Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy
Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy Edited by M. Prutton and M. El Gomati # 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 0-470-86677-2
Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy Martin Prutton University of York, York, UK
Mohamed M. El Gomati University of York, York, UK
Copyright ß 2006
John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England Telephone (þ44) 1243 779777
Email (for orders and customer service enquiries):
[email protected] Visit our Home Page on www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP, UK, without the permission in writing of the Publisher. Requests to the Publisher should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 8SQ, England, or emailed to
[email protected], or faxed to (þ44) 1243 770620. Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The Publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, USA Jossey-Bass, 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741, USA Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Boschstr. 12, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd, 42 McDougall Street, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02-01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons Canada Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada M9W 1L1 Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Scanning Auger electron microscopy / [edited by] Martin M. Prutton, Mohamed M. El Gomati. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: 978-0-470-86677-1 (cloth : acid-free paper) ISBN-10: 0-470-86677-2 (cloth : acid-free paper) 1. Scanning Auger electron microscopy. I. Prutton, M. II. El Gomati, Mohamed M. QH212.S24S31 2006 502.80 25–dc22
2005031938
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN-13 978-0-470-86677-1 (HB) ISBN-10 0-470-86677-2 (HB) Typeset in 10/12pt Sabon by Thomson Press (India) Limited, New Delhi Printed and bound in Spain by Grafos S.A., Barcelona This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
To Aisha and in loving memory of Elsie who both believed that MULSAM was a concept worth supporting. You did so with care, encouragement and love. We could not have spent so much time, energy and effort on it without your support.
Contents List of Contributors
ix
Preface
xi
Acknowledgments
xv
1. Introduction M.M. El Gomati and M. Prutton
1
2. The Auger Process J.A.D. Matthew
15
3. Instrumentation M.M. El Gomati and M. Prutton
45
4. The Spatial Resolution M.M. El Gomati
125
5. Forming an Auger Image M.M. El Gomati and M. Prutton
165
6. Image Processing and Interpretation M. Prutton
201
7. Quantification of Auger Images M. Prutton
245
8. Applications: Materials Science R.K. Wild
259
9. Applications: Semiconductor Manufacturing C.F.H. Gondran
295
viii
CONTENTS
10. Concluding Remarks M.M. El Gomati and M. Prutton
341
Author Index
351
Subject Index
359
List of Contributors M. M. El Gomati, Department of Electronics, University of York, Heslington, York, YO10 5DD, UK C. F. H. Gondran Process Characterization Laboratory, ATDF Inc. [A subsidiary of SEMATECH], 2706 Montopolis Drive, Austin, TX 78741, USA J. A. D. Matthew Department of Physics, University of York, Heslington, York, YO10 5DD, UK M. Prutton Department of Physics, University of York, Heslington, York, YO10 5DD, UK R. K. Wild Interface Analysis Centre, Oldbury House, 121 St Michaels Hill, Bristol BS2 8BS, UK
Preface Activity in surface science underwent an enormous explosion in the mid1960s when ultra-high vacuum (UHV) technology became commercially available and so it became possible to clean a surface and maintain sufficient cleanliness for a time adequate to make a measurement of some kind. The activity started with measurements of work functions and of the diffraction of low energy electrons but soon expanded to the development and use of many spectroscopies that yielded information about the electronic and vibrational states of atoms at or near the free surface. Applications to the early stages of chemical reactions and to the metallurgical properties of materials were very prominent at this stage. Thus, the state of a nominally clean surface was of interest as were the effects of various surface contaminants upon its properties and the subsequent reaction with the components of a gaseous atmosphere or a beam of some other kind of atoms. Once the electron spectroscopies had been applied to these problems there was considerable progress in the development of the understanding of surface processes. These spectroscopies included X-ray photoelectron spectroscopies and Auger electron spectroscopy that were sensitive to the number and kind of atoms that were present right at the surface of the sample. However, practical surfaces were unlikely to consist of a clean, flat, arrangement of atoms and the spatial resolution of these spectroscopies was so poor that the information so gleaned required the preparation of such perfect surfaces or was an integration over many differently oriented crystallographic grains or even different materials. Nevertheless, enormous progress was made in revealing the nature of the free surface of a solid and many surprising phenomena were discovered. Electron stimulated Auger electron spectroscopy was a good candidate for a microscopy because the beam of incident electrons upon the sample could be focused onto the surface and could be scanned across the surface. These two properties were critical in the conversion of a spectroscopy to a microscopy that could provide maps or images of the distribution of a selected element in the surface of a sample. All that was
xii
PREFACE
required was a scanning electron microscope that provided a UHV environment and was equipped with an electron energy analyser to select a particular Auger electron energy from the distribution of electron energies emitted from the sample. This apparently simple statement is quite deceptive. This book sets out to describe the considerations required for this development to be brought to reality and then to illustrate the application of scanning Auger electron microscopy to the surfaces of semiconducting device structures and to systems in materials science. It is now a mature methodology that is used in commercial instruments developed in Europe, Japan and the USA. Naturally, the complexity of these instruments means that they are expensive and so unlikely to be found in the corner of any laboratory! Notwithstanding this expense they have provided information crucial, for instance, to the successful production of integrated circuits and to the oxidation of the superalloys, and so the reliability of the jet engines of the aeroplanes that we all use. The editors (and authors) of this book have been contributing to the development and the applications of this microscopy since the early 1970s. They have built, developed and used three complete Auger electron microscopes. The first was a UHV scanning electron microscope (HB200) from Vacuum Generators Ltd and funded by the R.W. Paul Instrument Fund of the Royal Society that we adapted by adding a concentric hemispherical analyser for electron energy analysis. This instrument proved, to our satisfaction, that Auger electron imaging was feasible and delivered our first results. It also showed that analog detection of the electron current leaving the analyser was not a practical way forward and that field emission electron sources were a subject for research in their own right! The second instrument was developed with electron counting techniques for measuring the current leaving the analyser and Schottky field emission sources in the gun for the electron column. This instrument was much more successful and we were able to use it for the study of the surfaces of nickel superalloys and for the identification of artefacts that can occur at the sharp edges of structures on top of a surface. Attempts were started at this stage to acquire quantitative images of the distribution of a given element on a surface. This appeared feasible because of successful attempts to analyse the amount of material on a surface using Auger electron spectroscopy carried out by ourselves and others (see Chapters 2 and 3). The difficulties of this image quantification led us to consider the simultaneous acquisition of other types of electrons and photons from
PREFACE
xiii
the sample in order to try to disentangle the structure of the surface region from the yield of each kind of signal being detected. This led to the invention and development of the third microscope, the multispectral Auger microscope (MULSAM), that was equipped with detectors for simultaneous measurement of images from an area of interest using scanning electron microscopy, energetic back-scattered electrons, loss electrons and characteristic X-rays. This instrument has been used for a wide variety of applications, some of which are described in this book. It may be clear from this description that the design, building and development of these three instruments has been a huge task that has occupied the time of many people. We are very pleased that we are able to acknowledge their various contributions in the subsequent section. Spending all this time on instrument development has meant that the editors felt it unwise to attempt to review other areas of the subject. Accordingly, we are very pleased that Jim Matthew, Bob Wild and Carolyn Gondran were able to contribute Chapters 2, 8 and 9 from their areas of expertise – contributions that reflect the value of their work in this field. The material in this book is intended as a guide to the subject of Auger electron microscopy and so it is hoped that it will be of interest to researchers in this field as well as to others who wish to discover what can be achieved with this technique and what are its limitations. Thus it is hoped that it will be useful to analysts working with scanning Auger electron microscopes, who are hard pressed to hurry up and measure many samples and so have little time to work on other aspects of the behaviour of their instrument or the problems that they may, perhaps unwittingly, encounter. M. M. El Gomati M. Prutton
Acknowledgments The editors (and authors) have many people to thank for the help they have been given in the building, development and use of the MULSAM instrument at York. Building an entire electron microscope from scratch is a far from minor undertaking especially when it has to be a UHV instrument with energy analysis and it is entirely computer controlled. There were times when we wished that we had not committed ourselves to the job! The first and most important acknowledgment is to Oliver Heavens who backed us from the paper study stage through all the trials and tribulations with humour, a deep interest and, most importantly, money. In spite of an absurdly heavy workload when he was head of department, he managed to come by at least once a week to see how we were progressing and to bring along some champagne at times of success. Thank you very much Oliver. The project started with the design and build of a fast concentric hemispherical analyser which was funded by the R.W. Paul Fund of The Royal Society. The Royal Society Assessors for this work were Peter Duncumb and Reg Garton who came not to criticise but to offer their experience and help. This was invaluable and an important contributor to the speed of progress. Peter Bassett worked on this development which successfully began the whole set of moves to build, develop and use a scanning Auger electron microscope. In fact, three scanning Auger electron microscopes were constructed and a number of postdoctoral fellows and research students were involved. The first instrument was an analog realisation to which Ray Browning and the late Dave Peacock were crucial contributors. They quickly demonstrated that although the Auger electrons could be detected in this way it was the wrong way to go about it. Dave and Ray stayed on and were joined by Peter Kenny and Chris Walker (at different times) to build a digital instrument. Peter Kenny worked for 6 years on the software for the microscope (writing some 200 000 lines of
xvi
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
software which worked first time) with occasional inputs from Martin Prutton and Mohamed El Gomati and from Chris Walker and Dave Peacock. This was an exciting and productive time helped by the fact that we were joined by Ron Roberts from the University of Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia, who brought many skills in experimental techniques and electronics to the project. Ron has made repeated visits to work with us and has been an invaluable help. The final instrument to be built was MULSAM. This is the most complex instrument and took the efforts of many individuals. Matt Wenham contributed to the software with multivariate statistics, John Greenwood and Ian Barkshire contributed to the hardware and software designs and execution in many important ways. David Wilkinson extended the use of an energy dispersive X-ray detector to work simultaneously with the various electron detectors. Support for this work relied on help generously given by Cedric Powell of NIST and Martin Seah of NPL. There were many contributions from D. Phil. students including Ahmed Assa’d, Taib Bakoush, Martin Crone, Barack Kola, John Kudjoe, Dan Loveday, Phil Tenney, John Walton, Torquil Wells, Andy Gelsthorpe and Li Chen, all of whom helped to move the whole project forward. Of course, a big instrumental build of this kind also required the technical assistance of many people. Jack Dee worked as a technician looking after all three microscopes and his help was indispensable. It is a pleasure to be able to thank Colin Ovenden, David Coulthard and Mick Peters for a wide range of skills that helped to keep the instruments running. Staff in the mechanical workshop made beautiful jobs of the concentric hemispherical analyser, the specimen manipulator, the electron column and many other smaller components. They included John Eastwood, the late Lennie Jarvis, Leigh Crosby, Peter Durkin, Bob Easton, Brent Wilkinson, Ian Wright and Pete Turner. Staff in the electronics workshop made excellent high stability power supplies, beam scanning and stigmators as well as many smaller pieces of electronic hardware. They included the late Jim Scott, Steve Lawson, Simon Hart, Pete Turner and Bob Hide. The technical staff was as important to this project as the scientists. Help with electron optical design was generously given in the early stages of the project by Ken Smith and Eric Munro of the Engineering Department, University of Cambridge. We would also like to thank Tom Mulvey, Aston University, Birmingham, for his encouragement and advice from his wide experience of many different kinds of electron
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
xvii
optical devices. Don Whitehead of the then VSW Ltd was extremely generous with financial support for electron optics for which we are most grateful. Collaboration with colleagues in the semiconductor fabrication industry was very important in demonstrating just what could be learned with an Auger microscope. Funding for the project came from the Alvey Project of the Department of Trade and Industry and from the Adequat Project of the European Union for which we are most grateful. In these projects we worked with Chris Hill, Pete Pearson, Peter Augustus and Kevin Stribley of Plessey, with Barry Lamb of Standard Telecommunications Ltd and Geoff Spiller and Chris Tuppen of British Telecom. We are most grateful to these collaborators and for the excellent samples that they made available to us. Carolyn Gondran would like to thank Mark Clark, Chris Sparks, Charlene Johnson but most especially Milt Godwin and Laurie Modrey for their many, many helpful comments and suggestions, and Marilyn Redmond and Bob Ruliffson from the SEMATECH library for assistance with reference material. She would also like to thank her family: Chris for moral support and her daughters for the endless distractions.
1 Introduction M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton
The region near to the surface of a solid material can play importantroles in the properties of that solid. Should an atom or molecule arrive at such a surface, be it in vacuo, in air, in a liquid or in contact with the surface of a different material, then the crystallographic structure, the atomic type, the electronic structure, the vibrations of surface atoms and the bonding forces between the arrival and the surface may all affect what happens next. Thus, for example, the arrival may adhere to the solid surface or be scattered off of it, or the arrival may react with the surface forming a new compound locally. Should the temperature, the structure and the binding energies of the atoms in the surface have appropriate values then the arrival may diffuse into the solid or even cause atoms in the solid to diffuse out to the surface. For these reasons solid surfaces are important in many processes in a wide variety of different parts of science, including biology, chemistry, materials science and physics. Further, they are important in many areas of technology such as semiconductor device fabrication and characterisation, the design of catalysts to speed up chemical reactions, and the development of anti-corrosion layers on alloys and metals. The subject of surface science is thus very broad indeed, having scientific and commercial implications in the effects that it has on large industries. Introductions to the subject include books by Prutton1, Walls2, Woodruff and Delchar3 and Zangwill4. The whole area has been reviewed, for instance, by Duke5 and by Duke and Plummer6. What is meant by the surface of a solid? The answer to this question depends upon what surface properties are under investigation and what Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy Edited by M. Prutton and M. El Gomati # 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 0-470-86677-2
2
INTRODUCTION
experimental techniques are being used for their measurement. The theoretical physicist may be interested in the wave functions of atoms in the outermost layer of the solid. Most extremely, interest may be on the wave functions and their properties in the region in a vacuum outside the solid surface. The experimental scientist may be measuring the properties of the topmost few atomic layers of the solid or the topmost few hundred layers depending upon the methods being used. Most experimental methods involve the bombardment of the surface under study by particles or photons and the detection of scattered particles or photons. If visible photons are incident and reflected photons are detected then the depth of the region of the solid being probed is of the order of the wavelength of the light being used – the information depth is of the order of many hundreds of nanometers. If energetic X-rays are incident and detected then this depth may be of the order of microns. If energetic X-rays are incident and photoelectrons are detected this depth can be as small as a fraction of a nanometer – only a few atom layers are being probed. A similar information depth is obtained when energetic electrons are incident and Auger electrons are emitted from the atoms in the solid. In this book the surface is taken to be the region of a solid within a depth of a few (<20) atomic layers from its free surface. This information depth depends upon the relative sizes of the depth penetrated by the incident photons or particles – the penetration depth and the depth from which the stimulated particles or photons can arrive at the detector with properties unchanged – the escape depth. If the penetration depth is small compared with the escape depth then it is the penetration depth that determines the information depth. This is the case, for example, in energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) detection where electrons are focused onto a solid sample and may penetrate to a depth of the order of a micron and characteristic X-rays are emitted and detected. The X-rays may reach their detector unchanged from such a relatively small depth so the information depth is the penetration depth. At the other extreme, in Auger electron spectroscopy (AES), energetic (say 10 keV) electrons may be focused onto the solid and low energy Auger electrons are detected. The ingoing electrons may penetrate a micron or so but the Auger electrons have much lower kinetic energies and can only escape from the solid with their energies unchanged if they originate from very near the surface. In this case the escape depth determines the information depth and may be very small – about 0.5 nm depending upon the kinetic energy of the Auger electrons. The information depths for X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy are very similar to those of Auger spectroscopy – particularly when the
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
3
kinetic energies of the photoelectrons are below about 1 keV. This subject is dealt with more completely in Chapter 2. When the intention is to study the topmost atomic layer in a solid the environment in which the sample is immersed becomes of critical importance. Even in a ‘vacuum’, in every second many atoms or molecules in the ambient atmosphere will strike the surface. This rate depends upon the pressure of the ambient gas – the lower the pressure the lower the rate of impact. Since these events may change the surface by knocking off atoms expected to be present, by sticking to the surface or by reacting with the surface then the surface may be changed from whatever state it was intended to be in – atomically clean, covered with specific atoms of a different kind or whatever the investigator required. The kinetic theory associated with contamination from the ambient atmosphere is discussed in more detail in Chapter 3. Most surface science measurements are conducted in ultra-high vacuum (UHV)7 in which the total pressure is less than about 109 mbar. In such pressures the arrival rate of molecules from the ambient gas can allow measurement times of several hours8 before the surface under study is covered with a single layer (a monolayer) of contaminating molecules. One question that usually needs to be answered about a surface is ‘what is it composed of?’ The answer is revealed with those measurements that can be chemically specific and yet have sufficient sensitivity to detect the small amount of material in the topmost atomic layer. The techniques available to a surface analyst are summarised in Table 1.1 where a rough guide to the sensitivity of each method is given. Table 1.1 The commonly available methods to identify the elements in or near the surface of a solid together with a rough estimate of their sensitivities in terms of atomic monolayers. Most elemental materials contain about 1019 atoms m2
Method Energy dispersive X-ray analysis X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy Auger electron spectroscopy Secondary ion mass spectroscopy
Acronym
Incident ‘particles’
EDX
Electrons (5–30 keV)
XPS
Monochromatic X-rays (5 keV) Monochromatic electrons (5 keV) Monochromatic ions (Ar)
AES SIMS
‘Particles’ detected
Rough sensitivity (monolayers)
Characteristic X-rays (0.5–10 keV) Photoelectrons (0.1–5 keV)
200
Auger electrons (0.1–3 keV) Secondary ions (mass 1–5000)
0.1
0.1
10 atoms
4
INTRODUCTION
Figure 1.1 Potraits of Pierre Auger and Lise Meitner. Both pictures are by courtesy of the American Institute of Physics, Emilio Segre` Visual Archives. The picture of Meitner is part of the Herzfeld Collection in those archives
This book concentrates upon a form of scanning electron microscopy in which electrons are focused onto the surface of a solid sample and Auger electrons are emitted into an energy analyser in which their kinetic energy is established. These electrons were first described as a theoretical possibility in 1923 by Rosseland9 and were identified by Meitner10,11 and independently by Auger12 from the results of cloud chamber experiments. Photographs of Auger and Meitner are reproduced in Figure 1.1 and the story of Lise Meitner’s scientific struggles is described by Sime13. All their work was directed at the explanation of sharp spectral features in b-ray spectroscopy arising from internal conversion in g irradiation. The subject is described in the book by Burhop14. The use of Auger electrons in the analysis of surfaces was first described by Lander as early as 195314. As can be seen in the caption to Figure 1.2, the kinetic energy of an Auger electron is determined by the differences between the electronic energy levels in the atoms involved in the process. This energy depends upon the element emitting Auger electrons and is independent of the energy of the ionising beam of electrons. The intensity (the number of electrons detected) in a particular
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
5
Figure 1.2 A one-electron energy level diagram for a mythical metallic sample. The labels on the right indicate the notation used for the energy levels in X-ray spectroscopy. The labels on the left correspond to the binding energies of the electrons in each level measured from the vacuum level. (a) The process of generation of an Auger electron is indicated. In this example the electron beam is incident with sufficient kinetic energy to ionise the K shell of the atoms involved. The energy of the ionised atom is reduced by one electron falling into the initial state hole from a less tightly bound state and by a second electron being emitted from the same or another less tightly bound state. The kinetic energy of the electron leaving the atom is approximately EK EL1 EL2;3 . This energy is independent of the energy of the incident electron. This particular process would be described as the emission of a KL1 L2;3 Auger electron. (b) For XPS the monochromatic X-ray beam with energy hn ionises the 1s level and causes the emission of an electron with kinetic energy hn E1s . E1s is the binding energy of the electron in the 1s (or K) state
6
INTRODUCTION
Auger peak in the electron spectrum does depend upon the energy of the ionizing beam. Indeed, using the example in Figure 1.2(a), if this energy is lower than the binding energy of the initial state electron (EK in that example) then no Auger electrons can be emitted based upon that initial state. If the energy is above this threshold then the intensity is determined, in part, by the ionisation cross-section for that initial state. The dependence of Auger intensities upon the energy of the incident electron beam is covered in more detail in Chapter 2. An example of some Auger peaks from a contaminated silver sample is shown in Figure 1.3 and examples of spectra from many elements, compounds and alloys can be found in the handbooks of spectra published by Japan Electron Optics (JEOL Ltd)16 and by Physical Electronics Inc. (PHI)17 and on the web at http://www.lasurface.com. The whole subject of surface analysis has been reviewed in books by Prutton1, Vickerman18, Venables19 and Briggs and Grant20. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy is similar to Auger electron spectroscopy in that the incident radiation has sufficient energy to ionise core levels in the atoms of the surface. Photoelectrons are emitted with an energy corresponding to the difference between that of the incident X-ray photons and the binding energy of electrons in the level ionised. Thus, in Figure 1.2(b), the ionization was of a K state and so the energy of the photoelectron emitted would be hn EK . Again, for a fixed X-ray beam energy the kinetic energy of the photoelectrons is characteristic of the emitting element. Photoelectron spectroscopy has played an important part in the history of the study of wave particle duality. The effect was described by Innes21 in 1907 and developed into a spectroscopy later by Siegbahn22 and others. Siegbahn gave the name ‘Electron Spectroscopy for Chemical Analysis’ (ESCA) for the use of both Auger and photoelectron spectroscopies excited by X-ray photons. It is technically simple to scan an electron or ion beam across a surface with a deflecting electric or magnetic field acting on the incident beam to cause it to remain focused on the sample but to be displaced across the surface in some desired sequence of movements. This makes scanning microscopy possible. The beam can be scanned across the surface of the sample in a series of steps. Whilst the beam is static the ions or electrons emitted from the sample can be detected and mass or kinetic energy analysed and the number of scattered ions with a particular mass (for SIMS) or the number of Auger electrons with a particular kinetic energy (for AES) counted and stored. The beam is then moved to the next position on the sample and the process repeated. This step, analyse,
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
50
100
150
200
250
Ag + C
Energy (eV)
300
Ag
350
Ag
400
450
500
550
Figure 1.3 A section from an Auger spectrum from a silver sample. The incident electron beam had energy of 5 keV and a beam current of 10 nA. The energy analyser was a concentric hemispherical type in the York MULSAM instrument (see Chapter 3). The peaks are superimposed upon a slowly changing background due to the secondary electrons leaving the sample
Counts
8
INTRODUCTION
count and store cycle is usually carried out in either a square or rectangular array of points on the surface – a so-called digital raster. Either after or during this process an image of the surface can be displayed on a computer monitor or other device in which the position of the incident beam on the sample has a simple mapping onto the screen of the display and the counts detected at that position on the sample determine the intensity of the corresponding point on the display. Thus, places on the sample with a large number of atoms emitting electrons of the chosen kinetic energy appear brighter on the display than places with few of the same kind of atoms. The display thus provides a chemical map of the distribution of that element in the surface. It is a spectroscopic image in the sense that the variations in the intensity of a feature in an energy spectrum have been mapped from place to place on a surface. The first to report the use of Auger electrons to demonstrate scanning Auger microscopy were Harris23 and McDonald24. A diagram comparing the components of a scanning electron microscope and a scanning Auger microscope is shown in Figure 1.4. Scanning Auger microscopy should strictly be defined as scanning Auger electron microscopy (abbreviated as SAEM) but common usage is now to refer to it as scanning Auger microscopy (SAM) which is conveniently shorter and easier to pronounce, at least in English! Clearly it is electrons that are being scanned not an individual whose name is Auger! Spectroscopic imaging of this kind involves the acquisition of a great deal of data. Imagine, for example, the characterization of the surface chemical composition of an area of a sample containing five elements whose concentrations vary from place to place. At each position on the sample at which a measurement is made the heights or areas of at least five peaks in a spectrum must be estimated. The simplest approach might be to make estimates of the peak heights by subtracting the measured background counts in the spectrum with energy above or below each peak from the counts in the spectrum at the peak energy. Thus, for five elements, a minimum of 10 measurements must be made. Consider that a set of five images are to be formed, one for each element, each with 256 by 256 picture points (pixels) for adequate image quality for presentation or subsequent analysis. This means that at least 655360 measurements are required to derive the five images. If it is assumed that 32-bit precision is needed in each measurement in order to have adequate dynamic range in the possible counts and to allow subsequent numerical processing then this image set requires at least 2.5 Mbytes of storage space. If some experimental parameter is to be varied – say
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
9
Conventional vacuum
1
4
2
3
6
5
10 9 8
7 (a) Ultrahigh vacuum 1
4
2
13 3
6
5
10 12 7
11 8
9
(b)
Figure 1.4 A comparison of the principal components of (a) an SEM and (b) a SAM. Item 1 is an electron source; items 2 and 3 are electron lenses and 4 is a set of power supplies all of which are used to form a focused electron beam on the sample surface, item 7. Items 5 and 6 are components to scan the focused beam across the surface of the sample. Item 8 detects secondary electrons in (a) and electrons of selected kinetic energy emerging from an energy analyser 11 in (b). Items 9 and 10 amplify and condition the signal from 8 to control the brightness of a display 10 or provide input to a control computer 13. Item 12 represents the electronics providing control of the potentials in the electron energy analyser in (b)
10
INTRODUCTION
the sample temperature or exposure to some gas reacting with the surface – then many such sets of data may be required as the surface changes. The implications for data storage are obvious and some form of data compression may be essential for efficient use of available resources. Some considerations of the hardware and software requirements for these instruments are described in Chapter 3. A more important issue arises from the time that must be taken to acquire such a set of images. Most electron energy analysers are sequential devices. The potentials are set on each electrode of an analyser to determine the kinetic energies of electrons that lie in a small band of energies about the energy of the feature to be measured. Counting can then begin and is allowed to continue for the dwell time of measurement. After this time the analyser has to be set for a new energy or the beam exciting the electrons is moved on to the next position on the sample surface. Using the case of Auger electron emission and the equation for the yield of Auger electrons proposed by Bishop and Riviere25 (see Chapter 2), the example described in the previous paragraph can be pursued. Consider, for example, an incident electron beam of 10 nA striking a monolayer of oxygen atoms absorbed upon a silicon surface. Auger electrons with 505 eV kinetic energy are emitted from the oxygen atoms that are present with a density of about 1015 cm2. The cross-section for this process is about 1021 cm2. If, say, 1 % of the Auger electrons emitted enter the energy analyser and are detected then the current collected is about 1016 A or about 600 electrons s1 . Using Poisson statistics for the counting of electrons and a counting time of t s then the signal to noise ratio in a single measurement will be (600t)1/2. Thus, for example, if a measurement is made for 17 ms then about 10 electrons will be detected and the signal to noise ratio will be about 3:1. If this dwell time is chosen for each of the 10 energies in the example above and for each position of an incident electron beam on the sample then the 655360 measurements must take at least 3 h. Less time can be taken only by modifying the energy analyser to acquire several energy channels simultaneously or to collect a greater fraction of the total emission from the sample, accepting a lower number of points in the image, increasing the current in the beam reaching the sample or allowing a further reduction in the signal to noise ratio. The saving in time so gained scales with the square root of the number of electrons counted in each pixel and at each energy and so it is difficult to make large reductions in the total data acquisition time unless radical changes are made to the energy analyser.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
11
The argument in the paragraph above assumes that spectral information is acquired in the direct energy distribution NðEÞ. This is a common method of collecting images because, although the differential spectrum is often used for spectroscopy in order to improve discernment of peaks on a slowly changing background, the direct spectrum has a higher signal to noise ratio. Some researchers question the wisdom of acquiring images. This is largely because of the experimental time required to accumulate all of the information. The question therefore arises as to whether it is more efficient to choose places in or on the sample by some criterion such as a characteristically different contrast in, for instance, a rapidly measured scanning electron microscope (SEM) image. These particular places are then carefully observed using spectroscopy and the analysis performed at those places only. A slightly more detailed approach might be to scan a region of a sample along a line using spectroscopic imaging techniques and so reduce the data acquisition time from that required to collect a whole picture (a frame) to that required to collect a single line of that frame whilst ensuring that the line crosses the feature of interest. A criticism of these faster experimental methods is that it is very easy to miss features of special interest. This tactic can be misleading because there can be barely any contrast at all in the SEM image and yet the Auger image may reveal, for example, a distinct layer structure in the sample. Another example which can occur is when unexpected regions or phases have occurred in the sample and they just happen to have identical contrast in whatever fast scanning technique is used to try to classify how many different kinds of regions are present in the sample. Often it is the occurrence of unexpected effects that are both interesting and valuable in science! Finally, it should be stressed that the human eye–brain combination is very powerful at spotting spatial correlations and by analysing at points or along lines, the spatially correlated information about the sample is entirely or largely thrown away. Perhaps also we should bear in mind the cliche´ – ‘a picture is worth a thousand words’! The prediction as to the future of Auger electron spectroscopy made by Lander in his 1953 paper (cited above) had considerable foresight. To quote him explicitly: ‘In many problems of applied physics and chemistry, the identification of surface composition is at present impossible but of considerable importance. Where the material of interest is present to a depth of several atomic layers and the high vacuum condition is not prohibitive, the method offers a positive means of analysis. Problems of
12
INTRODUCTION
this type can be of a widely varied type.’ This has proved to be true. In addition to the pioneering work of Harris and of McDonald together with an enormous volume of work on Auger electron spectroscopy, scanning Auger microscopes have been designed and built by Griffiths et al.26, Bishop27, Brandis28, Christou29, Le Gressus et al.30, Powell et al.31, Todd and Poppa32, Venables et al.33 and Browning et al.34. Clearly, Lander was right. As stated above, this book focuses the reader’s attention upon the imaging of a surface by using a selected peak in the spectrum of Auger electrons. The subject was reviewed some years ago by Ferguson35 but both the methodology and the applications of the technique have developed significantly since that time. As mentioned several times above, Chapters 2 and 3 are concerned, respectively, with the theory of the Auger process and the instrumentation needed in an Auger microscope. Chapters 4 and 5 discuss, respectively, the limits to the spatial resolution of the microscopy and the methods used to separate the chemical information in an Auger image from potentially confusing effects (referred to as imaging artefacts) due to other properties of the sample, the experimental geometry employed or the methods used for collecting or displaying the data. Chapter 6 describes the software tools useful to interpret the information in an Auger image. Chapter 7 discusses methods that can convert the intensities of the pixels in a set of images using different Auger peaks from the same area of a sample into a set of maps revealing the atomic concentrations at each point in the surface – image quantification. Chapters 8 and 9 describe some of the most important applications of Auger microscopy in the fields of metallurgy and of semiconductor device characterisation. Many of the examples of Auger microscopy and the figures in this book were obtained by two of the authors (Mohamed El Gomati and Martin Prutton) in the study of a wide variety of samples using the multi-spectral Auger microscope (MULSAM) at York. This instrument was particularly useful in that it enabled the comparison of several different simultaneous signals from the sample and the combination of these signals in models of the electron scattering. This is not a conventional technique for SAM and so this imbalance is at least partially restored in Chapter 8 where Wild uses results for metals and alloys using an instrument from Physical Electronics (PHI 595) and in Chapter 9 where Gondran describes results for semiconductor device structures using another instrument from Physical Electronics (PHI 670 Field Emission Scanning Auger Microscope).
