The Earth's Core
This is Volume 37 in INTERNATIONAL GEOPHYSICS SERIES A series of monographs and textbooks Edited by WILLIAM L. D O N N A complete list of the books in this series appears at the end of this volume.
The Earth's Core
J . A. JACOBS Department of Earth Sciences University of Cambridge. England
SECOND EDITION
1987
ACADEMIC PRESS San Diego
New York
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers London Orlando Austin Boston Sydney Tokyo Toronto
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD 24/28 Oval Road, London N W I 7DX
W'
United States Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. Orlando, Florida 32887
Copyright @ 1987 by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publishers
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Jacobs, J. A. The earth's core.-2nd ed.(International geophysics series, ISSN 0074-6142; v. 37). 1. Earth-Core I. Title II. Series 551 .I '1 2 QE509 ISBN 0 - 1 2-378951 - 6
Filrnset by Eta Services (Typesetters) Ltd, Beccles, Suffolk and printed in Great Britain by St Edrnundsbury Press Ltd, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk
Preface t o the First Edition
The innermost regions of the Earth are inaccessible to man and no direct measurements of any of its physical properties can be made. Much attention has been given in the last few years to the “inverse problem in geophysicsthat of determining some physical parameter from a set of observations made at the surface of the Earth. Our knowledge of the core of the Earth comes from many different fields, of which seismology and geomagnetism are the most important and a discussion of these disciplines form a large part of this book. The role of the Earth’s core is essential to our understanding of many geophysical phenomena-it is the seat of the Earth’s magnetic field and coupling between the core and mantle is responsible for some of the variations in the length of the day. The advent of satellites and spacecraft to the moon and terrestrial planets has given an added interest to the internal properties of these bodies-measurements of their magnetic field has already given us some clues on their constitution and possible cores. The question of cores in the other planets is discussed in the last chapter. J. A. JACOBS J u l y 1975 ”
V
This page intentionally left blank
Preface t o the Second Edition
It is just over ten years since the first edition of The Earth‘s Core was published It has been said that the typical doubling period for the accumulation of scientific knowledge during the last two centuries is about fifteen years, and this is certainly the case for the Earth’s core. The second edition has been largely rewritten and expanded, but follows the same layout as the first edition. The first chapter on the general physical properties of the Earth now includes a long section on the core-mantle boundary (the so-called D” layer). The section on free oscillations of the Earth is extended and a section on attenuation (the Q of the Earth) added. In Chapter 2, the accretion mechanism is treated in much more detail and the sections on heat sources in the early Earth and the time of core formation more thoroughly discussed. Chapter 3 now contains a section on Griineisen’s parameter and its role in the thermal regime of the Earth. Melting-point depth curves are discussed in more detail in the light of more recent highpressure shock wave data and a new section is added on the thermal consequences of an iron-alloy core. In Chapter 4 the section on reversals of the Earth’s magnetic field is greatly expanded and the sections on the energetics of the Earth’s core and on variations in the length of the day largely rewritten. A new section on the secular variation is added. Chapter 5 has been considerably modified. I t now contains a more detailed discussion of equations of state and a new section on experimental methods (both static and dynamic). The constitution of the Earth’s core is reviewed in more detail and the case for the presence of silicon, sulphur, oxygen and potassium in the core assessed. Chapter 6 is essentially rewritten. It contains much more information on the cores of the Moon and vii
viii
Preface to the Second Edition
other planets-mainly as a result of increased data from space probes and more detailed numerical modelling. In general SI units have been used. However, in some cases where the older system seems to persist in much of the literature, their usage has been retained, e.g. densities are expressed in g/cm3 rather than in kg/m3. This also has the advantage that their magnitude is reduced by a factor of three. Again the ST unit of pressure is the pascal (Pa), but much experimental work at high pressures still quotes results in kilobars (kb). The conversion is 1 giga pascal (GPa) = 10 k bar. Pressures in the Earth’s core exceed 100 G P a = 1 M bar. J. A. JACOBS
Contents
Preface to the First Edition Preface to the Second Edition
Chapter O n e
V
vii
General Physical Properties of t h e Earth
I. I I .2 1.3 I .4
Introduction Travel-Time and Velocity-Depth Curves The Core-Mantle Boundary (MCB) Free Oscillations of the Earth 1.5 Attenuation in the Earth 1.6 Variation of Density and Other Physical Properties within the Earth 1.7 Models of the Earth’s Interior
Chapter Two 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
3. I 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
30 39 48 56
The Origin of t h e Core
Introduction The Accretion Mechanism Heat Sources for an Earth Accreting Cold Time of Core Formation Inhomogeneous Models of the Earth Variation of the Gravitational Constant G with Time
Chapter Three
i
3 18
81
82 93 107 116 126
The Thermal Regime of t h e Earth’s Core
Introduction Gruneisen’s Parameter The Earths Inner Core Melting-Point-Depth Curves Adiabatic Temperatures The Earth’s Inner Core Reconsidered Thermal Consequences of an Iron-Alloy Core The Core and the Thermal History of the Earth ix
137 137 145 147 159 164 169 175
Contents
X
Chapter Four 4. I 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8
The Earth’s Magnetic Field
Introduction The Origin of the Earth’s Magnetic Field The Homogeneous Dynamo Equations Mean-Field Electrodynamics Reversals of the Earth’s Magnetic Field Energetics of the Earth’s Core The Secular Variation Variations in the Length of the Day
191 20 I 207 213 217 236 247 267
Chapter Five The Constitution of t h e Core 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8
Equations of State The Birch--Murnaghan Equation of State Experimental Methods Ramsey’s Hypothesis Bullen’s (k,p ) Hypothesis Bullen’s Fe,O Hypothesis The Constitution of the Core The Possibility of Potassium in the Core
Chapter Six 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7
The Cores of Other Planets
Introduction Mercury Mars Venus TheMoon Summary The Great Planets
Appendix A Index
291 299 302 308 310 314 315 336
347 349 359 371 377 39 1 394
407 409
Chapter One
Genera I Phys ica I Properties of the Earth
1.1 Introduction
This book is concerned with the Earth’s core-the innermost regions of the Earth. No direct measurements can be made of any of its physical properties and in some ways we know more about the distant stars than we do about the deep interior of the Earth. However, the core plays a key role in many geophysical studies-amongst other things it is believed that the Earth’s magnetic field is a result of motions in the fluid outer core ($4.2). The core, whose radius is just over one-half of that of the Earth, consists of an outer core (OC) that is fluid and an inner core (IC) that is most probably solid-there may also be one or more transition zones between these two regions. The radius of the IC is about one-fifth that of the Earth-thus, although its linear dimensions are quite large, its volume is only about 0.007 that of the whole Earth. Geophysics is an observational science and our objective is to try to explain our observations with theories based on sound scientific principles. To do this we set up models that approximate conditions in the real Earth and try to solve the problem for this idealized situation. A whole series of models of ever-increasing sophistication can be considered, but it must not be forgotten that they are only models and that the real Earth may behave quite differently. The assumptions and limitations of any model must be clearly stated and always borne in mind when assessing the success of any theory. 1
2
The Earth‘s Core
The mathematical equations that describe most physical phenomena are often non-linear and extremely complex so that analytical solutions are in general not possible. In many cases order-of-magnitude arguments are used to draw some preliminary conclusions, but one must be very wary of much of this type of “arithmetic”, since it is all too easy to be misled by “geophysical numerology” (Jacobs, 1970). In such cases intuition is a notoriously bad guide. Moreover, order-of-magnitude calculations can often lead to contradictions resulting from over simplification of the original equations. Our knowledge of the deep interior of the Earth is pieced together from information obtained from a number of different disciplines-physics, chemistry, astronomy and geology. A fundamental problem in geophysics is the determination of some physical parameter (e.g. density) from a set of observations made at the surface of the Earth. This “inverse” problem as it is called has received much attention during the last few years. It has been formulated using sophisticated mathematics, and with the aid of modern computers it is also possible to obtain information about the uncertainty and non-uniqueness of Earth models. The resulting proliferation of Earth models has had two consequences. Firstly, there is the difficulty of choice of an adequate Earth model for researches that depend on the structure of the Earth; and secondly, several researchers have adopted some properties from one model and other properties from another, with the result that their models are not self-consistent. At the XV General Assembly of the International Union of Geodesy and Geophysics (IUGG), held in Moscow in 1971, a committee was set up to advise on a Standard Earth Model (SEM) covering the distribution of various physical properties of the Earth’s interior. A necessary requirement of a reference Earth model is that it must fit data on the Earth’s mean radius R, mass M , and z where I = z M R 2 and I is the Earth’s mean moment of inertia. Account must be taken of data derived from records of seismic body waves, seismic surface waves, and free Earth oscillations. In addition there is a large body of information from other sources, including data on Earth tides, finitestrain and solid-state theory, laboratory experiments on rocks (including shock-wave experiments at pressures up to 4 million atmospheres), and evidence from other disciplines such as planetary physics, geology and geochemistry. The SEM committee set up a number of subcommittees to examine particular aspects of the SEM project. At a meeting of the Symposium on Mathematical Geophysics held at Banff in 1972, three research groups, headed by D. L. Anderson, F. Gilbert and F. Press, presented Earth models giving the main parameters. The results were published in the Geophysical Journal 35, 1973. At a meeting of the International Association of Seismology and Physics of the Earth’s Interior (IASPEI) in Lima in 1973, there was agree-
General Physical Properties of the Earth
3
ment about the need for a parameterization of an Earth model and Dziewonski et al. (1975) later published parametrically simple Earth models (PEM) consistent with geophysical data. It was also decided in Lima to publish some of the interim reports prepared by the sub-committees (Physics of the Earth & Planetary Interiors 9, 1 4 4 , 1974). By the time of the IASPEI meeting in Durham in 1977 it had become evident that it was possible to construct Earth models taking account of damping. The effects of attenuation were considered to be important, but since such effects are not well-determined it was decided to produce two Earth models-one including attenuation and one not. It was further decided to entrust to D. L. Anderson and A. M. Dziewonski the task of constructing suitable models. They presented a Preliminary Reference Earth Model (PREM) at the XVII General Assembly of the IUGG in Canberra in 1979 that was subsequently published in Physics of the Earth & Planetary Interiors 25,297-356,1981. Although a definitive SEM has not yet been produced, the SEM committee was finally dissolved at the XVIII General Assembly of the IUGG in Hamburg in 1983. It was realized, however, that refinement of the Preliminary Reference Earth Model is necessary, and further work is continuing, Details of recent Earth models are given in $1.7.
1.2 Travel-Time and Velocity-Depth Curves
The major source of our information about the Earth’s interior comes from the field of seismology. Following an earthquake, elastic waves travel throughout the Earth and may be observed at the large number of seismological stations distributed across the world. The theory of the propagation of elastic waves may be found in any standard text on seismology (see, for example, Bullen, 1963) and will not be developed here. There are two distinct types of elastic waves-P waves and S waves. A P wave is a condensation- . rarefaction wave involving change of volume. Motion of the medium is longitudinal, so that there is no polarization of a P wave. An S wave is a shear wave in which there is distortion without change of volume. S waves are transverse waves and thus exhibit polarization. In addition surface waves are set up: these have yielded valuable information about the crustal layers of the Earth. Recently, long-period surface waves have been used to obtain additional information about the deeper parts of the Earth. It can be shown that the velocities of P and S waves are given by
4
The Earths Core
and r
V, =
J’P
where k, is the bulk modulus or adiabatic incompressibility, ,u the modulus of rigidity and p the density. Thus V p and V, depend only on the elastic parameters and density of the medium. In particular, if the rigidity is zero, V, = 0, i.e. shear waves cannot be transmitted through a liquid. It follows from (1.1) and (1.2) that r#~ =
k,/p = V;
-
$Vg
(1.3)
When an elastic wave meets a sharp boundary between two media of different properties, part of it will be reflected and part refracted, and laws of reflection and refraction analogous to those of geometrical optics apply. The case of elastic waves is more complicated, however, since waves of both P and S type may be reflected and refracted. The‘ theory is based on Fermat’s principle, according to which an elastic wave takes the quickest path between any two points. This does not imply that there is only one path-there may be a number of alternative paths-but each path must involve a minimum transit time relative to small deviations in the path. Figure 1.1 illustrates some of the many possible reflections and refractions of elastic waves at discontinuities within the Earth. The figure also illustrates the terminology used to designate some of the different phases. A P wave reflected from the Earth’s surface can give rise to both a P wave and an S wave (called PP and PS waves respectively). Likewise an S wave reflected from the surface can give both P and S waves (called SP and SS waves respectively). The letters c and i denote reflections from the boundaries of the OC and IC respectively, and h denotes reflection from the surface of the F shell (the transition layer between the OC and IC). The letters Kand I are used for P waves in the O C and IC. Thus SKP is an S wave that has been refracted into the OC (necessarily as a P wave) and refracted back into the mantle as a P wave. S waves have never been observed in the OC, which is thus considered to be liquid. On the other hand, it has often been conjectured that the IC is solid and the symbol J was proposed for paths of S waves (if they exist) in the IC. It was not until 1972 that Julian et al. claimed to have identified the phase P K J K P on seismograms4onfirmation of their work would establish the existence of rigidity in the IC directly. They obtained a value of V, N 2.95 km s - ’ in the IC which is difficult to reconcile with that of -3.6 km s - ’ obtained by Gilbert et al. (1973) from an analysis of free Earth oscillation data (see $1.4). A value of -3.6 km s- also follows from Bullen’s ( k , p ) hypothesis (see 55.5). There is a possibility that Julian et al. observed the phase (1974) has suggested that the SKJKP, rather than PKJKP-Doornbos
’
5
General Physical Properties of the Earth
----s rays Fig. 1 .l.Representative seismic rays through the Earth (After Bullen, 1954.)
phase P K J K P is too small to be observed. Multiple ( n ) internal refections from the mantle-core boundary (MCB) into the O C are indicated by nK. Thus P7KP is a P wave that has been refracted into the OC, suffering 7 internal reflections in the core before being refracted back into the mantle as a P wave (see Fig. 1.2). The times of arrival of the different seismic waves may be determined from the records at a number of stations, so that it is possible to construct traveltime curves, i.e. plots of arrival times T against distance A (measured in degrees along the surface of the Earth) between the source and the seismic observatory. The construction of travel-time curves has had a long history of successive approximation and increasing accuracy. Revision of the early travel-time curves was undertaken by Jeffreys in 1931 (see Jeffreys, 1936, 1961 for complete details) using a least-squares technique. In collaboration with Bullen he produced the first J.B. Tables in 1935. Substantial refinements were incorporated in a new set of J.B. Tables first published in 1940. These gave travel-times, not only of P and S waves, but also of reflected and refracted
6
The Earths Core
Fig. 1.2. Diagram showing seven internal reflections from the M C B into the OC (P7KP). (After C. H . Chapman.)
waves. Details of the production of these tables and of the early history of the subject may be found in Bullen (1963). Improvements in the records and the use of large artificial explosions have led to corrections to the J.B. Tables (see e.g. Herrin, 1968). However, the production of the J.B. Tables, before highspeed computers were avilable, was a monumental achievement. From the travel-time curves, it is possible to calculate the velocities of P and S waves at any depth within the Earth. The details of such an inversion will not be given here (see e.g. Bullen (1963) for details). Figure 1.3 shows the gross features of the velocity-depth curves in the Earth according to Jeffreys and Gutenberg. During 1940-42, Bullen divided the Earth into a number of regions based on such curves. His nomenclature
7
General Physical Properties of the Earth
Depth ( k m ) Fig. 1.3. Seismic velocities of P and S waves as a function of depth. (After Birch, 1952.)
has since been widely used, and, in spite of uncertainties in the positions (and realities) of the boundaries between the different regions, continues to serve as a useful basis in discussing the Earth’s interior. The upper mantle consists of region B extending from the base of the crust (region A) to a depth of about 400 km, and region C which is a transition zone between depths of about 400 and 1000 km. The lower mantle, below a depth of about 1000km, is called region D. The core is divided into an outer core E, a transition region F and an inner core G. In recent years much finer detail has been obtained, particularly in the upper mantle (regions B and C, see Fig. 1.4), and in the vicinity of the boundary of the IC (region F). In the following discussion of the physical properties of the Earth, attention will be confined to the core and very deep mantle: no account will be given of the crust or the low-velocity layer in the upper mantle, nor of possible phase changes in region C. Sengupta and Julian (1978) have investigated the variation of P and S wave velocities in the lower mantle using data from deep-focus earthquakes. The chief advantage of using deep-focus earthquakes is the reduction of anomalies caused by complex structures near the source. Their standard deviations of average travel times are as much as a factor of two smaller than those determined from the data of shallow-focus earthquakes (see e.g., Herrin et al., 1968; Hales and Roberts, 1970). No pronounced decrease in either the P or S
8
The Earth's Core
Pressure ( k bar )
I. I. I
I' 1.
I:p I:
1:
I:
I: I: I'
i
c IL
I' 6.
LOWER
MANTLE
:?
CORE
L
t
;z .........../*'
..'
......
1: I:..
I I
fNIA1; MOHO. I I
i
I
I
Depth ( k m 1 Fig. 1.4. Seismic velocity distribution in the mantle for P waves, solid line (Johnson, 1967, 1969); S waves, solid line (Nuttli, 1969); broken lines P and S waves (Jeffreys, 1937, 1 9 3 9 ~ ) (After . Ringwood, 1972.)
velocity just above the MCB is required by their data, though a small velocity decrease could not be ruled out (see also $1.3). However, anomalous rapid changes in the gradient of the P velocity were found around depths of 2400 km and 2600 km. Their model for P velocities in the lower mantle agrees best with that of Herrin et al. (1968), and for S velocities with the 1066B model of Gilbert and Dziewonski (1975). Lee and Johnson (1984a) used travel-time data from the ISC Bulletin to
9
General Physical Properties of the Earth
0
1000 Y v
f a cu
a 2000
3000
4
6
a
10 Velocity ( k m s-')
12
14
Fig. 1.5. P a n d S velocitydepth bounds computed with upper mantle 7 ( p ) envelope. (After Lee and
Johnson, 1984a.)
determine confidence limits for the seismic parameter z(p) = T ( p ) - pA(p) where p is the ray parameter for mantle P and S waves. One year of P data (- 108,000 travel-times) and four years of S data (- 75,000 travel-times) were used. Based on these results, they obtained (Lee and Johnson, 1984b) extrema1 bounds on seismic velocities in the mantle (see Fig. 1.5). Bounds on the lower mantle P velocity have an average resolution of 70 km in the depth range -800-2900 km. The average bound width is -0.14 km sC1 at the 97% confidence level. Bounds on the lower mantle S velocity have an average resolution of 85 km in the depth range -850-2900 km and an average width of 0.13 km s-l. These confidence limits were computed with an assumed upper mantle velocity distribution. It should be noted that linearized inverse techniques (e.g. Backus and Gilbert, 1970; Johnson and Gilbert, 1972a,b) provide uncertainties in velocity and depth at a particular point in a model, whereas the method of Lee and Johnson establishes a confidence region for the entire model. The inversion methods of obtaining velocity-depth curves from travel-time curves break down if there is a region in the Earth in which the velocity decreases with depth. In such a case there will be a range of A in which arrivals from an earthquake are not observed (a shadow zone). There is an abrupt, discontinuous drop in the velocity of P waves across the MCB with a corresponding shadow zone in the range 105" < A < 143". Some waves are recorded in this range, however, so that it is not a true shadow zone (see Fig. 1.6).The
10
The Earths Core
Fig. 1.6. P, PcP, PKP, PKIKP, and diffracted P waves. (After Bullen, 1954)
amplitudes of such waves are much reduced and for many years their presence was attributed to diffraction round the boundary of the core. Miss I. Lehmann suggested in 1936 that such waves had passed through an IC in which the P wave velocity is significantly greater than that in the O C and later work has corroborated her hypothesis. Our present knowledge of seismic velocities in the core comes chiefly from the interpretation of travel-times of short-period P waves. There is a wide variation in the estimated velocities of P waves just below the MCB with likely values ranging from 7.9 k m s - ' (Hales and Roberts, 1971) to 8.26 k m s - l (Randall, 1970). Inversion studies favour a value fairly close to Jeffreys'( 1939d) value of 8.10 km s-'. At depths in the O C greater than about 200 km, most velocity models converge to values that are generally higher than those of the Jeffreys (1939d) model, although within 0.1 km s-' of it. A detailed discussion of the results of different authors has been given by Engdahl(1968). Nearly all authors of travel-time studies agree that there is a gradual increase in P velocity in the O C down to a depth of about 4600 km. Most disagreements arise in the transition zone F between the OC and IC. Calculations by Gutenberg and Richter (1938, 1939) and by Jeffreys (1939c,d) corroborated Miss Lehmann's hypothesis of a rapid or discontinuous increase in the velocity of P waves in the Earth's core, but differed in the interpretation of the velocity distribution near the inner core boundary (ICB). Jeffreys assumed that the wave velocity decreased with depth just above the IC, and then increased discontinuously at the ICB (see Fig. 1.3). Gutenberg, on the other hand, favoured a gradual increase in velocity in a transition zone without a preceding decrease. Neither of these models, however, can explain (using ray theory alone) the observed short-period precursors to P K P waves at distances less than 140". Jeffreys (1939~)considered
General Physical Properties of the Earth
11
diffraction near a caustic and showed that appreciable amplitudes for a diffracted P K P wave could not exist more than about 3" from the P K P caustic at 143" for periods of 1 s, or 14" for periods of 10 s. Denson (1952) and Gutenberg (1957, 1958a,b, 1959) attributed these early arrivals to dispersion in the transition zone. The lack of definitive observational evidence, however, is a significant argument against accepting this as the mechanism that is operative in the Earth. An explanation for the early onsets in terms of magnetoelastic coupling was also shown to be unlikely by Knopoff and Macdonald (1958). Bolt (1962,1964) proposed that two discontinuous increases in the velocity distribution of P waves in the Earth's core could explain these arrivals as rays refracted through an intermediate shell. He used observations from a study of P K P readings in the range 11O0
12
The Earths Core
11 I I I I
I
.-
h
m
E lo
Y u
L > _V
-ar0
Jeffreys (1939 a , b )
-Bolt (1962) .......... Adams-Randall (1964) Randall (1971) .-.-.- Hales -Rober t s (1 971 )
>
9
0
#-
1
0 0 0
-
Model KOR5
-
I
8 1 3000
I 2000
I
I
1000
0
Radius ( k m ) Fig. 1.7. Compressional wave velocity for different core models. (After Qamar. 1973.)
recorded deep-focus earthquakes and a near-surface event. Arrival times and amplitudes of core phases from these events were supplemented by P K P observations. Engdahl first tried to find a solution in terms of a decreasing velocity function within the intermediate shell of the Bolt core model-his velocity distribution is shown in Fig. 1.8 (the Bolt core model is indicated by the dashed line). He obtained an alternative velocity model (Fig. 1.9) by increasing the radius of the Bolt intermediate layer to a point just below the radius of penetration (r,, = 1881 km) of the point B (the P K P caustic). These two models represent the limits of allowable velocity solutions for a singlelayer transition zone corresponding to the observed data. Engdahl (1968) also considered more complicated models with additional discontinuities in the core. The velocity function proposed by Adams and Randall (1964) consisted of three discontinuous increases between the OC and IC-the details of this velocity structure are shown by the dashed line in Fig. 1.7 Engdahl came to the conclusion that the unusual curvatures indicated between 0.3 and 0.6 Rc are artificial and unwarranted by the data.
14
-
13
1
I
1
1
1
I
1
L
I
-
L
c
ul
E
-
12-
Y
v
.-=U. 0 s0
L
.-C u
11
9
-
I I
-
10-
9-
L 3
.-
0 C
o
-1
8-
7.
1
1
1
I
I
I
1
I
I
1
Fig. 1.8. Compressional wave velocity in the core. The dashed line represents the Bolt core model. (After Engdahl. 1968.)
14
I
I
I
I
1
I
1
I
I
13
-
-
El2
-
-
h
c
ul Y
v
r/ Rc Fig.1.9. Alternative compressional wave velocity in the core. The dashed line represents the Bolt core model. (After Engdahl, 1968.)
14
The Earth's Core
7
I
I
1
1
1.0
I
1
I
1
0.8
1
I
1
1
0.6 r/ Rc
1
I
1
1
0.4
I
1
1
I
0.2
I
I 0
Fig. 1.10. Compressional wave velocity in the core The dashed line represents the Adams-Randall model (After Engdahl. 1968 )
To test the hypothesis of multiple discontinuities in the core, Engdahl set up a model consisting of two constant-velocity shells within the transition zone (Fig. 1.10). To be consistent with observational data for models of this type, it was necessary to consider changes in the core which prevent rays in the OC from forming a P K P caustic at B (the P K K P caustic is preserved). Engdahl thus believes that the fine structure of the core proposed by Adams and Randall has not been established. Engdahl concluded that a working model of the core consisting of a singlelayer transition zone (a modified Bolt model) can explain the observed data within reasonably close limits. This layer is between 400 and 600 km thick and has a P velocity distribution either constant or decreasing with depth. In order to explain early P K P arrivals, characteristically observed in the range 125"-140", a velocity discontinuity must be introduced in the core between radii of 1667 and 1806 km, approximately. The radius of this discontinuity defines the top of the transition layer. The bottom of the layer or ICB, also defined by a jump in the velocity, is between radii of about 1233 and 1250 km. Haddon (1972), in a study of precursors to PKZKP, concluded that they were not likely to be associated with the presence of a transition layer of the Bolt type, nor with any internal discontinuities inside the OC or IC, and suggested that they may be caused by scattering of P K P waves from irregularities near the MCB. In addition to meeting the observational requirements,
General Physical Properties of the Earth
15
this interpretation has the further advantage of simplicity-the only discontinuity in the core being the boundary between the IC and OC. This is also a feature of model B1 of Jordan (1972)-see $1.7. It must be pointed out, however, that some authors still claim that the seismic data demand a two-layer transition zone in the core, although not excluding inhomogeneities at the base of the mantle that they consider a secondary effect-see, for example, Bertrand and Clowes' (1 974) analysis of travel-times and travel-time gradients recorded at the Warramunga seismic array. These authors claim that the data are best fitted by three discontinuous increases in the P velocity, one at the ICB and two at shallower depths. These discontinuities define two layers, each a few hundred km thick, surrounding the IC-the velocity increase in both of these two layers being less than 0.1 km s - '. Muller (1975) has shown that long-period precursors to PKZKP should be observed if they are due to discontinuities in the OC. However, long-period seismograms* for an earthquake in the New Hebrides do not show them. Muller thus concludes that the discontinuities of Bertrand and Clowes' model are not real and that the P velocity depth-function in the OC in smooth down to the ICB. For most models, P velocities in the IC are approximately constant, the velocity increase at the ICB being 0.9-1.0 km s- '. The models of Buchbinder (1971) and Qamar (1973) are exceptions-they show a velocity increase of about 0.6 km s-' at the ICB followed by a pronounced velocity gradient in the outermost part of the IC. Qamar's model (KOR5) is also shown in Fig. 1.7-it was developed to satisfy all available observations of travel-times, dT/dA, and amplitudes of core waves. The model is also tied to the Herrin (1968) tables for P and the Randall (1970) tables for S K S . The average velocity in the transition region is 1)% lower than in Bolt's (1962) model: at the outer boundary of the transition zone ( r = 1782 km), model KOR5 has a velocity jump of only 0.013 km s-l, which is 1/20 of that in Bolt's (1962) model. The jump at the ICB (I = 1213 km) is 0.6 km s-', which is about 2/3 of that in most other models. Very similar results have been obtained by Muller (1973) from a study of long-period core phases. He found that the P velocity distribution is quite smooth right down to the ICB with no first-order discontinuities in the transition region. The P velocity increase at the ICB is 0.60.7 km s-', with again a strong velocity gradient in the outer part of the IC; the S velocity just inside the boundary of the IC is -3.5 km s-'. This is greater than the value of 2.95 km s - ' obtained by Julian et al. (1972) in their paper claiming to have identified the phase P K J K P and confirms the value obtained earlier by Dziewonski and Gilbert (1971) based on normal mode oscillations (see 91.4). The simplest explanation of a possible velocity gradient or a constant * From the
World- Wide Standardized Seismograph Network ( W W S S N ) .
16
The Earth’s Core
velocity in the F region is the existence of an abnormally high temperature there, which would imply radioactive heat sources in the core. Liu (1982a) has shown by geochemical arguments that there should be about one-third to one-half of the Earth’s heat-producing elements below the upper mantle. O’Nions et al. (1978) and Clark and Turekian (1979) came to the same conclusion to account for the heat flux observed at the Earth’s surface. Highpressure experiments by Liu (1 982b) showed that these heat-producing elements would exist as dioxide solid solutions that are chemically incompatible with the major mantle silicates at the temperature and pressure conditions in the lower mantle. Because of the great densities of these dioxides, probably in excess of that of the liquid OC, Liu (1982a) suggested that they may be gravitationally transported to, and concentrated in, the F zone. Alder and Trigueros (1977) explained the small observed dependence with pressure of the speed of sound just outside the solid IC by suggesting that there is a eutectic region between the liquid O C and solid IC.* If the composition lies on the liquidus of a eutectic phase diagram, the liquid phase would be in equilibrium with pure solid iron, which precipitates out. Along the liquidus the concentration of the lighter component would increase as complete solidification is approached. Since the lighter component will in general have a lower sound speed, increasing its concentration would result in a mixture whose sound speed may be nearly constant, since the effect of the pressure increase is nearly compensated for by the concentration increase. Alder and Trigueros calculated the change in concentration of the light element required to give the observed variation of sound speed with depth and estimated the resulting variation of density with depth. They found that the change in concentration is comparable to that for the known liquidus under normal conditions if the light component is sulphur or silicon. They also found that the predicted density change along the liquidus is very small, possibly leading to hydrodynamic instabilities. Their suggestion remains an interesting possibility, but it is difficult to quantify the results because of uncertainty in predicting the sound speed of iron alloyed with different elements at the pressure and temperature conditions of the core. Seismic anelasticity studies (see $1.5) indicate anomalously low Q t for P waves in the core, which suggests that the outer part of the IC may be
* See 55.7: It is generally believed that the OC consists of Fe alloyed with some 10% lighter element. t Departures from ideal elasticity in the Earth can be expressed in terms of the reciprocal of the dimensionless parameter Q (Knopoff, 1964), defined by the equation 2nIQ
=
AE/E
where AE is the energy dissipated per cycle and E is the peak energy stored. The mechanical Q defined above is mathematically equivalent to the Q of an oscillatory electrical circuit. A region with low Q values thus implies an extremely dissipative zone.
General Physical Properties of the Earth
17
partially molten. Fearn et al. (198 1) followed up this idea and suggested that the outer part of the IC is a mushy layer of mixed liquid and solid. They found that this layer can be very thick, extending possibly to the centre of the Earth. Although the mechanism proposed by Fearn et al. is in accord with the observational evidence of seismic anelasticity, the agreement is not well-founded, since the anelastic model in common use, in which the anelasticity has been modelled using Landau damping, is inadequate to describe a partially molten system in which melting and freezing can occur. The Landau model works well for a homogeneous material but can lead to serious errors when applied to a heterogeneous material. Loper & Fearn (1983) have since developed a theory of the anelasticity of a partially molten material resulting from thermal and material diffusion (in the Landau model, the governing equations are relaxational rather than diffusive). In their model the OC contains no solid material, but the IC contains liquid in a dendrite layer or mushy zone. This agrees with seismic evidence (Doornbos, 1974; Cormier, 1981; Choy and Cormier, 1983; Hage, 1981) that indicates a non-homogeneous region several hundred kilometres thick below the ICB. The ICB also presents a sharp interface for the phases P K i K P and PKZZKP at small A (Bolt, 1977). The theory of Fearn et al. (1981) is consistent with these observations provided the mass fraction of solid below the ICB grows from zero at the boundary to a significant fraction within several kilometres. Hage (1983) used long-period P K P amplitudes to obtain velocity constraints in the IC. Using theoretical amplitudes (derived from synthetic seismograms calculated for 56 systematic modifications in the IC of Earth model 1066B), he showed that the parameters of a regression line through the logarithmic and normalized amplitudes in the distance range 110-134" are related to the velocity and density jump at the ICB. His analysis showed that the main influence on P K P amplitudes is the jump in the P velocity, which can be restricted to 0.64 0.05 km s- ', implying a need for substantial revision of the P velocity distribution in the IC for core models such as 1066B or PREM. Hage also showed that there is a trade-off between the jump in S velocity and the density jump. Restricting the latter to the reasonable range 0-1.2 g ~ m - he ~ found , the jump in the S velocity at the ICB to be between 2.5 and 3.0 km s-'. The data do not permit a shear velocity less than 2.5 km s - l at the ICB, in contrast to the results of Choy & Cormier (1983), who compared observed with theoretical short-period and broad-band P K P waveforms and suggested that the S velocity may be nearly zero at the top of the IC. Hage also found a rather steep S velocity gradient below the ICB if the travel-time of S waves through the IC is in accord with that implied by free oscillation data. As a result, Poisson's ratio in the IC decreases rather sharply from 0.46 to 0.435. This supports the idea of a dendritic layer characterized by a liquid fraction of core material at the top of the IC as suggested by Fearn et
18
The Earths Core
al. (1981). A decrease in the liquid fraction with depth in the IC would lead to an increase in the S velocity. The analysis of Choy and Cormier (1983) gave a jump of 0.52 0.07 km s - in the P velocity at the ICB in reasonable agreement with that obtained by Hage. They found no zone of small or negative P velocity gradient or of strong anelasticity at the bottom of the OC (the F region). On the other hand, in order to satisfy average properties of the IC inferred from travel-times and normal-mode data, strong gradients in both P and S velocities and anelasticity are required in the upper 20&300 km of the IC. Choy and Cormier concluded that the process of IC solidification produces the most evident seismic effects in body waves with turning points that bottom in the upper 20&300 km of the IC, rather than in the lowermost F region of the OC. This model is not very different from that proposed by Hage (1 983).
1.3 The Core-Mantle Boundary (MCB)
There has been much argument about the structure of the Earth at the base of the mantle (called by Bullen region D"). Apart from its seismological interest, it is critical for thermodynamic models of the mantle. The basic question is whether this boundary layer is compositional and/or thermal. If heat from the core contributes significantly to the convective heat flux of the mantle, then a thermal boundary layer must exist at the base of the mantle so that heat from the core can diffuse across the MCB into the mantle. Models for D" can be divided into two classes-those that allow for an abrupt change in the velocity gradient at the top of D" followed by a nearly constant gradient down to the MCB and those that, in addition to the change in gradient at the top of D", have a more complicated velocity distribution within D". It should be pointed out that even if the seismic velocities in D" are determined to be anomalously low, consistent with a superadiabatic temperature gradient, it cannot be definitely concluded that there is a thermal boundary layer at the MCB-a compositional change would be a possible alternative. However, a thermal boundary layer would seem to be necessary as well, since a significant heat flux from the core is implied by any geodynamo mechanism (see $4.6). The physical mechanisms of the attenuation of seismic waves have been discussed by Jackson and Anderson (1970). Seismic wave attenuation is strongly temperature-dependent, showing a rapid increase with rising temperature. Attenuation increases sharply with the onset of melting-shear waves cannot propagate in a completely molten material. Although the O C is generally considered to be fluid, some investigators believe that it has a finite, though small, rigidity (Sato and Espinosa, 1967; Balakina and Vvedenskaya,
General Physical Properties of the Earth
19
1962). Ibrahim (1971) obtained a better fit to the observed amplitude ratio PcPIP if the O C has a finite rigidity. In a later investigation (1973) he showed that it is easier to explain the observational data (mainly from deep-focus earthquakes) if two to four low-velocity, high-density layers are imbedded between the mantle and core. All Ibrahim’s models indicate that the OC has a finite rigidity, with an upper bound for the shear wave velocity of 1.4 km s-’. Buchbinder and Poupinet (1 973) have criticized Ibrahim’s results and claim that the layered system he proposed is not likely to be found from the data he used (short-period phases sampled at their maximum amplitude), even if such a layered system existed. Buchbinder and Poupinet maintain that PcPIP amplitude ratios cannot be used to study the structure of the MCB. However, from a study of their waveforms (following two large nuclear explosions), they suggest that the MCB may be approximated by a thin highimpedance liquid layer several kilometres thick embedded between the mantle and the core-the data do not permit exact determination of the model parameters, and the structure of the MCB may be radially asymmetric. The shear velocities in the Earth’s lower mantle have long been thought to increase moderately and monotonically downward to the MCB. However, some shear velocity models have been proposed in which the region just above the MCB contains a significant negative velocity gradient. Such models have been proposed by Cleary (19691, Bolt et al. (1970) and Robinson and Kovach (1972) on the basis of dT/dA determinations of diffracted S waves. Their estimates of the shear velocity just above the core range between 6.81 and 6.99 km s - l , as opposed to Jeffreys’ value of 7.30 km s-’. Observations of the periods of free oscillations of the Earth provide additional data for determining the shear velocity distribution (see 41.4). Tradeoffs, however, occur between the shear velocity, density, and core radius, and a unique determination of these is difficult (Dziewonski, 1970). Different investigators have been able to satisfy the free-oscillation data with models differing radically in lower mantle structure. The effect of these trade-offs can be reduced if overtones of the spheroidal and toroidal modes are incorporated in the inversion. Jordan (1972) combined all available free-oscillation data with a large body of travel-times and found that, although a model with a negative shear velocity gradient in the lower 100 km of the mantle provided a satisfactory fit to the data, the fit was not as good as that in which the negative velocity gradient was absent. In model UTD124A’ of Dziewonski and Gilbert (1972) and model B1 of Jordan and Anderson (1974) the P and S velocities vary smoothly down to the MCB without any extreme change in gradient. Both models are in good agreement with most travel-time and free-oscillation data. Their validity rests on the supposition, supported in part by theoretical studies, that data that suggest the presence of a low velocity in D” result from distortion of seismic
20
The Earths Core
waves by the MCB. On the other hand, slowness and amplitude data from short-period P waves indicate a fairly rapid decrease in velocity gradient at a depth corresponding to an epicentral distance of about 92", and it is very unlikely that these data can be interpreted as interface phenomena. The measured P and S times at distances beyond about 96" also indicate reduced velocities in D". In model B2 of Jordan (1972), Bolt's (1972) model, and model ANU2 (Cleary, 1974), the velocity gradients decrease fairly abruptly at a height of 100 km above the MCB and maintain a value close to the critical gradient down to the boundary. All models have high density gradients indicative of inhomogeneity in the region. Model B2 fits the oscillation data reasonably well, but has an unjustifiably low S velocity at the MCB. Mitchell and Helmberger (1973) examined details of the velocity distribution near the base of the mantle that are not resolvable using free-oscillation data or travel-times of reflected waves. Their data consisted of long-period S and ScS waves recorded by the WWSSN and the Seismological Service of Canada. They compared amplitude ratios of these phases with the ratios determined from synthetic seismograms generated by the Cagniard-deHoop method for a spherically layered Earth (Gilbert and Helmberger, 1972). They found that the observed amplitude ratios of transversely polarized shear waves ScSHISH exhibited a minimum at a distance of about 68". Synthetic seismograms computed for a Jeffreys-Bullen model and for models with negative linear velocity gradients at the base of the mantle fail to explain this feature. On the other hand, various positive linear velocity gradients above the MCB can explain the amplitude ratio minimum as well as an apparent difference in arrival times of the transversely and radially polarized core reflections ScS. Good agreement between the observed amplitude ratios and those computed cannot, however, be achieved without assigning low Q values to the lower mantle or a small shear velocity to the OC. High-velocity regions between 40 and 70 km thick containing increases of from 0.3 to 0.5 km s - ' above the velocity of a Jeffreys velocity model yield the best explanation to the combined amplitude and differential time data. Mitchell and Helmberger also observed ScS phases that bottom at widely diverse points on the MCB. They concluded that it is likely that a high-velocity zone is widely prevalent at the base of the mantle and may even be a general feature of that region. Lateral variations in this layer could easily account for the scatter in dT/dA measurements at large distances. Such a model is consistent with the proposed core evolution of Anderson and Hanks (1972) (see $2.5) in which silicate material rich in calcium, aluminium and uranium and having high velocities might remain as a residue from the early processes of core formation. The model derived by Mitchell and Helmberger contrasts sharply with diffusion models, in which it is thought that liquid core material has pene-
-
General Physical Properties of the Earth
21
trated great distances into the lower mantle. If such a phenomenon does occur, it must be restricted to a thin layer that remains undetected by the methods they applied. Wright (1973) analysed d T / d A measurements for P and pP phases for 57 earthquakes at distances between 82” and 115” recorded at the Yellowknife array, and found good evidence for regional differences in lower mantle structure that persist to depths greater than 2700 km. There is also a decrease in velocity with increasing depth below 2825 km. Hales and Maki-Lopez (1980) have carried out an analysis of P wave travel times from the Nevada test site using data from 23 explosions between 1966 and 1976. Their results show a scatter they find difficult to account for in terms of anomalies in the upper mantle near the stations. They suggested that at least some part of the scatter arises in the lower mantle as proposed by Dziewonski et al. (1977). Bolt et al. (1970) studied S wave velocities in D” from diffracted S H waves at the MCB for a north-south North American profile from the Iranian earthquake of August 31, 1968. Okal and Geller (1979) criticized their analysis, maintaining that the measurements were affected by the focal mechanism. Bolt and Niazi (1984) showed that the criticisms are unjustified both theoretically and also by comparison with analogous recordings from the Imperial Valley earthquake of October 15, 1979. They also showed that an S H ray parameter estimated from sharp onsets of diffracted S H waves does not represent a shear velocity averaged over a hundred kilometre depth, but rather the velocity within a few tens of kilometres of the MCB. Bolt and Niazi also analysed long-period seismograms for two Tonga earthquakes and obtained new estimates for the SH slowness, i.e. dT/dA variations, indicating no significant average change in S H velocity at the base of the mantle along two easterly profiles 3000km apart under the east Pacific and North America. The average velocity near the MCB is 7.24 km s-’-in agreement with estimates in D” by Mula and Miiller (1980). This latest analysis by Bolt and Niazi indicates a slightly positive SH velocity gradient towards the base of the mantle, but gives no direct information on the gradient just above the boundary. Haddon (1972), in a study of precursors to P K Z K P , suggested that they may be caused by scattering of P K P waves from irregularities near the MCB. In a later paper, Cleary and Haddon (1972) examined this suggestion in more detail and presented additional evidence in its favour. King et al. (1973) obtained measurements of slowness, within P K Z K P precursor wavetrains which they claim provide crucial evidence in favour of scattering near the MCB. The obvious lack of scatter in the higher-order P n K P arrivals observed by a number of authors suggests that lateral inhomogeneities in the lower mantle are the likely source of scattered waves rather than “bumps” on the MCB. Further support to the suggestion that precursors to PKZKP are
22
The Earth’sCore
the result of the scattering of P K P waves by random irregularities near the base of the mantle has been obtained by King et al. (1974) from an analysis of 12 large earthquakes in the distance range 128”-142” from the Warramunga seismic array in northern Australia. In a later, more detailed analysis, Haddon and Cleary (1974) showed that scattering of P K P waves by random irregularities in densities and elastic parameters of about 1% in the bottom 200 km of the mantle is consistent with most of the evidence on precursors to PKZKP including travel-times, slownesses, azimuthal deviations, amplitudes and amplitude variations. Doornbos (1976) investigated lower mantle inhomogeneities from an analysis of precursors observed at NORSAR. He found localized scattering throughout the region extending to at least 600 km above the MCB. The length-scale of his “window” to the lower mantle was restricted to the range 1&30 km. Smaller or larger-scale inhomogeneities are of course possible. Doornbos showed that convection alone cannot account for the anomalies he found and suggested that they may be due either to rigidity or to density anomalies. If the anomalies are in rigidity only, variations of at least 35% are required, implying that partial melting is almost certainly necessary. If the anomalies are in density only, variations of at least 8% are required, implying chemical inhomogeneities. Later Doornbos (1978) investigated whether bumps on the MCB could be the cause of precursors of certain types of core phases rather than inhomogeneities in the lower mantle. He showed that most of the P K P precursors could be accounted for by both a slightly rough MCB (radial variations up to a few hundred metres) and by a slightly heterogeneous lower mantle (relative variations in physical parameters up to a few per cent). The relevant length-scales of the variations are about the same in both mechanisms (1@20 km). Husebye et al. (1976) re-examined the question of the cause of precursors to the core phase P K I K P , also using data from the NORSAR array. Their analysis confirms the earlier suggestion by Haddon (1972) that they arise from the scattering of ordinary P K P waves by small-scale random irregularities on or near the MCB. Since then considerable support for the scattering hypothesis has been received as against other interpretations that require the presence of transition layers between the IC and OC. Muller (1975) showed that discontinuous variations of more than 0.03 km s-’ within the OC would entail observable long-period precursors, which have never been reported. The analysis of Husebye et al. (1976) also shows that the precursor data of Bertrand and Clowes (1974) are fully consistent with the scattering interpretation and do not require the presence of two discontinuous velocity increases in the OC. In almost all studies of wave velocities and densities on both sides of the MCB using amplitudes of PCP, short-period records from earthquakes and
General Physical Properties of the Earth
23
nuclear explosions have been used. Muller et al. (1977) looked at the amplitudes of long-period PcP waves from two South American deep-focus earthquakes recorded by WWNSS and CSN stations in North America in the hope of reducing the scatter in the PcP/P amplitude ratio characteristic of short-period investigations. They found that most of the models derived from short-period observations and characterized by discrete layers above the MCB are inconsistent with the long-period data. The long-period data also do not permit low, non-zero S velocities below the MCB. On the other hand, simple first-order discontinuity models of the MCB, such as the JeffreysBullen model and models based mainly on free-oscillation data, fit the data resonably well. The agreement of observation and theory is improved for negative P velocity gradients above the MCB. However, a good model for the amplitudes of PcP requires so strong negative gradients that it is no longer a good solution for travel-times of PcP. Sacks et a1. (1979) investigated lateral heterogeneity in the velocity structure near the base of the mantle by analysing amplitude ratios of P K P phases. The observed amplitude ratios vary by well over an order of magnitude, but the size of the ratios is correlated with particular regions of the MCB. Sacks et al. interpreted the differences as indicating lateral heterogeneities in the velocity near the MCB. Clark and Pearce (1981) criticized the analysis of Sacks et al., maintaining that the spread in amplitude ratios is attributable to source radiation patterns as well as focusing and de-focusing by the lowermost mantle velocity structure. Sacks and Snoke (1981) agree with Clark and Pearce that source effects contribute to the scatter of the data, but maintain that their conclusion about variable transmission at the base of the mantle is valid. Doornbos and Mondt (1979a) investigated the attenuation of P and S waves diffracted round the core. A comparison of the observed decay spectra of diffracted P and S H waves with theoretical results for a standard Earth model showed characteristic differences. Both the absolute value and the shape of the observed decay spectra differ significantly for P and SH, whereas the theoretical curves for the standard model do not. Moreover, observational and theoretical curves differ significantly for S H at all frequencies and for P at high frequencies. To explain these differences, Doornbos and Mondt considered five possibilities-velocity gradients in the mantle, density and velocity contrasts across the MCB, anelastic damping, scattering by a rough MCB, and scattering by heterogeneity in the mantle above the MCB. In estimating the importance of various model parameters, they used independent information to put constraints on the model. For some parameters the constraints were sufficient to preclude the associated attenuations as an explanation of the observed anomalies. This was the case with the scattering effects of a rough MCB and of irregular structure above it. Other model parameters
24
The Earths Core
where admissible changes have no significant effect on the decay spectra are the density contrast p + / p - and the P velocities V i , V i , at the MCB (the f signs refer to conditions above and below the MCB respectively). Significant effects were obtained by changing the velocity gradients above the MCB, the velocities V:, V,- at the MCB (a finite V,- implies finite core rigidity), and the anelastic damping factor Q. Characteristics of the observed decay spectra are best explained by models with little anelastic damping of P and SH waves, except possibly for the higher frequencies of S H . This precludes a thick low-Q zone at the base of the mantle, although it would be possible for such a low-Q zone to have a significant effect on the higher frequencies of S. In a companion paper, Doornbos and Mondt (1979b) examined P and S waves diffracted around the core and interpreted the data in terms of a transition zone with a linear velocity profile above the MCB. The combined P and S H data sets allow a thickness of the transition zone of 5&100 km with both P and S velocities decreasing with depth (see Table 1.1). Their preferred model has a thickness of 75km with both P and S velocity gradients -0.0019. There is also a suggestion of an additional low-Q zone at the base of the mantle. The physical implications of such a model are an anomalous density gradient and/or a super-adiabatic temperature gradient above the MCB. The total density increase across a 75 km-thick transition layer would be 3%. This could be explained by diffusion of iron-it would inhibit convection in the region. A super-adiabatic gradient of -9" km-' would be needed to explain the model if the transition layer is assumed to be homogeneous.* Doornbos and Mondt caution that their numerical estimates with regard to density and temperature should be regarded only as rough estimates since the seismic parameters are very sensitive to small changes in the model and values of the thermodynamic parameters are not known very precisely. The early papers on seismic waves scattered on or near the MCB were all related to observations of forward-scattering, where the scattering occurred at entry to, or exit from, the core; from the observations it is not clear whether the scattering occurred at the MCB or in the heterogeneous lower mantle. Chang and Cleary (1978) used P K K P data from Novaya Zemlya explosions recorded at LASA and showed that the back-scattering probably exists also in the form of PK(KP). Since back-scattering does not occur in the lower mantle but at or near the point of underside reflection at the MCB, these data give strong support to the idea that seismic wave scattering occurs on the MCB. In a later paper Chang and Cleary (1981) analysed the same data and
-
-
* Jones (1977) suggested that long-term variations in the frequency of reversals of the Earth's magnetic field may reflect the response of the core to fluctuating temperatures at the MCB. He estimated a temperature gradient of 12"km- across D (see 54.5). Zharkov et al. (1985) made a similar suggestion.
-
TABLE 1 .I Velocity models of the lower mantle for the PEMC madel (Dziewonski et a/. 1975) together with five different perturbations for the base of the mantle (PEMC-LO1,. . ., PEMC-105). (After Doornbosand Mondt 1979b.).
PEM-C
PEMC-LO1
PEMC - LO3
PEMC-LO2
Radius (km) ~
3700 361 0 7 3585 7 3560 7 3485 7
VP
vs
(km/s) -13524 13612 13636 13661 13732
VP
vs
(km 1s)
7169 7200 7209 7218 7243
PEMC- LO5
PEMC-LO4 -
..____.
