Law Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity
Rodopi Philosophical Studies
8
Edited by
Francisco Miró Quesada (Univers...
91 downloads
1571 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Law Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity
Rodopi Philosophical Studies
8
Edited by
Francisco Miró Quesada (University of Lima)
Ernest Sosa (Brown University)
Amsterdam - New York, NY 2007
Law Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity Social, Political, & Legal Philosophy, Volume 2
Edited by
Enrique Villanueva
INSTITUTO DE INVESTIGACIONES JURÍDICAS UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL AUTÓNOMA DE MÉXICO
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, AND LEGAL PHILOSOPHY
Edited by Enrique Villanueva Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, UNAM Editorial Advisory Board: Ruth Chang Rutgers University Jules Coleman Yale University Mark Greenberg University of California, Los Angeles Christopher Kutz University of California, Berkeley Thomas Nagel New York University Stephen Perry University of Pennsylvania Ulises Schmill Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de México Scott Shapiro University of Michigan at Ann Arbor Jeremy Waldron Columbia University
The paper on which this book is printed meets the requirements of “ISO 9706:1994, Information and documentation - Paper for documents Requirements for permanence”. ISBN: 978-90-420-2375-8 ©Editions Rodopi B.V., Amsterdam - New York, NY 2007 Printed in the Netherlands
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
Contents Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
PART I METAPHYSICS, MEANING, AND OBJECTIVITY 1. Interpretivist Theories of Law . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nicos STAVROPOULOS
3
2. How Facts Make Law . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mark GREENBERG
21
3. On the Normative Significance of Brute Facts . . . . . . . . Ram NETA
75
4. On Practices and the Law . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mark GREENBERG
95
5. Supervenience, Value, and Legal Content . . . . . . . . . . 125 Enrique VILLANUEVA 6. Reasons Without Values? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133 Mark GREENBERG 7. Theory, Practice and Ubiquitous Interpretation: The Basics . . 145 Martin STONE
vi
CONTENTS
8. Law as a Reflective Practice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 Scott HERSHOVITZ 9. On Reflective Practices and ‘Substituting for God’ . . . . . 189 Martin STONE 10. Metasemantics and Objectivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 215 Ori SIMCHEN 11. Can Objectivity be Grounded in Semantics? . . . . . . . . . 235 Michael S. MOORE
PART II RIGHTS THEORY 12. A Hybrid Theory of Claim-Rights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263 Gopal SREENIVASAN 13. Is the Will Theory of Rights Superseded by the Hybrid Theory? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 289 Horacio SPECTOR 14. In Defence of the Hybrid Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 299 Gopal SREENIVASAN
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
Preface Some of the main papers in this volume were presented to the I International Conference of the Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, celebrated in Mexico City, July 7-11, 2003. It inaugurated a series of International Conferences to be organized by this Instituto. We express our gratitude to Dr Diego Valadés Ríos former Head of the Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, UNAM, for his overall support that made possible both, first, the celebration of that Conference and, later, the publication of this volume. We also express our gratitude to Dr Héctor Fix-Fierro, Head of our Instituto, for his support in the final stages of the publication process. This is the first volume that appears in a co-edition between the Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas and Rodopi Publishing Company. Our gratitude to Prof Ernesto Sosa, Director of the Philosophy Series for his support. Thanks to Rodrigo Ortiz who helped with the organization of that conference. Our gratitude to the Publishing Department, Lic Raúl Márquez, Head, Jaime García Díaz and José Antonio Bautista Sánchez who made the typescript, of our Instituto de Investigaciones Juridicas. Petersburg, Russia, November 2006
PART I METAPHYSICS, MEANING, AND OBJECTIVITY
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
1
Interpretivist Theories of Law* Nicos Stavropoulos** Interpretivism about the nature of law is the view that legal rights and duties are determined by the scheme of principle that provides the best justification of certain political practices of a community: a scheme identifiable through an interpretation of the practices that is sensitive both to the facts of the practices and to the values or principles that the practices serve. Interpretivism has been developed by Ronald Dworkin in a number of publications over the last 30 years or so (see the works of Dworkin cited in the Bibliography). Interpretivism as developed by Dworkin includes the claim that interpretation is sensitive to values in the way just explained, and that it is fundamental to the nature of law. Many theorists accept that, given the law, interpretation that is sensitive to values is necessarily employed in its application (e.g. Brink 2001). In this entry, we shall be concerned exclusively with interpretivism as a theory about the nature of law, and so we shall not consider such views (except as possible misunderstandings of interpretivism). We shall focus on the explanation of the position defended by Dworkin (though not necessarily on his way of defending it), and briefly consider some alternatives in respect of the normative character of legal interpretation. The arrival of interpretivism in the scene, previously dominated by positivist and natural law theories about the nature of law, has stimu* © Nicos Stavropoulos 2003.
Reprinted from The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2003 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2003/entries/law-in terpretivist. ** University Lecturer in Legal Theory, University of Oxford .
4
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
lated a great deal of debate (the following are some examples from the vast secondary literature: Mitchell 1983; Cohen 1984; Hart 1994 (Postscript); Raz 1986; Finnis 1992; Coleman 2001). 1. Propositions and Grounds 2. Propositions and the Nature of Law 3. Interpretive Practices 4. Interpretation 5. Facts and Impact 6. Justifying the Facts 7. Why Political Morality? Bibliography 1. Propositions and Grounds Interpretivism is a thesis about what determines legal rights and duties, i.e. what makes it the case that the law requires what it does. As such, it is a thesis about the nature of law. These questions can be formulated in terms of the grounds of propositions of law. Propositions of law are expressed by sentences that describe legal requirements. For example, such a proposition may be that Gratuitous promises not relied upon are not enforceable in law. Such propositions can be at all levels of generality. They may involve relatively abstract legal requirements, such as the above example, or concrete requirements such as the proposition that Smith is entitled to $100 from Jones. They can be expressed in terms of legal rights or duties: e.g. ‘in law, no duty to do as promised applies to those who promise gratuitously, as long as their promise is not relied upon’, or ‘Jones has a legal duty to pay Smith $100’. What makes a proposition of law true, when it is true? We want to investigate the grounds of law, so it would not help to cite facts that trivially make legal propositions true — we already know that, for any x, the fact that x is capable of making the proposition that x true — and it would not help to cite any legal facts either — doing so would merely postpone, not answer our question. What are the likely candidates?
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
5
It seems uncontroversial that biographical and other contingencies in the lives of ordinary citizens, such as the fact that Jones was drunk when he met Smith to discuss a deal, are among the facts that make true concrete propositions of law that involve such citizens’ rights and duties. More interestingly, it is uncontroversial that the truth of all legal propositions is, at least in part, dependent upon certain political facts. By ‘political facts’ I mean political decisions and practices, including legislative enactments, custom, or settled judicial practice, understood in non-legal terms, i.e. without reference to what the law requires; and further understood in non-evaluative terms, i.e. without reference to facts about what is right or good. It is uncontroversial that the question whether gratuitous promises bind in law is partly dependent upon political decisions and practices. It is further widely accepted that such decisions and practices crucially include what officials said and did in the past, conceived simply in terms of the texts and utterances they issued and their settled practice of behaving in a certain way, all of which at least in part make propositions of law true. For example, it is widely accepted that the text of a statute that reads ‘gratuitous promises shall not be enforced’, or the fact that judges, as a matter of settled practice, are disposed not to enforce gratuitous promises, would go a long way towards explaining why such promises are not enforceable. Political facts properly conceived may include more than these simple facts. Official utterances and texts are meaningful entities, not mere sounds or ink stains (which could not as such make any legal proposition true) so any proper conception of political facts must rely on some doctrine about what makes texts and utterances mean what they do. But a conception of political facts may be much richer still: for example, it may include counterfactual dispositions of officials, or psychological states of officials such as their intentions, desires, hopes, and expectations not specified in terms of dispositions. Did members of Congress intend or expect that the text of the statute should be construed in a certain way? Would they have formulated the text differently if they had contemplated a contingency they did not in fact contemplate? An appropriate conception of political facts may further include other, more complex facts such as the fact that certain courts possess the power to quash other courts’ decisions. It is more
6
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
controversial whether such complex facts are ultimately reducible to simple facts of linguistic and other behavior of officials or citizens, including their collective dispositions, or whether they are indeed relevant at all. It is however uncontroversial that political facts, conceived in non-evaluative terms, play a critical role in the grounding of legal propositions. For convenience, I shall call political facts so conceived political practice. Interpretivism accepts and provides an explanation for these widely accepted claims, but also defends a view usually attributed to the natural law tradition: that, in spite of their obvious dependence upon political practice, legal requirements further depend, in some complex way, upon certain non-contingent evaluative facts. This part of interpretivism is highly controversial, so we need to clarify and defend it. Interpretivism is the view that, if true, a proposition of law is true in virtue of an interpretive fact: in a nutshell, in virtue of the fact that the proposition follows from the best justification of a community’s political practice. Interpretivism says that it is not political practice alone — such as the fact that Congress voted for a statute that says that gratuitous promises are not enforceable, that its power to enforce its decisions is recognized, or that it is treated as supreme law-maker by lawyers, or the fact that as a matter of settled practice courts do not enforce such promises — that makes legal propositions true, nor is it moral or other evaluative facts alone — e.g. that it is good that gratuitous promises should not be enforceable — that make them true either. Rather, legal propositions are made true by the best justification of political practice, i.e. the scheme of principle that underlies and governs political practice, including e.g. the fact that it is right that Congress should wield the power that it does or that courts’ settled practice should have a large impact on our duties. Interpretivism therefore claims that legal requirements are sensitive to both the facts of the practice and the values served by it, but not fully determined by either. 2. Propositions and the Nature of Law The question of the grounds of legal propositions is not a question about the legal requirements in any jurisdiction. It is not the question of
