Z, i = −1, j = −1. Then there are sequences {kj+ }j∈Z , {kj− }j∈Z , {kj+− }j>0 , and {kj−+ }j<0 such that + ki−j , (i, j) ∈ Z+ × Z+ , k − , (i, j) ∈ Z− × Z− , i−j K(i, j) = +− ki−j , (i, j) ∈ Z+ × Z− , −+ ki−j , (i, j) ∈ Z− × Z+ , −+ and kj+− = k−j , j > 0. Here Z− = Z \ Z+ . − µ µ−+ If µ = is a positive matrix Borel measure on T, then µ−+ µ+ we can put def
k + (j) = µ+ (j), k +− (j) = µ+− (j),
k − (j) = µ− (j),
j ∈ Z+ ,
k −+ (−j) = µ−+ (−j),
j < 0,
Concluding Remarks
59
and obtain a positive semidefinite generalized Toeplitz kernel. We say that this generalized Toeplitz kernel is determined by the matrix µ. Obviously, the measures µ+ and µ− are uniquely determined by the generalized Toeplitz kernel while only the Fourier coefficients µ ˆ−+ (n) with n < 0 are −+ is determined up to a function in the Hardy uniquely determined. Thus µ class H 1 . The main result obtained in the papers by Arocena, Cotlar, and Sadosky mentioned above says that each positive semidefinite generalized Toeplitz kernel is determined by a positive matrix measure. This theorem generalizes the Nehari theorem. Indeed, let {αi+j }i≥0,j≥1 be a bounded Hankel matrix and let c = {αi+j }i≥0,j≥1 . Put
c, j = 0, k + (j) = k − (j) = and k −+ (j) = k +− (−j) = αj , j > 0. 0, j = 0, It is easy to see that the corresponding generalized Toeplitz kernel is positive semi-definite, and so it is determined by a positive matrix measure µ− µ−+ . Since µ ≥ O, it follows that µ−+ is absolutely conµ= µ−+ µ+ tinuous with respect to Lebesgue measure, dµ = ϕdm, ϕ ∈ L∞ , ϕ∞ ≤ c, and ϕ(−j) ˆ = αj , j > 0. The authors also found other interesting applications; in particular, they obtained two weight inequalities for the operator of harmonic conjugation. Let us also mention the Axler–Chang–Sarason–Volberg theorem that characterizes the compact operators of the form Hψ∗ Hϕ , ϕ, ψ ∈ L∞ : the operator Hψ∗ Hϕ is compact if and only if H ∞ [ϕ] ∩ H ∞ [ψ] ⊂ H ∞ + C. Here H ∞ [ϕ] is the smallest closed subalgebra of L∞ that contains ϕ. The part “if” was obtained in Axler, Chang, and Sarason [1], while the part “only if” was obtained in Volberg [1]. We conclude this chapter with the following list of books and survey articles that discuss Hankel operators: Ando [1], Khrushch¨ev and Peller [2], N.K. Nikol’skii [2], [3], [4], Partington [1], Peetre [2], Peller [23], Peller and Khrushch¨ev [1], Power [2], Sarason [5], and Zhu [1].
2 Vectorial Hankel Operators
In this chapter we study Hankel operators on spaces of vector functions. We prove in §2 a generalization of the Nehari theorem which describes the bounded block Hankel matrices of the form {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 , where the Ωj are bounded linear operators from a Hilbert space H to another Hilbert space K. The proof is based on a more general result on completing matrix contractions. This result is obtained in §1. Namely, we obtain in §1 a necessary and sufficient condition on Hilbert space operators A, B, and Cfor the ex A B istence a Hilbert space operator Z such that the block matrix C Z is a contraction (i.e., has norm at most 1). Moreover, we describe in §1 all solutions of this completion problem. Note that the results of §2 will be used in Chapter 5 to parametrize all solutions of the Nehari problem. In §3 we give an alternative approach to the problem of boundedness of vectorial Hankel operators. This approach is based on the Sz.-Nagy–Foias commutant lifting theorem. Section 4 is devoted to the description of the compact vectorial Hankel operators. We obtain an analog of the Hartman theorem. In §5 we introduce the important notion of a Blaschke–Potapov product, we give a description of the finite rank vectorial Hankel operators, and we obtain an explicit formula for the rank of such operators. Finally, in §6 we discuss relationships between vectorial Hankel operators and imbedding theorems.
62
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
1. Completing Matrix Contractions This section is devoted to the following problem. Let H, K be Hilbert spaces, A a bounded linear operator on H, B a bounded linear operator from K to H, and C a bounded linear operator from H to K. The problem is to find out under which conditions there exists a bounded linear operator Z on K such that the operator A B QZ = (1.1) C Z on H ⊕ K is a contraction, that is, QZ ≤ 1. It is easy to see that if the problem is solvable, then the operators A A B and (1.2) C from H to H ⊕ K and from H ⊕ K to H, respectively, are contractions. It turns out that the converse is also true. Theorem 1.1. Let H, K be Hilbert spaces, A : H → H, B : K → H, and C : H → K bounded linear operators. There is an operator Z : K → K for which the operator QZ defined by (1.1) is a contraction on H ⊕ K if and only if A A B ≤ 1. (1.3) C ≤ 1 and Another problem we shall consider here is to describe all operators Z on K for which QZ is a contraction. Clearly, the second problem is meaningful only under the condition (1.3). To state the description we need some preliminaries. Lemma 1.2. Let H, H1 , and H2 be Hilbert spaces, and let T : H1 → H and R : H2 → H be bounded linear operators. Then T T ∗ ≤ RR∗ if and only if there exists a contraction Q : H1 → H2 such that T = RQ. Proof. Suppose that T = RQ and Q ≤ 1. We have (T T ∗ x, x)
=
(RQQ∗ R∗ x, x) = (Q∗ R∗ x, Q∗ R∗ x)
= Q∗ R∗ x2 ≤ R∗ x2 = (RR∗ x, x). Conversely, assume that T T ∗ ≤ RR∗ . We define the operator L on Range R∗ as follows: LR∗ x = T ∗ x, x ∈ H2 . The inequality T T ∗ ≤ RR∗ implies that L is well-defined on Range R∗ and L ≤ 1 on Range R∗ . We can extend L by continuity to clos Range R∗ and put L Ker R = L (Range R∗ )⊥ = O. Set Q = L∗ . Clearly T = RQ. For a contraction A : H1 → H2 the defect operator DA is defined on H1 by DA = (I − A∗ A)1/2 . It is also convenient besides DA to consider
1. Completing Matrix Contractions
63
˜ such that D∗ DA = I − A∗ A, where H ˜ is other operators DA : H1 → H A a Hilbert space. In this case DA = V DA for some isometry V defined on clos Range DA . ˜ be Hilbert spaces, A : H → H, B : K → H Lemma 1.3. Let H, K, H ˜ be an operator such linear operators such that A ≤ 1. Let DA∗ : H → H ∗ ∗ ∗ D = I − A A . Then that DA ∗ A A B ≤1 (1.4) ∗ ˜ if and only if B = DA ∗ K for a contraction K : K → H. Proof. It is easy to see that (1.4) is equivalent to the fact that A∗ A B ≤ IH , B∗ ∗ which means that AA∗ + BB ∗ ≤ I or, which is the same, BB ∗ ≤ DA ∗ DA∗ . ∗ By Lemma 1.2, this is equivalent to the fact that B = DA K for some ∗ ˜ contraction K : K → H.
Remark. The conclusion of the lemma is valid if DA∗ = DA∗ = (I − AA∗ )1/2 . It is easy to see that we can choose a contraction K : K → H such that Range K ⊂ clos Range(I − AA∗ ) and B = DA∗ K. Clearly, such a contraction K is unique. ˜ be Hilbert spaces and let A : H → H, Lemma 1.4. Let H, K, H ˜ be an C : H → K be linear operators such that A ≤ 1. Let DA : H → H ∗ ∗ operator such that DA DA = I − A A. Then A (1.5) C ≤1 ˜ → K. if and only if C = LDA for some contraction L : H Proof. The result follows from Lemma 1.3, since (1.5) is equivalent to the inequality ∗ A C ∗ ≤ 1. Remark. As in Lemma 1.3 we can take DA = DA = (I − A∗ A)1/2 . Clearly, one can find a contraction L : H → K such that ⊥ L (Range(I − A∗ A)) = O and C = LDA . As in Lemma 1.3 it is easy to see that such a contraction L is unique. Now we are in a position to state the description of those operators Z : K → K for which the operator QZ defined by (1.1) is a contraction. As we have already observed, the operators in (1.2) are contractions. Therefore (see the Remarks after Lemmas 1.3 and 1.4) there exist unique contractions K : K → H and L : H → K such that Range K ⊂ clos Range(I − AA∗ ),
B = DA∗ K,
(1.6)
64
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
⊥ L (Range(I − A∗ A)) = O,
C = LDA .
(1.7)
Theorem 1.5. Let H, K be Hilbert spaces, A : H → H, B : K → H, and C : H → K bounded linear operators satisfying (1.3). Let K : K → H and L : H → K be the operators satisfying (1.6) and (1.7). If Z : K → K is a bounded linear operator, then the operator QZ defined by (1.1) is a contraction if and only if Z admits a representation Z = −LA∗ K + DL∗ M DK ,
(1.8)
where M is a contraction on K. Note that we may always assume that M (Range DK )⊥ = O and Range M ⊂ clos Range DL∗ .
(1.9)
If these two conditions are satisfied, then Z determines M uniquely, and so the contractions M satisfying (1.9) parametrize the solutions Z. It is easy to see that Theorem 1.1 follows from Theorem 1.5. Indeed, we can always take M = O. To prove Theorem 1.5, we need one more lemma. Lemma 1.6. Let A, B be as above and let K : K → H be an operator satisfying (1.6). Then the operator DA −A∗ K D(AB) = (1.10) O DK satisfies ∗ D(AB) = IH⊕K − D(AB)
A∗ B∗
A
B
.
Proof. We have ∗ ∗ DA −A∗ K A DA −A∗ K A B + ∗ O DK O DK B ∗ ∗ DA O DA −A K A A B = + ∗ ∗ B −K A DK O DK ∗ 2 ∗ −DA A K A A A∗ B DA + = 2 −K ∗ ADA B∗A B∗B K ∗ AA∗ K + DK −DA A∗ K IH − A∗ A = 2 K ∗ K + DK − K ∗ DA∗ DA∗ K −K ∗ ADA ∗ A A A∗ B + . B∗A B∗B Let us show that DA A∗ = A∗ DA∗ . We have (I −A∗ A)A∗ = A∗ (I −AA∗ ). It follows that ϕ(I − A∗ A)A∗ = A∗ ϕ(I − AA∗ ) for any polynomial ϕ, so the same equality holds for any continuous function ϕ. If we take ϕ(t) = t1/2 , t ≥ 0, we obtain DA A∗ = A∗ DA∗ . Similarly, DA∗ A = ADA .
1. Completing Matrix Contractions
Consequently,
∗ D(AB) D(AB)
=
IH − A∗ A −B ∗ A
−A∗ B I − B∗B
+
+
A∗ B∗
A∗ A B∗A
A
A∗ B B∗B
65
B
=
IH O
O IH
.
Proof of Theorem 1.5. Suppose that QZ ≤ 1. By Lemma 1.2 C Z = X Y D(AB) , where X Y is a contraction from H ⊕ K to K and D(AB) is defined by (1.10). Then C = XDA . Let P be the orthogonal projection from H ˜ = XP . Clearly, C = XD ˜ A and by the onto clos Range(I − A∗ A). Put X ˜ Remark after Lemma 1.4, X = L. It is easy to see that C Z = L Y D(AB) . (1.11) Clearly,
L Y
=
X
Y
P O
O IH
,
which proves that L Y is a contraction. Then by Lemma 1.3, the operator Y admits a representation Y = DL∗ M for a contraction M on K. Formula (1.8) follows now immediately from (1.11). Suppose that Z satisfies (1.8), where M is a contraction on K. Then it is easy to see that A DA∗ O I O A B I O O DA −A∗ O O K . = C Z O L DL∗ O O M O DK (1.12) The result follows from the fact that all factors on the right-hand side of (1.12) are contractions, which is a consequence of the following lemma. Lemma 1.7. Let T be a contraction on Hilbert space. Then the operator
T DT
DT ∗ −T ∗
is unitary. Proof. We have
=
T DT
DT ∗ −T ∗
T ∗ T + DT2 DT ∗ T − T D T
∗
T DT
DT ∗ −T ∗
T ∗ DT ∗ − DT T ∗ DT2 ∗ + T T ∗
.
66
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
It has been shown in the proof of Lemma 1.6 that T ∗ DT ∗ = DT T ∗ and T DT = DT ∗ T . Thus ∗ T DT ∗ I O T DT ∗ = . DT −T ∗ DT −T ∗ O I Similarly,
T DT
DT ∗ −T ∗
T DT
DT ∗ −T ∗
∗
=
I O O I
.
The following uniqueness criterion is an immediate consequence of Theorem 1.5. Corollary 1.8. The following statements are equivalent: (i) there is only one operator Z for which QZ ≤ 1; (ii) either DL∗ = O or DK = O; (iii) either K is an isometry or L∗ is an isometry. Remark. The same results are valid if A is an operator from H1 to H2 , B is an operator from K1 to H2 , C is an operator from H1 to K2 , and Z is an operator from K1 to K2 , where H1 , H2 , K1 , K2 are Hilbert spaces. The proof given above works in this more general situation.
2. Bounded Block Hankel Matrices Let H and K be separable Hilbert spaces and Ω = {Ωj }j≥0 a sequence of bounded linear operators from H to K. Consider the block matrix ΓΩ = {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 .
(2.1)
Such matrices are called block Hankel matrices. In the case H = K = C the matrix ΓΩ can be considered as a Hankel matrix with scalar entries. The main aim of this section is to obtain an analog of the Nehari theorem for block Hankel matrices, that is to describe the block Hankel matrices that determine bounded operators from 2 (H) to 2 (K). There are several different approaches to this problem. Here we use the one based on the problem of completing matrix contractions that was considered in §1. In §3 we present another approach based on the Sz.-Nagy–Foias commutant lifting theorem. As in the scalar case we consider a realization of Hankel operators as operators on the Hardy class H 2 (H) of functions with values in a Hilbert space H. We study elementary properties of symbols with minimal norm and maximizing vectors of vectorial Hankel operators. Denote by B(H, K) the space of bounded linear operators from H to K and by L∞ (B(H, K)) the space of bounded weakly measurable B(H, K)-valued functions. In the case H = K we shall use the notation
2. Bounded Block Hankel Matrices
67
B(H) = B(H, H). If Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)), we define the Fourier coefficients ˆ Φ(n), n ∈ Z, of Φ as usual:
ˆ Φ(n) = ζ¯n Φ(ζ)dm(ζ). T
ˆ Clearly, Φ(n) ∈ B(H, K), n ∈ Z. Theorem 2.1. Let {Ωj }j≥0 be a sequence of bounded linear operators from H to K. The block Hankel matrix ΓΩ determines a bounded linear operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K) if and only if there exists a function Φ in L∞ (B(H, K)) such that ˆ Ωn = Φ(n), In this case
n ≥ 0.
(2.2)
ˆ = Ωn , n ≥ 0 . ΓΩ = inf ΦL∞ (B(H,K)) : Φ(n)
As in the scalar case we can consider vectorial Hankel operators as operators on the Hardy class H 2 of vector-valued functions. If H is a separable Hilbert space, the Hardy class H 2 (H) is defined as follows: H 2 (H) = {F ∈ L2 (H) : Fˆ (n) = 0, n < 0}, where L2 (H) is the space of weakly measurable H-valued functions F for which
2 F L2 (H) = F (ζ)2H dm(ζ) < ∞. T
2 (H) = L2 (H) H 2 (H). Let K be another separable Hilbert space Put H− and let Ψ be a function in L2s (B(H, K)) (see Appendix 2.3), i.e.,
Ψ(ζ)x2K dm(ζ) < ∞ for any x ∈ H. (2.3) T
Recall that for functions Ψ satisfying (2.3) the Fourier coefficients ˆ Ψ(n) ∈ B(H, K) are defined by
ˆ Ψ(n)x = ζ¯n Ψ(ζ)x dm(ζ), n ∈ Z, x ∈ H. T
We can also define for such functions Ψ the Hankel operator 2 HΨ : H 2 (H) → H− (K) on the set of polynomials in H 2 (H) by HΨ F = P− ΨF,
F ∈ H 2 (H),
(2.4)
where as in the scalar case we denote by P+ and P− the orthogonal pro2 jections onto H 2 (H) and H− (K). If Ψ is an operator function satisfying (2.3), we denote by P− Ψ and P+ Ψ the functions ((P− Ψ)(ζ)) x = (P− (Ψx)) (ζ),
ζ ∈ T, x ∈ H,
((P+ Ψ)(ζ)) x = (P+ (Ψx)) (ζ),
ζ ∈ T, x ∈ H.
68
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
We can identify in a natural way 2 (H) with H 2 (H): z k xk . {xk }k≥0 ∈ 2 (H) → k≥0
As in the scalar case it is easy to see that Theorem 2.1 is equivalent to the following statement in which def ˆ H ∞ (B(H, K)) = Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) : Φ(n) = 0, n < 0 . Theorem 2.2. Let Ψ be a B(H, K)-valued function that satisfies (2.3). Then the operator HΨ defined by (2.4) extends to a bounded operator on H 2 (H) if and only if there exists a function Φ in L∞ (B(H, K)) such that ˆ ˆ Φ(n) = Ψ(n),
n < 0,
and HΨ = distL∞ (Φ, H ∞ (B(H, K)) . Proof of Theorem 2.1. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) and ΓΩ = {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 be the block Hankel matrix defined by (2.1) and (2.2). Let us show that ΓΩ is a bounded operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K) and ΓΩ ≤ ΦL∞ . Put Ψ(z) = z¯Φ(¯ z ). It is easy to see that ΓΩ is bounded on 2 (H) if and only if HΨ is bounded on H 2 (H) and ΓΩ = HΨ . We have HΨ F L2 (K) = P− ΨF L2 (K) ≤ ΨF L2 (K) ≤ ΨL∞ F H 2 (K) . Hence, HΨ ≤ ΨL∞ = ΦL∞ . To show the converse, we extend the sequence {Ωj }j≥0 to a two-sided sequence {Ωj }j∈Z so that the block matrix Λ = {Ωj+k }j∈Z,k≥0 determines a bounded operator from 2 (H) to 2Z (K), where 2Z (K) = x = {xj }j∈Z : xj ∈ K, x22 (K) = xj 2K < ∞ . Z j∈Z
Moreover, we show that Λ = ΓΩ . Let us first find Ω−1 . Consider the matrix {Ωj+k }j≥−1,k≥0 where Ω−1 = Z is an unknown operator: Z Ω0 Ω1 Ω2 · · · Ω0 Ω1 Ω2 Ω3 · · · Ω1 Ω2 Ω3 Ω4 · · · (2.5) . Ω2 Ω3 Ω4 Ω5 · · · .. .. .. .. .. . . . . .
2. Bounded Block Hankel Matrices
Let
Ω1 Ω2 Ω3 .. .
A=
C=
Ω0
Ω2 Ω3 Ω4 .. . Ω1
Ω3 Ω4 Ω5 .. . Ω2
··· ··· ··· .. . ···
,
B=
Ω0 Ω1 Ω2 .. .
69
,
.
The matrix in (2.5) can be identified with the matrix Z C . B A Clearly, B
A = ΓΩ ,
C A = ΓΩ .
By Theorem 1.1 and the Remark at the end of §1, there exists an operator Z such that Z C B A = ΓΩ . Put Ω−1 = Z. We have {Ωj+k }j≤−1,k≥0 = ΓΩ . If we continue this process, we can find a sequence of operators {Ωj }j≤−1 such that for any m ∈ Z+ {Ωj+k }j≤−m,k≥0 = ΓΩ . Given m ∈ Z+ , consider the matrix Λm = {Tjk }j∈Z,k≥0 , Tjk = Ωj+k , j ≥ −m, and Tjk = O, j < −m. Clearly, Λ = ΓΩ and the sequence {Λm }m≥1 converges to Λ = {Ωj+k }j∈Z,k≥0 in the weak operator topology. Thus Λ = ΓΩ . We can now consider the block matrix Q = {Ωj+k }j,k∈Z . As above it is easy to see that {Ωj+k }j∈Z,k≥−m = ΓΩ and Q = ΓΩ . Thus Q determines a bounded operator from 2Z (H) to 2Z (K). Let us identify 2Z (H) with L2 (H) and 2Z (K) with L2 (K) in the standard way: {xj }j∈Z → z j xj . j∈Z
We can consider now the operator Q as an operator from L2 (H) to L2 (K). Let x ∈ H and let x be the constant H-valued function on T identically equal to x. Then ζ k Ωk x (Qx)(ζ) = k∈Z
70
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
and Qx ∈ L2 (K). Since K is separable, we can define a B(H, K)-valued function Φ almost everywhere on T such that Φ(ζ)x = ζ k Ωk x, a.e. k∈Z
It is easy to see that
(QF )(ζ) = Φ(ζ)F ζ¯ ,
a.e.
(2.6)
for any trigonometric polynomial F with coefficients in H. Now let M be multiplication by Φ defined on the set of trigonometric polynomials in L2 (H) by (M F )(ζ) = Φ(ζ)F (ζ). It is easy to see from (2.6) that M extends to a bounded operator from L2 (H) to L2 (K) and its norm is equal to Q. To prove that Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) and ΦL∞ ≤ Q, it is sufficient to show that ess sup |(Φ(ζ)x, y)| ≤ Q ζ∈T
for any x ∈ H and y ∈ K with x ≤ 1 and y ≤ 1. Put ϕ(ζ) = (Φ(ζ)x, y), ζ ∈ T. Clearly, multiplication by the scalar function ϕ defined on the set of trigonometric polynomial extends to a bounded operator on L2 . It is also obvious that ϕ ∈ L2 , and so multiplication by ϕ is a bounded operator from L2 to L1 . By continuity, multiplication by ϕ is a bounded operator on L2 . It is easy to see now that ϕL∞ ≤ M = Q, which completes the proof. Now let Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)). As in the scalar case it is easy to use a compactness argument to show that there exists a function F ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)) such that HΦ = Φ − F L∞ (B(H,K)) . In other words, Φ − F is a symbol of HΦ of minimal norm. Suppose that HΦ has a maximizing vector f ∈ H 2 (H), i.e., f is a nonzero vector function in H 2 (H) such that HΦ f H−2 (Cm ) = HΦ · f H 2 (Cn ) . We obtain a result similar to Theorem 1.1.4. However, unlike the scalar case HΦ may have infinitely many symbols of minimal norm (we will discuss this in more detail in Chapter 14). Theorem 2.3. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (H, K) and F ∈ H ∞ (H, K) satisfy Φ − F L∞ (B(H,K)) = HΦ > 0. Suppose that f ∈ H 2 (H) is a maximizing vector of HΦ . Then 2 (K), (Φ − F )(ζ)B(H,K) = HΦ for almost all ζ ∈ T, (Φ − F )f ∈ H− and f (ζ) is a maximizing vector of (Φ − F )(ζ) almost everywhere on T. If g = HΦ −1 HΦ f , then f (ζ)H = g(ζ)K for almost all ζ ∈ T.
(2.7)
3. Hankel Operators and the Commutant Lifting Theorem
71
Proof. Without loss of generality we may assume that HΦ = 1. We have f 2 = HΦ f 2 = P− (Φ − F )f 2 ≤ (Φ − F )f 2 ≤ f 2 . Hence, P− (Φ − F )f 2 = (Φ − F )f 2 = f 2 . 2 (K). Since f (ζ) = O and The first equality means that (Φ − F )f ∈ H− (Φ − F )(ζ) ≤ 1 almost everywhere on T, it follows from the second equality that (Φ−F )(ζ) = 1 and f (ζ) is a maximizing vector of (Φ−F )(ζ) for almost all ζ ∈ T. Therefore g(ζ) is a maximizing vector of (Φ − F )∗ (ζ) for almost all ζ ∈ T. Hence, g(ζ)K = HΦ −1 (Φ − F )∗ (ζ)B(K,H) f (ζ)H = f (ζ)H , which proves (2.7). Remark. We can also consider vectorial Hankel operators on the Hardy class H 2 (C+ , H) of vector-valued functions on the upper half-plane C+ (see §1.8) and integral operators Γ Ξ on spaces of vector functions on R+ (see §1.8). The same reasoning as in §1.8 shows that bonded operators Γ Ξ have block Hankel matrices with respect to the block bases of vector-valued Laguerre polynomials.
3. Hankel Operators and the Commutant Lifting Theorem In this section we give an alternative approach to the boundedness problem for vectorial Hankel operators. We show that Theorem 2.1 can be deduced from the commutant lifting theorem. On the other hand, we show that in an important special case the commutant lifting theorem can be deduced from the vector version of the Nehari theorem (Theorem 2.1). An alternative proof of Theorem 2.1. We give a proof of the nontrivial part of Theorem 2.1. Namely, we prove that if ΓΩ = {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 determines a bounded operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K), then there exists a function ˆ = Ωj , j ∈ Z+ , and ΦL∞ = ΓΩ . Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) such that Φ(j) We denote by SH the shift operator on 2 (H): SH (x0 , x1 , · · · ) = (O, x0 , x1 , · · · ),
(x0 , x1 , · · · ) ∈ 2 (H).
Similarly, we denote by SK the shift operator on 2 (K). It is easy to see that ∗ ΓΩ = ΓΩ SH SK
(3.1)
and both operators in (3.1) are given by the block matrix {Ωj+k+1 }j,k≥0 . ∗ Equality (3.1) means that the operator ΓΩ intertwines the contractions SK and SH .
72
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
Consider now the bilateral shift SH on the space 2Z (H) of two-sided sequences: SH {xj }j∈Z = {xj−1 }j∈Z , {xj }j∈Z ∈ 2 (H). Similarly, we can define the bilateral shift SK on the space 2Z (K). We identify in a natural way the spaces 2 (H) and 2 (K) with subspaces of 2Z (H) and 2Z (K). It is easy to see that under these identifications the ∗ is operator SH is a minimal unitary dilation of SH while the operator SK ∗ a minimal unitary dilation of SK . Now we are in a position to apply the commutant lifting theorem (see Appendix 1.5), which implies that there exists an operator R : 2 (H) → 2 (K) such that ∗ SK R = RSH ,
P2 (K) R2 (H) = ΓΩ ,
(3.2) (3.3)
and R = ΓΩ
(3.4)
(as usual P2 (K) is the orthogonal projection onto 2 (K)). It follows easily from (3.2) that R has a block matrix representation in the form {Rj+k }j,k∈Z , where the Rj are bounded linear operators from H to K. It is easy to see from (3.3) that Rj = Ωj , j ∈ Z+ . The rest of the proof is the same as in the proof of Theorem 2.1 given in §2. As in that proof we can find a function Φ in L∞ (B(H, K)) such ˆ that Φ(j) = Rj , j ∈ Z, and ΦL∞ = R. It follows now from (3.4) that ΦL∞ = ΓΩ . We are going to consider now an important special case of the commutant lifting theorem and deduce it from the vector version of the Nehari theorem. Let H be a Hilbert space and let Θ ∈ H ∞ (B(H)) be an operator inner function such that Θ(ζ) is a unitary operator for almost all ζ ∈ T. On the space def KΘ = H 2 (H) ΘH 2 (H) we consider the compression S[Θ] of the shift operator SH (multiplication by z) on H 2 (H) defined by S[Θ] = PΘ SH KΘ , where PΘ is the orthogonal projection onto KΘ . In the case of scalar functions such operators have been considered in §1.2. As in the scalar case it is easy to see that PΘ f = ΘP− Θ∗ f,
f ∈ H 2 (H).
Recall that T is unitary equivalent to an operator S[Θ] for some unitaryvalued operator inner function Θ if and only if T is a C00 -contraction on Hilbert space (i.e., T ≤ 1 and lim T n = lim (T ∗ )n = O in the strong n→∞
operator topology) (see Appendix 1.6).
n→∞
3. Hankel Operators and the Commutant Lifting Theorem
73
The following theorem is a special case of the commutant lifting theorem (see Appendix 1.5). It will be deduced from the vector version of the Nehari theorem (Theorem 2.1). Recall that the case of scalar functions has been considered in §1.2 (Theorem 1.2.1). Theorem 3.1. Let H be a Hilbert space and let Θ ∈ H ∞ (B(H)) be a unitary-valued operator inner function. If R commutes with S[Θ] , then there exists a function Φ ∈ H ∞ (B(H)) such that ΦL∞ = R and Rf = PΘ Φf,
f ∈ KΘ .
The proof of Theorem 3.1 is similar to that of Theorem 1.2.1. 2 (H) by Proof. Define the operator A : H 2 (H) → H− Af = Θ∗ RPΘ f,
f ∈ H 2 (H).
(3.5)
As in Lemma 1.2.2 we prove that A is a Hankel operator. Again, as in the scalar case it is easy to see that A is Hankel if and only if P− zAf = Azf,
f ∈ H 2 (H).
(3.6)
We have P− zAf
= P− zΘ∗ RPΘ f = Θ∗ ΘP− Θ∗ zRPΘ f = Θ∗ PΘ zRPΘ f = Θ∗ S[Θ] RPΘ f.
On the other hand,
Azf = Θ∗ RPΘ zf.
Clearly, for f ∈ ΘH 2 (H) P− zAf = Azf = O. If f ∈ KΘ , then bearing in mind that R and S[Θ] commute, we obtain P− zAf = Θ∗ S[Θ] Rf = Θ∗ RS[Θ] f = Azf, which proves (3.6). By Theorem 2.1, there exists Ψ ∈ L∞ (B(H)) such that ΨL∞ = A 2 (H). Hence, and A = HΨ . It follows from (3.5) that ΘP− ΨH 2 (H) ⊥ H− 2 2 ∞ ΘΨH (H) ⊥ H− (H), and so ΘΨ ∈ H (B(H)). def
Now put Φ = ΘΨ ∈ H ∞ (B(H)). We have Rf = ΘP− Ψf = ΘP− Θ∗ Φf = PΘ Φf,
f ∈ KΘ .
(3.7)
We have ΦL∞ = ΨL∞ = A ≤ R. On the other hand, R ≤ PΘ · ΦL∞ = ΦL∞ . Remark. Formula (3.7) implies that
R = M Θ HΘ ∗ Φ KΘ ,
(3.8)
where MΘ is multiplication by Θ. By (3.5), HΘ∗ Φ ΘH 2 (H) = HΨ ΘH 2 (H) = O. It follows now from (3.8) that the operators R and HΘ∗ Φ have the same metric properties (compactness, singular values, etc.; see §6.9).
74
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
4. Compact Vectorial Hankel Operators Here we obtain an analog of the Hartman theorem for vectorial Hankel operators. In §4.3 we obtain a formula for the essential norm of a vectorial Hankel operator. Let H and K be Hilbert spaces. Denote by H ∞ (B(H, K)) + C(C(H, K)) the subspace of L∞ (B(H, K)), which consists of functions F that admit a representation F = G+H, where G ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)) and H is a continuous function with values in the space C(H, K) of compact operators from H to K. Theorem 4.1. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (H, K)). The following statements are equivalent: (i) the Hankel operator HΦ is compact on H 2 (H); (ii) Φ ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)) + C(C(H, K)); ˆ ˆ (iii) there exists a function Ψ in C(C(H, K)) such that Φ(n) = Ψ(n) for n < 0. It is easy to see that Theorem 4.1 can be reformulated as follows. Theorem 4.2. Let {Ωj }j≥0 be a sequence of bounded linear operators from H to K. Then the block Hankel matrix {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 determines a compact operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K) if and only if there exists a function ˆ Ψ in C(C(H, K)) such that Ψ(n) = Ωn for n ≥ 0. To prove Theorem 4.1, we need a lemma where CA (B(H, K)) denotes the ˆ set of functions Φ ∈ C(B(H, K)) for which Φ(n) = O, n < 0. Lemma 4.3. Let H, K be finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Let Φ ∈ C(B(H, K)). Then distL∞ (Φ, H ∞ (B(H, K))) = distL∞ (Φ, CA (B(H, K))) . The proof of the lemma is exactly the same as that of Lemma 1.5.2. Proof of Theorem 4.1. Clearly, (ii)⇔(iii). The implication (iii)⇒(i) is very easy. Indeed, if Ψ is a trigonometric polynomial with coefficients in ˆ − k)}j≥0,k≥1 C(H, K), then HΨ is compact since the block matrix {Ψ(−j corresponding to HΨ has finitely many nonzero entries, each of which is compact. If Ψ ∈ C(C(H, K)), the result follows from the fact that Ψ can be approximated by trigonometric polynomials with values in C(H, K). Suppose now that HΦ is compact. Let {Pn }n≥1 be a sequence of finite rank orthogonal projections on H such that Pn H ⊂ Pn+1 H and H = clos Pn H. Let {Qn }n≥1 be a sequence of projections on K with n≥1
the same properties. Let Φ1 = Q1 ΦP1 , Φn = Qn ΦPn − Qn−1 ΦPn−1 , n ≥ 2. It is easy to see that HΦ1 = Q1 HΦ P1 ,
HΦn = Qn HΦ Pn − Qn−1 HΦ Pn−1 ,
n ≥ 2,
4. Compact Vectorial Hankel Operators
75
where Pn is the orthogonal projection from L2 (H) onto the subspaces of functions with values in Pn H and Qn is the orthogonal projection from L2 (K) onto the subspace of functions with values in Qn K. Since HΦ is compact, it follows that HΦn → 0 as n → ∞. Therefore it is possible to choose sequences {Pn }n≥1 and {Qn }n≥1 such that HΦn < ∞. n≥1
Clearly, HΦ =
HΦ n .
(4.1)
n≥1
We need the following lemma. Lemma 4.4. Let H and K be finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces and 2 let HΦ be a compact Hankel operator from H 2 (H) to H− (K). Then for any ε > 0 there exists a function Ψ ∈ C(B(H, K)) such that HΦ = HΨ and ΨL∞ ≤ HΦ + ε. Let us first complete the proof of Theorem 4.1 and then prove Lemma 4.4. Consider HΦn H 2 (Pn H) as a Hankel operator from H 2 (Pn H) to 2 (Qn K). It follows from Lemma 4.4 that for any ε > 0 there exists a H− function Ψn ∈ C(B(Pn H, Qn K)) such that HΨn = Qn HΦn H 2 (Pn H) and Ψn ∞ ≤ Φn ∞ + ε2−n . Now put Ψn Pn . Ψ= n≥1
Clearly, Ψn Pn ∈ C(C(H, K)) and Ψn Pn ∞ ≤ Φn ∞ + ε. n≥1
(4.2)
n≥1
It follows from (4.1) that HΨ = HΦ , and it follows from (4.2) that Ψ ∈ C(C(H, K)). Proof of Lemma 4.4. We can assume that H = Cm and K = Cd . Then we can interpret Φ as a matrix function {ϕjk }1≤j≤d,1≤k≤m . It is easy to see that HΦ is compact if and only if so are the Hϕjk for all j, k. By the Hartman theorem (Theorem 1.5.5) for each j, k there exists a function ξjk in C(T) such that Hξjk = Hϕjk . Let Ξ = {ξjk }1≤j≤d,1≤k≤m . Then Ξ ∈ C(B(Cm , Cd )) and HΦ = HΞ . By Theorem 2.2 HΞ = distL∞ (Ξ, H ∞ (B(H, K))) . Since Ξ ∈ C(B(Cm , Cd )), it follows from Lemma 4.3 that for any ε > 0 there exists a function Υ ∈ CA (B(H, K)) such that Ξ − Υ∞ ≤ HΦ + ε. def
Now the function Ψ = Ξ − Υ is desired.
76
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
Remark. It is easy to see that we can choose sequences {Pn }n≥1 and {Qn }n≥1 such that HΦn ≤ HΦ + ε n≥1
for any given positive ε. It follows that if HΦ is a compact vectorial Hankel operator, then for any ε > 0 there exists a function Ψ in C(C(H, K)) such that HΨ = HΦ and Ψ∞ ≤ HΦ + ε.
5. Vectorial Hankel Operators of Finite Rank In this section we obtain an analog of Kronecker’s theorem for vectorial Hankel operators. We shall show that a vectorial Hankel operator has finite rank if and only if it has a rational symbol whose coefficients have finite rank. We shall also obtain a formula for the rank of such operators. However, this formula is considerably more complicated than in the scalar case. First we describe the invariant subspaces of the multiple shift operator (multiplication by z on H 2 (H)) that have finite codimension. To this end we need the notion of a finite Blaschke–Potapov product. Let H be a Hilbert space. A function B in H ∞ (B(H)) is called a finite Blaschke–Potapov product if it admits a factorization B = U B1 B2 · · · Bn , where Bj (z) =
(5.1)
λj − z ¯ j z Pj + (I − Pj ) 1−λ
for some λj in D, orthogonal projections Pj on H, and a unitary operator U . The degree of the Blaschke–Potapov product (5.1) is defined by deg B =
n
rank Pj .
j=1
Lemma 5.1. Let L be an invariant subspace of multiplication by z on H 2 (H). Then L has finite codimension if and only if L = BH 2 (H) for a Blaschke–Potapov product B of finite degree. Moreover, codim L = deg B. Proof. Denote by SH multiplication by z on H 2 (H). Clearly, L⊥ is ∗ an invariant subspace of SH and dim L⊥ = codim L. If dim L⊥ < ∞, ∗ ⊥ ¯ ∈ D. Since Ker(S ∗ − λI) ¯ consists of then SH L has an eigenvalue λ H the functions x ¯ , x ∈ H, 1 − λz
5. Vectorial Hankel Operators of Finite Rank
it follows that Ker
∗ (SH
¯ L⊥ = − λI)
77
x ¯ : x ∈ Hλ , 1 − λz
where Hλ is a finite-dimensional subspace of H. Let z−λ ¯ PHλ + (I − PHλ ), 1 − λz where PHλ is the orthogonal projection onto Hλ . It is easy to see that ∗ ¯ L⊥ = Ker P+ B ∗ , Ker (SH − λI) 1 B1 (z) =
where B ∗1 is multiplication by B1∗ . ∗ whose dimension is Clearly, P+ B ∗1 L⊥ is an invariant subspace of SH ⊥ less than dim L . Therefore we can repeat the above procedure finitely many times and we find that L⊥ = Ker P+ B ∗ , where B is a Blaschke– Potapov product of the form (5.1) and B ∗ is multiplication by B ∗ . Clearly, deg B < ∞. Hence, L = BH 2 (H). Conversely, let B be a Blaschke–Potapov product of the form (5.1). Clearly, multiplication by Bj on H 2 (H) is an isometry and the result will follow from the fact that codim Bj H 2 (H) = rank Pj . Let us show that
H (H) Bj H (H) = 2
2
x ¯ j z : x ∈ Pj H . 1−λ
(5.2)
Indeed, if x ∈ Pj H, F ∈ H 2 (H), we have x x Bj F, = 0, = F, ¯j z z − λj 1−λ 2 since 1/(z − λj ) ∈ H− . Suppose now that G ∈ H 2 (H) and G ⊥ Bj H 2 (H). We have (Bj F, G) = (bPj F, G) + ((I − Pj )F, G) = (F, ¯bPj G + (I − Pj )G) = 0
¯ j z)−1 . Hence, for any F ∈ H 2 (H), where b(z) = (λj − z)(1 − λ ¯bPj G + (I − Pj )G ∈ H 2 (H). Consequently, (I − Pj )G = O, that is, G 2 . takes values in the finite-dimensional space Pj H and ¯bG ∈ H− def 2 2 ¯ Let x ∈ Pj H and let f (z) = (G(z), x). Then f ∈ H and bf ∈ H− . It follows that f ∈ {g ∈ H 2 : H¯b g2 = g2 }.
(5.3)
Since rank H¯b = 1 (see Corollary 1.3.2), the space in (5.3) is one-dimens¯j z ¯ j z , and so f = c/ 1 − λ ional; obviously it contains the function 1/ 1 − λ for some c ∈ C. It is easy to see now that G belongs to the right-hand side of (5.2).
78
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
The following analog of Corollary 1.3.3 describes the vectorial Hankel operators of finite rank. As above H and K are Hilbert spaces. Theorem 5.2. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)). Then HΦ has finite rank if and only if there exists a Blaschke–Potapov product B in H ∞ (B(H)) of finite degree such that ΦB ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)). In this case it is possible to choose B so that deg B = rank HΦ . Proof. Let rank HΦ < ∞. Then Ker HΦ is an invariant subspace of SH of codimension rank HΦ . By Lemma 5.1, Ker HΦ = BH 2 (H), where B is a Blaschke–Potapov product such that deg B = rank HΦ . Clearly, HΦB = O, and so ΦB ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)). Conversely, if ΦB ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)), then HΦ BH 2 (H) = O, and so Ker HΦ has finite codimension. Remark. It can also be shown that HΦ has finite rank if and only if there exists a Blaschke–Potapov product B1 in H ∞ (B(K)) of finite degree such that B1 Φ ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)). Moreover, B1 can be chosen so that deg B1 = rank HΦ . Indeed, let Ψ(z) = (Φ(¯ z ))∗ . Then Ψ ∈ L∞ (B(K, H)), and it is easy to see that rank HΦ = rank HΨ . Therefore by Theorem 5.2, ΨB ∈ H ∞ (B(K, H)) for some Blaschke–Potapov product B in H ∞ (B(K)) of finite degree. Let B1 (z) = (B(¯ z ))∗ . It is easy to show that B1 is a Blaschke–Potapov product ∞ in H (B(K)) and deg B1 = deg B. Clearly, B1 Φ ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)). Theorem 5.2 gives a description of the vectorial Hankel operators of finite rank. However, it is difficult to compute the rank of such an operator by using Theorem 5.2. We conclude this section with a more explicit formula for the rank of a vectorial Hankel operator. To state the result, we need some preliminaries. Let Λ be a finite subset of the unit disc and let Ψ be a rational function of the form Ψ(ζ) =
k(λ) λ∈Λ n=1
Tλ,n , (z − λ)n
Tλ,k(λ) = O,
(5.4)
where the k(λ) are positive integers and Tλ,n ∈ B(H, K), λ ∈ Λ, (j) 1 ≤ n ≤ k(λ). Let us construct by induction on j the operators Tλ,n for 0 ≤ j ≤ k(λ) − n. Put (0)
Tλ,n = Tλ,n ,
(j+1)
Tλ,n
(j)
= Tλ,n PKer T (j)
(j)
+ Tλ,n+1 PRangeT (j)
λ,k(λ)−j
λ,k(λ)−j
∗ ,
(5.5)
where PM denotes the orthogonal projection onto M . Theorem 5.3. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)). Then rank HΦ < ∞ if and only if Ψ = P− Φ admits a representation (5.4), where Λ is a finite set in D and the Tλ,n are finite rank operators from H to K, λ ∈ Λ, 1 ≤ n ≤ k(λ). In
5. Vectorial Hankel Operators of Finite Rank
79
this case rank HΦ =
k(λ)−1 λ∈Λ
(j)
rank Tλ,k(λ)−j ,
(5.6)
j=0
(j)
where the operators Tλ,n are defined by (5.5). 2 Proof. Let S˜ be the compressed shift on H− (K) defined by ˜ = P− zf, Sf
2 f ∈ H− (K).
˜ Let L = Range HΦ . Clearly, L is S-invariant and dim L = rank HΦ . If HΦ has finite rank, there exist a finite set Λ in D and N ∈ Z+ such that L ⊂ span{Ker(S˜ − λI)N : λ ∈ Λ}. Put
k(λ) = min n ∈ Z+ : Ker((S˜ − λI)L)n = Ker((S˜ − λI)L)n+1 .
It is easy to see that
Ker(S˜ − λI)n = span Therefore def
L ⊂ L = span
x : x ∈ K, 1 ≤ m ≤ n . (z − λ)m
x : λ ∈ Λ, x ∈ K, 1 ≤ m ≤ k(λ) . (z − λ)m
Let us now define the operators Tλ,n , λ ∈ Λ, 1 ≤ n ≤ k(λ), by Tλ,n x = (z − λ)n Pλ,n P− (Φx),
x ∈ H,
(5.7)
where Pλ,n is the projection onto the subspace
x : x∈K (z − λ)n along the other subspaces
x : x ∈ K , (z − µ)m
µ ∈ Λ, 1 ≤ m ≤ k(λ),
that is,
x =O (z − λ)m whenever λ = µ or m = n. In (5.7) we identify vectors in K with constant K-valued functions. It is easy to see that the operators Tλ,n have finite rank and Ψ = P− Φ satisfies (5.4). Let ' Lλ = L Ker(S˜ − λI)k(λ) , λ ∈ Λ. Pλ,n
Clearly, rank HΦ =
λ∈Λ
dim Lλ .