V.7
VP
(km/s)
VP
vs
13524
7169
13.524
7.169
13661 1 3 519
7218 7076
13.661 13.617
7.218 7 076
VP
vs ( k mIs 1
(km/s) 13.524
7.169
13.636
7.209
13.609
7.067
VP
vs
(km/s)
13.524 13.612
7.169 7.200
13 606
7.060
13.524
7.169
13.661 13.557
7.218 7.130
26
The Earth’s Core
concluded that the observations also require lateral variations in the topography of the MCB and a region of relatively large topography responsible for the anomalous P K K P signals. Doornbos (1980) analysed data of precursors to P K K P observed at NORSAR from several source regions. Following the suggestion of Chang and Cleary (1978) that such signals may be due to back scattering at the MCB, he found that his data implied a rough MCB-with small-scale radial variations of 100-200m, although in some regions the MCB appears to be much smoother. Chang and Cleary (1978,1981) in their analysis of the LASA data suggested that much larger topography may exist in the region of the MCB they sampled. Doornbos pointed out that even small undulations of the MCB may be significant. For finite viscosity q of the mantle, such undulations would tend to be smoothed out. Taking q 10” poise (Cathles, 1975) leads to a decay time of lo5 years, which is small compared with the age of the core. Thus if this estimate of q is correct, the undulations at the MCB must be dynamically produced. Mula (1981) carried out a frequency and time-domain analysis of longperiod P and S waves diffracted round the core observed at WWNSS and CSN stations in order to confirm earlier conclusions (Mula and Muller, 1980) about velocities at the bottom of the mantle that were based on ray parameters. Combining the results from these two investigations, Mula found that models for the base of the mantle with either strongly negative or strongly positive gradients are not acceptable. The only model that satisfied all the data is one with a slightly positive gradient; a slightly negative gradient is possible but unlikely. Mula thus reaffirmed the earlier conclusion that velocities at the base of the mantle increase slowly with depth, implying that there is no significant departure from adiabatic or homogeneous conditions. Thus non-adiabatic gradients, as demanded by a thermal boundary layer as suggested by some authors (e.g. Jones, 1977; Jeanloz and Richter, 1979), are not supported by Mula’s studies. In addition, an extremely-low-Q zone at the base of the mantle is not indicated, Qp being at least greater than 250. Ruff and Helmberger (1982) used the amplitudes of short-period P and diffracted P waves to investigate the internal structure of D”. They used data from Soviet underground nuclear explosions recorded at North American WWSSN stations and synthetic seismograms to test various Earth models and showed that the amplitudes from smooth D” models with a small velocity gradient in D” decay too slowly in the shadow zone. This cannot be explained by random forward-scattering or by a thin low-Q layer within D”. All the features of the observed amplitude profile can be explained as interference effects of a model that has a low-velocity zone in the upper part of D” and a normal velocity gradient in the lower part of D”. The favoured models imply a compositional change and/or a phase change at the top of D” and do
-
-
General Physical Properties of the Earth
27
not allow D" to be interpreted as a single thermal boundary layer between the mantle and core. Ruff and Helmberger suggest that the low-velocity channel could be a double thermal boundary layer with very thin boundary layers if there is sufficient heat flux from the core. However, the existence of a thermal boundary layer at the top of D" does not remove the necessity for compositional stratification. Doornbos (1983) used new long- and short-period diffraction data from the SRO network and from NORSAR in an attempt to settle the question of whether there is a boundary layer at the base of the mantle. Figure 1.1 1 shows three velocity models and two different interpretations of the combined P and S velocity profiles; as a density effect and as a temperature effect. The density profiles assume an adiabatic but possibly chemically inhomogeneous medium, and the temperature profiles assume a chemically homogeneous medium but possibly non-adiabatic conditions. Doornbos concluded from his analysis that the data could best be explained by a relatively thin (< 100 km) low-velocity zone at the base of the mantle, consistent with a thermal boundary layer. Some individual short-period P wave studies from geographically limited regions cannot be explained by this model unless lateral variations also exist. Lateral variations are, however, not in conflict with boundary layer models. Lay and Helmberger (1983a,b) carried out a detailed study of SH phases that traverse the lower mantle. The data show a consistent S H arrival not predicted by smoothly varying gross Earth models. A lower mantle S wave triplication was also found in the distance range 70"-95". Modelling of the observations with synthetic seismograms indicated that the triplication is caused by a roughly 2.75% increase in the shear velocity about 280 km above the MCB. There also appear to be lateral variations in the depth of such a discontinuity of some 4G50 km on a global scale. Lay and Helmberger concluded that the interpretation of the D" region as a thermal boundary layer with diminished velocity gradients caused by a super-adiabatic thermal gradient is inadequate to explain the data, and proposed a new model for the depth dependence of the S wave velocity in the lowermost 400-500 km of the mantle. The main feature of their model is a velocity increase of 2.5-3% across a narrow zone 25G300 km above the MCB, i.e. approximately at the top of the D" layer. Their model predicts pronounced pulse-form changes of longperiod S H body waves in the epicentral distance range 95"-120", a range not studied by them. Schlittenhardt et al. (1985) examined nine long-period seismograms of S H and P waves from deep-focus earthquakes below Fiji, West Brazil, the Sea of Japan, the Sea of Okhotsk and the Banda Sea, and found practically no indication of the predicted changes. They thus rejected Lay and Helmberger's model and suggested that the changes in pulse form that Lay and Helmberger observed at distances from 70°-800, and inter-
28
The Earth's Core
-
I
1
13.7{
L1
PREM
/
13.5
A
I
4000 -
I
3800
3700
3600
3500
Radius (km) Fig. 1.11. Models of P and S velocity V,, VS, density p, and temperature T i n the lower mantle. The super-adiabatic temperature profiles of PREM and L1 correspond to a homogeneous density (PEM profile), and the inhomogeneous density profiles correspond to the adiabatic temperature of PEM Absolute temperatures have been arbitrarily fixed. (After Doornbos, 1983.)
preted as reflections from their proposed discontinuity, must arise from a different cause. In PREM (see §1.7), the layer D" is 150 km thick, in which the pressure derivative of the bulk modulus, dkldp, has an anomalously low value of 1.64 as compared with an average of 3.2 for the overlying mantle. Since PREM
-
29
General Physical Properties of the Earth
shows no accompanying change in density or density gradient, Stacey and Loper (1983) identify D” as a thermal boundary layer and not as a chemically distinct zone. Although there is still controversy about compositional gradients, they maintain that the existence of a thermal boundary layer at the base of the mantle is necessary for the transfer of heat from the core through the mantle-a significant heat flux from the core is implied by any geodynamo mechanism (see $4.6). Using data on dk,/dp in D” from the PREM model and thermodynamic identities, Stacey and Loper concluded that the temperature increase across D” is 840 K. Such a layer cannot be a static feature, but must be maintained by a downward motion of lower mantle material towards the MCB with a strong horizontal flow near the bottom of D” confined to a layer at its base. Assuming a core heat flux of 1.6 x 10” W, they estimated the speed of the downward motion to be -0.07 mm y- and the thickness of the layer of horizontal flow at the base of the mantle a scale height of 11 km, much thinner than the thermal scale height (73 km). The thermal gradient at the base of the mantle is -9.6 K km-’ in fairly good agreement with that of Jones (1977) but considerably less than that implied from seismic studies of D” by Cleary (1974) and Doornbos and Mondt (1979b). Zharkov et al. (1985) investigated the convective stability of D”. They showed that it depends mainly on the value of the viscosity vMCB of the mantle at the MCB. D” is stable when v M ~ BN 10” poise and unstable when vMcBN 10’’ poise. They suggest that the thermal regime of D is not stationary. Relatively quiet long periods, when heat is transferred by conduction, end with the formation of a hot, locally unstable, layer (or spots) at the bottom of the mantle. This is followed by a comparatively short period during which the hot unstable layer disintegrates. Christensen (1984) has carried out a series of two-dimensional numerical model calculations to investigate the instability of a hot, low-viscosity boundary layer at the base of the mantle. The layer grows by thermal diffusion and becomes unstable, eventually leading to the formation and ascent of thermal plumes. When the temperature-induced viscosity contrast is as large as lo4, small-scale convection confined to the boundary layer precedes the ejection of a plume. The rise of the diapir is essentially controlled by the background viscosity and is slower than the rapid amplification of an instability inside the boundary layer. The application of Christensen’s results to the Earth is hampered by the idealization of the models and of the uncertain values of the parameters. In order to limit the heat flow from the core to a reasonable value, the lower mantle viscosity must be at least loz3poise when the temperature drop in the D” layer is of the order of 1000 K. This is larger than values derived from the analysis of post-glacial rebound (Sabadini and Peltier, 1981). The structure of the D” layer is still in doubt. A thermal boundary layer
-
’,
-
30
The Earth’s Core
seems to be necessary to provide a significant heat flux from the core demanded by any geodynamo mechanism. O n the other hand, a composition change in addition cannot be ruled out. A detailed account of the structure of the core and lower mantle has been given by Loper (1984). Seismological studies of lateral heterogeneity have determined the longestwavelength components of seismic velocity variations in the lower mantle (Dziewonski et al., 1977; Dziewonski, 1984). These velocity variations would be expected to be proportional to density variations if both were the result of temperature differences associated with mantle convection. However, the inferred density variations are negatively correlated with the geoid. This may be explained by counteracting effects of dynamically supported surface deformations in the gravity field, for example hot upwellings in the mantle cause uplift of the Earth’s surface and of the MCB. This dynamically maintained topography has a strong effect on the gravity field. Richards and Hager (1984) have shown that for a given density structure, the total gravity field depends on the viscosity structure and on the presence or absence of chemical stratification in the mantle. Hager et al. (1985) later showed that the longestwavelength components of the residual geoid can be predicted from the seismically determined density contrasts in the lower mantle using dynamic response functions for mantle convection with a moderate increase in viscosity with depth. They obtained long-wavelength temperature differences of the order of 20 K with hot lower mantle underlying hotspots at the Earth’s surface. The deformation of the MCB is 3 km.*
-
1.4 Free Oscillations of the Earth
When any part of a deformable body like the Earth is in motion, it may be regarded as either a vibrating system with an indefinite number of degrees of freedom or as a medium transmitting waves. Seismic wave theory regards the associated Earth motions as travelling disturbances affecting only a relatively small part of the Earth’s volume at any given time. Oscillation theory, on the other hand, regards the motions as normal modes of oscillation, the principal ones of which affect a relatively large fraction of the Earth’s volume at any instant. The wave theory approach is usually more appropriate for shorter periods (less than about 3 minutes), the oscillation approach for longer * A special issue of Geophysical Research Letters (Volume 13, No. 12) was published in December 1986 to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the discovery of the inner core by Inge Lehmann. The issue is devoted entirely to the geophysics of the core and core-mantle boundary and contains a number of papers on the structrure of the D layer. From an analysis of PKP phases, some authors suggest that a significant fraction of the hererogeneity at the MCB may actually reside in the fluid OC.
31
General Physical Properties of the Earth
periods. The relatively late application of free Earth oscillation theory is due to the fact that only recently could instruments record ground motions with periods greater than about 3 minutes. Free Earth oscillations were first observed in 1952, although it was not until the great Chilean earthquake of May 22, 1960, that improved instrumentation enabled detailed measurements to be made-additional results were obtained from the great Alaska earthquake of March 28, 1964. Although the free oscillations of a uniform elastic sphere were first investigated more than a hundred years ago, calculations for realistic Earth models taking into account detailed structure, gravitational forces and rotation were not undertaken until fairly recently (see e.g. Alterman et al., 1959). Such calculations would have been impossible without the aid of modern computers. The free oscillations excited by a major earthquake last for several days, but their amplitude diminishes because the Earth is not a perfectly elastic body. If spectra are computed for successive time intervals following the excitation, the damping of each mode can be determined and information on the anelasticity of the Earth's interior obtained. From an analysis of the normal modes from 84 recordings of the Alaska earthquake of March 1964, Dziewonski and Gilbert (1971,1972) concluded that the IC of the Earth must be solid. There are two main classes of oscillations. The first class are called torsional (or toroidal) oscillations-the dilatation is everywhere zero and there is no radial component of displacement. Since the dilatation is zero, torsional oscillations cause no disturbances in density and hence no disturbances in the gravitational field. Thus, instruments designed to measure small fluctuations in gravity cannot record torsional oscillations, although spheroidal oscillations may be detected. Spheroidal oscillations are coupled oscillations and involve radial displacements as well as torsional motions. The deformation of the Earth's surface is best described by spherical harmonic functions P r (cos where P," (cos 0) are the associated Legendre functions and 8,4 the co-latitude and longitude. Each class of vibration is characterized by the order m and degree n of the spherical harmonic involved and by the number of nodal surfaces in the radial direction. It has become general pracfor the spheroidal and tice to specify oscillations by the symbols l S r and toroidal types respectively, the subscript 1 indicating the number of nodal surfaces. The superscript m is dropped when there is no longitude dependence.* For the lowest values of n, the fundamental free Earth oscillation periods are determined predominantly by the properties of the Earth's deeper interior. For these values of n, the effect of lateral variations in the properties of the
$):I$
lr
* In much of the literature on the free oscillations of the Earth these symbols are written &" and .TY with the subscripts ( I , n) interchanged. We have, however, preserved the more common notation P y (cos 0) for the associated Legendre functions and use I to indicate the number of nodal surfaces.
32
The Earfhs Core
Earth on oscillation periods are negligible. For higher values of n, the periods become increasingly influenced by properties nearer the surface of the Earth, where lateral variations may be more significant. The fundamental spheroidal oscillation oSois an alternating compression and rarefaction of the whole Earth. There are an infinite series of overtones *So with spherical nodal surfaces within the Earth. The case n = 1 is precluded-it represents a net translation of the surface and hence of the centre of gravity and would require the application of an external force. oS2 represents the “football” mode. There are two nodal parallels of latitude dividing the surface into three zones. As the sphere oscillates, it is distorted alternately into an oblate and prolate spheroid. Spheroidal modes oS3, o S 4 . .. are motions with an increasing number of subdivided zonal distributionseach of these modes also has overtones with internal nodal surfaces. For torsional oscillations, there is no solution for n = 0. The case oT, is precluded. It implies a variation in the rate of rotation of the whole Earth, concentric shells within the Earth executing small rigid body rotations about the polar axis. The simplest torsional mode is oT2-in this case there is a nodal line for displacement around the equator, the two hemispheres oscillating in anti-phase. Higher modes arise from subdivisions of the Earth into 3,4 . . . zones with opposite motions. There are also overtones with internal nodal surfaces. For Earth models that are spherically symmetric and non-rotating, it is not necessary to include the parameter m-the oscillations may be described using only the two parameters ( I , n). For a rotating body it is necessary to include m. Travelling waves are set up where wavefronts are diametral planes containing the polar axis and revolving about it, either east-west or west-east depending on the sign of m. The longest free Earth oscillation periods (- 1 hour) are small compared with the axial rotation period (1 day). The effect of axial rotation is thus small. When it can be neglected, then for any value of m, the above east-west and west-east waves combine to produce standing waves (which are in reality oscillations) in which the frequency is independent of the value of m. Thus, an effect of axial rotation is to cause “split modes”, i.e. a small separation of a single mode into two or more distinct modes with slightly different periods. Backus and Gilbert (1961) showed that axial rotation causes the nodal pattern to drift westward round the Earth’s axis with angular speed equal to the frequency difference between successive members of the split mode. The Earth’s ellipticity contributes further to the splitting of modes. The records of free Earth oscillations show that the lowest frequency modes often appear as a number of closely spaced lines in the spectrum. Pekeris et at. (1961) suggested that this might be due to the rotation of the Earth splitting any mode having a longitude ( m ) dependence into a number of
33
General Physical Properties of the Earth
frequencies. They coined the term “terrestrial spectroscopy” for the study of free oscillation spectra, pointing out that the observed splitting of certain lines due to the Earth’s rotation is a mechanical analogue of the Zeeman splitting of lines of atomic spectra by a magnetic field. Smith (1974) obtained the equations of motion for a rotating, slightly elliptical, self-gravitating Earth, and later (1976) used them to generate numerical normal-mode eigensohtions for translational oscillations of the solid IC. Both he and Busse (1974) also pointed out the severe theoretical shortcomings of an earlier dynamic model of Won and Kuo (1973). Smith’s results show the profound influence of the Earth’s steady rotation, particularly on motions in the fluid OC. The variation of eigenfrequencies with core structure shows how stable (or unstable) stratification in the OC acts to increase (or decrease) the associated eigenfrequencies. O n the other hand, compressibility, as opposed to stratification, in the fluid OC is of little significance, but IC elasticity has a very significant effect. While convective circulation is not possible in a core that is everywhere sub-adiabatic, very-long-period gravitational oscillations (undertones) are possible. Because the gravitational restoring forces of a sub-adiabatic core are weak compared to the elastic restoring forces of free oscillations, the periods of vibration exceed the gravest free-oscillation periods. Although most freeoscillation spectra show prominent energy peaks at periods longer than the gravest elastic oscillation (53.8 min.), only recently have attempts been made to compute the expected periods. The first investigation was by Pekeris and Accad (1972). They ignored the Coriolis force and Smylie (1973) has since shown that this can have a significant effect on the periods. In his investigation, Smylie neglected the main magnetic field and assumed the liquid core to behave as an ideal fluid and calculated the undertones of the mode Si (azimuthal number m = 2, degree n = 2). Table 1.2 and Fig. 1.12 compare his TABLE 1.2 Gravitational undertone periods of S: in hours. (After Smylie, 1973.) Radial order
0’ 1 2 3 4 5 6
Pekeris and Accad (1972)
0.89583 7.3515 11.6735 16.0187 20.2618 24 3077
-
Coriolis-freet
0.89744 7.4524 12.4716 17.5474 22.3871 26.8703 -
Actual period
0.87125 6.7598 10.5285 13.8070 16.4970 18.6584 20.3377
* This is the gravest mode of vibration of the Earth.
t These periods differ from those of Pekeris and Accad (1972),presumably because of the presence of the solid inner core in the Earth model used in Smylie‘s study.
34
The Earths Core
35 I 30
1
1
z a
15
I
I
1
I
UNDERTONE EIGENPERIODS OF
2 25 3 0 I 20
I
I
I
1
1
Si MODE
-
WITH INNER CORE
WITHOUT INNER CORE
-
-4H-
-
-
INNER CORE AND CORlOLlS FORCE
3
0
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
UNDERTONE NUMBER Fig. 1.12. Dispersion relations for undertone eigenperiods of S: mode. The results for the Earth model without a solid IC are taken from Pekeris and Accad (1 972). (After Smylie, 1973.)
results (for different radial orders) with those of Pekeris and Accad, and show how the periods of the normal modes of a stable core are substantially reduced by rotation. These periods calculated by Pekeris and Accad neglecting rotation extend to infinity but become compressed to less than 1.5 days when rotation is included. In his analysis, Smylie (1974) considered the displacement field to be composed of purely spheroidal harmonics. Although torsional motion cannot exist independently in an inviscid fluid, torsional modes of oscillation can be excited when rotation is present. Crossley (1975) expanded the displacement field into both spheroidal and torsional components. He found that the periods of the undertones were considerably modified by rotation, which serves to couple together modes by the excitation of torsional motion. The undertones are confined within the period range 0-12 hours. Smylie has installed a specially designed gravimeter of extremely high sensitivity to try to detect possible core undertones, so far without success. Detection of such undertones (for which gravitation alone provides the restoring force) would constitute decisive evidence for stable stratification of the core and have far-reaching implications for geomagnetism and the thermal history of the Earth (See g4.6 and 3.8). Melchior and Ducarme (1985) have since installed a superconducting
35
General Physical Properties of the Earth
gravimeter at the Royal Observatory of Belgium in Brussels to try to detect inertial gravity oscillations in the Earth’s core. Such a gravimeter has a noise level 100 times less than that of a spring gravimeter. The superconducting gravimeter in Brussels has been recording without interruption since May 1981. After removing atmospheric pressure and polar motion effects, Melchior and Ducarme found spectral peaks of 1&15 nanogal around a period of 13.9 h which were enhanced immediately after two deep-focus earthquakes of magnitude 7.2. Crossley and Rochester (1980) had found a number of possible eigenperiods for a non-rotating Earth, including one at 13.458 h and one at 13.383 h. Friedlander (1985) showed that the effect of compressibility can produce a small shift in the frequency locations, although Crossley (1984) pointed out that in a rotating Earth the spectrum around 12 h is likely to be very dense and perhaps continuous (because of line broadening). The gravitational stability of the liquid core bears a direct relationship to the Adams-Williamson equation (1.10), which will be obtained later. If a fluid element is suddenly displaced radially by an amount Sr it suffers an adiabatic expansion and its density decreases by an amount equal to its initial density multiplied by its dilation, i.e.
where ( p o , go) are the equilibrium density and gravity and k, is the incompressibility. The displaced fluid element finds itself among neighbouring elements whose density is less than its initial density by the amount - (dpo/dr) Sr. The excess density of the displaced fluid element is thus
where P(r) = 1
dP0 +2 S O P 0 dr ks
a dimensionless factor originally introduced by Pekeris and Accad. It is clear that if P(r) < 0 everywhere, the liquid core is gravitationally stable (the restoring force is positive); if p(r) = 0, it is neutrally stable and if P(r) > 0 everywhere the core is gravitationally unstable. It should be noted that if the Adams-Williamson equation holds, i.e. if p ( r ) = 0, the liquid core is neutrally stable. Smylie showed that in the static case for spheroidal displacements of degree n 2 1, either the core must deform in such a way that the individual fluid elements, though displaced, suffer no dilatation, or the equilibrium density in
36
The Earths Core
the core must satisfy the Adams-Williamson equation. Smylie and Mansinha (1971) had earlier pointed out that, for fluids in static equilibrium, equipotential, isobaric and isopycnic (i.e. equal density) surfaces are parallel and that individual fluid elements may be displaced on such surfaces without resistance. Fluid elements are free to move aside on such surfaces to permit penetration of the solid IC and mantle into the liquid OC. Moreover, such surfaces not only remain parallel but are carried radially with the fluid element. There has been much confusion in the literature on the proper boundary conditions for the motions coupling the mantle with the liquid core, and different authors have come to different conclusions. Wunsch (1974) has shown that the essential difficulties and most of the physical phenomena can be reproduced in a much simplified model-the deformation in the static limit of an elastic half-space overlying a liquid half-space. He showed that, as is often the case in fluid dynamical problems, the problem is one of singular perturbation which leads to paradoxes if not handled correctly. Wunsch showed that in the case of the coupling of the motion of an elastic mantle to a stratified fluid core, the static limit is singular in a perfect fluid and can lead to physically meaningless results. Including rotation, however, makes the static limit a regular one, since Coriolis forces can support the deformed isopycnic surfaces in a steady flow. In a later paper (1975), Wunsch extended his analyses to include the effects of viscosity and density diffusion, and showed that paradoxes and contradictions that arise by treating only perfect fluids may be resolved by taking dissipation into account. Wunsch also considered the effect of a large ambient magnetic field-depending upon its orientation, its effect is similar to that of stratification or rotation. In particular, a toroidal field introduces a static limit singularity similar to that of density stratification. When a non-rotating spherical Earth model is used (Alterman et al., 1959), each spheroidal and toroidal component can be separated and the solution of the dynamic equation of equilibrium presents no major problems. Once rotation and ellipticity are taken into account, however, the spheroidal and toroidal fields become infinitely coupled (Smith, 1974; Shen and Mansinha, 1976). To circumvent the problem of infinite coupling, the effects of rotation and ellipticity can be considered as perturbations to a spherical, non-rotating Earth. This is feasible when the frequencies of the normal modes are much greater than the diurnal frequency. For elastic oscillations with periods of less than a sidereal hour, adequate results can be obtained with a first-order perturbation approximation (e.g. Backus and Gilbert, 1961; Pekeris et al., 1961; Dahlen, 1968; Luh, 1974). The approach fails, however, when long-period oscillations such as those confined mainly to the liquid OC are considered. Because the eigenperiods for these oscillations are comparable to or greater
37
General Physical Properties of the Earth
than the diurnal period, the full effects of rotation, and in some cases of ellipticity, must be taken into account. We then have an infinitely coupled system of ordinary differential equations. Traditionally, solutions of this system have been attempted by straightforward numerical integration (e.g. Smylie, 1974; Crossley, 1975; Shen and Mansinha, 1976; Johnson and Smylie, 1977; Crossley and Rochester, 1980). This approach, however, runs into the unavoidable problem of having to truncate the coupling chain severely and it is also difficult to interpret the numerical results. Shen (1983) has shown that by invoking appropriate approximations, analytic solutions can be developed for free oscillation of the Earth’s fluid OC. Crossley and Rochester (1980) attempted to justify certain approximations to their Earth model which permit more terms to be included in the expansion without increasing computer time. By considering simplified models of the Earth’s core they showed that, at least for the case of a non-rotating Earth, the effects of mantle structure and boundary rigidity on the undertone periods are minimal. Further, the combined effects of core compressibility and self-gravitation in a real Earth model can, to a good approximation, be replaced by a single parameter, the Brunt-Vaisala buoyancy frequency N.* Applying these simplifications to a rotating Earth model, Crossley and Rochester solved the resulting equations of motion with a longer coupling chain than any used previously. This approach, based on the chain beginning with the spheroidal term S;, supports the hypothesis that the periods of core undertones for a realistic rotating Earth model are crowded into a narrow band around 12 h. A different approach has been taken by Johnson and Smylie (1977) who used a variational procedure and considerable computational manipulation to include three spheroidal terms in the displacement field throughout the Earth. Figure 1.13 shows their results for the periods of the first few undertones of the spheroidal chain of azimuthal number two compared with earlier results obtained by direct integration. Moon (1982) has also used a variational procedure to derive seismic free oscillations and core modes for a rotating, slightly elliptical Earth model. He obtained numerical solutions for two Earth models (1066B and B156) minimizing the energy functionals for the terrestrial spectral range longer than the lowest-order free oscillation. For model B156, with stably stratified OC, the periods of core modes range from about 4-13 h with most of the modes crowded around periods of 6 h and 12 h. (Crossley and Rochester (1980) had shown that the periods for B156 are expected to be limited to the range * N is defined by the equation N2 =
-gdP-&
P d.r k, If the fluid is incompressible, the second term vanishes.
38
The Earths Core
24
0
t
I
2
3
I
1
1
4
5
6
UNDERTONE ORDER Fig. 1.13. Periods of the first few undertones of the spheroidal chain of azimuthal number 2. The curves show the effect of successive truncations. The case of no rotational coupling is due to Pekeris and Accad (1972) as modified by Smylie (1 974) to include a solid IC; the self-coupling case is due to Smylie (1974). who considered only rotational coupling of the first member of the spheroidal chain back on itself; coupling to T: was considered by Crossley (1975) in a direct integration of the equations of motion; and the case of coupling up to and including T; is due to Johnson and Smylie (1977). After Johnson and Smylie, 1977.)
between 6 and 12 h.) The core-mode periods for model 1066B are much more spread out without clustering around periods of 6 h and 12 h. Moon concluded that an Earth model can support long-period oscillations even when it is not stably stratified. According to the nature of the fluid motions and the primary driving force, free oscillations of the Earth’s core may be divided into two classes: gravitational oscillations and inertial oscillations. Gravitational oscillations are those that arise from density stratification in the core and are characterized by fluid flows in which the pressure variation due to compression is approxi-
General Physical Properties of the Earth
39
mately balanced by that due to transport (Shen, 1978; Smylie and Rochester, 1981). Inertial oscillations, on the other hand, are characterized by a predominantly solenoidal flow in the fluid and result from the rotation of the Earth (Greenspan, 1968). Shen (1983) argued that the equation of motion for inertial oscillations of the Earth’s core is identical in form to that of a nongravitating, homogeneous, incompressible fluid, density stratification coming in only when the change in gravitational potential is taken into account. Thus, the existence of inertial oscillations is independent of the density stratification in the liquid OC, in disagreement with the findings of Olson (1977) and Smylie and Rochester (1981). However, Shen agrees with Smylie and Rochester that the flow will be non-solenoidal for gravitational oscillations of the O C (undertones) in which density stratification is the principal governing factor. Smylie and Rochester showed that for sufficiently small (subacoustic) frequencies, an approximation that neglects the effect of flow pressure on the density is valid (they called this the “sub-seismic approximation”). This leads to a second-order partial differential equation in a single scalar variable, a great simplification from the original fourth-order partial differential vector equation. The validity of the sub-seismic approximation was first shown by Pekeris and Accad (1972) for gravitational oscillations of a fluid core in a non-rotating Earth using explicit solutions, and by Smylie and Rochester (1981) for a rotating Earth using scaling analysis. Shen (1983) showed that, despite Coriolis coupling, the sub-seismic equation can still be solved analytically for some core models. In a non-rotating Earth, gravitational oscillations are possible only for a stably stratified fluid core (Pekeris and Accad 1972). Shen showed, however, that with rotation gravitational oscillations become possible for any density stratification in the OC, the eigenfrequencies being divided into alternating allowed and forbidden zones. Furthermore, in each allowed zone, there exist an infinite number of such normal modes with their eigenfrequencies approaching asymptotically the eigenfrequency of a corresponding inertial oscillation. Both the solenoidal flow approximation (for inertial oscillations) and the sub-seismic approximation (for gravitational oscillations) ignore the fluid flow arising from variations in gravitational potential. Shen developed an asymptotic formulation to allow for this as well as taking into account deformation of the solid part of the Earth. He showed that the eigenfrequencies can be determined without explicitly solving for the correction terms.
1.5 Attenuation in the Earth
Most models based on free-oscillation periods assume that the elastic proper-
40
The Earth’s Core
ties of the Earth are independent of frequency. It is well known that absorption decreases the intrinsic elastic properties and causes velocity dispersion (Zener, 1948). This means that laboratory, body wave, surface wave, and freeoscillation data cannot be directly compared unless the absorptiondispersion correction is applied. The effect of absorption on free oscillation periods was initially ignored, however. Serious discrepancies were found with body wave results, which were attributed to a “baseline” effect, a presumed difference between the average Earth and that sampled by body wave data. Later, the effects of absorption on dispersion were re-examined and found to be of the first-order as Jeffreys (1965) had all along maintained, and not second-order as was initially assumed. The damping of free oscillations changes, for example, the eigenfrequencies of oT2 and oSz by about 0.5 and 0.25% (13 and 8 s) respectively (Randall, 1976; Hart et al., 1977). Jeffreys (1967) pointed out that for any form of imperfection of elasticity, except elasticoviscosity, there must be a systematic lengthening of free periods that may be about one part in 160. Thus, Earth models obtained by inversion of uncorrected normal mode data will yield lower velocities than models based on body wave data. The method for correcting seismic data has been given by Liu et al. (1976) and consistent Earth models have been determined by Hart et al. (1976). The physical dispersion accompanying absorption also complicates comparisons of laboratory and seismic data since they are taken at quite different frequencies. This must be taken into account in attempting to infer the composition of the Earth by comparing laboratory and seismic data. A large number of body wave observations are consistent with a low-Q zone at the bottom of the mantle.* Mikumo and Kurita (1968) estimated a 300-km thick layer at the base with QP 100. Teng (1968) determined the variation of Q with depth from the spectra of P phases from deep earthquakes. His data indicate a 200-km thick zone with QP 200. The observed amplitude ratios of ScS/S of Mitchell and Helmberger (1973) can be interpreted in terms of a thin low-Q zone (approximately 150 km thick with Qs about 100). The amplitudes of grazing P K P phases (Sacks and Snoke, 1976) also indicate a low-Q zone at the base of the mantle, Kuster (1972) proposed a low-Q zone (QP = 300, thickness 150 km) on the basis of P K P and P K K P spectral amplitude ratios. Berzon, et al. (1974) estimated the attenuation parameter QP in the mantle based on changes in the form of P-wave amplitude spectra as a function of distance. They used two independent sets of data from narrow-band and wide-band seismometers. They found the average value of QP in the depth in-
-
-
* Q has already been defined on page 16. Q for P waves is denoted by QP and for S waves by Q-in some papers by Q,. Often the subscript is omitted if there is no confusion about which Q is being discussed.
41
General Physical Properties of the Earth
TABLE 1.3 Comparison of Qpvalues in the upper and lower mantle. (After Berzon etal., 1974.)
0,according to: Depth interval (km)
Velocity Values used (krns-’)
Berzon eta/. (1974)
Anderson
~- et al.
lstset
2ndset
100-760
9.04
760-2900
12.48
710 k 150 + 730 1330- 360 1200:
100-2900
11.45
+ 420 1080- 285
0-100 0-760
7.62 8.91
0-2900
11.29
220 5 3 0 k 150 + 420 845 - 260
,”7”,”
(1965)
Kanamori (1967a) (1967b)
380
165
3210
1210
990
420
230 345
100 150
850
375
0-900 900-2900
410-630
Mikumo and Kurita (1968) M-5 M-14
1690
4900
120
274
292
702
180-240 1600-6000
terval 100-760 km to be 710 and in the interval 76@2900 km to be between 1200 and 1330. Table 1.3 compares their values with those obtained by other investigators using different methods. The differences are most likely due to the different data used (particularly the different frequency ranges) and the methods of analysis. Canas and Bolt (1983) showed that the ratio of the observed amplitudes of PcP and PcS phases at a station from the same earthquake is directly related to the density ratio at the MCB and the average attenuation parameter Qs for the mantle. Later Bolt and Canas (1985) obtained clear wave pulses at Berkeley and Jamestown for three earthquakes giving reflections at the MCB under both continental and oceanic areas. Comparison with plausible Earth models confirms a density jump at the MCB of 1.7. The average mantle Qsvalues under continental and oceanic regions are 705 f 365 and 585 ? 305, giving a mean of 650 k 335, in general agreement with results from surface waves. Agreement between observations and theoretical models is best if it is assumed that Qs increases with frequency o as oawhere c1 also increases with frequency. The Q of the O C is extremely high. High-frequency PnKP phases ( P K P , P K K P , P K K K P , etc.) travel with little change in shape or amplitude for long distances. Cormier and Richards (1976) concluded that QP in the OC is at least lo4 and probably much higher. A high Q for the O C is also supported by studies by Buchbinder (1971), Sacks (1971a, 1972), Adams (1972), Miiller (1973) and Qamar and Eisenberg (1974). Most of these studies infer a Q greater than 4000. It must be pointed out, however, that part of these differences in Q-values may be due to differences in the period ranges upon which
-
42
The Earths Core
the estimates were based. Qamar and Eisenberg’s investigation used spectral ratios of seismic core waves. For seismic waves of frequencyf2 1 Hz they found a high value of Q( 2 5000) in the OC. This was based on the fact that PnKP phases were observed for large values of n (at least n = 7): the P7KP/ P4KP ratios suggest a Q in the range 400CL8000, while the average slope of the P7KPIP4KP spectral ratio yields Q 11 10,000. Qamar and Eisenberg’s analysis, which assumed the applicability of classical ray theory and plane wave reflection coefficients, could not explain the observation that P7KP has consistently greater high-frequency content than P4KP. They suggested that frequency dependence of the MCB reflectiontransmission coefficients (Richards, 1973) may be important even in the highfrequency range of their study (0.2-2.0 Hz). Cormier and Richards (1976) later showed that this was in fact the case, and put a lower bound to Q in the oc of 10,000. There have been a number of body wave measurements of dissipation in the IC. Buchbinder (1971), using P K P amplitude ratios, found an average value of Q in the IC of about 400. Spectral ratios of IC and OC phases (Sacks, 1971b) indicate an average value of Q in the IC of 600. Sacks’ data suggest that QP is not constant through the IC but ranges from 100 to 200 in the outer 300 km to 1000 at greater depths. Kuster (1972) found a value of 300 for QP from spectral ratios of core phases. Julian et al. (1972) estimated that Q, in the IC is between 500 and 1000. A high value for Q, in this region is also implied by the fact that IC shear modes (e.g. 2S2) are observed (Buland and Gilbert, 1978). The Q of 2 S 2 implies a Q, for the IC of about 550. For the outer 450 km of the IC, Qamar and Eisenberg (1974) using the P K I K P I P K P ratio, obtained a value of Q in the range 120-1400, more than an order of magnitude less than that in the OC. Doornbos (1974) studied the anelasticity of the IC using spectral ratios of short-period core phases with common source and receiver and with nearly the same ray paths in the mantle. For 1 Hz compressional waves, he found that Q rises from a value of about 200 near the ICB to about 600 at a depth of 400km inside the IC. Below 450km from the boundary, the Q structure cannot be determined with any precision but is probably less than 2000. From observations of high-Q normal modes with a high energy concentration in the IC, Doornbos found a suggestion that, over a wider frequency range, Q is frequency-dependent. A frequency-dependent Q with low Q values around 1 Hz is compatible with partial melting in the IC. He suggested that at the ICB the temperature is close to the melting point and that in the IC the temperature gradient only slightly exceeds the melting point gradient (see also 63.6). From a spectral analysis of the phases PKZZKP and P K i K P from the same record, Bolt (1977) obtained a mean QP of 450 f (100) in the IC. Akopyan et al. (1975, 1976), Liu et al. (1976) and Hart et al. (1977) tackled
General Physical Properties of the Earth
43
the problem of dispersion caused by the Earth’s anelasticity by “correcting” the observed eigenperiods for attenuation before performing inversion to find an Earth model. This procedure can eliminate the “base-line” problem mentioned above-that travel times predicted by Earth models derived from free oscillations are generally slower than those predicted by Earth models derived from body waves. Lee and Solomon (1978), in a study of surface waves, showed that it is strictly more correct to perform simultaneous inversion for elastic and anelastic properties, rather than “correcting” some of the observations. Sailor and Dziewonski (1978) attempted to obtain the anelastic properties of the average Earth. As a first approximation, they considered the anelastic properties separately, without taking into account the coupling to elastic properties. In spite of the known lateral heterogeneity of both elastic and anelastic properties of the Earth, it is still useful to consider the concept of a spherically symmetric average Earth. The average Earth can serve as a standard of comparison for seismic observations made in more limited regions. Sailor and Dziewonski derived models of the gross Earth attenuation and found no indication of frequency dependence of Q in the period range from 100 to 3000 s. They obtained more than 230 Q measurements, using two different techniques-individual LaCoste-Romberg gravimeter recordings of three large earthquakes and 211 WWSSN recordings of two deep earthquakes. They inverted these data to obtain models of the distribution of Q in the mantle. The data-space inversion gave no indication of large variations of Q in the lower mantle-the data being consistent with very simple Q models. The data for modes dominated by shear energy can be satisfied by models with constant Q,-’ (attenuation of shear energy) in two regions: the upper mantle in which Q, is about 110, and the lower mantle below 670 km, in which Q, is a little below 400. The average Q, of the mantle is about 210. Models in which only shear energy is dissipated do not satisfy the observations of Q for radial modes. They also found that Q K (bulk dissipation) is finite in the upper mantle and possibly in the IC. Simultaneous inversion for Q, and QK showed that the data can be satisfied if QK is infinite in the IC and lower mantle, but finite in the upper mantle. Anderson and Hart (1978a) revised their earlier Q model MM8 for the Earth (Anderson et al., 1965). Their data set included fundamental and overtone observations of radial, spheroidal and toroidal modes, ScS observations and amplitudes of body waves as a function of distance. Their preferred model includes a low-Q zone at both the top and bottom of the mantle. Absorption in the mantle is predominantly due to losses in shear, although in the IC compressional absorption may be important as well. Most of the attenuation data can be satisfied by a frequency-independent Q versus depth model. Although Q is probably frequency-dependent in the high-Q regions of
-
44
The Earths Core
the Earth (the lithosphere and mid-mantle, (200-2000 km)), it is the low-Q regions of the Earth, where Q is only weakly dependent on frequency, that dominate the absorption of teleseismic body waves and normal modes. Anderson and Hart interpreted their Q model in terms of a thermally activated relaxation process that involves a distribution of activation energies and a small activation volume. A grain boundary relaxation model explains the dominance of shear over compressional dissipation, the roughly frequency-independent average value for Q and the variation of Q with depth. In a later paper Anderson and Hart (197%) made further estimates of the variation of Q with depth in the Earth. Their approach was to construct models based on body wave data and then to test and modify these models in order to satisfy the normal-mode data. Most of the attenuation data are consistent with frequency-independent Q versus depth models. They found that Q increases smoothly with depth over most of the lower mantle with a low-Q zone at its base. Normal-mode and body wave data indicate that there is bulk and shear dissipation in the IC, although no bulk dissipation is required in the mantle. Table 1.4 and Fig. 1.14 show the values of Q for their preferred model. Cormier (1981) synthesized short-period (0.2-2 Hz) seismograms for P K P waves interacting with the IC in anelastic Earth models. The agreement he obtained between predicted and observed amplitudes and spectral ratios requires neither a low-Q zone nor a low- or negative-P velocity gradient at the bottom of the OC. Thin low-Q, zones beneath the ICB fit the spectral data that sample the upper 200 km of the IC but fail to fit data that sample the lower IC. Only models having Q p 280, nearly constant with depth in the IC, satisfy all the spectral ratio and amplitude data. This suggests nearly constant temperature, pressure and phase composition with depth in the IC. The closeness to the melting temperature of some thermal models of the IC (see $3.6) suggests that the anelasticity may be due to partial melting. The amplitude of a mode at its resonant frequency is proportional to its Q. Thus even a weakly excited core mode (i.e. a spheroidal mode of elasticgravitational oscillation that has an energy partition dominated by shear energy in the IC) may be observable if Qs in the IC is high. Masters and Gilbert (1981), using recordings from the IDA gravimeter network of an earthquake in the Tonga region, obtained the first unambiguous observations of core modes. At low frequencies, the IC has a very high Q (about 3500) Core modes are extremely sensitive to the travel-time of shear waves in the IC. Masters and Gilbert computed the frequencies of the identified core modes using a constant shear velocity in the IC and a variable IC radius. The calculations are insensitive to structure above the ICB and frequencies computed using models 1066A and 1066B (Gilbert and Dziewonski, 1975) differ by less than 1 pHz. The observations are consistent with a low-frequency
-
TABLE 1.4 Q model SL8. (After Anderson and Hart, 1978b ) Thickness
Qs
Q P
(km) ~~
6371 00 6365 50 6360 00 6325 79 6291 62 6257 46 6223 29 618913 6154 97 61 20 80 6086 64 6052 17 601 8 31 5984 15 5950 00 5908 30 5866 64 5824 97 5783 31 5741 65 5700 00 561 3 93 5527 00 5440 09 5353 15 5266 23 51 79 39 5092 39 5005 47 491 8 54 4831 62 4744 70 4657 78 4570 86 4483 93 4397 02 431 0 09 4223 18 41 36 25 4049 33 3962 41 3875 48 3788 55 3701 62 361 4 70 3527 76 3484 30 2326 40 1229 50 61475
5 50 5 50 34 20 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 34 16 41 68 41 66 41 66 41 66 41 66 41 66 86 06 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 92 86 93 86 93 86 93 86 93 86 93 86 93 43 46 115787 1096 92 614 75 614 75
00 5 50 1 1 00 45 20 79 37 11353 147 70 181 86 21 6 02 250 19 284 35 31 8 52 352 68 386 84 421 00 462 69 504 35 546 02 587 68 629 34 671 00 757 07 843 99 930 91 101784 110476 1191 68 1278 60 1365 52 1452 45 1539 37 1626 29 171321 180013 1887 06 1973 98 2060 90 2147 82 2234 74 2321 67 2408 59 2495 52 2582 45 2669 38 2756 30 2843 24 2886 70 4044 60 5141 50 5756 25
Read 0.1OOE - 05 as 0.100
X
1 O-’.
500 00 500 00 500 00 11000 90 00 90 00 105 00 105 00 105 00 105 00 105 00 105 00 120 00 124 00 140 00 150 00 166 00 180 00 196 00 21 5 00 230 00 260 00 287 00 31 0 00 338 00 360 00 370 00 390 00 41 0 00 425 00 440 00 455 00 465 00 477 00 485 00 495 00 505 00 510 00 51500 51 5 00 515 00 51 0 00 500 00 300 00 200 00 100 00 0 00 0 00 425 00 850 00
1242 22 124411 1047 31 240 20 207 14 218 50 265 92 273 85 279 38 282 06 282 18 280 41 317 59 324 98 363 50 386 40 424 59 457 15 494 09 537 10 566 31 631 43 691 66 744 03 81218 871 42 905 02 963 85 1022 26 1067 57 111251 115709 118794 1221 83 1242 57 1266 60 1291 80 1308 10 1329 50 1342 44 1357 89 1359 37 1343 27 809 24 539 77 268 99 1 000,00000 1,000,00000 425 00 850 00
00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00
00 00 0 100E - 05 0 lOOE - 05 0 235E - 02 0 118E- 02
46
The Earth's Core
0
0
100
200
300
QP 400 500
600
700
800
J
,-
500 -
Model SL8 I000 -
1500-
2000 -
E
1
-
v
2500-
a
Q,
D
Outer Core
4871 -
Q,= co
5371 -
Fig. 1.14. 0 model SL8. (After Anderson and Hart, 1978b.)
travel-time of shear waves (radius/mean shear velocity) in the IC of 345 f 1.5 s. Stiller et al. (1980) have given two possible explanations for the distribution of the attenuation coefficient Q-' in the Earth's core. An appreciable asymmetric peak occurs at the ICB (see Fig. 1.15). It is somewhat surprising that the attenuation is higher in the solid IC than in the liquid OC, since one would expect sound waves to be generally damped less in solids than in their melts. Doornbos (1974) suggested that this is due to partial melting in the IC. Stiller et al. discuss two possible mechanisms that could explain the large anelasticity in the IC: one takes into account slow relaxation processes near
47
General Physical Properties of the Earth
4 5-
4-
3c
I
Q
m
0 2-
1 -
--
1
-.-
, tl200
ICB
I
I 1000
I
-------- - - _ _ _ _ _ _ I 800
I
1
I
600
I 400
I
I 200
I
3
I 0
Radius (km )
Fig. 1.15. Attenuation coefficient of seismic P waves in the Earth’s core. 1, data of Doornbos (1 974). 2, relaxation model of Stiller e t a / . (1980) with temperature distribution of Higgins and Kennedy (1 971). 3,relaxation model of Stiller et a/. (1980) with temperature distribution of Stacey (1 977); 4, contribution from attenuation in inhomogeneous matter (second model). (In the paper of Higgins and Kennedy the ICB is located at a different depth from that in the papers of Doornbos and Stacey). (After Stiller, Franck and Schmidt, 1980.)
the melting transition at the ICB, and the other is a quasi-polycrystalline structure for the IC. The first mechanism via slow order parameter relaxation can account for the shape of the Q - curve for the Earth’s core if Higgins and Kennedy’s (1971) temperature distribution is used (see Fig. 1.15). This explanation is a direct result of the condition that the whole IC, although solid, is very close to its melting temperature or solidus. Stiller et al. prefer this mechanism. The second mechanism would be more likely if the temperature distribution in the IC is like that of Stacey (1977), in which case the order parameter relaxation effect cannot account for the high energy loss in the lower 1000 km of the core. Karato (1980) has estimated temperatures in the lower mantle from the distribution of Q. He found a thermal boundary layer at the base of the mantle corresponding to the low-Q zone found by Anderson and Hart (1978a,b). This is not really surprising, but the accuracy of such temperature determinations is very dependent on that of Q, which is not at all well-known.
48
The Earths Core
1.6 Variation of Density and Other Physical Properties within the Earth
The density p will depend on the pressure p , the temperature T, and an indefinite number of parameter nispecifying the chemical composition, i.e. P = P ( P , T,ni)
(1.5)
If m is the mass of material within a sphere of radius r, then, since the stress in the Earth's interior is essentially equivalent to a hydrostatic pressure,* dP dr
- = -9P
where g=-
Gm
(1.7)
r2
and G is the gravitational constant. Considering first a chemically homogeneous layer in which the temperature variation is adiabatic, it follows from (1.5) that nP-----dPdP - - 9 P 2 dr - d p dr k, where k, is the adiabatic incompressibility defined by the equation
where s is entropy. A homogeneous region is here defined as one in which there are no significant changes of either phase or chemical composition. It follows from (1.7), (1.8) and (1.3) that dp
dr
-
-Gmp2 - -Gmp -~
ksr2
rz 4
(1.10)
The distribution of 4 throughout the Earth is known from the velocity-depth curves (cf. 1.3). Since dmldr = 47cpr2, a second-order differential equation for p = p ( r ) can be written down by differentiating (1.10). This equation, first obtained by
* In the deeper interior of the Earth, strains are fairly large (e.g. near the MCB, the mean of the principal strains has magnitude about 0.14). The mean (+pix) of the principal stresses is correspondingly large. In contrast the strength of the materials in the Earth, and therefore the greatest deviatoric stresses that can be attained, is small, i.e. the ratio of any pi, to fp,.. (which corresponds to pressure) is small at depths greater than -50 km and diminishes steadily as the depth increases. We can thus neglect the p,, compared with j p k k in the Earth's deep interior and treat the internal stresses of the Earth, when in its equilibrium state, as hydrostatic.
General Physical Properties of the Earth
49
Adams and Williamson in 1923 (Williamson and Adams, 1923), may be integrated numerically to obtain the density distribution in those regions of the Earth where chemical and non-adiabatic temperature variations may be neglected. Any density distribution must satisfy two conditions-it must yield the correct total mass of the Earth and the moment of inertia about its rotational axis. Using these two conditions and a value p1 of 3.32 g cm-3 for p at the top of layer B of the mantle (assumed to be at a depth of 33 km), Bullen applied (1.10) throughout the regions B, C and D. He then found that this led to a value of the moment of inertia I , of the core greater than that of a uniform sphere of the same size and mass. This would entail the density to decrease with depth in the core and would be an unstable state in a fluid. Birch (1952) showed that a non-adiabatic temperature gradient only worsened the situation. A reasonable value for I , could be obtained by increasing the initial value of pl, but only if an impossibly high value (at least 3.7 gem-' were chosen. Thus the assumption of chemical homogeneity must be in error; the region where this assumption is most likely to be invalid is region C where there are large changes in the slope of the velocity-depth curves. In his original Earth Model A, Bullen thus used the Adams-Williamson equation (1.10) in regions B and D while in region C he fitted a quadratic expression in r for p = p(r). In the O C (region E) (1.10) is likely to apply, and values of p down to a depth of about 5000 km can be obtained with some confidence. In the core one boundary condition is m = 0 at Y = 0, but lack of evidence on the value of the density p o at the centre of the Earth leads to some indeterminacy in the density distribution in regions F and G. Bullen initially derived density distributions on two fairly extreme hypotheses: (i) p o = 12.3 g cmP3and (ii) p o = 22.3 g cm-3 (this value being taken quite arbitrarily). A model with density values midway between those of these two hypotheses has been called Model A. More recent evidence indicates that p o is probably much nearer its minimum value and that a model based on po = 12.3 (Model A-i) is more likely to be correct.* These earlier determinations of the density distribution only made use of the information contained in the velocity-depth curves. The biggest source of additional information has come from analyses of the free vibrations of the Earth excited by major earthquakes. None of the existing velocity-depth curves combined with Bullen’s density distribution were consistent with the longer-period free-oscillation data obtained from the great Chilean earthquake of May 22,1960, and the great Alaska earthquake of March 28,1964. Using this additional data Landisman et al. (1965) investigated a number * A good account of this early work can be found in Bullen (1963,1975).