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
7
what is the content of the law, here or elsewhere. Rather, it is the question of what makes the content of the law what it is. If the law, for example, includes a requirement to pay capital gains tax at a certain rate, what makes it the case that it includes that requirement? Consider by way of analogy the proposition that a certain course of action, A, is immoral. If this proposition is true, what makes it true? We learn something important about the nature of morality if we learn whether, e.g., this proposition is true in virtue of the fact that A is disapproved by the Gods, or that A is considered immoral by most people. Similarly, in the legal domain we may hope to learn about the nature of law by learning whether legal propositions are made true by contingent political facts — and if so, which ones — or by political values, economic forces, or divine will, or have any other colorable ground. The core at least of any doctrine about the nature of law including all the familiar ones may be formulated as a thesis about legal propositions and their grounds. Put in those terms, some of these doctrines may imply that legal propositions divide into distinct classes, on the basis of the kind of grounds each has. For example, a theory may hold that certain propositions are either made true by a special class of facts of political practice, law-creating facts, alone, or are entailed by propositions that are made true by such facts alone. These propositions constitute a basic class, the law. By contrast, propositions that follow from the basic class with the addition of further contingent or evaluative premises constitute the law’s applications (compare Raz 1980, 70-92; 216-24). Moreover, each theory provides or entails an account not merely of the grounds and the propositions they make true, but also of the nature of the relation between grounds and propositions. For example, a theory may hold that the links between true legal propositions and political practice are conceptual, in the special sense of the shared implicit understanding of the concept of law or other key concepts such as the concept of authority. That is, the theory may say that it is such a conceptual truth that certain aspects of the practices determine the propositions that they do (see Greenberg 2004 for systematic discussion of possible determination relations). Interpretivism may be consistent with a classification of legal propositions by kind of grounds but, since it would not accept that any le-
8
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
gal proposition is made true by political practice (in the narrow technical sense identified above) alone, it need not place any emphasis on such a division. Interpretivism would further say that the relation that holds between the grounds and the propositions is interpretive, in a sense to be explained further. The question of the grounds of legal propositions should not be confused with another question often discussed by legal philosophers: not what makes legal propositions true but rather what makes norms (or legal rules or laws) valid. Some theorists hold that the conditions of validity of norms are exclusively source-based, consisting only in facts about the norms’ pedigree. Other theorists hold that norms’ validity may further depend on certain moral conditions, if such conditions are laid down by more fundamental source-based norms, or by settled judicial practice, or by some other feature of political history. For example, such a view may be that in case the Constitution entrenches some values, the conditions of validity of ordinary legislation include those values. Or it may be that, in case officials happen to use moral tests, e.g. they treat as law whatever Congress says yet only insofar as it is consistent with liberty and equality, these values set partial tests of validity. In both cases the values play the crucial role only because legislators themselves said so or because officials treat them as such — in virtue of political practice. Interpretivism is often taken to represent another possibility along that spectrum: it is recast as the thesis that legal norms’ validity is partly dependent upon the best justification of political practice, in the specific sense that valid norms are those which, in addition to having the right source — their having been promulgated by the right people or institutions — are further consistent with the principles that justify the relevant political practice (even if the principles are not explicitly laid down by any authority). On that reading, interpretation consists in the derivation of valid legal norms through the application of an evaluative filter to a set of given norms. As the metaphor of a filter makes plain, the reading in question presupposes a set of norms (or rules or laws), whose identity does not depend on interpretation, to which the filter is applied at an analytically later stage. The interpretivist, however, need not accept that any legal norms or rules are individuated non-interpretively.
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
9
On another version, interpretivism does not take any norms as (non-interpretively) given. It rather claims that valid legal norms are identifiable through an interpretation of the legal materials such as authoritative texts — the texts of the constitution, statutes and cases, which canonically formulate the legal decisions — in the light of certain political values. But even on that version, the materials’ legality is given. A broadly positivistic explanation of law in terms of authoritative sources is once again assumed, with interpretation understood as some kind of evaluative processing of the sources. The confusion may be encouraged by the assumption that the interpretivist must rely on or presuppose a division of legal propositions into a special class of propositions grounded on law-creating facts alone, which constitute the law and in respect of which interpretation plays no role, and those that follow from the special class with the addition of further premises, which constitute the application of law. On this assumption, the interpretivist is merely claiming that law must be interpreted to be applied. As we saw however, interpretivism is not restricted in this way. 3. Interpretive Practices The interpretivist claims that legal practice is, in its nature, interpretive. What makes a practice interpretive? Dworkin explains this in terms of a special attitude, which has two components, holding among practitioners. He uses an imaginary example of a practice of courtesy, which includes many rules cited by practitioners and taken by them to set out what courtesy requires. He describes the components of the attitude (Dworkin 1986, 47) as follows: The first is the assumption that the practice of courtesy does not merely exist but has value, that it serves some interest or purpose or enforces some principle — in short, that it has some point — that can be stated independently of just describing the rules that make up the practice. The second is the further assumption that the requirements of courtesy — the behavior it calls for or the judgments it warrants — are not necessarily or exclusively what they have always been taken to be but are instead sensitive to its point, so that the strict rules must be understood or applied or modified or qualified or limited by that point.
10
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
Dworkin’s two components capture two independent conditions, both of which must be satisfied. It is not enough that the practice be thought to serve some value (which would satisfy the first condition); further, the value must be taken to be constitutive of the practice, which is what the second condition amounts to. Together, the conditions have important consequences in respect of the practice’s character. It should be emphasized that the value or principle in question is assumed to be genuine and not trivially satisfied by the practice. The assumption is that the practice is in fact valuable, not that it can be rationalized. Baby-torturers may think that their practice serves some value, and even that its requirements are sensitive to it, but they are wrong: the value in question cannot be the value of torturing babies, a value their practice would trivially satisfy if it existed. Nor can it be the value of inflicting suffering, which would not be trivial but likewise does not exist. In this case, we can confidently assume that no real value or principle is served by what they do. This case is however only a dramatic extreme: the fact that practitioners assume that their practice serves a value does not suffice to make it so, so it could turn out for any practice whatever — including legal practice — that the assumption is false. Practitioners hold themselves responsible to a standard that is set by the value, if any, which in fact justifies the practice, not their individual or collective understanding of the value. This aspect of the attitude introduces a critical dimension to interpretive practices. It implies that the standard that governs such a practice is taken to be in a crucial sense external to it. Participants accept that they are fallible, even collectively, in respect of the standard and thus in respect of the behavior or judgment that the standard entails. Any particular aspect of the practice, however well-settled, may turn out to be a mistake, and the practice could have determinate requirements even where it is unsettled. Consider by way of contrast a conventional practice, as commonly understood: in that case, the standard that governs a practice is defined — exclusively set — by settled practice (compare Hart 1982, 153-61). It follows that, in that case, no part of settled practice could turn out to be a mistake, a failure by practitioners to discharge the duty imposed by the practice. For the interpretivist, however, there is no such guarantee. The question can always be raised in respect of any
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
11
aspect of the practice: does it really serve the value the practice is meant to serve? But while the standard is in that sense partly external, it is not in another. Participants are open-minded in respect of what makes their practice as it stands now require what it does. When they are inclined to correct their actual practice to conform to a new, better interpretation, they take it that that the new interpretation better articulates the standard to which they were antecedently committed, not that they are persuaded to substitute a new, more attractive standard for the old one (compare Burge 1986). Room for error in the practice entails that disagreement of a special kind is possible. Participants can sensibly disagree about what constitutes courtesy —what the standard of courtesy is, not merely whether some behavior satisfies a given standard— and take it that the right answer to that constitutive question would be right in virtue of capturing the rationale of the practice, whatever it is, not their understanding of the rationale (whether explicit or implicit, individual or collective). This is not to say that it follows from the mere fact that participants appear to disagree in that fundamental way that they do. Rather, the point is that, if participants do hold themselves responsible to the value, whatever it is, that justifies their practice, it is possible for such disagreement to obtain. Whether any actual disagreement has the character in question depends on whether it is in fact best explained in those terms. 4. Interpretation The interpreter’s task in respect of an interpretive practice is to formulate a hypothesis, i.e. to postulate a value that could in fact justify the practice’s requiring what it is held to require. The interpreter’s hypothesis amounts to the attribution of a rationale or point to the relevant practice, an articulation of the values that are served by behaving in the way participants do behave when they are trying to conform to the requirements of the practice in question. It is worth repeating that the practice’s interpretive character merely entails that the interpreter must look for such a rationale, not that there is some guarantee that one exists.
