Hallowed Secularism
This page intentionally left blank
Hallowed Secularism Theory, Belief, Practice Bruce Ledewitz
...
43 downloads
1808 Views
874KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Hallowed Secularism
This page intentionally left blank
Hallowed Secularism Theory, Belief, Practice Bruce Ledewitz
hallowed secularism Copyright © Bruce Ledewitz, 2009. All rights reserved. First published in 2009 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN® in the United States—a division of St. Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Where this book is distributed in the UK, Europe and the rest of the world, this is by Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN-13: 978-0-230-61402-4 ISBN-10: 0-230-61402-7 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available from the Library of Congress. A catalogue record of the book is available from the British Library. Design by Scribe Inc. First edition: March 2009 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
To Anna, Jonas, Ben, Joanne, Ryan, Douglas and Julia, their children and their children’s children, with all my love. You will see a secular world. “This gradual crumbling to pieces . . . is interrupted by the sunrise, which, in a flash and at a single stroke, brings to view the form and structure of the new world.” —Hegel, Phenomenology of Mind
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Preface
ix
Acknowledgments
xi
Introduction
1
Part I
Why Hallowed Secularism Is Necessary and How It Is Possible
1
Secularists’ Indifference and Hostility Toward Religion
11
2
The Roots of Secularism
21
3
The Failure of Secularism
35
4
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
53
Part II The Beliefs and Practices of Hallowed Secularism 5
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
71
6
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
87
7
The Local Life of Hallowed Secularism
105
8
The International Life of Hallowed Secularism
121
Part III The Meaning of Hallowed Secularism 9
Beyond Religion
139
10
Beyond Humanism
155
11
Beyond Materialism
171
12
The Possibility of Hope
187
Conclusion
203
Bibliography
205
Index
211
This page intentionally left blank
Preface As I put the final touches on this manuscript before the production process begins, the debate in secularism of which this book is a part is finally breaking out. So, I believe the book is coming out at an opportune moment. For the past several years, secularism has grown in the United States. It has grown first, in a very slow, long-term trend, especially among the young, whose attachment to organized religion is not as strong as it is among their elders. But secularism has also grown in a seemingly sudden way, as a cascade of books from those I call the New Atheists has come into the market in the last five years. The reader is probably familiar with some of those writers: Sam Harris, Daniel Dennett, Victor Stenger, Mark Lilla, and others, culminating in the culture-changing impact of Christopher Hitchen’s best seller, God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, in 2007. All at once, it seemed, secularists were a national audience. This secular prominence did not immediately translate into political or policy influence. The 2008 presidential primary campaigns were perhaps the most religiously influenced in American history with the early success of Mike Huckabee, Mitt Romney’s speech on his Mormon faith, and the constant efforts of John Edwards, Hillary Clinton, and Barack Obama to speak the language of faith during debates and in their campaigning. From the tone of the presidential races, you would not know that any secularists existed in America. But beneath this surface appearance, a change was beginning to manifest in secularism itself. Before, the only issue for secularists had been to establish secularism as an alternative to religion. Thus, the tone of the New Atheists was still religion bashing of the old style. There was not much concern in these works about secularism itself and what kind of life a secularist could lead. Now that secularism is established as a national force, as a genuinely mass movement for the first time, the question of the future of secularism has begun to come to the fore. It is no longer enough for the secularist to say, “I am not religious.” The question now is, what am I and how shall I live? That change is now apparent. Earlier this year, too late for me to take much note of it in this manuscript, Austin Dacey published The Secular
x
•
Preface
Conscience: Why Belief Belongs in Public Life. I was happy to see this book because, as a staff member of the Center for Inquiry, Dacey is practically a card-carrying member of the atheist movement. Thus, when he accuses secularism of a soul-destroying relativism, he cannot be accused of harboring secret hopes for religious conversion. Dacey is right about the problem and wrong about the solution. In any event, this book offers a very different way out of secularism’s current morass than the path he is offering. We shall see which way secularism ultimately goes. For now, it is enough to note that even secularists hostile to religion are beginning to recognize that the objective values which religion used to offer to the culture are a necessary foundation for healthy human life. If we are not going to be religious in the future, we need to establish a new relationship to that religious tradition. Bruce Ledewitz June 2008
Acknowledgments My most immediate thanks go to Donald J. Guter, dean of the Duquesne University School of Law, who approved a sabbatical for me for fall 2007 to finish this book although I applied much too late to qualify for the program, and to Duquesne University Provost, Ralph Pearson, who went along with it. Their generosity in this instance is rather typical of the Duquesne University community, of which I have been a happy member since 1980. My colleagues at the law school have been extremely supportive of my ongoing work in religion and public life. They have shared not only their knowledge but also their contacts, and I thank them. I must single out two of my colleagues for special mention. Bruce Antkowiak has held my hand for every up and down of the publication process. Robert Taylor has simply been my teacher for the last twenty-five years. There is not a single major source in this work that Robert did not introduce me to. Naturally, Robert is not to blame for the use I have made of his teaching. The staff at the law school have gone out of their way to help me prepare this material, especially Kathy Koehler, without whom neither this book nor much of anything else in my academic life would get done. I also want to thank Frank Liu, the director of Duquesne’s Center for Legal Information, and his colleagues for their continuing help in research at the law school, as well as the staff of Gumberg Library at Duquesne University. The editors at Palgrave Macmillan have been very encouraging, especially Brigitte Shull, who, despite my various mishaps, never seemed to doubt that this book would be published. I have been fortunate in having two very able research assistants during the last two years, Jesse Leisawitz and Glen Downey, who continued to help with manuscript preparation even after they graduated from the law school. I will always be indebted to friends at my former synagogue, Dor Hadash, where I first developed my thinking in Judaism and then later grew away from the tradition. A special thanks to Anita Dufalla, artist extraordinary, for the cover. Finally, I wish to thank my family. My children have commented extensively and candidly on this manuscript and on the blog—http://www.hallowedsecularism.org—that accompanies it. They and their generation are this book’s intended audience,
xii
•
Acknowledgments
and they have tried to help me reach that audience. I cannot thank my wife, Patt, because that would be too much like trying to thank myself. Since this book is a product of our ongoing religious development, I cannot always tell where she stops and I begin.
Introduction
W
ouldn’t you like to live your life abundantly? You and your family? Why don’t you? You must be aware that living life abundantly is precisely what Jesus promised and what Christianity offers. Most Americans were raised in Christian families. So why do you not practice Christianity in a serious way? If you are not from a Christian family, the other religions, like Judaism and Islam, make the same promise of abundant life to their adherents. Why do you not practice these traditions? From what I can see, your refusal does not imply that we already live abundant lives. Our lives are often harried and empty and shallow when they are supposed to be calm and meaningful and deep. We are alone when we are meant to live surrounded by love. All of that is what Jesus meant when he promised abundant life. So why do you not live in a committed way in whatever religious tradition you come from? Of course, the phrase “live life abundantly” may never have occurred to you. It’s a religious phrase, and you are probably secular, as I am. You and I do not believe in God, and we do not believe in miracles. Every religion requires beliefs we find ridiculous. For these reasons the promise of an abundant life, whether made by Jesus or by the other religions, is unavailable to us. What are we left with? Often, we are left with rather flat, pointless lives. The purpose of this book is to describe and begin to create a new way of life called Hallowed Secularism. Instead of opposing religion, as secularism tends to do today, Hallowed Secularism opens us to these and other sources of meaning for human life. Secularism is a broader category than just something that relates to religion. Secular means “world.” A saeculum is the span of a human life, which is how it came to mean “world.” Gabriel Vahanian, perhaps the best known of the “God-is-dead” theologians, says that saeculum refers to a shared world of human experience. So the secularist may be thought of as one who insists that
2
•
Hallowed Secularism
this world is all there is to reality. There is no heaven, no afterlife of any kind, and no Messiah. This is not a sufficient definition of secularism. Abraham in the Bible did not experience heaven, afterlife, or a Messiah, but Abraham was no secularist. Abraham knew the God of the Bible. Yet one point of this book is that the secularist need not be an atheist. The secularist can also have a conception of God. So, in order to distinguish the secularist from Abraham, in addition to this worldliness we will add the absence of a traditional God—that is, the absence of an entity outside time and space who can affect the workings of the natural world. Now we have our secularist. There have been thinkers within the religious traditions who have been secular by this definition. Rabbi Mordecai Kaplan, the founder of Reconstructionist Judaism, seems to fit, for example. The Chicago minister and philosopher Edward Ames also fits. Secularism thus sounds potentially very close to religion. Nevertheless, if you fit this definition of secularism, you cannot participate wholeheartedly in the traditional Christian, Jewish, or Islamic traditions. I doubt you would fit easily in any other religion either. And the religious thinkers who thought along these lines also did not fit in easily. In our time and place, a person who thinks this way is distanced from religion. That is enough to make you a secularist. Some secularists go to church or to synagogue. Some of us may even raise our children in Christianity, Judaism, or another religion because we want our children to have something. But once our children grow up, we often stop practicing religion, except perhaps to use religious rituals to promote family connection. The problem is that we cannot give our whole hearts to the stories these religions tell. Without a whole heart, none of Our Religions, which is what the comparative religion people call them, deliver the abundant life they promise. Our Religions are not merely out of our reach. They are also often malign. If you’re gay, for example, you are condemned in the Bible. Often in the world, the more religious people are, the more violent they are. We see Muslims blowing up themselves and others, Hindus practicing an excluding nationalism, Orthodox Jews opposing peace with the Palestinians, and conservative Christians supporting the war in Iraq. Some of us have turned in other directions—away from religion—in our search for a life of meaning. “I don’t need religion,” we say. We turn to the arts, or politics, or service to others. These things are important, and they can be substitutes for religion for a while, but that does not last. Except for art, these other ways lack ecstasy and depth. Art, for its part, lacks a grounding direction for our lives. In the end, for most of us, only Our Religions teach the wisdom and connections to all of life that we need. Only religious lives sustain life’s fullness.
Introduction
•
3
Some people find the answer to meaning in nature. They worship, or purport to anyway, the sun or the earth and its spirits. Perhaps I have just not seen this done properly, but it does not seem to hold out real hope. Nature can be just as cold as the human heart. There is something behind nature that these people sense and seek, not nature itself. In response to these dead ends, some of us have begun to deny that abundant life is even possible. We have begun to doubt that there is more to life than paychecks, shopping, entertainment, and family and friends. Perhaps there is actually not that much to hope for in human life. But what if I told you that you could have abundant life without religious fantasy and without surrendering your intellect or your political principles? And that you could have this without New Age mumbo jumbo or obscure practices borrowed from indigenous peoples? What if I told you, in other words, that you could have abundant life just as Christianity promises without becoming a Christian? You could have what Our Religions promise without joining any of them. And what if I told you that you could have this not just for yourself and your family but also for your country? Jesus did not just promise abundant life for individuals. He promised peace and justice for the world. What if you could have that, too? Having all that without Our Religions is the project of Hallowed Secularism. I think you can live such a life without membership in any religion. But the how is the difficult part. The how is what this book is about. In the short run, this book describes a way of life as I see that way of life unfolding. But in the longer run, others will decide the future of Hallowed Secularism by living it or by rejecting it. You, the reader, will decide. The book proceeds in three parts. In the first part, I ask two questions: why has Hallowed Secularism become so necessary, and how is Hallowed Secularism possible? Hallowed Secularism is necessary because secularism has failed. Science and globalization have rendered the traditional images and messages of Our Religions unbelievable for many people. The number of these secularists is growing, especially among the young. Our Religions are themselves partly to blame for this because they have failed to answer the challenges of a new secular world, especially in regard to the place of women and homosexuals. Yet secularism, for its part, has failed to imagine and put into practice a genuinely fulfilling way of life. So a new kind of secularism is necessary. This new secularism will not be the same in different parts of the world. Each religious civilization—for example, the Christian civilization of Europe and the Americas or the Hindu civilization of India—will produce a secularism
4
•
Hallowed Secularism
with a different flavor. This book is primarily about the Judeo-Christian secularism of North America, but its lessons about secularism apply more broadly. As to how Hallowed Secularism is possible, modern theologians and other religious thinkers already have been at work describing the frameworks of the various religions in secular terms. This has especially been the case with Christianity. This secularizing effort might be said to go back to St. Augustine’s term, “the two cities,” for the City of God and the City of Man. The beginning of the modern Christian engagement with secularism is associated with Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who wrote in Letters and Papers from Prison, as he was held by the Nazis before his execution, that the next stage of human history might be “a complete absence of religion” and that it was “already more or less that case” that man had become “radically religionless.” Bonhoeffer pondered the theological meaning of this historic shift. So, in creating and living Hallowed Secularism, you and I will have teachers. The second part of the book describes what Hallowed Secularism might look like in practice. Chapter 5 sets forth its fundamental beliefs: truth, world, man, God, and the future. I hope to convince you that secularists are not cut off from meaningful connection with our religious heritage. The rest of Part II attempts to employ these concepts in the projected life of Hallowed Secularism. While Hallowed Secularism is not actually a new religion, insofar as it forms the basis for society it must still offer both social and personal ways to live. There must be insight from Hallowed Secularism into public life, including economics and politics, as well as personal life, such as prayer and ritual. Finally, the third part of the book raises the deeper meaning of this new phenomenon of Hallowed Secularism. What is the relationship between Hallowed Secularism and the other dominant orientations to reality, such as Our Religions, humanism, and materialism? A world of Hallowed Secularism is different from anything that has gone before in human history because humans have never been so secular. The ultimate question is, can a secularism of holiness contribute to the flourishing of the human spirit? Is it really possible for secularism to be “hallowed?” How can it be holy? That seems to be a contradiction in terms. After Auschwitz and Hiroshima, surely the world is profane in every sense. Surely man now knows himself too well for such a mirage. We seem to have only two choices: God—a transcendent being outside space and time—or man as the measure of all things. We cannot believe that such a God exists, and man on his own is a horror. What is needed is a source of power, order, and beauty outside humans themselves—in fact, outside the visible order altogether but not outside human experience. This is precisely what Our Religions give to those who are open to them. Can secularists have this without the traditional God?
Introduction
•
5
Yes. Even without Our Religions, human beings can encounter a mysterious otherness, both personally and historically—an otherness upon which we can build our lives and a civilization. This is well known at the personal level. Accounts of nontheistic spiritual experiences are common. Here is a beautiful example from Dr. Rachel Remen’s book, My Grandfather’s Blessings: A neighbor, a down-to-earth and practical person, shared . . . an experience with me. . . . She had been cleaning her house . . . when suddenly it was as if her life were passing rapidly in front of her and she became aware of something she had not recognized before, that there was a coherence and direction that ran through it like a thread. . . . Though she had never experienced this direction before, it was familiar to her. It was as if she had been following something unseen for many years and she had not known.
* * * As she stood in her kitchen . . . she became deeply certain that what was true of her personally was also true of life in general. Everything was unfolding according to a direction. It underlay all existence, binding it all together. For a heartbeat, it seemed to her that she could experience this directly. “A steady unseen force, like a wind,” she told me.
A religious believer might call this mysterious experience an encounter with God. But that is not how this woman experienced it. She experienced what any secularist could. I am not suggesting that Hallowed Secularism should be charismatic, seeking meaning primarily in personal and emotional encounters with the unseen. Hallowed Secularism can, however, acknowledge that human life has this aspect and that it is meaningful. Such an encounter might even be authoritative in one’s life; that is, such experiences might teach me how to live. Such experiences are not merely subjective. This sense of oneness with all reality that Remen describes is a common theme in nondogmatic thinkers as diverse as Eric Voegelin and John Dewey. In fact, such a sense of cosmic unity may underlie all Our Religions. Religious thinking of this kind has a great deal to teach us about reality. Hallowed Secularism must be open to such teaching. This openness to personal religious experience is not the same as a God who is a personality with a will, plans, and actions. Yet it is not atheism either. The sense of depth that comes from these experiences can be gained through more than just personal encounters. There is also public consciousness of transcendence. By transcendence, I mean the sense that there is something more to human life than is ordinarily apparent. Something deeper is at work.
6
•
Hallowed Secularism
Public consciousness of transcendence may come to us in great public events: Martin Luther King Jr.’s march on Washington, the funeral of John F. Kennedy, and the attacks of 9/11. This is the revelation of history. The public sense of depth also means an appreciation of the power of justice in history. Abraham Lincoln understood the Civil War as God’s judgment for the sin of slavery. Thomas Jefferson feared such a civil catastrophe out of the same concern for God’s judgment. I feel that way about global warming. Reality is structured in such a way that there are consequences for national injustice. Mistreat the poor and your society will end up in ruin. Worship money and you end up with callous violence. This is what the Hebrew prophets taught. Hallowed Secularism must be open to this message, too. So transcendence is not all sweetness. The Hebrew prophets remind us that just as the awareness of connection and belonging is both personal and social, so the reality of sin is both social—that is national—and personal. Christianity and Judaism both teach that human beings fail to live properly. We sin constantly. Hallowed Secularism has to deal with this reality of human life and not pretend, as much New Age religion does, that a sense of the divine is always welcome. The woman’s experience in Dr. Remen’s book, for example, was wonderful. Who would not want an experience like that? But what if her life passing before her had reminded her of the harm she had brought to the people she loved? Those experiences are also a part of the spiritual life of humanity and may be the most important part. The reality of sin shows the value of Our Religions in taming human pretension. Nevertheless, positive or negative, reality must be lived at this level to be meaningful. In order to recover from consumerism and the flatness of American life, the sense of depth must be present in public life as well as in personal encounters. This requires rejection of the scorn secularists now exhibit toward anything “religious.” We are dealing here not with superstition or with the supernatural but with a broader sense of the unexpected possibilities in human life. Secularists must be open to that. On the other hand, religion cannot be sovereign. The power and truth of science cannot be subjected to some religious test. Hallowed Secularism will insist that scientific discovery be accepted where science is appropriately relied upon. Once we clear out the brush of religious dogmas that conflict with the natural laws of the universe—resurrection, heaven, hell, Messiah, apocalypse, reincarnation, and a being called God—Hallowed Secularism falls out as what’s left. What’s left is neither materialism nor humanism. It’s beyond both, for there is reality to the unseen that is beyond human will. The number two cannot be seen, yet it is real. And love cannot be seen. The secularist can reject
Introduction
•
7
both traditional religion and its traditional alternatives, in the name of the unseen. Secularism has been down this road before: this road of assimilating religion. In the first part of the twentieth century, leading to the proclamation of the Humanist Manifesto of 1933, secularists, humanists, and liberal religious believers gave a great deal of thought to the meaning of religion in human life and to how our religious traditions might be incorporated into the new scientific age. With exceptions, these men and women were not hostile to religion. William James’s 1902 book, The Varieties of Religious Experience, and John Dewey’s Terry Lectures, which were published as A Common Faith in 1934, form appropriate bookends for this serious, thoughtful, and helpful effort. Unfortunately, the pressures of the Depression, World War II, and then the cold war ended this age. Now it is time to reacquaint ourselves with what these giants learned and to extend the knowledge they acquired. When I look, in contrast, at recent books on the same subject of secularism and religion, I am struck by their sneering tone and their partisan attacks. You can see just by the title of the most popular book in this group, Christopher Hitchens’s God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, that these people, as opposed to James or Dewey, have very little of enduring worth to teach us. Secularism has to get beyond its juvenile hostility toward religion and its illiberal attempts to banish religion from political life. Secularism must redevelop an appreciation of what Our Religions have to offer. Hallowed Secularism is an attempt to do just that. Let me give a final word about the title of this book, Hallowed Secularism. I took the term from a speech given by Sarah Blumenthal, a character in E. L. Doctorow’s 2000 novel, City of God. Sarah is a very liberal rabbi struggling with the Jewish tradition in a synagogue called the “Synagogue of Evolutionary Judaism.” At the end of the novel, Sarah gives an address, which is set forth in the book in full, to the “Conference of American Studies in Religion.” In her talk, Sarah asks the question that must be confronted in this new secular world: “Is it possible that the behavioral commandments of religion . . . can be maintained without reference to the authority of God?” Sarah is not just asking about ethics. She is also asking about depth. Without “the exclusionary, the sacramental, the ritualistic, and simply fantastic elements of religion . . . can a universalist ethics be maintained—in its numinousness?” For those unfamiliar with the term, the numinous is the elevated, the beyond, the transcendent. Sarah is asking whether secular life must be flat and unrewarding or, instead, can capture the sense of mystery in life. Sarah’s answer is yes. We can have a secular life that is both deep and good, and she refers to this life as a “hallowed secularism.” She says that in such a
8
•
Hallowed Secularism
secular life God can be recognized as “Something Evolving.” We human beings pursue a “teleology,” an ultimate purpose that we do not know but that “has given us only the one substantive indication of itself—that we, as human beings, live in moral consequence.” This book is an attempt to spell out what Sarah was getting at. Secularists should not be afraid of this sort of religious seeking. You and I are not threatened today by religion on the march, the violence of Islamic fundamentalism notwithstanding. No one is making us follow the teachings of some religion. We live in a democracy as religious or irreligious as it chooses to be. You and I are threatened by something quite different: by the gradual loss of meaning in a secular human culture. We cannot become religious again in the traditional way, but we can find the holiness we have been missing.
