Springer Handbook of Experimental Solid Mechanics
Springer Handbooks provide a concise compilation of approved key information on methods of research, general principles, and functional relationships in physical sciences and engineering. The world’s leading experts in the fields of physics and engineering will be assigned by one or several renowned editors to write the chapters comprising each volume. The content is selected by these experts from Springer sources (books, journals, online content) and other systematic and approved recent publications of physical and technical information. The volumes are designed to be useful as readable desk reference books to give a fast and comprehensive overview and easy retrieval of essential reliable key information, including tables, graphs, and bibliographies. References to extensive sources are provided.
Springer
Handbook of Experimental Solid Mechanics Sharpe (Ed.) With DVD-ROM, 874 Figures, 58 in four color and 50 Tables
123
Editor: Professor William N. Sharpe, Jr. Department of Mechanical Engineering Room 126, Latrobe Hall The Johns Hopkins University 3400 North Charles Street Baltimore, MD 21218-2681, USA
[email protected]
Library of Congress Control Number:
ISBN: 978-0-387-26883-5
2008920731
e-ISBN: 978-0-387-30877-7
c 2008, Springer Science+Business Media, LLC New York All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC New York, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. The use of designations, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Product liability: The publisher cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information about dosage and application contained in this book. In every individual case the user must check such information by consulting the relevant literature. Production and typesetting: le-tex publishing services oHG, Leipzig Senior Manager Springer Handbook: Dr. W. Skolaut, Heidelberg Typography and layout: schreiberVIS, Seeheim Illustrations: Hippmann GbR, Schwarzenbruck Cover design: eStudio Calamar Steinen, Barcelona Cover production: WMXDesign GmbH, Heidelberg Printing and binding: Stürtz GmbH, Würzburg Printed on acid free paper SPIN 11510079
9085/3820/YL
543210
V
Preface to Handbook on Experimental Stress Analysis
Experimental science does not receive Truth from superior Sciences: she is the Mistress and the other sciences are her servants ROGER BACON: Opus Tertium. Stress analysis has been regarded for some time as a distinct professional branch of engineering, the object of which is the determination and improvement of the mechanical strength of structures and machines. Experimental stress analysis strives to achieve these aims by experimental means. In doing so it does not remain, however, a mere counterpart of theoretical methods of stress analysis but encompasses those, utilizing all the conclusions reached by theoretical considerations, and goes far beyond them in maintaining direct contact with the true physical characteristics of the problems under considerations. Many factors make the experimental approach indispensable, and often the only means of access, in the investigation of problems of mechanical strength. At our present state of knowledge it is remarkable how quickly we can reach the limit of applicability of mathematical methods of stress analysis, and there is a multitude of comparatively simple, and in practice frequently occurring, stress problems for which no theoretical solutions have yet been obtained. In addition to this, theoretical considerations are usually based on simplifying assumptions which imply certain detachment from reality, and it can be decided only by experimentation whether such idealization has not resulted in an undue distortion of the essential features of the problem. No such doubt needs to enter experimental stress analysis, especially if it is done under actual service conditions, where all the factors due to the properties of the employed materials, the methods of manufacture, and the conditions of operation are fully represented. The advantage of the experimental approach becomes especially obvious if we consider that it is possible to determine experimentally the stress distribution in a machine part in actual operation without knowing the nature of the forces acting on the part under these circumstances, which proposition is clearly inaccessible to any theoretical method of analysis. To these major advantages we may add one more, from the point of view of the average practicing engineer, whose mathematical preparation is not likely to enable him to
deal theoretically with some of the complex strength problems which he, nevertheless, is expected to settle satisfactorily. To these men experimental methods constitute a recourse that is more readily accessible and that, with proper care and perseverance, is most likely to furnish the needed information. Several principal methods and literally hundreds of individual tools and artifices constitute the “arsenal” of the experimental stress analyst. It is interesting to observe, however, that each of these devices, no matter how peculiar it sometimes appears to be, has its characteristic feature and, with it, some unique advantage that may render this tool most suitable for the investigation of a particular problem. The stress analyst cannot afford, therefore, to ignore any of these possibilities. This circumstance, together with the ever-increasing demand on mechanical strength, will always tend to keep experimental stress analysis a distinct entity in the field of technical sciences. There has been a long-felt need of a comprehensive reference book of this nature, but, at the same time, it was recognized that no one person could possibly write with authority on all the major experimental procedures that are being used at present in the investigation of mechanical strength. It was proposed therefore that the problem could be solved only by a concerted effort which might be initiated most suitably under the aegis of the Society for Experimental Stress Analysis, and the writer was appointed as editor with complete freedom to proceed with the organization of this undertaking. Invitations were sent to thirty eminent engineers and scientists who were best known for their outstanding contributions in one or more of the specific branches of experimental stress analysis. It was most impressive to witness the readiness and understanding with which these men, many of them not even associated with the Society, responded to the request and joined the editor in contributing their work, without remuneration, to the furtherance of the aims of the Society, which thus becomes the sole recipient of all royalties from this publication. This being the first comprehensive publication in its field, it may be of general interest to say a few words about the method used in the planning and coordina-
VI
tion of the material. In inviting the contributors, I first briefly out-lined the subject to be covered requesting, in return, from each author a more detailed outline of what he would propose on his respective subject. These authors’ outlines were subsequently collected in a booklet, a copy of which was sent to each participant, thus informing him in advance of projected contents of all the other parts of the book. This scheme proved of considerable help in assuring adequate coverage of all matters of interest, without undue overlaps, repetition, or need of frequent cross references. In the final plan, as seen in the table of contents, the main body of the book was divided into 18 chapters, each dealing with either a principal method, from mechanical gages to x-ray analysis, or a major topic of interest, such as residual stresses, interpretation of service fractures, or analogies. In addition to these, an appendix was devoted to the discussion of three theoretical subjects which are of fundamental importance in the planning and interpretation of experimental stress work. In the final outcome, not only the book as a whole but also most of the individual chap-
ters turned out to be pioneering ventures in their own rights, often constituting the first systematic exposition of their respective subject matter. Another innovation was undertaken in the treatment of bibliographical references, where an effort was made to review briefly the contents of each entry, since it was found that the mere titles of technical articles seldom convey a satisfactory picture of their respective contents. Despite all precautions the book is bound to have errors and shortcomings, and it is the sincere hope of the editor that users of the book will not hesitate to inform him of possibilities of improvement which may be incorporated in a later edition. In the course of this work the editor was greatly aided by advice from numerous friends and colleagues, among whom he wishes to acknowledge in particular the invaluable help received from B. F. Langer, R. D. Mindlin, W. M. Murray, R. E. Peterson, and G. Pickett. Evanston, Illinois April 1950
M. Hetenyi
VII
Preface to the Handbook on Experimental Mechanics, First Edition
The Handbook on Experimental Stress Analysis, which was published under the aegis of the Society for Experimental Stress Analysis in 1950, has been the comprehensive and authoritative reference in our field for more than thirty years. Under the able editorship of the late M. Herenyi, 31 authors contributed without compensation 18 chapters and 3 appendices to this handbook. It received international acclaim and brought considerable income to the Society for Experimental Mechanics. Since 1950, new experimental techniques, such as holography, laser speckle interferometry, geometric moire, moire interferometry, optical heterodyning, and modal analysis, have emerged as practical tools in the broader field of experimental mechanics. The emergence of new materials and new disciplines, such as composite materials and fracture mechanics, resulted in the evolution of traditional experimental techniques to new fields such as orthotropic photoelasticity and experimental fracture mechanics. These new developments, together with the explosive uses of on/off-line computers for rapid data processing and the combined use of experimental and numerical techniques, have expanded the capabilities of experimental mechanics far beyond those of the 1950s. Sensing the need to update the handbook, H. F. Brinson initiated the lengthy process of revising the
handbook during his 1978-79 presidency of the Society. Since M. Hetenyi could not undertake the contemplated revision at that time, the decision was made to publish a new handbook under a new editor. Opinions ranging from topical coverage to potential contributors were solicited from various SEM members, and after a short respite I was chosen as editor by the ad hoc Handbook Committee chaired by J. B. Ligon. Despite the enormous responsibility, our task was made easier by inheriting the legacy of the Herenyi Handbook and the numerous suggestions that were collected by H. Brinson. The new handbook, appropriately entitled Handbook on Experimental Mechanics, is dedicated to Dr. Hetenyi. Twenty-five authors have contributed 21 chapters that include, among others, the new disciplines and developments that are mentioned above. The handbook emphasizes the principles of the experimental techniques and de-emphasizes the procedures that evolve with time. I am grateful to the contributors, who devoted many late afterhours in order to meet the manuscript deadlines and to J. B. Ligon who readily provided welcomed assistance during the trying times associated with this editorship.
Albert S. Kobayashi 1987
VIII
Preface to the Handbook on Experimental Mechanics, Second Edition
Since the publication of the first edition, considerable progress has been made in automated image processing, greatly reducing the heretofore laborious task of evaluating photoelastic and moire fringe patterns. It is therefore appropriate to add Chapter 21: “Digital Image Processing” before the final chapter, “Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data.” Apart from the new chapter, this second edition is essentially same as the first edition with minor corrections and updating. Exceptions to this are the addition of a section on optical fiber sensors in Chapter 2: “Strain Gages,” and extensive additions to
Chapter 14, which is retitled “Thermal Stress Analysis,” and to Chapter 16: “Experimental Modal Analysis.” To reiterate, the purpose of this handbook is to document the principles involved in experimental mechanics rather than the procedures and hardware, which evolve over time. To that extent, we, the twenty-seven authors, judging from the many appreciative comments which were received upon the publication of the first edition, have succeeded. Albert S. Kobayashi April 1993
IX
Preface
This handbook is a revision and expansion of the Handbook on Experimental Mechanics published by the Society for Experimental Mechanics in 1987 with a second edition in 1993 – both edited by Albert Kobayashi. All three of these trace a direct lineage to the seminal Handbook of Experimental Stress Analysis conceived and edited by Miklós Hetényi in 1950 and they encapsulate the history of the field. In 1950, the capability of measuring strains on models and structures was just becoming widely available. Engineers were still making their own wire resistance foil gages, and photoelasticity measurements required film processing. Conversion of these measurements to stresses relied on slide rules and graph paper. Now, foil resistance gages are combined with automatic data acquisition, and photoelasticity is just as automated. Input from both experimental methods is combined with finite element analysis to present stress variations in color on a computer screen. The focus then was on large structures such as airframes; in fact, the efforts of the Society for Experimental Stress Analysis (founded in 1938) were crucial to the rapid development of aircraft in the 1940s. While measurements on large structures continue to be important, researchers today also measure the mechanical properties of specimens smaller than a human hair. The field is completely different now. Experimental techniques and applications have expanded (or contracted if you prefer) from stress analysis of large structures to include the electromechanical analysis of micron-sized sensors and actuators. Those changes – occurring gradually over the early years but now more rapidly – led to a change in the society name to the Society for Experimental Mechanics. Those changes also have led to the expansion of the current volume with the deletion of some topics and the addition of others
in order to address these emerging topics in the “micro world”. This volume presents experimental solid mechanics as it is practiced in the early part of the 21st century. It is a field that is important as a technology and rich in research opportunities. A striking feature of this handbook is that 20 of the 36 chapters are on topics that have arisen or matured in the 15 years since the last edition; and, in most cases, these have been written by relatively young researchers and practitioners. Consider microelectromechanical systems (MEMS), for example. That technology, originated by electrical engineers only 25 years ago, now permeates our lives. It was soon learned that designers and manufacturers needed better understanding of the mechanical properties of the new materials involved, and experimental mechanists became involved only 15 years ago. That is just one example; several of the chapters speak to it as well as similar completely new topics. The reader will find in this volume not only information on the traditional areas of experimental solid mechanics, but on new and emerging topics as well. This revision was initiated by the Executive Board of the Society and managed by the very capable staff at Springer, in particular Elaine Tham, Werner Skolaut, and Lauren Danahy. Sound advice was provided over the course of the effort by Jim Dally and Tom Proulx. However, the real work was done by the authors. Each chapter was written by authors, who are not only experts, but who volunteered to contribute to this Handbook. Although they are thoroughly familiar with the technical details, it still required a major effort on their part to prepare a chapter. On behalf of the Society and Springer, I acknowledge and thank them. Baltimore June 2008
William N. Sharpe, Jr.
XI
About the Editor
William N. Sharpe, Jr. holds the Alonzo G. Decker Chair in Mechanical Engineering at the Johns Hopkins University where he served as department chairman for 11-1/2 years. His early research focused on laser-based strain measurement over very short gage lengths to study plasticity and fracture behavior. The past fifteen years have been devoted to development and use of experimental methods to measure the mechanical properties of materials used in microelectromechanical systems. He is a Fellow and Past President of the Society for Experimental Mechanics from which he received the Murray Medal. The American Society of Mechanical Engineers awarded him the Nadai Award as well as Fellow grade. He has received an Alexander von Humboldt Award along with the Roe Award from the American Society of Engineering Education.
XIII
List of Authors Jonathan D. Almer Argonne National Laboratory 9700 South Cass Avenue Argonne, IL 60439, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Archie A.T. Andonian The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. D/410F 142 Goodyear Boulevard Akron, OH 44305, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Satya N. Atluri University of California Department of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering, Center for Aeorspace Research & Education 5251 California Avenue, Suite 140 Irvine, CA 92612, USA David F. Bahr Washington State University Mechanical and Materials Engineering Pullman, WA 99164, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Chris S. Baldwin Aither Engineering, Inc. 4865 Walden Lane Lanham, MD 20706, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Stephen M. Belkoff Johns Hopkins University International Center for Orthopaedic Advancement, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Bayview Medical Center 5210 Eastern Avenue Baltimore, MD 21224, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Hugh Bruck University of Maryland Department of Mechanical Engineering College Park, MD 20742, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Ioannis Chasiotis University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Aerospace Engineering Talbot Lab, 104 South Wright Street Urbana, IL 61801, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Gary Cloud Michigan State University Mechanical Engineering Department East Lansing, MI 48824, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Wendy C. Crone University of Wisconsin Department of Engineering Physics 1500 Engineering Drive Madison, WI 53706, USA e-mail:
[email protected] James W. Dally University of Maryland 5713 Glen Cove Drive Knoxville, TN 37919, USA e-mail:
[email protected] James F. Doyle Purdue University School of Aeronautics & Astronautics West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Igor Emri University of Ljubljana Center for Experimental Mechanics Cesta na brdo 85 Lubljana, SI-1125, Slovenia e-mail:
[email protected] Yimin Gan Universität GH Kassel Fachbereich 15 – Maschinenbau Mönchebergstr. 7 34109 Kassel, Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
XIV
List of Authors
Ashok Kumar Ghosh New Mexico Tech Mechanical Engineering and Civil Engineering Socorro, NM 87801, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Peter G. Ifju University of Florida Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Gainesville, FL 32611, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Richard J. Greene The University of Sheffield Department of Mechanical Engineering Mappin Street Sheffield, S1 3JD, UK e-mail:
[email protected]
Wolfgang G. Knauss California Institute of Technology-GALCIT 105-50 1201 East California Boulevard Pasadena, CA 91125, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Bongtae Han University of Maryland Mechanical Engineering Department College Park, MD 20742, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Albert S. Kobayashi University of Washington Department of Mechanical Engineering Seattle, Washington 98195-2600, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
M. Amanul Haque Pennsylvania State University Department of Mechanical Engineering 317A Leonhard Building University Park, PA 16802, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Sridhar Krishnaswamy Northwestern University Center for Quality Engineering & Failure Prevention Evanston, IL 60208-3020, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Craig S. Hartley El Arroyo Enterprises LLC 231 Arroyo Sienna Drive Sedona, AZ 86332, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Roger C. Haut Michigan State University College of Osteopathic Medicine, Orthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratories A407 East Fee Hall East Lansing, MI 48824, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Jay D. Humphrey Texas A&M University Department of Biomedical Engineering 335L Zachry Engineering Center, 3120 TAMU College Station, TX 77843-3120, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Yuri F. Kudryavtsev Integrity Testing Laboratory Inc. PreStress Engineering Division 80 Esna Park Drive Markham, Ontario L3R 2R7, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] Pradeep Lall Auburn University Department of Mechanical Engineering Center for Advanced Vehicle Electronics 201 Ross Hall Auburn, AL 36849-5341, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Kenneth M. Liechti University of Texas Aerospace Engineering and Engineering Mechanics Austin, TX 78712, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
List of Authors
Hongbing Lu Oklahoma State University School of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering 218 Engineering North Stillwater, OK 74078, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Ian McEnteggart Instron Coronation Road, High Wycombe Buckinghamshire, HP12 3SY, UK Dylan J. Morris National Institute of Standards and Technology Materials Science and Engineering Laboratory Gaithersburg, MD 20877, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Sia Nemat-Nasser University of California Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering 9500 Gilman Drive La Jolla, CA 92093-0416, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Wolfgang Osten Universität Stuttgart Institut für Technische Optik Pfaffenwaldring 9 70569 Stuttgart, Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Eann A. Patterson Michigan State University Department of Mechanical Engineering 2555 Engineering Building East Lansing, MI 48824-1226, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Daniel Post Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University (Virginia Tech) Department of Engineering Science and Mechanics Blacksburg, VA 24061, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Ryszard J. Pryputniewicz Worcester Polytechnic Institute NEST – NanoEngineering, Science, and Technology CHSLT – Center for Holographic Studies and Laser Micro-Mechatronics Worcester, MA 01609, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Kaliat T. Ramesh Johns Hopkins University Department of Mechanical Engineering 3400 North Charles Street Baltimore, MD 21218, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Krishnamurthi Ramesh Indian Institute of Technology Madras Department of Applied Mechanics Chennai, 600 036, India e-mail:
[email protected] Krishnaswamy Ravi-Chandar University of Texas at Austin 1 University Station, C0600 Austin, TX 78712-0235, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Guruswami Ravichandran California Institute of Technology Graduate Aeronautical Laboratories Pasadena, CA 91125, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Robert E. Rowlands University of Wisconsin Department of Mechanical Engineering 1415 Engineering Drive Madison, WI 53706, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Taher Saif University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Micro and Nanotechnology Laboratory, 2101D Mechanical Engineering Laboratory 1206 West Green Street Urbana, IL 61801, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Wolfgang Steinchen (deceased)
XV
XVI
Jeffrey C. Suhling Auburn University Department of Mechanical Engineering 201 Ross Hall Auburn, AL 36849-5341, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Michael A. Sutton University of South Carolina Center for Mechanics, Materials and NDE Department of Mechanical Engineering 300 South Main Street Columbia, SC 29208, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Robert B. Watson Vishay Micro-Measurements Sensors Engineering Department Raleigh, NC, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Robert A. Winholtz University of Missouri Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering E 3410 Lafferre Hall Columbia, MO 65211, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
XVII
Contents
List of Abbreviations ................................................................................. XXVII
Part A Solid Mechanics Topics 1 Analytical Mechanics of Solids Albert S. Kobayashi, Satya N. Atluri .......................................................... 1.1 Elementary Theories of Material Responses ..................................... 1.2 Boundary Value Problems in Elasticity ............................................ 1.3 Summary ...................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
3 4 11 14 14
2 Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist Craig S. Hartley ........................................................................................ 2.1 Structure of Materials .................................................................... 2.2 Properties of Materials................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
17 17 33 47
3 Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity Wolfgang G. Knauss, Igor Emri, Hongbing Lu ............................................ 3.1 Historical Background.................................................................... 3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity ..................................................................... 3.3 Measurements and Methods .......................................................... 3.4 Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Material Characterization ........................... 3.5 Closing Remarks ............................................................................ 3.6 Recognizing Viscoelastic Solutions if the Elastic Solution is Known ... References ..............................................................................................
49 49 51 69 84 89 90 92
4 Composite Materials Peter G. Ifju ............................................................................................. 4.1 Strain Gage Applications ................................................................ 4.2 Material Property Testing ............................................................... 4.3 Micromechanics ............................................................................ 4.4 Interlaminar Testing ...................................................................... 4.5 Textile Composite Materials............................................................ 4.6 Residual Stresses in Composites ..................................................... 4.7 Future Challenges.......................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
97 98 102 107 111 114 117 121 121
5 Fracture Mechanics Krishnaswamy Ravi-Chandar ................................................................... 5.1 Fracture Mechanics Based on Energy Balance ................................. 5.2 Linearly Elastic Fracture Mechanics .................................................
125 126 128
XVIII
Contents
5.3 Elastic–Plastic Fracture Mechanics .................................................. 5.4 Dynamic Fracture Mechanics .......................................................... 5.5 Subcritical Crack Growth ................................................................ 5.6 Experimental Methods................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
132 137 140 140 156
6 Active Materials Guruswami Ravichandran ........................................................................ 6.1 Background .................................................................................. 6.2 Piezoelectrics ................................................................................ 6.3 Ferroelectrics ................................................................................ 6.4 Ferromagnets ................................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
159 159 161 162 166 167
7 Biological Soft Tissues Jay D. Humphrey ..................................................................................... 7.1 Constitutive Formulations – Overview ............................................ 7.2 Traditional Constitutive Relations ................................................... 7.3 Growth and Remodeling – A New Frontier ...................................... 7.4 Closure ......................................................................................... 7.5 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
169 171 172 178 182 182 183
8 Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites Sia Nemat-Nasser .................................................................................... 8.1 Microstructure and Actuation ......................................................... 8.2 Stiffness Versus Solvation............................................................... 8.3 Voltage-Induced Cation Distribution .............................................. 8.4 Nanomechanics of Actuation ......................................................... 8.5 Experimental Verification .............................................................. 8.6 Potential Applications ................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
187 188 191 193 195 197 199 199
9 A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS Wendy C. Crone ........................................................................................ 9.1 Background .................................................................................. 9.2 MEMS/NEMS Fabrication ................................................................. 9.3 Common MEMS/NEMS Materials and Their Properties ....................... 9.4 Bulk Micromachining versus Surface Micromachining ...................... 9.5 Wafer Bonding .............................................................................. 9.6 Soft Fabrication Techniques ........................................................... 9.7 Experimental Mechanics Applied to MEMS/NEMS.............................. 9.8 The Influence of Scale.................................................................... 9.9 Mechanics Issues in MEMS/NEMS ..................................................... 9.10 Conclusion .................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
203 203 206 206 213 214 215 217 217 221 224 225
Contents
10 Hybrid Methods James F. Doyle ......................................................................................... 10.1 Basic Theory of Inverse Methods .................................................... 10.2 Parameter Identification Problems ................................................. 10.3 Force Identification Problems ........................................................ 10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems ................................ 10.5 Discussion of Parameterizing the Unknowns ................................... References ..............................................................................................
229 231 235 240 246 255 257
11 Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data James W. Dally ........................................................................................ 11.1 Characterizing Statistical Distributions ............................................ 11.2 Statistical Distribution Functions .................................................... 11.3 Confidence Intervals for Predictions ............................................... 11.4 Comparison of Means .................................................................... 11.5 Statistical Safety Factor .................................................................. 11.6 Statistical Conditioning of Data ...................................................... 11.7 Regression Analysis ....................................................................... 11.8 Chi-Square Testing ........................................................................ 11.9 Error Propagation .......................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
259 260 263 267 270 271 272 272 277 278 279
Part B Contact Methods 12 Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages Robert B. Watson ..................................................................................... 12.1 Standardized Strain-Gage Test Methods ......................................... 12.2 Strain and Its Measurement ........................................................... 12.3 Strain-Gage Circuits....................................................................... 12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage .......................................................... 12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages ........................................................... References ..............................................................................................
283 284 284 285 291 325 332
13 Extensometers Ian McEnteggart ...................................................................................... 13.1 General Characteristics of Extensometers ........................................ 13.2 Transducer Types and Signal Conditioning ...................................... 13.3 Ambient-Temperature Contacting Extensometers............................ 13.4 High-Temperature Contacting Extensometers ................................. 13.5 Noncontact Extensometers............................................................. 13.6 Contacting versus Noncontacting Extensometers ............................. 13.7 Conclusions ................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
335 336 337 338 341 343 345 346 346
XIX
XX
Contents
14 Optical Fiber Strain Gages Chris S. Baldwin ...................................................................................... 14.1 Optical Fiber Basics........................................................................ 14.2 General Fiber Optic Sensing Systems ............................................... 14.3 Interferometry .............................................................................. 14.4 Scattering ..................................................................................... 14.5 Fiber Bragg Grating Sensors ........................................................... 14.6 Applications of Fiber Optic Sensors ................................................. 14.7 Summary ...................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
347 348 351 354 359 361 367 368 369
15 Residual Stress Yuri F. Kudryavtsev .................................................................................. 15.1 Importance of Residual Stress ........................................................ 15.2 Residual Stress Measurement ......................................................... 15.3 Residual Stress in Fatigue Analysis ................................................. 15.4 Residual Stress Modification .......................................................... 15.5 Summary ...................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
371 371 373 381 383 386 386
16 Nanoindentation: Localized Probes of Mechanical Behavior
of Materials David F. Bahr, Dylan J. Morris .................................................................. 16.1 Hardness Testing: Macroscopic Beginnings...................................... 16.2 Extraction of Basic Materials Properties from Instrumented Indentation ..................................................... 16.3 Plastic Deformation at Indentations ............................................... 16.4 Measurement of Fracture Using Indentation ................................... 16.5 Probing Small Volumes to Determine Fundamental Deformation Mechanisms ..................... 16.6 Summary ...................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
402 404 404
17 Atomic Force Microscopy in Solid Mechanics Ioannis Chasiotis ..................................................................................... 17.1 Tip–Sample Force Interactions in Scanning Force Microscopy ........... 17.2 Instrumentation for Atomic Force Microscopy.................................. 17.3 Imaging Modes by an Atomic Force Microscope ............................... 17.4 Quantitative Measurements in Solid Mechanics with an AFM ........... 17.5 Closing Remarks ............................................................................ 17.6 Bibliography ................................................................................. References ..............................................................................................
409 411 412 423 432 438 439 440
389 389 392 396 399
Contents
Part C Noncontact Methods 18 Basics of Optics Gary Cloud ............................................................................................... 18.1 Nature and Description of Light ..................................................... 18.2 Interference of Light Waves ........................................................... 18.3 Path Length and the Generic Interferometer................................... 18.4 Oblique Interference and Fringe Patterns ....................................... 18.5 Classical Interferometry ................................................................. 18.6 Colored Interferometry Fringes ....................................................... 18.7 Optical Doppler Interferometry ....................................................... 18.8 The Diffraction Problem and Examples ........................................... 18.9 Complex Amplitude ....................................................................... 18.10 Fraunhofer Solution of the Diffraction Problem ............................... 18.11 Diffraction at a Clear Aperture ........................................................ 18.12 Fourier Optical Processing .............................................................. 18.13 Further Reading ............................................................................ References .............................................................................................. 19 Digital Image Processing for Optical Metrology Wolfgang Osten ....................................................................................... 19.1 Basics of Digital Image Processing .................................................. 19.2 Techniques for the Quantitative Evaluation of Image Data in Optical Metrology ...................................................................... 19.3 Techniques for the Qualitative Evaluation of Image Data in Optical Metrology ...................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
447 448 449 451 453 455 461 464 468 470 472 474 476 479 479
481 483 485 545 557
20 Digital Image Correlation for Shape
and Deformation Measurements Michael A. Sutton .................................................................................... 20.1 20.2 20.3 20.4 20.5 20.6 20.7 20.8 20.9 20.10
Background .................................................................................. Essential Concepts in Digital Image Correlation ............................... Pinhole Projection Imaging Model.................................................. Image Digitization ......................................................................... Intensity Interpolation .................................................................. Subset-Based Image Displacements ............................................... Pattern Development and Application ............................................ Two-Dimensional Image Correlation (2-D DIC)................................. Three-Dimensional Digital Image Correlation.................................. Two-Dimensional Application: Heterogeneous Material Property Measurements............................. 20.11 Three-Dimensional Application: Tension Torsion Loading of Flawed Specimen.................................. 20.12 Three-Dimensional Measurements – Impact Tension Torsion Loading of Single-Edge-Cracked Specimen ..................................... 20.13 Closing Remarks ............................................................................
565 566 568 569 573 573 575 577 579 581 585 588 593 597
XXI
XXII
Contents
20.14 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
597 599
21 Geometric Moiré Bongtae Han, Daniel Post ........................................................................ 21.1 Basic Features of Moiré .................................................................. 21.2 In-Plane Displacements ................................................................ 21.3 Out-Of-Plane Displacements: Shadow Moiré .................................. 21.4 Shadow Moiré Using the Nonzero Talbot Distance (SM-NT) ............... 21.5 Increased Sensitivity...................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
601 601 607 611 617 623 626
22 Moiré Interferometry Daniel Post, Bongtae Han ........................................................................ 22.1 Current Practice ............................................................................. 22.2 Important Concepts ....................................................................... 22.3 Challenges .................................................................................... 22.4 Characterization of Moiré Interferometry ........................................ 22.5 Moiré Interferometry in the Microelectronics Industry ..................... References ..............................................................................................
627 630 634 644 645 646 652
23 Speckle Methods Yimin Gan, Wolfgang Steinchen (deceased)............................................... 23.1 Laser Speckle ................................................................................ 23.2 Speckle Metrology ......................................................................... 23.3 Applications .................................................................................. 23.4 Bibliography ................................................................................. References ..............................................................................................
655 655 658 668 672 672
24 Holography Ryszard J. Pryputniewicz .......................................................................... 24.1 Historical Development.................................................................. 24.2 Fundamentals of Holography ......................................................... 24.3 Techniques of Hologram Interferometry.......................................... 24.4 Representative Applications of Holography ..................................... 24.5 Conclusions and Future Work ......................................................... References ..............................................................................................
675 676 677 679 685 696 697
25 Photoelasticity Krishnamurthi Ramesh ............................................................................ 25.1 Preliminaries ................................................................................ 25.2 Transmission Photoelasticity .......................................................... 25.3 Variants of Photoelasticity ............................................................. 25.4 Digital Photoelasticity.................................................................... 25.5 Fusion of Digital Photoelasticity Rapid Prototyping and Finite Element Analysis ........................................................... 25.6 Interpretation of Photoelasticity Results .........................................
701 704 705 710 719 732 734
Contents
25.7 Stress Separation Techniques ......................................................... 25.8 Closure ......................................................................................... 25.9 Further Reading ............................................................................ 25.A Appendix ...................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
735 737 737 738 740
26 Thermoelastic Stress Analysis Richard J. Greene, Eann A. Patterson, Robert E. Rowlands ......................... 26.1 History and Theoretical Foundations .............................................. 26.2 Equipment .................................................................................... 26.3 Test Materials and Methods ........................................................... 26.4 Calibration .................................................................................... 26.5 Experimental Considerations.......................................................... 26.6 Applications .................................................................................. 26.7 Summary ...................................................................................... 26.A Analytical Foundation of Thermoelastic Stress Analysis .................... 26.B List of Symbols .............................................................................. References ..............................................................................................
743 744 745 747 749 749 753 759 760 762 763
27 Photoacoustic Characterization of Materials Sridhar Krishnaswamy ............................................................................. 27.1 Elastic Wave Propagation in Solids ................................................. 27.2 Photoacoustic Generation .............................................................. 27.3 Optical Detection of Ultrasound...................................................... 27.4 Applications of Photoacoustics ....................................................... 27.5 Closing Remarks ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
769 770 777 783 789 798 798
28 X-Ray Stress Analysis Jonathan D. Almer, Robert A. Winholtz ..................................................... 28.1 Relevant Properties of X-Rays ........................................................ 28.2 Methodology ................................................................................. 28.3 Micromechanics of Multiphase Materials ........................................ 28.4 Instrumentation ............................................................................ 28.5 Experimental Uncertainties ............................................................ 28.6 Case Studies .................................................................................. 28.7 Summary ...................................................................................... 28.8 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
801 802 804 807 809 810 813 817 818 818
Part D Applications 29 Optical Methods Archie A.T. Andonian ............................................................................... 29.1 Photoelasticity .............................................................................. 29.2 Electronic Speckle Pattern Interferometry .......................................
823 824 828
XXIII
XXIV
Contents
29.3 Shearography and Digital Shearography ......................................... 29.4 Point Laser Triangulation ............................................................... 29.5 Digital Image Correlation ............................................................... 29.6 Laser Doppler Vibrometry ............................................................... 29.7 Closing Remarks ............................................................................ 29.8 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
830 831 832 834 835 836 836
30 Mechanical Testing at the Micro/Nanoscale M. Amanul Haque, Taher Saif ................................................................... 30.1 Evolution of Micro/Nanomechanical Testing .................................... 30.2 Novel Materials and Challenges...................................................... 30.3 Micro/Nanomechanical Testing Techniques ..................................... 30.4 Biomaterial Testing Techniques ...................................................... 30.5 Discussions and Future Directions .................................................. 30.6 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
839 840 841 842 856 859 862 862
31 Experimental Methods in Biological Tissue Testing Stephen M. Belkoff, Roger C. Haut ............................................................ 31.1 General Precautions ...................................................................... 31.2 Connective Tissue Overview ............................................................ 31.3 Experimental Methods on Ligaments and Tendons.......................... 31.4 Experimental Methods in the Mechanical Testing of Articular Cartilage ...................................................................... 31.5 Bone ............................................................................................ 31.6 Skin Testing .................................................................................. References ..............................................................................................
871 871 872 873 876 878 883 884
32 Implantable Biomedical Devices
and Biologically Inspired Materials Hugh Bruck ............................................................................................. 32.1 Overview....................................................................................... 32.2 Implantable Biomedical Devices..................................................... 32.3 Biologically Inspired Materials and Systems .................................... 32.4 Conclusions ................................................................................... 32.5 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
891 892 899 909 923 924 924
33 High Rates and Impact Experiments Kaliat T. Ramesh...................................................................................... 33.1 High Strain Rate Experiments ......................................................... 33.2 Wave Propagation Experiments ...................................................... 33.3 Taylor Impact Experiments ............................................................. 33.4 Dynamic Failure Experiments ......................................................... 33.5 Further Reading ............................................................................ References ..............................................................................................
929 930 945 949 949 953 954
Contents
34 Delamination Mechanics Kenneth M. Liechti ................................................................................... 34.1 Theoretical Background ................................................................. 34.2 Delamination Phenomena ............................................................. 34.3 Conclusions ................................................................................... References ..............................................................................................
961 962 968 980 980
35 Structural Testing Applications Ashok Kumar Ghosh ................................................................................. 985 35.1 Past, Present, and Future of Structural Testing ................................ 987 35.2 Management Approach to Structural Testing ................................... 990 35.3 Case Studies .................................................................................. 997 35.4 Future Trends ................................................................................ 1012 References .............................................................................................. 1013 36 Electronic Packaging Applications Jeffrey C. Suhling, Pradeep Lall ................................................................. 36.1 Electronic Packaging...................................................................... 36.2 Experimental Mechanics in the Field of Electronic Packaging ........... 36.3 Detection of Delaminations ........................................................... 36.4 Stress Measurements in Silicon Chips and Wafers ............................ 36.5 Solder Joint Deformations and Strains ............................................ 36.6 Warpage and Flatness Measurements for Substrates, Components, and MEMS .......................................... 36.7 Transient Behavior of Electronics During Shock/Drop ....................... 36.8 Mechanical Characterization of Packaging Materials ........................ References ..............................................................................................
Acknowledgements ................................................................................... About the Authors ..................................................................................... Detailed Contents...................................................................................... Subject Index.............................................................................................
1015 1017 1019 1022 1024 1031 1036 1039 1041 1042 1045 1049 1059 1083
XXV
XXVII
List of Abbreviations
A AASHTO ABS ACES AC AFM AFNOR AISC ALT AREA ASTM
Association of State Highway Transportation Officials American Bureau of Shipping analytical, computational, and experimental solution alternating current atomic force microscopy Association Française de National American Institute of Steel Construction accelerated lift testing American Railway Engineering Association American Society for Testing and Materials
B bcc BGA BHN BIL BSI BS BrUTS
body-centered cubic ball grid array Brinell hardness number boundary, initial, and loading British Standards Institute beam-splitter bromoundecyltrichlorosilane
C CAD CAE CAM CAR CBGA CCD CCS CDC CD CGS CHS CMC CMM CMOS CMP CMTD CNC CNT COD COI CP
computer-aided design computer-aided engineering computer-aided manufacturing collision avoidance radar ceramic ball grid array charge-coupled device camera coordinate system Centers for Disease Control compact disc coherent gradient sensing coefficient of hygroscopic swelling ceramic matrix composite coordinate measuring machine complementary metal–oxide-semiconductor chemical–mechanical polishing composite materials technical division computer numerical control carbon nanotube crack opening displacement crack opening interferometry conductive polymer
CSK CSM CTE CTOD CVD CVFE CW CZM
cytoskeleton continuous stiffness module coefficient of thermal expansion crack-tip opening displacement chemical vapor deposition cohesive-volumetric finite elements continuous wave cohesive zone model
D DBS DCB DCPD DC DEC DGL DIC DIN DMA DMD DMT DNP DPH DPN DPV DRIE DR DSC DSPI DSPSI DSP DTA DTS DTS
directional beam-splitter double-cantilever beam dicyclopentadiene direct current diffraction elastic constant Devonshire–Ginzburg–Landau digital image correlation Deutsches Institut für Normung dynamical mechanical analyzers digital micromirror device Derjaguin–Muller–Toporov distance from the neutral point diamond pyramid hardness dip-pen nanolithography Doppler picture velocimetry deep reactive-ion etching deviation ratio digital speckle correlation digital speckle-pattern interferometry digital speckle-pattern shearing interferometry digital speckle photography differential thermal analyzer distributed temperature sensing dodecyltrichlorosilane
E EAP ECM ECO EDM EDP EFM EFPI EMI ENF EPFM EPL
electroactive polymer extracellular matrix poly(ethylene carbon monoxide) copolymer electric-discharge machining ethylenediamine pyrochatechol electrostatic force microscopy extrinsic Fabry–Pérot interferometer electromagnetic interference end-notched flexure elastic–plastic fracture mechanics electron-beam projection lithography
XXVIII
List of Abbreviations
ESIS ESPI ESSP ES ET EW EXAFS
European Structural Integrity Society electronic speckle pattern interferometry electrostatically stricted polymer expert system emerging technologies equivalent weight extended x-ray absorption fine structure
IEC IFM IMU IPG IPMC IP IR-GFP ISDG ISO
focal adhesion complex fine-pitch ball grid array fiber Bragg grating flip-chip ball grid array face-centered cubic flip-chip plastic ball grid array Food and Drug Administration finite element modeling finite element fast Fourier transform full field of view functionally graded material focused ion beam force modulation microscopy Fillers–Moonan–Tschoegl frequency modulation friction stir welds Fourier-transform method field of view
ISTS IT
F FAC FBGA FBG FC-BGA fcc FC-PBGA FDA FEM FE FFT FFV FGM FIB FMM FMT FM FSW FTE FoV
G GF GMR GPS GRP GUM G&R
growth factor giant magnetoresistance global positioning sensing glass-reinforced plastic Guide for the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement growth and remodeling
H HAZ hcp HDI HEMA HFP HNDE HRR HSRPS HTS
heat-affected zone hexagonal close-packed high-density interconnect 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate half-fringe photoelasticity holographic nondestructive evaluation Hutchinson–Rice–Rosengreen high strain rate pressure shear high-temperature storage
I IBC IC
International Building Code integrated circuits
ion exchange capacity interfacial force microscope inertial measurement unit ionic polymer gel ionomeric polymer–metal composite image processing infrared grey-field polariscope interferometric strain/displacement gage International Organization for Standardization impulsive stimulated thermal scattering interferometer
J JIS
Japanese Industrial Standards
L LAN LASIK LCE LDV LED LEFM LFM LIGA LMO LORD LPCVD LPG LVDT LVDT
local area network laser-based corneal reshaping liquid crystal elastomer laser Doppler vibrometry light-emitting diode linear elastic fracture mechanics lateral-force AFM lithography galvanoforming molding long-working-distance microscope laser occlusive radius detector low-pressure CVD long-period grating linear variable differential transformer linear variable displacement transducer
M MBS MEMS MFM micro-CAT MITI MLF MMC MOEMS MOSFET MO M-TIR μPIV MPB MPCS MPODM MW(C)NT
model-based simulation micro-electromechanical system magnetic force microscopy micro computerized axial tomography Ministry of International Trade and Industry metal leadframe package metal matrix composites microoptoelectromechanical systems metal-oxide semiconductor field-effect transistor microscope objective modified total internal reflection microparticle image velocimetry morphotropic phase boundary most probable characteristics strength multipoint overdeterministic method multiwalled (carbon) nanotubes
List of Abbreviations
N NA NC-AFM NCOD NC NDE NDT/NDE NEMS NEPA NHDP NIST NMR NSF NSOM NVI
numerical aperture noncontact AFM normal crack opening displacement nanocrystalline nondestructive evaluation nondestructive testing/evaluation nanoelectromechanical system National Environmental Policy Act The National Highways Development Project National Institute of Standard and Technology nuclear magnetic resonance National Science Foundation near-field scanning optical microscopy normal velocity interferometer
OFDR OIML OIM OMC ONDT OPD OPS OSHA
optical/digital fringe multiplication object coordinate system orientation distribution function optoelectronic holography optoelectronic laser interferometric microscope optical frequency-domain reflectometry Organisation Internationale de Metrologie Legale orientation imaging microscopy organic matrix composites optical nondestructive testing optical path difference operations per second Occupational Safety and Health Administration
P PBG PBS PCB PCF PDMS PECVD PE PID PIN PIV PLA PLD PLZT PL PM fiber PMC
photonic-bandgap phosphate-buffered saline printed circuit board photonic-crystal fiber polydimethylsiloxane plasma-enhanced CVD pulse-echo proportional-integral-derivative p-type intrinsic n-type particle image velocimetry polylactic acid path length difference Pb(La,Zr,Ti)O3 path length polarization maintaining fiber polymer matrix composites
phase-measurement interferometry polymethyl methacrylate Pb(Mgx Nb1−x )O3 polarization maintaining power meter plastic quad flat package photorefractive crystal point spread function phase shifting technique plated-through holes polyvinyl chloride polyvinylidene fluoride physical vapor deposition phase velocity scanning Pb(Zr,Ti)O3
Q QC QFP QLV
O O/DFM OCS ODF OEH OELIM
PMI PMMA PMN PM PM PQFP PRC PSF PST PTH PVC PVDF PVD PVS PZT
quality-control quad flat pack quasilinear viscoelastic theory
R RCC RCRA RF RIBS RMS RPT RSG RSM RS RVE R&D
reinforced cement concrete Resource Conservation and Recovery Act radiofrequency replamineform inspired bone structures root-mean-square regularized phase tracking resistance strain gage residual stress management residual stress representative volume element research and development
S S-T-C S/N SAC SAM SAM SAR SAW SCF SCS SC SDF SD SEM SEM SHPB SIF SI SLC
self-temperature compensation signal to noise Sn–Ag–Cu scanning acoustic microscopy self-assembled monolayer synthetic-aperture radar surface acoustic wave stress concentration factor sensor coordinate system speckle correlation structure data files standard deviation scanning electron microscopy Society for Experimental Mechanics split-Hopkinson pressure bar stress intensity factor speckle interferometry surface laminar circuit
XXIX
XXX
List of Abbreviations
SLL SMA SNL SNR SOI SOTA SPATE SPB SPM SPSI SPS SP SQUID SRM SSM STC STM SThM ST SW(C)NT
surface laminar layer shape-memory alloy Sandia National Laboratories signal-to-noise ratio silicon on insulator state-of-the-art stress pattern analysis by thermal emissions space–bandwidth product scanning probe microscope speckle pattern shearing interferometry spatial phase shifting speckle photography superconducting quantum interface device sensitivity response method sacrificial surface micromachining self-temperature compensated scanning tunneling microscope scanning thermal microscopy structural test single-walled (carbon) nanotubes
TIG TIM TIR TMAH TM TPS TSA TS TWSME Terfenol-D TrFE
thermal barrier coatings temperature coefficient of expansion temperature coefficient of resistance transverse displacement interferometer time division multiplexing thermoelectric cooler transmission electron microscopy thermal evaluation for residual stress analysis tetrafluoroethylene
VLE
T TBC TCE TCR TDI TDM TEC TEM TERSA TFE
tungsten inert gas thermal interface materials total internal reflection tetramethylammonium hydroxide thermomechanical temporal phase shifting thermoelastic stress analysis through scan two-way shape memory effect Tb0.3 Dy0.7 Fe2 trifluoroethylene
U UCC UDL UHV ULE UP
ultrasonic computerized complex uniformly distributed load ultrahigh vacuum ultralow expansion ultrasonic peening
V VCCT VDA VISAR
virtual crack closure technique video dimension analysis velocity interferometer system for any reflector vector loop equations
W WCS WDM WFT WLF WM WTC
world coordinate system wavelength-domain multiplexing windowed Fourier transform Williams–Landel–Ferry wavelength meter World Trade Center
1
Part A
Solid Mec Part A Solid Mechanics Topics
1 Analytical Mechanics of Solids Albert S. Kobayashi, Seattle, USA Satya N. Atluri, Irvine, USA 2 Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist Craig S. Hartley, Sedona, USA 3 Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity Wolfgang G. Knauss, Pasadena, USA Igor Emri, Lubljana, Slovenia Hongbing Lu, Stillwater, USA 4 Composite Materials Peter G. Ifju, Gainesville, USA 5 Fracture Mechanics Krishnaswamy Ravi-Chandar, Austin, USA 6 Active Materials Guruswami Ravichandran, Pasadena, USA
7 Biological Soft Tissues Jay D. Humphrey, College Station, USA 8 Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites Sia Nemat-Nasser, La Jolla, USA 9 A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS Wendy C. Crone, Madison, USA 10 Hybrid Methods James F. Doyle, West Lafayette, USA 11 Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data James W. Dally, Knoxville, USA
3
Albert S. Kobayashi, Satya N. Atluri
In this chapter we consider certain useful fundamental topics from the vast panorama of the analytical mechanics of solids, which, by itself, has been the subject of several handbooks. The specific topics that are briefly summarized include: elementary theories of material response such as elasticity, dynamic elasticity, viscoelasticity, plasticity, viscoplasticity, and creep; and some useful analytical results for boundary value problems in elasticity.
1.1
Elementary Theories of Material Responses ........................... 1.1.1 Elasticity ..................................... 1.1.2 Viscoelasticity ..............................
1.1.3 Plasticity ..................................... 1.1.4 Viscoplasticity and Creep ...............
7 9
Boundary Value Problems in Elasticity .... 1.2.1 Basic Field Equations .................... 1.2.2 Plane Theory of Elasticity............... 1.2.3 Basic Field Equations for the State of Plane Strain ............................. 1.2.4 Basic Field Equations for the State of Plane Stress ............................. 1.2.5 Infinite Plate with a Circular Hole... 1.2.6 Point Load on a Semi-Infinite Plate
11 11 12
Summary .............................................
14
References ..................................................
14
1.2
4 4 6
1.3
12 12 13 13
Herein, we employ Cartesian coordinates exclusively. We use a fixed Cartesian system with base vectors ei (i = 1, 2, 3). The coordinates of a material particle before and after deformation are xi and yi , respectively. The deformation gradient, denoted as Fij , is defined to be ∂yi ≡ yi, j . (1.1) ∂x j
A wide variety of other strain measures may be derived [1.1–4]. Let ( da) be a differential area in the deformed body, and let n i be direction cosines of a unit outward normal to ( da). If the differential force acting on this area is d f i , the true stress or Cauchy stress τij is defined from the relation
The displacement components will be denoted by u i (= yi − xi ), such that
Thus τij is the stress per unit area in the deformed body. The nominal stress (or the transpose of the so-called first Piola–Kirchhoff stress) tij and the second Piola– Kirchhoff stress Sij are defined through the relations
Fij = δij + u i, j ,
(1.2)
where δij is a Kronecker delta. The Green–Lagrange strain tensor εij is given by 1 1 εij = (Fki Fk j − δij ) ≡ (u i, j + u j,i + u k,i u k, j ) . 2 2 (1.3)
When displacements and their gradients are infinitesimal, (1.3) may be approximated as 1 (1.4) εij = (u i, j + u j,i ) ≡ u (i, j) . 2
d f i = ( da)n j τij .
d f i = ( da)N j t ji = ( dA)N j S jk yi,k ,
(1.5)
(1.6) (1.7)
where ( dA)N j is the image in the undeformed configuration, of the oriented vector area ( da)n j in the deformed configuration. Note that both t ji and S ji are stresses per unit area in the undeformed configuration, and t ji is unsymmetric, while S ji is, by definition, symmetric [1.3,4]. It should also be noted that a wide variety of other stress measures may be derived [1.3, 4].
Part A 1
Analytical Me 1. Analytical Mechanics of Solids
4
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 1.1
From the geometric theory of deformation [1.5], it follows that ∂xi (1.8) , ( da)n j = (J)( dA)Nk ∂y j where ρ0 dv (1.9) = . J= d∀ ρ In the above dv is a differential volume in the deformed body, and d∀ is its image in the undeformed body. From (1.5) through (1.9), it follows that ∂x j ∂xi ∂xi τm j and Sij = J τmn . (1.10) tij = J ∂ym ∂ym ∂yn
Another useful stress tensor is the so-called Kirchhoff stress tensor, denoted by σij and defined as σij = Jτij .
(1.11)
When displacements and their gradients are infinitesimal, J ≈ 1, ∂xi /∂yk = δik and so on, and thus the distinction between all the stress measures largely disappears. Hence, in an infinitesimal deformation theory, one may speak of the stress tensor σij . For more on finite deformation mechanism of solids see [1.6, 7].
1.1 Elementary Theories of Material Responses The mathematical characterization of the behavior of solids is one of the most complex aspects of solid mechanics. Most of the time, the general behavior of a material defies our mathematical ability to characterize it. The theories discussed below must be viewed simply as idealizations of regimes of material response under specific types of loading and/or environmental conditions.
invariants of εij . These invariants may be defined as
1.1.1 Elasticity
where eijk is equal to 1 if (ijk) take on values 1, 2, 3 in a cyclic order, and equal to −1 if in anticyclic order, and is zero if two of the indices take on identical values. Sometimes, invariants J1 , J2 , and J3 , defined as
In this idealization, the underlying assumption is that stress is a single-valued function of strain and is independent of the history of straining. Also, for such materials, one may define a potential for stress in terms of strain, in the form of a strain-energy density function, denoted here by W. It is customary [1.4] to measure W per unit of the undeformed volume. In the general case of finite deformations, different stress measures are related to the derivative of W with respect to specific strain measures, labeled as conjugate strain measures, i. e., strains conjugate to the appropriate form of stress. Thus it may be shown [1.3] that tij =
∂W , ∂F ji
Sij =
∂W . ∂εij
(1.12)
Note that, for finite deformations, the Cauchy stress τij does not have a simple conjugate strain measure. When W does not depend on the location of the material particle (in the undeformed conjugation), the material is said to be homogeneous. A material is said to be isotropic if W depends on εij only through the basic
I1 = 3 + 2εkk , I2 = 3 + 4εkk + 2(εkk εmm − εkm εkm ) , and I3 = det|δmn + 2εmn | ≡ 1 + 2εkk + 2(εkk εmm − εkm εkm ) ,
J1 = (I1 − 3), J2 = (I2 − 2I1 + 3) , J3 = (I3 − I2 + I1 − 1)
(1.13)
(1.14)
are also used. When the material is isotropic, the Kirchhoff stress tensor may be shown to be the derivative of W with respect to a certain logarithmic strain measure [1.4]. Also, by decomposing the deformation gradient Fij into pure stretch and rigid rotation [1.4, 8], one may derive certain other useful stress measures, such as the Biot–Lure stress, Jaumann stress, and so on [1.4]. An isotropic nonlinearly elastic material may be characterized, in its behavior at finite deformations, by W=
∞
Crst (I1 − 3)r (I2 − 3)s (I3 − 1)t ,
r,s,t=0
C000 = 0 .
(1.15)
The ratio of volume change due to deformation, dv/ d∀, is given, for finite deformations, by I3 . Thus, for
Analytical Mechanics of Solids
¯ = W(εij ) + p(I3 − 1) , W
(1.16)
that is, tij =
∂W ∂I3 +p , ∂F ji ∂F ji
Sij =
∂W ∂I3 +p . (1.17) ∂εij ∂εij
For isotropic, incompressible, elastic materials, W(εij ) = W(I1 , I2 ) .
(1.18)
Thus (1.17) and (1.18) yield, for instance, ∂W ∂W δij + 4[δij (1 + εmm ) − δim δ jn εmn ] ∂I1 ∂I2 + p[δij (1 + 2εmm ) − 2δim δ jn εmn + 2eimn e jrs εmr εns ] . (1.19)
Sij = 2
A well-known representation of (1.18) is due to Mooney [1.8], where W(I1 , I2 ) = C1 (I1 − 3) + C2 (I2 − 3) .
(1.20)
So far, we have discussed isotropic materials. In general, for a homogeneous solid, one may write W = E ij εij + 12 E ijmn εij εmn + 13 E ijmnrs εij εmn εrs + · · · .
(1.21)
We use, for convenience of presentation, Sij and εij as conjugate measures of stress and strain. Since Sij and εij are both symmetric, one must have E ij = E ji , E ijmn = E jinm = E ijnm = E mnij , E ijmnrs = E jimnrs = E ijnmrs = E ijmnsr = · · · = Ersijmn = · · · . (1.22) Thus Sij = E ij + E ijmn εmn + E ijmnrs εmn εrs + · · · . (1.23) Henceforth, we will consider the case when deformations are infinitesimal. Thus εij ≈ (1/2)(u i, j + u j,i ). Further, the differences in the definitions of various stress measures disappear, and one may speak of the stress σij . Thus (1.23) may be rewritten as σij = E ij + E ijmn εmn + E ijmnrs εmn εrs + · · · . (1.24)
A material is said to be linearly elastic if a linear approximation of (1.24) is valid for the magnitude of strains under consideration. For such a material, σij = E ij + E ijmn εmn .
(1.25)
The stress at zero strain (i. e., E ij ) most commonly is due to temperature variation from a reference state. The simplest assumption in thermal problems is to set E ij = −βij ΔT where ΔT [= (T − T0 )] is the temperature increment from the reference value T0 . For an anisotropic linearly elastic solid, in view of the symmetries in (1.23), one has 21 independent elastic constants E ijkl and six constants βij . In the case of isotropic linearly elastic materials, an examination of (1.13) through (1.15) reveals that the number of independent elastic constants E ijkl is reduced to two, and the number of independent βs to one. Thus, for an isotropic elastic material, σij = λεkk δij + 2μεij − βΔT δij ,
(1.26a)
where λ and μ are Lamé parameters, which are related to the Young’s modulus E and the Poisson’s ratio ν through E Eν , μ= . λ= (1 + ν)(1 − 2ν) 2(1 + ν) The bulk modulus K is defined as 3λ + 2μ . K= 3 The inverse of (1.26a) is ν 1+ν (1.26b) σij + αΔT δij , εij = − σmn δij + E E where β and α are related through Eα β= (1.26c) 1 − 2ν and α is the linear coefficient of thermal expansion. The state of plane strain is characterized by the conditions that u r = u r (X s ), r, s = 1, 2, and u 3 = 0. Thus ε3i = 0, i = 1, 2, 3. In plane strain, 1 − ν2 ν σ22 + α(1 + ν)ΔT , σ11 − ε11 = E 1−ν (1.27a)
1 − ν2 ν ε22 = σ22 − σ11 + α(1 + ν)ΔT , E 1−ν
(1.27b)
1+ν σ12 , E σ33 = ν(σ11 + σ) − αEΔT . ε12 =
(1.27c) (1.27d)
5
Part A 1.1
incompressible materials, I3 = 1. For incompressible materials, stress is determined from strain only to within a scalar quantity (function of material coordinates) called the hydrostatic pressure. For such materials, one ¯ in may define a modified strain-energy function, say W, which the incompressibility condition, I3 = 1, is introduced as a constraint through the Lagrange multiplier p. Thus
1.1 Elementary Theories of Material Responses
6
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 1.1
The state of plane stress is characterized by the conditions that σ3k = 0, k = 1, 2, 3. Here one has 1 (1.28a) ε11 = (σ11 − νσ22 ) + αΔT , E 1 ε22 = (σ22 − νσ11 ) + αΔT , (1.28b) E 1+ν ε12 = (1.28c) σ12 , E ν ε33 = − (σ11 + σ22 ) + αΔT . (1.28d) E Note that in (1.27c) and (1.28c), ε12 is the tensor component of strain. Sometimes it is customary to use the engineering strain component γ12 = 2ε12 . Note also that, in the case of a linearly elastic material, the strainenergy density W is given by W= =
σij (t) = εkl (0+ )E ijkl +
t E ijkl (t − τ) 0
∂εkl dτ ∂τ (1.33a)
= E kl (0+ )εijkl +
t εijkl (t − τ) 0
∂E kl dτ . ∂τ (1.33b)
1 2 σij εij 1 2 (σ11 ε11 + σ22 ε22 + σ33 ε33
In the above, it has been assumed that σkl = εkl = 0 for t < 0 and that εij (t) and E ij (t) are piecewise continuous. E ijkl (t) is called the relaxation tensor for an anisotropic material. Conversely, one may write
+ 2ε12 σ12 + 2ε13 σ13 + 2ε23 σ23 ) ≡ 12 (σ11 ε11 + σ22 ε22 + σ33 ε33 + γ12 σ12 + γ23 σ23 + γ13 σ13 ) .
(1.29)
From (1.26b) it is seen that, for linearly elastic isotropic materials, 1 − 2ν σmm σmm + 3αΔT ≡ + 3αΔT . (1.30) εkk = E 3k When the bulk modulus k → ∞ (or ν → 12 ), it is seen that εkk → 3αΔT and is independent of the mean stress. Note also from (1.26c) that β → ∞ as ν → 12 . For such materials, the mean stress is indeterminate from deformation alone. In this case, the relation (1.26a) is replaced by σij = −ρδij + 2μεij
(1.31a)
with the constraint εkk = 3αΔT ,
(1.31b)
εij
where ρ is the hydrostatic pressure and is the deviator of the strain. Note that the strain-energy density of a linearly elastic incompressible material is W = μεij εij − p(εkk − 3αΔT ) ,
materials are those for which the current deformation is a function of the entire history of loading, and conversely, the current stress is a function of the entire history of straining. Linearly viscoelastic materials are those for which the hereditary relations are expressed in terms of linear superposition integrals, which, for infinitesimal strains, take the forms
(1.32)
wherein p acts as a Lagrange multiplier to enforce (1.31b).
1.1.2 Viscoelasticity A linearly elastic solid, by definition, is one that has the memory of only its unstrained state. Viscoelastic
+
t
εij (t) = σkl (0 )Cijkl +
Cijkl (t − τ) 0
∂σkl dτ , ∂τ (1.34)
where Cijkl (t) is called the creep compliance tensor. For isotropic linearly viscoelastic materials, E ijkl = μ(t)(δik δ jl + δlk δ jk ) + λ(t)δij δkl ,
(1.35)
where μ(t) is the shear relaxation modulus and B(t) ≡ [3α(t) + 2μ(t)]/3 is the bulk relaxation modulus. It is often assumed that B(t) is a constant; so that the material is assumed to have purely elastic volumetric change. In viscoelasticity, a Poisson function corresponding to the strain ratio in elasticity does not exists. However, for every deformation history there is computable Poisson contraction or expansion behavior. For instance, in a uniaxial tension test, let the stress be σ11 , the longitudinal strain ε11 , and the lateral strain ε22 . For creep at constant stress, the ratio of lateral contraction, denoted by νc (t), is νc (t) = −ε22 (t)/ε11 (t). On the other hand, under relaxation at constant strain, ε11 , the lateral contraction ratio is ν R (t) = −ε22 (t)/ε11 . It is often convenient, though not physically correct, to assume that Poisson’s ratio is a constant, which renders B(t) proportional to μ(t). A constant bulk modulus provides a much better and simple approximation for the material behavior than a constant Poisson’s ratio when properties over the whole time range are needed.
Analytical Mechanics of Solids
σ ij ( p) = pE ijkl ( p)εkl ( p)
(1.36a)
εij ( p) = pC ijkl ( p)σ kl ( p) ,
(1.36b)
and
deformation is assumed to be insensitive to hydrostatic pressure, the yield function is assumed, in general, to depend on the stress deviator, σij = σij − 13 σmm δij . The commonly used yield functions are von Mises
where (·) is the Laplace transform of (·) and p is the Laplace variable. From (1.36a) and (1.36b), it follows that p E ijkl C klmn = δim δn j . 2
M
μm exp(−μm t) ,
m=1 M
B(t) = B0 +
Bm exp(−βm t) .
m=1
1.1.3 Plasticity Most structural metals behave elastically for only very small values of strain, after which the materials yield. During yielding, the apparent instantaneous tangent modulus of the material is reduced from those in the prior elastic state. Removal of load causes the material to unload elastically with the initial elastic modulus. Such materials are usually labeled as elastic–plastic. Observed phenomena in the behavior of such materials include the so-called Bauschinger effect (a specimen initially loaded in tension often yields at a much reduced stress when reloaded in compression), cyclic hardening, and so on [1.9, 10]. (When a specimen a specimen is subjected to cyclic straining of amplitude −ε to +ε, the stress for the same value of tensile strain ε, prior to unloading, increases monotonically with the number of cycles and eventually saturates.) Various levels of sophistication of elastic-plastic constitutive theories are necessary to incorporate some or all of these observed phenomena. Here we give a rather cursory review of this still burgeoning literature. In most theories of metal plasticity, it is assumed that plastic deformations are entirely distortional in nature, and that volumetric strain is purely elastic. The elastic limit of the material is assumed to be specified by a yield function, which is a function of stress (or of strain, but most commonly of stress). Since plastic
J2 = 12 σij σij ,
(1.38)
Tresca f (σij ) = (σ1 − σ2 )2 − 4k2 (σ2 − σ3 )2 − 4k2 (1.39) × (σ1 − σ3 )2 − 4k2 = 0 .
(1.37)
It is also customary to represent the relaxation moduli, μ(t) and B(t), in series form, as μ(t) = μ0 +
f (σij ) = J2 − k2 ,
In (1.38) and (1.39), k may be a function of the plastic strain. Both (1.38) and (1.39) represent a surface, which is defined as the yield surface, in the stress space. The two equations also imply the equality of the tensile and compressive yield stresses at all times – so-called isotropic hardening. The yield surface expands while its center remains fixed in the stress space.√ The relation of k to test data follows: in (1.38), k = σ¯ / 3, where σ¯ is the yield stress in uniaxial tension, which may be a function of plas√ tic strain for strain-hardening materials, or k = τ¯ / 2, where τ¯ is the yield stress in pure shear; or in (1.39), k = σ¯ /2 or τ¯ . Experimental data appear to favor the use of the Mises condition [1.11, 12]. To account for the Bauschinger effect, one may use the representation of the yield surface f (σij − αij ) = 0 = 12 σij − αij σij − αij − 13 σ¯ 2 =0,
(1.40)
αij
where represents the center of the yield surface in the deviatoric stress space. The evolution equations suggested for αij by Prager [1.13] and Ziegler [1.14], respectively, are that the incremental dαij is proporp tional to the incremental plastic strain dεij or dαij = c dεij
(1.41)
dαij = dμ(σij − αij ) .
(1.42)
p
and
(·)
In the above, denotes the deviatoric part of the second-order tensor (·) where an additive decomposition of differential strain into elastic and plastic parts p (i. e., dεij = dεije + dεij ) was used. Elastic processes (with no increase in plastic strain) and plastic processes (with increase in plastic strain) are defined [1.12] as
7
Part A 1.1
The Laplace transforms of (1.33) and (1.34) may be written as
1.1 Elementary Theories of Material Responses
8
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 1.1
elastic process: f < 0 or
f = 0 and
∂f dσij ≤ 0 , ∂σij
(1.43)
plastic process: ∂f dσij > 0 . (1.44) ∂σij The flow rule for strain-hardening materials, arising out of consideration of stress working in a cyclic process and stability of the process, often referred to as Drucker’s postulates [1.15], is given by f = 0 and
p dεij
∂f = dλ . ∂σij
(1.45)
The scalar dλ is determined from the fact that d f = 0 during a plastic process, the so-called consistency condition. Using the isotropic-hardening (J2 flow) theory for which f is given in (1.38), this consistency condition leads to 9 σ dσmn p (1.46) dεij = σij mn 2 , 4 H σ¯ where H is the slope of the curve of stress versus plastic strain in uniaxial tension (or, more correctly, the slope of the curve of true stress versus logarithmic strain in pure tension). On the other hand, for Prager’s linearly kinematic hardening rules, given in (1.40) and (1.41), the consistency condition leads to 3 p σmn − αmn dσmn σij − αij . (1.47) dεij = 2cσ¯ 2 For pressure-insensitive plasticity, the stress–strain laws may be written as dσmn = (3λ + 2μ) dεmn , p dσij = 2μ dεij − dεij .
(1.48a) (1.48b) p
Choosing a parameter ζ such that ζ = 1 when dεij = 0 p and α = 0 when dεij = 0, we have dσ 9 σmn mn dσij = 2μ dεij − σij α (1.49) 4 H σ¯ 2 for isotropic hardening, and
3 dσij = 2μ dεij − (σ − αmn ) 2cσ¯ 2 mn × dσmn (σij − αij )α
(1.50)
for Prager’s linearly kinematic hardening. Taking the tensor product of both sides of (1.49) with σij (and
dσ noting that σmn dσmn = σmn mn by definition), we have 3α σ dσ (1.51a) dσij σij = 2μ dεij σij − 2H mn mn or 2μH dσij σij = dε σ , when α = 1 . (1.51b) H + 3μ ij ij Use of (1.51b) in (1.49) results in
9α dσij = 2μ dεij − 2μ σ σ dε . 4(H + 3μ)σ¯ 2 ij mn mn
(1.52)
Combining (1.48a) and (1.52), one may write the isotropic-hardening elastic-plastic constitutive law in differential form as dσij = 2μδim δ jn + λδij δmn 9αμ − 2μ σ σ (1.53) dεmn , (2H + 6μ)σ¯ 2 ij mn dε ≡ σ dε wherein σmn mn has been noted. Simimn mn larly, by taking the tensor product of (1.50) with (σij − αij ) and repeating steps analogous to those in (1.51) through (1.53), one may write the kinematic-hardening elastoplastic constitutive law as
3μ dσij = 2δim δ jn + λδij δmn − 2μ (c + 2μ)σ¯ 2 × (σij − αij )(σmn − αmn ) dεmn . (1.54) Note that all the developments above are restricted to the infinitesimal strain and small-deformation case. Discussion of finite-deformation plasticity is beyond the scope of this summary. (Even in small deformation plasticity, if the current tangent modulus of the stress–strain relation are of the same order of magnitude as the current stress, one must use an objective stress rate, instead of the material rate dσij , in (1.54).) Here the objectivity of the stress–strain relation plays an important role. We refer the reader to [1.4, 16, 17]. We now briefly examine the elastic-plastic stress– strain relations in the isotropic-hardening case, for plane strain and plane stress, leaving it to the reader to derive similar relations for kinematic hardening. In the planestrain case, dε3n = 0, n = 1, 2, 3. Using this in (1.53), we have
dσαβ = 2μδαθ δβν + λδαβ δθν 9αμ − 2μ σ σ (1.55) dεθν (2H + 6μ)σ¯ 2 αβ θυ
Analytical Mechanics of Solids
dσ33 = λ dεθθ − 2μ
9αμ σ σ dεϑν , (2H + 6μ)σ¯ 2 33 θυ
α, β, θ, ν = 1, 2 . (1.56) Note that, in the plane-strain case, σ33 , as integrated from (1.56), enters the yield condition. In the planestress case the stress–strain relation is somewhat tedious to derive. Noting that in the plane-stress case, dεαβ = dεeαβ + p dεαβ one may, using the elastic strain–stress relations as given in (1.33), write p
dεαβ = dεeαβ + dεαβ
1 ν p = dσαβ − dσθθ δαβ + dεαβ (1.57) 2μ 1+ν
1 ν dσαβ − = dσθθ δαβ 2μ 1+ν 9 , (1.58) + σαβ (σθυ dσθυ ) 4H σ¯ 2 wherein (1.16) has been used. Equation (1.58) may be inverted to obtain dσαβ in terms of dεθν . This 3 × 3 matrix inversion may be carried out, leading to the result [1.18] 2 Q ) + 2P dε11 dσ11 = (σ22 E + (−σ11 σ22 + 2ν P) dε22 σ11 + νσ22 − 2 dε12 , σ12 1+ν Q σ22 + 2ν P) dε11 dσ22 = (−σ11 E 2 + (σ11 ) + 2P dε22 σ + σ11 2 − 22 dε12 , σ12 1+ν σ11 + νσ22 Q dσ12 = − σ12 dε11 E 1+ν σ + νσ11 − 22 σ12 dε22
1+ν R 2H + + (1 − ν)σ¯ dε12 , 2(1 + ν) 9E where σ2 2H 2 P= σ¯ + 12 , Q = R + 2(1 − ν2 )P , 9H 1+ν (1.59)
and 2 + 2νσ11 σ22 + σ22 2. R = σ11
(1.60)
As noted earlier, the classical plasticity theory has several limitations. Intense research is underway to im-
prove constitutive modeling in cyclic plasticity, and so on, some notable avenues of current research being multisurface plasticity model, endochronic theories, and related internal variable theories (see, e.g., [1.19–21]).
1.1.4 Viscoplasticity and Creep A viscoplastic solid is similar to a viscous fluid, except that the former can resist shear stress even in a rest configuration; but when the stresses reach critical values as specified by a yield function, the material flows. Consider, for instance, the loading case of simple shear with the only applied stress being σ12 . Restricting ourselves to infinitesimal deformations and strains, let the shearstrain rate be ε˙ 12 = ( dε12 / dt). Then ε˙ 12 = 0 until the magnitude of σ12 reaches a value k, called the yield stress. When |σ12 | > k, ε˙ 12 , by definition for a simple viscoplastic material, is proportional to |σ12 | − k and has the same sign as σ12 . Thus, defining a function F 1 for this one-dimensional problem as |σ12 | (1.61) −1 , k the viscoplastic property may be characterized by the equation F1 =
2η˙ε12 = k(F 1 )σ12 , where
(1.62)
F1
must have the property ⎧ ⎨0 if F 1 < 0 , F 1 = ⎩ F 1 if F 1 ≥ 0 ,
(1.63)
and where η is the coefficient of viscosity. The above relation for simple shear is due to Bing2 for simple shear, ham [1.22]. Recognizing that J = σ12 a generalization of the above for three-dimensional case was given by Hohenemser and Prager [1.23] as νp
η˙εij = 2k
F 1
∂F , ∂σij
(1.64a)
where
1/2 1/2 σij σij /2 J2 F= −1 = −1 , k k
(1.64b)
and the specific function F is defined similar to F 1 of (1.63). For an elasto-viscoplastic solid undergoing infinitesimal straining, one may use the additive decomposition p
ε˙ ij = ε˙ ije + ε˙ ij
(1.65)
9
Part A 1.1
and
1.1 Elementary Theories of Material Responses
10
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 1.1
and the stress–strain rate relation ν p σ˙ ij = E ijkl ε˙ kl − ε˙ kl ,
(1.66)
where E ijkl are the instantaneous elastic moduli. Note that the viscoplastic strains in (1.64a) are purely deviatoric, since ∂F/∂σij = σij /2 is deviatoric. Thus, for an isotropic solid, (1.66) may be written as σ˙ mn = (3λ + 2μ) ε˙ mn and
σ˙ ij = 2μ ε˙ ij − ε˙ ij .
(1.68)
(1.69a)
(1.69b)
The expression (1.69a) is often referred to as time hardening and (1.69b) as strain hardening. In as much as (1.68), (1.69a), and (1.69b), are valid for constant stress, (1.69a) and (1.69b), when integrated for variable stress histories, do not necessarily give the same results. Usually, strain hardening leads to better agreement with experimental findings for variable stresses. In the study of creep at a given temperature and for long times, called steady-state creep, the creep strain rate in uniaxial loading is usually expressed as ε˙ c = f (σ, T ) ,
(1.70)
where T is the temperature. Assuming that the effects of σ and T are separable, the relation ε˙ c = f 1 (σ) f 2 (T ) = Aσ n f 2 (T ) = Bσ n
3 σ σ 2 ij ij
and ε˙ ceq =
2 ε˙ ij ε˙ ij 3
1/2 (1.73)
(1.67b)
or, equivalently, ε˙ c = g(σ, εc ) .
(1.72)
where the subscript “eq” denotes an “equivalent” quantity, defined, analogous to the case of plasticity, as σ˙ eq =
where σ is the uniaxial stress and t is the time. The creep rate may be written as ε˙ c = f (σ, t) ,
n , ε˙ ceq = Bσeq
(1.67a)
On the other hand, for metals operating at elevated temperatures, the strain in uniaxial tension is known to be a function of time, for a constant stress of magnitude even below the conventional elastic limit. Most often, based on extensive experimental data [1.24], the creep strain under constant stress, in uniaxial tests, is expressed as ε˙ c = Aσ n t m ,
involve no volume change. Thus, in the multiaxial case, ε˙ ijc is a deviatoric tensor. The relation (1.71) may be generalized to the multiaxial case as
(1.71a) (1.71b)
is usually employed, with B denoting a function of the temperature. The steady-state creep strains are associated largely with plastic deformations and are usually observed to
such that σeq ε˙ ceq = σij ε˙ ijc . Thus (1.72) implies that ε˙ ijc =
3 B(σeq )n−1 σij . 2
(1.74)
For the elastic-creeping solid, one may again write ε˙ ij = ε˙ ije + ε˙ ijc
(1.75)
and once again, the stress–strain rate relation may be written as (1.76) σ˙ ij = E ijkl ε˙ kl − ε˙ ckl . In the above, the applied stress level has been assumed to be such that the material remains within the elastic limit. If the applied loads are of such a magnitude as to cause the material to exceed its yield limit, one must account for plastic or viscoplastic strains. An interesting unified viscoplastic/plastic/creep constitutive law has been proposed by Perzyna [1.25]. Under multiaxial conditions, the relation for inelastic strain rate suggested in [1.26] is ε˙ ija = Aψ( f )
∂q , ∂σij
(1.77)
where A is the fluidity parameter, the superscript “a” denotes an elastic strain rate, and f is a loading function, expressed, analogous to the plasticity case, as f (σij , k) = ϕ(σij ) − k = 0 ,
(1.78)
q is a viscoplastic potential defined as q = q(σij ) , and ψ( f ) is a specific function such that ⎧ ⎨0 if f < 0 ψ( f ) = ⎩ψ( f ) if f ≥ 0 .
(1.79)
(1.80)
Analytical Mechanics of Solids
ψ( f ) = f n and
f =
3 σ σ 2 ij ij
(1.81a)
1/2 − σ¯ = σeq − σ¯ .
(1.81b)
By letting σ¯ = 0 and q = f , one may easily verify that ε˙ ija of (1.77) tends to the creep strain rate ε˙ ijc of (1.74). Letting σ¯ be a specified constant value and q = f , we obtain, using (1.81b) in (1.77), that ε˙ ija =
σij 3 A(σeq − σ¯ )n 2 σeq
for f > 0 (i. e., σeq > σ¯ ) .
(1.82)
The equivalent inelastic strain may be written as 2 a a 1/2 = A(σeq − σ¯ )n (1.83a) ε˙ ij ε˙ ij ε˙ aeq = 3 or 1 a 1/2 . (1.83b) ε˙ eq σeq − σ¯ = A Thus, if a stationary solution of the present inelastic model (i. e., when ε˙ aeq → 0) is obtained, it
is seen that σeq → σ. ¯ Thus a classical inviscid plasticity solution is obtained. This fact has been utilized in obtaining classical rate-independent plasticity solutions from the general model of (1.77), by Zienkiewicz and Corneau [1.26]. An alternative way of obtaining an inviscid plastic solution from Perzyna’s model is to let A → ∞. This concept has been implemented numerically by Argyris and Kleiber [1.27]. Also, as seen from (1.83b), σeq or equivalently the size of the yield surface is governed by isotropic work-hardening effects as characterized by the dependence on viscoplastic work, and the strain-rate effect as q characterized by the term (˙εeq )1/n . Thus rate-sensitive plastic problems may also be treated by Perzyna’s model [1.25]. Thus, by appropriate modifications, the general relation (1.77) may be used to model creep, rate-sensitive plasticity, and rate-insensitive plasticity. By a linear combination of strain rates resulting from these individual types of behavior, combined creep, plasticity, and viscoplasticity may be modeled. However, such a model is more or less formalistic and does not lead to any physical insights into the problem of interactive effects between creep, plasticity, and viscoplasticity. Modeling of such interactions is the subject of a large number of current research studies.
1.2 Boundary Value Problems in Elasticity 1.2.1 Basic Field Equations When deformations are finite and the material is nonlinear, the field equations governing the motion of a solid may become quite complicated. When the constitutive equation is of a differential form, such as in plasticity, viscoplasticity, and so on, it is often convenient to express the field equations in rate form as well. On the other hand, when stress is a single-valued function of strain as in nonlinear elasticity, the field equations may be written in a total form. In general, when numerical procedures are employed to solve boundary/initial value problems for arbitrary-shaped bodies, it is often convenient to write the field equations in rate form, for arbitrary deformations and general constitutive laws. A wide variety of equivalent but alternative forms of these equations is possible, since one may use a wide variety of stress and strain measures, a wide variety of rates of stress and strain, and a variety of coordinate
systems, such as those in the initial undeformed configuration (total Lagrangian), the currently deformed configuration (updated Lagrangian), or any other known intermediate configuration. For a detailed discussion see [1.3, 4]. Each of the alternative forms may offer advantages in specific applications. It is beyond the scope of this chapter to discuss the foregoing alternative forms. Here we state, for a finitely deformed nonlinearly elastic solid, the relevant field equations governing stress, strain, and deformation when the solid undergoes dynamic motion. For this purpose, let x j denote the Cartesian coordinates of a material particle in the undeformed solid. Let u k (xi ) be the arbitrary displacement of a material particle from the undeformed to the deformed configuration. Let Sij be the second Piola–Kirchhoff stress in the finitely deformed solid. Note that S jj is measured per unit area in the undeformed configuration. Let the Green–Lagrange strain tensor, which is work-conjugate to Sij [1.3],
11
Part A 1.2
If q ≡ f , one has the so-called associative law, and if q = f , one has a nonassociative law. Perzyna [1.25] suggests a fairly general form for ψ as
1.2 Boundary Value Problems in Elasticity
12
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 1.2
be εij . Let ρ0 be the mass density in the undeformed solid; b j be body forces per unit mass; ti be tractions measured per unit area in the undeformed solid, prescribed at surface St , of the undeformed solid; and let u i be prescribed displacements at Su . The field equations are [1.4]: linear momentum balance Sik (δ jk + u j,k ) + ρ0 b j = ρ0 u¨ j ,
(1.84)
angular momentum balance Sij = S ji ,
(1.85)
strain displacement relation εij = 12 (u i, j + u j,i + u k,i u k, j ) , constitutive law
(1.86)
∂W , ∂εij
(1.87)
at Si ,
(1.88)
Sij = traction boundary condition n j Sik (δ jk + u j,k ) = t j
displacement boundary condition u j = u¯ i at Su . (1.89) In the above, (·)k denotes ∂(·)/∂xk ; (¨·) denotes ∂ 2 (·)/∂t 2 ; n i are components of a unit normal to St ; and W is the strain-energy density, measured per unit volume in the undeformed body. When the deformations and strains are infinitesimal, the differences in the alternate stress and strain measures disappear. Further, considering only an isothermal linearly elastic solid, the equations above simplify as σij,i + ρ0 b j = ρ0 u¨ j , σij = σ ji , 1 εij = (u i, j + u j,i ) , 2 σij = E ijkl εkl , n i σij = t¯i at St , u i = u¯ i
at Su ,
(1.90) (1.91) (1.92) (1.93) (1.94) (1.95)
and the initial condition, u i (xk , 0) = u ∗ (xk ), u˙ i (xk , 0) = u˙ i∗ (xk , 0) at t = 0 . (1.96)
problems, unfortunately, are few and are limited to semifinite or finite domains; homogeneous and isotropic materials; and often relatively simple boundary conditions. In practice, however, it is common to encounter problems with finite but complex shape in which the material is neither homogeneous nor homogeneous and the boundary conditions are complex. The rapid development and easy accessibility of large-scale numerical codes in recent years are now providing engineers with numerical tools to analyze these practical problems, which are mostly three dimensional in nature and that commonly occur in engineering. Often, however, some three-dimensional problems can be reduced, as a first approximation, to two-dimensional problems for which analytical solutions exist. The utility of such twodimensional solutions lies not in their elegant analysis but in their use for physically understanding certain classes of problems and, more recently, as benchmarks for validating numerical modeling and computational procedures. In the following, we will reformulate the basic equations in two-dimensional Cartesian coordinates and provide analytical example solutions to two simple problems in terms of a polar coordinate system.
1.2.3 Basic Field Equations for the State of Plane Strain A plane state of strain is defined as the situation with zero displacement, say u 3 = 0. Equation (1.90) through (1.96) recast with this definition are σ11,1 + σ21,2 + ρ0 b1 = ρ0 u¨ 1 σ12,1 + σ22,2 + ρ0 b2 = ρ0 u¨ 2 , σ1,2 = σ2,1 , ε11 = u 1,1 ,
ε22 = u 2,2 ,
1 − ν2
(1.97) (1.98)
ε12 =
1 2 (u 1,2 + u 2,1 ) ,
ν σ22 , E 1−ν 1 − ν2 ν ε22 = σ22 − σ11 , E 1−ν 1+ν ε12 = σ12 , E σ33 = ν(σ11 + σ22 ) . ε11 =
σ11 −
(1.99) (1.100a) (1.100b) (1.100c) (1.100d)
1.2.2 Plane Theory of Elasticity The basic field equations and boundary conditions for a three-dimensional boundary/initial value problem in linear elasticity are given in (1.90) through (1.96). Analytical (exact) solutions to idealized three-dimensional
1.2.4 Basic Field Equations for the State of Plane Stress The plane state of stress is defined with zero surface traction, say σ33 = σ31 = σ32 = 0, parallel to the
Analytical Mechanics of Solids
1 (1.101a) (σ11 − νσ22 ) , E 1 ε22 = (σ22 − νσ11 ) , (1.101b) E 1+ν ε12 = (1.101c) σ12 , E ν ε33 = − (σ11 + σ22 ) . (1.102) E In the following, we cite three classical analytical solutions to the linear boundary value problem in Eqs. (1.97) through (1.102) for specific cases that are often of interest. ε11 =
1.2.5 Infinite Plate with a Circular Hole Consider a plane problem of an infinite linearly elastic isotropic body containing a hole of radius a. Let the body be subjected to uniaxial tension, say o∞ 11 , along the x1 axis. Let the Cartesian coordinate system be located at the center of the hole and let r and θ be the corresponding polar coordinates with θ being the angle measured from the x1 axis. The state of stress near the hole is given by [1.28] ∞ σ11 a2 σrr = 1− 2 2 r ∞ σ a4 a2 + 11 1 − 4 2 + 3 4 cos 2θ , (1.103a) 2 r r σ∞ σ∞ a2 a4 σθθ = 11 1 + 2 − 11 1 + 3 4 cos 2θ , 2 2 r r σrθ = −
∞ σ11
2
1+2
a2 r2
−3
a4 r4
(1.103b)
sin 2θ .
(1.103c)
The solution for a biaxial stress state may be obtained by superposition. For a compendium of solutions of holes in isotropic and anisotropic bodies, and for shapes of holes other than circular, such as elliptical holes, see Savin [1.28].
A basic problem for a heterogeneous medium such as a composite, is that of an inclusion (or inclusions). Consider then a rigid inclusion of radius a and assume a perfect bonding between the medium and the inclusion. The solution for stresses near the inclusion due to a far-field uniaxial tension, say o∞ 11 , are σ∞ a2 σrr = 11 1 − ν 2 2 r ∞ σ a4 a2 + 11 1 − 2β 2 − 3δ 4 cos 2θ , (1.104a) 2 r r ∞ ∞ σ11 σ11 a2 a4 σθθ = 1+ν 2 − 1 − 3δ 4 cos 2θ , 2 2 r r σrθ = −
∞ σ11
a2
a4
(1.104b)
(1.104c) 1 + β 2 + 3δ 4 sin 2θ , 2 r r 2(λ + μ) μ λ+μ β=− ν=− δ= , λ + 3μ λ+μ λ + 3μ (1.104d)
where λ and μ are Lamé constants.
1.2.6 Point Load on a Semi-Infinite Plate Consider a concentrated vertical force P acting on a horizontal straight edge of a semi-infinitely large plate. The origin of a Cartesian coordinate is at the location of load application with x1 in the direction of the force. Consider again a polar coordinate of r and θ with θ being the angle measured from the x1 axis, positive in the counterclockwise direction. The state of stress is a very simple one given by 2P cos θ π r σθθ = σrθ = 0 . σrr = −
(1.105a) (1.105b)
This state of stress satisfies the natural boundary conditions as all three stress components vanish on the straight boundary, i. e., θ = π/2, except at the origin, where σrr → ∞ as r → 0. A contour integration of the vertical component of σrr over a semicircular arc from the origin yields the statically equivalent applied force P and thus all boundary conditions are satisfied. By using stress equations of transformations, which can be found in textbooks on solid mechanics, the stresses in polar coordinates can be converted into Cartesian coordinates as 2P (1.106a) cos4 θ , σ11 = σrr cos2 θ = − πa
13
Part A 1.2
x1 –x2 plane. This state shares the same stress equations of equilibrium and strain-displacement relations with the state of plane strain, i. e. (1.97) through (1.99). Equations (1.97) and (1.98) are necessary and sufficient to solve a two-dimensional elastostatic boundary value problem when only tractions are prescribed on the boundary. Thus the stresses of the plane-stress and plane-strain solutions coincide while the strains differ. The stress–strain relations for the state of plane stress are
1.2 Boundary Value Problems in Elasticity
14
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 1
2P (1.106b) sin2 θ cos2 θ , πa 2P σ12 = σrr sin θ cos θ = − sin θ cos3 θ . (1.106c) πa σ22 = σrr sin2 θ = −
Since strain is what is actually being measured, the corresponding strains can be computed by (1.100) for the plane-strain state or by (1.101) for the plane-stress state.
1.3 Summary It is obviously impossible in this extremely brief review even to mention all of the important subjects and recent developments in the theories of elasticity, plasticity, viscoelasticity, and viscoplasticity. For further details,
readers are referred to the many excellent books and survey articles (see for example [1.29] and [1.30]), many of which are referenced in the succeeding chapters, in each of the disciplines.
References 1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9
1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13
1.14
C. Truesdell (Ed.): Mechanics of Solids. In: Encyclopedia of Physics, Vol. VIa/2 (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1972) C. Truesdell, W. Noll: The Nonlinear Field Theories of Mechanics. In: Encyclopedia of Physics, Vol. III/3, ed. by S. Flügge (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1965) S.N. Atluri: Alternate stress and conjugate strain measures, and mixed foundations involving rigid rotations for computational analysis of finitely deformed solids, with application to plates and shells. I- Theory, Comput. Struct. 18(1), 93–116 (1986) S.N. Atluri: On some new general and complementary energy theorems for rate problems in finite strain, classical elastoplasticty, J. Struct. Mech. 8(1), 61–92 (1980) A.C. Eringen: Nonlinear Theory of Continuous Media (McGraw-Hill, New York 1962) R.W. Ogden: Nonlinear Elastic Deformation (Dover, New York 2001) Y.C. Fung, P. Tong: Classical and Computational Solid Mechanics (World Scientific, Singapore 2001) M. Mooney: A theory of large elastic deformation, J. Appl. Phys. 11, 582–592 (1940) A. Abel, R.H. Ham: The cyclic strain behavior of crystal aluminum-4% copper, the Bauschinger effect, Acta Metallur. 14, 1489–1494 (1966) A. Abel, H. Muir: The Bauschinger effect and stacking fault energy, Phil. Mag. 27, 585–594 (1972) G.I. Taylor, H. Quinney: The plastic deformation of metals, Phil. Trans. A 230, 323–362 (1931) R. Hill: The Mathematical Theory of Plasticity (Oxford Univ. Press, New York 1950) W. Prager: A new method of analyzing stress and strains in work-hardening plastic solids, J. Appl. Mech. 23, 493–496 (1956) H. Ziegler: A modification of Prager’s hardening rule, Q. Appl. Math. 17, 55–65 (1959)
1.15
1.16
1.17
1.18
1.19
1.20
1.21
1.22 1.23
1.24 1.25
D.C. Drucker: A more fundamental approach to plane stress-strain relations, Proc. 1st U.S. Nat. Congr. Appl. Mech. (1951) pp. 487–491 S. Nemat-Nasser: Continuum bases for consistent numerical foundations of finite strains in elastic and inelastic structures. In: Finite Element Analysis of Transient Nonlinear Structural Behavior, AMD, Vol. 14, ed. by T. Belytschko, J.R. Osias, P.V. Marcal (ASME, New York 1975) pp. 85–98 S.N. Atluri: On constitutive relations in finite strain hypoelasticity and elastoplasticity with isotropic or kinematic hardening, Comput. Meth. Appl. Mech. Eng. 43, 137–171 (1984) Y. Yamada, N. Yoshimura, T. Sakurai: Plastic stressstrain matrix and its application to the solution of elastic-plastic problems by the finite element method, Int. J. Mech. Sci. 10, 343–354 (1968) K. Valanis: Fundamental consequences of a new intrinsic tune measure plasticity as a limit of the endochronic theory, Arch. Mech. 32(2), 171–191 (1980) Z. Mroz: An attempt to describe the behavior of metals under cyclic loads using a more general workhardening model, Acta Mech. 7, 199–212 (1969) O. Watanabe, S.N. Atluri: Constitutive modeling of cyclic plasticity and creep using an internal time concept, Int. J. Plast. 2(2), 107–134 (1986) E.C. Bingham: Fluidity and Plasticity (McGraw-Hill, New York 1922) K. Hohenemser, W. Prager: Über die Ansätze der Mechanik isotroper Kontinua, Z. Angew. Math. Mech. 12, 216–226 (1932) I. Finnie, W.R. Heller: Creep of Engineering Materials (McGraw-Hill, New York 1959) P. Perzyna: The constitutive equations for rate sensitive plastic materials, Quart. Appl. Mech. XX(4), 321–332 (1963)
Analytical Mechanics of Solids
1.27
O.C. Zienkiewicz, C. Corneau: Visco-plasticity, plasticity and creep in elastic solids – a unified numerical solution approach, Int. J. Numer. Meth. Eng. 8, 821–845 (1974) J.H. Argyris, M. Keibler: Incremental formulation in nonlinear mechanics and large strain elastoplasticity – natural approach – Part I, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 11, 215–247 (1977)
1.28 1.29 1.30
G.N. Savin: Stress Concentration Around Holes (Pergamon, Elmsford, 1961) A.S. Argon: Constitutive Equations in Plasticity (MIT Press, Cambridge, 1975) A.L. Anand: Constitutive equations for rate independent, isotropicelastic-plastic solid exhibitive pressure sensitive yielding and plastic dilatancy, J. Appl. Mech. 47, 439–441 (1980)
15
Part A 1
1.26
References
17
Materials Scie
2. Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
This chapter presents selected principles of materials science and engineering relevant to the interpretation of structure–property relationships. Following a brief introduction, the first section describes the atomic basis for the description of structure at various size levels. Types of atomic bonds form a basis for a classification scheme of materials as well as for the distinction between amorphous and crystalline materials. Crystal structures of elements and compounds are described. The second section presents the thermodynamic and kinetic basis for the formation of microstructures and describes the use of phase diagrams for determining the nature and quantity of equilibrium phases present in materials. Principal methods for the observation and determination of structure are described. The structural foundations for phenomenological descriptions of equilibrium, dissipative, and transport properties are described. The chapter includes examples of the relationships among physical phenomena responsible for various mechanical properties and the values of
2.1
Structure of Materials ........................... 2.1.1 Atomic Bonding ........................... 2.1.2 Classification of Materials .............. 2.1.3 Atomic Order ............................... 2.1.4 Equilibrium and Kinetics ............... 2.1.5 Observation and Characterization of Structure .................................
17 18 21 22 28
Properties of Materials .......................... 2.2.1 The Continuum Approximation ...... 2.2.2 Equilibrium Properties .................. 2.2.3 Dissipative Properties ................... 2.2.4 Transport Properties of Materials .... 2.2.5 Measurement Principles for Material Properties ..................
33 34 35 38 43
References ..................................................
47
2.2
31
46
these properties. In conclusion the chapter presents several useful principles for experimental mechanists to consider when measuring and applying values of material properties.
2.1 Structure of Materials Engineering components consist of materials having properties that enable the items to perform the functions for which they are designed. Measurements of the behavior of engineering components under various conditions of service are major objectives of experimental mechanics. Validation and verification of analytical models used in design require such measurements. All models employ mathematical relationships that require knowledge of the behavior of materials under a variety of conditions. Assumptions such as isotropy, homogeneity, and uniformity of materials affect both analytical calculations and the interpretation of experimental results. Regardless of the scale or purpose of the measurements, properties of materials that comprise the
components affect both the choice of experimental techniques and the interpretation of results. In measuring static behavior, it is important to know whether relevant properties of the constituent materials are independent of time. Similarly, measurements of dynamic behavior require information on the dynamic and dissipative properties of the materials. At best, the fundamental nature of materials, which is the ultimate determinant of their behavior, forms the basis of these models. The extent to which such assumptions represent the actual physical situation limits the accuracy and significance of results. The primary axiom of materials science and engineering states that the properties and performance of
Part A 2
Craig S. Hartley
18
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
a material depend on its structure at one or more levels, which in turn is determined by the composition and the processing, or thermomechanical history of the material. The meaning of structure as employed in materials science and engineering depends on the scale of reference. Atomic structure refers to the number and arrangement of the electrons, protons, and neutrons that compose each type of atom in a material. Nanostructure refers to the arrangement of atoms over distances of the order of 10−9 m. Analysis of the scattering of electrons, neutrons, or x-rays is the principal tool for measurements of structure at this scale. Microstructure refers to the spatial arrangement of groups of similarly oriented atoms as viewed by an optical or electron microscope at resolutions in the range 10−6 –10−3 m. Macrostructure refers to arrangements of groups of microstructural features in the range of 10−3 m or greater, which can be viewed by the unaided eye or under low-power optical magnification. Structure-insensitive properties, such as density and melting point, depend principally on composition, or the relative number and types of atoms present in a material. Structure-sensitive properties, such as yield strength, depend on both composition and structure, principally at the microscale. This survey will acquaint the experimental mechanist with some important concepts of materials science and engineering in order to provide a basis for informed selections and interpretations of experiments. The chapter consists of a description of the principal factors that determine the structure of materials, including techniques for quantitative measurements of structure, followed by a phenomenological description of representative material properties with selected examples of physically based models of the properties. A brief statement of some principles of measurement that acknowledge the influence of material structure on properties concludes the chapter. Additional information on many of the topics covered in the first two sections can be found in several standard introductory texts on materials science and engineering for engineers [2.1–4]. Since this introduction can only briefly survey the complex field of structure–property relationships, each section includes additional representative references on specific topics.
2.1.1 Atomic Bonding The Periodic Table The realization that all matter is composed of a finite number of elements, each consisting of atoms with a characteristic arrangement of elementary particles, be-
came widespread among scientists in the 19th and 20th century. Atomic theory of matter led to the discovery of primitive units of matter known as electrons, protons, and neutrons and laws that govern their behavior. Although discoveries through research in high-energy physics constantly reveal more detail about the structure of the atom, the planetary model proposed in 1915 by Niels Bohr, with some modifications due to later discoveries of quantum mechanics, suffices to explain most of the important aspects of engineering materials. In this model, atoms consist of a nucleus, containing protons, which have a positive electrical charge, and an approximately equal number of electrically neutral neutrons, each of which has nearly the same mass as a proton. Surrounding this nucleus is an assembly of electrons, which are highly mobile regions of concentrated negative charge each having substantially smaller mass than a proton or neutron. The number of electrons is equal to the number of protons in the nucleus, so each atom is electrically neutral. Elements differ from one another primarily through the atomic number, or number of protons in the nucleus. However, many elements form isotopes, which are atoms having identical atomic numbers but different numbers of neutrons. If the number of neutrons differs excessively from the number of protons, the isotope is unstable and either decays by the emission of neutrons and electromagnetic radiation to form a more stable isotope or fissions, emitting electromagnetic radiation, neutrons, and assemblies of protons and neutrons that form nuclei of other elements. The Periodic Table, shown in Fig. 2.1, classifies elements based on increasing atomic number and a periodic grouping of elements having similar chemical characteristics. The manner in which elements interact chemically varies periodically depending on the energy distribution of electrons in the atom. The basis for this grouping is the manner in which additional electrons join the atom as the atomic numbers of the elements increase. Quantum-mechanical laws that govern the behavior of electrons require that they reside in the vicinity of the nucleus in discrete spatial regions called orbitals. Each orbital corresponds to a specific energy state for electrons and is capable of accommodating two electrons. Electron orbitals can have a variety of spatial orientations, which gives a characteristic symmetry to the atom. Four quantum numbers, arising from solutions to the Schrödinger wave equation, governs the behavior of the electrons: the principal quantum number n, which can have any integer value from 1 to infinity; the azimuthal quantum number , which can have any integer
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
value from 0 to (n − 1); the magnetic quantum number m , which can have any integer value between − and +; and the spin quantum number m s which has values ±1/2. The Pauli exclusion principle states that no two electrons in a system can have the same four quantum numbers. As the number of electrons increases with increasing atomic number, orbitals are filled beginning with those having the lowest electron energy states and proceeding to the higher energy states. Elements with electrons in full, stable orbitals are chemically inert gases, which occupy the extreme right column of the periodic table (group 8). Electronegative elements, which occupy columns towards the right of
2.1 Structure of Materials
Part A 2.1
the periodic table, have nearly full orbitals and tend to interact with other atoms by accepting electrons to form a negatively charged entity called an anion. The negative charge arises since electrons join the originally neutral atom. Electropositive elements occupy columns towards the left on the periodic table and ionize by yielding electrons from their outer orbitals to form positively charged cations. Broadly speaking, elements are metals, metalloids, and nonmetals. The classification proceeds from the most electropositive elements on the left of the periodic table to the most electronegative elements on the right. A metal is a pure element. A metal that incorpo8A
1A 1
2
H
H
1s1 hydrogen
1s2 helium
1.008
2A
3A
4A
5A
6A
7A
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
4.003
10
Li
Be
B
C
N
O
F
Ne
[He]2s1 lithium
[He]2s2 beryllium
[He]2s22p1 boron
[He]2s22p2 carbon
[He]2s22p3 nitrogen
[He]2s22p4 oxygen
[He]2s22p5 fluorine
[He]2s22p6 neon
6.941
9.012
10.81
12.01
14.01
16.00
19.00
20.18
11
12
13
14
16
16
17
18
Na
Mg
Al
Si
P
S
Cl
Ar
[Ne]3s1 sodium
[Ne]3s2 magnesium
22.99
24.31
3B
4B
5B
6B
7B
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
K
Ca
Sc
Ti
V
Cr
Mn
Fe
[Ar]4s1 pollassium
[Ar]4s2 calcium
[Ar]4s23d1 scandium
[Ar]4s23d2 titanium
[Ar]4s23d3 vanadium
[Ar]4s13d5 chromium
[Ar]4s23d5 manganese
39.10
40.08
44.96
47.88
50.94
52.00
55.94
37
38
39
40
41
42
Rb
Sr
Y
Zr
Nb
[Kr]5s1 nubidium
[Kr]5s2 strontium
[Kr]5s24d1 yttrium
[Kr]5s24d2 zirconium
85.47
87.62
88.91
91.22
55
57
57
Cs
Ba
1
[Xe]6s casium
132.9
87
[Ne]3s23p1 aluminum
[Ne]3s23p2 silicon
[Ne]3s23p3 phosphorus
[Ne]3s23p4 sulfur
[Ne]3s23p5 chlorine
[Ne]3s23p6 argon
11B
12B
26.98
28.09
30.97
32.07
35.45
39.95
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
Co
Ni
Cu
Zn
Ga
Ge
As
Se
Br
Kr
[Ar]4s23d6 iron
[Ar]4s23d7 cobalt
[Ar]4s23d8 nickel
[Ar]4s13d10 copper
[Ar]4s23d10 zinc
55.85
58.93
58.69
63.55
65.39
69.72
72.58
74.92
78.96
79.90
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
52
Mo
Tc
Ru
Rh
Pd
Ag
Cd
In
Sn
Sb
Te
I
Xe
[Kr]5s14d4 niobium
[Kr]5s14d5 molybdenum
[Kr]5s24d5 technetium
[Kr]5s14d7 ruthenium
[Kr]5s14d8 rhodium
[Kr]4d10 palladium
[Kr]5s14d10 silver
[Kr]5s24d10 cadmium
92.91
95.94
(98)
101.1
102.9
106.4
107.9
112.4
114.8
118.7
121.8
127.6
126.9
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
La*
Hf
Ta
W
Re
Os
Ir
Pt
Au
Hg
Tl
Pb
Bi
Po
At
Rn
[Xe]6s2 barium
[Xe]6s25d1 lanthanum
[Xe]6s24f145d2 hafnium
[Xe]6s24f145d3 tantalum
[Xe]6s24f145d4 tungsten
[Xe]6s24f145d5 rhenium
[Xe]6s24f145d6 osmium
[Xe]6s24f145d7 iridium
[Xe]6s14f145d9 platinum
[Xe]6s14f145d10
[Xe]6s24f145d10
[Xe]6s24f145d106p1
[Xe]6s24f145d106p2
[Xe]6s24f145d106p3
[Xe]6s24f145d106p4
[Xe]6s24f145d106p5
[Xe]6s24f145d106p6
gold
mercury
thallium
lead
bismuth
polonium
astatine
radon
137.3
138.9
178.5
180.9
183.9
186.2
190.2
190.2
195.1
197.0
200.5
204.4
207.2
208.9
(209)
(210)
(222)
8B
[Ar]4s23d104p1 [Ar]4s23d104p2 [Ar]4s23d104p3 [Ar]4s23d104p4 [Ar]4s23d104p5 [Ar]4s23d104p6 gallium germanium arsenic selenium bromine krypton
[Kr]5s24d105p1 [Kr]5s24d105p2 indium tin
83.80
[Kr]5s24d105p3 [Kr]5s24d105p4 [Kr]5s24d105p5 [Kr]5s24d105p6 antimony tellurium iodine xenon
131.3
88
89
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
114
116
118
Ra
Ac ~
Rf
Db
Sg
Bh
Hs
Mt
Ds
Uuu
Uub
Uuq
Uuh
Uuo
1
[Rn] 7s francium
[Rn]7s2 radium
[Rn]7s26d1 actinium
(223)
(226)
(227)
(272)
(277)
(296)
(298)
(?)
Fr
58 Lanthanide series*
Actinide series ~
[Rn]7s25f146d2 [Rn]7s25f146d3 [Rn]7s25f146d4 [Rn]7s25f146d5 [Rn]7s25f146d6 [Rn]7s25f146d7 [Rn]7s15f146d9 rutherfordium dubnium seaborgium bohrium hassium meitnerium darmstadtium
(257)
59
(260)
60
(263)
61
(262)
62
(265)
63
(266)
64
(271)
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
Ce
Pr
Nd
Pm
Sm
Eu
Gd
Tb
Dy
Ho
Er
Tm
Yb
Lu
[Xe]6s24f15d1 cerium
[Xe]6s24f3 praseodymium
[Xe]6s24f4 neodymium
[Xe]6s24f5 promethium
[Xe]6s24f6 samarium
[Xe]6s24f7 europium
[Xe]6s24f75d1 gadolinium
[Xe]6s24f9 terbium
[Xe]6s24f10 dysprosium
[Xe]6s24f11 holmium
[Xe]6s24f12 erbium
[Xe]6s24f13 thulium
[Xe]6s24f14 ytterbium
[Xe]6s24f145d1 lutetium
140.1
140.9
144.2
(147)
(150.4)
152.0
157.3
158.9
162.5
164.9
167.3
168.9
173.0
175.0
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
Th
Pa
U
Np
Pu
Am
Cm
Bk
Cf
Es
Fm
Md
No
Lr
[Rn]7s25f46d1 neptunium
[Rn]7s25f6 plutonium
[Rn]7s25f7 americium
[Rn]7s25f76d1 curium
[Rn]7s25f9 berkelium
[Rn]7s25f10 californium
[Xe]6s24f11 einsteinium
[Rn]7s25f12 fermium
[Rn]7s25f13 mendelevium
[Rn]7s25f14 nobelium
[Rn]7s25f146d1 lawrencium
(237)
(242)
(43)
(247)
(247)
(249)
(254)
(253)
(256)
(254)
(257)
[Rn]7s26d2 thorium
232.0
[Rn]7s25f26d1 [Rn]7s25f36d1 protactinium uranium
(231)
(238)
Liquids at room temperature
Gases at room temperature
Solids at room temperature
Fig. 2.1 The Periodic Table of the elements. Elements named in blue are liquids at room temperature. Elements named in red are
gases at room temperature. Elements named in black are solids at room temperature
19
20
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
rates atoms of other elements into its structure without changing its essential metallic character forms an alloy, which is not a metal since it is not a pure element. The major differences in materials have their origins in the nature of the bonds formed between atoms, which are determined by the manner in which electrons in the highest-energy orbitals interact with one another and by whether the centers of positive and negative charge of the atoms coincide. The work required to remove an ion from the substance in which it resides is a measure of the strength of these bonds. At suitable temperatures and pressures, all elements can exist in all states of matter, although in some cases this is very difficult to achieve experimentally. At ambient temperature and pressure, most elements are solids, some are gases, and a few are liquid. Primary Bonds Primary bonds are the strongest bonds that form among atoms. The manner in which electrons in the highest energy levels interact produces differences in the kinds of primary bonds. Valence electrons occupy the highest energy levels of atoms, called the valence levels. Valence electrons exhibit three basic types of behavior: atoms of electropositive elements yield their valence electrons relatively easily; atoms of electronegative elements readily accept electrons to fill their valence levels; and elements between these extremes can share electrons with neighboring atoms. The valence of an ion is the number of electrons yielded, accepted or shared by each atom in forming the ion. Valence is positive or negative according to whether the ion has a positive (cation) or negative (anion) charge. The behavior of valence electrons gives rise to three types of primary bonds: ionic, covalent and metallic. Ionic bonds occur between ions of strongly electropositive elements and strongly electronegative elements. Each atom of the electropositive element surrenders one or more electrons to one or more atoms of the electronegative element to form oppositely charged ions, which attract one another by the Coulomb force between opposite electrical charges. This exchange of electrons occurs in such a manner that the overall structure remains electrically neutral. To a good approximation, ions involved in ionic bonds behave as charged, essentially incompressible, spheres, which have no characteristic directionality. In contrast, covalent bonds involve sharing of valence electrons between neighboring atoms. This type of bonding occurs when the valence energy levels of the atoms are partially full, corresponding to valences in the vicinity of 4. These bonds
are strongly directional since the orbitals involved are typically nonspherical. In both ionic and covalent bonds nearest-neighbor ions are most strongly involved and the valence electrons are highly localized. Metallic bonds occur in strongly electropositive elements, which surrender their valence electrons to form a negatively charged electron gas or distribution of highly nonlocalized electrons that moves relatively freely throughout the substance. The positively charged ions repel one another but remain relatively stationary because the electron gas acting as glue holds them together. Metallic bonds are relatively nondirectional and the ions are approximately spherical. A major difference between the metallic bond and the ionic and covalent bonds is that it does not involve an exchange or sharing of electrons with nearest neighbors. The bonds in many substances closely approximate the pure bond types described above. However, mixtures of these archetypes occur frequently in nature, and a substance can show bonding characteristics that resemble more than one type. This hybrid bond situation occurs most often in substances that exhibit some characteristics of directional covalent bonds along with nondirectional metallic or ionic bonds. Secondary Bonds Some substances are composed of electrically neutral clusters of ions called molecules. Secondary bonds exist between molecules and are weaker than primary bonds. One type of secondary bond, the van der Waals bond, is due to the weak electrostatic interaction between molecules in which the instantaneous centers of positive and negative charge do not coincide. A molecule consisting of a single ion of an electropositive element and a single ion of an electronegative element, such as a molecule of HCl gas, is a simple example of a diatomic molecule. The center of negative charge of the system coincides with the nucleus of the chlorine ion, but the center of positive charge is displaced from the center of the ion because of the presence of the smaller, positively charged hydrogen ion (a single proton), which resides near the outer orbital of the chlorine ion. This results in the formation of an electrical dipole, which has a short-range attraction to similar dipoles, such as other HCl molecules, at distances of the order of the molecular dimensions. However, no long-range attraction exists since the overall charge of the molecule is zero. The example given is a permanent dipole formed by a spatial separation of centers of charge. A temporary dipole can occur when the instantaneous centers of charge separate because of the motion of electrons.
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
2.1.2 Classification of Materials It is useful to categorize engineering materials in terms either of their functionality or the dominant type of atomic bonding present in the material. Since most materials perform several functions in a component, the classification scheme described in the following sections takes the latter approach. The nature and strength of atomic bonding influences not only the arrangement of atoms in space but also many physical properties such as electrical conductivity, thermal conductivity, and damping capacity. Ceramics Ceramic materials possess bonding that is primarily ionic with varying amounts of metallic or covalent character. The dominant features on the atomic scale are the localization of electrons in the vicinity of the ions and the relative incompressibility of atoms, leading to structures that are characterized by the packing of rigid spheres of various sizes. These materials typically have high melting points (> 1500 K), low thermal and electrical conductivities, high resistance to atmospheric corrosion, and low damping capacity. Mechanical properties of ceramics include high moduli of elasticity, high yield strength, high notch sensitivity, low ductility, low impact resistance, intermediate to low thermal shock resistance, and low fracture toughness. Applications that require resistance to extreme thermal, electrical or chemical environments, with the ability to absorb mechanical energy without catastrophic failure a secondary issue, typically employ ceramics. Metals Metallic materials include pure metals (elements) and alloys that exhibit primarily metallic bonding. The
free electron gas that permeates the lattice of ions causes these materials to exhibit high electrical and thermal conductivity. In addition they possess relatively high yield strengths, high moduli of elasticity, and melting points ranging from nearly room temperature to > 3200 K. Although generally malleable and ductile, they can exhibit extreme brittleness, depending on structure and temperature. One of the most useful features of metallic materials is their ability to be formed into complex shapes using a variety of thermomechanical processes, including melting and casting, hot working in the solid state, and a combination of cold working and annealing. All of these processes produce characteristic microstructures that lead to different combinations of physical and mechanical properties. Applications that require complex shapes having both strength and fracture resistance with moderate resistance to environmental degradation employ metallic materials. Metalloids Metalloids are elements in groups III–V of the periodic table and compounds formed from these elements. Covalent bonding dominates both the elements and compounds in this category. The name arises from the fact that they exhibit behavior intermediate between metals and ceramics. Many are semiconductors, that is, they exhibit an electrical conductivity lower than metals, but useable, which increases rather than decreases with temperature like metals. These materials exhibit high elastic moduli, relatively high melting points, low ductility, and poor formability. Commercially useful forms of these materials require processing by solidification directly from the molten state followed by solid-state treatments that do not involve significant deformation. Metalloids are useful in a variety of applications where sensitivity and response to electromagnetic radiation are important. Polymers Polymeric materials, also generically called plastics, are assemblies of complex molecules consisting of molecular structural units called mers that have a characteristic chemical composition and, often, a variety of spatial configurations. The assemblies of molecules generally take the form of long chains of mers held together by hydrogen bonds or networks of interconnected mers. Most structural polymers are made of mers with an organic basis, i. e., they contain carbon. They are characterized by relatively low strength, low thermal and electrical conductivity, low melting points, often high
21
Part A 2.1
The resulting attraction forms a weak bond at small distances and is typical of van der Waals bonds. The other secondary bond, the hydrogen bond, involves the single valence electron of hydrogen. In materials science and engineering, the most important type of hydrogen bond is that which occurs in polymers, which consist of long chains or networks of chemically identical units called mers. When the composition of a mer includes hydrogen, it is possible for the hydrogen atom to share its valence electron with identical mers in neighboring chains, so that the hydrogen atom is partly in one chain and partly in another. This sharing of the hydrogen atom creates a hydrogen bond between the chains. The bond is relatively weak but is an important factor in the behavior of polymeric materials.
2.1 Structure of Materials
22
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
ductility, and high formability by a variety of techniques. These materials are popular as electrical and thermal insulators and for structural applications that do not require high strength or exposure to high temperatures. Their principal advantages are relatively low cost, high formability, and resistance to most forms of atmospheric degradation. Composites Composite materials consist of those formed by intimate combinations of the other classes. Composites combine the advantages of two or more material classes by forming a hybrid material that exhibits certain desirable features of the constituents. Generally, one type of material predominates, forming a matrix containing a distribution of one or more other types on a microscale. A familiar example is glass-reinforced plastic (GRP), known by the commercial name of R . In this material, the high elastic modulus Fibreglass of the glass fibers (a ceramic) reinforces the toughness and formability of the polymeric matrix. Other classes of composites have metal matrices with ceramic dispersions (metal matrix composites, MMC), ceramic matrices with various types of additions (ceramic matrix composites, CMC), and polymeric matrices with metallic or ceramic additions. The latter, generically known as organic matrix composites (OMC) or polymer matrix composites (PMC), are important structural materials for aerospace applications.
2.1.3 Atomic Order Crystalline and Amorphous Materials The structure of materials at the atomic level can be highly ordered or nearly random, depending on the nature of the bonding and the thermomechanical history. Pure elements that exist in the solid state at ambient temperature and pressure always exhibit at least one form that is highly ordered in the sense that the surroundings of each atom are identical. Crystalline materials exhibit this locally ordered arrangement over large distances, creating long-range order. The formal definition of a crystal is a substance in which the structure surrounding each basis unit, an atom or molecule, is identical. That is, if one were able to observe the atomic or molecular arrangement from the vantage point of a single structural unit, the view would not depend on the location or orientation of the structural unit within the material. All metals and ceramic compounds and some polymeric materials have crystalline forms. Some ma-
terials can exhibit more than one crystalline form, called allotropes, depending on the temperature and pressure. It is this property of iron with small amounts of carbon dissolved that is the basis for the heat treatment of steel, which provides a wide range of properties. At the other extreme of atomic arrangement are amorphous materials. These materials can exhibit local order of structural units, but the arrangement a large number of such units is haphazard or random. There are two principal categories of amorphous structures: network structures and chain structures. The molecules of network structures lie at the nodes of an irregular network, like a badly constructed jungle gym. Nevertheless, the network has a high degree of connectivity and if the molecules are not particularly mobile, the network can be very stable. This type of structure is characteristic of most glasses. Materials possessing this structure possess a relatively rigid mechanical response at low temperatures, but become more fluid and deformable at elevated temperatures. Frequently the transition between the relatively rigid, low-temperature form and the more fluid high-temperature form occurs over a narrow temperature range. By convention the midpoint of this transition range defines the glasstransition temperature. Linear chain structures are characteristic of polymeric materials made of long chains of mers. Relatively weak hydrogen bonds and/or van der Waals bonds hold these chains together. The chains can move past one another with varying degrees of difficulty depending on the geometry of the molecular arrangement along the chain and the temperature. An individual chain can possess short-range order, but the collections of chains that comprise the substance sprawl haphazardly, like a bowl of spaghetti. Under certain conditions of formation, however, the chains can arrange themselves into a pattern with long-range order, giving rise to crystalline forms of polymeric materials. In addition, some elements, specific to the particular polymer, can bond with adjacent chains, creating a three-dimensional network structure. The addition of sulfur to natural rubber in the R is an example. process called Vulcanizing Materials that can exist in both the crystalline and amorphous states can also have intermediate, metastable structures in which these states coexist. Glass that has devitrified has microscopic crystalline regions dispersed in an amorphous network matrix. Combinations of heat treatment and mechanical deformation can alter the relative amounts of these structures, and the overall properties of the material.
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
metric compound contains ions exactly in the ratios that produce electrical neutrality of the substance. In binary (two-component) compounds, the ratio of the number of ions of each kind present is the inverse of the ratio of the absolute values of their valences. For example, Na2 O has two sodium atoms for each oxygen atom. Since the valence of sodium is +1 and that of oxygen is −2, the 2 : 1 ratio of sodium to oxygen ions produces electrical neutrality of the structure.
Cubic
Simple
Body-centered
Tetragonal
Simple
Face-centered
Monoclinic
Body-centered
Simple
End-centered
Orthohombic
Simple Rhombohedral
Body-centered Hexagonal
Fig. 2.2 Bravais lattices and crystal systems
Face-centered
End-centered Triclinic
23
Part A 2.1
Crystal Structures of Elements and Compounds Because ionic bonds require ions of at least two elements, either metallic or covalent bonds join ions of pure elements in the solid state, although the condensed forms of highly electronegative elements and the inert gases exhibit weak short-range bonding typical of van der Waals bonds. Chemical compounds, which can exhibit ionic bonding as well as the other types of strong bonds, form when atoms of two or more elements combine in specific ratios. A stoichio-
2.1 Structure of Materials
24
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
In the solid state, patterns of atoms and molecules form lattices, which are three-dimensional arrays of points having the property that the surroundings of each lattice point are identical to those of any other lattice point. There are only 14 unique lattices, the Bravais lattices, shown in Fig. 2.2. Each lattice possesses three non-coplanar, non-collinear axes and a characteristic, unique array of lattice points occupied by structural units, which can be individual atoms or identical clusters of atoms, depending on the nature of the substance. The relative lengths of the repeat distance of lattice points along each axis and the angles that the axes make with one another define the seven crystal systems. Figure 2.2 also shows the crystal system for each of the Bravais lattices. Each of the illustrations in Fig. 2.2 represents the unit cell for the lattice, which is the smallest arrangement of lattice points that possesses the geometric characteristics of the extended structure. Repeating one of the figures in Fig. 2.2 indefinitely throughout space with an appropriately chosen structural unit at each lattice point defines a crystal structure. Lattice parameters include the angles between coordinate axes, if variable, and the dimensions of the unit cell, which contains one or more lattice points. To determine the number of points associated with a unit cell, count 1/8 for each corner point, 1/2 for each point on a face, and 1 for each point entirely within the cell. A primitive unit cell contains only one lattice point (one at each corner). The coordination number Z is the number of nearest neighbors to a lattice point. One of the most important characteristics of crystal lattices is symmetry, the property by which certain rigid-body motions bring the lattice into an equivalent configuration indistinguishable from the initial configuration. Symmetry operations occur by rotations about an axis, reflections across a plane or a combination of rotations, and translations along an axis. For example, a plane across which the structure is a mirror image of that on the opposite side is a mirror plane. An axis about which a rotation of 2π/n brings the lattice into coincidence forms an n-fold axis of symmetry. This characteristic of crystals has profound implications on certain physical properties. The geometry of the lattice provides a natural coordinate system for describing directions and planes using the axes of the unit cell as coordinate axes and the lattice parameters as units of measure. Principal crystallographic axes and directions are those parallel to the edges of the unit cell. A vector connecting two lattice points defines a lattice direction. A set of
three integers having no common factor that are in the same ratio as the direction cosines, relative to the coordinate axes, of such a vector characterizes the lattice direction. Square brackets, e.g., [100], denote specific crystallographic directions, while the same three integers enclosed by carats, e.g., 100, describe families of directions. Directions are crystallographically equivalent if they possess an identical arrangement of lattice points. Families of directions in the cubic crystal system are crystallographically equivalent, but those in noncubic crystals may not be because of differences in the lattice parameters. The Miller indices, another set of three integers determined in a different manner, specify crystallographic planes. The notation arose from the observation by 19th century crystallographers on naturally occurring crystals that the reciprocals of the intercepts of crystal faces with the principal crystallographic axes occurred in the ratios of small, whole numbers. To determine the Miller indices of a plane, first obtain the intercepts of the plane with each of the principal crystallographic directions. Then take the reciprocals of these intercepts and find the three smallest integers with no common factor that have the same ratios to one another as the reciprocals of the intercepts. Enclosed in parentheses, these are the Miller indices of the plane. For example, the (120) plane has intercepts of 1, 1/2, and ∞, in units of the lattice parameters, along the three principal crystallographic directions. Families of planes are those having the same three integers in different permutations, including negatives, as their Miller indices. Braces enclose the Miller indices of families, e.g., {120}. Crystallographically equivalent planes have the same density and distribution of lattice points. In cubic crystals, families of planes are crystallographically equivalent. Although there are examples of all of the crystal structures in naturally occurring materials, a relatively few suffice to describe common engineering materials. All metals are either body-centered cubic (bcc), facecentered cubic (fcc) or hexagonal close-packed (hcp). The latter two structures consist of different stacking sequences of closely packed planes containing identical spheres or ellipsoids, representing the positive ions in the metallic lattice. Figure 2.3 shows a plane of spheres packed as closely as possible in a plane. An identical plane fitted as compactly as possible on top of or below this plane occupies one of two possible locations, corresponding to the depressions between the spheres. These locations correspond to the upright and inverted triangular spaces between spheres in the figure. The same option exists when placing a third
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
B-layer C-layer
Fig. 2.3 Plane of close-packed spheres
c
a
Fig. 2.4 Hexagonal close-packed unit cell
which is not a close-packed structure. Figure 2.6 shows the unit cell of this structure. The structure has a coordination number of eight and the unit cell contains two atoms. The density of a crystalline material follows from its crystal structure and the dimensions of its unit cell. By definition, density is mass per unit volume. For a unit cell this becomes the number of atoms in a unit cell n times the mass of the atom, divided by the cell volume Ω: ρ=
nA . Ω N0
25
Part A 2.1
identical plane on the second plane, but now two distinct situations arise depending on whether the third plane is exactly over the first or displaced from it in the other possible stacking location. In the first case, when the first and third planes are directly over one another, the stacking sequence is characteristic of hexagonal close-packed structures and is indicated ABAB. . . The close-packed, or basal, planes are normal to an axis of sixfold symmetry. Figure 2.4 shows the conventional unit cell for the hcp structure. Based on the hexagonal cell of the Bravais lattice, this unit cell contains two atoms. The c/a ratio is the height of the cell divided by the length of the side of the regular hexagon forming the base.√If the ions are perfect spheres, this ratio is 1.6333 = (8/3). In this instance, the coordination number of the structure is 12. However, most metals that exhibit this structure have c/a ratios different from this ideal value, indicating that oblate or prolate ellipsoids are more accurate than spheres as models for the atoms. Consequently, the coordination number is a hybrid quantity consisting of six atoms in the basal plane and six atoms at nearly the same distances in adjacent basal planes. Nevertheless, the conventional value for the coordination number of the hcp structure is 12 regardless of the c/a ratio. When the third plane in a close-packed structure occurs in an orientation that is not directly above the first, the stacking produces a face-centered cubic (fcc) structure. The sequence ABCABC. . . represents this stacking. The {111} planes are close-packed in this structure, the coordination number is 12, and the unit cell contains four atoms, as shown in Fig. 2.5. The third crystal structure typical of metallic elements and alloys is the body-centered cubic structure,
2.1 Structure of Materials
(2.1)
The mass of an atom is the atomic weight, A, divided by Avogadro’s number, N0 = 6.023 × 1023 , which is the number of atoms or molecules in one gram-atomic or gram-molecular, respectively, weight of a substance. The (8 − N) rule classifies crystal structures of elements that bond principally by covalent bonds, where N (≥ 4) is the number of the element’s group in the Periodic Table. The rule states that the element forms a crystal structure characterized by a coordination number of (8 − N). Thus, silicon in group 4 forms a crystal
Fig. 2.5 Face-centered cubic unit cell and {111} plane
26
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
Fig. 2.6 Unit cell of bcc structure
that has four nearest neighbors. Crystal structures based on this rule can be quite complex. Ionic compounds are composed of cations and anions formed from two or more kinds of atoms. These compounds form crystal structures based on two principles: (1) the entire structure must be electrically neutral and (2) the ions can be regarded as relatively rigid spheres of differing sizes forming a three-dimensional structure based on the efficient packing of different size spheres. The radius ratio rule is the principle that describes the crystal structures of many ionic compounds. This rule specifies the coordination number Z which gives the most efficient packing for spheres whose radius ratios are in a particular range. The radius ratio R employed for this calculation is the radius of the cation to that of the anion. Table 2.1 illustrates the relationship of this ratio to the resulting lattice geometry. Defects in Crystals The structures described in the previous sections are idealized descriptions that accurately characterize the arrangement of the vast majority of atomic and molecular arrangements in materials. Within any substance there will exist irregularities or defects in the structure that profoundly influence many of the properties of the material. These defects can exist on the electronic, atomic or molecular scale, depending on the substance. A common classification scheme for atomic and molecular defects in materials utilizes their dimensionality. Point defects have dimensions comparable to an atom or molecule. Line defects have an appreciable
extent along a linear path in the material, but essentially atomic dimensions in directions normal to that path. Surface defects have appreciable extent on a surface in two dimensions, but essentially atomic extent normal to the surface. Surface defects are regions of high local atomic disorder. This characteristic makes them prone to higher chemical activity than the regions that they bound. In addition, the local disorder associated with the boundaries has different mechanical properties than the bulk. These two features of surface defects cause them to be extremely important in affecting the mechanical and often the chemical properties of materials. Volume defects occur over volumes of several tens to several millions of atoms. The scale of these defects is generally at the mesoscale and above. The simplest kind of point defect occurs when an atom of a pure substance is missing from a lattice site. The vacant lattice site is a vacancy. Atoms of an element that leave their lattice sites and attempt to share a lattice site with another atom form interstitialcies. Clearly, interstitialcies are closely associated with vacancies. This combination typically occurs under conditions of neutron radiation, and the associated damage is a limiting factor to the use of materials in such environments. A lattice site occupied by an atom different from the host is a substitutional impurity, creating a substitutional solid solution with the host as solvent and the impurity as solute. The concentration of such impurities that a host element can tolerate is dependent in large part on the relative sizes of the impurity and the host atoms. Typically, solid solubility is extremely limited if the atomic sizes of solute and solvent differ by more than 15%. Interstitial solid solutions occur when smaller solvent atoms occupy some of the spaces (interstices) between solute atoms. Only five elements – C, N, O, H, and B – can be interstitial solutes in metals, principally because of the relative sizes of the atoms involved. The systematic or random insertion into linear polymers of mers having different chemical compositions forms copolymers. Since the substituent mers constitute a disruption in the basic polymer chain, they are substi-
Table 2.1 Radius ratios and crystal lattice geometry Z
R
2 3 4 6 8
0.000–0.155 0.155–0.225 0.225–0.414 0.414–0.732 0.732–1.000
Exact range √ 0 to 23 3 − 1 √ √ 2 1 3 √3 − 1 to √ 2 6−1 1 2−1 2 6 − 1 to √ √ 2 − 1 to 3 − 1 √ 3 − 1 to 1
Lattice geometry Linear Trigonal planar Tetrahedral Octahedral Cubic
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
the region of the crystal that has experienced slip from that which has not. This boundary forms a linear crystal defect called a dislocation. As a dislocation passes over its slip plane, one part of the crystal moves relative to the other by a lattice vector, the Burgers vector, which is generally, but not always, one atomic spacing in the direction of the highest density of atoms. Dislocations are an important source of internal stress in crystalline materials and their motion is the principal mechanism of permanent deformation. Further information on the behavior of dislocations can be found in standard references [2.5, 6]. Homogeneous crystalline materials generally consist of an aggregate of grains, which are microscopic crystalline regions having differing orientations. That is, the principal crystallographic directions in each grain have different orientations relative to an external coordinate system than corresponding directions in neighboring grains. Grain boundaries, which are surfaces across which grain orientations change discontinuously, separate the grains. Since the grain boundaries contain most of the atomic disorder that accommodates the orientation change, they are surface defects. Grain boundaries permeate the material, forming a three-dimensional network that has a shape and topology determined by its thermomechanical history. Close-packed crystal structures, such as facecentered cubic and hexagonal close-packed, exhibit another form of surface defect called a stacking fault. This occurs when local conditions of deformation or crystal growth produce a stacking sequence that is locally different from that for the crystal structure. For example, suppose the stacking sequence of closepacked planes in the sequence ABC|ABC. . . is locally disrupted across the surface indicated by the vertical line so that to the left of the line the crystal is shifted to cause A planes to assume B stacking, B planes to assume C stacking and C planes to assume A stacking. Then the stacking sequence would be ABC|BCA. . . This is topologically equivalent to the removal of a plane of A stacking, creating a three-layer hcp structure while preserving the face-centered cubic structure on either side of the fault plane. Such a configuration is an intrinsic stacking fault and is associated with the formation and motion of certain kinds of dislocations in face-centered cubic crystals. Materials can also consist of an aggregate of regions having differing chemical composition and crystal structure from one another. Each region that is chemically and physically distinct and separated from the rest of the system by a boundary is called a phase. Each
27
Part A 2.1
tutional point defects in the same sense as solute atoms in a solid solution. The semiconducting properties of metalloids are due to the thermal excitation of electrons from filled valence bands into sparsely populated conduction bands. In a pure substance, this behavior is intrinsic semiconductivity. The addition of small amounts of impurities (of the order of one impurity atom per million host atoms) that have a different chemical valence significantly modifies the electrical conductivity of many such substances. These substitutional impurities, which are electronic defects as well as lattice defects, contribute additional electronic energy states that can contribute to conductivity. This is extrinsic semiconductivity. A donor impurity has more valence electrons than the host does, and contributes electron energy states. Acceptor impurities have a lower valence than the host, leaving holes, which can contribute to the transport of electrical charge, in the valence energy band. The holes are defects in the electronic structure having equal and opposite charges to the electrons. Point defects in ionic compounds must maintain electrical neutrality. One or more defects possessing equal and opposite charges must be present to cancel any local charge caused by the addition or removal of ions from lattice sites. One such defect is the Frenkel defect, a cation vacancy associated with a nearby cation interstitial. The excess charge created by the interstitial cation balances the charge deficiency due to the vacancy. In principle, such defects are possible with anions replacing cations, but the relatively large size of anions generally precludes the existence of anion interstitials. The other important type of point defect in ionic materials is the Schottky defect, which is a cation vacancy–anion vacancy pair where the ions have equal and opposite charges. Clearly, the removal of an electrically neutral unit maintains local electrical neutrality. Both types of defects can affect electrical and mechanical properties of the substance. Permanent deformation that preserves the number of lattice sites in crystalline materials generally occurs by slip, also called glide, which is the motion of one part of the crystal relative to the other across a densely populated atomic plane, the slip plane, in a densely populated atomic direction, the slip direction. For energetic reasons this motion does not occur simultaneously across the entire crystal, but commences at a free surface or region of high internal stress and propagates over the atomic plane until it either passes out of the crystal or encounters a barrier to further motion. At any instant during this propagation, a boundary separates
2.1 Structure of Materials
28
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
phase can contain a network of grain boundaries. However, the interphase boundaries that separate the phases are surface defects that differ from grain boundaries, since the regions they separate differ in not only spatial orientation and chemical composition but also, in most cases, in crystal structure. A multiphase material has a system of interphase boundaries whose extent and topology depend not only on the thermomechanical history of the material but also on the relative amounts of the phases present. Cracks and voids caused by solidification are examples of volume defects. These often arise during processing and can be significant sources of mechanical weakness and vulnerability to environmental attack of the material. Gases formed during fission of nuclear fuel can also form internal voids during operation, causing swelling and distortion on a macroscopic scale.
2.1.4 Equilibrium and Kinetics Thermodynamic Principles The overall composition and processing history determine the arrangements of groups of atoms in the microstructure. The resulting structure of the material determines its response to many conditions of measurement. Concepts of thermodynamic equilibrium, the rate of approach to equilibrium, and the response of the material to its physical and mechanical environment govern relationships that connect composition, processing, and microstructure. A thermodynamic system is any collection of items separated from their surroundings by a real or imaginary interface, which can be permeable or impermeable to the exchange of energy. Thermodynamics is the study of the laws that govern
1. the exchange of energy between the system and its surroundings 2. the energy content of such a system 3. the capacity of the system to do work and 4. the direction of heat flow in the system. The sum of the kinetic and potential energies of all components of the system is the internal energy U, which measures the energy content of a system. The first law of thermodynamics relates the rate of change of internal energy of a system to the rate of heat exchange with the surroundings and the rate of work done by external forces U˙ = Q˙ − P ,
(2.2)
where Q˙ represents the rate of heat exchanged with the surroundings, P is the power exerted by external forces, and the superposed dot indicates the derivative with respect to time. The second law of thermodynamics states that the rate of production of entropy S at an absolute temperature T , defined as Q˙ (2.3) , T must be ≥ 0. For a real system, changes in S refer to changes from a standard temperature and pressure. The internal energy less the product of the volume of the system V and the pressure on the system, P, is the heat content or enthalpy H. The relationship connecting these thermodynamic state variables is S˙ =
H = U + PV .
(2.4)
The definition of free energy, which is the capacity of the system to do work, differs when dealing with gaseous and condensed systems of matter. The Gibbs free energy G employed for condensed systems is related to other thermodynamic variables by G = H − TS .
(2.5)
The following discussion designates free energy by F without reference to the state of the system. Changes in the free energy of a system occur when variables that define the state of the system do work on the system. Gradients in the free energy of a system with respect to these state variables are generalized thermodynamic forces characterized by adjectives that describe the nature of the variable – chemical, thermal, mechanical, electrical, etc. – giving rise to the force. Absolute equilibrium exists when these forces sum vectorially to zero, i. e., the free energy of the system is an absolute minimum. A system in equilibrium with one or more type of force, while not being in equilibrium with others, is in a state of partial equilibrium. Equilibria can be stable, metastable or unstable. If small changes in the thermodynamic forces tend to alter the state of the system from its equilibrium condition, the equilibrium is unstable. If such changes tend to restore the system to its equilibrium state, the equilibrium is stable if the original state represents an absolute minimum in the free energy of the system or metastable if the minimum is local. These concepts are illustrated in Fig. 2.7, which depicts various states of mechanical equilibrium. Although materials are rarely in thermodynamic equilibrium with their surroundings during engineering applications, the extent of deviation from its equilibrium state determines the propensity of a structure to change
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
with time. Since changes in structure cause changes in properties, the suitability of a material for a particular engineering application may also change.
2.1 Structure of Materials
29
Force ΔF *
P = exp(−ΔF ∗ /kT ) ,
(2.6)
when ΔF ∗ is expressed per atom or mole of the substance. In (2.6) k is Boltzmann’s constant, the universal gas constant per atom or molecule. The Arrhenius equation expresses the rate of change of many chemical reactions and solid-state processes: r = ν0 exp(−ΔF ∗ /kT ,
m n (a)
Phase Diagrams The structure of engineering materials at the microscale generally consists of regions that are physically and chemically distinct from one another, separated from the rest of the system by interfaces. These regions are called phases. The spatial distribution and, to a limited extent, the chemical composition of phases can be altered by thermomechanical processing prior to the end use of the material. Sometimes service conditions
m y
(b)
l
m
(c)
x
Fig. 2.7 (a) Metastable, (b) unstable, and (c) stable mechanical equilibrium states for a brick (after Barrett et al. [2.7])
can cause changes in the microstructure of a material, usually with accompanying changes in properties. Knowledge of the phases present in a material at various temperatures, pressures, and compositions is essential to the prediction of its engineering properties and to assessing its propensity for change under service conditions. The phase diagram, a map of the thermodynamically stable phases present at various temperatures, pressures, and compositions, presents this information in a graphical form. The number of degrees of freedom f (≥ 0) of a system refers to the number of environmental and composition variables that can be changed without changing the number of phases in equilibrium. The phase rule relates f to the number of distinct chemical species or components C and the number of phases present Φ: f = C −Φ+2 ,
(2.7)
in which the rate of change r is the product of the frequency of attempts at change ν0 and P is the probability of a successful attempt. Figure 2.8 illustrates the process schematically for the case of a thermally activated process assisted by external stress.
ΔF
l
(2.8)
ΔF (1-3) ΔF * (1) ΔF
(1-2)
(3)
(2) A*
A(1-2)
A0
Fig. 2.8 Free energy (F) versus slipped area ( A0 ) for deformation processes
Part A 2.1
Rate of Approach to Equilibrium In order for a system that is in metastable equilibrium in its current state (state 1) to attain the (stable or metastable) equilibrium state with the next lowest free energy (state 2), passage through an unstable equilibrium state (state 3) whose free energy is higher than that of states 1 or 2 is generally required. State 3 is an activated state and constitutes a barrier to the transition of the system from state 1 to the lower free energy of state 2. The free energy difference between states 1 and state 3 ΔF (1−3) must be supplied by internal and external sources in order to effect the transition from the metastable state to the activated state, from which subsequent transition to the next lower energy state is assumed to be spontaneous. The nature of the barrier determines the free energy difference. The free energy ΔF (1−3) contains both thermal energy and work done by external fields during activation. The difference between ΔF (1−3) and the work done by external sources is called the free energy of activation ΔF ∗ . The Boltzmann factor P is the probability that the system will change its state from state 1 to state 3
30
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
where 2 refers to temperature and pressure. The degrees of freedom in phase diagrams of condensed systems at constant pressure (isobaric diagrams) is given by a form of equation (2.6) in which 2 is replaced by 1, since the pressure is fixed. Either the weight percent or atomic percent of the components specifies the composition of a multicomponent system. In many engineering applications, weight percent is preferred as a more practical guide to the relative amounts of components. In scientific studies of the nature of diagrams formed from elements having similar chemical characteristics, atomic fraction is preferred. For an ncomponent system, the weight percent of component i can be calculated from its atomic percent by the relation (a/o)i (at.wt.)i × 100% , (2.9) (w/o)i = n (a/o) j (at.wt.) j j=1
where (a/o) and (w/o) are the atomic percent and weight percent, respectively, and at.wt. refers to the atomic weight of the subscripted substance. The summation extends over all components. A similar expression relates the atomic percent of a component to the weight percents and atomic weights of the components. It is impossible to represent a phase diagram in three dimensions for a material consisting of more than three components. More commonly, diagrams that show the stable phases for a two-component (binary) system at one atmosphere pressure and various temperatures are used as guides to predict the stable phases. This permits a two-dimensional map with temperature as the ordinate and composition as the abscissa to represent the possible structures. ASM International offers an extensive compilation of binary phase diagrams of metals [2.8]. A similar compilation is available for ceramic systems [2.9]. Three-component (ternary) phase diagrams are more difficult to represent since they require two independent compositional variables in addition to temperature. The most common three-dimensional representation is a prism in which the component compositions are plotted on an equilateral triangle base and the temperature on an axis normal to the base. Ternary diagrams of many metallic systems have been determined are available as a compilation similar to that for the binary systems [2.10]. Phase diagrams not only give information on the number and composition of phases present in equilibrium, but also provide the data necessary to calculate the relative amounts of phases present at any temperature. Figure 2.9 illustrates this principle, the inverse lever law, using the silver–copper binary diagram as an example.
From this diagram we note that an alloy of 28.1 w/o Cu solidifies at 779.1 ◦ C into a solid consisting of two solid phases: a silver-rich phase α containing 8.8 w/o Cu and a copper-rich phase β containing 92.0 w/o Cu. This alloy, which passes directly from the liquid state to the solid state without going through a region of solid and liquid in equilibrium, is a eutectic. To determine how much of each phase is present in the eutectic alloy at the solidification temperature, we note that, while the overall composition of the alloy c0 is 28.1 w/o Cu, it is a mixture of copper- and silver-rich phases, each having a known composition. Performing a mass balance on the amount of copper in the alloy yields the result: cβ − c0 × 100% (%)α = cβ − cα (92 − 28.1) × 100% = 76.8% (2.10) = (92 − 8.8) for the weight percentage of the silver-rich phase in the alloy. The inverse lever law gets its name from the fact that the numerator in (2.10) is the distance on the composition axis from the overall alloy composition to the composition of the copper-rich phase cβ on the opposite side of the diagram from the silver-rich phase whose percentage is to be determined. The denominator is the entire distance between the compositions of the copperrich and silver-rich phases. The calculation is analogous to balancing the relative amounts of the phases on a lever whose fulcrum is at the overall alloy composition. While the numerical result shown illustrates the calculation for the eutectic alloy and temperature, the principle applies to any constant temperature as long as we choose the appropriate overall alloy composition Temperature (°C) 1200 1100 Liquid 1000 961.93 °C 900 800 8.8 % 28.1 % 700 (Ag) 600 500 400 300 200 Ag 10 20 30 40 50
1084.87 °C
(Cu) 779.1°C 92 %
60
70
80 90 Cu wt % copper
Fig. 2.9 Silver–copper phase diagram at 1 atm pressure
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
and the compositions of the phases in equilibrium at that temperature.
2.1.5 Observation and Characterization of Structure
Metallographic techniques Metallographic approaches to studying the structure of materials are either surface techniques or transmission techniques. Surface techniques rely on images formed by the reflection of a source of illumination by a prepared surface. The wavelength of the illuminating radiation and the optical properties of the observation system determine the resolution of the technique. Optical metallography employs a reflecting microscope and illumination by visible light to examine the polished and etched surface of a specimen either cut from bulk material or prepared on the surface of a sample, taking care not to introduce damage during the preparation. Consequently, the examination is generally a destructive technique. Magnifications up to approximately 1200 × are possible with careful specimen preparation. Properly chosen etches reveal the arrangement of grain boundaries, phases and defects intersected by the plane of polish. Contrast arises from the differing reflectivities of the constituents of the microstructure. Interpretation of micrographs to relate the observed structure to the properties and behavior of the material requires experience and knowledge of the composition and thermomechanical history of the material. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) employs a beam of electrons as an illuminating source [2.11]. The de Broglie wavelength of an electron is λ = h/ p, where h is Planck’s constant and p is the momentum of the electron. The de Broglie wavelength of electrons varies with the accelerating voltage V since for an electron eV = p2 /2m, where e and m are the charge and mass, respectively, of the electron. Electromagnetic lenses use the charge on the electron beam to condense, focus, and magnify it. Magnifications ob-
tained by this technique range from those characteristic of optical microscopy to nearly 100 times the best resolution obtained from optical techniques. Contrast among microconstituents arises because of their differing scattering powers for electrons. Since electron optics permits a much greater depth of field than is possible with visible light, SEM is the observation tool of choice for examining surfaces with a high degree of spatial irregularity, such as those produced by fracture. While the images are nearly always two-dimensional sections through three-dimensional structures, stereo microscopy is widely used in the examination of fracture surfaces. Although this method can employ an appreciable range of wavelengths, it is necessary to operate in a vacuum and to provide a means of dissipating any electrical charge on the specimen induced by the electron beam. In recent years, the development of special environmental chambers has permitted the observation of nonconductive materials at atmospheric pressure. Transmission metallographic techniques produce images that are the projection of the content of the irradiated volume on the plane of observation. Clearly, such techniques rely on the transparency of the material to the illumination. This requires the preparation of thin sections of the material, followed by treatments to improve the contrast of structural features, then observed by transmission microscopy. Visible light generally suffices as the illuminating source for biological materials. Since most engineering materials are not transparent to visible light, observation by transmitted radiation is less common for these materials. The following section discusses both of the principal exceptions, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and x-ray radiography. Information obtained from metallographic observations serves a variety of purposes: to determine the microstructural state of a material at various stages of processing, to reveal the condition of material in a failed engineering part, and to obtain a semiquantitative estimate of some types of material behavior. All cases where the images represent plane sections require analysis by stereological techniques to obtain quantitative information that for relating structure to properties [2.12]. For a microstructure containing two or more microconstituents, such as phases, inclusions or internal cavities, the simplest parametric characterization is the volume fraction VV (n) of the n-th microconstituent. It is easily shown that this is also equal to the area fraction A A (n) of the n-th constituent on an observation plane, which can easily be measured on a polished metallographic specimen [2.12].
31
Part A 2.1
In order to implement in the selection and design of materials and processes the axiom that structure at various levels determines the properties of materials, it is necessary to have means of examining, measuring, and describing quantitatively the structure at various scales. The information so obtained then leads to the development, validation, and verification of models that describe the behavior of engineering structures. The following sections describe two types of characterization techniques that are useful for this purpose.
2.1 Structure of Materials
32
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.1
Another common measurement of microstructure is the mean linear intercept Λ(t) or its reciprocal PL (t), the intercept density, of a test line parallel to the unit vector t with the traces of internal boundary surfaces on an observation plane. The intercept density is the number of intersections per unit length of the test line with the feature of interest. Since microstructures are generally anisotropic PL (t) depends on the orientation of the test line. The volume average of all measurements is an average intercept density, PL ; its reciprocal is the mean linear intercept Λ. The grain size refers to the mean linear intercept of test lines with grain boundaries. When employing this terminology, remember that the measurement is actually the mean distance between grain boundaries in the plane of measurement and may not apply to the three-dimensional structure. In addition, the concept of size implies an assumption of shape, which is not included in the measurement. Nevertheless Λ remains the most widely used quantitative characterization of microstructure in the materials literature. Similar measurements can be made of the intersections of test lines with interphase boundaries and internal cavities, or pores. The associated mean linear intercepts are phase diameters or pore diameters, respectively. The intercept density for a particular class of boundaries also measures the total boundary area per unit volume SV through the fundamental equation of stereology: SV = 2 PL .
(2.11)
This quantity is important when studying properties influenced by phenomena that occur at internal boundaries. Diffraction Techniques In an irradiated array of atoms, each atom acts as a scattering center, both absorbing and re-radiating the incident radiation as spherical wavelets having the same wavelength as the incident wave. When the wavelength of the incident radiation is comparable to the spacing between atoms, interference effects can occur among the scattered wavelets. A crystalline material acts as a regular array of scattering centers, and produces a pattern of scattered radiation that is characteristic of the array and the wavelength of the radiation. Amorphous materials also produce scattering, but the lack of long-range atomic order precludes the development of patterns of diffracted beams. Diffracted rays occur by the constructive interference of radiation reflected from atomic planes. The model proposed by W. H. Bragg and W. L. Bragg, illustrated in Fig. 2.10, describes the phenomenon.
Radiation of wavelength λ is incident at an angle θ on parallel atomic planes separated by a distance d. Scattered radiation from adjacent planes interferes constructively, producing a scattered beam of radiation, when the path difference between rays scattered from adjacent planes is an integral number n of wavelengths. The relationship describing this phenomenon is Bragg’s law, nλ = 2d · sin θ ,
(2.12)
which is the basis for all measurements of the atomic dimensions of crystals. X-rays, a highly energetic electromagnetic radiation having a wavelength the same order of magnitude as the spacing between atoms in crystals, inspired the original derivation of (2.12) [2.13, 14]. If the crystal is sufficiently thin to permit diffracted beams to penetrate it, transmission diffraction patterns occur on the side of the crystal opposite to the incident radiation. However, even if the diffracted beams cannot penetrate the crystal, back-reflection diffraction patterns occur on the same side as the incident beam. Crystal structure analysis employs both types of patterns. One method of identifying unknown materials employs analysis of diffraction patterns formed by radiation of known wavelength to determine the lattice parameter and crystal structure of an unknown substance, which is then compared with a database of known substances for identification [2.15, 16]. Both incident and diffracted X-radiation can penetrate substantial thicknesses of many materials, rendering this diffraction technique useful for determining the condition of material in the interior of an engineering part. Lattice distortion giving rise to internal stress, averaged over the irradiated volume, can be determined by comparing the interplanar spacings of a material containing internal stress with those of a material free of internal stress [2.17]. This technique of x-ray stress analysis is extremely valuable in deter-
θ
θ θ d
Fig. 2.10 Derivation of Bragg’s law
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
trons and neutrons, which have de Broglie wavelengths comparable to the interatomic spacing of the crystals. Electron beams are employed in both transmission and back-reflection modes to reveal information on the crystal structure and defect content of materials. The fact that electron beams possess electrical charge makes it possible to employ electromagnetic lenses to condense, focus, and magnify them. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) uses diffracted electron beams transmitted through material and subsequently magnified to reveal features of atomic dimensions [2.21]. Since electron beams are highly absorbed by most materials, specimens examined in TEM are only a few thousand atoms thick. Nevertheless, this technique reveals much useful information about the nature and behavior of dislocations, grain boundaries and other atomic-scale defects. Orientation imaging microscopy (OIM) [2.22] employs back-reflection electron diffraction patterns to form maps called pole figures by determining the orientation of individual grains. These maps describe the orientation distribution of grains in a material, which is a major cause of the anisotropy of many bulk properties. The greater penetrating power of neutron beams reveals information from greater thicknesses of material than x-rays [2.23]. Since these beams are not electrically charged, their magnification by electromagnetic lenses is not possible. Therefore, their principal use is for measurements of changes in lattice spacings due to internal stresses, and not for forming images. In addition to revealing the structure of materials, many advanced techniques reveal not only the structure but also the chemistry of a substance at the microscale. While techniques such as the three-dimensional (3-D) atom probe, Auger electron spectroscopy and imaging, Z-contrast microscopy, and many others complement those for structural examination and often employ similar physical principles; a complete survey is beyond the scope of this review.