50
The Earth's Core
of Earth models without assuming homogeneity and an adiabatic temperature gradient (except in the OC). A feature of their models is constant density between depths of about 1600 and 2800 km. Bullen and Haddon (see later), were able to avoid this very implausible conclusion by treating the radius of the core rc as a free parameter-a normal value of the density gradient in the lower mantle could be obtained by increasing r, by about 15 km. Dorman et al. had earlier (1965) proposed an Earth model in which rc was increased by 10 km. Pekeris (1966) also obtained density distributions in the Earth without assuming homogeneity and an adiabatic temperature gradient in any region of the Earth. His density distribution p ( r ) was represented by 50 pivotal values p(rk) with linear variations in between and with discontinuities at the base of the crust and at the MCB. Pekeris varied the p k by the method of steepest descent so as to minimize the sum of the squares of the residuals of all the observed periods of the free oscillations of the Earth. As might be expected the density distribution in the IC has little effect on the spectrum as a whole. Other workers have supplemented the travel-time data with experimental empirical data. Birch (1960, 1961a,b, 1964) used an approximate linear relationship between density and the velocity of compressional waves that he had observed for silicates and oxides of about the same iron content, viz. p = a(m)
+ bVp
(1.11)
where m is the mean atomic weight. Birch only used this equation in the upper mantle (where there are high thermal gradients) and the transition zone (where there are phase changes). In the rest of the Earth he used the Adams-Williamson equation. A relationship between p and V , was proposed by Simmons (1964) and verified by Christensen (1966). McQueen et al. (1964) suggested that a better estimate of the density in the upper mantle might be obtained by using an empirical relationship between the bulk sound velocity c = (V: - SVi)* and density p rather than Birch's relation ( 1 . 1 1) between V p and p. This was verified by Wang (1968,1970). Birch's law implies a unique relationship between V pand p for materials of common atomic weight irrespective of whether density changes are due to crystallographic structure, pressure, or temperature. Liebermann and Ringwood (1973) obtained data for low- and high-pressure polymorphs for a wide variety of crystallographic phase transformations likely to be important in the Earth's interior. Their data indicate that V p - p relationships across such polymorphic transformations are not always equivalent to V p- p changes caused by varying pressure, temperature, or composition at constant mean atomic weight.
General Ph ysical Properties of the Earth
51
Chung (1974) obtained ultrasonic data on some crustal structures important in mantle minerology, using a powder-matrix method (Simmons and Chung, 1968) in which the elastic parameters of the unknown material are inferred from the measured elastic parameters of a composite made of the powdered material imbedded in a vacuum hot-pressed matrix of AgCI. Chung showed that a power law describes the velocitydensity (V,, ,J relationship for high-pressure polymorphs better than Birch’s linear law. In particular he found that V , varied quite linearly with density over very wide density (and thus wide pressure) ranges for materials of lower mean atomic weight, the linearity even being preserved through solid-solid phase transformations. For materials of higher mean atomic weight, on the other hand, evidence for linearity is weak. In a later paper Shankland and Chung (1974) obtained a power law equation for the dependence of V, upon m and p . Birch’s linear law and Anderson’s (1967) seismic equation of state may be deduced from it as special cases. Anderson (1973) has reviewed the literature on the power law representation of Birch’s law. Clark and Ringwood (1964) and Wang (1972) estimated densities in the Earth using petrological models for the upper mantle. Mizutani and Abe (1972) obtained an Earth model consistent with all the data using a trial-and-error method with the help of an equation of state of some rock-forming minerals. It must be emphasized that the overall density distribution within the Earth is not changed drastically by taking into account the additional observational data on its free vibrations and the revised estimate of its moment of inertia about its axis of rotation as determined from analyses of the orbits of artificial satellites (Cook, 1963). Inside the mantle, the largest difference in p between models A-i and HB, (to be discussed later) is only 0.15 gcm-3, while inside the core the values of p in model HB, exceed those in model A-i at all depths by amounts between 0.2 and 0.3 g ~ m - ~ . Buchbinder (1968) carried out a detailed study of PcP phases from eight explosions and three earthquakes. He reported cases of reversed polarity of PcP phases relative to P for epicentral distances < 32” at which distance the amplitudes of PcP pass through a minimum. Buchbinder suggested that these results reflect properties at the MCB that cannot be satisfied by any of the ‘‘conventional’’ Earth models. He found that the velocity at the top of the core is some 7-8% lower than values usually quoted and that there is no density discontinuity across the MCB. Buchbinder interpreted his results to indicate that the bottom of the mantle is inhomogeneous-the inhomogeneity being caused by an increase in iron (or other heavy metal) content with depth that increases the mean atomic weight and density with but little change in P velocity. The drop in P velocity across the MCB may then be explained by a discontinuous increase in mean atomic weight with but little change in density.
52
The Earth's Core
Various authors have objected to Buchbinder's interpretation. Berzon et al. (1972) noted that PcP phases are observed near 30" as frequently as at other epicentral distances, thus ruling out a zero in amplitude. Kogan (1972) demonstrated, by correlation between P and PcP phases, that PcP phases do not invert their polarity. Chowdhury and Frasier (1973) carried out an analysis of short-period P and PcP phases from earthquakes in the range 26" < A < 40" from the Large-Aperture Seismic Array (LASA) in Montana. No reversals of PcP polarity for A < 32" and no minimum in amplitudes at 32" were observed-again ruling out Buchbinder's model and favouring the more conventional models with a density ratio at the MCB of about 1.7. Buchbinder himself has now abandoned his original interpretation. A different approach to the inverse problem is the Monte Carlo method described in its geophysical context by Keilis-Borok and Yanovskaya (1967). It was used by Press (1968a,b) to obtain a number of Earth models using as data 97 eigenperiods, travel-times of P and S waves and the mass and moment of inertia of the Earth. The Monte Carlo method uses random selection to generate large numbers of models in a computer, subjecting each model to a test against geophysical data. Only those models whose properties fit the data within prescribed limits are retained. This procedure has the advantage of finding models without bias from preconceived or over-simplified ideas of Earth structure. Monte Carlo methods also offer the advantage of exploring the range of possible solutions and indicate the degree of uniqueness obtainable with currently available geophysical data. Press was able later (1970a,b) considerably to speed up his Monte Carlo procedures. Using new and more accurate data he was able to find a large number of successful models and also confirmed that the Earth's core is inhomogeneous and that the density at the top of the core is constrained to the narrow range 9.9-10.2 g cmP3.Wiggins (1969) also used Monte Carlo techniques to investigate the nature of the non-uniqueness inherent in the interpretation of body wave data. Haddon and Bullen (1969) constructed a series of Earth models (HB) using free oscillation data consisting of the observed periods of fundamental spheroidal and toroidal oscillations for 0 Q n Q 48 and 2 Q n Q 44 respectively and certain spheroidal overtones. Data from the records of both the Chilean and Alaskan earthquakes were used. Their procedure was to start from models derived independently of the oscillation data and to produce a sequence of models showing improved agreement with all the available data. In passing from one model to the next, a guiding principle was to introduce and vary one or more of the parameters in the model description at any stage in order to satisfy the oscillation data. They thus tried to establish models described in terms of the minimum number of parameters demanded by the data. A major difference in principle between their method and the Monte Carlo procedure
General Physical Properties of the Earth
53
of Press is the comparatively large number of parameters that Press permits to be randomly varied. Haddon and Bullen pointed out that the predominance of complex models found by Press is inherent in his method, since a simple random walk would automatically have a low probability. Haddon and Bullen also stressed that the “average” Earth to which average periods of free-oscillation modes relate is not necessarily the same as an Earth model to which the currently available average seismic body wave travel-times apply, since earthquake epicentres and recording stations are not randomly distributed over the Earth’s surface. In 1970, Bullen and Haddon used additional evidence to derive an improved Earth model (HB,). Model HB2 incorporated the newer P travel-time data of Herrin (1968) and takes into account the abnormalities in the body wave observations in the lower 200 km of the mantle and the detailed structure of the lower core (Bullen, 1965). In their earlier model HB1 a simplified core structure was assumed (the whole core being considered fluid), since free Earth oscillation data are incapable at present of resolving fine detail in the lower core. Derr (1969) also developed a series of Earth models using freeoscillation data. Anderssen and Seneta (1971, 1972) examined in detail the Monte Carlo method of inversion of geophysical data: in particular they developed a statistical procedure for estimating the reliability of non-uniqueness bounds defined by a family of randomly generated models. Anderssen et a / . (1972) applied these techniques to the problem of obtaining the density distribution within the Earth, and in a later paper (Worthington et al., 1972) attempted to resolve the major discrepancies between the density models of Bullen and Haddon and those of Press. They showed that these differences cannot be due to the different techniques employed to derive the models, and concluded that they are predominantly due to differences in assumptions about the permissible range of values of the shear velocity in the upper mantle. An upper bound to the density increase at the ICB was obtained by Bolt and Qamar (1970) from measured amplitudes of P K i K P and PcP phases recorded at LASA in Montana. The P K i K P waves were reflected at steep angles from the ICB (epicentral distance A (40”) and demonstrate the sharpness of that boundary (Engdahl et a!., 1970). Bolt and Qamar’s analysis indicated a minimum value of 0.875 for the ratio of the densities at the ICB. This would give a maximum density jump Apic at the ICB of 1.8 g cm-3 if the density in the O C at the boundary is 12.35 g cm-3 (see also Bolt, 1972). This result has been obtained on seismological evidence alone and does not depend on any assumptions concerning the chemical composition of the core. It is also in agreement with recent core models that indicate that the density in the IC is much lower than was at one time supposed. Dziewonski (1971) has stressed that only observations of overtones will
54
The Earths Core
allow the density distribution to be determined with sufficient detail to enable meaningful estimates of the structure and composition of the Earth’s deep interior. The diversity of models that satisfy travel-time and fundamental mode data indicates the insufficiency of the constraints provided by the more limited set of data. Dziewonski was able to identify overtones with periods greater than 250-300 s on records of the March 1964 Alaska earthquake from stations belonging to the WWSSN. Using this additional information, he constructed a number of Earth models. His final models indicate a change in composition in the bottom 500 km of the mantle. His density distributions show systematic differences from the HB1 model and Press’s models in the lower mantle, although all models lie within Press’s band of solutionsexcept that lower shear velocities are found in the depth range 480-650 km. Although agreement with these other models is good for the fundamental modes and the first two spheroidal overtones, it is poor for the third and fourth spheroidal and torsional overtones. A solid IC is also demanded by Dziewonski’s data-if the shear velocity in the IC is 3.5 km s - ’ Apic = 0.81 gcm-3. Details of the most recent Earth models are given in the next section. From (1.6) and (1.7). it follows that (1.12)
Hence by numerical integration, the pressure distribution may be obtained once the density distribution has been determined. Since the density is used only to determine the pressure gradient, the pressure distribution is insensitive to small changes in the density distribution and may be determined quite accurately. The variation of g can be calculated from (1.7). From a knowledge of the density distribution it is easy to compute values of the elastic constants. Thus (1.2) and (1.3) give p and ks directly. Poisson’s ratio r~ can be expressed in terms of V, and V, or ks and p; viz. o=
V; - 2V: 2(V; - Vg)
3k.y - 2 p 6ks + 2p
=-
(1.13)
Estimates of the IC radius compatible with differential P K i K p travel-times (Engdahl et al., 1974) correspond to a shear velocity of 3.55 ? .03 kms-’. This estimate is very close to the value found by Dziewonski and Gilbert (1971) from an analysis of other modes sensitive to IC properties. The low shear velocity results in a high Poisson’s ratio (- 0.45) for IC material and it has been suggested that this is indicative of a material near its melting point. The high value of CJ in the IC of many Earth models has often been used to argue that it cannot be a crystalline solid. However Al’tshuler and Sharip-
55
General Physical Properties of the Earth
dzhanov (1971) have reported shock wave measurements of 0 for copper and iron up to pressures of 1 and 2 Mbar. They obtained values of 0.43 at about 2 Mbar and the data extrapolate smoothly to the value found for the IC. Unlike other elastic properties, 0 increases with both temperature and pressure, although some metals have extremely high values of 0 even at low temperatures and pressures (Simmons and Wang, 1971). Falzone and Stacey (1980) have shown that it is not merely normal but necessary that 0 should be very high in any crystal at very high pressures. They point out that terms in conventional elasticity theory that are normally neglected become important when the ambient pressure is not negligible in comparison with the elastic moduli. These terms give a pressure dependence to the elastic moduli in addition to that resulting from the pressure dependence of atomic forces. The net effect is to reduce the modulus of rigidity and to increase the incompressibility, resulting in an increase in 0 (see (1.13)). The high value of 0 implies a state which allows large lateral contraction compared with longitudinal extension, suggesting a soft solid that is perhaps near its melting point. Under these conditions some variation of physical properties throughout the IC might be expected. The viscosity of the Earth's core is one of the least known physical parameters of the Earth. Estimates in the literature of the kinematic viscosity v differ by many orders of magnitude, ranging from to 10" cm2 s-'. High values of the viscosity have been deduced from the observation that compressional waves traverse the core without suffering appreciable attenuation (see e.g. Rochester, 1970). Such results lead to a value of v of the order of 109-f011 cm2 s-'. Gans (1972a) has shown that the effect of the Earth's magnetic field at the MCB cannot reconcile seismic data for S H waves with a very low viscosity. However, he offered the very interesting speculation that a highly 10" c m2 s -l could viscous region 5 10km thick at the MCB with v satisfy the seismic data and still permit a very low value of the viscosity in the OC as a whole. Hide (1971) has estimated the value of v at the MCB. He argued that if "bumps" on the boundary strongly influence the flow in the core, as suggested by himself and Malin (see §4.7), their height must exceed the viscous boundary layer thickness by a certain factor. Using the estimate for the height of these bumps given by himself and Horai (1968), he obtained an upper limit for the effective kinematic viscosity (i.e. eddy plus molecular) at the MCB of 1o6cm2s-'. Gans (1972b) has estimated the value of v at the ICB, assuming that this boundary is a melting transition and using Andrade's formula for the viscosity of a substance at its melting point. The estimates for pure iron give
-
-
9.0 x
< v < 1.7
x
10-2cm2s-'
56
The Earth’s Core
The core, however, is not pure iron, but contains some 10% lighter alloying element-silicon, oxygen and sulphur have been proposed (see $5.7). Both substances would lower the liquidus temperature, density and average atomic weight. The experimental data on the effect of alloying on the viscosity, however, are very sparse, although it seems probable that it would be lowered. It is not possible to estimate with any certainty the amount of the decrease. Gans suggests that in the core 2.8 x
< v < 1.5 x lo-’ cm2 s - ’
with a typical value of 6 x cm2 s-’. This range of values applies at the ICB. However if the melting point gradient is very shallow throughout the core (see $3.4), this range will not change much. With these values, the precessional mechanism proposed by Malkus (1968) to generate the Earth’s magnetic field (see $4.6) would be unstable. Whether it would be sufficiently unstable to overcome a highly sub-adiabatic temperature gradient in the core as proposed by Higgins and Kennedy (1971) cannot be determined. Crossley and Smylie (1975) have considered in detail the rate at which energy is dissipated in the liquid OC of the Earth. There are two possible dissipative mechanisms, ohmic and viscous, and they showed that oscillations in the core are virtually unaffected by either damping mechanism. Most of the ohmic dissipation takes place within a few “skin-depths’’ of the boundariesCrossley and Smylie expect that a similar result would be obtained for viscous dissipation, although their calculations were confined to estimating laminar dissipation in the body of the liquid core. The conclusion that the Earth’s core appears to be nearly free of dissipation for small harmonic oscillations, such as those which occur in the natural elastic oscillations of the Earth or those which may occur as gravitational oscillations if the temperature profile in the core is subadiabatic (see 991.4 and 3.6), suggests that modes of oscillation that are largely confined to the core may persist for unexpectedly long times-perhaps long enough to be important in driving the geodynamo (see $4.6). The viscosity of the lower mantle is discussed in $3.8.
1.7 Models of the Earth‘s Interior
The mathematical formulation of the inverse problem in geophysics characterizes possible variations of physical parameters as entities in an abstract function space, each entity representing an Earth model. In particular, a spherically symmetric, non-rotating, linearly elastic, isotropic Earth can be
General Physical Properties of the Earth
57
described by specifying the compressional velocity, the shear velocity, and the density as functions of the radius. An observation is the value of a functional defined in this space of Earth models+xamples are the Earth’s mass, moment of inertia, the measured travel-times of seismic waves, and the observed periods of free oscillation. Since the distributions of physical parameters are continuous in some interval and the number of data obtainable is necessarily finite, the inverse problem generally has no unique solution. Furthermore, the observations used as data are invariably contaminated by errors; only estimates of the values of data functionals for the Earth are available. A general discussion of the inverse problem in geophysics has been given in a series of papers by Backus and Gilbert. They investigated (1967) the extent to which a finite set of data functionals (called by them gross Earth data) can be used to determine the Earth’s internal structure. In a later paper (1968) they showed how to determine the shortest length-scale the given data can resolve at any particular depth. The principal result of their work is that it is possible to draw rigorous conclusions about the internal structure of the Earth from a finite set of gross Earth data. Infinite resolution can never be achieved, yet rigorous answers can nevertheless be given to a number of qualitative questions, such as whether there are low-velocity zones or density inversions in the mantle. In these first two papers, observational errors were neglected. In a later paper, Backus and Gilbert (1970) considered the effect of such errors and investigated the inversion of a finite set G of inaccurate gross Earth data-they showed that from some sets G it is possible to determine the structure of the Earth (except for fine-scale detail) within certain limits of error. They also showed how to determine whether a given set G will permit the construction of such localized averages of Earth structure, and how to find the shortest length-scale over which G gives a local average structure at a given depth if the variance of the error is to be less than a given amount. Detailed accounts of their work have been given by Backus (1971) and Parker (1970,1972a). In practice all data will be subject to some error, so that there are two measures of imprecision (an error of the estimate and its resolution) both of which one would like to make as small as possible. It is not possible, however, to minimize both at once. The error estimate of a property can be improved, but only at the expense of the resolving power and vice versa. Thus there exists a tradeoff between error and resolution at every radius, and some compromise must be made in choosing the best model. Parker (1972b) has also considered the inverse problem with grossly inadequate data. Such is the case, not only when the number of observations is small, but also if the inverse problem is intrinsically non-unique as is the case of attempting to determine the density inside a body from gravity obser-
58
The Earths Core
vations outside the body. Parker showed that although inadequate data cannot yield detailed structure, they can nevertheless be used to rule out certain classes of structures and provide bounds on acceptable models. The interpretation of inaccurate, insufficient and inconsistent data has also been investigated by Jackson (1972). The question of uniqueness has been further discussed by Dziewonski (1970) and the general linear inverse problem has been reviewed by Wiggins (1972). Finally, it must be emphasized that most inverse problems in geophysics are non-linear. In such cases Backus and Gilbert linearize the problem. Basically, their method employs an iterative perturbation algorithm that approximates the difference between the sought representation of the Earth and some initial model as a particular solution to the finite system of linear, inhomogeneous, integral equations relating changes in the data. The data functionals are computed for the starting model and subtracted from the observed data; the system of perturbation equations is solved, and the calculated perturbation added to the starting model. This process is iterated until the data are satisfied. Because the inverse problem is non-linear and has no unique solution, interpretation of any numerical results needs special care. A common mistake is to infer that because a certain model satisfies the data, some feature of that model actually exists in the Earth, when in reality the data do not require this feature. Moreover there is no guarantee that other starting models do not exist which are outside the scope of a linear description. Wiggins et al. (1973) have shown that body wave behaviour is too strongly non-linear for linearized schemes to be effective in predicting uncertainties. McMechan and Wiggins (1972) have developed a direct method for inverting seismic travel-time (T,A) data to determine velocity-depth profiles. They showed how a set of data points in the ( T , A ) plane, with estimates of the uncertainties, may be converted into an equivalent envelope in the velocitydepth plane. They refer to the problem of finding such envelopes of all possible models consistent with the observations as “extremal inversion”. They believe that the extremal inversion technique makes the usual Monte Carlo inversion method obsolete. In a later paper, Wiggins et al. (1973) examined the range of Earth structures that can be obtained from a set of body wave observations. Figure 1.16 shows the envelope of all possible models consistent with the set of data they used. In particular they found that there is an uncertainty of f 4 0 km in the radius of the ICB and f 18 km at the MCB. The velocity uncertainty is about f0.08 km s-’ for P and S waves in the lower mantle and about kO.10 km s-’ in the core. An interesting result of their investigation is that quite crude observations of SKKS-SKS traveltimes restrict the range of possible models far more than do the most precise estimates of PnKP travel-times.
..
c
'm lo-
**+**
E
Fixed crust" Fixed upper mantle
Y
v
,9
L .-
x
I
3
@
-
76-
5-
6!500
6000
5500
5ooo
4500
4000
: Radius (km
Fig. 1.16. Envelopes of all possible models of Earth structure from a given set of body wave observations. The envelope for the core was found under the assumption of 8 fixed core radius uf 3481 km. The heavy middle line is the standard model. (After Wiggins et a / . ,1973.)
60
The Earth's Core
The basic concept in the theory of Backus and Gilbert is that, although the exact solution cannot be computed because the information provided by the data is insufficient, it is possible to estimate accurately linear averages of the desired model. The aim of their theory is the construction of an optimal inverse filter from the constraints imposed by the observations, through which the correct solution may be viewed. As already mentioned, there is a tradeoff between the ability to resolve detail and the accuracy with which this detail can be estimated. Jordan (1972) has used a variation of the Backus-Gilbert theory incorporating the stochastic inverse theory of Franklin (1970). A particular, unique solution to the linear system is obtained by minimizing a specified quadratic measure of error. This quadratic form is the sum of two terms, a measure of the resolution of the estimate and a measure of its accuracy, parameterized to yield a Backus-Gilbert-type tradeoff curve. Jordan showed that the generalized inverse of Penrose (1955) and Moore (1920) and the stochastic inverse of Franklin (1970) lie on this tradeoff curve, the stochastic inverse being, in one sense, an optimal point. Any particular solution computed by selecting a point on the tradeoff curve is shown to be an estimate of the correct solution convolved with a projection-like smoothing operator. Dziewonski and Gilbert (1973a) observed an IC mode (llSz) in 11 spectra of seismograms with large lag times-over two days after the origin time in some cases (see Fig. 1.17). This represents direct proof of the solidity of the
r
Period ( s 1 Fig. 1.17. Histograms of a number of spectral peaks read from the spectra of vertical component readings. The histogram for seismograms with a lag-time of less than 18 h, broken line; over 18 h, solid line. (After Dziewonski and Gilbert, 1973a.)
General Physical Properties of the Earth
61
IC-the mode lSz could not exist if the IC were liquid. The IC mode lSz is coupled with a compressional mode of nearly identical phase velocity (loSz)-the observed periods are 246.89 s and 247.74 s respectively. The coincidence of loSzand llSz implies that the average shear velocity in the IC must be 3.6 km s - l , and that dissipation in the IC is low. Because of the large wavelengths of the normal modes, their eigenfrequencies are likely to be more closely related to the properties of a spherically symmetric, radially stratified “average” Earth than the nearly exclusive land-based travel-time observations. The resolving power of the normal mode data set shows that the average velocities and densities are known in the mantle to 1% for averaging lengths of -200 km (Gilbert et al., 1973). For the same precision the averaging lengths in the OC are -400 km. The structure of the region D” has been discussed in 51.3. There is no question about the sharpness of the MCB, although there may be minor lateral variations in some of the physical properties there. Dziewonski and Haddon (1974) have reviewed all data on the radius rc of the core. The first close estimate was made by Gutenberg (1913), who obtained a value of 3471 km from a determination of the distance at which P waves become diffracted. Much later, Jeffreys (1939a) proposed a method using the travel-times of core reflections and obtained a value of 3473 ( f 4.2) km, which he revised later (1939b) to 3473.1 (k2.5) km. His method (with some modifications) is still being used and it is only in recent years that additional data have forced revision of his estimate. Using travel-times of PcP phases from nuclear explosions, Taggart and Engdahl (1968) obtained a value of 3477 (k2.0) km for rc. Bolt (1972) inferred a 2% decrease in V , through the lowest 150 km of the mantle leading to a value for rc of 3475 (k2.0) km. Hales and Roberts (1970) obtained values of I , of 3490 (f4.7) km and 3486 (k4.6) km for two possible mantle models, basing their calculations on the differences in travel-times between ScS and S in the distance range 48” < A < 70”. Engdahl and Johnson (1972) analysed the differential travel-times Pep-P from three nuclear explosions in the Aleutian Islands and concluded that yC should be increased by 5-15 km over the value of 3477 km obtained by Taggart and Engdahl(l968). Their preferred estimation is 3482.2 ( 2.9) km. The free oscillation data demanded an increase in I , over earlier estimates. Dorman et al. (1965) proposed a model in which r, was increased by 10 km and a “soft” layer introduced at the base of the mantle. Haddon and Bullen (1969) showed that the travel-time and free oscillation data could be reconciled with an Adams-Williamson density gradient (see 51.6) in the lower mantle by increasing r, by 15-20 km over Jeffreys’ (1939b) value of 3473 km. Press used a Monte Carlo method to generate a large number of Earth models (see 51.6). The successful models (1970b) did not show a strong prefer-
-
62
The Earths Core
ence for any particular value of the core radius within the bounds from 3463 to 3483 km. Dziewonski (1970) showed that only additional overtone data could narrow the range of permissible solutions based on fundamental mode data alone. Using the eigenperiods of 70 spheroidal and toroidal overtones from the spectra of 84 recordings of the Alaska earthquake of March 28, 1964 (identified and measured by Dziewonski and Gilbert, 1972), he was able to narrow the range of r, to 3486-3491 km. Many more overtone data have now been obtained (Dziewonski and Gilbert, 1973b) and have been used by a number of authors in constructing Earth models. Jordan and Anderson (1974) obtained a value for r, of 3845 km and Gilbert et al. (1973) values of 3482.6 and 3484.9 km for two different models. Engdahl and Johnson (1974) using differential P C P travel-times, obtained values in the range 34843486 km. The best available estimate at present for I , is 3485 ( IfI 3) km. A radius of 1250 km postulated for the IC in the Jeffreys-Bullen model now appears to be somewhat too great. Bolt’s (1962) model used a radius of 1216 km and later work by Bolt (1964) supported by wide-angle reflections of P K i K P (Bolt et al., 1968) gave values near 1220 km. The models of Buchbinder (1971) and Qamar (1973) incorporate IC radii of 1226 and 1213 km respectively. Engdahl et al. (1974) have estimated the radius of the IC from differential P K i K P (i.e. P K i K P minus PcP) arrival time data for a number of different Earth models. The data indicate an IC radius in the range 12201230 km. For a model incorporating a decreased velocity gradient just above the ICB, their preferred value for the radius of the IC is 1227.4 & 0.6 km. Comparison of pulse shapes and pulse durations for P , PcP and P K i K P phases indicates that the ICB is very sharp. A value in the range 12151235 km is now preferred. Bolt and Urhammer (1975) carried out least-squares iterations with penalty functions on Earth model CAL5* based on observations of eigenvibrations, surface waves and body waves. In the penalty function method, linear equality constraints are weighted so that the least-squares estimator suffers a specified penalty for progressive violation of the physical restrictions. They also derived a procedure for calculating the trade-off between spread and variance for density estimates, and then assessed the resolvability of density and index of homogeneity at a number of levels in the Earth. The density in the lower mantle in their final model is a little closer to homogeneous, adiabatic conditions. Density values are about 0.15 g cm-3 less than those of B1 (Jordan and Anderson, 1974) in the region 20W2500 km. As a consequence, density values in the core are significantly greater than those of
* Details of these earlier models will not be given-they required.
can be found in the references if
63
General Physical Properties of the Earth
-
B1 (the mean density at the bottom of the OC is 1 2 . 3 4 g ~ m -compared ~ with 12.11 g ~ m -in ~ Model Bl). In the IC, V , N 3.55 kms,-l, p N 13.30g cm-3 and Poisson's ratio ~ 0 . 4 5 . Hales et al. (1974) suggested the construction of a spherically symmetric Earth model in which the radial variations of seismic parameters are expressed by piece-wise continuous analytical functions such as low-order polynomials in the radius. This idea was taken up by Dziewonski et al. (1975) who used polynomials of order not higher than three to construct a parametric Earth model (PEM). Their starting model was based on model 1066B (Gilbert and Dziewonski, 1975) with some modifications. The data used in the inversion consisted of observations of eigenperiods for 1064 normal modes, 246 travel-times of body waves for five different phases and regional surface-wave dispersion data. They presented three Earth models, all identical below a depth of 420 km; models P E M - 0 and PEM-C reflecting the different properties of the oceanic and continental upper mantles and model PEM-A representing an average Earth. The densities and velocities in the lower mantle (depths greater than 670 km) and core are consistent with the Adams-Williamson equation to less than 0.2%. Thus, any departures from homogeneity and adiabaticity within these regions must be very small. Dziewonski et al. (1975) also showed that the velocities in the lower mantle were consistent with the complete first-order finite-strain theory to within 0.2% for V p and 0.4% for Vs. In the IC, Vs varies from 3.44 to 3.56 km s-', confirming the earlier estimate of 3.5 km s-' by Dziewonski and Gilbert (1971). Buchbinder (1976) computed PcP and PmKP travel times for three simple or parametric Earth models based on free oscillation and travel-time dataH B , (Haddon and Bullen, 1969), B1 (Jordan and Anderson, 1974) and PEMA (Dziewonski et al., 1975)-and compared them with PCP and PmKP travel-times from different sources. The comparison was made only for the region above and below the MCB. He found that only model B1 does not need a correction for its PcP travel-times. For the PmKP travel-times all three models needed corrections. Normal-mode data are not adequate to resolve details of Earth structure having wavelengths of the order of 1 W 2 0 0 km. To resolve these features, body wave data, which are of higher resolving power, must be used. Such data are by their nature more path-dependent than normal modes-the role of free oscillations is to determine differences between the average Earth and the more path-specific body wave structures. Anderson and Hart (1976) thus used a starting model based on high-resolution body wave data and perturbed it to fit the normal mode data set. The resulting model retains the features found by body wave studies, but the average properties are suitably adjusted to correspond to average Earth properties, as is required by the nor-
64
The Earths Core
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
Radius (km) Fig. 1.18. A comparison of densities p and seismic velocities Vp and V, estimated in three Earth models, CALG, PEM and QM2. (After Bolt and Uhrhammer 1981 .)
ma1 mode data set. Their final model (C2) shows slight inhomogeneity at the base of the mantle, the top of the core and the regions on both sides of the ICB. Both the V p and density jump at the ICB are small. Hart et al. (1977) later examined the effect of correcting Earth model C2 for attenuation. The result was generally to increase seismic velocities, particularly shear velocities, throughout the model. The largest increases occur in those regions where Q is lowest. In spite of recent refinements, the resolution of P and S velocity gradients places considerable limitations on the sharpness of inferences that can be drawn about dynamical properties, density stratification and deviations from adiabatic conditions. Recent core models have been based on limited sets of data on travel-times and amplitudes of seismic core waves, and measurements of the eigenfrequencies of the Earth. A comparison shows that the differences between independently constructed models such as CAL6 (Bolt and Urhammer, 1975), PEM (Dziewonski et al., 1975) and QM2 (Hart et al., 1977) are almost everywhere less than 1% (see Fig. 1.18). The differences depend on weighting and selections of data and on assumptions on smoothing. Figure 1.19 gives the distribution of the seismic parameter 4
6ot
50 4000
1
I
1
3Ooo
2000
Radius
Fig. 1 .IS.A comparison of the seismic parameter and Q M 2 . (After Bolt & Urhammer, 1981 .)
-0 -0
3
1
I
0
loo0
(km)
4 calculated from three Earth models, CALG, PEM,
-
-
2 -
-
v
c I
1
I
I
I
I
Fig. 1.20. The PREM model. Dashed lines are the horizontal components of velocity. Where q is 1 the model is isotropic. The core is isotropic. (After Dziewonski and Anderson, 1981 ).
TABLE 1.5 Earth model PREM and its funcrionals evaluated at a reference period of 1 s. Above 220 km the mantle is transversely isotropic;the parameters given are ”equivalent” isotropic moduli and velocities. (After Dziewonski and Anderson, 1981 .) Radius (km)
Depth (km)
Density (gcmP)
VP
v5
(kms-’)
(kms-’)
Q,
0. 100.0 200.0 300.0 400.0 500.0 600.0 700.0 800.0 900.0 1000.0 1 1 00.0 1200.0 1221.5 1221.5 1300.0 1400.0 1500.0 1600 0 1700.0 1800.0 1900.0 2000.0 21 00.0 2200.0 2300.0 2400.0 2500.0 2600.0
6371 0 6271 0 6171 0 6071 0 5971 0 5871 0 5771 0 5671 0 5571 0 5471 0 6371 0 5271 0 5171 0 5149 5 51 49 5 5071 0 4971 0 4871 0 4771 0 4671 0 4571 0 4471 0 4371 0 4271 0 4171 0 4071 0 3971 0 3871 0 3771 0
13.08848 13.08630 13.07977 13.06888 13.05364 13.03404 13.01009 12.98178 12.94912 12-3121 1 12.87073 12.82501 12.77493 12.76360 12.16634 12.12500 12.06924 12.00989 11.94682 11.87990 1 1 -80900 11.73401 11.65478 1 1 -57119 1 1 -48311 11.39042 1 1 29298 11,19067 11.08335
11.26220 11.26064 11.25593 11.24809 11.23712 11.22301 11.20576 11,18538 1 1 ,I6186 11,13521 1 1.1 0542 11.07249 11.03643 1 1.02827 10.35568 10.30971 10.24959 10.18743 10.12291 10.05572 9.98554 9.91206 9.83496 9.75393 9.66865 9.57881 9.48409 9.38418 9.27876
3.66780 3.66670 3.66342 3.65794 3.65027 3.64041 3.62835 3.61411
85 85 85 85
3.59767 3.57905 3.55823 3.53522 3.51002 3.50432
0. 0.
0. 0. 0. 0. 0.
0. 0. 0. 0. 0.
0. 0. 0.
0
328 328 328 328 328 328 328 1328 1328 1328 1328 1328 1328 1328 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822
0
57822
85 85 a5
85 a5 85
85 a5 85 85
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
108.90 108.88 108.80 108.68 108.51 108.29 108.02 107 70 107.33 106.91 106.45 105.94 105.38 105.25 107.24 106.29 105.05 103.78 102.47 101.12 99.71 98.25 96.73 95.14 93.48 91 7 5 89.95 88 06 86.10
ti
P
(kbar)
(kbar)
14253 14248 14231 14203 14164 14114 14053 13981 13898 13805 13701 13586 13462 13434 13047 12888 12679 12464 12242 1201 3 1 1 775 1 1 529 1 1 273 1 1009 10735 10451 101 58 9855 9542
1761 1759 1755 1749 1739 1727 1713 1696 1676 1654 1630 1603 1574 1567
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0
IS
0.4407 0.4407 0.4408 0.4409 0.4410 0.4412 0.4414 0.6417 0.4420 0.4424 0.4428 0.4432 0.4437 0.4438 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000 0.5000
Gravity
Pressure (kbar)
dkldp
3638.524 3636.131 3628.956 361 7.011 3600.315 3578.894 3552.783 3522.024 3486.665 3446.764 3402.383 3353.596 3300.480 3288.513 3288.502 3245.423 31 87.493 31 26.159 3061.461 2993.457 2922.221 2847.839 2770.407 2690.035 2606.838 2520.942 2432.484 2341.603 2248.453
2 3360 2 3363 2 3365 2 3369 2 3375 2 3382 2 3391 2 3402 23414 2 3428 2 3443 2 3460 2 3480 2 3486 3 7545 3 6539 3 5478 3 4649 3 401 7 3 3552 3 3230 3 3028 3 2927 3 291 1 3 2966 3 3080 3 3242 3 3441 3 3670
(crnr-2)
0. 36.56 73.11 109.61 146.04 182.39 21 8.62 254.73 290.68 326.45 362.03 397.39 432.51 440.02 440.03 463.68 494.13 524.77 555.48 586.14 61 6.69 647.04 677.15 706.57 736.45 765.56 794.25 822.48 850.23
2700 0 2800 0 2900 0 3000 0 31000 3200 0 3300 0 3400 0 3480 0 3480 0 3500 0 3600 0 3630 0 3630 0 3700 0 3800 0 3900 0 4000 0 4100 0 4200 0 4300 0 4400 0 4500 0 4600 0 4700 0 4800 0 4900 0 5000 0 51 00 0 5200 0 5300 0 5400 0 5500 0 5600 0
3671 .O 3571 .O 3471 .O 3371 .O 3271 .O 31 71 .O 3071 .O 2971 .O 2891 .O 2891 .O 2871 .O 2771 .O 2741 .O 2741 .O 2671 .O 2571 .O 2471 .O 2371 .O 2271 .O 21 71 .O 2071 .0 1971 0 1871 .O 1771.O 1671 .O 1571 0 1471 .O 1371 .O 1271 .O 1171 0 1071 .O 971 .O 871 .O 771 0
10.97091 10.85321 10.73012 10.60152 10.46727 10.32726 10.181 34 10.02940 9 90349 5.56645 5.55641 5.50642 5.49145 5.49145 5.45657 5.40681 5.35706 5.30724 5.25729 5.20713 5 15669 5.10590 5.05469 5.00299 4.95073 4.89783 4.84422 4.78983 4.73160 4.67844 4.62129 4.56307 4.50372 4.44317
9.16752 9.05015 8.92632 8.79573 8.65805 8.51298 8.36019 8.19939 8.06482 13.71660 13.71168 13.68753 13.68041 13.68041 13.59597 13.47742 13 36074 13.24532 13.13055 13.01579 12.90045 12.78389 12.66550 12.54466 12.42075 12.29316 12.161 26 12.02445 11.88209 11.73357 11.57828 11.41560 11.24490 11.06557
0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0
0 726466 726486 726575 7 26597 7 26597 723403 718892 714423 709974 705525 701053 696538 691957 687289 682512 6 77606 672548 667317 661891 656250 650370 644232 637813 6 31091 624046
0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0
312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312 312
57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 !m22 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822
84 04 81 91 79 68 77 36 74 96 ?2 47 69 89 67 23 65 04 17 78 17 64 16 96 16 76 16 76 1508 11273 11046 708 23 10604 103 88 101 73 99 59 97 43 95 26 93 06 90 81 88 52 86 17 83 76 81 28 78 72 76 08 73 34 70 52
9220 8889 8550 8202 7846 7484 7116 6743 6441 6556 6537 6440 641 2 641 2 6279 6095 591 7 5744 5575 5409 5246 5085 4925 4766 4607 4448 4288 41 za 3966 3803 3638 3471 3303 31 33
0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 0 05000 2938 03051 2933 03049 2907 03038 2899 03035 2899 03035 2855 03026 2794 03012 2734 02998 2675 02984 2617 02971 2559 02957 2502 0 2943 2445 02928 2388 02913 2331 02898 2273 02881 2215 02864 2157 02846 2098 02826 2039 02805 1979 02183 1918 02758 1856 02731 1794 02701 1730 02668
21 53 189 2055 978 1956.991 1856.409 1754418 1651.209 1546.982 441 941 357 51 0 357 509 345 61 9 287 067 269 742 269 741 229 71 9 1173 465 1 1 18 207 1063 864 101 0 363 957 641 905 646 854 332 803 660 753 598 704 119 655 202 606 830 558 991 511 676 464 882 41 8 606 372 852 321 673 282 928
33919 3 41a0 3 4448 3 471 4 3 4972 3 5215 3 5437 3 5629 3 5769 16435 7 6434 16424 16420 3 3344 3 2957 3 2443 3 2029 31716 3 1503 3 1393 3 1383 3 1472 3 1657 3 1935 3 2302 3 2750 3 3276 3 3871 3 4527 3 5236 3 5989 3 6775 3 7582 3 8403
877 46 904 14 930 23 955 70 980 51 1004 64 1028 04 1050 65 1068 23 1068 23 1065 32 1052 04 1048 44 1048 44 1040 66 1030 95 1022 72 1015 80 101006 1005 35 1001 56 998 59 996 35 994 74 993 69 993 14 993 01 993 26 993 83 994 67 995 73 996 98 998 36 999 85
T A B L E l . 5 continued overleaf
TABLE 1.5-contmued
5600 0 5650 0 5701 0 5701 0 5736 0 5771 0 5771 0 5821 0 5871 0 5921 0 5971 0 59Ji 0 60160 6061 0 6106 0 6151 0 6151 0 6186 0 6221 0 6256 0 6291 0 6291 0 631 1 0 6331 0 6346 6 6346 6 6356 0 6356 0 6368 0 6368 o 6371 0
771 0 721 0 670 0 670 0 635 0 600 0 600 0 550 0 500 0 450 0 400 0 400 0 355 0 3100 265 0 220 0 220 0 1850 1500 1150 80 0 80 0 60 0 40 0 24 4 24 4 150 150 30 30 0
4 4431 6 4 41 241 4 38071 3 9921 4 3 98399 3 97584 3 97584 3 91 282 3 84980 3 78678 3 72378 3 54325 3 51 639 3 48951 3 46264 3 43578 3 35950 3 36330 3 36710 3 37091 3 37471 3 37471 3 37688 3 37906 3 38076 2 90000 2 90000 2 60000 2 60000 102000 102M)o
VP
vs
(kms-')
(kms-')
11 06556
6 24046 6 0941 8 5 94508 5 57020 5 5431 1 5 51 602 5 51 600 5 3701 4 5 22428 5 07842 4 93259 4 76989 4 73840 4 70690 4 67540 4 64391 4 41 885 4 431 08 4 44361 4 45643 4 46953 4 46954 4 4771 5 4 48486 4 49094 3 90000 3 90000 3 20000 3 20000
10 91 005
I075131 10 26622 10 21 203 10 15782 10 15782 9 901 85 9 64588 9 38990 9 13397 8 90522 8 81 867 8 73209 8 64552 a 55896 7 98970 801180 8 03370 8 0554Q 8 07688 8 07689 8 08907 810119 811061 6 80000 6 80000 5 80000 5 80000 145000 145000
0 0
# QP
31 2 31 2 31 2 143 t 43 143 143 143 143 143 143 143 143 143 143 143 80 80 80 80 80 600 600 600 600 600 600
600 600 0 0
QA
57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 578.22 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822 57822
L:
( k m 2 K z ) (kbar)
70.52 69.51 68.47 64.03 63.32 62.61 62.61 59.60 56.65 53.78 50.99 48.97 47.83 46.71 45.60 44.50 37.80 38.01 38.21 38.41 38.60 38.60 38.71 38.81 38.89 25 96 25.96 i9.99 19.99 210 2.10
P
(kbar)
u
21
02668 02732 02798 02914 02911 02909 02909 02917 02924 02933 02942 02988 02971 02952 02933 0 2914 02797 0.2797 0.2796 02795 02793 02793 02792 02790 02789 02549 02549 02812 02812 0 05000
21
0 05000
31 33 3067 2999 2556 2523 2489 2489 2332 21 81 2037 1899 1735 1682 1630 1579 1529 1270 1278 1287 1295 1303 1303 1307 1311 1315 753 753 520 520
1730 1639 1548 1239 1224 1210 1210 1128 1051 977 906 806 790 773 757 741 656 660 665 669 674 674 677 680 682 441 441 266 266
Pressure (kbar)
282 927 260 783 238 342 238 334 224 364 21 0 426 21 0 425 190 703 171 311 152 251 133 527 133 520 117 702 102 027 86 497 71 115 71 108 59 466 47 824 36 183 24 546 24 539 17 891 1 1 239 6 043 6 040 3 370 3 364 0 303 0 299 -0 000
dk/dp
2 981 9 3 0086 3 0358 2 4000 2 3868 2 3734 8 091 0 7 8833 7 6761 7 4695 7 2633 33718 3 3369 3 301 7 3 2662 3 2305 - 0 7364 - 0 7200 -0 7035 - 0 6868 - 0 6700 - 0 6700 - 0 6603 -0 6505 - 0 6428 - 0 0000 0 0000 0 0000 - 0 0000 - 0 0000
0 000
Gravity (ems-')
999 85 1000 63
1001 43 1001 43
1000 88 1000 38 1000 38 999 65 998 83 997 90 996 86 996 86 995 22 993 61 992 03 990 48 990 48 989 1 1 987 83 986 64 985 53 985 53 984 93 984 37 983 94 983 94 983 32 983 31 982 22 982 22 gal 56
General Physical Properties of the Earth
69
(equation 1.3) for the above three models and shows that the gradients of this parameter are not well-resolved. (It is the gradient of 4 that is important for solid state, temperature, compositional and convection studies.) Recent seismological evidence has favoured a simple two-layer core with a liquid OC, and a sharply-bounded solid IC. As discussed in 51.2, the hypothesis of a sharply-bounded transition region F has fallen from favour because of the explanation of precursors to P K I K P in terms of scattering sources near the MCB. Nevertheless, velocity jumps in F need be as small as only 0.01 km s-' to give rise to back-scattered waves with the observed amplitudes (Bolt and Urhammer, 1981). The P wave velocity distribution in the O C shows that the P velocity between 1600km and about 1200km changes by only a few percent, i.e. there is near-independence of sound speed over a pressure change of 400 kbar. Thus, a region F between E and G does exist. The density distributions in E (see Fig. 1.18) determined from eigenvibration and travel-time inversions, without using the assumptions of Adams and Williamson, confirm a density gradient close to the Adams and Williamson value (at least, in the central part of E). The conclusion is that zero deviations from homogeneity and adiabaticity throughout most of E are sufficient but not necessary to satisfy the data. The largest differences in the estimates of density occur in the IC. However, both CAL6 and PEM have about the same jump in density (0.6 g cm-3) at the ICB. Models PEM and QM2 have essentially equal density distributions throughout the liquid OC. Observations of the amplitude of P K i K P and P K I I K P imply that there must be a sharp discontinuity in density, or in compressibility, or both, at the ICB. A jump in rigidity will not yield either of these reflections with the amplitudes observed. The central densities of CAL6, PEM and QM2 are 13.35, 13.01 and 12.57 g cm-3 respectively. In 1981 Dziewonski and Anderson published their Preliminary Earth Model (PREM) which they had presented at the 1979 IUGG General Assembly in Canberra. In order to satisfy the large amount of normal mode, surface wave and body wave data, they found it necessary to introduce anelastic dispersion and anisotropy for the mantle above 220 km. Their model is thus frequency-dependent. Like the earlier model PEM, PREM is parametric in nature, the various physical parameters being expressed as loworder polynomials in the radius, of order between zero and three in the various regions of the Earth. They used about 1000 normal mode periods, 500 summary travel-time observations and 100 normal mode Q values. This data set was supplemented with a special study of 12 years of ISC phase data which yielded an additional 1.75 x lo6 travel-time observations for P and S waves. To obtain reasonably good control over velocities in the OC, they com-
70
The Earths Core
bined data from four travel-time branches: S K K S , SKS, P K P ( A B ) and P K P ( B C ) . Differential travel-times, PCP - P (Engdahl and Johnson, 1974) and ScS- S (Jordan and Anderson, 1974) are important for the control of the radius of the OC. The P K i K P - PcP differential travel-times of Engdahl et al. (1974) give the best control of the radius of the IC. Their final model is shown in Fig. 1.20 and values of various physical parameters in Table 1.5. This table includes values of the parameter r] of Bullen (see (5.32)) which represents a measure of the deviation of a model from the Adams-Williamson equation (for which r] = 1). For the most part r] in the core and lower mantle is very close to unity, the small deviations, in some cases, being an artifact of the polynomial representation. In the lower 150 km of the mantle (region D”), the velocity is nearly constant; the radius of the OC is 3480 km. Dziewonski and Anderson suggest that the core radius may be 1.7 km larger, which would satisfy the observations that slower velocities may exist in D”.
References
Adams, R. D. (1972). Multiple inner core reflections from a Novaya Zemlya explosion. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 62, 1063. Adams, R. D. and Randall, M. J. (1963). Observed triplication of PKP. Nature 200,744. Adams, R. D. and Randall, M. J., (1964). The fine structure of the Earth’s core. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 54, 1299. Akopyan, S. Ts., Zharkov, V. N. and Lyubimov, V. M. (1975). The dynamic shear modulus in the interior of the Earth. Dokl. Earth Sci. Ser. 223, 1. Akopyan, S. Ts., Zharkov, V. N. and Lyubimov, V. M. (1976). Corrections to the eigenfrequencies of the Earth due to the dynamic shear modulus. Izo. Acad. Sci. U S S R Phys. Solid Earth 12,625. Alder, A. J. and Trigueros, M. (1977). Suggestion of a eutectic region between the liquid and solid core of the Earth. J . Geophys Res. 82,2535. Alterman, Z., Jarosch H. and Pekeris, C. L. (1959). Oscillations of the Earth. Proc. Roy. SOC. London A252,80. Al’tshuler, L. and Sharipdzhanov, L. (1971). Distribution of iron in the Earth and its chemical differentiations. Izv. Acad. Sci. USSR. Phys. Solid Earth 4 3 . Anderson, D. L. (1967). A seismic equation of state. Geophys. J . 13,9. Anderson, D. L. and Hanks, T. C. (1972). Formation of the Earth’s core. Nature 237,387. Anderson, D. L. and Hart, R. S. (1976). An Earth model based on free oscillations and body waves. J . Geophys. Rex 81, 1461. Anderson, D. L. and Hart, R. S. (1978a). Attenuation models of the Earth. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 16, 289. Anderson, D. L. and Hart, R. S.(1978b). Q of the Earth. J . Geophys. Res. 83,5869. Anderson, D. L., Ben-Menahem, A. and Archambeau, C. B. (1965). Attenuation of seismic energy in the upper mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 70,505. Anderson, 0. L. (1973). Comments on the power law representation of Birch’s law. J . Geophys. Res. 78,4901. Anderssen, R. S. and Seneta, E. (1971). A simple statistical estimation procedure for Monte Carlo inversion in geophysics. Pure Appl. Geophys. 91,5014.