80
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
Therefore formula (5.6) will be established if we prove that
k(λ)−1
dim Lλ =
(j)
rank Tλ,k(λ)−j ,
λ ∈ Λ.
j=0
Assume for simplicity that λ = 0. The general case can be treated similarly; moreover it can be reduced to the case λ = 0 by a conformal change of variable. (j) (j) Let k = k(λ), Tn = T0,n , and Tn = Tλ,n . We have k L0 = P0,m HΦ H 2 (H) = P− Ψ0 H 2 (H) m=1
k−n ( Tk+n x span : 0 ≤ n < k, x ∈ H , (z − λ)m m=1
= where
Ψ0 (z) =
k
z −n Tn .
n=1
Let E = Ker Tk . Then all nonzero functions in P− Ψ0 E ⊥ are polynomials of z −1 of degree k. On the other hand, the space P− Ψ0 H 2 (H) E ⊥ = P− Ψ0 H 2 (E) ⊕ zH 2 (E ⊥ ) consists of polynomials of degree less than k. (Here we identify vectors in E ⊥ with constant E ⊥ -valued functions.) Therefore the above subspaces are linearly independent and so dim P− Ψ0 H 2 (H) = dim P− Ψ0 E ⊥ + dim P− Ψ0 H 2 (E) + zΨ0 H 2 (E ⊥ ) . Clearly, and
dim P− Ψ0 E ⊥ = rank Tk dim P− Ψ0 H 2 (E) + zΨ0 H 2 (E ⊥ ) = dim Ψ1 H 2 (H),
where ˜ E⊥ = Ψ1 = ΨPE + SΨP
k−1
z −n Tn(1) ,
n=1 (1) Tn
(1) T0,n
the operators = being defined by (5.5). Repeating the above procedure k times, we arrive at the formula dim L0 =
k−1
(j)
rank Tk−j .
j=0
Suppose that λ ∈ C and Φ is a rational operator function of the form
k(λ)
Φ=
n=1
Tλ,n + Qλ , (z − λ)n
Tλ,k(λ) = O,
6. Imbedding Theorems
81
where Qλ is analytic at λ. Then the McMillan degree degλ Φ of Ψ at λ can be defined as k(λ)−1 (j) degλ Φ = rank Tλ,k(λ)−j , j=0 (j)
where the Tλ,k(λ)−j are defined by (5.5). Similarly, one can define the McMillan degree deg∞ Φ of Φ at infinity. The McMillan degree deg Φ of Φ is defined by degλ Φ. deg Φ = λ∈C∪{∞}
Theorem 5.3 says that rank HΦ is equal to the McMillan degree of P− Φ.
6. Imbedding Theorems In this section we find relations between vectorial Hankel operators and certain imbedding operators. In particular we shall show that for any Carleson measure µ there exists a bounded Hankel operator HΦ , Φ ∈ L∞ (B(C, H)), such that f L2 (µ) = HΦ f ,
f ∈ H 2.
In other words, the Carleson imbedding operator Iµ : H 2 → L2 (µ) (see Appendix 2.1) can be represented as Iµ = V HΦ for some isometry V . This allows one to reduce the study of metric properties of Iµ (such as the norm, singular values, etc.) to the corresponding properties of Hankel operators. Note that in §1.7 we have already found a relation between scalar Hankel operators and Carleson imbedding operators. We are going to consider more general imbedding operators and relate ¯ −1 them with certain Hankel operators. Recall that kζ (z) = (1−|ζ|2 )(1− ζz) 2 is the normalized reproducing kernel of H . Theorem 6.1. Let H be a Hilbert space, Φ ∈ L2 (H). The Hankel 2 (H) defined on the set of polynomials by operator HΦ : H 2 → H− HΦ f = P− f Φ
(6.1)
is bounded if and only if sup HΦ kζ < ∞. ζ∈D
The proof is the same as that of Theorem 1.6.1. The only difference is that we have to deal with vector-valued functions. Clearly, in our case B(C, H)-valued functions can be identified with H-valued functions. By Theorem 2.2, HΦ is bounded if and only if Φ determines a bounded linear functional on H 1 (H). Therefore Theorem 6.1 is equivalent to the fact that
82
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
an H-valued function Φ determines a bounded linear functional on H 1 (H) if and only if the Garsia norm
sup Ψ(ζ) − Ψ(τ )2H Pζ (τ )dm(τ ) T
ζ∈D
def
of Ψ = P− Φ is finite, where as before we denote the harmonic extension of Ψ to D by the same symbol Ψ. The proof of this Hilbert-valued version can be obtained in exactly the same way as the corresponding scalar result (see Garnett [1], Ch. VI, §2, where the scalar case is treated). We consider here the following imbedding operators. Let ν be a positive Borel measure on a subset Λ of D and let λ → ϑλ , λ ∈ Λ, be a measurable family of inner functions. As before Pϑλ is the orthogonal projection of H 2 onto Kϑλ = H 2 ϑλ H 2 . Let f ∈ H 2 . Define the function If in the direct integral
Λ
⊕Kϑλ dν(λ)
by (If )(λ) = Pϑλ f,
λ ∈ Λ,
(6.2)
(see Appendix 1.4 for the definition of direct integrals). We show that I = V HΦ for a certain vectorial Hankel operator HΦ and an isometry V . The following generalized imbedding theorem holds. Theorem 6.2. Let ν be a positive measure on a subset Λ of D and let {ϑλ }λ∈Λ be a measurable family of inner functions. The following statements are equivalent: (i) the operator I defined by (6.2) is bounded, i.e.,
Pϑλ f 2 dν(λ) ≤ cf 22 , f ∈ H 2 ; Λ
(ii)
(1 − |ϑλ (ζ)|2 )dν(λ) < ∞;
sup ζ∈D
Λ
(iii)
sup ζ∈D
Λ
Pϑλ kζ 2 dν(λ) < ∞.
Note that the Carleson imbedding operator can be considered as a special case of the above operators (6.2). Indeed, if z−λ 2 ¯ , dµ(λ) = (1 − |λ| )dν(λ), 1 − λz then it is easy to see that
2 Pϑλ f dν(λ) = |f (λ)|2 dµ(λ), f ∈ H 2 . ϑλ (z) =
Λ
Λ
6. Imbedding Theorems
83
In particular, Theorem 6.2 implies the following well-known version of the Carleson imbedding theorem (see N.K. Nikol’skii [2], Lect. VII, §1). Theorem 6.3. Let µ be a positive measure on D. Then the imbedding operator Iµ : H 2 → L2 (µ) is bounded if and only if
1 − |ζ|2 sup ¯ 2 dµ(λ) < ∞. ζ∈D D |1 − ζλ| In other words, µ is a Carleson measure if and only if sup Iµ kζ L2 (µ) < ∞. ζ∈D
To prove Theorem 6.2, we need the following result, which reduces the study of the imbedding operators (6.2) to the study of vectorial Hankel operators. Theorem 6.4. Let ν be a positive measure on a subset Λ of D and let {ϑλ }λ∈Λ be a measurable family of inner functions. For H = L2 (ν) define the H-valued function Φ by (Φ(ζ)) = ϑλ (ζ),
ζ ∈ T, λ ∈ Λ.
Then If = HΦ f for f ∈ H 2 , where I is defined by (6.2) and the Hankel operator 2 HΦ : H 2 → H− (H) is defined by (6.1). Proof. Clearly, Pϑλ f = ϑλ P− ϑ¯λ f = Hϑ¯λ f . It follows that
If = 2
Pϑλ f dν(λ) = 2
Λ
Λ
Hϑ¯λ f 2 dν(λ) = HΦ f 2 .
Proof of Theorem 6.2. Let us show that (ii)⇔(iii). We have Pϑλ kζ 2 = 1 − ϑλ P+ ϑ¯λ kζ 2 = 1 − ϑλ (ζ)ϑkζ 2 = 1 − |ϑλ (ζ)|2 , which proves that (ii)⇔(iii). The fact that (i)⇒(iii) is trivial. The implication (iii)⇒(i) is an immediate consequence of Theorems 6.1 and 6.4. Remark. It can also be proved that I is compact if and only if
Pϑλ kζ 2 dν(λ) = 0. lim |ζ|→1
Λ
84
Chapter 2. Vectorial Hankel Operators
Concluding Remarks Theorem 1.1 was established in Parrott [1]. Lemma 1.3 is taken from Douglas [1]. Theorem 1.5 in the special case of self-adjoint operators was proved in Krein [1]. A more general case was considered in Arlinskii and Tsekanovskii [1]. In the general case Theorem 1.5 was obtained independently in Shmul’yan and Yanovskaya [1], Arsene and Gheondea [1], and Davis, Kahan, and Weinberger [1]. The proof of Theorem 1.5 given in §1 is suggested by Vasyunin. Theorem 2.1, which is the operator-valued version of the Nehari theorem, was obtained first in Page [1]. The approach given in §2 is due to Adamyan, Arov, and Krein [4]; see also Parrott [1]. Theorem 2.3 is a well-known analog of Theorem 1.1.4. The approach to the operator-valued version of the Nehari theorem, given in §3 is due to Page [1]. We also mention the approach found in Sarason [1] which is based on factorizations of operator functions of class H 1 (S 1 ). The proof Theorem 3.1 based on the operator version of the Nehari theorem was obtined by N.K. Nikol’skii [2]. Formula (3.8) is also due to N.K. Nikol’skii [2]. The compactness criterion obtained in §4 was first given in Page [1]. Theorem 5.2 is well known. Theorem 5.3 is due to Treil [3]. The results of §6 were obtained in Treil [6]. Theorem 4.1 was used in the paper Yafaev [1] to construct a function Φ ∈ H ∞ (B(H)) (H is a Hilbert space) such that Φ is continuous on a nondegenerate closed arc I ⊂ T, Φ(ζ) is compact for ζ ∈ I but Φ(ζ) is not compact for ζ ∈ I. Theorem 2.2 leads naturally to the Nehari problem for operator-valued functions: for Hilbert spaces H and K, and Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) find a best approximation from H ∞ (B(H, K)), i.e., find an operator function Q ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)) such that Φ − QL∞ (B(H,K)) = HΦ . A more general problem, very important in control theory (see Ch. 11), is the so-called four block problem.Let H1 , H2 , K1 , and K2 be Hilbert Φ11 Φ12 be an operator function such that spaces, and let Φ = Φ21 Φ22 Φij ∈ L∞ (B(Hj , Ki )), i, j = 1, 2. The four block problem is to find Q ∈ H ∞ (B(H1 , K1 )), which minimizes Φ11 − Q Φ12 . Φ21 Φ22 L∞ (B(H ⊕H ,K ⊕K )) 1
2
1
2
The four block problem reduces to the Nehari problem in the case Φ12 , Φ21 , and Φ22 are the zero functions. Consider now the four block operator 2 (K1 ) ⊕ L2 (K2 ), 4Φ : H 2 (H1 ) ⊕ L2 (H2 ) → H−
Concluding Remarks
85
which plays the same role in the four block problem as the Hankel operators play in the Nehari problem: f1 f1 = P− Φ , f1 ∈ H 2 (H1 ), f2 ∈ L2 (H2 ), 4Φ f2 f2 where P− is the orthogonal projection from L2 (K1 ) ⊕ L2 (K2 ) onto 2 (K1 ) ⊕ L2 (K2 ). The analog of the Nehari theorem is H− Φ11 − Q Φ12 4Φ = inf . Φ21 Φ22 L∞ (B(H ⊕H ,K ⊕K )) Q∈H ∞ (H1 ,K1 ) 1
2
1
2
Note that 4Φ can be compact only if Φ12 , Φ21 , and Φ22 are the zero functions. We refer the reader to Foias and Tannenbaum [1], [2] for the above facts and detailed information on the four block problem.
3 Toeplitz Operators
We study in this chapter another very important class of operators on spaces of analytic functions, the class of Toeplitz operators. Toeplitz operators can be defined as operators with matrices of the form {tj−k }j,k≥0 . In §1 we characterize the bounded Toeplitz operators and study elementary properties of Toeplitz operators on the Hardy class H 2 . We obtain spectral inclusion theorems, and we reduce the problem of the invertibility of an arbitrary Toeplitz operator to the case of Toeplitz operators with unimodular symbols. Then we use the Nehari theorem to obtain necessary and sufficient conditions for left invertibility and right invertibility in the case of unimodular symbols. We obtain similar results for left Fredholmness and right Fredholmness. In §2 we obtain a general invertibility criterion for Toeplitz operators. Although this criterion is not geometric, it turns out to be very useful in obtaining geometric descriptions of the spectra for various classes of Toeplitz operators (see §3). We give geometric descriptions of spectra for several classes of Toeplitz operators in §3. We consider here the classes of Toeplitz operators with real-valued symbols, with continuous symbols, with symbols in H ∞ + C, and the class of Toeplitz operators with piecewise continuous symbols. Section 4 is devoted to Toeplitz operators on spaces of vector functions. We obtain a boundedness criterion and prove general spectral inclusion theorems. Then we study invertibility conditions for Toeplitz operators with isometric-valued symbols, and we conclude §4 with a Fredholmness criterion for Toeplitz operators with matrix-valued symbols of class H ∞ + C.
88
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
In §5 we prove that if a Toeplitz operator with matrix-valued symbol is Fredholm, then its symbol admits a Wiener–Hopf factorization. We characterize the invertible and the Fredholm Toeplitz operators with matrixvalued symbols in terms of such Wiener–Hopf factorizations. We also find formulas for the indices of such factorizations. We conclude this chapter with §6 in which we obtain a criterion for the left invertibility of an operator function Ω in the space of bounded analytic operator functions. We prove that Ω is left invertible if and only if the Toeplitz operator with symbol Ω(¯ z ) is left invertible.
1. Basic Properties We define here Toeplitz operators on the Hardy class H 2 as those which have Toeplitz matrices (i.e., their entries depend only on the difference of the coordinates) in the basis {z n }n≥0 . In this section we study basic properties of Toeplitz operators. We shall see that a special role is played by Toeplitz operators with unimodular symbols. Definition. An operator T : H 2 → H 2 defined on the set of polynomials is called a Toeplitz operator if there is a two-sided sequence of complex numbers {tn }n∈Z such that (T z k , z j ) = tj−k ,
j, k ∈ Z+ .
(1.1)
Theorem 1.1. A Toeplitz operator T defined by (1.1) is bounded on H 2 if and only if there exists a bounded function ϕ on T whose Fourier coefficients coincide with the tj : ϕ(n) ˆ = tn . In this case T = ϕ∞ . Proof. Suppose that T is a bounded Toeplitz operator. For each n ∈ Z we consider the operator Tn on L2 (T) defined by Tn f = z¯n T P+ z n f,
f ∈ L2 .
Clearly, Tn is bounded and Tn ≤ T . If j ≥ −n and k ≥ −n, then (Tn z k , z j ) = (T z n+k , z n+j ) = tj−k . Therefore the sequence {Tn }n≥0 converges weakly to a bounded operator M on L2 . Obviously, M ≤ T and (M z k , z j ) = tj−k for any j, k ∈ Z. It is also clear that M zf = zM f , f ∈ L2 (it suffices to verify this equality for f = z j , j ∈ Z). Let ϕ = M 1 ∈ L2 . It is easy to see that M f = ϕf , for any polynomial f . Clearly, multiplication by ϕ is a bounded operator from L2 to L1 , and it follows that M f = ϕf for any f ∈ L2 . Since M is a bounded operator on L2 , it is easy to see that ϕ ∈ L∞ and ϕ∞ = M (it suffices to apply M to the charcteristic functions of the sets {ζ ∈ T : |ϕ(ζ)| > N }).
1. Basic Properties
89
We have ϕ(n) ˆ = (M 1, z n ) = tn and T f = P+ M f = P+ ϕf for any polynomial f . Consequently, T f 2 ≤ ϕ∞ f 2 = M · f 2 . Thus T ≤ M = ϕ∞ . The converse follows immediately from the equality T f = P+ ϕf (which is sufficient to verify for f = z n , n ≥ 0). Given ϕ ∈ L∞ we define the Toeplitz operator Tϕ on H 2 by Tϕ f = P+ ϕf,
f ∈ H 2.
(1.2)
It follows from Theorem 1.1 that Tϕ = ϕ∞ . The function ϕ is called the symbol of Tϕ . In contrast with Hankel operators the symbol of a Toeplitz operator is uniquely determined by the operator. It is easy to see that Tϕ∗ = Tϕ¯ ,
ϕ ∈ L∞ .
(1.3)
Although the definition of Toeplitz operators (1.2) looks similar to the definition of Hankel operators (see (1.1.6)), the properties of Hankel operators are quite different from those of Toeplitz operators. In particular the Toeplitz operator Tϕ is never compact unless ϕ = O. Indeed, let ϕ ∈ H 2 and Tϕ f = O. Then it is easy to see that Tϕ z n f 2 ≥ Tϕ f 2 ,
n ≥ 0.
On the other hand, the sequence {z f }n≥0 converges weakly to O, which makes it impossible for Tϕ to be compact. However, there are important relations between Hankel and Toeplitz operators and there are useful formulas that relate Hankel operators with Toeplitz ones. We begin with the simplest one. Given ϕ ∈ L∞ , denote by Mϕ multiplication by ϕ on L2 : n
Mϕ f = ϕf,
f ∈ L2 .
Then obviously Mϕ f = Hϕ f + Tϕ f,
f ∈ H 2.
(1.4)
Another formula that will be used frequently is the following: Tϕψ − Tϕ Tψ = Hϕ∗¯ Hψ ,
ϕ, ψ ∈ L∞ .
(1.5)
The proof of (1.5) is straightforward: Tϕψ f − Tϕ Tψ f
= P+ ϕψf − P+ (ϕP+ ψf ) = P+ (ϕP− ψf ) = Hϕ∗¯ Hψ f,
f ∈ H 2.
The Toeplitz operators can also be described as the operators satisfying a certain commutation relation. Theorem 1.2. Let T be an operator on H 2 . Then T is a Toeplitz operator if and only if S ∗ T S = T, where S is multiplication by z on H 2 .
(1.6)
90
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Proof. Let j, k ∈ Z+ . Clearly, (1.6) means that (T z k , z j ) = (S ∗ T Sz k , z j ) = (T z k+1 , z j+1 ), that is, T has Toeplitz matrix (see (1.1)). It follows from Theorem 1.5.5 and from (1.5) that the functional calculus ϕ → Tϕ , ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C, is multiplicative modulo the compact operators. But it is not multiplicative. The following assertion characterizes the pairs ϕ, ψ ∈ L∞ for which Tϕψ = Tϕ Tψ . Theorem 1.3. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ L∞ . Then Tϕψ = Tϕ Tψ if and only if ψ ∈ H ∞ or ϕ¯ ∈ H ∞ . Proof. If ψ ∈ H ∞ , then Tϕψ f = P+ ϕψf = Tϕ ψf = Tϕ Tψ f , f ∈ H 2 . If ∗ ϕ¯ ∈ H ∞ , it follows from (1.5) that Tϕψ = Tϕ¯ψ¯ = Tψ¯ Tϕ¯ = Tψ∗ Tϕ∗ = (Tϕ Tψ )∗ , so Tϕψ = Tϕ Tψ . Suppose now that Tϕ Tψ = Tϕψ . It follows from (1.5) that Hϕ∗¯ Hψ = O. Let us show that either Hψ = O or Hϕ¯ = O. We have ¯ = 0, (Hϕ∗¯ Hψ z n , z k ) = (Hψ z n , Hϕ¯ z k ) = (P− z n ψ, P− z k ϕ)
n, k ≥ 0.
Therefore (P+ z¯n f, P+ z¯k g) = (S ∗n f, S ∗k g) = 0,
n, k ≥ 0,
(1.7)
where f = z¯P− ψ ∈ H 2 , g = z¯P− ϕ¯ = S ∗ P+ ϕ ∈ H 2 . If f = O and g = O, put L1 = span{S ∗n f : n ≥ 0}, L2 = span{S ∗k g : k ≥ 0}. The subspaces L1 and L2 are S ∗ -invariant and nontrivial. So by Beurling’s theorem (see Appendix 2.2) there exist nonconstant inner functions ϑ1 and ϑ2 such that L1 = H 2 ϑ1 H 2 , L2 = H 2 ϑ2 H 2 . It follows from (1.7) that L1 ⊥ L2 and so H 2 ϑ1 H 2 ⊂ ϑ2 H 2 . It is easy to see that if τ h ∈ L1 , and τ is inner, then h ∈ L1 . Indeed, (τ h, ϑ1 η) = 0 for every η ∈ H 2 . Put η = τ ξ, ξ ∈ H 2 . Then (τ h, ϑ1 τ ξ) = (h, ϑ1 ξ) = 0 for every ξ ∈ H 2 , which means that h ∈ L1 . Therefore L1 contains an outer function that certainly cannot belong to ϑ2 H 2 . Thus either f = O or g = O, which means that either Hψ = O or Hϕ¯ = O. One of the most important questions in studying Toeplitz operators is to find an invertibility criterion and describe the spectrum. To study such a problem we need the notion of Fredholm operators. Recall (see Appendix 1.2 for more information) that an operator T on Hilbert space H is called Fredholm if it is invertible modulo compact operators. The index of a Fredholm operator T is defined by ind T = dim Ker T − dim Ker T ∗ ,
1. Basic Properties
91
and the essential spectrum σe (A) of a bounded operator A is, by definition, σe (A) = {λ ∈ C : A − λI is not Fredholm}. Clearly, σe (A) ⊂ σ(A), where σ(A) is the spectrum of A. Obviously, the index of an invertible operator is zero. It turns out that for Fredholm Toeplitz operators the converse is also true. Theorem 1.4. Let ϕ be a nonzero function in L∞ . Then either Ker Tϕ = {O} or Ker Tϕ∗ = {O}. 2 2 Proof. Let f ∈ Ker Tϕ and g ∈ Ker Tϕ∗ . Then ϕf ∈ H− and ϕg ¯ ∈ H− . 1 def 1 1 ˆ = 0, j ≥ 0} and ϕ¯f¯g ∈ H− . Let Therefore ϕf g¯ ∈ H− = {ψ ∈ L : ψ(j) 1 ˆ ¯ , which means that h(n) =0 h = ϕf g¯. Then both h and h belong to H− for any n ∈ Z and so h = O. Since ϕ = O, it follows that either f or g must vanish on a set of positive measure, which implies that either f = O or g = O (see Appendix 2.1). Corollary 1.5. A Toeplitz operator Tϕ is invertible if and only if it is Fredholm and ind Tϕ = 0. In the case ϕ ∈ H ∞ the operator Tϕ is simply multiplication by ϕ. Such operators are called analytic Toeplitz operators. The spectrum of such operators can easily be described. Theorem 1.6. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ . Then σ(Tϕ ) = clos ϕ(D). Proof. Let us show that Tϕ is invertible if and only if ϕ is invertible in H ∞ . Let ψ ∈ H ∞ and ϕψ = 1. Then clearly Tϕ Tψ = Tψ Tϕ = Tϕψ = I. Suppose now that Tϕ is invertible. Then ϕH 2 = H 2 . Consequently, there exists a function ψ in H 2 such that ϕψ = 1. Let g = ϕf , f ∈ H 2 . Then Tϕ−1 g = f = ψg. Since ϕH 2 = H 2 , it follows that Tϕ−1 g = ψg for any g in H 2 . Thus ψ is bounded and so ϕ is invertible in H ∞ . We are going to establish some elementary properties of the spectrum of Toeplitz operators.
Definition. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . The set R(ϕ) of those λ in C for which the set {ζ ∈ T : |f (ζ) − λ| < ε} has positive Lebesgue measure for any ε > 0 is called the essential range of ϕ. In other words λ ∈ R(ϕ) if and only if ϕ − λ is noninvertible in L∞ . Clearly, R(ϕ) is closed in C. Theorem 1.7. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then R(ϕ) ⊂ σe (Tϕ ). Proof. It suffices to show that if Tϕ is Fredholm, then ϕ is invertible in L∞ . By Theorem 1.4, either Ker Tϕ = {O} or Ker Tϕ∗ = {O}. To be definite, suppose that Ker Tϕ = {O}. Then there exists ε > 0 such that εf 2 ≤ Tϕ f 2 ≤ ϕf 2 , Therefore z n f 2 . ε¯ z n f 2 ≤ ϕ¯
f ∈ H 2.
92
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Since the set {¯ z n f : f ∈ H 2 , n ≥ 0} is dense in L2 , it follows that εg2 ≤ ϕg2 for any g ∈ L2 , which implies that 1/ϕ ∈ L∞ . Corollary 1.8. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then R(ϕ) ⊂ σ(Tϕ ). Denote by conv E the convex hull of a set E. Theorem 1.9. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then σ(Tϕ ) ⊂ conv R(ϕ). Proof. It is sufficient to prove that if an open half-plane contains R(ϕ), then it also contains σ(Tϕ ). By the linearity of the map ϕ → Tϕ we can assume that the half-plane in question is {ζ ∈ C : Re ζ > 0}. Moreover it is sufficient to show that if R(ϕ) ⊂ {ζ ∈ C : Re ζ > 0}, then Tϕ is invertible. Let us show that there exist ε > 0 and r < 1 such that εR(ϕ) ⊂ {ζ : |1 − ζ| < r}.
(1.8)
Indeed, the discs DR = {ζ : |R − ζ| < R},
R > 0,
cover the half-plane {ζ ∈ C : Re ζ > 0}. Therefore R(ϕ), being compact, is contained in some DR . Then R(ϕ) ⊂ {ζ : |R − ζ| < R − δ} for some δ > 0. Now (1.8) holds with ε = 1/R, r = 1 − δ/R. It follows that εϕ − 1∞ < 1, so Tεϕ − I < 1, which implies that Tεϕ is invertible and so is Tϕ . In the general case the problem of the invertibility of a Toeplitz operator can be reduced to the case of a Toeplitz operator with unimodular symbol. (A function u is called unimodular if |u(ζ)| = 1 almost everywhere on T.) Lemma 1.10. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . The following statements are equivalent: (i) Tϕ is invertible; (ii) ϕ is invertible in L∞ and Tϕ/h is invertible, where h is an outer function with |h| = |ϕ|; (iii) ϕ is invertible in L∞ and Tϕ/|ϕ| is invertible. Proof. If Tϕ is invertible, then ϕ is invertible in L∞ by Corollary 1.8. By Theorem 1.3, Tϕ = Tϕ/h Th . Since Th is invertible, it follows that (i)⇔(ii). To show that (i)⇔(iii), take an outer function h1 such that |h1 | = |ϕ|−1/2 . By Theorem 1.3, Tϕ/|ϕ| = Th¯1 ϕh1 = Th∗1 Tϕ Th1 . The result follows from the invertibility of Th1 and Th∗1 . Theorem 1.11. Let u be a unimodular function on T. Then Tu is left invertible if and only if distL∞ (u, H ∞ ) < 1. Tu is right invertible if and u, H ∞ ) < 1. only if distL∞ (¯ Proof. It follows from (1.4) that f 2 = Hu f 2 + Tu f 2 ,
f ∈ H 2.
Hence, Tu f 2 ≥ εf 2 for some ε > 0 if and only if Hu < 1. By Theorem 1.1.3 this is equivalent to the fact that dist(u, H ∞ ) < 1.
1. Basic Properties
93
The second assertion of the theorem follows from the equality Tu∗ = Tu¯ .
Theorem 1.12. Let u be a unimodular function on T. If Tu is invertible and h is a function in H ∞ such that u − h∞ < 1, then h is an outer function. Proof. We have ¯h∞ = u − h∞ . I − Tu¯h = 1 − u Therefore Tu¯h = Tu∗ Th is invertible and so is Th , which means by Theorem 1.6 that h is invertible in H ∞ . Theorem 1.13. Let u be a unimodular function on T. Then Tu is invertible if and only if there exists an outer function h such that u − h∞ < 1. Proof. The existence of such an outer function for an invertible Tu follows from Theorems 1.11 and 1.12. Suppose that u − h∞ < 1 for an outer function h. Then h is separated away from zero on T and since h is outer, it follows that h is invertible in H ∞ . We have I − Tu¯ Th < 1, which implies that Tu¯ Th is invertible. Hence, Tu is also invertible. Theorem 1.14. Let u be a unimodular function on T such that Tu is left invertible. Then Tu is invertible if and only if Tz¯u is not left invertible. Proof. If Tu is invertible, then there is a function f in H 2 such that Tu f = 1. Hence, Tz¯u f = O. Suppose now that Tz¯u is not left invertible. That means that inf {Tz¯u f 2 : f 2 = 1} = 0 or, which is the same, inf Tu f − T) u f (0) · 12 : f 2 = 1 = 0. By the hypothesis inf {Tu f 2 : f 2 = 1} > 0. Hence, 1 ∈ clos Tu H 2 = Tu H 2 . Let g be a function in H 2 such that Tu g = 1. From the identity 1 = Tz¯n Tu z n g, n ∈ Z+ , it follows by induction that z n ∈ Tu H 2 , n ∈ Z+ , that is, Tu H 2 = H 2 . We are now going to obtain similar descriptions of Fredholm, left Fredholm, and right Fredholm Toeplitz operators with unimodular symbols. Recall that a bounded linear operator T on Hilbert space is called left Fredholm if there exists a bounded linear operator R such that RT − I is compact and T is called right Fredholm if there is a bounded linear operator R such that T R − I is compact.
94
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Theorem 1.15. Let u be a unimodular function on T. Then Tu is left Fredholm if and only if Hu e < 1. Tu is right Fredholm if and only if Hu¯ e < 1. Proof. Clearly, it is sufficient to prove only the first part of the theorem. Suppose that Hu e = distL∞ (u, H ∞ + C) < 1. Then there exists n ∈ Z+ such that distL∞ (z n u, H ∞ ) = distL∞ (u, z¯n H ∞ ) < 1. By Theorem 1.11, the operator Tzn u = Tu Tzn is left invertible. Let R be a bounded linear operator such that RTu Tzn = I. It follows that RTu Tzn Tz¯n = Tz¯n . Clearly, I −Tzn Tz¯n is compact, and so RTu −Tz¯n is compact. Multiplying this operator by Tzn on the left, we find that Tzn RTu − I is compact which proves that Tu is left Fredholm. Suppose now that Tu is left Fredholm. Then there exists a bounded linear operator R such that RTu − I is compact. Hence, dim Ker RTu < ∞. It follows that there exists n ∈ Z+ such that Ker RTzn u = {O}. Since RTzn u − I is compact, it follows that RTzn u is invertible, and so Tzn u is left invertible. By Theorem 1.11, distL∞ (z n u, H ∞ ) < 1. The result follows now from the obvious equality distL∞ (u, H ∞ + C) = distL∞ (z n u, H ∞ + C). Corollary 1.16. Let u be a unimodular function on T. Then Tu is Fredholm if and only if Hu e < 1 and Hu¯ e < 1.
2. A General Invertibility Criterion The following theorem due to Devinatz and Widom gives an invertibility criterion for a Toeplitz operator. Although the criterion is not geometric, we shall see later that it can be used to obtain geometric descriptions of the spectra of certain Toeplitz operators. Theorem 2.1. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then Tϕ is invertible if and only if ϕ is invertible in L∞ and ϕ/|ϕ| admits a representation ϕ/|ϕ| = exp i(˜ α + β + c) ∞
(2.1)
where α and β are real functions in L , β∞ < π/2, and c ∈ R. Recall that α ˜ is the harmonic conjugate of α (see Appendix 2.1). Proof. By Lemma 1.10, we may assume that ϕ is unimodular. Suppose that Tϕ is invertible. Then there exists an outer function h such that 1 − ϕh ¯ ∞ < 1 (see Theorem 1.13). Hence, γπ R(ϕh) ¯ ⊂ ζ ∈ C : | arg ζ| < 2 for some γ < 1. Therefore there exists a real-valued function β such that β∞ < π/2 and ϕh ¯ = |h|e−iβ . Hence, ¯ −1 eiβ = exp(log |h| + β + c) ϕ = |h|h
2. A General Invertibility Criterion
95
def
for some c ∈ R. Clearly, α = log |h| ∈ L∞ . Suppose now that ϕ = exp i(˜ α + β + c). Put ϕ1 = exp i(β + c) and ¯ and so h = exp((α + i˜ α)/2). Then h is invertible in H ∞ , ϕ = ϕ1 h/h Tϕ = T1/h¯ Tϕ1 Th . The operators T1/h¯ and Th are obviously invertible. Since β∞ < π/2, it follows that 0 ∈ conv(R(ϕ1 )). Thus Tϕ1 is invertible by Theorem 1.9. To obtain further results we make use of Zygmund’s theorem, which asserts that exp β˜ ∈ Lp whenever β is a real-valued function satisfying β∞ < π/2p (see Appendix 2.1). Corollary 2.2. Let u be a unimodular function for which Tu is invertible on H 2 . Then there exists an outer function h such that both h and ¯ 1/h belong to H p for some p > 2 and u = h/h. Proof. By Theorem 2.1, u = exp i(˜ α + β + c), where c ∈ R, α, β are real-valued functions in L∞ and β∞ < π/2. Put α ˜ β α β˜ , h2 = exp −i , h = e−ic/2 h1 h2 . h1 = exp − − i 2 2 2 2 ¯ Then u = h/h. It is also clear that h1 is invertible in H ∞ . By Zygmund’s theorem h2 and 1/h2 belong to H p for some p > 2. Let us show that the representation of a unimodular function obtained in Corollary 2.2 is unique. Lemma 2.3. Let h1 and h2 be outer functions such that h1 ∈ H 2 and ¯ 1 /h1 = h ¯ 2 /h2 , then h2 = ch1 for some c ∈ R. 1/h2 ∈ H 2 . If h −1 1 ¯ ¯ −1 Proof. Since h1 h−1 2 ∈ H , it follows from h1 h2 = h1 h2 that h1 /h2 is constant. Corollary 2.4. Suppose that under the hypotheses of Corollary 2.2 the function u has real Fourier coefficients. Then there exists an outer function h with real Fourier coefficients such that h and 1/h belong to H p for some ¯ p > 2 and u = h/h. Proof. The result follows immediately from Corollary 2.2 and Lemma 2.3. ¯ Theorem 2.5. Let u = h/h, where h is an outer function in H 2 . Then Tϕ is invertible if and only if |h|2 admits a representation |h|2 = exp(ξ + η˜), where ξ and η are real functions in L∞ and η∞ < π/2. Proof. Suppose that (2.2) holds with ξ and η as required. Then ξ η˜ η ξ˜ exp exp −i +i 2 2 2 2
(2.2)
96
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
is an outer function whose modulus coincides with |h| on T. So ξ η˜ ξ˜ η h = τ exp exp +i −i 2 2 2 2 for some unimodular constant τ . Therefore ˜ = exp i(η − ξ˜ + c), ¯ = τ¯ exp i(η − ξ) u = h/h τ where c ∈ R, eic = τ¯/τ . Thus u can be represented as in (2.1) and so Tu is invertible by Theorem 2.1. Suppose now that Tu is invertible. Then u admits a representation (2.1) with α, β ∈ L∞ and β∞ < π/2. Put β˜ α ˜ β α exp − + i , +i h1 = τ exp 2 2 2 2 where τ is a unimodular constant such that τ¯/τ = eic . Then h1 and h−1 1 ¯ 1 /h1 = h/h. ¯ belong to H 2 by Zygmund’s theorem and h By Lemma 2.3, h = γh1 for some constant γ. Then ˜ |h|2 = |γ|2 · |h1 |2 = exp(δ + α − β), def
where δ = log |γ|. Clearly, ξ = δ + α and η = −β satisfy the requirements. Remark. Positive functions that can be represented as exp(ξ + η˜) with ξ and η as in the statement of Theorem 2.5 are said to satisfy the Helson– Szeg¨ o condition. We shall discuss this condition in more detail in connection with prediction theory. It follows from Zygmund’s theorem that if |h|2 satisfies the Helson–Szeg¨o condition, then h ∈ H p and 1/h ∈ H p for some p > 2. Corollary 2.6. Let u = exp i(˜ α + β), where α and β are real-valued functions in C(T). Then Tu is invertible and u can be represented as ¯ u = h/h, where h is an outer function such that h and 1/h belong to H p with any p < ∞. Moreover α ˜ + β = log |h|2 + c for some c ∈ R. Proof. Let q be a trigonometric polynomial such that β − q∞ < π/2p, where 0 < p < ∞. Then α ˜ + β = (α − q˜) + β − q + qˆ(0). So by Theorem 2.1, Tu is invertible. Let α1 = α − q˜, β1 = β − q, d = qˆ(0). Put 1 1 α1 ), h2 = exp (−β˜1 + iβ), h = e−d/2 h1 h2 . h1 = exp (α1 + i˜ 2 2 ¯ Then u = h/h. Clearly, h1 is invertible in H ∞ and by Zygmund’s theorem p h2 , h−1 2 ∈ H . It is easy to see that log |h|2 = α − β˜ − d
3. Spectra of Certain Toeplitz Operators
97
and so ˜+β+c log |h|2 = α for some c ∈ R. Corollary 2.7. If f and g are real functions in V M O such that exp if = exp ig, then f (ζ) − g(ζ) = 2kπ, ζ ∈ T, for some k ∈ Z. Proof. By Corollary 2.6 there exist outer functions h1 and h2 such that ¯ 1 /h1 , exp if = h
¯ 2 /h2 exp ig = h
−1 and h1 , h−1 ∈ H 2 . By Lemma 2.3, h1 = γh2 , γ ∈ C. It follows 1 , h2 , h2 from Corollary 2.6 that
f − g = log |h1 |2 − log |h2 |2 + const = const .
3. Spectra of Certain Toeplitz Operators In this section we find geometric descriptions of spectra of Toeplitz operators with symbols belonging to certain classes. We begin with the class of Toeplitz operators with real symbols. Theorem 3.1. Let ϕ be a real function in L∞ . Then σ(Tϕ ) = σe (Tϕ ) = [ess inf ϕ, ess sup ϕ]. Proof. It follows from Theorems 1.7 and 1.9 that σ(Tϕ ) ⊂ [ess inf ϕ, ess sup ϕ] and the endpoints of this interval belong to σ(Tϕ ). Suppose that λ ∈ (ess inf ϕ, ess sup ϕ) and Tϕ−λ is invertible. Then there exists a function f in H 2 such that Tϕ−λ f = 1. We have (Tϕ−λ f, f z n ) = (1, f z n ) = 0, Therefore
n ≥ 1.
((ϕ − λ)f, f z ) = n
T
(ϕ − λ)|f |2 z¯n dm = 0,
n ≥ 1.
Since ϕ−λ is real-valued, it follows that the Fourier coefficients of (ϕ−λ)|f |2 vanish for n = 0. Therefore (ϕ−λ)|f |2 is constant, which is impossible, since it changes sign on (ess inf ϕ, ess supp ϕ). Thus σ(Tϕ ) = [ess inf ϕ, ess sup ϕ]. Since Tϕ is self-adjoint, it is evident that σe (Tϕ ) = [ess inf ϕ, ess sup ϕ]. Let us proceed to the class of Toeplitz operators with continuous symbols and symbols of class H ∞ + C. Theorem 3.2. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Then Tϕ is Fredholm if and only if ϕ is invertible in H ∞ + C.
98
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Proof. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ H ∞ + C and ϕψ = 1. Then by (1.5) I − Tϕ Tψ = Hϕ∗¯ Hψ ,
I − Tψ Tϕ = Hψ∗¯ Hϕ .
By the Hartman theorem both operators are compact, which implies that Tϕ is Fredholm. Suppose now that Tϕ is Fredholm. Then 1/ϕ ∈ L∞ by Theorem 1.7 and so ϕ = uη, where η is an outer function invertible in H ∞ and u is a unimodular function. Clearly, Tu = Tϕ Tη−1 is Fredholm. Let n = ind Tu . Let us show that Tzn u is invertible. By Corollary 1.5, it is sufficient to show that it is Fredholm with zero index. If n ≥ 0, then Tzn u = Tu Tzn and ind Tzn u = ind Tu + ind Tzn = n − n = 0.
(3.1)
If n < 0, then Tzn u = Tzn Tu and again (3.1) holds. Thus Tzn u is invertible and so is Tz¯n u¯ = Tz∗n u . By Theorem 1.13, there exists an outer function h in H ∞ such that 1 − z n uh∞ = ¯ znu ¯ − h∞ < 1. Consequently, z n uh is invertible in H ∞ +C, and so ϕ = uh is also invertible in H ∞ + C. It is very easy now to evaluate the spectrum of a Toeplitz operator with symbol in C(T). Let ϕ be a function in C(T) that does not vanish on T. We define the winding number wind ϕ with respect to the origin in the following way. Consider a continuous branch of the argument argϕ of the function t → ϕ(eit ), t ∈ [0, 2π], i.e., ϕ(eit ) = exp(i argϕ (t)), |ϕ(eit )|
argϕ ∈ C([0, 2π]),
t ∈ [0, 2π].
Then
1 argϕ (2π) − argϕ (0) . 2π Theorem 3.3. Let ϕ ∈ C(T). Then σe (Tϕ ) = ϕ(T). For λ ∈ σe (Tϕ ) we have ind(Tϕ − λI) = − wind(ϕ − λ). def
wind ϕ =
Proof. By Theorem 3.2, the operator Tϕ − λI is Fredholm if and only if ϕ − λ is invertible in H ∞ + C. Since ϕ ∈ C(T), the last condition means that ϕ − λ does not vanish on T, which proves that σe (Tϕ ) = ϕ(T). Let λ ∈ σe (Tϕ ). Without loss of generality we can assume that λ = 0. Since ϕ does not vanish on T, the curve t → ϕ(eit ), t ∈ [0, 2π], is homotopic in C \ {0} to the curve t → eint for some integer n. Since the index depends continuously on the operator, it does not change under homotopy. It is also clear that wind ϕ = wind z n = n. Thus ind Tϕ = ind Tzn = −n = − wind z n = − wind ϕ.
Corollary 3.4. Let ϕ ∈ C(T). Then Tϕ is invertible if and only if ϕ = ef for some f ∈ C(T).
3. Spectra of Certain Toeplitz Operators
99
To obtain an invertibility criterion for Toeplitz operators with symbols in H ∞ + C, we have to define the winding number of an invertible function in H ∞ + C. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Consider its harmonic extension to the unit disc, def which we also denote by ϕ. Given r < 1, let ϕr (ζ) = ϕ(rζ), ζ ∈ T. Clearly, ϕr = ϕ ∗ Pr , where Pr is the Poisson kernel. Theorem 3.5. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Then ϕ is invertible in H ∞ + C if and only if there exists r0 ∈ (0, 1) such that |ϕ| is separated away from zero on the annulus {ζ : r0 < |ζ| < 1}. In this case wind ϕr is constant for r0 < r < 1. To prove the theorem we need a lemma on the asymptotic multiplicativity of the harmonic extension of functions in H ∞ + C. Lemma 3.6. Let ϕ, ψ ∈ H ∞ + C. Then lim (ϕψ)r − ϕr ψr ∞ = 0.
r→1−
Proof. Let ϕ = f + α, ψ = g + β, where f, g ∈ H ∞ , α, β ∈ C(T). Since (f g)r = fr gr , we have (ϕψ)r − ϕr ψr = (f β)r − fr βr + (gα)r − gr αr + (αβ)r − αr βr . It is obvious that (αβ)r − αr βr ∞ → 0 as r → 1, since α and β can be approximated by trigonometric polynomials and so it is sufficient to consider the case α = z n , β = z m . Then (αβ)r − αr βr ∞
= r|n+m| z m+n − r|n| z n r|m| z m ∞ = |r|n+m| − r|n|+|m| | → 0.
Let us show that (f β)r − fr βr ∞ → 0. The proof of the fact that (gα)r − gr αr ∞ → 0 is similar. It is also clear that we can consider only the case β = z¯n , n > 0, since the trigonometric polynomials are dense in C(T) and for β ∈ H ∞ the situation is trivial. Let f = q + z n h, where q is an analytic polynomial, deg q ≤ n − 1, and h ∈ H ∞ . We have (f β)r − fr βr ∞ ≤ (q¯ z n )r − qr (¯ z n )r ∞ + hr − (z n h)r (¯ z n )r ∞ . Clearly, hr − (z n h)r (¯ z n )r ∞
= hr − rn z n hr · rn z¯n ∞ = (1 − r2n )hr ∞ → 0,
r → 1,
and (q¯ z n )r −qr (¯ z n )r ∞ → 0 since q and z¯n are trigonometric polynomials. Proof of Theorem 3.5. Suppose that ϕ is invertible in H ∞ + C. Then ψ = 1/ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C and by Lemma 3.6, 1 − ϕr ψr ∞ = (ϕψ)r − ϕr ψr ∞ → 0.