2.2 Properties of Materials Material properties are attributes that relate applied fields to response fields induced in the material. Applied and induced fields can be of any tensorial rank [2.24, 25]. Fields are conjugate to one another if the applied field does an incremental amount of work on the system by causing an incremental change in the induced field. External fields and the associated field variables include temperature T , stress τ, and electrical (E) and
magnetic (H) fields; their respective conjugate fields are entropy S, strain ε, electrical displacement D, and magnetic induction B. Cross-effects occur when changes in an applied field cause changes in induced fields that are not conjugate to the applied field. Consider a system subjected to a cyclic change of applied field variables such that each variable changes arbitrarily while the others are constant, then the pro-
33
Part A 2.2
mining residual stresses in heat-treated steel parts, for example. It has the advantage that lattice strain, which is the source of internal stress, is the direct result of the measurement. This is in contrast to the calculation of stress from measurements of strain on the external surface of a material, which include components due to both lattice strain and the stress-free, permanent strain caused by dislocation motion. When stress is calculated from such surface measurements, the assumption that dislocation motion is absent or negligible is implicit [2.18]. Diffraction contrast from scattered x-rays forms the basis for x-ray topography of crystals, useful in the study of the defect structure of highly perfect single crystals used in electronic applications [2.19]. Magnified diffraction spots from crystals reveal images of the structure of the material with a resolution comparable to the wavelength of the radiation. Small changes in the orientation and spacing of atomic planes due to the presence of internal defects change the diffraction conditions locally, creating contrast in the image of the diffracted beam. The availability of high-intensity xray sources from synchrotrons has greatly increased the applicability and usefulness of this technique. Radiography also forms images by the interaction of material with x-rays, but in this case, the contrast mechanism is by the differential absorption of radiation caused by varying thicknesses of material throughout an irradiated section as well as by regions having differing densities, which affects the ability of material to absorb x-rays [2.20]. Radiography can reveal macroscopic defects and heterogeneous distributions of phases in materials. Since contrast is not due to diffraction by the structure, this process cannot provide information on its crystal structure or the state of lattice strain in the material. The principles of diffraction apply not only to electromagnetic radiation but also to the scattering of highly energetic subatomic particles, such as elec-
2.2 Properties of Materials
34
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.2
cess reverses until the variables have their initial values. If such a closed cycle occurs under conditions such that the system is continuously in equilibrium with its surroundings, the thermodynamic states at the beginning and the end of the process will be the same and no net work is done. Properties that relate conjugate fields in this case are equilibrium properties and depend only on the thermodynamic state of a system, not its history. A caloric equation of state relates conjugate fields, which permits the description of the relationship between applied and induced fields in terms of appropriate derivatives of a thermodynamic potential. If processes that occur during the cycle dissipate energy, they produce entropy and the system is not in the same state in the initial and final conditions. Although the applied field variables are the same at the beginning and end of the cycle, the conjugate induced variables do not return to their original values. The change of thermodynamic state occurs because of irreversible changes to the structure of the material caused, at least in part, by changes in the internal structure of the system that occur during the cyclic change. Associated material properties are dissipative and exhibit hysteresis. Dissipative properties are dependent on time and the history of the system as well as its current thermodynamic state. However, in some cases it is possible to relate these properties to appropriate derivatives of a complex dissipative potential [2.24]. In general, equilibrium properties are structure insensitive, while dissipative properties are structure sensitive. The search for additional state variables that depend on the internal structure of the material is a subject of much continuing research. Transport processes are dynamic processes that cause the movement of matter or energy from one part of the system to another. These produce a flux of matter or energy occurring in response to a conjugate thermodynamic force, defined as the gradient of a thermodynamic field [2.26]. Attributes that connect fluxes and forces are generally structure-insensitive material properties.
2.2.1 The Continuum Approximation Continuity The complex nature of real materials requires approximation of their structure by a mathematical concept that forms a basis for calculations of the behavior of engineering components. This concept, the continuous medium, replaces discrete arrays of atoms and molecules with a continuous distribution of matter. Fields and properties defined at every mathematical
point in the medium are continuous, with continuous derivatives, except at a finite number of surfaces separating regions of continuity [2.24]. The process that defines properties at a point in the medium consists of taking the limit of the volume average of the property over increasingly smaller volumes. For sufficiently large volumes the average will be independent of sample size. However, as the volume sampled decreases below a critical range, the volume average will exhibit a dependence on sample size, which is a function of the nature of the property being measured and the material. The smallest sample volume that exhibits no size dependence defines the continuum limit for the material property. The continuum approximation assigns the value of the size-independent volume average of the property to a point at the centroid of the volume defined by the continuum limit. It follows that, when the size of a sample being tested approaches the continuum limits of relevant properties, results can be quite different from those predicted by a continuum model of the material. This limit depends on the material, its structural state, and the property being measured, so that all need to be specified when assigning a value to the continuum limit. The continuum approximation employs the concept of the material particle to link the discrete nature of real materials to the continuum. By the argument above, the material attributes of such a particle must be associated with a finite volume, the local value of the continuum limit for the attributes. As noted earlier, continuum limits may differ for different properties; consequently the effective size associated with a material particle will depend on the property associated with the continuum. Coordinate systems based on material particles, in contrast to those based on the crystal lattice, must necessarily be continuous by the assumption of global continuity of the medium. Despite the inherent differences in concepts of material structure, it is possible to develop models of many material properties based on atomic or molecular characteristics that interface well with the continuum model at the scale of the continuum limit. These limits can only be determined experimentally or by the comparison of properties calculated from physically based models of atomic arrays of various sizes. Such models form essential links between continuum mechanics and the knowledge of structure provided by materials science. Homogeneity The continuous medium used for calculation of the behavior of engineering structures also possesses the
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
Isotropy The usual model of a homogeneous continuous medium also assumes that properties of the material are isotropic, i. e., they are independent of the direction of measurement. This assumption generally results in the minimum number of independent parameters that describe the property and simplifies the math-
ematics involved in analysis. However, isotropy is infrequently observed in real materials, and neglect of the anisotropic nature of material properties can lead to serious errors in estimates of the behavior of engineering structures. Properties of materials possess symmetry elements related to the structure of the material. The following Gedanken experiment illustrates the meaning of symmetry of a property [2.25]. Measure the property relative to some fixed set of coordinate axes. Then operate on the material with a symmetry operation. If the value of the property is unchanged, then it possesses the symmetry of the operation. Neumann’s principle states that the symmetry elements of any physical property of a crystal must include the symmetry elements of the point group of the crystal. Notice that the principle does not require that the crystal and the property have the same symmetry elements, just that the symmetry of the property contains the symmetry elements of the crystal. Since an isotropic property has the same value regardless of the direction of measurement, it contains all possible point groups. As mentioned above, bulk properties of polycrystalline and multiphase materials are appropriate averages of the properties of their microconstituents, taking account of the distribution of composition, size, and orientation. A common source of bulk anisotropy in a material is the microscopic variation in orientation of its grains or microconstituents. An orientation distribution function (ODF) describes the orientation distribution of microscopic features relative to an external coordinate system. Depending on the feature being measured, quantitative stereology or x-ray diffraction analyses provide the information required to determine various types of ODFs. Used in conjunction with the properties of individual crystals of constituent phases, ODFs can describe the anisotropy of many bulk properties, such as the elastic anisotropy of metal sheet formed by rolling.
2.2.2 Equilibrium Properties Although the definition of equilibrium properties is phenomenological, without reference to the structure of the material, values of the properties depend on the structure of materials though models described in treatises on condensed-matter physics and materials science [2.27]. Properties described in the following sections are all first order in the sense that they arise from an assumed linear relationship between applied and induced fields. However, most properties have measurable de-
35
Part A 2.2
property of homogeneity, that is, properties at a material point do not depend on the location of the point in the medium. While this assumption is reasonably accurate for single-phase materials of uniform composition, it no longer applies to multiphase materials at the microscale. In the latter case, properties of the bulk depend on appropriate averages of the properties of the constituent phases, which include parameters such as the volume fraction of each phase, the average size of the particles of each phase, and in some cases the orientation of the phases relative to one another and to externally applied fields. Higher order models of multiphase materials treat each phase as a distinct continuum with properties distinct from other phases. Physical fields within the body are also influenced by the nature, orientation, and distribution of the phases present. Average values of induced internal fields determined from the external dimensions of a body and fields applied to the surfaces may not accurately reflect the actual conditions at points in the interior of the body due to different responses from constituent phases within the material. Material properties determined from the bulk response to these mean fields may differ significantly from similar properties measured on homogeneous specimens of the constituent phases. Measurements of local fields rely on techniques that sample small, finite volumes to determine local material response, then inferring the values of the fields producing the response. Since a quantitative determination of variables that determine the bulk properties of multiphase materials is often difficult, time-consuming, and expensive, experimental measurements on bulk specimens typically determine these properties. It is important to realize that applying the results of such measurements implicitly assumes that differences in structure of the material at the microscale have a negligible effect on the resulting properties. Structural variability due to inhomogeneity can be taken into account experimentally by determining properties of the same material with a range of structures and assigning a quantitative value to the uncertainty in the results.
2.2 Properties of Materials
36
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.2
pendencies on other applied fields. Such field-induced changes cause second-order effects, such as optical birefringence and the electro-optical effect, where firstorder properties depend on strain and electrical field, respectively. For compactness, this review will not consider these effects, although many of them can provide the basis for useful measurements in experimental mechanics. The usual description of equilibrium properties employs conjugate effects. In principle, any change in an applied field produces changes in all induced fields, although some of these effects may be quite small. Figure 2.11, adapted from Nye [2.25] and Cady [2.28], illustrates the interrelationship among first-order effects caused by applied and induced fields. Applied field variables appear at the vertices of the outer tetrahedron, while the corresponding vertices of the inner tetrahedron represent the conjugate induced field variables. Lines connecting the conjugate variables represent principal, or direct, effects. Specific Heat For a reversible change at constant volume, an incremental change in temperature dT produces a change of entropy dS: ε C (2.13) dT , dS = T
where C ε is the heat capacity at constant strain (volume) and T is the absolute temperature. To maintain constant volume during a change in temperature, it is necessary to vary the external tractions on the surface of the body (or the pressure, in the case of a gas). When measurements are made at constant stress (or pressure), the volume varies. The heat capacity under these conditions is C τ . Specific heat is an extensive, isotropic property.
τ H B
D E
ε
S T
Fig. 2.11 Relationships among applied and induced fields
Electrical Permittivity A change in electrical field dE produces a change in electrical displacement dD:
dDi = κij dE j ,
(2.14)
where the suffixes, which range from 1 to 3, represent the components of the vectors D and E, represented by bold symbols, along reference coordinate axes and summation of repeated suffixes over the range is implied here and subsequently. The second-rank tensor κ is the electrical permittivity, which is in general anisotropic. Magnetic Permeability A change in magnetic field dH produces a corresponding change in magnetic induction or flux density dB:
dBi = μij dH j ,
(2.15)
where μ is the second-rank magnetic permeability tensor, which is in general anisotropic. Equations (2.14) and (2.15) apply only to the components of D and B that are due to the applied electrical or magnetic field, respectively. Some substances possess residual electrical or magnetic moments at zero fields. The integral forms of (2.14) and (2.15) must account for these effects. Hookean Elasticity An incremental change in stress dτ produces a corresponding change in strain dε according to:
dεij = sijk dτk ,
(2.16)
where s is the elastic compliance tensor. In this case, the applied and induced fields are second-rank tensors, so the compliances form a fourth-rank tensor that exhibits the symmetry of the material. The elastic constant, or elastic stiffness, tensor c, is the inverse of s in the sense that cijmn smnkλ = 1/2(δik δ jλ + δiλ δ jk ). Equation (2.16) is Cauchy’s generalization of Hooke’s law for a general state of stress. A material that obeys (2.16) is an ideal Hookean elastic material. Most engineering calculations involving elastic behavior assume not only Hooke’s law but also isotropy of the elastic constants. This reduces the number of independent elastic constants to two, i. e. cijmn = λδij δmn + μ(δim δ jn + δin δ jm ), where λ and μ are the Lamé constants. Various combinations of these constants are also employed, such as Young’s modulus, the shear modulus, the bulk modulus and Poisson’s ratio, but only two are independent in an isotropic material. The Chapter on continuum mechanics in this work lists additional relationships among the isotropic elastic constants [2.29].
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
Cross-Effects All conjugate fields can be included in the description of the thermodynamic state. Define a function Φ such that
Φ = U − τij εij − E D − Bk Hk − TS .
(2.17)
Then using the definition of work done on the system by reversible changes in the conjugate variables and the first and second laws of thermodynamics, we have dΦ = −εij dτij − D dE − Bk dHk − S dT . (2.18) Since Φ = Φ(τ, E, H, T), ∂Φ ∂Φ dτij + dE dΦ = ∂τij E,H,T ∂E τ,H,T ∂Φ ∂Φ + dHk + dT ∂Hk E,τ,T ∂T E,H,τ
the coefficients of the form 2 ∂εij ∂ Φ = − ∂τij ∂T E,H ∂T σ,E,H ∂S = = βijE,H ∂τij T,E,H
(2.22)
τ
ΔS = βij τij + (C /T )ΔT ,
(2.23)
where sT is the isothermal compliance tensor. Extension of this argument shows that the full matrix of matera)
Heat of deformation
Strain
Entropy
Elasticity
Heat capacity
(2.19)
Piezocaloric effect
Stress
it follows that ∂Φ = −εij , ∂τij E,H,T ∂Φ = −Bk , ∂Hk E,τ,T
∂Φ = −D , ∂E τ,H,T ∂Φ = −S . ∂T E,H,τ (2.20)
Further differentiation of (2.19) and (2.20) with respect to the independent variables gives relationships among
(2.21)
for the thermal expansion coefficient tensor β at constant electrical and magnetic field. Thermoelasticity illustrates cross-effects that occur among equilibrium properties. Consider the section of the tetrahedron containing only the applied field variables stress and temperature and the associated induced field variables, strain and entropy, illustrated in Fig. 2.12. In this illustration, the line connecting stress and strain represents the elastic relationships and the line connecting entropy and temperature denotes the heat capacity. The indirect, or cross-effects are the heat of deformation, the piezocaloric effect, thermal expansion, and thermal pressure, as shown in the figure. Ten independent variables specify the thermodynamic substate of the material. These can be the nine stress components and temperature, nine strain components and temperature, or either of the preceding with entropy replacing temperature. Specification of ten independent variables determines the ten dependent variables. Nye [2.25] shows that the relationships connecting the effects become: T τk + βij ΔT , εij = sijk
c s σ
Thermal expansion
Temperature
Thermal pressure
b)
f
ε α
S α
–f
37
Part A 2.2
While isotropy is a convenient approximation for mathematical calculations, all real materials exhibit elastic anisotropy. Single crystals of crystalline materials display symmetry of the elastic coefficients that reflects the symmetry of the crystal lattice at the microscale [2.25]. The single-crystal elastic constants are often expressed in a contracted notation in which the two suffixes of stress and strain components become a single suffix ranging from 1 to 6. The independent terms of the corresponding elastic constant tensor become a 6 × 6 array, which is not a tensor. This notation is convenient for performing engineering calculations, but when the elastic constants are not isotropic, changes in the components of the elastic constant matrix due to changes in the coordinate system of the problem must be calculated from the full, fourth-rank tensor description of the constants [2.25]. Anisotropic crystalline materials can display a lower elastic symmetry at the mesoscale than at the single-crystal scale due to preferred orientation of the crystallites introduced during processing.
2.2 Properties of Materials
T/C C/T T
Fig. 2.12a,b Equilibrium properties relevant to thermoelastic behavior: (a) quantity and (b) symbol
38
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.2
ial coefficients defined by relationships similar to (2.21) and written in the form of (2.22) is symmetric. The atomic basis for the linear relationships in (2.22) arises from the nature of the forces between atoms. Although the internal energy of a material is in reality a complex, many-body problem that is beyond the capabilities of even modern computers to solve, summation over all atoms of the bond energies of nearest-neighbor pairs offers a physically reasonable and computationally manageable alternative. The energy of an atom pair exhibits a long-range attraction and a short-range repulsion, resulting in a minimum energy for the pair at a distance equal to or somewhat greater than the interatomic spacing in the material. In the simplest case, a diatomic molecule of oppositely charged ions, the Coulomb force between unlike charges provides the attractive force and the mutual repulsion that arises when outer shells of electrons begin to overlap is the repulsive force. The minimum energy of the pair is called the dissociation energy, and is the energy required to separate the two ions to an infinite spacing at absolute zero. For the example cited the energy is radially symmetric, so that the energy–distance relationship is independent of the relative orientation of the ions, and the energy minimum occurs at the equilibrium interionic spacing. Figure 2.13 illustrates this behavior schematically. It follows from (2.16)–(2.20) that sijk = −
∂2Φ , ∂τij ∂τk
(2.24)
which can be expressed in terms of the strain relative to the equilibrium spacing by (2.16). Thus the elastic compliances are proportional to the curvature of the energy-distance curve of ionic pairs, measured at the equilibrium interionic distance. Extension of this model to condensed systems of atoms having more complex bonds leads to modification of the details of the relationships. The elastic constants of single crystals of single-phase cubic alloys can be estimated by an extension of this concept [2.30]. The energy–bond length relationship shown in Fig. 2.13 applies only at absolute zero. At finite temperatures, the energy of the pair is increased above the minimum by an amount proportional to kT . This implies that for any finite temperature T there exist two values of the interionic spacing with the same energy. The observed spacing at T is the average of these two. Most materials exhibit a curve that is asymmetric about r0 , the equilibrium spacing at T = 0 causing the mean spacing to change with temperature. Generally the na-
Lattice energy (eV) 15 12 9
Repulsive energy
6 3 0 –3 –6 Minimum energy
–9
Attractive energy
–12 –15
0
0.1
0.2
r0
0.4
0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 Interionic spacing (nm)
Fig. 2.13 Energy–bond length relationship for an ionic
solid
ture of this asymmetry is such that the mean spacing increases with temperature, as illustrated in Fig. 2.13, leading to a positive coefficient of thermal expansion. Different values of the elastic compliances result from measurements under isothermal (ΔT = 0) or adiabatic (ΔS = 0) conditions. The adiabatic compliance tensor sS is determined by setting ΔS = 0 and solving for ΔT in the second of (2.22), eliminating ΔT from the first equation and defining sS as the resulting coefficients of σ. The relationships among the isothermal and adiabatic quantities are τ C S T − sijk = −βij βk (2.25) . sijk T Since the coefficients of the thermal expansion tensor are positive for most materials, adiabatic compliances are typically smaller than isothermal compliances. Nye [2.25] gives expressions such as (2.25) relating differences between various properties with different sets of applied field variables being constant. This reasoning emphasizes the fact that the definitions of these properties include specification of the measurement conditions.
2.2.3 Dissipative Properties Equilibrium processes are reversible and conservative, whereas nonequilibrium processes are irreversible and nonconservative. In the latter cases, work done on the system dissipates in the form of heat, generating entropy. This introduces history and rate dependence in the response of the system to external fields and influ-
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
depends on the conditions of measurement. Engineering standards establish boundaries between these regimes that form the basis for design calculations. For example the limit of applicability of the equations of elasticity in engineering calculations can be defined as the stress at which strain no longer obeys Hooke’s law (proportional limit) or the more easily measured offset yield stress, defined as the stress required to produce some small but easily measurable permanent strain. The boundaries are always compromises between the accuracy with which they can be measured and the intended uses of the information. Viscoelasticity When stresses or strains are independent variables applied periodically with time, the response of the corresponding dependent variable is out of phase with the applied field. This causes a delay in response, manifested by an induced field that has the same frequency, but is out of phase with the applied field. Consider a uniaxial stress τ(t) = τ0 exp(iωt) applied with frequency ω that causes a strain ε(t) = ε0 exp[i(ωt − δ)]. The complex compliance S∗ is defined as
S∗ =
ε0 ε (t) = exp (−iδ) . τ (t) τ0
(2.26)
The storage compliance S is the real component of S∗ , and the loss compliance S
is the imaginary component. These are related to the loss angle, δ, by tan(δ) = S
/S . The complex stiffness or modulus is the reciprocal of S∗ . Applying this concept to other states of stress and strain permits determination of all components of the viscoelastic constant tensor. The complex elastic constants and the loss angle are functions of the frequency of the applied field as can be noted by analysis of the above example using the theory of damped oscillations. Consider an experiment in which the component of total strain, ε0 , in a particular direction remains constant while the corresponding stress component is measured on a plane normal to the same axis. Let instantaneous and relaxed values of stress be τ0 and τ∞ , respectively. The dependence of stress on time t has the form: τ (t) = τ∞ + (τ0 − τ∞ ) exp (−t/ξε ) ,
(2.27)
if a single relaxation mechanism dominates the process. Each mechanism of relaxation possesses a characteristic relaxation time, which is the mathematical manifestation of the physical process causing the delay in response of the induced field to the applied field. The
39
Part A 2.2
ences the phenomenological material coefficients that relate applied and induced fields. The definition of properties associated with dissipative processes is formally similar to that for equilibrium properties with the caveat that history dependence affects the properties and their values under various measurement conditions. The following sections employ mechanical properties to illustrate mathematical descriptions of dissipative processes and definitions of associated properties. While these illustrations are most germane to typical problems in experimental mechanics, the mathematical descriptions of phenomena are similar for other processes relating other pairs of conjugate variables. Naturally, the physical interpretation of associated properties will vary with the particular conjugate phenomena investigated. The idealized behavior described by (2.16), is nondissipative. Real materials typically exhibit a timedependent response of the dependent variable to the independent variable, which is generally expressed as a relationship between the time rate of change of the dependent variable and the independent variable. Since the dependent variable does not instantaneously assume its final value in response to changes in the independent variable, these are not in phase during a cyclic process, and energy is dissipated during a closed cycle of deformation. In a static experiment viscoelastic, or anelastic, behavior is characterized by an induced strain field that exhibits not only an instantaneous response to a constant applied stress field, but also continues to increase until it reaches its final, higher, value over a period of time. Similarly, the stress field induced in response to an applied strain field relaxes from an initial value to a lower, constant value after a sufficiently long time. This leads to the definition of relaxed and unrelaxed elastic coefficients in relations of the form of (2.16), depending on whether the instantaneous or final values of the induced variables are employed. Chapter 29 on the characterization of viscoelasticity materials presents a comprehensive treatment of the viscoelastic behavior of materials. Viscoplastic behavior occurs when the material does not return to its original state on the restoration of the initial boundary conditions. Classical continuum plasticity is the limiting case in which time-dependent behavior is sufficiently small to be neglected. Many comprehensive treatments of the mathematics and phenomenology of these models are available to the interested reader; see [2.24]. The transition from reversible, dissipative behavior to irreversible, dissipative behavior is difficult to establish unequivocally and
2.2 Properties of Materials
40
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.2
value of t for which (τ0 − τ∞ ) exp(−t/ξε ) reaches 1/ e of its final value defines the relaxation time at constant strain, ξε . The ratio of ε0 to τ(t) is the viscoelastic compliance S(t). Clearly, this ratio depends on time during the relaxation process. Relaxed and unrelaxed compliances S0 and S∞ follow from dividing ε0 by τ0 and τ∞ , respectively. Viscoelastic stiffnesses, relaxed and unrelaxed elastic stiffnesses, or moduli, are the reciprocals of the corresponding compliances. A similar experiment in which the applied stress is kept constant and the strain increases with time to a limiting value results in the definition of a relaxation time at constant stress ξσ which is generally different in magnitude from ξε . A single relaxation time for viscoelastic effects often refers to the geometric mean of relaxation times determined in experiments where stress and strain are, respectively, the independent variables. Zener develops the theory of superposition of a distribution of a spectrum of relaxation times to the description of material response [2.30]. While the example given applies to uniaxial normal stress and the resulting normal strain, the concept applies to other states of stress or strain to obtain components of the full elastic constant and compliance tensors. The physical phenomena that cause relaxation in a material depend on its atomic and molecular structure. For example, the individual molecular chains in a linear polymer do not respond instantaneously to an applied stress field because of their mutual interference with relative motion. Over time, thermal motion of the molecules assisted by the local stress overcomes interference and a configuration in equilibrium with the applied stress field results. Upon removal of the stress, the material relaxes towards its initial configuration. Depending on the magnitude of the deformation and the extent of mutual interference of molecules, it may not be possible for the material to achieve its original state. In this case, the residual deformation is permanent and the deformation is viscoplastic. The book by Ferry [2.31] gives more detail on the theory and data on the viscoelastic properties of polymers. Mechanisms for energy dissipation in polymeric materials occur at the scale of longchain molecules, while those in metals and ceramics occur at the scales of atoms and ions [2.30]. Consequently, relaxation times for polymers tend to be longer than for metals and ceramics, leading to higher damping capacities in the former materials. Damping phenomena are relatively more important to engineering applications of polymeric materials that of metals and ceramics.
Viscoplasticity A cyclic deformation process that does not return the material to its initial state, even after relaxation, produces permanent, or plastic, deformation. This occurs when processes in the material that respond to a change in independent variable, stress or strain, result in irreversible changes that prevent the material from assuming its initial state after restoration of the independent variable to its original value. The physical mechanisms responsible for irreversible behavior in materials are extensively studied and modeled at the microscale. The natures of all such mechanisms are such that time-dependent behavior results on a macroscale. Notwithstanding a reasonably detailed understanding of the microscopic processes involved in permanent deformation, the application of this knowledge to the description of behavior at the macroscale is one of the most challenging research areas in the mechanics of materials. Plasticity in amorphous materials involves permanent rearrangement of the linear molecular or network structure of the substance. The fundamental process of deformation is the stretching, distorting or breaking of individual atomic or molecular bonds and reforming them with different neighbors. A volume change may or may not accompany these processes. Changes typically occur in a manner that is correlated with the local stress state and often involve a combination of thermal activation with stress. Since amorphous structures do not possess long-range atomic or molecular order, it is not appropriate to describe this process in terms of the presence or propagation of structural defects. Permanent deformation of these materials is still best described in terms of phenomenological theories. Chapter 29 reviews some phenomenological approaches to viscoplasticity in which differences of behavior among materials are contained in material parameters appearing in the theories, but not specifically linked to atomic structure or mechanisms. This section presents a formally similar treatment, but introduces material parameters for crystalline materials that are based on the atomic and defect structure of the deforming material. Representative phenomenological approaches to viscoplasticity in which differences of behavior among materials are contained in material parameters appearing in the theories, but not specifically linked to atomic structure or mechanisms. As noted earlier, in crystalline materials permanent deformation at the microscale below half the absolute melting temperature occurs primarily by slip, the relative displacement of material across crystallographic
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
shape coordinate system, embedded in the body, having nodes at material points and deforming congruently with the body as a whole. If no dislocations remain in the body after deformation, lattice coordinates and shape coordinates are related by a one-to-one mapping. While deformation of the shape coordinate system is always compatible (unless voids or cracks form during deformation), deformation of the lattice coordinate system is not compatible if dislocations remain in the body. Following the convention employed in Chap. 1, define a total, or shape, distortion as the deformation gradient FS which maps a reference vector in the initial state dX to its counterpart in the final state dx using shape coordinates. The lattice distortion FL , relates dx to its counterpart expressed in lattice coordinates dζ while the dislocation distortion FD relates dζ to dX [2.32]. Then dx = FL dζ = FL FD dX = FS dX, leading to the multiplicative decomposition FS = FL FD .
(2.28)
By the assumption of continuity FS is compatible, while FL and FD can be compatible or incompatible, depending on the nature of the deformation process. If either is incompatible, the other must be also and the incompatibilities must be equal and opposite. To facilitate understanding the connection between dislocation deformation and macroscale changes in shape, define a reference state consisting of a body free of external tractions and having a zero or selfequilibrating internal stress field. Consider the transition of a small volume of material δV bounded by a surface δS from the reference state to a deformed state by a two-step thought process [2.33, 34]: 1. remove δV from the reference material, replacing any tractions exerted by the rest of the body with tractions on the surface of δV so that its state remains unchanged, and give δV an arbitrary permanent change in shape δV ( dζ = FD dX), 2. replace δV in the original location of δV by applying the necessary tractions to its surface, δS , then remove the tractions, allowing δV to relax to its new, deformed configuration δV
bounded by δS
( dx = FL dζ). Two possibilities exist for step 1: dislocations may or may not be introduced into δV by the permanent change in shape. Each leads to a different situation in δV
after step 2. Case I refers to the situation where no dislocations are introduced in δV and FD is compatible within δV resulting in a stress-free distortion.
41
Part A 2.2
planes. Relative motion occurs such that the local structure of the material is preserved, that is, nearestneighbor distances are unchanged and the material remains crystalline. Motion does not occur simultaneously across an entire slip plane, but sequentially, so that the atomic distortion caused by the motion is localized near boundaries between regions where relative displacement has occurred and regions where it has yet to occur. These boundaries are dislocations, which are the principal source of internal stress in materials. For crystalline regions permanently deformed entirely by slip, dislocations pass out of the region and vanish at free surfaces or accumulate at internal surfaces that bound the region. Characterization of a dislocation requires specification of the slip vector, or Burgers vector b, which is the vector describing the relative displacement of material across the slip plane, and the line direction, a unit vector, t, tangent to the boundary, pointing in an arbitrarily chosen positive direction. Conventionally the senses of b and t are chosen such that the unit normal to the slip plane n = (b × t)/|b| points towards the region of lattice expansion associated with the dislocation. While motion of dislocations in their slip planes conserves lattice sites and produces no volume change, motion of dislocations normal to their slip planes, known as climb, creates or destroys vacant lattice sites, producing a permanent change in volume. Generally this nonconservative motion is associated with deformation at temperatures above one-half of the absolute melting point of the material, while conservative motion with no volume change dominates at lower temperatures. Permanent deformation by dislocation motion results in one of two final configurations. If dislocations pass entirely through the body, the shape is permanently changed, but no (additional) residual stress is introduced in the deformed material. In this case the total deformation is equal to the deformation due to dislocations, or dislocation deformation, both of which are compatible in the usual sense of finite deformation theory [2.24]. In the second case, dislocations remain in the material, causing additional deformation of the crystal lattice accompanied by residual stresses. Relating the latter scenario to conventional measures of deformation based on changes in the external dimensions of a body requires recognition of the fact that deformation of the crystal lattice may not be congruent with the deformation of the body as a whole. It is necessary to describe the process with reference to two coordinate systems: the lattice coordinate system, based on the crystal lattice in which dislocation deformation is measured, and the
2.2 Properties of Materials
42
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.2
Since a permanent change of shape has occurred, when δV is reintroduced into the body any misfit must be accommodated by dislocations distributed on δS
after relaxation. The resulting compatible FL within δV
is composed of a component due to these dislocations and a component due to surface tractions arising from the constraint of the rest of the body. This corresponds to Eshelby’s misfitting inclusion problem [2.33]. Case II refers to the situation where dislocations remain in δV
after step 1 and FD is not compatible. After reinsertion within δV
FL now consists of an incompatible distortion due to the dislocations within δV
in addition to the compatible distortion due to the boundary conditions on δS
. The implications of this decomposition become evident if δV
is considered as a representative volume element (RVE) or continuum limit for a continuum theory of plasticity. Including dislocations in δV
requires a decomposition of shape distortion in which both the dislocation and lattice components are incompatible. Figure 2.14 illustrates the relationships among the various components of deformation discussed above and the familiar elastic and plastic distortion components employed in continuum mechanics Chap. 1. Referring to the previous discussion of the decomposition of distortion, case I applies to the situation when the dislocation distortion coincides with the plastic distortion FP and the lattice distortion is entirely due to boundary conditions on δV
. Both distortions are compatible except on the boundary δS where dislocations have accumulated. Case II corresponds to the situation when dislocations that remain in δV cause an incompatible lattice distortion FLD that has an incompatibility equal and opposite to FD . The remaining compatible component of the lattice distortion FLC is Deformed state
Reference state FS Fp FD
FL
F LC = F e
F LD
Fig. 2.14 Decomposition of shape (total) distortion (after [2.35])
due to tractions on the boundary of δV and is formally equal to the conventional elastic distortion Fe . The multiplicative decompositions now become FS = FL FD = (FLC )(FLD FD ) = Fe Fp ,
(2.29)
where we have identified Fe , the conventional elastic distortion, with FLC and the conventional compatible plastic distortion Fp with the product FLD FD . Continuum plasticity employs the decomposition of total distortion into the two compatible distortion components on the extreme right-hand side (RHS) of (2.29), which does not permit the inclusion of dislocations explicitly in the theory and restricts its application to situations in which permanent distortion is uniform throughout the deformed region of material. Crystal plasticity modifies this model by invoking the geometry of crystalline slip to allow deformed regions of the material to experience differing amounts of distortion in response to the local stress field. By the arguments above the boundaries between these regions must contain dislocations sufficient to make the local shape distortion compatible, although the presence of these dislocations is not included explicitly in the theory. However, this approach often employs dislocation theory to construct constitutive relations at the microscale, which permits the local rate of distortion to differ throughout the material in response to the local state of stress [2.36]. For a viscoplastic material the rate of plastic distortion depends on the applied stress through a flow law of the form [2.37] ε˙ˆ ijD = Φ(σˆ ∗ , π1 · · · π K , Θ)σˆ ij∗ ,
(2.30)
in which the carat indicates the deviatoric component of the tensor Φ is a scalar function πi are internal material parameters dependent on structure and Θ is the absolute temperature. The effect of internal structure on mechanical behavior enters through its contribution to the viscoplastic potential Φ. The rate dependence of mechanical response originates with the resistance of the material to dislocation motion. Obstacles to dislocation motion are primarily the intrinsic resistance of the lattice (Peierls stress) and the stress fields of other defects and dislocations. Dislocations move over their slip planes by overcoming the resistance due to these obstacles under the influence of the local stress field and thermal activation, as illustrated schematically in Fig. 2.8. Observable deformation occurs by the collective motion of large numbers of dislocations over an obstacle array with a spectrum of strengths.
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
The kinematics of deformation relate to dislocation motion through the geometry of the microscopic process. The dislocation distortion rate due to dislocation motion on N slip systems is ˙ D = LD = F
N
b(k) ⊗ (ρ(k) × v(k) ) ,
(2.31)
where the superposed dot refers to differentiation with respect to time. For the k-th slip system, ρ(k) is a vector whose length is a measure of the instantaneous length of mobile dislocations per unit volume having Burgers vector b(k) and whose direction is determined by the edge-screw character of the distribution of line directions, while v(k) is a vector normal to ρ(k) that specifies the mean velocity of the mobile dislocation configuration [2.35]. For typical deformation processes, the lattice distortion and lattice distortion rate are small compared to the dislocation distortion rate so that (2.31) is approximately equal to the total or shape distortion rate. Employing a single thermally activated deformation process due to a single dislocation mechanism, Hartley [2.35] demonstrated how the microscale parameters describing the process can lead to an interpretation of the viscoplastic potential in terms of parameters determined by the model of the dislocation–barrier interaction. Similar models can be constructed for creep, or high-temperature deformation under constant stress, where the primary mechanism of dislocation motion is climb, or motion normal to the glide plane. Constructing a model of this process that can be inserted into a continuum description of deformation includes several challenging components. First, models must be constructed of the interaction of individual dislocations with various obstacles at the scale of individual obstacles. These models must then be scaled up to include the interaction of a distribution of dislocations with a distribution of obstacles on a slip plane. The interaction of dislocation motion on the various slip planes in a crystal follows at the next scale, and finally the distribution of crystals and their associate slip planes throughout the material must be established. At each level, appropriate statistical models of the microscopic quantities must be constructed and related to the adjacent scales of structure. This process of multiscale modeling has received much attention in the past decade. Attempts to relate previous knowledge of dislocation theory and viscoplasticity have benefited considerable from advances in the computational speed and capacity of supercomputers. Present capabilities still fall short of permitting engineering properties
to be calculated from inputs based entirely on microscopic models of dislocation processes. Nevertheless, considerable progress has been made in this area and the inclusion of microscale models of deformation processes in engineering design codes promises to add a significant component of material design to the process in the future.
2.2.4 Transport Properties of Materials When a system is not in the same state throughout, gradients of free energy exist, causing fluxes of energy that tend to eliminate the gradients. The free energy gradients are thermodynamic forces and the resulting fluxes can include matter, energy or electric charge depending on the nature of the force. Although the description of the relationship between forces and fluxes is called irreversible thermodynamics [2.26], it is important to recognize that systems in which such forces occur are not in thermodynamic equilibrium [2.26]. Phenomenological equations similar to those defining equilibrium and dissipative properties define properties that relate forces and fluxes. Thermal Transport A difference in temperature between various parts of a system causes heat to flow. In this case, the thermodynamic force is the temperature gradient. A vector represents the heat flux. The magnitude of the vector is equal to the flux of heat flowing across unit area normal to the vector and the direction of the vector is the direction of heat flow. In general, the heat flux vector need not be parallel to the temperature gradient. The dependence of the heat flux on the temperature gradient defines the thermal conductivity, k, by the relationship
qi = −kij T j ,
(2.32)
where the suffix j refers to partial differentiation with respect to the spatial variable x j . The negative sign specifies that heat flows from regions of higher temperature to regions of lower temperature. The thermal resistivity tensor r is the inverse of k; both are symmetric second-rank tensors. Principal values of the conductivity tensor are positive for all known materials. The conductivity ellipsoid is the quadric surface [2.24] k () = kij i j
(2.33)
such that the thermal conductivity k() in the direction of the unit vector is the reciprocal of the square root
43
Part A 2.2
k=1
2.2 Properties of Materials
44
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
of the radius vector from the origin to the surface in the direction of . By Neumann’s principle, the symmetry elements of the conductivity tensor contain those of the point group of any crystalline material that they describe. Isotropic thermal conductivity tensors describe a material that is isotropic with respect to heat flow.
Part A 2.2
Electrical Charge Transport The treatment of electrical conductivity in anisotropic materials is formally identical to that for thermal conductivity. In the former case, the flux is electrical charge instead of heat and the corresponding force is the gradient of electrical potential ϕ I = −E i . The expression
ji = −σik ϕk = σik E k
(2.34)
defines the electrical conductivity tensor σ in terms of the current density j and E. Equation (2.34) is Ohm’s law for a material exhibiting general anisotropy with respect to electrical conductivity. The electrical resistivity tensor ρ is the inverse of σ. All comments in the previous section about the symmetry properties and representation of the thermal conductivity and resistivity tensors apply to the corresponding tensors of electrical properties. The preceding discussion describes the conduction of heat and electrical charge as independent processes. However, when both occur together, they are coupled in a fashion similar to that describing equilibrium properties. For a description of the phenomenon of thermoelectricity and the associated material properties, the interested reader can consult [2.25, Chap. 12]. Mass Transport Engineering materials produced by ordinary manufacturing processes are never in their equilibrium state. A typical example is the segregation of components in an alloy prepared by solidification from the liquid state. The segregation is due to nonuniform cooling and compositional differences between the liquid and the first solids that form on solidification. It is generally desirable to eliminate this segregation to form a material with more uniform properties than the as-cast structure exhibits. This modification is possible because of the tendency of the material to remove spatial variations in composition under appropriate conditions by diffusion, a solid-state mass transport process. Two types of diffusion occur in materials. Stochastic, or random, diffusion occurs because of the random thermal motion of atoms or molecules in a substance. In the absence of any force biasing the random motion, the mean position of the diffusing entity will not change
with time. However, its root-mean-square (RMS) displacement from its origin will not vanish. This means that at any instant t after measurement begins, the displacement of the entity from its starting point may not be zero. In three dimensions, the RMS displacement u(t) is √ u(t) = 6Dt , (2.35) where D is the diffusion coefficient for the diffusing species. The diffusion coefficient depends strongly on temperature and the mechanism by which the diffusing entity moves through the material. Elementary arguments based on a model of diffusion as a thermally activated process lead to the expression of the Arrhenius form for the diffusion coefficient [2.38] −ΔH ∗ (2.36) , D = D0 exp kT where ΔH ∗ is the enthalpy of activation and D0 is a factor containing the square of the distance moved in a single jump of the diffusing entity, the frequency of jumps, a geometric factor, and a term related to the entropy of activation. Self-diffusion is synonymous with stochastic diffusion. Thermodynamic forces existing in materials bias stochastic diffusion, causing chemical diffusion, a net flux of matter that tends to eliminate gradients in the chemical potential of each component. For the purpose of describing diffusion, the chemical potential μ(i) of component i in a system is the partial derivative of the Gibbs free energy of the system with respect to the number of atoms or molecules of component i present, holding constant the temperature, stress state, and number of atoms of all other components. Multicomponent systems can exhibit fluxes of each component due to gradients in the chemical potentials of all components. In chemical diffusion, the force conjugate to the flux of each component is the gradient of the chemical potential of that component. Gradients of other fields, such as temperature and electrical potential, can also cause fluxes of the components. The description of diffusion including these cross effects is formally similar to that for thermoelectricity, giving rise to the definition of the thermal diffusion coefficient, electrostatic diffusion coefficient, and related properties. The following section presents a brief treatment of the principal equations and concepts in chemical diffusion in a two-component system. Consider a binary system of components A and B in which equal and opposite fluxes of the components J (K ) , where K takes on the values A and B, occur
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
parallel to a characteristic direction xi . Fick’s first law assumes that the flux of each component is proportional to the concentration gradient and occurs in the opposite direction Ji(A) = − D˜
∂NA , ∂xi
(2.37)
Property Change Through Heat Treatment One of the most useful features of many structural materials, particularly metals and alloys, is the ability to alter the microstructure so that selected physical and mechanical properties can be significantly changed without substantially affecting the external shape. This change is usually accomplished through heat treatment, which is the exposure of a material to an elevated temperature, generally somewhere between the proposed service temperature and the melting point of the material and often in a protective atmosphere to prevent adverse interaction with the environment. The extent of the exposure must be determined empirically to effect desired changes of properties without undesirable side effects. During the exposure internal stresses may be relieved by
the nucleation and growth of new, stress-free grains (recrystallization), preceded by the mutual annihilation of pre-existing dislocations (recovery); metastable phases present may transform to more stable forms and compositional variations at the microscale can be diminished by interdiffusion of components of the material. The three examples below illustrate such changes. Many structural metals and alloys are prepared for use by a sequence of processes beginning with the solidification of an ingot from a molten source, followed by several stages of substantial permanent deformation, often alternated with heat treatments, to arrive at a final form suitable for the fabrication of engineering structures. The deformation generally begins at elevated temperatures (above 0.5Tm , where Tm is the absolute melting temperature) where the deformation can be accomplished at lower loads. This process also breaks up the grain structure of the cast ingot, which is highly anisotropic. The elevated temperatures at which deformation is conducted promote mass transport of alloying elements, which promotes compositional homogeneity by diminishing local variations in the material. Since interaction with the environment, resulting in undesirable consequences such as surface roughness, accompanies deformation at elevated temperatures, final processing occurs at near-ambient temperatures. This low-temperature deformation introduces work-hardening, which may occur to such an extent that additional processing is not possible without damage to the material. In such cases, intermediate heat treatments that cause recovery and recrystallization in the material provide a means for lowering the flow stress to a point where additional cold work can be accomplished without fracture of the material. Changes in the internal structure of materials by altering the number, amount, and composition of phases present is a common result of heat treatment. Both the hardening of steel and precipitation hardening of aluminum alloys are examples of this process. The hardening of steel results from the fact that iron undergoes a transformation of crystal structure from body-centered cubic to face-centered cubic on heating from ambient temperature to above 910 ◦ C. When carbon is added, the bcc form of iron, ferrite, has a lower solubility limit than the fcc form, austenite. Thus an alloy that may be single phase at an elevated temperature will tend to become two-phase at ambient temperature as the structure transforms from austenite to ferrite. If the alloy is cooled slowly through the transforma-
45
Part A 2.2
where NA is the atomic fraction of component A, and D˜ is the coefficient of chemical diffusion, also known as the interdiffusion coefficient. The interdiffusion coefficient contains the thermodynamic factor relating the concentration to the chemical potential of component A. In many systems, experiments show that the fluxes of two species are not equal and opposite due to the accompanying flux of the point defects responsible for diffusion at the nanoscale. Although the gradient in defect concentration is generally negligible relative to that of the other diffusing species, the defect flux can be similar in magnitude to the fluxes of the other diffusing species. The phenomenological treatment of this effect describes the flux of each component in terms of a relation similar to (2.37) with the interdiffusion coefficient replaced by an intrinsic diffusion coefficient D(K) which contains the thermodynamic factor relating the chemical potential to the concentration of component K. Neglecting the defect concentration relative to those of the atomic or molecular species requires that N (A) + N (B) = 1, and the gradients are equal and opposite. Then (2.32) describes the flux of either species with the interdiffusion coefficient replaced by (N (A) D(B) + N (B) D(A) ). For additional information on experimental and theoretical treatment of this topic, the interested reader can consult the excellent book by Glicksman [2.38].
2.2 Properties of Materials
46
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 2.2
tion temperature range, this occurs by the formation of a second phase, Fe3 C or cementite, which appears in the form of an eutectoid, pearlite, consisting of alternating lamellae of cementite and ferrite. However if the alloy is cooled rapidly (quenched) from the higher temperature, the precipitation has insufficient time to occur and the excess carbon is trapped in the bcc lattice, distorting it to form a metastable, bodycentered tetragonal structure (martensite). Martensite is considerably harder than ferrite or pearlite, so the resulting alloy has substantially higher yield strength that a material of identical composition that has been slowly cooled from the same elevated temperature. Since martensite is often too brittle for use in the as-quenched condition, subsequent heat treatments below the transformation temperature can further alter the structure and increase toughness by reducing internal stresses without significantly affecting the yield strength. Precipitation hardening has similarities to the heat treatment of steel, but does not require a phase change of the pure element that is the base of the alloy system. This process is most commonly employed to strengthen aluminum alloys. The effect exploits the fact that the solubility of most alloying elements in a metal increases with increasing temperature. Thus, in the appropriate range of composition, an alloy that is single phase at an elevated temperature may have an equilibrium structure consisting of two or more phases at ambient temperature. Heat treatment to cause precipitation hardening consists of heating such an alloy to a temperature in the single-phase region, followed by quenching to ambient temperature to retain the singlephase structure, then reheating to a lower temperature in the multiphase region and holding for an empirically determined time (aging) to permit the structure to approach the equilibrium phase structure. In the early stage of aging metastable proto-precipitates are formed, which strain the lattice of the matrix material and increase the yield stress. As aging progresses and precipitates grow from these nuclei, internal stresses diminish, causing the yield stress to decrease, approaching the value of the as-quenched, single-phase solid solution. Processing of these materials is designed to conduct the aging treatment at temperatures and times that optimize the combination of strength, ductility, and toughness required for intended applications. Service temperatures for precipitation hardened alloys must be sufficiently below the aging temperatures so that additional unintended changes in properties do not occur during use.
2.2.5 Measurement Principles for Material Properties The measured properties of materials and the use of these measurements in various experimental mechanics applications require an appreciation of the limitations and dependencies described in the previous sections. The physical foundations of phenomenological relationships connecting structure and properties of materials comprise the preceding sections of this chapter. This connection leads to the following general principles, which call attention to the need for appropriate qualification of experimental measurements involving the properties of materials. Isolation In conducting experiments where measurements of conjugate fields provide data for the calculation of material properties, either isolate the system from additional fields that can affect the results or hold all but the conjugate fields constant. Without isolation or a constant environment of other fields, the measured properties will include cross-effects giving an incorrect value for the property associated with the conjugate fields. The same principle applies when specifically measuring cross-effects. Structure Consistency When measuring a material property or using the value of a material property in a measurement, ensure that samples to which the property applies are structurally identical. This is especially true of structure-sensitive properties, such as yield strength. However, variations in microstructure due to varying conditions of preparation can also affect other properties, such as electrical resistivity, sufficiently to cause inconsistencies in measurements with different samples. Quantitative Specification of Structure When measuring a material property or employing a material as an element in a measurement system, describe the composition and microstructural condition of the material in sufficient quantitative detail that subsequent similar experiments can employ structurally comparable material. Failure to observe this principle will introduce an unaccountable element of variability in the results of apparently comparable experiments. Consistency of Assumptions In analyzing results of measurements involving materials, ensure that the conditions of measurement
Materials Science for the Experimental Mechanist
satisfy the assumptions employed in the calculation. For example, the calculation of internal stress from measured values of strain must employ lattice strain or acknowledge the fact that the use of measured values of total strain implicitly assume that no plastic deforma-
References
tion occurs during the measurements. Only diffraction techniques measure lattice strain. Other techniques that use surface strains must satisfy the conditions under which these strains equal lattice strains, i. e., negligible dislocation motion.
2.2 2.3 2.4
2.5 2.6 2.7
2.8
2.9
2.10
2.11
2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15
2.16
2.17
J.F. Shackelford: Introduction to Materials Science for Engineers, 6th edn. (Pearson-Prentice Hall, New York 2004) D.W. Callister: Materials Science and Engineering An Introduction, 6th edn. (Wiley, New York 2003) D.R. Askeland: The Science and Engineering of Materials, 2nd edn. (Thomson, Stanford 1992) M.F. Ashby, D.R. Jones: Engineering Materials 1: An Introduction to Their Properties and Applications, 2nd edn. (Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford 2000) J.P. Hirth, J. Lothe: Theory of Dislocations, 2nd edn. (Wiley, New York 1982) F.R.N. Nabarro, J.P. Hirth (Eds.): Dislocations in Solids, Vol. 12 (Elsevier, Amsterdam 2004) C.S. Barrett, W.D. Nix, A. Tetleman: Principles of Engineering Materials (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs 1973) T.B. Massalski, H. Okamoto, P.R. Subramanian, L. Kacprzak: Binary Alloy Phase Diagrams, 2nd edn. (ASM Int., Materials Park 1990) R.S. Roth, T. Negas, L.P. Cook: Phase Diagrams for Ceramists, Vol. 5 (American Ceramic Society, Inc., 1983) P. Villers, A. Prince, H. Okamoto: Handbook of Ternary Alloy Phase Diagrams (ASM Int., Materials Park 1995) J. Goldstein, D.E. Newbury, P. Echlin, D.C. Joy, A.D. Romig Jr., C.E. Lyman, C. Fiori, E. Lifshin: Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-Ray Microanalysis, 2nd edn. (Springer, New York 1992) R.T. DeHoff, F.N. Rhines: Quantitative Microscopy (McGraw-Hill, New York 1968) B.D. Cullity: Elements of X-ray Diffraction, 2nd edn. (Addison-Wesley, Reading 1978) B.E. Warren: X-ray Diffraction (General, New York 1990) D.K. Smith, R. Jenkins: The powder diffraction file: Past, present and future, Rigaku J. 6(2), 3–14 (1989) W.I.F. David, K. Shankland, L.B. McCusker, C. Baerlocher (Eds.): Structure Determination from Powder Diffraction Data, International Union of Crystallography (Oxford Univ. Press, New York 2002) I.C. Noyan, J.B. Cohen, B. Ilschner, N.J. Grant: Residual Stress Measurement by Diffraction and Interpretation (Springer, New York 1989)
2.18 2.19
2.20
2.21
2.22
2.23
2.24
2.25 2.26 2.27 2.28
2.29 2.30 2.31 2.32 2.33 2.34
2.35
C.S. Hartley: International Conference on Experimental Mechanics, ICEM12-12th (Italy 2004) D.K. Bowen, B.K. Tanner: High Resolution X-ray Diffractometry and Topography (Taylor Francis, New York 1998) L. Cartz: Nondestructive Testing Radiography, Ultrasonics, Liquid Penetrant, Magnetic Particle, Eddy Current (ASM Int., Materials Park 1995) D.B. Williams, C.B. Carter: Transmission electron microscopy: a textbook for materials science (Kluwer Academic, New York, 1996) B.L. Adams, S.I. Wright, K. Kunze: Orientation imaging: The emergence of a new microscopy, Met. Mat. Trans. A 24, 819–831 (1993) J.A. James, J.R. Santistban, L. Edwards, M.R. Daymond: A virtual laboratory for neutron and synchrotron strain scanning, Physica B 350(1–3), 743–746 (2004) L.E. Malvern: Introduction to the Mechanics of a Continuous Medium (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs 1969) J.F. Nye: Physical Properties of Crystals (Clarendon, Oxford 1985) S.M. DeGroot: Thermodynamics of Irreversible Processes (North-Holland, Amsterdam 1951) M.P. Marder: Condensed Matter Physics (Wiley, New York 2000) W.G. Cady: Piezoelectricity: An Introduction to the Theory and Applications of Electromechanical Phenomena in Crystals (Dover, New York 1964) C.S. Hartley: Single crystal elastic moduli of disordered cubic alloys, Acta Mater. 51, 1373–1391 (2003) C. Zener: Elasticity and Anelasticity of Metals (Univ. Chicago Press, Chicago 1948) J.D. Ferry: Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd edn. (Wiley, New York 1980) B. A. Bilby: Continuous Distributions of Dislocations, Progress in Solid Mechanics (1960) J.D. Eshelby: The continuum theory of lattice defects, Solid State Phys. 3, 79–144 (1956) E. Kröner: Continuum theory of defects. In: Les Houches, Session XXXV, 1980 – Physics of Defects, ed. by R. Balian, M. Kleman, J.-P. Poirer (NorthHolland, Amsterdam 1981) pp. 282–315 C.S. Hartley: A method for linking thermally activated dislocation mechanisms of yielding with
Part A 2
References 2.1
47
48
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
2.36
continuum plasticity theory, Philos. Mag. 83, 3783– 3808 (2003) R. Asaro: Crystal Plasticity, J. Appl. Mech. 50, 921–934 (1983)
2.37 2.38
J. Lubliner: Plasticity Theory (Macmillan, New York 1990) M.E. Glicksman: Diffusion in Solids (Wiley, New York 2000)
Part A 2
49
Mechanics of 3. Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
Wolfgang G. Knauss, Igor Emri, Hongbing Lu
3.1
3.2
Historical Background ........................... 3.1.1 The Building Blocks of the Theory of Viscoelasticity ..........................
49
Linear Viscoelasticity ............................. 3.2.1 A Simple Linear Concept: Response to a Step-Function Input .............. 3.2.2 Specific Constitutive Responses (Isotropic Solids) .......................... 3.2.3 Mathematical Representation of the Relaxation and Creep Functions 3.2.4 General Constitutive Law for Linear and Isotropic Solid: Poisson Effect .. 3.2.5 Spectral and Functional Representations ...........................
51
3.2.6 Special Stress or Strain Histories Related to Material Characterization 3.2.7 Dissipation Under Cyclical Deformation............ 3.2.8 Temperature Effects ...................... 3.2.9 The Effect of Pressure on Viscoelastic Behavior of Rubbery Solids ......................... 3.2.10 The Effect of Moisture and Solvents on Viscoelastic Behavior................ 3.3
3.4
50
51
Measurements and Methods .................. 3.3.1 Laboratory Concerns ..................... 3.3.2 Volumetric (Bulk) Response ........... 3.3.3 The CEM Measuring System ............ 3.3.4 Nano/Microindentation for Measurements of Viscoelastic Properties of Small Amounts of Material......... 3.3.5 Photoviscoelasticity ...................... Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Material Characterization ................................... 3.4.1 Visual Assessment of Nonlinear Behavior................... 3.4.2 Characterization of Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Behavior Under Biaxial Stress States ............
56 63 63
68 69 69 70 71 74
76 83 84 84
85
53
3.5
Closing Remarks ...................................
89
53 55
3.6 Recognizing Viscoelastic Solutions if the Elastic Solution is Known.............. 3.6.1 Further Reading ...........................
90 90
55
References ..................................................
92
3.1 Historical Background During the past five decades the use of polymers has seen a tremendous rise in engineering applications. This growing acceptance of a variety of polymer-based de-
signs derives in part from the ease with which these materials can be formed into virtually any shape, and in part because of their generally excellent performance
Part A 3
With the heavy influx of polymers into engineering designs their special, deformation-rate-sensitive properties require particular attention. Although we often refer to them as time-dependent materials, their properties really do not depend on time, but time histories factor prominently in the responses of polymeric components or structures. Structural responses involving time-dependent materials cannot be assessed by simply substituting time-dependent modulus functions for their elastic counterparts. The outline provided here is intended to provide guidance to the experimentally inclined researcher who is not thoroughly familiar with how these materials behave, but needs to be aware of these materials because laboratory life and applications today invariably involve their use.
50
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.1
in otherwise normally corrosive environments. This recent emergence is driven by our evolving capabilities during the last seven decades to synthesize polymers in great variety and to address their processing into useful shapes. Historically polymers have played a significant role in human developments, as illustrated by the introductory comments in [3.1]. Of great consequence for the survival or dominance of tribes or nations was the development of animal-derived adhesives for the construction of high-performance bows, starting with the American Indian of the Northwest through the developments by the Tartars and leading to the extraordinary military exploits of the Turks in the latter Middle Ages [3.2]. In principle, these very old methods of producing weaponry continue to aid today in the construction of modern aerospace structures. While the current technology still uses principles exploited by our ancestors many years ago, the advent of the synthetic polymers has provided a plethora of properties available for a vast range of different engineering designs. This range of properties is, indeed, so large that empirical methods are no longer sufficient to effect reliable engineering developments but must now be supported by optimum analytical methods to aid in the design process. One characteristic of polymers is their relative sensitivity to load exposure for extended periods of time or to the rate of deformations imposed on them. This behavior is usually and widely combined under the concept of viscoelastic behavior, though it is sometimes characterized as representing fading memory of the material. These time-sensitive characteristics typically extend over many decades of the time scale and characteristically set polymers apart from the normal engineering metals. While the strain-rate sensitivity [3.3] and the time dependence of failure in metals [3.4] are recognized and creep as well as creep rupture [3.5–10] of metals is well documented, one finds that the incorporation of rate-dependent material properties into models of time-dependent crack growth – other than fatigue of intrinsically rate-insensitive materials – still stands on a relatively weak foundation. Metallic glasses (i.e., amorphous metals) are relatively newcomers to the pool of engineering materials. Their physical properties are at the beginning of exploration, but it is already becoming clear through initial studies [3.11, 12] that their amorphous structure endows them with properties many of which closely resemble those of amorphous polymers. While these developments are essentially in their infancy at this time it is
well to bear in mind that certain parts of the following exposition are also applicable to these materials. Because the emphasis in this volume is placed on experimental methods, rather than on stress analysis methods, only a cursory review of the linearized theory of viscoelasticity is included. For the reader’s educational benefit a number of books and papers have been listed in the Further Reading section, which can serve as resources for a more in-depth treatment. This review of material description and analysis is thus guided by particular deformation histories as a background for measurements addressing material characterization to be used in engineering design applications. Although the nonlinearly viscoelastic characteristic of these materials are not well understood in a general, three-dimensional setting, we include some reference to these characteristics in the hope that this understanding will assist the experimentalist with properly interpreting laboratory measurements.
3.1.1 The Building Blocks of the Theory of Viscoelasticity Forces are subject to the laws of Newtonian mechanics, and are, accordingly, governed by the classical laws of motion. While relativistic effects have been studied in connection with deforming solids, such concerns are suppressed in the present context. Many texts deal with Newtonian mechanics to various degrees of sophistication so that only a statement of the necessary terminology is required for the present purposes. In the interest of brevity we thus dispense with a detailed presentation of the analysis of stress and of the analysis of strain, except for summarizing notational conventions and defining certain variables commonly understood in the context of the linear theory of elasticity. We adhere to the common notation of the Greek letters τ and ε denoting stress and strain, respectively. Repeated indices on components imply summation; identical subscripts (e.g., τ11 ) denote normal components and different ones shear (e.g., τ12 ). The dilatational components of stress, τii , are often written as σkk , with the strain complement being εkk . Because the viscoelastic constitutive description is readily expressed in terms of deviatoric and dilatational components, it is necessary to recall the components Sij of the deviatoric stress as 1 Sij = τij − τkk · δij , 3
(3.1)
where δij denotes the Kronecker operator. Similarly, the corresponding deviatoric strain e is written in compo-
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
nent form as 1 eij = εij − εkk · δij . (3.2) 3 For further definitions and derivations of measures of stress or strain the reader is referred to typical texts.
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
51
The remaining building block of the theory consists of the constitutive behavior, which differentiates viscoelastic materials from elastic ones. The next section is devoted to a brief definition of linearly viscoelastic material behavior.
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity face (boundary) of a viscoelastic solid. Specification of such a quantity under uniaxial relaxation is not particularly useful, except to note that in the limit of short (glassy) response its value is a limit constant, and also under long-term conditions when the equilibrium (or rubbery) modulus is effective, in which case the Poisson’s ratio is very close to 0.5 (incompressibility).
3.2.1 A Simple Linear Concept: Response to a Step-Function Input It is convenient for instructional purposes to consider that the stress can be described, so that the strain follows from the stress. The reverse may hold with equal validity. In general, of course, neither may be prescribed a priori, and a general connection relates them. The structure of the linear theory must be completely symmetric in the sense that the mathematical formulation applies to these relations regardless of which variable is considered the prescribed or the derived one. For introductory purposes we shall use, therefore, the concept of a cause c(t) (input) and an effect e(t) (output) that are connected by a functional relationship. The latter must be linear with respect to (a) the amplitude (additivity with respect to magnitude) and (b) time in the sense that they obey additivity independent of time. It is primarily a matter of convenience that the cause-and-effect relation is typically expressed with the aid of a step-function cause. Other representations are
Table 3.1 Nomenclature for viscoelastic material functions Type of loading Shear
Bulk
Uniaxial extension
μ(t) J(t) μ (ω) μ (ω) J (ω) J (ω)
K (t) M(t) K (ω) K (ω) M (ω) M (ω)
E(t) D(t) E (ω) E (ω) D (ω) D (ω)
Mode Quasistatic
Relaxation Creep Strain prescribed
Harmonic Stress prescribed
Storage Loss Storage Loss
Part A 3.2
The framework for describing linearly viscoelastic material behavior, as used effectively for engineering applications, is phenomenological. It is based mathematically on either an integral or differential formulation with the material representation described realistically in numerical (tabular) or functional form(s). The fundamental equations governing the linearized theory of viscoelasticity are the same as those for the linearized theory of elasticity, except that the generalized Hooke’s law of elasticity is replaced by a constitutive description that is sensitive to the material’s (past) history of loading or deformation. It will be the purpose of the immediately subsequent subsections to summarize this formalism of material description in preparation for various forms of material characterization. Little or no reference is made to general solution methods for viscoelastic boundary value problems. For this purpose the reader is referred to the few texts available as listed in Sect. 3.6.1. Rather than repeating the theory as already outlined closely in [3.13] we summarize below the concepts and equations most necessary for experimental work; if necessary, the reader may consult the initially cited reference(s) (Sect. 3.6.1) for a more expansive treatment. In brief, the viscoelastic material functions of first-order interest are given in Table 3.1. Note the absence of a generic viscoelastic Poisson function, because that particular response is a functional of the deformation or stress history applied to the sur-
52
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.2
feasible and we shall address a common one (steadystate harmonic) later on as a special case. For now, let E(t, t1 ) represent a time-dependent effect that results from a step cause c(t1 ) = h(t1 ) of unit amplitude imposed at time t1 ; h(t1 ) denotes the Heaviside step function applied at time t1 . For the present we are concerned only with nonaging materials, i. e. with materials, the intrinsic properties of which do not change with time. (With this definition in mind it is clear that the nomenclature timedependent materials in place of viscoelastic materials is really a misnomer; but that terminology is widely used, nevertheless.) We can assert then that for a non-aging material any linearity of operation, or relation between an effect and its cause, requires satisfaction of Postulate (a): proportionality with respect to amplitude, and Postulate (b): additivity of effects independent of the time sequence, when the corresponding causes are added, regardless of the respective application times. Condition (a) states that, if the cause c(0) elicits E(t, 0), then a cause of different amplitude, say c1 (0) ≡ α · h(0), with α a constant, elicits a response α · E(t, 0). Under the non-aging restriction this relation is to be independent of the time when the cause starts to act, so that c1 (t1 ) ≡ α · h(t1 ) → αE(t, t1 ); t > t1 also holds. This means simply that the response–effect relation shown in the upper part of Fig. 3.1 holds also for a different time t2 , which occurs later in time than t1 .
Condition (b) entails then that, if two causes c1 (t1 ) ≡ α1 · h(t1 ) and c2 (t2 ) ≡ α2 · h(t2 ), imposed at different times t1 and, t2 act jointly, then their corresponding effects α1 · E(t, t1 ) and α2 · E(t, t2 ) is their sum while observing their proper time sequence. Let the common time scale start at t = 0; then the combined effect, say e(t), is expressed by c(t) ≡ c1 (t1 ) + c2 (t2 ) → e(t) = α1 · E(t − t1 ) + α1 · E(t − t2 ) . (3.3)
Specifically, here the first response does not start until the time t1 is reached, and the response due to the second cause is not experienced until time t2 , as illustrated in Fig. 3.1. Having established the addition process for two causes and their responses, the extension to an arbitrary number of discrete step causes is clearly recognized as a corresponding sum for the collective effects e(tn ), up to time t, in the generalized form of (3.3), namely (3.4) e(t) = αn E(t − tn ) ; (tn < t) . This result may be further generalized for causes represented by a continuous cause function of time, say c(t). To this end consider a continuously varying function c(t) decomposed into an initially discrete approximation of steps of finite (small) amplitudes. With the intent of ultimately proceeding to the limit of infinitesimal steps, note that the amplitude of an individual step amplitude at, say, time τn is given by (3.5) αn → Δc(τn ) = (Δc/Δτ) Δτ , τn
Stress
which, when substituted into (3.4), leads to e(t) = E(t − tn )(Δc/Δτ) Δτ .
Strain
τn
t1
Time
Stress
t1
Time
Strain
In the limit n → ∞ (Δτ → dτ), the sum Δc e(t) = lim E(t − tn ) Δτ , Δτ τn
(3.7)
passes over into the integral 2
t
2 1
(3.6)
e(t) =
1
E(t − τ)
dc(τ) dτ . dτ
(3.8)
0
t1
t2
Time
t1
t2
Time
Fig. 3.1 Additivity of prescribed stress steps and corres-
ponding addition of responses
Inasmuch as this expression can contain the effect of a step-function contribution at zero time of magnitude c(0), this fact can be expressed explicitly through the
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
alternate notation
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
53
effect, one obtains the inverse relation(s) t
e(t) = c(0)E(t) +
E(t − τ)
0+
dc(τ) dτ , dτ
(3.9)
3.2.2 Specific Constitutive Responses (Isotropic Solids) For illustrative purposes and to keep the discussion within limits, the following considerations are limited to isotropic materials. Recalling that the stress and strain states may be decomposed into shear and dilatational contributions (deviatoric and dilatational components), we deal first with the shear response followed by the volumetric part. Thermal characterization will then be dealt with subsequently. Shear Response Let τ denote any shear stress component and ε its corresponding shear strain. Consider ε to be the cause and τ its effect. Denote the material characteristic E(t) for unit step excitation from Sect. 3.2.1 in the present shear context by μ(t). This function will be henceforth identified as the relaxation modulus in shear (for an isotropic material). It follows then from (3.8) and (3.9) that t dε(ξ) (3.10) dξ τ(t) = 2 μ(t − ξ) dξ 0
t = 2ε(0)μ(t) + 2 0+
μ(t − ξ)
dε(ξ) dξ . dξ
(3.11)
The factor of 2 in the shear response is consistent with elasticity theory, inasmuch as in the limits of short- and long-term behavior all viscoelasticity relations must revert to the elastic counterparts. If one interchanges the cause and effect by letting the shear stress represent the cause, and the strain the
t J(t − ξ)
dτ dξ dξ
(3.12)
0
t
1 1 = τ(0)J(t) + 2 2
J(t − ξ) 0+
dτ dξ , dξ
(3.13)
where now the function E ≡ J(t) is called the shear creep compliance, which represents the creep response of the material in shear under application of a step shear stress of unit magnitude as the cause. Bulk or Dilatation Response Let εii (t) represent the first strain invariant and σ jj (t) the corresponding stress invariant. The latter is recognized as three times the pressure P(t), i. e., σ jj (t) ≡ 3P(t). In completely analogous fashion to (3.12) and (3.13) the bulk behavior, governed by the bulk relaxation modulus K (t) ≡ E(t), is represented by
t σ jj = 3
K (t − ξ)
dεii (ξ) dξ dξ
(3.14)
0
t = 3εii (0)K (t) + 3
K (t − ξ)
0+
dεii (ξ) dξii . dξ (3.15)
Similarly, one writes the inverse relation as 1 εii = 3
t M(t − ξ)
dσ jj (ξ) dξ dξ
(3.16)
0
1 1 = σ jj (0)M(t) + 3 3
t M(t − ξ) 0+
dσ jj (ξ) dξii , dξ (3.17)
where the function M(t) ≡ E(t) represents now the dilatational creep compliance (or bulk creep compliance); in physical terms, this is the time-dependent fractional volume change resulting from the imposition of a unit step pressure.
3.2.3 Mathematical Representation of the Relaxation and Creep Functions Various mathematical forms have been suggested and used to represent the material property functions
Part A 3.2
where the lower integral limit 0+ merely indicates that the integration starts at infinitesimally positive time so as to exclude the discontinuity at zero. Alternatively, the same result follows from observing that for a step discontinuity in c(t) the derivative in (3.5) is represented by the Dirac delta function δ(t). In fact, this latter remark holds for any jump discontinuity in c(t) at any time, after and including any at t = 0. In mathematical terms this form is recognized as a convolution integral, which in the context of the dynamic (vibration) response of linear systems is also known as the Duhamel integral.
1 ε(t) = 2
54
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.2
analytically. Preferred forms have evolved, with precision being balanced against ease of mathematical use or a minimum number of parameters required. All viscoelastic material functions possess the common characteristic that they vary monotonically with time: relaxation functions decreasing and creep functions increasing monotonically. A second characteristic of realistic material behavior is that time is (almost) invariably measured in terms of (base 10) logarithmic units of time. Thus changes in viscoelastic response may appear to be minor when considered as a function of the real time, but substantial if viewed against a logarithmic time scale. Early representations of viscoelastic responses were closely allied with (simple) mechanical analog models (Kelvin, Voigt) or their derivatives. Without delving into the details of this evolutionary process, their generalization to broader time frames led to the spectral representation of viscoelastic properties, so that it is useful to present only the rudiments of that development. The building blocks of the analog models are the Maxwell and the Voigt models illustrated in Fig. 3.2a,b. In this modeling a mechanical force F corresponds to the shear stress τ and, similarly, a displacement/deflection δ corresponds to a strain ε. Under a stepwise applied deformation of magnitude ε0 – separating the force-application points in the Maxwell model – the stress (force) abates or relaxes by the relation τ(t) = ε0 μm exp(−t/ξ) , a)
b)
F
(3.18)
c)
F
μ μ
η
η
μ1
η1
μ2
η2
μ3
η3
F
F F
d) μ∞
F
μ1
μ2
μ3
μj
η1
η2
η3
ηj
F
where ξ = ηm /μm is called the (single) relaxation time. Similarly, applying a step stress (force) of magnitude to the Voigt element engenders a time-dependent separation (strain) of the force-application points described by τ0 [1 − exp(−t/ς)] , (3.19) ε(t) = μν where ς = ην /μν is now called the retardation time since it governs the rate of retarded or delayed motion. Note that this representation is used for illustration purposes here and that the retardation time for the Voigt material is not necessarily meant to be equal to the relaxation time of the Maxwell solid. It can also be easily shown that this is not true for a standard linear solid either. By inductive reasoning, that statement holds for arbitrarily complex analog models. The relaxation modulus and creep compliance commensurate with (3.18) (Maxwell model) and (3.19) (Voigt model) for the Wiechert and Kelvin models (Fig. 3.2c,d) are, respectively μn exp(−t/ξn ) (3.20) μ(t) = μ∞ + n
and J(t) = Jg +
Jn [1 − exp(−t/ςn )] + η0 t ,
where Jg and η0 arise from letting η1 → 0 (the first Voigt element degenerates to a spring) and μn → 0 (the last Voigt element degenerates to a dashpot). These series representations with exponentials are often referred to as Prony series. As the number of relaxation times increases indefinitely, the generalization of the expression for the shear relaxation modulus, becomes ∞ dξ (3.22) , μ(t) = μ∞ + H (ξ) exp(−t/ξ) ξ 0
where the function H (ξ) is called the distribution function of the relaxation times, or relaxation spectrum, for short; the creep counterpart presents itself with the help of the retardation spectrum L(ζ ) as ∞
μj
ηj
J(t) = Jg +
L(ζ )[1 − exp(−t/ζ )] 0
F
Fig. 3.2a–d Mechanical analogue models: (a) Maxwell, (b) Voigt, (c) Wiechert, and (d) Kelvin
(3.21)
n
dζ + ηt , ζ (3.23)
Note that although the relaxation times ξ and the retardation times ζ do not, strictly speaking, extend over the range from zero to infinity, the integration limits are so
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
assigned for convenience since the functions H and L can always be chosen to be zero in the corresponding part of the infinite range.
3.2.5 Spectral and Functional Representations
3.2.4 General Constitutive Law for Linear and Isotropic Solid: Poisson Effect
A discrete relaxation spectrum in the form H (ξ) = μn ξn δ(ξn ) ,
One combines the shear and bulk behavior exemplified in (3.13), (3.16) and (3.19), (3.20) into the general stress–strain relation t 2 ∂εkk K (t − τ) − μ(t − τ) dτ σij (t) = δij 3 ∂τ t +2 0−
μ(t − τ)
∂εij dτ , ∂τ
(3.24)
where δij is again the Kronecker delta. Poisson Contraction A recurring and important parameter in linear elasticity is Poisson’s ratio. It characterizes the contraction/expansion behavior of the solid in a uniaxial stress state, and is an almost essential parameter for deriving other material constants such as the Young’s, shear or bulk modulus from each other. For viscoelastic solids the equivalent behavior cannot in general be characterized by a constant; instead, the material equivalent to the elastic Poisson’s ratio is also a time-dependent function, which is a functional of the stress (strain) history imposed on a uniaxially stressed material sample. This time-dependent function covers basically the same (long) time scale as the other viscoelastic responses and is typically measured in terms of 10–20 decades of time at any one temperature. However, compared to these other functions, its value changes usually from a maximum value of 0.35 or 0.4 at the short end of the time spectrum to 0.5 for the long time frame. Several approximations are useful. In the nearglassy domain (short times) its value can be taken as a constant equal to that derived from measurements well below the glass-transition temperature. In the long time range for essentially rubber-like behavior the approximation of 0.5 is appropriate, though not if one wishes to convert shear or Young’s data to bulk behavior, in which case small deviations from this value can play a very significant role. If knowledge in the range between the (near-)glassy and (near-)rubbery domain are required, neither of the two limit constants are strictly appropriate and careful measurements are required [3.14–16].
(3.25)
where δ(ξn ) represents the Dirac delta function, clearly leads to the series representation (3.20) and can trace the modulus function arbitrarily well by choosing the number of terms in the series to be sufficiently large; a choice of numbers of terms equal to or larger than twice the number of decades of the transition is often desirable. For a history of procedures to determine the coefficients μn see the works by Hopkins and Hamming [3.17], Schapery [3.18], Clauser and Knauss [3.19], Hedstrom et al. [3.20], Emri and Tschoegl [3.21–26], and Emri et al. [3.27, 28], all of which battle the ill-conditioned nature of the numerical determination process. This fact may result in physically inadmissible, negative values (energy generation), though the overall response function may be rendered very well. A more recent development that largely circumvents such problems, is based on the trust region concept [3.29], which has been incorporated into MATLAB, thus providing a relatively fast and readily available procedure. The numerical determination of these coefficients occurs through an ill-conditioned integral or matrix and is not free of potentially large errors in the coefficients, including physically inadmissible negative values, though the overall response function may be rendered very well. Although expressions as given in (3.22) and (3.23) render complete descriptions of the relaxation or creep behavior once H (ξ) or L(ξ) are determined for any material in general, simple approximate representations can fulfill a useful purpose. Thus, the special function μ0 − μ∞ ξ0 n exp(−ξ0 /ξ) (3.26) H (ξ) = Γ (n) ξ with the four parameters μ0 , μ∞ , ξ0 , and n representing material constants, where Γ (n) is the gamma function, leads to the power-law representation for the relaxation response μ(t) = μ∞ +
μ0 − μ∞ . (1 + t/ξ0 )n
(3.27)
This equation is represented in Fig. 3.3 for the parameter values μ∞ = 102 , μ0 = 105 , ξ0 = 10−4 , and n = 0.35. It follows quickly from (3.22) and the figure that μ0 represents the modulus as t → 0, and μ∞
Part A 3.2
0−
55
56
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
3.2.6 Special Stress or Strain Histories Related to Material Characterization
log modulus 6
For the purposes of measuring viscoelastic properties in the laboratory we consider several examples in terms of shear states of stress and strain. Extensional or compression properties follow totally analogous descriptions.
5 4 3 2
Part A 3.2
1 –10
–5
0
5
10 log t
Fig. 3.3 Example of the power-law representation of a relaxation modulus
its behavior as μ(t → ∞); ξ0 locates the central part of the transition region and n the (negative) slope. It bears pointing out that, while this functional representation conveys the generally observed behavior of the relaxation phenomenon, it usually serves only in an approximate manner: the short- and long-term modulus limits along with the position along the log-time axis and the slope in the mid-section can be readily adjusted through the four material parameters, but it is usually a matter of luck (and rarely possible) to also represent the proper curvature in the transitions from short- and long-term behavior. Nevertheless, functions of the type (3.26) or (3.27) can be very useful in capturing the essential features of a problem. With respect to fracture Schapery draws heavily on the simplified power-law representation. An alternative representation of one-dimensional viscoelastic behavior (shear or extension), though not accessed through a distribution function of the type described above, is the so-called stretch exponential formulation; it is often used in the polymer physics community and was introduced for torsional relaxation by Kohlrausch [3.30] and reintroduced for dielectric studies by Williams and Watts [3.31]. It is, therefore, often referred to as the KWW representation. In the case of relaxation behavior it takes the form (with the addition of the long-term equilibrium modulus μ∞ ),
(3.28) μ(t) = μ∞ + μ0 exp −(t/ξ0 )β . Further observations and references relating to this representation are delineated in [3.13].
Unidimensional Stress State We call a stress or strain state unidimensional when it involves only one controlled or primary displacement or stress component, as in pure shear or unidirectional extension/compression. Typical engineering characterizations of materials occur by means of uniaxial (tension) tests. We insert here a cautionary note with respect to laboratory practices. In contrast to working with metallic specimens, clamping polymers typically introduces complications that are not necessarily totally resolvable in terms of linear viscoelasticity. For example, clamping a tensile specimen in a standard test machine with serrated compression claps introduces a nonlinear material response such that, during the course of a test, relaxation or creep may occur under the clamps. Sometimes an effort is made to alleviate this problem by gluing metal tabs to the end of specimens, only to introduce the potential of the glue line to contribute to the overall relaxation or deformation. If the contribution of the glue line to the deformation is judged to be small, an estimate of its effect may be derived with the help of linear viscoelasticity, and this should be stated in reporting the data. For rate-insensitive materials the pertinent property is Young’s modulus E. For viscoelastic solids this constant is supplanted by the uniaxial relaxation modulus E(t) and its inverse, the uniaxial creep compliance D(t). Although the general constitutive relation (3.24) can be written for the uniaxial stress state (σ11 (t) = σ0 (t), say, σ22 = σ33 = 0), the resulting relation for the uniaxial stress is an integral equation for the stress or strain ε11 (t), involving the relaxation moduli in shear and dilatation. In view of the difficulties associated with determining the bulk response, it is not customary to follow this interconversion path, but to work directly with the uniaxial relaxation modulus E(t) and/or its inverse, the uniaxial creep compliance D(t). Thus, if σ11 (t) is the uniaxial stress and ε11 (t) the corresponding strain, one writes, similar to (3.10) and (3.12),
t σ11 (t) = ε11 (0)E(t) + 0+
E(t − ξ)
dε11 (ξ) dξ dξ
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
ε
ε
ε0
t0
tions to generate a ramp
+
t0
t
t0
t
t
modulus (3.22) together with the convolution relation (3.10) to render, with ε˙ (t) = const = ε˙ 0 and ε(0) = 0, the general result t
0+
We insert here a cautionary note with respect to laboratory practices: In contrast to working with metallic specimens, clamping polymers typically introduces complications that are not necessarily totally resolvable in terms of linear viscoelasticity. For example, clamping a tensile specimen in a standard test machine with serrated compression clamps introduces nonlinear material response such that during the course of a test relaxation or creep may occur under the clamps. Sometimes an effort is made to alleviate this problem by gluing metal tabs to the end of specimens, only to introduce the potential of the glue-line to contribute to the overall relaxation or deformation. If the contribution of the glue-line to the deformation is judged to be small an estimate of its effect may be derived with the help of linear viscoelasticity, and such should be stated in reporting the data. Constant-Strain-Rate History. A common test method
for material characterization involves the prescription of a constant deformation rate such that the strain increases linearly with time (small deformations). Without loss of generality we make use of a shear strain history in the form ε(t) = ε˙ 0 t (≡ 0 for t ≤ 0, ε˙ 0 = const for t ≥ 0) and employ the general representation for the relaxation τ
µ (t)
Error
ε0
t0
t
t0
t
Fig. 3.5 Difference in relaxation response resulting from
step and ramp strain history
μ(t − ξ)˙ε0 dξ
τ(t) = 2 0
t = 2˙ε0
∞ μ∞ +
0
0
t − ξ dς H (ς) exp − du ς ς (3.29)
t = 2μ˙ε0
μ(u) du = 2˙ε0 t · 0
1 t
t μ(u) du 0
= 2ε(t)μ(t) (3.30) ¯ ; t −ξ ≡ u . t Here μ(t) ¯ = 1t 0 μ(u) du is recognized as the relaxation modulus averaged over the past time (the time-averaged relaxation modulus). Ramp Strain History. A recurring question in viscoelas-
tic material characterization arises when step functions are called for analytically but cannot be supplied experimentally because equipment response is too slow or dynamic (inertial) equipment vibrations disturb the input signal: In such situations one needs to determine the error if the response to a ramp history is supplied instead of a step function with the ramp time being t0 . To provide an answer, take explicit recourse to postulate (b) in Sect. 3.2.1 in connection with (3.29)/(3.30) to evaluate (additively) the latter for the strain histories shown in Fig. 3.4. To arrive at an approximate result as a quantitative guide, let us use the power-law representation (3.27) for the relaxation modulus. Making use of Taylor series approximations of the resulting functions for t 0 one arrives at (the derivation is lengthy though straightforward) n t0 /ξ0 τ(t) = μ(t) 1 + (3.31) +... 2ε0 2 (1 + t/ξ0 )
Part A 3.2
and the inverse relation as t dσ11 (ξ) ε11 (t) = σ11 (0)D(t) + D(t − ξ) dξ . dξ
ε
57
Fig. 3.4 Superposition of linear func-
ε
=
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
58
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.2
as long as μ∞ can be neglected relative to μ0 (usually on the order of 100–1000 times smaller). The derivation is lengthy though straightforward. The expression in the square brackets contains the time-dependent error by which the ramp response differs from the ideal relaxation modulus, as illustrated in Fig. 3.5, which tends to zero as time grows without limit beyond t0 . By way of example, if n = 1/2 and an error in the relaxation modulus of maximally 5% is acceptable, this condition can be met by recording data only for times larger than t/t0 = 5 − ς0 /t0 . Since ς0 /t0 is always positive the relaxation modulus is within about 5% of the ramp-induced measurement as long as one discounts data taken before 5t0 . To be on the safe side, one typically dismisses data for an initial time interval equal to ten times the ramp rise time. In case the time penalty for the dismissal of that time range is too severe, methods have been devised that allow for incorporation of this earlier ramp data as delineated in [3.32, 33]. On the other hand, the wide availability of computational power makes an additional data reduction scheme available: Using a Prony series (discrete spectrum) representation, one evaluates the constant-strain-rate response with the aid of (3.30), leaving the individual values of the spectral lines as unknowns. With regard to the relaxation times one has two options: (a) one leaves them also as unknowns, or (b) one fixes them such that they are one or two per decade apart over the whole range of the measurements. The second option (b) is the easier/faster one and provides essentially the same precision of representation as option (a). After this choice has been made, one fits the analytical expression with the aid of Matlab to the measurement results. Matlab will handle either cases (a) or (b). There may be issues involving possible dynamic overshoots in the rate-transition region, because a test machine is not able to (sufficiently faithfully) duplicate the rapid change in rate transition from constant to zero rate, unless the initial rate is very low. This discrepancy is, however, considerably smaller that that associated with replacing a ramp loading for a step history. Mixed Uniaxial Deformation/Stress Histories Material parameters from measured relaxation or creep data are typically extracted via Volterra integral equations of the first kind, i. e., of the type of (3.20) or (3.21). A problem arises because these equations are ill-posed in the sense that the determination of
the kernel (material) functions from modulus or creep data involving Volterra equations of the first kind can lead to sizeable errors, whether the functions are sought in closed form or chosen in spectral or discrete (Prony series) form [3.18, 19, 27]. On the other hand, Volterra equations of the second kind do not suffer from this mathematical inversion instability (well-posed problem). Accordingly, we briefly present an experimental arrangement that alleviates this inherent difficulty [3.28]. At the same time, this particular scheme also allows the simultaneous determination of both the relaxation and creep properties, thus circumventing the calculation of one from the other. In addition, the resulting data provides the possibility of a check on the linearity of the viscoelastic data through a standard evaluation of a convolution integral. Relaxation and/or creep functions can be determined from an experimental arrangement that incorporates a linearly elastic spring of spring constant ks as illustrated in Fig. 3.6, readily illustrated in terms of a tensile situation. The following is, however, subject to the assumption that the elastic deformations of the test frame and/or the load cell are small compared to those of the specimen and the deformation of the added spring. If the high stiffness of the material does not warrant that assumption it is necessary to determine the contribution of the testing machine and incorporate it into the stiffness ks . Similar relations apply for a shear stress/deformation arrangement. In the case of
lb
Δl b0 ls ls Δl Δl s0
Fig. 3.6 Arrangement for multiple material properties de-
termination via a single test
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
bulk/volume response the spring could be replaced by a compressible liquid, though this possibility has not been tested in the laboratory, to our knowledge. For a suddenly applied gross extension (compression) of the spring by an amount Δl = const, both the bar and the spring will change lengths according to Δlb (t) + Δls (t) = Δl ,
(3.32)
where the notation in Fig. 3.6 is employed (subscript ‘b’ refers to the bar and “s” to the spring). The correspondingly changing stress (force) in the bar is given by
(3.33)
which is also determined by Ab Fb (t) = lb
t E(t − ξ)
d [Δlb (ξ)] dξ dξ
0
+
Ab 0 Δl E(t) , lb b
(3.34)
which, together with (3.32), renders upon simple manipulation Ab Δlb (t) εb (0)E(t) + Δl ks Δl t E(t − ξ)
+
d [εb (ξ)] dξ = 1 . dξ
(3.35)
0
This is a Volterra integral equation of the second kind, as can be readily shown by the transformation of variables ξ = t − u; it is well behaved for determining the relaxation function E(t). By measuring Δlb (t) along with the other parameters in this equation, one determines the relaxation modulus E(t). Similarly, one can cast this force equilibrium equation in terms of the creep compliance of the material and the force in the spring as ks lb Fb (t) + Ab
t D(t − ξ)
d [Fb (ξ)] dξ dξ
0
Time-Harmonic Deformation A frequently employed characterization of viscoelastic materials is achieved through sinusoidal strain histories of frequency ω. Historically, this type of material characterization refers to dynamic properties, because they are measured with moving parts as opposed to methods leading to quasi-static relaxation or creep. However, in the context of mechanics dynamic is reserved for situations involving inertia (wave) effects. For this reason, we replace in the sequel the traditional dynamic (properties) with harmonic, signifying sinusoidal. Whether one asks for the response from a strain history that varies with sin(ωt) or cos(ωt) may be accomplished by dealing with the (mathematically) complex counterpart
ε(t) = ε0 exp(iωt) · h(t)
0
(3.36)
It is clear then that, if both deformations and the stress in the bar are measured, both the relaxation modulus
(3.38)
so that after the final statement has been obtained one would be interested, correspondingly in either the real or the imaginary part of the result. Here h(t) is again the Heaviside step function, according to which the real part of the strain history represents a step at zero time with amplitude ε0 . The evaluation of the appropriate response may be accomplished with the general modulus representation so that substitution of (3.22) and (3.38) into (3.12) or (3.13) renders, after an interchange in the order of integration, ∞ dς τ(t) = 2ε0 μ∞ + H (ς) exp(−t/ς) ς t t −ξ H (ς) exp − ς 0 0 dς × exp(iωξ) dξ ς ∞
0
+ Fb (0)D(t) = ks Δl .
and the creep compliance can be determined and the determination of the Prony series parameters proceeds without difficulty [3.21–26] The additional inherent characteristic of this (hybrid) experimental–computational approach is that it may be used for determining the limit of linearly viscoelastic behavior of the material. By determining the two material functions of creep and relaxation simultaneously one can examine whether the determined functions satisfy the essential linearity constraint, see (3.62)–(3.64) t D(t − ξ)E(ξ) dξ = t . (3.37)
+ 2ε0 iω
59
Part A 3.2
Fb (t) = Fs (t) = kb (t)Δls (t) = ks [Δl − Δlb (t)] ,
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
60
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
t + 2ε0 iωμ∞
exp(iωξ) dξ ,
(3.39)
0
which ultimately leads to τ(t) = 2ε0 [μ(t) − μ∞ ] ∞ iωH (ς) − 2ε0 exp(−t/ς) dς 1 + iως 0
∞ iωH (ς) dς . + 2ε(t) μ∞ + 1 + iως
(3.40)
Part A 3.2
0
The first two terms are transient in nature and (eventually) die out, while the third term represents the steady-state response. For the interpretation of measurements it is important to appreciate the influence of the transient terms on the measurements. Even though a standard linear solid, represented by the spring–dashpot analog in Fig. 3.7 does not reflect the full spectral range of engineering materials, it provides a simple demonstration for the decay of the transient terms. Its relaxation modulus (in shear, for example) is given by μ(t) = μ∞ + μs exp(−t/ζ0 ) ,
(3.41)
where ζ0 denotes the relaxation time and μ∞ and μs are modulus parameters. Using the imaginary part of (3.40) corresponding to the start-up deformation history ε(t) = ε0 sin(ωt)h(t) one finds for the corresponding stress history ωζ0 μs τ(t) =R= (cos ωt + ωζ0 sin ωt) 2μ∞ ε0 μ∞ 1 + ω2 ζ02 ωζ0 μs e−t/ζn . (3.42) − μ∞ 1 + ω2 ζ02 F
μ
η
μ0 F
The last term is the transient. An exemplary presentation with μs /μ∞ = 5, ωζ0 = 1, and ζ0 = 20 is shown in Fig. 3.8. For longer relaxation times the decay lasts longer; for shorter ones the converse is true. One readily establishes that in this example the decay is (exponentially) complete after four to five times the relaxation time. The implication for real materials with very long relaxation times deserves extended attention. The expression for the standard linear solid can be generalized by replacing (3.41) with the corresponding Prony series representation. 1 ωζn μn τ(t) = (cos ωt + ωζn sin ωt) 2μ∞ ε0 μ∞ n 1 + ω2 ζn2 1 ωζn μn −t/ζn0 e . (3.43) − μ∞ n 1 + ω2 ζn2 Upon noting that the fractions in the last term sum do not exceed μn /2 one can bound the second sum by 1 ωζn μn −t/ζn0 e μ∞ n 1 + ω2 ζn2 1 1 μ(t) ≤ μn e−t/ζn0 = −1 . (3.44) 2μ∞ n 2 μ∞ This expression tends to zero only when t → ∞, a time frame that is, from an experimental point of view, too long in most instances. For relatively short times that fall into the transition range, the ratio of moduli is not small, as it can be on the order of 10 or 100, or even larger. There are, however, situations for which this error can be managed, and these correspond to those cases when the relaxation modulus changes very slowly during the time while sinusoidal measurements are being R 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 –1 –2 –3 –4 –5 –6 0
20
40
60
80
100
120 140 160 Normalized time
Fig. 3.7 Standard
Fig. 3.8 Transient start-up behavior of a standard linear
linear solid
solid under ε(t) = h(t) sin(ωt)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
τ(t) = μ∞ + 2ε(t)
∞ 0
iωH (ς) dς . 1 + iως
Both the strain ε(t) and the right-hand side are complex numbers. One calls μ∗ (ω) ≡ μ∞ +
∞ 0
iωH (ς) dς 1 + iως
Stress:
(3.46)
τ (t) sin[ωt +Δ(ω)] 2ε0 μ(ω) Strain:
1
the complex modulus μ∗ = μ (ω) + iμ (ω) with its real and imaginary parts defined by ∞ (ως)2 μ (ω) = μ∞ + H (ς) dς (3.47) 1 + (ως)2 0
(the storage modulus) and ∞ ως μ (ω) = H (ς) dς 1 + (ως)2
(3.48)
0
(the loss modulus), respectively. Polar representation allows the shorthand notation μ∗ = μ(ω) exp[iΔ(ω)] ,
(3.49)
where
μ (ω) and μ (ω) μ(ω) ≡ |μ∗ (ω)| = [μ (ω)]2 + [μ (ω)]2 , tan Δ(ω) =
(3.50)
so that, also μ (ω) = μ(ω) cos Δ(ω) and μ (ω) = μ(ω) sin Δ(ω) .
(3.51)
The complex stress response (3.45) can then be written, using (3.50), as τ(t) = 2ε(t)μ∗ (ω) = 2ε0 exp(iωt)μ(ω) exp[iΔ(ω)] , (3.52)
(3.45)
ε (t) = sin ωt ε0
t Δω
Fig. 3.9 Illustration of the frequency-dependent phase shift between the applied strain and the resulting stress
61
which may be separated into its real or imaginary part according to τ(t) = 2ε0 μ(ω) cos[ωt + Δ(ω)] and τ(t) = 2ε0 μ(ω) sin[ωt + Δ(ω)] .
(3.53)
Thus the effect of the viscoelastic material properties is to make the strain lag behind the stress (the strain is retarded) as illustrated in Fig. 3.9. It is easy to verify that the high- and low-frequency limits of the steadystate response are given by μ∗ (ω → ∞) = μ(t → 0) = μ0 , the glassy response, and μ∗ (ω → 0) = μ(t → ∞) = μ∞ , as the long-term or rubbery response (real). An Example for a Standard Linear Solid. For the stan-
dard linear solid (Fig. 3.7) the steady-state portion of the response (3.52) simplifies to ω2 ς02 , μ (ω) = μ∞ + μs 1 + ω2 ς02 ως0 μ (ω) = μs , (3.54) 1 + ω2 ς02 ως0 tan Δ(ω) = . (3.55) μ∞ /μs + (1 + μ∞ /μs )(ως0 )2
Part A 3.2
made. This situation arises when the material is near its glassy state or when it approaches rubbery behavior. As long as the modulus ratio can be considered nearly constant in the test period, the error simply offsets the test results by additive constant values that may be subtracted from the data. Clearly, that proposition does not hold when the material interrogation occurs around the middle of the transition range. There are many measurements being made with commercially available test equipment, when frequency scans or relatively short time blocks of different frequencies are applied to a test specimen at a set temperature, or while the specimen temperature is being changed continuously. In these situations the data reduction customarily does not recognize the transient nature of the measurements and caution is required so as not to interpret the results without further examination. Because viscoelastic materials dissipate energy, prolonged sinusoidal excitation generates rises in temperature. In view of the sensitivity of these materials to temperature changes as discussed in Sects. 3.2.7 and 3.2.8, care is in order not to allow such thermal build-up to occur unintentionally or not to take such changes into account at the time of test data evaluations. Consider now only the steady-state portion of (3.40) so that
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
62
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
which, upon using the transformation t − ξ = u, yields
Log of functions 3
τ(t) = iω 2ε(t)
2
∞
μ(u) e−iωu du = μ∗ (ω) .
If one recalls that the integral represents the Fourier transform F {μ(t), t → ω} of the modulus in the integrand one may write
1 0
μ∗ (ω) = iωF {μ(t), t → ω} –1
Part A 3.2
–2 –1.5
(3.59)
−∞
(3.60)
along with the inverse, –1
–0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5 2 2.5 Log frequency
Fig. 3.10 Steady-state response of a standard linear solid to
sinusoidal excitation, (μ0 = 1, μ = 100, μ/η = ς0 = 0.1). Symbols: μ (ω); short dash: μ (ω); long dash: tan Δ(ω)
While this material model is usually not suitable for representing real solids (its time frame is far too short), this simple analog model represents all the proper limit responses possessed by a real material, in that it has short-term (μ0 + μs , glassy), long-term (μ∞ , rubbery) as well as transient response behavior as illustrated in Fig. 3.10. Note that, with only one relaxation time present, the transition time scale is on the order of at most two decades. The more general representation of the viscoelastic functions under sinusoidal excitation can also be interpreted as a Fourier transform of the relaxation or creep response. Complex Properties as Fourier Transforms. It is often
desirable to derive the harmonic properties from monotonic response behaviors (relaxation or creep). To effect this consider the strain excitation of (3.38), ε(t) = ε0 exp(iωt)h(t) ,
(3.56)
and substitute this into the convolution relation for the stress (3.11), t μ(t − ξ)
τ(t) = 2ε(0)μ(t) + 2 0−
dε(ξ) dξ , dξ
(3.57)
and restrict consideration to the steady-state response. In this case, the lower limit is at t → −∞ so that the integral may be written as t μ(t − ξ) eiωξ dξ ,
τ(t) = lim 2ε0 iω t→∞
−t
(3.58)
μ(t) =
1 2π
∞ −∞
μ∗ (ω) −iωt dω . e iω
(3.61)
Thus the relaxation modulus can be computed from the complex modulus by the last integral. Note also that because of (3.60) μ and μ are derivable from a single function, μ(t), so that they are not independent. Conversely, if one measures μ and μ in a laboratory they should obey a certain interrelation; a deviation in that respect may be construed either as unsatisfactory experimental work or as evidence of nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior. Relationships Among Properties In Sect. 3.2.2 exemplary functional representation of some properties has been described that are generic for the description of any viscoelastic property. On the other hand, the situation often arises that a particular function is determined experimentally relatively readily, but really its complementary function is needed. The particularly simple situation most often encountered is that the modulus is known, but the compliance is needed (or vice versa). This case will be dealt with first. Consider the case when the relaxation modulus (in shear), μ(t) is known, and the (shear) creep compliance J(t) is desired. Clearly, the modulus and the compliance cannot be independent material functions. In the linearly elastic case these relations lead to reciprocal relations between modulus and compliance. One refers to such relationships as inverse relations or functions. Analogous treatments hold for all other viscoelastic functions. Recall (3.10) or (3.11), which give the shear stress in terms of an arbitrary strain history. In the linearly elastic case these inverse relations lead to reciprocal relations between modulus and compliance. Recall also that the creep compliance is the strain history resulting from a step stress being imposed in a shear test. As a corollary, if the prescribed strain
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
history is the creep compliance, then a constant (step) stress history must evolve. Accordingly, substitution of the compliance J(t) into (3.10) must render the step stress of unit amplitude so that t h(t) = J(0)μ(t) +
μ(t − ξ)
dJ(ξ) dξ . dξ
(3.62)
0+ + → 0 , J(0+ )/μ(0+ ) = 1
t μ(t − ξ)J(ξ) dξ = t .
(3.63)
0
Note that this relation is completely symmetric in the sense that, also, t J(t − ξ)μ(ξ) dξ = t .
(3.64)
0
Similar relations hold for the uniaxial modulus E(t) and its creep compliance D(t), and for the bulk modulus K (t) and bulk compliance M(t). Interrelation for Complex Representation. Because
the so-called harmonic or complex material characterization is the result of prescribing a specific time history with the frequency as a single time-like (but constant) parameter, the interrelation between the complex modulus and the corresponding compliance is simple. It follows from equations (3.45) and (3.46) that 1 2ε0 eiωt 2ε(t) = ∗ = = J ∗ (ω) , τ(t) μ (ω) τ0 ei(ωt+Δ(ω))
(3.65)
where the function J ∗ (ω) is the complex shear compliance, with the component J (ω) and imaginary component −J (ω) related to the complex modulus by J ∗ (ω) = J (ω) − iJ (ω) = J(ω)eiγ (ω) =
1 e−iΔ(ω) = μ∗ (ω) μ(ω)
(3.66)
so that, clearly, 1 and γ (ω) = −Δ(ω) , μ(ω) with J(ω) = [J (ω)]2 + [J (ω)]2 . J(ω) =
(3.67)
63
Thus in the frequency domain of the harmonic material description the interconnection between properties is purely algebraic. Corresponding relations for the bulk behavior follow readily from here.
3.2.7 Dissipation Under Cyclical Deformation In view of the immediately following discussion of the influence of temperature on the time dependence of viscoelastic materials we point out that general experience tells us that cyclical deformations engender heat dissipation with an attendant rise in temperature [3.34, 35]. How the heat generated in a viscoelastic solid as a function of the stress or strain amplitude is described in [3.13]. Here it suffices to point out that the heat generation is proportional to the magnitude of the imaginary part of the harmonic modulus or compliance. For this reason these (magnitudes of imaginary parts of the) properties are often referred to as the loss modulus or the loss compliance. We simply quote here a typical result for the energy w dissipated per cycle and unit volume, and refer the reader to [3.13] for a quick, but more detailed exposition: ∞ 2mπ m ε2m μ (3.68) . w/cycle = π T m=1
3.2.8 Temperature Effects Temperature is one of the most important environmental variables to affect polymers in engineering use, primarily because normal use conditions are relatively close to the material characteristic called the glasstransition temperature – or glass temperature for short. In parochial terms the glass temperature signifies the temperature at which the material changes from a stiff or hard material to a soft or compliant one. The major effect of the temperature, however perceived by the user, is through its influence on the creep or relaxation time scale of the material. Solids other than polymers also possess characteristic temperatures, such as the melting temperature in metals, while the melting temperature in the polymer context signifies specifically the melting of crystallites in (semi-)crystalline variants. Also, typical amorphous solids such as silicate glasses and amorphous metals exhibit distinct glass-transition temperatures; indeed, much of our understanding of glass-transition phenomena in polymers originated in understanding related phenomena in the context of silicate glasses.
Part A 3.2
Note that, as t so that at time 0+ an elastic result prevails. Upon integrating both sides of (3.62) with respect to time – or alternatively, using the Laplace transform – one readily arrives at the equivalent result; the uniaxial counterpart has already been cited effectively in (3.37).
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
64
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.2
The Entropic Contribution Among the long-chain polymers, elastomers possess a molecular structure that comes closest to our idealized understanding of molecular interaction. Elastomer is an alternative name for rubber, a cross-linked polymer that possesses a glass transition temperature which is distinctly below normal environmental conditions. Molecule segments are freely mobile relative to each other except for being pinned at the cross-link sites. The classical constitutive behavior under moderate deformations (up to about 100% strain in uniaxial tension) has been formulated by Treloar [3.36]. Because this constitutive formulation involves the entropy of a deformed rubber network, this temperature effect of the properties is usually called the entropic temperature effect. In the present context it suffices to quote his results in the form of the constitutive law for an incompressible solid. Of common interest is the dependence of the stress on the material property appropriate for uniaxial tension (in the 1-direction) 1 1 2 subject to λ1 λ2 λ3 = 1 , σ = NkT λ1 − 3 λ1 (3.69)
where λ1 , λ2 , and λ3 denote the (principal) stretch ratios of the deformation illustrated in Fig. 3.11 (though not shown for the condition λ1 λ2 λ3 = 1), the multiplicative factor consists of the number of chain segments between cross-links N, k is Boltzmann’s constant, and T is absolute temperature. Since for infinitesimal deformations λ1 = 1 + ε11 , one finds that NkT must equal the elastic Young’s modulus E ∞ . Thus the (small-strain) Young’s modulus is directly proportional to the absolute temperature, and this holds also for the shear modulus because, under the restriction/assumption of incompressibility the shear modulus μ∞ of the rubber
obeys μ∞ = 13 E ∞ . Thus μ∞ /T = Nk is a material constant, from which it follows that comparative moduli obtained at temperatures T and T0 are related by T μ∞|T = μ∞|T0 or equivalently T0 T E ∞|T = E ∞|T0 . (3.70) T0 If one takes into account that temperature changes affect also the dimensions of a test specimen by changing both its cross-sectional area and length, this is taken into account by modifying (3.71) to include the density ratio according to ρT μ∞|T0 or equivalently μ∞|T = ρ0 T0 ρT E ∞|T = E ∞|T0 , (3.70a) ρ0 T0 where ρ0 is the density at the reference temperature and ρ is that for the test conditions. To generate a master curve as discussed below it is therefore necessary to first multiply modulus data by the ratio of the absolute temperature T (or ρT , if the densities at the two temperatures are sufficiently different) at which the data was acquired, and the reference temperature T0 (or ρ0 T0 ). For compliance data one multiplies by the inverse density/temperature ratio. Time–Temperature Trade-Off Phenomenon A generally much more significant influence of temperature on the viscoelastic behavior is experienced in connection with the time scales under relaxation or creep. To set the proper stage we define first the notion of the glass-transition temperature Tg . To this end consider a measurement of the specific volume as a function Volume
λ1
λ3
λ2
B A Equilibrium line
Fig. 3.11 Deformation of a cube into a parallelepiped. The
unit cube sides have been stretched (contracted) orthogonally in length to the stretch ratios λ1 , λ2 , and λ3
Tg
Temperature
Fig. 3.12 Volume–temperature relation for amorphous solids (polymers)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
log G (t) Experimental window
sensitive properties, at least for polymers. For ease of presentation we ignore first the entropic temperature effect discussed. The technological evolution of metallic glasses is relatively recent, so that a limited amount of data exist in this regard. However, new data on the applicability of the time–temperature trade-off in these materials have been supplied in [3.12]. Moreover, we limit ourselves to considerations above the glass-transition temperature, with discussion of behavior around or below that temperature range reserved for later amplification. Experimental constraints usually do not allow the full time range of relaxation to be measured at any one temperature. Instead, measurements can typically be made only within the time frame of a certain experimental window, as indicated in Fig. 3.13. This figure shows several (idealized) segments as resulting from different temperature environments at a fixed (usually atmospheric) pressure. A single curve may be constructed from these segments by shifting the temperature segments along the log-time axis (indicated by arrows) with respect to one obtained at a (reference) temperature chosen arbitrarily, to construct the master curve. This master curve is then accepted as the response of the material over the extended time range at the chosen reference temperature. Because this time– temperature trade-off has been deduced from physical measurements without the benefit of a time scale of unlimited extent, the assurance that this shift process is a physically acceptable or valid scheme can be derived only from the quality with which the shifting or
P = P0 T1
T0 = T3
⎛ σ 273 ⎛ ⎜ (psi) ⎝ ε0 T ⎝
log0 ⎜ 5
T3
Temperature (°C) –30.0 –25.0 –22.5 –22.0 –17.5 –15.0 –12.5 –7.5 –5.0 –2.5 5.0
T2 T4
log aT4
4
Master curve at T3
3
T5
ε0 = 0.05
T1 < T2 < ···
Fig. 3.13 Illustration of the temperature shift phenomenon.
Segments of G(t) measured at different temperatures, and corresponding master curves
2 –2
–1
0
1
2 3 log10 t (min)
Fig. 3.14 Relaxation modulus for a polyurethane formula-
tion measured at various temperatures in uniaxial tension
65
Part A 3.2
of temperature. Typically, such measurements are made with a slowly decreasing temperature, curve A in Fig. 3.12, because the rate of cooling has an influence on the outcome. Figure 3.12 shows a typical result, which illustrates that at sufficiently low and high temperatures the volume dependence is linear, with a transition connecting the two segments. The glass-transition temperature is defined as the intersection of two linear extensions of the two segments roughly in the center of the transition range. As also indicated in Fig. 3.12, an increase in the rate of cooling causes reduced volume shrinkage as a result of the unstable evolution of a molecular microstructure that consolidates with time, curve B in Fig. 3.12. This phenomenon is associated with physical aging [3.37– 44]. In practical terms the lowest – most stable – response curve is determined basically by the patience of the investigator, though substantial deviations must be measured in terms of logarithmic time units: Relatively little may be gained by reducing the cooling rate from 1 to 0.1 ◦ C/h. We turn next to the effect of temperature on the time scale and present this phenomenon in terms of a relaxation response, say, in shear. The discussion is generic in the sense that it applies, to the best of the collective scientific knowledge, to all time- and rate-
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
66
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
superposition can be accomplished. To examine this quality issue requires that test temperatures are chosen sufficiently closely, and that the measurements vary as widely as feasible over the log-time range to afford maximum overlap of the shifted curve segments. The amount of shifting along the log-time axis is recorded as a function of the temperature. This function is usually called the temperature-dependent shift factor, or simply the shift factor for short; it is a material characteristic, and is often designated by φT . Figures 3.14 and 3.15 illustrate the application of the shift principle for a polyurethane elastomer, together with the associated shift factor φT in Fig. 3.16.
Part A 3.2
The Role of the Entropic Contribution Having demonstrated the shift phenomenon in principle, it remains to address the effect of the entropic contribution to the time-dependent master response. Recall that the entropic considerations were derived in the context of purely rubbery material behavior, and specifically in the absence of viscoelastic effects. Thus any modulus variation with temperature is established, strictly speaking, only in the long-term time domain when rubbery behavior dominates, so that (3.70) applies. Various arguments have been put forward [3.45] to apply a similar reduction scheme to data in the viscoelastic transition
log (shift factor) 8
region. Two arguments dominate, but they are based on pragmatic rather than rigorously scientific principles. The first argument states that, even in the transition region, the polymer chain segments experience locally elastic behavior in accordance with the theory of rubber elasticity. Accordingly, all curve segments obtained at the various temperatures should be multiplied by their respective ratios of the reference temperature and the test temperature, i. e., T0 /T , in the case of modulus measurements, and with the inverse ratio in the case of compliance measurements, regardless of by how many log-time units the material behavior is removed from the rubbery (long-term) domain. The alternative view asserts that the entropic correction does not apply in the glassy state and, accordingly should decrease continuously from the long-term, rubbery domain as the glassy or short-term behavior is approached. The rule by which this change occurs is not established scientifically either, but is typically taken to be linear with the logarithmic time scale throughout the transition. Ultimately one needs to decide on the basis of the precision in the data whether one or the other scheme produces the better master curve. The crucial argument in that decision is whether the mutual overlap of the segments derived from measurements at different temperatures provides for the most continuous and smoothest master curve. The Shift Factor While several researchers have contributed significantly to clarifying the concept and the importance of the
6 4
log10 (273/T ) E (t) (psi) 5
2
4.5
Reference temperature T0 = 0 °C 5% strain
4
0
3.5 –2 3 –4 – 40
–30
–20
–10
0
10 20 Temperature
Fig. 3.15 Time–temperature shift factor for reducing the polyurethane data in Fig. 3.14 to that in Fig. 3.16. Tg = −18 ◦ C The solid line represents the WLF-equation
−8.86(T − 32 ◦ C) − 4.06 log10 φT = 101.6 + (T − 32 ◦ C)
2.5 2 –9 –8 –7 –6 –5 –4 –3 –2 –1 0 1 2 log10 t/φT (min)
Fig. 3.16 Temperature-reduced uniaxial relaxation modulus for a polyurethane formulation derived from data in Fig. 3.14 and with the shift factors in Fig. 3.15
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
log(aT ) =
c1 (T − Tref ) , c2 − (T − Tref )
(3.71)
where Tref denotes an arbitrarily chosen reference temperature typically about 50 ◦ C above the glasstransition temperature of the polymer under consideration. The constants c1 and c2 vary from polymer to polymer, but for many take on values around c1 ∼ = 8.86 and c2 ∼ = 101.6. In terms of the relaxation data in Fig. 3.14, the shift procedure renders the composite or master curve as shown in Fig. 3.16. Time–Temperature Trade-Off under Transient Temperature Conditions While the time–temperature shift principle is observed in the laboratory under different temperatures, which are however constant during the measurements, there are many situations in the engineering environment in which temperatures vary more or less continuously while creep or relaxation processes occur. To assess how such thermal changes affect the viscoelastic response, Morland and Lee proposed [3.54], following the ideas promulgated in the practice developed for the silicate glasses, that the time–temperature shift relation applies instantaneously. Let T0 denote the reference temperature at which the master curve has been established and let T be the temperature at which the material behavior is desired. Then the developments in Sect. 3.2.8 above state that the time (scale) at a temperature T , and designated by t , is related to the time (scale) t at the reference temperature by
t =
t . φT (T )
(3.72)
Instantaneous obeyance to this rule requires then that (3.72) apply differentially as the temperature
changes with time, namely dt or alternatively that dt = φt (T (t)) t dt . t = φT (T (t))
67
(3.73)
0
While such an integration can always be effected numerically, in principle, it is important to note that the logarithmic time scale calls for careful evaluations of the integrals with variable time steps, yet without incurring excessive computation time or inaccurate evaluations resulting from too crude an incrementation of time [3.55]. Time–Temperature Shifting Near and Below the Glass Transition. The time–temperature shifting above the
glass-transition temperature has been presented as basically an empirical rather than a uniquely explained process, though many researchers firmly trust its validity because of extensively consistent demonstration (see, e.g., [3.45, 50]). The applicability of the shift principle to temperatures near and below the glass transition has been questioned for many years, but is gradually gaining acceptance with certain provisos. First, no functional analytic form has been proposed – uniquely supportive or conflicting – that yields credence to the effect in terms of some molecular model. Moreover, because phenomena at and below the glass transition do not occur with molecular conformations in equilog [E (t)] (Pa) 9.6 22 °C
9.4
35°C 50°C 65°C
9.2
80°C 90°C
9
100°C 105°C
8.8
0
1
2
3
4
5 log (t) (s)
Fig. 3.17 Relaxation behavior in shear for PMMA at various temperatures in the transition range and below the glass transition; the glass-transition temperature is 105 ◦ C. (Material supplier: ACE. After [3.15])
Part A 3.2
time–temperature superposition principle [3.46–49], it was the group of Williams, Landel, and Ferry [3.50] that has been credited with formulating the time– temperature relationship through the now ubiquitously quoted WLF equation. They demonstrated the near universality of this connection for many diverse polymers, and provided a physical model for the process in terms of a free-volume interpretation. Plazek [3.51– 53] has supplied an exemplary demonstration of the nearly perfect obeyance of the shift phenomenon for polystyrene and poly(vinyl acetate). Ignoring, for brevity of presentation, the details of the polymer mechanical argumentation, WLF derived on the basis of free-volume concepts that above the glass-transition temperature the shift factor is given by the relation
3.2 Linear Viscoelasticity
68
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
rates leading to a more unique adherence to a shift concept. Figure 3.17 shows relaxation data of polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) at various (constant) temperatures below the glass transition (Tg =105 ◦ C for PMMA). This data, shifted to produce the master curve in Fig. 3.18, generates a shift factor, that while not fitting the WLF equation (3.71), represents nevertheless a reasonably coherent relation [3.15], as shown in Fig. 3.19. Many independent, but not thoroughly documented, counterparts have been produced over the last decade, which present equally supportive information of a consistent time–temperature superposition application through and below the glass transition.
log [ µ (t)] (Pa) 9.2 8.8 8.4 8 7.6 7.2
Part A 3.2
6.8 –10
–5
0
5
10 log (t) (s)
Fig. 3.18 Relaxation in PMMA, reduced (shifted) commensurate with the shift function in Fig. 3.19. The entropic correction has not been applied to the vertical axis (Material supplier: ACE. After [3.15])
librium, the ideas underlying the shift phenomenon above the glass transition are questioned more readily in the context of these lower temperatures. For example, the role of nonequilibrium changes in freevolume interferes with simple concepts and complicates the rules by which such examinations and data interpretations are carried out. For example, Losi and Knauss [3.56] have argued on the basis of free-volume considerations that any shift operation below the glass transition should depend on the temperature rate with which the state of the polymer is approached, slower
3.2.9 The Effect of Pressure on Viscoelastic Behavior of Rubbery Solids It is important to recognize that pressure can have a large effect on the viscoelastic response through its influence on the free volume. This fact is important when high speed impact is involved, such as when measurements are made with split Hopkinson bars, or when materials are otherwise subjected to high pressures (civil engineering: building support pads for protection against earthquake damage). Similar to the time–temperature trade-off, pressure produces a pressure-sensitive shift phenomenon. Figlog G (t) Experimental window T = T0
log [φT (t)] (s) 12
P5 Shift factor for E (t)
10
P0 = P3
P3 P4
8 6
P2
log aP2
4 Master curve at P3
2
P1
0 –2
0
25
50
75
100 125 Temperature (°C)
Fig. 3.19 Shift factor derived from Fig. 3.17 to generate the master curve in Fig. 3.18 (after [3.15])
P1 < P2 < ···
Fig. 3.20 Effect of pressure on the viscoelastic response of a polymer (after [3.57])
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
θ(P) = f T0 (P)/βf (P) and P P f T0 (P) = κe T0 dP − κφ T0 dP P0
(3.75)
P0
with κe denoting the compressibility of the entire volume, and κφ is the compressibility of the occupied volume. If we let K e∗ (T ) be the bulk modulus at zero pressure and κe a proportionality constant, one arrives at log αT,P = −
c00 1 [T − T0 − θ(P)]
with c00 2 (P) + T − T0 − θ(P) 1 + c06 P 1 + c04 P 0 − c θ(P) = c03 (P) ln (P) ln 5 1 + c04 P 1 + c06 P (3.76)
and the notation c00 1 = B/2.303 f 0 ;
c00 2 = f 0 /βf (P) ;
c00 3 = 1/kr βf (P) ;
∗ c00 4 = ke /K e ;
= 1/kφ βf (P) ;
∗ c00 6 = kφ /K φ .
c00 5
(3.77)
The 00 superscript indicates that the parameter is referred to the reference temperature T0 (first place) and to the reference pressure P0 (second place). A single 0 superscript refers to the reference temperature only. The asterisk superscript refers to zero pressure. Equation (3.76) is the Fillers–Moonan–Tschoegl (FMT) equation. Setting θ(P) = 0 (i. e., performing the experiments at the reference pressure), the FMT equation reduces to the WLF equation (3.71).
3.2.10 The Effect of Moisture and Solvents on Viscoelastic Behavior It has been observed that the presence of moisture in some polymers has an effect similar to that of an elevated temperature in that increased moisture content shortens the relaxation or retardation times [3.63, 64]. This process may or may not be reversible. Plazek [3.52] has pointed out, for example, that in polyvinyl acetate moisture must be removed carefully prior to forming centimeter-sized test samples. Once such larger test samples have absorbed (some) moisture, it may be impossible to totally remove the same. In determining viscoelastic properties it is thus important that one assess the tendency of the material to absorb moisture or other solvents. This property can be disturbing during the acquisition of mechanical properties if no specific precautions are taken: For example, measurements performed on days during changing humidity may render data that violates the concept of time–temperature trade-off. A technologically important material with a considerable tendency to absorb moisture is nylon (6 and 66), with corresponding implications for the deformability and/or structural load-carrying ability over time.
3.3 Measurements and Methods A considerable range of commercial equipment has been developed over the years to characterize viscoelastic material behavior. Such instrumentation for tensile and compression tests are standard screw-type test frames (Instron, Zwick) or servohydraulic machines (MTS, Instron); the latter type are available for torsional (shear) and combined tensile/torsional characterization, also. Because of the sensitivity to environmental temperatures, these machines are usually equipped – or should be – with environmental control chambers
69
(temperature and moisture control). Differential thermal analyzers (DTAs) are available commercially to measure glass transition and melt temperatures, though they are sometimes combined with force measurement capability, and these devices often function with short, stubby bend specimens and, as typically used, provide more qualitative rather than precise property measurements. Similarly, dynamical mechanical analyzers (DMAs) are more geared to making mechanical properties measurements and can employ either steady-state
Part A 3.3
ure 3.20 illustrates this material behavior parallel to the time–temperature shift phenomenon. Without delving into the molecular reasoning for modeling this phenomenon [3.58] we quote here the results by Fillers, Moonan, and Tschoegl [3.59–62], which extend the temperature shift factor into a consolidated temperature-and-pressure shift factor of the form (note the similarity to the WLF equation (3.71)) B log αT,P = − 2.303 f 0 T − T0 − θ(P) × , (3.74) f 0 /αf (P) + T − T0 − θ(P) where
3.3 Measurements and Methods
70
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.3
loading or oscillatory excitation for frequency sensitive properties, though here the same caveat is in order as for work with DTAs. For frequency imposed shear deformations (rotation) commercial test equipment is available and accessible over the web (e.g., Google→Rheometrics). Except for nanoindentation equipment, to be discussed later, other instrumentation is constructed for specific tasks. For example, Plazek has provided an exemplary construction of long-term measurement equipment [3.65] that provides precise force/moment definition and recording equipment that is unusually stable over long periods approaching six decades of time. A thoughtful design of a torsion pendulum for shorter time frames has been supplied by the same researcher [3.66]. A rheometer utilizing an eddy-current torque transducer and an air-bearing suspension has been developed by Berry et al. [3.67] for measurements of creep functions in shear in both the time and frequency domains. For investigating the interaction of shear and volume response, Duran and McKenna [3.68] developed a torsiometer with ultrafine temperature control to access time-dependent changes in volume resulting from the torsion of a cylinder, with the volume change being monitored via a mercury column.
3.3.1 Laboratory Concerns While test procedures for typical material characterization have been in place in the laboratory for many years, there are special considerations that apply to the determination of viscoelastic properties. Because usually long-term measurements are in order, careful attention needs to be paid to temporal consistency of the equipment. The most important and often recurring issues are discussed here briefly. Equipment Stability Because often extensive time intervals are needed to record data, the associated electrical equipment needs to be commensurately stable for long periods of time. Often electronic equipment will record data without drift for periods of an hour or two. However, with the desire to record data for as long as days, one needs to be assured that during that time interval the equipment does not drift or does not do so to a significant extent. The easiest way of checking stability is by trial. Environmental Control All polymers are sensitive to thermal variations and many also to moisture changes. While sometimes only
quick and rough estimation of physical properties are desired, careful measurements demand absolute environmental control that can be afforded only through suitable environmental chambers, most often matched to existing or purchased test frame systems. How closely environmental control must be exercised depends on the study at hand: Thermal control ranges that may be necessary can be estimated with the aid of the shift factor delineated in Sect. 3.2.8. Moisture control may be exercised by way of saline solutions if the test chamber is relatively small, or by injecting suitably proportioned streams of dry and water saturated air into the (larger) test chamber [3.63]. The degree to which moisture influences the time-dependent behavior may be estimated from volume considerations if the swelling from moisture of the material is known (it may have to be measured separately). One estimates that the moisture-induced volume change equals a thermally induced volume change, from which consideration one deduces the influence of moisture via Sect. 3.2.8 in the form of an equivalent temperature sensitivity. From this information one may estimate whether the potential moisture influence is disturbingly large. The Use of Wire and Foil Strain Gages on Polymers It is clear on general principles that the use of wire/foil gages is ill advised for soft materials because one typically needs to ignore the effect of reinforcing the test material by the stiff, if thin, gage(s). While it has been extensively attempted to develop strain-measuring devices with foil gages for application to relatively soft solids (solid propellant rocket fuels) with the aid of computational and experimental analysis tools, these costly programs have not yielded useful results. In contrast, wire/foil gages are, however, used on rigid polymers. As has been demonstrated amply in the above developments, polymer mechanical responses can be very sensitive to temperatures. This fact is important to remember in connection with the use of electric-currentdriven strain gages bonded to polymers. Because these devices dissipate heat in immediate proximity to the polymer, this phenomenon needs to be controlled. While it is true that in the past strain gages have been bonded to metallic structures without much concern for the thermal effects on the bonding agent, it must be remembered that these bonding agents had been developed with this special concern in mind, being also well aware that the metallic component usually
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
Soft Materials Most of the more standard engineering materials are relatively solid or stiff, so that clamping a specimen in the jaws of a typical test machine poses no particular problem. However, many polymers are either relatively soft (to the touch) or when stiff nevertheless will creep out of the machine gripping device(s) over time. Because the expected response may be a decrease over time (as in a relaxation test), a slow flow of material out of the gripping jaws may not become apparent unless careful tracking of that potential process is achieved. This problem is most prevalent, for example, when dealing with near-rubbery behavior under tension, because tension invokes Poisson contraction, which is maximal under these conditions (ν = 1/2) and thus most prone to give
71
rise to jaw flow. The traditional way to cope with this type of occurrence is to bond metal (aluminum) tabs to the ends of a specimen so as to redistribute the clamping forces. Mechanical Overshoot Phenomenon When relaxation tests are of interest the usual test machines provide a ramp history, as discussed in Sect. 3.2.6. If examined in detail these ramp histories typically exhibit an overshoot phenomenon that derives from the dynamics (inertia) of the test machine. Recall that it is usually of interest to gain access to as large a test duration as possible. Basically three avenues are open to the investigator, depending on the need for precision and necessary time range:
1. The time history involving the loading transients are ignored by disregarding the initial time history extending over ten times the ramp rise time. This is a serious experimental restriction, but represents the method most consistently practised in the past. 2. Expand the initial time scale by resorting to the method described in [3.32] or [3.33], remaining conscious, however, that the overshoot between the linear rise and constant deformation history should not interfere with the assumptions underlying these approximations. This means that the deformation history has to be carefully recorded. 3. Write out in closed form the response to the full ramp history and fit this analytical expression to the measurement data. With a Prony series representation it is advisable to choose a series representation that contains at least as many terms as are desired for the test duration. While this may be a tedious algebraic process, it may not be easily possible to achieve the same goal without a Prony-series representation. The overshoot phenomenon would then require a judicious redacting of the data so as to eliminate the inaccuracies derived from it. 4. The final, most precise method to date would entail a careful measurement of the deformation history, including the overshoot modeled by an integrable function, and apply the same representation method indicated under (3) above.
3.3.2 Volumetric (Bulk) Response In this section we distinguish between methods geared to determining small-strain volumetric properties and those derived from non-infinitesimal volumetric deformations.
Part A 3.3
provided excellent heat conductivity. Even so, it is a common, if not universal, practice to activate the electric current in the strain gage(s) only intermittently so as to reduce the heat generation. If foil gages are desired, the sufficiency of this option must certainly be considered. The overriding consideration in this connection is the temperature achieved at the strain gage site relative to the glass-transition temperature of the polymer, on the one hand, and the duration of the measurements on the other. Thus, a strain gage may well serve on a polymer in a wave propagation experiment, but may fail miserably in similar circumstances if the test time is measured in weeks. As a quick rule of thumb it is our recommendation that temperatures under a gage remain 50 ◦ C below the glass-transition temperature for applications of short duration. Ultimately, one must consider the relaxation or creep behavior of the polymer for the range of temperatures anticipated in the experiment, whereby a fractional change in stiffness must be estimated for the expected duration of the measurements. Clearly, one needs to be concerned with both the temperature and the test duration. This estimation may actually require that the temperature in the gage vicinity be determined experimentally (infrared tooling) and the results coupled with a numerical stress analysis assessment of the effect on the gage readout(s). Here it should also be remembered that modulus and compliance data are typically presented on a logarithmic scale, making changes due to temperature appear small, when in fact the true change is considerably larger. An error on the order of 10–15% in misinterpreted modulus data could translate into a commensurately large and systematic error in the ultimate, experimental results.
3.3 Measurements and Methods
72
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.3
Very Small Volumetric Strains In linearly elastic materials bulk behavior is most typically determined (a) directly from wave propagation measurements or (b) indirectly from shear or Young’s modulus data together with Poisson’s ratio as measured, e.g., from the antielastic curvature of beams. For viscoelastic solids other methods need to be employed with nontrivial equipment requirements. In our experience, this method has not been applied to viscoelastic materials. The dominant reason is, most likely, that the formation of an optical gap between the specimen and the reference mirrors, which would rest on the specimen edges, must cope with the deformations generated by the weight of the reference mirror. Absent a local reference mirror an interferometric assessment of the deformation field would require the subtraction of the overall specimen deformation from the curvatureinclusive deformation pattern, a process that is prone to lead to relatively large errors. For viscoelastic solids other methods need to be employed with non-trivial equipment requirements. Because the effort is considerable (see the historical development starting with [3.69, 70]) the details of this measurement method are not presented here, other than to point out via Fig. 3.21 what is involved in principle. As illustrated in Fig. 3.21, one process revolves around a stiff cavity to receive a specimen, after which the cavity is filled with an appropriate liquid with which the specimen does not interact (by swelling or otherwise). A piezoelectric driver generates (relatively) small sinusoidal pressure variations, which compress the specimen in a quasistatic manner as long as the cavity size is chosen appropriately. A separate piezoelectric a)
pick-up measures the pressure response with respect to both amplitude and phase shift relative to the input pressure. The compressibility of the liquid having been determined by calibration, the specimen compressibility modifies the cavity signal (by a small amount). From the (complex) difference one derives the harmonic bulk modulus or compliance. Because these are difference measurements, the precision for the bulk behavior requires the ultimate in precision in instrumentation and calibration. A major limitation of this approach is that because of potential resonances the range of frequencies is also limited to less than four decades of frequency (time). For further detail the reader may wish to consult the references [3.71, 72]. Bulk Measurements Allowing also for Non-infinitesimal Volume Strains An alternative method, though associated typically with larger volume strains, has been offered successfully by Ma and Ravi–Chandar [3.73, 74], Qvale and RaviChandar [3.75], and Park et al. [3.76], who followed the same method. This method involves a hollow cylinder instrumented with strain gages on its exterior surface. A physically closely fitting solid specimen is formed in, or introduced into, its interior and pressure is applied through an axially closely fitting compression piston, as illustrated in Fig. 3.22. Proper choice of the cylinder material and its wall thickness allows optimization of the response measurements to, say, a constant piston displacement (bulk relaxation) from which the bulk relaxation modulus can then be determined. If the cylinder is manufactured from a material that remains elastic during a test (say steel), with a and b denoting its interb)
Electrode
Oil outlet
Electrical feed-through
Teflon washer Outlet needle valve Cavity
Oil outlet
Piezoelectric disk
Specimen
Grid for specimen support Inlet needle valve
Electrode
K-Seal
Oil inlet
Oil inlet
Fig. 3.21 (a) Global and (b) local cavity arrangement for measuring the bulk modulus with harmonic excitation
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
Confining cylinder
3.3 Measurements and Methods
2 ezz (t) = [ezz (t) − err (t)] , 3 1 err (t) = eθθ (t) = − [ezz (t) − err (t)] , (3.81) 3 which are connected by the constitutive relations
(Steel) loading pins
t σkk (t) = 3σm (t) = 3
Strain gage(s)
t sij (t) = 2
μ(t − ξ)
−∞
bulk response
nal and external radius, respectively, the circumferential strain εθ on the exterior surface is related to the internal pressure σrr and the strains on the cylindrical specimen surface εrr = εθθ by (b/a)2 − 1 c E εh , σrr (t) = σθθ (t) = − 2 2 1 c c b εrr (t) = εθθ (t) = εh (t) (1 − v ) + (1 + v ) 2 , 2 a σzz (t) = σa (t) , (3.78) εzz (t) = εa (t) , where the usual nomenclature of radial coordinates applies, E c and vc are the elastic properties of the (steel) cylinder, and the subscript ‘a’ refers to the axially oriented stress and strain as determined, respectively, from the load cell of the test frame or measured by the relative motion of the pressure pistons. Upon expressing the stress and strain fields in the specimen into dilatational and deviatoric (shear) components by using the mean stress 1 (3.79) σm (t) = [σzz (t) + 2σrr (t)] 3 and the dilatation (3.80)
Along with the usual definition of deviatoric components of stress sij (t) and strain eij (t),
∂δ(ξ) dξ , ∂ξ
∂δ(ξ) dξ , ∂ξ
(3.82)
(3.83)
from which the bulk modulus K (t) and the shear modulus μ(t) can be determined. Typically, a constant piston displacement can be used to lead to relaxation behavior or alternatively, a constant relative velocity of the pistons can be used in the last set of equations. Ravi-Chandar and his coworkers demonstrated axial strains of as high as ≈ 20%, though the deformation in the linearly viscoelastic domain required only strains on the order of 5% or less. These latter values are still much larger than those encountered in the harmonic test method [3.71,72] though the same results should prevail with this difference in magnitudes, as long as one is convinced that the linear properties extend over this larger strain range. Because the specimen deformation depends on both the bulk and on the shear characteristics of the material one can evaluate simultaneously the (relaxation) shear modulus as well. A constant axial piston velocity may be used as an alternative loading history. log (modulus/GPa) 0.5 0 –0.5 –1 –1.5
Bulk modulus Shear modulus
–2 –5 –4 –3 –2 –1
0
1
2
3
4
5 6 log t
Fig. 3.23 Bulk and shear modulus in relaxation both obtained in a single measurement series in the apparatus of Fig. 3.22
Part A 3.3
Fig. 3.22 Cylinder/piston arrangement for determining
2 szz (t) = [σzz (t) − σrr (t)] , 3 1 srr (t) = sθθ (t) = − [σzz (t) − σrr (t)] , 3
K (t − ξ)
−∞
Specimen
δ(t) = εzz (t) + 2εrr (t) .
73
74
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
E(t) (GPa) 10 Highly confined
1 Unconfined
Confined
0.1 Tref = 80°C
Part A 3.3
0.01 –4 10
10–2
100
102
104
106 t/a T
Fig. 3.24 Uniaxial relaxation modulus as determined in
the configuration of Fig. 3.22, the confinement being controlled by the stiffness of the exterior cylinder [3.75]
Special care is required in order to minimize or eliminate the gap between the specimen and the interior cylinder wall. Because of the typically relatively high compressibility of polymers, the measurements are sensitive to small dimensional changes in the test geometry. However, sufficient precision can be achieved with appropriate care, as demonstrated in references [3.73–75]. An example of measurement evaluations are shown in Fig. 3.23 for PMMA in the form of both bulk and shear behavior. If the shear and bulk modulus possessed
the same time dependence, Poisson’s ratio would be a constant. From these figures it is immediately apparent over what range the bulk and shear moduli exhibit closely the same time dependence and over what range the approximation of a constant bulk modulus would render acceptable or even good results in a viscoelastic analysis. Qvale and Ravi-Chandar [3.75] point out that the polymer is well below the glass-transition temperature and that the effect of moving to high pressures is to extend the relaxation or retardation times to longer values as would be the result of cooling the material to lower temperatures. An example of this effect is demonstrated in Fig. 3.24 [3.75], which shows three data sets: one, identified as unconfined is for zero superposed pressure; the other two result from different degrees of pressure as controlled by the choice of material for the confining cylinder Fig. 3.22. This effect is thought to be linked to the reduction in free volume of the polymer as a result of the compression.
3.3.3 The CEM Measuring System A relatively recent measurement system providing for the determination of numerous (time-dependent) properties besides bulk response with a high degree of (Plazek)-precision is the CEM measuring system (taken from the initials of the Center for Experimental Mechanics, University of Ljubljana, Slovenia) [3.57, 77].
Table 3.2 Measuring capabilities of the CEM apparatus
Measured
Calculated from definitions
Calculated from models
Physical Properties
Symbols
Temperature Pressure Angular displacement Specimen length Torque Shear relaxation modulus Shear compliance Specific volume Linear thermal expansion coefficient Volumetric thermal expansion coefficient Bulk creep compliance Bulk modulus WLF constants WLF material parameters FMT constants FMT material parameters Shift factors
T (t) P(t) ϑ0 = ϑ(t = 0) L(t), L(T ), L(P) M(t), M(T ), M(P) G(t), G(T ), G(P) J(t), J(T ), J(P) ν(t), ν(T ), ν(P) α(T ), α(P) β(T ), β(P), βg , βe , βf B(t), B(T ), B(P) K (T ), K (P) c1 , c2 αf , f 0 c1 , c2 , c3 , c4 , c5 , c6 αf (P), α0 (P), B, K e∗ , ke , K φ , kφ a(T ), a(P) and/or a(T, P)
or or or or or or or or or
L(t, T, P) M(t, T, P) G(t, T, P) J(t, T, P) ν(t, T, P) α(T, P) βgef (T, P) B(t, T, P) K (T, P)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
3.3 Measurements and Methods
75
Thermal bath
Pressure vessel Electromagnet
Measuring inserts
Silicone oil Carrier amplifier Circulator
Data acquisition
Magnet and motor charger
Pressurizing system
Fig. 3.25 Schematic of the CEM measuring system
Although the apparatus is not yet available as a routine commercial product, we cite here its components because of the larger-than-normal range of properties that can be determined with it. This list is shown in Table 3.2. The system measures five physical quantities: temperature, T (t); pressure, P(t); torsional deformation (angular displacement) per unit length, ϑ0 , applied to the specimen at t = 0; specimen length L(t, T, P); and the decaying torque, M(t, T, P), resulting from the initial torsional deformation, ϑ0 . The system assembly is shown schematically in Fig. 3.25. The pressure is generated by the pressurizing system using silicone oil. The pressure vessel is contained within a thermal bath, through which another silicone oil circulates from the circulator, used for close control of the temperature. The apparatus utilizes two separate measuring inserts, which can be housed in the pressure vessel: the relaxometer, shown in Fig. 3.26a, and the dilatometer, shown in Fig. 3.26b. Signals from these measuring inserts pass through the carrier amplifier prior to being collected in digital format by the data acquisition system. The magnet and motor charger supplies power to the electromagnet, which initiates the measurement. The same charger also supplies current to the electric motor of the relaxometer, shown in Fig. 3.26a, which preloads the spring that then applies the desired torsional deformation (angular displacement) to the specimen. Specimens can be simultaneously subjected to pressures of up to 600 MPa with a precision of
± 0.1 MPa, and to temperatures ranging from −50 ◦ C to +120 ◦ C with a precision of ± 0.01 ◦ C. The Relaxometer The relaxometer insert, shown in Fig. 3.26a, measures the shear relaxation modulus by applying a constant torsional strain to a cylindrical specimen, and by monitoring the induced moment as a function of time. The specimen diameter can range from 2 mm to 10 mm, and its length from 52 mm to 58 mm. For details on specimen preparation the reader is referred to [3.77]. Two main parts of the insert are the loading device, and the load cell. The loading device applies a torsional strain by twisting the specimen a few degrees (typically around 2◦ in less than 0.01 s, depending on the initial stiffness of the specimen). To effect this deformation, the electric motor first preloads a torsion spring. Once twisted, the spring is kept in its preloaded position by a rack-and-pawl mechanism. The activation of the electromagnet, mounted outside the pressure vessel (Fig. 3.25), releases the pawl so that the spring deforms the specimen to a predetermined angle. The induced moment is then measured by the load cell, which is attached to the slider mechanism to compensate for possible changes in the length of the specimen resulting from changes in temperature, pressure, and the Poynting effect (shortening of the specimen caused by a torsional deformation). After the shear relaxation measurement is complete, the electric motor brings the specimen to its origi-
Part A 3.3
Silicone fluid
76
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a)
Fig. 3.26 The CEM relaxometer and dilatometer inserts
b) Loading device Triggering mechanism
LVDT
Electric motor 280 mm
LVDT rod
260 mm
Specimen Slider mechanism
Specimen
Part A 3.3
Load cell
nal undeformed state, while maintaining the pressure vessel fully pressurized. The relaxometer can measure shear moduli in the range 1–4000 MPa, with a maximal relative error of 1% over the complete measuring range. The Dilatometer The dilatometer insert, shown in Fig. 3.26b, is used to measure bulk properties such as the: bulk creep compliance, B(t, T, P); equilibrium bulk creep compliance, B(T, P) = B(t → ∞, T, P); specific volume ν(T, P) = ν(t → ∞, T, P), and thermal (equilibrium) expansion coefficient, β(T, P) = β(t → ∞, T, P). The bulk compliance may be inverted to yield the bulk modulus. Measurements are performed by monitoring the volume change of the specimen which results from the imposed changes in pressure and/or temperature, by measuring the change in specimen length, L(t, T, P), with the aid of a built-in linearly variable differential transformer (LVDT). The volume estimate can be considered accurate if the change in volume is small (up to a few percent) and the material is isotropic. Dilatometer specimens may be up to 16 mm in diameter and 40–60 mm in length. The relative measurement error in volume is 0.05%. Displacement dilatometry has an accuracy advantage over mercury confinement dilatometry inasmuch as it allows an easily automated measurement process for tracking transient volume changes over extended periods of time. However, for soft materials an important limitation arises (usually at temperatures above Tg ), when the specimen’s creep under its own weight becomes significant. Given the arrangement of the LVDT rod (Fig. 3.26b), there will be an additional creep caused
by the weight of the rod. For linearly viscoelastic behavior this limitation can be easily corrected.
3.3.4 Nano/Microindentation for Measurements of Viscoelastic Properties of Small Amounts of Material It is often necessary, as in a developmental research environment, to determine viscoelastic properties when only very small or thin specimens are available. The nanoindentation technique developed over the past two decades [3.78–80] has been demonstrated to be effective in such cases where thin films or microstructural domains in homogeneous or inhomogeneous solids are concerned. Methods have been established for the measurements of properties such as the Young’s modulus for materials exhibiting time- or rate-insensitive behavior. Under the assumption that unloading induces only elastic recovery, Oliver and Pharr [3.80] pioneered a method to measure Young’s modulus of time- or strain-rate-independent materials, using an assumed or known Poisson’s ratio. This method, which is based primarily on Sneddon’s solution [3.81], can measure properties such as Young’s modulus and harness without the need to measure directly the projected areas of permanent indent impressions in an inelastic solids by employing a modified or equivalent linearly elastic material response. While such methods work well for timeor rate-independent materials (metals, ceramics, etc.), applying these methods directly – i. e., without proper modifications – to viscoelastic materials is not appropriate. For example, the unloading curve in viscoelastic materials sometimes has a negative slope [3.82] under
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
a)
a α
R
Hc H O
r
77
tation of a rigid, axisymmetric indenter pressed into a homogeneous, linearly elastic and isotropic halfspace. The indentation depth H (Fig. 3.27) of the axisymmetric indenter tip is represented in terms of the indenter geometry by
b)
Z
3.3 Measurements and Methods
1
H
Fig. 3.27 (a) A conical indenter and (b) a spherical indenter
H= 0
Measurements of Viscoelastic Functions in the Time Domain Nanoindentation into a bulk material can often be considered as a process of indenting a half-space with a rigid indenter. Typically, indenters are made of diamond, so that their Young’s modulus is at least two orders of magnitude greater than that for a typical viscoelastic material; the indenter can then be considered to be rigid. Figure 3.27 shows a conical indenter and a spherical indenter. In nanoindentation testing, a pyramid-shaped indenter is often modeled as a conical indenter with a cone angle that provides the same area-to-depth relationship as the actual pyramidal indenter. As in the case of the Berkovich indenter, it can be modeled as an axisymmetric conical indenter with an effective half-cone angle of 70.3◦ . This makes solutions for axisymmetric elastic indentation problems available for determining material properties such as Young’s modulus with pyramidshaped indenters and the (linearly) viscoelastic behavior of the material can be determined by way of the load–displacement data obtained from indenting a viscoelastic solid. Linearly Elastic Indentation Problem. Sneddon [3.81] derived the load–displacement relation for the inden-
(3.84)
where z = f (x) is the shape function for an axisymmetric indenter, with x = r/a being the coordinate shown in Fig. 3.27; the origin of the frame is coincident with the indenter tip and a is the radius of the contact circle at the depth Hc . According to this analysis the load on an axisymmetric indenter is 4Ga P= 1−ν
1 0
x 2 f (x) dx , √ 1 − x2
(3.85)
where G and ν are the shear modulus and Poisson’s ratio, respectively. For a conical indenter one has z = f (x) = ax tan α, so that (3.84) becomes 1 H = πa tan α , 2
(3.86)
with the angle α defined as in Fig. 3.27a. The indentation load in (3.85) is then given by P=
πGa2 tan α , 1−ν
(3.87)
which, upon using (3.86), renders the load–depth relation for a conical indenter as P=
4 G H2 . π(1 − ν) tan α
(3.88)
Similarly, for the half-space indentation by a spherical indenter, with the geometry shown in Fig.3.27b, the indenter shape function is z = f (x) = R − (R2 − a2 x 2 ), where R is the sphere radius. Substituting into (3.84) and (3.85), one finds the load–displacement relation [3.86] √ 8 R (3.89) G H 3/2 P= 3(1 − ν) under condition of a small H/R ratio, typically H/R < 0.2 (see below).
Part A 3.3
situations where small unloading rates and relatively high loads are used for a material with pronounced viscoelastic effects. Accordingly, special procedures have been developed in recent years to measure viscoelastic behavior – relaxation modulus and creep compliance – for linearly viscoelastic materials. Cheng et al. [3.83] developed a method to determine viscoelastic properties using a flat-punch indenter. Lu et al. [3.84] proposed methods to measure the creep compliance in the time domain of solid polymers using either the Berkovich or spherical indenter. Huang et al. [3.85] developed methods to measure the complex modulus in the frequency domain using a spherical indenter. Some of these methods are summarized and discussed below.
f (x) dx , √ 1 − x2
78
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
The Linearly Viscoelastic Indentation Problem. For-
Part A 3.3
cing a rigid indenter into a linearly viscoelastic, homogeneous half-space can be treated as a quasistatic boundary value problem with a moving boundary between the indenter and the half-space, as the contact area between the indenter and the half-space changes with time. Note that because of the moving boundary condition the correspondence principle between a linearly viscoelastic solution and a linearly elastic solution is not applicable. To solve this problem, Lee and Radok [3.87] suggested to find the time-dependent stresses and deformations for an axisymmetric indenter through the use of a hereditary integral operator based on the associated solution for a linearly elastic material. Applying this Lee–Radok method (e.g., see Riande et al. [3.88]) to (3.88) leads to the timedependent indentation depth for any load history that does not produce a decrease in contact area (linearly viscoelastic material) H 2 (t) =
π(1 − ν) tan α 4
t
dP(ξ) J(t − ξ) dξ . dξ
0
(3.90)
P(t) = P0 h(t), where P0 is the magnitude of the indentation load, and h(t) is the Heaviside unit step function. Substituting this into (3.90) for a conical indenter one deduces the shear creep function from J(t) =
4H 2 (t) . π(1 − ν)P0 tan α
(3.92)
Similarly, if the indentation load P(t) = P0 h(t) is applied to a spherical indenter with (3.91) the shear creep function is determined from √ 8 RH 3/2 (t) . (3.93) J(t) = 3(1 − ν)P0 Indentation under a Constant Load Rate. With
Fig. 3.4 in mind we discuss first the case of determining the creep compliance from the measured load–depth relation for a load increasing at a constant rate. Let the load be P(t) = P˙0 t h(t), with P˙0 being the load rate (mN/s or μN/s). For a conical indenter, substitution of this P(t) into (3.90) yields π(1 − ν) P˙0 tan α H (t) = 4
t J(t − ξ) dξ ,
2
where J(t) is the shear creep compliance at time t. Radok [3.89], Lee and Radok [3.87], Hunter [3.90], and Yang [3.91] have investigated the indentation into linearly viscoelastic materials with a spherical indenter. For a rigid, spherical indenter with radius R, upon using the hereditary integral in (3.90), the relation between load and penetration depth is represented by H 3/2 (t) =
3(1 − ν) √ 8 R
t
dP(ξ) J(t − ξ) dξ . dξ
0
(3.91)
Either (3.90) (conical indenter) or (3.91) (spherical indenter) can be used to determine the shear creep compliance J(t) under a prescribed loading history, as illustrated below. We note that Poisson’s ratio is assumed to be constant in the above derivation. In the sequel we describe three monotonic load histories for determining the creep compliance of a linearly viscoelastic material: (i) a step load, (ii) a constant load rate, and (iii) a ramp loading with an initially constant load rate. Indentation under a Step Load. In the case of a step
load applied to the indenter, the load is represented by
(3.94)
0
which upon differentiation with respect to time yields J(t) =
8H(t) dH(t) . π(1 − ν)P0 tan α dt
(3.95)
Equation (3.95) determines the shear creep compliance J(t) from the measured indentation depth history H(t). This simplifies (for a constant load rate) to 8H(t) dH (3.96) J(t) = (t) . π(1 − ν) tan α dP For a spherical indenter, we have from (3.91) H 3/2 (t) =
t 3(1 − ν) P˙0 J(t − θ) dθ . √ 8 R
(3.97)
0
Differentiation of (3.97) with respect to t yields √ 4 RH 1/2 (t) dH (3.98) , J(t) = (1 − ν) P˙0 dt or, simplified, √ 4 RH 1/2 (t) dH (t) . J(t) = (1 − ν) dP
(3.99)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
For loads increasing with constant rates, (3.96) and (3.99) are the equations for deriving the creep function using conical or spherical indenters, respectively. Both equations require the derivative of the indentation depth with respect to load. Since experimental data tends to be scattered, the computation of the derivative dH/ dP is prone to induce undesirable errors. An alternative approach to determine the creep function under ramp loading is, therefore, described next. The representation of the creep function based on the generalized Kelvin model is N
Ji (1 − e−t/τi ) ,
Upon least-square fitting (3.104) to the experimentally measured load–displacement curve one finds the set of parameters J0 , J1 , . . . , JN and τ1 , τ2 , . . . , τ N (see again Sect. 3.2.5 for the choice of τ1 , τ2 , . . . , τ N ), which define the creep compliance. Ramp Loading Histories. As noted in Sect. 3.2.6, an
where J0 , J1 , . . . , JN are compliance values, τ1 , τ2 , . . . , τ N are the retardation times, and N is a positive integer. Substituting this into (3.94) for the conical indenter results in N 1 Ji t H 2 (t) = π(1 − nu) P˙0 tan α J0 + 4 i=1 N −t Ji τi 1 − e τi (3.101) . − i=1
For P(t) = P˙0 · t, (3.101) can be rewritten as N 1 H (t) = π(1 − ν) tan α J0 + Ji P(t) 4 i=1 N − P(t) − Ji (ν0 τi ) 1 − e P˙0 τi (3.102) . 2
i=1
If the experimentally measured nanoindentation load– displacement curve is (least-squares) fitted to (3.102), a set of best-fit parameters J0 , J1 , . . . , JN and τ1 , τ2 , . . . , τ N can be determined (Sect. 3.2.5 with respect to the choice of τ1 , τ2 , . . . , τ N ). These constants define the shear creep compliance (3.100). The same method for data reduction can be applied to a spherical indenter. With the substitution of (3.100) into (3.91) this leads to
i=1
(3.104)
i=1
(3.100)
i=1
N 3(1 − ν) P˙0 Ji t J0 + H 3/2 (t) = √ 8 R i=1 N t − Ji τi 1 − e τi . −
Since P(t) = P˙0 t again, (3.103) becomes N 3(1 − ν) Ji P(t) H 3/2 (t) = √ J0 + 8 R i=1 N − PP(t) ˙ τi ˙ 0 Ji ( P0 τi ) 1 − e . −
ideal step load history cannot be generated in laboratory tests. Instead one typically uses a ramp loading with a very short rise time t0 first (usually t0 is on the order of 1–2 s) and a constant load thereafter (Fig. 3.4). This observation applies equally to large test specimens (see Sect. 3.2.6) and to nanoindentations. Following then the developments in Sect. 3.2.6, (3.92) and (3.93) may be used to determine the creep function starting from a certain time after the constant load is reached. However, this period of time, which is conservatively chosen as five to ten times the rise time, can be a significant portion if the total time scale available is not large. To avoid or at least minimize the loss of the corresponding data, one can correct the initial portion of the data to find the creep compliance between the test starting time and ten times the rise time using the approach proposed by Lee and Knauss [3.32] or by Flory and McKenna [3.33]. Based on the Boltzmann superposition principle and with reference to Fig. 3.4, a realistic loading can be considered as P(t) = P1 (t) − P2 (t) = P˙0 t h(t) − P˙0 (t − t0 )h(t − t0 ), where P˙0 is again a constant loading/unloading rate. For a conical indenter, from (3.90), we have H 2 (t) =
t π(1 − ν) P˙0 tan α J(ξ) dξ ; 4
(t < t0 ) ,
0
(3.105)
H 2 (t) =
(3.103)
79
π(1 − ν) P˙0 tan α 4 t−t0 t J(ξ) dξ − J(ξ) dξ ; × 0
(t ≥ t0 ) .
