Exploring Visual Culture ~
Diflnitions, Concepts, Contexts
Edited by Matthew Rampley,;\''
Edinburgh University Press...
308 downloads
4359 Views
19MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Exploring Visual Culture ~
Diflnitions, Concepts, Contexts
Edited by Matthew Rampley,;\''<:~'
'\!J'
Ú ",/¿ r;1
':,reca;-, (>
Edinburgh University Press
rp t13,S .e.élS © in this edition Edinburgh University Press, 2005 © in the indivielual contributions is retained by the authors Eelinburgh Uni versity Press Ltd 22 George Square, Eelinburgh Typeset in 11.5! 13.5 Perpetua by Ser vis Filmsetting Ltd, Manchester, and Printeel and bound in Spain by GraphyCems A CIP recorel for this book is available fram the British Library ISBN O 7486 18457 (paperback) The right of the contributors to be identified as dUthorS of this work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Dcsigns and Patents Act 1988.
Every c1fort has been maele to trace the copyright holders, but if any have been inaelvertently overlooked, the publisher wi/l be pleased to make the necessary drrangements at the first opportunity.
Acknowledgements List of Figures Contributors Introduction Matthew Rampley
Visual Culture and ti Matthew Rampley
2 Def1nitions of Art an Neil MulholIand
3 Concepts of Craft Juliette MacDonald
4 Design and Modern Juliette MacDonald
5 Fashion: Style, Identi Fiona Anderson
Contents
Acknowledgements List of Figures Contributors
VII VIII XII
Introduction Matthew Rampley
Visual Culture and the Meanings of Culture Matthew Rampley
5
2 Definitions of Art arrel the Art World Neil MulholJand
18
3 Concepts of Craft
34
Juliette MacDonald
4 Design and Modero Culture Juliette MacDonald
so
5 Fashion: Style, Identity and Meaning Fiona Anderson
67
vi
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
6 Photography and Film
85
Glyn Davis
7 Architecture and Visual Culture
102
Richard Williams
8 Representation and the Idea of Realism
117
Neil Mulholland
9 Visual Rhetoric
133
Matthew Rampley
10 The Rise and Fall and Rise of the Author
149
Matthew Rampley
11 The Ideology of the Visual
163
G!yn Davis
12 Visual Practices in the Age ofIndustry
179
Matthew Rampley
13 Technical Reproduction and its Significance
There are many peop acknowledged. These
197
Ruth Pelzer
14 From Mass Media to Cyberculture
214
Glyn Davis
15 Visual Culture and its Institutions
Zurbrugg. Thanks are for supporting this pn
229
Fiona Anderson
Index
Richard Braine, Nick
Sutherland Hussey An Reay -Young, Alison
It is also importan1 whose indirect contri] be mentioned. They ir
246
David Michael Clark, McRobbie, Keith Mo Glass and Peter York. Lastly, thanks are d unstinting patience an
Acknowledgements
There are many people whose role in the development of this book needs to be acknowledged. These include: Amy de la Haye, Corinne Day, Susan Babchick, Richard Braine, Nick Knight, Jake Harvey, CIen Onwin, Donald Urquhart and Sutherland Hussey Architects, Martin ElIiott, Janet Morton, Karin Muhlert, Helga Reay- Young, Alison Britton, Takashi Murakami, Paul Rennie and Nicholas Zurbrugg. Thanks are also due to the Research Board of Edinburgh College of Art for supporting this project.
It is also important to thank the various visitors to Edinburgh College of Art whose indirect contributions to this book, through debate and discussion, should be mentioned. They include: Judy Attfield, Rosemary Betterton, Norman Bryson, David Michael Clark, James Elkins, Michael Ano Holly, Hubert Locher, Angela McRobbie, Keith Moxey, Maria Orisková, Donald Preziosi, Charlotte Schoell Class and Peter York. Lastly, thanks are due to Sarah Edwards of Edinburgh University Press, whose unstinting patience and support have helped make this book possible.
r
List of Figures
4.4 ObsessionJor Me © Adbusters. 5.1 Richard Braine Braine-PYMCJ 5.2 Anonymous ph © Roger-VioU 5.3 Corinne Day, ~ Day. 5.4 Nick Knight, A Dazed and Corji
1.1 Carl Andre, Equivalenl V111 (1978). Tate Gallery, London. © DACS. 2.1 Martin Elliott, Tennis Girl (1970). © Martin Elliott. 2.2 Jeff Koons, Michael jackson and Bubbles (1988). San Francisco Museum of Modcrn Art. © Jeff Koons. 2.3 Morris Louis, Bela Lambda (1960) New York, Museum of Modern Art. © Photo Scala, Florence. 3.1 Janet Morton, Cozy (1999). Ward lsland, Toranto. Photograph © Bruce Duffy. 3.2 Alison Britton, Black and Green Pot (1999). Photograph courtesy of Barrett Marsden Gallery, London. 3.3 Caroline Broadhead, Suspend (2001). Photograph courtesy of Barrett Marsden Gallery, London. 3.4 Karin Muhlert, untitled small works from Sea Ce1l series (1999). Photograph © K. Muhlert. 3.5 Helga Reay-Young, Autumn Feelings. Photograph from installation at Cochrane Gallery, London (1999). 4.1 Our Dynamic Earth, Edinburgh. Author's photograph (2004). 4.2 Ettore Sotsass, CarIton Bookcase (1981). Photograph © MEMPHIS. 4.3 Philippe Starck,juicy SalifLemon Squeezer (1990). Author's photograph (2004).
8 19 20 25 42 44 45 46 47 52 59 60
6.1 Eugene Delacrl 6.2 Harold Edgert( Photograph COl 6.3 Paul Strand, m of the Paul StrJ Strand Archive 6.4 Richard Billing Photograph COI 6.5 Still from Geor © BH stills. 7.1 Bicycle shed, V photograph (2C 7.2 Lincoln Cathed Edinburgh Uni' 7.3 Ludwig Mies Vi Exhibition, Bar photograph (2C 7.4 Citroen DS21 ( 7.5 Frank Gehry, C (1991). Author 8.1 Gustave Courb 8.2 Takashi Murak, Poe. Reproduc Kaikai Kiki Co. 8.3 Georg Braun al (1582). Nation 9.1 Anonymous, A; From L'JIluslral 9.2 Edward McKru Photograph co
L1ST OF FIGURES
4.4 ObsessionJor Men. Fram Adbusters magazine (1993). Photograph
© Adbusters. 5.1 Richard Braine, The Roxy Club (1977). Photograph © Richard
Braine-PYMCA. 5.2 Anonymous photograph of a Parisian drapery store (ca. 1860).
© Roger- Viollet, Paris. 5.3 Corinne Day, Kate Moss, the Third Summer if Lave (1990). © Corinne
Day. 5.4 Nick Knight, Aimee Mullen wearing Alexander McQueen, fram
Dazed and Corifused Magazine (1998) © Nick Knight. 6.1 Eugene Delacroix, Odalisque (1857). Private collection. 6.2 Harold Edgerton, Shootina the Apple (1964).
Photograph courtesy of Gus Kayafas and Palm Press. 6.3 Paul Strand, Wall Street (1915). Philadelphia Museum of Art: Gift
of the Paul Strand Foundation. © Apcrture Foundation Inc., Paul
Strand Archive. 6.4 Richard Billingham, Untitled (1995). © Richard Billingham.
Photograph courtesy of Anthony Reynolds Gallery, London. 6.5 Still fram Georges Mélies' Voyaae to the Moon (1902).
© BH stills. 7.1 Bicycle shed, Western General Hospital, Edinburgh. Author's
photograph (2003). 7.2 Lincoln Cathedral, twelfth to fourteenth century. Photograph,
Edinburgh University. 7.3 Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, German pavilion at the International
Exhibition, Barcelona, (1928-9). Reconstructed 1986. Author's
photograph (2003). 7.4 Citraen DS21 (1972). Author's photograph (2003). 7.5 Frank Gehry, Chiat Day Mojo Advertisina Buildina, Venice, California
(1991). Author's photograph (2003). 8.1 Gustave Courbet, The Stonebreakers (1851). Now destrayed. 8.2 Takashi Murakami, Hiropon (1997). Photograph courtesy Blum &
Poe. Repraduced with permission. © 1997 Takashi Murakami/
Kaikai Kiki Co., Ltd. 8.3 Georg Braun and Franz Hogenberg, Map if the Ci~ if Edinburah
(1582). National Library of Scotland. 9.1 Anonymous, An Aerial Baptismfor Dancers]raID Indochina (1931).
From fIllustration magazine. 9.2 Edward McKnight- Kauffer, Advertisina PosterJor BP (1934).
Photograph courtesy of Paul Rennie.
IX
63
73
78
80
82
87
89
91
93
95
104
105
107
110
112
118
122
125
140
141
x
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
9.3 A window of a shoe shop in Paris, with a painting by Ingres as part 142
of the display. Photograph: Ruth Pelzer (2003). 9.4 Jacques Louis David, The Oath e:f the Horatii (1785). The Louvre,
143
Paris. 9.5 Marcel Breuer, Wassi{y armchair, Model B3. Dessau, Germany (late
1927 or early 1928). New York, Museum of Modern Art.
145
Photograph © photo SCALA, Florence. 10.1 Henry Fuseli, StudyJor Seif-Portrait (1780s). Photograph courtesy of
Victoria and Albert Museum, London. 150
11. 1 The front cover ofthe Sun newspaper, 26 November 1993.
Photograph courtesy of News International. 167
11.2 Jan Van Goyen, Ruined Church at E8mond van Zeefrom the East (1633).
Private coHection. 172
11.3 The hairy angler fish from The Blue Planet. Photograph © David Shalel
175
naturepl.com. 12.1 Josef Albers, Cover of the exhibition catalogue Machine Art, New York,
Museum of Modern Art (1934). Photograph © SCALA, Florence. 187
12.2 Illustrations 75 and 73 from Machine Art catalogue, New York,
Museum of Modern Art (1934). Photograph © SCALA Florence. 188
12.3 David E. Scherman, World's Fair Locomotive (1939). Photograph
courtesy of Time & Life Pictures. 189
13.1 Newspapers reporting 11 September 2001 on a newspaper stand
in London. Author's photograph. 201
13.2 Gustav Klucis, design for a postcard for the AH-Union Olympiad
in Moscow (Spartakiada) (1928). Photograph © State Museum of
Art, Riga, Latvia. 205
13.3 Robert Rauschenberg, Press (1960). © Robert Rauschenberg/VAGA,
New York/DACS, London 2004. 206
13.4 Postcards from a kiosk stand, Paris. Author's photograph. 208
13.5 T-shirt with detail from Michelangelo 's ceiling to the Sistine Chapel,
Vatican, Rome. Photograph: the author. 209
14.1 Ang Lee's Hulk (2003). Image © Universal Television and Networks
Group. 216
14.2 9 April 2003. A statue of Saddam Hussein being pulled down in
Baghdad's Firdus Square. Photograph courtesy of AP Photo/Koji
Harada, Kyoto. 222
15. 1 Walter Gropius, The Bauhaus, Dessau (1919). Photograph courtesy
of RIBA Library Photographs Collection. 233
15.2 Pavilion de L'Intransigent, architect Henri Favier, from the Paris
Exposition des Arts Decoratifs et Industriels of 1925. Photograph
courtesy of F. R. Yerbury I Architectural Association. 238
15.3 Skinhead outfit p Skinheads publica Image courtesy e
LlST üF FIGURES
XI
15.3 Skinhead outfit photographed for the Su1érs, Soulies, Skacers and Skinheads publication that was linked to the Streetstyle exhibition. Image courtesy of the V&A PictUTC Libraq'.
240
Contributors
Neil Mulholland i Edinburgh College 01'
rary art, criticism and ' ZUr
Kunst, Untitled and
Art in the Late 20th (em aJso curated Leayjna Gh
Ruth Pelzer is a [eeh As a practising artist he
printlnaking) and thc in practice. She has exhibil Mica, Portugal and So
Matthew Rampley i College 01' Art. His res,
and historiogTaphy of al
Res, Kritische Berichte, A Aes
Glyn Davis is a lecturcr in Sí.TCen theory and history at Edinhurgh CDllcgc uf iht. Thl' ('o-editor (\vith Ka)' Dickinson) of J:en TV (nFl. 2004-), his rescarch focuses on fépresentJtions üf gcnocf <md .sexudlit)' in tclc\'lsion and film, Recent "....ork indudes articles Oll 'Youth
Richard Williams is a has publishcd widcly on The AnxlOus 00' (ROUl
Urriversity Press, 2000).
CONTRIBUTORS
XIII
Neil Mulholland is a lccturcr in contcmporary art and visual culture at Edinburgh College al' Art. His research i5 currently centred 00 global contempo rar)' art, criticism and visual culture. He is a regular critic fOl" Frieze, Flash Art, Texte /'ur Kunst, UntJtled and Flux. Rcccnt work ¡neludes: The Cultural Deyolution: British A,t in the Late 20th Centu')' (Ashgate, 2003); E" ... Sh'ig!e)' (ChanneI4, 2003). He al 50 curatcd 1.eaving Glasl'egas at the Praguc Biennale (2003).
Ruth Pelzer 15 a iecturcr in art and visual culture at Edinhurgh CüIlcgc üf Art. As a practising arti5t her research focuses on reproductive technologies, especially printmaking, and thc interface het...."cen theorics of rcproduction and print-making practice. She has exhibited her \,'ork in exhibitions and galleries in Germany, South Afriea, Portugal and Seotland.
Matthe'w Rampley is director of thc Graduate Research School, Edinhurgh College of Art. His research has focused on aesthetic theory, and the philosophy and hislOriography of arl. He has published ...videl)' in journals sueh as Ari Histar)', Res, Kritisehe Bedehte, ATl Bulletin amI ¡-}(nd and ¡mage. Books inelude: l\iiet7sche, Aesthctlcs ami Madernl'J' (Cambridge University Press, 2000) and In Remembrance?f Things Past: On Ab)' H'arburg and H'alter Benjamin
(Harrassov~'itz,
2000).
Richard Williams is a lccturcr in art history at thc Univcrsit} ofEdinhurgh. He has published widel)' on late modern art and urban culture. Publications inelude: The Am-iaus Cit.y (Routledge, 2004) and .ytcr ,Hadan Swipturc (Manchester Univcrsit)' Prcss, 2000).
Introduction
Matthew Rampley
This book is an introduction to visual culture. Its aim is to explore the various forms uf visual culture, to analyse sorne of the key ideas used in lt5 interpretation and to outline sorne of the socíal contexts in which the forms of visual culture are produccd, distributed and consumecl. It is intended as a primer that traces the life of concepts that have become central to tJle engagement with visual culture, in arder then to point towards ongoing and possible future dehates surrounding their present and further use. As an introductor} text, it cloes not claim to give an exhaustive account of thc topies; it aims rather to highlight salicnt points and indi cate where the reader may wish to pursue more detailed and in-depth discwision. The term 'visual culture' has had considerable prominence ovcr the past five to ten ycars, and there are many excellent studics af the subject. 1 Why, then, acld another book to an already burgcuning Iist? There are various reasons. First. many studies oI' visual <.~ulture equate it ,"vith the study oI' the imagc. Indced, the stud), of ·visual culture has often heen sccn as ¡denticai to the theory oI' the image. \Vhcrc art history is concf'rned with paintings, drawings and engravings, the proponents
01' \"isual culture argue that what is necded i5 a recognition oI' the role oI' tJ1e much broacler range al' ímages. In an age where the majority of imagcs encountered will he photographs in magazines, on advertising hoardings, films, television and other technologies oI' mass-production and reproduction, including personal holida), photographs ancl, most recently, digital videos, thc traditianal concerns 01' art history have been seen as culturally elitist. Art long ago ceased to be the most important visual expression oI' cultural identity.
2
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
I I
Thcre is much force to this argument; while in Britain ano America the tcrm
i
'visual culture' (and 'visual studies') is most commOn, dsewhcre, in Franee and
secono reason is lo do
1
Germany fur cxamplc, the link betwccn 'visual studies ano the imagc is mane
range 01' possibilities I fOCllSCO on in this boa
cxplicit b;' the rise of so-called image theor)' or the science 01' the image
twined and have often
(Bildwisscnschaft in Gcrman).2 Thc authors of this book, however, helicvE:' that this
lS too narrow a focus. Not 001)' does art consist of practices other th.:m the making
ofimages
ane should mention sculpturc ano, more recently, in1\tallatLOIl or text
based conceptual art - but also material artefacts playa crucial part in the visual articulation ol' cultural nlues amI idcntit)'- These rangc from fashion designs to
I
I
in otht'r ways too. Eari' of art, f()r cxample; in:
its re]ation to art and it
roweo heavily from fil n
eraftcd objeds, designeo eommooities or buildings and entire dties. Indeeo, one
The study of visual approaches. These inch
could arGue that visual culture begins with the human hao", with bodil\'¡ aoornment b '
of ic1eoIogical intcrpelL:
and the language ofbodily gesture. Most of these practices are Llsually abscnt from
tcchnology; scmiologic
accoLlnts oí" visual culture, v,/ith thcir fOCLlS on the mass media of photography, tele
writings of Julia Krist(
vision, film ancl the Internet. J Wherc this hook attempts, in It5 own mode~t "vay,
Ettinger; the postcolon
to make an onginal eontriblltion to the Jield, therdore, IS in its interpretatiun 01'
not that these thcorie~
\\"hat the krm entails.
reterred to here. Howe
1t could be objected that such a notlon makes Visual culture an impossibl y broad
even principal methods
subj('ct. lndeed, visual culture c(Julo he expanded to includc othcr practices,
af the authors mentionl
induoing thcatre, opera, hallet, musical performances, tourism,landscapc design,
Tions
road ancl motorway dcsign, gardcning, spectator sports, haute cUlsine. AH of these
somethíng more than th
comprise,
a grcatcr or lesser extent, visual display. Thcre may \\"ell be other pos
tion to 'canonkal' theOI
sibilities. There js undoubtedly some truth in tms e/aim; visual culture might con
It is often argued th crosion of traoitional bo·
lO
sequ('ntly cneompass practically aer:yrhmg, ancl a thcory of cverything is neither
images
ano gil
possibk nor nccessarily clesirahlc. N everthelcss, given that the generation of visual
'archÜecture' , can no 10J
meaning involves complex interactions bet\\'een images ano material artcfaets, and that the various practiees uf visual culture frequently rdy on su eh interaetions,
the v.llues af popular cuJ 'high culture' opera)
exclusive attention to images is open to interrogation.
appear to struggle to su
Thc question then ariscs as to whcre onc ora\,·s the limits and why this book
same time it is prematu
focuses 'onl)" un design, crart, art, cinema, television, the Internet ancl arehitcc
romantic ideas of .lrt as
ture. [n one sense there is no such thing as visual culture. There is no cultural prac
are no longer credihle. f
ticL' that is entird)' visual. AH cultural praetlCcs fundion using a variet} of means,
view, thc division hetwel
involving visual perception amI communication, but al so others, such as hearing,
lo\\' art 1S a readily den
lanauaoc bodilvo ano tactilc expcrience ' ami taste. Fashion is meant not onlv.' to be b b'
endemic in Western soei
seen, but also to he worn on the body. An opera or concert of popular music is as
Boulez or Olivier Messia
much a visual spectacle as a musical experience. A film may oftcn involve spcctac
shO\v, fur example. Inde
ular visual dleets. but it also relies on a soundtrack, not to mentíon a narrative
practices ami social instit
seript and dialoguc hetween its cast. This hook often highlights ano analyscs those
CIl.'mre that they maintaiJ of formal education an
'non-visual' factors that inform the production ano consumption ofvisu.ll culture. Then' are two principal reasons why this hook foctlses on a narro\.\·cr sct of prac
\'enues and various pub:
tices. Thc hrst is pragmatic; given thc impossibility of pro\'iding an account of
Cotlncil separat(' [rom
c\'erything, this book limits it.~ subjcet matter to something more feaslble. The
galleries and dealers,
t SL
INTRODUCTION
3
sccond reason is to Jo with thc landscape of cultural practicC'. For amongst the vast
rangc al' possibilities the tcrm 'visual culture' might cncompass, the practices focused 00 in this hook have long shared histories. They have often beeo ioter n... .ined and have ohen borrowed [rom each ather, c.xmceptually. aestheticaHy and in other \vays too. Early thcories al' film were consistentl), modellcd 00 the theory uf art, for examplc; indced, a m<:ljor prcoccupation for earI)' dehates on film was its rclation to .1rt and it5 validity as an art formo More rccently, art theory has hor
rowed hcavily from film theor;'. The stuJy uf visual culture has come to be dominated by certaio thcoretical approaches. These indudc: Lacanian notions of the gaze; Louis Althusser's notíon ofideological interpellation; v~lalter Benjamín's conceptions of aura, fetishism ,1no technology; scmioJogicaJ conceptions 01' meaning and representation; the feminist writings of Julia Kristeva, Judith Butler, Luce lrigara)' and Rracha Lichtenberg Ettinger; the postcolonial writings of Ga)'atri Chakravurty Spivak and others. lt js not that thcse thcorics are unimportant; they undouhtedly are, and the)' are referred to here-. However, this book cloes not assume that these are the onl)' or even principal methods hy ""híl'h
Ool'
should explore visual culture.lm.leed, man)'
01' thc authors mentioned ahoye conccrn {10m
thcm,~elves
with solcly visual representa
ímages - and given that this hook undt'rstands visual culture as involving
something more than this, it is dear v\lhy it does not ncce-ssarily offcr an introduc tion to 'canonical' theorists in visual studies. Jt i:-; ufLen argued that the fluid statc of contcmporary society has Ice! to an
erosion ol' traditional bounclarics and conccpts. Older concepts, including 'art' and 'architccturc', can no longer be seen as hc:vond s('rutiny. particularly in anera \\·hen the values 01' popular culture seem to he ubiquitous and v,,,hen traditional forms 01' "high culture' opera, classic..11 music, avant-g.1rdc .1rt, experimental cinema appear to struggle to survivc cconomically. This is wldüubtl'dly true. hut al the same time it is prcmature lo speak 01' the end of high art, for example, cven if romantic ideas ol' art as somehO\'v standing aloaf from the rUn 01' popular culture are no longer creJihle. As James E1kins has argucd: 'From a sociologist's point of vie\v, the division betwrcn people \....ho adhere to high art and those who consume 1mv art is a readily demonstrahle f
statistically spcaking, the division is
endernic in West<'rn sodety.'4 The audienee for the musical eompositions of Pierre Boulez or Olivier Mcssiaen is Jistinct from the stue!io audiencc for the Jcrry Sprin8er shO\.. , foI' cxample. IndC'ed. art, or craft or arehitccture persist as distinct visual practices and social institutions. Even if they frequcntly interact, numerous Jactors cnsure that the;' maintain separate centres of grJvity. This bcgins with the procf'ss ol' formal cducation and continues on to professional associations, exhibition venues and various public bodies. The faet that there exists in Britain a Crafts Council scparate from the Arts Council, for cxample, ....·¡lh parallel networks of gallerics and dealers, suggests such a Jifference. Consequently, trus book also
-4
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
examines the ways in which the activities of visual culture are organised amI definen
both with and against each other, .lnd how dif[erent practices have emerged as social institutions.
1.
This book also makes its own cxclusions. It could aIso have included medical
imagcry, astronomical charts, scientific diagrams, the charts of statisticians. Therc have beco a number 01' important studies 01' these kinds of visual Tepresentations. 'i Yet, as Wilh the case o[ the other possib¡lities mentioncd earlier, attention to these
would make this book impossibly broacl and lacking coherence. Many of these rep resentatians are ticd to specific scientilic discoursc:'i, the anal)'Sis of those líes beyond thE' scope al' visual studics. In most cases this book will be referring to the yisual culture o[ Britain and America, as bcflts its role as an introduction for an English-speaking reader~hip. We readily acknowlcdge thc limitations of this approach. In a postcolonial context the problems that besct such a [ocus on the West are ver)' apparent. As Elkins has noted, visual studies has ),et to engage seriously with non-\\'estern cultures. 6 However, this book do es not and should not aim at an all-encompassing, encyclo paedic account; man)' ofthe social and historical dcyelopments that have impclled thc interest in visual culture are unique to Wcstern societies. It 15 doubt[ul that one coulrl or even should spcak of thc visual culture 0[, [or example, Mali, Inrlonesia or Zambia, as ir it were comparable to Western notions of visual culture. We there fore leave it for rcaders to decide the wa)'s in \\/hich the issues explorcd in this book might be applied to the undcrstanding of othcr cultures and societjes.
Of the various questio
edly the most compl,
Notes
meaning has be en inte
sorne sense of the po
2
4- S
6
Sorne of the more recent introductory books include: James Elkins, )'¡,oua! Studies: a SkeptJcaJ lnlH'JuctlOn (New Yurk and London, 1993); Richard Ho\'"rdls, ¡'HUO} Culture: an Introducuon (Clmbridge, 2003); Makolm Bacnard, Appw(Jches w VJsual CuJwre (London, 2001); Marita Sturken and Lisa Cartwrighl, Practl(fS dLookm,q: an lnlroductíon lO Visual CuiflJre (Oxford, 2001); Nicholas MirzuelJ, An lntroducciun 10 Visual Culture (London, 1999); John Walker and Sarah Chaplin, Viw,JI Culture. An fmroductlDn U...1anchester, 19q7). To this ¡ist one can also M"ld the recent\y establishC'd journall:?I VJSUo.1[ Culture (2002- ). See, for cxample, Hans Bdting, B1JJ-Anthrupolo8ie, Ent ... ii~fe fur eme BildJ-l.'is.I'ens.-h4t (Munich, 200 J ); Gernot Ri-)hmC', Theone des Ri/des (Munich, 1999); GottfricJ B
imrnersed immediate1y
to a more basic questio
The idea of culture has . linked inextTicably witl synonymous with cu]tw
will be explored in gro treated as having the sa
English language in th, number of other ideas,
!
still fundamental to hov arose partIy in response
partly as a result ofEnlil' sodety. but there was al:
l. Visual Culture and the Meanings of Culture Matthew Rampley
Introduction Of the various questions raised hy rhe emergent tield of visual studies, undoubt edl)' rhe most eomplcx is rhe understanding of rhe term 'visual culture'. Its meaning has he en interpreted in various ways. This chapter \-viII attempt to give sorne sense al' the possihlc meanings af rhe term, hut rather than becoming immerscd immediately in recent debates ahout rhe sense 01' ',,¡su,]l culture", ir turns to a more basic question: What 15 rhe meaning al' 'culture'?
Concepts of Culture The id ca uf culture has a complex histOT)', and debates abour its meaning have been linked inextricably with rhe parallel concept al' 'civilisation', regarded by many as synonyrnous wirh culture, and hy othcrs as its antithesis. The rdatian hctween them will be explored in grcater detail shortl)'. but for the time being the tv·m can be trcatcd as having the same sensc. The term 'culture' onl)' began to appear in the English language in thc late eighteenth century and (:ame into use alongside a number of othcr ideas, such as 'industry', 'dcmocracy', 'class' and 'art', which are still fundamental to hm\t societ)' is understood. 1 Within Britain the idea of culture arose partl), in response to the impact of thc Industrial Revolution in England and partir as a result of Enlightcnmcnt speculation on the origins and meaning ofhuman society, but thcrc was also a wider Europe
6
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
was .lIso .ln invention 01' the late eighteenth century, while in Franee the ter m 'cj"i!
ing efTeets of modern in,
isation' nrst appearcd in 1766. 2 Yct while thc ¡dea of culture ü; rclatively recent, the
MacDonald (1906-82) d
origin~
ofthc word are r.lther oklcr, for it comes [rom the Latin cultura.
Mass culture. argued Ma,
Cultura originally denoten the cultivation ofnature. This mal' seem distant from
above. lt is fabricated by·
the eontemporar), unrlcrstanding of culture, hut man)' tcrms associated with the
consumers, their particip .. ,'6 A similar critique
development of nature still function as metaphors for human society. The Dotion
of 'cultivatian' , originalIv¡ describlng land husbanrlrv, has long becn associ'lted with the rlcvdopment of the individual; being 'cultivatcd' orten implies a proccss of per sonal rdin('ment. Similarly, 'hrccrlíng' was traditionally used in Britain to denote .1
....
writers such as TheodoT stressed the role of mass
sivity in the audience, inc
thc establishment and preservation of a distin(:t class ioentity, This mctaphor also
creating 'false' needs for
underpinned the association of culture ami civilisation with progress ano refine~
audience from being able
ment. From the Enlightenrnl'nt onwanls, they ha\'(' heen sccn as a proo.'SS ol' devcl
mindless escapism. 7 We
1
opment and perfection, both of society as a whole and of the individual. As the
Arnold's concerns aboutt
French historian Fram;ois Guizot stated in On Civilisation in France (1829): 'the idea
tices still take place wit
of progress, of devclopment, seems to me to be the fundamental idea contained in
regarded as 'lower' than
the word "civilisation'" . j Furthcrmore, the mcaníng ol' 'culture' and 'ci"ilisation'
Godard or Krzysztof Kiei
has also been shaped by their implicit opposition to harbarism nr savagcry; wherc
Dumb and Dumber (1994),
civilisation is a proccss of retincment, 'saxagery' is the ra\\' state ol' nature or, liter
Harry Potter novels and fi example, the poetry of Jel
a]]", living in thc forest. 'Although 'culture' initially dcnoted a proccss - the intcllectual and spiritual cul
hierarchy aften feeds inte
tivation ol' an individual or social groups - it carne to be scc.'n in the nineteenth
be the recurrent argumen
centur)' in material terms. No longer a quality 01' individuals, culture consisted of
vision. particularly in the
the outcornes nf such (:ultivation: artworks, poems, philosophical texts, literaturc, and so forth. Tbis shift has underpinncd many of the most contentious debates
dance at an art galJery mi~ These illustrate a broad
regarding culture, which have oftcn centred on the status nf individual objects and
expeeted to elevate theiT a
l'orms, and on \vhether or not they count as cxamples of 'genuine' culture.
them. Those that do not
Second, implicit in both the inca nf culturc as a process nf cultivation and in its
denied the status of 'genu
opposition to 'savagery' i5 its dependencc on notions of value; within W'cstern
and a potent case is the r
thought 'culture' has invariably functioncd as an aaluative ami hierarchical
tbere has been a recurrent
concept. A l'amous examplc can be scen in Mauhew Arnold's Culture and Anarchy
expectations of the publico
(1869), which dcscribed culture as involvjng the cultivation nf 'sweetnc.'ss and
Edouard Manet's painting
Iight'.4 Only what improved the human eondition was representati"c oI' 'true'
OVer the Tate Gallery's puro
culture, aecording to Arnold, a delinition that reJegated many social praetices to
or in reactions to Martin
I
the realm of popular cntertaínment. 1ndeed, for Arnold the greate ...t threat to
work has included a ball (
genuine culture carne from the Industrial Revolutian, which, with its introduction
(rlork # 81, 1993) and a li gallery space (Wolk # 227,
of mechanical prorluction and mass popular culture, threatencd to plungc European sacicty into barbarismo
dismay. While some of the
Arnold's views mar seem distant l'rom our own, but they informed a long intel
healthy scepticism toward~
Icctual tradition. In Britain, for instan<.:c, the literary seholar F. R. Leavis' widely
Madonna to award the priz
influential study Thc Great uadition (1948) identified authors whose works formcd
tion that art should ha"e a h
01' a 'genuine' culture that "vould aet as a bulwark against the dchumanis
Indeed, one of the most iJ
the basis
VISUAL CULTURE AND THE MEANINGS OF CULTURE
7
ing erfecls oI' modern industrial society.5 Likewise, the American theorist O,"vight MacDonald. (1906 -82) ore\v a sharp distinction bet\veen 'high' and 'mass' culture. Mass culture, argued MacLJonald., is a dehaseo form ofhigh culture 'imposed from aboye. lt is fabricated hy tcchnicians hired by busincssmen; its auniences are passive consumers, thcir participation limited to the choice between buying ano not buying .'6
A similar critique was mountco by the Frankfurt School al' critical thcory;
writers such as Theodor Adorno (190369) and Herbcrt Marcuse (1898-1979) stressed thc role of mass popular culture in encouraging a statc al' unthinking pas sivity in the audicncC', inculcating unthinking acceptance al' consumer culture ami creating 'false' needs for consumer goods. Such a s),stem ,lIso prcvented the mass audicncC' from being able to engagc with 'authcntic' art ami culture, offcring instead mindless cscapism. 7 We may no longcr see popular audiences as oupes, nor share Arnold's concerns about the growth of popular culture. Nevertheless, cultural prac tices still take place within a hierarchy, the mass products of popular culture regardco as 'lower' than high art, opera or litcrature. Thus the films of Jean-Lue Godard or Krz),sztof Kidlowski count as cxamples of 'high' culture in contrast to Dumb anJ Dumber (1994) ano other comedies by the Farrell)' Brothcrs. Likewisc the HaTT'y Potter nuvds and filrns eount as popular entertainment, in contrast to, for
exarnpk, the poetry ofJeremy Prynne, which is counted as 'scrious' literature. This hierarchy oftcn feeds into hasic debates ahout culture. An obvious cxample rnight be the recurrent argurne'nt about thc 'damaging' cffcets ol' watching too rnuch tele vision, particularl)' in the case of children. Nobody would suggest rcpcated atten dance ,1t an art gallery rnight have ncgative consequcnces. Thcse illustrate a hroader hahit ofthought, ,",vherc 'genuine' cultural practiccs are cxpeeted to ekvate their audiences and place intellectual and aesthctü: demands on thern. Those that do not are rclcgated to a lm.ver place in the' hierarchy
01"
even
oenied the status 01' 'genuinc'. Such expcctations can be observed in man)' areas, and a potent case is the response to art\\'orks; since the rnid-nineteenth century there has becn a recurrent tension hetwccn the challengc of avant-garde art and the expectatiom; ol' the publico This can bc seen in the initial public revulsion shown to Edouaro Manet '5 painting
OJ.ympw when first cxhibited in 1865, or in thc outcry
over the Tate Galler)"s purchase in 1978 of Carl Andre ',<,; Equivalent VIl! (Figure 1.1), or in reactions to Martin Creed, winner ofthe 2001 Turncr Prize. Creed, whose work has induded a ball of Blu-Tack (Wo,k (~tork
# 79, 1993), a plee" oE masking tape
# 81, 1993) and a light switching on anO off every fiyc seconds in an empty
gallery space (Hork # 227, 2001), was th(~ ~ource of considerable hemusement and dismay. While sorne of the criticisrns 01' the 2001 Turner Prizc were the result ol' a hcalthy scepticisrn towards its infatuation with the media - inc1uding thc choice of Madonna to award the prize - much crítical cornmcntary drew on the tacit assump tion that art shoulrl have a highcr, purpose not immediatcl)' (~vident in Crcco's ....v ork. Indeed, on(' ol' the most important art critics of the t\\'entieth century, CIernent
8
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
own 'cultivated' status
culture. Social sta tus al term 'cultural capita
(1930--2002), illustrat, a form of sj'mholic weal There are numerou
asked who decides wh:
issue; 1 have already mI
dition, and the issue w, Bloom, whose book Th
posedly indispensable' invited the reader to re:
not iTItend to criticise a
disagreement that highl whether there can be a
art and literature. The" Figure 1.1 -" Cad Andrc, Ec¡wvalent VlJI (1978). Tate Gallery. London. © DACS.
Grcenbcrg (1909-94), coined the term kItsch to distinguish between 'bagus' culture and genuine avant-ganle arto Kitsch was meant, he argued, for those \vha are 'insensible to the yaIues 01' genuine culture', offering \:icarious expericncc and fakcd sensation'. 8 In contrast, the role of avant-garde art \vas to 'kcep culture moving' and hen<_'e maintain cultural progress. As noted earlier, 'culture' has come to denote not mercly the process of indi
vidual and social development, but also the thm,gs- noyels, artworks, musical com~ positions, pocms, buildings - a socicty has produceci. ThE')' stand, in sorne sensc. as its monuments, and according to this view the process of cultivation, 01' becom
ing 'cultured', consists in an ncr-dccpening acguaintance \\.'ith the-sf' cultural artc facts. In Britain, the origins 01' this not10n can again be placed in the eighteenth ccntury, Jn nnportant role being played hy the Grand Tour. The purpose of the Grand Tour, which flourished between approximately 1700 and 1790, was to Jcguaint young aristocratic meu \vith the great an.:hitecturaJ and artistic monu ments 01' I:.uropc and, In particular, Italy. It funcLioneu as a substitutc for univcrsity cducation at a time when England had an underdeveloped university system in cornparison with other Furoppan statcs.lt was also designed to cernent the central role 01' classical culture - in particular ancient Rome - in providing the standards of refercnce for all judgements 01' taste. It also affordcd the gentry the opportunit)' to acguire through purchase or plunder the artefacts they encountered, thus con firming their 'cultured' status. Although the Grand Tour [eH into decline in the late 17005, thc idea that acguisition of ceruin kinds of artcfacts coulcl confirm orre's
dispute tht' indusion of be huge areas for disa: Valado n , fOf example, ~ Jane Campion it is not ¡ whether they formed p' Fcminist writers haV! privilege male artists, al !he [aet that most rustori, fact that the features vah 'masculine'. These have on individual autonorny; (heroes). In addition, m, often hf'C'n rt'garded as '[t in relation to the exciusif Snch "rguments highL be necessary to agree a e Russian cultural theorist no socicty has a single cu plurality of cultural voie 1930s and 1940s, and if t cultural and economic gl Indeed, it has proved evel all as constituting a sban ¡onger possiblc which ult would hr: that he was co
VISUAL CULTURE AND THE MEANINGS OF CULTURE
9
own 'cultivated' status has remained a powerful and persuasive one within Westcrn culture. Social status and class are no longer defined exclusively hy wealth, hut the tcrm 'cultural capital'. coincd by thc French soeiologist Pierrc Rourdicu (1930---2002), ¡llustrates clcarly the extent to which education and culture rcmain a form oL~l'mbohc wcalth that continues to define and structure social hierarchics. 9 Thcre are numerous problems with this vicw. Mast irnmediatcly. it has to be asked who decides what is to count as genuine culture. This has been a perennía] issue; 1 have already mentioned Leavis's attempt to identify the grcat cultural tra dition, and the issue was raised again in the 1990s by the American critie Harold Bloom, whose book The Western (anon (1995) included a list ofthe great and sup posedly indispensable \yorks ol' world literature. lO This was a bold tache, for it invited the reader to reflect on Bloom's criteria l'or inclusion <1nd exc:1usion. 1 do not intend to criticise an)'
01'
Rloom '5 individual judgements. It ¡s the possibiliy' of
disagrecment that highlights the central dil'ficulty ofhis approaeh: it is questionable whcther there can be a general consensus as to what counts as the great works of art and litcrature. There ma)' he considerable areas of consensus - few would dispute the inclusion ol' Shakespeare or Picasso in such lists - hut equally there will be huge arcas for disagreement. When it comes to the paintings
01'
Suzanne
Valadon, for example, or the photomontages of Romare Bearden or the films of Jane Campion it is not at aH dear that there would he universal agreemcnt as to whethcr they l'ormed part of the Wcstcrn cultural canon or noto Feminist \..: riters havc been particularly critical ol' the canon. It has tended to privilege male artist5. architeets. writers, and so forth. 1I Partly, this has reflected the faet that most histories ol' culture have been written hy men amI partl)', too, the fact that the features valued in the formatíon of canons, havc tended to he seen as 'masculine'. These havc induded. l'or examplc: a strong artistic identit)'; a stress on individual autonom),; an interest in narratives that privilege masculine actors (heroes). In addition, mass culture, and the consumerism associated \vith it, have 01'ten
been regarcled as 'femininc'. 12 Similar criticisms have becn made ofthe canon
in relation to the cxclusion ol' the culture of ethnic minorities. Such arguments highlight the l'aet that societies lack the unil'ormity that would he necessar)' to agree a common canon. Indeed, since the pioneering work ol' the Russian cultural theorist Mikhaj] Bakhtin (1895-1975) it has becn recognised that no societ)' has a single culture and that instead one must always think in terms ol' a pluralit)' ol' cultural voiees and values. 13 Rakhtin made such ohservations in the 19305 and 1940s, and if this was the case, then it is doubl)' so in the present, where cultural and economic glohalisation have rendered societies increasingl)' divcrse. Indeed, it has proved ever more dil'ficult to identil'y a hody ol' works recognised by aH as constituting a shared cultural tradition. It is the anxiet)' that this seems no longer possihle which ultimately motivates Bloom; an uncharitable interpretation would be that he was concerned by the fact that American East Coast literature
f 10
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
!
profcssors such as himself can no longer determine what counts as great art or
not by reference to son
culture, and that their judgerncnts are no longer automatically followcd or shared
classical antiquit)' or Fr<
byathers.