100
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Since ψr ∞ ≤ ψ∞ , it follows that |ϕ| is separated away from zero on {ζ : r0 < |ζ| < 1} for r0 sufficiently close to 1. Suppose now that |ϕ(ζ)| > δ > 0 for |ζ| > r0 . Then there exist a function f in H ∞ and n ∈ Z+ such that ϕ − z¯n f ∞ = z n ϕ − f ∞ < ε, where 0 < ε < δ/2. By Lemma 3.6, (z n ϕ)r − rn z n ϕr ∞ → 0. Consequently, |f (ζ)| ≥ δ − ε for |ζ| > r1 , where r0 < r1 < 1. Let f = ϑh, where ϑ is an inner function and h is an outer function. It follows that ϑ is a finite Blaschke product and h is invertible in H ∞ . Therefore f is invertible in H ∞ + C. We have z n ϕ/f − 1∞ = (z n ϕ − f )/f ∞ ≤ εf −1 ∞ ≤ ε(δ − ε)−1 < 1. Hence, z n ϕ/f is invertible in H ∞ + C and so is ϕ. The fact that wind ϕr does not depend on r follows from the fact that ϕr depends on r continuously and so wind ϕr is a continuous function on (r0 , 1). Let ϕ be an invertible function in H ∞ + C. Its winding number wind ϕ can be defined as follows. Let r0 be a number in (0, 1) such that inf{|ϕ(ζ)| : |ζ| > r0 } > 0. Then wind ϕ is by definition wind ϕr , where r is an arbitrary number in (r0 , 1). The winding number is well-defined in view of Theorem 3.5. Before we proceed to the description of the spectrum of Toeplitz operators with symbols in H ∞ + C, we compute the index of analytic Toeplitz operators. Lemma 3.7. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ . Then σe (Tϕ ) = R(ϕ) {λ ∈ C : dim H 2 ϑλ H 2 = ∞}, (3.2) where ϑλ is the inner factor of ϕ − λ. If λ ∈ σe (Tϕ ), then ind(Tϕ − λI) = − deg ϑλ = − wind(ϕ − λ). Proof. By Theorem 3.5 to prove (3.2) it is sufficient to show that if |ϕ| is separated away from zero on T, then Tϕ is Fredholm if and only if the inner part ϑ of ϕ is a finite Blaschke product. Let ϕ = ϑh where h is outer. Since Th is invertible, it follows that Tϕ is Fredholm if and only if so is Tϑ . Since Ker Tϑ∗ = H 2 ϑH 2 , the operator Tϕ is Fredholm if and only if ϑ is a finite Blaschke product, which proves (3.2). Clearly, if Tϕ is Fredholm, then deg ϑ = dim Ker Tϑ∗ = − ind Tϕ = wind ϑ by Theorem 3.3. Now we are in a position to describe the spectrum of Toeplitz operators with H ∞ + C symbols. Theorem 3.8. Let ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Then for λ ∈ σe (Tϕ ) ind(Tϕ − λI) = − wind(ϕ − λ).
3. Spectra of Certain Toeplitz Operators
101
Proof. Clearly, we can assume that λ = 0. Let n = ind Tϕ . Then Tzn ϕ is invertible. Let us show that wind z n ϕ = n + wind ϕ. Indeed, by Lemma 3.6, (z n ϕ)r − r|n| z n ϕr ∞ → 0 as r → 1. Since (z n ϕ)r and r|n| z n ϕr are separated away from zero for r sufficiently close to 1, it follows that wind(z n ϕ)r = wind r|n| z n ϕr = n + wind ϕr Therefore without loss of generality we can assume that n = 0, that is, Tϕ is invertible. Let ε > 0. There exist k ∈ Z+ and f ∈ H ∞ such that ϕ − z¯k f ∞ < ε. If ε is sufficiently small, then Tz¯k f is invertible and 0 = ind Tz¯k f = ind Tf + k. By Lemma 3.7, ind Tf = − wind f . Therefore ind Tz¯k f = − wind z¯k f . It is easy to see that if ε is sufficiently small, then wind ϕ = wind z¯k f = 0, which completes the proof. Let us now introduce the important class of quasicontinuous functions QC = (H ∞ + C) (H ∞ + C). It is easy to see that QC is the maximal self-adjoint subalgebra of H ∞ + C. Lemma 3.9. QC = V M O L∞ . Proof. Let ϕ ∈ QC. Then ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C and P− ϕ ∈ P− C(T) ⊂ V M O. Similarly, P+ ϕ ∈ V M O. Now let ϕ ∈ V M O L∞ . Then ϕ = P+ f + g, where f, g ∈ C(T) (see Appendix 2.5). Since ϕ ∈ L∞ , it follows that P+ f ∈ H ∞ , so ϕ ∈ H ∞ + C. Similarly, ϕ¯ ∈ H ∞ + C. The following theorem, which describes the unimodular functions in QC, will be important in what follows. Theorem 3.10. A unimodular function u belongs to QC if and only if it admits a factorization u = z n exp i(˜ α + β),
(3.3)
where n ∈ Z, and α and β are real functions in C(T). Proof. If u satisfies (3.3), then α) exp(−α + iβ) ∈ H ∞ + C, u = z n exp(α + i˜ since H ∞ + C is an algebra (see Theorem 1.5.1). Similarly, u ¯ ∈ H ∞ + C. Suppose now that u ∈ QC, then u ¯ ∈ QC and so u is invertible in H ∞ +C. By Theorem 3.2, Tu is Fredholm. Let n = − ind Tu and v = z¯n u. Then Tv is invertible. By Theorem 1.13, there exists an outer function h in H ∞ such that v − h∞ = 1 − v¯h∞ < 1. Consequently, v¯h has a logarithm in the Banach algebra H ∞ + C. Therefore there exist an f in C(T) and a g in v h)−1 = v/h = exp(f + g). Hence, H ∞ such that (¯ v = h exp(f + g) = exp(ic + log |h| + ilog |h| + f + g) for some c ∈ R. Since v is unimodular, it follows that log |h|+Re(f +g) = O. Put α = log |h| + Re g = − Re f ∈ C(T ). Since g ∈ H ∞ , we have α ˜ = log |h| + Im g − Im g(0).
102
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Putting now β = Im f + c + Im g(0) ∈ C(T), we see that u satisfies (3.3). In Chapter 7 we shall obtain similar results for many other classes of functions. We proceed now to Toeplitz operators with piecewise continuous symbols (see §1.5, where the class P C of piecewise continuous is defined). If ϕ ∈ P C, we can consider the set γ that consists of ϕ(T) and the union of the straight line intervals [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)], where ζ ranges over all jump points. It is easy to find a parametrization of that curve, that is, a function ϕ# in C(T) such that ϕ# (T) = γ. Thus γ = ϕ# (T) = ϕ(T) ∪ [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)], ζ
the union being taken over all jump points ζ. Theorem 3.11. Let ϕ ∈ P C. Then σe (Tϕ ) = ϕ# (T). If λ ∈ σe (Tϕ ), then ind(Tϕ − λI) = − wind(ϕ# − λ). Proof. It suffices to prove that Tϕ is Fredholm if and only if 0 ∈ ϕ# (T) and if Tϕ is Fredholm, then ind Tϕ = − wind ϕ# . Assume that 0 ∈ ϕ# (T). That means that ϕ does not vanish on T and the intervals [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)] do not contain the origin. Without loss of generality we may assume that ϕ is continuous at 1. Clearly, ϕ/|ϕ| ∈ P C and it is possible to find a branch of the argument α of ϕ (i.e., eiα = ϕ/|ϕ|) such that α ∈ P C, α is continuous at the continuity points of ϕ, except for a possible jump at 1, and |α(ζ − ) − α(ζ)| < π, In this case 1 wind ϕ# = 2π
ζ = 1.
lim α(e ) − lim α(e ) . it
t→2π−
it
t→0+
If wind ϕ# = 0, then α has no jump at 1 and so all jumps of α have moduli less than π − δ for some δ > 0. It is easy to see that α admits a representation α = ξ + η, where ξ ∈ C(T) and η∞ ≤ (π −δ)/2. Let q be a trigonometric polynomial such that ξ − q∞ < δ/4 and r = q˜. We have α = η + ξ − q − r˜ + qˆ(0). Clearly, η + ξ − q < π/2 and so by Theorem 2.1, the operator Tϕ/|ϕ| = Texp iα is invertible. z n ϕ)# has zero winding Let n = wind ϕ# = 0 and 0 ∈ ϕ# (T). Then (¯ number and as we have just proved, Tz¯n ϕ is invertible. If n > 0, then
4. Toeplitz Operators on Spaces of Vector Functions
103
Tz¯n ϕ = Tz¯n Tϕ ; if n < 0, then Tz¯n ϕ = Tϕ Tzn . In both cases it follows that Tϕ is Fredholm and 0 = ind Tz¯n f = ind Tz¯n + ind Tϕ = n + ind Tϕ , which implies that ind Tϕ = −n. Suppose now that 0 ∈ ϕ# (T). If 0 ∈ clos ϕ(T), then Tϕ is not Fredholm by Theorem 1.7. If 0 ∈ clos ϕ(T), then 0 ∈ [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)] for some jump point ζ in T. If Tϕ were Fredholm, then so would be any operator Tϕ−λ for sufficiently small λ. Moreover, ind Tϕ−λ = ind Tϕ for all such λ. Let us first take a very small λ0 such that λ0 belongs to only one interval of the form [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)]. Let ε be such a small number that the disc Dε = {ζ : |λ0 − ζ| < ε} does not intersect ϕ(T) and intersects only one interval of the form [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)]. Then as we have already proved, if λ1 and λ2 are in different components of Dε \ [ϕ(ζ − ), ϕ(ζ)], the operators Tϕ−λ1 and Tϕ−λ2 are Fredholm and have different indices, which contradicts the assumption that Tϕ is Fredholm.
4. Toeplitz Operators on Spaces of Vector Functions In this section we study vectorial Toeplitz operators (i.e., Toeplitz operators on spaces of vector functions). Let H and K be separable Hilbert spaces. We identify the spaces H 2 (H) and H 2 (K) with 2 (H) and 2 (K) in the usual way: f → {fˆ(j)}j≥0 .
(4.1)
We define vectorial Toeplitz operators from H 2 (H) to H 2 (K) as operators that with respect to the decompositions (4.1) have block matrices of the form {Ωj−k }j,k≥0 ,
(4.2)
where {Ωj }j∈Z is a two-sided sequence of operators from H to K. Here we obtain basic results on vectorial Toeplitz operators and characterize in the finite-dimensional case the Fredholm Toeplitz operators with symbols in H ∞ + C. In the next section we obtain a characterization of the invertible and Fredholm Toeplitz operators in terms of certain factorizations of their symbols. The following theorem characterizes the bounded vectorial Toeplitz operators. Theorem 4.1. Let {Ωj }j∈Z be a sequence of bounded linear operators from H to K. The block matrix (4.2) determines a bounded operator from
104
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
H 2 (H) to H 2 (K) if and only if {Ωj }j∈Z is the sequence of the Fourier coefficients of a function Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)). In this case {Ωj−k }j,k≥0 = ΦL∞ (B(H,K)) . Note that, as usual, we identify operators from H 2 (H) to H 2 (K) with their block matrices with respect to the decomposition (4.1). Proof. Denote by T the operator with block matrix (4.2). Suppose that T is a bounded Toeplitz operator from H 2 (H) to H 2 (K). For each n ∈ Z we consider the operator Tn from L2 (H) to L2 (K) defined by Tn f = z¯n T P+ z n f,
f ∈ L2 (H).
Clearly, Tn is bounded and Tn ≤ T . If j ≥ −n and k ≥ −n, then (Tn z k x, z j y) = (T z n+k x, z n+j y) = (Ωj−k x, y), x ∈ H, y ∈ K. Therefore the sequence {Tn }n≥0 converges weakly to a bounded operator M from L2 (H) to L2 (K). Obviously, M ≤ T and (M z k x, z j y) = (Ωj−k x, y) for any j, k ∈ Z. It is also clear that M zf = zM f , f ∈ L2 (it suffices to verify this equality for f = z j x, j ∈ Z, x ∈ H). Let x ∈ H and let x be the constant H-valued function identically equal to x. We have (M x)(ζ) = ζ j Ω−j x. j∈Z
Clearly, M x ∈ L2 (K). We can define a measurable B(H, K)-valued function on T by ζ j Ω−j x, a.e. Φ(ζ)x = ∈Z
It is easy to see that (M f )(ζ) = Φ(ζ)f (ζ),
a.e.
for any trigonometric H-valued polynomial f . In exactly the same way as in the proof of Theorem 2.2.2 it can easily be shown that Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) and T = ΦL∞ (B(H,K)) . The converse follows immediately from the equality T f = P+ Φf , f ∈ H 2 (H), (which is sufficient to verify for f = z n x, n ≥ 0, x ∈ H). As in the scalar case an operator TΦ can be compact only if Φ = O (the proof is the same). The scalar formula (1.5) is also valid in the vectorial case: if H1 , H2 , H3 are Hilbert spaces, Ψ ∈ L∞ (B(H1 , H2 )), Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H2 , H3 )), then TΦΨ − TΦ TΨ = HΦ∗ ∗ HΨ (the proof is exactly the same). It is also easy to see that TΦ∗ = TΦ∗ ,
Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)).
It follows from (4.3) that TΦΨ = TΦ TΨ
(4.3)
4. Toeplitz Operators on Spaces of Vector Functions
105
if Ψ ∈ H ∞ (B(H1 , H2 )) or Φ ∈ (H ∞ (B(H2 , H3 )))∗ (cf. Theorem 1.3). However, in contrast with the scalar case the converse does not hold. Indeed, let L be a nonzero subspace of H2 such that L = H2 . Suppose that Range Ψ(ζ) ∈ L, a.e. on T and Ker Φ(ζ) ⊂ L, a.e. on T. Then it is easy to see that TΦΨ = TΦ TΨ = O, while Ψ does not have to be in H ∞ (B(H1 , H2 )) as well as Φ does not have to be in (H ∞ (B(H2 , H3 )))∗ . In the case when the corresponding Hilbert spaces H and K are finitedimensional we can identify H with Cn , K with Cm , and B(H, K) with the space Mm,n of m × n matrices. We shall use the notation Mn for Mn,n . Note that the study of spectral problems for Toeplitz operators on spaces of vector functions is much harder than in the scalar case. In particular fundamental Theorem 1.4 does not generalize to the Toeplitz operators with matricial symbols. Indeed, let m = n = 2. Consider the matrix function Φ ∈ L∞ (M2 ) defined by ζ 0 Φ(ζ) = , ζ ∈ T. 0 ζ¯ It is easy to see that TΦ is Fredholm,
O 1 , Ker TΦ∗ = span Ker TΦ = span 1 O (recall that 1 is the function identically equal to 1), and so ind TΦ = 0 though TΦ is noninvertible. Let us obtain some general results. Theorem 4.2. Let H be a Hilbert space and let Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H)). Suppose that TΦ is Fredholm. Then Φ(ζ) is invertible almost everywhere and Φ−1 ∈ L∞ (B(H)). Proof. Assume first that TΦ is left invertible. Then there exists ε > 0 such that εf H 2 (H) ≤ TΦ f H 2 (H) ≤ Φf H 2 (H) ,
f ∈ H 2 (H).
Therefore ε¯ z n f L2 (H) ≤ Φ¯ z n f L2 (H) . Since the set {¯ z n f : f ∈ H 2 (H), n ≥ 0} is dense in L2 (H), it follows that εgL2 (H) ≤ ΦgL2 (H) ,
g ∈ L2 (H).
(4.4)
Let us show that Φ(ζ)xH ≥ εxH , x ∈ H, for almost all ζ ∈ T. Indeed, otherwise there are a positive δ, δ < ε, and a measurable subset ∆ of T of positive measure such that for each ζ ∈ ∆ there exists a nonzero x ∈ H for which Φ(ζ)xH ≤ δxH . Let χ be the characteristic function of [0, δ 2 ]. Clearly, χ((Φ(ζ))∗ Φ(ζ)) = O for ζ ∈ ∆. Denote by M the operator of multiplication by Φ∗ Φ on L2 (H). It is easy to see that χ(M ) = O. Clearly,
106
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
for f ∈ Range χ(M ) we have Φf L2 (H) ≤ δf L2 (H) , which contradicts (4.4). Let us get rid of the assumption that TΦ is left invertible. Since TΦ is left invertible on a subspace of finite codimension, it follows that TΦ is left invertible on z n H 2 (H) for some n ≥ 0, which is the same as saying that Tzn Φ is left invertible on H 2 (H). Therefore ζ n Φ(ζ)xH ≥ εxH , x ∈ H, a.e. on T, which is equivalent to the inequality Φ(ζ)xH ≥ εxH , x ∈ H, a.e. on T. The same reasoning applied to Φ∗ yields Φ∗ (ζ)xH ≥ κxH , x ∈ H, a.e. on T for some κ > 0. Consequently, Φ(ζ) is invertible almost everywhere on T and Φ−1 ∈ L∞ (B(H)). Note that in the finite-dimensional case for Φ ∈ L∞ (Mn ) the condition −1 Φ ∈ L∞ (Mn ) is equivalent to the condition (det Φ)−1 ∈ L∞ . As in the scalar case the Toeplitz operators with unitary-valued symbols play a special role as one can see from the following lemma. Lemma 4.3. Let H be a Hilbert space and let Φ be a function in L∞ (B(H)) such that Φ−1 ∈ L∞ (B(H)). Then Φ admits a representation Φ = U Ψ, where U is a unitary-valued function in L∞ (B(H)) and Ψ is an invertible function in H ∞ (B(H)). Proof. Consider the subspace L of L2 (H) defined by def
L = {Φg : g ∈ H 2 (H)}. It is easy to see that L is a closed subspace of L2 (H) invariant under multiplication by z. Let us show that it is completely nonreducing (see Appendix 2.3). Indeed, suppose that f is a nonzero function and z¯n f ∈ L for n ≥ 0. Then f = Φh for h ∈ H 2 (H). We can choose m > 0 such that z¯m h ∈ H 2 (H). Then z¯m f ∈ L, which contradicts our assumption. Then L has the form L = U H 2 (K), where K is a Hilbert space and U is a function in L∞ (B(K, H)) such that U (ζ) is isometric for almost all ζ ∈ T (see Appendix 2.3). Since Φ is invertible in L∞ (B(H)), we have H 2 (H) = Φ−1 U H 2 (K) and it is easy to see that U (ζ) maps K onto H for almost all ζ ∈ T. Therefore we can identify K with H after which U becomes a unitary-valued function in L∞ (B(H)). def
Put now Ψ = U ∗ Φ. Clearly, ΨH 2 (H) = H 2 (H), and so Ψ ∈ H ∞ (B(H)). The invertibility of Ψ in H ∞ (B(H)) is obvious. If Φ satisfies the conclusion of Lemma 4.3, then TΦ = TU TΨ , and so TΦ is invertible (Fredholm) if and only if TU is. As in the scalar case the following criterion holds. Theorem 4.4. Let H and K be Hilbert spaces, and let U be a function in L∞ (B(H, K)) such that U (ζ) is isometric for almost all ζ ∈ T. Then TU is a left invertible operator from H 2 (H) to H 2 (K) if and only if distL∞ (B(H,K)) {U, H ∞ (B(H, K))} < 1.
4. Toeplitz Operators on Spaces of Vector Functions
107
Proof. As in the scalar case we have U f 2L2 (K) = TU f 2H 2 (H) + HU f 2H 2 (H) , −
f ∈ H 2 (H).
It follows that TU is left invertible if and only if HU < 1. The result now follows from Theorem 2.2.2. Corollary 4.5. Let H be a Hilbert space and let U be a unitary-valued function in L∞ (B(H)). Then TU is invertible if and only if distL∞ (B(H)) {U, H ∞ (B(H))} < 1 and
distL∞ (B(H)) {U ∗ , H ∞ (B(H))} < 1.
As in §1 we can obtain now a Fredholmness criterion for Toeplitz operators with matricial unitary-valued symbols. Theorem 4.6. Let n be a positive integer and let U be a unitaryvalued function in L∞ (Mn ). The operator TU is Fredholm if and only if HU e < 1 and HU ∗ e < 1. The proof of Theorem 4.6 is exactly the same as the proof of Theorem 1.15. As in Theorem 1.15 one can also state necessary and sufficient conditions for left Fredholmness and right Fredholmness. To conclude this section we obtain a Fredholmness criterion for Toeplitz operators with symbols in (H ∞ + C)(Mn ) and compute their index. Throughout the book we use the following convention. If X is a space of functions, we denote by X(Cn ) the space of n × 1 column functions whose entries belong to X. Sometimes we shall use the notation {fj }1≤j≤n for the column function with entries fj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n. Similarly, we denote by X(Mn,m ) (or X(Mn ) if m = n) the space of m × n matrix functions with entries in X. If it does not lead to a confusion, we can write f ∈ X instead of f ∈ X(Cn ) or Φ ∈ X instead of Φ ∈ X(Mm,n ). The following theorem characterizes the Fredholm Toeplitz operators with symbols in H ∞ + C. Theorem 4.7. Let n be a positive integer and let Φ ∈ (H ∞ +C)(Mn ). The operator TΦ is Fredholm if and only if det Φ is invertible in H ∞ + C. Proof. Suppose that det Φ is invertible in H ∞ + C and Ψ = Φ−1 . Then Ψ ∈ H ∞ + C. By (4.3), I − TΦ TΨ = TΦΨ − TΦ TΨ = HΦ∗ ∗ HΨ ,
∗ I − TΨ TΦ = TΨΦ − TΨ TΦ = HΨ ∗ HΦ ,
and so it follows from the Hartman theorem that both I − TΦ TΨ and I − TΨ TΦ are compact, which means that TΦ is Fredholm. Suppose now that TΦ is Fredholm. It follows that TΦ is left invertible on z m H 2 (Cn ) for some m ≥ 0, which means that the operator Tzm Φ is left invertible. Clearly, it is sufficient to show that z m Φ is invertible in H ∞ +C. Without loss of generality we may assume that m = 0. By Theorem 4.2, Φ−1 ∈ L∞ , and so by Lemma 4.3, Φ admits a representation Φ = U Ψ, where U is a unitary-valued matrix function and Ψ is invertible in H ∞ . We have TΦ = TU TΨ . Since TΨ is invertible, it follows
108
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
that TU is left invertible and it is sufficient to show that U is invertible in H ∞ + C. By Theorem 4.4, there exists a function Ξ in H ∞ (Mn ) such that U − ΞL∞ < 1. Hence, I − TU ∗ Ξ < 1. It follows that TU ∗ Ξ = TU∗ TΞ is invertible. Since TU is Fredholm, it follows that TΞ is Fredholm. By Theorem 4.2, Ξ is invertible in L∞ , and so by Lemma 4.3, Ξ admits a representation Ξ = ΘG, where Θ is a unitary-valued inner function and G is invertible in H ∞ (Mn ). It remains to show that Θ is invertible in H ∞ + C. Since G is invertible in H ∞ , it follows that TG is invertible, and so TΘ = TΨ TG−1 is Fredholm. Hence, the subspace ΘH 2 (Cn ) of H 2 (Cn ) has finite codimension. By Lemma 2.5.1, Θ is a Blaschke–Potapov product of finite degree that implies that Θ is invertible in H ∞ + C. The following theorem computes the index of a Fredholm Toeplitz operator with symbol in (H ∞ + C)(Mn ) (see §3.3 for the definition of the winding number for scalar functions invertible in H ∞ + C). Theorem 4.8. Let Φ be a function in H ∞ + C(Mn ) such that TΦ is Fredholm. Then ind TΦ = − wind det Φ. Proof. We have lim distL∞ (Mn ) {Φ, z¯m H ∞ (Mn )} = 0,
m→∞
and so for any ε > 0 there exists F ∈ H ∞ (Mn ) such that Φ − z¯m F ∞ < ε. Clearly, if ε is sufficiently small, then Tz¯m F is Fredholm and ind TΦ = ind Tz¯m F . It is also clear that for a sufficiently small ε we have wind det Φ = wind det z¯m F. Hence, it is sufficient to show that ind Tz¯m F = − wind det z¯m F . Since Tz¯m F = Tz¯m In TF , we have ind Tz¯m F = ind Tz¯m In + ind TF = ind TF + mn (recall that In stands for the n × n identity matrix). It is also easy to see that wind det z¯m F = wind det F − mn. Therefore it is sufficient to show that ind TF = − wind det F . Since F is invertible in L∞ , it follows from Lemma 4.3 that F = ΘG, where Θ is an inner function in H ∞ (Mn ) and G is invertible in H ∞ (Mn ). Clearly, TG is invertible, wind det G = 0 (follows from Lemma 3.7). Hence, it suffices to show that ind TΘ = − wind det Θ. Since TΘ is Fredholm, it follows from Lemma 2.5.1 that Θ is a Blaschke– Potapov product of finite degree. Clearly, it is sufficient to consider the case when Θ has degree 1, i.e., Θ(ζ) =
λ−ζ ¯ P + (I − P ), 1 − λζ
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations
109
where λ ∈ D and P is an orthogonal projection on Cn of rank 1. Then by Lemma 2.5.1, ind TΘ = −1. On the other hand, it is easy to see that det Θ(ζ) =
λ−ζ ¯ , 1 − λζ
and so wind det Θ = 1.
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations of Symbols of Fredholm Toeplitz Operators In this section we show that the symbol of a Fredholm Toeplitz operator on H 2 (Cn ) admits a certain factorization (Wiener–Hopf factorization). This allows us to obtain a general Fredholmness criterion. With a Wiener– Hopf factorization we associate factorization indices. We obtain formulas for the dimension of the kernel of a Fredholm Toeplitz operators and for its index in terms of the factorization indices of its symbol. We also show that if the indices are arranged in the nondecreasing order, they are uniquely determined by the symbol. Let us first characterize the invertible Toeplitz operators. Theorem 5.1. Let Φ be an n×n matrix function in L∞ . The following are equivalent: (i) the Toeplitz operator TΦ is invertible; (ii) Φ admits a factorization Φ = Ψ1 Ψ2 , where Ψ1 and Ψ2 are n × n matrix functions such that both Ψ1 (ζ) and Ψ2 (ζ) are invertible for almost −1 2 all ζ ∈ T; Ψ1 , Ψ2 , Ψ−1 1 , Ψ2 belong to H (Mn ), and the operator R defined 2 n on the set of polynomials in H (C ) by Rf = Ψ−1 2 P+ Ψ1 2
−1
f
(5.1)
n
extends to a bounded operator on H (C ). −1
Note that P+ Ψ1 f is a polynomial for any polynomial f and so R maps polynomials in H 2 (Cn ) into H 2 (Cn ). Proof. Suppose that TΦ is invertible. Then there exist functions fj ∈ H 2 (Cn ) and gj ∈ H 2 (Cn ), 1 ≤ j ≤ n, such that O .. . ∗ TΦ fj = TΦ gj = 1 . .. O (1 is in the jth row). Consider the n × n matrix functions F = f1 · · · fn , G = g1 · · · gn .
110
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Clearly, (P+ ΦF )(ζ) = (P+ Φ∗ G)(ζ) = I, Φ∗ G
a.e. on T.
∈H . It follows that ΦF ∈ H and Put Ξ = G∗ ΦF . Then Ξ = G∗ (ΦF ) ∈ H 1 since both G∗ and ΦF are in H 2 . On the other hand, Ξ = (G∗ Φ)F ∈ H 1 since both G∗ Φ = (Φ∗ G)t and F are in H 2 . Therefore Ξ is a constant function. Assume that det Ξ = 0. We have det Ξ = det G(ζ) · det Φ(ζ)F (ζ) for almost all ζ ∈ T. Since the columns g1 (ζ), · · · , gn (ζ) of G(ζ) are linearly independent a.e. on T as well as the columns f1 (ζ) · · · , fn (ζ) of F (ζ), it follows that det Φ(ζ) = 0 a.e. on T. However, this contradicts the invertibility of TΦ (see Theorem 4.2). Hence, det Ξ = 0, and so Ξ is invertible. 2
def
2
def
Put Ψ1 = ΦF , Ψ2 = F −1 . Clearly, Ψ1 Ψ2 = ΦF F −1 = Φ. We have already shown that Ψ1 ∈ H 2 . We have −1 Ψ−1 = Ξ−1 G∗ ∈ H 2 . 1 = (ΦF ) 2 Obviously, Ψ−1 2 = F ∈ H . We have
Ψ2 = F −1 = Ξ−1 G∗ Φ = Ξ−1 (Φ∗ G)∗ ∈ H 2 . −1 2 Suppose now that Ψ1 , Ψ2 , Ψ−1 1 , Ψ2 ∈ H and Φ = Ψ1 Ψ2 . It remains to show that TΦ is invertible if and only if the operator R defined by (5.1) is bounded on H 2 (Cn ). Suppose that R is bounded. In this case it is easy to see that −1 −1 Ψ2 Rf = P+ Ψ1 f for an arbitrary f ∈ H 2 (Cn ) and so P+ Ψ1 f ∈ H 1 (Cn ) −1 for any f ∈ H 2 (Cn ). Hence, Rf = Ψ−1 f for any f ∈ H 2 (Cn ). 2 P+ Ψ1 −1 Let us show that TΦ is invertible and TΦ = R. We have for a polynomial f in H 2 (Cn )
= P+ Ψ1 Ψ2 Ψ−1 2 P+ Ψ1
TΦ Rf
= P+ Ψ1 Ψ1 since obviously, P+ Ψ1 P− Ψ1
−1
−1
−1
f = P+ Ψ1 P+ Ψ1
f − P+ Ψ1 P− Ψ1
−1
−1
f
f = f,
f = O. On the other hand,
RTΦ f = Ψ−1 2 P+ Ψ1
−1
P+ Ψ1 Ψ2 f = Ψ−1 2 P+ Ψ2 f = f,
and so TΦ is invertible and TΦ−1 = R. Suppose now that TΦ is invertible. We have f = TΦ TΦ−1 f = P+ Ψ1 Ψ2 TΦ−1 f = P+ Ψ1 P+ Ψ2 TΦ−1 f. −1
Multiplying by Ψ1
−1 P+ Ψ1 f
on the left and applying P+ , we obtain −1
= P+ Ψ1 P+ Ψ1 P+ Ψ2 TΦ−1 f ∈ (P+ L1 )(Cn ).
Therefore −1
P+ Ψ1 f
−1
−1
= P+ Ψ1 Ψ1 P+ Ψ2 TΦ−1 f − P+ Ψ1 P− Ψ1 P+ Ψ2 TΦ−1 f −1
= P+ Ψ1 Ψ1 P+ Ψ2 TΦ−1 f = Ψ2 TΦ−1 f,
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations
111
−1
since, obviously, P+ Ψ1 P− Ψ1 P+ Ψ2 TΦ−1 f = O. It follows that −1
TΦ−1 f = Ψ−1 2 P+ Ψ1 f,
f ∈ H 2 (Cn ).
−1
−1 2 n 2 n is a Hence, Ψ−1 2 P+ Ψ1 f ∈ H (C ) for any f ∈ H (C ) and R = TΦ 2 n bounded operator on H (C ). Let us now characterize the Fredholm Toeplitz operators in terms of factorizations of their symbols.
Theorem 5.2. Let Φ be an n×n matrix function in L∞ . The following are equivalent: (i) the Toeplitz operator TΦ is Fredholm; (ii) Φ admits a factorization Φ = Ψ1 ΛΨ2 , where Ψ1 and Ψ2 are n × n matrix functions such that both Ψ1 (ζ) and Ψ2 (ζ) are invertible for almost −1 2 all ζ ∈ T; Ψ1 , Ψ2 , Ψ−1 1 , Ψ2 ∈ H (Mn,n ); Λ is a diagonal matrix function of the form k O z 1 O ··· O z k2 · · · O Λ= . (5.2) .. .. , k1 , · · · , kn ∈ Z; .. .. . . . O
O
···
z kn
and the operator B defined on the set of polynomials in H 2 (Cn ) by Bf = Ψ−1 2 P+ ΛP+ Ψ1
−1
f
(5.3)
extends to a bounded operator on H 2 (Cn ). Factorizations of the form Φ = Ψ1 ΛΨ2 , where Ψ1 and Ψ2 are matrix functions invertible in H 2 (Mn,n ) and Λ is of the form (5.2), are called Wiener– Hopf factorizations of Φ. With such a factorization we associate Wiener– Hopf factorization indices (or simply factorization indices) k1 , k2 , · · · , kn . It is easy to see that if Φ has a Wiener–Hopf factorization, we can always find such a factorization that k1 ≤ k2 ≤ · · · ≤ kn . We show in this section that if the factorization indices are arranged in the nondecreasing order, they are uniquely determined by the function Φ itself. To prove Theorem 5.2 we start with the following lemma. Lemma 5.3. Let L be a finite-dimensional subspace of H 2 (Cn ). Then there exist a closed subspace L# of H 2 (Cn ) and analytic polynomials p1 , · · · , pn with zeros in D such that L ∩ L# = {O}, L + L# = H 2 (Cn ), and multiplication by the matrix function P , p1 O · · · O O p2 · · · O P = . .. . . .. , .. . . . O O · · · pn maps H 2 (Cn ) isomorphically onto L# .
112
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Proof. Let k = dim L. We argue by induction. Let us construct subspaces L0 , L1 , · · · , Lk = L# satisfying the following properties: (1) H 2 (Cn ) = Lj + L, 0 ≤ j ≤ k; (2) dim Lj ∩ L = k − j; (3) Lj = {Pj f : f ∈ H 2 (Cn )}, where Pj is a diagonal matrix function of the form O p1,j O · · · O p2,j · · · O Pj = . . .. , .. .. .. . . O
O
···
pn,j
and p1,j , · · · , pn,j are analytic polynomials with zeros in D. Put L0 = H 2 (Cn ). Suppose that we have already constructed Lj , j < k. Let us construct Lj+1 . Let g = {gr }1≤r≤n be a nonzero element in Lj ∩ L. Then there exist m, 1 ≤ m ≤ n, and ζ0 ∈ D such that gm (ζ0 ) = 0. Put def
Lj+1 = {Pj+1 f : f ∈ H 2 (Cn )}, where O p1,j O · · · O p2,j · · · O .. .. .. .. . . . . def Pj+1 = O O · · · (z − ζ 0 )pm,j . . . . .. .. .. .. O O ··· O
··· ··· .. . ··· .. . ···
O O .. .
. O .. . pn,j
Clearly, Lj+1 ⊂ Lj . Let us show that Lj = Lj+1 + span{g}. Indeed, let g = Pj g˘, g˘ ∈ H 2 (Cn ). Let f = Pj f˘, f˘ ∈ H 2 (Cn ), be an arbitrary function in Lj . We have f = Pj (f˘ + λ˘ g − λ˘ g ) = Pj (f˘ + λ˘ g ) − λg, λ ∈ C. We can ˘ now choose λ so that the mth component of (f + λ˘ g )(ζ0 ) is zero. Clearly, Pj (f˘ + λ˘ g ) ∈ Lj+1 , while λg ∈ span{g}. It follows that dim Lj+1 ∩ L = k − j − 1. We have Lj+1 + L = Lj+1 + (span{g} + L) = (Lj+1 + span{g}) + L = Lj + L = L by the inductive hypothesis. def Doing it this way, we can construct Lk . It remains to put L# = Lk . We have to introduce several classes of functions. We denote by R the algebra of rational matrix functions {fjk }1≤j,k≤n such that the poles of the fjk are outside T. We denote by R−1 the set of invertible elements of R. We also consider the class R + H 2 consisting of n × n matrix functions F that can be represented as F = G1 + G2 , where G1 ∈ R and G2 ∈ H 2 (Mn ). It is easy to see that R · H 2 ⊂ R + H 2 , i.e., F G ∈ R + H 2 for any F ∈ R and G ∈ H 2 . We denote by (R + H 2 )−1 the set of functions invertible in R + H 2 .
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations
113
Finally we need the class R∩H 2 , which is a subalgebra of R that consists of matrix functions in R with poles outside clos D. We denote by (R∩H 2 )−1 the set of invertible elements in R ∩ H 2 . To prove Theorem 5.2 we need the following result. Theorem 5.4. Let Ψ be a function of class (R + H 2 )−1 . Then Ψ admits a representation Ψ = Ξ1 ΛΞ2 , where Ξ1 , Ξ2 , Λ are matrix functions −1 2 2 such that Ξ1 , Ξ−1 1 ∈ H , Ξ2 , Ξ2 ∈ R ∩ H , and Λ is a diagonal matrix −1 function of the form (5.2). If Ψ ∈ R , then we can factorize Ψ so that 2 Ξ1 , Ξ−1 1 ∈R∩H . The proof of Theorem 5.4 is based on the following lemma. Lemma 5.5. Let F be an n × n matrix function in H 2 such that det F is not identically equal to 0 and det F (ζ0 ) = 0 for some ζ0 ∈ D. Then F admits a representation F = F1 W , where F1 ∈ H 2 , det F1 (ζ) = (ζ − ζ0 )−1 det F (ζ), and W is a matrix function of the form 1 0 ··· 0 ξ1 0 ··· 0 0 1 ··· 0 0 ··· 0 ξ2 .. .. . . .. .. .. . . .. . . . . . . . . 0 0 · · · 1 ξk−1 0 · · · 0 (5.4) W (ζ) = 0 0 · · · 0 ζ − ζ0 0 · · · 0 0 0 ··· 0 0 1 ··· 0 . . . . . .. . . .. . . .. .. .. .. . . . 0 0 ··· 0 0 0 ··· 1 for some k ∈ Z, 1 ≤ k ≤ n, and ξ1 , · · · , ξk−1 ∈ C. Proof of Lemma 5.5. Let f1 , · · · , fn ∈ H 2 (Cn ) be the columns of F . Since det Φ(ζ0 ) = 0, there exist k ≤ n and complex numbers ξ1 , · · · , ξk−1 such that fk (ζ0 ) = ξ1 f1 (ζ0 ) + · · · + ξk−1 fk−1 (ζ0 ). Consider the matrix function W defined by (5.4). It is easy ζ = ζ0 the matrix W (ζ) is invertible and −ξ1 0 ··· 0 1 0 · · · 0 ζ−ζ 0 −ξ2 0 1 · · · 0 ζ−ζ 0 ··· 0 0 .. .. . . .. .. .. . . . . . . . . .. . . 0 0 · · · 1 −ξk−1 0 · · · 0 ζ−ζ0 W −1 (ζ) = 1 0 0 ··· 0 0 ··· 0 ζ−ζ0 0 0 ··· 0 0 1 ··· 0 . . . . . . . . .. .. .. . . . ... .. .. 0 0 ··· 0 0 0 ··· 1
(5.5) to see that for .
114
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators def
Put F1 (ζ) = F (ζ)W −1 (ζ), ζ ∈ T. Clearly, det F1 (ζ) = (ζ−ζ0 )−1 det F (ζ). Let us show that F1 ∈ H 2 . It suffices to show that the kth column of F1 belongs to H 2 (Cn ). It is easy to see that the kth column of F1 is equal to 1 (−ξ1 f1 − · · · − ξk−1 fk−1 + fk ) ∈ H 2 (Cn ) z − ζ0 by (5.5). Proof of Theorem 5.4. Obviously, there exists a scalar analytic polynomial p with zeros in D such that P Ψ ∈ H 2 , where p O ··· O O p ··· O P = . . . . . . ... .. .. O
O ···
p
def
Let m = deg p. We have
Ψ = (P Ψ)
z¯m O .. .
O z¯m .. .
··· ··· .. .
O O .. .
O
O
···
z¯m
m −1 (z P ).
(5.6)
Clearly, P Ψ ∈ H 2 , (P Ψ)−1 ∈ R + H 2 , and (z m P −1 )±1 ∈ R + H 2 . Since Ψ ∈ (R + H 2 )−1 , it follows that det P Ψ has finitely many zeros in D. Let d be the number of zeros of det P Ψ in D (counted with multiplicities). For j = 0, · · · , d we construct by induction factorizations Ψ = Ξ1,j Λj Ξ2,j ,
(5.7)
where Ξ2,j ∈ (R ∩ H 2 )−1 , Λj is a diagonal matrix function of the form 2 (5.2), Ξ1,j ∈ H 2 , Ξ−1 1,j ∈ R + H , and det Ξ1,j has d − j zeros in D. After we do that we simply put Ξ1 = Ξ1,d , Λ = Λd , and Ξ2 = Ξ2,d . For j = 0 we take representation (5.6). Let 0 ≤ j < d and suppose that Ψ admits a representation of the form (5.7) satisfying the desired properties. Let s z 1 O ··· O O z s2 · · · O Λj = . .. .. . .. .. . . . O
O
···
z sn
Without loss of generality we may assume that s1 ≥ s2 ≥ · · · ≥ sn (otherwise we can change the order of the basis vectors in Cn and write matrix representations in the new basis). Let us apply Lemma 5.5 to F = Ξ1,j and obtain a representation 2 Ξ1,j = Ξ1,j+1 W , where W is given by (5.4), Ξ1,j+1 ∈ H 2 , Ξ−1 1,j+1 ∈ R + H , and det Ξ1,j+1 has d − j − 1 zeros in D.
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations
We have Ψ = Ξ1,j+1 W Λj Ξ2,j . It is easy where 1 0 ··· 0 ξ1 ζ¯ 0 1 ··· 0 ξ2 ζ¯ . . . .. . . . . ... . . . 1 ξk−1 ζ¯ def 0 0 · · · W# (ζ) = 0 0 · · · 0 1 − ζ0 ζ¯ 0 0 ··· 0 0 .. .. . . .. .. . . . . . 0 0 ··· 0 0 and
Λj+1
115
to see that W Λj = W# Λj+1 , ··· ··· .. .
0 0 .. .
0 ··· 0 ··· 1 ··· .. . . . . 0 ···
0 0 0 .. .
0 0 .. .
,
ζ ∈ T,
1
z s1 .. . O def = O O . ..
··· .. . ··· ··· ··· .. .
O .. .
O .. .
O .. .
z sk−1 O O .. .
O z sk +1 O .. .
O O z sk+1 .. .
··· .. . ··· ··· ··· .. .
O
···
O
O
O
···
O .. . 0 O . O .. . z sn
Let V be the matrix function satisfying the equation W# Λj+1 = Λj+1 V . Then V = Λ−1 j+1 W# Λj+1 . It is easy to see that def V (ζ) =
0
ξ1 ζ sk −s1 ξ2 ζ sk −s2 .. .
··· ··· .. .
0 0 .. .
··· ··· ··· .. .
1 0 0 .. .
ξk−1 ζ sk −sk−1 1 − ζζ0 0 .. .
0 ···
0
0
1 0 0 1 .. .. . . 0 0 0 0 0 0 .. .. . .
··· ··· .. .
0 0 .. .
0 ··· 0 ··· 1 ··· .. . . . . 0 ···
0 0 0 .. .
0 0 .. .
,
ζ ∈ T.
1 def
We have Ψ = Ξ1,j+1 Λj+1 Ξ2,j+1 , where Ξ2,j+1 = V Ξ2,j . Clearly, −1 V ∈ R ∩ H 2 and V ∈ R ∩ H 2 , and so Ξ2,j+1 ∈ (R ∩ H 2 )−1 . It is easy to see that if Ψ ∈ R−1 , then the function Ξ1 constructed above 2 satisfies Ξ1 , Ξ−1 1 ∈R∩H . Proof of Theorem 5.2. Suppose that TΦ is Fredholm. Let us first show that Φ admits a factorization of the form Ψ1 ΛΨ2 , where Ψ1 and Ψ2 are 2 matrix functions such that Ψ±1 j ∈ H , j = 1, 2, and Λ is a diagonal matrix function of the form (5.2).