12
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
For example, the rationale of giving up one’s seat to a senior in the name of courtesy (i.e. as a duty entailed by a standard that requires many other things too, such as excusing oneself from certain parties) may be to show respect (assuming that this constitutes a virtue or has some other value); if so, the display of respect would constitute the point of the practice, so that, if faced with the question what the practice requires that one do in a different context, the right answer would be sensitive to that point. For another example, which greatly simplifies a far more complicated practice, the rationale of awarding compensation for injuries caused by defective products may be that manufacturers should bear the cost of the risk associated with the use of the relevant products. Such a rationale would justify awarding damages when such injuries occur, whether or not the manufacturer is at fault — i.e. would justify no-fault liability. Finally, consider the practice of treating statutes as capable of overriding many long-standing arrangements of rights and duties, as having the power instantly to invent new or to extinguish old such arrangements. It would be a major undertaking fully or even adequately to specify the values served by treating the legislature as possessing such sweeping powers; plausibly, they are abstract political values that involve procedural justice. These values, once articulated, would partly determine the impact of a statute that purports to override some fundamental right, with which the legislature had never interfered before. These examples are meant merely to convey the flavor of the interpreter’s task. Given the complexity of legal practice, the legal interpreter’s complete task would be to construct an equally complex hypothesis that can explain and justify, so far as possible, all the ‘data’, the facts of a large number of specific practices, many of which may seem to pull in different directions. The interpretivist then may introduce a superhuman character, the ideal interpreter, who should be able to find a complex hypothesis that achieves equilibrium among all the relevant practices (Dworkin famously calls him ‘Hercules’). Although sometimes presented as a flaw in the theory, the superhuman character merely helps illustrate an aspect of legal practice which does not seem controversial: that any candidate interpretation of the law, however narrowly focused, is open to the challenge that it does not cohere with another part of the law, where both the interpreter and the
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
13
challenger agree what that part requires. The possibility of this form of challenge implies the formal aspect of interpretation discussed here: that any local interpretation must aspire to be a genuine component of the global, all-encompassing and perfectly calibrated interpretation of the totality of legal practice. The fact that no lawyer or judge can put together such an interpretation is no more disturbing than the fact that no scientist can put together a total explanation of the natural world. Like the total scientific theory, the global interpretation provides the measure of correctness and thus the standard of criticism of ordinary science and ordinary interpretation. 5. Facts and Impact The interpretivist’s central claim is that legal practice is indeed interpretive, in the sense explained above. He claims that it is possible for lawyers to disagree in the special way (and is likely further to claim that they often do disagree in that way): e.g. about what constitutes negligence or legislative intent, each assuming that his or her explanation of the law on the disputed point is the best in virtue of being the only explanation that properly justifies the rest of the practice (the part not in dispute). Most lawyers would agree of course on some very weak proposition about the grounds of law. They would agree that certain aspects of practice — e.g. statutory texts — have large impact on the law, but they only agree because they each rely on a far more elaborate understanding of the precise impact that any aspect of the practice does have. Their thin agreement is only an overlap of very different complete accounts. That is not to say that each lawyer has a well-articulated Herculean account in mind when he engages in a local dispute, only that he assumes that his partial account is good in virtue of being a part of the Herculean account, and hence assumes a responsibility to articulate as best he can the implications or presuppositions of the part he defends, in any direction. Even if lawyers may occasionally have to dirty their hands in the detail, perhaps philosophers could leave the matter at the area of overlap, and be content with the proposition that some role or other must be assigned to political facts. But which facts, more precisely, are we
14
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
talking about? And what makes those facts so central to legal propositions? We can dramatize this question: what makes facts about what members of Congress said and did, though not facts about what each member’s best friend said and did, pertinent to law? And which facts about members of Congress are crucial? Is it exclusively facts about members voting for bills, or perhaps facts about Congressional debates as well? And how about facts about committee activities? And do we only care for the explicit utterances and formal deeds of members of Congress, or are we also interested in any psychological facts about these people (Dworkin 1985b; 1986 Ch. 9)? We can ask such questions in respect of any sub-class of political facts: we can reformulate our questions to focus on the Framers and their friends, the Framers’ speeches and their correspondence, and the political pamphlets some of them wrote; and so on for judges and other political agents. Interpretivism claims that values justify the precise kind of authority that different agents and institutions have and hence the precise way in which their decisions and other acts determine legal duties (including any specific cases in which it may turn out that that the values may dictate that the facts about authoritative decision-making alone determine our duties). Although the interpretivist accepts that propositions of law are founded on political decisions, i.e. that the content of the law is sensitive to what a political community historically decides; and he also accepts that, more abstractly, law is dependent upon certain political practices of a community, including legislation and adjudication; he further says that what makes these decisions and practices the grounds of propositions of law is the normative fact that it is good that they should be such grounds. The interpretivist says that it is in virtue of the fact that our rights and duties ought to flow from past political decisions that they flow from them; or that, more abstractly, legal duties ought to be determined by social practices that they do. And he thinks that they ought to be determined by such decisions and practices because doing so serves certain political virtues such as fairness and procedural justice. The interpretivist says that a fuller articulation of these virtues and of their connections with other political values would yield a more detailed account of the precise way in which the practices determine legal duties.
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
15
The full account would include the answer to the more specific kind of question that was illustrated above, and so would tell us whether our duties depend on the explicit decisions, only, of Congress and other bodies, or further on the psychological states of the decisionmakers, the decision-makers’ own understanding of the decisions, or any other element of political history and structure. For the interpretivist, the legality of the aspects of political practice that do in fact serve as the grounds of law is settled by reference to what is right or good. It would be a mistake however to think that the only question is which facts count as legal. We do not merely need to work out questions such as why someone ought to make law and who gets to make it (and possibly also what is the broad or rough way in which the words and deeds or other behavior of the relevant persons determine the law’s requirements). The principles of political morality that figure in the best interpretation of political practices do not only dictate that certain facts about the promulgation of statutes and the resolution of cases, or some other aspect of a community’s political practices, are the distinctively legal facts on which rights and duties depend, without helping precisely to determine what impact the facts have on our rights and duties. The question to which the values provide an answer can be expressed more simply (see Greenberg 2004). It is this: in respect of all the facts that could conceivably play a role in determining legal rights and duties, what is the role that each has? This is not simply a question of relevance or even rough weight. Rather, the question invites an answer in terms of the precise impact that a fact has on our rights and duties, i.e. an answer which includes a specification of the impact of the relevant fact, in case different relevant facts pull in different directions. The interpretivist then says that values determine the precise impact that all candidate facts have on legal rights and duties. Legality and impact are not distinct. 6. Justifying the Facts We have just seen that the interpretivist claims that it is in virtue of certain values that the law has the determinants that it does — i.e. that
16
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
its content depends on a community’s political practices. He claims that values do not merely make the political facts relevant but also select the way in which the facts determine legal rights and duties. Simplifying the thesis in that way helps us better to understand Dworkin’s famous claim that interpreting the practices consists in assigning to them the content that best fits and justifies them (Dworkin 1986). While Dworkin’s distinction between fit and justification, as tests of interpretive success, is explicitly a mere heuristic device (Dworkin 1982, 1986 at 229-63), it has received intense critical scrutiny (Raz 1986; Finnis 1992; Hart 1994, Postscript). The distinction seems to suggest that the interpreter has two separate tasks, first to formulate alternative hypotheses that are consistent with the facts of the practice, and second show which one among them provides the most attractive justification of the facts of the practice. The dimension of fit may then be understood as an independent, non-normative constraint, in the sense either that this is how the interpretivist understands it, or that this how he cannot but understand it. In fact the distinction in question is no more than a rough distinction between ineligible and eligible interpretations, which is made within particular interpretations, not prior to any interpretation. It is merely a device for organizing complex interpretations and so for facilitating the representation of alternative interpretations involved in notional or actual disputes. An interpretation will be typically organized in terms of the examples from the practice that it undertakes to justify, and the justification that it offers. But no interpretation need accept that any particular example’s standing as such is immune from interpretive assessment. The interpretation must itself (normatively) explain what makes a putative example a genuine example, if it is indeed such. That implies that no example is immune from discount as a mistake, as a piece of fool’s gold lurking among the genuine samples. The interpretivist does not accept, nor does the fit-justification distinction properly understood entail, a distinction between the data and their reading that is prior to and independent of interpretation. As we have already noticed, common ground among interpretations is mere overlap. No aspect of the practice can be taken as a non-interpretive given. Rather, they are both parts of the interpretive, thoroughly normative account.