General Physical Properties of the €arrh
71
Anderssen, R. S. and Seneta, E. (1972). A simple statistical estimation procedure for Monte Carlo inversion in geophysics. 11: Efficiency and Hempel's paradox. Pure Appl. Geophys. 96, 5. Anderssen, R. S., Worthington, M. H. and Cleary, J. R. (1972). Density modelling by Monte Carlo inversion. I: Methodology. Geophys. J . 29,433. Backus, G. (1971). Inference from inadequate and inaccurate data. In Mathematical Problems in the Geophysical Sciences (W. H. Reid, ed.). Lectures in Applied Mathematics, Vol. 14, Amer. Math. SOC. Backus, G. E. and Gilbert, J. F. (1961). The rotational splitting of the free oscillations of tfie Earth. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U S A 47, 362. Backus, G. E. and Gilbert, J. F. (1967). Numerical applications of a formalism for geophysical inverse problems. Geophys. J . 13,247. Backus, G. E. and Gilbert, J. F. (1968). The resolving power of gross Earth data. Geophys. J . 16, 169. Backus, G. and Gilbert F. (1970). Uniqueness in the inversion of inaccurate gross Earth data. Ehil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A266, 123. Balakina, L. M. and Vvedenskaya, A. V. (1962). Izv. Akad. Nauk SSR. Ser. Geojiz 11,909. Bertrand, A. E. S. and Clowes, R. M. (1974). Seismic array evidence for a two-layer core transition zone. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 8,251. Berzon, I. S., Kogan, S. D. and Pessechnik, I. P. (1972). The character of the mantle-core boundary from observations of PCP waves. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 16, 166. Berzon, I. S., Pessechnik, I. P. and Polikarpov, A. M. (1974). The determination of P wave attenuation values in the Earth's mantle. Geophys. J . 39,603. Birch, F. (1952). Elasticity and constitution of the Earth's interior. J . Geophys. Res. 57,227. Birch, F. (1960). The velocity of compressional waves in rocks to 10 kilobars, 1. J . Geophys. Res. 65, 1083. Birch, F. (1961a). The velocity ofcompressional waves in rocks to 10 kilobars, 2. J . Geophys. Res. 66,2199. Birch, F. (1961b). Composition of the Earth's mantle. Geophys. J . 4,295. Birch, F. (1964). Density and composition of mantle and core. J . Geophys. Res. 69,4377. Bolt, B. A. (1959). Travel times of PKP up to 145".Geophys. J . 2,190. Bolt, B. A. (1962). Gutenberg's early PKP observations. Nature 196, 122. Bolt, B. A. (1964). The velocity of seismic waves near the Earth's centre. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 54,191. Bolt, B. A. (1972). The density distribution near the base of the mantle and near the Earth's centre. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 5,301. Bolt. B. A. (1977). The detection of PKIIKP and damping in the inner core. Ann. Geojis. 30,507. Bolt, B. A. and Canas, J. A. (1985). Constraints from core reflections on mantle Q and density at the core boundary. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 38,l. Bolt, B. A. and Niazi, M. (1984). S velocities in D" from diffracted SH-waves at the core boundary. Geophys. J . 79,825. Bolt, B. A. and Qamar, A. (1970). Upper bound to the density jump at the boundary of the Earth's inner core. Nature 228, 148. Bolt, B. A. and Urhammer, R. (1975). Resolution techniques for density and heterogeneity in the Earth. Geophys. J . 42,419. Bolt, B. A. and Urhammer, R. (1981). The structure, density and homogeneity of the Earths core. In Evolution ofthe Earth (R. J. OConnell, W. S. Fyfe eds). Geodynamics Series Vol. 5, Amer. Geophys. Union. Bolt, B. A,, ONeill, M. and Qamar, A. (1968). Seismic waves near 110": is structure in core or upper mantle responsible? Geophys. J . 16,475.
72
The Earth’s Core
Bolt, B. A,, Niazi, M. and Somerville, M. (1970). Diffracted SCS and the shear velocity of the core boundary. Geophys. J . 19,299. Buchbinder, G. G. R. (1968). Properties of the core-mantle boundary and observations of PCP. J . Geophys. Res. 73,5901. Buchbinder, G. G. R. (1971). A velocity structure of the Earth’s core. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 61, 429. Buchbinder, G. G. R. (1976). A test of new Earth models against PCP and PmKP travel times. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 11,13. Buchbinder, G. G. R. and Poupinet, G. (1973). Problems related to PCP and the core-mantle boundary illustrated by two nuclear events. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 63,2047. Buland, R. and Gilbert, F. (1978). Improved resolution of complex eigenfrequencies in analytically continued seismic spectra. Geophys. J . 52,457. Bullen, K. E. (1954). Seismology. Methuen, London. Bullen, K. E. (1963). An Introduction to the Theory of Seismology. Cambridge University Press, London. Bullen, K. E. (1965). Models for the density and elasticity of the Earths lower core. Geophys. J . 9, 233. Bullen, K. E. (1975). The Earths Density. Chapman and Hall. Bullen, K. E. and Haddon, R. A. W. (1970). Evidence from seismology and related sources on the Earth’s present internal structure. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 2,342. Busse, F. H. (1974). On the free oscillations of the Earth’s inner core. J . Geophys. Res. 79,753. Caloi, P. (1961). Seismic waves from the outer core and the inner core. Geophys. J . 4,139. Canas, J. A. and Bolt, B. A. (1983). Nuevo metodo para la obtencion simultanea del factor medio de calidad especifica en el manto y litosfera terrestre y el salto de densidades en el limite. Nucleo-manto. Teoria Anales de Fisica Serie A 79, 57. Cathles, L. M. (1975). The oiscosity of the Earth’s mantle. Princeton University Press, Princeton, MA. Chang, A. C. and Cleary, J. R. (1978). Precursors to PKKP. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 68,1059. Chang, A. C. and Cleary, J. R. (1981). Scattered P K K P further evidence for scattering at a rough core-mantle boundary. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 24, 15. Chowdhury, D. K. and Frasier, C. W. (1973). Observations of PCP and P phases at LASA at distances from 26” to 40”. J . Geophys. Res. 78,6021. Choy, G. L. and Cormier, V. F. (1983). The structure of the inner core inferred from short-period and broadband GDSN data. Geophys. J . 7 2 , l . Christensen, N. I. (1966). Elasticity of some ultrabasic rocks. J . Geophys. Res. 71,5921. Christensen, U. (1984). Instability of a hot boundary layer and initiation of thermo-chemical plumes. Ann. Geophys. 2,311. Chung, D. H. (1974). General relationship among sound speeds. I: New experimental information. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 8, 113. Clark, R. A. and Pearce, R. G. (1981). Comments on “Lateral heterogeneity at the base of the mantle revealed by observations of amplitudes of PKP phases” by I. S. Sacks, J. A. Snoke and L. Beach. Geophys. J . 66,741. Clark, S. P. Jr. and Ringwood, A. E. (1964). Density distribution and constitution of the mantle. Rev. Geophys. 2,35. Clark, S . P. Jr. and Turekian, K. K. (1979). Thermal constraints in the distribution of long-lived radioactive elements in the Earth. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A291,269. Cleary, J. R. (1969). The S-velocity at the core-mantle boundary from observations of diffracted S . Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 59, 1399. Cleary, J. R. (1974). The D region. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 9, 13.
General Physical Properties of t.be Earth
73
Cleary, J. R. (1981). Seismic wave scattering on underside reflection at the core-mantle boundary. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 26, 266. Cleary, J. R. and Haddon, R. A. W. (1972). Seismic wave scattering near the core-mantle boundary: a new interpretation of precursors to PKP. Nature 240, 549. Cook, A. H. (1963). The contribution of observations of satellites to the determination of the Earth’s gravitational potential. Space Sci. Rev. 2, 355. Cormier, V. F. (1981). Short-period P K P phases and the anelasticity mechanism of the inner core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 24,291. Cormier, V. F. and Richards, P. G. (1976). Comments on “The damping of core waves” by Anthony Qamar and Alfred0 Eisenberg. J . Geophys. Res. 81,3066. Crossley, D. J. (1975). Core undertones with rotation. Geophys. J . 42,477. Crossley, D. J. (1976). Reply to comments on “Core undertones with rotation” by M. L. Smith. Geophys. J . 44,729. Crossley, D. J. (1984). Oscillatory flow in the liquid core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 36, 1. Crossley, D. J. and Rochester, M. G. (1980). Simple core undertones. Geophys. J . 60, 129. Crossley, D. J. and Smylie, D. E. (1975). Electromagnctic and viscous damping of core oscillations. Geophys. J . 42, 1011. Dahlen, F. A. (1968). The normal modes of a rotating elliptical Earth. Geophys. J . 16,329. Dahlen, F. A. (1969). The normal modes of a rotating ellipical Earth-11: New resonance multiplet coupling. Geophys. J . 18,397. Dahlen, F. A. and Smith, F. L. (1975). The influence of rotation on the free oscillations of the Earth. Phil. Trans. R o y . Soc. London A279, 583. Denson, M. E. (1952). Longitudinal waves through the Earth’s core. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 42, 119. Derr, J. S. (1969). Internal structure of the Earth inferred from free oscillations. J . Geophys. Res. 74, 5202. Doornbos, D. J. (1974). The anelasticity of the inner core. Geophys. J . 38,397. Doornbos, D. J. (1976). Characteristics of lower mantle inhomogeneities from scattered waves. Geophys. J . 44,447. [Correction 49,541 (1977).] Doornbos, D. J. (1978). On seismic wave-scattering by a rough, core-mantle boundary. Geophys. J . 53,643. Doornbos, D. J. (1980). The effect of a rough core-mantle boundary on PKKP. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 21,351. Doornbos, D. J. (1981). The observable effect of wave interaction with a rough core-mantle boundary. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 26,264. Doornbos, D. J. (1983). Present seismic evidence for a boundary layer at the base of the mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 88,3498. Doornbos, D. J. and Mondt, J. C. (1979a). Attenuation of P and S waves diffracted round the core. Geophys. J . 57,353. Doornbos, D. J. and Mondt, J. C. (1979b). P and S waves diffracted around the core and the velocity structure at the base of the mantle. Geophys. J . 57,381. Dorman, J., Ewing, J. and Alsop, L. (1965). Oscillations of the Earth: new core-mantle boundary model based on low-order free vibrations. Proc. N a t . Acad. Sci. U S A 54,364. Dziewonski, A. M. (1970). Correlation properties of free period partial derivatives and their relation to the resolution of gross Earth data. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 60,741. Dziewonski, A. M. (1971). Overtones of free oscillations and the structure of the Earth’s interior. Science 172, 1336. Dziewonski, A. M. (1984). Mapping the lower mantle: determination of lateral heterogeneity in P velocity up to degree and order 6. J . Geophys. Res. 89,5929.
74
The Earths Core
Dziewonski, A. M. and Anderson, D. L. (1981). Preliminary reference Earth model. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 25,297. Dziewonski, A. M. and Gilbert, F. (1971). Solidity of the inner core of the Earth inferred from normal mode observations. Nature 234,465. Dziewonski, A. M. and Gilbert, F. (1972). Observations of normal modes from 84 recordings of the Alaska earthquake of 1964, March 28. Geophys. J . 27,393. Dziewonski, A. M. and Gilbert, F. (1973a). Observations of normal modes from 84 recordings of the Alaska earthquake of 1964, March 28. 11: Further remarks based on new spheroidal overtone data. Geophys. J . 35,401. Dziewonski, A. M. and Gilbert, F. (1973b). Identification of normal modes using spectral stacking and stripping. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 54,374. Dziewonski, A. M. and Haddon, R. A. W. (1974). The radius of the core-mantle boundary inferred from travel-time and free oscillation data; a critical review. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 9, 28. Dziewonski, A. M., Hales, A. L. and Lapwood, E. R. (1975). Parametrically simple Earth models consistent with geophysical data. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 10, 12. Dziewonski, A. M., Hager, B. H. and OConnell, R. J. (1977). Large scale heterogeneities in the lower mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 82,239. Engdahl, E. R. (1968). Core phases and the Earth’s core. PhD Thesis, St. Louis University. Engdahl, E. R. and Johnson, L. E. (1972). A new PCP data set from nuclear explosions on Amchitka Island. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 53, 1045. Engdahl, E. R. and Johnson, L. E. (1974). Differential PCP travel times and the radius of the core. Geophys. J . 39,435. Engdahl, E. R., Flinn, E. A. and Romney, C. F. (1970). Seismic waves reflected from the Earth‘s inner core. Nature 228,852. Engdahl, E. R., Flinn, E. A. and Masse, R. P. (1974). Differential PKiKP travel times and the radius of the inner core. Geophys. J . 39,457. Ergin, K. (1967). Seismic evidence for a new layered structure of the Earth’s core. J . Geophys. Res. 72, 3669. Falzone, A. J. and Stacey, F. D. (1980). Second-order elasticity theory: explanation for the high Poissons’s ratio of the inner core. Phys. Earth Planet. Znt. 21,371. Fearn, D. R., Loper, D. E. and Roberts, P. H. (1981). Structure of the Earth’s inner core. Nature 292,232. Franklin, J. N. (1970). Well-posed stochastic extensions of ill-posed linear problems. J . Math. Analysis Applic. 31, 682. Friedlander, S . (1985). Internal oscillations in the Earth’s fluid core. Geophys. J . 80,345. Gans, R. F. (1972a). Reflection of SH in the presence of a magnetic field. Geophys. J . 29,173. Gans, R. F. (1972b). Viscosity of the Earth’s core. J . Geophys. Res. 77,360. Gilbert, F. and Dziewonski, A. M. (1975). An application of normal mode theory to the retrieval of structural parameters and source mechanisms for seismic spectra. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC. London A278,187. Gilbert, F. and Helmberger, D. (1972). Generalized ray theory for a layered sphere. Geophys. J . 27,57. Gilbert, F., Dziewonski, A. M. and Brune, J. (1973). An informative solution to a seismological inverse problem. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U S A 70, 1410. Greenspan, H. P. (1968). The Theory ofRotating Fluids. Cambridge University Press, London. Gutenberg, B. (1913). Uber die Konstitution des Erdinnern, erschlossen aus Erdbebenbeobachtungen. Phys. Z . 14,1217. Gutenberg, B. (1957). The “boundary” of the Earth’s inner core. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 38, 750. I
General Physical Properties of the €arth
75
Gutenberg, B. (1958a). Wave velocities in the Earth’s core. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 48,301. Gutenberg, B. (1958b). Caustics produced by waves through the Earth’s core. Geophys. J . 1,238. Gutenberg, B. (1959). Physics of the Earth’s Interior. Academic Press, London and Orlando. Gutenberg, B. and Richter, C. F. (1938). P and the Earth’s core. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. Geophys. Suppl. 4,363. Gutenberg, B. and Richter, C. F. (1939). On seismic waves. Gerl. Beit. Geophys. 54,94. Haddon, R. A. W. (1972). Corrugations on the mantle-core boundary or transition layers between inner and outer core? Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union. 53,600. Haddon, R. A. W. (1982). Evidence for inhomogeneities near the core-mantle boundary. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.London A306,61. Haddon, R. A. W. and Bullen, K. E. (1969). An Earth model incorporating free Earth oscillation data. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 2,35. Haddon, R. A. W. and Cleary, J. R. (1974). Evidence for scattering of seismic PKP waves near the mantle-core boundary. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 8,211. Hage, H. (1981). P and S velocity jump at the inner-core boundary from PKP amplitudes. In Identification of Seismic Sources-Earthquakes or Underground Explosions (E. S . Husebye and S. Mykkeltreit eds), p. 483. D. Reidel, New York. Hage, H. (1983). Velocity constraints for the inner core inferred from long-period PKP amplitudes. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 31, 171. Hager, B. H., Clayton, R. W., Richards, M. A,, Comer,’R. P. and Dziewonski, A. M. (1985). Lower mantle heterogeneity, dynamic topography and the geoid. Nature 313, 541. Hai, N. (1961). Propagation des ondes longitudinales dans le noyeau terrestre d’apres les seismes profonds de Iles Fidji. Ann. Geophys. 17,60. Hai, N. (1963). Propagation des ondes longitudinales dans le noyeau terrestre. Ann. Geophys. 19, 285. Hales, A. L. and Maki-Lopez, M. L. (1980). P travel times from Nevada test site explosions and the determination of average global P travel times. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 23, 188. Hales, A. L. and Roberts, J. L. (1970). Shear velocities in the lower mantle and the radius of the core. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 60, 1427. Hales, A. L. and Roberts, J. L. (1971). The velocities in the outer core. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 61, 1051. Hales, A. L., Lapwood, E. R. and Dziewonski, A. M. (1974). Parameterization of a spherically symmetric Earth model with special reference to the upper mantle. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 9,9. Hannon, W. J. and Kovach, R. L. (1966). Velocity filtering of seismic core phases. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 54,441. Hart, R. S., Anderson, D. L. and Kanamori, H. (1976). Shear velocity and density of an attenuating Earth. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 32, 25. Hart, R. S., Anderson, D. L. and Kanamori, H. (1977). The effect of attenuation on gross earth models. J . Geophys. Res. 82, 1647. Herrin, E. (1968). Introduction to the 1968 Seismological Tables for P phases. Bull. Seism. SOC. Amer. 58, 1193. Herrin, E., Tucker, W., Taggart, J., Gordon, D. W. and Lobdell, J. L. (1968). Estimation of surface focus P travel times. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 58, 1273. Hide, R. (1971). Viscosity of the Earth’s core. Nature Phys. Sci. 233,100. Hide, R. and Horai, K. I. (1968). On the topography of the coremantle interface. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 1, 305. Higgins, G. and Kennedy, G. C. (1971). The adiabatic gradient and the melting point gradient in the core of the Earth. J . Geophys. Res. 76,1870.
76
The Earths Core
Husebye, E. S., King, D. W. and Haddon, R. A. W. (1976). Precursors to PKIKP and seismic wave scattering near the mantle-core boundary. J . Geophys. Res. 81,1870. Ibrahim, A. K. (1971). The amplitude ratio PCPjP and the core-mantle boundary. Pure Appl. Geophys. 91,114. Ibrahim, A. K. (1973). Evidences for a low velocity core-mantle transition zone. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 7, 187. Jackson, D. D. (1972). Interpretation of inaccurate, insufficient and inconsistent data. Geophys. J . 28,97. Jackson, D. D. and Anderson, D. L. (1970). Physical mechanisms of seismic-wave attenuation. Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 8 , l . Jacobs, J. A. (1968). The structure of the Earth’s core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 1, 196. Jacobs, J. A. (1970). Geophysical numerology. Nature 227,161. Jeanloz, R. and Richter, F. M. (1979). Convection, composition and thermal state of the lower mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 84, 5497. Jeffreys, H. (1936). On travel times in seismology. Bur. Cent. Seism.Inter. A,, Fasc. 14, 1. Jeffreys, H. (1937). On the materials and density of the Earth’s crust. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. SOC. Geophys. Suppl. 4,50. Jeffreys, H. (1939a). The times of P, S and SKS and the velocities of P and S . Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. SOC.Geophys. Suppl. 4,498. Jeffreys, H. (1939b). The times of PCP and SCS. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. Geophys. Suppl. 4, 537. Jeffreys, H. (1939~).The times of the core waves. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. SOC.Geophys. Suppl. 4, 548. Jeffreys, H. (1939d). The times of the core waves. Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. Geophys. Suppl. 4, 594. Jeffreys, H. (1961). Theory of Probability. Clarendon Press, Oxford. Jeffreys, H. (1965). The damping of S waves. Nature 208,675. Jeffreys, H. (1967). Radius of the Earth’s core. Nature 215,1365. Jeffreys, H. (1978). On imperfections of elasticity in the Earth’s interior. Geophys. J . 55,273. Jeffreys, H. and Bullen, K. E. (1935). Times of transmission of earthquake waves. Bur. Cent. Seism. Inter. A. Fasc. 11. Jeffreys, H. and Bullen, K. E. (1940). Seismological Tables. British Association, Gray-Milne Trust. Johnson, I. M. and Smylie, D. E. (1977). A variational approach to whole-Earth dynamics. Geophys. J . 50,35. Johnson, L. E. and Gilbert, F. (1972a). Inversion and inference for teleseismic ray data. In Methods in Computational Physics (B. A. Bolt, ed.) vol. 11, p. 231. Johnson, L. E. and Gilbert, F. (1972b). A new datum for use in the body wave travel time inverse problem. Geophys. J . 30,373. Johnson, L. R. (1967). Array measurements of P velocities in the upper mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 72,6309. Johnson, L. R. (1969). Array measurements of P velocities in the lower mantle. Bull. Seism. SOC. Amer. 59,973. Jones, G . M. (1977). Thermal interaction of the core and the mantle and long term behaviour of the geomagnetic field. J . Geophys. Res. 82, 1703. Jordan, T. H. (1972). Estimation of the radial variation of seismic velocities and density in the Earth. PhD. Thesis, California Institute of Technology. Jordan, T. H. and Anderson, D. L. (1974). Earth structure from free oscillations and travel times. Geophys. J . 36,411. Julian, B. R., Davies, D. and Sheppard, R. M. (1972). PKJKP. Nature 235,317.
General Physical Properties of the Earth
77
Kanamori, H. (1967a). Spectrum of P and PCP in relation to the mantle-core boundary and attenuation in the mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 72,559. Kanamori, H. (1967b). Attenuation of P waves in the upper and lower mantle. Bull. Earthquake Res. Inst. 45,299. Karato, S. (1980). Low Q-zone at the base of the mantle: evidence for lower mantle convection? Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 22, 155. Keilis-Borok, V. I. and Yanovskaya, T. R. (1967). Inverse problems of seismology. Geophys. J . 13, 223. King, D. W., Haddon, R.A. W. and Cleary, J. R.(1973). Evidence for seismic wave scattering in the D layer. Earth Planet. Sci. Left.20,353. King, D. W., Haddon, R. A. W. and Cleary, J. R. (1974). Array analysis of precursors to PKIKP in the distance range 128" to 142". Geophys. J . 37, 157. Knopoff, L. (1964). Quart. Rev. Geophys. 2,625. KnopofT, L. and MacDonald, G. J. F. (1958). The magnetic field and the central core of the Earth. Geophys. J . 1,216. Kogan, S. D. (1972). A study of the dynamics of a longitudinal wave reflected from the Earth's core. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR Earth Phys. 6,3. Kuster, G . T. (1972). Seismic wave propagation in two-phase media and its applications to the earth's interior. PhD. Thesis, MIT, Cambridge, MA. , Landisman, M., Sato, Y. and Nafe, J. (1965). Free vibrations of the Earth and the properties of its deep interior regions. 1: Density. Geophys. J . 9,439. Lay, T. and Helmberger, D. V. (1983a). A shear velocity discontinuity in the lower mantle. Geophys. Res. Lett. 10,63. Lay, T. and Helmberger, D. V. (1983b). A lower mantle S-wave triplication and the shear velocity structure of D . Geophys. J . 75,799. Lee, R. C. and Johnson, L. R. (1984a). Tau estimates for mantle P- and S-waves from global travel-time observations. Geophys. J . 77,655. Lee, R. C. and Johnson, L. R. (1984b). External bounds on the seismic velocities in the Earth's mantle. Geophys. J . 77,667. Lee, W. B. and Solomon, S. C. (1978). Simultaneous inversion of surface wave phase velocity and attenuation: waves in western North America. J . Geophys. Res. 83,3389. Lehmann, I. (1936). " P . Publ. Bur. Cent. Seism. I n t . Ser. A 14,3. Liebermann, R. C. and Ringwood, A. E. (1973). Birch's law and polymorphic phase transformations. J . Geophys. Rex 78,6926. Liu, L. (1982a). The F zone. Geophys. Res. Lett. 9,808. Liu, L. (1982b). Phase transformation in MgSiO, compounds at high pressures and their geophysical implications. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 57, 110. Liu, H. P., Anderson, D. L. and Kanamori, H. (1976). Velocity dispersion due to anelasticity: implications for seismology and mantle composition. Geophys. J . 47,41. Loper, D. E. (1984). Structure of the core and lower mantle. Adv. Geophys. 26,l. Loper, D. E. and Fearn, D. R. (1983). A seismic model of a partially molten inner core. J . Geophys. Res. 88, 1235. Luh, P. C. (1974). Normal modes of a rotating self-gravitating inhomogeneous Earth. Geophys. J . 38, 187. Malkus, W. V. R. (1968). Precession of the Earth as the cause of geomagnetism. Science 160,259. Masters, G. and Gilbert, F. (1981). Structure of the inner core inferred from observations of its spheroidal shear modes. Geophys. Res. Lett. 8,569. McMechan, G. A. and Wiggins, R. A. (1972). Depth limits in body wave inversions. Geophys. J . 28,459.
78
The Earth's Care
McQueen, R. G., Fritz, J. N. and Marsh, S. P. (1964). On the composition of the Earth's interior. J . Geophys. Res. 69,2947. Melchior, P, and Ducarme, B. (1985). Detection of inertial gravity oscillations in the Earth's core with a superconducting gravimeter at Brussels. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 42, 129. Mikumo, T. and Kurita, T. (1968). Q-distribution for long-period P waves in the mantle. J . Phys. Earth 16, 11. Mitchell, B. J. and Helmberger, D. V. (1973). Shear velocities at the base of the mantle from observations of S and SCS. J . Geophys. Res. 78,6009. Mizutani, H. and Abe, K. (1972). An Earth model consistent with free oscillation and surface wave data. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 5,345. Moon, W. (1982). Variational solution of long period oscillations of the Earth. Geophys. J . 69, 431. Moore, E. H. (1920). Bull. Am. Math. Soc. 26,394. Mula, A. H. G. (1981). Amplitudes of diffracted long-period P and S waves and the velocities and Q structure at the base of the mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 86,4999. Mula, A. H. and Muller, G. (1980). Ray parameters of diffracted long period P and S waves and the velocities at the base of the mantle. Pure Appl. Geophys. 118, 1270. Muller, G . (1973). Amplitude studies of core pkases. J . Geophys. Res. 78, 3469. Muller, G. (1975). Further evidence against discontinuities in the outer core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 10,70. Muller, G., Mula, A. H. and Gregersen, S. (1977). Amplitudes of long-period PCP and the coremantle boundary. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 14,30. Nuttli, 0.W. (1969). Travel times and amplitudes of S waves from nuclear explosions in Nevada. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 59,385. Okal, E. A. and Geller, R. J. (1979). Shear wave velocity at the base of the mantle from profiles of diffracted SH waves. Bull. Seism. Soc. Amer. 69,1039. Olson, P. (1977). Internal waves in the Earth's core. Geophys J . 51,183. ONions, R. K., Evensen, N. M., Hamilton, N. J. and Carter, S. R. (1978). Melting of the mantle past and present: isotope and trace element evidence. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A258, 547. Parker, R. L. (1970). The inverse problem ofelectrical conductivity in the mantle. Geophys. J . 22, 121. Parker, R. L. (1972a). The BackusGilbert method and its application to the electrical conductivity problem. In Mathematics of Projile Inversion (L. Colin, ed.). NASA Tech. Mem. 62, 150. Parker, R. L. (1972b). Inverse theory with grossly inadequate data. Geophys. J . 29,123. Pekeris, C. L. (1966). The internal constitution of the Earth. Geophys. J . 11,85. Pekeris, C . L. and Accad, Y. (1972). Dynamics of the liquid core of the Earth. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc,London A273,237. Pekeris, C. L., Alterman, Z . and Jarosch, H. (1961). Rotational multiplets in the spectrum of the Earth. Phys. Rev. 122, 1692. Penrose, R. (1955). A generalized inverse for matrices. Proc. Camb. Phil. SOC.51,406. Press, F. (1968a). Density distribution in Earth. Science 160, 1218. Press, F. (1968b). Earth models obtainedby Monte Carlo inversion. J . Geophys. Res. 73,5223 Press, F. (1970a). Earth models consistent with geophysical data. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 3,3. Press, F. (1970b). Regionalized Earth models. J . Geophys. Res. 75,6575. Qamar, A. (1973). Revised velocities in the Earth's core. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 63, 1073. Qamar, A. and Eisenberg, A. (1974). The damping of core waves. J . Geophys. Res. 79,758. Randall, M. J. (1970). SKS and seismic velocities in the outer core. Geophys. J . 21,441.
General Physical Properties of the Earth
79
Randall, M. J. (1976). Attenuative dispersion and frequency shifts of the Earth’s free oscillation. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 12, 1. Richards, P. G. (1973). Calculation of body waves, for caustics and tunnelling in core phases. Geophys. J . 35,243. Richards, M. A. and Hager, B. H. (1984). Geoid anomalies in a dynamic Earth. J . Geophys. Res. 89, 5987. Ringwood, A. E. (1972). Mineralogy of the deep mantle: current status and future developments. In The Nature of the Solid Earth (E. C. Robertson, ed.) McCraw-Hill, New York. Robinson, R. and Kovach, R. (1972). Shear wave velocities in the Earth’s mantle. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 5, 30. Rochester, M. G. (1970). Coresmantle interactions: geophysical and astronomical consequences. In Earthquake Displacement Fields and the Rotation ofthe Earth (L. Mansinha, D. E. Smylie and A. E. Beck, eds). D. Reidel, Holland. Ruff, L. J. and Helmberger, D. V. (1982). The structure of the lowermost mantle determined by sport-period P wave amplitudes. Geophys. J . 68,95. Sabadini R. and Peltier, W. R. (1981). Pleistocene deglaciation and the Earth’s rotation: implications for mantle viscosity. Geophys. J . 66, 553. Sacks, I. S. (1971a). Anelasticity of the outer core. Carnegie Inst. Year Book 69,414. Sacks, I. S. (1971b). Anelasticity of the inner core. Carnegie Insr. Year Book 69,416. Sacks, I. S. (1972). Q structure of the inner and outer core.’EOS Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union. 53, 601. Sacks, I. S. and Snoke, J. A. (1976). Heterogeneous structure at the base of the mantle, 2, Observations and interpretations. 1lth Int. Symp. Math. Geophys. Seeheim, West Germany. Sacks, I. S. and Snoke, J. A. (1981). Reply to Clark and Pearce. Geophys. J . 66,747. Sacks, I. S., Snoke, J. A. and Beach, L. (1979). Lateral homogeneity at the base of the mantle revealed by observations of amplitides of P K P phases. Geophys. J . 59,379. Sailor, R. V. and Dziewonski, A. M. (1978). Measurements and interpretation of normal mode attenuation. Geophys. J . 53,559. Sato, R. and Espinosa, A. F. (1967). Dissipation in the Earth’s mantle and rigidity and viscosity in the Earth’s core determined from waves multiply reflected from the mantle-core boundary. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 57, 829. Schlittenhardt, J., Schweitzer, J. and Miiller, G. (1985). Evidence against a discontinuity at the top of D”. Geophys. J . 81,295. Sengupta, M. K. and Julian, B. R. (1978). Radial variation of compressional and shear velocities in the Earth’s lower mantle. Geophys. J . 54, 185. Shankland, T. J. and Chung, D. H. (1974). General relationships among sound speeds. 11: Theory and discussion. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 8,121. Shen, P. Y. (1976). A theory of toroidal core oscillations of the Earth. Geophys. J . 46,307. Shen, P. Y. (1978). On gravitational oscillations of Earth’s outer core. EOS Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union. 59, 1027. Shen, P. Y. (1983). On oscillations of the Earth’s fluid core. Geophys. J . 75,737. Shen, P. Y. and Mansinha, L. (1976). Oscillation, nutation and wobble of an elliptical rotating Earth with liquid outer core. Geophys. J . 46,467. Simmons, G. (1964). Velocity of shear waves in rocks to 10 kilobars. J . Geophys. Res. 69,1123. Simmons, G. and Chung, D. H. (1968). A powder method for determining the elastic parameters of a solid. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union. 49,308. Simmons, G. and Wang, H. (1971). Single Crystal Elastic Constants and Calculated Aggregate Properties: a Handbook, 2nd edn. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. Smith, M. L. (1974). The scalar equations of infinitesimal elastic-gravitational motion for a rotating, slightly-elliptical Earth. Geophys. J . 37,491.
80
The Earth’s Core
Smith, M. L. (1976). Translational inner core oscillations of a rotating, slightly elliptical Earth. J . Geophys. Res. 81,3055. Smith, M. L. (1977). Wobble and nutation of the Earth. Geophys. J . 50, 103. Smylie, D. E. (1973). Dynamics of the outer core. Proc. 2nd Int. Symp. Geod. Phys. Earth, Potsdam. Smylie, D. E. (1974). Dynamics of the outer core. Veroff Zentralinst. Phys. Erde. Akad. Wiss. DDR 30,91. Smylie, D. E. and Mansinha, L. (1971). The elasticity theory of dislocation in real Earth models and changes in the rotation of the Earth. Geophys. J . 23,329. Smylie, D. E. and Rochester, M. G. (1981). Compressibility, core dynamics and the sub-seismic wave equation. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 24,308. Stacey, F. D. (1977). A thermal model of the Earth. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 15,341. Stacey, F. D. and Loper, D. E. (1983). The thermal boundary layer interpretation of D and its role as a plume source. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 33,45. Stiller, H., Franck, S. and Schmidt, U. (1980). On the attenuation of seismic waves in the Earth’s core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 22,221. Subiza, G. P. and Bath, M. (1964). Core phases and the inner core boundary. Geophys. J . 8,496. Taggart, J. and Engdahl, E. R. (1968). Estimation of PCP travel times and depth to the core. Bull. Seism. SOC.Amer. 58,1293. Teng, T. L. (1968). Attenuation of body waves and the Q structure of the mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 73,2195. Wang, C.-Y. (1968). Constitution of the lower mantle as evidenced from shock wave data for some rocks. J . Geophys. Res. 73,6459. Wang, C.-Y. (1970). Density and constitution of the mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 75,3264. Wang, C.-Y. (1972). A simple Earth model. J . Geophys. Res. 77,4318. Wiggins, R. A. (1969). Monte Carlo inversions of body wave observations. J . Geophys. Res. 74, 3171. Wiggins, R. A. (1972). The general linear inverse problem: implication of surface waves and free oscillations for Earth structure. Reu. Geophys. Space Phys. 10,251. Wiggins, R. A,, McMechan, G . A. and Toksoz, M. N. (1973). Range of Earth structure nonuniqueness implied by body wave observations. Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 11,87. Williamson, E. D. and Adams, L. H. (1923). Density distribution in the Earth. J . Wash. Acad. Sci. 13,413. Won, I. J. and Kuo, J. T. (1973). Oscillation of the Earth’s inner core and its relation to the generation of geomagnetic field. J . Geophys. Res. 78,905. Worthington, M. H., Cleary, J. R. and Anderssen, R. S. (1972). Density modelling by Monte Carlo inversion. 11: Comparison of recent Earth models. Geophys. J . 29,445. Wright, C. (1973). Array studies of P phases and the structure of the D region of the mantle. 1. Geophys. Res. 78,4965. Wunsch, C. (1974). Simple models of the deformation of an Earth with a fluid core, I. Geophys. J . 39,413. Wunsch, C. (1975). Simple models of the deformation of an Earth with a fluid core, 11. Dissipation and magnetohydrodynamic effects. Geophys. J . 41,165. Zener, C. (1948). Elasticity and Anelasticity ofMetals. Chicago University Press, Chicago. Zharkov, V. N., Karpov, P. B. and Leontjev, V. V. (1985). On the thermal regime of the boundary layer at the bottom of the mantle. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 41,138.
Chapter Two
The Origin of the Core
2.1
Introduction
A fundamental question in any discussion of the Earth’s core is its origin. Has the Earth always had a core, or has its present structure evolved over geological time? Such a question cannot be divorced from the much broader issue of the origin of the Earth itself. There is one constraint, however, that can be imposed upon possible evolutions. Most theories of the origin of the Earth’s magnetic field ascribe it to motions in the liquid OC (see $4.2). Rocks as old as 3500 Ma have been found which possess remanent magnetization, so that it is extremely probable that the Earth had a molten OC, comparable in size to that at present at least that long ago. No similar deductions can be made about the state of the IC. With regard to the broader question of the origin and evolution of the solar system, it must not be forgotten that it is by no means certain a priori that the problem can be given a definite answer. It may well be that all memory has been lost of the circumstances under which our solar system was born. All that we can do is to attempt to derive its present state from an assumed event or series of events that occurred in the distant past. Thus, in a sense, the method is one of trial and error. It is more reasonable to assume that planets are normally present in the vicinity of certain stars than to suppose that our planetary system is unique or at least very rare-there are about 200,000 million stars in our galaxy alone. The origin of the solar system is thus part of a very much larger problem-the evolution of the sun and stars in general. Theories of the origin of the Earth and other members of the solar system 81
82
The Earth's Core
may be classified in a number of ways. The Earth may have cooled from a hot gas or accreted cold from dust particles, probably of composition similar to that of chondritic meteorites. In the past, most theories of the origin of the Earth have assumed that the proto-Earth was homogeneous and that the present differentiation into a core, mantle and crust occurred later. There are, however, a number of difficulties with such theories, and there has been some discussion in recent years of non-homogeneous models. In such models, the core of the Earth is formed first and the mantle is deposited upon it later. Non-homogeneous models can also have either a hot or a cold origin. A hot origin involves a consideration of the order of condensation of the elements in the primitive solar nebula; a cold origin involves a study of the mechanics of the accretion process. 2.2
The Accretion Mechanism
Regardless of how stars like the sun form, at some time matter in the form of grains or small bodies must have aggregated to form the terrestrial planets. There are two possible mechanisms by which this may have been accomplished-gravitational collapse and accumulation. In the first case, matter aggregates into larger objects under the influence of a gravitational field following a gravitational instability. In the second case, bodies grow by the gradual addition of matter following collisions and coherence. These two processes may occur with or without the presence of a dynamically significant gas phase. During the initial stages of the evolution of the solar system, large amounts of gas must have been present and the beginning of planetary growth must have involved a gas phase. However, it is possible that the gas was removed by solar ultraviolet or corpusular radiation on a time-scale less than that required for the growth by collisions of the initial solid bodies that formed from gravitational instabilities in the dust layer of the solar nebula. A large body of literature exists on gas-free accumulation models of the evolution of the terrestrial planets: see, for example, Safronov (1969). The evolution of terrestrial planetary material from dust to planets can be considered in roughly three main stages. The early stage, producing kilometre-size planetesimals formed by smallscale gravitational instabilities of the dust layer alone. The intermediate stage, during which kilometre-sized planetesimals grow to 1000-km-sized bodies. The dynamical evolution of this stage is governed by two competing mechanisms: collisional fragmentation and gravitational accumulation. The late stage, or final stage, during which 1000-km-sized embryos grow to full-sized planets, with the right orbital spacing, eccentricities, inclina-
The Origin of the Core
83
tions, and rotations. Wetherill (1980a) has reviewed in detail these different phases of the formation of the terrestrial planets. For the smallest particle sizes, accumulation cannot be very rapid. The particles will collide, partly as a result of their Brownian motion in the gas, and partly as a result of acceleration by very weak electric fields that can be expected to be produced in the nebula through the interaction of convection with ionization produced by natural radioactivity. This state of accumulation may be greatly accelerated as a result of the natural magnetism of the interstellar grains. Purcell and Spitzer (1971) believe that the interstellar grains most probably would be ferromagnetic or super-paramagnetic, so that they could be aligned by the very weak interstellar magnetic field. If this is the case, and it appears to be consistent with evidence from meteorites (Brecher, 1971), then the interstellar grains would be able to come together to form considerably larger units, both during the late stages of the collapse that formed the primitive solar nebula and during the early history of the solar nebula itself. The cross-section for magnetic capture of one particle by another would be very much greater than the geometric cross-sections involved in ordinary non-magnetic collisions. The initial step is the presence of interstellar grains in the gas which, after some dregree of gas absorption, find themselves concentrated in the nebular plane and somehow manage to accrete into larger bodies. The main problem is the fact that the number of these bodies must eventually be considerably reduced: from swarms of small bodies, eventually a few large planets must be produced. This reduction can only take place by collisions. The model of Safronov (1969, 1972) starts with a quiet nebula in which dust particles rotate and begin to sink slowly (under gravity) towards the equatorial plane. The assumption is made that all the particles such a dust particle meets on the way down adhere to it, and, upon arriving at mid-plane (after 2: 103-104 years) it has reached a size of N 1 cm. The critical assumption is the so called “cold welding” of matter which represents an upper limit to the efficiency of the process. When the density of the dust layer exceeds a certain value, condensation of matter would be induced by gravitational instabilities. In those regions close to the sun, gas motions would have been too fast for gravitational instabilities to take place and growth of bodies could only occur through aggregation during collisions. Safronov argued that the relative velocities of the bodies would be determined by their gravitational perturbations at encounters and should be less than 1 m s - so long as the objects were less than 5 km in diameter. Alfvkn and Arrhenius (1970a,b, 1973) solved the problem of reducing the relative velocities of colliding bodies so as to facilitate coalescence by the concept of “jet” streams. They argued that collisions
a4
The Earth‘s Core
between particles in Keplerian orbits do not lead to a spreading but to an equalization of the orbits of the particles when the collisional frequency is smaller than the orbital frequency. This state, in any theory of this type, either prevails originally or develops by accretion. It results in a focusing of particles into jet streams with increasingly similar orbital elements and velocities of the individual particles. The partially inelastic collisions will lead to the growth of embryo bodies of which some eventually reach the size where gravitational accretion becomes increasingly important. Alfven and Arrhenius believe that the maximum possible velocity for accretion is 0.5 km s- It must be pointed out that the jet stream hypothesis of Alfvtn and Arrhenius has not been universally accepted (see e.g. Reeves (1972), p. 86-87, for a discussion on this point). Cameron (1972) has also recognized that, during the lifetime of the nebula, collision probabilities were too low for accretion to take place in any reasonable time. He suggested, however, that during the collapse phase from the interstellar cloud to the nebula the situation was much more favourable, since violent gas motions (in the form of turbulent eddies) would have considerably increased the collision probabilities of gas and grains. Cameron estimated typical grain velocities to be N 10 m s-’. At the end of the collapse the nebula is formed and turbulence rapidly decays out, embedding a set of bodies up to 20 cm in radius. Goldreich and Ward (1973) investigated the process whereby dust particles can accrete to form gravitationally active objects. They concluded that gravitational instabilities can account for the growth of objects up to several km in radius. These instabilities develop, not in the gaseous solar nebula, but in a thin disc of particulate matter that forms in the central plane during an initial condensation phase. A first generation of planetesimals whose radii range up to 0.1 km form from this dust disc by gravitational collapse in a time-scale of order 1 year. The resulting disc of first-generation planetesimals is still gravitationally unstable and the planetesimals group into clusters. The clusters then contract on a time-scale of a few thousand years to form a second generation of planetesimals having radii of order 5 km. The contraction is controlled by the rate at which gas drag damps their internal rotation and random kinetic energy. In Goldreich and Ward’s model planetary accretion does not depend on the if the dust grains tend to “stickiness” of the surface of the dust particles-ven stick together upon impact, the growth of solid bodies by this process would be much slower than by gravitational instabilities. However, Weidenschilling (1980) pointed out that non-Keplerian rotation of the solar nebula results in shear between the gas and a dust layer. This shear produces turbulence within the layer that inhibits gravitational instability unless the mean particles are larger than a critical size (- 1 cm at 1 AU). Weidenschilling believes that
’.
85
The Origin of the Core
some coagulation of grains is possible in the solar nebula; Van der Waals forces may be sufficient to allow formation of centimetre-sized aggregates during settling to the central plane. Growth is primarily due to the sweeping up of small particles by larger ones: settling times are lo3 years in the inner nebula and lo4 years in the outer regions. Drag-induced relative velocities then result in collisions and larger bodies can accrete if reasonable impact lo3cm, relative velocities decrease strength is assumed. After sizes reach and the growth rate declines. Damping of out-of-plane motions by gas drag concentrates these intermediate-sized bodies into a thin layer that is subject to gravitational instability. Kilometre-sized planetesimals are then formed. In Weidenschilling’s model, the formation of planetesimals is a composite process involving, first, a stage of collisional accretion, followed by gravitational instability. Similar conclusions were reached by Nakagawa et al. (1981) using a different numerical method and different assumptions in their model. In the evolution of a growing swarm of planetesimals, relative velocities will be increased by mutual gravitational perturbations, and decreased by dissipative collisions. If the relative velocity is too high (say, several times the gravitational escape velocity of the growing planet), fragmentation rather than accumulation will be dominant and planets will not grow. On the other hand, if relative velocities are too low, the system of planetesimals will be in nearly circular concentric orbits, and the collisions required for growth will not take place. Safronov (1962) showed that for plausible assumptions regarding dissipation of energy in collisions, and size distribution of the bodies, the mutual gravitational perturbations of the bodies cause their mean relative velocity to be only somewhat less than the escape velocity of the larger bodies. Thus, throughout the entire course of planetary growth, from 1-km planetesimals to Earth-sized planets, the system regulated itself in such a way that the larger bodies could always grow, whereas smaller objects would fragment. In its initial, non-gravitational stage, the accretion process may be regarded as a series of collisions between grains in intersecting orbits under conditions that result in a net transfer of mass to some of the grains. An important parameter for accretion theories is the range of impact velocities over which accretion occurs. Kerridge and Vedder (1 972) experimentally investigated this velocity range by observing the impact at different velocities of particles similar to material thought to be present in the early solar system. The projectile material used was kaolinite (a hydrated aluminium silicate) in the form of thin micrometer-sized laminated flakes with a density of 2.63 g cm-3. Such material structurally resembles the major mineral component of the primitive type I carbonaceous chondrites and may well have been widespread in the early solar system. For target material, thick ( - 5 mm) sections of clinochrysotile (a magnesium silicate) with a density of 2.50 g cm- were
-
-
-
86
The Earths Core
used. They found that in any velocity range, impacts in which a significant transfer of projectile material occurred were outnumbered by those in which little or no transfer took place. Moreover, such impacts, at least those above 2 km s-’ were accompanied by the formation of craters with dimensions comparable to or greater than those of the projectile. Thus no accretion could take place for impacts in the velocity range studied (1.5-9.5 km s-l). By contrast, Neukum (1968) showed that for micrometer-sized iron particles impacted into a variety of metallic targets, almost the entire projectile mass is transferred to the target in the velocity range 0.5-13 km s - I . Below 0.5 km s - ’ iron particles rebounded from the metallic targets. There is thus a striking difference between the accretion behaviour of silicates and that of metals-over at least part of the velocity range in which silicate accretion was efficient, metal particles would have rebounded without accreting. Simple accretion theory cannot, therefore, be applied to silicate particles in markedly dissimilar orbits but must be restricted to situations characterized by generally low interparticle velocities. Whether or not impacts at lower velocities can actually lead to accretion of material is not known. No obvious sticking mechanism exists for bonding normal silicates together during lowvelocity impact, although a number of mechanisms have been proposed based on assumed properties of primordial dust grains. Possibly the sticking process was aided by the presence of the volatile coatings on the grains. Alternatively, adhesion may have been prompted by electrostatic charge asymmetries produced in the surface regions of circumsolar grains by charged particle irradiation, as proposed by Arrhenius et al. (1972) A third possible mechanism, suggested by Maurette and Bibring (1972), is the release of stored energy from the irradiation-damaged amorphous rims of grains exposed to the solar wind. Kerridge and Vedder (1972) suggested that metal-silicate fractionation in the solar system may have been affected by differences in the accretionary behaviour of metal and silicate particles. In particular, at the low velocities that must have prevailed during most of the accretionary process, silicates would have preferentially accreted. Similarly, if some regions of the solar system were characterized by higher interparticle velocities, bodies enriched in metal may have been produced. In this respect it may be significant that among the terrestrial planets there is a rough tendency for density, and therefore assumed metal content, to increase with orbital velocity. Dole (1970) developed a computer program to simulate the formation of planetary systems. Planets are assumed to form by aggregation of particles within a cloud of dust and gas surrounding the newly-formed sun. In his model nuclei are “injected” into the cloud one at a time, on elliptical orbits. The dimensions of the semimajor axis and the eccentricity of the orbit of each nucleus are determined by using random numbers. As the nuclei orbit within
87
The Origin of the Core
I
I
I
I I
0.11 -.-.--.
I I ' I
-.-.0.12
2
0.0001
0.36 :
0.005 0.04
0.36
0.05
0.06
""I
2.50
1.27
0.003
I I
I
I
" h
1.08
-
r
\
13.4 n
1.08 0.821
0.1 1 -
-
1
0.15
0.18 .
I
0.1
I
0.24
I I i l l l l I 1 I 1 I 1 I l l 1 10 Orbital distance (a. u.)