Herder is often cred civilisation as a singular
Culture without Values
each of which has to be 1
concerned to legitimise
Behind the TIotion üf culture as something of qualit)' to be achieved or possessed
tradition in Europe at ti
lies a complex set 01' social expectations and values. The Grand Tour again offcr~
German national consci
.lD important examplc, for its PUTraSe \'''as not onl)' to educatc the gentry and the aristocrac)', hut .lIso to ensure that the)' rctaincd social prestige arrd dominancc
with nationalist ideolol
notion of ethnically 'p
through their access to a culture unavailable to athers. It ¡s no coincidence that the
endorsed such ideals; h
Grand Tour declined in importance in the late cighteenth centur) as It bccarnc
resisting cultura.l domin
affordable for larger numbcrs of the middle classes to visil Ital)'. Moreover, the
inition 01' culture. [terrr
\veaknesses of this evaluative notion of culture are further evident \vhen consid
with its roots in thc stuc
ered in the context of contCrTlflOrary Western society. Whilc
su eh soeieties on their
\'\T
may aH have
varying degrees of familiarity with the canonical works of \Vestern culture, far
Western societies. Of ('1
more infiuential and prevalent m contemporary European and AmerIcan societics
is itself open to questic
are forms of popular culture - from film and tclevision to ('omie books or com puter games - which writers such as Arnold, Leavis and Eliot would not cven con
strated, there are gool observer. 15 N evertheles
sider as examples of 'culture'. Yet fev.' would maintain that ours is an age with no
able for two important
culture. Its values and concerns have changed in important wa)'s deplored this faet
ami man)' have
hut that is a different question. In other words, the definition
tures and valucs whil superiorit)' of certain
Cl
of l-ulture nccds to be separated out from qUl'stions of CJualitr This ma)' appear to
Although such debat
he a ver)' contemporar), issue, hut it was alrcad)' being artieulatcd in the cightecnth
problems of the eighteer
century by the Gcrman philosopher Johann Gottfricd Herder (1744-1803).
is of a ver)' direct kind¡
Herder objected to the fact that European culture \\:as ddined largdy in terms
ter Silvio Berlusconi, th<
01' ancient Greecc and Rome and its persistence in the literature and art of se\cn
Carey, the former Archl Arabic culture highlight
tccnth- and eighteenth-ecntur)' France, \víth a eonsequent disregard for national cultures from othcr, non-classícal traditions. Herder proposed an alternatin~, more
cultural value and diffel
democratic notion of culture that was no longcr Iinked to the classical traclition or
manifestation of these d
more generall), to judgemcnts uf quality. Indeed, until now 1 have tended to treat
been taken up by various
'culture' ami 'civilisation' as interchangcahle terms, but in raet Herder introduccd
ccrns with high culture.
the notion of 'culture' (Kultur) in opposition to the dommancc of the classically
Thc idea of a visual c
inspired civihsation of France. 'Culture' designatcd for Herder the \'\/a)' oflife of a
historian Michael Baxal
particular eommunity, y."hich included ever)'da)' customs and hahits, beliefs and 'civ¡lisation'. 'Culture' \Vas now a purel)' descriptive term that madI..' no judgement
f!fieenlh Century lta!y. 16 works of art was to esta the artistic intluenees on
about the moral, intdlcctual or aesthetic qualit)' of a cultural practíce. One can
complex symbolíc imag(
traditions alongsidc the great artistic and intcllcctuai monuments Jssociated with
think again of biological metaphors, for where the hrst dehnition of culture \jcws
oso phi cal and theologicc
it in terms of a process of cultiyation, Herder sees culture as the organic and nat
consulted to establish its
urally gro"ving expression of a givcn cornmunity. In other \\'ords, a culture grows
the artist would also be f
VISUAL CULTURE AND THE MEANINGS Of CULTURE
11
not by reference to sorne artificially imposcd standards drawn from elsewhere classical antiguity or Franee - hut spontaneolisly according to its own impulses. 14 Herder is often credited with being the first cultural rclativist; in the place 01' civilisation as a singular achievcrncnt he propasen the idea al' a plurality of societies, cach oI' which has to be understood in terms nI' its
0\\'0
cultural valucs. Herder was
concerned to let7jÜmise Gnman culture as difIerent fram the dominant classical
notion 01' ethnically 'pure' culture. Herder himsclf woulo not have remotel), endorsed !'uch ideals; he was concerned aboye aH with promoting pluralism aud resisting cultural domination. His approach al so emphasised an anthropolo8ical def inition of culture. I term it 'anthropological' because contemporary anthropology. with its roots in the study oI' non- Western cultures, has long sought to understand such socicties on their own terms, without projecting onto them the values of Western societies. Of course, the idea oI' a neutral description 01' another culture is itsell' open to question, ano as the anthropologist James Clil'ford has demon strated. there are good reasons to doubt the authority ol' the ethnographic ohserver.1'i Nevcrthelcss, thc anthropological definition 01' culture has he en valu able for t\o\·o important reasons: it has ensured rcengnition ol' the plurality of cul tures and valucs while also challenging long-held assumptions about the superiority 01' certain cultures over others. Although such debates aprear root<..~d in particular political and intellectual problcms ofthe cighteenth centur)'. their relevance to eontemporary visual culture is of a ver)' direct kind; the recent, unpromptcd outbursts by Italian prime minis ter Silvio Rerlusconi, the British television presenter Robert Kilroy-Silk or Gcorgc Carey, the former Archbishop of Cantcrbury. concerning the alleged inferiorit)' of Arabic culture highlight the continued existence oI' deep-seated prejudiccs about cultural value and dHTerence. Thc rise of the notion ol' visual culture is a fllrther maniI'cstation nI' thesc dehates over the dehnition 01' culture. In particular, it has bccn takcn up by various authors to counter the elitism oftraditional scholarly con cerns ,.. ., ith high culture. The idea ol' a visual culture "vas first explorcd system.ltically by thc British art historian Michacl Baxandall, in a widel)' read work, l'ainring and Experience in F!ftecnth Ccnwr'y ltatl,.16 The traditional art-historical appro3ch to interpreting
works ol' art v,'as to establish its rclation to other artworks, in order to asccrtain the artistic inHllcnces on the painter or sculptor. In addition, if the \vork relied on complex symbolic imagery, contemporaneous literar)' sources, ranging from phil osophica! and thcological texts through to c1assical works of m)'thology. would be consulten to establish its meaning. Frequently, the role 01' the aristocratic patron 01' th .... artist would .lIso be examined in oroer to analyse the process of its production.
12
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
and the possibilit)' oI' tracing an artwork back to its point oI' origin wouId dcmon
graphic design, cornic 1
strate its authenticity (and enhance its monetary value).
such popular forms o
Baxandall undertakes much ol' this kind al' scholarly analysis l but in addition he
beliefs and values as ti
suggests that \Ve look bcyond the confines al' art and al' the high culture ol' thc
recent examples, Anne
Renaissance in arder to understand the paintings 01' the fifteenth century. For
design aml material cu
cxample, he argues that thc invention ofperspective by Filippo Brunelleschi in thc
hairstyles, while Kirsti
carly 1400s, with its obsessive attention to mathematical proportion, has to be coo
which the dcsign of (
sidered in relatian to the dominance al' the practical mathematics oI' cornmercial
washing machines offe]
transactions 01' the time, in which rncrchants wouId need to pcrform complex cal
the 1950sand 1960s.1'
culations on a daily basis. In a society that invcnted double-entry book-kceping, a
The art historian H
predisposition to attend to mathematical guantities and proportions also informed
ago that the design of ¡
visual experience, including pictorial representations. Baxandall also compares
ieval European cultun
representations of the human figure in painting ""ith manuals on dancing of the
Wülffiin was emphasisi
same time.
such items are taken f(
Baxandall tried to change thc context in which artworks \verc seen. Instead of
tions underlying a cult
the exclusive focus on 'high' artistic and literary culture, he hrought in other
role in the rise of cu
aspects ol' cultural life that egually informed the making ol' artistic images. üf cour~e, one has to be eautious here; in Renaissanee Ital)' paintings were accorded a
Rayrnond Williams ex practices. 19 Wülffiin's
higher value than man)' othcr kinds oI' artefacto Neverthcless, Baxandall indicated
are often sorne of the
how significant other apparentl), minor and peripheral cultural practices \.\-'ere when attempting to understand the art of the time, and numerous others have 1'01
This applies not only clothing for aH sorts O
lowed his example. Svetlana Alpers, 1'or example, compared seventcenth-century
forms. As Fiona Ander
Dutch paintings - the so-ealled golden age 01' Dutch art -- to other kinds ol' visual
markers of cultural ide.
representations such as maps and scientific illustrations, as well as examining
sexes, between social (
various ideas about vis ion prevalent at the time. 17 Alpers \.\-·as also the first to use
Many have thus turn
the term 'visual culture'. However, for both Baxandall and Alpers, artworks
the eHtist cultural vah:
remained the centre ol' interest, and the broader context of visual culture \\-'as
book art remains an im
explored in order better to illuminate the understanding of individual paintings or
tant than a century agc
artists. In other words, both privileged works 01' art beeause they werc secn to be
order to enable a propl
more important expressions 01' a culture than otber kinds ofimage-making. In addi
understand a culture ir
tion, while he moves beyond the domain of art, Baxandall was ultimately eon
is to be discOllllted as
¡
cerned with the bcliefs, ideas and values - in short, the culture -- 01' the \\-'calth)'
the Rocky films starring
prnducers and consumers ol' painting in Renaissance Ital)'. We are therefore still in
eters of American cult
the shadow 01' the cultural elite 01' Italian societ)'. More recen ti)', the idea of visual culture has come to involvc a broader perspec tive, in \vhich the object of study is no longer the concerns of a cultural elite, but
the paintings of Julian This does not mean
tJ
Scorsese 's Haaina Bull
rather the much wider set of ideas, beliel's and customs of a society and the wa)'s in
masculine identity thar
which che)' are Hiven visual expression. This has a number o1'important consequences.
and taste it was probab
Most immediatcly this means that visual culture is secn as consisting not only 01'
tural and historical sig
works of art, but al so ol' aH other kinds ol' visual imagery; in relation to the twen
and aesthetic quality.
tieth century tbese would indude, for example, cincma, television, advertising and
In certain respects
VISUAL CULTURE AND THE MEANINGS Of CULTURE
13
graphic design, eomje books oI' photography. [o attempting to understand a. society, 5uch popular forms visual image-making offer just as important clues to its beJiefs and valucs as the traditional sphere of high art. Thus, to take arre ol' two
or
recent examples, Anne Massey has examincd the impact of Hollywood cinema on design and material culture in Britain, from architecture to ffiakc-up, fashion and hairstyles, while Kirstin Ross's study Fast Cars CJean Badies has analysed thc ways in which the design of cars, women '5 magazines, films, popular fiction and even washing machines ülTer a due as to the formation ofFrench cultural identit)' during the 19505 and 19605."
The art historian Heinrich W,llfflin (1864-1945) argued more than a eentur)' ago that the design of a shoe eouId be as important an index of the values of med ieval European culture as the great Gothic eathedrals of Chartrc~ or Strasbourg. W¿)lftlin \'las emphasising the importance ol' cveryday objccts; it is preeisel), because sueh items are takcn for granted that the)' reveal so much about the tacit assump tions undcrl)'ing a culture. A concern with the everyday also played an important role in the rise of cultural studies, \\Cith authors sueh as Henri Lcfebvre and Raymond Williams cxplieitly turning to the ordinary, in contrast to elite cultural practiees. 19 Wülfl-lin's mention of a shoe highlights the faet that dress and fashion are orten sorne of the more \\'idespread means of visual expression in a culture. This applies not onl)' to the self-conscious products of haute couture, but also to clothing for aH sorts of purposes, from casual drcss to work wear or military uni forms. As Fiona Anderson argues in ch.lptcr 5, dress and fashion scrve as powerful markers of cultural identit)' -and difTerence world-widc, distinguishing between the sexes, between social classes and between gencrations. Manv 01' visual culture out of dissatisfaction \\-' ith , have thus turned lo the analysis , the elitist cultural "alues associated with the study of art. For the authors of this book art remains an important constituent of visual culture - although less impor tant than a centur)' ago - but what is requircct is to place it in a broader contcxt in order to cnable a properly eritical analysis. [t is aIso necessar)' to loo k beyond it to understand a culture in aH its facets. It fo11o\\'s, thcrefore, that no cultural practice is to be discountcd as a legitimate object of cnquiry on qualitative grounds alone; thc Rack), fílms starring Syl"estcr Stallone, for example. were as important barom eters of American cultural values ol' the 1980s as the no\'els ol' Thomas Pynchon, the paintings of Julian Sehnahcl or the architectural projccts ol' Michael Graves. This does not mean that one should suspend all judgements of qualit)'; Martin Seorscse's RagIng Bull (1980) undoubtedly ofl'ered a more penetrating study of masculine identit} than the Rack), films, but as an indcx of American cultural vatues and taste it was probably less significant. Herc we come to the recognition that cul tural and historical significance are to be separatcd out from questions of artistie and aesthetic quality. In certain respccts the antagonistic attitude that the stucly ol' visual culture
14
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
VIS
adopts tO\\'ards art typifies a much ....... ideT debate
QVcr
the definition
or culture, and
visual alone. Neverthcless
the attempt to reasscss what counts as 'Iegitimate' cultural practice has cncoun
pre-emincnce, and the
tered ficrce resistance. Orre particularl)' prominent example . .v ithin Rritain has
dependent on the produc
or univcrsíty degrecs in media studies.
(1956), bascd on Shakespe
heen the widespread criticism ol' the grüwth
COl
At the roo! of such ohjections is the notion that rhe mass media - newspapers, radio
Austen 's Eruma. Much of ti
and television - together with other forms al' popular culture such as film, do not
the impulse to make it ever
meTít scrious scholarly attention, that they are intrinsically 'inferior' to the great
invention ol' colour film or
...y orks of 3rt and literaturc. The arrogan ce of such vicws hardI)' needs cornmcnt
format ol' cinemascope.
ing on, hut it is intcrcsting to note thar in the t 920s similar criticisms \Vere made
enhanced the visual speeta
01' thc notion that the study ofEnglish Htcrature was as valíd as the stud y ofthe das sical Jiterature 01' Greece and Rome.
viewing the cinema, l'rom ..
ro..
numerous writers have sf certain deep-seated psyc
Visual Culture and the Culture of the Image There is a further dimcnsion to the iJea 01' visual culture, and this is linked closel)'
Television, too, having on viewing expcrience l'rom t the development of 'hom
to the idea that the visual image has become central to contemporary cul tural prac
quality 01' the OVO- Furthe
tiee in the West. For most of its historvo Western soderv.' has been an oral socíetv' o'
tainment provided h y corn
the dominant forms uf cultural expression \'o'cre oral, the principal form of cultu ral transmission the passing on of stories, legends, histories b): \vord ol' mouth.
contemporal'Y lil'e in geneT ol' the closcd-circuit TV ca
lbere are, ol' coursc, numerous \vritten monuments l'rom the oral period of
sorne form ol' video surveil
European culture, but thesl' were oftcn the summation ol' a long oral traJition or,
the video camera either pr<
as in the great courtly epics and romances of the Middlc Ages, transcriptions of
indiviJuallives, the most s
poems originally composed to be recited to .ln audiencc. At a time of Imv literac)',
programmes such as You've
and when the process ol' producing manuscripts was enormously costl)' and slo\\',
accidents and pratl'alls, test screen Uves.
cultural values Jnd traditions were circulated and handed dmvn primarily by oral of texts such that the written \vord gradually became the central form of cultural
In general, therefore, ' culture, facilitaten and prob
communieation. This gave rise to cultural forms such as the novel, directed
suggested that a l'urther rea
towards the reader as opposed to the listener, or the mas.,,-circuiation newspaper in
speetacle. Walter BenjamÍl
thc late 1800s, which could only have come into being \vith a general rise in liter ae)'.20 Ol' egual signifieance was the invention of the woodeut, and later of increas
early ninetecnth-century' F
means. The invention nf printing in the fi.fteenth century increased the circulation
ingly complex techniques for the ma.'is production of printed images. induding
magical spectacle - what B( 21 ThIS 1-d ea was t sumpt lOn.
engraving, lithography and photography. Such technologies cnsured that the distri
highlightcd the extent to w]
bution of images beeame increasingly widcspread, l'rom the political and religious
which not only underlies tl
pamphlets of the t 500s to advertising in the 1800s. This intcnsified in the twenti
ates aU social relations. Thi
eth century with the invention 01' cinema, tclevision amI the computer, and in par
argucd that in aH aspects (
ticular the WYSIWYG interface familiar from Applc and \Vindo",-/s-based personal
replace real experienee of
computers. One might add to this list the uhiquitous computer gamc, from the
Raymond Williams, for ins
Nintcndo Gamchoy to the Son)' Play Station.
the past two eentudes. In th
Such media havc not completely supplanted traditional 'literary' cultural
based but developed an inc
forms; eyen computer games have a narrative structurc that is not reducible to the
cable in tcrms of the a'
VISUAL CULTURE AND THE MEANINGS OF CULTURE
15
visual alone. Nevertheless, the novel, for cxample, no longer enjoys its former pre-eminencc, and the continued popularity al' man)' literar)' 'classics' is often
dcpcnncnt on the production of filmie adaptations, from The Forbíddcn Planet
(1956), based on Shake'pcarc', Thc 7émpest, to elueIess (1995), adapted from Janc Austen 's Emma. Much af the history oi' postwar visual culture has bcen nriven by the impulse to make ir ever more vísually spectacular. Here ane might think of the invcntion of colour tilm or of the use, in the 19505 and 19605, uf the wide-screen formar of cinemascopc. More rcccnd)', too, the rise al' digital tcchnology has enhanccd the visual spectac1e inyolved in vie\ving the cinema. The conditions al' viewing the cinema, from within a darkcncd room, also emphasise this aspect, and numerous wríters ha....c spcculatccl on the way that this process engages ,vith certain deep-seated psychological processes on the part of the viewer. 21 Television, too, ha....ing once been seen as involving a rather differcnt kincl of vie\ving experience from the cinema, ís now movíng in the same direction, with the de\'elopmcnt of 'home cinema', wide-screen television and the cincmatic quality of the DVD. Furthermore, one need not rcfcr onl)' to the torms ol' enter tainment provided by commcrcial procluccrs. As Nicholas Mirzoeff has argued, contcmporar)' life in general occurs on screen; in \\/estern socjl'lics th(, ubiquity
01' the closed-circuit TV camera mcans that most of Jire i5 now carried out undcr sorne Form of viclco surveillance. 22 Similarly, the proHferation nI' photography and the video camera either produces or gratifics an urge to record e....ery detail of our individuallivcs, thc most significant the most banal. The popularit), nI' tclcvision programmes such as You 've Been Framed, in which vicwcrs submit footage of family accidents and pratfalls, testitics to an insatiablt:' appetite to watch each other's on scrcen lives. In general, thcn:forc, Wc:-;tern society has become a predominantl), visual culture, facilitated and probably even initiated by certain tcchnologics. Others have suggested that a funhcr rL'3son ma)" he the clependence 01' consumerism on visual spectaclc. Walter Benjamin (1892- t 940) analysed the first shopping arcadcs in earl), nineteenth-eentur), Paris, the primaq' function of which ,\'as to create a magical spcctaclc - what Bcnjamin termed a 'clream landscape'
to promote con
sumption. 21 This idea was taken up by others such as Guy Deborn (1931-94), who híghlightcd the cxtl'nt to which Western society has become in thraH to the image, which not onl)' underlies the basis of contcmporar)' consumerism, Dut also medi ates aH social rclations. This thesis 'vas popularised by lean Baudrillard, ,vho has arguecl that in aH aspects of Western society imanc.\ of the worlcl have come to replace real experience oI' it. 24 Historical stuclies have confirmed such claims; Raymond WiIliams, for instance, explored shifts in the nalure of advertising over the past two centuríes. In the earl), 1800s aclvertisements were predominantly text hasecl hut cleveloped an increasing relianee on images. ~'j Par tI)' tbis shift is expli cable in lerms of the availabilit)', of technologies that permitted the easy
16
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
reproduction al' images. But it i5 thc significance of such a shift that is al' primary
¡nteTest, ror in its current form consumerism wouId be lll1thinkable without the plethora al' advertising imagery selling ever)' imaginable product and service. This
i5 evident, too, in thc ubiquity ofthc logo, from the Nike swoosh to the golden arches of MacDonald's, which adds a distinctive visual marker to the product bcing sold, indeed ha:-; come to be more important than the commodity ir denotes.
Conclusion
11 See, for example, Gri: AH 's H1Stories (London 12 See, for example, And Huyssen, .'!fiu the Gr. 1986), pp. 44---64. 13 See Mikhail Bakhtin, 7 14 For a dear outline of tJ HJStC'q ~r Ideas (Londo' 1S James CliIford, 'On Et
EthnflgUlphy, Literatme e ~ 6 .Micha el Baxandall,
This transformed landscape al' contcmporary Western saciet)' i5 central to the approach of this book. Given such changes ir i5 no looger tenable to holel on unquestioningly to traditional notions of culture, art or creativity. Nevertheless, whilc such old~r cultural forms and boundaries are increasingly open to qucstion, we proceed on the assumption that thcy still play an active and vital role in the popular imagination and hence in popular culture. Although an artist such as Andy Warhol was already eroding the boundaries betwccn art and popular culture in the earl)' 1960s, .art' is still a scparatc cultural practice, and there are numerous cul tural instltutions, Jrom museums, public and commcrcial gallcrícs to art col1eges, academics amI media rcprcsentations, which treat it as such.
Further Reading
POI
17 Svetlana Alpers, The Aj 18 Anne Massey, Hollywo
Rodies: Decolonisation al
t 9 Rayrnond WilIiams, '( (London, 2002), pp. ~ 1991 ). 20 On the impact of litera Lireracy (London, 1982 21 A useful overview of ! 2000). See especially ': Spcctator' (pp. 229-3~ 22 Nicholas Mirzoeff, An J 23 Scc \Valter Benjamin, study by Thomas Ric Specracle 1851-1914 (1
24 Guy Oebord, The Societ Yock, 1983). 2S Rayrnond WiI\iams, 'A. and Culturc (London, ti
Eagleton, T. The IJea ?ICulture (Oxford, 2000).
Mir7ocff, N. An IntroauctlOn to Visual Cufrure (London, 1999).
Strinati, O. An Inrroaucuon ro Theones?I Popular Culture (Landon, 1995).
\Villiams, R. Culture ona Sociery 1780-1950 (Lomion, 1958).
Notes 1 Raymond Williams, 'Culture', in R. Williams, Keyltoras (London, 198~), pp. 87 9,. 2 See Lucien Febvre, 'Civilisation: Evolution of a Word and a Group of Idcas,' in L. felH re, ..1 '\'CI\" K¡nJ?I HíslOr)',Jrom the ~Vnt¡ngs ifFebvre, ed. E Burle (Lomion, 1973), pp. 219--57. 3 CileJ in AJam Kuper, Culrure: [he Anthropo1oBlsts' AccounI (Camhridge, MA, 1999), p. 26. 4 Matthew i\molel, cited in John Storey, ej., Cultural Theor)' ana Popular Culture (London, 1994), p. 8. S Frank L .'avis, The Greot Trodition: GeoIfle EllOl, Henr)'James,Joseph Comad (Londnn, 1948). 6 Dwight MacDonald, 'A Thcory nf Mass Culture', in R. Ro~enberg and D. W. \Vhite, eds, Mass ClJ/rure: ¡he Popular AHS in Amenca (New York, 1957), pp. 59- n. 7 Sec, for example, Theodor Adorno, [he Culture fndu.'iuj" (London, 1991); Herbert Marcuse, One-DimenslOna/ ilIon (l ondan, 1964). 8 Clement Greenberg, 'Avant-Ganlc and Kitsch' [1939]. in F. Frascina, ('J., Ptlllock anJ j~¡rCI: the Critical Debate (LonJon, 1985), p. 24. 9 See Pierre Bourdieu, DlStmctJOn: a S(lchJI enoque oJ che Judgemenr C}f TaSf!! (LonJon, 1984). 10 Harold Bloom, The Wesw!n Canon: {he Boo1<., ana Sch(lfl[ oJrhe ABes (London, 1995)
VISUAL CULTURE AND THE MEANINGS OF CULTURE
17
11 Sec, for cxample, Grisclda Pollock, Diffirencma the (unon. Feminist Dente and the rVririna rf Art 's H15toms (London, 1999). 12 Sef', for cxamplc, Andreas Huyssen, 'Mass Culture as \Vornan. Modernism's Other', in A. Hu)'ssen, A.¡ter {he Grear DiYIde: Modernism. Mass Culrute and Postmodermsm (Basingstoke, 1986), pp. 44 64. 13 See Mikhail Bakhtin, The DiaJo8JCal lmoajnalion (ALJstin, TX, 1981). 14 Far a clcar outline ofthe work ofHerder, see Isaiah Berlin, Vico and Herder: Two Srudles In the Hisrory ~flJe<1s (Lancion, 1976). 15 James CIifford, 'On Ethnographie Authority' , in The Predicamenl c1 Culrure. Twencierh Century Erhnosraph)', Literarme and Aa (Cambridge, MA, 1988), pp. 21- 54. 16 Michael Baxandall. Paintlna ond Expetience in Fifteenth CenrulJ' Ital;' (Oxrord, 1972). 17 Svetlana Alpers, The Aa 4 Describin8: Dutch Art in the Seventeenth CenrulJ' (Chieago, 1983). 18 Anne Massey, Holl;'lwod be.yonJ the Saeen (Oxrord, 2000); Kirstin Ross, Fase Can, Clean Rodies: DecolomsatlOn anJ the Reorderine ifFrench Culture (Cambridge, MA, 1996). 19 Raymond Williams, 'Culture is Orninary', in B. Highmore, ed., The EvelJ'day Lifé Reader (London, 2002), pp. 91-100; Henri Lefebvre, The Critique qfEvelJ'day Lije (Cambridge, 1991). 20 On the impact ofliteracy and printing in European sodeties, see Walter J. Ong, Orality and J.¡rera(j" (London, 1982). 21 A useful over ....iew of such aecounts can be found in Roben Stam, Film TheolJ' (Oxford, 2000). See espeeially 'From Linguistics to Psychoanalysis' (pp. 158-68); 'The Birth ofthe Spectator' (pp. 229-34); and 'Cogniti.. .'e and Analytic Theory' (pp. 235--47). 22 Nicholas Mil"zoeff, An lntroduetion to Visual Cultllre (London, 1999), p. 1. 23 See \\'alter Benjamin, The Arcades ProJea (Han'ard, MA, 1999). See, too, the more recent study by Thomas Richarns, The CommodHJ Culture if Vicwrian Ene/and. Adt'enisine anJ Speaacle 1851-1914 (London. ]990). 24 Cuy Debord, The SocJety ?f the Speetacle (Detroit, 1986); Jean Baudrillard, SimulaUons (New Ymk,I983). 2S Rayrnond Williams, 'Advertising. the Magie S)'stem', in R. Williams, Problems In Materialism and Culture (London, t 980), pp. 180-96.
2. Definitions of Art and the Art World Neil Mulholland
Introduction
If someone C'alls it 3rt. it's art. (Donald JucId)1
Donald Judd's statement
SCCffi:i
:iclf-cvidcnt. If someone wants to cal! something
'art', who can stop thcm? While such
.lO
assumption appears common sense, it
leads into challenging disputes. Toda)', molo)' people wouId consirler Martin Elliott's postcr 7Cnnü Girl of t 970 (Figure 2.1) to be in poar taste. Thcy may
Of
mol)'
not regard this attrihute posltivci)'. hut the)' \-,,'ouId generall), be unlikely to think it was .ln cxample of a .serious \\'ork al' art. Wc mal' decide to make preciseI)' the solme evaluation of Jefr Koons' sculplure Michael Jackson and BubbJes (1988) (Figure 2.2). A senior art world representative, su eh as the Director al' New York\i Museum of Modern Art (MOMA), would, howt"vef. be ver)' likely to accept Koons' sculpturc as a significant work 01' art, while rcjcctíng EJliot 's postcr. We rna)' object to the art world represcntative's "'icws, hut what \\'ould lhis objection achievc? If it is reaIl} a case that ir someone says it's art, it's art, why is the art world representative takcn more scriously on such matters than most? \Vho (Jr what has the power to proclaim sorne things works of art and not
- .. '6 ~,
others l
These are difficult questions to ans"'er in the abstract, sincc what can be said to
(
f
he art has changecl throughout history along with its conditions ol' display and con sumption. Today's professionaI art representativc is very different frorn sorneon('
Figure 2,1 - Martin Elliott,
DEFINITIONS OF ART AND THE ART WORLD
Figure 2.1 Martin Elliott, TenJl!s G/ti (1970). © Martin Elliott.
19
20
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Figure 2.2 - JeffKoons, il1ichaelJackson and Bubbles (1988). San Francisco Museum ofModern Art. © Je1f Koons.
who would have been in a position to commission an artist 500 years ago. The audi ences for Elliot or Koons also differ dramatically trom earlier audiences. When audiences and institutions mutate, art changes as different cultural possibilities emerge. What i8 important to note is that these possibilities are fimté at any given historical moment. This is one rcason that onl)' a limited number of people have been able to proclaim something to be art and have their opinion taken seriously. Moreover, this authority has only been vested in artists themselves [or a relatively short period of mstory.
The Rise of the Idea of Art In the earlvj modern era , laroe mural commissions provided bv the Church and rich (::) rnerchant patrons gave artists greater responsibility for the production of intellec tually and technically ambitious works. In Rome, Michelangelo Buonarroti pro duced murals for the Sistine Chopel Vault (1508-12), paintings that were symptomatic o[ the artist's new sense of authority. Michelangelo 's control over the intellectual content and practical execution ofthe murals signined that he was not simply a proficient technician, but an individual who could respond to Christian doctrine on bis own terms. By conceiving and painting his work alone, j
Michelangelo distanced ~ workers such as rnasons, tailors, watchmakers and pendent realm, unconstr< In pan, ihis sense of ir directors and collectors, Michelangelo a sense of church patronage began t unsurprising that durillg t counted amongst the libe) craft skills, skills which ~. the labouring c1asses. Thi people today use the term a relic of a much older un Michelangdo, however, t,l higher order ofhuman prc independent) and religiOl Protestant attack on ima~ merchants, iconoclasm cr from thc need for ari to ~ freedom. Fonns oE display in the did not come into existen, '""hite cube' exhibition v consumption. 5 Stimulated into natural history in the eties, religious orders ar encouraged by the devel0f of 'new' worlds, they collf their 'cabinets of curiosi Wundcrkammer).7 The majoj turies consisted of compe Works of art were not va sums. These cabinets forrr earth, sea and air to be COl jmagine humanity and uat\ or odd objects representin vegetable world and the m art!ficialw, or human achi, world, collectors soughtto tacle and fantas)' in microc
DEFINITION5 OF ART AND THE ART WORLD
21
Michelangelo ~istanc('n his practice from that of feliow craftsrnell ami collective \,",orkers such as masons, house huildcrs, locksmiths, tinkcrs, wea"t:"rs, spinners, tailors, watchmakers and jcwt:"llt:"fS. Michdangclo was ."leen to perform in an incte pendent rcalm, unconstrained b)' rules. In part, this sense of indcpendent 'genius' was an illusion. Like today's gallcry direL'tors and collcctor5, rieh patrons \\,'ere in a po.''iition to gi"c artists such as Michclangelo a sense of frccctom. At the same time, Financial autonorny [rom church patronagc hegan to alto,,' artists to explore secular themcs. Given this, it is unsurprising that during the carly modern era, painting ann sculpture began to he counted amongst the liheral arts sueh as poetr)'. 2 Art became separated from other eraft skills, skil1s whieh were now perceived to be the province of merchants ami the labouring c1asses. This division of lahour marks the origins of the wa)' man)' people toda), use the term 'art' , yet to man)', art is still shorthanct for 'well crafted', a relie of a mU<..:h oldcr uncterstanding al' the term.:l To a Renaissance artist such as Michclangclo, however, this was insufficient. Art was aboye eraft; it was part of a higher order ofhuman proctuction. This clivision hetween secular art (scholarly and inclepL'ndcnt) anct religious art (a tool of Christian propaganda) was aictcct hy the Protestant attack on images in the IS00s. Bolstercd b), the wealth of Protestant merchants, iconoclasm ereatcd the locale for the urbane art-lover to break away from the need for art to serve an overt ideological funetion. in seareh 01' artistie frcedom. Forms of display in the early modern period hindcrect this quest. Art gallcrics did not come into existence until the mid-eighteenth century;4- today's uhiquitous 'white eube' exhibition venues are a product 01' twenticth-century eonspicuous consumption. 5 Stimulated by the rebirth uf humanist seholarship ami its insights into natural history in the earl)' sixteenth eentur)'. princcly eourts, scientihc soci eties, religious ordcrs anct laypersons startect to colleet curiosities. 6 Further encclUragect b;' the developments in transport that led to the European exploratiofl of 'new' worlds, they collectect objects from arounct the \,"orld and placed thcm in their 'eabincts of curiosity' (also 01't en referred to by their German name, Wunderkammer).7 The majority of the eabinets in the sixtecnth and sevenleenth cen
turies consisted of composite objects and seldom contained onl)' wurks af arto Works of art were not valuect as highl)' as sorne curios anct often fetehed lower sums. These cabinets formed s),nopses of the "·orld, allO\~ring the proctuce of the carth, sea and air to be eomparect with the produce of mankind. using wonder to imagine humanit)' anct nature. The cabincts of curiosities were co\lections of rare ar ocld objccts representing the threc elements of naturalia: the animal ,,¡orld, the vegetable world and the mineral world. In addition, collectors would accumulate art~ficiaj¡a,
or human achievements. Amassing the most curious artefacts in the
wodd, colleetors sought to illuminate the secrets of nature by reproducing its spec tacle and fantas)' in microcosm. The cahinets were non-scientific in the sense that
• 22
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
they prirnarily encapsulated the sen,e 01' wonderrncnt that lay at the heart 01'
enment reason, Roman
Christian creationist doctrine. As such, the objective o1'the early modero cahincts
too complex to be map]
was not to produce a logical, enc)'clopacdic map of cvcryday naturalw and art!fi
of rigorous scientific m
cialia, but to support and promote religious knowledge. Thc early Wunderkammer
the irrational and the
weTe primarily produced for spiritual ami ritualistic purposes.
SI
understood or represer
Curiosit)' cahinets began to disappear in the follO\\ling centurics whcn thcir coo
ral, political, social and
tents became subsumed as explicahle objects of scientific enquiry rather than relig ious rches or puzzling \....onders. The objects considercd most intcresting were
example, in Critique ef works of modern aes'
relocated to museums nf art and natural history. The transformation of the princely
central to aesthetic eXI
gallerjes of Eurape into museums was one that scrved the ideological needs of the
impossibility of reducin
middíe c1asscs and nation states, providing secular civic rituals. Museums bceamc
At the same time, for K.
one means by whieh emergent imperial states sueh as Britain, Franee and Germany
not delibcrately so, it w
could represent, justify and take pride in their global authority Public mw;eums not
of modern kno"t'ledge.
unir displa1'ed the nation's power and wealth, in thc form nf objccts taken from col
play involved in ,lrt rel
onies, but providcd a platform upon whieh to establish an historical canon of
classes. 12 It has also bee
'national' culture. s Viewing 'indigenous' artefacts imparted a strong sense 01' civic
states that non-Europeil
and national continuity, ritualising the acquisition of national idcntit)' while surrep titiousl)' nurturing the coloniallogic of intcrnational cultural superiority. Museums applied cnlightenment logie to these collections, c1assifying them scícntífically and placing them into appropriate dcpartments.. Such museums were public rather than
The conditions of the pI
prívate; they were often statc-owned and had an educational role and responsibil
development ol' mercar
ity. " Thev , were crcrlitcd with the ahilitv, to escort an unsophisticated public into a
money creatcd new tas1
ncw eomportment and higher echelon of moral amI civiliscd behaviour. Public and
l'rom the world. Artists
moral policics nursed the modern museum out of the curiosity cabinet, to take part
ol' art dealers and the al
in new schemes ofbiological categorísation and museological speetacle illuminated
merchants, the Chureh,
h y exubcrant collisíons 01' visual teehniques and concepts.
for the market. Toward
By the late 1700s, thcrcforc, artists ,vere given further reason to define their
their rejection of the e:
activities systematically in terms ol' what they were noto Likc natural scicnce, art
suceessful in establishin
beeame increasingly exclusive, a professional activit1' engaged in as a form ol' spe
Pre-Raphaelite Brother
cialist knowledge. The formation 01' artists' academics, follo"t'ing the model 01' the
Rifusés and the Vienna
Académic Royale founded in Paris in 1648, al so cemented this process. Modern
amplifying the sense th,
industrialised societ)' of this period was dcdicated to the pursuit of knowledge to
ating the rclated illusiOl
a("hicve order. Modernity relied increasingly on establishing binar)' oppositions
Artists and philosopf
between 'order' and 'disorder', constructing 'disorder' as a foil. As the Polish soci
tions from moral and p
ologist Zygmunt Bauman has pointed out, a central rt:'curríng feature 01' modern
thetic COnct:'rns - havir
societ)' has been its attempt to margínalise the ambiguous, the ambivalent. 9 Art
began to materialist:' eXF
occupied a complex position in this situation. ln choosing the terms by which they
reached a sophistic,lted
wishcd thcir work to be reeeived, artists rejected numerous um...arranted associa
works as having no relat
tions. In the Renaissance, this meant differentiating 'high' art from the merely artis
Oscar Wilde stated: 'A
anal. By thc late eighteenth century, ir meant separating art from 'science'. Rather
purel)' on her 0'.\~1 Iine5
than support the tot,llising c1aims of science and the industrial 'progress' of enlight
symbols, her retleetion.'
DEFINITIONS OF ART AND THE ART WORLD
23
enment reasnn, Romantic conceptinns of art .md the artist held that the world \-vas too complex to be mapped out in its cntircty. 11) Faced by the dernystifying challenge of rigorous scientit-ic methüd, art increasingly becarnc a haven for the imaginatian, the ¡rrationa} and the sublime, it becamc a rneans of dealing with things not casily undcrstood or representcd in rational terros, providing distraction from the cultu ral, patitical, social and economic changcs '\vrought by the industrial rc\'olution. For l'xample, in CntIque
if lhe
Powcr c:IJuJgcment (1790), onc
01' the most important
works of modern acsthetics, Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) made imaginatioll central to aesthetic experlcncc and the production of art, insisting, too, on the impossibility of reducing judgements ofbeauty or the sublime to logieal eoncepts.
11
At the same time, for Kant, aesthetic appreciation of art denoted taste, and although not deliberate])' so, it was soeiall)' exclusive, a rcjection 01' the demoeratising daims of modern kno\'.dedge. lt has been argued that his emphasis on the free imaginative play involved in art reprc5ented the ideals of thc late eighteenth-century middlc classes. 12 It has al so been pointed out that it was raeiall)' motivated; Kant explicitly states that non-Europeans are incapable of appreciating art aesthctically.l'
Aesthetics and Art Theory The conditions of the production and reception o[ art \'Vere l'urther mutated by the deve]opmcnt of mereantile eapitalism spawned by the industrial revolution. New money created ne\\- tastes, bringing an even greater sense 01' the artist's autonom)' from the world ...o\rtist5 were able to split [rom their patrons with the introduetion o[ art dealcrs ano the art market. Patronage no longer had to be sought froro rieh merehants, the Chureh or the state; artists eould begin to make works speculatively [or the market. Towards the end o[thc nineteenth eentury, artists becamc vocal in their rejeetion o[ the cstahlished acaoemies ol' arto Artists were al so increasingly sUl'cess1'ul in establishing their own s),stems of support and education such as the
Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, thc New English Art Club, thc ,o-called Salan des R~fusés
and the Vienna Secession. In aH, thesc devclopments had the e[[eet o[
ampli[ying the sense that art was a separate realm from the Test of culture, gener ating the related illusions of aesthetie autonomy and artistie self-sufficieney. Artists and philosophers also made inereasing efforts to separate al'sthetic <jues tions trom moral and politieal debates. By the mid-nineteenth eentury, these aes thetic eonecrns -- having be en developnl to an immensely sophisticatcd level hegan to materialise explicitly in the fine arts. Trus quest [or artistie self-sufficiene), reaehed a sophisticatcd state of self-a\vareness '\... hen artists began to think o[ their works as having no relationship with the outside wOTld. As one o[ the characters 01' Osear Wilde stated: 'Art never expresses anything but itself . . . She develops purely on her own lines. She is not symbolie 01' any age. It is the ages that are her symbols, her reflections, her echoes.' 14 James Abbott McNeil \Vrustler is a good
24
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
example 01' an arti~t seeking to make their work self-sufficlcnt, demanding that it be observed by a gazc unobstructed by bourgeois values 01' practical efhciency
(whar cloes it Jo?) aod morality (what cloes it teJJ us?). Whistlcr famausly defended his painting in court, arguing thar its maio conecro
\\'a5
not with the reliable dcpic
tion al' the visible warld, but with forms (colours, tines and masses) and relations
üf forms. He later statcd that art should 'stand alone arrd appeaJ to the arti5tic sensc nf eye or ear. without confounding it .....,¡th cmatíans entirdy foreign to 11, as devo tion, love, patriotism arrd the Iib.~. AH these havc no kiod of conecrn with it, arrd . w hy l·mSlS! . 00 ca ti·mg my wor k s "arrangements" an d "h armomes . " .'i 5 t h at 15 Conspieuously, Whistler's conception of art is ha~ed on a further set of exciusions: he excludes the sentimental, moralising literary eontent popular in his day, perhaps for fcar that sueh associations are insufliciently pirraría!. In place of literary de ments, \Vhistler alludes to music, an art form he belicvcd had no representational value, one apprcciated lar its formal or aesthetic values a1one. Whistler \vas in favour of art being used to denote visual cultural production, and as sueh he expli citIy rejeeted the intelleetual, polítical and moral functions previously thought to be central to art. This notion of formal visual experimentation can be found in many artworks in the ensuing eentury. For cxample, Monis Louis' 1960 acrl'lie painting Bera Lambda (Figure 2.3) was, in his own words, about 'colour and surfacc. That's a1l.' 16 Such a definition is related to the theory 01' aesthetic formalism, an idea assodated \\-'ith
Figure 2.3 - Morris LouJ Scala, Florence.
figures such as Kant and critics sueh as Clivc Bell. Clement Greenberg and Miehael Fried. Despite thcir insistence on pure form, their theories of art also tended to
nature, the aesthetic e
promotc the idea that something b('comes art becausc it performs particularIunc
aesthetie coneerns. R
[jom. Indeed, numerous peoplc hold 'functionalist' theories of art without realising
feeling elated, can be
it. For example, to claim that art should makc one happy or should produce a feeling
or rust, which possess
of elation is to require that it fulfil these functions in order to daim 3rt status or
experiencing an artefa
'arthood'. To come hack 10 the specific case 01' formalism, the c1aim that art is
Nor is it possible to e
defined and unoerstood by 5ight alone seems rdatively easy to understand. In this
essential quality of a v
sense, it might have a demoeratising cffeet sinee it secmingly requires no knowJeogc
dasses of objeets'.