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
13
REFERENCES 1. M. Prutton, Introduction to Surface Physics (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1994). 2. J. M. Walls, Methods of Surface Analysis, Techniques and Application (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989). 3. D. P. Woodruff and T. A. Delchar, Modern Techniques of Surface Science (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1994). 4. A. Zangwill, Physics at Surfaces (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1988). 5. C. B. Duke, Surface Science 299/300, 1 (1994). 6. C. B. Duke and E. W. Plummer, Surface Science 500, 1 (2002). 7. P. A. Redhead, J. P. Hobson and E. V. Kornelsen, The Physical Basis of Ultra-High Vacuum (Chapman and Hall, London, 1968). 8. A. Chambers, Modern Vacuum Physics (Chapman and Hall/CRC, London, 2004). 9. S. Rosseland, Zeitschrift fu¨r Physik 14, 173 (1923). 10. L. Meitner, Zeitschrift fu¨r Physik 9, 131 (1922). 11. L. Meitner, Zeitschrift fu¨r Physik 17, 54 (1923). 12. P. Auger, Journal de Physique Radium 6, 205 (1925). 13. R. L. Sime, Lise Meitner: A Life in Physics (University of California Press, Berkeley, 1996). 14. E. H. S. Burhop, The Auger Effect and Other Radiationless Transitions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1952). 15. J. J. Lander, Physical Review 91, 1382 (1953). 16. T. Sekine, Y. Nagasawa, M. Kudoh, Y. Sakai, A. S. Parkes, J. D. Geller, A. Mogami and K. Hirata, Handbook of Auger Electron Spectroscopy (JEOL, Tokyo, 1982). 17. K. D. Childs, B. A. Carlson, L. A. LaVanier, J. F. Moulder, D. F. Paul, W. F. Stickle and D. G. Watson, Handbook of Auger Electron Spectroscopy, 3rd Edition (Physical Electronics Inc., Eden Prairie, 1995). 18. J. C. Vickerman, Surface Analysis – The Principal Techniques (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1997). 19. J. A. Venables, Introduction to Surface and Thin Film Processes (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2000). 20. D. Briggs and J. T. Grant, Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (IM Publications and Surface Spectra, Chichester, 2003). 21. P. D. Innes, Proceedings of The Royal Society (London) A79, 442 (1907). 22. K. Siegbahn, C. Nordling, A. Fahlman, R. Nordberg, K. Hamrin, J. Hedman, G. Johansson, T. Bergmark, S. Karlson, I. Lindgren and B. Lindberg, ESCA: Atomic, Molecular and Solid State Structure Studied by Means of Electron Spectroscopy (Almqvist and Wiksells Boktryckeri AB, Uppsala, 1967). 23. L. A. Harris, General Electric Research and Development Report 67-C-201 (1967). 24. N. C. MacDonald, Applied Physics Letters 16, 76 (1970). 25. H. E. Bishop and J. C. Riviere, Journal of Applied Physics 40, 1740 (1969). 26. B. W. Griffiths, A. V. Jones and I. R. M. Wardell, in Scanning Electron Microscopy: Systems and Applications (Institute of Physics, Bristol, 1973), p. 42. 27. H. E. Bishop, Auger spectroscopy in an SEM, Report no. 7899 (AERE, Harwell, 1974). 28. E. K. Brandis, in Scanning Electron Microscopy 1975 (Illinois Institute of Technology and Research, Chicago, 1975), p. 149.
14
INTRODUCTION
29. A. Christou, in IITRI/SEM/1975, edited by O. Johari (SEM Inc., Chicago, 1975), p. 149. 30. C. L. Gressus, D. Massignon and R. Sopizet, Comptes Rendus Hebdomaire Se´ance Academie Sciences Paris B 280, 439 (1975). 31. B. D. Powell, D. P. Woodruff and B. W. Griffiths, Journal of Physics E: Scientific Instruments 8, 548 (1975). 32. G. Todd, H. Poppa, D. Moorhead and M. Bales, Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology 12, 953 (1975). 33. J. A. Venables, A. P. Janssen, C. J. Harland and B. A. Joyce, Philosophical Magazine 34, 495 (1976). 34. R. Browning, P. J. Bassett, M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton, Proceedings of The Royal Society (London) A357, 213 (1977). 35. I. F. Ferguson, Auger Microprobe Analysis (Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol, 1989).
2 The Auger Process J. A. D. Matthew
2.1
INTRODUCTION
In Chapter 1 the basic phenomenon of the Auger process was introduced and in this chapter further elaboration is offered on the basic physics of the Auger process showing how the effect provides highly specific atomic concentration information in the surface and near surface region. This has been the subject of many reviews1–4, often in conjunction with analytic aspects of X-ray photoemission. In this respect strong reference is made to the recent book edited by Briggs and Grant5and the useful practical guide of Briggs and Seah6, where in both cases a widely respected ensemble of authors outline the state of the art in analytic electron spectroscopy. Although these references include some discussion of Auger microscopy7 and nanostructures8 the main emphasis in this chapter is on surface analysis without regard to spatial resolution. Therefore, limited reference is made to the complications of microscopy whilst indicating how the basic formulae of surface analysis are underpinned by good science with attention to how some of the results have to be modified at high spatial and depth resolution.
2.2
CLASSIFICATION OF AUGER PROCESSES
Before assessing the kinetic energies of the Auger transitions that provide the signatures used in Auger electron spectroscopy (AES) and scanning Auger microscopy (SAM) it is important to say a little more Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy Edited by M. Prutton and M. El Gomati # 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 0-470-86677-2
16
THE AUGER PROCESS
Table 2.1 Notation for XPS and AES processes Quantum numbers 1 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
0 0 1 1 0 1 1 2 2 0 1 1 2 2 3 3
1/2 1/2 1/2 3/2 1/2 1/2 3/2 3/2 5/2 1/2 1/2 3/2 3/2 5/2 5/2 7/2
X-ray suffix
X-ray level
Spectroscopic level
1 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
K L1 L2 L3 M1 M2 M3 M4 M5 N1 N2 N3 N4 N5 N6 N7
1s1/2 2s1/2 2p1/2 2p3/2 3s1/2 3p1/2 3p3/2 3d3/2 3d5/2 4s1/2 4p1/2 4p3/2 4d3/2 4d5/2 4f5/2 4f7/2
about the nomenclature used. A single electron state is specified by the quantum numbers n (principal), l (orbital), s (spin) and j (total angular momentum), which has values l þ 1/2 or l-1/2 (l ¼ 1, 2, 3, . . .) and ½ for l ¼ 0. The single electron binding energy E(nlj) is then specified by these three quantum numbers, which are indicated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopists in the form n ‘l’ j, where ‘l’ uses the letters s,p,d,f, etc., to denote l ¼ 0, 1, 2, 3, etc. In Auger spectroscopy the historical X-ray notation is employed with K, L, M, N, etc., for n ¼ 1, 2, 3, 4, etc., and a suffix to specify the l and j values (Table 2.1). Auger transitions require information on both the initial one electron state from which an electron is removed and the states of the two final state holes. For states of relatively low binding energy spin orbit effects are often not resolved and two j related indices are given together in the X-ray notation, e.g. the KL2,3L2,3 transition in Al involves a 1s electron being removed (no need for the unique index of unity to be given) and two 2p holes being present in the final state. In the resulting 2p4 configuration the Coulomb and exchange interaction between the holes is greater than the spin orbit interaction (LS coupling) leading to final states 1D,1S and 3P with the prefix 2S þ 1 being the total spin multiplicity and S, P and D giving the total orbital angular momentum. The total angular momentum (orbital plus spin) is not present because the spin–orbit interaction is not resolved in this case. Although selection rules in Auger emission are very sparse by comparison with the competitive X-ray emission channel where dipole rules dominate, in this case the 3P transition is disallowed due to requirements of spin and
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
17
Figure 2.1 Electron excited Auger spectrum of Al showing the main KL2,3L2,3 1D peak and accompanying losses. With permission from IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd and courtesy of J. T. Grant5
parity conservation, while the intensity of the 1S peak is much less than that of the 1D feature. Figure 2.1 shows the KLL spectrum of Al in EN(E) format, i.e. displaying the number of emitted electrons per unit energy range multiplied by the energy with electron losses B on the low energy side of the peak: as discussed above a single peak dominates the KL2,3L2,3 spectrum. In contrast the M4N4,5N4,5 and M5N4,5N4,5 spectra of Ag (Figure 1.3 in Chapter 1 ) are resolved from one another through the 6 eV spin orbit splitting of the 3d initial states while the final states give a complex profile involving a superposition of various multiplets with LS values allowed by angular momentum addition rules9. In the examples quoted so far the final states are well described by atomic physics, i.e. the states are well localised. Such transitions are denoted as CCC, where C represents a core as opposed to a valence electron V. If valence/conduction electrons are vacated in the final state (CVV or CCV transitions) the Auger profile may be influenced by the band structure of the material reflecting in some way a local density of states. Such features are sometimes used in surface analysis, e.g. KVV transitions in carbon (Figure 2.2) and L2,3VV transitions in Al and Si. The relatively low energy of these features implies higher surface sensitivity than for CCC transitions, a feature that can be usefully exploited in surface and near surface analysis. There are, however, marginal cases, for example the M4,5N4,5N4,5 transitions in Ag discussed above: the N4,5 electrons correspond to the 4d
18
THE AUGER PROCESS
Figure 2.2 The KVV Auger spectrum of carbon in various systems. With permission from IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd and courtesy of D. E. Ramaker24
electrons which combine with sp like electrons to form the conduction band of Ag metal. There is competition between the Coulomb and exchange interaction associated with the 4d holes (an atomic physics effect) and the broadening of the single electron spectral range due to band formation. This struggle is enshrined in the Cini–Sawatsky criterion10,11: if Ueff (the hole–hole interaction) exceeds twice the relevant band width (2W) atomic structure prevails but if Ueff 2W band effects are important. In the case of Ag metal atomic physics wins (only just)12,13, while in the case of the adjacent element Pd the profile is very dependent on chemical environment14–17. This is a very active area of interest for Auger spectroscopists (as opposed to Auger analysts) seeking to understand correlation between valence holes18, but the surface analyst/microscopist can exploit the resulting profile in a suitably empirical way.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
2.3
19
AUGER ENERGIES
For a CCC transition involving electrons in localised states the Auger energy is given by: EAXYZ ¼ EX EY EZ Ueff
ð2:1Þ
where X,Y and Z each specify the n, l and j values of the levels involved, and the E values are the binding energies of the corresponding one electron states as determined by X-ray photoemission and referenced to the sample’s Fermi level. The Ueff arises because the Z electron is removed in the presence of a Y hole (or vice versa) and accounts for the hole–hole interaction in the final state. Ueff is very sensitive to the degree of localisation of the final state holes and is affected by the efficiency of screening of holes by the valence/conduction electrons in the material of interest. Generally Ueff increases as EY and EZ become larger, i.e. as localisation is intensified. In practice, Auger microscopes generally concentrate on transitions of energy less than 2 keV with EY and EZ typically varying from a few eV (3d electrons in Cu or 4d electrons in Ag) to around 100 eV (2p electrons in Si): Ueff then varies from a few eV (for the 4d8 final state configuration in Ag M5N4,5N4,5 emission) to about 20 eV for the 2p4 final state for Si KL2,3L2,3. is the work function of the analyser (approximately 4.5 eV but subject to drift) so that the Auger energies are referenced to the vacuum level of the analyser. This contrasts with the common practice in X-ray photoemission where all energies are Fermi level referenced. In that case X-ray excited Auger emission energies can be combined with binding energy data to give a reference free measure of the environmental dependence of the electron spectroscopic data – the so-called Auger parameter19–21. This is not possible using electron excitation but the variation of Auger energies with environment can be usefully employed (see below). Surface analysts sensibly use the most intense available Auger features and Figure 2.3 gives peak energies for the most commonly used XYZ transitions – the energies are for elemental solids except where indicated otherwise. Seah22 has established particularly reliable standard energies for spectra in N(E) form for Cu, Au and Al (see Figure 2.4). The energies in Figure 2.3 are 4–5 eV less than those quoted under X-ray excitation and slightly lower than those observed when the data are expressed in dN(E)/dE form as discussed in Chapter 3. Although there are variations in position and width of these CCC Auger features in different environments the same quasi-atomic phenomenon
Li
H
14.1
Fr
Be
5.0 KVV 99 12 Mg 14.0 KLL 1181 20 Ca 29.9 LMM 286 38 Sr 33.7 LMM 1644 56 Ba 39 MNN 579 88 Ra 45
4
LMM KE eV
A
z
V
Atomic Volume 10 – 6 m 3 / mole
5
B
Ce 21.0 MNN 656 90 Th 19.9 0VV 60
58
60 Pr Nd 20.8 20.6 MNN MNN 694 725 91 92 Pa U 15.0 12.5 OVV 67
59
61
Pm
63 Sm Eu 19.9 28.9 MNN MNN 809 853
62
65 66 Gd Tb Dy 19.9 19.2 19.0 MNN MNN MNN 890 1068 1121
64
4.6 KVV 174 13 Al 10.0 KLL 1383 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 Sc Ti V Cr Mn Fe Co Ni Cu Zn Ga 15.0 10.6 8.35 7.23 7.39 7.1 6.7 6.6 7.1 9.2 11.8 LMM LVV LVV LVV LVV LVV LVV LMM MVV LMM LMM 335 413 468 524 584 698 770 843 914 989 1065 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 Y Zr Nb Mo Tc Ru Rh Pd Ag Cd In 19.8 14.1 10.8 9.4 8.3 8.3 8.9 10.3 13.1 15.7 MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN 122 142 162 181 268 298 295 351 371 399 57 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 La Hf Ta W Re Os Ir Pt Au Hg Tl 22.5 13.6 10.9 9.53 8.85 8.43 8.54 9.10 10.2 14.8 17.2 MNN NNN NNN NNN NNN NVV NVV NVV NVV NVV 620 180 174 174 171 49 59 71 79 64 89 Ac
AES Transition Kinetic Energy
Atomic Number Element C
N
17.3 KVV 374 15 P 17.0 LMM 115 33 As 13.1 LMM 1223 51 Sb 18.4 MNN 449 83 Bi 21.3 NVV 96
7
O
14 KVV 503 16 S 15.5 LMM 147 34 Se 16.5 LMM 1310 52 Te 20.5 MNN 478 84 Po 22.7
8
F
17.1 KLL 642 17 Cl 18.7 LMM 176 35 Br 23.5 LMM 1371 53 I 25.7 MNN 506 85 At
9
31.8 Ne 16.8 KLL 800 18 Ar 24.2 LMM 210 36 Kr 32.2 MNN 48 54 Xe 42.9 MNN 527 86 Rn
He
10
2
68 69 70 71 Ho Er Tm Yb Lu 18.7 18.4 18.1 24.8 17.8 MNN MNN MNN MNN MNN 1170 1388 1444 1509 1568
67
5.3 KVV 267 14 Si 12.1 LVV 87 32 Ge 13.6 LMM 1142 50 Sn 16.3 MNN 425 82 Pb 18.3 NVV 89
6
Figure 2.3 Energies of Auger transitions commonly used in surface analysis. Referred to the spectrometer vacuum level
87
13.1 KVV 38 11 Na 23.7 KLL 985 19 K 45.3 KLL 247 37 Rb 55.9 LMM 1560 55 Cs 70
3
1
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
21
Figure 2.4 Calibration peaks for key elements at realistic resolution (0.3 %) in electron energy distribution mode NðEÞ given by the solid lines and in differential form using 2V differentiation amplitude (see Chapter 3). The bottom energy scale is relative to the spectrometer vacuum level while the top scale is referenced to the sample Fermi level. With permission from Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena and courtesy of M. P. Seah22
is being observed. In contrast CVV and CCV transitions may be very different in energy profile in different systems. Such transitions may be the only available feature for low atomic number elements, e.g. KVV emission in B or C, but can also be used to complement CCC data, e.g. L2,3VV and KLL emission in Si. The resulting profiles reflect the band structure of the system having a breadth approximately twice the relevant band width. In this situation Ueff 0 so that the maximum energy is approximately ECVV ¼ EC . The precise shape of the profiles depends on the local density of states and other factors23, 24 and is not a simple convolution of the bulk density of states. This is illustrated for a number of systems involving carbon in Figure 2.2.
22
2.4
THE AUGER PROCESS
ENVIRONMENTAL SHIFTS
Although CCC transitions can be clearly identified their precise energy does vary in different chemical systems. All the individual EX, EY and EZ values and Ueff shift with environment. There are two reasons for this. Firstly, the electrostatic potential experienced by core electrons will differ from one system to another, e.g. 1s electrons in Al metal or Al2O3 will sense very different valence/conduction electron charge distributions leading to shifts in E1s of a few eV. This is the initial state effect. If the shifts, e, in the initial and final one electron states are approximately the same and Ueff is unaffected EXYZ ¼ e; where the shifts are relative to the elemental solid or another more convenient standard. When a core hole is created the electrons around the site experience an attractive force leading to transfer of electron density towards the location of the hole. This screening of the hole potential lowers the energy of the system and contributes to a lowering of the binding energies by the so-called relaxation energy R. When two core holes are formed in the final state of a CCC Auger process, the potential driving the screening electrons inward is approximately doubled and the response also doubled implying a screening interaction about four times that for a single hole and a reduction in Ueff. The Auger shift represents the difference in energy between a two-hole final state and a one-hole initial state predicting a reduction in energy of 3R. Environmental shifts then take the form: EX ¼ e R EXYZ ¼ e 3R:
ð2:2Þ
In X-ray excited AES e and R can be separated19–21, but this is not possible under electron excitation. However, the Auger shifts are often substantial and can be directly exploited in SAM. Table 2.2 gives binding energy and Auger shifts for a selection of metallic, covalent and ionic bonding systems for some key elements. The ratio of the two shifts gives an indication of the balance of initial and final state shifts. The general hierarchy of Auger shifts goes from ionic systems to semiconductors to metallic alloys, where values less than 1 eV are typical. In imaging as opposed to spectroscopic mode distinction between different chemical regimes for a given element is only possible
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
23
Table 2.2 Comparison of Auger and binding energy shifts relative to the elemental solid of key elements in various environments: oxides; compound semiconductors; and metallic alloys and silicides. Values are averages of data in the literature except where otherwise indicated. General precision is of order 0.1 eV in binding energy and 0.2–0.3 eV in Auger energies System Oxides
Element
Mg Al Cu Cu Zn Cd In Sn Compound Ga semiconductors As Ga Ga Cd Te Metallic alloys Al and silicides Al Mg Si Si
Compound MgO Al2O3 CuO Cu2O ZnO CdO In2O3 SnO2 GaAs GaAs GaN GaP CdTe CdTe FeAla VAlb(ucA) Mg–30ct %Tic MoSid2 PdSi
Level 2p 2p 2p 2p 2p 3d 3d 3d 3d 3d 3d 3d 3d 3d 1s 1s 1s 2p 2p
BE shift AES (eV) transition þ1.0 þ1.1 þ1.1 0.1 þ0.3 þ0.3 þ0.5 þ1.7 þ0.6 þ0.8 þ0.8 þ0.6 0.1 –0.2 0.6 0.3 þ0.6 þ0.1 þ0.3
KLL KLL LMM LMM LMM MNN MNN MNN LMM LMM LMM LMM MNN MNN KLL KLL KLL KLL KLL
AES shift (eV) 5.2 5.1 0.6 2.1 þ0.8 1.6 4.0 4.7 1.2 1.2 2.8 2.3 1.4 1.5 0.1 þ0.1 þ0.3 þ0.6 þ0.7
Notation: aAbel et. al. Ref 77, bDiplas et. al. Ref 78, cMitchell et. al. Ref 79, dArvantis et. al. 80.
if shifts are a few eV: it is feasible to isolate oxide and metal regions by tracking adjacent emission energies but not different alloy phases. On the other hand it may be possible to exploit changes in CVV Auger emission profiles with chemical environment in order to map the bonding profile of individual elements as in the case of carbon (Figure 2.2).
2.5
THE SPECTRAL BACKGROUND
The Auger peaks discussed above are superposed on a substantial background signal (see Figure 2.5). This has two main sources: although some primary electrons initially of energy E0 are reflected unscathed to form the elastic peak, most lose energy as they travel through the system. Some only suffer a few losses and are observed as identifiable loss peaks, while others undergo multiple losses (rediffused primaries or retarded electrons) and create a relatively smooth background contribution. The primary electrons may lose their energy by exciting plasmons (collective
24
THE AUGER PROCESS
Figure 2.5 Schematic representation of the electron energy distribution NðEÞ from incident electrons of energy Eo
excitations of valence/conduction electrons) or may create secondary electrons by direct one electron transitions of valence or sometimes core electrons, which leads to a secondary electron background that falls off with energy approximately as Em with m 1, the so-called Sickafus profile25,26. The overall electron energy distribution then takes the shape shown in Figure 2.5. Although the Auger electrons of most interest to surface analysts are those which leave the surface without loss of energy, Auger emission creates its own retarded electrons and secondary electron profile with electrons emitted deep in the system generally suffering greater loss. Discrete loss features may be observed on the low kinetic energy side of CCC or CVV transitions of interest: these may take the form of relatively sharp plasmon losses at multiples of the bulk plasmon energy EP ¼ ðNeff e2 =e0 mÞ1=2 , where Neff is the effective concentration of quasifree valence electrons, e the electronic charge, m the electron mass and e0 the permittivity of free space, with values typically in the range 5–20 eV27 (see Figure 2.1). In addition, electrons leaving the surface may excite surface plasmons at energy EP /21=2 through long range interactions with the electron gas near the surface, an effect of particular importance for lower energy Auger emission (<100 eV ). Plasmon losses are well defined in simple metals such as Mg and Al, for covalently bonded semiconductors, e.g. Si and GaAs and even for simple oxides such as MgO, where Neff is well represented by the density of oxygen
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
25
valence electrons. However, more complex structure over a wider energy range is observed in systems involving transition metals, in which interband transitions complicate the response of the system. In that case Tougaard28 has evolved a standardised functional profile for the loss that can be readily fitted to the data. In addition, the Auger process itself perturbs the valence electrons and produces intrinsic losses at much the same energy as the extrinsic losses associated with electron transport to the surface discussed above. The surface analyst has to separate the ‘no loss signal’ or more correctly the ‘no loss plus intrinsic loss signal’ from the debris at lower kinetic energy and algorithms of varying degrees of sophistication have been developed to do this, e.g. by Tougaard29 and Werner30. The Tougaard scheme can be readily used by non experts and has the bonus of being able to cope with nanosystems where the loss intensity and profile are sensitive to the precise nanostructure8. Practical means of separating ‘no loss’ intensity are discussed in Chapter 3. In the meantime we will assume that such a separation can be carried out and examine how the Auger intensity IAXYZ from atomic species A can be related to the atomic concentration of species A at and near the surface.
2.6
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS
Using the notation of Seah31 for the case of a homogeneous system the Auger intensity per unit beam current into solid angle d for a pure element is then: IAXYZ ¼ Io gAXYZ nAX sAX ðEo Þ sec a½1 þ rA ðEAX ; Eo ; aÞ NA QðEAXYZ Þ d ð2:3Þ
lA ðEAXYZ Þ cos y 4p where gAXYZ is the probability that the core hole in level X is filled through an XYZ Auger process, nAX is the number of electrons in level X, sAX ðEo Þ is the ionisation cross-section for an electron in level X for incoming electrons of energy Eo at angle a relative to the surface normal, rA ðEAX ; Eo ; aÞ gives the additional ionisation due to backscattering of incident electrons, NA the atomic density of A atoms, QAðEAXYZÞ takes account of elastic scattering of Auger electrons on their way to the surface, lA(EAXYZ) is the inelastic mean free path at the Auger emission energy and y the angle of emission of the detected electrons from the surface normal.
26
THE AUGER PROCESS
The sensitivity factors given here assume that the instrument response function to be discussed in Chapter 3 has been applied to isolate a fundamental Auger signal. Let us consider the behavior of the individual terms in Equation (2.3).
2.6.1
Inner Shell Ionisation Cross-section sAX ðEÞ
In Auger microanalysis primary electrons of energy Eo much higher than the inner shell binding energies are generally used so that inner shell ionisation cross-sections can be calculated using the Born approximation32–34, where sAX can be expressed as a function of the overvoltage U ¼ Eo/EAX sAX ¼ E2 AX f ðUÞ ln U=U
ð2:4Þ
Most scientists are content with this functional form but there is not a consensus on the precise nature of the relatively slowly varying function fðUÞ. The best compromise is probably that developed by Casnati35,36. However, there is general agreement that sAX peaks around U ¼ 3 and falls off fairly slowly beyond that – see Figure 2.6 for a comparison of cross-sections. Note that sAX scales as E2 AX at a given U so that for an XYZ transition the Auger intensity will decrease significantly with increasing atomic number and consequent increase in binding energy. The nAX factor gives the natural scaling with the number of core electrons in the shell. Typically the cross-sections are such that the probability of an incident electron producing inner shell ionisation in a surface layer is of order 103 104 : taking account of the other factors in Equation (2.3) it requires incoming electrons of order 104 or more to produce an Auger electron of interest and so the Auger signal is superimposed on a high background. The fact that the Auger peak occurs at a specific energy while the background is well spread in energy allows the analyst to isolate relevant events but the fight against background intensity is always important, particularly in Auger microscopy.