1
2.43
I
I I
I t l L
100
Fig.2.1. Planetary systems generated by Dole (1 970). Solid circles represent terrestrial planets, while open circles indicate Jovian planets that have accreted gas as well as dust. The radius of each circle is scaled solely by the cube root of the planet's mass, given in the figures in units of Earth masses. The positions of Jovian planets are given by the centres of the circles. All planets produced are well separated, as the relative positions of their centres indicate. (After lsaacman and Sagan. 1977.)
the cloud they grow by aggregation and gradually sweep out dust-free annular lanes. If they grow larger than a specified critical mass they can begin to accumulate gas as well from the cloud. If the orbit of a planet comes inside a certain interaction distance from a planet that was formed earlier, or if the orbits cross one another, the two bodies coalesce to form a single, more massive, planet which may then continue to grow by aggregation. The process of injecting nuclei is continued until all the dust has been swept from the system. Each planetary system produced by using a different random number sequence is unique. However, all the systems so produced share the major regular features of our solar system (see Fig. 2.1.) The orbital spacings have patterns of regularity suggestive of "Bode's Law". The innermost planets are small rocky bodies; the mid-range planets are large gaseous bodies; the outermost planets are generally small. The general pattern of planetary mass distribution is similar to that in our solar system with masses ranging from less than that of Mercury to greater than Jupiter's. Dole was able to produce planetary systems of recognizable characteristics
a8
The Earth’s Core
only with a certain choice of input parameters and assumed structure of the solar nebula. Isaacman and Sagan (1977) investigated the consequences of varying these parameters and assumptions. They found that only for a small subset of conceivable cases are planetary systems generated that are closely like our own. Many models have tendencies toward one of two preferred configurations: multiple-star systems, or planetary systems in which Jovian planets either have substantially smaller masses than in our system or are absent altogether. However, for a wide range of cases recognizable planetary systems are generated, ranging from multiple-star systems with accompanying planets, to systems with Jovian planets at several hundred astronomical units, to single stars surrounded only by asteroids. Many systems exhibit planets like Pluto and objects of asteroidal mass, in addition to usual terrestrial and Jovian planets. No terrestrial planets were generated more massive than five Earth masses. The number of planets per system is for most cases of the order 10, and, roughly, inversely proportional to the orbital eccentricity of the accreting grains. All systems generated obey a relation of the TitiusBode variety for relative planetary spacing. Isaacman and Sagan comment that it is rather remarkable that such a simple and incomplete model, based merely on Newtonian physics and accretion with unit sticking efficiency, should generate plausible planetary systems for a wide variety of initial conditions. A problem with these simulations is the neglect of mutual gravitational perturbations, which could play a major role during the latest stage of planetary growth. Also, velocities are assumed that are impossibly high in the gaseous interplanetary medium. In his models, Hills (1970) includes gravitational perturbations but ignores collisions. Wetherill (1978) has discussed the shortcomings of many of these earlier attempts at numerical simulations of multi-planet growth and pointed out that in the real solar system accumulation of the terrestrial planets proceeded more or less simultaneously. Greenberg et al. (1978a) carried out a numerical simulation of collisional and gravitational interactions in a possible early solar system. Their results show that “planets” 500 km in diameter can be generated from an initial swarm of kilometre-sized planetesimals, such as might have resulted from gravitational instabilities in the solar nebula. Their models are based on experimental (see Hartmann, 1978) and theoretical impact results (such as rebound, cratering and catastrophic fragmentation) for a reasonable range of parameters and initial conditions. The experimental work of Hartmann indicated that by the time bodies of multi-metre size have formed, they should have regolith surfaces or granular structure throughout. Regolith strongly favours accretion by inhibiting rebound, so that such bodies would have grown very efficiently by collisions with neighbouring bodies. The small planets grow fast on time-scales of a few tens of thousands of years, during which time most of the mass of the system continues to remain in particles
89
The Origin of the Core
near the original size. Relative random velocities remain of the order of a kilometre-sized body’s escape velocity, those of the largest objects being somewhat lower because of damping by the bulk of the material. Greenberg et al. suggested that the few 500-km-sized planets, in a swarm still dominated by kilometre-scale planetesimals, may act as seeds for the subsequent, gradual accretional growth into full-sized planets. While there are uncertainties about many stages of the origin of the solar system and planetary accretion, one of the most serious questions concerns the intermediate phase of accretion, i.e. growth after the hypothetical formation of planetesimals by gravitational instability (Safronov, 1972; Goldreich and Ward, 1973) but before the later stages of accretion when the largest bodies have substantial gravitational cross-sections. It is not clear how planetesimals could have efficiently accreted one another. However, the modelling of Greenberg et al. (1978a), based on detailed physical experiments involving low-velocity collisions among rocky bodies, demonstrates that accretion through this intermediate size range is efficient and rapid-it is a natural result of low-velocity rebound phenomena. Greenberg et al. point out that additional physical processes might be important in this intermediate stage, such as resonant phenomena that might accelerate or retard growth in certain zones, and gas-drag. A potentially disrupting influence on accretion would be high-velocity bodies, perhaps scattered into the zone of interest by an early-formed Jupiter. In this regard, Hartmann (1978) suggested that highvelocity planetesimals passing through the asteroid belt could have stopped further growth of Ceres, rather than a lack of accretable material. Greenberg (1979) later considered the problem of the size of the largest planetesimals that grew near, and later impacted, those that became full-sized planets. The question is important since the final stages of the growth of a terrestrial planet would significantly affect many of its fundamental properties, such as its thermal history and petrology. Greenberg showed that given the range of plausible mechanisms, parameters and initial conditions, possible results for the radius of the second largest planetesimal in the Earth’s zone range from only a few hundred kilometres to 2500 km, with corresponding accretion times of 7 x lo6 and lo8 years respectively. Cox (1978) and Cox and Lewis (1980) carried out numerical simulations to determine whether terrestrial-like planetary systems could be produced as a result of gravitationally-induced collisions and accretions occurring in a swarm of protoplanets assumed to have already reached approximately lunar mass. In their calculations the mass and relative velocity distributions of the bodies are free to evolve simultaneously in response to close gravitational encounters and occasional collisions between bodies. Thus, collisions between bodies arise in a natural way and assumptions concerning the relative velocity distribution and the gravitational collision cross-section are
-
-
90
The Earth‘s Core
unnecessary. The initial eccentricities of the orbits were randomly chosen from a uniform distribution ranging from zero to emax.Their model was twodimensional: the inclinations remain zero throughout the evolutionary ~ 0 . 1 0resulted in process. Cox and Lewis found that simulations with emax final-state configurations having many bodies of nearly equal mass, none of which were comparable to that of the Earth or Venus. Simulations with emax >0.20 resulted in a substantial number of catastrophically disruptive collisions between bodies. On the other hand, simulations with emaxN 0.15 gave six planets, surprisingly close to the actual number (4), with spacings between orbits resembling those of the terrestrial planets. This rather large value of emaxis mainly the consequence of assuming coplanar motions. Cox and Lewis estimated the length of time for the stage of accretion considered in their simulations to be ~2 x lo7 years. Wetherill (1978) and Greenberg et al. (1978b) have questioned whether a self-contained swarm can avoid premature orbital isolation of embryo planets, with the consequent production of too many small bodies. Wetherill (1980b) also investigated to what extent the simulations of Cox (1978) and Cox and Lewis (1980) depend on the calculations being two-dimensional. Wetherill used a different (less exact) method of calculation, but reproduced = 0.05 and 0.10 for the two-dimensional case in which 8 Cox’s results for emax to 10 bodies finally remain. In the three-dimensional case, the final number of bodies is reduced to 3-5 for a low value of emax= 0.05 (see Fig. 2.2) The difference between the three- and two-dimensional results is a consequence of the lesser importance of collisions relative to gravitational perturbations in three dimensions. The time-scale for accretion is lo8 years, most of it occurring during the first 20 Ma. The three-dimensional treatment allows accumulation to proceed for a longer time prior to the separation of embryo planets into isolated orbits*. Spaute et al. (1985) have studied the dynamical evolution of an initial population of kilometre-sized planetesimals in the early solar system subject to collisions, taking into account accretion, rebound, cratering and catastrophic fragmentation. They used a Monte-Carlo statistical method which yielded the mass and velocity distribution of the planetesimals as a function of time and heliocentric distance. They carried out a number of computations simulating the accretional growth of planetesimals (initial mass N 10l6g) in the absence (or presence) of gas-drag, with (or without) one larger embryo among them and with (or without) a size gradient. The work of Spaute et al.
-
* Wetherill has since carried out more sophisticated similar calculations (in Origin of the Moon, W. K. Hartmann, R. J. Phillips, G. J. Taylor eds, Lunar & Planetary Institute, Houston, 1986). He concluded that for a wide range of initial conditions, terrestrial planet accumulation was characterized by giant impacts, ranging in mass up to 3 times that of Mars, at typical impact velocities of 9 km s - I .
-
91
The Origin of the Core
I
l
l
l
15
,
l
0.8
,
25
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
11
2rcl9
-
21 w
42 w l
l
w -
w
H
l
34
30
13
l
l
W
w
I
l
39
16 w
0.4
l
1
i
24
l
l
1.2
l
l
l
l
l
l
1.6
l
l
2.0
l
l
l
2.4
Heliocentric distance (a.u.1 Fig. 2.2. Final distribution of mass found in three-dimensional calculations of multiplanet accumula= 0.05). The tion. A reasonable number of planets is formed even for low initial eccentricities (emax numbers represent the percentage of the total mass of the system. (After Wetherill 1980a.b.)
is an extension of that of Greenberg et al. (1978a) by considering the effect of gas-drag. Gas-drag can cause some planetesimals to move inside the feeding zone of an embryo, allowing their further growth to reach planetary size. This could help to overcome the difficulty of embryos becoming isolated from the remaining population. Nakagawa et al. (1983) also considered the effect of gas in their study of the evolution of intermediate-sized planetesimals. However, the effect of gas-drag is more important in the simulations of Spaute et al. than in those of Nakagawa et al., since the initial mass of the planetesimals in Spaute et al.3 models is one-hundredth of the mass assumed by Nakagawa et al. Specifically, Spaute et al. showed that, assuming an initial negative size gradient as the heliocentric distance increases, local accumulation of planetesimals can take place by gas-drag alone leading to embryos a few hundred kilometres in radius. Moreover, when an embryo is present among a population of planetesimals, its growth is about twice as rapid in the presence of gas-drag since gas-drag allows a continuous feeding of the embryo by planetesimals moving inwards towards the sun. When an embryo has become massive enough, it becomes more and more efficient in inhibiting the inward diffusion of planetesimals, limiting the growth of the next inner embryo. Such a process may have acted to prevent the formation of many small planets in contrast to the few large existing ones. Cazenave et a!. (1982) have also carried out numerical simulations of the latest stages of planet growth. They considered the motions of a small number of large protoplanets of unequal mass in orbit around the sun.
92
The Earth's Core
Mutual gravitational perturbations, accretion and collisional fragmentation are all taken into account. Their model is three-dimensional, gravitational encounters are treated exactly by numerical integration of the N-body problem, and the outcome of collisional fragmentation is based on the model of Greenberg et al. (1978a). They found that motion during close encounters departs significantly from that predicted by the two-body approximation. For large protoplanets (mass loz5g), accretion always prevails against fragmentation as long as relative velocities are not too great. The mean eccentricities and inclinations evolve towards a steady state, the average value of the inclination (in radians) being about one-half that of the eccentricity. Also, the population evolves towards a quasi-equilibrium relative velocity distribution whatever the initial conditions. Wetherill later (1985) extended his earlier (1980a, 1980b) work on the late stages of growth of the terrestrial planets. He considered the simultaneous growth of several planets from planetesimals in the absence of gas-drag using three-dimensional numerical calculations. He supposed that as most of the mass began to be concentrated in larger bodies, further evolution would be dominated by perturbations by large bodies in orbits of low eccentricity in neighbouring zones rather than by collisions of small bodies. This would cause the eccentricities to increase gradually and Wetherill estimated that there would be -500 bodies of mass -2.5 x when they reached -8 x g (i.e. - 3 the lunar mass). During the first 1.8 Ma, mutual perturbations increased eccentricities to values as high has 0.2. After 9.4 Ma two bodies with masses greater than 3 x loz7g and with relatively low eccentricities (about 0.03 or less) and inclinations ( < 3") formed, in addition to a large number of g (the size of Mercury or Mars). bodies with masses in the range loz6to At this stage, 71% of the final mass of the Earth accumulated. During the last stages of accumulation, requiring up to 2 x lo8 years, almost all these intermediate-mass bodies, including failed planets with masses greater than 3 x loz6g, collided and merged with the two bodies in orbits similar to those of the present Earth and Venus. The accumulation process was accompanied by the impact of very large bodies-as large as three times the mass of Mars at velocities of -9 km s-'. The kinetic energy released in these largest impacts would be several times greater than that required to melt the entire Earth. The Earth, as it grew, would have been at least partially melted throughout, leading to core formation by gravitational segregation of iron. A problem common to all models of cold origin is the means by which the Earth would have heated up sufficiently to lead to a (predominantly iron) molten OC at least 3500 Ma ago. This problem will be discussed in the next section.
-
93
The Origin of the Core
2.3 Heat Sources for an Earth Accreting Cold 2.3.1
Long-lived Radioactive Isotopes
The radioactive isotopes that contribute significantly to the present heatproduction within the Earth are 238U,235U,232Thand 40K,all of which have half-lives comparable to the age of the Earth. The temperature increase due to the radioactive decay of these long-lived isotopes is thus small, of the order of 150 K after 100 Ma (MacDonald, 1959). During the first 1000 Ma, the temperature increase would only be about 700 K (assuming no heat escape) while the total heat produced over the life-time of the Earth (-4500 Ma), if trapped within the Earth, would raise the temperature by 1800 K. Thus long-lived radioactive isotopes can account for part of the initial heating of the Earth, but other sources are necessary as well. It is usually assumed that there is no uranium in the Earth’s core, since uranium (and potassium) exist as siderophobic compounds, such as silicates and oxides in the Earth’s mantle, and were thus thought to be immiscible with the metal core (Urey, 1952). However Hodkin and Potter 1980) have carried out experiments on the binary system of steel and UO, and shown that above 3120 K the system is a two-phase liquid, one rich in UOz and the other poor in UOz. Their phase diagram predicts that there must be a temperature above which there is total miscibility between UO, and steel. Feber et al. (1984) thus suggested that uranium is steadily dissolving into the core and supplying radioactive heat, sufficient to power the geodynamo (see $4.6). The power required is IOl3 W (Gubbins 1981). Murrell et al. (1983), Murrell and Burnett (1985,1986) have carried out experimental work on the partitioning of K, U and Th between sulphide and silicate liquids. Contrary to what has usually been assumed, they found U and Th partitioning into Fe FeS liquids much more important than K partitioning. Of course, uranium could not act as a heat source in the core to power the geodynamo until the core was already molten. If the power required (- 1013 W) is supplied solely by the decay of 40K, the K concentration currently required in the core is 1500 ppm. On the other hand, the actinide core concentrations’ currently required are about 50 ppb U or 180 ppb Th. The question of the possibility of K in the Earth’s core is discussed further in Section 5.8.
-
-
-
2.3.2 Short-lived Radioactive Isotopes
Short-lived radioactive isotopes could have contributed to the initial heat of the Earth if the time between the formation of the elements and the aggregation of the Earth was short compared with the half-lives of the isotopes. The
94
The Earfhs Core
most important short-lived isotopes are 236U,I4%m, 244Puand 247Cm,all of which have half-lives sufficiently long to have heated up the Earth for some tens of million years after the initial formation. These four isotopes would, in fact, have contributed about 20 times the heat produced by 40K during this period. The decay of three shorter-lived radionuclides 26A1, 36Cl and 60Fe would have significantly heated up accreting planetary bodies for a period of about 5-15 Ma after the termination of nucleosynthesis in the primitive solar system (Fish et al., 1960). Of these, 26A1 is the most important. It decays to 26Mgwith a half-life of 0.74 Ma and would remain as a significant source of heat for about 10 Ma. If the Earth accreted within 20 Ma of the termination of nucleosynthesis, the heat released through the decay of 26A1 could be the main cause of its high internal temperature. If, on the other hand, the time of accretion was of the order of 100 Ma, the decay of 26A1would have had a negligible effect on the Earth's thermal history. In this regard, no trace of any anomaly in the 26Mg/24Mgratio had, until recently, been found in meteorites or in lunar and terrestrial samples (Schramm et al., 1970). Gray and Compston (1974), however, found an anomalous value of the 26Mg/24Mg ratio in a melilite-bearing chondrule in the Allende meteorite. They suggested that the anomaly results entirely from excess 26Mg,implying an origin by the radioactive decay of 26Al formed during intense proton irradiation in the early stages of the solar system. Later, Typhoon Lee et al. (1976, 1977) measured the isotopic composition of Mg in different phases of a Ca-Al-rich inclusion in the Allende meteorite and found large excesses of 26Mg of up to 10% that correlated with the 27A1/24Mgratio for four coexisting phases with distinctive chemical compositions. They concluded that the most plausible cause of the 26Mganomaly is the decay in situ of 26A1,providing definite evidence for the presence of 26A1in the early solar system. This would require either injection of freshly synthesized nucleosynthetic material into the solar system immediately before condensation and planet formation, or local production within the solar system by intense activity of the early sun. One suggestion to account for the excess 26Mg in the aluminium-rich minerals from the Allende meteorite is that a supernova exploded beside the forming solar system, peppering the solar cloud from which Allende formed with 26A1. This conclusion has now been questioned by the detection of surprisingly large amounts of 26A1in the interstellar medium (Mahoney et al. 1984; Mahoney 1985) by the third HighEnergy Astrophysical Observatory (HEAO 3). The concentration is approximately 1 atom of 26A1 on the average for every 100,000 atoms of 27A1. This discovery has been confirmed by a pray spectrometer on board the Solar Maximum Mission Satellite (Share et al., 1985) The prays coming from the general direction of the galactic centre are a product of the P-decay of the 26A1 nucleus. Clayton (1984) showed that if the 26A1 is spread uniformly
The Origin of the Core
95
throughout the interstellar gas, its concentration (- 10 ppm of Al) is close to that in the Allende minerals, in which case it is unnecessary to invoke the injection of 26A1into the forming solar system by a supernova. In any case, supernova explosions are not adequate to maintain the average level of observed interstellar radioactivity. The excess of 26A1 in Allende minerals, however, is too large to be the result of the average interstellar concentration. If 26A1decayed in the Allende minerals, there must have been some source of 26A1enhancement in the solar cloud as it collapsed to form the solar system. Clayton (1984) now expresses some doubts that 26A1 was ever "alive" in Allende. Some information on the time of nucleosynthesis has come from a study of xenon isotopes. "'I decays through p-emission to "'Xe with a half-life of 16.4 Ma. This half-life is so short that no "'I now exists in nature. However, this isotope should be produced at the time of formation of the other elements. It can be expected that the condensation of planetary material would incorporate any of the iodine present, but would be unlikely to incorporate much xenon. "'Xe formed within the condensed materials would be trapped and might be observed today-very small amounts of excess "'Xe have in fact been found in a number of meteorites. Absolute formation intervals calculated by the 129Xe-1291method generally give values between 40 and 300 Ma depending on the nucleosynthesis model assumed. Variations in relative formation intervals are much less, but are difficult to assess because of different methods of data treatment between different laboratories. Podosek (1970) has subjected all of the Berkeley data to a common method of analysis and found 15 different meteorites possessing formation intervals within a period of 15 Ma. Other noble-gas components in meteorites that arise from an extinct radionuclide and have the potential for the determination of formation intervals are the heavy xenon isotopes 131-136Xethat arise from the fission of 244Pu. These fission Xe components are much more difficult to identify than the excess lZ9Xe and were not discovered until precise isotopic data were obtained on the calcium-rich achondrites, a class of meteorites high in uranium (supposedly chemically similar to plutonium) and very low in trapped Xe (Rowe and Kuroda, 1965). Rao and Gopalan (1973) have also considered the fission Xe components in different types of meteorites and in particular have investigated whether some actinide isotopes could produce the excess fission Xe found in primitive chondrites. They concluded that the I-Xe and Cm-Xe systematics relate to different events in the early history of the solar system. The former refers to the time when I-Xe clocks are re-set during metamorphism of the ordinary chondrites while the latter refers to the time of primary condensation of the refractory materials from the cooling solar nebula (Hoyle and Wickrama-
96
The Earth's Core
singhe, 1968). The occurrence of the short-lived nuclide 248Cm ( Q T , ,=~ 0.4 Ma) in primitive meteorites has important consequences for the time-scales of the earliest events in the evolution of the solar system. As the solar nebula cools from about 2000 to 1400 K, i.e. to the temperature at which iron and magnesium silicates condense, the high-temperature minerals (or phases) form as refractory condensates (Fireman et al., 1970; Podosek and Lewis, 1972). Curium, being a refractory element similar to uranium, plutonium and the rare-earths, is most likely to be incorporated into these minerals, which would preserve the spontaneous fission record of 248Cmif they cooled fast to the Xe-retention temperature. Hence this actinide isotope could fix the timescale for a fast cooling stage, i.e. if the time interval for condensation was about 2 Ma, the 248Cmrecord would be preserved in these early condensations, but if it lasted for tens of millions of years, 248Cm would have completely decayed before it could be incorporated into these minerals. Ozima et al. (1985) have re-examined xenon isotopes produced from the decay of '291 and from 244Puand considered the constraints they impose on the early history of the Earth. The accretion time of planetesimals into the terrestrial planets is of the order of lo7- lo8 years. This is a significant time for the short-lived "'I and 244Pu.While condensation and accretion result in closure of solid elements such as Pu and I, Xe closure might be established only after collisions among planetesimals, since impact shock could result in the effective degassing of volatiles (Lange and Ahrens, 1982). Thus it would be possible for early- and late-accreting material to have significantly different Xe closure times. The excess '29Xe in some terrestrial materials indicates that the region from which it was derived must have been isolated from the atmosphere for nearly the whole history of the Earth. The commonly held view is that this excess lZ9Xeis a result of early mantle degassing (see e.g. Staudacher and AIlCgre, 1982; Allhgre et al., 1983; Hart et al., 1983). Ozima et al. (1985) offer an alternative explanation, viz. that the Earth's inner regions accreted a few tens of millions of years earlier than the outer regions from which the atmosphere evolved. The minimum time interval between the formation of the two regions is of order 1.4 x lo7 years.
2.3.3 Superheavy Elements
Runcorn et al. (1977) and Runcorn (1978) have suggested that superheavy elements (SHE) with atomic numbers between 114 and 126 may be relatively stable and may have provided the early heat source that melted the moon in its first few 100 Ma. They further suggested that these elements may be soluble in iron and hence provide the driving mechanism for the generation of the ancient lunar magnetic field. In a later paper, Libby et al. (1979) suggested
The Origin of the Core
97
that the heavy elements in iron meteorites may be partly the fission products of SHE. Flerov et al. (1977) claim to have observed in carbonaceous chondritic meteorites spontaneous fission of nuclei that they argue are SHE nuclei. However, there is no firm evidence as yet for the existence of relatively stable SHE. Kaiser et al. (1981) carried out a search for any records of fission events in the metal phase of IA and IVB meteorites, and found no evidence in support of a fissionable, siderophile superheavy element; limits for fission events are too low for fission to be a significant heat source in planetary cores. The highest possible value for heat production deduced from their Nd-Sm data in iron meteorites is one order of magnitude smaller than that required to drive the geodynamo by heat release due to radioactive decay (see 94.6). The lower values obtained from Kr, Xe and fission track data are two to three orders of magnitude smaller than the required energy production. Kaiser et al. conclude that nuclear fission could not have contributed significantly as a heat source to drive an early lunar, or a terrestrial, core dynamo.
2.3.4 Adiabatic Compression
The temperature of the material within the aggregating Earth would also increase because of adiabatic compression. Although data (particularly on the variation with pressure of the coefficient of thermal expansion) are rather uncertain, a rise in temperature of several hundred degrees from this source seems possible.
2.3.5 Potential Energy due to the Mutual Gravitational Attraction of the Particles of the Dust Cloud
The kinetic energy of the aggregating particles is either converted into internal energy or radiated away. It is extremely difficult to estimate the contribution from this source because of our lack of knowledge of the physical processes of accretion. The result depends quite critically on the temperature attained at the surface of the aggregating Earth and on the transparency of the surrounding atmosphere to radiation. Comparatively low surface temperatures (of the order of a few hundred degrees) have been suggested, mainly because the atmosphere of the primitive Earth was assumed transparent so that the thermal energy of the impinging particles was immediately re-radiated into space. Ringwood (1960) has argued, however, that during these early years the primitive Earth would have had a large reducing atmosphere. In the presence of these reducing
98
The Earth’s Core
agents (chiefly carbon and methane), the accreting material would be reduced to metallic alloys-principally of iron, nickel and silicon. The outer regions of the Earth would thus be metal-rich and dense (referred to zero pressure) compared with the interior. Such a state is gravitationally unstable and convective overturn would follow, leading to a sinking of the metal-rich outer regions to the centre. This would release further heat due to the energy of gravitational rearrangement. Ringwood believes the whole process is likely to be catastrophic, since the overturn would be accelerated as the initial temperature rose. The relative importance of the gravitational potential energy of the dust cloud as a means of heating the proto-Earth depends critically on the duration of the accretion process-rapid accretion is necessary to produce high temperatures and melt the OC. The rate of growth of mass of the embryo Earth would increase in the beginning of the accretion process (because of the increase in the capture cross-section of the embryo), pass through a maximum and then decrease (because of the exhaustion of accretable material). The law governing the flux, h, of falling matter determines the ultimate thermal profile, since losses by radiation depend upon how fast the recent fall is covered by new layers thus insulating the former from radiative loss. The energy balance is given by the equation T 3
+ CP[T(t)- T&l
for infalling matter having the velocity of escape at impact, where G is the universal constant of gravitation, M ( t ) the mass of the Earth, m the mass flux, r(t) the instantaneous radius of the Earth, p the mass density, E, the emissivity, c the Stefan-Boltzmann constant, T ( t )the instantaneous temperature of the surface of the proto-Earth at time t, To the background temperature of free space of the circumsolar nebula into which radiative losses take place, and cp the specific heat at constant pressure, In (2.1) the term on the left-hand side represents the gravitational energy input, the first term on the right-hand side the radiative loss rate, and the second term the rate of heat takeup by the infalling matter in coming to the temperature T(t).Heat conduction to the interior from the hot surface regions is neglected since it is vanishingly small for time-scales of the order of 103-106years. Heating due to adiabatic compression is also ignored. The mass flux, m(t), is the dominant parameter in calculating the thermal profile resulting purely from accretion, although To has an important effect under certain conditions. In general m = m(t) but, as will be shown later, whether m = m ( t ) or is constant has little bearing upon the main conclusions. It is easy to generalize a set of laws for m that include gravity and slower rates
99
The Origin of the Core
of accretion as well. It can be shown that the exact form of the law has little effect upon the time-limit for sufficient energy to be stored to melt surface or subsurface regions. Write m = c,/r"
where r
= r(t) and c
(2.2)
is a constant with index n. Since M = 47cpr2i, m = h / 4 n r 2 = pi.
Hence from (2.2) and (2.3),
except for the case n = - 1. In this case
For n = 0, m is constant and the radius grows linearly with time while for 1 the growth is slowed. None of these assumptions is especially plausible physically, as the accretion rate should depend upon the gravitational force (n = - 1) or potential (n = - 2), assuming that the escape velocity is not exceeded and an infinite source reservoir is available. For the case n = - 2, (2.1) becomes la>
$ c p G c - 2r4 =
T4 - T:)
+ c pc
-
2r2(T - To)
(2.7)
where the constant c - ~= mf/R: where mf is the mass flux at the termination of growth, r = R,. From (2.5), it then follows that
and the time taken for the Earth to grow from radius, ro, to final radius, Rmis given by
where Ar = r
-
ro. When r
= R,,
(2.10)
100
The Earths Core
For R,/ro = 2, t = p R , / m f which is the same as for the case m = co. Thus the time taken for the Earth to grow from half-radius to its full value under gravitational accumulation is the same as for riz = co. Although the radiative losses depend upon the accretion time, there is not a great difference in the final temperature for these two cases. The effect of heat being admitted to the incoming matter tends to diminish the differences between the different mass laws for k. Without this term in (2.1), the temperature would vary as r for gravitational accretion and be less for cases where n> -2. If all the gravitational energy of accumulation were trapped in the Earth, the first term on the right-hand side of (2.1) vanishes and the resulting increase in temperature AT can be estimated from the equation (2.1 1)
where R , is the final radius. This gives a temperature of the order of 50,000 K. This is the maximum thermal effect of the accretion process-such a hot origin of the Earth would lead to core formation and large-scale differentiation upon accretion (Ringwood, 1966). The minimum thermal effect of the accretion process may be obtained by assuming that the energy released by inelastic collisions of matter falling in from the primordial gas/dust cloud is partially compensated by energy reradiated to space. The equilibrium condition is then given by (2.1) with the last term omitted. If we assume black-body radiation, E, = 1 and the resulting temperatures are minimal. The unknown quantity is i., the rate of accretion. Hanks and Anderson (1969) have considered a number of models. The simplest assumed a constant accretion rate: more plausible models were obtained with accretion rates i = A sin at and i = Ct2 sin y t , where i is zero at r = 0 and r = Rm. The constants A , a, C and y are determined by the final radius R , and t,,,, the total time of accretion. Figure 2.3 shows the radial growth as a function of time for this last model, when t,,, = 1 Ma. It can be seen that it takes 0.3 Ma for the Earth to reach asteroidal size-the rapid acceleration of the accretion process between 0.4 and 0.9 Ma is responsible for the major part of the temperature rise. The accretion rate begins to decelerate significantly only in the last 200 km. Safronov (see, e.g. 1969) and Urey (1962) prefer an accretion time of the order of lo8 years, rather than the very much shorter times advocated by Ringwood (1959, 1966), Hanks and Anderson (1969) and Turekian and Clark (1969). The above calculation ignores the details of each accretion event-an approximation that can only be justified if all the accreting particles are very small compared to the planet. If the terrestrial planets were .formed by accumulation, there must have been impacts involving proto-planetary
101
The Origin of the Core
I
I
I
I
7
5000
"0
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Time of ter accretion begins ( M a1
1.0
Fig. 2.3. Radial growth of the Earth. (After Hanks and Anderson, 1969.)
bodies of many different sizes: the above theory would not simulate the heating from such events at all. Again, this simple theory does not take into account any mass loss by the growing planets during accretion: high speed impacts could cause considerable heating, at the same time ejecting more mass from the forming body than they brought to it. The heating effect of impacts of large falling bodies is considered in more detail in $2.3.8. The accretional heating of terrestrial planets has been reviewed by Ransford (1982).
2.3.6 Dissipation of the Earth's Rotational Energy
As the Earth slows down through tidal interaction with the moon (and to a lesser extent with the sun), part of its rotational energy is dissipated by tides in the oceans and part in the interior of the Earth by Earth tides. It is difficult to estimate how the energy loss is divided between ocean and Earth tidesprobably most of it is dissipated in the shallow seas. If the heat generated by tides were evenly distributed over the whole volume of the Earth, the increase
102
The Earths Core
in temperature would be unimportant (probably less than 100 K). However, if there is a region of low viscosity in the upper mantle, most of the energy of tidal deformation should be dissipated there, resulting in a greater increase of temperature. This would have occurred when the Earth and moon were relatively close together and the Earth’s rotation was much faster than it is now; but even if the moon was once close to the Roche limit, it would recede so rapidly that the effect of tidal heating would be negligible.
2.3.7 The Formation of the Core
If the Earth formed by accretion from approximately homogeneous material and later differentiated into crust, mantle and core, the formation of the core would release a large amount of gravitational energy as a result of the concentration of the high density nickel-iron in the centre of the Earth. Tozer (1965) estimated the increase of heat arising from core formation from an originally undifferentiated Earth to be 470 cal/g. About 6% of this would melt the Ni-Fe phase, while the rest would raise the mean temperature of the Earth about 1500 K. Birch (1965) has made a similar estimate and obtained essentially the same result (400 cal/g) for the energy available for heating. In a later paper, Flaser and Birch (1973) corrected an error in Birch’s original paper. Their revised estimate of the energy release due to core formation is 590 cal/g which would be sufficient to heat the Earth by about 2000 K. Thus the formation of the Earth’s core may well have played a dominant role in the thermal history of the Earth.
2.3.8 Impacts of Falling Bodies
Safronov (1969, 1972, 1978) is of the opinion that one of the main sources of heat for an Earth accreting cold was the impacts of falling bodies. Estimates of the initial temperature from this source depend largely on the body sizes assumed. Calculations based on the assumption that these bodies were small give a low initial temperature-from 300 K near the surface to 800-900 K at the centre. The impact energy of small bodies and particles would be liberated near the surface of the growing Earth, practically all of it being radiated back into space. Safronov believes, however, that relatively large bodies were involved in the formation of the planets, the largest bodies falling on the Earth having diameters of several hundred kilometres. The larger the incident body, the greater the depth at which its impact energy would be released and hence the greater the fraction of this energy that would be trapped inside the Earth, unable to escape into space. Moreover, larger bodies would produce
The Origin of the Core
103
deeper craters, inducing more intensive mixing of the material on impact. Heat transfer by mixing of material during the impact of large bodies is far more efficient than heat transfer by ordinary thermal conduction. Numerical estimates show that the maximum initial temperature of the Earth occurred in the region of the upper mantle (at a depth -500 km) and probably exceeded 1500 K. The largest bodies striking the Earth would also cause primary inhomogeneities in the mantle. Apart from inhomogeneities arising from differences in chemical composition of the impacting bodies, there would also be temperature inhomogeneities. Regions of impact of the largest bodies with sizes up to 1000 km would be additionally heated some hundreds of degrees-in such large areas the temperature would not be equalized even after 1000 Ma. With the additional heat due to radioactive decay, the central zones of these regions would be the first to reach melting temperatures. When about half of the material had melted, local gravitational differentiation would take place-heavy materials would settle down to the lower part of the zone, and light materials rise to the upper part. During such global differentiation large amounts of thermal energy would be released. As a result, a greatly heated vertical column of lower viscosity would be formed along which masses of heavier materials would sink downwards to form the core. Safronov also suggested that it was above such regions excessively heated by impacts that the formation of the continents took place. Safronov’s conclusions were based on an extremely simple model, Kaula (1979) refined the model by treating the thermal evolution of the Earth to be time-varying in a spherical geometry. The energy partitioning at impact was taken from the work of O’Keefe (1977) and O’Keefe and Ahrens (1977), the distribution of impact energy declining with depth. The greatest uncertainty in Kaula’s models is that portion of the impact energy partitioned to internal energy that is retained after material falls back in great impacts. Kaula found that models of the Earth with growth times of the order of 50 Ma became hot enough for vaporization to occur if more than about 12% of the heat energy is retained upon impact. He also showed that early planetary heating is insensitive to planetary growth time-rapid formation is not required. In a later paper, Kaula (1980) re-examined his earlier model and reaffirmed his conclusion that the impact of falling bodies would have led to significant heating, more than enough to trigger core formation. The principal modification from the conclusions of his 1979 paper is that the temperature would never have risen much above melting, since the viscosity of molten material would have been low enough to remove heat as rapidly as it was generated by impacts. The effects of lateral heterogeneity are mainly to promote convection and thus heat removal. Core formation probaby started before the Earth was 10% formed, since melting temperatures would have been reached by
104
The Earths Core
that time. Kaula estimated that the peak energy release was near the MCB, and that about 60% went to the core. The resulting temperature gradient in the mantle was strongly super-adiabatic. The energy released by differentiation of subsequently infalling material would have gone mainly into the mantle, where it would have further contributed to vigorous convection, and not into the core. The calculations of the accretion heating effect by Safronov (1972, 1978) and Kaula (1979, 1980) assumed that there was no overlap between the growth zones of the Earth and Venus during their formation. Wetherill (1976) considered this possibility and also the effect of slightly eccentric orbits for the proto-Earth and proto-Venus, and obtained much higher relative velocities in both the Earth and Venus zones and much larger masses for the planetesimals relative to the proto-Earth and proto-Venus. In this model, both the Earth and Venus and the Moon would have melted completely during accretion. Davies (1985) has discussed in detail the heating of a planet due to the impact of falling bodies. In a growing planet, the heating rate will be greatest at the surface and will decrease with depth. Heat transport back to the surface will also be affected by mixing accompanying impacts and this effect will also decrease with depth. Moreover, the surface of the planet will be moving upwards as new material is added. Relative to the accreting surface, the material is moving downwards. Thus, heat that is deposited too deeply will not be conducted back to the surface before it is carried into the low conductivity interior and there trapped. Davies thus identifies three depth-scales that affect the fraction of deposited heat that is retained in the growing planetthe depth-scales of heat deposition, impact mixing and the ratio u/v where u is the thermal diffusivity and u the upward velocity of the accreting surface. He showed that the efficiency of heat retention is independent of planetary growth rate, and confirmed Safronov’s (1969, 1972, 1978) conclusion that a significant amount of impact energy will be retained in a slowly growing planet. Assuming a heat deposition efficiency of 20%, a terrestrial planet will reach melting temperatures in its outer layers at a radius of between 2000 and 3000 km (see Fig. 2.4). Davies stresses the importance of the correct scaling for impact effects, and questions some of the results of Kaula (1979, 1980) that are inconsistent with the general scaling forms deduced by Holsapple & Schmidt (1982).
2.3.9 Blanketing Effect of a Primordial Dense Atmosphere
Hayashi et al. (1979) considered the heating due to the blanketing effect of a primordial dense atmosphere surrounding the proto-Earth. When the mass
105
The Origin of the Core
1
I
5
I
6 log R (rn)
Fig. 2.4. Temperature profiles for growing terrestrial (rock-iron) planets. Solid lines bound the preferred range corresponding to impactor heating, while short-dashed lines correspond to crater heating. M and E denote momentum and energy scaling, respectively. Long-dashed sloping lines are the limits assuming lOO%-efficient heat retention ( T A ) and 100%-efficient deposition plus retention ( T T ) . Deposition efficiency of 20% is assumed; a different value would shift TAand lower profiles vertically relative to TT. Horizontal lines bound estimated melting ranges of relevant silicate and metal phases. Temperature profiles near and above the melting temperatures are not realistic, since heat transport by convection and melting would then dominate. (After Davies, 1985.)
of the proto-Earth was 20.1 of the mass of the present Earth, an appreciable amount of gas from the solar nebula would form an optically thick, dense atmosphere. They showed that the temperature at the bottom of the atmosphere, i.e. at the surface of the proto-Earth, increases greatly with the mass of the proto-Earth and is 1500 K when its mass is a quarter that of the present Earth, and 4000 K when the proto-Earth reached its present size. However, their results depend rather critically on the boundary conditions of the Earth’s proto-atmosphere, and are difficult to assess. Later Matsui and Abe (1986) considered the blanketing effect of an impactinduced atmosphere. The impact of large bodies-planetesimals-would result in the ejection of enormous amounts of fine dust and the release of
-
106
The Earrh’s Core
volatile gases such as HzO and COz. Lange and Ahrens (1982a,b) had earlier suggested that the primordial H 2 0 atmosphere was formed on the Earth by impact dehydration of H,O-bearing minerals. Since grains, C O , and HzO are all good absorbers of infrared radiation, Matusi and Abe suggested that the impact energy released at the surface of a growing planet could not have escaped directly into space and was thus expended in heating a surface layer. They estimated that the surface temperature due to the blanketing effect of an impact-induced H 2 0 atmosphere would exceed the melting temperature of the surface materials leading to a “magma ocean” covering the entire surface of the Earth (and Moon) just after their formation.
2.3.10 Electrical Induction
Electrical induction as a means of joule heating of planets has been studied extensively by Sonett and coworkers (see e.g. Sonett and Colburn, 1967,1968; Sonett et al. 1968, 1970; Sonett and Herbert, 1977). Electromagnetic induction depends upon certain properties of the pre-main-sequence Sun-that it passed through a T Tauri phase and at that time had a high spin and surface magnetic field of about 10-100 G. Under these conditions a strong electromagnetic field would be set up in the interplanetary cavity. Planetary objects in such an environment would be subject to electrical induction: the Apollo magnetometer detected a very large transverse electric (TE) mode in the Moon excited by the forcing field of the solar wind (Sonett et al., 1972). As seen by the planetary object, the induction takes the form of a unipolar generator of linear geometry using the solar wind motion and the interplanetary magnetic field, with the conductive interior of the planet acting as the armature. Sonnett and coworkers have shown that joule heating can cause the melting of objects in the inner solar system, the amount depending on the solar distance, and the bulk electrical conductivity of the rocky matter. Other parameters important for excitation by the electric field are the temperature in the interplanetary cavity into which the object will radiate, the strength of the magnetic field, accretion time, and the solar wind ram-pressure. Sonnett and coworkers initially suggested electrical induction as a means of heating small planetary objects (meteorites and asteroids) and possibly the Moon and Mercury. Application to the other terrestrial planets-Earth, Mars and Venus is much more complex. These planets have an atmosphere and, in the case of the Earth, a strong intrinsic magnetic field. For a body whose temperature and conductivity decrease towards the surface, the bulk of the electric field will occur near the surface. The deep interior of a hot object will effectively be a short-circuit and will show little electric field.
The Origin of the Core
2.4
107
Time of Core Formation
Views of the time required to form the Earth’s core have changed considerably over the past two decades. Runcorn (1962a,b) suggested that the core has continued to grow throughout geological time and developed a theory of continental drift based on its growth. Vening Meinesz (1952) had argued that the positions of the continents today could result from a large-scale, regular pattern of convective motions in the mantle, continental material tending to congregate at places where the currents are descending. Using the results of Chandrasekhar’s (1961) studies on the convection of a fluid in a spherical shell, Runcorn showed that the present radius of the core is only just greater than the value at which the fourth harmonic convection pattern in the mantle should become less readily excited than the fifth. During a transition from one harmonic to another, the continents will be under much stress as the convection pattern changes to a new form. The relatively recent time (geologically speaking) at which continental drift took place is thus understandable. Runcorn also predicted other epochs of large continental displacements when the core radius reached successively the values at which the first degree convection pattern in the mantle, initially present when the core was only beginning to form, gave place to the second and the second to the third, etc. These other epochs of continental drift occurred early in the early Precambrian. In addition to continental displacements, one would expect a series of orogenies during such transition periods. Radioactive age determinations have mainly been obtained from igneous rocks that come from depth or metamorphic rocks formed in the deeper parts of the crust as the result of orogenic forces (Gastil, 1960). It is interesting that the ages obtained for such rocks group in broad peaks around the dates 2600, 1800, 1000, and 300 Ma ago. The most recent peak covers much of the geological record since the middle Palaeozoic and this is associated with continental drift and the transition from a fourth to a fifth degree convection pattern in the mantle. Runcorn suggested that it is naturai to identify the 1000 Ma peak with the transition from the third to the fourth degree convection pattern, the 1800 Ma peak with the transition from tne second to the third and the 2600 Ma peak with the transition from the first to the second. In this way the dates at which the core radius reached these critical values can be determined-see Fig. 2.5 which also shows that, on this theory, the core only started its growth a little over 3000 Ma ago. Elsasser (1963) has considered in some detail the model of an Earth accreted cold with the material uniformly distributed. The main feature of such an Earth model is that the melting point curve of the silicates rises much more steeply with depth than the actual temperature. This implies that the viscosity of the silicates should increase appreciably with increasing depth. As
108
The Earth’s Core
0.60
0-55 0.50 r 0-45
0.40
-
1
0-35
3
7
-
Final radius of core
\
n.4-
n=5/
n=3-
n.4’
/ n~2-n-3
Present
0.30
day
f
2000 Origin
of Earth
1000
I
Age ( M a )
Fig. 2.5. Growth of the Earth’s core compared with radioactive age determination peaks. (After Runcorn. 1962b.)
the original Earth is heated by radioactivity, the outer layers are then the first to become soft enough to permit iron to sink towards the centre-farther down the fall of iron is slowed by increased viscosity. It then forms a coherent layer which, however, is gravitationally unstable and results in the formation of quite large drops. The latter fall rapidly to the centre giving rise to a protocore. Elsasser estimated that the formation of a proto-core slightly smaller than the present core probably took no more than several hundred million years. The fall of iron is controlled by the elasto-viscous properties of the silicate matrix. Below the melting point, the viscosity will increase exponentially with decreasing temperature. Thus, instead of a uniform rain of iron towards the centre we have a far more complicated process in which the fall of iron is largely controlled by the variation in temperature at any given depth. As iron fell through the almost fluid silicate material, the general flow pattern of the latter would at first be nearly streamline, but, since the viscosity of the mantle increases with depth, the inner portion would not have time to flow but would be pushed outwards by the falling drop of iron. Elsasser suggested that the composition of the mantle might thus become asymmetrical, the material displaced to the antipodal point containing iron, while that above the falling drop lost most of its iron. A difficulty with Elsasser’s model of core formation is that the centre of the
The Origin of the Core
109
proto-Earth is likely to be initially cold and thus possibly strong enough to resist penetration of iron droplets. Davis (1982) pointed out that the work of Kinsland and Bassett (1977) and Kinsland (1978) indicates that the ultimate strengths of silicates are only of the order of 1-2 G P a even under extreme pressures, Deviatoric stresses of this magnitude can easily be generated in a planet with large density contrasts, such as between rock and iron. Davies showed that the minimum size of a density heterogeneity that would exceed the strength of the mantle and sink towards the centre of the planet is a few tens of kilometres in radius. He further investigated the possibility that such heterogeneities might arise by the accretion of differentiated planetesimals, in which case core segregation could be initiated by heterogeneous impact heating well before extensive near-surface melting occurred. In the most favourable circumstances segregation could begin in a proto-planet when its radius is only 700 km. This increases the likelihood that core segregation was essentially contemporaneous with accretion. Tozer (1965) has reconsidered the question of the kinetics of core formation and concluded that the simple theory of falling iron masses in silicate material is untenable. He suggested as an alternative a mechanism based on the flow of iron along channels in the silicate phase-the acceptability of this theory, however, depends quite critically on whether iron is able to flow over distances of the order of a kilometre under such conditions. Tozer concluded that in any case core formation is proceeding today much more slowly than in the past and that it was virtually complete very early in the Earth’s history. Tolland (1973) has also considered core formation following accretion from an initially homogeneous mixture (82% by volume of silicate and 18% of iron plus sulphide). His model differs from other models (such as that of Elsasser, 1963) in that he considers the role of convection during core formation, taking into account the interaction between infall and convection processes. Tolland used Tozer’s (1972) model of the thermal history of the Earth (see $3.8). Tozer showed that for small departures from hydrostatic equilibrium, the rheology of the Earth can be described in terms of a Newtonian viscosity. If the convecting region is of the order of hundreds of kilometres thick, the viscosity is lo2*poise for any reasonable value of heat generation. This answers the objection to infall theories that the mantle viscosity is too high. Tolland assumed the present core to be an Fe-S mix (see §5.7.2)-the first melt in the proto-Earth would then be well below the melting point of iron. Rapid convection would prevent the Earth from ever having been extensively melted-a fact which Urey (1952) deduced on geochemical grounds. Tolland estimated that, for a mantle viscosity of 10’’ poise, to form the core in about lo8 years requires an initial “seed” of about 1 m in size, which does not seem unreasonable. Vityazev (1973) calculated the radial distribution of gravitational energy
-
110
The Earth’s Core
Model# 15
Model#30
Mode l#O
ModeW60
0@ @ a
a
b
b
Fig. 2.6. Earth models at various stages of core separation according to (a) the sinking layer model, ( 6 ) Elsasser’s model. Model 15 has = + o f the total mass differentiated: model 30 shows differentiation to a depth = t. Earth’s radius. (After Shaw, 1978.)
resulting from core formation. His solution necessitated a number of simplifying assumptions-incompressible Earth, no change in g as core formation proceeds and no consideration of the question of energy transfer between the silicate and iron phases. His model gave maximum energy release in the region of the MCB. A feature of Vityazev’s model was that the iron would separate out as a discrete layer falling to the centre of the Earth. This is different from the earlier approach of Elsasser (1963), who envisaged core formation resulting from the fall of a series of drops. Shaw (1978) has investigated a series of Earth models at various stages of core formation. The initial state is a homogeneous mixture of “silicate” and “iron”. The iron separates from the outside inwards, leaving an outer silicate layer as it moves towards the centre as in Vityazev’s model: for comparison he considered as well a set of models based on Elsasser’s mode of core formation (see Fig. 2.6). Shaw calculated the density, pressure and gravitational acceleration at various stages of core formation and hence the energy of assembly as differentiation proceeds. He was thus able to obtain the energy release as a function of degree of differentiation, in particular as a function of depth to which iron separation has taken place. Probably the most serious assumption in Shaw’s model is that the calculations are isothermal rather than adiabatic, so that the temperature rise is ignored. Shaw found that for the sinking-layer model the energy of assembly is approximately a linear function of depth of separation, following a slow change near the surface. Shaw then calculated the energy release on the assumption that it takes place primarily within the iron layer, as silicate rises through that layer. At each stage of the separation process, most of the Earth is remote from the site of energy release and thus does not receive any signifi-
The Origin of the Core
111
cant fraction of the energy. The energy release is small (- 100 J g- ') for the separation of the 100-km layer near the Earth's surface. As separation proceeds and the iron layer thickens, the energy release quickly rises to about 400 J g-', remaining at about this value for the separation of most of the mass, and then gradually drops to zero as separation is completed. By contrast, in Elsasser-type models the energy release is largest during the early stages of separation and then rapidly decreases with very little energy released by the separation of the mass which was originally within one-half Earth-radius from the centre. For the sinking-layer model, Shaw found that the core receives a substantial amount of the energy released, about one-half. This concentration of energy in the iron is due to its participation in the energy release throughout the process. This contrasts with the results of Vityazev and Mayeva (1976), who found that the mantle would receive -83% of the energy and the core 17%. This difference is due to the details of energy exchange between silicate and iron and the effect of isolation of silicate from the site of energy release, which was not taken into account in Vityazev and Mayeva's calculations*. Melting of disseminated iron would occur before melting of the major silicate fraction, especially if any alloying constituent is present to depress the melting point. Liquid iron would have readily penetrated downward through the silicate matrix, but since deeper levels were probably colder, the iron could not have immediately migrated to the centre of the planet. Rather, it would have formed a spheroidal layer, the bottom of which would necessarily have been at its freezing point. Below this layer there would have been a zone consisting of an undifferentiated, cold primordial mixture of materials, and the mantle above the iron-rich layer would have been iron-depleted and wellstirred by thermal convection and Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities caused by incoming iron-bearing planetesimals. Stevenson (1 981) believes that both the Elsasser blob model (1963) and the sinking layer model of Vityazev and Mayeva (1976) are feasible, given enough time. The problem with both models is the length of time needed for core formation-several hundred million years-mainly due to the slow thermal diffusion. Stevenson has suggested an alternative model. Figure 2.7(1) shows a cold, undifferentiated primordial core overlain by the denser iron that has accumulated from the partially molten mantle above. In Fig. 2.7(11), a spontaneous asymmetry develops. Large, non-hydrostatic stresses on the resulting primordial core lead
* Shaw (personal communication) has pointed out that the model depicted in Fig. 2.6 is highly oversimplified. The highly symmetrical process shown is also highly unstable. Shaw believes, however, that it does give a limiting result in that it favours maximum energy transfer to the material of the mantle. Any more realistic model would result in more energy (higher temperature) in the core, with a consequent cooler mantle. This implies even steeper thermal gradients immediately following core separation.