0
(3.106)
Part A 3.3
J(t) = J0 +
3.3 Measurements and Methods
80
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Differentiation of (3.105) and (3.106) with respect to time t yields J(t) =
dH(t) 8H(t) ; (t < t0 ) , π(1 − ν) P˙0 tan α dt
J(t − t0 ) = J(t) − (t ≥ t0 ) .
(3.107)
8H(t) dH(t) ; π(1 − ν) P˙0 tan α dt (3.108)
Part A 3.3
Similarly, for a spherical indenter, the following results are obtained: √ 4 RH 1/2 (t) dH(t) J(t) = (3.109) ; (t < t0 ) , dt (1 − ν) P˙0 J(t − t0 ) = J(t) −
√ 4 RH 1/2 (t) dH(t) ; (t ≥ t0 ) . dt (1 − ν) P˙0 (3.110)
Therefore, the procedure of data correction could be considered as backward recursion starting at some time, for example, ten times the rise time t0 . For a conical indenter, using (3.107) and (3.108), the creep function determined by (3.92) can be corrected through the following steps: 1. For kt0 ≤ t ≤ (k + 1)t0 with k ≥ 10 being a positive integer, compute J(t − t0 ) at t = kt0 + mλt0 by (3.108); the result of J(t) is calculated using (3.92), where λ is some sufficiently small number, m is an increasing integer from 1, and 0 < m ≤ 1/λ. Note that λt0 is the time increment used in backward recursion. 2. For (k − 1)t0 ≤ t ≤ kt0 , compute J(t − t0 ) at t = (k − 1)t0 + mλt0 by (3.108) and the result from (1). 3. Repeat the same step as (2) for (n − 1)t0 ≤ t ≤ nt0 , where n = k − 1, k − 2, . . . , 3. 4. For 0 ≤ t < t0 compute J(t) by (3.107). For a spherical indenter, the same method can be used to augment the initial part of creep function. Simply replace (3.92), (3.107), and (3.108) in (1)–(4) for a conical indenter by (3.93), (3.109), and (3.110), respectively. Limitations of Micro/Nanoindentation in the Determination of Linearly Viscoelastic Functions. Nanoin-
dentation uses sharp, pointed indenters to penetrate into a test specimen, and leads to relatively large deformations under the indenter tip, especially when a Berkovich indenter is used. Since viscoelastic materials often exhibit nonlinear behavior at strains larger
than ≈ 0.5%, it is expected that nonlinearly viscoelastic deformations arise. Linearly viscoelastic analysis should thus be considered a first-order approximation for measuring linearly viscoelastic functions. Indeed, the linearly viscoelastic analysis has been shown to be a good approximation under a variety of situations. For example, Cheng et al. [3.83] have determined that the standard linear solid model can be appropriate for some polymers if a sufficiently small time range is involved. Hutcheson and McKenna [3.92] found that linearly viscoelastic analysis is applicable to the embedment of nanospheres into a polystyrene surface as demonstrated on data obtained by Teichroeb; and Forrest [3.93] and Oyen [3.94] have demonstrated that linearly viscoelastic analysis is appropriate for at least some materials under spherical nanoindentation. On the other hand, others have found that linearly viscoelastic analysis is not applicable to some materials or under particular conditions: Thus, in an early application of indentation to viscoelastic properties determination, Valandingham et al. [3.95] found for several polymers that the relaxation modulus as determined from differently sized step displacements depended on their magnitude. Since linearly viscoelastic functions are considered to be properties – i. e., they should be independent of the stress and of the deformation amplitude – in nano/microindentation measurements this would seem to be an indication that nonlinear response is involved. If interest rests on the linearly viscoelastic functions one should ensure that the measurement results are independent of load or deformation level. A comment is in order with respect to the shortterm or glassy response in such measurements. It is noted from (3.96) and (3.99) that the instantaneous shear creep compliance is zero at time t = 0 because h(0) = 0 under loading at a constant load rate. Polymers normally have nonzero instantaneous creep compliance. The error on the instantaneous creep compliance is the result of the limitation in the viscoelastic analysis since the solution is singular due to the sharp point discontinuity of the tip at zero indentation depth. It is found, however, that after passing the initial loading stage, the creep compliance typically increases with time, and approaches the value representing the viscoelastic behavior. For the initial contact in nanoindentation, the solution details of the viscoelastic problem are rather complex, involving the effects of (molecular) repulsion, adhesion, and friction, as well as initial plowing through the material. An analysis that takes into account all of these factors might be necessary to develop a method to determine the instantaneous creep compliance. How-
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
3.3 Measurements and Methods
ever, experience at a much larger length scale tells us that such an expectation is not well placed. Also, from a purely operational point of view in consideration of the fact that nanoindenters cannot provide accurate information for very small depths (of the order of 50 nm or less) data for the creep function at short times are usually not very accurate.
point below). Loubet et al. [3.96] presented the following equations to compute the complex modulus E ∗ (ω)
Specimen Preparation. The method(s) described above
where E and E are the uniaxial storage modulus and the loss modulus, respectively. S is a contact stiffness defined as the local slope of the relation between the load and the penetration depth, dP/ dH, C a damping coefficient defined through the instrument software as ˙ the ratio of the load to the penetration rate, C = P/ H, and A the contact area between the indenter and the workpiece as determined from the penetration depth and the indenter geometry. This method was employed in the quoted reference [3.96], for example, to measure the complex modulus of polyisoprene. As this work took no particular note of the issues associated with the viscoelastic effects resulting from decreasing contact during part of the load cycle, the method is suspect. Therefore, Huang et al. [3.85] conducted measurements, using also an MTS Nano Indenter XP system, which was also equipped with a continuous stiffness module, but with the specific intent of elucidating the need to bring viscoelasticity theory in accord with the test conditions (contact retention). This was accomplished for the spherical indenter shown in Fig. 3.27b. Leaving the details of development to the reader’s individual study, we go to the heart of the matter by pointing out that experimental provisions need to be made to prevent the occurrence of reduction in contact between the indenter and the substrate. Huang et al. provided for this by imposing a preload (carrier load) onto which a much smaller harmonic load was superposed. This is accomplished through either a constant (creep) load or through a load that increases at a constant rate. We record first the results for the constant carrier load and then for the constant carrier load rate, after which the conditions for nondecreasing contact area are stated. Consider then a sinusoidal indentation load superimposed on a step loading, represented by
Measurements of Viscoelastic Functions in the Frequency Domain To illustrate the current state of development with nanoindentation equipment and data interpretation we review here briefly earlier studies that suffer from an inadequate attention to the details of viscoelastic vis-à-vis elastic analysis. Loubet et al. [3.96] proposed a method to determine the complex modulus of viscoelastic materials with the aid of an MTS Nano Indenter XP system coupled with a continuous stiffness module (CSM). The CSM allows cyclic excitation in load or displacement and the recording of the resulting displacement or load [3.97]. The indentation displacement response and the out-of-phase angle between the applied harmonic force and the corresponding harmonic displacement are measured continuously at a given excitation frequency. For the subsequent discussion the reader is again alerted to the fact that currently available indentation solutions require non-decreasing contact area between the material and the indenter. When that condition cannot be guaranteed, the measurement results must be considered suspect and usually require careful examination and evaluation (see the earlier caveat-discussion on transients in Sect. 3.2.6 as well as further discussion on this
E (ω) = E + iE , with √ πCω and E = √ , 2 A
P(t) = Pm + h(t)ΔP0 sin ωt ,
√ πS E = √ 2 A
(3.111)
(3.112)
where Pm is the (constant) carrier or main load, and ΔP0 is the amplitude of the harmonic load. Inserting
Part A 3.3
for nanoindentation/microindentation on polymers assumes that the material is in its natural, stress-free state as the reference configuration. Specimens need to be prepared carefully prior to the start of measurements. They typically need to be annealed at a temperature in a range of ±10 ◦ C of the glass-transition temperature for 2 h or longer to remove any residual stress; they then need to be cooled slowly (typical cooling rates ≈ 5 ◦ C/min) to room or the test temperature. The physical aging time must be maintained at the same value for all tests to produce consistent results, unless of course the effect of physical aging time is under study. The room temperature has to be recorded, as well as the room humidity, which needs to be controlled to a constant value using a humidifier/dehumidifier if the temperature control unit does not offer this capability.
∗
81
82
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
(3.112) into (3.91), we have 3(1 − ν) H 3/2 (t) = √ 8 R t × Pm J(t) + ωΔP0 J(t − θ) cos ωθ dθ .
Following similar procedures as in deriving (3.119), the formulae to determine the complex compliance can also be derived under the condition that the time t has evolved to a value such that Hm (t) ΔH0 . Substituting (3.119) into (3.91) for the spherical indenter, one has then
0
(3.113)
Part A 3.3
√ The contact radius is a(t) = RH(t) for H(t) R. After the loading transients have died out (see the discussion in Sect. 3.2.6), one finds 3(1 − ν) Pm J(t) H 3/2 (t) = √ 8 R + ΔP0 [J (ω) sin ωt − J (ω) cos ωt] . (3.114)
with J (ω) and J (ω) denoting the storage and loss compliances in shear, respectively. If Hm (t) denotes the carrier displacement component, and ΔH0 is the amplitude of the harmonic displacement component, the displacement from (3.112) is in the form H(t) = Hm (t) + ΔH0 sin(ωt − δ) ,
(3.115)
where δ is the phase angle between the harmonic force and the ensuing displacement, ΔH0 is of the order of a few nanometers while Hm (t) (from the step loading) is on the order of a few hundreds of nanometers. Assuming that this implies that no loss in contact occurs and that ΔH0 Hm (t), (3.115) leads to 3 1/2 3/2 H 3/2 (t) = Hm (t) + Hm (t)ΔH0 cos δ sin ωt 2 3 1/2 − Hm (t)ΔH0 sin δ cos ωt + o(ΔH0 ) , 2 (3.116)
where o(ΔH0 ) indicates the higher-order terms in ΔH0 , which are negligible as long as ΔH0 Hm (t). Comparing (3.116) with (3.114), one finds for the constant carrier load that 3(1 − ν) 3/2 (3.117) Pm J(t) , Hm (t) = √ 8 R √ 1/2 4 R Hm (t)ΔH0 J (ω) = cos δ , and 1−ν ΔP0 √ 1/2 4 R Hm (t)ΔH0 J (ω) = sin δ . (3.118) 1−ν ΔP0 The alternative loading condition in which a small sinusoidal load is superimposed upon a carrier loading increasing at a constant rate P˙0 , i. e., (3.119) P(t) = P˙0 t + h(t)ΔP0 sin ωt .
H
3/2
t 3(1 − ν) (t) = √ P˙0 J(t − θ) dθ 8 R 0
+ ΔP0 [J (ω) sin ωt − J (ω) cos ωt] .
(3.120)
Upon comparing (3.120) with (3.116), the same formulas as in (3.118) for the complex compliance can be derived for a small oscillatory load that is superimposed upon a constant-rate carrier load. We next provide conditions on the load magnitude(s) under which nondecreasing contact area is maintained so that the solution derived from the Lee– Radok approach is valid. These conditions are sufficient because they are imposed such that the total load rate does not become negative, although it is conceivable that a small negative load rate does not necessarily lead to a reduction in contact area. Note that similar argumentation cannot be used if the prescribed loading is in the form of displacement histories. For a harmonic loading superimposed on a step loading one ensures (small) positive loading rates by requiring that, for each arbitrary time interval, say half a harmonic cycle, the indentation rate due to the constant carrier load exceeds temporary unloading. From (3.115) the contact area will be nondecreasing during the whole process, as long as the frequency does not exceed the critical value ωc = H˙ m /ΔH0 . A value for H˙ m may be estimated from (3.117) as if the relation described an elastic half-space. For higher frequencies a temporary decrease in the contact is likely as a result of the applied harmonic load so that the Ting approach should be adopted. Nevertheless, when the frequency exceeds the critical value by a small amount (ω > ωc ), the solutions derived from the methods by Lee and Radok [3.87] and by Ting [3.86] are still very close, even though the condition for the Lee–Radok approach is not strictly fulfilled. Since a closed-form solution derived from the Lee–Radok approach exists, while only numerical solutions can be obtained using the Ting approach, the formulas derived for a harmonic superimposed on a step loading from the Lee–Radok approach can then still be used to estimate the complex viscoelas-
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
a) Storage modulus (GPa)
value, indicating considerable uncertainty associated with the method by Loubet et al. [3.96] as summarized by (3.111) for measuring the storage modulus. This discrepancy exists for both PC and for PMMA.
3.3.5 Photoviscoelasticity A classical tool for determining strain and stress distributions in two-dimensional geometries is the photoelastic method [3.98]. For three-dimensional geometries the method required slicing the body into sections and treat each two-dimensional section/slice separately and sequentially. While the early application of this technique employed relatively rigid polymers such as homalite (a polyester) or polystyrene with glass temperatures above 100 ◦ C, also softer and photoelastically more sensitive materials such as polyurethane elastomers have been employed [3.99]. This method was found useful in both quasistatic as well as dynamic applications when wave mechanics was an important consideration [3.100]. With respect to viscoelastic responses it is important to consider the time scale of the measurements relative to time of the test material. Rigid polymers are stiff because their dominant relaxation processes occur slowly around typical laboratory temperatures, so that timedependent issues are not of much concern. On the other hand, they should be of concern if observations extend over long time periods measured in weeks and months if the relaxation times at the prevailb) Storage modulus (GPa)
8
8
7
7
6
6
5
5
4
4
3
3 Nanoindentation (2004) Conventional (DMA) Nanoindentation (1995)
2
0
Nanoindentation (2004) Conventional (DMA) Nanoindentation (1995)
2
1
1 0
25
50
75
100
125
150 Time (s)
83
0
0
25
50
75
100
125
150 Time (s)
Fig. 3.28a,b Comparison of the storage compliance at 75 Hz computed by three methods for (a) PC and (b) PMMA
Part A 3.3
tic functions in the regime of linear viscoelasticity when ω > ωc . Next consider the carrier load to increase at a constant rate P˙0 . Differentiation of (3.119) with respect to time guarantees a positive loading rate as long as P˙0 ≥ ΔP0 ω. Additionally, the substitution √ of this inequality into (3.91) together with a(t) = RH(t) shows that the contact area will then also not decrease during the entire indentation history. Figure 3.28 shows a comparison of these developments with an application of (3.111) [3.96] under the assumption of a constant Poisson ratio: when measurements over a relatively short time (such as ≈ 250 s used in this study) are made, the Poisson’s ratio [3.15] does not change significantly for polymers in the glassy state, such as PMMA or polycarbonate (PC) and thus introduces negligible errors in the complex compliance data. To compute the complex modulus of PC and polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) at 75 Hz, data were acquired continuously at this frequency for ≈ 125 s. In general the data increase correctly with time, and approach a nearly constant value for each material. These constant values are considered to represent the steady state and are quoted as the storage modulus. Also shown for comparison in Fig. 3.28 are data measured with the aid of conventional dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) for the same batch of PC and PMMA. The uniaxial storage modulus of PC measured by DMA at 0.75 Hz is 2.29 GPa. However, the storage modulus computed using (3.111) is at least 40% higher than this
3.3 Measurements and Methods
84
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
ing temperatures are of the same order of magnitude. Because dynamic events occur in still shorter time frames wave mechanics typically little concern in this regard. The situation is quite different when soft or elastomeric polymers serve as photoelastic model materials. In that case quasistatic environments (around room temperature) typically involve only the long-term or rubbery behavior of the material with the stiffness measured in terms of the rubbery or long-term equilibrium modulus. On the other hand, when wave propagation phenomena are part of the investigation, the longest relaxation times (relaxation times that govern the tran-
sition to purely elastic behavior for the relatively very long times) are likely to be excited so that the output of the measurements must consider the effect of viscoelastic response. It is beyond the scope of this presentation to delineate the full details of the use of viscoelastically photoelastic material behavior, especially since during the past few years investigators have shown a strong inclination to use alternative tools. However, it seems useful to include a list of references from which the evolution of this topic as well as its current status may be explored. These are listed as a separate group in Sect. 3.6.1 under References on Photoviscoelasticity.
Part A 3.4
3.4 Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Material Characterization Viscoelastic materials are often employed under conditions fostering nonlinear behavior. In contrast to the mutual independence in the dilatational and deviatoric responses in a linearly viscoelastic material, the viscoelastic responses in different directions are coupled and must be investigated in multiaxial loading conditions. Most results published in the literature are restricted to investigating the viscoelastic behavior in the uniaxial stress or uniaxial strain states [3.101, 102] and few results are reported for time-dependent multiaxial behavior [3.103–105]. Note that BauwensCrowet’s study [3.104] incorporates the effect of pressure on the viscoelastic behavior but not in the data analysis, simply as a result of using uniaxial compression deformations. Along similar lines Knauss, Emri, and collaborators [3.106–110] provided a series of studies deriving nonlinear viscoelastic behavior from changes in the dilatation (free-volume change) which correlated well with experiments and gave at least a partial physical interpretation to the Schapery scheme [3.111, 112] for shifting linearly viscoelastic data in accordance with a stress or strain state. The studies became the precursors to investigate the effect of shear stresses or strains on nonlinear behavior as described below. Thus the proper interpretation of the uniaxial data as well as their generalization to multiaxial stress or deformation states is highly questionable. This remains true regardless of the fact that such data interpretation has been incorporated into commercially available computer codes. Certainly, there are very few engineering situations where structural material use is limited to uniaxial states. In this section we describe some aspects of nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior in
the multiaxial stress state. References regarding nonlinear behavior in the context of uniaxial deformations are too numerous to list here. The reader is advised to consult the following journals: the Journal of Polymer, Applied Polymer Science, Polymer Engineering and Science, the Journal of Materials Science and Mechanics of Time-Dependent Materials, to list the most prevalent ones.
3.4.1 Visual Assessment of Nonlinear Behavior Although it is clear that even under small deformations entailing linearly viscoelastic behavior the imposition of a constant strain rate on a tensile or compression specimen results in a stress response that is not linearly related to the deformation when the relation is established in real time (not on a logarithmic time scale). Because such responses that appear nonlinear on paper are not necessarily indicative of nonlinear constitutive behavior, it warrants a brief exposition of how nonlinear behavior is unequivocally separated from the linear type. To demonstrate the nonlinear behavior of a material, consider first isochronal behavior of a linearly viscoelastic material. Although isochronal behavior can be obtained for different deformation or stress histories, consider the case of shear creep under various stress levels σn , so that the corresponding strain is εn = J(t)σn for any time t. Consider an arbitrary but fixed time t ∗ , at which time the ratio εn /σn = J(t ∗ )
(3.121)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
Shear stress (MPa) 16 14 t = 10s 12 t = 104 s 10
ial. These values are likely to be different for other materials.
3.4.2 Characterization of Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Behavior Under Biaxial Stress States In the following sections, we describe several ways of measuring nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior in multiaxial situations. Hollow Cylinder under Axial/Torsional Loading A hollow cylinder under axial/torsional loading conditions provides a vehicle for investigating the nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior under multiaxial loading conditions. Figure 3.30 shows a schematic diagram of a cylinder specimen. Dimensions can be prescribed corresponding to the load and deformation range of interest as allowed by an axial/torsional buckling analysis. Two examples are given here for specimen dimensions. With the use of a specimen with outer diameter of 22.23 mm, a wall thickness of 1.59 mm, and a test length of 88.9 mm, the ratio of the wall thickness to the radius is 0.14. These specimens can reach a surface shear strain on the order of 4.0–4.5%. With the use of an outer diameter of 25.15 mm, a thickness of 3.18 mm, and a test length of 76.2 mm, the ratio of the wall thickness to the radius is 0.29. This allows a maximum shear strain prior to buckling in the range of 8.5–12.5% based on elastic analysis. The actual maximum shear strain that can be achieved prior to buckling can be slightly different due to the viscoelastic effects involved in the material. Estimates of strains leading to buckling may be achieved by considering a Young’s modulus for the material that corresponds to the lowest value achieved at the test temperature and the time period of interest for the measurements.
8
x
6
Fig. 3.30 A thin-
4 2 y 0
0
0.01
0.02
0.03 Shear strain
Fig. 3.29 Isochronal shear stress–shear strain relation of PMMA at 80 ◦ C
85
D O z
walled cylinder specimen for combined tension/compression and torsion to generate biaxial stress states [3.113]
Part A 3.4
takes on a particular property value. At that time all possible values of σn and εn are related linearly: a plot of σ versus ε at time t ∗ renders a linear relation with slope 1/J(t ∗ ) and encompassing the origin. For different times t ∗ , straight lines with different slopes result and the linearly viscoelastic material can thus be characterized by a fan of straight lines emanating from the origin, the slope of each line corresponding to a different time t ∗ . The slopes decrease monotonically as these times increase. Each straight line is called a linear isochronal stress–strain relation for the particular time t ∗ . Figure 3.29 shows such an isochronal representation for PMMA. It is seen that, at short times and when the strains are small in creep (shear strain 0.005, shear stress 8 MPa), the material response is close to linearly viscoelastic where all the data stay within the linear fan formed, in this case, by the upper line derived from the shear creep compliance at 10 s, and the lower line corresponding to the compliance in shear at 104 s. At the higher stress levels and at longer times, when the strains are larger, material nonlinearity becomes pronounced, as data points in Fig. 3.29 are outside the linear fan emanating from the origin. In this isochronal plot, the deviation from linearly viscoelastic behavior begins at approximately 0.5% strain level. Isochronal data at other temperatures indicate also that the nonlinearity occurs at ≈ 0.5% strain and a shear stress of about 7.6 MPa at all temperatures for this mater-
3.4 Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Material Characterization
86
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 3.4
Application of Digital Image Correlation The use of strain gages for determining surface strains on a polymer specimen is fraught with problems, since strain gages tend to be much stiffer than the polymer undergoing time-dependent deformations, and, in addition, the potential for increases in local temperature due to the currents in the strain gage complicates definitive data evaluation. Digital image correlation (DIC, Chap. 20) thus offers a perfect tool, though that method is not directly applicable to cylindrical surfaces as typically employed. While we abstain from a detailed review of this method in this context (we refer the reader to [3.114] for particulars), here it is of interest for the completeness of presentation only to summarize this special application to cylindrical surface applications. The results are presented in the form of (apparent) creep compliances defined by 2ε(t)/τ0 . We emphasize again that the creep compliance for a linear material is a function that depends only on time but not on the applied stress. This no longer holds in the nonlinearly viscoelastic regime, but we adhere to the use of this ratio as a creep compliance for convenience. To use DIC for tracking axial, circumferential, and shear strains on a cylindrical surface, a speckle pattern is projected onto the specimen surface. While the same image acquisition system can be used as for flat images special allowance needs to be made for the motion of surface speckles on a cylindrical surface, the orientation of which is also not known a priori. If the focal length of the imaging device is long compared to the radius of the cylinder, an image can be considered as a projection of a cylinder onto an observation plane. Planar deformations can be determined using digital im-
age correlation techniques [3.115, 116], and corrected for curvature to determine the axial, circumferential, and shear strains [3.114]. To assure that the motion is properly interpreted in a cylindrical coordinate system – that the camera axis is effectively very well aligned with the cylinder axis and test frame orientation – the imaging system must also establish the axis of rotation. This can be achieved through offsetting the specimen against a darker background (Fig. 3.31) so as to ensure sufficient contrast between the specimen edge and background for identification of any inclination of the cylinder axis relative to the reference axis within the image recording system. The axis orientation is then also evaluated using the principles of digital image correlation. Without such a determination the parameters identifying the projection of the cylindrical surface onto a plane lead to uncontrollable errors in the data interpretation. The details of the relevant data manipulation can be found in the cited references. Specimen Preparation Specimens can be machined from solid cylinders or from tubes, though tubular specimens tend to have a different molecular orientation because of the extrusion process. Prior to machining, the cylinders need to be annealed at a temperature near the glass-transition temperature to remove residual stresses. The thinwalled cylinder samples need to be annealed again after machining to remove or reduce residual surface stresses possibly acquired during turning. To avoid excessive gravity deformations, annealing is best conducted in an oil bath. Any possible weight gain must be monitored with a balance possessing sufficient resolution. The weight gain should be low enough to avoid any effect of the oil on the viscoelastic behavior of materials. For testing in the glassy state, specimens must have about the same aging times; and the aging times should be at least a few days so that during measurements the aging time change is not significant (on a logarithmic scale). Because physical aging is such an important topic we devote further comments to it in the next subsection. Prior to experiments samples need to be kept in an environment with a constant relative humidity that is the same as the relative humidity during measurements. The relative humidity can be generated through a saturated salt solution in an enclosed container [3.118]. Physical Aging in Specimen Preparation. When an
Fig. 3.31 A typical speckle pattern on a cylinder surface
inclined with respect to the observation axis of the imaging system
amorphous polymer is cooled (continuously) from its melt state, its volume will deviate from its equilibrium state at the glass-transition temperature (Fig. 3.12).
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
87
the time required to attain equilibrium after quenching within practical limits. The value of t ∗ may have to be determined prior to commencing characterization tests. If the viscoelastic properties are investigated without paying attention to the aging process, characterization of polymers and their composites are not likely to generate repeatable results. For characterization of the long-term viscoelastic behavior through accelerated testing, physical aging effects have to be considered, in addition to time–temperature superposition and other mechanisms. An Example of Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Behavior under Combined Axial/Shear Stresses Figure 3.32 shows the creep response in pure shear for PMMA at 80 ◦ C [3.113, 117]. The axial force was controlled to be zero in these measurements. The plotted shear creep compliance was converted from the relaxation modulus in shear under infinitesimal deformation, representing the creep behavior in the linearly viscoelastic regime. For a material that behaves linearly viscoelastically, all curves should be coincident in this plot. In the case of data at these stress levels, the deformations in shear at higher stress levels are accelerated relative to the behavior at infinitesimal strains. This observation constitutes another criterion for separating linear from nonlinear response. To represent the nonlinear characteristics we draw on the isochronal representation discussed above. At any given time spanned in Fig. 3.32, there are five data points from creep under a pure shear stress, giving four sets of isochronal stress/strain data. Plotting these four log (shear creep compliance) (1/MPa) –2.2 –2.4
σ = 0, τ = 16 MPa σ = 0, τ = 14.7 MPa σ = 0, τ = 12.3 MPa σ = 0, τ = 9.4 MPa
T = 80°C
–2.6 –2.8 Inversion from µ(t)
–3 –3.2 0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4 4.5 log (time) (s)
Fig. 3.32 Shear creep compliance of PMMA at several levels of shear stress at 80 ◦ C (after [3.117])
Part A 3.4
Polymers have different viscoelastic characteristics depending on whether they are below the glass-transition temperature (Tg ), in the glass-transition region (in the neighborhood of Tg ), or in the rubbery state (above Tg ). In the rubbery state a polymer is in or near thermodynamic equilibrium, where long-range cooperative motions of long-chain molecules are dominant and result in translational movements of molecules. Below the glass-transition temperature, short-range motions in the form of side-chain motions and rotations of segments of the main chain (primarily in long-term behavior) are dominant. The glass-transition range depends on the cooling rate. After cooling a polymer initially in the rubbery state to an isothermal condition in the glassy state, the polymer enters a thermodynamically nonequilibrium, or metastable, state associated with a smaller density than an optimal condition (equilibrium) would allow. In the equilibrium state the density would increase continuously to its maximum value. If the temperature in the isothermal condition is near Tg , the density increase can occur in a relatively short time, but if the temperature is far below Tg this process occurs over a long period of time, on the order of days, weeks, or months. Prior to reaching the maximum density, as time evolves, depending on how long this process has taken place, the polymer possesses a different viscoelastic response. This phenomenon is called physical aging because no chemical changes occur. The time after quenching to an isothermal condition in the glassy state is called aging time. The viscoelastic functions (e.g., bulk and shear relaxation moduli) change during aging until that process is complete within practical time limitations. The effect of physical aging is similar to a continual decrease of the temperature and results in the reduction of the free volume that provides the space for the mobility of the polymer chain segments as the chain undergoes any rearrangement. There now exists a relatively large body of information on physical aging and the reader is referred to a number of representative publications, in which references in the open literature expand on this topic. References [3.38–44,119–122] showed that physical aging leads to an aging time factor multiplying the external time, analogous to the temperature-dependent multiplier (shift factor) for thermorheologically simple solids in the context of linear viscoelasticity theory. Elaborations of this theme for various materials have been offered to a large extent by McKenna and by Gates as well as their various collaborators Effects of physical aging can be pronounced before aging time reaches the value, say, t ∗ , which is
3.4 Nonlinearly Viscoelastic Material Characterization
88
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
log(axial creep compliance) (1/MPa) –2.2
A–A
Clamped with bolt A – A
Glued for θ > 40°
–2.4 Tension + torsion σ = 25.3 MPa, τ = 14.5 MPa
T = 50°C
–2.6 θ
–2.8 Compression + torsion σ = 25.3 MPa, τ = 14.5 MPa
–3
Part A 3.4
–3.2 0.5
A x y A
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4 4.5 log (time) (s)
Fig. 3.33 Axial creep compliance of PMMA under tension/torsion and compression/torsion at 50 ◦ C
data points at each of the 16 fixed times, say, gives the isochronal stress–strain relation shown in Fig. 3.29. It is clear that the creep rate increases with an increase in applied shear stress, indicating nonlinear creep behavior in shear. We note that for isochronal behavior at strains above 0.5%, there exists a fan emanating from the shear strain 0.5% and a shear stress of 7.6 MPa. The corresponding fan center is considered to be the yield point, above which the creep rate is accelerTest section 10.16 R = 10.16
22.54
22.3
22.54
44.6
15.14 30.48
Fig. 3.34 Geometry of an Arcan specimen (all dimensions are in mm, thickness is 3 mm)
Fig. 3.35 Fixture for testing Arcan specimens
ated measurably. It is of interest to note that the creep process is more pronounced (accelerated) in tension/torsion than under compression/torsion as illustrated in Fig. 3.33 for 50 ◦ C. We have already observed that thin-walled cylinders tend to buckle under sufficiently high torsion and/or compression. A cylinder with an outer diameter of 25.15 mm, a thickness of 3.18 mm, and a test length of 76.2 mm would buckle at ≈ 5% shear strain under pure torsion. The use of thicker-walled cylinders would reduce the homogeneity of the stress and strain within the cylinder wall and lead to inaccuracy in the determination of stress or strain. Other techniques, such as testing with the Arcan specimen should, therefore, be used when the nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior at larger deformations is investigated. Use of the Arcan Specimen Arcan’s specimen [3.123–125] can be used for multibiaxial test with the use of a uniaxial material test system. Figure 3.34 shows an Arcan specimen, and Fig. 3.35 a corresponding test fixture. The loading axis can form different angles with respect to the specimen axis so that biaxial stress states can be generated in the region of uniform deformation in the middle of the specimen. When the loading axis of the fixture is aligned with the major specimen axis, this configura-
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
Fig. 3.36 Isochronal contours of creep strains under fixed biaxial loading. Each contour corresponds to a different time between 10 s and about 105 s. Ellipses correspond to linear response characteristics
3.5 Closing Remarks
89
Normal strain 0.025 0.02 0.015 0.01 0.005 0 – 0.005 – 0.01 – 0.015 – 0.02 – 0.025 –0.03
–0.02
–0.01
0
0.01
0.02 0.03 Normal strain
show ellipses (a/b = 2) that would correspond to totally linearly viscoelastic behavior.
3.5 Closing Remarks As was stated at the very beginning, today’s laboratory and general engineering environment is bound to involve polymers, whether of the rigid or the soft variety. The difference between these two derives merely from the value of their glass-transition temperature relative to the use temperature (usually room temperature). As illustrated in this chapter the linearized theory of viscoelasticity is well understood and formulated mathematically, even though its current application in engineering designs is usually not on a par with this understanding. A considerable degree of response estimation can be achieved with this knowledge, but a serious deficiency arises from the fact that when structural failures are of concern the linearized theory soon encounters limitations as nonlinear behavior is encountered. There is, today, no counterpart nonlinear viscoelastic material description that parallels the plasticity theory for metallic solids. Because the atomic structures of metals and polymers are fundamentally different, it would seem imprudent to characterize polymer nonlinear behavior along similar lines of physical reasoning and mathematical formulation, notwithstanding the fact that in uniaxial deformations permanent deformations in metals and polymers may appear to be similar. That similarity disappears as soon as temperature or extended
time scales follow an initially nonlinear deformation history. It is becoming clear already that the superposition of dilatational stresses or volumetric strains has a greater influence on nonlinear material response of polymers than is true for metals. Consequently it would seem questionable whether uniaxial tensile or compressive behavior would be a suitable method for assessing nonlinear polymer response, since that stress state involves both shear and bulk (volumetric) components. To support this observation one only needs to recall that very small amounts of volume change can have a highly disproportionate effect on the time dependence of the material, as delineated in Sects. 3.2.8, 3.2.9, and 3.2.10. This is well illustrated by the best known and large effect which a change in temperature has on the relaxation times, where dilatational strains are indeed very small compared to typical shear deformations; responses under pressure and with solvent swelling underscore this observation. The recent publication history for time-dependent material behavior exhibits an increasing number of papers dealing with nonlinear polymer behavior, indicating that efforts are underway to address this lack of understanding in the engineering profession. At the same time it is also becoming clear that the intrinsic time-dependent behavior of polymers is closely
Part A 3.5
tion induces shear forces applied to an Arcan specimen so that there is a pure shear zone in the central portion of the specimen. Other orientations allow the nonlinearly viscoelastic shear behavior to be characterized under loading conditions combining tension/shear, compression/shear, and pure shear. The data processing is illustrated using the results obtained by Knauss and Zhu [3.126,127] as an example. Figure 3.36 shows isochronal creep shear and normal strains at 80 ◦ C using an Arcan specimen under a nominal (maximum) shear stress of 19.3 MPa. At each fixed time, line segments connect points to form an isochronal strain contour. The innermost contour corresponds to a creep time of 10 s, and the outermost contour is the results from 0.8 × 105 s. For comparison purposes we also
90
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
connected to the molecular processes that are well represented by the linearly viscoelastic characterization of these solids. It is thus not unreasonable, in retrospect, to have devoted a chapter mostly to describing linearly
viscoelastic solids with the expectation that this knowledge provides a necessary if not sufficient background for dealing with future issues that need to be resolved in the laboratory.
3.6 Recognizing Viscoelastic Solutions if the Elastic Solution is Known
Part A 3.6
Experimental work deals with a variety of situations/test configurations for which boundary value histories are not readily confined to a limited number of cases. For example, when deformations are to be measured by photoelasticity with the help of a viscoelastic, photosensitive material in a two-dimensional domain it may be important to know the local stress state very well, if knowing the stress state in a test configuration is an important prerequisite for resolving an engineering analysis problem. There exists a large class of elastic boundary value problems for which the distribution of stresses (or strains) turns out to be independent of the material properties. In such cases the effect of loading and material properties is expressed through a material-dependent factor and a load factor, both multiplying a function(s) that depends only on the spatial coordinates governing the distribution of stress or strain. It then follows that for the corresponding viscoelastic solution the distribution of stresses is also independent of the material properties and that the time dependence is formulated as the convolution of a material-dependent multiplicative function with the time-dependent load factored out from the spatial distribution function(s). In the experimental context beams and plates fall into this category, though even the simple plate configuration can involve Poisson’s ratio in its deformation field. More important is the class of simply connected two-dimensional domains for which the in-plane stress distribution is independent of the material properties. Consider first two-dimensional, quasistatic problems with (only) traction boundary conditions prescribed on a simply connected domain. For such problems the stress distribution of an elastic solid throughout the interior is independent of the material properties. The same situation prevails for multiply connected domains, provided the traction on each perforation is self-equilibrating. If the latter condition is not satisfied, then a history-dependent Poisson function enters the stress field description so that the stress distribution is, at best, only approximately independent of, or insensitive to, the material behavior. This topic is discussed in a slightly more detailed manner in [3.13].
3.6.1 Further Reading For general background it appears useful to identify the dominant publications to bolster one’s understanding of the theory of viscoelasticity. To that end we summarize here first, without comment or reference number, a list of publications in book or paper form, only one of which appears as an explicit reference in the text, namely the book by J.D. Ferry as part of the text development [3.45] with respect to the special topic of thermorheologically simple solids. 1. T. Alfrey: Mechanical Behavior of High Polymers (Interscience, New York, 1948) 2. B. Gross: Mathematical Structure of the Theories of Viscoelasticity (Herrmann, Paris, 1953) (re-issued 1968) 3. A.V. Tobolsky: Properties and Structure of Polymers (Wiley, New York, 1960) 4. M.E. Gurtin, E. Sternberg: On the linear theory of viscoelasticity, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 11, 291–356 (1962) 5. F. Bueche: Physical Properties of Polymers (Interscience, New York, 1962) 6. M.L. Williams: The structural analysis of viscoelastic materials, AIAA J. 2, 785–809 (1964) 7. Flügge (Ed.): Encyclopedia of Physics VIa/3, M.J. Leitman, G.M.C. Fischer: The linear theory of viscoelasticity (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1973) 8. J.J. Aklonis, W.J. MacKnight: Introduction to Polymer Viscoelasticity (Wiley, New York 1983) 9. N.W. Tschoegl: The Phenomenological Theory of Linear Viscoelastic Behavior, an Introduction (Springer, Berlin, 1989) 10. A. Drozdov: Viscoelastic Structures, Mechanics of Growth and Aging (Academic, New York, 1998) 11. D.R. Bland: The Theory of Linear Viscoelasticity, Int. Ser. Mon. Pure Appl. Math. 10 (Pergamon, New York, 1960) 12. R.M. Christensen: Theory of Viscoelasticity: An Introduction (Academic, New York, 1971); see also R.M. Christensen: Theory of Viscoelasticity An Introduction, 2nd ed. (Dover, New York, 1982)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
17. C.W. Folkes: Two systems for automatic reduction of time-dependent photomechanics data, Exp. Mech. 10, 64–71 (1970) 18. P.S. Theocaris: Phenomenological analysis of mechanical and optical behaviour of rheo-optically simple materials. In: Photoelastic Effect and its applications, ed. by J. Kestens (Springer, Berlin New York, 1975) pp. 146–152 19. B.D. Coleman, E.H. Dill: Photoviscoelasticity: Theory and practice. In: The Photoelastic Effect and its Applications, ed. by J. Kestens, (Springer, Berlin New York, 1975) pp. 455–505 20. M.A. Narbut: On the correspondence between dynamic stress states in an elastic body and in its photoviscoelastic model, Vestn. Leningr. Univ. Ser. Mat. Mekh. Astron. (USSR) 1, 116–122 (1978) 21. R.J. Arenz, U. Soltész: Time-dependent optical characterization in the photoviscoelastic study of stress-waver propagation, Exp. Mech. 21, 227–233 (1981) 22. K.S. Kim, K.L. Dickerson, W.G. Knauss (Eds): Viscoelastic effect on dynamic crack propagation in Homalit 100. In: Workshop on Dynamic Fracture (California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, 1983) pp. 205–233 23. H. Weber: Ein nichtlineares Stoffgesetz für die ebene photoviskoelastische Spannungsanalyse, Rheol. Acta. 22, 114–122 (1983) 24. Y. Miyano, S. Nakamura, S. Sugimon, T.C. Woo: A simplified optical method for measuring residual stress by rapid cooling in a thermosetting resin strip, Exp. Mech. 26, 185–192 (1986) 25. A. Bakic: Practical execution of photoviscoelastic experiments, Oesterreichische Ingenieur- und Architekten-Zeitschrift, 131, 260–263 (1986) 26. K.S. Kim, K.L. Dickerson, W.G. Knauss: Viscoelastic behavior of opto-mechanical properties and its application to viscoelastic fracture studies, Int. J. Fract. 12, 265–283 (1987) 27. T. Kunio, Y. Miyano, S. Sugimori: Fundamentals of photoviscoelastic technique for analysis of time and temperature dependent stress and strain. In: Applied Stress Analysis, ed. by T.H. Hyde, E. Ollerton (Elsevier Applied Sciences, London, 1990) pp. 588– 597 28. K.-H. Laermann, C.Yuhai: On the measurement of the material response of linear photoviscoelastic polymers, Measurement, 279–286 (1993)
91
Part A 3.6
References on Photoviscoelasticity 1. R.D. Mindlin: A mathematical theory of photoviscoelasticity, J. Appl. Phys. 29, 206–210 (1949) 2. R.S. Stein, S. Onogi, D.A. Keedy: The dynamic birefringence of high polymers, J. Polym. Sci. 57, 801–821 (1962) 3. C.W. Ferguson: Analysis of stress-wave propagation by photoviscoelastic techniques, J. Soc. Motion Pict. Telev. Eng. 73, 782–787 (1964) 4. P.S. Theocaris, D. Mylonas: Viscoelastic effects in birefringent coating, J. Appl. Mech. 29, 601–607 (1962) 5. M.L. Williams, R.J. Arenz: The engineering analysis of linear photoviscoelastic materials, Exp. Mech. 4, 249–262 (1964) 6. E.H. Dill: On phenomenological rheo-optical constitutive relations, J. Polym. Sci. Part C 5, 67–74 (1964) 7. C.L. Amba-Rao: Stress-strain-time-birefringence relations in photoelastic plastics with creep, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. C 5, 75–86 (1964) 8. B.E. Read: Dynamic birefringence of amorphous polymers, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. C 5, 87–100 (1964) 9. R.D. Andrews, T.J. Hammack: Temperature dependence of orientation birefringence of polymers in the glassy and rubbery states, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. C 5, 101–112 (1964) 10. R. Yamada, C. Hayashi, S. Onogi, M. Horio: Dynamic birefringence of several high polymers, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. C 5, 123–127 (1964) 11. K. Sasguri, R.S. Stain: Dynamic birefringence of polyolefins, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. C 5, 139–152 (1964) 12. D.G. Legrand, W.R. Haaf: Rheo-optical properties of polymers, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. C 5, 153–161 (1964) 13. I.M. Daniel: Experimental methods for dynamic stress analysis in viscoelastic materials, J. Appl. Mech. 32, 598–606 (1965) 14. I.M. Daniel: Quasistatic properties of a photoviscoelastic material, Exp. Mech. 5, 83–89 (1965) 15. A.J. Arenz, C.W. Ferguson, M.L. Williams: The mechanical and optical characterization of a Solithane 113 composition, Exp. Mech. 7, 183– 188 (1967) 16. H.F. Brinson: Mechanical, optical viscoelastic characterization of Hysol 4290: Time and temperature behavior of Hysol 4290 as obtained from creep tests in conjunction with the time-temperature superposition principle, Exp. Mech. 8, 561–566 (1968)
3.6 Recognizing Viscoelastic Solutions if the Elastic Solution is Known
92
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
29. S. Yoneyama, J. Gotoh, M. Takashi: Experimental analysis of rolling contact stresses in a viscoelastic strip, Exp. Mech. 40, 203–210 (2000) 30. A.I. Shyu, C.T. Isayev, T.I. Li: Photoviscoelastic behavior of amorphous polymers during transition
from the glassy to rubbery state, J. Polym. Sci. Pt. B Polym. Phys. 39, 2252–2262 (2001) 31. Y.-H. Zhao, J. Huang: Photoviscoelastic stress analysis of a plate with a central hole, Exp. Mech. 41, 312–18 (2001)
References 3.1 3.2
Part A 3
3.3
3.4 3.5
3.6 3.7
3.8 3.9 3.10
3.11
3.12
3.13
3.14 3.15
3.16
3.17
W.G. Knauss: The mechanics of polymer fracture, Appl. Mech. Rev. 26, 1–17 (1973) C. Singer, E.J. Holmgard, A.R. Hall (Eds.): A History of Technology (Oxford University Press, New York 1954) J.M. Kelly: Strain rate sensitivity and yield point behavior in mild steel, Int. J. Solids Struct. 3, 521–532 (1967) H.H. Johnson, P.C. Paris: Subcritical flaw growth, Eng. Fract. Mech. 1, 3–45 (1968) I. Finnie: Stress analysis for creep and creeprupture. In: Appllied Mechanics Surveys, ed. by H.N. Abramson (Spartan Macmillan, New York 1966) pp. 373–383 F. Garofalo: Fundamentals of Creep and Creep Rupture in Metals (Macmillan, New York 1965) N.J. Grant, A.W. Mullendore (Eds.): Deformation and Fracture at Elevated Temperatures (MIT Press, Cambridge 1965) F.A. McClintock, A.S. Argon (Eds.): Mechanical Behavior of Materials (Addison-Wesley, Reading 1966) J.B. Conway: Numerical Methods for Creep and Rupture Analyses (Gordon-Breach, New York 1967) J.B. Conway, P.N. Flagella: Creep Rupture Data for the Refractory Metals at High Temperatures (Gordon-Breach, New York 1971) M. Tao: High Temperature Deformation of Vitreloy Bulk Metallic Glasses and Their Composite. Ph.D. Thesis (California Institute of Technology, Pasadena 2006) J. Lu, G. Ravichandran, W.L. Johnson: Deformation behavior of the Zr41.2 Ti13.8 Cu12.5 Ni10 Be22.5 bulk metallic glass over a wide range of strain-rates and temperatures, Acta Mater. 51, 3429–3443 (2003) W.G. Knauss: Viscoelasticity and the timedependent fracture of polymers. In: Comprehensive Structural Integrity, Vol. 2, ed. by I. Milne, R.O. Ritchie, B. Karihaloo (Elsevier, Amsterdam 2003) W. Flügge: Viscoelasticity (Springer, Berlin 1975) H. Lu, X. Zhang, W.G. Knauss: Uniaxial, shear and Poisson relaxation and their conversion to bulk relaxation, Polym. Eng. Sci. 37, 1053–1064 (1997) N.W. Tschoegl, W.G. Knauss, I. Emri: Poisson’s ratio in linear viscoelasticity, a critical review, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 6, 3–51 (2002) I.L. Hopkins, R.W. Hamming: On creep and relaxation, J. Appl. Phys. 28, 906–909 (1957)
3.18
3.19
3.20
3.21
3.22
3.23
3.24
3.25
3.26
3.27
3.28
3.29
3.30
R.A. Schapery: Approximate methods of transform inversion for viscoelastic stress analysis, Proc. 4th US Natl. Congr. Appl. Mech. (1962) pp. 1075–1085 J.F. Clauser, W.G. Knauss: On the numerical determination of relaxation and retardation spectra for linearly viscoelastic materials, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 12, 143–153 (1968) G.W. Hedstrom, L. Thigpen, B.P. Bonner, P.H. Worley: Regularization and inverse problems in viscoelasticity, J. Appl. Mech. 51, 121–12 (1984) I. Emri, N.W. Tschoegl: Generating line spectra from experimental responses. Part I: Relaxation modulus and creep compliance, Rheol. Acta. 32, 311–321 (1993) I. Emri, N.W. Tschoegl: Generating line spectra from experimental responses. Part IV: Application to experimental data, Rheol. Acta. 33, 60–70 (1994) I. Emri, N.W. Tschoegl: An iterative computer algorithm for generating line spectra from linear viscoelastic response functions, Int. J. Polym. Mater. 40, 55–79 (1998) N.W. Tschoegl, I. Emri: Generating line spectra from experimental responses. Part II. Storage and loss functions, Rheol. Acta. 32, 322–327 (1993) N.W. Tschoegl, I. Emri: Generating line spectra from experimental responses. Part III. Interconversion between relaxation and retardation behavior, Int. J. Polym. Mater. 18, 117–127 (1992) I. Emri, N.W. Tschoegl: Generating line spectra from experimental responses. Part V. Time-dependent viscosity, Rheol. Acta. 36, 303–306 (1997) I. Emri, B.S. von Bernstorff, R. Cvelbar, A. Nikonov: Re-examination of the approximate methods for interconversion between frequency- and timedependent material functions, J. Non-Newton. Fluid Mech. 129, 75–84 (2005) A. Nikonov, A.R. Davies, I. Emri: The determination of creep and relaxation functions from a single experiment, J. Rheol. 49, 1193–1211 (2005) M.A. Branch, T.F. Coleman, Y. Li: A subspace interior, and conjugate gradient method for large-scale bound-constrained minimization problems, Siam J. Sci. Comput. 21, 1–23 (1999) F. Kohlrausch: Experimental-Untersuchungen über die elastische Nachwirkung bei der Torsion, Ausdehnung und Biegung, Pogg. Ann. Phys. 8, 337 (1876)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
3.31
3.32
3.33
3.34
3.35
3.37
3.38
3.39
3.40
3.41
3.42
3.43
3.44
3.45 3.46
3.47
3.48
3.49
3.50
3.51
3.52
3.53
3.54
3.55
3.56
3.57
3.58
3.59
3.60
3.61
3.62
J. Bischoff, E. Catsiff, A.V. Tobolsky: Elastoviscous properties of amorphous polymers in the transition region 1, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 74, 3378–3381 (1952) F. Schwarzl, A.J. Staverman: Time-temperature dependence of linearly viscoelastic behavior, J. Appl. Phys. 23, 838–843 (1952) M.L. Williams, R.F. Landel, J.D. Ferry: Mechanical properties of substances of high molecular weight. 19. The temperature dependence of relaxation mechanisms in amorphous polymers and other glass-forming liquids, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 77, 3701–3707 (1955) D.J. Plazek: Temperature dependence of the viscoelastic behavior of polystyrene, J. Phys. Chem. US 69, 3480–3487 (1965) D.J. Plazek: The temperature dependence of the viscoelastic behavior of poly(vinyl acetate), Polym. J. 12, 43–53 (1980) R.A. Fava (Ed.): Methods of experimental physics 16C. In: Viscoelastic and Steady-State Rheological Response, ed. by D.J. Plazek (Academic, New York 1979) L.W. Morland, E.H. Lee: Stress analysis for linear viscoelastic materials with temperature variation, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 4, 233–263 (1960) L.J. Heymans: An Engineering Analysis of Polymer Film Adhesion to Rigid Substrates. Ph.D. Thesis (California Institute of Technology, Pasadena 1983) G.U. Losi, W.G. Knauss: Free volume theory and nonlinear viscoelasticity, Polym. Eng. Sci. 32, 542–557 (1992) I. Emri, T. Prodan: A Measuring system for bulk and shear characterization of polymers, Exp. Mech. 46(6), 429–439 (2006) N.W. Tschoegl, W.G. Knauss, I. Emri: The effect of temperature and pressure on the mechanical properties of thermo- and/or piezorheologically simple polymeric materials in thermodynamic equilibrium – a critical review, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 6, 53–99 (2002) R.W. Fillers, N.W. Tschoegl: The effect of pressure on the mechanical properties of polymers, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 21, 51–100 (1977) W.K. Moonan, N.W. Tschoegl: The effect of pressure on the mechanical properties of polymers. 2. Expansively and compressibility measurements, Macromolecules 16, 55–59 (1983) W.K. Moonan, N.W. Tschoegl: The effect of pressure on the mechanical properties of polymers. 3. Substitution of the glassy parameters for those of the occupied volume, Int. Polym. Mater. 10, 199–211 (1984) W.K. Moonan, N.W. Tschoegl: The effect of pressure on the mechanical properties of polymers. 4. Measurements in torsion, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. 23, 623–651 (1985)
93
Part A 3
3.36
G. Williams, D.C. Watts: Non-symmetrical dielectric behavior arising from a simple empirical decay function, Trans. Faraday Soc. 66, 80–85 (1970) S. Lee, W.G. Knauss: A note on the determination of relaxation and creep data from ramp tests, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 4, 1–7 (2000) A. Flory, G.B. McKenna: Finite step rate corrections in stress relaxation experiments: A comparison of two methods, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 8, 17–37 (2004) J.F. Tormey, S.C. Britton: Effect of cyclic loading on solid propellant grain structures, AIAA J. 1, 1763–1770 (1963) R.A. Schapery: Thermomechanical behavior of viscoelastic media with variable properties subjected to cyclic loading, J. Appl. Mech. 32, 611–619 (1965) L.R.G. Treloar: Physics of high-molecular materials, Nature 181, 1633–1634 (1958) M.-F. Vallat, D.J. Plazek, B. Bushan: Effects of thermal treatment of biaxially oriented poly(ethylene terephthalate), J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. 24, 1303– 1320 (1986) L.E. Struik: Physical Aging in Amorphous Polymers and Other Materials (Elsevier Scientific, Amsterdam 1978) G.B. McKenna, A.J. Kovacs: Physical aging of poly(methyl methacrylate) in the nonlinear range – torque and normal force measurements, Polym. Eng. Sci. 24, 1138–1141 (1984) A. Lee, G.B. McKenna: Effect of crosslink density on physical aging of epoxy networks, Polymer 29, 1812– 1817 (1988) C. G’Sell, G.B. McKenna: Influence of physical aging on the yield response of model dgeba poly(propylene oxide) epoxy glasses, Polymer 33, 2103–2113 (1992) M.L. Cerrada, G.B. McKenna: Isothermal, isochronal and isostructural results, Macromolecules 33, 3065– 3076 (2000) L.C. Brinson, T.S. Gates: Effects of physical aging on long-term creep of polymers and polymer matrix composites, Int. J. Solids Struct. 32, 827–846 (1995) L.M. Nicholson, K.S. Whitley, T.S. Gates: The combined influence of molecular weight and temperature on the physical aging and creep compliance of a glassy thermoplastic polyimide, Mech. TimeDepend. Mat. 5, 199–227 (2001) J.D. Ferry: Viscoelastic Properties of Polymers, 3rd edn. (Wiley, New York 1980) J.R. Mcloughlin, A.V. Tobolsky: The viscoelastic behavior of polymethyl methacrylate, J. Colloid Sci. 7, 555–568 (1952) H. Leaderman, R.G. Smith, R.W. Jones: Rheology of polyisobutylene. 2. Low molecular weight polymers, J. Polym. Sci. 14, 47–80 (1954)
References
94
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
3.63
3.64
3.65
3.66
3.67
Part A 3
3.68
3.69
3.70
3.71
3.72
3.73
3.74
3.75
3.76
3.77
3.78
3.79
W.G. Knauss, V.H. Kenner: On the hygrothermomechanical characterization of polyvinyl acetate, J. Appl. Phys. 51, 5131–5136 (1980) I. Emri, V. Pavˇsek: On the influence of moisture on the mechanical properties of polymers, Mater. Forum 16, 123–131 (1992) D.J. Plazek: Magnetic bearing torsional creep apparatus, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Chem. 6, 621–633 (1968) D.J. Plazek, M.N. Vrancken, J.W. Berge: A torsion pendulum for dynamic and creep measurements of soft viscoelastic materials, Trans. Soc. Rheol. 2, 39–51 (1958) G.C. Berry, J.O. Park, D.W. Meitz, M.H. Birnboim, D.J. Plazek: A rotational rheometer for rheological studies with prescribed strain or stress history, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. Ed. 27, 273–296 (1989) R.S. Duran, G.B. McKenna: A torsional dilatometer for volume change measurements on deformed glasses: Instrument description and measurements on equilibrated glasses, J. Rheol. 34, 813–839 (1990) J.E. McKinney, S. Edelman, R.S. Marvin: Apparatus for the direct determination of the dynamic bulk modulus, J. Appl. Phys. 27, 425–430 (1956) J.E. McKinney, H.V. Belcher: Dynamic compressibility of poly(vinyl acetate) and its relation to free volume, J. Res. Nat. Bur. Stand. Phys. Chem. 67A, 43–53 (1963) T.H. Deng, W.G. Knauss: The temperature and frequency dependence of the bulk compliance of Poly(vinyl acetate). A re-examination, Mech. TimeDepend. Mater. 1, 33–49 (1997) S. Sane, W.G. Knauss: The time-dependent bulk response of poly (methyl methacrylate), Mech. TimeDepend. Mater. 5, 293–324 (2001) Z. Ma, K. Ravi-Chandar: Confined compression– a stable homogeneous deformation for multiaxial constitutive characterization, Exp. Mech. 40, 38–45 (2000) K. Ravi-Chandar, Z. Ma: Inelastic deformation in polymers under multiaxial compression, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 4, 333–357 (2000) D. Qvale, K. Ravi-Chandar: Viscoelastic characterization of polymers under multiaxial compression, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 8, 193–214 (2004) S.J. Park, K.M. Liechti, S. Roy: Simplified bulk experiments and hygrothermal nonlinear viscoelasticty, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 8, 303–344 (2004) A. Kralj, T. Prodan, I. Emri: An apparatus for measuring the effect of pressure on the timedependent properties of polymers, J. Rheol. 45, 929–943 (2001) J.B. Pethica, R. Hutchings, W.C. Oliver: Hardness measurement at penetration depths as small as 20 nm, Philos. Mag. 48, 593–606 (1983) W.C. Oliver, R. Hutchings, J.B. Pethica: Measurement of hardness at indentation depths as low as 20 nanometers. In: Microindentation Techniques in Materials Science and Engineering ASTM STP 889, ed.
3.80
3.81
3.82
3.83
3.84
3.85
3.86
3.87 3.88
3.89 3.90
3.91 3.92
3.93
3.94 3.95
by P.J. Blau, B.R. Lawn (American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia 1986) pp. 90–108 W.C. Oliver, G.M. Pharr: An improved technique for determining hardness and elastic modulus using load and displacement sensing indentation experiments, J. Mater. Res. 7, 1564–1583 (1992) I.N. Sneddon: The relation between load and penetration in the axisymmetric boussinesq problem for a punch of arbitrary profile, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 3, 47–57 (1965) M. Oyen-Tiesma, Y.A. Toivola, R.F. Cook: Loaddisplacement behavior during sharp indentation of viscous-elastic-plastic materials. In: Fundamentals of Nanoindentation and Nanotribology II, ed. by S.P. Baker, R.F. Cook, S.G. Corcoran, N.R. Moody (Mater. Res. Soc., Warrendale 2000) pp. Q1.5.1– Q1.5.6, MRS Proc. Vol. 649, MRS Fall Meeting, Boston L. Cheng, X. Xia, W. Yu, L.E. Scriven, W.W. Gerberich: Flat-punch indentation of viscoelastic material, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. 38, 10–22 (2000) H. Lu, B. Wang, J. Ma, G. Huang, H. Viswanathan: Measurement of creep compliance of solid polymers by nanoindentation, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 7, 189–207 (2003) G. Huang, B. Wang, H. Lu: Measurements of viscoelastic functions in frequency-domain by nanoindentation, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 8, 345–364 (2004) T.C.T. Ting: The contact stresses between a rigid indenter and a viscoelastic half-space, J. Appl. Mech. 33, 845–854 (1966) E.H. Lee, J.R.M. Radok: The contact problem for viscoelastic bodies, J. Appl. Mech. 27, 438–444 (1960) E. Riande, R. Diaz-Calleja, M.G. Prolongo, R.M. Masegosa, C. Salom: Polymer Viscoelasticity-Stress and Strain in Practice (Dekker, New York 2000) J.R.M. Radok: Visco-elastic stress analysis, Q. of Appl. Math. 15, 198–202 (1957) S.C. Hunter: The Hertz problem for a rigid spherical indenter and a viscoelastic half-space, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 8, 219–234 (1960) W.H. Yang: The contact problem for viscoelastic bodies, J. Appl. Mech. 33, 395–401 (1960) S.A. Hutcheson, G.B. McKenna: Nanosphere embedding into polymer surfaces: A viscoelastic contact mechanics analysis, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 076103.1– 076103.4 (2005) J.H. Teichroeb, J.A. Forrest: Direct imaging of nanoparticle embedding to probe viscoelasticity of polymer surfaces, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 016104.1– 106104.4 (2003) M.L. Oyen: Spherical indentation creep following ramp loading, J. Mater. Res. 20, 2094–2100 (2005) M.R. VanLandingham, N.K. Chang, P.L. Drzal, C.C. White, S.-H. Chang: Viscoelastic characterization of polymers using instrumented indentation–1. Quasi-static testing, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. 43, 1794–1811 (2005)
Mechanics of Polymers: Viscoelasticity
3.96
3.97
3.98
3.100
3.101
3.102
3.103
3.104
3.105
3.106
3.107
3.108
3.109
3.110
3.111 R.A. Schapery: A theory of non-linear thermoviscoelasticity based on irreversible thermodynamics, Proc. 5th Natl. Cong. Appl. Mech. (1966) pp. 511–530 3.112 R.A. Schapery: On the characterization of nonlinear viscoelastic materials, Polym. Eng. Sci. 9, 295–310 (1969) 3.113 H. Lu, W.G. Knauss: The role of dilatation in the nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior of pmma under multiaxial stress states, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 2, 307–334 (1999) 3.114 H. Lu, G. Vendroux, W.G. Knauss: Surface deformation measurements of cylindrical specimens by digital image correlation, Exp. Mech. 37, 433–439 (1997) 3.115 W.H. Peters, W.F. Ranson: Digital imaging techniques in experimental stress analysis, Opt. Eng. 21, 427–432 (1982) 3.116 M.A. Sutton, W.J. Wolters, W.H. Peters, W.F. Ranson, S.R. McNeil: Determination of displacements using an improved digital image correlation method, Im. Vis. Comput. 1, 133–139 (1983) 3.117 H. Lu: Nonlinear Thermo-Mechanical Behavior of Polymers under Multiaxial Loading. Ph.D. Thesis (California Institute of Technology, Pasadena 1997) 3.118 D.R. Lide: CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics (CRC Press, Boca Raton 1995) 3.119 G.B. McKenna: On the physics required for prediction of long term performance of polymers and their composites, J. Res. NIST 99(2), 169–189 (1994) 3.120 P.A. O’Connell, G.B. McKenna: Large deformation response of polycarbonate: Time-temperature, time-aging time, and time-strain superposition, Polym. Eng. Sci. 37, 1485–1495 (1997) 3.121 J.L. Sullivan, E.J. Blais, D. Houston: Physical aging in the creep-behavior of thermosetting and thermoplastic composites, Compos. Sci. Technol. 47, 389–403 (1993) 3.122 I.M. Hodge: Physical aging in polymer glasses, Science 267, 1945–1947 (1995) 3.123 N. Goldenberg, M. Arcan, E. Nicolau: On the most suitable specimen shape for testing sheer strength of plastics, ASTM STP 247, 115–121 (1958) 3.124 M. Arcan, Z. Hashin, A. Voloshin: A method to produce uniform plane-stress states with applications to fiber-reinforced materials, Exp. Mech. 18, 141–146 (1978) 3.125 M. Arcan: Discussion of the iosipescu shear test as applied to composite materials, Exp. Mech. 24, 66– 67 (1984) 3.126 W.G. Knauss, W. Zhu: Nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior of polycarbonate. I. Response under pure shear, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 6, 231–269 (2002) 3.127 W.G. Knauss, W. Zhu: Nonlinearly viscoelastic behavior of polycarbonate. II. The role of volumetric strain, Mech. Time-Depend. Mater. 6, 301–322 (2002)
95
Part A 3
3.99
J.L. Loubet, B.N. Lucas, W.C. Oliver: Some measurements of viscoelastic properties with the help of nanoindentation, International workshop on Instrumental Indentation, ed. by D.T. Smith (NIST Special Publication, San Diego 1995) pp. 31–34 B.N. Lucas, W.C. Oliver, J.E. Swindeman: The dynamic of frequency-specific, depth-sensing indentation testing, Fundamentals of Nanoindentation and Nanotribology, Vol. 522, ed. by N.R. Moody (Mater. Res. Soc., Warrendale 1998) pp. 3–14, MRS Meeting, San Francisco 1998 R.J. Arenz, M.L. Williams (Eds.): A photoelastic technique for ground shock investigation. In: Ballistic and Space Technology (Academic, New York 1960) Y. Miyano, T. Tamura, T. Kunio: The mechanical and optical characterization of Polyurethane with application to photoviscoelastic analysis, Bull. JSME 12, 26–31 (1969) A.B.J. Clark, R.J. Sanford: A comparison of static and dynamic properties of photoelastic materialsm, Exp. Mech. 3, 148–151 (1963) O.A. Hasan, M.C. Boyce: A constitutive model for the nonlinear viscoelastic-viscoplastic behavior of glassy polymers, Polym. Eng. Sci. 35, 331–334 (1995) J.S. Bergström, M.C. Boyce: Constitutive modeling of the large strain time-dependent behavior of elastomers, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 46, 931–954 (1998) P.D. Ewing, S. Turner, J.G. Williams: Combined tension-torsion studies on polymers: apparatus and preliminary results for Polyethylene, J. Strain Anal. Eng. 7, 9–22 (1972) C. Bauwens-Crowet: The compression yield behavior of polymethal methacrylate over a wide range of temperatures and strain rates, J. Mater. Sci. 8, 968– 979 (1973) L.C. Caraprllucci, A.F. Yee: The biaxial deformation and yield behavior of bisphenol-A polycarbonate: Effect of anisotropy, Polym. Eng. Sci. 26, 920–930 (1986) W.G. Knauss, I. Emri: Non-linear viscoelasticity based on free volume consideration, Comput. Struct. 13, 123–128 (1981) W.G. Knauss, I. Emri: Volume change and the nonlinearly thermo-viscoelastic constitution of polymers, Polym. Eng. Sci. 27, 86–100 (1987) G.U. Losi, W.G. Knauss: Free volume theory and nonlinear thermoviscoelasticity, Polym. Eng. Sci. 32, 542–557 (1992) G.U. Losi, W.G. Knauss: Thermal stresses in nonlinearly viscoelastic solids, J. Appl. Mech. 59, S43–S49 (1992) W.G. Knauss, S. Sundaram: Pressure-sensitive dissipation in elastomers and its implications for the detonation of plastic explosives, J. Appl. Phys. 96, 7254–7266 (2004)
References
97
Composite M 4. Composite Materials
Peter G. Ifju
4.2.3 Shear Testing ............................... 105 4.2.4 Single-Geometry Tests .................. 106 4.3
Micromechanics.................................... 4.3.1 In Situ Strain Measurements .......... 4.3.2 Fiber–Matrix Interface Characterization........................... 4.3.3 Nanoscale Testing ........................ 4.3.4 Self-Healing Composites ...............
107 107 108 109 111
4.4 Interlaminar Testing ............................. 4.4.1 Mode I Fracture............................ 4.4.2 Mode II Fracture........................... 4.4.3 Edge Effects .................................
111 111 113 114
4.5 Textile Composite Materials ................... 4.5.1 Documentation of Surface Strain .... 4.5.2 Strain Gage Selection .................... 4.5.3 Edge Effects in Textile Composites ..
114 114 116 117 117 118 118 119 120 120
4.1
Strain Gage Applications ....................... 98 4.1.1 Transverse Sensitivity Corrections ... 98 4.1.2 Error Due to Gage Misalignment ..... 99 4.1.3 Temperature Compensation ........... 100 4.1.4 Self-Heating Effects ...................... 101 4.1.5 Additional Considerations ............. 101
4.6 Residual Stresses in Composites ............. 4.6.1 Composite Sectioning ................... 4.6.2 Hole-Drilling Methods .................. 4.6.3 Strain Gage Methods .................... 4.6.4 Laminate Warpage Methods .......... 4.6.5 The Cure Reference Method ...........
4.2
Material Property Testing ...................... 102 4.2.1 Tension Testing ............................ 103 4.2.2 Compression Testing ..................... 103
4.7
References .................................................. 121
The advancement of civilization has historically been tied to the materials utilized during the era. For example, we document the technological progression of mankind through the stone age, the bronze age, the iron age, etc. [4.1]. If such a description were to be used for the second half of the 20-th century, it is conceivable that the era could be called the composites age. AdR vanced composites such as carbon fiber and Kevlar reinforced polymers, and ceramic matrix materials represent the pinnacle of structural material forms during this era. These are the material systems of choice when high specific strength and stiffness are required [4.2–4].
A composite is defined as a material composed of two or more constituents whose mechanical properties are distinctly different from each other, and phase separated such that at least one of the constituents forms a continuous interconnected region and one of the constituents acts as the reinforcement (and is typically discontinuous) [4.2–4]. The resulting composite has physical properties that differ from the original constituents. By nature, experimental stress analysis on composites can be considerably difficult, since composites can be highly anisotropic and heterogeneous. Many of the well-established experimental techniques
Future Challenges ................................. 121
Part A 4
The application of selected experimental stress analysis techniques for mechanical testing of composite materials is reviewed. Because of the anisotropic and heterogeneous nature of composites, novel methodologies are often adopted. This chapter reviews many of the more applicable experimental methods in specific research areas, including: composite-specific strain gage applications, material property characterization, micromechanics, interlaminar testing, textile composite testing, and residual stress measurements. It would be impossible to review all test methods associated with composites in this short chapter, but many prevalent ones are covered.
98
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 4.1
require special procedures, different data analysis, or may not be applicable. Additionally, for anisotropic materials the principal strain direction does not necessarily coincide with the principal stress direction. Failure mechanisms in composites can be also be significantly more complicated than for traditional isotropic materials. There are three main forms of composites: particulate reinforced, lamellar, and fiber reinforced. Some composite materials combine two or more of these forms; for example, a sandwich structure is a lamellar form that can incorporate fiber reinforced face sheets. In this chapter we will focus on advanced fiber and particulate reinforced composites. The objective of this chapter is to help guide the experimentalist by introducing modern experimental stress analysis techniques that are applicable to composites. The chapter is organized by research topics within the composites field. These include: special consideration when testing with electrical resistance strain gages,
coupon and material property testing, micromechanics studies, interlaminar fracture, textile composites, residual stress, and thermal testing. Other chapters of this manual cover time-dependent testing, high-strain-rate experiments, thermoelastic stress analysis, and fiberoptic strain gages, all of which are also important to the study of composites. In 1989 the Composite Materials Technical Division (CMTD) of the Society for Experimental Mechanics, sponsored publication of the Manual on Experimental Methods for Mechanical Testing of Composites [4.5]. The publication was edited by Pendelton and Tuttle. In 1998, Jenkins and the CMTD revised and updated the manual [4.6]. The most recent version is a 264-page book that covers broad aspects of composite testing and analysis. This chapter is significantly more condensed, and highlights applications as well as updates the most recent manual. Often during the course of the chapter, the author will refer the reader to this manual for more details.
4.1 Strain Gage Applications To this day, strain gages are still the most used experimental method to measure mechanical strain on isotropic as well as composite material applications. The previous chapters on strain gages clearly outline the theory and application of strain gages for general testing. For composite applications there are a number of special considerations [4.6] and procedures that should be followed in order to insure accurate and repeatable measurements. This section expands on the use of strain gages for composite material applications by providing a description of these special considerations and showing examples of how severe errors may occur if precautions are not implemented.
4.1.1 Transverse Sensitivity Corrections To obtain accurate strain measurements, transverse sensitivity corrections must be performed in all but two cases [4.7, 8]. The first case is when the transverse sensitivity coefficient K t is equal to zero. This is very rare: typically the transverse sensitivity coefficient is nonzero. The second is when the axial strain is measured on a material with a Poisson’s ratio equal to that of the strain gage calibration device and the state of stress is identical to the calibration device. For the latter case, in practice, this means that the tensile strain is measured for a uniaxial state of stress on a material with a Pois-
son’s ratio ν0 equal to 0.285 (steel). In general, errors due to transverse sensitivity are greatest when the transverse strain with respect to the gage εt is large compared to the axial strain with respect to the gage εa and the transverse sensitivity coefficient is high. Equation (4.1) describes the percentage error E if no corrections are performed due to transverse sensitivity. E=
K t [(εt /εa ) + ν0 ] × 100 . 1 − ν0 K t
(4.1)
For a simple experiment to determine the Poisson’s ratio of metallic material using strain gages, shown in Fig. 4.1, one would apply two strain gages to a tensile specimen, one aligned in the axial direction with respect to the load and one mounted in the transverse direction with respect to the load. If the specimen were aluminum (with a Poisson’s ratio of 0.33) and the transverse sensitivity correction factor of the gage was 2%, then the error in the axial gage would be very small (E = −0.09%) and the error in the transverse gage would be larger (E = −5.46%). If one were to completely ignore these corrections then one would calculate the Poisson’s ratio to be 0.312, rather than 0.33. Although most strain gages have a transverse sensitivity correction factor less than 2%, one can appreciate that corrections should be made.
Composite Materials
σx
4.1 Strain Gage Applications
99
to correct for transverse errors in the other gage. When orthogonal gages are used, as shown in Fig. 4.2, biaxial strain gage rosette corrections may be applied. The correction equations are given in (4.2), which gives the true strains ε1 and ε2 , obtained from the indicated strains ε1 and ε2 , and the transverse sensitivity correction factors K t1 and K t2 for gages 1 and 2.
σx
ε1 (1 − ν0 K t1 ) − K t1 ε2 (1 − ν0 K t2 ) , 1 − K t1 K t2 ε (1 − ν0 K t2 ) − K t2 ε1 (1 − ν0 K t1 ) ε2 = 2 . (4.2) 1 − K t1 K t2 Note that for each gage in the rosette, there may be a different transverse sensitivity coefficient. Similarly, the equations for a rectangular rosette (as shown in Fig. 4.2) are provided in (4.3). Often K t1 and K t3 are equal to each other. ε1 =
Fiber direction
Isotropic material
Unidirectional composite
Even for a seemingly routine test, if the specimen were unidirectional graphite/epoxy, large errors can arise if corrections are not made. For instance, if the objective is to measure ν21 , consider a specimen loaded in the direction transverse to the fibers (Fig. 4.1). For graphite/epoxy a typical ν21 is around 0.015 and therefore the strain gage used to measure the normal strain transverse to the loading direction experiences εt on the order of 66 times that of εa . For K t = 2% the strain gage measuring the strain transverse to the loading direction would yield a value with −132% error if transverse sensitivity corrections are not applied. Therefore the Poisson ratio ν21 would have an error of the order 132% since the error in the axial gage is very small. In order to perform an accurate correction for transverse sensitivity, at least two gages are required. For instance, in the above example, one gage may be used y
y
2
3
2 45°
x 1 Two gage biaxial rosette
1
x
Three gage rectangular rosette
Fig. 4.2 Biaxial and rectangular rosettes
ε1 (1 − ν0 K t1 ) − K t1 ε3 (1 − ν0 K t3 ) , 1 − K t1 K t3 ε (1 − ν0 K t2 ) ε2 = 2 1− K t2 − K t2 ε1 (1 − ν0 K t1 )(1 − K t3 ) + ε3 (1 − ν0 K t3 )(1 − K t1 ) −1 × (1 − K t1 K t3 )(1 − K t2 ) , ε3 (1 − ν0 K t3 ) − K t3 ε1 (1 − ν0 K t1 ) ε3 = . 1 − K t1 K t3
ε1 =
Part A 4.1
Fig. 4.1 Measurement of the Poisson ratio ν for an isotropic material and ν21 for a unidirectional composite material
(4.3)
4.1.2 Error Due to Gage Misalignment Whenever a practitioner mounts strain gages on a mechanical component or test coupon, gage alignment is an important consideration [4.9]. If the gage is not aligned precisely with respect to the loading direction or geometry of the component, the strain information that is recorded may differ from the value obtained if it were aligned properly. This can lead to errors and/or misinterpretation of the data. For isotropic materials, errors of the order of a couple degrees typically do not lead to significant errors in strain measurement. For instance, for a simple tension test on a steel bar, where both axial and transverse (with respect to the load) gages are utilized, there would be an error in the axial strain of − 0.63% and in the transverse strain of 2.2%, for a misalignment of 4◦ . This may or may not be within the acceptable error for such a measurement. Most able practitioners can routinely align gages to within 2◦ . The errors for such a 2◦ misalignment are − 0.16% and 0.55% for the axial and transverse gages, respectively.
100
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
θ
Percent strain measurement error 80
σx
β = –4°
β
60 β = –2°
40 20 0 β
–20 β = 2°
–40 –60 –80
β = 4°
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70 80 90 Fiber angle (deg)
Fig. 4.5 Transverse strain errors as a function of fiber an-
σx
gle and gage misalignment error (courtesy M. E. Tuttle)
Part A 4.1
Fig. 4.3 Gage misalignment nomenclature
For unidirectional composites, misalignment can introduce significant errors because of the deleterious interaction between the loading direction and the orthotropy of the material. Take the same unidirectional graphite/epoxy material from the previous section where the moduli are E 1 = 170 GPa, E 2 = 8 GPa, G 12 = 6 GPa, and the Poisson’s ratio is ν12 = 0.32. A case where the gage is intended to line up with the load will be used for an example. For a tension test, where the fiber direction with respect to the loading Percent strain measurement error 20
direction is denoted by θ, and the gage misalignment denoted by β, Figs. 4.3, 4.4, and 4.5 illustrate the relationship between the misalignment angle β and the percentage strain measurement error and the fiber angle θ. Figure 4.4 pertains to errors in the axial direction of the specimen and Fig. 4.5 pertains to the transverse direction. Errors exceeding 15% can occur at fiber angles near 12◦ for the axial gage and greater than 60% near a 12◦ fiber angle for the transverse gage. Because of the exaggerated error when testing composites, special procedures may be warranted in the experimental program to ensure proper gage alignment.
4.1.3 Temperature Compensation
β = –4°
15 β = –2°
10 5 0 –5
β = 2°
–10 –15 –20
β = 4°
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70 80 90 Fiber angle (deg)
Fig. 4.4 Axial strain errors as a function of fiber angle and
gage misalignment angle (courtesy M. E. Tuttle)
When a strain gage is mounted on a mechanical component or test coupon which is subjected to both mechanical loads and temperature variations, the gage measurements are a combination of strains induced by both effects [4.10, 11]. It is often the objective to separate the effects of the mechanical loads, a process known as temperature compensation. The strain gage output which results from temperature variation can occur for two reasons: the electrical resistance of the gage changes with temperature, and the coefficient of expansion of the gage may be different from that of the underlying material. Temperature compensation is more difficult when dealing with composites than with homogeneous isotropic materials. Some of the options for metallic materials are not applicable to composites. For instance,
Composite Materials
4.1.4 Self-Heating Effects According to Joule’s law, the application of voltage to a strain gage (a resistor) creates a power loss which results in the generation of heat [4.7, 12]. This heat is dissipated in the form of conduction by the substrate material and the surrounding environment. The heat that is generated is primarily related to the excitation voltage of the strain gage circuit, as well as to the resistance of the strain gage. The ability of the substrate material to stabilize or neutralize self-heating is related to its power density, which is a measure of
its ability to act as a heat sink. When self-heating is not neutralized it can result in gradual heating of the substrate, which can lead to creep of the underlying material, as well as signal hysteresis and drift. This is typically not acceptable and therefore steps must be implemented in order to avoid self-heating. In general, one can choose a combination of gage resistance, excitation voltage, and gage size to avoid the problem. Larger gage resistance levels develop less self-heating, larger grid areas allow more efficient dissipation, and lower excitation levels decrease self-heating. However, by decreasing the excitation level, the circuit sensitivity also decreases. Additionally, higher-resistance and larger gages can be more expensive. A balance must be struck in order to optimize the experimental configuration [4.12]. Most composite materials are fabricated with polymer matrices. Since polymers have low power densities (and are thus poor heat sinks), it is very important to select gages with a higher resistance and larger grid area, and/or use lower excitation levels as compared to strain gages used for traditional materials. A range of acceptable power densities for composites is 0.31–1.2 kW/m2 (0.2–0.77 W/in.2 ). As such, a rule-of-thumb recommendation was developed by Slaminko [4.11] for strain gage applications on composites: Size: 3 mm(0.125 in.) or larger; Resistance: 350 Ω or higher; Excitation voltage: 3 V or less. Smaller gages can be used, if necessary (to measure in locations with high strain gradients, for instance), by reducing the excitation levels.
4.1.5 Additional Considerations The process of performing a successful experiment with strain gages starts with the selection of the gage. Vishay [4.13] suggests the following order should be followed when selecting a gage: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
gage length gage pattern gage series options resistance self-temperature compensation
Note that the gage size is the first, and arguably the most important, consideration. This is especially
101
Part A 4.1
the self-temperature compensation (S-T-C) numbers provided by the gage manufacturer do not match most composites and therefore the temperature compensation data (polynomial and graphical corrections) cannot be applied. As a result other methods of compensation are required. The so-called dummy compensation method is a robust method for performing compensation on composites. Dummy compensation requires a second gage to be mounted in a half-bridge configuration with the active gage. Three requirements must be fulfilled in order to perform dummy compensation. First, the dummy gage must be from the same gage lot as the gage that measures the combined thermal and mechanical components. Second, the dummy gage must be mounted on an unconstrained piece of the same material, of approximately the same volume and aligned in the same orientation with respect to the orthotropy as the mechanically loaded specimen. Finally, the two specimens (one loaded and the other unconstrained) must be in the same thermal environment and in close proximity. Violation of any of these requirements can result in large errors. The two gages are then connected in a half-bridge configuration where the thermal output from each gage cancel. One can also perform a precalibration test to separate the thermal strain from the mechanical strain. This is performed by mounting a gage on the specimen to be mechanically tested through a range of temperatures. Then, the specimen is subjected to the thermal cycle only and the apparent strain is recorded as a function of temperature. Once this is established, the specimen can be mechanically tested over the same temperature range. The strains due to thermal effects are subtracted from the results of the test with both thermal and mechanical contributions. An accurate temperature measurement is required for this technique as well as postprocessing of the data.
4.1 Strain Gage Applications
102
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 4.2
true for composites, since the scale associated with homogeneity is often significantly larger than that for traditional materials. For textile composite forms, which will be discussed later, the optimal strain gage size depends on the textile architecture. In general, smaller gages will produce more experimental scatter than larger gages and therefore should be avoided, unless strains are to be measured in areas of high gradients. Additionally, in some instances the average value for a highly nonuniform strain distribution is desired and thus larger gages, or those that span the entire test section, are more appropriate [4.14]. The selection of the gage pattern is largely dependent on the objectives of the experiment, for instance, whether one two or three axes are of interest, or whether normal or shear strains are required. If multidirectional gages are used there is often a choice of planar or stacked configurations. For experiments where high stress gradients are present and the material is more heterogeneous, stacked configurations are desired. Stacked configurations, however, can be more expensive, and create more reinforcement effects and self-heating problems. The gage series relates to the materials (foil and backing) that are used in the strain gage. The available choices relate to the temperature range, fatigue characteristics, and stability. The most common sensing grid alloys used for composites are constantan and Karma. Both have good sensitivity, stability, and fatigue resistance. Karma is more stable at temperatures over 65 ◦ C (150 ◦ F), but is more difficult to solder to than constantan. Polyimide backing materials are well suited for composites and allow for contourability and maximum
elongation, while fiber glass reinforced phenolics offer better temperature stability. As in noncomposite applications there may be instances where options such as preattached leads are required. As far as the resistance of the gage is concerned, Slaminko recommends that 350 Ω or greater should be used. Finally, since S-T-C is generally not an option for composites, there is no need to consider this number and any S-T-C value is appropriate. There are other considerations that the experimentalist should be aware of when using strain gages on composites. For example, the ideal measurement technique should be nonintrusive. For strain gage applications this means that, by applying the gage to the underlying material, the strain data recorded represents that for the case where there is no gage present. Since the gage and the adhesive used to attach the gage have finite stiffness, there is always a reinforcing effect. For measurement of material systems where the modulus is much higher than the gage material this effect is typically considered insignificant and can be ignored. When taking measurements on relatively compliant materials, however, gage reinforcement can lead to errors. In the case of composites, the stiffness of the material is highly orthotropic in nature, ranging from modulus values similar to that of common strain gages to values that are significantly higher. Additionally, when considering the entire installation, adhesive selection may be an important consideration when taking measurements along compliant axes (such as transverse loading). A detailed description of reinforcement effects is presented by Perry in the manual [4.15, 16] for both isotropic and anisotropic materials.
4.2 Material Property Testing With the rapid development of composite material systems throughout the last three decades, there has been a need to characterize them accurately. The primary loading conditions of tension, compression, and shear applied to more than one loading direction introduced many new mechanical test methods. Because of this rapid progress, standardization has not been entirely achieved for all loading conditions. The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), under the D30 subcommittee, is the primary organization for composite test standards. The organization consists of a voluntary membership and conducts round-robin testing and standards writing. Recent activ-
ity by the US Military Standards (Mil Specs) under the MIL-Handbook-17 (Polymer Matrix Composites) has expanded standards to include fabrication. Five volumes of the handbook, released in 2002, include: Guidelines for Characterization of Structural Materials, Polymer Matrix Composites: Material Properties, Materials Usage, Design, and Analysis, Metal Matrix Composites, and “Ceramic Matrix Composites”. Planning is under way for the release of a volume on Structural Sandwich Composites. Internationally, the British Standards Institute (BSI) in the United Kingdom, the Association Française de National (AFNOR) in France, the Deutsches Institut für Normung (DIN) in Germany,
Composite Materials
4.2.1 Tension Testing Tension testing under ASTM D 3039 [4.19] has become a well-accepted standard for testing of high-modulus and high-strength composites. The standard defines a tabbed, straight, flat specimen of high aspect ratio (Fig. 4.6). The tabs, with a beveled entry into the test section, are added to the specimen to allow for substanASTM D 3039
ASTM D 608
Fig. 4.6 ASTM standard tension test specimen geometries
tial clamping forces at the grip. These tabs are typically made from G-10 glass/epoxy and are adhered using a high-strength epoxy. Untabbed, dog-boned specimens (Fig. 4.6), under ASTM D 608 [4.20] may be use for some composites that have lower tensile strength values (for instance transverse tension testing). However, for composite systems with higher tensile strength, often the enlarged portion shears off parallel to the long dimension, thus reducing the specimen to a flat, straight specimen similar to that used in ASTM D 3039, without tabs. In general, ASTM D 3039 is appropriate for almost any composite form. Both mechanical and hydraulic grips may be used for ASTM D 3039. The clamping pressure on wedgetype mechanical grips is generally proportional to the applied loads. This reduces the potential for crushing the specimen in the tabbed area. Hydraulic grips add more versatility, since the clamping force is independent of the load, although care must be taken to avoid specimen crushing.
4.2.2 Compression Testing Compression testing of composites has received a considerable amount of attention and has proven to be more complicated than tension testing [4.17]. Since the compressive strength (in the fiber direction) is generally lower than the tensile strength, and since there is a desire to use a larger fraction of the ultimate load capacity, there is a need to characterize the compressive strength accurately. Because relatively thin specimens are desired, buckling may occur if the unsupported length is too large. Therefore, in general, most compression tests are designed such that the specimen fails due to true compressive failure of the material and not due to Euler buckling. There are three methods [4.21–23] of introducing compressive loading into the specimen: via shear through end tabs (ASTM D 3410), by direct end loading (ASTM D 695), and by bending of a composite sandwich panel (ASTM D 5476). The latter is rarely used since the specimens are typically large, difficult to manufacture, and expensive. Additionally, there is a concern that prevails among the composites community that the compressive failure strength may be artificially elevated by the presence of the core being bonded along the entire face sheet. Introducing the compressive load via shear through end tabs is similar to the way loads are introduced in tensile tests, except that the loads are of opposite sign and therefore the wedges in the grips are inverted. In ASTM D 3410 two test fixtures are described: the
103
Part A 4.2
Japanese Industrial Standards (JIS) and Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI) distributed by the Japanese Standards Association, are the primary standardization organizations. Whether testing composite materials in tension, compression or shear, there are three basic objectives that should be realized. First, since material systems are often expensive (especially when they are initially developed), thin laminates and small specimens are generally desired. Second, the test method should be capable of measuring the elastic properties as well as the failure strength. As such, the state of stress in the test section of the specimen must be pure (without other stresses) and uniform. Third, the test should be devised such that common universal testing machines can be utilized. Often, these considerations rule out the use of complicated geometries and testing in specialized testing machines. The Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites [4.17, 18] has a comprehensive chapter written by Adams on test methods. This section will only briefly describe the most used test methods and summarize the appropriate procedures.
4.2 Material Property Testing
104
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Fig. 4.7 The Celanese compression fixture (Wyoming Test
Fixtures Inc.)
Part A 4.2
Celanese compression fixture [4.24] and the IITRI compression fixture [4.25]; they are shown in Figs. 4.7 and 4.8. Both of these test fixtures have a specified gage length (unsupported length) of 12.8 mm (0.5 in.). Testing of thin specimens may lead to buckling if the slenderness ratio is too high. The original standard was written for the Celanese fixture in 1975. The fixture incorporates cylindrical wedges and has an alignment sleeve. It has been criticized for being potentially unstable if precautions, outlined in the standard, are not followed. These instabilities arise because the wedge grips travel in a conical track and some degrees of freedom are not well constrained. Additionally, the fixture is limited to specimens with a maximum width of 6.4 mm (0.25 in.). For testing of textile composites and materials with heterogeneity on a larger scale, the limited width can be a problem. The IITRI fixture was developed to eliminate the problem of instability by utilizing a flat wedge grip, thus minimizing degrees of freedom. The fixture also allows for testing of wider and thicker specimens. As a result, the fixture is significantly larger than the Celanese fix-
Fig. 4.8 The IITRI compression fixture (Wyoming Test Fixtures Inc.)
ture and weighs in at almost 46 kg (100 lb). This effects ease of handling and increases the cost (typically there is a proportional relationship between the weight and cost of the fixture). By combining the favorable features of the Celanese and IITRI fixtures, Adams et al. developed the Wyoming-modified Celanese compression fixture [4.26], shown in Fig. 4.9. The fixture can accommodate a specimen of 12.8 mm (0.5 in.) wide and 7.6 mm (0.3 in.) thick, twice the values of the original Celanese fixture. Another modification of the Celanese fixture is the German DIN 65 380 compression fixture [4.27]. It uses flat wedge grips and an alignment sleeve. The second common method used to introduce load into the compression specimen is through the ends of the specimen (ASTM D 695) [4.22]. This method can be used with or without end tabs. End tabs increase the bearing surface and thus prevent bearing failure prior to compression failure inside the test section. The clamped portion of the fixture confines the specimen and also suppresses bearing failure, which usually occurs in the form of brooming. Some fixtures can accommodate dog-bone geometries without tabs, again to increase the bearing surface area. Generally speaking, for specimens with compression failure strengths less than 700 MPa (100 ksi) dog-boning may be adequate. For those above that value tabs are usually required because the bog-boned portion shears, and subsequent bearing failure occurs at the ends. Examples of end-loaded fixtures include the Wyoming end-loaded side-supported fixture [4.28], the modified ASTM D 695 compression test fixture, and the NASA short block compression test fixture. Specimens may
Fig. 4.9 The Wyoming modified compression fixture
(Wyoming Test Fixtures Inc.)
Composite Materials
also be loaded through both end loading and shear. An example of such a fixture is the Wyoming combinedloading compression fixture (ASTM D 6641) [4.29,30]. The fixture incorporates the advantages of both load introduction schemes.
4.2.3 Shear Testing
and colleagues at the University of Wyoming along with the development of dedicated loading fixtures. The Iosipescu specimen, illustrated in Fig. 4.10, is a relatively small, rectangular beam with V-shaped notches to concentrate the shear in the test section (the volume between the notches). The notches serve two purposes. They reduce the cross-sectional area in the test section (thus allowing for failure to be confined) and they produce a more uniform state of shear. The latter is highly dependent on the notch angle and the orthotropy of the material being tested. In general, this test violates one of the prerequisites for material strength measurements, since the state of stress in the test section is neither truly pure nor is it perfectly uniform. There exists a free edge in the test section, where the shear stresses are zero (in this case at the notch roots). The shear stresses then rise from the free edge and form a distribution that varies with fiber orientation and notch angle. This large gradient must be accommodated by normal stress gradients, according to equilibrium, and thus the state of shear is neither pure nor uniform. Although, strictly speaking, flat coupons cannot produce the perfect shear field, the Iosipescu geometry provides a practical approach, since the shear stress and strain distribution is near uniform. Shear strain information is recorded with strain gages located in the test section. Two styles have been proposed, a centrally located small ±45◦ rosette and a ±45◦ rosette that spans the entire test section [4.14]. Displacements (μm) –70
0 y x
19 Experimental ux contours –202
–15 Experimental uy contours
Fig. 4.10 The modified Wyoming Iosipescu shear test fix-
ture (Wyoming Test Fixtures Inc.)
Fig. 4.11 Loading condition and displacement fields for a proposed T-shaped specimen (courtesy M. Grediac)
105
Part A 4.2
Shear testing has also received considerable attention in recent years. Unlike tension and compression testing, it is difficult to create a pure and uniform shear field using a specimen made from a flat coupon. Ideally, thin-walled torsion testing provides the most uniform and pure shear state of shear. However, cylindrical composite specimens are inordinately expensive to produce, torsion test stands are relatively rare, and the obtained shear properties extended to flat laminates are questionable. Therefore, numerous specimens have been proposed for shear testing of flat coupons [4.17]. These include the two- and three-rail shear tests, the off-axis tension test, the ±45 tension test, short beam shear, notched compression, picture frame, and notch tests such as the Arcan and Iosipescu specimens. The latter [4.31–33] (ASTM D 5379) has become the most widely used test method for composites. First developed by Nicolai Iosipescu in the early 1960s for isotropic materials, it was extended for use on composites by Adams
4.2 Material Property Testing
106
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Load cell
0°
[(0/90)3]s r = 2
αA
Surface covered with a grating
Fixed
Moveable
265 εxyexp (i, j)
εxyana (i, j)
εxyexp (i, j) – εxyana (i, j)
Part A 4.2 Fig. 4.12 Open-hole specimen and loading configuration with experimental shear strain distribution, analytic shear strain distribution, and differences after the application of difference minimization using the Levenberg–Marquardt algorithm (courtesy J. Molimard)
The latter was developed to correct for the nonuniform shear stress distributions and reduces the experimental scatter when employed on textile composites or materials with significant heterogeneity. It is suggested that gages be placed on both sides of the specimen to cancel the affects of twist [4.34]. By using two Iosipescu strain gages (one on each side of the specimen) the coefficient of variation in modulus can be reduce to less than 2%. A number of fixtures have been proposed for loading the Iosipescu specimen, the most popular being the modified Wyoming shear test fixture (ASTM D 5379) [4.31], which is mounted in a universal testing machine, loads the specimen through wedge clamps, and incorporates a linear bearing for alignment. Loads are imparted to the specimen on the upper and lower edges. For some material systems, tabs may be required if local crushing of the edges is evidenced.
4.2.4 Single-Geometry Tests In order to determine the multiple elastic constants for orthotropic materials, a number of tests must be per-
formed. This can add considerable time and expense. Several researchers have proposed the use of unique geometries and loading conditions in combination with full-field optical methods to determine multiple elastic constants. These tests are generally for elastic constants and are typically not well suited for strength measurements since failure may be from combined effects. Two recent studies in experimental mechanics will be used as examples of such methods [4.35]. The first, proposed in 1999 by Grediac et al., utilizes a unique T-shaped specimen loaded as shown in Fig. 4.11. The investigators used a phased stepped grid method to determine the displacement fields, as shown in the figure, and then determined the strain fields by differentiation. The principal of virtual work, relying on global equilibrium, was employed. Four virtual fields were chosen to satisfy four elastic constants. In practice the four virtual fields act like filters that enable the extraction of the unknown rigidities (constants). From this, the stiffness components can be identified. The axial elastic constants were determined to within 15% of those values obtained using traditional means. It was determined
Composite Materials
that the shear elastic constant could not be determined with reasonable accuracy, since, as the authors point out, the specimen deformation is generally not governed by shear. An open-hole tension specimen was employed by Molimard et al. [4.36] to measure four orthotropic plate constants from a single geometry. They used phase-shifted moiré interferometry to measure full-field surface displacement and strain. Figure 4.12 shows the geometry and loading fixtures used in their tests. Displacement and strain contours were measured in the area around the open hole. The principal employed was
4.3 Micromechanics
107
to minimize the discrepancy between experimental and theoretical strain results using a Levenberg–Marquardt algorithm. Comparisons between the experimental and analytical shearing strain values are presented in Fig. 4.12. The method takes into consideration the optical system, signal processing, and the mechanical aspects. Cost functions were investigated leading to a simple mathematical form. Two models were used: an analytical model based on the Lekhnitskii approach and the finite element method. The researchers were able to identify the four elastic constants to within 6% of those measured using traditional means.
4.3 Micromechanics
a)
b)
be broken down into critical experiments. For instance, the interface can be probed by dedicated tests such as the single-fiber pull-out test. Other critical experiments have been performed on testing of the constituents individually in bulk form. These include polymer studies, fiber strength tests, and nanofiber characterization. Also, by including microencapsulated adhesives with dimensions on the fiber scale, self-healing composites have been developed. In this section full-field fiberscale testing, interface testing, nanocomposites, and self-healing composites will be addressed.
4.3.1 In Situ Strain Measurements As mentioned above, the length scale associated with micromechanics challenges the experimentalist. There have been numerous studies to create scaled-up model materials (to match the capabilities of various experimental techniques such as moiré methods, photoelasticity, etc.) of an ideal geometry (square and hexagonal array) for validation of analytical and numerical modc)
Fig. 4.13 (a) E-beam moiré grating, (b) fringe pattern prior to interlaminar fracture, (c) fringe pattern after fracture (courtesy J. W. Dally)
Part A 4.3
Experimental micromechanical characterization is extremely challenging because of the length scales involved. For example, the diameter of a carbon fiber is of the order 8 μm, boron fibers are of the order 200 μm, and carbon nanotubes are measured in nanometers. As such, there have only been a few notable examples of full-field experimental documentation of the strain field on the fiber scale. Any experimental technique that is suitable for such a task must have extreme spatial resolution, high sensitivity, and be used in conjunction with high magnification capabilities. Traditional experimental techniques, such as moiré interferometry, cannot be used without enhancement. Additionally, most of the interesting micromechanical phenomena occur in the interior of the ply and not on the surface, therefore lack of visual access (whether through traditional optical microscopy or scanning electron microscopy) prohibits the investigation of such problems. As a result, modeling efforts are far ahead of the experimental efforts and precious little experimental evidence supports these models. Nevertheless, aspects of micromechanics can
108
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Fiber pull-out
Fiber push-in
Fiber push-out
Fig. 4.14 Schematic illustrations of the single-fiber pull-out, pushin, and push-out tests
els. This methodology can be useful in understanding the interaction between the fiber and matrix, but often the essence of the micromechanical phenomenon is lost. Here, only implementation of full-field techniques on real composites will be presented.
Part A 4.3
Striker bar
Incident bar
Transmitter bar
Strain gage
Strain gage
3.2 mm Incident bar
Transmitter bar
Punch Specimen
4.3.2 Fiber–Matrix Interface Characterization
Support
Force (N) 0
–1000
5m/s
–2000
7 m/s
–3000 15 m/s
–4000
0
The first example is a novel method developed by Dally and Read called electron beam moiré [4.37– 40]. The method involves writing very high-frequency (10 000 lines/mm) gratings on sectioned composites using e-beam polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) resists and performing a moiré test in the scanning electron microscope (SEM) using the scanning lines as the reference grating. While details of the technique are given in the reference, the example presented on glass fiber reinforced epoxy will be illustrated here. The interface between the 0◦ and 90◦ plies on the edge surface of a [02 /902 ]2s laminate was interrogated for a specimen loaded in tension using a small testing machine located within the SEM specimen chamber. The crossed-line grating on the surface of a small region of the specimen is shown in Fig. 4.13, along with moiré fringe patterns at two load levels, one prior to and one after a delamination crack. Xing et al. [4.41] also extended the used of e-beam moiré, by measuring the interfacial residual stresses in SiC/Ti-15-3 silicon fiber reinforced ceramic composites. Additional in situ high-spatial-resolution studies using novel experimental techniques include the use of micro-Raman spectroscopy [4.42–44] for the study of fiber breakage in compression specimens and the interaction between neighboring fibers.
10
20
30
40
50
60 70 Time (μs)
Fig. 4.15 Effect of sliding speed on the push-out force for a rough
aluminum fiber (12 mm long) in an epoxy matrix (courtesy J. Lambrose)
Fiber–matrix interface properties can dominate the mechanical behavior of a composite. The properties of the interface can influence delamination, microcracking, kink band formation, residual stresses, and numerous other failure modes. Therefore, the characterization of the interfacial strength is of importance when developing micromechanical models to predict the strength of composites. The interface, defined as the boundary between the fiber and matrix, actually has a finite volume. This is because the fiber typically has a sizing to control adhesion of the matrix and the matrix morphology varies near the fiber. Hence, the term interphase has been adopted to describe this finite volume. The interphase volume is on a length scale even smaller than the fiber scale, and therefore introduces serious challenges to the experimentalist. However, the importance of this volume has spurred numerous researcher efforts. A number of tests that have been proposed to measure the adhesive strength of the fiber–matrix interphase. These tests include the single-fiber pull-out, push-in, and push-out tests shown schematically in Fig. 4.14.
Composite Materials
4.3 Micromechanics
1 μm
Stress σ (×106 Pa) 30 25 20 15 10 Dow DER732+DER331 Nanocomposite 5wt%
5 0
0
1
2
3
4 Strain ε (%)
Fig. 4.16 TEM micrograph of clay platelet reinforced polymer and the tensile stress–strain response of unreinforced and 5% clay reinforced polymer (courtesy I. M. Daniel)
They are common in that a traction is placed on a single fiber to initiate and propagate bond failure between the fiber and matrix either as an adhesive or cohesive failure. An example of such a test is presented in this section. In 2002 Zhouhua et al. [4.45] conducted experiments to determine the dynamic fiber debonding and frictional push-out in a model composite system. The investigators utilized a modified split Hopkinson pressure bar with a tapered punch to apply a compressive load on a single fiber (modeled using aluminum and steel) embedded in an epoxy matrix. In the push-out experiment, the fiber model is pushed from the surface
4.3.3 Nanoscale Testing The quest to achieve improved mechanical properties has led to the development of composites that incorporate nanoparticle, nanofiber, or nanotube reinforcement. These nanocomposites are a class of composite material where one of the constituents has dimensions in the range of 1–100 nm. Over the past decade, the development of nanoreinforcements, processing them into composites, and assessing their mechanics has rapidly evolved. In this section we will briefly describe two studies: the incorporation of nanoclay particles in polymers and a study of the mechanical characterization of multiwalled carbon nanotubes. Some polymer–inorganic nanocomposites have demonstrated pronounced improvements in stiffness, strength, and thermal properties over unreinforced polymers without sacrificing density, toughness, and processibility. The advantages of nanocomposites over traditional composites come from the high surface-areato-volume ratio of the reinforcement, and thus have a direct effect on the interfacial mechanics. Measuring the stress and strain distribution on the nanoscale
Part A 4.3
and punches through a hole in a support. The test allows real-time measurement of the relative fiber–matrix displacement and push-out force. Figure 4.15 shows a schematic of the setup and an example force–time plot to demonstrate the effect of sliding speed (directly related to the loading rate). The technique documented the effects of loading rate, material mismatch, fiber length, and surface roughness on the push-out event. It was observed that surface roughness played an important role in the dynamic interfacial strength, and that the maximum push-out force increased with loading rate. The plot in the figure shows a markedly different behavior between slow and fast sliding speeds, with a transition occurring around 10 m/s. At slow speeds the transmitted force reaches a maximum in two steps, indicating that the load levels required for initiating and propagating the debonding crack differ. A finite element model was constructed to extract the interface strength and toughness values. On the scale of real composites (versus model materials) the single-fiber push-in test is more applicable since the only specimen preparation required is cross-cutting and polishing the specimen. Micro- and nanoindenters have been utilized for applying loads over the small area of the fiber cross-section. These devices have load and position readout and are well suited for static loading cases.
109
110
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a)
increased the tensile modulus and strength by as much 50%, as can be seen in the figure. When adding additional reinforcement, the modulus increased, but the strength significantly degraded. These findings were thought to be attributed to increased voids, inclusions, and agglomeration of the nanoparticles during processing. Recent research by Zhu and Espinosa [4.47] has lead to the development of very small tensile testing machines that are capable of testing single multiwalled carbon nanotubes. The system utilizes a micro-
b)
5 μm
c)
d)
Microcapsule Catalyst Crack
Part A 4.3
Fig. 4.17 The procedure to attach a nanowire to the cross-heads of the MEMS-based testing machine involves welding the wire using electron-beam-induced deposition (courtesy Y. Zhu)
is a current challenge to the experimentalist. Many of the experimental mechanics contributions to this field pertain to using traditional test methods applied to the macroscopic behavior of nanocomposites. Examples include using tensile tests, fracture tests, and shear tests to validate the inclusion of nanoparticles in matrix materials. Daniels et al. [4.46] characterized clay nanoparticle platelet reinforced epoxy via tension tests to determine how process parameters (such as the weight percentage of the reinforcement) affect the stress–strain response. Figure 4.16 shows a tunneling electron microscope micrograph of the exfoliated Cloisite 30B clay reinforced Dow DER331/DER732 epoxy system. It was found that moderate nanoclay concentrations on the order of 5% a)
Healing agent
Polymerized healing agent
20 μm
b)
500 nm
500 nm
Fig. 4.18 Tension tests of a multiwalled carbon nanotube with detailed insets to shown the wall thickness and morphology (courtesy Y. Zhu)
Fig. 4.19 Self-healing concept for thermosetting matrix with SEM image of broken microcapsule (courtesy E. N. Brown)
Composite Materials
4.3.4 Self-Healing Composites Researchers at the University of Illinois have developed a self-healing polymer that they have incorporated into the fabrication of fiber reinforced composite materials [4.48, 49]. The concept is to heal a crack in polymers using a microencapsulated healing agent that
is released upon the intrusion of a crack. The healing agent is then hardened by an embedded catalyst. The dicyclopentadiene (DCPD) healing agent, stabilized by 100–200 ppm p-tert-butylcatechol encapsulated by a poly-ureaformaldehyde shell, catalyzes when exposed to bis(tricyclohexylphosphine)benzylidine ruthenium (IV) dichloride (otherwise called Grubbs’ catalyst), which is imbedded in the composite matrix. Mean capsule diameters are of the order 166 μm. Figure 4.19 shows a schematic of the fracture/healing process, where a crack penetrates through the bulk polymer and the shells of the microcapsules. The healing agent then wicks into the crack and comes into contact with the embedded catalyst, leading to polymerization of the healing agent and subsequent bridging of the crack. The researchers also conducted extensive fracture studies on unreinforced (no fibers) EPON 282 epoxy tapered double-cantilever beam specimens, and found that, once healed, the polymer containing the healing agent exhibited 90% of its virgin fracture toughness [4.50,51]. Studies were then performed by combining the self-healing matrix material with a plain-weave graphite fiber fabric. Fracture tests were performed using a width-tapered double-cantilever beam specimen. It was found that as much as 45% of the virgin fracture toughness was recovered by autonomic healing, and as much as 80% was recovered by increasing the temperature to 80 ◦ C during recovery.
4.4 Interlaminar Testing Since most composite materials are layered with only the matrix material binding each layer to its neighbor, weak planes exist. As a result, delamination between layers is a common failure mode. Delamination may initiate from a number of different loading conditions, including impact (high and low velocity), tension, compression, and flexure. The resulting interlaminar normal and shear stresses can then lead to interlaminar fracture and possible subsequent catastrophic failure of a structural component. Often, interlaminar fracture initiates at a free edge where the interlaminar stresses may be much higher than the nominal applied stresses. Figure 4.20 provides dye penetrant enhanced radiography images showing delamination (dark areas) initiated at the free edge, at a stress concentration and at an impact site. This section will cover the experimental characterization of
mode I (opening mode), mode II (shearing mode), and mixed-mode interlaminar fracture, as well as a study of stresses due to free edge effects.
4.4.1 Mode I Fracture Mode I interlaminar fracture toughness is traditionally measured using a double-cantilever beam (DCB), as shown in Fig. 4.21. The specimen is fabricated such that a starter or initial crack is produced using a Teflon film sandwiched between the layers where fracture is intended to propagate (typically the midplane). When loaded, the crack propagates in the plane of delamination. Mode I fracture toughness can be determined in two ways from the critical energy release rate. First, the load at which the delamination starts to propagate can
111
Part A 4.4
electromechanical system (MEMS) for in situ electron microscopy. Loads in the nanonewton and displacements in the subnanometer range can be resolved with the device. The system was used to measure the stress–strain response of free-standing polysilicon films, metallic nanowires, and carbon nanotubes. Figure 4.17 shows electron microscopy images of a nanowire bridging the two cross-heads of the loading device. Small welds secure the fiber in place. Figure 4.18 shows a tunneling electron microscope (TEM) image of a multiwalled carbon nanotube (with an outer diameter of 130 nm and inner diameter of 99 nm) being loaded. Upon rupture, crystallization is clearly seen in the inset of the lower plot in Fig. 4.18. The failure stress was measured at 15.84 GPa with a failure strain of 1.56%. These correspond to a modulus of more than 1000 GPa. These strength and stiffness values are of the order a fivefold improvement over the best traditional carbon fiber (10 μm diameter), and confirm the extraordinary potential that exists from the processing and mechanics of these materials.
4.4 Interlaminar Testing
112
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
be used to compute G IC , the critical energy release rate: F 2 a2 (4.4) G IC = C , bE I where FC is the load at which the crack propagates, a is the current crack length, b is the beams width, and E I is the equivalent flexural rigidity of the upper and lower arms of the specimen. In the second method, the specimen is unloaded after the crack propagates a distance Δa. The area under the load–deflection diagram, bounded by the loading portion, load drop due to crack extension, and unloading portion, represents the work done, ΔU, for crack propagation and the critical energy release rate, G IC , is computed as ΔU (4.5) . bΔa One of the challenges associated with this methodology is the accurate determination of the crack position. Optical microscopes, digital image correlation, and moiré interferometry have been utilized for this purpose. For visual inspection, the edge of the specimen is painted white so that the crack is more pronounced. Perry et al. [4.52] used full-field moiré interferometry to measure the displacement fields for the calculation of the J-integral, in order to determine the strain energy release rate on the DCB specimen. They also developed a method to determine the energy release rate for arbitrary geometries (not DCB) and used the DCB test to validate the methodology. An example
Initial crack
F
Δa a
F Load F
G IC =
Load point displacement
Part A 4.4
Fig. 4.21 The double-cantilever beam specimen, loading, and typical load–displacement diagram
of the phase wrapped moiré displacement pattern for the DCB test is shown in Fig. 4.22. Numerous other researchers have implemented a modified version of the DCB method. Some of these modifications include tapering the specimen in either the vertical direction by adding material to the top and bottom surfaces or tapering the specimen in the widthwise direction [4.53,54]. These modifications transition the crack growth from unstable to stable, and crack propagation occurs at a near-constant load level. For through-thickness stitched composites, it was found that the force required to open the crack breaks the arms of the specimen. The failure was governed by compres-
2 mm
Cracks emanating from the free-edge during loading
Cracks emanating from a stress riser
Damage from impact
Fig. 4.20 Delamination and cracking due to cyclic loading and im-
pact
Fig. 4.22 Moiré interferometry, wrapped, fringe pattern, at the crack tip, for the vertical displacements on a DCB specimen (courtesy K. E. Perry)
Composite Materials
113
in a sliding mode horizontally as the beam bends. The critical energy release rate can be determined using the same analyses as those used for the DCB test. For the instantaneous mode II critical energy release rate
F F/2
F/2
4.4 Interlaminar Testing
Load F
3 FC2 a2 (4.6) . 64 bE I Additionally, by determining the area in the load– displacement diagram (Fig. 4.23), bounded by the loading portion, load drop due to crack extension, and unloading portion, the critical energy release rate is determined in the following equation. G IIC =
ΔU (4.7) . bΔa Typically, the location of the crack front is difficult to determine since the crack does not open, but rather slides. Full-field techniques can be of value for locating the crack tip. Perry et al. used moiré interferometry for both crack front location as well as displacement mapG IIC =
Load point displacement
Fig. 4.23 The end-notched flexure specimen, loading, and typical load–displacement diagram
Ny –5 y
x
5
4.4.2 Mode II Fracture Mode II fracture toughness can be determined using the end-notched flexure (ENF) specimen [4.52]. The specimen is fabricated in the same manner as that used in the double-cantilever beam test, with a Teflon starter crack. It is loaded, however, in a three-point bend configuration, as shown in Fig. 4.23. The crack propagates
V field Ny fringes
0
10
Graphite/ epoxy
15
(O2 /±452 /902)n
20
f = 2400 lines/mm
γxy /|εyav|
γxy x 106
4 8000 2 0
0 –2
–8000 –4
2 mm
–16000
–6
0
8
16
24
32
40
Ply thickness = 0.19 mm (= 0.0075 in.) 48
Ply no.
Fig. 4.24 Horizontal displacement field, at the crack tip,
for an ENF specimen (courtesy K. E. Perry)
Fig. 4.25 Moiré interferometry fringe pattern on a portion of the edge of a quasi-isotropic laminate. Strong interlaminar shear strain are present between +45◦ and −45◦ plies (courtesy D. Post)
Part A 4.4
sive instability. Additional horizontal forces were added by Chen et al. [4.55, 56] to suppress this instability. Under the basic assumptions of superposition of axial load and bending moments in beams, the compressive stresses were reduced and more bending moment could be applied. Crack propagation was realized for stitched materials and traditional DCB analysis showed that the fracture toughness increased by more than 60-fold.
114
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
ping to calculate the energy release rate. Figure 4.24 shows the wrapped fringe pattern used in the analysis.
4.4.3 Edge Effects
Part A 4.5
Often, delamination initiates at the free edge of a composite laminate because of highly localized stresses between layers of dissimilar orientation. This free edge effect forms a stress gradient that dissipates to the nominal stress level of the interior within a distance equivalent to a few ply thicknesses. These stress distributions can be highly complex and three dimensional, involving all three normal and all three shear stresses, and are dependent on the loading condition, the stacking sequence, and material properties. Some are restricted to the interior and cannot be measured on any of the free surfaces, making a comprehensive experimental characterization difficult. Additionally, if residual stresses are ignored in the overall analysis, the absolute stresses cannot be determined. In order to study the free edge affect, very high spatial resolution is required, since the strain gradients are high and the geometric features are small. Post et al. [4.57,58] conducted a series of tests using moiré interferometry to study the interlaminar strains
on both cross-ply and quasi-isotropic thick laminates. They performed both in-plane and interlaminar compression tests and documented the strain distributions on the ply scale. As an example of the experiments performed, a (02 / ± 452 /902 )n , graphite–epoxy laminate subjected to in-plane compressive loading will be presented. Figure 4.25 shows the specimen geometry, the moiré interferometry fringe pattern of the displacement in the vertical direction (loading direction), and the shear strain distribution along a line in the thickness direction on the free surface. The fringe pattern shows significant waviness, where there would only be horizontal, straight, evenly spaced, parallel fringes for a homogeneous isotropic specimen (for instance, a monolithic metallic specimen). By analyzing the horizontal fringe gradient ∂v/∂x the shear strains were determined. Strong gradients were present between the +45◦ and −45◦ plies. The shear strains were of the order of five or five times the applied normal strain. Additionally, from the u-field patterns, it was found that tensile strains in the transverse direction (Poisson effect) varied significantly with peak tensile strains of the order of the applied axial compressive strain.
4.5 Textile Composite Materials Textile composites are a form of composite that utilizes reinforcement in the form of a fabric. The fabric may be woven, braided, knit or stitched and then combined with matrix materials, via resin transfer techniques, hand lay-up, or prepreg methods. Textiles have distinct advantages over traditional laminates made from unidirectional layers, including better contourability over complex three-dimensional (3-D) tools, enhanced interlaminar strength, cost savings through near-net-shape production, and better damage tolerance. Disadvantages include lower fiber volume fraction, the existence of resin-rich volumes between yarns, and degraded inplane properties (as a result of the nonstraight path that the yarns must accommodate). Even so, they are extensively used in applications from the sporting goods industry to advanced aerospace vehicles. Textile composites pose additional challenges to the experimentalist since they have an additional level of heterogeneity. Not only is there heterogeneity on the fiber scale, but also on the scale of the textile architecture and the laminate scale (if multiple layers of cloth are used). For many textile forms a yarn may contain
12 000 fibers, or more, and the repeating unit in the textile architecture may have linear dimensions of the order 1 cm or more. This can pose significant challenges to the experimentalist, even for seemingly routine tests to determine the elastic properties.
4.5.1 Documentation of Surface Strain It has been assumed that the textile architecture induces repeating spatial variation of strain on the surface coincident with the architecture itself. In order to document the strain distribution associated with the architecture, high spatial and measurement resolution are required. Recent studies using moiré interferometry, digital phase-shifting shearography, and Michelson interferometry have documented the strain field on the surface of composites. These results can be used to guide instrumentation practices for strain gages as well as to validate modeling efforts. Lee et al. [4.59] used digital phase-shifting grating shearography to characterize experimentally plainweave carbon–epoxy composites under tensile load.
Composite Materials
Measuring area
8 N/mm 14.8 N/mm 22.7 N/mm 28 N/mm
4500 8 N/mm
4000
x1
Two peaks on the fill arm
4
6
115
Fig. 4.26 Tensile strain contour maps for four load levels. Plots along two lines show the variation of strain and correspondence to the textile architecture (courtesy J. Molimard)
Tensile strain (με) 5000
4.5 Textile Composite Materials
3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500
14.8 N/mm
0
0
2
8
10
12
14
16
Distance along x1-line (mm) Tensile strain (με) 5000
Measuring area
4000 22.7 N/mm
3500
Part A 4.5
8 N/mm 14.8 N/mm 22.7 N/mm 28 N/mm
x2
4500
Two volleys on the warp yarn
3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500
28 N/mm
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Distance along x2-line (mm) –353
174
701
1228
1756
2283
Tensile strain (με)
The experimental technique is similar to moiré interferometry and can be used in conjunction with Michelson interferometry to determine the three in-plane strain components (εx , ε y , γxy ) on a full-field basis, as well as the out-of-plane displacements and surface slopes. They found that the strain varied in a cyclic manner and followed the weave architecture. Figure 4.26 shows contour plots as well as line plots (at two different locations with respect to the architecture) of the tensile strain for four load levels. The maximum strains were of the order of three times greater than the minimum strain values. In the transverse direction they found that the normal strain is predominantly compressive (Poisson effect), but locally there are regions of tensile strain. These effects are attributed to yarn crimp and bending as a function of axial load.
2810
3338
Δ = 264
Shrotriya et al. [4.60] used moiré interferometry to measure the local time–temperature-dependent deformation of a woven composite used for multilayer circuit boards. They studied both the deformation fields in the plane as well as over the cross-section through a temperature range of 27–70 ◦ C. Their measurements revealed the influence of the fabric architecture in the deformation field. They noted that the variation in strain was greater when the composite was loaded in the fill direction (versus the warp direction) due to higher crimp angles (the angle that defines the undulation of a yarn as is passes over and under the transverse yarn). They also found that the total deformation increased with temperature and time (reflecting what was previously measured using strain gages) but the shape and distribution remained almost identical for all the loading cases and
116
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
A
Stacked nesting case B 1.2 mm
Split – span nesting case
C
y (a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f )
(g)
(h)
(i)
Diagonal nesting case
x Prepreg tows
Fig. 4.27a–i Moiré fringe patterns in the fill direction at 27 ◦ C for: (a) initial u-field, (b) u-field at 0.1 min, (c) u-field at 1 min, (d) ufield at 10 min, (e) composite microstructure, (f) initial v-field, (g) vfield at 0.1 min, (h) v-field at 1 min, (i) v-field at 10 min (courtesy
Prepreg tape
Part A 4.5
P. Shrotriya).
sample configurations. Figure 4.27 represents a sample of the fringe patterns taken on the edge of the composite for various times after the load was applied. In the figure, both the horizontal and vertical displacement fields are presented, as well as a schematic of the fabric architecture.
Fig. 4.29 Idealized textile composites can be used to val-
4.5.2 Strain Gage Selection
idate models. Three nesting configurations were tested by the investigators (courtesy D. O. Adams)
Because of the pronounced strain variation on the surface of textile composites, strain gage size (length and Coefficient of variation of strain readings (%) 7 6 Gage data Moire data
5 4 3 2 1 0
0
2
4
6
8 10 12 14 Gage length (mm)
Fig. 4.28 Coefficient of variation (CV) results using differently sized strain gages and CV results from the moiré pattern analysis (courtesy S. Burr)
Tensioned
width) selection is critical in order to avoid significant measurement variation. Studies performed by Burr and Ifju [4.61, 62] showed that, if the strain gage length is sufficiently smaller than the repeating unit cell size of the textile architecture, larger coefficients of variation in material property measurements are observed for simple tension testing. After testing with a variety of gage sizes, it was also observed that, as the gage length increased, the coefficient of variation decreased. Moiré interferometry fringe patterns on the surface of graphite–epoxy triaxial braided specimens were used to determine the appropriate gage length for a variety of braided materials (reinforcement in three directions) with unit cell sizes ranging from 2.5 mm to 22.4 mm. A representative gage area was superimposed over the fringe pattern and a procedure to measure the average strain in the gage area was developed. The representative area was then moved throughout the pattern and the variation of average values was used to determine the relationship between gage area and unit cell size. Figure 4.28 shows a fringe pattern with a represen-
Composite Materials
tative gage area superimposed along with a plot of the gage length versus coefficient of variation for both strain gage experiments and moiré interferometry patterns. Good correlation was found between the moiré prediction of the gage variation and the actual gage variation itself. It was suggested that, prior to performing multiple strain gage experiments, where specimen fabrication and instrumentation costs are prohibitive, a simple moiré experiment can be used to guide gage selection, with the reduction in measurement variability as the payoff.
4.5.3 Edge Effects in Textile Composites
woven composites, where the free edge is typically oriented with the yarn directions, these shearing stresses are less pronounced. It has been shown, however, that small differences in the in-plane fiber angle can lead to significant interlaminar shear on the free edge, where shear would not be expected to exist. For instance, in a weave with fibers running 0/90, there should not be strong shear stresses on the free edge. However, if the fiber angle deviates even a small amount from 90◦ or 0◦ then shear strains will be present, as evidenced by Hale et al. [4.63]. Modeling of the stress and strain fields in textile composites assumes idealized geometries. For multilayered textile composites, the nesting of the layers can influence these fields. Adams and colleagues [4.64] have developed a methodology to produce idealized textile composites with near-perfect nesting, so that experiments performed using full-field optical methods can be directly related to the model. The technique utilizes a method of curing the composite on the actual loom and controlling the tension and precise positions of individual warp and fill yarns. The result is almost perfect alignment of each layer such that layer-to-layer nesting can be controlled. Figure 4.29 shows some of the fabric nesting configurations that were studied.
4.6 Residual Stresses in Composites The act of combining two constituents in the fabrication process of composites typically induces residual stresses in the material.These stresses can arise from two separate sources, the chemical shrinkage of the matrix material (if the matrix undergoes a chemical reaction such as polymerization) as well as stresses due to differences in the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) between the fiber and matrix. The stresses can exist on both the fiber scale as well as the ply scale of the laminate. Additionally, for textile composites, these stresses can exist on the fiber architecture scale. The residual stresses due to chemical shrinkage typically occur during cure, but may also evolve with time as additional curing and physical aging transpires. The stresses that arise from CTE mismatch occur when the material is subjected to temperatures that differ from that of the cure temperature, and as such are strongly dependent on temperature. Many composite material systems, especially the high-tech graphite–epoxy systems used for aerospace applications, are cured in a high-pressure high-temperature apparatus called an
autoclave. This allows the materials to be operated at higher temperatures and typically leads to higher fiber volume fraction and lower void fraction. However, when the composite is utilized at a temperature much lower than the cure temperature, large residual stresses can arise. These stresses superimpose with the applied loads and may cause premature failure of the component. In some cases residual stresses may be high enough to lead to failure, even before loads are applied. For laminated forms, residual stresses on the ply scale exist because of the orthotropic nature of the thermal expansion coefficients in the principal material directions. A typical value for the CTE in the fiber direction α1 is very near zero if not slightly negative, while that in the transverse direction α2 is quite high and dominated by the CTE of the matrix material. For instance, a typical value for α1 is − 0.018 × 10−6 /◦ C for graphite–polymer and 6.3 × 10−6 /◦ C for glass– polymer unidirectional material. Typically, α2 is around 24 × 10−6 /◦ C for both graphite–polymer and glass– polymer materials. This value is nearly the same as
117
Part A 4.6
As seen in laminate forms, edge effects can produce significant shear and normal stress components that may be many times greater than in the interior of the laminate. In textile composites a similar phenomenon transpires, except it occurs on the yarn scale, and can be highly localized. If a free edge cuts through a yarn that is neither parallel nor perpendicular to the free surface, large shearing strains may be present in the interface between the yarn and its nearest neighbor. In the case of braided materials, the yarns are typically inclined to the free edge, leading to large shear stresses and strains. For
4.6 Residual Stresses in Composites
118
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 4.6
that of a typical aluminum. A unidirectional composite is rarely used on mechanical components since the transverse properties are so poor. By laminating the composite, desired mechanical properties can be achieved, however the lamination process leads to residual stresses as neighboring plies constrain each other. A recent example of the seriousness of these stresses is documented by the failure of the NASA X-33 liquid hydrogen fuel tanks [4.65]. A full-size prototype tank was fabricated with honeycomb sandwich core and quasi-isotropic, graphite–epoxy face sheets. Upon filling the tank with liquid hydrogen at cryogenic temperatures, the face sheets failed (cracked) because of residual stress induced by a CTE mismatch on the ply scale superimposed with chemical shrinkage effects on the ply scale. Hydrogen leaked into the core and expanded upon emptying the tank, leading to face sheet separation. The resulting failure led to the cancellation of the entire X-33 program. Given the seriousness of these stresses, there has been a concerted effort to develop experimental techniques to quantify them. This section will document five such methods: the composite sectioning method, the hole-drilling method, the strain gage method, the nonsymmetric lay-up method, and the cure reference method. Generally speaking, the methods can be diHorizontal displacement field (O2/904)13s AS/3501-6 Sectioning here
Mid-plane
vided into two groups, destructive (require damaging the specimen to extract the stress information) and nondestructive. The first two methods are considered destructive, while the following three are nondestructive.
4.6.1 Composite Sectioning Whenever a multidirectional laminate is cut, a free edge is created and stresses are liberated. Stresses at the free edge must satisfy equilibrium and thus the normal stress perpendicular to, and the shear stress components parallel to, the newly developed surface must be zero. Stresses still exist in the interior of the composite, and thus there is a gradient established by forming the free edge. One can measure the strain relief as a result of the creation of the free edge and then relate this to the stresses that existed in the laminate before the cut. There is an underlying assumption that the cutting method itself does not create a deformation field (i. e., no plastic deformation). For most fiber reinforced polymer materials, a well-lubricated slow-speed diamond-impregnated cut-off wheel has been shown to produce negligible local deformation. This can be verified by cutting a unidirectional composite, where-ply level residual stresses do not exist. A number of researchers have utilized this method to back-out the residual stress in laminates [4.66–69]. Joh et al. [4.66] used a combination of moiré interferometry and layer separation to determine residual stresses in a thick (02 /904 )13s , AS/3501-6, cross-ply composite. A grating was attached to the composites before it was sectioned. Cutting was performed to separate plies, and subsequently, moiré experiments were conducted to reveal the displacement field. Figure 4.30 shows the moiré interferometry fringe pattern after ply separation. The displacements were used to determine the strain and subsequent stresses through laminate theory. The method was shown to be capable of determining the residual stresses as a function of ply position and thickness. Tensile stresses of the order the transverse strength of a single ply were reported. Gascoigne [4.67] used a similar procedure to investigate a (020 /9020 /020 )T cross-ply that was composed of thick layers. Similar findings were reported by other investigators [4.69].
4.6.2 Hole-Drilling Methods Fig. 4.30 Moiré interferometry fringe pattern of the hori-
zontal displacements after ply separation (courtesy D. Joh)
The hole-drilling method, originally developed for anisotropic materials by Mathar [4.70], has been ex-
Composite Materials
y x
drilled to two depths (h in the figure). The investigators were able to determine the residual stresses in each ply of a (02 /902 )2s laminate. Later, the method was simplified by Sicot et al. [4.74] by the use of the residual stress rosette in combination with incremental hole drilling. Instead of the displacement information used in Wu’s work, Sicot utilized strain information at the location of the residual stress gages.
4.6.3 Strain Gage Methods Strain gages may be mounted on a cured composite in order to evaluate the thermal coefficient of expansion. This method requires extensive calibration of the strain gage and typically dummy gages mounted on a material that has coefficients of thermal expansion with well-known values. To measure the strain induced during cure however, strain gages must be mounted on the composite and co-cured with it. These gages may be mounted either on top of or embedded in the interior, between plies. The gages must be calibrated through the temperature range and they must be of a gage series that is appropriate for the temperature range. In order to determine the coefficient of expansion through a large temperature range a detailed proce-
υ-field h = 375 μm
u-field h = 112 μm
Finite element model utilizing symmetry about the mid-plane and hole υ-field h = 112 μm
υ-field h = 375 μm
Residual stress (MPa) 80 60 40 20 0 –20 –40 –60
In y-direction
In x-direction
Fig. 4.31 Moiré fringe patterns for
0
112.5
225
337.5
450
562.5
675
119
787.5
900
Thickness direction (μm)
two drill depths, the finite element model used for calibrating coefficients, and the residual stresses as a function of thickness (courtesy Z. Wu)
Part A 4.6
tended for use on orthotropic materials by Schajer et al. [4.71]. This method is similar to the composite sectioning techniques, except instead of a straight cut the free edge is created by a drill-type end mill. The method involves drilling a flat-bottom hole progressively through a laminate (layer by layer), and analyzing the deformation relieved by the process. A special strain gage rosette [4.72] is used to measure the strain field near the hole created by the stress relief. For complicated multidirectional laminates, where the stresses in each individual ply can be different, the simple orthotropic solution cannot be applied. Wu et al. [4.73] introduced the experimental technique of incremental hole drilling, with a 2 mm-diameter drill bit, in combination with the optical method of full-field moiré interferometry. The drilling increments were computer controlled and were coincident with the interfaces between plies. An expression describing the relationship between displacements on the surface, stresses in each layer, in-plane direction cosines, and a set of coefficients was employed. A rigorous calibration of the constants was performed using the full-field moiré displacement fields, and a 3-D finite element model of the 16-ply composite. Figure 4.31 shows two sets of moiré displacement patterns around the hole after the mill had
4.6 Residual Stresses in Composites
120
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
dure was reported by Scalea in [4.75]. He derived analytical expressions for the CTEs of orthotropic lamina, accounting for transverse sensitivity and gage misalignment effects. Experiments were performed on glass–epoxy specimens and Invar as a reference material. He developed rules for temperature dwell time in order to ensure thermal equilibrium.
4.6.4 Laminate Warpage Methods
Part A 4.6
In 1989 [4.76] a method was introduced for the measurement of residual stresses in laminated material systems by fabrication of a nonsymmetric lay-up, more specifically a (0n /90n )T configuration. Numerous researchers have since utilized the method. After cure, the curvature induced from residual stress can be measured for a narrow strip of the laminate and the residual stresses calculated using laminate theory. The curvature can be measured with a variety of methods, including projection moiré, shadow moiré, digital image correlation or simply using a dial gage and assumptions of the shape. The resulting residual stresses are a combination of those induced both thermally and chemically. By heating the specimen to the cure temperature, the thermal contribution can be separated from the contribution due to chemical shrinkage. Figure 4.32 illustrates
the specimen geometry and the deformed shape. In the lower image, a shadow moiré fringe pattern of the curved specimen is presented.
4.6.5 The Cure Reference Method The cure reference method [4.77, 78] introduced in 1999 utilizes moiré interferometry and the application of a diffraction grating on the surface of a composite during the autoclave curing process, as shown in Fig. 4.33. This grating forms a datum from which subsequent thermal stresses can be referenced. Additionally, the method is capable of measuring the combination of the thermally induced and chemically induced components of strain. Unlike many of the former methods, it is capable of determining the residual stresses on any laminate stacking sequence (not just cross-plies), alPorous release film Breather ply Bleeder ply Vacuum bag Vacuum line
Autoclave tool
Non-porous release film Grating Pre-preg
During cure at elevated temperature
Pre-preg 3501-6 epoxy layer Evaporated aluminum 3501-6 epoxy layer
0° 90°
Astrosital autoclave tool (O2/452)2s AS4/3501-6
After cure at room temperature
u displacement field y, υ Shadow moire contour plot documenting the curvature
Fig. 4.32 Warping of a nonsymmetric laminate can be
used to determine residual stresses
x, u
υ displacement field
Fringe patterns were taken over a 1 in. diameter area contered on the face of the composite panel
Fig. 4.33 CRM grating replication and fringe patterns
Composite Materials
the coefficient of thermal expansion α2 , the modulus E 2 , and the shear modulus G 12 on temperature (these three properties are highly dependent on temperature while the others are nearly independent of temperature). These temperature-dependent material properties were then utilized in the analysis. It was shown that the laminate configuration that was presumed to be within a safe operating condition at cryogenic condition, with a predicted factor of safety of 1.3, actually had a safety factor of 0.8, once the temperature-dependent properties and chemical shrinkage residual stresses were incorporated into the analysis. Unfortunately, this analysis was performed after the failure of the fuel tank and the cancellation of the entire X-33 program. In a parallel optimization study, an alternative laminate sequence was developed in order to carry the applied loads, and at the same time, resist residual stress failure. The resulting angle-ply laminate, (±25)n , was tested using the cure reference method in parallel to the X-33 laminate. It was found that it retained a safety factor of 1.8 even when the chemical shrinkage term and the temperature-dependent material properties were used in the analysis.
4.7 Future Challenges Even though many experimental stress analysis techniques have been presented in this chapter, the fact is that modeling efforts are significantly more prevalent. This is especially true on the nanoscale, where molecular and multiscale modeling is proceeding at a strong rate, and the experimental tools to validate these models lag. As such, many of the models remain experimentally unsubstantiated, with little or no validation. Currently, there is a dearth of experimental methods that probe the nanoscale to investigate the complex interaction between composite phases. The traditional continuum breaks down and interatomic mechanics rules the behavior. On the nanoscale, full-field stress analysis techniques are nearly absent and thus this area of research is primed for major contributions. Experimental methods to measure strain must be developed in the atomic force microscope, scanning electron microscope, and tunneling electron microscope.
As new material systems are invented there will be a continuous need to characterize them. Nondestructive evaluation methods discussed in other chapters will play a pivotal role in the adoption of composite materials and their widespread utilization. On the macroscale, with the confidence bought by experimental and modeling efforts and the ability to produce and inspect composite structures, there will be an increase in the number of structures that will be built out of composites. This is especially true in our civil infrastructure, such as bridges and buildings. Continued advances in flight vehicles, lightweight ground vehicles, and sporting goods will require composites because of their advantageous properties. The future of composites is bright and the need to experimentally characterize them will only increase. Tomorrow’s composites may look very different than today’s but the challenges will be similar.
References 4.1
I. M. Daniels: Experimentation and modeling of composite materials, J. Exp. Mech. 39(1) (1999)
4.2
R.F. Gibson: Principles of Composite Material Mechanics (McGraw-Hill, New York 1994)
121
Part A 4
though standard Kirchoff assumptions are made in the analysis (therefore variations due to through-thickness cure gradients cannot be measured). If the specimen is brought to the cure temperature and the strain is monitored, the thermal and chemical contributions can be separated. By applying the cure reference method to a unidirectional material, the free residual strain, defined by the thermal expansion and chemical shrinkage terms combined, can be measured. Then, by applying the cure reference method to a laminate (in the same autoclave cycle) the stresses can be calculated on the ply scale from the laminate strain information and the free residual strains, within the context of laminate theory. Experiments on the X-33 laminate were conducted at the University of Florida using a combination of the cure reference method and strain gages. The strain on the surface of multidirectional and unidirectional composites was measured through the temperature range from cure to liquid nitrogen. It was determined that approximately 20% of the strain at cryogenic temperatures originates from chemical shrinkage and the remainder from a thermal expansion mismatch. A series of experiments were performed to determine the dependence of
References
122
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
4.3
4.4 4.5
4.6
4.7 4.8
4.9
Part A 4
4.10
4.11
4.12
4.13
4.14
4.15
4.16
4.17
M.W. Hyer: Stress Analysis of Fiber-Reinforced Composite Materials (WCB/McGraw-Hill, New York 1998) R.M. Jones: Mechanics of Composite Materials (McGraw-Hill, New York 1975) R.L. Pendelton, M.E. Tuttle (Eds.): Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Elsevier, Amsterdam 1989) C.H. Jenkins (Ed.): Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Fairmont, Lilburn 1998) J.M. Dally, W.F. Riley: Experimental Stress Analysis, 3rd edn. (College House, Knoxville 1991) Measurements Group, Inc.: Errors Due to Transverse Sensitivity in Strain Gages, M-M Tech Note, TN-509, (Micro Measurements Div., Raleigh) M.E. Tuttle: Fundamental Strain Gage Technology. In: Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites, ed. by M.E. Tuttle (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Fairmont, Lilburn 1998) pp. 25–34 Measurements Group, Inc.: Temperature-Induced Apparent Strain and Gage Factor Variation, M-M Tech Note, TN-504 (Micro Measurements Div., Raleigh 1983) R. Slaminko: Strain Gages on Composites-GageSelection Criteria and Temperature Compensation. In: Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites, ed. by M.E. Tuttle (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Fairmont, Lilburn 1998) pp. 35–40 Measurements Group, Inc.: Optimizing Strain Gage Excitation Levels, M-M Tech Note, TN-502 (Micro Measurements Div., Raleigh 1979) Measurements Group, Inc.: Strain Gage SelectionCriteria Procedures, Recomendations, M-M Tech Note, TN-505, (Micro Measurements Div., Raleigh 1983) P.G. Ifju: The shear gage for reliable shear modulus measurements of composite materials, Exp. Mech. 34(4), 369–378 (1994) C.C. Perry: Strain Gage Reinforcement Effects on Orthotropic Materials. In: Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites, ed. by M.E. Tuttle (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Fairmont, Lilburn 1998) pp. 49–54 C.C. Perry: Strain Gage Reindorcement Effets on Low Modulus Materials. In: Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites, ed. by M.E. Tuttle (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Fairmont, Lilburn 1998) pp. 55–58 D.F. Adams: Mechanical Test Fixtures. In: Manual on Experimental Methods of Mechanical Testing of Composites, ed. by M.E. Tuttle (Society for Experimental Mechanics, Fairmont, Lilburn 1998) pp. 87–100
4.18
4.19
4.20 4.21
4.22
4.23
4.24
4.25
4.26
4.27
4.28
4.29
4.30
4.31
4.32 4.33
4.34
H. Czichos, T. Saito, L. Smith (Eds.): Springer Handbook of Materials Measurement Methods (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 2006), Part C ASTM: Test Method for Tensile Properties of Polymer Composite Materials, ASTM Standard D 3039-95a (ASTM, Philadelphia 1996) ASTM: Test Method for Tensile Properties of Plastics, ASTM Standard D 638-95 (ASTM, Philadelphia 1996) ASTM: Test Method for Compressive Properties of Polymer Matrix Composite Materials with Unsupported Gage Section and Shear Loading, ASTM Standard D 3410-95 (ASTM, Philadelphia 1996) ASTM: Test Method for Compressive Properties of Rigid Plastics, ASTM Standard D 695-91 (ASTM, Philadelphia 1996) ASTM: Test Method for Compressive Properties of Unidirectional Polymer Matrix Composites Using a Sandwich Beam, ASTM Standard D 5467-93 (ASTM, Philadelphia 1996) I.K. Park: Tensile and compressive test methods for high modulus graphite fiber reinforced composites, Int. Conf. on Carbon Fibers, Their Composites and Applications (The Plastics Institute, London 1971) K.E. Hofer Jr., P.N. Rao: A new static compression fixture for advanced composite materials, J. Test. Eval. 5, 278–283 (1977) M.N. Irion, D.F. Adams: Compression creep testing of unidirectional composite materials, Composites 2(2), 117–123 (1981) DIN Standard 65 380: Compression Test of Fiber Reinforced Aerospace Plastics: Testing of Unidirectional Laminates and Woven-Fabric Laminates (Deutsches Institut für Normung, Köln 1991) D.F. Adams: A comparison of composite material compression test methods in current use, Proc. 34th SAMPE Symp. (SAMPE, Covina 1989) D.F. Adams, J.S. Welsh: The Wyoming combined loading compression (CLC) test method, J. Comp. Technol. Res. 19(3), 123–133 (1997) ASTM: ASTM Standard D 6641-01 (2001), Test Method for Determining the Compressive Properties of Polymer Matrix Composite Laminates Using a Combined Loading Compression (CLC) Test Fixture (ASTM, West Conshohocken 2001) ASTM: ASTM Standard D5379-98 (1998), Standard Test Method for Shear Properties of Composite Materials by the V-Notched Beam Method (ASTM, West Conshohocken 1993) first published N. Iosipescu: New accurate procedure for single shear testing of metals, J. Mater. 2(3), 537–566 (1967) D.E. Walrath, D.F. Adams: The Iosipescu shear test as applied to composite materials, Exp. Mech. 23(1), 105–110 (1983) J. Morton, H. Ho, M.Y. Tsai, G.L. Farley: An evaluation of the Iosipescu specimen for composite materials shear property measurements, J. Comp. Mater. 26, 708–750 (1992)
Composite Materials
4.35
4.36
4.37 4.38
4.39
4.40
4.41
4.43
4.44
4.45
4.46
4.47
4.48
4.49
4.50
4.51
4.52
4.53 4.54
4.55
4.56
4.57
4.58
4.59
4.60
4.61
4.62
4.63
4.64
4.65
4.66
4.67
4.68
K.E. Perry Jr., J. McKelvie: Measurement of energy release rates for delaminations in composite materials, Exp. Mech. 36(1), 55–63 (1996) Y.W. Mai: Cracking stability in tapered DCB test pieces, Int. J. Fract. 10(2), 292–295 (1974) Z. Li, J. Zhou, M. Ding, T. He: A study of the effect of geometry on the mode I interlaminar fracture toughness; measured by width tapered double cantilever beam specimen, J. Mater. Sci. Lett. 15(17), 1489–1491 (1996) L. Chen, B.V. Sankar, P.G. Ifju: A novel double cantilever beam test for stitched composite laminates, J. Compos. Mater. 35(13), 1137–1149 (2001) L. Chen, B.V. Sankar, P.G. Ifju: A new mode I fracture test for composites with translaminar reinforcements, Comp. Sci. Technol. 62(10-11), 1407–1414 (2002) D. Post, B. Han, P.G. Ifju: High Sensitivity Moiré. In: Experimental Analysis for Mechanics and Materials, Mechanical Engineering Series, ed. by F.F. Ling (Springer, New York 1994) Y. Guo, D. Post, B. Han: Thick composites in compression: an experimental study of mechanical behavior and smeared engineering properties, J. Compos. Mater. 26(13), 1930–1944 (1992) J.R. Lee, J. Molimard, A. Vautrin, Y. Surrel: Application of grating shearography and speckle pattern shearography to mechanical analysis of composite, Appl. Sci. Manuf. A 35, 965–976 (2004) P. Shrotriya, N.R. Sottos: Local time-temperaturedependent deformation of a woven composite, J. Exp. Mech. 44(4), 336–353 (2004) S. Burr, P.G. Ifju, D. Morris: Optimizing strain gage size for textile composites, Exp. Tech. 19(5), 25–27 (1995) P.G. Ifju, J.E. Masters, W.C. Jackson: Using moiré interferometry to aid in standard test method development for textile composite materials, J. Comp. Sci. Technol. 53, 155–163 (1995) R.D. Hale, D.O. Adams: Influence of textile composite microstructure on moiré interferometry results, J. Compos. Mat. 31(24), 2444–2459 (1997) M.A. Verhulst, R.D. Hale, A.C. West, D.O. Adams: Model materials for experimental/analytical correlations of textile composites, Proc. SEM Spring Conf. Experimental Mechanics (Bellevue 1997) pp. 182–183 NASA: Final Report of the X-33 Liquid Hydrogen Tank Test Investigation Team (NASA George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville 2000) D. Joh, K.Y. Byun, J. Ha: Thermal residual streses in thick graphite/epoxy composite laminates-uniaxial approach, Exp. Mech. 33(1), 70–76 (1993) H.E. Gascoigne: Residual surface stresses in laminated cross-ply fiber-epoxy composite materials, Exp. Mech. 34(1), 27–36 (1994) C.K.B. Bowman, D.H. Mollenhauer: Experimental investigation of residual stresses in layered mater-
123
Part A 4
4.42
M. Grediac, F. Pierron, Y. Surrel: Novel procedure for complete in-plane composite characterization using a single T-shaped specimen, J. Exp. Mech. 39(2), 142–149 (1999) J. Molimard, R. Le Riche, A. Vautrin, J.R. Lee: Identification of the four orthotropic plate stiffnesses using a single open-hole tensile, Test J. Exp. Mech. 45, 404–411 (2005) J.W. Dally, D.T. Read: Electron beam moiré, Exp. Mech. 33, 270–277 (1993) J.W. Dally, D.T. Read: E-beam moiré, Proc. SEM Spring Conference (MI, Dearborn 1993) pp. 627– 635 J.W. Dally, D.T. Read: Theory of E-beam moiré, Proc. SEM Spring Conference (MI, Dearborn 1993) pp. 636– 645 D.T. Read, J.W. Dally: Electron beam moiré study of fracture of a GFRP composite, Proc. SEM Spring Conference (MI, Dearborn 1993) pp. 320–329 Y.M. Xing, S. Kishimoto, Y. Tanaka, N. Shinya: A novel method for determining interfacial residual stress in fiber reinforced composites, J. Compos. Mater. 38(2), 135–148 (2004) L.S. Schadler, M.S. Amer, B. Iskandarani: Experimental measurement of fiber/fiber interaction using micro raman spectroscopy, Mech. Mater. 23(3), 205– 216 (1996) M.L. Mehan, L.S. Schadler: Micromechanical behavior of short fiber polymer composites, Comp. Sci. Tech. 60, 1013–1026 (2000) M.S. Amer, L.S. Schadler: Interphase toughness effect on fiber/fiber interaction in graphite/epoxy composites: experimental and modeling study, J. Raman Spectrosc. 30, 919 (1999) L. Zouhua, B. Xiaopeng, J. Lambrose, P.H. Geubelle: Dynamic fiber debonding and frictional push-out in model composite systems: experimental observations, Exp. Mech. 42(3), 417–425 (2002) I.M. Daniel, H. Miyagawa, E.E. Gdoutos, J.J. Luo: Processing and characterization of epoxy/clay nanocomposites, Exp. Mech. 43(3), 348–354 (2003) Y. Zhu, H.D. Espinosa: An electromechanical material testing system for in situ electron microscopy and applications, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 102(41), 14503– 14508 (2005) M.R. Kessler, S.R. White: Self-activated healing of delamination damage in woven composites, Appl. Sci. Manuf. A 32(5), 683–699 (2001) M.K. Kessler, N.R. Sottos, S.R. White: Self-healing structural composite material, Appl. Sci. Manuf. A 34(8), 743–753 (2003) E.N. Brown, N.R. Sottos, S.R. White: Fracture testing of a self-healing polymer composite, Exp. Mech. 42(4), 372–379 (2002) E.N. Brown, S.R. White, N.R. Sottos: Microcapsule induced toughening in a self-healing polymer composite, J. Mater. Sci. 39, 1703–1710 (2004)
References
124
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
4.69
4.70
4.71
4.72
4.73
ials using moiré interferometry, J. Electron. Packag. 124(4), 340–344 (2002) D.J. Lee, R. Czarnek: Measuring residual strains in composite panels using moiré interferometry, SEM Spring Conf. Experimental Mechanics, Milwaukee, (A93-16601 04-39) (1991) pp. 405– 415 J. Mathar: Determination of initial stresses by measuring the deformation around drilled holes, Trans. ASME 56 4, 249–254 (1934) G.S. Schajer, L. Yang: Residual stresses measurement in orthotropic materials using the hole-drilling method, Exp. Mech. 34(4), 324–333 (1994) ASTM: ASTM Designation: E837-01, Standard Test Method for Determining Residual Stresses by the Hole-Drilling Strain Gage Method (ASTM, Philadelphia 1999) Z. Wu, X. Niu, J. Lu, P. Ifju: Study of Process-Induced Residual Stress in Orthotropic Composite Laminate
4.74
4.75
4.76
4.77
4.78
– Carbon/Epoxy [02 /902 ]2s, Proc. SEM Spring Conference (1998) O. Sicot, X.L. Gong, A. Cherout, J. Lu: Determination of residual stress in composite laminates using the incremental hole-drilling method, J. Compos. Mat. 37(9), 831–844 (2003) F.L. Scalea: Measurement of thermal expansion coefficients of composites using strain gages, Exp. Mech. 38(4), 233–241 (1998) I.M. Daniel, T. Wang: Determination of chemical cure shrinkage in composite laminates, J. Comp. Technol. Res. 12(3), 172–176 (1989) P. G. Ifju, B. C. Kilday, X. Niu, S. C. Liu: A novel means to determine residual stress in laminated composites, J. Compos. Mat. 33(16), 1511–1524 (1999) P.G. Ifju, X. Niu, B.C. Kilday, S.-C. Liu, S.M. Ettinger: Residual strain measurement in composites using the cure-referencing method, J. Exp. Mech. 40(1), 22–30 (2000)
Part A 4
125
Fracture Mec 5. Fracture Mechanics
Krishnaswamy Ravi-Chandar
In this chapter, the basic principles of linearly elastic fracture mechanics, elastic plastic fracture mechanics, and dynamic fracture mechanics are first summarized at a level where meaningful applications can be considered. Experimental methods that facilitate characterization of material properties with respect to fracture and analysis of crack tip stress and deformation fields are also summarized. Full-field optical methods and pointwise measurement methods are discussed; many other experimental methods are applicable, but the selection presented here should provide sufficient background to enable implementation of other experimental methods to fracture problems.