2.6.2
Auger Transition Probability gAXYZ
Once a core hole is created the system may de-excite by a number of paths as discussed in Chapter 1. First of all there is competition between X-ray emission and Auger emission. The driving forces for these two processes (a dipole matrix element for fluorescence and a Coulomb/ exchange matrix element for Auger) scale with transition energy in entirely different ways with the nonradiative channel dominant at
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
27
Figure 2.6 Inner shell ionisation cross sections sAX ðEo =EAX Þ for calculations by Casnati, Gryzinski and Drawin. With permission of Surface and Interface Analysis and courtesy of M. P. Seah and J. S. Gilmore36
energies <1000 eV. Here Nature is being kind because it is just these lower energy electrons we need for surface sensitivity. The Auger channel parameter gAX for any Auger channel from level X is to a good approximation given by gAX ¼ 1 Z4 = Z4 þ Z4o
ð2:5Þ
where Z is the atomic number of element A and Z0 ¼ 32:4 for X ¼ K (i.e.1s), Zo ¼ 89:4 for X ¼ L, Zo ¼ 155:9 for X ¼ M and Zo ¼ 300 for X ¼ N.
28
THE AUGER PROCESS
Indirect core ionisation by Auger cascade from higher energy levels, particularly Coster–Kronig transitions involving initial state and final state holes with the same principal quantum number, significantly contributes to inner shell ionisation. For example, in the transition elements L1 ionisation leads to creation of L2 and L3 holes via L1L2,3 M emission. Such effects are not present for KLL emission but can be accounted for in other Auger processes as outlined by Seah31. The X-ray emission that competes with Auger emission provides another mechanism for inner shell ionisation. Photon ionisation cross–sections are particularly high close to threshold and this extra channel may become important at high primary energies where X-ray production is enhanced37 – see also discussion of this effect in Chapter 4.
2.6.3
Backscattering Factor rAX ðE; EAX ; Eo Þ
The backscattering factor rAX takes account of electrons that travel into the material losing energy but eventually being backscattered through the surface region with sufficient energy to produce inner shell ionisation. Such processes can be modelled by Monte Carlo methods38,39 with the losses described by a Bethe stopping power (the energy loss per unit path length) and elastic scattering. A discussion of such electron transport processes that shape the Auger yield, the loss structure and the secondary electron background is presented at the end of this chapter. However, the qualitative trends in rAX can be readily understood. Incident electrons have to be scattered through a relatively large angle to re-enter the Auger information depth and cause inner shell ionisation. For typical 3–20 keV primary energies used in AES and SAM high atomic number increases the backscattering and so the Auger yield (see Figure 2.7). In mid-periodic table the Auger yield is about doubled by elastic backscattering but the most rapid enhancement in rAX with Z occurs up to Z 20. Furthermore, rAX tends to increase both as EAX decreases and as Eo increases because the rediffused primaries can lose more energy and yet still be capable of core hole creation. This tends to offset the decrease of sAX beyond U ¼ 3 and helps to make higher primary energies competitive.
2.6.4
Inelastic Mean Free Path lA ðEÞ
If the emitted Auger electrons that lose no energy (the ones we are interested in) do not suffer elastic scattering on their path out of the solid
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
29
Figure 2.7 The energy dependence of the Auger backscattering parameter for a selection of atomic numbers as a function of core binding energy EAX . The incident energy of the electrons is 5 keV and they are at 30 to the surface normal. Permission from John Wiley and Sons Ltd and courtesy of H. J. Mathieu1.
(the straight line approximation), the probability of emission from a depth z is exp(z=lA cos y) implying a net escape depth of lA cos y. The greater surface sensitivity at large exit angles can be exploited to obtain information on the depth distribution of the emitting atoms. However, the Auger electrons may be elastically scattered before emerging from the surface and then have little chance of being rescattered out of the surface with no loss of energy. The net effect is then to reduce Auger yield by the factor QA ðEAXYZ ; yÞ which for reasonable y values (<60 ) varies typically between 0.9 and 1. Quantitative corrections maybe found in Seah and Gilmore41. The dielectric formalism of Penn42 exploits optical data to deduce the variation of lðEÞ with energy. Tanuma, Powell and Penn (TPP)43–48 have successfully fitted the resulting numerical results with an analytic formula n h io ˚ ð2:6Þ lðEÞ ¼ E= E2p b lnðgEÞ CE1 þ DE2 ðAÞ where 1
EP ¼ 28:8ðNV r=MÞ2 ðeVÞ is the effective free electron plasmon energy, expressed in a different but equivalent form to that presented earlier, NV the number of valence electrons per atom for atoms or molecular unit for compounds, r the
30
THE AUGER PROCESS
density in g cm3 and M the atomic or molecular weight. The remaining parameters are fitted to the Penn results as discussed by TPP. At kinetic energies above 200 eV the C and D parameters have little influence and the formula is of the classic Born–Bethe form similar to that of the inner shell ionisation. The values obtained are very sensitive to the valence electron density which in turn depends sensitively on the atomic density, which for elemental solids varies periodically with atomic number, and the number of valence electrons per atom. See Tanuma49 for the assumptions made. Above 200 eV lðEÞ varies roughly as E0.7 (see Figure 2.8). The minimum below 100 eV reflects the maximum in the inelastic cross-section at about three times the peak loss energy, but little surface analysis is done in that regime. Variation in mean free path is particularly marked in going through a transition metal series, e.g. lðEÞ varies from about 3 nm to 1.7 nm for 500 eV electrons between Ca and Cu50. Inorganic materials tend on average to have rather larger mean free paths at a given energy with organic compounds even higher values due to their more open structures.
Figure 2.8 Energy dependence of electron inelastic mean free paths for (a) elemental solids, (b) inorganic compounds and (c) organic compounds. Permission of IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd and courtesy of S. Tanuma49
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
31
How reliable are these estimates? The Penn algorithm satisfies certain important sum rules and this ensures that the cross-section is close to reality provided that good optical data are available. Above 200 eV the TPP fit shows only small deviations from the dielectric model and overall precision of a few percent is anticipated. Comparison with experiment, in particular recent studies involving elastic peak spectroscopy51–53 give strong support to the TPP results.
2.6.5
Other Factors
The Auger yield is naturally proportional to NA while the sec(a) factor reflects the increased path length of the primary electrons in traversing the escape depth region. The emission of Auger electrons is approximately spherical in symmetry, at least in polycrystalline systems so that (d/4p) is the fraction of emission captured by the spectrometer. In some single crystal systems diffraction54 corrections need to be applied. We are now in a position to calculate sensitivity factors for the main Auger features used in AES surface analysis. Because of difficulties in accounting for Coster–Kronig contributions to any one Auger feature it is preferable to sum over the Auger intensities of all transitions involving the same principal quantum number for their initial state. Figure 2.9(a) shows the Auger yield per unit incident current per unit solid angle as calculated by Seah and Gilmore55 for a primary energy of 10 keV. The general structure can be understood from the insights gained in discussing the individual factors in Equation (2.3). At low Z (<15) KLL Auger transitions fall in a suitable surface sensitive energy range and are used for analysis e.g. the Mg KL2,3L2,3 peak is at 1182 eV. With increasing Z the 1s binding energy EAK increases and the inner shell ionisation energy decreases roughly as E2 AK if backscattering is taken into account. This is partially offset by an increase in the mean free path varying approximately as E0:7 AKLL and the decrease in U, while on the other hand the fluorescence yield begins to increase at higher Z. For Al, Si and P both L shell and K shell Auger decay are used in analysis: now the L shell cross-sections decrease with increasing Z – note the difference in gradient for the second row elements in the periodic table and the first transition series which follow – this is strongly influenced by variations in atom density in this region. As Z increases M and N shell atomic number dependence follows similar trends. The net effect of this is that useful Auger yields may vary by almost two orders of magnitude for different elements.
32
THE AUGER PROCESS
Figure 2.9 (a) Calculated Auger electron yields for electrons incident at 30o to the surface normal. The intensities predicted sum over all K or L or M or N or O transitions. The incident energy is 10 keV. (b) Corresponding experimental yields with those below 150 eV considered to be less accurate
How well are these trends reflected in observation? In making such a comparison it is important to separate the ‘no loss’ Auger signal from the secondary electron background and extrinsic loss structure on the low energy side of the peak as well as removing instrumental response effects. Seah and Gilmore56 have made high quality intensity measurements of Auger intensities from data in NðEÞ mode, i.e. from the electron energy distribution: the ways of isolating the relevant yield
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
Figure 2.10
33
Ratio of the experimental to theoretical sensitivities
from the spectrometer signal are discussed in Chapter 5. In Figure 2.9(b) the experimental data is separated into two regions: below 150 eV the Auger peak is competing against a strong secondary electron background which is difficult to subtract off with great precision, but above 180 eV the intensities carry greater reliability. Figure 2.10 ratios the experimental to theoretical predictions in that regime. Given the uncertainties in various aspects of the theory discussed above the correlation between theory and experiment is remarkably good especially for the K, L and M series with an average discrepancy of 4 % and an overall scatter factor of 30 %. The sensitivity factors for homogeneous solids are therefore on the whole well understood, but one must test how robust these factors are for complex inhomogeneous systems and for investigating nanostructural information sought by Auger spectroscopists. Ideally the analyst would happily bypass theory and hope to estimate the atomic concentration XA in some environment with a formula along the lines X 1 1 Ii =Ii ð2:7Þ XA ¼ ðIA =IA Þ= i
where the Ii are the observed Auger intensities for element i (including i ¼ A) and the Ii1 are the elemental standard signals obtained under identical experimental conditions. Since only intensity ratios are involved the intensities used have only to be proportional to the ‘no loss’ Auger area. The theoretical understanding outlined above demonstrates the limitations of such an approach. Although the inner
34
THE AUGER PROCESS
shell ionisation cross-sections are to a good approximation independent of environment, the total atomic concentration, the elastic scattering correction factor, the backscattering factor and the mean free path vary significantly from system to system. Neglecting the complication of Coster–Kronig effects for the moment, Equation (2.3) requires a matrix correction to the form X
1 1 ð2:8Þ Fim Iim =Ii XA ¼ FAm IAm =IA i
where FAm ¼ ½NA QA f1 þ rA glA =½Nm Qm f1 þ rm glm and the suffix m or A is associated with values of the relevant quantity in matrix m or the element A. The total concentration Nm may vary wildly from system to system and the other quantities also change significantly particularly when A is combined with elements of very different atomic number. This means that FAm is itself dependent on XA and furthermore will vary by well over an order of magnitude, i.e. Equation (2.8) is far from ideal. In addition, the contribution of Coster–Kronig transitions needs to be accounted for by summing over all channels with the same principal quantum number as X. Seah and Gilmore55 elegantly cut through these complications by replacing the elemental solid standards Ii1 and IA1 by those of an average matrix IiAV and IAAV . These are related to the empirical elemental standards by a theoretical scaling through AV AV that appropriately assigned parameters for NAV , QAV A , lA , and rA have been assigned intuitively but successfully by Seah and Gilmore. Now, by replacing the pure element relative sensitivity factors (PERSFs) by new average matrix relative sensitivity factors (AMRSFs) matrix corrections are greatly reduced so that the formula X AV AV ð2:9Þ Iim =Ii XA ¼ IAm =IA i
is a good starting point, a result much in the spirit of the pragmatic approach of Palmberg57 in the early days of AES. However, it is theoretical understanding that allows us to have confidence in the AMRSFs approach. Details of the idealised but useful average matrices are given in Seah and Gilmore55,56. The results above apply, of course, only to homogeneous systems, much simpler than those usually faced in microscopy. For thin
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
35
homogeneous overlayers of A of thickness d on substrate B the signals are approximately related to the bulk Auger emission signal at angle y by IA ¼ IA1 f1 exp½d=LA ðEA Þ cos y g IB ¼ IB1 exp½d=LA ðEB Þ cos y
ð2:10Þ
where EA and EB are the respective Auger energies. In the absence of elastic scattering LA ¼ lA ðEA Þ, etc., are the corresponding inelastic mean free paths. However, the yield is modified by high angle elastic scattering which largely prevents these electrons leaving the system without losing energy because of the increase in their path lengths – this is of course the origin of the QA term in the bulk case. For not too large exit angles (<60 to the normal) LA ðEÞ can be approximated by an attenuation length lA ðEÞ which is less than liA ðEÞ, i.e. the signals still show an approximate exponential dependence on thickness. Quantitative calculations of lA ðEÞ involving modeling the path length distribution of emitted electrons, for example by Jablonski and Powell58 and Seah and Gilmore41, predict lA values typically 10–20 % lower than liA values at a given energy. For fractions of a monolayer f , d can be replaced by fd, where d is the thickness of a monolayer. The appropriate value of LA is now less clear as high angle elastic scattering of Auger electrons emitted out of the surface layer will have low probability and there are reasonable arguments for using LA ¼ liA in IA but not necessarily for IB . It is not easy to invert data from such formulae to determine d but further discussion of the overlayer problem is given by Cumpson59 and Seah31. Microscopists face much more complex morphologies than those presented in this chapter, but the thin layer formulae presented here give some insight into the depth sensitivity of the Auger technique with sub nm depth resolution at least for nonorganic systems up to 1000 eV kinetic energy.
2.7
ELECTRON TRANSPORT
As discussed above, the Auger signal that the analyst cherishes is in competition with a background of electrons due to re-diffused primaries and fast secondary electrons and indeed the Auger electrons themselves add to the background through Auger electrons travelling to the surface. The balance of signal to background depends sensitively on the paths of
36
THE AUGER PROCESS
primary, secondary and Auger electrons and this requires an understanding of electron transport in solids. First it is necessary to define the basic electron scattering processes which in turn define a number of important length scales that have been highlighted by Tougaard and Sigmund60 and others30,61–68.
2.7.1
Elastic Scattering
Collisions with no loss of energy are dominated by the screened Coulomb potential of atoms and are readily calculated using potential scattering programs with Thomas–Fermi–Dirac69 or Hartree–Fock potentials calculated from free atom charge densities70. For typical Auger energies there is always a strong forward scattering peak, i.e. small angle scattering (Figure 2.11), that is greater at high atomic number: these involve quasi-classical terms in scattering from the ‘edge’ of the atom, i.e. with a relatively high impact parameter. Although such low angle scattering will differ somewhat between atom and solid, it contributes little to controlling the path length of electrons within the solid. It is the high angle scattering events that principally influence background signals at the surface: they involve low impact parameter scattering within the atoms that is well described by
Figure 2.11 Comparison of the differential elastic scattering cross-sections for (a) Al and (b) Pt at relevant energies. Permission of IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd and courtesy of W. S. Werner30.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
37
atomic cross-sections. For low atomic numbers and reasonably high energies the differential elastic cross-section dse =d is relatively weak and falls off smoothly in accordance with modified Rutherford scattering in the screened nuclear potential71,72. For high atomic number systems the greatly enhanced nuclear potential leads to much stronger backscattering in the higher primary energy regime (a few keV) but below 1 keV the cross-section has a number of deep minima (Figure 2.10) in a phenomenon called the generalised Ramsauer effect73. Crudely this can be thought of as destructive interference occurring in multiple scattering events within the atom. The backscattering cross-sections are no longer necessarily greater at high atomic number. It is therefore expedient to define two separate elastic mean free paths, one le representing the average distance between elastic collisions and another ltr which emphasises high-angle collisions through a ð1 cos yÞ weighting. Then, for elemental solids, we have l1 e and
ð
¼ NA se ¼ NA ðds=dÞd
ð ¼ N s ¼ N l1 A tr A ðdse =dÞð1 cos yÞd tr
ð2:10Þ
ð2:11Þ
where NA is, as before, the elemental atomic concentration.
2.7.2
Inelastic Scattering
As previously discussed in studying the yield of Auger electrons the mean distance between elastic collisions is given by the inelastic mean free path li whose energy dependence largely determines the surface sensitivity of AES. The dominant contribution to li generally comes from relatively low energy excitations (<40 eV) which are strongly forward scattered and therefore in themselves do not greatly influence the path length distribution in the solid. These are observed both on the low energy side of the elastic peak at Eo and below the Auger peaks. Much of the background on which the Auger electrons are superimposed are re-diffused primaries or high energy secondary electrons which have undergone multiple losses in travelling from well below the surface to a region within of that the Auger attenuation length. It is useful then to specify the losses through the stopping power, the energy
38
THE AUGER PROCESS
Figure 2.12 Inelastic li , elastic le and transport ltr mean free paths and linear range R for (a) Al and (b) Pt calculated by Werner30 as a function of energy. The data points are experimental results obtained by elastic peak spectroscopy. Permission of IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd and courtesy of W. S. Werner30.
loss per unit path length S, that decreases with energy beyond a multiple of the dominant loss energy. It is then possible to estimate a range for the incident electrons defined plausibly as ð R ¼ SðEÞdE with a range of integration between Eo and Emin , which is usually set at 50 eV. The way in which these scattering parameters vary with energy has been vividly illustrated by Werner30 – see Figure 2.12 for Al and Pt metals that have the same fcc lattice structure and similar lattice constants, i.e. the NA are comparable. li ðEÞ is consistently slightly lower than for Al in the dominant 200–2000 eV analysing regime, while le is dramatically lower due to the much higher atomic number. Al Although lPt tr < ltr down to E 500 eV, the two elements backscatter with similar average cross-sections between 100 and 500 eV due to the interference effects at high atomic number discussed above. For both systems ltr li consistent with the relatively modest elastic scattering correction QA calculated for Auger yields. Note also the sharp fall in R below 1000 eV implying that the primary electrons have much larger ranges than even the fastest Auger electrons used in surface analysis. While Figure 2.12 gives a very clear picture of the dependence of various kinds of scattering on energy it is important to remember the very strong periodic variation of NA with atomic number which influences both ltr directly and li through the knock-on effect on the valence density.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
39
Once these length scales are established how can one use transport theory to give further understanding of AES and the further complications of the nanoscales inherent in SAM? There are two basic approaches, one through solving Boltzmann transport equations in which str appears as a natural parameter or by Monte Carlo methods where random numbers are used to control both elastic and inelastic scattering weighted properly to the calculated cross-sections. A detailed discussion is not attempted here but attention is drawn to how it affects various aspects of AES and SAM.
2.7.2.1 Backscattering corrections The atomic number and energy dependence are well modelled by the Monte Carlo approach which can be readily adapted to incorporate complex geometries and local atomic number variations that are present in applications to nanotechnology. The general decrease with atomic number reflects the reduction above 500 eV in the high angle backscattering events required for re-diffused primaries to cause ionisation in the surface region. The results of the Monte Carlo simulations can then be fitted to a polymomial expression incorporating the relevant dimensionless variables Z, o and E/Eo , which can conveniently be used by analysts. Here o¼
li li þ ltr
is a measure of the relative strengths of high angle elastic scattering and inelastic scattering.
2.7.2.2 Attenuation lengths Detailed electron transport analysis implies that the yield of Auger electrons may be characterised by an attenuation length la somewhat less than liA but there is no guarantee that the depth distribution of emitted electrons will be exponential; quite complicated behavior can occur particularly at high exit angle. For example, Monte Carlo modelling by Jablonski and Powell58 can be fitted by la ¼ liA ð1 GoÞ
40
THE AUGER PROCESS
where G is a number of order 0.7. The correction is therefore an appropriate ratio of the scaling lengths discussed above.
2.7.2.3 Electron energy loss In reflection electron energy loss spectroscopy (REELS) the surface is bombarded with electrons of primary energy Eo and backscattered electrons may suffer various surface and bulk losses. Models of electron path distributions are required to separate multiple scattering components from the loss structure to isolate the single loss profile which gives information about the optical properties of the material and the inelastic electron mean free path30,74–76. REELS structure at the same primary energy as the Auger energy EAXYZ can be used to isolate the ‘no loss’ signal that can then be used in quantitative analysis77.
Figure 2.13 Simulation by Tougaard8 of photoemission from Cu on Au for various different surface morphologies
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
41
The Auger loss structure is strongly dependent on the local environment. A monolayer of a particular element A will dominantly have a ‘no loss’ peak with mainly intrinsic loss structure below the main peak. In contrast, emission from a monolayer of A that is a few mean free paths below the surface will be dominated by extrinsic loss structure with little evidence of a ‘no loss’ peak. This is illustrated for photoemission from Cu where four widely different structures of Cu on Au give identical ‘no loss’ intensities but dramatically different loss structure (Figure 2.13). These effects have been modelled by Tougaard8 who has developed readily usable algorithms for coping with diverse nanostructures, mainly for XPS, but with ready adaptation to AES and SAM78, where the finite excitation depth distribution further complicates the resulting profile.
2.8
SUMMARY
Auger emission is instigated by an atomically specific electron scattering cross-section (that for inner shell ionisation) but the Auger yield is then controlled by a combination of elastic and inelastic scattering events which are very sensitive to environment through the local atomic density and the inherent atomic number dependence of the relevant crosssections. The preceding discussion has paved the way to an understanding of the various processes that take place in an electron–solid interaction leading to the escape of an Auger electron. In applications of Auger microscopy featuring micro- and nanoscale dimensions as discussed in Chapters 4 and 5 it will be necessary to employ Monte Carlo simulations building on the basic physics developed in this chapter.
REFERENCES 1. H. J. Mathieu, in Surface Analysis. The Principal Techniques, edited by J. C. Vickerman (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1997), p. 99. 2. G. C. Smith, Surface Analysis by Electron Spectroscopy (Plenum Press, New York and London, 1994). 3. M. Thompson, M. D. Baker, A. Christie and J. T. Tyson, Auger Electron Spectroscopy (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, New York, 1985). 4. J. F. Watts and J. Wolstenholme, An Introduction to Surface Analysis (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 2003). 5. D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (eds) Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003).
42
THE AUGER PROCESS
6. D. Briggs and M. P. Seah, Practical Surface Analysis. Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1990). 7. M. Prutton, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), Vol. 1, p. 899. 8. S. Tougaard, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 295. 9. H. Haken and H. C. Wolf, Atomic and Quantum Physics (Springer Verlag, Berlin, 2005). 10. M. Cini, Solid State Communications 24, 681 (1977). 11. G. A. Sawatsky, Physical Review Letters 39, 504 (1977). 12. P. J. Bassett, T. E. Gallon, J. A. D. Matthew and M. Prutton, Surface Science 35, 432 (1973). 13. C. J. Powell, Physical Review Letters 30, 1179 (1973). 14. P. Weightman and P. T. Andrews, Journal of Physics C 13, L815 (1980). 15. P. Weightman, P. T. Andrews, G. M. Stocks and H. Winter, Journal of Physics C 16, L81 (1983). 16. P. Weightman, Reports on Progress in Physics 45, 753 (1982). 17. P. Weightman, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 68, 127 (1994). 18. P. Weightman, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 797. 19. G. Moretti, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 501. 20. C. D. Wagner, Faraday Discussions of the Chemical Society 60, 291 (1975). 21. C. D. Wagner and A. Joshi, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 47, 283 (1988). 22. M. P. Seah, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 97, 235 (1998). 23. D. E. Ramaker, Critical Reviews in Solid State and Materials Science 17, 211 (1991). 24. D. E. Ramaker, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 465. 25. J. C. Greenwood, M. Prutton and R. H. Roberts, Physical Review B 49, 12485 (1994). 26. E. N. Sickafus, Physical Review B 16, 1436 (1977). 27. H. Raether, Excitation of Plasmons and Interband Transitions by Electrons (Springer Verlag, Berlin, 1980). 28. S. Tougaard, Solid State Communications 61, 547 (1987). 29. S. Tougaard, Surface and Interface Analysis 11, 453 (1988). 30. W. S. Werner, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 235. 31. M. P. Seah, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 345.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
43
32. H. Bethe, Annal de Physique 5, 325 (1930). 33. H. E. Bishop and J. C. Riviere, Journal of Applied Physics 40, 1740 (1969). 34. C. J. Powell, in Electron Impact Ionisation, edited by T. D. Mark and G. H. Dunn (Springer, Berlin, 1985), p. 198. 35. E. Casnati, A. Tartari and C. Baraldi, Journal of Physics B 15, 155 (1982). 36. M. P. Seah and I. S. Gilmore, Surface and Interface Analysis 26, 815 (1998). 37. J. Cazaux, D. Gramari, S. Moutou and A. G. Nassiopoulos, Journal de Physique Colloque C2, 337 (1984). 38. R. Shimizu, Japanese Journal of Applied Physics 22, 1631 (1983). 39. D. Ze-jun and R. Shimizu, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 587. 40. P. Cumpson, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 73, 25 (1995). 41. M. P. Seah and I. S. Gilmore, Surface and Interface Analysis 31, 835 (2001). 42. D. R. Penn, Physical Review B 35, 482 (1987). 43. S. Tanuma, C. J. Powell and D. R. Penn, Surface and Interface Analysis 17, 911 (1991). 44. S. Tanuma, C. J. Powell and D. R. Penn, Surface and Interface Analysis 17, 927 (1991). 45. S. Tanuma, C. J. Powell and D. R. Penn, Surface Science 192, L849 (1987). 46. S. Tanuma, C. J. Powell and D. R. Penn, Surface and Interface Analysis 11, 577 (1988). 47. S. Tanuma, C. J. Powell and D. R. Penn, Surface and Interface Analysis 20, 77 (1993). 48. S. Tanuma, C. J. Powell and D. R. Penn, Surface and Interface Analysis 21, 165 (1994). 49. S. Tanuma, in Surface Analysis By Auger and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications and Surface Spectra Ltd, Chichester, 2003), p. 259. 50. W. S. M. Werner, Surface and Interface Analysis 18, 217 (1992). 51. G. Gergely, Surface and Interface Analysis 3, 201 (1981). 52. C. J. Powell and A. Jablonski, Journal of Chemical and Physical Reference Data 28, 19 (1999). 53. W. S. M. Werner, C. Tomastik, T. Cabela, R. Richter and H. Stori, Surface Science 470, L123 (2001). 54. H. E. Bishop, B. Chornic, C. Le Gressus and A. Le Mondel, Surface and Interface Analysis 6, 116 (1984). 55. M. P. Seah and J. S. Gilmore, Surface and Interface Analysis 26, 908 (1998). 56. M. P. Seah and I. S. Gilmore, Surface and Interface Analysis 31, 778 (2001). 57. P. W. Palmberg, Analytical Chemistry 45, 549A (1973). 58. A. Jablonski and C. J. Powell, Surface Science Reports 47, 33 (2002). 59. P. J. Cumpson, Surface and Interface Analysis 29, 403 (2000). 60. S. Tougaard and P. Sigmund, Physical Review B 25, 4452 (1982). 61. V. M. Dwyer and J. A. D. Matthew, Surface Science 143, 57 (1984). 62. V. M. Dwyer and J. M. Richards, Surface and Interface Analysis 18, 555 (1992). 63. A. Jablonski, Surface Science 364, 380 (1996). 64. R. Mayol and F. Salvat, Atomic Data and Nuclear Data 65, 55 (1997).
44
THE AUGER PROCESS
65. C. J. Powell, A. Jablonski, I. S. Tilinin, S. Tanuma and D. R. Penn, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 98, 1 (1999). 66. I. S. Tilinin and W. S. M. Werner, Surface Science 290, 119 (1993). 67. S. Tougaard, Surface and Interface Analysis 26, 249 (1998). 68. W. S. M. Werner, Surface and Interface Analysis 31, 141 (2001). 69. A. Jablonski and C. J. Powell, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 85, 205 (1997). 70. Z. Czyewski, Journal of Applied Physics 68, 3066 (1990). 71. J. A. D. Matthew, A. R. Jackson and M. M. El Gomati, Journal of Physics Condensed Matter 9, 8601 (1997). 72. I. S. Tilinin, Mikrochimica Acta 114, 485 (1994). 73. P. J. Cumpson, Surface and Interface Analysis 25, 447 (1997). 74. S. Tougaard and I. Chorkendorff, Physical Review B 35, 6570 (1987). 75. S. Tougaard and F. Yubero, Surface and Interface Analysis 36, 824 (2004). 76. F. Yubero, J. M. Sanz, B. Ramskor and S.Tougaard, Physical Review B 53, 9719 (1996). 77. M. P. Seah, Surface Science 471, 185 (2001). 78. D. Fujita, M. Schleberger and S. Tougaard, Surface and Interface Analysis 24, 211 (1996).