PART I
Why Hallowed Secularism Is Necessary and How It Is Possible
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 1
Secularists’ Indifference and Hostility Toward Religion
I
showed my daughter the introduction to this book. Upon reading the opening question, “Wouldn’t you like to live your life abundantly?” she said that her friends would not read any further. It sounded too religious. Her friends, she said, had no interest in religion. That is my impression as well in my dealings with young people. Many seem quite indifferent to religion and religious issues. My first task is to awaken interest in religion. Indifference to religion is something new in secularism. John Dewey, who could be considered one of the great American secularists, was very familiar with the teachings of Christianity and quite sympathetic to them. Breaking with Christianity, to the extent Dewey ever really did so, was difficult. Dewey was not indifferent to religion. No one would dispute that young people in America are more secular than their parents and grandparents. According to a March 2007 Pew Research Center report, 19 percent of those born after 1976, which is, roughly, thirty-years-old and under, describe themselves as “atheist, agnostic, or no religion.” This compares with only 5 percent of those born before 1946 and 11 percent of those born between 1946 and 1964. In another Pew Research Poll, among those sixty-five and older, 44 percent considered the Bible the “literal word of God” versus 29 percent among those eighteen to twenty-nine years old. Conversely, 13 percent of those sixty-five and older viewed the Bible as “not [the] word of God,” compared to the 24 percent of those eighteen- to twenty-nine-year-olds who felt that way. Nor is this just a matter of young people being more secular and growing more religious as they age. The 2007 Pew report concluded “the number of seculars within each generational group is about the same in 2007 as it was 10
12
•
Hallowed Secularism
or 20 years before. Thus it appears that people have not become less secular as they have aged.” These numbers show that America is still a very religious society and is going to continue to be so for a long time. That is why presidential candidates in 2008 are busy emphasizing their belief in God. America is a religious democracy for the foreseeable future. My point is not how secular we are at the moment, but rather that secularists are now sufficiently numerous that they can no longer be considered a fringe group. The importance of that change is that, for some young people, religion no longer sets a framework for meaning. For someone like Dewey, religion was the frame even if he rejected parts of the religious message. In contrast, there is now, for the first time, a substantial group of secular young people who never learned much about religion and do not feel they are lacking anything because of that. This group will continue to grow. This is the sort of person who hears the term “abundant life” and feels uncomfortable. Religion for such a person is not even a mystery. This shortchanges people more than they know. This ignorance of religion is described by a story in the Haggadah, the collection of stories, blessings, and prayers that Jews read in their homes on the evening of Passover. In the Haggadah, several accounts of the Exodus from Egypt are told. One of the ways this is done is through the four types of sons who may hear the Exodus story: the wise son, the hostile son, the simple son, and the son who is too young to know how to ask a question. I want to address some questions to the simple son—those indifferent to religion. These are today’s young secularists. Look around you. Why is there something rather than nothing? You may give an answer from astrophysics. You may say it’s the big bang. Everything we see, everything we know, and much that we cannot see and cannot know just sort of happened out of nothing one day. Does this not awaken in you a sense of awe? Does it not bring forth in you a sense of reverence for the mystery of existence? If it does, you are not so indifferent to religion after all. But, perhaps it does not. Perhaps you are dull to such feelings. Then, I will ask you about the love you feel for your wife or husband or child or parent. Do these feelings not awaken in you amazement in the presence of the power of love? Do you not wonder if there is not something greater that you might love? You may tell me these feelings of love have a biological purpose. I will then ask you whether you are not more than a biological purpose. You must be more, for there is no biological purpose in wondering whether you are more than a biological purpose. Perhaps you do not love anyone, and no one loves you. I will ask you then, how do you know how to live? If you tell me you seek pleasure, I will tell you
Secularists’ Indifference and Hostility Toward Religion
•
13
that the pleasure you are now seeking pales eventually, if it has not already. You are not made for that kind of pleasure. There is a greater pleasure awaiting you. But no one can experience it who does not love. We have all heard that we should devote ourselves to something larger. We have heard it, but does our culture really believe it? Do any of us really believe it? Colleges keep advertising their advantages in procuring good jobs for students. Colleges do not advertise much about something larger in human life. Well, whether people believe it or not, it is true that we cannot live well unless we devote ourselves to something larger than our own egos and possessions. But what is this “something larger?” Jesus answers that we are to live in radical love. That is his answer to everyone, not just to the “religious.” Jesus says this to the “lawyer” in the Gospel of Luke, in what is known as the parable of the good Samaritan (Revised Standard Version of the Bible, 1952). The lawyer asks how he is to “inherit eternal life.” Do not be put off by this phrase; the man does not necessarily mean, how do I go to heaven? He means exactly what we have been looking at, how to live a life of deepest meaning—the truest kind of life there is. Jesus answers by asking what the Torah, which is the Old Testament, teaches. The man answers, as any Jew would have, to love God and my neighbor. Jesus says that’s right. The lawyer then asks, “And who is my neighbor?” Why does he ask that? While “lawyer” is the usual translation, it is misleading to an American reader thinking of secular law. “Religious scholar” might convey a better sense of the text. So, in asking this question, the man is seeking to justify the way he lives. He thinks he already does enough good in the world to satisfy the requirements of his religion. Jesus then tells the story of the Samaritan. The Samaritans were an ethnically mixed group that many Jews of the time looked down on as not really Jews. The Samaritan came upon a Jew who had become a crime victim, and, unlike the religious leaders who had passed the man by, the Samaritan took him to a place of safety and refuge and paid the man’s bill. Who was neighbor to the victim? asks Jesus. Many commentators have noticed that Jesus did not directly answer the question the lawyer had asked him. The man had asked Jesus, who is my neighbor? In context that meant, whom must I love? Jesus answered that question only indirectly: even Samaritans are neighbors. You must even love Samaritans. The parable, thus, is one more step on the road to the universalization of Judaism.
14
•
Hallowed Secularism
But Jesus also answered a question the man did not ask. The unasked question was, how can I be a neighbor? In other words, what does it mean to love my neighbor? Jesus answered the right question because this lawyer was not someone who really loved his fellow man, not even his fellow Jews. Jesus was also answering our question: what does it mean to devote myself to something larger? It means to meet the world in love. Jesus’s love is a radical commitment. Look at what the Samaritan did for someone he did not even know. He bandaged the victim. He treated the wounds. He put the man on his donkey. He took the man to an inn and stayed with him overnight. The next day the Samaritan paid the innkeeper and told him to give the man what he needed, and the Samaritan would pay the rest when he returned. The Samaritan did all this not because he felt he had to and not because anyone would find out but because the Samaritan had “compassion.” The parable of the good Samaritan is not “religious.” The secularist is addressed, too. Loving God is not even part of the parable. Jesus does not tell the lawyer to go to synagogue or to pray or to engage in ritual or even to give charity to the poor. The way to live, Jesus is telling us, is to be like this Samaritan. Living in radical love is the way to live “beyond yourself.” Notice how much further Jesus tells us to go in love than we would go in what we call “ethics.” If you come upon an unconscious crime victim, must you interrupt your trip, care for him, take him to a hotel, stay with him, pay for his room, and then pay for whatever he spends after you leave? Of course not. You are indifferent to religion, but you cannot be indifferent to Jesus’s radical instruction. Jesus says that this is the way people are supposed to live—in radical love. Neither you nor I have the slightest intention of actually living this way, of course; nor do Christians live this way. But I’m not sure we dare to dispute Jesus’s demand that we live like the Samaritan. Jesus is making a claim on everyone, including secularists. You can disobey. We all disobey. But you cannot ignore him. It turns out that not only are you not indifferent to religion, you are not even indifferent to the gospel. Our failure to live the way Jesus instructs is sin. “Sin” is a religious term and, as secularists, we may think we can avoid it. Like religion, we say we are indifferent to such things. When I speak to secular groups, someone will inevitably say at this point, “I don’t need religion to live a good life.” I always agree. “No, of course not,” I say. But that is not the proper answer. I should respond, “You don’t live a good life. I would have no trouble lining up large numbers of people you have wronged, just as you could with me. And you probably have never in your life
Secularists’ Indifference and Hostility Toward Religion
•
15
treated anyone like the Samaritan did, unless it was a family member, and you had to. We live a bad life.” We do need religion, or at least we need to learn the lessons religion teaches. Lessons like the one offered by the good Samaritan. Jesus is way ahead of this religion/nonreligion distinction. Jesus’s description of how to live in this parable is not religious. It is just the way to live. Of course, it follows that the lawyer’s way to live, which is sin, is not religious either. Claiming to be indifferent to religion turns out not to be so easy. All these questions of how to live, which every person must answer, are both religious questions and secular questions. This sense of sin also relates religious teaching to a public, as opposed to a purely personal or private, context. Many secularists believe that religion should play no role in American public life. We do not want another president to tell us that “God told me to invade” a country. This rejection of a public role for religion is the public equivalent of personal indifference to religion. This criticism of public religion is fair enough. Politicians do use religion this way. However, if sin is not necessarily “religious” in the sense of relating purely to God but consists in failing to live in radical love, then all our national policies are sinful. It seems to me that this insight would be a welcome corrective to America’s tendency to regard itself as good and its enemies as evil. That needed sense of humility was a theme in Peter Beinart’s 2006 book, The Good Fight, which argued that liberalism during the Cold War was able to fight totalitarianism with humility and restraint, unlike the Bush administration’s assumption of American moral purity in fighting the war on terror. The source of humility in those American leaders, however, was not calculation but a realistic view of human sinfulness, including their own. The theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, whom Beinart greatly admires, warned specifically of the ambiguity of power. That ambiguity roots in human sinfulness, as Niebuhr knew but Beinart, as a secularist, cannot appreciate. This quick survey of the breadth of religion and its importance in our lives is meant to show no more than this: although you may know little about traditional religious doctrine and may legitimately have no interest in it, religion itself—its themes and thoughts—is simply too large and too much a part of human life for you to ignore. This does not mean you cease to be a secularist. You and I are firmly wedded to this world and no other. Instead, it might mean that the religious orientation of Hallowed Secularism has something important to offer to you. Let me turn now to the hostile son. The secularists who are angry at religion have definite ideas about it; they consider religion to be very important; they wish to combat it rather than leave it alone. These strong feelings stem
16
•
Hallowed Secularism
from several different sources: disdain, disagreement, fear, and an intellectual commitment to atheism. I will take these factors up in turn. The disdain for religion by secularists is something we have all heard. It is said that religious people are hypocrites. This objection may be focused on something like sex scandals in the Catholic Church or the willingness of followers of the Prince of Peace to support war. Or, it could be more personal—that for all the claims of sanctity, religious people are no better than anyone else. They may be worse. All of these criticisms of religion are true to some extent. But these criticisms do not have anything to do with our subject here, which is Hallowed Secularism. It is not any part of what religious people believe, or say they believe, that bothers the critics, but that religious people do not live up to their message. There would be nothing here to prevent borrowing by secularists from religion. In fact, with all this criticism of religion, secularists might like to show that they can live according to the commandment of love to a greater extent than most religious people do. It is not surprising that religious believers do not live up to the teachings of their religions. They never have. The teachings of Our Religions require something approaching saintliness, which most of us lack. Karl Barth, perhaps the leading Protestant theologian of the twentieth century, even had a name for this phenomenon of falling short. He called the church “the Church of Essau,” as opposed to the Church of Jacob, from the two brothers in the book of Genesis. His point was that the church, and we may add any religion, is not usually, and never totally, the Church of God. The church is usually the church of men and, therefore, corrupt. But Barth did not think this was a reason to abandon the church. Everything else was always and totally the work of Essau. From what vantage point does the critic dare to throw stones at religion? Religious believers fall short of the glory of God, but the secularist does not even try to live up to that glory. You and I will not let ourselves off the hook that easily. Disdain is no answer to the religious question. In Hallowed Secularism, we are going to appropriate what we consider the best of religion. We will try to do better with this gift than religious people have done. But I doubt we will. A second type of secular hostility against religion stems from disagreement with religious believers about certain issues. In America, it is probably the case that the more often a person goes to any house of worship, the more culturally conservative that person is likely to be. This often translates into opposition to practices like abortion, gay marriage, and the separation of church and state. So, people on the other side of these issues become generally hostile to “religion.”
Secularists’ Indifference and Hostility Toward Religion
•
17
This kind of opposition to religion is not a new phenomenon. Anticlericalism in the French Revolution, the Mexican Revolution, and the Spanish Civil War all stemmed, at least in part, from opposition to the conservative political role that the Catholic Church was perceived to have played in those countries. The presence in the last few years, on one side of the political spectrum, of solid religious support for the Republican Party solidified and accelerated the trend of some political liberals to oppose religion in a more general and even theological sense. This religious partisanship caused the political observer Kevin Phillips to point to the danger of “theocracy” and led to a whole industry of books to promote atheism. In terms of this issue opposition to religion, secularists should remember two things. First, religious believers are not monolithic on political issues. Second, religious believers have been, and are, powerful allies in terms of a constellation of other political issues, such as opposition to the harsh treatment of illegal aliens in America. Secularists probably are aware of these two political facts of life, but it is helpful to remind ourselves. Opposition to abortion, for example, has a powerful religious impetus. Yet, many religious liberals support a woman’s right to choose. The issue of gay rights is visibly splintering many religious denominations. A lot of liberal believers support gay rights. On other issues, such as support for workers’ rights and the rights of immigrants, religious support puts secular liberal commitment to shame. American bishops opposed President Clinton’s welfare reform at a time when secular liberals had more or less abandoned the poor. So, obviously, religion cannot properly be thought of as simply a conservative political front. Issues are not a reasonable ground for secularists to avoid thinking about religion. In addition, we are considering Hallowed Secularism, not conversion to one of Our Religions. We do not have to worry too much about the position of the Catholic Church concerning abortion, for example, because we are not becoming Catholics. Yet, there is a sense in which the secular person primarily committed to certain political issues should be suspicious of Hallowed Secularism. After all, this book and the movement I hope it stimulates are based on a fundamental, transcendent foundation to reality, which Our Religions have encountered and are trying to engage and which secularism should also encounter and try to engage. That transcendent foundation does make demands on us. Or, since it is not a person, I should say that encountering reality in this way changes us and that the change it promotes is in tension with many modern trends in Western society. On one hand, Hallowed Secularism is not going to
18
•
Hallowed Secularism
be comfortable with abortion or any utilitarian approach to human life. On the other hand, Hallowed Secularism should be a powerful support for gay rights, as an aspect of human liberation. Religious teachings do not translate directly into ordinary politics. God makes strange demands on people who are open to him. That is why the Roman Catholic bishops are all over the place politically. It is also why any ideologue, even a religious one, is going to resist genuine religion. In any event, I think it is fair to conclude that commitments on particular political issues are not an absolute barrier to the openness to the transcendent that Hallowed Secularism promotes. A third source of secular hostility to religion is fear of religion as irrational and violent. Christopher Hitchens is convinced that religion is a dangerous force in the world. Who can argue with him? There are no secular suicide bombers. Hitchens does not think that this sort of violent behavior is the influence of just one bad religion—Islam. Hitchens believes that all religions are like this, that religion is inherently violent, irrational, and intolerant. He includes in his critique religious figures you might think are not like that: the Dalai Lama, St. Francis, and Gandhi. When secularists think of religion in this way, they are really criticizing any total belief system. If there were any belief you would be willing to die for or kill for, it would be equally “religious” for someone like Hitchens. This is why he believes that the murderous regimes of Hitler, Stalin, and Mao were not instances of secular violence. Those regimes were not really secular to Hitchens. Hitchens is criticizing emotional commitment, not religion. Dewey also feared simple emotionalism and did not see it as a positive force. He wrote a correction of Matthew Arnold, who had once described religion as morality “touched with emotion.” Dewey responded, in A Common Faith, that “the religious is ‘morality touched by emotion’ only when the ends of moral conviction [are] so inclusive that they unify the self.” Dewey saw what Hitchens and other critics of religion tend to forget— that the power of positive emotion is the engine of human life. Certainly, the power of emotion is twisted when a suicide bomber attacks innocent people. That is why Dewey modified the Arnold quote to specify what kind of emotion ought to be encouraged. Yet, there cannot be real change in the world or in one’s own life without engaging the emotions. Hitchens presumably believes that the world would be better if we all lived in his cool, ironic post-modernism. It is true that if no one cared deeply about anything, no one would kill anyone. But eliminating religion would not accomplish this. America is not killing people in Iraq because of American
Secularists’ Indifference and Hostility Toward Religion
•
19
religion. We may have invaded Iraq for good reasons—such as the promotion of democracy—or bad—to attain cheap oil—but we certainly did not invade to impose Christianity. Nor did we invade because Iraq threatened us for its own religious reasons, though that claim was made at the time. In addition, if there were no passionate, emotional commitments, not only would violence cease, but all attempts to improve the world would cease as well. Hitchens is thus worshipping the status quo. Religion is not necessarily irrational or antirational. Not all religious believers deny the accomplishments of science, for example. Pope Benedict considers Christianity to be the very embodiment of reason. The basic point the pope was making in his famous 2006 lecture at the University of Regensburg, when his comment about Islam grabbed everyone’s attention, was not that reason is bad but that reason should not be limited to “the empirically falsifiable.” Any sort of deeply felt life is going to be criticized as mindless, but to proclaim that there is more to human life than meets the eye is not mindless. It is the claim that makes life possible. Finally, opposition to religion can be grounded in an intellectual commitment to atheism. A serious source of hostility to religion can be premised on modern science, for example. I will deal more fully with this subject in the next chapter. Even if science undermines some religious claims, that is not a sufficient reason for the secularist to oppose all religion. We do not know yet what kind of religion, if any, is fitting and proper in the new scientific and post-dogmatic age. Hallowed Secularism is an experiment. It should go forward and be greeted with an open mind. Our Religions contain the way of life humanity needs to survive and prosper in the dangerous future that we face. The contribution that they make is not just in choices of policy. Rather, they connect us to the depth of human life that makes all commitment possible. What the young always seek is life in the fullness of its possibility. Only Our Religions hold open that path. Granted, we are not going to re-embrace them, strictly speaking, but we had better be completely open to them.
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 2
The Roots of Secularism
A
massive shift is occurring at the beginning of the twenty-first century in which millions of people are moving away from the religious traditions of their cultures and into the technological/commercial vortex of secularization, the process by which secularism is growing. By and large, this change is not good for people. It is true that many people are thereby liberated from barbaric traditional practices and gross superstition in their native cultures, and secularization brings with it medical marvels and sometimes economic prosperity. But this does not always happen, and sometimes it is at a great cost. Lives that were centered are now adrift. The cost of secularization does not matter, however. The trend is probably permanent. In fact, secularization seems to be picking up speed. Secularization did not begin in the twentieth century, and it will not end in the twenty-first century. I foresee its victory in the sense that secularism will no longer seem to be significant—it will just be the way things are—sometime after the year 2100. What makes the process of secularization inevitable is that it works at the level of what is believable—what Charles Taylor calls the conditions of belief. According to the political philosopher Eric Voegelin, in his volume, In Search of Order, epiphanies—revelations of the truth of order, such as those that happened with Jesus and the Buddha—have occurred throughout history and will continue to occur. Each revelation succeeds to the extent that its new symbols express the “common sense” of people in a particular place and time with the “authority commonly present in everybody’s consciousness.” Religious images and stories today seem strange, whereas secularism expresses our common sense of how things are. It is not so much that we deny religious claims of miracles, for example, as that they do not seem possible and therefore do not really challenge us at all. This is what happened to me. I began to sense that Our Religions were unreal. At one time I was a liberal Jewish believer. Then, at a certain point, it
22
•
Hallowed Secularism
took too much effort to listen to words that could not be true, and the worst part of this process—the part most revealing of how cut off you are from your religious tradition—is that you do not even feel you have lost anything. I can no longer believe, at least not in the old way. There are many others like me. Our Religions do not disappear in this process of secularization. In fact, they remain robust, first in opposition to secularism and then later in dialogue with it. Many people who come from religious families will probably remain religious believers in every generation, but as the number of religious families declines, the total number of believers will also fall. The deterioration of religious civilization will take a long time. Even after the triumph of secularism is complete, Judaism, Christianity, and all Our Religions will still be present and viable to many. However, they will be secondary to the secular world, which will be normative. This event—the displacement of Our Religions—although it will take place gradually, will signal a radically new era. There has never been a time in human history in which religion has not been the dominant worldview. Today, religion is still primary. The struggle against secularism is still ongoing. When that struggle ends, the world will look quite different. This chapter lists some of the forces contributing to secularism. I believe these forces will triumph over religion. However, as the next chapter shows, these forces displace religion, but they do not replace it because they do not lead us to abundant life. For that, we need to achieve Hallowed Secularism.
Science Science undermines religion in a number of ways. First, science shows that revelation, the most important source of our knowledge of God, is not wholly and uniquely reliable. Then, science shows us a universe in which God does not seem possible and certainly is not necessary. Finally, science shows us processes that do not bear the hand of a careful creator. Given all this, it is not surprising that religion begins to pale. Science displaces any supernatural account of the world. Why is the success of science in explaining the world a threat to Our Religions? Why cannot religion be in charge of morality and science be in charge of material life? Even many atheists admit that moral values can be real and enduring. In a Newsweek debate about the reality of God, Sam Harris, representing the atheist side, said, “I’m not at all a moral relativist . . . I think there is an absolute right and wrong.” So why not divide the spheres of life with material life on the science side, morality on the religious side, and the field of history split between them? This sort of division is what liberals in America have been suggesting for years—that religion is a private matter and
The Roots of Secularism
•
23
that it should have no role to play in public life. The problem is that limiting religion to private life is not the way the Bible sees things. God is Lord of morality, history, and nature. This is why God begins as creator in Genesis 1:1. God is Lord of history in Exodus, the book in which the slaves are freed from Egypt, and God is Lord of morality in the Prophets, for example, in Amos’s condemnation of the rich merchants: “Hear this, O you who swallow up the needy, so as to destroy the poor of the land.” This is a very crude division—actually, God is Lord of all three aspects of reality everywhere in the Bible. The God of the Bible is in charge of everything. Furthermore, this God is not remote. He did not just start things at the big bang, set up evolution on autopilot, and then watch everything unfold scientifically. In Christian dogma, God sends his Son to bring salvation to all human beings. In the Jewish view, God enters into a covenant with Abraham so that the Jewish people will bring a blessing to the world. These are plans by an all-powerful and loving being. There is no room for an area of life in which science rather than God holds sway. There have been suggestions that other religions might be less vulnerable to the claims of science than are the biblical religions. The Dalai Lama, for example, is more open to the claims of science than are most representatives of the “religions of the Book”: Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, which are sometimes so named because of their fidelity to holy texts. In his book The Universe in a Single Atom, the Dalai Lama is careful to concede the claims of science, but this admission turns out to have its limits. This is how George Johnson put it in a review of the Dalai Lama’s book: But when it comes to questions about life and its origins, this would-be man of science begins to waver. Though he professes to accept evolutionary theory, he recoils at one of its most basic tenets: that the mutations that provide the raw material for natural selection occur at random. Look deeply enough, he suggests, and the randomness will turn out to be complexity in disguise—“hidden causality,” the Buddha’s smile. There you have it, Eastern religion’s version of intelligent design. He also opposes physical explanations for consciousness, invoking instead the existence of some kind of irreducible mind stuff, an idea rejected long ago by mainstream science.
So it is fair to say that science is a challenge to all of Our Religions to a greater or lesser extent. How exactly does science contradict the Bible? The story of the rise of Western science can be told in a number of ways. In one sense, science is important simply because its discoveries enable us to know how the universe works and thus enable humans to do extraordinary things, like fly to the
24
•
Hallowed Secularism
moon. For this latter accomplishment, we can thank Sir Isaac Newton, who solved the problem of planetary motion in 1687, laying down the three laws of motion that would frame a view of the physical universe lasting until the twentieth century. A second great scientific achievement was the establishment in geology of the ancient age of the earth, currently estimated to be around 4.5 billion years but understood even by the mid-nineteenth century to be at least in the millions of years, along with the related insight that the earth is not static but in perpetual change. These discoveries grew more gradually than did those of Newton, but by the early twentieth century, especially with the perfection of radiometric dating, there is no longer scientific controversy about the geologic outline. The third important scientific achievement, from the perspective of religion, was Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection, which he first announced in 1859 in his book On the Origin of Species. Darwin applied his theory to human evolution in 1871 in The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. These three scientific discoveries contradict a plain reading of the Bible. The Book of Genesis shows God forming the heavenly bodies and setting them in their courses, but Newton explained that gravity, not God, keeps the universe in its motion (though Newton did not put it that way). Genesis shows the earth created by God in its current form at the same time everything else was created, but geology explains that the earth is older than life itself—far older than Genesis suggests—and that the earth continually changes its form. Finally, Genesis shows all life created at the same time, but evolution traces life back to a common ancestor from whom all varieties of life are descended. Therefore, the Bible is not literally true. That by itself need not have been a radical challenge to the religions of the Book. Karl Barth, a religiously orthodox thinker, explains that the Word of God is not based on “a specific cosmology,” even though the Bible may express itself through a particular cosmology. Barth meant by this that scientific accounts of the workings of the natural order are not inconsistent with the meaning of the Bible. To put this simply, the point of the Bible is that God created everything, not how God did so. But that understanding does not elimintate the problem of the scientific challenge to the literal truth of the Bible for two reasons. First, despite Barth, Our Religions have had a tough time swallowing these scientific accounts, especially evolutionary theory. Certain Protestant groups reject evolution altogether. Some Muslims do as well. For example, on the “Understanding
The Roots of Secularism
•
25
Islam” Web site, sponsored by the Al-Mawrid Institute of Islamic Sciences in Pakistan, I found the following exchange: What is Islam’s view on evolution? In your question, if “evolution” implies that man is actually an evolved form of a certain other creature, then Islam does not affirm such a standpoint. According to the Qur’an, Adam (pbuh)—the first man—was a direct creation of God, as a man. The Qur’an does not support that Adam evolved from another species.