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
17
There is yet another misunderstanding that we must guard against. We concluded that interpretivism claims that neither question — what are the data and what justifies them — can be answered in a non-normative manner. But even if it is conceded that interpretation has no non-normative part, it may still seem that there are two distinct normative questions to be asked, namely what is the justification for taking certain data to be generally decisive in determining our duties, and what is the justification for taking the data to determine them in a particular way, i.e. in a way such that certain duties and not others are identified as legally imposed. And if we think that there are two distinct questions — even if it is granted that they are both normative — it may seem that there could be tensions between them, so that a further question remains which concerns how to balance the two components of the normative account when they conflict. We may dissolve this further misunderstanding by recalling our formulation of the interpretivist point in terms of a single question. Interpretivism says that values select, from among all the facts that could conceivably be determinants of legal duty, the ones that are such determinants, by providing an account that justifies the impact that each precise determinant has on our rights and duties. 7. Why Political Morality? The fact that the interpretivist seeks to identify the foundation of duties that, on their face, seem political — duties owed to political decisions and practice — suggests why that foundation, if it exists, is likely to come from political morality, the domain of duties owed to each other or to institutions or to the community as a whole in virtue of some feature of political life that is capable of providing such a foundation. But the interpretivist commitment is weaker than that. It is rather that, whatever, if anything, is capable of justifying doing as the law requires because it requires it, is an eligible candidate. The interpretivist does not deny that the quest for such a foundation may fail. If so, no value that can play the role of foundation may be attributable to the practice. What the interpretivist must deny is that the attribution of a value or point that is too weak to justify genuine
18
NICOS STAVROPOULOS
duties should always be preferred, even if the attribution of a point that is not weak in that way is available and compelling. For the claim then becomes non-interpretivist, since it assumes that a test other than (and prior to) interpretive success is fundamental. Bibliography Brink, David (2001): ‘Legal Interpretation and Morality’, in B. Leiter (ed.) Objectivity in Law and Morals, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Burge, Tyler (1986): ‘Intellectual Norms and Foundations of Mind’, Journal of Philosophy 83, 697-720. Cohen, Marshall (ed.) (1984): Ronald Dworkin and Contemporary Jurisprudence, London: Duckworth. Coleman, Jules (ed.) (2001): Hart’s Postscript, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Dworkin, Ronald (1977): Taking Rights Seriously, London: Duckworth. (1977a): Ch. 2 (The Model of Rules I) (1977b): Ch. 3 (The Model of Rules II) (1977c): Ch. 4 (Hard Cases) (1977d): Appendix (Reply to Critics) —— (1982): ‘Natural Law Revisited’, U. Florida. Law Review, 34: 165. —— (1983): ‘My Reply to Stanley Fish (and Walter Benn Michaels): Please Don’t Talk about Objectivity any More’, in W. J. T. Mitchell (ed.), The Politics of Interpretation, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. —— (1984): ‘A Reply’, in M. Cohen (ed.), Ronald Dworkin and Contemporary Jurisprudence, London: Duckworth. —— (1985): A Matter of Principle, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press. (1985a): Ch 1 (Political Judges and the Rule of Law) (1985b): Ch 2 (The Forum of Principle) (1985c): Ch 3 (Principle, Policy, Procedure) (1985d): Ch 5 (Is there Really No Right Answer in Hard Cases?) (1985e): Ch 6 (How Law is Like Literature) (1985f): Ch 7 (On Interpretation and Objectivity) —— (1986): Law’s Empire, Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press. —— (1996): ‘Objectivity and Truth: You’d Better Believe It’, Philosophy and Public Affairs, 25: 88. Finnis, John (1992): ‘Natural Law and Legal Reasoning’, in George, R. (ed.), Natural Law Theory, Oxford: Clarendon Press. George, Robert (ed.) 1992: Natural Law Theory, Oxford: Clarendon Press. Greenberg, Mark (2004): ‘How Facts Make Law’, forthcoming, Legal Theory. Hart, H.L.A. (1982): Essays on Bentham, Oxford: Clarendon Press. —— (1994): The Concept of Law, 2nd edition, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
INTERPRETIVIST THEORIES OF LAW
19
Mitchell, W.J.T. (ed.) (1983): The Politics of Interpretation, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Raz, Joseph (1980): The Concept of a Legal System, 2nd edition, Oxford: Clarendon Press. —— (1984): ‘Legal Principles and the Limits of Law’, in Cohen, M. (ed.), Ronald Dworkin and Contemporary Jurisprudence, London: Duckworth. —— (1986): ‘Dworkin: a New Link in the Chain’, CAL. L. R. 74: 1103. —— (1994): Ethics in the Public Domain, Oxford: Clarendon Press. —— (2001): ‘Two Views about the Nature of Law’, in Coleman, J. ed., Hart’s Postscript, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
2
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
How Facts Make Law* Mark Greenberg** I. Introduction Nearly all philosophers of law agree that nonnormative, nonevaluative, contingent facts—descriptive facts, for short—are among the determinants of the content of the law. In particular, ordinary empirical facts about the behavior and mental states of people such as legislators, judges, other government officials, and voters play a part in determining that content. It is highly controversial, however, whether the relevant descriptive facts, which we can call law-determining practices, or law practices (or simply practices) for short,1 are the only determinants of legal content, or whether legal content also depends on normative or evaluative facts—value facts,2 for short. In fact, a central—perhaps the central—debate in the philosophy of law is a debate over whether value facts are among the deter* For helpful comments on ancient and recent predecessors of this paper, I am very grateful to Larry Alexander, Andrea Ashworth, Ruth Chang, Jules Coleman, Martin Davies, Ronald Dworkin, Gil Harman, Scott Hershovitz, Kinch Hoekstra, Harry Litman, Tim Macht, Tom Nagel, Ram Neta, Jim Pryor, Stephen Perry, Joseph Raz, Gideon Rosen, Scott Shapiro, Seana Shiffrin, Ori Simchen, Martin Stone, Enrique Villanueva, and two anonymous referees for Legal Theory. Special thanks to Susan Hurley and Nicos Stavropoulos for many valuable discussions. I would also like to thank audiences at the University of Pennsylvania, New York University, UCLA, Yale University, the 2002 Annual Analytic Legal Philosophy conference, and the 2003 International Congress in Mexico City, where versions of this material were presented. Finally, I owe a great debt to the work of Ronald Dworkin. ** University of California, Los Angeles. 1 For the moment, I will be vague about the nature of law practices. For more precision, see Section II.B below. 2 For some explanation of what I mean by “value facts,” see note 22 below.
22
MARK GREENBERG
minants of the content of the law (though the debate is not usually characterized in this way). A central claim of legal positivism is that the content of the law depends only on social facts, understood as a proper subset of descriptive facts. As Joseph Raz says, “H.L.A. Hart is heir and torch-bearer of a great tradition in the philosophy of law which . . . regards the existence and content of the law as a matter of social fact whose connection with moral or any other values is contingent and precarious.”3 In contemporary philosophy of law, there are two distinct ways of developing this tradition: hard and soft positivism. Hard positivism denies that value facts may play any role in determining legal content.4 Soft positivism allows that the relevant social facts may make value facts relevant in a secondary way. For example, the fact that a legislature uses a moral term—“equality,” say—in a statute may have the effect of incorporating moral facts—about equality, in this case—into the law.5 On this soft positivist view, however, it is still the social facts that make the value facts relevant, and the social facts need not incorporate value facts into the law. Hence according to both hard and soft positivism, it is possible for social facts alone to determine what the law is, and even when they make value facts relevant, social facts do the fundamental work in making the law what it is—work that is explanatorily prior to the role of value facts. To put things metaphorically, hard positivism and soft positivism hold that there could still be law if God destroyed all value facts. Ronald Dworkin is the foremost contemporary advocate of an antipositivist position. According to Dworkin, a legal proposition is true in a given legal system if it is entailed by the set of principles that best justify the practices of the legal system.6 Since the notion of justification on which Dworkin relies is a normative notion, a consequence of Dworkin’s view is that the content of the law depends on value facts. 3 JOSEPH RAZ, ETHICS IN THE PUBLIC DOMAIN 210 (1994). Raz also puts the point epistemically: the content of the law “can be identified by reference to social facts alone, without resort to any evaluative argument.” Id. at 211. 4 See, e.g., RAZ, supra note 3, at ch. 10; JOSEPH RAZ, THE AUTHORITY OF LAW ch. 3 (1979). 5 See, e.g., Jules Coleman, Negative and Positive Positivism, 11 J. LEGAL STUD. 139 (1982); H.L.A. Hart, Postscript, in THE CONCEPT OF LAW (2nd ed., 1997). 6 See RONALD DWORKIN, LAW’S EMPIRE (1986).