3 Instrumentation M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton
3.1
INTRODUCTION
This chapter covers some of the design principles of a scanning Auger microscope. Rather than give detailed descriptions of each of the instruments that are, or have been, commercially available or designed and built in the facility where they are used, the emphasis in this chapter is placed upon the key factors to be taken into consideration in the hardware and software design. Before describing the components of a scanning Auger microscopy (SAM) system in more detail an idea of the features of an example of an entire microscope is shown in the diagram of Figure 3.1. Here, the key components are indicated with the exception (for clarity in the figure) of the sample manipulator essential to translate and rotate the sample into the position desired. The complexity of the entire system is clear. After brief consideration of several different methods of obtaining analytical images attention is turned to the particular requirements of SAM. The first matter of importance is an estimation of the time taken to acquire a single Auger image – the frame scan time. This is important because acquisition may take many minutes and the design of components to try to reduce the frame scan time by collecting as large a fraction of the Auger electrons leaving the sample is of central significance. Further, because of the relatively long frame scan times the contamination of the sample by any ambient gas and the stability of the measurement conditions are also very important. All these matters are considered in this chapter. Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy Edited by M. Prutton and M. El Gomati # 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 0-470-86677-2
46
INSTRUMENTATION SEM Display
SEM Electronics
Computer Display
EDX Controller
Scanning Electronics
Control Computer
Analyser Controller
Ion Gun Controller
Electron Gun and Column
Electron Energy Analyser
X-ray Detector
Ion Gun SEM Detector
Sample Transfer Mechanism
Sample Mass Spectrometer
Sample Entry
Ionisation Gauge
Pump
Pump
Mass Spectrometer Electronics
Pump Controller
Gauge Controller
Gas Admittance
Pump Controller
Sample Heating
Mass Spectrum Display
Figure 3.1 Schematic of an example scanning Auger microscope showing the principal components. The sample manipulator and the sample transfer device are omitted for clarity in the display of the other components. All the components in the analysis chamber (on the left) may not be mounted in a single plane in order that the axis of each device may pass through a common point in the surface of the sample without the components fouling each other. There may well be UHV valves incorporated between the sample entry and cleaning chamber on the right and the analysis chamber as well as between each pump and its chamber
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
3.2
47
THE ACQUISITION OF ANALYTICAL IMAGES
There are two modes of acquisition of analytical images – scanning and direct. The scanning modes use a focused probe of particles or radiation that is scanned in an analog or digital fashion across the sample under study. Some of the scattered particles or radiation intended for use in microanalysis are collected by a spectrometer/detector arrangement and the signal measured is either stored in the memory of a control computer or is used to modulate the brightness of the beam in a cathode ray tube display which is being scanned synchronously with the motion of the probe on the sample. This is the principle used in the well-known scanning electron microscope (SEM). The general arrangement is outlined in Figure 3.2(a). The subject has been extensively reviewed in a number of textbooks and research monographs. The SEM and the physics of the scattering of an incident electron beam into a variety of signals have been described by Reimer1. Examples of analytical techniques that use a scanned probe and detect scattered particles or radiation to form an image are: Secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) in which the probe is a beam of focused, monochromatic ions and the signal is formed by selecting a particular mass of secondary sputtered ion using a mass spectrometer. SIMS methods are described by Briggs and Seah2, Dowsett and Collins3 and Wittmaack4. Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) in which the probe is a focused beam of high-energy electrons (usually 100 keV) and the signals detected are those arising at the bottom surface of a thin sample through which the electrons have been transmitted. These signals might be the true secondary electrons, those electrons which have undergone many energy loss processes in the sample but still emerge with considerable kinetic energy (say greater than about 50 eV), characteristic X-rays excited by ionisation of the atoms in the sample, Auger electrons also excited by ionisations, incident electrons which have lost energy to a single ionisation of the atoms of the sample (this is the basis of electron energy loss spectroscopy or EELS), or incident electrons which have lost energy to the excitation of plasmons or phonons in the sample. In this kind of instrument there are many processes causing electron scattering and many kinds of signals that can be measured. Some STEMs are equipped with multiple detectors so that several different signals can be measured from the same place on the sample
48
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.2 (a) Scanning imaging: the incident beam is focused onto the sample. An energy analyser and detector collect electrons from the place that is illuminated. (b) Direct imaging: the surface is evenly illuminated with electrons and the energy analyser is designed to pass electrons in a selected energy band as well as to image the surface of the sample onto a multichannel detector. Reproduced by permission of IOP Publishing Ltd from Prutton27
simultaneously. This allows subsequent use of image correlation techniques to learn more about the sample than can be gleaned from individual measurements. STEM is described by Brown5 and Browning et al.6. Imaging energy or wavelength dispersive X-ray analysis (EDX or WDX). Here an electron probe is scanned across the sample and Xray emission is detected. The wavelengths or energies of the X-rays are characteristic of the types of atoms in the sample. EDX and WDX are described by Heinrich and Newbury7, Reed8 and Scott and Love9. EDX and WDX are also called EDS and WDS, where S stands for spectroscopy, as well as EPMA (electron probe microanalysis).
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
49
Scanning Auger microscopy (SAM). This is analogous to EDX except that the Auger electrons ejected from a sample after ionisation of component atoms by energetic electrons are used to form the signal. This technique is very sensitive to the distributions of atoms in the top few atomic monolayers of the sample and is the subject of this book. Scanning low energy electron loss microscopy (SLEELM). This is a scanned electron beam technique in which the spectrometer is set up to pass electrons that have lost rather small energies in their interactions with the sample. Examples of such excitations are phonon, plasmon and exciton processes and interband transitions in insulators and semiconductors10–12. Direct imaging methods of microanalysis (Figure 3.2(b)) are designed so that the sample is illuminated over a large area instead of the incident radiation being focused into a fine probe. The spectrometer is of a type that images the emitting region of the sample onto a detector array. This kind of instrument has the substantial advantage that all regions in the area of interest are imaged simultaneously and so it is usually much faster than the scanned probe techniques. Examples of such direct methods are: Parallel electron energy loss spectroscopy (PEELS). Here a high energy resolution electron spectrometer collects electrons from an illuminated area on a sample and images those electrons which have lost a selected amount of energy through ionisations or other excitations onto an array of solid state electron detectors. EELS and PEELS are described by Krivanek13 and by Williams and Newbury14. Low energy electron microscopy (LEEM). Ingenious lens designs are used in this technique to illuminate a sample with low energy electrons (say 100 eV kinetic energy) and then to collect an image of the elastically scattered electrons backscattered from the surface of the sample. This is a powerful method for detecting crystallographic variations from place to place. LEEM was invented by Bauer et al.15. Photoelectron microscopy or imaging XPS (PEEM). In this imaging technique X-rays or ultraviolet photons illuminate an area of the sample and the analyser images a selected photoelectron energy onto a detector or detector array. PEEM is described by Bauer16.
50
INSTRUMENTATION
This (incomplete) list of techniques is given to indicate the range of incident probes and detected signals that are in use in both scanning and direct methodologies. Acronyms abound! Although attention will be focused hereafter upon the scanning methods and upon Auger imaging in particular many of the data manipulation and interpretation techniques that will be described are applicable to the other kinds of images. References to the literature of microanalytical imaging methods are as numerous as the subject matter is broad. Electron optical matters are described in Hawkes and Kasper17. SEM is reviewed in Reimer1 and Wells et al.18 where many of the physical processes occurring when electrons are scattered by solids are explained. The literature relevant to image processing and interpretation are of similar scale. Much image processing technique has been developed by researchers involved with space vehicles and is to be found in libraries held by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). Examples are by Gonzalez and Wintz19, Niblack20 and Moik21. More specific but general references to processing and interpretation can be found in Newbury22, Bright et al.23, Jeanguillaume and Colliex24, King et al.25, El Gomati et al.26, Prutton27–30 and Bonnet31, 32.
3.3
FRAME SCAN TIMES
The relatively long data acquisition times required to obtain Auger images with acceptable signal to noise ratios were outlined briefly in Chapter 1. These times have some important effects on the design of the hardware and software of the instrument. In particular, the needs for ultra-high vacuum (UHV) environment, for adequate mechanical stability in the chamber, electron column and manipulator and for stability in the electronic components in the system will be considered in this chapter. Further, increasing the current in the electron beam scanning the sample can reduce the data acquisition times. This increase can be secured by exploiting the use of high brightness electron sources in the column – a matter that will be discussed further below. Using the description of the yield of Auger electrons leaving a surface found in Chapter 2 the analysis leading to the estimation of the time required for one scan of an area on the surface (referred to as a ‘frame scan’ – following TV usage) is presented in Figure 3.3. If the discussion below is, to some extent, anticipated, reasonable practical values for the parameters in Figure 3.3 can be inserted into the equations there to make a rough estimate of the order of magnitude of the frame scan time to be expected. Thus, for the values:
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
51
The Image Acquisition Time Following Bishop and Riviere (see Chapter 2) the yield, YA, of Auger electrons generated due to ionisation by an electron beam with current ib is given by:
YA = ibϕω (1+r)λ nsecθ In this expression:
φ ω r λ n θ
is the ionisation cross-section for the Auger process being observed, is the fluorescence yield, is the Auger backscattering factor, is the inelastic mean free path for those electrons giving yield YA, is the number density of atoms contributing to YA, is the angle of incidence of the electron beam.
This yield is delivered into 4 π steradians of which only a fraction Ω / 4π enter the energy analyser whose acceptance solid angle is Ω . Thus, the number of Auger electrons measured – the signal, S, is given by:
S =YA Ωτ
4π e
Here, the measurement time per pixel of a digital image is
τ s.
Neglecting other electrons counted at the same energy but in the spectral background enables estimation of the minimum value of τ and so the minimum image acquisition time. If the electrons reaching a detector can be counted with no extraneous (noise) counts and Poisson statistics are assumed to be applicable then the smallest measurable signal is about
3 S . Electron counting systems can be designed to detect individual electrons and so let us set the minimum number of detectable electrons at 10. Then the three equations above can be manipulated to give a minimum dwell time of:
τ min =
400π e 9ιb ϕω (1+r)λ nΩ secθ
Thus the minimum acquisition time T min for an image containing N×N pixels can be seen to be
Τmin = Ν 2 τ min
Figure 3.3 A simple estimation of the frame scan time. The sample is assumed to consist only of one element
52
INSTRUMENTATION
Beam current Angle of incidence Sample Atomic density Ionisation energy Ionisation cross-section Auger backscattering factor Fluorescent yield Inelastic mean free path Collection solid angle Scan size Average no. of electrons per pixel
10 nA 0 Carbon 3 1022 atoms cm3 272 eV 1:5 1014 cm2 eV2 1 1 3 108 cm 1% of 4p steradians 128 128 pixels 36
The expected frame scan time is about 210 s and the dwell time of the beam on each point on the surface is about 13 ms. Even this estimate is optimistic in that the Auger peak used for imaging is likely to be superimposed upon a background of inelastically scattered and secondary electrons which require more electrons to be counted at each point for the same signal to noise ratio assumed above. Dwell times of 100 or 200 ms are often practical with the corresponding frame scan times being about 1600 or 3200 s. If the beam current is increased by changing the operation (or even the design of the electron column) then the minimum diameter of the spot of electrons striking the sample is usually increased. Since it is this spot size that determines the spatial resolution in the resulting Auger image there is a compromise between frame scan time and spatial resolution.
3.4
THE VACUUM ENVIRONMENT
There are a number of texts available which explain the science and methodology of UHV technique. Particular attention is drawn here to the book by Redhead et al.33 and to works by Chambers34 and by Czanderna et al.35. For this reason the UHV considerations will simply be outlined here.
3.4.1
Kinetic Theory
The rate at which a surface can be covered with molecules from the ambient atmosphere is the key reason why most surface analytical techniques require the use of UHV. The kinetic theory outlined in Figure 3.4 leads to an expression for the flux of molecules arriving at
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
53
Monolayer Formation due to Ambient Gas
The average velocity of a gas molecule is known from the kinetic theory of ideal gases. It is:
v = 8kT πm for Boltzmann’s constant k, absolute temperature T and molecular mass m. The impingement rate, J, of molecules at a surface situated in an ideal gas containing n molecules m-3 is:
J = nv . 4 Using the fact that, for a gas pressure p
n= p kT from the ideal gas law, the values of n and v from the equations above can be substituted in the expression for J to give:
J=
p 2π mkT
,
in which values for the constants can be inserted so resulting in:
J = bp M rT for relative molecular weight M r and the constant b given by
b = 2.63 × 1024 molecules m -2 s-1 K ½ Pa -1 b = 3.51 × 1026 molecules m -2 s-1 K ½ Torr -1 b = 2.63 × 1026 molecules m -2 s-1 K ½ mbar -1
Figure 3.4 The estimation of the rate of arrival of molecules (the flux) at a surface in a vacuum system
54
INSTRUMENTATION
a surface immersed in an atmosphere of molecules of relative weight Mr at pressure p. In Figure 3.4 this flux is expressed numerically for the pressure measured in Pascals (Pa), torr (mm mercury) and millibars (mbar). In a simple vacuum system with no materials or procedures used to obtain UHV the pressure is likely to be of the order of 106 mbar (104 Nm2) and the ambient atmosphere is composed mostly of nitrogen molecules. This leads to an arrival rate of nitrogen molecules on a surface at 295 K in this system of roughly 3 1014 cm2 s1 . Since a layer one molecule thick (a monolayer) contains about 1015 molecules cm2 this means that a surface prepared to be clean at this pressure will be contaminated with a monolayer of the ambient gas molecules in about 3 s after the cleaning process is stopped – not a great deal of time to carry out any experiment on a supposedly clean surface! As the flux from the ambient gas is proportional to the pressure of that gas then if the pressure can be reduced to 1010 mbar the arrival time for a complete monolayer is increased to about 8 h. The regime of pressures below about 109 mbar is regarded as UHV and is essential for most surface studies. The estimates given above of the rate of contamination due to the gas in the vacuum are pessimistic because some molecular types have a low probability of staying on the surface once having landed. The sticking probability is very low for atoms or molecules of the noble gases because their binding to the surface is very weak being dominated by the van der Waals forces. On the other hand molecules that bind strongly to the surface through ionic or covalent bonds (oxygen or carbon and their compounds) can have sticking probabilities of very near to unity. This means that the times for a monolayer of contamination to occur are generally longer than those estimated above. However, some molecules in the vacuum will be preferred for adsorption because of their higher sticking probabilities. Details of the measurement and values of sticking probabilities can be found in Czanderna et al.35, Hudson36, Redhead et al.33 and Somorjai37. Other contamination effects associated with electron beam damage and accidental admission of impurity gases during the preparations for sample oxidation or inert gas admission for ion bombardment are discussed separately below.
3.4.2
Vacuum Hardware
Some of the important features of a UHV system are outlined below. More information can be obtained from many of the books cited above33,36–38.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
55
The vacuum chamber and its associated pipework are normally fabricated with stainless steel, the permanent structure being connected with argon-arc welding or vacuum braising. This material has a low corrosion rate in air and has low rates of outgassing of absorbed gas. Some chambers are fabricated using a material with high magnetic permeability in order to provide magnetic screening of the internal components. Alternatively, a magnetic shield may be fitted as a sleeve inside the vacuum system – a procedure that involves lower mechanical stresses on the magnetic material and so smaller probability of loss of its high permeability. Screening of some kind is common practice in Auger microscopes to reduce the penetration of both the earth’s magnetic field and any alternating magnetic fields from neighboring equipment into components where the kinetic energies of the electrons are low. The vacuum junctions are made with metal gaskets. Gold O-rings or flat copper rings are normally used here. The use of metal gaskets avoids release of organic contaminants, reduces leakage of water vapor from the atmosphere into the system, and allows the baking procedures described below. The whole chamber assembly and its internal components and permanent wiring are designed to be heated in air whilst pumps are operating. This baking procedure causes accelerated desorption of water vapor (and other gases) from all the internal surfaces. When the system is cooled to room temperature for normal operation the ultimate pressure attainable is thus substantially reduced. Bakeout temperatures can be as high as 550 K but some internal components may not survive such temperatures with properties unaltered – channeltrons, microchannel plates, some semiconducting devices, and some special UHV adhesives may require bakeout to be below 420 K. This lower temperature bakeout results in slower desorption of gases from all the surfaces and so can take substantially longer times. Many systems are equipped for unattended bakeout that can be carried out overnight. Bakeout times vary between a few hours and several days depending upon the materials and components inside the vacuum system. Pressures of the order of 1010 mbar are routinely available. Evacuation of the chamber is usually by means of combinations of diffusion pumps (with special construction methods and fluids), ion pumps, titanium sublimation pumps and turbomolecular pumps. These methods avoid the use of conventional oils and their associated contamination of the system. UHV diffusion pumps are fabricated from stainless steel and filled with polyphenyl ether – a fluid that has a low vapor pressure at the temperatures required to achieve pumping. Initial
56
INSTRUMENTATION
pumping of the chamber from atmospheric pressure is usually by conventional rotary pumps provided with efficient traps to prevent flow or diffusion of oil into the chamber or any other component. The chamber may be separated from any diffusion pump or turbomolecular pump by a trap cooled to liquid nitrogen temperatures. The cold surfaces of any such trap reduce diffusion and creep of fluids from the pump or pumps. Similarly, it is possible for water vapor to enter the sample chamber together with gas that may be admitted deliberately for a surface reaction or for surface cleaning. Very small proportions of water vapor can be present in bottles used for to admit nominally pure gases. A simple trap composed of a spiral of the tube carrying this gas but immersed in dry ice is an effective method of removing traces of water vapor. The selection of materials used inside the vacuum chamber is made to avoid materials with high vapor pressures during bakeout or at room temperature. Stainless steel, molybdenum and tantalum are commonly used to fabricate metallic components. Oxygen-free high conductivity copper is commonly used as an electrical conductor. High-density ceramics such as alumina, glass, fibreglass woven material (without an organic binder) and kapton are used as insulating materials. Some lubricants are possible on bearings – a thin coating of silver or very small amounts of molybdenum disulfide can be used.
3.4.3
Vacuum Measurement
The measurement of the pressure in various parts of the vacuum system of an Auger microscope is most often made with a variant of the ionisation gauge called a Bayard–Alpert (BA) gauge for the lower pressure range and a Pirani gauge for higher pressures. The Pirani gauge works by measuring the change of resistance of a hot wire cooled by heat exchange with the gas in which it is situated. It is a robust and easily fabricated device that can be constructed with UHV compatible materials. It is useful in the pressure range 101–103 mbar. The BA gauge exploits the ionisation of gas molecules by electrons generated by a thermionic filament and accelerated by a grid electrode to about 150 eV. Ion current is measured at a collector situated at the center of the cylindrical grid. The gauge is usually mounted ‘naked’ in the vacuum system to minimize the effects of the pumping action it has most noticeably when in a restricted space. This gauge can be used in the range 104 to 1011 mbar. It needs to be outgassed by changing the
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
57
electrode potentials so that electrons from the filament heat them and any surrounding metal and cause desorption of gases at temperatures higher than that of normal gauge operation. Facilities for this degassing are usually incorporated in the electronics supplied by the gauge manufacturer. It is sometimes convenient (e.g. the ionisation gauge may not be operational) to use the current being drawn by any ion pump in the system. The ion pump works by ionising molecules that enter the region between its electrodes where there is arranged to be a high electrostatic field. The current drawn by this discharge is proportional to the number of gas molecules in this region and so to the pressure. Most ion pump power supplies are provided with metering of this ion current that can be useful as a rough guide to the pressure in the system.
3.4.4
Interlocking
Most scanning Auger microscopes contain components that may have high electrostatic potentials applied to their electrodes with correspondingly high electric fields. This is particularly true of field emission electron sources and some electron detectors such as channeltrons and microchannel plates. Further, sudden application of high operating potentials can result in transient pulses that reach sensitive detectors such as single electron counters or high input impedance analog amplifiers (electrometers) that can be so damaged (expensively!). In addition, some components can be damaged should the pressure in the vacuum system rise unexpectedly causing a discharge inside those components. This can happen for instance inside a microchannel plate pair used for electron counting. Finally, the logistics of operating the vacuum system, its bakeout routine, pumping down from atmosphere and admitting gas to return to atmospheric pressure can be sufficiently complex that these procedures are also a source of possible damage should the wrong procedure be adopted. For these reasons these complex and expensive microscopes are usually provided with comprehensive interlocking for the correct sequence in pumping from atmospheric pressure with all potentials turned off and then a controlled rate of application of these potentials once sufficiently low pressures have been achieved so that discharges will not occur. Similarly, related interlocking is provided for ensuring safe conditions during bakeout and safe sequencing of turning off operations during the return to atmospheric pressure.
58
3.5
INSTRUMENTATION
ELECTRON EMITTERS IN HIGH CURRENT PROBES
The discussions in the previous sections (Figure 3.3 and associated text) have established that a beam current of the order of 5–10 nA is required for reasonably short Auger frame scan times (<500 s), with an electron spot size defined by the highest spatial resolution needed. These requirements necessitate the use of adequately stable, high brightness and long life electron sources. The brightness (b) is defined as the number of Asr1cm2 an electron source supplies to its probe forming system, and a high value is required for adequate beam current and spatial resolution applications. High electron beam stability is needed because the acquisition time of an Auger electron image (or a set of images) can be several tens of minutes to several hours, and the user may be engaged in the analysis (through mapping) of elements that may be present with concentrations of only few atomic % on a specimen surface. For such analytical work the beam current has to have a stability of better than 1 % per hour or the variation in the beam current during the frame scan time will interfere with (or even conceal) the variations in the concentration of the element being mapped. Finally, the long lifetime of the source is a requirement partially dictated by the need to establish UHV conditions around the specimen, an operation that can normally take 2–3 days to achieve (see previous section). In addition, an Auger spectroscopy measurement at a point on the sample or over a small scanned area may last for several tens of hours. These considerations lead to the need for source lifetimes in excess of 1000 h. Table 3.1 lists a comparison of the important source parameters for the most widely used electron sources in high resolution electron columns. As can be seen from this comparison, field electron emitters have the highest brightness and longest lifetimes, but tend to be less Table 3.1 A comparison of some parameters for various electron sources
Source Tungsten hairpin LaB6 Cold field emitters Schottky field emitter
Brightness, (b) (A cm2 sr1) 1:5 105 1–5 106 109 >108
Vacuum Stability requirement (% h1) (mbar) 2–3 1–2 5 <1
<104 <106 <109 < 5 109
Lifetime (h)
Source size, d0 (lm)
<500 <1000 >5000 >5000
25 1–5 0.03–0.05 0.03–0.05
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
59
stable than the thermionic and Schottky electron sources. In the early days of AES developments, only thermionic sources were available for use in surface analysis instruments. However, soon after SAM was demonstrated in an SEM by MacDonald39 in 1970, both field emission based and LaB6 sources were introduced to microscopy, making possible their use in surface analysis instruments. In the following discussion a brief overview of thermionic sources is given first and this is followed by a more detailed discussion of the LaB6 and Schottky field emitters, because these are the more commonly used sources in modern instruments. An overview of how the various parameters of an electron source contribute to the final electron beam diameter is then outlined. In simple electron optical terms, the final beam diameter is an image of the emitting source that is degraded because of the aberrations of the electron optical arrangement used to form the beam striking the sample. In other words, there are two major inputs to the final beam diameter; one due to the source properties and one due to the lenses used in the subsequent electron column. These effects can be described by: dT ¼
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi do2 þ dd2 þ dc2 þ ds2
ð3:1Þ
where dd ¼ 0:61 l=ai ds ¼ 0:5Csi a3i dc ¼ 2Cci ai V=Vi : Here, dT is the total beam diameter at the sample, do is the diameter of the emitting source, dd is the contribution due to diffraction effects in the column, dc and ds are the chromatic and spherical aberration contributions to the beam diameter, respectively, l is electron wavep length and is given by l ¼ 1:25= Vi nm, ai is the beam angle in the image side, Csi and Cci are, respectively, the spherical and chromatic aberration coefficients of the lens and V is the energy spread of the electron source used. It is important to note at this point that the chromatic aberration is directly proportional to the energy spread, which in this context is represented by the term V which is a composite from both the energy distribution of the emitted electrons and the ripple of the power supply used to provide the beam energy.
60
3.5.1
INSTRUMENTATION
Thermionic Cathodes
The heated tungsten hairpin filament has been the most commonly used electron source in conventional electron probes. Its properties are well documented40. The filament is commonly made from tungsten wire about 125 mm in diameter and is operated at a temperature of the order 2850 K and a pressure below 104 mbar for stable emission. This high temperature limits the life of the filament to a few tens of hours because of evaporation of filament material. Brores41 shows that a brightness of about 1:5 105 A cm2 sr1 is obtained from such cathodes with a lifetime of 10–15 h. A pointed cathode can improve the brightness with a slight reduction in the operating temperature. This results from two effects, first the high surface field applied to prevent the limitation of the current by space charge and secondly the emission enhancement by the Schottky effect. Brightnesses of about 5 105 A cm2 sr1 have been reported by Brores41 at pressure of about 107 mbar. A source size of about 25 mm is expected for this type of emitter. One of the most important parameters of electron sources is the energy spread because this determines the contribution of the chromatic aberrations in the column to the final probe diameter. For thermionic emission, the energy distribution would be of the form e de e > 0 ð3:2Þ FðeÞde / e exp kT FðeÞ ¼ 0
e<0
ð3:3Þ
where e is the energy above the vacuum level, k is Boltzmann’s constant and T is the absolute temperature. The full width at half the maximum (FWHM) of this distribution is 2:9 kT, which for 3000 K is 0.27 eV as can be inferred in Figure 3.5. In low brightness operation, figures closer to the above theoretical values can be obtained. For high brightness systems, a much higher value of 4–5 eV is obtained40. This broadening is due to the Boersch effect42. 3.5.1.1 Lanthanum hexaboride (LaB6) Lanthanum hexaboride (LaB6), was recognised as an alternative high brightness electron source in 1951 by Lafferty43. However, its use was restricted because of its reactivity at high temperature. In 1969 Brores44 realised a gun in which the LaB6 cathode was heated by electron
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
61
Figure 3.5 Theoretical total energy distribution plots for various values of ðkT=dÞ. From Swanson and Crouser70 courtesy of The Journal of Applied Physics
bombardment. Further improvements to the design by Ahmed45 have allowed a reduction in the heater power. A brightness of about 5 106 A cm2 sr1 and an energy spread of about 3–4 eV are typical for a 1 mm diameter tip41. A vacuum of better than 106 mbar is also essential for the operation of such emitters. For pressures greater than 106 mbar, the oxygen content around the source causes its erosion and hence a change in the source shape which, in turn, results in a change in the position of the virtual source, both leading to a deterioration in the electron optical performance of the column. Shimizu et al.46 have devised a method to fabricate single crystal LaB6 in sharp needle shapes suitable for field emission. Zaima et al.47 reported an energy spread of about 1 eV for a (100) single crystal LaB6 tip operated in the TF mode (defined below) with a temperature between 1000 K and 1500 K. The current density was 3:9 105 A cm2 and the tip radius was estimated to be about 0.13 mm from Fowler–Nordheim plots48. This figure was in good agreement with measurements of the emitter radius estimated using an SEM. Thermionic sources have been used only in the early SAM instruments. However, LaB6 sources soon became widely used in commercial SAM instruments (VG Microscopes, Perkin Elmer, PHI, and JEOL).