A traditional understanding of Islam would seem to be skeptical of evolutionary theory. My impression is that most Orthodox Jews accept the scientific conclusions described above, as does the Catholic Church, though perhaps with reluctance in both cases. Law professor Noah Feldman, writing in the New York Times about his experiences in an Orthodox Yeshiva when he was growing up, told of a lecture on creation by the head of the Yeshiva. The rabbi said that he accepted the theory of evolution but had trouble believing that man was descended from monkeys. In terms of the Catholic Church, the statement by Pope John Paul II acknowledging that evolution is “more than a hypothesis,” for example, betrayed the discomfort the Church experienced around the topic of evolution. The church’s position on evolution gradually became more supportive. By 2007, Pope Benedict called the creation-evolution debate “an absurdity” and evolution “a reality that we must see”—one that does not exclude a role for God. As shown above, even the Dalai Lama is not entirely comfortable with the whole scientific account. For those of us outside Our Religions, who accept scientific explanations as simply true, these sorts of rejections, or even qualms, about science undermine the acceptability of Our Religions and contribute to secularism’s appeal. It is not so much that science and religious dogma conflict, which many people are unable actually to judge, as that religious authorities doubt the reliability of science that many of us take for granted. The second way science contradicts the scriptures is that science claims to have more authority than religion. Galileo was forced by the church to recant not just because of the substance of his scientific conclusions but also because he regarded neither the revealed Word of God in the Bible nor the traditions of the Church to be appropriate sources of authority for conclusions in scientific investigations. In other words, Galileo thought that the wisdom of Our Religions must be judged against scientific reasoning and empiricism rather than the other way around. At least in the fields in which it is competent to judge, science is the umpire rather than religion.
26
•
Hallowed Secularism
Galileo’s conclusion about the authority of science is obvious to a secular mind, but it must be intolerable to many believers. If you are, for example, a Muslim who believes that the angel Gabriel dictated the Qur’an to the Prophet Muhammad and that, therefore, the Qur’an is the very Word of God, what sense can it make to assert that mere human investigation not only rivals its authority but also surpasses it? So, again, science undermines at least a certain kind of religious belief. There are Christians and Jews who concede that the Bible is not the literal Word of God but that it is the work of inspired human authors. They accept scientific accounts of reality. They may even consider the Genesis account of the creation of the world to be a kind of poetry. The problem with this religious response is that it can be seen as solving the scientific threat by surrendering to it. When does poetry stop and something else begin in scripture? Maybe the giving of the Torah at Sinai, the Virgin Birth, or the Resurrection are poetry. Maybe every miracle is somehow consistent with science, and when reading this poetry every religious service should add an asterisk. At some point, what is left of religious claims? Aside from contradicting biblical accounts, science undermines religion by showing a universe that appears to operate on its own. There is the absence of supernatural causation. Science shows how things happen. We do not need God to be present for the sun to come up. There is no reason to imagine anyone behind the actions of the natural world. Scientific ordering is not literally an argument against the existence of God. God might exist without running things. God might have begun all this in the big bang and might have designed all these processes to run on their own. But the kind of God who could intervene in the natural world in violation of scientific laws becomes difficult to accept. The God of the Bible is that kind of God. In addition, there is a secular effect from observing natural processes working without God, even if God exists. This secular effect renders God irrelevant. That irrelevance leads easily to indifference. That indifference is secularism. For many people, this indifference to God does lead finally to the denial of God’s existence, but that is not its immediate or most important effect. In fact, for some people, God is no longer sufficiently real or present to even bother denying. Finally, science shows us a universe that operates in the sort of unwieldy fashion that argues against a directing intelligence. Not only does the universe operate on its own, but it does so in an inefficient and even inelegant way. The universe is more complex than it ought to be if a certain kind of God were in charge of it.
The Roots of Secularism
•
27
Here is an example from astronomy of what I mean. An astronomer who was also a Catholic priest came to Duquesne University a few years ago to talk about the relationship between science and religion. He said essentially the following: I do not know why God created life out of carbon rather than out of something else. But once life is based on carbon, there must be a sufficient cycle of star deaths to create the element carbon. That necessitates a certain age for life. Those statements do not imply a conflict between science and religion, but if the point of God’s plan is ultimately to create man, why should an allpowerful being bother with star cycles or evolution? Why not create humans in a straight line, as Genesis says God did? The processes of reality do not necessarily mean that there is no God. To jump ahead into the content of Hallowed Secularism, God may be “in” the processes of the universe or may even be “the structure in things,” as the theologian Richard Niebuhr once wrote. Or God could be the meaning of things or could represent what we mean when we say that events have meaning. The point here is that science does seem to undermine a certain way of looking at God. Thus science is one of the sources of secularism. Another such source is globalization.
Globalization There are two related meanings of globalization: economic and cultural. Both aspects contribute to secularization but in different ways. Probably the most commonly held meaning of globalization is the economic one. Since the fall of communism in the 1980s, a worldwide capitalist economy has been growing. In this unified world, capital is largely free to move. Labor is less free to move, but because production moves, jobs can go to workers rather than workers having to move to seek out jobs. Americans call this process outsourcing, and it is an enormous force in the world economy. The currency of this one-world capitalism is consumption. The economic well being of everyone depends on consumers everywhere continually buying an increasing mass of products, and these products are becoming the same all over the world. Globalization is not yet complete by any means. It is just an important trend. We can foresee, however, the eventual establishment of a worldwide, genuinely interconnected economy. There have been winners and losers in globalization. Automobile workers in America have not prospered. On the other hand, the growth of wealth in China, India, and certain other places has been astonishing.
28
•
Hallowed Secularism
The ability to move economic operations to other places in the world has increased the pressure on workers everywhere to be more productive. In a sense, workers are now competing against themselves everywhere in the world to keep prices low for consumers. This pressure has also been increased by technological innovations that spur productivity by homogenizing even white-collar work, thus contributing to the ability of corporations to move operations around the world. These technologies also tend to render certain types of organizations—for example, record companies and newspapers—as antiquated as the old guilds. People are beginning to obtain information and entertainment in new ways, and it is not yet clear what kinds of delivery systems will be profitable. These economic processes have both increased wealth around the world and increased disparities of wealth. Owners of capital, including intellectual capital, are rewarded highly in the globalized economy. Skilled workers are rewarded less than owners of capital, and unskilled laborers are rewarded even less. The other meaning of globalization is cultural. Globalization also refers to the interpenetration of the cultures of the world. Through all sorts of exchanges, not just economic, all the peoples of the world are in closer contact than ever before. Part of the reason for this is the Internet, which allows for continuing contact between people in different places. There is some overlap between these two types of globalization—economic integration and cultural exchange. After all, one way in which cultural contact happens is the spread of what is referred to as Western mass culture, and certainly one way that culture spreads is by the purchasing of products. How does economic globalization lead to secularization? There are two aspects to this. First, there is the content—the ideology—of this globalized culture. It is basically a consuming and producing culture. Therefore, what people learn from it is materialism. Economic globalization is not in any sense a spiritual awakening. Second, economic globalization loosens cultural ties. The Indian computer worker who spends time in Seattle, away from home and family, may no longer see the need for worship. The associate who is sent by a law firm to Tokyo for an extended period may not bother with church. These sorts of physical movements can weaken religious commitments. Here is an example from the cultural rather than the religious sphere that illustrates this power of economic globalization. For years, Spain has practiced siesta, a roughly three-hour break in the middle of the workday. Siesta moved the end of the workday and the evening meal to later in the day than in most other countries.
The Roots of Secularism
•
29
Siesta was apparently not an ancient custom, but it was well adapted to Spain’s Mediterranean climate and, in my own experience, was followed pretty rigorously in southern Spain and less so in northern Spain. Anyone who has spent any time in Spain will testify that siesta gave Spanish life a different feel from that of the rest of Europe. Then, in January 2006, the Spanish government abolished siesta for federal agencies and conducted a campaign to try to convince private enterprise to follow suit. This was done in acknowledged response to the rhythm of economic life in Europe, specifically so that Spanish business schedules and those of the rest of the EU would be similar. This was felt to be more efficient and thus economically beneficial. It was also hoped that abolishing siesta would increase productivity. I do not mean to suggest that this change was a bad thing. Apparently, many young parents felt that the shorter workday was a more family-friendly policy, so the change may have been beneficial for more than economic reasons. However, the abolition of siesta was not intended to help families. It was intended to make money. That also is not necessarily a bad thing. This change in Spain is reminiscent of the gradual erosion of the Sunday closing laws in the United States during the twentieth century—also in response to economic pressures—which accelerated the secularization of American culture. Both these changes demonstrate that money can be a stronger force than either culture or religion. You will never see a serious American candidate for president advocate closing the malls on Sunday, even though doing so would probably revitalize Christian religious practice in the United States more than any other single act. The secularizing effect of the other form of globalization—cultural contact—is quite different from crude economic pressure. Religious skepticism can be born from anthropological relativism. Historically, most human beings knew mostly their own kind and certainly did not know that much about the traditions of other and different kinds of people. When we learn that all cultures have their religious traditions, the effect can be dramatic. Globalization disrupts our religious certitudes by bringing us into contact with different cultural and religious traditions. Philip Kitcher in Living with Darwin describes what often happens next: “As understanding of the diversity of the world’s religions increases, it’s hard for believers to avoid viewing themselves as participants in one line of religious teaching among many. You profess your faith on the authority of the tradition in which you stand, but you also have to recognize that others, people who believe very different, in compatible things, would defend their beliefs in the same fashion. By what right can you maintain that your tradition is the right one, that its deliverances are privileged?”
30
•
Hallowed Secularism
This problem also beset Pem, an Episcopal Priest, in City of God, when he asks in a sermon, “But how do we distinguish our truth from another’s falsity . . . ?” The more we know of other religions, the harder it is to believe that the one we grew up in happens to be the ultimately right one. But the matter is even worse than that, because not only do we now know that there are sincere believers in other and different religions but we also know that our own tradition, especially if it is Christian, could at various points have gone in different doctrinal directions. The Gospel of Thomas, for example, could have been admitted into the canon. It is clear that the entire Old Testament was put together out of different and identifiable sources. In other words, Our Religions are man-made. The response from many people to this knowledge is that all religions are basically the same. That similarity may come down to something very innocuous, like “be a good person.” Thus begins a dull secularism that is out of touch with any deeper possibilities of human life. No religious tradition nor, for that matter, much truth of any fundamental kind can be embraced out of such thinking. The sorts of generalizations I am making here must be approached with care. Is secularization truly growing? Despite some obvious indications to the contrary, I think the answer is yes. Sometimes opposition to a trend like secularization, which is what we are seeing in both the Islamic world and in America, is evidence that the trend is strong, not that it is weak. For example, in American politics, the 2008 presidential election may well be the most “religious” in history as Democratic Party candidates try to reach across the God gap that has favored the Republican Party among religious voters in recent years. This does not change the fact that the younger you are in America, the less likely you are to go to church or synagogue, and that trend seems to reflect a generational change rather than a continuing change-of-life scenario. Also, secularization can sometimes be masked and can be much more present than it seems. For example, President George Bush’s policies in Iraq would not normally be described as secular in the sense of being antireligious. But after the invasion of Iraq, the intention of the Bush administration was to create a secular Iraqi constitution. In fact, as late as the December 2005 Iraqi elections, the media reported the electoral success of religious parties as a blow to the hopes of the United States for a secular Iraq. Despite its support from the Christian community in America, Bush administration policies could be quite secular. The Bush administration sought to privatize Islam in Iraq. I admit that the secularization that is going on in the rest of the Islamic world is hard to specify. Islam in many places—for example, in India and
The Roots of Secularism
•
31
Indonesia—was for many years much more relaxed in its practices than it is today. There is a hardening of religious attitudes and practices going on in the Islamic world, and because of this, you do not see obvious signs of secularization—for example, increasing consumption of alcohol. If you looked elsewhere, however—for example, at the economic integration that requires lending at interest, in violation of some interpretations of Islamic law, or the teaching of secular subjects in religious schools, or even the growth of the Islamic bond market (sukuk bonds)—I think you would find signs of secularization, even in Islam, and if you do not see it now, you will soon. What we have seen so far in this chapter is that science and globalization are leading us to a secularized world. Next, we will see that Our Religions themselves play a third role in the growth of today’s secularism.
Our Religions Our religions are failing the test of modernity. A few years ago, Father Richard John Neuhaus, the editor of the religiously conservative magazine First Things and the author of the very influential book The Naked Public Square, gave a speech about his own history. In the speech, Neuhaus said that he had originally been a liberal. The issue that moved him out of the liberal camp was abortion. What struck me was how Neuhaus put it. He said he regarded abortion as a test of whether liberalism would be true to its historic mission of expanding the boundary of the human family. Liberalism, after all, had challenged the racial caste system in America; fought for the rights of women, native peoples, and other excluded groups; and supported unions. Neuhaus argued in liberal circles that unborn life was the next frontier of human rights. When he could not make even a dent in the unwavering support of the right to choose, he abandoned liberalism. This notion of the test case is relevant to the way Our Religions contribute to secularization. Our Religions have failed and are failing two great tests in our day: the role of women and the rights of homosexuals. In only a small fraction of Our Religions are women and gays treated as genuinely equal to heterosexual men. In liberal religious pockets, women have achieved almost full equality in the ministry and administrative leadership. This is true in the Episcopal Church, for example, but even there, there is tension over the role of women within the greater Anglican community. The more telling example is that women cannot be priests in the Roman Catholic Church. In terms of the rights of gays, an even smaller number of liberal religious groups perform gay marriages and truly accept homosexuality.
32
•
Hallowed Secularism
Of course, it is not for me or any nonbeliever to tell a religious institution whether women ought to serve as priests or whether gay marriage should be recognized, but the right of Our Religions to believe what they believe is not what’s at issue. For many people, including me, it is obvious that women and men are equal in any sense relevant to religion. To anyone like that, excluding women or limiting their role is just prejudice—no different from a rule excluding blacks from leadership positions. It is just impossible to take Our Religions seriously when the role of women is even controversial. What is even worse is that, from the point of view of the religions of the Book, Moses, Jesus, and Muhammad must be regarded as rather advanced— even revolutionary for their time—in their views of women. For their followers to be less radical in attitude is demoralizing. The prejudice against homosexuals is even greater. Many religious people regard homosexuality as objectively unnatural, but we now know that homosexuality is rather common in nature and has always been present in human society. Jesus never condemned homosexuality. The matter never came up. Homosexuality among men is condemned in the Old Testament, but why should the Book of Leviticus be invoked against homosexuality when it is not invoked against eating ham and shrimp, which of course were also condemned in the Old Testament? Christians ought to know better than anyone that when Peter saw in a trance in the Book of Acts that nonkosher food could be eaten, all the old laws were swept away. Immediately following this divine message, Peter was called to the home of the Roman centurion Cornelius. Though it had been unlawful for Jews to meet with gentiles, Peter is not to call another man unkosher. It is bizarre that this is not understood today to apply to persons whose only crime is that they love one another. The prejudice against homosexuality in Our Religions has had the tragic effect of turning many gay people against religion itself. Obviously this is not the intention of any religious leader, regardless of his or her opinion about gays. Nevertheless, people are responsible for the consequences of their actions. It seems to me that the contribution of these failures of religion to the growing secularization of our time, especially among the young, who do not share these prejudices to the same extent as their elders, is a judgment against Our Religions. There are other failures by Our Religions, of course. There are justifications for an atheist like Christopher Hitchens to write a book attributing the problems of the world to Our Religions. Young people look at these failures, and many turn away from religion. Our Religions also contribute to secularism by losing the heart of their own message and becoming a part of the problem, even if they are not the
The Roots of Secularism
•
33
most significant part. Bill McKibben makes this point in his book Deep Economy. McKibben points out that most Christians in America believe that the saying “God helps those who help themselves” can be found in the Bible. Actually, the phrase originated with Ben Franklin, and it expresses an individualism that is at odds with the Bible in general and with Jesus’s message in particular. This is just one example of how tame Christianity and Judaism have become in the face of the current capitalist organization of the world. Our Religions are just important enough to be a source of conflict among people, but they have not been radical enough to be the source of transformation they were meant to be and have been in the past. Part of the reason that Our Religions have not convinced the young that religion embodies the future is that they have been either asleep or defensive in the face of a vigorous atheism. Religion does not have to be ridiculous, but it often is because even its own new thinking does not enter the houses of worship. Theologians have dealt with the issue of miracles from the perspective of modern man, for example, but you will not hear their message in most churches or synagogues. Even the bold clergy who reinterpret for their flocks tend to do so in postmodern irony, without the passionate commitment that originally gave our holy texts life. It is not helpful to hear the words “whatever you think that means” after invoking God. We do not have a lot of Sarah Blumenthals in our pulpits. One consistent exception to these criticisms is liberal, politicized religion, like that of certain Unitarian congregations. Here you can find gay ministers and consistently caring congregants. Maybe this will be a model in the future, but religions of this sort tends to be partisan, even predictable. Religion really is more than politics, which is why the genuine politics of religion can be so shockingly original. Suddenly, Buddhist monks are demonstrating against a military government. Suddenly, Polish workers are forming a Catholic labor union supported by a Polish pope. In contrast, politicized religion that supports some political party’s usual goals to me is not hallowed. Therefore, although I often agree with the political goals of politicized religion, I do not trust it, and I cannot give my life to it. A final source of secularization promoted by Our Religions is the problem of the embarrassing passages in the Bible, especially in the Old Testament. Some of these passages promote genocide. In the liberal religious communities I know, such passages are dismissed as primitive, thus demeaning the Bible and ultimately undermining biblical religion. Worse, in conservative religious circles, these passages are sometimes embraced and have led to shocking violence.
34
•
Hallowed Secularism
One of these passages is in the Book of Kings, in which the prophet Elijah brings down fire from heaven, discrediting the 450 rival prophets of Ba’al, and then has them killed. Following this episode, Elijah wanders to Horeb, the mountain of God, and hears God in a still, small voice. A passage like this makes me want to burn my Bible. Thus I was amazed to read Pope Benedict’s interpretation of this passage in his book Many Religions—One Covenant. Pope Benedict acknowledges that Elijah “calls to heaven and is heard.” The fire does actually come down, but the pope says that Elijah here is no better than Prometheus or modern man in his technological accomplishments because Elijah is relying on himself and manipulating the world. This kind of human effort is doomed to failure. The text shows that this effort does fail in the case of Elijah. As the pope put it, “Elijah has to realize that this is not the way in which God triumphs; he realizes that faith cannot be established by such signs, by force.” This is precisely what the still, small voice teaches Elijah on Mount Horeb. Pope Benedict’s interpretation reminds us why religion must be rehabilitated and why the failures of Our Religions, which today lead many to secularism, are the most serious failures of all. Humanity can survive mechanistic science. It can survive brutal globalization. But humanity cannot survive a loss of faith. We secularists need to come into a better and more hopeful relationship with Our Religions. We need to continue to hear insights such as this one from the pope. This chapter, highlighting the roots of secularization, begs the question of what kind of secularism is developing. In the next chapter, we see that secularism has fundamental problems of its own.
CHAPTER 3
The Failure of Secularism
T
hough secularism is growing, we are beginning to see disenchantment with it. In 2006, Hent de Vries and Lawrence Sullivan published Political Theologies: Public Religions in a Post-Secular World. In the book, several scholars tried to come to terms with a new political and religious reality—that the Enlightenment effort to relegate religion to the private sphere seems to have ground to a halt. The same recognition constituted the shared starting point for then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger and the German political philosopher Jürgen Habermas in their 2004 debate concerning the moral foundations of the liberal state. My own book American Religious Democracy is also part of this growing recognition of a need for religion in public life. This greater openness to religion is not a reinvigoration of institutional religion, nor a lessening of secularization. Rather, something has happened within secularism itself. Our public life is not healthy. Perhaps in response, a number of thinkers are now questioning a separation of religion and public life that had been taken for granted. Further, it is not just public life in which religion is receiving new attention. Secularism has not generated human satisfaction in our private lives either. This chapter outlines the failure of secularism. My purpose is to suggest why Hallowed Secularism, which establishes a closer relationship between secularism and religion, is necessary. Necessary here means that secularism must be brought to the sort of completion that will allow it to grow and develop into a sustainable and satisfying civilization. There is a problem, though, in addressing the faults of secularism. Institutionally, there is no such thing as secularism. There is no movement called secularism, and there are no official spokespeople. There are no commonly accepted secularist texts. There are just people for whom organized religion is no longer meaningful but who have not found other sources of meaning for their lives.
36
•
Hallowed Secularism
Since there is no actual secularism movement, I will take examples and insights from where I can to assess how secularism is doing. This means jumping back and forth from some of the New Atheist writers to American culture as a whole.
No Ground Secularism has failed to establish a ground for human existence. “Ground” here does not mean anything exotic. I just mean that secularism has not given us a way to orient ourselves to reality. Secularism does not know how to answer questions like, what is the purpose of human life? or, what may I hope for? Secularism does not even like to think about such questions. One possible reason for secularism to be coy about some of the questions that have fascinated men and women since human life began is that its answers are unpalatable. The answer to the question, what is the purpose of human life? may be “there is no purpose.” The answer to the question, what may I hope for? may be “nothing.” Secularism cannot be blamed for the truth of existence, of course. So, if these are its potential answers, they must not be ruled out just because of our wishful thinking. In fact one would expect secularism to answer in these ways because it might be secularism’s view that life is a cosmic accident. An example of tough-minded secularism is the French existentialist JeanPaul Sartre. Philosophy Professor William Barrett described Sartre’s atheism as follows: “Sartre’s atheism states candidly . . . that man is an alien in the universe, unjustified and unjustifiable, absurd in the simple sense that there is no Leibnizian reason sufficient to explain why he or his universe exists.” Sartre held that there is no ground for human existence. But Sartre did not flee from the dark implications of his insight. Man is radically free and radically alone (Sartre may have changed his view about this toward the end of his life). Now, compare Sartre’s honesty and depth with the shallow, cheerful optimism of the American atheist Sam Harris. I quoted Harris earlier claiming to believe in absolute right and wrong, presumably independent of man’s opinion of the matter. Harris’s view of right and wrong is reassuring, but Sartre would have seen it not only as unjustified but also as a threat to human freedom. Harris just asserts this view of the absolute, never admitting that absolute right and wrong do not fit his atheist universe. Here is a similar, jolly quote from Harris’s book The End of Faith: “Clearly, it must be possible to live ethically . . . without presuming to know things about which we are patently ignorant. Consider it: every person you have ever met . . . is going to die. . . . All are going to lose everything they love in this world. Why would anyone want to be anything but kind to them in the
The Failure of Secularism
•
37
meantime?” I do not understand the cheerfulness of our New Atheists. Here, there is an almost willful refusal to confront the implications of atheism. Why not say instead, “I’ll kill these other people out of my despair at the absurdity of losing everything I love?” I do not mean to suggest that violence is a better response to the apparent absurdity of human existence than kindness, but it is certainly a possible response. Another of our current atheists, Philip Kitcher, is more realistic about the effect of his thinking on average people. Kitcher writes about Elaine Pagels’s account of finding herself, unaccustomedly, in church after learning of the likely fatal illness of her young child. Kitcher writes about the difficulty of finding “comfort without supernaturalist hope.” But Kitcher does not understand that the biblical God is not just about comfort. God is also about justice. And punishment for wrong. And the shape of history. All this is lost when we dispense with God. If the hope that religion offers is “illusory to be sure,” as Kitcher says, what is Kitcher’s hope for life? Kitcher does not see that there is much more lost here than mere comfort. In his 2004 debate with Cardinal Ratzinger, Habermas seemed much more sensitive to what is lost when religious orientation is removed from our public life. Habermas called for a “saving translation” from religious to secular terms, such as the image of God transformed into the equal worth of all persons. But, Habermas also admitted that this does not always work. He was greatly worried about genetic engineering and a kind of rootless modernization in the world. Yet Habermas still argued that the legitimacy of the modern secular state could be grounded without religion in democratic argumentation. This does not seem too stable a foundation. Democratic argumentation is not a ground by itself. Only if there is something real behind argumentation does democracy achieve its promise. Here is what a ground for secularism might look like: When Rachel Remen’s grandfather would make an appointment or even just a plan, she reports that he would invariably add, “God willing.” This practice is common among Orthodox Jews of a certain generation. The phrase “God willing” reminds us that we are not in charge of the world or even our lives. Our plans are contingent. According to Remen, her grandfather believed that “all tragedy or blessing was a part of some unknowable and dynamic purpose. One might not always get one’s own way, but one trusted the Way absolutely.” This is an attitude potentially as acceptable to the secularist as to the religious believer. Life has its purposes. Accept them, align yourself with them, and trust them. This is the way to live.