112
The Earth’s Core
PR IMOR D IA L
I
IRON LAYER
II
COLD ‘ROCKBERG’
m
Fig. 2.7. A hypothetical scenario for the early stages of core formation. At this stage, the proto-earth may be much smaller than the final earth. In I, a cold, undifferentiated primordial core is overlain by the more dense iron that has accumulated from the partially molten mantle above. In II, a spontaneous asymmetry develops. Large, non-hydrostatic stresses on the resulting primordial core lead to deformation and even fracturing. In 111, the debris from this is distributed in the form of ‘rockbergs‘ around the newly formed core. Thermal equilibration of these ‘rockbergs’ with the surroundings is by thermal diffusion and takes longer than Earth accretion. (After Stevenson, 1981 .)
to deformation and even fracturing. In Fig. 2.7(111), the debris from this is distributed in the form of “rockbergs” around the newly formed core. Thermal equilibration of these rockbergs with the surroundings is by thermal diffusion and takes longer than Earth accretion. Stevenson had earlier (1980) suggested that the nearside-farside asymmetry of the Moon was a natural result for a rigid, low-density core overlain by an inviscid high-density layer. Although the initiation of the core-forming process may be difficult because of the cold central part of the Earth, Stevenson believes that the subsequent migration of iron-rich material would be quite rapid (- 1 Ma), so that core formation was essentially contemporaneous with the accretion of the Earth. As pointed out in $2.3, a rapid rate of accretion of the Earth is essential if the gravitational potential energy of the dust cloud is to play a major role in the heating of the embryo Earth. There are a number of lines of evidence which indicate that the time-scale for accretion was quite short. It is generally believed that the Earth’s magnetic field arises from dynamo action in the fluid, electrically conducting OC (see 54.2). Remanent magnetization has been found in rocks as old as 3500 Ma so that the OC must have been molten at least that long ago. Hanks and Anderson (1969) have carried out an investigation of the thermal history of the Earth with this additional constraint and come to the conclusion that the Earth must have accreted in a period less than 0.5 Ma. There would not have been time for the decay of long-lived radioactive isotopes to have had sufficient heating effect and the authors discount the importance of the decay of short-lived radionuclides. A short accretion time is thus essential so that most of the gravitational potential energy of the dust cloud is trapped and not lost to space. The accretion
The Origin of the Core
113
time could be lengthened somewhat, since the core is not pure iron. The addition of silicon or sulphur (see 55.7) would lower the melting point of ironHall and Murthy (1972) have estimated that at core pressures the melting temperature of the Fe-FeS eutectic is about 1600°C lower than that of pure iron. Wetherill (1972) pointed out that measurements of the concentration of Rb and Sr and the Sr isotopic composition of lunar samples indicate that a major fractionation of Rb relative to Sr took place on the moon 4600 Ma ago. Similar studies of the highly differentiated lunar breccias provide additional evidence for a very early lunar differentiation. Wetherill concluded that the most likely heat source for this initial differentiation is the gravitational energy of lunar accretion and that, for a sufficiently high temperature to be reached during the accretion period, the time-scale for accretion must be of the order of 1000 years. By analogy with the moon, Wetherill suggested that the entire Earth was initially melted and fractionated, and that the age of the oldest rocks ( N 3500 Ma) indicates that it was not until then that the Earth cooled sufficiently to enable the formation of extensive areas of stable crust. Oversby and Ringwood (1971) have also produced evidence for an early formation of the Earth’s core. Ringwood had argued in 1960 that iron descending during core formation would take with it substantial amounts of lead but not of uranium, i.e. core formation would change the Pb/U ratio in the upper crust and mantle. He thus concluded that the 4550 Ma terrestrial event recorded by Pb/U geochronology referred to the time of core formation, which must have taken place very soon after the formation of the Earth. The main argument for Ringwood’s conclusion is that during core formation the Pb/U ratio of the metal phase would be higher than that in silicates; the opposite point of view was taken by Patterson and Tatsumoto (1 964). Oversby and Ringwood (1967) carried out experimental measurements of the distribution coefficient of lead between relevant metal and silicate systems to settle this question. Since the core is believed to contain some 1&30% of one or more light elements in addition to iron (see 95.7), they examined a number of core models with different synthetic metal phase compositions (Fea3SlsC2, FesgSi, 1, Fe3,S30-weight per cent). The silicate phase used in the experiments consisted of simplified synthetic basaltic compositions, doped with 1000 ppm of lead (as oxide) in some runs and 100 ppm in others. Finely powdered samples of metal phase were mixed with silicate in the ratio 1 part (by weight) of metal to 2 parts silicate. The mixture was heated to a temperature at which both metal and silicate phases were known to be molten (the experiments were carried out at high pressures under closed-system conditions to prevent volatilization of lead). Their results showed that lead ends up preferentially in the (i.e. the ratio of Pb metal phase and values of the distribution coefficient Kmis
114
The Earths Core
A
5 (Ma)
Fig. 2.8. Relationship of the time delay for core formation after accretion of the Earth, ATc, with the distribution coefficient for lead between metal and silicate phases, I?"'. Time of accretion is taken as 4550 Ma. Isotopic composition of upper mantle lead is taken as that from tholeiites dredged from the floor of the Pacific Ocean. (After Oversby and Ringwood, 1971 .)
concentration in the metal to that in the silicate phase) were obtained for each run. A relationship exists between K"/" and the time interval ATc between accretion of the Earth and segregation of the core. The exact relationship depends on certain "boundary" conditions-Fig. 2.8 shows one of the curves produced by Oversby and Ringwood. The distribution coefficient for a model with a metal phase composition Fea3SI5Czis 2.5 and Fig. 2.8 shows that core segregation must have occurred within about 20 Ma after accretion. For the Fe70S30 and Fe&i compositions, K"Is values are larger-however, because the ATc curve is very steep above K"/" = 1.5, the ATc intervals are only slightly shorter. Oversby and Ringwood thus concluded that the Earth's core formed either during accretion or very soon after. Reasonable variations in the boundary conditions do not affect this basic result. These conclusions strongly favour models in which much of the accretion of the Earth occurred rapidly under sustained high-temperature conditions, rather than those in which the Earth accreted in a cool, unmelted state, followed by subsequent internal heating and core formation at a much later stage. Vollmer (1 977) repeated Oversby and Ringwood's calculations using the
115
The Origin of the Core
revised U decay constants of Jaffey et al. (1971), which somewhat alters Oversby and Ringwood’s conclusions. Vollmer found that core formation cannot have occurred before 200 Ma and probably not later than 500 Ma after accretion. Oversby and Ringwood concluded that accretion must have resulted in a hot initial Earth, since the time interval between accretion and formation of the core in their calculation was less than 100 Ma. On the other hand, Vollmer’s results are compatible with an initially solid Earth being heated by radioactive decay until the metallic phase suddenly segregated into a core. Vollmer also considered another model compatible with hot accretion resulting in a completely or partially molten Earth and came to the same conclusion, that core formation was not quasi-simultaneous with accretion but occurred after or during a period of several hundred million years following accretion. Vollmer appreciates that his models are over-simplifications and do not take into account the non-uniform temperature distribution. Thus, they cannot give any details of the process of core formation but do demonstrate that there was probably a maximum time of some 100Ma between accretion and the completion of core formation. Gancarz and Wasserburg (1977) also showed that major differentiation of the Earth, accompanied by the transport of most of the Earth’s lead into the core, must have taken place in the first few hundred million years. From an analysis of Sr and P b isotopic data, Vidal and Dosso (1978) concluded that, although the core most probably formed early and quickly in the Earth‘s history, core growth has nevertheless continued but at a much slower rate for the following 3 x lo9 years. Allegre et al. (1982) used data on lead isotope ratios in mantle material to calculate growth curves for the core. Neglecting the continental crust, the chemical balance equation can be written as PE = Pnd1 - a )
(2.12)
where p = 238U/204Pband the subscripts E and rn stand for the bulk Earth C is the concentration of 204Pband the suband the mantle; a = Ccmc/CEmE, script c stands for the core. The core is assumed to contain no uranium so that pc = 0. Equation (2.12) can then be written (2.13)
p,,,(t) is determined from isotopic data, and equation (2.13) then gives mc(t)for fixed values of the parameter C,/C, and p E . Growth curves for the core for various models and values of p E are shown in Fig. 2.9. For their preferred model, Allegre et al. found that 85% of the core would have formed early in
116
The Earth's Core
0.5
0
I
4
I
2 9 Age (10 years)
Fig. 2.9. Growth of the mass of the core throughout geological time according to various models and two values of p~ = 2"U/2MPb for the whole Earth. (After Allegre e t a / . , 1982.)
the Earth's history (during the first 5Ck200 Ma) and 15% subsequently, its growth still continuing.
2.5
lnhomogeneous Models of the Earth
Orowan (1969) was one of the first to suggest that the Earth may have accreted inhomogeneously. He pointed out that iron is plastic ductile, even at low temperatures, provided that it does not contain far more carbon than is found in meteorites. As a result, metallic particles would be expected to stick together when they collide because they can absorb kinetic energy by plastic deformation. They can therefore combine by cold or hot welding. Silicates, on the other hand, are brittle and break up on collision, except within a narrow temperature range near their melting point. The accretion of the planets may thus have started with metallic particles. Once sufficiently large a body could easily collect non-metallic particles by embedding them in ductile metal, and
The Origin of the Core
117
later by gravitational attraction. Orowan thus suggested that planets may arise cold in this way with a metal core already partially differentiated. The problem of heat sources to provide subsequent melting of the core remains. Harris and Tozer (1967) pointed out that in the preplanetary dust cloud, particle adhesion and aggregation would have been most effective for magnetic grains. They thus suggested that the magnetostatic attraction of ferromagnetic dust particles could lead to enhanced capture or “sticking” crosssections. They showed that, with a Curie point for iron or an iron-nickel alloy of more than 700°C, and an average time interval between dust particle collisions (based on the optical cross-section) of the order of one year, there would have been time for a very large number of such collisions before oxidation of the iron occurred to any significant degree. Makalkin (1980) also investigated the possibility of the formation of an originally inhomogeneous Earth. His model depends on differences in the physical properties of dust grains in the early stages of evolution of the protoplanetary nebula. These differences are expected to produce difference in the sizes of iron-rich and silicate-rich grains leading to a segregation of the two types of grain. Makalkin believes that segregation would occur if the silicon-rich grains were smaller than the iron-rich grains, the latter being about lo-’ cm in size, or larger. Thus provided that gas was present in the solar nebula during accumulation of the present core-sized embryo, the Earth could form as an inhomogeneous planet with an original iron-rich core and a silicate mantle. Wesson and Lermann (1978) have examined the interaction of dust grains with each other in the solar nebula, taking into account that such grains would carry net steady-state charges like those of grains in interstellar clouds. This would provide a screening mechanism during accretion, resulting in bodies of different compositions depending on the local temperature in the nebula. They found that planetesimals of 0.1-10’ cm in size would form in a time 106-107 years and in the inner solar system would be of iron, stone or mixed composition. Such a mechanism could explain the different types of meteorites. Wesson and Lermann also found that iron grains would have accreted fastest in the inner regions of the primitive nebula. If such iron planestesimals were able to accumulate gravitationally to form larger bodies on a time-scale much shorter than the silicate accretion time-scale, then a planet could evolve with an iron core formed first, the silicate mantle being deposited later. Eucken (1944), Anders (1968), Turekian and Clark (1969) and Clark et al. (1972) have also proposed a model Earth in which the Earth accreted inhomogeneously-not a cold accretion model like that of Orowan (1969), but as a result of condensations from the solar nebula. The observed decrease in density of solid bodies with distance from the sun may then be causally N
118
The Earths Core
related to the radial temperature gradient present in the solar nebula during the condensation of the component materials. The sequence of chemical compositions of solar system bodies may be pictured as paralleling the sequence of condensation reactions undergone by a gas of solar composition during cooling from >2000 K to perhaps 30 K. More specifically, it is possible in principle to calculate the equilibrium chemical composition of solar material as a general function of pressure and temperature, and specify the exact sequence of reactions and the composition of the condensate along any pressure-temperature profile. Larimer (1967) calculated that the order of condensation would be Fe and Ni, magnesium and iron silicates, alkali silicates, metals such as Ag, Ga, Cu, iron sulphide, and finally metals such as Hg, TI, Pb, In and Bi. Such an order of condensation is that grossly inferred in the Earth and usually attributed to differentiation. Turekian and Clark (1969) suggested that the Earth’s core formed by accumulation of the condensed FeNi in the vicinity of its orbit which, as in Orowan’s model, then became the nucleus upon which the silicate mantle was deposited. However, Blander and Katz (1967) and Blander and Abdel-Gawad (1969) maintain that, at the pressures expected to have existed in the solar nebula, the silicates would have condensed before iron. Larimer later revised his estimates and concluded also that iron condensed slightly later than the silicates (Anders, 1968; Larimer and Anders, 1970). Lewis (1972a,b) has developed a model for the origin of the solid bodies in the solar system beginning with a solar nebula in which there is a steep radial temperature gradient. He assumed that the bulk composition of condensates in the nebula is determined by chemical equilibium between the condensates and gases in a system of solar composition. He then calculated the bulk density of condensate as a function of temperature (over the range 0-2200 K) and pressures from lo-’ to loc’ atm. He found that the plot of density of condensate versus temperature was quite insensitive to total pressure over a wide range of pressures, the sequence of reactions and compositions of solid phases formed at equilibrium being essentially pressure-invariant. The condensation and reaction sequence for inner solar system material of the most abundant elements is given in Table 2.1. Lewis obtained a specific density versus temperature curve (Fig. 2.10) that shows large density decreases due to oxidation of iron, hydration of silicates, condensation of water ice, and formation of solid gas hydrates. A notable exception to the trend of decreasing density with falling temperature is the formation of FeS, the mineral troilite, at 680 K. Retention of the volatile element sulphur leads to a density increase because of the high atomic weight of sulphur. Lewis’ model also permits specific correlation of the total volatile content of the bodies with their bulk densities. Thus density, oxidation state, and volatile content are all causally interrelated.
119
The Origin of the Core
TABLE 2.1 Condensationsequence for solar material. (After Lewis, 1973.)
Reaction Refractory oxide condensation Metallic iron condensation MgSiO, condensation Alkali aluminosilicateformation FeS formation Tremoliteformation End of Fe oxrdation to FeO Talclserpentine formation
Temperature (at lO-’bar) ( K) 1720 1460 1420 1250 680 540‘ 490
400
Cumulative bulk density of condensate (gem ’) -3 -7 4 4 4 -4
5 0 40 40 46 3’
3 a5 32
* Tremolite formations occur while the density of the condensate IS already falling rapidly due to Fe oxidation A small uncertainty in the free energy of formation of tremolite thus corresponds to a large uncertainty in the bulk condensate density at the temperatureof tremolite formation
The observed density trends of the terrestrial planets thus need not be the result of special fractionation processes, but a consequence of physical and chemical restraints on the structure of the solar nebula, particularly the variation of temperature with heliocentric distance. The densities of Venus, Mars and the Earth are then due to different degrees of retention of S, 0 and H as FeS, FeO and hydrous silicates produced in chemical equilibrium between condensates and solar-composition gases. Only the Earth is likely to have differentiated so as to extract the heavy alkali metals into the core-thus the very large heat source ( N 10L3Js-’), possible within the OC of the Earth, is impossible on Mercury or Venus and unlikely on Mars. Lewis envisions the planets and smaller bodies to be formed by slow, low-temperature accretion of condensate particles, initially by grain-interaction forces (“stickiness”, magnetic moments, electrostatic forces, etc.) but eventually, after growth of some protoplanets to multikilometre dimensions, by gravitational attraction. Hoyle (1972) has also discussed the origin of the solar system from the viewpoint of condensations in the primitive solar nebula. The temperature of the gases would fall off with increasing distance d from the centre, and certain solid and liquid materials become thermodynamically stable as the temperature falls. As the temperature fell below -1500K a group of refractory materials would condense first, iron in metallic form and certain metal oxides, particularly SiOz, MgO and CaO. This would happen for d - 2 x 1013cm, i.e. at about the radius of the Earth’s orbit. If such condensing materials formed into large enough bodies they would fall out of the gas and continue moving in more or less Keplerian orbits with d remaining of the same order of magnitude. The relevant size for this to happen is of the order of a few metres. Smaller particles would be swept outward by the gas. Solid materials forming
120
The Earths Core
3
6
I
~
/
P
Mercury Venus
d
Earth
d
Mars
MgSi03 condensation
Fe S
formotipn a Fe /
FeO ond
Fe/Si = 0.96
24
1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 Temperature ( K ) Fig.2.10. Density of condensed material in equilibrium with a solar-composition gas, 400-1 600 K at 10-3 bar. A simplified chemical system (the 20 most abundant elements) is employed for three different values of the Fe:Si ratio. The densities of some of the planets are in excellent agreement with an Fe:Si ratio of 1.08, but the omission of rare elements and uncertainties in the abundance of major elements could have displaced the entire manifold of curves slightly. (After Lewis, 1972b.)
in a slowly cooling gas might be expected to be quite pure chemically. Also, for slow cooling the condensation of any one substance should be essentially completed before that of another starts, unless the two substances happen to become thermodynamically stable at much the same temperature. Hoyle thus predicted that iron would be likely to condense independently of MgO and SO2. At a temperature of 1500 K the iron would be metallic, not FeS as usually assumed by geochemists. Hoyle suggested that "chunks of iron would aggregate together more readily at 1500 K than chunks of silica, because the
-
The Origin of the Core
121
iron would be more sticky. Hence it does not seem unreasonable that the first substantial condensations, with sizes of some kilometres, would be balls of comparatively pure iron. I would imagine that from such a beginning the core of the Earth was formed first and that the rock-forming materials were added later”. This general conclusion has been substantiated by the detailed investigations of Grossman (1972a,b) on the condensation sequence of the elements as the primitive solar nebula cooled. Grossman assumed the vapour to be in chemical equilibrium with each condensed phase over the entire temperature range between its condensation point and the temperature at which it was consumed by reaction to form new phases. Thus, the derived sequence of condensation is an accurate description of the changing distribution of the elements between vapour and solid phase and between solid phases themselves, since the effects of high temperature condensates on the composition of the gas were considered in determining the condensation temperatures of lowertemperature species. The temperature of condensation and disappearance of all phases (at 1O-j atm total pressure) are given in Table 2.2. Metallic iron first appears at 1473 K and contains 12.1 mole% Ni. As the gas cools and more alloy condenses, its equilibrium Ni content decreases, reaching 4.9 mole %, corresponding to the Ni/Fe ratio of the solar system (Cameron, 1968), by 1350K. Forsterite first appears at 1444 K, at which temperature 46% of the total iron has already condensed. The pressure dependence of the condensation temperatures of iron, forsterite and enstatite are shown in Fig. 2.1 1, from which it can be seen that iron has a higher condensation temperature than forsterite and enstatite at pressures above about 7.1 x atm respectively. The differand 2.5 x ence between the temperatures of appearance of iron and forsterite gradually increases with increasing pressure, reaching approximately 80” at 10- atm. Forsterite condenses just before enstatite at all pressures above at least atm, with the temperature gap between them also gradually increasing with increasing pressure. At 10-2atm, forsterite condenses at 1528 K and enstatite at 1511 K. Equilibrium condensation of iron-nickel alloy proceeds in the same way over the entire pressure range investigated. The first alloy to condense is relatively nickel-rich but its nickel content rapidly decreases on cooling. Table 2.3 gives the compositions of the first-condensing alloys and their condensation points at several different total pressures. The initial nickel content of the alloy appears to increase very slowly with decreasing pressure, rising 1-1.5 mole % per ten-fold decrease in the total pressure. In Grossman’s inhomogeneous model, in a cooling gas of solar composition at atm, total pressure, 46% of the iron condenses before the forsterite appears. As accretion continues, the release of gravitational poten-
122
The Earth's Core
Stability fields of equilibrium condensates at
TABLE 2.2 atmospheres total pressure. (After Grossman. 1972a.) Condensation temperature
Temperature of disappearance
( K)
(K)
1758 1647 1625 1513 1473 1450 1444 1393 1362 1349 1294 1274 1139 1125' 1000 700 405 Q 200
1513 1393 1450 1362
Phase Corundum Perovskite Melilite Spinel Metallic Iron Diopside Forsterite Anorthite Enstatite Eskolaite Metallic Cobalt Alabandite Rutile Alkali Feldspar Troilite Magnetite Ice
A1203 CaTiO, Ca,AI,SiO,-Ca,MgSi,O, MSAW, (Fe, Ni) CaMgSi,O, Mg,SiO, Ti,O, CaAI,Si,O, MgSiO, CrA co MnS TiO, (Na, K)AlSi,O, FeS Fe,O, Hk-0
1125
-
' Below this temperature, calculations were performed manually using extrapolated high-temperature vapour composition data. In some cases, gaseous species that had been very rare assumed major importance at low temperature (CH,).
tial energy causes melting of the core and the less dense components of the early condensate such as Al2O3,perovskite and melilite float to the surface. Below 1444 K, iron and magnesium silicates condense together and accrete upon the Ni-Fe planetary nucleus. Melting of silicates and iron takes place as a result of the impacting of infalling material and 5-10% Si may enter the sinking metallic liquid by reactions such as those proposed by Brett (1971). In Grossman's model, a large fraction of the total iron is buried inside the Earth at temperatures far above 700 K, below which it would have reacted with solar gases to form FeS. Although high temperature olivine and pyroxene are nearly Fe-free, severe loss of Hz relative to HzO by Jeans escape from the atmosphere of the planet allows 15-20 mole % of the iron end members to enter these phases by the time the temperature has fallen to 1000-900 K. In the later stages of accretion, the accumulation rate decreases and the surface temperature falls, allowing more volatile and oxidized condensates to be retained by the Earth. Lower surface temperatures lead to a convective stage during which both the core and that part of the mantle already accreted are each internally homogenized. A difficulty with the Turekian-Clark and Grossman models is that there does not appear to be enough energy available to melt the OC either during
h
E
c
0
Fig. 2,11. The variation with pressure of the Condensation temperatures of Fe. forsterito and enstatite The deprtvsion of the condensation point of enstatite by the crystallization of forsterite has not been considered in this calculation. At any given pressure, the alloying of N i in the metal will widen slightly the temperature difference between the appearance of Fe and forsterite. Although this temperature gap is small at lo-’ atm, 46% of the Fe will have condensed before forsterite appears. (After Grossman, 1972b.)
124
The Earth’s Core
TABLE 2.3 Composition of the first condensing alloy, its condensation temperature and the fraction of the total iron condensed before the appearance of forsterite as a function of pressure. (After Grossman, 1972a.)
Pressure (am)
10-2
10-3 10-4 10-5 10-6
Condensation temperature of alloy (K)
Initial nickel content of alloy (mole %)
Percentage of total iron condensed at condensation point of forsterite
1584 1473 1377 1292 1218
10.9 12.1 13.5 14.9 16.4
66 46 13 0 0
or after accretion-it is even more difficult to do so for a cold accretion model. It was for this reason that Hanks and Anderson (1969) postulated a very short accretion time-less than 0.5 Ma. This difficulty can be alleviated to some extent if the lighter component of the core is sulphur. In an Earth of meteoritic composition, a sulphur-rich iron liquid would be the first melt to form (see 95.7.2). Core formation could proceed under these conditions at a temperature some 600°C lower than would be required to initiate melting in pure iron. In the vicinity of the core, the eutectic temperature is probably some 1600°C lower than that for pure iron (Hall and Murthy, 1972). Anderson and Hanks (1972) reconsidered the inhomogeneous accretion model and concluded that it could account for the early melting of the core. In their model the proto-Earth consists of a uranium/thorium rich central nucleus, composed chiefly of Ca-, A l - and Ti-rich silicates; a shell of Fe-Ni containing some of the earlier condensates that had not fully condensed or accreted when the Fe and Ni condensed; a shell of less refractory silicates, mainly pyroxene and olivine; a shell of potassium- and sodium-rich silicates; and finally a shell of hydrated minerals and volatile-rich condensates. The proto-core is composed of the refractory nucleus and the Fe-Ni shell. It is the presence of a radioactive nucleus that provides the mechanism for melting the metal shell. In the model of Anderson and Hanks, melting of Fe commences at about 0.4 x lo9 years. The nucleus and the proto-core are not in gravitational equilibrium because Fe is denser than the nucleus. As melting of Fe commences, the nucleus will attempt to rise-the rise of the nucleus to the base of the mantle will not be symmetric because of the convective pattern in the core which is controlled by the rotation of the Earth. When the nucleus leaves the centre of the Earth it will be replaced by nickel-iron which, before its descent, is close to its melting point. Because of the steep slope of the melting curve relative to the adiabatic curve, it will refreeze, explaining the seismic evidence of the solidity and composition of the IC. Their model also suggests
125
The Origin of the Core
that part of the extra-light alloying material in the molten O C may be residue from the nucleus, i.e. Ca-Al-rich oxides and silicates either in solution or in suspension. In this case, the high radioactivity of the material could provide part of the energy for driving the geomagnetic dynamo (see w.7). Ruff and Anderson (1980) have refined this model using additional data from the Allende meteorite. Although their model predicts long-lived heat sources within the initial core, the early thermal history of the Earth is dominated by the short-lived nuclide 26A1 which is responsible for melting the core. In addition, another significant heat source is the potential energy release associated with the rising refractories-their calculations indicate that this heat source is capable of melting at least some fraction of the core. They further suggested that the emplacement of refractory material (including U and Th) in the lowermost mantle is the cause of motions in the core (and could also drive convection in the mantle). They believe that U and Th can provide enough heat energy to maintain the Earth’s magnetic field against dissipative losses. Further experimental work is highly desirable. In this regard Lange and Ahrens (1984) used shock-wave experiments to estimate the strength of impact necessary to free water from minerals such as brucite and serpentine on the surface of an accreting planet. They found that when the Earth was about half its present radius, the impact of further planetesimals would have freed all the water. They then examined how the water would react with iron as the Earth continued to accrete. Water, iron and enstatite react to form forsterite, fayalite and hydrogen; the hydrogen gas could escape, depleting the Earth of its water content. Lange and Ahrens circumvent this difficulty by proposing an inhomogeneous accretion, in which the first planetesimals include more iron than the later arrivals. In order to obtain loz5g of atmospheric water by the end of accretion, slightly heterogeneous accretion is required-the first planetesimals being 36% iron by mass, the last arrivals having almost no iron, as compared to a homogeneous value of 34%. Such models yield final FeO budgets that either require a higher FeO content of the mantle (17 weight %) or oxygen as the light element in the OC of the Earth (see $57.3). Some meteorites contain chondrules, small ( - 1 mm) bodies of crystalline material which may have formed initially as molten droplets by direct condensation in the solar nebula. Other meteorite materials, lacking chondrules, may have crystallized directly from a gas phase, i.e. may have solidified without passing through a liquid state. Workers at the Geophysical Laboratory of the Carnegie Institution, Washington DC, have studied the triple-point conditions for the major meteoritic minerals. High-temperature experiments bar. The triple-point for diopside were carried out at pressures as low as (CaMgSi,O,) was found to be 4 x lo-* bar at 1553 K, and that for enstatite
-
126
The Earths Core
(MgSiO,) somewhat lower. Preliminary work has been carried out at pressures as low as lo-’’ bar. Many of the questions raised in this chapter will be discussed again in Chapter 5 on the constitution of the Earth’s core. Grossman and Larimer (1974) have reviewed the literature on chemical fractionations during the condensation of the solar system, and their consequences on the establishment of chemical differences between the different classes of chondrites and between the planets. As already mentioned, the temperatures for condensation of iron and the major silicate phases from the solar nebula are within a few tens of degrees of one another. Stevenson (1981) thus believes that efficient separation would be very difficult and that, in the absence of an efficient physical or chemical mechanism for large-scale separation, the Earth is more likely to have accreted in an approximately homogeneous fashion with incoming planetesimals containing both iron and silicates in roughly solar (chondritic) abundances.
2.6 Variation of the Gravitational Constant G with Time
Another physical process that could affect the evolution of the Earth is the possibility that the gravitational constant G varies with time. A number of geophysicists (e.g. Egyed, 1956; Carey, 1958; Heezen, 1959; Wilson, 1960) have suggested that the Earth has been expanding with time. In Carey’s hypothesis the expansion took place mainly during the past 500 Ma, leading to an average rate of increase in the radius of the Earth during this period of about 5 mm per year; Egyed inferred a rate of increase of the Earth’s radius of 0.4-0.8 mm per year. Creer (1965) noticed that all the continents fit closely together on a globe about half its present size. Expansion from a completely sial-covered sphere of about 3700km radius at a constant rate of about 0.6 mm per year over 4.5 x lo9 years would give continents the present-day configuration, perhaps modified by continental drift (Wesson 1973). One of the mechanisms that has been suggested to account for such an expansion is Dirac’s (1938) speculation that the gravitational constant G varies inversely with time. With a gradual decrease of G, the pressure would decrease inside the Earth and the volume increase. Dicke (1957) showed that, to account for the expansion demanded by Carey by this mechanism, it would be necessary to assume that G has been decreasing at a rate of roughly 1 part in lo8 per year: to meet the expansion of Egyed, the rate of decrease of G would have to be 1 part in lo9 per year. Egyed (1960) first suggested that palaeomagnetic data might be used to calculate the radius of the Earth at various times in the past. On the expansion hypothesis of Carey, Heezen, and Egyed, the continents do not increase
The Origin of the Core
127
in area, so that the distance between any two points on a stable part of one continent remains the same. Thus if the Earth’s radius increases, the geocentric angle between the two points decreases. Assuming the Earth’s ancient magnetic field to be dipolar, the Earth’s ancient radius may then be found from the measured inclinations of contemporaneous rocks from two localities on the same stable continental block. Cox and Doell (1961) used this method on Permian data from Europe and Siberia to obtain an estimated Permian radius of 0.99 times the present radius. Ward (1963) generalized Egyed’s method of calculation and applied it to Devonian and Triassic data as well as Permian data from Europe and Siberia. He obtained estimated Earth radii for these periods of 1.12, 0.94 and 0.99 times the present radius, respectively, and considered none of these estimates to be significantly different from the present radius. McElhinny et al. (1978) have used palaeomagnetic data for the Earth, and a study of the morphology of the planetary surfaces in other cases, to obtain limits to possible expansion for the Earth, Moon, Mars and Mercury. They concluded that the Earth has not increased its radius by more than 0.8% of its present value over the last 4 x lo8 years, and that the Moon has not expanded by more than 0.06% over the last 4 x lo9 years. Mars and Mercury may have changed their radii slightly over their histories, but not by much. The Mercury data have also been used to set the limit lG/Gl 5 8 x 10- l 2 a for variable-G cosmologies without continuous creation, and IG/Gl 5 2.5 x lo-” a - in cosmologies like Dirac’s (X)-model where there is continuous creation. The palaeomagnetic limit for Earth expansion is equivalent to a limit on the expansion rate of about 0.13 mm per year. The palaeomagnetic method of estimating the radius of the Earth in the past has been criticized by Carey (1976), Wesson (1978) and Smith (1978). Wesson summarizes the arguments and concludes that there is no evidence that rules out slow expansion; but on the other hand there is no evidence that proves the reality of expansion. The expanding Earth hypothesis has also been reviewed by Dearnley (1966), Creer (1967), Carey (1976) and Wesson (1973, 1978). Using high-pressure shock wave data, Birch (1968) showed that the increase in radius of an Earth having a chemically distinct mantle and core would only be about 370 km for a decrease in the gravitational constant from 2G to its present value of G. A larger increase in radius would be possible if Ramsey’s hypothesis (see 95.4) were true-Birch showed, however, that Ramsey’s hypothesis is extremely unlikely to hold. He concluded that if the mass of the Earth has remained constant, changes in the Earth’s radius are unlikely to exceed 100 km. Thus, the sum total of evidence indicates that any large expansion of the Earth has not taken place and that the upper limit to any rate of change of G is about 1 part in 10’O per year.
’
128
The Earths Core
If G has been decreasing with time, the rate of radiation of the sun would have been higher in the past and hence asteroids and meteorite bodies would have been warmer, possibly leading to loss of argon from the material of the meteorites. From the observed K-Ar ages of meteorites, Peebles and Dicke (1962) have shown that G cannot have been decreasing by more than about 1 part in 10" per year. This rules out the possibility that a decrease in G could lead to the large expansions required by Carey and Egyed: the limit of 1 part in 10" per year in the variation in G leads to an upper limit in the rate of increase in the Earth's radius of about 0.05 mm per year. Further deductions by Dicke (1966) on various geophysical effects indicate that only a very small decrease in G is possible. On the other hand, Hoyle (1972) is in favour of a decrease in G with time. One result of this would be higher temperatures in the past-the mean sea-level temperature of the Earth being about 70°C 2000 Ma ago. The most serious objection to a variable G is, in Hoyle's opinion, the Precambrian glaciation of the Canadian shield, which has been estimated to have occurred 2500 Ma ago. Recently there has been a fairly rapid increase in the number of observations of "discrepant redshifts". Hoyle and Narlikar (1971) have given a possible explanation in a theory that incorporates a gravitational constant G that is decreasing with time. In a later paper (1972) they showed that their theory implies that the radius of the Earth has increased at a rate of about 0.1 mm per year. Shapiro ef al. (1971) have placed an observational upper limit of 4 x lo-'' per year on G/G. Taking Hubble's constant as 5 x lo-" year, the variation expected would be lo-'' per year, which is in close agreement with Dicke's (1962) estimate. If G decreases by a sufficient amount a cluster of particles will expand. In some cases the particles may have sufficient velocity to escape from the cluster as the gravitational binding decreases. Since it is known that clusters of galaxies and globular clusters currently exist with finite dimensions, Dearborn and Schramm (1974) were able to set limits on the magnitude of the variation of G , by investigating numerically the dynamical effects on an isolated cluster of galaxies caused by non-zero values of G/G. For a range of initial conditions, the maximum rate of change in G was determined that would still allow the existence of clusters of galaxies at the current epoch. A similar study was made for globular clusters and the results were found to be comparable. They found an upper limit for G/G of 4-10 x lo-" per year. This limit is much stronger than that of Shapiro et al. (1971). However, the Dirac cosmology is not consistent with this limit. Also the Hoyle-Narlikar (1972) cosmology with G/G K l/t would seem to be inconsistent with the observations. On the other hand, Morrison (1973) obtained a limit of similar magnitude to that given by Dearborn and Schramm. He used occultations timed on atomic scales to determine the slowing of the Earth's rotation due to
The Origin of the Core
129
tidal and non-tidal (i.e. depending on 6)forces. Previous determinations were based on data timed on a gravitational basis on which the assumed effects of G/G would not be apparent, leaving only tidal slowing. The close agreement of the deceleration rates then implies G/G = 0, yielding an upper limit of 2 x lo-'' per year on G/C from the uncertainty in the data. This result is approximately the same as that of Dearborn and Schramm. There have been a number of suggestions for obtaining information about the strength of the Earth's gravitational field in the past. To obtain mean rates of change over millions of years a gravity-sensitive geological system is required. There is no shortage of gravity-controlled phenomena, but gravity seldom leaves a permanent record in the rocks and the effects of gravity are usually small compared with those of other often unpredictable variables. Stewart (1970) has suggested a number of phenomena, both geological and biological, that could possibly be used for this purpose. These include the gravitational compaction of clays, the compaction of clays beneath glacial ice, palaeobarometry, the size of flying animals, the depth of animals' footprints, the dimensions of the frames of land animals, and the growth of diapirs. Later Stewart (1972), developed a method that, while not determining accurate values of palaeogravity, has been able to define a limit to the decrease of g with time. The limit, though broad, is not inconsistent with theoretical predictions. Stewart argued that if gravity in the past had been higher than today it is conceivable that some fine-grained sedimentary deposits would be over-consolidated, i.e. compacted more by the smaller sedimentary column above them in the past than by the larger one existing today. Since compaction is relatively rapid and largely irreversible, the requisite evidence could be preserved. Stewart measured the degree of overconsolidation in sediments in the London basin. He found that the London clay now exposed has been consolidated by higher pressures than would have been produced by what is now the greatest thickness of sedimentary overburden to be found anywhere in the London basin. It is of course possible that this extra pressure was derived from sediments younger than any now observed, additional overburden that has since been eroded away. However, if the additional pressure was caused solely by a higher value of g in the past (about 26 Ma ago), Stewart's results indicate that gravity at that time could not have been more than twice its present value. This implies that the maximum possible decrease in g over the past 26 Ma is 4 parts in lo8 per year. Stewart later (1978) set a limit to changes in palaeogravity since the late Precambrian by analysing the pressure-temperature relation of upper-mantle kimberlite nodules, finding that g (now) 5 g (Precambrian) 5 29 (now). This limit confirms his earlier conclusion that g (now) 5 g (Phanerozoic) 5 1.49 (now), obtained from the non-occurrence of lawsonite in deep sedimentary basins (Stewart, 1977). These limits rule out the fast-expansion hypothesis for the
130
The Earths Core
Earth if G and the mass of the Earth have not changed significantly over the last lo9 years; and while the slow-expansion hypothesis is not ruled out, there is no evidence to suggest that g has changed significantly during the last lo9 years. A bibliography on measurements of G, including the question of its possible time-dependence, has been given by Gillies (1982). References
Alfven, H. and Arrhenius, G . (1970a). Structure and evolutionary history of the solar system. I. Astrophys. Space Sci. 8,338. Alfven, H. and Arrhenius, G. (1970b). Origin and evolution of the solar system, 11. Astrophys. Space Sci. 9,3. Alfven, H. and Arrhenius, G. (1973). Structure and evolutionary history of the solar system, 111. Astrophys. Space Sci. 21, 117. Allegre, C. J., DuprB, B. and Brevart, 0. (1982). Chemical aspects of the formation of the core. Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.London A M , 49. Allkgre, C. J., Staudacher, T. L., Sarda, P. and Kurtz, M. (1983). Constraints on evolution of Earth’s mantle from rare gas systematics. Nature 303,762. Anders, E. (1968). Chemical processes in the early solar system, as inferred from meteorites. Acc. Chem. Res. 1,289. Anderson, D. L. and Hanks, T. C. (1972). Formation of the Earth’s core. Nature 237,387. Arrhenius, G., Asunmaa, S . K. and Fitzgerald, R. W. (1972). In Lunar Sci. Inst. (C. Watkins, ed.). Contribution No. 88 in Lunar Science 111. Birch, F. (1965). Energetics ofcore formation. J . Geophys. Res. 70.6217. Birch, F. (1968). On the possibility of large changes in the Earth‘s volume. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 1, 141. Blander, M. and Katz, J. L. (1967). Condensation of primordial dust. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 31, 1025. Blander, M. and Abdel-Gawad, M. (1969). The origin of meteorites and the constrained equilibrium condensation theory. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 33,701. Brecher, H. (1971). On the primordial condensation and accretion environment and the remanent magnetization of meteorites. Proceedings of the IAU Symposium on the Evolutionary and Physical Properties of Meteoroids, Albany, June, 1971. Brett, R. (1971). The Earth’s core; speculations on its chemical equilibrium with the mantle. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 35,203. Cameron, A. G. W. (1968). A new table of abundances of the elements of the solar system. In Origin and Distribution of the Ekments (L. H. Ahrens, ed.). Pergamon Press, Oxford. Cameron, A. G. W. (1972). Models of the primitive solar nebula. Symposium on the Origin ofthe Solar System, Nice 1972 (H. Reeves, ed.) Cent. Nat. Rech. Scient., Paris. Carey, S. W. (1958). A tectonic approach to continental drift. In Continental Drijt, a Symposium. University of Tasmania, Hobart. Carey, S. W. (1976). The Expanding Earth. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Cazenave, A., Lago, B. and Dominh, K. (1982). Numerical experiment applicable to the latest stage of planet growth. Icarus 51,113. Chandrasekhar, S . (1961). Hydrodynamic and Hydromagnetic Stability. Oxford University Press, London. Clark, S. P. Jr., Turekian, K. K. and Grossman, L. (1972). Model for the early history of the Earth. In The Nature ofthe Solid Earth (E. C. Robertson, ed.). McGraw-Hill, New York.
The Origin of the Core
131
Clayton, D. (1984). 26A1 in the interstellar medium. Astrophys. J . 280, 144. Coradini, A., Fedorico, C. and Lanciano, P. (1983). Earth and Mars; early thermal profiles. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 31, 145. Cox, L. P. (1978). Numerical simulation of the final stages of terrestrial planet ,formation. PhD Thesis, MIT. Cambridge, MA. Cox, A. and Doell, R. R. (1961). Palaeomagnetic evidence relevant to a change in the Earth’s radius. Nature 189,45. Cox, L. P. and Lewis, J. S. (1980). Numerical simulation of the final stages of terrestrial planet formation. Icarus 44,706. Creer, K. M. (1965).An expanding Earth? Nature 205,539. Creer, K. M. (1967).Earth, possible expansion of. In International Dictionary ofGeophysics (S. K. Runcorn, ed.). Pergamon Press, Oxford. Davies, G. F. (1982). Ultimate strength of solids and formation of planetary cores. Geophys. Res. Lett. 9, 1267. Davies, G. F. (1985). Heat deposition and retention in a solid planet growing by impacts. Icarus 63,45. Dearnley, R. (1966). Orogenic belts and a hypothesis of Earth evolution. Phys. Chem. Earth 7 , l . Dearborn, D. S. and Schramm, D. N. (1974). Limits on variation of G from clusters of galaxies. Nature 247,441. Dicke, R. H. (1957). Principle of equivalence and the weak interactions. Rev. Mod. Phys. 29,355. Dicke, R. H. (1962). Implication for cosmology of stellar and galactic evolution rates. Rev. Mod. Phys. 34, 110. Dicke, R. H. (1966). The secular acceleration of the Earth’s rotation and cosmology. In The Earth-Moon System (B. G. Marsden and A. G. W. Cameron, eds.). Plenum Press, New York. Dirac, P. A. M. (1938).A new basis for cosmology. Proc. Roy. Soc. London A165 199. Dole, S. H. (1970).Computer simulation of the formation of planetary systems. Icarus 13,494. Egyed, L. (1956). A new theory on the internal constitution of the Earth and its geologicalgeophysical consequences. Acta. Geol. Hung, 4,43. Egyed, L. (1960). Some remarks on continental drift. Geofis. Pura Appl. 45,115. Elsasser, W. M. (1963). Early history of the Earth. In Earth Science and Meteoritics (J. Geiss and E. D. Goldberg, eds.). North-Holland, Amsterdam. Eucken, A. (1944). Physikalisch-chemische Betrachtungen uber die fruheste Entwicklungsgeschichte der Erde. Nachr Akad. Wiss. Gottingen, Math-Phys. K I . , Heft 1, 1. Feber, R. C., Wallace, T. C. and Libby, L. M. (1984). Uranium in the Earth’s core. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union. 65,785. Flerov, G. N., Ter Akopjan, G. M., Popecko, A. G., Fefilov, B. V. and Subbotin, V. G. (1977).Sou. J . Nucl. Phys. 26,449. Fireman, E. L., DeFelice J. and Norton, E. (1970). Ages of the Allende meteorite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 34,873. Fish, R. A,, Goles, G. G. and Anders, E. (1960). The record in the meteorites. 111: On the development of meteorites in asteroidal bodies. Astrophys. J . 132,243. Flasar, F. M. and Birch, F. (1973). Energetics of core formation: a correction. J . Geophys. Res. 78, 6101. Gancarz, A. J. and Wasserburg, G. J. (1977). Initial P b of the Amitsoq gneiss, West Greenland and implications for the age of the Earth. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 41,1283. Gastil, G. (1960).The distribution of mineral dates in time and space. Amer. J . Sci. 258, 1 . Gillies, G. T. (1982).The Newtonian gravitational constant: an index of measurements. Rapport Bur. Int. Poids Mesures 8219. Sevres, France. Goldreich, P. and Ward, W. R. (1973).The formation of planetesimals. Astrophys. J . 183, 1051.
132
The Earth’s Core
Gray, C . M. and Compston, W. (1974). Excess 26Mgin the Allende meteorite. Nature 251,495. Green berg, R. (1979). Growth of large, late-stage planetesimals. Icarus 39, 141. Greenberg, R., Wacker, J. W., Hartmann, W. K., and Chapman, C. R. (1978a). Planetesimals to planets: numerical simulation of collisional evolution. Icarus 35, 1. Greenberg, R., Hartmann, W. K., Chapman, C. R. and Wacker, J. F. (1978b). The accretion of planets from planetesimals. In Protostars and Planets (T. Gehrels, ed.). University of Arizona Press. Grossman, L. (1972a). Condensation in the primitive solar nebula. Geochim. Cosmochim Acta 36, 597. Grossman, L. (1972b). Condensation, chondrites and planets. PhD. Thesis, Yale University. Grossman, L. and Larimer, J. W. (1974). Early chemical history of the solar system. Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 12,71. Gubbins, D. (1981). Planetary magnetism and the thermal evolution of planetary cores. In Evolution ofthe Earth, Geodyn. Ser. (ed. R. J. O’Connell and W. S. Fyfe.) Amer. Geophys. Un., Washington, D.C. Hall, H. T. and Murthy, V. R. (1972). Comments on the chemical structure of an Fe-N-S core of the Earth. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union. 53,602. Hanks, T. C. and Anderson, D. L. (1969). The early thermal history of the Earth. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 2, 19. Harris, P. G. and Tozer, D. C. (1967). Fractionation of iron in the solar system. Nature 215,1449. Hart, R., Dymond, J., Hogan, L. and Schilling, J. G. (1983). Mantle plume noble gas components in glassy basalts from Reykjanes Ridge. Nature 305,403. Hartmann, W. K. (1978). Planet formation: mechanism of early growth. Icarus 33,50. Heezen, B. C. (1959). Palaeomagnetism, continental displacements and the origin of submarine topology. Inter. Ocean. Cong. Hayashi, C., Nakazawa, H. and Mizuno, H. (1979). Earths melting due to the blanketing effect of the primordial dense atmosphere. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 43,22. Hills, J. G. (1970). Dynamic relaxation of planetary systems and Bode’s law. Nature 225,840. Hodkin, D. J. and Potter, P. E. (1980). On the chemical constitution of a molten oxide core of a fast breeder reactor. Rev. Int. Hautes Temper. Refract. Fr. 17,70. Holsapple, K. A. and Schmidt, R. M. (1982). On the scaling of crater dimensions, 2. Impact processes. J . Geophys. Res. 87, 1849. Hoyle, F. (1972). The history of the Earth. Quart. J . Roy. Astron. Soc. 13,328. Hoyle, F. and Narlikar, J. V. (1971). On the nature of mass. Nature 233,41. Hoyle, F. and Narlikar, J. V. (1972). Cosmological models in a conformally invariant gravitational theory. 11: A new model. Mon. Not. Roy Astron. Soc. 155,323. Hoyle, F. and Wickramasinghe, N. C. (1968). Condensation of the planets. Nature 217,415. Isaacman, R. and Sagan, C. (1977). Computer simulations of planetary accretion dynamics: sensitivity to initial conditions. Icarus 31,510. Jaffey, A. H., Flynn, K. F., Glendenin, L. E., Bentley, W. C. and Essling, A. M. (1971). Precision measurements of half-lives and specific activities of 235Uand 238U.Phys. Reo. C 4,1889. Kaiser, T., Piepgras, D. and Wasserburg, G. J. (1981). A search for evidence of a fissionable nuclide in iron meteorites and implications on heat sources in planetary cores. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 52,239. Kaula, W. M. (1979). Thermal evolution of Earth and Moon growing by planetesimal impacts. J . Geophys. Res. 84,999. Kaula, W. M. (1980). The beginning of the Earth’s thermal evolution. In The Continental Crust and its Mineral Deposits (D. W. Strangway, ed.). Geol. Soc. Canad. Spec. Paper 20. Kerridge, J. F. and Vedder, J. F. (1972). Accretionary processes in the early solar system: an experimental approach. Science 177,161.
The Origin of the Core
133
Kieffer, S. W. and Simonds, C. M. (1980). The role of volatiles and lithology in the impact cratering process. Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 18,143. Kinsland, G. L. (1978). The effect of the strength of materials on the interpretation of data from opposed-anvil high-pressure devices. High Temp. High Press. 10,627. Kinsland, G. L. and Bassett, W. A. (1977). Strength of MgO and NaCl polycrystals to confining pressures of 250 kbar at 25°C. J. Appl. Phys. 48,978. Lange, M. A. and Ahrens, T. J. (1982a). Impact induced dehydration of serpentine and the evolution of planetary atmospheres. J. Geophys. Res. 87, Suppl. A, 451. Lange, M. A. and Ahrens, T. J. (1982b). The evolution of an impact generated atmosphere. Icarus 51, 96. Lange, M. A. and Ahrens, T. J. (1984). FeO and HzO and the homogeneous accretion of the Earth. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 71, 111 . Larimer, J. W. (1967). Chemical fractionation in meteorites. I: Condensation of the elements. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 31,1215. Larimer, J. W. and Anders, E. (1970). Chemical fractionation in meteorites. 111: Major element fractionations in chondrites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 34,367. Typhoon Lee, Papanastassiou, D. A. and Wasserburg, G. J. (1976). Demonstration of 26Mg excess in Allende and evidence for 26A1.Geophys. Res. Lett. 3, 109. Typhoon Lee, Papanastassiou, D. A. and Wasserburg, G. J. (1977). Aluminium-26 in the early solar system: fossil or fuel? Astrophys. J. 211, L107. Lewis, J. S. (1972a). Low temperature condensation from the solar nebula. Icarus 16,241. Lewis, J. S. (1972b). Metal/silicate fractionation in the solar system. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 15, 286. Lewis, J. S. (1973). Chemistry of the planets. Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 24,339. Libby, L. M., Libby, W. F. and Runcorn, S. K. (1979). The possibility of superheavy elements in iron meteorites. Nature 278,613. MacDonald, G. J. F. (1959). Calculations on the thermal history of the Earth. J . Geophys. Res. 64,1967. Mahoney, W. A. (1985). 165th Meeting Amer. Astr. SOC.,Tucson, Arizona, Jan 13-16. Mahoney, W. A., Ling, J. C., Wheaton, Wm. A. and Jacobson, A. S. (1984). HEAO 3 discovery of 26A1in the interstellar medium. Astrophys. J . 286,578. Makalkin, A. B. (1980). Possibility of formation of an originally inhomogeneous Earth. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 22, 302. Matsui, T. and Abe, Y. (1986). Formation of a “magma ocean” on the terrestrial planets due to the blanketing effect of an impact induced atmosphere. Earth, Moon, Planets 34,223. Maurette, M. and Bibring, J. P. (1972). Stellar wind radiation damage in cosmic dust grains: implications for the history of early accretion in the solar nebula. Symposium on the Origin of the Solar System, Nice 1972 (H. Reeves, ed.). Cent. Nat. Rech. Scient., Paris. McElhinny, M. W., Taylor, S. R. and Stephenson, D. J. (1978). Limits to expansion of Earth, Moon, Mars and Mercury and to changes in the gravitational constant. Nature 271,316. Morrison, L. V. (1973). Rotation of the Earth from A.D. 1663-1972 and the constancy of G. Nature 241,519. Murrell, M. T. and Burnett, D. S. (1985). K, U and Ca partitioning between sulfide and silicate liquids: heating of planetary cores. Lunar Planet. Sci. XVI, 603. Murrell, M. T. and Burnett, D. S. (1986). Partitioning of K, U, and Th between sulfide and silicate liquids: implications for radioactive heating of planetary cores. J . Geophys. Res. 91, 8 126. Murrell, M. T., Heuser, W. R. and Burnett, D. S. (1983). Partitioning of potassium and uranium between Fe- FeS and silicate liquids. Lunar Planet. Sci. XIV, 536.