62
3.5.2
INSTRUMENTATION
Field Electron Emitters
At the beginning of the development of SAM instruments, field electron emitters were being introduced as electron sources in commercial SEMs (e.g. the Vacuum Generators HB200 and the Welter and Coates SEM). Both instruments used a single crystal oriented W(310) field emitter operated at room temperature (frequently referred to colloquially as cold field emission), and were used with a gun-lens based on the design of Crewe et al.49. Routine use of these early instruments was difficult because of poor beam current stability. The reason for this was the lack of understanding of the operational requirements of field emitters as electron sources, e.g. low pressure ð< 1 1010 mbarÞ, cleanliness of the surrounding electrodes, the choice of emitter crystal orientation, and the mode of operating the emitter for a particular instrument. For example, in the transmission electron microscope a total emission current of a few mA is normally adequate for forming a probe with sufficient current, while in the SEM and other probes used in microanalysis (e.g. the electron microprobe analyser) or for lithography application, higher emission currents (>50 mA) were required depending on the specific application. The early work in SAM instrument developments were based around SEM columns that employ field emitters as the electron source. This choice meant that a beam current of about an order of magnitude higher than is normally used in the SEM mode was essential. This was a further constraint on cold field emitters because emission fluctuations increase with the higher emission currents needed50. Several studies have been carried out to establish reliable ways of operating field emitters at relatively high emission currents with improved lifetimes51–53. However, it soon became clear that these requirements are not easily achievable in instruments that are provided with fast entry air-locks, that are designed for multi-users and are used for a wide variety of applications and, perhaps, in different research or industrial environments. Even in modern SEMs, the use of cold field emitters requires the periodic cleaning of the emitter to re-establish a sufficient beam current. This is usually achieved with the aid of an electronic circuit that senses the total emission current and switches on the filament current to heat the tip if the emission current drops below a given value. However, the use of cold field emitters in the SEM is tolerated due to their lower energy spread in the beam leaving the source and because the acquisition of secondary electron images takes only a matter of seconds or a few minutes at most, during which the beam
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
63
current will not change dramatically. This is different from SAM imaging that can last for many minutes or even a few hours. In the late 1970s, Swanson and co-workers were able to measure the characteristics of a tungsten field emission based electron source which has the work function of the (100) plane lowered from 4.6 eV to 2.8 eV by the addition of zirconium and oxygen54. Further work from the same group established the operational conditions of this source in various environments. The Zr/W(100) emitter, now known as the Schottky field emitter (SFE), soon became the industry standard for SEMs, TEMs, Auger and lithography instruments. It is instructive here to give some introductory remarks on field electron emitters and their operational requirements because it is most likely that most current SEMs and SAM instruments will feature electron columns employing Schottky emitters. 3.5.2.1 The characteristics and operational requirements of field emitter electron sources The physics of field emitters. When a large electric field of the order of 2–5 107 V cm1 is applied to a metal surface, the potential step barrier is changed into a barrier of finite width through which electrons can tunnel into the vacuum with a high current density. This effect is known as field electron emission. Complete discussion of the phenomena can be found in several articles55–58. Figure 3.6 shows the energy diagram of
Figure 3.6 Energy diagram for a free electron metal electrode with an electric field applied normal to its surface. (a) Potential energy due to the external electric field. (b) Resultant potential barrier
64
INSTRUMENTATION
electrons in a metal and the effects of an applied electric field. Fowler and Nordheim48 derived an expression relating the field emission current density J (A cm2), to the electric field at the surface E (V cm1), and the work function f (eV). They assumed a triangular potential distribution and neglected the outside image force acting on the emitted electrons. If this image force is taken into consideration and a linear applied macroscopic electric field is assumed, their expression can be written as55: " ! # AE2 f3=2 ðyÞ ð3:4Þ J ¼ 2 exp B ft ðyÞ E where A ¼ 1:54 106 B ¼ 6:87 107 y ¼ 3:79 104 E1=2 =f tðyÞ ¼ nðyÞ 1:5yd½nðyÞ =dy
ð3:5Þ
Over the useful operating ranges of field emitters, the slowly varying functions n(y) and t(y) have the following approximate values59 t2 ðyÞ ¼ 1:1
and nðyÞ ¼ 0:95 y2 :
ð3:6Þ
It is useful to note that, by plotting the IðVÞ characteristics of the emitter as shown in Figure 3.7, one should obtain a straight line that reflects the occurrence of field emission behavior. This plot is known as the Fowler–Nordheim plot. Field emitter cathodes are generally made of a single crystal wire of diameter about 125 mm welded to a heater hairpin and electropolished to a sharp point. This is illustrated in Figure 3.8(a). Methods of fabricating field emitters are described by Good55 and Dyke56. Due to its high tensile strength and thus its ability to withstand the applied electrostatic stresses, and its high melting point (3670 K), single crystal tungsten wires have been used as electron sources in field emission probe forming systems. The emitter radius typically ranges from 0.01 to 1.0 mm, depending on the particular application of the emitter. However, the actual source size is much smaller than this. Crewe et al.49 have estimated the source diameter to be about 2 nm, and Cleaver60 suggests a diameter of 1.5 nm. Wiesner61 assumed different tip shapes and diameters and included the contributions of spherical aberration, energy spread E, and diffraction for the calculation of the source size. His
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
65
Figure 3.7 A typical Fowler–Nordheim plot of the current versus applied voltage for field emission. It is the total current leaving the tip and Ip is the current in the beam reaching the sample. From Swanson and Martin54 courtesy of The Journal of Applied Physics
results suggest a source diameter ranging from 4 to 10 nm, assuming an energy spread E ¼ 0:3 eV. He found an optimum source size for a tip diameter of 0.6 mm operated with an extraction potential of 4 kV. Note that any extractor voltage quoted throughout this discussion is that needed to establish an electric field at the tip of the emitter of greater than 2 107 V cm1 . It is obvious in this respect that the distance
66
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.8 (a) An image depicting the shape of the etched tungsten single crystal and the position of the zirconium reservoir on the shank. (b) SEM micrograph of a Zr/O/W(100) built-up emitter showing the polyhedral shape of the emitter tip
between the emitter and the extractor is an important consideration should only an extractor voltage be stated. Experimental measurements of the source size in the case of cold field emitters agree well with Wiesner’s predictions62. Stringent vacuum conditions (<1010 mbar) are, however, necessary for stable emission as will be seen later. Following Young63, the FWHM of the total energy distribution ðEÞ for cold field emission is given by: E ¼ 6:76 109 Ef1=2 tðy2 Þ
ð3:7Þ
where tðyÞ is given by Equation (3.5). For typical applied fields (2–5 107 V cm1), this ranges between 0.063 eV and 0.155 eV. At relatively low current densities, measured values of 0.14 –0.22 eV, in close agreement with the theory, have been reported64–66. At high current densities, the Boersch effect42 (i.e. Coulomb interaction of the electrons within the emitting area) is known to play an important role in broadening the energy distribution. Cumming and Smith67 have measured the energy spread from W(111) to be 3.2 eV at 2 mA emission current. In the thermally assisted field emission mode (the TF mode), where the emitter is operated at a temperature of about 1200 K to 1500 K in order to desorb any contaminants that may be accumulated during
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
67
operation and which alter the local work function as with cold field emission, the energy spread is usually higher than either for cold field emission or thermionic emission68. Veneklasen et al.69 have assumed an energy spread of 2.5 eV at 100 mA emission current for an emitter operated at 1200 K. Such high values in this mode can be explained as follows. Following Swanson and Crouser70, the total energy distribution J(d) assuming a free-electron model is given by: JðdÞ ¼ J
ed=d dð1 þ ed=kT Þ
ð3:8Þ
with d ¼ 1:44E where d is the electron energy relative to the Fermi level, J is given by Equation (3.4). Equation (3.8) breaks down for kT > 1 and is regarded as unreliable for kT > 0:7. Figure 3.5 shows J(d) as a function of d/d for various values of kT=d70. At low temperatures ðkT=d 1Þ the energy distribution is narrow, as most emitted electrons are a result of ‘cold’ field emission. As the temperature is raised, the potential ‘barrier’ will be depressed below the vacuum level allowing more electrons to be emitted thermionically. This condition occurs at kT=d ¼ 0:5, which for tungsten, assuming E ¼ 4 107 V cm1 and f ¼ 4:5 eV, corresponds to a temperature of 1400 K. The FWHM in this case will be about 3–4 eV. As the temperature is raised further, the majority of electrons will be thermionically emitted and the energy distribution will become narrower. Practical aspects of operating field emitters in probe forming systems. A method of reducing the angular spread of the field emitted electrons (i.e. angularly confining the emission) and selectively lowering the work function of W(100) was developed by Swanson and coworkers54,70 in what is now has come to be known as the Schottky field emitter (SFE) cathode. The technique involves the deposition of a mixed zirconium and oxygen layer on the emitter shank which acts as a reservoir for subsequent diffusion along the shank to the emitting region. The mixed oxide at the tip was found to reduce the W(100) work function from a value of 4.6 eV to 2.6–2.8 eV. Furthermore, the oxide confines the electron emission to about 0.1–0.15 sr. Extraction voltages, Ve , of 3–8 kV giving total emission in excess of 100 mA were obtained. The energy spread at a temperature of 1350–1450 K was found to be 1 eV. In a detailed study of this cathode, Swanson and Martin54 suggest an emitter temperature of about 1700–1800 K for long
68
INSTRUMENTATION
term stability and for an energy spread of the order of 0.6–0.7 eV. A lifetime exceeding 5000 h at a pressure of <108 mbar and a temperature of 1350–1450 K is also reported by the same authors. However, it is now accepted that the appropriate temperature to use for prolonged and stable emission is in the range 1700–1800 K. One advantage of this coated emitter is the resulting low work function of the (100) plane at the end of the tip that allows the use of emitters with relatively larger radii than those that are uncoated. The use of a larger radius reduces the probability of emitter destruction in the event of an electrical breakdown in the column. The experience at York and elsewhere has found that an emitter radius of about 0.4–0.6 mm operated at about 1750 K with adequate zirconium on the emitter shank can last for several years of daily operation with beam current stability of <1 %. The SFE is today the more accepted emitter for use in most electron microscopes, with the exception of the TEM and some SEMs that are used for higher spatial resolutions than are otherwise obtainable. However, the stability obtained from the SFEs, particularly for beam currents in excess of 1 nA, makes their use attractive. Figure 3.8(a) shows a typical SFE depicting the profile of the etched single crystal and the position of the zirconium reservoir on the emitter shank. Figure 3.8(b) is an SEM image of the end-form of a typical SFE and Figure 3.9(a) shows the corresponding emission pattern observed in a field electron emission microscope. Note that the end form of the emitter seen in Figure 3.8(b) displays clear crystal facetting of the various planes of the tungsten single crystal wire. The flat at the tip of the emitter is the
Figure 3.9 Field electron micrographs of the emission patterns from Zr/O/W(100). (a) The case of a pattern from a fully processed emitter. (b) The case when the emitter has lost its end-form faceting that gives rise to the emission pattern shown in (a). In this case while the total emission current may be similar to the clean case, the on axis current is much lower and is unstable. (Note that the dark spot in the middle of the pattern is that for a Faraday cup for measuring the on axis current density)
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
69
origin of the emitted electrons used to form the probe. If, for some reason (e.g. faults in tip manufacture or problems inside the SAM column), the chemical composition or the shape of the end form change from that shown in Figure 3.8(b), the emission pattern may take a form such as that depicted in Figure 3.9(b), that shows a series of ring patterns. The emission current in the central spot of this pattern (used to form the beam) will then show fluctuations of about 10 % whilst the total emission current may show stability of about 2–3 %. To restore current stability (i.e. where emission returns to a single central spot), the user may need to subject the emitter to a high temperature treatment (normally >2000 K) in the presence of a moderate field of about half that used for operating the emitter. This is then followed by a prolonged period of processing under the correct field for emission and temperature in the range 1750–1800 K. Although the SFE emitter behaves in a similar way to conventional thermionic cathodes, great care is needed for reliable operation. The following procedure was found by El Gomati and co-workers at the University of York both to reduce the probability of cathode destruction due to excessive emitted current at the early stages of operation and to maintain the emitter shape shown in Figure 3.8(b) which is a prerequisite for the many advantages displayed by this type of cathode. Following a bakeout operation to the column or after the replacement or installation of a new emitter, first, an extractor voltage is set to about 1.5–2 kV and the emitter is flashed to a temperature of about 1750– 1850 K for a period of 20–30 s to desorb the loosely bound contaminants on the emitter’s end form accumulated due to exposure to the atmosphere. The filament current is then set to give a temperature of about 1400 K and is subsequently increased slowly and smoothly to achieve a value of 1700–1750 K over a period of 15–30 min. At the end of this period, the emission current, Ie , rises to about 5–10 mA. It is recommended that Ie should not exceed this value at the early stages of activation in order to reduce the probability of arcs initiated by the emitted current. This mechanism54, is responsible for the destruction of the emitter. The extractor voltage of the given emitter is then slowly increased until its value, as specified in the data sheet issued by the manufacturer, is achieved in about 30–60 min. A rate of increase of the order of 10 V s1 is found to be safe to use. It is important that the user operates the column using the manufacturer’s recommended values. This is particularly necessary in order to obtain a small probe diameter (i.e. for high resolution applications). As
70
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.10 Diagrams for electron emission from a free electron metal together with the respective energy distributions of the emitted electrons. Thermionic emission: (a) without applied field; (b) in the presence of the applied field (Schottky emission). (c) Field emission (FE). Permission of Academic Press and courtesy of Vu Thien Binh et al132
can be seen from Figure 3.10, operating the emitter at a different temperature could lead to a different emission regime (Schottky versus thermally assisted field emission). The consequence of this is reflected in the resulting energy spread, which increases the chromatic aberration component of the probe. This is important because most columns are chromatic aberration limited as will be seen in the following section.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
3.6 3.6.1
71
ELECTRON COLUMNS Introduction
Electron columns are the part of any microprobe instrument that has the functions of focusing, accelerating or retarding and deflecting the electrons after they leave the source, be this of the thermionic or field emission type, i.e. it is the probe forming part of the instrument. This component contains the electron lenses, deflector plates and stigmator corrector electrodes. There are basically two types of electron columns employed in SAM: magnetic and electrostatic. Traditionally, magnetic columns have been used in electron microscopes in general as these offer better focusing properties than electrostatic lenses due to their smaller aberration coefficients. However, the comparison is not straightforward and there are specific situations where one type will be preferred to another. For example, electrostatic lenses suffer no image rotation, consume neglible power and are light in weight. Magnetic lenses on the other hand require no high voltage insulation and need no stable high voltages. In the early days of SAM developments, most of the electrostatic small diameter columns were developed by academic groups51,71, while most commercial columns featured a magnetic column. In what follows, an overview of the major components of a typical electron column as used in SAM instruments will be given. The subject of electron columns, however, is very wide and the reader is directed to books and review articles that cover the subject in greater detail17,58,72,73.
3.6.2
Electrostatic and Magnetic Columns
The general function of the column is to attempt to provide faithful point to point imaging of a small object, normally the emitting area of the electron source to the probe at the sample. These electrons leave the source with an angular spread and hence the column requirement of refocusing them into a small spot. The performance of the column’s lens (or combination of lenses), however, deviates from the ideal due to two kinds of aberrations: mechanical and electronic, both acting to deform the shape of the final electron spot. Mechanical aberration is due to imperfections in the different lens shapes and the material used in their manufacture, which result in astigmatism, ellipticity and coma. Electronic aberration is due to the charge and speed of the charged particles used (electrons in the present case), which cause chromatic and space charge
72
INSTRUMENTATION
effects. Spherical aberration, on the other hand, depends on the form of the lenses used and the convergence in the beam that they cause. The contributions to the final spot size are summarized in Equation (3.1) in the previous section. For field electron emitters and Schottky emitters the diameter of the emitting region on the source is also referred to as the virtual source size, do , because it is the diameter of the region within the emitter from which the electrons appear to originate. The value of do has been estimated to be of the order of 25–30 nm for Schottky emitters74 and for cold field emitters it is estimated to be of the order of 5–10 nm. Electrostatic columns were used in SAM instruments developed in universities for several reasons: their compatibility with UHV technology, their small size that enables the entire column to be fitted inside the electron energy analyser (particularly the CMA type) and that no magnetic fields are present to interfere with the analysis of the very low energy secondary electrons that are backscattered from the surface of the sample under investigation. In addition, it was found that the high beam currents required for SAM applications at long working distances, as the case normally is in SAMs, can be achieved in beam diameters only slightly worse than those produced by magnetic columns. Figure 3.11
Figure 3.11 A schematic diagram of an electrostatic column developed at York. It consists of a pre-aligned Schottky field electron emitter and extractor, gun-lens and low energy electron detector. It is 45 mm in diameter by 91 mm long
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
73
Figure 3.12 An image of the pre-aligned Schottky emitter and extractor developed by YPS Ltd[1] for use in electron columns. The module measures 20 20 mm
shows, as an example of the electrostatic columns used in SAMs, one of several such columns developed at the University of York. The column measures only 91 mm in total length and 45 mm in diameter and fits inside a single pass CMA. It contains the Schottky electron source, two lenses (gun/condenser and objective type), an in-lens low energy electron detector as used in the cathode lens mode where the incident beam energy can continuously be varied in the range 1–10 000 eV75 and all the deflectors and stigmator corrector electrodes. Another important feature of this column is the pre-aligned nature of all its components, including the Schottky emitter which is depicted in Figure 3.12. Although the development of small electrostatic columns is not currently being pursued in SAM instruments any more, the use of such small columns is still rather attractive in electron beam lithography applications, particularly in maskless type instruments. Mankos et al.76 proposed an instrument featuring an array of small columns of about 20 mm diameter operating in parallel. While such an instrument has not been offered in commercial instruments yet, its realisation is still being actively76 pursued by a number of research groups worldwide. [1]
See www.yps-ltd.com
74
INSTRUMENTATION
The coefficients CS and CC of magnetic lenses are far superior to those for electrostatic lenses and it is because of this that most high resolution electron microscopes (for spot diameters less than 10 nm) employ one or two magnetic lenses to form the focused electron beam. Further, as described previously in this chapter, Auger electron spectroscopy and microscopy require a UHV environment to be carried out, a process that requires baking the instrument to temperatures exceeding 100 C. This requirement was technically challenging for the use of SEM columns employing magnetic lenses in the early stages of developing Auger electron microscopy because all the components used were not compatible with UHV technology. Recently, the development of Schottky field electron emitters as the most widely used electron source in electron microscopy, has finally persuaded most instrument manufacturers to develop magnetic lenses for use in UHV SEM instruments. These columns are also used in modern commercial SAMs (Thermo VG Scientific, Physical Electronics USA, Japan Electron Optics Ltd and Omicron GmbH). Figure 3.13 depicts a schematic of a magnetic column of the type used in SAM instruments. All the above manufacturers offer SAM columns with probe diameters of less than 10 nm as used in the SAM mode, as indicated in Table 3.2.
3.6.3
Astigmatism
The imperfections in the mechanical shapes of the lenses or the materials used in their construction normally leads to a form of aberration referred to as astigmatism (i.e. effects due to a lack of cylindrical symmetry). This defect refers to the fact that the focusing power of a lens will vary for charged particles (electrons in our case) travelling within different planes with respect to the axes of the asymmetry. This defect is similar to that which occurs in the human eye, when the lens shape departs from being round. In electrostatic lenses imperfections with regard to the circularity of the lens apertures are the main cause of astigmatism. In the case of a magnetic electron lens, the lack of axial symmetry of the magnetic field that has the focusing action is normally the result of mechanical imperfections in the shape of the pole pieces of the lens and can also be due to magnetic inhomogeneity (i.e. variation in permeability) within the pole-piece material. If the axis of the column is taken to be the z-direction, differences in the focusing power of the lenses in the x–z and y–z planes of a column will cause the focus of a single point object to appear as a line focus. The
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
75
Figure 3.13 A schematic diagram of a magnetic electron column inside a CMA. Courtesy of Physical Electronics USA
Table 3.2 A comparison of the performance of several commercial electron columns in SAMs
Manufacturer and model JEOL JAMP 7900F OMICRON MULTISCAN LAB PHI 2000 Thermo VG Microlab 350
SEM resolution (nm) 3 3 6 8
Auger resolution (nm) 8 6–8 8 <12
Beam voltage (keV) 30 15 10 30
76
INSTRUMENTATION
correction of such an aberration is achieved via the insertion of a weak lens on the column’s optical axis, whose focusing power (in the two perpendicular planes x–z and y–z) and orientation can be adjusted. This lens is called the stigmator77–79. In magnetic columns practical stigmators take the form of two quadrupole lenses, each consisting of four electromagnets with similar poles facing each other. In the case of electrostatic stigmators, four plates carrying similar voltages are arranged with pairs facing each other. The two quadrupoles are oriented at 45 to each other to avoid mechanically rotating them. Connecting a voltage Va to the first quadrupole and Vb on the second results in a field of magnitude and direction controlled by the relative sizes of the two voltages. Similarly, in magnetic octopole stigmators a similar set-up can be achieved with eight saddle windings. By varying the relative strengths of the currents Ia and Ib through the two quadrupoles, a quadrupole field of controllable strength and orientation can be generated. Both types of stigmator require the use of high stability power supplies.
3.7 3.7.1
MECHANICAL POSITIONING AND STABILITY Introduction
The sample positioning and orientation of the sample in an Auger microscope has many similarities with the same task in a conventional electron microscope. The precision required of movements and the stability of sample position are similar but the task is made more difficult because of the need for UHV compatibility of the components and the bearing surfaces of the manipulator. This extra difficulty is offset to some extent in comparison with the sample handling in a transmission electron microscope because there is usually somewhat more space around the sample in a SAM. This section outlines some of the requirements for a SAM sample manipulator and illustrates one design.
3.7.2
Sample Manipulators
A practical specification for the sample stage is that it should be capable of locating an area of interest on the sample surface and allowing data acquisition for, say, 10 h whilst moving less than one-tenth of the spatial resolution obtainable in the instrument. Since SAM instruments can
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
77
have spatial resolutions of the order of 5 nm this means there is a stringent criterion that having located the area of interest the sample will not drift in position at a rate greater than about 0.05 nm per hour if realisation of this resolution is to be achieved. Changes in the temperature of the laboratory or relief of stresses stored in mechanical motions coupled to the sample stage can easily cause drift rates greater than this. As well as the UHV compatibility of the materials making up the manipulator other important matters are the size of any differential thermal expansion effects, the magnetic properties of the materials and their surroundings (hopefully there are no magnetic materials in the manipulator or surrounding parts) and frictional effects in mechanical drives and their bearings. Differential thermal expansion effects can be significant both internal to the manipulator assembly itself and between the manipulator and the vacuum chamber upon which it is mounted. The thermal conductivity of stainless steel is not very high and it is possible for temperature gradients to exist around the chamber and between the chamber wall and its contents. The former can cause small changes in the shape of the chamber to which the electron column and the manipulator are usually mounted on separate flanges. The effect of changes in the temperature of the air temperature in the laboratory then cause the electron beam to strike a different place on the sample surface – beware of blasts of air from any air conditioning or heaters in the laboratory that may be thermostatically controlled. An ingenious solution to this problem was described by Todd et al.80 who mounted the sample manipulator rigidly onto the framework of a CMA that contained a coaxial electron column. The sample could be moved using flexible drives (Bowden cables) driven by rotary feedthroughs. Because analyser, column and manipulator were all mounted from a single flange on the UHV wall differential thermal effects were almost completely eliminated. This general principle is possible for all instruments with CMA energy analysers but is not possible when a CHA is used because the input transfer lens cannot coincide with the electron column. All the constraints on the choice of materials for construction of UHV compatible components are as described earlier in this chapter. The bearings for any translations or rotations are a potential source of problems because almost all normal lubricants are oils with high vapor pressures at both room and bakeout temperatures that will cause contamination of the sample surface as well as any semiconducting materials used as detectors. If no lubricants are used then the surfaces of the moving and fixed parts of any bearing tend to diffuse
78
INSTRUMENTATION
into each other causing cold-welding of the materials and loss of the motion that is needed. Very small quantities of the lubricants Dycronite (tungsten disulfide) or Rocol (molybenum disulfide) in a low vapor pressure solvent can be used at critical places. If the frictional forces at rotating or sliding contacts of metals are allowed to rise then stage stability can be degraded because energy can be stored as stress in any drives causing these motions. Once the drives have reached their desired settings this energy can cause very slow motions to continue as the elastic energy in a torque or tension is released. The source of friction has to be identified and the effects reduced for stage specifications to be recovered. An example of a sample manipulator assembly by Physical Electronics USA is shown in Figure 3.14. This manipulator has five degrees of freedom: The sample can be translated parallel to its surface by 25 mm in mutually perpendicular X and Y directions. The sample can be translated by 20 mm normal to its surface. The sample can be tilted about an axis in its surface in the range 0–60 . The sample can be rotated continuously through the full 360 about its normal. These motions are driven by internal UHV electric motors thus obviating the need for UHV motion feedthroughs and allowing remote electronic control of all the motions. An important feature of the use of motor driven motions for a sample stage are that the sample position and orientation can be computer controlled. This allows the controlling software to set absolute or relative sample positions, to save and recall previous positions of interest to the analyst and even maintain the position of the sample relative to the electron beam should temperature or other changes cause a movement. Because of the long times needed to bake the vacuum system after it has been allowed to reach atmospheric pressure it is usually very important to have a sample introduction mechanism that allows specimen insertion or removal without requiring such admission of air. This can be done by having an appendage chamber with small volume attached to the main chamber via a valve and equipped with separate means of pumping. A mechanical transfer mechanism for the sample then passes through the open valve when the pressure in the small
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
79
Figure 3.14 The 15-680 sample manipulator from Physical Electronics USA. This manipulator has five degrees of freedom and is operated by internal UHV compatible electric motors under computer control. The sample is mounted on a holder that is inserted into the stage at the position indicated by the arrow where it is retained by a clip. Courtesy of Dennis Paul and Physical Electronics USA
80
INSTRUMENTATION
chamber is low. The valve is then closed and the small chamber allowed to rise to atmospheric pressure. A sample (or samples) can then be removed or introduced, the small chamber closed off and pumped to a low pressure and the transfer mechanism used again. This can save a good deal of valuable instrument time compared with opening the whole system to air. A further convenience can be to have a carrousel inside the UHV system that acts as a temporary storage device in UHV for many samples. The transfer mechanism can be organised to move samples between the carrousel and the sample stage as needed – a quick and convenient operation. Having positioned the sample so that the region of interest on the surface can be studied and having provided adequate stability in the mechanics of sample location there remain related issues as to the stability of the electronic systems locating the beam on the sample and energy analysing the emitted electrons. This topic is discussed briefly in the last section of this chapter.
3.8 3.8.1
ENERGY ANALYSERS Introduction
The frequent aspiration to reduce the frame scan time in order to speed up measurements or reduce any electron beam damage of the sample leads to an interest in the properties of the electron energy analyser. For instance, to what extent can the solid angle of acceptance of the analyser be increased so as to increase the electron counting rate? For a given analyser design, increasing the size of the entrance aperture (which usually determines the solid angle of acceptance) the energy resolution of the analysis is degraded. This may be acceptable up to the point where neighboring peaks in the electron spectrum are caused to overlap due to the degraded energy resolution. This may not be acceptable when the peaks that now overlap contain information that the analyst is seeking. Conversely, if the energy resolution is made unnecessarily high then electron counts may be reduced and frame scan times increased unacceptably when detailed information about peak shapes or chemical shifts is not sought. These considerations are amplified below. The electron energy analyser (or strictly, the electron velocity analyser) is at the center of the construction and operation of a scanning Auger microscope. It accepts a fraction of the electrons scattered from
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
81
the point where the beam strikes the sample, allows the detection of only those electrons in a selected range of kinetic energies and rejects all others without causing any undesirable secondary effects. In principle the analyser can be of magnetic or electrostatic type (or even a combination of both) but electrostatic types have been preferred for Auger electron spectroscopy and microscopy. This is because the useful Auger electron spectrum extends to quite low kinetic energies (a few tens of eV) and any magnetic fields have to be very carefully controlled or even nearly eliminated if these electrons are not to have their trajectories severely disturbed in the region outside the analyser. Screening of electrostatic fields from components of a spectrometer is simple and requires only a grounded conducting enclosure around the source of disturbance. Screening of magnetic fields is possible with high magnetic permeability shields but it is more difficult to avoid the disturbing effects of stray magnetic fields leaking through the holes in the shield that are essential for entry and exit of the electrons whose velocity is to be analysed and that are essential for pumping the volume where the analyser is situated. Two types of electrostatic analyser have been in widespread use – the cylindrical mirror analyser (CMA) and the concentric hemispherical analyser (CHA). These two types are described below together with a more recent type – the hyperbolic field analyser (HFA). Auger electron spectroscopy started with the retarding field analyser (RFA)81 but this was rapidly displaced by the CMA and CHA because of signal to noise considerations82,83. The RFA detects all electrons with kinetic energies above a controllable threshold – it is a high pass filter. The Auger signals are recognised by differentiating the spectrum with respect to kinetic energy and have a size determined by the gradients at the sides of the peaks in the spectrum. This is closely related to the peak height for most peaks because the peak widths are roughly the same for most Auger features. However, the noise in the measurement of these gradients is determined by the fluctuations in the total number of electrons collected. Since all electrons above the kinetic energy of a peak are collected the noise in the measurement is larger than it would be if the analyser passed to its detector only electrons with kinetic energies in a narrow range around the peak. This behavior is provided by band pass filters, i.e. analysers that are dispersive and detect electrons over a narrow controllable energy range. The CMA and CHA are analysers of this type. It is convenient to define the energy resolution of a dispersive analyser in two ways that reflect practical modes of operation. By analogy with
82
INSTRUMENTATION
other types of spectroscopy the absolute resolution is defined as the full width at half maximum (FWHM), E, of a chosen measured peak and the relative resolution, R, is defined as the ratio of E to the kinetic energy Eo of the peak maximum. Thus R¼
E Eo
ð3:9Þ
The relative resolution is often expressed as a resolving power, r, by using the reciprocal of R. Thus, r¼
Eo E
ð3:10Þ
In conventional AES it is common to operate the analyser at constant resolving power. This is helpful as the shape of energy distribution in the spectrum falls with increasing kinetic energy and so the use of constant resolving power helps to ‘flatten’ out the shape of the spectrum because the energy window widens as the energy increases. This would be a disadvantage if it were not that the Auger peaks themselves have intrinsic widths of a few electron volts and so are relatively wide features. An average value of E of 1–2 eV over the entire range from 50 to 2000 eV with a resolving power of about 400 is a practical choice for most spectroscopy.