5.2
Fracture Mechanics Based on Energy Balance ................................ Linearly Elastic Fracture Mechanics......... 5.2.1 Asymptotic Analysis of the Elastic Crack Tip Stress Field.. 5.2.2 Irwin’s Plastic Correction ............... 5.2.3 Relationship Between Stress Analysis and Energy Balance – The J-Integral .............................. 5.2.4 Fracture Criterion in LEFM ..............
126 128 128 129
Elastic–Plastic Fracture Mechanics.......... 5.3.1 Dugdale–Barenblatt Model............ 5.3.2 Elastic–Plastic Crack Tip Fields ....... 5.3.3 Fracture Criterion in EPFM ............. 5.3.4 General Cohesive Zone Models ....... 5.3.5 Damage Models ...........................
132 132 134 135 136 136
5.4 Dynamic Fracture Mechanics .................. 5.4.1 Dynamic Crack Initiation Toughness ................................... 5.4.2 Dynamic Crack Growth Toughness... 5.4.3 Dynamic Crack Arrest Toughness .....
137 138 139 139
5.5 Subcritical Crack Growth........................ 140 5.6 Experimental Methods .......................... 5.6.1 Photoelasticity ............................. 5.6.2 Interferometry ............................. 5.6.3 Lateral Shearing Interferometry ..... 5.6.4 Strain Gages ................................ 5.6.5 Method of Caustics ....................... 5.6.6 Measurement of Crack Opening Displacement ...... 5.6.7 Measurement of Crack Position and Speed...................................
140 141 143 147 151 152 153 155
130 131
References .................................................. 156
Assessment of the integrity and reliability of structures requires a detailed analysis of the stresses and deformation that they experience under various loading conditions. Many early designs were based on the limits placed by the strength of the materials of construction; in this approach the structure never attains loading that will cause strength-based failure during its entire lifetime. However, many spectacular failures of engineered structures occurred, not by exceeding strength limitations, but due to inherent flaws in the material and/or the structure, or due to flaws that grew to critical dimensions during operation. For example, during World
War II, Liberty ships simply broke into two pieces while sitting still in port as a result of cracking. The first commercial jet aircraft, the de Havilland Comet, failed in flight due to fractures emanating from window corners that grew slowly under repeated loading, eventually becoming critical. Such events provided the impetus for analysis that takes into account material and structural defects and spawned the development of the philosophy of flaw-tolerant design – such that the structure will operate safely, even in the presence of certain anticipated modes of failure. Such a damage- or flawtolerant approach to structural integrity and reliability
Part A 5
5.1
5.3
126
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 5.1
has become possible through a combination of material characterization, flaw detection and fracture mechanics analysis. The success of the flaw-tolerant design approach may be seen in the mid-flight tearing of fuselage panels of the Aloha Airlines Boeing 737 in 1988. While a significant portion of the fuselage was blown off due to linking of multiple cracks, the deflection of crack growth through bulkhead tear-straps limited crack growth, retaining the structural integrity of the airplane, which was able to land safely. The theory of fracture mechanics and the experimental methods used in fracture characterization are described in this chapter. The fundamental ideas of the theory of rupture were formulated elegantly by Griffith [5.1]; the crux of this theory is captured in Sect. 5.1. Griffith’s analysis brought a key element to the theory: that the maximum load-carrying capacity of a structural element depends not only on the strength of the material, but also on the size of flaws that may exist in the structural element – the larger the flaw, the smaller the load capacity or strength. Formalization of this into the practical theory of fracture mechanics – now called linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM) – was spearheaded through the efforts of Irwin [5.2, 3] who introduced the idea of the stress intensity factor that combined the stress and flaw issues into one parameter, and by many others;
LEFM is discussed in Sect. 5.2. The limitations of elastic analysis were recognized by many investigators (beginning with Griffith) and a theory of fracture that accounts for elastic–plastic material behavior, the theory of elastic–plastic fracture mechanics, described in Sect. 5.3, was developed. For fast-running cracks, the effect of inertia becomes important; the fundamentals of dynamic fracture theory and practical implementation aspects are discussed in Sect. 5.4. The experience from the Comet airplane incident indicated that, even if the structure was not fracture-critical under monotonic loading, crack extension could occur under repeated loading through a process of fatigue. Other processes such as stress corrosion and creep also engender timedependent crack growth under subcritical conditions. Subcritical crack growth is handled phenomenologically by correlating a loading parameter to crack speed (crack extension per cycle or per unit time). A short description of subcritical crack growth is provided in Sect. 5.5. Experimental investigations and specific experimental methods of analysis have played a crucial role in the development of fracture mechanics. Optical methods that provide full-field information over a region near the crack tip and pointwise measurement of some component of stress or deformation are both in common use; these methods are discussed in detail in Sect. 5.6.
5.1 Fracture Mechanics Based on Energy Balance Consider the equilibrium of a linearly elastic medium containing a crack; a special geometry, called the double-cantilever beam (DCB) is illustrated as an example in Fig. 5.1. This specimen contains a crack of length a and the other relevant geometrical quantities are shown in the figure; the specimen width is taken to be unity, indicating that all loads are considered to be per unit thickness. The total energy of the system E can be partitioned into two components: the potential energy Π and the energy associated with the crack Us . Thus, E = Π + Us .
to be the fracture energy per unit area of crack surface and not specifically attributed to the surface energy. We consider a quasistatic problem and hence the kinetic energy has been neglected. The energy of the system P, ΔT CM P, Δ
(5.1)
The potential energy is the sum of the work done by the applied external tractions WE and the stored energy in the system U. Us was defined originally by Griffith [5.1] as the surface energy of the crack. Orowan [5.4] generalized this to include plastic dissipation during creation of the surface and thus Us can be considered generally
2h
a
Fig. 5.1 Geometry of the double-cantilever beam fracture
specimen
Fracture Mechanics
must be an extremum when the system is in equilibrium; thus dE/ dA = 0, where A represents the crack surface area, which for the unit thickness considered is equal to the crack length a. We define the potential energy release rate per unit crack surface area G and the fracture resistance per unit surface area R as dUs dΠ (5.2) , R≡ . da da The equilibrium condition can be written as an expression that the potential energy released by the body in extending the crack is equal to the fracture resistance: G(a) ≡ −
G(ac ) = R ,
(5.3)
Δ (5.4) , P where P is the load per unit thickness and Δ is the displacement of the load point. Let the specimen be attached to a pinned support at the bottom and attached to a load through a spring at the top. The total displacement ΔT (considered to be fixed) is ΔT = C(a) + CM P , (5.5) C(a) =
where CM is the compliance of the loading machine, with CM = 0 indicating a fixed-grip loading and CM → ∞ implying a dead-weight loading on the specimen. The potential energy in the system – the specimen and the loading machine – at fixed total displacement is Π=
Δ2 (ΔT − Δ)2 + . 2CM 2C(a)
(5.6)
127
The potential energy release rate can then be calculated either at fixed load or fixed grip conditions: 1 2 d C(a) (5.7) P . 2 da Thus, calculation of the compliance of a cracked body will yield the potential energy release rate directly. For the specific example of the double-cantilever beam, elementary beam theory can be used to estimate the 3 compliance of the beam segments: C(a) = E8ah 3 . Substituting in (5.7) and equating to the fracture resistance, we find that the equilibrium crack length can be written either in terms of the beam deflection or the applied load: 3 1/2 3Eh 3 Δ2 1/4 Eh R = . (5.8) ac = 16R 12P 2 G=
Obreimoff [5.5] used this idea and successfully measured the fracture resistance of mica subjected to cleavage between its layers. It is to be noted that the compliance of the loading machine does not enter into the determination of the equilibrium crack length, but will influence the stability of crack growth. The most remarkable aspect of the formulation of the fracture problem in terms of the energy approach is that the issue of analysis of the stresses and deformations in the vicinity of the crack is completely circumvented. In the case of the DCB specimen, as illustrated above, and in a few other simple cases, the compliance may be estimated rather easily and hence the energy approach is easily implemented. In other cases, the compliance can be obtained in the process of experimentation or through a numerical simulation of the structural problem and hence used in the analysis of fracture. The main obstacle to applying this approach in general is the determination of the fracture resistance. If the fracture energy per unit area is to be regarded as a material property, determined in analog laboratory tests and used in applications, the conditions under which crack growth occurs must be similar in the laboratory tests and field applications. This requires consideration of how the deformation and stresses evolve in the vicinity of the crack tip region. Analysis of the stress and deformation in a solid containing a crack is considered next, within the context of the theory of linear elasticity.
Part A 5.1
where ac is the equilibrium crack length. If the fracture resistance is taken to be a material parameter, then the problem of determining the equilibrium crack length is reduced to the problem of determining the potential energy release rate. This is the essence of fracture mechanics as outlined by Griffith [5.1] and augmented by Orowan [5.4]. Calculation of the potential energy release rate can be accomplished experimentally, analytically or numerically by solving the appropriate boundary value problems. A simple analytical method is described here, with application to the double-cantilever beam as an illustrative example. In general, the compliance of any specimen can be written as
5.1 Fracture Mechanics Based on Energy Balance
128
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
5.2 Linearly Elastic Fracture Mechanics The Griffith theory of fracture discussed above was developed further through analysis of the details of the stress and deformations in an elastic body containing a crack. We summarize these analyses under the assumption that the material may be modeled as a linearly elastic medium up to the point of failure. Criteria for failure under these conditions are also discussed.
5.2.1 Asymptotic Analysis of the Elastic Crack Tip Stress Field
Part A 5.2
The nature of the stress field near the crack tip in a linearly elastic solid was established through the efforts of Inglis [5.6], Mushkhelisvili [5.7], Williams [5.8], Irwin [5.2], and many other investigators. In general, consideration of three different loading symmetries is sufficient to decompose any arbitrary loading with respect to a crack; as illustrated in Fig. 5.2; these are typically called mode I or opening mode, mode II or inplane shearing mode, and mode III or antiplane shearing mode. For a homogeneous, isotropic, and linearly elastic solid, the structure of the solutions to the equations of equilibrium subjected to traction-free crack surfaces can easily be determined for each of the three modes of loading; this stress field in the vicinity of the crack for modes I and II may be written in the following form: KI I (θ, 1) + σ0x δ1α δ1β Fαβ σαβ (r, θ) = √ 2πr ∞ n I + (θ, n) An r n/2 Fαβ 2 n=3
K II II +√ Fαβ (θ, 1) 2πr ∞ n II + (θ, n) Bnr n/2 Fαβ 2 n=3 ⎧ ⎨0 plane stress , σ33 (r, θ) = ⎩νσ (r, θ) plane strain
(5.9)
where the θ dependence is given by Kobayashi [5.9] I (θ, 1) = cos 12 θ 1 − sin 12 θ sin 32 θ , F11
II F22 (θ, 1) = sin 12 θ cos 12 θ cos 32 θ ,
The corresponding displacement field can be expressed as σ0x 2 KI r I G θ, 1 + rG I θ, 2 u α (r, θ) = μ 2π α μ 1+ν α ∞ An n/2 I r G α θ, n + 2μ n=3 K II r II + G α θ, 1 μ 2π ∞ Bn n/2 II + r G α θ, n , 2μ ⎧ n=3 ⎨− νxE3 σαα r, θ plane stress , (5.10) u 3 r, θ = ⎩0 plane strain where
αα
I F12 (θ, 1) = sin 12 θ cos 12 θ cos 32 θ , I F22 (θ, 1) = cos 12 θ 1 + sin 12 θ sin 32 θ , II F11 (θ, 1) = − sin 12 θ 1 + cos 12 θ cos 32 θ , II F12 (θ, 1) = cos 12 θ 1 − sin 12 θ sin 32 θ ,
I (θ, n) = 2 + (−1)n + 12 n cos 12 n − 1 θ F11 − 12 n − 1 cos 12 n − 3 θ ,
I F12 (θ, n) = − (−1)n + 12 n sin 12 n − 1 θ + 12 n − 1 sin 12 n − 3 θ ,
n I F22 (θ, n) = 2 − −1 − 12 n cos 12 n − 1 θ + 12 n − 1 cos 12 n − 3 θ , for n ≥ 2 ,
n II F11 (θ, n) = − 2 + −1 + 12 n sin 12 n − 1 θ + 12 n − 1 sin 12 n − 3 θ ,
n II F12 (θ, n) = −1 + 12 n cos 12 n − 1 θ + 12 n − 1 cos 12 n − 3 θ ,
n II F22 (θ, n) = − 2 − −1 − 12 n sin 12 n − 1 θ − 12 n − 1 cos 12 n − 3 θ . for n ≥ 2 .
G I1 (θ, 1) = cos 12 θ 1 − 2ν + sin2 G I2 (θ, 1) = sin 12 θ 2 − 3ν − cos2 2 1 G II 1 (θ, 1) = sin 2 θ 2 − 2ν + cos 2 1 G II 2 (θ, 1) = cos 2 θ 1 − 2ν + sin
1 2θ , 1 2θ , 1 2θ , 1 2θ ,
G I1 (θ, 2) = cos θ , G I2 (θ, 2) = −ν sin θ ,
n n n G I1 (θ, n) = (3 − 4ν) cos θ − cos −1 θ 2 2 2 n n n + (−1) cos θ , + 2 2
Fracture Mechanics
n n n G I2 (θ, n) = (3 − 4ν) sin θ + sin −1 θ 2 2 2 n n + (−1)n sin θ , − 2 2 for n ≥ 3 , n n n G II (θ, n) = −(3 − 4ν) sin θ + sin − 1 θ 1 2 2 2 n n + (−1)n sin θ , − 2 2 n n n II −1 θ G 2 (θ, n) = −(3 − 4ν) cos θ + cos 2 2 2 n n + (−1)n cos θ , − 2 2 for n ≥ 3 .
σ22 σ12 σ11
y r θ x
Fig. 5.3 Crack tip coordinate system and notation for
stress components
The stress intensity factors are a function of the applied load, the geometry of the specimen or structure, and the length of the crack, and must be determined by solving the complete boundary value problem in linear elasticity that includes the full geometric description of the cracked structure and the applied load; the stress intensity factor has dimensions √ of (FL3/2 ) and in SI units is typically indicated as MPa m. The displacement field in (5.10), on the other hand, is bounded and u α → 0 as r → 0. While it may be objectionable to consider extending linear elastic calculations to infinite stresses and strains, there are two simple arguments to reconcile this difficulty. First, even though the stresses are unbounded, the energy in a small volume near the crack tip is always bounded because the displacements tend to zero. Secondly, inelastic deformations occur in the regions of high stress and hence, these expressions are taken to be applicable for small values of r relative to structural dimensions, but outside of a distance rp where inelastic, nonlinear, and fracture processes dominate the deformation of the material; an estimate of rp is obtained in the next section. For distances that are very large in comparison to rp , terms involving higher powers of r may become important. The nonsingular term is labeled σ0x in keeping with the literature in experimental mechanics, but it is also called the T-stress in the general fracture literature. This term in (5.9) is independent of r and arises only in the σ11 component of stress. These terms may not necessarily be important in characterizing fracture itself – although there is some debate in recent literature that suggests otherwise – but must be taken into account while evaluating experimental data collected from fullfield optical techniques discussed later in this chapter.
5.2.2 Irwin’s Plastic Correction Fig. 5.2 Three loading symmetries in a cracked specimen
129
Irwin [5.3] suggested that the effect of the plastic zone near the crack tip can be approximated by a very simple
Part A 5.2
The corresponding expressions of the stress and deformation fields for mode III can also be written; we do not address mode III problems in this chapter and hence these fields are not provided here. The corresponding expressions for plane strain may be obtained by replacing ν by ν/(1 + ν). The standard notation of linear elastic theory is used; the Cartesian components of stress are written in terms of the polar coordinates centered at the crack tip (see Fig. 5.3 for the coordinate system and notation). δαβ is the Kronecker delta and E is the modulus of elasticity. Standard index notation is used; Greek subscripts take the range 1, 2 and summation with respect to repeated subscripts is implied. These fields are seen to be separable in r and θ; the θ dependence for the two different modes are given above for completeness. From the first term in (5.9), the stress components are seen to be square-root singular as r → 0 and hence (5.9) cannot be valid very close to the crack tip. The strength of the singularity is determined by the two scalar quantities K I and K II , called the stress intensity factors in modes I and II, respectively.
5.2 Linearly Elastic Fracture Mechanics
130
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
such as B, the specimen thickness a, the crack length, and any other length defining the geometry of the specimen. This gives a qualitative meaning to the concept of small-scale yielding, and a more precise restriction must be obtained from experimental characterization of materials.
σ22
5.2.3 Relationship Between Stress Analysis and Energy Balance – The J-Integral
ry
rp
x
Fig. 5.4 Irwin model of the crack tip plastic zone
model; assume that the stress in the plastic zone near the crack tip must be limited to some multiple of the yield stress: σ22 (r < rp , 0) = βσY , where rp is the extent of the plastic zone. However, in order to maintain equilibrium, the above assumption requires that the stress estimated from (5.9) for some distance r < ry must be redistributed to regions r > ry , as indicated in Fig. 5.4. This is expressed by the following equation
Part A 5.2
ry σ22 (r, 0) dr = rp βσY , 0
1 KI ry = 2π βσY
2 . (5.11)
Evaluating this equation yields rp = 2ry . In this estimate, the square-root singular field is considered to have its origin shifted to the point r = ry , effectively considering the crack to be of length aeff = a + ry . Hence the stress intensity factors need to be evaluated using this effective crack length. If we assume a Tresca yield criterion, for thin plates with σ33 = 0, it is easy to show that β = 1. However, for conditions of plane strain expected expects to prevail near the crack tip, with σ33 > 0, one √ β to be larger; Irwin suggested a value of β = 3, resulting in an estimate of plastic zone size 1 KI 2 . (5.12) rp = 3π σY This simple estimate of the zone of yielding does remarkably well in capturing the extent of yielding near the crack tip. More importantly, this analysis indicates clearly that the characteristic scale in the frac2 length ture problem is obtained as σKYI . In applying the ideas of LEFM, it is now clear that one must ensure that (K I /σY )2 is much smaller than other relevant lengths
The energy release rate described in Sect. 5.1 and the stress field discussed above must, of course, be related in some manner. This relationship can be obtained in a formal way by considering the change in potential energy, using ideas of conservation integrals. Eshelby [5.10] introduced these in a general sense for defects; Cherepanov [5.11] and Rice [5.12] defined a special case – the J-integral – for cracks. Knowles and Sternberg [5.13] developed these as general conservation laws for elastostatic problems, but Rice’s paper was the key to recognizing the importance to fracture mechanics. The J-integral is defined as
∂u α (5.13) Un 1 − σαβ n β ds , J= ∂x1 Γ
where U =
ε
σαβ dεαβ is the mechanical work in de-
0
forming to the current strain level, and n α are the components of the unit outward normal to the contour of integration Γ shown in Fig. 5.5; this integral is independent of the path of integration. By considering a contour along the boundaries of the specimen, it can be shown that dΠ (5.14) =G. J =− da Furthermore, by considering a contour to lie in the region close to the crack tip such that the asymptotic field in (5.9) and (5.10) is valid, it can be established that 1 − ν2 2 1 − ν2 2 1 + ν 2 (5.15) KI + K II + K III . J= E E E x2
x1 s Γ
Fig. 5.5 Contour path for the J-integral
n
Fracture Mechanics
For plane stress, the factor (1 − ν2 ) in the first two terms of (5.15) is replaced with unity. This equivalence between the potential energy release rate and the stress intensity factor forms the basis of the local approach to fracture.
5.2.4 Fracture Criterion in LEFM Equations (5.3) and (5.14) provide the basis for formulating the fracture criterion in terms of the energy release rate or the J-integral; for the case of small-scale yielding (5.15) indicates that the fracture criterion may be posed in terms of the stress intensity factor as well. The crack is now considered to be fracture critical under mode I loading when KI = KC ,
(5.16)
KC
the specimen thickness B obey the following inequality K IC 2 a, B ≥ 2.5 . (5.17) σY The characteristic length scale can be seen to arise from Irwin’s scaling analysis in Sect. 5.2.2; the numerical factor was determined through numerous tests in different materials and loading geometries. Standard techniques for characterization of the fracture toughness are provided by the American Society for Testing and Materials, the British Standards Institution, the Japanese Society of Mechanical Engineers, and the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). In particular, conditions for preparation and testing of specimens that produce a valid measurement of the plane-strain fracture toughness that obeys the restriction in (5.17) are discussed in these standards. The typical range of values of the fracture toughness for different materials is provided in Table 5.1. This methodology of assessing fracture with very limited inelastic deformation is called linearly elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM). As an illustration of LEFM, consider a simple example: a large panel with a crack of length 2a subjected to uniform stress σ; the stress√intensity factor for this configuration is simply K I = σ πa. Applying the fracture criterion in√(5.16) results in the critical condition, expressed as σ πa = K IC . This condition can be used in one of three ways in fracture-critical structures. First, at the design stage, one sets the crack length to be at the limit that is detectable by nondestructive inspection techniques. Then, for a desired design load, a material with the appropriate fracture toughness can be selected or alternatively, for a given material, the maximum permissible stress can be determined. Second, for a given structural application with fixed fracture toughness and stress, the critical crack length can be calculated and Table 5.1 Typical values of the fracture toughness for various materials
KIC
2.5 Normalized specimen thickness B
σY KIC
2
Fig. 5.6 Dependence of the fracture toughness on specimen thickness
Material
K IC , MPa
Ductile metals: Cu, Ni, Ag A533 Steel Mild steels High-strength steels Al alloys Ceramics: Al2 O3 , Si3 N4 Polyethylene Polycarbonate Silica glass
100– 350 200 140 50– 150 20– 45 3–6 2 1 – 2.5 0.7
√ m
131
Part A 5.2
where K C is the critical stress intensity factor, considered to be a material property; note that it must be evaluated with special care to ensure that conditions of small-scale yielding are assured. One expects that the plastic work in a thinner specimen is larger than in that in a thicker specimen; this is reflected in the typical variation of K C with specimen thickness as shown in Fig. 5.6. The measured value of K C is high for small specimen thicknesses and reaches a nearly constant lower plateau at large specimen thicknesses; it is this value of the critical stress intensity factor, labeled K IC , that a new material property called the plane strain fracture toughness that is taken to be a new material. The main condition that arises here ensures that the radius rp of the inelastic region near the crack tip is small enough; thus, in tests performed to evaluate the fracture toughness, one must have the crack length a and
5.2 Linearly Elastic Fracture Mechanics
132
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
used in inspections to determine how close the structure is to fracture criticality. Considering that cracks grow during subcritical loading (Sect. 5.5), one may also determine how long the crack will grow in the time interval between inspections. Finally, for a given crack length and material, one can impose limits on loading such that critical conditions are not reached during operation. The fracture criterion described above is valid only for the mode I loading symmetry. Under a combination of modes I and II, the crack typically kinks from its initial direction and finds a new direction; hence the fracture criterion should not only determine the load at which the crack will initiate under mixed-mode loading, but also determine the direction of the new crack. Applying the energy balance idea to this problem, the fracture criterion may be stated as follows: The crack will follow the path along which the potential energy release rate is maximized. While this is the most appropriate form of the fracture criterion, it is difficult to apply since the energy release rate has to be calculated for different paths and then maximized. A number of alternative criteria exist: the maximum tangential
stress criterion, the principle of local symmetry, the strain energy density criterion, etc., but their predictions are not clearly distinguishable in experimental observations. The maximum tangential stress criterion, which provides the same estimate for the crack direction as the energy-based criterion, can be stated as follows: The crack will extend in the direction γ such that ∂σθθ /∂θ is maximized. Using the stress field in (5.9), ⎫ ⎧ ⎨ K I − K I2 + 8K II2 ⎬ . γ = 2 arctan (5.18) ⎭ ⎩ 4K II The energy release rate for extension in that direction G(γ ) must be equal to the fracture resistance R at the onset of crack initiation. The fracture criterion appropriate for mode III loading is significantly more complicated. A straightforward extension of the maximum tangential stress criterion discussed in this paragraph for use in combined mode I and mode II can be shown to breakdown simply from symmetry considerations. In fact, the crack front breaks up into a fragmented structure and appropriate criteria for characterizing this are still not well developed.
Part A 5.3
5.3 Elastic–Plastic Fracture Mechanics In cases where the extent of the plastic zone becomes large compared to the specimen thickness and crack length, the LEFM methodology of Sect. 5.2 breaks down and one is forced to contend with the inelastic processes that occur within r < rp . This is the subject of elastic–plastic fracture mechanics (EPFM). First, an elegant and simple way of incorporating the inelastic effects – through the Dugdale–Barenblatt model – is introduced; this is followed by an evaluation of the stress and deformation field using the deformation theory of plasticity. Then we return to an extension of the Dugdale–Barenblatt model in the form of generalized cohesive zone models for inelastic fracture. Finally, a generalized damage model based on void nucleation and growth is described.
the crack tip, interatomic (cohesive) forces that attract the two separating crack surfaces cannot be ignored in the analysis. Dugdale considered a larger-scale picture where a linear region in the prolongation of the crack tip would limit the development of stress to some multiple of the yield stress (similar to the observation of Irwin discussed in Sect. 5.2.2). Both these suggestions amount
δt
α
5.3.1 Dugdale–Barenblatt Model The idea of eliminating the source of the singularities in the elastic analyses was proposed independently by Barenblatt [5.14] and Dugdale [5.15] and has been generalized into what are now commonly called cohesive zone models. Barenblatt suggested that, close to
δt
Fig. 5.7 Schematic diagram of the Dugdale–Barenblatt model of fracture
Fracture Mechanics
Problem a
factors:
K Ia = σ ∞ π(a + rp ) , a + rp a b −1 (5.19) . cos K I = −2βσY π a + rp Note that the negative sign in problem b is a mere formality arising from the fact that the loads pinch the crack tip closed. The condition that the resulting problem does not contain singular stresses is enforced by requiring the sum of the stress intensity factor from the two component problems to be zero; this results in the following estimate for the extent of the inelastic zone: ∞ rp πσ (5.20) −1 . = sec a 2βσY The crack-tip opening displacement (CTOD) is defined as the separation between the top and bottom surfaces of the physical crack tip located at x1 = a; this can also be calculated as the superposition of the elastic solutions to the two problems; for plane stress, this results in δt = u 2 (x1 = a, x2 = 0+ ) − u 2 (a, 0− ) ∞ 8βσY a πσ = (5.21) . ln sec πE 2βσY A key feature of the DB condition is that the crack opening profile is not parabolic, as indicated by the singular solution, but a smooth cusp-like closing from x1 = a to x1 = a + rp ; this is indicated in Fig. 5.9. Crack opening displacement – πE δ 2βσY a 10
5
σ∞ Problem b
133
0
βσ Y –5 2(a+rp) 2(a+rp) –10 –2
–1
0
1 Position –
2 x1 a
Fig. 5.8 Dugdale–Barenblatt model of fracture for a center- Fig. 5.9 Crack opening profile in the Dugdale–Barenblatt cracked specimen model of fracture
Part A 5.3
to a model for the fracture process and provide a way to regularize the stress near the crack tip. Since then generalizations of the cohesive zone ideas to craze failure in polymers (Knauss [5.16] and Schapery [5.17]), fracture in weakening solids such as concrete by Hillerborg et al. [5.18], and for ductile failure in metallic materials [5.19] have been developed. A schematic diagram of the Dugdale–Barenblatt (DB) model is shown in Fig. 5.7. Assuming that the extent of the inelastic zone ahead of the crack tip rp is large in comparison to the specimen thickness B, it can be modeled as a line segment on x2 = 0, along which the normal stress σ22 can be taken to be limited by the yield stress as in the case of the Irwin model: σ22 (r < rp , 0) = βσY . However, the extent of the inelastic zone is obtained by ensuring that the singularity indicated by the elastic analysis is removed, rather than from the local equilibrium analysis of Irwin; this is called the DB condition. This requires the solution of the appropriate boundary value problem for the cracked elastic solid; the procedure is illustrated here for the case of a large plate with a central crack of length 2a loaded in uniform remote tension as shown in Fig. 5.8. Consider that the material in the DB zone is removed and replaced with its equivalent effect, i. e., a constant stress of magnitude βσY over the length rp . (Indeed, there is no reason to limit this to constant stress; the generalization of nonlinear cohesive zone models simply relies on introducing a nonlinear traction separation law over the line of the inelastic zone.) This is represented as the superposition of two elastic problems, problem a, with uniform far-field stress σ ∞ of a crack of length 2(a + rp ), and problem b, with uniform closing stress of magnitude βσY only over the extended crack surfaces rp near either tip. The solutions to these problems result in the following stress intensity
5.3 Elastic–Plastic Fracture Mechanics
134
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
While the introduction of the DB model has removed the singularity and provided a way to estimate the extent of the inelastic zone, it has also eliminated the possibility of imposing a fracture criterion based on the stress intensity factor. One has to resort to the energy or J-based criterion for fracture; the latter can be accomplished by evaluating the J-integral for a contour indicated in Fig. 5.7 that closely follows the DB zone; for a < x1 < a + rp , we have n 1 = 0, σ11 = 0, σ12 = 0, σ22 = βσY ; thus, a+α
∂u 2 ∂u 2 J =− − (−βσY ) dx1 ∂x1 (x2 ,0+ ) ∂x1 (x1 ,0− ) a
= βσY δt .
(5.22)
Part A 5.3
The equivalence indicated in (5.22) between the Jintegral and the CTOD holds in general for all elastic–plastic crack tip models, but the particular form above is valid for all crack geometries based on the DB model. Now, the fracture criterion may be applied by setting J = Jc at the onset of crack initiation, or equivalently in terms of the CTOD. For the particular case of the center-cracked geometry, substituting from (5.21), setting J = Jc at the failure stress σ ∞ = σf , and rearranging, we get an estimate for the failure stress under the DB model as: 2 πE σf J = sec−1 exp (5.23) . c βσY π 8(βσY )2 a A plot of the failure stress as a function of the crack length is shown in Fig. 5.10. For comparison, the estiNormalized failure stress – 2
mate based on small-scale yielding is also shown in the figure. It is clear that, for short cracks, the failure stress is large enough that large-scale yielding becomes important and LEFM does not provide a correct estimate of the fracture strength.
5.3.2 Elastic–Plastic Crack Tip Fields In order to account in greater detail for the development of plastic deformation in the vicinity of the crack tip, Hutchinson [5.20], and Rice and Rosengren [5.21] performed an asymptotic analysis of the fields in a nonlinear elastic solid characterized by a power-law constitutive model. The stress–strain relationship is given as n−1 sαβ εαβ 3 σe = α , (5.24) εY 2 σY σY where α is a material constant, n ≤ 1 is the strainhardening exponent, σY is the yield stress in uniaxial tension and εY = σY /E is the corresponding yield strain, sαβ = σαβ − σγγ δαβ /3 are the components of the stress deviatoric, and σe = 3sαβ sαβ /2 is the effective stress. The field near the crack tip was determined to be J 1 1/(n+1) σ˜ αβ (θ, n) , σαβ (r, θ) = σY ασY εY In r εαβ (r, θ) = αεY
ε˜ αβ (θ, n) , (5.26)
σf βσY
J 1 ασY εY In r
(5.25)
n/(n+1)
1 J u α (r, θ) = αεYr ασY εY In r
n/(n+1) u˜ α (θ, n) , (5.27)
1.5
1
0.5
0
0
1
2
3
Normalized crack length –
4 8(βσY)2 a πEJc
Fig. 5.10 Comparison of the failure stress calculated from
LEFM (dashed line) and the DB model (solid line)
where J is the value of the J-integral, In is a dimensionless quantity that depends only on the strain hardening exponent (see, for example, Kanninen and Popelar [5.22] for calculations of I (n)), and σ˜ αβ (θ, n), ε˜ αβ (θ, n), and u˜ αβ (θ, n) express the angular variation of the stress, strain, and displacement variation near the crack tip, determined numerically; the description of the field given above is called the HRR field, in honor of the original authors, Hutchinson, Rice and Rosengren. It is clear that the stress and strain components given in (5.25) and (5.26) are singular as r → 0, but with the order of singularity different from the corresponding linear elastic problem and different for the stress and strain components. The strength of the singularity
Fracture Mechanics
is determined by the value of the J-integral. Equations (5.25)–(5.27) cannot be valid very close to the crack tip and a small region in the vicinity of the crack tip – called the fracture process zone, rfpz – must be excluded from consideration. The fracture process zone is taken to be the region in which the actual process of fracture – void nucleation, growth, and coalescence – occurs and results in the final failure of the material. Furthermore, it is clear from (5.27) that the CTOD, defined arbitrarily as the opening at the intercept of two symmetric 45◦ lines from the crack tip and the crack profile, should be proportional to the J-integral: δt = d(n, εY )J/σY , where d(n, εY ) can be calculated in terms of the HRR field; see Kanninen and Popelar [5.22] for a plot of this variation. Thus, in EPFM, J plays multiple roles – determining the amplitude of the plastic stress and deformation field, determining the CTOD, and determining the potential energy release rate. It is possible to incorporate terms that are higher order in r but evaluation of such terms is much more difficult in the elastic–plastic problem in comparison to the elastic problem. Attempts have been made to incorporate the next-order term (the nonsingular term) in fracture analysis [5.23, 24], but these are not addressed here.
Unlike the case of LEFM, there is no simple way in which to estimate the size of the process zone rfpz and hence of the region of dominance of the HRR field expressions given above. Some attempts using moiré interferometry are discussed in Sect. 5.6.2. However, it is clear from discussions of the plastic zone in Sect. 5.2.2 and the CTOD that the only characteristic length scale relevant to this problem can be written as J/σY . Thus, the remaining uncracked segment b and the thickness of specimen B must obey the following inequality in order to justify the use of the HRR field b, B > κ
J . σY
(5.28)
Estimates of how large this should be vary significantly depending on the geometry of the specimen; estimates based on finite element analysis show that κ varies over a range from about 20–300 depending on the specimen geometry. Under such conditions, the fracture criterion may be posed as the equivalent of the energy criterion discussed above. Hence, we have J(σ , a) = JC .
(5.29)
135
Here it is necessary to calculate J(σ , a), a somewhat more challenging task than the corresponding calculation of the stress intensity factor for a problem in LEFM. Under laboratory testing conditions, since the J-integral is the change in potential energy of the system, one can use (5.14) and the experimentally measured load versus load-point displacement data to evaluate J. Typically, this results in a simple expression of the form J=
ηA , bB
(5.30)
where A is the area under the load–displacement curve, b is the remaining uncracked ligament, B is the specimen width, and η is a factor that depends on the specimen geometry. Therefore, monitoring the load–displacement curve is adequate in the evaluation of the J-integral. The value of the J-integral at onset of crack extension should result in an experimental measurement of the fracture toughness under elastic–plastic conditions, not restricted to small-scale yielding. In applying this approach of EPFM to other structural configurations, one encounters two difficulties. First, whereas many different handbooks tabulate solutions of stress intensity factors for different geometric and loading conditions, few such solutions are available for elastic plastic problems. The Ductile Fracture Handbook [5.25] provides a tabulation of estimates of the J-integral for a few cases associated with circular cylindrical pipes and pressure vessels. However, with modern computational tools, this is hardly a limitation and one should, in principle, be able to calculate the J-integral for arbitrary loading and geometric conditions. The second – and more challenging – difficulty arises from the fact that the measured crack resistance in many common structural materials increases significantly with crack extension and that such an increase depends critically on the constraint to plastic deformation provided in the particular geometric condition of the test. This brings into question the transferability of laboratory test results to full-scale structural integrity assessment. Therefore the methodology presented in this section remains limited in its use to a few configurations of cylindrical pipes and pressure vessels where there is significant experience in its use. Recent advances in elastic–plastic fracture methodology have focused more on generalized cohesive zone models and damage models as discussed in the next two sections. Such generalized cohesive zone models are
Part A 5.3
5.3.3 Fracture Criterion in EPFM
5.3 Elastic–Plastic Fracture Mechanics
136
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
now embedded into commercial finite element software packages.
5.3.4 General Cohesive Zone Models
Part A 5.3
Cohesive zone models for nonlinear fracture problems are simply a straightforward extension of the Dugdale– Barenblatt model. In these models, the inelastic region (including the plastic zone and the fracture process zone) is assumed to be in the form of a line ahead of the crack tip, as in the DB model. However a relationship between the traction across this line T and the separation δ between the two surfaces T = F(δ) is postulated. Such a relationship may be obtained directly from experimental measurements (as in the case of some polymeric materials) or more typically from a micromechanical model of the void nucleation, growth, and coalescence that are the underlying fracture processes. A typical traction-separation law for cohesive zone models is shown in Fig. 5.11. Two crucial features can be identified: the peak stress that corresponds to the maximum stress that can be sustained by the material in the fracture process zone and the maximum displacement that corresponds to the critical CTOD. The area under the traction separation curve is the fracture energy JC . Details of such generalized cohesive models may be found in a number of papers by Knauss [5.16], Schapery [5.17], Hilleborg et al. [5.18], Kramer [5.26], Normalized traction T 1.5
1
0.5
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6 0.8 1 Normalized separation δ
Fig. 5.11 A typical traction–separation law used in cohesive zone models is shown. Traction is normalized by the peak cohesive traction and the separation is normalized by the critical CTOD; the area under the curve is the fracture energy
Carpinteri [5.27], Needleman [5.28], Xu and Needleman [5.29], Yang and Ravi-Chandar [5.30], Ortiz and Pandolfi [5.31], and many other references. Incorporation of such a generalized cohesive zone model into finite element computational strategies allows for estimation of crack growth to be performed automatically, without imposing additional criteria for fracture. Irreversible models of the cohesive zone have also been proposed based on the maximum attained crack surface separation [5.30–32]. In particular, persistence of previous damage in the cohesive zone, and contact and friction conditions upon unloading, are important aspects to include in a proper description of the cohesive zone model. Numerous investigators have shown that crack growth simulations based on cohesive zone models are somewhat insensitive to the detailed form of the traction-separation curve and that it is much more important to capture the correct fracture energy. However, care should be exercised in using this idea since there is an inherent dependence on the mesh size and geometry dependence of the results obtained (Falk et al. [5.33]).
5.3.5 Damage Models In cases where the cohesive zone model may not be appropriate because of the diffuse nature of the inelastic zone, one may resort to continuum damage models for modeling fracture. The Gurson–Tvergaard–Needleman model is perhaps the most commonly used model for simulations of fracture [5.34]. In this model, the yield function describing the plastic constitutive model is represented as σ2 3q2 σH −1 g(σe , σH , f ) = e2 + 2 f ∗ q1 cosh 2σ σ 2 (5.31) − q1 f ∗ , where σe is the effective stress, σH = σii/3 is the mean stress, and σ is the flow stress of the material at the current state, q1 and q2 are fitting parameters used to calibrate to model predictions of periodic arrays of spherical and cylindrical voids, f is the void volume fraction, and f ∗ is a bilinear function of the void volume fractions that accounts for rapid void coalescence at failure and is given as ⎧ ⎨f f < fc , (5.32) f∗ = ⎩ f c + (1/q1 − f c ) ( f − f c ) f ≥ f c ( ff − fc )
where f f represents the void volume fraction corresponding to failure; the value of f ∗ at zero stress f c
Fracture Mechanics
is the critical void volume fraction where rapid coalescence occurs. The above description of the yield function needs to be augmented with evolution equations for both the flow stress σ and the void volume fraction f . The instantaneous rate of growth of the void fraction depends both on nucleation of new voids and growth of preexisting voids. Thus, f˙ = f˙nucleation + f˙growth .
(5.33)
Chu and Needleman [5.35] assumed that void nucleation will obey a Gaussian distribution; then straincontrolled nucleation can be expressed as 1 ε¯ p − εn ˙ p fn ε¯ (5.34) f˙nucleation = √ exp − 2 sn sn 2π where sn is the standard deviation, εn is the nucleation threshold strain, f n is a constant, and ε¯ p is the average plastic strain. The latter is related to the plastic strain through a work equivalence expressed as (1 − f )¯εp σ = σ : ∂Φ ∂σ . The growth rate is obtained by enforcing that the plastic volumetric strain rate in the matrix (outside of the voids) is zero; thus, p f˙growth = (1 − f )˙εkk .
(5.35)
where m is the strain rate hardening exponent, and g(¯ε, T ) is the temperature-dependent effective stress versus effective strain response calibrated through a uniaxial tensile test at a strain rate ε˙¯ 0 and temperature T .
Setting f = 0 results in the above formulation reducing to a standard von Mises yield surface for an isotropic material. Equations (5.31)–(5.35) augment the standard plasticity equations in the sense that void nucleation and growth are now incorporated into the model. If the above model is evaluated under monotonically increasing uniaxial strain on a cell of unit height, initially a linear elastic behavior is obtained; this is followed by nonlinearity associated with plastic deformation and eventually a maximum stress associated with the onset of decohesion or failure of the unit cell. Beyond this level of displacement, the cell is unstable to load control, but deforms in a stable manner under displacement control. Thus, the damage zone model mimics the response that one assumes in the generalized cohesive zone models discussed above. Two main issues need to be addressed with respect to this type of damage model. First, there are numerous constants embedded into the theory. In addition to the usual elastic constants E and ν, one has the plastic constitutive description g(¯ε, T ), the strain-rate hardening parameter m, the four parameters that define the yield function q1 , q2 , f c , f f , and the three parameters that define the nucleation criterion f n , sn , εn . These need to be determined through calibration experiments for each particular material. Second, the introduction of a cell is a micromechanical construct: it introduces an artificial length scale and geometric effect that must be considered carefully. For example, does calibrating the model parameters under uniaxial straining provide sufficient characterization to handle biaxial or triaxial loading conditions? Active research continues in this area to explore these questions further and to validate the approach of the damagemodel-based fracture analysis.
5.4 Dynamic Fracture Mechanics In many applications, it is necessary to consider cracks that grow rapidly at speeds that are a significant fraction of the stress wave speeds in the material. In such cases, material inertia effects cannot be ignored in considerations of crack growth. Within the setting of small-scale yielding, analysis of the stress and displacement field near the tip of a crack moving at a speed v can be accomplished easily within linear elastodynamic theory [5.36, 37]; the crack tip stress and displacement fields for in-plane loading conditions may be written in
terms of polar coordinates moving with the crack tip as KI K II II I f αβ f αβ (θ, v) (θ, v) + √ σαβ (r, θ) = √ 2πr 2πr + σox αd2 − αs2 δα1 δβ1 + · · · , ⎧ ⎨0 plane stress σ33 (r, θ) = , (5.37) ⎩νσ (r, θ) plane strain αα
137
Part A 5.4
Power-law hardening of the plastic material is represented as m σ ˙ε¯ = ε˙¯ 0 , (5.36) g(¯ε, T )
5.4 Dynamic Fracture Mechanics
138
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
√ KI r I u α (r, θ) = √ gα,β (θ, v) 2π √ K II r II + √ gαβ (θ, v) + · · · , ⎧ 2π ⎨− νx3 σ (r, θ) plane stress E αα . (5.38) u 3 (r, θ) = ⎩0 plane strain I (θ, v) and f II (θ, v) are The functions f αβ αβ I f 11 (θ, v) =
1 R(v)
G(v) =
cos 12 θd 1 + αs2 1 + 2αd2 − αs2 1/2 γd
− 4αd αs
1
1 2 θs
cos , 1/2 γs 2 cos 12 θd 1 I (θ, v) = − 1 + αs2 f 22 1/2 R(v) γd 1 + 4αd αs 1/2 cos 12 θs , γs 1 + αs2 sin 12 θd sin 12 θs 2α d I − , f 12 (θ, v) = 1/2 1/2 R(v) γ γs d
Part A 5.4
II f 11 (θ, v) = −
2αs R(v)
(5.39)
sin 12 θd 1 + 2αd2 − αs2 1/2 γd
1 − 1 + αs2 1/2 sin 12 θs , γs 2 2αs 1 + αs sin 12 θd 1 II 1 (θ, v) = − sin θ f 22 2 s , 1/2 1/2 R(v) γd γs cos 12 θd 1 II f 12 (θ, v) = 4αd αs 1/2 R(v) γd cos 12 θs − 1 + αs2 (5.40) , 1/2 γs where Cd and Cs are the dilatational and distortional wave speeds, respectively, and γd = 1 − (v sin θ/Cd )2 and (5.41) γs = 1 − (v sin θ/Cs )2 , tan θd = αd tan θ , tan θs = αs tan θ , 2 R(v) = 4αd αs − 1 + αs2 .
gularity dictated by the dynamic stress intensity factor for the appropriate mode of loading. In analogy with the quasistatic crack problems, it is possible to define a dynamic energy release rate; it is the energy released into the crack tip process zone per unit crack extension. Introducing the elastodynamic singular stress field, G can be related to the dynamic stress intensity factor
(5.42) (5.43)
As in the case of quasistatic LEFM, the crack tip stress field is square-root singular, with the strength of the sin-
1 − ν2
AI (v)K I2 + AII (v)K II2 , E
v2 αd and (1 − ν)Cs2 R(v) v2 αs . AII (v) = (1 − ν)Cs2 R(v)
(5.44)
AI (v) =
(5.45)
E is the modulus of elasticity and ν is the Poisson’s ratio. The fracture criterion in (5.3) can be imposed in this problem as well – the dynamic energy release rate must be equal to the dissipation; thus G(v) = R provides the equation of motion for the crack velocity. The functions AI (v) and AII (v) in (5.45) are singular as v → CR . To satisfy the energy balance equation, the dynamic stress intensity factors K I (t, v) and K II (t, v) must tend to zero as v → CR . This implies that the limiting crack speed in modes I and II is the Rayleigh wave speed. Experimental measurements by many investigators, beginning with the pioneering work of Schardin [5.38], have found that in practice cracks never reach that speed, branching into two or more cracks at speeds of only about one half of the Rayleigh wave speed. For use in applications, the deviations from the energy criterion discussed above has been circumvented by the use of distinct criteria for dynamic crack initiation, dynamic crack growth, and dynamic crack arrest as described in the following sections.
5.4.1 Dynamic Crack Initiation Toughness Since the state of stress near the crack tip is described in terms of the dynamic stress intensity factor K I (t), crack initiation can be identified with the stress intensity factor reaching a critical value; the dynamic crack initiation criterion is postulated as (5.46) K I (tf ) = K Id T, K˙ I . The right-hand side represents the dynamic initiation toughness, with the subscript ‘d’ replacing the subscript ‘C’ used for the critical stress intensity factor for the quasistatic fracture toughness. The dependence
Fracture Mechanics
of the dynamic crack initiation toughness on the temperature and rate of loading (represented by the rate of increase of the dynamic stress intensity factor, K˙ I ) is indicated through the arguments; this dependence must be determined through experiments covering the range of temperatures and rates of loading of interest. The temperature dependence of the dynamic crack initiation toughness arises from the increase in ductility with increasing temperature or from heating associated with inelastic deformation in the near-tip zone or a combination of both. The left-hand side of (5.46) represents the applied stress intensity factor at time tf when crack propagation commences. Standard procedures do not exist for characterization of the dynamic crack initiation toughness at rates on the order of K˙ I ≈ 1 × 104 MPa m3/2 s−1 or larger, but there exist a large database on specific materials; a survey is presented by Ravi-Chandar [5.37].
5.4.2 Dynamic Crack Growth Toughness
5.4 Dynamic Fracture Mechanics
139
An interesting consequence of this difference between crack initiation and growth toughness is that the crack will jump to a large finite speed immediately upon initiation. Second, experimental efforts to determine K ID v, K˙ I , T have met with mixed success, particularly for nominally brittle materials; variations in the measurements with different specimen geometries [5.39, 40] and loading rates [5.41] have not been resolved completely. Also, indications that the measurements are hysteretic – meaning that accelerating and decelerating cracks exhibit different behavior – have been reported [5.42]. For ductile materials, (5.47) appears to be a more reasonable characterization of dynamic fracture; see Rosakis et al. [5.43]. As in the case of dynamic crack initiation toughness, standard procedures have not been developed for determination of the dynamic crack growth toughness, but there is a large literature on methods of characterization and data on specific materials; Ravi-Chandar [5.37] presents a survey of available results on this topic.
5.4.3 Dynamic Crack Arrest Toughness
The upper-case subscript ‘D’ is used to indicate the dynamic crack growth toughness instead of the lowercase ‘d’ that was used to indicate the dynamic initiation toughness. Once again, the right-hand side represents the material property to be characterized through experiments and the left-hand side represents the dynamic stress intensity factor calculated from the solution of the boundary initial value problem in elastodynamics. The dynamic crack growth toughness is commonly referred to as the K I –v relation. Some important limitations must be recognized in using (5.47) for dynamic crack growth problems. First, the crack initiation point is not on the curve characterizing the dynamic crack growth criterion. Thus, K ID v → 0, K˙ I , T = K Id T, K˙ I . This could be possibly due to bluntness of the initial crack, the intrinsic rate dependence of the material, or inertial effects.
In applications, the most conservative design approach would utilize (5.48), thus assuring that the dynamic stress intensity factor for all possible loading conditions never exceeds the crack arrest toughness. Thus a dynamically growing crack is never encountered in the lifetime of the structure and one avoids the complications in computing the dynamic stress intensity factors for growing cracks and in determining the dynamic crack growth criterion. Based on round-robin tests and an accumulation of data a standard test procedure, the ASTM E-1221 standard has been established that describes the determination of crack arrest toughness in ferritic steels. A rapid crack growth-arrest sequence is generated in a compact crack arrest specimen by using a displacement-controlled wedge loading; as the crack grows away from the loading wedge, the stress intensity factor drops quickly and hence results in arrest of the
Crack arrest is not the reversal of initiation and hence the initiation toughness discussed above is not relevant for crack arrest; also, the characterization of the crack growth criterion at very slow speeds is quite difficult. This has led to the postulation of a separate criterion for crack arrest: the dynamic crack arrest toughness is defined as the smallest value of the dynamic stress intensity factor for which a growing crack cannot be maintained; thus the crack arrests when K I (t) < K Ia (T ) .
(5.48)
Part A 5.4
Once dynamic crack growth has been initiated as per the conditions of the dynamic initiation criterion, subsequent growth must be determined though a separate criterion that characterizes the energy rate balance during growth. The dynamic stress field near a growing crack is still characterized by the dynamic stress intensity factor, but now this is a function of loading, time, crack position, and speed and is represented as K I (t, v). The energy rate balance in (5.44) can be expressed as a relation between the instantaneous dynamic stress intensity factor and the toughness: (5.47) K I (t, v) = K ID v, K˙ I , T .
140
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
crack. The dynamic run–arrest sequence that this specimen experiences under the wedge load clearly indicates the need for a dynamic analysis of the problem. However, according to the ASTM standard, a static analysis is considered to be appropriate assuming that the values
measured at 2 ms after crack arrest do not differ significantly from the values measured at 100 ms after crack arrest. The stress intensity factor at arrest is taken to be the crack arrest toughness, K Ia . Further details can be found in the ASTM E-1221 standard.
5.5 Subcritical Crack Growth
Part A 5.6
The discussion above has been focused on fracture under monotonically increasing loading that approaches the critical conditions resulting in quasistatic or dynamic crack growth. The primary design philosophy of flaw-tolerant design is to ensure that the structure should never reach the critical condition during its useful life. However, this does not imply that crack growth does not occur during the lifetime of the structure; crack extension occurs under subcritical conditions; if such subcritical extension is due to repeated loading– unloading cycles, the resulting crack extension is called fatigue crack growth. Such extension could also be due to operational conditions under steady loading; temperature-dependent accumulation of plastic deformation, resulting in creep crack growth in metals above 0.5 TM , and stress-assisted corrosion in glass and some metallic materials are some other examples of subcritical crack growth. In all these cases, crack extension occurs very slowly over a number of cycles or over a long time; eventually such cracks reach a critical length, resulting in catastrophic failure at some point. Subcritical crack growth is typically handled in a phenomenological sense; regardless of the underlying cause, material characterization of crack extension can be performed under specified condition and represented as da (5.49) = f (K I , . . .) , dξ where ξ is the number of cycles for fatigue, and time for time-dependent crack growth; thus the crack growth
rate per unit cycle or unit time is some function of the stress intensity factor (or an equivalent parameter), the environment, and perhaps other variables. The functional form of the dependence on the stress intensity factor (or its range in the case of cyclic loading) is obtained from experimental characterization. For fatigue, the dependence is typically written as ΔK I da = C(ΔK I )b , dN
(5.50)
where C and b are empirical constants, determined through calibration experiments for each material; it is well known that these are not true material constants, but influenced significantly by material microstructure, crack length, loading range, etc. If the critical crack length, ac , at final fracture is known, then the number of cycles to failure can be obtained by integrating (5.50)
ac Nc = a0
da . C(ΔK I )b
(5.51)
Details of fatigue crack growth analysis may be found in specialty books devoted to fatigue of materials [5.44, 45]. Standard methods for fatigue crack growth characterization, such as E 647, have also been established by the ASTM and other organizations. A good summary of progress in creep fracture is provided by Riedel [5.46]. Stress-corrosion and chemical effects are discussed in detail by Lawn [5.47].
5.6 Experimental Methods Many different experimental methods have been developed and used in investigations of fracture. They may be broadly classified into two categories: those based on optical methods that provide full-field information over a region near the crack tip and those based on pointwise measurement of some component of stress or
deformation. While full-field techniques are preferred in research investigations where the sophistication of apparatus and analysis are required in order to elucidate fundamental phenomena, in applications to industrial practice, simpler methods such as those based on strain gages or compliance methods are to be preferred. The
Fracture Mechanics
methods of photoelasticity, moiré and classical interferometry, and shearing interferometry, fall into the first category and are discussed first. The digital image correlation (DIC) method is rapidly gaining popularity in light of the availability of commercial hardware and software. This method is described in detail in Chap. 25 and hence is not discussed in the present chapter. The optical method of caustics and strain-gage-based methods provide much more limited data, but are quite useful in the determination of stress intensity factors; these are discussed next. Finally, methods based on measurement and analysis of the compliance of the entire specimen and loading system are also of significant use in fracture mechanics; this is a straightforward application of (5.7) and is not discussed further. Three different volumes devoted to experimental methods in fracture characterization have been published in the last 25 years [5.48–50]; while the present chapter provides a survey of the methods, these original references remain invaluable resources for details on the different methods discussed in this chapter.
5.6 Experimental Methods
141
5.6.1 Photoelasticity The method of photoelasticity has been applied to fracture problems under both static and dynamic loading conditions. In a circular polariscope, illustrated in Fig. 5.12, the intensity of the light beam is: Δs(x1 , x2 ) (5.52) , I (x1 , x2 ) ∝ k2 sin2 2 where k is the amplitude of the electric vector and Δs(x1 , x2 ) is the absolute phase retardation (see Chap. 24 for details of the analysis). Thus, in this optical arrangement, the spatial variation of the light intensity is governed only by the phase retardation introduced by the stressed specimen. Introducing the phase difference from (25.2) of Chap. 25, bright fringes corresponding to maximum light intensity are lines in the x1 –x2 plane along which (σ1 − σ2 ) =
N fσ , with N = 0, ±1, ±2, . . . , (5.53) h Axis of polarization Light source
Fast axis Polarizer π/4 σ1 λ/4
σ2 α
Fast axis
Specimen π/4
λ/4
Polarizer
Axis of polarization
Fig. 5.12 Optical arrangement of a circular polariscope in a dark-field configuration
Part A 5.6
*
142
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Table 5.2 Material stress fringe value f σ for selected polymers (λ = 514 nm) Material
fσ (kN/m)
Source
Homalite 100
22.2
Polycarbonate
6.6
Polymethyl methacrylate
129
Dally and Riley [5.51] Dally and Riley [5.51] Kalthoff [5.52]
Part A 5.6
where N is called the fringe order, f σ is the stress-fringe value, which depends on the material, h is the specimen thickness, and σ1 and σ2 are the principal stress components. Typical values of f σ for materials commonly used in fracture studies are given in Table 5.2. Therefore, placing the specimen between crossed circular polarizers reveals lines of constant intensity that are contours of constant in-plane shear stress; these lines are called isochromatic fringes. Such isochromatic fringe patterns are captured with a camera at sufficient spatial and temporal resolution for quasistatic and dynamic problems and analyzed to determine the stress field. In applications to fracture mechanics, it is assumed that the appropriate asymptotic field is applicable in the vicinity of the crack tip and the parameters of the asymptotic field are then extracted by fitting the observed isochromatic fringes to theoretically predicted patterns in a least-squared error minimization process. Assuming that the fringe pattern formation is governed by the asymptotic stress field near the crack tip and substituting for σ1 and σ2 , the geometry of the a)
b)
fringe pattern can be expressed as N fσ (5.54) = g(r, θ, K I , K II , σox , . . .) . h For given values of the stress intensity factors, fringes can be simulated using (5.54). Examples of such simulated isochromatic fringe patterns corresponding to assumed values of K I , K II , and σox are shown in Fig. 5.13; in this representation, only the singular term and the first higher-order term are indicated, whereas in actual applications higher-order terms in the crack tip stress field are also taken into account in interpreting the experimental fringe pattern. An example of the time evolution of the fringe patterns obtained with a high-speed camera is shown in Fig. 5.14 [5.53]. The stress intensity factor K I can be obtained at each instant in time by using a leastsquares matching of the experimentally measured fringe pattern with simulations based on (5.54). We describe the general method of extracting parameters of the stress field from experimentally observed isochromatics. First, the experimental isochromatic fringe pattern is quantified by a collection of (Ni , ri , θi ), measured at M points. The distance r at which these measurements are taken should be appropriate for application of the two-dimensional asymptotic crack tip stress field; this is typically interpreted to hold for r/h > 0.5, based on the experimental results of Rosakis and RaviChandar [5.54], but Mahajan and Ravi-Chandar [5.55] showed that for fringe data based on photoelasticity, one may be as close as r/h > 0.1 and still obtain a good estimate of the stress intensity factors. The sum of the squared error in (5.54) at all measured points is then given by M Ni f σ e(a1 , a2 , . . . ak ) = h i=1 2 − g(ri , θi , a1 , a2 , . . . ak ) . (5.55)
Fig. 5.13a,b Simulated isochromatic fringe patterns corresponding to a dark-field circular polariscope arrangement (a) K I = 1 MPa m1/2 , K II = 0, and σox = 0 (b) K I = 1 MPa m1/2 , K II = 0, and σox = 50 MPa. f σ = 7 kN/m corresponding to polycarbonate has been assumed. The field of view shown in these figures is 40 mm along one side and v/Cd = 0.1
In (5.55), the stress field parameters (K I , K II , σox , . . .) are represented by the vector a = (a1 , a2 , . . . ak ). The stress field parameters must be obtained by minimizing e with respect to the parameters. Near the minimum, the function e can be expanded as a quadratic form e(a1 , a2 , a2 , . . .) ∼ γ − 2
M k=1
βk a k +
M M
αkl ak al ,
k=1 l=1
(5.56)
Fracture Mechanics
5.6 Experimental Methods
143
Fig. 5.14 High-speed sequence showing isochromatic fringe patterns obtained in an experiment with a quasistatically loaded single-edge-notched specimen. Polycarbonate specimen observed in a dark-field circular polariscope arrangement. Frames are 10 μs apart. The height of the field of view presented in the image is about 75 mm (after Taudou et al. [5.53])
where 1 ∂e = 2 ∂ak
i=1
Ni f σ ∂gi − gi h ∂ak
and
M 1 ∂2e ∂gi ∂gi = 2 ∂ak ∂al ∂ak ∂al i=1 2 Ni f σ ∂ gi − − gi h ∂ak ∂al and gi = g(ri , θi , a1 , a2 , a2 . . .). Since Nihf σ − gi is expected to be small, the second term in αkl is usually neglected and only the first derivative of g needs to be evaluated. The estimate for the increment in the parameters is obtained by setting ∇e = 0. This results in the following equation for the increments in the parameters δak :
αkl =
βl =
M
αkl δak .
(5.57)
k=1
With the update of the parameters a = (a1 , a2 , . . . ak ) obtained from the above, the procedure is repeated until the parameters converge. For a thorough discussion of the procedures for such least-squared error fitting see Press et al. [5.56]. Curve fitting routines based on the above are also implemented in Mathematica, Matlab,
and other commercial software packages. There appear to be multiple minima for the function in (5.56) and hence it is usually good practice to simulate the isochromatic fringe patterns with the converged parameters and perform a visual comparison of the recreated fringes to the experimentally observed pattern. Numerous examples of the application of the least-squares fitting method for extraction of the stress intensity factors in quasistatic and dynamic fracture problems can be found in the literature [5.53, 57–61].
5.6.2 Interferometry Classical optical interferometry has been applied by numerous researchers to investigations of fracture problems; two implementations of classical interferometry are commonly used, one to measure the out-of-plane displacement on the free surface of a cracked planar specimen and the other to measure the crack opening displacement in the vicinity of the crack. Complementing this, moiré interferometry has also been used in investigations of the in-plane deformations near a crack tip. The basic principles and interpretation of results are discussed in this section. Measurement of Out-of-Plane Displacements The basic principle of the method is the interference of coherent light beams in a classical two-beam
Part A 5.6
βk = −
M
144
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Object plane
Specimen
Reference mirror
5 mm
Image plane Imaging optics Beam splitter
Beam-forming optics
Laser
Fig. 5.15 Twyman–Green interferometer for the measurement of
out-of-plane displacements (after Schultheisz et al. [5.62, 63])
Part A 5.6
interferometer; the arrangement of a Twyman–Green interferometer, a variant of the Michelson interferometer, shown in Fig. 5.15 was used by Schultheisz et al. [5.62] to accomplish this interference scheme. Light rays reflected from the deformed surface of the specimen and the reference mirror are brought together to interfere; as a result of path differences introduced by the deformation of the surface, fringe patterns are observed in this arrangement as contours of constant out-of-plane displacement component u 3 . This component, corresponding to the singular term of the asymptotic stress field, is given by νK I I Fαα (θ, 1) , u 3 (r, θ) = − √ E 2πr
Fig. 5.16 Interference fringes obtained in a Twyman– Green interferometer corresponding to contours of constant out-of-plane displacements (after Schultheisz et al. [5.62, 63]). 4340 steel specimen
( f -number) limits the acceptance angle of incoming rays; a high f -number is desirable for maximum acceptance angle. Furthermore, as the fringe density becomes high near the crack tip, the resolution of the imaging and reproduction systems limits the visibility of the fringes. The Twyman–Green interferometer has also (mm) 4
(5.58)
where are known functions of θ given in (5.10). Proper alignment of the optical system is essential in order to record these fringe patterns; typically the experimental arrangement is housed on a floating optical table in order to eliminate random vibrations. Also, the specimen surface must be polished to a high degree of flatness and reflectivity; while this may be easily accomplished in inorganic and organic glasses, it is much more difficult to achieve in metallic specimens. An excellent application of this method to the measurement of the out-of-plane deformation of a 4340 steel specimen is demonstrated by Schultheisz et al. [5.62]; an image of the fringe pattern obtained in a Twyman– Green interferometer is shown in Fig. 5.16. Note that, as one approaches the crack tip, the visibility of the fringes becomes poor. This is due to the fact that the slope of the deformed surface increases as the crack tip is approached and the numerical aperture
2
FαI β (θ)
0
–2
–4 –4
–2
0
2
4 (mm)
Fig. 5.17 Out-of-plane displacement field near a rapidly growing crack in a PMMA specimen. Stress waves radiating from the crack tip damage zone can be seen as perturbations in the fringe pattern, especially behind the crack tip. The crack speed was 0.52 mm/μs (about 0.522 Cs ) (after Pfaff et al. [5.64])
Fracture Mechanics
Crack Opening Interferometry The measurement of crack opening displacements with optical interferometry relies on the transparency of the specimen and generation of specularly reflecting fracture surfaces. The basic principle of the method, called crack opening interferometry (COI), is illustrated in Fig. 5.19. When the light rays reflected from the top
145
u3 (μm) 20 0 –20 –40 –60 –80 –100 Expt 35.0 kN FEM 35.0 kN Expt 52.3 kN FEM 52.3 kN Expt 73.5 kN FEM *73.5 kN
–120 –140 –160 –180
0
0.5
1
1.5
2 r/t
Fig. 5.18 Comparison of measured out-of-plane displacement vari-
ation along θ = 0 with a fine-mesh finite element simulation. Good comparison is obtained at the lower load levels, but the discrepancy increases significantly at higher loads (and hence larger plastic zone size) (after Schultheisz et al. [5.63])
and bottom surfaces of the crack are brought together (rays 1 and 2 in the figure), fringes of equal separation between the surfaces can be observed on the image plane. Along the crack surface, the separation distance is the crack opening displacement (COD) denoted as δ(r); the relationship between the fringe number and the Ray 1 Ray 2
y δ (r)
x
Fig. 5.19 Optical arrangement for crack opening interferometry. Rays 1 and 2 reflect from the top and bottom surfaces of the crack and interfere to form fringes of constant COD
Part A 5.6
been used successfully in dynamic fracture problems where the challenges of alignment are significant; fringe patterns captured in a dynamic experiment is shown in Fig. 5.17 [5.64]. Postprocessing was used to subtract out the initial fringe pattern revealing only the surface deformation due to the loading of the crack. Also, the region near the crack tip that is obscured due to aperture limitations has been removed during image processing. Stress waves radiating from the crack tip damage zone can be seen as perturbations in the fringe pattern, especially behind the crack tip. These are caused by the intermittency in the crack propagation process. The displacements calculated from such fringes are pure measurements in the sense that no assumptions about the deformation or stress state are imposed in obtaining the displacements from the measurements. Fitting the observed fringe patterns ahead of the crack to a prediction based on (5.58) using a least-square error method, the stress intensity factor can be determined, in the same way as discussed in Sect. 5.6.1, for the method of photoelasticity. A major difficulty in using this method arises from the fact that, while the measurements of the displacement components are themselves very accurate, the application of the plane asymptotic fields in the interpretation of the crack tip field parameters introduces significant errors, particularly when one approaches the crack tip. Therefore, such experiments may serve as verification on the limitations of models or the accuracy of more precise elastoplastic numerical simulations. Schultheisz et al. [5.63] compared the measured out-of-plane displacement ahead of the crack to a fine-mesh finite element simulation of the same problem (Fig. 5.18) and suggested that good agreement could be obtained with a proper model of the constitutive response of the material as long as the applied loads were low and three-dimensional deformation of the specimen was modeled appropriately. The last aspect is especially important in using classical interferometry since the technique provides the out-ofplane displacements only on the outer surface of the specimen.
5.6 Experimental Methods
146
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
COD can be written as nλ δ(r) = u 2 (r, π) − u 2 (r, −π) = , 2 n = 0, 1, 2, . . . ,
(5.59)
where λ is the wavelength of light used and n is the fringe order; it is assumed that the gap between the crack surfaces is filled with air and that the incidence angle of the light beam is normal to the crack surface. Thus, monitoring the fringe patterns results in a direct measurement of the COD; once again, as in the out-ofplane measurements, this is a pure measurement devoid of assumptions on the nature of the deformation and needs to be interpreted in terms of a theoretical model. The measured COD can be compared either with the elastic stress field in (5.10) or the elastic–plastic field corresponding to one of the plasticity models for extraction of the stress intensity factor or the J-integral. For example, if the crack tip deformation is governed by (5.10), then ⎧ ⎨ 8K I r plane stress E 2π . (5.60) δ(r) = 2 ⎩ 8(1−ν )K I r plane strain E 2π
Part A 5.6 Thickness (μm) In unbroken craze stress ≈ 0 for this configuration (note different scales)
2 1 0
Crack
–1 –2
Craze Fracture surface layer thickness ≈ 0.58 μm –80 –70 –60 –50 –40 –30 –20 –10
0
10
20
30
40
Length (μm)
Fig. 5.20 COI fringes for a crack-craze system in PMMA
are shown at the top. The graph indicates the variation of crack and craze opening displacement calculated from the fringe pattern (after Kambour [5.65])
Comparing the measured COD to the calculation based on the elastic field above, the stress intensity factor can be extracted. An example of the COI fringe pattern in a Dugdale–Barenblatt-type craze zone near a crack tip in a polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) specimen is shown in Fig. 5.20; the displacement profile extracted from this measurement is also shown in the figure. In this example, one can clearly see from the fringe spacing that the COD changes from concave to convex as the crack tip is approached. This corresponds to a physical crack with a craze that develops in the fracture process zone of the PMMA; note the similarity between the COD measured and the one shown in Fig. 5.9. The DB model is more appropriate for this situation; numerous investigators [5.26, 65, 66] have demonstrated that such a model can be applied to crazes. It is also possible to apply nonlinear cohesive zone models to interpret such measurements. One major advantage of COI is that variations in the crack front (three dimensionality) can be rendered visible directly; however, this method comes with big penalties: the optical arrangement is rather complicated since one has to approach the interior of the specimen and more importantly, since only normal opening is measured, effects of mixedmode loading cannot be assessed with this measurement alone. Numerous investigators have used COI to explore problems of brittle fracture [5.67–69], crazing in polymers [5.26, 65, 66], interfacial cracks [5.70], and elastic–plastic problems [5.71]. Moiré Interferometry The method of moiré interferometry is discussed in detail in Chap. 22; here a brief description of the method and its applications to fracture problems is presented. The basic principle relies on diffraction and interference. Consider a diffraction grating adhered to the specimen surface; if two incident beams strike the specimen symmetrically with respect to the normal to the surface such that the first-order diffraction from both beams is normal to the surface, then the two diffracted beams will interfere and provide uniform illumination. If the specimen deforms nonuniformly, then the two diffracted beam will, in general, contain phase differences and hence provide fringe patterns that reflect the deformation of the surface. The fringes are to be interpreted as contours of equal in-plane displacement components with the direction given by the grating used. Details of different systems for implementation of moiré interferometry are discussed by Post et al. [5.72] and are not repeated here. This method is insensitive to out-of-plane displacements near the crack tip
Fracture Mechanics
18 500 N 10 mm
5.6 Experimental Methods
147
in Sect. 5.3.2. It is striking that, while the component of strain perpendicular to the crack line matches the HRR singularity quite well, the strain parallel to the crack exhibits significant deviation. Such detailed strain measurements, obtained without a priori assumptions regarding the material or the deformation, are quite useful in outlining the limits of validity of analytical estimates. Schultheisz et al. [5.62, 63] also performed moiré interferometric experiments on a 4340 steel specimen; however, they compared the measured displacements to a fully three-dimensional finite element simulation (Fig. 5.23) and demonstrated excellent agreement with the experiments, but only for low loading levels. At higher load levels, they found that there was a significant discrepancy; this was attributed to tunneling of the crack front in the interior of the specimen and the resulting three dimensionality of the displacement field not captured in the numerical simulations.
5.6.3 Lateral Shearing Interferometry
Fig. 5.21 Moiré interferometric fringes corresponding to
displacements u 1 (upper image) and u 2 (lower image) (after Schultheisz et al. [5.62])
and hence provides a nice complement to the out-ofplane measurements through classical interferometry. Applications to quasistatic as well as dynamic loading problems in elastic, elastic–plastic, and damaging materials have been considered [5.62, 63, 72–74]. In the case of elastic problems, the interest in application of moiré interferometry is in identifying the crack tip displacement field, outlining the regions of dominance of the elastic singularity, and eventually in the extraction of the stress intensity factor. The moiré interference fringes from a fracture experiment indicating the u 1 and u 2 components of displacement are shown in Fig. 5.21. Dadkhah and Kobayashi [5.73] examined the displacement fields near a crack in a biaxially loaded Al 2024-T3 alloy specimen. Their result for a biaxiality of two is reproduced in Fig. 5.22; here the strain components evaluated from the moiré interferometric fringes are compared with an estimate based on the HRR singularity discussed
where Δs is the absolute phase angle of the components, which depends on the state of stress of the specimen at the point (x1 , x2 ); we assume that the specimen is optically isotropic. Shearing of images is
Part A 5.6
18 500 N 10 mm
The principle of shearing interferometry is very similar to other two-beam interferometric techniques; the main difference is that, rather than using a reference wavefront to interfere with the wavefront of interest, the wavefront is made to interfere with a copy of itself after introducing a predetermined, selectable, (lateral) shear displacement between the two components. Tippur et al. [5.75] developed a variant based on a diffraction grating that enabled them to examine the surface deformations near stationary and dynamically propagating cracks; they termed their implementation the coherent gradient sensor (CGS). Lee and Krishnaswamy [5.76] later introduced a simpler implementation of the experiment based on a calcite crystal; a variant of this scheme is described here. The analysis of the light propagation through Jones calculus makes the manipulations simple [5.77, 78]; see the chapter on photoelasticity for details of Jones’s calculus. The optical arrangement is shown in Fig. 5.24; a light beam polarized at an angle of π/4 with respect to the global x1 -axis passes through the stressed specimen that acts as a phase retarder. The electric vector of the light emerging from the specimen is given by −iΔs(x 1 ,x 2 ) iωt e , (5.61) E = ke e−iΔs(x1 ,x2 )
148
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Strain εx 0.01
Strain εy 0.02 θ = 0° B=2
0.008 Moire
0.006
Moire HRR – 0.93
0.01
θ = 0° B=2
– 0.5
0.004 HRR 0.002
0
0
10 20 Distance from crack tip r (mm)
0
– 0.923 0
10 20 Distance from crack tip r (mm)
Fig. 5.22 Comparison of the strain determined from moiré interferometry with calculations based on the HRR field; note that, while the normal strain ε22 compares favorably, the crack parallel strain ε11 shows significant deviation (after Dadkhah and Kobayashi [5.73])
Part A 5.6
accomplished by introducing a uniaxial optical crystal (for example, calcite) into the path of the light beam. Uniaxial crystals produce two refracted beams – the ordinary ray with a refractive index n and the extraordinary ray with a refractive index n – for each incident beam, each polarized in mutually orthogonal planes (see Born and Wolf [5.79] for a discussion of uniaxial crystals). Let the uniaxial crystal be aligned such that the ordinary ray is polarized along x1 , the extraordinary ray is polarized along the x2 -axis, and that these rays are sheared by an amount Δx1 along the x1 -axis. At every point in the field, there are now two beams: the ordinary ray that entered the specimen at the point (x1 , x2 ) and the extraordinary ray that entered the specimen at the point (x1 + Δx1 , x2 ). Thus the light beam leaving the crystal may be written as e−iΔs(x1 ,x2 ) iωt . (5.62) E = ke e−iΔs(x1 +Δx1 ,x2 ) These two components are brought together by a polarizer oriented at an angle of π/4 with respect to the global x1 -axis. The output electric vector is given by 1 −iΔs(x 1 ,x 2 ) + e−iΔs(x1 +Δx1 ,x2 ) iωt 2 e E = ke . 1 −iΔs(x 1 ,x 2 ) + e−iΔs(x1 +Δx1 ,x2 ) 2 e (5.63)
The intensity of this light beam is the time average of the electric vector E2 , averaged over a time significantly longer than the period; if the beam displacement Δx1 ,
is small, the intensity may be written as k2 Δx1 ∂Δs . cos2 I (x1 , x2 ) = 2 2 ∂x1
(5.64)
Thus, the light intensity variation observed in this optical arrangement depends on the gradients of the phase difference in the x1 -direction. In applying this method to problems in mechanics, it remains to evaluate the angular phase difference Δs; for an optically opaque specimen, if the surfaces are finished to be specularly reflecting, the phase difference is given by hν Δs = − (σ11 + σ22 ) ≡ hcr (σ11 + σ22 ) , (5.65) 2π/λ E where cr = −hν/E represents the sensitivity of the method. Therefore, bright fringes corresponding to maximum light intensity are lines in the x1 –x2 plane along which mλ ∂(σ11 + σ22 ) = , ∂x1 Δx1 with m = 0, ±1, ±2, . . . ,
hcr
(5.66)
where m is the fringe order. Therefore, fringes observed in the shearing interferometer or the coherent gradient sensor are lines of constant gradient ∂(σ11 + σ22 )/∂x1 . Obviously, by reorienting the ordinary axis of the calcite fringes representing lines crystal with the x2 -direction, of constant ∂ σ11 + σ22 /∂x2 can be obtained. A similar analysis can be performed for transparent materials, with only a slight modification in the constant cr .
Fracture Mechanics
Expt 35.0 kN FEM 35.0 kN Expt 52.3 kN FEM 52.3 kN Expt 73.5 kN FEM *73.5 kN
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
r/t
u2 (μm) 400 Expt 35.0 kN FEM 35.0 kN Expt 52.3 kN FEM 52.3 kN Expt 73.5 kN FEM *73.5 kN
350 300 250 200 150
50 0
0.25
0.5
0.75
1
1.25
1.5
r/t
Fig. 5.23 Comparison of the u 1 and u 2 displacement components determined from moiré interferometry with a fine-mesh finite element analysis. While good agreement is observed at lower load levels, a large departure is observed at the highest load (after Schultheisz et al. [5.62])
The above description of the shearing interferometer is quite general and can be applied to many problems in mechanics. Also,from (5.64), it is clear that the gradient of u 3 x1 , x2 , − h2 may be determined directly, without relating it to the plane-stress calculation of the stress component; therefore, the method can also be used to determine surface profiles of objects. Explicit equations for the light intensity can be obtained through the introduction of the asymptotic crack tip stress field in (5.9). The singular term, the higher-order terms in the steadystate asymptotic expansion, and the dynamic asymptotic field have all been used in interpreting the fringe pattern observed near stationary and dynamically growing cracks. We will describe only the quasistatic applica-
The entire analysis presented above carries over if the image shearing is introduced in the x2 -direction; in this case, the x2 gradient of the field is obtained. Simulated interference fringe patterns corresponding to the x1 gradient for assumed values of the stress intensity factors are shown in Fig. 5.25 for pure mode I and mixed-mode loading. An example of the shearing interference fringe patterns obtained in a shearing interferometer is shown in Fig. 5.26. In comparing the images in these figures, it should be noted that only the singular term in the crack tip asymptotic field has been used in the simulations, whereas the complete field will influence the patterns observed in the experiments. In the discussion above, only the singular term was introduced in the evaluation of the fringe patterns. However, since the asymptotic field is not expected to establish dominance at large distances from the crack tip where the fringe patterns are typically analyzed, higher-order nonsingular terms in the expansion in (5.9) must be introduced as we discussed in the case of photoelasticity. The stress intensity factor, K I , can be obtained at each instant in time by using a leastsquares matching of the experimentally measured fringe pattern with simulations based on (5.67). First, the experimental fringe pattern is quantified by a collection of (m i , ri , θi ), measured at M points. The distance r at which these measurements are taken should be appropriate for the application of the two-dimensional asymptotic crack tip stress field; based on the experiments of Rosakis and Ravi-Chandar [5.54], it should be recognized that the distance r must be larger than 0.5h to be away from the zone of three-dimensional deformations. Then, the sum of the squared error in (5.67) at all measured points is then given by e(A0 , A1 , . . . Ak−1 ) 2 M m i πλ − hcr g(ri , θi , A0 , A1 , . . . Ak−1 ) . = Δx2 i=1
(5.68)
In (5.68), the stress field parameters (K I , K II , . . .) are represented by the vector A = (A0 , A1 , . . . Ak−1 ) and g(r, θ, A0 , A1 , . . . Ak−1 ) is used to represent ∂(σ11 + σ22 )/∂x1 determined from the k-term description of the asymptotic crack tip stress field. Also, since
Part A 5.6
100
0
149
tion. Introducing the singular term from (5.9) into (5.66) results in the equation for bright fringes 3θ 3θ mλ hcr . (5.67) K I cos + K II sin = √ 3/2 2 2 Δx 2πr 1
u1 (μm) 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 –5
5.6 Experimental Methods
150
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Axis of polarization
*Light source
π/4 σ1 σ2 α
Polarizer
Specimen
Fast axis Image shearing crystal
π/4
x2 Polarizer
Part A 5.6
x3
x1
Fig. 5.24 Optical arrangement for lateral shearing interferometry
shearing interferometry or the coherent gradient sensing method depends on the gradient of the stress field, the constant nonsingular term σox in the asymptotic expansion does not contribute to fringe formation and cannot be determined in the analysis. The remaining a)
b)
stress field parameters must be obtained by minimizing e with respect to the parameters. The least-squared error method described in connection with photoelastic data analysis in Sect. 5.6.1 can be used here as well to a)
b)
10 mm
Fig. 5.25a,b Simulated shearing interferometric fringe patterns corresponding to the optical arrangement in Fig. 5.24 (a) K I =1 MPa m1/2 , K II =0 (b) K I =1 MPa m1/2 , K II =0.5 The field of view shown in these figures is 40 mm along one side and v/Cd = 0.1. The lack of clarity in the region near the crack tip is a numerical artifact
Fig. 5.26a,b Fringe patterns from the coherent gradient sensing (CGS) arrangement of the lateral shearing interferometer: (a) image shearing parallel to the crack line, (b) image shearing perpendicular to the crack line; the dashed lines are reconstructions based on a threeparameter crack tip field
Fracture Mechanics
evaluate the best fit coefficients A = (A0 , A1 , . . . Ak−1 ). The entire procedure carries over to the dynamic problem if the appropriate asymptotic field in (5.37) is used in (5.66). Tippur et al. [5.80] examined the applicability of the asymptotic stress field by comparing the experimentally observed fringe patterns with the analytically estimated patterns; dashed lines in Fig. 5.26 correspond to theoretical estimates based on a threeparameter fit. They concluded that measurements need to be made at a distance of about one-half of the plate thickness, reinforcing earlier results of Rosakis and Ravi-Chandar [5.54]. A complete discussion of the application of this method to quasistatic and dynamic problems is provided by Rosakis [5.81].
5.6.4 Strain Gages
x2
x'2
x'1 α
θ x1
Fig. 5.27 Location and orientation of strain gage relative to the crack tip
151
type, dimensions, and sensitivity of the strain gage are extremely important and are addressed in the chapters that deal with strain gages and are not addressed here. Dally and Berger [5.84] introduced a very simple idea for the use of strain gages in the evaluation of stress intensity factors. Consider a strain gage mounted at a point (r, θ), with the strain gage itself oriented at an angle α with respect to the global x1 -axis (Fig. 5.27); the strain gage will measure the extensional strain ε11 in the direction x1 . For the case of a stationary crack√under mode I loading, retaining up to terms of order r the strain can be evaluated to be E ε (r, θ) (1 + ν) 11 θ 1 K I (t) 3θ k cos − sin θ sin =√ cos 2α 2 2 2 2πr 3θ 1 sin 2α + A1 (k + cos 2α) + sin θ cos 2 2 √ θ + A2 r cos 12 θ k + sin2 cos 2α 2 1 (5.69) − sin θ sin 2α + . . . , 2 where k = (1 − ν)/(1 + ν). Through a proper choice of θ and α the second and third terms in (5.69) can be made to vanish; this is assured by the conditions cos 2α = −k
and
tan 12 θ = − cot 2α .
(5.70)
For a material with ν = 1/3, we get k = 1/3 and α = θ = π/3. Introducing these values in (5.69), we obtain π 3 Eε11 r, θ = (5.71) = KI . 3 8πr Thus, by placing a strain gage aligned along a line oriented at an angle θ = π/3, the measured strain can be directly related to the stress intensity factor. It should be noted that the distance r at which the strain gage is placed is still open, but this can be farther from the crack tip than the K -dominant region, since (5.71) is based on a three-term representation of the strain field. This arrangement can be used in the evaluation of dynamic initiation toughness as well. Examples of application of this method are demonstrated by Dally and Barker [5.85], who evaluated the dynamic initiation toughness of a Homalite 100 specimen at high loading rates by imposing an explosively driven stress wave on a crack. Owen et al. [5.86] determined both the dynamic initiation toughness and dynamic propa-
Part A 5.6
While optical methods yield measurements of the stress field components over the complete field of observation, they also require elaborate instrumentation. Full-field optical methods dominated fracture research in the early years of the discipline, primarily because issues related to the dominance of the various asymptotic fields could be evaluated with these schemes. On the other hand, multiple strain gages can be used more readily with simpler instrumentation requirements; this method was used very successfully by Kinra and Bowers [5.82], Shukla et al. [5.83], and many other investigators for dynamic problems. Recent progress in this area was summarized by Dally and Berger [5.84], who describe the application of strain gages to quasistatic as well as dynamic fracture problems. Here we provide a brief description as applied to dynamic problems. In general, strain gages may be placed at different positions (r, θ) to measure one or more components of the strain tensor. These measurements can be used to determine the stress intensity factors K I and K II as well as the higher-order terms by fitting the experiment in a leastsquare sense to the asymptotic fields of quasistatic or dynamic problems. Practical considerations on the
5.6 Experimental Methods
152
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 5.6
gation toughness for an aluminum 2024-T3 alloy; they found the initiation toughness to be independent of the dyn rate of loading up to K˙ I = 105 MPa m1/2 s−1 , but then to increase threefold as the rate of loading indyn creased to K˙ I = 106 Pa m1/2 s−1 . Owen et al. [5.86] also determined the dynamic propagation toughness, but using (5.71), justifying its use by the fact that the crack speeds were quite low, about 4% of the shear wave speed. For dynamically running cracks, two major errors are encountered in using (5.71); the first is due to the inertial distortion of the crack tip strain field, which is ignored in developing (5.71). While this error is likely to be small at low crack speeds, it cannot be ignored when the crack speed is high; this error can be removed completely by using the appropriate asymptotic strain field. The second, and perhaps more important, contribution to the error arises from the fact that the distance r and the orientation θ of the position of the strain gage relative to the moving crack tip are continuously changing as a result of crack growth. This must be taken into account in the analysis. Therefore, the simplification introduced in (5.71) is not appropriate and one must incorporate the additional feature that both r and θ are now functions of time, given by (5.72) r(t) = r02 + v2 t 2 − 2r0 vt cos θ0 , r0 sin θ0 θ(t) = arcsin (5.73) , r(t) a)
Specimen
Real screen
where r0 and θ0 are the distance and orientation at time t = 0. Of course, it has been assumed that the crack extension is straight along the x1 -direction. RaviChandar [5.87] used the above analysis to evaluate the measurements of Kinra and Bowers [5.82]. More recently, Berger et al. [5.88] have used measurements from multiple strain gages to set up an overdetermined system of equations and obtain improved estimates of the dynamic propagating toughness. In summary, strain-gage-based methods are just as powerful as full-field optical techniques for crack tip field characterization while at the same time requiring only minimal investment in measuring equipment. This is particularly useful in the development of standard methods of measuring the initiation, propagation, and arrest toughness.
5.6.5 Method of Caustics The method of caustics discovered by Schardin [5.38] was popular in early dynamic fracture investigations due to its simplicity, although significant inherent limitations in the method have made it a little used technique. It provides a direct measurement of the stress intensity factor and is applicable to static and dynamic problems. Here we describe the essential ingredients of the method for completeness. The principle of formation is illustrated in Fig. 5.28 for transparent and opaque specimens. Consider a parallel beam of light incident along the x3 -direction, normal b)
x2
x2 r0 (z0)
r0 (z0) x3
D
Crack front
S1
Virtual screen
Specimen
x3
D
Crack front
S2 z0
z0
Fig. 5.28a,b Schematic illustration of the principle of formation of the caustic curve: (a) transmission arrangement for transparent specimens, (b) reflection arrangement for opaque specimens
Fracture Mechanics
a)
153
b)
D
Dmin Dmax
Fig. 5.29a,b Simulated bitmap image of caustics. The field of view represents a square, 20 mm along one side. (a) K I = 1 MPa m1/2 , K II = 0; (b) K I = 1 MPa m1/2 , K II = 1 MPa m1/2
determined. For mixed-mode loading conditions, the variation of the stress intensity factor with time may be obtained by measuring two length dimensions: Dmax and Dmin . The ratio (Dmax − Dmin )/Dmax depends only on μ; this dependence is shown in Fig. 5.30a. Therefore, μ can be determined first from the measurements of Dmax and Dmin and then K I and K II are determined from the following: √ 3 2 2π Dmax 2 , (5.75) KI = 2ct hz 0 F(v) g(μ) K II = μK I .
(5.76)
The function g(μ) is shown in Fig. 5.30b. While the method has been used by a number of investigators in evaluating mixed-mode stress intensity factors in quasistatic problems, dynamically growing cracks typically follow a locally mode I path and hence there are very few examples of the evaluation of the mixed-mode stress intensity factors. Examples of the application of the method of caustics to dynamic problems may be found in the papers by Kalthoff [5.89], Ravi-Chandar and Knauss [5.41, 90, 91], and Rosakis et al. [5.43].
5.6.6 Measurement of Crack Opening Displacement While the COI discussed before provides an accurate measurement of the crack opening displacement, it has two major limitations: first, it requires a transparent specimen with a complicated optical arrangement, and second, significant postprocessing of fringe data is needed in order to extract the crack opening. In many practical applications, specimens are opaque and hence one needs other means of measuring the COD. In industrial practice, methods based on replica techniques
Part A 5.6
to the specimen free surface. In a transparent material a light ray passing through a stressed plate is deviated from its path partly due to thickness variation generated by the deformation and partly due to the change in refractive index caused by stress-induced birefringence. In an opaque material, the light ray reflects with a deviation from parallelism dictated by the local slope or equivalently the thickness change. If the plate contains a crack, the rays are deviated from the region around the crack tip and these form a singular curve called a caustic on a reference plane at some distance away from the specimen. The size of the caustic curve can be related to the stress intensity factor by introducing an analysis based on geometrical optics and fracture mechanics. This analysis is described in detail in many references [5.81]; we provide just the final results. As can be seen from the illustration in Fig. 5.28, far away from the crack tip, the light rays pass through the transparent specimen and maintain their parallel propagation; the influence of the stress field on the wavefront is small enough to be neglected. On the other hand, in the region near the crack tip, where the specimen exhibits a concave surface due to the Poisson contraction, the light rays deviate significantly from parallelism. As a result, a dark region called the shadowspot forms on the screen at z 0 , where there are no light rays at all. This shadow region is surrounded by a bright curve, called the caustic curve. The line on the specimen plane whose image is the caustic curve on the specimen is called the initial curve. Light rays from outside the initial curve fall outside the caustic; rays from inside the initial curve fall on or outside the caustic curve and rays from the initial curve fall on the caustic curve. Hence the caustic curve is a bright curve that surrounds the dark region. Figure 5.29 shows simulated caustics corresponding to mode I and mixed-mode loading. For mode I loading, the transverse diameter is related to the stress intensity factor through the following relation: √ 3 2 2π D 2 , (5.74) KI = 2cp hz 0 F(v) 3.17 where h is the plate thickness, z 0 is the distance between the midplane and the screen, and specimen F(v) = 2 1 + αs2 αd2 − αs2 /R(v) is a correction factor for a crack propagating dynamically at a speed v, cp = −ν/E for opaque specimens and cp = c − (n − 1)ν/E for transparent specimens, where c is the direct stress-optic coefficient of the material. Thus, from measurements of the transverse diameter of the caustic curve, the dynamic stress intensity factor can be
5.6 Experimental Methods
154
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a) (Dmax -Dmin )/Dmax
b) Numerical factor g
0.5
4
0.4
3
0.3 2 0.2 1
0.1 0
0
1
2
3
4 5 6 7 8 ∞ Stress intensity factor ratio µ = KII /KI
0
0
1
2 3 4 5 Stress intensity factor ratio µ = KII /KI
Fig. 5.30 (a) Relationship between the caustic dimensions and the mixed-mode μ (b) g(u) versus μ (after Kalthoff [5.52])
Part A 5.6
or clip gages are commonly used. Replica techniques are quite clumsy; they require that a soft polymer be inserted into the crack under load, cured in-place, and then extracted by breaking the specimen. This replica is then characterized to determine the crack opening displacement. A crucial factor in determining the reliability of this method is the uncertainty associated with the flow of the viscous polymer into the crack opening before curing begins; while the replica technique remains a powerful tool in determining metallographic aspects of fracture, is not a very good quantitative tool for precise COD measurements. Clip gages are more reliably used in such applications; these rely on two flexible beam elements, inserted into the crack along the load line, with strain gages attached on them. Opening of the crack results in variations in the bending strains that are then calibrated in terms of the opening of the crack. Many commercial devices suitable a)
b)
A
c)
α d
Fig. 5.31 (a) Vickers indents on the specimen surface 100 μm apart. (b) Optical arrangement for the interferometric strain/displacement gage. (c) Pattern of light observed, indicating the triangular outline
and the interference fringes
for different environmental conditions (high temperature, etc.) are available and therefore clip gage methods are not reviewed here. An optical technique developed by Sharpe [5.92, 93] called the interferometric strain/displacement gage (ISDG) is quite versatile and can be applied in static and dynamic applications and in different environments. We describe the basic principles and capabilities of this technique. The ISDG takes advantage of two-beam interference just as other classical interferometric techniques discussed in Sect. 5.6.2, with the exception that, instead of attempting full-field measurement, reflections from two points on the specimen are considered. In the simplest implementation of the method, two small microindentations are made on the specimen with a pyramidal Vickers indentor; typically the indents are about 10–20 μm long and are spaced about 100 μm apart (Fig. 5.31a), and the reflections from these two points are made to interfere. The two indents could be placed across the crack line if COD is to be measured at that location; they can also be placed anywhere where the local strain is to be measured. If a light beam impinges on these two indents at normal incidence to the nominal surface, the reflected beams from each face of the pyramidal indent will overlap and generate interference fringes in space; the beam diffraction from the indents ensures that overlap of the two beams occurs. This is a variant of the Fresnel mirror arrangement and can be viewed as equivalent to Young’s two-slit interference scheme [5.79]. The scheme is illustrated in Fig. 5.31b; to an observer at point A, the light beams reflected from the two pyramidal faces of the indent ap-
Fracture Mechanics
pear as two slits separated by a distance d sin α. The fringe formation condition for the Young’s two-slit interference scheme is sd sin α = m Lλ ,
m = 0, ±1, ±2, . . . ,
(5.77)
5.6.7 Measurement of Crack Position and Speed Measurements of crack tip position and speed are often required in order to analyze the fracture problem. Different electrical resistance methods have been used to determine the crack position and speed. The two most popular techniques are the resistive grid and potential drop methods. In the grid method a number of electrical wires are laid across the path of the crack. As the crack propagates, it severs the wires sequentially and provides an electrical signal which can then be used to determine the crack position and speed with time (see, for example, Dulaney and Brace [5.94] and Paxson and Lucas [5.95]). Commercial suppliers of strain gages now provide such grids for crack speed measurements; these grids can be incorporated into standard strain gage bridge circuits to provide the history of wire breakage and hence the crack position as a function of time. While very good estimates of the crack speed can be obtained from such grid techniques, the discrete nature
of the grids dictate that the sampling rate of the crack speed will typically be much lower than that obtained using other methods. In contrast to this discrete measurement, if the change in resistance of a conducting specimen is measured as a function of crack length, then the crack length can be inferred at very high spatial and temporal resolution; this is the basis of the potential drop technique. The method can be used even in nonconducting materials, provided that a thin conducting film is deposited on the surface of the specimen. Carlsson et al. [5.96] demonstrated the application of this method to the measurement of crack speed in PMMA; they used a voltage divider circuit to measure the resistance change. Many other investigators have used this method to determine the speed of running cracks [5.97, 98]. Commercial versions of this technique – such as the KrakGageTM – are now available; it is also quite easily accomplished in the laboratory with thin-film coating methods. ASTM guidelines have also been established for measurement of crack position during fatigue crack growth characterization (ASTM E 647). A review of the method can be found in Wilkowski and Maxey [5.99]. A simple arrangement of the method is shown in Fig. 5.32. The specimen or the conducting coating on the specimen is connected to one arm of a Wheatstone bridge as indicated and balanced initially to give a null output; as the crack length increases, the change in resistance of this segment of the bridge circuit results in an output voltage from the bridge. The relationship between this voltage output and the crack length can be obtained through direct calibration or by calculating the electric field numerically for the particular specimen geometry (see Bonamy and Ravi-Chandar [5.100] for a recent application). Analytical and numerical solutions are available for a number of specimen geometries (see the ASTM E 647 standard for references). Both direct- (DC) and alternating-current (AC) excitation and V0 R1
Ra
Vbat Rb
Fig. 5.32 Potential drop technique for measurement of crack tip position
155
Part A 5.6
where s is the distance between fringes, m is the fringe order, λ is the wavelength of light, and L is the distance between the plane of the indents and the plane of observation. The pyramidal shape of the surface of the indent dictates that the light beam emerging from the surface is triangular as well (Fig. 5.31c). Diffraction effects dictate that the reflected beams will acquire a small divergence angle. It is clear from (5.77) that the distance between the fringes will increase as one moves away from the specimen plane (as L increases). However, in the implementation of ISDG, L is fixed and changes in the spacing between the indents Δd cause changes in the fringe spacing. If these changes are monitored with a photosensor, the movement of the fringes over the sensor yields sinusoidal variations in the intensity at a fixed point. High-resolution data can be captured by measuring the intensity variations with a photosensor array and interpreted in terms of fractional fringe orders. Displacement resolutions on the order of 5 nm can be achieved with this kind of displacement gage. The method is suitable for static and dynamic applications, as well as high-temperature applications. Details of the implementation of the method are described in Sharpe [5.92, 93].
5.6 Experimental Methods
156
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
constant-voltage or constant-current excitation can be used; however, for high-speed cracks, it is preferable to use constant-voltage DC excitation. In fatigue applications, this method is used to determine crack position
to within a resolution of a few micrometers. In dynamic applications, where the crack speed may be in the range of 500–1500 m/s, the speed can be determined to within a few tens of m/s.
References 5.1
5.2
5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6
5.7 5.8 5.9
Part A 5
5.10
5.11
5.12
5.13
5.14
5.15 5.16
A.A. Griffith: The phenomena of rupture and flow in solids, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A221, 163–198 (1920) G.R. Irwin: Analysis of stresses and strains near the end of a crack traversing a plate, J. Appl. Mech. 24, 361–364 (1957) G.R. Irwin: Plastic zone near a crack and fracture toughness, Sagamore Res. Conf. Proc., Vol. 4 (1961) E. Orowan: Fracture and Strength of Solids (Rep. Progr. Phys.) 185 (1948) J.W. Obreimoff: The splitting strength of mica, Proc. R. Soc. London A 127, 290–297 (1930) C.E. Inglis: Stresses in a plate due to the presence of cracks and sharp corners, Proc. Inst. Naval Architect. 55, 219–241 (1913) N.I. Mushkhelishvili: Some Basic Problems in the Theory of Elasticity (Noordhoff, Leiden 1953) M.L. Williams: On the stress distribution at the base of a stationary crack, J. Appl. Mech. 24, 109–114 (1957) A.S. Kobayashi: Linear elastic fracture mechanics. In: Computational Methods in the Mechanics of Fracture, ed. by S.N. Atluri (North Holland, Amsterdam 1986) pp. 21–53 J.D. Eshelby: The determination of the elastic field of an ellipsoidal inclusion and related problems, Proc. R. Soc. London A241, 376–396 (1957) G.P. Cherepanov: Crack propagation in continuous media, J. Appl. Math. Mech. 31, 503–512 (1967), English translation of Prikladnaya Mathematica i Mechanika 31, 476–488 (1967) J.R. Rice: A path independent integral and the approximate analysis of strain concentration by notches and cracks, J. Appl. Mech. 35, 379–386 (1968) J.K. Knowles, E. Sternberg: On a class of conservation laws in linearized and finite elastostatics, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 44, 187–211 (1972) G.I. Barenblatt: Concerning equilibrium cracks forming during brittle fracture: the stability of isolated cracks, relationship with energetic theories, Appl. Math. Mech. 23, 1273–1282 (1959), English translation of PMM 23, 893–900 (1959) D.S. Dugdale: Yielding of steel sheets containing slits, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 8, 100–104 (1960) W.G. Knauss: On the steady propagation of a crack in a viscoelastic sheet: Experiments and analysis. In: Deformation and Fracture in High Polymers, ed. by H.H. Kausch (Plenum, New York 1974) pp. 501–541
5.17
5.18
5.19
5.20
5.21
5.22 5.23
5.24
5.25
5.26 5.27 5.28
5.29
5.30
5.31
5.32
R.A. Schapery: A theory of crack initiation and growth in viscoelastic media. I. Theoretical development, Int. J. Fract. 11, 141–159 (1975) A. Hillerborg, M. Modeer, P.E. Peterson: Analysis of crack formation and crack growth in concrete by means of fracture mechanics and finite elements, Cem. Concr. Res. 6, 773–782 (1976) X. Gao, J. Kaleskog, C.F. Shih, R.H. Dodds: Ductile tearing in part-through cracks: Experiments and cell-model predictions, Eng. Fract. Mech. 59, 761–777 (1998) J.W. Hutchinson: Singular behavior at the end of a tensile crack tip in a hardening materials, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 16, 13–31 (1968) J.R. Rice, G.F. Rosengren: Plane strain deformation near a crack tip in a power-law hardening material, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 16, 1–12 (1968) M.F. Kanninen, C.H. Popelar: Introduction to Fracture Mechanics (Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford 1985) Z.-Z. Du, J.W. Hancock: The effect of non-singular stresses on crack-tip constraint, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 39, 555–567 (1991) N.O. O’Dowd, C.F. Shih: Two-parameter fracture mechanics: Theory and applications. In: Fracture Mechanics, ASTM STP 1207, 21–47 (1994) A. Zahoor: Ductile Fracture Handbook, Circumferential Throughwall Cracks, Vol. 1 (EPRI Rep. NP-6301-D, Palo Alto 1989) E. Kramer: Microscopic and molecular fundamental of crazing, Adv. Polymer Sci. 52/53, 105–167 (1983) A. Carpinteri: Mechanical Damage and Crack Growth in Concrete (Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht 1986) A. Needleman: A continuum model for void nucleation by inclusion debonding, J. Appl. Mech. 54, 525–531 (1987) X.-P. Xu, A. Needleman: Numerical simulations of fast crack growth in brittle solids, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 42, 1397–1434 (1994) B. Yang, K. Ravi-Chandar: On the role of the process zone in dynamic fracture, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 44, 1955–1976 (1994) M. Ortiz, A. Pandolfi: Finite-deformation irreversible cohesive elements for three-dimensional crack propagation analysis, Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 44, 1267–1282 (1999) P.H. Geubelle, J.R. Rice: A spectral method for threedimensional elastodynamic fracture problems, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 43, 1791–1824 (1995)
Fracture Mechanics
5.33
5.34
5.35
5.36 5.37 5.38 5.39 5.40
5.41
5.42
5.43
5.45 5.46 5.47 5.48 5.49 5.50 5.51 5.52
5.53
5.54
5.55
5.56
5.57
5.58
5.59
5.60 5.61
5.62
5.63
5.64
5.65
5.66
5.67
5.68
5.69
5.70
dimensional effects, Int. J. Solids Struct. 22, 121–134 (1986) R.V. Mahajan, K. Ravi-Chandar: Experimental determination of stress intensity factors using caustics and photoelasticity, Exp. Mech. 29, 6–11 (1989) W.H. Press, S.A. Teukolsky, W.T. Vettering, B.P. Flannery: Numerical recipes in C; The art of scientific computing, 2nd ed (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1992) A.A. Wells, D. Post: The dynamic stress distribution surrounding a running crack – A photoelastic analysis, Proc. Soc. Exp. Stress Anal. 16, 69–92 (1958) A.S. Kobayashi, B.G. Wade, W.B. Bradley: Fracture dynamics of Homalite-100. In: Deformation and Fracture of High Polymers, ed. by H.H. Hausch (Plenum, New York 1973) pp. 487–500 G.R. Irwin, J.W. Dally, T. Kobayashi, W.L. Fourney, M.J. Etheridge, H.P. Rossmanith: Determination of · the a–K relationship for birefringent polymers, Exp. Mech. 19, 121–129 (1979) J.W. Dally: Dynamic photoelastic studies of fracture, Exp. Mech. 19, 349–361 (1979) W.B. Bradley, A.S. Kobayashi: Fracture dynamics – A photoelastic investigation, Eng. Fract. Mech. 3, 317– 332 (1971) C. Schultheisz, R. Pfaff, W.G. Knauss: An experimental/analytical comparison of three-dimensional deformations at the tip of a crack in a plastically deforming plate, I. Optical interferometry and experimental preliminaries, Int. J. Fract. 90, 1–25 (1998) C. Schultheisz, R. Pfaff, W.G. Knauss: An experimental/analytical comparison of three-dimensional deformations at the tip of a crack in a plastically deforming plate, III: Comparison of numerical and experimental results, Int. J. Fract. 90, 47–81 (1998) R.D. Pfaff, P.D. Washabaugh, W.G. Knauss: An interpretation of Twyman-Green interferograms from static and dynamic fracture experiments, Int. J. Solids Struct. 32, 939–956 (1995) R.P. Kambour: Mechanism of fracture in glassy polymers. III. Direct observation of the craze ahead of the propagating crack in polymethylmethacrylate and polystyrene, Part A, J. Polym. Sci. 2(4), 349–358 (1975) W. Döll: Optical interference measurements and fracture mechanics analysis of crack tip craze zones, Adv. Polym. Sci. 52/53, 105–167 (1983) E. Sommer: An optical method for determining the crack-tip stress intensity factor, Eng. Fract. Mech. 1, 705–718 (1970) P.B. Crosley, S. Mostovoy, E.J. Ripling: An optical – interference method for experimental analysis of cracked structures, Eng. Fract. Mech. 3, 421–433 (1971) E. Sommer, U. Soltéz: Crack-opening-displacement mesurements of a dynamically loaded crack, Eng. Fract. Mech. 2, 235–241 (1971) K.M. Liechti, W.G. Knauss: Crack propagation at material interfaces: I. Experimental technique to
157
Part A 5
5.44
M.L. Falk, A. Needleman, J.R. Rice: A critical evaluation of cohesive zone models of dynamic fracture, J. Phys. IV 11, 43–50 (2001) V. Tvergaard, A. Needleman: Analysis of cup-cone fracture in a round tensile bar, Acta Metall. 32, 157– 169 (1984) C.C. Chu, A. Needleman: Void nucleation effects in biaxially stretched sheets, J. Eng. Mater. Technol. 102, 249–258 (1980) L.B. Freund: Dynamic Fracture Mechanics (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1990) K. Ravi-Chandar: Dynamic Fracture (Elsevier, Amsterdam 2004) H. Schardin: Velocity effects in fracture. In: Fracture, ed. by A. Verbach (Wiley, New York 1959) pp. 297–330 A.S. Kobayashi, S. Mall: Dynamic fracture toughness of Homalite-100, Exp. Mech. 18, 11–18 (1978) J.F. Kalthoff: On some current problems in experimental fracture dynamics. In: The proceedings of the NSF-ARO Workshop on Dynamic Fracture. ed. by W.G. Knauss, K. Ravi-Chandar, A.J. Rosakis (1983) K. Ravi-Chandar, W.G. Knauss: An experimental investigation into dynamic fracture -IV. On the interaction of stress waves with propagating cracks, Int. J. Fract. 26, 189–200 (1984) K. Arakawa, K. Takahashi: Relationship between fracture parameters and surface roughness of brittle polymers, Int. J. Fract. 48, 103–114 (1991) A.J. Rosakis, J. Duffy, L.B. Freund: The determination of dynamic fracture toughness of AISI 4340 steel by the shadow spot method, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 32, 443–460 (1984) S. Suresh: Fatigue of Materials (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1991) J. Schijve: Fatigue of Structures and Materials (Kluwer, Dordrecht 2001) H. Riedel: Fracture at High Temperature (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1987) B. Lawn: Fracture of Brittle Solids, 2nd edn. (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1995) A.S. Kobayashi (Ed.): Experimental Techniques in Fracture Mechanics, Vol. 1 (VCH, Weinheim 1973) A.S. Kobayashi (Ed.): Experimental Techniques in Fracture Mechanics, Vol. 2 (VCH, Weinheim 1975) J.S. Epstein (Ed.): Experimental Techniques in Fracture (VCH, Weinheim 1993) J.W. Dally, W.F. Riley: Experimental Stress Analysis, 2nd Ed (McGraw Hill, New York 1978) J.F. Kalthoff: Shadow optical method of caustics. In: Handbook of Experimental Mechanics, ed. by A.S. Kobayashi (Prentice Hall, New York 1987) pp. 430–498 C. Taudou, S.V. Potti, K. Ravi-Chandar: On the dominance of the singular dynamic crack tip stress field under high rate loading, Int. J. Fract. 56, 41–59 (1992) A.J. Rosakis, K. Ravi-Chandar: On crack tip stress state: An experimental evaluation of three-
References
158
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
5.71
5.72 5.73
5.74
5.75
5.76
5.77
5.78
5.79
Part A 5
5.80
5.81
5.82
5.83
5.84
5.85
determine crack profiles, Exp. Mech. 22, 383–391 (1982) K.M. Liechti, Y.-S. Chai: Biaxial loading experiments for determining interfacial fracture toughness, J. Appl. Mech. 58, 680–688 (1991) D. Post, B. Han, P. Ifju: High Sensitivity Moiré (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1994) M.S. Dadkhah, A.S. Kobayashi: HRR field of a moving crack: An experimental analysis, Eng. Fract. Mech. 34, 253–262 (1989) J.S. Epstein, M.S. Dadkhah: Moiré interferometry in fracture research. In: Experimental Techniques in Fracture,, ed. by J.S. Epstein (Wiley VCH, Weinheim 1993) pp. 427–508 H.V. Tippur, S. Krishnaswamy, A.J. Rosakis: A coherent gradient sensor for crack tip deformation measurements: Analysis and experimental results, Int. J. Fract. 48, 193–204 (1990) H. Lee, S. Krishnaswamy: A compact polariscope/shearing interferometer for mapping stress fields in bimaterial systems, Exp. Mech. 36, 404–411 (1996) R.C. Jones: A new calculus for the treatment of optical systems Part I, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 31, 488–493 (1941) R.C. Jones: A new calculus for the treatment of optical systems, Part II, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 31, 493–499 (1941) M. Born, E. Wolf: Principles of Optics, 7th Ed (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1999) H.V. Tippur, S. Krishnaswamy, A.J. Rosakis: Optical mapping of crack tip deformations using the method of transmission and reflection coherent gradient sensing: a study of the crack tip K-dominance, Int. J. Fract. 52, 91–117 (1991) A.J. Rosakis: Two optical techniques sensitive to the gradients of optical path difference: The method of caustics and the coherent gradient sensor. In: Experimental Techniques in Fracture, Vol. III, ed. by J.S. Epstein (VCH, Weinheim 1993) pp. 327–425 V.K. Kinra, C.L. Bowers: Brittle fracture of plates in tension. Stress field near the crack, Int. J. Solids Struct. 17, 175 (1981) A. Shukla, R.K. Agarwal, H. Nigam: Dynamic fracture studies on 7075-T6 aluminum and 4340 steel using strain gages and photoelastic coatings, Eng. Fract. Mech. 31, 501–515 (1989) J.W. Dally, J.R. Berger: The role of the electrical resistance strain gage in fracture research. In: Experimental Techniques in Fracture, ed. by J.S. Epstein (Wiley VCH, Weinheim 1993) pp. 1–39 J.W. Dally, D.B. Barker: Dynamic measurements of initiation toughness at high loading rates, Exp. Mech. 28, 298–303 (1988)
5.86
D.M. Owen, S. Zhuang, A.J. Rosakis, G. Ravichandran: Experimental determination of dynamic initiation and propagation fracture toughness in thin aluminum sheets, Int. J. Fract. 90, 153–174 (1998) 5.87 K. Ravi-Chandar: A note on the dynamic stress field near a propagating crack, Int. J. Solids Struct. 19, 839–841 (1983) 5.88 J.R. Berger, J.W. Dally, R.J. Sanford: Determining the dynamic stress intensity factor with strain gages using a crack tip locating algorithm, Eng. Fract. Mech. 36, 145–156 (1990) 5.89 J.F. Kalthoff: On the measurement of dynamic fracture toughness – a review of recent work, Int. J. Fract. 27, 277–298 (1985) 5.90 K. Ravi-Chandar, W.G. Knauss: An experimental investigation into dynamic fracture - I. Crack initiation and crack arrest, Int. J. Fract. 25, 247–262 (1984) 5.91 K. Ravi-Chandar, W.G. Knauss: An experimental investigation into dynamic fracture – III. On steady state crack propagation and branching, Int. J. Fract. 26, 141–154 (1984) 5.92 W.N. Sharpe Jr.: An interferometric strain/displacement measuring system, NASA Tech. Memo. 101638 (1989) 5.93 W.N. Sharpe Jr.: Crack-tip opening displacement measurement techniques. In: Experimental Techniques in Fracture, Vol. III, ed. by J.S. Epstein (VCH, Weinheim 1993) pp. 219–252 5.94 E.N. Dulaney, W.F. Brace: Velocity behavior of a growing crack, J. Appl. Phys. 31, 2233–2236 (1960) 5.95 T.L. Paxson, R.A. Lucas: An investigation of the velocity characteristics of a fixed boundary fracture model. In: Dynamic Crack Propagation, ed. by G.C. Sih (Noordhoff, Leiden 1973) pp. 415–426 5.96 J. Carlsson, L. Dahlberg, F. Nilsson: Experimental studies of the unstable phase of crack propagation in metals and polymers. In: Dynamic Crack Propagation, ed. by G.C. Sih (Noordhoff International, Leyden 1973) pp. 165–181 5.97 B. Stalder, P. Beguelin, H.H. Kausch: A simple velocity gauge for measuring crack growth, Int. J. Fract. 22, R47–R54 (1983) 5.98 J. Fineberg, S.P. Gross, M. Marder, H.L. Swinney: Instability in dynamic fracture, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 457–460 (1991) 5.99 G.M. Wilkowski, W.A. Maxey: Review and applications of the electric potential method for measuring crack growth in specimens, flawed pipes and pressure vessels, ASTM STP 791, II266–II294 (1983) 5.100 D. Bonamy, K. Ravi-Chandar: Dynamic crack response to a localized shear pulse perturbation in brittle amorphous materials: On crack surface roughening, Int. J. Fract. 134, 1–22 (2005)
159
Active Materi 6. Active Materials
Guruswami Ravichandran
This chapter provides a brief overview of the mechanics of active materials, particularly those which respond to electro/magnetic/mechanical loading. The relative competition between mechanical and electro/magnetic loading, leading to interesting actuation mechanisms, has been highlighted. Key references provided within this chapter should be referred to for further details on the theoretical development and their application to experiments.
6.1
Background ......................................... 159 6.1.1 Mechanisms of Active Materials........................ 160
6.1.2 Mechanics in the Analysis, Design, and Testing of Active Devices ......... 160 6.2
Piezoelectrics ....................................... 161
6.3 Ferroelectrics ....................................... 6.3.1 Electrostriction............................. 6.3.2 Theory ........................................ 6.3.3 Domain Patterns .......................... 6.3.4 Ceramics .....................................
162 162 163 163 165
6.4 Ferromagnets....................................... 166 6.4.1 Theory ........................................ 166 6.4.2 Magnetostriction .......................... 167 References .................................................. 167
6.1 Background shown in Fig. 6.1 [6.1]. Active materials are widely used as sensors and actuators, including vibration damping, Work per volume (J/m3) 108
Experimental Theoretical
Shape memory alloy
7
10
Solid–liquid
106
Fatigued SMA
Thermopneumatic
Ferroelectric EM ES
Thermal expansion
105
PZT
Electromagnetic (EM)
104 Muscle Electrostatic (ES) EM
103 102 0 10
ES Microbubble
101
102
103
ZnO
104 105 106 107 Cycling frequency (Hz)
Fig. 6.1 Characteristics of common actuator systems (after
Krulevitch et al. [6.1])
Part A 6
Active materials in the context of mechanical applications are those that respond by changing shape to external stimuli such as electro/magnetic-mechanical loading, which is in general reversible in nature. The change in shape results in mechanical sensing and actuation that can be exploited in a variety of ways for practical applications. The mechanics of actuation depends on a wide range of mechanisms, which generally depend on some form of phase transition or motion of phase boundaries under external stimuli. There are also active materials which respond to thermomechanical loading such as shape-memory alloys, which are not discussed here. This chapter is confined to materials which respond to electro/magnetic-mechanical loading such as piezoelectric, ferroelectric, and ferromagnetic solids. A common feature of these materials is that cyclic actuation takes place, often accompanied by hysteresis. The common figures of merit used to characterize actuator performance are the work/unit volume and the cycling frequency. The characteristics of common actuator materials/systems in this parameter space are
160
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
micro/nanopositioning, ultrasonics, sonar, fuel injection, robotics, adaptive optics, active deformable structures, and micro-electromechanical systems (MEMS) devices such as micropumps and surgical tools.
a)
ε E
E
6.1.1 Mechanisms of Active Materials The mechanics of actuation for most solid-state active materials depend on one or a combination of the following effects, illustrated in Fig. 6.2a–c.
•
•
•
Piezoelectric effect (Fig. 6.2a) is a linear phenomenon in which the mechanical displacement (strain ε) is proportional to the applied field or voltage (E) and the sign of the displacement depends on the sign of the applied field. Electrostriction (Fig. 6.2b) is generally observed in dielectrics and most prominent in single-crystal ferroelectrics and ferroelectric polymers, where the displacement (strain ε) or actuation is a function of the square of the applied voltage (E) and hence the displacement is independent of the sign of the applied voltage. Magnetostriction (Fig. 6.2c) is similar to electrostriction except that the applied field is magnetic in nature, which is most common in ferromagnetic solids. The displacement (strain ε) in single-crystal magnetostrictive material is proportional to the square of the magnetic field (H).
b)
ε ±E E
c)
ε ±H H
Fig. 6.2 (a) Piezoelectricity described by the converse piezoelectric effect is a linear relationship between strain (ε) and applied electric field (E). (b) Electrostriction is a quadratic relationship between strain (ε) and electric field (E), or more generally, an electric-field-induced deformation that is independent of field polarity. (c) Magnetostriction is a quadratic relationship between strain (ε) and the applied magnetic field (H), or more generally, a magnetic-field-induced deformation that is independent of field polarity
Part A 6.1
trasonics, linear and rotary micropositioning devices, and sonar. Potential applications include microrobotics, active surgical tools, adaptive optics, and miniaturized actuators. The problems associated with active materials are multi-physics in nature and involve solving coupled boundary value problems. 6.1.2 Mechanics in the Analysis, Design, The formulation of boundary value problems in and Testing of Active Devices solid mechanics and the solution techniques have been discussed in Chap. 1 and will not be revisited here The quest for the design and analysis of efficient except to restate some of the governing equations inand compact devices for actuation in the form of volving linearized theory and the appropriate boundary micro/nano-electromechanical systems (MEMS/NEMS) conditions. The active materials of interest may undergo places considerable demands on the choice of mater- large deformations at the microstructural scale due ials, processing, and mechanics of actuation. Most of to various phase transformations (reorientation of unit the current applications of actuators except for a few cells); the macroscopic deformations generally do not specialized applications use piezoelectric materials. exceed a few percentage (ranging from 0.2% for piezoA detailed understanding of the various mechanisms electric, 1–6.5% for single-crystal ferroelectrics, and and mechanics of actuation in active materials will pave ≈ 0.1% for single-crystal magnetostrictive solids). Linthe way for the design of new actuation devices, ad- earized theory of elasticity is used throughout, which vancing further application of this promising class of suffices for most experimental design and applications. materials and other emerging multiferroic materials. Appropriate references for provided for readers who The current applications of these materials include ul- are interested in using rigorous large-strain (finiteThough the electrostrictive and magentostrictive effects are most evident in single-crystal materials, they also play an important role in polycrystalline solids, where these effects are influenced by the texture (orientation) of the various crystals in the solid.
Active Materials
deformation) formulations. For the basic notions of materials science such as the unit cell, crystallography, and texture, the reader is referred to Chap. 2. The parameters of interest in solid mechanics for the active materials (occupying a volume V , with surface denoted by S) include the Cauchy stress tensor (σ), the small-strain tensor ε(εij = 12 (u i, j + u j,i )), and the strain energy density W. The materials are assumed to be linearly elastic solids characterized by the fourth-order elastic moduli tensor C. The Cauchy stress is related to the strain through the elastic moduli σij = Cijkl εkl . The mechanical equilibrium of the stress state is governed by the following field equation σij, j + ρ0 bi = 0 in V .
(6.1)
The boundary conditions are characterized by the prescribed traction (force) vector (t 0 ) on S2 and/or the displacement vector (u0 ) on S1 . The traction on a surface is related to the stress through the Cauchy relation, t i = σij n j , where n is the unit outward normal to the surface. ρ0 is the mass density and b is the body force per unit mass.
6.2 Piezoelectrics
161
The parameters of interest in the electromechanics of solids include the polarization ( p) and the electrostatic potential (φ). The governing equation for the electrostatic potential is expressed by Gauss’s equation ∇ · (−ε0 ∇φ + p) = 0 in V ,
(6.2)
where ε0 is the permittivity. The boundary conditions on the electrostrictive solid are characterized by the conductors in the form of the electric field on the electrodes (∇φ = 0 on C1 ), including the ground ( S ∂φ ∂n dS = 0 and φ = 0 on C2 ). The parameters of interest in the magnetomechanics of solids include the magnetization (m) and the induced magnetic field (H). The governing equations are given by ∇ × H = 0,
∇ · (H + 4πm) = 0 in V ,
(6.3)
An important aspect of electro(magnetic) active materials is that the electro(magnetic) field permeates the space (R3 ) surrounding the body that is polarized (magnetized).
6.2 Piezoelectrics
Di = dijk σ jk ,
(6.4)
where σ is the stress tensor and D is the electric displacement vector, which is related to the polarization p according to Di = pi + ε0 E i ,
(6.5)
where E is the electric field vector [6.3]. For materials with large spontaneous polarizations, such as ferroelectrics, the electric displacement is approximately equal to the polarization (D ≈ p). For actuators, a more common representation of piezoelectricity is the converse piezoelectric effect. This is a linear relationship between strain and electric field, as shown in Fig. 6.1a and in the following equation at constant stress, eij = dijk E k ,
(6.6)
where e is the strain tensor and d is the same as in (6.4). These relationships are often expressed in matrix notation as Di = dij σ j , e j = dij E i , σ j = sij E i ,
(6.7) (6.8) (6.9)
where s is the matrix of piezoelectric stress constants [6.2, 3]. The parameters commonly used to characterize the piezoelectric effect are the constants d3i (in particular, d33 ), which are measures of the coupling between the applied voltage and the resultant strain in the specimen.
Part A 6.2
Piezoelectricity is a property of ferroelectric materials, as well as many non-ferroelectric crystals, such as quartz, whose crystal structure satisfy certain symmetry criteria [6.2]. It also exists in certain ceramic materials that either have a suitable texture or exhibit a net spontaneous polarization. The most common piezoelectric materials which are widely used in applications include lead zirconate titanate (PZT, Pb(Zr,Ti)O3 ) and lead lanthanum zirconate titanate (PLZT, Pb(La,Zr,Ti)O3 ). Many polymers such as polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) and its copolymers with trifluoroethylene (TrFE) and tetrafluoroethylene (TFE) also exhibit the piezoelectric effect. The typical strain achievable in the common piezoelectric solids is in the range of 0.1–0.2%. The direct piezoelectric effect is defined as a linear relationship between stress and electric displacement or charge per unit area,
162
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
6.3 Ferroelectrics The term ferroelectric relates not to a relationship of the material to the element iron, but simply a similarity of the properties to those of ferromagnets. Ferroelectrics exhibit a spontaneous, reversible electrical polarization and an associated hysteresis behavior between the polarization and electric field [6.4–6]. Much of the terminology associated with ferroelectrics is borrowed from ferromagnets; for instance, the transition temperature below which the material exhibits ferroelectric behavior is referred to as the Curie temperature. The ferroelectric phenomenon was first discovered in Rochelle salt (NaKC4 H4 O6 · 4H2 O). Other common examples of ferroelectric materials include barium titanate (BaTiO3 ), lead titanate (PbTiO3 ), and lithium niobate (LiNbO3 ). Materials of the perovskite structure (ABO3 ) appear to have the largest electrostriction and spontaneous polarization.
6.3.1 Electrostriction Electrostriction, in its most general sense, means simply electric-field-induced deformation. However, the term is most often used to refer to an electric-field-induced deformation that is proportional to the square of the electric field, as illustrated in Fig. 6.1b, εij = Mijkl E k El .
(6.10)
Part A 6.3
This effect does not require a net spontaneous polarization and, in fact, occurs for all dielectric materials [6.5]. The effect is quite pronounced in some ferroelectric ceramics, such as Pb(Mgx Nb1−x )O3 (PMN) and (1 − x)[Pb(Mg1/3 Nb2/3 )O3 ] − xPbTiO3 (PMN-PT), which generate strains much larger than those of piezoelectric PZT. The term electrostriction will be defined in a more general sense as electric-field-induced deformation that is independent of electric field polarity. As mentioned earlier, piezoelectricity exists in polycrystalline ceramics which exhibit a net spontaneous polarization. For a ferroelectric ceramic, while each grain may be microscopically polarized, the overall material will not be, due to the random orientation of the grains [6.2, 7]. For this reason, the ceramic must be poled under a strong electric field, often at elevated temperature, in order to generate the net spontaneous polarization. The ceramic is exposed to a strong electric field, generating an average polarization. The most interesting property of a ferroelectric solid is that it can be depolarized by an electric field and/or stress. It is this property which can be
exploited effectively in achieving large electrostriction [6.6]. Poling involves the reorientation of domains within the grains. In the case of PZT it may also involve polarization rotations due to phase changes. PZT is a solid solution of lead zirconate and lead titanate that is often formulated near the boundary between the rhombohedral and tetragonal phases (the so-called morphotropic phase boundary). For these materials, additional polarization states are available as it can choose between any of the 100 polarized states of the tetragonal phase, the 111 polarized states of the rhombohedral phase, or the 11k polarized states of the monoclinic phase. The final polarization of each grain, however, is constrained by the mechanical and electrical boundary conditions presented by the adjacent grains. A typical polarization–electric field hysteresis curve for a ferroelectric material is shown in Fig. 6.3. The spontaneous polarization, P s , is defined by the extrapolation of the linear region at saturation back to the polarization axis. The remaining polarization when the electric field returns to zero is known as the remnant polarization P r . Finally, the electric field at which the polarization returns to zero is known as the coercive field E c [6.8]. Polarization
Ps Pr
Ec
Electric field
Fig. 6.3 Polarization–electric field hysteresis for ferro-
electric materials. The spontaneous polarization (Ps ) is defined by the line extrapolated from the saturated linear region to the polarization axis. The remnant polarization (Pr ) is the polarization remaining at zero electric field. The coercive field (E c ) is the field required to reduce the polarization to zero
Active Materials
6.3.2 Theory
163
W
Based on the concepts for ferroelectricity postulated by Ginzburg and Landau, Devonshire developed a theory in which he treated strain and polarization as order parameters or field variables, which is collectively known as the Devonshire–Ginzburg–Landau (DGL) model [6.2, 9]. This theory was enormously successful in organizing vast amounts of data and providing the basis for the basic studies of ferroelectricity. The adaptation of this theory following Shu and Bhattacharya [6.10] is the most amenable in the context of mechanics and is described below. Consider a ferroelectric crystal V at a fixed temperature subject to an applied traction t 0 on part of its boundary S2 and an external applied electric field E 0 . The displacement u and polarization p of the ferroelectric are those that minimize the potential energy, 1 ∇ p · A∇ p + W(x, ε, p) − E0 · p dx Φ( p, u) = 2 V ε0 − t0 · u dS + (6.11) |∇φ|2 dx , 2 S2
6.3 Ferroelectrics
R3
W(θ, ε, p) = χij pi p j + ωijk pi p j pk + ξijkl pi p j pk pl + ψijklm pi p j pk pl pm + ζijklmn pi p j pk pl pm pn + Cijkl εij εkl + aijk εij pk + qijkl εij pk pl + · · · , (6.12) where χij is the reciprocal dielectric susceptibility of the unpolarized crystal, Cijkl is the elastic stiffness tensor, aijk is the piezoelectric constant tensor, qijkl is the electrostrictive constant tensor, and the coefficients are functions of temperature [6.8].
Fig. 6.4 The multiwell structure of the energy of a ferro-
electric solid with a tetragonal crystal structure as in the case of common perovskite crystals
The third and fourth terms in (6.11) are the potentials associated with the applied electric field and mechanical load, respectively. The final term is the electrostatic field energy that is generated by the polarization distribution. For any polarization distribution, the electrostatic potential φ is determined by solving Gauss’s equation (6.2) in all space, subject to appropriate boundary conditions, especially those on conductors. Thus, this last term is nonlocal. Ferroelectric crystals can be spontaneously polarized and strained in one of K crystallographically equivalent variants below their Curie temperature. Thus, if ε(i) , p(i) are the spontaneous strain and polarization of the i-th variant (i = 1, . . . , K ), then the stored energy W is minimum (zero without loss of generality) on the K [(ε(i) , p(i) )] and grows away from it as shown Z = ∪i=1 in the bottom right of Fig. 6.4.
6.3.3 Domain Patterns A region of constant polarization is known as a ferroelectric domain. The orientation of polarization and strain in ferroelectric crystals is determined by the possible variants of the underlying crystal structure. For example Fig. 6.5a shows the six possible variants that can form by the phase transformation of a perovskite (ABO3 ) crystal from the high-temperature cubic phase to the tetragonal phase when cooled below the Curie temperature. Domains are separated by 90◦ or 180◦ domain boundaries (the angle denotes the orientation between the polarization vectors in adjacent domains, Fig. 6.5b), which can be nucleated or moved by electric field or stress (the ferroelastic effect). Domain patterns are commonly visualized using polarized light microscopy and are shown in Fig. 6.5c for BaTiO3 . The process of changing the polarization direction of a domain by nucleation and growth or domain wall motion is known as domain switching. Electric field can induce both 90◦ or 180◦ switching, while stress
Part A 6.3
where A is a positive-definite matrix so that the first term above penalizes sharp changes in the polarization and may be regarded as the energetic cost of forming domain walls. The second term W is the stored energy density (the Landau energy density), which depends on the state variables or order parameters, the strain ε, and the polarization p, and also explicitly on the position x in polycrystals and heterogeneous media; W encodes the crystallographic and texture information, and may in principle be obtained from first-principles calculations based on quantum mechanics. It is traditional to take W to be a polynomial but one is not limited to this choice; for example, the energy density function W is assumed to be of the form,
ε, p
164
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
can induce only 90◦ switching [6.11]. The domain wall structures in the mechanical and electrical domain have recently been experimentally measured using scanning probe microscopy [6.12], which is typically in the range of tens of nanometers. In light of the multiwell structure of W, minimization of the potential energy in (6.11) leads to domain patterns or regions of almost constant strain and polarization close to the spontaneous values separated by domain walls. The width of the domain walls is proportional to the square root of the smallest eigenvalue of A. If this is small compared to the size of the crystal, as is typical, then the domain wall energy has a negligible effect on the macroscopic behavior and may be dropped [6.10]. This leads to an ill-posed problem as the minimizers may develop oscillations at a very fine scale (Fig. 6.5b), however there has been significant recent progress in studying such problems in recent years, motivated by active materials. a)
The minimizers of (6.11) for zero applied load and field are characterized by strain and polarization fields that take their values in Z. So one expects the solutions to be piecewise constant (domains) separated by jumps (domain walls). However the walls cannot be arbitrary. Instead, an energy-minimizing domain wall between variants i and j, i. e., an interface separating regions of strain and polarization (ε(i) , p(i) ) and (ε( j) , p( j) ) as shown in Fig. 6.5d, must satisfy two compatibility conditions [6.10], 1 ε( j) − ε(i) = (a ⊗ n + n ⊗ a) , 2 (6.13) ( p( j) − p(i) ) · n = 0 , where n is the normal to the interface. The first is the mechanical compatibility condition, which assures the mechanical integrity of the interface, and the second is the electrical compatibility conditions, which assures that the interface is uncharged and thus that energy minimizing. At first glance it appears impossible to solve these equations simultaneously: the first equation has at most two solutions for the vectors a and n, and there is no reason that these values of n should satisfy the second. It turns out however, that if the variants are related by two-fold symmetry, i. e., ε( j) = Rε(k) RT , 180◦
b)
90° boundary
Part A 6.3
180° boundary
c)
d)
n (ε(2), p (2))
(ε(1), p (1)) 100 μm
Fig. 6.5 (a) Variants of cubic-to-tetragonal phase transformation, the arrows indicate the direction of polarization. (b) Schematic of 90◦ and 180◦ domains in a ferroelectric crystal. (c) Polarized-light micrograph of the domain pattern in barium titanate. (d) Schematic of a domain wall in a ferroelectric crystal
ε( j) = Rp(k) ,
(6.14)
for some rotation R, then it is indeed possible to solve the two equations (6.14) simultaneously [6.10]. It follows that the only domain walls in a 001c polarized tetragonal phase are 180◦ and 90◦ domain walls, and that the 90◦ domain walls have a structure similar to that of compound twins with a rational {110}c interface and a rational 110c shear direction. The only possible domain walls in the 110c polarized orthorhombic phase are 180◦ domain walls, 90◦ domain walls having a structure like that of compound twins with a rational {100}c interface, 120◦ domain walls having a structure like that of type I twins with a rational {110}c interface, and 60◦ domain walls having a structure like that of type II twins with an irrational normal. The only possible domain walls in the 111c polarized rhombohedral phase are the 180◦ domain walls, and the 70◦ or 109◦ domain walls with a structure similar to that of compound twins. One can also use these ideas to study more-complex patterns involving multiple layers, layers within layers, and crossing layers. The potential energy (6.11) also allows one to study how applied boundary conditions affect the microstructure. The nonlocal electrostatic term is particularly interesting. For example, an isolated ferroelectric that
Active Materials
is homogeneously polarized generates an electrostatic field around it, and its energetic cost forces the ferroelectric to either become frustrated (form many domains at a small scale) or form closure domains or surface layers. In contrast, ferroelectrics shielded by electrodes can form large domains. Hard (high compliance, i. e., stiff) mechanical loading can force the formation of fine domain patterns [6.10], while soft (low compliance, dead loading being the most ideal example) loading leads to large domains. Therefore any strategy for actuation through domain switching must use electrodes to suitably shield the ferroelectric and soft loading in such a manner to create uniform electric and mechanical fields.
6.3 Ferroelectrics
165
by forming a (compatible) microstructure. However, when each pair of variants satisfy the compatibility conditions (6.13), the results of DeSimone and James [6.15] can be adopted to show that Z S equals the set of all possible averages of the spontaneous polarizations and strains of the variants n λi ε(i) , Z S = (ε, p) : ε∗ = i=1
p∗ =
n
λi (2 f i − 1) p(i) , λi ≥ 0 ,
i=1
n
λi = 1, 0 ≤ f i ≤ 1 .
(6.15)
i=1
6.3.4 Ceramics
Z P ⊇ Z T = ∩ Z S (x) = x∈Ω
{(ε, p)|(R(x) ε RT (x), R(x) p) ∈ Z S (x), ∀x ∈ Ω} . (6.16)
This simple bound is easy to calculate and also a surprisingly good indicator of the actual behavior of the material, which has the following implications. A material that is cubic above the Curie temperature and 001c -polarized tetragonal below has a very small set of spontaneous polarizations and no set of spontaneous strains unless the ceramic has a 001c texture. Indeed, each grain has only three possible spontaneous strains so that it is limited to only two possible deformation modes. Consequently the grains simply constrain
Part A 6.3
A polycrystal is a collection of perfectly bonded single crystals with identical crystallography but different orientations [6.13]. The term ceramic in the case of ferroelectrics refers to a polycrystal with numerous small grains, each of which may have numerous domains. The functional (6.11) (with A = 0) describes all the details of the domain pattern in each grain, and thus is rather difficult to understand. Instead it is advantageous to replace the energy density W in the functional (6.1) with ¯ the effective energy density of the polycrystal. The W, energy density W describes the behavior at the smallest length scale, which has a multiwell structure as dis- ˆ x, ε, p cussed earlier. This leads to domains, and W is the energy density of the grain at x after it has formed a domain pattern with average strain η and average polarization p. Note that this energy is zero on a set Z S , which is larger than the set Z. Z S is the set of all possible average spontaneous or remnant strains and polarizations that a single crystal can have by formˆ and Z S can vary from ing domain patterns. However, W grain to grain. The collective behavior of the polycrys¯ W(ε, ¯ tal is described by the energy density, W. p) is the energy density of a polycrystal with grains and domain patterns when the average strain is ε∗ and the average polarization is p∗ . Notice that it is zero on the set Z P , which is the set of all possible average spontaneous or remnant strains and polarization of the polycrystal. The size of the set Z P is an estimate of the ease with which a ferroelectric polycrystal may be poled, and also the strains that one can expect through domain switching. A rigorous discussion and precise definitions are given by Li and Bhattacharya [6.14]. The set Z S is obtained as the average spontaneous polarizations and strains that a single crystal can obtain
This is the case in materials with a cubic nonpolar high-temperature phase, and tetragonal, rhombohedral or orthorhombic ferroelectric low-temperature phases; explicit formulas are given in [6.14]. This is not the case in a cubic–monoclinic transformation, but one can estimate the set in that case. In a ceramic, the grain x has its own set Z S (x), which is obtained from the reference set by applying the rotation R(x) that describes the orientation of the grain relative to the reference single crystal. The set Z p of the polycrystal may be obtained as the macroscopic averages of the locally varying strain and polarization fields, which take their values in Z S (x) in each grain x. An explicit characterization remains an open problem (and sample dependent). However, one can obtain an insight into the size of the set by the so-called Taylor bound Z T , which assumes that the (mesoscale) strain and polarization are equal in each grain. Z T is simply the intersection of all possible sets Z S (x) corresponding to the different grains as x varies over the entire crystal. It is a conservative estimate of the actual set Z p :
166
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
each other. Similar results hold for a material which is cubic above the Curie temperature and 111c -polarized rhombohedral below it unless the ceramic has a 111c texture. These results imply that tetragonal and rhombohedral materials will not display large strain unless they are single crystals or are textured. Furthermore, it shows that it is difficult to pole these materials. This is the situation in BaTiO3 at room temperature, PbTiO3 , or PZT away from the morphotropic phase boundary (MPB). The situation is quite different if the material is either monoclinic or has a coexistence of 001c -polarized
tetragonal and 111c -polarized rhombohedral states below the Curie temperature. In either of these situations, the material has a large set of spontaneous polarizations and at least some set of spontaneous polarizations irrespective of the texture. Thus these materials will always display significant strain and can easily be poled. This is exactly the situation in PZT at the MPB. In particular, this shows that PZT has large piezoelectricity at the MPB because it can easily be poled and because it can have significant extrinsic strains [6.14].
6.4 Ferromagnets
Part A 6.4
Magnetostrictive materials are ferromagnetics that are spontaneously magnetized and can be demagnetized by the application of external magnetic field and/or stress. Ferromagnets exhibit a spontaneous, reversible magnetization and an associated hysteresis behavior between magnetization and magnetic field. All magnetic materials exhibit magnetostriction to some extent and the spontaneous magnetization is a measure of the actuation strain (magnetostriction) that can be obtained. Application of external magnetic fields to materials such as iron, nickel, and cobalt results in a strain on the order of 10−5 –10−4 . Recent advances in materials development have resulted in large magnetostriction in ironand nickel-based alloys on the order of 10−3 –10−2 . The most notable examples of these materials include Tb0.3 Dy0.7 Fe2 (Terfenol-D) and Ni2 MnGa, a ferromagnetic shape-memory alloy [6.15,16]. A well-established approach that has been used to model magnetostrictive materials is the theory of micromagnetics due to Brown [6.17]. A recent approach known as constrained theory of magnetoelasticity proposed by DeSimone and James [6.15, 18] is presented here, which is more suited for applications related to experimental mechanics.
6.4.1 Theory The potential energy of a magnetostrictive solid can be written as [6.15, 18], Φ(ε, M, θ) = Φexch + Φmst + Φext + Φmel ,
(6.17)
where Φexch is the exchange energy, Φmst is the magnetostatic or stray-field energy, Φext is the energy associated with the external magnetomechanical loads consisting of a uniform prestress σ0 applied at the boundary of S, and of a uniform applied magnetic field H0 in V . The expression (6.17) is similar to the ex-
pression for the potential energy of a ferroelectric solid in (6.11). The arguments for the ferroelectric solid for neglecting the first two terms in the exchange energy and the stray-field energy are also applicable to the magnetostrictive solids under appropriate conditions, namely 1. that the specimen is much larger than the domain size so that the exchange energy associated with the domain walls can be neglected, and 2. that the sample is shielded so that energy associated with the stray fields is negligible. Such an approach enables one to explore the implications of the energy minimization of (6.17). However, shielding the sample is a challenge and needs careful attention. The energy associated with the external loading is written (6.18) Φext = − t0 · u dS − H0 · m dV . S2
V
The magnetoelastic energy that accounts for the deviation of the magnetization from the favored crystallographic direction can be written (6.19) Φmel = W(ε, m) dV . V
The magnetoelastic energy density W is a function of the elastic moduli, the magentostrictive constants, and the magnetic susceptibility, and is analogous to (6.12). For a given material, W can be minimized when evaluated on a pair consisting of a magnetization along an easy direction and of the corresponding stress-free strain. In view of the crystallographic symmetry, there will be several, symmetry-related energy-minimizing magnetization (m) and strain (ε) pairs, analogous to the
Active Materials
electrostrictive solids explored in Sect. 6.3.2. Assuming that the corresponding minimum value of Wis zero, one can define the set of energy wells of the material, K [(ε(i) , m(i) )], which is analogous to the energy Z = ∪i=1 wells for ferroelectric solids shown in Fig. 6.5; W increases steeply away from the energy wells. Necessary conditions for compatibility between adjacent domains in terms of jumps in strain and magnetization have been established and have a form similar to (6.13). Much of the discussion concerning domain patterns in ferroelectric solids presented in Sect. 6.3 is applicable to magentostrictive solids, with magnetization in place of electric polarization.
6.4.2 Magnetostriction The application of mechanical loading (stress) can demagnetize ferromagnets by reorienting the magnetization axis, which can be counteracted by an applied magnetic field. This competition between applied magnetic field and dead loading (constant stress) acting on the solid provides a competition, leading to nucleation and propagation of magnetic domains across a specimen that can give rise to large magnetic actuation. For Terfenol-D, the material with the largest known room-temperature magnetostriction, the energy wells comprising Z are eight symmetry-related variants. Experiments on Terfenol-D by Teter et al., illustrate the effect of crystal orientation and applied stress on magnetostriction and are reproduced in Fig. 6.6 [6.19]. Interesting features of the results
References
Magnetostriction (x 10 –3 ) 2.5 [111]
2 [112]
1.5 1 0.5 [110]
0 –2000
–1000
0
1000
2000 Field (Oe)
Fig. 6.6 Magnetostriction versus applied magnetic field for three mutually orthogonal directions in single-crystal Terfenol-D at 20 ◦ C and applied constant stress of 11 MPa. (after 6.19 with permission. Copyright 1990, AIP)
include the steep change in energy away from the minimum (th ereference state at zero strain) and the varying amounts of hysteresis for different orientations. The constrained theory of magnetoelasticity described above can reproduce qualitative features of the experiments based on energy-minimizing domain patterns. An important aspect of modeling magnetostriction hinges on the ability to measure the magnetoelastic energy density, W, and the associated constants.
6.2
6.3 6.4
6.5 6.6
P. Krulevitch, A.P. Lee, P.B. Ramsey, J.C. Trevino, J. Hamilton, M.A. Northrup: Thin film shape memory alloy microactuators, J. MEMS 5, 270–282 (1996) D. Damjanovic: Ferroelectric, dielectric and piezoelectric properties of ferroelectric thin films and ceramics, Rep. Prog. Phys. 61, 1267–1324 (1998) L.L. Hench, J.K. West: Principles of Electronic Ceramics (Wiley, New York 1990) C.Z. Rosen, B.V. Hiremath, R.E. Newnham (Eds): Piezoelectricity. In: Key Papers in Physics (AIP, New York 1992) Y. Xu: Ferroelectric Materials and Their Applications (North-Holland, Amsterdam 1991) K. Bhattacharya, G. Ravichandran: Ferroelectric perovskites for electromechanical actuation, Acta Mater. 51, 5941–5960 (2003)
6.7
6.8 6.9 6.10
6.11
6.12
L.E. Cross: Ferroelectric ceramics: Tailoring properties for specific applications. In: Ferroelectric Ceramics, ed. by N. Setter, E.L. Colla (Monte Verita, Zurich 1993) pp. 1–85 F. Jona, G. Shirane: Ferroelectric Crystals (Pergamon, New York 1962), Reprint, Dover, New York (1993) A.F. Devonshire: Theory of ferroelectrics, Philos. Mag. Suppl. 3, 85–130 (1954) Y.C. Shu, K. Bhattacharya: Domain patterns and macroscopic behavior of ferroelectric materials, Philos. Mag. B 81, 2021–2054 (2001) E. Burcsu, G. Ravichandran, K. Bhattacharya: Large electrostrictive actuation of barium titanate single crystals, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 52, 823–846 (2004) C. Franck, G. Ravichandran, K. Bhattacharya: Characterization of domain walls in BaTiO3 using simultaneous atomic force and piezo response
Part A 6
References 6.1
167
168
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
6.13 6.14
6.15
force microscopy, Appl. Phys. Lett. 88, 1–3 (2006), 102907 C. Hartley: Introduction to materials for the experimental mechanist, Chapter 2 J.Y. Li, K. Bhattacharya: Domain patterns, texture and macroscopic electro-mechanical behavior of ferroelectrics. In: Fundamental Physics of Ferroelectrics 2001, ed. by H. Krakauer (AIP, New York 2001) p. 72 A. DeSimone, R.D. James: A constrained theory of magnetoelasticity, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 50, 283–320 (2002)
6.16
6.17 6.18
6.19
G. Engdahl, I.D. Mayergoyz (Eds.): Handbook of Giant Magnetostrictive Materials (Academic, New York 2000) W.F. Brown: Micromagnetics (Wiley, New York 1963) A. DeSimone, R.D. James: A theory of magnetostriction oriented towards applications, J. Appl. Phys. 81, 5706–5708 (1997) J.P. Teter, M. Wun-Fogle, A.E. Clark, K. Mahoney: Anisotropic perpendicular axis magnetostriction in twinned Tbx Dy1−x Fe1.95 , J. Appl. Phys. 67, 5004–5006 (1990)
Part A 6
169
Biological So 7. Biological Soft Tissues
Jay D. Humphrey
A better understanding of many issues of human health, disease, injury, and the treatment thereof necessitates a detailed quantification of how biological cells, tissues, and organs respond to applied loads. Thus, experimental mechanics can, and must, play a fundamental role in cell biology, physiology, pathophysiology, and clinical intervention. The goal of this chapter is to discuss some of the foundations of experimental biomechanics, with particular attention to quantifying the finite-strain behavior of biological soft tissues in terms of nonlinear constitutive relations. Towards this end, we review illustrative elastic, viscoelastic, and poroelastic descriptors of softtissue behavior and the experiments on which they are based. In addition, we review a new class of much needed constitutive relations that will help quantify the growth and remodeling processes within tissues that are fundamental to long-term adaptations and responses to disease, injury, and clinical intervention. We will see that much has
Constitutive Formulations – Overview .... 171
7.2
Traditional Constitutive Relations .......... 7.2.1 Elasticity ..................................... 7.2.2 Viscoelasticity .............................. 7.2.3 Poroelasticity and Mixture Descriptions .............. 7.2.4 Muscle Activation ......................... 7.2.5 Thermomechanics ........................
176 177 177
7.3
Growth and Remodeling – A New Frontier 7.3.1 Early Approaches.......................... 7.3.2 Kinematic Growth ........................ 7.3.3 Constrained Mixture Approach .......