38
•
Hallowed Secularism
This is not just wisdom for one’s private life; history is also part of life. Abraham Lincoln believed—and proclaimed in his second inaugural address—that the Civil War reflected God’s unknowable and dynamic purpose, which he thought he could intuit to a certain extent. I think that I see purpose in the historic and ongoing liberation of women, for example, as an ongoing process that, barring some catastrophe, is unstoppable. Does the atheist say no to this? Does the atheist insist that life has no purpose and that history has no shape? If so, what is the basis for this denial? Of course, it is common ground between the atheist and any kind of secularist that there is no being whose will orders the universe. But even without God, the experience of meaningful life is one that many people have. Furthermore, it would be just an assumption, and an unwarranted one, that this experience of meaningful life is an illusion. Trusting life works. Primo Levi reported that Orthodox Jews did much better than others at Auschwitz because they could somehow see its inhumanity in a religious context, as part of God’s will. If we study religion as a natural phenomenon, as Daniel Dennett tells us to do, we will have to concede that and explain it. The atheist might respond, but no one ever denied that fooling yourself can be useful. The people who see life in these terms are deluded but in a helpful way. Yet that response does not seem quite right. Wishful thinking is not generally a good strategy in life, certainly not consistently over time for large numbers of people. We are either made to function this way—that is, we see connections where there are none—or life somehow is actually trustworthy. Life actually has purpose. How life could come to have a purpose without a being like God would just have to remain a mystery. In other words, the atheist asserting the meaninglessness of reality is simply wrong. This disagreement over the ground of reality, with the candid atheist asserting that life has no meaning and the religious believer and the hallowed secularist claiming that life is trustworthy, is a fundamental difference among people. This difference does not always correspond to whether people go to church. There are churchgoers who do not trust life. Then there are secularists who do. Such secularists trust life and its purposes though they do not believe in God unless by “God” you mean that reality is trustworthy. Trusting reality does not require a belief in an afterlife. In Genesis, Abraham trusts God’s promise, although he has no expectation of any afterlife and is not reported in the Bible as having one. Abraham just dies. Secularism in America and generally in the West has not come clean on its ground of existence. An earlier generation of atheists was willing to acknowledge the implications of its humanistic and materialistic views of life. Now we have cheerful atheists who suggest somehow that good things and good people are
The Failure of Secularism
•
39
inevitable without God or anything God-like. This is a sharp delineation between secularism and Hallowed Secularism.
No Limit on Technology Humans are threatened today by an avalanche of technology. We see already the deadening effects of our gadgets: the declining attention span as multitasking replaces thinking; the lack of privacy as information spreads; the simple noise, as more places become wired. Our thinking lacks subtlety under the technological constraints of the screen. Our politics minimize thoughtful discussion and, instead, become the rants of blogging and talk radio. Our advertising moves ever futher away from providing information about products to the psychological manipulation of “branding.” The pressure of seeking efficiency leads to stagnating wages in return for more and harder work. And yet, increased technology is not increasingly efficient. We now live in a world of computer viruses and identity theft. These are all mere instances of the more general and insidious technological threat—that we come to regard ourselves as pieces of technology. We become thing-like. This threat is what lies behind a number of issues, such as genetic engineering, stem cell research, cloning, and abortion. This is why our benefits offices are now called offices of Human Resources. We are not people in the workplace but resources. Our humanity is at risk. People have been thinking about themselves as things at least since the times of Descartes and Newton. Morris Berman explains in his book, The Reenchantment of the World, that Descartes envisioned the universe “as a vast machine, wound up by God to tick forever,” and that Newton demonstrated how that machine is “held together by the forces of gravity.” The importance of understanding nature as a machine and not as having purposes of its own (or of God’s for that matter) is that nature’s only significance is its usefulness to humans. As Berman puts it, truth becomes identified with utility. This understanding of nature, as merely useful to humans, and of no value in and of itself, is the core of the scientific method and is absolutely secular. In theory, there is no reason why such a mechanical worldview could not have been restricted to nonhuman nature. Human beings could have been considered exceptional. Descartes regarded animals as machines but not humans. But the rejection of any distinction in mechanism between humans and the rest of nature is now threatening our humanity. As a character in Nicholas Christopher’s novel, The Bestiary, says, “Once you believed animals were insensate things, disposable, of utilitarian value only, it wasn’t so hard to move on to people.”
40
•
Hallowed Secularism
Like other things, humans are also now subject to engineering. Genetic engineering promises to produce people who are smarter, taller, better looking, and so forth. So far, character seems beyond simple biological manipulation, but perhaps manipulating character is also in our future. You do not have to be religious to be uneasy about our increasing capacity to change ourselves. Bill McKibben’s 2003 book, Enough, was a general challenge to scientific activity that blurs the boundary of the human. Referring to the same technological capacities to alter human beings as was McKibben, Habermas stated his concern about the new “liberal eugenics” in his discussion with Pope Benedict. In his recent book, The Case Against Perfection: Ethics in the Age of Genetic Engineering, and in a 2004 Atlantic Monthly article, the philosopher Michael Sandel sets forth what he considers a secular case against genetic engineering: that it undermines the view of human life as a gift and restricts our “openness to the unbidden.” While Sandel expressly eschews religious grounds for his position, his language is premised on a traditional Judeo-Christian outlook. Indeed, Sandel acknowledges that he took the phrase “openness to the unbidden” from the theologian William F. May. One wonders what Sandel means when he says the “moral stakes [of genetic engineering] can . . . be described in secular terms,” and concludes that he wants us to see “our talents as gifts for which we are indebted, rather than as achievements for which we are responsible.” These sentiments are religious. Sandel is close to Hallowed Secularism. In contrast to Sandel, secularism usually adopts a fatalistic pose in the presence of science. One secular critic wrote of him, “a strategy that defines itself against the core idea of scientific progress cannot succeed.” Everything that man can do, man ultimately will do. Thus we see that secularism does not deliver on its promise of enhancing human freedom. Instead, we end up helpless in the face of scientific advancement. This fatalism in the face of technology is clearly expressed in the landmark case, Diamond v. Chakrabarty, which, in 1980, established the patentability of bioengineered life. Chakrabarty is widely regarded as the legal birth of biotechnology in America. The case was brought against the U.S. Patent Office after it denied a patent for a bacterium that had been engineered to consume hydrocarbons, with particular application in cleaning up oil spills. The Patent Office argued that no living organism could be patented. The United States Supreme Court held, 5–4, that living things can be patented as long as the new living thing has characteristics “markedly different” from anything found in nature. The majority opinion by Chief Justice Burger rejected any categorical limits to
The Failure of Secularism
•
41
patentability, quoting legislative history that patent protection extends to “‘anything under the sun that is made by man.’” The majority’s basic position was that biotechnology research, and presumably production, would not be affected by any decision the Court made. Chief Justice Burger’s suggested that in the end it would not even matter what Congress determined about patentability: “Legislative or judicial fiat as to patentability will not deter the scientific mind from probing into the unknown any more than Canute could command the tides.” The suggestion that “whatever can be done will be done” is frightening. We sometimes say that you cannot stop progress. But Burger is not talking about progress. He is not saying that the future will be better, only that technology has a certain momentum that is beyond human control. This fundamental threat from technology is also identified by the philosopher Martin Heidegger in his famous essay, The Question Concerning Technology. Heidegger views technology in very broad terms, as everything being ordered to stand by, to be in ready as a “standing reserve." Thus, even the Rhine River, with its hydroelectric plant, appears now to be something at our command as “a water-power supplier.” The picturesque Rhine seen on postcards is still there to be sure, “as an object on call for inspection by a tour group ordered there by the vacation industry.” But man only imagines that he is in charge of this process. Man too is “ordered . . . to do this” and belongs himself within the standing reserve. Human subservience to technology and the related inability to resist or to take a stand other than within technology explain the political power of stem cell research in America. President George W. Bush has lost considerable political support, even among those Republicans who are pro-life, for his opposition to federal funding for stem-cell research and his vetoes of bills supporting stem-cell research. This political weakness is strange because stem cell research, for the moment, requires the destruction of human embryos. A human embryo is fairly described as the very first stage of the development of a human being. It can be said with certainty that, if a new birth control pill that operated by destroying the human embryo were developed, the pro-life movement would unanimously oppose it. Yet, the pro-life movement is split over funding for stem cell research, which does the same thing. In the context of secularism’s subservience to technology, we can understand the politics of the issue. Abortion is seen as a “moral” issue. Secularism loves to take positions on moral issues—especially, on the left, if it can be done in the language of personal choice and, on the right, in the name of traditional sexual morality. But, stem cell research is regarded as a scientific issue. Secularism is loath to oppose scientific advance or technological
42
•
Hallowed Secularism
application. This is why little criticism is heard about egg donors, sperm banks, embryo freezing or any of the other aspects of the human reproduction industry. Why do we not go even further? We are already beginning to resemble the mountains of humans used to produce energy for machines in the Matrix movies. Why do we not harness these same embryos that we are willing to use for medical purposes to produce energy? In sufficient numbers they would reduce our need for foreign oil. And they do not pollute. If that does not work out, we could always eat them. Secularism is uniquely vulnerable to the technological threat because secularism has no place to stand outside technology. In other words, secularism is hard pressed to answer the question, what is so special about human beings that they should not be treated like things? Unlike secularism, Our Religions can answer that question. The religions of the Book answer, human beings were created by God to serve him in a unique way, and to have dominion, within the limits of creatureliness, over nature. Other religions might say that man is special because he is a part of life and all life is holy. These responses can serve as foundations for resistance to technology. Hallowed Secularism attempts to borrow from religion here. This book is not the place for a full critique of technology. I am only pointing out the failure of our secularism to help us live humane and fulfilled lives. First, we saw the lack of ground, then the inability to resist technology. Next, let’s look at the failure of secularism to bring social peace.
No Peace Secularists like to claim that Our Religions are a source of conflict in the world. Supposedly, one important accomplishment of secularism is to avoid the conflicts that religious differences bring. The secular remedy for religious violence is to relegate religion to the private and individual sphere. This thesis was expressed by U.S. Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer in a dissent in a 2002 case—Zelmon v. Simmons-Harris—that upheld a school voucher system in Cleveland, in which most of the money ended up going to the Catholic schools in that city. Justice Breyer explained the case in terms of the wider context of religious conflict. According to Justice Breyer, the Establishment Clause was meant to protect the “Nation’s social fabric from religious conflict. . . . These Clauses [adding the Free Exercise Clause] embody an understanding, reached in the 17th century after decades of religious war, that liberty and social stability demand a religious tolerance. . . . The Clauses reflect the Framers’ vision of an American Nation free from the religious strife that had long plagued the nations of Europe.”
The Failure of Secularism
•
43
Mark Lilla, a professor of the humanities at Columbia and one of the New Atheists, recently expanded this argument in magazine article and book form. Borrowing from Thomas Hobbes, he claims the “Great Separation” of religion from politics is the key political accomplishment of America and the West. From secularism’s perspective, there are three explanations for the tendency of religion to lead to violence. First, there are simple doctrinal differences that people feel strongly about and are willing to struggle over. Second, there is a more general critique that people fight out of irrationality and that, unlike secular reason, religion is part of the irrational side of life. Finally, there is a specific critique of a certain kind of religion—apocalyptic religion—including the monotheisms with which the West is familiar. In its 2005 report, Exploring Religious Conflict, the Rand Corporation, an American think tank, calls this apocalyptic tendency “cosmic war,” borrowing the concept from Mark Juergensmeyer. Cosmic War “refers to the metaphysical battle between the forces of Good and Evil that enlivens the religious imagination and compels violent action.” Many of America’s opponents in the world today, the report asserts, are “religious extremists” engaged in Cosmic War. I think the secular position is wrong. Not only is religion not a particular source of violence, secularism itself is. In terms of religious violence, it is important to distinguish conflict based on religious differences from conflict in which religion is used as one more source of enthusiasm against an enemy. For example, the conflict between the United States and Japan from 1941 to 1945 would not be considered a religious conflict. Nevertheless, on both sides, religious differences were utilized for propaganda purposes. As Carl Schmitt put it, political conflict “draws upon other distinctions for support.” In other instances of conflict, the difference between religious conflicts and conflicts that arise from other sources is harder to distinguish. Conflicts in Northern Ireland and Israel, for example, plainly involve religion but are basically ethnic or cultural rather than religiously doctrinal. Religion itself is not usually the source of conflicts in the modern world. Let me now set forth the contrasting position—that secularism is the source of violence. I will briefly address that claim on three levels: the amount of conflict, the relationship of conflict to secular reason, and the inherent tendencies to violence of religion and secularism. On the amount of conflict, for all the religious wars of the sixteenth century and in our own day, the secular conflicts of the twentieth century—World War I, World War II and the cold war—surpass them in scope and ferocity to such a degree that the secular claim appears ridiculous. While it is true that there are Islamic fanatics out there who might be happy to drop an atomic
44
•
Hallowed Secularism
bomb on New York City, it remains the case that they have not yet done so, while we secularists did drop atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. When I say things like that in discussions with secularists, they resent the use of the Nazi movement as representative of secularism. They consider anything emotional, as opposed to reasonable, to be religious. The Holocaust, therefore, notwithstanding the Nazi movement’s hostility to Christianity on many levels, is characterized by secularists as a religious attack. Lilla even attributes World War I to religion, despite the fact that most of the participants were Christian. These secular claims about World War I and World War II are unpersuasive. Just as one example, Auschwitz was a labor camp that killed the people it did not need for labor and worked everyone else to death. The slogan at Auschwitz was “arbeit macht frei” (work makes [one] free). The phrase has a mystical tone, to be sure. But Auschwitz was not a religious conception, nor was the freedom referred to in the slogan religious. But, rather than belabor the point, let me demonstrate an undeniable instance of secular reason leading to violence. The highest achievement of secular reason was the nightmare of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD), in which the two sides in the cold war rationally aimed thousands of nuclear warheads at each other and were apparently ready to use them. They were ready to do this even though everyone knew that human life would be destroyed. No one can claim that these calculations were anything but rational from a certain point of view. This is my answer as well to the claim of cosmic war. While there are, no doubt, religious people ready to bring on Armageddon, only secularists have taken upon themselves to put a finger one-inch from the Armageddon button. Apparently, religious people are not as irrational as secularists. There is an inherent reason for secularism’s violence. At their hearts, Our Religions promise peace that generally is not the result of war. As John Milbank puts it, “a harmonizing peace which is yet beyond the circumscribing power of any totaling reason.” In contrast, secularism assumes that difference is inevitable and necessarily implies “arbitrariness and violence” that can only be controlled by subjecting difference to the irresistible power of “market economies and sovereign politics.” True, Milbank was speaking only of Christianity in his contrast to secular thought, and would probably not agree with the expansion to other religions. But the point here is the flaw at the heart of secularism. Milbank denies the sweet reason that secularism claims. He would not be shocked that secularists might stare at each other from behind barbed wire or missile launchers. Peace requires at least the possibility of “infinite order.”
The Failure of Secularism
•
45
Without that hope, there is only the temporary interruption of violence. Not, as is at least possible in Our Religions, peace as the expression of truth. In a world of almost constant violence, religion is not innocent. But secularism has failed in its promise of peace.
No Truth America is a country of untruth. This is how the author Nathaniel Philbrick describes the explorer Amerigo Vespucci and his relationship to the country that bears his name: “What Vespucci did have . . . was a gift for chicanery and self-promotion, along with an aching need to be remembered. As it turns out, America—this nation of notorious hucksters, dreamers and spin doctors— was named for just the right guy.” Is this claim exaggerated? Our consumer economy is driven by advertising, which is not based on truth. We even have a term for the lies of advertising, in order not to call them lies—we call them “puffing,” and they are never actionable in a court of law. Our political life is also based on lies, in the sense that all partisanship is dishonest, because you must always protect your friends and attack your enemies. I once read the columnist William Safire defending the political one-sidedness of his writing by explaining that you could not have an impact in American political life if you did not speak and associate with one side. Safire made it sound like a matter of commitment—that people who did not do this were wishy-washy. The notion of a commitment to truth did not enter into it. Newsweek recently did a cover story on what the magazine called the global warming “denial machine.” The denial machine consists of a corporately funded effort to manipulate the public into thinking that there is scientific division about the truth of global warming, when there is no serious scientific dispute. The story characterized politicians, especially conservative Republicans, as easily duped, and corporate leadership, especially that of ExxonMobil, as liars willing to sacrifice human good for greater profit. Lest you think this means that conservatives are liars and liberals tell the truth, the whole global warming story can be examined in the exact opposite way. From the point of view of people who believe, mistakenly but certainly honestly, that global warming is not true, the entire scientific establishment in the world is in on what Senator James Inhofe once called the “greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people.” Either way, whether global warming is true or not, our society is corrupt. Either way, a lot of people are lying. Once you live in the realm of lies, truth is very hard to come by. It can become difficult even for you to know whether you are telling the truth.
46
•
Hallowed Secularism
The height of our culture of dishonesty is the war in Iraq, which had nothing much to do with the reasons given for pursuing it. I still do not know why we invaded Iraq—and the reason could have been legitimate—but it could not have been a sincere attempt to prevent the accumulation of weapons of mass destruction by Saddam Hussein, since the American government made it difficult for the weapons inspectors to finish their investigation. That investigation would have shown whether or not there were weapons of mass destruction. The invasion of Iraq was based in part on lies from the political right. But we all know that lying is nonpartisan. On the left, people defended President Clinton’s lies and on the right people defended Lewis Libby’s lies. The absence of truth is also at the heart of one of the American Constitution’s great accomplishments—free speech in the First Amendment. The idea of free speech might be, and to a certain extent is, that the absence of restrictions on speech ultimately leads to truth. But its acknowledged judicial spokesman, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. had a more jaundiced view of free speech: “time has upset many fighting faiths.” Holmes’s skepticism about truth could be really shocking, even absurd. Here is a quote from his famous Memorial Day Speech to the Harvard graduating class in 1895: I do not know what is true. I do not know the meaning of the universe. But in the midst of doubt, in the collapse of creeds, there is one thing I do not doubt, that no man who lives in the same world with most of us can doubt, and that is that the faith is true and adorable which leads a soldier to throw away his life in obedience to a blindly accepted duty, in a cause which he little understands, in a plan of campaign of which he has little notion, under tactics of which he does not see the use.
Holmes here is praising idiocy and slaughter, which he thinks he knows to be true, at least in a relative sense. Believe it or not, American law schools revere Holmes, both on the left and on the right. This is secularism. Also present in our society is the more technical noncommitment to truth that is associated with postmodernity. This philosophical trend emerged some years ago in the humanities and is grounded, if that could be the right word, in cultural and historical change. The idea is that there is no hard truth underneath our assertions, just temporary convention. Surprisingly, this relativism is established in conservative thought as well as in left-wing political movements. A few years ago, the political thinker Harry Jaffa criticized his conservative allies for their skepticism. In particular, Jaffa had in mind Chief Justice Rehnquist’s view that without the First
The Failure of Secularism
•
47
Amendment there could be no right of free speech. Jaffa regarded free speech as a natural human right. The most extraordinary example of the lack of commitment to truth is that this society has an actual, professional news organization—Fox News— that, depending on your point of view, is either consciously dishonest, makes no attempt to deliver the news impartially, or is about the only news organization that does deliver the news impartially. This situation is baffling. If Fox News is really just partisan politics, how can it pretend to be a news organization? How can the journalists who work there look at themselves in the mirror? If people know this about Fox and still watch it, what does that say about the general view of truth in this society? On the other hand, if Fox is just telling it as it is, and its accounts differ from those of other news organizations, does not that mean that these other organizations are lying? How did we get to this point? I know that many secularists think that religious believers are dishonest. But genuinely religious people cannot denigrate truth. For believers, God the Creator stands as an insistence that the way things truly are is grounded and important. We see the weight of truth dramatically in the accounts in the New Testament of two opponents of Jesus and of the Jesus movement: Pilate and Saul, later to be renamed Paul. In the Gospel of John, before Pilate, Jesus says, “I have come into the world . . . to bear witness to the truth. Everyone who is of the truth hears my voice.” Pilate famously responds, “What is truth?” In other words, Pilate orders Jesus’s execution for reasons of expediency, not to dispute the claim that Jesus is King of the Jews—that is, the Messiah. Saul, on the other hand, is part of the mob that stoned Stephen to death for claiming that Jesus was the “Righteous One.” The book of Acts describes that upon hearing Stephen’s claim, “they cried out with a loud voice and stopped their ears and rushed together upon him.” In other words, Stephen is killed because Saul and the others deny the truth of his claim. This is the difference, as the New Testament sees it, between Rome and Jerusalem. In Rome truth does not matter, only power. And power is willing to kill even though there is no truth. In Jerusalem, on the other hand, truth is all that matters, even to death. In present American society, we are mostly like Pilate. For us, the most important thing is not truth but power or power’s equivalents: money, fame, health and so forth. Because we are secular—even some of us who claim to be religious—we are willing to live with less than the truth.
48
•
Hallowed Secularism
No Hope In a thoroughly secular world, there is nothing to hope for. You cannot hope for eternal life. You cannot hope to see God. You cannot hope for the Messiah. About all you can hope for is to live relatively well, to find love, to help others, to see your children grow up and to die easily. That does not describe a bad life. But it is not an ultimately satisfying one. Beyond the individual, what can a secular country and a secular western civilization hope for? Surely we can hope for a world of peace, justice and caring for the environment. Pope Benedict has described this hope, perhaps a little mockingly, as the secularized version of the Kingdom of God. But we do not even hope for these things. Instead, there is something quite poisonous in the atmosphere. For many individuals, the common saying is “life is sh—, then you die.” For society as a whole, the closest we had to a common endeavor was to impose democracy on the Islamic world, which is a project that came to grief in Iraq. American society is at a dead end. Individual life is a flat, endless, working and consuming—a losing tread mill—interrupted by bouts of entertainment and escape, lacking in depth and tradition, constantly running up more and more debt. Social life is now lived in fear of endless threat from a seemingly incoherent world without and from illegal immigration within. We have a sense that America is losing ground, losing its way, losing its leadership, and losing its prosperity. In part, these perceptions are the result of demographics and world trends. America has a relatively aging population, which robs it of vitality. America is an aging empire, desperately trying to keep new arrivals on the world scene, particularly China, at bay. The pathology that this situation gives rise to is all around. In the individual realm, there are the new exotic religious products. For example, secularists, who ought to know better, are now dabbling in the afterlife. Two recent scientific books purport to make differing cases for nontheistic immortality: Frank Tipler in 1994 argued that we might be resurrected in computer simulations in the future, and John Leslie argues in a new book that we will survive death based, in part, on quantum physics. These recent efforts update the tunnel-of-light reports by those close to death, which were gathered in the 1970s by Raymond Moody. As another example, there is the new fascination with the Mayan calendar and suggestions that the world will end, or that something will happen, in 2012. The Mayan enthusiasm seems to be a kind of rapture for non-Christians. The pathology in the collective American psyche is more dangerous. This explains the strong and rather sudden anti-immigrant wave. This is why we are ready for conflict with China. Though 9/11 was a real and justified shock,
The Failure of Secularism
•
49
this lack of hope helps explain why America was so ready for the thorough militarization of foreign policy that followed 9/11. The basic belief in progress that characterized the West for the last three hundred years no longer seems to sustain us. Global warming reminds us that technology is no panacea and the Islamic resurgence suggests to us that the world is not becoming more secular and peaceful. In other words, we do not even have the hopes that we thought secularism was competent to deliver. The problem is that these hopes, as understood, were merely utopian. We cannot just will international cooperation. We will not just suddenly have an era of peace and justice. There are real impediments and always have been, including our own sinfulness. These dreams of a better world rested on humanism. They aimed to bring the Kingdom of God without God. But man is not capable on his own of such an achievement. What might renewed hope look like in Hallowed Secularism? The point of Hallowed Secularism is that there is something transcendent in reality— something really there—and Our Religions are good guides to its nature. We are not left without guidance, personally or collectively. Thus, while it is true that there is no afterlife, there can be intergenerational blessing. Assuming there is something real beneath and around us, my individual life can contribute to the coming-to-fruition of such blessing. The same thing can be true for society as a whole. Assuming there is something God-like available for guidance, we could bring our society into better alignment with its thrust. Or, at least, we could try to do so. Since there will not be a Second Coming, whatever we are able to achieve socially will not last. Each generation will have the same task for its time and place. But this is a rewarding and gratifying task. The burden of these efforts is not solely ours. The point of trusting reality is believing that our best efforts will be met and enhanced beyond our own capacities. That is the hope that Hallowed Secularism gives us, which we do not now have. I will return to the theme of hope in the last chapter of this book.