3.8.2
Cylindrical Mirror Analysers
Auger electron spectroscopy owes much of its popularity to the use of the CMA for the rapid collection of moderately high resolution energy spectra. This is because of the ease of construction and operation of this type of analyser and for its high signal transmission due to its cylindrical symmetry (that gives rise to a high sensitivity) as well as its modestly high energy resolution in comparison with many other analysers used in the early days of AES. There are several authors who independently paved the way for the development of this analyser as a charged particle detector84–89. However, it was Palmberg and co-workers82 who first used the CMA for the detection of Auger electron features (peaks) in the secondary electron spectrum that made it one of the most widely used analysers in electron spectroscopy for surface analysis. This picture has been altered in recent years with extensive work on the CHA as a higher
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
83
Figure 3.15 The electron trajectories in a CMA. r2 and r1 are the radii of the outer and inner cylinders, respectively. This inner cylinder is at ground potential and the outer cylinder is provided with a potential V with respect to ground. The sample under investigation is placed at S, which also represents the position of the source of electrons in this diagram. Electrons emitted within an angular range a travel through a mesh-covered aperture and are refocused at F where the distance between S and F is denoted by L
resolution electron energy analyser of more flexible electron optical design. The electron optical principles of the CMA are relatively straightforward. The design involves the use of two co-axial cylinders of radii, r1 and r2 (with r2 > r1 ), whereby the outer cylinder is placed at a voltage (V with respect to ground) while the inner cylinder is earthed; this configuration forms a type of condenser device. As shown in Figure 3.15, electrons leaving a surface at the analyser’s focal point S with energy E, have straight line trajectories in the field free space within the inner cylinder. These then pass through an annular aperture in the wall of the inner cylinder, covered with a high transparency metal mesh, to be deflected by a repulsive field from the outer cylinder causing them to pass through a second mesh-covered annular aperture near the output of the analyser where they focus at F. In this configuration, the field between the two cylinders causes the potential at a distance r (where r2 > r > r1 ) to behave as lnðr/r1 Þ. The focal condition of the analyser then becomes: E¼
eK0 V lnðr2 =r1 Þ
ð3:11Þ
where e is the electron charge and K0 ¼ L/r1 with L the distance between S and F. The CMA analyser, however, is best operated under the second order focusing condition in order to increase its collection efficiency. This becomes clear by examining the relationship between K0
84
INSTRUMENTATION
and the angle of electron emission a from the sample normal. Following Sar-El88 and Seah90, it was found that this occurs when the angle a has a value of 42 18.50 . As pointed out by Hafner et al.85, this configuration is very useful indeed because it allows electrons of a wide range of a values to focus at F for a fixed value of L given by: L ¼ 6:13R1
ð3:12Þ
It is found that, under second order focusing, it is possible to choose a value of K0 that allows a reasonably large range of electron emission angles from the sample to be chosen, a desirable effect that increases the analyser’s sensitivity. However, for small semi-angles a, either side of the angle a there is a range of electron energies, E, that enter the dispersive region. This energy spread will cause a shift in the distance L between the focal points of the analyser F and S, by an amount L. Because the position of the analyser’s detector is normally fixed at F for ease of construction and operation, this geometry defines the positional sensitivity of the sample in this class of analysers – the depth of field L. Following Hafner et al.85 and Seah90, this shift is given by: L ¼ 5:6r1 ðE=EÞ 15:4r1 ðaÞ3 þ 10:3ðE=EÞa
ð3:13Þ
This relationship is significant in the determination of the positioning of the sample at the focus S in order to detect the electrons at the energy specified by Equation (3.11) above. In electron optical terms, the quantity L is the depth of focus of the CMA. As an example, consider an analyser having r1 ¼ 15 mm. A shift of the sample position from S by 1 mm will result in an apparent energy shift of 1000 eV electrons by about 12 eV. This energy shift is in addition to loss of electron signal at the detector. In other words, misplacing the sample away from its correct electron optical position will cause a proportional percentage change in position of the resulting Auger electron peak. This property is the most serious disadvantage of the CMA and care has to be taken in setting up the analyser before any data collection. A procedure for correct setting up the sample position will be outlined below. The relationship above can also be used to estimate the theoretical energy resolution of the CMA. For small a and for very small L this reduces to: E=E ¼ 2:255ðaÞ3 ;
ð3:14Þ
which can be further improved with use of an annular aperture at the CMA exit, as will be shown below.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
85
Assuming isotropic electron emission from the sample, the fraction of electrons that enter the analyser is defined by 2sina a. Thus, for an angle a of 42 18.50 this gives a value for the fraction T of emitted electrons transmitted through the analyser and reaching the detector as T ¼ 1:346a:
ð3:15Þ
Many of the commercial CMA designs have an acceptance angle a ¼ 5 or 6 , which theoretically gives a transmission factor T of about 12 % or 14 % and an energy resolution of 0.37 % or 0.64 %, respectively. It is easy to see therefore that the transmission and the energy resolution of this analyser are strong functions of the acceptance semiangle a. Further inspection of the CMA’s electron optical properties shows that this instrument is limited by spherical aberration, and hence there exists a circle of least confusion on the analyser’s axis short of the image plane. This occurs at a radius of 5.28 r1 ðaÞ2 and leads to a reduction of the coefficient ðaÞ3 by a factor of 4 in the expressions describing the depth of focus and the energy resolution90. By placing a ring slit of width W at this position, Sar-El88 shows that the energy resolution improves to E=E ¼ 0:18W=r1 þ 5:5=4ðaÞ3
ð3:16Þ
In the above case with a semi-angle of 6 , an inner cylinder of 25 mm radius and a slit width of 125 mm, this gives an improved resolution of about 0.25 %. Most CMAs in SAM instruments employ an annular aperture at the analyser’s exit (i.e at r0 in Figure 3.15) in order to improve the energy resolution. Hence, the expression above should be used to estimate the energy resolution of such instruments. As the CMA’s energy window is proportional to the analysis energy, E, it is important to note here that the shapes of any measured energy spectra from a CMA are ENðEÞ versus E and not NðEÞ versus E, where the latter is the energy distribution of the emitted electrons. This is another useful property of this type of analyser, which improves the signal to noise ratio of the high energy, weak intensity, Auger peaks; a useful property when imaging. As described below, a CHA can be used to obtain a spectrum proportional to NðEÞ itself. An important advantage of the CMA, that has not been fully exploited, derives from its collection geometry that spans an azimuthal angle of 2p. Physical Electronics have used a detector which is divided
86
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.16 Diagram of the CMA equipped with a six-channel electron detector, after Gelsthorpe and El Gomati92. An electrostatic lens at the output of the CMA is used to linearise the trajectories of the electrons. Courtesy of A. Gelsthorpe, D. Phil. Thesis, University of York, 2001
into several annuli to improve the obtained signal to noise ratio using appropriate methods of summing the signals from the annuli in the data acquisition software. However, although this in principle can be used to span a range of energies, to the authors’ knowledge this has not been used for this mode of operation. El Gomati and co-workers divided the detector annulus into six segments/channels spanning 360 as shown in Figure 3.16 that gives parallel detection using six angles. This arrangement collects separately electrons emitted from different azimuthal angles and hence can be used to identify and later correct for topographical artefacts in the measured signal91 as shown in Chapter 4. In order to avoid any nonlinearity in the emitted electron trajectories, Gelsthorpe and El Gomati92 used a small lens at the output of the analyser which is electrically connected to the outer cylinder’s voltage. An electron trajectory simulation of low and high energy electrons that exit the output aperture of the CMA are shown in Figure 3.17. This multichannel detector is particularly useful for a spectrometer involving the use of a coaxial electron column, as featured by most CMAs. Another important property of any electron energy analyser is its field of view (FOV), i.e. the maximum area from which the analyser can collect electrons. This is normally defined as the diameter of the area on a homogeneous surface from which the measured signal changes by less
Figure 3.17 A simulation of the electron trajectories of low and high energy electrons as they leave the output aperture of the CMA before being collected by the six-channel detector. Courtesy of A. Gelsthorpe, D. Phil. Thesis, University of York, 2001
88
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.18 Possible sources of internal scattering in a single pass CMA. (a) Electrons emitted within the range a with the correct kinetic energy (corresponding to the pass energy of the analyser) pass through the input aperture and are focused at the detector as indicated in the bottom half of the diagram. Electrons emitted with higher energies than the pass energy of the analyser, as shown in the upper half of the diagram, strike the inner surfaces of the outer cylinder where they generate secondary and back-scattered electrons. Some of the latter electrons may have energies and directions of emission that allow them to reach the electron detector and contribute to the total electron count reaching the external electronics. (b) Simulation of electron trajectories showing the effect of the field trimmers in the generation of internal scattering in a single pass CMA. 1000 eV electrons leaving the sample are shown impinging upon the outer cylinder of a CMA operated with a pass energy of 500 eV. Secondary electrons are simulated with kinetic energies randomly distributed up to the impingement energy. Low energy secondaries are attracted to and reach the inner cylinder but the majority of the higher energy secondaries strike the surfaces of the field trimmers where they generate tertiary electrons that find their way through the exit aperture to the electron detector. Permission of Surface and Interface Analysis and courtesy of El Gomati and El Bakoush96.
than 10 %. The analyser may accept some electrons from a much wider area than this but as they leave the surface further away from the intersection of the optic axis of the analyser with the sample surface the smaller is the fraction that will arrive at the detector. Eagen and
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
89
Sickafus93 have completed a careful study of this property for single pass CMA and found it to be about 200 mm. A detailed study of the transfer function of a CMA has been described by Eagen and Sickafus93 and the FOV of a double pass CMA has been reported by Erikson and Powell94. For quantitative analysis, it is important that data are collected from the sample with the minimum of (and preferably no) interference from other sources in the spectrometer. One such source of noise is internal scattering of electrons that leave the sample and strike the inner surfaces of the various components of the analyser so generating secondary electrons that can add an unwanted contribution to the measured signal. The effects of these internally scattered electrons are to reduce the peak to background ratio of the collected spectrum and complicate the data analysis and quantification process. Seah95 and El Gomati and El Bakush96 have made extensive studies of the possible sources of internal scattering of electrons in single and double pass CMAs. Figure 3.18 depicts the possible sources of internal scattering. All these sources were found not to contribute to the collected spectrum in a single pass CMA, except the field trimmers at the back of the analyser and the final aperture in front of the electron detector. By placing a high transparency mesh that is negatively biased to 10–20 V, the effect of these electrons on the collected spectra can be eliminated or reduced. Placing the sample at the analyser’s focal point turns out to be the most serious disadvantage of this class of analyser. This is due to its small depth of focus. It is found that the sample needs to be placed to within 100 mm of the focal point S (see Figure 3.15) to maintain an elastic peak height of greater than or equal to 90% of its maximum height. This setup procedure must be rigorously followed before any spectrum or image collection takes place.
3.8.3
Concentric Hemispherical Analysers
The CHA was first described by Purcell97 and developed for atomic spectroscopy by Kuyatt and Simpson98. It consists of a pair of concentric metallic surfaces as indicated in Figure 3.19. The surfaces are negative with respect to ground potential and the outer hemisphere is more negative than the inner. The field between the hemispheres causes electrons leaving a point sourced at S to focus onto a point at D with trajectories around the median of radius R0 provided that their kinetic energy is appropriate for the values of V1 and V2 as indicated in
90
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.19 The principles of the CHA. Electrons are velocity analysed using the central force between two concentric hemispherical surfaces at potentials V1 and V2 . The pass energy and the energy resolution are set out in the two boxes
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
91
Figure 3.1999. Using the equations in Figure 3.19 it can be seen, for example, that 500 eV electrons pass on the median trajectory between hemispheres of radius 8 and 10 cm with a potential difference of 416.7 V. With respect to ground potential the inner hemisphere has to be set at 250 V and the outer at 666.7 V. Given a slit width W of 1 mm and an angular spread da of 0.02 rad the energy resolution is 2.6 eV. This analyser would have constant resolving power of 192. As is common with most spectroscopies, the resolution can be improved by reducing the slit width but this improvement is accompanied by a reduction in the number of electrons leaving the slit and travelling towards the detector. Most practical CHAs are used in conjunction with electrostatic lenses that transfer electrons from the sample to the entrance of the analyser at the diameter of the hemispheres and to transfer the energy analysed electrons leaving the slit to a detector. A typical arrangement is indicated in Figure 3.20. The transfer lenses can be designed to offer several advantages: (i) The input lens acts as a buffer between the space where electrons leave a sample that is usually at ground potential to a space where the potential corresponds to the kinetic energy of electrons on the median path around the CHA. Similarly, the output lens acts as a buffer between the space where electrons exit the hemispheres and the space of an electron detector. Such buffering serves the particularly important function of matching the electric fields at the hemisphere entrance and exit planes to the lens fields. This can minimise the distortion away from the hemispherical shape intended for the analyser fields in these regions. (ii) The input lens can be designed to allow the sample to be further away from physical obstructions than it would if the sample was near to the entrance slit of the analyser. This allows access to the sample for electron, ion or atom beams as well as space for other devices such as cleavage attachments. Coxon100 has reported a design in which the sample is as much as 5 cm away from the front end of the input transfer lens. (iii) The input lens can act to retard the electrons in order that they enter the analyser with lower kinetic energies. Since the hemispheres have constant resolving power this means that the energy resolution is smaller and yet the kinetic energy corresponds to that they had when leaving the sample. The retardation can be controlled by varying the potentials on the lens elements so allowing flexibility in the properties of the entire analyser.
92
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.20 A CHA equipped with a four-element input lens and a three-element output lens. The input lens can be operated in constant resolving power or constant energy resolution modes by controlling the potentials applied to its elements and to the hemispheres. The output lens images the output plane of the hemispheres onto the surface of an electron detector such as a channeltron or microchannel plate
(iv) Alternative lens designs can allow the spherical aberrations in the input transfer lens to be exploited101,102 so that the virtual slit width is controlled along with the focusing of the electrons onto the analyser’s entrance plane in order to provide a constant resolution over a wide range of kinetic energies of electrons leaving the sample. This is particularly useful if a position sensitive electron detector is the detector because it allows multi-channel operation (see later) with the same energy resolution in each channel.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
93
Figure 3.21 The CHA in the York MULSAM instrument. For clarity the mumetal shield is not shown and the wiring to the lens elements and hemispheres is not in place. Courtesy of J.C. Greenwood, D.Phil. Thesis, Department of Physics, University of York, 1990
A photograph of a CHA and its lenses together with a position sensitive detector is shown in Figure 3.21. An example of an input lens reported by Greenwood et al.102 and used in the York MULSAM instrument is shown in Figure 3.22. This design
Figure 3.22 An input lens for the hemispheres of the York MULSAM instrument. (a) Lens dimensions. The lens gaps are specified as distances from the sample surface that is 10 mm from the front surface of the lens. The lens gaps are one-tenth of the lens diameter (25 mm). (b) An example of the most extreme path of electrons entering the lens at angle ya and focusing on the entrance plane of the hemispheres. The kinetic energies of electrons in elements 2 and 3 are denoted by E2 and E3 and are varied to maintain the same focal position as the pass energy of the hemispheres, E0 is held constant and the retardation of the lens is changed as a spectrum is acquired. (c) The locus AB of the values of E3 =E0 versus E2 =E0 as the lens retardation is varied. Courtesy of J.C. Greenwood, D.Phil. Thesis, Department of Physics, University of York, 1990
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
95
permits the spectrometer to operate with constant transmission, TðEÞ, and constant energy resolution, E, as the lens retardation is varied and the pass energy, E0 , is held constant. Typically, E is 1 eV for retardations between 50 eV and 2000 eV and a pass energy of 128 eV. This may be regarded as a rather poor resolution for spectroscopy but it is practical for SAM because the sensitivity can be quite high, 1.7 % of the electrons leaving the sample with the appropriate energy reaching the detector. The resolution can be improved for spectroscopy by raising the retardation and lowering the pass energy of the hemispheres. By this means E can be 0.2 eV using a pass energy of 20 eV. The output lens is not so demanding to design as the input lens. The detector has a sensitivity independent of the kinetic energy of the electrons leaving the sample103 provided that the potential at its sensitive surface is arranged to cause electrons arriving there to have a constant kinetic energy. If the hemispheres are operating at constant pass energy this means that the lens is operating at constant retardation. A simple three-element lens104 is sufficient for this task. This arrangement is suitable for a spectrometer that is designed to make measurements at a single energy at one time – a single channel analyser. The CHA can be operated in a multi-channel mode if the detector is position sensitive because the analyser brings electrons near the energy E0 to a focus shifted in the dispersion plane from the median between the hemispheres. This can be exploited to detect several energies simultaneously so speeding up the acquisition of a spectrum or of images at several closely spaced energies. Fifteen channel detection systems have been described by Weightman105 and by Prutton et al.106. In this case it is convenient to place the position sensitive detector near to the output focus of the analyser and the output lens may be dispensed with (see later). As mentioned in the section concerning the CMA, the FOV of the analyser is an important property in the application to microscopy. It is frequently required to collect an Auger image at low magnification in order to obtain an overview of a sample before zooming in to investigate regions of special interest in more detail. The limit to the lowest magnification that can be obtained is usually set by the size of the region of the sample that can deliver electrons detectable after passage through the analyser. As the beam is scanned away from the point where the analyser or input lens axis intersects the sample surface the transmission efficiency of the analyser falls as some electrons are intercepted by the edges of any internal apertures. An example of the effects of this loss of signal as the beam goes off-axis is illustrated for a CHA in
96
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.23 The size of the FoV of the CHA in the York MULSAM instrument. The pass energy was set at 50 eV and the FoV measured using electrons from 50 to 2000 eV kinetic energy using a 64 64 pixel scan of a flat single crystal Cr(110) surface. Reprinted from Peacock et al.108, Copyright (1984), with permission from Elsevier
Figure 3.23. Using the imaging method described by Seah107 a relatively large area of a flat chromium sample was scanned in a 64 64 pixel array of points. If the signal rose above a preselected threshold proportion of the maximum signal for a given kinetic energy leaving the sample, a display of the scan was brightened up. This work has been described by Peacock et al.108 who define the edge of the FOV as the locus of beam positions where the signal from the analyser falls to 80 % of its value at the center. With this instrument the lowest usable magnification was about 10 times. Another important property of an energy analyser is depth of field – that is, the range of distances of the sample from the front end of the entrance lens that causes an Auger peak to appear at the output within acceptable deviations from its known energy and its maximum peak height. In the study of the FOV of the York CHA, Peacock et al.108 also reported such depth of field effects. The shifts in the observed energy of
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
97
an elastic scattering peak as the sample was translated along the axis of the input lens were found to be very small (<1 eV at 1000 eV). Much more important was the fall in height of the elastic peak (and, similarly, Auger peaks) as the sample to lens aperture distance was varied. These authors reported a drop of 10 % in peak height for a 600 mm displacement towards or away from the entrance aperture. Further, especially at energies above about 800 eV, the electron spectrum changed shape for displacements greater than 600 mm. Thus, these authors concluded that this analyser required the sample to be positioned within 200 mm of the intersection of the electron column and input lens axes to ensure an accuracy in integrated Auger currents of 10 %. This is compared with similar properties of other analyser types in a later section of this chapter. In a SAM that necessarily has low beam currents (a few nA) the Auger peak heights are small and the analysis methods need to employ electron counting with shot noise limited statistics in order to keep the frame scan times as low as possible. Any electrons reaching the detector that are additional to those in the spectrum simply add to the background counts under any Auger peaks and contribute to the noise. One such effect is internal scattering – an effect in which electrons striking surfaces inside the analyser generate secondary electrons some of which may reach the detector. This effect has been reported in CHAs by Seah et al.109, Seah and Smith110 and by Greenwood et al.111. Examples of two places in a CHA where internal scattering can arise are shown in Figure 3.24. In both instances shown there, electrons entering the entrance aperture of the input lens having kinetic energies above those that will pass around the hemispheres strike either the last element of the input lens (Figure 3.24(a)) or the inner surface of the outer hemisphere (Figure 3.24(b)). Of course, electrons with higher energies than those passed by the analyser are always present in an electron spectrum and so such internal scattering is always present to some extent and adds background to the ‘true’ electron spectrum. The scattering from the input lens can be reduced by adding an aperture at the output of this lens with a diameter chosen to allow through only those electrons coming to a focus at the hemisphere’s entrance plane. However, some electrons may still enter the gap between the hemispheres and have a direction and velocity adequate to reach the detector. Further, the introduction of such an aperture will modify the equipotentials in this region and cause an increase in the width of the energy window. Fortunately, the energy resolution required for SAM is not as high as is required in many forms of electron spectroscopy because the principal objective is to collect as
98
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.24 Two sources of the contribution of internal scattering to the spectrum. In both cases electrons enter the analyser assembly with kinetic energies above that which will pass around the analyser. (a) Electrons strike the internal surfaces of the input lens and generate secondary electrons some of which enter the volume between the hemispheres in directions and with energies that can reach the output. (b) Electrons above the pass energy strike the outer hemisphere near to the output plane where they generate secondaries that can reach the output
many Auger electrons as possible to maintain an adequate signal to noise ratio. Therefore this degradation in energy resolution is not of practical importance. On the other hand, scattering from the outer hemispheres surface near the exit plane of the hemispheres can be rather more difficult to reduce significantly. In a single channel analyser the energy analysed electrons form a spot at the exit plane but the internally scattered electrons are spread over the entire space between the hemispheres. This analyser can be fitted with an output lens that focuses the spot onto the detector (probably a channel electron multiplier) and rejects most of the internally scattered electrons because they have the wrong directions, positions and energies. However, for a multichannel analyser it is desirable to use the space between the hemispheres at the exit plane as much as possible. This is because electrons with energies slightly different from those with the pass energy are brought to a focus at different positions on this exit plane and this can be exploited by placing a position sensitive electron detector at or near to this plane. Thus, electrons in several energy channels may be detected simultaneously. This speeds up the acquisition of spectra by a factor equal to the number of energy channels that can be collected simultaneously. It also speeds up the acquisition of energy analysed images in
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
99
cases where simultaneously one energy channel can be deployed to collect electrons at or near the Auger peak energy and another channel to collect electrons with energies above the peak to be used for subsequent background subtraction. This mode of operation, if it is to be combined with an output lens to reduce internal scattering effects, presents problems in lens design. These problems arise because the size of the object is a significant fraction of the space between the hemispheres and this has to be imaged onto a similarly sized position sensitive detector whilst rejecting internally scattered electrons and not degrading the image resolution too much due to lens aberrations. In the CHA in the York MULSAM instrument a compromise was struck by using an Einzel lens made with thin metallic sheets between the hemispheres and the position sensitive detector. This compromise left some internal scattering from the hemispheres in the data collected. Possible corrections for this effect are described in Chapter 5.
3.8.4
Other Analyser Types
3.8.4.1 Combined magnetic and electrostatic transfer lenses All electrostatic lens systems suffer from large spherical aberration effects relative to purely magnetic systems with the same focal lengths and acceptance angles. By combining the two lens types into a single transfer lens Walker112 was able to show how some release from the tight constraints of electrostatic lens design could be achieved and acceptance angles could be increased for practical imaging X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) to be carried out. This combination exploited the properties of a single pole-piece magnetic lens just below the sample position as described by Mulvey113. It has the important property that a high proportion of the electrons leaving the sample surface can be collected and energy analysed with, for instance, a CHA. The magnetic and electrostatic lenses need to be cylindrically symmetric about the normal to the sample surface and, for XPS, the incident X-rays strike the surface at oblique incidence in order to avoid striking the transfer lens assembly. As a photoelectron spectrum is scanned both the lens potentials and the magnetic field strength are varied to maintain constant focal properties for the transfer lens. This is practical for X-rays because the incident beam is not deflected by the varying monopole magnetic field. No application of this powerful collection
100
INSTRUMENTATION
and analysis method has been reported for electron excited Auger spectroscopy or imaging presumably because of the difficulty of retaining a constant position of the electron beam on the surface during spectroscopy or providing a controlled scan form of the electron beam during SAM. The subject of energy analysers for imaging XPS has been reviewed by Drummond114,115. The microscope that has demonstrated the highest spatial resolution in SAM images has been built and used by workers at the Universities of Sussex and of Arizona State and is based upon a heavily modified STEM. The instrument is known as MIDAS (Microscope for Imaging, Diffraction and Analysis of Surfaces). It has been reported by Hembree et al.116. Here the magnetic element in the analyser is a paralleliser mounted below the specimen in a magnetic STEM. Scattered electrons are deflected into a CHA whose input axis is perpendicular to the electron optical axis of the STEM. The resolution was demonstrated using oriented silver microcrystallites grown on a silicon (100) substrate117 where an edge resolution of 4 nm was shown. The spatial resolution of the scanning Auger microscope is discussed in Chapter 4.
3.8.4.2 The hyperbolic field analyser (HFA) It is demonstrated above that the sequential acquisition of the data forming an Auger image is a slow process. This is because of the need to obtain adequate precision in the electron counting statistics combined with the serial natures of the scanning process and the setting of the different electron kinetic energies for each Auger peak in the elements of the sample. If the entire spectrum of the electrons leaving the sample could be energy analysed simultaneously then a substantial reduction in the acquisition time could be realised. Thus, an analyser with no smaller acceptance angle than a CMA or a CHA but with simultaneous detection of sufficient energy channels to span all the energies needed for the N Auger peaks characterizing the sample would acquire all the data needed for collection and processing of this data at least N times faster than could those analysers. Since the data for background subtraction would be measured simultaneously with the data for the peak heights this could be 2N or 3N times faster depending on the method of background subtraction. One new analyser capable of this improved speed has been described by Jacka et al.118 and has been called the hyperbolic field analyser (HFA) by them. A related analyser intended for ion spectroscopy has been
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
101
Figure 3.25 The focusing and dispersion of electrons by a hyperbolic field. Reproduced by permission of American Institute of Physics from Jacka et al.118
described by Curtis and Hsieh119. The elements of the HFA are shown in Figure 3.25 and a practical version is shown in Figure 3.26. The electrodes E1 to E6 are provided with potentials that cause the electrostatic field in the region of the electron trajectories to approximate to a hyperbolic form. As a result electrons from the sample are focused onto
Figure 3.26 The construction of a hyperbolic field analyser. Reproduced by permission of American Institute of Physics from Jacka et al.118
102
INSTRUMENTATION
a detector at different positions according to their kinetic energies. The distance x from the entrance aperture of the focal point for electrons of kinetic energy E is given by x ¼ kE1=2
ð3:17Þ
and the device operates as an energy analyser with resolving power that increases as E1=2 with increasing E for a constant increment E. More recent versions of the HFA use a detector assembly that consists of a pair of microchannel plates followed by a phosphor screen followed by a position sensitive detector made with a linear array of 1024 photodetectors. The properties of this analyser are compared with other types in a separate section below.