178 178 179 180
7.4
Closure ................................................ 182
7.5
Further Reading ................................... 182
172 172 176
References .................................................. 183 been learned, yet much remains to be discovered about the wonderfully complex biomechanical behavior of soft tissues.
there was a need to await the development of a nonlinear theory of material behavior in order to quantify well that of soft tissues. It is not altogether surprising, therefore, that biomechanics did not truly come into its own until the mid-1960s. It is suggested that five independent developments facilitated this: (i) the post World War II renaissance in nonlinear continuum mechanics [7.2] established a general foundation needed for developing constitutive relations suitable for soft tissues; (ii) the development of computers enabled the precisely controlled experimentation [7.3] that was needed to investigate complex anisotropic behaviors and facilitated the nonlinear regressions [7.4] that were needed to determine best-fit material parameters from data; (iii) related to this technological advance, development of sophisticated numerical methods, particularly the
Part A 7
At least since the time of Galileo Galilei (1564–1642), there has been a general appreciation that mechanics influences the structure and function of biological tissues and organs. For example, Galileo studied the strength of long bones and suggested that they are hollow as this increases their strength-to-weight ratio (i. e., it increases the second moment of area given a fixed amount of tissue, which is fundamental to increasing the bending stiffness). Many other figures in the storied history of mechanics, including G. Borelli, R. Hooke, L. Euler, T. Young, J. Poiseuille, and H. von Helmholtz, contributed much to our growing understanding of biomechanics. Of particular interest herein, M. Wertheim, a very productive experimental mechanicist of the 19-th century, showed that diverse soft tissues do not exhibit the linear stress–strain response that is common to many engineering materials [7.1]. That is,
7.1
170
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Mechanical stimuli ECM
α β
Cell-cell G-proteins
Ion channels
GF receptor Cadherins Cell membrane
Mechanobiologic factors
Cell-matrix Integrins FAC changes
Signaling pathways
CSK changes
Transcription factors Gene expression
Altered mechanical properties
Altered cell function
Fig. 7.1 Schema of cellular stimuli or inputs – chemical, mechanical, and of course, genetic – and possible mechanobio-
logic responses. The cytoskeleton (CSK) maintains the structural integrity of the cell and interacts with the extracellular matrix (ECM) through integrins (transmembrane structural proteins) or clusters of integrins (i. e., focal adhesion complexes or FACs). Of course, cells also interact with other cells via special interconnections (e.g., cadherins) and are stimulated by various molecules, including growth factors (GFs). Although the pathways are not well understood, mechanical stimuli can induce diverse changes in gene expression, which in turn alter cell function and properties as well as help control the structure and properties of the extracellular matrix. It is clear, therefore, that mechanical stimuli can affect many different aspects of cell function and thus that of tissues and organs
Part A 7
finite element method [7.5], enabled the solution of complex boundary value problems associated with soft tissues, including inverse finite element estimations of material parameters [7.6]; and (iv) the space race of the 1960s increased our motivation to study the response of the human body to applied loads, particularly high G-forces associated with lift-off and reentry as well as the microgravity environment in space. Finally, it is not coincidental that the birth of modern biomechanics followed closely (v) the birth of modern biology, often signaled by discoveries of the structure of proteins, by L. Pauling, and the structure of DNA, by J. Watson and F. Crick. These discoveries ushered in the age of molecular and cellular biology [7.7]. Indeed, in contrast to the general appreciation of roles of mechanics in biology in the spirit of Galileo, the last few decades have revealed a fundamentally more important role of mechanics and mechanical fac-
tors. Experiments since the mid-1970s have revealed that cells often alter their basic activities (e.g., their expression of particular genes) in response to even subtle changes in their mechanical environment. For example, in response to increased mechanical stretching, cells can increase their production of structural proteins [7.8]; in response to mechanical injury, cells can increase their production of enzymes that degrade the damaged structural proteins [7.9]; and, in response to increased flow-induced shear stresses, cells can increase their production of molecules that change permeability or cause the lumen to dilate and thereby to restore the shear stress towards its baseline value [7.10]. Cells that are responsive to changes in their mechanical loading are sometimes referred to as mechanocytes, and the study of altered cellular activity in response to altered mechanical loading is called mechanobiology (Fig. 7.1). Consistent with the mechanistic philosophy
Biological Soft Tissues
of R. Descartes, which motivated many of the early studies in biomechanics, it is widely accepted that cells are not only responsive to changes in their mechanical environment, they are also subject to the basic postulates of mechanics (e.g., balance of linear momen-
7.1 Constitutive Formulations – Overview
171
tum). As a result, basic concepts from mechanics (e.g., stress and strain) can be useful in quantifying cellular responses and there is a strong relationship between mechanobiology and biomechanics. Herein, however, we focus primarily on the latter.
7.1 Constitutive Formulations – Overview There are, of course, three general approaches to quantify complex mechanical behaviors via constitutive formulations: (i) theoretically, based on precise information on the microstructure of the material; (ii) experimentally, based directly on data collected from particular classes of experiments; and (iii) via trial and error, by postulating competing relations and selecting preferred ones based on their ability to fit data. Although theoretically derived microstructural relations are preferred in principle, efforts ranging from C. Navier’s attempt to model the behavior of metals to L. Treloar’s attempt to model the behavior of natural rubber reveal that that this is very difficult in practice, particularly for materials with complex microstructures such as soft tissues. Formulating constitutive relations directly from experimental data is thus a practical preference [7.11], but again history reveals that it has been difficult to identify and execute appropriate theoretically based empirical approaches. For this reason, trial-and-error phenomenological formulations, based on lessons learned over years of investigation and often motivated by limited microstructural information, continue to be common in biomechanics just as they are in more traditional areas of applied mechanics. Regardless of approach, there are five basic steps that one must follow in any constitutive formulation:
•
Specifically, the first step is to classify the behavior of the material under conditions of interest, as, for example, if the material exhibits primarily a fluid-like or a solid-like response, if the response is dissipative or not, if it is isotropic or not, if it is isochoric or not, and so forth. Once sufficient observations enable one to classify the behavior, one can then establish an appro-
Fibroblast Endothelial cell Collagen
Smooth muscle Adventitia
Elastin
Media Intima
Basal lamina
b)
Fig. 7.2 (a) Schema of the arterial wall, which consists of three basic layers: the intima, or innermost layer, the media, or middle layer, and the adventitia, or outermost layer. Illustrated too are the three primary cells types (endothelial, smooth muscle, and fibroblasts) and two of the key structural proteins (elastin and collagen). (b) For comparison, see the histological section of an actual artery: the dark inner line shows the internal elastic lamina, which separates the thin intima from the media; the lighter shade in the middle shows the muscle dominated media, and the darker shade in the outer layer shows the collagendominated adventitia
Part A 7.1
• • • •
delineate general characteristics of the material behavior, establish an appropriate theoretical framework, identify specific functional forms of the relations, calculate values of the material parameters, evaluate the predictive capability of the final relations.
a)
172
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
priate theoretical framework (e.g., a theory of elasticity within the context of the definition of a simple material by W. Noll), with suitable restrictions on the possible constitutive relations (e.g., as required by the Clausius– Duhem inequality, material frame indifference, and so forth). Once a theory is available, one can then design appropriate experiments to quantify the material behavior in terms of specific functional relationships and best-fit values of the material parameters. Because of the complex behaviors, multiaxial tests are often preferred, including in-plane biaxial stretching of a planar specimen, extension and inflation of a cylindrical specimen, extension and torsion of a cylindrical specimen, or inflation of an axisymmetric membrane, each of which has a tractable solution to the associated finite-strain boundary value problem. The final step, of course, is to ensure that the relation has predictive capability beyond that used in formulating the relation. With regard to classifying the mechanical behavior of biological soft tissues, it is useful to note that they often consist of multiple cell types embedded within an extracellular matrix that consists of diverse proteins as well as proteoglycans (i. e., protein cores with polysaccharide branches) that sequester significant amounts of water. Figure 7.2 shows constituents in the arterial wall, an illustrative soft tissue. The primary structural proteins in arteries, as in most soft tissues, are elastin and different families of collagen. Elastin is perhaps the most elastic protein, capable of extensions of over 100% with little dissipation. Moreover, elastin is one of the most stable proteins in the body, with a normal halflife of decades. Collagen, on the other hand, tends to be very stiff and not very extensible, with the exception that it is often undulated in the physiologic state and thus can undergo large displacements until straightened.
The half-life of collagen varies tremendously depending on the type of tissue, ranging from a few days in the periodontal ligament to years in bone. Note, too, that the half-life as well as overall tissue stiffness is modulated in part by extensive covalent cross-links, which can be enzymatic or nonenzymatic (which occur in diabetes, for example, and contribute to the loss of normal function of various types of tissues, including arteries). In general, however, soft tissues can exhibit a nearly elastic response (e.g., because of elastin) under many conditions, one that is often nonlinear (due to the gradual recruitment of undulated collagen), anisotropic (due to different orientations of the different constituents), and isochoric (due to the high water content) unless water is exuded or imbibed during the deformation. Many soft tissues will also creep or stress-relax under a constant load or a constant extension, respectively. Hence, as with most materials, one must be careful to identify the conditions of interest. In the cardiovascular and pulmonary systems, for example, normal loading is cyclic, and these tissues exhibit a nearly elastic response under cyclic loading. Conversely, implanted prosthetic devices in the cardiovascular system (e.g., a coronary stent) may impose a constant distension, and thus induce significant stress relaxation early on but remodeling over longer periods due to the degradation and synthesis of matrix proteins. Finally, two distinguishing features of soft tissues are that they typically contain contractile cells (e.g., muscle cells, as in the heart, or myofibroblasts, as in wounds to the skin) and that they can repair themselves in response to local damage. That is, whether we remove them from the body for testing or not, we must remember that our ultimate interest is in the mechanical properties of tissues that are living [7.12].
Part A 7.2
7.2 Traditional Constitutive Relations At the beginning of this section, we reemphasize that constitutive relations do not describe materials; rather they describe the behavior of materials under welldefined conditions of interest. A simple case in point is that we do not have a constitutive relation for water; we have different constitutive relations for water in its solid (ice), liquid (water), or gaseous (steam) states, which is to say for different conditions of temperature and pressure. Hence, it is unreasonable to expect that any single constitutive relation can, or even should, describe a particular tissue. In other words, we should expect that
diverse constitutive relations will be equally useful for describing the behavior of individual tissues depending on the conditions of interest. Many arguments in the literature over whether a particular tissue is elastic, viscoelastic, poroelastic, etc. could have been avoided if this simple truth had been embraced.
7.2.1 Elasticity No biological soft tissue exhibits a truly elastic response, but there are many conditions under which the
Biological Soft Tissues
assumption of elasticity is both reasonable and useful. Toward this end, one of the most interesting, and experimentally useful, observations with regard to the behavior of many soft tissues is that they can be preconditioned under cyclic loading. That is, as an excised tissue is cyclically loaded and unloaded, the stress versus stretch curves tend to shift rightward, with decreasing hysteresis, until a near-steady-state response is obtained. Fung [7.12] suggested that this steadystate response could be modeled by separately treating the loading and unloading curves as nearly elastic; he coined the term pseudoelastic to remind us that the response is not truly elastic. In practice, however, except in the case of muscular tissues, the hysteresis is often small and one can often approximate reasonably well the mean response between the loading and the unloading responses using a single elastic descriptor, similar to what is done to describe rubber elasticity. Indeed, although mechanisms underlying the preconditioning of soft tissues are likely very different from those underlying the Mullin effect in rubber elasticity [7.13], in both cases initial cyclic loading produces stress softening and enables one to use the many advances in nonlinear elasticity. This and many other parallels between tissue and rubber elasticity likely result from the long-chain polymeric microstructure of both classes of materials, thus these fields can and should borrow ideas from one another (see discussion in [7.14] Chap. 1). For example, Cauchy membrane stress (g/cm) 120 RV epicardium equibiaxial stretch Circumferential Apex–to–base 60
1
1.16
1.32 Stretch
Fig. 7.3 Representative tension–stretch data taken, fol-
lowing preconditioning, from a primarily collagenous membrane, the epicardium or covering of the heart, tested under in-plane equibiaxial extension. Note the strong nonlinear response, anisotropy, and negligible hysteresis over finite deformations (note: membrane stress is the same as a stress resultant or tension, thus having units of force per length though here shown as a mass per length)
advances in rubber elasticity have taught us much about the importance of universal solutions, common types of material and structural instabilities, useful experimental approaches, and so forth [7.14–16]. Nonetheless, common forms of stress–strain relations in rubber elasticity – for example, neo-Hookean, Mooney–Rivlin, and Ogden – have little utility in soft-tissue biomechanics and at times can be misleading [7.17]. A final comment with regard to preconditioning is that, although we desire to know properties in vivo (literally in the body), it is difficult in practice to perform the requisite measurements without removing the cells, tissues, or organs from the body so that boundary conditions can be known. This process of removing specimens from their native environment necessarily induces a nonphysiological, often poorly controlled strain history. Because the mechanical behavior is history dependent, the experimental procedure of preconditioning provides a common, recent strain history that facilitates comparisons of subsequent responses from specimen to specimen. For this reason, the preconditioning protocol should be designed well and always reported. Whereas a measured linear stress–strain response implies a unique functional relationship, the nonlinear, anisotropic stress–strain responses exhibited by most soft tissues (Fig. 7.3) typically do not suggest a specific functional relationship. In other words, one must decide whether the observed characteristic stiffening over finite strains (often from 5% to as much as 100% strain) is best represented by polynomial, exponential, or more complex stress–strain relations. Based on one-dimensional (1-D) extension tests on a primarily collagenous membrane called the mesentery, which is found in the abdomen, Fung showed in 1967 that it can be useful to plot stiffness, specifically the change of the first Piola–Kirchhoff stress with respect to changes in the deformation gradient, versus stress rather than to plot stress versus stretch as is common [7.12]. Specifically, if P is the 1-D first Piola– Kirchhoff stress and λ is the associated component of the deformation gradient (i. e., a stretch ratio), then seeking a functional form P = P(λ) directly from data is simplified by interpreting dP/ dλ versus P. For the mesentery, Fung found a near-linear relation between stiffness and stress, which in turn suggested directly (i. e., via the solution of the linear first-order ordinary differential equation) an exponential stress–stretch relationship (with P(λ = 1) = 0): α β(λ−1) dP e −1 , = α+βP → P = dλ β
(7.1)
173
Part A 7.2
0
7.2 Traditional Constitutive Relations
174
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
where α and β are material parameters, which can be determined via nonlinear regressions of stress versus stretch data or more simply via linear regressions of stiffness versus stress data. Note, too, that one could expand and then linearize the exponential function to relate these parameters to the Young’s modulus of linearized elasticity if so desired. Albeit a very important finding, a 1-D constitutive relation cannot be extended to describe the multiaxial behavior that is common to many soft tissues, ranging from the mesentery to the heart, arteries, skin, cornea, bladder, and so forth. At this point, therefore, Fung made a bold hypothesis. Given that this 1-D first Piola–Kirchhoff versus stretch relationship was exponential, he hypothesized that the behavior of many soft tissues could be described by an exponential relationship between the second Piola–Kirchhoff stress tensor S and the Green strain tensor E, which are conjugate measures appropriate for large-strain elasticity. In particular, he suggested a hyperelastic constitutive relation of the form: ∂W ∂Q whereby S = = c eQ , W = c eQ − 1 ∂E ∂E (7.2)
Part A 7.2
where W is a stored energy function and Q is a function of E. Over many years, Fung and others suggested, based on attempts to fit data, that a convenient form of Q is one that is quadratic in the Green strain, similar to the form of a stored energy function in terms of the infinitesimal strain in linearized elasticity. Fung argued that, because Q is related directly to ln W, material symmetry arguments were the same for this exponential stored energy function as they are for linearized elasticity. Q thus contains two, five, or nine nondimensional material parameters for isotropic, transversely isotropic, or orthotropic material symmetries, respectively, and this form of W recovers that for linearized elasticity as a special case. The addition of a single extra material parameter, c, having units of stress, is a small price to pay in going from linearized to finite elasticity, and this form of W has been used with some success to describe data on the biaxial behavior of skin, lung tissue, arteries, heart tissue, urinary bladder, and various membranes including the pericardium (which covers the heart) and the pleura (which covers the lungs). In some of these cases, this form of W was modified easily for incompressibility (e.g., by introducing a Lagrange multiplier) or for a twodimensional (2-D) problem. For example, a commonly used 2-D form in terms of principal Green strains
is 2 2 + c2 E 22 + 2c3 E 11 E 22 − 1 , W = c exp c1 E 11 (7.3)
where ci are material parameters. It is easy to show that physically reasonable behavior is ensured by c > 0 and ci > 0 and that convexity is ensured by the additional condition c1 c2 > c23 [7.18, 19]. Nonetheless, (7.2) and (7.3) are not without limitations. This 2-D form limits the degree of strain-dependent changes in anisotropy that are allowed, and experience has shown that it is typically difficult to find a unique set of material parameters via nonlinear regressions of data, particularly in three dimensions. Perhaps more problematic, experience has also revealed that convergent solutions can be difficult to achieve in finite element models based on the three-dimensional (3-D) relation except in cases of axisymmetric geometries. The later may be related to the recent finding by Walton and Wilber [7.20] that the 3-D Fung stored energy function is not strongly elliptic. Hence, despite its past success and usage, there is clearly a need to explore other constitutive approaches. Moreover, this is a good reminder that there is a need for a strong theoretical foundation in all constitutive formulations. The Green strain is related directly to the right Cauchy Green tensor C = F F, where F is the deformation gradient tensor, yet most work in finite elasticity has been based on forms of W that depend on C, thus allowing the Cauchy stress t to be determined via (as required by Clausius–Duhem, and consistent with (7.2) for the relation between the second Piola–Kirchhoff stress and Green strain): t=
∂W 2 F F . det F ∂C
(7.4)
For example, Spencer [7.21] suggested that materials consisting of a single family of fibers (i. e., exhibiting a transversely isotropic material symmetry) could be described by a W of the form ˆ II, III, IV, V) , W = W(I,
(7.5)
where I = tr C,
2II = (tr C)2 − tr C2 ,
IV = M · CM,
V = M·C M , 2
III = det C, (7.6)
and M is a unit vector that identifies the direction of the fiber family in a reference configuration. Incompress-
Biological Soft Tissues
ibility, III = 1, reduces the number of invariants by one while introducing an arbitrary Lagrange multiplier p, namely p ˜ II, IV, V) − (III − 1) , (7.7) W = W(I, 2 yet it is still difficult to impossible to rigorously determine specific functional forms directly from data. Indeed, this problem is more acute in cases of twofiber families, including orthotropy when the families are orthogonal. Hence, subclasses of this form of W have been evaluated in biomechanics. For example, Humphrey et al. [7.22] showed, and Sacks and Chuong [7.23] confirmed, that a stored energy funcˆ IV), determined directly from tion of the form W(I, in-plane biaxial tests (with I and IV separately maintained constant) on excised slabs of noncontracting heart muscle to be a polynomial function, described well the available in-plane biaxial stretching data. This 1990 paper [7.22] also illustrated the utility of performing nonlinear regressions of stress–stretch data using data sets that combined results from multiple biaxial tests as well as the importance of respecting Baker–Ericksen-type inequalities [7.2] in the parameter estimations. Holzapfel et al. [7.18] and others have similarly proposed specific forms of W for arteries based on a subclass of the two-fiber family approach of Spencer. Specifically, they propose a form of W that combines that of a neo-Hookean relation with a simple exponential form for two-fiber families, namely ˜ = c(tr C − 3) W c1 exp b1 (M1 · CM1 − 1)2 − 1 + b1 c2 exp b2 (M2 · CM2 − 1)2 − 1 , + b2
(7.8)
175
depend on traditional invariants of C is not optimal, hence alternative invariant sets should be identified and explored [7.18, 24, 25]. Experiments designed based on these invariants remain to be performed, however. Preceding the one- and two-fiber family models were the microstructural models proposed by Lanir [7.26]. Briefly, electron and light microscopy reveal that the elastin and collagen fibers within many soft tissues have complex spatial distributions (notable exceptions being collagen fibers within tendons, which are coaxial, and those within the cornea of the eye, which are arranged in layered orthogonal networks). Moreover, it appears that, despite extensive cross-linking at the molecular level, these networks are often loosely organized. Consequently, Lanir suggested that a stored energy function for a tissue could be derived in terms of strain energies for straightened individual fibers if one accounted for the undulation and distribution of the different types of fibers, or alternatively that one could postulate exponential stored energy functions for the individual fibers (cf. (7.3)) and simply account for distribution functions for each type of fiber. For example, for a soft tissue consisting primarily of elastin and type I collagen (i. e., only two types of constituents), one could consider
Ri (ϕ, θ) wif λif sin ϕ dϕ dθ , (7.9) φi W= i=1,2
φi
where and Ri are, respectively, the volume fraction and distribution function for constituent i (elastin or collagen), and wif is the 1-D stored energy function for a fiber belonging to constituent i. Clearly, the stress could be computed as in (7.1) provided that the fiber stretch can be related to the overall strain, which is easy if one assumes affine deformations. In principle, the distribution function could be determined from histology and the material parameters for the fiber stored energy function could be determined from straightforward 1-D tests, thus eliminating, or at least reducing, the need to find many free parameters via nonlinear regressions in which unique estimates are rare. In practice, however, it has been difficult to identify the distribution functions directly, thus they have often been assumed to be Gaussian or a similarly common distribution function. Although proposed as a microstructural model, the many underlying assumptions render this approach microstructurally motivated at best; that is, there is no actual modeling of the complex interactions (including covalent cross-links, van der Waals forces, etc.) between the many different proteins and proteoglycans that endow the tissue with its bulk properties,
Part A 7.2
where Mi (i = 1, 2) denote the original directions of the two-fiber families. Although neither of these forms is derived directly from precise knowledge of the microstructure nor inferred directly from experimental data, this form of W was motivated by the idea that elastin endows an artery with a nearly linearly elastic (neo-Hookean)-type response whereas the straightening of multiple families of collagen can be modeled by exponential functions in terms of fiber stretches. Thus far, this and similar forms of W have proven useful in large-scale computations and illustrates well the utility of the third approach to modeling noted above – trial and error based on experience with other materials or similar relations. It is important to note, however, that inferring forms of W for incompressible behaviors that
7.2 Traditional Constitutive Relations
176
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
which are measurable using standard procedures. Indeed, perhaps one reason that this approach did not gain wider usage is that it failed to predict material behaviors under simple experimental conditions, thus like competing phenomenological relations it had to rely on nonlinear regressions to obtain best-fit values of the associated material parameters. As noted earlier, the extreme complexity of the microstructure of soft tissues renders it difficult to impossible to derive truly microstructural relations. Nevertheless, as we discuss below, microstructurally motivated formulations can be a very useful approach to constitutive modeling provided that the relations are not overinterpreted. Among others, Bischoff et al. [7.27] have revisited microstructurally motivated constitutive models with a goal of melding them with phenomenological models. In summary, although no soft tissue is truly elastic in its behavior, hyperelastic constitutive relations have proven useful in many applications. We have reviewed but a few of the many different functional forms reported in the literature, thus the interested reader is referred to Fung [7.12], Maurel et al. [7.28], and Humphrey [7.19] for additional discussion.
7.2.2 Viscoelasticity Although the response of many soft tissues tends to be relatively insensitive to changes in strain rate over physiologic ranges, soft tissues creep under constant loads and they stress-relax under constant deformations. Among others, Fung [7.12] suggested that single-integral heredity models could be useful in biomechanics just as they are in rubber viscoelasticity [7.29]. For example, we recently showed that sets of strain-dependent stress relaxation responses of a collagenous membrane, before and after thermal damage, can be modeled via [7.30]
Part A 7.2
τ G(τ − s) t(τ) = − p(τ)I + 2F(τ) 0
∂ ∂W × (s) ds F (τ) , ∂s ∂C
(7.10)
where G is a reduced relaxation function that depends on fading time (τ − s) and W was taken to be an exponential function similar to (7.3); all other quantities are the same as before except with explicit dependence on the current time. Various forms of the reduced relaxation function can be used, including a simple form that
we found to be useful in thermal damage G(x) =
1− R +R, 1 + (x/τR )n
(7.11)
where n is a free parameter, τR is a characteristic time of relaxation, and R is the stress remainder, that is, the fraction of the elastic response that is left after a long relaxation (e.g., R = 0 for a viscoelastic fluid). If short-term responses are important, numerous models can be used; for example, the simple viscohyperelastic approach of Beatty and Zhou [7.31] is useful in modeling biomembranes [7.32]. Briefly, the Cauchy stress is assumed to be of the general form t = tˆ(B, D), where B = FF is the left Cauchy–Green tensor, with F the deformation gradient, and D = (L + L )/2 is the ˙ −1 . stretching tensor, with the velocity gradient L = FF Specifically, assuming incompressibility, the Cauchy stress has three contributions: a reaction stress, an elastic part, and a viscous part, namely t = − pI + 2F
˜ ∂W F + 2μD , ∂C
(7.12)
where p is again a Lagrange multiplier that enforces incompressibility, W is the same strain energy function that was used in the elastic-only description noted above, and μ is a viscosity. Hence, this description of short-term nonlinear viscohyperelasticity adds but one additional material parameter to the constitutive equation, and the elastic response can be quantified first via quasistatic tests, thereby reducing the number of parameters in each regression. Some have considered a synthesis of the short- and long-term models. For a discussion of other viscoelastic models in softtissue mechanics, see Provenzano et al. [7.33] or Haslach [7.34] and references therein.
7.2.3 Poroelasticity and Mixture Descriptions Not only do soft tissues consist of considerable water, every cell in these tissues is within ≈ 50 μm of a capillary, which is to say close to flowing blood. Clearly then, it can be advantageous to model tissues as solid–fluid mixtures under many conditions of interest. A basic premise of mixture theory [7.2] is that balance relations hold both for the mixture as a whole and for the individual constituents, with the requirement that summation of the balance relations for the constituents must yield the classical relations. Moreover, it is assumed that the constituent balance relations include additional constitutive relations, particularly those that model the
Biological Soft Tissues
exchanges of mass, momentum, or energy between constituents. The first, and most often used, approach to model soft tissues via mixture theory was proposed by Mow et al. [7.35]. Briefly, their linear biphasic theory treated cartilage as a porous solid (i. e., the composite response due to type II collagen, proteoglycans, etc.), which was assumed to exhibit a linearly elastic isotropic response, with an associated viscous fluid within. They proposed constitutive relations for the solid and fluid stresses of the form t (s) = −φ(s) pI + λs tr(ε)I + 2μs ε , t (f) = −φ(f) pI − 23 μf div v(f) I + 2μf D ,
(7.13)
and, for the momentum exchange between the solid and fluid, − p(f) = p(s) = p∇φ(f) + K (v(f) − v(s) ) ,
(7.14)
177
7.2.4 Muscle Activation Another unique feature of many soft tissues is their ability to contract via actin–myosin interactions within specialized cells called myocytes. Examples include the cardiac muscle of the heart, skeletal muscle of the arms and legs, and smooth muscle, which is found in many tissues including the airways, arteries, and uterus. The most famous equation in muscle mechanics is that postulated in 1938 by A. V. Hill to describe force–velocity relations. This relation, like many subsequent ones, focuses on 1-D behavior along the long axis of the myocyte or muscle; data typically comes from tests on muscle fibers or strips, or in some cases rings taken from arteries or airways. Although much has been learned, much remains to be learned particularly with respect to the multiaxial behavior. The interested reader is referred to Fung [7.12]. Zahalak et al. [7.42], and Rachev and Hayashi [7.43]. In addition, however, note that modeling muscle activity in the heart (i. e., the electromechanics) has advanced significantly and represents a great example of the synthesis of complex theoretical, experimental, and computational methods. Toward this end, the reader is referred to Hunter et al. [7.44, 45].
7.2.5 Thermomechanics The human body regulates its temperature to remain within a narrow range, and for this reason there has been little attention to constitutive relations for thermomechanical behaviors of cells, tissues, and organs. Nevertheless, advances in laser, microwave, highfrequency ultrasound, and related technologies have encouraged the development and use of heating devices to treat diverse diseases and injuries. For example, supraphysiologic temperatures can destroy cells and shrink collagenous tissue, which can be useful in treating cancer and orthopedic injuries, respectively. Laser-based corneal reshaping, or LASIK, is another prime example. Due to space limitations here, the interested reader is referred to Humphrey [7.46], and references therein, for a brief review of the growing field of biothermomechanics and insight into ways in which experimental mechanics and constitutive modeling can contribute. Also see Diller and Ryan [7.47] for information on the associated bioheat transfer. Of particular note, however, it has been shown that increased mechanical loading can delay the rate at which thermal damage accrues, hence there is a strong thermomechanical coupling and a pressing need for more mechanics-based studies – first experimental, then computational.
Part A 7.2
where the superscripts and subscripts ‘s’ and ‘f’ denote solid and fluid constituents, hence v(s) and v(f) are solid and fluid velocities, respectively. Finally, φ(i) are constituent fractions, μs and λs are the classical Lamé constants for the solid, μf is the fluid viscosity, and ε is the linearized strain in the solid. In some cases the fluid viscosity is neglected, thus allowing tissue viscoelasticity to be accounted for solely via the momentum exchange between the solid and diffusing fluid, where K is related to the permeability coefficient. Mow and colleagues have developed this theory over the years to account for additional factors, including the presence of diffusing ions [7.36, 37] (see also [7.38] for a related approach). Because of the complexity of poroelastic and mixture theories, as well as the inherent geometric complexities associated with most real initial–boundary value problems in soft tissues, finite element methods will continue to prove essential; see, for example, Spilker et al. [7.39] and Simon et al. [7.40] for such formulations. In summary, one can now find many different applications of mixtures in the literature on soft tissues (e.g., Reynolds and Humphrey [7.41] address capillary blood flow within a tissue using mixture theory) and, indeed, the past success and future promise of this approach mandates intensified research in this area, research that must not simply be application, but rather should include development and extension of past theories. Moreover, whereas many of the experiments in biomechanics have consisted of unconfined or confined uniaxial compression tests using porous indenters, there is a pressing need for new multiaxial tests.
7.2 Traditional Constitutive Relations
178
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
7.3 Growth and Remodeling – A New Frontier As noted above, it has been thought at least since the time of Galileo that mechanical stimuli play essential roles in governing biological structure and function. Nevertheless an important step in our understanding of the biomechanics of tissues began with Wolff’s law for bone remodeling, which was put forth in the late 19-th century. Briefly, it was observed that the fine structure of cancellous (i. e., trabecular) bone within long bones tended to follow lines of maximum tension. That is, it appeared that the stress field dictated, at least in part, the way in which the microstructure of bone was organized. This observation led to the concept of functional adaptation wherein it was thought that bone functionally adapts so as to achieve maximum strength with a minimum of material. For a discussion of bone growth and remodeling, see Fung [7.12], Cowin [7.48], and Carter and Beaupre [7.49]. Although the general concept of functional adaptation appears to hold for most tissues, it is emphasized that bone differs significantly from soft tissues in three important ways. First, bone growth occurs on surfaces, that is, via appositional growth rather than via interstitial growth as in most soft tissues; second, most of the strength of bone derives from an inorganic component, which is not true in soft tissues; third, bone experiences small strains and exhibits a nearly linearly elastic, or poroelastic, behavior, which is very different from the nonlinear behavior exhibited by soft tissues over finite strains. Hence, let us consider methods that have been applied to soft tissues.
7.3.1 Early Approaches
Part A 7.3
Murray [7.50] suggested that biological “organization and adaptation are observed facts, presumably conforming to definite laws because, statistically at least, there is some sort of uniformity or determinism in their appearances. And let us assume that the best quantitative statement embodying the concept of organization is a principle which states that the cost of operation of physiological systems tends to be a minimum. . . ” Murray illustrated his ideas by postulating a cost function for “operating an arterial segment.” He proposed that the radius of a blood vessel results from a compromise between the advantage of increasing the lumen, which reduces the resistance to flow and thereby the workload on the heart, and the disadvantage of increasing overall blood volume, which increases the metabolic demand of maintaining the blood (e.g., red blood cells have a life-
span of a few months in humans, which necessitates a continual production and removal of cells). Murray’s findings suggest that “. . . the flow of blood past any section shall everywhere bear the same relation to the cube of the radius of the vessel at that point.” Recently, it has been shown that Murray’s ideas are consistent with the observation that the lumen of an artery appears to be governed, in part, so as to keep the wall shear stress at a preferred value – for a simple, steady, incompressible, laminar flow of a Newtonian fluid in a circular tube, the wall shear stress is proportional to the volumetric flow rate and inversely proportional to the cube of the radius [7.19]. Clearly, optimization approaches should be given increased attention, particularly with regard to the design of useful biomechanical experiments and the reduction of the associated data. Perhaps best known for inventing the Turing machine for computing, Turing also published a seminal paper on biological growth [7.51]. Briefly, he was interested in mathematically modeling morphogenesis, that is, the development of the form, or shape, of an organism. In his words, he sought to understand the mechanism by which “genes . . . may determine the anatomical structure of the resulting organism.” Turing recognized the importance of both mechanical and chemical stimuli in controlling morphogenesis, but he focused on the chemical aspects, especially the reaction kinetics and diffusion of morphogens, substances such as growth factors that regulate the development of form. For example, he postulated linear reaction– diffusion equations of the form ∂M1 = a (M1 − h) + b (M2 − g) + D1 ∇ 2 M1 , ∂t ∂M2 = c (M1 − h) + d (M2 − g) + D2 ∇ 2 M2 , ∂t
(7.15)
where M1 and M2 are concentrations of two morphogens, a, b, c, and d are reaction rates, and D1 and D2 are diffusivities; h and g are equilibrium values of M1 and M2 , and t represents time during morphogenesis. It was assumed that the local concentration of a particular morphogen tracked the local production or removal of tissue. Numerical examples revealed that solutions to such systems of equations could “develop a pattern or structure due to an instability of the homogeneous equilibrium, which is triggered off by random disturbances.” These solutions were proposed as possible descriptors of the morphogenesis. It was not until the
Biological Soft Tissues
1980s, however, that there was an increased interest in the use of reaction–diffusion models to study biological growth and remodeling, which now includes studies of wound healing, tumor growth, angiogenesis, and tissue engineering in addition to morphogenesis [7.52–56]. As noted by Turing, mechanics clearly plays an important role in such growth and remodeling, thus it is not surprising that there has been a trend to embed the reaction–diffusion framework within tissue mechanics (albeit often within the context of linearized elasticity or viscoelasticity). For example, Barocas and Tranquillo [7.53] suggested that reaction–diffusion models for spatial–temporal information on cells could be combined with a mixture theory representation of a tissue consisting of a fluid constituent and solid network. In this way, they studied mechanically stimulated cell migration, which is thought to be an early step towards mechanically stimulated changes in deposition of structural proteins. See the original paper for details. In summary, there has been significant attention to modeling the production, diffusion, and half-life of a host of molecules (growth factors, cytokines, proteases) and how they affect cell migration, mitosis, apoptosis, and the synthesis and reorientation of extracellular matrix. In some cases the reaction–diffusion models are used in isolation, but there has been a move towards combining such relations with those of mechanics (mass and momentum balance). Yet because of the lack of attention to the finite-strain kinematics and nonlinear material behavior characteristic of soft tissues [7.57], there is a pressing need for increased generalization if this approach is to become truly predictive. Moreover, there is a pressing need for additional biomechanical experiments throughout the evolution of the geometry and properties so that appropriate kinetic equations can be developed.
7.3.2 Kinematic Growth
being conserved, the overall mass density appeared to remain constant, thus focusing attention on changes in volume.) Tozeren and Skalak [7.59] suggested further that finite-strain growth and remodeling in a soft tissue (idealized as fibrous networks) could be described, in part, by considering that “The stress-free lengths of the fibers composing the network are not fixed as in an inert elastic solid, but are assumed to evolve as a result of growth and stress adaptation. Similarly, the topology of the fiber network may also evolve under the application of stress.” One of the remarkable aspects of Skalak’s work is that he postulated that, if differential growth is incompatible, then continuity of material may be restored via residual stresses. Residual stresses in arteries were reported soon thereafter (independently in 1983 by Vaishnav and Fung; see the discussion in [7.19]), and shown to affect dramatically the computed stress field in the arterial wall. The basic ideas of incompatible kinematic growth, residual stress, and evolving material symmetries and stress-free configurations were seminal contributions. Rodriguez et al. [7.60] built upon these ideas and put them into tensorial form – the approach was called “finite volumetric growth”, which is now described in brief. The primary assumption is that one models volumetric growth through a growth tensor Fg , which describes changes between two fictitious stress-free configurations: the original body is imagined to be fictitiously cut into small stress-free pieces, each of which is allowed to grow separately via Fg , with det Fg = 1. Because these growths need not be compatible, internal forces are often needed to assemble the grown pieces, via Fa , into a continuous configuration. This, in general, produces residual stresses, which are now known to exist in many soft tissues besides arteries. The formulation is completed by considering elastic deformations, via Fe , from the intact but residually stressed traction-free configuration to a current configuration that is induced by external mechanical loads. The initial–boundary value problem is solved by introducing a constitutive relation for the stress response to the deformation Fe Fa , which is often assumed to be isochoric and of the Fung type, plus a relation for the evolution of the stress-free configuration via Fg (actually Ug since the rotation Rg is assumed to be I). Thus, growth is assumed to occur in stress-free configurations and typically not to affect material properties. See, too, Lubarda and Hoger [7.61], who consider special cases of transversely isotropic and orthotropic growth. Among others, Taber [7.62] and Rachev et al. [7.63] independently embraced the concept of kinematic
179
Part A 7.3
In a seminal paper, Skalak [7.58] offered an approach very different from the reaction–diffusion approach, one that brought the analysis of biological growth within the purview of large-deformation continuum mechanics. He suggested that “any finite growth or change of form may be regarded as the integrated result of differential growth, i. e. growth of the infinitesimal elements making up the animal and plant.” His primary goal, therefore, was to “form a framework within which growth and deformation may be discussed in regard to the kinematics involved.” (Note: Although it was realized that mass may change over time, rather than
7.3 Growth and Remodeling – A New Frontier
180
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
growth and solved initial–boundary value problems relating to cardiac development, arterial remodeling in hypertension and altered flow, and aortic development. For the purposes of discussion, briefly consider the model of aortic growth by Taber [7.62]. The aortic wall was assumed to have material properties (given by Fung’s exponential relation) that remained constant during growth, which in turn was modeled via additional constitutive relations for time rates of change of the growth tensor Fg = diag[λgr , λgθ , 1], namely dλgr 1 ge t¯θθ (s) − t¯θθ , = dt Tr dλgθ 1 ge t¯θθ (s) − t¯θθ = dt Tθ 1 ge + τ¯w (s) − τ¯w eα(R/Ri −1) , Tτ
(7.16)
where Ti are time constants, t¯jj and τ¯w are mean values of wall stress and flow-induced wall shear stress, respectively, the superscript ‘ge’ denotes growthequilibrium, α is a parameter that reflects the intensity of effects, at any undeformed radial location R, of growth factors produced by the cells that line the arterial wall and interact directly with the blood. Clearly, growth (i. e., the time rate of change of the stress-free configuration in multiple directions) continues until the stresses return to their preferred or equilibrium values. Albeit not in the context of vascular mechanics, Klisch et al. [7.64] suggested further that the concept of volumetric growth could be incorporated within the theory of mixtures (with solid constituents k = 1, . . . , n and fluid constituent f ) to describe growth in cartilage. The deformation of constituent k was given by Fk = Fke Fak Fkg , where Fkg was related to a scalar mass growth function m k via t
Part A 7.3
det Fkg (t) = exp
m k dτ,
(7.17)
0
and mass balance requires dk ρ k + ρk div vk = ρk m k , dt dfρf + ρ f div v f = 0 . dt
(7.18)
This theory requires evolution equations for Fkg (or similarly, m k ), which the authors suggested could depend on the stresses, deformations, growth of other constituents, etc., as well as constitutive relations for the mass growth
function. It is clear that such a function could be related to the reaction–diffusion framework of Turing, and thus chemomechanical stimulation of growth. Although it is reasonable, in principle, to consider a full mixture theory given that so many different constituents contribute to the overall growth and structural stability of a tissue or organ, it is very difficult in practice to prescribe appropriate partial traction boundary conditions and very difficult to identify the requisite constitutive relations for momentum exchanges. Indeed, it is not clear that there is a need to model such detail, such as the momentum exchange between different proteins that comprise the extracellular matrix or between the extracellular matrix and a migrating cell, for example, particularly given that such migration involves complex chemical reactions (e.g., degradation of proteins at the leading edge of the cell) not just mechanical interactions. For these and other reasons, let us now consider an alternative mixture theory.
7.3.3 Constrained Mixture Approach Although the theory of kinematic growth yields many reasonable predictions, we have suggested that it models consequences of growth and remodeling (G&R), not the processes by which they occur. G&R necessarily occur in stressed, not fictitious stress-free, configurations, and they occur via the production, removal, and organization of different constituents; moreover, G&R need not restore stresses exactly to homeostatic values. Hence, we introduced a conceptually different approach to model G&R, one that is based on tracking the turnover of individual constituents in stressed configurations [7.65]. Here, we illustrate this approach for 2-D (membrane-like) tissues [7.66]. Briefly, let a soft tissue consist of multiple types of structurally important constituents, each of which must deform with the overall tissue but may have individual material properties and associated individual natural (i. e., stress-free) configurations that may evolve over time. We employ the concept of a constrained mixture wherein constituents deform together in current configurations and tacitly assume that they coexist within neighborhoods over which a local macroscopic homogenization would be meaningful. Specifically, not only may different constituents coexist at a point of interest, the same type of constituent produced at different instants can also coexist. Because of our focus on thin soft tissues consisting primarily of fibrillar collagen, one can consider a constitutive relation for the principal Cauchy stress resultants for the tissue (i. e., constrained mixture) of the
Biological Soft Tissues
form 1 ∂wk T1 (t) = T10 (t) + , λ2 (t) ∂λ1 (t) k
1 ∂wk , T2 (t) = T20 (t) + λ1 (t) ∂λ2 (t)
(7.19)
k
where Ti0 (i = 1, 2) represent contributions by an amorphous matrix (e.g., elastin-dominated or synthetic/reconstituted in a tissue equivalent) that can degrade but cannot be produced, λi are measurable principal stretches that are experienced by the tissue, and wk is a stored energy function for collagen family k, which may be produced or removed over time. Note, too, that 2 2 k (7.20) λ (t) = λ1 cos α0k + λ2 sin α0k are stretches experienced by fibers in collagen family k relative to a common mixture reference configuration, with α0k the angle between fiber family k and the 1 coordinate axis. To account for the deposition of new collagen fibers within stressed configurations, however, we further assume the existence of a preferred (i. e., homeostatic) deposition stretch G kh , whereby the stretch experienced by fiber family k, relative to its unique natural configuration, can be shown to be λkn(τ) (t) = G kh λk (t)/λk (τ) ,
(7.21)
with t the current time and τ the past time at which family k was produced. Finally, to account for continual production and removal, let the constituent stored energies be [7.66] wk (t) =
0
(7.22)
where ρ is the mixture mass density, M k (0) is the 2-D mass density of constituent k at time 0, when G&R commences, Q k (t) ∈ [0, 1] is the fraction of constituent k that was produced before time 0 but survives to the current time t > 0, m k is the current mass density production of constituent k, W k λkn(τ) (t) is the strain energy function for a fiber family relative to its unique natural configuration, and q k is
181
an associated survival function describing that fraction of constituent k that was produced at time τ (after time 0) and survives to the current time t. Hence, consistent with (7.4), the principal Cauchy stress resultants of the constituents that may turnover are k M (0)Q k (t)G kh ∂W k ∂λk (t) 1 T1k (t) = λ2 (t) ρλk (0) ∂λkn(τ) (t) ∂λ1 (t) t
m k (τ)q k (t − τ)G kh ρλk (τ) 0 ∂W k ∂λk (t) × k dτ , ∂λn(τ) (t) ∂λ1 (t) k M (0)Q k (t)G kh ∂W k ∂λk (t) 1 T2k (t) = λ1 (t) ρλk (0) ∂λkn(τ) (t) ∂λ2 (t) +
t
m k (τ)q k (t − τ)G kh ρλk (τ) 0 ∂W k ∂λk (t) × k dτ . ∂λn(τ) (t) ∂λ2 (t) +
(7.23)
As in most other applications of biomechanics, the key challenge therefore is to identify specific functional forms for the requisite constitutive relations, particularly the individual mass density productions, the survival functions, and the strain energy functions for the individual fibers, not to mention relations for muscle contractility and its adaptation. Finally, there is also a need to prescribe the alignment of newly produced fibers, not just their rate of production and removal. These, too, will require contributions from experimental biomechanics. Illustrative simulations are found nonetheless in the original paper [7.66], which show that stable versus unstable growth and remodeling can result, depending on the choice of constitutive relation. Given that the biomechanics of growth and remodeling is still in its infancy, it is not yet clear which approaches will ultimately prove most useful. The interested reader is thus referred to the following as examples of alternate approaches [7.67–71]. Finally, it is important to emphasize that, regardless of the specific theoretical framework, the most pressing need at present is an experimental program wherein the evolving mechanical properties and geometries of cells, tissues, and organs are quantified as a function of time during adaptations (or maladaptations) in response to altered mechanical loading, and that such information must be
Part A 7.3
M k (0) k Q (t)W k λkn(0) (t) ρ t k m (τ) k + q (t − τ)W k λkn(τ) (t) dτ , ρ
7.3 Growth and Remodeling – A New Frontier
182
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
correlated with changes in the rates of production and removal of structurally significant constituents, which in turn depend on the rates of production, removal, and diffusion of growth factors, proteases, and related substances. Clearly, biomechanics is not simply mechanics
applied to biology; it is the extension, development, and application of mechanics to problems in biology and medicine, which depends on theoretically motivated experimental studies that seek to identify new classes of constitutive relations.
7.4 Closure In summary, much has been accomplished in our quest to quantify the biomechanical behavior of soft tissues, yet much remains to be learned. Fortunately, continuing technological developments necessary for advancing experimental biomechanics (e.g., optical tweezers, atomic force and multiphoton microscopes, tissue bioreactors) combined with traditional methods of testing (e.g., computer-controlled in-plane biaxial testing of planar specimens, inflation and extension testing of tubular specimens, and inflation testing of membranous specimens; see [7.19] Chap. 5) as well as continuing advances in theoretical and computational mechanics are helping us to probe deeper into the mechanobiology and biomechanics every day. Thus,
both the potential and the promise of engineering contributions have never been greater. It is hoped, therefore, that this chapter provided some background, and especially some motivation, to contribute to this important field. The interested reader is also referred to a number of related books, listed in the Bibliography, and encouraged to consult archival papers that can be found in many journals, including Biomechanics and Modeling in Mechanobiology, the Journal of Biomechanics, and the Journal of Biomechanical Engineering. Indeed, an excellent electronic search engine is NIH PubMed, which can be found via the National Institutes of Health web site (www.nih.gov); it will serve us well as we continue to build on past achievements.
7.5 Further Reading
Part A 7.5
Given the depth and breadth of the knowledge base in biomedical research, no one person can begin to gain all of the needed expertise. Hence, biomechanical research requires teams consisting of experts in mechanics (theoretical, experimental, and computational) as well as biology, physiology, pathology, and clinical practice. Nevertheless, bioengineers must have a basic understanding of the biological concepts. I recommend, therefore, that the serious bioengineer keep nearby books on (i) molecular and cell biology, (ii) histology, and (iii) medical definitions. Below, I list some books that will serve the reader well.
• • • •
H. Abe, K. Hayashi, M. Sato: Data Book on Mechanical Properties of Living Cells, Tissues, and Organs (Springer, New York 1996) Dorland’s Illustrated Medical Dictionary (Saunders, Philadelphia 1988) S.C. Cowin, J.D. Humphrey: Cardiovascular Soft Tissue Mechanics (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht 2001) S.C. Cowin, S.B. Doty: Tissue Mechanics (Springer, New York 2007)
• • • • • • • • •
D. Fawcett: A Textbook of Histology (Saunders, Philadelphia 1986) Y.C. Fung: Biomechanics: Mechanical Properties of Living Tissues (Springer, New York 1993) F. Guilak, D.L. Butler, S.A. Goldstein, D.J. Mooney: Functional Tissue Engineering (Springer, New York 2003) G.A. Holzapfel, R.W. Ogden: Biomechanics of Soft Tissue in Cardiovascular Systems (Springer, Vienna 2003) G.A. Holzapfel, R.W. Ogden: Mechanics of Biological Tissue (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 2006) J.D. Humphrey, S.L. Delange: An Introduction to Biomechanics (Springer, New York 2004) V.C. Mow, R.M. Hochmuth, F. Guilak, R. TransSon-Tay: Cell Mechanics and Cellular Engineering (Springer, New York 1994) W.M. Saltzman: Tissue Engineering (Oxford Univ Press, Oxford 2004) L.A. Taber: Nonlinear Theory of Elasticity: Applications to Biomechanics (World Scientific, Singapore 2004)
Biological Soft Tissues
References
183
References 7.1
7.2
7.3
7.4 7.5 7.6
7.7
7.8
7.9
7.10
7.11
7.12 7.13
7.14
7.16 7.17
7.18
7.19
7.20
7.21 7.22
7.23
7.24
7.25
7.26 7.27
7.28
7.29
7.30
7.31
7.32
7.33
7.34
7.35
J.R. Walton, J.P. Wilber: Sufficient conditions for strong ellipticity for a class of anisotropic materials, Int. J. Nonlinear Mech. 38, 441–455 (2003) A.J.M. Spencer: Deformations of Fibre-Reinforced Materials (Clarendon, Oxford 1972) J.D. Humphrey, R.K. Strumpf, F.C.P. Yin: Determination of a constitutive relation for passive myocardium: I. A new functional form, ASME J. Biomech. Eng. 112, 333–339 (1990) M.S. Sacks, C.J. Chuong: Biaxial mechanical properties of passive right ventricular free wall myocardium, J. Biomech. Eng. 115, 202–205 (1993) J.C. Criscione, J.D. Humphrey, A.S. Douglas, W.C. Hunter: An invariant basis for natural strain which yields orthogonal stress response terms in isotropic hyperelasticity, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 48, 2445–2465 (2000) J.C. Criscione, A.S. Douglas, W.C. Hunter: Physically based strain invariant set for materials exhibiting transversely isotropic behavior, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 49, 871–897 (2001) Y. Lanir: Constitutive equations for fibrous connective tissues, J. Biomech. 16, 1–12 (1983) J.E. Bischoff, E.M. Arruda, K. Grosh: A rheological network model for the continuum anisotropic and viscoelastic behavior of soft tissues, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 3, 56–65 (2004) W. Maurel, Y. Wu, N. Magnenat, D. Thalmann: Biomechanical Models for Soft Tissue Simulation (Springer, Berlin 1998) G.A. Johnson, G.A. Livesay, S.L.Y. Woo, K.R. Rajagopal: A single integral finite strain viscoelastic model of ligaments and tendons, ASME J. Biomech. Eng. 118, 221–226 (1996) S. Baek, P.B. Wells, K.R. Rajagopal, J.D. Humphrey: Heat-induced changes in the finite strain viscoelastic behavior of a collagenous tissue, J. Biomech. Eng. 127, 580–586 (2005) M.F. Beatty, Z. Zhou: Universal motions for a class of viscoelastic materials of differential type, Continuum Mech. Thermodyn. 3, 169–191 (1991) G. David, J.D. Humphrey: Further evidence for the dynamic stability of intracranial saccular aneurysms, J. Biomech. 36, 1143–1150 (2003) P.P. Provenzano, R.S. Lakes, D.T. Corr, R. Vanderby Jr: Application of nonlinear viscoelastic models to describe ligament behavior, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 1, 45–57 (2002) H.W. Haslach: Nonlinear viscoelastic, thermodynamically consistent, models for biological soft tissues, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 3, 172–189 (2005) V.C. Mow, S.C. Kuei, W.M. Lai, C.G. Armstrong: Biphasic creep and stress relaxation of articular cartilage
Part A 7
7.15
J.F. Bell: Experimental foundations of solid mechanics,. In: Mechanics of Solids, Vol. I, ed. by C. Truesdell (Springer, New York 1973) C. Truesdell, W. Noll: The nonlinear field theories of mechanics. In: Handbuch der Physik, ed. by S. Flügge (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 1965) R.P. Vito: The mechanical properties of soft tissues: I. A mechanical system for biaxial testing, J. Biomech. 13, 947–950 (1980) J.C. Nash: Compact Numerical Methods for Computers (Wiley, New York 1979) J.T. Oden: Finite Elements of Nonlinear Continua (McGraw-Hill, New York 1972) K.T. Kavanaugh, R.W. Clough: Finite element application in the characterization of elastic solids, Int. J. Solid Struct. 7, 11–23 (1971) B. Alberts, A. Johnson, J. Lewis, M. Raff, K. Roberts, P. Walter: Molecular Biology of the Cell (Garland, New York 2002) D.Y.M. Leung, S. Glagov, M.B. Matthews: Cyclic stretching stimulates synthesis of matrix components by arterial smooth muscle cells in vitro, Science 191, 475–477 (1976) S. Glagov, C.-H. Ts’ao: Restitution of aortic wall after sustained necrotizing transmural ligation injury, Am. J. Pathol. 79, 7–23 (1975) L.E. Rosen, T.H. Hollis, M.G. Sharma: Alterations in bovine endothelial histidine decarboxylase activity following exposure to shearing stresses, Exp. Mol. Pathol. 20, 329–343 (1974) R.S. Rivlin, D.W. Saunders: Large elastic deformations of isotropic materials. VII. Experiments on the deformation of rubber, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 243, 251–288 (1951) Y.C. Fung: Biomechanics (Springer, New York 1990) M.F. Beatty: Topics in finite elasticity: Hyperelasticity of rubber, elastomers, and biological tissues with examples, Appl. Mech. Rev. 40, 1699–1734 (1987) L.R.G. Treloar: The Physics of Rubber Elasticity, 3rd edn. (Oxford Univ Press, Oxford 1975) A.E. Green, J.E. Adkins: Large Elastic Deformations (Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford 1970) R.W. Ogden: Non-Linear Elastic Deformations (Wiley, New York 1984) H.W. Haslach, J.D. Humphrey: Dynamics of biological soft tissue or rubber: Internally pressurized spherical membranes surrounded by a fluid, Int. J. Nonlinear Mech. 39, 399–420 (2004) G.A. Holzapfel, T.C. Gasser, R.W. Ogden: A new constitutive framework for arterial wall mechanics and a comparative study of material models, J. Elast. 61, 1–48 (2000) J.D. Humphrey: Cardiovascular Solid Mechanics (Springer, New York 2002)
184
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
7.36
7.37
7.38
7.39
7.40
7.41
7.42
7.43
7.44
7.45
7.46
Part A 7
7.47
7.48 7.49 7.50
7.51
in compression: Theory and experiments, ASME J. Biomech. Eng. 102, 73–84 (1980) W.M. Lai, V.C. Mow, W. Zhu: Constitutive modeling of articular cartilage and biomacromolecular solutions, J. Biomech. Eng. 115, 474–480 (1993) V.C. Mow, G.A. Ateshian, R.L. Spilker: Biomechanics of diarthroidal joints: A review of twenty years of progress, J. Biomech. Eng. 115, 460–473 (1993) J.M. Huyghe, G.B. Houben, M.R. Drost, C.C. van Donkelaar: An ionised/non-ionised dual porosity model of intervertebral disc tissue experimental quantification of parameters, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 2, 3–20 (2003) R.L. Spilker, J.K. Suh, M.E. Vermilyea, T.A. Maxian: Alternate Hybrid, Mixed, and Penalty Finite Element Formulations for the Biphasic Model of Soft Hydrated Tissues,. In: Biomechanics of Diarthrodial Joints, ed. by V.C. Mow, A. Ratcliffe, S.L.Y. Woo (Springer, New York 1990) pp. 401–436 B.R. Simon, M.V. Kaufman, M.A. McAfee, A.L. Baldwin: Finite element models for arterial wall mechanics, J. Biomech. Eng. 115, 489–496 (1993) R.A. Reynolds, J.D. Humphrey: Steady diffusion within a finitely extended mixture slab, Math. Mech. Solids 3, 147–167 (1998) G.I. Zahalak, B. de Laborderie, J.M. Guccione: The effects of cross-fiber deformation on axial fiber stress in myocardium, J. Biomech. Eng. 121, 376–385 (1999) A. Rachev, K. Hayashi: Theoretical study of the effects of vascular smooth muscle contraction on strain and stress distributions in arteries, Ann. Biomed. Eng. 27, 459–468 (1999) P.J. Hunter, A.D. McCulloch, H.E.D.J. ter Keurs: Modelling the mechanical properties of cardiac muscle, Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 69, 289–331 (1998) P.J. Hunter, P. Kohl, D. Noble: Integrative models of the heart: Achievements and limitations, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A359, 1049–1054 (2001) J.D. Humphrey: Continuum thermomechanics and the clinical treatment of disease and injury, Appl. Mech. Rev. 56, 231–260 (2003) K.R. Diller, T.P. Ryan: Heat transfer in living systems: Current opportunities, J. Heat. Transf. 120, 810–829 (1998) S.C. Cowin: Bone stress adaptation models, J. Biomech. Eng. 115, 528–533 (1993) D.R. Carter, G.S. Beaupré: Skeletal Function and Form (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 2001) C.D. Murray: The physiological principle of minimum work: I. The vascular system and the cost of blood volume, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 12, 207–214 (1926) A.M. Turing: The chemical basis of morphogenesis, Proc. R. Soc. London B 237, 37–72 (1952)
7.52
7.53
7.54
7.55
7.56
7.57
7.58
7.59
7.60
7.61
7.62
7.63
7.64
7.65
7.66
7.67
R.T. Tranquillo, J.D. Murray: Continuum model of fibroblast-driven wound contraction: Inflammationmediation, J. Theor. Biol. 158, 135–172 (1992) V.H. Barocas, R.T. Tranquillo: An anisotropic biphasic theory of tissue equivalent mechanics: The interplay among cell traction, fibrillar network, fibril alignment, and cell contact guidance, J. Biomech. Eng. 119, 137–145 (1997) L. Olsen, P.K. Maini, J.A. Sherratt, J. Dallon: Mathematical modelling of anisotropy in fibrous connective tissue, Math. Biosci. 158, 145–170 (1999) N. Bellomo, L. Preziosi: Modelling and mathematical problems related to tumor evolution and its interaction with the immune system, Math. Comput. Model. 32, 413–452 (2000) A.F. Jones, H.M. Byrne, J.S. Gibson, J.W. Dodd: A mathematical model of the stress induced during avascular tumour growth, J. Math. Biol. 40, 473–499 (2000) L.A. Taber: Biomechanics of growth, remodeling, and morphogenesis, Appl. Mech. Rev. 48, 487–545 (1995) R. Skalak: Growth as a finite displacement field, Proc. IUTAM Symposium on Finite Elasticity, ed. by D.E. Carlson, R.T. Shield (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague 1981) pp. 347–355 A. Tozeren, R. Skalak: Interaction of stress and growth in a fibrous tissue, J. Theor. Biol. 130, 337– 350 (1988) E.K. Rodriguez, A. Hoger, A.D. McCulloch: Stressdependent finite growth in soft elastic tissues, J. Biomech. 27, 455–467 (1994) V.A. Lubarda, A. Hoger: On the mechanics of solids with a growing mass, Int. J. Solid Struct. 39, 4627– 4664 (2002) L.A. Taber: A model for aortic growth based on fluid shear and fiber stresses, ASME J. Biomech. Eng. 120, 348–354 (1998) A. Rachev, N. Stergiopulos, J.-J. Meister: A model for geometric and mechanical adaptation of arteries to sustained hypertension, ASME J. Biomech. Eng. 120, 9–17 (1998) S.M. Klisch, T.J. van Dyke, A. Hoger: A theory of volumetric growth for compressible elastic biological materials, Math. Mech. Solid 6, 551–575 (2001) J.D. Humphrey, K.R. Rajagopal: A constrained mixture model for growth and remodeling of soft tissues, Math. Model. Meth. Appl. Sci. 12, 407–430 (2002) S. Baek, K.R. Rajagopal, J.D. Humphrey: A theoretical model of enlarging intracranial fusiform aneurysms, J. Biomech. Eng. 128, 142–149 (2006) R.A. Boerboom, N.J.B. Driessen, C.V.C. Bouten, J.M. Huyghe, F.P.T. Baaijens: Finite element model of mechanically induced collagen fiber synthesis and degradation in the aortic valve, Ann. Biomed. Eng. 31, 1040–1053 (2003)
Biological Soft Tissues
7.68
7.69
A. Gamba, D. Ambrosi, A. Coniglio, A. de Candia, S. Di Talia, E. Giraudo, G. Serini, L. Preziosi, F. Bussolino: Percolation morphogenesis and Burgers dynamics in blood vessels formation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 118101 (2003) D. Ambrosi, F. Mollica: The role of stress in the growth of a multicell spheroid, J. Math. Biol. 48, 477–488 (2004)
7.70
7.71
References
185
A. Menzel: Modeling of anisotropic growth in biological tissues: A new approach and computational aspects, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 3, 147–171 (2005) E. Kuhl, R. Haas, G. Himpel, A. Menzel: Computational modeling of arterial wall growth, Biomech. Model. Mechanobiol. 6, 321–332 (2007)
Part A 7
187
Electrochemo 8. Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
Sia Nemat-Nasser
The ionomeric polymer–metal composites (IPMCs) consist of polyelectrolyte membranes, with metal electrodes plated on both faces and neutralized with an amount of counterions, balancing the charge of anions covalently fixed to the membrane. IPMCs in the solvated state form soft actuators and sensors; they are sometimes referred to as artificial muscles. Here, we examine the nanoscale chemoelectromechanical mechanisms that underpin the macroscale actuation and sensing of IPMCs, as well as some of their electromechanical properties.
8.2.2 Pressure in Clusters ...................... 192 8.2.3 Membrane Stiffness ...................... 192 8.2.4 IPMC Stiffness .............................. 192 8.3 Voltage-Induced Cation Distribution ...... 193 8.3.1 Equilibrium Cation Distribution ...... 194 8.4 Nanomechanics of Actuation ................. 8.4.1 Cluster Pressure Change Due to Cation Migration ................ 8.4.2 Cluster Solvent Uptake Due to Cation Migration ................ 8.4.3 Voltage-Induced Actuation............
195 195 196 197
8.5 Experimental Verification ...................... 197 8.5.1 Evaluation of Basic Physical Properties ........... 197 8.5.2 Experimental Verification .............. 198
8.2 Stiffness Versus Solvation ...................... 191 8.2.1 The Stress Field in the Backbone Polymer .............. 191
8.6 Potential Applications ........................... 199 References .................................................. 199
Polyelectrolytes are polymers that carry covalentlybound positive or negative charges. They occur naturally, such as deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and ribonucleic acid (RNA), or they have been manuR factured for various applications, such as Nafion R or Flemion , which consist of three-dimensionally structured backbone perfluorinated copolymers of polytetrafluoroethylene, having regularly spaced long perfluorovinyl ether pendant side-chains that terminate in ionic sulfonate (Nafion) or carboxylate (Flemion) groups. The resulting Nafion or Flemion membranes are permeable to water or other polar solvents and cations, while they are impermeable to anions. The ionomeric polymer–metal composites (IPMCs) consist of polyelectrolyte membranes, about 200 μm thick, with metal electrodes (5–10 μm thick) plated on both faces [8.1] (Fig. 8.1). The polyelectrolyte matrix is neutralized with an amount of counterions, balancing
the charge of anions covalently fixed to the membrane. When an IPMC in the solvated (e.g., hydrated) state is stimulated with a suddenly applied small (1–3 V, depending on the solvent) step potential, both the fixed anions and mobile counterions are subjected to an electric field, with the counterions being able to diffuse toward one of the electrodes. As a result, the composite undergoes an initial fast bending deformation, followed by a slow relaxation, either in the same or in the opposite direction, depending on the composition of the backbone ionomer, and the nature of the counterion and the solvent. The magnitude and speed of the initial fast deflection also depend on the same factors, as well as on the structure of the electrodes, and other conditions (e.g., the time variation of the imposed voltage). IPMCs that are made from Nafion and are neutralized with alkali metals or with alkyl-ammonium cations (except for tetrabutylammonium, TBA+ ), invariably first bend to-
Microstructure and Actuation................. 8.1.1 Composition ................................ 8.1.2 Cluster Size .................................. 8.1.3 Actuation ....................................
Part A 8
188 188 189 191
8.1
188
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a)
b)
Au plating
Fig. 8.1a,b Cross section of (a) a Pt/Au-plated Nafion-117 membrane at electrode region; the length of the bar is 408 nm; and (b) an Auplated Flemion at electrode region; the length of the bar is 1 μm
Au plating
Platinum particles
Au 408 nm
Flemion
wards the anode under a step direct current (DC), and then relax towards the cathode while the applied voltage is being maintained, often moving beyond their starting position. In this case, the motion towards the anode can be eliminated by slowly increasing the applied potential at a suitable rate. For Flemion-based IPMCs, on the other hand, the initial fast bending and the subsequent relaxation are both towards the anode, for all counterions that have been considered. With TBA+ as the counterion, no noticeable relaxation towards the cathode has been recorded for either Nafionor Flemion-based IPMCs. Under an alternating electric
1μm
potential, cantilevered strips of IPMCs perform bending oscillations at the frequency of the applied voltage, usually no more than a few to a few tens of hertz, depending on the solvent. When an IPMC membrane is suddenly bent, a small voltage of the order of millivolts is produced across its faces. Hence, IPMCs of this kind can serve as soft actuators and sensors. They are sometimes referred to as artificial muscles [8.2, 3]. In this chapter, we examine the nanoscale chemoelectromechanical factors that underpin the macroscale actuation and sensing of IPMCs, as well as some of their electromechanical properties.
8.1 Microstructure and Actuation 8.1.1 Composition The Nafion-based IPMC, in the dry state, is about 180 μm thick and the Flemion-based one is about 160 μm thick (see [8.4–7] for further information on IPMC manufacturing). Samples consist of 1. backbone perfluorinated copolymer of polytetrafluoroethylene with perfluorinated vinyl ether sulfonate pendants for Nafion-based and perfluorinated b) Nanosized
a)
interconnected clusters
Cracked metal overlayer
Metal coating
Part A 8.1
Ionic polymer Naflon or Flamion
0.2 mm
Cluster group
Fig. 8.2 (a) A schematic representation of an IPMC and (b) a transmission electron microscopy (TEM) photo of the cluster structure (see Fig. 8.3 for more detail)
propyl ether carboxylate pendants for Flemionbased IPMCs, forming interconnected nanoscale clusters ([8.8]; primary physical data for fluorinated ionomers have been summarized in [8.9]) 2. electrodes, which in Nafion-based IPMCs consist of 3–10 nm-diameter platinum particles, distributed mainly within a 10–20 μm depth of both faces of the membrane, and usually covered with about 1 μmthick gold plating to improve surface conductivity, while in Flemion-based IPMCs, the electrodes are gold, with a dendritic structure, as shown in Fig. 8.1 3. neutralizing cations 4. a solvent Figure 8.2 shows a schematic representation of a typical IPMC, including a photograph of the nanostructure of the ionomer (Nafion, in this case), and a sketch of ionic polymer with metal coating. Figure 8.3 shows some additional details of a Nafion-based IPMC. The dark spots within the inset are the left-over platinum crystals. The ion exchange capacity (IEC) of an ionomer represents the amount of sulfonate (in Nafion) and carboxylate (in Flemion) group in the material, mea-
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
a) Metal overlayer
1μm
8.1 Microstructure and Actuation
b)
189
c)
O O
O
O
O O
Platinum diffusion zone (0 –25 μm)
Fig. 8.4 (a) Chemical structure of 18-Crown-6 (each node is CH2 ); (b) Na+ ion; and (c) K+ ion within a macrocyclic 18-Crown-6
ligand
8.1.2 Cluster Size Left-over platinum particles 20 nm
Fig. 8.3 Near-surface structure of an IPMC; the lower in-
set indicates the size of a typical cluster in Nafion
2 3NkT 3 NEWion Uela = − aI , ρ ∗ NA h 2 ρB + wρs ρ∗ = , 1+w
(8.1)
where N is the number of dipoles inside a typical cluster, k is Boltzmann’s constant, T is the temperature, h 2 is the mean end-to-end chain length, ρ∗ is the effective density of the solvated membrane, and NA is Avogadro’s number (6.023 × 1023 ). The electrostatic en-
Part A 8.1
sured in moles per unit dry polymer mass. The dry bare ionomer equivalent weight (EW) is defined as the weight in grams of dry ionomer per mole of its anion. The ion exchange capacity and the equivalent weight of Nafion are 0.91 meq/g and 1.100 g/mol, and those of Flemion are 1.44 meq/g and 694.4 g/mol, respectively. For neutralizing counterions, we have used Li+ , + Na , K+ , Rb+ , Cs+ , Mg2+ , and Al3+ , as well as alkylammonium cations TMA+ , TEA+ , TPA+ , and TBA+ . The properties of the bare ionomer, as well as those of the corresponding IPMC, change with the cation type for the same membrane and solvent. In addition to water, ethylene glycol, glycerol, and crown ethers have been used as solvents. Ethylene glycol or 1,2ethanediol (C2 H6 O2 ) is an organic polar solvent that can be used over a wide range of temperatures. Glycerol, or 1,2,3-propanetriol (C3 H8 O3 ) is another polar solvent with high viscosity (about 1000 times the viscosity of water). Crown ethers are cyclic oligomers of ethylene glycol that serve as macrocyclic ligands to surround and transport cations (Fig. 8.4). The required crown ether depends on the size of the ion. The 12-Crown-4 (12CR4) matches Li+ , 15-Crown-5 (15CR5) matches K+ , and 18-Crown-6 matched Na+ and K+ . For example, an 18-Crown-6 (18CR6) molecule has a cavity of 2.7 Å and is suitable for potassium ions of 2.66 Å diameter. A schematic configuration of this crown with sodium and potassium ions is shown in Fig. 8.4.
X-ray scanning of the Nafion membranes [8.10] has shown that, in the process of solvent absorption, hydrophilic regions consisting of clusters are formed within the membrane. Hydrophilicity and hydrophobicity are generally terms used for affinity or lack of affinity toward the polar molecule of water. In the present work we use these terms for interaction toward any polar solvent (e.g., ethylene–glycol). Cluster formation is promoted by the aggregation of hydrophilic ionic sulfonate groups located at the terminuses of vinyl ether sulfonate pendants of the polytetrafluoroethylene chain. While these regions are hydrophilic, the membrane backbone is hydrophobic and it is believed that the motion of the solvent takes place among these clusters via the connecting channels. The characteristics of these clusters and channels are important factors in IPMC behavior. The size of the solvated cluster radius aI depends on the cation form, the type of solvent used, and the amount of solvation. The average cluster size can be calculated by minimizing the free energy of the cluster formation with respect to the cluster size. The total energy for cluster formation consists of an elastic Uela , an electrostatic Uele , and a surface Usur component. The elastic energy is given by [8.11]
190
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a13 (nm3) 15
10
5
0
Model x-ray 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3 η 105
Fig. 8.5 Cluster size in Nafion membranes with different solvent uptakes
ergy is given by Uele = −g
N 2 m2 , 4πκe aI3
where n is the number of clusters present in the membrane. Minimizing this energy with respect to cluster tot = 0 , gives the optimum cluster size at size, ∂U ∂aI which the free energy of the ionomer is minimum. In this manner Li and Nemat-Nasser [8.11] have obtained ⎡ γ h 2 EWion (w + ΔV ) aI = ⎣ 2RT ρB −2 ⎤1/3 4πρ B ⎦ × 1− 3 ∗ , 3ρ (w + ΔV ) NA Vi ρd , (8.5) EWion where Vi is the volume of a single ion exchange site. Assuming that h 2 = EWion β [8.12], it can be seen that, ΔV =
(8.2)
aI3 =
−2 EW2ion (w + ΔV ) 4πρB 3 η= 1− . ρB 3ρ∗ (w + ΔV )
where g is a geometric factor, m is the dipole moment, and κe is the effective permittivity within the cluster. The surface energy can be expressed as
(8.6)
Usur = 4πaI2 γ ,
(8.3)
where γ is the surface energy density of the cluster. Therefore, the total energy due to the presence of clusters in the ionomer is given by Utot = n(Uele + Uela + Usur ) , a)
γβ η, 2RT
(8.4)
(c) t = 4m 45s
Figure 8.5 shows the variation of the cluster size (aI3 in nm3 ) for different solvent uptakes. Data from Nafion-based IPMC samples with different cations and different solvent uptakes are considered. The model is compared with the experimental results on the cluster size based on x-ray scanning, shown as circles
b)
c) –
(d) t = 6 m 27s –
R
+
t = 3ms t = 210ms
+
t = 5ms
t= 129ms
1cm
(a) t = 0 (b) t = 0.6 s
t = 10ms
t = 54ms t = 36ms
t = 15ms t = 24ms
Fig. 8.6 (a) A Nafion-based sample in the thallium (I) ion form is hydrated and a 1 V DC signal is suddenly applied
Part A 8.1
and maintained during the first 5 min, after which the voltage is removed and the two electrodes are shorted. Initial fast bend toward the bottom ((a) to (b), anode) occurs during the first 0.6 s, followed by a long relaxation upward (towards the cathode (c)) over 4.75 min. Upon shorting, the sample displays a fast bend in the same upward direction (not shown), followed by a slow downward relaxation (to (d)) during the next 1.75 min. (b) A Nafion-based sample in the sodium ion form is solvated with glycerol, and a 2 V DC signal is suddenly applied and maintained. It deforms into a perfect circle, but its qualitative response is the same. (c) A Flemion-based sample in tetrabutylammonium ion form is hydrated, and a 3 V DC signal is suddenly applied and maintained, resulting in continuous bending towards the anode (no back relaxation)
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
in Fig. 8.5 for a Nafion ionomer in various cation forms and with water as the solvent [8.10]. We have set β = 1.547, γ = 0.15, and Vi = 68 × 10−24 cm3 to calculate the cluster size [8.12].
8.1.3 Actuation A Nafion-based IPMC sample in the solvated state performs an oscillatory bending motion when an alternating voltage is imposed across its faces, and it produces a voltage when suddenly bent. When the same strip is subjected to a suddenly imposed and sustained constant voltage (DC) across its faces, an initial fast displacement (towards the anode) is gen-
8.2 Stiffness Versus Solvation
191
erally followed by a slow relaxation in the reverse direction (towards the cathode). If the two faces of the strip are then shorted during this slow relaxation towards the cathode, a sudden fast motion in the same direction (towards the cathode) occurs, followed by a slow relaxation in the opposite direction (towards the anode). Figure 8.6 illustrates these processes for a hydrated Tl+ -form Nafion-based IPMC (left), Na+ -form with glycerol as solvent (middle), and hydrated Flemion-based in TBA+ -form (right), under 1, 2, and 3 V DC, respectively. The magnitudes of the fast motion and the relaxation that follows the fast motion change with the corresponding cation and the solvent.
8.2 Stiffness Versus Solvation To model the actuation of the IPMC samples in terms of the chemoelectromechanical characteristics of the backbone ionomer, the electrodes, the neutralizing cation, the solvent, and the level of solvation, it is first necessary to model the stiffness of the corresponding samples. This is discussed in the present section. A dry sample of a bare polymer or an IPMC placed in a solvent bath absorbs solvent until the resulting pressure within its clusters is balanced by the elastic stresses that are consequently developed within its backbone polymer membrane. From this observation the stiffness of the membrane can be estimated as a function of the solvent uptake for various cations. Consider first the balance of the cluster pressure and the elastic stresses for the bare polymer (no metal plating) and then use the results to calculate the stiffness of the corresponding IPMC by including the effect of the added metal electrodes. The procedure also provides a way of estimating many of the nanostructural parameters that are needed for the modeling of the actuation of the IPMCs.
8.2.1 The Stress Field in the Backbone Polymer
σr (r0 ) = − p0 + K [(r0 /a0 )−3 (w/w0 − 1) + 1]−4/3 , σθ (r0 ) = σϕ (r0 ) = − p0 + K [(r0 /a0 )−3 (w/w0 − 1) + 1]2/3 ,
(8.7)
where r0 measures the initial radial length from the center of the cluster, and w0 is the initial (dry) volume fraction of the voids. Theeffective elastic resistance of the (homogenized solvated) membrane balances the cluster’s pressure pc which is produced by the combined osmotic and electrostatic forces within the cluster.
Part A 8.2
The stresses within the backbone polymer may be estimated by modeling the polymer matrix as an incompressible elastic material [8.13, 14]. Here, it will prove adequate to consider a neo-Hookean model for the matrix material. In this model, the principal stresses σI are related to the principal stretches λI by σI = − p0 + K λ2I ,
where p0 is an undetermined parameter (pressure) to be calculated from the boundary data and K is an effective stiffness, approximately equal to a third of the overall Young’s modulus. The aim is to calculate K and p0 as functions of the solvent uptake w for various ionform membranes. To this end, examine the deformation of a unit cell of the solvated polyelectrolyte (bare membrane) by considering a spherical cavity of initial (i. e., dry state) radius a0 (representing a typical cluster), embedded at the center of a spherical matrix of initial radius R0 , and placed in a homogenized solvated membrane, referred to as the matrix. In micromechanics, this is called the double-inclusion model [8.15]. Assume that the stiffness of both the spherical shell and the homogenized matrix is the same as that of the (as yet unknown) overall effective stiffness of the hydrated membrane. For an isotropic expansion of a typical cluster, the two hoop stretches (and stresses) are equal, and using the incompressibility condition and spherical coordinates, it follows that
192
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
8.2.2 Pressure in Clusters For the solvated bare membrane or an IPMC in the M+ -ion form, and in the absence of an applied electric field, the pressure within each cluster pc consists of osmotic Π(M+ ) and electrostatic pDD components. The electrostatic component is produced by the ionic interaction within the cluster. The cation–anion conjugate pairs can be represented as uniformly distributed dipoles on the surface of a spherical cluster, and the resulting dipole–dipole (DD) interaction forces pDD calculated. The osmotic pressure is calculated by examining the difference between the chemical potential of the free (bath) solvent and that of the solvent within a typical cluster of known ion concentration within the membrane. In this manner, one obtains [8.16] pc =
νQ − B K0φ
w RT K0 = , F
±α2
1 −2 Q , 3κe B w2 ρB F , Q− B = EWion +
by the volume of solid), respectively. The membrane Young’s modulus may now be set equal to YB = 3K (w), assuming that both the elastomer and solvent are essentially incompressible under the involved conditions.
8.2.4 IPMC Stiffness To include the effect of the metal plating on the stiffness, note that for the Nafion-based IPMCs the gold plating is about a 1 μm layer on both faces of an IPMC strip, while platinum particles are distributed through the first 10–20 μm surface regions, with diminishing density. Assume a uniaxial stress state and average the axial strain and stress over the strip’s volume to obtain their average values, as ε¯ IPMC = f MH ε¯ B + (1 − f MH )¯εM , σ¯ IPMC = f MH σ¯ B + (1 − f MH )σ¯ M ,
f MH =
fM , 1+w (8.10)
(8.8)
where φ is the practical osmotic coefficient, α is the effective length of the dipole, F is the Faraday constant, ν is the cation–anion valence (ν = 2 for monovalent cations), R = 8.314 J/mol/K is the universal gas constant, T is the cluster temperature, ρB is the density of the bare ionomer, and κe is the effective permittivity.
where the barred quantities are the average values of the axial strain and stress in the IPMC, bare (solvated) membrane, and metal electrodes, respectively (indicated by the corresponding subscripts ‘B’ and ‘M’, respectively); and f M is the volume fraction of the metal plating in a dry sample. Setting σ¯ B = YB ε¯ B , σ¯ M = YM ε¯ M , and σ¯ IPMC = Y¯IPMC ε¯ IPMC , it follows that YM YB , BAB YM + (1 − BAB )YB (1 + w)(1 − fM) ¯ B= , w = w(1 ¯ − fM) , 1 + w(1 − fM) ¯
Y¯IPMC =
8.2.3 Membrane Stiffness The radial stress σr must equal the pressure pc in the cluster at r0 = a0 . In addition, the volume average of the stress tensor, taken over the entire membrane, must vanish in the absence of any externally applied loads. This is a consistency condition that to a degree accounts for the interaction among clusters. These conditions are sufficient to yield the undetermined pressure p0 and the stiffness K in terms of solvation volume fraction w and the initial dry void volume fraction w0 for each ion-form bare membrane, leading to the following final closed-form results: 1+w , w0 In − (w0 /w)4/3 1 + 2An 0 1 + 2A w − , A= −1 , In = w0 n 0 (1 + An 0 )1/3 (1 + A)1/3 K = pc
Part A 8.2
(8.9)
where n 0 and w0 = n 0 /(1 − n 0 ) are the initial (dry) porosity and initial void ratio (volume of voids divided
(8.11)
where AB is the concentration factor, giving the average stress in the bare polymer in terms of the average stress of the IPMC σ¯ IPMC . Here YB = 3K is evaluated from (8.9) at solvation w ¯ when the solvation of the IPMC is w. The latter can be measured directly at various solvation levels. Experimentally, the dry and solvated dimensions (thickness, width, and length) and masses of each bare or plated sample are measured. Knowing the composition of the ionomer, the neutralizing cation, and the composition of the electrodes, all physical quantities in equations (8.8) and (8.11) are then known for each sample, except for the three parameters α, κe , and AB , namely the effective distance between the neutralizing cation and its conjugate covalently fixed anion, the effective electric permittivity of the cluster, and the concentration factor that defines the fraction of axial stress
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
carried by the bare elastomer in the IPMC. The parameters α and κe are functions of the solvation level. They play critical roles in controlling the electrostatic and chemical interaction forces within the clusters, as will be shown later in this chapter in connection with the IPMC’s actuation. Thus, they must be evaluated with care and with due regard for the physics of the process. Estimate of κe and α The solvents are polar molecules, carrying an electrostatic dipole. Water, for example, has a dipole moment of about 1.87 D (Debyes) in the gaseous state and about 2.42 D in bulk at room temperature, the difference being due to the electrostatic pull of other water molecules. Because of this, water forms a primary and a secondary hydration shell around a charged ion. Its dielectric constant as a hydration shell of an ion (about 6) is thus much smaller than that in bulk (about 78). The second term in expression (8.8) for the cluster pressure pc , can change by a factor of 13 for water as the solvent, depending on whether the water molecules are free or constrained to a hydration shell. Similar comments apply to other solvents. For example, for glycerol and ethylene glycol, the room-temperature dielectric constants are about 9 and 8 as solvation shells, and 46 and 41 when in bulk. When the cluster contains both free and ion-bound solvent molecules, its effective electric permittivity can be estimated using a micromechanical model. Let κ1 = ε1 κ0 and κ2 = ε2 κ0 be the electric permittivity of the solvent in a solvation shell and in bulk, respectively, where κ0 = 8.85 × 10−12 F/m is the electric permittivity of free space. Then, using a double-inclusion
8.3 Voltage-Induced Cation Distribution
193
model [8.15] it can be shown that κ2 + 2κ1 + f (κ2 − κ1 ) κ1 , κe = κ2 + 2κ1 − f (κ2 − κ1 ) m w − CN EWion w f = , mw = (8.12) . mw Msolvent ρB ν Here, CN is the static solvation shell (equal to the coordination number), m w is the number of moles of solvent per mole of ion (cation and anion), and ν = 2. When m w is less than CN, then all solvent molecules are part of the solvation shell, for which κe = ε1 κ0 . On the other hand, when there are more solvent molecules, equation (8.12) yields the corresponding value of κe . Thus, κe is calculated in a cluster in terms of the cluster’s volume fraction of solvent, w. Similarly, the dipole arm α in (8.8), which measures the average distance between a conjugate pair of anion– cation, is expected to depend on the effective dielectric constant of the solvation medium. We now calculate the parameter ±α2 , as follows. As a first approximation, we let α2 vary linearly with w for m w ≤ CN, i. e., we set ± α 2 = a1 w + a2 ,
for
m w ≤ CN ,
(8.13)
and estimate the coefficients a1 and a2 from the experimental data. For m w > CN, furthermore, we assume that the distance between the two charges forming a pseudodipole is controlled by the effective electric permittivity of the their environment (e.g., water molecules), and hence is given by 2 κe (a1 w + a2 ) . (8.14) α2 = 10−20 κ1 Note that for m w > CN, we have a1 w + a2 > 0. An illustrative example is given in Sect. 8.5 where measured results are compared with model predictions.
8.3 Voltage-Induced Cation Distribution terized by [8.17–19], Ci Di ∂μi (8.15) + Ci υi , RT ∂x where Di is the diffusivity coefficient, μi is the chemical potential, Ci is the concentration, and υi is the velocity of species i. The chemical potential is given by Ji = −
μi = μ0 + RT ln(γi Ci ) + z i φF ,
(8.16)
where μ0 is the reference chemical potential, γi is the affinity of species i, z i is the species charge, and
Part A 8.3
When an IPMC strip in a solvated state is subjected to an electric field, the initially uniform distribution of its neutralizing cations is disturbed, as cations on the anode side are driven out of the anode boundary clusters while the clusters in the cathode side are supplied with additional cations. This redistribution of cations under an applied potential can be modeled using the coupled electrochemical equations that characterize the net flux of the species, caused by the electrochemical potentials (chemical concentration and electric field gradients). The total flux consists of cation migration and solvent transport. The flux Ji of species i is charac-
194
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
φ = φ(x, t) is the electric potential. For an ideal solution where γi = 1, and if there is only one type of cation, the subscript i may be dropped, as will be done in what follows. The variation in the electric potential field in the membrane is governed by the basic Poisson’s electrostatic equations [8.20, 21], ∂(κ E) = z(C − C − )F , ∂x
E=−
∂φ , ∂x
(8.17)
where E and κ are the electric field and the electric permittivity, respectively; C − is the anion concentration in moles per unit solvated volume; and C = C(x, t) is the total ion (cation and anion) concentration. Since the solvent velocity is very small, the last term in (8.15) may be neglected and, in view of (8.17) and continuity, it follows that
∂C(x, t) J(x, t) = −D ∂x F − zC(x, t) E(x, t) , RT ∂C(x, t) ∂J(x, t) =− , ∂t ∂x ∂E(x, t) F (8.18) =z (C(x, t) − C − ) . ∂x κ¯ Here κ¯ is the overall electric permittivity of the solvated IPMC sample that can be estimated from its measured effective capacitance. The above system of equations can be directly solved numerically, or they can be solved analytically using approximations. In the following sections, the analytic solution is considered. First, from (8.18) it follows that
∂ ∂(κ E) −D ∂x ∂t
∂ 2 (κ E) ∂x 2
−
C− F2 κ RT
(κ E)
=0. (8.19)
Part A 8.3
This equation provides a natural length scale and a natural time scale τ that characterize the ion redistribution, 2 κ¯ RT 1/2 , τ= (8.20) , = − 2 D C F where κ¯ is the overall electric permittivity of the IPMC. If Cap is the measured overall capacitance, then we set √ κ¯ = 2HCap. Since is linear in κ¯ and κ¯ is proportional to the capacitance, it follows that is proportional to the square root of the capacitance.
8.3.1 Equilibrium Cation Distribution To calculate the ion redistribution caused by the application of a step voltage across the faces of a hydrated strip of IPMC, we first examine the time-independent equilibrium case with J = 0. In the cation-depleted (anode) boundary layer the charge density is −C − F, whereas in the remaining part of the membrane the charge density is (C + − C − )F. Let the thickness of the cation-depleted zone be denoted by and set Q(x, t) =
C+ − C− , C−
Q 0 (x) = lim Q(x, t) . t→∞
(8.21)
Then, it follows from (8.17) and boundary and continuity conditions that [8.16] the equilibrium distribution is given by ⎧ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨−1 for x ≤ −h + Q 0 (x) ≡
F RT [B0 exp(x/) − B1 exp(−x/)] , ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ for − h + < x < h ,
(8.22)
2φ0 F B1 = K 0 exp(−a ) , = −2 , RT
2 φ0 1 B2 = − K0 +1 +1 , 2 2 B0 = exp(−a) φ0 /2 + B1 exp(−a) + B2 , F K0 = (8.23) , RT where φ0 is the applied potential, a ≡ h/, and a ≡ (h − )/. Since is only 0.5–3 μm, a ≡ h/, a ≡ h / 1, and hence exp(−a) ≈ 0 and exp(−a ) ≈ 0. The constants B0 and B1 are very small, of the order of 10−17 or even smaller, depending on the value of the capacitance. Therefore, the approximation used to arrive at (8.22) does not compromise the accuracy of the results. Remarkably, the estimated length of the anode boundary layer with charge √constant negative density −C − F, i. e., = 2φ0 F/RT − 2 , depends only on the applied potential and the effective capacitance through the characteristic length. We use as our length scale. From (8.23) it can be concluded that, over the most central part of the membrane, there is charge neutrality within all clusters, and the charge imbalance in clusters occurs only over narrow boundary layers, with the anode boundary layer being thicker
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
than the cathode boundary layer. The charge imbalance in the clusters is balanced by the corresponding electrode charges. Therefore, the charge imbalance defined by (8.23) applies to the clusters within each boundary layer and not to the boundary layer itself, since the combined clusters and the charged metal particles within the boundary layers are electrically balanced. We now examine the time variation of the charge distribution that results upon the application of a step voltage and leads to the equilibrium solution given above. To this end, rewrite equation (8.19) as 2 ∂ Q Q ∂Q − 2 =0, (8.24) −D ∂t ∂x 2 and set Q = ψ(x, t) exp(−t/τ) + Q 0 (x) to obtain the following standard diffusion equation for ψ(x, t): ∂ψ ∂2ψ =D 2 , ∂t ∂x
ψ(x, 0) = −Q 0 (x) ,
(8.25)
from which it can easily be concluded that, to a good degree of accuracy, one may use the following simple approximation in place of an exact infinite series
8.4 Nanomechanics of Actuation
195
solution [8.16]: Q(x, t) ≈ g(t)Q 0 (x) , g(t) = 1 − exp(−t/τ) . (8.26) Actually, when the electric potential is suddenly applied and then maintained, say, at a constant level φ0 , the cations of the anode clusters are initially depleted at the same rate as cations being added to the clusters within the cathode boundary layer. Thus, initially, the cation distribution is antisymmetric through the thickness of the membrane, as shown by Nemat-Nasser and Li [8.22], C(x) = C − +
κφ ¯ 0 sinh(x/) . 2F2 sinh(h/)
(8.27)
After a certain time period, say, τ1 , clusters near the anode face are totally depleted of their cations, so only the length of the anode boundary layer can further increase, while the cathode clusters continue to receive additional cations. Recognizing this fact, recently Nemat-Nasser and Zamani [8.23] have used one time scale for the first event and another time scale for the remaining process of cation redistribution. To simulate the actuation, however, these authors continue to use the one-time-scale approximation similar to (8.26).
8.4 Nanomechanics of Actuation changes in the pressure within the clusters in the anode and cathode boundary layers, and the resulting diffusive flow of solvent into or out of the corresponding clusters.
8.4.1 Cluster Pressure Change Due to Cation Migration The elastic pressure on a cluster can be calculated from (8.7) by simply setting r0 = aI , where aI is the initial cluster size just before the potential is applied, and using the spatially and temporally changing volume fraction of solvent and ion concentration w(x, t) and ν(x, t), since the osmotic pressure depends on the cluster’s ion concentration and it is reduced in the anode and is increased in the cathode clusters. The corresponding osmotic pressure can be computed from Π(x, t) =
φQ − C + (x, t) B K0 +1 , ν(x, t) , ν(x, t) = w(x, t) C− (8.28)
C + (x, t)
where is the cation concentration; note from (8.21) that ν(x, t) = Q(x, t) + 2. The pressure pro-
Part A 8.4
The application of an electric potential produces two thin boundary layers, one near the anode and the other near the cathode electrodes, while maintaining overall electric neutrality in the IPMC strip. The cation imbalance within the clusters of each boundary layer changes the osmotic, electrostatic, and elastic forces that tend to expand or contract the corresponding clusters, forcing the solvents out of or into the clusters, and producing the bending motion of the sample. Thus, the volume fraction of the solvent within each boundary layer is controlled by the effective pressure in the corresponding clusters produced by the osmotic, electrostatic, and elastic forces. These forces can even cause the cathode boundary layer to contract during the back relaxation that is observed for Nafion-based IPMCs in various alkali metal forms, expelling the extra solvents onto the IPMC’s surface while cations continue to accumulate within the cathode boundary layer. This, in fact, is what has been observed in open air during the very slow back relaxation of IPMCs that are solvated with ethylene glycol or glycerol [8.24]. To predict this and other actuation responses of IPMCs, it is thus necessary to model the
196
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
duced by the electrostatic forces among interacting fixed anions and mobile cations within each cluster varies as the cations move into or out of the cluster in response to the imposed electric field. As the cations of the clusters within the anode boundary layer are depleted, the dipole–dipole interaction forces diminish. We model this in the anode boundary layer by calculating the resulting pressure, pADD , as a function of the cation concentration, as follows: 2 + 1 C (x, t) −2 α(x, t) pADD (x, t) = . Q 3κ(x, t) B w(x, t) C− (8.29)
Parallel with the reduction in the dipole–dipole interaction forces is the development of electrostatic interaction forces among the remaining fixed anions, which introduces an additional pressure, say pAA , 1 2 pAA (x, t) = Q− B 18κ(x, t) R02 C + (x, t) × 1− , (8.30) C− [w(x, t)]4/3 where R0 is the initial (unsolvated, dry) cluster size. This expression is obtained by considering a spherical cluster with uniformly distributed anion charges on its surface. The total pressure within a typical anode boundary layer cluster hence is tA (x, t) = −σr (a0 , t) + Π(x, t) + pAA (x, t) + pADD (x, t) .
(8.31)
Part A 8.4
Consider now the clusters in the cathode boundary layer. In these clusters, in addition to the osmotic pressure we identify two forms of electrostatic interaction forces. One is repulsion due to the cation–anion pseudodipoles already present in the clusters, and the other is due to the extra cations that migrate into the clusters and interact with the existing pseudo-dipoles. The additional stresses produced by this latter effect may tend to expand or contract the clusters, depending on the distribution of cations relative to fixed anions. We again model each effect separately, although in fact they are coupled. The dipole–dipole interaction pressure in the cathode boundary layer clusters is assumed to be reduced as 1 α(x, t) 2 2 Q− pCDD (x, t) = 3κ(x, t) B w(x, t) C− × (8.32) , C + (x, t)
while at the same time new dipole–cation interaction forces are being developed as additional cations enter the clusters and disturb the pseudo-dipole structure in the clusters. The pressure due to these latter forces is represented by pDC (x, t) =
2 2Q − R0 α(x, t) C(x, t) B − 1 . 9κ(x, t) [w(x, t)]5/3 C− (8.33)
However, for sulfonates in a Nafion-based IPMC, we expect extensive restructuring and redistribution of the cations. It appears that this process underpins the observed reverse relaxation of the Nafion-based IPMC strip. Indeed, this redistribution of the cations within the clusters in the cathode boundary layer may quickly diminish the value of pCD to zero or even render it negative. To represent this, we modify (8.33) by a relaxation factor, and write 2Q − R0 αC (x, t) B pDC (x, t) ≈ 9κC (x, t) [wC (x, t)]5/3 + C (x, t) × − 1 g1 (t) , C− g1 (t) = [r0 + (1 − r0 ) exp(−t/τ1 )], 2
r0 < 1 , (8.34)
where τ1 is the relaxation time and r0 is the equilibrium fraction of the dipole–cation interaction forces. The total stress in clusters within the cathode boundary layer is now approximated by tC = −σr (a0 , t) + ΠC (x, t) + pCDD (x, t) + pDC (x, t) . (8.35)
8.4.2 Cluster Solvent Uptake Due to Cation Migration The pressure change in clusters within the anode and cathode boundary layers drives solvents into or out of these clusters. This is a diffusive process that can be modeled using the continuity equation ∂υ x, t w ˙ x, t + (8.36) =0, ∂x 1 + w x, t and a constitutive model to relate the gradient of the solvent velocity, ∂υ(x, t)/∂x, to the cluster pressure. We may use a linear relation and obtain w ˙ i x, t = DBL ti x, t , i = A, C , (8.37) 1 + wi x, t
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
where DBL is the boundary-layer diffusion coefficient, assumed to be constant here.
8.4.3 Voltage-Induced Actuation As is seen from Fig. 8.6, an IPMC strip can undergo large deflections under an applied electric potential. Since the membrane is rather thin (0.2 mm) even if it deforms from a straight configuration into a circle of radius, say 1 cm still the radius-to-thickness ratio would be 50, suggesting that the maximum axial strain in the membrane is very small. It is thus reasonable to use a linear strain distribution through the thickness and use the following classical expression for the maximum strain: εmax ≈ ±
H , Rb
(8.38)
8.5 Experimental Verification
197
where Rb is the radius of the curvature of the membrane and H is half of its thickness. The strain in the membrane is due to the volumetric changes that occur within the boundary layers, and can be estimated from εv (x, t) = ln[1 + w(x, t)] .
(8.39)
We assume that the axial strain is one-third of the volumetric strain, integrate over the thickness, and obtain L L = Rb 2H 3 (3Y IPMC − 2YB ) h × YBL (w(x, t))x ln[1 + w(x, t)] dx , (8.40) −h
where all quantities have been defined before and are measurable.
8.5 Experimental Verification We now examine some of the experimental results that have been used to characterize this material and to verify the model results.
8.5.1 Evaluation of Basic Physical Properties Both the bare ionomer and the corresponding IPMC can undergo large dimensional changes when solvated. The phenomenon is also affected by the nature of the neutralizing cation and the solvent. This, in turn, substantially changes the stiffness of the material. Therefore, techniques have been developed to measure the dimensions and the stiffness of the ma-
terial in various cation forms and at various solvation stages. The reader is referred to Nemat-Nasser and Thomas [8.25, 26], Nemat-Nasser and Wu [8.27], and Nemat-Nasser and Zamani [8.23] for the details of various measurements and extensive experimental results. In what follows, a brief account of some of the essential features is presented. One of the most important quantities that characterize the ionic polymers is the material’s equivalent weight (EW), defined as dry mass in grams of ionic polymer in proton form divided by the moles of sulfonate (or carboxylate) groups in the polymer. It is expressed in grams per mole, and is measured by neutralizing the same sample sequentially with deferent
Table 8.1 Measured stiffness of dry and hydrated Nafion/Flemion ionomers and IPMCs in various cation forms Thickness
⎧ ⎨ Bare
Nafion
⎧ ⎨ Flemion IPMC
⎩
Nafion-based Flemion-based
K+ Cs+ Na+ K+ Cs+ Cs+ Cs+
Stiffness
Thickness
Water-saturated form Density Stiffness
(μm)
(g/cm3 )
(MPa)
(μm)
(g/cm3 )
(MPa)
Hydration volume (%)
182.1 178.2 189.1 149.4 148.4 150.7 156.0 148.7
2.008 2.065 2.156 2.021 2.041 2.186 3.096 3.148
1432.1 1555.9 1472.2 2396.0 2461.2 1799.2 1539.5 2637.3
219.6 207.6 210.5 167.6 163.0 184.2 195.7 184.1
1.633 1.722 1.836 1.757 1.816 1.759 2.500 2.413
80.5 124.4 163.6 168.6 199.5 150.6 140.4 319.0
71.3 50.0 41.4 42.0 34.7 53.7 54.1 58.1
Part A 8.5
⎩
Na+
Dry form Density
198
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 8.5
cations, and measuring the changes in the weight of the sample. This change is directly related to the number of anion sites within the sample and the difference in the atomic weight of the cations. Another important parameter is the solvent uptake w, defined as the volume of the solvent divided by the volume of the dry sample. Finally, it is necessary to measure the weight fraction of the metal in an IPMC sample, which is usually about 40%. The uniaxial stiffness of both the bare ionomer and the corresponding IPMC changes with the solvent uptake. It is also a function of the cation form, the solvent, and the backbone material. Table 8.1 gives some data on bare and metal-plated Nafion and Flemion in the indicated cation forms. Note that the stiffness can vary by a factor of ten for the same sample depending on whether it is dry or fully hydrated. Surface conductivity is an important electrical property governing an IPMC’s actuation behavior. When applying a potential across the sample’s thickness at the grip end, the bending of the cantilever is affected by its surface resistance, which in turn is dependent on the electrode morphology, cation form, and the level of solvation. An applied electric field affects the cation distribution within an IPMC membrane, forcing the cations to migrate towards the cathode. This change in the cation distribution produces two thin layers, one near the anode and the other near the cathode boundaries. In time, and once an equilibrium state is attained, the anode boundary layer is essentially depleted of its cations, while the cathode boundary layer has become cation rich. If the applied constant electric potential is V and the corresponding total charge that is accumulated within the cathode boundary layer once the equilibrium state is attained is Q, then the effective electric capacitance of the IPMC is defined as C = Q/V . From this, one obtains the corresponding areal capacitance, measured in mF/cm2 , by dividing by the area of the sample. Usually, the total equilibrium accumulated charge can be calculated by time integration of the measured net current, and using the actual dimensions of the saturated sample. For alkali-metal cations, one may have capacitance of 1–50 mF/cm2 for an IPMC.
8.5.2 Experimental Verification As an illustration of the model verification, consider first the measured and modeled stiffness of the bare and metal-plated Nafion-based samples (Fig. 8.7). Here, the
Stiffness (MPa) 2500 Experimental_bare Naflon Experimental_IPMC (Sh2) Experimental_IPMC (Sh5) Model_bare Naflon Model_Naflon IPMC
2000 1500 1000 500 0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Hydration (%)
Fig. 8.7 Uniaxial stiffness (Young’s modulus) of bare Nafion-117 (lower data points and the solid curve, model) and an IPMC (upper data points and solid curve) in the Na+ -form versus hydration water
lower data points and the solid curve are for the bare ionomer in Na+ -form, and the upper data points and the solid curve are for the corresponding IPMC. The model results have been obtained for the bare Nafion using (8.9) and for the IPMC from (8.11). In (8.9), φ is taken to be 1 and n 0 to be 1%. The dry density of the bare membrane is measured to be 2.02 g/cm3 , the equivalent weight for Nafion-117 in Na+ -form (with 23 atomic weight for sodium) is calculated to be 1122, the electric permittivity is calculated from (8.12) with CN = 4.5, the temperature is taken to be 300 K (room temperature), and κe is calculated using (8.12), with α2 Tip displacement/gauge length 0.12 Experiment Model
0.08 0.04 0 –0.04 –0.08 –0.12 –0.16 –10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Time (s)
Fig. 8.8 Tip displacement of a 15 mm cantilevered strip of a Nafion-based IPMC in Na+ -form, subjected to a 1.5 V step potential for about 32 s, then shorted; the solid curve is the model and the geometric symbols are experimental points
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
being calculated from (8.13) or (8.14) depending on the level of hydration, i. e., the value of w. The only free parameters are then a1 and a2 , which are calculated to be a1 = 1.5234 × 10−20 and a2 = −0.0703 × 10−20 , using two data points. In (8.11), f M is measured to be 0.0625, YM is 75 GPa, and AB (the only free parameter) is set equal to 0.5. To check the model prediction of the observed actuation response of this Nafion-based IPMC, consider a hydrated cantilevered strip subjected to a 1.5 V step potential across its faces that is maintained for 32 s and then shorted. Figure 8.8 shows (geometric symbols) the measured tip displacement of a 15 mm-long cantilever strip that is actuated by applying a 1.5 V step potential across its faces, maintaining the voltage for about 32 s and then removing the voltage while the two faces are shorted. The initial water uptake is wIPMC = 0.46, and the volume fraction of metal plating is 0.0625. Hence, the initial volume fraction of water in the Nafion part of the IPMC is given by wI = wIPMC /(1 − f M ) = 0.49. The formula weight of sodium is 23, and the dry density of the bare membrane is 2.02 g/cm3 . With EWNa+ = 1122 g/mol, the initial value of C − for the
References
199
bare Nafion becomes 1208. The thickness of the hydrated strip is measured to be 2H = 224 μm, and based on inspection of the microstructure of the electrodes, we set 2h ≈ 212 μm. The effective length of the anode boundary layer for φ0 = 1.5 V is L A = 9.78, and in order to simplify the model calculation of the solvent flow into or out of the cathode clusters, an equivalent uniform boundary layer is used near the cathode whose thickness is then estimated to be L C = 2.84, where = 0.862 μm for φ0 = 1.5 V. The electric permittivity and the dipole length are calculated using a1 = 1.5234 × 10−20 and a2 = −0.0703 × 10−20 , which are the same as for the stiffness modeling. The measured capacitance ranges from 10 to 20 mF/cm2 , and we use 15 mF/cm2 . Other actuation model parameters are: DA = 10−2 (when pressure is measured in MPa), τ = 1/4 and τ1 = 4 (both in seconds), and r0 = 0.25. Since wI ≈ (a/R0 )3 , where a is the cluster size at wa−1/3 ter uptake wI , we set R0 ≈ w0 a, and adjust a to fit the experimental data; here, a = 1.65 nm, or an average cluster size of 3.3 nm, prior to the application of the potential. The fraction of cations that are left after shorting is adjusted to r = 0.03.
8.6 Potential Applications tors in space-based applications [8.2, 37], as their lack of multiple moving parts is ideal for any environment where maintenance is difficult. Besides these, IPMCs find applications in other disciplines, including fuel-cell membranes, electrochemical sensing [8.38], and electrosynthesis [8.2, 37, 39], as their lack of multiple moving parts is ideal for any environment where maintenance is difficult. Besides these, IPMCs find applications in other disciplines, including fuelcell membranes, electrochemical sensing [8.38], and electrosynthesis [8.39]. The commercial availability of Nafion has enabled alternate uses for these materials to be found. Growth and maturity in the field of IPMC actuators will require exploration beyond these commercially available polymer membranes, as the applications for which they have been designed are not necessarily optimal for IPMC actuators.
References 8.1
P. Millet: Noble metal-membrane composites for electrochemical applications, J. Chem. Ed. 76(1), 47– 49 (1999)
8.2
Y. Bar-Cohen, T. Xue, M. Shahinpoor, J.O. Simpson, J. Smith: Low-mass muscle actuators using elec-
Part A 8
The ultimate success of IPMC materials depends on their applications. Despite the limited force and frequency that IPMC materials can offer, a number of applications have been proposed which take advantage of IPMCs’ bending response, low voltage/power requirements, small and compact design, lack of moving parts, and relative insensitivity to damage. Osada and coworkers have described a number of potential applications for IPMCs, including catheters [8.28, 29], elliptic friction drive elements [8.30], and ratchet-and-pawl-based motile species [8.31]. IPMCs are being considered for applications to mimic biological muscles; Caldwell has investigated artificial muscle actuators [8.32, 33] and Shahinpoor has suggested applications ranging from peristaltic pumps [8.34] and devices for augmenting human muscles [8.35] to robotic fish [8.36]. Bar-Cohen and others have discussed the use of IPMC actua-
200
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
8.3
8.4
8.5
8.6
8.7
8.8
8.9
8.10
8.11
8.12
8.13 8.14 8.15
8.16
8.17
Part A 8
8.18 8.19
troactive polymers (EAP), Proc. SPIE. 3324, 218–223 (1998) Y. Bar-Cohen, S. Leary, M. Shahinpoor, J.O. Harrison, J. Smith: Electro-active polymer (EAP) actuators for planetary applications, SPIE Conference on Electroactive Polymer Actuators, Proc. SPIE. 3669, 57–63 (1999) R. Liu, W.H. Her, P.S. Fedkiw: In situ electrode formation on a Nafion membrane by chemical platinization, J. Electrochem. Soc. 139(1), 15–23 (1992) M. Homma, Y. Nakano: Development of electrodriven polymer gel/platinum composite membranes, Kagaku Kogaku Ronbunshu 25(6), 1010–1014 (1999) T. Rashid, M. Shahinpoor: Force optimization of ionic polymeric platinum composite artificial muscles by means of an orthogonal array manufacturing method, Proc. SPIE 3669, 289–298 (1999) M. Bennett, D.J. Leo: Manufacture and characterization of ionic polymer transducers with non-precious metal electrodes, Smart Mater. Struct. 12(3), 424–436 (2003) C. Heitner-Wirguin: Recent advances in perfluorinated ionomer membranes – structure, properties and applications, J. Membr. Sci. 120(1), 1–33 (1996) R.E. Fernandez: Perfluorinated ionomers. In: Polymer Data Handbook, ed. by J.E. Mark (Oxford Univ. Press, New York 1999) pp. 233–238 T.D. Gierke, C.E. Munn, P.N. Walmsley: The morphology in Nafion perfluorinated membrane products, as determined by wide- and small-angle X-ray studies, J. Polym. Sci. Polym. Phys. Ed. 19, 1687–1704 (1981) J.Y. Li, S. Nemat-Nasser: Micromechanical analysis of ionic clustering in Nafion perfluorinated membrane, Mech. Mater. 32(5), 303–314 (2000) W.A. Forsman: Statistical mechanics of ion-pair association in ionomers, Proc. NATO Adv. Workshop Struct. Properties Ionomers (1986) pp. 39–50 L.R.G. Treolar: Physics of Rubber Elasticity (Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford 1958) R.J. Atkin, N. Fox: An Introduction to the Theory of Elasticity (Longman, London 1980) S. Nemat-Nasser, M. Hori: Micromechanics: Overall Properties of Heterogeneous Materials, 1st edn. (North-Holland, Amsterdam 1993) S. Nemat-Nasser: Micromechanics of actuation of ionic polymer-metal composites, J. Appl. Phys. 92(5), 2899–2915 (2002) J. O’M Bockris, A.K.N. Reddy: Modern Electrochemistry 1: Ionics, Vol. 1 (Plenum, New York 1998) P. Shewmon: Diffusion in Solids, 2nd edn. (The Minerals Metals & Materials Society, Warrendale 1989) M. Eikerling, Y.I. Kharkats, A.A. Kornyshev, Y.M. Volfkovich: Phenomenological theory of electro-osmotic effect and water management in polymer electrolyte proton-conducting membranes, J. Electrochem. Soc. 145(8), 2684–2699 (1998)
8.20 8.21 8.22
8.23
8.24
8.25
8.26
8.27
8.28
8.29
8.30
8.31
8.32
8.33 8.34
8.35
8.36
J.D. Jackson: Classical Electrodynamics (Wiley, New York 1962) W.B. Cheston: Elementary Theory of Electric and Magnetic Fields (Wiley, New York 1964) S. Nemat-Nasser, J.Y. Li: Electromechanical response of ionic polymer-metal composites, J. Appl. Phys. 87(7), 3321–3331 (2000) S. Nemat-Nasser, S. Zamani: Modeling of electrochemo-mechanical response of ionic-polymermetal composites with various solvents, J. Appl. Phys. 38, 203–219 (2006) S. Nemat-Nasser, S. Zamani, Y. Tor: Effect of solvents on the chemical and physical properties of ionic polymer-metal composites, J. Appl. Phys. 99, 104902 (2006) S. Nemat-Nasser, C. Thomas: Ionomeric polymermetal composites. In: Electroactive Polymer (EAP) Actuators as Artificial Muscles, ed. by Y. Bar-Cohen (SPIE, Bellingham 2001) pp. 139–191 S. Nemat-Nasser, C. Thomas: Ionomeric polymermetal composites. In: Electroactive Polymer (EAP) Actuators as Artificial Muscles 2nd edn, ed. by Y. BarCohen (SPIE, Bellingham 2004) pp. 171–230 S. Nemat-Nasser, Y. Wu: Comparative experimental study of Nafion-and-Flemion-based ionic polymermetal composites (IPMC), J. Appl. Phys. 93(9), 5255– 5267 (2003) S. Sewa, K. Onishi, K. Asaka, N. Fujiwara, K. Oguro: Polymer actuator driven by ion current at low voltage, applied to catheter system, Proc. IEEE Ann. Int. Workshop Micro Electro Mech. Syst. 11th (1998) pp. 148–153 K. Oguro, N. Fujiwara, K. Asaka, K. Onishi, S. Sewa: Polymer electrolyte actuator with gold electrodes, Proc. SPIE 3669, 64–71 (1999) S. Tadokoro, T. Murakami, S. Fuji, R. Kanno, M. Hattori, T. Takamori, K. Oguro: An elliptic friction drive element using an ICPF actuator, IEEE Contr. Syst. Mag. 17(3), 60–68 (1997) Y. Osada, H. Okuzaki, H. Hori: A polymer gel with electrically driven motility, Nature 355(6357), 242– 244 (1992) D.G. Caldwell: Pseudomuscular actuator for use in dextrous manipulation, Med. Biol. Eng. Comp. 28(6), 595 (1990) D.G. Caldwell, N. Tsagarakis: Soft grasping using a dextrous hand, Ind. Robot. 27(3), 194–199 (2000) D.J. Segalman, W.R. Witkowski, D.B. Adolf, M. Shahinpoor: Theory and application of electrically controlled polymeric gels, Smart Mater. Struct. 1(1), 95–100 (1992) M. Shahinpoor: Ionic polymeric gels as artificial muscles for robotic and medical applications, Iran. J. Sci. Technol. 20(1), 89–136 (1996) M. Shahinpoor: Conceptual design, kinematics and dynamics of swimming robotic structures using active polymer gels, Act. Mater. Adapt. Struct. Proc. ADPA/AIAA/ASME/SPIE Conf. (1992) pp. 91–95
Electrochemomechanics of Ionic Polymer–Metal Composites
8.37
8.38
Y. Bar-Cohen, S. Leary, M. Shahinpoor, J.O. Harrison, J. Smith: Electro-active polymer (EAP) actuators for planetary applications, SPIE Conf. Electroactive 8.39 Polymer Actuators Proc. SPIE 3669, 57–63 (1999) D.W. DeWulf, A.J. Bard: Application of Nafion/platinum electrodes (solid polymer electrolyte structures) to voltammetric investigations of highly resistive
References
201
solutions, J. Electrochem. Soc. 135(8), 1977–1985 (1988) J.M. Potente: Gas-phase Electrosynthesis by Proton Pumping Through a Metalized Nafion Membrane: Hydrogen Evolution and Oxidation, Reduction of Ethene, and Oxidation of Ethane and Ethene. Ph.D. Thesis (North Carolina State University, Raleigh 1988)
Part A 8
203
Wendy C. Crone
The expanding and developing fields of micro-electromechanical systems (MEMS) and nano-electromechanical (NEMS) are highly interdisciplinary and rely heavily on experimental mechanics for materials selection, process validation, design development, and device characterization. These devices range from mechanical sensors and actuators, to microanalysis and chemical sensors, to micro-optical systems and bioMEMS for microscopic surgery. Their applications span the automotive industry, communications, defense systems, national security, health care, information technology, avionics, and environmental monitoring. This chapter gives a general introduction to the fabrication processes and materials commonly used in MEMS/NEMS, as well as a discussion of the application of experimental mechanics techniques to these devices. Mechanics issues that arise in selected example devices are also presented.
9.1
Background ......................................... 203
9.2
MEMS/NEMS Fabrication ......................... 206
9.3 Common MEMS/NEMS Materials and Their Properties ............................. 206 9.3.1 Silicon-Based Materials ................ 207 9.3.2 Other Hard Materials .................... 208
9.3.3 Metals ........................................ 9.3.4 Polymeric Materials ...................... 9.3.5 Active Materials ........................... 9.3.6 Nanomaterials ............................. 9.3.7 Micromachining ........................... 9.3.8 Hard Fabrication Techniques ......... 9.3.9 Deposition .................................. 9.3.10 Lithography ................................. 9.3.11 Etching .......................................
208 208 209 209 210 211 211 211 212
9.4 Bulk Micromachining versus Surface Micromachining .............. 213 9.5 Wafer Bonding ..................................... 214 9.6 Soft Fabrication Techniques................... 215 9.6.1 Other NEMS Fabrication Strategies .. 215 9.6.2 Packaging ................................... 216 9.7
Experimental Mechanics Applied to MEMS/NEMS .......................... 217
9.8 The Influence of Scale ........................... 9.8.1 Basic Device Characterization Techniques .................................. 9.8.2 Residual Stresses in Films .............. 9.8.3 Wafer Bond Integrity .................... 9.8.4 Adhesion and Friction...................
217 218 219 220 220
9.9 Mechanics Issues in MEMS/NEMS ............. 221 9.9.1 Devices ....................................... 221 9.10 Conclusion ........................................... 224 References .................................................. 225
9.1 Background The acronym MEMS stands for micro-electromechanical system, but MEMS generally refers to microscale devices or miniature embedded systems involving one or more micromachined component that enables higher-level functionality. Similarly NEMS, nanoelectromechanical system, refers to such nanoscale devices or nanodevices. MEMS and NEMS are fab-
ricated microscale and nanoscale devices that are often made in batch processes, usually convert between some physical parameter and a signal, and may be incorporated with integrated circuit technology. The field of MEMS/NEMS encompasses devices created with micromachining technologies originally developed to produce integrated circuits, as well as
Part A 9
A Brief Introd 9. A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
204
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.1
Table 9.1 Sample applications of MEMS/NEMS Sensors Actuators
Passive structures
Accelerometers, biochemical analyzers, environmental assay devices, gyroscopes, medical diagnostic sensors, pressure sensors Data storage, drug-delivery devices, drug synthesis, fluid regulators, ink-jet printing devices, micro fuel cells, micromirror devices, microphones, optoelectric devices, radiofrequency devices, surgical devices Atomizers, fluid spray systems, fuel injection, medical inhalers
non-silicon-based devices created by the same micromachining or other techniques. They can be classified as sensors, actuators, and passive structures (Table 9.1). Sensors and actuators are transducers that convert one physical quantity to another, such as electromagnetic, mechanical, chemical, biological, optical or thermal phenomena. MEMS sensors commonly measure pressure, force, linear acceleration, rate of angular motion, torque, and flow. For instance, to sense pressure an intermediate conversion step, such as mechanical stress, can be used to produce a signal in the form of electrical energy. The sensing or actuation conversion can use a variety of methods. MEMS/NEMS sensing can employ change in electrical resistance, piezoresistive, piezoelectric, change in capacitance, and magnetoresistive methods (Table 9.2). MEMS/NEMS actuators provide the ability to manipulate physical parameters at the micro/nanoscale, and can employ electrostatic, thermal, magnetic, piezoelectric, piezoresistive, and shape-memory transformation methods. Passive MEMS structures such as micronozzles are used in atomizers, medical inhalers, fluid spray systems, fuel injection, and ink-jet printers.
MEMS have a characteristic length scale between 1 mm and 1 μm, whereas NEMS devices have a characteristic length scale below 1 μm (most strictly, 1–100 nm). For instance a digital micromirror device has a characteristic length scale of 14 μm, a quantum dot transistor has components measuring 300 nm, and molecular gears fall into the 10–100 nm range [9.2]. Additionally, although an entire device may be mesoscale, if the functional components fall in the microscale or nanoscale regime it may be referred to as a MEMS or NEMS device, respectively. MEMS/NEMS inherently have a reduced size and weight for the function they carry out, but they can also carry advantages such as low power consumption, improved speed, increased function in one package, and higher precision. There is no distinct MEMS/NEMS market, instead there is a collection of niche markets where MEMS/NEMS become attractive by enabling a new function, bringing the advantage of reduced size, or lowering cost [9.1]. Despite this characteristic, the MEMS industry is already valued in tens of billions of dollars and growing rapidly. The Small Times Tech Business DirectoryTM
Table 9.2 Physical quantities used in MEMS/NEMS sensors and actuators (after Maluf [9.1]) Method
Description
Physical and material parameters
Order of energy density (J/cm3 )
Electrostatic
Attractive force between two components carrying opposite charge Certain materials that change shape under an electric field Thermal expansion or difference in coefficient of thermal expansion Electric current in a component surrounded by a magnetic field gives rise to an electromagnetic force Certain materials that undergo a solid–solid phase transformation producing a large shape change
Electric field, dielectric permittivity
≈ 0.1
Electric field, Young’s modulus, piezoelectric constant Coefficient of expansion, temperature change, Young’s modulus Magnetic field, magnetic permeability
≈ 0.2
Transformation temperature
≈ 10
Piezoelectric Thermal Magnetic
Shape memory
≈5 ≈4
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
ples include biofluidic chips for biochemical analyses, biosensors for medical diagnostics, environmental assays for toxin identification, implantable pharmaceutical drug delivery, DNA and genetic code analysis, imaging, and surgery. NEMS is often associated with biotechnology because this size scale allows for interaction with biological systems in a fundamental way. BioNEMS may be used for drug delivery, drug synthesis, genome synthesis, nanosurgery, and artificial organs comprised of nanomaterials. The sensitivity of such bioNEMS devices can be exquisite, selectively binding and detecting a single biomolecule. More complete background information on microfluidic devices can be found in Beeby [9.7], Koch [9.9] and Kovacs [9.10]. Semiconductor NEMS devices can offer microwave resonance frequencies, exceptionally high mechanical quality factors, and extraordinarily small heat capacities [9.11, 12]. Examples of NEMS devices also include transducers, radiating energy devices, nanoscale integrated circuits, and optoelectronic devices [9.13, 14]. NEMS manufacturing is being further enabled by the drive towards nanometer feature sizes in the microelectronics industry. Terascale computational ability will require nanotransistors, nanodiodes, nanoswitces, and nanologic gates [9.15]. NEMS also opens the door for fundamental science at the nanometer scale investigating phonon-mediated mechanical processes [9.16] and quantum behavior of mesoscopic mechanical systems [9.17]. Although there is some discussion as to whether the NEMS definition requires a characteristic length scale below 1000 nm or 100 nm, there is no argument that the field of NEMS is in its infancy. Existing commercial devices are limited at this point, but research on NEMS is extremely active and highly promising. Many challenges remain, including assembly of nanoscale devices and mass production capabilities. In the long term, a number of issues must be addressed in analysis, design, development, and fabrication for high-performance MEMS/NEMS to become ubiquitous. Of most relevance to the focus of this handbook, advanced materials must be well characterized and MEMS/NEMS testing must be further developed. Additionally for commercialization, MEMS/NEMS design must consider issues of market (need for product, size of market), impact (enabling new systems, paradigm shift for the field), competition (other macro and micro/nanoproducts existing), technology (available capability and tools), and manufacturing (manufacturability in volume at low cost) [9.18].
205
Part A 9.1
lists more than 700 manufacturers/fabricators of microsystems and nanotechnologies [9.3]. High-volume production with lucrative sales have been achieved by several companies making devices such as accelerometers for automobiles (Analog Devices, Motorola, Bosch), micromirrors for digital projection displays (Texas Instruments), and pressure sensors for the automotive and medical industries (NovaSensor). Currently, the MEMS markets with the largest commercial value are ink-jet printer heads, optical MEMS (which includes the Digital Micromirror DeviceTM discussed below), and pressure sensors, followed by microfluidics, gyroscopes, and accelerometers [9.4]. The MEMS market was reported to be US $5.1 billion in 2005 and projected to reach US $9.7 billion by 2010 [9.4]. The NEMS industry, while still young, has been growing in value. The market research firm Report Buyer recently released a market report on Nanorobotics and NEMS indicating that the global market for NEMS increased from US $29.5 million to US $34.2 million between 2004 and 2005 and projecting that the market will reach US $830.4 million by 2011 [9.5]. Microfluidic and nanofluidic devices also fall under the umbrella of MEMS/NEMS and are often classified as bioMEMS/bioNEMS devices when involving biological materials. These devices incorporate channels with at least one microscale or nanoscale dimension in which fluid flows. The small scale of these devices allow for smaller sample size, faster reactions, and higher sensitivity. Microfluidic devices commonly use both hard and soft fabrication techniques to produce channels and other fluidic structures [9.6]. The common feature of these devices is that they allow for flow of gas and/or liquid and use components such as pumps, valves, nozzles, and mixers. Commercial and defense applications include automotive controls, pneumatics, environmental testing, and medical devices. The advantages of the microscale in these applications include high spatial resolution, fast time response, small fluid volumes required for analysis, low leakage, low power consumption, low cost, appropriate compatibility of surfaces, and the potential for integrate signal processing [9.7]. At the microscale, pressure drop over a narrow channel is high and fluid flow generated by electric fields can be substantial. The micrometer and nanometer length scales are particularly relevant to biological materials because they are comparable to the size of cells, molecules, diffusions length for molecules, and electrostatic screening lengths of ionic conducting fluids [9.8]. Device exam-
9.1 Background
206
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.3
The field of MEMS/NEMS is highly multidisciplinary, often involving expertise from engineering, materials science, physics, chemistry, biology, and medicine. Because of the breadth of the field and the range of activities that fall under the scope of MEMS/NEMS, a comprehensive review is not possible in this chapter. After providing general background, the focus will be on mechanics and specifically experimental mechanics as it is applied to MEMS/NEMS.
Mechanics is critical to the design, fabrication, and performance of MEMS/NEMS. A broad range of experimental tools has been applied to MEMS/NEMS. This chapter will provide an overview of such work. Additional information on the application of mechanics to MEMS/NEMS can be found in the proceedings of the annual symposium held by the MEMS and Nanotechnology Technical Division of the Society for Experimental Mechanics (see, for example, [9.19]).
9.2 MEMS/NEMS Fabrication Traditionally MEMS/NEMS are thought of in the context of microelectronics fabrication techniques which utilize silicon. This approach to MEMS/NEMS brings with it the momentum of the integrated circuits industry and has the advantage of ease of integration with semiconductor devices, but fabrication is expensive in both the infrastructure and equipment required and the time investment needed to create a working prototype. An alternative approach that has seen significant success, especially in its application to microfluidic devices, is the use of soft materials such as polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). Soft MEMS/NEMS fabrication can often be conducted with bench-top techniques with no need for the clean-room facilities used in microelectronics fabrication. Additionally, polymers offer a range of properties not available in siliconbased materials such as mechanical shock tolerance, biocompatibility, and biodegradability. However, polymers can carry disadvantages for certain applications because of their viscoelastic behavior and low thermal stability. Ultimately a combination of function and
economics decides the medium of choice for device construction. Whether we talk about hard or soft MEMS/NEMS, the basic approach to device construction is similar. Material is deposited onto a substrate, a lithographic step is used to produce a pattern, and material removal is conducted to create a shape. For traditional microelectronics fabrication, the substrate is often silicon, material deposition is achieved by vapor deposition or sputtering, lithography involves patterning of a chemically resistant polymer, and material is removed by a chemical etch. Alternatively, for soft MEMS/NEMS materials, fabrication often utilizes a glass or plastic substrate, material in the form of a monomer is flowed into a region, a lithographic mask allows exposure of a pattern to ultraviolet (UV) radiation triggering polymerization, and the unpolymerized monomer is removed with a flushing solution. For both hard and soft MEMS/NEMS fabrication there are a number of variations on these basic steps which allow for a wide array of structures and devices to be constructed.
9.3 Common MEMS/NEMS Materials and Their Properties Materials used in MEMS/NEMS must simultaneously satisfy a range requirements for chemical, structural, mechanical, and electrical properties. For biomedical and bioassay devices, material biocompatibility and bioresistance must also be considered. Most MEMS/NEMS devices are created on a substrate. Common substrate materials include singlecrystal silicon, single-crystal quartz, fused quartz, gallium arsenide, glass, and plastics. Devices are made with a range of methods by machining into the substrate and/or depositing additional material on top of the
substrate. The additional materials may be structural, sacrificial, or active. Although traditionally MEMS in particular have relied on silicon, the materials used in MEMS/NEMS are becoming more heterogeneous. Selected properties are given in Table 9.3 for comparative purposes, but an extensive list of properties for the wide range of materials used in MEMS/NEMS cannot be included here. It should be noted, however, that the constitutive behavior of materials used in MEMS/NEMS applications can be sensitive to fabrication method, processing parame-
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
9.3 Common MEMS/NEMS Materials and Their Properties
Property
Si
SiO2
Si3 N4
Quartz
SiC
Si(111)
Stainless steel
Al
Young’s modulus (GPa) Yield strength (GPa) Poisson’s ratio Density (g/cm3 ) Coefficient of thermal expansion (10−6 /◦ C) Thermal conductivity at 300 K (W/cm · K) Melting temperature (◦ C)
160 7 0.22 2.4 2.6
73 8.4 0.17 2.3 0.55
323 14 0.25 3.1 2.8
107 9 0.16 2.65 0.55
450 21 0.14 3.2 4.2
190 7 0.22 2.3 2.3
200 3 0.3 8 16
70 0.17 0.33 2.7 24
1.57
0.014
0.19
0.0138
5
1.48
0.2
2.37
1415
1700
1800
1610
2830
1414
1500
660
ters, and thermal history due to the relative similarity between characteristic length scales and device dimensions. A good resource compiling characterization data from a number of sources is the material database at http://www.memsnet.org/material/ [9.20]. The following books, used as references for the discussion here, are valuable resources for more extensive information: Senturia [9.18], Maluf [9.1], and Beeby [9.7].
9.3.1 Silicon-Based Materials Silicon, Polysilicon, and Amorphous Silicon Silicon-based materials are the most common materials currently used in MEMS/NEMS commercial production. MEMS/NEMS devices often exploit the mechanical properties of silicon rather than its electrical properties. Silicon can be used in a number of different forms: oriented single-crystal silicon, amorphous silicon, or polycrystal silicon (polysilicon). Single-crystal silicon, which has cubic crystal structure, exhibits anisotropic behavior which is evident in its mechanical properties such as Young’s modulus. A high-purity ingot of single-crystal silicon is grown, sawn to the desired thickness, and polished to create a wafer. Single-crystal silicon used for MEMS/NEMS are usually the standard 100 mm (4 inch diameter, 525 μm thickness) or 150 mm (6 inch diameter, 650 μm thickness) wafers. Although larger 8-inch and 12-inch wafers are available, they are not used as prevalently for MEMS fabrication. The properties of the wafer depend on both the orientation of crystal growth and the dopants added to the silicon (Fig. 9.1). Impurity doping has a significant impact on electrical properties but does not generally impact the mechanical properties if the concentration is approximately < 1020 cm−3 . Silicon is a group IV semiconductor. To create a p-type material, dopants
from group III (such as boron) create mobile charge carriers that behave like positively charged species. To create an n-type material, dopants from group V (such as phosphorous, arsenic, and antimony) are used to create mobile charge carriers that behave like negatively charged electrons. Doping of the entire wafer can be accomplished during crystal growth. Counter-doping can be accomplished by adding dopants of the other type to an already doped substrate using deposition followed by ion implantation and annealing (to promote diffusion and relieve residual stresses). For instance, p-type into n-type creates a pn-junction. Amorphous and polysilicon films are usually deposited with thicknesses of < 5 μm, although it is also possible to create thick polysilicon [9.21]. The residual stress in deposited polysilicon and amorphous silicon thin films can be large, but annealing can be used to provide some relief. Polysilicon has the disadvantage of a somewhat lower strength and lower piezoresistivity than single-crystal silicon. Additionally, Young’s
(100) n-type
Secondary flat
(111) n-type
Primary flat
(100) p-type
Primary flat
Secondary flat
Primary flat
(111) p-type
Primary flat
Secondary flat
Fig. 9.1 Flats on standard commercial silicon wafers used
to identify crystallographic orientation and doping (after Senturia [9.18])
Part A 9.3
Table 9.3 Properties of selected materials (after Maluf [9.1] and Beeby [9.7])
207
208
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.3
modulus may vary significantly because the diameter of a single grain may comprise a large fraction of a component’s width [9.22]. Silicon, polysilicon, and amorphous silicon are also piezoresistive, meaning that the resistivity of the material changes with applied stress. The fractional change in resistivity, Δρ/ρ, is linearly dependent on the stress components parallel and perpendicular to the direction of the resistor. The proportionality constants are the piezoresistive coefficients, which are dependent on the crystallographic orientation, and the dopant type/concentration in single-crystal silicon. This property can be used to create a strain gage. Silicon Dioxide The success of silicon is heavily based on its ability to form a stable oxide which can be predictably grown at elevated temperature. Dry oxidation produces a higherquality oxide layer, but wet oxidation (in the presence of water) enhances the diffusion rate and is often used when making thicker oxides. Amorphous silicon dioxide can be used as a mask against etchants. It should be noted that these films can have large residual stresses. Silicon Nitride Silicon nitride can be deposited by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) as an amorphous film which can be used as a mask against etchants. It should be noted that these films can have large residual stresses. Silicon Carbide Silicon carbide is an attractive material because of its high hardness, good thermal properties, and resistance to harsh environments. Additionally, silicon carbide is piezoresistive. Although it can be produced as a bulk polycrystalline material it is generally grown or deposited on a silicon substrate by epitaxial growth (single crystal) or by chemical vapor deposition (polycrystal).
Quartz Single-crystal quartz, which has a hexagonal crystal structure, can be used in natural or synthesized form. Like silicon, it can be etched selectively but the results are less ideal than in silicon because of unwanted facets and poor edge definition. Single-crystal quartz can be used as substrate material in a range of cuts which have different temperature sensitivities for piezoelectric or mechanical properties. Detailed information about quartz cuts can be found in Ikeda [9.25]. Quartz is also piezoelectric, meaning that there is a relationship between strain and voltage in the material. Fused quartz (silica) is a glassy noncrystalline material that is also occasionally used in MEMS/NEMS devices. Glass Glasses such as phosphosilicate and borosilicate (Pyrex) can be used as a substrate or in conjunction with silicon and other materials using wafer bonding (discussed below). Diamond Diamond is also attractive because of its high hardness, high fracture strength, low thermal expansion, low heat capacity, and resistance to harsh environments. Diamond is also piezoresistive and can be doped to produce semiconducting and metal-like behavior [9.26]. Because of its hardness, diamond is particularly attractive for parts exposed to wear. The most promising synthetic forms are amorphous diamond-like carbon, nanocrystalline diamond, and ultra-nanocrystalline diamond films created by pulsed laser deposition or chemical vapor deposition [9.27–31].
9.3.3 Metals
Silicon on Insulator (SOI) Silicon on insulator (SOI) wafers are also used for MEMS sensors and actuators [9.23]. Different SOI materials are distinguished by their properties. Buried oxide layers can be produced either through ion implantation or wafer bonding processes; these techniques are discussed further below [9.24].
Metals are usually deposited as a thin film by sputtering, evaporation or chemical vapor deposition (CVD). Gold, nickel and iron can also be electroplated. Aluminum is the most common metal used in MEMS/NEMS, and is often used for light reflection and electrical conduction. Gold is used for electrochemistry, infrared (IR) light reflection, and electrical conduction. Chromium is often used as an adhesion layer. Alloys of Ni, such as NiTi and PermalloyTM , can be used for actuation and are discussed in more detail below.
9.3.2 Other Hard Materials
9.3.4 Polymeric Materials
Gallium Arsenide Gallium arsenide (GaAs) is a III–V compound semiconductor which is often used to create lasers, optical devices, and high-frequency components.
Photoresists Polymeric photoresist materials are generally used as a spin-cast film as part of a photolithographic process. The film is modified by exposure to radiation
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
Polydimethylsiloxane Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) is an elastomer used as both a structural component in MEMS devices and a stamping material for creating micro- and nanoscale features on surfaces. PDMS is a common silicone rubber and is used extensively because of its processibility, low curing temperature, stability, tunable modulus, optical transparency, biocompatibility, and adaptability by a range functional groups that can be attached [9.32,33].
9.3.5 Active Materials There are several types of active materials that successfully perform sensing and actuation functions at the microscale. Several examples of active materials are given below. NiTi Near-equiatomic nickel titanium alloy can be deposited as a thin film and used an as active material. This material is of particular interest to MEMS because the actuation work density of NiTi is more than an order of magnitude higher than the work densities of other actuation schemes. These shape-memory alloys (SMAs) undergo a reversible phase transformation that allows the material to display dramatic and recoverable stress- and temperature-induced transformations. The behavior of NiTi SMA is governed by a phase transformation between austenite and martensite crystal structures. Transformation between the austenite (B2) and martensite (B19) phases in NiTi can be produced by temperature cycling between the hightemperature austenite phase and the low-temperature martensite phase (shape-memory effect), or loading and unloading the material to favor either the highstrain martensite phase or the low-strain austenite phase (superelasticity). Thus both stress and temperature produce the transformation between the austenite and martensite phases of the alloy. The transfor-
mation occurs in a temperature window, which can be adjusted from −100 ◦ C to +160 ◦ C by changing the alloy composition and heat treatment processing [9.34]. PermalloyTM PermalloyTM , Nix Fe y , displays magnetoresistance properties and is used for magnetic transducing. Multilayered nanostructures of this alloy give rise to a giant-magnetoresistance (GMR) phenomenon which can be used to detect magnetic fields. It has been widely applied to read the state of magnetic bits in data storage media. Lead Zirconate Titanate (PZT) Lead zirconate titanate (PZT) is a ceramic solid solution of lead zirconate (PbZrO3 ) and lead titanate (PbTiO3 ). PZT is a piezoelectric material that can be deposited in thin film form by sputtering or using a sol–gel process. In addition to natural piezoelectric materials such as quartz, other common synthetic piezoelectric materials include polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF), zinc oxide, and aluminum nitride. Actuation performed by piezoelectrics has the advantage of being capable of achieving reasonable displacements with fast response, but the material processing is complex. Hydrogels Hydrogels, such as poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA)) gel, with volumetric shape-memory capability are now being employed as actuators, fluid pumps, and valves in microfluidic devices. In an aqueous environment, hydrogels will undergo a reversible phase transformation that results in dramatic volumetric swelling and shrinking upon exposure and removal of a stimulus. Hydrogels have been produced that actuate when exposed to such stimuli as pH, salinity, electrical current, temperature, and antigens. Since the rate of swelling and shrinking in a hydrogel is diffusion limited, the temporal response of hydrogel structures can be reduced to minutes or even seconds in microscale devices.
9.3.6 Nanomaterials Nanostructuring of materials can produce unique mechanical, electrical, magnetic, optical, and chemical properties. The materials themselves range from polymers to metals to ceramics, it is their nanostructured nature that gives them exciting new behaviors. Increased hardness with decreasing grain size allows for
209
Part A 9.3
such as visible light, ultraviolet light, x-rays or electrons. Exposure is usually conducted through a mask so that a pattern is created in the photoresist layer and subsequently on the substrate through an etching or deposition process. Resists are either positive or negative depending on whether the radiation exposure weakens or strengthens the polymer. In the developer step, chemicals are used to remove the weaker material, leaving a patterned photoresist layer behind. Important photoresist properties include resolution and sensitivity, particularly as feature sizes decrease.
9.3 Common MEMS/NEMS Materials and Their Properties
210
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.3
Table 9.4 Micromachining processes and their applications (after Kovacs [9.10]) Process
Example applications
Lithography Thin-film deposition
Photolithography, screen printing, electron-beam lithography, x-ray lithography Chemical vapor deposition (CVD), plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD), physical vapor deposition (PVD) such as sputtering and evaporation, spin casting, sol–gel deposition Blanket and template-delimited electroplating of metals Electroplating, LIGA, stereolithography, laser-driven CVD, screen printing, microcontact printing, dip-pen lithography Plasma etching, reactive-ion enhanced etching (RIE), deep reactive-ion etching (DRIE), wet chemical etching, electrochemical etching Drilling, milling, electrical discharge machining (EDM), focused ion beam (FIB) milling, diamond turning, sawing Direct silicon-fusion bonding, fusion bonding, anodic bonding, adhesives Wet chemical modification, plasma modification, self assembled monolayer (SAM) deposition, grinding, chemomechanical polishing Thermal annealing, laser annealing
Electroplating Directed deposition Etching Machining Bonding Surface modification Annealing
hard coatings and protective layers, lower percolation threshold impacts conductivity, and narrower bandgap with decreasing grain size enable unique optoelectronics [9.35]. Hundreds of different synthesis routes have been created for manufacturing nanostructured materials. (See, for example, the proceedings of the International Conferences on Nanostructured Materials [9.36].) A few examples of such materials are given below. Carbon Nanotubes and Fullerenes Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and fullerenes (buckyballs, e.g., C60 ) are self-assembled carbon nanostructures. CNTs are cylindrical graphene structures of single- or multiwall form which are extremely strong and flexible. They possess metallic or semiconducting electronic behavior depending on the details of the structure (chirality). They can be created in an arc plasma furnace, laser ablation, or grown by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) on a substrate using catalyst particles [9.37]. Quantum Dots, Quantum Wires, and Quantum Films Quantum behavior occurs in semiconductor materials (such as GaAs) when electrons are confined to nanoscale dimensions. The confined space forces electrons to have energy states that are clustered around specific peaks, producing fundamentally different electrical and optical properties than would be found in the same material in bulk form. The number of directions free of confinement is used to classify structures, thus two-dimensional (2-D) confinement leads to a quan-
tum film, one-dimensional (1-D) confinement leads to a quantum wire, and zero-dimensional (0-D) confinement leads to a quantum dot. The dimension of the confined direction(s) is so small that the energy states are quantized in that direction [9.37]. Nanowires A variety of methods have been developed for making nanowires of a wide range of metals, ceramics, and polymers. Examples include gold nanowires made by a solution method [9.38], palladium nanowires created by electroplating on a stepped surface [9.39], and zinc oxide nanowires created by a vapor/liquid/solid method [9.40]. In one popular technique, electroplating is conducted inside a nanoporous template of alumina or polycarbonate to direct the growth of nanowires [9.41, 42]. The template can be chemically removed, leaving the nanowires behind. In another application, lithographically patterned metal is used as a catalyst for silicon nanowire growth, creating predefined regions of nanowires on a surface [9.43, 44]. Using various combinations of metal catalysts and gases, a wide range of nanowire compositions can be created from chemical vapor deposition methods.
9.3.7 Micromachining Micromachining is a set of material removal and forming techniques for creating microscale movable features and complex structures, often from silicon. The micromachining processes listed in Table 9.4 can be applied to other materials such as glasses, ce-
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
9.3.8 Hard Fabrication Techniques Hard MEMS utilizes enabling technologies for fabrication and design from the microelectronics industry. The MEMS industry has modified advanced techniques, leveraging well beyond the capability to fabricate integrated circuits. Micromachining involves three fundamental processes: deposition, lithography, and etching. Deposition may employ oxidation, chemical vapor deposition, physical vapor deposition, electroplating, diffusion, or ion implantation. Lithography methods include optical and electron-beam techniques. Etching methods include wet and dry chemical etches, which can be either isotropic (uniform etching in all directions, resulting in rounded features) or anisotropic (etching in one preferential direction, resulting in well-defined features).
9.3.9 Deposition Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD) Physical vapor deposition (PVD) includes evaporation and sputtering. The evaporation method is used to deposit metals on a surface from vaporized atoms removed from a target by heating with an electron beam. This technique is performed under high vacuum and produces very directional deposition and can create
shadows. Sputtering of a metallic or nonmetallic material is accomplished by knocking atoms off a target with a plasma of an inert gas such as argon. Sputtering is less directional and allows for higher deposition rates. Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) In chemical vapor deposition (CVD), precursor material is introduced into a heated furnace and a chemical reaction takes place on the surface of the wafer. The CVD process is generally performed under low-pressure conditions and is sometimes explicitly referred to as low-pressure CVD (LPCVD). A range of materials can be deposited by CVD, including films of silicon (formed by decomposition of silane (SiH4 )), silicon nitride formed by reacting dichlorosilane (SiH2 Cl2 ) with ammonia (NH3 )), and silicon oxide (formed by silane with an oxidizing species). LPCVD can produce amorphous inorganic dielectric films and polycrystalline polysilicon and metal films. Epitaxy is a CVD process where temperature and growth rate are controlled to achieve ordered crystalline growth in registration with the substrate. PECVD is a plasma-enhanced CVD process. Electroplating A variety of electroplating techniques are used to make micro- and nanoscale components. A mold is created into which metal is plated. Gold, copper, chromium, nickel, and iron are common plating metals. Spin Casting Spin casting is used to create films from a solution. The most common spin-cast material is polymeric photoresist. Sol–Gel Deposition A range of sol–gel processes can be used to make films and particles. The general technique involves a colloidal suspension of solid particles in a fluid that undergo a reaction to generate a gelatinous network. After deposition of the gel, the solvent can be removed to transform the network into a solid phase which is subsequently sintered. Piezoelectric materials such as PZT can be deposited with this method.
9.3.10 Lithography Most of the micromachining techniques discussed below utilize lithography, or pattern transfer, at some point in the manufacturing process. Depending on the resolution required to produce the desired feature sizes and the aspect ratio necessary, lithography is either per-
211
Part A 9.3
ramics, polymers, and metals, but silicon is favored because of its widespread use and the availability of design and processing techniques. Other advantages of silicon include the availability of relatively inexpensive pure single-crystal substrate wafers, its desirable electrical properties, its well-understood mechanical properties, and ease of integration into a circuit for control and signal processing [9.7]. Although often performed in batch processes, micromachining for MEMS application may make large-aspect-ratio features and incorporation of novel or active materials a higher priority than batch manufacturing. This opens the door for a wider range of fabrication techniques such as focused ion-beam milling, laser machining, and electron-beam writing [9.22, 45, 46]. A brief overview of micromachining is provided below. The following books, used as references for the discussion here, are valuable resources for more extensive information [9.1, 2, 10, 18, 22, 33]. Additional information can be found in Taniguchi [9.47] and Evans [9.48] on microfabrication technology, Bustillo [9.49] on surface micromachining, and Gentili [9.50] on nanolithography.
9.3 Common MEMS/NEMS Materials and Their Properties
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.3
formed with ultraviolet light, an ion beam, x-rays, or an electron beam. X-ray lithography can produce features down to 10 nm and electron beams can be focused down to less than 1 nm [9.50]. Optical lithography allows aspect ratios of up to three whereas x-ray lithography can produce aspect ratios > 100. This large depth of focus, lack of scattering effects, and insensitivity to organic dust make x-ray lithography very attractive for NEMS production. Electron-beam lithograph has the attractive feature that a pattern can be directly written onto a resist, as well as the fact that it produces lower defect densities with a large depth of focus, but the process must be performed in vacuum. In most cases a mask that carries either a positive or negative image of the features to be created must first be produced. Masks are commonly made with a chromium layer on fused silica. Photoresist covering the chromium is exposed with an optical pattern generated from a sequence of small rectangles used to draw out the pattern desired. Other mask production techniques include photographic emulsion on quartz, electron-beam lithography with electron-beam resist, and high-resolution ink-jet printing on acetate or mylar film. Photolithographic fabrication techniques have a long history of use with ceramics, plastics, and glasses. In the case of silicon fabrication, the wafer is coated with a polymeric photoresist layer sensitive to ultraviolet light. Exposure of the photoresist layer is conducted through a mask. Depending on whether a positive or negative photoresist is used, the light either weakens the polymer or strengthens the polymer. In the developer step, chemicals are used to remove the weaker material, leaving a patterned photoresist layer behind. The photoresist acts as a protective layer when etching is conducted. Contact lithography produces a 1:1 ratio of the mask size and feature size. Proximity lithography also gives a 1:1 ratio with slightly lower resolution because a gap is left between the mask and the substrate to minimize damage to the mask. A factor of 5–10 reduction is common for projection step-and-repeat lithography. Because this technique allows for the production of feature sizes smaller then the mask, only a small region is exposed at one time and the mask must be stepped across the substrate.
9.3.11 Etching A number of wet and dry etchants have been developed for silicon. Important properties include orientation
dependence, selectivity, and the geometric details of the etched feature (Fig. 9.2). A common isotropic wet etchant for silicon is HNA (a combination of HF, HNO3 , and CH3 COOH), while anisotropic wet etchants include KOH, which etches {100} planes 100 times faster than {111} planes, tetramethylammonium hydroxide (called TMAH or (CH3 )4 NOH), which etches {100} planes 30–50 times faster than {111} planes but leaves silicon dioxide and silicon nitride unetched, and ethylenediamine pyrochatechol (EDP), which is very hazardous but does not etch most metals. Wet etchants such as HF for silicon dioxide, H3 PO4 for silicon nitride, KCl for gold, and acetone for organic layers, can be performed in batch processes with little cost [9.51]. An important feature of an etchant is its selectivity; for example, the etch rate of an oxide by HF is 100 nm/min compared to 0.04 nm/min for silicon nitride [9.51]. The etching reaction can be either reaction rate controlled or mass transfer limited. Because wet etchants act quickly, making it hard to control depth of the etch, electrochemical etching is sometimes employed using an electric potential to moderate the reaction along with a precision thickness epitaxial layer used for etch stop. The challenge comes with drying after the wet etching process is complete. Capillary forces can easily draw surfaces together, causing damage and stiction. Supercritical drying, where the liquid is converted to a gas, can be used to prevent this. Alternatively, application of a hydrophobic passivation layer such as a fluorocarbon polymer can be used to prevent stiction. Chemically reactive vapors and plasmas are highly effective dry etchants. Xenon difluoride (XeF2 ) is a commercially important highly selective vapor etchant for silicon. Dry etchants such as CHF3 + O2 for silicon dioxide, SF6 for silicon nitride, Cl2 + SiCl4 for
Wet etch
Plasma (dry) etch
Isotropic
Part A
Anisotropic
212
{111}
Fig. 9.2 Trench profiles produced by different etching processes (after Maluf [9.1])
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
all parts of the wafer. Ion milling refers to selective sputtering and can be done uniformly over a wafer or with focusing electrodes by focused ion-beam milling (FIB). FIB is also becoming a more important technique for test sample production and the application of gratings used for interferometry [9.52]. In addition to FIB, techniques such as scanning probe microscope (SPM) lithography and molecular-beam epitaxy can also be used to create micro- and nanoscale gratings [9.53]. Beyond the use of etching as part of the initial fabrication of a device, some small adjustments may be required after the device is fabricated due to small variations that occur in processing. Compensation can be performed by trimming resistors and altering mechanical dimensions via techniques such as laser ablation and FIB milling. Calibration can be performed electronically with correction coefficients.