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
23
Understanding and resolving the debate between positivists and antipositivists requires understanding the nature of the relevant determination relation—the relation between determinants of legal content and legal content. The debate, as noted, concerns whether law practices are the sole determinants of legal content. It is difficult to see how one can systematically address the question of whether A facts are the sole determinants of B facts without understanding what kind of determination is at stake. But the positivist/antipositivist debate has so far been conducted with almost no attention to this crucial issue. A preliminary point is that the determination relation with which we are concerned is primarily a metaphysical, or constitutive, one, and only secondarily an epistemic one: the law-determining practices make the content of the law what it is. To put it another way, facts about the content of the law (“legal-content facts”) obtain in virtue of the law-determining practices. It is only because of this underlying metaphysical relation that we ascertain what the law is by consulting those practices. A second preliminary point, which should be uncontroversial, is that no legal-content facts are metaphysically basic or ultimate facts about the universe, facts for which there is nothing to say about what makes them the case. Legal-content facts, like facts about the meaning of words or facts about international exchange rates (e.g., that, at a particular time, a U.K. pound is worth 1.45 U.S. dollars), hold in virtue of more basic facts. The important implication for present purposes is that the full story of how the determinants of legal content make the law what it is cannot take any legal content as given. It will not be adequate, for example, to hold that law practices plus some very basic legal-content facts (for example, legal propositions concerning the relevance of law practices to the content of the law) together make the law what it is, for such an account fails to explain what it is in virtue of which the very basic legal-content facts obtain. Descriptive facts about what people said and did (and thought) in the past are among the more basic facts that determine the content of the law. I claim that the content of the law depends not just on descriptive facts but on value facts as well. Given the plausible assump-
24
MARK GREENBERG
tion that fundamental7 value facts are necessary rather than contingent, there is, however, a difficulty about expressing my claim in terms of counterfactual theses or theses about metaphysical determination. Even if the value facts are relevant to the content of the law, it is still true that the content of the law could not be different from what it is without the descriptive facts being different (since it is impossible for the value facts, being necessary, to be different from what they are). Necessary truths cannot be a nonredundant element of a supervenience base. Hence both positivists and antipositivists can agree that descriptive facts alone metaphysically determine the content of the law.8 In order to express the sense in which the content of the law is claimed to depend on value facts, we therefore need to employ a notion different from and richer than metaphysical determination. We can say that a full metaphysical (or constitutive) account of the content of the law (of why certain legal propositions are true) must appeal to value facts. I earlier put the point metaphorically by saying that if God destroyed the value facts, the law would have no content. The epistemic corollary is that working out what the law is will require reasoning about value. 7 The point of the qualification “fundamental” is to distinguish basic or pure value facts—that, say, harm is a relevant moral consideration—from applied or mixed value facts—that returning the gun to John tomorrow would be wrong. The fundamental value facts are plausibly metaphysically necessary, while the applied value facts obviously depend on contingent descriptive facts as well as on fundamental value facts. This qualification does not affect the point in the text, since the contingent facts are encompassed in the supervenience base of descriptive facts. That is, if the fundamental value facts supervene on the descriptive facts, the applied value facts will do so as well. 8 The term “metaphysical determination” is typically used to specify a form of modal determination. In this sense, that the A facts metaphysically determine the B facts does not imply that the B facts obtain in virtue of the obtaining of the A facts, or even that the B facts are more ontologically basic than the A facts. Positivists and antipositivists can agree not only that descriptive facts alone modally determine the content of the law but also that the obtaining of the relevant descriptive facts is part of the explanation of the obtaining of legal-content facts. In this paper, we will be concerned only with cases in which the putative determinants are more basic than and part of the explanation of the determined facts. For convenience, I will therefore say that the A facts metaphysically determine the B facts only when the B facts obtain at least in part in virtue of the obtaining of the A facts.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
25
As we will see, a full account of what it is in virtue of which legal-content facts obtain has to do more than describe the more basic facts that are the metaphysical determinants of legal content. The relevant determination relation is not bare metaphysical determination. (As we have just seen, if that were the relevant relation, there would be no debate between the positivists and the antipositivists. Positivists would win the debate trivially, since the descriptive facts alone fix the content of the law.) I argue for a particular understanding of the metaphysical relation (between the determinants and the legal content that they determine), which I call rational determination. Rational determination, in contrast to bare metaphysical determination, is necessarily reason-based (in a sense that I elaborate in Section II.B). A quick way to grasp the basic idea is to consider the case of aesthetic facts. Descriptive facts metaphysically determine aesthetic facts. A painting is elegant in virtue of facts about the distribution of color over the surface (and the like). But arguably there need not be reasons that explain why the relevant descriptive facts make the painting elegant. We may be able to discover which descriptive facts make paintings elegant (and even the underlying psychological mechanisms), but even if we do, those facts need not provide substantive aesthetic reasons why the painting is elegant (as opposed to causal explanations of our reactions). On this view, it may just be a brute fact that a certain configuration of paint on a surface constitutes or realizes a painting with certain aesthetic properties. (As noted below, facts about humor provide an even clearer example.) In contrast, if it is not in principle intelligible why the determinants of legal content—the relevant descriptive facts—make the law have certain content, then it does not have that content. Rational determination is an interesting and unusual metaphysical relation because it involves the notion of a reason, which may well be best understood as an epistemic notion. If so, we have an epistemic notion playing a role in a metaphysical relation. (Donald Davidson’s view of the relation between the determinants of mental content and mental content is plausibly another example of this general phenomenon.)9 For this reason, I believe that the rational-determination relation is of independent philosophical interest. 9
See notes 17 and 18.
26
MARK GREENBERG
My main goal in this paper, however, is to show that, given the nature of the relevant kind of determination, law practices—understood as descriptive facts about what people have said and done—cannot themselves determine the content of the law. Value facts are needed to determine the legal relevance of different aspects of law practices. I therefore defend an antipositivist position, one that is roughly in the neighborhood of Dworkin’s, on the basis of very general philosophical considerations unlike those on which Dworkin himself relies. 10 We have two domains of facts: a higher-level legal domain and a lower-level descriptive domain. It is, I claim, a general truth that a domain of descriptive facts can rationally determine facts in a dependent, higher-level domain only in combination with truths about which aspects of the descriptive, lower-level facts are relevant to the higher-level domain and what their relevance is. Without the standards provided by such truths, it is indeterminate which candidate facts in the higher-level domain are most supported by the lower-level facts. There is a further question about the source or nature of the needed truths (about the relevance of the descriptive facts to the higher-level domain). In the legal case, these truths are, I will suggest, truths about value. The basic argument is general enough to apply to any realm in which a body of descriptive facts is supposed to make it the case by rational determination that facts in a certain domain obtain. For example, if the relation between social practices, understood purely descriptively, and social rules is rational determination, the argument implies that social practices cannot themselves determine the content of social rules. (At that point, we reach the further question of the source of the truths needed in the case of social rules; the answer may differ from that in the legal case.) Hence the argument is of interest well beyond the philosophy of law. In this paper, I will largely confine the discussion to the legal case. 10 Dworkin’s theory of law depends on a view about the nature of “creative interpretation.” In particular, he argues that to interpret a work of art or a social practice is to try to display it as the best that it can be of its kind. See DWORKIN, supra note 6, at 49–65. Dworkin’s central argument for the position that legal interpretation is an instance of this general kind of interpretation is that this position is the best explanation of “theoretical disagreement” in law. Id. at 45–96; see also Dworkin, Law as Interpretation, in THE POLITICS OF INTERPRETATION (W.J.T. Mitchell ed., 1983).
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
27
In Section II, I clarify the premises of the argument and explain that they should not be controversial. In Section III, I examine why there is a problem of how legal content is determined. The content of the law is not simply the meanings of the words (and the contents of the mental states) that are uttered in the course of law practices. Something must determine which elements of law practices are relevant and how they combine to determine the content of the law. Next, in Section IV, I argue that law practices themselves cannot determine how they contribute to the content of the law. In Section V, I consider and respond to three related objections. Finally, in Section VI, I examine what the argument has established about the relation between law and value. 11 II. The Premises In this section, I set out the two premises of the argument and make a number of clarifications. The second premise will require a great deal more discussion than the first. I take both premises to be relatively uncontroversial in many contemporary legal systems, including those of, for example, the United States and the United Kingdom. A. Premise 1: Determinate Legal Content The first premise of the argument is the following: In the legal system under consideration, there is a substantial body of determinate legal content. My use of the term “determinate” (like my use of “determine”) is metaphysical, not epistemic. That is, for the law to be determinate on a given issue is not for us to be able to ascertain what the law requires on that issue (or still less for there to be a consensus), but for there to be a fact of the matter as to what the law requires with respect to the issue. Thus, when I say that there is a substantial body of determinate legal content, I mean roughly that there are many true legal proposi11 There are interesting connections between this paper and G.A. Cohen’s recent Facts and Principles, 31 PHIL. & PUB. AFF. 211 (2003). Cohen’s paper came to my attention too late for me to explore the connections here, however.