01' art history or theory, providing al1 with a system of comprehending art from aH
essarily mean that we \
periods of history. As sueh, formalism also sccms to eonfirm our most hasic
objeets aesthetiealIy nc
responses to art. As a universal theory of art, however, it is wrought with problems.
Artists and (,Tities 51
18
1
For Kant, an artwork was produced 'through a capadt)' for choice that grounds
an intellectual elite, n
its aetion5 in reason', 17 which is to sal' that artwork~ are man-made, dcliberately
art in the faee of 'POpl
Jcsígned objects. This suggests a dissimilarity hctween our experience of art and our
amongst cultural elite
expnienee of naturl', namely, that thc experience of nature involvcs the experiencl'
the middle classes and
01' 'free bcauty', ,",vhereas art is producefl by conscious human subjects. Hence, while
(or kitsch as Greenberg
01' nature is based on a non-conceptual aesthetie response, the expc
In tms sense, claims 1'0
the experienee
rienee of art cannot help bllt involve consifleration of what kind of a thing the paint
autonomy or elitism p
ing, seulpture or drawing is meant to be. Kant thus concluded that in contrast to
group in society able t
DEFINITION5 OF ART AND THE ART WORLD
25
.........
-~-_.-_
Figure 2.3 - Morris Louis, Bcra Lambda (1960) Ncw York, Museum of Modern Art. ~) Photo Scala, Florence.
naturc, the aesthetic expericnce of art i5 oot entircly 'free', since it 1S ticd to noo aesthetic conn~rns. By the same token, it is cIear that aesthctic effects, such as
feeling c1ated, can be promptcd by natural phenorncna, such as noises, landscapes or fust, which possess formal propertics but are not artworks. As such, the aet of expcricncing ao artefact acsthetically would oot justify classifying it as an artwork. Nor i5 it possible to claim convindngl)', as Bell does, that 'significant form i5 the essential quality 01' a work oE art, the quality which distinguishes it from aH other classes 01' objects'. ItI To l'ail to experience .ln artwork aesthetically wouId not nec essarily mean that we were not witnessing an artwork, sincc thc v\-'aY ..\'e experience objccts aesthetically need have nothing to do with how ,"ve classify them. Artists and critics such as Whistlcr, Bell or Greenberg 53\\' themselves as part nl' an intellectual elite, regarding it as their duty to defend and promote challenging art in the facc ol' 'popular' opposition. This attitude carne l'rom the growing sense amongst cultural elites in the nineteenth and twenticth centuries th.lt the rise ol' the middle classes and the spread of democracy vulgarised and commcrcialised art (or kitsch as Greenberg described thc popular productions ol' the culture industry). [n this sense, claims l'or the autonomy ol' art were tied to covert claims ol' cultural autonomy or elitism perpetuated by a particular dorninant or strategically located group in society able to project their views as impartial. Exclusion, the regulation
26
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
of art against weak imitations, was a dominant fcaturc of such a thcory of arto
mento The faet that Man2
Although such decisions are clearly historically relative and specific, formalist the ories tend to present such cxclusions as inevitable. For example, according to
senting it as art suggests the mundane and everyd(
Fried, 'the history of painting from Manet through Synthetic Cubism and Matissc may be characterised in tcrms of gradual withdrawal of painting fram the task of
is it required that the me siblc to call something 'al
representing reality - or 01' reality from the power al' painting to represcnt it - in favour of an increasing preoccupation with problems intrinsic to painting itself' .19 By providing a highly selective causal and continuous history of painting's separatc
If this is so, then perhaps
How things acquire n, dren 's l'able Throllgh the
ness from the world, Fried inadvertently reveals that such values are historically spe
Carroll famously formuh
cifle products and practiccs rather than socially transcendent. To see such painting
as something concerned mainly with its own problems, as Fried does, we would need to have recourse to a body of knowledge that lies outsidc what we see bcfore our eyes. As such, the democratic claims made by sorne formalists are jeopardised, for ,",ve never do simply 'sec what ,\.'C get'. As a theorv , ol' art ' formalism turns out to be too narrow. Bell even went so far as to claim that most artefacts that we most commonly think of as art were not: '1 cannot believe that more than onc in a hundrcd nf thc works produccd bctwccn 1450 and 1850 can be properly described as a work of art.'20 Bell's foeus on the appearanee ol' art over its role exc1udes works ol' art and ways of lnterpreting it that are primarily focused on issues of history, ideas, meaning and representation, seeing the past as an inevitable preview ofhis prescnt-day interests. In this, formal
ism is essentJalist, an attempt to isolate 'art' artificially l'rom the way it is revealed to us in experience in order to locatc its m)'Stcry ingredients. Works of art are not necessarilv autonomous objects; they are record s ol' culture, or the world as seen
,
by particular peoplc at specific times. Formalism systematically obscures and denies its social and historical determinants, perceiving art and artists as extraor dinarv and timeless. Clearlv, art is acleasr the product of the historical events 1have
-
,
described. The simple l'act that formalism cannot account l'or the way that art has always been experieneed bears testimony to the faet that it is not a universal defi nition of arto While formalism is thus Hawed, it does at least provide a direction for artists to pursuc by pcrsuasivcly forcgrounding ccrtain dcvclopmcnts in art as paradigmatic and seminal, at the expense ol' others, which are deemed unimportant. Where does this Icavc us in rclation to Judd's definition ol' art? His exasperated comment was an attempt to validate and enfranchise the art of the 1960s, a period of rapid cul tural and political experimentation in ,",vhieh a narrO\v and inhospitable modernism '\'as supplanted by wbat Rosalind Krauss latcr callcd an 'cxpandcd ficld' for art. 21 The so-called de-definitional impulse that swept through art practice in the 1960s Icd to a transformed conception of art based on altcrnativc philosophical premises. Judd realised that l'ormalist theories were inadequate to explain the status of works such as Picro Manzoni's Artist's Shit (1961), a tin can containing thc artist's cxcrc
'When I use a
WOI
means just what 1 el
Humpty Oumpty is a rela tive standards of authorit \\'ords. It may be that we
communication to take p constraint upon the use oJ il' it is to he uscful. Manzc
by his social investment i
cxeremcnt for future gen
knowledge 01' tbe hjstory
of found ohjects), l'actors as an artist. Anyone can ( would secm to dcmand ti
which this authority is ac~ dictum, something that su art that was multiplc and
One important theory th theory of art, or procedur
dated wüh the philosoph:
ol' Picrre Bourdieu. 23 Wh thcir views, although we 1
only in an historieal and cr Art is not, in this view, pr
or procedures. 'To see so the eye cannot decry - an of art; an artworld.' 24 FOI
DEFINITIONS OF ART AND THE ART WORLD
27
ment. The fact that Manzoni gave his signature to such an ohjeet as a means of pre senting it as art suggcsts that he, and not just anyone, had the power to transform the mundane and everyday into a work of art. If we are to sal' that something is art, is it required that the meaning of the term 'art' have sorne limits? Must it be pos sibil' to cal! something 'art' and be wrong ifthe word is to have an)' meaning at all? II' this is so, then perhaps Judd ,vas Y,irong in an important sense. How things acquire names has puzzled philosophers for centuries. In his chil dren's fable Throuah the Lookina Glass and What Alice Found TheTe (1872), Lewis CarroIl famously formulated this logieal problem: 'When 1 use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornfu] tone, 'it means just what I choose it to mean neither more nor lcss.' 21 Humpty Dumpty is a relativist, one who daims that there are no external or ohjec tive standards of authorit)' by which an individual might veril'y or refute the use 01' words. It may be that we cannot find an absolute form of authority, but, if ' . . 'e wish communication to take place, we can at Icast dcmand that thl're he sorne form of constraint upon the use 01' words. In this sense, the term 'art' must have constraints if it is to be useful. Manzoni's US(: of thc tcrm 'art' sc(:ms to han:- been constrained by hi.<; social investment in art in:'ititutions (signified by his desire to preserve his excrement for future generations to ('njo)), its authorial signs (signatures) and his knowlcdge 01' the history of art (that Cubism and Dada \\'ere precedents for the use of found objects), factors which helped him manuf.:lctLIrc his 'professional' repute as an artist. Anyonc can daim arthood for what they do, but to do so convincina{v wouId seem to demand the tailored acqui~ition of an air of authority. Thc ways in which this authorit)' is acguired are far more complex and negotiable than in Judd's dictum, something that su~g('sted that a new theory of.:lrt was ncccssary to explain art that was multiplc and open-cndcd.
Art as an Institution One important theory that emerged in the 1960s was known a.s thc institutional thcory 01' art, or proceduralism. Proceduralism is a theory 01' art most dosely asso ciated with the phiIosoph), of Arthur Danto and George Dickie and thl' sociology
01' Pierrc Bourdieu. 23 While these writers are contemporaries, they also differ in their views, although we couId 5a)' that they share the idea that art can be defined onl)' in an historical and critical contcxt that makcs it rclevant to social institutions. Art is not, in this view, produced for ~ffictj it is created by following a set of rules or procedures. 'To see something as art,' wrotc Danto, 'reguires something that the eye cannot decry - an atmosphere 01' artistic theory, knowledge of the history of art; .:In artworld.'24 For Danto, art worlds havc always bl'en construeted from
28
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
the interrelated efforts al' artists, the history al' art, changing conditions of display,
10 helow on authorship. "
critical writings and the responses ol' audiences. For Danta, the production ol' art
socio-historical character
is highly dependent on such funden expericnce, what is possihlc in art
00\'"
being
histor)' merel)' contradk1:s
ingfulness have difhculty'
reliaot on what has come hefore. Proceduralism has a number of benetits. First, ir allows ar~thin8 potentially to
to elude making sense, su
becornc art, although there are limitations. Danto c1aims that at aoy specific time,
level, [rom a proceduralis1
the art world allows only esteerncd figures to propase sometmng as arto In addi
This largcly dcfeats the in
tion, ",hat they might propase to be art will, in turn, be limitcd by the course that
posits that the neo-avant-g
su eh an artist has directed the artworld. To illustrate this paint, he argues that Paul
01' art in its own right.
Cézanne would not have been able to prescnt his tie as a readymade, whereas Pablo
Another oh"ious weakr
potentially to become an
institution. It cannot be el
artist by following rules. In this sense, it ma)' be more egalitarian than formalist
the poli ce . ~ince it has no s
accounts sincc it does not s"ek to mystif)' art by referring the Yicwcr or artist to
tion ofartists, crities, deal(
Picasso might hav" been.)5 Proceduralism a110ws
the immeasurable
an'y0ne
tj}eets 01' the work. This means that intuiti"c dehnitions of art are
politieians and others. Son
ruled out explieitly; the 'innocent e:'e' found in formalism is regan-lcd as a sociall)'
We discuss the art \'mrld
prnduced myth. MoreovCT, it is ah1c to account for conceptual artworks, works of
of the media when confraI
;<
art that had no tangihle material or visual form and readily adapt to the expansive
Icmatic in its emphasis on t
ehanging character of arto As Danto puts it:
could be seen to be respor
occurred sincc the 1960s. i The greatcr the variety of aesthetica1ly relevant predicates, the more complex
in:-titutional theory contai
thc individual members of the artworld become; and the more one knows of
illto rhetoric by encouragit
the entire population ol' the artworld, thc richer one's experience with any
duction f]uestioned many e
of its members. 16
entered into the rcalm of r
This raises the qucstion ' Such a theory eliminates the necd to think of art as exclusive, since it transforms
of art in contemporary het
art into a descriptive rather than an evaluative termo Art i5 no longer 'hne'; it i5
eduralist dehnitions of art ¡
simply a \Vay of descrihing something that carries no sensc ol' inhercnt value.
of complexit)'. David Wils,
Indeed, alt art can be judgcd under the same criteria since proceduralism rejects
California, for example, 'h
'n~alíst'
as we1l as th" qucstion of' orate art installation'. 28 F(
theories of rcpresentation, holding that a11 artworks refer to other art
works via the historv of' art and ib social institutions rather than
lO
thc 'world' .
Proceduralism has it problems nevntheless. Since the theory is concerncd with
faet, overblown truths and
art as a form of communication, it rules out the notion that art might fail to signify.
demonstrate unusual or ct
For Danto, thc inability to interpret an art\.vork marks its failurc to achic"e art
that can fly through lead
status. Artists havc to prove that they intend to make statcments through thcir
ingesting prongcd stink an
\\'ork, that they are not simply manipulating signs for thcir own sake. Therc are two
Mary Davis of Saughall, el
main problems with this causal view of art. First, it assumes that we can determine
history of display:
our judgcments oi' artistic intention on the cvidence of objects alone, when material effeets and aets ha\o'e no essential m<.~aning other than those that wc bring to them. This is partícularly oifficult when C'onsidering found art ohjects, many
01'
which, being mass-produced an~ identical, bear little trace of intentional produ<.> tion. In this, Danto risks committing the 'intentional fa1laey' exploren in chapter
To put sacred works i aesthetic significance
chronological order f relation oE earlier to l;
OEFINITIONS OF ART ANO THE ART WORLO
29
10 heloV\' on authorship. This is partly avoided, perhaps, by Danto's stress on the socio-historieal eharaeter of art, but trus endeavour to projeet 'meaning' into history merely contradi(·ts his emphasis on cause. Second, Danto's eriteria ofmean ing1'ulness have ditticulty aeeounting for irrational and ahsurdist art that strugglcs to elude making sen se, sueh as Darla, surrealism or Fluxus. Moreover, at a basie level, from a proceduralist point of view, llllCl-art is unquestionably regarded as art. This large1y defeats thc intentions of anti-artists 01' the 1960s and earlier in that it posits that the neo-avant-garde assault on the eonventions of art constitutes a form of art in its own right. Another ohvious weakness lies in the assumption that the art world rea1ly is an institution. It cannot be claimecl that it is regulatcd likc othcr institutions such as the poliee, sinee it has no set consensual values. The art world is a loose eonfigura tion of artists, critics, dealcrs, curators, collectors, eommissioners, administrators, politieians and others. Sorne 01' these individuals share sorne ideas, others do not. We diseuss the art \vorld as a rnonolithic institution, and this is a popular pursuit of the media when eon1'ronted hy art that they do not like. Proeeduralism is prob lernatie in its ernphasis on the power of the institutions ofhigh art and in man)' ways could be seen to he responsible for the inereased bureaueratisation 01' art that has occurred since the 1960s. In heralding the 'cnd nf art' as far hack as 1964, Danto 's institutional theor)' eontained the seeds 01' its own destruetion, transforming art into rhetorie by encouraging a 'linguistic turn'. Thc cnsuing pcriod of artistic pro duction qucstioned man)' of thcse assumptions, while showing that sueh ideas haye entered into the realm of reeeived artistie ideas. 27 This raiscs thc qucstion 01' whcthcr or not it is dcsirablc to seek a general tht:>ory 01' art in eontemporary heterogeneous visual culture. Sinee the early 1960~, proc cduralist dcfinitions 01' art havc heen thoroughly absorbed and taken to IWW levels ol' eomplexity. David Wilson's Museurn of Jurassie Teehnology (MJT) in Culver, California, for cxampIe, 'has lcft visítors puzzling over the veracity of its exhibits as we1l as the question 01' whether it is an actual museum or sorne kind of elab orate art insta1lation'.n Formcr spccial cffeets dcsigner Wilson mixes together faet, ovcrblown truths and hoax. In the MjT, emphasis is plaeed on objeets 'that demon.strate unusual or CllrlOllS technological qualitics'29 such as rainforest bats that can By through lead wa1ls, MeBolaponera Foetens (funga1ly-infeeted, spore ingesting pronged stink ants of the Cameroon) and a horn grown on the head of Mary Davis of Saughall, Cheshire. The MjT tackles a number ofkey issues in the
history of display: To put ,'iacred work.'i in a secular setting assumes that these artefaets possess acsthctic signifieancc o\'cr and aboye their religious meaning. Placing them in chronological order presupposes that this is the best way to understand the rclation oI' carlicr to later art. Segrcgating artworks from minerals, shells and
30
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
animals implies that artefacts have a special ¡dentitl" Preserving these arte
today? In 1995 in the nc
facts implies that they are best seeo as historical records. 30
that they had liule oppo
crcate theirown institut The system of organisation found in the MJT questions these very assumptions by
artists saw themselves
aping the organisational systcm of the curiosity cabinets, drawing no clcar lioe
othcr time ami space in
between art and non-art, fact and fiction, authority and imagination. Wilson sees
varied and generally nor
no prc-cxisting. csscntial arder to history; arder emerges onl)" within thc MJT's
The evcnts were organi
¿¡
peculiar narratives. In this, Wilson aims to make seeing oracular again, to reinte
Programme' , as a mean
gratc people with wonder ,..., hile dra\'/ing attcntion to the muscum's idcological
autonomous artists, 'Ti
role in a self-conscious way that has 001)' recently become possible in wake ofproc
cgy succeedcd in Manci
eduralist theories of arto
establish their own mic
This has been explored by major modern and contemporary art museums such
to know what thev, weI
as the predominately privatcl)'-funded MOMA in New York and thc mainly state
self-proclaimed autono
funded Tate Modern in London. Both institutions have abandoned the linear and
Sccession of the late n
historical models of display that once dominated the historical exhibition and of
attitude. This had a part
Western art, modcls that MOMA was influential in forming. In their place are thc matic devices that seek to elaborate important issues within twentieth- and t\.venty first-century art practices, looking 'at the art of the last hundred years from the vantage point 01' four separate themes that cut right through history'. 31 The
While Enlightenment 1
'Anxious Objcct' room in thc Tate Modern, for exampie, displays \\'orks by major
today', local and globa
artists in vitrines in order to rehabilitate and remind audiences of the cabinets of
rnented than before. D
past displays. The works in this space seem to be located bctween objects deliber
calI), anywhere in the
ately fabricated as \-\'orks of art and found objects of curiosity. To sorne, this exem
audience they wish to a
plHies art as an institutional game to be played out by curators and organised like
the world, allowing ar
a stamp collcction, cut offfrom any sense 01' living culture in an entertaining state endorsed spectacle. 12 Perhaps this is an unfair criticism. Tate Modern has learned
audience instantly. It w(
its lcssons from critiques ol' the authority ano exclusivity 01' museums inaugurated
recourse to well-establ
by the disciplines of art history, art theory amI museology. Unfortunatcly, its
justification. In sorne w
authoritative stance on its chosen issues seems to unoerrnine the element of sur
nominate something as
prise and anti-establishment readings 01' art that it seeks to achieve. This is evident
Unlike Danto's idea of ¡
tion to oeclare that
~
in Herzog & de Meuron's commanding architectural conversion of Giles Gilbert
inately by theories of art
Scott's Bankside Power Station and also in Tate Modern's propensity towards a
an overabundance of
didactic curatorial approach. B Architecturally, Tate Modern is modelled on artist
of their roles. In this di
aa
initiated warehouse exhibitions popular in London and elsewhere in the late 1980s.
describe any number 01
In this, it attempts to ape more contemporary conditions of oisplay favoureo by
articulation. As such, ti
artists who founo themsclves exduded from the pantheons 01' arto However, like
tinue to revolve around
man)' major contemporary art museums around the world, Tate Modern wants to
arthood. They cannot
remain the official national British institution of contemporary art and be perceived
art's definition will ev(
as a major world player, lending this power to everything it sanctions. 34
terrns of what it is not.]
1
Are such grandiose venues and their accompanying bureaueracies really required
more challenging quest
for bestO\ving the appropriate context in which to produce or display \·vorks of art
demand more of their e
DEFINITlüN5 üF ART AND THE ART WüRLD
31
toda),? In 1995 in the northern English eit)' of Manchcster, a group af artists, finding that thcy had Httle opportunity to exhibit their \-vork in their municipality, dccided to create their own in5titution.'O ''''ithollt the sanc:tion ofthe leading artworld figures. Thc artists saw themselves as their 0\\'11 bes! crities, a pccr group that could award each other time and spacc in which to show their work on their own terms. Venues \-vere varied and generall)' non-sanctionecl, ranging from pcoplc'shouscs to the Tmvn Hall. The ('vents weTe organiscd around the ironically distinguished legend 'Thc Annual Prograrnme', as a means ofattracting attcntion. 35 As a group nl' self-organised, quasi autonomous artists, 'The Annual Programme' were far from unique, but their strat egy succeeded in Manchestcr, providing them with the infrastructure they needed to estahlish their own microcosmic art world, thereby allO\\'ing the rest of the world to know ","hat they were accomplishing. lndecd, their strateg), had its roots in the self-proclaimcd autonomy to be 1'ound in avant-garrle movements from the Vienna Secession
01' the late ninetecnth ccntury to punk's pop/anti-art 'do-it-yourself'
attitude. This had a particularly strong heritagc in ManchcstL'r..H"
Conclusion While Enlightenment models
01' institutional and thcorctical authority ~till exist,
torlay's local and glohal art \\'orlds are bigger, more Huid, multivalent and frag mented than before. Due to travei and technology, artists can make work practi eall)' anywhcre in the ,...'orld, ,,"ith virtually anything, l'or almost any pcn:eived audience they wIsh to attrad. Digital mass communication is rapidly transforming the world, allowing artists to rilsseminate their cultural productions to a global audiencC' instantl),. It would scem that today's artists are, more than ever, in a posi tion to declare that ",hat they do is art (persuasivcly or otherwise) without recourse to well-estahlished, centrally sanctioned authorities or meta-theorctical justification. In sorne ways, perhaps, Juod wasn't so wrong after aH. The power to nominate soml'thing as art has come to be seen as dispersed rather than possesscd. Unlike Danto's idea ol' a limiten and ddinahle art world that is inhabited predom inatcly hy lneurie:i ol' art, today's art world is a rapiol)' cxpanding spacc occupied by an overabundance ol' Qgcnts, mediators who constantl)' seek to redefine the limits oftheir roles. In this climate, 'ar1' beco mes an increasingly vacuous term, used 10 describe any number of activities, regulating art onl)' at the moment of each new articulation. As such, the important questions presC'ntly do not (and cannot) con tinue to revolve around ohlique and circuitous de-bates ofho'\\' something achicves arthood. They cannot continue sincc, as Danto argues, continual broadening ol' ar1's dcfinition will eventually make it impossible to define art scmantically in terms of ".·hat it is noto 17 Torlay's highl)' visually litcrate audiences ask trusting and more challcnging questions of artists and what they do, ,.. ·hile artists c'Ontinue to demand more 01' their ever-diversil'ying audienccs.
32
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Further Reoding Duncan, Carolo C1V1lismg Riwo!s: InSlde Pubhe Art ;l1useulIIs (Lonuon. 1995.\.
Harríngton, Austin. Arr and Social Thwry (OxforJ, 2001).
Shiner, Larry. Thc lnventJOn Art: a euhum! Hucory (Chicago, 2001),
Williams, Robert. A.rr The0r.r:an HistonúJJ InlfoJuetlOn (OxforJ, 2004).
#
Notes Donald Judd, 'Arl after Philosophy " , StudlO IntematJOna], Oclober 1969, pp. 134-7. "2 Scc l::rnst Gombrich, 'The Rf'naissance Conccption ol' Artistic Progrcss', ;\'orm and /wm (London, 1966), pp. 1-10.
In classical antiquit)' th..:- terms for 'art' (0'5 in Latin and rechne in Gn'ck) Jenoted skill, and art \\-'as dccmed une (low-ranking) skill amongst many ather:;. For a hricf sketch of the con notations of thc t('rm, see Ro)' Harris, Thc .1I..!cccsw)' C?IArtspeak (Lonoon and Ne\-\' York, 2003), pp. 15-2H. 4 See Susan L. Feagin ano Craig Alh~n Subler, 'Showing Picturl.'~: Aesthetics and thl.' Art Galler}', The jouma] c:.fAes[hetie EJw<J/lon, Vol. 27 (1993). pp, 6J- 72. 5 See Brendan O'Doherty, InsJJc rhe l[hile Cube: the lJeoloa}" rif [he Gol/er) Spacc (Los Angeles, 1999). SI.'I.' too Russellllelk, Collecrina Jn a Consuma Societ)' (London, 199S). 6 See Paula f.indlcn, PossessIn8 .I\¡'ature: Museums. Collcctlrl,g and SCJentific Culll.H" m l:.'ar~r Modem lt'Jly (Los Angeles, 1994); and Lorraine Daston anO Katherine Park, ~t(>nders anJ rh.: Order c:fNawre, 1100 1750 (New York, 1998). 7 Sl.'e -Iom Barringcr, C%nwhsm and [he ObJeer (Lonoon, 1998). Set~ too Ton)' Bennett, The Bmh cf [he jfuseum: HHfory, Theory, PO!JtlCS (London, 1995); ano Oli..·er Impey and Arthul" ~1acGregor, eds, 7he Ori8Jns ?fMuscum.\.' Th.: Cobinet q[Curwsltle.\ In Sin.:enth- and Sel'enteenlh Ccntur.y Europe (Oxforo, 1985). 8 For a recent account ofmuseum in relation to lhe nation state. see \lil'k Prior, it.fU'ieUm.l tlnd .+loderml} (Oxford, 2002). 9 Zygmunt Bauman, MoJemit)' and A.mbIvolence (Cambrioge, 1991). 10 Sec Annr('v.' Bowie, AesthetlCl anJ Sublee/lVIt)' (Manchcster, 2003). 11 See hnmanuel Kant, The CrH14ue q[ the POlVer c:IjuJ8ement, transo Paul Guyer and F.rie Matthews (Cambrioge, 2002). 12 S..' e Terry Eaglcton, The ldeolo.qy rif the Aesthetle (Oxford, 1990). See espccially 'Frce Particulars' (pp. 13-30) and 'Thc Kantian Imaginary' (pp. 70- 101 ). 13 A thorough critique' of the racial bias of dghté'enth-centur), acsthctic theories, including that of Kan\, ha~ been ofTcred by Daúo Bindman, From Ape w Apollv' Aenhetics anJ ¡he IJeG vj Raee Jn ¡he b8hreenlh Cenrur) (London, 2002), 14 'Vivian', in Osear Wilde's satirical manifesto, 'The Dt'ca} 01' Lying: A Dialogue', in Janh's Knowles, ecl., The Niner.eenth Centur:,r:a /rfonth~r ReneM, Vol. XXV Oanuary June 1889), p.S1. 15 james Ahhott McNeill Whistler. 'kn (1 'C/ock Lee/ure al Pnnres Hall, PiecaJJ!lj·, London (l ondon, 1S85¡ 16 Cited in Ellen H. John~on, Amencan Artists fln Arr: FrvfT] 1940 1980 (\lew 'York, 1982), p. 50. 17 Kant, Crmque c:l rhe PVH'"Cf c:fJud8emem, § 43 p. 182. 18 Clive Bell, Aa (Oxfonl, [90S7), p. 8. First published in 1914. 19 Miehael hieo, Thrcc .'!.makan PQlnrers: Kennclh No}anJ,jules Ohtsb, Frank Stella (Camhringe, MA, 1965), p. 5 20 Rcll, ArI, p. 46.
21 Sé'C Rusalino Krauss, '5 22 rhe Pensuln Complete Lel 23 See Georg,e Dickie, :Ir Pierre llounlieu, [)iscin
24 Arthur Danto, 'The Ar 25 See Anhur Danto, 'Tl (1973), pp. 1-17. 26 Danto, 'The Artworld' 27 See Reesa Greenherg, 28 RalfRugoff, 'Rulesofl his nrst permanent Ml Vcnice Roule,'an.1, Cut Ernst Osthaus Museurr Mr. W¡}son's Cablnc¡ rifH 29 David Wilson, IntroJuci 30 David Carrier, The D (19S7), p. 83. 31 Lars Nittve, 'Director'. 32 Sec i\1atthew Collings, 33 See Carol Duncan, Cin H '[Tate Modero] aims t( one of the premier glol Local', 7(1[e Modem: The 3:. See Richard J. William! JI GooJ In Mancheslet (N 36 See Howard Slater, 'G Issue 3 (1998). 37 As Danto states: '',\'he art,\'orld ha.~ shadeJ inl The lranllsurQtlon if th.
DEFINITION5 OF ART AND THE ART WORLD
33
21 Sec Rosalind Krau~s, 'Sculpture in the Expanded Field'. Oetaba, No. 8 ([ 979), pp. ~ 1 44. 22 7ne Penguin Complete ¡ ewis (arwJl (Harmonds,\'orth, 1983). p. 196. 23 See George Oickie, Art and tne Aesrhetlc in fn)"rirWlOnal AniJ[ysis (Ithaca, NY, 1974); ami Pic:rre l-{ourJieu, Dístinc/Íon; iJ SOCÍal Cntulue oj"rhe judgemenl '!.F [aste (Cambridge, t 984). 24 Arthur Danto, 'The Arh\'orld.',journal ?fPhllosophy. Vol. 61 (1964), p. 580. 25 Sec Anhur Danto, 'The Last Work 01' Art. Art\\'orks ,md Real Things', lheona, VoL 39 (1973), pp. 1-17. 26 Danto, 'The ArtworlJ', pp. 581 4. 27 St'e Rcesa Greenberg, Thinkln8 aboLlt Exh¡bilil>rls (London, 1996). 28 RalfRugofF, 'Rules orlhe (;amc', Frieze (Januak (London, 2000), p. to. 32 ~e Matthe\.... Collings. ,~rr (uu)' .""atíon (Lundon, 200 [). 33 Scc Carol Duncan, CJl1fumg R/t!lals: 1m/de Pub}¡c Art MW'eums (Ne\\' York, 1995). 34 '[Tah' Modero] aims to be "a tlagship for London", "a ne\\' landmark for the nation", and one uf the premier' global centres uf modcrn art.' Doreen Massey, 'Banksick: lnternaüona] Local', Tate .Modern: The Handbook, p. 27. 3~ See Richard J. \ViHiams, 'Anything is Pos.~ibk: The Annual Prugrammc 1995-2000', in lS Good in .11anchester (Manchestcr, 2001). 36 See Howard Slater, 'Graveyard & Ballroom: A Factor)' Records Scrapbook', BreakIFl¡'w, IssuE' 3 (199H). 37 As Danto states: 'Whcn philosoph),'s paintíngs, gre), in grey, are pan ol' the artworld, the art\\orld has shadcd intu its O\\'n philosuph)', ancl hy definition, gro\\ n old.' Arthur lhnto, The Tranifí811rmjon c:/the Common pldce (CambriJge, MA, 1981), p. 148.
'iJe
trast to heing industrial
3. Concepts of Craft
based on manual produc erally associatcd with in bascd production of the
Juliette MacDonald
During tbis period, valuC's rclating to ideals historical continuitv , and
hy the growth of moder: comp1ex and tense relal twentieth-century art an than a prívate hobby tha! conscqucnce al' this is th it)', in contrast to fine art
central part of cultural a as many feminíst critics
inhercntly jeminine pursu w hich has again made it 1 more 'masculine' practic These multiple defini
Introduction
raised nurnerous probler havc objccted to heing rf
Thc meaning of the tCTm 'eraft' has undergone numcrous transformatlons. Its var
ignated as eraft, because
iable senses havc had long-term lmplieations for both praetitioners and for ~uhs('
They prefcr instearilo be
quent critical analysis. Une of the most oiffieult problcms for the erafts centres on
enable them to distance t
the evolution of the meaning uf the word itself. Long estahUshed in the English lan
the expectation that wh
cra:.fr ean be traeed hack to earl)' medieval times wherc ir su~ested
üthers have found the ter
guagc, the vvord
a combination 01' intelligenec, skill and strength, a set oI' eonnotations retained in
as a eraftsperson. As th
the cognatc term 'eraft)". Although eraft is no\\' usually cquated wiLh applied art,
example: '1 am a potter, al
dccorative art or l~Vcn handicraft, these notions are relatively reCl~nt. Even in the
which belong
lo
a long h
late the eivhteenth eenturv it had a mueh broader se! of meanings. As Paul
cven no\\'. Just as the gay
Grecnhalgh has stated: 'eraft did not imply speeific methods, or trades or objeet
time for us to cclebrate a
.
'"
types ... It had no eonstitueney, ir couId he applied to an)' form of practice within
conecrning the terminolc
the culture. It ' ....as not a thing in itsclf.' 1 The eoncept of eraft is thus a modern one,
craft as a practice continu
('ven if many ol' the practiccs it refE'rs to havc a mueh longcr history; indeed, the
term denotes has been su
coneept of eraft signifies a fundamental re-interpretation of the meaning oI' the applied and dccorative arts prompted by the aovent of industrial modernity.
The meaning oI' 'eraft'
often heen defined in ter 'design'. At times, eraft ~
eraft. Art and Modernity
ano at other times it
Undoubtcdly the most irr During the eourse of the ninetccnth century 'eraft' gradualIy bccome more spc
.
cHic sueh that by the end of the 1800s it dcnoted somethinv made by fJ,md, in eon
,
'"
bet",,'ecn art and eraft. In I the arts and erafts was
Ul
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
3S
trast to bcing industrially produced, and 'craftsman' a persan whosc living was bascd on manual production. Indecd, the ter m 'manufacture', wbich i5 now gcn erally associated w¡th industrial output, originally denoted the small-scale, hand based production 01' thc craftsman. During this period, too, the hand-crafted object came to be endo'v\'Cd with valucs relating to idcals of a pre-industrial societ)' in which vernacular processes, historical continuíty and the scnsc of communal belonging had yet to be displaced
by the growth o[modcrnitr On this account alone 'eraft' has undergone an often complex and tense relationship with modern culture and man)' oI' the values of t\ventieth-ccntury art and designo In addition, craft i8 freguently seen as Httle more than a private hohby that functions as an outlet for private ereativit)'. A significant consequenee of this ís that eraft is widel)' pereeived as a rather ínsignifieant activ it)', in eontrast to fine art, for example, \\'hieh has long been regardcd as forming a central part
01' cultural and sociallife. A further dimension to this is rhe raet that,
as many feminist erities have pointed out, 'crafr' has heen seen eonsistently as an
inherentlyJeminine pursuit linked to the sphere uf domestie life, a eharacterisation whieh has again molde it dithcult for eraft to be seen as of equal ímportance to the more 'masculine' praetiees 01' art. These multiple dcfinitions have 01't en been the souree 01' confusion and have raised numerous problems within the practice of eraft itself. Some practítíoners have ohjeeted to being reterred to aS a 'eraftsperson', or to their work heing des ignated as eraft, beeause they feel the term is patronisíng and bclittles their skíll. They prcf('r instead to be known as artists or designer-artists heeause these tcrms cnahle them to distan ce themselves from notion5 of amateur aetivity and to avoid the expectation that what thcy produce will be traditional. utiHtarian objeets. Othcrs have found thc term less prohlematic and indecd, are proud to be deseribed as a craftsperson. As the Canadian eeramieist, Paul Mathieu, has argued, for exarnplc: '1 am a pottcr, and what l do is eraft: I have no problem \\'ith those words. vvhieh belong to a long history that has no reason to envy any other eraft or art, even no\\'. Jusr as the gay communit)' has appropriated the term "queer", so it is time for liS to celehrate anew certain terms that define what we do.' ~ The debate eoneerning the terminology for makers eontinues. What is clear, however, is that eraft as a praeticc eontinues ro dcvclop and change, and as a eonsequence what the term denotes has been suhjcct to the same shifts in meaning. The meaning of 'craft' is given further eomplexit)' h)' the faet that it has most often been dcfined in terms 01' íts relaríon to two other concL'pts: 'fine o1rt' and 'design'. At times, eraft has been seen as indistinguishablc from one or the other, and at other times it has heen defined through its diffirence from them. llndouhtedly the most important development was the gcncsis 01' the distinction between art and eraft. In classical antiquity and the Middle Ages thc separation of the arts amI erafts was unknown; índeed rhe Latin term alS from whieh 'art' i5
36
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
derived denoted a particular skill or eraft. Within the medieval system ofknowl
edge what we would now consider to be art and eraft both fell under the category üf thc liberal arts (artes liberales), which included grarnmar, rhetoric, dialectics, music, arithmetic, geometry and astronorny. As Umbcrto Eco has statcd, art 'meant construction, whether it was al' a ship or al' a building, a painting or a
hammer. The word artifex applied alike to blacksmiths, orators, poets, paintcrs and sheep-shearers.' 3 A divisioo between fine and decorative art, or between art and eraft, emerged during the Renaissancc in thc fiftccnth and sixtccnth ccnturics, hut it was not until the eighteenth century, the age al' Enlightenment, that an absolute division bctwccn thc two hcgan to opcn Up.4 This was givcn philosophicallcgiti
macy in Kant's Cntique i:!f the Power i:!fJudgement, which insisted on the distinction hetwcen thc 'fine art' of 'gcnius' on thc one hand, and thc applicd arts, or what Kant terms 'handicraft', on the other, which he regarded as based on mere tech nical skill, undcrtakcn primarily for financial remuncration. 5 This process had also been evident at an institutionallevel when, during the same period, painters and sculptors lefL the 10ng-esLablished medieval guild s)'stem and joined the ne"vl)' formed Academics of fim' arto
Edward Burne Jones an orative arts and to infh:
highlighting the equalir
In a lecture entitled dangcrs to al! forms aL
I shall not meddle
the great arts eorn] mind quite sever t
havc to speak abou ditions ol' lifc, thal
when they are so p: trivial, meehanica" upon them hy fash practised l'or a whi sure to lose their d
to unmeaning porr
By the earl)' 1800s an established hierarchy was in place which distinguished between painting and sculpture on the one hand, and the decorative arts on the other. 6 At the same time, however, the relative position of the decorative and the fine arts remaincd a subject ol' constant dcbate. Many \\-'fiters on cral't or the dec orative arts argued eloquently in their defence and agitated for their inclusion within the field of fine art and high culture. For cxamplc, thc art critic John Ruskin (1819-1900) even went as far as to state: 'There is no existing highest-order art
Clearly, Morris belicved to the whim 01' fashion
value within socieLy. MI the popular culture bee< thc cultural elite. Here
tion that has persisted ir
hut that it is decorative. Get rid then at once of any idea of decorative art h(~ing a degraded or a separate kind 01' art.'7
aH)" rigorous practice ir guestion of materials.
lt is impossible to talk of the formation of modern discourse on craft without mentioning William Morris (1834-96). Morris was a designer, social reformer and poet, and he remains the most famous and influential figure in thc British crafts movemcnt. He agreed with Ruskin's asscrtion that decorative arts were as valuahle as fine arts, and he also fought vociferousl)' against the division between the two. Following Ruskin's ideas, he looked hack nostalgically to the Middle Ages when there was no dHference 01' prestige among the arts and crafts, and he warned of the danoers to aH forms of art from this hierarchy. Linked to this was a social concern D , with the dehumanising effects 01' modern mass produetion, in the face of which Morris argued for a return to a more organic, non-alienatcd form of work. In an attempt to put his ideas into practice, he formed what was to beeome a highly suc cessful eraft: business, Morris and Co. The aim of this firm was to bring together artists, designers and arehitects with complementary skil1s to \York on decorative art projeets. The ambition of Morris and his eolleagues (who, when the firm was first set up in 1861, included the Pre-Raphaelite artists Dante Gabriel Rossetti,
It cannot be denied t erafts, partieularly thrOl thc essential characterist
of the highest aesthetic s utopian amI, despite the
practicc to that accorde( Whv , did Morris and
One of the principal di¡¡¡
merits of hand- and mac
the 1850, the Industrial
life; the feudal strueture é capitalist and industrial
middle class and urban c
with everyday domestic, replaecd by mass-produc
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
37
Edward Burne Jones and Ford Madox Brown) was to sct new standard s in the dec orative arts and to influcnce the general public in terms of good taste, as well as highlightjng thc equality of craft production with that of art. In a lecture entitled 'The Lesser Arts', Morris spoke 01' his corrccrns about the dangers to all forms of art from the split betwccn arts and crafts: I shall not meddle much with the great art of Architecture, and stillless with the great arts commonly ealled Sculpture and Painting, yet! cannot in my own mind quite scyer them from those lesser, so called Decorative Arts, which I have to speak about: it i5 only in lattcr times and under the most intricate con ditions ol' Jife, that they han: fallen apart from one another: and I hold that, when they are so parted, it is ill for the Arts altogcther: the lesser ones become trivial, mechanical unintelligcnt, incapable of resisting the changes pressed upon them by fashjon or dishonest)'; while the greater, howeyer thc)' mal' be practised for a ,,,,hile by men ofgrcat minds and wonder-working hands ... are sure to lose their dignity of popular arts and become nothing but dull adjuncts to unmeaning pomp or ingenjous lOys l'or a few rich or idle men,s Clearl)', Morris belicved that ifthe division continued, crafts ,,",ouId become subject to the whim of fashion - am) al so lose their intcllectual oasis - thereby losing their value within society. Mcanwhile, art would simultancously cease to bE' rooted in the popular culture because it v<'Ould become no more than an ¡dIe amusement 01' the cultural elite. Here one sees the restatement of a familiar conceptual distinc tion that has persisted in Western culture, whercby art was seen as an intellectu aHy rigorous practice in contrast to eraft, which \\'as oricnted primariI} to the question 01' matcrials. It cannot be denied that Morris succl'cded in injecting a new vitality into the crafrs, particularly through his renewed emphasis on the importance of retainjng the essential characteristics of the medieyal idiom. Yet his attcmpts to create crart of the highest aesthetic standards werc perceived by mao)' as merely idealistic and utopian and, despite the force ofhis arguments, he failed to raisc the status of eraft practice to that accordcd to the fine arts. Wh)' did Morris and his supporters not succeed in achieving their objective? One of the principal difficulties was that during the njnctccnth centur)' the relative merits 01' hand- and maehine-made products werc a subject of fiercc debate. '1 By the 18505 the Industrial Rcvolution had transformed British economic and social Jife; the feudal structurc and dominancc of agrieultural, ruralliJ"e was rcplaeed with capitalist and industrial mode ol' production, engendered by an entrepreneurial middle class and urban centres. Thc artisan or craftsman providing communities with everJday c1omestie, utilitarian goods quickly beeame redundant, his products replaced by mass-produced eommodities. Competitiveness in trade promoted an
38
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
increased consciousness af the rangc 01' machine- made products amI of hoth the speed and cos! at \vhich thc)' couId be produced. It
\\,'3S
no longer eornmercially
viable to produce well-crafted hand-mane goods when they couId be mass produced by machinc much more cheap1r Furniturc which had once beco hand craft<.~d [roro
salid woad couId now be maJe [roro cheap deal, nailcd together and
covered \vith a thin, machjne~cut veneer. Ruskin anJ Morris regarded such prac
tices as ¡rnmaral, and emphasis<:d the value and morality 01' ,..dl-made anJ, more often than no!, hand-produced goods, \vhdhcr those objects be furniturc, textiles
It has been argued tha
social critics was largel:
temporary culture. T~ had to deal with the no tive outlook. Whilst Futurists to thc Bauhat
or ceramies.
tion and engage with
Although it \.. . as arguably the demand For cheaper gooos that len to an expansion in the quantity of mass-proJuceJ, machine-based proJuction, it was freguently th<.'
rnodern technology - 1 in nostalgia and ideals ( art or archit<'TtUr<.~, cr
technologv itself that \...·as criticised. Furthermore, debate between the respective values of::raft versWi mass production was in turn linkcd to a division between Ver nacular and industrial urban societv. For critics of industrial development, towns gradually became synonymous with deprivation, soruiu ucpravity and the destruc tion ofheauty. More generally, industrialisation was .