No Way of Life The greatest failing of secularism today is its failure to be a way of life. Secularists do not even understand the need for this. They do not realize that they are missing anything. This is why, though we are not believers, we drift back to church and synagogue, our kids are confirmed, baptized, and bat mitzvahed, and ministers, priests, and rabbis offciate at our funerals. The most courageous among us do without these things, but have nothing to put in their place. We just do without.
50
•
Hallowed Secularism
Because secularism is not a way of life, we cannot even say for certain what it means to be secular. American society, for example, while clearly secular in many ways, is also influenced by religion. For example, the Catholic Church tried to force Senator John Kerry in the 2004 presidential campaign to change his position on abortion by threatening him with exclusion from communion. How different was this from Pope Gregory’s pronouncement of excommunication against Henry IV in 1076? Certainly President George Bush owed his reelection in 2004 at least in part to the clear, if not express, support of much of the American Catholic hierarchy. Yet, consider also how different the religious situation is today from the past. If Senator Kerry had made the matter of foreign religious interference with an American election a major issue, he doubtless would have gained political support. And, of course, President Bush is a Protestant. He literally owed the pope nothing in an institutional religious sense. The pope’s power in America is dependent on ordinary democratic forces. Whether it is the pope’s desire for change on abortion, or the Sierra Club seeking a change on global warming, it is a question of how many votes are at stake if the candidate moves one way or another. The church in other words, though very powerful, is powerful only as another interest group. In terms of the calendar, America is still interwoven with the religious year. Sunday is still something of a rest from business. Halloween, Christmas, and Easter still dominate the holiday seasons. Thanksgiving resonates with religious history and themes. Even the Jewish High Holy Days influence daily life where large concentrations of Jews live. And as other religious groups increase in numbers, their calendars will contribute to American religious consciousness. Yet, our religiously influenced calendar lacks the feel of religious time. We do not feel eternity. Often, Sunday is spent at the mall and the baseball game. Christmas is a time of watching Charlie Brown and buying presents. Easter is losing the cultural sense of the risen Christ. To see the degree of secularism present in our society, you must ask to what extent Christianity in particular or religion in general is the “ordering principle of human life,” as Glenn Olsen puts it. Does the world stand under the dominion of Christ or is it proudly autonomous? Put in these terms, we are plainly secular. What then is the ordering principle in America? Upon what are we dependent? What is the foundation of our way of life? To me, the answer seems to be threefold: political, scientific, and economic. Our lives are organized around human self-determination (democracy collectively and self-help individually); instrumental rationality (science in its many forms); and commerce (the world market). These are our sources of
The Failure of Secularism
•
51
meaning. And of the three, the market is dominant. This is what passes for a secular way of life. It is not a healthy way of life. It is a world without worship, without gratitude, without mystery, and without love. In a word, this secular world lacks holiness. It lacks the hallowed quality that secularism needs in its new, worldwide civilization. It is also a world without a plan for itself. Secularism has drifted into this situation, rather than having chosen it. I think that secularism needs a very different kind of life. That is what I mean by Hallowed Secularism. The first step in that direction is collective engagement. Secular society must begin a democratic reevaluation of our way of life. In other words, we must come to grips with our secularism as a people. Obviously, I do not mean “politics” when I say democratic. Politics is narrowly divisive. This process must be broadly inclusive. That is why the narrowly politicized religion of activist liberal churches seems to me a dead end. We need collective study and thought, and finally to make a decision, as to who we are to be in this secular age. To put this another way, we must give a new and deeper meaning to human self-determination. Without impoverishing ourselves economically and without disdaining human reason scientifically, we must come to see democratic self-examination as the new center of society. Only in that way, can we come back to the deeper sources of meaning in the universe that are outside human control. This book is meant to be a marker on the way to that undertaking.
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 4
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
A
few years ago, Thomas Friedman, the well-known columnist for the New York Times, wrote an influential best seller titled The World Is Flat. The book was about globalization, which is increasingly interconnecting the world. Trade barriers are down, political tensions are lessening, and technical advances are reducing the importance of geographical distance. Friedman is right that technology is changing the world. There are good things about this—for example, it unites people all over the world—as well as negative. But for our purposes, the most significant aspect of this new world is not that it is fast and interconnected but that it is “flat.” Of course, Friedman means flat as in unimpeded. He is describing a secular world, however, that is flat also in the sense of lacking meaning. Religion plays little role in Friedman’s book, except that of irrational impediment to globalization. But no other sources of meaning come into play in this new world either. Though there are new techniques for the transfer of information, we have less of significance to say to each other. Friedman’s title is a helpful image. The secular world is flat. That is what is wrong with it. It lacks depth. It lacks insight into the meaning of human life. This chapter explores some of the potential sources of depth in a world that no longer believes the stories Our Religions tell. The list of sources is merely suggestive. Each of them has its positive and negative side. All of them will be a part of the world of Hallowed Secularism.
Our Religions: History It is a major premise of this book that Our Religions must become a source of meaning for the secular world. This is not surprising since Our Religions have always been the major source of meaning for humankind.
54
•
Hallowed Secularism
The first lesson that religion can teach secularism is that God acts in our collective history. Our Religions, in particular, Christianity and Judaism, tell us that although God creates the potential for just societies, men instead institute injustice. When they do that, God responds. Religion in this context is not, and cannot be, private. The Old Testament is not primarily about the religious experiences of individuals. Those experiences are present, of course—the still voice speaking to Elijah, the burning bush that speaks to Moses. Such experiences are even fundamental in the unfolding story that the Torah tells. But those personal experiences are part of a communal story. That story is basically the formation, enslavement, liberation, maturation, decline, and eventual salvation of the Hebrews as a people in a covenant relationship with their God, Yahweh. That story is not restricted to the Hebrew people. The covenant extends to all people and to creation itself. Indeed, the point of the story of the Hebrew people, as explained by God to Abraham, is that the Hebrew people will be a blessing to all the people of the world. As heir to the promise of the Torah, the New Testament should not be thought of as personal, either. There is no such thing in the Bible as a personal savior. The savior—the Chosen One, the Messiah—is not sent to save individuals but, as Jesus puts it in Matthew 15:24, “the lost sheep of the house of Israel.” Salvation is communal. Incarnation, crucifixion, and resurrection are salvation history for all the world. Thus, the change from the Old to the New Testament is not from the collective to the individual. The change is the growing understanding that Yahweh, through Jesus, is now dealing directly with all the people of the world, for whose sake the covenant had been instituted from the beginning but who previously had been the recipients of blessing only indirectly. Jesus, his followers come to see, has been sent as savior not only to Israel but “to all nations.” It is certainly true that when Jesus preaches repentance, each individual must repent. This is why many people think of religion as a personal search for meaning. If someone insists that religion must deal with social problems, that person is accused of turning religion into politics. Pope Benedict sets forth the necessarily social thrust of Christianity in his book Jesus when he describes the foundational text behind Jesus’ statement, “I am the true vine.” Jesus’s claim sounds solely personal: Jesus is the true vine; believe in him and inherit eternal life. No doubt the pope believes that. But the pope reminds us that Jesus’s words about the vine cannot be understood without looking at the song of the vineyard in the book of Isaiah.
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
55
In Isaiah, the owner sings a love song concerning his vineyard. He did all he could for the vineyard, expecting good grapes, but sour grapes grew instead. Then, the prophet adds, so all understand, For the vineyard of the Lord of Hosts is the House of Israel, and the men of Judah are his pleasant planting; and he looked for justice, but behold bloodshed; for righteousness, but behold a cry. (Isa. 5:7)
As the pope says, forcing us to see political issues where we would prefer to see “religion,” “God gave them the way of justice in the Torah, he loved them, he did everything for them, and they have answered him with unjust action and a regime of injustice.” Secularism says there is no God. But that just transforms this religious claim into the terms of history per se. Is there an enduring shape to history? Is the cry of the orphan forgotten? Can a regime of brutality and injustice endure forever? The secularist who answers that history means nothing is leading us (and himself) into nothingness. Not only is such a person depressing and nihilistic, he is mistaken. Do you imagine that the rejection of human slavery is temporary, or the liberation of women not inevitable? Once these injustices are acknowledged, there is no going back. Supporters of these injustices are merely fighting a rearguard action. Something is on the scale of history, tilting it against slavery here, for the liberation of women there, promoting democracy across the globe. If God is not doing these things—and cannot be doing so because there is no God—it certainly acts in some ways like God. There are implications here for human autonomy. If history has a shape, then man is not absolutely free. This is of particular importance to Pope Benedict. The pope links the song in Isaiah to the parable in Mark of the tenants of the vineyard. The prophets in the parable are the servants sent to collect the rent. Israel, now the tenants rather than the vine, rejects the prophets. So the owner sends his beloved son, and the tenants kill the son, thinking now they will be free of the owner. Pope Benedict says this is the message of secularism. God is dead and man is free. Man is God, but look where our freedom is leading us. If we understand that history has a shape, we must accept that shape as binding. Human beings must conform to it or suffer the consequences. There are costs for injustice. This, then, is the second lesson for secularism: obedience. For secularists it cannot be obedience to the will of God. Yet, the Bible is a good guide to
56
•
Hallowed Secularism
what man is to do and not do. While I quibble over the culturally determined parts of the Bible—the condemnation of homosexuality, the discrimination against women, the prohibition against pork—its overall thrust is genuinely liberating. This liberation comes with judgment—that is, negative consequences—when we engage in oppression. The word obedience sticks in my throat. But what else can you call it when history is on the move? You can go on holding slaves. Pharaoh did. The South did. There were consequences, though. Yes, people disagree about the direction of history. That does not excuse us. Many slaveholders sincerely believed they were benevolent. They were wrong. They were oppressors, and they paid the price, often with their lives. We are directed to follow the genuine path of liberation in history. If we are wrong, we will certainly find out. Commandment in the Bible is not arbitrary. Man is not oppressed by the divine direction, whatever form the judgment of history takes. Do you think it is a burden that we are commanded to love each other? It is only a burden if you wish to be powerful and heedless. Only a burden if you worship money. Only if you think the planet’s climate is your plaything. It is a burden, in other words, if you are on top. But I’ll take the burdens of the Bible any day. The oppression that threatens us is from each other, not from God. This is the third lesson for secularism: continuing exodus—continuing liberation from human oppression. The slaves go free. Exodus is the heart of the Bible. Jesus’s first public proclamation is straight out of the liberation of the Torah. Jesus reads from the Prophet Isaiah: He has sent me to proclaim release to the captives and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty those who are oppressed, to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord. (Luke 4:18)
You and I refuse to be told what to do by the pope or by Jesus. But, when Francis Fukuyama says we are the end of history and that history ended with America on top, you can now tell him, based on the Bible, that history has a few more tricks up its sleeve. America’s will is not the final word. This means your will is not the final word either, and neither is mine. But this is no threat to our genuine autonomy. You and I were not running the world. People we might not care for were running the world: corporations, armies, dictators. And they were not really running the world, either. If, instead, something quite God-like is actually in charge, you and I and most everybody else are better off. What, then, is the final word of liberation in history? In the Bible the final word is the Kingdom of God.
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
57
As a secularist, talk of messiahs and second comings and resurrection puts me off entirely. This is superstition. But Jesus also said, The kingdom of God is not coming with signs to be observed; nor will they say, ‘Lo, here it is!’ or ‘There!’ for behold, the kingdom of God is in the midst of you. (Luke 17:20)
And the promise to Abraham is even more this worldly: his descendants are to be a blessing. So, the final lesson for the secularist is that the kingdom—a world substantially more just than this one and more liberating than what we know now—is promised. It is not just a dream. If we do our part, though we never yet have done so, reality will more than meet us. We will not be rowing into the wind, but will be buoyed up. Is this utopia? Not necessarily, nor is it humanism. For it is not based purely on our own efforts. It is the biblical promise. The point of Hallowed Secularism is that we must let the teachings of Our Religions lead us in our lives together. History, politics, social life, economics, and so forth are all places of potential holiness. We secularists must not give up this biblical vision. Here is the potential source of foundational justice. Here is a place of power in which the merely political comes alive.
Our Religions: The Personal I have had several spirit-filled experiences in my life. Once, at a time of great need, I asked God for help to simply go on and immediately received help. Once, at a time of deserved guilt, I asked for forgiveness of sin and immediately received forgiveness. Several times, while studying scripture alone or with others, I experienced what the Jewish tradition calls the world to come. On one startling occasion, at the end of Yom Kippur services, I experienced a vision of violence and destruction centered around abortion. What should a person conclude from such experiences? We know from William James in The Varieties of Religious Experience and, more generally, from the sociology of religion that experiences like these are common. They happen transculturally and transhistorically. These religious experiences can be sources of enormous power. They can promote great optimism or black despair, harmony or fragmentation of the psyche. They can bring a person to the world or lead one away from it. James’s attempts at categorizing religious experiences do not seem very informative of their nature. His accounts do, however, generally share the attributes of intensity and connection. These experiences are intense in that they are more vivid
58
•
Hallowed Secularism
than our usual lives and can be life changing. They are connecting in that the person experiences a broader, otherwise unavailable, reality in which all things participate. Religious experiences carry their own authority for the person who has them. When I experienced the forgiveness of my sins, it would have been senseless if someone had claimed that my sins had not really been forgiven; I only thought that they had been. Religious experiences, therefore, cannot serve as authority for anyone else. President George W. Bush is reported to have said that God instructed him to invade Iraq. The rest of us, of course, cannot rely on the authority of President Bush’s sincere report of God’s will. Similarly, my vision experience concerning abortion capped my long, slow movement to a pro-life position. My experience in synagogue was so vivid and powerful that it was impossible to interpret other than as instruction as to the violence implicit in abortion. Obviously, though, as in the case of President Bush’s experience, no one else would be persuaded by what happened to me. Like the fact that people disagree over the will of God in history, the atheist uses disagreements over the meaning of personal religious experiences to argue that these experiences are irrational and dangerous. President Bush’s confidence in his invasion strategy is a perfect example. My newfound and, I assure you, quite unwelcome, commitment on the issue of abortion is another example. The atheist says that people should rely not on visions and instructions from another world but on evidence and reason. James would respond, I think, that the atheist’s position is unscientific. These religious experiences happen. They actually happen a lot. They change people’s lives. They are thus fully real and fully a part of the world. As James put it, in terms specifically of God, “God is real since he produces real effects.” I would add, in terms James might reject, that the capacity to produce such large-scale effects argues against mere illusion. Besides, religion is not the only source of these deep experiences. Art, for example, also can evoke the sense of connection to something larger than ordinary human life. Art, like religion, can evoke the authority of an unseen realm. Meditation can do so. Even silence. Famously, sexual relations can lead us to experience heightened connection with everything around us. Human beings simply are, it seems, potentially connected with the power of a deeper reality. It comes as no surprise that I, raised in Judaism, called on the God of Israel for help and asked for forgiveness of sins in accordance with the ritual of Yom Kippur. Other people raised, let us say, as Muslims would experience divine help from Allah and would be transported by study of the life of the Prophet.
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
59
As the great Indian student of religion, Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, explains, “Something is directly experienced, but it is unconsciously interpreted in terms of the tradition in which the individual is trained.” What should the secularist learn from all this “religion”? Secularism must be open to religious experience of this kind and not flee from it or denigrate it. The reaction of dismissal is mere secular bias. Religious experiences are a natural and constant fact of human life. They have at least that much authority. I regard these religious experiences as quite profound. They are often the most meaningful experiences that people have ever had. Such experiences must be a part of secular civilization if that civilization is to be whole and rich. There is even a deeper importance to religious experience. We need it to reach our full human potential. Looking at this phenomenon for the moment through the lens of the Judeo-Christian tradition, even that most rational, enlightened figure, Thomas Jefferson, regarded Jesus of Nazareth as an exceptional human being, who not only taught self-sacrificial love, but practiced it in a way totally beyond the rest of us. Jesus was a product of the tradition of prayer, of contact with holy reality. I doubt that a human being remotely like Jesus is possible without openness to experiences of the holy. If secularism is to be capable of nourishing human beings who are whole and giving, it must find a way to cultivate religious experience. This is not just a matter of personal growth. Secularism must care for the world and its people. That kind of caring does not come from mere ideas. It does not come from self-interest. It does not come from ethics. Such caring can come from experiences of deep connection that communicate the oneness of reality. To conclude this short examination, secularism must learn to cultivate and study religious life. It must be open to religion’s power. This obviously will require secular structures and habits that do not now exist. In fact, openness to religious life sounds like the opposite of secularism. That is only because, until now, secularism has been able to borrow from the spiritual life of Our Religions without acknowledgement. In the world of the future, in which secularism becomes dominant, secularism will have to cultivate sources of meaning on its own. It will need religion. Does that imply all religion? I have a Western bias in favor of the ethical obligations generated by the religious life of Judaism and Christianity. I have been taught that the mystical religions of the East are more passive, more dedicated to mere experiencing of the Absolute. But I might be wrong about that. Secularism should proceed from a firm ethical foundation and not from mere relativism. While there must be tolerance of religious practice and belief, secularism will make judgments about which religious traditions
60
•
Hallowed Secularism
contribute the most to the betterment of human life. As I said at the beginning of the book, it is likely that the secular traditions that come from each religious civilization will differ in their appreciation of the content of the wisdom of Our Religions. Eastern secularism will probably be more open to the lessons of Eastern religion than Western secularism will be. At that point secularism will begin to learn from itself. All this contact with Our Religions leaves open the real possibility of religious conversion. After all, Our Religions are not going to disappear during the next hundred years. If secularism studies religion carefully, as it must, some secularists are going to convert. That is no threat. Secularism has to be devoted to truth, not to its own perpetuation. I doubt that secularism will be weakened because I think it corrects Our Religions in important ways and responds well to the needs of our time. But that is something history will decide. Is there any one thing at the center of these religious experiences? Our Religions teach that there is. At the heart of reality is unfathomable compassion. To come into contact and alignment with that reality is the fundamental goal of human life. Appropriating that insight is the level at which secularism becomes Hallowed Secularism.
Science We saw in an earlier chapter that science is one of the sources of secularism. Scientific accounts of the world tend to undermine the stories Our Religions tell. But that is not the end of the scientific interaction with religion. Science can also be a source of depth in human life. Of course, this is obvious in a simple sense. Psalm 19:1 proclaims that “the heavens are telling the glory of God.” And so they do. Most people who look at the immense sky, with its billions of stars, feel something deep and mysterious. In addition to the impact of nature’s grandeur, there is also amazement at nature’s intelligibility. Why are we able to understand at least part of the wonder of the natural world? Why is nature so regular? The experiences of the great scientists were akin to religious experiences. Then there is the mystery of our own intelligibility. We can study our capacity to know. In the hands of a master such as the theologian Bernard Lonergan, the methods by which we come to know the world suggest meaning in our efforts to do so. In these ways and others, science can deepen us and give us a sense of awe and gratitude. Obviously, then, Hallowed Secularism will be highly scientific. There is another sense in which science is important to the effort to deepen secularism. There is always a potential conflict between faith and reason in
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
61
religions that are historical, such as Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. Historical religions insist that certain events actually occurred. For the secularist, the natural laws discovered by science cannot be violated. Thus, science sets the boundary of what is possible to believe. Hallowed Secularism must begin at that point and nowhere else. You could say that secularism learns the power of truth from science. This obviously raises an issue between secularism and Our Religions. As Glenn Olsen puts it, in referring to the theology of Karl Barth, in secularism and in certain secularized versions of Christianity, “the world already sets the expectations to which Christianity must conform.” For Barth, this is an antireligious comportment that rejects the fundamental message of the Bible. To put this bluntly, Barth would say that man cannot tell God what God can do. This legitimate tension between secularism and religion is where Hallowed Secularism is born. Based on experience, the secularist does not believe that the laws of nature are ever set aside, nor that the sort of God who could set them aside, could exist. Yet the hallowed secularist thinks that the core of Christianity—not just its “ethical teachings”—is true all the same. I do not know how this tension will be resolved. Until now, religiously oriented people had to defend religious dogmas—that is, particular stories and explanations—against scientific attack by secularists who wanted to discredit religion in general. Sometimes, religious people accepted science and claimed that both science and religion were true. Sometimes, religious people responded, as did Pope John Paul II, by challenging the capacity of scientific reason to fully account for reality. Sometimes, there was a sort of mix that tried to split the difference by declaring, for example, that the age of miracles is over, but by implication that miracles had occurred. Unlike the defenders of Our Religions, Hallowed Secularism agrees that much religious teaching is indeed ruled out by science. Nor does Hallowed Secularism object that this is setting man above God. Humans were meant to use their brains in much the way we are doing. Hallowed Secularism denies, however, that science rules out what is fundamental in Our Religions. Our Religions do not make many claims that actually violate the natural order. Atheists love to point out, for example, that Jesus heals people, but that no one regrows an organ. This is supposed to show that Jesus lacks supernatural power. What it actually shows is that the Bible generally tells us about events that could happen. Jesus heals people. There are many examples of healers in human history who can remove disease by touch. Indeed, Jesus reminds his critics that they also heal the sick. There are details in biblical accounts that could not have happened. For example, no one can actually walk on water. Certainly, there is also exaggeration
62
•
Hallowed Secularism
in the Bible. An older couple might have a child, as in the example of Abraham and Sarah, but the ages they are given in the account might be older than they actually were. Other events are most improbable, but do not actually violate the laws of science. A virgin could theoretically give birth. The most important claim in the Bible is that God speaks to us. I know this does not violate the laws of nature because something like this happened to me. A related claim is that God enters history. Science certainly has nothing to say about that. In other words, the project of scientific atheism to disprove the existence of God, such as in Victor Stenger’s book God—The Failed Hypothesis: How Science Shows That God Does Not Exist, cannot succeed. It gives atheists a lot of comfort that the big bang could have happened without violating any natural laws. Or, that the universe might always have been existing in some sense. Either account would rule out the “button-pusher” God who creates by his will. But I want to know whether the creation of the universe matters. Is selfconscious, morally self-defining life both the goal—the teleology—and the most important accomplishment of the universe? I think the answer is yes, and I do not see that science puts any limit here. Scientific accounts do limit religious plausibility beyond mere physical impossibility. Science gives us a physical account of the world. An important part of that account is regularity. So, I cannot believe in a God who could alter that regularity. Such a God could not be. That has enormous theological implications. Science also shows us that everything we know about ourselves roots in our physical being. This rules out anything like an existence after death. Perhaps even more important, it keeps me from regarding death as an enemy to be overcome as opposed to a natural event. Why is science so important to us? I know it is not impossible to believe the Torah or Gospel more or less as traditionally understood. Once, I believed it. Furthermore, I do not know that much about science. I certainly do not vouch for it. The issue is not science as such. What is at issue is knowing the nature of human life. I insist that human life as I know it is approximately what human life has always been like. If there are no voices at Sinai today, there never were. If there are no miracles today, there never were. Conversely, if slaves go free today, then they always were being freed. If human greed today causes the rains to fail, as it does in global warming, then such a curse could always have been sent by heaven. The Kingdom of God must be something that we can seek here and now and that we have seen, or it does not exist at all.