MARK GREENBERG
28
tions (in the particular legal system). What do I mean by “legal propositions”? 12 A legal proposition is a legal standard or requirement. An example might be the proposition that any person who, by means of deceit, intentionally deprives another person of property worth more than a thousand dollars shall be imprisoned for not more than six months. For a legal proposition to be true in a particular legal system is for it to be a true statement of the law of that legal system.13 D is consistent with the law’s being indeterminate to some extent, and it is deliberately vague about how much determinacy there is. I think it is obvious that D is true in the legal systems of many contemporary nations. B. Premise 2: The Role of Law-Determining Practices The second premise is: The law-determining practices in part determine the content of the law. The basic idea behind L is that the law depends on the law practices. L thus rules out, for example, the extreme natural-law position that the law is simply whatever morality requires. I take it, however, that very few contemporary legal theorists would defend this position or any other position that makes law practices irrelevant to the content of the law. By the term “law practices” (or, more fully, “law-determining practices”) I mean to include at least constitutions, statutes, executive orders, judicial and administrative decisions, and regulations. Although it is unidiomatic, I will refer to a particular constitution, statute, judicial decision, and so on as a law practice. So a practice, in my usage, need not be a habitual or ongoing pattern of action. I need to clarify what I mean by saying that a practice can be, for example, a statute. Lawyers often talk as if a statute (or other law practice) is simply a text. It is of course permissible to use the word “statute” (or “constitution,” “judicial decision,” etc.) to refer to the corresponding text, and I will occasionally write in this way. But if law practices are to be de12 13
The term is Dworkin’s. See DWORKIN, supra note 6, at 4. I will usually omit the qualification about a particular legal system.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
29
terminants of the content of the law, the relevant practice must be, for example, the fact that a majority of the members of the legislature voted in a certain way with respect to a text (or alternatively the event of their having done so), not merely the text itself. So as I will generally use the term, “statute” (“constitution,” etc.) is shorthand for a collection of facts (or events),14 not a text. In general, then, law practices consist of ordinary empirical facts about what people thought, said, and did in various circumstances.15 For example, law practices potentially include the facts that, in a particular historical context, a legislative committee issued a certain report, various speeches were made in a legislative debate, a bill that would have repealed a statute failed to pass, a concurring judge issued a certain opinion, and an executive official announced a particular view of a statute.16 Once I have clarified the claim that law practices partially determine the content of the law, I will be able to say something more precise about what counts as a law practice. When L says that law practices determine (in part) the content of the law, what sense of “determine” is involved? As noted above, a preliminary point is that L’s claim is constitutive or metaphysical, not epistemic. That is, it is not a claim that we use law practices to ascertain what the content of the law is, but that such practices make it the case that the content of the law is what it is. I maintain that the relevant kind of determination is not bare metaphysical determination but what we can call rational determination. 14 I will hereafter ignore the possibility of taking law practices to be composed of events rather than facts. 15 Hypothetical decisions arguably play a significant role in determining the content of the law, but for purposes of this paper they will largely be ignored. Susan Hurley characterizes hypothetical decisions as hypothetical cases that have a settled resolution. See S.L. Hurley, Coherence, Hypothetical Cases, and Precedent, 10 OXFORD J. LEGAL STUD. 221 (1990). Another possibility is to include any hypothetical case that has a determinate right answer, even if there is disagreement on its resolution. There would be disagreement about which hypothetical cases had determinate right answers and therefore about which were determinants of legal content. 16 Nothing turns on how we individuate practices, at least in the first instance. For example, a legislative committee’s issuance of a report could be considered part of the circumstances in which a majority of the legislature voted for a statute or could be considered a separate practice. Once the roles of different elements of law practices are determined, there may be a basis for individuation.
30
MARK GREENBERG
The A facts rationally determine the B facts just in case the A facts metaphysically determine the B facts and the obtaining of the A facts makes intelligible or rationally explains the B facts’ obtaining. Thus, L is the conjunction of two doctrines, a metaphysical-determination doctrine and a rational-relation doctrine. Let me elaborate. I will make the (uncontroversial, I hope) assumption that there are facts that (1) are ontologically more basic than facts about legal content and (2) metaphysically determine that the content of the law is what it is. The metaphysical-determination doctrine is that these more basic facts that determine the content of the law non-redundantly include law practices. Metaphysical determination can be brute. If the A facts are more basic facts that metaphysically determine the B facts, there is a sense in which the A facts explain the B facts, for the A facts are more basic facts, the obtaining of which entails that the B facts obtain. But there need be no explanation of why the obtaining of particular A facts has the consequence that it does for the B facts. To dramatize the point, even a perfectly rational being may not be able to see why it is that particular A facts make particular B facts obtain. The metaphysical-determination doctrine is not enough to capture our ordinary understanding (which L attempts to articulate) of the nature of the determination relation between the law practices and the content of the law. We also need the rational-relation doctrine, which holds that the relation between the determinants of legal content and legal content is reason-based. In the relevant sense, a reason is a consideration that makes the relevant explanandum intelligible.17 Here is one way to put the point. There are indefinitely many possible mappings, from complete sets of law practices to legal content (to complete sets of legal propositions). As far as the metaphysical-determination doctrine goes, it could simply be arbitrary which mapping is 17 I will not attempt to spell out the relevant notion of a reason more fully here. One possibility is that the best way to do so is in terms of idealized human reasoning ability. For example, the idea might be that practices yield a legal proposition if and only if an ideal reasoner would see that they do. The notion of a reason would hence be an epistemic notion. In that case, L would imply that the metaphysics of law involves an epistemic notion; that is, what the law is would depend in part on what an ideal human reasoner would find intelligible.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
31
the legally correct one. In other words, the connection between a difference in the practices and a consequent difference in the content of the law could be brute. For example, it is consistent with the truth of the metaphysical-determination doctrine that, say, the deletion of one seemingly unimportant word in one subclause of one minor administrative regulation would result in the elimination of all legal content in the United States—in there being no true legal propositions in the U.S. legal system (though there is no explanation of why it would do so). By contrast, according to the rational-relation doctrine, the correct mapping must be such that there are reasons why law practices have the consequences they do for the content of the law. To put it metaphorically, the relation between the law practices and the content of the law must be transparent.18 (For the relation to be opaque would be for it to be the case that any change in law practices could have, so far as we could tell, any effect on the content of the law. The effects on the content of the law could be unfathomable and unpredictable, even if fully determinate.) It bears emphasis that what must be rationally intelligible is not the content of the law but the relation between determinants of legal content and legal content. L holds not that the content of the law must be rational or reasonable but that it must be intelligible that the determinants of legal content make the content of the law what it is. For example, there must be a reason that deleting a particular word from a statutory text would have the impact on the law that it would in fact have.19 Another important clarification is that it is no part of rational determination that the reasons in question must be value facts. The reasons 18 A useful comparison can be made to certain well-known positions in the philosophy of mind. Donald Davidson’s radical interpretation approach to mental and linguistic content presupposes that behavior determines the contents of mental states and the meaning of linguistic expressions in a way that must be intelligible or transparent. Davidson, Radical Interpretation, in INQUIRIES INTO TRUTH AND INTERPRETATION (1984); and Davidson, Belief and the Basis of Meaning, in INQUIRIES INTO TRUTH AND INTERPRETATION (1984). Similarly, Saul Kripke’s “Kripkenstein” discussion presupposes that we must be able to “read off” the contents of mental states from the determinants of content. SAUL KRIPKE, WITTGENSTEIN ON RULES AND PRIVATE LANGUAGE 24, 29 (1982). See note 25. 19 At this point in the text, I have deleted a paragraph that appeared in the original publication of this paper. I have also made a few changes in the next few paragraphs.
32
MARK GREENBERG
that the determining facts must provide are considerations that explain in rational terms why particular facts of the target domain, as opposed to others, obtain. In general, nonnormative (and nonevaluative) facts can constitute reasons of the relevant kind. Here is an example from a different domain. Consider the facts that (in a particular economy) the total amount of demand deposits is 2 million units and the total amount of currency in the hands of the public is 1 million units. With the fact that the money supply M1 consists in demand deposits plus currency in the hands of the public, these facts make rationally intelligible that the total amount of M1 (in the economy in question) is 3 million units. As far as the rational-relation doctrine is concerned, it is an open question whether there are nonnormative, nonevaluative facts that could constitute reasons for legal facts – and indeed whether there are value facts that could do so. (My ultimate view, of course, is not that value facts could themselves provide such reasons, but that both descriptive and value facts are needed.) The point is important because otherwise positivists could not accept the rational-relation doctrine. The strategy of the argument is to use the rational-relation doctrine, which, I claim below, most legal theorists implicitly accept, to argue for the controversial conclusion that value facts must be determinants of legal content. In principle, conceptual truths (that are not value facts) about law could, with law practices, make rationally intelligible the content of the law. For example, it might be claimed that it follows from the concept of law that a validly enacted statute makes true those propositions that are the ordinary meanings of the sentences of the statute. On this view, the fact that a statutory text says that any person who drives more than sixty-five miles an hour commits an offense, together with certain conceptual truths about law, makes it intelligible that the law requires that one not drive more than sixty-five miles an hour. The general point, again, is that it is a matter for argument, not something presupposed by L, what kinds of facts (if any) must supplement law practices in order for the determining facts to provide reasons that explain why particular legal propositions are true. In particular, L does not presuppose that value facts are needed. 20 20 At a later stage of analysis, we might find that there are other conditions that the determinants of legal content must satisfy. See infra the last paragraph of Section VI.A. L does not presuppose any such conditions, however.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
33
Why have I made the qualification that law practices partially determine the content of the law? Law practices must determine the content of the law. But, my argument continues, there are many possible ways in which practices could determine the content of the law. (Put another way, there are many functions that map complete sets of law practices to legal content.) Something other than law practices—X, for short—must help to determine how practices contribute to the content of the law (that is, to determine which mapping is the legally correct one). So a full account of the metaphysics of legal content involves X as well as law practices. This conclusion can be expressed in two equivalent ways. We could say that practices are the only determinants of legal content but that an account of legal content must do more than specify the determinants. This formulation is particularly natural if X consists of necessary truths.21 (A related advantage is that this way of talking highlights that practices are what typically vary, producing changes in the content of the law.) The second formulation would say that X and law practices are together the determinants of the content of the law. Because it is convenient to express this paper’s thesis by saying that X plays a role in determining legal content (and because I want to leave open the possibility that X may vary), this formulation seems preferable, and I will adopt it as my official formulation. Accordingly, I will say that law practices are only some of the determinants of the content of the law. (For brevity, however, I will sometimes omit the qualification “partially” and write simply that law practices determine the content of the law.) C. Law Practices as Descriptive Facts Let me now return to the question of what counts as a law practice. I have said that law practices consist of ordinary empirical facts about what people have thought, said, and done, including paradigmatically facts about what members of constitutional assemblies, legislatures, courts, and administrative agencies have said and done. I want to be clear about the exclusion of two kinds of facts. First, law practices do 21
See text accompanying notes 7 and 8.