1
present, a genre hest th historical traditions rai nalitv. [n the first decad
use on(y the simplest to 'glorious art, madc by t and the user' .12
This location of eraH continued to have a prol
reception of eraft obje( dra\\-n attcntion to the 1 the twentieth century I 't<'T}mological imaginati
chance, spontaneity, asse crucial to the identity o deemed to be diametricé to be 'too indebted to tJ nal" objects'. 14
Such belief.. made it ( art world, and craft and
twentieth century witnc.: theoretical writing On t writers, curators and thc.:
bypasscd within traditio: art-historical practice, rt:
pro"enance of the indi\' en5un~d that it could not
objects represented the division of labour, the loss 01' creative freedom and the suspension of mental processes, whereas crafts signified the culmination 01'
tional art-historical disc( serious eritical and theon
individual produetion, independent crcativity and even moral virtue.
as a whole has been deva
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
39
Cran: in the Twentieth Century It has beeo argued that this emphilsis on the vcrnacular by nineteenth-ccntury social cribes \\'as largcly responsíhlc for the dislocarian of craft: practice from coo temparar)' culture. Throughout the twentieth ccntur)' eraft practitioncrs have had to cical with the TIotion thar eraft is the cxpression of an essentially consen'3 t¡ve outlook. vVhilst avant-garde artists, designers and thcorists from the Futurists to the Bauhaus, Dada amI others 50ught to free themselves from tradi tion and engagc ,",vith eontemporary socícty - in particular, the possibilities 01' modern tcchnology eraft practicc and theory appeared to be static, caught up in nostalgia and idcals ofruralism. lnstead ofkeeping pace with dcvelopments io art or arehitccture, eraft practiec became the vehicle for a retreat from the preseo!, a genre hest thought of in terms of its adhcrence to local, vernacular ancl historical traditions rather than to social and aesthetic innovativenes.s and origi nality_ In the first dccades of thc twentieth ecntur)', man)' eraft: workers tended to use onl)' the simplest tools and procedures in order to rollow Morris's visioo of a 'glorious art, made hy the people aod for the pcople, as a happiness to the maker ami the user'. 12 This location of eraft in the imaginar)' prc-industrial past of Western cultures eontínued to have a profouod dIeet on its practitioncrs, ancl indeed on the popular reception oI' craft ohjccts. Both Raymoncl vVilliams and Andreas Huyssen have dra"vn attention to the fact that protagonists 01' the avant-garde 01' the tlrst hall' of the t\ventieth eentury foeused on radicall)' transforming ever)'day life through 'technological imagination'. 13 Modernist artists and designers utiliscd teehnology, ehance. spontaneity, assemblage and originality in their work. These elements were crucial to the identit)' 01' modernism and the avant-garde inasmueh as the)' were deemed to he diarnetrieally opposed to tradition and eraft praetiecs, which scerned to be 'too inclebted to the past, and too lacking in spontaneity to produce "origi naP' objeeb' .14 Such bcliefs made it difficult for craft: to gain acceptanec in the contemporar)' Mt
"vorld, ancl eraft and critical practicc "vere, on thc ",,'hole, ignored. vVhile the
twentieth eentury \"'itnessed an cnormous growth in the ,,-olume of avant-garcle theorctical "vriting on the nature, scopc and function 01' art ami, Jater, design. writers, curators and theorists tended to overlook eraft \vork. Moreo\'er erart was bypassed within traditional art criticismo Connoisseurship, once the rnainstay of art-historieal practice, rclied on the establishment of the artist's signature and the provenance 01' the individual work. The anonymity of rnuch eraft procluction ensured that it could not he easily accornmodated v.'ithin the boundaries of tradi tional art-historical discourse. This lack of attention rewlted in a marked lack of serious critieal and theoretical writing on eraft, a consequence of which is that eraft as a who}C' has been dcvalued. As Rowley has argued:
40
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
. the modernist history of modern art organised the experience al' artists
The Crafts Committl
al the sarue time as it disol8anised and negated the mode 01' expcricncc (lf the
01' presenting and writ
erafts practitioners. In this way, twcnticth-ccntury eraft has either becn
through thc eneourageJ
cxduded from historical and critical study or transforrncd in the proce.'is 01'
publication Crqfis whid
A visil lo almost any hook shop will demonstrate the
diseoursc, with curaton
incorporatían.
outcome 01' trus process.
e ounterpoint to the maoy, maoy diffeTent kinds of
questions for an approF
historical l eritical and thcorctical studies of art are the endless handbooks and
garde fine art praetice a
manuals of eraft.
crafts, such as WiIliam
.. \Vhat is lacking is the reflectivc, critical, theoretically
informed dialogue that Ii~s at the heart of a discipline. j ~
erar! practice was secn as invohing the produetion 01' objeets intended merely for
referred to, eraft history porary eraft. Crqfts maga remove nostalgia and ru
praetkal use in contrast to art, whieh has 01't en been regardcd as a vchicle for com~
In spite of sueh diffic
municating important insights into the social and human condition. This division
gaining rccognition alo
het'.\·een the two has also created a dilemma for many practitioncrs, affeeting how
A. ttempts are now made
thcy perceive thcmsd ves, how their vvork is 1'unded and the status it achicvcs within
using methods drawn, fa
the world of art and in the eycs uf the puhlic. As earlv as the 1970s the Crafts Advisorv Committee - now known as the erafts Council
~ acknowlcdged this problcm ami attempted to establish high-level criti
practiccs are now acknm
ral contexts, and the risl notion that craft has an
Ce
cal discourse on the subject, ,vhich would in turn improve the standing of craft.
to rai:-e the standard of
Following the advent 01' conceptual art in thc 1960.'1 art practice often seemed indis
Reviva!' and a renewed
tinguishahle from art theory, whereas it \vas apparent that writing about crafts was
helel clichés concerning e
SI
lagging far behind, indeed that eraft was in general under-theorised. An exchange
Gcnder in particular h
of ideas on craft practice did take place, hut it tended to he within small enclaves,
to contend, and, more sJ
involving, for example, ceramicists wriüng ahout their ,\'ork in journals for othcr
fernale activity in terms o
ceramicists. It is true that journals aimed at specific disciplines within eraft prac
gatcd this assumption so
tice providcd an arena for like-minded individuals to discuss their work and the state 01' their own particular discipline, hut there \"'as little room for progression
which considers the classi nificant art form. 17 She al
and expansion and, more importantl)" Httle e"idence of a cross-pollination of ideas
when ""omen embroider í
from other related cultural practices.
their femininity. Because (
The Crafts Advisory Committee aimed to provide better critkal eoverage for
as craft. Parker argues tha'
thc crafts, not just in what might he argued as paroehial single-discipline craft: puh
tuted whereby 'art made
lications but in fine art journals and on the arts pages of newspapcrs. This aspira
unegual: that the former
tíon proved to he an uphill strugglc, with continuing resistance from the media to
fortunatcly not as acrurat
gh'e significant space and attention to eraft praetice. [t proved immenscly difficult
come to be recognised as '
to convincc the national press of the true nature of the work being produced hy the
The vicw 01' needlewor
contemporary artist-craftsman. Craft was rarely revicwed in the .'lame critical
has had grave reperrussiol
terms as painüng and seulpture; its perception, intensity and relationshíp to a
sewing, emhroidery and rr
changing social order were seldom eonsidered. 16 Instead, the erafts \\-'ere (and sadly
for family needs, and the!
still are) viewed as ideal subjects for lively reHef 1'eatures on the womens' pages 01'
nantly, though not exclus
magazines or in consumer-oriented puhlications such as Counrry Living or Jlc}men
moncy. Uf course, there a
and Horne,
hut rather than acknO\'lled.
,
CONCEPT5 OF CRAFT
41
The Crafts Committee set about improving the situation by initiating a Ile\\' way of presenting and writing about the erafts, partly through its own exhibitions, through the encouragement of regional exhibitions and through its bi-monthly puhlication CTC!fts \-",hich was launched in 1973. The aim of Creifts was to create a diseourse, with curators and commentatoTs able to frame and ans\'\'er constructive qucstions for an appropriate audicnce. The model . .,.:a5 cssentially that o[ a\'aot garde fine art practice and criticism, ami whilst the great ancestral figures of the erafts, such as William Morris
OT
Charles Robert Ashhee, were occasionally
referred to, eraft history was oflittle ¡nteTest and the focus was firmly 00 contcm porary eraft.
Crqft5 magazine \\'as an irnportant and mueh necded puhlic attempt to
remü':e nostalgia ancl ruralism from the crafts. In spite of :iuch difficulties, howcycr, craft thcory is gradually cleveloping and gaining rceognition alongsicle other critical discourses within visual culture. Attempts are now macle to hring to hcar various analytical insights to the crafts, using methods drawn, for examplc, from feminism, semiology or Marxism. Craft praetices are now acknowledgcd as being firmly embedded \vithin multiple cultu ral contexts, and the rise ol' interdisciplinary research has further promoted the nOÜon that eraft has an equally valid placc alongside fine art and designo The move to raise the standard uf critical dehate and the erafts coincidecl ,"",ith a 'CraI'ts Revival' and a r('n('v'/ed sensc ofprofessionalism. Makers began to challengc long hcld clichés concerning craft, gencler, materials, function and utility. Gendcr in particular has long been a prohlematic issue with which eraft has had to contend, and, more specifieall)" the notion that craft practice is a specifically fcmale activity in terms ofboth acsthetic and production. Rozsika Parker interro gatcd this assurnption sorne twenty }l'ars ago in her book The Sub~·er.live Stitch, which considers thc c1assihcation of embroidery as a skillecl [raI't rather than a sig nificant art formo 17 She argucs that thc erux oI' thc problern líes in the belief that when wornen embroirlcr it is secn not as art but rather as entirel)' au expression of tbeir femininity. Because oI' this patriarchal view, such v.'ork is crueially categorised as eraft. Parkcr argues that the corollary oI' this thinking is that a hierarch)' is insti tutecl wbereby 'art made with thread and art marle with pajnt are intrinsically unequtll: that the former is artistically less significant' .18 Parker's cornments are fortunatcly not as accurate as they once w('re; tapcstry and textiles have slowly come to be recognisecl as 'serious' Jrt forms, but this is not universal. l ':! Tbe yiew of nccdle\vork as craft (ancl thcrefore as lcss eonsequentiaI than art) has had grave repereussions for wornen. The prejudiee stcms from the fad that sewing, ernbroidery and many otber erafts arc produccd in the horne, by women for farnil)' needs, and therefore not for mone)'. ",hereas painting was predomi nantlJ, though not exclusivel)', producecl by men in the publie sphere and for moncy. al' course. there are huge cliffcrcnces between painting and embroidery, but rather tban aeknowledging that simple differenee, ernbroidery Jnd indeed thc
42
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
to be an acti ve area of re lenging preconceived id craft and its status as art of the Bulgarian artist (
ranging from the Pont j\ tioned the traditional be Function has always b container that is incapah notion of utilit)' both ele
venting crafts from bein: tice of avant-garde art a outcome of an)' practice and the tangible form 01 quarter of the twentietl funetíon and their relati
Figure 3.1 - Janet I"\orton, Cozy (1999). Ward Island, Toronto. Photograph © Bruce Durry.
wider practice of crafts carne to be associated with the 'second sex' and with lower social classes, and were accorded a lower value.
Rethínking Craft There remain many misconceptions and misplaced prejudices about the place of craft, domesticity and gender even toda),. Canadian textile artist Janet Morton (Figure 3.1) frecluently addresses these issues in her work. Cozy was an event that took place on Ward Island, Toronto, in November 1999. In much of her work, Morton reconsiders the traditional relationships between knitting, domesticity, family, function and craft. For Cozy she gathered numerous discarded, hand-knitted garments and sewed them together to form a complete covering (rather like a giant
point. The ceramicistAIi interrogated the idea of j The Maker's Eye catalogue
My work in the fut say that trus group or an idea of a pos final presence of tl preoccupation, wh out as a distinct COI Britton's Black and Crw
playing with ideas of tral the long-standing dichol functions as a container, question the nature of il with subversion and re-e ture than a utilitarian oh The critic David W
tea cosy) for one of the single-storey houses on the Island. The result was a com bination of craft, sculpture and parody. The completed object had a nostalgic quality about it, the house resembled a childhood fantasy, reverberating with notions of securit)' and nurture; in other words, sentiments that tend to come so easily to mind when thinking about craft practice within the 'feminine' arena. Yet this 'cozy' was exposed to the elements for over a week and left to stretch and dis
functional domestic obje combined with an inte ceramic surface, she not an essay for the catalogue
integrate: the resulting object was a far cry from the hackne),ed expectation of female domestic craft. The discussion of textiles, their processes and their connec tions with materials and contemporar), culture in the light of feminism, continues
In man)' people's TI parable to the split
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
43
to be an active area of research for both makers and theoreticians 20 As well as chal lenging preconceived ideas on craft and gender, Cozy also questions the function of craft and its status as arto In particular, it can be seen partly as a parody of the work of the Bulgarian artist Christo, renowned for wrapping large buildings and sites, ranging from the Pont Neuf in Paris to the Reichstag in Berlin. Cozy thereby ques tioned the traditional boundary betvveen art and craft. Function has always been a key issue for the crafts. After all, what is the use of a container that is incapable of holding anything, or a teapot that doesn't pour? This notion of utility both defined and limited the crafts, and played a key role in pre venting crafts from being included within the spheres of critical thinking and prac tice of avant-garde art and architecture. An insistence on function as the ultimate outcome of any practice is bound to have a limiting effect on the intellectual content and the tangible form of the finished object. For many makers working in the last quarter of the twentieth century, a thorough questioning of form, meaning and function and their relationship to art and craft practice was an essential starting point. The ceramicist Alison Britton and textile artist Caroline Broadhead have both interrogated the idea of function and its relationship to craft. Britton's comment in The Moker's Eye catalogue highlights her concern with notions of function: My work in the future may be seen to have belonged to a 'group' ... 1 would say that this group is concerned with the outer limits of functionj function, or an idea of a possible function, is crucial, but is just one ingredient in the final presence of the object, and is not its only motivation. I think that this preoccupation, which can be perceived in various fields and materials, stands out as a distinct contribution of the last ten years 21 Britton's Block ond Creen Pot of 1999 (Figure 3.2) demonstrates her interest in playing with ideas of tradition, function and innovation as well as commenting on the long-standing dichotomy between art and craft. Block ond Creen Pot certainly functions as a container, but the two disparately shaped funnels lead the viewer to question the nature of its function. Indeed, the pot seems to be more concerned with subversion and re-organisationj it is more akin to a three-dimensional sculp ture than a utilitarian object. The critic David vVhiting has described her work as consisting of 'non functional domestic objects'. 22 Because ofher deliberate move away from function, combined with an interest in integrating architecturaJ form with decorated ceramic surface, she not so much confronts the art/ craft divide as suspends it. In an essay for the catalogue ofthe Beyond the Dovetoil exhibition Britton commented: In many people's minds there is a split between skills and ideas that is com parable to the split between craft and arto Furthermore, they think that skill
44
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Figure 3.2 - Alison Britton, Black and Creen Pot (1999). Photograph courtesy of Barrett Marsden Gallery, London.
belongs to craft and ideas belong to arto And tradition belongs to skill and craft, and innovation belongs to ideas and arto To sustain these notions you need to be thinking of skill as a manual thing, the gnarled and noble hand. But in reality the manual and the mental are seamlessly combined in the opera tion of skill whether you are ploughing a field or painting the Sistine Chapel. 23 Caroline Broadhead's work has also examined function, and in particular the rela tion between objects and the human body. Her initial enquiries centred on items of jewellery, but she progressed to cloth and her work has became more sculptural in fOl-m. Suspend (Figure 3.3) formed part of an installation that reAected Broadhead's interest in cloth and how it might function as a metaphor and memory of the body (or at the least, a human presence). All the garments in the installation were barely palpable, dissolving into painted shadows and highlighting the relationship between visible and invisible, questioning the real and the tangibility of memories. One element of the installation Web consisted of a fragile net barely visible to the naked eye; the outline of a garment could just be perceived, whilst Suspend was a tulle piece crudely hung by a large number of threads. This garment also had a ghostly presence
Figure 3.3 - Caroline Broa< Gallery, London.
and asked the viewer nol tion the nature of mero, roents of this installation Another significant e shaped objects froro a VI roany of the forms are c cling. The size and the ( process; the paper can b
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
45
Figure 3.3 - Caroline Broadhead, Suspend (2001). Photograph courtesy of Barrett Marsden Gallery, London.
and asked the viewer not on1y to reconsider its apparent function but a1so to ques tion the nature of memories as either fixed and indelib1e or, líke the ghost1y gar ments of this installation, fragiJe and precarious, gradually fading from sight. Another significant maker is Karin Muhlert, who creates organic, coch1ear shaped objects from a ""ide range of materia1s including brass and sandstone, but many of the forms are created from rolls of paper which were destined for recy cling. The size and the density of the roll of paper tends to dictate the working process; the paper can be twisted by hand or hammered with mallets and shaped
46
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Figure 3.5 - I-Ielga Reay-' Callery, London (1999).
Figure 3.4 - Karin Muhlert, untitled small works [rom Sea Cell series (1999). Photograph © K. Mublert.
with angle grinders and chisels. Sorne of the sculptures are small, shell-Iike shapes, such as the Sea Cell series (Figure 3.4). These three-dimensional paper objects were created as non-functional containers, but whilst they look Iike bowls, they could never function as such. When asked what they are, their creator Karin Muhlert replied, '} don't Iike to labe! these things, they are non-figurative pieces guided by nature and chance.' 24 As can be seen from the few examples given here, function is no longer a nec essary constituent of craft; craft objects are now frequently sold for their aesthet ic 'Iook' or concept rather than their function. This move away from function has had economic as well as critical and aesthetic repercussions. By freeing themselves from the ties of functionalism, craft practices have Iiberated themselves from the traditional Jciinition of craft, to the point where they are frequently indistinguish able from arto This in turn has allowed practitioners to break free from perceived class boundaries. No longer a trade, craft has taken up a place within visual culture in which it is seen as the expression of artistic identity, produced for an audience with a desire for functionless objects demanding complex aesthetic and conceptual engagelnen·~. Such a description could easily be applied, of course, to arto Gradually, the critical development of makers and the perception of consumers has changed, and long-held beliefs are continually b<.:ing challenged. These new
approaches have resull modern materials and the spaces between art no-longer so easy to m;
Helga Reay- Young as p:
Autumn FeelinS5 consisls
for the space. Hung on buildings, road and tret
the opposing ideas of n craft depends primaril: selves may be indisting1 and content, craft still ( other institutions qUití remain limits to the o persist in spite of the p
Craft histories are beiI theoreticians who are 'celebrities' such as Wi
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
47
Figure 3.5 - Helga Reay- Young, Autumn FeeJinas. Photograph from installation at Cochrane Gallery, London (1999).
approaches have resulted in a broader experimental synthesis of traditional and modern materials and forms. Practitioners and theorists have been interrogating the spaces between art and craft, and their work has ensured that the boundaries are no-longer so easy to map. For example, Autllmn Feelin85 (Figure 3.5) was created by Helga Reay- Young as part of a glass installation for the Cochrane GalIery in London. Alltllmn Feelina5 consists of 19 metres of Float-glass, wire and leaves specially created for the space. Hung on the first floor of the gallery and overlooking the pavement, buildings, road and trees, Reay- Young's intention was for the work to bring together the opposing ideas of nature and the city. The identification of a work such as this as craft depends primarily on where it is exhibited. Indeed, while the objects them selves may be indistinguishable in terms of medium, aesthetic and intellectual form and content, craft still operates within a network of galleries, exhibition spaces and other institutions quite distinct from that of arto In this regard, therefore, there remain limits to the overcoming of boundaries between the two, and these may persist in spite of the properties of individual craft practices and artists.
Conclusion Craft histories are being deconstructed and reconstructed by makers, critics and theoreticians who are trying to dispel the myths that have bu.ilt up around craft 'celebrities' such as \Villiam Monis, Charles Rennie Mackintosh or Bernanl Leach,
48
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
and high-profile groups induding the Bauhaus and de Stijl. They have also set out new agendas fOf crafts not based on old arguments but qucstioning wideT socio cultural issues. Craft practice has endlessly redcfined itself and devcloped new forms in new media as a response to fine art, design, modernism, postmodernism, educatian, patterns of consumption, dass, politics and all sorts of currenb in social and cultural historr The identity of eraft 15 vcry fragile, but its practices have con tinued to cornmand respect. Debates over its meaning and dchnition continuc, and it i5 precisely this protcan and fragile quality tbat a1so makes it so interesting.
Dormer, Peter, ed. The Culture ?f Crqfr- (Manches ter, 1996). Greenhalgh, Paul, E'd. The Persmence r:ifCIrift (1 andon, 2003). Harrod, Tanya. CI~/is if BIltain in the TWentlelh Centurx (Lomlon, 1999) Pye, David. The l.. .:uLUre anJ Arr ~f,ioIkmanshlp (Cambridge, 1968). Rowlcy, Sue. CI~ji and Contemporar}' Theo~~ (St Leonards, Ne\\ South \\'á.ies, 1997).
qI
Notes
ne
Paul Greenhalgh, 'The Hi:'ltorj' of Craft', in Peter Dormer, ed., Cuhure l?I Cra/i (Manchester, 1997), pp. 20-52, at p. 22. Paul Mathieu, 'The Space of Ponery: an Investigation of tbe Nature (Jf Crart:', in G. A. ,11eanlna In lontempllrJr)' CI
Sec PauJ Grt-·enhalgh, 'Thc Histor) ofCraft'.
lmmanuel Kant, The CrH1que i!.j'th,' POl'ier r:if}udacmen[, transo Paul Guyer amI Eric Matthcws
(Cambridge, 2002) § 43, pp. 182-3. On the de"clopment uf the modern systcm of the arts, Sl'(' Paul Oskar Kri.steller, Renawan(c Thuu,qhr amI/he Arr.\ (Ncw York. 1965). John Ruskin, 'Modern Manufacture and !)esign', in Sesame and 1¡líes (London, 1859), p.
4
3 4 5
6 7
Contempora'J Bnwh Tal
20 Texb sueh as .Halmal, cal discussion witrun th The Art anJ CU/fIlIe
if e
21 Alison Britton, The Ma 22 David Whiting, 'AlisOI
p.5J. 23 Alison Rritton, BeJondl 24 Karin Muhlert, 'Sea Cl
Further Reading
2
18 lbid., p. 5. 19 Scc, ror example, the
In. 8 William Morris, 'The Lesser Arts ofl ife' (1882), in W Morris, Thr Cplleclc'J Work ~.n'Villiam .Homs, h,¡. 22 (London, 1910-15), p. 27. 9 See Adrian Forty, 'Design and Meehanisation' ,in A. Fort)', Objeas c:fDesire. Deswn and .~o(Íe9 since 1750 (London, 1995), pp. 42---61. 10 Thomas CarJyk, quoted in G. Naylor, Arts ami CI~¡rS ,Hl'~ement (london, 1980), p. 26. 1 I John Ruskin, 'The Lamp of Ufe', tmm The Seren l.amps uF Arc"hltecture [1849], c¡uoted in Na)'lor, Arts and CI~/r.s MOI'l'mcnt, p. 26. 12 William Morris 'The Art ofthe People' [1879], quoteJ in T. Harrod, The Cr'ifts In Bnrom m (hr 20th Centu'J' (New Haven, CT anJ LonJon, 1999), p. 16, 13 Susan Rowley, 'Craft, Creativit)' and Critical Prac:ticc', in Relnventina Tc.\tiles· TradlflOn and Inno~atIOn (London, 2000), pp. 1 16. 14Ibid.,p.2.
15 S. Rowlc)', CI, Ncw South Wales, 1997), p. niii.
16 Scc HarroJ, The Crafts In Bmaln, p. 386.
17 Roszika Parkcr, The Sllbl'CISive Stit(h (London, 1984).
CONCEPTS OF CRAFT
49
18 ¡bid.. p. 5. 19 See, for example, thc c
22 DavId "'Vhiting. 'Alisan Britton's Ncw C('"ramics', in Crtifts, No. [69 (March/ April 200\),
p.53. 23 Alisan Britton, Bep>nd che Dovetml (Lomlon, 1991).
24 Karin Muhkrt, 'Sea Changcs', in Crqfi8, No. 162 (januar}/Fcbruarj' 2000}, p. 3.
4. Design and Modern Culture 'Design' has multiplc m( user and the eontext
Juliette MacDonald
oE
\vhich meant to draw, bu The ability to produCl Renaissanee when the ri: use of models and plans. lain vvhieh wcre exporte< onwards, Europe. 2 It \\'a sented hefore being prO( Thcre have heen num and one 01' the mast ele dct1ned design as a unifyi Dcsign is what aH f the intelligenee, ttH terro desiBn is a thl \'\.. hether in grapruc
Introduction
or the largcst integl In addition
Thc ver)' word 'dcsign' is a mystery to the cornmon man,l
lo
its definitil
and desirability and as
SUl
magazines. Telcvision pr' This earoment, made in 1938 by the British cTitic Anthony Bertram, ís initially
puzzling given that 'design' had long been in common use. Yet his cornment remaios appositc: design rcmaios .ln elusivc termo Not rncrcly concerncd with the surface appearancc uf things, it ma} be a value-free expression to describe
all¡Jroducts , or it can convcv .1
IUXUT)',
exclusivitv and elitism. The dichotOffiv) \-viII ./
design as .ln ever)'da)' wa sentation of de sigo, whetl they offcr a panicular fao use of the ter m .
proddc the context for this discussion as it raises thc most pertinent issues relat
The disciplines of desi: vioed tbe theoretical disc
ing to design Jnd the undcTstanding and cxpcctations nf it üvcr the last 150
and the processes of a give
years. Tbis charter commcnces with a hrid' consideration uf the cornmon mean
the historv of stvle and de
ings of de5;ign and ho.." approaches to the profession haye altcred. It then consid
ries nI' art as a conceptual
ers the rclationship bct\vcen design amI societ)' in the carl} decadcs of the
neld .lnd encompasses in
tWl'ntieth century hy focusing on thc pioneering work of industrial dcsigners and
cultural stuclies, sociolog
their collahoration with larllc American corporations. Finally., it assesscs the b ,
argues for it to he undel 'dcsign culture', which 'a
emergencc of design as an icon of wcalth and good taste, eoncluding with an cxamination of consumer culture and the role of design within global powcr
tures: not just ones 01' mm
structurcs and consum(:rism.
Europeanity, consumer en
sion oI' hranded leisure su
visitor's ."vhoJe t'xpericnce
DESIGN AND MODERN CULTURE
51
The Concept of Design 'Design' has multiple meanings, which can shift depending upon the identity of the user and the context of use. The word itself is derived from the Latin desianare which meant to draw, but had connotations of planning, eomposing and producing. Thc ability to produce well-drawn concepts (disesno) became vital in the Renaissance when the rise of tracle hetween distant urban centres neeessitated the use of models and plans. China, for example, produced large quantities of porce lain which ,\-'ere exported to India, the Miodle East and, from the sixteenth century onwards, Europe. 2 It was, thcrefore, crucial that concepts could be clearly repre sented before heing produced 1'or a particular market or a specifie customer. There have been numerous attempts to providc pithy descriptions of the term and one of the most cloquent was formed by theodst Richard Buchanan. who defined design as a unifying system: Design i!'\ what a1l forms of production for use have in common. It provides the intelligenee, the thought or idea - of course, one of the meanings of the term desisn is a thought or plan - that organizes all levels 01' production, whether in graphic design, engineering and industrial design, architecture. or the largcst integrated sJ'stems found in urban planning. J In addition to its definition as a process. 'design' can connote luxury, modernit)' and desirahility and as such is found in the 'lifest)'le' pages ofweekend papcrs and magazines. Television programmes that centre on home improvements portray design as an everyday way ol' tife accessible to aH. Each interpretation and repre st.'ntation ol' design, whethcr it i5 as a plan, a concept or commodity. i:'i valid because they ofFer a particular facet of meaning. and together they contri bu te to the m'erall use of the termo The disciplines of dcsign history, design studies and material culture have pro vided thc theoretical discourscs used to describe the connections between design and the processes of a given society. The early study ofdesign was preoccupied with the history ol' style and decoration, and was heavil)' influenced by formalist histo ries orart as a conceptual model.o} More recently, howe\-'er, it has he come <1 broader field and cncompasses interdisciplinary interest in the social sciences. including cultural studies, sociology and anthropology. [n The Culture qf Desisn Guy ]ulier argues 1'or il to be understood within the context of an increasingly pervasive 'design culture', which 'appropriates and employs a wide range of discursive fea tures: not just ones ()f modernity, but also risk, heritage, sub-cultural, public space, Europcanity, consumer empowcrment and many others'. ') For example, his discus sion ol' branJed Icisurc such as theme parks and visitor attractions shows how the visitor's \vholc C'xperience has bccome the subject of design strategies. Julier notes:
52
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Design o\ves much of its italist one where eonsun For example, within the restock their wardrobe i to think that Western-s' lution of thc nineteenth life for many Europeans hetween consumerism al design historian Adrian prohJems to designers:
What is described • mous with the ran~ the henents are m güüds. Rut it is a pe hrings a sequ~nce o so that, in the name
Figure 4.1 - O[¡r D)'n'lmic Earth, Edinhurgh. Author's photograph (2004).
tantly related and p 'kisure spaces providc a veritahlc 8csamtkunsrwerk [total art1 of cxpcriences '. lo Thc
Dynamj( farth created in Edinburgh in 1999 (Figure 4.1) 15 a
Thc SUCTess ol' sueh pr
prime cxample of such ao experienn.'. In addition to text, video clips and static
to its ability to inspire a d.
cxhibits, the intcrac-tiye displays including \vork hy Michael Wolchover's campan)'.
engine in the ninetecnth
exhibition centre
OUT
A Slight Shift, simulate cvents in lhe Earth's evolutÍon, whilst lhe striking music
upon the creation of a me
anJ sound design hy Pete Sto\lcry and sophi.<;ticated lighting design fuse the
induce. Again, Forty note
encountcr into an impressive ""hole. Thc visitor's ongoing C'xperience is al.<;o con
design, through its capaeit
sidcrcd as part uf the design proccssj the exhihitían contextualises sorne glohal
important. Design alters 1
phenomena ín terms uf th<.' loeallandscape, such as Arthur's Seat, the ,-o\canie hill
In Europe in the first (
that forms the backdrop to the centre which visítors see when they leave. Thc
to conlTrn themselves wi
huilding itsclf, designed by Michael Hopkins and Partners, contains a larg<.' fore
the müdernist movement
court that functions as a public spacc as ,",veH as a foycr for the exhihitíon. The spacc
predominant issues, and
1
D__v namj(
basic dcsign vocabulary. T
Eartn promotes the architecture as having aH extended role: just as 'Holyrood ical evülution. so the Dynamic Earth Projcct uses afl·hitccture to conncet natural
by the American arehitecl pervading la,," 01' aH thing! 01' aH thin(15 hum , C> P hvsical,
history to human and civic Jife'.7 Taken together, thcse elements provide a can'
of thc h('ad, ofthc heart. (
full)" designed contenl <'Uld contcxt for the visitor. Designcrs have a crucial role in
form c\"er follovvs functio
can he used as an amphitheatre for performan<.T events, and here again
OUT
Palace and lhe ne,"' [Seottish¡ Parliament building use architecture to suggest polit
shaping the media
as well as the user interface and it is ckar from this, and
ticalíty 01' an objcct was p.
from othcr examples, that dcsign possesses a \vide-ranging role in contemporar)'
functionalit\'. Surbce deta
Western societ\', lhat arvuablv I)enetrates aH sl)heres of Jite. C>,
of the object"
(ontent
DESIGN AND MODERN CULTURE
53
Design, Consumption and Capitalism Design owcs much 01' its ubiquity to the fact that Westcrn society is a liberal, cap ítalist one where consumerism relies on design to fud ever greater consumption. For example, wjthin the fashion industry ever)' 'season' requires the consumer to rcstock their wardrohe in the seasons 'new' colours. It would be wrong, however, to think that Western-style consumerism onl)' began with thc lndustrial Revo lution of the nineteenth century. Consumerbm had become an established wal' of life for man)' Europeans by the seventcenth century.8 Consequcntly a relationship hetwccn consurnerism and design in the West was aIread)' established. Yet, as the design historian Adrian Forty points out, capitalism brought its o\\'n particular prohlcms to designers: What is descrihed as progrcss in modern societics is in fact IargeIy s)'nony mous with thc range of changes brought ahout by industrial capital. Among thc henehts are more food, hetter transport and a greater abundancc 01' goods. But it is a pcculiarity 01' capitalism that each beneficial innovatian also brings a sequence of othcr changes, not al! oi' which are desired by aH peoplc so that, in thl:" turne of progress, we are compdled to accept a grcat man)' dis tantl), rdated and possibly unwantcd changes. g The success of such progress, despite its attendant problems, can he attributed to lts ahilit)' to inspire a desire for dlJ.nge. Any new product. whether it be a steam engine in the ninctccnth century 01' nanotcchnology in the twenty-first, depends upon thc creation 01' a mood of acccptance for the product ami any changes it may induce. Again, Forty notes that: 'Among thc ways in which this acccptancc is \Von, design, through its capacit)' to makc things seem other than they are, has been most important. Design altcrs the ways people scc commodities.' 10 In Europe in the first decades 01' thc twentieth century man)' designers began to coneCTn themsehes \vith the moral and political dimensions of designo Within the modernist movement utility, standardisation and mass production became the predominant issues, and the rdation between form and function provided their basÍC' design vocabulary. The phrase 'form follows function' dedved from an essa)' by thc American architect Louis Sullivan (1856-1924), who argued that 'It i5 the perlfading la", of aH things organíc, and inorganic, ol' aH things physical and meta physical, uf all things human and aH things super-human, ol' all true manifestations of the head, ol' the heart, of the soul, that life is recognisable in its expresslon, that form ever follows function.' 11 In terms of the design process, the utilit)' or prac ticality of an object was paramount and the form was a consequence of achieving funetionalitl" Surl'acc (ktail was not aHowed to impinge upon the functional design of thc objcct.