116
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Put L = Ker TΦ . We can apply Lemma 5.3 and find a subspace L# and a diagonal polynomial P satisfying the conclusion of Lemma matrix function 5.3. Then Ker TΦ L# = Ker TΦ P H 2 (Cn ) = {O}. Hence, Ker TΦP = {O}. Since P is a diagonal matrix whose diagonal entries can have zeros only in D, it follows that TP is Fredholm, and so TΦP = TΦ TP is a Fredholm operator with trivial kernel. ∗ = TP ∗ Φ∗ and We can proceed in the same way with the operator TΦP find a diagonal polynomial matrix function Q whose diagonal entries can have zeros only in D such that TP ∗ Φ∗ Q is a Fredholm operator with trivial kernel. Clearly, TP ∗ Φ∗ Q maps H 2 (Cn ) onto itself, and so it is invertible. Hence, TQ∗ ΦP = TP∗ ∗ Φ∗ Q is invertible. By Theorem 5.1, there exist matrix functions Υ1 and Υ2 such that ±1 2 ∗ ∗ −1 Υ±1 Υ1 Υ2 P −1 . 1 , Υ2 ∈ H and Q ΦP = Υ1 Υ2 . It follows that Φ = (Q ) −1 t −1 Consider the functions (Q∗ )−1 Υ1 = (Q ) Υ1 and P Υ2 = (Υ2 P −1 )−1 . Clearly, they belong to (R + H 2 )−1 . Therefore by Theorem 5.4 there ex±1 ∈ H 2, ist matrix functions Ξ1 , Ξ2 , Ω1 , Ω2 , Λ1 , Λ2 such that Ξ±1 1 , Ξ2 ±1 ±1 Ω1 , Ω2 ∈ R ∩ H 2 , Λ1 and Λ2 are diagonal matrix functions of the form (5.2), and (Qt )−1 Υ1 = Ξ1 Λ1 Ω1 , P Υ−1 2 = Ξ2 Λ2 Ω2 . Therefore −1 −1 Φ = (Q∗ )−1 Υ1 Υ2 P −1 = Ξ1 Λ1 Ω1 Ω−1 2 Λ2 Ξ2 . −1 It is easy to see that Λ1 Ω1 Ω−1 ∈ R−1 . Applying Theorem 5.4 to 2 Λ2 −1 −1 Λ1 Ω1 Ω−1 , we can find matrix functions ∆1 , Λ, ∆2 such that 2 Λ2 ±1 2 2 ∆±1 1 ∈ R ∩ H , ∆2 ∈ R ∩ H , Λ is of the form (5.2), and −1 −1 −1 −1 Λ1 Ω1 Ω−1 = ∆−1 ∆1 . 2 Λ2 2 Λ
We now have Φ = Ψ1 ΛΨ2 ,
(5.8)
where Ψ1 = Ξ1 ∆1 and Ψ2 = ∆2 Ξ−1 2 . Clearly, Ψ1 and Ψ2 satisfy the requirements of Theorem 5.2. It remains to prove that if Φ ∈ L∞ (Mn,n ) satisfies (5.8) with Ψ1 ,Ψ2 , and Λ are as above, then TΦ is Fredholm if and only if the operator B defined by (5.3) extends to a bounded operator on H 2 . We can represent Λ in the form Λ = Λ− Λ+ , where d1 m z¯ O ··· O z 1 O ··· O O z¯d2 · · · O z m2 · · · O O = , Λ Λ−= . . . .. , . . + . . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . (5.9) mn dn O O ··· z O O · · · z¯ where d1 , · · · , dn ∈ Z+ and m1 , · · · , mn ∈ Z+ , and min{dj , mj } = 0,
1 ≤ j ≤ n.
5. Wiener–Hopf Factorizations
117
Clearly, kj = mj − dj (see (5.2)). It is easy to see that Λ− Λ+ = Λ+ Λ− . Now we are in a position to complete the proof of Theorem 5.2. −1 Suppose that B is bounded. It is easy to see that Ψ2 Bf = P+ ΛP+ Ψ1 f −1 for any f ∈ H 2 (Cn ). It follows that P+ ΛP+ Ψ1 f ∈ H 1 (Cn ) for any −1 2 n f ∈ H 2 (Cn ). Hence, Bf = Ψ−1 2 P+ ΛP+ Ψ1 f for any f ∈ H (C ). ∗ Let us show that the operators BTΦ − I and B TΦ∗ − I have finite rank, which would imply that TΦ is Fredholm. 2 n Let p be a polynomial in H 2 (Cn ) and f = Ψ−1 2 p ∈ H (C ). We have BTΦ f
−1
=
Ψ−1 2 P+ ΛP+ Ψ1 P+ Ψ1 ΛΨ2 f
=
−1 Ψ−1 2 P+ ΛP+ ΛΨ2 f = Ψ2 P+ ΛP+ Λp.
Consider the linear manifold def
L = {p = {pj }1≤j≤n : gj ∈ P A , z¯dj pj ∈ H 2 } and the subspace def
2 }. M = {p = {pj }1≤j≤n : gj ∈ P A , z¯dj pj ∈ H−
(5.10)
Clearly, dim M = d1 + · · · + dn . Obviously, Λp ∈ H (C ) for any p ∈ L, −1 and so BTΦ Ψ−1 2 p = Ψ2 p for p ∈ L. It follows that BTΦ f = f for any −1 f ∈ clos Ψ2 L. We need the following simple fact. Lemma 5.6. Let Ψ be an n×n function on T such that Ψ ∈ H 2 (Mn,n ) and Ψ−1 ∈ H 2 (Mn,n ). Then Ψ is an outer function, i.e., the set 2
n
def
K = {Ψp : p = {pj }1≤j≤n : pj ∈ P A } is dense in H 2 (Cn ). Proof. Suppose that ϕ ∈ H 2 (Cn ) and ϕ ⊥ K. We have
∗ (Ψ∗ (ζ)ϕ(ζ)) p(ζ)dm(ζ) 0 = (Ψp, ϕ) = T 1 for any polynomial p ∈ H 2 (Cn ). It follows that Ψ∗ ϕ ∈ H− (Cn ). Since 2/3 Ψ−1 ∈ H 2 (Mn,n ), it follows that ϕ = (Ψ∗ )−1 Ψ∗ ϕ ∈ H− (Cn ). Since 2 n 2 n ϕ ∈ L (C ), we have ϕ ∈ H− (C ), which is possible only if ϕ = O. Now we are able to complete the proof of Theorem 5.2. 2 n By Lemma 5.6, Ψ−1 2 (L + M) is dense in H (C ). Since BTΦ f = f on −1 −1 clos Ψ2 L and dim Ψ2 M = d1 + · · · + dn , it follows that
rank(BTΦ − I) ≤ d1 + · · · + dn < ∞. Consider now the operator B ∗ TΦ∗ − I. It is easy to see that B ∗ f = (Ψt1 )−1 P+ ΛP+ (Ψ∗2 )−1 f for any polynomial f . Now the proof of the fact that rank(B ∗ TΦ∗ − I) < ∞ is exactly the same as for the operator BTΦ − I.
118
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
Finally, suppose that TΦ is Fredholm. Let us show that the operator B defined on the set of polynomials by (5.3) extends to a bounded operator on H 2 (Cn ). Denote by X the space {f = ϕ + P+ ψ : ϕ, ψ ∈ L1 }. We can endow X with the natural norm f X = inf{ϕL1 + ψL1 : f = ϕ + P+ ψ}. Obviously, P+ is a bounded operator on X. Define the operator A on H 2 (Cn ) by −1 Af = P+ ΛP+ Ψ1 f. Clearly, Af = Ψ2 Bf if f is a polynomial in H 2 (Cn ). It is easy to see that A maps H 2 (Cn ) to X(Cn ). We have −1
ATΦ f = P+ ΛP+ Ψ1 P+ Ψ1 ΛΨ2 f = P+ ΛP+ ΛΨ2 f. It is easy to see that
ATΦ Ψ−1 2 p = p,
p ∈ L,
and so ATΦ f = Ψ2 f,
f ∈ clos Ψ−1 2 L.
(5.11)
We can define now Bf for each function f ∈ H 2 (Cn ) by Bf = Ψ−1 2 Af . It follows from (5.11) that BTΦ f = f for any f ∈ clos Ψ−1 L. Since TΦ is 2 2 n Fredholm, it follows that B maps the subspace TΦ clos Ψ−1 L into H (C ). 2 −1 By Lemma 5.6, TΦ clos Ψ2 L has finite codimension. −1 As we have already explained, P+ Ψ1 f is a polynomial for any polynomial f , and so B maps analytic vector polynomials into H 2 (Cn ). Let P m be the space of polynomials {pj }1≤j≤n such that deg pj ≤ m. Since −1 2 n codim TΦ clos Ψ−1 2 L < ∞, it follows that P m + TΦ clos Ψ2 L = H (C ) for 2 n some m ∈ Z+ . Hence, B is a bounded operator on H (C ). Let us now describe the kernel of TΦ end evaluate ind TΦ . Theorem 5.7. Ker TΦ = Ψ−1 2 M, where M is defined by (5.10). Proof of Theorem 5.7. It is easy to see that Ψ−1 2 M ⊂ Ker TΦ . Sup2 pose now that f ∈ Ker TΦ . This means that Ψ1 Λ− Λ+ Ψ2 f ∈ H− (Cn ). −1 2 1 n Since Ψ1 ∈ H (Mn,n ), it follows that Λ− Λ+ Ψ2 f ∈ H− (C ). Hence, Λ+ Ψ2 f = {pj }1≤j≤n , where pj is a polynomial, deg pj < dj if dj > 0 and pj = O if dj = 0. Since min{dj , mj } = 0, 1 ≤ j ≤ n, it follows that Ψ2 f = {pj }1≤j≤n which implies the result. Corollary 5.8. dim Ker TΦ = d1 + · · · + dn ,
ind TΦ = −(k1 + · · · + kn ).
Proof. The first equality follows immediately from Theorem 5.7. If we apply it to TΦ∗ = TΦ∗ , we find that dim Ker TΦ∗ = m1 + · · · + mn which implies the result.
6. Left Invertibility of Bounded Analytic Matrix Functions
119
Corollary 5.9. Suppose that under the above assumptions TΦ is Fredholm. Then TΦ is invertible if and only if Λ is identically equal to I. We conclude this section with the following result. Theorem 5.10. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (Mn,n ) be the symbol of a Fredholm Toeplitz operator on H 2 (Cn ). Suppose that k1 ≤ k2 ≤ · · · ≤ kn are the factorization indices of a Wiener–Hopf factorization of Φ. Then the indices kj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, are uniquely determined by the function Φ itself. Proof. Let m ∈ Z. Consider the function z m Φ. Clearly, Tzm Φ is Fredholm and z m Φ has a Wiener–Hopf factorization with indices m + k1 , m + k2 , · · · , m + kn . Consider the sequence {Nm }m∈Z defined by Nm = dim Ker Tzm Φ . By Corollary 5.8, Nm = 0,
m ≥ −k1 ,
and N−k1 −1 > 0.
This uniquely determines k1 . Let ν1 = N−k1 −1 . It follows from Corollary 5.8 that ν1 is the number of indices equal to k1 . We have k1 = · · · = kν1 and if ν1 < n, then kν1 +1 > k1 , and so k1 , · · · , kν1 are uniquely determined by the sequence {Nm }m∈Z . It follows from Corollary 5.8 that Nm = −ν1 (k1 + m),
−kν1 +1 ≤ m < −k1 ,
and N−kν1 +1 −1 > −ν1 (k1 − kν1 +1 − 1). This uniquely determines kν1 +1 . Put ν2 = N−kν1 +1 −1 + ν1 (k1 − kν1 +1 − 1). It follows easily from Corollary 5.8 that ν2 is the number of indices equal to kν1 +1 . Clearly, we can continue this process and determine all indices kj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, from the sequence {Nm }m∈Z .
6. Left Invertibility of Bounded Analytic Matrix Functions The famous Carleson corona theorem (see Appendix 2.1) says that if Ω is a function in H ∞ (Cn ) such that inf Ω(ζ)Cn > 0,
ζ∈D
(6.1)
then there exists a function Ξ in H ∞ (Cn ) such that Ξt (ζ)Ω(ζ) = 1 for all ζ ∈ D. Later this result was generalized to matrix functions; however, it
120
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
turns out that it does not generalize to the case of infinite matrix functions (see Concluding Remarks). We consider here another condition on a bounded analytic matrix function which is necessary and sufficient for left invertibility. Instead of (6.1) we assume that the Toeplitz operator TΩ is left invertible. Unlike condition (6.1), it also works in the case of infinite matrix functions. In this section we deal with functions taking values in the space Mm,n of m × n matrices. We identify Mm,n with the space of linear operators from Cn to Cm and equip Mm,n with the operator norm. We also admit the case of infinite matrix functions: if n = ∞, Cn is just the sequence space 2 . As usual, In stands for the identity matrix in Mn,n . The following theorem gives a necessary and sufficient condition for the left invertibility of a bonded analytic matrix function. The main tool in the proof is the commutant lifting theorem. Theorem 6.1. Let m and n be positive integers or equal to ∞, and K > 0. Let Ω be a function in H ∞ (Mm,n ). The following are equivalent: (i) there exists a function Ξ in H ∞ (Mn,m ) such that Ξ(ζ)Ω(ζ) = In ,
ζ ∈ D,
and
ΞH ∞ (Mn,m ) ≤ K;
(6.2)
(ii) the Toeplitz operator TΩ satisfies TΩ f H 2 (Cm ) ≥ K −1 f H 2 (Cn ) ,
f ∈ H 2 (Cn ).
(6.3)
Proof. Suppose first that (6.2) holds for a function Ξ in H ∞ (Mn,m ). We have TΞ TΩ = TΞΩ = I. Since TΞ = ΞH ∞ (Mn,m ) ≤ K, it follows that TΩ is left invertible and (6.3) holds. Conversely, assume that (6.3) holds. Consider the Toeplitz operator TΩ : H 2 (Cn ) → H 2 (Cm ). Clearly, ∗ TΩ = TΩ Sn∗ , Sm
(6.4)
where Sn and Sm are multiplications by z on H 2 (Cn ) and H 2 (Cm ). Let L be the range of TΩ . It follows from (6.3) that L is a closed subspace of H 2 (Cm ) and there exists a bounded linear operator Q : L → H 2 (Cn ) such that QTΩ = I and Q ≤ K. It follows easily from (6.4) that L is an ∗ invariant subspace of Sm and ∗ L = Sn∗ Q, QSm and so
(PL Sm L)Q∗ = Q∗ Sn ,
(6.5)
where PL is the orthogonal projection onto L. The operator Sn is isometric on H 2 (Cn). It is easy to see that the operator Sm is an isometric dilation of PL Sm L. The operator Q∗ intertwines Sn and PL Sm L. By the commutant lifting theorem (see Appendix 1.5),
Concluding Remarks
121
there exists a bounded linear operator R from H 2 (Cn ) to H 2 (Cm ) such that R ≤ K, Q∗ = PL RL, (6.6) and Sm R = RSn .
(6.7)
It follows easily from (6.7) that R has a block Toeplitz matrix. By Theorem 4.1, there exists a matrix function Ψ ∈ L∞ (Mm,n ) such that ΨL∞ ≤ K and R = TΨ . It also follows from (6.7) that Rz k H 2 (Cn ) ⊂ z k H 2 (Cm ), ∗ k ∈ Z+ . Hence, Ψ ∈ H ∞ (Mm,n ). Since L is an invariant subspace of Sm , ∗ ∗ it follows that L is also an invariant subspace of R = TΨ , and it follows from (6.6) that Q = PL R∗ L = R∗ L. Therefore I = QTΩ = R∗ TΩ = TΨ∗ TΩ . Hence, Ψ∗ Ω = In . It remains to put Ξ = Ψt . Theorem 6.1 admits an “invariant” reformulation. We need the following notation. If H and K are separable Hilbert spaces and Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)), we denote by Ψ# the function in L∞ (B(H, K)) defined by ¯ Ψ# (ζ) = Ψ(ζ),
ζ ∈ T.
Theorem 6.2. Let H and K be separable Hilbert spaces, K > 0, and let Ω ∈ H ∞ (B(H, K)). The following are equivalent: (i) there exists a function Ξ in H ∞ (B(K, H)) such that Ξ(ζ)Ω(ζ) = I,
ζ ∈ D,
and
ΞH ∞ (B(K,H) ≤ K;
(ii) the Toeplitz operator TΩ# satisfies TΩ# f H 2 (K) ≥ K −1 f H 2 (H) ,
f ∈ H 2 (H).
It is easy to see that Theorem 6.2 is equivalent to Theorem 6.1.
Concluding Remarks The systematic study of spectral properties of Toeplitz operators was started in the paper Brown and Halmos [1] in which Theorem 1.1 was obtained. Theorem 1.4 appeared in Coburn [1]. Theorem 1.6 is due to Wintner [1]. Theorem 1.7 can be found in Douglas [2]; see also Hartman and Wintner [1], where Corollary 1.8 was established. Theorem 1.9 is due to Brown and Halmos [1]. Theorems 1.11–1.13 were found by Widom [1] and Devinatz [1]. Theorem 1.14 was proved by N.K. Nikol’skii [2]. Finally, Theorem 1.15 is taken from Douglas and Sarason [1].
122
Chapter 3. Toeplitz Operators
The fundamental invertibility criterion, Theorem 2.1, was found in Widom [1] and Devinatz [1]. The remaining results of §2 are well-known; see Peller and Khrushch¨ev [1]. Theorem 3.1 was found in Hartman and Wintner [1]. Theorem 3.3 was discovered independently by many authors; see Gohberg [1], Mikhlin [1]. Theorems 3.2 and 3.5 are due to Douglas, see Douglas [2]. Theorem 3.10 was obtained in Sarason [3]. Theorem 3.11 was proved in Widom [1] in the case of finitely many jumps and in Devinatz [1] in the general case. Let us also mention the paper Krein [2] in which the theory of Toeplitz operators whose symbols have absolutely convergent Fourier series was developed. Theorems 4.1, 4.2, 4.4, and 4.6 are straightforward generalizations of the corresponding results in the scalar case. Theorem 4.8 is due to Douglas [3]. Theorems 5.1 and 5.2 were obtained in Simonenko [2]; see also Litvinchuk and Spitkovskii [1]. Theorems 5.7 and 5.10 are well-known. Theorem 6.1 was proved in Arveson [3] (for m = 1), Schubert [1], and Sz.-Nagy and Foias [2]. Note that in Fuhrmann [1] the following matricial corona theorem was proved: if Ω is a matrix function in H ∞ (Mm,n ) such that Ω(ζ)xCm ≥ δxCn for any ζ ∈ D and x ∈ Cn , then Ω is left invertible in the space of bounded analytic matrix functions. Vasyunin (see Tolokonnikov [1]) generalized this result to the case n = ∞ (in the case m = 1 and n = ∞ this was done by Tolokonnikov [1] and Rosenblum [4]). However, Treil [5] showed that these results do not generalize to the case of an arbitrary bounded analytic operator function. We also mention here the important and fruitful local theory of Toeplitz operator developed by Simonenko [1]. Another version of local theory was developed by Douglas [2]. A remarkable result by Widom [2] shows that the spectrum of Toeplitz operator is always connected; see also Douglas [2], where it was shown that the essential spectrum of a Toepliz operator is always connected. The spectral structure of self-adjoint Toeplitz operator was completely described in Ismagilov [1] and Rosenblum [3]. Earlier Rosenblum [2] showed that a self-adjoint Toeplitz operator must have absolutely continuous spectral measure. In Peller [7], [14], and [21] estimates of resolvents of Toeplitz operators for certain classes of symbols were obtained. Based on those estimates the existence of nontrivial invariant subspaces as well as some similarity results were found there. Note, however, that Treil [4] has shown that the resolvent of a Toeplitz operator with continuous symbol can grow arbitrarily fast. Interesting similarity theorems were obtained in Clark [4] and Yakubovich [1] for certain classes of Toeplitz operators. Let us mention here the classical Riemann–Hilbert problem. Given func2 tions g, h ∈ L2 , find functions f+ ∈ H 2 and f− ∈ H− such that
f+ = gf− + h.
Concluding Remarks
123
It is easy to see that the study of the Riemann–Hilbert problem is equivalent to the study of equations involving Toeplitz operators. Note that a complete solution of the Riemann–Hilbert problem with data in Λα was obtained for the first time by Gakhov [1]. Finally, we mention the following books and survey articles on Toeplitz operators: Douglas [2], [3], B¨ otcher and Silbermann [1], Nikol’skii [2]-[4], Peller and Khrushch¨ev [1], and Litvinchuk and Spitkovskii [1].
4 Singular Values of Hankel Operators
In this chapter we study singular values of Hankel operators. The main result of the chapter is the fundamental theorem of Adamyan, Arov, and Krein. This theorem says that if Γ is a Hankel operator, then to evaluate the nth singular value sn (Γ) of Γ, there is no need to consider all operators of rank at most n, sn (Γ) is the distance from Γ to the set of Hankel operators of rank at most n. In §1 we prove the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem in the special case when sn (Γ) is greater than the essential norm of Γ. In §2 we reduce the general case to the case treated in §1. In §1 we also prove the uniqueness of the corresponding Hankel approximant of rank at most n under the same condition sn (Γ) > Γe , and we obtain useful formulas for multiplicities of singular values of related Hankel operators. We prove a generalization of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem to the case of vectorial Hankel operators in §3. We also obtain in §3 a formula for the essential norm of vectorial Hankel operators. Finally, in §4 we consider relationships between the singular values of Hu and Hu¯ for unimodular functions u. We obtain a very useful formula that relates these two Hankel operators which leads to interesting results about the singular values of Hu and Hu¯ . We also obtain in §4 similar results for vectorial Hankel operators.
126
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
1. The Adamyan–Arov–Krein Theorem Recall that for a bounded linear operator T from a Hilbert space H1 to a Hilbert space H2 the singular values sm (T ), m ∈ Z+ , are defined by sm (T ) = inf{T − R : rank R ≤ m}.
(1.1)
Clearly, s0 (T ) = T and sm+1 (T ) ≤ sm (T ). Put s∞ (T ) = lim sm (T ). m→∞
It is easy to see that s∞ (T ) = T e , the essential norm of T . Clearly, T is compact if and only if s∞ (T ) = 0 (see Appendix 1.1). The main aim of this and the next section is to prove that in the case of a Hankel operator T to find sm (T ) we can consider the infimum in (1.1) over only the Hankel operators of rank at most m. 2 , m ≥ 0. Theorem 1.1. Let Γ be a Hankel operator from H 2 to H− Then there exists a Hankel operator Γm of rank at most m such that Γ − Γm = sm (Γ).
(1.2)
Since by Kronecker’s theorem rank Γm ≤ m if and only if Γm has a rational symbol of degree at most m, Theorem 1.1 admits the following ∞ be the set of functions f in L∞ such that P− f is a reformulation. Let H(m) ∞ rational function of degree at most m. Clearly, H(m) can be identified with the set of meromorphic functions in D bounded near T and having at most m poles in D counted with multiplicities. Theorem 1.2. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ , m ∈ Z+ . Then there exists a function ψ ∞ in H(m) such that ϕ − ψ∞ = sm (Hϕ ).
(1.3)
Note that the problem of approximation of an L∞ function on T by ∞ is called the Nehari–Takagi problem. functions in H(m) We shall consider in this section the case when sm (Γ) > s∞ (Γ). The proof in the case sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ) will be given in the next section. It turns out that in the case sm (Γ) > s∞ (Γ) there exists a unique Hankel operator Γm of rank at most m that satisfies (1.2). In other words, the following theorem holds. Theorem 1.3. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ , m ∈ Z+ . If sm (Hϕ ) > s∞ (Hϕ ), then ∞ there exists a unique ψ in H(m) that satisfies (1.3). Definition. Let T be a bounded linear operator from a Hilbert space H1 to a Hilbert space H2 . If s is a singular value of T and s > s∞ (T ), consider the subspaces Es(+) = {x ∈ H1 : T ∗ T x = s2 x}, (+)
Es(−) = {y ∈ H2 : T T ∗ y = s2 y}.
are called Schmidt vectors of T (or, more precisely, Vectors in Es (−) s-Schmidt vectors of T ). Vectors in Es are called Schmidt vectors of
1. The Adamyan–Arov–Krein Theorem
127
T ∗ (s-Schmidt vectors of T ∗ ). Clearly, x ∈ Es if and only if T x ∈ Es . A pair {x, y}, x ∈ H1 , y ∈ H2 , is called a Schmidt pair of T (s-Schmidt pair) if T x = sy and T ∗ y = sx. (+)
(−)
Proof of Theorem 1.1 in the case sm (Γ) > s∞ (Γ). Put s = sm (Γ). If s = Γ, the result is trivial. Assume that s < Γ. Then there exist positive integers k, µ such that k ≤ m ≤ k + µ − 1 and sk−1 (Γ) > sk (Γ) = · · · = sk+µ−1 (Γ) > sk+µ (Γ).
(1.4)
Clearly, it suffices to consider the case m = k. Lemma 1.4. Let {ξ1 , η1 } and {ξ2 , η2 } be s-Schmidt pairs of Γ. Then ξ1 ξ¯2 = η1 η¯2 . To prove the lemma we need the following identity (see formula (1.1.13)): P− (z n Γf ) = Γz n f,
n ∈ Z+ .
(1.5)
Proof of Lemma 1.4. Let n ∈ Z+ . We have ¯ ξ) 1 ξ2 (−n)
1 n 1 (z ξ1 , Γ∗ η2 ) = (Γz n ξ1 , η2 ) s s
=
(z n ξ1 , ξ2 ) =
=
1 (P− z n Γξ1 , η2 ) = (z n η1 , η2 ) = η) 1 η¯2 (−n) s
¯ ¯ by (1.5). Similarly, ξ) ¯2 . 1 ξ2 (n) = η) 1 η¯2 (n), n ∈ Z+ , which implies ξ1 ξ2 = η1 η Corollary 1.5. Let {ξ, η} be an s-Schmidt pair of Γ. Then the function η ϕs = (1.6) ξ is unimodular and does not depend on the choice of {ξ, η}. Proof. Let ξ1 = ξ2 = ξ, η1 = η2 = η in Lemma 1.4. It follows that |ξ|2 = |η|2 and so η/ξ is unimodular for any Schmidt pair {ξ, η}. Let {ξ1 , η1 } and {ξ2 , η2 } be s-Schmidt pairs of Γ. By Lemma 1.4, η1 /ξ1 = ξ¯2 /¯ η2 . Since η2 /ξ2 is unimodular, it follows that η1 /ξ1 = η2 /ξ2 . We resume the proof of Theorem 1.1. Put Γs = Hsϕs , where ϕs is defined by (1.6). Clearly, Γs ≤ s. The result will be established if we show that rank(Γ − Γs ) ≤ k. Let {ξ, η} be an s-Schmidt pair of Γ. Let us show that it is also an s-Schmidt pair of Γs . Indeed η Γs ξ = sP− ξ = sη, ξ
ξ Γ∗s η = sP+ η = sξ. η
Let E+ = {ξ ∈ H 2 : Γ∗ Γξ = s2 ξ},
2 E− = {η ∈ H− : ΓΓ∗ η = s2 η}
128
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
be the spaces of Schmidt vectors of Γ and Γ∗ . It is easy to see that dim E+ = dim E− = µ. It follows easily from if Γξ = Γs ξ, then Γz n ξ = Γs z n ξ for (1.5) that any n ∈ Z+ . Since Γs E+ = Γ E+ , it follows that Γ and Γs coincide on the S-invariant subspace spanned by E+ , where S is multiplication by z on H 2 . By Beurling’s theorem this subspace has the form ϑH 2 , where ϑ is an inner function (see Appendix 2.2). Denote by Θ multiplication by ϑ. We have ΓΘ = Γs Θ. The proof will be completed if we show that dim(H 2 ϑH 2 ) ≤ k. Put d = dim(H 2 ϑH 2 ). Lemma 1.6. The singular value s of the operator ΓΘ has multiplicity at least d + µ. Note that sj (ΓΘ) ≤ sj (Γ)Θ = sj (Γ) and so s∞ (ΓΘ) < s. It will follow from Lemma 1.6 that d < ∞. Proof of Lemma 1.6. Let τ be an inner divisor of ϑ (i.e., ϑτ −1 ∈ H ∞ ). Let us show that for any ξ ∈ E+ (Γs Θ)∗ (Γs Θ)¯ τ ξ = s2 τ¯ξ ∈ E+ .
(1.7)
Indeed it is easy to see that Γ∗ z¯f¯ = z¯Γf for any f ∈ H 2 . Let J be the transformation on L2 defined by Jf = z¯f¯. It follows that J maps E+ onto ¯ 2. E− . Since E+ ⊂ ϑH 2 , we have E− ⊂ ϑH − −1 ¯ ∗ , where Let ξ ∈ E+ , η = s Γξ ∈ E− . We can represent η as η = ϑη 2 η∗ ∈ H− . We have (Γs Θ)∗ (Γs Θ)¯ τξ
η τ ξ = s(Γs Θ)∗ P− η∗ τ¯ (Γs Θ)∗ sP− ϑ¯ ξ ξ¯ ¯ = s2 τ¯ξ, = s(Γs Θ)∗ η∗ τ¯ = s2 P+ ϑη ∗τ η =
which proves (1.7). Since d = dim(H 2 ϑH 2 ), it follows that for any n < d we can find inner divisors {ϑj }1≤j≤n+1 of ϑ such that ϑn+1 = ϑ, ϑj+1 ϑ−1 ∈ H ∞, j ϑj+1 ϑ−1 j = const, and ϑ1 = const (see Appendix 2.2). Then it follows from (1.7) that the subspace Ej = span{E+ , ϑ¯1 E+ , · · · ϑ¯j E+ },
1 ≤ j ≤ n + 1,
∗
consists of eigenvectors of (ΓΘ) (ΓΘ) corresponding to the eigenvalue s2 . Clearly, E1 \ E+ = ∅ and Ej+1 \ Ej = ∅, 1 ≤ j ≤ n. Therefore dim Ker (ΓΘ)∗ ΓΘ − s2 I ≥ dim En+1 ≥ µ + n + 1. Therefore the left-hand side is equal to ∞ if d = ∞ and is at least µ + d if d < ∞. We can now complete the proof of Theorem 1.1. As we have already observed, sj (ΓΘ) ≤ sj (Γ). Thus if d = ∞, then it follows from Lemma 1.6 that s is a singular value of Γ of infinite multiplicity, and so d < ∞. Again,
1. The Adamyan–Arov–Krein Theorem
129
by Lemma 1.6 we have sk+µ (Γ) < sk+µ−1 (Γ) = · · · = sk (Γ) = sd+µ−1 (ΓΘ) ≤ sd+µ−1 (Γ). Therefore d + µ − 1 < k + µ and so d ≤ k, which completes the proof of Theorem 1.1 in the case sm (Γ) > s∞ (Γ). Remark. Note that d = k. For otherwise if d < k, then it would follow that sk−1 (Γ) = s, which contradicts (1.4). Let Γ = Hϕ , where ϕ ∈ L∞ . Assuming (1.4) and s = sk (Hϕ ), we can consider the function 1 Γξ , (1.8) u = ϕs = · s ξ where ξ ∈ E+ , that is, Hϕ∗ Hϕ ξ = s2 ξ. Then u is a unimodular function and sk (Hϕ ) = ϕ − ψ∞ , where ψ = ϕ − su.
(1.9)
It has been shown in the proof of Theorem 1.1 that rank Γψ ≤ k. Since sk−1 (Hϕ ) > sk (Hϕ ), it follows that rank Γψ = k. Theorem 1.7. Let Γ = Hϕ be a Hankel operator satisfying (1.4) and let u be the unimodular function defined by (1.8). Then dim Ker Tu = 2k + µ. Remark. Clearly, dim Ker Tu is the multiplicity of the singular value 1 of Hu . Proof. Let us first show that dim Ker Tu ≥ 2k + µ. Let ϑ be the greatest common divisor of functions in E+ . Let us prove that for any inner divisor τ of ϑ both τ E+ and τ¯E+ are contained in Ker Tu . Let ξ ∈ E+ . Then Γξ η u= = . sξ ξ Therefore Tu τ ξ = P+ τ η = O, 2 . We since it has been shown in the proof of Theorem 1.1 that ϑE− ⊂ H− have Tu τ¯ξ = P+ τ¯η = O. ∞ Let {ϑj }1≤j≤k be inner divisors of ϑ such that ϑ1 = const, ϑ−1 j ϑj+1 ∈ H , −1 ϑj ϑj+1 = const, 1 ≤ j ≤ k − 1, and ϑk = ϑ. Consider the subspaces (1.10) ϑ¯k E+ , ϑ¯k−1 E+ , · · · , ϑ¯1 E+ , E+ , ϑ1 E+ , · · · , ϑk E+ . Clearly, dim ϑ¯k E+ = dim E+ = µ. Let Fj be the span of the j leftmost subspaces in (1.10), 1 ≤ j ≤ 2k + 1. Then Fj+1 \ Fj = ∅, 1 ≤ j ≤ 2k. It follows that dim F2n+1 ≥ 2k + µ and F2k+µ ⊂ Ker Tu .
130
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Suppose now that dim Ker Tu > 2k + µ. It follows that 1 is a singular value of Hu of multiplicity greater than 2k + µ. Therefore s is a singular value of Hϕ−ψ of multiplicity greater than 2k + µ. We have s = s2k+µ (Hϕ−ψ ) ≤ sk+µ (Hϕ ) + sk (Hψ ) (see Appendix 1.1). Since rank Hψ = k, it follows that sk (Hψ ) = 0 and so sk+µ (Hϕ ) ≥ s, which contradicts (1.4). To prove uniqueness, we need the following lemma. Lemma 1.8. Let u be a unimodular function such that ∞ N = dim Ker Tu > 0. Let f be a function in H(N −1) such that P− f = O. Then Hu+f > 1. ∞ Proof. Since f ∈ H(N −1) , there exists a finite Blaschke product B of degree at most N − 1 such that Bf ∈ H ∞ . Let v = Bu. Then ' dim Ker Tv = dim Ker Tu BH 2 > 0. Clearly, Hv g2 = g2 for any g ∈ Ker Tv , and by Theorem 1.4 of Chapter 1, v admits a representation ¯ h v = z¯ϑ¯ , h where ϑ is an inner function and h is an outer function in H 2 . Clearly, Hu h2 = h2 . ¯ Therefore ¯ h. Let us show that Hu h ⊥ Hf h. We have Hu h = z¯ϑ¯B ¯ f h) = (¯ ¯ Bf h) = 0, ¯ h, (Hu h, Hf h) = (¯ z ϑ¯B z ϑ¯h, since Bf ∈ H ∞ . Consequently, Hu+f h2 = h2 + Hf h2 . To complete the proof, it suffices to show that Hf h = O. Suppose that Hf h = O. Then Hf z n h = O and since h is outer, it would follow that Hf = O, which contradicts the assumption P− f = O. Proof of Theorem 1.3. Suppose that there exists a function q in ∞ such that q = ψ and H(k+µ−1) ϕ − q∞ = sk (Hϕ ).
(1.11)
We have ϕ − q = ϕ − ψ + ψ − q. Let u = (ϕ − ψ)/sk (Hϕ ), f = (ψ − q)/sk (Hϕ ). By Theorem 1.7, ∞ ∞ , q ∈ H(k+µ−1) and so dim Ker Tu = 2k + µ. Clearly, ψ ∈ H(k) ∞ ψ − q ∈ H(2k+µ−1) . If P− (ψ − q) = O, it follows from Lemma 1.8 that Hu+f > 1 and so Hϕ−q > sk (Hϕ ), which contradicts (1.11). Thus ψ − q ∈ H ∞ . The Hankel operator Hϕ−ψ attains its norm on the unit ball of H 2 , since for any ξ ∈ E+ Hϕ−ψ ξ2 = sk (Hϕ ) · ξ2 = Hϕ−ψ · ξ2 .
2. The Case sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ)
131
Therefore if (1.11) holds, we have Hϕ−ψ = ϕ − ψ∞ = ϕ − ψ + (ψ − q)∞ . By Theorem 1.1.4 it follows that ψ − q = O. ∞ Remarks. 1. It follows from (1.9) that the function ψ in H(m) satisfying the equality ϕ − ψ∞ = sm (Hϕ ) is given by
ψ =ϕ−
Hϕ ξ , ξ
(1.12)
where ξ is an arbitrary nonzero function satisfying Hϕ∗ Hϕ = s2m ξ. 2. It will be shown in §7.1 that if ϕ ∈ V M O, then ϕ − ψ ∈ QC and so it will follow from Theorem 1.7 that wind(ϕ − ψ) = −(2k + µ).
2. The Case sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ) In this section we complete the proof of Theorem 1.1. To this end we ˜ > s∞ (Γ) ˜ and ˜ for which sm (Γ) construct an auxiliary Hankel operator Γ ˜ apply Theorem 1.1 to Γ, which we can do because of the above inequality. ˜ we make use of the one-step extension method, which has To construct Γ been used in Chapter 2 to establish the analog of the Nehari theorem for vectorial Hankel operators. Proof of Theorem 1.1 in the case sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ). If sm (Γ) = s0 (Γ), the situation is trivial (Γm = O). Assume that sk−1 (Γ) > sk (Γ) = sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ). It is sufficient to show that there exists a Hankel operator Γk of rank k such that Γ − Γk = sk (Γ). Let ρ be a real number satisfying sk−1 (Γ) > ρ > sk (Γ).
(2.1)
Let us show that if ρ satisfies (2.1), then there exists a Hankel operator Hψ such that rank Hψ ≤ k and Γ − Hψ ≤ ρ. To do that, we reduce the situation to the case already treated in §1. ˜ such that Namely, we construct an auxiliary Hankel operator Γ ˜ − ρ2 I) = {O} ˜∗Γ Ker(Γ
(2.2)
˜ ≥ sk−1 (Γ) ≥ sk (Γ) ˜ ≥ sk (Γ) ≥ sk+1 (Γ). ˜ sk−1 (Γ)
(2.3)
and
132
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
˜ in the form We are searching for such a Γ f ∈ H 2,
˜ = z¯Γf + (f, h)¯ Γf z,
(2.4)
where H ∈ H 2 . ˜ defined by Let us find out under which conditions on h the operator Γ (2.4) is a Hankel operator. In other words, we have to characterize those h for which ˜ n = P− z n Γ1, ˜ Γz
n ≥ 0.
(2.5)
˜ satisfies (2.5) if and only if Let Γ = Hϕ . It is easy to see that Γ ˆ h(n) = ϕ(−n), ˆ
n > 1.
˜ = Hϕ , then ϕˆ1 (−n) = ϕ(−n If Γ ˆ + 1), n > 1. Let α = ϕˆ1 (−1). Then 1 ¯ + zΓ∗ z¯. h=α ¯ + zP+ z¯ϕ¯ = α
(2.6)
It follows from (2.4) that ˜ ∗ Γf ˜ = Γ∗ Γf + (f, h)h, Γ
f ∈ H 2.
˜ is a perturbation of Γ∗ Γ by a nonnegative rank one operator, ˜∗Γ Therefore Γ which implies (2.3) (see Appendix 1.1). Lemma 2.1. For any ρ ∈ (sk (Γ), sk−1 (Γ)) sufficiently close to sk (Γ) there exists α ∈ C such that (2.2) holds. By Lemma 2.1, if ρ is sufficiently close to sk (Γ), then ρ is a singular ˜ and since (2.3) is satisfied, the only possibility is that ρ = sk (Γ). ˜ value of Γ, ˜ Clearly, s∞ (Γ) = s∞ (Γ) < ρ. So it follows from the part of Theorem 1.1 already treated in §1 that there exists a Hankel operator Hψ1 such that ˜ − Hψ = sk (Γ) ˜ = ρ. As we have already observed, rank Hψ1 = k and Γ 1 ˜ = Hϕ , where ϕˆ1 (n) = ϕ(n Γ ˆ + 1), n ≤ −2, and so 1 ˜ Γ = P− S Γ, where S is multiplication by z on L2 . Put ψ = zψ1 . We have ˜ − P− SHψ ≤ Γ ˜ − Hψ = ρ. Γ − Hψ = P− S Γ 1 1 On the other hand, rank Hψ = rank P− SHψ1 ≤ rank Hψ1 = k. To complete the proof, we can take a sequence {ρn } in (sk (Γ), sk−1 (Γ)) that tends to sk (Γ) and construct a sequence of Hankel operators Hϕn such that rank Hϕn ≤ k and Γ − Hϕn ≤ ρn . Since the operators Hϕn are uniformly bounded, there exists a subsequence weakly convergent to an operator, say Γm . It is easy to see that rank Γm ≤ k and Γm is a Hankel operator. Clearly, Γ − Γm ≤ sk (Γ), which completes the proof.
2. The Case sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ)
133
Proof of Lemma 2.1. Clearly, (2.2) is equivalent to the fact that there is a nonzero f in H 2 satisfying (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)f = (f, h)h.
(2.7)
Put Rρ = (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 and r(ρ) = (Rρ 1, 1). It is easy to see that there can be at most one ρ in (sk (Γ), sk−1 (Γ)) such that r(ρ) = 0. Indeed, r is differentiable on (sk (Γ), sk−1 (Γ)) and dr(ρ) = −2ρ(Rρ2 1, 1) < 0, dρ
ρ ∈ (sk (Γ), sk−1 (Γ)),
and so r is strictly decreasing on (sk (Γ), sk−1 (Γ)). Lemma 2.2. If r(ρ) = 0, then there exists α ∈ C such that the function h defined by (2.6) satisfies (Rρ h, h) = 1.
(2.8)
Let us first complete the proof of Lemma 2.1. Put f = Rρ h, then f is nonzero and satisfies (2.7). ¯ + g. Proof of Lemma 2.2. Put g = zΓ∗ z¯. Then (2.6) means that h = α It is easy to see that (2.8) is equivalent to the following equation: α(Rρ 1, g)) + (Rρ g, g) = 1. |α|2 r(ρ) + 2 Re (¯ Multiplying both sides of this equation by r(ρ), we see that it is equivalent to the following one: |αr(ρ) + (Rρ 1, g)|2 = r(ρ) + |(Rρ 1, g)|2 − r(ρ)(Rρ g, g).
(2.9)
Let us prove that r(ρ) + |(Rρ 1, g)|2 − r(ρ)(Rρ g, g) =
1 . ρ2
(2.10)
If we do that, we can put for any complex τ of modulus 1 α=
(Rρ 1, g) τ − . ρr(ρ) r(ρ)
Clearly, α satisfies (2.9). Thus to complete the proof, we have to verify (2.10). Let J be the operator on L2 defined by Jf = z¯f¯, f ∈ L2 . Put Γ = SJΓ, where S is multiplication by z on H 2 . Clearly, Γ 1 = Γ1 = g. We are going to establish the identity Γ Rρ 1 = ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ g − ρ2 (Rρ g, 1)Rρ 1.
(2.11)
134
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Let us first show that (2.11) implies (2.10). Taking the inner product of both sides of (2.11) with g = Γ 1, we obtain ρ2 r(ρ)(Rρ g, g) − ρ2 |(Rρ g, 1)|2
=
(Γ Rρ 1, Γ 1) = (SJΓRρ 1, SJΓ1)
=
(JΓRρ 1, JΓ1) = (Γ1, ΓRρ 1)
=
(1, Γ∗ ΓRρ 1) = ρ2 r(ρ) − 1,
which proves (2.10). To establish (2.11), we apply to both sides of (2.11) the operator Rρ−1 = ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ and find that it is equivalent to Rρ−1 Γ Rρ 1 = ρ2 r(ρ)g − ρ2 (Rρ g, 1)1.
(2.12)
Let P0 be the orthogonal projection from H 2 onto the space of constant functions, i.e., P0 f = (f, 1)1. Let us show that (I − P0 )Rρ−1 Γ Rρ 1 = ρ2 r(ρ)g
(2.13)
(Rρ−1 Γ Rρ 1, 1) = −ρ2 (Rρ g, 1),
(2.14)
and
which will imply (2.12). Let us first prove (2.13). It is easy to check that JΓ = Γ∗ J and JΓS = S ∗ Γ∗ J. Hence, (Γ )2 = SJΓSJΓ = SS ∗ Γ∗ Γ = (I − P0 )Γ∗ Γ. It follows that (I − P0 )Rρ−1 = (I − P0 )(ρ2 I − (Γ )2 ).
(2.15)
Hence, (I − P0 )Rρ−1 Γ Rρ 1 = (I − P0 )(ρ2 I − (Γ )2 )Γ Rρ 1 = Γ (ρ2 I − (Γ )2 )Rρ 1 = Γ (I − P0 )(ρ2 I − (Γ )2 )Rρ 1 + Γ P0 (ρ2 − (Γ )2 )Rρ 1. By (2.15) Γ (I − P0 )(ρ2 I − (Γ )2 )Rρ 1 = Γ (I − P0 )1 = O. Thus (I − P0 )Rρ−1 Γ Rρ 1 =
Γ P0 (ρ2 − (Γ )2 )Rρ 1
= ρ2 Γ P0 Rρ 1 = ρ2 r(ρ)Γ 1 = ρ2 r(ρ)g, since P0 Γ = O. It remains to prove (2.14). We have ΓΓ = J(JΓS)JΓ = J(S ∗ Γ∗ J)JΓ = JS ∗ (ρ2 I − Rρ−1 ).