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
63
Democracy How is the Kingdom of God to be sought? Devotion to God must be total to be meaningful. If religion does not determine your life, you are just like your secular neighbors, except that you go to church or synagogue. Maybe you vote your religious commitments, but secularists vote their commitments, too. God really means nothing in a life in which religion is not the primary determinant. Yet, such a status quo religious life is overwhelmingly the life of most believing Americans. Today, movements are springing up to renew Christian life in fundamental ways. An example is the New Monasticism movement, based loosely on Jonathan Wilson’s book Living Faithfully in a Fragmented World. The theme of the movement is that, to practice Christian life seriously, there must be small-scale communities that live differently from their neighbors. Similar in commitment is “radical orthodoxy” in the Catholic and Anglican Churches, in which the locus of all of life for the Christian is the church, rather than the culture. Secularism needs a response just this radical in order to become Hallowed Secularism. But how can this happen when there is no institution like the church to promote alternative secular living? Hallowed Secularism cannot happen until we figure out how to create a countercultural model. In the 1960s, young people tried to do this through alternative lifestyles. That did not last. Something more fundamental is needed. Democracy can be a starting point in this effort to create radical secularism. By democracy, I mean the way that a people decides collectively the fundamental orientation of their society. Every act, every word that we speak, creates a social world that answers the question, what does it mean to be human? We can call this organic totality of social life, radical democracy. Hallowed Secularism aims to answer the question, what does it mean to be human? differently from the way we are answering that question now. With the long-term decline of organized religion, secular societies will have to work at meaning. In the future, secularism will not be able to preach life without value while relying on Our Religions to keep the world basically decent. The current secular answer to the question, what does it mean to be human?, is production and consumption relieved by entertainment without greater possibility. This answer, if it ever really becomes the world’s answer, will lead to despair. In contrast, the answer of Hallowed Secularism to that question is holiness and love in a world without the God of the Bible but with the traces of that God remaining. With that answer, we might get by.
64
•
Hallowed Secularism
Making that answer a social reality is the overall task of Hallowed Secularism. The institutions that will make that possible do not yet exist. These institutions will have to function at the collective, local, and individual levels. At the collective level, the task is to define a national orientation to reality in opposition to materialism, militarism, and nihilism. In other words, the American people must become a people as the Hebrews did, with a selfconscious longing to orient ourselves to what is fundamentally real in the universe. This task carries several implications. First, secularism must be open to religion even just to get started. So, our political practices and constitutional doctrines must change to allow easy public openness to religious reality. Secularism is currently hostile to religion, but that is because secularism has not yet figured out its great task. Second, the state cannot be “neutral in worldview” as liberal political theory would have it. Of course, the government in America is not neutral now and no state could be. The government now endorses capitalism. The government now endorses materialism. The government now endorses anthropocentrism. Our national life now puts humans ahead of nature and puts money ahead of humans. There is nothing neutral about it. Since I am recognizing and endorsing a strong government role, I must address the danger of totalitarianism. Some future politician will want to run everybody’s life in the name of Hallowed Secularism and will invite the voters to help him do so. There really is no distinction in Hallowed Secularism between the State and religion and, I must admit, that is dangerous to liberty. How did the Hebrews deal with this threat, since they also mixed church and state? The Hebrews used prophecy as a check against the danger of tyrannical theocracy. America, and all other secular societies aiming to redefine what it means to be human, must therefore be open to a prophetic voice in order to protect themselves against arbitrary government power. America already has institutions that allow prophecy to occur. I am not speaking of the courts. The institutions I am referring to are the normal foundations of democracy: freedom of speech, the press, and association. As long as we have these, we can hope that some prophetic voice will arise and protect the people from themselves. As long as we have these freedoms, we cannot be a totalitarian state whatever the role of religion. The task of radical democracy—deciding what it means to be human—is what every democratic society decides every day. This democratic task is one of fundamental social orientation. It has little to do with individualism as such. So, the libertarians are both right and wrong. They are right that what small social units do, like families, is more important than what governments
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
65
do. However, they are quite wrong in imagining that these small-scale, private, decisions are not of cumulative weight. Libertarians think you can only be oppressed by something the government does. They imagine that the private decisions of others cannot be oppressive. But, in fact, the market economy and its attendants, like advertising, overwhelm people and set the benchmark for the culture of what it means to be human. That is a social, not individual, question. Strong people can manage to dissent, of course, but they have to overcome a great deal. Overcoming a great deal is not liberty. This social task is not a mere policy issue. Hallowed Secularism’s task is to determine the fundamental attitudes of society, hopefully determining them differently from the current market orientation. But, this is not the same as deciding particular policy issues. Just as it is wrong to enlist Jesus in a debate about the tax rate, it will be equally wrong to do that kind of thing in the context of Hallowed Secularism. To do that is to engage in moralism. I have written thus far about the responsibilities of the collective. How do individuals, families, and neighborhoods participate in Hallowed Secularism, since it has no churches? How can we determine anything collectively unless we can discuss and come to grips with matters locally? This is a serious problem, and it has the potential for undermining American democracy no matter what direction our secularism takes. We lack ways to talk with each other outside narrowly defined “political channels,” like election campaigns. At one time I thought Americans might begin to organize “Democracy Clubs” to talk about fundamental questions. Others think the Internet may be part of a solution. We have not yet responded to this challenge to democracy. But even if such institutions of communication and exchange existed, how can secular Americans confront the aspects of our culture that they reject? How can secularists begin to actually live the countercultural lives that Hallowed Secularism demands? Obviously, we will need radical thinking about secularism to spur alternatives. In other words, we need new ideas and then a way of putting these ideas into practice. In the next section, I ask where these ideas, the content of Hallowed Secularism, will come from.
Theology The great postwar preoccupation of Christian thinking has been to ponder the rise of secularism and the meaning of that rise in light of the God of the Bible and the revelation in Jesus Christ. Never before has humanity been in this situation. While there have been individual atheists, there has never been a culture that believes humans are alone in the universe. As the strong interest in Charles
66
•
Hallowed Secularism
Taylor’s book A Secular Age shows, we have begun to wonder how this state of affairs came about and what it means. This Christian theological project was the positive counterpart to the challenge implicit in Feuerbach’s statement in 1841 that “the personality of God is nothing else than the projected personality of man” and the shocking announcement by Nietzsche in 1882 that “God is dead.” Feuerbach denied he was an atheist. Nietzsche was more radical in his understanding of man’s relation to God. Nietzsche saw in the death of God the potential negation of all value. One obvious, potential theological response to the rise of secularism is that secularism is simply the latest manifestation of human sinfulness. Man has again turned away from God. Humans have always used religion to turn away from God and now are using secularism to do so. Under this view, the proper role of the church would be to confront and resist modernity. Certain aspects of Barth’s theological opposition to liberal Protestantism can be looked at that way, and, similarly, some identify Pope John Paul II as “the last anti-modern Pope.” Pope Pius X’s encyclical “Pascendi Dominici Gregis” (On the Doctrine of the Modernists) is often also cited in this context. But Christian theology did not ultimately embrace that rejection of modernity. Most theologians looked for the positive implication of secularism. In what Dietrich Bonhoeffer called his “secular interpretation,” he seems to equate secularism with Jesus’s cry on the cross that God has abandoned him. God will not save in this world: “God lets himself be pushed out of the world on to the cross.” He is to be found only in “weakness and suffering.” Thus, we find ourselves in a world come of age without God, but before God; that is, all this in accordance with God’s will. From Bonhoeffer we may conclude that if we want to destroy ourselves, God will not prevent us from doing so. God has told us how to live. Now that we have the power and knowledge to live without superstitious belief in him, we must live in accordance with his teachings or suffer the consequences. And in that suffering, God suffers with us. Bonhoeffer was trying to understand the theology of—the meaning behind—the rise of secularism as a context without God. The theologian Jurgen Moltmann calls this task grasping “the implicit theology of this modern world of ours” and he sometimes refers to it, apropos Hallowed Secularism, as “Godless Theology.” In the name of human liberation, Moltmann practices a radical critique of modernity and its will to domination. He affirms that all theology in the secular world is public theology—that is, theology with its eye on the Kingdom of God—seeing what in the modern world moves toward the Kingdom and what moves away. To accomplish this goal, theology needs secularism, so that
Sources of Depth in Hallowed Secularism
•
67
it is free of the institutional restrictions of the church; but theology also needs openness on the part of secularism to hear theology’s critique of modernity. A somewhat different critique of secularism is articulated by Eberhard Jungel, a near contemporary of Moltmann. Jungel is very Christ oriented and so at first seems far away from secular man. But that is just Jungel’s point. Without God, man runs the risk of self-divination. This is precisely the danger to which secularism is exposed and to which Hallowed Secularism attempts to respond. Jungel might ridicule the whole notion of Hallowed Secularism, but that only means it is not a certainty that the task of Hallowed Secularism can be accomplished. Bonhoeffer, Moltmann, and Jungel have a great deal to teach us, and they are just a tiny sample of modern theology encountering secularism. Our world is one in which organized religion no longer controls thinking about God. But in current secularism, theology has a hard time reaching popular thinking. Not many people in our secular world are reading theology. But in Hallowed Secularism, theology would become the blueprint for human life to confront reality. In other words, free of church control, secular man can return in his autonomy to religious sources for guidance. This is something of what Bonhoeffer was getting at. This is a secular world come of age. What Hallowed Secularism is attempting to get secular man to see is that the religious question is the most important matter for us. When all supernaturalism is abandoned, after miracles are rejected and death is embraced as real, that religious question amounts to this: what is reality really like, and what is the human response to reality to be? No doubt there are other ways into this question besides religion. But since philosophy has become technical and unhelpful to people, theology is the best source for thinking about this question, which is, after all, the most important question. In Part II of this book, we will use theological sources, as well as other available sources of depth, to develop an understanding of the key concepts of Hallowed Secularism: truth, world, man, God, and the future. Then we will begin to apply these conceptions to imagine the world of Hallowed Secularism.
This page intentionally left blank
PART II
The Beliefs and Practices of Hallowed Secularism
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 5
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
T
his chapter begins the process of defining and specifying our longing. Secularists want to belong to a meaningful whole and feel cutoff instead. We want justice to triumph while we worry that it may not. We are willing to die without hope of any future life, but we want to experience the world to come here on earth. The basic categories for understanding are not surprising: world, man, God, and the future. But we begin not with a category, but with a method— what religious people call “the way.” We begin with truth.
Truth Let me give an example of what I mean by truth. The German theologian Eberhard Jungel was asked why communism failed in Europe. He responded that it was the “objective untruthfulness” of the system. By this he did not mean socialism in principle but “the untruthful way in which the socialist ideals were implemented by a kind of power politics.” Hallowed Secularism agrees with Jungel that a truth claim of this kind—that there is such thing as objective untruthfulness—is meaningful. On the other hand, no one has the whole truth of anything for all time. That is one problem with religious dogma. We must live empirically. As Ludwig Wittgenstein says, “look and see.” Truth can be contrasted with image. In 2006, Robin Givhan won a Pulitzer Prize for criticism as fashion editor for the Washington Post. I listened to a speech by Givhan in which she said she was only concerned with image and with the power of the image. Ms. Givhan and her Pulitzer are the perfect symbol of the postmodern, secular world. It is a world increasingly out of touch with truth.
72
•
Hallowed Secularism
Unlike this secular age, the Bible sees truth behind the image. The image is merely of the slave. The Hebrews are slaves, but the power of the universe is somehow on their side. Jesus is the image of a slave, but he is actually allpowerful. Reality does not reside in the image of things but in how things really are. And this is what frees us—the truth of things rather than the false image. That is why Jesus promises in the Gospel of John that knowing the truth will make you free. No one really denies truth in terms of his own life. For example, a person like Pontius Pilate, who asks, “What is truth?,” knows the truth of his own self-interest perfectly well; and he follows that truth even to the point of committing violence against the innocent. The same is the case with postmodernism’s deconstructions. The people who practice deconstruction are on top. They do not burn with the passion of social justice because they are comfortable with the way things are. They also know the truth of their self-interest. Thus, the secularist and the believer are probably not divided over truth as such. Truth is not a religious category. Pope Benedict has often said that there are things that a secular conscience knows as well as a religiously grounded one. Even though our consciences are culturally and historically conditioned, at any particular historical moment, people of goodwill are going to agree about a lot. Religious dogma need not interfere with such agreement. Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan says this in the name of the Hindu tradition, but really in the name of all religion: “The creeds of religion correspond to the theories of science.” Science does not give us a perfect picture of the ultimate nature of the physical world; its “theories are symbolic and are accepted because they work.” This is also true of our ideas of God. They do not capture God, but they are consonant with our experience of reality, including our experience of revelation itself and history read in the light of revelation. Radhakrishnan’s contextual religious thinking is uniquely Eastern. John Milbank, a fully orthodox Christian, and one of the founders of the radical orthodoxy movement, explains that Christian truth develops out of the experiences of the church. Milbank is a different kind of postmodernist. He criticizes what he calls secular reason for its abstract and ahistorical quality. So, given the crucial importance of living by truth and yet recognizing that culture and history condition us, what can be a starting point for Hallowed Secularism? The main conclusion that I draw from looking at reality is that everything is one. That is, there is unity in reality. Truth is the whole. Of course, I, having been raised as a Jew, am conditioned to think that from the Sh’ma—the central prayer of Judaism: Hear O Israel: the Lord our God is one.
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
73
Nevertheless, I do not say this simply out of traditional religious commitment. All the world, as we live in it, seems to be one. The laws of physics, for example, apply in the realms of chemistry and biology. In fact the laws of physics undergird them. The same is true of doing good. The truly good is not ugly but beautiful. The good, the true, and the beautiful are one. Theology at its best deals with the world as one. This is why Milbank calls theology the queen of the sciences. This fundamental unity means that the current division among science, politics, and religion cannot be permanent. The theologian Harvey Cox describes his view of an increasingly integrated religious and secular future as follows: “I predict . . . a postmodern world in which science, philosophy, and theology have once again begun to communicate with each other, and in which politics and religion no longer inhabit different compartments of the human enterprise.” The implication of this unity for Hallowed Secularism is precisely Cox’s unified world of inquiry. Hallowed Secularism will be a world open to truth that deals with all aspects of life. Thus, the realm of the holy and the realm of the secular must be one. This insight is not new. The doctrine of the incarnation of Jesus Christ has already testified to the unity of the holy and the world, of God and man. We could say that living by truth is the religion of Hallowed Secularism. There is no fear that truth will lead to evil, or even to impiety, because reality is one. Science, therefore, could never contradict the truth of religion, or vice versa. What about truth for an individual’s life? Here again truth is not a matter of religious dogma. The key lies in following what John Dewey—a young Dewey of twenty-seven—called “the perfect and matchless character of Christ.” As Karl Barth said, that is not a matter of believing in any particular set of ideas, including Christian ones, but of actually following him, of building one’s life on the model of Jesus and relying on a connection to him. Of course, others may object here, offering other models, not convinced that truth lives in Jesus. That is fine. I am not suggesting truth of that sort. When I am most open, I see Jesus as the model I should follow. Others may see things differently. The point in Hallowed Secularism is that there is a model—a true model—that one should follow in life. The models will be contested and, probably, never finally resolved. The consequence of losing the commitment to truth is the triumph of evil. For genuine evil is always based on some sort of lie, whether that lie is the claimed inhuman quality of people—Africans in slavery, Jews in the Holocaust, the inferiority of women—or something else, like the supposed right of people to exploit the natural world. Pope John Paul II was correct in the encyclical “Evangelium Vitae” (The Gospel of Life) to begin his treatment of human inhumanity with Cain’s lie before God after the murder of his
74
•
Hallowed Secularism
brother Able. Asked by God about the whereabouts of his brother, Cain responds falsely, “I do not know; am I my brother’s keeper?” The pope writes, “Cain tries to cover up his crime with a lie. This was and still is the case, when all kinds of ideologies try to justify and disguise the most atrocious crimes against human beings.” The old saying that for evil to triumph, good people need only be silent is only partly true. Someone needs to be willing to lie as well. When truth is at the heart of life, what do we find is at the heart of truth? The answer is love. The life of truth is fulfilling. The result of truth is rewarding. The clarity of truth is ennobling. This, of course, is what Christianity has always said. Dewey wrote this of the Christian message: “God is truth; . . . as truth He is love.” Though this sounds like dogma, it is simply what we find when we look.
World Hallowed Secularism’s major commitment is to this world—this reality that we all experience—as all there is. This world is what secularists see when they look. The world is what science investigates. The nonhuman aspects of this world are often called nature. We humans are part of nature, too. We are also apart from nature. Defining the limits and boundaries of the world is not an obvious or simple matter. The question becomes, what is this world? There is transcendence in this world. There are what Abraham Maslow called “peak experiences” in this world. The world is in no sense the opposite of religion. Here is how Mary Catherine Hilkert describes the thinking of the theologian Edward Schillebeeckx on this point: “In the midst of our ordinary daily lives, certain events and experiences provide a point of breakthrough, even cause a kind of ‘gestalt shift’ in the way we live and understand ourselves and life. . . . Whether suddenly or gradually, something happens through which, upon reflection, we recognize deeper dimensions of ourselves and of reality.” It is important here to note—so there is no misunderstanding—that this is not just religious. Schillebeeckx is describing the experiences of morality, beauty, history, of depth of any kind. The conversion experience is not always a matter of falling off your donkey upon the address of God. It need not be mystical or dramatic. A lot of people experience this breaking-in when they read the Gettysburg Address or when they see people bravely insisting on their human rights against all odds. Suddenly, we feel connected with a sweep of movement beyond the everyday. These depth experiences are not supernatural. They are part of life as lived in this world. Materialists pretend that life is flat and just a matter of forces of various kinds. But that is not how life feels.
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
75
Surprisingly, Our Religions also mostly teach that this world is what matters. Here is an example from Pope Benedict’s book, Jesus. Pope Benedict writes of Jesus’s numerous invocations of the Kingdom of God: “When Jesus speaks of the Kingdom of God, he is quite simply proclaiming God, and proclaiming him to be the living God, who is able to act concretely in the world and in history and is even now so acting.” This is shocking reading for us secularists. The pope is saying that the believer and the secularist are looking at the same event when the believer says, “You see, there is God acting.” There is no invisible realm for the secularist to deny. What the believer is claiming, in attributing action to God, is simply an interpretation of the here and now. When the skeptic responds, “Where is God acting? I don’t see anything,” the believer says, with Jesus, “the captives are freed; the blind see and the oppressed are set at liberty.” The believer says, “Haven’t you seen liberation in your life? There is God.” Suddenly, the concept of world does not seem so irreligious. This is why Schillebeeckx, interpreted on this point again by Hilkert, says that God himself is to be found in this world: “While religious traditions provide a searchlight for believers, the traces of the living God are to be discovered in the history we have called secular and the world we have considered profane.” Pope Benedict writes similarly about heaven. In a discussion of the Lord’s Prayer, where Jesus prays that God’s will be done on earth as it is in heaven, the pope says “the essence of ‘heaven’ is that it is where God’s will is unswervingly done. . . . Earth becomes ‘heaven’ when and insofar as God’s will is done there.” Nor is it just religion that suggests more to the world than mechanism. Science also points to something beyond materialism in the world. Just as one example, it may turn out that, in principle, computers cannot achieve selfawareness, the Terminator movies notwithstanding. Consciousness may not be reducible to particular physical relationships. This has been argued by, for example, Roger Penrose in his book The Emperor’s New Mind. I am not suggesting that Penrose’s theory of mind in particular is crucial. I simply mean that science cannot explain consciousness in simple physical terms, or even mathematical terms, and may never be able to do so. As another example of the nonphysicality of reality, science, at the quantum level, has not been able to explain matter itself, which seems at a certain point to dissolve into indeterminacy. There is no reason to invoke God here as a gap-filler until we learn more about how things work. Things may just not work in a simple, physical way. If that is the case, then the statement “This world is all there is” does not represent closure against a religious view of life. Or, better, religious and nonreligious views of reality could be similar.
76
•
Hallowed Secularism
It is said that Einstein objected to the indeterminacy of quantum physics, claiming that the Old One would not play dice with the universe. His objection may have occurred because Einstein was a better scientist than he was a theologian. Science may call nondeterminism arbitrary, saying the universe either changes in a determined way or in an arbitrary way. You and I might say, instead, that there is freedom in the universe. And that freedom is, beyond a certain point, a mystery to us. Thus, when we look at the world in a certain way, we see mystery. What can we know of this mystery? First, the world is basically good to us and for us. Daniel Quinn, in the novel Ishmael, makes this point dramatically. Our ancestors over millions of years became the human beings we know by trusting nature and living within and by its rhythm and limits. The invention of agriculture was precisely the “fall” that Genesis describes. No longer would humankind trust nature. The results of this change away from trust in nature have not been good for people, says Quinn. Second, the world pursues its natural course. It is a mistake to see the hand of the divine or judgment or purpose in every act of nature. The Talmud, the ancient Jewish book of learning, gives this example. Suppose someone steals seeds and plants them. By right, the seeds should not grow. But the world pursues its natural course, and they will grow or not grow, without regard to the morality of the original act. This is true of catastrophes also, such as tsunamis and hurricanes. They just happen in nature’s natural course. One day an asteroid may hit the earth, destroying all life. It will be not some great purpose or punishment; it will just be the way the universe operates. Asserting that the world follows its natural course resolves some of the problems of theodicy—the existence of evil despite God—but raises in its place questions about the nature of God. Or, for secularists, you could say it raises questions about the meaning of things. Why does the world pursue its natural course? Is it God’s choice or something about the structure of reality? If God cannot do anything about nature’s regularity, then the biblical account of God has to be modified. But, now, contrast this ordinary operation of nature with the biblical story of the plagues in Egypt. Nature in that instance went haywire. This is represented in the Bible as having been brought on by human evil—in this case, disobedience and slavery. If global warming is changing the climate as a result of human greed and selfishness and if that change makes hurricanes and other natural disasters worse, this seems closer to the plagues than to planting a seed. Not everything that happens is nature’s natural course.
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
77
Third, while nature thus does not pursue a teleology—that is, an end or goal—humans do pursue purposes. And human history, as Sarah Blumenthal says in City of God, shows that human beings live in moral consequence. This moral consequence is not our creation. It is somehow rooted in the world in which we live. Of course, one could suggest here that since humans are part of nature and since humans evolved within a natural process, we are nature’s telos. Fourth, implied by our relationship with the rest of nature, we cannot assume that matter is lifeless and that the world is merely here for our convenience. There are consequences when humans act that way. This was stated powerfully by the Russian theologian Vladimir Solovyov, who was speaking of secularists: “They put forth [the] false view that nature is lifeless matter and a soulless machine. And earthly nature, as though offended by this . . . untruth, refuses to feed mankind.” Finally, the world shows us that we are not the source of things. For the secularist, even the hallowed secularist, there is, of course, no creator God. Yet it is still the case that humans did not create the universe. Thus we are still creatures. This is how Leon Kass, in his commentary on Genesis, puts it: “We can discern the distinctions in things, but we have not made them separate. Neither have we made that power of mind that registers the articulations of the world and permits us to recognize distinctions.”
Man Even more pressing and more difficult than the question, what is the world? is the question, who is man? And behind that question, is another question: in whose image is man made? What view of man lies in the balance between atheism and religion? That may sound like a surprising question. Man, after all, could have the same nature whether God exists or not. So, the nature of man and the existence of God could be completely separate issues. But they are not. If man is alone, radically alone—as religion and Hallowed Secularism both deny though in different ways—then the nature of man and nothing else determines everything. If you see man as flawed, then you get the atheism of Sartre: man is essentially doomed, though defiant. Unlike Sartre, the New Atheism is not in despair. This is because it has confidence in human nature. In this confidence it mirrors its precursor: John Dewey. In the 1940s, Dewey, then in his eighties, challenged what he saw as the revitalization of supernaturalism in religion, seeing in it a “skeptical, even cynical and pessimistic, view of human nature.”