54
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Designers such as 'lv'alter Gropius, the hcad of the Bauhaus School in Germany, Pierre Jeannerct (better knO\.. .m as Le Corbusier) in Franee, members of the De Stijl group in the Netherlands and the Constructivists in Russia forrncd a reper toire of abstraet geometric forms from mudern materials which they believed ",erc the most suitahle functional dcsign for standardiscd mass production. For cxample, Warwawa Stepanova, J lcading proponent ofRussian Constructivism, believed that
art and design could be combincd to create potent, progressive forces in the De\\' machinc~age saciety and her textile and clothing design... reflectcd thi5 aim. Amongst the ruany designs she crcated were sports clothes adorned with hold geo metric designs which could be easily mass-produced in clothing fadories. Avant garJe furniturc simHarly reHected these utilitarian belicfs and chromium-plated tubular stee1 became a popular choice of material because it was light, durable anJ produced in standardised parts. These parts were then formeJ to shape flUlctional chairs, tables and lamps, which again required no additional decoration. Modernist acsthetic notions of form and function \VtTe gradually superscded. None the less. these ideas were significant bccause they provideJ an ideology for the role of dcsign in a modern industrialiscd societ)'. Whi]st designers in earl)' twenticth-centur)' Europe concerned themselvcs with a body of design theory which emphasised form and practicality, and their signifi cance for sodety, in thc United States thc emphasis centrcd more on the potential of technology itself. The ke)' factor was the unshakcable belief in tcchnology and its ability to transform the world into a bcttcr place to líve. Thc theme 01' the New York \Vorld's Fair of 1939 was 'Dcsign lar Tomorrow', and it pnwided an ideal opportunit)' lar industrial designers and large American corporations to work together to sell their ideas to the general publk and 'to situate themselves as pow erful economic forces in the quest to stimulate consumer dcmand' .12 Man)' of the displays were conccrned \vith specd and travel.ln thc 'Transportation Zone' visi tors could l/iC\v Raymond Locwy's ideas on improving travel betwecn London and Ncw York in the form of a passenger rocket being fired from a gun, with the pro jeeted journey time being one hour. lnside the Ford Motor Compan)" Ruilding, 'A-'alter Dorwln Teague's -Ford Cycle of Production' was on \'iew, and vehicles such as Lincoln-Zephyrs were availahlc for road-testing on the spiral 'Road ol' TomorrO\v'. Visitors could \vitness the bcnefits of a Westinghouse electric dish washer in Wcstinghouse's 'Battle of the Centuries'. Having been \\'elcomcd into the exhihit by the se\'en foot-high robot, Electro, and his robotic dog Sparky, visi tors were invited to watch a Jishwashing contest bet".'cen Mrs Modern, \vho uscd the company's latest model dishwasher, and Mrs Drudge, who washcd by hand. The collaboration bctween industrial dcsign. corporate idcntity and branding \'.'as clearly evident in the Fair. Thcrc \'.'ere, of couTSe, financial benefits to be gained lrom this rclationship, but dcsign had an additional role to play in American socicty through its contrihution to the formation 01' a national amI cultural identity. The
United States had witne begjnning 01' the twenti of races and nationalitit: all of whom wished to estahlish an American id and comfort carne to rel Kryk wrote Economic Prc Protection of heal and longevity - is This motive with( Physical comfort í American standarc the widespread sy eas)' chairs. 1 J Alongside hygiene anl abundan ce of commodit reflected these ideals al
an emphasis on charac American. Such comrnOl
ities capable of achieving Raymond Loewv's de~ example of the way a desi He received the comrnis
estahlishcd cornmodity o generall\' foC'used on tht: could pnwidc. However,
whilst they workcd effic
reflcct the hygienic imag' Coldspar "f 1936. In place taller, .streamlined versior concealed hinges. Certair handJes, this appliance ~
fas:ade and brilIünt \vhitt The design's emphasis DI Corbusier, and it was the.
also la id down the paraml from rddgerators to was] Ret\\'een the first and 5 on]y other designcrs hut \
DESIGN AND MODERN CULTURE
55
Unitcd States had \\'itncsscd large-scale irnmigration at the end of thc ninctccnth and beginning of the twentieth centuries. America "\-"as thus eomposed of a wide range al' races and nationalities cach ,"vith their
0\\'0
traditions, culture and languag<.', out
aH of whom \\'ishcd to be considered American. lt was, thcrefore, important to
cstablish an American ideal \\rith which cvcryone could ¡dentify. Hygiene, cleanlinc:-;s and comfort carne to represent important characteristics of this ideal. In 1933 Hazel
Kryk ,"vrote EconornJc Problcms ?fthc Fami{r in which she set out key American values: Protection 01' health - everything promoting physical bealth, badil), vigour and longcvity -- is a]so undoubtedly on the list of values rated rclatively high. This motive without question justífies any expenditure of time and mone)'. Physical comfort and oodily cleanliness too, ... rank relativcly high in the American standard of living.... The physical comfort motive shows itself in the \'videspread systems of central heating, electric fans, refrigeration amI eas)' chairs. 13 Along~idc hygicne and health sat a fundamental belief in material wealth and the
aoundance of commodities. 14 Design played a central roJe in creating objects that rd]ected the~c ideals and thus appealed to the many minoríty groups through an emphasis on eharacteristics which immediatel)' molde them identifiable as Americiln. Sueh eommon dcnominators molde the objects into desirable commod ities cilpahlc uf achieving mass sales and prornoting the idea
01' prosperity
Rayrnond Loewy\, design for a new rcfrigerator for Sears Roebuck ofIers a good example of the wa)' a dcsigner could incorporate suc'h ideals into a domestic ooject. He receivecl the cornmission in 1935 and oy this time refrigerators were a well established commudity on toe American market. The advertising relating to them generally focused on the hygienic and hl'illth-giving properties the refrigerators could provide. However, the)' were normaJJy encased \"ithin a wooden cabinet and, whilst thc)' worked eHiciently and efTectivel)', Lheir appcarance did not readily reHect the h)'gienic image of the advertising campaigns. Loew)"s solution was the Coldspot of 1936. In placc of the large l angular wooden cabinet Loewy produced a taller, streamlined version molde fram pressed stecl. It al so had a smooth finish with concealed hinges. Certainly, withaut the extrusions 01' hinges and numcrous door handles, this appliance was much easier to clcan. More importantl)" the s]eek fac;'ade and brilliant \-"hite finish exaggerated the elements of hygiene and purit)'. The design's emphasis on cieanliness coincided \\·ith the modernist ideas of Le Corbusier, and it was the epitome of the American design ideal described above.lt also laid down the parameters for the design of aH subsequent kitchen appliances frorn refrigerilLors to \,,'ashing machines and dishwashers. Bctween the first and seconrl world wars such innovatary dcsigns inspired not onl)' otber rlesigners but WesLern so cid)' in gcm:ral. S<.'veral writers, for example,
56
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
have noted the inHucncc of the strearnlined shapes of aircraft, traios and domestic
appliances of Normal Be! Geddes, Rayrnond Locw)' and Walter Dorwin Teague on the imagined spaccships of science fiction. As Woodham notes in his hook no twen tieth-century design:
famous notion of the
they used psycbology
huying whatever the a( Fuller, (me of America'
ical of both the growi Coneepts such as speed and changc, and the exploration ofthe possibilitics o[
intended to last a Jiret
new material s, together with the deve10pment of new modes of transport
of time - and .lIso the ~
and appliances werc abo common to both the more extravagant futurcs por
energies into developi
trayed by Be! Geddes and many science-fiction writers, illustrators and film
benefit from mínimum
makers. 15
'Dymaxion', attempte
mathematics to produl Henry. Ford's Motor Company . clearly articulated the relationship hctwccn
ecologically sound. Ur
society's fascinatian with speed, technology, mass production and consumerism.
to achieve widespread
Establisberl in 1901, Ford's Model-T cars were bigbly sougbt alter. Tbcir popular
tions in which he artic
jt)' necessitated changes in production which were to have a profound effect
and marketing were t,
throu(1hout the industrjalised world. In 1908 Ford introduccd thc production-line
cxample, in 1950 he al
to
re~ace nodal
assembly. Tasks were divided into smaller unÍts and machines
replaccd handv·."Ork wherever possible. The single-purposc dcdicated machinery
industrial design
resulted in a vastly incrcased scak of production, which, in turn, resulted in
company will let
cheapcr cars. By 1927 a total of hfteen million cars had tollcd off the assembly
Industrial desigm
lineo 16 The \'lorkers
awardcd higher wages as compensation for the deskilling
torso Ancl yet. I'v
and monotony the)' endured, but the real change to consumer history brought
the steamship, Un
WCTC
about hy Ford was not so much the production of the Model T, hut tathcr the
that the industria
company's introduction 01' the cíght-dollar, five-day working \'leek. What la)'
:;ailing clown Nev
behind thc pay-packet \Vas the recognition that mass production reguired mass
cloucls and brie
consumption; Fonl was cteating a matket for his goods \'lithin his O\'ln workforce
together. 20
since they" could no\\" afford to buv , his cars. The consequences of Fordism for design \Ver e enormous and it ttansformcd numerous sectors of manufacture from
The second world war (
food ,md dothes to furniture and larming. Tt also had an impact on advcrtising, Cor
lcscence, hut it also enc(
potate ¡dentit)' and hranding, all of \vhich were required to ensure the stcad), con
design continued as a
sumption of goods.
markets. Scandinavian (
Superficially, the cxtravagant exhibits at the World Fair and contcmpotaty domestic commodities rdlccted thc hencfits of the collaboration bet""'ecn
1
oversea.-; consumptlOn. simplicit)'- Ital)' similarl
dynamic dcsigners and magnanimous corporations. It was also apparent, however,
Europe. Th" ltalian gOVt
that the 'well-designed future' would incrcase a compan)"s profit margins. As a
establishment of three-'
result, companies in the 1930s frequentl)' used a sttateg)' of 'consumer engineer
raised the pro lile of its
ing' whieh shortened the cycle of consumption by placing an emphasis on stylc
'ltal)' at Work: Hcr Ren
rather than function.
17
N ot evervone ho\Vcvet, agtccd \..-ith this ovcrt dependence "
L
However, the succes
ol' eapitalist production un designo In the 19505 the sociologist Vanee Packard
out the 1950s and 196C
argued that advertiser.'i w-ete manipulating public desire fur nc\..- goods by creat
they perceived as capita
ing artificial necds in comumers. Ueseribing advertising eompanies with thc now
in common with PackaJ
DESIGN AND MüDERN CULTURE
57
famous notion of the 'hiddcn persuaders', Packard analyscd the \-vays in which they used psychology as a means of stirnulating the consumer into desiring and buying whatcver rhe advertiser wished them to. 18 Similarlv, , , Richard Buckminster Fullcr, orre al' America's most radical designers of rhe perioo, was particularly crit ical of both the gmwiIlg treno towards bujlt~jn obsolescence - goods \'Vere not ¡otended to last a Iifetime but rather to becomc outdated within a limited space
of time - and also rhe snperficial styling of many consumer products. 19 He put ros energies into devdoping a 'design sciencc' thar ,..'ouId offer maximum human bencfit [roro minimum use of material and energy. His concept, ,""hieh he termed 'Dymaxion', attempted to combine a visionar)' Yiew of design with sc\encc and mathematics to produce yehicles Jnd houses ..vhich were economical to use and ecologicall)' sound. Unfonunately, the majorit)' of FulJer's design projects failed to achie\'c widcspread acceptance, Perhaps of more use were his many publica tions in which he ;¡rticulated his strong belicfs that industrial desjgn, advertising and marketing were too closel)' associaterl ,.... ith each other and dishoncst. For exampk, in 1950 he argued thato industrial tlesign is a ver)' tarnishcd affair I assure you that no aircraft: company willlet an industrial designer through its engineering front door. Industrial designers are considereu
to
be pure interior and exterior necora
torso And yet. I've listcned to industria! designen,: asscrt that they designed the steamship, United States. If you were tu exhibit sehematicalI)' aH the items that the industrial designers creatcd for the United ,)fate" )'on would have sailing down New York Harbour an arra)'
01' window curtains, ehairs, paint
clouds and bric-a-brac Hoating in space, '\\-ith nothing to reaHy hold it together. 20 The second world war C'urb"d thc tendencics uf styling for profit and built-in obso lescenee, but it also encouraged much more efficient modes of production. Similarl)" design continued as a useful tool with which manufacturers couId develap new markets, Scandinavian countries, for cxample, promoted 'Scandinavian Desjgn' for overseas consumption. The objects the)' produced for export empha~jsed functional simpliC"ity. ltaly similady attcmpted to cultivate its identity as the design centre of Europe. The Italian government activel)' promoted its country's designs through the establishment of three-year JesigIl exhibitions (Triennalc) in Milan, and in 1950 it raiscd thc profile of its designcrs by sending a majar travelling exhibition entitled 'Ital)' at Work: Hcr Renaissance in Design Today' to the United Statcs. Hov.'ever, the suecess of Italian dcsign brought its own problems and through out thc t 950s and 1960s members of the Italian avant-garde began to dislike what they percC'ive-d as capitalist expectations of their work. Their accusations hacl much in common v.'ith Packard's hcliefs that dcsign had bccome a cheap marketing ploy,
58
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
an<1 as a rcsult they were trapped into producing fashionable, elegant dorncstic commodities. Manufacturen, they argucd, wcn~ merely 'responding to the eco nomic dictates of the market-place rather than the imaginative ami crcativc pos sibilities
01'
design as a mean S (lf cnhancing the quality of Jife' .21 As a result,
avant-garde designers such as Ettore Sottsass Jr ami Gaetano Pesce set out to rcclc hne Italian dcsign hy rcjcctíng rationalism and elegance and exploring kitsch, eclec ticism and nostalgia. Yet this solution "\'as rncrdy a changc of dcsign rathcr than a changc of the natuH.' (lf dcsign and its relationship to manufacture and consump tion. Many 01' the designs produced as a part of this anti-design movement were dccidedly un-chic. Pescc's Sit Down eh.1ir ol' 1970 for the Milan-based eompan)' Cassina is an ideal examp1e of the anti-design attempt to undermine market-lcd expectations. Inspired hy Claus Oldenberg's work and anthropomorphic in form, the SIt Down attempted to defiect attention away from styk, form and blatant con sumcrism, and focus instead on design's broader socio-cultural functions. Similar1y, Sottsass's questioning of the status ami meaning of objeLts .lIso played a pivotal role in the avant-garde dimate of the late 1960s and 19705. He forged a long-standing relationship with Olivetti for whom he designed office furniture and machinery. His "vorks combined technical adjustments with an exploration uf the nature of taste and thc percei....cd status of objccts. His Va]enrine typc""ritt:'r of 1969, for example, was small, eompact and made ofred plastic. This mcant it was light, cas)' to move and keep clean and, therefore, ideal for the ofhce environmt:'nt. Yd its decorative appearanee suggested it was more of a fashion acccssory th.1n a func tional office appliance. Sottsass's establishment of the dcsign group Mcmphis in conjunetion with Michele De Lucehi similarly provided a stimulating ethos ror dt:'sign throughout th(' 1980s. Found('d in Milan in 1981, Memphis ncver fnrmulatcd .1n established design philosophy but none the less attempted to responrl to th(' culture of th(' time by disassociating itsclf from cstablished notions of design .1nd the homogenisation
01' mass markets: 'For Sottsass the use of imagination and a rieh visuallanguage in dcsign \vas both a means of enhancing the consumer experience and 01' persuading manufac-turt:'r5 to re-examine their understanding nf thc acsthetic possihilities inhcrent in e\"er)'day products.'22 Memphis has been deseribed as the ultimate 'rrult salad' and Sottsas.<; hims('lf commcntcd: 'Anything that ís tamed by culture lost:'s its flavour after a \""hile, it's like eating eardboard. You have to put mustard 011
Figure 4.2 - Ettore Sotsass,
it or take little picccs of canlboard and eat them with tomatoes and salad. It's a
lot bt:'ttt:'r ir you don't eat cardboard at .111.'13 Many of the objccts crcatcd by
Sotsass's Carlton Bookcas/
Mcmphi.~ dcsign"-Ts
were produccd from plastic laminate mat.erials in bright 'tutti
group's ideas: the bookl
J"rutti colours. In addition, the form of the objeets thcmsclvcs rcvealcd a profound
emphasis Ís sharpl), focus
l
anti-functionalist attitudc, and ideas for their designs \vere drawn f"rom a \vide
Memphis designers w,
range of sourees encompassing everything from ancient civilisation to American
ceramics, and beh"'t:'en th
consumerism as weH as making reference to both high and popular culture.
they wcre united in the bf
OESIGN ANO MOOERN CULTURE
59
Figure 4.2 - Ettore Sotsass, Corlton Bookcose (1981). Photograph © MEMP[-[]S.
Sotsass's CarItan Baakcase (Figure 4.2), created in 1981, is the epitome of the group's ideas: the bookcase hardly looks capable of supporting books and the emphasis is sharply focused on its aesthetic qualities. Memphis designers worked in a variety of media, including textiles, glass and ceramics, and between them they produced a disparate range of objects. However, they were united in the belief that design was an integral part of the fashion process.
60
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
In the catalogue accom¡ designers stated that th style. The irony, as SOlDe imitated, resulting in th This New Design, a~ voice. Objects containiJ to have a particular mar ignation 'high design' along with the price-tal: credentials of an artefa, objects for display and ci found in museums and everyday use. Michael Philippe Starck's lemO! Alessi) are representativ
tional kitchen device it ( prevent pips from fallin spatter until one learns
Novelty has thus apparel process and consequent can, however, be argued
cial styling. Such objcct~ owed by their symbolic sense is a privilege, beca ically conspicuous but rr
taste and culture. This n
of this book, and it has 1 the chief function of a fu
ments this is merely an e something as culturall) rational function (protel cultural value lies in di~ Thus here, and in the
c;
mythologised27 It repre style-conscious consume Jean Baudrillard fashi< consume objects, only ~ Figure 4.3 - Philippe Starck,juic)' SalifLemon Squeezer (1990). Author's photograph (2004).
example, the consumer
OESIGN ANO MüOERN CULTURE
61
In the catalogue accompanying the group's first exhibition in September 1981 the designers stated that they believed that Memphis furniture would soon go out of style. The irony, as sorne critics noted, was that the design group's ideas were widely imitated, resulting in the commercial conformity they had attempted to escape. 24 This New Design, as it was termed, also laid more emphasis on the authorial voice. Objects containing a celebrity dcsigner's signature carne to be understood to have a particular mark of distinction. These objects generally fall within the des ignation 'high design' where 'conscious designer intervention and authorship, along with the price-tag, playa large role in establishing the cultural and aesthetic credentials of an artefact'. 25 Such objects blur the boundaries between designed objects for display and designed objects to be consumed, as they are not only to be found in museums and fashionable galleries but they may also be purchased for everyday use. Michael Grave's Kettle with Bird produced for Alessi in 1985 and Philippe Starck's lemon squeezer, JUieJ 501if (Figure 4.3) from 1990 (also for Alessi) are representativc ofthis trend.JuieJ 501ifhas a striking form, but as a func tional kitchen device it does not perform well; users comment that it is difficult to prevent pips fmm falling into the glass along with the juice and the juice tends to spatter until one learns exactly how much pressure to exert.
Critiques of Design Novelty has thus apparently overtaken function as prime concern within the design process and consequently design is often perceived as shallow and superficial. It can, however, be argued that these elements of kitsch represent more than superfi cial styling. Such objects function as metaphors; their utilitarian role is overshad owed by their symbolic role as an official item of contemporary culture. This in a sense is a privilege, because the owner has something that is functional and aesthet ically conspicuous but more importantly it sets her /him apart as a person of good taste and culture. This notion of object as metaphor is explored in a later chapter of this book, and it has led to an important critical reassessment of designo While the chief function of a fur coat, for example, appears to be protection from the ele ments this is merely an excuse, 'a way of naturalizing the cultural order, of making something as culturally arbitrary as a status symbol appear to have a natural and rational function (protection) and one that is motivated by reality' .26 The coat's cultural value lies in distinguishing very wealthy men and women from others. Thus here, and in the case of JUieJ 5011, it can be argued that function has been mythologised. 27 It represents far more than utility, in that it signifies affluent and style-conscious consumerism. Jean Baudrillard fashioned similar claims in the 1960s, arguing that we no longer consume objects, only signs. He contended that by buying a fridge-freezer, for example, the consumer is not so much buying a utilitarian object as invoking an
62
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
entire system of meaning. 28 A streamlined Loewy Coldspot refrigerator, through employing acode of modern functionality, can be said to have signified domestic modernity. The sociologist Dan Slater has suggested that Baudrillard demonstrates that 'this systematic semiotic relatedness gives the underlying dynamic of contem porary consumer culture, as production, marketing and retailing are increasingly oriented to provide consumers with coherent, coordinated and appealing life-style concepts, ... which give both the consumer and consumer goods a firm social iden tity within a meaningful universe' .29 In other words, design can be understood as
1
a symbolic activity representing the consumption of signs (such as function and utility) rather than the consumption of the objects themselves. Over the past few decades consumer culture has witnessed a shift from the Fordist mass production of standardised goods for a homogeneous consumer to a more fragmented culture of specialised production of commodities for a precise consumer group which is c1.efined by Jifesty!C or niche markets rather than by c1ass, age or gender. This post-Fordist system is less concerned with industrial designers and more reliant on design consultants and producers of 'concepts'. Consumption, not prodllction, is the dominating force. lt is abo clear that through an emphasis on lifestyle and consumerism design has become a global commodity. This is unsur prising since design consultants and the design press have worked hard to give it a critical econornic role within the market-place. Design has played a central role in creating corporate identities, logotypes and branding associated with specific prod ucts and companies. This in turn has 'been a powerful testimony to the perceived ability of design to communicate particular cultural values, as well as to engender corporate profitability'. 30 Global brands are said to be the top wealth creators in the world. However, their ability to enrich society has often been challenged. In Seattle in 1999 at the World Trade Organisation talks, the street protest at the dominance of global brands erupted into violence. Naomi Klein's book No Loao abo offered a challenge to global consumerism and raised the leve! of debate regarding the worth of global branding and the role of multinational corporations. 31 The role of designers became a crucial isslle. It was widely recognised that design was a powerful too!. As the designer Tibor Kalman commented, for example, design has the potential to make oil companies look clean or a tomato sauce appear to be made by someone's grandmother 32 The Adbusters Media FOllndation based in Canada sim ilarly issued a challenge to the international design community by creating 'uncom mercials' and spoof advertisements (Figure 4.4). They abo publishe
Figu re 4.4 - ObsessionJor ¡l·
Whilst Adbusters ir
ticular, drew much sUF of designers retaliated
Aaoinst Future Retro-Ma
tricable links between
would not change even objectives. 34 Some of these issues
ogy of the culture that F
OESIGN ANO MOOERN CULTURE
63
Figure 4.4 - Obsession Jor ¡Hen. From Adbusters magazine (1993). Photograph © Adbusters.
Whilst Adbusters in general, and the First Things First 2000 manifesto in par ticular, drew much support they also had their critics. In England, a small group of designers retaliated by producing their ovv11 manifesto entitled A CaIl to Arms Against Future Retro-jJ;Janifestos from the DisiIlllsioned, which pointed out the inex
tricable links betweCll design and capitalisrn and argued that this relationship would not change even if designers thernselves were to re-evaluate their airns and objectives. 34 Sorne of these issues concerning the relationship between design and the ideol ogy of the cultUl"c that produces it have been addressed by the design historian Peter
64
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Dormer, who has often spoken up in defence ol' designo In The Meunings c1J11oJern
Design he argued that design and manufacturing do not have their roots in advertis ing OT television but in human expericnce, and that achicving the continuity 01' progress should be the fundamental desire of cvery designer. 'The point for dcsign ers i5 that, in .ln agc of scepticism. mOTe and mOTe weight is being givcn by soci eties to the social rules, obligations and institutions that providc continuity and service in al! its moral complexity.'35 In other words, Dormer \t\'as highlighting the need for design to offer practica} ser vice to institutions and cornmunities and to truthfully represent the ideals and values of people within those groups. Dcsign's social responsibility has al so been debated in Tdation to the environ
ment. This aspiration is clearl)' articulatcd in the l'ollowing comment which appeared in Green PaBe.c The Business t?I Sm'inB lhe World: 'The grccn consumcr is likely to be an increasingly important inHuenee in the world of product designo Designcrs who ignore the l'act, or who allow their clients to ignore it, risk losing out on sorne ol'the most exciting marketing opportunities of the eighties and nine ties.,j6 Such av,,'arcness has resulted in the development ol' environmentally driven clesign agencies such as 02, a glohal collectivl' that l'ocuses on ecological concerns such as sustainabilit)', and ,",'orks with tracle and industry to minimise an)' destruc tivc impacto 37 Oesignen; within the group have produccd a wide variety ol' prod ucts. These range from Droog Design plant pots made l'rom cattle dung, which simultaneously use \,"aste material whilst l'ertilising plants as they grow, to Trevor Ba)'liss's wind-up radios for countries ¡n Africa, where battcries are not ahvays availahlc, but where dissemination of information to comhat AIDS, for example, can he crucial.
Conclusion Clearl)', design is integrated into the \vider patterns ol' consumerism and society. Yet designers can be active participants in debating these critical issues through a eombination of theoretical discourse and dcsign practicc. Despite the numerous criticisms, design is clearl)'· not merely' a matter of the surface appearanee of objects; i1. is dcepl), rooted in 1.he strueture and the evolution of society. 11. shapes and, indecJ, is shapcd by the cultural, political, economie and sodal environment in which it evolvcs.
Further Reading Fony, Adriall. ObJeas ef Desire: DC;J8n and Sourty SinO: 1750 (1ondon, 1995).
Heskctt, John. '/;JOthPICks <1nd 108[15: Dc.'l8n In Erc~lJay 1 iJé (Oxford, 2002)
Julier, Guy. Thc Culture 4Des18n (London, 2000).
Margc1lin, Victor, cd. [)c>J8n Discoursc: Hntor!. Thcor:v, CrifirHm (Chicago, 1989).
Woodham, Jonathan. Twentterh-Ccmury DcsJ8n (OxEon1, 1997).
I Anthony Bcrtram, DesiBI 2 On the rising lrade bctw, ([ ondon, J 99S); Lisa Jar anJ lH!st (London, 200( i}Jichdangf10 (Oxfonl, 20 3 Ric"hanl Buehanan, cited
(Chicago, 1%9), p. 3.
4 On the dnelopmcnt of (
¡he 1-{¡st(l~)' uIDesign (1on( S Cuy Julier, ]"he Culture ej' 6 Ibid., 1'.147. 7 Scc wW\"".dynamicearth e 8 Simon 'lch;ma, Emharra:'s (London, ¡ 987) offers a gl Ndherlands. 9 Adrian Forty, OhJccls ofDe 10 Ibid., p. 1I 11 Louis Sullivan. 'A Tall 01 Kindergarten ChrliS (rfJlised 1 12 jonathan Woodharn, Tirent 13 H. Kryk, circe! in Forh, Ol 14 Ibid. .
J 5 Woodham, Twcntietn.(entu. 16 Sec.'\ ldou.s lfuxlcy, Bran: N disation by imagining a mI: film ,110dem rlm~s oE 1936 17 Sel' Kay Shddon and E~ (Nc\',' York, 1932). 18 Sce Vallce PaC"kard, The }¡ 19;7
19 See james Meller, eJ., The j 20 R. Buckrnimter FulJcr 'Th Uni\ersity of Orcgon ¡'n 19 21 \Voodharn, ljventlrth.Cenrur; 22 Ibid .. 1'. 196. 23 Ettore Sottsas.'>, citC'd in Mid 1986), p. In. 24 Sce Volkcr H.~chcr, ed., Oesj 25 Julier, The Culture qfDcs/8 n ,; 26 Don Slater, Consumer Culture 27 See Roland Banhc.'i, J~)'lholq 28 lean Ballrlrillard, fhe' Systcm. 29 Slater, Consuma Culture and ,i 30 Woodham, 7¡'¡'·entieth.Century 31 Naomi KJein, No '.ogo (Lond. 32 Alkn Case)', 'Tibor Kalrnan: 1998), p. 25. 33 First fhm8s Fmr .lfan!festo l{lC
OESIGN ANO MüOERN CULTURE
65 Notes
3
4 5 6 7 8
9
la 1J
12 1i 14 15 16
17 1S \9
20
21 22 23 24 2')
26 27 28 29
30 31 3~
33
Anthony Ikrtram, Dcsl,qn (London, 1938) p. 1\. ()n thc rising tl"ad(· Dctwecn Europe and Asia, see Craig Cluna:'., Chmese Export Art and Deslfln (London, 199B); Lisa jardinc am)jerry Brotton, Glohal InlCTóh Renaissance An bClll·ú'n East .m J HesT (London, 2000); Jerr)' Brotton, The Renl1l.lxonce Ra7QQr: hom the Silk Rood ro .lúdle!anlje!o (Oxfonl, 200i). Richanl Buchanan, cited in Vic10r Margolin, ed., De,I'18n DiscoulSe: HlSrO~", Theo"r, Cn/lCIsm (Chicago, 1989), p. 3. On lhe deve!opm('nt ol' Jesign history as a diKiplitle, see John Walker, DC:ilgn HmofJ cmJ lhc HHro"r rif Deslljn (London, 1989). Gu)' Julier, lhe Cu!lure ?IDi!sIBn (Lonclon, 2000), p. ). [hid., p. 147. Se!.: \\w\v.dvnalllÍC"earth.co.uk. Simon Schama, [mbarTassmenr o/ RH'hc,': ,m Imerprewllon of Dureh Cuflure In the Colden /Ifle (London, 19~7) otTl'r~ a good account of' the consumerist hoom in the sC\cntccnth-century Netherlal\rls. Adrian Forty, ObJens ?J De.wC." De.';JBn and SOCIél} .IWü' 1750 (London, 1995), p. 11. Ihid.,p.l!. Louis Sullivan, 'A Tal] Ofticc Building Artisrically Comidered' (\896), jn 1. Atlw\', ('d. KmJ.:rjarten ChClls (m ¡,ed /918) ilnJ Otha ll"lItlllfls (New York, 19+7), pp. 202 13. Jonathan \Voodham, TwcntIClh-Cenrury DC.i13n (Oxl'ord, 1997), p. n. H. Kr)'k, cited in Fony, Obleet., arDes/re, p. 245. Ibid. \Voodham, 7i~rnllerh-CenruryDeslgn, p. 71. Sel' A]dous Huxley, Bmre :\ew ¡f;Jrld (1932), which Jtta<..'ks such meciunisation and ~tandar di~ation by imagining a nwd1<1ni~tic socicty devoid 01' (,lllotion. AJso, t1lí' Charlic Chaplin ti]m .l{oJan Times of 19 3b, which ~imilarly attelllpts to portr"y these ideas. Se!' Ray Shddon ami ....gmont Arens, Comumcr LnBIneenno· /1 \'cw 7echmque Jor Prospl'lJt) (New York, \932). Sce Vance Packard, The H1JJen Perwl1Jers
hnI Thin8s First ,ll<.lTl!fesro 2000, ww\v.adhusters.org.
66
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
34 'Th(' Rt'.ldf'TS Repl), to First Things First Manif('sto 2000', in fm'Wé, \lo. 2S (Fall, 1999).
35 Pc:kr Dorrner, The MC¡JnJtl8S ?f/ffoJcrn De.\'18n \Lonc1on, jqqO), p. 181.
~6 Elington, Burke ane! Hail('.~, Lited in vVnodharn, TwcFltieth CenftJ~1 Des/8n, p. 239.
37 Scc ww\\.o2.org.
--------------Fashion i~ one of the fastest eh culture. h a150 has widespre..:
much greater accessibilit)' thar
alent designer industries. Sine
profile within acaciemic thougl cver bcfore. This chapter (00 fashion that have de\'dopecl e writer... in the area such as EH: Christopher Breward. Their w of sdf-fashionino, fro ro its rolé b to cornmunicate and challenge signihcancc al' fa:--hion as both
with the reaHtics nf fashion as"
------------1
Bcfore cxploring fashion in gre
Should the ter m 'fashion' be ap
hi:"tory? Cenainlv" all human el , body in sorne wa)', as Elizaheth
5. Fashion: Style. Identity and Meaning Fiona Anderson
Introduction Fashion ís one of the fastest changing sourccs af new ideas in contemporary Yisua! culture. lt also has ",...idespread popular appeal; evcn designer-k ...·el fashion has much greatcr acccssibility than the equivalent products, images and tcxts af equiv alent designer industries. Since the mid-1980s fashion has also enjoyed a higher profilc ,,,'ithin academic thought, international exhihitions and popular media than evcr befofc. This chapter looks at multidisciplinar)' approaches to the study of fashion tha! have dcvelopcd during this periad, and discusscs the work 01' key "Titen in the area such as Elizabdh WlIson, Fred Davis, Joanne Entwhistle and Christophef Bre\\'anl. Thcir work will he uscd to highlight debates on aH aspects oI' self-fashioning, from its role in thc negotiation 01' gender rclations to its power to communicatc and challcnge accepted social and political ideals. It explores the significance of fashion as both a historical and contcmporary phenomenon, along \\'ith the realitics ol' fashion as a commercial industry and economic conccrn.
Definitions
------------------------Before exploring fashion in grcater depth it is uscful to considcr some i;lefinitions. Should the tcrm 'fashion' be applied to all meaDS ol' aoorning the body thr'Oughout histor}? Certainly, aH human cultures and societit:s have uecorated or adorneo the body in .'>ome way, as Elizabdh Wilson states:
68
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
In aH societics thc horly is 'dressed' and cvcry"\vhere dress and adornment play
in modern weste
svrnholic, communicati\'(~ .md aesthetic roles. Drcss 1S ahvay.'i 'uDspeakably
terms of all sart<
~1e<mingful.' Thc
carllest forros of 'clothing' seem to have bcco adornments
wcar clothes that
such as hod y painting, ornarncnts. scaritlcations (scarring). tattooing, masks
To he unfashional
and often constricting neck and "".list hands. Many 01' these ddormed, reforrncd or otherwise modificd the hody."
thc parameters. 4o
The questioD of \\,hether these earlicr forms of 'dressing' the hüd y should be vicwcd in a similar wav to historieal
This is c~rtainly true o fashionab]c drcss and in
contemporarv, fashionable dress dcscrves further investigation. This is particularl)' due to the recent popularity of 'tribal'
century thc expansion e
adornments such as tattooing and multiple piercings \vithin mainstream contcm
ities took on new mor
porar)' appearam.:cs. Mmt eontemporary \\:riters descrihe fashion as a specific
earlier restriction to eo'
.'iystem of dress that emergcd \".. . ithin Europe in Lhc late Middle Ages. It... deve1op
until the 19305 , hv, whi, which eyeryonc, or aIm
Of
~
ment \vas linked to the cxpansion 01' cities and thc gro...v th of mercantilc capital
sumers on])' sorne tim
ism. Whilst earlier forms of ciress and adornment have sorocthing in common \\,ith fashion - the)' also express important meanings within speeific societies and cul tures - one should not consider tlwm in the same wal' as the distinctive s)'stem of drcss known as Llshion. So what js unique to fashion as a \vay 01' adorning, thc hody? Elizabelh Rousc has suggested lhat 'fashion seems to be about change for changl''s
The increasing importa: ti . . . e criticism from mor
sake , and thc illusion of non·ltv'. , 2 Ulrich Lehmann has made a similar point,
toonists. Sen··.. een the fe
arguing that 'Jn itsclf, sartorial fashion stands, almost b)' definition, for the abso
creation of sumptuary la
lutel)' ncw - for permanent non'1ty and constant, insatiable ehange.' \
restríct the consurnptio
This appears to be a highly appropriate way to distinguish hctwccn Western dress froro the late Middle Ages onwards and modes of apparC'] such as Lhe lndian sari or ]apanese kimono, which have remained rdatively unchanged for ccnturies.
practicc thcy , were rarel'. betwecn the spread of f tures. s Criticisms of fash
Yet although Wcstern fashion has unquestionabl)' been hascd on a ceaseless ami
ter within mid-scventee
rapid turnoyer 01' styles, ciress in the rest ofthc world has not remained complete]),
period, whi<.:h states:
untouched by change. Neyertheless, in broad terros such a characterisation ol' fashion rcmains extremely useful. It also leaos to further questions, such as
A woman which is
whether (]11 Western dress from thc fourtecnth century onwards should be con
worme, which is bl
sidered as fashion. Surdy Lhere must bE' sornc exceptions that stand outsidc thc
gras5e Iyeth hid the
relentlessly changing cycle of new styles. For instance, WE' aH are a\varE' 01' individ
po)'son: and in the (
uals who takc HttlE' interest in their appearance or who through taste, age or
some filthiness in h
OLTU
pation seem to be rathcr disconnected from contemporary fashion styling. But even if one considcrs an example like Rritish police uniforms since the 1960s, it
Such criticisms had se¡
is eas)' to identify changcs in design informcd hy deyelopments in fashion. The
pursuit, hut tbey belped t
need for the policc to communicatc social authority means that their uniforms
trivial and jéminine. SUbSf
have to show symbolic links with the societ)' being policcd. The most logical \Vay
or Georg Simmd (1858
to do this is to adhcrc to sorne of the codes of contemporary fashion designo
thE'ir writings were often
Consideration of su eh aH examplc makes it eas)' to concur with Elizabeth Wilson 's
icisms of tashion. Por e:
\'¡ew that
fashjon, as feehle beings
FASHION: STYLE, IDENTITY AND MEANING
69
in modern westcrn societies no clothes are outside fashion; fasruon sets the terms of al! sartorial bchayiour . . . Even the determincdly unfashionablc wcar clothes thar manifest]y represent a reaetían against what is in fashion. Tú be unfashionable is not to escape the whole discourse,
OT
to get outside
the parameters. 4 This is certainly true al' contemporary dress and saciet)', but unlimitecl access to Fashionable dress and information abour new styles became a reahty for most con sumers ooly sorne time after the late Middle Ages. From the mid-eighteenth century the expansion al' the mass consumption al' fashionable styles and commod ¡ties took on new momentum. Fashionable ciTess began to move a\vay from ib earlil'r restriction to court society and wealth)' merchants. This process continued until the 1930s, by which time it \vas possible to speak ol' fashion as something in \vhich l'veryone, or almost everyone, could and did take parto
Debates on Fashion The increasing importancc ol' fashion has inspired considerable debate and nega tivc criticism from moralists, government and religious figures and political car toonists. Between the l'ourtcenth and sixteenth centuries its emergence led to the creation 01' sumptuary laws in several European countrics. These werc designed to restrict the consumption uf certain textiles to the upper echclons 01' societ),. In practicc they '.\-'ere rarcly enforced, hut their introduction is indicative of eonfliets between the spread 01' fashion consumption and cxisting social and moral struc tures.:; Criticisms of l'ashion took on a particularly extreme and aggressive charac ter within mid-sf'venteenth-century Britain, as illustrated by a pamphlet ol' the period, which states: A woman which is faire in shew, is foule in condition: shc is like unto a glow worme, '\vhich is bright in the hcdge, and blacke in the hand; in thc greenest grasse lycth hid the greatest serpents: painted pottes commonly hold deadly poyson: and in the c1eerest water the ugliest Tode; and the fairest woman hath sorne filthincss in her. 6 Such criticisms had scant effcct
OIl
the rise uf fashion consumption as a popular
pursuit, but they helped to create a penasive view 01' fashion as immoral, wastcful, -. trivial andIemmme. Subsequently, thcorists such as Thorstein Veblen (1857-1929) or Georg Simmel (18 ~8 1918) formulated more sophisticatcd approaches, but their writings were often underpinned by negative stanees that echoed earlier crit icisms of fashion. For example, Veblen's writings depict women as objects of fashion, as reeble beings whose prime motivation is to decorate themselves as a
70
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
means of displaying their husbancl's wealth. 7 ~ggativ~ vicws uf fashion have per
articulate more subtle, 1
sisted even until relatively recent times, and this has been despite the declining influ
moods, aspirations and el
ence of religious moral views
Oil
the body and rhe fa(:t thar in the West rhey have
largcly becn replaced by a consumerist-inspircd c-e1ebration ol' bodies, pleasure and
By social identit)', 11
erotÍC' visual cli::.play. Thc follüwing excerpt [rom The Face of August 1997 highlights
to which sorne soc
the contradictor)' vie\\'s
Oil
rhe body, consumption and pleasure prevalent in coo
temparar)' saciety. It statcs:
within the concept' through symbolic rr through predominaJ
Many people have becn paying fashion more and more attention throughout
this fast, hright, jumbled-up decade
however imprecise ,
. Thanks to the designer boom, oft
identit)' points to thl
controversial fashion photography, in the forro of adverts, no\\' looms largc
and actually do con
e atwalk shO\vs are no longer the province 01' the cog
ahvays the same).lO
in our towns and cities.
noscenti, but staple light--entertainment fare. Reporters analyse the shows and the stories and turn them into nevvs, so often that we no\v think nothing
Fashion encapsulates c(
of seeing a story about a modcl's age or weight on the front page of a national
with other characteristics
m·wspaper. Al! this means that fashion has nO\v accrucd all the celebrities,
speciflc historical develof
merchandising, empty spectacle, duhious morality and media coverage that
mid-eighteenth ccntury o
it no\\-' takes to bccome a fully-Hedged entertainment mcdium. 1l
from the countryside to
although by the nineteent Oespite the continued promincnce of similar views in contemporary media,
Individuals, whose exper
recent critical and theoretical writing on fashion has tended to move awa)' from
highly personal ba,;s withi
such condemnation. The so-called 'ncw fashion history' has focused on a more
radically ncw expericnce~
rounded analysis of fashion, acknowledging nc-gative aspccts such as the exploita
ers, unknown and anonyr
ti..-c nature of clothing production. hut also embracing its positive characteristics.
from thcir dressed outer :
Elizabeth Wilson's work, in particular. AdorneJ in Drearos: rashion and Modcrnuy
fashion made possible by 1
(19gS), has he en iclentitied as somcthing
01' a turning point in the development of
new approaches to fashion. It typifies the tendency within n::(:ent rescarch to explore fashion 's ability to articulate identitics in a pleasurable and empowering
to-wear c10thing industry, ne\\-' forms of sociallife. A related phenomenon
way, as well as its potential to provoke debate about wider social and political con
led to widespread anxietie:
cerns. Such writing draws on a range of academi(: disciplines, induding sodology,
about the possibility tha~
cultural studies, material cultural studies, psychology and gender studies."