3. Finite Rank Approximation of Vectorial Hankel Operators
135
Consequently, (Rρ−1 Γ Rρ 1, 1)
= ρ2 (Γ Rρ 1, 1) − (Γ∗ ΓΓ Rρ 1, 1) = −(JS ∗ (ρ2 I − Rρ−1 )Rρ 1, Γ1) = −ρ2 (JS ∗ Rρ 1, Γ1) = −ρ2 (JΓ1, S ∗ Rρ 1) = −ρ2 (g, Rρ 1),
since Γ f ⊥ 1 for any f ∈ H 2 , which completes the proof.
3. Finite Rank Approximation of Vectorial Hankel Operators In this section we present another approach to the problem of finite rank approximation of Hankel operators which works in both cases sm (Γ) > s∞ (Γ) and sm (Γ) = s∞ (Γ). Moreover, it also works in the case of vectorial Hankel operators. However, the proof given in §1 for the scalar case gives more information on the best approximant. As an application we find a formula for the essential norm of a vectorial Hankel operator. Let H and K be separable Hilbert spaces. The main result of this section is the following generalization of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem. Theorem 3.1. Let Φ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)). Then sn (HΦ ) = inf{Φ − Ψ∞ : rank HΨ ≤ n}. Remark. It is easy to see that “infimum” in the statement of Theorem 3.1 can be replaced with “minimum”. Indeed, if {Ψj } is a bounded sequence of functions in L∞ (B(H, K)) such that rank HΨj ≤ n and ˆ j (m) Φ − Ψj ∞ → sn (HΦ ), there exists a subsequence {Ψjk } such that Ψ k ∞ ˆ converges weakly to Ψ(m), m ∈ Z, for some Ψ ∈ L (B(H, K)). It is easy to see that the sequence {HΨjk } converges to HΨ in the weak operator topology, and so rank HΨ ≤ n. Clearly, Φ − Ψ∞ = sn (HΦ ). To prove Theorem 3.1, we make use of the following fact, which will be established after the proof of Theorem 3.1. Theorem 3.2. Let A be a bounded self-adjoint operator and S a bounded operator on a Hilbert space H. Let C = {x ∈ H : (Ax, x) ≥ 0} and let P− = E((−∞, 0)), P+ = E([0, ∞)), where E is the spectral measure of A. Suppose that the following conditions are satisfied: def (a) A− = A |Range P− is invertible; (b) SC ⊂ C; (c) P+ SP− is compact. Then there exists a subspace L of H such that SL ⊂ L and L ⊂ C, and L is a maximal (by inclusion) subspace of H contained in C.
136
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Put H− = P− H, H+ = P+ H, and A− = AH− , A+ = AH+ . Denote by M the set of subspaces L of H such that L ⊂ C and P+ L = H+ . Clearly, M = ∅, since H+ ∈ M. To deduce Theorem 3.1 from Theorem 3.2 we need the following lemma. Lemma 3.3. The following assertions hold: (i) if L ∈ M, then there exists a unique operator TL : H+ → H− such that L = {x + TL x : x ∈ H+ };
(3.1)
(ii) the set {TL : L ∈ M} is a convex subset of B(H+ , H− ), which is compact in the weak operator topology; (iii) if L is a subspace of H, L ⊂ C, then L belongs to M if and only if it is a maximal subspace contained in C; (iv) if rank A− < ∞, L is a subspace of H, L ⊂ C, then it belongs to M if and only if codim L = rank A− . First we deduce Theorem 3.1 from Theorem 3.2. Then we prove Lemma 3.3 and, finally, we prove Theorem 3.2. Proof of Theorem 3.1. Let H = H 2 (H), A = s2n (HΦ )I − HΦ∗ HΦ , and S is multiplication by z on H 2 (H). Clearly, in this case C = f ∈ H 2 (H) : HΦ f ≤ sn (HΦ )f . It is easy to see that if f ∈ C, then HΦ SF ≤ HΦ f ≤ sn (HΦ )f = sn (HΦ )Sf . Hence SC ⊂ C. Clearly, rank P− ≤ n, and so conditions (a) and (c) in the statement of Theorem 3.2 are obviously satisfied. By Theorem 3.2 and Lemma 3.3, (iii), (iv) there exists a subspace L ⊂ H 2 (H) such that SL ⊂ L, codim L ≤ n, and L ⊂ C. Clearly, the last inclusion means that HΦ L ≤ sn (HΦ ). (3.2) By Lemma 2.5.1, there exists a Blaschke–Potapov product B of finite degree such that L = BH 2 (H). Therefore HΦ L = HΦ BH 2 (H) = HΦB , and it follows from (3.2) that HΦB ≤ sn (HΦ ). By Theorem 2.2.2, there exists a function Ω in H ∞ (H, K) such that HΦB = ΦB − Ω∞ . Since B takes unitary values on T , we have ΦB − Ω∞ = Φ − ΩB ∗ ∞ . Since L = BH 2 (H) ⊂ Ker HΩB ∗ , it follows that rank HΩB ∗ ≤ codim L ≤ n, and so inf{Φ − Ψ : rank HΨ ≤ n} ≤ Φ − ΩB ∗ ∞ ≤ sn (HΦ ).
3. Finite Rank Approximation of Vectorial Hankel Operators
137
The opposite inequality sn (HΦ ) ≤ inf{Φ − Ψ∞ : rank HΨ ≤ n} is trivial. Proof of Lemma 3.3. (i) Let x ∈ C. Then x = x+ + x− , where x+ = P+ x, x− = P− x. We have −1 0 ≤ (Ax, x) = (A+ x+ , x+ ) + (A− x− , x− ) ≤ A+ · x+ 2 − A−1 x− 2 . −
Therefore 1/2 x+ . x− ≤ (A+ · A−1 − )
(3.3)
This implies that P+ |L is bounded from below, since it follows from (3.3) that for x ∈ L 2 x2 = x+ 2 + x− 2 ≤ (1 + A+ · A−1 − )x+ .
Thus we can put
TL = P− (P+ L)−1 ,
(3.4)
which is well-defined on H+ . It is easy to check that (3.1) holds. The uniqueness of TL is obvious. (ii) The fact that the set {TL : L ∈ M} is bounded follows from (3.3) and (3.4): 1/2 TL ≤ (A+ · A−1 − ) for any L in M. Let us show that it is convex. Let L1 , L2 ∈ M, λ ∈ (0, 1), def
and Tλ = λTL1 + (1 − λ)TL2 . If x ∈ H+ , we have (A(x + Tλ x), x + Tλ x)
= (A+ x, x) + (A− Tλ x, Tλ x) ≥ (A+ x, x) + min (A− TLj x, TLj x) ≥ 0, j=1,2
since L1 , L2 ∈ M. Consequently, {x + Tλ x : x ∈ H+ } ∈ M for λ ∈ (0, 1). Since for any x+ ∈ H+ , the set {x− ∈ H− : (A(x+ + x− ), x+ + x− ) ≥ 0} is closed, it follows that the set {TL : L ∈ M} is closed in the strong operator topology and since this set is convex, it is also closed in the weak operator topology (see Dunford and Schwartz [1], VI.1.5). Hence, it is weakly compact. (iii) Let L ∈ M. We are going to show that L is a maximal subspace contained in C. Suppose that L is a subspace of H and L ⊂ L ⊂ C. It follows that P+ L = H+ and by (i) L = {x + TL x : x ∈ H+ }. On the other hand, L = {x + TL x : x ∈ H+ }. Since L ⊂ L , it follows that TL = TL and so L = L.
138
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Suppose now that L is a maximal subspace of C but P+ L = H+ . Since L is bounded from below, it follows that it has been proved in (i) that P + P+ L is a closed subspace of H+ . Assume first that A+ is invertible. Then A+ P+ L is a closed subspace of H+ and A+ P+ L = H+ . Put L = L + (H+ A+ P+ L). Clearly, L = L. If x ∈ L and f ∈ H+ A+ P+ L, we have (A(x + f ), x + f ) = (A− x− , x− ) + (A+ (x+ + f ), x+ + f ) = (A− x− , x− ) + (A+ x+ , x+ ) + (A+ f, f ) ≥ (Ax, x) ≥ 0. Hence, L ⊂ C, which contradicts the assumption that L is maximal. Let us now consider the general case. Put 1 A(n) = A− P− + A+ + IH+ P+ , n ≥ 1. n
(n)
Then A+ is invertible. Clearly, def
L ⊂ Cn = {x ∈ H : (A(n) x, x) ≥ 0}. By Zorn’s lemma L is contained in a maximal subspace of Cn and since (n) A+ is invertible, we have already proved there exists Tn : H+ → H− such that L ⊂ {x + Tn x : x ∈ H+ } ⊂ Cn . Clearly, sup Tn < ∞. Let T be the weak limit of a subsequence of n
{Tn }n≥1 . Since Cn+1 ⊂ Cn , we have
'
L ⊂ {x + T x : x ∈ H+ } ⊂
Cn = C.
n≥1
Clearly, {x + T x : x ∈ H+ } ∈ M and since L is maximal, it follows that L = {x + T x : x ∈ H+ } ∈ M. (iv) Since codim H+ = rank A− , the result follows from the following equality, which is valid for any bounded operator T : H+ → H− : codim{x + T x : x ∈ H+ } = codim H+ . To prove Theorem 3.2 we need the following fact. Lemma 3.4. Let H1 , H2 be Hilbert spaces and let X be a convex subset of B(H1 , H2 ) that is compact in the weak operator topology. Let α be a map from X to B(H1 ) and β a map from X to B(H1 , H2 ) that satisfy the following conditions: (1) for any X ∈ X there exists Y ∈ X such that Y α(X) = β(X); (2) the map F : X × X → B(H1 , H2 ) defined by F (X, Y ) = Y α(X) − β(X)
(3.5)
3. Finite Rank Approximation of Vectorial Hankel Operators
139
is jointly continuous in the weak operator topology. Then there exists X0 ∈ X such that X0 α(X0 ) = β(X0 ). Proof of Theorem 3.2. Put H1 = H+ , H2 = H− , X = {TL : L ∈ M}, α(X) = P+ S H+ + P+ SX, β(X) = P− S H+ + P− SX,
X ∈ X, X ∈ X.
By Lemma 3.3, X is convex and weakly compact. Since the operator P+ SP− is compact and P+ SX = P+ SP− X, X ∈ X , it follows that the function F defined by (3.5) satisfies condition (2) of Lemma 3.4. Let us verify condition (1). Since SC ⊂ C and any subspace contained in C is contained in a maximal subspace in C (i.e., a subspace from M), it follows that for any L ∈ M there exists L ∈ M such that SL ⊂ L .
(3.6)
If x ∈ C, L ∈ M, then x ∈ L if and only if TL P+ x = P− x.
(3.7)
Clearly, SL = {Sx + STL x : x ∈ H+ }. It follows from (3.7) that (3.6) is equivalent to the fact that TL (P+ Sx + P+ STL x) = P− Sx + P− STL x
(3.8)
for any x ∈ H+ , which means that condition (1) of Lemma 3.4 is satisfied. It follows from Lemma 3.4 that there exists L ∈ M such that (3.8) holds with L = L, which means that SL ⊂ L. Lemma 3.4 follows trivially from the following fact. Theorem 3.5. Let W be a locally convex Hausdorff space, X a compact convex subset of W , and F a continuous map from X × X to W such that F (x, λy1 +(1−λ)y2 ) = λF (x, y1 )+(1−λ)F (x, y2 ), x, y1 , y2 ∈ X , 0 ≤ λ ≤ 1. If for any x ∈ X there exists y ∈ X such that F (x, y) = O, then there exists x0 ∈ X such that F (x0 , x0 ) = O. Note that if F (x, y) = y − f (x), where f is a continuous map from X to X , then Theorem 3.5 turns into Tikhonov’s fixed point theorem (see Edwards [1], §3.6). Lemma 3.6. Let X be a compact convex subset in a locally convex space and let Q be a closed subset of X × X such that (x, x) ∈ Q for any x ∈ X and the set {y ∈ X : (x, y) ∈ Q} is convex for any x ∈ X . Then there exists x0 ∈ X such that (x0 , y) ∈ Q for any y ∈ X .
140
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Let us first deduce Theorem 3.5 from Lemma 3.6. Proof of Theorem 3.5. Let {ρν } be a set of seminorms that determines the topology in W . Put Gν = {x ∈ X : ρν (F (x, x)) = 0} . Since X is compact, it is sufficient to show that for any finite set ν1 , · · · , νn the set n ' Gνk = ∅. k=1
Fix ν1 , · · · , νn and put Q=
(x, y) ∈ X × X :
n
n
ρνk (F (x, y)) ≥
k=1
( ρνk (F (x, x)) .
k=1
It is easy to see that Q satisfies the assumptions of Lemma 3.6. Therefore there exists x0 ∈ X such that (x0 , y) ∈ Q for any y ∈ X . By the assumptions of Theorem 3.5 there exists y0 ∈ X such that F (x0 , y0 ) = O. By the definition of Q n
ρνk (F (x0 , x0 )) ≤
k=1
n
ρνk (F (x0 , y0 )) = 0,
k=1
so ρνk (F (x0 , x0 )) = 0 for any k, 1 ≤ k ≤ n, which means that x0 ∈
n '
Gνk .
k=1
To prove Lemma 3.6, we need one more lemma. Lemma 3.7. Let t1 , t2 , · · · , tn be points in Rn−1 such that their convex hull K = conv{t1 , t2 , · · · , tn } is an (n − 1)-dimensional simplex (i.e., has nonempty interior in Rn−1 ). Let V1 , V2 , · · · , Vn be subsets of K that are open in K. Suppose that for any subset {k1 , k2 , · · · , kl } of {1, 2, · · · , n} l '
Vjs
'
conv {tk1 , tk2 , · · · , tkl } = ∅.
(3.9)
s=1
Then K =
n
Vj .
j=1
Proof. Suppose that K
=
n
Vj . Then there are closed sets
j=1
W1 , W2 , · · · , Wn such that Wj ⊂ Vj , 1 ≤ j ≤ n, and K =
n j=1
Wj . Without
3. Finite Rank Approximation of Vectorial Hankel Operators
141
loss of generality we can assume that n tj = 0. j=1
It follows that any n − 1 vectors from {t1 , t2 , · · · , tn } are linearly independent. Put dj (t) = dist(t, Wj ), t ∈ K, and Dj (t) = max{s ≥ 0 : t − stj ∈ K}.
(3.10)
Let F be the continuous function on K defined by n 1 F (t) = t − (min{dj (t), Dj (t)}) tj . n j=1 It follows from (3.10) that F (t) ∈ K for any t ∈ K. By Brouwer’s fixed point theorem (see Dunford and Schwartz [1], Ch. V, §12), there exists n Wj = K, it follows that dj (t0 ) = 0 t0 ∈ K such that F (t0 ) = t0 . Since j=1
at least for one j. Since any n − 1 vectors from the set t1 , t2 , · · · , tn are linearly independent, it follows from the equality F (t0 ) = t0 that min{dj (t0 ), Dj (t0 )} = 0
(3.11)
for 1 ≤ j ≤ n. Clearly, dj (t0 ) = 0 if and only if t0 ∈ Wj , while Dj (t0 ) = 0 if and only if t ∈ conv{t1 , · · · , tj−1 , tj+1 , · · · , tn }. Therefore it follows from (3.11) that there exists a subset {k1 , k1 , · · · , kl } of {1, 2, · · · , n} such that l '
Wjs
'
conv {tk1 , tk2 , · · · , tkl } = ∅,
s=1
which contradicts (3.9). Proof of Lemma 3.6. Let y ∈ X . Put def
Qy = {x ∈ X : (x, y) ∈ Q}. We have to verify that Qy = ∅. Since X is compact, it is sufficient to show that
n j=1
y∈X
Qyj = ∅ for any finite set y1 , y2 , · · · , yn in X . The latter is
equivalent to the fact that
n j=1
def
Vyj = X , where Vy = X \ Qy . Clearly, Vy is
open. Let us show that for any y1 , y2 , · · · , yn in X n ' ' Vyj conv{y1 , y2 , · · · , yn } = ∅. j=1
142
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Indeed, if x belongs to the above intersection, then yj ∈ {y ∈ X : (x, y) ∈ Q},
1 ≤ j ≤ n,
and so by the hypotheses of Lemma 3.6, (x, x) ∈ Q, which contradicts the assumption that Q contains the diagonal. Let t1 , t2 , · · · , tn ∈ Rn−1 be vectors satisfying the hypotheses of Lemma 3.7. Let τ : K = conv{t1 , t2 , · · · , tn } → conv{y1 , y2 , · · · , yn } ⊂ X def
be the affine map defined by τ tj = yj . Then the sets Vj = τ −1 (Vyj ) satisfy n the hypotheses of Lemma 3.7. It follows that Vj = K, so j=1
conv{y1 , y2 , · · · , yn } ⊂
n
V yj ,
j=1
which completes the proof. To conclude this section, we obtain a formula for the essential norm of a vectorial Hankel operator that is analogous to Theorem 1.5.3. Theorem 3.8. Let H and K be separable Hilbert spaces and let Φ ∈ L∞ ((B(H, K)). Then (3.12) HΦ e = distL∞ Φ, H ∞ (B(H, K)) + C(C(H, K)) . Proof. Clearly, by Theorems 2.2.2 and 2.4.1, (3.12) is equivalent to the fact that HΦ e is equal to the distance from HΦ to the set of compact 2 (K). Clearly, HΦ e is equal vectorial Hankel operators from H 2 (H) to H− to the distance from HΦ to the set of finite rank operators. The result follows now from Theorem 3.1.
4. Relations between Hu and Hu¯ The aim of this section is to obtain a useful formula that relates the Hankel operators Hu and Hu¯ for a unimodular function u. This would allow us under certain circumstances to get information about properties of Hu¯ from properties of Hu . In particular, we will be able to get information about the singular numbers of Hu¯ from the singular values of Hu . Let u be a unimodular function on T. Then Hu¯∗ Hu¯ Tu = Tu Hu∗ Hu .
(4.1)
To prove this formula we make use of formula (3.1.5): Hu¯∗ Hu¯ Tu = (I − Tu Tu¯ )Tu = Tu (I − Tu¯ Tu ) = Tu Hu∗ Hu . To obtain consequences of formula (4.1) we need the notion of polar decomposition. Let T be an operator on a Hilbert space H. Then T admits a representation in the form T = U(T ∗ T )1/2 , where Ker U = Ker T and
4. Relations between Hu and Hu¯
143
U |H Ker U is an isometry onto clos Range T (see Halmos [2], Problem 134). U is called the partially isometric factor of T . Lemma 4.1. Let A and B be self-adjoint operators on Hilbert space and let T be an operator such that AT = T B. Then AU = UB, where U is the partially isometric factor of T . Proof. It follows from AT = T B that T ∗ A = BT ∗ and so T ∗ T B = T ∗ AT = BT ∗ T. Hence, B commutes with any function of the self-adjoint operator T ∗ T , in particular with (T ∗ T )1/2 . We have AU(T ∗ T )1/2 = U(T ∗ T )1/2 B = UB(T ∗ T )1/2 . Multiplying on the right by (T ∗ T )1/2 , we obtain AUT ∗ T = UBT ∗ T . It follows that AU and UB coincide on clos Range T ∗ T . Let us verify that they also coincide on Ker T ∗ T = Ker T , which is the orthogonal complement to clos Range T ∗ T . Since Ker U = Ker T and since Ker T is B-invariant (the latter follows from AT = T B), we see that AU Ker T = UB Ker T = O. Applying Lemma 4.1 to (4.1), we obtain Hu¯∗ Hu¯ Uu = Uu Hu∗ Hu ,
(4.2)
where Uu is the partially isometric factor of Tu . Theorem 4.2. Let u be a unimodular function on T such that clos Tu H 2 = H 2 and E = f ∈ H 2 : Hu∗ Hu f = f . Then Hu¯∗ Hu¯ is unitarily equivalent to Hu∗ Hu H 2 E . Proof. Note that E = Ker Tu = Ker Uu and Uu maps H 2 E isometrically onto H 2 . It follows from (4.2) that Hu¯∗ Hu¯ = Uu Hu∗ Hu Uu∗ = Uu Hu∗ Hu H 2 E Uu∗ . Corollary 4.3. Let u be a unimodular function such that Ker Tu = Ker Tu∗ = {O}. Then Hu¯∗ Hu¯ and Hu∗ Hu are unitarily equivalent. The following assertion allows us to get information about the singular values of Hu from the singular values of Hu¯∗ . Corollary 4.4. Let u be a unimodular function in H ∞ + C such that Tu has dense range. Then the Hankel operator Hu¯ is compact and sk (Hu¯ ) = sk+n (Hu ), where n = dim Ker Tu = dim E.
k ≥ 0,
144
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
Proof. This follows immediately from Theorem 4.2 and the facts that ∗ Hu Hu H 2 E < 1 and Hu∗ Hu f = f for f ∈ E. In the next corollary S p , 0 < p < ∞, is the Schatten–von Neumann class (see Appendix 1.1). Corollary 4.5. Let u be a unimodular function such that Tu has dense range in H 2 . If Hu is compact, then so is Hu¯ . If Hu ∈ S p , 0 < p < ∞, then Hu¯ ∈ S p and Hu¯ S p < Hu S p . Corollary 4.6. Let u be a unimodular function in H ∞ + C such that distL∞ (¯ u, H ∞ + C) < 1. Then u ∈ QC. Proof. There is an integer n such that distL∞ (z n u ¯, H ∞ ) < 1. Without loss of generality we can assume that n = 0. By Theorem 1.11 of Chapter 1, Tu¯ is left invertible and so Tu H 2 = H 2 . Since Hu is compact by the Hartman theorem, Hu¯ is also compact and again by the Hartman theorem u ¯ ∈ H ∞ + C. Corollary 4.7. Let u be a unimodular function such that dim Ker Tu < ∞ and dim Ker Tu¯ < ∞. Then Hu e = Hu¯ e . Proof. By Theorem 3.1.4, Ker Tu = {O} or Ker Tu¯ = {O}. To be definite, suppose that Ker Tu¯ = {O}. Then Tu has dense range in H 2 and by Theorem 4.2, Hu¯∗ Hu¯ is unitarily equivalent to the restriction of Hu∗ Hu to the orthogonal complement of Ker Tu . By the hypotheses, dim Ker Tu < ∞, and so Hu¯ e = lim sj (Hu¯ ) = lim sj (Hu ) = Hu e . j→∞
j→∞
Corollary 4.8. Let u be a unimodular function such that the Toeplitz operator Tu is Fredholm. Then Hu e = Hu¯ e . Let us now characterize those unimodular functions u for which Tu has dense range in H 2 . Theorem 4.9. Let u be a unimodular function. Then clos Tu H 2 = H 2 if and only if there exist an outer function h in H 2 and an inner function ¯ ϑ such that u = zϑh/h. Proof. Suppose that clos Tu H 2 = H 2 . Therefore Ker Tu¯ = {O}. Let f 2 be a nonzero function in Ker Tu¯ . Then u ¯f ∈ H− . Let g be a function in 2 H such that z¯g¯ = u ¯f . Since |g| = |f | on T, there exist an outer function h in H 2 and inner functions ϑ1 , ϑ2 such that f = ϑ1 h, g = ϑ2 h. Then ¯ u = zϑ1 ϑ2 h/h. ¯ then obviously h ∈ Ker Tu¯ . Hence, clos Tu H 2 = H 2 . If u = zϑh/h, The following sufficient condition for Tu to have a dense range will be very useful.
Concluding Remarks
145
¯ Theorem 4.10. Let u = ϑ¯h/h, where ϑ is an inner function and h is 2 an outer function in H . Then Tu has dense range in H 2 . ¯ = 0 for Proof. Suppose that f ⊥ Tu H 2 and f = O. Then (f, ϑ¯hg/h) any g in H 2 . Let f = τ k, where τ is an inner function and k is an outer ¯ = 0, that is, k(0)h(0) = 0, which is function. Take g = τ ϑh. Then (k, h) impossible since both h and k are outer. Consider now the case of vectorial Hankel operators with unitary-valued symbols. Let H be a separable Hilbert space and let U be a unitary-valued function with values in B(H). Then the following analog of formula (4.1) holds: HU∗ ∗ HU ∗ TU = TU HU∗ HU . This allows us to generalize Theorem 4.2 to the case of Hankel operators with unitary-valued symbols. Theorem 4.11. Let U be a unitary-valued function in L∞ (B(H)) such that clos TU H 2 (H) = H 2 (H) and E = f ∈ H 2 : HU∗ HU f = f . Then HU∗ ∗ HU ∗ is unitarily equivalent to HU∗ HU H 2 E . The proof of Theorem 4.11 is exactly the same as that of Theorem 4.2. It is also easy to see that Corollaries 4.3–4.5 also generalize very easily to the case of unitary-valued operator functions. Let us also state an analog of Corollary 4.8. Corollary 4.12. Let U be a unitary-valued matrix function such that the Toeplitz operator TU is Fredholm. Then HU e = HU ∗ e .
Concluding Remarks The results of §1 and §2 were obtained in Adamyan, Arov, and Krein [3]. Note that earlier Clark [1] proved a special case of the Adamyan– Arov–Krein theorem; namely, he considered the case of self-adjoint Hankel matrices. Later Butz [1] gave another proof of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem. Section 3 follows the paper Treil [3]. Note that the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem was generalized earlier to the case of finite matrix functions in Ball and Helton [1]. The results of §4 were obtained in Peller and Khrushch¨ev [1] for scalar functions; see Peller [17], where the case of operator functions was considered in connection with applications to vectorial stationary processes. Note that Corollary 4.5 for p = 2 was established in Solev [1]. In Le Merdy [1] the following generalization of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem was found. It was shown that if Hϕ is a Hankel operator from H p
146
Chapter 4. Singular Values of Hankel Operators
q to H− , p ≥ 2, 1 < q ≤ 2, then
inf{Hϕ − KB(H p ,H−q ) : rank K ≤ n} ≤ const inf{Hϕ − Hf B(H p ,H−q ) : rank Hf ≤ n}. In Baratchart and Seyfert [1] the authors proved a precise analog of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem for Hankel operators from H q , q ∈ [2, ∞] 2 to H− . They proved that the distance to the set of operators of rank at most n equals the distance to the set of Hankel operators of rank at most n. In other words, def
σn (Hϕ ) = inf{Hϕ − KB(H q ,H 2 ) : rank K ≤ n} is the distance in the norm of Lp from ϕ to the set of meromorphic functions with at most n poles in D, where 1/p + 1/q = 1/2. Moreover, in Baratchart and Seyfert [1] a precise analog of the Adamayan–Arov–Krein formula was obtained for the best meromorphic approximant in terms of “singular vectors” of the Hankel operator Hϕ : H q → H 2 . It was also mentioned in Baratchart and Seyfert [1] that a precise analog of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem can also be obtained for Hankel operators from H q to the quotient space Lr /H r , where 1/p+1/q+(r−1)/r = 1. This allows one to express the numbers σn (Hϕ ) in terms of the distance in Lp to the set of meromorphic functions with at most n poles in D. Here p can be an arbitrary number in [1, ∞). However, in this case no explicit formulas for the best meromorphic approximant in terms of “singular vectors” were found. We also mention here the paper Prokhorov [3] in which the analog of the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem for Hankel operators from H q to the quotient space Lr /H r was obtained independently of the paper Baratchart and Seyfert [1].
5 Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
2 For a Hankel operator Γ from H 2 to H− and ρ ≥ Γ, we consider in this section the problem of describing all symbols ϕ ∈ L∞ of Γ (i.e., Γ = Hϕ ) which satisfy the inequality ϕ∞ ≤ ρ. If ϕ0 is a symbol of Γ, then as we have seen in §1.1, this problem is equivalent to the problem of finding all approximants f ∈ H ∞ to ϕ0 satisfying ϕ0 − f ∞ ≤ ρ. This problem is called the Nehari problem. If ρ = Γ, a solution ϕ of the Nehari problem (i.e., a symbol ϕ of Γ of norm at most ρ) is called optimal. If ρ > Γ, the solutions of the Nehari problem are called suboptimal). Clearly, the optimal solutions of the Nehari problem are the symbols of Γ of minimal norm. In §1 we present the original approach by Adamyan, Arov, and Krein which is based on studying unitary extensions of isometric operators defined on a subspace of a Hilbert space. We obtain a uniqueness criterion and parametrize all solutions in the case of nonuniqueness. In particular, we show that in the case of nonuniqueness there are solutions of the Nehari problem of constant modulus equal to ρ. In §2 we apply the results of §1 to the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem. In case there are two distinct solutions of the Nevanlinna–Pick problem we show that there are solutions that are inner functions and we parametrize all solutions. Another approach to the Nehari problem (also due to Adamyan, Arov, and Krein) is given in §3. This approach works only in the case ρ > G and it also allows us to treat a more general problem, the so-called Nehari– Takagi problem. This problem can be described as follows. Suppose that Γ is a Hankel operator, ρ > 0, and m ∈ Z+ is such that sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ) if m > 0 and s0 (Γ) < ρ if m = 0. The problem is to describe all functions
148
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
ψ ∈ L∞ such that Hψ ≤ ρ and rank(Γ − Hψ ) ≤ m. Clearly, this problem is just the Nehari problem if m = 0. We parametrize in §3 all solutions of the Nehari problem. In §4 we consider the Nehari problem for a block Hankel operator Γ and use the method of so-called one-step extensions developed by Adamyan, Arov, and Krein. We parametrize all solutions of the Nehari problem in the case of finite-dimensional spaces (i.e., in the case of Hankel operators with matricial symbols) and ρ > Γ. Finally, in §5 we obtain a parametrization formula in the general case of vectorial Hankel operators. We use an approach that also depends on studying unitary extensions of isometric operators. However, it is different from the original approach by Adamyan, Arov, and Krein presented in §1, and it is based on the notion of the characteristic function of a unitary colligation. Note that we return to the Nehari problem in Chapter 14.
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case In this section we use the original approach by Adamyan, Arov, and Krein to the Nehari problem in the scalar case. We start with a Hankel operator 2 and a number ρ ≥ Γ, and consider the corresponding Γ from H 2 to H− Nehari problem. We obtain a criterion for the uniqueness of a solution and find a parametrization formula for the solutions in the case there are at least two distinct solutions (this is always the case if ρ > Γ). Consider the auxiliary operator Aρ on L2 defined by 1 Aρ f = f + (Γf+ + Γ∗ f− ), ρ where def
f+ = P+ f,
def
f− = P− f,
f ∈ H 2.
We introduce a new pseudo-inner product on L2 by (f, g)ρ = (Aρ f, g). Let us show that Aρ ≥ O. We have (Aρ f, f )
2 Re(Γf+ , f− ) ρ f+ 2 + f− 2 − 2f+ · f− ≥ 0.
= f+ 2 + f− 2 + ≥
If ρ > Γ, then (·, ·)ρ is equivalent to the standard inner product on L2 . The pseudo-inner product (·, ·)ρ is nondegenerate on L2 unless ρ = Γ and the norm of Γ is attained on the unit ball of H 2 . Indeed (f, f )ρ = 0 if
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
149
and only if 2 Re(Γf+ , f− ) = 0, ρ
f+ 2 + f− 2 + which is equivalent to
Γf+ = ρf+ ,
Γf+ = −ρf− .
Denote by K the Hilbert space obtained from L2 by factorization and completion with respect to (·, ·)ρ . From now on we denote the inner product in K by (·, ·)K , (f, g)K = (f, g)ρ for f, g ∈ L2 . 2 Let S be multiplication by z on L2 . Clearly, H 2 and H− are isometrically imbedded in K and 2 K = span{H 2 , H− } 2 with respect to (·, ·)K . It is also clear that S maps isometrically z¯H− + H2 2 2 onto H− +zH in the metric of K. Denote by V the closure of this isometric operator. Then the domain DV and the range RV of V are given by
DV = closK {f ∈ L2 : fˆ(−1) = 0}, RV = closK {f ∈ L2 : fˆ(0) = 0}. We consider minimal unitary extensions of V . Let K be imbedded in a Hilbert space H. A unitary operator U on H is called a unitary extension of V if U |DV = V. If in addition to that H = span{U k H : k ∈ Z}, the extension is called minimal. Let U be a minimal unitary extension of V and EU its spectral measure. Consider the operator-valued measure EU on the space K defined by EU (∆) = PE U (∆)|K, ∆ ⊂ T, where P is the orthogonal projection onto K. Define the scalar measure µU on T by dµU = ρ¯ z d(EU 1, z¯)H = ρ¯ z d(EU 1, z¯)K .
(1.1)
Theorem 1.1. For any minimal unitary extension U of V the measure µU is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure and the density ψ=
dµU dm
(1.2)
satisfies ψ∞ ≤ ρ
and
Hψ = Γ.
(1.3)
Conversely if ψ satisfies (1.3), then there exists a minimal unitary extension U of V such that ψ is given by (1.2).
150
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Theorem 1.1 describes the solutions of the Nehari problem with norm at most ρ in terms of minimal unitary extensions of V . It turns out that the map dµU U → ψ = dm is a one-to-one correspondence between the minimal unitary extensions of V and the solutions of the Nehari problem with norm at most ρ if we identify equivalent extensions. By equivalent extensions we mean the following. Let U1 and U2 be minimal extensions of V on spaces H1 and H2 . They are called equivalent if there is a unitary map W of H1 onto H2 such that W K is the identity and W U1 = U2 W.
(1.4)
It is easy to see that if U1 and U2 are equivalent, then EU1 = EU2 . U The following result shows that the map U → ψ, ψ = dµ dm , is a oneto-one correspondence between the equivalence classes of minimal unitary extensions of V and the solutions of the Nehari problem with norm at most ρ. Theorem 1.2. Let U1 and U2 be minimal unitary extensions of V on H1 and H2 . The following statements are equivalent: (i) U1 is equivalent to U2 ; (ii) EU1 = EU2 ;
(iii) ψ1 = ψ2 , where ψj =
dµUj dm
, j = 1, 2.
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Let U be a minimal unitary extension of V and EU its spectral measure. We have for all k ≥ 0 U k 1 = zk ,
U −k z¯ = z¯k+1 .
Since U is unitary, the vectors U k 1 are pairwise orthogonal for k ∈ Z, and so are U k z¯. Therefore we have for any trigonometric polynomials f and g:
f (ζ)g(ζ)(dEU (ζ)1, z¯)ρ = | (f (U )1, g(U )¯ z )H | T
≤
f (U )1 · g(U )¯ z = f L2 gL2 .
Therefore µU is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure U and the density ψ = dµ dm satisfies ψ ∈ L∞ ,
ψL∞ ≤ ρ.
Let k ≥ 1. We have
d ˆ ψ(−k) = (EU (ζ)1, z¯)K dm(ζ) ψ(ζ)ζ k dm(ζ) = ρ ζ k−1 dm T T = ρ(U k−1 1, z¯)H = ρ(z k−1 , z¯)K = ρ(Aρ z k−1 , z¯) = (Γz k−1 , z¯). So Γ = Hψ .
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
151
Suppose that ψ∞ ≤ ρ and Γ = Hψ . Put ξ=
1 ψ, ρ
κ = 1 − |ξ|2 ,
L2κ = closL2 κ 1/2 L2 ,
Hψ = L2 ⊕ L2κ .
Clearly,
L2κ = f ∈ L2 : f {ζ : |ξ(ζ)| = 1} = O . Define the imbedding I = Iψ of K in Hψ on a dense subset of K by If = (f− + ξf+ ) ⊕ κ 1/2 f+ ,
f ∈ L2 .
Let us show that I extends to an isometric imbedding of K in Hψ . We have (If, Ig)
(f− + ξf+ , g− + ξg+ ) + (κ 1/2 f+ , κ 1/2 g+ ) 1 1 = (f− , g− ) + (f− , ψg+ ) + (ψf+ , g− ) ρ ρ 1 1 2 f (ψf , ψg ) + 1 − |ψ| , g + + + + + ρ2 ρ2 1 1 = (f− , g− ) + (f+ , g+ ) + (f− , P− ψg+ ) + (P− ψf+ , g− ) ρ ρ 1 1 = (f, g) + (f− , Γg+ ) + (Γf+ , g− ) = (f, g)K . ρ ρ Let U be the unitary operator defined on Hψ by =
U (f ⊕ g) = zf ⊕ zg. It is evident that U IDV = IVρ DV . So U is a unitary extension of V under the identification of K with IK. Let us show that U is minimal. Indeed, U n I z¯k = z n−k ⊕ O, U Iz = ξz n
k
n+k
⊕κ
k ≥ 2, n ∈ Z; 1/2 n+k
z
,
k ≥ 0, n ∈ Z.
Clearly, span{U n I z¯k : k ≥ 2, n ∈ Z} ∪ {U n z k : k ≥ 0, n ∈ Z} = Hψ . Let EU be the spectral measure of U . Then EU (∆) is multiplication by χ∆ on Hψ . Therefore
(EU (∆)I1, I z¯)Hψ = ζ ξ(ζ)dm(ζ). ∆
It follows that d d z (EU I1, I z¯)Hψ = ρ¯ (EU 1, z¯)K , dm dm which completes the proof. ψ = ρ¯ z
Proof of Theorem 1.2. If U1 and U2 are equivalent minimal unitary extensions of V and W : H1 → H2 is a unitary map such that W K = IK and (1.4) holds, then for any f, g in K (U1k f, g)H1 = (W ∗ U2k W f, g)H1 = (U2k f, g)H2 .
152
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
This implies (EU1 (∆)f, g)H1 = (EU2 (∆)f, g)H2 ,
f, g ∈ K,
which proves (i)⇒(ii). The implication (ii)⇒(iii) is trivial. Let us establish (iii)⇒(i). We have from (iii): (EU1 1, z¯)H1 = (EU2 1, z¯)H2 , which implies (U1k 1, z¯)H1 = (U2k 1, z¯)H2 ,
k ∈ Z.
(1.5)
Since U1 and U2 are extensions of V , it follows that U1k 1 = U2k 1 = z k ,
k ≥ 0,
U1−k z¯ = U2−k z¯ = z¯1+k ,
(1.6)
k ≥ 0.
(1.7)
H1 = span{U1k 1, U1k z¯, k ∈ Z},
(1.8)
H2 = span{U2k 1, U2k z¯, k ∈ Z}.
(1.9)
By minimality
Define the operator W : H1 → H2 by W U1k 1 = U2k 1,
W U1k z¯ = U2k z¯,
k ∈ Z.
It follows from (1.8) and (1.9) that to show that W is a unitary operator from H1 to H2 , it is sufficient to prove that (U1k 1, U1m 1)H1 = (U2k 1, U2m 1)H2 ,
(1.10)
(U1k z¯, U1m z¯)H1 = (U2k z¯, U2m z¯)H2 ,
(1.11)
(U1k z¯, U1m 1)H1 = (U2k z¯, U2m 1)H2 .
(1.12)
Clearly, (1.12) follows directly from (1.5). To establish (1.10) and (1.11), we assume (to be definite) that k ≥ m. Then (U1k 1, U1m 1)H1
(U1k , z¯, U1m z¯)H1
=
(U1k−m 1, 1)H1 = (z k−m , 1)K
=
(U2k−m 1, 1)H2 = (U2k 1, U2m 1)H2 ,
=
(¯ z , U m−k z¯)H1 = (¯ z , z¯1+k+m )K
(¯ z , U2m−k z¯)H2 = (U2k z¯, U2m z¯)H2 . Thus W is unitary. It follows from (1.6) and (1.7) that W DV = IDV . The identity W U1 = U2 W follows directly from (1.8), (1.9), and the definition of W . =
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
153
Uniqueness We are now going to consider the question of uniqueness of solutions ψ of the Nehari problem with ψ∞ ≤ ρ. Define the deficiency indices of the operator V by d1 = dim K DV ,
d2 = dim K RV .
Clearly, 0 ≤ d1 , d2 ≤ 1. Lemma 1.3. d 1 = d2 . Proof. Let J be the (real-linear) operator on L2 defined by Jf = z¯f¯. 2 Clearly, JH 2 = H− , J 2 = I, and Jf 2 = f 2 for any f in L2 . Let us show that 2 . ΓJh = JΓ∗ h, h ∈ H−
Indeed, let Γ = Hϕ , ϕ ∈ L∞ . We have ¯ = JP+ J(ϕ¯ ¯ = JP+ ϕh ΓJh = Hϕ Jh = P− ϕ¯ zh z h) ¯ = JΓ∗ h. In a similar way one can prove that Γ∗ Jh = JΓh,
h ∈ H 2.
It follows that (Jf, Jg)K = (f, g)K ,
f, g ∈ H 2 .
Indeed, let f+ = P+ f , f− = P− f . We have (Jf, Jg)K
1 1 (Aρ Jf, Jg) = (Jf, Jg) + (ΓJf− , Jg) + (Γ∗ Jf+ , Jg) ρ ρ 1 1 ∗ = (f, g) + (JΓ f− , Jg) + (JΓf+ , Jg) = (f, g)K . ρ ρ
=
Since obviously J1 = z¯ and J{f ∈ L2 : fˆ(−1) = 0} = {f ∈ L2 : fˆ(0) = 0}, it follows that JDV = RV , and so DV coincides with K if and only if so does RV . This implies that d1 = d2 . Lemma 1.4. The following statements are equivalent: (i) there is a unique solution ψ of the Nehari problem with ψ∞ ≤ ρ; (ii) d1 = d2 = 0. Proof. Suppose that d1 = d2 = 0. Then DV and RV coincide with K and so V extends by continuity to a unitary operator on K. Clearly, such an extension is unique.
154
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
If d1 = d2 = 1, then dim K DV = dim K RV = 1. Let g1 ∈ K DV , g2 ∈ K RV , g1 ρ = g2 ρ = 1. Given γ ∈ T we can define a unitary extension U (γ) of V by U (γ) f = f, f ∈ DV ,
U (γ) g1 = γg2 .
(1.13)
Clearly, U (γ) extends by linearity to a unitary extension of V on K and U (γ1 ) = U (γ2 ) for distinct γ1 and γ2 . If ρ > Γ, then (·, ·)ρ is equivalent to the initial inner product in L2 . So z¯ ∈ DV and by Lemma 1.4, there are infinitely many solutions of the Nehari problem. If ρ = Γ and the norm of Γ is attained on the unit ball of H 2 (the latter is fulfilled if Γ is compact), then as we have seen in §1.1, there exists a unique solution ϕ of the Nehari problem and |ϕ(ζ)| = ρ almost everywhere on T. However, we will see in this section that if Γ = ρ and Γ does not attain its norm on the unit ball of H 2 , the Nehari problem may have a unique solution or infinitely many solutions. The following theorem establishes a criterion of the uniqueness of a solution of the Nehari problem. Theorem 1.5. The following statements are equivalent: (i) there is a unique solution ψ of the Nehari problem with ψ∞ ≤ ρ; (ii) lim ((r2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 1, 1) = ∞; r→ρ+
(iii) 1 ∈ Range(ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 . We need the following elementary lemma. Lemma 1.6. Let A be a nonnegative operator on a Hilbert space H, def
(f, g)A = (Af, g),
1/2
f A = (f, f )A , f ∈ H.
Given h ∈ H, the linear functional f → (f, h) is continuous in · A if and only if lim (A + sI)−1 h, h < ∞, s→0+
which in turn is equivalent to the fact that h ∈ A1/2 H. Proof of Lemma 1.6. Let h = A1/2 x, x ∈ H. We have |(f, h)| = |(f, A1/2 x)| = |(A1/2 f, x)| ≤ x · A1/2 f = x · |(A1/2 f, A1/2 f )|1/2 = x · |(Af, f )|1/2 = x · fA . Thus the functional f → (f, h) is continuous in · A . On the other hand, if f → (f, h) is a continuous linear functional with norm c, then ((A + sI)−1 h, h) ≤ c (A + sI)−1 hA = c (A(A + sI)−1 h, h)1/2 ≤ c h1/2 A(A + sI)−1 h1/2 ≤ c h, since t(t + s)−1 ≤ 1 for t ≥ 0, and so A(A + sI)−1 ≤ c.