3.8.5
Comparison of Analyser Types
It is clear from the discussion above that the performance of the energy analyser is critical if the shortest data acquisition time is to be obtained for a given signal to noise ratio. In order to compare analysers it is useful to devise a figure of merit containing only parameters universal to all analysers. Such a figure of merit has been devised by Kruit and Venables120 with the objective of optimising the design of the electron column and the analyser as a pair of components. Another figure of merit has been reported by Seah et al.121 using measurements of the signal to noise ratio and the peak to background ratio of the Cu LMM peak near 920 eV. This figure of merit is useful for comparison of the performance of different instruments. In order to give a simple estimate of an analyser’s suitability for Auger imaging, another figure of merit F is F¼
N
E
ð3:18Þ
where N is the number of energy channels measured simultaneously,
is the fraction of 2p steradians accepted by the analyser and E is the energy resolution of a single channel. This definition of F puts emphasis upon the importance of obtaining as much signal as possible whilst allowing that the analyser must also be used for electron spectroscopy for which energy resolution is important. It has been used to compare analyser types in Table 3.3.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
103
Table 3.3 A comparison of various types of electron energy analyser. N is the number of energy channels detected simultaneously. is the solid angle subtended at the sample by the entrance aperture of the analyser. The CMA is a constant resolving power device so the energy window is quoted here for electrons with 500 eV kinetic energy. The parallel detector CMA resolves 6 different angles simultaneously not 6 energies.
N Single channel CHA (MULSAM) 1 Parallel detector CHA (MULSAM) 15 Single channel CMA 1 Parallel detector CMA 6
O (%)
Figure E of merit (eV) (eV1)
Working Field Depth distance of view of field (lm) (lm) (lm)
0.5
1.0
0.005
10
200
500
0.5 16 16
1.0 2.0 2.0
0.075 0.08 0.48
10 12 12
200 150 150
500 50 50
The data in Table 3.3 indicate that the best figure of merit is for the 6 channel CMA because of the large collection angle combined with 6 channel detection. However, this may not be the only criterion for choice of analyser. The CMA is a large structure that is close to the sample whereas the transfer lens for a CHA is a smaller structure that allows other equipment into the space near to the sample. Secondly, the depth of focus of the CHA transfer lens is greater than that of a CMA, a fact that allows a larger tolerance in the location of the sample.
3.9 3.9.1
ELECTRON DETECTORS Faraday Cups
A direct measurement of the current in an electron beam is possible by focusing the beam to enter a Faraday cup. This can be as simple as a deep hole bored into an electrically isolated piece of metal with the beam current measured as the current flowing to ground. The design of Faraday cups has been investigated by Gilmore and Seah122. The accuracy with which the beam current can be determined depends upon the fraction of the total secondary electron emission from the inner surfaces of the hole that can escape back into the vacuum system. This can be reduced if the cup is biased with a positive potential with respect to ground so preventing the escape of many of the secondary electrons. Seah and Gilmore show that if the beam enters a hole of depth
104
INSTRUMENTATION
more than five times the diameter that is biased by more than þ30 V with respect to ground the beam current can be measured to better than 1 % for beams with energies below 25 keV. This precision is adequate for most spectroscopic and quantitative imaging work. The minimum beam current that can be measured with this method depends upon the sensitivity of the current measuring device and the leakage current flowing through the insulation between the Faraday cup and ground. Minimum currents of 1012 A are usually possible. This kind of Faraday cup can usually form an integral part of the sample attachment components on the specimen manipulator. Alternatively it may be a separate component that can be moved from a carrousel storing other samples in situ and placed in the normal position where a sample can be mounted.
3.9.2
Channel Electron Multipliers
If the electron current leaving the analyser is lower than about 10 pA some form of amplification is needed for measurement to be made in a reasonable time. Channel electron multipliers (CEMs) are useful for this task. Sketches of two commercial CEMs are shown in Figure 3.27. They
Figure 3.27 Two commercial channel electron multiplier types. (a) A design by Galileo. (b) A design by Mullard. From Seah103 courtesy of Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
105
are fabricated from a lead glass treated such that it has a secondary electron yield of about 2. A potential difference of usually between 1 kV and 3 kV is applied across the device. Electrons striking the inner surface of the horn at the front of the device generate secondary electrons that are accelerated into the curved tubular channel by the field in the horn. As they pass down the channel they collide with the wall where more secondaries are generated. Thus a cascade of electrons emerges from the end of the channel where it can be detected. Since a pulse of electrons is produced at the output due to a single electron striking the horn then it is possible to count individual electrons reaching the horn. In the pulse counting mode the potential difference applied across the CEM is usually about 3 kV and the gain of the device is about 108. If the arrival rate of electrons is above about 106 s1 then the pulse counting mode becomes very nonlinear and analog detection of the output electron current is used with the CEM operated with a gain of between 1000 and 10 000. The efficiency, gain and linearity of CEMs for both pulse counting and analog modes has been reported by Seah103 and by Seah and Tosa123. The average gain per electron, G, is related to the secondary electron coefficients of the surface of the horn, dh , and the inner surface of the channel, dc by: G ¼ dh ðEÞdm c
ð3:19Þ
In this expression E is the kinetic energy of the electrons striking the horn and m is the number of collisions of electrons with the channel wall as they form the cascade. The number of electrons emitted at the horn surface is dependent upon E so, for constant gain of the CEM as the analyser sweeps a spectrum or is switched to acquire a different energy analysed image, electron optical measures must be taken to ensure that E is kept constant. The yield dh can be kept high and constant if E is constant and in the range 100–200 eV. The linearity of the CEM has been studied by Seah and Tosa123 who found that G is constant up to count rates equivalent of up to about 10 % of the standing current flowing through the wall of the CEM due to the potential difference across it. The first mechanism for nonlinearity arises in the pulse counting circuits where a pulse arriving during the time required to handle a previous pulse is ignored. This nonextended counting type is discussed in Chapter 5 and can be corrected to some extent by calibrating the CEM gain as a function of input electron arrival rate and establishing a ‘dead time’ for the counter. The second nonlinearity is fundamental to the CEM design. If the electron arrival
106
INSTRUMENTATION
Frequency
Electron pulses
Noise and Interference Pulses
Pulse Height Threshold
Figure 3.28 A sketch of the pulse height distribution reaching the electronics detecting and shaping electron pulses from a CEM. At low pulse heights there can be a distribution arising from noise and interference coupled to the wires from the CEM or MCP to the electronics outside the vacuum system. The true pulse height distribution due to electrons arriving at the CEM needs to be larger than the noise distribution as indicated. The electronics contains a discriminator that has a threshold pulse height above which the true electron pulses are amplified and shaped for counting
rate becomes too high the amplified electron current near to the end of the CEM becomes so high that depletion of electrons occurs from the wall current. The gain then falls sharply as the flux of input electrons is increased – eventually falling to zero. The pulse heights leaving the CEM are not constant but, because of the statistical nature of the cascade of electrons down the channel, they arrive at the electronics with a distribution of heights. This distribution is indicated schematically in Figure 3.28. Other pulses can arrive at the output due to ion feedback. This occurs when an atom reaches the output end of the CEM where it is ionised by the electron cascade emerging there. The positive ion so created is accelerated down the channel in the opposite direction to the electron cascade. The CEM manufacturers minimise this effect by curving the channel as can be seen in Figure 3.27(b). This curvature allows the relatively
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
107
massive ions to travel only a short distance down the wall where they are adsorbed. The long-term stability of the gain of a CEM depends upon both the vacuum and temperature conditions during system bakeout and the ambient gas pressure during operation. Since the gain of the device depends upon the secondary electron yield at its internal surfaces it is not surprising that the gain will change if contamination occurs. This is not likely to be a problem if the CEM is maintained in UHV during operation. If, however, gases are admitted to the microscope for modification of the surface of a sample under study then the analyst needs to be aware that the CEM gain may change and so system sensitivity may alter. During bakeout the CEM will reach the same temperature as the walls of the vacuum system and this may be high enough for the composition of the electron emitting surfaces to change so changing the gain of the device. For this reason most CEM manufacturers recommend that bakeout temperatures should not exceed 180 C. This low bakeout temperature leads to long bakeout times to reduce water vapor content in the walls and the vacuum – maybe several tens of hours. If a sample introduction vacuum lock is available on the equipment then new samples can be introduced without the need for another bakeout so reducing the need for bakeouts to the occasions when the internal components of the microscope need to be serviced or changed.
3.9.3
Microchannel Plates
If a number of CEMs are combined in an integrated array then a detector is available for amplifying the intensity distribution in an electron image. This is the microchannel plate (MCP). An example of the construction of an MCP is shown in Figure 3.29. It is a thin, usually circular, glass plate with metallic alloy electrodes on both faces that are used to apply a potential difference across all the channels that penetrate the plate in its thin direction. The channels can be specified to have diameters in the range 10–25 mm. The insulating properties of the glass limit the maximum potential difference that can be applied across the plate to about 1600 V. They are typically operated with a potential difference of near 1000 V for which the channels have an electron gain of about 104. In order to achieve gains comparable with those obtainable from CEMs a pair of MCPs can be used sequentially so realising gains of about 108. For energy analysis they are combined with a
108
INSTRUMENTATION
Figure 3.29
Diagram of the structure of a multi-channel plate electron multiplier
position sensitive detector that enables electron charge pulses associated with particular kinetic energies of the electrons arriving at the MCP pair to be detected. In the York MULSAM instrument the position sensitive detector is an array of 15 gold strips on a sapphire disk with the central strip aligned to receive electrons passing round the central trajectory through the hemispheres. The structure of this detector array is indicated in Figure 3.30. To reduce the effects of ion feedback in two MCPs used in cascade the manufacturers incline the channels at a small angle (typically 13 ) to the surface of each plate. The two plates are then assembled with their channels in opposite directions so reducing the probability of a positive ion traveling down channels in both plates. The stability of the gain of MCPs and the limitations on bakeout temperatures are very similar to those described above for CEMs. Assembly requires somewhat more care than used for CEMs because it is easy to block the channels with small dust particles from the laboratory atmosphere. Recommended practice is to change, repair or modify the detector assembly whilst in a dust free clean room.
3.9.4
SEM, BSE and EDX Detectors
As already mentioned it is very useful to equip a SAM with UHV versions of the detectors often found in conventional SEMs. The secondary electron emission and the sample absorption current are both useful for speedy image acquisition and to help relate the
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
109
Figure 3.30 The 15-channel detector in the York MULSAM instrument. A, gold plated electrical contact disks; CP, the two MCPs; C, ceramic spacers; D, 15-strip detector array; H, detector mount; P, aperture plate that also clamps the assembly together; G, aperture plate covered with metallic mesh reducing potential penetration into the CHA. Courtesy of J.C. Greenwood, D.Phil. Thesis, Department of Physics, University of York, 1990
appearance of the sample to that observed in preliminary work in an SEM. The characteristic X-ray emission is powerful for identifying the elements present inside the solid – an observation that is often complementary to the Auger imaging that reveals what is present at or very near to the surface itself. Some detectors for these signals are described in the books by Wells18 and Reimer1. However these designs are not usually compatible with the UHV requirements of a surface analytical instrument. UHV versions of the well-known Everhart and Thornley124 SEM detector are commercially available. They usually consist of a positively biased grid facing the sample behind which is a scintillator biased even more positively to accelerate electrons and cause optical emission. The light so generated is coupled via a UHV window or a light pipe to the photocathode of a light sensitive device such as a photomultiplier. A more compact arrangement is to follow the grid with a channeltron. This requires only the electrical signal to be conveyed to the laboratory
110
INSTRUMENTATION
as opposed to an optical path of some kind. Such a CEM detector has a long life in the UHV environment of a SAM. A high current (low electrical resistance), analog CEM is usually employed in this application because the secondary electron yield from the sample and the high collection efficiency of this detector combined with the high beam current in a SAM mean that secondary electron currents as high as 109 A may reach the detector. A simple electrical modification to the CEM electron detector is to bias the grid positively by Vb with respect to the potential of the field electron source in the gun of the microscope (the potential of the sample) so repelling electrons with kinetic energies less than Ep eVb . The current from this detector contains both elastically scattered electrons and those that have lost less energy than eVb in their scattering by the sample. It is thus a loss electron signal that can provide a useful indication of the atomic number of the material below the surface. The use of this detector has been described by Barkshire et al.125. Another UHV compatible detector for fast image acquisition and for obtaining both topographical and atomic number contrast of subsurface material is a back-scattered electron (BSE) device described by Walker et al.126. The various types of BSE detectors are described by both Reimer1 and Wells18. These detectors form an electrical signal from all the electrons with kinetic energies above some threshold that may be set by the design of the sensor. A sketch of a UHV compatible, planar, p–n diode device[1] installed in the York MULSAM instrument is shown in Figure 3.31126. It consists of four quadrants of a circular silicon structure consisting of a planar diode about 2 mm below the free surface that is exposed to the electrons scattered from the sample. It has a hole at its center through which the electron beam passes onto its way to the sample. This structure is sensitive to electrons with kinetic energies above about 2 keV. Each BSE reaching the depletion layer of the p–n junction generates electron-hole pairs that are swept out of the device with a small bias across the junction. The current so generated is amplified and used as a signal related to the number of BSEs leaving the sample. If the signals from each quadrant are added then the total signal reveals changes in the average atomic number Z in the region of the sample immediately underneath the surface. This total signal increases as Z in the region struck by the beam increases. If the outputs [1]
Developed from a sensor supplied by KE Developments Ltd, The Mount, Toft, Cambridge CB3 7RL, UK.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
111
Figure 3.31 The UHV BSE detector in the York MULSAM instrument. Plan and side views. 1, the p–n diode; 2, gold conductors; 3, gold coated phosphor bronze pins; 4, fine gold wires carrying the signals from the detectors; 5, stainless steel packing plate; 6, tantalum shield; 7, ceramic base plate; 8, stainless steel base plate; 9, machinable glass ceramic with tapped holes for pins. Courtesy of J.C. Greenwood, D.Phil. Thesis, Department of Physics, University of York, 1990
from the detectors are subtracted the difference signal reveals contrast due to the inclination of the sample to surface to the incident beam direction127. This is a valuable resource in Auger microscopy because it enables the separation of the chemical contrast in the SAM images from contrast due to backscattering coefficient variations in the material underneath the surface as well as contrast in an Auger image due to variations in the angle of incidence of the electron beam due to the surface topography. These matters are discussed in more detail in Chapter 6. Many conventional SEMs are equipped with an analytical facility using the detection of characteristic X-rays excited in the sample by the electron beam. This is a valuable method for the chemical analysis and chemical imaging of the sub-surface region of the sample. A common form of detector for energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) detection is a silicon crystal doped with lithium – Si(Li). This detector also results in the generation of electron–hole pairs due to the X-rays ionising lithium
112
INSTRUMENTATION
atoms. The number of electron–hole pairs generated is proportional to the energy of each X-ray photon striking the detector and so the spectrum of X-rays leaving the sample can be observed by carrying out pulse height analysis (often, less transparently, called multi-channel analysis) of the pulses leaving the detector. This detector needs to be maintained at liquid nitrogen temperatures at all times to prevent diffusion of the lithium. The normal procedure is to keep the Si(Li) in a subsidiary vacuum system that is pumped at all times and which has a thin window (usually beryllium) to admit the X-rays to the detector. This requirement is difficult when it is to be used in a UHV system. One solution to this problem is to withdraw the detector using flexible bellows so that it is outside the bakeout region during the baking process. This is not a very desirable solution because, as well as the assembly being rather large and clumsy, the detector is contaminated by ambient gases in the higher pressure residual atmosphere and, because it is cold, the gas molecules stick to the detector surface or any thin X-ray window in front of it. When the detector is in its normal operating position for analysis these contaminants may be desorbed from its surfaces by any scattered electrons and there is a line of sight to the sample surface that may become contaminated itself. This problem has
Figure 3.32 The UHV EDX detector in the York MULSAM instrument. The beryllium window is 12 mm thick and is sealed to the stainless steel housing using a compressed gold wire. The inner shield T3 reaches a temperature of about 70 C when the outer jacket T1 is being baked at 250 C. Normal bakeout is at 180 C. Reproduced by permission of IOP Publishing Ltd from El Gomati et al.128
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
113
been avoided by El Gomati et al.128 by surrounding the detector assembly with an inner copper heat shield in addition to the normal internal heat shield. The outer is constructed with normal bakeable stainless steel. This design is shown in Figure 3.32. The X-ray window is a beryllium window 12 mm thick that is UHV sealed to a stainless steel outer with a thin gold wire gasket. This detector can be kept in the normal analytical position during system bakeout and reaches only 70 C when the bakeout temperature is 250 C. A photograph of the arrangement of detectors around the sample as installed in the York MULSAM instrument is shown in Figure 3.33. This
Figure 3.33 The detectors as they are arranged around the sample in the York MULSAM instrument. The sample and its manipulator normally can be seen left of center but have been removed to show the detectors for this illustration. A, the transfer lens for the CHA; B, the Si(Li) EDX detector; C, the ion gun for cleaning and beveling; D, the BSE quadrant detectors. The electron beam comes through the hole in the center; E, the SEM detector. Courtesy of R.H. Roberts, D.Phil. Thesis, Department of Physics, University of York, 1998
114
INSTRUMENTATION
is intended to illustrate one way in which several detectors can be disposed around the sample. The sample manipulator, together with the sample, would normally be seen in this view appearing from the left hand side but it has been removed to reveal the detectors in more detail.
3.10 ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS 3.10.1
Introduction
The design of the entire Auger microscope involves not only the vacuum components but also the analog and digital systems used to detect, condition and record the output signals from the various detectors that may be in the vacuum system. Further, electronic systems are needed to control various electron column functions such as the beam energy and focusing, the deflection of the electron beam to provide a scan across the sample surface and the correction of any astigmatism in the column. The energy analyser usually has several electron optical elements that have to be provided with potentials setting the range of kinetic energies of electrons entering the analyser that will successfully reach an electron detector. Finally, as described above, there may be other detectors in the instrument – a secondary electron detector, a BSE detector or a characteristic X-ray detector for instance – all of which may require control voltages and amplification and/or signal conditioning and which have special requirements as to sensitivity, input and output impedances and stability. These electronics design considerations are not dealt with here as they can be found in a wide variety of published texts. Rather, some considerations of the necessary noise and stability relevant to microscopy are outlined below. The data acquisition functions are usually handled by a digital computer equipped with an instrument control interface to the microscope. Various issues arise such as should standalone or networked computer systems be used? Do the data quantities lead to a requirement for data compression facilities? Should data acquisition be separated from data visualisation and processing? Since the data are often four dimensional – measured signal as a function of electron kinetic energy, and coordinates of the position on the sample struck by the electron beam, SðE; x; yÞ – are there data visualisation issues presenting any challenges? There is some discussion of these matters later in this chapter.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
3.10.2
115
High Voltage Supplies
The kinetic energy of the focused electron beam that is scanned over the sample surface is usually established by the potential difference between the sample (that is at, or very near, ground potential) and the electron source – often a field electron emitter. For an electrostatic column this means that the power supplies providing the extraction, focusing and astigmatism correction potentials are most conveniently organised to have their common rail at the potential corresponding to the beam energy. An example of the arrangement of power supplies for an electrostatic column is shown in Figure 3.34. For safety reasons, and to minimise the coupling of main supply frequency interference to the generally rather long cables between the power supplies and the column elements themselves, the supplies are usually in a single screened case and the cables are surrounded by a grounded screen. The most sensitive supply as far as the effects of noise and ripple are concerned is that providing the scan voltages and the corrections for astigmatism in the column. This is because the scan and astigmatism electrodes cause deflection of the electron beam at the sample and so noise and ripple cause degradation of the spatial resolution. For fast scanning of the sample, the bandwidth of the connections to the deflectors has to be one of the highest in the entire system and the capacitance of the connecting cables has to be kept as low as possible whilst maintaining good screening from external sources. The supplies determining the beam energy and column focusing are not so critical because the energy of Auger peaks is independent of the beam energy and the focus is not a sensitive function of the potentials on those electrodes. They are often computer controlled. The supplies heating a SFE source and extracting the electrons for delivery to the rest of the column are floating on the beam energy supply and require very high stability because the stability of the emission from the Schottky source is a critical function of the tip temperature and the emission current is a fast function of the extractor–tip potential difference. Filament current stability of better than 10 mA in 2 A is essential and the extractor potential difference should typically be constant to better than 0.1 V in 2000 V if the beam current is to be constant to better than 1 % over 10 or more hours. Similarly, the beam voltage supply should be stable to 1 part in 105.
116
INSTRUMENTATION
Vd
Vfil
Vs
Ve
Vg
Vo
Vp
Figure 3.34 A power supply arrangement for an electron column. The sample is shown as grounded although there may be a nanoammeter in the grounding wire to measure the sample absorption current. Vp is the beam energy supply. Vfil is the tip heating supply for a Schottky source. Vs is the suppressor supply providing rejection of thermionically emitted electrons. Ve is the extractor supply accelerating electrons out of the FE tip. Vg is the supply for the potentials on the gun lens. Vd is the supply to deflect, scan and correct for astigmatism. Vo is the supply for the potential on the objective lens
3.10.3
Energy Analyser Supplies
An example for a configuration of power supplies for a CHA with a four-element transfer lens and a multi-channel detector (MCD) is shown in Figure 3.35. The stability, the noise and interference and the slew rates of these supplies are important.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
-
V2
+
-
V3
+
117
AMPS
-
V4
+ +
-
VCHA ++
- VP
VMCP -
VOH VIH
+
Figure 3.35 A power supply arrangement for a CHA with a four-element transfer lens and a multi-channel plate plus position sensitive detector. V2 , V3 and V4 are the supplies for the second, third and fourth elements of the transfer lens. V2 and V3 may be nonlinear functions of the analysis energy eVP . In which case they may each consist of two programmable power supplies in series – one determining an offset voltage that is constant for a given analyser pass energy and the other that provides a nonlinear potential maintaining focus for the input lens as Vp is varied. VMCP provides the potential difference across the multi-channel plate as well as a power supply biasing the front face of the MCP in order that electrons strike it with a kinetic energy independent of the analysis energy
Unlike the supplies for the column the analyser requires the potentials on its elements to be changed quickly as a spectrum or a set of images are acquired. Delays involved with the speed of response to a computer controlled input to a supply or to the time required for a potential to reach its intended value at an electrode both add to the data acquisition time. These delays can be avoided by using supplies that operate as high
118
INSTRUMENTATION
voltage operational amplifiers that have high bandwidths and by careful choice or design of the capacitance in the cables from the supplies to the analyser electrodes. The former is usually specified by the slew rate of the supplies – a number that specifies the rate at which the output can be changed. Slew rates of about 106 Vs1 can be achieved[2] in supplies that provide up to several kV. It is worth noting that the combination of a high output impedance in a power supply plus a high capacitance in the interconnecting cable can introduce an unacceptably high time constant for a potential to reach its intended value. Since the voltages being handled are quite high it is not unusual for readily available supplies to have high output impedances. The noise and interference is particularly important on the hemisphere potentials because it can degrade the energy resolution as well as adding noise to the output signal. This can normally be kept to below 1 mV peak to peak by careful attention to the screening of cable both outside and inside the vacuum system. The stability of these supplies is important if long acquisition times are to be used. This may be necessary, for example, in order to search for a feature in a spectrum with a low peak to background ratio or for a minority element in an Auger image. Stabilities of the order of 10 mV h1 C1 are useful for acquisition times that are (exceptionally) of the order of several hours.
3.10.4
Sensor Signal Conditioning
The charge pulses (containing about 1:6 1011 C) leaving the MCD need to be changed into square pulses at an appropriate source impedance for counting. This can be done, for instance with a single integrated circuit chip[3] in each channel that contains a charge-tovoltage converter and a discriminator. For single channel electron counting, of course only one such chip is needed. For analog detection a high gain, low noise, preamplifier is required. Whichever of these signal conditioning devices is needed, it is mounted close to the air side of the vacuum flange carrying the signals out of the vacuum system in order both to reduce interference and additional stray capacitance. The outputs of these devices can then be processed by pulse counting or by analog to digital conversion (ADC) in a control computer. ½2
For example, Kepco OPS2000 from Kepco Inc., 131–138 Sanford Avenue, Flushing, NY 11352, USA. [3] For example, Amptek Inc., 6 De Angelo Drive, Bedford, MA 01730, USA.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
119
Analog signals from an SEM detector, a specimen current amplifier or an electron energy loss detector can be amplified by small preamplifiers again mounted near to the corresponding feedthroughs and then prepared for measurement by ADCs or voltage-to-frequency converters. The signals from an EDX system are somewhat different in that the signal conditioning is normally supplied integral with the Si(Li) detector inside the detector cryostat and the output is a square pulse whose height is proportional to the energy of the X-ray photon that was sensed. This requires the use of a pulse height analyser (PHA) in order to display the X-ray spectrum. This is a ‘parallel’ device in the sense that it processes every X-ray photon as it arrives at the Si(Li) sensor and the whole spectrum can be observed as it is acquired, the signal to noise ratio improving steadily as the acquisition time increases. This kind of detection is possible with an extra card and software in the control computer[4].
3.10.5
Computer Systems
Many modern desktop personal computers have the speed and power to control an electron microscope and to acquire the data from several different detectors even if hundreds of megabytes of data are to be handled. Further, current operating systems (for instance Linux or Windows) can be used to control all the functions of a microscope and to acquire the data from a multi-detector SAM instrument. The control functions can be handled by cards added to the computer itself or they can be by separate electronic systems in an interfacing unit such as is available in NIM or CAMAC modules often used in particle and nuclear physics experiments. The software writing for such a system is a major task and this is often supplied by the manufacturers of SAM instruments or by third party suppliers[5]. It is advantageous from the analysts’ point of view to separate the control and acquisition functions for the microscope from the data analysis, display and reporting functions. This point has been stressed by Fathers et al.129 who pointed out that these are ‘very different functions done at a different pace and in a different atmosphere’. Saxton and Koch130 describe how two independent computers can each be optimised
[4]
For example, Oxford Instruments Ltd, Halifax Rd, High Wycombe, HP12 3SE, UK. For example, Interface Analysis Centre, Olbury House, 121 St Michael’s Hill, Bristol BS2 8BS, UK; RBD Enterprises Inc., 563 SW 13th St, Suite 201, Bend, OR 97702, USA. [5]
120
INSTRUMENTATION
for their particular pattern of use. This requirement is especially important in the analysis and interpretation of multi-image sets because the analyst may wish to have continuous access to a data set whilst acquisition is in progress for further data. This objective is realisable by using two or more computers in a local area network with one machine being dedicated to control and acquisition. It remains of practical value for the control computer to have limited capability for display of results as they are acquired and some simple facilities, such as data smoothing and zooming in to examine limited regions of the data. These resources assist with the decision as to retention and longer term storage of the data or their abandonment or repetition of the acquisition. Acceptable data can then be transferred across the network for storage or archiving elsewhere and subsequent analysis and interpretation. Detailed considerations of the choice of computer configurations for SAM can be found in the D.Phil. thesis by Kenny131.
REFERENCES 1. L. Reimer, Scanning Electron Microscopy (Springer, Berlin, 1998). 2. D. Briggs and M. P. Seah, Practical Surface Analysis. Volume 2 – Ion and Neutral Spectroscopy (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1992). 3. M. G. Dowsett and R. Collins, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A354, 2713 (1996). 4. K. Wittmaack, in 40th Scottish Universities Summer School in Physics, edited by A. G. Fitzgerald, B. E. Storey and D. Fabian (Institute of Physics, Dundee, 1992), p. 351. 5. L. M. Brown, Journal de Physique IV 3, 2073 (1993). 6. N. D. Browning, I. Arslan, P. Moeck and T. Topuria, Physics Status Solidi-Basic Research 227, 229 (2001). 7. K. F. J. Heinrich and D. E. Newbury, Electron Probe Quantitation (Plenum Press, New York, 1991). 8. S. J. B. Reed, Electron Probe Microanalysis (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1993). 9. V. D. Scott and G. Love, Quantitative Electron Probe Microanalysis (Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1983). 10. A. J. Bevolo, in Scanning Electron Microscopy, edited by O. Johari (Om Johari, Bristol, 1985), Vol. 4, p. 1449. 11. M. M. El Gomati and J. A. D. Matthew, Journal of Microscopy, 147, 137 (1987). 12. E. Paparazzo, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 143, 219 (2005). 13. O. Krivanek, Ultramicroscopy 28, 118 (1989). 14. D. B. Williams and D. E. Newbury, Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics 62, 161 (1984).