" essay 'Fashion' (1904), Sir to ncgotiate thc ne\'\' ten sil
Fashion and Identity
distinctive, sense of indivi(
Our public and private selves are expericnccd on a dail), hasis as inseparable from
fasbion is the imitatie
fashionable dress and adornmcnt. Even in tlw most intimate moments we are
adaptation ... at the
usually 'dresscd' through hairstyling, je\vellery or other bodily adjustments related
fercntiation, the ten
to display, such as hair removal, dieting or exercise. Thus when one considers the
changC' ami contrast.
formation Jnd cxpression 01' social identities, fashionablc appearances playa crucial role. Fashion has the potential to interact with primary social categories such as gender, age, race, dass and nationality. Self-fashioning a1so has thc potential to help
As our b()(tie.s circulate they are drosed provides
t'
FASHION: STYLE, IDENTITY AND MEANING
71
articulate more subtlc, though equa)))' important, aspects al' ourselves such as moods, aspirations and emotions. As Frcd Davis states:
By social idcntity. 1mean much more than the symbols of social class Of status to "\vhich sorne soeiologists are inclined to restrict the concepto 1 inelude within the conccpt's purview ao)' aspcct uf self abau! which individuals can through symbolic means cornmunicate \vith athers, in the instance al" ciress through predoffiinantly non-discursive visual, tactile, and olfactory symbols, howc"cr imprecise and elusivc these may be. In .lny case the concept of social identity point.s to the configuration of attrihutes and attitudes persons seck to and J\._tually do cornmunicate about themselves (obviously thc two are not always the samc).IO Fashion encapsulates complex and contradictory aspects of our identities, but as with other characteristics of t~1.shion this nccds to he considered in conncction with spccific historical developmcnts. The development of industrialisation from the mid-eighteenth ccntur)" onwards led to the movement 01' vast numbers of pcople from thc countryside to largc urhan centres. This happcncd first in Britain, although hy the nincteenth century it
,:\'.1:--
occurring throughout most of Europe.
lndividuals. whose experience of social contact h
I1
Thesc changcs, along with the wider acccss to
fashion made possible by re]ativcly larger ineomes and an cxpansion in the ready to-wear clothing industry, helped to position fashion as playing a crucial role in th(· new forms of sociallif'e. A related phenomcnon was the emergence uf thc crowd in urban contexts. This led to widcspread anxieties amongst city dwellers, who becamc incrcasingly feariul about the possibHity thatthe·individual might 1)(.> overwhclmed by the mass. In rus ~"- essay 'Fashion' (1904), SirnmeYpinpoints thc role
01' fashionable dress as a mcans
to negotiate the new tensions hct\veen fitting in "\vith thc crowd, and expressing a distinctivc, scnsc of individuality. He statcs: fashion is thc imitation of a given examplc and satisfies the demand for social adaptation.
. at the same time it satisnes in no less degrcc thc need of dif
ferentiation, thc tcndency towards dissimilarity, the desire for constant changc and contrast. 12 As our bocHes circulate ......ithin societ)', the fact that they are dressed and haw thcy are dressed prmides the opportunity either to eonform socially or to express
72
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
OUT
individuality. In practice, most people aim to satisfy both thcsc contradic1:ory
social and psychologícal drives simultaneously. Fashion provides a means of forming ana articulating identity in relation to the various social groups we cncounter in
OUT
lives, as weH as the wider social cornmunity. As Lehmann .'ltates,
'ir i5 precisdy sartorial fashion that establishes the depieted as a social hcing, as a waman or man who is sct \\o'ithio progressing time'. 13 This sacül dimension of
¡.shion has bccn explored by other authors, including Norbert Elias (1897 1990) amI Picrre Bourdieu, who trau' the links between distinctions in bodi'íy adornment and the maintcnance of dass, status and püwcr by certain groups.l+ Adorning the body provides a means of nmnccting with others, but it may also be used to exclude them if thcir appearance indicates that the)' do not belong to the appro 2iatc social group for a speeific contexto When attending a public school parents' day, a pub after a football match, or a hip hop dub, most people dress to fit in, for fear that they might othen\,'ise be excluded from social contact hy the rest 01' the gathering. Even when people deliberatel)' sd thcmsclves apart by exhibiting a par ticular taste, tbey al so often simultaneously show membership of specific social groups. A goocl example of this is youth subcultures in which individuals use style as a means of asserting a group identity that is in sorne way cliffercnt from main stream tastes and values.
Ir is also important to consider the constantly shifúng nature of the rclationship betwecn social identity and fashion. This has beco me increasingly complex since the 19605, when traditional social categories of dass, race, gender amI sexuality began to be debated and contestcd by polítical mo"ements such as feminism and the civil rights movemcnt in America. The appearancc orthe punk girl at the ,.'entrc ofRichard Brainc's photograph of The Roxy Club vividly illustrates punk's rejection of cstablishecl notjons of fcmininity and femininc heauty. (Figure 5. 1). The radical campaigns by these movcmcnts for greater social status and freedom for minorit)' groups have to a large extent now hccomc accepted witrun main stream societrJ Elizabeth Wilson argues tbat fashion is an important means by which ,ve negotiate the complcxities of contemporar)' societ)'l stating that 'our culture of global mass media feeds us so mucb information that a massivc cultural ec1ecticism is the on1)' possiblc response'. 15 The attempt to form a cohesive sense of identity ,",,,,ithin this cnvironment becomes extreme!} difhcult, and hcncc sclf adornment becomes a means of articulating a sense 01" ambiguity and ambivalence. However acute the sense of relentlessly shifting reaHty in contemporary life, in earlier periods fashion displayed a crucial ability to knit togcthcr contradictor), aspccts of our social selves into visual and tactite formo Probably the most impor tant social category dcfined by dress is gcndcr. Despite significant changes in the gendcr roles 01' men and womcn since the 1960s, maintenance of gender identity remains a predominant feature of contemporary social Jife, and this is primarily gauged through appearances. Uniscx garments such as jeans, trainers and T-shirts
Figure' 5.1 - Richard Braine,
FASHION: STYLE, IDENTITY AND MEANING
73
Figure 5 1 - Richard Brainc, The Ro~y Club (1977). Photograph C1l Richard Braine~PYMCA.
74
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
are no\\' woro and accepted within a variety of social contexts. However, most
endeavours could lie onl
people wearing these t)'pcs al' garments use hairst)'ling, make-up, je\,\rcllery or
elegantly or claborately ¡
remale gendcr idcntity. From the 19705 on\vards, and particularl), sincc- thc 19805, promincnt fashj()~ dcsigners such as Jean Pa01 Gaultier and Vivienne \Vestwood have explored
rcyealed the previously míddle-class maje consul
thc persistencc of gender coding conventions and stereot)pes through thcir
in male dress ol' the peric
designs. In mast contexts nonconformity to gender roles through drcss tends to
nm'elty and sartorial disf
othcr iteros of clothing as a meaos of reasserting a srecifie maIe
üf
signallack of social conformity in a broader sensc.
This idea has recently
not onl)' hetween men ar
Becausc üf its cruC'Íal role in cornmunicating gender, dTess has had a strong pres
Due to the hinary relatio
eoce within political and social campaigns to changC' the status nf vmmen. Thi." has
and masculinitics cannol
included thc ('ad)' American feminist movcment of the mid-nineteenth centur)'
engagement with fasIDo!
whích, through thc campaigns 01' AmeBa Bloomcr, directly chalknged the incvita
domain in the period frOl
hility 01' men being the only gender literally and also metaphoricalIy lo 'wear the trousers'. 16 The second wave feminist movement 01' the 1960s and 1970s took at
on the relationship betwl
hest a rather disdainfuI view 01' fashion. Most \-vriters were 01' the opinion that fashion objeetitled \\'omcn and that it played a key role in reinforcing fcmale stereo types and therefore femaIe oppression by meno However, a si.gnificant shift in fem
A focus on the capacity 01
inist thought in the 1980s encouraged new attitudes to sexual pleasure, whieh werc
nifieant social and cultur;
soon translaled into new approaches to a range of media connected to female plcas
that it is alsü t'erJ big busi! it is essential to acknowle
ure, including cinema, romantic hetion, make-up and fashionabIe dress. 17 Most writing on drcss and adornment has until reeentlJ focuscd on the relation
nomic conU.Tn. Large 1',
ship between the femaIe gender and fashion. Furthermore, the majority ofwriting
make huge profits froro d
on men's dress has tended to 'underplay ir not den)' the phenomcnon of men's
for fantas)', sdf-realisatic
fashion' .\S Since the 1980s, however, such assumptlons have been challenged, for
fashion, does one begin
fashionabIe consumption has had an equally important role in the formation and
fashioJ1 business and alsl
express ion 01' maIe identities. Most rcsearch in this area has focusea on the perlod alter thc second world war, highlighting the role- of fashion in men 's lives in an era
devcloped understandin~ society, the mode! 01' the
üf cxpanding consumerism. The key dehate has been whether this shift was linked
Cllsses it in the following
1
purel)' to new cornmercial strategies on behalf 01' marketers, advertisers Jnd retail ers, or whethcr it reHeeted genuine shifts "'ithin mJinstream masculinity. Much has
Understandíng fas.hi
revohed around the concept 01' the 'Ne\\' Man', a model 01' cJring, nurturing ano
different boclies ope
narcissistic mJsculinity widely touted in media and advcrtising 01' thc 1980s. These
dcnts, dcsigners an
challenges to the simplistic and all-cmhracing assumptions that fashion is primar
photographers, as
ilv J feminine pursuít, and that men enjo), a predominantly practical rclationship
buyers, shopsandec
~ith their dothes, led, in
the late 19905, to a wider re-examination of the histori
there would he no (
cal relJtionship betwecn men and fashion. This eentred principall), around a ques
cultural intermedial
tioning 01' the theor)' oi' the 'Creat Masculine Renunciation' proposed by the
psychologist
J.
C. Flugd in 1932. Flugel argucd that from the late eighteenth
\'/Ould not be tTansn
i'ashionable dress w(
eentury onwards men renounced any ¡ntcrest in fashion and fashionable disphv:
~t
This model is particuL
being onl)' useful. So far as c10thes remajncd oí' importance to him, his utmost
necting individuals, inst
'Man
~hJndoned his
c1aim to be
co~sidered beautiful.
He hcnceforth aimed
FASHION: STYLE, IDENTITY AND MEANING
75
endeavours could lie únly in thc (Hrection of being "correctly" attired, not ofbeing elegantl)' or elaboratcly attired.' 19 This idea has recentl)' beco guestionecl. For example, Christopher Breward has re\'ealed the previousl)' hiel den connections betvveen vt'Orking~clas!' and lower ~ middle-class mal e consumers ano fashionable display_ Alongsidc a ('ertaio sobricty in male drcss al' the period there also existcd a ¡h'el)' engagcment vliith Fasbionable novelt)' and sartorial display.20 This has led to
Dew
pcrspectives 00 the relationship
not únl)' bctween men and fashion, but al so het\veen men and women ana fashion. Due to the binar)' rclationsrup betwccn gender amI dress, changing vicws on men and masculinities cannot hclp but affeet our vie\\-'s on fernininity and ferninine engagcrnent with fa~hion, 11' fashion ('annot be sccn as an exclusi"cly ferninine dornain in the periad from the late eighteenth ccntury to thc 1950s, then our vicws on thc rclationship het\\'een women and fashion must change too,
The Fashion 5ystem A focus on the capadt)' offashion to encap~ulate eomplex, intangible but highly sig nificant social and cultural meanings can sometimes lead to myopi,a about the faet that it is .lIso ver)' big business. [n order to study fashion in any kind of apposite ""vay it is essential to acknowledge that it is a commercial industry and therefore 3n eco nomic eoncern. large fashion companie:-. such as Cahin Klein, Gap amI Gucci make huge profits from the precarious business of appealing to consumers' desires for fanta.s)', sclf-realisation ana the next hig thing. How, thcn, when studying fashion, aoes one hegin to embrace an understanding of both the rcalities 01' the fashion husiness and also it.s wider social and cultural significance? For a more devclopcd understanding of the complex series of roles that fashion plays within societ)', the modcl of the fash¡on s)'stem 1S a usdul starting point. Entwhistle dis cusscs it in the following \Va)': Undcrstanding fas,hion reguires undcrstanding thc rclationship betwccn these difIerent bodics operating within the fashion s)'stem: fashion colleges and stu dents, aesigners and design houscs, tailors and scarnstresses, modcls and photographers, as "vell as fashion editors, distributors, retailcrs, fashion buycrs, shops and consumcrs ... without the countless scamstresses and tailors there would he no dothes to comume; without the promotion of rashion by cultural intermediaries, sueh as Jashion journalists, 'fashion' as the latest st)'le would not be transmitted ver)' rar; ana without thc acceptance 01' consumers, fashionahlc dress ,,,,,ould lie unworn in factorics, shops and wardrobes. 21 This mode\ i.'i particularl), revealing as it traces thc complex series of intercon necting imliYiduals, institutions and preoccupations potentially involved with
76
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
fashion. The fashion system is al50 llseful as it embraces hoth the positive and neg
dd ven hy new, more so
ative aspects nf fashlon. It allows us to conceive of ao industry that shamefully
ing goods. 26
exp\oits Asian workers in ugly sweatshops, whilst at the same time creating objects
The nineteenth centu development of a mode
ofgreat heaot)', e1<.'gance and charro. This rundel also provides a good starting point for thinking about haw to study [a5hion. Although Ent\vistlc's examples mainI)'
the nineteenth century t"
relate to rhe eontemporary fashion system, she al so maps out the broad pararnc
the development of sciel
ters for rescarching historical [a5hion, namely design, production, consumption
such as the chest is used
and social amI cultural contexts. Within fashion studies rhe word 'collsumption'
curves arouna the undere
implies the whole sphere of activity connccted to rhe sale of fa.'Ohion from market
and dothing sizes a pos
ing, advertising, distrihution .1ml ret
machinc in the 1840s, gr
think about it .1fter purchase.
c1otrung. By the late n:
Roland Barthes (1915 80) unclertook the first significant study ofthe repn:scn
expandcd tu involve pot(
t.1tion of fashion, or the transl.1tion of clothing into language in The Fashion S)'stem,
middlc-class consumers.
\vhich was first published in 1967. In this semiotic analysis of fashion texts in mag
Since the e.1dy t\vent
azines, Barthes providcs a det.1iled interpretation uf one specific slice uf th<..' f.1shion s),stem. 22 Huwever, the term 'fashion system' here embraces wider .1speets of thc
distinguished by its low industries. This is due
fashion inclustry and dothing in ever)'day use. It i.'O therefore important to examine
machine, which remains
briefly some key developments ,.... ithin the fashion inclustry from the mid
done much to shape the
cighteenth centur)' tu the presen!. This is not
attempt to provide .1 comprehen
with most production fo.
sive anal)'sis of a vast .1nd complex set of intcrconnecting developments. It is merely
most design and marketi
to highlight how variuus aspccts of the iashion s)'Stem are shaped by and aIso hclp
01" the "Vest.
ID
to shape the wiclcr dynamics ofsocial, economic, political ancl cultural change. This
The relatively hackwar
also hclps rcinforce the notion that the study of fasruon is a hybrid subject, which
tr.1st to the aggressive ar
involves consideration uf consumption, technology, cconomics, politics and social
advertising. From the lat
ancl cultural contcxts, as weH as the actions ofindivicluals. H
stimulated by the develo}
Frum at le.1st the 1750.'0, fashionable consumption began to shift from hcing
ing and retailing techniqu
centred .1lmost cxdusively on court socict)' ancl wealthy merchants, to being a
dt::partment stores of the '
widcspread popular conccrn. New clevelopment.s in manufacturing ancl t('chnol og)' also hegan to impact on the produC"tion of fashion. 24 Recent rese.1rch on
In Shoppi1l9 jor Plcasurl popul.1r lcisure actiyity ce
inclustri.1lisation has lecl to a rC.1ssessment of classic notions of the Industrial
nincteenth century there
Rcvolution, .1S inv(llving rapid and wiJesprcad mcch.1nisation in Hritain in the late
v.1riety 01' popular medi.1, ,
eightccnth ccntur)'. Man)' inclu:-itrics were in fact sIn", to meehanise, and the
inclu:-itry amI the way tha.t
vvúh.'spreacl clomin.1tion oI' maehine manuf.1cturing within British inclustr)' did not
"'as not just about clothes
happen until the nineteenth centur)'. ~5 Howeyer, the fashinn textiles inclustr)" par
lwcame inseparable from t
ticularl)' eotron, \V.1S rapidly transformed hy the introduction of powered machin
By the Ctul." twcntieth cen Fair offercd "·omen regule potential to providc fanta~ crucial to the dcveJopmenl sumer culture, to v,,·hich n ity were integral.
ery in the late cighteenth centur)'. At this time the reacly-madc clothing tr.1cle also cmlTgcd, which initially involvecl the production of simple, unfitted garments sueh as chemises, aprons, caps and sleeve ruH-ks. Fashion.1ble noveltics 01' thi5 kind becamc widC'l)' accessible to the midclle and lower social c1asses. This formed p.1rt of an overall expansion nf 1'a.shionable consumption amongst thc middle sections of society. This was in part facilitatcd by gre.1ter levels of wealth and was aIso
FASHION: STYLE, IDENTITY AND MEANING
77
driven by new, more sophisticated means of distributing, retailing and advertis ing goods. 26 The nineteenth ccntury brought furthcT technological changcs, cnhancing the development al' a modern, democratic fashion system. Around the beginning of the nineteenth century the tape measure carne into use, which subscqucntly led
lo
the developmcnt of scientific cutting systems. In these systcms a certain measure such as the chest is used lo calculate others more difficult lo measure, such as the
curves around the underarm. These advances helped lo makc standardised patterns and clothing sizes a possibility and, along with the introduction of the sc\.ving machine in the 1840s, greatly eontributcd lo the growth in the mass production ol' clothing. By the late ninetccnth centur)', the ready-made clothing trade had expanded to involve potentially the entirc wardrobe for working-class and lower middle-class consumers.?7 Since the earl)' twentieth century, the fashion industr), has been increasingly distinguished hy its low le\cel of technological developmcnt compared to other industries. This i5 due to the dominance of the índividuall)'-operated sewing machine, \\!hil'h remains at the centre of clothing production toda),.28 It has .lIso done much to shape the global structure ol' the nmtemporary fashion industry, with most production rocused in the Far East, ""here labour costs are cheap, and most dcsign and marketing activities carried out close to the consumer markcts of the West. Thc rclatively backward status of fashion manufacturing stands in marked con trast to the aggressi\'l~ and innovatory profiic of modern fashion marketing and ad\ertising. From the late nineteenth ccntury fashion consumption \\'as further stimulated by the developmcnt ol' increasingly sophisticated marketing, advertis ing and retailing techniques, as epitomiscd hy the new overwhclmingly luxurious dcpartment stores ol' the era (Figure -5.2). In Shopping Jor Plcasurc Erika Rappaport explores the rise of shopping as a popular leisure acti\ity central tn modern conceptions of puhHc Jife. 29 In the late nineteenth century therc- was J.lso an expansion in the protile of fashion withln a \ariety nf popular media, which had a significant impact on the naturc ofthe fashion industry and the
\\'J)'
that consumers engaged \Yith fashion. Increasingly, fashion
"'las not just about clothes; the idealised illustrations ol'fered by fashion magazines bccame inseparable from thc hcady experience of fJshion as part 01' daily sociallife.
By the ead)' twcntieth century publications such as HOl1Jdn's Own, l0guc and l/émisr Fuir
offcrcd \vomen regular opportunities to engagc with fashion imagery and its
potentiJ] to providc fantas)', escape or sclf-rcalisation."lO These publkatioTl'i were crucial to th(' development and promotion of the values of twenticth-century con~ sumer culture, to which ne\v conceptions oflwauty, gender, the bod)' and scxual itj' \.....cre
integral.
78
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
advertisements. Anotl the fashion system by the fashion industry, i~ After the second w a distincti Vl' social cat! the 1950s, a host of di mods, skinheads, punl tion of specific group j in sorne wa)' oppositio plified the pot ntial e Lurie argues: Youth cultures al meaning in a ral dress, demeanor, these eady interj of defiance, polit
However, subcultur of pure or 'authentic' values. This was partiCl in the 1970s, such as D in th e debates was tI writel-S tended to see 1 tive influence on subcL various forms of media tures. As McRobbie st,
ligure 5.2 - Anonymolls photograph oF a Parisian drapery store (ca. 1860).© Roger- Viollet, Paris.
The Fashion System and Contemporary Fashion Consumption The model of the fashion system leads away from notions of the fashion industry as an inescapable controlling force that dominates our thinking about our bodies and ourselves. Although the fashion industry and allied media have a powerful and per suasive influence on th public, it is incorrect to :¡ssume that people simply swallow wholesale the imagcs, attitudes and actions proposed to them by fa:;hion market ing. For examplc, Diesel clothing may currently be fashionable, yet fey\, pcople wear it hcad to toe or strÍ\'e to look precisel} ¡ike the mod -ls in the company's
youth cultures m the text through fanzine-, video, al this and alongsid, taminated by thc provoke the react The relationship of.} than has been acknowk gence of The Face ane! I 1980s, hank Mort idel consuDlption. The dos tian are indicative of tl
FASHION: STYLE, IOENTITY ANO MEANING
79
advertisements. Another leading example of how consumers play an active role in the fashion system by contesting the mainstream meanings and values proposed by the fashion industry, is the phenomenon of youth subcultures. After the second world war, youth subcultures and youth carne to be treated as a distinctive social category, as a group vvith its ovvn tastes, styles and values. Since the 1950s, a host of different youth subcultures have emerged such as teddy boys, mods, skinheads, punks and skaters. These have been characterised by the forma tion of specific group identities, based not merely on age, but also on sets of values in sorne way oppositional to mainstream culture and society. They have thus exem plified the potential of dress lo express dissidence and social critique. As Celia Lurie argues: Youth cultures are thus .'leen here as the .'lites of struggles over the control of meaning in a rapidly developing consumer culture, struggles played out in dress, demeanor, music and language. The notion of resistance vvas central to these early interpretations of youth sub-cultures - style was .'leen as a form of defiance, political protest or semiotic guerrilla vvarfare. 31 Hovvever, subcultures are often vievved in a rather romanticised way, as a form of pure or 'authentic' resistance against mainstream social, polítical and cultural values. This was particularly the case in the early studies of subcultures undertaken in the 1970s, such as Dick Hebdige's Subculcure che Meaning1Seyle. 32 A central issue in these debates vvas the role of the media in relation to youth subcultures. Early writers tended to .'lee the media as having an antagonistic and ultimately destruc tive influence on subcultures. However, it has been recognised more recently that various forms of media play an integral part in the formation and spread of subcul tures. As McRobbie states: youth cultures make an explosive entrance into the world of the image and the text through a frenzy of communication, in style, in sound, in posters, fanzines, video, and in flyers and other publicity information. Without al! of this and alongside the pretensions of preferring to remain pure and uncon taminated by the media, youth cultures require this kind of self-publicity to provoke the reaction they do. 33 Thc relationship of youth subcultures to consumption is also far more complex than has been acknowledged in most texts on the topic. In rus analysis of the emcr gen ce of The Face and ID magazines, subsequently termed the 'style press' in the 1980s, Frank Mort identifies a form of youth cullure obsessively focused on elite consumption. The close relationships between youth, style, media and consump tion are indicative of the fact that 'the history of post-war British youth culture
80
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
displayed an ongoing as: other words, youth ClIlt tíon, and sub-cultural, ( kind of engagement wit placing youth at the cen rary culture 35 The complex Iinks 1; have also had significan' photography since the 1< quoted stat 'ment that 'f; fashion' became more J] photography to display a ral comment grew out ( ments in magazine pul-: magazines to feature 'stl club culture in one pub strong commitment to a ship from the mainstrcan of the 1980s these maga" ing new approaches to fa: in the 1990s. The commissioning pe and Duren have highlighte designers, photographcr: Many of these individuals on contemporary societ) phy, violence, death ancl 1990s, the neo-realist "c side aspirational, idealis("( ín the pages of Tne Face an dictory nature of the relat Hence, fashion encapslIl; culture, yet it may also ar
Figure 5.3 - Corinne Day, Kate Moss, ¡he Third Sllmmer '?f Lave (1990). © Corinne Da)'.
Fashion is defined by its e¡: Sdm~ time it plays the con of individuality or self-idc to fashion an identity thal development of industrio
FASHION: STYLE, ID· TITY ANO MEANING
81
displayed an ongoing association between commerce and popular aesthetics'.34 In other words, youth culture has always taken place within the sphere of consump tion, and sub-cultural, or other youth identities have never existed without sorne kind of engagement with consumer markets. Lurie takes this argument further by placing youth at the centre of new developments in consumerism and contempo rary culture 35 The complex links between media, youth cultures and fashion consumption have also had significant, if not transformative, effects on the nature of fashion photography since the late 1980s. 36 In that period Susan Sontag's erudite and oft quoted statement that 'fashion photography is much more than the photography of fashion' became more apt than ever before. 37 The increasing tendency of fashion photography to display a significant and self-conscious element of social and cultu ral comment grew out of and was facilitated by earlier groundbreaking develop ments in magazine publishing. The Face and ID emerged in 1980 as the first magazines to feature 'street-style' fashion, popular music, political comment and club culture in one publication. In the early years of publication, despite their strong commitment to a focus on style, they had a somewhat distanced relation ship from the mainstream fashion industry and from fashion advertising. By the end of the 1980s these magazines began to emerge as the breeding ground for challeng ing new approaches to fashion photography that were to become firmly established in the 1990s. The commissioning policies of magazines such as !he Face, ID, Dazed and Corifused and Dutch have highlighted the work of a young artistic and cultural elite of fashion designers, photographers, stylists, make-up artists, art directors and journalists. Many of these individuals have taken up the opportunity to make critical comment on contemporary society by raising issues such as racism, drugs, child pornogra phy, violence, death and confused sexual identities through their work. In the 1990s, the neo-realist work of Corinne Day and Davide Sorrenti coexisted along side aspirational, idealised advertising imagery from firms like Versace and Chanel in the pages of The Face and ID magazine, thus epitomising the complex and contra dictory nature of the relationships between fashion and young people (Figure 5.3). Hence, fashion encapsulates the desires and anxieties connected to consumer culture, yet it may also articuJate a refusal of, or challenge to, its inherent values.
Conclusion Fashion is defined by its ephemerality and constant dynamic of change, whilst at the same time it plays the contracJjctory role of 'fixing' or grounding our fragile sense of individuality or self-identity. The use of fashionable commodities by consumers to fashion an identity that is attractive or acceptable to others was integral to the development of industrialisation. From the mid-eighteenth century onwards
82
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
fashion became increas con test, accepted social uality. Fashion has been Western consumer cult sexuality are integral. H potent critiques of main temporary fashion desig Nick Knight (Figure 5.4 tal issues such as death a
Breward, Christopher. Fash¡, Entwistle, Joanne. The Fashío Taylor, Lou. Esrablishing Dres Wilson, Elizabeth. Adorned i,
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
,..J
(14 15 16 17 Figure 5.4 - ~ick Knight, Aimee Mullen wearing Alexander McQueen, from Dazed and Corjílsed Magazine (1998) ~.) Nick Knight.
18 19
Elizabeth ""ilson, Adol/)( Elizabeth Rouse, Underst, Ulrich Lehman, Ti8erspn Wilson, Adorned in Drearr. Negley Harte, 'State Cor in Medieval Europe (Londo (Manchester, 1995), pp. Archer, 'The Arraignme Christopher Breward, Th Thorstein Veblen, The Th 1899). Editorial in The Face, Aug See Joanne Entwhistlc, (Cambridge, 2000); and J Fred Davis, Fashion, CU/tlll Entwhistle, The FashioneJ Georg Simmel, 'Fashion' 1971)
Lehman, TiíJerspllln8' pp. ( Norbert Elias, The CivilisÍl Critique of the Jud8ement <J' Elizabeth Wilson, 'FJ.shiOl eds, Chic Thrills (London, En twhistle, The Fashioned ¡ See Jane Gaines. 'lntrodu( eds, Fabrications: Costume al Jennifer Craik, The Face of John Cad Flugel, The PSYCl
FASHION: STYLE, IDENTITY AND MEANING
83
fashion became incrcasingly available to aH as a means by which to express, or contest, acccptcd social norros rclatjng to gender. wealth, status, ethnicity or scx uality. Fashion has been central to the developrncnt
ano promotion of the \"alues of
Western consurncr culture to which conceptions of gendcr, bcauty, the bod]' and sexualit)' are integral. Howcvcr, the objects ano images of fashion ma)' aIso involve potent critiques of mainstream values amI idcals. Hence the tcndcncy of sorne con temparary fashion designers and photographers, such as Alexander Me Queen anO Nick Knight (Figure 5.4), to use an ephcmcral medium to cornmcnt 00 fundamen
tal issues such as death and the yulnerability of the body.
Further Reading Rre\\3rd, Christopher. Fashi(ln (Oxford, 2003).
Entwistle, Joanne. The FashlOTleJ Btl~v. Fashion, Dress anJ Mojan Socia! Theor)' (Cambridge, 2000).
Taylor, Lou. Estahlishin8 Dress Hmory (ManchestcT, 2004).
Wilson, Elizaheth. AdorneJ in Dreams: FashlOn In Jfodemit'y (London, 198 S).
Notes I 2 3 4 S
6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Elizabeth Wilson, AJomeJ In Dreoms: Fashion and MoJcrTllry \ London, 198 S), p. 3.
Elizabcth Rouse, UnJerstanJln8 Fushion (London, 1989), p. 69.
Ulrich Lehman, TI8ersprun,q: Fashl0n In ModerTll~r (Cambridge, MA, 20(0), p_ 9.
\Vilson, AdomeJ 1n Dreams, p. S.
Negle)' Harte, '5tate Control ofDress', in N. Harte and K. Ponting, eds., Uvrh iJnJ Clothin8
m "-tedieva! Eurape (London, 1983), pp. 139---47; Christopher Breward, ne Culwre ~r Fashwn (Manches ter, 1995 J, pp. S4-S. Archcr, 'The i\.rraignmf'nt of 1 c\·.. d, Idle, Froward ami Unconstant Womcn,' cited in Christopher Brewarrl, !he Culture 0IFalhion, pp. 91-2. Thorstcin Veblen, The Theo~y ~r the f.ei)·ure Class: An Economl\: SwJy (?{lnsWutions (Ncw York, 1899) Editorial in The Foce, August 1997, p. 18. See Joannc Entwhistle, The f(l.Ihioned Fh,Jy: FashlOn, Dress anJ Modcrn 5o<"iul Theory (Camhridge, 2000); and Lou Taylor, The StuJ.-r cJDre5s Historj" (Manchcstcr, 2003). Fred Davis, Fashwn. (l/lrure unJ lJcntltj" (Chicago, 1992), p. 16. Entv"'histle, The FashwneJ B(l~¡:, pp. 115-16. Georg Simmel, 'Fashion', in D. Levinc, cd., On lnJH"lJualir)' onJ SNlal Forms (London, 1971 ). Lf'hman, TJ8e"prun,q, pp. 6-8. :i\orhert F.lia~, The' Cmhsm8 hocess (:'Je\o,-- YOI'k, 1978); Pícrrc Bourdieu, Dl.ltinctlOn A Sodal Cmutue (:1" the luJgement c!f Toste (Camhridge, MA, 1984). Elizaheth \Vil~on, 'Fashion and the l'ostmodern Rody' , in Ju[iet Ash and Elizabcth \-"'¡[son, ed~, Ch¡c rhrills (London, 1992), p. 6. Ent\-\histlc, The FashlOnrJ 800/, p. 164. See Janc Gaines, 'lntroduction: Eahricating the rema le Bnd)", in J. Gaines and C. Herzog, cd~, FJbT/ca(lOns: Costume anJ fhe Fenwle 80'!)' (Londnn, 1990), pp. 5-7. Jennifa Craik, The Faee oJ"Fashwn (London, 1993), p. 176. John Cad Flugt'1, The P.~vcholo8Y qfClorh,'s (Londnn [1931J, 1966), pp. 110 11.
84
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
20 Christopher Breward, rhe Hlddcn Consuma: MascuJimtJes, Fashion and CIt.? Life 1860-/914 (Manchester, 1999). 21 Ent\\'histle, rhe Fashioncd BoJ.-r, p. l. 22 Roland Barthes, rhe Fashion Sy,um (london, 1985). See too Paul Jobling, FashlOTl Sprrads: WorJ ,md ¡mua!? in Fashion PhDsumprion and ¡he WorJd 4Goods (London, 1993). 25 Maxine Berg, The ABe 01 MamifOL'rures 1700~ 1820: Indust'f, Innovation and ~olk Jn Bn/mn (London, 1994). 26 BC'ierly Lemire, 'Developing Consumerisffi and thc Ready-made Clothing Trade in Britain, 1750--1800' , in Textile HJstor)', Vol. 15, No. I (t 984), pp. 21--44; John Brev,'C'r and Ro)' Por ter, Consumpuon and the World ?! Goods (Lomlon, 1993); 8re\..-ard, Thc Cultur~ ~j'FashlOn, p. 110. 17 Lemire, 'Developing Consumerism and thc Rcad)'-made Clothing Trade'; Christopher Breward, 'Manlincss, Modernit)' and the Shaping of Male Clothing,' in Joannc Entwhistle and Elizabeth Wilson, eds, Bod)' Dressina (Oxford, 2001), pp. 165-81. 28 EIlen Lcopold, 'The Manufacture of the Fashion Sptem', in Julict Ash amI Elizabcth Wilson, eds, ChIC Thnlls, pp. 110-15. 29 Philippe PeHot, Fashionina the BoulaeolSlc: A Hist0I.-r '?! Clochina m che NJneteenth Century (Princeton, Nj, 1994), pp. 58 79; Erika Rappaport, ShoppJnBIor PlMsurc: Homen in ¡he .tfakJnB ?! rondon's West End (Princeton, N J, 2000). 30 Christopher Breward, FashlOn (Oxford, 2003), pp. 115-27. 11 Cdia Lurie, Consuma Culrulc (Cambridge, 1996), p. 197.
32 Dick Hebdige, Suhculture: the Meanina oJ .'(yle (London, 1979).
33 Angcla McRobhie, POS(mOdcrlll5m and PopuIJr Culture (London, 1994), p. 214.
34 Frank Mort, Cl1!ttuCi?! Con;l1mption: MJsculinitJes and Soc101 Space Jn Late Twentieth-Century
Britain (London, 1996), pp. 27-8. 35 As Lurie ~tates, 'the stylization of eonsumption is in large pan the outcome of cTeatiw prac tices by )'oung pcopk'. Luri(', Consuma CU}I_urc (Cambridge, 1996), p. 197, 36 Charlotte Cotton, lmpeJ:/;'a Beaucr che .lfJkJna ?! Contempolary FashlOn PhotoBraph~ (London, 2000), p. 6. 37 Susan Sontag, 'The Avedon Eye', in British ~óaue (December, 1978), pp. 104--7.
Photographic and cinem
pace. Digital forms of ir in thc \Vestern cultural: such as Í1'ünsxtc (2000) al older forms of film stod
cost of 'home entertainn
and photographic techne ablc priees. This ubiquity
a Jarge perccntage of the ' duction - prohlematises
photography. For
ir takiJ
many, idcntifying the ma
ingly diflicult. This eh,1p bcen, and continuc to be
cinema, in thc process hig daims regarding either ~ dcvelopment, the first h cinema,
6. Photography and Film Glyn Davis
Introduction Photographic and cinematic technologícal advances continuc to occur at a rapid pace. Digital forms of imag(~ capture, for instancc, have p]anted a firm foothold in the Westcrn cultural sphere and dscwhere, with films shot on digital video
such as ivansxtc (2000) and This is ¡VOC a Love Son8 (2002) - screening in cinemas, older forms of film stock sueh as 16 mm hcading towards obsolescencc, and the cost or 'horne entertainment' digital cameras constantly dropping. Indeed, fi]mic and photographie tcchnology is now widdy available, accessible at fairly afford able priccs. This ubiquity which cngenders a 'point and click' culture in which a large pereentage of the workl's population has aceess to the means of imagc pro duction
prohlcmatises an)' attempts to idcntity 'artistic' examplcs of film and
photography. For if taking photographs and making movies are now open to many, identifying the markers of photographic or filmic 'art' beconws increas ingly difficult. This chapter introouces a range of specific guestions that have been, and continue to be, debated about the 'artistic' nature of photography and cinema, in the process highlighting the diUiculties of attempting to make concrete claims regarding cither medium. Taking them in thc chronological order of thcir de,,'elopmcnt, the h.rst half of the ehapter examines photography, the second cmema.
86
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Photography: The Artist's Tool? Many tine artists sinc~ the dcvelopment of photography in the first half of the nine tecnth ceotur)' have uscd photographs as records to assist thcm, aids to the process of working in stone, on a canvas) and so oo. To take just ane example, Eugene Delacroix used photographs of anude remale modcl as a visual tool whcn painting
rus 1857 Odah,qué (Figure 6.1). Similar records al' working practice exist for Paul Gauguin, Edgar Degas, Paul and man)' others. For sorne critics, writing in rhe mid-1800.~, this was a fair use al' the camera: photography ('QuId not be seco as ao emergent art form, hut rncrcly a rncchanical rccording dcvice. Sir William Ne\\'ton, for instance, in the Na~h
inaugural issue of the journal ef tne Pnorograpnic 5ocJefj' "!f London, published in 1853, argued that the limitccl types of images that couid (at that time) be produced hy photographers militated against the mcclium's artistic status. Incleed. he suggóted that onl)' images that were purposefully out of focus, or that had been tinkered with in the darkroom, might stake some daim to Jn 'artistic impulse'. Otherwise 1
photographs were hest conccptuaHzed as an artist's tools: 1do not consider it neccssary that the whole afthe subject should be what is caBed in}XU5; on the contrary, 1have found in many instances that the object is hetter ohtainecl by the ,vhole .'luhject heing a Httle out l1joCU5, thereby giving a greater breadth of efIeet, and conscquently more 5lJgBesthe ofthe charactcr of nature. I wi.'lh, however, to he understood as applying these observations to artists only, such productions heing considered as private studies to assist him in his compositions ... 1 Despite sueh scepticism, photography was admittecl into gallery spaccs fairly sWiftly: photographs appearecl in the 1859 Paris Salan, for instance. However, man} of the photographie images attempting to attain artistie credibility for the medium \Vere 'High Art' photographs - a specific form of photograph that had scorn heaped upon it by cantcmporary cnmmentators such as Charles Baudelaire. As Mar)' ~rarner Maricn ,,,Tites: High Art photographs hlcncled theatre, printmaking, and palnting with photography. Actors or other pla)'('rs were posed singly or in a lableau vivanl. Interestingly, specific paintings werc only occasionally replicated in High Art photography. For the most part, these images rendcred original conceptions, illustrating religious ur moral precepts orten in the manner 01' rnaudHn genre painting ana popular Victori;m prints. By partaking in the established didac tic runction of the fme arts, High Art photographers attempted to skirt objec tions lo the mcdium's inartistic vcri.similitude-. 2
Figure 6.1 - Eugcne Delo
Although 'High Art' I of fme art, they tended Their pale lIllitation 01 photography as
él
roed:
PHOTOGRAPHY Mm FILM
Figur 6.1
87
[ug' tl¡> Delacroix, Odalisque (1!l57). Private colJection.
Althou h 'I-ligh Art' photo al hs lricd to display som of the key ch raet'ri tic, of fine art, they tended to resemble littlt' more than painters' photographic studics. Th<'ir pak imitatíon of arti:try faiJl'd t capit,lJize 011 lhE' spt'cific eh ra teristi . of photography as a mcdium.
88
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Photography and Painting Throughout photography's history, tbe artistic status of individual images has often been judged according to criteria drawn from tbe critical discourses used to eval uate painting. Terms such as 'tone', 'composition', 'contrast', 'framing' and 'texture' recur in comments on the work of specific photographers. In one sense tbis is understandable: due to its extensive history, painting has long remained tbe yardstick by which al! still, framed images tend to be measured, and many of the critical terms used can be applied to botb media. Relating photographs to tbe realm and lineage of fine art may also result in the attribution of 'artistry' to the work of particular photographers - thus according (to some degree) a 'respectable' status to the medium. The work of some photographers can clearly be compared witb, or related to, specific fields of fine art practice: these images may thus be more open to interpel lation as 'art'. For instance, the photographs of Bill Brandt include a large number of studies of nudes shot in a surrealist fashion. Resembling the distortions of fair ground mirrors, tbese pictures position women's bodies - and tbe camera - in such a way that specific facets of the body seem to swell in size: a hand and forearm 100m across a table in front of a passive sitter; the curve of a buttock monopolises the framed space. In a related manner, the decision of respected artists to use photog raphy as a facet of tbeir working process may also help in raising photography to the critical status of fine arto David Hockney's photomontages, for example, build complete collaged images from photographic fragments. The photographs provide the completed pieces of work witb a glossy texture - a shine arguably appropriate for the pictures of cinematic American landscapes and city spaces that Hockney has produced utilising this method. Such uses of photography, however - in relation to established art movements or as a tool available for use by knovvn artists - fail to acknowledge the character istics tbat mark photography as a distinct medium. Exploitation of chese can result in striking imagery no other medium is capable of producing, requiring evaluation as photographs. Moreover, if the critical terminology and discourses available for such evaluation remain somewhat limited, still at an immature stage in their evo lution, tbis is due to the persistence of photography's historical positioning as fine art's lesser relative. One of photography's key characteristics is its ability to capture instantaneous, fleeting moment; exposure times have been calibrated in fractions of a second since the 1880s. Not only can photography reveal details imperceptible to the human eye - the movement of a bullet as it passes through an apple in Harold Edgerton's famous image (Figure 6.2), 01' the splash of fluid as a droplet hits a placid surface it may also capture symbolic, significant events in a manner beyond painting, for instance, due to its necessarily lengthy production time.