34
MARK GREENBERG
not include legal-content facts. Second, law practices do not include facts about value, for example, facts about what morality requires or permits.22 The law practices thus consist of non-legal-content descriptive facts. (For convenience, I will generally write simply “descriptive facts” rather than “non-legal-content descriptive facts”; this shorthand does not reflect a presupposition that legal-content facts are value facts.) Let me explain the reasons for the two exclusions. As I said, I am assuming that the content of the law is not a metaphysically basic aspect of the world but is constituted by more basic facts. The reason for the first exclusion—of legal-content facts—is that law practices are supposed to be the determinants of legal content, not part of the legal content that is to be determined. Suppose an objector maintained that the law practices that determine legal content are themselves laden with legal content. It is certainly natural to use the term “law practices” in this way. After all, the fact that the legislature passed a bill is legal-content laden: it presupposes legal-content facts about what counts as a legislature and a bill. Since legal-content facts are not basic, however, there must be non-legal-content facts that constitute the legal-content-laden practices. At this point, we will have to appeal to descriptive facts about what people thought, said, and did—the facts that I am calling “law practices.” For example, the fact that a legislature did such and such must hold in virtue of complex descriptive facts about people’s behavior and perhaps also value facts. (If, in order to account for legal-content-laden practices, we have to appeal not merely to descriptive facts but also to value facts, so much the worse for the positivist thesis that the content of the law depends only on descriptive facts.) The convenience of 22 By “facts,” I mean simply true propositions. Hence facts about value, or value facts, are true normative or evaluative propositions, such as true propositions about what is right or wrong, good or bad, beautiful or ugly. The fact that people value something or believe something is valuable is not a value fact but a descriptive fact about people’s attitudes. For example, the fact, if it is one, that accepting bribes is wrong is a value fact; the fact that people value honesty is a descriptive fact. This paper does not attempt to address a skeptic who maintains that there are no true propositions about value. One could use an argument of the same form as mine to argue that there must be value facts—for without them there would not be determinate legal requirements. But a skeptic about value facts would no doubt take such an argument to be a case of the legal tail wagging the value dog.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
35
talking as if law practices consisted in legal-content-laden facts about the behavior of legislatures, courts, and so on should not obscure the fact that there must be more basic facts in virtue of which the legal-content facts obtain. To build legal-content facts into law practices would beg the question at the heart of this paper—the question of the necessary conditions for law practices to determine the content of the law. (For ease of exposition, I will continue to use legal-content-laden characterizations of the law practices, but the law practices should, strictly speaking, be understood to be the underlying descriptive facts in virtue of which the relevant legal-content facts obtain.) It is uncontroversial that certain kinds of facts are among the supervenience base for legal content: roughly speaking, facts about what constitutional assemblies, legislatures, courts, and administrative agencies did in the past. Of course, as just noted, such characterizations are legal-content-laden and are therefore shorthand for non-legal-content characterizations of the law practices. (I do not mean, of course, that it is uncontroversial exactly which facts of these kinds are relevant; I’ll return to this point shortly.) There are at least two kinds of controversy, however, about the determinants of legal content. First, it is controversial whether value facts are among the determinants of content. The reason for the second exclusion—the exclusion of value facts—is that this paper tries to argue from the uncontroversial claim that law practices are determinants of the content of the law to the conclusion that value facts must play a role in determining the content of the law. If law practices were taken to be value-laden, it would no longer be uncontroversial that they are determinants of legal content. (On the other hand, even those theorists who think that value facts are needed to determine the content of the law can accept that descriptive facts also play a role.) Moreover, unless we separate the descriptive facts from the value facts, we cannot evaluate whether the descriptive facts can themselves determine the content of the law. In sum, by understanding law practices to exclude value facts, I ensure that L is uncontroversial and I prepare the way for my argument that descriptive facts alone cannot determine the content of the law. The second kind of controversy about the determinants of legal content is controversy over precisely which descriptive facts are deter-
36
MARK GREENBERG
minants. I have mentioned some paradigmatic determinants of legal content. But there are other kinds of descriptive facts, for example, facts about customs, about people’s moral beliefs, about political history, and about law practices in other countries that are arguably among the determinants of legal content. Also, somewhat differently, it is controversial which facts about judicial, legislative, or executive behavior are relevant. There can be debate, for example, about the relevance of legislative history, intentions of legislators and of drafters of statutes, legislative findings, judicial obiter dicta, and executive interpretations of statutes. I propose to deal with this second kind of controversy by leaving our understanding of law practices open and nonrestrictive. There are several reasons for this approach. First, my argument is that practices, understood as composed of descriptive facts, cannot themselves determine the content of the law. If I begin with a restrictive understanding of practices, my argument will be open to the reply that I failed to include some of the relevant facts. For this reason, I want to be liberal about which descriptive facts are part of law practices. Second, my argument will not depend on exactly which descriptive facts make up law practices. Rather, I will make a general argument that descriptive facts—in particular, facts about what people have done and said and thought—cannot by themselves determine the content of the law. Therefore it will not matter precisely which such facts are included in law practices. Third, my view is ultimately that the question of which facts are part of law practices—like the question of how different aspects of law practices contribute to the content of the law—is dependent on value facts. (Indeed, I will often treat the two questions together as different aspects of the general question of the way in which law practices determine the content of the law.) As we will see, that we cannot in an uncontroversial way specify which are law practices and which are not is one consideration in support of my argument for the necessary role of value. All we need to begin with is some rough idea of law practices, which can be overinclusive. In sum, let law practices include, in addition to constitutions, statutes, and judicial and administrative decisions, any other non-legal-content descriptive facts that turn out to play a role in determining
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
37
the content of the law.23 Which facts these are and what role they play are controversial, so we can begin with a rough and inclusive understanding of law practices. One aspect of figuring out how law practices contribute to the content of the law will be figuring out which facts make a contribution and which do not. But there is no reason to expect a clean line between law practices and other facts.24 The exclusion of value facts should not be taken to suggest that law practices are to be understood in solely physical or behavioral terms. To the contrary, as I explain in the next section, I take for granted the mental and linguistic contents involved in law practices. In other words, law practices include the facts about what the actors believe, intend, and so on and about what their words mean. D. Why L Should be Uncontroversial The metaphysical-determination doctrine should be relatively uncontroversial, certainly for those who accept that there are determinate legal requirements. Positivists, Dworkinians, and contemporary natural-law theorists as well as practicing lawyers and judges accept that constitutions, statutes, and judicial and administrative decisions are (nonredundant) determinants of the content of the law. That law practices may also include other descriptive facts to the extent that those facts are determinants of the content of the law obviously cannot make the metaphysical-determination doctrine controversial. More generally, we began with the premise that there are determinate legal requirements. What makes them legal requirements is that they are determined, at least in part, by law practices. Contrast the requirements of morality (or, to take a different kind of example, of a 23 This proviso does not make L the tautological claim that the determinants of legal content determine legal content. L says that constitutions, statutes, judicial decisions, and so on are (nonredundantly) among the determinants of content. 24 One natural understanding of “law practices” is more restrictive than the way I use the term. According to this understanding, law practices are limited to (facts about) what legal institutions and officials do in their official capacities. If we used the term “law practices” in this natural way, we would need, in addition to the category of law practices, a category of other descriptive facts that play a role in determining the content of the law.