9.4 Bulk Micromachining versus Surface Micromachining The processes for silicon micromachining fall into two general categories: bulk (subtraction of substrate material) and surface (addition of layers to the substrate). Other techniques used on a range of materials include surface micromachining, wafer bonding, thin film screen printing, electroplating, lithography galvanoforming molding (LIGA, from the German Lithografie-Galvanik-Abformung), injection molding,
electric-discharge machining (EDM), and focused ion beam (FIB). Figure 9.3 provides a basic comparison of bulk micromachining, surface micromachining, and LIGA. Bulk Micromachining Removal of significant regions of substrate material in bulk micromachining is accomplished through
a)
b)
c)
Bulk micromachining
Surface micromachining
LIGA Resist structure Base plate
Deposition of sacrificial layer
Deposition of silica layers on Si Membrane <111> face
Metal structure Electroforming
Patterning with mask
Gate plate
Patterning with mask and etching of Si to produce cavity Silicon
Silica
Lithography
Mold insert Mold fabrication
Deposition of microstructure layer Molding mass
Mold filling
Etching of sacrificial layer to produce freestanding structure Silicon
Polysilicon
Sacrificial material
Plastic structure
Unmolding
Fig. 9.3a–c Schematic diagrams depicting the processing steps required for (a) bulk micromachining (b) surface micromachining, and (c) LIGA. All views are shown from the side (after Bhushan [9.2] Chap. 50)
213
Part A 9.4
aluminum, and O2 for organic layers, are used as a plasma [9.51]. The process is conducted in a specially designed system that generates a chemically reactive plasma species of ion neutrals and accelerates them towards a substrate with an electric or magnetic field. Plasma etching is the spontaneous reaction of neutrals with the substrate materials, while reactive-ion etching involves a synergistic role between the ion bombardment and the chemical reaction. Deep reactive-ion etching (DRIE) allows for the creation of high-aspectratio features. DRIE involves periodic deposition of a protective layer to shield the sidewalls either through condensation of reactant gasses produced by cryogenic cooling of the substrate or interim deposition cycles to put down a thin polymer film. Ions can also be used to sputter away material. For example, argon plasma will remove material from
9.4 Bulk Micromachining versus Surface Micromachining
214
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.5
anisotropic etching of a silicon single-crystal wafer. The fabrication process includes deposition, lithography, and etching. Bulk micromachining is commonly used for high-volume production of accelerometers, pressure sensors, and flow sensors.
are used to produce a free-standing structure. Surface micromachining is attractive for integrating MEMS sensors with electronic circuits, and is commonly used for micromirror arrays, motors, gears, and grippers.
Surface Micromachining Alternating structural and sacrificial thin film layers are built up and patterned in sequence for surface micromachining. The process used by Sandia National Laboratory uses up to five structural polysilicon and five sacrificial silicon dioxide layers, whereas Texas Instrument’s digital micromirror device (discussed below) is made from a stack of structural metallic layers and sacrificial polymer layers [9.1, 54]. Deposition methods include oxidation, chemical vapor deposition (CVD), and sputtering. Annealing must sometimes be used to relax the mechanical stresses that build up in the films. Lithography and etching
LIGA Lithography galvanoforming molding (LIGA, from the German Lithografie-Galvanik-Abformung) is a lithography and electroplating method used to create very high-aspect-ratio structures (aspect ratios of more than 100 are common). The use of x-rays in the lithography process takes advantage of the short wavelength to create a larger depth of focus compared to photolithography [9.14]. Devices can be up to 1 mm in height with another dimension being only a few microns and are commonly made of materials such as metals, ceramics, and polymers. See Guckel [9.55], Becker [9.56], and Bley [9.57] for additional details.
9.5 Wafer Bonding Although microelectronics fabrication processes allow stacking layers of films, structures are relatively two dimensional. Wafer bonding provides an opportunity for a more three-dimensional structure and is commonly used to make pressure sensors, accelerometers, and microfluidic devices (Fig. 9.4). Anodic and direct bonding are the most common techniques, but
2.5μm LPCVD polysilicon mask
Sheat Sample inlet injector holes
Fused silica substrate Electrochemical-discharge machined through-holes
Two substrates thermally bonded together
Fig. 9.4 Schematic diagram depicting a wafer bonding process used to create a microfluidic channel for flow cytometry (after Kovacs [9.10])
bonding can also be achieved by using intermediate layers such as polymers, solders, and thin-film metals. Anodic (electrostatic) bonding can be used to bond silicon to a sodium-containing glass substrate (with a matched coefficient of thermal expansion) using an applied electric field. This is accomplished with the application of a large voltage at elevated temperature to make positive Na+ ions mobile. The positively charged silicon is held to the negatively charged glass by electrostatic attraction. Direct (silicon-fusion) bonding requires two flat, clean surfaces in intimate contact. Direct bonding of a silicon/glass stack can be achieved by applying pressure. Direct wafer bonding allows joining of two silicon surfaces or silicon and silicon dioxide surfaces and is used extensively to create SOI wafers. After treatment of the surfaces to produce hydroxyl (OH) groups, intimate contact allows van der Waals forces to make the initial bond followed by an annealing step to create a chemical reaction at the interface. Grinding and polishing is sometimes needed to thin a bonded wafer. Annealing must be performed afterwards to remove defects incurred during grinding. Alternatively, chemomechanical polishing can be used to combine chemical etching with the mechanical action of polishing.
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
9.6 Soft Fabrication Techniques
Self-Assembly Partly because of the high cost of nanolithography and the time-consuming nature of atom-by-atom placement using probe microscopy techniques, self-assembly is an important bottom-up approach to NEMS fabrication [9.59]. To offset the time it takes to build unit by unit to create a useful device, massive parallelism and autonomy is required. The advantage of self-assembly is that it occurs at thermodynamic minima, relying on naturally occurring phenomena that govern at the nanoscale and create highly perfect assemblies [9.58]. The atoms, molecules, collections of molecules, or nanoparticles self-organize into functioning entities using thermodynamic forces and kinetic control [9.60]. Such self-organization at the nanoscale is observed naturally in liquid crystals, colloids, micelles, and self-assembled monolayers [9.61]. Reviews of self-assembly can be found in [9.62–65]. At the nanoparticle level, a variety of methods have been used to promote self-assembly. Three basic requirements must be met: there must be some sort of bonding force present between particles or the particles and a substrate, the bonding must be selective, and the particles must be in random motion to facilitate chance interactions with a relatively high rate of occurrence. Additionally, for the technique to be practical, the particles must be easily synthesized. Selectivity can be facilitated by micromachining the substrate including patterns with geometric designs that allow for only certain orientations of the mating particle. Particularly powerful are self-assembly methods using complementary pairs and molecular building blocks (analogous to DNA replication). Complementary pairs can bind electrostatically or chemically (using functional groups with couple monomers). Molecular Table 9.5 Techniques for creating patterned SAMs [9.58] Method
Scale of features
Microcontact printing Micromachining Microwriting with pen Photolithography/lift-off Photochemical patterning Photo-oxidation Focused ion-beam writing Electron-beam writing Scanning tunneling microscope writing
100 nm – some cm 100 nm – some μm ≈ 10–100 μm > 1 μm > 1 μm > 1 μm ≈ some μm 25–100 nm 15–50 nm
building blocks can use a number of different bonds and linkages (ionic bonds, hydrogen bonds, transition metal complex bonds, amide linkages, and ester linkages) to create building blocks for three-dimensional (3-D) nanostructures and nanocrystals such as quantum dots. Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) can be produced in patterned form by several techniques that produce features in a range of micro- and nanoscale sizes (Table 9.5). Combined with lithography, defined areas of self-assembly on a surface can be created. Applications of SAMs include fundamental studies of wetting and electrochemistry, control of adhesion, surface passivation (to protect from corrosion, control oxidation, or use as resist), tribology, directed assembly, optical systems, colloid fabrication, and biologically active surfaces for biotechnology [9.58]. Soft Lithography The term soft lithography encompasses a number of techniques that can be used to fabricate microand nanoscale structures using replica molding and self-assembly. These techniques include microcontact printing, replica molding, microtransfer molding, micromolding in capillaries, and solvent-assisted micromolding [9.66]. As an example, microcontact printing uses a selfassembled monolayer as ink in a stamping operation that transfers the SAM to a surface (Fig. 9.5). The stamp is fabricated from of an elastomeric material such as PDMS by casting onto a master with surface features. The master can be produced with a range of photolithographic techniques. The polymeric replica mold is used as a stamp to enable physical pattern transfer. The advantages of microcontact printing are its simplicity, conformal contact with a surface, the reusability of the stamp, and the ability to produce multiple stamps from one master. Although defect density and registration of patterns over large scales can be issues, the flexibility of the stamp can be use to make small features (≈ 100 nm) using compression or pattern transfer onto curved surfaces [9.58]. The aspect ratio of features is a constraint with PDMS however. Ratios between 0.2 and 2 must be used to ensure defect-free stamps and molds [9.67].
9.6.1 Other NEMS Fabrication Strategies Nanoscale structures can be created from both topdown and bottom-up approaches. Because of the push
Part A 9.6
9.6 Soft Fabrication Techniques
215
216
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.6
to miniaturize commercial electronics, many top-down methods are refinements of micromachining techniques with the goal of achieving manufacturing accuracy on the nanometer scale. Bottom-up methods rely on additive atomic and molecular techniques, such as self-organization, self-assembly, and templating, using building blocks similar and size to those used in nature [9.68]. A brief review of some additional examples is provided below. Nanomachining Scanning probe microscopes (SPMs) are a valuable set of tools for NEMS characterization, but these tools Photoresist
Si Photolithography is used to create a master Photoresist pattern (1–2 μm thickness)
Si
PDMS is poured over master and cured
PDMS Photoresist pattern
Si PDMS is peeled away from the master
PDMS PDMS is exposed to a solution containing HS(CH2)15CH3
PDMS
Alkanethiol
Stamping onto gold substrate transfers thiol to form SAM
SAMs (1–2 nm) Au (5–2000 nm)
Si
Ti (5–10 nm) Metal not protected by SAM is removed by exposure to selective chemical etchant
Si
Fig. 9.5 Schematic diagram depicting the processing steps required for microcontact printing. All views are shown from the side (after Wilbur [9.58])
can also be used for NEMS manufacturing. These microscopes share the common feature that they employ a nanometer-scale probe tip in the proximal vicinity of a surface. They are many times more powerful than scanning electron microscopes because their resolution is not determined by wavelength for the interaction with the surface under investigation. The scanning tunneling microscope (STM) can be used to create a strong electric field in the vicinity of the probe tip to manipulate individual atoms. Atoms can be induced to slide over a surface in order to move them into a desired arrangement by mechanosynthesis [9.69]. Resolution is effectively the size of a single atom but practically the process is exceptionally time consuming and the sample must be held at very low temperature to prevent movement of atoms out of place [9.70]. With slightly less resolution but still less than 100 nm, an STM can also be used to write on a chemically amplified negative electron-beam resist. Nanolithography Surface micromachining can be conducted at the nanoscale using electron-beam lithography to create free-standing or suspended mechanical objects. Although the general approach parallels standard lithography (see above), the small-scale ability of this technique is enabled by the fact that an electron beam with energy in the keV range is not limited by diffraction. The electron beam can be scanned to create a desired pattern in the resist [9.8]. Nanoscale resolution can also be obtained using alternative lithographic techniques such as dip-pen nanolithography (DPN) [9.71]. This technique employs an atomic force microscope (AFM) probe tip to deposit a layer of material onto a surface, much as a pen writes on paper. A pattern can be drawn on a surface using a wide range of inks such as thiols, silanes, metals, sol–gel precursors, and biological macromolecules. Although the DPN process is inherently slower that standard mask lithographic techniques, it can be used for intricate functions such as mask repair and the application of macromolecules in biosensor fabrication, or it can be parallelized to increase speed [9.72]. This and other nanofabrication techniques using AFM to modify and pattern surfaces are reviewed by Tang [9.73].
9.6.2 Packaging Packaging of a MEMS/NEMS device provides a protective housing to prevent mechanical damage, minimize stresses and vibrations, guard against contamination,
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
considerations include thickness of the device, wafer dicing (separation of the wafer into separate dice), sequence of final release, cooling of heat-dissipating devices, power dissipation, mechanical stress isolation, thermal expansion matching, minimization of creep, protective coatings to mitigate damaging environmental effects, and media isolation for extreme environments [9.1]. In the die-attach process, each individual die is mounted into a package, by bonding it to a metal, ceramic or plastic platform with a metal alloy solder or an adhesive. For silicon and glass, a thin metal layer must be placed over the surface prior to soldering to allow for wetting. Electrical interconnects can be produced with wire bonding (thermosonic gold bonding with ultrasonic energy and elevated temperature) and flip-chip bonding (using solder bumps between the die and package pads). Fluid interconnects are created by insertion of capillary tubes, mating of self-aligning fluid ports, and laminated layers of plastic [9.1].
9.7 Experimental Mechanics Applied to MEMS/NEMS With a basic understanding of the materials and processes used to make MEMS/NEMS devices, the role of mechanics in materials selection, process validation, design development, and device characterization can now be discussed. The remainder of this chapter will
focus on the forces and phenomena dominant at the micrometer and nanometer scales, basic device characterization techniques, and mechanics issues that arise in MEMS/NEMS devices.
9.8 The Influence of Scale To gain perspective on the micrometer and nanometer size scales, consider that the diameter of human hair is 40–80 μm and a DNA molecule is 2–3 nm wide. The weight of a MEMS structure can be about 1 nN and that of a NEMS components about 10−20 N. Compare this to the mass of a drop of water (10 μN) or an eyelash (100 nN) [9.2]. The minuscule size of forces that influence behavior at these small scales is hard to imagine. For instance, if you take a 10 cm length of your hair and hold it like a cantilever beam, the amount of force placed on the tip of the cantilever to deflect it by 1 cm is on the order of 1 pN. That piece of hair is 40–80 μm in diameter, which is large compared to most MEMS/NEMS components. In dealing with micro- and nanoscale devices, engineering intuition developed through experience with
macroscale behavior is often misleading. It should be noted that many macroscale techniques can be applied at the micro- and nanoscales, but advantages come not from miniaturization but rather working at the relevant size scale using the uniqueness of the scale. The balance of forces at these scales differs dramatically from the macroscale (Table 9.6). Compared to a macroscale counterpart of the same aspect ratio, the structural stiffness of a microscale cantilever increases relative to inertially imposed loads. When the length scale changes by a factor of a thousand, the area decreases by a factor of a million and the volume by a factor of a billion. Surface forces, proportional to area, become a thousand times large than forces that are proportional to volume, thus inertial and electromagnet forces become negligible. At small scales, adhesion, friction, stiction
217
Part A 9.8
protect from harsh environmental conditions, dissipate heat, and shield from electromagnetic interference [9.15]. Packaging is critical because it enables the usefulness, safety, and reliability of the device. Hermetic packaging made of metal, ceramic, glass or silicon is used to prevent the infiltration of moisture, guard against corrosion, and eliminate contamination. The internal cavity is evacuated or filled with an inert gas. For MEMS/NEMS the packaging may also be required to provide access to the environment through electrical and/or fluid interconnects and optically transparent windows. In these cases, the devices are left more vulnerable in order for them to interact with the environment to perform their function. Although there are well-established techniques for packaging of common microelectronics devices, packaging of MEMS/NEMS presents particular challenges and may account for 75–95% of the overall cost of the device [9.1]. Packaging design must be conducted in parallel with design of the MEMS/NEMS component. Design
9.8 The Influence of Scale
218
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.8
Table 9.6 Scaling laws and the relative importance of phenomena as they depend on linear dimension, i (after Madou [9.22]) Importance at small scale Diminished
Increased
Phenomena
Power of linear dimension
Flow Gravity Inertial force Magnetic force Thermal emission Electrostatic force Friction Pressure Piezoelectricity Shape-memory effect Velocity Surface tension Diffusion van der Waal force
l4 l3 l3 l 2 , l 3 or l 4 l 2 or l 4 l2 l2 l2 l2 l2 l l l 1/2 l 1/4
(static friction), surface tension, meniscus forces, and viscous drag often govern. Acceleration of a small object becomes rapid. At the nanoscale, phenomena such as quantum effects, crystalline perfection, statistical time variation of properties, surface interactions, and interface interactions govern behavior and materials properties [9.35]. Additionally, the highly coupled nature of thermal transport properties at the microscale can be either an advantage or disadvantage depending on the device. Enhanced mass transport due to large surface-to-volume ratio can be a significant advantage for applications such as capillary electrophoresis and gas chromatography. However, purging air bubbles in microfluidic systems can be extremely difficult due to capillary forces. The interfacial surface tension force will cause small bubble less than a few millimeters in diameter to adhere to channel surfaces because the mass of liquid in a capillary tube produces an insubstantial inertial force compared to the surface tension [9.10]. Some scaling effects favor particular micro- and nanoscale situations but others do not. For instance, large surface-to-volume ratio in MEMS devices can undermine device performance because of the retarding effects of adhesion and friction. However, electrostatic force is a good example of a phenomena that can have substantial engineering value at small scales. Transla-
tional motion can be achieved in MEMS by electrostatic force because this scales as l 2 as compared to inertial force which scales as l 3 . Microactuation using electrostatic forces between parallel plates is used in comb drives, resonant microstructures, linear motors, rotary motors, and switches. In relation to MEMS testing, gripping of a tension sample can be achieved using an electrostatic force between a sample and the grip [9.74]. It is also important to note that, as the size scale decreases, breakdown in the predictions of continuumbased theories can occur at various length scales. In the case of electrostatics, electrical breakdown in the air gap between parallel plates separated by less than 5 μm does not occur at the predicted voltage [9.75]. In optical devices, nanometer-scale gratings can produce an effective refractive index different from the natural refractive index of the material because the grating features are smaller than the wavelength of light [9.76]. For resonant structures continuum mechanics predictions break down when the structure’s dimensions are on the order of tens of lattice constants in cross section [9.11]. Detailed discussions of issues related to size scale can be found in Madou [9.22] and Trimmer [9.77].
9.8.1 Basic Device Characterization Techniques A range of mechanical properties are needed to facilitate design, predict allowable operating limits, and conduct quality control inspection for MEMS. As with any macroscale device or component, structural integrity is critical to MEMS/NEMS. Concerns include friction/stiction, wear, fracture, excessive deformation, and strength. Properties required for complete understanding of the mechanical performance of MEMS/NEMS materials include elastic modulus, strength, fracture toughness, fatigue strength, hardness, and surface topography. In MEMS devices the minimum feature size is on the order of 1 μm, which is also the natural length scale for microstructure (such as the grain size, dislocation length, or precipitate spacing) in most materials. Because of this, many of the mechanical properties of interest are size dependent, which precipitates the need for new testing methods given that knowledge of material properties is essential for predicting device reliability and performance. A detailed discussion about micro- and nanoscale testing can be found in Part B of this handbook as well as in references such as Sharpe [9.78], Srikar [9.79], Haque and Saif [9.80], Bhushan [9.2], and Yi [9.81]. The following sections
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
9.8.2 Residual Stresses in Films Many MEMS/NEMS devices involve thin films of materials. Properties of thin-film material often differ from their bulk counterparts due to the high surfaceto-volume ratio of thin films and the influence of surface properties. Additionally, these films must have good adhesion, low residual stress, low pinhole density, good mechanical strength, and good chemical resistance [9.22]. These properties often depend on deposition and processing details. The stress state of a thin film is a combination of external applied stress, thermal stress, and intrinsic residual stress that may arise due to factors such as doping (in silicon), grain boundaries, voids, gas entrapment, creep, and shrinkage with curing (in polymeric materials). Stresses that develop during deposition of thin-film material can be either tensile or compressive and may give rise to cracking, buckling, blistering, delaminating, and void formation, all of which degrade device performance. Residual stresses can arise because of coefficient of thermal expansion mismatch, lattice mismatch, growth processes, and nonuniform plastic deformation. Residual stresses that do not cause mechanical failure may still significantly affect device performance by causing warping of released structures, changes in resonant frequency of resonant structures, and diminished electrical characteristics. In some instances, however, residual stresses can be used productively, such as in shape setting of shape-memory alloy films or stress-modulated growth and arrangement of quantum dots. There are numerous techniques for measuring residual stresses in thin films. Fundamental techniques rely on the fact that stresses within a film will cause bending in its substrate (tension causing concavity, compression causing convexity). Simple displacement measurements can be conducted on a circular disk or a micromachined beam and stress calculated from the radius of curvature of the bent substrate or the deflection of a cantilever. Strain gages may also be made directly in the film and used to make local measurements. Freestanding portions of the thin film can be created by micromachining so that the films stresses can be explored by applied
pressure, external probe, critical length for buckling, or resonant frequency measurements. For instance, the critical stress to cause buckling in a doubly supported beam can be estimated from: π 2t2 , K L2 where K is a constant determined by the boundary conditions (3 for a doubly supported beam), E is Young’s modulus, t is the beam thickness, and L is the shortest length of beam displaying buckling [9.10]. The stress or strain gradient over a region of a film can be found by measuring deflections in a simple cantilever. The upward or downward deflection along the length of the beam can be measured by optical methods and used to estimate the internal bending moment M from the expression: σCR = E
(1 − ν2 ) δ (x) =K+ Mx , x 2E I where δ(x) is the vertical deflection at a distance x from the support, E is Young’s modulus, ν is Poisson’s ratio, I is the moment of the beam cross section about the axis of bending, and K is a constant determined by the boundary conditions at the support [9.83]. A number of techniques have been developed for determining residual stresses including an American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standard involving optical interferometry [9.84]. The bulge test is a basic technique for measuring residual stress in a freestanding thin film [9.85]. The bulge test structure can be easily created by micromachining with well-defined boundary conditions. The M-test is an on-chip test that uses bending of an integrated free-standing prismatic beam [9.86]. The principle of an electrostatic actuator is used to conduct the test to find the onset of instability in the structure. The wafer curvature test is regularly used for residual stress measurement in nonintegrated film structures, and can be used even when the film thickness is much smaller than the substrate thickness [9.87]. Dynamic testing can be used to measure resonant frequency and extract information about residual stress and modulus. Resonant frequency increases with tension and decreases in compression [9.88, 89]. Air damping can significantly impact theses measurements, however, so they must be conducted in vacuum [9.18]. Other established techniques that can be employed to measure residual stresses in films include passive strain sensors, Raman spectroscopy, and nanoindentation [9.79]. More recently, nanoscale gratings created by focused ion-beam (FIB) milling have been used to
219
Part A 9.8
provide a review of some mechanics issues that arise at the device level. The following sources, used as references for the discussion below, should be consulted for additional background on mechanics, metrology, and MEMS: Trimmer [9.77], Madou [9.22], Bhushan [9.2], and Gorecki [9.82].
9.8 The Influence of Scale
220
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.8
produce moiré interference between the grating on the specimen surface and raster scan lines of a scanning electron microscope (SEM) image [9.90]. This technique can be used to provide details of residual strains in microscale structures as they evolve with etching of the underlying sacrificial layer [9.52]. Digital image correlation (DIC) has also been applied to SEM and atomic force microscopy (AFM) images in combination with FIB. DIC is used to capture deformation fields while nearby FIB milling of the specimens releases residual stresses, allowing very local evaluation [9.91].
9.8.3 Wafer Bond Integrity Wafer bonding is often an essential device fabrication step, particularly for microfluidic devices, microengines, and microscale heat exchangers. Although direct bonding of silicon can achieve strengths comparable to bulk silicon, the process is sensitive to bonding parameters such as temperature and pressure. The appearance of voids and bubbles at the interface is particularly undesirable for both strength and electrical conductivity [9.92]. An important nondestructive technique for assessing the bond quality of bonded silicon wafers is infrared transmission. At IR wavelengths of about 1.1 μm silicon is transparent [9.1]. Quantification of bond strength can be conducted with techniques such as the pressure burst test, tensile/shear test, knife-edge test, or four-point bend-delamination test [9.93]. Although a range of techniques and processes can be employed to bond both similar and dissimilar materials, the stresses and deformation of the wafers that develop are consistent. The residual stress stored in the bonded wafers is important because it may provide the elastic strain energy to drive fracture. Details of the wafer geometry can impact the final shape of the bonded pair and the integrity of the bond interface [9.94].
9.8.4 Adhesion and Friction Adhesion is both essential and problematic for MEMS/NEMS. For multilayered devices, good adhesion between layers is critical for overall performance and reliability, where delamination under repetitive applied mechanical stresses must be avoided. Adhesion between material layers can be enhanced by improved substrate cleanliness, increased substrate roughness, increased nucleation sites during deposition, and addition of a thin adhesion-promoting layer. Standard tests for film adhesion include: the scotch-tape test, abrasion,
scratching, deceleration using ultrasonic and ultracentrifuge techniques, bending, and pulling [9.95]. In situ testing of adhesion can also be conducted by pressurizing the underside of a film until initiation of delamination. This method also allows the determination of the average work of adhesion. Adhesion can be problematic if distinct components or a component and the nearby substrate come into contact, causing the device to fail. For example, although the mass in an accelerometer device is intended to be free standing at all points of operation, adhesion can occur in the fabrication process. Commonly with freestanding portions of MEMS structures, the capillary forces present during the drying of a device after etching to remove sacrificial material are large enough to cause collapse of the structure and failure due to adhesion [9.96]. To avoid this problem, supercritical drying is used. Contacting surfaces that must move relative to one another in MEMS/NEMS are minimized or eliminated altogether, the reason being that friction and adhesion at these scales can overwhelm the other forces at play. Because silicon readily oxidizes to form a hydrophilic surface, it is much more susceptible to adhesion and accumulation of static charge [9.97]. When contacting surfaces are involved, lubricant films and hydrophobic coatings with low surface energy can be applied to minimize wear and stiction (the large lateral force required to initiate relative motion between two surfaces). For instance, Analog Devices uses a nonpolar silicone coating in its accelerometers to resist charge buildup and stiction [9.98]. Processing plays a major role in surface properties such as friction and adhesion. Polishing will dramatically affect roughness, as in the case of polysilicon where roughness can be reduced by an order of magnitude from the as-deposited state [9.2]. The doping process can also lead to higher roughness. Organic monolayer films show promise for lubrication of MEMS to reduce friction and prevent wear. The atomic force microscope and the surface force apparatus used to quantify friction and MEMS test structures such as those developed at Sandia National Laboratory are aiding the development of detailed mechanics models addressing friction [9.99–102]. Flow Visualization Flow in the microscale domain occurs in a range of MEMS devices, particularly in bioMEMS, microchannel networks, ink-jet printer heads, and micropropulsion systems. The different balance of forces at micro-
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
flow fields in microfluidic devices, where micron-scale spatial resolution is critical [9.103]. Microparticle image velocimetry (μPIV) has been used to characterize such things as microchannel flow [9.104] and microfabricated ink-jet printer head flow [9.105]. For the high-velocity, small-length-scale flows found in microfluidics, high-speed lasers and cameras are used in conjunction with a microscope to image the particles seeded in the flow. With μPIV techniques, the flow boundary topology can be measured to within tens of nanometers [9.106].
9.9 Mechanics Issues in MEMS/NEMS 9.9.1 Devices A wide range of MEMS/NEMS devices is discussed in the literature, both as research and commercialized devices. These devices are commonly planar in nature and employ structures such as cantilever beams, fixed–fixed beams, and springs that are loaded in bending and torsion. A range of mechanics calculations are needed for device characterization, including the effective stiffness of composite beams, deflection analysis of beams, modal analysis of a resonant structures, buckling analysis of a compressively loaded beams, fracture and adhesion analysis of structures, and contact mechanics calculations for friction and wear of surfaces. A substantial literature is available on the application of mechanics to MEMS/NEMS devices. The selected MEMS/NEMS examples presented below were chosen for their illustrative nature. Digital Micromirror Device Optical MEMS devices range from bar-code readers to fiber-optic telecommunication, and use a range of wideband-gap materials, nonlinear electro-optic polymers, and ceramics [9.107]. (See Walker and Nagel [9.108] for more information on optical MEMS.) A wellestablished commercial example of an optical MEMS device is the Digital Micromirror DeviceTM (DMD) by Texas Instruments used for projection display (Fig. 9.6) [9.109]. These devices have superior resolution, brightness, contrast, and convergence performance compared to conventional cathode ray tube technology [9.2]. The DMD contains a surface micromachined array of half a million to two million independently controlled, reflective, hinged micromirrors that have a mechanical switching time of 15 μs [9.110]. This de-
vice steers a reflected beam of light with each individual mirrored aluminum pixel. Pixel motion is driven by an electrostatic field between the yoke and an underlying electrode. The yoke rotates and comes to rest on mechanical stops and its position is restored upon release by torsional hinge springs [9.111]. Almost all commercial MEMS structures avoid any contact between structural members in the operation of the device, and sliding contact is avoided completely because of stiction, friction, and wear. The DMD is currently the only commercial device where structural components come in and out of contact, with contact occurring between the mirror spring tips and the underlying mechanical stops, which act as landing sites. To prevent adhesion problems in the DMD, a self healing perfluorodecanoic acid coating is used on the structural aluminum components [9.112]. Other challenges for the DMD include creep and fatigue behavior in the hinge, shock and vibration, and sensitivity to debris within the package [9.2]. The primary failure mechanisms are surface contamination and hinge memory due to creep in the metallic alloy resulting in a residual tilt angle [9.1]. Heat transfer, which contributes to the creep problem, is also an issue for micromirrors. When the reflection coefficient is less than 100% some of the optical power is absorbed as heat and can cause changes in the flatness of the mirror, damage to the reflective layer, and alterations in the dynamic behavior of the system [9.113]. Micromirrors for projection display involve rotating structures and members in torsion. Such torsional springs must be well characterized and their mechanics well modeled. For production devices extensive finite element models are developed to optimize performance [9.114]. For initial design calculations however,
221
Part A 9.9
scopic length scales can influence fluid flow to produce counterintuitive behavior in microscopic flows. Additionally, the breakdown in continuum laws for fluid flow begins to occur at the microscale. For instance, the no-slip condition no longer applies and the friction factor starts to decrease with channel reduction. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) is a technique commonly used at macroscopic length scales to measure velocity fields through the use of particles seeded in the fluid. The technique has been adapted to measure
9.9 Mechanics Issues in MEMS/NEMS
222
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.9
some closed-form solutions for mechanics analysis can be employed. For instance, an appropriate material can be chosen or the basic dimensional requirements can be found from calculation of the maximum shear stress τmax in a beam of elliptical cross section in torsion (with a and b the semi-axis lengths) using: 2Gαa2 b , for a > b , a 2 + b2 where G is the shear modulus and α in the angular twist [9.107]. Mechanical integrity of the DMD relies on low stresses in the hinge, thus the tilt angle is limited to ±10◦ [9.1]. τmax =
atomic force microscopy [9.117, 118], and magnetic beads [9.119], but these techniques have the disadvantage of requiring external probes, labeling, and/or optical excitation. Alternatively, there are several methods using molecular recognition and the small-scale forces created by events such as DNA hybridization and receptor–ligand binding to produce bending in cantilevers to create sensors with high selectivity and resolution [9.115, 120]. Microcantilever sensors have been used for some time to detect changes in relative humidity, temperature, pressure, flow, viscosity, sound, natural gas, mercury vapor, and ultraviolet and infrared radiation. More re-
Biomolecular Recognition Device Biological molecules can be probed by external methods using techniques such as optical tweezers [9.116], a)
100 μm Oligonucleotide
x
b)
Mirror –10 deg Mirror +10 deg
Hybridization
Δx Hinge Yoke Landing tip
CMOS substrate
Fig. 9.6 (a) SEM image of yoke and hinges of one pixel with mirror removed (b) Schematic of two tilted pixels with mirrors (shown as transparent) (reprinted with permission, Hornbeck [9.111], Bhushan [9.2])
Fig. 9.7 SEM image of a portion of the cantilever sensor
array and schematics illustrating functionalized cantilevers with selective sensing capability (reprinted with permission, Fritz [9.115])
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
Δm ≈ 2
Meff Δω ω0
where Meff is the effective vibratory mass of the resonator, and ω0 is the resonance frequency of the device [9.11]. The mass sensitivity of NEMS devices with micromachined cantilevers can be as small as a single small molecule (in the range of a single Dalton). In a device such as that shown in Fig. 9.7, a liquid medium, which contains molecules that dock to a layer of receptor molecules attached to one side of the cantilever, is injected into the device. Sensitizing an array of cantilevers with different receptor allows docking of different substances in the same solution [9.115]. Hybridization can be done with short strands of single-stranded DNA and proteins known a)
to recognize antibodies. When docking occurs, the increase in the molecular packing density leads to surface stress, causing bending (10–20 nm of deflection). This deflection can be measured by a laser beam reflected off of the end of the cantilever [9.115]. Alternatively, simple geometric interference by interdigitated cantilevers that act as diffraction gratings can be used to provide output of a binding event [9.120]. Thermomechanical Data Storage Device Much of the drive to nanometer-scale devices originates in the desire for higher density and faster computational devices. Magnetic data storage has been pushed into the nanoscale regime, but limitations have prompted the development of alternative methods for data storage such as the NEMS device known as the Millipede, developed by IBM. The Millipede, or scanning probe array memory device, is an array of individually addressable scanning probe tips (similar to atomic force microscope probe tips) that makes precisely positioned indentations in a polymer thin film. The Millipede is scanned to address a large area for data storage. The indentations are bits of digital information. A polymer thin film (50 nm thick) of polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) is used for write, read, erase, and rewrite operations. Each individual bit is a nanoscale feature, which allows the Millipede to extend storage density to the Tbit/in2 range with a bit size of 30–40 nm [9.123]. The device uses multiple cantilever probe tips equipped with integrated heaters which allow for data transfer rates of up to a few Mb/s [9.124].
Multiplex driver
2-D cantilever array chip
b) Highly doped silicon cantilever leg
Nickel bridge
x
Metal 1 (Gold) Metal 2 (Nickel)
z3 Low-doped Schottky diode area y
Polymer storage media on x/y/z scanner
z1 z2
Stress-controlled nitride
Silicon cantilever
Heater platform
Fig. 9.8 (a) Schematic illustration of the millipede device, (b) with a detail of one cantilever cell (reprinted with permission, Despont [9.122])
223
Part A 9.9
cently micromachined cantilevers have been used to interact and probe material at the molecular level. Devices employing these micromachined cantilevers can be dynamic, which are sensitive to mass changes down to 10–21 g (the single molecule level), or static, which are sensitive to surface stress changes in the low mN/m range (changes in Gibbs free energy caused by binding site-analyte interactions) [9.121]. In this case adhesion is required between the device and the material to be detected. In a functionalized cantilever array device produced to measure biomechanical forces created by DNA hybridization or receptor–ligand binding, detection of the mass change is accomplished by measuring a shift in resonant frequency. The responsiveness of the device to a change in mass is given by the expression:
9.9 Mechanics Issues in MEMS/NEMS
224
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9.10
Substrate Polymer Cantilever Write current Pit: 25nm deep 40nm wide (maximum)
Erasure current
Sensing current
Inscribed pins Data stream 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 Output signal 0
The Millipede device is a massively parallel structure with a large array of thousands of probe tips (100 cantilevers/mm2 ), each of which is able to address a region of the substrate where it produces indentations for use as data storage bits (Fig. 9.8) [9.125]. As illustrated in Fig. 9.9, the probes writes a bit by heating and a mechanical force applied between a can-
Fig. 9.9 Schematic of the writing, erasing, and reading op-
erations in the Millipede device. Data are mechanically stored in pits on a surface (reprinted with permission, Vettiger [9.127])
tilever tip and a polymer film. Erasure of a bit is also conducted with heating by placing a small pit just adjacent to the bit to be erased or using the spring back of the polymer when a hot tip is inserted into a pit. Reading is also enabled by heat transfer since the sensing relies on a thermomechanical sensor that exploits temperature-dependent resistance [9.126]. The change in temperature of a continuously heated resistor is monitored while the tip is scanned over the film and relies on the change in resistance that occurs when a tip moves into a bit [9.123]. Scanning x, y manipulation is conducted magnetically with the entire array at once. The data storage substrate is suspended above the cantilever array with leaf springs which enables the nanometer-scale scanning tolerances required. The cantilevers are precisely curved using residual stress control of a silicon nitride layer in order to minimize the distance between the heating platform of the cantilever and the polymer film while maximizing the distance between the cantilever array and the film substrate to ensure that only the tips come into contact [9.123]. Fabrication details are given in Despont [9.125]. Thermal expansion is a major hurdle for this device since a shift of ≈ 30 nm can cause misalignment of the data storage substrate and the cantilever array. A 10 nm tip position accuracy of a 3 mm × 3 mm silicon area requires that temperature of the device be controlled to 1 ◦ C using several sensors and heater elements [9.123]. Tip wear due to contact between the tip and the underlying silicon substrate is an issue for device reliability. Additionally, the PMMA is prone to charring at the temperatures necessary for device operation (around 350 ◦ C) [9.128] so new polymeric formulations had to be developed to minimize this problem. The feasibility of using thin-film NiTi shape-memory alloy (SMA) for thermomechanical data storage as an alternative to the polymer thin film has also been shown [9.129].
9.10 Conclusion The sensors, actuators, and passive structures developed as MEMS and NEMS devices require a highly interdisciplinary approach to their analysis, design, de-
velopment, and fabrication. Experimental mechanics plays a critical role in design development, materials selection, prediction of allowable operating lim-
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
MEMS/NEMS testing must be further developed. This chapter has provided a brief review of the fabrication processes and materials commonly used and experimental mechanics as it is applied to MEMS and NEMS.
References 9.1 9.2 9.3
9.4
9.5
9.6
9.7 9.8 9.9
9.10 9.11
9.12 9.13
9.14
9.15
9.16
N. Maluf: An Introduction to Microelectromechanical Systems Engineering (Artech House, Boston 2000) B. Bhushan (Ed.): Springer Handbook of Nanotechnology (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 2006) Small Tech Business DirectoryTM Guide, Small Times Media, http://www.smalltechdirectory.com/ directory/directory.asp. Accessed July 20, 2007. J.C. Eloy: The MEMS industry: Current and future trends, OnBoard Technol., 22–24 (2006), http://www.onboard-technology.com/ pdf_settembre2006/090604.pdf (Accessed July 20, 2007) NewswireToday: Nanorobotics and NEMS to Reach $830.4 million by 2011, 05/31/2007, http://www.newswiretoday.com/news/18867/ (Accessed July 20, 2007) B. Ziaie, A. Baldi, M. Lei, Y. Gu, R.A. Siegel: Hard and soft micromachining for BioMEMS: review of techniques and examples of applications in microfluidics and drug delivery, Adv. Drug Deliv. Rev. 56, 145–172 (2004) S. Beeby, G. Ensell, M. Kraft, N. White: MEMS Mechanical Sensors (Artech House, Boston 2004) H.G. Craighead: Nanoelectromechanical systems, Science 290, 1532–1536 (2000) M. Koch, A.G.R. Evans, A. Brunnschweiler: Microfluidic Technology and Applications (Research Studies, Baldock 2000) G.T.A. Kovacs: Micromachined Transducers – Sourcebook (McGraw-Hill, New York 1998) K.L. Ekinci: Electromechanical transducers at the nanoscale: Actuation and sensing of motion in nanoelectromechanical systems (NEMS), Small 1(8-9), 786–797 (2005) K.L. Ekinci, M.L. Roukes: Nanoelectromechanical systems, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 76(061101), 1–12 (2005) P. Gammel, G. Fischer, J. Bouchaud: RF MEMS and NEMS technology, devices, and applications, Bell Labs Tech. J. 10(3), 29–59 (2005) W.A. Goddard III, D.W. Brenner, S.E. Lyshevski, G.J. Iafrate (Eds.): Handbook of Nanoscience, Engineering and Technology (CRC, Boca Raton 2002) S.E. Lyshevski: Nano- and Microelectromechanical Systems: Fundamentals of Nano- and Microengineering (CRC, Boca Raton 2000) T.S. Tighe, J.M. Worlock, M.L. Roukes: Direct thermal conductance measurements on suspended
9.17
9.18 9.19
9.20
9.21
9.22 9.23
9.24
9.25 9.26
9.27
9.28
monocrystalline nanostructures, Appl. Phys. Lett. 70(20), 2687–2689 (1997) R.G. Knobel, A.N. Cleland: Nanometre-scale displacement sensing using a single electron transistor, Nature 424(6946), 291–293 (2003) S.D. Senturia: Microsystem Design (Kluwer Academic, Boston 2001) SEM: Society for Experimental Mechanics, Bethel, 2007 SEM Annual Conference Proceedings, Springfield (2007). MEMS and Nanotechnology Clearinghouse: Material Index, http://www.memsnet.org/material/ (Accessed July 20, 2007) P. Lange, M. Kirsten, W. Riethmuller, B. Wenk, G. Zwicker, J.R. Morante, F. Ericson, J.A. Schweitz: Thisck polycrystalline silicon for surface micromechanical applications: deposition, structuring and mechanical characterization, 8th International conference on solid-state sensors and actuators (Transducers ’95), Stockholm (1995) pp. 202–205 M. Madou: Fundamentals of Microfabrication (CRC, Boca Raton 1997) B. Diem, M.T. Delaye, F. Michel, S. Renard, G. Delapierre: SOI(SIMOX) as a substrate for surface micromachining of single crystalline silicon sensors and actuators, 7th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors and Actuators (Transducers ’93), Yokohama (1993) pp. 233–236 J.M. Noworolski, E. Klaassen, J. Logan, K. Petersen, N. Maluf: Fabricationof SOI wafers with buried cavities using silicon fusion bonding ans electrochemical etchback, 8-th International conference on solid-state sensors and actuators (Transducers ’95), Stockholm (1995) pp. 71–74 T. Ikeda: Fundamentals of Piezoelectricity (Oxford Univ., New York 1990) P. Gluche, A. Floter, S. Ertl, H.J. Fecht: Commercial applications of diamond-based nano- and microtechnolgy. In: The Nano-Micro Interface, ed. by H.-J. Fecht, M. Werner (Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2004) pp. 247–262 S. Cho, I. Chasiotis, T.A. Friedmann, J.P. Sullivan: Young’s modulus, Poisson’s ratio and failure properties of tetrahedral amorphous diamond-like carbon for MEMS devices, J. Micromech. Microeng. 15, 728–735 (2005) A.R. Krauss, O. Auciello, D.M. Gruen, A. Jayatissa, A. Sumant, J. Tucek, D.C. Mancini, N. Moldovan,
225
Part A 9
its, device characterization, process validation, and quality control inspection. Commercial devices exist, and research in the area of MEMS/NEMS is extremely active, but many challenges remain. Advanced materials must be well characterized and
References
226
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9 9.29 9.30
9.31
9.32 9.33 9.34 9.35 9.36
9.37 9.38
9.39
9.40
9.41
9.42
9.43
9.44
9.45 9.46
A. Erdemir, D. Ersoy, M.N. Gardos, H.G. Busmann, E.M. Meyer, M.Q. Ding: Ultrananocrystalline diamond thin films for MEMS and moving mechanical assembly devices, Diamond Relat. Mater. 10(11), 1952–1961 (2001) D. Gruen: Nanocrystalline diamond films, Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci. 29, 211–259 (1999) D.M. Gruen, S. Liu, A.R. Krauss, J. Luo, X. Pan: Fullerenes as precursors for diamond film growth without hydrogen or oxygen additions, Appl. Phys. Lett. 64, 1502–1504 (1994) D.M. Gruen, S. Liu, A.R. Krauss, X. Pan: Buckyball microwave plasmas – fragmentation and diamondfilm growth, J. Appl. Phys. 75, 1758–1763 (1994) S.J. Clarson, J.A. Semlyen (Eds.): Siloxane Polymers (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs 1993) C. Liu: Foundations of MEMS (Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River 2006) K. Otsuka, C.M. Wayman (Eds.): Shape Memory Materials (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1998) H.-J. Fecht, M. Werner: The Nano-Micro Interface (Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2004) M.J. Yacamaìn, T. Tsakalakos, B.H. Kear (Eds.): Proceedings of the First International Conference on Nanostructured Materials, Cancun, Nanostruct. Mater. 3(1/6), 22–26 (1993) V.E. Borisenko, S. Ossicini: What is What in the Nanoworld (Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2004) B.D. Busbee, S.O. Obare, C.J. Murphy: An improved synthesis of high-aspect-ratio gold nanorods, Adv. Mater. 15(5), 414–416 (2003) F. Favier, E.C. Walter, M.P. Zach, T. Benter, R.M. Penner: Hydrogen sensors and switches from electrodeposited palladium mesowire arrays, Science 293(5538), 2227–2231 (2001) M.H. Huang, S. Mao, H. Feick, H.Q. Yan, Y.Y. Wu, H. Kind, E. Webber, R. Russo, P.D. Yang: Roomtemperature ultraviolet nanowire nanolasers, Science 292(5523), 1897–1899 (2001) R.M. Penner, C.R. Martin: Preparation and electrochemical characterization of ultramicroelectrode ensembles, Anal. Chem. 59(21), 2625–2630 (1987) J.C. Hulteen, C.R. Martin: A general template-based method for the preparation of nanomaterials, J. Mater. Chem. 7(7), 1075–1087 (1997) S. K. Chakarvarti: Science and art of synthesis and crafting of nano/microstructures and devices using ion-crafted templates: A review, Proc. SPIE 61702(61720G), 1–9 (2006) M.S. Dresselhaus, Y.-M. Lin, O. Rabin, M.R. Black, G. Dresselhaus: Nanowires. In: Springer Handbook of Nanotechnology, ed. by B. Bhushan (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 2007) W.R. DeVries: Analysis of Material Removal Processes (Springer, New York 1992) S. Kalpajian: Manufacturing Processes for Engineering Materials (Addison-Wesley, Reading 1984)
9.47
9.48 9.49
9.50 9.51
9.52
9.53
9.54
9.55
9.56
9.57
9.58
9.59
9.60 9.61
9.62
N. Taniguchi: Current status in, and future trends of, ultraprecision machining and ultrafine materials processing, Ann. CIRP 32, S573–S582 (1983) C. Evans: Precision Engineering (Cranfield, Cranfield 1989) J.M. Bustillo, R.T. Howe, R.S. Muller: Surface micromachining for microelectromechanical systems, Proc. IEEE 86(8), 1559–1561 (1998) M. Gentili, C. Giovannella, S. Selci (Eds.): Nanolithography (Kluwer Academic, Boston 1994) K.R. Williams, R.S. Muller: Etch rates for micromachining processing, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 5(4), 256–269 (1996) B. Li, X. Tang, H. Xie, X. Zhang: Strain analysis in MEMS/NEMS structures and devices by using focused ion beam system, Sens. Actuator A 111(1), 57–62 (2004) H. Xie, Z. Liu, H. Shang, Q. Xue, J. Jia, D. Fang: Micro/nano grating and its application to moire measurement, Proc. SPIE 5852, 740–744 (2005) Sandia National Laboratories, Micromachines: SAMPLESTM Program, http://mems.sandia.gov/ samples/index.html (Accessed July 20, 2007) H. Guckel: High-aspect ratio micromachining via deep x-ray lithography, Proc. IEEE 86(8), 1586–1593 (1998) E.W. Becker, W. Ehrfeld, P. Hagmann, A. Maner, D. Munchmeyer: Fabrication of microstructures with high aspect ratios and great structural heights by synchrotron radiation lithography, galvanoforming, and plastic moulding (LIGA process), Microelectron. Eng. 4(1), 35–56 (1986) P. Bley, W. Menz, W. Bacher, K. Feit, M. Harmening, H. Hein, J. Mohr, W.K. Schomburg, W. Stark: Application of the LIGA process in fabrication of three-dimensional mechanical microstructures, 4th International Symposium on MicroProcess Conference Kanazawa (1991) pp. 384–389 J.L. Wilbur, G.M. Whitesides: Self-assembly and self-assembled monolayers in micro- and nanofabrication. In: Nanotechnology, ed. by G. Timp (Springer, New York 1999) pp. 331–369 G.M. Whitesides, J.P. Mathias, C.T. Seto: Molecular self-assembly and nanochemistry: a chemical strategy for synthesis of nanostructures, Science 254, 1312–1318 (1991) G.M. Whitesides: Self-assembling materials, Sci. Am. 273, 146–149 (1995) H. Ringsdorf, B. Schlarb, J. Venzmer: Molecular architecture and function of polymeric oriented systems: Models for the study of organization, surface recognition, and dynamics, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 27, 113–158 (1988) G.M. Whitesides, P.E. Laibinis: Wet chemical approaches to the characterization of organic surfaces. Self-assembled monolayers, wetting, and the
A Brief Introduction to MEMS and NEMS
9.64 9.65
9.66 9.67
9.68 9.69
9.70
9.71 9.72
9.73
9.74 9.75
9.76
9.77 9.78
9.79
9.80
9.81
9.82
9.83 9.84
9.85
9.86
9.87 9.88
9.89
9.90
9.91
9.92
9.93
9.94
9.95
9.96
9.97 9.98
C. Gorecki (Ed.): Microsystems Metrology and Inspection, Proc. EuroOpto Ser, Vol. 3825 (The Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers, Washington 1999) W.C. Young, R.G. Budynas: Roark’s Formulas for Stress and Strain (McGraw-Hill, New York 2002) ASTM International: ASTM E2245-05, Standard Test Method for Residual Strain Measurements of Thin, Reflecting Films Using an Optical Interferometer (2005) M.G. Allen, M. Mehregany, R.T. Howe, S.D. Senturia: Microfabricated structures for the in-situ measurement of residual stress, Young’s modulus, and ultimate strain of thin films, Appl. Phys. Lett. 51(4), 241–243 (1987) P.M. Osterberg, S.D. Senturia: M-TESt: a test chip for MEMS material property measurements using electrostatically actuated test structures, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 6(2), 107–117 (1997) W.D. Nix: Mechanical properties of thin films, Metall. Trans. 20A, 2217–2245 (1989) K.E. Petersen: Dynamic micromechanics on silicon: Techniques and devices, IEEE Trans. Electron. Dev. 25, 1241–1250 (1978) L.M. Zhang, D. Uttamchandani, B. Culshaw: Measurement of the mechanical properties of silicon resonators, Sens. Actuator A 29, 79–84 (1991) B. Li, H. Xie, B. Xu, R. Geer, J. Castracane: Investigation of strain in microstructures by a novel moire method, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 11(6), 829–36 (2002) D. Vogel, D. Lieske, A. Gollhardt, J. Keller, N. Sabate, J.R. Morante, B. Michel: FIB based measurements for material characterization on MEMS structures, Proc. SPIE 5766, 60–69 (2005) A.A. Ayon, X. Zhang, K.T. Turner, D. Choi, B. Miller, S.F. Nagle, S.M. Spearing: Characterization of silicon wafer bonding for power MEMS applications, Sens. Actuator A 103, 1–8 (2003) P.G. Charalambides, H.C. Cao, J. Lund, A.G. Evans: Developments of a test method for measuring the mixed mode fracture resistance of bimaterial interfaces, Mech. Mater. 8(4), 269–283 (1990) K.T. Turner, M.D. Thouless, S.M. Spearing: Mechanics of wafer bonding: Effect of clamping, J. Appl. Phys. 95(1), 349–355 (2004) D.S. Campbell: Mechanical properties of thin films. In: Handbook of Thin Film Technology, ed. by L.I. Maissel, R. Glang (McGraw-Hill, New York 1970) C.H. Mastrangelo, C.H. Hsu: Mechanical stability and adhesion of microstructures under capillary forces. I. Basic theory, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 2(1), 33–43 (1993) M.P. de Boer, T.M. Mayer: Tribology of MEMS, MRS Bull. 26(4), 302–304 (2001) J.R. Martin, Y. Zhao: Micromachined device packaged to reduce stiction, US Patent 5694740 (1997)
227
Part A 9
9.63
physical-organic chemistry of the solid-liquid interface, Langmuir 6(1), 87–96 (1990) L.H. Dubois, R.G. Nuzzo: Synthesis, structure, and properties of model organic-surfaces, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 43, 437–463 (1992) A. Ulman: Surface-absorption of monolayers, Mater. Res. Soc. Bull. 20(6), 46–51 (1995) A.R. Bishop, R.G. Nuzzo: Self-assembled monolayers: Recent developments and applications, Curr. Opin. Coll. Interface Sci. 1(1), 127–136 (1996) Y. Xia, G.M. Whitesides: Soft lithography, Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci 28, 153–184 (1998) E. Delamarche, H. Schmid, H.A. Biebuyck, B. Michel: Stability of molded polydimethylsiloxane microstructures, Adv. Mater. 9(9), 741–746 (1997) J.A. Preece, J.F. Stoddart: Concept transfer from biology to materials, Nanobiology 3, 149–166 (1994) J.A. Stroscio, D.M. Eigler: Atomic and molecular manipulation with the scanning tunneling microscope, Science 254, 1319–1326 (1991) D. Eigler: From the bottom up: building things with atoms. In: Nanotechnology, ed. by G. Timp (Springer, New York 1999) pp. 331–369 R.D. Piner, J. Zhu, F. Xu, S. Hong, C.A. Mirkin: “Dippen” nanolithography, Science 283, 661–663 (1999) D. Bullen, X. Wang, J. Zou, S.-W. Chung, C.A. Mirkin, C. Liu: Design, fabrication, and characterization of thermally actuated probe arrays for Dip Pen nanolithography, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 13(4), 594–602 (2004) Q. Tang, S.-Q. Shi, L. Zhou: Nanofabrication with atomic force microscopy source, J. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. 4(8), 948–963 (2004) W.N. Sharpe, K.T. Turner, R.L. Edwards: Tensile testing of polysilicon, Exp. Mech. 39(3), 162–70 (1999) S.F. Bart, T.A. Lober, R.T. Howe, M.F. Schlecht: Design considerations for micromachined electric actuators, Sens. Actuator 14, 269–292 (1988) D.W. Carr, L. Sekaric, H.G. Craighead: Measurement of nanomechanical resonant structures in singlecrystal silicon, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 16(6), 3821–3824 (1998) W.S. Trimmer (Ed.): Micromechanics and MEMS (IEEE, New York 1997) W.N. Sharpe: Mechanical properties of MEMS materials. In: MEMS handbook, ed. by M. Gad-el-Hak (CRC, Boca Raton 2002) V.T. Srikar, S.M. Spearing: A critical review of microscale mechanical testing methods used in the design of microelectromechanical systems, Exp. Mech. 43(3), 238–247 (2003) M.A. Haque, M.T.A. Saif: A review of MEMS-based microscale and nanoscale tensile and bending testing, Exp. Mech. 43(3), 248–255 (2003) T. Yi, C.J. Kim: Measurement of mechanical properties of MEMS materials, Meas. Sci. Tech. 10, 706–716 (1999)
References
228
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 9
9.99
9.100 9.101
9.102
9.103
9.104
9.105
9.106
9.107
9.108
9.109 9.110
9.111
9.112 9.113
9.114
R.W. Carpick, M. Salmeron: Scratching the surface: Fundamanetal investigations of tribology with atomic force microscopy, Chem. Rev. 97, 1163–1194 (1997) B. Bhushan: Introduction to Tribology (Wiley, New York 2002) M.P. de Boer, J.A. Knapp, T.M. Mayer, T.A. Michalske: The role of interfacial properties on MEMS performance and reliability. In: Microsystems Metrology and Inspection, Proc. EuroOpto Ser., Vol. 3825, ed. by C. Gorecki (Society of Photo-Optical, Washington 1999) pp. 2–15 M.P. de Boer, N.F. Smith, N.D. Masters, M.B. Sinclair, E.J. Pryputniewicz: Integrated platform for testing MEMS mechanical properties at the wafer scale by the IMaP methodology, ASTM Spec. Tech. Pub. 1413, 85–95 (2001) J.G. Santiago, S.T. Wereley, C.D. Meinhart, D.J. Beebe, R.J. Adrian: A particle image velocimetry system for microfluidics, Exp. Fluids 25, 316–319 (1998) C.D. Meinhart, S.T. Wereley, J.G. Santiago: PIV measurements of a microchannel flow, Exp. Fluids 27, 414–419 (1999) C.D. Meinhart, H. Zhang: The flow structure inside a microfabricated inkjet printer head, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 9, 67–75 (2000) S. Wereley, C.D. Meinhart, S. Stone, V. Hohreiter, J. Chung: Experimental microfluidics toolbox for MEMS characterization, Proc. SPIE 4558, 124–132 (2001) E.T. Enikov: Structures and materials. In: Mechatronics Handbook, ed. by R.H. Bichop (CRC, Boca Raton 2002) S. J. Walker, D. J. Nagel: Optics and MEMS, Tech. Rep. NRL/MR/6336-99-7975 (Naval Research Lab, Washington 1999) L.J. Hornbeck: Frame addressed spatial light modulator, US Patent 4615595 (1986) P.F. Van Kessel, L.J. Hornbeck, R.E. Meier, M.R. Douglass: A MEMS-based projection display, Proc. IEEE 86(8), 1687–1704 (1998) L.J. Hornbeck: Digital light processing for highbrightness, high-resolution applications, Proc. SPIE 3013, 27–40 (1997) S.A. Henck: Lubrication of Digital Micromirror DevicesTM , Tribol. Lett. 3(3), 239–247 (1997) K. Hehr, S. Kurth, J. Mehner, W. Dotzel, T. Gessner: Investigation of heat transfer in micromirrors. In: Microsystems Metrology and Inspection, Proc. EuroOpto Ser., Vol. 3825, ed. by C. Gorecki (The Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers, Washington 1999) pp. 24– 33 R. E. Meier: DMDTM pixel mechanics simulation, TI Tech. J., 64–74 (1998) Special issue on DLP—DMD Manufacturing and Design Challenges
9.115 J. Fritz, M.K. Baller, H.P. Lang, H.P. Rothuizen, P. Vettiger, E. Meyer, H.-J. Guntherodt, C. Gerber, J.K. Gimzewski: Translating biomolecular recognition into nanomechanics, Science 288(5464), 316–318 (2000) 9.116 S.C. Kuo, M.P. Sheetz: Force of single kinesin molecules measured with optical tweezers, Science 260(5105), 232–234 (1993) 9.117 E.L. Florin, V.T. Moy, H.E. Gaub: Adhesion forces between individual ligand-receptor pairs, Science 264(5157), 415–417 (1994) 9.118 G.U. Lee, L.A. Chrisey, R.J. Colton: Direct measurement of the forces between complementary strands of DNA, Science 266(5186), 771–773 (1994) 9.119 S.B. Smith, L. Finzi, C. Bustamante: Force of single kinesin molecules measured with optical tweezers, Science 258(5085), 1122–1126 (1992) 9.120 T. Thundat, G. Wu, M. Mao, A. Majumdar: Biochemoopto-mechanical (BioCOM) chip for chemical and biomolecular detection, 1st NASA and NCI Workshop on Sensors for Bio-Molecular Signatures (1999) 9.121 M. Sepaniak, P. Datskos, N. Lavrik, C. Tipple: Microcantilever transducers: a new approach in sensor technology, Anal. Chem. 74(21), 568A–575A (2002) 9.122 M. Despont, J. Brugger, U. Drechsler, U. Dürig, W. Häberle, M.I. Lutwyche, H.E. Rothuizen, R. Stutz, R. Widmer, G.K. Binnig, H. Rohrer, P. Vettiger: VLSI-NEMS chip for AFM data storage, Technical Digest, 12th IEEE International Micro Electro Mechanical Systems Conference (MEMS ’99), Orlando (1999) pp. 564–569 9.123 P. Vettiger, M. Despont, U. Drechsler, U. Dürig, W. Häberle, M.I. Lutwyche, H.E. Rothuizen, R. Stutz, R. Widmer, G.K. Binnig: The “Millipede” – more than one thousand tips for future AFM data storage, IBM J. Res. Dev. 44(3), 323–340 (2000) 9.124 P. Vettiger, B. Cross, M. Despone, U. Drechsler, U. Durig, B. Botsmann, W. Haberle, M.A. Lantz, H.E. Rothuizen, R. Stutz, G.K. Binnig: The “millipede” – nanotechnology entering data storage, IEEE Trans. Nanotechnol. 1(1), 39–55 (2002) 9.125 M. Despont, U. Drechsler, R. Yu, H.B. Pogge, P. Vettiger: Wafer-scale microdevice transfer/interconnect: its application in an AFM-based data-storage system, J. Microelectromech. Syst. 13(6), 895–901 (2004) 9.126 G.K. Binnig, J. Brugger, W. Häberle, P. Vettiger: Investigation and/or manipulation device, US Patent 6249747 (2001) 9.127 P. Vettiger, G. Binnig: The nanodrive project, Sci. Am. 288(1), 47–53 (2003) 9.128 B.J. Holland, J.N. Hay: The thermal degradation of poly(vinyl alcohol), Polymer 42(16), 6775–6783 (2001) 9.129 G.A. Shaw, J.S. Trethewey, A.D. Johnson, W.J. Drugan, W.C. Crone: Thermomechanical high-density data storage in a metallic material via the shapememory effect, Adv. Mater. 17, 1123–1127 (2005)
229
Hybrid Metho 10. Hybrid Methods
Analyses involving real structures and components are, by their very nature, only partially specified. The central role of modern experimental analysis is to help complete, through measurement and testing, the construction of an analytical model for the given problem. This chapter recapitulates recent developments in hybrid methods for achieving this and demonstrates through examples the progress being made.
10.1 Basic Theory of Inverse Methods ............ 10.1.1 Partially Specified Problems and Experimental Mechanics ......... 10.1.2 Origin of Ill-Conditioning in Inverse Problems...................... 10.1.3 Minimizing Principle with Regularization ...................... 10.2 Parameter Identification Problems......... 10.2.1 Sensitivity Response Method (SRM) . 10.2.2 Experimental Data Study I: Measuring Dynamic Properties ....... 10.2.3 Experimental Data Study II: Measuring Effective BCs................. 10.2.4 Synthetic Data Study I: Dynamic Crack Propagation ........................ 10.3 Force Identification Problems ................ 10.3.1 Sensitivity Response Method for Static Problems ....................... 10.3.2 Generalization for Transient Loads .
231 231 232 234 235 235 237 239 240 240
10.3.3 Experimental Data Study I: Double-Exposure Holography ........ 243 10.3.4 Experimental Data Study II: One-Sided Hopkinson Bar ............. 244 10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems ............................................. 10.4.1 Nonlinear Data Relations .............. 10.4.2 Nonlinear Structural Dynamics ....... 10.4.3 Nonlinear Space–Time Deconvolution ............................. 10.4.4 Experimental Data Study I: Stress Analysis Around a Hole ........ 10.4.5 Experimental Data Study II: Photoelastic Analysis of Cracks ....... 10.4.6 Synthetic Data Study I: Elastic–Plastic Projectile Impact ..... 10.4.7 Synthetic Data Study II: Multiple Loads on a Truss Structure 10.4.8 Experimental Data Study III: Dynamic Photoelasticity ................ 10.5 Discussion of Parameterizing the Unknowns...................................... 10.5.1 Parameterized Loadings and Subdomains .......................... 10.5.2 Unknowns Parameterized Through a Second Model ............... 10.5.3 Final Remarks ..............................
246 246 247 248 250 251 252 253 254
255 255 256 257
241 242
References .................................................. 257
Experimental methods do not provide a complete stress analysis solution without additional processing of the data and/or assumptions about the structural system. As eloquently stated by Kobayashi [10.1] in the earlier edition of this Handbook: “One of the frustrations of an experimental stress analyst is the lack of a universal experimental procedure that solves all problems”. Figure 10.1 shows experimental whole-field data for some sample stress analysis problems; these example prob-
lems were chosen because they represent a range of difficulties often encountered when doing experimental stress analysis using whole-field optical methods. The photoelastic data of Fig. 10.1b can directly give the stresses along a free edge; however, because of edge effects, machining effects, and loss of contrast, the quality of photoelastic data is poorest along the edge, precisely where we need good data. Furthermore, a good deal of additional data collection and processing
Part A 10
James F. Doyle
230
Part A
a)
Part A 10
b)
Solid Mechanics Topics
P
Initial
p (x)
c)
Fig. 10.1a–c Example whole-field experimental data. (a) Moiré inplane u-displacement fringes for a point-loaded plate (the inset is the initial fringe pattern). (b) Photoelastic stress-difference fringes for a plate with a hole. (c) Double-exposure holographic out-ofplane displacement fringes for a circular plate with uniform pressure
is required if the stresses away from the free edge are of interest (this would be the case in contact and thermal problems). By contrast, the moiré methods give objective displacement information over the whole field but suffer the drawback that the fringe data must be spatially differentiated to give the strains and subsequently the stresses. It is clear from Fig. 10.1a that the fringes are too sparse to allow for differentiation; this is especially true if the stresses at the load application point are of interest. Also, the moiré methods invariably have an initial fringe pattern that must be subtracted from the loaded pattern, which leads to further deterioration of the computed strains. Double-exposure holography directly gives the deformed pattern but is so sensitive that fringe contrast is easily lost (as seen in Fig. 10.1c) and fringe localization can become a problem. The strains in this case are obtained by double spatial differentiation of the measured data on the assumption that the plate is correctly described by classical thin-plate theory – otherwise it is uncertain as to how the strains are to be obtained. Conceivably, we can overcome the limitations of each of these methods in special circumstances; in this work, however, we propose to tackle each difficulty dir-
ectly and in a consistent manner across the different experimental methods and different types of problems. That is, given a limited amount of sometimes sparse (both spatially and temporally) and sometimes (visually) poor data, determine the complete stress and strain state of the structure. The basic approach is to supplement the experimental data with analytical modeling of the problem; this is referred to as hybrid stress analysis. Experimental mechanics has a long tradition of using hybrid methods; early examples in stress analysis were the use of finite differences combined with the equilibrium and/or compatibility equations to separate the stress components in photoelasticity. Kobayashi [10.1, 2] gives an in-depth study of this early literature with an impressive array of applications and results. More recent hybrid literature is represented by Rowlands and coworkers [10.3–5] and their cited bibliography. Applications include strain gages for stress concentrations, stress pattern analysis by thermal emissions (SPATE) for thermoelastic problems, and moiré for crack analysis, to name a few. This chapter builds on this earlier research but tries to extend it beyond stress to more general applications in experimental mechanics. The ideas expressed here are elaborated in [10.6], where the thesis is advanced that the central role of experimental mechanics is to help complete construction of the analytical model using the finite element method (FEM). A single approach, called the sensitivity response method, is used across all problems and this is made feasible because of the coupling with finite element methods. The chapter begins with a general discussion of inverse problems and places the hybrid methods within the context of partially specified problems. It is shown that the two main categories of problems are parameter identification and force identification. The following sections then show solutions of these in a variety of situations involving static/dynamic and linear/nonlinear problems, and using point/whole-field data. The examples discussed are a mixture of those using experimental data to assess the practicality of the methods and those using synthetic data to assess the robustness of the algorithms. The chapter ends with a general discussion of methods of parameterizing the problem and identifying the fundamental set of unknowns.
Hybrid Methods
10.1 Basic Theory of Inverse Methods
231
10.1 Basic Theory of Inverse Methods
10.1.1 Partially Specified Problems and Experimental Mechanics To begin making the connection between analysis (or model building) and experiment, consider a simple situation using the finite element method for analysis of a linear static problem; the problem is mathematically represented by [K ]{u} = {P} , where [K ] is the stiffness of the structure, {P} is the vector of applied loads, and {u} is the unknown vector of nodal displacements. (The notation is that of [10.11, 12].) The solution of these problems can be put in the generic form {u} = [K −1 ]{P} or {response} = [system]{input} . We describe forward problems as those where both the system and the input are known and only the response is unknown. A finite element analysis of a problem where the geometry and material properties (the system) are known, where the loads (the input) are known, and where we wish to determine the displacement (the response) is an example of a forward problem. An inverse problem is one where something about the system or the input is unknown but inferred by utilizing some measured response information. A common example is the measurement of load (input) and strain (response) on a uniaxial specimen to infer the Young’s modulus (system). In fact, all experimental problems can be thought of as inverse problems because we use response information to infer something about the system or the input. A word about terminology. Strictly, an inverse problem is one requiring the inverse of the system matrix.
Thus all problems involving simultaneous equations (which means virtually every problem in computational mechanics) are inverse problems. But we do not want to refer to these FEM problems as inverse problems; indeed, we want to refer to them as forward problems. Consequently, we shall call those methods, techniques, algorithms, etc., for the robust inversion of matrices inverse methods and give looser meanings to forward and inverse problems based on their cause and effect relationship. Thus a forward problem (irrespective of whether a matrix inversion is involved or not) is one for which the system is known, the inputs are known, and the responses are the only unknowns. An inverse problem is one where something about the system or the input is unknown and knowledge of something about the response is needed in order to effect a solution. Thus the key ingredient in inverse problems is the use of response data and hence its connection to experimental methods. A fully specified forward problem is one where all the materials, geometries, boundary conditions, loads, and so on are known and the displacements, stresses, and so on are required. A partially specified forward problem is one where some input information is missing. A common practice in finite element analyses is to try to make all problems fully specified by invoking reasonable modeling assumptions. Consider the following set of unknowns and the type of assumptions that could be made:
• • • •
Dimension (e.g., ice on power lines): Assume a standard deposit thickness. Report the results for a range of values about this mean. Boundary condition (e.g., loose bolt connection): Assume an elastic support/attachment. Report the results for a range of support values from very stiff to somewhat flexible. Loading (e.g., hail impacting a windshield): Assume an interaction model (hertzian, plastic). Report the results for a range of model parameters. Model (e.g., sloshing fuel tank): Assume no dynamic effects, just model the mass and stiffness. Since the unknown was not parameterized, its effect cannot be gauged.
Note that in each case because assumptions are used the results must be reported over the possible latitude of the assumptions. This adds considerably to the total cost of the analysis. Additionally, and ultimately more impor-
Part A 10.1
Before developing specific algorithms for solving problems in experimental mechanics, we will first review some of the basic theory of solving inverse problems. Inverse problems are difficult to solve since they are notoriously ill-conditioned (i.e., small changes in data result in large changes of response); a robust solution must incorporate (in addition to the measurements and our knowledge of the system) extra information either about the underlying system, or about the nature of the response functions, or both. A key idea to be introduced is that of regularization. Additional details can be found in [10.6–10].
232
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 10.1
tantly, the use of assumptions makes the results of the analyses uncertain and even unreliable. It may appear that the most direct way of minimizing uncertainty in our assumptions is simply to measure the unknown. For an unknown dimension this may be straightforward but what about the force due to impact of hail on an aircraft wing? This is not something that can be measured directly. It is our objective here to use indirect measurements in the solution of partially specified problems to infer, rather than assume, quantities that are not directly measurable. The unknowns in a problem fall into two broad categories: system and input. Those associated with the system will be referred to as parameter identification problems, whereas those associated with the input will be referred to as force identification problems. As will be shown, by using the idea of sensitivity responses generated by the analytical model, we can formulate both sets of problems using a common underlying foundation; we will refer to the approach as the sensitivity response method (SRM). Also, quantities of interest in usual hybrid analyses (such as stress and strain distributions) are not considered basic unknowns; once the problem is fully specified these are obtained as a postprocessing operation on the model. What emerges is the central role played by models: the FEM model, the loading model, and so on. Because of the wide range of possible models needed, it would not make sense to embed these models in the inverse methods. We instead will try to develop inverse methods that use FEM and the like as external processes in a distributed computing sense. In this way, the power and versatility of stand-alone commercial packages can be harnessed.
10.1.2 Origin of Ill-Conditioning in Inverse Problems We begin with a simple illustration of the distinction between forward and inverse problems and how a system can become ill-conditioned. Reference [10.10] introduces the scenario of a zookeeper with an unknown number of animals and, based on the number of heads and feet, we try to infer the number of animals of each type. Let us continue with this scenario and suppose the zookeeper has just a number of lions (L) and tigers (T ), then the number of heads (H) and paws (P) of all his animals can be computed as H = L +T H 1 1 L or = . P = 4L + 4T P 4 4 T
This is a well-stated forward set of equations; that is, given the populations of lions and tigers (the input), and the number of heads and paws per each animal (the system), we can compute precisely the total number of heads and paws (the output). Let us invert the problem, that is, given the total number of heads and paws, determine the populations of lions and tigers. The answer is −1 H L 1 1 . = P T 4 4 Unfortunately, the indicated matrix inverse cannot be computed because its determinant is zero. When the determinant of a system matrix is zero, we say that the system is singular. It is important to realize that our data are precise and yet we cannot get a satisfactory solution. Also, it is incorrect to say we cannot get a solution as, in fact, we get an infinity of solutions that satisfy the given data. Thus it is not always true that N equations are sufficient to solve for N unknowns; the equations may be consistent but contain insufficient information to separate the N unknowns. Indeed, we can even overspecify our problem by including the number of eyes as additional data and still not get a satisfactory solution. The origin of the problem is that our choice of features to describe the animals (heads, paws, eyes) does not distinguish between the animals because lions and tigers have the same number of heads and paws. Let us choose the weight as a distinguishing feature and say (on average) that each lion weighs 100 and each tiger weighs 100 + Δ. The heads and weight totals are H 1 1 L = , W 100 100 + Δ T 1 100 + Δ −1 H L . = Δ −100 1 W T As long as (on average) the animals have a different weight (Δ = 0) then we get a unique (single) inverse solution for the two populations. The heads are counted using integer arithmetic and we can assume it is precise, but assume there is some error in the weight measurement, that is, W → W ± δ. Then the estimated populations of lions and tigers are given by 1 100 + Δ −1 H L∗ = , or Δ −100 1 T∗ W ±δ δ δ L∗ = L ∓ , T ∗ = T ± , Δ Δ
Hybrid Methods
a)
I2 I1 y1
S2 d
y2
D
d S1
from our choice of weight as a purported distinguishing feature between the animals. The second thing we notice about the estimated populations is that the errors go in opposite directions. As a consequence, if the estimated populations are substituted back into the forward equations then excellent agreement with the measured data is obtained even though the populations may be grossly in error. The sad conclusion is that excellent agreement between model predictions and data is no guarantee of a good model if we suspect that the model system is ill-conditioned. As a more pertinent example of ill-conditioning, consider the measurement situation shown in Fig. 10.2 where two detectors, I1 and I2 , are used to determine the strength of two sources, S1 and S2 . Suppose the intensity obeys an inverse power law so that it diminishes as 1/r, then the detectors receive the intensities 1/r11 1/r12 S1 I1 = , I2 1/r21 1/r22 S2 rij = D2 + (yi + d j )2 , where the subscripts on r(i, j) are (sensor, source). We wish to investigate the sensitivity of this system to errors. Figure 10.2b shows the reconstructions of the sources (labeled as direct) when there is a fixed 0.001% source of error in the second sensor. The sources have strengths of 1.0 and 2.0, respectively. There is a steady increase in error as the sensors become more remote (D increases for fixed d; a similar effect occurs as d is decreased for fixed D). Least squares is popularly used to normalize a system of equations that is overdetermined (more equations than unknowns) [10.8]; let us use least squares here even though to system is determined. This leads to S1 1/r11 1/r21 1/r11 1/r12 1/r12 1/r22 1/r21 1/r22 S2 I1 1/r11 1/r21 . = 1/r12 1/r22 I2
b) Strength 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 –2 –4 –6 –8 –10
Direct Least squares
–12 10
20
30
40
50 60 Distance (D/d)
Fig. 10.2a,b Two detectors measuring emissions from two sources: (a) geometry and (b) reconstructions of source strengths for fixed error in the second sensor
The inverse results are also shown in Fig. 10.2b. The least-squares solution shows very erratic behavior as D/d is increased. It is sometimes mistakenly thought that least squares will cancel errors in the data and thereby give the correct (true or smoothed) answer. Least squares will average errors in the reconstructions of the data but in all likelihood the computed solu-
233
Part A 10.1
where L and T are the exact (true) values, respectively. We notice two things about this result. First, for a given measurement error δ, the difference in weight between the animals acts as an amplifier on the errors in the population estimates; that is, the smaller Δ is, the larger is δ/Δ. When Δ is small (but not zero) we say the system is ill-conditioned – small changes in data (δ) cause large changes in results. If there were no measurement errors, then we would not notice the ill-conditioning of the problem, but the measurement errors do not cause the ill-conditioning – this is a system property arising
10.1 Basic Theory of Inverse Methods
Solid Mechanics Topics
B(u) = {u} [H]{u} with [H] being an [M × M] positive-definite matrix (the unit matrix, say), then minimizing this will lead to a unique solution for {u}. Of course, the solution will not be very accurate since none of the data were used. The key point in the inverse solution is: if we add any multiple γ times B(u) to A(u) then minimizing A(u) + γ B(u) will lead to a unique solution for {u}. Thus, the essential idea in our inverse theory is the objective to minimize A + γ B = {d} − [A]{u} W {d} − [A]{u}
B∝
du dx
2 dx ∝
M−1
({u}m − {u}m+1 )2
m=1
= ([D]{u})2
La
rg e
rm
ro r
where {d} is the data vector and [A] is the system matrix. If [A] has fewer rows (N, data) than columns (M, unknowns) then minimizing A(u), will give the correct number of equations (M); however, it will not give a unique solution for {u} because the system matrix will be rank deficient. Suppose instead we choose a nondegenerate quadratic form B(u), for example,
These equations can be solved by standard techniques such as [LU] decomposition [10.11]. As opposed to the standard least-squares form, these equations are not ill-conditioned because of the role played by γ and the regularization matrix [H] in preventing the system eigenvalues from becoming very small, and, as will be discussed shortly, can be used to add levels of smoothness to the inverse solution. The concept of regularization is a relatively recent idea in the history of mathematics; the first few papers on the subject seem to be those of [10.13, 14], although [10.9] cites earlier literature in Russian. A readable discussion of regularization is given in [10.8] and a more extensive mathematical treatment can be found in [10.7]. This latter reference has an extensive bibliography. The regularization method we will use here is generally called Tikhonov regularization [10.9, 15, 16]. Typically, the functional B involves some measure of smoothness that derives from first or higher derivatives. Consider a distribution represented by u(x) or its discretization {u} which we wish to determine from some measurements. Suppose that our a priori belief is that, locally, u(x) is not too different from a constant, then a reasonable functional to minimize is associated with the first derivative
“Best” solution od
er
Suppose that {u} is an unknown vector that we plan to solve for by some minimizing principle. Suppose, further, that our functional A(u) has the particular form of the χ 2 error function [10.8], A(u) = {d} − [A]{u} {d} − [A]{u} ,
[A] W[A] + γ [H] {u} = [A] W{d} .
at a
10.1.3 Minimizing Principle with Regularization
so-called trade-off curve of Fig. 10.3. The minimization problem is reduced to a linear set of normal equations by the usual method of differentiation to yield
el
rd
Part A 10.1
tion will not be smooth. Closer inspection shows that when one solution is up the other is down, and vice versa. What we are seeing is the manifestation of illconditioning. It should also be emphasized that these erratic values of S1 and S2 reconstruct the measurements, I1 and I2 , very closely (i. e., within the error bounds of the measurements). Ill-conditioning is a property of the system and not the data; errors in the data manifests the illconditioning. As it happens, the condition number of the matrix product [A ][A] (the ratio of its largest eigenvalue to its smallest) is the square of that of the matrix [A] and this is why least-squares solutions are more apt to be ill-conditioned. In this work, we alleviate this problem by introducing regularization.
er
ro r
rg e
Part A
La
234
+ γ u [H]u , where W is a general weighting array, although we will take it as diagonal. We minimize the error functional for various values of 0 < γ < ∞ along the
More regularization
Fig. 10.3 Inverse solutions involve a trade-off between achieving good data agreement and smooth modeling
Hybrid Methods
since it is nonnegative and equal to zero only when u(x) is constant. We can write the second form of B as B = {u} [D] [D]{u} ,
0 −1 · · · ⎡ ⎤ 1 −1 0 · · · ⎢ ⎥ ⎢−1 2 −1 · · ·⎥ [H] = [D] [D] = ⎢ ⎥. ⎣ 0 −1 2 · · ·⎦ ··· −1 · · · The above choice of [D] is only the simplest in an obvious sequence of derivatives. References [10.6, 8] give explicit forms for the matrices [D] and [H] for higherorder smoothing. An apparent weakness of regularization methods is that the solution procedure does not specify the amount of regularization to be used. This is not exactly true, but choosing an appropriate value for γ is an important aspect of solving inverse problems. First, we must understand that there is no correct value; the basis of the 0
choice can range from the purely subjective (the curvefit looks reasonable) to somewhat objective based on the variances of the data. A reasonable initial value of γ to try is
γ = tr [A] [A] /tr[H] , where tr is the trace of the matrix computed as the sum of diagonal components. This choice will tend to make the two parts of the minimization (model error versus data error) have comparable weights; adjustments (in factors of ten) can be made from there. To emphasize this last point, the purpose of regularization is to provide a mechanism for enforcing on the solution a priori expectations of the behavior of the solution; its determination cannot be fully objective in the sense of only using the immediate measured data. We will see in the following examples that other judgments can and should come into play. For example, suppose that we are determining a transient force history: before the event begins, we would expect the reconstructed force to show zero behavior, and if it is an impact problem we would expect the force to be of only one sign. Subjectively judging these characteristics of the reconstructions can be very valuable in assessing the amount of regularization to use.
10.2 Parameter Identification Problems In some ways the parameter identification (ID) problem is simpler than the force identification problem, so we will begin with it. It will be a good vehicle to illustrate the concepts behind the sensitivity response method. We will generalize the programming to the case of many measurements and parameters (and hence the possible need for regularization). Since the parameters can be of very different types (e.g., dimension, modulus, boundary condition), we will also include scaling of the data and parameters. It should be mentioned, however, that there is one category of parameter ID problem that is in a class of its own: the location problem (force location, damage location, and so on). What makes these so difficult is that, in addition to a search over the parameter space, they also involve a global search over the physical space of the structure. These problems are not considered here, but note is made of [10.17], which introduces some innovative ideas using the sensitivity response method.
235
10.2.1 Sensitivity Response Method (SRM) The dynamics of a general nonlinear system are described in detail in [10.12] and given by the relationship ¨ + [C]{u} ˙ = {P} − F(u) , [M]{u}
(10.1)
where [M] is the mass matrix, [C] the damping matrix, {P} the vector of applied loads, and {F} the vector of element nodal forces. The latter is a function of the deformations and would therefore be updated as part of an incremental/iterative-type solution procedure. How this is done is of no immediate concern here since we will treat the FEM as a black box that provides solutions to fully specified forward problems. Consider a situation in which we have measured a set of response histories di (t) for a known load excitation {P(t)}, and there are M unknown parameters a j that need to be identified. Let us have a set of reasonable initial guesses for the unknown parameters, then solve
Part A 10.2
where [D] is the [(M − 1) × M] first difference matrix and [H] is the [M × M] symmetric matrix given by, respectively, ⎡ ⎤ −1 1 0 · · · ⎢ ⎥ [D] = ⎣ 0 −1 1 · · ·⎦ ,
10.2 Parameter Identification Problems
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 10.2
StrlDent: Make guess {a}0 Iterate ∂u Compute: ψ = ∂a Solve: ~ [ΨT W Ψ + γH]{P } T = {Ψ Wd} – {ΨTWu0}
FEM: {a}, {a + Δa}
+ {ΨTW Ψ P 0} Update: a = a + Δa
Script file
SDF
GenMesh
{P}
Script file
{u}
StaDyn/NonStaD
where a¯ j is a normalizing factor, typically based on the search window for the parameter. The small change da j should also be based on the allowable search window; typically it is taken as 5%, but in some circumstances it could be chosen adaptively. Additional discussions of this point are given in [10.6, 18]. The response solution corresponding to the true parameters is different from the guessed parameter solution according to u j − u 0 Δa j {u} = {u}0 + da j j = {u}0 + {ψ} j Δ P˜ j , j
Fig. 10.4 Algorithm schematic of the distributed computing rela-
tionship between the inverse program and the FEM programs for implementation of the sensitivity response method (SRM) for parameter identification
the system [M]{u} ¨ 0 + [C]0 {u} ˙ 0 = {P} − {F}0 , where the subscript 0 means that the forward problem was solved with the initial guesses. In turn, change each of the parameters (one at a time) by the definite amount a j −→ a j + da j and solve ˙ j = {P} − {F} j . ¨ j + [C]0 {u} [M]{u} The sensitivity of the solution to the change of parameters is constructed from u j − u0 a¯ j , {ψ} j ≡ da j a)
Δa j . Δ P˜ j ≡ aj It remains to determine Δa j or the equivalent nondimensional scales Δ P˜ j . Replacing Δ P˜ j with P˜ j − P˜ 0j , and using subscript i to indicate measurements di , we can write the error function as Wi di − Qu0i + Q ψij P˜ 0j A= i j 2 −Q ψij P˜ j , j u0i = u xi , a0j , where Q acts as a selector. This is reduced to standard form by minimizing with respect to P˜ j to give
˜ [QΨ ] W[QΨ ] + γ [H] { P} = [QΨ ] W{d − Qu0 + Qψ P˜ 0 } . b)
b L = 254 mm b = 25.4 mm h = 6.3 mm 40 elements 2024 aluminum
h
L
#1
L
#2
L
P (t)
Acceleration (g)
236
υ1
100 0
–100
2
υ2
P (t) 0
2
4
6
Fig. 10.5a,b An impacted aluminum beam: (a) geometry and properties and (b) recorded accelerations
8 10 Time (ms)
Hybrid Methods
#1
Acceleration (g)
Iterated
100 0 –100
100 0 –100 Nominal
Nominal
1000
Part A 10.2
Acceleration (g)
237
#2
Forward Recorded
Iterated
0
10.2 Parameter Identification Problems
2000
3000
4000
5000 Time (μs)
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.6 Comparison of the recorded responses and the forward solution responses
The system of equations is solved iteratively with the new parameters used to compute updated responses and sensitivities. An implementation of this approach is shown in Fig. 10.4: StrIDent is the inverse solver, GenMesh, the FEM modeler program, produces the changed structure data files (SDF) that are then used in the FEM (StaDyn/NonStaD) programs. Note that there is a nice separation of the inverse problem and the FEM analysis. The significant advantage of the algorithm is that it is independent of the underlying problem, be it static/dynamic, linear/nonlinear, and so on.
10.2.2 Experimental Data Study I: Measuring Dynamic Properties This example shows how the dynamic properties of an impacted beam were obtained. Note that wave propagation characteristics are dominated by the ratio √ c0 = E/ρ and therefore wave responses are not the most suitable for obtaining separated values of E and ρ. Since mass density can be easily and accurately determined by weighing, we will illustrate the determination of the Young’s modulus and damping. Fig. 10.8a–c Pressure-loaded circular plate: (a) geometry and gage positions, (b) center mesh, and (c) the elastic
boundary condition, modeled with an overhang of unknown modulus
Pressure gauge
Ring and bolts
Pressurized cylinder
Plate and gages p
ε1
ε2
ε3
ε4
ε5
80
778
292
590
140
140
Fig. 10.7 Photograph of pressurized plate and maximum recorded
strains
a)
b) 5 3
1
2
4 Diameter: 107mm (4,214 in.) Thickness: 3.3 (0.131in.) 2024 T-3 aluminum Gage: EA-13-062AQ-350
c)
p (x,y) = specified
E2 = ?
238
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a) Strain (µε)
b) Strain (µε)
1200
–4 FEM Theory Experiment
1000
1200 FEM Experiment
1000
Part A 10.2
800
1
800
600
3
600
400
400 2
200
5
0
200 0
0
20
40
60 80 Nominal pressure (psi)
0
20
40
60 80 Nominal pressure (psi)
Fig. 10.9a,b Pressurized plate comparisons: (a) plate with fixed boundary and (b) plate with identified flexible boundary
Data frame
P(l ) P(t)
a0
Symmetry
a0: 6.35 mm L = 63.5 mm 2h = 12.7 mm b = 25.4 mm Aluminum
Fig. 10.10 Double cantilevered beam specimen: geometry, properties and mesh
Figure 10.5 shows the geometry and the acceleration data recorded for the impact of the beam. The force transducer described in [10.6] was used to record
the force history and PCB 303 A accelerometers (made by Piezotronics, Inc.) were used for the response. The DASH-18 system recorded the data. The impact was on the wide side of the beam, which increased the amount of damping due to movement through the air. The damping is implemented in the FEM code as [C] = α[M] = (η/ρ)[M], which is a form of proportional damping. The parameter α has units of s−1 and this will be identified along with the modulus. The search window for this type of problem can be set quite narrow since we generally have good nominal values. Consequently, convergence was quite rapid (three or c)
a) u (x, y) δ = 64 nm σ0 = 241MPa
υ (x, y)
δ
b)
σ0
0
5
10
15 Iterations
Fig. 10.11a–c Double cantilever beam synthetic data: (a) moiré u(x, y) and v(x, y) fringes at 10.6 μs, (b) deformed shape (exaggerated ×10), and (c) convergence behavior using a single frame of data with 0.2% noise
Hybrid Methods
a)
10.2 Parameter Identification Problems
239
b)
P21 P19
a (t)
(60×103 in./s) a· (t) P3 P1 0
5
10
15 Time (μs)
0
5
10
15
20
25 30 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.12a,b Reconstruction of the DCB specimen behavior. (a) Cohesive force history. (b) Crack tip position and speed
four iterations) and the values obtained were Nominal:
c0 = 5080.00 m/s (200 000 in./s) ,
Iterated:
α = 0.0 s−1 , c0 = 4996.18 m/s (196 700 in./s) , α = 113.37 s−1 .
Figure 10.6 shows the response reconstructions using the nominal values and the iterated values compared to the measured responses. It is apparent that taking the damping into account can improve the quality of the comparisons considerably. To improve the correspondence over a longer period of time would require iterating on the effective properties of the clamped condition. Physically, the beam was clamped in a steel vise and not fixed as in the model. For wave propagation problems, some energy is transmitted into the vise. Determining effective boundary conditions is discussed next.
10.2.3 Experimental Data Study II: Measuring Effective BCs This second experiment is that of a plate with a uniform pressure. In this case, the pressure loading is actually known with a good deal of confidence but, because the plate is formed as the end of a pressurized cylinder with bolted clamps, the true boundary conditions are not rigidly clamped as was originally intended. The ob-
jective will be to get a more realistic modeling of the boundary condition. A photograph of the plate forming the end of a cylinder is shown in Fig. 10.7. Sixteen bolts along with an aluminum ring are used to clamp the plate to the walls of the cylinder. Note that the cylinder has an increased wall thickness to facilitate this. Figure 10.8 shows the geometry of the plate and the gage locations. Gages 4 and 5 are not exactly on the edge of the plate, but the gage backing was trimmed so that they could be put as close as possible to the edge. Each gage ended up being approximately 1.8 mm (0.07 in.) from the edge; the meshes, such as that in Fig. 10.8b, were adjusted so as to have a node at the gage positions. Figure 10.9a shows the recorded strains. There is very good linearity with very little offset; consequently, the data was used directly as part of the inverse solutions. The strains at the maximum pressure are shown in Fig. 10.7. Figure 10.9a shows that modeling the boundary condition as fixed does not give a good comparison with experiment. Figure 10.8b models the problem as an overhanging plate with specified thickness but unknown modulus; the pressure load will be taken as specified. With E 2 as the single unknown, the converged result gave E 2 = 0.26E 1 and the reconstructions are shown in Fig. 10.9b; the standard deviation in the strain is 18 μe. The comparison between the model and ex-
Part A 10.2
1500m/s
240
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
~
10
1 × P1 ~
5
1 × P2 +
Part A 10.3
~
{ψ}1 × P1
+
=
~
{ψ}2 × P2
=
{d}
Fig. 10.13 The data {d} are conceived as synthesized from the superpositions of unit-load solutions {ψ}1 and {ψ}2 modified by scalings P˜1 and P˜2
periment is considerably improved. The results hardly changed when both moduli were assumed simultaneous unknowns.
10.2.4 Synthetic Data Study I: Dynamic Crack Propagation A theme of this work is the central role played by the model in stress analysis. We illustrate here how it can be used in the design of a complicated experiment. That is, it is generally too expensive in both time and money to design experiments by trial and error and a wellconstructed model can be used to narrow the design parameters. To make the scenario explicit, consider a double cantilever beam (DCB) specimen made from two aluminum segments bonded together as shown in Fig. 10.10. The crack (or delamination) is constrained to grow along the interface, and the interface properties of the bond line are the basic unknowns of the experiment. This delamination is modeled as a cohesive layer described by σ (v) = σ0 [v/δ] e(−v/δ) , where v is the separation distance and (σ0 , δ) are the parameters to be identified. Reference [10.19] contains details about this type of crack modeling that is implemented in the nonlinear FEM code NonStaD. To get accurate estimates of the interface properties, it is necessary to record the data as the crack passes
through the frame of view. Typical frames are shown in Fig. 10.11a along with the exaggerated deformed shape in Fig. 10.11b. The applied load is a rectangular pulse of long duration with a rise time of 3 μs and, for identification purposes, is taken as known. This is a problem with a wide range of scales. As seen from Fig. 10.11b, the tip deflection is of order h/10 but h is of order δ × 105 . At rupture, the deflections along the line of symmetry are 1δ ∼ 10δ. To increase the accuracy of the data, the frames came from just the 12 mm × 12 mm window indicated in Fig. 10.10a. The noise added to the synthetic data had a specified standard deviation of 0.2 × δ; with a moiré sensitivity of 100 line/mm, this works out to about 0.2% of a fringe. The convergence behavior is shown in Fig. 10.11c where a single v(x, y) frame of data at 10.6 μs was used; both parameters have converged by the tenth iteration. The results are robust with reasonable initial guesses for the parameters. In the present tests, the allowable search windows spanned 10–200% of the exact values, with the initial guesses being 50%. Keep in mind that, during the iteration process, at each iteration a complete crack propagation problem is solved three times (once for the nominal parameters, and once each for the variation of the parameters); thus the computational cost is quite significant. Once the parameters are determined, reconstructions of any quantity can be obtained, which is the utility of the hybrid methods. Figure 10.12a shows, for example, the interface force histories at every other node. These histories are almost identical to the exact histories, which is not surprising because of the goodness of the parameter estimates. The quality of these reconstructions is greatly superior to those achieved in [10.20], which determined the interface forces directly; this underlines the value of a reparameterization of unknowns of a problem. The position of the crack tip is quite apparent in Fig. 10.12a; using the peak value of the force as the indicator, Fig. 10.12b shows the crack tip position and its speed. The speed is not constant because of the decrease in beam stiffness as the crack propagates.
10.3 Force Identification Problems In the inverse problems of interest here, the applied loads and displacements are unknown but we know some information about the responses (either in the
form of displacements or strains). In particular, assume that we have a vector of measurements d(t) which are related to the structural degree of freedom (DoF) ac-
Hybrid Methods
cording to {d(t)} ⇔ [Q]{u(t)} ,
10.3.1 Sensitivity Response Method for Static Problems Since there is a relation between {u} and {P}, then (for minimization purposes) we can take either as the basic set of unknowns; here it is more convenient to use the loads because for most problems the size of {P} is substantially smaller than the size of {u}. Let the unknown forces be represented as the collection ˜ = [Φ]{ P} ˜ , (10.2) {P} = [{φ}1 {φ}2 · · · {φ} Mp ]{ P} where each {φ}m is a known distribution of forces and P˜m the corresponding unknown scale. As a particular case, {φ}m could be a single unit force, but it can also represent a uniform or a Gaussian pressure distribution; for traction distribution problems it has a triangular distribution [10.20]. We will refer to each {φ}m distribution as a unit or perturbation load; there are Mp such loads. Solve the series of forward FEM problems [K ]{ψ}1 = {φ}1 , [K ]{ψ}2 = {φ}2 , [K ]{ψ} Mp = {φ} Mp .
... ,
The {ψ}m responses will have imbedded in them the effects of the complexity of the structure; consequently, usual complicating factors (for deriving analytical solutions used in hybrid methods) such as geometry, material, and boundary conditions are all included in {ψ}m , which in turn is handled by the finite element method. Furthermore, note that the responses are not necessarily just displacement; they could be strain or principal stress difference as required by the experimental method, and consequently the inverse program does not need to perform differentiation to get strains. In other words, anything particular to the modeling or mechanics of the structure is handled by the FEM program. We can therefore write the actual forward solution as ˜ , {u} = [Ψ ]{ P} [Ψ ] = [{ψ}1 {ψ}2 · · · {ψ} Mp ] , (10.3)
˜ is not known. In this way, the coefficients although { P} ˜ act as scale factors on the solutions in [Ψ ]. of { P} This idea is shown schematically in Fig. 10.13 where the two-load problem is conceived as the scaled superposition of two separate one-load problems. This superposition idea leads to simultaneous equations to ˜ solve for the unknown scales { P}. The measured data at a collection of locations are related to the computed responses as ˜ . {d} ⇐⇒ [Q]{u} = [Q][Ψ ]{ P} If supplementary information is available (e.g., additional data or a relationship among the unknowns), it is incorporated simply by appending to this set of equations before the least-squares procedure is used. The error functional can be written as a function of P˜ only and minimized to get ˜ = [QΨ ] W{d} . [Ψ Q WQΨ + γ H]{ P} (10.4)
This reduced system of equations is of size [Mp × Mp ] and is relatively inexpensive to solve since it is symmetric and small. Once the loads are known, the actual forward solution is then obtained from (10.3), which involves a simple matrix product. The key to understanding our approach to the computer implementation is the series of solutions in the matrix [Ψ ] – it is these that can be performed externally (in a distributed computing sense) by a commercial FEM code. The basic relationship is shown in Fig. 10.14 and is laid out in a similar style to Fig. 10.4. If the number of unknowns are computationally too large, then a parameterized loading scheme can be used, where the loading is assumed to be synthesized from speci-
StrlDent: Form: – – – [A ] = [Q ][Ψ ] –
φm (t)
FEM: GenMesh StaDyn
–
[B ] = [A ]T{d} Solve: – – – – – [A TA + γH ]{P } = {B }
Script file
{ψ}m (t)
Response file
Fig. 10.14 Algorithm schematic of the distributed computing relationship between the inverse program StrIDent and the FEM programs. For static problems, the FEM program is run once for each load position; for dynamic problems, a {ψ}m (t) history at all data locations is computed for each force location
241
Part A 10.3
where [Q] is a selection matrix that plays the role of selecting the subset of responses participating in forming the data. We want to find the forces {P(t)} that make the system best match the measurements. We will introduce the ideas behind the method by first considering static problems, and then generalize them to the dynamic case.
10.3 Force Identification Problems
242
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
fied forms [10.21]. The experimental study to follow is a simple example.
10.3.2 Generalization for Transient Loads
of the structure. Because of the linearity of the system, the responses are also similar to each other but shifted an amount mΔT . This basic idea is illustrated in Fig. 10.15. The error functional is
Let the force history be represented as
Part A 10.3
P(t) =
Mp
P˜m φm (t) ,
˜ , {P} = [Φ]{ P}
(10.5)
m=1
where φm (t) are specified functions of time; they are similar to each other but shifted an amount mΔT . We will consider specific forms later. The array [Φ] has as columns each φm (t) discretized in time. The vector {P} has the force history P(t) discretized in time. This force causes the response at a particular point in the model u(x, t) =
Mp
P˜m ψm (x, t) ,
A = {d − Qu} W{d − Qu} ˜ . ˜ W{d − QΨ P} = {d − QΨ P} Force reconstructions show the manifestations of illconditioning as ΔT is changed because, with small ΔT , the data are incapable of distinguishing between neighbor force values Pn + Δ, Pn+1 − Δ. Time regularization is therefore important and connects components within ˜ that is, { P}, ˜ = { P} ˜ [H]{ P} ˜ . ˜ [D] [D]{ P} B = { P} Minimizing with respect to P˜m then gives
˜ = [QΨ ] W{d} . [QΨ ] W[QΨ ] + γ [H] { P}
˜ , {u(x)} = [Ψ ]{ P}
m=1
(10.6)
(10.7)
where ψm (x, t) is the response to force φm (t) at the particular point, and [Ψ ] are all the discretized responses arranged as columns. As in the static case, we refer to φm (t) as unit or perturbation forces and ψm (t) as sensitivity responses. These responses are obtained by the finite element method, and therefore will have imbedded in them the effects of the complexity
The core array is symmetric of size [Mp × Mp ]. There are a variety of functions that could be used for φm (t); the main requirement is that they have compact support in both the time/space and frequency domains. Reference [10.22] used a Gram–Schmidt reduction scheme to generate a series of smooth orthogonal functions from the basic triangular pulse; a set
a) P (t)
b) Actual force
φ (t)
Pertubation force
ψ (t)
Sensitivity response
Time P (t) P3 P2 P1
P4
P5
P6
Measured response
P7 Time
0
200
400
600
800
1000 1200 1400 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.15a,b The sensitivity response concept for transient load identification. (a) A discretized history is viewed as a series of scaled triangular perturbations. (b) How the scaled perturbations superpose to give the actual histories
Hybrid Methods
¯ = {[Φ]1 { P} ˜ 1 , [Φ]2 { P} ˜ 2 , · · · , [Φ] Np { P} ˜ N p } , { P} ˜ n is the history Pn (t) arranged as a vector where each { P} of Mp time components. This collection of force vectors causes the collection of responses ⎫ ⎡ ⎧ ⎤ ⎪ [Ψ ]11 [Ψ ]12 · · · [Ψ ]1Np {u}1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎥ ⎬ ⎢ ⎨ {u}2 ⎪ ⎢ [Ψ ]21 [Ψ ]22 · · · [Ψ ]2Np ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ .. ⎪ = ⎢ .. .. .. .. ⎥ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ . ⎣ . ⎦ . . . ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ ⎩ {u} Nd [Ψ ] Nd 1 [Ψ ] Nd 1 · · · [Ψ ] Nd Np ⎫ ⎧ ˜ 1 ⎪ ⎪ { P} ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ˜ ⎪ ⎨ { P}2 ⎬ (10.8) × . ⎪ ⎪ .. ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ˜ Np ,⎭ { P} where {u}i is a history of a displacement (DoF) at the i measurement location. We also write this as ˜ j or {u} ¯ . ¯ P} [Ψ ]ij { P} {u}i = ¯ = [ψ]{ j
The [Mp × Mp ] array [Ψ ]ij relates the i location response history to the j applied perturbation force. It contains the responses ψm (t) arranged as a vector. Let the Nd sensor histories of data be organized as ¯ = {{d}1 , {d}2 , · · · , {d} Nd } , {d}
243
where {d}n is a vector of Md components (it is simplest to have Md = Mp but this is not required). The measured data DoF are a subset of the computed responses, that is, ¯ u} ¯ i ⇐⇒ [Q]{ {d} ¯ or
¯ ψ]{ ¯ ⇐⇒ [Q ¯ . ¯ P} {d}
(10.9)
Define a data error functional as ¯ ψ¯ P} ¯ ψ¯ P} ¯ ¯ = {d¯ − Q ¯ W{d − Q E( P)
¯ [Ht ]{ P} ¯ + γs { P} ¯ [Hs ]{ P} ¯ , + γt { P} which has incorporated regularization in both time [Ht ] and space [Hs ]. Time regularization connects components within each P˜ j only, while space regularization connects components in P˜ j across near locations. The sparsity of the matrices [Ht ] and [Hs ] are quite different and therefore their effect on the solution is also quite different, even for same order regularizations. Minimiz¯ gives ing with respect to { P}
¯ ψ] ¯ ψ] ¯ ¯ + γt [Ht ] + γs [Hs ] { P} ¯ W[Q [Q ¯ ψ] ¯ . ¯ W{d} = [Q
(10.10)
The core matrix is symmetric, of size [(Mp × Np ) × (Mp × Np )], and in general is fully populated. Only when Np is large (there are a large number of force histories) does the computational cost of solving (10.10) become significant. The computer implementation is shown in Fig. 10.14. The sensitivity response is computed only once for a given force location irrespective of the number of sensors, hence the FEM cost is simply that of a forward solution (times the number of forces).
10.3.3 Experimental Data Study I: Double-Exposure Holography Figure 10.1c shows a double-exposure holographic fringe pattern for the out-of-plane displacement of a pressure-loaded plate. The plate forms one end of a pressurized cylinder and the inner white dots in the figure show the flexing part of the plate. The small change of pressure was applied accurately using a manometer. As sometimes happens with holography, the fringe pattern is not of uniform quality. Furthermore, there is a slight asymmetry in the fringe pattern which could be due to a slight overall rigid-body motion of the cylinder. Figure 10.16b shows the limited number of discretized data points used. Because of the expected symmetries in the results the points were distributed somewhat uniformly so as to provide averaging. Figure 10.16c shows
Part A 10.3
of these is illustrated in Fig. 10.15b. Here we will use the triangular pulse directly; this is equivalent to using a linear interpolation between the discretized points, as shown in Fig. 10.15a. The advantage of the triangle is that the scales P˜m have the direct meaning of being the discretized force history and hence there is no need to actually perform the summation in (10.5). In fact, without losing the advantage of the straight triangular pulse, it is also possible to use a smoothed triangular pulse; this is the scheme implemented in StrIDent. There are a number of features we now wish to add to the above developments, primarily the ability to determine multiple unknown force histories. There are two situations of interest here: the first is that of multiple isolated forces and the second is traction distributions. The main difference is whether the forces are related to each other or not; isolated forces are a finite number of forces which are not related, but traction distributions contain very many forces which are continuously related to their neighbors and therefore space regularization can be used. Let the Np unknown force histories be organized as
10.3 Force Identification Problems
244
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a)
b)
c)
Diameter: 107 mm (4.215 in) Thickness: 3.12 mm (0.123 in) 6061 aluminum
Part A 10.3
α: 17 deg, β: 0 deg λ: 632nm (24.9 μin.)
Fig. 10.16a–c Holographic experiment of a pressure-loaded plate. (a) Cylindrical pressure vessel properties and holographic parameters. (b) Discretized data positions. (c) FEM mesh
a)
b)
Nominal: 7.63 kPa (1.09psi) Computed: 7.77 kPa (1.11psi)
σxx
σxy
Fig. 10.17a,b Reconstructions. (a) Displacement fringe pattern: top recorded, bottom reconstructed. (b) Stress contours
the FEM mesh used. The data were relocated onto the nearest nodes of this mesh by the scheme discussed in [10.6]. The edge of the plate was modeled as being rigidly clamped. The pressure was taken as the only unknown in formulating the inverse problem. Since the number of
Strain gages P (t)
Steel
Rs (t)
Ra (t)
Accelerometers
data far exceed the number of unknowns, regularization is not required. The nominal measured and computed pressures are given in Fig. 10.17. The comparison is very good. Figure 10.17a shows a comparison of the reconstructed fringe pattern (bottom) with that measured (top). Since the pressure comparison is good, it is not surprising that this comparison is also good. A theme running through the hybrid solutions in this work is that, once the unknown forces (or whatever parameterization of the unknowns is used) have been determined, the analytical apparatus is then already available for the complete stress analysis. Figure 10.17b shows, for example, the σxx and σxy stress distributions. What is significant about these reconstructions is that (in comparison to traditional ways of manipulating such holographic data) the process of directly differentiating experimental data is avoided. Furthermore, this would still be achievable even if the plate was more complicated by having, say, reinforcing ribs (in which case the strains are not related to the second derivatives of the displacement). Note also that, because the experimental data were not directly differentiated, only a limited number of data points needed to be recorded.
aluminum
51
Accelerometers #1 #2 L
L = 305 mm D = 102 mm h = 6.3 mm 6061 aluminum
Fig. 10.18 Square plate with a central hole. The Hopkinson bar is
attached to the left side and its two strain gages are sufficient to determine both the input load and the transmitted load
10.3.4 Experimental Data Study II: One-Sided Hopkinson Bar It often occurs that we need to apply a known force history to a structure. In some instances, where the frequency of excitation is low, we can use an instrumented hammer as is common in modal analysis [10.23]. In other instances, we need a high-energy high-frequency input, and common force transducers do not have the required specifications. The one-sided Hopkinson bar
Hybrid Methods
b)
Strain (ue)
0
0.1
Part A 10.3
100
0 –0.1
–100
0
1000
2000
3000
4000 Time (μs)
0
1000
2000
3000
4000 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.19a,b Experimentally recorded data. (a) Strains from the OSHB. (b) Velocities of the plate computed from measured accelerations
force input to the plate. These force reconstructions are shown labeled as P and Rs , respectively, in Fig. 10.20. The impact force, as expected, is essentially that of a single pulse input. The reconstructions of the force at the connection point, on the other hand, are quite complicated, persisting with significant amplitude for the full duration of the recording. Note that the connection force is larger than the impact force because of the high impedance of the plate. The Rs force from the bar was used as input to the forward problem for the plate and the computed
P (t) Accelerometers Hopkinson bar
R s (t), R 2a (t)
#2 1
P/P0
(OSHB) was designed for this purpose. More details and examples can be found in [10.24, 25]. Figure 10.18 shows a schematic of a problem used to test the ability of accelerometers to reconstruct forces on a twodimensional plate. This force will be compared to that determined by the strain gage responses from the onesided Hopkinson bar. Figure 10.18 shows the specimen dimensions and placement of the accelerometers. The specimen was machined from a 6.3 mm (1/4 in.)-thick sheet of aluminum to be a 305 mm (12 in.) square with a 76 mm (4 in.)-diameter hole at its center. A small hole was drilled and tapped at the midpoint of the left edge for the connection of the OSHB. Accelerometers were placed on the same edge as the force input and on the opposite edge, at 25.4 mm (2 in.) off the force input line. The data were collected at a 4 μs rate over 4000 μs. The force input to the OSHB was from the impact of a steel ball attached to a pendulum. The acceleration data were converted to velocities and detrended, the strain gage data were modified to account for the slight nonlinearity of the Wheatstone bridge (since the resistance change of semiconductor gages is relatively large). These data are shown in Fig. 10.19. The inverse problem was divided into two separate problems corresponding to the bar and the plate. The data from the two strain gages on the bar were used simultaneously to reconstruct the impact force and the
245
Measured Forward
Velocity (m/s)
a)
10.3 Force Identification Problems
R s (t), R 1a (t)
0 #1
0
1000
2000
3000
4000 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.20 Force reconstructions for the plate with a hole. The reference load is P¯0 = 2224 N (500 lb)
246
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 10.4
velocities are compared to the measured in Fig. 10.19. The comparison is quite good considering the extended time period of the comparison. The data from the accelerometers were then used as separate single sensor inputs to reconstruct the force at the connection point. These force reconstructions are shown labeled as R1a and R2a in Fig. 10.20. The reconstructed forces at the connection point agree quite closely both in character and magnitude. This is significant because the force transmitted across the boundary
is quite complex and has been reconstructed from different sensor types placed on different structural types. Reference [10.6] discusses a collection of possible variations of the one-sided Hopkinson bar. The basic idea expressed is that, because a general finite element modeling underlies the force identification method, and because we can determine multiple unknown forces simultaneously, we are given great flexibility in the design of the rod and its attachment to the structure.
10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems Nonlinearities can arise in a number of forms: material nonlinearity such as plasticity and rubber elasticity, geometric nonlinearity as occurs with large displacements and rotations, and nonlinearities associated with the data relation. We discuss examples of each.
10.4.1 Nonlinear Data Relations In photoelasticity there is a nonlinear relationship between observed fringes and applied loads. To see this, recall that fringes are related to stresses by [10.26]
fσ N h
2 2 = (σxx − σ yy )2 + 4σxy .
From this, while it is true that a doubling of the load doubles the stress and therefore doubles the fringe orders, this is not true for nonproportional loading. That is, the fringe pattern caused by two loads acting simultaneously is not equal to the sum of the fringe patterns of the separate loads even though the stresses would be equal. Since our inverse method is based on superposition, we must modify it to account for this nonlinear relation. Based on this discussion, it may seem that photoelasticity is not as attractive as other methods. This is perhaps true, but the main reason it is included here is as an example of data with a nonlinear relation to mechanical variables. It may well be that sensors of the future will also have a nonlinear relationship and the algorithms developed here will be available to take advantage of them. For example, there is currently a good deal of activity in developing pressure-sensitive paints, fluorescent paints, and the like; see [10.27, 28] for a discussion of their properties and some of the literature. These inexpensive methods, most likely, will have
a nonlinear relation between the data and the mechanical variables. We need to generate a linear relation between the fringe data and the applied loads. As usual for nonlinear problems, we begin with a linearization about a known state. That is, suppose we have a reasonable estimate of the stresses as [σxx , σ yy , σxy ]0 ; then the true stresses are only a small increment away. A Taylor series expansion about this known (guessed) state provides
2
fσ 2 N ≈ (σxx − σ yy )2 + 4σxy 0 h + 2 (σxx − σ yy )0
× (Δσxx − Δσ yy ) + (4σxy )0 Δσxy . Let the stress increments (Δσxx , Δσ yy , Δσxy ) be computed from the scaled unit loads so that for all components of force we have {ψxx , ψ yy , ψxy } j Δ P˜ j . {Δσxx , Δσ yy , Δσxy } = j
The stress sensitivities {ψ} j must be computed for each component of force. Noting that Δ P˜ = P˜ − P˜0 , we write the approximate fringe relation as
2 fσ G¯ j P˜o j + G¯ j P˜o j (10.11) N ≈ σ02 − h j
j
with
2 σ02 ≡ (σxx − σ yy )2 + 4σxy , 0 G¯ j ≡ [2(σxx − σ yy )0 (ψxx − ψ yy ) j + 8(σxy )0 ψxy j ] . Equation (10.11) is our linear relation between fringes and applied loads. Let the data be expressed in the form
Hybrid Methods
N¯ ≡ N f σ /h so that the minimization principle leads to
[QG] W[QG] + γ [H] P˜ = [QG] W{ N¯ 2 − Qσ02 + QG P˜0 } , (10.12)
10.4.2 Nonlinear Structural Dynamics The dynamics of a general nonlinear system are described by (10.1) and rewritten here as ˜ − {F} . [M]{u} ¨ + [C]{u} ˙ = {P} − {F} = [Φ]{ P} There are two sets of loads: {P}, which is the set of unknown applied loads to be identified, and the element nodal forces {F}, which depend on the deformations and are also unknown. Both {P} and {F} must be identified as part of the solution. We begin the solution by approximating the element nodal forces by a Taylor series expansion about a known (guessed) configuration ! ∂F {Δu} = {F}0 + [K T ]0 {u − u0 } {F} ≈ {F}0 + ∂u = {F}0 − [K T ]0 {u}0 + [K T ]0 {u} , where the subscript 0 means known state and {F0 } − [K T ]0 {u}0 is a residual force vector due to the mismatch between the correctly reconstructed nodal forces {F} and its linear approximation [K T ]0 {u}0 ; at convergence, it is not zero. The square matrix [K T ]0 is the tangent stiffness matrix. We have thus represented the nonlinear problem as a combination of known forces {F0 } − [K T ]0 {u}0 (known from the previous iteration)
StrlDent: ~
Make guess: {P }
[Φ]
Script file
[Ψ]
StaDyn
{P}
Script file
247
Iterate Update: G, σ0 Solve: ~ [GT WG + γH]{P }
[σxx, σyy, σxy ]
–2
= {GTWN } – {GTWσ02} ~ + {GTWP0}
StaDyn FEM:
Fig. 10.21 Algorithm schematic of the distributed computing relationship between the inverse program and the FEM programs when nonlinear updating is needed
and a force linearly dependent on the current displacements, [K T ]0 {u}. The governing equation is rearranged in the form [M]{u} ¨ + [C]{u} ˙ + [K T ]0 {u} ˜ − {F}0 + [K T ]0 {u}0 . = [Φ]{ P} This is a linear force identification problem with un˜ and known {F}0 and [K T ]0 {u}0 . Solve the known { P} three linear dynamics problems ¨ + [C][ψ] ˙ + [K T ]0 [Ψ ] = [Φ] , [M][ψ] [M]{ψ¨ F } + [C]{ψ˙ F } + [K T ]0 {ψF } = −{F}0 , [M]{ψ¨ u } + [C]{ψ˙ u } + [K T ]0 {ψu } = [K T ]0 {u}0 . Note that the left-hand operator is the same in each case. The total response can be represented as ˜ + {ψF } + {ψu } , {u} = [Ψ ]{ P} and the data relation becomes [Q]{u} − {d} = 0
⇒
˜ = {d} − {QψF } − {Qψu } = {d ∗ } . [QΨ ]{ P} The minimum principle leads to
˜ [QΨ ] W[QΨ ] + γ [H] { P} = [QΨ ] {d − QψF − Qψu } ,
(10.13)
which is identical in form to the linear dynamic case except for the carryover terms {ψF } and {ψu }. The core array is symmetric, of size [Mp × Mp ]; note that it does not change during the iterations and hence the decomposition need be done only once. The right-hand side
Part A 10.4
where, as before, [Q] plays the role of a selector. This ˜ to is solved repeatedly using the newly computed { P} ˜ 0. replace { P} In terms of the computer implementation shown in Fig. 10.21, the sensitivity solution {ψ} is determined only once for each load component, but the updating of the stress field {σ0 } requires an FEM call on each iteration. Both the left- and right-hand side of the system of equations must be reformed (and hence decomposed) on each iteration. In all iterative schemes, it is important to have a method of obtaining good initial guesses. There are no hard and fast rules for the present type of problem; however, the rate of convergence depends on the number of unknown forces, this suggests using minimal forces initially to obtain an idea of the unknowns to use as starter values. Furthermore, the effect of regularization is sensitive to the number of unknowns and therefore it is wise to obtain starter values without regularization.
10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems
248
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
StrlDent: Make guess: P Form: [ΨTΨ + γH ] Iterate
Part A 10.4
[Φ]
Script file
[Ψ]
StaDyn
{P}
Script file
[F ], [u]
NonStaD
[F ], [u]
Script file
FEM:
Update: P, u, F Solve: ~ [ΨTΨ + γH ] {P } = {ΨTd} +{ΨTψu} +{ΨTψF}
{ψu}, {ψF}
StaDyn
Fig. 10.22 A possible algorithm schematic for the distributed computing relationship between the nonlinear dynamic inverse program and the FEM programs
10
∑ ⇒ {d}
9
3
8
Δt
7
Data frames
6
∑ ⇒ {d}
5
2
4
Whole-field {ψ} snapshots Perturbation φm forces
3 2 1 φm 0
∑ ⇒ {d} 1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
∑ ⇒ P (t)
Fig. 10.23 Relationship between frames due to the perturbation
forces and the measured frames
a)
b)
P
Fig. 10.24a,b Photoelastic fringe pattern due to distributed load: (a) experimentally recorded and (b) reconstructed
changes during the iterations due to the updating associated with {ψF } and {ψu }.
The basic algorithm is: starting with an initial guess for the unknown force histories, the effective data in (10.13) is updated, then P˜ is obtained from solving (10.13), from which new effective data are obtained and the process is repeated until convergence. The implementation details, however, are crucial to its success. A very important issue that needs to be addressed is the formation and assemblage of the matrices associated with the above formulation and, as much as possible, to have the FEM portion of the inverse solution shifted external to the inverse programming; this is discussed in great detail in [10.6, 21]. The main conclusion is that, since the Newton–Raphson iterations scheme does not require the exact tangent stiffness matrix for convergence, then, perhaps at the expense of the number of iterations and the radius of convergence, the sensitivity responses can be obtained from the external FEM program by using an approximate tangent stiffness matrix. An obvious choice would be to use the linear elastic stiffness matrix; another could be a linear elastic stiffness matrix that is based on an updated or mean geometry. The implementation actually uses two structural models: the true model and a separate model for estimating the tangent stiffness matrix. While not a proof as such, the following examples make the key point that it is the Newton–Raphson iterations on the equilibrium, and not the quality of the [K T ] estimate, that produces the converged result. The schematic for the algorithm as implemented in the program StrIDent is shown in Fig. 10.22. Note that [u] and [F] are histories of every DoF at every node, and therefore can require a very large storage space. Also note that the linear FEM program is expected to give the dynamic responses to the loads {F}0 and [K T ]0 {u}0 ; both are loadings where every DoF at every node is an individual history. Forming the product [K T ]0 {u}0 , where each component of {u}0 is an individual history, is not something usually available in commercial FEM packages. Requirements such as this need to be implemented as special services in the FEM programs available to the inverse program. It seems that for the nonlinear problem there is not a definite separation (of what must be done internally and what can be done externally) as there is for linear problems.
10.4.3 Nonlinear Space–Time Deconvolution Consider an experiment that uses high-speed photography to record moiré or photoelastic fringes. The scenario we envision here is that the force history is
Hybrid Methods
φ1 (t)
⇒
amount mΔT , {ψ}4 is a snapshot of all the displacements at 50 μs caused by φ2 . Similarly, {ψ}3 , {ψ}2 , and {ψ}1 are caused by φ3 , φ4 , and φ5 at 50 μs, respectively. Therefore, for data frame {d}2 , P˜5 contributes to {u}1 , P˜4 contributes to {u}2 , all the way to P˜1 contributing to {u}5 ; any component greater than 5 does not contribute. It is this reversal in time that allows the scheme to be computationally efficient. Thus, a snapshot of the displacements (say) at time step i is {u}i = {ψ}i P˜1 + {ψ}i−1 P˜2 + {ψ}i−2 P˜3 + · · · + {ψ}1 P˜i + 0 P˜i+1 + · · · + 0 P˜Mp , where {u} is a snapshot of all the displacements (DoF) at this instant of time. Note that force components occurring at time steps greater than i do not contribute. We can write this relation as {u}i =
a)
{ψ}(i+1−m) P˜m +
m=1
Mp
0 P˜m
or
m=i+1
˜ . {u} = [Ψ ]{ P}
{ψ}1 , {ψ}2 , {ψ}3 , . . . {ψ} Mp .
A frame of data at time mΔt has contributions only up to that time but the sequence of snapshots are reversed in time. For example, let the time step be Δt = 10 μs and consider data frame {d}2 , the frame of all the displacements (DoF) at 50 μs caused by P(t). In this, {ψ}5 is a snapshot of all the displacements at 50 μs caused by φ1 . Since φm are similar to each other but shifted an
i
(10.14)
The [Mu × Mp ] array [Ψ ] (Mu is the total number of DoFs) relates the snapshot of displacements to the applied force. Let the Nd frames of data be organized as ¯ = {d}1 , {d}2 , · · · , {d} Nd , {d} b) Traction
0.6
0.08 P1 + P2
0.4
0.06
0.2 0.04 0 0.02 –0.2 P1 – P2 0
–0.4 –0.6
0
5
10
15 20 Node position
– 0.02
0
5
Fig. 10.25a,b Iterative results: (a) estimation of resultant load and (b) traction distribution
10
15 Node position
249
Part A 10.4
unknown (it is due to blast loading or ballistic impact, say) and we are especially interested in local (such as at the notch root) stress behavior. The mechanics of the underlying event or the data relation can be nonlinear. One thing that is clear is, since the total number of frames (photographs) is severely limited, the frames cannot be used directly to obtain history behavior. Conceivably, we can overcome this limitation by simply paying the price of having multiple cameras [10.29]. Here we propose to tackle the problem directly; that is, given a limited number of frames of sparse data, determine the complete history of the event including stresses and strains. Figure 10.23 attempts to show the relationship between the force and the observed frames; while both axes are time axes, it tries to show how a single frame of data has both early time and late time force information. Let a single unknown force history be represented by (10.5). Each perturbation force causes a snapshot at each time step; the sequence is the same for each force just shifted one time step. Thus it is sufficient to consider just the first perturbation force and its snapshots
10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems
250
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a)
b)
P1
P2
P3
full details, nonlinear versions of the problems represented by (10.12, 10.13) are covered by replacing the right-hand side by [QG] [W]{N 2 − Qσ02 + QG P˜0 } or
Part A 10.4
Width: 60 mm (2.35 in.) Thick: 2.03 mm (0.08 in.) Crack: 11.7 mm (0.46 in.) Load: 6.67 N (1.50 lb)
[QΨ ] {d − QψF − Qψu }
as is appropriate for nonlinear data relations and nonlinear dynamics, respectively.
10.4.4 Experimental Data Study I: Stress Analysis Around a Hole Fig. 10.26a,b Crack under predominantly mode I loading: (a) experimental light-field photoelastic fringe data and (b) modeling and reconstruction
¯ n is a vector of Md components. The minimizwhere {d} ing principle leads to
¯ ψ] ¯ ψ] ˜ ¯ W[Q ¯ + γt [ H¯ t ] + γs [ H¯ s ] { P} [Q ¯ ψ] ¯ . ¯ W{d} = [Q
(10.15)
This is the core of the algorithm and is quite similar in form to that of (10.10). Thus, without going into the a)
b)
Fig. 10.27a,b Crack tip fringe patterns. (a) Experimental dark-field fringe pattern for green separation. (b) Reconstructions with nearfield experimental white fringes indicated as data points υ = 50 m/s .
Line of symmetry
Fig. 10.28 Blunt projectile impacting a stop
Stop a = 63.5 mm b = 12.7 mm h = 2.5 mm Aluminum
Figure 10.24a shows the recorded photoelastic fringe pattern where the load is distributed over an area. It is not the intention here to determine the precise distribution of this load per se – to do this would require collecting data very close to the distribution. Rather, in the spirit of hybrid analysis, we will do a stress analysis in the region close to the hole precisely where the data is of poor quality. The distributed load was achieved by placing a soft rubber layer between the model and the applied load; consequently, there was no possibility of a priori knowing the distribution, only the resultant. More details on this example can be found in [10.30]. The results to be reported used data taken from both the top and bottom regions away from the edges and from the hole. Two studies were performed. In the first, the load distribution is represented by two forces a distance of three nodes apart. Figure 10.25a shows the sum and difference of these forces as the position is varied. The results clearly indicate the center of the resultant load at P1 − P2 = 0. The second study took into account the distributed nature of the applied load. The initial guess for this study was taken as the resultant load with all others being zero. Figure 10.25b shows the reconstructed distribution. The precise distribution depends on the amount of regularization used. A key point, however, is that the solution in the vicinity of the hole is not sensitive to the precise nature of the distribution of applied load. That is, all reconstructed distributions regardless of regularization gave nearly the same solutions in the vicinity of the hole. Figure 10.24b shows the reconstructed fringe pattern corresponding to the distribution of Fig. 10.25b. The patterns close to the hole are almost identical. The patterns near the distribution show a slight difference which might be due to the presence of a shearing traction. Needless to say, reconstructing the fringe patterns is just one example of the entire results now available
Hybrid Methods
from postprocessing the stress analysis of the fully specified model.
10.4.5 Experimental Data Study II: Photoelastic Analysis of Cracks
a)
+50 m/s
Remote u· (t)
–50 m/s
Contact
An epoxy specimen was cut to the dimensions shown in Fig. 10.26 and an artificial crack was machined using a very fine blade. The specimen was then loaded as described in [10.31] and sent through a stress freezing cycle. Figure 10.26a shows a zoomed out image of the stress frozen pattern; this is a light-field image of the green separation. The crack, as machined, is at a small angle to the edge and therefore there is a small amount of mixed-mode behavior. Figure 10.27a shows the green separation with the image oriented with respect to the crack. The mixed-mode behavior is evident in the inner fringes. A very versatile method of crack parameter extraction is that of the virtual crack closure technique (VCCT) first introduced in [10.32]. The way we will use the FEM modeling is first to use the photoelastic data to determine the effective loading and then use this loading with the VCCT to determine the stress intensities. Figure 10.26b shows the modeling: the clamp/pins are replaced with point support boundary conditions at the bottom and three applied loads on the top. The elevated (stress-freezing) temperature properties were used; the Young’s modulus was estimated as 16.75 MPa (2430 psi) and f¯σ of 200 N/m (1.1 lb/in.). Data remote from the crack tip but not close to the load points were used. First-order regularization was used with a relatively large value of regularization – this forced the distribution to be linear. The results were {P} = {0.351, 0.330, 0.318} P0 , P0 = 6.46 N (1.45 lb) .
0
b)
40
80
120
160 200 Time (μs)
σxx
εxx
–0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5 2 Strain (%)
Fig. 10.29a,b Projectile behavior: (a) velocity responses and (b) nonlinear σxx /¯xx stress–strain response at different locations
The expected resultant load value is P0 = 6.67 N (1.50 lb). It is interesting that the load distribution picks up a slight bending action. Figure 10.26b shows a reconstruction of the fringe pattern using these load values; the comparison with Fig. 10.26a is quite reasonable. The loads were then used to give the stress intensity factors. K 1 /K 0 = 1.18 (1.28) , K 2 /K 0 = 0.03 (0.03) , √ where K 0 = σ∞ πa is the stress intensity factor for an infinite sheet. The parenthetical values are results using the expected load distributed uniformly and computed using the VCCT. Reference [10.6] studied the same problem using the extrapolation method for the three color separations, as well as the Levenberg–Marquardt method for nonlinear parameter identification. The red, green, blue separation results for K 1 /K 0 were 1.37,
251
Part A 10.4
The objective of this study is to determine stress intensity factors using photoelastic data; however, unknown forces will be used as an intermediate parameterization. To elaborate further on this point, stress intensity √ factors are usually presented in graphs as K i = σ∞ πa f (a/W), where W is a geometric factor (such as the width) and f (a/W) shows the influence of the geometry on the crack behavior. This formula gives us a clue as to how to approach crack problems (and singularity-type problems in general): the FEM is used to characterize the geometric effects, and the role of the experiment is to characterize the effective remote loading. This is essentially what we will do in this problem.
10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems
252
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a)
b) Reconstructed Exact
Part A 10.4
Initial
5
1
10
2
15
3
30
0
20
40
60
80
100 120 Time (μs)
0
20
40
60
80
100 120 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.30a,b Convergence behavior with 1% noise. (a) First three iterations. (b) Samples over last 20 iterations. Numbers to the left are the iteration counter
1.34, and 1.19, respectively. Note that this required the use of data very close to the crack tip.
10.4.6 Synthetic Data Study I: Elastic–Plastic Projectile Impact One challenge of ballistic experiments is to be able to determine the force due to impact and penetration. References [10.33, 34] discuss two possible experimental methods; what they have in common is that they record data at the back end of the projectile from which they try to infer the applied loading at the front end. Two more recent examples [10.35, 36] used measurements off the side of the projectile. Figure 10.28 shows a blunt projectile impacting a stop – the stop, as implied, does not deform. This a)
P1 H
b)
L = 254 mm H = 127 mm b = 25.4 mm h = 2.5 mm Aluminum
σ
σY = E /500
P2 4
8
4
2 ε
8
2 L
0
0.25
0.5
0.75
1 1.25 Strain (%)
Fig. 10.31a,b A truss with two uncorrelated load histories: (a) geometry and (b) stress–strain behavior of members that yielded
example will be used to explore some of the issues involved in trying to use remote measurements to infer contact loads when the contact region undergoes elastic–plastic deformations. The program NonStaD can model dynamic contact problems [10.19] and was used to generate the synthetic data for the moving projectile contacting the rigid stop. A blunt projectile was chosen because it gives a sharper rise time in the contact force history than the corresponding rounded projectile. Although the six contacting nodes have individual histories only the resultant force history will be identified here. That is, StrIDent has the ability to identify individual forces or resultants on groups of nodes; in the present case, just the resultant will be identified. Figure 10.29a shows the velocity responses along the length of the projectile and Fig. 10.29b shows the stress–strain excursions experienced. As can be seen, there is a substantial amount of plasticity with multiple unloadings and reloadings; however, it is interesting to note that, although the head of the projectile experiences a good deal of plasticity, the rebound velocity shows only a slight loss of momentum. Figure 10.30 shows the resultant force history as the full heavy line. Note that the contact time depends primarily on the length of the projectile and not on the contact conditions. Figure 10.30 shows the convergence behavior using data just from the tail end. The
Hybrid Methods
a)
P2 (t)
Initial
Initial
1
1
5
5
9
9
13
13 1000
1500 Time (μs)
0
Part A 10.4
P1 (t)
500
253
b)
Reconstructed Exact
0
10.4 Some Nonlinear Force Identification Problems
500
1000
1500 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.32 Convergence behavior with 1% noise. Numbers to the left are the iteration counter
initial guess is based on the linear behavior and it looks quite good. This is not surprising because essentially the signal propagated to the monitor is dominated by the elastic response, and the measured response is insensitive to the particulars of the behavior in the vicinity of the contact. This accounts for the success of force identification methods even in the presence of localized plasticity as occurs in the impact of, say, a steel ball on aluminum. There are small but significant differences between the linear reconstructed force and the true force shown as the initial results in Fig. 10.30a. The phase delay is due to the change of modulus above yielding. The first few iterations then attempt to correct for this phase shift. By the fifth iteration this initial behavior has been corrected but, in the process, the maximum force has become large. Bear in mind that this maximum force will primarily affect the long-time response seen in the trailing edge. The next 20 or so iterations of Fig. 10.30b are concerned with reducing this peak force. Convergence is slow but, overall, the final comparison is quite good. That the reconstructed force could have the large excursions and still return to the correct answer attests to the basic robustness of the algorithm.
10.4.7 Synthetic Data Study II: Multiple Loads on a Truss Structure As a second elastic–plastic example, consider the multimember truss shown in Fig. 10.31. This is subject to
two uncorrelated loads and their histories are shown in Fig. 10.32 as the solid lines; note that the two forces are not identical.
Strain gages Photoelastic model
Impactor
Impactor: V = 4.3 m/s D = 19 mm Steel
Cordin 180 camera
Model: L = 508 mm W = 254 mm h = 6.35 mm Epoxy
Fig. 10.33 Experimental setup for recording dynamic photoelastic
photographs
a)
b)
Line of symmetry
P N = 0.5 N=1 N = 0.75
R .
Fig. 10.34a,b Photoelastic experiment: (a) recorded image and (b) discretized data superimposed on (partial view) mesh
254
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 10.4
Again, NonStaD was used to generate synthetic velocity data at each of the joints. With this particular loading, the members can experience many load–unload cycles. Three of the members yield and their stress– strain excursions are shown in Fig. 10.31b. Member 2, which is closest to P1 , shows a significant amount of plasticity. The convergence results are shown in Fig. 10.32 where the vertical velocity of the three center joints were used as data inputs. The initial guess for P1 is poor while that for P2 is quite good. This can be explained by noting that P1 on its own will cause the three members to yield whereas P2 on its own will not cause any yielding. The forces are reconstructed exceptionally well by the tenth or so iteration. Since there is 1% noise, the fluctuations never settle down. Initial attempts to reconstruct the forces over a longer period of time were not especially successful. The longer period encompasses the stage when the members, especially member 2, reverses stress sign. It seems that, when the members are in the unloading/reloading stage, the responses are sensitive to the history of stress up to that point; small variations in initial history can cause large variations in this behavior. This led, in [10.21], to the development of a time sliding algorithm. The basic solution strategy is to reconstruct the forces with a time base that expands (or slides) with the iterations. If the new force estimates are weighted in favor of retaining the already estimated early-time behavior then this gives a robust approach to getting to the unload/reloading stage. Such a strategy also helped considerably to give better initial guesses. Many examples are given in [10.21].
wave (indicated by R) propagating downward along the surface. It is the objective here to determine the contact force history from this single frame of data. One of the difficulties in using photoelasticity for dynamic problems is in identifying the fringe orders. In static problems a variety of techniques can be used including the use of white light where the zero fringe order can be identified as the black fringe. For dynamic crack propagation problems [10.38], the pattern close to the crack tip has a definite monotonic ordering easily counted from the remote state. For general dynamic problems with multiple reflections and data similar to the 300 μs frame in Fig. 10.34, there is just the grey scale image with no obvious ordering. It is worth mentioning, however, that all fringe orders need not be identified since only a subset of the data need be used for the inverse method to succeed. Thus a)
Initial
1 4 7 10 13 0
100
200
300 400 Time (μs)
b)
10.4.8 Experimental Data Study III: Dynamic Photoelasticity The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 10.33, the Cordin high-speed camera can record a sequence 27 photographs with a frame rate up to every 8 μs. The impact is generated by a steel ball. If the ball contacted the epoxy directly, then the contact time would be relatively long and wave propagation effects would be hardly noticeable. The epoxy plate is attached to the one-sided Hopkinson bar so that the impact is actually steel on steel and the strain gages on the bar allow the force at the plate to be computed as discussed earlier. A frame of data is shown in Fig. 10.34a. Reference [10.37] has complete sets of such fringe patterns for different specimen arrangements and different layered materials. The photograph shows the Rayleigh
Frame Force 100
Photoelastic
Bar 0 0
100
200
300
400
500
600 700 Time (μs)
Fig. 10.35a,b Convergence behavior of the force reconstructions. (a) Force reconstructions during iterations. (b) Comparison with force measured from the one-sided Hopkinson bar
Hybrid Methods
a)
b)
Fig. 10.36a,b Data reconstructions: (a) isochromatic fringe pattern and (b) contours of the fringe pattern at every 0.5 fringe order
results are shown in Fig. 10.36a; it has all the characteristics of Fig. 10.34a. What is very interesting is the actual contours of intensity as shown in Fig. 10.34b. These contours are plotted at every 0.1 of a fringe with the whole and half orders being the thick lines, and they show the very complex nature of the fringe pattern, especially in the vicinity of the Rayleigh wave. In particular, they show that the center of the white and black fringes cannot be relied upon to be whole- and halforder fringes, respectively. This reinforces the point that fringe identification can be a significant challenge in dynamic photoelasticity.
10.5 Discussion of Parameterizing the Unknowns The goal of the experimental work is to complete the specification of the given problem. As discussed in the Introduction, there are a variety of unknowns in the problem and consequently there is a choice as to how to parameterize these unknowns. This discussion, in light of the examples covered, attempts to frame the issues involved in choosing the appropriate parameterization. Consider the typical static FEM problem stated as [K (a j )]{u} = {P} . The stiffness, as indicated, depends on a number of parameters a j . From a partially specified problem point of view, the only allowable unknowns are the parameters a j and the applied loads {P}. Thus quantities of interest such as stresses or deformed shapes are not considered basic unknowns – once the problem is fully specified these are obtained as a postprocessing operation. However, force identification and parameter identification are often interchangeable problems; which approach is preferred will depend on the specifics of any particular problem. Some general ideas are discussed next.
255
10.5.1 Parameterized Loadings and Subdomains When the loading is distributed it may require a number of parameters to characterize it and there are a number of situations that may prevail depending on our a priori information and the number of sensors available. If there are a good number of sensors available, then the loading on each node can be considered unknown. If there are fewer sensors but the distribution is expected to be somewhat smooth, then again the loading on each node can be considered unknown and regularization used to maintain a well-behaved solution. If the number of unknowns is computationally too large, then a parameterized loading scheme can be used. A challenging situation arises where there are not many sensors and the distribution is not simple. Consider the situation of an airfoil in an unsteady stream or a building under wind loading. Both will have a complicated loading (in space and time) but we are interested somehow in characterizing (and therefore estimating) the stresses. In these
Part A 10.5
in Fig. 10.34b only those fringes that are obvious or clearly defined were identified and discretized. However, the data used must be distributed over the entire model otherwise the time information would be distorted. Figure 10.35a shows the convergence behavior; in spite of the very poor initial guess, the solution eventually converges to the nearly correct history. The frame of data was taken at time step t = 300 μs but the solution was determined over a time period of 400 μs; the horizontal trailing edge is indicative of the first-order time regularization used when no real information is in the data. A detailed plot of the force history is shown in Fig. 10.35b; the comparison is with the force determined from the one-sided Hopkinson bar. Overall, the comparison is quite good. It is expected that the results could be improved if more frames of data were used and if the parameters of the model (modulus, density, fringe constant, and so on) were tweaked as described earlier in the parameter identification section. The latter was not done here because the limited number frames did not warrant it. As additional processing, the determined force history was used to reconstruct the fringe pattern, and the
10.5 Discussion of Parameterizing the Unknowns
256
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
a) Unknowns: • Loads • Properties • BCs • Flaws
Region of interest Unknown event
Part A 10.5
b)
Free body cut
Region of interest
ty tx
Tractions
Fig. 10.37a,b Schematic of the subdomain concept. (a) The complete system is comprised of the unknowns of interest plus remote unknowns of no immediate interest. (b) The analyzed system is comprised of the unknowns of interest plus the unknown boundary tractions
cases it is necessary to develop a model (preferably, a physics- or mechanics-based model) for the loading. It usually happens that the distribution is in terms of parameters that appear nonlinearly in the relation. What the holographic analysis of the plate (Fig. 10.1c), the interferometric analysis of the beam (Fig. 10.1a), the photoelastic analysis of the hole (Fig. 10.24), all have in common is that they use the experimental data indirectly to infer some other information about the problem. That is, the data do not directly give the quantities of interest (the bending strains in the plate, for example) and additional processing is required to complete the stress analysis. Loads were introduced as a convenient intermediate parameterization of the unknowns. The loads as intermediate parameters may have physical significance, as for the Output Stresses
Input
Equilibrium
Loads
Hooke's law
Analysis Heat flow Input
Conduction
Temp Output
Fig. 10.38 Concatenated modeling: the conduction model is used to generate temperature sensitivities that are inputs to Hooke’s law, which in turn produces load sensitivities to the equilibrium modeling
applied pressure in the holographic case, but the traction distribution of Fig. 10.25 is not intended to be the actual traction distribution. The inferred loads are understood to be a set of loads that are consistent with the given experimental data and are capable of accurately reconstructing the stress state in the vicinity of the data. There are additional reasons for choosing forces as the set of unknowns. Often in experimental situations, it is impossible, inefficient, or impractical to model the entire structure. Indeed, in many cases, data can only be collected from a limited region. Furthermore, the probability of achieving a good inverse solution is enhanced if the number of unknowns can be reduced. All these situations would be taken care of if we could just isolate the subregion of interest from the rest of the structure: the aircraft wing detached from the fuselage, the loose joint separate from the beams, the center span independent of the rest of the bridge, and so on. The basic idea of our approach to this concern is shown schematically in Fig. 10.37. The original problem has, in addition to the primary unknowns of interest, additional unknowns associated with the rest of the structure. Through a free-body cut, these are removed from the problem so that the subdomain has the primary unknowns of interest plus a set of additional unknown tractions that are equivalent to the remainder of the structure. While these unknown tractions appear as applied loads on the subdomain, they are, essentially, a parametric representation of the effect the rest of the structure has on the subregion of interest.
10.5.2 Unknowns Parameterized Through a Second Model To help fix the ideas expressed here, consider the thermoelastic stress analysis of a nonuniform cylinder with a hot fluid slowly moving through its core. Further, assume we are using integrated photoelasticity [10.39, 40]; then the fringe distribution observed on any crosssection is fσ (σzz − σ yy )2 + 4σz2y dx , N(y, z) = h where the integration is along the light path. If the problem is parameterized with the stresses as the unknowns, there is insufficient data to determine the stress distributions even in the simple case of axisymmetric stresses [10.40]. Even if the problem is parameterized with the temperatures as the unknowns then there still would never be a sufficient number of independent light paths to determine the great many unknowns.
Hybrid Methods
concatenating many models generalizes to problems involving residual stresses, radiation, and electrostatics, to name a few. It can also be extended to complex interacting systems such as loads on turbine blades in an engine.
10.5.3 Final Remarks What these examples and discussions show is that a crucial step in inverse analysis is parameterizing the unknowns of a problem; the specific choices made depend on the problem type, the number of sensors available, and the sophistication of the modeling capability. The examples also show that we have tremendous flexibility as to how this can be done; this flexibility is afforded by incorporating FEM-type modeling as an integral part of the experimental analysis.
References 10.1
10.2 10.3
10.4
10.5
10.6
10.7
10.8
10.9 10.10
10.11 10.12
A.S. Kobayashi: Hybrid experimental-numerical stress analysis. In: Handbook on Experimental Mechanics, ed. by A.S. Kobayashi (VCH, Weinheim 1993) pp. 751–783 A.S. Kobayashi: Hybrid experimental-numerical stress analysis, Exp. Mech. 23, 338–347 (1983) T.H. Baek, R.E. Rowlands: Hybrid stress analysis of perforated composites using strain gages, Exp. Mech. 41(2), 195–203 (2001) B.J. Rauch, R.E. Rowlands: Stress separation of thermoelastically measured isopachics, Exp. Mech. 41(4), 358–367 (2001) J. Rhee, R.E. Rowlands: Moiré-numerical hybrid analysis of cracks in orthotropic media, Exp. Mech. 42(3), 311–317 (2002) J.F. Doyle: Modern Experimental Stress Analysis: Completing the Solution of Partially Specified Problems (Wiley, Chichester 2004) A. Neumaier: Solving ill-conditioned and singular linear systems: a tutorial on regularization, SIAM J. Appl. Math. 40(3), 636–666 (1998) W.H. Press, B.P. Flannery, S.A. Teukolsky, W.T. Vetterling: Numerical Recipes, 2nd edn. (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge 1992) A.N. Tikhonov, V.Y. Arsenin: Solutions of Ill-Posed Problems (Wiley, New York 1977) S. Twomey: Introduction to the Mathematics of Inversion in Remote Sensing and Indirect Measurements (Elsevier, Amsterdam 1977) J.F. Doyle: Static and Dynamic Analysis of Structures (Kluwer, Dordredt 1991) J.F. Doyle: Nonlinear Analysis of Thin-Walled Structures: Statics, Dynamics, and Stability (Springer, New York 2001)
257
10.13
10.14
10.15 10.16
10.17
10.18 10.19
10.20
10.21
10.22
10.23 10.24
D.L. Phillips: A technique for the numerical solution of certain integral equations of the first kind, J. Assoc. Comput. Mach. 9(1), 84–97 (1962) S. Twomey: On the numerical solution of Fredholm integral equations of the first kind by the inversion of the linear system produced by quadratures, J. Assoc. Comput. Mach. 10, 97–101 (1963) O.M. Alifanov: Methods of solving ill-posed inverse problems, J. Eng. Phys. 45(5), 1237–1245 (1983) Y. Martinez, A. Dinth: A generalization of Tikhonov’s regularizations of zero and first order, Comput. Math. Appl. 12B(5/6), 1203–1208 (1986) A.J. Quintana: A Global Search Method for Damage Detection in General Structures. M.Sc. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 2004) M. Kleiber: Parameter Sensitivity in Nonlinear Mechanics (Wiley, Chichester 1997) S.-W. Choi: Impact Damage of Layered Material Systems. Ph.D. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 2002) S.-M. Cho: A Sub-Domain Inverse Method for Dynamic Crack Propagation Problems. M.Sc. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 2000) S.-M. Cho: Algorithms for Identification of the Nonlinear Behavior of Structures. Ph.D. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 2004) J.F. Doyle: A wavelet deconvolution method for impact force identification, Exp. Mech. 37, 404–408 (1997) D.J. Ewins: Modal Testing: Theory and Practice (Wiley, New York 1984) R.A. Adams, J.F. Doyle: Multiple force identification for complex structures, Exp. Mech. 42(1), 25–36 (2002)
Part A 10
What we can do instead is use a second modeling (in this case a conduction model) to parameterize the temperature distribution in terms of a limited number of boundary temperatures or heat sources. The idea is shown in Fig. 10.38 as a concatenation of modelings: the stresses are related to the applied loads through the equilibrium model, the applied loads are related to the temperature distribution through Hooke’s law, and the temperature distribution is related to the parameterized heat sources through the conduction model. Working in reverse, the conduction model uses the boundary temperature fields to compute the temperature sensitivity fields. These in turn are used in the equilibrium modeling to compute the sensitivity responses to find the stresses. Thus the stress parameterization is ultimately related to the heat parameterization. This idea of using a second model or
References
258
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
10.25
10.26 10.27
Part A 10
10.28
10.29
10.30
10.31
10.32
10.33
R.A. Adams: Force Identification in Complex Structures. M.Sc. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 1999) J.W. Dally, W.F. Riley: Experimental Stress Analysis, 3rd edn. (McGraw-Hill, New York 1991) T. Liu, M. Guille, J.P. Sullivan: Accuracy of pressure sensitive paint, AIAA J. 39(1), 103–112 (2001) H. Sakaue, J.P. Sullivan: Time response of anodized aluminum pressure sensitive paint, AIAA J. 39(10), 1944–1949 (2001) J.W. Dally, R.J. Sanford: Multiple ruby laser system for high speed photography, Opt. Eng. 21, 704–708 (1982) U.-T. Kang: Inverse Method for Static Problems Using Optical Data. Ph.D. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 2002) J.F. Doyle, S. Kamle, J. Takezaki: Error analysis of photoelasticity in fracture mechanics, Exp. Mech. 17, 429–435 (1981) E.F. Rybicki, M.F. Kanninen: A finite element calculation of stress intensity factors by a modified crack-closure integral, Eng. Fract. Mech. 9, 931– 938 (1977) A.L. Chang, A.M. Rajendran: Novel in-situ ballistic measurements for validation of ceramic constitutive models, 14th US Army Symp. Solid Mech., ed.
10.34
10.35
10.36
10.37
10.38 10.39 10.40
by K.R. Iyer, S.-C. Chou (Batelle, Columbus 1996) pp. 99–110 H.D. Espinosa, Y. Xu, H.-C. Lu: A novel technique for penetrator velocity measurements and damage identification in ballistic penetration experiments. In: 14th US Army Symposium on Solid Mechanics, ed. by K.R. Iyer, S.-C. Chou (Batelle, Columbus 1996) pp. 111–120 H.A. Bruck, D. Casem, R.L. Williamson, J.S. Epstein: Characterization of short duration stress pulses generated by impacting laminated carbonfiber/epoxy composites with magnetic flyer plates, Exp. Mech. 42(3), 279–287 (2002) J. Degrieck, P. Verleysen: Determination of impact parameters by optical measurement of the impactor displacement, Exp. Mech. 42(3), 298–302 (2002) S.A. Rizzi: A Spectral Analysis Approach to Wave Propagation in Layered Solids. Ph.D. Thesis (Purdue University, West Lafayette 1989) J.W. Dally: Dynamic photoelastic studies of dynamic fracture, Exp. Mech. 19, 349–361 (1979) H.K. Aben: Integrated Photoelasticity (McGrawHill, New York 1980) J.F. Doyle, H.T. Danyluk: Integrated photoelasticity for axisymmetric problems, Exp. Mech. 18(6), 215– 220 (1978)
259
Statistical An
11. Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
James W. Dally
characterized statistically. Regression analysis provides a method to fit a straight line or a curve through a series of scattered data points on a graph. The adequacy of the regression analysis can be evaluated by determining a correlation coefficient. Methods for extending regression analysis to multivariate functions exist. In principle, these methods are identical to linear regression analysis; however, the analysis becomes much more complex. The increase in complexity is not a concern, because computer subroutines are available that solve the tedious equations and provide the results in a convenient format. Many probability functions are used in statistical analyses to represent data and predict population properties. Once a probability function has been selected to represent a population, any series of measurements can be subjected to a chi-squared (χ 2 ) test to check the validity of the assumed function. Accurate predictions can be made only if the proper probability function has been selected. Finally, statistical methods for accessing error propagation are discussed. These methods provide a means for determining error in a quantity of interest y based on measurements of related quantities x1 , x2 , ..., xn and the functional relationship y = f (x1 ‚x2 ‚ ..., xn ).