Figure 6.2 - Harold Edgertt Kayafas and Palm Press.
Photographs ofthe Hi ument the spectacular fir seemingly captured the J war in 1936 3 Indeed, photography' 1859, among the mediuI
It is an attribute, to parallel; to whose course, not attemp spiritual quality of quite independcnt ( to our readiest SYIT tion, tbe most mim special attention, h
crtainly, tbe ahility I physiognomy and appeaI
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
89
Figure 6.2 - Harold Edgerton, Shooting che Apple (1964). Photogl-aph courtesy of Gus Kayafas and Palm Press.
Photographs of the Hindenburg disaster at Lakehurst in 1937, for example, doc ument the spectacular fire and fury of the airship's destruction, while Robert Capa seemingly captured the moment of death of a soldier fighting in the Spanish civil war in 1936. 3 Indeed, photography's documentary capacities are, as Francis Frith noted in 1859, among the medium's 'chief peculiarities': It is an attribute, to which, we believe, there is, in the whole rangF of Art, no parallel; to whose uses and delights we can assign no limits, ancl shall, of course, not attempt to enumerate them .... We protest there is, in this new spiritual quality of Art, a charm of wonderful freshness and power, which is quite independent of general or artistic effect, and which appeals instinctively to our readiest sympathies. Every stone, every little perfeetion, or dilapida tion, the most minute detail, which, in an ordinary drawing, would merit no special attention, becomes, on a photograph, worthy of careful study."" Certainly, the ability of photography to capture swiftly a record of a person's physiognomy and appearance, or to document a specific landscape, was quickly
90
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
recognised as one of the medium 's strengths. It has often been argued that artists, accustomed to producing paintings of landscapes and portraits of sitters, among other subjects, were liberated from their role as recorders of visual reality. The invention of photography allowed painters to diversify and experimento In recent years, the idea of the photograph as impartial document - indeed, documentary's 'rhetoric of immediacy and truth' - has been subjected to sus tained interrogation by critics. As John Tagg has argued, for example, photo graphs are deeply enmeshed vvithin the society that produced them; even apparently 'objective' images, such as police identity photographs or medical records, are informed by the s),stems of power and representation that produce them. s Likewise, historical photographs now look unavoidably 'dated' and 'aged', due to a combination of factors including camera technology, film stock and the aesthetic and inteJlectual preferences of the time in which they were taken. Photography's position as marker of authenticity, as evidence, is thus often approached sceptically. Readers question the truth-value of photographs that appear in newspapers and magazines, but paradoxically this has not undermined the use of photography as a medium of reportage, creating or capturing images of people and places. It is perhaps no surprise that among the most renowned contemporary photog raphers there is a large number of individuals who work predominantly in the field of portraiture: David LaChapelle, Annie Leibowitz, Mario Testino, Bruce Weber. Each has a recognisable style: LaChapelle, for instance, stages gaudily coloured sce narios inflected with a pop sensibility, often placing his models in provocative poses. And yet the status of these photographers as artists is open to dispute: their pictures circulate widely in the press and in magazines. Leibowitz regulady shoots for VanitJ Fair, Testino for V08ue, Weber for lnterview, and this mass availability inter feres with the purported non-reproducibility and the often desired uniqueness of arto Even blowing up sorne of these photographs to gigantic sizes, as occurred with sorne of Mario Testino's images in an exhibition held at the National Portrait Gallery in London and the National Gallery of Modern Art in Edinburgh in 2003 - as though it is an artwork's sheer size that commands cultural respect - cannot entirely transmute them into arto
The Photographer as Artist Images produced by portrait photographers such as Testino are often commis sioned _.- and thus, potentially, 'tainted' by commercialism. Indeed, Testino's pic tu res of wealthy, beautiful people dressed in expensive clothing can seem to flaunt overtlya celebration of materialism. In contrast, the artist-photographer, it is often assumed, is driven by different imperatives: the desire to make a statement, raise awareness, promulgate a specific message, to enlighten and enhance the ¡ives of
Figure 6.3 - Paul Strand, Wa
Strancl Founclation. © Aperl
those who come into ca makes a photographer an listic model of the artist in a discussion of the iroace ing to this paradigm af ar
a revelatory proccss subject out of a hi~ photographer does 1 tively, no more than be discovered. Thc F a romantic traditian forms a dullliteral rl
Thus, Paul Strand's 1915 aesthetically pleasing ano of the frame, low sunli( ~ smears; aboye the humar status and power of capit
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
91
Figure 6.3 - Paul Strand, Wall Street (1915). Philadelphia Museum of Art: Gi[t of the Paul Strand Foundatioo. © Aperture Fouodation 1nc., Paul Strand Archive.
those who come into contact with the developed prints. In other words, what makes a photographer an artist is, perhaps, the intention of the snapper. This idea listic model of the artist-photographer is neatly encapsulated by Graham Clarke, in a discussion of the images of Paul Strand. Clarke describes photography, accord ing to this paradigm of artistry, as a revelatory process in which the photographer, through the camera, lifts the subject out of a historical context into its potential ideal condition. The photographer does not record, he creates, and the material world is, effec tively, no more than the outward manifestation of a spiritual other waiting to be discovered. The photographer is a seer, vvith all that implies in relation to a romantic tradition based on the artist as inspired ph.ilosopher who trans forms a dullliteral reality into something new and ideal 6 Thus, Paul Strand's 1915 image of Wall Street in New York (Figure 6.3) is both aesthetically pleasing and politically charged. Workers scuttle across the bottom of the frame, low sunlight stretching their shadows into dramatic diagonal smears; aboye the human figures towers an imposing bank, an edifice to the status ancl power of capitalismo The image is harmonious and neatly balanced,
92
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
verging towards the abstract in its composition. And yet it also has a comment to make regarding the position of the human subject in relation to the financial imperatives driving the modern world: Wall Street, a global symbol of monetary might, dwarfs the nameless and faceless individuals exiled to the lower limits of the image. The segregation of 'art photographers' from 'commercial photographers' is, of course, a false one: to so me extent, the pictures produced by both groups are intended to make money. And yet, throughout photography's history, a drive to divide up photographers into specific sub-groups has often surfaced, each popula tion identified by markedly different aims and desires. For example, as Nicholas Mirzoeff identifies, Ernest Lacan, writing in 1852 in the photography journal La Lumiece,
sub-divided photographers into four c1asses, corresponding to social c1ass: the basic photographer (working c1ass or artisan); the artist-photographer (bourgeois); the amateur, in the sense of connoisseur, hence aristocrat; and the distinguished photographer-savant, who c1aimed the c1assless status of the artist. Thus those who saw themselves as the photographic elite argued that 'legitimate photography' was that which could be identified as belonging to a specific place, time and c1ass 7 Although the boundaries are increasingly blurred, this attempt at division con tinues today: art photographers tend to be segregated from commercial photogra phers, images by the latter rarely appearing in galleries or photography journals. In addition, there is a separate realm of 'amateur photographers' - consumers of monthly publications that explore the techniques of taking photos, a group that could be seen as photography's equivalent of the 'Sunday painters' . And then there are the rest of us - camera owners, with sorne degree of technical proficiency, whose image production and circulation occur solely at the local leve!. That this hierarchy exists is evidence of the critical need to categorise the users of a specific creative tool into recognisable groups; what is difficult to discern is exactly who works to maintain this specific hierarchy. Certainly, art dealers, gallery curators and so on playa significant role in attrib uting artistic status to the work of specific photographers. Richard Billingham 's pictures of his parents, taken in their cramped, filthy council f1at - overweight mother dressed in a thin nightdress, engrossed in a jigsaw; thin father, face creased with lines (Figure 6.4) - sit on the cusp between 'family snaps' and socially moti vated documentary images of working-c1ass life in Britain. And yet these images appeared in the Sensation exhibition of young British Artists (or 'yBAs') heId at the Royal Academy in London in 1997, which led to Billingham's work being discussed in relation to that of Damien Hirst, Tracey
Figure 6.4 - Richard Billingl courtesy of Anthony Reynol
Emin, Sarah Lucas and 01 tures are simply 'snaps ( series of bucolic landscaF to be taken seriously as a
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
Figure 6.4 - Richard Billingham, Unlitled (1995). courtesy of Anthony Reynolds GaJlery, London.
93
© Richard Billingham. Photograph
Emin, Sarah Lucas and others. Billingham, self-effacingly, has claimed that the pic tures are simply 'snaps of rus folks'; he followed these images, however, with a series of bucolic landscape photographs, suggesting his desire fOI- rus photography to be taken seriously as arto
94
EXPlORING VISUAL CULTURE
Film as Art: Realism versus Fantasy Throughout thc briefhistory al' cinema - it5 birth is usually dated to 1896 with the screening uf images captured by the Lumiere brothers - argurncnts regarding the medium '5 arti5tic status have regularly rcsurfaced. One of the centnl axes around which such discussions have revolved correeTOS cinema's idculJorm; as with sirnl1ar debates ayer painting, a variet}' al' cornmentators have claimcd cinema's dehning characteristics proscribe both what film iSJOl and theJorm it should take. On the
whole, these arguments tend to propase eírher that cinema should be a conduit for realistic types of representation, al that it shoukl aim to produce [arrtas)' narratives. As cinema is rootcd in pbotograprue tcchnology, projecting a succession of still frames at such a rapid rate that the human eyc percei\'C~ the illusüm 01' motion - a trick of pcrception known as 'the persistence of vision' - the potency of film argu ably líes in its ability to capture and re-present what is placed in front of the record ing camera. That is, as with photography, cinema's aptitude for documcnting the real may be its ke)' characteristic the feature from "... hich it derives its forcc. Certainly, there are (possibly apocryphal) reports 01' early cinema audiences watch ing Lumiere brothers footage of a trajn arriving at a station and running from the auditorium in fear that the vehicle was about to career into them. Whether or not these stories are true, they attest to the po\\'er that has often been attributed to cinema's documentar} capacities. An alternative perspective on this topic argues that film, due to its temporal unfurling, its intimate connection to the passagc of time, is an inherently narrative medium. Cinema should be used to tell stories: in order to make best use of the medium's capacities, it should be utilised for the transmission of fantastical (and othcr) tales. In this regard, it is worth noting that probahly the most important con temporary of the Lumiere brothers was Georges MéW~s, also a Frenchman, whosc short films used trick effects (time-lapse, multiple-exposure and so on) and elab orate staging and set design ro relate imaginati ve yarns. The lasting impact of Mélícs' lOJQBC to the J.loon (1902) is marked; the film provided cinema history with one of its most enduring and iconic images - a grinning, winking moon (Figure 6.5). These two opposing modes of concl'ptualising the purpose of cinem.1, realism versus fantas)" - both in place, notably, at the inauguration of the medium - have been adopted and developed by a rangc of writers and filmmakers ovcr the rast ccntur)'- Perhaps most famousl)', André Ba7in (1918-58) - the author of numer ous essays on cinema, and thc co-founder 01' the French film journal Cahlcrs du Cinéma - claimcd that cincma's force was allied to its documentar)' potential. In his writings, Bazin argucd in favour of film directors ,",v hose shooting methods pro duced footage that approached or approximated reality, and whosc style rescm hlcd, or made use of, tbe specificities ofhuman vbion. Thus, Bazin praiscd ltalian neo-realist directors such as Roberto Rossellini for hlming on the postwar, ruhhle
figufr 6.5 - StiJ] {mm Georg
strewn strcets of Rome al butions to Citizcn Kane (15 ing Welles' film, whieh me
the 16 mm industry stand.. with the latter, he claimed in a simulation of 'real' vü
to lateh onto. 8 Although h have he en a fan al' several Na,h..,lle (1975), with thei vcntional narrative form, realist model of cinema. F prcsent, it js notable that pO\\.'ers of realism now ~ Rossellini's films, for insté that undercut the verisimi Bazin contrasted his ow and opinions of the Russ (1925), Battle>h¡p Potemki, argued in favour of manip' potential of cinema as a n
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
95
Figure 6.5 - StilJ from Georgcs Mé-Ii¡'s' ~~ya8e ca the Moon (1902). ~:J BFI stills.
strcwn streets 01' Rome and other citiC's. He al so eulogised Gregg Toland's contri
hutions to Citizen Kane (1941) - Toland developed a 17 mm camera leos for shoot ing Welles' film, which more closel)' approximated the curve of the human eye than the 16 mm industry standard. Bazin exal ted hoth the lcngthy takc and the long shot; \\'ith the tatter, he dairncd, the .spectator·5 eye must rove around the cinema screcn, in a simulation
01' 'real' Vi5100, searching for thc most relevant OT important facets to latch onto.1' Although he died before the)' \\rere made, Bazin would thus perhaps
have been a fao nf several al' Robert Altman's films, such as M*A*S*H (1970) and i\,'ashl'ilJe (1975), with their long takes, overlapping dialogue and rejection of (.'on ventional narrative formo And )'ct there are problems \\'ith Bazin's support of the realist model of cinema. Revisiting Bazin's argurnents from the perspective of the present, it is notahle that man)' of the films he praised for harne:'ising cinerna's powers of realism now seem hopelessl)' staged and rnclodramatic
Roberto
Rossellini's films, for instance, often resorted to using a syrupy orchestral scorc that undercut the verisimilitude of sorne of thcir irnagcs. Bazin contrastcd hi~ o,"\-'n beBef in the pmver of the realistic image with thc films and opinions ol' the Russian forrnalist Sergei Eisenstein. The director 01' Strike
(1925), Battleship Poremkin (1925) and October (1927), among others, Eisenstein argued in favour
01' manipulating film stock through editing; for him, the creative
potcntial of cinema as a medium could be properly expressed on]y through the
96
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
directorial assemblage of shot footage. Far Eisenstein, cinematic montage was a
extent, whv , Ridley, Scot
predominant concern: he helieved that the disjunctive juxtaposition of specific
Jlonk (2003) is unherald
shots causeo spectators to forge a meaning from the fragments - a meaning not
The terro 'auteur' or nalists for Cahiers du CiI
Y
¡nherent in the images themselves. Thus, in Ortober, a senior official's vanity is exposed by intercutting images al' the man with shots ol' a pcacock. Similarly, in a sequence from Battleship Potemkin, severa} shots al' stOIlC Iians (Iying clown, starting
Fran)=ois Truffaut and El rigbt. Tbe 'politique de,
to rise, fully alert) follow on from the infamous Odessa Steps hattle sequcnce: the
two LTucial arguments. j
intimatían deduced by the spectator is that the lians symbolise the púBtical avt'ak
nant in contrast ro that o
cning afthe Russian peasantry. Far 8azin, such montage editing was manipulative,
ary texts: American Cme"
almost heretical, interfering \vith film's abiHty to capture, uncxpurgated, the wonder 01' God's \.. ·orld (Bazin was a very religious man); for Eisenstein, it consti
Sceond, the postwar gh sereened en mane in Fran,
tutecl and encapsulatcd the true pO\\,'er of cinema.
Ford westerns in one sit
Debates regarding dnema's relationship to reality and fantasy - and pertaining to cinema's 'true form', to what could be called 'pure cinema'
ha\"e not disap
critics noticed that sorne own identity into the fiIn
pean:d. Indeed, to take just one examplc, they can be seen to underlie the criti
01' the director was evidl
cisms of Hollywood film raised by the Dogme film movement. Dogmc - initiated
surface style. These direc
by the Danish filmmakers Thomas Vinterherg and Lars von Tricr in 1995 - out
'artisanal' directors, terIr
lined a ten-point programme for making movies l a manifcsto that attempted to strip away the artifice ofHollywood. Only naturallight and sound weTe to be used;
Thesc tcrms of debate a numher ol' critics in (
cameras had to be hand-hcld; optical tricker), \Vas not allowcd; only diegetic sound
instance, writing in the
and music could be cmployecl. Films produced accorJing to this agenda - an agenda
prioritising thc input of t1l
include Vintcrherg's Festen (1998), Von Trier's
- from set designers to ca
that continues to attract devotees
Ir
The ldiolS (1998) and Harmony Korine's Julien DonkeJ-BoJ (1999). As Vinterbcrg
tributed to a finished Hol
has stated, highlighting Dogme 's preference for a realist model 01' cinema:
scriptwriters are largely w
by cinema 's visual irnpal We "\'dnted to seek a moment of truth, not pnwoking it too much, not iovolv
attempted in the journal F
ing our own tastes; just to see what happens between actors when we put
tigation to the practice of f
them in this situation. Still it is fiction, we'ye got the script, we've got the
structed lists of 'the best
casting we say 'action' we say do this amI that, but we try and see ourselves
reveal the subjective natUTf
as regarding, and not directing too much, if you understand. So it is like a . agamst . . th·mg. lO reactlOn t b e auteur
rist Timothy Corrigan has"
,
'"
Auteurism
i
for Hollywood, a valuable (
this hclps to explain why Kili BilI, Volumc I (2003),
e !
why Francis Ford Coppola' In the search for film art, the attribution of authorial intention and crcativity to
horror film }eepers Creepers (
specific contrihutors to the fihnmaking proccss is often attempted, v,rith certain
On tbe whole, debates a~
individuals isolated as making more significant contributions than others. Crucially,
to the overwhelrningly indl
ir is now largcly taken for granted in both popular and critical discoursc tbat the
ponderance of genre movie,
person rcsponsible for a film's contents and acsthetics is Íts director. Further, from
return, stars paid exorbitan
thc large numbcr of directors presentIy working, only a small percentage 01' those
pation with 'opening week(
are deemed to be 'artists', or 'auteurs', worth)' of comment; this is, to .sorne
their mark' can scem min
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
97
extent, why Ridley Scott's name is well known, but thc director of, say, Bul1etpf(lf}(
Monk (2003) is unheraldcd." The term 'auteur' originated in Franee in the 1950s in the writings ofthe jour nalists for Cahlers du Cinéma. Many of these authors - such as Jean-Lue Godard, Fran~ois Truffaut and Eric Rohmcr - cventually became filrnmakers in their O\... n right. The 'politique des auteurs' developed by the journal's crities was rooted in two crucial arguments. First, the)' claimed that French cinema had becornc stag nant in contrast to that of America, dependent on dull, stodgy adaptations ofliter ary texts: American cinema, it was argued, was quaHtatively better, more cinemaric.
Second, the postwar glut of American fiJms - hcld back during the war, then screened en massc in Francc in a tidal \\"ave - enabled viewers to watch several John Ford westerns in one sittjng, or a number of Howard Hawks films. The Cahiers critics noticed that sorne dircctors working in Hollp....ood were ahle to stamp their own identity jnto the films they worked on: over several different films, the trace of the director was evidcntly present, most obviously identifiablc in relation to surface s~vle. These directors \\'ere lahelled 'auteurs' and contrasted with more 'artisanal' directors, tcrmed 'metteurs-en-set:ne'. These terms ol' debate were subsequently picked up, argued oyer and rcfined by a number of critics in other countries. The British author lan Cameron, for instance, writing in the magazine Movie, critidsed the 'politique des auteurs' for prioritising the input of the director over that of the hundreds ol' other individuals from set designers to costumiers. einematographers to hairdressers - who con tributed to a finished Hollywood film. l ! This remains a significant coneern: film scriptwriters are largcly unkno\..'n, for example, a fact that is only partIy explained hy cinema's visual impact. In contrast, the American critic Andrew Sarris attempted in the journal Film Culture to apply pseudo-scientific methods ol' inves tigation to the practice of film production; he drew up tables and graphs, amI con structed Iists of 'the best directors' - in the process, inadvertentIy managing to rC\'cal the subjective nature of ranking 'film artists' .13 More recentIy, the film theo rist Timothy Corrigan has argued that the 'auteur' lS simply a use fuI marketing tool fOT Hollywood, a valuablc device for seducing audiences into cinemas. J4 Certainly, this helps to explain why Quentin Tarantino was predominantly used to promotc KJiJ BJiJ: VoJume 1 (2003), rather than the film', ¡ead actress, Urna Thurman; and
,....h y Francis Ford Coppola's name was so prominently featured on posters for the horror film Jeepers Creepers (2001), of which he was the executive producer. On the whole, debates about auteurism have focused on Hollywood cinema. Due to the overwhelmingly industrial nature 01' Hollp....ood film production - the pre ponderance 01' genre movies, sequcls churned out due to their lucrative box office return, stars paid exorbitant fees in proportion to tbór audience draw, a preoccu pation with 'opening weekend' figures ~ the possibility 01' any individual 'making their mark' can seem miraculous. And yet there are directors working within
98
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Hollywüoo wha have distinctive authorial styles - Paul Thomas !\noerson, Michacl Mano, M. Night Shyamalan, John Woo. The latter serves as a llsefu] example: Woo 's
handling of generic action material Hard Targct (1993), Broken Arrow (1996), Face/ OjJ( 1997), fV;ndtalker, (2002) - do es not prevent him from inserting his own prcoccupations and favoured symbolism. In almost c"ery Woo film, for instance,
there can be found: a slow-motion gun battle, choreographed like a hallet; imagcry of noves taking Hight; a hero and villain firing weapons through a wall scparating them froro each other, with the wall placed in the dead centre afthe frame; Christ likc poses adopted by key protagonists. However. these rlirectors are rare cxamples:
on the whale Hollv\\'ood cinema i5 usuallv seen as faceless, repetitivc, mass-pro duced, made 'solel; for thc purpose ol' 'e~tertainment' rather than any higher or alternative aim. Ofcourse, it should also he noted that the stuoios may occasionally
Clearl)', 'art cinema' li,tcd by Pelley high)¡ cinema'. Although lhe for American studios, " with smallcr ere......-s enal imperativc is not as m, scripts) to explore their Art cinema is abo t already established "eld confer art film with a d surrealist cinema - fron of the film, of David L}'I ¡st painting and sculptl
produce 'prestige pieture, sueh as Monste!s Ball (2001) and Tbe Haurs (2002) - that is, the sort of tilms that are awaroed Oscars and used to justify claims for Hollywood as a respectable cultural institution. Howevcr, for substantial traces ol' artistry in cinema, it is perhaps most useful to loo k bcyond the confines 01' the 'dream factory'.
(Robat Wiene. Fritz La and 19 30s is compared \ era. Andy vVarhol's fi]m~
Art Cinema
- are taken seriously du their hand' at making mo
Outsioe Hollywood's powerful 'vertically integrated' system of film production, distribution and exhibition, in which Hollywood product cnds up bcing shown to mass audiences in cavernous multiplexes also owned by the studios, therc is an alternatiyc scheme. Smaller companies (such as Metro Tartan) distribute non Hollywood films ('independent' American cinema, 'foreign languagc' ti des) to 'art house' exhibition venues, attracting less sizeable audiences. On the wholc, these films laek the trappings ol' Hollywood: enormous budgcts, overpaid stars, a reli arree on digital tric'kery, generic storytelling, huge (Te\VS. Thc)' also have ioentifi able formal charactcristics that differ l'rom thosc ol' Holly"mod films. The distinctions bet\,"'cen Hollywood cinema and 'art films' \Vere c1carly artic ulaled in the jaté 1970s and 1980s by David Bordwell and Steve Neale, and the terms of debate thev outlined remain dominant conceptualizations even today. As Julian Petley notes, ~hc term 'art cinema' was useti by Bordv,,'cll and Neale to refcr to films such as those of the French ne\\ \,,"'ave, the Ncw German Cinema, Bergman, Antonioni, Fellini, Kurosawa, Ray (Satyajit not Nicholas) ano the like, hut ir was al50 employeo retrospectively to denote such disparate cinc matic phenomena as Italian nf'o-realism, German silent cinema, the Soviet ciassics, and the prc-war Frcnch cinema, fromfilms d'art through surrealist vvorks such as Gcrmaine Dulac's La Coquille el le clerBYman (1928), Buñud's Un Chien Andalau (1928) and l.'Age d'Or (1930) to lhe aeuvres of Cocteau, Renoir, Carne, Préyert ano others ... 15
Longo's John~r Mnemonj, hoth critical and box offi Perhaps most significa form of 'art cinema' are - that ¡s, from \-,/hat is oJ
appeal only to an elite a stream. Art films might, social, cultural and politi( Dardcnnes brothers' Ros,
characters Jnd geographi, coastal to\\'n Ohan, and
Manern Callar (2002); 0P'
such as the long take, us instancej a preference for or self-reflexive narration
Of course, dividing th
sweeping and reductiye. ~ which man)' countries (i popular, gencric cinema rr ignores the significant arr occurs; the French new w American studio films'lan multiplexes in Britain may
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
99
Clearl)', 'art cinema' is largel)' a directar's cinema. The preponderancf' af names listed by Petle)' highlights a crucial distinction bctween Holly,vaod and 'art cinema' . Although thc occasional auteur mal' ]cave their mark on films produced for American studíos, 'art film' ís more evidently the work of its directors. Working with smaller crews enabks more control over the finished product; the commercial imperative is not as marked, cnabling director s (who mal' also havc written thc scripts) to explore their concerns and preoccupations with less ínterferenn'. Art cinema is also evidentl y a form of filmmaking \vith sorne affiliations to aIread)' established fields 01' artistic practice, such as fine art ficlds, in fact, which confer art film ,"vith a degree ol' culturallegítimacy. Thus, lnstanLes of Dada amI surrealist cinema - from Salvador Dali and Luis Buñuel's work to, perhaps, maoy of the film s 01' David Lynch - are discussed in relation to thc traditions 01' surreal ist painting and sculpture; similarly, thc cinema of the German Expressíonists (Robert Wiene, Fritz Lang, F. W Murnau, anrt others) produced during the 19205 amI 1930s is compared with, and connected to, Expressionist painting ol' the same era. And)' Warho1's film s - roany of them, by his own admission, unv.,atchably duB -- are taken seriously due to his status as an artist. Indced, \-\'hen fine artists 'tr)' their hand' at making movies, expectations are high and often disappointed: Robert Langa', johnny Mnemomc (1995) and Cindy Sherman's OJJice Kíller (1997) werc hoth critical and box ol'fice disasters. Perhaps most significantl)" however, David Bordwell daims that the content ami form of 'art ónema' are distinct from those ol' 'conventional' Hoth'wood cinema - that is, from what is often rel'erred to as the 'c1assical realist text'. lt may thus appeal only to an elite audience looking far an alternative to thc generic main stream. Art films might, then, display the following characteristics: an intcrest in social, cultural and patitical prohlems such as unemployment and poyerty, as in thc Dardennes hrothers' Rosetta (1999); an 'objective', 'truthful' representation of charaeters and gcographicallocations, such as the depiction of life in the Scotti.sh coastal town Oban, ami the unpredictable actions of the heroine, in Ramsay's Monern Callar (2002); open-endcd narratives; the use of ccrtain formal flourishes, such as the long take, used rather extravagantly in Japón (Reygadas, 2002), for instance; a preference for autobiography, as in many ofthe films 01' Nanni Moretti, or sclf-reflexivc narration. 16 Of coun;e, dh.'iding the \','orld of cinema into 'Hollywood' and 'art film' is sweeping and rcductive. Such an attt:'mpt at categorisation neglects the extent to \vhich man)' countries (including France and, most obviously, India) produce popular, generic cinema modclkd on the template of Hollywood examples. lt also ignores the !ligniflcant amount of Hollywood theft of 'art cinema' stylings that occurs; the French ncw waye 'jump cut', for ínstance, is no\v an acceptcd part ol' American !ltmfio films'language. Exhibition Is no longer as clear-cut as it once was: multiplexes in Britain mal' now regularly show foreign language tides, and regional
100
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
film theatrcs, in arder to stay financialIy solvent, may have to screen studio block husters. 'Independent' American cinema, as the film critie Kim Newman has
generated imager)' may characters on the prow
observed, has become almost impossible lo identify.17 And the spread of DVO
tastical creatures - as iJ
technology secms to be inaugurating a new system of film connoi.'i.'icurship - one
2002 and 2003). Such
crucially that erades the noundaries hctwccn 'mainstream' and 'art house' films
guage capahle of assessi
and their audicnccs - in 'which the plethora of extra information packcd onto dises provokes an enhanced interest in moving imagc culture. And yet, of coursc, thc 'mainstream/independent', 'art housc/multiplex', 'mass/elite audience' divisiOTIS continuc to influence general understandings of the field of cinema. Such is the dominance of Hollywood that it is necessary to conccp tualisc a spaee outside, or bel'ond the dutches of, tht, machinations
01'
the studios:
this 'space' is often given the label 'art film', As Perle)' argues:
Clarke, Graham. The Phou1j HolJows, Joanne and Janco' Lemagn), Jean-Claude, ed. Slam, Roben, fIlm TheoT)':,
Howcver difficult it mal' he to define art cinema in positive terms, that is, to sal' what it actually is, it is relativell' easl' to define it negatively as simply being 'not Hollywood' or evcn 'anti-Hollywood' . . . . It may he, then, that art cinema is hC:'3t concE'ptualized not as a certain historical pE'rioo of mainl)" European output ... nor as a directorial canon J nor as a set of distinctil.'c suh jects and stylcs, but, as 10m Rl'all has suggested, as an institution in \vhich certain films are' assigned defined in terms
01'
J
position within the general film culture and are
a particular mode of consumption'. l¡;
\Villiam Nev,'ton. 'UpO! Ch.lrles Harríson, Pau} , l~r Changmg JJeJs (Oxfor 2 ¡\1
663 4.
Conclusion As was noted at the beginning of this chapter, photographie ano filmic production i:'3 beeoming increasingly digital. This hrings notable benetíts to the users of thc technology: digital cameras can store more material, the editing out oflow-quality material can be done inside the device, ano so on. For the artist-photographer, pix Hation reduces the captured image to thousands of tinl' fragmcnt:'3, E'ach capable ol manipulation. That is, the digital photograph can, arguably, be said to resemble a painting: it can be worked on within a computer, using an arral' of SplTific tools, beforc the final image is complete. This removcs photographl' from its hallowed position as a documenta of faets. As a relatively new field of image production, the implications of these developments for photography as an art form remain to be .'leen. For cinema, thc proliferation 01' digital effects also complicates discussions of film artistry. If a film is . ;hot digitalll" with every frame open to digital manipulation, 'real' footage begins to blur with the realm 01' digital animatiou. Thc latter has itself swiftly become the dominant method of industry animatian, replacing the hand drawn \'ariety in films such as Findins Nema (2003). Thc additian of computer
John Tagg, The BUTden cf Graham Clarke, The Phot Nícholas MirzodT, An 1m See Ande" Ha'in, What H q See Sergd Eísenstein, Th 10 Thomas Víntcrberg, quol Cc)'!J¡I.~ed, No, 52 (March 11 for those concerned to k 12 Ian Camewn, 'Fílrns, Dil (London, 19SI), pp. 50-1 1 3 Anrire\..' S.lrris.• Notes on eds" hlm Theorr ond (rirh 14 Timothy Corrigan, A Cinel :'ij,1991) 15 Julian Pt>Uey, 'An Cinet (London, 1999, 2nd editi( 16 David Bordwell, NarratlOn exarnplcs suggested are n( 17 Kirn Newman, 'Independe und Sound Reader (London, 1S Petky. 'Art Cinema', pp. 1 5 6 7 8
PHOTOGRAPHY AND FILM
101
generated imagery ma)' cnhance realism - james Carncron gave 'cold breath' lo his characters on the prow 01' the T¡tanie (1997)
or to envisagc ana bring lo tife fan
tastical creatuTes -- as in Pctcr ]ackson's Lord ~Ithc Ringo\' trilog)' (relcascd in 2001, 2002 and 2003). Such is the pace nf development in this lield, that a critica] lan guagc capable of assessing its form and impact is yet lo be fully developcd.
Further Reading C1arkc, Graham. Th,' Phoruf/Taph (Oxford, 1997).
Hollow.~, Joanne ano Jancovich, Mark. eds. Approochcj lo Popular Film (J\lanchester, 1995).
Lemagny, Jean-Claude, ed. Thc Hl\'tcl~t' ?f PhotoBraph)' (Cambridge, 19R6).
Stam, Robert. Fdm Theory: An InrroduL'tlcln (Oxforo, 2000).
Notes \Villiam Newton, 'Upon Photography in .ln Artistic Vil'\v, and its Relalion lo the Arts', in Charles Harrison, Paul Wood ano Jason Gaiger, cds, Art In Theor)'. 1815-1900:an AncholviL)' qj"Chan8in8'Je¡]j (Oxford, 1998), p. 651. 1 Mar)' Warner Marien, Photo8raph), and m Cntlo: A Cultural H1S¡O~h 1839-1900 (Cambridge, 1997), p. 87. 1 It is worth noting that there are allegations that the image ma)' have been faked. 4 Francis Frith, 'The Art ol' Photography', in Harrison, \Vood and Gaiger, Arl in TheoI)', pp.
663-4. 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 1+ 15 16 17 18
John Tagg, The BurJen ~f RepIesentafIon: rss,:vs on Phot08raphíes and Hlstones (London, 191'8). Graham Clarh, Tile Photo8TOph (Oxford, 1997), p. 170. Nicholas MirzoeJr, /In Inrrodu(/wn ro VISual C[¡}l11re (London ano New York, 1999), p. 72. See Anoré Ba7in, WhallS Cmema,' Volume 1 (Los Angeles, 1967), See SergC'i bsenstein, The Fllm Sen,'e (London, 1943). Thomas Vinterberg, quoted in Wendy lde, 'No Lights, One Ca.TTu:ra, Action', in Da7ed and ConJused, No. 52 (March 1999), p. 67. f-"or those concerneJ to know, the man rrspomible was Paul HUnler. lan Cameran, 'rilms, Directors and Crities', in John Caugbie, ed., Theoncj c:IAuthOI5hlp (London, 1981), pp. 50 8. Andr(''A SalTis, 'Notes on the Auteur Theor)' in 1962' , in Gerald Mast and Marshall Cohen, ('(1:0,., FIlm Theory tlnd Cf1t1ClSm: Jmroducwrx Readings (New York. 197+), pp. 500 -15. Timothy Conigan, A (memo wlthout Walls: Mmló' and Culture _1jier heln
7. Architecture and Visual Culture Richard Williams
The scale, cost and pt tion, and as a result we 1
critic Walter Benjamin a distraction' , unlike othe]
priate surroundings - o architecture, a difficult, s notoriously hard to dem town planning, or any 01' It is a profession, and as ~ non-initiates. It comes w
arcane and exclusive tech
can we relate to a practi<
architecture degree, the F cated by a middle-elass b. sion. In what way can th, the} stand in relation to s
1 address thcse questi< rathcr more what has be< them. As wilJ bccome cle.a
Introduction Architccturc is the most public ol' the arts. Ir is incscapable on a daily hasis for anyone living in an urban socidy. Works of architecture frame our lives; we inhabit
sional realm as it is a mater as diseourse that one can el
ing three relatcd, but disti art; architecture as a symb
them; they define our movement through cities; the)' moralisc and discipline, or attcmpt too They are arre of the principal m(:am; by- which the public realm is mate rially represented amI for that reasan, the)' are al' huge social importance.
ThroughoLIt the industrialised world, this rclationship has been intensified in recent years. An irnmense amount al' spectacular ne\\-' architecture has heen built in the
What i5 architecture? Thü I'orward answer. For the ar
rast two decades, a product of the desire 00 thc part of social and polirical author it)' to update the public rcalm in the context 01' unprecedented prospcrity. Important recent cxamples inelude the Guggenheim Museum in Bilhao, the new parliamcnts or assembly buildings in Bcrlin, CardiI'I', Edinburgh, London and
was liUle ambiguity: 'a bi, introduction to An Outline
Strasbourg, the plans hy Daniel Libeskind for the reconstruction 01' LO'l.ver Manhattan aI'ter September 11, and the comp1ction oI' the so-caBed Brunds projcrs in
Lincoln Cathedral [FI that endmes space o building; the term are
Paris. None 01' thcm ha." heen cheap. The public role 01' works 01' architcdure-, not to mention their size and complexity, means that thcy can be I'antasticalIy expen
to aesthetic appeal . painter's modes 01' vi
sive, and more than an)' other practice oI' visual culture they require puhlic patron age. At the time 01' writing, the ne,v Scottish Parliament in Edinhurgh, by Enric Miralles, was estimated lo have cost .t400 miHion. The MiIlennium Dome in
c1aím supcriority over
London, by Richard Rogers, cost approximately L750 million. Thcse figures eclipse those in an)" other field.
This is architccture as arl threc dimensions, but unlik
architecture is the mo
ARCHITECTURE AND VISUAL CULTURE
103
The scale, cost and public presence of contemporary architecture demand atten lion, and as a result we occasionaHy raise our eyes to 100k at it in detail. But as the critic Walter Benjamin assertcd, it is more Iikcly that we apprehend it in a 'state of distraction' , unlike other practices, which we consume with due attention in appro priate surroundings - or try too I This is just one of the problems in considering architecture, a difficult, sometimes daunting area of visual culture. lt ¡s, for example, notoriously hard to define: How does it relate to building, or to urbanism, or to to\'·,.'O planning, or any of thc other mysterious professions of the built environment f lt is a profession, and as such ir is inherently exclusive, resisting interrogation from non-initiates. It comes \vith special institutions and social rituals, not to mention an arcane and exclusive tcchnicallanguage, acquired during a seven-year training. How can we relate to a practice likc this? We rna)' lack the technical skiHs taught on an architecture degree, thc professional cxperience and, perhaps, thc confidence incul cated by a middle-dass background, the social class that stil1 dominates the profes sion. In what way can they participate in debates about architecture? How might thc)' stand in relation to such a complex, difficult and seemingly exclusive field? 1 address these questions through a consideratíon of buildings, but 1 examine rathcr more what has been said about them; in other words, the dlscourse around them. As win hecome clear, architecturc is as much a philosophical, social or profes sional realm as it is a material one, and it is through the consideration 01' architecture as discourse that one can cngage with it as visual culture. 1suggest how by exemplify ing three related, but distinct, approaches to architecture: architecture as a form 01' art; architecturc as a symbolic reaJm; and architecture as spatial experience.
Defining Architecture:Architecture as Art What is architecture? This used to he a straightfonvard qucstion, with a straight forward answer. For thc art historian and critic Nikolaus Pevsner (1902-83), thcre was llule ambiguity: 'a bicycle shed is a building' (Figure 7.1), he wrote in the introduction to An Outline ?IEuropean Architccwre: Lincoln Cathedral [Figure 7.2] is a piecc of architecture. Nearly cvcrything that endoses space on a scale sufficient for a human being to move in js a building; the term architl'cture applies only to buildings designed with a view to aesthetic appeal ... the good architect rcquires the sculptor's and thc painter's modes of vision in addition to his own spatial imagination. Thus architccture is the most comprehcnsive 01' aH the visual arts and has a right to c1aim superiorit)' over the othcrs. 2 This ls architecturc as arto The architect is a special kind of artist who \vorks in thn'e dimensions, but unlikc the sculptor, he - and tbis is still an overwhelmingly
104
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Figun:' 7. 1- BiL)'clc ~hed, Westcrn General Hospital, cdinburgh. Authm\ photograph (2003)
masculine profession - works to enclose spacc as ,..di as simply making objects in space.lt ¡neludes c!emcnts ofthe other arts, but it i5 superior to them becausc it i5 a synthesis of them aH. As ao art, architecture demands a certain kind of apprehen
Figure 7.2 - Lincoln Cathedr Unh-crsit)' (2003).
sion [rom the beholder, which parallds thar of the other visual arts. Thinking of painting, one may be especialIy concerned with the treatment al' the twü
stylistie pattern. Like Rlli
dimensional aspects ofbuildings. aboye aH the stylistie treatment ofthe fayade, or
aspects of architecture, its
exterior. This i5 ao approach with a long histor),. John Ruskin, for examplc, saw in
Architccture as art is in
the architecture ofVenice a moral purposc that provided a model for his compatri
Most critics continue to ......
ots. 3 His coneern was exclusivel)' with the fayades of the buildings. In their Gothic
Glance)' in the Guardian
decoration he found forms he regarded as morally superior to the neoclassical alter
the New York Times appear o
native. Precisely \",/h)' depended on rcasoning that now seems arcan e . But what ¡s
to think about buildings as
01
important is that Ruskin 's interest in architecture \Vas a t)'picall)' art historical one:
expressions of a single cre,
it began and ended with st)'le.
or sculptor, or author. We
The work of Heinrich \Vülfllin does something very similar. His formalist anal ysis of art makes architecturc a central component, but his interest stops when arehitecture no longer accedes to the condition of art. 4 He was deepl), interested
own integrit), reaardless 01 b ing. We expect them to be
creator. We expect them to
in the stylistic qualities 01' building fayadcs and in how the)' articulate formal ideas
expect them, if they are m
in the same way as relief sculpturcs, or pajntings. Pevsner adopts a similar approach
challenge existing assumpti
in his popular series The BUl]dings ~IEngIQnd.