134
The Earths Core
Nakagawa, Y., Nakazawa, K. and Hayashi, C. (1981). Growth ofsedimentation ofdust grains in the primordial solar nebula. Icarus 45,517. Nakagawa, Y., Hayashi, C. and Nakazawa, K. (1983). Accumulation of planetesimals in the solar nebula. Icarus 54,361. Neukum, G. (1968). PhD Thesis, University of Heidelberg. OKeefe, J. D. (1977). Impact phenomena on the terrestrial planets. PhD Thesis, University California, Los Angeles. O'Keefe, J. D. and Ahrens, T. J. (1977). Impact induced energy partitioning, melting and vaporization on terrestrial planets. Proc. 8th Lunar. Sci. Con& p. 3357. Orowan, E. (1969). Density of the moon and nucleation of planets. Nature 222,867. Oversby, V. M. and Ringwood, A. E. (1971). Time of formation of the Earth's core. Nature 234, 463. Ozima, M., Podosek, F. A. and Igarashi, G. (1985). Terrestrial xenon isotope constraints on the early history of the Earth. Nature 315,471. Patterson, C. and Tatsumoto, M. (1964). The significance of lead isotopes in detrital feldspar with respect to chemical differentiation within the Earth's mantle. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 28, 1. Peebles, J. and Dicke, R. H. (1962). The temperature of meteorites, Dirac's cosmology and Mach's Principle. J . Geophys. Res. 67,4063. Podosek, F. A. (1970). Dating of meteorites by the high-temperature release of iodine-correlated Xe'29. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 34,341. Podosek, F. A. and Lewis. R. S. (1972). "'I and 244Puabundances in white inclusions of the Allende meteorite. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 15, 101. Purcell, E. M. and Spitzer, L. (1971). Orientation of rotating grains. Astrophys. J . 167,31. Ransford, G. A. (1982). The accretional heating of the terrestrial planets. Phys. Earth Planet Int. 29, 209. Rao, M. N. Gopalan, K. (1973). Curium-248 in the early solar system. Nature 245,304. Reeves, H. (ed.) (1972). Symposium on the Origin ofthe Solar System, Nice 1972. Cent. Nat. Rech. Scient., Paris. Ringwood, A. E. (1959). On the chemical evolution and densities of the planets. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 15,257. Ringwood, A. E. (1960). Some aspects of the thermal evolution of the Earth. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 20,241. Ringwood, A. E. (1966). Chemical evolution of the terrestrial planets. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 30,41. Rowe, M. W. and Kuroda, P. K. (1965). Fissiogenic xenon from the Passamonte meteorite. J . Geophys. Res. 70,709. Ruff, L. and Anderson, D. L. (1980). Core formation, evolution and convection: a geophysical model. Phys. Earth Planet. Znr. 21, 181. Runcorn, S. K. (1962a). Towards a theory ofcontinental drift. Nature 193,311. Runcorn, S. K. (1962b). Palaeomagnetic evidence for continental drift and its geophysical cause. In Continental Drft (S. K. Runcorn, ed.). Academic Press, London and Orlando. Runcorn, S. K. (1978). On the possible existence of superheavy elements in the primaeval moon. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 39, 193. Runcorn, S. K., Libby, L. M. and Libby, W. F. (1977). Primaeval melting of the moon. Nature 270,676. Safronov, V. S . (1962). Velocity dispersion in rotating systems of gravitating bodies with inelastic collisions. Voprosy Kosmogonii, 8, 168. Safronov, V. S. (1969). Evolution of the protoplanetary cloud and formation of the Earth and planets. Nauka, Moscow (1969); translated NASA TTF-667 (1972).
The Origin of the Core
135
Safronov, V. S. (1972). Accumulation of the planets. In Symposium on the Origin of’the Solar System, Nice 1972 (H. Reeves, ed.). Cent. Nat. Rech. Scient., Paris. Safronov, V. S. (1978). The heating of the Earth during its formation. Icarus 3 3 , l . Schramm, D. M., Tera, F. and Wasserburg, G. J. (1970). The isotope abundance of 26Mg and limits on 26A1 in the early solar system. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. l O , 4 4 . Shapiro, I. I., Smith, W. B., Ash, M. B., Ingalls, R. P. and Pettengill, G. H. (1971). Gravitational constant: experiment bound on its time variation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 26,27. Share, G. H., Kinzer, R. L., Kurfess, J. D., Forrest, D. J., Chupp, E. L. and Rieger, E. (1985). Detection of galactic 26A1gamma radiation by the SMM spectrometer. Astrophys. J . Lett. 292,2 Pt 2, L6l. Shaw, G. H. (1978). Effects ofcore formation. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 16,361. Smith, P. J. (1978). The end of the expanding Earth hypothesis? Nature 271,301. Sonett, C. P. and Colburn, D. S. (1967). Establishment of a lunar unipolar generator and associated shock and wake. Nature 216, 340. Sonett, C. P. and Colburn, D. S. (1968). The principle of solar wind induced planetary dynamos. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 1, 326. Sonett, C. P. and Herbert, F. L. (1977). Pre-main sequence heating of planetoids. In Proc. IAU Coll. No. 39, Relationships Between Comets, Asteroids and Meteorites (A. H. Delsemme, ed.). University of Toledo. Sonett, C. P., Colburn, D. S. and Schwartz, K. (1968). Electrical heating of meteorite parent bodies and planets by dynamo induction from a pre-main sequence T-Tauri solar wind. Nature 219,924. Sonett, C. P., Colburn, D. S., Schwartz, K. and Keil, K. (1970). The melting of asteroidal sized bodies by unipolar dynamo induction from a primordial T-Tauri sun. Astrophys. Space Sci. 7,446. Sonett, C. P., Smith, B. F., Colburn, D. S., Schubert, G, and Schwartz, K. (1972), in Proc. Third Lunar Sci. Conf. 3,2309 (Geochim. Cosmochim Acta Suppl. 3). Spaute, D., Lago, B. and Cazenave, A. (1985). Gaseous drag and planetary formation by accretion. Icarus 64,139. Staudacher, T. R. and Allegre, C. J. (1982). Terrestrial xenology. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 60,389. Stevenson, D. J. (1980). Lunar asymmetry and palaeomagnetisrn. Nature 287,520. Stevenson, D. J. (1981). Models of the Earth’s core. Science 214,61 I. Stewart, A. D. (1970). Palaeogravity. In Palaeogeophysics (S. K. Runcorn, ed.). Academic Press. London and Orlando. Stewart, A. D. (1972). Palaeogravity from the compaction of fine-grained sediments. Nature 235, 322. Stewart, A. D. (1977). Quantitative limits to palaeogravity, J . Geol. SOC.London 133,281. Stewart, A. D. (1978). Limits to palaeogravity since the late Precambrian. Nature 271, 153. Tolland, H. G. (1973). Formation of the Earth’s core. Nature Phys. Sci. 243, 141. Tozer, D. C. (1965). Thermal history of the Earth. 1: The formation of the core. Geophys. J . 9,95. Tozer, D. C. (1972). The present thermal state of the terrestrial planets. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 6, 182. Turekian, K. K. and Clark, S. P. Jr. (1969). Inhomogeneous accumulation of the Earth from the primitive solar nebula. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 6, 346. Urey, H. C. (1952). The Planets. Yale University Press. Urey, H. C. (1962). The origin of the moon and its relationship to the origin of the solar system. In The Moon ( Z . Kopal and Z. K. Mikhailov, eds.). Academic Press, London and Orlando. Vening Meinesz, F. A. (1952). Convection currents in the Earth and the origin of the continents, I. Kon. Ned. Akad. Weten. 55, 527. Vidal, P. and Dosso, L. (1978). Core formation+atastrophic or continuous-Sr and Pb isotope geochemistry constraints. Geophys. Res. Lett. 5, 169.
136
The Earths Core
Vityazev, A. V. (1973). On gravitational differentiation energy in the Earth. Izu. Earth Phys. 10, 676. Vityazev, A. V. and Mayeva, S. V. (1976). Model of the early evolution of the Earth. Izu. Earth Phys. 12, 79. Vollmer, R. (1977). Terrestrial lead isotopic evolution and formation time of the Earth’s core. Nature 210,144. Ward, M. A. (1963). On detecting changes in the Earth’s radius. Ceophys. J . 8,217. Weidenschilling, S. J. (1980). Dust to planetesimals: settling and coagulation in the solar nebula. Icarus 44,172. Wesson, P. S. (1973). The implications for geophysics of modern cosmologies in which G is variable. Quart. J . Roy, Astron. Soc. 14,9. Wesson, P. S. (1978). Cosmology and Geophysics. Adam Hilger, Bristol. Wesson, P. S. (1980). Graoity, Particles and Astrophysics. Reidel, Holland. Wesson, P. S. and Lermann, A. (1978). The formation of iron, stone and mixed planetesimals in the early solar system. Icarus 33,74. Wetherill, G. W. (1972). The beginning of continental evolution. Technophysics 13,31. Wetherill, G. W. (1976). The role of large impacts in the formation of the Earth and Moon. Proc. Lunar Sci Conf: 7,3245. Wetherill, G. W. (1978). Accumulation of the terrestrial planets. In Protostars and Planets, (T. Gehrels, ed.). University of Arizona Press. Wetherill, G. W. (1980a). Formation of the terrestrial planets. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophis. 18, 77. Wetherill, G. W. (1980b). Numerical calculations relevant to the accumulation of the terrestrial planets. In The continental crust and its mineral deposits (D. W. Strangway, ed.). Geol. SOC. Canad. Spec. Paper 20. Wetherill, G. (1985). Occurrence of giant impacts during the growth of the terrestrial planets. Science 228,877. Wilson, J. T. (1960). Some consequences of expansion of the Earth. Nature 185,880.
Chapter Three
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
3.1
Introduction
Early work on the thermal history of the Earth was based on the supposition that the thermal regime was controlled by conduction alone. This raised two difficulties. First, the time z required to reach equilibrium from some initial temperature distribution N R2/k,where R is the radius of the Earth and k the thermal conductivity. z is of the order of 10“ s, longer than the age of the Earth, so that most of the original heat would not have been dissipated. The second difficulty is the unknown initiai boundary conditions, which depend on the circumstances surrounding the origin of the solar system. Allowing for convection resolves these difficulties. z can be considerably reduced and, if the thermal regime of the deep interior is controlled by a fixed viscosity as maintained by Tozer (1972) and discussed in detail in $3.8, then the physical properties of the interior have only a “fading memory” of the initial conditions at the time of the formation of the solar system and do not depend on a prescribed cosmological theory. To obtain some idea of the thermal structure of the deep interior of the Earth, it is necessary to obtain estimates of the melting point and adiabatic gradients: these are considered in &3.4 and 3.5. Since both these gradients depend on Gruneisen’s parameter, this will be discussed first. 3.2
Griineisen’s Parameter
Many basic physical relationships that are important in a study of the Earth‘s 137
138
The Earths Core
deep interior can be expressed in terms of the dimensionless Gruneisen parameter y. These include the adiabatic gradient, the melting-point curve, the Hugoniot curve and the equation of state for solids and liquids. y can be defined as
where CI is the volume coefficient of expansion, kT and ks the isothermal and adiabatic incompressibilities, p the density and cv, c p the specific heats at constant volume and constant pressure respectively. Numerical values of y are close to unity for most condensed substances, including liquids and gases, and y is thus much more nearly constant over the range of physical conditions in the Earth’s deep interior than its component parameters a, k,, ks or p. For solids above about half of their Debye temperature, y is virtually independent of temperature, but decreases slightly with pressure. The definition of y in (3.1) is sometimes referred to as the thermodynamic Gruneisen parameter ?, to distinguish it from related parameters with different definitions. Using standard mathematical identities of thermodynamics, alternative definitions of y are (3.2)
where p is pressure, V volume and T temperature. This last expression shows that y is the negative slope of a log-log plot of temperature against volume in a material undergoing adiabatic compression. In his studies of crystal lattice dynamics, Gruneisen (1912, 1926) defined a parameter yi as y. =
- d (In vi)
d(In V )
(3.3)
where v i is the frequency of the ith mode of lattice vibration. If all vi have the same volume dependence and are independent of temperature, yi defined by (3.3) can be shown to be equivalent to y defined by (3.1)-see e.g., Knopoff (1963); If a material is heated from zero temperature and then recompressed to its original volume V, the total pressure p at temperature T is given by the Mie-Gruneisen equation of state yEth
P = P o + v
(3.4)
where E t h is the thermal energy. This assumes that the thermal pressure can be separated from the static pressure. In the absence of an electron contribution, y in (3.4) is the same as that defined in (3.1).
139
The Thermal Regime of the Earth‘s Core
Neglecting the electron contribution, (3.4) has been used by many authors to obtain a relationship between y and the pressure dependence of the incompressibility k. In 1939, Slater obtained the result 1 dk 2dp
y=----
1 6
(3.5)
In his analysis, he appealed to the Debye theory of lattice vibrations, in which 2/3 of the modes are transverse. Later, Dugdale and MacDonald (1953) obtained the expression
Irvine and Stacey (1975) showed that the main defect in this relationship is the assumption that the forces due to atomic vibrations in mutually perpendicular directions are independent. By considering classical (hightemperature) three-dimensional anharmonic thermal oscillations of atoms in simple crystal structures with purely central interatomic forces, Irvine and Stacey obtained the equation
Vashchenko and Zubarev (1963) obtained the same result by a completely different approach, and Irving and Stacey have since called it yvz. It reduces to Dugdale and MacDonald’s expression (3.6) if the vibrations are assumed to be one-dimensional. The greatest departures of (3.7) from laboratory values of y are for strongly covalent materials in which inherent bond rigidity introduces an additional constraint on thermal vibrations. Irving and Stacey allowed for non-central forces by adding a termfto the expression for interatomic force constants to account for the constraint imposed by bond flexure. This leads to a modification of equation (3.7): Y=
It must be emphasized that (3.7) has been derived on the assumption that y is independent of temperature. Since k(p) is fairly well known from seismic data, y can be estimated from Earth model data. It is assumed that the data on k(p) for a mixture of phases can be used to estimate y for the same mixture. This is unlikely to introduce serious errors, since finite-strain theories indicate a common approximate k ( p ) relationship for all materials at very high pressures; see also Bullen’s (k, p ) hypothesis (95.5). Application of (3.7) to the fluid
140
The Earths Core
OC may be justified by the fact that, at core pressures, the material must approximate a close-packed atomic arrangement despite being completely dislocated in the fluid state, and that the frequency of thermal atomic oscillations is much greater than the frequency of diffusive transitions. For the upper mantle, however, non-central forces are important and the additional correction factorfin (3.8) must be used. For plausible materials in the upper . the core and lower mantle, laboratory tests for y indicate a value ~ 0 . 8 For mantle,fN 0, and seismic data indicate values of y in the lower mantle N 1.0 and in the core N 1.4. It is interesting to note that this is not the trend of the pressure dependence of y for any particular material at constant phase, which shows a decrease with pressure. Anderson (1979a) has preferred to use (3.3) to define what he has called the high-temperature acoustic y:
(3.10)
(3.1 1)
The rationale of the derivation of (3.9) from equation (3.3) is given in Anderson (1968). Essentially all modes are lumped into two kinds-shear and longitudinal-and since all shear modes are equal, they are equal to ys. Anderson prefers his approach to Stacey’s (1977), since it involves the seismic data direct rather than derived values of k and dkldp which smooth out fluctuations in up and us. He found that yo decreases exponentially from 1.3 to 1.0 in the lower mantle and is about 1.5 in the core. In a later paper, Falzone and Stacey (1980) developed, for a face-centred cubic element, an atomic potential formulation for the second-order theory of elasticity, in which terms to second order in strain are retained in calculating atomic bond length changes and elastic moduli. They used the same approach in a further paper (1981) to calculate the energy of thermal vibrations. The analysis differs from that of Irvine and Stacey (1975) by allowing for the mutual dependence of atomic bonds. In the 1975 paper it was assumed that the only elastic forces that were significant were due to nearest-neighbour central force atomic interactions and that all the bonds in a crystal structure were independent. Falzone and Stacey (1980) showed that, although the central force approximation is good for close-packed structures, the assumption of bond independence is not. Allowing for this mutual dependence, they obtained (1981) a new formulation of their expression for the thermal
141
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
Gruneisen parameter y. Equation (3.7) again has additional terms infin the numerator and denominator, leading to the result
The casef= 1, representing independent bonds, reduces to (3.7). It should be noted that the factorfin (3.12) is not the same as the factorfin (3.8), where f = 0 reduces to (3.7). Falzone and Stacey (1980) believe that second-order elasticity theory provides the best explanation of the elasticity of the IC and that (3.12) is appropriate there. However, it cannot be applied to the lower mantle where atomic bond angle rigidity, not considered in the derivation of (3.12), may be appreciable. Jamieson et al. (1978) considered all possible contributions to y Iikely to be important in the core-vibrational, electronic, magnetic ordering (ferromagnetic) and Schottky anomaly (high-spin-low-spin). The thermodynamic Gruneisen parameter is then given by (3.13)
where yi are the partial Griineisen parameters and ci the specific heats. The vibrational contribution is estimated from (3.9) in the solid IC. In the OC another formula must be used that does not explicitly include the effect of shear waves, for example the Slater (3.9, Dugdale-MacDonald (3.6) or the Irvin Stacey (3.7) formulation. Jamieson et al. prefer the Irvine-Stacey formulation and estimated yvibfor a number of Earth models. They estimated the electronic contribution y e from the equation d In D ( Ye
=
d In p
E ~ )
(3.14)
where D(+) is the electronic density of states at the Fermi energy. They obtained the same range of values for ye as for yvib viz. 1.2-1.8. Finally, Jamieson et al. considered possible contributions from magnetic effects to c, = Ciciand y in the high-pressure form of iron. For the Schottky anomaly effect on the specific heat, they concluded that it might have a small effect under core conditions; if so, it would lead to a slight increase in y. For ferromagnetic ordering to be important under core conditions, the Curie temperature would have to increase fairly rapidly with pressure. This would lead to a further increase in y. Figure 3.1 shows their estimated contributions to the specific heat of iron in the core as a function of temperature. It can be seen that both the vibrational and electronic specific heats are significant under core conditions. Magnetic contributions may cause a small perturbation.
142
The Earth’s Core
I
3
I
I
I
I
V i brat ionol
-
cV
N k 2
I
I 1
200
500
1000 2000 5000 I( 100
Fig. 3.1. Contributions to Cv in iron under core pressures and temperatures (After Jamieson et a / , 1978 )
Table 3.1 summarizes their conclusions on the different contributions to c, and y. Fazio et al. (1978) also estimated y as a function of temperature and volume for iron. They considered various crystal structures and several kinds of intermolecular potential functions. They concluded that it was not possible to obtain sufficiently accurate estimates of y in the Earth’s core, mainly because experimental data cannot help choose between possible potential functions. Jeanloz (1979) has used shock-wave (Hugoniot) data for iron to estimate values of y at high pressures and temperatures. He found that they satisfy the empirical relation (Anderson, 1968, 1979a) Y = Yo (PO/PY
(3.15)
TABLE 3.1 Contributionsto Cvand y in core. (After Jamieson eial., 1978.) Term Vibrational Electronic Schottky Anomaly Ferromagnetic Total
CvlNk
Y
3 1-2 0-0.4
1.2-1.9 1 .z-1 .a 4
0 4-5.4
0 1.2-2.0
~
143
The Thermal Regime of the Earth‘s Core
Using the initial density of E-Fe as a centering volume, the best values for y o and q are 2.2(+0.5) and 1.62( f0.37) respectively. The value of y o is not very well constrained by the data because of greater uncertainties at low densities. However, the value of q is significantly different from 1, implying that the assumption often used (e.g. McQueen et al., 1970) py = const
(3.16)
is not correct for Fe at high pressures. Using only seismic data, Anderson (1979b) found that the empirical relation (3.15) was also applicable to the lower mantle. A value of q in the range, 0.8
I
I
2
Y 1
yvz
0
I
I
I
100
2 00
300
1 1
400
Pressure ( G P d Fig. 3.2. The Griineisen parameter for pressures extending through the core as estimated by Stacey (1977) and as extrapolated from the data on iron (Jeonloz. 1979), The function :?p const assumed by Mcaueen e t a / . (1970) is also shown. (After Jeanloz, 1979.)
145
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
TABLE 3.2 Estimates of y and for iron at pressures corresponding to the ICE and M C E ( j includes a correction for the electronic contribution.) (After 0. L. Anderson, 1982.)
7
Y
Stacey (1 977) Eoschi and Mulargia (1977) Jamieseon el a/. (1 978) Welch e t a / . (1 978) Anderson (1979a) Jeanloz (1 979) Stevenson (1981) Anderson (1 982) Probable value
MCE
ICE
MCE
ICE
-
-
1.2-2.0 1.15 1.45-1.65
1.2-2.0 1.04 1.4-1.6
1.32 1.3 1.2-2.0
1.17 0.734.93 1.2-2.0
-
1.4 1.7 -
(1.3)
In principle, y is specified by the pressure-dependencies of the elastic constants, which, in the case of the Earth, are well determined by seismology. A reasonable approach would be to accept the values of y inferred from seismological data and base thermal models of the Earth directly on seismological models, without appeal to any assumed equation of state.
3.3 The Earth’s Inner Core
The seismological evidence for a sharp ICB, and possibly one or more firstorder discontinuities in velocity at greater radii, raises the important question of possible liquid-solid or solid-solid phase transitions in either a homogeneous material or in a multi-component chemical system. If the transition from the IC to the OC is a transition from the solid to the liquid form of a single material, then the boundary must be at the melting point and a constraint is put on the thermal regime of the Earth’s interior. Jacobs (1953) used this fact to explain how the mantle and IC could be solid, while at the same time the OC is liquid. Consider the simplest type of model first-a core of pure iron and a mantle of silicates. At the boundary between the mantle and core there will then be a discontinuity in the melting-pointkdepth curve, although the actual temperature must be continuous across the boundary. The form of this discontinuity could, mathematically, take any of the three cases shown in Figure 3.3. Case 1, in which the melting-point curve in the core is always above that in the mantle, is impossible; for the actual temperature curve must lie below the melting-point curve in the mantle, above it in the core, and yet be continuous
146
MELTING PWT
The Earths Core
1
J d + I
MANTLE; CORE
-
W L E
CORE
MANTLE \CoRE I
-
Case 2 Case I DEPTH Fig. 3.3. Possible forms of the melting-pointdepth curve in the neighbourhood of the MCB.
Fig. 3.4. Melting-point curve and successive adiabats in the Earrh's interior. (After Jacobs, 1953.)
across the boundary. Cases 2 and 3 are both possible. In case 3, the meltingpoint curve in the core never rises above the value of the melting point in the mantle at the MCB, while in case 2 it exceeds this value for part of the core. Considering first case 2, the melting-point curve will be of the general shape shown in Figure 3.4. If the Earth cooled from a molten state, the temperature gradient would be essentially adiabatic, there being strong convection currents and rapid cooling at the surface. Solidification would commence at that depth at which the
147
The Thermal Regime of the Earth's Core
curve representing the adiabatic temperature first intersected the curve representing the melting-point temperature. Solidification would thus begin at the centre of the Earth. A solid IC would then continue to grow until a curve representing the adiabatic temperature intersected the melting-point curve twice, once at A, the boundary between the core and mantle, and again at B, as shown in Fig. 3.4. As the Earth cooled still further, the mantle would begin to solidify from the bottom upwards. The liquid layer between A and B would thus be trapped. The mantle would cool at a relatively rapid rate, leaving this liquid layer essentially at its original temperature, insulated above by a rapidly thickening shell of silicates and below by the already solid (iron) IC. In the above discussion, no specific values of the temperatures are postulated and the behaviour of the adiabatic and melting-point curves need not be known exactly. If they vary qualitatively as shown, the above argument gives a physical explanation for the existence of a solid IC. It follows by similar reasoning that if the melting-point-depth curve in the neighbourhood of the MCB is as shown in case 3 of Fig. 3.3, then as the Earth cooled from a molten state, the entire core would be left liquid. The physical state of the IC thus depends on the magnitude of the discontinuity in the melting-point curve at the MCB. Finally, if the Earth had a cold origin and never became completely molten, then as the temperature increased with time either case 2 or case 3 could lead eventually to a liquid OC with a solid IC. However, if the Earth were never completely molten, it is difficult to explain the differentiation into core and mantle and hence a melting-pointdepth curve of the form shown in Fig. 3.4. The Earth would have had to have accreted inhomogeneocsly (see $2.5). As discussed later, the core is not pure iron but contains some light alloying element(s). As the core cooled, solidification would still begin at the centre of the Earth when the temperature first intersected the liquidus and a solid IC would grow as outlined above. However, the above arguments break down if the melting point and adiabatic temperature curves of Higgins and Kennedy (1971) are correct-for in their curves the adiabatic gradient is steeper than the melting point gradient in the OC. The shape of these two curves is discussed in detail in the next two sections. 3.4
Melting-Point-Depth Curves
Simon (1937) formulated a semi-empirical equation for the dependence of the melting-point on pressure which has often been applied to geophysical problems. Simon's equation is P =A[($)
- 11
(3.17)
148
The Earths Core
where A is a constant, related to the internal pressure, T, the melting-point temperature at pressure p , Tmothe melting point at atmospheric pressure, and c numerical constant. A partial theoretical basis for Simon’s equation has been given by Salter (1954) and Gilvarry (1956a,b,c). Gilvarry showed that the constant c is related to Griineisen’s parameter y through the equation (3.18)
Another empirical expression for the melting-point at high pressures has been proposed by Kraut and Kennedy (1966). They showed that the Simon equation for metals almost invariably predicts higher melting temperatures at higher pressures than are measured in the laboratory, and that for most metals there is a linear relationship between T, and the fractional change in volume (AV/V& of the solid resulting from the applied pressure. Their equation is
where c is a constant depending on the particular substance. Substances bonded by van der Waals’ forces yield curves concave to the temperature axis; a small number of ionically bonded substances to which the relationship has been applied give curves convex to the temperature axis. Kennedy and Vaidya (1970) showed, however, that materials with metallic bonding result in general in a straight-line relationship. If the linear relationship (3.19) between T, and ( A V / V & holds for iron, a melting-point-depth curve may be obtained for the core of the Earth provided the initial slope of the melting curve of iron is known and also the relationship between pressure and the specific volume of iron along its melting curve. Higgins and Kennedy (1971) used data obtained from experimental work on the melting of iron by Sterrett et al. (1956) and from the results of shockwave experiments on the density of iron at high pressures (Van Thiel, 1966) to estimate the melting point gradient in the Earth’s core. Verhoogen (1973) pointed out that the estimate of Higgins and Kennedy is based on a hundred-fold linear extrapolation of the 30 kbar experimental results of Sterrett et al. (1965). These measurements are themselves somewhat uncertain as they also require an extrapolation, over a range of several hundred degrees, of the effect of pressure on the thermocouples. Higgins and Kennedy extrapolated results from 30 kbar to 3.3. Mbar, by assuming that the melting-point is a linear function of the fractional change in volume of the solid (3.19). This law (Kraut and Kennedy, 1966), which is known not to be valid for non-metals, is assumed to hold for all metals including iron, even though there are metals to which it obviously does not apply, such as those
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
149
that have a negative initial slope of the melting-point curve (e.g. Bi), or those (e.g. Cs) which have one or several maxima in the melting-point curve. Also, Higgins and Kennedy ignore the phase changes (d+y and Y + E ) that occur in iron and which must affect the slope of the melting-point curve. Verhoogen also pointed out that the very low melting-point gradient that Higgins and Kennedy obtained for the deeper parts of the core implies that at these high pressures iron melts with only a very small change in volume, in which case the density jump (-0.5 g cmP3)at the IC boundary cannot be accounted for by melting alone but must imply a notable difference in composition between solid and liquid: this in turn requires that the temperature there be much less than 4500 K. The core would then be practically isothermal and could not contain any heat sources of any kind and thermal convection would be ruled out. The effect of pressure on the melting temperature of metals has also been investigated by McLachlan and Ehlers (1971), based on the theory that an entrapped gaseous fraction is formed when a metal changes from the solid to the liquid state. Their equation is (3.20)
where R is the gas constant and /?’ an “effective” compressibility constant. The exponential term allows for the (observed) decrease in slope dT,/dp with increase in pressure. Equation (3.20) is based primarily on kinetic theory and is in good agreement with experimental curves of ( p , T,) obtained for Li, Na, K, Rb, Fe and Ni. McLachlan and Ehlers warn against extrapolating the melting curve for Fe to pressures at the MCB, however, because of our lack of knowledge of possible electronic and phase changes that may occur at such high pressures. One metal, Cs, has been subjected to pressures high enough to cause both types of changes to occur (Jayaraman et al., 1967). Cs shows a known structural phase change between 20 and 30 kbar and is accompanied by a mild, but distinct, dip in the melting-point curve. At higher pressures a phase change occurs whose cause was attributed by Fermi to electronic collapse of the atoms. The electronic phase change occurs first in the liquid over a broad pressure range. This causes a large drop in the melting-point curve to 42.5 kbar where the solid undergoes an abrupt volume change of about 9% followed by a large change in slope of the melting-point curve. Figure 3.5, after McLachlan and Ehlers (1971), shows schematically how any metal might behave under pressure. Starting at zero pressure with a melting point T,,, the curve follows (3.20) up to a limiting point M , where a phase change S t starts taking effect. This may be accompanied by a dip in the melting-point curve, as in the case of Cs. For close-packed structures phase
150
The Earth’s Core
Depthzf (pressure) Fig. 3.5. Hypothetical extension of melting-point data to the Earth’s core. The coordinates represent change of p and T with depth. Curve T, shows schematic changes of the melting-point curve, and T. is a possible geothermal gradient. The point K coincides with the ICB, whereas I may either be at the M C B or within the lower mantle. (After McLachlan and Ehlers. 1971 .)
changes should be absent, but one such change can be expected for bodycentred structures. At point G, (3.20) with a new set of parameters might apply up to the limiting point H, where an electronic change begins its influence, reducing the temperature from H, through I to J, then back up through K, and continuing through further possible electronic or phase changes up to pressures at the centre of the Earth L. Superimposed on this graph is a schematic curve of temperature of the Earth T,, extending from 0 through I, and from K to A. Between I and K the melting temperature T,,, is less than the geothermal gradient T,, and the material would be liquid. McLachlan and Ehlers warn that the data extend only to M, and are extrapolated to L on the T,-p curve to show the possible contrast between predictions of (3.20) and the effect of additional phase changes. Leppaluoto (1972) has applied Eyring’s significant structure theory of liquids to the problem of the melting of iron. The significant structure theory is based on the idea that molecules of liquid are more or less free to move about in a structure that is basically solid-like (see John and Eyring (1971) for a review on the subject). It is possible to calculate the thermodynamic properties of a liquid from a mathematical expression of this concept, and Tuerpe
The Thermal Regime of the Eart!is Core
151
and Keeler (1967) have used the theory to estimate melting curves at high pressures, but obtained anomalous results. Thus, as Kennedy and Higgins (1973a) have pointed out, the significant structure theory, although successful in predicting some thermal properties of liquids at moderate temperatures and pressures, may not be applicable to describing the phenomenon of melting. In Leppaluoto’s study the melting-point at high pressures is determined by equating the free energies of liquid and solid: shock wave data are used to determine the volume and other properties of the solid. The method has the advantage of removing some of the empiricism attached to other current melting laws that focus exclusively on the properties of the solid and ignore the essence of the melting phenomenon as a two-phase equilibrium. Leppaluoto’s calculations, however, involve a parameter (the activation volume) that is not well known, so that at very high pressures the melting-point can only be estimated to lie within a certain range. Leppaluoto estimated the melting point for iron to be k5000K at the MCB (-1.4Mbar) and 2 7000 K at the ICB ( N 3.3. Mbar). The fundamental relationship between the melting point and pressure is given by the Clausius-Clapeyron equation (3.21)
where A V and AS are the volume and entropy increments on melting and L the latent heat of melting. However, this equation cannot readily be applied to the deep interior of the Earth because of the unknown pressure dependence of A V and L. As a result, a number of semi-empirical relationships have been suggested-some of these have already been discussed. One that has been extensively used is Lindemann’s law (1910), which was derived on the hypothesis that melting occurs when the amplitudes of thermal vibrations of atoms becomes large enough to cause atomic “collisions”. Gilvarry (1956a) replaced Lindemann’s assumption of direct contact of neighbouring atoms at fusion by the criterion that melting occurs when the r.m.s. amplitude of thermal vibrations exceeds a critical fraction of the separation distance of nearest-neighbour atoms. The Lindemann law can be expressed in terms of the Gruneisen parameter y, (3.22)
where k is the incompressibility along the melting curve. It should be noted that y here is not the thermodynamic definition of y given by (3.1). Alder (1966) has used the Lindemann law and estimated the melting temperature of iron at the MCB to be about 4400 K, and at the ICB to be about 7450 K.
152
The Earth‘s Core
Stacey and Irvine (1977) obtained a melting equation similar to (3.22) based on thermodynamic arguments. They used the Clausius-Clapeyron equation (3.21) together with the assumption that the Mie-Griineisen equation can be adapted to describe the pressure change associated with melting at constant volume. This assumption implies that melting is only a minor perturbation of the crystal structure, atomic bonds being merely stretched or compressed. Those materials that do not satisfy Lindemann’s law presumably undergo major changes in coordination during melting. Stacey and Irvine obtained the equation 1 dT, 2 ( y - ~ ) Tm dP k
where a = (AV/V)(l
+ y) + 2yaT,
(3.23)
(3.24)
with ct being the volume coefficient of expansion and y the thermodynamic Gruneisen parameter. The two terms in a are both small compared to unity. aT, is =0.06 for metals and less for materials such as silicates. AV/V is also only a few per cent for most materials. Stevenson (1980) has used the modern theory of liquids (see e.g. the books by Egelstaff (1967), Croxton (1975)) and derived a formula for the melting point which also is very similar to the Lindemann law. His result is (3.25)
where C , is the atomic contribution to the specific heat in units of Boltzmann’s constant per atom. This reduces to Lindemann’s equation (3.22) when C, is equal to the classical value 3. Stevenson suggests that the difference between the liquid state thermodynamic y and the solid state Griineisen y should be 10% or less. Anderson (1982) has integrated (3.25) for four estimates of Gruneisen’s parameter (see Fig. 3.6). Case (a) is outside the experimental range at 250 GPa reported by Brown and McQueen (1982). Cases (b) and (d) bracket their estimated measurements, while case (c) intercepts their error bars. The extrapolated values of T, at the ICB are 520Ck6600 K, which compares well with the estimate of 5800K by Brown and McQueen. Values of T, at the MCB are 4350 f 250 K. A summary of estimates of the melting point of pure iron at the pressure of the ICB is given in Table 3.3. To estimate temperatures in the OC, an estimate of the depression ATdue to the light alloying material must be made. Anderson (1982) used the suggested value of Stevenson (1981) ~ . gives a value of T, in of ATat the ICB of - 1000 K for Ap of 1.0 g ~ m - This the O C at the ICB of 420G5600 K with the most probable value of 4800 K.
153
The Thermal Regime of the Earth‘s Core
-
-
6000 -
Y
v
L
. /2 0
I
80
I
I
160
I
I
240
I
I
320
Pressure (GPa) Fig. 3.6. The fusion curve of pure iron for several sets of values of the Gruneisen parameter, y. Three models satisfy the shock-wave data of Brown and McQueen (1 980, 1982) shown by the box Case C ( 8 )is used in subsequent calculations. ( a ) y = 1.6-1.4; ( b ) y = 1.3-1 . l ; (c) y = 1.2-1 .O; ( d ) y = 1. l 0.9. (After Anderson, 1982.)
The temperature distribution in the OC is then obtained by calculating the adiabat passing through this point (see (3.32)), where y is modified to include electronic effects. Anderson then finds the temperature on the core side of the MCB to be 3620 K. It follows from (3.23) that the melting point gradient is steeper than the adiabatic gradient (see $3.5) if y > 2a, or y > 2/3 if (3.22) is used. Thus the temperature of the deep mantle should be well below the temperature of the solidus if the currently accepted values of y in the mantle are reasonably correct (see $3.2). Boschi (1 974) estimated the melting curve for iron at high pressures by two methods. In the first he used a melting equation derived from the RossLindemann melting criterion (Ross, 1969). Ross generalized the Lindemann melting law by reformulating it in terms of the statistical-mechanical partition function: for a given substance, at all points along its melting curve, the solid always occupies the same fraction of configurational phase space. Boschi obtained the equation T,,, = Tmo(l- AV/VO)-n’3
(3.26)
He obtained the same equation independently from the ideal “three-phase
154
The Earths Core
TABLE 3.3 Predicted temperatures of the melting point of pure iron at the pressure of the inner-outer core boundary. (After 0. L. Anderson, 1986b.)
Gilvarry (1957) Zharkov (1962) Bundyand Strong (1962)’ Higginsand Kennedy (1971)’ Birch (1972)’ Leppaluoto (1972) Boschi (1975)t Liu (1975)T Stacey (1977) Boschietal. (1979)t Abelson (1981)Z Stevenson (1981 ) Brown and McQueen (1982)t Anderson (1 982)G Brown and McQueen (1 984)g Spiliopoulos and Stacey (1984)s Young and Grover (1984) Anderson (1986b)s
6200 6200 61 00-81 00 4250 51 00 7000-9000 6000 51 25 31 57 4500-7000 7800 6300 6200 i 500 5900 f 700 5800 f 500 6140 f 575 6600 621 0 i 400
’ Based upon an extrapolation from experiments at 6 GPa. t A special case of the Ross (1 969) theory.
t Based upon Monte Carlo theory.
5 Based upon an extrapolation from experiments at 243 GPa.
model” proposed by Hiwatari and Matsuda (1972a,b), using the results of Monte Carlo calculations by Hoover et al. (1970). Expanding (3.26) gives T m = T m o { l+ z3% V o+ n ( 6? +3
I)g)
’t...}
(3.27)
which, if second- and higher-order terms are neglected, reduces to the KrautKennedy relation (3.19). For any reasonable value of n, the quadratic term becomes 10% of the linear term when A V / V , ~ 0 . 0 5and for greater compression values, the higher-order terms become increasingly important. Boschi took n = 8.4, the value obtained by Hiwatari and Matsuda from a study of isothermal compression in the solid phase. He estimated the melting temperature of pure iron to be -4800°C at the MCB and 6600°C at the ICB. In a later paper, Boschi et al. (1979) considered the problem of the dependence of the melting temperatures of iron upon the choice of the interatomic potential. They concluded that the melting temperatures of iron at core pressures are extremely uncertain and estimated the melting temperature at the MCB to be in the range 350&4300 K and at the ICB to be between 4500 and 7000 K.
155
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
The work of Stacey and Irvine (1977) and Stevenson (1980) has given a much sounder and deeper physical significance to the original Lindemann law. Other empirical melting laws that have been used in geophysics, such as those of Simon (1937) and Kraut and Kennedy (1966) have no sound fundamental basis. Wolf and Jeanloz (1984) have used high-pressure experimental data to evaluate the validity of the Lindemann melting criterion for minerals. The parameters required in the Lindemann expression can be determined from an inversion of thermodynamic data so that a direct comparison with experimental melting data can be made without resort to model potentials. In general, they found that although atomic vibrations can be significantly anharmonic near the melting point, the shape of the melting curve predicted from the Lindemann criterion is not much influenced by anharmonicity. The Lindemann expression is inconsistent with experimental melting data for a variety of substances, particularly at low pressures, although in some cases the melting slopes observed at high pressures are consistent with a Lindemann expression. In general, Wolf and Jeanloz found that a Lindemann approach is inadequate in describing the melting behaviour of minerals. Presumably, this failure is a result of the complexity of the interatomic forces characteristic of minerals, the sensitivity of these forces to crystal structures and the inappropriateness of applying a Lindemann criterion to polyatomic systems. They conclude that the application of a Lindemann criterion to extrapolate melting temperatures of minerals to high pressures and to estimate the fusion curve and melting point gradient of the Earth’s interior is, at best, speculative. Poirier (1985) has estimated the melting temperature of iron at the ICB, using a theoretical model of dislocation-mediated melting that gives the temperature at which the free energy of a crystal saturated with dislocations becomes equal to that of the dislocation-free crystal. The theory was developed by Ninomiya (1978) and permits the calculation of the volume and entropy of melting and the slope of the melting curve as functions of the elastic moduli and Gruneisen’s parameter that may be determined from seismological Earth models. Poirier obtained a melting temperature of iron at the ICB of 6000 k 300 K with a preferred value of 6150 k 100 K, in good agreement with estimates based on shock wave experiments and with extrapolations using Lindemann’s law. Allowing for the depression in the melting point due to the addition of lighter elements in solution in the OC, he estimated the temperature at the ICB to be 5000 K. Poirier also found that the melting volume A V , decreases under pressure, its value being rather sensitive to the Griineisen parameter. He estimated 0.04 < A V , <0.06 which is comparable to the value calculated by Leppaluoto (1972) from significant structure theory. Poirier calculated the density change on melting Apm as about 0.12 g cm-3, which is about five times smaller than the total jump at the ICB. Masters
-
156
The Earth’s Core
(1979) estimated Apm to be 0.05 g cm-3 and Spiliopoulos and Stacey (1984) estimated it to be 0.17 g ~ m - ~ . Birch (1972) has pointed out that most discussions of the melting of iron neglect the fact that iron exists in several crystalline forms and that the melting curve defines a condition of equilibrium between the liquid phase and one y , 6 and E ) . of the solid phases. Four crystalline phases of iron are known (CI, Only at low pressures is the c( phase in equilibrium with the melt. Our knowledge of the thermodynamic properties of the y and &-phases(of most geophysical interest) is very rudimentary. Birch estimated that the y melting temperatures are about 700 degrees higher than those of Higgins and Kennedy, with E melting temperatures still higher. He does not believe that present evidence is sufficient to predict melting temperatures of iron at core pressures to within 500 degrees Verhoogen (1973) has also discussed the melting of iron pointing out that it must also not be forgotten that the core is not pure iron, but contains about 15% of some light alloying element (see 45.7). This would modify any phase relationships, and also considerably lower melting temperatures in the OCHall and Murthy (1972) suggest that the eutectic temperature may be some 1600°C lower than that for pure iron. There is also evidence that the depth of the eutectic trough deepens with increasing pressure (Kim et al., 1972). The phase diagram of iron is of vital importance to our understanding of the constitution of the core. Iron has two known triple-points (a, y, E ) and (6, y, 1) but these have no direct relevance to the core. Liu (1975) has considered the (y, &, 1) triple point and the fusion curve of E iron under core conditions. Liu and Bassett (1975) had found that the y - ~ phase boundary was linear up to 200 kbar and that extrapolation up to 1000 kbar is justified. Liu (1975) also extrapolated the y-l boundary determined by himself and Bassett (1975) up to 200 kbar using the Kraut-Kennedy law. He thus estimated the triple point (7, E, 1) of iron to be at 0.94 f 0.20 Mbar and 2970 & 200°C. He concluded that the E phase is the appropriate phase of iron for the IC, and that the melting temperature of E iron at the MCB is 3500 f 200°C and at the ICB 4650 f 500°C. Although Liu used the Kraut-Kennedy law to obtain these estimates of melting temperatures, the difference across the OC is more than twice as great as that estimated by Higgins and Kennedy (1971), who did not consider the effect of the y-E transformation on the melting curve. Brown and McQueen (1980) developed a new high-pressure shock wave technique that makes it possible to determine the sound velocity in shocked material. They used this technique (Brown and McQueen 1985) to determine where melting and phase transitions occur in iron at high pressures. This is almost impossible to achieve using conventional shock wave techniques. They were also able to obtain a direct measure of the Gruneisen parameter.
-
157
The Thermal Regime of the Earths Core
-
-’a
h
E
Y
10-
x
I 0
-al >
U
c
J 0
-
v)
8400
200 Pressure ( GPa)
Fig. 3.7. Rarefaction velocities for iron as a function of pressure. (After Brown and McQueen. 1986.)
They had previously (1982) shown the existence of two phase transitions above 100 GPa. The first transition at 200 G P a represents a transition from E to y iron, while the higher discontinuity at 243 G P a is caused by the melting of y iron (see Fig 3.7). The y phase is in equilibrium with the liquid at OC pressures. The Hugoniot temperatures are less certain-at melting there is an uncertainty of 800 K, the temperature bounds being 5000 K and 5800 K. Extrapolating from this temperature, the Lindemann equation (3.22) gives an estimate of 5800 f 500 K for the melting of pure iron at the pressure at the ICB (330 GPa). This is much higher than most reported values. The shock wave experiments also clearly show that the melting temperature for iron plotted against AV/V,, is not a straight line (as proposed by Kraut and Kennedy, 1966) but is concave upwards. Simon’s (1953) theory of melting also gives values that are too low. Brown and McQueen’s results (1982, 1986) are, however, in agreement with the work of Anderson (1982), who used Stevenson’s (1981) generalized form of Lindemann’s law to combine lowpressure measurements with shock wave measurements up to 250 GPa. Comparison of bulk sound velocities of iron with those observed in the OC support the generally accepted view that the O C consists predominantly of iron mixed with elements of lower atomic weight (see 55.7). By about 1982 it was generally accepted that the IC has the same physical
-
-
The Earth's Core 1
10
12
Density (lo6 g rn-3) Fig. 3.8. Elastic wave velocities as a function of density. Earth model velocities from 1066A. 10666 (Gilbert and Dziewonski, 1975) and PREM (Dziewonski and Anderson, 1981 ) are also shown for the OC and IC. (After Brown and McQueen, 1986.)
properties as pure iron. The remaining issue is whether it is E Fe or y Fe. Bukowinski (1977), Stacey (1977) and Spiliopoulos & Stacey (1984), amongst others, computed physical models of the IC and favoured y Fe. Shock wave experiments by Brown and McQueen (1980, 1986) enabled them to measure the velocity of iron at core pressures. When a shock wave encounters the liquid state, V p abruptly decreases to @* since the shear velocity Vs vanishes. Hence the pressure and temperature of a point on the fusion curve of iron can be determined. Figure 3.8 shows that V pfor E Fe extrapolates into the PREM seismic values of V , for the IC (Dziewonski and Anderson, 1981), whereas V , for y Fe does not. Additional analysis of Fig. 3.8 provides further evidence that the IC has the properties of E Fe. Brown and McQueen (1986) estimated Poisson's ratio CJ for iron at high pressure (Fig. 3.9). This figure shows that r~ for E Fe extrapolates into the seismically determined values of CJ for the IC whereas CJ for y Fe is too high for the IC. Anderson (1985, 1986b) used the
159
The Thermal Regime of the Earths Core
Liquid
-t-t-+-
11
12
13
D e n s t y (lo6 g Fig. 3.9. Poisson's ratio as a function of density for iron and the IC. (After Brown and McQueen. 1986.)
shock wave data of Brown and McQueen to construct the phase diagram of iron up to 330GPa (see Fig. 3.10) and found that the (7, E, I ) triple-point occurs at a pressure less than that at the TCB, adding further evidence that the IC is composed of E Fe.*
3.5 Adiabatic Temperatures
The increase in temperature dT for a reversible adiabatic increase of pressure d p is given by Tu dT=-dp
(3.28)
PC,
where a is the volume coefficient of thermal expansion, p the density and c,
* Boehler (Geophys. Res. Lett. 13,1153,1986) has investigated the phase diagram of iron up to 430 kbar using an internally heated diamond cell. He estimated the (c, y, I) triple point to be at 750 kbar and 2500 K, considerably below that found by Anderson (1986bt2.8 Mbar and 5760 K.