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
155
Suppose now that lim ((A + sI)−1 h, h) < ∞. Then s→0+
lim (A + sI)−1/2 h < ∞.
s→0+
There exists a sequence {sn }n≥0 of positive numbers such that lim sn = 0 n→∞
and the sequence {(A + sn I)−1/2 h}n≥0 weakly converges to an element x of H. Then obviously, w– lim A1/2 (A + sn I)−1/2 h = A1/2 x. n→∞
On the other hand, it follows easily from spectral theorem that A1/2 (A + sn I)−1/2 h → h in the strong operator topology, which implies that h = A1/2 x. Proof of Theorem 1.5. By Lemmas 1.3 and 1.4, (i) is equivalent to the fact that Rρ = Kρ . The latter means that the linear functional f → fˆ(0) is unbounded in · ρ . By Lemma 1.6 this is true if and only if lim (Aρ + sI)−1 1, 1 = ∞. (1.14) s→0
Let fs = (Aρ + sI)−1 1. We have by the definition of Aρ 1 1 1 = (1 + s)fs + ΓP+ fs + Γ∗ P− fs . ρ ρ Since 1 ∈ H 2 , it follows that 1 (1 + s)P− fs + ΓP+ fs = O ρ
(1.15)
1 1 = (1 + s)P+ fs + Γ∗ P− fs . ρ
(1.16)
and
Substituting P− fs from (1.15) in (1.16), we obtain 1 = (1 + s)P+ fs − and so
1 Γ∗ ΓP+ fs , (1 + s)ρ2
P+ fs = (1 + s)ρ2 (1 + s)2 ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 1.
We have (Aρ + sI)−1 1, 1
= =
(fs , 1) = (P+ fs , 1) (1 + s)ρ2 (1 + s)2 ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 1, 1 .
Thus (1.14) is equivalent to the fact that lim (1 + s)2 ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 1, 1 = ∞, s→0+
which is obviously equivalent to (ii). The fact that (ii) and (iii) are equivalent follows from Lemma 1.6.
156
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Let d0 = d1 = 1. Then by Theorem 1.1, the solutions of the Nehari problem are in a one-to-one correspondence with the minimal unitary extensions of V . There can be two different types of extensions. Extensions of the first type are defined on the space K while extensions of the second type are defined on a space larger than K. It is easy to see that all extensions of the first type are described by (1.13); they can be parametrized by the complex numbers of modulus one. First we are going to study solutions of the Nehari problem that correspond to minimal unitary extensions on the space K.
Canonical Functions A solution ψ of the Nehari problem with norm at most ρ is called a ρ-canonical function if the operator V has deficiency indices equal to 1 and the corresponding minimal unitary extension of V is an operator on K. We shall call ρ-canonical functions canonical if this does not lead to confusion. Theorem 1.7. If ψ is a canonical function, then |ψ| = ρ almost everywhere. Proof. As in the proof of Theorem 1.1 put ξ=
1 ψ, ρ
κ = 1 − |ξ|2 ,
L2κ = closL2 κ 1/2 L2 ,
If = (f− + ξf+ ) ⊕ κ 1/2 f+ ,
Hψ = L2 ⊕ L2κ ,
f ∈ L2 .
Then I extends to an isometric imbedding of K in Hψ . Put ˜ = IK, K
H+ = IH 2 ,
2 H− = IH− ,
˜ V = IRV . R
Then 2 ⊕ {O}, H− = H−
H+ = {ξf ⊕ κ 1/2 f : f ∈ H 2 }.
It follows that ˜ = clos(H− + H+ ), K
˜ V = clos(H− + zH+ ). R
˜ V . Let f ⊕ g ∈ Hψ R ˜ V . Since f ⊕ g ⊥ H− , it Let us describe Hψ R 2 follows that f ∈ H . The fact that f ⊕ g ⊥ zH+ means that ¯ + κ 1/2 g, zω) = 0 (f ⊕ g, zξω ⊕ zκ 1/2 ω)Hψ = (f, zξω) + (g, zκ 1/2 ω) = (ξf ¯ + κ 1/2 g ∈ zH 2 . Thus for any ω in H 2 . That is, ξf − ¯ + κ 1/2 g ∈ zH 2 }. ˜ V = {f ⊕ g : f ∈ H 2 , ξf Hψ R −
(1.17)
˜ V ) = 1. Let us show that this is possible By the assumption dim(Hψ R only if κ = 0. This would imply that |ψ| = ρ almost everywhere. ¯ + κ 1/2 g ∈ zH 2 . Suppose ˜ V . Then f ∈ H 2 , η def Let f ⊕ g ∈ Hψ R = ξf − that κ = O. Then there exist a set ∆ of positive measure and a positive number δ such that κ ≥ δ on ∆.
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
157
It is easy to construct a nonconstant function α in H ∞ such that Im α(ζ) = 0 for ζ ∈ ∆. Indeed, let χ = χ∆ . Put α = exp −(−χ ˜ + iχ)2 . Clearly,
˜2 ) ∈ L∞ . |α| = exp − Re(−χ ˜ + iχ)2 = exp(χ2 − χ
On the other hand, for ζ ∈ ∆
2 α(ζ) = exp χ ˜ (ζ) ∈ R.
So α ∈ H ∞ and Im α(ζ) = 0 for ζ ∈ ∆. We can define now the functions f∗ , η∗ , g∗ by f∗ = αf, g∗ (ζ) =
η∗ = α ¯ η, κ −1/2 (ζ) η∗ (ζ) − ξ(ζ)f∗ (ζ) , ζ ∈ ∆, ζ ∈ ∆.
α(ζ)g(ζ),
2 ˜ ρ . Clearly, f∗ ∈ H 2 , η∗ ∈ zH− , and Let us show that f∗ ⊕ g∗ ∈ Hψ R 2 1/2 ¯ ∗ + κ g∗ = η∗ . Let ζ ∈ ∆. Then g∗ ∈ Lκ . We have to prove that ξf
ξ(ζ)f∗ (ζ) + κ 1/2 (ζ)g∗ (ζ) = ξ(ζ)α(ζ)f (ζ) + κ 1/2 (ζ)α(ζ)g(ζ) = α(ζ)η(ζ) = α(ζ)η(ζ) = η∗ (ζ), since α(ζ) is real for ζ ∈ ∆. Let ζ ∈ ∆. We have ξ(ζ)f∗ (ζ) + κ 1/2 (ζ)g∗ (ζ) =
ξ(ζ)α(ζ)f (ζ) + α(ζ)η(ζ) − ξ(ζ)α(ζ)f (ζ)
= α(ζ)η(ζ) = η∗ (ζ), ˜ V (see (1.17)). which proves that f∗ ⊕ g∗ ∈ Hψ R Clearly, f ⊕ g and f∗ ⊕ g∗ are linear independent, which contradicts the ˜ V = 1. fact that dim Hψ ⊕ R Theorem 1.8. Let ψ be a canonical function. Then ψ admits a representation ¯ ψ = ρ h/h,
(1.18)
where h is an outer function in H 2 . Proof. Let ξ = ψ/ρ. By Theorem 1.7, |ξ(ζ)| = 1 almost everywhere on ˜ V , then T and Hψ = L2 . If f ∈ Hψ R ¯ = η, ξf
2 f ∈ H 2 , η ∈ zH− .
It follows that ξ = f /η. The functions f and η¯ belong to H 2 and have the same moduli. So f and η admit factorizations f = kϑ1 ,
η = k¯ϑ¯2 ,
158
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
where k is an outer function in H 2 , and ϑ1 and ϑ2 are inner functions. ¯ If ϑ1 ϑ2 = const, then k and ϑ1 ϑ2 k belong to Hψ R ˜V . Then ξ = ϑ1 ϑ2 k/k. Indeed, ¯ = ηk = k¯ϑ¯2 ϑ¯1 ∈ zH 2 , ξk − f ηϑ1 ϑ2 k 2 ξϑ1 ϑ2 k = = k¯ ∈ zH− . f Clearly, k and ϑ1 ϑ2 k are linear independent, which contradicts the fact ˜ is one-dimensional. that Hψ R Thus ϑ1 ϑ2 = c, |c| = 1, which implies ¯ ξ = c k/k. ¯ Let ζ ∈ T, ζ 2 = c¯. Put h = ζk. Clearly, h is an outer function and ξ = h/h. Remark. A representation of ψ in the form (1.18) is unique up to a multiplicative constant. Moreover, if ψ = ρϕ1 /ϕ¯2 , 2
where ϕ1 and ϕ2 are in H , then ϕ1 and ϕ2 are scalar multiples of h. ¯ 1 = ϕ¯2 , so ϕ1 ∈ Hψ R ˜ V , which implies that Indeed, in this case ξϕ ϕ1 /h = const. Since ϕ2 has the same modulus as ϕ1 , it follows that ϕ2 = ϑϕ1 , where ϑ is an inner function. If ϑ = const, then the same ˜ V > 1. reasoning as in the proof of Theorem 1.8 shows that dim Hψ R It follows from Theorem 1.7 that if the Nehari problem has at least two distinct solutions, then there exists a solution with constant modulus. As we have seen in §1.1, in the case ρ = Γ and Γ attains its norm on the unit ball of H 2 there is a unique solution of the Nehari problem and it has constant modulus. The following example shows that in the case of uniqueness the solution does not necessarily have constant modulus. Example. Let ¯ ψ = χϑ, where χ is the characteristic function of I = {eit : −α < t < α},
0 < α < π,
ζ +1 . ζ −1 Let us show that ψ is the only solution of the Nehari problem with ρ = 1 and Γ = Hψ . Suppose that f is a nonzero function in H ∞ such that ψ − f ∞ ≤ 1. Then χ − ϑf ∞ ≤ 1 and so |(ϑf )(ζ) − 1| ≤ 1 for ζ ∈ I. It follows that Re(ϑf )(ζ) ≥ 0 for ζ ∈ I. Since ϑf ∈ H ∞ , the inner factor of ϑf extends analytically across I (see Garnett [1], Ch. II, Prob. 14). However, ϑ does not extend analytically across I. ϑ(ζ) = exp
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
159
Theorem 1.9. Let ψ be a solution of the Nehari problem for Γ such that |ψ(ζ)| = Γ = ρ almost everywhere on T. Then the Nehari problem for Γ = Hψ has only one solution with norm at most ρ if and only if ψ does not admit a representation ψ = f /¯ g,
f, g ∈ H 2 .
(1.19)
Proof. Let ξ = ψ/ρ. Then κ = 0 a.e. on T. So Hψ = L2 and ¯ ∈ zH 2 }. ˜ V = {f ∈ H 2 : ξf Hψ R −
(1.20)
˜ V and f is a nonzero function in Hψ R ˜ V , then ψ satisfies (1.19) If Hψ = R 1 ¯ 2 with g = ρ ξ f ∈ H− . ˜ V , and so the Conversely, if ψ is represented by (1.19), then f ∈ Hψ R Nehari problem has infinitely many solutions. The following theorem contains simple facts about canonical functions. Theorem 1.10. Let ψ be a solution of the Nehari problem for Γ (i.e., Hψ = Γ). The following assertions hold: (i) If ψ admits a representation ¯ ψ = ρ h/h, where h ∈ H 2 , 1/h ∈ H 2 , then ψ is a canonical function. (ii) If ψ takes values in an arc of the circle {ζ : |ζ| = ρ} of angle less than π, then ψ is a canonical function. ¯ where h ∈ H 2 . Then ψ is a ρ-canonical function with (iii) Let ψ = ρh/h, Hψ < ρ if and only if the Toeplitz operator Th/h i s invertible on H 2 . ¯ ˜ V if and only if Proof. (i). It follows from (1.20) that f ∈ Hψ R f ∈ Ker Tz¯h/h = 1. Obviously, ¯ . Let us show that dim Ker Tz¯h/h ¯ h ∈ Ker Tz¯h/h ¯ . = Tz¯Th/h We have Tz¯h/h ¯ ¯ . Since dim Ker Tz¯ = 1, it remains to prove that ∗ = {O} or, which is equivalent, that Th/h = Th/h¯ has dense range. Ker Th/h ¯ ¯ 2 Let g = 1/h ∈ H . Clearly, g is outer and Th/h¯ = Tg¯/g . Now Tg¯/g has dense range by Theorem 4.4.10, which proves that ˜ V = dim K RV = 1. dim Hψ R Hence, Hψ = Iψ K and so ψ is canonical. (ii). In this case ψ can be represented in the form ψ = ρ exp i(c + α), where c ∈ R and α is a real-valued function, α∞ < π/2. Let 1 α + i(α + c)). h = exp (−˜ 2 Then by Zygmund’s theorem h ∈ H 2 , 1/h ∈ H 2 (see Appendix 2.1). Obvi¯ The result follows from (i). ously, ψ = ρh/h.
160
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
(iii). If Th/h is invertible, then by Theorem 3.1.11, Hh/h¯ < 1, and so ¯ Hψ < ρ. In this case dim Ker Tz¯h/h = 1 and as in (ii) we can show that ¯ ˜ dim Hψ RV = 1. ˜ V = 1 and Hψ < ρ. Then dim Ker Tz¯h/h Suppose that dim Hψ R = 1. ¯ Therefore Ker Th/h = {O}, since if Th/h ¯ , ¯ ¯ f = O, then h + zf ∈ Ker Tz¯h/h = 1. Hence, Th/h¯ has dense which contradicts the fact that dim Ker Tz¯h/h ¯ range. ¯ Let u = h/h. Then Tu has dense range in H 2 . Indeed, let h = gϑ, where g is outer and ϑ is inner. Then u = ϑ¯2 g¯/g and by Theorem 4.4.10, Tu has dense range in H 2 . It follows now from Corollary 4.4.3 that Hu = Hu¯ . Since Hψ < ρ, it follows that Hu¯ < 1. Hence, Hu < 1, which implies that Tu is invertible (see Theorem 3.1.11). Now we can give an example of a ρ-canonical function ψ for which Γψ = ρ. In this case the Nehari problem has infinitely many solutions and so ψ has different best approximations by bounded analytic functions. In §1.1 we have already constructed an example of a function ϕ in L∞ , which has different best approximations. We have shown here that for that function ϕ, there exists a function f in H ∞ such that ϕ−f ∞ = Γϕ and ϕ − f is a canonical function. The following example produces an explicit canonical function ψ satisfying the above requirements. Example. Let h be an outer function such that h ∈ H 2 , 1/h ∈ H 2 , but |h|2 does not satisfy the Helson–Szeg¨o condition (see §3.2). To produce such a function h, it suffices to pick any positive function w such that w ∈ L1 , 1/w ∈ L1 , but w ∈ L1+ε with any positive ε and to take h to be an outer function with modulus w1/2 (see the remark after the proof of Theorem is noninvertible. 2.5). Then by Theorem 2.2.5, the Toeplitz operator Th/h ¯ By Theorem 4.4.10 and Corollary 4.4.3, Hh/h ¯ = 1. Therefore ¯ = Hh/h would be invertible by Theorem 3.1.11. Hh/h¯ = 1; otherwise Th/h ¯ ¯ is a It follows now from Theorem 1.10, (i) and (iii) that ψ = ρh/h ρ-canonical function and Hψ = ρ.
Parametrization of Canonical Solutions We are going to describe all canonical solutions of the Nehari problem in the case of nonuniqueness. In this case there exists a canonical solution. Let us fix a canonical solution ψ: Hψ = Γ,
ψ∞ = ρ.
It follows from Theorem 1.8 that ψ admits a representation ¯ ψ = ρh/h, where h is an outer function in H 2 .
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
161
Consider the function G defined by *2 . G = |h|2 + i|h| G is an outer function and Re G(ζ) ≥ O, ζ ∈ D. Let k be the function analytic in D defined by G−1 . (1.21) k= G+1 Clearly, 1+k = G. (1.22) 1−k Since Re G ≥ O, it follows that k ∈ H ∞ and k∞ ≤ 1. The following theorem gives a parametrization of all canonical solutions of the Nehari problem. ¯ be a canonical function of the Nehari Theorem 1.11. Let ψ = ρh/h problem, where h is an outer function in H 2 of norm one and let k be the function defined by (1.21). Then for any w ∈ T the function ϕ defined by ϕ(ζ) = ρ
h(ζ)
·
h(ζ)
1 − k(ζ) 1 − k(ζ)
·
w − k(ζ) 1 − wk(ζ)
(1.23)
is ρ-canonical. Conversely, if ϕ is a ρ-canonical function, then there exists a complex number w of modulus one such that (1.23) holds. Proof. Let ϕ be a canonical function. Let Uϕ and Uψ be the minimal unitary extensions of V that correspond to ϕ and ψ. Let Eϕ = EUϕ = EUϕ ,
Eψ = EUψ = EUψ
be the spectral measures of Uϕ and Uψ . It follows from (1.1) and (1.2) that ϕ − ψ = ρ¯ z We have
(P+ (ϕ − ψ))(λ) =
T
d((Eϕ − Eψ )1, z¯)K . dm ϕ(τ ) − ψ(τ ) dm(τ ), 1 − λ¯ τ
(1.24)
λ ∈ D.
Substituting ϕ − ψ from (1.24), we obtain
d((Eϕ − Eψ )1, z¯)K (λ) (ϕ) (ψ) (P+ (ϕ − ψ))(λ) = ρ = ρ Rλ − Rλ 1, z¯ , τ −λ K T where Rλ = (Uϕ − λI)−1 , Rλ = (Uψ − λI)−1 are the resolvents of Uϕ and Uψ . Since Hϕ = Hψ , it follows that P− ϕ = P− ψ and so for ζ ∈ T (ϕ)
(ψ)
(ϕ − ψ)(ζ)
lim (P+ (ϕ − ψ)) (rζ) (ϕ) (ψ) = ρ lim Rrζ − Rrζ 1, z¯ . =
r→1−
r→1−
K
(1.25)
162
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
We identify K and Hψ = L2 with the help of the imbedding Iψ (since ψ is canonical, Iψ is onto): Iψ f = f− + ξf+ ,
f ∈ L2 ∩ K,
(1.26)
where ξ = ρ−1 ψ, f− = P− f , f+ = P+ f . To avoid confusion, we introduce the notation ˜ϕ = Iψ Uϕ I −1 ˜ψ = Iψ Uψ I −1 , U U ψ
ψ
˜ϕ is defined in terms of Iψ rather than Iϕ !). (U ¯ It is easily seen from (1.20) that We have ξ = h/h. ˜ V = {λh : λ ∈ C}. L2 R ˜ ∗ h ∈ Hψ D ˜V . It is evident that z¯h = U ψ ˜ψ on L2 D ˜ V . So U ˜ϕ f = zf , f ⊥ D ˜V . ˜ϕ coincides with U The operator U Clearly, ˜ V ) = L2 R ˜V . ˜ϕ (L2 D U ˜ϕ is unitary, there exists a complex number w of modulus one such Since U that ˜ϕ z¯h = wh. ¯ U 2 ˜ϕ acts on L as follows: Therefore U ˜ϕ f = zf + (w ¯ − 1)(f, z¯h)h, U
f ∈ L2 .
(1.27)
Formula (1.25) can be rewritten in the following way. Let ˜ (ϕ) = Iψ R(ϕ) I −1 , R λ λ ψ
˜ (ψ) = Iψ R(ψ) I −1 R λ λ ψ
˜ϕ and U ˜ψ . Clearly, Iψ 1 = ξ, Iψ z¯ = z¯. be the resolvents of U Then ˜ (ϕ) − R ˜ (ψ) ξ, z¯ , ζ ∈ T. R (ϕ − ψ)(ζ) = ρ lim rζ rζ r→1−
(1.28)
Let λ = rζ. We have ˜ (ϕ) − R ˜ (ψ) R λ λ
˜ϕ − λI)−1 − (U ˜ψ − λI)−1 = (U ˜ϕ − λI)(U ˜ϕ − λI)−1 I − (U ˜ψ − λI)−1 = (U (ϕ)
(ψ)
˜ (U ˜ψ − U ˜ϕ )R ˜ . =R λ λ Therefore by (1.27) ˜ (ϕ) − R ˜ (ψ) ξ, z¯h R ˜ (ψ) ξ = (1 − w) ˜ (ϕ) h. ¯ R R λ λ λ λ
(1.29)
(1.30)
Let us show that ˜ (ϕ) h = R λ
˜ (ψ) h R λ . ˜ (ψ) h, z¯h ¯ R 1 − (1 − w) λ
(1.31)
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
163
We have ˜ (ψ) h, z¯h R ˜ψ − U ˜ (ψ) h ˜ (ϕ) h = R ˜ (ϕ) h − R ˜ (ϕ) U ˜ϕ R ¯ R 1 − (1 − w) λ λ λ λ λ by (1.27). Formula (1.31) follows now from (1.29). Therefore we have from (1.30) ˜ (ψ) ξ, z¯h R ˜ (ψ) h ¯ R (1 − w) λ λ (ϕ) (ψ) ˜ −R ˜ . ξ= R λ λ ˜ (ψ) h, z¯h ¯ R 1 − (1 − w) λ It follows that
˜ (ψ) ˜ (ϕ) − R R λ λ
We have ˜ (ψ) ξ, z¯h R λ
˜ (ψ) h, z¯ R λ
˜ (ψ) h, z¯h R λ
= ρ
T
˜ (ψ) h, z¯ ˜ (ψ) ξ, z¯h R ¯ R (1 − w) λ λ ξ, z¯ = . (ψ) ˜ ¯ Rλ h, z¯h 1 − (1 − w)
h(τ ) τ h(τ ) dm(τ ) = ρ h(τ ) τ − λ
T
τ h(τ ) dm(τ ) = ρh(λ), τ −λ
τ h(τ ) = dm(τ ) = h(λ), T τ −λ
h(τ ) |h(τ )|2 = τ h(τ )dm(τ ) = dm(τ ). τ T τ −λ T 1 − λ¯
Let k be the function defined by (1.21). Then
1 + k(λ) τ +λ |h(τ )|2 dm(τ ). = G(λ) = 1 − k(λ) T τ −λ Since h2 = 1, we have 1 1 − k(λ)
Thus
1 + k(λ) 1 1+ = 2 1 − k(λ)
τ +λ 1 2 2 |h(τ )| + |h(τ )| dm(τ ) = 2 T τ −λ
|h(τ )|2 = dm(τ ). τ T 1 − λ¯
˜ (ψ) )ξ, z¯ ˜ (ϕ) − R (R λ λ
= ρ
2 ¯ (1 − w)(h(λ)) ¯ 1 − (1 − w)/(1 − k(λ))
= ρ
(w − 1)(h(λ))2 (1 − k(λ)) . 1 − wk(λ)
Let ζ ∈ T. It follows from (1.28) that ϕ(ζ) = ρ
h(ζ) h(ζ)
+ρ
(w − 1)(1 − k(ζ))(h(ζ))2 . 1 − wk(ζ)
164
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Note that |h(ζ)|2 = Re Therefore ϕ(ζ) = ρ
h(ζ) h(ζ)
1 − |k(ζ)|2 1 + k(ζ) = . 1 − k(ζ) |1 − k(ζ)|2
(w − 1)(1 − k(ζ))(1 − |k(ζ)|2 ) 1+ (1 − wk(ζ))|1 − k(ζ)|2
(1.32) ,
and after elementary transformations we obtain ϕ(ζ) = ρ
h(ζ) 1 − k(ζ) w − k(ζ) . h(ζ) 1 − k(ζ) 1 − wk(ζ)
Suppose now that w ∈ T and ϕ is given by (1.23). Then we can define an extension of V as follows. Let H = L2 and let Iψ be the imbedding of K in L2 given by (1.26). Define the unitary operator U on L2 by ¯ − 1)(f, zh)h, U f = zf + (w
f ∈ L2 .
Then U is a minimal unitary extension of Iψ V Iψ−1 . Let ϕ1 be the solution of the Nehari problem that corresponds to U . Then ϕ1 is a canonical function ˜ϕ . and U = U 1 It follows from the part of the theorem already proved that h 1 − k w − k¯ ϕ1 = ρ ¯ . h 1 − k¯ 1 − wk Thus ϕ1 = ϕ and ϕ is a canonical solution of the Nehari problem. Let ω = (1 − k)h. Then ω is an outer function and formula (1.23) can be rewritten as follows: ω w − k¯ ϕ=ρ , w ∈ T. (1.33) ω ¯ 1 − wk In this parametrization the function k depends on the choice of a canonical function ψ. However, the following result shows that k is determined uniquely by the Hankel operator Γ up to a unimodular constant. Theorem 1.12. Let ψ1 and ψ2 be canonical solutions of the Nehari problem, h1 h2 ψ1 = ρ ¯ , ψ2 = ρ ¯ , h1 h2 2 where h1 and h2 are outer functions in H of norm one, and let k1 and k2 be the functions defined by 1 + kj * 2 = |hj |2 + i|h j| , 1 − kj Then k1 /k2 is a unimodular constant. If ωj = (1 − kj )hj , then ω1 /ω2 is a unimodular constant.
j = 1, 2.
j = 1, 2,
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
165
Proof. Let U1 and U2 be the minimal unitary extensions of V on the space K that correspond to ψ1 and ψ2 . Then U1 |DV = U2 |DV .
(1.34)
Let x ∈ K DV , x = 1, y = U1 x. Then y ∈ K RV and U2 x = γy
(1.35)
for some unimodular constant γ. Consider the unitary map Iψ1 of K onto L2 given by 1 Iψ1 f = f− + ψ1 f+ , ρ
f ∈ K ∩ L2 .
˜ψ = Iψ U1 I −1 is multiplication by z on L2 . As we Then the operator U 1 1 ψ1 z h1 , where c have seen in the proof of Theorem 1.11, Iψ1 y = ch1 , Iψ1 x = c¯ is a unimodular constant. By the definition of k1 we have
1 + k1 (ζ) τ +ζ = |h1 (τ )|2 dm(τ ). 1 − k1 (ζ) T τ −ζ Since h1 2 = 1, it follows that
1 k1 (ζ) ˜ψ − ζI −1 h1 , h1 = ζ |h1 (τ )|2 dm(τ ) = ζ U 1 1 − k1 (ζ) τ −ζ T ˜ψ − ζI)−1 ch1 , ch1 = ζ (U1 − ζI)−1 y, y . = ζ (U 1 K It is also clear that 1 = 1 − k1 (ζ)
T
τ |h1 (τ )|2 dm(τ ) = U1 (U1 − ζI)−1 y, y K . τ −ζ
(1.36)
If we do the same with ψ2 , we obtain k2 (ζ) 1 − k2 (ζ)
= ζ (U2 − ζI)−1 U2 x, U2 x K = ζ (U2 − ζI)−1 γy, γy K = ζ (U2 − ζI)−1 y, y K .
(1.37)
It is easy to see from (1.34) and (1.35) that (U2 − ζI)−1 f − (U1 − ζI)−1 f = −(U2 − ζI)−1 (U2 − U1 )(U1 − ζI)−1 f = (1 − γ) (U1 − ζI)−1 f, x K (U2 − ζI)−1 y,
f ∈ K.
166
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Therefore k1 (ζ) k2 (ζ) − = ζ (U2 − ζI)−1 y − (U1 − ζI)−1 y, y K 1 − k2 (ζ) 1 − k1 (ζ) = (1 − γ)ζ (U1 − ζI)−1 y, x K (U1 − ζI)−1 y, x K k2 (ζ) (U2 − ζI)−1 y, y K = (1 − γ) 1 − k2 (ζ) k2 (ζ) = (1 − γ) U1 (U1 − ζI)−1 y, y K 1 − k2 (ζ) k2 (ζ) 1 = (1 − γ) 1 − k2 (ζ) 1 − k1 (ζ) by (1.37) and (1.36). This easily implies that k1 (ζ) = γk2 (ζ). Let us now show that ω1 and ω2 differ by a unimodular constant. Since ω1 and ω2 are outer, it is sufficient to show that |ω1 | = |ω2 |. It follows from (1.22) that 1 + kj 1 − |kj |2 |hj |2 = Re = , j = 1, 2, 1 − kj |1 − kj |2 and so |ω1 |2 = |1 − k1 |2 · |h1 |2 = 1 − |k1 |2 = 1 − |k2 |2 = |1 − k2 |2 |h2 |2 = |ω2 |2 .
Parametrization of All Solutions We have proved that each unimodular constant w determines by formula (1.33) a canonical solution of the Nehari problem. The following result claims that if w ranges over the unit ball of H ∞ , formula (1.33) describes all solutions. Theorem 1.13. Let Γ be a Hankel operator, Γ ≤ ρ. Suppose that the set of solutions {ϕ ∈ L∞ : Hϕ = Γ, ϕ ≤ ρ}
(1.38)
¯ be a of the Nehari problem contains two different functions. Let ψ = ρh/h 2 canonical solution, where h is an outer function in H of norm one, let k be the function defined by (1.21), and let ω = (1 − k)h. Then the map w → ϕw = ρ
ω w − k¯ ω ¯ 1 − wk
(1.39)
is an isomorphism from the unit ball of H ∞ onto the set (1.38) of solutions of the Nehari problem. Remark. It is easy to see that the map (1.39) is an isomorphism between the unit ball of L∞ and the ball of radius ρ of L∞ .
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
167
Proof. Let us first prove that ϕw is a solution of the Nehari problem for any w in the unit ball of H ∞ . Clearly, h 1 − k 1 − k¯ ϕ1 = ρ ¯ = ψ. h 1 − k¯ 1 − k Let w ∈ H ∞ and wH ∞ ≤ 1. We have 1 − k w − k¯ h ϕ1 − ϕ w = ρ ¯ 1 − h 1 − k¯ 1 − wk 1 − k w − k¯ h2 = ρ 2 1− |h| 1 − k¯ 1 − wk = ρ
h2 (1 − w)(1 − |k|2 ) . ¯ |h|2 (1 − k)(1 − wk)
Bearing in mind that |h|2 =
1 − |k|2 |1 − k|2
(see (1.32)), we obtain ϕ1 − ϕw = ρh2
(1 − w)|1 − k|2 (1 − w)(1 − k) = ρh2 . ¯ 1 − wk (1 − k)(1 − wk)
(1.40)
Since w∞ ≤ 1 and k∞ ≤ 1, it follows that Re(1 − wk) ≥ O and so 1 − wk is an outer function (see Appendix 1.2). Obviously, ϕ1 − ϕw ∈ L∞ , which implies that ϕ1 − ϕw ∈ H ∞ . This proves that Hϕw = Hϕ1 , so ϕw is a solution of the Nehari problem. Suppose now that ϕ is a solution of the Nehari problem, that is, Hϕ = Γ and ϕ∞ ≤ ρ. Then as we have noticed above, there is a function w in the def
unit ball of L∞ such that ϕ = ϕw, which means that f = ϕ1 − ϕw ∈ H ∞ . For our convenience we can assume without loss of generality that ρ = 1. We have |1 − f (ζ)ϕ1 (ζ)| = |ϕ1 (ζ) − f (ζ)| = |ϕw(ζ)| ≤ 1,
ζ ∈ T.
Therefore f ϕ1 takes values in {λ ∈ C : Re λ ≥ 0}. Hence, there exists a real-valued function α such that π π − ≤ α(ζ) ≤ , ζ ∈ T, 2 2 and f (ζ)ϕ1 (ζ) = |f (ζ)| exp iα(ζ),
ζ ∈ T.
(1.41)
Since |1 − f (ζ)ϕ1 (ζ)| ≤ 1, it follows elementarily that |f (ζ)| = |f (ζ)ϕ1 (ζ)| ≤ 2 cos α(ζ),
ζ ∈ T.
(1.42)
Put g = exp(˜ α − iα).
(1.43)
168
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Then g is an outer function. Consider the harmonic extensions of α and α ˜ to the unit disk; we keep the same notation α and α ˜ for them. Then g(ζ) = exp(˜ α(ζ) − iα(ζ)),
ζ ∈ D.
Clearly,
π π ≤ α(ζ) ≤ , ζ ∈ D. 2 2 Therefore Re g(ζ) ≥ 0 for ζ ∈ D. Let us show that gf ∈ H 1 . We have by (1.42) −
|g(ζ)f (ζ)| ≤ 2|g(ζ)| cos α(ζ) = 2 Re g(ζ),
ζ ∈ T.
The function Re g is a nonnegative harmonic function in D and so
|g(ζ)f (ζ)|dm(ζ) ≤ 2 Re g(ζ)dm(ζ) T T
Re g(rζ)dm(ζ) = 2 Re g(0) ≤ 2 lim inf r→1−
T
(see Appendix 2.1). Being the product of an outer function and a function in H ∞ , the function gf belongs to H 1 . We are going to establish that gf is a positive scalar multiple of h2 . Being in H 1 , the function gf admits a factorization gf = ϑh21 , where ϑ is an inner function and h1 is an outer function in H 2 . Then ϑh21 gf gf ϑh1 = = = . ¯ |h1 |2 |h1 |2 |gf | h1 It follows from (1.41) and (1.43) that gf ϕ¯1 = |gf ϕ¯1 | = |gf |, which implies h ϑh1 = ϕ1 = ¯ . ¯ h1 h However, being a canonical function, ϕ1 admits a unique (up to a constant η2 , η1 , η2 ∈ H 2 (see the Remark factor) representation of the form ϕ1 = η1 /¯ ¯ ¯ Thus after Theorem 1.8). Therefore ϑh1 = ch, h1 = ch. gf = ϑh21 = |c|2 h2 . It follows that Re
h2 (ζ) ≥ 0, f (ζ)
ζ ∈ D,
(1.44)
since Re g(ζ) ≥ 0 in D. Recall that by (1.40) f = ϕ1 − ϕw = h2 which implies h2 (ζ) 1 = f (ζ) 2
(1 − w)(1 − k) , 1 − wk
1 + k(ζ) 1 + w(ζ) + 1 − k(ζ) 1 − w(ζ)
,
ζ ∈ T.
(1.45)
1. Adamyan–Arov–Krein Parametrization in the Scalar Case
Since
1 + k(ζ) = |h(ζ)|2 , 1 − k(ζ)
Re
169
ζ ∈ T,
we obtain Re
1 + w(ζ) h2 (ζ) 1 − |h(ζ)|2 = ≥ 0, f (ζ) 2 1 − w(ζ)
ζ ∈ T.
(1.46)
Let
h2 (ζ) def 1 , w(ζ) = |f (ζ)|2 , ζ ∈ T. f (ζ) 2 Obviously, w ∈ L1 . However, it follows from (1.44) that the function v on T, being the boundary-value function of the positive harmonic function Re(h2 /f ), also belongs to L1 (see Appendix 2.1). Consider the harmonic extensions of v and w to the unit disk, keeping for them the same notation v and w. We have 1 + k(ζ) 1 , ζ ∈ D. (1.47) w(ζ) = Re 2 1 − k(ζ) def
v(ζ) = Re
It follows from the positivity of Re(h2 /f ) that Re
h2 (ζ) ≥ v(ζ), f (ζ)
ζ ∈ D,
(1.48)
(see Appendix 2.1). Inequality (1.46) means that v(ζ) − w(ζ) ≥ 0, ζ ∈ T, which implies v(ζ) − w(ζ) ≥ 0,
ζ ∈ D,
and together with (1.47) and (1.48) this yields Re
h2 (ζ) 1 1 + k(ζ) − Re ≥ 0, f (ζ) 2 1 − k(ζ)
ζ ∈ D.
(1.49)
Let
h2 (ζ) 1 1 + k(ζ) − . f (ζ) 2 1 − k(ζ) It follows from (1.49) that Re η(ζ) ≥ 0, ζ ∈ D. Therefore η is an outer function and we obtain from (1.45) def
η(ζ) =
1 + w(ζ) , ζ ∈ T. 1 − w(ζ) Hence, the function w analytically extends to D by η(ζ) − 1 , ζ ∈ D. w(ζ) = η(ζ) + 1 η(ζ) =
Since Re η(ζ) ≥ 0, ζ ∈ D, it follows that |w(ζ)| ≤ 1, ζ ∈ D. Remark. We have just proved that formula (1.39) parametrizes all solutions of the Nehari problem when w ranges over the unit ball of H ∞ . Theorem 1.11 claims that to describe the canonical functions, we have to substitute in (1.39) unimodular constants w. It is easy to see that a solution
170
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
ϕ in (1.39) has constant modulus ρ is and only if w is an inner function. This allows us to construct solutions of the Nehari problem of constant modulus ρ that are not canonical.
2. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nevanlinna–Pick Problem We apply in this section the results of §1 to the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem. We consider here the case of infinitely many distinct points ζj , j ≥ 0, in D. The case of finitely many points can be treated in the same way. In a similar way one can consider the case of multiple interpolating, i.e., interpolating not only values of a function but also values of its derivatives up to a certain order. Let ζj , j ≥ 0, be a sequence of distinct points in D and let wj , j ≥ 0, be complex numbers satisfying |wj | < 1. We are looking for functions f ∈ H ∞ satisfying: f (ζj ) = wj ,
j ∈ Z+ ,
and
f H ∞ ≤ 1.
(2.1)
We consider the case when this Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem has at least two distinct solutions. Clearly, in this case the sequence {ζj }j≥0 must satisfy the Blaschke condition (1 − |ζj |) < ∞. j≥0
We show that if the interpolation problem (2.1) has at least two distinct solutions, then there exist inner solutions of the problem (2.1) and we parametrize all solutions of (2.1). We denote by B a Blaschke product with simple zeros at the ζj , j ≥ 0. Suppose that f0 is a function in H ∞ interpolating the values wj at ζj , i.e., f (ζj ) = wj , j ≥ 0. Then all functions g in H ∞ satisfying g(ζj ) = wj , j ≥ 0, have the form g = f0 − Bq, where q ∈ H ∞ . We have g∞ = f0 − Bq∞ = Bf0 − q∞ , and so by the Nehari theorem, min f0 − Bq∞ = HBf0 .
h∈H ∞
It is easy to see that the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem reduces to the Nehari problem. Indeed, let ϕ = Bf0 . and ϕ − q∞ ≤ 1, then f0 − Bq is a solution of (2.1). Clearly, all solutions of (2.1) can be obtained in this way. Thus a necessary and sufficient condition for the problem (2.1) to have a solution is HBf0 ≤ 1. It is easy to see that if HBf0 < 1, then (2.1) has infinitely many distinct solutions.
2. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nevanlinna–Pick Problem
171
However, the problem (2.1) can have distinct solutions even if HBf0 = 1. Indeed, in §1.1 we have constructed an example of a Hankel operator with distinct symbols of minimal norm. We can use the same example now. Recall that in that example ω is the conformal map of D onto the domain
|1 − ζ| <1 . ζ ∈ C : |ζ| + 2 We have shown there that if B is an infinite Blaschke product whose zeros have an accumulation point at 1, then distL∞ (Bω, H ∞ ) = ω∞ = 1 and Bω − (1 − ω)/2∞ = 1. Suppose now that B has simple zeros ζj , j ≥ 0, and consider the interpolation problem (2.1) with wj = ω(ζj ). Then ω and ω − B(1 − ω)/2 are distinct solutions of (2.1). It is easy to see from the above example that if B is an infinite Blaschke product with simple zeros ζj , j ≥ 0, then there exists f ∈ H ∞ such that HBf = 1 and the problem (2.1) with wj = f (ζj ) has distinct solutions of norm 1. Theorem 2.1. If the interpolation problem (2.1) has at least two distinct solutions, there exists an inner function that solves (2.1). Proof. Consider the Nehari problem for the function ϕ = Bf0 . Since it has distinct solutions, the corresponding partial isometry V defined at the beginning of §1 has deficiency indices equal to 1, and so there exists a canonical solution ψ of the Nehari problem. By Theorem 1.7, a canonical solution ψ has modulus one almost everywhere. Let ψ = Bf0 − q. Then f = f0 − Bq is a solution of (2.1) and has modulus one almost everywhere. Thus f is an inner solution of (2.1). The following example shows that if (2.1) has one solution, it does not have to be inner. Example. Let {ζj }j≥0 be a sequence satisfying the Blaschke condition and such that lim ζj = 1. Let J be an open arc of T that contains 1 and j→∞
is not equal to T. Let f0 be a function invertible in H ∞ and such that |f0 (ζ)| = 1 for ζ ∈ J, f0 ∞ = 1, but |f0 | is not identically equal to 1 on T. Put wj = f (ζj ), j ≥ 0. Clearly, f0 is a solution of (2.1). Suppose that f = f0 − Bq, q ∈ H ∞ , is another solution. Then f0 − Bq∞ ≤ 1, and so |1 − (Bq/f0 )(ζ)| ≤ 1 for ζ ∈ J. Hence, Re(Bq/f0 )(ζ) ≥ 0 for ζ ∈ J. Then the inner factor of Bq/f0 extends analytically across J (see Garnett [1], Ch. II, Ex. 14). However, B does not extend analytically across J, and so q = O. Thus f0 is the only solution of (2.1), and f0 is not inner. Let us now apply Theorem 1.13 to obtain a parametrization formula for the solutions of (2.1) under the assumption that it has distinct solutions. ¯ be a canonical We consider the Nehari problem for ϕ = Bf0 . Let ψ = h/h solution of the Nehari problem, where h is an outer function in H 2 . As in
172
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
§1 we consider the function k defined by 1+k *2 . = |h|2 + i|h| 1−k Then k ∈ H ∞ and k∞ ≤ 1 (see §1). Consider the inner solution ϑ = ψB of (2.1). The following result parametrizes all solutions of (2.1) in the case of nonuniqueness. Theorem 2.2. Suppose that the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem (2.1) has distinct solutions. Then there exist functions α1 , α2 , and α3 in H ∞ such that the set of solutions of (2.1) is given by
α1 + α2 β (2.2) : β ∈ H ∞ , β∞ ≤ 1 . 1 − α3 β Moreover, for almost all ζ ∈ T the map α1 (ζ) + α2 (ζ)z (2.3) 1 − α3 (ζ)z is a conformal map of the unit disc onto itself. Proof. Let ϑ, k, and h be as above. By Theorem 1.13, all solutions of (2.1) are given by
h 1 − k β − k¯ ∞ · B·¯ · : β ∈ H , β∞ ≤ 1 . h 1 − k¯ 1 − βk It follows from (1.40) that f is a solution of (2.1) if and only if (1 − β)(1 − k) 1 − βk for some β in the unit ball of H ∞ . It follows from the definition of k that f = ϑ − Bh2
h2 (1 − k) =
2h2 *2 |h|2 + 1 + i|h|
,
and so h2 (1 − k) ∈ H ∞ . Thus the set of solutions of the Nevanlinna–Pick problem (2.1) is given by
ϑ − Bh2 (1 − k) + β(Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk) : β ∈ H ∞ , β∞ ≤ 1 . 1 − βk We can now put α1 = ϑ − Bh2 (1 − k),
α2 = Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk,
α3 = −k.
The fact that for almost all ζ ∈ T the map (2.3) is a conformal map of D onto itself is an immediate consequence of Theorem 1.11. However, this ¯ Indeed, can be verified straightforwardly if we use the fact that ϑ = Bh/h. ϑ − Bh2 (1 − k) + β(Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk) 1 − βk = (Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk)
−ϑ+Bh2 (1−k) (Bh2 (1−k)−ϑk)
1 − βk
−β
.
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
173
It follows from (1.21) and (1.22) that |h|2 =
1 − |k|2 |1 − k|2
(2.4)
whence it is easy to see that on T ¯ = |h|2 (1 − k) − k = 1. (Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk = (Bh2 (1 − k) − Bh/hk On the other hand, on T ¯ + Bh2 (1 − k) −ϑ + Bh2 (1 − k) −Bh/h −1 + |h|2 (1 − k) ¯ = = k, = ¯ Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk |h|2 (1 − k) − k Bh2 (1 − k) − Bkh/h which is an immediate consequence of (2.4). Thus we have on T ϑ − Bh2 (1 − k) + β(Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk) k¯ − β = (Bh2 (1 − k) − ϑk) , 1 − βk 1 − βk which completes the proof. It follows from Theorem 1.11 that all canonical solutions of the Ne¯ 0 can be obtained by substituting in (2.2) all complex hari problem for Bf numbers β of modulus one. Clearly, this produces inner solutions of the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem. However, there are other inner solutions. The following theorem parametrizes all inner solutions. Theorem 2.3. The inner solutions of of the Nevanlinna–Pick interpolation problem (2.2) correspond to the inner functions β in (2.2). Proof. The result is an immediate consequence of the fact that for almost all ζ ∈ T the map (2.3) is a conformal map of D onto itself.