His emphasis is that of an art histo
that is aehievcd in spite of
rian; he is concerned with the way a building as a set 01' t\Vo-dimensional planes in
words, and we are disappoiI
space, whose stylistic forms articulate an aesthdic purpose related to a broader
The idea 01' architecture a
5
ARCHlTECTURE AND VISUAL CULTURE
105
Figure 7.2 - Lincoln Cathcdral, twelfth to fourteenth century. Photograph, Erlinhurgh Universit)" (2001).
stylistie pattern. Like Ruskin befare him he is not much illtcrested in the spatíal aspects of architccture, its relationship ",.. ith i15 surroundings or its use. Architecture as art i5 in many respects the default mode af architcctural writing. Mast critics continue to work ln this way. The contemporary reviews by Jonathan Glance)' in the Guardian or Deyan Sudjie in the Obst?TYer or Herbert Muschamp in thc New York Times appear on thosc newspapers' arts pages. In this mode, we are lcd to think about buildings as individual works of arto We expect them to be unique exprcssions of a single creative mind, a genius artist of the same kind as a painter or sculptor, or author. We expect them to cxist as diserete objects that ha"c their own integrity regardless of site. Wc expect them to be permanent and unchang ing. We cxpect them 10 be expressions 01' their time as '.vell as of their individual crcator. We expect them to be legible as images, that is to say, as a single signo We expect thern, if they are modern buildings, to be revolutionary in sorne way, to chaHcnge existing assumptions about architecture. Wc cxpect a kind of greatness that is achieved in spite of the world. We expect aesthetic brilliance, in other words, and we are disappointed when huildings do not achieve ir. The idea of architecture as art has been manifest in various ways. It continues to
106
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
exist, although attention may perhaps have shifted lrom the building fa<;ade, which, with modernism, has mattercd less and less, to what the architectural historian Kenneth Frampton has caBed the 'tcctonic'. which is to say, an aesthctic coneero with the structure ofbuildings. For Frampton, a building's skin ought not to conceal thc structure, hut be integral to it, )'et his correerns are no less aesthetic, for he i5 interestcd primarily in thc look 01' a building anO how it i5 achieved. 6 Architecturc as art is underwritten hy the \vork nf su eh art historians as those cited abovc. It ¡s underwrittcn too by educational institutions, including univcrsities.
Architectural training still frequently imagines architects essentially to be artists, who wiB not be much involvcd with the construction 01' buildings, but Vv'ill be dra\ving and talking about ideas: doing, in other words, those things that other kinds oC visual artisb might do. This is further underwritten by certain kjnds of professional journals, whieh propagate the same idea. Prc-eminent in the Anglophone world is undoubtedly the Archítecrural Review. In continental Europe Domus (ltaly) and L'Architecrurc d'Aujourd'huí
(Franee) perform the same task. 7 Thesejournals aH function in similar ways. Thcir interest in architedure is Iimited, hy and large, to two building types: the large. gen erously funded, public projeet, and the small private house; \vhich i5 to say, the types ofbuilding arehitects would Iike to design, and the ones they would like to live in. The journals tend to imply that the building is a product oCa single (genius) mind, pcrson
Fi 6rure 7.3 - Ludwig Mies v, Barcelona, (1928-9). Recor
ifying the buildiug's aesthetic in an individual or group of individuals. They relate the building art-historieally to other buildings in the author's oeuvre, and to formall)' similar buildings hy other architects. They illustrate huildings profuscl)" and in colour. Their use ol' photography specifically avoids the depidion of the building in use, except for where this itsclf eonfirms the aesthctic intentions of the architect; indced, there is a long tradition 01' arehitedural photography of this kind. ~ The)' discuss the buildings in mostly aesthetic term~, as formal propositions that must be eriticiscd within their o\\'n terms; the)' include plans and eostings, but these un<;pcctacular amI unaesthetic things are relegated to the back of the artide
kind of reality resel
repose-; a kindofen
of technologieal mi He re, architecture is a t perhaps [utile. rearguard
lt i5 important that the
in these ter m.s. ArehitecD
Architecture as art is neverthcless an incomplcte definition 01' architecture.
vlduals ancl their prestig
Although perhaps the most familiar dcfinition. it is the preserve of a handful of star
eomplcx social and profeso
architects and their pet projects. It expUcitly rcjects the mass of buildings in the
!t:"ctu re may exist. It shoull
worlcl. For Frampton, global capitalism has such pcnvcr that its gencric shopping
than the material prodUCI
malls. petrol stations, moton...ays, skyscrapers and speculative housing have utterly
position in the puhlic rea]
swampecl the business of architecturc. Arehitecturc is not to be found in these things; quite the reverse: it is the business of resistwfl them. Unlike the petrol station, the shopping mall. the motorway or the speculative house it must m'ces sarHy be marginal and avant-g.lrde, a force for moral eriti(lue from the sidelines.
exists oecause a client aBe painting, the print or ever patronage. Ancl it is gener its specification, its locatio
01' the Spanish arehitect Ignaelo Sola-Morales, one oi' those
paramctt:'rs. Further, the a
responsible for the rcconstruction in 1986 of Ludwig Mies van der Rohc's Gcrman
city doe!-i not funetion witl
He Guotes the vllOrcls
pavilion, originally made for the Jnternational Exhibition o[ 1928-9 held in
trialised world, this wili h~
Barcelona (Figure 7.3). Sola-MoraJes rcgarcls architecturc as a
buildings that Ola)' be eree!
ARCHITECTURE ANO VISUAL CULTURE
107
Figure 7.3 - Ludwig Mies van dcr Rohc, Gennan p~\'ilion at the Intcrnation<'l} Exhihition, Barcdona, ([ 028 9). Rl.'cullslructcd 1986. Author's photograph (2003).
kind of reality reserve. a plact' where man can still hnd material and spiritl1al repose; a kind 01' enclave capable al' resisting J:-i other the destructivc onslaught al' technological modcrnisation. Y Here, architecturc is él tiny but morally "ital practicc, tightíng a desperatc, and perhaps futile. n.'drguard action against the tsunami of glohal capital. It is important that the business
01' architecture should not be solely represcnted
in these terms. Architf':c1llfe ¡", aher a1l, not only thc bu;.;incss of a handful of ÍmH
"iduals and their prestigiolis commis:-iions for art gallerics, it is also a dcepl), eomplcx social and professional praetice. Thcre are roany other ways in which archi tecturc may existo [t should be l..mderstood first as a praeticc that im"olves mueh more than the material produetion 01' an individual. Architecture, because ol' its uniquc posiLioll in the public reaIm, is a uniquely eompromised art, jl' it is an art at all. It
exists bccausc a client allows it to existo Unlike the novel, the pocm, the play, th c painting, the print or even most sculpturc, architccture can scaTlely t'xbt without patronJge. And it is gennal1y the dient who determines the function uf a project, its specification, its location and ahove aH, it'l cost; the architect worb within the.<¡e parameters. Further, the architcct must work \vithin the Iimitations ol' a location. A city does not function without sorne kind of planning régimc. In most of the indus trialiscd world, this wilI be exceedingly restrictive, specifying the size and shape of building, that ma)' he erccted on
J
specHlc site, their colour and materials, and their
108
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
purpose. Furthermore, the architect, unlike any other artist, works in a way that is
Since the seeond worJ
utterly dependent on a variety of other profcssionals: engineers, quantity survey
this rather simple idea o
ors, building contractors, electricians, property consultants. The architect's work is ncver his, or hers, alone. Furthermore the idea ofauthorship in architecture is highly complexo Even without the presence of these other professionals, the architect is
ular significance: Rolan( For Barthes, the world \
invariahly part of a team. Norman Foster and partners, the firm responsible for so
the requisite intellectuaJ
manyrecent Lancion buildings (the Greater Landon Assembly, thc Millcnnium [oot
befare. Thc iconographi
bridge across the Thames, the 'erotic gherkin' tower for Swiss Re, the reconstruc
examplc, was also preoc
tia! in the way that archi
tian of Trafalgar Square and Stansted Airport) employs severaI hundred peopIe its
Panofsky differ crucially
London office, onl)' sorne of whom will be involved in each project. The meaning
mcaning resided. For Pa
of Foster as author of the Greater London Assembly headquarters is very different
greatIy mattered. The m
from the meaning of Vincent van Gogh as author
joh 01' an art historian wa
01' Starry Night. JO
Hence architecture is compromised in ways that other arts are noto The para digm of architecture as art ma)' persist, but it is a highly misleading way
01' think
meaning was not expecÍl
to revisions). For Barthe1
01' an
ing about the practicc. Architccturc needs to he thought of Iess as a set of speeiaI
a legitimate object
material products and rather more as range of social and professional practices that
object, whether an art\\'<
sometimes, but by no means always, lead to buildings. They are practices that
relation with other thing
involve social and commercial networks and institutions as much as thev do indi
it. Mcaning was therefor
It then becomes
tingent and arhitrary. W}
possible to think about arcbitecture as something in which aH can participatc. One
distinct l'rom that of arch
can hcgin to free it from its professional tieso CruciaHy, one can begin to think about
interprctation, not only 1
viduals. Ahove aH, archítecture needs to be anal)'sed as
it from the point of vie\v
dlSCOllrse.
01' its consumption as much as its production. It is here
A sense
01' how this fd
that the field of visual culture as an approach ma)' have the most to offer in our
antholo gy Mythologíes (fi
undcrstanding of architecture. The consumption of architecture may be thought
a medieval cathedral, i5
01' the understanding of it as sign, or symbol;
(Figure 7.4)." Thcse things take the
about in two ways: first, in terms
second, in terms of it as spatial expcriencc.
tling, Hollywood cinero;;
Architecture as 5ign
cination. In a later essay
to the Tower might say
When 1 refer to the consumption of architecture, 1 mean its apprehension by a non
Charles Eiflel) and its fOl
specialiscd public. It is important to distinguish between this and the apprehension
same cngineer / artist. B
01' architecture by the art historian. The attentive reader might say that neither
points whích suggest a ri:
Ruskin, Pevsner nor Wülfflin were specialists, being art historians interested in
tíon of the beholder. 'Its
architecture l'or their own aesthetic ends. But none
01' them read architccturc
against thc intcntions of thc architcct. Nonc of them produced, in other words, a
confers on it the v(
critical reading ofit. AH assumed that they were constructing a story about archi
appcals of our ¡maÉ cation, of science 01
tecturc that had to do with the intentions of an architect, which couId be revealed by careful cxaminatíon of thc building in qucstions amI other historical sources.
Iightning rod or in~
Theirs was a conventional art-historical approach in other words. lt was concerned
thc inevitable sign;
aboye aH with intention as far as it could be knO\vn, and (mc that did not wish to
to encounter it, thl
complicate the business ol' looking.
edge its form and b
ARCHITECTURE ANO VISUAL CULTURE
109
Since the ~econd world war, numerous ~ocial and cultural critics have interrogated this rather simple idea of consumption, and their work has been profoundly influen tial in the way that architecture has come to be understood. One figure is of partic ular significancc: Roland Barthes (1915-80) 1 mast often associatcd with semiolog)'. For Rarthes, the world was a rorest 01' signs that could be interpreted by those ,"vith the requisite intcllectual tool5. Visual practices had been thought al' in these teTms
hcfore. The iconographical work of art historian Erwin Panofsky (1892-1968), for example, was a150 preoccupied \\'ith the symbolic meaning al' art. 11 But Barthes and Panofskydifl'er crucially in whal thcy considered important, and in wherethey thought meaning resided. For Panofsky, art alone rewarded attentive looking; nothing else greatly mattered. The meaning of an artwork was stable and contained within it; the job 01' an art historian 'Nas to reveal it by care1'ul investigation, and once revealed, the meaning 'Nas not expected to change (although, clearl)", further research might lead to revisions). For Barthes by contrast, not ju.-,t art, but the entire cultural dornain was a legitimate object 01' analysis, and unlike Panof"ky, he felt that the rneaning of an ohjcct, whether an artwork or sorne other image or artcfact, was dependent on its relation \-vith othcr things around it at the time and on what the be holder hrought to it. Mcaning was therefore not fixcd or stable, but the revene: it was mutable, con tingent and arbitrar)'. What this implies in terrns 01' architecture i5 an approach quite distinct trom that of architecturc as art. Specifically, it holds architecture as open to interpretation, not on])' by those with a prol'essional interest, but by anJone. A scnsc 01' how this radkal vicw rnight work in practice is provided by his short anthology MytllOJo81es (first published 1957), in which a great architectural work, a medieval cathedral, is regarded ,vith an equal gaze as the Citrocn 0521 car
(Figure 7.4)." These things take their place in a de-hicrarchised world in which aH-in wres tling, Holly\-vood cinema, striptease and steakfrites are al] rcgarded wirh equal 1'a5 cination. In a latlT cssay he writes on the Eil'1'd Tower. An art-historiral approach to the Tower might say something about its origins, its author (the engineer, Charles Eil'l'el) and its l'orm, perhaps relating it to a variety 01' earlier works by the same enginc(:r / artist. Barthes by contrast produces a reckless list al' rcfcrence points \-vhich suggest a radical openness to interpretation, contingent on the posi tion of the bcholder. 'Its simple primar)' shape', he writes, confcrs on it the vocation ol' an infinitc cipher: in turn and a<.:cording to the appeals of our imagination, the symbol ol' Paris, or morkrnity, ol' communi cation, uf scicnce or of the nineteenth century, rocket. stem, derriek, phallus, lightning rod or inseet, eonfronting the great itinerarie5 ol' our drcams, it is the inevitable sign; just as there is no Parisian glance which is not compellcd to cncounter it. there is no fantas)' \-vhieh Elils, sooner or latcr to acknO\.vl edge its l'orrn and be nourished by it. 13
110
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
in terms of architeeture be descrihed in terms of
In the United States, e the architects Robert Vel Like their English count¡; their work. And like thel on the kvel of sign, as we open to multiple interpr
single, authoritarian and • Venturi and Seott Brc
(1963), a sheltered horr ineludes a non-functiona mueh more monumental
London (1991), which n tecture of thc original bl that they do not simplv , UJ ~
a1low multiple readings. works
Figure' 7.4 - CitTf.>en DS2 t (t 971). This is an updatcd version nf th" car that Banhes described on its appcarance in 1gS6. Anthor\ photograph (2003).
oE
architectural Ü
(\ 966) and LearninaJrom 1 posed that architccture a(
The Tmver, as Barthes suggcsts, means an)'thing. 1 \vould not want to argue
the chaIJenge ol' Barthes, although
aH its complexity, in aH it the rarefieo ,vorlo of art b
he was increasingly wiaely read, but there is no douht that during the 1960s,
for whatcver architects di,
there was incrcasing criticism of trarlitional approaches to architcctuTc [rom a
allowed that a building w(
here that any architects havc directl)' taken
Oil
similar paint ol' vie\".. . Sorne- of this was maoc from a stancc sympathetic to Por
public - whatevcr archite.
Art, which undertook a provocati·.. . e blurring ol' the houndaries bctwccn so-called
architcct ~hould acknowI
high ano low culture. In England, important figures in this context ¡nelude the
rich, hut located witrun a'
architects Pctcr (1923-2003) and Alison Smithson (1925-93), Ccdric Price (1934--2003), Archigram (lormed in London 1962) amI the critic Reyncr Banham (1922-88), aH 01 whom attacked the dividc between high and low
cacy of w hat they called mean thc crude signs and
ir onl)'
They are what we ha'
culture, and sought to incorporate the popular rcalm into their work, ('ven in the form of quotation.
will not go away. Or
Banham's 1971 study of Los Angeles is particularly instructive.1+ At the time, the Californian rnetropolis was regardcd \\'ith abject horror hy European aesthctcs,
do not have the
pO'Yi
them \-\'ilh) and becal
\\'ho thought ¡ts heterogencous spraw( the antithcsis of civilisation. What Ranham
needs for variety am
shm..'CrI
it)' and rness wiJI stil
\,..'as that there was not only a pattcrn to its urbanisatioll, but that its huilt
form \Vas of considerable interest. His treatmen! of the commercial architecture
architecture, signific
of the frccways, 01' speculativc housing, of inforrnal architectural phcnomena such
evolutionary as well
as the Watts TO\".. .cr5, not to mentioo the freeways thernsclyes, showed grcat corn plexity, irnagination and symholic yalue in parts of the built cnvironment that critics usually ionored. Most of v\"hat Ranharn describcd coulrl not be accounted for ~
'"
In Learnwa. (rolll Las Ve extraordinarily brash urba
ARCHITECTURE AND VISUAL CULTURE
111
in tcrms of architecturc as arto But it undouhtedly had symbolic value, and could be descrihed in terms al' ao expanded vicw al' architccture. In the Unitcd States, a comparahle develapment couId be secn in the \\'ork af the architects Robert Vcnturi (born 1925) and Denisc Scott-Erown (boro 1931). Like thcir English counterparts, they sought to incorporate a pop sensihility into thcir work. And like thcm, the)' \VeTe ceTtain that architecture ought to function on the level al' sign, as well as anything cisc - and cTudally, that as signs, they ,,,,'erc open to muhiple interpretatían. The meaning o[ architecture was therefoTe not single, authoritarian and closed, hut multiple, democratic amI open. Vcnturi and Seatt Brown's architecture ineludes such works a<; Guild House
(1963), a sheltered home for thc elderly in Pennsylvania, the fa~ade of which ineludes a non-funetional TV aerial as part 01' a s)'mbolic eomposition. A later and muC'h more monumental work was the Sainsbury wing 01' the National Galler)' in London (1991), which makes playfuI referenee to the formal neo-classical archi tccture 01' the original huilding, hut .lIso dcparts picturesquely from it as if to say that they do not simply underwrite the moral message 01' the original huilding, but allow multiple readings. Venturi and Seott BrO\"m werc responsihle for h .....o vital works of architeetural theory, Complexily and Contradicrion in MoJern Arcnitecture
(1966) and Leammafrom Las Veaas (1972). Paralleling Barthcs and Banham they pro posed that architeeture acknowlcdge the factual existcnce of the modern wodd, in aH its eomplexit)', in aH ¡t.s ugliness as \yell as hcauty. It could not confine itself to the rarefied world of art buildings illustrated in the magazines, hecause the context for whatever architects did was a eomplcx and heterogeneous modernity. And thcy allowed that a huilding would inevitahly he oren to multiple interpretations hy the public - whatever architects dcsired.Instcad ol' dosing down such possihilities, the architect should acknowlcdge them and provide material that \vas s)'mbolically rich, bOl located within a ...v idely understood vernaeular 01' signs. Hence their advo cae)' of what the)' called 'honky-tonk' elemcnts in architecture, hy which they mean the crude signs and symhols on commercial buildings: Thcy are what we have. Architcets can bcmoan or try to ignore them hut they wiII not go away. Or the)' will not go away for a long time hecause architects do not havc the pm.. . er to replace them (nor do they kno,,", what to rcplace th.. ' m ...."ith) and because these commonplace c1ements accommodate existing needs for variety and eommunication. The old clichés imolving both hanal ity and mess \·..-ill still be the contcxt of our new architecture, and our new architeeture, significantly, will be the context for thcm ... Architeeture is evolutionary as wdl as revolutionan. 1'i In Lellrnmg from Las Vegas, they .lrgucd that thc temporar)', ephemeral and extraordinarily hrash urbanism of the Las Vegas 'strip' should be rcgarded as an
112
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
ironie signifier of arto Thl any product cornmunicate
The interest in architectu curiously it assumes a tr2 fore important to consi approaehes - that exami.l environment. r am refen
number of authors who ] been used by historians a Figure 7.5 - Fr:mk Gé'hr)', Chwt Da)' Mojo Ad,ertmng BUIlding, Venice. California (1991). Author's photograph (2001).
architecture as experienc
a manner paralleling Ban a discourse that may be s
archítectural phenomenon as important and worth)" ol' study as ancient Rome.
and the development of 1
What was ernerging along the high ...vays of the then still infant dty was not to be
novelty and a shock, .ln u
dismisscd as 'sprawl' but was in
raer a ncw kínd of urhanism, radicalIy unlike any
thing produccd in Europe. 16 Caesar's Pabee, then the biggest and mast spectacu
behaviour. lts profound
architedural fayade - in (
lar of the casino hotels, was photographcd in detail. Its faux Roman sculptures, it5
not in raer matter much ,
David and irs pastiche Bernini sculptures were all examincd with seriousnc."iS and
architectural CTiticism to
presentcd as evidencc of a new and important phenomcnon.
The earliest example ís
In summar)'. this tendenc)' in architecture shows a development of the category
the Workina Clüss in EnBlan
of architccture beyond the convention 01' architecture as art to inelude aH kinds of
1842-4." Engels' deta¡lec
building never intendcd as 'art'" This broadening of architecture .1llo\-..-s [or differ
important hints ofhow a c
ent kind~ of interpretation, and led to what \-vas later caIled postmodern architee
passage, he describes Mar
ture, which in the view of the critie Charles Jencks (horn 1939), aHowed 'double
success generatesextraord
coding' in other words, a dual set of symbolic re1'erences, one 1'or interpretation by 'high' archiLects, the other by the general puhlic. 17
crn .suburban corridor (th(
The devclopments in postmodernism sinee the 1960s show that architecture can
tivel)' do es the dty conee¡
be exp.1ndcd to aIlow for multiple readings and, ostensihl y at least, a more egali tarian approach. But they still pre.'luppose that the terms of tbe dehate are set by
st)'le, its focus is space, and
arehitects" If there is double coding in postmodern building, as Charles Jencks has
made oblivious of Manche
account, on the most basic
Engels gocs on to speo
.'luggested, then the architect, it .'leems, decides whieh symbolism is appropriate for
havc on human beha,"íour,
,,,,hich puhHc. This ís a patronising approach that c1assifies jokes according a pre
Thc German soeiologist Gl
judgcd intelligencc: Dorie ealumns ror the informed architeets, hamburger-joint
read essay 'Thc M('tropoli~
art dcco for the masses, Or in the case ofFrank Gehry's Cbiat Day Mojo offices at
to account for the curious
Venicc, California (Figure 7.5), a rnulti-layered joke: the hinoeulars reeall the daft
a recent and still rare phen
01' OVer a
commercial architecture of the LA freeW3}" \-<.-orld, but they .liso rcfer knO\vingly
with a population
to pop art and a highbrow take on modcrnity. It is, on the one hand, therefore a
anp'.. herc else. Simmel not duces a state of willed ana(
loving reereation of a no\\.' nostalgic form of vernaeular building, on the othcr, an
ARCHITECTURE AND VISUAL CULTURE
113
ironic signifier of arto The surreal, arbitrary quality of the sign, ils dislocation from
any product cornmunicates exceptional aesthetic sophistication. I g
Architecture and Urban Experience The ¡nterest in architecture as sign therefore opened up sorne nc\\' possihilities, hut curiously it assumes a traditional position between viewer and object. It is there fore important to consider an approach - or more accuratcly, collection of approaches - that examines architecture in terms o[ the experience o[ the urban environment. 1 am referring here not so much to a tradition or discipline as to a numher of authors \\'ho
pUl
forward similar ideas and whose writings havc often
been used by historians and theorists. What thev " , have in cornmon is a concern for architccturc as cxperienced by the user, or inhabitant, rather than the architect, in a manner paralleling Barthes' privileging of the rcader oycr the writer. They form a discoursc that may be said to have its beginnings in the mid-nineteenth century and the development of the modcrn metropolis. AH sce the metropolis as both a novelty and a shock, an unnatural phenomenon that produces ncw kinds of social behayiour. Its profound implications for architecture indude the idea that the architectural fac;;ade - in other words, the repository of architccture-as-art - may not in fact mattcr much at all. These writers continue to provide a challenge to architectural criticism to the present day. The earliest cxamplc is pcrhaps Friedrich Engels (1820-95), whose Condition eg" the Working Class
In
EngJand was writtcn ouring the author's stay in Manchester in
1842_-4. 1':1 Engels' detailed account of the world's nrst industrial city providcs sorne important hints ofhow a critical approach to architecture might evolve. In a famous passage, he describes Manchester in dystopian terms as a boomtown whose ver)' success generates extraordinar)' povcrty. This fmds spatial expression along its south ern suburban corridor (the present-day Oxford Road) where a wealthy man may be made obliYious of Manchcster's horror..; on his journe)' to and [rom work, so effee tivel)' does the cit)' eoneeal them behind a corridor of n.'spcctablc fa yades. 20 This account, on the most basic level, is about architecture: but instead of art-historical st)'le, its focus is space, ano in particular the rdationship between space and society. Engcls gocs on to speculate about the et'fect that urban spatial conditions may have on human behaviour, a conccpt much devcloped in the late twentieth century. The German s(lL"Íologist Georg Simmel (1858-1918) took up this thcme in a ".,'idely read essay 'The Metropolis and Mental Lifc', first published in 1902. Simmel tries to accounl for the curious behayiour of inhabitants of very large cities, themselves a rcccnt and still rare phenomenon; thcre were only a handh.l.l of citics in the world with a population 01' over a million. London at the time was ver)' much bigger than an)'whcre cisc. Simmel notes that in eontrast to the small town, the metropolis pro duces a state 01' willed anaesthesia in its inhabitants \,rhcreby the pereeption 01' city
114
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
life is consciously dulled. This is necessary. Simmel argues, bccause the new condi
ifSpace, has been enonr
tians of the dty have produced such a multitude of scnsations, that to accept them
so much an architectura
a11 wouId be to lose control. To survive, the cit)' dweller must timit his experience. This consciously limitcd state Simmel teTms the 'blasé outlook'. His definitían of
Httle more than fayades,
the term rncrits quoting at length:
Therc i5 perhaps no ps)'chic phenomenon 'which is so uncondiüonally reserved to the city as the blasé outlook.
. just as an irnmoderately scnsu
ous life makcs arre blasé hecause it stimulates the nerves to their ulmast reac tivil)' until they finall}' can no longcr produce any rcaction al a1l, so, less
harrnful stimuli, through the rapidity and contradictoriness of their shifts, force the neryes to make such violent responses, tear them apart so brutall)' that the)' exhaust their last reserves 01' strength and, remaining in the same milieu, do not have time for ne\... reserves to form. This incapacity to react to new stimulations \,,'ith the required amount of energy constitutes in fact the blasé attitude which eyer)' child of a large city evincC's when eompared with the product.s of the more peaceful and more stable milieu.)l
their social contexto Ex] se is tiny in relation to th tially authoritarian and may be properl), undersl and Richard Sennett havl reading it in the light of These writers represe its ostensible suhject. Th, expand its norms .md to critique of architecture pnwides a hopelessly nan of canonical buildings) al tries to Ioeate architectur ical practicc, and aboye
a:
Simmcl's essay is no conventional .study in arehitectural history, still lcss the passage quoted aboye, which barel)' refers to architecture. But it is important in the discussion of architccture because it describes the point at which debate
From the outside architec
cxpands from consideration ofbuildings alone, to consider the pS)'l·hological (and
nology, its scnse of prop
indeed other) effects that an aeeumulation ofbuildings might have. Simmel argues
outside 1S not eas;\ but a
that architecture might baye odd, perhaps unexpected dTects. They havc nothing
expert to cngage with ir,
whatever to do with style or an architect's intention, but the)' :-;till belong to thc
critical approach should
realm of architecturc. The importancc of this passage is cxemplified by the fre
Aboye all, architecture
Ol
quene)' with which subsequent authors have put forward similar accounts, clearly
a small part 01' the overall
infiucnced by Simmcl's argumento Notable amongst them is Siegfried Kr3cauer
network nI' practiccs and d
(1889-1966) and his essays on thc public spaces of the metropolis, particubrly the
ol' visual culture ought n01
hotel lobby, whieh he argucs 1S a metropolitan substitute for the ehureh. Whcre in
ture-as-art, but makc use
thc town, he write.s, the ehurch ís a place oI' gathering for believers, its metropol
century. The consideratio
itan equivalent, the hotellobb)', is a godles:-;, purposeless congrcgation, without
social cxpericncc another.
ritual, purpose or, for that matter, God. 22 Or a liule later, one might consider the
duction, and ir 1S this fact;
work of Walter Benjamin, \,·hose unfinishcd account of Pari.s, the Arcades Projea, attcmpted to undcrstand a cit)' through its existing an.:hitectural spaccs; not the spaces 01' the imagination produced by architects, but those actuall)' used, traverscd and inhabited, ful! ol' dcbris and traces (ll' the past. 23 The work of thcsc "'Titen led
10
an equall)' critical tradition of Frl'TH.:h writing
on the cit)', in \\'hich architceture as a ficld of enquiry was cxpanded to mean the cntire urban cxpcricnee, of which the arehitect's work is only a small part. Crucial in this regare! is the work of Henri Lefebvrc (1901-91), \'\-'hose book, The Producrwn
Banham, Rc)oer. /1 enrie Wríl Fort), Adrian. lJíHd, and BUlle; [each, Neil, ed. PH:thinktngAr LcGates, Richard T and Stou Venturi, Robert amI Scott-Brc 1')72).
ARCHITECTURE AND VISUAL CULTURE
115
i:!ISpace, has been enormously influential. 2+ Lefebvre argues that urban ~pace i5 not so much an architectural production as a social one; architects, he \\oTites, produce liule more than fayades, which can be inhabited in ao infioity of ways according to their social contexto Experience is crucial he "'Tites, but the role of an.:hitects per se i5 tin)' in rclation to the whole; thcir desire for arder in the urban realm is essen
tially authoritarian and idealising, and the realro Df social space i5 where thc cit.)' may be properly undcrstood. More recentI)', American writers such as Mike Davis and Richard Sennett have considered the experience nf eontemporary urban -"pace, reading it in the light nf largcr social and eeonomic developments. 25 These writers represent a strand ol' architectural thinking that is highl)' critical ol' its ostensible subject. They are deeply coneerned with arehitccture, but they scek to cxpand its norms and to interrogate its assumptions. They provide the most direct critique ol' architecture-as-art: l'or them, the art-historical conccrn l'or the l'a~ade providcs a hopelessly narro\'\' reading ofarchitecture, limited in both scope (a handl'ul of canonical buildings) and method (a conecrn for style). Tht.'ir projcct hy contrast tries to loeatc architccture in a hroadcrcontext, to make it legible asa social and polit ical practice, and aboye al] as something open to interpreta1Íon, question and use.
Conclusion From the outside architecture is a dauntrng fit'ld, with its private language, its termi nology, its sense ol' propriety and its prol'cssional rules. To approach it l'rom the outsidc is not eas)', but as this chapter suggests, there is much scope for the non expert to engage \vith it, and by so doing, provide alternativc rcadings nf it. A trul)' eritical approach should he prcciscly onc that is not professiona11y compromised. Above a11, architecture ought to be seen as discoursc. Buildings as material l'aets arc a small part ol' the oyera]] ficld nl' architecture, a field which is better regarded as a network ol'practices and debates about the builtenvironment.ln this sense, the stud y ol' visual culture ought not simply to reiteratc the prol'cssional discourse 01' architec turc-as-art, but make use ol' the critical approaches that have emerged over thc past century. The consideration ol' architecture as sign is (mc; arehiteeture as urhan and social expcrience another. Roth cmphasisc the reception of architecture over its pro duction, and it is this fact aboye aH that makes them usel'ul means nl' engagement.
Further Reading Hanham, Reynt-·r. ,1 Cn[J[ lYn!es (Berkeley ami Lo.~ Angeles, 1996). rnrty, Adrian. ¡~~lrJs and B¡¡¡ldings (Lonclon, 2000). Leach, Nt-·il. ej. Rt!/hmkJnfl ArchlteclUre (London, 1997). LcGate~. Richard T. and Stout, Frcc1cric, ('ds. The Cl/Y ReaJer (London, 1996). Venturi, Rohcrt and Scott-Brown, Denise. Leamlna/rom f.as Vegas (Carnhridgc, MAand London, [971)
116
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
Notes Waltcr Benjamín, lIluminat/om" (London, 1973), p. 241.
Nikolaus Pevsncr, An Outlmc ~f Europcan Arrhnecture (Harmondsv,iorth. 194-1), p. 9.
John Ruskin, The Stones ?!vénlce (London, 1976).
Heinrich Wolffiin, ReniJIssance and 8uTOQUC (London, 1964).
Nikolaus Pevsner, The BUlldings qfETlBland (Harrnondsv"'orth, 195 I 74),46 vols. For infor
matían on the series, including plans for further puh1ications, :ice http://'',,W\'>'. pcvsner.co.uk. 6 See Kenncth Frampton, Swdle5 in Tretome CUfrUlC: The PoellCs ~rCo1lStluctIOn m Nmctcenth- anJ 1iventieth-CmrulJ' Architecrufc (Cambridge, MA, 1995). 7 Both are puhlished in international editiom, \vith surnrnarics in English. 8 For discussions 01' architeetural photography, see Roherl Ehvall, Phowgr<¡ph)' Takes Command (London, 1994); abo R. J. WilJiams, 'Reprcscnting Architccture: the British An.:hitectural Prcss in the 1960s' ,Jouma} r:IDc'lfln HmoIJ', Vol. 9, No. 4- (1996), pp. 285- 96. 9 Frampton Studirs In Tecwmc C(¡]wre, p. )4-1. 10 The principal dcsigner of thc GLA building wa.~ in faet Ken Shun\eworth. 11 En..·in Panofskj', Meaning m che Vn-ua} Arts (Nt:'\.. York, 1955). 12 Roland Barthes, .Mj'tho}(>fllCj (Londou, 1972). First pub[ished Paris, 1957. 13 Roland Barthcl>. in ~eil Lcach, ed., R,'chmking Archamure (London, 1997), p. 173. 14- R(,)'llcr Banham, 1[15 ,~ngc1es: 1he Anhnecrure i?f Four F:COJ081e5 (London, 1971). 15 Venturi, in Kcnneth frolmpton, .lloJem Archirenur<':A Crmeal HlSIOfJ (London, 1992), pp. 290-1. 16 Venturi 1.t'ilrllingIrom Las ~'e8as (London, 1972), p. xi. 17 Charles Jencks, MoJan Mo~ements In itrchlt<'dure (Harmonclsworth, 1985), p. 373. 18 Thc huilding is in fact a ('ollaboration \.. ilh the pop arti~1 Claes Oldl"nhurg. For exampks of the roadsid(' architecture to which it refers, s('c what Venturi c1e.~lT¡be.-; as 'duck' archit('c ture in leamJn8.from Las ~e80', p. 17. 19 Frkc1rich Engcls, The ConJJtJOn l?f che H'orkmg (Joss in F.ngJanJ, ed. DaviJ McLcllan (Oxford, 1993). Thc book was nrst pubJj,;hed in Gcrrnan in 1845. i\n ~nglish cditiotl Jj¡l not appear ulltil 1872. 20 lbid., p. 59. 21 SimmeL in Lcac:h, Rerhmking ArchHecwrc, p. 73. 22 Kracaucr, in ¡bid., pp. 53-S. 23 Walter Iknjamin, The Arcade, ProJecc, transo Howard Eiland and Kel'in McLaugh1in (Cambridge, M . A., 2:000). 24 Hcnri Lefebvrc, The ProductlOn '-!.fSpace (Oxkml, 1991). f'irst puhlishcd iu 1947. 25 Mike Dayi~, CII) ~l @art7. EtúIVdtma [he FUfllre In Lo< .1nge1es (London, 1q92); Richard Scnnett, Fle,;h cJnd Stone. 7hc Bod)' and the C1sr In Hhrern C¡nli7.atJOn (London, 1994). 1 2 3 45
First follow N ature
By her just standan Alexander Pope, Al 'Realism' is ane of the m
utarly powerful hoId ove
Toda)', it is ver)" often use
art, photograph, televisi, cornmon scnsc and unco]
01' truth, straightfonvardl eues from the present;
ji
'Rcalism' ma)' be charact,
in 'ugliness' or contemp'
might originate in thc lite tionary <..'vents uf ] 848,
soeialist paintcr Gustave (
wríters such as Emile Zol
As an artistic rnovemel in modern polibcal and obscrvcd objet.:tively and
8. Representation and the Idea of Realism Neil Mulholland
Introduction First follow Naturc, arrd your judgement frame
By her just stanrlard, which is still the same. Alexander Pope,;In EssaJ on Cnricism (1711) 'Rcalism' is arre
01' the most carnmnnI)' used cultural terms and excrcises a partic
ularl)' powerful hold over the ,\'ays that people judge ano expioit visual culture. Toda)', it is ,Ter)' oflen used encouragingl)' as a
,\'ay
01' praising a particular ....·ork of
art, photograph, tclcYision prograrnme or film. To most people, its meaning is earnman scnse arrd uTIC'omplicated. For sorne, 'realism' conjures up connotations uf truth, straightforwanlness, sinccrity arrd horresty. For others 'realism' takes its eues [rom the present; it is basecl upon everyday cxperience rather than myth. 'Rcalism' mal' be char
118
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
In both its urban and predctermined \Va)' ol' assumed that they couId truth about the presento impression ol' totalit)' is. tations an: partial accou be said to be 'realistic'? ol' meeting arbitran: and depcnds ver} much upo cal circumstances. Whal
he 'real' could di/Ier dr Empire, the 'reality' ol'a chant in hfteenth-centur
dl/Terent thlngs to dilIe.
sctllcd termo Cultures a Figure' 8.1 - Gusta\'(' Courbet, The .\tonehrcakers (1 S) 1). No\..
destro~·ed.
1851 (Figure 8.1) I'rom dircct obser\'Jtion of the rurallabouring classes, while Emilc 201a'5 novell'Assommoir (1876) was basecl on facts and figures relating lo the payen)' and squalar suffercd hy people living in the slums nI' Paris. Writers and artists such as ZolJ Jnd Courbet uscd their empirical ohservations make barbl'd political cornrncntary 00 contcmporary socicty. Courbet's paint ing depiets t\\'o raggecl rurallahourers brcaking rocks, él physically demanding task [or whkh they are cIearly unsuited, the boy Oll the lcft being too young to lift his basket and the mao 00 the right being too old to \\'ield his harnmer. Although the tu
painting purports to represent life cxactly as it is l¡ved! the juxtapüsition ol' thc figures and thc loaded subjcct matter render it an obvious rhetorical assault on th(' reification of humanit)'. Both Courhct and Zola saw their suhject matter and its 'truthful' depiction in radical political terms. As committed social rcformcrs, thcy sought to producc a nc"v art relevant to thc masses flooding into huge cities engorged hy the Industrial Revolution, dealing with complex contL'mporary issucs of modern living in a direct, non-mythical fashion. Whik conceptions oFurbanism "'ere ccntral to man)' Realist artists anJ writers in this period, an <:qualiy significant number of cultural producers assodated Realism with naturalism. Rcalism in its naturalist guise \vas often used to cvoke- the authenticit), ol'unspoilcd nature, ofhoncst agricultural toil, or an ancient pastoral ,..-ay of Jife destro),ed hy migration 10 the afTected 'modern' multiculturalism of large cities. The naturalism found in the paintings of Jean Fran~ois Millet and Lhe novcls al' Georgc Elliot presentcd an alternatin: to the con taminations of industrialised life, and as such jars wiLh the urhan Rcalist genrc.
prcsumptions support. 11 ings of realism are preco ami philosophicallegacie The notion of mimesis hJance to what we .'lee Íl Westl'rn imagination. Th
encouraged. In The Repub thc mimetic role 01' the v who diverted people fro,
and beyond the physical .
lace, one thJt Plato wisht
protestations, man)' artist cate of the idea that visua
""as the art historian Ern! sionistic conventions suc
checked against perceptic ventions, or 'schemas', v, argued, there is a clear se
of Jrt. In early fifteenth-o the human countcnance i threc-dimensional hgure~ grcater interest in produci
of bodily structure by ao. nallcd that they were che they sa\\" w¡th thcir own e cate this issue. It \Vas also
REPRESENTATION AND THE IDEil OF REALlSM
119
In both its urhan and rural guiges, Rcalism was clearly an arti5tic convention, a pred(,tcrmined \Vay uf looking at ao inclustrialised culture. Realists obstinatel)" assumed that they could incorporate e"crything in their scope and rcvcal the ·""hale
truth about the present.! The ootioo that an)' representation can give an unmediarcJ impression oftotality is, at the very least, over-ambitious. Given that aH represen tations are partial dccounts, are thcrc aoy wa)'s that visual culture might helpfully
he said to be 'realistic'? To gaio such ao
01' linear perspcctivc
120
EXPLORING VISUAL CULTURE
were developcrl in Florence by the artists and architects Filippo Brunelleschi and
.systems of reprcsentatic
Leoo Battista Alberti, a "'ystem of rules that were to have a profound effeet on thc
that mirror images are,
\vork of artists such as Tomaso Masaccio, Paulo Uccello and Leonardo da Vinci.
ture how we view the '"
Linear perspcctive "vas a mathematil..'al s)'stem designed to .lid artists create the illu
this, '\'e might see it le:
sion of thrce-dimensional spacc and vaJume. Producing .ln artificial horizon lioc
Christians accurately ex
within the wíndow crcated by the canvas cn.'ates the illusían. Lines retreat from the
Verse. Medieval art ser
edge of the canvas to converge at a central 'vanishing paint', a paint which forms
European Christians, a 1
hoth an artificial horizoo tine and the main eompositional focus foI' the viewer of the work. Por Gombrich, the systcm of linear perspcctive "vas non-arbitrary, an unsurpassable means of representing space. Gn refleetion, Gombr