11.1
Characterizing Statistical Distributions ... 11.1.1 Graphical Representations of the Distribution........................ 11.1.2 Measures of Central Tendency ........ 11.1.3 Measures of Dispersion .................
260 260 261 262
11.2 Statistical Distribution Functions ........... 263 11.2.1 Gaussian Distribution ................... 263 11.2.2 Weibull Distribution ..................... 265 11.3 Confidence Intervals for Predictions ....... 267 11.4 Comparison of Means............................ 270
Part A 11
Statistical methods are extremely important in engineering, because they provide a means for representing large amounts of data in a concise form that is easily interpreted and understood. Usually, the data are represented with a statistical distribution function that can be characterized by a measure of central tendency (the mean x¯ ) and a measure of dispersion (the standard deviation Sx ). A normal or Gaussian probability distribution is by far the most commonly employed; however, in some cases, other distribution functions may have to be employed to adequately represent the data. The most significant advantage resulting from the use of a probability distribution function in engineering applications is the ability to predict the occurrence of an event based on a relatively small sample. The effects of sampling error are accounted for by placing confidence limits on the predictions and establishing the associated confidence levels. Sampling error can be controlled if the sample size is adequate. Use of Student’s t distribution function, which characterizes sampling error, provides a basis for determining sample size consistent with specified levels of confidence. Student’s t distribution also permits a comparison to be made of two means to determine whether the observed difference is significant or whether it is due to random variation. Statistical methods can also be employed to condition data and to eliminate an erroneous data point (one) from a series of measurements. This is a useful technique that improves the data base by providing strong evidence when something unanticipated is affecting an experiment. Regression analysis can be used effectively to interpret data when the behavior of one quantity y depends upon variations in one or more independent quantities x1 , x2 , ..., xn . Even though the functional relationship between quantities exhibiting variation remains unknown, it can be
260
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
11.5 Statistical Safety Factor ......................... 271 11.6 Statistical Conditioning of Data ............. 272 11.7 Regression Analysis............................... 272 11.7.1 Linear Regression Analysis............. 272 11.7.2 Multivariate Regression................. 274
Part A 11.1
Experimental measurements of quantities such as pressure, temperature, length, force, stress or strain will always exhibit some variation if the measurements are repeated a number of times with precise instruments. This variability, which is fundamental to all measuring systems, is due to two different causes. First, the quantity being measured may exhibit significant variation. For example, in a materials study to determine fatigue life at a specified stress level, large differences in the number of cycles to failure are noted when a number of specimens are tested. This variation is inherent to the fatigue process and is observed in all fatigue life measurements. Second, the measuring system, which includes the transducer, signal conditioning equipment, analogue-to-digital (A/D) converter, recording instrument, and an operator may introduce error in the measurement. This error may be systematic or random, depending upon its source. An instrument operated out of calibration produces a systematic error, whereas reading errors due to interpolation on a chart are random. The accumulation of random errors in a measuring system produces a variation that must be examined in relation to the magnitude of the quantity being measured. The data obtained from repeated measurements represent an array of readings not an exact result. Maximum information can be extracted from such an array of
11.7.3 Field Applications of Least-Square Methods .............. 275 11.8 Chi-Square Testing ............................... 277 11.9 Error Propagation ................................. 278 References .................................................. 279
readings by employing statistical methods. The first step in the statistical treatment of data is to establish the distribution. A graphical representation of the distribution is usually the most useful form for initial evaluation. Next, the statistical distribution is characterized with a measure of its central value, such as the mean, the median, or the mode. Finally, the spread or dispersion of the distribution is determined in terms of the variance or the standard deviation. With elementary statistical methods, the experimentalist can reduce a large amount of data to a very compact and useful form by defining the type of distribution, establishing the single value that best represents the central value of the distribution (mean), and determining the variation from the mean value (standard deviation). Summarizing data in this manner is the most meaningful form of presentation for application to design problems or for communication to others who need the results of the experiments. The treatment of statistical methods presented in this chapter is relatively brief; therefore, only the most commonly employed techniques for representing and interpreting data are presented. A formal course in statistics, which covers these techniques in much greater detail as well as many other useful techniques, should be included in the program of study of all engineering students.
11.1 Characterizing Statistical Distributions For the purposes of this discussion, consider the data obtained from an experiment conducted n times to measure the ultimate tensile strength of a fully tempered beryllium copper alloy. The data obtained represent a sample of size n from an infinite population of all possible measurements that could have been made. The simplest way to present these data is to list the strength measurements in order of increasing magnitude, as shown in Table 11.1. These data can be arranged into seven groups to give a frequency distribution as shown in Table 11.2. The ad-
vantage of representing data in a frequency distribution is that the central tendency is more clearly illustrated.
11.1.1 Graphical Representations of the Distribution The shape of the distribution function representing the ultimate tensile strength of beryllium copper is indicated by the data groupings of Table 11.2. A graphical presentation of this group data, known as a histogram, is shown in Fig. 11.1. The histogram method of presen-
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
Table 11.1 The ultimate tensile strength of beryllium cop-
per, listed in order of increasing magnitude Strength ksi (MPa)
Sample number
Strength ksi (MPa)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
170.5 (1175) 171.9 (1185) 172.6 (1190) 173.0 (1193) 173.4 (1196) 173.7 (1198) 174.2 (1201) 174.4 (1203) 174.5 (1203) 174.8 (1206) 174.9 (1206) 175.0 (1207) 175.4 (1210) 175.5 (1210) 175.6 (1211) 175.6 (1211) 175.8 (1212) 175.9 (1213) 176.0 (1214) 176.1 (1215)
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
176.2 (1215) 176.2 (1215) 176.4 (1217) 176.6 (1218) 176.7 (1219) 176.9 (1220) 176.9 (1220) 177.2 (1222) 177.3 (1223) 177.4 (1223) 177.7 (1226) 177.8 (1226) 178.0 (1228) 178.1 (1228) 178.3 (1230) 178.4 (1230) 179.0 (1236) 179.7 (1239) 180.1 (1242) 181.6 (1252)
tation shows the central tendency and variability of the distribution much more clearly than the tabular method of presentation of Table 11.2. Superimposed on the histogram is a curve showing the relative frequency of the occurrence of a group of measurements. Note that the points for the relative frequency are plotted at the midpoint of the group interval. A cumulative frequency diagram, shown in Fig. 11.2, is another way of representing the ultimate strength data from the experiments. The cumulative frequency is the number of readings having a value less
Number of observations 20
261
Relative frequency 0.5
18 0.4
16 14
0.3
12 10
0.2
8 6
0.1
4 2
0 0 167 169 171 173 175 177 179 181 183 185 Ultimate tensile strength Su (ksi)
Fig. 11.1 Histogram with superimposed relative frequency
diagram
than a specified value of the quantity being measured (ultimate strength) divided by the total number of measurements. As indicated in Table 11.2, the cumulative frequency is the running sum of the relative frequencies. When the graph of cumulative frequency versus the quantity being measured is prepared, the end value for the group intervals is used to position the point along the abscissa.
11.1.2 Measures of Central Tendency While histograms or frequency distributions are used to provide a visual representation of a distribution, numerical measures are used to define the characteristics of the distribution. One basic characteristic is the central tendency of the data. The most commonly employed measure of the central tendency of a distribution of data
Table 11.2 Frequency distribution of ultimate tensile strength Intervals group ksi (MPa)
Observations in the group
Relative frequency
Cumulative frequency
169.0 − 170.9 (1166 − 1178) 171.0 − 172.9 (1179 − 1192) 173.0 − 174.9 (1193 − 1206) 175.0 − 176.9 (1207 − 1220) 177.0 − 178.9 (1221 − 1234) 179.0 − 180.9 (1235 − 1248) 181.0 − 182.9 (1249 − 1261) Total
1 2 8 16 9 3 1 40
0.025 0.050 0.200 0.400 0.225 0.075 0.025
0.025 0.075 0.275 0.675 0.900 0.975 1.000
Part A 11.1
Sample number
11.1 Characterizing Statistical Distributions
262
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
It is evident that a typical set of data may give different values for the three measures of central tendency. There are two reasons for this difference. First, the population from which the samples were drawn may not be Gaussian (for which the three measures are expected to coincide). Second, even if the population is Gaussian, the number of measurements n is usually small and deviations due to a small sample size are to be expected.
Cumulative frequency 1 0.8 0.6 0.4
11.1.3 Measures of Dispersion 0.2
Part A 11.1
0 167 169 171 173 175 177 179 181 183 185 Ultimate tensile strength Su (ksi)
Fig. 11.2 Cumulative frequency diagram
is the sample mean x, ¯ which is defined as x¯ =
n xi , n
(11.1)
i=1
where xi is the i-th value of the quantity being measured and n is the total number of measurements. Because of time and costs involved in conducting tests, the number of measurements is usually limited; therefore, the sample mean x¯ is only an estimate of the true arithmetic mean μ of the population. It is shown later that x¯ approaches μ as the number of measurements increases. The mean value of the ultimate strength data presented in Table 11.1 is x¯ = 176.1 ksi (1215 MPa). The median and mode are also measures of central tendency. The median is the central value in a group of ordered data. For example, in an ordered set of 41 readings, the 21-st reading represents the median value with 20 readings lower than the median and 20 readings higher than the median. In instances when an even number of readings are taken, the median is obtained by averaging the two middle values. For example, in an ordered set of 40 readings, the median is the average of the 20-th and 21-st readings. Thus, for the ultimate tensile strength data presented in Table 11.1, the median is 1/2(176.1 + 176.2) = 176.15 ksi (1215 MPa). The mode is the most frequent value of the data; therefore, it is located at the peak of the relative frequency curve. In Fig. 11.1, the peak of the relative probability curve occurs at an ultimate tensile strength Su = 176.0 ksi (1214 MPa); therefore, this value is the mode of the data set presented in Table 11.1.
It is possible for two different distributions of data to have the same mean but different dispersions, as shown in the relative frequency diagrams of Fig. 11.3. Different measures of dispersion are the range, the mean deviation, the variance, and the standard deviation. The standard deviation Sx is the most popular and is defined as: 1/2 n (xi − x) ¯2 . (11.2) Sx = n −1 i=1
Because the sample size n is small, the standard deviation Sx of the sample represents an estimate of the true standard deviation σ of the population. Computation of Sx and x¯ from a data sample is easily performed with most scientific-type calculators. Expressions for the other measures of dispersion, namely, the range R, mean deviation dx , and variance Sx2 are given by R = xL − xs , n xi − x¯ dx = , n
(11.3) (11.4)
i=1
Relative frequency Small dispersion
Large dispersion
μ
Fig. 11.3 Relative frequency diagrams with large and small dispersions
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
Sx2 =
2 n xi − x¯ , n −1
(11.5)
i=1
estimate of the mean x. ¯ As the sample size n is increased the estimates of x, ¯ Sx , and Sx2 improve, as shown in the discussion of Sect. 11.4. Variance is an important measure of dispersion because it is used in defining the normal distribution function. Finally, a measure known as the coefficient of variation Cv is used to express the standard deviation Sx as a percentage of the mean x. ¯ Thus, Cv =
Sx (100) . x¯
(11.6)
The coefficient of variation represents a normalized parameter that indicates the variability of the data in relation to its mean.
11.2 Statistical Distribution Functions As the sample size is increased, it is possible in tabulating the data to increase the number of group intervals and to decrease their width. The corresponding relative frequency diagram, similar to the one illustrated in Fig. 11.1, will approach a smooth curve (a theoretical distribution curve) known as a distribution function. A number of different distribution functions are used in statistical analyses. The best-known and most widely used distribution in experimental mechanics is the Gaussian or normal distribution. This distribution is extremely important because it describes random errors in measurements and variations observed in strength determinations. Other useful distributions include the binomial, exponential, hypergeometric, chi-square χ 2 , Relative frequency 0.5
11.2.1 Gaussian Distribution The Gaussian or normal distribution function, as represented by a normalized relative frequency diagram, is shown in Fig. 11.4. The Gaussian distribution is completely defined by two parameters: the mean μ and the standard deviation σ. The equation for the relative frequency f in terms of these two parameters is given by: (11.7)
where
0.3
x¯ − μ (11.8) . σ Experimental data (with finite sample sizes) can be analyzed to obtain x¯ as an estimate of μ and Sx as an estimate of σ. This procedure permits the experimentalist to use data drawn from small samples to represent the entire population. The method for predicting population properties from a Gaussian (normal) distribution function utilizes the normalized relative frequency diagram shown z=
0.2 0.1 0
F, Gumbel, Poisson, Student’s t, and Weibull distributions; the reader is referred to [11.1–5] for a complete description of these distributions. Emphasis here will be on the Gaussian and Weibull distribution functions because of their wide range of application in experimental mechanics [11.6–13].
1 2 f (z) = √ e−(z /2) , 2π
0.4
μ–3σ μ–2σ –3 –2
μ–σ –1
μ 0
μ+σ 1
μ+2σ μ+3σ x 2 3 z
Fig. 11.4 The normal or Gaussian distribution function
263
Part A 11.2
where xL is the largest value of the quantity in the distribution and xs is the smallest value. Equation (11.4) indicates that the deviation of each reading from the mean is determined and summed. The average of the n deviations is the mean deviation. The absolute value of the difference (xi − x) ¯ must be used in the summing process to avoid cancellation of positive and negative deviations. The variance of the population σ 2 is estimated by Sx2 , where the denominator (n − 1) in (11.2) and (11.5) serves to reduce error introduced by approximating the true mean μ with the
11.2 Statistical Distribution Functions
264
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
A(0, +1) leads to the following determinations:
f (z)
Area =
Part A 11.2
–2
–1
0
1
f (z) dz
z2
z1 –3
z2
∫z
1
A(−1, +1) = p(−1, +1) = 0.3413 + 0.3413 = 0.6826 , A(−2, +2) = p(−2, +2) = 0.4772 + 0.4772 = 0.9544 , A(−3, +3) = p(−3, +3) = 0.49865 + 0.49865 = 0.9973 , A(−1, +2) = p(−1, +2) = 0.3413 + 0.4772 = 0.8185 . z
2
3
Fig. 11.5 Probability of a measurement of x between limits of z 1 and z 2 . The total area under the curve f (z) is 1
in Fig. 11.4. The area A under the entire curve is given by (11.7) as 1 A= √ 2π
∞
e−(z
2 /2)
dz = 1 .
(11.9)
−∞
Equation (11.9) implies that the population has a value z between −∞ and +∞ and that the probability of making a single observation from the population with a value −∞ ≤ z ≤ +∞ is 100%. While the previous statement may appear trivial and obvious, it serves to illustrate the concept of using the area under the normalized relative frequency curve to determine the probability p of observing a measurement within a specific interval. Figure 11.5 shows graphically, with the shaded area under the curve, the probability that a measurement will occur within the interval between z 1 and z 2 . Thus, from (11.7) it is evident that: z 2 p(z 1 , z 2 ) = z1
1 f (z) dz = √ 2π
z 2
e−(z
2 /2)
dz .
z1
(11.10)
Evaluation of (11.10) is most easily accomplished by using tables that list the areas under the normalized relative frequency curve as a function of z. Table 11.3 lists one-side areas between limits of z 1 = 0 and z 2 for the normal distribution function. Since the distribution function is symmetric about z = 0, this one-sided table is sufficient for all evaluations of the probability. For example, A(−1, 0) =
Because the normal distribution function has been well characterized, predictions can be made regarding the probability of a specific strength value or measurement error. For example, one may anticipate that 68.3% of the data will fall between limits of x¯ ± 1.0 Sx , 95.4% between limits of x¯ ± 2.0 Sx , and 99.7% between limits of x¯ ± 3.0 Sx . Also, 81.9% of the data should fall between limits of x¯ − 1.0 Sx and x¯ + 2.0 Sx . In many problems, the probability of a single sample exceeding a specified value z 2 must be determined. It is possible to determine this probability by using Table 11.3 together with the fact that the area under the entire curve is unity (A = 1); however, Table 11.4, which lists one-sided areas between limits of z 1 = z and z 2 ⇒ ∞, yields the results more directly. The use of Tables 11.3 and 11.4 can be illustrated by considering the ultimate tensile strength data presented in Table 11.1. By using (11.1) and (11.2), it is easy to establish estimates for the mean x¯ and standard deviation Sx as x¯ = 176.1 ksi (1215 MPa) and Sx = 2.25 ksi (15.5 MPa). The values of x¯ and Sx characterize the population from which the data of Table 11.1 were drawn. It is possible to establish the probability that the ultimate tensile strength of a single specimen drawn randomly from the population will be between specified limits (by using Table 11.3), or that the ultimate tensile strength of a single sample will not be above or below a specified value (by using Table 11.4). For example, one determines the probability that a single sample will exhibit an ultimate tensile strength between 175 ksi (1207 MPa) and 178 ksi (1234 MPa) by computing z 1 and z 2 and using Table 11.3. Thus, 175 − 176.1 = −0.489 , 2.25 178 − 176.1 z2 = = 0.844 , 2.25 p( − 0.489, 0.844) = A(−0.489, 0) + A(0, 0.844) = 0.1875 + 0.3006 = 0.4981 . z1 =
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
11.2 Statistical Distribution Functions
265
Table 11.3 Areas under the normal distribution curve from z 1 = 0 to z 2 (one side) 0.00
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.0
0.0000
0.0040
0.0080
0.0120
0.0160
0.0199
0.0239
0.0279
0.0319
0.0359
0.1
0.0398
0.0438
0.0478
0.0517
0.0557
0.0596
0.0636
0.0675
0.0714
0.0753
0.2
0.0793
0.0832
0.0871
0.0910
0.0948
0.0987
0.1026
0.1064
0.1103
0.1141
0.3
0.1179
0.1217
0.1255
0.1293
0.1331
0.1368
0.1406
0.1443
0.1480
0.1517
0.4
0.1554
0.1591
0.1628
0.1664
0.1700
0.1736
0.1772
0.1808
0.1844
0.1879
0.5
0.1915
0.1950
0.1985
0.2019
0.2054
0.2088
0.2123
0.2157
0.2190
0.2224
0.6
0.2257
0.2291
0.2324
0.2357
0.2389
0.2422
0.2454
0.2486
0.2517
0.2549
0.7
0.2580
0.2611
0.2642
0.2673
0.2704
0.2734
0.2764
0.2794
0.2823
0.2852
0.8
0.2881
0.2910
0.2939
0.2967
0.2995
0.3023
0.3051
0.3078
0.3106
0.3233
0.9
0.3159
0.3186
0.3212
0.3238
0.3264
0.3289
0.3315
0.3340
0.3365
0.3389
1.0
0.3413
0.3438
0.3461
0.3485
0.3508
0.3531
0.3554
0.3577
0.3599
0.3621
1.1
0.3643
0.3665
0.3686
0.3708
0.3729
0.3749
0.3770
0.3790
0.3810
0.3830
1.2
0.3849
0.3869
0.3888
0.3907
0.3925
0.3944
0.3962
0.3980
0.3997
0.4015
1.3
0.4032
0.4049
0.4066
0.4082
0.4099
0.4115
0.4131
0.4147
0.4162
0.4177
1.4
0.4192
0.4207
0.4222
0.4236
0.4251
0.4265
0.4279
0.4292
0.4306
0.4319
1.5
0.4332
0.4345
0.4357
0.4370
0.4382
0.4394
0.4406
0.4418
0.4429
0.4441
1.6
0.4452
0.4463
0.4474
0.4484
0.4495
0.4505
0.4515
0.4525
0.4535
0.4545
1.7
0.4554
0.4564
0.4573
0.4582
0.4591
0.4599
0.4608
0.4616
0.4625
0.4633
1.8
0.4641
0.4649
0.4656
0.4664
0.4671
0.4678
0.4686
0.4693
0.4699
0.4706
1.9
0.4713
0.4719
0.4726
0.4732
0.4738
0.4744
0.4750
0.4758
0.4761
0.4767
2.0
0.4772
0.4778
0.4783
0.4788
0.4793
0.4799
0.4803
0.4808
0.4812
0.4817
2.1
0.4821
0.4826
0.4830
0.4834
0.4838
0.4842
0.4846
0.4850
0.4854
0.4857
2.2
0.4861
0.4864
0.4868
0.4871
0.4875
0.4878
0.4881
0.4884
0.4887
0.4890
2.3
.4893
0.4896
0.4898
0.4901
0.4904
0.4906
0.4909
0.4911
0.4913
0.4916
2.4
0.4918
0.4920
0.4922
0.4925
0.4927
0.4929
0.4931
0.4932
0.4934
0.4936
2.5
0.4938
0.4940
0.4941
0.4943
0.4945
0.4946
0.4948
0.4949
0.4951
0.4952
2.6
0.4953
0.4955
0.4956
0.4957
0.4959
0.4960
0.4961
0.4962
0.4963
0.4964
2.7
0.4965
0.4966
0.4967
0.4968
0.4969
0.4970
0.4971
0.4972
0.4973
0.4974
2.8
0.4974
0.4975
0.4976
0.4977
0.4977
0.4978
1.4979
0.4979
0.4980
0.4981
2.9
0.4981
0.4982
0.4982
0.4983
0.4984
0.4984
0.4985
0.4985
0.4986
0.4986
3.0
0.49865
0.4987
0.4987
0.4988
0.4988
0.4988
0.4989
0.4989
0.4989
0.4990
z2
0.00
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
0.08
0.09
This simple calculation shows that the probability of obtaining an ultimate tensile strength between 175 ksi (1207 MPa) and 178 ksi (1234 MPa) from a single specimen is 49.8%. The probability of the ultimate tensile strength of a single specimen being less than 173 ksi (1193 MPa) is determined by computing z 1 and using Table 11.4. Thus, 173 − 176.1 = −1.37 , 2.25 p(−∞, −1.37) = A(−∞, −1.37) = A(1.37, ∞) = 0.0853 . z1 =
Thus, the probability of drawing a single sample with an ultimate tensile strength less than 173 ksi (1193 MPa) is 8.5%.
11.2.2 Weibull Distribution In investigations of the strength of materials due to brittle fracture, of crack initiation toughness, or of fatigue life, researchers often find that the Weibull distribution provides a more suitable approach to the statistical analysis of the available data. The Weibull distribution function p(x) is defined
Part A 11.2
z2
266
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Table 11.4 Areas under the normal distribution curve from z 1 to z 2 ⇒ ∞ (one side)
Part A 11.2
z1
0.00
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9
0.5000 0.4602 0.4207 0.3821 0.3446 0.3085 0.2743 0.2430 0.2119 0.1841 0.1587 0.1357 0.1151 0.0968 0.0808 0.0668 0.0548 0.0446 0.0359 0.0287 0.0228 0.0179 0.0139 0.0107 0.00820 0.00621 0.00466 0.00347 0.00256 0.00187
0.4960 .4562 0.4168 0.3783 0.3409 0.3050 0.2709 0.2389 0.2090 0.1814 0.1562 0.1335 0.1131 0.0951 0.0793 0.0655 0.0537 0.0436 0.0351 0.0281 0.0222 0.0174 0.0136 0.0104 0.00798 0.00604 0.00453 0.00336 0.00248 0.00181
0.4920 0.4522 0.4129 0.3745 0.3372 0.3015 0.2676 0.2358 0.2061 0.1788 0.1539 0.1314 0.1112 0.0934 0.0778 0.0643 0.0526 0.0427 0.0344 0.0274 0.0217 0.0170 0.0132 0.0102 0.00776 0.00587 0.00440 0.00326 0.00240 0.00175
0.4880 0.4483 0.4090 0.3707 0.3336 0.2981 0.2643 0.2327 0.2033 0.1762 0.1515 0.1292 0.1093 0.0918 0.0764 0.0630 0.0516 0.0418 0.0336 0.0268 0.0212 0.0166 0.0129 0.00990 0.00755 0.00570 0.00427 0.00317 0.00233 0.00169
0.4840 0.4443 0.4052 0.3669 0.3300 0.2946 0.2611 0.2296 0.2005 0.1736 0.1492 0.1271 0.1075 0.0901 0.0749 0.0618 0.0505 0.0409 0.0329 0.0262 0.0207 0.0162 0.0125 0.00964 0.00734 0.00554 0.00415 0.00307 0.00226 0.00164
0.4801 0.4404 0.4013 0.3632 0.3264 0.2912 0.2578 0.2266 0.1977 0.1711 0.1469 0.1251 0.1056 0.0885 0.0735 0.0606 0.0495 0.0401 0.0322 0.0256 0.0202 0.0158 0.0122 0.00939 0.00714 0.00539 0.00402 0.00298 0.00219 0.00159
0.4761 0.4364 0.3974 0.3594 0.3228 0.2877 0.2546 0.2236 0.1949 0.1685 0.1446 0.1230 0.1038 0.0869 0.0721 0.0594 0.0485 0.0392 0.0314 0.0250 0.0197 0.0154 0.0119 0.00914 0.00695 0.00523 0.00391 0.00288 0.00212 0.00154
0.4721 0.4325 0.3936 0.3557 0.3192 0.2843 0.2514 0.2206 0.1922 0.1660 0.1423 0.1210 0.1020 0.0853 0.0708 0.0582 0.0475 0.0384 0.0307 0.0244 0.0192 0.0150 0.0116 0.00889 0.00676 0.00508 0.00379 0.00280 0.00205 0.00149
0.4681 0.4286 0.3897 0.3520 0.3156 0.2810 0.2483 0.2177 0.1894 0.1635 0.1401 0.1190 0.1003 0.0838 0.0694 0.0571 0.0465 0.0375 0.0301 0.0239 0.0188 0.0146 0.0113 0.00866 0.00657 0.00494 0.00368 0.00272 0.00199 0.00144
0.4641 0.4247 0.3859 0.3483 0.3121 0.2776 0.2451 0.2148 0.1867 0.1611 0.1379 0.1170 0.0985 0.0823 0.0681 0.0559 0.0455 0.0367 0.0294 0.0233 0.0183 0.0143 0.0110 0.00840 0.00639 0.00480 0.00357 0.00264 0.00193 0.00139
as: −[(x−x 0 )/b]2
p(x) = 1 − e p(x) = 0
for x > x0 , for x < x0 ,
(11.11)
where x0 , b, and m are the three parameters which define this distribution function. In studies of strength, p(x) is taken as the probability of failure when a stress x is placed on the specimen. The parameter x0 is the zero strength since p(x) = 0 for x < x0 . The constants b and m are known as the scale parameter and the Weibull slope parameter (modulus), respectively. Four Weibull distribution curves are presented in Fig. 11.6 for the case where x0 = 3, b = 10, and m = 2, 5, 10, and 20. These curves illustrate two important features of the Weibull distribution. First, there
is a threshold strength x0 and if the applied stress is less than x0 , the probability of failure is zero. Second, the Weibull distribution curves are not symmetric, and the distortion in the S-shaped curves is controlled by the Weibull slope parameter m. Application of the Weibull distribution to predict failure rates of 1% or less of the population is particularly important in engineering projects where reliabilities of 99% or greater are required. To utilize the Weibull distribution requires knowledge of the Weibull parameters. In experimental investigations, it is necessary to conduct experiments and obtain a relatively large data set to accurately determine x0 , b, and m. Consider as an illustration, Weibull’s own work in statistically characterizing the fiber strength of Indian cotton. In this example, an unusually large sam-
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
Probability of failure (%) 100 90
11.3 Confidence Intervals for Predictions
Reduced variate y = log10 loge (1–P)–1 1
Probability of failure (%) 5
m = 20
2
10
80
P = m /(n +1) n = 3000 S0 = 0.46 g
99.9 99 90
70 60 x0 = 3 b = 10 m P (x) = 1 – e– [(x –3)/10]
50 40 30 20
0.5
70 50
0
30
–0.5
10
–1
10
–1.5 0
x0
5
10
15
20
25 Stress x
Fig. 11.6 The Weibull distribution function
(11.12)
where k is the order number of the sequenced data and n is the total sample size. At this stage it is possible to prepare a graph of probability of failure P(x) as a function of strength x to obtain a curve similar to that shown in Fig. 11.6. However, to determine the Weibull parameters x0 , b, and m requires additional conditioning of the data. From (11.11), it is evident that: e[(x−x0 )/b] = [1 − p(x)]−1 . m
(x − x0 ) b
m
= ln[1 − p(x)]−1 .
0
0.25
0.5
0.75
1 1.25 log (S – S0)
Taking log10 of both sides of (11.14) gives a relation for the slope parameter m. Thus: m=
(11.14)
log10 ln[1 − p(x)]−1 . log10 (x − x0 ) − log10 b
(11.15)
The numerator of (11.15) is the reduced variate y = log10 ln[1 − p(x)]−1 used for the ordinate in preparing a graph of the conditioned data as indicated in Fig. 11.7. Note that y is a function of p alone and for this reason both the p and y scales can be displayed on the ordinates (Fig. 11.7). The lead term in the denominator of (11.15) is the reduced variate x = log10 (x − x0 ) used for the abscissa in Fig. 11.7. In the Weibull example, the threshold strength x0 was adjusted to 0.46 g so that the data would fall on a straight line when plotted against the reduced x and y variates. The constant b is determined from the condition that: log10 b = log10 (x − x0 )
(11.13)
Taking the natural log of both sides of (11.13) yields:
–0.25
Fig. 11.7 Fiber strength of Indian cotton shown in graphical format with Weibull’s reduced variate (from data by Weibull [11.10])
ple (n = 3000) was studied by measuring the load to fracture (in grams) for each fiber. The strength data obtained was placed in sequential order with the lowest value corresponding to k = 1 first and the largest value corresponding to k = 3000 last. The probability of failure p(x) at a load x is then determined from: k , p= n +1
2 – 0.5
when
y=0.
(11.16)
Note from Fig. 11.7 that y = 0 when log10 (x − x0 ) = 0.54, which gives b = 0.54. Finally m is given by the slope of the straight line when the data is plotted in terms of the reduced variates x and y. In this example problem m = 1.48.
11.3 Confidence Intervals for Predictions When experimental data are represented with a normal distribution by using estimates of the mean x¯ and
standard deviation Sx and predictions are made about the occurrence of certain measurements, questions arise
Part A 11.3
0
267
268
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 11.3
concerning the confidence that can be placed on either the estimates or the predictions. One cannot be totally confident in the predictions or estimates because of the effects of sampling error. Sampling error can be illustrated by drawing a series of samples (each containing n measurements) from the same population and determining several estimates of the mean x¯1 , x¯2 , x¯3 , . . .. A variation in x¯ will occur, but fortunately this variation can also be characterized by a normal distribution function, as shown in Fig. 11.8. The mean of the x and x¯ distributions is the same; however, the standard deviation of the x¯ distribution Sx¯ (sometimes referred to as the standard error) is less than Sx because Sx (11.17) Sx¯ = √ . n When the standard deviation of the population of the x¯ is known, it is possible to place confidence limits on the determination of the true population mean μ from a sample of size n, provided n is large (n > 25). The confidence interval within which the true population mean μ is located is given by the expression (x¯ − zSx¯ ) < μ < [x¯ + zSx¯ ] ,
(11.18)
where x¯ − zSx¯ is the lower confidence limit and x¯ + zSx¯ is the upper confidence limit. The width of the confidence interval depends upon the confidence level required. For instance, if z = 3 in (11.18), a relatively wide confidence interval exists; therefore, the probability that the population mean μ will be located within the confidence interval is high (99.7%). As the width of the confidence interval decreases, the probability that the population mean μ will _
Table 11.5 Confidence interval variation with confidence level interval = x¯ + zSx¯ Confidence level (%)
z
Confidence level (%)
z
99.9 99.7 99.0 95.0
3.30 3.00 2.57 1.96
90.0 80.0 68.3 60.0
1.65 1.28 1.00 0.84
fall within the interval decreases. Commonly used confidence levels and their associated intervals are shown in Table 11.5. When the sample size is very small (n < 20), the standard deviation Sx does not provide a reliable estimate of the standard deviation μ of the population and (11.18) should not be employed. The bias introduced by small sample size can be removed by modifying (11.18) to read (x¯ − t(α)Sx¯ ) < μ < [x¯ + t(α)Sx¯ ] ,
(11.19)
where t(α) is the statistic known as Student’s t. α is the level of significance (the probability of exceeding a given value of t). Student’s t distribution is defined by a relative frequency equation f (t), which can be expressed as t 2 (ν+1)/2 , (11.20) f (t) = F0 1 + ν where F0 is the relative frequency at t = 0 required to make the total area under the f (t) curve equal to unity and ν is the number of degrees of freedom. f (t ) 0.5
f (x) or f (x )
υ = ∞ (normal distribution)
0.4
υ = 10 υ=5 υ=1
Distribution of x 0.3
_
Distribution of x 0.2 s sx = x √n _
sx_
0.1
sx
μ
_
x or x
Fig. 11.8 Normal distribution of individual measurements of the quantity x and of the mean x¯ from samples of size n
0 –5
–4
–3
–2
–1
0
1
2
3
4
5 t
Fig. 11.9 Student’s t distribution for several degrees of freedom ν
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
11.3 Confidence Intervals for Predictions
269
Table 11.6 Student’s t distribution for ν degrees of freedom showing t(α) as a function of area A (one side) 0.995
0.99
0.975
0.95
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 40 60 120 ∞
63.66 9.92 5.84 4.60 4.03 3.71 3.50 3.36 3.25 3.17 3.11 3.06 3.01 2.98 2.95 2.92 2.90 2.88 2.86 2.84 2.83 2.82 2.81 2.80 2.79 2.78 2.77 2.76 2.76 2.75 2.70 2.66 2.62 2.58
31.82 6.96 4.54 3.75 3.36 3.14 3.00 2.90 2.82 2.76 2.72 2.68 2.65 2.62 2.60 2.58 2.57 2.55 2.54 2.53 2.52 2.51 2.50 2.49 2.48 2.48 2.47 2.47 2.46 2.46 2.42 2.39 2.36 2.33
12.71 4.30 3.18 2.78 2.57 2.45 2.36 2.31 2.26 2.23 2.20 2.18 2.16 2.14 2.13 2.12 2.11 2.10 2.09 2.09 2.08 2.07 2.07 2.06 2.06 2.06 2.05 2.05 2.04 2.04 2.02 2.00 1.98 1.96
6.31 2.92 2.35 2.13 2.02 1.94 1.90 1.86 1.83 1.81 1.80 1.78 1.77 1.76 1.75 1.75 1.74 1.73 1.73 1.72 1.72 1.72 1.71 1.71 1.71 1.71 1.70 1.70 1.70 1.70 1.68 1.67 1.66 1.65
Confidence level α 0.90 0.80 3.08 1.89 1.64 1.53 1.48 1.44 1.42 1.40 1.38 1.37 1.36 1.36 1.35 1.34 1.34 1.34 1.33 1.33 1.33 1.32 1.32 1.32 1.32 1.32 1.32 1.32 1.31 1.31 1.31 1.31 1.30 1.30 1.29 1.28
The distribution function f (t) is shown in Fig. 11.9 for several different degrees of freedom ν. The degrees of freedom equal the number of independent measurements employed in the determination. It is evident that, as ν becomes large, Student’s t distribution approaches the normal distribution. One-side areas for the t distribution are listed in Table 11.6 and illustrated in Fig. 11.10.
1.376 1.061 0.978 0.941 0.920 0.906 0.896 0.889 0.883 0.879 0.876 0.873 0.870 0.868 0.866 0.865 0.863 0.862 0.861 0.860 0.859 0.858 0.858 0.857 0.856 0.856 0.855 0.855 0.854 0.854 0.851 0.848 0.845 0.842
0.75
0.70
0.60
0.55
1.000 0.816 0.765 0.741 0.727 0.718 0.711 0.706 0.703 0.700 0.697 0.695 0.694 0.692 0.691 0.690 0.689 0.688 0.688 0.687 0.686 0.686 0.685 0.685 0.684 0.684 0.684 0.683 0.683 0.683 0.681 0.679 0.677 0.674
0.727 0.617 0.584 0.569 0.559 0.553 0.549 0.546 0.543 0.542 0.540 0.539 0.538 0.537 0.536 0.535 0.534 0.534 0.533 0.533 0.532 0.532 0.532 0.531 0.531 0.531 0.531 0.530 0.530 0.530 0.529 0.527 0.526 0.524
0.325 0.289 0.277 0.271 0.267 0.265 0.263 0.262 0.261 0.260 0.260 0.259 0.259 0.258 0.258 0.258 0.257 0.257 0.257 0.257 0.257 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.256 0.255 0.254 0.254 0.253
0.158 0.142 0.137 0.134 0.132 0.131 0.130 0.130 0.129 0.129 0.129 0.128 0.128 0.128 0.128 0.128 0.128 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.127 0.126 0.126 0.126 0.126
The term t(α)Sx¯ in (11.19) represents the measure from the estimated mean x¯ to one or the other of the confidence limits. This term may be used to estimate the sample size required to produce an estimate of the mean x¯ with a specified reliability. Noting that one-half of the bandwidth of the confidence interval is δ = t(α)Sx¯ and using (11.17), it is apparent that the sample size is given
Part A 11.3
ν
270
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 11.4
Student's t 10 9 8 7 α = 0.001 6 5 0.01 4 0.02 3 0.05 2 0.1 1 0 2 4 6 8 10
Since t(α) depends on n, a trial-and-error solution is needed to establish the sample size n needed to satisfy the specifications. For the data of Table 11.1, n = 40: therefore ν = 39 and t(α) = t(0.995) = 2.71 from Table 11.6. The value t(α) = t(0.995) is used since 0.5% of the distribution must be excluded on each end of the curve to give a two-sided area corresponding to a reliability of 99%. Substituting into (11.21) yields 2.71(2.25) 2 = 12.00 . n= 1.76 12
14 16 18 20 Degrees of freedom ν
Fig. 11.10 Student’s t statistic as a function of the degrees of freedom ν with α as the probability of exceeding t as a parameter
by n=
t(α)Sx¯ δ
2 .
(11.21)
The use of (11.21) can be illustrated by considering the data in Table 11.1, where Sx = 15.51 MPa and x¯ = 1214.2 MPa. If this estimate of μ is to be accurate to ±1% with a reliability of 99%, then δ = (0.01)(176.1) = 12.14 MPa .
This result indicates that a much smaller sample than 40 will be sufficient. Next try n = 12, ν = 11, and t(α) = 3.11; then 3.11(2.25) 2 = 15.80 . n= 1.76 Finally, with n = 15, ν = 14, and t(α) = 2.98; then 2.98(2.25) 2 n= = 14.50 . 1.76 Thus, a sample size of 15 would be sufficient to ensure an accuracy of ±1% with a confidence level of 99%. The sample size of 40 listed in Table 11.1 is too large for the degree of accuracy and confidence level specified. This simple example illustrates how sample size can be reduced and cost savings effected by using statistical methods.
11.4 Comparison of Means Because Student’s t distribution compensates for the effect of small sample bias and converges to the normal distribution for large samples, it is a very useful statistic in engineering applications. A second important application utilizes the t distribution as the basis for a test to determine if the difference between two means is significant or due to random variation. For example, consider the yield strength of a steel determined with a sample size of n 1 = 20 which gives x¯1 = 540.6 MPa, and Sx1 ¯ = 41.65 MPa. Suppose now that a second sample from another supplier is tested to determine the yield strength and the results are n 2 = 25, x¯1 = 562.6 MPa, and Sx2 ¯ = 38.34 MPa. Is the steel from the second supplier superior in terms of yield strength? The standard deviation of can be expressed the difference in means S(x2− ¯ x1) ¯
as
2 S(2x2− ¯ x1) ¯ = Sp
1 1 + n1 n2
= Sp2
n1 + n2 , n1n2
(11.22)
where Sp2 is the pooled variance, which can be expressed as Sp2 =
2 + (n − 1)S2 (n 1 − 1)Sx1 2 x2 . n1 + n2 − 2
(11.23)
The statistic t can be computed from the expression t=
|x¯2 − x¯1 | . S(x2− ¯ x1) ¯
(11.24)
A comparison of the value of t determined from (11.24) with a value of t(α) obtained from Table 11.6 provides
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
a statistical basis for deciding whether the difference in means is real or due to random variations. The value of t(α) to be used depends upon the degrees of freedom ν = n 1 + n 2 − 2 and the level of significance required. Levels of significance commonly employed are 5% and 1%. The 5% level of significance means that the probability of a random variation being taken for a real difference is only 5%. Comparisons at the 1% level of significance are 99% certain; however, in such a strong test, real differences can often be attributed to random error.
11.5 Statistical Safety Factor
In the example being considered, (11.23) yields = 20.68 MPa, Sp2 = 230.1 MPa, (11.22) yields S(2x2− ¯ x1) ¯ and (11.24) yields t = 1.848. For a 5% level of significance test with ν = 43 and α = 0.05 (the comparison is one-sided, since the t test is for superiority), Table 11.6 indicates that t(α) = 1.68. Because t > t(α), it can be concluded with a 95% level of confidence that the yield strength of the steel from the second supplier was higher than the yield strength of steel from the first supplier.
zR =
x¯S − x¯σ , SS−σ
where SS−σ =
SS2 − Sσ2
R (%)
zR
R (%)
zR
50 90 95 99
0 1.288 1.645 2.326
99.9 99.99 99.999 99.9999
3.091 3.719 4.265 4.753
Stress
Strength
(11.25)
Region of failure
(11.26)
and the subscripts ‘S’ and ‘σ’ refer to strength and stress, respectively. The reliability associated with the value of z R determined from (11.25) may be determined from a table showing the area A(z R ) under a standard normal distribution curve by using: R = 0.5 + A(z R ) .
Table 11.7 Reliability R as a function of the statistic z R
(11.27)
Typical values of R as a function of the statistic z R are given in Table 11.7. The reliability determined in this manner incorporates a safety factor of 1. If a safety factor of N is to be specified together with a reliability, then (11.25)
Fig. 11.11 Superimposed normal distribution curves for strength and stress showing the region of failure
and (11.26) are rewritten to give a modified relation for z R as x¯S − N x¯ σ zR = , SS2 + Sσ2
(11.28)
which can be rearranged to give the safety factor N as 1 x¯S − z R SS2 + Sσ2 . N= (11.29) x¯σ
Part A 11.5
11.5 Statistical Safety Factor In experimental mechanics, it is often necessary to determine the stresses acting on a component and its strength in order to predict whether failure will occur or if the component is safe. The prediction can be a difficult if both the stress σij , and the strength S y , are variables since failure will occur only in the region of overlap of the two distribution functions, as shown in Fig. 11.11. To determine the probability of failure, or conversely, the reliability, the statistic z R is computed by using the equation
271
272
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
11.6 Statistical Conditioning of Data
Part A 11.7
Previously it was indicated that measurement error can be characterized by a normal distribution function and that the standard deviation of the estimated mean Sx¯ can be reduced by increasing the number of measurements. In most situations, sampling cost places an upper limit on the number of measurements to be made. Also, it must be remembered that systematic error is not a random variable; therefore, statistical procedures cannot serve as a substitute for precise accurately calibrated and properly zeroed measuring instruments. One area where statistical procedures can be used very effectively to condition experimental data is with the erroneous data point resulting from a measuring or recording mistake. Often, this data point appears questionable when compared with the other data collected, and the experimentalist must decide whether the deviTable 11.8 Deviation ratio DR0 used for statistical conditioning of data Number of measurements n
Deviation ratio DR0
Number of measurements n
Deviation ratio DR0
4 5 7 10 15
1.54 1.65 1.80 1.96 2.13
25 50 100 300 500
2.33 2.57 2.81 3.14 3.29
ation of the data point is due to a mistake (and hence should be rejected) or due to some unusual but real condition (and hence should be retained). A statistical procedure known as Chauvenet’s criterion provides a consistent basis for making the decision to reject or retain such a point from a sample containing several readings. Application of Chauvenet’s criterion requires computation of a deviation ratio (DR) for each data point, followed by comparison with a standard deviation ratio DR0 . The standard deviation ratio DR0 is a statistic that depends on the number of measurements, while the deviation ratio DR for a point is defined as xi − x¯ . (11.30) DR = Sx The data point is rejected when DR > DR0 and retained when DR ≤ DR0 . Values for the standard deviation ratio DR0 are listed in Table 11.8. If the statistical test of (11.30) indicates that a single data point in a sequence of n data points should be rejected, then the data point should be removed from the sequence and the mean x¯ and the standard deviation Sx should be recalculated. Chauvenet’s method can be applied only once to reject a data point that is questionable from a sequence of points. If several data points indicate that DR > DR0 , then it is likely that the instrumentation system is inadequate or that the process being investigated is extremely variable.
11.7 Regression Analysis Many experiments involve the measurement of one dependent variable, say y, which may depend upon one or more independent variables, x1 , x2 , . . ., xk . Regression analysis provides a statistical approach for conditioning the data obtained from experiments where two or more related quantities are measured.
11.7.1 Linear Regression Analysis Suppose measurements are made of two quantities that describe the behavior of a process exhibiting variation. Let y be the dependent variable and x the independent variable. Because the process exhibits variation, there is not a unique relationship between x and y, and the data, when plotted, exhibit scatter, as illustrated
in Fig. 11.12. Frequently, the relation between x and y that most closely represents the data, even with the scatter, is a linear function. Thus Yi = mxi + b ,
(11.31)
where Yi is the predicted value of the dependent variable yi for a given value of the independent variable xi . A statistical procedure used to fit a straight line through scattered data points is called the least-squares method. With the least-squares method, the slope m and the intercept b in (11.31) are selected to minimize the sum of the squared deviations of the data points from the straight line shown in Fig. 11.12. In utilizing the leastsquares method, it is assumed that the independent
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
variable x is free of measurement error and the quantity Δ2 = (yi − Yi )2 (11.32)
y = mx + b
(a)
0
0
x1
(b)
distribution of y is a measure of the correlation. When the dispersion is small, the correlation is good and the regression analysis is effective in describing the variation in y. If the dispersion is large, the correlation is poor and the regression analysis may not be adequate to describe the variation in y. The adequacy of regression analysis can be evaluated by determining a correlation coefficient R2 that is given by the expression n − 1 {y2 } − m{xy} 2 , (11.34) R = 1− n −2 {y2 }
where {y2 } = y2 − ( y)2 /n and {xy} = xy −
( x) ( y)/n. When the value of the correlation coefficient R2 = 1, perfect correlation exists between y and x. If R2 equals zero, no correlation exists and the variations observed in y are due to random fluctuations and not Table 11.9 Probability of obtaining a correlation coefficient R2 due to random variations in y
y = mx + b
x
Fig. 11.12 Linear regression analysis is used to fit a leastsquares line through scattered data points
Probability 0.02
n
0.10
0.05
5 6 7 8 10 15 20 30 40 60 80 100
0.805 0.729 0.669 0.621 0.549 0.441 0.378 0.307 0.264 0.219 0.188 0.168
0.878 0.811 0.754 0.707 0.632 0.514 0.444 0.362 0.312 0.259 0.223 0.199
0.934 0.882 0.833 0.789 0.716 0.592 0.516 0.423 0.367 0.306 0.263 0.235
0.01 0.959 0.917 0.874 0.834 0.765 0.641 0.561 0.464 0.403 0.337 0.291 0.259
Part A 11.7
posed on the linear regression graph
y
0
x
Fig. 11.13 Distribution of y at a fixed value of x superim-
Solving (b) for m and b yields
x y − n xy and m = 2
x − n x2
y−m x b= (11.33) , n where n is the number of data points. The slope m and intercept b define a straight line through the scattered data points such that Δ2 is minimized. In any regression analysis it is important to establish the correlation between x and y. Equation (11.31) does not predict the exact values that were measured, because of the variation in the process. To illustrate, assume that the independent quantity x is fixed at a value x1 and that a sequence of measurements is made of the dependent quantity y. The data obtained would give a distribution of y, as illustrated in Fig. 11.13. The dispersion of the
0
273
y
is minimized at fixed values of x. After substituting (11.31) into (11.32), the minimization process of Δ2 implies that ∂Δ2 ∂ = (yi − mx − b)2 = 0 , ∂b ∂b ∂Δ2 ∂ = (yi − mx − b)2 = 0 . ∂m ∂m Differentiating yields 2 (yi − mx − b) (−x) = 0 , 2 (yi − mx − b) (−1) = 0 .
11.7 Regression Analysis
274
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
changes in x. Because random variations in y exist, a value of R2 = 1 is not obtained even if y(x) is linear. To interpret correlation coefficients 0 < R2 < 1, the data in Table 11.9 is used to establish the probability of obtaining a given R2 due to random variations in y. As an example, consider a regression analysis with n = 15, which gives R2 = 0.65 as determined by (11.34). Reference to Table 11.9 indicates that the probability of obtaining R2 = 0.65 due to random variations is slightly less than 1%. Thus one can be 99% certain that the regression analysis represents a true correlation between y and x.
Part A 11.7
11.7.2 Multivariate Regression Many experiments involve measurements of a dependent variable y that depends upon several independent variables x1 , x2 , x3 , . . . , etc. It is possible to represent y as a function of x1 , x2 , x3 , . . . , by employing the multivariate regression equation Yi = a + b1 x1 + b2 x2 + . . . + bk xk ,
(11.35)
where a, b1 , b2 , . . . , bk are regression coefficients. The regression coefficients a, b1 , b2 , . . . , bk are determined by using the method of least squares in a manner similar to that employed for
linear regression analysis where the quantity Δ2 = (yi − Yi )2 is minimized. Substituting (11.32) into (11.35) yields Δ2 =
(yi − a − b1 x1 − b2 x2 − . . . − bk xk )2 . (11.36)
∂Δ2 =2 (yi − a − b1 x1 − b2 x2 ∂bk − . . . − bk xk )(−xk ) = 0 .
(11.37)
Equation (11.37) leads to the following set of k + 1 equations, which can be solved for the unknown regression coefficients a, b1 , b2 , . . . , bk , an + b1 x 1 + b2 x 2 + . . . bk xk = yi , a x 1 + b1 x12 + b2 x 1 x 2 + . . . bk x1 xk = yi x1 , x 1 x 2 + b2 x22 + . . . bk x2 xk a x 2 + b1 = yi x2 , .. .
x k + b1 = yi xk .
a
x 1 x k + b2
x 2 x k + . . . bk
xk2
(11.38)
The correlation coefficient R2 is again used to determine the degree of association between the dependent and independent variables. For multiple regression equations, the correlation coefficient R2 is given as n −1 R2 = 1 − n −k 2 {y } − b1 {yx 1 } − {yx 2 } − . . . − {yx k } , × {y2 } (11.39)
Differentiating yields ∂Δ2 =2 (yi − a − b1 x1 − b2 x2 ∂a − . . . − bk xk )(−1) = 0 , ∂Δ2 =2 (yi − a − b1 x1 − b2 x2 ∂b1 − . . . − bk xk )(−x1 ) = 0 , ∂Δ2 (yi − a − b1 x1 − b2 x2 =2 ∂b2 − . . . − bk xk )(−x2 ) = 0 , .. .
where
y xk yx k − {yx k } = and n 2 y y2 − . {y2 } = n This analysis is for linear, noninteracting, independent variables; however, the analysis can be extended to include cases where the regression equations would have higher-order and cross-product terms. The nonlinear terms can enter the regression equation in an additive manner and are treated as extra variables. With well-established computer routines for regression analysis, the set of (k + 1) simultaneous equations given by (11.38) can be solved quickly and inexpensively. No significant difficulties are encountered in adding extra terms to account for nonlinearities and interactions.
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
where
11.7.3 Field Applications of Least-Square Methods
Linear Least-Squares Method Consider a calibration model in photoelasticity and write the equation for the fringe order N(x, y) as
N(x, y) =
h G(x, y) + E(x, y) , fσ
E(x, y) = Ax + By + C .
(b)
h G(x, y) + Axk + Byk + C . fσ
(11.40)
Note that (11.40) is linear in terms of the unknowns (h/ f σ ), A, B, and C. For m selected data points, with m > 4, an overdeterministic system of linear equations results from (11.40). This system of equations can be expressed in matrix form as N = aw ,
⎛
The solution of the set of m equations for the unknowns h/ f σ , A, B, and C can be achieved in a least-squares sense through the use of matrix methods. Note that a N = cw , where c = a a , and that w = c−1 a N , where c−1 is the inverse of c. Solution of the matrix w gives the column elements, which are the unknowns. This form of solution is easy to accomplish on a small computer which can be programmed to perform the matrix manipulations. The matrix algebra outlined above is equivalent to minimizing the cumulative error E squared which is E=
For any selected point (xk , yk ) in the field, Nk is determined by N(x, y) =
⎛ ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ G 1 x1 y1 1 N1 h/ f σ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ G 2 x2 y2 1⎟ ⎜ N2 ⎟ A ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟w = ⎜ a = N=⎜ ⎜ ⎟. ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎝ B ⎠ ⎝ . ⎠ ⎝ . ⎠ C G m xm ym 1 Nm
(a)
where G(x, y) is the analytical representation of the difference of the principal stresses (σ1 − σ2 ) in the calibration model, h is the model thickness, f σ is the material fringe value, and E(x, y) is the residual birefringence. Assume a linear distribution for E(x, y) which can be expressed as
275
Part A 11.7
The least-squares method is an important mathematical process used in regression analysis to obtain regression coefficients. Sanford [11.12] showed that the leastsquares method could be extended to field analysis of data obtained with optical techniques (photoelasticity, moiré, holography, etc.). With these optical methods, a fringe order N, related to a field quantity such as stress, strain, or displacement, can be measured at a large number of points over a field (x, y). The applications require an analytical representation of the field quantities as a function of position (x, y) over the field. Several important problems including calibration, fracture mechanics, and contact stresses have analytical solutions where coefficients in the governing equations require experimental data for complete evaluation. Two examples will be described which introduce both the linear and nonlinear least-squares method applied over a field (x, y).
11.7 Regression Analysis
2 m h G(xk , yk ) + Ax k + Byk + C − Nk . fσ k=1
(11.41)
The matrix operations apply the least-squares criteria, which require that ∂E ∂E ∂E ∂E = = = =0. ∂(h/ f σ ) ∂A ∂B ∂C
(11.42)
The advantage of this statistical approach to calibration of model materials in optical arrangements is the use of full field data to reduce errors due to discrepancies in either the model materials or the optical systems. Nonlinear Least-Squares Method In the preceding section a linear least-squares method provided a direct approach to improving the accuracy of calibration with a single-step computation of an overdeterministic set of linear equations. In other experiments involving either the determination of unknowns arising in stresses near a crack tip or contact stresses near a concentrated load, the governing equations are nonlinear in terms of the unknown quantities. In these cases, the procedure to be followed involves linearizing the governing
276
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 11.7
equations, applying the least-squares criteria to the linearized equations, and finally iterating to converge to an accurate solution for the unknowns. To illustrate this statistical approach, consider a photoelastic experiment that yields an isochromatic fringe pattern near the tip of a crack in a specimen subjected to mixed-mode loading. In this example, there are three unknowns K I , K II , and σ0x , which are related to the experimentally determined fringe orders Nk at positions (rk , θk ). The governing equation for this mixed-mode fracture problem is 1 N fσ 2 = (K I sin θ + 2K II cos θ)2 h 2πr + (K II sin θ)2 θ 2σ0x sin K I sin θ(1 + 2 cos θ) +√ 2 2πr 2 . + K II (1 + 2 cos2 θ + cos θ) + σ0x
In matrix form the set of m equations represented by (11.46) can be written as f = aΔK , where the matrices are defined as ⎛ ⎞ f1 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ f2 ⎟ ⎟ f =⎜ ⎜ .. ⎟ , ⎝ . ⎠ fm ⎛ ⎞ ∂ f 1 /∂K I ∂ f 1 /∂K II ∂ f 1 /∂σ0x ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ∂ f 2 /∂K I ∂ f 2 /∂K II ∂ f 2 /∂σ0x ⎟ ⎟, a=⎜ .. ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ ⎠ . ∂ f m /∂K I ∂ f m /∂K II ∂ f m /∂σ0x ⎛ ⎞ ΔK I ⎜ ⎟ ΔK = ⎝ΔK II ⎠ . Δσ0x
(11.43)
Equation (11.43) can be solved in an overdeterministic sense, by forming the function f (K I , K II , σ0x ) as 1 (K I sin θk + 2K II cos θk )2 f k (K I , K II , σ0x ) = 2πrk 2σ0x θk + (K II sin θk )2 + √ sin 2 2πrk · K I sin θk (1 + 2 cos θk ) + K II (1 + 2 cos2 θk + cos θk ) Nk f σ 2 2 − =0, + σ0x h (11.44)
where k = 1, 2, 3, . . . m and (rk , θk ) are coordinates defining a point on an isochromatic fringe of order Nk . A Taylor series expansion of (11.44) yields: ∂ fk ∂ fk ΔK I + ΔK II ( f k )i+1 = ( f k )i + ∂K I i ∂K II i ∂ fk + Δσ0x , (11.45) ∂σ0x i where i refers to the i-th iteration step and ΔK I , ΔK II , and Δσ0x are corrections to the previous estimate of ΔK I , ΔK II , and Δσ0x . It is evident from (11.45) that corrections should be made to drive f (K I , K II , σ0x ) toward zero. This fact leads to the iterative equation ∂ fk ∂ fk ∂ fk ΔK I + ΔK II + Δσ0x ∂K I i ∂K II i ∂σ0x i = −( f k )i . (11.46)
(11.47)
The least-squares minimization process is accomplished by multiplying, from the left, both sides of (11.47) by the transpose of matrix a, to give a f = a aΔK or d = cΔK , where d = a f c = a a . Finally, the correction terms are given by: ΔK = c−1 d .
(11.48)
The solution of (11.48) gives ΔK I , ΔK II , and Δσ0x , which are used to correct initial estimates of K I , K II , and σ0x and obtain a better fit of the function f k (K I , K II , σ0x ) to m data points. The procedure is executed on a small computer programmed using MATLAB. One begins by assuming initial values for K I , K II , and σ0x . Then, the elements of the matrices f and a are computed for each of the m data points. The correction matrix ΔK is then computed from (11.48) and finally the estimates of the unknowns are corrected by noting that (K I )i+1 = (K I )i + ΔK I , (K II )i+1 = (K II )i + ΔK II , (σ0x )i+1 = (σ0x )i + Δσ0x .
(11.49)
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
The procedure is repeated until each element in the correction matrix ΔK becomes acceptably small. As convergence is quite rapid, the number of iterations re-
11.8 Chi-Square Testing
277
quired for accurate estimates of the unknowns is usually small.
11.8 Chi-Square Testing The chi-square (χ 2 ) test is used in statistics to verify the use of a specific distribution function to represent the population from which a set of data has been obtained. The chi-square statistic χ 2 is defined as k (n o − n e )2 ne
i=1
,
(11.50)
where n o is the actual number of observations in the i-th group interval, n e is the expected number of observations in the i-th group interval based on the specified distribution, and k is the total number of group intervals. The value of χ 2 is computed to determine how closely the data fits the assumed statistical distribution. If χ 2 = 0, the match is perfect. Values of χ 2 > 0 indicate the possibility that the data are not represented by the specified distribution. The probability p that the value of χ 2 is due to random variation is illustrated in Fig. 11.14. The degree of freedom is defined as ν = n −k ,
(11.51)
κ2 30 or
re c
t
Hypothesis not correct
tc
25
no
P = 0.1
pr ob
ab ly
P = 0.01
No reason to reject hypothesis
Table 11.10 Chi-squared χ 2 computation for grouped ulti-
yp
ot
he
sis
is
20
mate tensile strength data
H
15
P = 0.9
10 ta Da
5
sus
pec
t
to as
og
o
od
P = 0.99
Data may be falsified
0
0
5
10 15 20 25 Number of degrees of freedom ν
Fig. 11.14 Probability of χ 2 values exceeding those shown,
as a function of the number of degrees of freedom
Group interval 0 − 170.9 171 − 172.9 173 − 174.9 175 − 176.9 177 − 178.9 179 − 180.9 180 − ∞
Number observed 1 2 8 16 9 3 1
Number expected 0.468 2.904 9.096 13.748 9.836 3.360 0.588
(no − ne )2 /ne 0.604 0.281 0.132 0.369 0.071 0.039 0.289 1.785 = χ 2
Part A 11.8
χ2 =
where n is the number of observations and k is the number of conditions imposed on the distribution. As an example of the χ 2 test, consider the ultimate tensile strength data presented in Table 11.1 and judge the adequacy of representing the ultimate tensile strength with a normal probability distribution described with x¯ = 1214.2 MPa and Sx = 15.51 MPa. By using the properties of a normal distribution function, the number of specimens expected to fall in any strength group can be computed. The observed number of specimens in Table 11.1 exhibiting ultimate tensile strengths within each of seven group intervals, together with the computed number of specimens in a normal distribution in the same group intervals, are listed in Table 11.10. The computation of the χ 2 value (χ 2 = 1.785) is also illustrated in the table. The number of groups is n = 7. Because the two distribution parameters x¯ and Sx were determined by using these data, k = 2; therefore, the number of degrees of freedom is ν = n − k = 7 − 2 = 5. Plotting these results (ν = 5 and χ 2 = 1.785) in Fig. 11.14 shows that the point falls in the region where there is no reason to expect that the hypothesis in not correct. The hypothesis is to represent the tensile strength with a normal probability function. The χ 2 test does not prove the validity of this hypothesis, but instead fails to disprove it. The lines dividing the χ 2 − ν graph of Fig. 11.14 into five different regions are based on probabilities
278
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
Part A 11.9
of obtaining χ 2 values greater than the values shown by the curves. For example, the line dividing the regions marked “no reason to reject hypothesis” and “hypothesis probably is not correct” has been selected at a probability level of 10%. Thus, there is only one chance in 10 that data drawn from a population correctly represented by the hypothesis would give a χ 2 value exceeding that specified by the p > 0.10 curve. The “hypothesis rejected region” is defined with the p > 0.01 curve indicating only one chance in 100 of obtaining a χ 2 value exceeding those shown by this curve. The χ 2 function can also be used to question if the data have been adjusted. Probability levels of 0.90 and 0.99 have been used to define regions where data is suspected as too good and data may be falsified. For the latter classification there are 99 chances out of 100 that the χ 2 value will exceed that determined by a χ 2 analysis of the data. The χ 2 statistic can also be used in contingency testing where the sample is classified under one of two categories – pass or fail. Consider, for example, an inspection procedure with a particular type of strain gage where 10% of the gages are rejected due to etching imperfections in the grid. In an effort to reduce this rejection rate, the manufacturer has introduced new
Table 11.11 Observed and expected inspection results Group interval
Number observed
Number expected
(no − ne )2 /ne
Passed Failed
1840 160
1800 200
0.89 8.00 8.89 = χ 2
clean-room techniques that are expected to improve the quality of the grids. On the first lot of 2000 gages, the failure rate was reduced to 8%. Is this reduced failure rate due to chance variation, or have the new clean-room techniques improve the manufacturing process? A χ 2 test can establish the probability of the improvement being the result of random variation. The computation of χ 2 for this example is illustrated in Table 11.11. Plotting the results from Table 11.11 on Fig. 11.14 after noting that ν = 1 shows that χ 2 = 8.89 falls into the region “hypothesis is not correct”. In this case the hypothesis was that there has been no improvement. The χ 2 test has shown that there is less than one chance in a 100 of the improvement in rejection rate (8% instead of 10%) being due to random variables. Thus, one can conclude with confidence that the new clean-room techniques were effective in improving yield.
11.9 Error Propagation Previous discussions of error have been limited to error arising in the measurement of a single quantity: however, in many engineering applications, several quantities are measured (each with its associated error) and another quantity is predicted on the basis of these measurements. For example, the volume V of a cylinder could be predicted on the basis of measurements of two quantities (diameter D and length L). Thus, errors in the measurements of diameter and length will propagate through the governing mathematical formula V = π DL/4 to the quantity (volume, in this case) being predicted. Because the propagation of error depends upon the form of the mathematical expression being used to predict the reported quantity, standard deviations for several different mathematical operations are listed below. For addition and/or subtraction of quantities (y = x1 ± x2 ± . . . ± xn ), the standard deviation S y¯ of the mean y¯ of the projected quantity y is given by 2 + S2 + . . . + S2 . (11.52) S y¯ = Sx1 x2 xn ¯ ¯ ¯
For multiplication of quantities (y = x1 x2 . . . xn ), the standard deviation S y¯ is given by 2 S S2¯ S2¯ ¯ + x2 + . . . + xn . S y¯ = (x¯1 x¯2 . . . x¯n ) x1 2 2 x¯n2 x¯1 x¯2 (11.53)
For division of quantities (y = x1 /x2 ), the standard deviation S y¯ is given by 2 2 Sx2 S¯ x¯1 ¯ S y¯ = x1 + . x¯2 x¯12 x¯22
(11.54)
For calculations of the form (y = x1k ), the standard deviation S y¯ is given by S y¯ = k x¯1k−1 Sx1 ¯ .
(11.55)
Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data
For calculations of the form (y = x 1/k ), the standard deviation S y¯ is given by 1/k
x¯ S y¯ = 1 Sx1 . k x¯ 1 ¯
(11.56)
Consider for example a rectangular rod where independent measurements of its width, thickness, and length have yielded x¯1 = 40 with Sx1 ¯ = 0.10, x¯2 = 10 with Sx2 ¯ = 0.04, and x¯3 = 330 with Sx3 ¯ = 0.8, where all dimensions are in millimeters. The volume of the bar is V = x¯1 x¯2 x¯3 .
= (40)(10)(330) (0.10)2 (0.04)2 (0.8)2 × + + (40)2 (10)2 (330)2 = (132)(5.303) = 700 mm3 This determination of S y¯ for the volume of the bar can be used together with the properties of a normal probability distribution to predict the number of bars with volumes within specific limits. The method of computing the standard error of a quantity S y¯ as given by (11.52)–(11.56), which are based on the properties of the normal probability distribution function, should be used where possible. However, in many engineering applications, the number of measurements that can be made is small; therefore, the data x¯1 , x¯2 , . . . , x¯n and Sx1 ¯ , Sx2 ¯ , . . . , Sxn ¯ needed for statistical based estimates of the error are not available. In these instances, error estimates can still be made but the results are less reliable. A second method of estimating error when data are limited is based on the chain rule of differential calculus. For example, consider a quantity y that is a function
of several variables y = f (x1 , x2 , . . ., xn ) .
(11.57)
Differentiating yields ∂y ∂y ∂y dx 1 + dx 2 + . . . + dx n . (11.58) dy = ∂x1 ∂x2 ∂xn In (11.58), dy is the error in y and dx1 , dx2 , . . ., dxn are errors involved in the measurements of x1 , x2 , . . ., xn . The partial derivatives ∂y/∂x1 , ∂y/∂x2 , . . ., ∂y/∂xn can be determined exactly from (11.57). Frequently, the errors dx1 , dx2 , . . ., dxn are estimates based on the experience and judgment of the test engineer. An estimate of the maximum possible error can be obtained by summing the individual error terms in (11.58). Thus ∂y ∂y ∂y dx 1 + dx 2 + . . . + dx n . dy max = ∂x1 ∂x2 ∂xn (11.59)
Equation (11.59) gives a worst-case estimate of error, because the maximum errors dx1 , dx2 , . . . , dxn are assumed to occur simultaneously and with the same sign. A more realistic equation for estimating error is obtained by squaring both sides of (11.58) to give n ∂y 2 2 (dxi )2 (dy) = ∂xi i=1 n ∂y ∂y + dx i dx j , (11.60) ∂xi ∂x j i=1, j=1
where i = j. If the errors dxi are independent and symmetrical with regard to positive and negative values then the cross-product terms will tend to cancel and (11.60) reduces to dy = 2 2 2 ∂y ∂y ∂y dx 1 + dx 2 + . . . + dx n . ∂x1 ∂x2 ∂xn (11.61)
References 11.1 11.2 11.3
R.M. Bethea, R.R. Rhinehart: Applied Engineering Statistics (Dekker, New York 1991) J.T. McClave, T. Sincich: Statistics, 10th edn. (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River 2006) A. Agresti, C. Franklin: Statistics: The Art and Science of Learning from Data (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River 2006)
279
11.4
11.5 11.6
R. Hogg, A. Craig, J. McKean: Introduction to Mathematical Statistics, 6th edn. (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River 2005) P.S. Mann: Introductory Statistics, 5th edn. (Wiley, New York 2005) D.L. Harnett, J.F. Horrell: Data, Statistics and Decision Models with EXCEL (Wiley, New York 1998)
Part A 11
The standard error of the volume can be determined by using (11.53). Thus, 2 2 2 S Sx2 Sxn ¯ ¯ ¯ S y¯ = (x¯1 x¯2 . . . x¯ n ) x1 + + . . . + x¯n2 x¯12 x¯22
References
280
Part A
Solid Mechanics Topics
11.7
11.8 11.9 11.10
G.W. Snedecor, W.G. Cochran: Statistical Methods, 8th edn. (Iowa State Univ. Press, Ames 1989) W.C. Navidi: Statistics for Engineers and Scientists (McGraw-Hill, New York 2006) H. Pham (Ed.): Springer Handbook of Engineering Statistics (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg 2006) W. Weibull: Fatigue Testing and Analysis of Results (Pergamon, New York 1961)
11.11 11.12
11.13
J.S. Milton, J.C. Arnold: Introduction to Probability and Statistics (McGraw-Hill, New York 2006) R.J. Sanford: Application of the least squares methods to photoelastic analysis, Exp. Mech. 20, 192–197 (1980) J.R. Sanford, J.W. Dally: A general methods for determining mixed-mode stress intensity factors from isochromatic fringe patterns, Eng. Fract. Mech. 11, 621–633 (1979 )
Part A 11
281
Part B
Contact M Part B Contact Methods
12 Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages Robert B. Watson, Raleigh, USA 13 Extensometers Ian McEnteggart, Buckinghamshire, UK 14 Optical Fiber Strain Gages Chris S. Baldwin, Lanham, USA 15 Residual Stress Yuri F. Kudryavtsev, Markham, Canada 16 Nanoindentation: Localized Probes of Mechanical Behavior of Materials David F. Bahr, Pullman, USA Dylan J. Morris, Gaithersburg, USA 17 Atomic Force Microscopy in Solid Mechanics Ioannis Chasiotis, Urbana, USA
283
Robert B. Watson
The bonded resistance strain gage is an analog electrical sensor ideally suited to the task of measuring surface stains on solid materials. The two most common devices are the popular etched-foil sensor, and the somewhat more exotic semiconductor gage. Etched foil strain gages are produced with thin foil (typically 5 µm) bonded to a thin insulating carrier (typically 25 µm). Semiconductor gages are produced from a semiconductor material (typically 0.1 mm-thick silicon), commonly with an insulating carrier, but often bonded directly to a specimen. Strain gages work on the same principle as engineering strain; i. e., a starting gage length is deformed to a final gage length with a corresponding change in electrical resistance proportional to the deformation. Foundational characteristics, including sensitivity, thermal response, and limiting properties, and use of these sensors in experimental stress analysis applications, including shear measurement, thermal expansion measurement, and principal strain measurement, are reviewed. Electrical circuits used in the interrogation of strain gages are discussed, along with special considerations and exploitation of specific circuit arrangements for solving unique problems. Potential error sources and correction techniques for both the sensors and circuits are covered.
The present-day incarnation of the ubiquitous electrical resistance strain gage, the ancestral wire version of which was invented independently in the late 1930s by Ed Simmons at the California Institute of Technology and Arthur Ruge at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, from principles first discovered by Lord Kelvin in 1856, has become the de facto standard for the study of material deformations, be it a quick check, or an ex-
12.1 Standardized Strain-Gage Test Methods . 284 12.2 Strain and Its Measurement .................. 284 12.3 Strain-Gage Circuits .............................. 12.3.1 Elementary Circuits ..................... 12.3.2 The Potentiometer Circuit ............ 12.3.3 The Wheatstone Bridge Circuit .....
285 285 286 287
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage.................. 12.4.1 Manufacturing ........................... 12.4.2 Gage Factor – A Practical Theory... 12.4.3 Strains from Every Direction......... 12.4.4 Gage Factor – The Manufacturer’s Value ............ 12.4.5 Transverse Sensitivity Error – Numerical Examples ................... 12.4.6 The Influence of Temperature Changes.............. 12.4.7 Control of Foil Strain Gage Thermal Output 12.4.8 Foil Strain Gages and the Wheatstone Bridge ......... 12.4.9 Performance Characteristics ......... 12.4.10 Gage Selection Procedure ............ 12.4.11 Specific Applications ...................
291 291 292 294
303 306 310 312
12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages .................. 12.5.1 Manufacturing ........................... 12.5.2 Strain Sensitivity ........................ 12.5.3 Temperature Sensitivity .............. 12.5.4 Special Circuit Considerations ...... 12.5.5 Installation Techniques...............
325 325 327 328 331 332
295 296 297 302
References .................................................. 332
haustive research. Prior to the invention of the bonded wire strain gage, Charles Kearns of Hamilton Standard produced a crude version of the modern-day strain gage in 1936 by cementing flattened carbon composition resistor elements to a propeller blade [12.1]. These devices, though suited only for dynamic measurements due to their inherent lack of electrical resistance stability, were instrumental in the solving of aircraft propeller
Part B 12
Bonded Elect
12. Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
284
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.2
blade failures. Kearns notes that in-flight propeller blade failures went from as many as 41 in the early 1930s, to zero in 1940. Development in 1952 of today’s familiar etched-foil strain gage is attributed to the Saunders-Roe Company in the United Kingdom [12.2]. During its 70-plus year history, many technical articles, textbooks, and manufacturer’s white papers have been dedicated to the examination and use of these simple looking sensors. Even a cursory review of, say, the Society for Experimental Mechanics (SEM) archives will provide clear conformation of the intense scrutiny
and study to which these little devices have been subjected, particularly during the formative years of both the society and the sensor. This chapter attempts to briefly convey information on foundational characteristics and use, in specific experimental stress analysis applications, of electrical resistance strain gages, specifically the foil type and its cousin, the semiconductor strain gage, which is discussed last. An idiomatic distinction between these two sensor types could be that the former is electric in nature, and the latter electronic.
12.1 Standardized Strain-Gage Test Methods Fig. 12.1 Strain-gage layout and nomenclature
Bars: 45° axes alignment marks
End loops Gage length
Triangles: Grid center alignment marks
End loops Transition
Outer grid lines Inner grid lines
Overall pattern length
Solder tab length
Solder tab width Tab spacing Grid width
Outer line width Inner line width Space width
Engineering data supplied with each package of strain gages is critical to the successful use of the gages in accurate determination of specimen strains. A few standards organizations around the globe have produced documents detailing a format for uniform data collection and/or presentation. Among others, these include the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM E 251) [12.3], the Organisation Internationale de Metrologie Legale (OIML International Recommendation no. 62) [12.4], and the German Standards (VDI/VDE 2635) [12.5]. The following sections will draw heavily on the data supplied by manufacturers. To provide for a common terminology within this chapter, typical strain-gage structure and nomenclature are given in Fig. 12.1.
12.2 Strain and Its Measurement Strain gages provide for the determination of surface strains beneath the active measuring area of the gage (gage length × grid width). Thus, it is best to begin with a definition of exactly what is being measured. There are several accepted variations on the definition of strain, each having a particular applicability to a given study. The most commonly accepted definition used in the practice of experimental stress analysis is called engineering strain and is defined as the change in length of a prescribed initial length ε=
(L 1 − L 0 ) ΔL = , L0 L
(12.1)
where ε is the engineering strain (m/m, or some other dimensionless length unit), L 1 the final length (m) and L 0 is the initial length = L(m). Strain gages work in precisely the manner defined by engineering strain. The gage has an initial length (L 0 ) and when stretched (e.g., with the specimen to which it is attached), a final length (L 1 ). Fortuitously, as the conductor of the gage changes length, there is a corresponding change in resistance. It is this resistance change that is measurable and relatable to engineering strain.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
12.3 Strain-Gage Circuits
Common to both types of strain gages that will be discussed (etched-foil and semiconductor) are the electrical circuits used to interrogate them. These circuits become a significant part of the measurement system and will be discussed before gage characteristics proper. Stretching an electrical conductor causes its resistance to change. A full explanation and derivation of this behavior will be presented in later sections specific to the foil strain gage and the semiconductor gage, but to study circuits used with strain gages it is helpful to keep in mind that applied strain causes the gage to change resistance. It is the function of the circuit to ascertain these resistance changes, which provides for the measurement of strain. Any electrical circuit which can determine resistance of a conductor is a candidate for use with strain gages, but the minute resistance changes involved require sensitive and stable systems. For typical bonded foil gages used in stress analysis applications, there is approximately a 2 μΩ/Ω change in resistance per 1 μm/m (με) of applied strain (note that μm/m and με are used interchangeably). For typical semiconductor gages, this sensitivity can increase to over 100 μΩ/Ω /με, which somewhat simplifies the resistance measurement task. Most commonly, either the simple potentiometer circuit, or the Wheatstone bridge circuit are chosen to interrogate strain gages, but even more elementary circuits will suffice.
12.3.1 Elementary Circuits Electrical resistance is related to voltage (V ) and current (I ) by Ohm’s law, V = IR, indicating that resistance measurement is accomplished using either a reference voltage or reference current. Each method is illustrated in Fig. 12.2. As suggested by the figures, applying either a constant voltage or constant current across a strain gage a)
E =Vc
b)
Rg+ΔRg I0 -ΔI
E 0 +ΔE Rg+ΔRg
Ic Vc
Ic
Fig. 12.2a,b Elementary circuit arrangements: (a) constant voltage, (b) constant current
and ascertaining changes to these quantities as the gage resistance changes with applied strained, the resistance change can be related to the strain which causes it. The simple ohm-meter is the most basic form of this circuit; and, an ohm-meter can serve as a strain-gage instrument, but the resolution and accuracy of strains calculated from resistance data aquired this way are questionable. However, an inexpensive strain gage instrument can be built using a simple personal-computer-based ohm-meter board, whereby the computer can serve as both the data acquisition and data analysis system. Constant-Voltage Excitation Referring to Fig. 12.2a, if a constant-voltage power supply Vc is connected across a single strain gage Rg , according to Ohm’s law there will be an initial current flow I0 through the unstrained gage prescribed by
I0 =
E0 . Rg
(12.2)
For an increase in gage resistance, the current through the gage will drop from I0 to I0 − ΔI , given by I0 − ΔI =
E0 . Rg + ΔRg
(12.3)
Substituting E 0 = I0 Rg and solving for the relative change in current yields ΔRg Rg 1 ΔI . = R (12.4) = ΔR g I0 +1 1+ g ΔRg
Rg
Equation (12.4) shows that the relative change in current for the constant-voltage circuit is a nonlinear function of the relative change in gage resistance. Later it will be shown that, in the elastic-stress region of the gage, resistance change is a linear function of strain. Therefore, in the constant-voltage circuit, the relative current change is a nonlinear function of strain, which is an obvious disadvantage to using this circuit. Use of constant voltage across the strain gage produces a current-sensitive circuit. As such, there are limitations imposed on resolution by the self-heating effect of electrical current passing through the gage. While using a high voltage is beneficial to extracting the best resolution, the allowable safe power density in the gage restricts this available benefit. Thus, the circuit is most useful with gages of lower resistance and higher
Part B 12.3
12.3 Strain-Gage Circuits
285
Contact Methods
Part B 12.3
strain sensitivity. As is discussed in Sect. 12.5.4, even though semiconductor gages satisfy the sensitivity requirement, use of constant-voltage excitation with these sensors causes other problems. Constant-Current Excitation In like manner to the analysis of the constant-voltage circuit, the same procedure is applied to constantcurrent excitation (Fig. 12.2b). In this circuit ΔI = 0 at all times, and there is a change in voltage drop across the gage as its resistance changes with applied strain. By measuring this voltage drop, the change in resistance, and hence the applied strain, can be determined. From Ohm’s law
E 0 + ΔE = Ic (Rg + ΔRg ) .
(12.5)
Noting that Ic = I0 , and substituting (12.2) into (12.5) and simplifying yields ΔRg ΔE = . E0 Rg
(12.6)
From this expression it should be clear that the change in potential across a gage is linear with the unit resistance change of the gage, and hence with applied strain. Equation (12.6) also demonstrates that the constantcurrent circuit maximizes efficiency, since the unit voltage drop is precisely equivalent to the unit change in gage resistance, which suggests, with everything else equal, that gages of highest resistance and highest strain sensitivity will produce the highest measurement resolution. However, since the applied current must remain small ( 0.1 A) to avoid destructive self-heating in the gage, the output signal of the constant-current circuit is low, typically, on the order of μV, and this is on top of the source voltage, which is normally several volts.
12.3.2 The Potentiometer Circuit The potentiometer circuit shown schematically in Fig. 12.3 essentially combines both of the elementary circuits described above, or at least provides for similar operation to both. The primary benefits from studying this circuit come from the fact that it is simple to construct, versatile in use, and a second strain gage can be used in place of the ballast resistor Rb , which under certain measurement conditions allows for improved signal level and/or temperature compensation. In general, however, the potentiometer circuit suffers from the same low-level signal which plagues the elementary circuits. Since semiconductor gages can have over 50 times the strain sensitivity of foil gages,
I Rb C Vc or Ic E 0 +ΔE
Part B
Rg +ΔRg
286
Rm
E
Fig. 12.3 Potentiometer circuit arrangement showing capacitor-coupled output and display meter resistance
and since they are also prone to very high temperature sensitivity, this circuit is an attractive choice. Like the elementary circuits, perhaps the greatest limitation of the potentiometer circuit comes from the large common-mode voltage inherent in its output, consigning its use to dynamic applications. As depicted in Fig. 12.3, the potentiometer circuit has only three major components 1. the power source (either constant voltage or constant current) 2. the ballast resistor 3. the strain gage The circuit can be operated in either constantvoltage or constant-current mode and one benefit is that, regardless of mode, the output signal is a change in voltage, which somewhat simplifies its measurement. In addition to the three major components in the potentiometer circuit, adding an output circuit with capacitive coupling (also shown in the figure) separates the high-level direct-current (DC) voltage component present due to the voltage source from the low-level voltage changes produced by changes in gage resistance. Of course, this additional RC circuit relegates its use to dynamic strains above the low-frequency cutoff value, f c = 1/(2π Rm C). A device for capturing and displaying the output voltage from the circuit is also necessary, which can have a significant effect on the resolution, speed, and accuracy of the readings. With either mode of excitation, to avoid resistively loading the measurement circuit, it is beneficial to have a capture/display device with high impedance (Rm ) so as not to load the measurement circuit.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
E0 =
Rg Vc . Rg + Rb
(12.7)
Letting r = Rb /Rg , the change in output voltage caused by resistance changes in both the ballast resistor and strain gage can be written as ΔRg ΔRb r ΔE = − (12.8) (1 − η) , Vc Rb (1 + r)2 Rg where η = 1−
1+
1 1+r
1 ΔRg Rg
b − r ΔR Rb
.
(12.9)
The term η contains the nonlinear component of the output. If the ballast resistor is a matching strain gage to Rg , mounted on an unstrained sample of the same material and experiencing the same temperature profile as Rg , then it can be shown that this circuit achieves temperature compensation of the strain-gage temperature response. Also, if the ballast gage sees equal and opposite strain levels, the circuit output is doubled. However, note that the nonlinear term in (12.9) is largest when r = 1. Constant-Current Excitation By replacing the constant-voltage source (e.g., battery) with a constant-current source, the potentiometer circuit can be operated in constant-current mode. In this case, the ballast resistor is superfluous, since setting Rb = 0 does not change circuit performance. The voltage across the strain gage obeys Ohm’s law (12.2). Thus, going through the same derivation used with the elementary circuit arrives at the same expression for relative change in voltage drop across the gage
ΔRg ΔE = . E0 Rg
12.3.3 The Wheatstone Bridge Circuit As noted previously, even though the potentiometer circuit has several benefits, the drawback of having a large common-mode voltage on top of a small signal voltage makes its use impractical for static strain measurements, except in rare cases when used with semiconductor gages. Even then, separating ΔE from E 0 + ΔE is troublesome. By far the most common electrical circuit used with strain gages, and forming the basis of strain-gage instrumentation, is the Wheatstone bridge. Samuel Hunter Christie invented what was called the diamond method in 1833 and used the technique to compare resistances of wires with different thicknesses. The method went mostly unrecognized until 1843, when Charles Wheatstone proposed it in a paper to the Royal Society, for measuring resistance in electrical circuits. Although presented clearly as Christie’s invention, it was Wheatstone’s name that became associated with the bridge. As he used it, the bridge consisted of four resistors, a battery, and a galvanometer; he called it a differential resistance measurer; this same configuration is quite adequate for a simple straingage circuit. Wheatstone is also responsible for the curious habit of drawing the bridge in its familiar diamond shape. In developing the resistance equations particular to the bridge, it is helpful to begin with a battery power supply and galvanometer readout, and then discuss the influences of using more sophisticated supplies and electronic meters. This simple circuit is depicted in Fig. 12.4, where R1 , R2 , R3 , and R4 are the four arms of the bridge, Rm is the meter resistance, Rb represents the resistance of the battery circuit, plus any appreciaRb
B
1
2
Rm (12.10)
The meter resistance, effectively Rm in Fig. 12.3, can desensitize changes in gage resistance by shunting the gage. Two important benefits from using constantcurrent excitation with a high-impedance recorder instrument are, (1) reducing this shunting effect, and, (2) providing insensitivity of the circuit output to leadwire resistance.
V
E A
C
E0
4
3
D
Fig. 12.4 Basic Wheatstone bridge circuit including battery resistance Rb
287
Part B 12.3
Constant-Voltage Excitation For constant-voltage operation, a simple dry-cell battery is an excellent power source, providing an inexpensive alternative to high-end power supplies. For the unloaded, open-circuit output voltage, obtained when the meter resistance Rm is infinite,
12.3 Strain-Gage Circuits
288
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.3
ble leadwire resistance in series with the battery, and i b and i m are the battery and meter currents, respectively. It can be shown that for small unbalances of the bridge, the value of Rb does not appreciably influence the effective bridge resistance as presented to the meter. Therefore, an expression for the current sensed by the meter can be written as Em , (12.11) im = R + Rm where R is the effective bridge-circuit resistance as presented to the meter and is found by writing the total resistance for a pair of parallel circuits connected in series, as shown in Fig. 12.5. Thus R=
R2 R3 R1 R4 + . R1 + R4 R2 + R3
(12.12)
The voltage presented at the terminals of the meter is then R1 R2 − (12.13) , Em = E R1 + R4 R2 + R3 or written as the relative change in voltage Em R1 R3 − R2 R4 = . E (R1 + R4 )(R2 + R3 )
(12.14)
From this equation, it should be clear that the bridge output is zero when R1 × R3 = R2 × R4 .
(12.15)
Under this condition, the bridge is said to be balanced, which is important because it means the small voltage output caused by slight changes in resistance to one of the resistor elements (e.g., a strain gage) can be measured from a zero, or near-zero, starting condition. This small signal is then easily amplified for subsequent processing or recording. The voltage applied to the bridge E depends on the supply-circuit resistance (i. e., the resistance in series R1
R2
R4
R3 R
Fig. 12.5 Wheatstone bridge total resistance as presented
to an output meter
with the bridge and the voltage supply, and any internal battery resistance if a battery is used as the supply) and the total bridge resistance as presented to the power supply. For small unbalances, the bridge resistance as presented to the power source is Rc =
(R1 + R4 )(R2 + R3 ) . R1 + R4 + R2 + R3
(12.16)
Equation (12.16) evinces the series/parallel circuit arrangement of the two branches in a Wheatstone bridge (BAD and BCD in Fig. 12.4), hence, series resistors (R1 + R4 ) in parallel with series resistors (R2 + R3 ). The flow of voltage through this arrangement is described in the next section. It follows that the voltage applied to the bridge is then E=V
Rc . Rc + Rb
(12.17)
For the typical supply voltage used with strain gages (≈ 5–10 V), the useable bridge-output resolution is in the μV range, which prescribes a high-sensitivity meter for suitable display. Because the meter deflection, as dictated by (12.11), is based upon determination of the meter current, the circuit is said to be current sensitive. If the output is indicated with a high-impedance device, such as an electronic voltmeter or oscilloscope, current flow in the output circuit is essentially zero, because Rm → ∞ and i m → 0. But there can still be a resistive unbalance condition at the meter terminals, represented by the voltage across corners A and C of the bridge. In this case, the arrangement is called a voltage-sensitive deflection-bridge circuit [12.6], and the voltage indication is calculated by (12.13). Of course, the battery can be replaced by a constantvoltage power supply to achieve the same result, with the additional benefit of providing a zero, or near-zero, source resistance. Furthermore, given an essentially zero source resistance, the voltage applied to the bridge is equal to the power-source voltage. In application of the Wheatstone bridge with strain gages, the change in bridge output voltage caused by the change in gage(s) resistance(s) is the desired indication of strain. The exact bridge-output equations are particular to the arrangement and number of gages in the bridge, and these equations are provided in Sect. 12.4.8. However, the general expressions for constant-voltage and constant-current operation do illuminate differences between these types of excitation, which will now be discussed.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
R2 R1 = =r . R4 R3
(12.18)
As the gages are strained (and change resistance), the relative incremental gage output from (12.14) is
then that, when ΔR1 = ΔR3 = −(ΔR2 = ΔR4 ), the nonlinearity term is zero. Constant-Current Excitation Employing a constant-current power supply in place of a battery or constant-voltage supply converts the bridge into a current-dividing circuit, thus
I = I1 + I2 and its operation is governed by Ohm’s law, such that E m = I 1 R1 − I 2 R4 = I
(12.23)
which has the same balance condition as given in (12.15). The change in bridge output due to resistance changes in the bridge arms may be expressed as ΔE
r ΔE = E (1 + r)2 ΔR1 ΔR2 ΔR3 ΔR4 × − + − (1 − η) , R1 R2 R3 R4
=I
where 1
⎛ 1+⎝
1+r ΔR1 R1
ΔR3 ΔR4 2 + r ΔR R2 + r R3 + R4
a)
⎞.
R1 R3 R1 +ΔR1 +R2 +ΔR2 +R3 +ΔR3 +R4 +ΔR4 ΔR1 R1
R1
⎠
(12.24)
R2 Balance control
(12.20)
For the special case of all four gages having the same resistance Rg then r = 1 and (12.19) and (12.20) reduce to 1 ΔR1 − ΔR2 + ΔR3 − ΔR4 ΔE (1 − η) , = E 4 Rg
R4
R3
Amplifier
b)
R1
E
Display
R2
(12.21)
1 η= . 2Rg 1+ ΔR1 + ΔR2 + ΔR3 + ΔR4
ΔR3 ΔR1 ΔR3 ΔR4 2 − ΔR R2 + R3 − R4 + R1 R3 4 . − ΔRR22 ΔR R4
×
(12.19)
η=
R1 R3 − R2 R4 , R1 + R2 + R3 + R4
(12.22)
Equations (12.21) and (12.22) are the elementary bridge equations for constant-voltage excitation of the Wheatstone bridge circuit. The nonlinearity term η will be zero under the simultaneous conditions of ΔR1 = −ΔR4 and ΔR2 = ΔR3 = 0. Likewise, the term will be zero when ΔR2 = −ΔR3 and ΔR1 = ΔR4 = 0. It follows
E R4
R3
Amplifier
Display
Voltage injection circuit
Fig. 12.6 Two popular circuit arrangements for commer-
cial strain-gage instruments
289
Part B 12.3
Constant-Voltage Excitation Employing a constant-voltage power supply mimics the general analysis presented above, when a battery was the considered supply. Referring to Fig. 12.4, an input voltage is applied across the power corners (BD) and divided between the parallel circuits (BAD and BCD) through the series resistances (R1 + R4 ) and (R2 + R3 ), providing an output across the signal corners (AC) that is a function of the input voltage and the individual arm resistances. If the bridge is initially balanced, or nearly balanced, an output voltage ΔE is developed when any one of the four arms of the bridge changes resistance. Rearranging (12.15),
12.3 Strain-Gage Circuits
290
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.3
Examination of (12.19) and (12.24) for small resistance changes reveals that the bridge outputs are similar with either excitation. Using constant-current power is preferred because the output linearity error is roughly half that experienced when using constant-voltage excitation, which for large strains (i. e., large unequal changes in arm resistance) is an obvious plus. Practical Considerations Its simple construction and high resolution make the Wheatstone bridge circuit a popular choice for many commercial strain-gage instruments (e.g., two arrangements are shown in Fig. 12.6). Constant-voltage excitation is most commonly used. The bridge circuit is operated in either a balanced or unbalanced mode. For balanced circuits, the bridge arms are resistively symmetric about an axis bisecting the output corners of the bridge, such that
R1 R4
=1= nom
R2 R3
.
(12.25)
nom
The linearity error exists when resistance conditions in the bridge arms cause unequal changes in the currents through the arms. Given these asymmetrical current changes, the voltage output of the bridge is not proportional to the resistance changes and thus the bridge output is nonlinear with strain and the instrument indication is in error. Fortunately, this error is ordinarily small and can usually be ignored when measuring elastic strains in metals. However, the percentage error increases with the magnitude of strain being measured and can become significant at large strains. For example, in a quarter-bridge circuit the error is about 0.1% at 1000 με, 1% at 10 000 με, and 10% at 100 000 με (or, as a convenient rule of thumb, the error in percent is approximately equal to the strain, in percent, for quarter-bridge measurements). Considering the 50-fold strain sensitivity increase with semiconductor gages, it should be evident that, when operated in the unbalanced condition, large errors in the strain data will be contributed by the bridge nonlinearity. Therefore, special consideration must be given when using the Wheatstone bridge with these unique sensors, which is discussed in Sect. 12.5.
Nonlinearity Errors. One benefit of the balanced, con-
stant-voltage Wheatstone bridge circuit is the equal current flow through both branches of the bridge, which introduces no linearity error to the bridge output. In what’s called a quarter-bridge strain-gage circuit, the strain gage forms one arm of the bridge and fixed or variable resistors make up the other three arms. It should be obvious that, even if the circuit is initially balanced, as the gage changes resistance with strain, the bridge becomes unbalanced. Rarely, a static strain indicator works on the principle of rebalancing the bridge by adjusting a variable resistance in the adjacent arm, whereby the amount of resistance necessary to bring the bridge output to zero is the indication of strain. Under this condition, there is no linearity error associated with the bridge output. Most often, the Wheatstone bridge circuit found in commercial strain indicators is operated in an unbalanced mode. Even when voltage injection circuits are used, where the bridge output voltage is nulled by an equal and opposite voltage injected into the measurement circuit (amplifier), the bridge is resistively unbalanced and the linearity error is present. Voltage injection is frequently used to zero a strain indicator prior to starting a test. Note from Fig. 12.6 that in both circuits the balance control used to obtain an initial zero reading is outside the bridge, which indicates that, even with a balanced output condition, the bridge can be resistively unbalanced.
Noise Control. Electrical noise is a frequently encoun-
tered nuisance during strain-gage measurements. Some common causes are thermoelectric voltages (thermocouple effect at electrical junctions), high-frequency (and energy-level) radio waves, alternating-current (AC) or direct-current (DC) motors, florescent lights, and welding machines. Less common are exotic sources such as high-intensity x-rays or nuclear radiation. For sound data, it is important to recognize and eliminate noise. When using the Wheatstone bridge, disconnecting the power source is a simple and effective way of finding self-generating noise. With no power applied, obviously the bridge has no input with which to operate normally. Therefore, an output signal present when no power is applied must be caused by something other than strain or temperature acting on the bridge resistances (strain gages). If the observed noise signal is in strain units, it can simply be algebraically subtracted from acquired strain data, but the best course of action is to eliminate the signal altogether by removing the cause and/or shielding the strain gage, leadwires, and instrumentation system. For convenience in applying this noise detection method, most modern commercial strain-gage instrumentation has the function of disconnecting the power from the bridge circuit.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
As previously alleged, strain gages do not actually report strain, but work through electrical circuits to relate a measured resistance value to the coercing strain. Therefore, it is important to understand the accomplishment of this transformation, as well as the circuits used for interrogation. During this study, certain influences on the basic resistance parameter other than strain will be encountered, and these too must be understood, so they can either be eliminated or compensated, or perhaps even exploited to our benefit, leaving only our intended measurement goal: accurately attaining the mechanical strain present in the test specimen, underneath the strain gage.
12.4.1 Manufacturing Some early bonded metallic electrical-resistance strain gages were produced by unwrapping the fine wire found inside a wire-wound resistor and forming that wire into a sinuous pattern on a piece of cigarette paper, affixing the wire to the paper with Duco cement. This paper gage was then bonded to the surface of a test piece, again with Duco cement. So then, how hard can it be to manufacture strain gages? Actually, if the experimental conditions are favorable (laboratory environment, stable room temperature, reasonable strain level – not too high, nor too low – uniform uniaxial stress field, etc.) and especially if the desired accuracy from the measurement is modest, say no better than around 15% uncertainty, then it is not at all difficult to produce something which will work. However, to achieve the precision measurements available from the modern strain gage demands exacting production methods and calibration procedures. The production requirement of primary interest to a user of strain gages is consistency, because a purchased gage is not the one calibrated by the manufacturer. Therefore, it is only through excellent repeatability in the production process that sufficient consistency in the finished product allows the extraordinarily precise measurements available today. The simplistic appearance of modern foil strain gages is somewhat deceiving. Included in each gage is a wealth of engineering expertise. From the choice and formulation of the insulating carrier, to the adhesive which holds the highly processed foil in place, every element and production step can influence the ability of the finished product to accurately sense and respond to strain. Every manufacturer has highly detailed and pro-
prietary procedures for achieving the desired result. Foil is especially noteworthy. Modern strain-gage construction, particularly modern foil technology, provides the almost mindless ability to achieve better than 5% uncertainty strain data [12.7]. The two most common foils used in strain gages are a copper–nickel alloy, usually called constantan, and a nickel–chrome alloy, which is a modified version of the trademarked name Karma (here forward referred to as just karma). Of these two, constantan is by far the most used. Foils are chosen first for their processibility (for example, chemical machinability); second for the ability to satisfy a particular test specification (for example, stability and survivability of a temperature profile, or ability to withstand high elongation without failure or appreciable change in performance properties); third for the ability to respond to thermal and mechanical processing, which allows matching to a specific test specimen material for greatest stability and ease of use by removing the requirement for minute attention to details such as precise knowledge of test temperature; and finally the foil must also satisfy the resistivity requirements by allowing designs for desirable resistances in a suitable size, which typically requires the metal to be rolled to a gage as thin as 2.5 μm. At the forefront of all foil requirements is the demand for consistency and repeatability in performance properties, such as temperature response and fatigue. The proceeding is only a cursory list of foil requirements. Next, the foil must be attached to a carrier. Referring to Fig. 12.7, manufacturers start with a thin insulating layer. Any suitably thin, flexible material is a candidate, and over the years everything from paper to highly formulated, reinforced epoxyphenolic has been used. Today, use of polyimides Overlay Adhesive Foil Adhesive Backing Adhesive
Specimen Fig. 12.7 Schematic of strain-gage construction stack and
attachment to specimen
Part B 12.4
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
291
292
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
environment. In fact, to expect the best results from every step of the strain gage manufacturing and testing process, the facility must be hospital clean.
12.4.2 Gage Factor – A Practical Theory In 1856 William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) discovered the basis of operation for resistance strain gages: stretching a metal wire changes its electrical resistance. This relationship between change in wire length and change in resistance can be derived from the expression for the resistance of a metal conductor as a function of its dimensions and resistivity L (12.26) , A where R is the conductor resistance (Ω), ρ is the resistivity (Ω cm), L is the conductor length (cm), and A is the conductor area (cm2 ). Differentiating (12.26) with respect to resistance gives R = ρ×
Fig. 12.8 Section from a finished plate of foil strain gages
and epoxy-based materials is most common. Typically, this insulating layer (often called the backing) is 12.5–50 μm thick. The processed foil is attached to the backing with an adhesive chosen to provide the best solution for a given set of problems. For example, upper temperature limit, maximum elongation, maximum fatigue, cost, or flexibility. Once the foil is attached, the finished basic, as it is normally called, is put through a photolithography process to image the desired pattern onto the foil and then machine the image into the foil. What remains is called a plate of gages, an example of which is shown in Fig. 12.8. Chemical machining is the most common method of forming strain-gage patterns in the foil. However, some foils, like platinum–tungsten, require other techniques, such as ion milling. At this stage, the plate is ready for secondary processing, which includes resistance adjustment to a specified value with tight tolerance (usually better than 0.5%). Additional features can be added, such as solder options and protective encapsulation. At the end of the production process, the individual gages are cut from the plate and go through a stringent quality-control (QC) process, ensuring that all manufacturing specifications have been met. Included in the QC procedure is the necessary calibrations (gage factor, transverse sensitivity, temperature response, and so on) needed for strain measurement. Finally, the finished gages are packaged with the information needed for successful use in experimental mechanics. To ensure the highest production standards, all primary and secondary work is conducted in a clean-room
dρ dL dA dR = + − . R ρ L A Recognizing that, for elastic deformation, 2 dA dL 2 dL = −2ν +ν A L L
(12.27)
(12.28)
and, ignoring the higher-power term and substituting (12.28) into (12.27), dL dρ dR = (1 + 2ν) + . R L ρ
(12.29)
Equation (12.29) shows that the relative change in resistance for a metal conductor is controlled by two separate parameters. The first term is a function of the conductor geometry and the second term is a function of the conductor material. Recognizing that, in the limit, the relative change in length term ( dL/L) is equivalent to the axial strain εx (12.1), and dividing (12.29) by εx , yields dρ/ρ dR/R = (1 + 2ν) + . εx εx
(12.30)
Observing that accurate calculation of the second term in (12.30) is impossible, because the term is itself a function of strain, then this equation suggests that, in order to obtain strain readings from resistance measurements, calibration is required. This calibration is performed by measuring the relative change in resistance of a strain gage stretched by a reference strain
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
dR/R =F, εx
(12.31)
where F is the calibrated strain sensitivity of the strain gage, called the gage factor. An interesting deduction can be attained by substituting the conductor volume, V = AL, into (12.26) and essentially going through the same derivation as before, arriving at the result dρ dL dV dR = +2 − . R ρ L V
(12.32)
From (12.32), several different assumptions and approaches can be taken towards further derivation of a sensitivity expression, all subject to the fact that, in plastic deformation, volume does not change ( dV/V = 0). Regardless of the chosen approach, the end result is the same: under plastic deformation, the strain sensitivity of a metal conductor is, theoretically, close to 2. The importance of this conclusion should be obvious. It demonstrates that, to achieve a high degree of linearity over the largest range of deformation, strain sensitivity in the elastic range should to be as close to 2 as possible; this is indeed the case for the two most popular strain gage alloys: constantan and karma. While the previous simplistic analysis arrives at some interesting and useful conclusions, accurate gage factor calibration is a difficult task and demands certain compromises and bounding conditions. If not properly considered during the analysis of strain data, some of the necessary restrictions for running this calibration can subtly influence strain measurement results, possibly causing erroneous test conclusions.
Fig. 12.9 Gage factor measuring system per ASTM E 251
guidelines
Manufacturers adjust gages to a desired resistance with low uncertainty. For proper operation, the actual starting value is unimportant, but strain gage instrumentation is frequently built to accept predetermined resistance inputs. Typical gage resistance values offered by manufacturers are 120, 350, and 1000 Ω, and straingage instrumentation commonly accepts these initial resistances. These package resistance values can be shifted slightly during the gage installation process, but most strain gage instrumentation have adequate balance range to re-zero normal offsets caused by installation. This balanced value is then used as the reference for subsequent changes in resistance caused by strain (R and ΔR, respectively from (12.31)), or by other effects. To achieve accurate strain measurements, it is necessary to know with sufficient accuracy the relationship between applied strain and the resulting changes in gage resistance. From (12.31), it should be obvious that a critical element in the gage factor test is the applied strain. Unlike many other engineering parameters, there has never been an accepted standard for generating and precisely measuring strain. However, several researchers have addressed this void and have developed techniques for generating a single strain value in tension and in compression of approximately 1000 με with sufficient precision to allow gage factor uncertainties of 0.5% or better [12.8, 9]. These techniques are then used to verify a manufacturer’s gage factor measurement system. Figure 12.9 shows a test system used for determination of the gage factor. This system supplies a uniform, biaxial strain to gages attached to the constant-stress tapered steel cantilever beam. This system has the benefit of providing convenient determination of gage factor in both tension and compression, which is important because the two values are usually slightly different. The difference is small, normally 0.2% or less, and manufacturers normally report a single-value average of the two. In the following discussion, other subtleties of gage factor and its measurement are presented. Gage factor values supplied with the gages (package value) are normally entered into strain-gage instrumentation to scale the instrument output in units of microstrain (μm/m). However, it is not necessary – or sometimes even possible – to use the package gage factor value. Often, the instrument gage factor is set to a convenient number, like 2.000. This would be necessary, for example, if gage types having different gage factors are connected to a single channel instrument through a switch unit. Regardless, the instrument read-
293
Part B 12.4
input. Thus,
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
294
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
ing can easily be corrected using the relationship Fi εa = εi × , (12.33) Fa where εa is the strain corrected for gage factor, εi the indicated strain from the instrument, Fi the gage factor set on the instrument, and Fa the package gage factor.
12.4.3 Strains from Every Direction Strain gages are designed and intended to allow accurate determination of the strain beneath the gage, in the direction of its primary measurement axis, which is the direction defined by the gage length (Fig. 12.1). Note that the derivation of (12.31) is not limited to a particular direction of the conductor; it is only based on the correct application of dimensional measurements in the direction of interest. Recognizing this, and noting that the initial starting resistance is not critical to strain measurement because the electrical measurement is relative to any starting value, imagine the sensing grid of a strain gage as a summing transducer, where each infinitesimal length of metal foil acts as its own gage length and initial resistance value, and consider the quasihomogeneity of the metal foil; it should be evident that deformation of the foil from any direction will cause changes in electrical resistance. Hence, the gage responds not only to strains in the intended direction, but also to strains from every direction. (Strain gages are also sensitive to strain normal to their plane, but for common stress analysis gages, this sensitivity is negligible when compared with the in-plane sensitivity.) Since strains acting at every angle between 0◦ and 90◦ to the primary sensing axis are simply cosine combinations of the two orthogonal values, to allow correction for off-axis strains it is only necessary to know the cross-direction contribution; specifically, it is only necessary to know the percentage cross-direction sensitivity, relative to the primary axis sensitivity. This percentage is termed the transverse sensitivity, and is generally written Ft × 100 , (12.34) Kt = Fa where K t is the transverse sensitivity in percent, Ft is the sensitivity in the direction 90◦ to the primary sensing axis, and Fa is the sensitivity in the direction of the primary sensing axis. The practical combinations of variables which influence the magnitude of transverse sensitivity are numerous and complicated. Several design and construction parameters/properties contribute, including
grid geometry, alloy, conductor geometry (wire versus foil), and the shear stress between the conductor and the bonding carrier (gage backing). For example, a single strand wire strain gage bonded to a specimen has essentially zero sensitivity in the cross-direction. A single-line metal foil gage bonded to a specimen has varying cross-sensitivity, dependent on the line width. For a given alloy, short gage length gages tend to have a more positive transverse sensitivity than longer gage length gages. Within a similar geometrical design, constantan foil gages will have a more positive transverse sensitivity than karma foil gages. While it is theoretically possible to design a metal foil strain gage with zero transverse sensitivity, the result would be impractical to produce and not necessarily the best strain sensor. Because of the aforementioned attributes, similar to gage factor, transverse sensitivity must be measured. Unlike gage factor, the calibration of transverse sensitivity requires the application of a uniaxial strain (not uniaxial stress). A device for producing the required strain is shown in Fig. 12.10, and a method for measuring and reporting transverse sensitivity, along with gage factor, is provided in [12.3]. While an explanation is beyond the scope of the present work, suffice to say that it is not possible to generate a uniaxial strain as precisely, consistently, and uniformly as a uniaxial stress, which is why gage factor calibration is performed using the latter, and also why transverse sensitivity calibration is typically an order of magnitude less certain than gage factor calibration. Note that the measurement beam in Fig. 12.10 is short and wide. Plates attached to each enlarged end of the beam supply a bending force. Sufficiently inward from the sides of the beam (≈ 25 mm), strain is purely unidirectional. A strain magnitude of +1000 μm/m is
Fig. 12.10 Typical test rig for measuring transverse sensi-
tivity per ASTM E 251 guidelines
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
Kt =
(ΔR/R)t × 100 , (ΔR/R)a
(12.35)
where K t is the transverse sensitivity in percent, (ΔR/R)t is the relative change in gage resistance in the transverse direction, and (ΔR/R)a is the relative change in gage resistance in the axial direction. When principal strain directions are unknown and multiple gages are installed at various angles to one another (e.g., a rosette gage; Sect. 12.4.10), it is almost certain that at least one grid will have a significant portion of a principal strain acting transverse to its measuring axis. If the transverse sensitivity of the gage elements in these gages is other than zero, the individual strain readings will be in error. From the standpoint of principal stress and principal strain calculation, one of the most convenient rosette arrangements is known as the rectangular rosette, where the grids are at 45◦ to one another. Correction for the effects of transverse sensitivity can be made either on the individual strain readings or on the calculated principal strains or principal stresses. Numbering the gage elements consecutively, elements 1 and 3 correspond directly to the two-gage 90◦ rosette and the same equations can be used for transverse sensitivity correction. The center grid of the rosette requires a unique correction relationship since there is no direct measurement of the strain perpendicular to this grid. The correction equations for all three grids are 1 − ν0 K t (ε1 − K t ε3 ) , 1 − K t2 1 − ν0 K t [ε2 − K t (ε1 + ε3 − ε2 )] , εˆ 2 = 1 − K t2 1 − ν0 K t (ε3 − K t ε1 ) , εˆ 3 = 1 − K t2 εˆ 1 =
(12.36) (12.37) (12.38)
where ε1,2,3 are the indicated strains from the respective grid elements and εˆ 1,2,3 are the corrected strains along the respective grid axes. It should be noted that (12.36–12.38) assume transverse sensitivity is the same, or effectively so, in all grid elements, which is often the case in stacked rosettes. This may not be true for planar rosettes, since each grid is oriented at a different angle with respect to the rolling direction of the foil used in making the gage.
However, even for planar rosettes, transverse sensitivity of the individual grids is normally close (and usually equal for at least grids 1 and 3) and a suitable average value for all grids can be used with these equations to provide adequate correction accuracy in most cases. For the fully general case of unequal transverse sensitivity among the grids, the reader is directed to Vishay Micro-Measurements [12.10].
12.4.4 Gage Factor – The Manufacturer’s Value With transverse sensitivity defined, perhaps it becomes clear that the manufacturer’s normal method of measuring gage factor in a uniaxial stress field yields a result dependent upon the Poisson’s ratio of the test beam. Strictly speaking, the manufacturer’s value is only valid on materials with the same Poisson’s ratio. Fortunately, ignoring this restriction normally results in a small error which can be disregarded for most stress analysis applications. However, if the material under test and the beam used to measure the gage factor have a significantly different Poisson’s ratio, or if appreciable transverse strains relative to the axial strains exist in the test part (i. e., biaxial loading), or the highest strain data accuracy is required, corrections should be made for transverse sensitivity. In general, then, a strain gage has two gage factors, Fa and Ft , which refer to the gage sensitivities as measured in a uniaxial strain field (not uniaxial stress) with, respectively, the gage axes aligned parallel to and perpendicular to the principal strain direction. For any strain field, the output of the strain gage can be expressed as ΔR (12.39) = Fa εa + Ft εt , R where εa is the strain parallel to the gage axis, εt is the strain perpendicular to the gage axis, Fa is the axial gage factor, and Ft is the transverse gage factor, or ΔR = Fa (εa + K t εt ) , R
(12.40)
where K t = FFat is the transverse sensitivity coefficient. When the gage is calibrated for gage factor in a uniaxial stress field on a material with Poisson’s ratio ν0 , εt = −ν0 εa . Therefore, ΔR = Fa (εa − K t ν0 εa ) , R
295
Part B 12.4
normally used. Test gages of the same type are bonded with their principal measurement axis parallel to and perpendicular to this applied strain, and gage sensitivity is measured in both directions. Transverse sensitivity is calculated and supplied as a percentage
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
296
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
or ΔR = Fa εa (1 − ν0 K t ) . R
(12.41)
Strain-gage manufacturers commonly write this as ΔR = Fε , R
(12.42)
where F is the manufacturer’s gage factor. This is deceptively simple in appearance, since, in reality F = Fa (1 − ν0 K t ) .
Error – % of axial strain 60 εt/εa = 5
50 –5 = εt/εa
4
–4
3
30 –3 20
–1
0
0
10
1
– 20
2
–2
+ 10
1 0 –1 –2
2 –3 3
30 40
εa
4
–4 –5
5
ϕε =
(12.43)
Furthermore, ε, as used by the manufacturer, is actually εa , the strain along the gage axis (and only one of two strains sensed by the gage during calibration) when the gage is aligned with the maximum principal stress axis in a uniaxial stress field, on a material with Poisson’s ratio equal to that of the beam used for gage factor calibration. Errors and confusion can occur due to failure to fully comprehend and always account for the real meanings of F and ε as they are used by manufacturers. To judge the effect on subsequent test data caused by the conditions present during gage factor calibration, it is important to recognize that, for a gage with
40
nonzero transverse sensitivity, there is always an error in the strain indication unless the gage is used under the exact same conditions present during gage factor calibration. In some instances, this error is small enough to ignore. In others, it is not. The error due to transverse sensitivity for a strain gage oriented at any angle, in any strain field, on any material, can be expressed as
εt
Kt
εt εa
+ ν0
1 − ν0 K t
,
(12.44)
where ϕε is the error (as a percentage of the actual strain along the gage axis), ν0 is the Poisson’s ratio of the material used by the manufacturer for gage factor calibration, and εa and εt , respectively, are the actual strains parallel and perpendicular to the primary sensing axis of the gage. For convenience in judging whether the error magnitude is significant for a particular test condition, (12.44) is plotted in Fig. 12.11.
12.4.5 Transverse Sensitivity Error – Numerical Examples The effects of transverse sensitivity should always be considered in measurement applications where the strain field and/or test material do not match that which was used during gage factor calibration. Either it should be demonstrated that the error associated with transverse sensitivity is negligible and can be ignored, or if not negligible the proper correction should be made. As a simple first example, consider a tension test on an unfilled plastic using a single linear gage. With the instrument gage factor set to match the package gage factor supplied by the manufacturer, the test parameters and strain indication are
• • • • •
plastic beam in tension ν = 0.48 K t = 2.9% ν0 = 0.285 εI = 1200 μm/m
50 60 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
–
+ Transverse sensitivity Kt (%)
Fig. 12.11 Error in indicated axial strain from transverse sensitivity for various ratios of principal strains
Equation (12.41) provides the specific relationship for relative resistance change of a strain gage in a uniaxial stress field for the particular case of ν0 (Poisson’s ratio for the gage factor calibration beam). This relationship can be generalized by substituting a generic ν for the specific ν0 . Further, solving (12.43) for Fa and
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
ΔR Fε(1 − νK t ) . = R 1 − ν0 K t
(12.45)
All Wheatstone-bridge-based strain-gage instrumentation work by the relationship ΔR (12.46) = Fεi , R where εi is the indicated strain as displayed or recorded by the instrumentation. Equating (12.45) and (12.46), εi = ε
1 − νK t . 1 − ν0 K t
(12.47)
Solving for the actual strain ε along the gage axis, 1 − ν0 K t (12.48) 1 − νK t and substituting the example numerical information, ε = εi
1 − 0.285(0.029) 1 − 0.48(0.029) = 0.0012 × 1.00574 = 1206.8 με
ε = 0.0012 ×
results in a possibly negligible error of less than 0.6% for this example. For a second example of correcting strain gage data for transverse sensitivity, assume a stacked rectangular rosette, with each grid in the rosette having a transverse sensitivity of +5%. After loading, the three strain-gage readings are εx = 856 μm/m , ε3 = 306 μm/m .
ε2 = 195 μm/m ,
All three indicated strains contain small errors caused by the transverse sensitivity of the sensing grids. Rather than develop the correction equations for each grid in the rosette and then correct each individual reading before substituting into the rosette data-reduction equations, a simpler technique is to calculate the principal strains from the uncorrected strain measurements, and then correct the principal strains. For this example, the principal strains calculated from the three strain measurements are εpr = 1053 μm/m,
εqr = 108 μm/m ,
where εpr and εqr are the raw and uncorrected principal strains, respectively. Since transverse sensitivity errors in the calculated principal strains reflect the same errors as the individual strain readings, and since the principal strains are
two perpendicular strains, they can be corrected using (12.36) and (12.37). Thus, ignoring the (1 − K t2 ) term in the denominator, since it is less than 0.25% away from unity, one obtains εp = (1 − ν0 K t )(εpr − K t εqr ) , εq = (1 − ν0 K t )(εqr − K t εpr ) .
(12.49) (12.50)
Using the transverse sensitivity value of +5% and assuming a Poisson’s ratio of 0.285 for the gage factor calibration beam, the corrected principal strains are calculated as εp = (1 − 0.285 × 0.05)(1053 − 0.05 × 108) = 1033 με , εq = (1 − 0.285 × 0.05)(108 − 0.05 × 1053) = 55 με .
12.4.6 The Influence of Temperature Changes Thus far, attention has been focused on the response of strain gages at temperatures close to normal laboratory environments (≈ 24 ◦ C). Of the possible stimuli responsible for causing resistance changes in metal conductors, and therefore in strain gages, temperature is by far the most impressive. A sufficient change in temperature can easily cause resistance changes much larger than those resulting from normal elastic deformations in metal specimens. Left unchecked, this bias in strain data renders test results, at the least meaningless, and often dangerous. Fortunately, the signal generated by temperature is additive to the signal generated by strain and can therefore effectively be corrected or compensated. To begin an examination of the effect temperature has on strain gage readings, consider that all three independent variables of conductor resistance in (12.26) are themselves functions of temperature. Metal conductors have a temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR), which causes their electrical resistance to change with temperature, and a temperature coefficient of expansion (TCE), which causes dimensional changes with temperature. Thus, it should be evident that, since (12.26) is used to derive (12.31), this relationship is also a function of temperature. Dependent on the alloy used to make a gage, strain sensitivity can either increase or decrease with a temperature rise. Manufacturers normally supply a room-temperature gage factor and a slope for percentage change in sensitivity per degree of temperature change, sometimes called the temperature coefficient
297
Part B 12.4
substituting into (12.41),
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
298
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
(TC) of gage factor, or just the TC of gage factor. When strain gages are used at temperatures other than that which the manufacturer used during gage factor calibration, a correction may be needed. Equation (12.33) serves this purpose. In using (12.33) to correct gage factor variation with temperature, Fa is the actual gage factor at the test temperature, not the package gage factor. If the test temperature is known in advance, the gage factor control on the strain indicator can initially be set at Fa and no further correction is necessary. When using this technique, it should be remembered that, if thermal output corrections (see later discussion) are to be made using the thermal output correction data supplied by the manufacturer, these correction data must be adjusted from the gage factor value used by the manufacturer to collect the data, if that value is different from Fa . As a brief numerical example, assume a roomtemperature gage factor of 2.05 and a TC of gage factor equal to − 1.0%/100 ◦ C. With the instrument set at the room-temperature gage factor value, the strain indication at +230 ◦ C is 1820 με. Then, the percentage change in gage factor is −0.01 × (230 − 24)/100 = −0.0206 , and the gage factor at the test temperature is Fa = 2.05(1 − 0.0206) = 2.01 . Substituting into (12.33) yields εa = 1820 ×
2.05 = 1856 με . 2.01
In addition to the temperature effect on sensitivity (TC of gage factor), there is also the more complicated combined affect from the TCR of the alloy used in the gage, and the TCE of the strain-gage system (metal foil, backing, adhesive, and specimen). Before analyzing these two effects on gage response, the question of why it is important to consider temperature changes in the first place should be answered, and one should also look at benefits the strain gage can provide when temperature does change during an experimental stress analysis. Subjected to a temperature change, all materials experience an associated dimensional change. If the material is unrestrained (free to expand without restraint), this dimensional change causes no corresponding stress in the material. Dependent on the material and temperature excursion, the deformation associated with a temperature change can be large when compared with
typical elastic strains in metals. If, for example, a traditional extensometer is used to measure strain during this temperature excursion, the reading will include not only the strain caused by any mechanical loading, but also the free expansion resulting from the temperatureinduced dimensional change. Typically, the only desired result from strain-gage measurements is the one relating solely to strain in the test specimen caused by mechanical loading (mechanical stress). However, like most sensors, strain gages are sensitive to many influences besides that which is intended, temperature being prominent. Unlike many other sensors (e.g., the extensometer just mentioned), strain gages can be tailored to minimize temperature response within a specific scope and, at the same time, compensate for the unimportant temperature-induced deformations in the test specimen. Once an installed gage is connected to a strain indicator and the instrument zeroed, a subsequent change in temperature of the gage installation can produce a resistance change in the gage and a corresponding reading on the instrument. This temperature-induced resistance change is independent of, and unrelated to, any mechanical (stress-induced) strain in the test object. This response, resulting purely from a temperature change, is often called the thermal output, or more expansively the apparent thermally induced strain of the strain gage. Thermal output is potentially the most serious error source in the practice of static strain measurement with strain gages. In fact, when measuring strains at temperatures far from room temperature (or from the initial balance temperature of the gage circuit), the error due to thermal output, if not controlled, can be much greater than the magnitude of the strain being measured. Therefore, it is usually necessary to either use some type of compensation for thermal output or make subsequent numerical corrections to the acquired strain data. Several techniques are available to reduce or eliminate errors caused by thermal output. The easiest technique is simply to zero the strain gage circuit at the test temperature, and then not change the temperature again during data collection. A key to success when using this technique is ensuring that the test part remains completely free of mechanically or thermally induced stresses before zeroing the circuit. Obviously, this is not always possible. Many factors affect the thermal output of strain gages: test specimen material and shape; foil alloy and batch; gage construction and pattern geometry; transverse sensitivity; installation procedures and environmental protection; heating rate; and so on. To
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
Thermal output με (Fi = 2) 4000 3000 Isoelastic
Nichrome V
2000 Karma (full hard) 1000
several key elements of the test are not specifically addressed. One key issue is heating rate, which is simply instructed to be slow. Dependent on the test material, heating rate can noticeably affect thermal output results [12.11]. Another concern is the test material itself. While most manufacturers use standard reference specimens, it is not at all certain that the properties of these materials will closely match a user’s test specimen, especially with regard to size and shape, even if within the same class of material. Additionally, manufacturers mainly want to give a representative thermal output characteristic. Rarely will more than one gage type be used to acquire thermal output data for a given batch of foil. It is almost a certainty that thermal output data supplied by the manufacturer will not adequately match the user’s specific test parameters. If it is determined, however, that the thermal output data provided by the manufacturer is sufficient, either because the manufacturer’s test conditions closely match the user’s, or the user’s accuracy demands are low (≈ ±10%), then correcting acquired strain readings for thermal output is simple. Using the test temperature at which the strain reading was acquired, determine from the supplied graph or equations what the value of thermal output is at that temperature, and then algebraically subtract that value from the strain readings. As noted previously, remember that consideration must be given to the instrument gage factor setting, ensuring that the acquired strain data and the supplied correction data use gage factors which have been properly corrected for temperature. From the above discussion it should be evident that in order to achieve the most accurate correction for thermal output, it is generally necessary to obtain thermal
24 °C 0 Constantan (full hard)
75 °F –1000 –2000 –3000
Alloys bonded to steel specimen –4000 –100
0
100
200
300
400
500
Temperature (°F) –50
0
50
100
150
200
250
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 12.12 Thermal output of several strain gage alloys (in the as-rolled metallurgical condition) bonded to steel
Fig. 12.13 Representative thermal output test system per
ASTM E 251 guidelines
299
Part B 12.4
help users, strain-gage manufacturers supply representative data for thermal output, usually presented in the form of a graph with accompanying curve-fit equations, or just the equations themselves (or perhaps just the coefficients). Representative thermal output plots for the special case of several as-rolled (hardtemper) strain gage alloys bonded to steel are shown in Fig. 12.12. Note that the curves for both the karma and constantan alloy gages pertain to non-self-temperaturecompensated foil (self-temperature compensation is discussed later in this section, where the benefits will become obvious when compared with the curves in Fig. 12.12). This data is used to correct acquired strain readings by providing a method for determining the value of thermal output at the temperature point(s) of interest. To complete the correction, this value is algebraically subtracted from the acquired strain readings. Because of the myriad affects on thermal output, it is important to understand fully how the manufacturer collects this data in order to determine its relevance to a particular set of test conditions. ASTM standard test method E 251 [12.3] presents suggestions for standardized testing of thermal output (Fig. 12.13 shows a representative thermal output test system following ASTM E 251 guidelines). However,
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
300
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
output data from the actual test gage installed on the actual test part. For this purpose, a thermocouple or resistance temperature sensor is installed immediately adjacent to the strain gage. With the gage connected to the strain indicator and no loads applied to the test part, the instrument is balanced for a zero strain reading. Subsequently, the test part is subjected to the test temperature(s), again with no loads applied, and the temperature and indicated strain are recorded under equilibrium conditions. If throughout this process the part is completely free of mechanical and thermal stresses and the temperature measurement accurately reflects the strain-gage temperature, the resulting strain indication at any temperature is the thermal output at that temperature. If the instrument gage factor setting during subsequent strain measurement is the same as that used for thermal output calibration, the calibrated thermal output at any test temperature can be subtracted algebraically from the indicated strain to arrive at the corrected strain. Otherwise, the thermal output data should be adjusted for the difference in gage factor settings – as previously described – prior to subtraction. Referring to Fig. 12.12, one can conclude that both constantan and karma in the hard-temper state have a high TCR. Fortunately, and unlike the other two alloys
shown in this figure, the TCR of both constantan and karma responds to heat treatment. With appropriate heat treatment, the thermal output curves for these two alloys can be rotated to minimize the temperature response over a wide temperature range when the gages are used on materials for which the foil heat treatment was targeted. Strain gages employing these specially processed foils are referred to as self-temperature compensated (STC). Representative curves for self-temperaturecompensated constantan and karma alloy strain gages bonded to 1018 steel are shown in Fig. 12.14. Note the ordinate scale and the markedly reduced output when compared with Fig. 12.12. While self-temperature compensation does not completely eliminate thermal output, it does improve performance to the point of reducing the number of cases where correction is mandatory. Thermal Output Compensation Techniques Exploiting the fact that thermal output is dependent on the difference between specimen and gage thermal expansion provides for a sometimes useful technique of minimizing temperature response, particularly when using gages in extreme cold (e.g., cryogenic temperatures). By installing the gage on a material other than that for which it was intended, the thermal outThermal output (με) 200
Thermal output με (Fi = 2) 500 400
0
300 200
K-alloy
24 °C
100
–200
0 –100
75 °F
–200
– 400 A-alloy
–300 –400
– 600
–500
Aluminum, TCE = 23.2 με/ °C Brass, TCE = 20.0 με / °C
–600
– 800
–700 –800
Test specimen – 1018 steel
–900 – 1000 –200
–100
0
100
200
300
400
500
–1000 –400 –300 –200 –100
0
100 200 300 Temperature (°F)
Temperature (°F) –100
–50
0
50
100
150
200
250
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 12.14 Representative thermal output of self-temper-
ature-compensated constantan (A-alloy) and modified Karma (K-alloy) strain gages
–250 –200 –150 –100 –50
0
50 100 150 Temperature (°C)
Fig. 12.15 Example of STC mismatch (thermal output curve rotation caused by using a gage on brass that was processed for use on aluminum)
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
εTO(B) = εTO(A) + (αS(B) − αS(A) )ΔT ,
(12.51)
where εTO(B) is the expected thermal output of a strain gage intended for material A but installed on material B, εTO(A) is the manufacturer’s calibrated thermal output, measured on standard material A, αS(B) is the TCE of material B, and αS(A) is the TCE of material A. If certain conditions are expressly met, one of the best techniques for compensating thermal output is using a compensating gage, often called a dummy gage. The technique exploits the arithmetic capabilities of the Wheatstone bridge by placing an exact duplicate of the active gage in an adjacent arm of the bridge (Fig. 12.16). This gage is subjected to precisely the same temperature profile experienced by the active gage, but is mounted on an unstrained piece of duplicate test material and connected to the instrumentation using the same type of leadwire system routed beside the active gage leads (to allow an equal temperature profile on all leadwires). Under these conditions, two adjacent arms of the bridge (R1 and R4 in Fig. 12.4) will experience identical resis-
Active gage
L1
L2 Compensating gage
e0
E
L3
L4
Fig. 12.16 Circuit diagram for the dummy-gage thermal output compensation technique
tance changes caused by thermal output. From (12.25), this condition does not unbalance the bridge and, hence, the temperature response self-cancels in the bridge and there is no change in reading on the strain indicator. The effect from specimen surface curvature is the final topic covered on temperature effects. Hines [12.13] demonstrated that, when a strain gage is installed on a sharply curved surface, thermal output is different when compared to the same gage installed on a flat surface. As will be shown in the next section, thermal output is a function of the difference between TCE of the gage and specimen. This difference causes a real strain in the gage. The curvature-induced change in thermal output is the result of the strain-sensitive grid being above the specimen surface by an amount equal to the gage backing layer plus the installation-adhesive layer thicknesses, effectively causing a neutral-axis shift when compared to the flat-surface case. The curvature-induced change in thermal output is a second-order effect that can ordinarily be ignored, but it can become significant when the radius of curvature is small. As a rule of thumb, when the radius of curvature is greater than 12 mm, the effect is of little consequence. Employing the same basic approach and approximations used by Hines, but generalizing to account for any combination of adhesive and backing properties, an expression for estimating the curvature-induced change in thermal output can be written as follows ΔεTO =
1 [(1 + 2νA-B )(h A αA + h B αB ) R − 2νA-B αS (h A + h B )]ΔT ,
(12.52)
where, in consistent units, ΔεTO is the curvatureinduced change in thermal output, R is the test surface radius of curvature at gage site, νA-B is the average Poisson’s ratio of adhesive and backing, h A and h B are the adhesive and backing thickness, respectively, αA and αB are the TCEs of the adhesive and the backing, respectively, αS is the TCE of the substrate (specimen material), and ΔT is the temperature change from the reference temperature. Approximate values for some common strain gage adhesive and backing parameters used in (12.52) are given in Table 12.1. The sign of the change in thermal output is obtained from (12.52) when the signs of ΔT and R are properly accounted for; that is, an increase in temperature from the reference temperature is taken as positive, and a decrease negative; and correspondingly, a convex curvature is positive, and a concave curvature is negative. The calculated result ΔεTO is added algebraically with the standard thermal output correction
301
Part B 12.4
put curve is rotated. This technique is termed, STC mismatch [12.12]. The curves in Fig. 12.14 show that both constantan and karma strain gages have a steep thermal output slope below room temperature, and that the slope progressively increases as the temperature decreases. Because it does have a lower slope at cold temperatures, karma alloy is normally used at or near cryogenic temperatures, but the thermal output is still high. When a gage processed for use on a material with a certain TCE is used instead on a material with a lower TCE, the original thermal output curve is effectively rotated clockwise (Fig. 12.15). Conversely, using the gage on a material with a higher TCE will rotate its thermal output curve counter-clockwise. The following generalized form approximately accomplishes this transformation analytically
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
302
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
Table 12.1 Typical strain gage component values (used with (12.52)) Adhesives
Backings
Type Cyanoacrylate
HA , mm (in) 0.015 (0.0006)
Two-component 100%-solids epoxy Two-component, solvent-thinned, epoxy-phenolic
0.025 (0.001)
0.005 (0.002)
ppm/◦ C (◦ F)
αA , 227 × 10−6 (126 × 10−6 ) 81 × 10−6 (45 × 10−6 ) 81 × 10−6 (45 × 10−6 )
Type Cast polyimide
HB , mm (in) 0.030 (0.0012)
Single-thickness, glass-fiber-reinforced, epoxy-phenolic Double-thickness, glass-fiber-reinforced, epoxy-phenolic
0.025 (0.001)
0.038 (0.0015)
αB , ppm/◦ C (◦ F) 90 × 10−6 (50 × 10−6 ) 18 × 10−6 (10 × 10−6 ) 18 × 10−6 (10 × 10−6 )
νA-B = 0.35 for all combinations
data, prior to correcting indicated strains, as previously described. Because the adhesive and backing parameters given in Table 12.1 are approximate and are affected by gage installation technique and other variables, the curvature correction defined by (12.52) has limited accuracy. When the surface curvature is severe enough to warrant correction, the actual thermal output should be measured following the prescribed method given earlier.
12.4.7 Control of Foil Strain Gage Thermal Output In this section, an explanation is given for how a manufacturer controls thermal output to achieve selftemperature compensation. As noted above, there are two effects controlling the response of a strain gage to changes in temperature. The first, the TCR of the alloy used in making the gage, is a material property and can be expressed as ΔR
= β × ΔT , R β
(12.53)
where β is the temperature coefficient of resistance (Ω/Ω /◦ C) and T is the temperature (◦ C). The second effect is caused by a mismatch between the specimen and gage TCE. When present, as is usually the case, a change of temperature causes a thermally induced strain in the gage. Additionally, temperature affects materials isotropically, so an account must be made for both axial and transverse strains. Thus, assuming equal coefficients of thermal expansion in both directions for the specimen and gage (not necessarily true, but a necessary simplification to contain the
derivation), ΔR/R|a ΔL
(12.54)
= (αS − αG )ΔT = α L a Fa and, ΔL
ΔR/R|t . (12.55)
= (αS − αG )ΔT = L αt Ft Solving (12.54) and (12.55) for ΔR/R and summing both with (12.53), the total relative resistance change of the gage due to thermal output is ΔR
= [β + Fa (αS − αG ) + Ft (αS − αG )]ΔT . R TO (12.56)
Converting Fa and Ft to the manufacturer’s gage factor F, 1 + Kt ΔR
(αS − αG ) ΔT .
= β+F R TO 1 − ν0 K t (12.57)
For some alloys used in the production of strain gages, most notably constantan and karma, β can be controlled via thermal and mechanical processing. And this is precisely how manufacturers’ produce STC strain gages. An obvious consequence of the temperature-respondent TCR is the establishment of upper temperature bounds. For constantan, when the temperature exceeds 65 ◦ C for several hours, the initial room-temperature resistance will begin to drift (zero drift) as β changes (from thermal reprocessing). Similarly, when karma is exposed to temperatures in excess of 200 ◦ C, its initial zero will drift. Additionally, both foils, when exposed to sufficiently high temperatures for a significant period, can be reprocessed into another STC, but long before this occurs the zero drift will have rendered any strain data meaningless.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
Bridge/strain arrangementa 1
ε E0
2
E
ε E0
E
–νε
3
ε E0
E
–ε
4
ε E0
E ε
5
ε
–νε E0 ε
–νε
6
E
ε
–νε E0
7
E
–ε
νε
ε
–ε E0
–ε
E ε
Nonlinearity b,c , η, where E0 /E = K × 10−3 (1 − η)
Bridge output b,c E0 /E (mV/V)
Description
K=
Single active gage in uniaxial tension or compression.
E0 E
=
F ×10−3 4+2F ×10−6
Two active gages in uniaxial stres field – one aligned with maximum principal strain, one Poisson gage.
E0 E
=
F (1+ν)×10−3 4+2F (1−ν)×10−6
Two active gages with equal and opposite strains – typical of bending-beam arrangement
E0 E
=
F
2
Two active gages with equal strains of same sign – used on opposite sides of column with low temperature gradient (bending cancellation, for instance).
E0 E
=
F ×10−3 2+F ×10−6
Four active gages in unaxial stress field – two aligned with maximum principal strain, two Poisson gages (column)
E0 E
=
F (1+ν)×10−3 2+F (1−ν)×10−6
Four active gages in unaxial atress field – two aligned with maximum principal strain, two Poisson gages (beam).
E0 E
=
F (1+ν)×10−3 2
Four active gages with pairs subjected to equal and opposite strains (beam in bending or shaft in torsion)
E0 E
= F × 10−3
× 10−3
η=
K= η=
K=
K= η=
K= η=
K=
Corrections c
F 4 F 10−6 2+F ×10−6
=
2 i 2−F i ×10−6
F(1+ν) 4 F (1−ν)×10−6 2+F (1−ν)×10−6
=
2 i 2(1+ν)−F i (1−ν)×10−6
η=0
=
i 2
F 2 F ×10−6 2+F ×10−6
=
2 i 4−F ×10−6
F(1+ν) 2 F (1−ν)×10−6 2+F (1−ν)×10−6
=
2 i 4(1+ν)−F i (1−ν)×10−6
=
i 2(1+ν)
=
i 4
F 2;
F(1+ν) ; 2
η=0
K = F; η = 0
1 2
a, 4 3 (R /R ) 1 4 nom = 1; (R2 /R3 )nom = 1 when b Constant-voltage power supply is assumed c
two or fewer active arms are used
and i are expressed in microstrain units (m/m × 106 )
12.4.8 Foil Strain Gages and the Wheatstone Bridge Recalling the relationship between input voltage, arm resistances, and bridge output given in (12.13), and using (12.42), if the bridge is populated with four gages in
what’s called a full bridge, which have impressed strains ε1 , ε2 , ε3 , and ε4 , then (12.13) for constant-voltage excitation can be written as 1 + Fε1 1 + Fε2 E0 = − . E 2 + F(ε1 + ε4 ) 2 + F(ε2 + ε3 )
(12.58)
Part B 12.4
Table 12.2 Bridge output relationships for several common Wheatstone bridge arrangements used with strain gages
303
304
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
Note that for clarity the gage factor has been assumed equal in all four gages. While not necessarily true, this is a common condition (e.g., any installation using four gages of the same type and construction) and this assumption greatly simplifies the equation. Several common strain gage bridge arrangements are shown in Table 12.2. With appropriate substitution of active and fixed gages into (12.58), the bridge output can be calculated and plotted to show the nonlinearity associated with each case. For reference, these relationships are provided in the table. Note that, for all relationships presented in the table, strain is scaled in m/m × 106 (e.g., 1500 m/m × 106 = 1500 μm/m = 0.001500 m/m). For each of the bridge arrangements shown, the nondimensional circuit output, in mV/V, can be expressed as E0 = K ε × 10−3 (1 − η) , E
(12.59)
where K is a constant, determined by the gage factor of the strain gage(s) and the number of active arms in the bridge circuit; and η, when not zero, represents the nonlinearity caused by unequal changes in the currents through the bridge arms. The fourth column of the table gives the expressions for calculating the nonlinearity associated with each bridge arrangement. Multiply this result by 100 to Percent nonlinearity 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3
Case #1, #4 2
Case #2, #5 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2
0.1 1000
10 000
100 000
Strain (με)
Fig. 12.17 Error in indicated tensile strain caused by Wheatstone bridge nonlinearity
obtain the percentage nonlinearity in the circuit output. Examination of this column shows that only cases 3, 6, and 7 are linear. This is true because only in these three cases are the resistance changes due to strain such that the currents through the bridge arms remain equal. It can also be noted from this column that, on a percentage basis, the nonlinearity magnitudes are identical for cases 1 and 4, and for cases 2 and 5, although the circuit outputs differ. For convenience in quickly judging nonlinearity magnitudes, the relationships in cases 1, 2, 4, and 5 are plotted in Fig. 12.17, assuming positive (tensile) strains, a gage factor of 2.0, and Poisson’s ratio (where involved) of 0.30. The nonlinearity for compressive strain is opposite in sign and somewhat different in magnitude, but can always be calculated from the provided relationships. The final (rightmost) column in Table 12.2 holds relationships for converting the indicated strain εi , as registered by a strain indicator or other instrumentation system, to the actual surface strain under a single active gage, ε. These expressions numerically correct for Wheatstone bridge nonlinearity (when present) and for the number of active gages in the circuit. Linearity Error Correction Examples Three numerical examples of correcting foil strain-gage data for Wheatstone bridge nonlinearity follow. For simplicity, each assumes a quarter-bridge circuit with a single active gage, and a gage factor of 2.0. However, the procedures used in the examples are general and applicable to all circuit arrangements in Table 12.2. For the first example, the quarter-bridge circuit is initially resistively balanced and no load is applied to the test piece. The test piece is then loaded until the strain indicator displays a tension reading of 10 000 με. From Fig. 12.17 for case 1 (single active gage), the nonlinearity is approximately 0.99% or about 99 με. Substituting F = 2.0 and εi = 10 000 με into the correction equation from Table 12.2 for case 1 gives the actual surface strain in the test piece as 10 101 με. If the indicator had registered −10 000 με for compression, the same procedure would yield a surface strain of −9901 με. These calculations demonstrate that Wheatstone bridge nonlinearity causes indicated tensile strains to be low, and indicated compressive strains to be more positive. The previous example assumed the Wheatstone bridge was initially resistively balanced. However, it is not unusual during the bonding of a strain gage for the as-manufactured resistance to be significantly shifted; or assembly or preload stresses can strain the gage into the plastic range prior to making measurements. In such
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
Leadwire Attenuation An often-overlooked source of potential error in straingage measurements are the wires used to connect the
gage(s) to instrumentation. There is potentially both a static concern (attenuation caused by the leadwire resistance) and a dynamic concern (change in leadwire resistance caused by a temperature change in the wire). When the Wheatstone bridge is used to indicate the resistance change of a strain gage, the gage and leadwire system constitute one arm of the bridge circuit. Therefore, leadwire resistance appears to the bridge as part of the measurement circuit by adding inactive (from the specimen-strain perspective) electrical resistance to the initial gage resistance. As the gage changes resistance with applied strain, the bridge circuit interprets the change as a function of the total arm resistance. The inactive leadwire resistance effectively reduces, or desensitizes, the gage factor by presenting strain-insensitive resistance to the bridge circuit, which increases the effective R in (12.42), without commensurately increasing the ΔR. Clearly, long runs of small-diameter and/or high-resistance wire are most problematic. The desensitization factor D is computed as D=
RG , RG + RL
(12.60)
where RG is the gage resistance and RL is the total initial resistance of leadwires in series with the gage (both lengths of wire for a two-wire circuit; one length of wire for a three-wire circuit). When the leadwire resistance is known (e.g., using a wire table value), leadwire errors can be corrected by multiplying indicated strains by 1/D. Alternatively, leadwire desensitization can be compensated by using an adjusted instrument gage factor setting, FG , instead of the package value, where FG = DFG . The percentage error in strain reading, e, caused by leadwire resistance can be expressed as e=
RL /RG RG × 100 . 1 + RL
(12.61)
The temperature coefficient of resistivity of metal leadwire introduces another complication if the leadwire temperature changes after zeroing the instrument. For leadwire attenuation correction using (12.60) when there is a temperature change after zeroing the instrument, RL and RG must be computed as the resistances at the test temperature. A temperature change in the leadwire system during a test can result in a resistance change of the leadwire that gets added to the resistance change of the gage. Knowing the wire TCR, this effect can be compensated by measuring the temperature change, calculating
305
Part B 12.4
cases, the gage resistance does not match the bridge completion resistors, causing a state of resistive unbalance. If not known to be insignificant, the initial unbalance should be measured. When large enough to warrant consideration, this initial unbalance (expressed in units of strain) must be added algebraically with any subsequent observed strains so that the nonlinearity correction is based on the total unbalance of the Wheatstone bridge. For the next example, assume that when the installed strain gage is connected in a quarter-bridge circuit, the strain indicator displays an initial unbalance of −3726 με. This is an indicated unbalance and, therefore, includes a small nonlinearity error. Substituting as before into the relationship from Table 12.2 for a single active gage, the actual unbalance (in strain units) is ε = −3712 με. With the instrument remaining in this state of unbalance, a specified load is applied to the test object. The instrument strain indication after the applied load is −12 034 με. The calculated correction for this strain indication is −11 891 με. Algebraically adding the corrected initial reading to the corrected final reading, the actual applied strain in the test object is −1891 − (−3712) = −8179 με. As a final example, consider a case where the indicated initial unbalance of the quarter-bridge circuit after installing the strain gage is +2200 με. The test object is then installed into a structure and the indicated reading is −47 500 με. Subsequent loading of the structure produces an indicated reading of −44 500 με, or an apparent load induced strain of +3000 με. What corrections should be made to determine the actual strain caused by loading the structure? Prior to loading the structure, the Wheatstone bridge is unbalanced by an indicated total of −47 500 με. Substituting into the correction expression for a single active gage from Table 12.2, the actual resistive unbalance in strain units prior to loading is ε = −45 346 με. After loading, the indicated unbalance of the bridge is −44 500 με. The calculated correction for this indicated strain yields −42 604 με. The applied strain due to loading the structure is then −42 604 − (−45 346) = +2742 με. This example demonstrates that, even with relatively modest working strains, the nonlinearity error can be significant (about 10% in this case) if the Wheatstone bridge is operated far from the resistive balance condition.
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
306
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
L1 L3 L2
e0
E
Fig. 12.18 Three-wire system for strain gage connection to the Wheatstone bridge
the change in leadwire resistance at the test temperature, and then computing the equivalent strain value resulting from this resistance change and algebraically subtracting it from the indicated strain reading. The apparent strain εAPL associated with leadwire temperature change can be computed as εAPL =
ΔRL /(RG + RL ) (ΔT β RL )/(RG + RL ) = , Fi Fi (12.62)
where ΔT is the change in leadwire temperature, after zeroing the instrument, β is the leadwire temperature coefficient of resistivity, and Fi is the instrument gage factor setting. To correct for leadwire apparent strain, algebraically subtract the result from (12.62) from the measured strains. Effects from leadwire resistance can be rendered negligibly small by using a three-wire connection to the strain gage, which is represented in Fig. 12.18. This wiring method affords two benefits. First by reducing the offending resistance to only one wire length L 1 , and second by placing equal resistances of leadwire into adjacent arms of the Wheatstone bridge, thus maintaining electrical balance with respect to the leadwire system, even with temperature changes, when the adjacent arm leadwires see these changes equally.
tionally, each is a function of gage construction and geometry, whereby a favorable specification for one can degrade performance in another. Therefore, a good understanding of what can affect sensor performance in each category will allow the user to make an informed choice when picking the best gage for the task. Fatigue Determining structural fatigue life is a common stress analysis measurement. Typically, these measurements constitute cycling the structure sufficiently long and at a sufficiently high mechanical strain level until it breaks. The working life for the structure at that strain level is then set at some fraction of the measured failure life. Like all metals, the sensing grid of a strain gage can break when cyclically strained. However, long before visible damage (cracking or breaking), the gage will exhibit erroneous resistance changes, rendering it unusable as an accurate strain sensor [12.14]. It is the useful measuring life that determines the fatigue resistance of strain gages. The number of cycles sustainable by a particular gage before it begins yielding poor data is commonly referred to as the fatigue life of the gage. When subjected to cold work during cyclic loading, the metal sensing grid in a strain gage will shift from its initial unstrained resistance. This change is permanent and is termed zero shift. Continued cyclic loading will cause small cracks to form in the foil, indicated by spike changes in the resistance as the gage is flexed. This condition is called supersensitivity. Resistance changes caused by zero shift and supersensitivity are inseparable from resistance changes caused by strain. Long before the gage ultimately fails (electrically open) data
12.4.9 Performance Characteristics The preceding sections discussed corrections for typical errors encountered when using strain gages in stress analysis applications. This section discusses strain gage performance characteristics associated with three specific parameters: fatigue, elongation, and reinforcement. Unlike the correctable errors, these parameters are inherent characteristics of the sensors, and can determine applicability to a particular test environment. Addi-
Fig. 12.19 Cracks (circled) in strain-gage foil grid lines, which cause supersensitivity
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
Elongation All bonded resistance strain gages are limited in elongation capability by characteristics of the grid alloy, the backing system, and the installation adhesive. Highstrain failure usually occurs through grid cracking,
Cyclic strain level (με) ±5000
Isoelastic ±4000
Modified nickel – chromium (S TC condition)
±3000
±2000 Iron– chromium– aluminum Constantan (S TC condition) ±1000 102
103
104
105
106
107
108
Number of cycles (N)
Fig. 12.20 Representative fatigue life curves for four common strain gage alloys
matrix cracking, adhesive cracking, or loss of bond. Because of close strain coupling, any crack in the specimen surface, adhesive, or matrix will immediately propagate through the thin foil grid. High-performance gages using a glass-fiber-reinforced backing system are usually limited to maximum strains of 1–2% (10 000–20 000 με). Regular STC gages using constantan foil and a compliant polyimide backing system are capable of 5–10% strains (50 000–100 000 με), especially in larger gage lengths (> 3 mm). Certain gages are specifically designed for the measurement of very high (single-cycle) strains. These are often called either high-elongation or post-yield strain gages, and employ fully annealed constantan alloy
Fig. 12.21 Typical strain-gage fatigue failure (cracked solder tab, tangent to solder joint)
307
Part B 12.4
no longer represents what is happening on the surface of the test part. Zero shift manifests itself as an offset in the strain reading. As such, it is normally not of concern for purely dynamic testing, because the peak-to-peak readings remain accurate. However, if the test combines static and dynamic components, zero shift is important because the static results are biased by the shift. Supersensitivity results from cracks forming in the grid area of the foil, often at the transition between the straight grid line and the curved end loop (Fig. 12.19). These cracks open during the tension phase of the loading cycle. Monitoring the strain-gage output on an oscilloscope can display supersensitivity; when present, the waveform will become distorted on the tension loop, usually represented by a spike at the top of the loop. Often, the zero-load gage reading is nearly normal, because the cracks close at no load. If unexpectedly large strain signals appear during a cyclic test, the waveform should be checked for supersensitivity before interpreting the data as a possible failure in the test part. In the light of the preceding considerations, straingage fatigue failure is usually defined as a positive zero shift of either 100 or 300 με, dependent on the application (quasistatic versus purely dynamic, respectively). As would be expected, different strain-gage alloys exhibit differences in fatigue life as a function of their mechanical strength. Representative fatigue life curves for four common strain gage alloys are presented in Fig. 12.20. Each alloy represented in this graph was tested using a high performance strain-gage construction (fully encapsulated, glass-fiber-reinforced epoxy-phenolic resin system), for best performance. It should be noted that fatigue life is affected not only by alloy choice, but also by the strain-gage backing system. Furthermore, no other test environment is more demanding on gage installation technique than fatigue. Thin, unfilled adhesives are the best choices (cyanoacrylate or solventthinned unfilled epoxy). Since the most common fatigue failure mode of a strain gage is a tangent crack in the solder tab, adjacent to the solder joint on the grid side (Fig. 12.21), leadwires and solder connections should be as small as practicable, with the leadwire exiting the tab 90◦ to the direction of principal strain.