Slope
5.2 GPa
7
liauid
7000
6000
5000
\
11 GPa
4000
1
3000
0
10 Pressure (GPa 1
(a)
200
300 Pressure ( GPa 1 rbl
Fig. 3.10. The pressure-temperature phase diagram of iron ( a ) modified from Liu (1975) indicates the triple points a t 5 2 GPa as determined by Mao e t a / (1967) a n d at 1 1 G Pa as determined by Strong el a/ ( 1 973) (bJshows the trlple point at 280 G Pa determined by Anderson ( 1 986a) (After Anderson, 1986b)
161
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
the specific heat at constant pressure. Assuming hydrostatic equilibrium, the variation of pressure with depth z is dpldz = 9P
(3.29)
Hence the adiabatic temperature gradient is given by dT dz
-
gctT cp
(3.30)
Values of a and c p are not well known in the core-the range of values (in kg J-’) as quoted by various authors (see Frazer, 1973) is (3.31)
Since values of y = g(z) are sufficiently well known, it is possible to integrate (3.30) for different values of a/c,, assuming that the adiabatic and melting temperatures are the same at the ICB. Adiabatic and melting temperatures can thus be compared throughout the OC. Assuming Boschi’s (1974) estimates of the melting point of iron at the ICB (6600°C) and at the MCB (4800°C), a/cp must be less than 1.8 x for the adiabatic temperature to exceed the melting temperature at the MCB. If the melting point of iron is lowered because of the addition of lighter alloying elements in the core, the upper bound for a/cp is increased. It is obvious, however, from (3.30) that the adiabatic temperature gradient is critically dependent on the value of a/cp and its possible radial dependence. The adiabatic gradient may also be written in terms of Gruneisen’s parameter y = aks/pcp (3.1): (3.32)
where q5 = k s / p = V; - $Vi (see (1.3)) and is known from seismic data. The adiabatic temperature gradient is quite sensitive to the assumed value of y for iron at high pressures-in fact for a liquid, y may be no more than a dimensionless combination of thermodynamic parameters and have no real connection with Griineisen’s parameter for a solid (Knopoff and Shapiro, 1969). Birch (1972) has pointed out some of the problems involved in calculating adiabats, e.g. the deflection of an adiabat on passing through a phase boundary and the usual (unverified) assumption that the Gruneisen parameter is independent of temperature. Birch conjectured that the y phase of iron is suppressed or confined to low pressures and that the E phase will be the stable solid phase at core pressures-in this case he estimated that the adiabat originating at the melting temperature of the ICB lies entirely in the liquid
162
The Earth's Core
phase, though never very far from the freezing curve-supporting the earlier conclusions of Jacobs (197 1b). Verhoogen (1973) has also estimated the adiabatic temperature gradient from (3.32) using a method due to Stewart (1970). Stewart showed that our present knowledge of the density and distribution of # in the OC is not sufficiently accurate to allow a unique determination of the parameters that characterize core material. He was able to construct a number of graphs showing what combinations of values of the parameters fit the seismic data with a given accuracy. He found that a very wide range of values of Gruneisen's ratio y are consistent with the seismic data and the assumed density-pressure distribution in the core, and concluded that y in the core cannot be estimated from seismic data alone or from its value for solid iron at low pressures. Of the acceptable sets of parameters, many yield temperatures at the MCB in the range 3500-5000 K. Some give an adiabatic gradient steeper than the conductive gradient and are thus compatible with convection, others do not. Since the properties of Fe-S melts are unknown it is not possible to select any one set of parameters in preference to another or even to assert that the OC is a Fe-S melt (see 95.7.2). The important point is, however, as Verhoogen pointed out, that solutions can be found that correspond to near-adiabatic or super-adiabatic conditions in the OC which are therefore compatible with convection. In estimating the (adiabatic) temperature in the convective parts of the Earth from (3.32), a constant of integration is needed-the value of T a t some depth. To obtain this, appeal must be made to experimental results on a solid-state transition that can be identified as corresponding to a seismically determined transition. Stacey (1977), using experimental results on the compression of iron-sulphide systems to extrapolate to the pressure corresponding to the IC-OC transition, fixed T there at 3900°C. Jeanloz and Richter (1979), Brown and Shankland (1 98 1) and Anderson (1 98 1b), amongst others, have used the experimental results of the phase transition of peridotite at pressures corresponding to the seismic transition zone (38c-670 km) to fix T at 670 km. It must be stressed that both these attempts to obtain an integrating constant are based on assumptions about the chemical composition of the mantle and core. Both methods lead to a fairly low value of T o n the mantle side of the MCB, necessitating a large jump in Tacross the thermal boundary layer if the T profile in the core is to resemble that of iron (or iron alloyed with some lighter element). A number of more recent estimates of temperatures in the lower mantle are shown in Fig. 3.1 1. Stacey (1972) suggested that if the temperature gradient of the liquid in the OC of the Earth is adiabatic, heat flowing down the adiabat would have to escape into the mantle and that, unless there are special heat sources in the core and special heat sinks in the mantle, the core of the Earth would soon
163
The Thermal Regime of the Earth‘s Core
/T
Centre T = 4800 K Inner core -outer core boundarv T 4635 K
.......
A
Anderson (1981 Stacey (1977) Baurngardner and Anderson (1981) Jeanloz and Richter (19791 B r o w n and Shankland (1981)
1000 0
1000
2000 Depth ( k m )
3000
3800
Fig. 3.1 1. Recently computed geotherms of the lower mantle (After Anderson, 1981 b.)
become isothermal. Kennedy and Higgins (1973b) came essentially to the same conclusion, estimating a temperature difference of only 25-35°C across the OC. This would completely inhibit any kind of adiabatic radial mixing of the core. A way out of this conclusion would be if there were a heat source in the Earth’s core and a heat sink at the MCB. Freezing of iron at the ICB (Verhoogen, 1961) and/or potassium in the fluid OC (Murthy and Hall, 1972) might possibly provide sufficient heat sources. Convective circulation of deep mantle rocks might carry away sufficient heat to enable a high temperature gradient to be maintained in the core. An alternative heat sink in the deep mantle was proposed by Kennedy and Higgins (1973b) who re-estimated the liquidus, solidus and adiabatic gradient in the Earth’s mantle (see Fig. 3.12). They found that the adiabatic and solidus curves are essentially the same over the lower one-third of the mantle, suggesting that convection is restricted to the upper two-thirds. Also the temperature of their solidus curve is not too different at the MCB from the estimated temperature of the melting of iron. They thus suggested that the requisite heat sink could be formed by the melting of silicate or oxide materials near the MCB with upward migration of liquid along the melting curve. This would imply that the temperature gradient throughout the mantle is that of the solidus curve. Seismological evidence
The Earth's Core
164
Pressure (Mbar) Fig.3.12. Estimated solidus, liquidus and adiabat for t h e Earth's mantle (After Kennedy and Higgins. 1973b )
gives some support to the possibility of melting at the MCB-a number of authors have reported a substantial decrease in shear velocity immediately above the MCB (see $1.3).
3.6 The Earth's Inner Core Reconsidered
Higgins and Kennedy (1971) found that both the melting-point and adiabatic gradients were extremely flat in the IC (see Fig. 3.13). Assuming that the IC is solid and the OC fluid, so that the adiabatic and melting temperatures are the same at the ICB, Higgins and Kennedy found that these temperatures differ by only 15°C at the centre of the Earth. O n the other hand, they found a very sharp curvature in the adiabatic gradient in the OC-much steeper than the melting-point gradient-the adiabatic gradient being about 1250°C across the OC compared with 500°C for the melting-point gradient. This is just the opposite to what has usually been supposed, and the mechanism Jacobs (1953) put forward for the formation of a solid IC and liquid O C would no
165
The Thermal Regime ofthe Earth’s Core
ADIABATIC TEMPERATURE CURVE (AFTER JACOBS)
CJ
7
COSROElj{:t&LE
CENTRE OF EARTH
1 2
4000 BOUNDARY
ADIABATIC TEMPERATURE2 CURVE (AFTER HlGGlNS AND KENNEDY)
Lu
lS0OV
I
I
1000
2000
I
3000 DEPTH ( km 1
i
I
I
4000
5000
6000
Fig. 3.13. Melting-point curve of iron and adiabatic temperature curves of Jacobs (1971b) and Higgins and Kennedy (1 971 ) versus depth in the Earth’s interior
longer be valid. If actual temperatures were distributed along the adiabat of Higgins and Kennedy throughout the OC, it too would be solid-there would be no liquid OC. Higgins and Kennedy thus concluded that the actual temperature gradient in the OC is much less than the adiabatic gradient. If this is the case the OC would be thermally stably stratified, thereby inhibiting radial convection and the question of the generation of the motions which drive the geomagnetic dynamo would have to be reconsidered (see 94.7). Immediate reaction to Kennedy and Higgins’ paper was to accept their results at face value and try to invent ways and means to get around what they have since called the core paradox (Kennedy and Higgins, 1973a). Thus Bullard and Gubbins (1971) pointed out that a stable fluid can have internal wave motions, and they carried out preliminary calculations that indicated that a body of fluid could possibly act as a dynamo, even when its motion is purely oscillatory. Busse (1972), Malkus (1973) and Elsasser (1972) independently suggested that the OC might consist of a slurry of fine iron particles suspended in an iron-rich liquid. There is, however, a critical limit to the solid grain size in order that they do not precipitate out faster than the core can stir them up. Malkus (1973) estimated that the critical size is 1 pm for a convection-driven dynamo and 10 pm for a precession-driven dynamo. Such small grain sizes d o not seem to be in accord with metallurgical experience. Reports of extremely low attenuation of seismic waves in the OC also seem hard to reconcile with such a constitution. Stacey (1972) has suggested yet another solution. If the light alloying element in the core is sulphur (see $5.7.2)and if this is confined to the OC, the IC
166
1 The Earth’s Core
ADIABAT
TEMPERATURE
I
MANTLE Si
I
I I lOUTER CORE I INNER CORE I Fe-S I Fe-Ni I I
Fig. 3.14. Possible melting-point curve in the Earth and adlabat through the ICE (After Stacey, 1972 )
consisting mainly of nickel-iron with very few lighter components, the presence of sulphur in the OC may so reduce its liquidus below that of iron that the adiabat of Higgins and Kennedy through the ICB does not intersect it (see Fig. 3.14). Ullmann & Walzer (1980) have also considered the problem. They used the theory of Ullmann & Pan’kov (1976) on the volume dependence of Griineisen’s parameter y to estimate the adiabatic gradient. They found that the core would be thermally stably stratified if the melting point curve of Higgins and Kennedy (1971) were true, although thermal convection would be possible if Leppaluoto’s (1972) or Boschi’s (1974) melting point curve is used. Their adiabatic gradient is slightly shallower than Liu’s (1975) melting point curve but slightly steeper if allowance is made for the electronic contribution to y. This reinforces the conclusion of Jacobs (1971a) and Birch (1972) that actual temperatures in the core are probably very close to those of the melting temperature. If the melting-point and the adiabatic gradients are virtually the same throughout the entire core, then perhaps parts of the mantle may from time to time become soluble in the OC or material from the OC diffuse into the lower mantle-thereby giving rise to “bumps” on the MCB as has been suggested by Hide (1969) in a different connection (44.7).The position and shape of the boundary may thus change over the course of time and be instrumental in initiating and dictating motions in the OC. If the topography of either boundary of the OC has a direct influence on core motions, then changes in the frequency of reversals of the Earth’s magnetic field may well be random as the shape of these boundaries (randomly) changes. It is not easy to estimate the time-scale for producing such bumps on the core boundary, but it seems likely that it is greater than the (geologically) short time-scale of reversals found for the last 20 Ma (54.5). If this is the case, then there could not be a one-to-one correspondence between the production of bumps and
The Thermal Regime of the Earths Core
167
individual reversals. However, changes in the topography of the core boundary could indirectly affect the frequency of reversals of the Earth’s magnetic field-perhaps accounting for such intervals in the Earth’s history as the Kiaman (a span of some 50-60 Ma, some 300 Ma ago) when reversals have only very rarely been observed. Schloessin (1974) has put forward the interesting suggestion that bumps on the MCB may arise from constitutional supercooling. Constitutional supercooling is generally found in crystallization from impure solutions or melts. It is favoured by constraint growth conditions, low temperature gradients across the solid-liquid interface and high viscosity of the liquid phase. Rejection of an impurity component from the solid interface raises the impurity content in the liquid near the interface. If, owing to the phase relationship of the components involved, the impurity causes an increased liquidus temperature, the actual temperature in the liquid, ahead of the interface, will be below the liquidus temperature and the liquid becomes “constitutionally supercooled”. As a result the solid-liquid interface becomes unstable and advances. Schloessin suggested that there may be a slow growth of the mantle and IC at the expense of the liquid OC by such a process. Although formation of a solid IC and liquid OC most probably occurred early in the Earth’s history (see $2.4). the liquid phase may have remained sufficiently impure for a slow “overgrowth” of both mantle and IC to be still continuing. The abnormal P velocities in both the D” and F layers (see 51.3) may be evidence for a slow growth rate of both boundaries of the OC. The advance of the solid-liquid interface will be controlled by T-TL where T is the actual temperature and TL the liquidus temperature. If TL is sensitive to the concentration CLiof an impurity component i in the liquid and dTL/ dCLi>O,then regions rich in component i will solidify at a lower temperature and regions depleted in i, at a higher temperature. For a given radial variation of CLi the position of the liquidus will follow roughly the inverse of the curve for the impurity distribution (see Fig. 3.15). Over a distance AH to the right of the interface, TL > T, thus defining the region which is constitutionally supercooled. Schloessin also suggested that constitutional supercooling may provide the motive force for driving the geodynamo ($4.6) through the free energy change associated with the overgrowth of both the mantle and the IC. Density inhomogeneities could be generated by this mechanism independent of thermal inhomogeneities-even in a predominantly stratified core. Self-sustained and regenerative concentration gradients of segregated components confined either to layers adjacent to the boundaries or extending through the entire liquid core could thus be the answer to the core paradox of Kennedy and Higgins (1973a). The difficulties in estimating the melting-point and adiabatic temperatures
The Earth's Core
168
I
(0
1
Solid-liquid interface
t
Fig. 3.15. Variation of the concentration of a rejected component i a n d of the corresponding liquidus temperature ( T L )as a function of distance ( f ) from the solid-liquid interface. The shaded region, extending to a distance AH, determines the width of the constitutionally supercooled region. (After Schloessin, 1974.)
in the core have been discussed in 993.4 and 3.5 and it is impossible to say definitely which gradient is the steepest in the core (Jacobs, 1973). However, most recent estimates indicate that the adiabat originating at the melting temperature at the ICB lies entirely in the liquid phase. It thus seems unnecessary at the moment to try to circumvent the consequences of accepting Higgins and Kennedy's results. In any case, thermal convection is not considered now to be mandatory as a driving force for the geodynamo (see $4.6). Liu (1982a) has given an alternative explanation for the velocity distribution in the F zone (see 91.2). The simplest explanation of a negative velocity gradient (or a constant velocity) is the existence of an abnormally high temperature in the F zone, which would entail heat sources in the core. Substantial amounts of radioactivity below the upper mantle also appear to be necessary to account for the surface heat flux (see e.g. ONions et al., 1978;
The Thermal Regime of the Earth's Core
169
Clark and Turekian, 1979). High-pressure experiments by Liu (1982b) have shown that the heat-producing elements uranium and thorium would exist in dioxide solid solutions rather than silicates at the temperature and pressure conditions in the lower mantle. The densities of these dioxides are more than twice as great as mantle silicates and even slightly greater than pure iron under similar temperature and pressure conditions. Liu (1982a) suggested that gravitational separation due to slow mantle convection may transport these dioxides to the deep interior of the Earth. Since these dense heatproducing dioxides are likely to remain as solids, and their densities are likely to be greater than the liquid OC, Liu further suggested that they might be located at the ICB (the F zone). The existence of heat-producing elements in the F zone would also provide an additional energy source to drive convection in the O C needed to power the geodynamo (see $4.6).
3.7 Thermal Consequences of an Iron-alloy Core
Although the OC is generally presumed to be completely molten, it could contain up to about 30% solids in suspension and still exhibit the liquid-like behaviour indicated by seismic data. Since a light alloying element is required to explain the density of the core, it is likely that the core has a melting interval rather than a well-defined melting temperature. The solidus, or eutectic temperature, of the core could be quite a bit lower than the melting point of pure iron or the liquidus temperature of the alloy. If core temperatures are below the liquidus then solid iron would coexist with an iron-rich melt solution. The solid iron could either be held in suspension by turbulent convection or settle to the centre of the core to form the solid IC. In the latter case the IC would grow with time and the temperatures in the OC would lie on the liquidus. Since the liquidus is pressure-dependent, the composition of the core would vary with depth. Loper and Roberts (1978) have developed a general theory for the motion of an iron-alloy core containing a slurry. In their treatment, as in most studies of the evolution of the core, it is assumed that it is iron-rich, i.e. that it contains a larger mass fraction of Fe than is present in a eutectic mixture. The possible states of the core depend on three gradients of temperature with pressure-the gradients of the liquidus temperature TL,the adiabatic temperature TA,and the conduction temperature T,. In what follows, a prime will denote differentiation with respect to pressure. (Since the core is essentially in hydrostatic equilibrium, these temperature gradients with pressure may be interpreted as gradients with depth.) It is assumed that the liquid O C and the solid IC are in thermal equilibrium at their common boundary. This implies that the actual temperature T
170
The Earth’s Core
I I
I
I I
5 (PI) -
T = TA /
/
I I I
I
T
I
I
Tc
I I
/’
I
I
/’
I I
/’
’
I I
TL I
Convection
I
1
I
I Conduction I Solid
i I
1 P
I
I
I I 1
-
PI
Fig. 3.16. A schematic representation of thermal regime A 7,< T ; iT ; The fluid is both compositionally and thermally buoyant The IC grows by direct freezing on its surface (After Loper, 1978 )
of the O C is on its liquidus at the ICB and that TL > TL or TL, or both, since otherwise the O C would be solid. If TL > Tj4 heat is removed from the core by thermal conduction and the core is stably stratified thermally with Tc = TLat the ICB. There are six possible variations of the relative magnitudes of Tj4, TL and T;7.It is easy to see that the cases Tk < T i < Th and T i < TL < T‘’ are not possible, since they would both result in a solid OC. This leaves four possible thermal regimes, which have been discussed in detail by Loper (1978) and summarized below.
Regime A: Tj4 < TL < T i The solid freezes directly onto the IC, and the latent heat released there is removed by a thin conductive layer in which the temperature remains above the liquidus; see Fig. 3.16. The fluid is buoyant both compositionally and thermally. This regime represents the conventional picture of a thermally driven dynamo.
171
The Thermal Regime of the Earth's Core
I
TL ( P , )
T = la
/ ' /
I /-
T
/ I *
TL
#
/
/
I
I I I
I I
Tc
I
I
I
I
Convection
I
I
I I I
I
7
Slurry
I I
I
Solid
1
Fig. 3.17. A schematic representation of thermal regime B: 16 < 1; < 1:. A slurry layer must form at the bottom of the OC. The IC grows by sedimentation of solid particles. (After Loper, 1978.)
Regime B: T i < TL < TL In this regime the solid cannot freeze directly onto the IC because a conductive layer to remove the latent heat cannot be constructed. Since TL < TL in such a layer, it would be frozen solid. This is prevented by the formation of a slurry of solid particles suspended in the liquid phase directly above the ICB. The latent heat released by the freezing of particles raises the temperature from the adiabat to the liquidus as shown in Fig. 3.17. Since the particles are heavier than the fluid because of their compositional difference, they tend to fall radially inward onto the surface of the solid IC. The deficit of particles in the slurry layer, together with the excess of light material released at the boundary makes the fluid compositionally buoyant, setting up convection. With some of the latent heat released throughout the layer, rather than directly at the ICB as in regime A, the conductive gradient at the boundary is the same as the liquidus gradient. Regime C: TL < T i < Ti In this case the thermal conductivity of the fluid is sufficiently large that the thermal component of the density gradient tends to stabilize the fluid. If the compositional component of the density gradient is destabilizing and sufficiently strong to overcome the stabilizing effect of the thermal component, the core fluid will overturn. Again a thin conductive layer exists close to the ICB as shown in Fig. 3.18 The opposing effects of conduction and mixing keep T between TL and TL. The temperature is everywhere above the liquidus, so that no slurry forms. Since T i < T , more heat is conducted down the temperature gradient with motion than in the static case. The excess of heat
172
The Earth's Core
I
$9'-
_-----
/* . ; c
0 -
0
T
0 -
M 0
c
T,
/
/'
/ '/TL'
I I
I I
I I I I
I
I I I
I
C o n v e c t i o n ;Conduction I Solid I
I I
I I
P Pl Fig.3.18. A schematic representation of thermal regime C : TL < T i < T ; . The fluid ISthermally stable but overturning is driven by compositional buoyancy. The convective motions carry heat radially inward. (After Loper, 1978.)
conducted radially outward cannot be transferred to the mantle, and must be carried radially inward by the convective motions. This is in contrast to motions driven by thermal buoyancy in which the convective heat transfer is invariably radially outward.
RegimeD: TL < TL < TL There are two possibilities depending upon the relative magnitude of the effects of conduction and convection. Regime Df:High thermal conductivity If the thermal conductivity is sufficiently high that
the situation is essentially the same as regime C (see Fig. 3.19). Convection is driven by compositional buoyancy despite the stabilizing effect of the thermal gradients.
Regime 02: Low thermal conductivity If the thermal conductivity is too small to maintain T < TL, then the regime
173
The ThermalRegime of the Earth’s Core
7; (P,
T=Tc
-
+‘0
I I
1
I I
7
I I
’TL
0
,/
,I
T,
I
Convection
I
I
I
I
I
1 I 1 Conduci-ion] Solid
I
I
I
I 1
I
I
Fig. 3.19. A schematic representation of thermal regime D1: T ; < T’ < T ; < T i . This regime is very similar to C. (After Loper, 1978.)
holds for the bulk of the O C as shown in Fig. 3.20. A thin conductive layer occurs near the ICB, and a similarly thin convective layer occurs immediately above it, with the bulk of the core being filled with a slurry as envisaged by Busse (1972) and Malkus (1973). Thermal conduction leads to a stable thermal gradient, and gravitational settling of the dense, metal-rich particles also creates a stable compositional gradient. Thus the slurry would be very stable and any convective motions restricted to a very thin layer near the ICB, making any dynamo action very improbable. Fearn and Loper (198 1) have estimated the relative importance of thermal and compositional buoyancy in the core. They calculated the density profile in the core on the assumption that, as the IC grows, the lighter material and the latent heat released are redistributed by diffusion. They concluded that compositional effects dominate thermal effects in determining the stratification of the core. The diffusive flux of light material has two components-the flux down the compositional gradient acting to make the composition homogeneous (minimizing the chemical potential energy) and the baro-diffusive flux acting to separate out the light component from the heavy component (minimizing the gravitational potential energy). Using estimates of parameters relevant to the core, Fearn and Loper found that the diffusive density profile is unstable throughout the O C except for a layer some 70 km thick adjacent to the MCB. This would imply that, except for this thin layer just below the MCB, compositional convection acts throughout the OC. Loper and Roberts (1981, 1983) have examined in more detail conditions in the core if it is in regime B of Loper (1978). i.e. if T i < Ti, < TL, which implies that the liquid above the IC is frozen (constitutionally supercooled).
174
The Earth’s Core
P
PI
Fig.3.20. A schematic representation of thermal regime D2: T: < T’ = T; < T i . A slurry occurs in the OC. Irreversible processes generate stable gradients that inhibit radial motion. (After Loper, 1978.)
The resolution of this apparent paradox lies in reducing the amount of freezing directly on the growing IC and instituting freezing above it in a slurry. Copley et ul. (1970) studied the freezing of a 30 wt% solution of ammonium chloride in water as it is cooled from below by liquid nitrogen. The cooling causes crystals of ammonium chloride to freeze into a dendritic interface at the bottom of the sdution. The experiments of Copley et ul. have convinced Loper and Roberts that the slurry is more likely to be a mushy zone of dendrites between the liquid O C and the solid IC. Such dendrites are tree-like structures and are likely to be easily broken-in Copley et d ’ s experiments they were broken by natural convection flow creating isolated “chimneys” free of solid. The flow pattern was highly non-linear with all the upward flow occurring within these chimneys. Fearn et at. (1981) showed that the thickness of the mushy zone is strongly dependent on the difference in composition between the O C and the corresponding liquid with the lowest melting point. Unless the two compositions are very nearly equal, the mushy zone will be very thick, possibly extending to the centre of the Earth. Loper and Roberts (1983) thus suggested that the entire IC may be a mixture of liquid and solid. Seismic evidence has given some hints that the IC may be in a partially molten state. Doornbos (1974), Stiller et al. (1980) and Cormier (1981) have suggested that the attenuation of seismic waves in the IC may be due to the presence of fluid inclusions. In a later paper, Loper and Fearn (1983) constructed a model of a partially molten IC. They developed a model for the bulk anelasticity of a solid containing liquid inclusions nearly in melting-freezing equilibrium that is quan-
The Thermal Regime of the Earth's Core
175
titatively capable of explaining the observed anelasticity. However, the mass fraction of liquid must not be too small and there is a restriction on the size distribution of the liquid inclusions. Braginsky (1963) originally suggested that the geodynamo (see also $4.6) is driven through the downward settling of a heavy iron-rich component in the fluid OC to form a growing solid IC. He proposed a silicon-rich core in order to explain the F layer. However, the existence of the F layer is now in some doubt (see 51.2). t o p e r (1978) discussed the thermal regime of a fluid whose composition is less metallic than the eutectic, as proposed by Braginsky (1963). One difficulty with this model is that the solid that forms initially is less metallic and hence less dense than the liquid. This light solid cannot freeze directly onto the IC, since it would result in an IC less dense than the surrounding liquid. The metal-poor particles must float upwards, leaving a thin metal-rich layer at the bottom of the OC. Since the metal is the more dense constituent, this layer is stably stratified, and of variable composition, and thus heat can only be removed by conduction. Because of the difficulties in removing heat from this layer, toper concluded that a metal-poor composition for the core is very unlikely. Fearn and Loper (1983) examined in more detail how an IC of eutectic composition might grow in an iron-poor core. They investigated the evolution of a completely molten core as it cooled and concluded that the IC cannot be explained by the secular cooling of an iron-poor core because of the difficulty of removing the latent heat released. McCammon et al. (1983) presented a model of core formation in which a solid IC grows by pressureinduced freezing as the Earth grows by accretion, i.e. the cause of the freezing of the IC is not a decrease in temperature but an increase in the central pressure as the mass of the Earth grows. Fearn and Loper (1985) later showed that, as in the case of secular cooling, there is no difficulty in pressure-freezing a solid IC from an iron-rich core, but there are serious problems if the core is iron-poor. Their general conclusion is that the core has an iron-rich composition and was essentially entirely molten immediately following its formation. 3.8 The Core and the Thermal History of the Earth
The classical approach to the Earth's thermal history is to formulate it as an initial boundary-value problem with calculations based on the theory of heat conduction in a solid. Although calculations based on the theory of heat conduction are relatively straightforward, the results are not applicable to the real Earth. The data required are poorly known and conduction does not describe all the processes of heat and mass transfer within the Earth. Largescale convection is extremely efficient in transporting heat and such convec-
176
The Earth's Core
tive heat transfer will dominate thermal lattice and radiative heat conduction even for small velocities. Goto et al. (1980) have carried out shock wave measurements of the optical absorption spectrum from 41G580 nm of 0.14 and 0.26 mole% FeZf-bearing MgO (synthetic periclase) to pressures of 42 GPa. They found considerably lower opacities at short wavelengths than those inferred from static highpressure'measurements on more Fe2+-rich samples, implying that significant radiative thermal conductivity of the lower mantle may take place in Fe z + depleted minerals under highly-reducing conditions. However, although the effective conductivity may be enhanced by radiative transfer at high temperatures, it is unlikely to be a major factor in heat transport in the Earth. A difficult feature of any calculation of the thermal regime of the Earth based on conduction theory alone is that the thermal time constant is much greater than the age of the Earth, with the result that temperatures in the deep interior depend on the thermal conditions existing at the time of formation of the Earth. This difficulty is largely overcome by convection theory. A stabilization temperature of less than about 2500 K, and the great increase in heat transport above it, result in the present thermal conditions being virtually independent of initial conditions, and make the temperature distribution far less sensitive to details of the heat source distribution. An investigation of the thermal history of the Earth taking into account convection and fractionation of radioactive elements is extremely difficult. The difficulties are two-fold-mathematical and physical. A mathematical treatment of the problem entails the formulation and solution of the complete field equations of a multicomponent, multiphase and radioactive continuum of varying properties. The physical difficulties arise mainly from our lack of understanding of the Earth's rheological behaviour and fractionation processes. Lee (1967, 1968) developed mathematical techniques to treat the Earth's thermal history beyond simple heat-conduction theory, taking into account latent heat, convection, and fractionation of radioactive elements. He showed that large-scale convection within the Earth is unlikely and that heat transfer by small-scale penetrative convection is also unimportant. Such convection is of great importance, however, as a means of moving the radiogenic heat sources upward. Very little work has been done on convection as a mode of heat transfer in the mantle, although it has been realized that convection may play a dominant role in the thermal regime in the Earth. Tozer (1967, 1970a,b) has made some significant contributions in this regard, although the value of his work has unfortunately not been fully recognized or appreciated. As a result of both experimental work and theoretical considerations, Tozer proposed that convective motions in the Earth are such as to minimize the mean temperature across any spherical shell in which the conduction solution is unstable
177
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
and that it is possible to use data from laboratory model experiments to find that minimum. Tozer also showed that it is possible to estimate mean temperatures on level surfaces without knowing the exact details of the velocity distribution-such temperatures below a depth of about 800 km are controlled by the viscosity dependence on temperature. For all plausible viscositytemperature relationships, the temperature is always that which gives a viscosity N 1020-1021poise. Thus, the prevalent idea that any convection theory for the mantle must be very imprecise because of uncertainty in the viscositytemperature relationship is not true; rather the viscosity itself is constrained to lie within very narrow limits. In a later paper, Tozer (1972) showed that, for a very large range of physically plausible values of the material parameters, the temperature distribution in bodies larger than about 800 km in radius is very different from that predicted by conduction theory. In any body the average temperature rises with depth according to the conduction or state of rest solution until either the centre of the body is reached or the kinematic viscosity has fallen to a value -1020cm2s-’-whichever is reached first. Once a body is large enough for its central viscosity to be incapable of stabilizing a state of rest solution, the steady central temperature becomes comparatively independent of the radius and surprisingly low (see Fig. 3.21). Thus, of all bodies in the solar system, small objects (radius 5 800 km) best preserve conditions existing at their birth. The magnitude of the velocity of internal motions, the nonhydrostatic stresses and the viscosity in the convective zones are all relatively insensitive to the choice of values of the material parameters. Most planetary thermal evolution models now use the “parameterized” convection approach. Instead of solving the complete set of equations which govern convection, parameterized convection uses a relationship between the Nusselt number and the Rayleigh number independent of the actual details of the convective structure. The Nusselt number Nu describes the efficiency of convection in transporting heat: it is the ratio of the convective heat flux to the heat flux that would obtain if heat were conducted across the layer. In the case of constant viscosity and with isothermal boundaries, the Rayleigh number is defined as R
= (xyd3AT)/(Kv)
(3.33)
where a is the coefficient of thermal expansion, g the acceleration due to gravity, d the depth of the fluid layer, AT the temperature drop across it, K the thermal diffusivity and v the kinematic viscosity. The Rayleigh number describes the tendency of a fluid to convect: the larger the number, the more vigorous the convection. The relationship Nu
=
u(R/R,)O
(3.34)
178
The Earths Core
External radius (1000 k r n ) Fig. 3.21. The central temperature T, as a function of the external radius R for two values of the heat source density H. Curve 1 : H = 1.6 x 10-’4calcm-’s ’. Curve 2: H = 5 x 1 0 - ‘ 5 c a l c m - 3 s ‘, On the left, the steeply rising curves are steady state of rest solutions-unstable where dotted. Note the relative independence of T, on R when R > 800 km and the surprisingly low values of T,. (After T o m , 1972.)
+
where , ! is Ibetween and +,and R, is the critical Rayleigh number for the onset of convection, gives good results for a number of conditions (see, e.g. Turcotte and Oxburgh, 1967; Sharpe and Peltier, 1978; Schubert, 1979). Nataf and Richter (1982) point out that the “existence of such a simple relationship is basically due to the way convection ‘works’: convective motions are organized in cells whose typical dimensions are of the same order as the depth of the convective layer; heat is conducted through a boundary layer at the bottom, advected in plumes around an isothermal core to the upper boundary layer which conducts it to the top surface. However, when there is a very large viscosity variation across the layer, one expects a thick rigid lid to develop on top of the convective region where the Nu-R relationship applies. The problem is to determine the thickness of the ‘lid’ or the temperature drop across it. In other words, one has to define where the cut-off between a more or less rigid and conducting lid and the convective regime takes place.” Different authors have used different assumptions to define the cut-off. In his original model, Tozer (1972) took the viscosity at the base of the lid to calculate the Rayleigh number and the parameterized Nusselt number for the convective region beneath the lid, and then assumed that the lid thickness is that which minimizes the bottom temperature (i.e. maximizes the overall
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
179
Nusselt number). Most authors have assumed a constant viscosity-that applicable to the interior of the convective region-although with very different values. Ellsworth et al. (1985) have estimated the variation of viscosity q across the lower mantle based on models of the Gibb’s free energy of activation G* and the adiabatic temperature. The variation of G* with depth is estimated in two ways: using an elastic strain energy model, in which G* is related to the seismic velocities, and a model assuming G* proportional to the melting temperature (obtained from Lindemann’s law-see 93.4). The adiabatic temperature gradient is estimated from (3.2) and (3.9) which assume that the acoustic Griineisen parameter is the same as the thermodynamic Griineisen parameter. Finally estimates of q depend on the rheology of the lower mantle, whether it can be considered as a Newtonian or power law fluid. Ellsworth et al. obtained a wide range of values of q. For G* based on the melting temperature, increases in y~ with depth vary from a factor of about 100 for Newtonian deformation or power-law flow with constant stress to about 5 for non-Newtonian deformation with constant strain rate. (See Fig. 3.22.) For G* based on the elastic strain energy model, increases in q with depth range from a factor of about 1500 for Newtonian deformation or power-law flow with constant stress to about 10 for non-Newtonian deformation with constant strain rate. Only a non-Newtonian lower mantle convecting with constant strain rate or constant strain energy dissipation rate is consistent with recent estimates of mantle viscosity obtained from post-glacial rebound and true polar-wander data (Nakiboglu and Lambeck, 1980; Peltier, 1981; Sabadini and Peltier, 1981; Yuen et al., 1982), which indicate that the viscosity of the mantle is essentially constant with depth. Verhoogen (1973) has shown that it is possible to construct models of a radioactive core (due to the decay of 40K) that agree with seismic data and account for convective instability, the existence of a solid IC and other details of core structure (particularly the F layer) He assumed that the OC consists of Fe, S and a small amount of K (see 55.8) which generates heat by the radioactive decay of 40K. He considered two cases, one corresponding to a high rate of heat production h (8 x 10’’ W) which would require about 0.1% K by weight. This value of h corresponds to a heat flux at the surface of the Earth of about 25% of the average measured value. Verhoogen took as the other case a lower limit for h that was 10 times smaller. The temperature in the lower mantle has been estimated by Wang (1972) to be about 3300 K 800 at a depth of 2800 km. Bolt (1 972) has shown that the decrease with depth of the seismic velocities V pand Vs in the lowermost 100-150 km of the mantle (region D”) may imply a sharp density gradient.*
*
The D” layer is discussed in detail in $1.3.
I
I
I
I
In 4
I
I
I
I
1
h
f a U
1 L
r
-
\
r
\
10'
\ 0..
--
F
-
-
(
D v
-
\
-
0
-
-
......
r
\ t
loo I I 3500 3500 4000 4500 5000 5500 6000 Radius (km)
Radius (km)
Fig 3 22 Variation o f effective viscosity '1 across the lower mantle calculated (a) from the elastic strain energy model for G* { b j from the melting temperdturc model for G' Solid line-constant stress Dashed Ilne--constant strain energy dissipation rate Dotted line-constant strain rate Calculations are based on a power law rheology w i t h n = 3 (After Ellsworth e t a / , 1985 )
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
181
This density gradient, caused perhaps by an admixture of core material may be sufficiently steep to prevent convection and maintain a high (conductive) temperature gradient, which accounts in part for the decrease in the seismic velocities. The layer D” may then be thought of as a non-convecting thermal boundary layer separating the convecting thermal regime of the core from that of the lower mantle above D”. If this interpretation is correct the temperature T, at the MCB may be considerably higher than the temperature at the top of D”. Verhoogen thus took T, to be about 4500-5000K for h = 8 x 10” W and perhaps only 3500 K for the lower limit of h or if the layer D” participates in mantle convection. Instability in the OC probably requires a temperature gradient at least as great as the adiabatic. Verhoogen thus first determined the gradient that would be maintained by the heat sources in the absence of convection. For distributed heat sources (40K) the temperature difference across the OC is approximately 1600 K for high h and only 160 K for low h. With this lower value of h the core is essentially isothermal. The heat drop across the core could be raised to 850 degrees even for this low value of h if it was released by crystallization at the ICB (Verhoogen, 1961), rather than by the radioactive decay of 40K. Verhoogen estimated the adiabatic gradient from (3.30) and showed that the lower rate of heat production from distributed heat sources leads to a conductive gradient that is everywhere less than the adiabatic and is thus incompatible with convection. Stacey and Loper (1984) have discussed the thermal histories of the core and mantle. Essential to their model is the existence of a thermal boundary layer at the base of the mantle (the D” layer). Core cooling is not effective until this layer develops by cooling of the bulk of the mantle. The core cooling rate is strongly influenced by the temperature increment across D that developed within the first few hundred million years and is still increasing (at present it is N 800 K). These results are shown in Figs 3.23 and 3.24. It can be seen that mantle cooling is non-linear with time. On the other hand, the core cooling rate has been essentially steady for more than 3 x lo9 years. The figures also show that the energy available to drive the geodynamo has been sensibly constant for a long period. This is consistent with the long-term average geomagnetic field strength that has been more or less steady for the entire palaeomagnetic record. In Stacey and Loper’s model, the core does not begin to cool apppreciably until a temperature difference has been established across the D” layer by cooling of the mantle. This places a limit on the heat flux from the core and makes it difficult to have a thermally driven dynamo (see $4.6) early in the Earth’s history as proposed by Stevenson (1983). The addition of radioactive 40K in the core would not help-in fact it would create a further difficulty because of its relatively short half-life-as the early core would be heating rather than cooling.
182
The Earths Core A
E
1.3~
(D
0
v
i- 1.0QG
ln-
.-
6 core
U 0
L
2 0.5 -
- 1.0
0 U
QD
ij
-cc
1
1
1
I
1
I
I
0 74000
TM
JUUU L
l
I
4.5 4.0
l
3.0
I
I
2.0
(
i
I
1.0
Time before present (lOgyears) Fig. 3.23.Preferred thermal history for a Newtonian mantle. The lower plot gives the mantle solidus temperature, Tu, core temperature T,. and lower mantle temperature, Ts, as functions of time The upper plot gives IC radius, r,, total core heat, d,,,,. the rate of gravitational energy release by rejection from the IC of the light alloying ingredient of the OC, QG and the net energy for the geomagnetic dynamo, do. The total mantle-derived heat flux is 27.5 x 10l2W and the mantle radiogenic heat is 22.78 x 10l2W at the present time (After Stacey and Loper, 1984.)
There is still much argument as to whether convection in the mantle is single-stage or two-stage: the question will not be reviewed here. It is important, however, for the constitution of the mantle, since whole-mantle convection would be incompatible with a difference in the bulk chemical composition between the upper and lower mantle: the question of whether there is such a compositional difference is controversial. Jeanloz and Richter (1979) constructed a thermal model for the lower mantle based on petrologically-derived estimates of the temperature in the transition zone (see Fig. 1.4) and from an adiabat based on the thermal properties of MgO and S i 0 2 measured at high pressures. They found that a thermal boundary layer ( - 100 km thick) is required at the base of the mantle (the D” region) in order to satisfy their estimate of the lowest possible temperature in the core ( - 2800 K). Their preferred model (with more reasonable core temperatures of about 320C3500 K) requires a second boundary layer in the lower mantle, most likely close to its base or at the transition zone. A thermal structure with only one boundary layer at the base of the mantle is acceptable only if the OC
183
The Thermal Regime of the Earth's Core
2.0
1 .o
74000
TM ,-,
Y
v
2
-3500 2
!i
' E
3000 ,
I
I
4.5 4.0
I
3.0
I
I
2.0
I
I
I
1.0
Time before present (lOgyears) Fig. 3.24. Thermal history for non-Newtonian mantle rheology. In this case, the mantle radiogenic heat is 18.6 x 10" W. (After Stacey and Loper, 1984.)
is at a lower temperature, or if the heat flux from the core is significantly larger than has been considered reasonable ( > 50 m Wm-'). Davies (1980) has constructed thermal histories for a number of Earth models in which heat is transported by convection alone. The only heat source considered is that due to radioactive decay: the calculations thus only apply to the time since core segregation (or accretion) ceased to be a significant heat source. Transient conductive near-surface cooling is also ignored. Davies used an empirical relationship between the rate of convective heat transport and the temperature difference across a convecting fluid, and an approximate proportionality between effective mantle viscosity and T-" ( n N 30 throughout the mantle). He found that assuming the present surface heat flux to be entirely primordial (i.e. non-radiogenic) leads to unrealistically high temperatures about 1700 Ma ago. The inclusion of radiogenic heat sources moves these high temperatures further back in time. Davies concluded that there is a significant imbalance between present heat production and heat loss in the Earth, the present heat production/heat loss ratio being between about 0.45 and 0.65. The internal structure of the Earth consists essentially of a silicate material overlying an iron core. The fluidity of the OC then depends primarily on its
184
The Earth's Core
T
Fig. 3.25. A likely tempetaturexomposition phase diagram for a terrestrial core alloy. X represents the light alloying constituent (e.g sulphur, oxygen). S refers to the solid (almost pure iron), L is the liquid phase, OC refers to the liquid outer core and I C refers to a solid inner core. The full vertical line represents a cooling evolution and the broken line represents the present OC composition after some I C growth. (After Stevenson, 1983.)
composition and thermal evolution. This in turn implies the existence of alloying constituents in the OC capable of substantially reducing the melting point of iron. This follows from the fact that the mantle undergoes solid-state convection and self-regulates at a temperature considerably lower than the melting point of its major mineral phases. Moreover, the melting points of iron and of the major silicate and oxide phases are very similar even at high pressures. The question of the composition of the core and the likely alloying element(s) is discussed in $5.7. Figure 3.25, after Stev-enson (1983), shows a likely temperature-composition phase diagram for the Earth's core, where X represents the light alloying constituent. Consider a thermal evolution in which the core starts out hotter than the melting curve and then gradually cools. The evolution trajectory of the centre would follow the vertical line shown in the figure until it intercepted the phase boundary. At that point, solid iron would form and the coexisting fluid remnant would try to evolve towards being richer in the alloying constituent X. However, this fluid is intrinsically less dense than the overlying fluid (which has not yet undergone any freezing) and must therefore rise. This compositionally driven convection will homogenize the liquid OC to a composition that is in phase equilibrium with the solid IC. Eventually, the eutectic composition is reached and com-
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
185
plete freeze-out of the liquid is possible. The rate at which the core can cool over geological time is determined by the heat-transporting properties of the overlying mantle. However, the core cannot cool faster than the mantle, and the mantle cools rather slowly because its viscosity is very strongly temperature dependent. The existence of the Earth’s magnetic field for at least the last 3500 Ma demands a continued energy source and this provides a constraint on the thermal evolution of the core. The amount of power required depends on the nature of the source. Gubbins et al. (1979) used the equations of global energy and entropy balance and showed that for radioactive heating alone, 1013W are required, which is just within the limits set by the observed surface heat flux ( ~ x 4 l o i 3W). Cooling itself cannot release enough heat to power the dynamo, because the required cooling rate is so high that the IC would be a very recent feature of the Earth. The release of gravitational energy can produce a magnetic field of 1-2 x T with the IC growing slowly to its present size over 4 x lo9 years and a heat release of 2.5 x 1 O I 2 W (a lower heat flux is required because of the greater efficiency of conversion of gravitational energy into magnetic field than heat). For most of their calculations, the heat flowing from the core is less than that conducted down the adiabatic gradient, suggesting that convection is driven gravitationally against thermal stratification. These questions are discussed in more detail in $4.6.
References
Abelson, R. S. (1981). P h D Thesis, University ofCalifornia, Los Angeles. Alder, B. J. (1966). Is the mantle soluble in the core? J . Geophys. Re.?.71,4973. Anderson, 0. L. (1968). Some remarks o n the volume dependence of the Gruneisen parameter. J . Geophys. Rex 73, 5187. Anderson, 0. L. (1979a). The high-temperature acoustic Gruneisen parameter in the Earth’s interior. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 18, 221. Anderson, 0. L. (1979b). Evidence supporting the approximation yp = const. for the Griineisen parameter of the Earths lower mantle. J . Geophys. Res. 84,3537. Anderson, 0. L. (1981a). Temperature profiles in the Earth. In Evolution of the Eurth (R. J. O’Connell and W. S. Fyfe, eds) Geodynamics Series 5, Amer. Geophys. Union. Anderson, 0. L. (1981b). A decade of progress in Earth’s internal properties and processes. Science 213, 76. Anderson, 0. L. (1982). The Earth’s core and the phase diagram of iron. Phil. Trans. Roy, Soc. London A306,21. Anderson, 0.L. (1986a). The phase diagram ofiron to 300 GPa. J . Phys. Chem. Solids. (in press). Anderson, 0. L. (1986b). Properties of iron at the Earths core condition. Geophys. J . 84,561. Baumgardner, J. R. and Anderson, 0. L. (1981). Using the thermal pressure to compute the physical properties of terrestrial planets. Adu. Space Res. 1,159. Birch, F. (1972). The melting relations of iron and temperatures in the Earth’s core. Geophys. J . 29,373.
186
The Earth’s Core
Bolt, B. A. (1972). The density distributions near the base of the mantle and near the Earth’s centre. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 5, 301. Boschi, E., (1974). Melting of iron. Geophys. J . 38,327. Boschi, E. (1975). The melting relation of iron and temperatures in the Earth’s core. Riu. Nuovo. Cim. 5,501. Boschi, E. and Mulargia, F. (1977). Equation of state of liquid iron at the Earth’s core conditions. J . Geophys. 43,467. Boschi, E., Mulargia, F. and Bonafede, M. (1979). The dependence of the melting temperatures of iron upon the choice of the interatomic potential. Geophys. J . 58,201. Braginsky, S. I. (1963). Structure of the F layer and reasons for convection in the Earth’s core. Dokl. Akad., Nauk, SSSR, 149,8. Brown, J. M. and McQueen, R. G. (1980). Melting of iron under core conditions. Geophys. Res. Lett. 7, 533. Brown, J. M. and Shankland, T. J. (1981). Thermodynamic parameters in the Earth as determined from seismic profiles. Geophys. J . 66,579. Brown, J. M. and McQueen, R. G. (1982). The equation of state for iron and the Earth’s core. In High Pressure Research in Geophysics (S. Akimoto and M. H. Manghnani, eds), pp. 61 1623. Center Acad. Publ., Tokyo. Brown, J. M. and McQueen, R. G. (1986). Phase transitions, Griineisen parameter, and elasticity for shocked iron between 77 G P a and 400 GPa. J . Geophys. Res. 91,7485. Bukowinski, M. S. T. (1977). A theoretical equation of state for the inner core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 14,333. Bullard, E. C. and Gubbins, D. (1971). Geomagnetic dynamos in a stable core. Nature 232,548. Bundy, F. P. and Strong, H. M. (1962). In Solid State Physics (F. Seitz and D. Turnbull, eds), Vol. 13, p. 81. Academic Press, London and Orlando. Busse, F. H. (1972). Comment on the paper “The adiabatic gradient and the melting point gradient in the core of the Earth” by G. Higgins and G. C. Kennedy, J . Geophys. Res. 77, 1589. Clark, S. P. Jr. and Turekian, K. K. (1979). Thermal constraints on the distribution of long lived radioactive elements in the Earth. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A291,269. Copley, S. M., Giamei, A. F., Johnson, S. M. and Hornbecker, M. F. (1970). The origin of freckles in unidirectionally solidified castings. Metall. Trans 1,2193. Cormier, V. F. (1981). Short period P K P and the anelastic mechanism of the inner core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 24, 291. Croxton, C. (1975). Introduction to Liquid State Physics. Wiley, New York. Davies, G. F. (1980). Thermal histories of convective Earth models and constraints on radiogenic heat production in the Earth. J . Geophys. Rex 85,2517. Doornbos, D. J. (1974). The anelasticity of the IC. Geophys. J . 38,397. Dugdale, J. S. and MacDonald, D. K. C. (1953). Thermal expansion of solids. Phys. Rev. 89,832. Dziewonski, A. M. and Anderson, D. L. (1981). Preliminary reference Earth model. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 25,297. Egelstaff, P. A. (1967). A n Introduction to the Liquid State. Academic Press, London and Orlando. Ellsworth, K., Schubert, G. and Sammis, C. G. (1985). Viscosity profile of the lower mantle. Geophys. J . 83, 199. Elsasser, W. M. (1972). Thermal stratification and core convection. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 53, 605. Falzone, A. J. and Stacey, F. D. (1980). Second order elasticity theory: explanation for the high Poisson’s ratio of the inner core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 21,371. Falzone, A. J. and Stacey, F. D. (1981). Second-order elasticity theory: an improved formulation of the Griineisen parameter at high pressure. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 24,284.
The Thermal Regime of the Earth’s Core
187
Fazio, D., Mulargia, F. and Boschi, E. (1978). Thermodynamical Griincisen’s function for pure iron at the Earth’s core conditions. Geophys. J . 53,531. Fearn, D. R. and Loper, D. E. (1981). Compositional convection and stratification of Earth’s core. Nature 289,393. Fearn, D. R. and Loper, D. E. (1983). The evolution of an iron-poor core 1. Constraints on the growth of the inner core. In Stellar and Planetary Magnetism (A. M. Soward, ed.). Gordon & Breach, London. Fearn, D. R., Loper, D. E. and Roberts, P. H. (1981). Structure of the Earth’s inner core. Nature 292,232, Fearn, D. R. and Loper, D. E. (1985). Pressure freezing of the Earth’s inner core. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 39, 5. Frazer, M. C. (1973). Temperature gradients and the convective velocity in the Earth’s core. Geophys. J . 34, 193. Gilbert. F. and Dziewonski, A. M. (1975). An application of normal mode theory to the retrieval of structural parameters and source mechanisms from seismic spectra. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A278,187. Gilvarry, J. J. (1956a). The Lindemann and Griinciscn laws. Phys. Rev. 102,308. Gilvarry, J. J. (1956b).Gruneisen’s law and the fusion curve at high pressures. Phys. Rev. 102,317. Gilvarry, J. J. (1956~).Equation of the fusion curve. Phys. Rev. 102,325. Gilvarry, J. J. (1957). Temperatures of the Earth’s interior. J . Atmos. Terr. Phys. 10,84. Goto, T., Ahrens, T. J., Rossman, G. R. and Syono, Y. (1980). Absorption spectra of shockcompressed Fezf-bearing MgO and the radiative conductivity of the lower mantle. Phys. Earth Planet. Int. 22,277. Gruneisen, E. (1912). Theorie des festen zustandes einatomiger elemente. Ann. Phys. 39,257. Griineisen, E. (1926). The state of a solid body. Handhuch Phys. 10, 1. [NASA translation RE218-59W (1959).] Gubbins, D., Masters, T. G., and Jacobs, J. A. (1979). Thermal evolution of the Earth’s core. Geophys. J . 59,57. Hall, H. T. and Murthy, V. R. (1972). Comments on the chemical structure of an Fe-Ni-S core of the Earth. Trans Amer. Geophys. Union 53,602. Hide, R. (1969). Interaction between the Earth’s liquid core and solid mantle. Nature 222, 1055. Higgins, G. H. and Kennedy, G. C. (1971). The adiabatic gradient add the melting point gradient in the core of the Earth. J . Geophys. Re