78
•
Hallowed Secularism
We now have more experience with human nature unconstrained by traditional religious authority. However much atheists might like to attribute World War II to religious motivations, no one can claim the Nazis had permission from any religious authority to create the death camps; nor can anyone blame religious authority for the creation, use, and further development of atomic weapons. Mutual-assured destruction came a hairsbreadth away on several occasions from blowing up humankind and maybe all life with it. Man, unconstrained by religion, does not look good. Even if the New Atheists are right about the pernicious influence of religion, and of course, to some extent, they are right, man’s actions should give them pause about human nature. Christopher Hitchens likes to say that “religion is a human fabrication.” Assuming that, what does it say about man’s nature that he would fabricate what the atheist regards as a violent, vengeful, and malevolent God? As Ludwig Feuerbach saw, this God must be a projection of man. Thus, once freed from whatever constraints that even the atheists admit religion imposes, why would human beings not just give in to these destructive impulses even more fully than heretofore? In fact, by ignoring the negative truth about humanity, even while tearing down the flimsy restrictions of religion, the New Atheism would bring on catastrophe all the more certainly. Similar thoughts led the conservative theorist Russell Kirk to write in The Conservative Mind in 1953 that the “the salvation of civilization is contingent upon the revival of something like the doctrine of original sin.” Kirk was referring to the thought of Irving Babbitt, who had written that man must either “take on the yoke of a definite doctrine and discipline . . . [or] at least do inner obeisance to something higher than his ordinary self.” The point both men were making is that humanity must recognize our potential for evil in order to restrain ourselves. This is in a way an atheistic view of human nature. There is nothing external to ourselves, like God, to restrain us. But this atheism is, in contrast to Dewey, pessimistic about human nature. It might be said that Kirk and Babbitt were inconsistent. How could a flawed human nature be improved by a restriction it knows it is only placing on itself? What kind of jail gives every inmate a key to the door? Yet, despite this inconsistency, they did at least try to deal with human nature’s flaws. Christianity in particular has emphasized the flaw in man’s nature in the doctrine of original sin. By original sin, I am not referring to the cause of human sinfulness, which is the classic doctrine of original sin, but rather simply a description of human nature as sinful. Adam and Eve’s fall, in other words, is a symbol for what we are. This is more or less how Reinhold Niebuhr saw
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
79
original sin: man loves himself and does not trust God, which drives him to actual and present sin. But there is more in the Christian view of evil than merely man’s sinful nature. Pope Benedict, for example, notes our tendency to trivialize evil. He sees evil as a real and overwhelming force in the world. Man actually “encounter[s] the superior power of evil.” This is, the pope says, what Paul meant by his reference to the “principalities” and “powers” of darkness. This is “the poisoning of the spiritual climate all over the world,” which man, by himself, is powerless to overcome. This poison makes it difficult, even for good people, to see clearly. As evidence of the power of evil beyond human control, we can point to the current blindness with regard to stem cell research. Something precious and even miraculous is created: a new human life. But we imagine that we have a right to destroy this human life for our benefit. And it is really good people for really good reasons who make this terrible mistake. We see the same blindness in regard to the environment. The current talk is about “accommodating” global warming, dealing with it, in other words, rather than trying to lessen or prevent it. We just assume not only that the developed world has the right to change the environment in ways that harm poorer nations, such as island nations, and future generations, but that humans own earth’s climate in general and therefore have the right to change it. We also think that we own ourselves and have the right to genetically engineer a new human being. Maybe a new human race. Many good people simply cannot see all this. They do not know what they are doing. When Satan does not appear with a pitchfork and a pointed tail, he is hard to see. We are at the point now where human beings can be thought of as having to earn the right to be considered human. Those whom Eberhard Jungel calls the “non-producers” are at risk. Abortion is a part, though only a part, of this. The end of welfare as a full entitlement in America was also part of this. And, as could have been predicted, abortion is now sought not only to end pregnancies that are threatening to women but also to try to have a baby with some certain characteristics, including aborting girls in order to try for a boy. Atheists should be worried about the flaws in human nature. Atheists should also be worried about evil and its essence. Why is the world so ambiguous that we almost never can do the right thing? Why does even the right thing turn out often to be incomplete and horrible? Atheists should foresee disaster in our future, since there is no God to save us. It is different for Our Religions. For them, man is not alone. This is somehow true even in nontheistic religion. They also see the ambiguous and evil nature of man’s situation in this world. Different religions may even be thought of as offering differing treatments for a disease we all share. The point is not
80
•
Hallowed Secularism
whether they work in some sense. Maybe they do not. After all, the world today is a reflection of Our Religions. But Our Religions acknowledge the depth of man’s problem, and they think there is something that can be done about it. The “something” that they propose is sufficiently outside human control that we are not being asked to cure ourselves on our own. There is something beyond human beings that helps. In the case of the religions of the Book, that something is God. By God’s grace even the sinner is capable of doing good. God limits the harm man can do to himself and the world, even if that limit is itself God’s judgment. The rainbow after the flood is a symbol that God will not destroy the world again as a response to human evil. Where, in all this, is Hallowed Secularism? Hallowed Secularism is capable of seeing man as he in fact is. But it does not despair. There is something outside man that reaches out to him in benevolent aid. But what can that something be if there is no traditional God? We now, finally, turn to that question.
God It is not always clear what the dispute between the New Atheism and religion is about. The full title of Hitchens’s book is God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything. But, the title of the book is confused. God is not the same as religion. So, God could be great, and yet Our Religions, misinterpreting God, could poison everything. In that case, one could reinterpret God for oneself. Or, Our Religions could be great in theory, and each religion could be great in its own way, but the current human leadership of Our Religions might be bigoted, ignorant, and hateful. In that case, one should become a prophet, calling each religion back to its beautiful truth. But none of that would diminish God. In this section I am asking about God, not about religion or any particular religion. Inevitably, I am influenced by the Bible in trying to say who or what God is or might be, but the Bible is not the only source of knowledge of God. There is nature. There are other religious sources. There is profane learning. There is the world in its entirety, in other words. The New Atheism is attempting to lead secularism away from traditional religious life. It is not clear what the New Atheism intends as a new or different way of life. Conversely, it is clear that Hallowed Secularism aims to keep people in the orbit of religion, though looking at things differently. In discussing whether God exists—the classic question for theism and atheism—atheists complain that religious people present God as a moving target. A. C. Grayling, for example, a professor of philosophy in England and one of the New Atheists, calls religious thinkers “an evasive community, who
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
81
seek to avoid or deflect criticism by slipping behind the abstractions of higher theology.” There are two criticisms here. First, and the one Grayling is probably making, that religion is not theology and that religions are responsible for the superstitions of their flock. So, it is not sufficient for religions to present to critics a more sophisticated form of its teachings as a defense against criticism, when ordinary religious people do not share this sophisticated understanding. The second criticism of higher theology is that it is not biblical. God cannot be a philosophical category, such as uncaused cause or ground of being, and still engage in a conversation with Moses, let alone love the world and send His son. It would seem that only a being of some sort could do those things. Some theologians, even self-proclaimed Christian theologians, sometimes do not defend the kind of God the Bible seems to speak of. Here is an example, from a very well-respected theologian, Karl Rahner, of what might be called evasion: “that God really does not exist who operates and functions as an individual existent alongside of other existents, and who would thus as it were be a member of a larger household of all reality.” Instead, says Rahner, God is “the most radical, the most original, and in a certain sense the most self-evident reality.” What are we to do with that? Is this something that can hear our prayer? Let’s start then, in considering God, with a common ground between Hallowed Secularism and the New Atheism. As Dewey would say, there is no all-powerful, perfect being dwelling apart from the world, who created reality. This does not remove us from the more radical aspects of the Christian tradition. There have always been doubts in Christian thought that the statement “God exists” can be meaningful if God is the ground of existence itself. The theologian Paul Tillich states this expressly: “God does not exist. He is being itself beyond essence and existence. Therefore to argue that God exists is to deny him.” The theologian Bernard Lonergan, in his book Method in Theology, has a different way of approaching the question of God—one that does not link God to existence as a being. It is also a way that is not abstract, but has definite moral implications. I am led to say that Lonergan’s God is real and makes demands on every person. But on the other hand, Lonergan’s God—that is, his God only in one book since Lonergan was a loyal Roman Catholic—is the sort of God many atheists could also affirm. Lonergan says that “man achieves authenticity in self-transcendence.” In the realm of intelligence, I make judgments—to the extent I am not deluding myself—as to what is in fact so. The judgment about what is, is independent of me. Things would be this way if I were not here. It is beyond, trans, me.
82
•
Hallowed Secularism
This is a form of cognitive self-transcendence, that is, self-transcendence in thinking. Then, according to Lonergan, every human being moves to moral selftranscendence by asking whether the world as it is, or parts of it, are truly good. This is not a question of advantage or preference but of objective value. To live in what Sarah calls “moral consequence” is to ask questions about the good, answer them, and then try to live by the answers. Lonergan calls this “living a moral self-transcendence.” Herein, he says, lies “the possibility of benevolence and beneficence, of honest collaboration and true love, of swinging completely out of the habitat of an animal and becoming a person in a human society.” All this is a human capacity, which becomes actual when we love. You may object that this is all within the human being. What does it have to do with God? But, for Lonergan, there is no self-transcendence unless we are stretching toward “the intelligible, the unconditioned, the good of value.” Our horizon, in other words, must stretch to eternity if we are to practice the self-transcendence that allows for human authenticity. There is within this horizon “a region for the divine, a shrine for ultimate holiness.” Lonergan concedes that this space, this possibility of holiness, might resolve nothing since the atheist pronounces this space empty and the agnostic says it is inconclusive. Yet, reality is such that this possibility, the possibility of ultimate transcendence, cannot be ignored. We are drawn toward this possibility. Atheists do not ignore this possibility, nor our attraction to it. Our attraction to this possibility is derided by atheists who call it the religious instinct in people. But it is present in the atheist’s relationship to reality, too. This possibility is built into us and into the reality we encounter. With this possibility of ultimate transcendence, we have come to God, and not God entirely of our own making. What I find important in Longergan’s approach is his insistence that humans must transcend their self-regarding natures and that this goal is not mere moral carping but is our destiny in this universe. We live in accordance with reality only when we strive to live this way. When we do not, there are consequences. Some atheists hate consequences for behavior. But even a child knows there are such. Other thinkers have come to somewhat similar conclusions about the shape of reality. The crucial similarity among them is that this shape is independent of man. It is something man must take into account, like not wanting to walk into a dresser in the dark. So, C. S. Lewis begins Mere Christianity with transhistorical and transcultural notions, such as taking your turn, which is an intelligible demand wherever there are people, whether they follow this rule or not. Apparently taking your
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
83
turn is a real value, as Lonergan would put it, one that is built into reality. And, if one day we meet intelligent aliens, they will understand taking your turn. The theologian Schillebeeckx writes of our experiencing “reality as a gift which frees us from the impossible attempt to find a basis in ourselves.” This is the mystery of graciousness at the depth of human experience. Even Dewey, who was not a theist at the end, wrote of the awareness of the whole of reality that human beings experience. This sounds very much like Lonergan’s horizon. I quote these thinkers, and I could add others, in order to demonstrate that they are all making the claim that reality calls to human beings and invites their participation in accordance with certain norms. This is the case with regard to individual lives, societies as a whole and history in its entirety. This is God. Walter Brueggemann writes in his classic work Theology of the Old Testament that the ancient Hebrews discovered something new, something never before expressed, at the heart of reality: “a hidden cunning in the historical process that is capable of surprise, and that prevents the absolutizing of any program or power.” Of course, they called this cunning, God. God, they said, was ultimately in control of history rather than we. The Ancient Hebrews discovered a power at the center of things. Often, they did not understand this power. It was a mystery to them. However, they did see it work in history, and they were able to sense its presence. To a degree unlike that of any other people, they saw this power as involved in the life of humankind on the side of the powerless. In fact, they had a sense that this current world did not reflect the way things were supposed to be. They were certain that the power at the center of things, in contrast, did reflect the way things were supposed to be. In the Bible, you see human history as the movement from the original Garden of Eden and its loss, to the differing ways of trying to put reality back the way it is supposed to be. One such way was the covenant with Abraham. The Hebrews did not think they could command this power. They could not even name it. Sometimes it appeared person-like. At other times, as power itself. It was the Hebrew genius to try to figure this out. I think the ancient Hebrews were absolutely right that there is a mysterious power in reality and that its effects are present in our lives and in history. I also think they were right about its strangeness. I do not have any doubt that it is real and that it is in control rather than we. This power is behind the natural order, not instead of it. I do not think it does tricks with nature. The Hebrews apparently also thought that miracles in nature were uncertain, since magicians are shown in the Bible as able to do some of the same things in nature that God does.
84
•
Hallowed Secularism
The Hebrews thought this power was something like a person. Here I think they made a mistake. This mistake had consequences because it led them to imagine a plan—God’s plan—and, eventually, an end to things. By the time of Jesus, some of the Jews foresaw a Messiah and an end to the world as we know it, with the resurrection of the dead and the last great day. The Jewish followers of Jesus knew him as this Messiah and his resurrection as the beginning—the first fruit—of the coming end, the eschaton. Some current Christian thinkers maintain that the second coming was not to be the end of history. Yet, it was to be the end of death and the resurrection of the dead, so in what sense could it not be the end of history? In any event, Jesus is now for Christians the face of God who is absolutely a person with a will and a plan and the power to control nature and change its laws. Atheism and Hallowed Secularism both deny that this sort of God is real. But for atheists, this world seems pretty self-explanatory. We happen to be here, and we do things, and then we die. There is nothing in any sense behind all this. Hallowed Secularism stands against that self-evidence. I think the Hebrews were mostly right and the atheists mostly wrong. In some ways the world we know is out of whack. It is not the way things are supposed to be. Somehow, humans know this, especially once a book like the Bible points it out. When humans work to change this world, both collectively and personally, toward the way it is supposed to be, they come into contact with something that helps them, that comforts them, that consoles them and sometimes “speaks” to them. That is, there is communication. Humans begin to see the world as it is supposed to be. This force does not change nature. It does not work that way. And it does not always act. The Hebrews were slaves in Egypt four hundred years before Moses. Their cries were not answered during that time. Those slaves died as slaves. When humans try to bring a new world into being on their own, the results are failure and sometimes catastrophic violence. This is utopianism. But instead, when humans work with this power, or better yet, allow this power to work through them, the results can be spectacular. I have previously called this a tilt in the universe toward the good and the weak. But that formulation does not seem right. A tilt does not comfort. A tilt does not communicate. But, on the other hand, a personal God is just a big and wonderful human being, which is not right either. So I will just leave it as a powerful force at the heart of reality sometimes experienced as personal. Rabbi Mordecai Kaplan said something like this. He called God the power that makes for salvation. We just have to remember that salvation is never an end, but a process.
The Framework of Hallowed Secularism
•
85
You can now see that the disagreement between atheism and religion is not really about the existence of God. It is instead about the nature of reality. The word God can sometimes be a shorthand way of claiming a kind of meaningfulness and order in the universe. To that extent lawyers and judges are arrogant to think of restricting claims about God in public proclomations, such as the Pledge of Allegiance. For these references to God are not just “religious” claims but are assertions about how things are. Every people must decide what is ultimately true about the way things are. Atheists imagine that politics can be separated from that decision. They do not understand that a decision about the nature of reality is behind every political act.
The Future The prior section foreshadows what the future holds. The question is, what can we hope for? If I am right about reality, we cannot hope for an end to death or the final establishment of the Kingdom of God. These things are never to be. It is the lack of this hope, or one like it, that Peter Beinart, the political writer, sensed in an Internet posting he wrote for The New Republic in August 2007. Beinart noticed that the Democratic netroots, as he calls them—the liberal bloggers who have become such a force in the Democratic Party—are without much radical hope. They are not pressing for fundamental change. And neither is anyone else in our political life. Beinart is right about this, but he cannot say why this is. He is himself a moderate and is happy that there is no destructive utopianism around. Things after all are pretty good, especially if we elect Democrats. Universal health insurance and an end to the war in Iraq are all we should be concerned with. I know why there is no vision on the left. It is because the left is secular. That means there cannot be any real hope in the future. The future will be just like the past. Instead, Hallowed Secularism says that we can work toward the establishment of the Kingdom of God, with the understanding that, though we work toward it, this Kingdom is never finally established. It is always on the way. We are always helping, only helping, to bring it about. And in doing this work, we must be very careful to try to bring ourselves into alignment with the power in the universe that is at the heart of reality. We must genuinely try to pray Jesus’s prayer: not my will but yours. For if we do not, the dangerous forces we unleash can destroy the world. And what about my future, personally? Well, I am going to die, and that will be the end of me. So, whatever taste I am going to have of the eternal will have to be here and now.
86
•
Hallowed Secularism
And a taste is possible. The psalmist writes in Psalm 27:4, of his wish to dwell in the house of the Lord all his days: “One thing have I desired of the Lord, that I will seek after; that I may dwell in the house of the Lord all the days of my life, to behold the beauty of the Lord, and to inquire in his temple.” The writer does not ask for God’s presence after he dies. The touch and presence of the power of the universe is the highest, most intense good that there is in this life. We could call it a taste of the world to come. The rabbis never said with clarity whether the world to come is heaven or the messianic future or simply the unsayable. Clearly, the rabbis thought there was something beyond the taste. Unlike them, I think the taste of it is all there is. But, we can still seek that taste. We can live from it. I often wonder why religious schools advertise to parents their economic benefits—your child will be successful—or their loyalty benefits—your child will remain a Jew or a Catholic. Religious schools never advertise what they should be about. They should say, send your child here, and perhaps one day your child will know God’s presence and will work toward the establishment of the Kingdom. Actually, I know why such advertisements are not run. The world is filled with atheists. Some of them are parents. And some of them are in charge of religious schools. The presence of God is not guaranteed. The world was shocked when, in the summer of 2007, the letters of Mother Teresa revealed her spiritual loneliness almost her whole life. It was not granted to her to know the presence of the Nameless throughout her life. Yet, she was faithful to the Kingdom as well as she knew how to be. Mother Teresa is a good model for us. I do not mean her particular doctrines. Maybe she was wrong about those. I do not even mean her particular methods; maybe she misread everything. I mean that she is a model because she sought to bring the Kingdom closer, and she sought the presence of the divine in her own life. Now there is a future. All of the above—all of this chapter—may strike an atheist as pretty religious and not very secular. That is a debate all secularists should be having— not about the crusades or Islam, not about the harm of religion, but about the nature of reality.
CHAPTER 6
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
T
he categories employed here—democracy, economics, and law—are intended to capture all the ways that we act publicly, as a nation. The categories are sufficiently broad that everything can be placed within them. I begin with democracy because that is the broadest category of our shared public life. While I deal here with America, the implications are there for others to look at their societies in order to create Hallowed Secularism there.
Democracy As everyone knows, there are ways in which the American political system is not technically democratic. A minority of the people can elect the majority of the Senate, for example, since every state is allotted two senators. The Electoral College sometimes allows a presidential candidate with fewer overall votes to become president, as in 2000. In addition, five votes on the nondemocratic Supreme Court decide certain policy questions. But I am not referring to democracy in those terms. As I explained in Chapter 4, by democracy, I mean something else. I mean collective selfdetermination. In a free society with free communication of information and opinion, with regular expressions of formal public views such as voting, with limited tenure in office, and with an overall relationship of servant and master between government officials and the people, the people can decide or try to decide all the important issues of the day. This is collective self-determination. And it goes on all the time, not just at election time. This vision of an organic democracy, one in which informal decisions by the people are as important as formal elections, is not inconsistent with leadership by public officials, or even leadership by judges. In fact, political leadership, which often consists of taking necessary but unpopular action, is
88
•
Hallowed Secularism
one way that choices and issues are presented to the people for decision. President Franklin Roosevelt, for example, foresaw a war that most Americans wanted to avoid. Roosevelt prepared for this war as aggressively as he could despite popular opposition. That was his job as president. The fact that the war in Iraq is unpopular is not what condemns it; what condemns it is that it was a bad idea in the first place. None of this has to do directly with the issue of religion and democracy. I left religion out of the democratic context for the moment because I want to contrast any sort of conception of collective decision by the people, including a purely secular one, with the extreme individualism of the New Atheism’s understanding of political life. The New Atheism has no idea of democracy. In August 2007, Mark Lilla wrote a New York Times Magazine article titled “The Politics of God.” The article was more or less a summary of Lilla’s new book, The Stillborn God. Lilla’s basic idea was that the Western separation of church and state protects us from killing each other over differing visions of ultimate salvation, which any religiously based political system, even one that is liberal and rational, will eventually lead to. The “Stillborn God” of the title refers to the failure of the rational conception of God in the nineteenth century to inspire religious life or to restrain religiously motivated violence. According to Lilla, non-Western people, primarily Muslims, are not lucky enough to enjoy this separation of religion from political life; therefore they are subject to irrational religious violence. We Westerners are always in danger of losing our way and returning religion to political life, despite the threat that religion represents. Lilla is a fair representative figure of the New Atheism, and his work is well received in these circles. The point for me in looking at Lilla is to demonstrate how truncated political life must become in order to avoid religion. Here is Lilla’s conclusion, in which he describes what he claims is our politics: “We have made a choice . . . [W]e have chosen to limit our politics to protecting individuals from the worst harms they can inflict on one another, to securing fundamental liberties and providing for their basic welfare, while leaving their spiritual destinies in their own hands. We have wagered that it is wiser to beware the forces unleashed by the Bible’s messianic promise than to try exploiting them for the public good.” Lilla’s description of our politics is just wrong. We have not limited politics to prohibiting individual harms without endorsing conceptions of the good. None of our serious political issues fit into Lilla’s conception of political life. In the case of abortion, for example, one might say that it is a matter of fundamental liberty. However, the law still must decide between abortion and infanticide, which would not be a matter of a woman’s fundamental liberty. Infanticide, according to Lilla’s categories, would be a matter of harming others.
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
89
The distinction between legal abortion and illegal infanticide can only be made by deciding at what point a person joins the political community: at conception, at birth, or some other point. If the mother gets to choose, there will still be a point when she loses her choice. You cannot get away from the question of who is a human being. This fundamental question is why slavery could not ultimately be compromised. No separation of church and state could avoid the question of the humanity of the slave. It was a question of ultimate values. How about the question of whether there should be redistribution of income through progressive taxation? To decide that issue, you have to decide whether it is good for people to live in a society of extreme divisions between the rich and the poor. You also have to decide whether the property a person earns belongs to that person in a fundamental way. Is property something a person holds or something that defines a person? Is property private, or is it social? How about the question of whether prostitution should be legal? Or heroin? Here, you must decide whether uses of freedom that degrade human personality should be permitted. Or, in perhaps the most extreme example, how about the decision that it would be better to use atomic weapons that might destroy all or most human life than to allow the Soviet Union to take over the world? That decision involved a commitment by the American people that there are some things worth dying for and killing for. Yet none of these decisions are religious in any traditional sense. They are simply and inescapably political decisions. Ultimately, these matters are what politics is about—deep conceptions of the good that we struggle over. Attempts by liberal thinkers to imagine a state that is neutral about defining the good life have always failed and always will fail. It is true that any conception of the good life that is worth dying for can lead to conflict and violence, as Lilla suggests. That, unfortunately, is the nature of political life, and as Lilla says about religious societies, we must find the resources not to kill each other over rival conceptions of the good. The only way to achieve the political peace that Lilla envisions is to abandon political life altogether and to live simply as individuals, surrendering to whatever dominant forces control a society. That can be done in America. One simply works, shops, and goes to sporting events. But that is not democracy. The inadequacy of Lilla’s conception of secular political life is helpful because it eliminates the need to justify democracy in Hallowed Secularism as a search for the good. All politics is a collective search for the good. Hallowed Secularism simply approaches that task in a particular way.