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
308
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
grids (non-STC) on a low-modulus unfilled polyimide film. Using careful installation techniques and a highelongation adhesive, these gages are capable of strains in excess of 20% (200 000 με) before grid failure. This performance requires a smooth defect-free test surface and small, flexible leadwire attachment with correspondingly small solder joints, preferably using a soft solder (e.g., 63% tin, 37% lead). The usual adhesive choice for high-elongation work is a two-component 100%-solids epoxy system. This adhesive can be cured over an extended period (≈ 2 weeks) at room temperature (≈ 24 ◦ C), or in about 2 h at +75 ◦ C. Most of these adhesive systems have some filler to regulate glue-line thickness. Prior to use, large particles should be removed from the mix. Reinforcement Although strain gages appear small and delicate, they are actually fairly stiff. Dependent on backing type, foil type, stacking elements, and encapsulation options, stress analysis gages range in thickness from slightly less than 0.025 mm, to about 0.18 mm. The composite modulus of elasticity (combined grid, backing, and encapsulation if present) usually lies between 5 and 30 GPa for standard organic-backing strain gages. On most metallic specimens of at least a few millimeters thickness, the gage stiffness is negligible, but if the specimen has a low modulus when compared to the gage, and/or is only a few times thicker than the gage, the presence of the installed gage can significantly alter the specimen strain distribution. For example, Fig. 12.22 shows the strain field disruption on a 0.25 mm-thick specimen of fully annealed copper in pure tension, caused by the presence of a post-yield strain gage installed using a high-elongation epoxy adhesive. The copper strain level is approximately 3% at the gage site, but the bulk specimen strain level (outside
Fig. 12.22 Moiré fringe pattern displaying strain field disruption in thin, annealed copper at high elongation, caused by the presence of a strain gage (located on opposite side at center of photo)
the gage area) is approximately 10% higher (3.3% total strain). This reduction of strain level at the gage site is caused by local reinforcement from the strain gage. The deformed fringes, which show lines of constant strain in the moiré pattern, clearly outline the gage boundary, which is bonded to the opposite side of the specimen from where the moiré measurements are taken. Obviously, strain-gage measurements on plastics require consideration of reinforcement. A somewhat subtle concern when making measurements on plastics is the self-heating generated by passing an electrical current through a strain gage. If high enough, the heat generated by the strain gage can soften (reduce the Young’s modulus of) the plastic specimen, thus altering its strain distribution relative to the unheated bulk of the part. Therefore, it is important to use the lowest gage excitation voltage possible (keeping the power density on the gage below 0.03 kW/m2 ) when making measurements on plastics. A general guideline for setting instrument voltage when testing any material with poor heat conduction is to start at a very low power density (≈ 0.01 kW/m2 ) and gradually increase the voltage until the zero reading becomes unstable (drifts or fluctuates), then back off about 5% below the highest value that results in a stable zero reading. A qualitative measure of the impact from reinforcement on any material subjected to plane strain can be calculated as Pr =
tb E b + tf E f + ta E a × 100 , ts E s
(12.63)
where Pr is the percentage reinforcement, tb is the gage backing thickness, tf is the gage foil thickness, ta is the installation adhesive layer thickness, ts is the specimen thickness, E b is the gage backing modulus of elasticity, E f is the foil modulus of elasticity, E a is the adhesive modulus of elasticity, and E s is the specimen modulus of elasticity. Because the accuracy of this calculation is restricted by many assumptions, not the least of which includes the requirement for the specimen and gage to have equal width, the result cannot be used for quantitative assessment. However, if the percentage reinforcement calculated from (12.63) is greater than about 10%, steps should be taken to compensate the strain measurements for this local increase in stiffness. For any low-modulus material including plastics once self-heating is avoided, a common method of compensating room-temperature strain readings is to calibrate the gage (measure gage factor) on a specimen made from the same material which will be used during
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
typically make the measurement in a biaxial strain field on a steel beam with a Poisson’s ratio close to 0.28. Although a complete discussion is beyond the scope of the present work, readers are directed to [12.15–17]
Table 12.3 Performance parameters for certain strain gage components (used to facilitate gage selection) Type of test or application
General static or static–dynamic stress analysisa
Highelongation (post-yield)
Cyclic loading
Operating temperature range (◦ C)
−45 to +65
−45 to +205 −270 to +230 < 315 < 700 −45 to +65
−20 to +260 −270 to +260 −75 to +65 −195 to +260
Test duration (h)
< 104 > 104 > 104 > 104 < 103 > 103 > 103 < 102 < 10 < 10 > 103 > 103 > 102 < 103 < 104 < 104 < 104 < 104
Accuracy requiredb
Moderate Moderate Very High High Moderate High Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate
Cyclic endurance required
Typical selection
Maximum stain, με
Gage construction, foil/backing A/P A/P A/G K/G A/G K/G K/G K/G K/G A/P Y/P Y/P A, K/G K/G D/P D/G D/G D/G
±1300 ±1300 ±1600 ±2000 ±1600 ±2000 ±2000 ±1800 ±1500 ±50 000 ±100 000 ±200 000 ±15 000 ±10 000 ±20 000 ±24 000 ±20 000 ±23 000
Number of cycles < 106 < 106 > 106 > 106 < 106 < 106 < 106 < 106 < 106 1 1 1 1 1 107 107 107 < 105
Adhesive No.
Description
1 2 3 4 5
Cyanoacrylate Two-component, 100%-solids epoxy (room- or elevated-temperature cure) Two-component, 100%-solids epoxy (elevated-temperature cure) Two-component, solvent-thinned epoxy-phenolic (elevated-temperature cure) Two-component, 100%-solids epoxy, high elongation (room- or elevated-temperature cure)
Adhesive
1 or 2 2 or 3 3 or 4 3 or 4 4 4 4 4 4 2 3 5 4 4 1 or 2 2 or 3 4 4
Foil/backing A K Y D P G a
Constantan (Cu-Ni) Karma (Ni-Cr) Constantan (Cu-Ni), treated for high-elongation, post-yield performance Isoelastic (Ni-Fe) Cast polyimide Glass-fiber-reinforced epoxy-phenolic
Category includes most testing situations where some degree of stability under static test conditions is required. For absolute stability with constantan gages over long periods of time and temperatures above +65 ◦ C, it may be necessary to employ half- or full-bridge patterns. Protective coatings may also influence stability. b It is inappropriate to quantify accuracy as used in this table without consideration of various aspects of the actual test program and the instrumentation used. In general, “moderate” for stress analysis purposes is in the 2–5% range, “high” in the 1–3% range, and “very high” is 1% or better.
309
Part B 12.4
the actual test, and then use this value for subsequent testing of that material with the same gage types. This also has the added benefit of avoiding the inherent errors associated with gage factor, since manufacturers
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
310
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
for more information on using strain gages successfully with plastics and other low-modulus materials.
12.4.10 Gage Selection Procedure Proper strain-gage selection is important for achieving reliable and valid data. One shortcoming with strain gages is the ability to relatively easily obtain a reading, even if that reading is meaningless. The only way to avoid useless data is to plan the test meticulously and choose the best gage carefully for the test conditions. Recognizing that compromises are often necessary in gage choice, and utilizing the fundamental gage properties and characteristics thus presented, the goal for this section is to provide a logical checklist that results in the selection of a gage with the greatest chance of success under the established test conditions. When beginning the gage selection process, there are six general considerations:
• • • • • •
type of strain measurement (static, dynamic, high elongation, etc.) strain field operating temperature at gage installation test duration required accuracy required cyclic endurance
Meeting these test considerations requires choice of certain gage design and construction parameters
• • • • • • •
alloy backing material gage length/overall size geometry self-temperature compensation grid resistance options
Performance expectations from several of these parameters have been discussed earlier. The information in Table 12.3 summarizes these expectations and provides the basic means for preliminary selection of the gage for several conventional applications. Also included are recommendations for adhesive, since the adhesive in a strain gage installation becomes part of the gage system, and correspondingly affects the performance of the gage. Of the selectable gage construction parameters, alloy is primary in determining gage operating characteristics. Cyclic endurance, elongation, temperature range, long-term stability, and even cost are a few of the gage characteristics determined by alloy choice.
As previously stated, constantan is the most widely used modern strain-gage alloy. This is true because it has the best overall combination of properties needed for many strain-gage applications. For example, it has an adequately high strain sensitivity, or gage factor, which is relatively insensitive to strain level and temperature. Additionally, its resistivity is high enough to achieve suitable resistance values, even in small grids, and it can be processed for self-temperature compensation to match a wide variety of test materials. Constantan can also be processed (annealed) to survive very large strains (> 20%), when used in gage lengths of 6 mm and longer, and its cyclic endurance is adequate for many test conditions. However, constantan is not the best choice for high-cycle, purely dynamic applications. Another shortcoming of constantan is that it drifts in resistance at temperatures above +65 ◦ C, rendering it a bad choice for good zero stability over a period of hours or days above this temperature. The second most widely used strain gage alloy, karma, is characterized by good fatigue life and excellent stability; it is the preferred choice for accurate static strain measurements over long periods of time (months or years) at room temperature, or shorter periods at elevated temperature. It is recommended for extended static strain measurements over the temperature range from −270 to +260 ◦ C. For short periods (a few minutes), an encapsulated karma-alloy strain gage can operate reliably when exposed to temperatures as high as +400 ◦ C. An inert atmosphere can improve stability and prolong useful life at these high temperatures. Karma has a higher resistivity than constantan and can therefore achieve higher gage resistances in similarly sized patterns, or the same resistances in smaller patterns. Like constantan, karma alloy can be selftemperature compensated for many common structural materials, and has a flatter thermal output curve, permitting more accurate correction for thermal output errors at temperature extremes. One drawback to the alloy is solderability. Either a plating feature (nickel or copper are most common) or acid solder flux must be used to attach leadwires. This is because, after cleaning/abrading the solder tabs, the alloy almost instantaneously forms a protective surface corrosion, which inhibits solder wetting. When making purely dynamic strain measurements – that is, when it is not necessary to maintain a stable reference zero – a nickel–iron–chrome alloy called isoelastic offers advantages. Principal among these are superior fatigue life, when compared with constantan or karma, and a high gage factor (≈ 3.2), which improves
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
sonable accuracy (better than ±5◦ ). Of course, multiple single-grid gages can be installed at desirable relative angles and spacings to solve many stress analysis problems, but most gage manufacturers supply multigrid gages on a common backing to simplify the installation process. A good example is the dual-grid pattern where the grids are ±45◦ to the axis of the gage. When attached to a specimen and connected as a summing half-bridge, the resultant reading from the gage is equal to the shear strain in the specimen along the direction of the gage axis. For the most general measurement case, when the specimen stress state and principal axes are unknown, a three-element rosette should be used to determine the principal stress magnitudes and directions. When using a rosette, consideration should be given to the difference in measurement characteristics between single-plane and stacked rosettes. For any given gage length, the single-plane rosette is superior to the stacked rosette in terms of heat transfer to the test specimen, generally providing better stability and accuracy for static strain measurements. Furthermore, when there is a significant strain gradient perpendicular to the test surface (as in bending), the single-plane rosette will produce more accurate strain data because all grids are as close as possible to the specimen surface. Additionally, single-plane rosettes are more conformable than stacked rosettes. However, when there is a large strain gradient in the plane of the test surface, as is often the case, the single-plane rosette can produce errors in strain indication because the grids sample the strain field at different points. The stacked rosette is most advantageous in this case (but can result in a compromise with neutral-axis shifts for bending strains), and also when there is limited space for attaching the gage. Strain Peak strain
Indicated strain
x
Fig. 12.23 Reduction in indicated strain caused by strain averaging along the gage length
311
Part B 12.4
signal-to-noise ratio in dynamic testing. Isoelastic is not subject to self-temperature compensation and its thermal output is high (about 145 με/◦ C), typically making it unusable for static strain measurement. When possible, use of a half- or full-bridge configuration can reduce the temperature response. Isoelastic is magnetoresistive, which introduces another error source in high magnetic fields. Also, its gage factor is nonlinear, becoming significantly so at strains beyond ±5000 με. The strain-gage backing serves several important purposes. Foremost, it provides a way of stabilizing the delicate metal pattern and offers a means for handling the sensor during installation. The backing also affords a readily bondable surface for adhering the gage to a specimen and provides electrical insulation between the metal pattern and electrically conductive specimens. Good backing materials also allow excellent strain transmission into the grid of the gage, which supports good fidelity between specimen strain and gage reading. The two most popular strain gage backing materials are polyimide (cast or film) and glass-fiber-reinforced epoxy. Cast polyimide offers excellent flexibility and toughness and can easily be contoured to fit small radii (≈ 0.5 mm). With its typical operating temperature of −195 to +175 ◦ C, polyimide is an ideal choice for general-purpose static and dynamic stress analysis. It is also capable of high elongations, and can be used to measure plastic strains in excess of 20%. For higher-temperature operation and improved stability, cast polyimide can be reinforced with glass fibers, but flexibility and elongation are reduced. Higher-modulus film polyimide has slightly less flexibility and elongation, but has excellent long-term stability, partly as the result of lower moisture absorption, when compared with cast polyimide. Glass-fiber-reinforced epoxy offers outstanding performance over the widest range of temperatures. This backing can be used for static and dynamic strain measurement from −270 to +400 ◦ C. However, its flexibility is limited and the backing cannot be conformed over small radii (< 5 mm) or survive large elongation (> 2%). The pattern geometry, including gage length, is most often dictated by the strain field that the strain gage will sense. Many different patterns are commercially available to solve specific test problems with minimum effort and complication. For example, a single-grid gage would normally be used only when the stress state at the point of measurement is known to be uniaxial and the directions of the principal axes are known with rea-
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
312
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
Table 12.4 Checklist for strain gage selection
Considerations for parameter selection Selection step: 1 Parameter: Gage length
Selection step: 2 Parameter: Gage pattern
Selection step: 3 Parameter: Gage series
Selection step: 4 Parameter: Options
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
• • • • • • • • •
Selection step: 5 Parameter: Gage resistance Selection step: 6 Parameter: S-T-C number
• • • • • • • •
Strain gradients Area of maximum strain Accuracy required Static strain stability Maximum elongation Cyclic endurance Heat dissipation Space for installation Ease of installation Strain gradients (in-plane and normal to surface) Biaxiality of stress Heat dissipation Space for installation Ease of installation Gage resistance availability Type of strain measurement application (static, dynamic, post-yield, etc.) Operating temperature Test duration Cyclic endurance Accuracy required Ease of installation Type of meassurement (static, dynamic, post-yield, etc.) Installation environment – laboratory or field Stability requirements Soldering sensitivity of substrate (plastic, bone, etc.) Space available for installation Installation time constraints Heat dissipation Leadwire desensitization Signal-to-noise ratio Test specimen material Operating temperature range Accuracy required
Since a strain gage reports the average strain reading from the area of its grid (Fig. 12.23), gage length and width must always be carefully considered relative to the expected strain gradients. For steep gradients, such as those found near stress concentrations, a grid that is large compared to the slope of the gradient will report significantly lower strain values than the peak strains in the specimen. As a rule of thumb, when practicable, the gage length should be no greater than 0.1 times the radius of a hole, fillet, or notch, or the corresponding dimension of any other stress raiser near which the gage will be installed. Obviously, for even a moderately small stress raiser, say, 12 mm, this rule will lead to a very small, if not impractical, gage size – another example where compromise is necessary. In the opposite case, for nonhomogeneous materials such as concrete, long gage lengths (> 100 mm) are used to span several periods of any repeating feature (aggregate, in the case of concrete), so that the bulk material strain can be measured, not a locally perturbed value biased by the repeating feature. Using the above considerations a checklist can be produced, which is shown in Table 12.4. While not allinclusive, this checklist is a good starting point for the gage selection process. Simply check all bullets that are relevant at each selection step, and then with consideration to available gages, determine which considerations must be compromised to choose the most likely gage that will be successful in achieving the desired test results.
12.4.11 Specific Applications The following sections present and discuss specific measurement applications and the best use of foil strain gages in solving these problems, resulting in the collection of the best experimental data. These applications will demonstrate many of the techniques, corrections, and characteristics presented in earlier sections. Plane Shear Measurement A conventional, linear, strain gage does not respond to pure shear strain as such, since shear strain simply changes the shape of the gage without altering the lengths of the grid filaments. However, shear and normal strains are related through the laws of elasticity; and it is thus possible, by proper orientation of the gages on the strained surface, and proper arrangement of the gages in a Wheatstone bridge circuit, to produce an instrument indication that is directly proportional to the shear strain in the surface. First, a theoretical basis for deriving shear strains from the normal strain
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
2
θ2 1
θ1 X
(12.68)
Fig. 12.24 Arbitrarily oriented strain gages in a biaxial
strain field
It is thus evident that, if the gage axes are oriented symmetrically with respect to, say, the X-axis (Fig. 12.25), θ1 = −θ2 = α
measurements is presented, and then several practical applications of the procedure are given.
and γ XY = −
Shear Strains From Normal Strains. Consider an array
of two strain gages oriented at arbitrarily different angles with respect to an X–Y coordinate system, which, in turn, is arbitrarily oriented with respect to the principal axes, as in Fig. 12.24. From elementary mechanics of materials, the strains along the gage axes can be written as ε X + εY ε X − εY γ XY + cos 2θ1 + sin 2θ1 , ε1 = 2 2 2
ε1 − ε2 ε1 − ε2 ε1 − ε2 = = . sin 2θ2 sin 2θ1 sin 2α
a) Y
X 2 1
1
(12.64)
ε2 =
(12.69)
ε X + εY ε X − εY γ XY + cos 2θ2 + sin 2θ2 . 2 2 2 (12.65)
Subtracting (12.65) from (12.64) and solving for γ XY gives γ XY =
2(ε1 − ε2 ) − (ε X − εY )(cos 2θ1 − cos 2θ2 ) . sin 2θ1 − sin 2θ2 (12.66)
2
b) 1 4
Y
1
2
4
3
2 3
2
α X
α 1
Fig. 12.25 Defining the X-axis as the bisector of the angle
between the gage axes
Fig. 12.26a,b Strain-gage shear bridges, with corresponding Wheatstone bridge connection: (a) 90◦ rosette for direct indication of shear strain, and (b) full shear bridge, typically for force measurement
Part B 12.4
It is now noticeable that if cos 2θ1 ≡ cos 2θ2 the term in ε X and εY vanishes, and 2(ε1 − ε2 ) . (12.67) γ XY = sin 2θ1 − sin 2θ2 Since the cosine function is symmetrical about the zero argument and about all integral multiples of π, cos 2θ1 ≡ cos 2θ2 when, π π nπ θ1 + α = − , (0), , = θ2 − α . 2 2 2
Y
313
314
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
The preceding results can be generalized as follows: The difference in normal strain sensed by any two arbitrarily oriented strain gages in a uniform strain field is proportional to the shear strain along an axis bisecting the strain gage axes, irrespective of the included angle between the gages. When the two gages are 90◦ apart, the denominator of (12.69) becomes unity and the shear strain along the bisector is numerically equal to the difference in normal strains. Thus, a 90◦ , two-gage rosette constitutes an ideal shear half-bridge because the required subtraction ε1 − ε2 is performed automatically for two gages in adjacent arms of the Wheatstone bridge circuit. When the gage axes of a two-gage 90◦ rosette are aligned with the principal axes, (Fig. 12.26a), the output of the half-bridge is numerically equal to the maximum shear strain. A full shear-bridge (with twice the output signal from the circuit) is then composed of four gages as shown in Fig. 12.26b. The gages may have any of several configurations, including the cruciform arrangement and the compact geometry illustrated in the figure. Principal Strains. It should be kept in mind that, with
the shear bridges described above, the indicated shear strain exists along the bisector of any adjacent pair of gage axes, and it is not possible to determine the maximum shear strain or the complete state of strain from any combination of gage outputs unless the orientation of the gage axes with respect to the principal axes is known. In general, when the directions of the principal axes are unknown, a three-gage 45◦ rectangular rosette can be used. Referring to Mohr’s circle for strain (Fig. 12.27), it is apparent that the two shaded triangles are always
–
γ 2
3 B 2
45°
A
22.5° 1
Fig. 12.28 45◦ rosette used to determine γA and γB , the shear strains in the A and B directions, respectively
identical for a 45◦ rosette, and therefore the maximum shear strain is equal to the vector sum of the shear strains along any two axes, which are 45◦ apart on the strained surface. Looking at the 45◦ rosette as shown in Fig. 12.28, it can be seen that the shear strains along the bisectors of the gage pairs 1–2 and 2–3 are in fact 45◦ apart, and thus the maximum shear strain is
γmax = γA2 + γB2 and, considering (12.69), ε2 − ε3 2 ε1 − ε2 2 γmax = + sin 45◦ sin 45◦ or, γmax =
√ 2 (ε1 − ε2 )2 + (ε2 − ε3 )2
(12.70)
ε1 ε2 2 1
2θ
2θ ε
0 ε3
3
ε1 +ε3 2
ε1 – ε3 2
ε1 +ε3 – ε2 2
Fig. 12.27 Mohr’s circle for strain used to determine maxi-
mum shear strains
Fig. 12.29 Setup for shear-buckling testing of a composite panel (courtesy of the National Research Council, Canada)
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
d
0° fibers
w h
90° fibers R
d
L L h d R w
= 76.2 mm = 19.05 mm = 3.81 mm = 1.27 mm = 11.43 mm
Thickness = 2.54 – 5.08 mm (12.7 mm max)
Fig. 12.30 Schematic of v-notch (Iosipescu) specimen
used for shear modulus testing of composite materials
and, from Mohr’s circle again, the principal strains are obviously εp , εq =
ε1 + ε3 ± (ε1 − ε2 )2 + (ε2 − ε3 )2 . 2 (12.71)
Shear Measurement Applications. As described in the preceding material, shear strains are not measured directly, but inferred from the measurement of two normal strains at different angular orientations. An increasingly prominent area of shear strain determination occurs in research on shear buckling of thin panels of composite materials employed in satellites and other aerospace equipment generally. In such cases, it is always necessary to minimize the weight of the panel, while avoiding the danger of catastrophic failure by shear buckling. Figure 12.29 shows a small portion of a composite panel in a picture-frame loading fixture preparatory to undergoing a shear-buckling test. Shear strain magnitudes are obtained from the two centrally located strain gages. Since composite materials are not yet as standardized as the common structural metals, there is a frequent need for measuring basic material properties such as shear strength and shear modulus. The ASTM has developed a number of tests for evaluating these properties in composites (ASTM Annual Book of Standards,
a)
P A
a)
y Average A 0° fibers Conventional tee-rosette
b)
T C T
γxy
b)
y A–A
Average
C Bending stress
Shear stress
90° fibers
c)
T
C Front Rear
γxy
Fig. 12.31a,b Shear strain distributions for (a) 0◦ and (b) 90◦ unidirectionally reinforced graphite/epoxy speci-
mens (after Ifju [12.18])
C
T
Fig. 12.32a–c Schematics showing (a) the principal of the shear-web load cell, with (b) stress distribution and (c) circuit arrangement
315
Part B 12.4
90°
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
316
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
Volume 15.03). The goal has always been to achieve a small, inexpensive, easily produced specimen, which is characterized by a state of pure shear in its test zone. The V-notch (Iosipescu) specimen, shown in Fig. 12.30, initially appeared promising for this purpose [12.18]. However, it was soon found that the Iosipescu specimen did not produce reliable, material-independent results [12.19]. The reason for this outcome is seen in Fig. 12.31, which illustrates that the shear strain distribution varies across the test zone dependent on the fiber direction in unidirectionally reinforced composite materials. The strain gage will average the part of this distribution that it covers [12.20]. Therefore, different average shear strain readings are obtained dependent on the gage length. The solution to this problem was to design a shear gage specific to the specimen geometry such that both grids cover the full test zone height (from edge to edge). Since the average shear strain over the full test zone must be equal with either fiber direction, the new gages produced the same average shear strains regardless of fiber orientation. Probably the widest use of shear measurement is one in which the user does not care what the shear strain is at all, because he is measuring force or load that is proportional to shear strain. The reference here is to what are commonly called shear-web transducers, a schematic of which is shown in Fig. 12.32a, along with the corresponding stress distribution in the transducer (Fig. 12.32b) and the circuit arrangement (Fig. 12.32c). Such transducers are often made in the form of cantilever beams with recesses milled into both sides of the beam to leave a thin web, which is instrumented with two strain gages on either side, oriented to produce an output proportional to the shear strain. Shear-web transducers offer several advantages to the transducer designer. They are characteristically compact and robust, and capable of sensing high loads in minimal space. Furthermore, the transducer response is independent of the point of load application, because the vertical shear force is necessarily the same at every section of the beam to the left of the recess. Primarily because of the limited beam deflection, shear-web transducers also tend to exhibit very good linearity. Measurement of Thermal Expansion Coefficient The thermal expansion coefficient is a basic physical property of a material, which can be of considerable importance in mechanical and structural design applications. Although there are many published tabulations of expansion coefficients for the common metals and stan-
dard alloys, quite frequently the need arises to measure this property for a specific material over a particular temperature range. In some cases (e.g., composite materials, new or special alloys, etc.) there is apt to be no published data whatsoever on expansion coefficients. In others, data may exist (and eventually be found), but may encompass the wrong temperature range, apply to a somewhat different material, or be otherwise unsuited to the application. Dilatometry is the classical method for measuring thermal expansion, in which a dilatometer is used to determine the relative expansion between a test specimen and reference material. In this type of instrument, the difference in expansion between a rod made from the test material and a length of quartz or vitreous silica is compared. Differential expansion between the two materials is measured with a sensitive dial indicator or with an electrical displacement transducer, or some applicable optical method. When necessary, the expansion properties of the quartz or silica can be calibrated against the accurately known expansion of pure platinum or copper. The instrument is typically inserted in a special tubular furnace or liquid bath to obtain the required uniform temperatures. Making expansion measurements with the dilatometer is a delicate, demanding task, and is better suited to the materials science laboratory, rather than the typical experimental stress analysis facility. Given below is an alternate method for easily and quite accurately measuring the expansion coefficient of a test material with respect to that of a reference material having known thermal expansion characteristics. The technique described here uses two wellmatched strain gages, with one bonded to a specimen of the reference material, and a second to a specimen of the test material. The specimens can be of any size or shape compatible with the available equipment for heating and refrigeration (but specimens of uniform cross-section will minimize potential problems with temperature gradients). Under stress-free conditions, the differential output between the gages on the two specimens, at any common temperature, is equal to the differential unit expansion (in/in or m/m). Aside from the basic simplicity and relative ease of making thermal expansion measurements by this method, it has the distinct advantage of requiring no specialized instruments beyond those normally found in a stress analysis laboratory. This technique can also be applied to the otherwise difficult task of determining directional expansion coefficients of composite materials with anisotropic thermal properties.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
ΔL /L (ppm) 8
Thermal expansion: –80°C to +150°C 6 4
Principle of the Measurement Method. When a resis-
tance strain gage is installed on a stress-free specimen of any material, and the temperature of the specimen is changed, the electrical resistance of the strain gage changes correspondingly. As noted previously, this effect is referred to as the thermal output of the strain gage. The magnitude of the thermal output, for a particular strain gage type, is dependent on only two variables: the magnitude of the temperature change, and the difference between two thermal expansion coefficients (that of the strain gage, and that of the material on which the gage is bonded). Expressed mathematically βG + (αS − αG ) ΔT , (12.72) εT(G/S) = FG where εT(G/S) is the thermal output of the gage, βG /FG is the temperature coefficient of resistance of the strain gage alloy, divided by gage factor, (αS − αG ) is the difference in expansion coefficient between the specimen material and the gage, and ΔT is the temperature change. Similarly, when the same type of strain gage is installed on a reference material of known thermal expansion coefficient, βG + (αR − αG ) ΔT . (12.73) εT(G/R) = FG Subtracting (12.73) from (12.72) and rearranging, αS − αR =
(εT(G/S) − εT(G/R) ) . ΔT
(12.74)
Thus, the difference in expansion coefficients between the reference material and the test material, referred to a particular temperature range, is equal to the change in thermal output for the same change in temperature. Obvious from the derivation of (12.74) is that the output of the reference gage not only serves as a relative point from which thermal expansion can be measured, but the gage also serves as a compensating dummy to the specimen gage, thus precisely eliminating the TCR contribution from the gage.
2 0 –2 –80 –60 –40 –20
0
–20 –40 –60 –80 –100 –120 –140
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 12.33 Thermal expansion characteristics of titanium
silicate reference material (courtesy Corning Inc.) Measurement Procedures. Selection of the material
used as a reference standard is an important factor in the accuracy of this method, as it is for any form of differential dilatometry. In principle, the reference material could be almost any substance for which the expansion properties are accurately known over the temperature range of interest. In practice, however, it is often advantageous to select a material with expansion properties as close to zero as possible. Doing so will provide an output signal that closely corresponds to the absolute expansion coefficient of the test material, and permits a more straightforward test procedure. The thermal expansion of the reference material should also be highly repeatable and stable with time at any constant temperature. In addition, the elastic modulus of the material should be high enough that mechanical reinforcement by the strain gage is negligible. An excellent reference material with these and other desirable properties is ultra low expansion (ULE) titanium silicate, code 7972, available from Corning Incorporated, Corning, NY. As illustrated in Fig. 12.33, this special glass has a low thermal expansion coefficient, particularly over the temperature range from about −45 to +75 ◦ C. It should be noted, however, that the material also has a low coefficient of thermal conductivity, making it slow to reach thermal equilibrium. For optimum results, a dwell time of at least 45 min should be used at each new temperature point before taking data. Another potential disadvantage of titanium silicate as a reference material is its brittleness, since it will fracture readily if dropped on a hard surface. Because of the foregoing, a low expanding metal such as Invar may offer a preferred alternative.
317
Part B 12.4
Because typical expansion coefficients are measured in terms of a few parts per million per degree of temperature change, close attention to procedural detail is required with any measurement method to obtain accurate results; and the strain gage method is no exception to this rule.
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
318
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
a) Test material 1 2 3
E e0
1 2 3
Reference material
b) Test material 1
E 2
e0
3
Reference material
Fig. 12.34a,b Strain-gage circuits for measuring thermal expansion coefficients; (a) separate quarter-bridge circuits; (b) half-bridge cir-
cuit
In general, 350 Ω gages are preferable for this test to minimize self-heating by the excitation current. The gages should be of the same type, and should be from the same manufacturing lot for closely related thermal output characteristics. When expansion measurements must be made over an extended temperature range, or at high or low temperature extremes, the STC number of the gages should be carefully selected to obtain the best measurement accuracy. With excessive mismatch between the STC number of the gage and the expected thermal expansion of the specimen, the slope of the thermal output curve can become very steep at one or both temperature extremes. Judicious selection of the STC mismatch can be used to simultaneously keep the shapes of the thermal output curves for both the test and the reference materials under reasonably good control over the expected temperature range. The circuit arrangements shown in Fig. 12.34 offer the greatest convenience in reading the difference in thermal outputs required by (12.74). The two gages are connected in adjacent arms of a Wheatstone bridge circuit to form a half bridge, and the circuit output is a direct reading of the difference in thermal outputs. It is important that the leadwires be as short as possible, and the same length and wire size. It is also necessary that
Strain-Gage Selection and Measurement Circuits.
In principle, any standard strain gage of 3 mm length or longer, and with a backing material suitable for the expected temperature range, should suffice for this purpose. It should be remembered, however, that the procedure described here requires a pair of wellmatched strain gages: one for the test material, and one for the reference material.
–
γ ,τ 2
ε(φ– β) εφ ε(φ+ β)
+2β –2β
ε(φ – β)
2φ
εφ ε(φ+β) +β
Y
ε,σ
0 –β φ
Strain circle
X
Stress circle
εq(–) 1 Rε = – ν
σp
εp(+)
εq
εp
Fig. 12.35 Polar plot of strain distribution at a point in uniaxial
Fig. 12.36 Mohr’s circles of stress and strain for uniaxial
stress
stress
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
Errors Due to Misalignment – Single Gage in a Uniform Biaxial Strain Field When a strain gage is installed on a test surface at a small angular error with respect to the intended axis of strain measurement, the indicated strain will be in error due to this gage misalignment. In general, for a single gage in a uniform biaxial strain field, the magnitude of the misalignment error depends upon three factors (ignoring transverse sensitivity):
1. the ratio of the algebraic maximum to the algebraic minimum principal strains εp /εq 2. the angle φ between the maximum principal strain axis and the intended axis of strain measurement 3. the angular gage-mounting error β between the gage axis after bonding and the intended axis of strain measurement These quantities are defined in Figs. 12.35 and 12.36 for the particular but common case of the uniaxial stress state. Figure 12.35 is a polar diagram of the strain at the point in question, and Fig. 12.36 illustrates the concentric Mohr’s circles for stress and strain at the same point. In Fig. 12.35, the distance to the boundary of the diagram along any radial line is proportional to the normal strain magnitude along the same line. The small lobes along the Y -axis in the diagram represent the negative Poisson strain for this case. It can be seen qualitatively from Fig. 12.35 that, when φ is zero or 90◦ , a small angular misalignment of the gage will produce a very small error in the strain indication, since the polar strain diagram is relatively flat and passing through zero slope at these points. However, for angles between 0 and 90◦ , Fig. 12.35 shows that the error in indicated strain due to a small angular misalignment can be surprisingly large because the slope of the polar diagram is quite steep in these regions. More specifically, it can be noticed from Fig. 12.35 that, when φ = 45◦ or 2φ = 90◦ , the same small angular misalignment will produce the maximum error in indicated strain, since ε is changing most rapidly with angle at this point. Writing the analytical expression for the polar strain diagram, and setting the second derivative equal to zero to solve for the angle at which the maximum slope occurs would obtain the same result. In fact, the general statement can be made that in any uniform biaxial strain field the error due to gage misalignment is always great-
est when measuring strain at 45◦ to a principal axis, and is always least when measuring the principal strains. The error in strain indication due to angular misalignment of the gage in a uniform biaxial strain field can be expressed as follows n = εφ±β − εφ ,
(12.75)
where n is the error in με, εφ±β is the strain on gage axis with angular mounting error ±β in με, and eφ is the strain on axis of intended measurement at angle φ from principal axis in με, or εp − εq (12.76) [cos 2(φ ± β) − cos 2φ] , n= 2 where εp and εq are the maximum and minimum principal strains, respectively. The error can also be expressed as a percentage of the intended strain measurement εφ εφ±β − εφ n = , (12.77) εφ Error in strain indication (με) β = –10°
200 –8°
– 6°
100
– 4°
– 2° – 1°
0 1° 2° 4°
–100 6°
8°
Uniaxial stress
–200
εp = 1000 με εq = –285 με
10°
0
10
20
30
40
50
60 70 80 90 Gage angle φ (deg)
Fig. 12.37 Error in indicated strain due to gage misalignment for the special case of a uniaxial stress field in steel
319
Part B 12.4
leadwire 2 be connected at the midpoint of the jumper between the gages so that half of the resistance of that wire is in each bridge arm.
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
320
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
which can be rewritten as n =
cos 2(φ ± β) − cos 2φ Rε +1 Rε −1
β
× 100 ,
Misaligned rosette axes (12.78)
ε
where Rε = εpq . However, from (12.77) it can be seen that n becomes unmeaningfully large for small values of εφ , and infinite when εφ vanishes. In order to better illustrate the order of magnitude of the error due to gage misalignment, (12.76) is evaluated for a more-or-less typical case Given: Assume: Then, and
εq = −νp , ν = 0.285 . εp = 1000 με . εq = −285 με n = 642.5[cos 2(φ ± β) − cos 2φ] . (12.79)
Equation (12.79) is plotted in Fig. 12.37 over a range of φ from 0 to 90◦ , and over a range of mounting errors from 1 to 10◦ . In order to correct for a known misalignment by reading the value of n from Fig. 12.37, it is only necessary to solve (12.75) for εφ and substitute the value of n, including the sign, as given by Fig. 12.37. This figure is provided only as an example, and applies only to the case in which εq = −0.285 εp (uniaxial stress in steel). Equation (12.76) can be used to develop similar error curves for any biaxial strain state. Errors due to Misalignment – Two-Gage Rectangular Rosette While the above analysis of the errors due to misalignment of a single gage may help in understanding the nature of such errors, the 90◦ , two-gage (tee) rosette is of considerably greater practical interest. A tee rosette is ordinarily used by stress analysts for the purpose of determining the principal stresses when the directions of the principal axes are known from other sources, such as failure histories. In this case, the rosette should be bonded in place with the gage axes coincident with the principal axes. Whether there is an error in orientation of the rosette with respect to the principal axes, or in the directions of the principal axes themselves, there will be a corresponding error in the principal stresses as calculated from the strain readings. In Fig. 12.38, a general biaxial strain field is shown, with the axes of a tee rosette, misaligned by the angle β, superimposed. The percentage error in the principal stresses and maximum shear stress due to the misalign-
β
Principal axes
Fig. 12.38 Biaxial strain field with rosette axes misaligned
by the angle β from the principal axes
ment are σˆ − σp × 100 , σp (1 − Rε )(1 − ν)(1 − cos 2β) np = × 100 , 2(Rε − ν) σˆ − σq nq = × 100 , σq (Rε − 1)(1 − ν)(1 − cos 2β) nq = × 100 , 2(1 + ν Rε ) τˆmax − τmax nτ = × 100 , τmax n τ = −(1 − cos 2β) × 100 , n=
(12.80) (12.81) (12.82) (12.83) (12.84) (12.85)
where σˆ p , σˆ q , and τˆmax are the principal stresses and maximum shear stress inferred from the indicated strains when the rosette is misaligned by the angle β, and Rε = εp /εq is the ratio of the algebraic maximum to the algebraic minimum principal strain, as before. When the principal strain ratio is replaced by the principal stress ratio, where σp Rε + ν = (12.86) Rσ = 1 + ν Rε σq or, εp Rσ − ν Rε = = , (12.87) 1 − Rσ εq then 1 − Rσ (1 − cos 2β) × 100 , (12.88) 2Rσ Rσ−1 nq = (12.89) (1 − cos 2β) × 100 . 2 Equations (12.85), (12.88), and (12.89) will next be applied to an example in order to demonstrate the magnitudes of the errors encountered. np =
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
σp /σq = 2
6 5 4 3
rσq
2 1 0 –1
rσp
–2 –3 –4
n τmax
–5 –6 –7 –8
0
1
2
3
4
5 6 7 8 9 10 Rosette mounting error β (deg)
Fig. 12.39 Error in calculated principal stresses and maximum shear stress for a biaxial stress field with σp /σq = 2.0 caused by angular misalignment of a tee rosette
Consider first a thin-walled cylindrical pressure vessel. In this case, the hoop stress is twice the longitudinal stress, and of the same sign. Thus σp = Rσ = 2 , (12.90) σq
where σˆ p is the maximum principal stress as calculated from the gage readings, σˆ q is the minimum principal stress as calculated from gage readings, and τˆmax is the maximum shear stress as calculated from τˆmax = (σˆ p + σˆ q )/2. While the errors in the above case were very small, this is not true for stress fields involving extremes of Rσ . In general, n p becomes very large for |Rσ | 1.0, as does n q for |Rσ | 1.0. The error in the shear stress is independent of the stress state. The preceding generalities can be demonstrated by extending the previous case of the pressurized cylinder. Consider an internally pressurized cylinder with an axial compressive load applied externally to the ends. If, for example, the load were 0.8πr 2 p, where r is the inside radius of the cylinder and p is the internal pressure, the principal stress ratio would become Rσ = 10. Then, from (12.88) and (12.89), n p = −0.45(1 − cos 2β) × 100 , n q = 4.5(1 − cos 2β) × 100 .
(12.88b)
In this case, a 5◦
error in mounting the rosette produces a 0.68% error in σp and a 6.75% error in σq .
and (12.85), (12.88), and (12.89) become n τ = −(1 − cos 2β) × 100 , n p = −1/4(1 − cos 2β) × 100 , n q = 1/2(1 − cos 2β) × 100 .
(12.87b)
Rectangular (12.84a)
(12.88a)
3
2
2
1 1
Equations (12.84a), (12.87a), and (12.88a) are plotted in Fig. 12.39. From the figure, it can be seen that the errors introduced by rosette misalignment in this instance are quite small. For example, with a 5◦ mounting error, τmax , σp , and σq are in error by only − 1.5%, − 0.38%, and + 0.75%, respectively. In order to correct for a known misalignment by reading the value of n from Fig. 12.39, or any similar graph derived from the basic error equations (12.81), (12.83), (12.85), (12.88), and (12.89), it is only necessary to solve (12.80), (12.82), and (12.84) for σp , σq ,
3
3
(12.87a)
1
2
Delta 3
3 3
2
1 1
2
2
3
2 1
1
Fig. 12.40 Geometrically different, but functionally equiv-
alent, configurations of rectangular and delta rosettes
321
Part B 12.4
and τmax , respectively, and substitute the value of n from Fig. 12.39, including the sign. That is, σˆ p σp = (12.91) np , 1 + 100 σˆ q σq = (12.92) nq , 1 + 100 τˆmax τmax = (12.93) nτ , 1 + 100
Stress error (%) 8 7
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
322
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
The errors defined and evaluated in the foregoing occur, in each case, due to misalignment of a single gage or of an entire tee rosette. The effect of misalignment among the individual gages within a rosette is not treated in this discussion. Strain-Gage Rosettes A strain-gage rosette is, by definition, an arrangement of two or more closely positioned gage grids, separately oriented so as to measure the strains along different directions in the underlying surface of a test part. Rosettes are designed to serve a very practical purpose in experimental stress analysis. It can be shown that for the not uncommon case of the general biaxial stress state, with the principal directions unknown, three independent strain measurements (in different directions) are required to determine the principal strains and stresses. Even when the principal directions are known in advance, two independent strain measurements are needed to obtain principal strains and stresses. For the purpose of meeting these requirements, strain-gage manufacturers typically offer three basic types of strain gage rosettes, each in a variety of forms:
• • •
Tee – two perpendicular grids Rectangular – three grids, with the second and third grids angularly displaced from the first grid by 45 and 90◦ , respectively Delta – three grids, with the second and third grids 60 and 120◦ away, respectively, from the first grid
As illustrated in Fig. 12.40, rectangular and delta rosettes may appear in any of several geometrically different, but functionally equivalent, forms. It must be appreciated that, while the use of a strain gage rosette is in many cases a necessary condition for obtaining the principal strains, it is not a sufficient condition for doing so accurately. Knowledge in the selection and application of rosettes is crucial to their successful use in stress analysis; the following information is intended to be helpful in this process. Rosette Selection Considerations. In addition to the
usual parameters that must be considered in the selection of any strain gage (i. e., the strain-sensitive foil, backing material, self-temperature-compensation number, gage length, etc.) two other parameters are important in rosette selection (1) the rosette type (tee, rectangular, or delta) and (2) the rosette construction (planar or stacked). The tee rosette can be used only when the principal directions are known in advance from other considera-
tions. Cylindrical pressure vessels and shafts in torsion are two classical examples. However, care must be exercised in all such cases that extraneous stresses (bending, axial stress, etc.) are not present, since these will affect the directions of the principal axes. Attention must also be given to nearby geometric irregularities (holes, ribs, shoulders, etc.) that can locally alter the principal directions. When necessary (and, using the proper datareduction relationship), the tee rosette can be installed with its axes at any known angle from the principal axes, but greatest accuracy will be achieved when alignment is along the principal directions. In the latter case, ignoring the error due to transverse sensitivity, the two gage elements in the rosette indicate the corresponding principal strains directly. The principal strains can also be expressed in the following form, which parallels those given later for rectangular and delta rosettes εp,q =
ε1 + ε2 1 (ε1 − ε2 )2 . ± 2 2
(12.94)
When the directions of the principal strains are unknown, a three-element rectangular or delta rosette is required, and the rosette can be installed without regard to orientation. Functionally, there is little difference between the rectangular and delta rosettes. Because the gage axes in the delta rosette have the maximum possible uniform angular separation (effectively 120◦ ), this rosette is assumed to yield the optimum sampling of the underlying strain distribution. Rectangular rosettes have historically been the more popular of the two, primarily because the data-reduction relationships are somewhat simpler. Currently, however, with widespread access to computers and programmable calculators, the computational advantage of the rectangular rosette is of little consequence. As a result of the foregoing, the choice between rectangular and delta rosettes is apt to be based on practical considerations such as availability from stock, convenience of solder tab arrangement, and other pragmatic considerations. Data-reduction relationships for the two types of rosettes are as follows Rectangular: εp,q =
ε1 + ε3 1 ± √ (ε1 − ε2 )2 + (ε2 − ε3 )2 , 2 2
φp,q =
1 (ε2 − ε3 ) − (ε1 − ε2 ) tan−1 2 ε1 − ε3
(12.95)
,
(12.96)
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
ε1 + ε2 + ε3 εp,q = √ 3 2 (ε1 − ε2 )2 + (ε2 − ε3 )2 + (ε1 − ε3 )2 , ± 3 (12.97)
√ 3(ε2 − ε3 ) 1 −1 φp,q = tan (12.98) . 2 (ε1 − ε2 ) + (ε1 − ε3 ) For (12.94), (12.95), and (12.97), the first term on the right-hand side represents the distance to the center of Mohr’s circle for strain, and the second term represents the radius of the circle. All three types of rosettes (tee, rectangular, and delta) are manufactured in both planar and stacked versions. As indicated (for the rectangular rosette) in Fig. 12.41, the planar rosette is etched from the strainsensitive foil as an entity, with all gage elements lying in a single plane. The stacked rosette is manufactured by assembling and laminating two or three properly oriented single-element gages. When strain gradients in a)
Planar
1
b)
2
3
Stacked
the plane of the test part surface are not too severe, the normal selection is the planar rosette. This form of rosette offers a number of advantages in such cases:
• • • • • • •
thin and flexible minimal reinforcing effect superior heat dissipation to the substrate minimal sensitivity to strain gradients perpendicular to the surface (e.g., in bending) accepts all standard gage construction options optimal stability provides maximum freedom in leadwire routing and attachment
The principal disadvantages of the planar rosette arise from the larger surface area covered by the sensitive portion of the gage assembly. When the space available for gage installation is small, a stacked rosette may fit, although a planar rosette will not. More importantly, where a steep strain gradient exists in the surface plane of the test part, the individual gage elements in a planar rosette may sense different strain fields and magnitudes. For a given active gage length, the stacked rosette covers the least possible area, and therefore most nearly approaches measuring the strains at a point. It should be realized, however, that the stacked rosette is noticeably stiffer and less conformable than its planar counterpart. Also, because the heat conduction paths for the upper grids in a stacked rosette are much longer, the heat dissipation problem is more critical. This may necessitate reduction of the bridge voltage in order to achieve stable gage operation. Taking into account their poorer heat dissipation and their greater reinforcement effects, stacked rosettes are not commonly recommended for use on plastics and other nonmetallic materials. A stacked rosette can also give erroneous strain indications when applied to a thin specimen in bending, since the grid plane of the uppermost gage in a three-gage stack may be as much as 0.12 mm above the specimen surface. In short, the stacked rosette should ordinarily be reserved for applications in which the requirement for minimum surface area dictates its selection. General Errors and Corrections. Strain-gage rosettes
Fig. 12.41a,b Rectangular rosettes (of the same gage length) in (a) planar and (b) stacked construction
are subject, of course, to the same errors as singleelement gages (thermal output, leadwire resistance errors, etc.) and require the same controlling and/or corrective measures to obtain accurate data. There are, however, a few areas in the application of rosettes that require special attention. One, for example, is the sim-
323
Part B 12.4
Delta:
12.4 The Bonded Foil Strain Gage
324
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.4
a)
b) 2
1
2
3
1
c)
3
d)
3
1
1
3 2
2
Fig. 12.42 A counterclockwise numbering scheme for
grids in strain-gage rosettes
ple matter of how the gage elements on the rosette are numbered. The foregoing equations for calculating the principal strains and the principal angle from rectangular and delta rosette strain measurements implicitly assume that the gage elements are numbered in a particular manner. A useful guide for numbering and analyzing strain gage rosette data is provided in [12.21]. Improper numbering of the gage elements will lead to ambiguity in the interpretation of φp,q ; and, in the case of the rectangular rosette, can also cause errors in the calculated principal strains. Treating the latter situation first, it is always necessary in a rectangular rosette to assign gage numbers 1 and 3 to the two mutually perpendicular gages. Any other numbering arrangement will produce incorrect principal strains. Ambiguities in the interpretation of φp,q for both rectangular and delta rosettes can be eliminated by numbering the gage elements as follows. In a rectangular rosette, gage 2 must be 45◦ away from gage 1; and gage 3 must be 90◦ away, in the same direction. Similarly, in a delta rosette, gages 2 and 3 must be 60 and 120◦ away, respectively, in the same direction from gage 1. By definition φp,q is the acute angle from the axis of gage 1 to the nearest principal axis. When φp,q is positive, the direction is the same as that of the gage numbering; when negative, the opposite applies. If εi is algebraically greater than the center coordinate of
Mohr’s strain circle, the axis of maximum principal strain is indicated; if less, the axis of minimum principal strain is indicated. Numbering the gage elements clockwise or counterclockwise is incidental to the interpretation of φp,q , but the direction must be established with some care. Examples of the grid numbering for several representative rosette types are illustrated in Fig. 12.42. In (a), the gages in this rectangular rosette are numbered counterclockwise; while in (b), after conceptually transposing gage 2 across the diameter to satisfy the 45 and 90◦ requirements, the gages are numbered clockwise. Similarly, in (c), the gages in this delta rosette appear to be numbered clockwise; but when gage 2 is transposed diametrically so as to be 60◦ from gage 1, the numbering is counterclockwise. In contrast, the gages in the stacked delta rosette (d) require no readjustment because gages 2 and 3 are already 60 and 120◦ , respectively, away from gage 1 in the same direction, and the gages are numbered counterclockwise. Because at least one of the gages in any rosette will in every case be subjected to a transverse strain that is equal to or greater than the strain along the gage axis, consideration should always be given to the transverse-sensitivity error when performing rosette data reduction. The magnitude of the error in any particular case depends on the transverse-sensitivity coefficient (K t ) of the gage grid, and on the ratio of the principal strains, εp /εq . In general, then, when K t ≤ 0.01, the transverse sensitivity error is small enough to be ignored. However, for larger values of K t , depending on the required measurement accuracy, correction for transverse sensitivity may be necessary. Procedures and relationships for making such corrections are given in Sect. 12.4.3. A potentially serious source of error can be created when the strain-gage user decides to make up a rosette on the specimen from single-element strain gages. The error is caused by misalignment of the individual gages within the rosette. If, for example, the second and third gages in a rectangular rosette configuration are not accurately oriented at 45◦ and 90◦ , respectively, from the first gage, the calculated principal strains will be in error. The magnitude of the error depends, of course, on the magnitude (and direction) of the misalignment, but it also depends on the principal strain ratio εp /εq and on the overall orientation of the rosette with respect to the principal axes. For certain combinations of principal strain ratio and rosette orientation, 5◦ misalignment errors in gages 2 and 3 with respect to gage 1 can pro-
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
treme care should be exercised to obtain accurate gage alignment. When the principal strain directions can be known or determined, even approximately, alignment of gages 1 and 3 in a rectangular rosette, or alignment of any gage in a delta rosette, with a principal axis will minimize errors caused by intergage misalignment.
12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages If etched-foil strain gages are the common workhorse of the experimental mechanics community, then semiconductor gages live in the ivory tower. Fascinating in theory and construction, with extraordinary sensitivity and range, their use can be equally frustrating in practice, with difficult data analysis and unique handling requirements, often leading to disastrous results unless great attention is given to the details. Developed in the 1950s as an outgrowth of work performed at Bell Laboratories on semiconductor devices for the electronics industry, semiconductor strain gages were first described and popularized by Smith [12.22] and Mason et al. [12.23]. Like foil strain gages, semiconductor gages work on the principle of piezoresistance. However, the similarities end there and trying to acquire and analyze data using the same techniques will inadvertently lead to gross errors in strain measurement. The primary performance differences between foil gages and semiconductor gages are (1) the extraordinarily high strain sensitivity found in semiconductor gages (> 50 × that of foil gages), which leads to (2) extraordinarily high nonlinearity in resistance change with applied strain and in temperature response. The very high changes in resistance also cause difficulties when using the Wheatstone bridge (the normal circuit found in strain-gage instrumentation), because of the bridge’s own inherent nonlinearity (although, as shall be discussed, with certain gage/bridge combinations, one nonlinearity opposes the other to provide some nonlinearity cancellation). High strain sensitivity, rock-solid repeatability, and impressive reliability are the hallmark characteristics of semiconductor gages; these very features make them the only choice for certain measurement problems, particularly for applications involving low strains, or high cycles, or very long (kilometers) leadwires. Additionally, since the gages are single-crystal elements, they have no measurable hysteresis or creep, which makes
them attractive for long-term installations, or for use in unique transducer applications, especially where long fatigue life is also a requirement. The fundamental understanding of semiconductor strain gages with respect to strain and temperature response was developed by Dorsey in the early 1960s and published by BLH Electronics of Waltham, MA in a series of eight papers under the common title, Semiconductor Strain Gage Handbook. The treatment of the operational characteristics of these unique sensors presented here follows that work.
12.5.1 Manufacturing Semiconductor strain gages are produced from either single-crystal silicon or germanium, with silicon being most widely used. Pure silicon is usually doped with another element to improve performance characteristics of the sensors. Since the single-crystal materials have a very high resistivity, most gages are simple singlestrand designs, unlike the sinuous patterns required with foil. Single-crystal silicon is grown in a rod shape called a boule, which is frequently referred to as an ingot because of its similar function as that found in the production of metal alloys. The boule is normally about 50 mm in diameter. Slices are precisely cut from the boule on what are labeled Miller indices, typically the (111) and (100) axis. The respective axis is chosen dependent upon the impurity to be added later. Pure silicon has several characteristics which can be improved for strain gage use by adding impurities from either the third or fifth group of the Periodic Table. This not only reduces the intrinsically high resistivity, but also reduces the nonlinear electrical resistance behavior inherent with the pure material. Two common additives are phosphorus and boron. When phosphorus is used, the electrical conduction mechanism of the resulting alloy is by negative elec-
325
Part B 12.5
duce an error of 20% or more in one of the principal strains. Since it is very difficult for most people to install a small strain gage precisely aligned, the user is well advised to employ commercial rosettes. For those cases in which it is necessary, for whatever reason, to assemble a rosette from single-element gages, ex-
12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages
326
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.5 Fig. 12.43 Three examples of finished semiconductor strain gages (the bottom example is unbacked)
trons, which is labelled n-conduction. Hence, gages manufactured from this material are commonly called n-type gages, and they happen to have negative strain sensitivity (decrease in electrical resistance with tensile strain). For n-type gages, the boule is sliced on the (100) axis. The use of boron as an additive results in conduction by positive holes, or vacancies, and is termed p-conduction. Therefore, strain gages made using phosphorus-doped silicon are typically called p-type gages, and have a positive gage factor. P-type gages are made from material sliced on the (111) axis. ΔR/R0
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2 0.1 –5000
– 4000
–3000
Compression strain ( μm/m)
–2000
–1000
1000 – 0.1 – 0.2
2000
3000
Tension strain ( μm/m)
Fig. 12.44 Strain sensitivity of high resistance (undoped) p-type
silicon
Diffusion of the additions (doping), or impurities, is administered in a furnace at temperatures above 1000 ◦ C. Slices are placed in the furnace and an inert gas containing the desired dopant is passed through the chamber. In general, higher levels of the impurity further reduce resistivity and nonlinearity, but there is a practical limit, restricted by the ability to consistently and uniformly diffuse atoms into the silicon slices. Dopant levels are dictated by the desired roomtemperature resistivity of the finished slice. For p-type material, a value of 0.02 Ω cm is normal, and the diffusion time is chosen to achieve this value. As will be discussed later, n-type gages have a unique behavior (negative strain sensitivity), which allows processing for self-temperature compensation on select materials. Therefore, room-temperature resistivity varies with compensation number, ranging from a low of 0.01 to a high of 0.04 Ω cm. The finished slices are then processed by photolithographic masking and etching techniques, similar to those used in the manufacturing of etched-foil gages, to form a pattern of gages on each slice. Because of the high resistivity, these sensors are normally straight lengths of silicon, or infrequently U-shaped, less than 0.5 mm wide by about 0.05 mm thick, with some higher resistance sensors having a thickness of only 0.01 mm. Further masking and processing deposits a thin film of metal, usually aluminum or gold, to form connection pads. Pure gold leads are attached to these pads, usually through a welding operation. These leads serve as jumpers to the final instrument lead, which is welded to the gold jumpers. The individual gages are then separated from the slice by etching and lapping/polishing. It is during this stage that the flexibility and fatigue resistance of the sensor is developed. Great care is exercised to achieve a very smooth and defect-free surface. The bare silicon strip can be used as is, or to enhance handling and robustness it can be attached to an insulating carrier, much like foil strain gages. Some examples are shown in Fig. 12.43. At this point, some unique characteristics of semiconductor gages surface. For example, even when using very controlled and precise production methods, there is no guarantee the individual gages will be close in strain and temperature sensitivity. This is easily understood, considering the bulk nature of the impurity diffusion process. Also, there is not normally a simple method of adjusting the initial resistance of the individual gages. To overcome these limitations, manufacturers will provide matched sets, typically in lots of four. These matched sets can have a nominal initial resistance
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
ΔR/R0 0.6 0.5
12.5.2 Strain Sensitivity
0.4
Analogous to foil strain gages, change in semiconductor gage resistance is dependent upon several parameters, including: absolute temperature (T ), strain level (ε), unstressed resistance (R0 ), material resistivity (ρ), and geometric design, all of which have some temperaturesensitive component. Since strain sensitivity is the primary concern here, this may be expressed qualitatively as ε ε2 ε3 ΔR = f (12.99) , 2, 3 ... , R0 T T T which can be written quantitatively as ΔR = C 1 ε + C 2 ε2 + · · · , R0
0.2
– 4000
–3000
–2000
0.1 –1000
1000
2000
3000
4000
Tension strain ( μm/m)
– 0.1
Bonded gage condition
– 0.2 – 0.3 – 0.4 – 0.5
Fig. 12.45 Strain sensitivity of 0.02 Ω cm silicon (12.100)
where C1 and C2 are experimentally determined constants, themselves a function of temperature. Note that powers higher than strain squared in (12.99) are ignored, since the product of strain cubed and a fitted calibration constant C3 (≈ 35 000) is negligibly small. Equation (12.100) describes a parabola and is plotted in Fig. 12.44 for T = 25 ◦ C using C1 = 175 and C2 = 72 625, which are values given by Mason [12.23] for high-resistivity (low-doping) p-type silicon. Note that the inflection point for (12.100) is described by ε=
0.3
Compression strain ( μm/m)
−C1 ΔR −C12 , = . 2C2 R0 4C2
The most popular p-type silicon material has a roomtemperature resistivity of approximately 0.02 Ω cm. The experimental determination of the change in resistance versus strain for this material is plotted in Fig. 12.45. Note that the act of bonding semiconductor gages tends to move the initial resistance along the curve (denoted by a cross in the figure), which alters the starting sensitivity. Using a best-fit parabola for this curve yields C1 = 119.5 and C2 = 4000, which is different from the values found by Mason for low-doped silicon. Apparently, the many-valley theory that works well in describing low-doped p-type silicon does not hold for high doping levels. Since C1 is the slope of the parabola at the origin, it could be considered the basic strain sensitivity, or gage factor, for this material. However, a quick study
ΔR/R0 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 – 4000
–3000
–2000
Compression strain ( μm/m)
–1000
1000 – 0.1 – 0.2
327
Part B 12.5
tolerance of better than ±2% and a nominal matched temperature sensitivity of ±0.2% over a 110 ◦ C temperature range.
12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages
2000
3000
4000
Tension strain ( μm/m)
– 0.3
Fig. 12.46 Strain sensitivity of 0.031 Ω cm n-type silicon
of Fig. 12.45 reveals an inherent nonlinear change in resistance with applied strain. N-type silicon gages behave similarly to the p-type just discussed, the most significant difference being a reduction in resistance when stretched. That is, n-type gages have a negative gage factor. This behavior is plotted in Fig. 12.46 for a highly doped, low-resistivity (0.031 Ω cm) n-type gage. In this example, the strain relationship is given by (12.100), where C1 = −110 and C2 = 10 000. An interesting observation from Fig. 12.46 is that, given the normal compressive strain locked into a bonded gage during the adhesive cure cycle, which
328
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.5
is caused by the differential expansion of the gage and specimen at the cure temperature, the resistance will be shifted up the curve, toward the more linear portion. When n-type gages are pre-installed on a thin shim for subsequent spot-welding to a specimen, the manufacturer can prestress the shim and force the installed resistance into the more linear region of the curve, thus improving linearity response to service strains. This is beneficial, because as can also be seen from the figure, n-type gages are inherently more nonlinear than p-type.
Temperature changes affect the resistance (TCR) and the sensitivity (TC of gage factor) of semiconductor strain gages. Because gage sensitivity varies with applied strain, the process of determining this effect, suitable for use in strain data correction, is different from the method used with foil gages. To better understand the issues involved with temperature sensitivity, it is necessary to examine (12.100) more closely, which, by ignoring terms higher than squared, can be expanded as: 298 298 2 2 ΔR = C2 ε . (12.101) F0 ε + R0 T T In this equation, 298 refers to an arbitrarily selected reference at room temperature in Kelvin, F0 is the reference-temperature gage factor, and C2 is the reference temperature calibration constant; ε is, of course, the applied strain. Noting that F0 will vary inversely as a function of T , and that C2 will change with the ΔR /R0 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.05 Ω cm 0.2 0.02 Ω cm
0.1 0.01 Ω cm
0.05 0 23.8
50
75
100
125
150
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 12.47 Thermal output of p-type silicon, various resis-
tivities
0.3 0.25 0.04 Ω cm 0.2 0.031 Ω cm 0.15 0.25 Ω cm 0.1
0.018 Ω cm
0.05 0 –0.025 23.8
12.5.3 Temperature Sensitivity
0.15
ΔR /R0
0.01 Ω cm 50
75
100
125
150
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 12.48 Thermal output of n-type silicon, various resis-
tivities
square of the inverse of T , suggests that higher temperature changes result in more linear gage output. For p-type sensors, output becomes more linear with increased temperature for two distinct reasons. First, C2 decreases rapidly in comparison with gage factor and, second, most materials expand at a rate higher than p-type silicon, which has a TCE of 1.5–3.0 ppm/◦ C. Consequentially, a tensile strain is exerted on the gage as temperature rises, and as can be seen from Fig. 12.45, the higher the tensile strain, the more linear the gage response. The usual method of bonding a strain gage to a reference material and subjecting the installation to a temperature excursion of interest will yield false thermal output data from semiconductor gages, because the gage sensitivity changes so dramatically with temperature. Additionally, unless assurance can be given of a zero state of stress in the installed gage (very difficult), the initial resistance at room temperature R0 will not be that of the free filament. Therefore, the starting point for generating a thermal output curve is shifted (Figs. 12.45 and 12.46) from the origin, and the resistance–temperature relationship is not valid for general use. If the exact conditions present during such a calibration are also those encountered during a subsequent test (e.g., using the installed gage as a temperature sensor), then this procedure is adequate. Otherwise, and most typically, this is not the case, which leads to the inconvenient task of either measuring the resistance changes with applied temperature of an unbonded sensor, or employing a fixture suitable for correcting the temperature-induced strain in the gage, present because of different TCE values between the gage and specimen.
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
Temperature Compensation Given the above discussion on the strain–temperature characteristics of semiconductor gages, it should be no surprise that both the determination of and implementation of temperature compensation for stress analysis applications is both different and somewhat more involved than that which is employed with foil gages. There is no heat-treatment option available for silicon-based sensors to finely alter the intrinsic TCR. However, the negative gage factor of n-type silicon can be exploited to provide a rudimentary compensation on certain materials. This is best explained by examining the bonded TCR as given by
βb = β + (αs − αg )F ,
Gage factor 0
100
125
150
175
200 1
1.05
3034 Aluminum
1.1 0.9 300 Series stainless steel 1.15 0.85
1018 Steel 1.2
Data correction factor
Fig. 12.49 TC of gage factor for 0.02 Ω cm p-type strain gages bonded to 1018 steel (11.7 ppm/◦ C), 300series stainless steel (17.1 ppm/◦ C), and 2024 aluminum (23.4 ppm/◦ C) with constant-current bridge excitation
range of −100 to −135, it is clear from this example how a select group of specimen materials can be self-temperature compensated. Although limited in application, self-temperature-compensated n-type sensors are the most economical way to achieve temperature compensation with semiconductor gages. Taking advantage of the opposite-sign strain sensitivities for p- and n-type gages, and the additive nature Gage factor (% of room-temp. value) 100
where βb is the bonded TCR, β is the unbonded TCR, αs is the specimen TCE, αg is the gage TCE, and F is the gage factor. The bonded TCR, βb , will be zero, or negative, when the differential expansion term in (12.102) is equal to or exceeds the unbonded gage TCR, β. Thus the condition for self-temperature compensation is approximated when STC ≈ αs , where
90
For example, a backed n-type gage having F = −110, αg = 2.5 ppm/◦ C, and β = 1080 ppm/◦ C is essentially self-compensated when bonded to a mild steel specimen (αs = 11.7 ppm/◦ C and STC = 12.3 ppm/◦ C). With highly doped n-type gages having a gage factor
75
0.95
110
(12.103)
Temperature (°C) 50
1
(12.102)
β STC = αg + . |F|
25
0
25
50
75
Temperature (°C) 100
125
150
175
200 1
1018 Steel
80
1.2
1.4
70 300 Series stainless steel
1.6
60 2024 Aluminum 50
1.8
2
Data correction factor
Fig. 12.50 TC of gage factor for STC n-type strain gages on 1018 steel (11.7 ppm/◦ C), 300-series stainless steel (17.1 ppm/◦ C), and 2024 aluminum (23.4 ppm/◦ C) with constant-current bridge excitation
329
Part B 12.5
In the former, care must be taken to avoid excessive self-heating of the free filament; use of a liquid environment is beneficial. In the latter, a fixture must be used to relieve the temperature-induced tensile strain in the gage, by applying a corresponding compressive strain in the specimen. Typical thermal output curves from various resistivity p-type and n-type unstressed gages are shown in Figs. 12.47 and 12.48, respectively. Essential to the interpretation of (12.101) and these figures is the understanding that R0 is the unstrained resistance at temperature T , and that it varies with T [12.24]. There will be a different R0 at each temperature. Interestingly, even though n-type semiconductor strain gages have a negative strain sensitivity, like ptype sensors, they too have a positive TCR. As is discussed in the next section, it is these unique characteristics of n-type gages which provide a means of rudimentary self-temperature compensation on select materials.
12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages
330
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12.5
of adjacent arms in a Wheatstone bridge, provides another method to achieve self-temperature compensation. This technique is commonly referred to as circuit compensation with push–pull gages, and is similar to the dummy-gage method, but relieves the necessity of ensuring zero stress on the compensating gage (dummy gage). In the push–pull method, a p-type and an n-type gage are bonded side-by-side on the test piece and wired as adjacent arms in the Wheatstone bridge. Assuming equal gage TCE values, the difference in bonded gage TCR is βp − βn = (Fn − Fp )(αs − αg ) .
An obvious benefit of the push–pull method is the ability to combine more gage characteristics and, therefore, compensate for more specimen materials. While not usually a concern with semiconductor gages, the push– pull method also increases bridge output. TC of Gage Factor Compensation The temperature coefficient of gage factor is negative for both p- and n-type gages. Much of the drop in sensitivity with increased temperature is the result of the large, positive TCR of silicon, causing the gage resistance (R) to increase significantly, thus decreasing the
0 100
25
50
75
Temperature (°C) 100
125
110
25
50
100
150
175
200
75
Temperature (°C) 100
125
150
175
200 1
90 1.2
80
1.4
70
1.6 60 1.8 50
2
Data correction factor
Fig. 12.52 TC of gage factor for any STC n-type strain
gage bonded to the matching material with constantvoltage bridge excitation
apparent sensitivity (ΔR/R). An obvious way to eliminate this effect is by using constant-current excitation. This obvious conclusion illustrates a not-so-obvious issue when using semiconductor gages: the choice of excitation can dramatically influence correction of acquired strain data. Figures 12.49 and 12.50 show TC of gage factor curves for p- and n-type sensors, respectively, on several different materials and with constant-current excitation. Figures 12.51 and 12.52 provide the same information with constant-voltage excitation. From these figures the benefit of constant-current excitation is clear. However, most commercial strain gage instrumentation utilizes constant-voltage bridge excitation.
1
90 80
0
(12.104)
Temperature compensation is approximated when STCc ≈ αs , where, βp − βg STCc = αg + . (12.105) Fn − Fp
Gage factor (% of room-temp. value)
Gage factor (% of room-temp. value)
RS /2 1.25
70
V 1.5
60 1.75
RS /2
Data correction factor
Fig. 12.51 TC of gage factor for p-type silicon with constant-voltage bridge excitation
Fig. 12.53 Full-bridge semiconductor circuit showing the inclusion of compensation resistors for TC of gage factor
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
|FTb | Rs = , RB mβb − |FT |
(12.106)
where Rs is the value of compensation resistor, RB is the total bridge resistance across the power corners, FTb is the bonded gage TC of gage factor, m = 1 for full-bridge or 0.5 for half-bridge installations, βb is the bonded gage TCR (12.102), and FT is the unbonded gage TC of gage factor. It is usual practice to insert one-half of Rs into each of the two power leads, although this is not a requirement.
12.5.4 Special Circuit Considerations Given their high sensitivity to strain, semiconductor gages do lend themselves to use with elementary or potentiometer circuits. However, the common-mode voltage is still problematic and must be subtracted away from the measurement. Still, there are recorded instances of accurate strain measurement, and especially troubleshooting, of semiconductor installations by use of a simple ohm-meter [12.25]. Apparent from previous discussions is the relatively large resistance shifts encountered with semiconductor gages, caused by any stimulant. In some ways these large changes make for simpler interrogation of the sensors, but it can also make the job more difficult, as almost all modern strain-gage instrumentation operates with a constant-voltage Wheatstone bridge. Nonlinearity Errors Because of the large resistance changes encountered with semiconductor gages, steps must be taken to address the inherent nonlinearity associated with this condition in the constant-voltage Wheatstone bridge, especially if the typical stress analysis quarter-bridge
circuit is employed. In fact, use of this circuit is rare with semiconductor gages, half- and full-bridge installations being the norm. One method to overcome the linearity concern in a constant-voltage, quarter-bridge circuit is to buck the inherent bridge nonlinearity with that of the gage. As shown in Fig. 12.45 for p-type silicon, the nonlinearity is concave up. The nonlinear bridge output for a quarter-bridge circuit is concave down. With the gage designated by Rg , and occupying the R1 (Fig. 12.4) position in the bridge, this can be written as ⎛ ⎞ ⎜ E0 = E ⎜ ⎝
⎟ ΔRg R3 ⎟. × ΔRg (Rg + R4 )(R2 + R3 ) ⎠ 1+ Rg + R4 (12.107)
To counteract the expected high resistance changes of Rg relative to the other bridge resistances, R3 and R4 can be made larger than Rg and R2 , by a multiplier. With the multiplier equal to 10, for example, the nonlinearity is reduced to about 10% of its normal value [12.26]. Although unattractive because of a loss in sensitivity, another method of linearization is simply to desensitize the output by shunting the active gage, which has the combined effect of lowering circuit output and reducing nonlinearity. However, for a shunt ratio of 1.5 (shunt resistance to installed gage resistance), which produces a quite linear output curve, the reduction in output sensitivity to applied strain is 44%. Like the multigage methods used for temperature compensation, use of push–pull gages and p/n-type pairs can also reduce circuit nonlinearity. Push–pull gages do not completely eliminate the nonlinear output, but through careful selection of gage pairs, placed in adjacent arms of the bridge, with one gage sensing compressive strain and the other sensing tensile strain, linearity is improved and output is increased. The same result is achieved when a full bridge is employed, as is the case in most semiconductor-based transducers. P- and n-type gages can be chosen and mounted side by side (sensing the same strain) to achieve partial circuit linearization, but the method is imperfect, because n-type gages are more nonlinear than p-type. Leadwire Attenuation Leadwire attenuation is less serious with semiconductor gages, because the gages have such large resistance changes when compared to any realistic leadwire contribution, and the sensitivity is so high in comparison to
331
Part B 12.5
Since all semiconductor gages have a positive TCR and a negative TC of gage factor, gage factor change with temperature can be compensated by increasing the bridge supply voltage in proportion to the loss in sensitivity. This is accomplished by inserting low-TCR, fixed resistors in series with bridge power leads, as shown in Fig. 12.53. In this circuit, the bridge is considered a single, variable resistor with positive TCR, and the circuit acts like a voltage divider. By choosing the ratio of series resistance to bridge resistance equal to the ratio of bridge TCR to TC of gage factor, the increase in bridge voltage resulting from the positive bridge TCR can be made to offset the drop in bridge sensitivity caused by the negative TC of gage factor, thus
12.5 Semiconductor Strain Gages
332
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 12
any leadwire desensitization. When using the Wheatstone bridge circuit, however, it is still necessary to give consideration to leadwire affects, as discussed in Sect. 12.4.8 on foil gages.
12.5.5 Installation Techniques Installation techniques for backed semiconductor gages are no different from those used with backed foil gages [12.27]. However, care must be exercised to avoid undue resistance shifts during installation, or at least the installed resistance must be accurately measured to determine where on the strain-sensitivity curve the installed gage falls. Also, methods are available for prestraining the installation, to provide a specific initial condition. This is most frequently done to match the performance of one gage against another to aid linearity and/or temperature compensation. These methods are beyond the scope of this overview treatment, but can be studied in the literature [12.2, 28, 29]. Free-filament semiconductor gages are rarely used in experimental stress analysis work. They are, however,
popular in certain transducer applications. Installation of the free filament is straightforward. The specimen surface is prepared in accordance with normal straingage procedures, and then a thin precoat of adhesive is cured on the specimen surface to act as an insulator. This precoat is subsequently abraded to remove the glossy finish, and the gage is laid in a pool of adhesive on top of the prepared precoat layer. No pressure is necessary, as capillary action will form a smooth, thin glue line, even in the overhead position. Most often instrument leads are welded to the preattached wires supplied by the manufacturer. This is because the normal wire material used by the manufacturer is a delicate gold, which does not solder well. However, gages can also be supplied with heavy-gage lead ribbons already welded to the gold jumpers. These heavier ribbons accept the same soldering techniques as any strain-gage installation. Obviously, care must be taken to ensure stress relief in the instrument leads, so that subsequent loading of the part does not tear off the leadwire.
References 12.1
12.2 12.3
12.4
12.5
12.6 12.7
12.8
12.9
P.K. Stein: 1936 – a banner year for strain gages and experimental stress analysis – an historical perspective, Exp. Tech. 30(1), 23–41 (2006) A.L. Window, G.S. Holister: Strain Gage Technology (Applied Science, London 1982) ASTM: Standard Test Methods for Performance Characteristics of Metallic Bonded Resistance Strain Gages, Vol. E 251 (ASTM Int., West Conshohocken 2003) BIML: Performance Characteristics of Metallic Resistance Strain Gauges, Vol. 62 (Bureau International de Metrologie Legale, Paris 1985) VDE/VDI: Bonded Electric Resistance Strain Gauges with Metallic Measurement Grids – Characteristics and Testing Conditions, VDE/VDI – Richtlinien, Vol. 2635 (Verein Deutscher Ingenieure, Düsseldorf 1974) J.P. Holman: Experimental Methods for Engineers (McGraw-Hill, New York 1989) G.F. Chalmers: The dangers of the 5% mentality, Proc. Int. Conf., BSSM & The Institution of Production Engineers (UK 1980) R.B. Watson, D. Post: Precision strain standard by moire interferometry for strain gage calibration, Exp. Mech. 22(7), 256–261 (1982) R.B. Watson: Calibration techniques for extensometry: Possible standards of strain measurement, J. Test. Eval. 21(6), 515–521 (1993)
12.10
12.11
12.12
12.13
12.14
12.15
12.16 12.17
Vishay: Errors Due to Transverse Sensitivity in Strain Gages, Technical Note TN-509 (Document Number: 11051), (Vishay Micro-Measurements, Raleigh 2007) R.B. Watson, C.C. Perry, S.K. Harris: Effects of material properties and heating/cooling rate on strain gage thermal output observations, ICEM12 – 12th Int. Conf. Experimental Mechanics (Politecnico di Bari, Italy 2004) R.B. Watson, C.C. Perry: The intelligent use of strain gage thermal output, Proceedings of the 2002 Conf. on Experimental Mechanics (The Society for Experimental Mechanics, Bethel 2002) F.F. Hines: Effect of mounting surface curvature on the temperature coefficient of bonded resistance strain gages, Proceedings, Western Regional Strain Gage Committee (The Society for Experimental Mechanics, Bethel 1960), pp 39–44 ASTM: Standard Test Method for Ambient Temperature Fatigue Life of Metallic bonded Resistance Strain Gages, Vol. E 1949 (ASTM Int., West Conshohocken 2003) C. C. Perry: Strain gage reinforcement effects on low-modulus materials, Exp. Tech. 9(5), 25–27 (1985) E.G. Little, D. Tocher, P. O’Donnell: Strain gauge reinforcement of plastics, Strain 26(3), 91–97 (1990) A. Ajovalasit, B. Zuccarello: Local reinforcement effect of a strain gauge installation on low modulus materials, J. Strain Anal. 40(7), 643–653 (2005)
Bonded Electrical Resistance Strain Gages
12.19
12.20
12.21
12.22 12.23
P.G. Ifju, D. Post: A Compact Double Notched Specimen for In-Plane Shear Testing, Proc. 1989 Conf. on Experimental Mechanics (The Society for Experimental Mechanics, Bethel 1989) M.-J. Pindera, P.G. Ifju, D. Post: Iosipescu shear characterization of polymeric and metal matrix composites, Exp. Mech. 30(1), 101–108 (1990) R.B. Watson, C.C. Perry: Factors influencing the measurement of shear properties when using vnotch specimens with strain gages, Proc. 2nd European Conf. on Composites (ECCM-CTS2) (Hamburg 1994) ASTM: Standard Practice for Analysis of Strain Gage Rosette Data, Vol. E 1561 (ASTM Int., West Conshohocken 2003) C.S. Smith: Piezoresistive effect in silicon and germanium, Phys. Rev. 94(42) (1954) W.P. Mason, J.J. Forst, L.M. Tornillo: Recent Developments in Semiconductor Strain Transducers,
12.24
12.25
12.26 12.27
12.28
12.29
Vol. 15-NY-60 (Instrument Society of America, Research Triangle Park 1960), Preprint J.Dorsey: BLH Semiconductor Strain Gage Handbook (Theory), Section I, (Vishay Micro-Measurements, Raleigh 1964) J. Dorsey: BLH Semiconductor Strain Gage Handbook (Strain Measurement), Section VII, (Vishay Micro-Measurements, Raleigh 1965) H.K.P. Neubert: Strain Gauges (Macmillan, London 1967) ASTM: Standard Guide for Installing Bonded Resistance Strain Gages, Vol. E 1561 (ASTM, West Conshohocken 2003) J. Dorsey: BLH Semiconductor Strain Gage Handbook (Gage Application), Section IV, (Vishay MicroMeasurements, Raleigh 1964) Micron Instruments: Installation of Semiconductor Strain Gages, Technical Note, Rev. 1.01, (Micron Instruments, Simi Valley 2005)
333
Part B 12
12.18
References
335
Extensomete 13. Extensometers
The important characteristics and construction of the common types of extensometers are reviewed. Extensometers are the most convenient and widely used instruments for the measurement of strain in a material test specimen. Traditionally extensometers have been based around contacting techniques, however noncontacting optical techniques are becoming more important and the two approaches are compared in this chapter. Whichever technique is employed it is important to be aware of the possible influence of the extensometer on the test specimen and the need to match the extensometer to the specimen, environment, and test being carried out.
13.2.5 Linear Incremental Encoders ......... 338 13.2.6 Electronics and Signal Conditioning 338 13.3 Ambient-Temperature Contacting Extensometers ..................... 13.3.1 Clip-On Axial Extensometers .......... 13.3.2 Other Types of Clip-On Extensometers ............................. 13.3.3 Long-Travel (Elastomeric) Extensometers ............................. 13.3.4 Automatic Extensometers ..............
338 338 340 340 341
13.4 High-Temperature Contacting Extensometers ..................... 341 13.4.1 Longitudinal-Type High-Temperature Extensometers .. 341 13.4.2 Side-Loading High-Temperature Extensometers ............................. 341
13.1 General Characteristics of Extensometers 13.1.1 Accuracy...................................... 13.1.2 Resolution................................... 13.1.3 Stability ...................................... 13.1.4 Temperature Coefficient ................ 13.1.5 Operating Force ........................... 13.1.6 Contact Force ............................... 13.1.7 Weight ........................................ 13.1.8 Response Time/Bandwidth ............ 13.1.9 Kinematics and Constraints ...........
336 336 336 336 336 337 337 337 337 337
13.5 Noncontact Extensometers .................... 13.5.1 Optical Targets ............................. 13.5.2 Servo Follower Type Optical Extensometers ............................. 13.5.3 Scanning Laser Extensometers ....... 13.5.4 Video Extensometers .................... 13.5.5 Other Noncontact Optical Extensometers ............................. 13.5.6 Noncontact Extensometers for High-Temperature Testing ........
13.2 Transducer Types and Signal Conditioning 13.2.1 Strain-Gaged Flexures .................. 13.2.2 LVDTs .......................................... 13.2.3 Potentiometers ............................ 13.2.4 Capacitance Transducers ...............
337 337 337 338 338
13.6 Contacting versus Noncontacting Extensometers ..................................... 345
Extensometers provide the most convenient way of accurately measuring the average strain in the gage section of a material test specimen. Alternative methods such as attempting to determine strain from the movement of the test machine or using bonded strain gages are either much less accurate or are more complex and involve a significant amount of specimen preparation.
343 343 344 344 344 344 345
13.7 Conclusions .......................................... 346 References .................................................. 346
There are a wide range of different types of extensometer covering many materials, applications, and environments. Applications range from multi-axis cyclic fatigue testing to high-throughput, industrial quality control, tensile testing. Materials range from tissues and other biological materials to concrete and other construction materials. Environments range from
Part B 13
Ian McEnteggart
336
Part B
Contact Methods
liquid-helium cryostats through saline baths at body temperature to ultrahigh-temperature furnaces. Extensometers have the potential to influence the behavior of the test specimen, and the strain measurements obtained are often influenced by the extensome-
ter’s mounting and environment. In order to obtain representative and repeatable strain results from an extensometer it is very important that the user of these devices understands their operating principles and characteristics.
Part B 13.1
13.1 General Characteristics of Extensometers 13.1.1 Accuracy The ability of a measurement system using an extensometer to measure accurately the strain in a test specimen depends on both the gage length and extension accuracy. The gage length accuracy of an extensometer can be verified by directly measuring the distance between the extensometer knife edges using, for example, a calibrated traveling microscope. Alternatively the marks made by the knife edges in a soft material, e.g., copper can be measured using the same type of equipment. Verification of extensometer extension measurement performance at ambient temperature can be achieved using calibrated displacement reference devices (e.g., precision micrometers or laser interferometers). Practical considerations dictate that most hightemperature extensometers are verified at ambient temperatures. It is, however, desirable to check the accuracy of these extensometers at temperature, in the test configuration in which they are to be used. Such a verification can be performed by providing extended rods that allow the reference device to be located outside the high-temperature environment (i. e., a temperature chamber or furnace) and the motion to be transmitted to the extensometer which is located inside the hightemperature environment [13.1]. Methods of verifying the accuracy of contacting extensometers are defined in various standards [13.1, 2]. Regular verification checks on extensometer accuracy are recommended, particularly in the case of extensometers which are used for testing materials which release large amounts of energy at failure and subject the extensometer to repeated shock loads.
13.1.2 Resolution The resolution of a measurement device or system is usually defined as the smallest discernible change in the measured value. For extensometers based on analogue transducers the resolution can be taken as being equal
to one-half of the noise level. For extensometers based on digital transducers (e.g., optical encoders) the resolution is usually equal to the resolution of the digital transducer. Signal processing techniques, such as oversampling, filtering, and resampling, can increase the effective resolution of a transducer system. It should be clear that a good resolution specification for an extensometer does not necessarily imply a corresponding high accuracy, and both specifications should be checked when selecting an extensometer for an application.
13.1.3 Stability The stability of an extensometer is the drift in the measured value as a function of time. Zero, or balance, stability can be expressed as a fraction of the full-scale change in output the over a given time period. Span stability is similarly expressed as a change in full-scale output sensitivity over time. Stability is important for extensometers used in long-term creep or fatigue testing.
13.1.4 Temperature Coefficient The temperature coefficient of an extensometer is a measure of the change in output as a function of temperature. The temperature coefficient is expressed as a fraction of the full-scale change in output for a defined change in temperature. As for stability, the temperature coefficient is generally unimportant in short-duration tension or compression tests but it is important in long-term testing. It should be noted that extensometer temperature coefficients are almost always quoted for isothermal conditions, i. e., when there are no temperature gradients across the extensometer. In some situations, e.g., high-temperature extensometers used with tube-type, furnaces there can be large temperature gradients across the extensometer; in these cases the temperature coefficient should be checked in the test configuration.
Extensometers
13.1.5 Operating Force
13.1.6 Contact Force The contact force is the force applied to the knife edges to keep them attached to the specimen and to prevent them from slipping. The required contact force is determined by both the weight and operating force of the extensometer.
13.1.7 Weight The weight of an extensometer can be important when testing delicate materials, as the weight of the extensometer has to be supported by the specimen via the knife edges. In some cases supporting springs or a counterbalance system can reduce the effective weight of the extensometer.
13.1.8 Response Time/Bandwidth The extensometer system (i. e., the combination of the extensometer and the associated signal condition-
ing electronics) must have a sufficiently fast response, to follow the behavior of the material in a test. Most modern systems have a sufficiently rapid response for monitoring strain in routine tensile testing. Extensometers used as strain feedback devices for machine control or for use in high-frequency cyclic testing (> 10 Hz) need to have a fast-response, wide bandwidth and be free of resonances within the control bandwidth. Reference [13.1] outlines a method that can be used to investigate the suitability of an extensometer for dynamic use.
13.1.9 Kinematics and Constraints The strain measured by an ideal extensometer will be unaffected by the presence of mechanical mounting constraints and will only be sensitive to specimen strain. In practice extensometers, apart from clip-on types, require some form of independent mechanical mounting. The extensometer mounting is a constraint which can influence the strain measurement, e.g., errors in the measured strain can be introduced by lateral movement of the specimen at the start of a tensile test in a machine with a self-aligning load string. The principles and details of kinematic design are explained in Chap. 3 of [13.3].
13.2 Transducer Types and Signal Conditioning Modern extensometers make use of a number of different transducers to convert mechanical deflections into electrical output signals that can be easily processed and recorded. Transducers in common use include 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
strain-gaged flexures linear variable differential transformers (LVDTs) potentiometers capacitance transducers linear incremental encoders
13.2.1 Strain-Gaged Flexures In this type of transducer a number of foil-type strain gages (usually four) are bonded to a flexural beam and electrically connected in the form of a Wheatstone bridge. Bending of the beam causes a change in resistance of the gages [13.4]. The change in resistance is
small and the full-scale electrical output signal from the bridge is typically 2 mV/V, however modern signal conditioning electronics can measure the signals from such bridges with great stability and accuracy. Provided that the flexure is deformed elastically it has excellent linearity and repeatability [13.5]. Strain-gaged flexures have a significant operatingforce; however they have the advantages of being of small size and having low mass. The operating temperature range of foil-type strain gages, suitable for transducer use, ranges from cryogenic temperatures to about 200 ◦ C.
13.2.2 LVDTs A LVDT is basically a transformer with variable coupling between two or more inductance coils [13.4]. LVDTs are usually of a cylindrical form with a central
337
Part B 13.2
The operating force of an extensometer is the force required to displace the extensometer knife edges by a known amount. The operating force is usually expressed as a force divided by the full-scale displacement of the extensometer.
13.2 Transducer Types and Signal Conditioning
338
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 13.3
plunger – the output signal is proportional to the position of the plunger. In principle LVDTs have a zero operating force; however most commercially available units incorporate a spring and have an appreciable operating force. Compared to strain-gaged flexures LVDTs are larger and more massive, and can operate over similar temperature ranges.
13.2.3 Potentiometers Potentiometers consist of a sliding contact running along a resistive track [13.4]. Rotary or linear potentiometers have limited resolution and linearity and are, generally, limited to use at ambient temperature. Multi-turn rotary types and types using conductive plastic tracks provide the highest available resolution, making them most suitable for use in extensometers. Potentiometers produce a large direct-current (DC) output signal, making them easy to interface to dataacquisition systems. The main extensometer application of potentiometers is in long-travel extensometers; they are unsuitable for dynamic use.
13.2.4 Capacitance Transducers The capacitance between two adjacent electrodes is a function of the overlapping area, the gap, and the dielectric occupying the space between the electrodes. The majority of capacitive transducers are based on the variation in capacitance as a function of the gap [13.4]. In general the electrical output from a capacitive transducer is a nonlinear function of displacement and the conditioning electronics must incorporate some form of linearization in order to produce acceptable system measurement accuracy. Capacitive transducers have a zero operating force and are available in small sizes with low mass. The
maximum operating temperature range of a capacitive transducer can be several hundred degrees Celsius.
13.2.5 Linear Incremental Encoders Linear incremental encoders are essentially digital devices which produce output pulses corresponding to defined changes in displacement. These encoders are often based on optical gratings along with optical sensors and interpolation electronics. Incremental transducers are usually very accurate and can have resolutions of less than 0.1 μm. They are, however, bulky and massive. Furthermore they are generally unsuitable for dynamic applications because they cannot follow rapid displacement changes. Incremental transducers are generally limited to operation at room temperature. It should be noted that linear encoders can make excellent reference transducers for extensometer calibrators.
13.2.6 Electronics and Signal Conditioning Almost all of today’s materials testing machines are based around digital electronics; however the majority of extensometers are based on analogue transducers, so some form of analogue-to-digital (AD) conversion is required. Once the signal is converted into a stream of sampled data it can be processed and recorded. Common processing operations include linearization to improve accuracy and filtering/resampling to reduce noise and improve resolution. As well as providing real-time signal conditioning functions modern testing machine and data-acquisition electronics will often provide automatic transducer identification and calibration. Automatic transducer identification eliminates the possibility of operator error when changing transducers.
13.3 Ambient-Temperature Contacting Extensometers The majority of extensometers in use today are contacting types. This section outlines the designs and characteristics of some of the main types of contacting extensometers.
13.3.1 Clip-On Axial Extensometers Clip-on extensometers are very widely used in the testing of rigid materials such as metals, plastics, and
composites, over a range of temperatures from cryogenic to several hundred degrees Celsius. They are designed to attach directly to, and be supported by, the test specimen, as illustrated in (Fig. 13.1). Because of their weight and relatively large operating and contact forces they are not generally suited to testing flexible or delicate materials such as foils/films, rubbers, fabrics, and many biological materials. The design of clip-on extensometers limits the maximum measurable
Extensometers
Fig. 13.2 Biaxial extensometer (courtesy of Epsilon Cor-
poration)
Fig. 13.3 Long-travel extensometer (courtesy of Instron)
strain to about 100% and hence they are not generally suitable for testing high-extension materials. Clip-on extensometers are available with single and multiple fixed gage lengths from below 10 mm to over 200 mm. Full-scale strains are in the range 5–100%. Clip-on extensometers incorporate a means of setting the reference gage length and a transducer to measure the extension of the test specimen. The extensometer illustrated in Fig. 13.1 has a manually operated spring-loaded gage length setting mechanism. Another common means of setting the gage length is a closefitting pin, which locks the extensometer to the required gage length. Clip-on extensometers use a pair of knife edges located on the specimen to define the gage length. These knife edges are usually quite sharp and are held in place using some form of spring or clip in order to reduce the chances of slip during the test. The unwanted stresses due to the presence of knife edges on the surface of a delicate specimen can influence the test itself. In addition to the stresses due to the knife-edge contacts, the weight and operating (or activation) force of the extensometer can exert an influence when testing delicate materials. With any type of clip-on extensometer the effect of energetic specimen breaks on the long-term reliability of the extensometer should be considered. In some situations, e.g., tensile testing of metals, it is possible to pause the test and remove the extensometer after the yield stress has been determined and determine the specimen strain for the rest of the test from the machine extension. The most common transducer mechanism employed in a clip-on extensometer is a strain-gaged flexure; however LVDTs, capacitive and incremental digital transducers are also used. Strain-gaged flexures are compact and lightweight, making them easy to integrate into a clip-on extensometer design. They have a very high inherent resolution; the limiting factor is the noise level or digital resolution of the conditioning electronics. The accuracy of clip-on extensometers using strain-gaged flexures will usually be sufficient to meet ASTM E83 [13.1] grade B1/B2 or ISO 9513 [13.2] grade 0.5 (i. e., accuracy is better than 0.5% of the reading). LVDT transducers are larger and more massive than equivalent strain-gaged flexures. They have a high resolution; however, in general, the linearity of LVDT transducers is not as high as a strain-gaged flexure. They are generally more robust than strain-gaged flexures and because of this they are often used in extensometers intended for testing materials, which release significant
339
Part B 13.3
Fig. 13.1 Clip-on extensometer (courtesy of Instron)
13.3 Ambient-Temperature Contacting Extensometers
340
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 13.3
energy at breakage, e.g., steel plate and reinforcing bars. Extensometers for this type of heavy-duty testing are often designed to separate into two halves when the specimen breaks. Tension/compression testing of materials in the range −150 ◦ C to 500–600 ◦ C is usually carried out using a temperature chamber. The use of clip-on extensometers to test at temperatures above and below ambient using a temperature chamber is limited by the ability of the transducer to withstand the test temperatures. Standard extensometers using strain-gaged flexures can be used down to cryogenic temperatures; however they will require calibration at the test temperature because of the effect of temperature on the sensitivity of the strain gages and on the reference gage length. Using standard strain gages and wiring limits the maximum temperatures to about 200 ◦ C. Operation at temperatures above about 200 ◦ C requires either a strain-gaged extensometer with some form of cooling (e.g., water or air) or the use of a transducer capable of operating at the test temperature, e.g., a high-temperature encapsulated strain gage or capacitive type. Clip-on extensometers can be used when testing in environments other than air, e.g., in high-humidity air, fluids or gases. In these situations care should be taken to ensure that all the materials used in the construction of the extensometer are compatible with the particular environment in use.
13.3.2 Other Types of Clip-On Extensometers In addition to axial clip-on extensometers there are a number of other clip-on extensometers, some of these are outlined here. The averaging axial clip-on extensometer uses a pair of axial extensometers positioned across the width or diameter of the test specimen. The measurement of average axial strain eliminates strain measurement errors arising from the presence of bending in the test specimen caused by alignment errors in the load string [13.6]. Measurement of some materials properties, e.g., Poisson’s ratio or plastic strain ratio (r-value) requires the simultaneous measurement of axial and transverse strain using either strain gages bonded to the specimen or a combination of axial and transverse extensometers. Transverse clip-on extensometers are similar in design to axial types but they measure the change in diameter or width of the test specimen. A gage length setting mechanism is usually not required; the gage length (in
Fig. 13.4 Automatic extensometer (courtesy of Instron)
this case a gage width) is determined by the dimensions of the specimen. Biaxial extensometers (Fig. 13.2) which integrate both axial and transverse extensometers into a single unit are available and are more convenient to attach than two separate extensometers. Crack-opening clip gages, whilst not strictly extensometers, have much in common with clip-on extensometers. There is no requirement for a gage length setting mechanism and the operating forces are very high.
13.3.3 Long-Travel (Elastomeric) Extensometers Long-travel extensometers (Fig. 13.3) are contacting types with travels typically in excess of 250 mm. They are intended for strain measurement on materials such as rubber with high failure strains (e.g., 1000–2000%). Typically this type of long-travel extensometer is based on a pair of arms (which may be counterbalanced) with spring-loaded clamps which locate on the test specimen. The arms are free to move on a vertical track following the movement of the specimen gage length. The arms then operate either a potentiometer or an incremental digital transducer, which converts the arm separation into an electrical output. Gage length setting is provided by means of mechanical stops.
Extensometers
Long-travel extensometers are optimized for testing high-elongation materials – they can measure high elongations accurately, however, they have much lower resolution than clip-on extensometers.
13.3.4 Automatic Extensometers
can be automatically set to the required proportional gage length when testing specimens of differing crosssectional area. There are two main types of contacting automatic extensometers: the direct acting type and the servo follower type. Direct acting automatic extensometers have a set of arms which contact the specimen and link directly to a measurement transducer located inside the body of the extensometer. Servo follower type automatic extensometers have deflection sensors (usually strain-gaged flexures) incorporated into the arms; these sensors then drive servo systems which drive the arms to maintain zero deflection (Fig. 13.4). In this way the operating force of the extensometer can be reduced to a very low level. Once again arms are linked to a measurement transducer. A common feature found on an automatic extensometer is a transverse strain measurement transducer, which provides the ability to measure the plastic strain ratio (r-value) on sheet metals.
13.4 High-Temperature Contacting Extensometers The term high-temperature extensometer is commonly applied to extensometers designed to work at temperatures beyond 500–600 ◦ C. Below test temperatures of 500–600 ◦ C most testing takes place inside a temperature chamber and it is possible to use a suitable clip-on extensometer inside the chamber. Above these temperatures it is usual to locate the transducer outside the heated zone and to transfer the specimen motion to the transducer by means of refractory rods. Using this approach it is possible to produce extensometers capable of measuring strain on specimens being tested at very high temperatures. There are two main approaches to the design of contacting, high-temperature extensometer for use at high temperatures. Longitudinal high-temperature extensometers use rods oriented parallel to the test specimen to transmit the deflection to the displacement transducers. Side-entry high-temperature extensometers have rods oriented at right angles to the specimen.
13.4.1 Longitudinal-Type High-Temperature Extensometers
testing of metals. They are also employed in hot tensile testing. The design uses refractory metal rods, located on either end of the specimen gage length by machined ridges, or groves, or via knife edges clamped on to the specimen. The rods transmit the specimen strain to displacement transducers located outside (usually at the bottom) of the furnace. The transducers employed are usually LVDTs or capacitive displacement sensors, but strain-gaged clip-on extensometers are sometimes employed. This type of extensometer can measure strain on either side of the specimen, from which average strain can be obtained. The measurement of average strain in a materials test reduces errors in materials properties due to bending of the specimen caused by poor alignment of the load string. The metal rods and clamps used in the construction of the longitudinal high-temperature extensometers limit their use to temperatures below about 1100 ◦ C.
13.4.2 Side-Loading High-Temperature Extensometers
The other approach to high-temperature extensometry Longitudinal-type high-temperature extensometers [13.5], uses a side-loaded design. In this type of extensome(Fig. 13.5) are widely used for high-temperature creep ter the extensometer is provided with ceramic rods,
341
Part B 13.4
Automatic extensometers are contacting types with remote control of many or all of the extensometer functions. These extensometers are mainly used for the tensile testing of rigid materials and they find wide application in high-volume tensile testing of metals. Automatic extensometers are an essential part of any fully automated (robotic) testing system. As a minimum an automatic extensometer will be provided with an ability to engage and disengage from a test specimen. Fully automatic extensometers will have other remotely controlled functions, e.g., gage length setting and gripping force setting. The ability to control the gage length remotely means that it
13.4 High-Temperature Contacting Extensometers
342
Part B
Contact Methods
Part B 13.4
which pass through a cut-out in the side of the furnace or through a gap in an induction heating coil. Side-entry extensometers (Fig. 13.6) can be designed to attach directly to the specimen using high-temperature cords or they can be designed to be suspended from a support mechanism located outside the furnace or heating coils and pushed on to the specimen. Externally supported high-temperature extensometers may be provided with a slide mechanism, which allows the extensometer to be loaded onto the test specimen after the specimen has been heated to the test temperature. This so-called hot loading can be very useful as hightemperature load strings can be subject to a significant amount of movement due to thermal expansion during the heat-up phase. A slide loading mechanism also allows the extensometer to be withdrawn from the specimen prior to failure – this eliminates the possibility of the energy release at failure damaging the extensometer rods. Gage length setting on side-loaded high-temperature extensometers can be provide by a pin to lock the rods at the required gage lengths, the pin being removed after
loading the rods on to the specimen. Alternatively the extensometers rods are located on a gage length reference bar (i. e., a bar with a pair of grooves separated by the required gage length) and the output is set to zero. The extensometer is then transferred to the specimen and the rods adjusted until the output is, once again, zero. At this point the contact points are at the correct gage length. The transducers in common use with side-loading extensometers are strain-gaged flexures, capacitive sensors, and LVDTs. Capacitive and LVDT sensors both offer the advantage of zero operating force. In addition the capacitive sensor is small, light, and offers no resistance to out-of-axis movements. LVDT sensors are relatively heavy, which complicates the design of the extensometer, limiting the bandwidth and requiring high contact forces. The profile of the end of the rod in contact with the specimen is important if the possibility of knife edge slip is to be reduced and consistent results are to be obtained. The aim should be to have a kinematic contact (i. e., sufficiently constrained but not overconstrained contact). For flat specimens, conical point contacts are required. For round samples, two flat chisel ended rods or one rod with an inverted V chisel contact and one flat chisel rod. The ideal material for the rods of a high-temperature extensometer would have high modulus, low density, low thermal conductivity, good creep resistance, and be chemically compatible with the specimen and the test environment. For temperatures up to about 1000 ◦ C the material with the best thermal properties is quartz, which has a very low coefficient of thermal expansion and a low thermal conductivity, however it is
Fig. 13.5 Longitudinal-type high-temperature extensometer (courtesy of Instron)
Fig. 13.6 Side-entry high-temperature extensometer (courtesy of Epsilon Corporation)
Extensometers
13.5 Noncontact Extensometers
343
Table 13.1 Materials for high-temperature extensometer rods Material Quartz
E (MPa)
α (ppm/◦ C)
ρ (g/cm3 )
K (W/m◦ C)
1000
Very good thermal performance but very brittle Creeps above 1200 ◦ C Good for testing in air to 1600 ◦ C Vacuum/inert only Vacuum/inert only *Typical (anisotropic)
0.4
2.2
Alumina Silicon carbide
360 440
8.1 4.8
4.0 3.2
29 79
1200–1600 1500–1600
Graphite C–C (C3 )
207 71*
7.9 −0.4
2.3 1.7
5.0 21
2500+ 2500+
mon materials used in extensometer rods is shown in Table 13.1. In order to minimize drift the sensitive parts (e.g., pivots/flexures and sensors) of a high-temperature extensometer must be kept cool. Techniques to achieve this include the use of radiation shields, cooling fins, forced air or thermostatically controlled water-cooling systems. In the case of longitudinal extensometers the location of the transducers below the furnace assists in keeping them cool. For demanding long-term creep tests the use of a fully temperature-controlled environment is recommended.
13.5 Noncontact Extensometers There are a number of different approaches to optical, noncontact extensometry. Most noncontact optical extensometers, designed for use at ambient temperatures, operate in a reflection mode in which light is reflected off optical targets back into the detector. It is also possible to use a transmission mode in which the optical targets cast a shadow. Noncontacting extensometers are inherently free from spurious mechanical resonances and hysteresis, however there may be a time delay (lag) in the output signal which can affect stability when using the signal for closed-loop control.
13.5.1 Optical Targets The majority of noncontacting, optical techniques require that a contrasting mark or target be attached to the specimen to define the axial gage length. This is a critical area, as any slip or distortion of the target will generate a spurious strain signal. The use of contrasting ink or paint marks on the specimen surface is effective in many situations; how-
ever at large strains the size of the ink mark grows and the contrast may reduce. In situations where ink or paint marks are not suitable adhesive targets may be used. The size and shape of the target is important. Round targets are generally preferred over line targets because they eliminate errors that can arise from rotation of the mark. Line targets do, however, allow the possibility of measuring average strain. When testing delicate specimens the target size should be as small as possible in order to minimize the reinforcing effect of the target on the specimen. When applying targets to delicate specimens care should be taken to ensure that the adhesives and/or solvents used in the inks or paints are compatible with the specimen. Clearly any chemical incompatibility obviates one of the key benefits of noncontact optical technique. Another potential problem with optical targets is a mismatch between the mechanical gage length, as defined by the distance between points of contact on the specimen, and the gage length sensed by the optical measurement
Part B 13.5
Notes
70
a brittle material which is easily broken by mishandling or by the shocks from specimen failure. Alumina is a more durable material and can be used to above 1200 ◦ C. Silicon carbide is suitable for temperatures of up to 1600 ◦ C. Rods for use above 1600 ◦ C can be made from carbon, usually in the form of carbon– carbon composite. These materials oxidize rapidly in air so they must be used in a vacuum or inert gas environment. At very high temperatures chemical compatibility can often only be satisfied by using knife edges made from the same material as the specimen. A summary of the relevant properties of some com-
0.22
Tmax (◦ C)
344
Part B
Contact Methods
13.5.2 Servo Follower Type Optical Extensometers
Part B 13.5
The servo follower type optical extensometer is similar, in principle, to the servo follower type automatic extensometer described earlier. The extensometer uses a pair of optical sensors mounted on moving carriages that track contrasting targets on specimen. An analogue or incremental digital displacement transducer then measures the separation of the carriages.
13.5.3 Scanning Laser Extensometers The scanning laser extensometer is a reflection-mode system in which a beam of laser light is rapidly scanned across a pair of reflective optical targets on the specimen. An optical detector detects the reflected energy. The distance between the targets is determined from the time that elapses between the reflections. There are two alternative implementations of this principle. The first is intended to measure large extensions and uses a large-angle (45−90◦ ) fan beam of laser light reflected off a rotating mirror. This type of optical extensometer has a relatively low resolution (typically 10–100 μm) and is suitable for high-elongation testing of rubbers and elastomers. The second uses a more sophisticated optical system to produce a parallel scanned beam. This type of extensometer has a smaller extension range but much higher resolution.
13.5.4 Video Extensometers Video extensometers use real-time image processing of images from a video camera to measure the position of contrasting marks on a test specimen. In common with several other techniques the video extensometer measures strain by tracking two contrasting targets, which define the gage length. However unlike most noncontact optical systems, which measure along one axis, the video extensometer is an area scan device. Because of this it is possible to track the position of the target more precisely so that the measurement is less sensitive to target distortion, specimen lateral movement, or bending. Figure 13.7 shows a block diagram of a typical video extensometer system. The system is based on a MegaPixel charge-coupled device (CCD) digital camera sending 50 images per second to a high-performance personal computer (PC) via an IEEE 1394 (firewireTM ) interface. The CCD image sensor has approximately 1200 × 800 pixels (light-sensitive elements) and real-
time image-processing algorithms can determine the locations of the marks to subpixel accuracy, achieving a resolution of better than one-hundredth of a pixel. A key part of the system is the lighting system, which is designed to enhance the contrast of the optical targets whilst minimizing the sensitivity of the extensometer the surface finish of the test specimen and to changes in ambient lighting. The lighting system uses a large number of red light-emitting diodes (LEDs) pulsed synchronously with the camera’s electronic shutter. A red filter on the camera optimizes the sensitivity of the camera to the light from the LEDs, and a pair of crossed polarizing filters, one in front of the LEDs and a second in front of the camera, eliminate specular reflections from the specimen. This enhances the mark contrast, particularly when working with specimens with a bright, polished surface. The image analysis routines used in the video extensometer can track either dot or line targets. Dot targets are suitable for most tests but line targets can be used to measure an average strain across the width of a test specimen. When dot targets are used the video extensometer is capable of measuring both axial and transverse strain, making it suitable for determining rvalue (anisotropy ration) as part of a tensile test. The field of view (FoV) of the camera can be changed by simply changing the camera lens. Fields of view from 60 mm to 500 mm are available. A key element of the system is the method of calibration, which uses a precision two-dimensional (2-D) target to correct for any distortions in the optics. Calibration of the extensometer involves positioning the calibration target instead of the test specimen and running an automatic calibration routine.
13.5.5 Other Noncontact Optical Extensometers In addition to the techniques described other approaches have been used. One technique is a transmission technique based on optical diffraction. Optical flags are attached to the specimen defining the gauge length the flags are large and are arranged so there is a small gap between them. A laser beam is aimed to pass through the gap and on to a detector. The light is diffracted by the gap, forming a diffraction pattern at the detector. Measurement of the fringe spacing of the diffraction pattern can be used to determine the separation of the flags and hence the strain in the specimen [13.7]. Another approach that has been used successfully at very high temperatures (3000 ◦ C) has been to use opti-
Extensometers
Narrow band optical filter matched to illumination
13.6 Contacting versus Noncontacting Extensometers
345
Fig. 13.7 Video extensometer block diagram (courtesy of Instron)
Firewire digital camera
Forced air Firewire interface CDAT
Polarizing filter
Parallel port
Camera synch interface Controller
PC interface
Data synch
Pulsed LED lighting driver
cal flags, high-power laser back-lighting and a Zimmer electro-optical measurement system to track an image of the flags. A comparison of this approach with a contacting approach appears in [13.8, Chap. 14].
13.5.6 Noncontact Extensometers for High-Temperature Testing Noncontact optical extensometers are attractive instruments for measuring strain at nonambient temperatures; however they have limitations that need to be recognized. As mentioned earlier, tension/compression testing of materials in the range from −150 ◦ C to 500–600 ◦ C is usually carried out using a temperature chamber. It is possible, indeed it is common practice, to provide these chambers with viewing windows, usually consisting of a number of glass panels separated by gaps. In principle noncontact optical extensometers can see the test specimen through the window and can measure the required strain. In practice a number of factors need to be addressed including the quality of the glass used in the window and that the targets used to define the gage length must be able to operate at the required temperatures without degradation.
When testing at low temperatures, there is a tendency for atmospheric moisture to lead to ice build up on the window and specimen, obscuring the view through the window and decreasing the contrast of the optical targets. When used at temperatures above 1000 ◦ C optical extensometers require a powerful source of external illumination and some method of preventing the sensitive optical detectors from being overloaded by the intense black-body radiation from the furnace. Suitable sources of external illumination are laser light or a mercury vapor lamp. Optical filters matched to the wavelength(s) of the external light source are then used to protect the optical detectors from the radiation from the furnace. All optical systems are sensitive to noise caused by convection currents in the vicinity of hot objects. With all noncontact optical extensometers that are used to test at nonambient temperatures the resolution of the measurements reduces as the temperatures increase due to light refraction from the air currents inside the chamber. It is possible to isolate the light paths from the turbulent air flow around the chamber or furnace by enclosing them in evacuated tubes or using light guides, however these are expensive and complex to integrate with other equipment.
13.6 Contacting versus Noncontacting Extensometers Contacting extensometers are in direct mechanical contact with the specimen and do not require the attachment of optical targets. Furthermore the contact is, generally, unaffected by changes in the surface condition of the
specimen (as may be caused by oxidation in metals or microcracking in polymers). However, particularly with delicate materials, contact stresses at the knife-edge locations may lead to premature specimen failure and the
Part B 13.6
LED array
346
Part B
Contact Methods
weight of a contacting extensometer can generate some degree of bending in the specimen. Noncontacting measurement means that no unwanted loads are applied to the specimen. In practical
terms noncontact extensometers are generally more robust and less subject to damage and drift than contacting extensometers. They are also easier to use and less prone to operator error.
Part B 13
13.7 Conclusions There are a range of contacting and noncontacting techniques for measuring specimen strain. When selecting an extensometer for a specific test it is important to understand the characteristics of the properties of the material being tested and the characteristics of the extensometer. When correctly applied, both contact and noncontact extensometry are capable of producing reliable data.
We can expect to see continued advances in CCD cameras and real-time analysis of video images. These developments will generate exciting possibilities for noncontact extensometry leading to improvements in both the accuracy and flexibility of this technique. Nevertheless, there will continue to be a need for a range of high-performance contacting extensometry into the foreseeable future.
References 13.1
13.2
13.3 13.4
ASTM: ASTM E83-06 Standard Practice for Verification and Classification of Extensometer Systems (ASTM International, West Conshohocken 2006) ISO: ISO 9513:1999 Metallic materials – Calibration of extensometers used in uniaxial testing (ISO, Geneve 1999) S.T. Smith, D.G. Chetwynd: Foundations of Ultraprecision Mechanism Design (CRC, Boca Raton 1994) H.K.P. Neubert: Instrument transducers (Oxford Univ. Press, Oxford 1975)
13.5
13.6 13.7
13.8
B.F. Dyson, M.F. Loveday, M.G. Gee: Materials Metrology and Standards for Structural Performance (Chapman Hall, New York 1995) P. Han: Tensile Testing (ASM International, Metals Park 1992) B.F. Dyson, R.D. Lohr, R. Morell: Mechanical Testing of Engineering Ceramics at High Temperatures (Elsevier, Amsterdam 1989) R. Lohr, M. Steen: Ultra High Temperature Mechanical Testing (Woodhead, Cambridge 1995)
347
Optical Fiber 14. Optical Fiber Strain Gages
Chris S. Baldwin
14.1 Optical Fiber Basics ............................... 348 14.1.1 Guiding Principals for Optical Fiber 348 14.1.2 Types of Optical Fibers ................. 349
14.2.3 14.2.4 14.2.5 14.2.6
Advantages of Fiber Optic Sensors . Limitations of Fiber Optic Sensors .. Thermal Effects ........................... Introduction to Strain–Optic Effect
352 353 354 354
14.3 Interferometry ..................................... 14.3.1 Two-Beam Interference ............... 14.3.2 Strain–Optic Effect....................... 14.3.3 Optical Coherence ....................... 14.3.4 Mach–Zehnder ........................... 14.3.5 Michelson .................................. 14.3.6 Fabry–Pérot ............................... 14.3.7 Polarization................................ 14.3.8 Interrogation of Interferometers ...
354 355 355 356 357 357 357 358 358
14.4 Scattering ............................................ 359 14.4.1 Brillouin Scattering...................... 359 14.4.2 Strain Sensing Using Brillouin Scattering................................... 359 14.5 Fiber Bragg Grating Sensors .................. 14.5.1 Fabrication Techniques ................ 14.5.2 Fiber Bragg Grating Optical Response ................................... 14.5.3 Strain Sensing Using FBG Sensors .. 14.5.4 Serial Multiplexing ...................... 14.5.5 Interrogation of FBG Sensors, Wavelength Detection.................. 14.5.6 Other Grating Structures ...............
361 361 362 363 364
14.6 Applications of Fiber Optic Sensors ......... 14.6.1 Marine Applications..................... 14.6.2 Oil and Gas Applications .............. 14.6.3 Wind Power Applications ............. 14.6.4 Civil Structural Monitoring ............
367 367 367 368 368
366 367
14.2 General Fiber Optic Sensing Systems....... 351 14.2.1 Strain Sensing System Concept ...... 351 14.2.2 Basic Fiber Optic Sensing Definitions ................................. 351
References .................................................. 369
Many optical fiber sensors are based on classical bulk optic arrangements, as discussed in Chap. 18 – Basics of Optics. These arrangements are named after the in-
ventors who are credited with their invention. Other optical fiber sensors are based on physical phenomenon such as scattering effects that are inherent to the optical
14.7 Summary ............................................. 368
Part B 14
Optical fiber strain sensing is an evolving field in optical sciences in which multiple optical principles and techniques are employed to measure strain. This chapter seeks to provide a concise overview of the various types of optical fiber strain sensors currently available. The field of optical fiber strain sensing is nearly 30 years old and is still breaking new ground in terms of optical fiber technology, instrumentation, and applications. For each sensor discussed in the following sections, the basic optical layout is presented along with a description of the optical phenomena and the governing equations. Comprehensive coverage of all aspects of optical fiber strain sensing is beyond the scope of this chapter. For example, each sensor type can be interrogated by a number of means, sometimes based on differing technology. Furthermore, these sensors are finding applications in a wide variety of fields including aerospace, oil and gas, maritime, and civil infrastructures. The interested reader is referred to the works by Grattan and Meggit [14.1], Measures [14.2], and Udd [14.3] for more-detailed descriptions of interrogation techniques and applications of the various sensors.
348
Part B
Contact Methods
fiber material. In general, fiber optic sensors function by monitoring a change in an optical parameter as the optical fiber is exposed to the strain field. The three main types of optical fiber strain gages are
• • •
interferometry (changes in optical phase) scattering (changes in optical wavelength) fiber Bragg grating (changes in optical wavelength)
Other optical phenomena such as intensity variations are exploited for optical fiber sensors measuring other quantities such as chemical concentrations, applied loads/pressure, and temperature. The strain sensing mechanisms listed above are explored in the sections below, but first an introduction to optical fibers and a general overview of the basic layout, advantages, and disadvantages of optical fiber strain sensors is provided.
14.1 Optical Fiber Basics Part B 14.1
The first thought many people have when introduced to optical fiber is of a thin, fragile piece of glass. On the contrary, the ultrapure manufacturing that goes into producing the low-loss optical fiber of today creates a thin glass structure essentially free of defects with tensile strength values near 800 ksi (5.5 GPa) [14.2]. The following sections discuss the optical guiding properties of optical fiber and provide a brief description of the various types of optical fiber commercially available for sensing applications.
14.1.1 Guiding Principals for Optical Fiber Before any discussion of fiber optic strain sensors can be realized, an understanding of the light guiding principles of optical fiber should be presented. The basic material for optical fiber is fused silica [14.2]. Standard optical fiber consists of two concentric glass portions. The inner portion is called the core and the outer portion is called the cladding. The core region of the optical fiber typically contains dopants such as germanium (Ge) or boron (B) to increase the refractive index of the core (n core ) to a slightly higher value than that of the cladding (n clad ), which is pure fused silica. Optical fiber also uses protective layers of polymer coatings to protect the glass surface from damage. For most strain sensing applications, one of two coatings is applied to the optical fiber. Acrylate-coated optical fibers have a final outer diameter of 250 μm. Polyimide-coated optical fibers are available in a range of final outer diameters, typically around 180 μm. Standard telecommunications optical fiber has a germanium-doped core. The optical transmission spectrum for Ge–Si is shown in Fig. 14.1 [14.2]. The transmission spectra displays the characteristic decay of the Rayleigh curve (1/λ4 ); at higher wavelengths the transmission is limited by the absorption of energy by the silica structure. The multiple peaks in the attenua-
tion curve are due to OH− (hydroxyl) scattering in the optical transmission curve. The effect of the hydroxyl peaks is the creation of transmission windows for optical fiber. The telecommunications industry makes use of the wavelength regions around 1550 nm due to the lowloss properties and the availability of optical sources and detectors. This is commonly referred to as the Cband. The region around 1300 nm, termed the S-band, is also used for data transmission, but typically is reserved for shorter-length applications such as local area networks (LANs). A schematic diagram of standard single-mode optical fiber is shown in Fig. 14.2. The size of the core (radius = a) is dependent on the wavelength of light the optical fiber is designed to guide. For single-mode operation in the C-band, this value is around 4 μm. The cladding diameter is standardized at 125 μm for many optical fiber types. This allows for the use of common optical fiber tools such as cleavers, strippers, and fusion splicers to be used on different optical fiber types from different optical fiber vendors. In the simplest sense, light is guided via total internal reflection (TIR) between the core and cladding Attenuation (dB/km) S-band
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
C-band
1.4
1.6 1.8 Wavelength (μm)
Fig. 14.1 Optical transmission windows for optical fibers
Optical Fiber Strain Gages
14.1 Optical Fiber Basics
349
1 J0 (V ) 250 μm a
0.75
J1 (V )
0.5
125μm
V = 2.405
0.25 0
Fig. 14.2 Schematic of typical optical fibers –0.25
Therefore, the modal propagation of light in a stepindex optical fiber is dependent on the core size (a), the refractive index difference between the core and cladding, and the wavelength of light propagating in the core. The V number value to ensure single-mode operation is 2.405. If the V number is larger than 2.405 then
Acceptance cone
α
Cladding Core
Fig. 14.3 Total internal reflection between core and
cladding
–0.5 –0.75
–J1 (V ) 0
2 4 Singlemode region
6
8
10
Fig. 14.4 Bessel solution space for modal operation of op-
tical fiber
light in the optical fiber is not propagating as singlemode. Based on the formulation given in (14.1), a cutoff wavelength value can be determined for the optical fiber, which defines the lower limit of single-mode operation with respect to wavelength. The cutoff wavelength is given by: 2πa n 2core − n 2clad . (14.2) λcutoff = V Any wavelength of light lower than the cutoff wavelength will not propagate as single-mode in the optical fiber. Likewise, to determine the appropriate core size to ensure single-mode operation at a given wavelength, (14.1) can be written as (14.3) a = 2.405λ/2πV n 2core − n 2clad . The vast majority of optical fiber strain sensors employ standard single-mode optical fiber or similar constructed optical fiber. The following section provides a brief description of optical fiber types that may be encountered in the field of strain sensing.
14.1.2 Types of Optical Fibers For the most part, fiber optic strain sensors make use of readily available, standard optical fiber and components. Optical fiber sensing has experienced a new thrust of interest and development in recent years. Much of the current research has been focused on the field of biosensing with the development of new optical fiber types and sensing techniques. Optical fiber strain sensing has been steadily finding and being integrated
Part B 14.1
of the optical fiber, as illustrated in Fig. 14.3. TIR was introduced in Chap. 18. Figure 14.3 shows a slab waveguide description for optical fiber. Based on the slab waveguide formulation, the standard Snell’s law can be employed to determine the guiding principles for the structure. This analysis leads to an acceptance cone where light entering the core within this angle will result in a guiding condition. In optical fiber terms, this is related to the numerical aperture (NA). Of course, the explanation of TIR for the guiding principles of optical fiber is very limiting. The derivation for the propagation of light through an optical fiber is based on a solution of the electromagnetic wave equation (18.1), as discussed in Chap. 18. This derivation is beyond the scope of this chapter. The important result from the derivation is that the propagation of light through the core is based on Bessel functions (Ji (x)). Single-mode propagation in optical fiber is defined by a parameter known as the V number, which is the argument of the Bessel function solution for guided core modes [14.2]. The solution plots of the first few Bessel functions are shown in Fig. 14.4. The V number for standard single-mode optical fiber is expressed as 2πa n 2core − n 2clad . (14.1) V = ka n 2core − n 2clad = λ
350
Part B
Contact Methods
a) Singlemode
b) Multimode
c) PM-elliptical core
d) PM-bowtie
Part B 14.1
Fig. 14.5a–d Cross-section views of various types of opti-
cal fiber
into more application areas including civil infrastructure monitoring, oil and gas application, embedded composite sensing, and maritime sensing. As discussed in Sect. 14.2.3, optical fiber sensing possesses some inherent advantages over traditional sensing techniques for these and other application areas. The development of low-loss optical fibers in the 1970s began a period of innovation in both telecommunications and sensing applications. The first optical fibers designed for telecommunication applications were manufactured by Corning in 1970 and possessed attenuation values just less than 20 dB/km [14.2]. Current attenuation values for telecommunication grade optical fiber are of the order of 0.2 dB/km [14.2]. Although the vast majority of fiber optic sensors use standard communications-grade single-mode optical fiber, it should be noted that multiple varieties of optical fiber exist and are being explored for various sensing applications. Figure 14.5 shows a cross-section view of several types of optical fiber. For example, a variety of polarization-maintaining optical fibers exist that possess an induced birefringence throughout the fiber length, thus maintaining two principal polarization axes for optical transmission. Various dopants and fiber structures have been explored throughout the past few decades to
decrease the influence of bend losses and improve signal quality within optical fiber. Using Fig. 14.2 as a reference, the optical fibers displayed in Fig. 14.5 can be compared to the standard single-mode optical fiber. Multimode optical fiber (illustrated in Fig. 14.5b) possesses a much larger core size compared to single-mode fiber. This aspect was discussed in Sect. 14.1.1 in terms of the V number dictating single-mode operation. Multimode optical fiber may either have a step index core (like the single-mode optical fiber) or a graded refractive index core. If the multimode fiber is step index, then the various propagation modes travel different path lengths due to the oscillatory nature of the propagation. Graded-index optical fibers allow the various modes propagating in the fiber to have equivalent path lengths. Figure 14.5 also displays two types of polarizationmaintaining fiber (PM fiber). Polarization of light is covered in both Chaps. 18 and 25 of this Handbook. The polarization-maintaining aspect is induced either through a geometric structure of the core (elliptical core fiber – Fig. 14.5c) or by inducing a permanent mechanical load within the fiber structure (such as bow-tie fiber – Fig. 14.5d). PM fiber develops two polarization states (fast and slow axis) whose responses to mechanical loads are slightly different. PM fiber has found applications in strain sensing, as discussed in Sect. 14.3.7. Most recently, the development of photonicbandgap (PBG) fiber and photonic-crystal fiber (PCF) has generated great interest in the sensing community, particularly in the field of chemical and biosensing. These optical fibers are commonly referred to as “holey fibers” because the core and cladding regions are developed by manufacturing a structured pattern of voids (holes) that traverse the entire length of the optical fiber. For more information on this type of optical fiber, the reader may visit www.crystal-fibre.com. In general, PCFs use a patterned microstructure of voids along the length of the optical fiber to create an effective lower-index cladding and guide light in a solid core by modified total internal reflection (M-TIR)[14.4]. PBG fibers guide light within a low-index region (longitudinal void) by creating a photonic bandgap based on the structure and pattern of the voids [14.4].
Optical Fiber Strain Gages
14.2 General Fiber Optic Sensing Systems
351
14.2 General Fiber Optic Sensing Systems 14.2.1 Strain Sensing System Concept
Interrorgation unit
Fiber optic sensor
Source Optics Feedback Data acquisition
Demodulator
Fig. 14.6 Basic configuration of an optical fiber sensor sys-
tem
a) Distributed
b) Discrete
Fig. 14.7a–c Fiber optic sensor classifications
14.2.2 Basic Fiber Optic Sensing Definitions Due to the wide variety of fiber optic sensors, some definitions of optical fiber strain sensing are required. Fiber optic sensors can be classified into distributed, discrete, or cumulative strain sensors, as illustrated in Fig. 14.7. A distributed strain sensor provides a measure of strain at potentially every point along the sensing optical fiber. Distributed sensors typically have a spatial resolution of approximately 1 m due to the resolution of the measurement systems. A discrete strain sensor provides a strain measurement at one location often based on a smallgage-length fiber optic sensor. By serially multiplexing these sensors, a distributed sensor array can be fabricated with the strain measurements being at discrete points instead of an average of the spatial resolution. A cumulative strain sensor provides a measure of strain that is an average strain value over the entire sensing length of the optical fiber. The selection of a fiber optic strain sensor for a particular application is driven by the sensing requirements for the application. For example, measurement of the hoop strain of a pressure vessel may use a distributed sensor to obtain strain values at multiple locations around the circumference. A discrete sensor can provide a single strain measurement at a single location on the circumference or multiple measurements if serially multiplexed. A cumulative strain sensor would provide a single strain measurement based on the overall strain induced in the fiber bonded to the circumference of the vessel. Cumulative sensors provide the highest sensitivity and are often employed when very small strain signals are of interest such as the measurement of acoustic fields. In many cases, the optical fiber serves as both the conduit for the optical signal and the sensing mechanism. In this situation, the sensor is referred to as an intrinsic sensor. An extrinsic sensor is the case where the optical fiber delivers the optical signal to the sensc) Cumulative
Part B 14.2
The basic building blocks of a fiber optic strain sensor system can be compared to the building blocks of a resistance strain gage (RSG) system discussed in Chap. 12. A resistance strain gage circuit requires a voltage supply, Wheatstone bridge, electrical wires connecting to the RSG, a voltmeter to monitor the circuit output, and a data-acquisition system to record the voltage changes. In terms of fiber optic sensors, an equivalent arrangement can be drawn where the voltage supply is equivalent to the light source (laser, light emitting diode, or other optical source). The Wheatstone bridge is equivalent to the optics that guide the light to and from the sensors or sensing region of the optical fiber. The wires that connect to the RSG are simply the lead optical fiber to the fiber optic sensors. In some cases, a single strand of optical fiber is used to monitor multiple (potentially thousands) fiber optic strain sensors (see multiplexing below). This is vastly different from RSG circuits where each uniaxial gage requires at least two conductors. The voltmeter for a fiber optic sensor system is the interrogation unit (also called a demodulator). The interrogation units typically have one or more photodetectors to transfer the optical signal to a voltage signal proportional to the optical intensity. The data-acquisition system is the one component that may be an exact duplicate between the RSG circuit and the fiber optic sensor system. This is typically a personal computer (PC) or laptop device with appro-
priate interface cards/boards to record the data from the interrogation unit.
352
Part B
Contact Methods
A
A/2
B/2
B
A/2 B/2
Fig. 14.8 Bidirectional optical fiber coupler
Part B 14.2
ing mechanism such as an air cavity. In both cases, the applied strain induces a physical change in the geometry of the sensor. For the case of an intrinsic sensor, a strain–optic effect is also induced and must be considered when determining the calibration coefficient (gage factor) of the sensor. Another differentiation between types of optical fiber sensors is whether the sensor works as a reflective or a transmission element. The majority of fiber optic strain sensors function in reflection mode, where light traveling in the optical fiber is reflected back towards the optical source from reflective elements or from inherent scattering of the optical fiber material. In order to direct the back-reflected light to the interrogation instrumentation, an optical fiber coupler device is employed. A bidirectional coupler is typically used in these applications, as shown in Fig. 14.8. The commercially available standard bidirectional coupler is termed a 3 dB coupler because it divides the optical signal equally into the two output arms as indicated in Fig. 14.8.
14.2.3 Advantages of Fiber Optic Sensors Optical fiber sensors offer many advantages over traditional electrical-based strain sensors. Many of these advantages stem from the pure optical nature of the sensor mechanisms. Traditional sensors depend on the measurement of variations of resistance or capacitance of the electrical sensors. Optical fiber sensors depend on changes to optical parameters of the optical fiber or the light traveling within the optical fiber. This difference leads to many advantages, including
• • • •
immunity to electromagnetic interference long transmission lead lines no combustion danger serial multiplexing
The following discussion expands on each of the advantages stated above.
Immunity to Electromagnetic Interference Optical fiber sensors function by measuring changes to the light that is traveling within the optical fiber. Unlike low-level voltage signals, resistance changes, or other electrical phenomena used for traditional sensors, electromagnetic influences do not cause measurable levels of noise. Therefore, when dealing with optical lead lines and cabling, no special shielding is required, thus greatly reducing the cabling weight compared to traditional sensors. Long Transmission Lines With the advances made in the telecommunications field for optical fiber transmission, current standards for optical signal transmission allow the light signal to be transmitted many kilometers without a detrimental level of signal degradation. Optical power loss in current communications grade optical fiber are on the order of 0.2 dB/km. Other factors that affect the transmission of optical signals in fibers such as chromatic and material dispersion have also experienced improvements. No Combustion Danger In some applications, there exists a risk of ignition or explosion of combustive materials from sparks or electrical potentials from sensors. The optical power guided within the core for fiber optic sensors is typically less than 1 mW, essentially eliminating any potential of spark or ignition danger. Without the requirement of a voltage potential at the sensor location and the ability to have long lead lines, optical fiber sensors are regarded as being immune to combustion danger. This is one reason why fiber optic sensors are being heavily explored for various oil and gas industry applications [14.5]. Multiplexing Some of the optical fiber sensors discussed in this chapter have the ability to be multiplexed (multiple sensors interrogated by a signal instrumentation system). The two main types of multiplexing are parallel and serial multiplexing. In parallel multiplexing (also called spatial multiplexing), the light source is separated into multiple optical fiber channels, with each channel containing an optical sensor. Typically, each sensor in a parallel multiplexing scheme will have its own detector and processing instrumentation. If the light source is guided to the multiple channels via a fiber optic switch component (as shown in Fig. 14.9), then the optical sensor signals are not monitored simultaneously but sequentially depending on the timing of the optical switch. In this case, a common detector and processing instru-
Optical Fiber Strain Gages
Optical switch Source
Coupler
Demodulation and data acquisition
Sensor arrays
Switch control signal
Fig. 14.9 Parallel multiplexing employing an optical
switch Coupler
#1 #2 #3
#n–1 #n
Sensor array
Instrumentation
Fig. 14.10 Serially multiplexed sensors
mentation may be employed for all the sensors. If the optical source is divided to all the sensors via a fiber optic coupler arrangement, then all the fiber optic sensors can be interrogated simultaneously through each sensor’s individual processing instrumentation. Serial multiplexing is a major advantage of some types of optical fiber sensors (in particular the fiber Bragg grating, Sect. 14.5). In serial multiplexing techniques, multiple sensors are positioned along a single optical fiber lead (in serial fashion), as illustrated in Fig. 14.10. The strain signals from each of these sensors are separated through optical means or via the processing instrumentation. The sensing system may also contain a secondary fiber sensor to provide reference and/or gating signals to decouple the serially multiplexed signals.
14.2.4 Limitations of Fiber Optic Sensors In most texts dealing with optical fiber sensors, the reader can find a similar list of advantages as displayed in Sect. 14.2.3. What is often omitted from these texts is a list of their limitations. For the reader (and potential user of these systems), it is imperative that these factors be discussed and explained so the strain sensing community achieves a common understanding of the present limitations of fiber optic strain sensors. The following lists the major limitations of fiber optic sensing technology. The degree to which each limitation affects fiber optic sensing technology is dependent on the particular style of fiber optic sensor
1
1.5
2 2.5 Bend radius (cm)
Fig. 14.11 Attenuation due to bend radius for SMF-28 optical fiber with one complete wrap 1550 nm (marks data, solid line theory)
• • • •
limited bend radius precise alignment of connections cost varying specifications
Limited Bend Radius In order to maintain optimum transmission of the optical power, the limited bend radius of the optical fiber must be adhered to. This is much more restricted compared to traditional electrical sensors where bending the electrical wires through a 90◦ turn does not damage the electrical wire. Thus placing optical fiber sensors near physical boundaries requires some consideration. A general rule of thumb is to keep the bend radius greater than 2 cm. When the optical fiber bend radius decreases below 2 cm, the level of attenuation sharply increases, as shown in Fig. 14.11. Manufactures have been developing new classes of optical fiber for various applications. Some of these are considered bend insensitive. Precise Alignment with Connections Unlike traditional electrical sensors, where twisting two copper conductors together is all that is needed to make a connection, optical fiber requires precise alignment of the two end-faces to ensure proper transmission of the optical power. For single-mode optical fiber, the alignment of the adjoining cores is critical. The end-faces of the fiber optic connectors must also be polished and cleaned to ensure low losses at the connection. Issues with misalignment can cause signal loss and also reduce signal-to-noise levels with the introduction of backscat-
353
Part B 14.2
Source
Power loss (%) 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0 0.5
14.2 General Fiber Optic Sensing Systems
354
Part B
Contact Methods
tered light from the interface. Fortunately, a number of fiber optic connectors have become industry standards and these provide quality connections.
Part B 14.3
Cost In some cases, the cost of the optical fiber sensor is equivalent to the price of standard telecommunication fiber and components. With the high-volume production of optical fiber and certain optical components, these items are reasonably priced. However, the instrumentation systems required to interrogate these sensors are high-precision electro-optic systems that are relatively expensive, especially compared with RSG instrumentation. Varying Specifications As mentioned earlier, there are multiple choices for instrumentation systems for each fiber optic strain sensor type. This level of variability in the marketplace has led to a lack of industry standards, with companies continuing to market a particular technology to various application areas. This issue is of greatest importance for the fiber Bragg grating sensor discussed in this chapter where various types of the FBG sensors can be used to measure strain with different interrogation techniques.
respect to temperature. With RSG sensors, proper selection of materials and fabrication of the foil allows for the manufacture of sensors that are thermally compensated for a particular material. This same process of developing thermally self-compensating sensors cannot be implemented with fiber optic sensors. There is a definite limit on the material property selection for optical fibers, and the fabrication procedures for optical fibers do not allow for the development of material property variations that occur with metal coldworking processes. There are some athermal packages of fiber optic sensors available commercially, but these are not designed for strain measurement. The sensors are bonded into self-contained housings (not suited for bonding to other structures) that are typically composed of materials of differing thermal expansion coefficients, thus counteracting any expansion or contraction due to thermal variations. For the most part, thermal compensation is accomplished by using a secondary sensor to measure the temperature and subtract this effect from the measured strain reading of the fiber optic sensor. Often, the secondary sensor is another fiber optic sensor of similar design, but isolated from the strain field such that the sensor thermal response is well characterized for the application.
14.2.6 Introduction to Strain–Optic Effect 14.2.5 Thermal Effects Most fiber optic sensors also experience issues of thermal apparent strain readings. Extrinsic sensors, whose strain sensing is accomplished in an air gap or comparable structure, may have negligible thermal issues. Intrinsic sensors suffer from thermal influences due to the thermal expansion of the optical fiber and changes in the refractive index with respect to temperature. These quantities are comparable to the elongation and the resistance change of electrical resistance strain gages with
Central to many fiber optic strain sensors is the influence of the strain–optic effect. As a mechanical load is applied to the optical fiber, the length of the optical fiber changes and the refractive index also changes as a function of the strain field. The change in the refractive index is similar to the change in specific resistance of electrical strain gages with respect to the applied strain. Similar to the thermal effects, extrinsic sensors do not experience this influence due to the use of an air cavity as the sensing region.
14.3 Interferometry As low-loss optical fiber became more readily available, researchers in the late 1970s and 1980s began exploring the uses of optical fiber as a sensing medium. Some of the first sensors to be explored were optical fiber equivalents of classical interferometers such as those of Michelson and Mach–Zehnder (MZ) [14.1]. Another interferometer, the Sagnac fiber optic sensor, has enjoyed commercial success as the fiber optic gyroscope [14.6].
Many of the basic concepts employed in fiber optic interferometry are discussed in Chap. 18 in this Handbook. Each interferometer discussed in this section makes use of fiber optic components to create two optical paths that interfere to provide a measurement of strain. Similar to full-field strain measurement discussed in other chapters of this Handbook, fiber optic interferometers must extract the strain data from the resulting fringe information. In the case of fiber op-
Optical Fiber Strain Gages
tic interferometers, the resulting interference signal is detected via a photodetector and transformed to a voltage signal, which is processed via an instrumentation system.
14.3.1 Two-Beam Interference
where nd is the optical path length for the wave, ω is the frequency of the light wave, and φ is the phase of the optical wave. Interference is generated by the combination of two coherent light waves with different optical phases. In general, the phase difference is created by having the two optical waves travel different paths forming a path length difference (PLD) as discussed in Chap. 18. The derivation of the intensity response of a general interferometer begins with two coherent light waves that differ by the optical phase term, as given in (14.6). E1 = A1 cos(φ1 − ωt) , E2 = A2 cos(φ2 − ωt) .
(14.6)
The intensity that results from the interference of these two electric field vectors is given by I = |E1 + E2 |2 . I= 2A1 A2 cos(φ1 − ωt) cos(φ2 − ωt) . A21 cos2 (φ1 − ωt) +
identity: 2 cos(α) cos(β) = cos(α + β) + cos(α − β). Applying these two considerations to (14.8), the intensity function becomes I = A¯ + A1 A2 cos(φ1 + φ2 − 2ωt) + . . . A1 A2 cos(φ1 − φ2 ) .
I = A + B cos(Δφ) ,
(14.8)
The first two terms in (14.8) are the intensity of the two individual electric field vectors and only contribute an effective constant to the measurement signal as described in Chap. 18. The final term in the above expression can be replaced by the product of cosines
(14.10)
where the phase difference (Δφ) contains the strain information of interest in the terms of a PLD. The differences between the types of fiber optic interferometers are based on how the two coherent beams are derived from the system and where the two optical paths are recombined. In classical interferometers, the output of a light source is split via a beam-splitter and the two paths are recombined on a screen. In fiber optic interferometers, the beam splitting and recombining are accomplished within the optical fiber components so that the optical signals are always guided. The interference signal is then coupled to one (or more) photodetectors for signal acquisition and data processing.
14.3.2 Strain–Optic Effect The following derivation examines how the change in optical phase is related to the strain on the optical fiber. Where the stress–optic law discussed in Chap. 25 examines the optical effect on a two-dimensional structure (i. e., plate) under a state of plane stress, the strain–optic effect discussed here examines the influence of a strain state on an optical fiber. Light traveling in an optical fiber can be classified by an optical modal parameter called the propagation constant β given by [14.7] β = nkw =
A22 cos2 (φ2 − ωt) + . . .
(14.9)
The second term in (14.8) is at twice the optical frequency and only adds to the constant term in the equation. The final term in (14.8) provides a means for measuring the difference in optical phase between the two coherent light waves with intensity. Equation (14.8) can now be written in the more familiar form for interferometers
(14.7)
Substituting (14.6) into (14.7) yields:
355
2πn core , λ
(14.11)
where n core is the refractive index of the core of the optical fiber and kw is the wavenumber associated with the wavelength of light propagating in the optical fiber. The optical phase (φ) of light traveling through a section of optical fiber is given by φ = βL =
2πn core L. λ
(14.12)
Part B 14.3
As discussed in Chap. 18, the basic equation for the electric vector of a light wave is given by (18.1) and is rewritten here for convenience in (14.4): 2π (14.4) (z − vt) , E1 = A cos λ where A is a vector giving the amplitude and plane of the wave, λ is the wavelength, and v is the wave velocity. Since the wave is traveling in the optical fiber, the refractive index of the core is included in the path length and wave velocity as 2π c nd − t E1 = A cos λ n
2π 2π nd − ct = A cos λ nλ (14.5) = A cos(φ − ωt) ,
14.3 Interferometry
356
Part B
Contact Methods
When a mechanical load is applied to the optical fiber, a phase change is experienced due to changes in the length of the optical fiber (strain) and due to changes to the propagation constant (strain–optic). These influences are the basis for interferometric strain sensors. The change in optical phase (Δφ) can be written as [14.8] Δφ = βΔL + LΔβ .
(14.13)
Part B 14.3
The influence of the βΔL term is directly related to the strain on the optical fiber (ε), as a change in length and can be written as βεL. The change in the propagation constant is attributed to two sources. One is a waveguide dispersion effect due to the change in the optical fiber diameter. This effect is considered negligible compared to the other influences on the optical phase change [14.8]. The other source is the change in the refractive index, written as dβ (14.14) Δn . LΔβ = L dn The dβ/ dn term is reduced to the wavenumber, kw , but the Δn term is related to the optical indicatrix, Δ[1/n 2 ]2,3 , as [14.8, 9]
n3 1 (14.15) Δn = − , Δ 2 2 n 2,3 where light is propagating in the axial direction of the optical fiber as indicated in Fig. 14.12. For the case of small strains, the optical indicatrix is related to the strain on the optical fiber as: 1 = pij ε j , (14.16) Δ 2 n eff i where pij is the strain–optic tensor of the optical fiber and ε j is the contracted strain tensor. In the general case, the strain–optic tensor will have nine distinct elements, termed photoelastic constants related to the normal strains (shear strain is neglected). Fortunately, for a homogenous, isotropic material (such as optical fiber), the strain–optic tensor can be 2
Fig. 14.12 Indicial directions for optical fiber
For the case of a surface-mounted sensor, it has been shown that the contracted strain tensor with zero shear strain may be written as [14.2, 9] ⎛ ⎞ 1 ⎜ ⎟ (14.18) ε j = ⎝−ν ⎠ εz , −ν where ν is Poisson’s ratio for the optical fiber. If transverse loads are of interest, they may be incorporated through the strain tensor. Due to the symmetry of the optical fiber, the optical indicatrix is equivalent for i = 2 or 3. Incorporating the contracted strain tensor into (14.16) leads to the following expression for a surfacemounted optical fiber sensor 1 = εz [ p12 − ν( p11 + p12 )] . (14.19) Δ 2 n eff 2,3 After substituting (14.19) into (14.13), the result is Δφ = βεz L −
2π L n 3 εz [ p12 − ν( p11 + p12 )] . λ 2 (14.20)
Reducing the above equation leads to: n2 Δφ = βL 1 − [ p12 − ν( p11 + p12 )] εz . 2 (14.21)
Normalizing (14.21) by (14.12) yields the standard form of the phase change with respect to the original phase: n2 Δφ = 1 − [ p12 − ν( p11 + p12 )] εz . (14.22) φ 2
14.3.3 Optical Coherence
1 3
represented by two photoelastic constants p11 and p12 as [14.9] ⎞ ⎛ p11 p12 p12 ⎟ ⎜ pij = ⎝ p12 p11 p12 ⎠ . (14.17) p12 p12 p11
Another important concept for fiber optic interferometers is optical coherence. Interference of optical waves can only occur if the two waves are coherent, meaning that the phase information between the two waves is related. When light is emitted from a source, it is composed of coherent packets of energy. Coherence of
Optical Fiber Strain Gages
Fig. 14.13 Optical source spectrum
λ 20 Lc ≈ Δλ
357
Sensing path
Δλ λ0
14.3 Interferometry
Reference path
Fig. 14.14 Basic Mach–Zehnder fiber optic sensor arrangement
λ
14.3.5 Michelson
Lc ≈
λ20 Δλ
.
(14.23)
14.3.4 Mach–Zehnder As optical fiber and optical fiber components became available for sensing purposes, the recreation of classic interferometers was the first choice for early researchers. The first reported fiber optic strain gage by Butter and Hocker was an optical-fiber-based Mach– Zehnder [14.8]. In this early version, the output from two optical fibers was recombined on a screen to monitor the resulting interference pattern. As displayed in Fig. 14.14, light from a coherent light source is split into two optical paths via a 3 dB coupler. A second 3 dB coupler is used to recombine the optical paths and create the interference signal. The interference signal passes through both outputs of the second 3 dB coupler to the photodetectors. The use of both outputs is beneficial to some interrogation techniques. The path length difference for the Mach–Zehnder interferometer is dependent on the strain applied to the sensing path.
The history of the Michelson interferometer was discussed in the basic optics chapter of this handbook (Chap. 18). Like the Mach–Zehnder interferometer, the Michelson interferometer is constructed in a similar fashion to its classical namesake. The Michelson interferometer, illustrated in Fig. 14.15, uses a 3 dB coupler to divide the optical source into two optical paths. Each optical path has a mirror that reflects the optical signal back to the 3 dB coupler where the two paths interfere. The intensity of the interference signal is then monitored via the photodetector. The reference path is usually isolated from strain, so changes to the sensing path due to the applied load create an optical phase change with respect to the reference path.
14.3.6 Fabry–Pérot The basis of a Fabry–Pérot interferometer is the interference of a light wave reflected from a cavity. French physicists Fabry and Pérot analyzed this type of optical structure in the 19th century. As displayed in Fig. 14.16, the basic fiber optic Fabry–Pérot sensor functions from the interference of a reflection from a first surface, fiber to air, and a second surface, air to fiber. The air–glass interface leads to a reflection of approximately 4% of the input intensity. With such a low reflectivity percentage, the Fabry–Pérot interferometer can be assumed to be a two-beam interferometer. If higher-reflectivity coatings are applied, then a multipass interferometer is created. The particular Fabry–Pérot sensor displayed in Fig. 14.16 is an extrinsic Fabry–Pérot interferometer
Sensing path
Reference path
Fig. 14.15 Basic Michelson fiber optic sensor
Part B 14.3
an optical source is a measure of the length of the optical wave packets. Each wave packet can be thought to have a different starting optical phase; thus, light from two different wave packets have different starting phases and will not produce an interference pattern. For very narrow-band sources such as lasers, the coherence length is very long. For broadband optical sources such as light bulbs, the coherence length is very short. In order for an interferometer to function and produce an interference signal, the coherence length of the optical source must be greater than the resulting PLD of the interferometer. A general rule of thumb for determining the coherence length (L c ) of an optical source is to divide the square of the center wavelength (λ0 ) by the bandwidth of the source (Δλ), as given by (14.23). A depiction of the optical source spectrum is shown in Fig. 14.13.
358
Part B
Contact Methods
signal is generated when the output of the PM fiber is launched back into standard single-mode fiber. It should be noted that PM fiber and PM optical components are also used to make Michelson, Mach– Zehnder, and Fabry–Pérot interferometers with the light being restricted to a single polarization axis. This type of construction alleviates issues due to polarization fading that are common among the optical fiber interferometers. Fig. 14.16 Schematic of a fiber optic Fabry–Pérot sensor
14.3.8 Interrogation of Interferometers Part B 14.3
(EFPI). The sensor is extrinsic because the sensing region is the air cavity formed by the two optical fiber end faces. There are intrinsic Fabry–Pérot sensors where the sensing cavity is formed between partial mirrors fused within an optical fiber. These sensors are much more difficult to fabricate and have not experienced the same commercial availability as the EFPI sensors. The low-finesse interferometer allows for a twobeam interferometer to be assumed for mathematical analysis. With the sensing region taking place in an air cavity for the EFPI, the influence of the strain–optic effect can be neglected and the refractive index is assumed to be equal to 1. Thus, the optical phase change with respect to applied strain can be written as Δφ = βΔL =
4π L FP ε. λ
(14.24)
For the case of intrinsic Fabry–Pérot sensors, the strain– optic effect will be included in the phase change formulation.
14.3.7 Polarization As discussed in Sect. 14.1.2, there exist specialty optical fibers that are designed to preserve the polarization of light as it is guided