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem For a function ϕ in L∞ , ρ > 0, and m ∈ Z+ , the Nehari–Takagi ap∞ proximation problem is to approximate ϕ by functions f in H(m) so that ∞ ϕ − f ∞ ≤ ρ. Recall (see §4.1) that H(m) is the set of bounded functions whose antianalytic part is a rational function of degree at most m. By the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem (see §4.1 and §4.2), this problem is solvable if and only if sm (Hϕ ) ≤ ρ. We are going to parametrize all solutions of the Nehari–Takagi problem in the suboptimal case (i.e., sm (Hϕ ) < ρ). Moreover, we consider the case when sm (Hϕ ) < ρ < sm−1 (Hϕ ) (sm (Hϕ ) < ρ if m = 0). If m = 0, we deal with analytic approximation and thus we arrive at the Nehari problem. All solutions of the Nehari problem in the case of nonuniqueness have been parametrized in §1. We offer here a different approach that also works for m = 0 and ρ > Hϕ in which case it leads to a parametrization of all solutions of the Nehari problem. Using the Adamyan–Arov–Krein theorem mentioned above, one can reformulate the Nehari–Takagi problem in the following way. Let
174
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
2 Γ : H 2 → H− be a bounded Hankel operator, ρ > 0, and k ∈ Z+ . The ∞ problem is to parametrize all functions f ∈ H(m) such that Γ − Hf ≤ ρ. We assume in this section that
sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ)
(3.1)
(in the case m = 0 we simply assume that sm (Γ) < ρ). We are going to use the notation introduced in §4.2. Recall that Rρ = (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 , def
def
r(ρ) = (Rρ 1, 1),
and J is the real-linear operator on L2 defined by Jg = z¯g¯. We define the functions pρ and qρ in H 2 by pρ = ρRρ 1,
qρ = zRρ Γ∗ z¯.
(3.2)
We need the following properties of pρ and qρ . Lemma 3.1. Let Γ, ρ, pρ , and qρ be as above. The following holds: qρ , Γpρ = ρJS ∗ qρ = ρ¯
Γqρ = ρJS ∗ pρ ,
(3.3)
and |pρ |2 − |qρ |2 = r(ρ)
on
T.
(3.4)
Proof. Let us show that JΓRρ = Rρ Γ∗ J.
(3.5)
∗
Indeed, it is easy to see that JΓ = Γ J, and so JΓRρ = Γ∗ JRρ . Multiplying this equality by ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ on the left, we obtain (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)JΓRρ = ρ2 Γ∗ JRρ − Γ∗ ΓΓ∗ JRρ = Γ∗ (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )JRρ . Using the obvious fact that ΓΓ∗ J = JΓ∗ Γ, we have (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)JΓRρ = Γ∗ J(ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)Rρ = Γ∗ J, which implies (3.5). Let us now establish (3.3). It follows from (3.5) that Γpρ = ρΓRρ 1 = ρJRρ Γ∗ z¯ = ρJ z¯qρ = ρJS ∗ qρ , since qρ ∈ zH 2 . Obviously, J z¯qρ = q¯ρ . To prove the second equality in (3.3), we observe the following equalities: (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 Γ∗ = Γ∗ (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1
(3.6)
J(ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 = (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 J.
(3.7)
and To verify (3.6), it suffices to multiply it by ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ on the left and by ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ on the right. To verify (3.7), it suffices to multiply it on the right by ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ .
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
175
We have Γqρ
=
ΓzRρ Γ∗ z¯ = ΓzΓ∗ (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 z¯ = P− zΓΓ∗ (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 z¯
= −P− z(ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )(ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 z¯ + ρ2 P− z(ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 z¯ = ρ2 J 2 P− z(ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 z¯ = ρ2 JS ∗ Rρ J z¯ = ρ2 JS ∗ Rρ 1 = ρJS ∗ pρ . Finally, to prove (3.4), it suffices to show that pρ , (S ∗ )j pρ = qρ , (S ∗ )j qρ , j ≥ 1,
(3.8)
and pρ 22 − qρ 22 = r(ρ). Using (3.3), we obtain ρpρ − 1 = =
(3.9)
ρ2 Rρ − I 1 = ρ2 Rρ − ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ Rρ 1
Γ∗ ΓRρ 1 = Γ∗ J z¯qρ = Γ∗ q¯ρ .
Hence, for j ≥ 1, ρ(S ∗ )j pρ = (S ∗ )j Γ∗ q¯ρ = Γ∗ z¯j q¯ρ . Thus for j ≥ 1, ρ pρ , (S ∗ )j pρ
=
(pρ , Γ∗ z¯j q¯ρ ) = (Γpρ , z¯j q¯ρ )
qρ , z¯j q¯ρ ) = ρ qρ , (S ∗ )j qρ . = ρ(J z¯qρ , z¯j q¯ρ ) = ρ(¯ It remains to verify (3.9). We have by (3.3), 1 (pρ , pρ ) − (qρ , qρ ) = (pρ , pρ ) − 2 (Γpρ , Γpρ ) ρ 1 2 (ρ I − Γ∗ Γ)pρ , pρ = (Rρ 1, 1) = r(ρ). ρ2 ˜=Γ ˜ (α) defined as in Now let α ∈ C and consider the Hankel operator Γ §4.2: ˜ (α) = Hϕ , Γ α where ϕα is a function such that ϕˆα (j) = ϕ(j ˆ + 1) for j ≤ −2 and ϕˆα (−1) = α. Let us make the assumption that =
r(ρ) = (Rρ 1, 1) = 0. It has been shown in the proof of Lemma 4.2.2 that ρ2 is a simple eigenvalue ˜∗Γ ˜ if α = ατ is given by of the operator Γ ατ =
τ (Rρ 1, zΓ∗ z¯) − , ρr(ρ) r(ρ)
(3.10)
where |τ | = 1. Moreover, the function gτ defined by ¯ τ Rρ 1 + Rρ zΓ∗ z¯ = Rρ (¯ ατ + zΓ∗ z¯) gτ = α
(3.11)
176
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
˜∗Γ ˜ that corresponds to the eigenvalue ρ2 . is an eigenfunction of Γ Lemma 3.2. The eigenfunction gτ defined by (3.11) satisfies τ ρ2 r(ρ)gτ = pρ + τ qρ .
(3.12)
Proof. By (3.11), τ ρ2 r(ρ)gτ = τ α ¯ τ ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ 1 + τ ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ zΓ∗ z¯. We have from (3.10) τα ¯ τ ρ2 r(ρ) = ρ − ρ2 τ (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1), and so τ ρ2 r(ρ)gτ = ρRρ 1 − ρ2 τ (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)Rρ 1 + τ ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ zΓ∗ z¯.
(3.13)
By formula (2.11) of Chapter 4, we have ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ zΓ∗ z¯ = ρ2 (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)Rρ 1 + SJΓRρ 1, and so by (3.5), ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ zΓ∗ z¯ = ρ2 (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)Rρ 1 + zRρ Γ∗ z¯. It follows now from (3.13) that τ ρ2 r(ρ)gτ
= ρRρ 1 − ρ2 τ (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)Rρ 1 + ρ2 τ (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)Rρ 1 + τ zRρ Γ∗ z¯ = ρRρ 1 + τ zRρ Γ∗ z¯,
which proves (3.12). We start with the case m = 0, i.e., we first consider the Nehari problem. We have already obtained in §1 a parametrization formula in this case. Nevertheless, here we give another approach that works if ρ > Γ, and we parametrize all solutions of the Nehari problem in terms of the functions pρ and qρ defined by (3.2). Clearly, in this case r(ρ) = ((ρ2 I −Γ∗ Γ)−1 1, 1) > 0. We need the following lemma. Lemma 3.3. Suppose that ρ > Γ. Then for any υ in the unit ball of H ∞ , the function pρ + υqρ is outer. To prove Lemma 3.3 we need one more lemma. Lemma 3.4. Let p and q be functions in H 2 such that p + q is outer and |p(ζ)|2 − |q(ζ)|2 ≥ δ > 0 for almost all ζ ∈ T. Then p is outer. Proof. We have |p| |p| · |p + q| 2 ≤ ≤ |p|2 ∈ L1 , 2 2 |p + q| |p| − |q| δ and since p + q is outer, it follows that p(p + q)−1 ∈ H 1 . To prove that p is outer, it suffices to show that Re p(p + q)−1 ≥ O on T (see Appendix 2.1). This is obvious, since Re
p+q q |q| = 1 + Re ≥ 1 − ≥ O. p p |p|
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
177
Proof of Lemma 3.3. Let τ ∈ C and |τ | = 1. Let α = ατ be the number ˜ (α) defined (α) by (3.10) and let Γ be the(α)corresponding Hankel operator. Then ˜ of multiplicity 1 (see formula (2.3) of ˜ = ρ, ρ is a singular value of Γ Γ Chapter 4). It follows from Lemma 3.2 that pρ + τ qρ is a maximizing vector ˜ (α) . It is easy to see that pρ + τ qρ is an outer function, since otherwise of Γ we could divide it by its inner factor and obtain another maximizing vector ˜ (α) , which is impossible since the multiplicity of the singular value ρ is of Γ one. It follows now from Lemma 3.4 and (3.4) that pρ is outer. Finally, suppose that υH ∞ ≤ 1. Since pρ is outer, it follows from (3.4) that υqρ /pρ ∈ H ∞ and υqρ /pρ ∞ ≤ 1. Hence, υqρ Re 1 + ≥ O on T, pρ and so
υqρ pρ + υqρ = pρ pρ is outer which implies that pρ + υqρ is outer. Theorem 3.5. Suppose that ρ > Γ. A function ψ is a solution of the Nehari problem Hψ = Γ, ψ∞ ≤ ρ 1+
if and only if it has the form ψ=ρ
υ p¯ρ + q¯ρ pρ + υqρ
(3.14)
for a function υ in the unit ball of H ∞ . Proof. Let τ be a complex number of modulus 1. Suppose first that ψ is defined by (3.14), where υ is the constant function identically equal to τ . Clearly, ψ∞ = ρ. Let us show that Hψ = Γ. Let α = ατ be the number ˜=Γ ˜ (α) be the corresponding Hankel operator. defined by (3.10) and let Γ ˜ the function Since by Lemma 3.2, pρ + τ qρ is a maximizing vector of Γ, ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) Γ(p p ρ + τ qρ ˜ (see Theorem 1.1.4). Let us show that is a symbol of the Hankel operator Γ ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) = ρ¯ z (¯ qρ + τ p¯ρ ). Γ(p
(3.15)
˜ of multiplicity 1, it follows from Indeed, since ρ is a singular value of Γ Theorem 1.1.4 that ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) = cρ¯ Γ(p z (¯ pρ + τ¯q¯ρ ) = c¯ τ z¯(¯ qρ + τ p¯ρ )
(3.16)
for some complex number c of modulus 1. We have to prove that c¯ τ = 1. Using formulas (2.4) and (2.6) of Chapter 4, we obtain ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) = z¯Γ(pρ + τ qρ ) + (pρ + τ qρ , α ¯ + zΓ∗ z¯)¯ z. Γ(p
178
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
It follows easily from (3.3) that ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) = ρ¯ Γ(p z (¯ qρ + τ p¯ρ ) + d¯ z for some d ∈ C. It is easy to see from (3.2) that q¯ρ + τ p¯ρ is not a constant function. On the other hand, if we compare the jth Fourier coefficients of ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) for j ≤ −2, we see from (3.16), that c¯ τ = 1. c¯ τ z¯(¯ qρ + τ p¯ρ ) and Γ(p This proves (3.15). We can conclude now that the function q¯ρ + τ p¯ρ ρ¯ z pρ + τ q ρ ˜ i.e., is a symbol of Γ, ˜ = H q¯ρ +τ p¯ρ . Γ ρ¯ z pρ +τ qρ
˜ it follows that Since Γ = ΓS, Γ = Hzρ¯z q¯ρ +τ p¯ρ = Hρ q¯ρ +τ p¯ρ . pρ +τ qρ
pρ +τ qρ
In other words, the function ρ(¯ qρ + τ p¯ρ )(pρ + τ qρ )−1 is a symbol of Γ. Suppose now that υ is in the unit ball of H ∞ . Obviously, for almost all ζ ∈ T the function τ →
q¯ρ (ζ) + τ p¯ρ (ζ) pρ (ζ) + τ qρ (ζ)
(3.17)
maps T onto itself. By (3.4), |qρ (ζ)/pρ (ζ)| ≤ 1 for almost all ζ ∈ T, and so the map (3.17) is a conformal map of D onto itself. Thus the function def
ϕυ = ρ
υ p¯ρ + q¯ρ pρ + υqρ
satisfies ϕυ ∞ ≤ ρ. To show that ϕυ is a symbol of Γ, it suffices to prove that τ p¯ρ + q¯ρ def ϕυ − ϕτ = ϕυ − ρ ∈ H ∞. pρ + τ qρ We obtain from (3.4) ϕυ − ϕτ = ρr(ρ)
υ−τ ∈ H ∞, (pρ + υqρ )(pρ + τ qρ )
(3.18)
since ϕυ − ϕτ ∈ L∞ and the function (pρ + υqρ )(pρ + τ qρ ) is outer by Lemma 3.3. Suppose now that ψ ∈ L∞ , ψ∞ ≤ ρ, and Γ = Hψ . Since (3.17) is a conformal map of D onto itself, it follows that there exists a function υ in the unit ball of L∞ such that υ p¯ρ + q¯ρ . ψ=ρ pρ + υqρ
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
179
We have to show that υ ∈ H ∞ . Let τ be a complex number of modulus 1. Since Γ = Hϕτ , it follows that υ−τ υ p¯ρ + q¯ρ def − ϕτ = ρr(ρ) = ρr(ρ)κτ ∈ H ∞ . (3.19) ρ pρ + υqρ (pρ + υqρ )(pρ + τ qρ ) def
Let L = {ω ∈ H 1 : υω ∈ H 1 }. Clearly, L is a closed subspace of H 1 that is invariant under multiplication by z. Next, L = {O}, which is a consequence of the following easily verifiable equality: υ(1 − κτ qρ (pρ + τ qρ )) = κτ pρ (pρ + τ qρ ) + τ. (Note that 1 − κτ qρ (pρ + τ qρ ) cannot be the zero function for all τ ∈ T.) Then L has the form L = ϑH 1 for an inner function ϑ (see Appendix 2.2). def
Let h = ϑυ ∈ H ∞ . It is easy to see that h and ϑ are coprime; otherwise if they had a nonconstant common inner factor ϑ# , we would have the inclusion ϑ¯# ϑH 1 ⊂ L, which is impossible. It follows from the definition of κτ (3.19) that κτ (pρ + τ qρ )(ϑpρ + hqρ ) = ϑ(υ − τ ) = h − τ ϑ. It follows that the inner factor (ϑpρ + hqρ )(i) of ϑpρ + hqρ is a divisor of h − τ ϑ for any τ ∈ T. Hence, (ϑpρ + hqρ )(i) is a common divisor of h and ϑ. However, h and ϑ are coprime, and so the function ϑpρ + hqρ is outer. By (3.4), |ϑpρ |2 − |hqρ |2 ≥ |pρ |2 − |qρ |2 = r(ρ) on T. It follows now from Lemma 3.4 that ϑpρ is outer, and so ϑ is constant, ¯ ∈ H ∞. which means that υ = ϑh We proceed now to the case when m > 0 and sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ). Recall that for a function ψ ∈ H 1 we denote by ψ(o) its outer factor and by ψ(i) the inner factor of ψ (see Appendix 2.1). Recall also that for an inner function ϑ its degree deg ϑ is the dimension of H 2 ϑH 2 and deg ϑ < ∞ if and only if ϑ is a finite Blaschke product (see Appendix 2.1). We need the following version of Rouch´e’s theorem. Lemma 3.6. Let ξ and η be functions in H 1 such that |η(ζ)| ≤ |ξ(ζ)|, ξ ζ ∈ T. Then deg(ξ + η)(i) ≤ deg ξ(i) . If, in addition, ξ+η ∈ L1 , then deg ξ(i) ≤ deg(ξ + η)(i) . Proof. It is easy to see that ξ+η η ∈ H ∞ and ∈ H ∞, ξ(o) ξ(o) and we can replace the functions ξ and η with ξ/ξ(o) and η with η/ξ(o) . Thus without loss of generality we may assume that ξ is inner and η∞ ≤ 1. def
Put ϑ = (ξ + η)(i) . Assume that deg ξ < deg ϑ. Then dim(H 2 ξH 2 ) < dim(H 2 ϑH 2 ). Hence, there exists a nonzero function ω in ξH 2 ∩ (H 2 ϑH 2 ). Then def ¯ ∈ H 2 . On the other hand, ω ϑ¯ ∈ H 2 . ψ = ξω −
180
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Consider the Hankel operator Hϑξ ¯ . Clearly, Hϑξ ¯ ≤ 1. On the other hand, ¯ ξω ¯ 2 = P− ϑω ¯ 2 = ϑω ¯ 2 = ψ2 . Hϑξ ¯ ψ2 = P− ϑξ 2 Thus Hϑξ ¯ = 1 and Hϑξ ¯ attains its norm on the unit ball of H . By ¯ of norm 1. However, Theorem 1.1.4, Hϑξ ¯ has only one symbol ϑξ
¯ − (ξ + η)(o) ∞ = ξ − ϑ(ξ + η)(o) ∞ = ξ − (ξ + η)∞ = ξ∞ = 1, ϑξ ¯ and ϑξ ¯ − (ξ + η)(o) are symbols of H ¯ of minimal norm, and so both ϑξ ϑξ and we have got a contradiction. ξ Suppose now that ξ+η ∈ L1 . Assume that deg ξ > deg ϑ. Then ϑ is a def
finite Blaschke product. Let Γ = Hϑξ ¯ . Let us show that Γ < 1. Indeed, since ϑ is a finite Blaschke product, rank Γ < ∞ (see Corollary 1.3.3). If Γ = 1, then there is a nonzero function w ∈ H 2 such that 2 ¯ ϑξw ∈ H− , and so Ker Tϑξ ¯ = {O}. Consider now the Toeplitz operator ∗ 2 Tϑξ ¯ = Tξ¯Tϑ . We have Range Tϑ = ϑH and ¯ = Tξϑ Ker Tξ¯ = Kξ = H 2 ξH 2 . By our assumption, dim Kξ = deg ξ > codim ϑH 2 = deg ϑ, and so Ker Tξϑ ¯ = {O}, which contradicts Theorem 3.1.4. ¯ + ϑη ¯ ∈ H ∞ , and so Obviously, ϑξ Γ = Hϑξ ¯ . ¯ = H−ϑη ¯ and −ϑη ¯ of norm at most 1. Put Hence, Γ has two distinct symbols ϑξ ρ = 1 and apply Theorem 3.5. Thus there exist functions υ and υ# in the unit ball of H 1 such that ¯ = υ# p¯1 + q¯1 . ¯ = υ p¯1 + q¯1 and − ϑη ϑξ p1 + υq1 p1 + υ# q1 Recall that for almost all ζ ∈ T τ p¯1 (ζ) + q¯1 (ζ) p1 (ζ) + τ q1 (ζ) ¯ is a unimodular function, is a conformal map of D onto itself, and since ϑξ it follows that υ is also unimodular, i.e., υ is an inner function. We claim that p1 and q1 are rational functions with poles outside the closed unit disk. Indeed, since rank Γ < ∞, the range of Γ consists of rational functions (see the Remark at the end of §1.3). Then by (3.3), q1 is rational and S ∗ p1 is rational, and so p1 is also rational. Now it follows easily from (3.4) that the function (p1 + υq1 )(p1 + υ# q1 ) is invertible in H ∞ . We have by (3.4) τ →
(ξ + η)(o)
2 2 ¯ − (−ϑη) ¯ = (υ − υ# )(|p1 | − |q1 | ) = ϑξ (p1 + υq1 )(p1 + υ# q1 ) υ − υ# . = r(1) (p1 + υq1 )(p1 + υ# q1 )
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
181
By Lemma 3.3, the functions p1 + υq1 and p1 + υ# q1 are outer, which implies that υ − υ# is outer. Moreover, υ 1 1 −1 ξ 1 = υ − υ# |υ − υ# | = r(1) |(p1 + υq1 )(p1 + υ# q1 )| ξ + η ∈ L . On the other hand, since |υ# | ≤ |υ| on T, it is easy to see that υ Re ≥ 0 on T, υ − υ# and so the function υ(υ − υ# )−1 is outer, and since υ − υ# is outer, we find that υ is outer. However, υ is inner, and so υ(ζ) = τ almost everywhere on T, where |τ | = 1. Then ¯ = τ p¯1 + q¯1 = τ p1 + τ q1 . ϑξ p1 + τ q1 p1 + τ q1 ¯ is Again, it follows from (3.4) that p1 + τ q1 has no zeros on T, and so ϑξ a rational function, which implies that ξ is a rational function, i.e., ξ is a finite Blaschke product. Since p1 + τ q1 is invertible in H ∞ , it follows that the Toeplitz operators T(p1 +τ q1 )−1 and Tp1 +τ q1 are invertible on H 2 , and so Tϑξ ¯ = τ Tp1 +τ q1 T(p1 +τ q1 )−1 is invertible. We now have 0 = ind Tϑξ ¯ = ind Tϑ ¯ + ind Tξ = deg ϑ − deg ξ, which completes the proof. Corollary 3.7. Suppose that sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ) and r(ρ) > 0. Then deg(pρ )(i) = m. Moreover, for any inner function ϑ and any υ in the unit ball of H ∞ , deg(ϑpρ + υqρ )(i) = deg ϑ + m.
(3.20)
Proof. By (3.4), |ϑpρ |2 − |υqρ |2 ≥ |pρ |2 − |qρ |2 = r(ρ) > 0
on T.
Next, |pρ |(|ϑpρ | + |υqρ |) ϑpρ 1 ϑpρ + υqρ ≤ |ϑpρ |2 − |υqρ |2 ≤ r(ρ) |pρ |(|ϑpρ | + |υqρ |), and so ϑpρ (ϑpρ + υqρ )−1 ∈ L1 . It follows now from Lemma 3.6 that deg(ϑpρ + υqρ )(i) = deg(ϑpρ )(i) = deg ϑ + deg(pρ )(i) . In particular, for any complex number τ of modulus 1 deg(ϑpρ + τ qρ )(i) = deg(pρ )(i) . ˜ = Γ ˜ (α) be the Now let α = ατ be the number defined by (3.10) and Γ ˜ corresponding Hankel operator. Then ρ = sm (Γ) (see §4.2) and by Lemma ˜ which corresponds to the singular 3.2, pρ + τ qρ is a Schmidt function of Γ,
182
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
value ρ. By the Remark after the proof of Lemma 4.1.6, deg(pρ )(i) = m, which completes the proof. Now we are ready to parametrize the solutions of the Nehari–Takagi problem. We start with the case r(ρ) > 0. Theorem 3.8. Let m be a positive integer. Suppose that sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ) and r(ρ) > 0. A function ψ ∈ L∞ satisfies the conditions rank(Γ − Hψ ) ≤ m
and
ψ∞ ≤ ρ
(3.21)
if and only if it can be represented in the form def
ψ = ϕυ = ρ
υ p¯ρ + q¯ρ pρ + υqρ
for a function υ in the unit ball of H ∞ . Moreover, υ → ϕυ is a one-to-one map of the unit ball of L∞ onto the ball of radius ρ of L∞ . Proof. Obviously, for almost all ζ ∈ T the map τ →
υ p¯ρ (ζ) + q¯ρ (ζ) pρ (ζ) + υqρ (ζ)
(3.22)
maps T onto itself. By (3.4), |qρ (ζ)/pρ (ζ)| < 1 almost everywhere on T, and so the map (3.21) is a conformal map of D onto itself, which implies that υ → ϕυ is a one-to-one map of the unit ball of L∞ onto the ball of radius ρ of L∞ . Let us show that for any complex number τ of modulus 1 the function def
ϕτ = ρ
τ p¯ρ + q¯ρ pρ + τ qρ
satisfies rank(Γ − Hϕτ ) ≤ m. The proof of this fact is similar to the corresponding fact for m = 0 that has been established in the proof of Theorem 3.5. Indeed, let ˜ def Γ(pρ + τ qρ ) κ = , p ρ + τ qρ ˜=Γ ˜ (α) and α = ατ is defined by (3.10). Recall that pρ + τ qρ is a where Γ ˜ that corresponds to the singular value ρ. It has been Schmidt function of Γ ˜ − Hκ ) = m. It has been proved in §4.1 that proved in §4.1 that rank(Γ ˜ corresponding to the singular J maps the space of singular vectors of Γ ˜ ∗ corresponding to the same value ρ onto the space of singular vectors of Γ singular value. Since the multiplicity of the singular value ρ is 1, it follows ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) = const J(pρ + τ qρ ). In the same way as in the proof of that Γ(p Theorem 3.5 we can now show that ˜ ρ + τ qρ ) = ρ¯ z (¯ qρ + τ p¯ρ ). Γ(p
(3.23)
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
We have rank(Γ − Hϕτ )
˜ − Hκ )S rank(Γ − Hzκ ) = rank (Γ ˜ − Hκ = m. ≤ rank Γ
183
=
(3.24)
Suppose that ψ satisfies (3.21). Then ψ = ϕυ , where υ is in the unit ball of L∞ . Let us show that υ ∈ H ∞ . Let Γ = Hϕ , where ϕ ∈ L∞ . Then there exists an inner function θ such that deg θ ≤ m and θ(ϕ − ϕυ ) ∈ H ∞ .
(3.25)
By Corollary 3.7, for any complex number τ of modulus 1 deg(pρ + τ qρ )(i) = m.
(3.26)
Let us show that pρ + τ qρ ∈ Ker(Γ − Hϕτ ). Indeed, by (3.23), Γ(pρ + τ qρ ) = ρP− (τ p¯ρ + q¯ρ ). On the other hand, it follows from the definition of ϕτ that Hϕτ (pρ + τ qρ ) = ρP− (τ p¯ρ + q¯ρ ). Since the kernel of a Hankel operator is an invariant subspace under multiplication by z, we have (pρ + τ qρ )(i) H 2 ⊂ Ker(Γ − Hϕτ ). It follows now from (3.24) and (3.26) that Ker(Γ − Hϕτ ) = (pρ + τ qρ )(i) H 2 .
(3.27)
We now have from (3.25) and (3.27) hτ = θ(pρ + τ qρ )(i) (ϕυ − ϕτ ) ∈ H ∞ . def
As in (3.18), ϕυ − ϕτ = ρr(ρ)
υ−τ . (pρ + υqρ )(pρ + τ qρ )
Now it is an elementary exercise to verify the following equality: υ ρr(ρ)θ − hτ qρ (pρ + τ qρ )(o) = τ ρr(ρ)θ + hτ pρ (pρ + τ qρ )(o) .
(3.28)
(3.29)
Clearly, ρr(ρ)θ − hτ qρ (pρ + τ qρ )(o) = O, since otherwise we would have pρ = −τ qρ , which contradicts (3.4). As in the proof of Theorem 3.5, consider the closed subspace L of H 1 def defined by L = {ω ∈ H 1 : υω ∈ H 1 }. It follows from (3.29) that L = {O}. Then L has the form L = ϑH 1 for an inner function ϑ (see Appendix 2.2). def
Thus the function g = ϑυ belongs to H ∞ , g∞ ≤ 1, and g and ϑ are coprime. It follows from (3.28) that hτ (pρ + τ qρ )(o) (ϑpρ + gqρ ) = ρr(ρ)θ(g − τ ϑ), and so (ϑpρ +gqρ )(i) is a divisor of θ(g −τ ϑ). Since τ is an arbitrary number of modulus 1 and ϑ is coprime with g, it follows that (ϑpρ + gqρ )(i) is a divisor of θ. Hence, by (3.25), deg(ϑpρ + gqρ )(i) ≤ deg θ ≤ m.
184
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
On the other hand, by Corollary 3.7, deg(ϑpρ + gqρ )(i) = deg ϑ + m. Thus deg ϑ = 0, and so υ = g/ϑ ∈ H ∞ . Suppose now that υ ∈ H ∞ and υ∞ ≤ 1. Let us show that if τ1 and τ2 are distinct numbers of modulus 1, then pρ + τ1 qρ and pρ + τ2 qρ have no common zeros. Indeed, we have from (3.28) ϕτ1 − ϕτ2
=
ρr(ρ)(τ1 − τ2 ) (pρ + τ1 qρ )(pρ + τ2 qρ )
= ρr(ρ)
(τ1 − τ2 )(pρ + τ1 qρ )(i) (pρ + τ2 qρ )(i) (pρ + τ1 qρ )(o) (pρ + τ2 qρ )(o)
.
−1 Clearly, (pρ + τ1 qρ )−1 (o) (pρ + τ2 qρ )(o) is a bounded outer function, and so (3.30) Ker Hϕτ1 − Hϕτ2 = (pρ + τ1 qρ )(i) (pρ + τ2 qρ )(i) H 2 .
On the other hand, by (3.27), Ker(Γ − Hϕτj ) = (pρ + τj qρ )(i) H 2 , Clearly,
j = 1, 2.
(3.31)
Ker(Γ − Hϕτ1 ) ∩ Ker(Γ − Hϕτ2 ) ⊂ Ker Hϕτ1 − Hϕτ2 ,
and (3.30) and (3.31) imply that (pρ + τ1 qρ )(i) and (pρ + τ2 qρ )(i) have no common zeros. Let ϕ ∈ L∞ and Γ = Hϕ . It follows from (3.27) and (3.28) that P− (ϕ − ϕυ ) is a rational function with poles in the zeros of (pρ + τ qρ )(pρ + υqρ ) counted with multiplicities. However, P− (ϕ − ϕυ ) does not depend on the choice of τ and we have just proved that for distinct τ1 and τ2 the functions (pρ + τ1 qρ ) and (pρ + τ2 qρ ) have no common zeros. Thus P− (ϕ − ϕυ ) is a rational function with poles in the zeros of pρ + υqρ . It follows now from Corollary (3.7) that rank(Γ − Hϕυ ) ≤ m. Consider now the case r(ρ) < 0. Theorem 3.9. Let m be a positive integer. Suppose that sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ) and r(ρ) < 0. A function ψ ∈ L∞ satisfies the conditions rank(Γ − Hψ ) ≤ m
and
ψ∞ ≤ ρ
if and only if it can be represented in the form def
ψ = ϕυ = ρ
p¯ρ + υ q¯ρ υpρ + qρ
for a function υ in the unit ball of H ∞ . Moreover, υ → ϕυ is a one-to-one map of the unit ball of L∞ onto the ball of radius ρ of L∞ .
3. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari–Takagi Problem
185
The proof of Theorem 3.9 is the same as the proof of Theorem 3.8. We simply have to interchange the roles of pρ and qρ . In particular, in this case the analog of Corollary 3.7 is the following: deg(ϑqρ + υpρ )(i) = deg ϑ + m for any υ in the unit ball of H ∞ and any inner ϑ. We proceed now to the remaining case r(ρ) = 0. By (3.4), |pρ | = |qρ |. However, much more can be said in this case. It follows from formula (2.11) of Chapter 4 and from (3.5) that −ρ2 (Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)Rρ 1 + ρ2 r(ρ)Rρ zΓ∗ z¯ = zRρ Γ∗ z¯, and since r(ρ) = 0, we have from (3.2) −ρ(Rρ zΓ∗ z¯, 1)pρ = qρ , i.e., pρ and qρ are linear dependent. Thus pρ + τρ qρ = O
(3.32)
for some complex number τρ of modulus 1. Consider now on the interval (sm (Γ), sm−1 (Γ)) the operator function t → Rt = (t2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 . Clearly, it is differentiable. It follows that the vector functions t → pt
and t → qt
are also differentiable on (sm (Γ), sm−1 (Γ)). Here by the derivatives we understand the derivatives of the above operator and vector functions as functions of t. It is easy to see that Rt = −2tRt2 .
(3.33)
By (3.3), we have for τ ∈ T Γ(pt + τ qt ) = tJS ∗ qt + tτ JS ∗ pt = tτ JS ∗ (pt + τ qt ). Hence,
Γ(pt + τ qt ) = τ JS ∗ (pt + τ qt ) + τ tJS ∗ (pt + τ qt ). Substituting t = ρ and τ = τρ , we obtain Γ(pρ + τρ qρ ) = ρτρ JS ∗ (pρ + τ qρ ). Now put wρ = pρ + τ qρ .
(3.34)
Γwρ = ρτρ JS ∗ wρ .
(3.35)
Clearly, wρ ∈ H 2 and Let us show that pρ and wρ are linearly independent. Indeed, pρ (0) = ρ(Rρ 1, 1) = r(ρ) = 0. On the other hand, wρ (0) = (wρ , 1) = (pρ + τρ qρ , 1).
186
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
By (3.2), qt (0) = 0 for any t ∈ (sm (Γ), sm−1 (Γ)), and so qρ (0) = 0. On the other hand, (pρ , 1) = ρ(Rρ 1, 1) = −2ρ2 (Rρ2 1, 1) by (3.33). Thus wρ (0) = −2ρ2 (Rρ 1, Rρ 1) < 0. By (3.3) and (3.32), we have Γpρ = ρJS ∗ qρ = −ρτρ JS ∗ pρ .
(3.36)
Now we obtain from (3.35) and (3.36) Γ(wρ + ispρ ) = ρτρ JS ∗ (wρ + ispρ ),
s ∈ R.
(3.37)
For s ∈ R we find the number α = α(s) ∈ C from the equation ¯ + zΓ∗ z¯) = 0. − ρτρ (J(wρ + ispρ ), 1) + (wρ + ispρ , α
(3.38)
The equation is solvable, since (wρ , 1) = 0 and (pρ , 1) = O. As before, ˜=Γ ˜ (α) defined by consider the Hankel operator Γ ˜ = z¯Γg + (g, α z, Γg ¯ + zΓ∗ z¯)¯
g ∈ H 2.
It follows easily from (3.37) and (3.38) that ˜ ρ + ispρ ) Γ(w
= ρτρ z¯JS ∗ (wρ + ispρ ) + (wρ + ispρ , α ¯ + zΓ∗ z¯) = ρτρ J(wρ + ispρ ) − ρτρ (J(wρ + ispρ ), 1) +
¯ + zΓ∗ z¯) (wρ + ispρ , α
= ρτρ J(wρ + ispρ ). Hence, ˜ ∗ Γ(w ˜ ρ + ispρ ) = ρ2 (wρ + ispρ ). Γ ˜ and since sm (Γ) < ρ, we can prove in the same Consequently, ρ = sm (Γ) way as in the proof of Theorem 3.8 (see (3.27)) that Ker(Γ − Hϕs ) = (wρ + ispρ )(i) H 2 , where (wρ − pρ ) + wρ + pρ w ¯ρ − is¯ pρ = 1+is . wρ + ispρ wρ − pρ + 1−is 1+is (wρ + pρ ) 1−is
ϕs = ρτρ Note that
1 − is 1 + is = 1.
Lemma 3.10. Suppose that r(ρ) = 0. Then the function wρ defined by (3.34) satisfies Re wρ (ζ)pρ (ζ) = −ρRρ 12
for almost all
ζ ∈ T.
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
187
Proof. In the proof of Lemma 3.1 we have shown (see (3.8) and(3.9)) that for any t ∈ (sm (Γ), sm−1 (Γ)) the following equalities hold: (pt , (S ∗ )j pt ) − (qt , (S ∗ )j qt ) = 0,
j ≥ 1,
and (pt , pt ) − (qt , qt ) = (Rt 1, 1). Let us differentiate these equalities and put t = ρ. Then using (3.32), we obtain pρ + τρ qρ , (S ∗ )j pρ + pρ , (S ∗ )j (pρ + τ qρ ) = 0, j ≥ 1, and
(pρ + τρ qρ , pρ ) + (pρ , pρ + τ qρ ) = −2ρRρ 12
(see (3.33)). Hence, the jth Fourier coefficient of Re wρ (ζ)pρ (ζ) is zero for j = 0 and −ρRρ 12 for j = 0. Theorem 3.11. Let m be a positive integer. Suppose that sm (Γ) < ρ < sm−1 (Γ) and r(ρ) = 0. A function ψ ∈ L∞ satisfies the conditions rank(Γ − Hψ ) ≤ m and ψ∞ ≤ ρ if and only if it can be represented in the form def
ψ = ϕυ = ρτρ
υ(wρ − pρ ) + wρ + pρ wρ − pρ + υ(wρ + pρ )
for a function υ in the unit ball of H ∞ . Moreover, υ → ϕυ is a one-to-one map of the unit ball of L∞ onto the ball of radius ρ of L∞ . Proof. The fact that υ → ϕυ is a one-to-one map of the unit ball of L∞ onto the ball of radius ρ of L∞ is a simple consequence of the equality |wρ (ζ) − pρ (ζ)|2 − |wρ (ζ) + pρ (ζ)|2 = 4ρRρ 12 > 0, which, in turn, follows immediately from Lemma 3.10. Next, as in Corollary 3.7 one can prove that for any inner function ϑ and any function υ in the unit ball of H ∞ deg(ϑ(wρ − pρ ) + υ(wρ + pρ )(i) = deg ϑ + m. The rest of the proof is the same as the proof of Theorem 3.8.
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension We consider here the Nehari problem for vectorial Hankel operators. Let H and K be Hilbert spaces and let Γ = {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 be a block Hankel matrix, where the Ωj , j ∈ Z+ , are bounded linear operators from H to K such that Γ determines a bounded linear operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K). Suppose that Γ ≤ ρ. The Nehari problem in this context is to describe ˆ all functions Ξ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) such that Ξ(j) = Ωj , j ∈ Z+ . As we have already discussed in §2.2, this problem is equivalent to the problem of
188
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
describing all extensions {Ωj }j∈Z of the sequence {Ω }j≥0 such that the operator matrix Γ = {Ωj+k }j,k∈Z determines a bounded linear operator from 2Z (H) to 2Z (K) of norm at most ρ. Note that the adjoint operator Γ∗ is also a Hankel operator from 2 (K) to 2 (H) and it has Hankel matrix {Ω∗j+k }j,k≥0 .
One-Step Extension We begin with the problem of one-step extension, i.e., we want to describe the operators Ω : H → K such that the sequence Ω, Ω0 , Ω1 , Ω2 , · · · determines a bounded block Hankel matrix Ω Ω0 Ω1 · · · Ω0 Ω1 Ω2 · · · ˜= (4.1) Γ Ω1 Ω2 Ω3 · · · .. .. .. .. . . . . ˜ is a one-step ρ-extension of norm at most ρ. In this case we say that Γ of Γ. We parametrize the set of all such operators Ω. Then we obtain a parametrization of all solutions of the Nehari problem in the case when the spaces H and K are finite-dimensional and Γ < ρ. We consider the natural imbedding JH into 2 (H) defined by def
JH x = (x, O, O, · · · ),
x ∈ H.
Clearly, J∗H (x0 , x1 , x2 , · · · ) = x0 and JH J∗H (x0 , x1 , x2 , · · · ) = (x0 , O, O, · · · ). Similarly, we define the imbedding JK of K into 2 (K). For ρ > Γ we consider the following operators: Rρ = (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 ,
R∗ρ = (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1 ,
Gρ = (J∗H Rρ JH )−1/2 ,
G∗ρ = (J∗K R∗ρ JK )−1/2 .
def
def
def
def
Here we use the same notation I for the identity operator on different Hilbert spaces. Sometimes to avoid confusion we write IX for the identity operator on a space X. Recall that SH and SK are shifts on 2 (H) and 2 (K). The following identity characterizes the vectorial Hankel operators: ∗ Γ = ΓSH . SK
(4.2)
˜ defined by (4.1) satisfies It is easy to see that the one-step extension Γ the following equality: ˜ = JK ΩJ∗ + SK Γ + JK J∗ ΓS ∗ . (4.3) Γ H K H
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
189
The following result parametrizes all one-step ρ-extensions in the case ρ > Γ. Theorem 4.1. Let ρ > Γ. An operator Ω : H → K determines a one ˜ defined by (4.1) if and only if Ω admits a representation step ρ-extension Γ 1 ∗ Ω = −J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH G2ρ + G∗ρ EGρ , (4.4) ρ where E : H → K and E ≤ 1. Proof. Replacing Γ with ρ1 Γ, we can reduce the general case to the case ρ = 1. Let R = R1 , R∗ = R∗1 , G = G1 , and G∗ = G∗1 . Then R = DΓ−2 and R∗ = DΓ−2 ∗ (see the notation in §2.1). Now we can deduce Theorem 4.1 from Theorem 2.1.5. We have Ω C ˜= Γ , B A where
A = ΓSH
Ω1 Ω2 ∗ = SK Γ = .. . Ω0 = Ω1 , .. .
Ω2 Ω3 .. .
··· ··· , .. .
B = ΓJH
and C = J∗K Γ =
Ω0
Ω1
···
.
Then B = DA∗ K and C = LDA , where the operators K and L are the ˜ ≤ 1 if and only if Ω same as in Theorem 2.1.5. By Theorem 2.1.5, Γ admits a representation Ω = −LA∗ K + DL∗ EDK , with E ≤ 1. To compute DK , we first observe that 2 DA ∗
Hence,
∗ ∗ = I − ΓSH SH Γ = DΓ2 ∗ + ΓJH J∗H Γ∗ ∗ ∗ −1 DΓ∗ . = DΓ∗ I + DΓ−1 ∗ ΓJH JH Γ DΓ∗
−2 −1 −1 ∗ ∗ −1 −1 −1 DA DΓ∗ . ∗ = DΓ∗ I + DΓ∗ ΓJH JH Γ DΓ∗
−1 Since K = DA ∗ ΓJH , it follows that 2 DK
−2 = I − J∗H Γ∗ DA ∗ ΓJH
−1 ∗ ∗ −1 −1 −1 = I − J∗H Γ∗ DΓ−1 DΓ∗ ΓJH ∗ I + DΓ∗ ΓJH JH Γ DΓ∗ =
−1 (I + JH Γ∗ DΓ−2 = (JH DΓ−2 JH )−1 = G2 . ∗ ΓJH )
Here we have used the following elementary and easily verifiable facts: T ∗ (I + T T ∗ )−1 T = I − (I + T ∗ T )−1
190
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
and T ∗ (I − T T ∗ )−1 T = (I − T ∗ T )−1 − I
(4.5)
(the operator on the left-hand side is invertible if and only if the operator on the right-hand side is). Similarly, one can show that DL∗ = G∗ . −1 , we have Finally, let us compute LA∗ K. Since L = J∗K ΓDA LA∗ K
−1 ∗ −1 −2 = J∗K ΓDA A DA∗ ΓJH = J∗K ΓA∗ DA ∗ ΓJH
∗ ∗ −1 ∗ ∗ −1 −1 −1 = J∗K ΓSH Γ DΓ∗ I + DΓ−1 DΓ∗ ΓJH ∗ ΓJH JH Γ DΓ∗ ∗ ∗ −2 −1 = J∗K ΓSH Γ DΓ∗ ΓJH (I + J∗H Γ∗ DΓ−2 ∗ ΓJH ) ∗ ∗ = J∗K ΓSH (R − I)JH (J∗H RJH )−1 = J∗K ΓSH RJH G2 , ∗ since, clearly, SH JH = O. Here we have used (4.5) and another elementary identity: (I + T T ∗ )−1 T = T (I + T ∗ T )−1 .