90
•
Hallowed Secularism
What is that way? The heart of democracy, as John Dewey wrote in The Ethics of Democracy, is the radical commitment to equality, in which every individual has the means to achieve personhood and realize his or her unique capacities. For Dewey, this achievement required an ethical economic life and a social life of solidarity as well as individual liberty. The Torah’s word for such conditions of material life is not equality but tzedeck, often translated as “justice.” Deuteronomy 16:20 says, “Justice, Justice shall you pursue, that you may live, and inherit the land which the Lord your God gives you.” Justice is the starting point of the politics of Hallowed Secularism, for only with justice can democracy even begin. But the collective commitment to justice is only a starting point. Democracy is a continuing and overarching task. A democratic people must decide what reality is. This includes deciding the nature of human beings, a philosophy of history, the definition of the good life, and so on. All this is necessary to know what justice requires. A democratic people living Hallowed Secularism will answer these fundamental questions in accordance with the wisdom and teachings of Our Religions. In America, that means starting with the Bible. I know that is a controversial suggestion, but for now I am more interested in what the Bible actually says about political life than in justifying its formative role. That role for the Bible will either emerge on its own or it will not. There are two quite different implications concerning religion and public life that can be drawn from the biblical tradition. One is that faith is essentially apolitical until and unless the political authorities transgress fundamental human norms. This is the view Pope Benedict seems to take, at least at one point, in his book Jesus, in which he calls Christianity “apolitical” and describes it as acknowledging the legitimacy of governing authorities. Perhaps this is a view born of coexistence with the Roman Empire in the church’s early history. The quote above from Deuteronomy concerning justice, however, takes a very different starting point. Here, the people as a whole are instructed to create a just society in accordance with God’s law. There is no possible distinction in this understanding between politics and religion. There is, in other words, no separation of church and state at the level of the just society. For me it is Deuteronomy that represents the sounder view of politics. In a democracy, the people are responsible for everything that goes on. They must seek justice both at home and abroad in all that their nation does. Lilla would object that people do not agree about what justice requires. This will be true in Hallowed Secularism as well, of course. But there does not need to be agreement about the content of the pursuit of justice and the meaning of life. All that is needed for democracy to flourish is agreement that the pursuit of justice is a proper subject of political life and that protection of
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
91
the vulnerable is the core of justice. We may not agree, for example, precisely what we owe to future generations in regard to the use of the earth. But justice prohibits asserting that our needs are all that should be taken into account. That is an important starting point for democracy. The struggle over actual outcomes is what political life does. No legitimate conception of political life can eliminate that struggle. Although people will not agree and will struggle over the requirements of justice, Deuteronomy insists that justice is not a matter of opinion. There are consequences to getting justice wrong; specifically in Deuteronomy, you lose the land. There are two implications here for our politics. First, the land, the nation in which we live, is a gift. We did not earn the right to be here, nor did we earn the right to be part of this political commonwealth. We do not own America. Second, the gift can be rescinded. This kind of judgment is not a matter of supernaturalism. It is a matter of the power of justice and the harm of injustice. Reality is constructed in such a way that injustice eats away at the foundations of any human society. This understanding of reality is part of the political commitment of Hallowed Secularism. All of the above is about political substance. But what about the style of democracy? If Americans are to be like the ancient Hebrews in coming close to the power at the heart of the universe, then the American people must, like the Hebrews, have ceremonies that celebrate their life together as a people. Some of the rudiments of a potential democratic ritual life are already present in America. Obviously, Thanksgiving is one, July Fourth is another, and Memorial Day is yet another. Some people celebrate the Constitution. Unfortunately, the inauguration of the president partakes of party politics and therefore cannot serve the unifying purpose of democratic ritual. There is not much else in our current national life. Dewey is no help here. He is short on the rituals of democracy. I will return to this theme of ritual and prayer in Hallowed Secularism in the next chapter. Partly this is the same problem that Hallowed Secularism has in general: it is not an actual religion. Plus, without a clear conception of a personal God, prayer life is awkward in Hallowed Democracy. Nevertheless, I can say that Hallowed Secularism requires a much more robust sense of democratic life than America currently experiences. Furthermore, democracy must be led back to its religious roots in order to nourish the political life of the people. This is what Hallowed Secularism aims to do. I have been assuming that people can think and talk about their collective lives in meaningful ways. Some thinkers on the left, however, are now questioning the possibility of meaningful political discourse. There are a number of political writers, most recently Drew Westen in The Political
92
•
Hallowed Secularism
Brain, who argue that rational political discourse is a cover for various psychological needs in the public. In Westen’s book, this psychological need is to make us feel good. John Judis expanded this theme in The New Republic in August 2007, arguing that politics is a subconscious struggle against the fear of death. This view of politics seems to represent, at least in part, an excuse for past Democratic Party election losses. The party, it is said, is too intellectual, too rational. The Republicans are better at the psychological manipulation needed to win elections. This message is also present in political analysis, like that of Jeffrey Feldman in Framing the Debate, which suggests that framing an issue is the key to winning elections. These ideas are too broad to be wrong exactly. There is a sense in which all of our efforts in life are an attempt to come to terms with death. Unfortunately, accuracy is not the point of this political work. These authors are not trying to improve our democracy. Their point is that politics is inevitably psychological manipulation. These thinkers conclude that voters do not actually know what they are voting about. I assume something very different. I assume that political discourse is meaningful on its own terms. When I say politics is rational, I do not mean that it is merely instrumentalist, nor do I mean that it is mere self-interest. I mean that the voters do know in a general way what they are doing. If their emotions are engaged, it is only because that is how human beings live. If the fear of death is in play, that is only because we know we are mortal. Of course, there is such a thing as persuasive discourse. And politicians, like trial lawyers, do put their arguments in the most persuasive package they can. But we assume in the courtroom that trial tactics only go so far. We assume that, at some point, the facts decide the matter. That is true in politics, too. The Democratic Party lost its majority status after 1968 for many reasons. People certainly will disagree about what happened and why. But there were reasons for this political change. It was not just image. Like trials, politics is ultimately about something real in the world. Good presentation only gets you so far. This new political irrationalism, which asserts that politics is unthinking psychology and rhetoric, is another form of atheism. It is another way to say that we live in a world of chaos and meaninglessness. Hallowed Secularism and Our Religions both deny that this is so. There is a world. We can meet as equals to talk about what the world is, why it is, and how it should be.
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
93
Economics The Baal Shem Tov, the eighteenth-century founder of the Chasidic movement in Judaism, once said that people are not usually tempted into evil that their society condemns. He was writing about Jews who lose the sense of God’s presence through overzealous study of religious law. Instead, we lose our way through temptations that are socially acceptable but lead us away from God. This is what has happened to religion in America with regard to wealth. A Christian, for example, would not usually be tempted to kill, become a drug addict, or rob a bank. But Christians are seduced into imagining that the pursuit of wealth and the message of Jesus are compatible. That is wrong. Jesus was very specific about material things. Beyond a certain point of material comfort, which Jesus called “our daily bread,” the pursuit of wealth moves one away from God—“No one can serve two masters . . . You cannot serve God and mammon” (Mt 6:24). The actual achievement of riches virtually disqualifies one from salvation—“It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God” (Mt 19:24). I know the devil can quote scripture, but I am not taking a cheap shot at the rich. Jesus was consistent about money. That condemnation was part of the core of his message. Astonishingly, there is a whole movement in America called the Gospel of Prosperity, in which belief in Jesus Christ promises material gain. This idea is now spreading around the world. My point, though, is not about fringe Christian movements. Rather, it is about how mainstream religion in the West has come to accept the dominance of economics over everything else. Our orientation is to production and consumption. We think about jobs and goods. America has become a nation of shoppers. Here is an example of world of economics as our dominant frame of reference. Christmas in America has become a grotesque, commercial orgy that has little to do with the birth of Christ. It has become instead the key foundation for retail prosperity. In fact, the growth of the American economy may be said to depend on Christmas sales. But, despite occasional warmhearted blather about putting Christ back into Christmas, no mainstream Christian denomination—not Catholic, not mainstream Protestant, not Evangelical, no one—would dare to put a simple dollar limit on what Christians are allowed to spend on Christmas presents. Such a limit would make great sense because Christmas giving distracts the faithful from the message of the season. Plus, the pressure of giving harms the poor and the working class. But even stating the idea shows its absurdity. Such a thing is not going to happen.
94
•
Hallowed Secularism
I could have come up with an example from Judaism, too. The only reason I did not was the old canard about Jews and money. The truth is that Our Religions in America worship material gain. Christmas is just the most dramatic example of the dominance today of economics over everything else. The British author Tony Judt recently put this very simply: “We live in an economic age.” In this light, the prior section on democracy seems naïve because the social solidarity that radical democracy requires is not currently a cultural option. We do not think about matters that way any more. We think about products. Here is another example of the dominance of economic thinking. Dr. Leon Kass, an expert on bioethics and, by all accounts, a very good person, wrote a commentary on Genesis called The Beginning of Wisdom. However, he devotes only a short space in 666 pages to the Sabbath, a key subject in Judaism that is introduced in Genesis. The short treatment he does give the Sabbath is primarily about separation, holiness, and awe. Those are good things—in fact, this book is about those things—but they are not the most important things about the Sabbath. The most important thing about the Sabbath is rest. Without the Sabbath, man would be a beast of burden. We would work 24/7 every week of the year. The Sabbath is a critique of precisely the kind economic system we are now developing. That economic system increasingly does require work 24/7, and it has in fact obliterated the Sabbath in America. But Kass does not write about this. I do not think he sees it. When I found out that Kass is associated with the American Enterprise Institute, I made a point of looking to see how he would treat Sabbath, and he did so exactly as you would expect a capitalist to do: as moral suasion rather than as criticism of capitalism. A moral Sabbath is the sort of Sabbath you get in a world dominated by material goods. You do not get a critique of capitalist economics. The dominance of economic life has become so pronounced that its manifestations do not strike us as odd anymore. For example, the New York Times Magazine now often has a section on marketing. People go on vacation in part to shop. National newsmagazines rate products. This has all occurred in the last thirty years. But my favorite example of the dominance of economics is a recent Sports Illustrated reference in its “Sign of the Apocalypse” column, which is a weekly celebration of the absurd. A sports team in England could not convince free agents to sign with the team because the shopping in that town was subpar. I suppose I should be glad that the magazine at least thought that this was absurd.
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
95
It is not just the sheer presence of material goods that is alarming; the way economics looks at human nature is now treated as an adequate account of what it means to be human. Thus Freakonomics by Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner was a big hit. The book explains much of life by reference to hidden incentives, thus fostering the view of human beings as self-interested, rational decision makers. Since economists love to tweak conventional moral wisdom, this way of thinking soon led to the book More Sex is Safer Sex by Steven Landsburg, in which the author argues, among other counterintuitive positions, that chastity contributes to the spread of AIDS. This is also why New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg’s plan of offering cash incentives to low-income students for good grades and classroom attendance seemed plausible. I do not mean by these examples to criticize the notion that economic thinking can help solve social problems. It obviously can and does. That is why caps and tradeoffs in environmental policy often improve outcomes compared to regulation. But the economic view of human beings takes only a part of human nature for the whole. The economic view of human nature is seriously harmful when treated as the sole truth of human life. Human beings do not need incentives to live meaningful lives. Or, if they do, if rational self-interest is the truth of human life, the emphasis on self-sacrifice in Christianity dooms it to irrelevance. It is true that Christianity spread in the Roman Empire, in part, as Ramsay MacMullen has argued, by the promise of salvation and the presence of healing, which are both powerful incentives. So, to that extent, early Christianity might be said to be consistent with economics. But serious Christians know that salvation is not possible unless it comes from the love of Christ; salvation cannot come from expectation of gain. Hallowed Secularism, which cannot even promise heaven but can deliver only a life of meaning, is ruled out by economics as a way of life. Christian theologians have been bitter critics of capitalism in general and the world’s current economic organization in particular. Jurgen Moltmann, just as an example, writes powerfully of the will to dominate that distinguishes the West, including its economic and technological organization. He writes of the effect of Western economics on the developing world and on nature. There are many examples of such religious critiques. But this theology has not reached the pews. What has been the actual economic performance of this economic worldview? Has it brought prosperity to people? The answer is that, to some extent, it has. The West is wealthy by any historic standard. In the developing world, millions of people have been brought out of poverty. Yet, increasingly, the economic system is failing to deliver its gains to the majority of human beings. Development is uneven worldwide, with Asia prospering much more
96
•
Hallowed Secularism
than Latin America and Africa. Within the success stories of China and India, as another example, massive rural poverty persists. In America we see an increasing divide not only between the rich and the poor but also between the super rich and everyone else. While average wages grow very slowly, the salaries of CEOs grow at an accelerating rate. Because the costs of medical care and other necessities also increase faster than wages, average people must work longer hours, additional jobs, and outside the home, despite having young children, to make up for the lack of growth in wages. What we have in America today is a nation that does not feel its prosperity. It does not help popular morale to read that the sixtieth birthday party of Stephen Schwarzman, the chairman of Blackstone Group, cost five million dollars and that, when the private equity company he founded went public, he earned around $600 million. Then, there is hedge fund manager Edward S. Lampert, who, in 2004, made $1.02 billion. Often it is said of the ancient world that the wealth of the privileged classes was carried on the backs of the peasantry, who did not really share in that wealth. That is how it increasingly seems to be today in America. The bursting of the subprime lending bubble has led to numerous bankruptcies by ordinary people. Somehow, the rating companies, which made large profits from the exaggerated values assigned to mortgage instruments, do not seem to be paying much of a price. If they do, I assure you they will be bailed out with only token firings of management. Our world is a stacked deck in favor of the wealthy and the insiders. All this is criticism, but what does Hallowed Secularism actually offer economically? I cannot describe an economic system that does not yet exist, but I can set forth four starting points. First, economics must serve larger purposes, not simply feed an unending lust for material goods. Prosperity is fine until it becomes the purpose of life. A society committed to money and things will never achieve satisfaction. There will always be the need for more, nor will such a society ever live in peace with the world—either the natural world or other people. Such a society will always need too much. The second point is the requirement of economic security. Some marketoriented thinkers actually want workers to be insecure as a goad to efficient production. The hero of these market people is the entrepreneur who risks all to make a lot of money. That is why they want to privatize social security and to leave medical insurance to a private system. But normal people want to relax. They do not want this goad of living on the edge of disaster. Jesus said not to worry about material things because God would provide them. The way God has provided them is by making us wealthy enough to take some of the economic worry out of life. Without going into detail, that seems to
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
97
require a society-wide retirement system, like social security, and universal healthcare in some form. Such a proposal would also aid the competitiveness of American companies, but that subject is beyond my scope in this book. The third point is the need for economic democracy—what Dewey called industrial democracy. People need more of a say in the economic direction of their society. This can happen in a number of different ways—from greater government oversight of the economy, to laws requiring notifying workers of plant closings, to empowering shareholders. But we must stop looking at economic life as something other than public policy. Wealth is not a private matter. It always rests on a public foundation, whether that foundation is an educated workforce or a low crime rate or simply social peace. Taxation is not theft. It is more true to say that income is theft or at least that one’s income is dependent on the cooperation of others. It is never my own income. Sometimes that cooperation is bartered directly between people, like when I pay someone to work for me. More often it is a background cooperation, like the road my trucks use. Even when cooperation is directly bartered, I rely on the general orderliness of society and the goodwill of promise keeping. Economics is the most social of enterprises. Fourth, there is a need for greater economic equality. We need a little socialism. There will always be rich and poor, but intelligent public policy spreads the wealth around. Such redistribution is fair and is also likely to produce more prosperity for everyone, including the rich. It also creates the necessary social solidarity for democracy to work. In other words, it is in the interest of the wealthy themselves that the wealth be shared, as they should have learned by now. Beyond these commitments, what will the economic system of Hallowed Secularism be like? No doubt it will be basically market-oriented. That system has worked well and is much more likely to work well compared to any other economic system. Plus, the market is merely a system of production and first-order distribution. The market does not prevent us from redistributing wealth, nor does the market require that we value material things beyond everything else. We have fallen into the error of a certain kind of economic thinking. That is what economics in Hallowed Secularism needs to correct.
Law Law as now understood in America has an antidemocratic tone. Courts are celebrated for their antimajoritarian role. Courts are said to protect the minority against the injustices of the majority. Law schools and courts perpetrate the myth of the politics-free judiciary. That is where the antidemocratic tone originates.
98
•
Hallowed Secularism
Surprisingly, then, it is actually easy to show that law is not antidemocratic. Elections indirectly decide the makeup of the Supreme Court and thus the content of its decisions. The Court follows the election returns. As John Rawls once said, the Supreme Court decides what the people allow it to. The public hears a lot about method as a constraint on constitutional interpretation. Conservatives and liberals wrangle over proper reasoning by the Court. We hear about “strict construction” by judges, for example. What the public hears is not true. Law, like any other aspect of political life, is not about method but about outcome. You can tell that by the example of one well-known proponent of judicial restraint, the conservative Federalist Society. As far as I have seen, the society treated with silence the Supreme Court’s invasion of the political realm in the 2000 presidential election, in the Bush v. Gore decision. Because they favored the election of George Bush, they said nothing about the Court’s overreaching even though, based on their stated philosophy against judicial activism, they should have opposed the Court’s entering the case. According to their approach, the matter of which Florida electors to recognize should have been left to the Florida legislature and Congress. The 2000 presidential election perfectly illustrates America’s cult of the apolitical Supreme Court. For years conservatives warned liberals not to rely on courts because doing so would lessen the democratic instincts of the people. This has happened. The 2000 election should have been left to the political system to sort out. George Bush would certainly have been elected anyway and his legitimacy assured. We will not worry about judicial method here. The constitutional matters that are at stake for our purposes are not clearly decided by text or by history anyway. Arguments about methods of interpreting the Constitution are just a distraction. What are these constitutional matters? That is, in what sense is Supreme Court constitutional doctrine an impediment to Hallowed Secularism? The impediment is that constitutional law is currently excessively individualist, capitalist, and atheist. All this must be modified to achieve Hallowed Secularism, and that can easily be done. As to individualism, Hallowed Secularism requires that we regard ourselves as a people, as an organic whole. Democracy itself requires that. In contrast, the Supreme Court sees us as a collection of individuals. In part, this is a structural flaw in our legal system. That system is based largely on cases being brought by individuals. Plus, the rights tradition itself, such as the right of free speech or to be free from unreasonable searches, draws its strength from individualism.
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
99
The Court exacerbates these tendencies toward individualism by refusing to look at issues from a group perspective even when a collective view is strongly suggested by the legal materials. For example, police searches are a collective issue. The privacy of all is threatened by police overzealousness. Yet the case law emphasizes the individual’s privacy interest in deciding whether the result of a search can even be challenged. As another example, race discrimination is clearly a group harm. Yet if race discrimination is proved, group remedies are disfavored. Of course, there are countervailing justifications for these approaches. I am here simply trying to highlight the individualist perspective of constitutional law. Another example of individualism is the Court’s inability to see any relevant groupings of people other than the government and the individual. The Court cannot see civil society, in other words. So, for example, in deciding about prayer at a public high school graduation ceremony, the Court asks only about the “government prayer” being imposed on an individual—student, parent, or whomever—in the audience. Aside from what ought to be the rule about prayer, which we will return to below, this division of the world into government and individual is incomplete. The parents who want the graduation ceremony to include prayer are neither the government nor a collection of individuals. Because such groupings of parents are literally invisible to the law, the outcomes of these prayer cases have been wooden and unsatisfactory. A second way in which constitutional doctrine obstructs Hallowed Secularism is the Supreme Court’s commitment to capitalism. Hallowed Secularism requires at least some skepticism concerning the primacy of property. In part, the promotion of capitalism is another aspect of the Court’s individualism. For example, the Court sometimes gives priority to private property over the needs of the collective. In a well-known case, Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council, a man bought beachfront property to build a house. But, before he could do so, South Carolina passed an antierosion law that essentially forbade all development of the property. The United States Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Antonin Scalia, reversed the State Supreme Court, potentially ordering more than a million dollars paid to the landowner as just compensation for the loss of the use of his property. In other words, even though, as we shall assume here, the law was passed in good faith and the development threatened to erode the beach, the taxpayers had to pay the man to prevent him from using his property in a way that would harm others. Why was it not just the man’s bad luck that he bought eroding property? Surely he knew that antierosion laws were being tightened. Two recent changes in free speech law also strengthen capitalist control over the political system. The Court seems to have finally concluded that
100
•
Hallowed Secularism
money is speech. It is likely, therefore, that almost all campaign finance restrictions will be held to be unconstitutional. This means that rich people will continue to have a disproportionate influence on political life. This expansive reading of the free speech clause of the First Amendment is probably not justified by the history of the clause. Still, rich people have rights, too. Therefore, their political speech should be protected. If that threatens democracy, so does restricting their speech. The real threat to democratic life lies in the combination of the money-equals-speech doctrine with the bizarre and indefensible doctrine that corporations have constitutional rights. Corporations are creatures of law. They are not persons. There is no way by text or by history—the two supposed sources of conservative constitutional thinking—to justify the expansion of constitutional rights to corporations. The idea that corporations have rights is a very late judicial invention. Corporations, with their enormous funds, eternal life, and complete lack of human conscience, are a danger to our collective democracy. Just look at the cigarette companies’ campaign of dishonesty about the health effects of smoking and ExxonMobil’s funding of lies about global warming. It takes a corporation to lie that well. Corporations have been deemed to have rights not because this holding is required by the Constitution but because this holding helps powerful economic interests prevent government regulation of economic life. A second late, procapitalist speech doctrine is the idea that commercial advertising is free speech protected by the First Amendment. Traditionally, advertising was just the proposal of a sale and could be regulated like any other aspect of the market. But, beginning in 1976, the Supreme Court began to protect pure commercial messages from government regulation. This is part of the reason that drug companies are now badgering people in ads to pressure their doctors to prescribe medications people do not need. This is the reason Massachusetts was denied the authority to regulate tobacco ads near schoolyards. To his credit, then-Justice William Rehnquist warned that the result of these decisions would be advertising for prescription drugs, but many people did not take his warnings seriously. The American people cannot take their country back and reconsider the relationship of capitalism and democracy until commercial advertising loses its falsely prestigious position as free speech. Of course, this is another area in which granting constitutional rights to corporations makes the situation all the worse. It will come as no surprise to readers that I next accuse the Court of atheism. People have been blaming the Court for years for taking prayer and God out of the public schools. But I want to begin with a different line of cases. In 1990, in Employment Division v. Smith, Justice Scalia dismayed many of his
The Public Life of Hallowed Secularism
•
101
admirers by writing an ahistorical opinion holding that the government could completely limit religious practice as long as the law applied generally and not just to religious activities. So, for example, a Prohibition law restricting all use of alcohol need not make any exception for Christians and Jews who use wine in religious ceremonies. Indeed, Smith itself was a case very much like that, in which members of a Native American Church used peyote, which is a traditional part of their religious practice and yet was illegal. Smith was a surprising case, not so much because of its outcome—the plaintiffs worked for a drug rehabilitation organization and so being fired was no shock. What was surprising in Smith was the lack of weight given to the free exercise of religion clause in the First Amendment. In other rights contexts, such as free speech, the effects of government regulation are looked at, not just whether the government is regulating speech as such. Regulating speech is just a factor in the legal analysis. But with regard to religion, effects on ritual practice are irrelevant under Smith unless the government is regulating religion as such. Exercise of religion is thus a second-class right. Smith was an odd decision rendered by an unusual majority. However, attempts by Congress to overturn it have had only limited success. I keep waiting for a presidential candidate to run against Smith and promise a Supreme Court that will defend religion, as the text of the Constitution seems to promise. Smith is a kind of atheism in practice that denigrates religion. We come finally to the area of constitutional law most directly affecting Hallowed Secularism—the prohibition on the establishment of religion. Under the influence of Thomas Jefferson’s metaphor—the wall of separation between church and state—the Court has said that government must be neutral about religion and may not promote it. This principle led to the prohibition of prayer and Bible reading in the public schools. Obviously, the principle of government neutrality toward religion is in some degree of tension with Hallowed Secularism. That is because the Court does not know when something is a religious belief or practice and