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
121
15. E. Bauer, T. Duden, H. Pinkvos, H. Poppa and K. Wurm, Magnetism and Magnetic Materials 156, 1 (1996). 16. E. Bauer, Journal of Physics – Condensed Matter 13, 11391 (2001). 17. P. W. Hawkes and E. Kasper, Principles of Electron Optics (Academic Press, London, 1989). 18. O. C. Wells, A. Boyde, E. Lifshin and A. Rezanowich, Scanning Electron Microscopy (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1974). 19. R. C. Gonzalez and P. Wintz, Digital Image Processing (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA, 1982). 20. W. Niblack, Digital Image Processing (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1986). 21. J. G. Moik, Digital Processing of Remotely Sensed Images (NASA Special Publications, Washington, DC, 1980). 22. D. E. Newbury, Scanning Electron Microscopy 1, 71 (1981). 23. D. S. Bright, D. E. Newbury, R. B. Marinenko, E. B. Steel and R. L. Myklebust, Journal of Metals 40, 57 (1988). 24. C. Jeanguillaume and C. Colliex, Ultramicroscopy 28, 252 (1989). 25. P. L. King, R. Browning, P. Pianetta, I. Lindau, M. Keenlyside and G. Knapp, Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology A 7, 3301 (1989). 26. M. M. El Gomati, I. R. Barkshire, J. C. Greenwood, P. G. Kenny, R. Roberts and M. Prutton, Compositional Imaging in Scanning Auger Microscopy (American Microanalytical Society, San Fransisco, 1992). 27. M. Prutton, in Quantitative Microbeam Analysis, edited by A. G. Fitzgerald, B. E. Storey and D. Fabian (Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol, 1993), p. 43. 28. M. Prutton, Microscopy, Microanalysis and Microstructures 6, 289 (1995). 29. M. Prutton, I. R. Barkshire, P. G. Kenny, R. H. Roberts and M. Wenham, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A 354, 2683 (1996). 30. M. Prutton, D. K. Wilkinson, P. G. Kenny and D. L. Mountain, Applied Surface Science 144–145, 1 (1999). 31. N. Bonnet, Journal of Microscopy 190, 2 (1998). 32. N. Bonnet, Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics 114, 1 (2000). 33. P. A. Redhead, J. P. Hobson and E. V. Kornelsen, The Physical Basis of Ultra-high Vacuum (Chapman and Hall, London, 1968). 34. A. Chambers, Modern Vacuum Physics (Chapman and Hall/CRC, London, 2004). 35. A. W. Czanderna, C. J. Powell and T. E. Madey, Specimen Handling, Preparation and Treatments in Surface Characterization (Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, 1998). 36. J. B. Hudson, An Introduction to Surface Science (Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston, 1992). 37. G. A. Somorjai, Introduction to Surface Chemistry and Catalysis (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, New York, 1994). 38. A. Chambers, R. K. Fitch and B. S. Halliday, Basic Vacuum Technology (Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol, 1998). 39. N. C. MacDonald, Applied Physics Letters 16, 76 (1970). 40. M. E. Haine and P. A. Einstein, British Journal of Applied Physics 3, 40 (1952). 41. A. N. Brores, in 5th International Conference on Ion and Laser Beam Science and Technology (Electrochemical Society, New York, 1972), p. 3. 42. H. Boersch, Zeitschrift fur Physik 139, 115 (1954). 43. J. M. Lafferty, Journal of Applied Physics 22, 299 (1951).
122
INSTRUMENTATION
44. A. N. Brores, Journal of Physics E: Scientific Instruments 2, 273 (1969). 45. H. Ahmed, in Electron Microscopy, edited by O. Johari (Om Johari, Bristol, 1972), Vol. 14, p. 10. 46. R. Shimizu, Y. Kataoka, S. Kawai and T. Tanaka, Applied Physics Letters 27, 113 (1975). 47. S. Zaima, M. Sase, H. Adachi et al. Journal of Physics D 13, 47 (1980). 48. R. H. Fowler and L. Nordheim, Proceedings of The Royal Society (London) A119, 173 (1928). 49. A. V. Crewe, J. Wall and L. M. Weller, Journal of Applied Physics 39, 5861 (1968). 50. D. Swann and K. C. A. Smith, in Scanning Electron Microscopy, edited by O. Johari (Om Johari, Chicago, IL, 1973), p. 176 SEM Inc., Chicago, USA. 51. G. Todd, H. Poppa and L. Veneklasen, Thin Solid Films 57, 213 (1979). 52. M. M. El Gomati, in Electron Microscopy and Analysis 1983 (Institute of Physics, Guildford, 1983), Vol. 1, p. 489. 53. R. Shimizu, Y. Katraoka and H. Hashimoto, Comparison of Emission Stability from various Tungsten planes. Ed. H. Hashimoto (Osaka University, 1973), p. 403. 54. L. W. Swanson and N. A. Martin, Journal of Applied Physics 46, 2029 (1975). 55. R. H. Good and E. Muller, Handbuch der Physik 21, 178 (1956). 56. W. P. Dyke and W. W. Dolan, Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics 8, 89 (1956). 57. L. W. Swanson and A. E. Bell, Advances in Electronics and Electron Physics 32, 193 (1973). 58. J. Orloff, Handbook of Charged Particle Optics (CRC, New York, 1997). 59. C. A. Spindt, I. Brodie, K. Humphrey and E. R. Westerberg, Journal Applied Physics 47, 5248 (1976). 60. J. R. Cleaver, Journal of Electronics 38, 513 (1975). 61. J. C. Wiesner, Field electron emission, D.Phil. Thesis (University of California, 1970). 62. L. Swanson, Personal Communication (1981). 63. R. D. Young, Physical Review 113, 110 (1959). 64. R. D. Young and E. Muller, Physical Review 113, 115 (1959). 65. A. G. Van Oostrom, Performance Computations for a High-resolution Retarding Field Electron Analyser (Philips, Eindhoven, 1966), p. 102. 66. A. D. Cumming and K. C. A. Smith, in Microcurrent Engineering, edited by A. Brores (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1978), p. 22. 67. L. W. Swanson and G. A. Schwind, Handbook of Charged Particls Optics, edited by J. Orloff (CRC Press, Boca Raton, New York, 1977), p 77. 68. F. Charbonnier, Applied Surface Science 94/5, 26 (1996). 69. L. Veneklasen, N. Yew and J. Wiesner, in International Conference on Ion and Laser beam Science and Technology (Electrochemical Society, New Jersey, 1979), p. 11. 70. L. Swanson and L. C. Crouser, Journal of Applied Physics 40, 4741 (1969). 71. R. Browning, P. J. Bassett, M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton, Proceedings of The Royal Society (London) A357, 213 (1977). 72. P. Grivet, Electron Optics (Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1972). 73. A. B. El-Kareh and J. C. El-Kareh, Electron Beams, Lenses and Optics (Academic Press, New York, 1970). 74. L. Swanson and P. Schwind, in Handbook of Charged Particle Optics, edited by J. Orloff (CRC, New York, 1997), p. 96.
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
123
75. I. Mullerova, M. M. El Gomati and L. Frank, Ultramicroscopy 93, 240 (2002). 76. M. Mankos, K. Y. Lee, L. Murray, J. Spallas, Y. Hsu, C. Stebler, W. DeVore, E. Bullock and T. H. P. Chang, Journal of Vaccum Science and Technology B 18, 3057 (2000). 77. F. Bertein, Annales de Rod Electricite 2, 48 (1947). 78. M. E. Haine, Journal of Scientific Instruments 31, 325 (1954). 79. O. Rang, Optik 5, 518 (1949). 80. G. Todd, H. Poppa, D. Moorhead and M. Bales, Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology 12, 953 (1975). 81. L. A. Harris, General Electric Research and Development Report 67-C-201 (1967). 82. P. W. Palmberg, G. K. Bohn and J. C. Tracy, Applied Physics Letters 15, 254 (1969). 83. K. Siegbahn, C. Nordling, A. Fahlman, R. Nordberg, K. Hamrin, J. Hedman, G. Johansson, T. Bergmark, S. Karlson, I. Lindgren and B. Lindberg, ESCA: Atomic, Molecular and Solid State Structure Studied by Means of Electron Spectroscopy (Almqvist and Wiksells Boktryckeri AB, Uppsala, 1967). 84. E. Blauth, Zeitschrift fur Physik 147, 228 (1957). 85. H. Hafner, J. A. Simpson and C. E. Kuyatt, Review of Scientific Instruments 39, 33 (1968). 86. W. Melhorn, Zeitschrift fur Physik 160, 247 (1960). 87. W. Melhorn, Zeitschrift fur Physik 187, 21 (1965). 88. H. Z. Sar-El, Review of Scientific Instruments 38, 1210 (1967). 89. V. V. Zashkavara, M. I. Koursunski and O. S. Kosmachev, Soviet Physics (English Translation) 11, 96 (1966). 90. M. P. Seah, in Methods of Surface Analysis, edited by J. M. Walls (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989). 91. M. M. El Gomati, M. Prutton, B. Lamb and C. G. Tuppen, Surface and Interface Analysis 11, 251 (1988). 92. A. Gelsthorpe and M. M. El Gomati, Journal of Vaccum Science and Technology B 21, 744 (2003). 93. C. F. Eagen and E. N. Sickafus, Review of Scientific Instruments 48, 1269 (1977). 94. N. E. Erikson and C. J. Powell, Surface and Interface Analysis 9, 111 (1986). 95. M. P. Seah, Surface and Interface Analysis 20, 876 (1993). 96. M. M. El Gomati and T. Elbakush, Surface and Interface Analysis 24, 152 (1996). 97. C. E. Purcell, Physical Review 54, 818 (1938). 98. C. E. Kuyatt and J. A. Simpson, Review of Scientific Instruments 38, 103 (1967). 99. J. C. Riviere, in Practical Surface Analysis, edited by D. Briggs and M. P. Seah (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 1990), Vol. 1, p. 19. 100. P. Coxon, J. Krizek, M. Humpherson and I. R. M. Wardell, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 52, 821 (1990). 101. R. Browning, M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton, Surface Science 68, 328 (1977). 102. J. C. Greenwood, M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton, in EMAG-MICRO 89 (Institute of Physics, London, 1989), Vol. 98, p. 547. 103. M. P. Seah, Journal of Electron Spectroscopy and Related Phenomena 50, 137 (1990). 104. D. W. O. Heddle, Electrostatic Lens Systems (Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol, 2000).
124
INSTRUMENTATION
105. P. Weightman, Physica Scripta T41, 277 (1992). 106. M. Prutton, C. G. H. Walker, J. C. Greenwood, P. G. Kenny, J. C. Dee, I. R. Barkshire, R. H. Roberts and M. M. El Gomati, Surface and Interface Analysis 17, 71 (1991). 107. M. P. Seah, Surface and Interface Analysis 2, 222 (1980). 108. D. C. Peacock, M. Prutton and R. Roberts, Vacuum 34, 497 (1984). 109. M. P. Seah, M. E. Jones and M. T. Anthony, Surface and Interface Analysis 6, 242 (1984). 110. M. P. Seah and G. C. Smith, Surface and Interface Analysis 15, 751 (1990). 111. J. C. Greenwood, M. Prutton, R. H. Roberts and Z. Liu, Surface and Interface Analysis 20, 891 (1993). 112. A. R. Walker, in European Patent Office (Kratos Analytical Ltd, 1991). 113. T. Mulvey, in Magnetic Electron Lenses, edited by P. W. Hawkes (Springer, Berlin, 1982), p. 359. 114. I. W. Drummond, Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society (London) A354, 2667 (1996). 115. I. W. Drummond, in Surface Analysis by Auger and X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, edited by D. Briggs and J. T. Grant (IM Publications, Chichester, 2003), Vol. 1, p. 117. 116. G. Hembree, F. C. H. Luo and J. A. Venables, in XIIth International Conference for Electron Microscopy (San Francisco Press, San Francisco, 1990), Vol. 2, p. 382. 117. J. A. Venables and G. G. Hembree, in Electron Microscopy and Analysis (Institute of Physics, Newcastle, 1991), Vol. 119, p. 33. 118. M. Jacka, M. Kirk, M. M. El Gomati and M. Prutton, Review of Scientific Instruments 70, 2282 (1999). 119. C. C. Curtis and K. C. Hsieh, Review of Scientific Instruments 59, 2424 (1988). 120. P. Kruit and J. A. Venables, in Scanning Electron Microscopy Supplement 1, edited by O. Johari (Scanning Microscopy International, Chicago, 1987), Vol. 1, p. 115. 121. M. P. Seah, C. P. Hunt and W. A. Dench, Surface and Interface Analysis 12, 164 (1988). 122. I. S. Gilmore and M. P. Seah, Surface and Interface Analysis 23, 248 (1995). 123. M. P. Seah and M. Tosa, Surface and Interface Analysis 18, 240 (1992). 124. T. E. Everhart and R. F. M. Thornley, Journal of Scientific Instruments 37, 246 (1960). 125. I. R. Barkshire, R. H. Roberts and M. Prutton, Applied Surface Science 120, 129 (1997). 126. C. G. H. Walker, M. Prutton, J. C. Dee, M. M. El Gomati and M. J. Cowham, in EMAG-MICRO 89 (Institute of Physics, London, 1989), Vol. 98, p. 555. 127. S. Kimoto and H. Hashimoto, in The Electron Microprobe, edited by T. D. McKinley, K. F. J. Heinrich and D. B. Wittry (John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Washington DC, 1966), p. 480. 128. M. M. El Gomati, B. Lowe, M. Prutton and C. G. H. Walker, in EMAG-MICRO 89 (Institute of Physics, Bristol, 1989), Vol. 98, p. 556. 129. D. J. Fathers, C. J. Harland and J. A. Venables, in EMAG 83 (Institute of Physics, Bristol, 1983), Vol. 68, p. 227. 130. W. O. Saxton and T. L. Koch, Ultramicroscopy 4, 343 (1982). 131. P. G. Kenny, The acquisition and analysis of multi-spectral analytical electron microscope images, D.Phil Thesis (University of York, 1990). 132. Vu Thien Binh, N. Garcia and S. T. Purcoll, in Advances in Imaging and Electron Physics, edited by P. W. Hawkes (Academic Press, 1996) p.63.
4 The Spatial Resolution M. M. El Gomati
4.1
INTRODUCTION
The ability to resolve small variations between different elements or chemicals is an important feature that will always favor the use of one technique over another for a given problem. This feature is further highlighted when such a distinction, between the elements or chemicals, can be made for small dimensions in the sample – a property that is referred to as the technique’s spatial resolution. In electron probe technology, it has become accepted to refer to a technique as being a ‘high resolution’ method the closer it is in achieving atomic resolution, as the case is in the transmission electron microscope. The use of the term ‘high resolution’ in this context comes from optical spectroscopy. For a full account of the theoretical treatment of this subject, the reader is referred to Sato1. Auger electron microscopy shares many of the same electron–solid interaction mechanisms as those encountered in the electron probe microanalyser (EPMA). This similarity led, in the early days of development of SAM, to concerns that the SAM spatial resolution will be equally affected by the energetically back-scattered electrons which are produced within the pear-shaped interaction volume between the incident electrons and the solid. The radius of this interaction volume, where the collected X-ray signal is produced, is the dominating factor in determining the spatial resolution in EPMA. A number of studies
Scanning Auger Electron Microscopy Edited by M. Prutton and M. El Gomati # 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. ISBN: 0-470-86677-2
126
THE SPATIAL RESOLUTION
supporting this view of SAM were reported. However, some of these studies lacked clarity with respect to the experimental condition and were confused between the technical state of electron probe technology of the time with the actual resolution limits of SAM based on the mechanisms of electron–solid interaction. Christou2,3, for example, reported on differences in the obtainable spatial resolution as a function of the type of electron source used to form the SAM probe: thermionic sources, LaB6 and FE, and suggested that because of beam scattering effects a resolution limit of 10 times the incident probe diameter will be obtained. These results, however, can be easily seen to be a problem associated with the signal to noise ratio of the Auger electron measurement that are made with such electron sources rather than being dependent on the physics of the electron–solid interaction. Brandis4 argued that energetic back-scattered electrons close to the incident electrons would produce a significant proportion of Auger electrons and hence predicted that it is unlikely that a SAM spatial resolution of less than 200 nm will be obtained. Several other studies investigating the role of energetic back-scattered electrons were reported over a period of about 10 years but without giving a consistent view on what to expect as the limit of resolution for this emerging technology5–11. The debate continued, however, with studies7–9 arguing that the SAM spatial resolution should in principle be similar to that of the SEM. This was based on the assumption that since both methods (SEM and SAM) use secondary electrons as the imaging signal (where the Auger electrons are also considered as secondary electrons), and since both types of signal stem from the surface region of the sample under investigation, then both techniques should yield a similar resolution limit. In this respect, it is the probe diameter which controls the obtained spatial resolution. The problem of the SAM spatial resolution is in fact more complicated than in either EMPA or SEM. It has been shown in Chapter 2 that the Auger electron process is an alternative to X-ray production for the relaxation of an ionised atom. This means that the Auger electrons are produced within the same volume as the X-rays. Although the generated X-rays suffer from absorption as they emerge from the target, a big fraction of these can still be collected. This absorption depends on the X-ray energy, the atomic number and composition of the sample and can be an order of magnitude less than the generated X-ray signal12. Auger electrons, on the other hand, have a lower probability of generation than X-rays and in addition any such generated electrons which
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
127
suffer energy losses of more than half the full width of the Auger peak at half its maximum are not detected as Auger electrons and appear as part of the secondary electron background. As a result, the efficiency of production of the collected Auger electrons is worse than that for Xrays, being usually 105–104 per incident electron, compared with 103–102 for X-rays. This means that the collected Auger electrons come from the top few atomic layers, making this technique so surface sensitive. These Auger electrons are produced in one of four ways. Most are produced directly by the incident primary electrons, some by elastically scattered primary electrons, some by energetic secondaries and some by back-scattered electrons on their way out of the sample under investigation. The size of the contribution from the last three mechanisms is referred to in the literature (see Chapter 2) as ‘the Auger electron backscattering factor’, r, which has a value 1 < r < 2:5 depending on the target material, energy and angle of incidence of the incident electrons, as discussed in detail in Chapter 2. The spatial extent of the back-scattered electrons and their efficiency in producing Auger electrons in comparison with those produced directly by the incident primary electrons is what determines the SAM spatial resolution in a given experimental geometry. Monte Carlo based simulation techniques are probably the most basic theoretical approach for the understanding of electron scattering in solids. This technique is particularly suitable for modeling conditions where the sample under investigation consists of multi-layers or when it features sharp topographical and chemical edges, as in the overlayers and via holes encountered in modern electron devices (see Chapter 9). It is therefore appropriate to use this method in the study of the SAM spatial resolution. There are, however, several Monte Carlo models of various degrees of sophistication that have been used over the years in calculating the SAM spatial resolution. In the following, a brief description of the basic structures of these models will be given together with some examples of applications.
4.2
CHOICE OF A MONTE CARLO MODEL
The use of Monte Carlo simulation approaches to study electron–solid interaction at microscopic scale has followed the development of microanalytical probe techniques13,14. A number of models of varying degrees of sophistication have been reported over the years9,15–19. The complexity of the different models depends on the theory adopted and
128
THE SPATIAL RESOLUTION
on the point being investigated. It sould be noted that even with some of the most basic models reported to date, if care is taken in accounting for the generation and escape of the Auger electron signal, the results obtained are in reasonably close agreement with some of the more sophisticated models currently available. The reason for this is that the accuracy of some of the expressions/formulae used in the generation of the Auger electron signal are only accurate to within 10–30 % in some cases (see Chapter 2). However, the choice of a given model becomes crucial as the sample under investigation becomes more complex and includes micro- and nanostructures which contain sharp physical topographies combined with chemical variations, as often encountered in electron devices and novel materials. In these cases, for example, it will be important to pay more attention to the scattering cross-sections and the step length produced by the model. It is instructive to review at this stage some of the sample categories that are encountered in SAM and which need to be discussed in terms of estimating the spatial resolution of the technique when analysing such a sample. These can be divided into: (1) A flat sample surface featuring a sharp edge of elemental material or chemical of atomic number which is different than that of the underlying substrate. (2) The case involving a topographical edge which is also made out of a material of atomic number different than that of the substrate. In addition, the experimental conditions relating to the incident beam energy, the orientation of the chemical/elemental edge under study with respect to the direction of scanning as well as the angle of beam incident on the sample surface are all important factors in determining the spatial resolution. Figure 4.1 depicts the general sample geometries that cover the above conditions.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 4.1 The principal sample geometries encountered in SAM. (a) A via hole. (b) A thick film overlayer. (c) A thin surface film. The shaded region may represent a different atomic number material
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
129
There are two strategies that have been used in Monte Carlo simulations, one involving multiple scattering and the other is based on single scattering events. The idea of multiple scattering is to replace the effects of a number of single scattering events that cause the electron to travel a distance S within the solid, where S is the total distance traveled by the incident electron, by a single event occurring at some arbitrarily selected point within the step. The general agreement between theory and experiment using this approach in estimating the backscattering coefficient (Z) of a solid is very good, especially if one uses the exact Mott elastic scattering cross-section20. This model is fast and hence allows the simulation of a large number of electron trajectories in a reasonably short time. Krefting and Reimer21 on the other hand used a single scattering approach involving an exact Mott elastic scattering cross-section, where energy losses greater than about 100 eV were treated as single scattering events. Their results agreed well with experiment but this method is much slower than the multiple scattering type approaches. In the early days of developments of EMPA and SAM and with the availability of only modest speed computers, this option was a disadvantage. It is worth mentioning at this stage that the criterion for setting up a Monte Carlo model is to introduce as many simplifications to the scattering process as possible without significantly affecting the end result. Furthermore, since Monte Carlo calculations are statistical in nature, the bigger the number of events simulated the better the accuracy of the results obtained. Taking into account the low efficiency of the Auger electron production in the target, a simple model would enable one to improve the signal to noise ratio of the results obtained by increasing the number of electron trajectories for a given simulation time in comparison with more realistic models. With these points in mind, Curgenven and Duncomb15 have described a model which is based on a simplified multiple scattering formalism with the use of a fixed electron step length. Several studies have demonstrated the usefulness of this relatively simple approach22,23 where comparable results with other more elaborate Monte Carlo calculations as well as experiments were obtained. El Gomati and co-workers adopted this model for the production of Auger electrons and made extensive use of it in studying the factors that affect the spatial resolution of Auger electron microscopy13,24,25. This model has also been extensively used by Joy18. In what follows, a brief description of the model will be given first followed by the results obtained. For more details on the structure of these models, the reader is referred to the original publications26,27.
130
4.2.1
THE SPATIAL RESOLUTION
Description of the Model
A typical electron trajectory in the solid is shown in Figure 4.2, where Cartesian coordinates are used. There are two distinct processes that need to be considered in electron–solid interaction that cause an electron impinging a solid to lose energy and change its direction randomly. The first is the elastic scattering by the nucleus (the so-called Rutherford interactions). This is responsible for most of the angular scattering of the electrons inside the solid, which in this context are dominated by small angle (<10 ) events. Each electron emitted from an ionised atom is given a random trajectory, where a random number in the interval between
Figure 4.2 Geometry of a typical electron trajectory in solids. y is the incident electron angle, SL is the Lth step length, b is the Rutherford scattering angle and g is the azimuthal angle
SCANNING AUGER ELECTRON MICROSCOPY
131
0 and 1 is chosen for the angle of emission and another for the probability of emission. In a Monte Carlo simulation, each scattering event is treated randomly. In addition, the scattering process can also result in some electrons being backscattered out of the target surface facing the incident electrons and these normally enhance the production of Auger electrons and may affect the obtainable resolution of a SAM. The second process is the inelastic scattering of the incident electron with orbital electrons of the atoms composing the solid under investigation. This process causes the incident electrons to lose energy continuously with very little angular deflection. 4.2.1.1 Angular scattering of electrons Following Curgenven and Duncumb15, angular scattering of electrons inside the solid is regarded as being due entirely to elastic scattering from the nucleus. To simplify the calculation, the authors used the Rutherford formula in its unscreened form to describe this process and hence avoiding the need to store large arrays of previously computed scattering angles as in Bishop28 or Shimizu and Murata9 models. The Rutherford scattering angle b is given by: cot b=2 ¼ 13:9PE=Z
ð4:1Þ
where P is the impact parameter in nm (i.e. the closest distance the electron would approach the nucleus if no deflection occurred), E is the energy of the electron in eV, and Z is the atomic number of the target. The errors introduced by using a Rutherford cross-section, by treating all angular scattering as elastic and by ignoring screening are partially corrected for by choosing the impact parameter to force the Monte Carlo calculation to result in the experimentally measured value of the back-scattered electron coefficient. 4.2.1.2 The electron energy loss and range The interaction of the moving electron with the core and band electrons in the solid results in loss of energy by excitation with very little angular deflection. For simplicity inelastic scattering is neglected and the loss is assumed to be continuous and to have the form given by Bethe29, 78 500Z 1:166E ln ð4:2Þ dE=dðrSÞ ¼ EA J
132
THE SPATIAL RESOLUTION
where A is the atomic weight of the target material, (rS) is the distance along the electron trajectory, J is the mean ionisation potential for these inelastic interactions (i.e. the average energy loss per inelastic event). Bethe’s theory assumes J to be constant for all electron energies. As the energy approaches J/1.166, the above expression predicts a rate of energy loss equal to zero, which is physically wrong. This is dealt with by a modification of the Bethe expression proposed by Rao-Sahib and Wittry30 at an energy E /J ¼ 6:338 and is given by dE=dðrSÞ ¼
62 360Z pffiffiffiffiffiffi A JE
ð4:3Þ
Equations (4.2) and (4.3) are used to determine the range of electrons in the solid (rSÞmax using ðrSÞmax ¼
Z
Eo 0
dE dE=dðrSÞ
ð4:4Þ
For 20 keV incident electrons it is found to be adequate to divide the range of each electron into 100 steps, which is a compromise between the true number of scattering acts and the time required for the computation. The electron energy is then numerically evaluated at each step. As electrons reach the Auger electron escape depth, defined as three times the inelastic mean free path (l), they are allowed to ionise the atoms using a Gryzinski cross-section (see Chapter 2). It should be noted here that the choice of a specific cross-section will not cause a large change to the results as interest here is on the relative heights of the signal due to the primary and back-scattered electrons and not on their absolute values. Finally, it is customary to check the validity of the Monte Carlo method by running a number of tests using the simulation to compare results with experimental values. These may include, for example, the back-scattered electron coefficient, Z, the spatial and energy distribution of the back-scattered electrons, the electron energy range in the solid, R, the Auger back-scattered electron coefficient, r. In addition, one may also like to plot the electron trajectories for different solids, as shown in Figure 4.3 which depicts the case for 20 keV electrons incident on Al, Cu, and Au obtained with the above Monte Carlo model. An example of the type of data input required to run a Monte Carlo program based on the above described model is given in Table 4.1.
Figure 4.3 Simulations of 100 electron trajectories at different angles of incidence for (a) Al, (b) Cu and (c) Au trajectories at Eo ¼ 20 keV and for three angles of incidence 0 , 45 and 75 with the exception of Cu for which the highest angle of incidence is 60
134
THE SPATIAL RESOLUTION
Table 4.1 Data used to calculate the Auger electron emission Material Property
Al
Backscattering coefficient, Z Mean ionisation potential, J (eV) Auger process Auger initial state energy, Ec (eV) Auger escape depth, (nm) Maximum ionisation cross-section, smax ðcm2 eV2 1014 )
0.309 392 L3VV 931 12 11.7
Cu
Au
0.164 176 KVV 1560 2.8 7.3
0.507 1067 N6,7VV 84 0.6 9.2
References 40 23 41 41 42 43–45
Table 4.2 Electron ranges (in microns) for a primary beam energy of 20 keV compared with results from Murata31 Element Aluminum Copper Gold
Present data 4.54 1.79 1.36
Murata’s data 3.9 1.49 1.04
These data have also been used to obtain the spatial distribution of the emitted Auger electrons for Al, Cu and Au results presented here. The electron energy range for 20 keV incident electrons obtained using these data is compared in Table 4.2 with values reported by Murata31. Although there is a difference between the two sets of results, which are attributed to the use of different coefficients in Equation (4.2) (1.166 in the model used here against a value of 2 used by Murata), it is interesting to note that the backscattering data obtained in these calculations were insensitive to changes in the electron range of the order shown in Table 4.2.
4.3 4.3.1
THE SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION OF THE AUGER ELECTRONS A sharp Chemical Edge, Theoretical E