This completes the proof. The set of operators Ω that admit a representation of the form (4.4) is an operator quasiball. Operator quasiballs can be defined as follows. If Λ is a nonnegative operator on K, Π is a nonnegative operator on H, and O is a bounded linear operator from H to K, the set of operators of the form B = {O + ΛEΠ : E ∈ B(H, K), E ≤ 1} is called an operator quasiball. The operator O is called the center of B, Λ is called a left semiradius and Π is called a right semiradius of B. The quasiball B is nontrivial, i.e., it consists of more than one element if and only if both Λ and Π are nonzero operators. Clearly, the semiradii are not uniquely determined by the quasiball. However, if the quasiball is nontrivial, then the left and right semiradii are determined modulo positive scalar constant multiples. It is also easy to see that the center is uniquely determined by the quasiball. ∗ The center of the quasiball in (4.4) is −J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH G2ρ . If we apply formula (4.4) to the operator Γ∗ and take the adjoint, we obtain another expression for the center: −G2∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH . Hence, ∗ − J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH G2ρ = −G2∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH
(4.6)
is the center of the quasiball (4.4). B 3 ⊃ · · · is a sequence of operator quasiballs, then If B 1 ⊃ B 2 ⊃ B j is also an operator quasiball. Indeed, let Oj be their intersection j≥0
the center of B j . It can easily be seen that one can choose the semiradii Λj and Πj of B j so that Λj ≥ Λj+1 and Πj ≥ Πj+1 . Let O be the limit in the weak operator topology of a subsequence of {Oj }j≥1 . It can be shown
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
191
that the sequences {Λj }j≥1 and {Πj }j≥1 converge in the weak operator topology to operators Λ and Π and ' B j = {O + ΛEΠ : E ∈ B(H, K), E ≤ 1}. j≥0
Moreover, it is not hard to see that the sequence {Oj }j≥1 converges in the weak operator topology to O. We refer the reader to Shmul’yan [1] for the facts on operator quasiballs mentioned above. Consider now the case ρ = Γ, i.e., we consider one-step extensions of minimal norm. Let {ρj }j≥1 be a sequence of positive numbers such that ρj > Γ and ρj → Γ as j → ∞. An operator Ω : H → K determines a one-step extension of minimal norm if and only if it belongs to the intersection of the quasiballs
1 def ∗ ∗ 2 B j = −JK ΓSH Rρj JH Gρj + G∗ρj EGρj : EB(H,K) ≤ 1 . ρj −1/2
−1/2
G∗ρj }j≥1 and {ρj Gρj }j≥1 are It is easy to see that the sequences {ρj nonincreasing and we obtain the following result. Theorem 4.2. An operator Ω : H → K determines a one-step extension of minimal norm if and only if it belongs to the operator quasiball with center ∗ − lim J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH G2ρ ρ→ Γ +
and semiradii
1 lim J∗ R∗ρ JK Γ ρ→ Γ + K
and
1 lim J∗ Rρ JH , Γ ρ→ Γ + H the limits being taken in the strong operator topology. Now we are able to describe the operators Γ with a unique one-step extension of minimal norm. Theorem 4.3. Let Γ be a vectorial Hankel operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K). Then it has a unique one-step extension of minimal norm if and only if at least one of the following conditions (i) and (ii) is satisfied: (i) s- lim Gρ = O; ρ→ Γ +
(ii) s- lim ρ→ Γ +
G∗ρ = O.
Moreover, (i) is equivalent to the condition (i ) Range(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 JH H = {O}, and (ii) is equivalent to the condition (ii ) Range(Γ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )1/2 JK K = {O}. Proof. In view of the above discussion it remains to show that (i)⇔(i ) and (ii)⇔(ii ). Let us establish the equivalence of (i) and (i ). To verify the equivalence of (ii) and (ii ), it suffices to interchange the roles of Γ and Γ∗ .
192
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Suppose that (i) is satisfied and x is a vector in H such that JH x ∈ Range(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 , i.e.,
JH x = (Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 g, g ∈ 2 (H). Then for ρ > Γ we have 2 G−1 = (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 JH x, JH x ρ x 2 = (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1/2 (Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 g 2
(H)
→ g2 def
as ρ → Γ+, by the spectral theorem. Thus the family yρ = G−1 ρ x, ρ > Γ, is bounded. Hence, it follows from (i) that Gρ yρ → 0 as ρ → Γ+ in the weak operator topology. However, Gρ yρ = x, which proves that (i)⇒(i ). Conversely, suppose that (i) does not hold. Since Gρ1 ≥ Gρ2 for ρ1 ≥ ρ2 and the operators Gρ are nonnegative, it is well known (see Halmos [2], Problem 120) that there exists a strong limit G of Gρ as ρ → Γ+. Let w ∈ H such that def x = Gw = lim Gρ w = O. ρ→ Γ +
Let us show that −1 G−1 ρ x = Gρ Gw ≤ w. −1 Clearly, G−1 ρ G = GGρ . and so G2ρ ≥ G2 for ρ ≥ Γ.
It is easy to see that Thus
(4.7) G2ρ1
≥
G2ρ2
for ρ1 ≥ ρ2 ,
2 2 −1 −1 2 −1 −1 2 GG−1 ρ v = (G Gρ v, Gρ v) ≤ (Gρ Gρ v, Gρ v) = v ,
which proves (4.7). We have 2 2 (ρ I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 JH x, JH x = G−1 ρ x ≤ const, and it follows from Lemma 5.1.6 that JH x ∈ Range(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 . Corollary 4.4. Suppose that Γ2 is an eigenvalue of Γ∗ Γ and clos J∗H Ker(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ) = H;
(4.8)
then Γ has a unique one-step extension of minimal norm. Proof. Suppose that x ∈ H and JH x = (Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)1/2 f for some f ∈ 2 (H). Then JH x ⊥ Ker(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ). By (4.8), x = O. Remark. Another sufficient condition for uniqueness can be obtained if we interchange the roles of Γ and Γ∗ . We obtain now some useful identities that will be used in this section. In addition to (4.2) we need the following easily verifiable commutation relation: ∗ ∗ = SK Γ + JK J∗K ΓSH − SK ΓJH J∗H . ΓSH
(4.9)
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
193
It follows easily from (4.2) and (4.9) that ∗ ∗ (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )SK = SK (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ ) + SK ΓJH J∗H Γ∗ − JK J∗K ΓSH Γ .
This implies the following identity: ∗ ∗ Γ R∗ρ . (4.10) SK R∗ρ = R∗ρ SK + R∗ρ SK ΓJH J∗H Γ∗ R∗ρ − R∗ρ JK J∗K ΓSH
If we apply (4.10) to the operator Γ∗ , we obtain ∗ ΓRρ . SH Rρ = Rρ SH + Rρ SH Γ∗ JK J∗K ΓRρ − Rρ JH J∗H Γ∗ SK
(4.11)
We also need the following simple formula: Γ∗ R∗ρ Γ = ρ2 Rρ − I.
(4.12)
To prove (4.12), we observe that Γ∗ R∗ρ Γ(ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ) = Γ∗ R∗ρ (ρ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )Γ = Γ∗ Γ = ρ2 I − (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ). Multiplying this on the right by Rρ , we obtain (4.12). If we apply (4.12) to Γ∗ , we find that ΓRρ Γ∗ = ρ2 R∗ρ − I.
(4.13)
Finally, we need the formula ∗ ˜Γ ˜ ∗ = (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )(Ω∗ J∗K + J∗H Γ∗ SK Γ ) + ΓΓ∗ .
Indeed,
˜Γ ˜∗ Γ
=
Ω Ω0 Ω1 .. .
Ω0 Ω1 Ω2 .. .
Ω1 Ω2 Ω3 .. .
··· ··· ··· .. .
Ω∗ Ω∗0 Ω∗1 .. .
Ω∗0 Ω∗1 Ω∗2 .. .
Ω∗1 Ω∗2 Ω∗3 .. .
(4.14) ··· ··· ··· .. .
Ω = Ω0 Ω∗ .. .
Ω0 Ω1 + .. . =
Ω1 Ω2 .. .
Ω∗0
···
∗ Ω0 ··· Ω∗1 ··· .. .. . .
Ω∗1 Ω∗2 .. .
··· ··· .. .
∗ (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )(Ω∗ J∗K + J∗H Γ∗ SK ) + ΓΓ∗ .
Let us introduce now the following important operators. Pρ : Qρ : P∗ρ : Q∗ρ :
H → 2 (H), H → 2 (K), K → 2 (K), K → 2 (H),
Pρ = ρRρ JH Gρ ; Qρ = SK ΓRρ JH Gρ ; P∗ρ = ρR∗ρ JK G∗ρ ; Q∗ρ = SH Γ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ .
194
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
One-Step Canonical Extensions Without loss of generality we may assume that dim H ≤ dim K. Otherwise we could study Γ∗ rather than Γ. If ρ > Γ, we say that a one-step ˜ is canonical if the operator E : H → K in (4.4) is an isometric ρ-extension Γ operator, i.e., E ∗ E = IH . ˜ be a canonical one-step Theorem 4.5. Let ρ > Γ and let Γ ρ-extension of Γ determined by an isometry E in (4.4). Then the following equalities hold: ˜ ρ + Q∗ρ E) = ρ(Qρ + P∗ρ E), Γ(P
˜ ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E) = ρ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E). (4.15) Γ
Moreover, ˜ ∗ Γ) ˜ = (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)H, Ker(ρ2 I − Γ and
Γ2 , ρ2
'
˜Γ ˜ ∗ ) ⊃ (Qρ + P∗ρ E)H, Ker(ρ2 I − Γ (4.16)
' ∗ ˜ = Γ2 , ρ2 ˜∗Γ ˜Γ ˜ = ∅. σ Γ σ Γ
Remark. It is easy to see that J∗H (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)H = H. Indeed, it follows from the definition of Pρ , Qρ , P∗ρ , Q∗ρ that J∗H (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)H = J∗H Pρ H = ρJ∗H Rρ JH Gρ H = ρG−1 ρ H = H. Proof of Theorem 4.5. Let us show that for any operator E from H to K the following equalities hold: ∗ Γ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E) = ρSK (Qρ + P∗ρ E);
∗ Γ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E) = ρSH (Pρ + Q∗ρ E). (4.17)
Indeed, by the definition of Pρ , Qρ , P∗ρ , Q∗ρ , we have Γ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E)
= ρΓRρ JH Gρ + ΓSH Γ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E ∗ ∗ Qρ + SK ΓΓ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E = ρSK ∗ ∗ Qρ + SK ((ΓΓ∗ − ρ2 I) + ρ2 I)R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E = ρSK ∗ ∗ ∗ = ρSK Qρ + SK (−I + ρ2 R∗ρ )JK G∗ρ E = ρSK (Qρ + P∗ρ E),
∗ JK G∗ρ E = O. The second equality in (4.17) can be since obviously, SK proved in exactly the same way. Using (4.3), we obtain
˜ ρ + Q∗ρ E) Γ(P
= JK ΩJ∗H (Pρ + Q∗ρ E) ∗ (Pρ + Q∗ρ E). + SK Γ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E) + JK J∗K ΓSH
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
195
By (4.17), SK Γ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E)
∗ = ρSK SK (Qρ + P∗ρ E)
= ρ(Qρ + P∗ρ E) − ρJK J∗K (Qρ + P∗ρ E) = ρ(Qρ + P∗ρ E) − ρJK J∗K P∗ρ E = ρ(Qρ + P∗ρ E) − ρ2 JK G−1 ∗ρ E. Next, ∗ ∗ (Pρ + Q∗ρ E) = ρJK J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH Gρ + JK J∗K ΓΓ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E, JK J∗K ΓSH
and JK J∗K ΓΓ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E
= JK J∗K ((ΓΓ∗ − ρ2 I) + ρ2 I)R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E = −JK G∗ρ E + ρ2 JK J∗K R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E = −JK G∗ρ E + ρ2 JK G−1 ∗ρ E.
It follows from (4.4) that JK ΩJ∗H (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)
= JK ΩJ∗H Pρ 1 ∗ = −JK J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH G2ρ J∗H Pρ + JK G∗ρ EGρ J∗H Pρ ρ ∗ = −ρJK J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH Gρ + JK G∗ρ E.
This proves the first equality in (4.15). To establish the second equality we ˜∗: use the following analog of (4.3) for Γ ∗ ˜ ∗ = JH Ω∗ J∗K + SH Γ∗ + JH J∗H Γ∗ SK Γ .
We have ˜ ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E) Γ
= JH Ω∗ J∗K (Qρ + P∗ρ E) ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E). + SH Γ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E) + JH J∗H Γ∗ SK
By (4.17), SH Γ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E)
∗ = ρSH SH (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)
= ρ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E) − ρJH J∗H (Pρ + Q∗ρ E) = ρ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E) − ρ2 JH J∗H Rρ JH Gρ = ρ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E) − ρ2 JH G−1 ρ . Next, ∗ ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E) = JH J∗H Γ∗ ΓRρ JH Gρ + ρJH J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E JH J∗H Γ∗ SK
196
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
and JH J∗H Γ∗ ΓRρ JH Gρ
= JH J∗H ((Γ∗ Γ − ρ2 I) + ρ2 I)Rρ JH Gρ = −JH Gρ + ρ2 JH J∗H Rρ JH Gρ = −JH Gρ + ρ2 JH G−1 ρ .
Finally, it follows from (4.4) and (4.6) that JH Ω∗ J∗K (Qρ + P∗ρ E)
= JH Ω∗ J∗K P∗ρ E ∗ R∗ρ JK G2∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E = −ρJH J∗H Γ∗ SK
+ JH Gρ E ∗ G∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E + JH Gρ E ∗ E = −ρJH J∗H Γ∗ SK ∗ R∗ρ JK G∗ρ E + JH Gρ . = −ρJH J∗H Γ∗ SK
This proves the second equality in (4.15). Obviously, (4.15) implies that ˜ ˜ ∗ Γ) (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)H ⊂ Ker(ρ2 I − Γ and ˜Γ ˜ ∗ ). (Qρ + P∗ρ E)H ⊂ Ker(ρ2 I − Γ It follows from the Remark preceding the proof of this theorem that if ˜ ˜ ∗ Γ), (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)H = Ker(ρ2 I − Γ ˜∗Γ ˜ with eigenvalue ρ2 such that then there exists an eigenvector f of Γ ∗ ∗ f∈ / (Pρ + Q∗ρ E)H and JH f = O. Let g = SH f ∈ 2 (H). Then ˜ = Γ ˜ · f = ρg. Γf On the other hand, it is easy to see that ˜ = ΓS ˜ H g = Γg, Γf and so Γg ≥ ρg, which contradicts the assumption Γ < ρ. The second part of (4.16) is obvious. To complete the proof, we need the following elementary result. Lemma 4.6. Let Y and Z be Banach spaces, and let T1 : Y → Z and T2 : Z → Y be bounded linear operators. If λ is a nonzero complex number, then λ belongs to the spectrum of T1 T2 if and only if λ belongs to the spectrum of T2 T1 . Proof. Let λ be a nonzero complex number. It has to be proved that if T1 T2 − λI is invertible, then T2 T1 − λI is. Clearly, without loss of generality we may assume that λ = 1. We claim that T2 (T1 T2 −I)−1 T1 −I is the inverse of T2 T1 − I. Indeed, we have (T2 (T1 T2 −I)−1 T1 −I)(T2 T1 −I) = T2 (T1 T2 −I)−1 (T1 T2 −I)T1 −T2 T1 +I = I
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
197
and (T2 T1 −I)(T2 (T1 T2 −I)−1 T1 −I) = T2 (T1 T2 −I)(T1 T2 −I)−1 T1 −T2 T1 +I = I. By Lemma 4.6, it is sufficient to show that (Γ2 , ρ2 ) is contained in the ˜Γ ˜∗. resolvent set of Γ Suppose that λ > Γ. We have by (4.14) ˜Γ ˜ ∗ = λ2 I − ΓΓ∗ − (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )(Ω∗ J∗ + J∗ Γ∗ S ∗ ). λ2 I − Γ K H K Multiplying this equality on the left and on the right by (λ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1/2 , ˜Γ ˜ ∗ is invertible if and and only if the operator we find that λ2 I − Γ ∗ )(λ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1/2 I − (λ2 I − ΓΓ∗ )−1/2 (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )(Ω∗ J∗K + J∗H Γ∗ SK
is invertible. It follows from Lemma 4.6 that this is equivalent to the invertibility of the operator ∗ T (λ) = IH − (Ω∗ J∗K + J∗H Γ∗ SK )R∗λ (JK Ω + SK ΓJH ) def
on H. Let us compute T (ρ). Using (4.4) and (4.6), we obtain ∗ ∗ (Ω∗ J∗K + J∗H Γ∗ SK )R∗ρ JK Ω = −J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK G2∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ JK Ω
+
1 ∗ Gρ E ∗ G∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ JK Ω + J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK Ω ρ
1 ∗ = −J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK Ω + Gρ E ∗ G−1 ∗ρ JK Ω ρ ∗ R∗ρ JK Ω = + J∗H Γ∗ SK
1 Gρ E ∗ G−1 ∗ρ JK Ω ρ
1 2 ∗ = − Gρ E ∗ G−1 ∗ρ JK G∗ρ JK R∗ρ SK ΓJH ρ 1 + 2 Gρ E ∗ G−1 ∗ρ JK G∗ρ EGρ ρ 1 1 = − Gρ E ∗ G∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH + 2 Gρ E ∗ EGρ ρ ρ and Ω∗ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH
∗ = −J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK G2∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH
+
1 Gρ E ∗ G∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH . ρ
Since E ∗ E = IH , we have T (ρ)
1 2 ∗ G + J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK G2∗ρ J∗K R∗ρ SK ΓJH ρ2 ρ ∗ − J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH .
= IH −
198
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Let us show that T (ρ) = O. By (4.10), we have ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ R∗ρ = SK R∗ρ SK + SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH J∗H Γ∗ R∗ρ − SK R∗ρ JK J∗K ΓSH Γ R∗ρ .
Hence, ∗ J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH
= J∗H Γ∗ R∗ρ ΓJH ∗ − J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH J∗H Γ∗ R∗ρ ΓJH ∗ ∗ ∗ + J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK J∗K ΓSH Γ R∗ρ ΓJH . (4.18)
Using (4.12), we obtain from (4.18) ∗ J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH
∗ ∗ ∗ = −I + ρ2 G−2 ρ + JH Γ SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH ∗ − ρ2 J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ SK ΓJH G−2 ρ ∗ ∗ − J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK J∗K ΓSH JH ∗ ∗ + ρ2 J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH .
∗ Since obviously, SH JH = O, it follows that ∗ ∗ ∗ R∗ρ SK ΓJH = −G2ρ + ρ2 I + ρ2 J∗H Γ∗ SK R∗ρ JK J∗K ΓSH Rρ JH G2ρ . ρ2 J∗H Γ∗ SK
Dividing this equality by ρ2 and applying (4.6), we see that T (ρ) = O. Let us show that for λ ∈ (Γ, ρ), (−T (λ)x, x) ≥ δx2 ,
x ∈ H,
(4.19)
for some positive number δ. Indeed, it follows from the spectral theorem that ρ2 − λ2 f 2 , f ∈ 2 (K), λ ∈ (Γ, ρ). (R∗λ − R∗ρ )f, f ≥ λ2 ρ2 Now let f = (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )x. Then (R∗λ − R∗ρ )f, f = T (ρ) − T (λ))x, x = (−T (λ)x, x) and f 2 (K)
= (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )x2 (K) −1/2
= R∗ρ ≥
1/2
R∗ρ (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )x2 (K)
R∗ρ −1 R∗ρ (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )x2 (K) 1/2
1/2
1/2 1/2 = R∗ρ −1 (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )∗ R∗ρ (JK Ω + SK ΓJH )x, x 1/2 1/2 1/2 = R∗ρ −1 (I − T (ρ))x, x = R∗ρ −1 xH , which implies (4.19). Thus T (λ) is invertible for λ ∈ (Γ, ρ).
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
199
˜ is a canonical one-step ρ-extension It follows from Theorem 4.6 that if Γ ˜ of Γ, then Γ = ρ. Now we can show that a canonical one-step ρ-extension has a unique one-step extension of minimal norm. ˜ be a canonical one step Theorem 4.7. Let ρ > Γ and let Γ ˜ ρ-extension of Γ. Then Γ has a unique one-step ρ-extension. Proof. This is an immediate consequence of Corollary 4.4 and the Remark followed by the proof of Theorem 4.5.
Complete ρ-Extensions If Γ = {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 : 2 (H) → 2 (K) is a vectorial Hankel operator such that Γ ≤ ρ and {Ωj }j∈Z is an extension of the sequence {Ωj }j≥0 such that Ωj ∈ B(H, K), j ∈ Z, and the operator Γ# = {Ωj+k }j,k≥∈Z : 2Z (H) → 2Z (K) has norm at most ρ, we say that Γ# is a complete ρ-extension (or simply ρ-extension) of Γ. It is evident that Γ# ≥ Γ. We have proved in §2.2 that each bounded vectorial Hankel operator Γ has a complete extension of norm Γ. Moreover, in §2.2 a complete extension has been constructed by constructing first a one-step extension, then a one step extension of the one-step extension, etc. It turns out that a complete extension of norm Γ is unique if and only if a one-step extension of norm Γ is unique. Theorem 4.8. Let Γ = {Ωj+k }j,k≥0 be a bounded block Hankel matrix. The following are equivalent: (i) Γ has a unique one-step extension of minimal norm; (ii) Γ has a unique complete extension of minimal norm. Proof. The implication (ii)⇒(i) is obvious. Let us prove that (i)⇒(ii). ˜ of norm It is sufficient to show that if Γ has a unique one-step extension Γ ˜˜ ˜ also has a unique one-step extension of minimal norm. Let Γ Γ, then Γ ˜˜ = Γ. Since Γ = S ∗ Γ, ˜ such that ˜ we have be a one-step extension of Γ Γ K
∗˜ ˜∗Γ ˜−Γ ˜ ∗ JK J∗K Γ ˜≥Γ ˜ ∗ Γ. ˜ ˜ ∗ SK SK Γ=Γ Γ∗ Γ = Γ ˜ −1 , ρ > Γ. Consequently, ˜ ∗ Γ) Hence, (ρ2 I − Γ∗ Γ)−1 ≤ (ρ2 I − Γ ∗ 2 ∗ −1 ˜ −1 JH def ˜ ∗ Γ) ˜ −2 JH ≤ J∗H (ρ2 I − Γ = G G−2 ρ = JH (ρ I − Γ Γ) ρ .
˜ 2ρ ≤ G2ρ . By the Heinz inequality (see Appendix 1.7), It follows that G ˜ Gρ ≤ Gρ . If we interchange the roles of Γ and Γ∗ , we obtain the inequality ˜ −1 JK −1/2 . The result follows ˜ ∗ρ def ˜ ∗ Γ) ˜ ∗ρ ≤ G∗ρ , where G = J∗K (ρ2 I − Γ G now from Theorem 4.3 (see conditions (i) and (ii)). Theorems 4.3 and 4.8 give a necessary and sufficient condition for the uniqueness of a complete extension of minimal norm. Note that in the scalar case the same result has been proved in §5.1 (see Theorem 1.5).
200
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
We can obtain now an analog of the uniqueness result in Theorem 1.1.4 for vectorial Hankel operators. Corollary 4.9. Suppose that ρ2 is an eigenvalue of Γ∗ Γ and (4.8) holds. Then Γ has a unique extension of minimal norm. Proof. This is an immediate consequence of Corollary 4.4 and Theorem 4.8. Note that another sufficient condition for uniqueness can be obtained if we interchange the roles of Γ and Γ∗ . We now consider a condition stronger than (4.8). Namely, we assume that J∗H Ker(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ) is a one-to-one map of the eigenspace Ker(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ) of Γ∗ Γ onto H. Let V : H → Ker(Γ2 I − Γ∗ Γ) be the inverse of this operator. We consider V as an operator from H to 2 (H). Let W : H → 2 (K) be the operator defined by 1 W = ΓV. ρ Clearly, 1 ΓV = ρW and Γ∗ W = Γ∗ ΓV = ρV. (4.20) ρ We denote by Γ# the complete extension Γ# of norm Γ, which is unique ˆ for an operator by Corollary 4.9. Then Γ# = {Ωj+k }j,k∈Z , where Ωj = Ξ(j) function Ξ ∈ L∞ (B(H, K)) such that ΞL∞ = Γ (see §2.2). As usual we identify in a natural way the spaces 2 (H) and 2 (K) with the Hardy classes H 2 (H) and H 2 (K). We also identify the spaces 2Z (H) and 2Z (K) with L2 (H) and L2 (K). Under this identification we can write (Γ# f )(ζ) = Ξ(ζ)f ζ¯ , ζ ∈ T, f ∈ L2 (H). We have ˜ · V x, P+ Γ# V x = ΓV x = ρV x = Γ ∗
Hence, ΓV = P+ Γ# V = Γ# V . Similarly, Γ W = Γ# V = ρW
and
x ∈ H.
P+ Γ∗# W
= Γ∗# W . Thus
Γ∗# W = ρV.
(4.21)
Let V x = {Vj x}j≥0 and W x = {Wj x}j≥0 , where Vj : H → H and Wj : H → K are the operators defined by ∗ j Vj = J∗H (SH ) V
∗ j and Wj = J∗K (SK ) W.
The following identity holds: j ∗ j V = W ∗ (SK ) W. V ∗ SH
Indeed, ∗ j W ∗ (SK ) W =
1 ∗ ∗ j 1 j j W (SK ) ΓV = W ∗ ΓSH V = V ∗ SH V. ρ ρ
(4.22)
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
It follows from the definition of V that V0 = IH . Let V and W be the operator functions defined by Vx= z j Vj x and W x = z j Wj x, j≥0
201
x ∈ H.
j≥0
It is easy to see that (4.20) and (4.21) can be rewritten in the following way: z ) = ρW , P+ Ξ∗ W (¯ z ) = ρV P+ ΞV (¯ and ΞV (¯ z ) = ρW ,
Ξ∗ W (¯ z ) = ρV .
(4.23) For x and the functions vx,y = V (z)V (z)x, y and y∗ in H we consider wx,y = W (z)W (z)x, y on the unit circle. We have
j j V y) = (x, V ∗ SH V y), vˆx,y (j) = V (ζ)x, ζ j V (ζ)y dm(ζ) = (V x, SH
∗
T
for j ≥ 0 and
−j −j −j vˆx,y (j) = ζ V (ζ)x, V (ζ)y dm(ζ) = (SH V x, V y) = (V ∗ SH V x, y), T
for j ≤ 0. Similarly,
∗ j W (ζ)x, ζ j W (ζ)y dm(ζ) = W ∗ (SH ) W x, y , w ˆx,y (j) = T
and w ˆx,y (j) =
T
∗ −j ζ −j W (ζ)x, W (ζ)y dm(ζ) = x, W ∗ (SH ) Wy ,
j ≥ 0,
j ≤ 0.
By (4.22), we obtain w ˆx,y (j) = vˆx,y (−j),
j ∈ Z.
z ), and so This means that wx,y (z) = vx,y (¯ W ∗ (z)W (z) = V ∗ (¯ z )V (¯ z ).
(4.24)
If the space H is finite-dimensional, det V belongs to the Hardy class H 2/ dim H , and since det V (0) = det X0 = 1, it is a nonzero function. Therefore for almost all ζ ∈ T the operator V (ζ) is invertible, and by (4.23), we have Ξ(ζ) = ρW (ζ)V −1 ζ¯ , ζ ∈ T. It now follows from (4.23) and (4.24) that the function ρ1 Ξ takes isometric values almost everywhere on T. Suppose now that Γ is a Hankel operator from 2 (H) to 2 (K) and ˜ be a canoniρ > Γ (we do not assume here that dim H < ∞). Let Γ cal one-step ρ-extension that corresponds to an isometry E : H → K in (4.4). By Theorem 4.5 and the Remark following its statement, J∗H is a ˜ ∗ Γ) ˜ onto H, and formulas (4.15) hold. Now one-to-one map of Ker(ρ2 I − Γ
202
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
the operators Pρ + Q∗ρ and Qρ + P∗ρ can play the roles of the operators V and W above. Note, however, that in this case (Pρ + Q∗ρ )0 = J∗H (Pρ + Q∗ρ ) def
does not have to be equal to IH , but we do not need it! We have used only the fact that V0 is invertible on H, and the fact that (Pρ + Q∗ρ )0 is invertible on H is an immediate consequence of the definition of Pρ and Q∗ρ . ˜ has a unique complete extension of norm As we have already observed, Γ def ˜ ∗˜ ˜ ρ, which we denote by Γ# . It is easy to see that Γ# = Γ # SH = SK Γ# is a complete ρ-extension of Γ. (Recall that SH and SK are bilateral shifts on 2Z (H) and 2Z (K).) Thus by (4.15), we have ∗ (Qρ + P∗ρ E), Γ# (Pρ + Q∗ρ E) = ρSK
∗ Γ∗# SK (Qρ + P∗ρ E) = ρ(Pρ + Q∗ρ E).
(4.25) We define the operator functions P ρ , Qρ , P ∗ρ , and Q∗ρ by P ρx =
z j (Pρ )j x,
Qρ x =
j≥0
and P ∗ρ x =
z j (P∗ρ )j x,
z j (Qρ )j x,
x ∈ H,
j≥0
Q∗ρ x =
j≥0
z j (Q∗ρ )j x,
x ∈ H,
j≥0
where as in the case of operators V and W above, Pρ x = {(Pρ )j x}j≥0 , P∗ρ x = {(P∗ρ )j x}j≥0 ,
Qρ x = {(Qρ )j x}j≥0 ,
and Q∗ρ x = {(Q∗ρ )j x}j≥0 .
ˆ Let Ξ be an operator function in L∞ (B(H, K)) such that Ξ(j) = Ωj , j ≥ 0. As we have already mentioned, ΞL∞ = ρ and (Γ# f )(z) = Ξ(z)f (¯ z ), f ∈ L2 (H). We obtain from (4.25) z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E = ρ¯ z Qρ (z) + P ∗ρ (z)E . (4.26) Ξ(z) P ρ (¯ and
Ξ∗ (z) = z¯ Qρ (z) + P ∗ρ (z)E = ρ P ρ (¯ z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E .
Again, if dim H < ∞, we obtain from (4.26) the following formula for Ξ: −1 z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E . Ξ(z) = ρ¯ z Qρ (z) + P ∗ρ (z)E (P ρ (¯ Such complete ρ-extensions are called canonical.
(4.27)
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
203
Properties of the Functions Pρ , P∗ρ , Qρ , and Q∗ρ We establish here some important properties of P ρ , P ∗ρ , Qρ , and Q∗ρ which we are going to use later in this section. Theorem 4.10. Suppose that ρ > Γ. Then the following identities hold for almost all ζ ∈ T: ¯ ¯ P ∗ρ (ζ)P ρ (ζ) − Q∗ρ (ζ)Q ρ (ζ) = IH ;
(4.28)
¯ ∗ρ (ζ) ¯ − Q∗ (ζ)Q (ζ) = IK ; P ∗∗ρ (ζ)P ∗ρ ∗ρ
(4.29)
∗ ¯ ¯ P ∗∗ρ (ζ)Q ρ (ζ) − Q∗ρ (ζ)P ρ (ζ) = O.
(4.30)
Proof. Let us establish the following formulas:
IH , j = 0, j ∗ j Pρ∗ SH Pρ − Q∗ρ (SK ) Qρ = O, j > 0, ∗ j P∗ρ SK P∗ρ
−
∗ j Q∗∗ρ (SH ) Q∗ρ
=
(4.31)
IK , j = 0, O, j > 0,
(4.32)
and j ∗ j ∗ j ∗ ∗ j P∗ρ SK Qρ − Q∗∗ρ (SH ) Pρ = P∗ρ (SK ) Qρ − Q∗∗ρ SH Pρ = O,
j ≥ 0. (4.33)
It follows easily from definition that SK ΓPρ = ρQρ
and
∗ Γ∗ SK Qρ = ρPρ − JH Gρ .
Hence, Pρ∗ = ρ1 (Gρ J∗H + Q∗ρ SK Γ), and so for j > 0 we have j Pρ∗ SH Pρ
=
1 1 j j (Gρ J∗H + Q∗ρ SK Γ)SH Pρ = Q∗ρ SK ΓSH Pρ ρ ρ
=
1 ∗ 1 ∗ j ∗ ∗ j ∗ j ) ΓPρ = Q∗ρ SK SK (SK ) SK ΓPρ = Q∗ρ (SK ) Qρ . Q SK (SK ρ ρ ρ
On the other hand, Pρ∗ Pρ − Q∗ρ Qρ
= Pρ∗ Pρ − =
1 ∗ ∗ P Γ ΓPρ ρ2 ρ
1 ∗ 2 P (ρ I − Γ∗ Γ)Pρ = Gρ J∗H Rρ JH Gρ = IH . ρ2 ρ
This proves (4.31). Using the identities SH Γ∗ P∗ρ = ρQ∗ρ
and
∗ ΓSH Q∗ρ = ρP∗ρ − JK G∗ρ ,
we can prove in the same way (4.32).
204
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Let us establish (4.33). We have for j ≥ 0 ∗ j SK Qρ P∗ρ
=
1 1 j j+1 Qρ = Q∗∗ρ SH Γ∗ SK ΓRρ JH Gρ (G∗ρ J∗K + Q∗∗ρ SH Γ∗ )SK ρ ρ
=
1 ∗ 1 ∗ j+1 ∗ ∗ j ∗ Q∗ρ SH (SH ) Γ ΓRρ JH Gρ = Q∗∗ρ (SH ) Γ ΓRρ JH Gρ ρ ρ
=
1 ∗ ∗ j Q (S ∗ )j (Γ∗ Γ − ρ2 I + ρ2 I)Rρ JH Gρ = Q∗∗ρ (SH ) Pρ , ρ ∗ρ H
since obviously, 1 ∗ Q (S ∗ )j JH Gρ = O. ρ ∗ρ H Finally, for j > 0 we obtain j Pρ Q∗∗ρ SH
=
1 ∗ 1 ∗ ∗ j−1 j−1 Pρ = P∗ρ (SK ) ΓPρ P∗ρ ΓSH ρ ρ
=
1 ∗ ∗ j ∗ ∗ j P (S ) SK ΓPρ = P∗ρ (SK ) Qρ , ρ ∗ρ K
which completes the proof of (4.33). Now it is easy to deduce (4.28), (4.29), and (4.30) from (4.31), (4.32), and (4.33). Let us show how to obtain, for example, (4.28). We compare z )Qρ (¯ z ). Since the Fourier coefficients of the functions P ∗ρ (z)P ρ (z) and Q∗ρ (¯ both functions take self-adjoint values, it is sufficient to compare their jth Fourier cofficients with j ≥ 0. Let x, y ∈ H and j > 0. Then
∗ ∗ P ρ (ζ)P ρ (ζ)x, y ζ¯j dm(ζ) = P ρ (ζ)P ρ (ζ)x, ζ j P ρ (ζ)y dm(ζ) T
T
j ∗ j (x, Pρ∗ SH Pρ y) = (x, Q∗ρ (SK ) Qρ y)
∗ Qρ (ζ)Qρ (ζ)x, y ζ j dm(ζ) =
=
T
=
T
j ¯ ¯ ¯ Q∗ρ (ζ)Q ρ (ζ)x, y ζ dm(ζ).
For j = 0 we have
∗ ∗ ¯ ¯ P ρ (ζ)P ρ (ζ)x, y dm(ζ) − Qρ (ζ)Q ρ (ζ)x, y dm(ζ) T
T
=
(Pρ∗ Pρ x, y) − (Q∗ρ Qρ x, y) = (x, y).
Formulas (4.29) and (4.30) can be deduced from (4.32) and (4.33) in a similar way.
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
205
Suppose now that the spaces H and K are finite-dimensional and dim H ≤ dim K. Consider the block matrix function Uρ on T defined by P ρ (z) Q∗ρ (z) (4.34) Uρ (z) = z ) P ∗ρ (¯ z) Qρ (¯ and the matrix
def
J =
O −IK
IH O
.
(4.35)
It is easy to see that (4.28)–(4.30) mean that Uρ∗ (ζ)JUρ (ζ) = J
for almost all ζ ∈ T.
(4.36)
In other words, the matrix function Uρ is J-unitary. It is easy to see that the matrix function Uρ∗ is also J-unitary. Indeed, by (4.36), Uρ (ζ) = J(Uρ∗ (ζ))−1 J, and so Uρ (ζ)JUρ∗ (ζ) = J(Uρ∗ (ζ))−1 JJUρ∗ (ζ) = J(Uρ∗ (ζ))−1 Uρ∗ (ζ) = J.
(4.37)
Considering all entries in (4.37), we obtain the following identities P ρ (ζ)P ∗ρ (ζ) − Q∗ρ (ζ)Q∗∗ρ (ζ) = IH ;
(4.38)
¯ ∗ (ζ) ¯ − Q (ζ)Q ¯ ∗ (ζ) ¯ = IK ; P ∗ρ (ζ)P ρ ∗ρ ρ
(4.39)
¯ − Q (ζ)P ∗ (ζ) ¯ = O. P ρ (ζ)Q∗ρ (ζ) ∗ρ ∗ρ
(4.40)
It follows from (4.28) and (4.29) (as well as from (4.38) and (4.39)) that the operator functions P ρ (z) and P ∗ρ (¯ z ) are invertible. Moreover, −1 ¯ (ζ) ≤ 1 and P ( ζ) ≤ 1 almost everywhere on T. P −1 ρ ∗ρ Consider now the operator function Xρ on T defined by ∗ z )(P ∗∗ρ )−1 (¯ z) Xρ (z) = P −1 ρ (z)Q∗ρ (z) = Qρ (¯
(4.41)
(see (4.40)). Theorem 4.11. The function Xρ has the following properties: Xρ (0) = O;
Xρ (ζ) < 1,
ζ ∈ D;
and
(1 − Xρ (z))−1 ∈ L1 . (4.42)
The operator functions P ρ , P ∗ρ , Qρ , and Q∗ρ are uniquely determined by Xρ , and the functions P ρ and P ∗ρ satisfy ∞ P −1 ρ ∈H ;
P −1 z) ∈ H ∞. ∗ρ (¯
Proof. The fact that Xρ (0) = O is an immediate consequence of the definition of Q∗ρ . It is easy to see from (4.38) that for almost all ζ ∈ T ∗ −1 (ζ) = 1−P ρ (ζ)−2 < 1. Xρ (ζ)2 = Xρ (ζ)Xρ∗ (ζ) = IH −P −1 ρ (ζ)(P ρ )
Hence, (1 − Xρ (ζ))−1 = (1 + Xρ (ζ))P ρ (ζ)2 ≤ 2P ρ (ζ)2 ,
ζ ∈ T,
206
and so
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
T
(1 − Xρ (ζ))
−1
dm(ζ) ≤ 2
T
P ρ (ζ)2 dm(ζ) < ∞.
This completes the proof of (4.42). Now let E be an isometry from H to K and let −1 def z Qρ (z) + P ∗ρ (z)E (P ρ (¯ z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E . ΞE (z) = ρ¯
(4.43)
ˆ E (j) = Ωj , j ≥ 0. It follows from (4.28)– We have already shown that Ξ (4.30) that ΞE also admits the following representation: −1 ∗ ΞE (z) = ρ¯ Q∗ρ (¯ z P ∗∗ρ (z) + EQ∗ρ (z) z ) + EP ∗ρ (¯ z) . (4.44) Moreover, if E is an arbitrary contractive operator from H to K (i.e., E ≤ 1), then the operator functions defined by (4.43) and (4.44) coincide. It is easy to see that if E1 and E2 are contractive operators from H to K, and we use (4.43) for ΞE1 and (4.44) for ΞE2 , then the following identity follows from (4.28)–(4.30): −1 −1 ΞE1 (z)−ΞE2 (z) = ρ¯ z (P ∗∗ρ (z)+E2 Q∗ρ (z) (E1 −E2 )(P ρ (¯ z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E1 . (4.45) If E1 and E2 are isometries, then it follows from (4.45) that −1 2 z¯(P ∗∗ρ (z) + E2 Q∗ρ (z) (E1 − E2 ) ∈ H− (B(H, K)) and
−1 2 z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E1 ∈ H− (B(H, K)). z¯(E1 − E2 )(P ρ (¯ If E1 is an arbitrary isometry, we can put E2 = −E1 and we find that −1 2 z ) + Q∗ρ (¯ z )E1 ∈ H− (B(H)). (4.46) z¯(P ρ (¯
On the other hand, given an isometry E2 and an arbitrary vector b in K, we can find an isometry E1 such that b ∈ Range(E1 − E1 ). Thus it is easy to see that −1 2 ∈ H− (B(K)). z¯(P ∗∗ρ (z) + E2 Q∗ρ (z) Note that for finite-dimensional spaces H1 and H2 and a space X of functions on T, we say that an operator function F belongs to X(B(H1 , H2 )) (or simply F ∈ X) if (F a, b) ∈ X for any a ∈ H1 and b ∈ H2 . For an isometry E from H to K we define the function GE by −1 GE (z) = P ρ (z) + Q∗ρ (z)E P ρ (z) − Q∗ρ (z)E . It is easy to see from (4.46) that GE ∈ H 1 . By the definition of Xρ , we have for almost all ζ ∈ T: GE (ζ) = (IH + Xρ (ζ)E)−1 (IH − Xρ (ζ)E). Since Xρ (ζ) < 1 for almost all ζ ∈ T, it is easy to see that GE∗ (ζ) + GE (ζ) > O,
a.e. on T.
4. Parametrization via One-Step Extension
207
Taking the Poisson integral, we find that GE∗ (ζ) + GE (ζ) > O,
ζ ∈ D.
(4.47)
Define the operator function Y by Y(ζ) = (IH + GE (ζ))−1 (IH − GE (ζ)),
ζ ∈ D.
It is well known (see e.g., Sz.-Nagy and Foias [1], Ch. IV, §4) and easy to verify that that (4.47) implies that Y(ζ) < 1, ζ ∈ D. It is also clear from the definition of Y that GE (ζ) = (IH + Y(ζ))−1 (IH − Y(ζ)),
ζ ∈ D.
It follows that the boundary values of Y coincide with the function Xρ E almost everywhere on T. Thus Xρ E ∈ H ∞ . Since E is an arbitrary isometry, it follows that Xρ ∈ H ∞ . Next, −1 (IH + Xρ (ζ)E) P ρ (ζ) + Q∗ρ (ζ)E −1 = (IH + P −1 = P −1 ρ (ζ)Q∗ρ (ζ)E) P ρ (ζ) + Q∗ρ (ζ)E ρ (ζ) 2 for almost all ζ ∈ T. It follows that P −1 ρ ∈ H and since it is bounded on −1 −1 ∞ z) ∈ H ∞. T, it follows that P ρ ∈ H . Similarly, P ∗ρ (¯ Finally, by (4.41) and (4.38), we have for almost all ζ ∈ T ∗ ∗ −1 −1 ∗ −1 Xρ (ζ)Xρ∗ (ζ) = P −1 ρ (ζ)Q∗ρ (ζ)Q∗ρ (ζ)(P )ρ (ζ) = IH − P ρ (ζ)(P )ρ (ζ).
Hence, Thus
P −1 ρ
∗ −1 IH − Xρ (ζ)Xρ∗ (ζ) = P −1 ρ (ζ)(P )ρ (ζ),
ζ ∈ T.
is a solution of the factorization problem IH − Xρ Xρ∗ = F F ∗ .
It is easy to see that this factorization problem has a unique solution F such that F ∈ H 2 , F −1 ∈ H 2 , and F (0) > O. Indeed, if F1 and F2 are both solutions of the factorization problems satisfying the above conditions, we have F2−1 F1 = F2∗ (F1∗ )−1 . The left-hand side of this equality belongs to H 1 while the right-hand side belongs to H 1 . Thus F2−1 F1 = C, where C is a constant operator. It follows that F2 CC ∗ F2∗ = F2 F2∗ , and so CC ∗ = I. Since, C = F2−1 (0)F1 (0), and both F1 and F2 are positive, we have CC ∗ = F2−1 (0)F1 (0)F1 (0)F2−1 (0) = I. Hence, F22 (0) = F12 (0), which implies C = I. −1 Thus P −1 ρ is uniquely determined by Xρ . Since Xρ (z) = P ρ (z)Q∗ρ (z), Q∗ρ (z) is also uniquely determined by Xρ . Similarly, it can be shown that IK − Xρ∗ (z)Xρ (z) = P −1 z )(P ∗∗ρ )−1 (¯ z ), ∗ρ (¯ and the functions P ∗ρ and Qρ are uniquely determined by Xρ .
208
Chapter 5. Parametrization of Solutions of the Nehari Problem
Lemma 4.12. The following equality holds: ¯ det P ρ (ζ) = det P ∗∗ρ (ζ),
ζ ∈ D.
(4.48)
Proof. Since, P ρ ∈ H 2 , it follows that det P ρ ∈ H 2/n . Next, ∈ H ∞ , and so (det P ρ )−1 ∈ H ∞ . Hence, det P ρ is an outer function. It follows from the definition of P ρ that det P ρ (0) > 0. Similarly, z ) is an outer function, and it takes a positive value at 0. By det P ∗∗ρ (¯ (4.38) and (4.29), we have for almost all ζ ∈ T P −1 ρ
| det P ρ (ζ)|2
=
det(IH + Q∗ρ (ζ)Q∗∗ρ (ζ))
=
¯ 2. det(IK + Q∗∗ρ (ζ)Q∗ρ (ζ)) = | det P ∗∗ρ (ζ)|
z ) are outer functions with positive valSince both det P ρ (z) and det P ∗∗ρ (¯ ues at 0, we obtain (4.48). Consider now the operator quasiball (4.5). Obviously, the left and right semiradii Λρ and Πρ of this quasi-ball admit the following representations: Λρ = ρ1/2 P ρ (0),
Πρ = ρ1/2 P ∗∗ρ (0).
By (