38
MARK GREENBERG
particular club). If law practices did not determine legal content, there could still be moral requirements and officials’ whims, but there would be no legal requirements. In order to think differently, one would have to hold a strange view of the metaphysics of law according to which the content of the law is what it is independently of all the facts of what people said and did that make up law practices, and law practices are at best evidence of that content. So I think it should be uncontroversial that law practices are among the determinants of the content of the law. As to the rational-relation doctrine, it is fundamental to our ordinary understanding of the law and taken for granted by most legal theory, though seldom articulated. The basic idea is that the content of the law is in principle accessible to a rational creature who is aware of the relevant law practices. It is not possible that the truth of a legal proposition could simply be opaque, in the sense that there would be no possibility of seeing its truth to be an intelligible consequence of the law practices. In other words, that the law practices support these legal propositions over all others is always a matter of reasons—where reasons are considerations in principle intelligible to rational creatures. (A corollary is that to the extent that the law practices do not provide reasons supporting certain legal propositions over others, the law is indeterminate.) I will not attempt to defend the rational-relation doctrine fully here but will mention a few considerations. Suppose the A facts metaphysically determine the B facts, but the relation between the A facts and the B facts is opaque. In that case, how could we know about the B facts? One possibility is that we have access to the B facts independently of our knowledge of the A facts. An example might be the relation between the microphysical facts about someone’s brain and the facts about that person’s conscious experience. Suppose that the microphysical facts metaphysically determine the facts about the person’s conscious experience but that the relation is opaque. The opaqueness of the relation does not affect the person’s ability to know the facts about his conscious experience, because we do not in general learn about our conscious experience by working it out from the microphysical facts. (Moreover, since we have independent knowledge of conscious experience, we might be able to discover correla-
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
39
tions between microphysical facts and conscious experience even if those correlations were not intelligible even in principle.) To take a different kind of example, the microphysical facts may metaphysically determine the facts about the weather, and the relation may be opaque, but again, we do not learn about the weather by working it out from the microphysical facts. A second possibility is that we do work out the B facts from the A facts but that we have a nonrational, perhaps hardwired, capacity to do so. For example, it is plausible that the facts about what was said and done (on a particular occasion, say) determine whether what was said and done was funny (and to what degree and in what way). And we do work out whether an incident was funny from the facts about what was done and said. It is plausible, however, that the relation between what was said and done and its funniness is not necessarily transparent to all rational creatures; our ability to know what is funny may depend on species-specific tendencies; that is, there may not be reasons that make the humor facts intelligible; it may just be a brute fact that humans find certain things funny. 25 Law seems different from both of these kinds of cases. First, our only access to the content of the law is through law practices. It is not as if we can find out what the law is directly or through some other route. And the whole enterprise of law-making is premised on the assumption that the behavior of legislators, judges, and other lawmakers will have understandable and predictable consequences for the content of the law. Second, we are able to work out what the law is and predict the effect on the law of changes in law practices through reasons, not through some nonrational human tendency to have correct law reactions to law practices. 25 Compare the issue of how facts about our use of words determine their meaning. Natural languages are a biological creation. Although many philosophers have thought differently (see note 18), we cannot take for granted that the correct mapping from the use of words to their meaning will be based on reasons. How, it may be objected, would we then be able to work out from their use of words what others mean? The answer may simply be that we have a species-specific, hardwired mechanism that rules out many incorrect mappings that are not ruled out by reasons. In that case, an intelligent creature without that mechanism would not be able to work out what words mean.
MARK GREENBERG
40
When lawyers, judges, and law professors work out what the law is, they give reasons for their conclusions. Indeed, if we find that we cannot articulate reasons that justify a provisional judgment about what the law is in light of law practices, we reject the judgment. By contrast, it is notoriously difficult to explain why something is or is not funny, and we do not generally hold our judgments about humor responsible to our ability to articulate reasons for them. A related point is that we believe that we could teach any intelligent creature that is sensitive to reasons how to work out what the law is. It might be objected that although the epistemology of law is reason-based, the metaphysics might not be. It is difficult to see how such an objection could be developed. For present purposes, I will simply point out that when legal practitioners give reasons for their conclusions about what the law is, they believe that they are not merely citing evidence that is contingently connected to the content of the law; rather, they believe that they are giving the reasons that make the law what it is. The point is not that lawyers believe themselves to be infallible. Rather, they believe that when they get things right, the reasons they discover are not merely reasons for believing that the content of the law is a particular way, but the reasons that make the content of the law what it is. Although they would never put it this way, lawyers take for granted that the epistemology of law tracks its metaphysics. And the epistemology of law is plainly reason-based. Legal theorists generally take for granted some version of the claim that the relation between law practices and the content of the law is reason-based. An example is H.L.A. Hart’s argument that the vagueness and open texture of legal language have the consequence that the law is indeterminate.26 If bare metaphysical determination were all that was at issue—if it were not the case that the relation between practice and content were necessarily intelligible—the vagueness of language would in no way support the claim that law was indeterminate. Similarly, when legal realists or Critical Legal Studies theorists argue that the existence of conflicting pronouncements or doctrines in law practices results in underdetermination of the law, their arguments
26
H.L.A. HART, THE CONCEPT OF LAW ch. 7 (2nd ed. 1997).
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
41
would be beside the point if what was at stake were not rational determination.27 In general, the large body of legal theory that has explored the question of whether law practices are capable of rendering the law determinate (and if so, how determinate) presupposes that law practices determine the content of the law in a reason-based way. If the relation between law practices and the content of the law could be opaque, any set of law practices would be capable, as far as we would be able to judge, of determining any set of legal propositions. (As long as there are as many possible sets of law practices as there are possible sets of legal propositions, there is no barrier to the content of the law’s being fixed by the practices, and we would have no warrant to rely on our assessment of other putative prerequisites for practices to determine the content of the law.) In sum, the doctrine that law practices rationally determine the content of the law captures a basic conviction about the law that is shared by lawmakers, lawyers, and legal theorists and is supported by the epistemology of law. Why does it matter to my argument that the relation between law practices and the content of the law is reason-based? This paper explores the necessary conditions for law practices’ making the content of the law what it is. The central argument is that descriptive facts cannot determine their own rational significance—what reasons they provide. The argument therefore depends on the claim that the descriptive facts determine the content of the law in a reason-based way. It turns out that value facts are needed to make it intelligible that law practices support certain legal propositions over others. 28 E. The Scope of the Argument Premises D and L tell us something about the scope of my argument. The argument is sound only for legal systems in which D and L are See, e.g., Andrew Altman, Legal Realism, Critical Legal Studies, and Dworkin, 15 PHIL. & PUB. AFF. 205 (1986); Mark Kelman, Interpretive Construction in the Substantive Criminal Law, 33 STAN. L. REV. 591 (1981). 28 Suppose that the relation between law practices and the content of the law were necessarily intelligible only in a way that depends on some human-specific tendency. As long as practices must provide considerations that are intelligible (even if only to humans), a version of my argument should still go through. 27
42
MARK GREENBERG
true. So my conclusions are limited to legal systems in which there are legal requirements that are determined in part by law practices. If there is a legal system in which there are no determinate legal requirements, my argument would not apply to it. Similarly, if there is a legal system in which law practices, understood as (facts about) various people’s sayings and doings, do not play a role in determining the content of the law, my argument would not apply to it. For example, perhaps there could be a legal system in which the content of the law is determined exclusively by the content of morality or exclusively by divine will. In this paper, I do not address questions of the necessary conditions for something’s counting as a legal system. It might be argued that a substantial body of legal requirements that are determined by practices of various officials or institutions is a necessary condition for the existence of a legal system, but I do not intend to pursue such an argument. III. Is There a Distinctively Legal Problem of Content? We begin with our two premises: that the law has determinate content, and that law practices in part determine that content. Our question is: What conditions must be satisfied in order for law practices to determine legal propositions? As I said above, since we are interested in problems of the determination of content only to the extent that they are peculiarly legal, we can take for granted the content of sentences and propositional attitudes.29 So the question is: How can a collection of facts about what various people did and said (including the facts about what they intended, believed, preferred, and hoped, and about what their words meant) determine which legal propositions are true? At this point, however, it must be asked whether there is a peculiarly legal problem of content. Once we take for granted the relevant 29 There is no practical problem with taking these matters for granted and proceeding without a solution to basic problems concerning how linguistic and mental content are possible. These problems do not concern difficulties we encounter in practice in attributing linguistic and mental content; the difficulty is in saying what it is in virtue of which a linguistic expression or mental state has its content.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
43
mental and linguistic content, it may seem that no problem of legal content remains. Legal content is simply the content of the appropriate mental states and texts. In this section, I consider this possibility and argue that it is not at all plausible. The ordinary mental and linguistic content of utterances and mental states of participants in law practices—nonlegal content, for short—does not automatically endow the law with legal content. Something must determine which aspects of law practices are relevant and how they together contribute to the content of the law. In the next section, I consider the possibility that, given the content of the relevant utterances and attitudes, law practices themselves determine how they contribute to the content of the law and thus can unilaterally determine the content of the law. But before we turn to whether law practices can solve the problem of legal content, we need to see what the problem is—why the nonlegal content of law practices does not provide the content of the law. That is the topic of this section. In legal discourse, both ordinary and academic, constitutional or statutory provisions and judicial decisions are often conflated with rules or legal propositions. For example, lawyers will sometimes talk interchangeably of a statutory provision and a statutory rule, or of a judicial decision and the rule of that case. In nonphilosophical contexts there is generally no harm in this kind of talk. Since our question, however, is how law practices determine the content of the law, it is crucial not to confuse law practices with legal propositions. For example, if one assumed that a statute was the rule or proposition expressed by the words of the statute, one might think that there was no problem of how law practices could determine legal content; or one might think that the only problem was how to combine or amalgamate a large number of rules or propositions. Although it would beg the question to take legal propositions for granted, we do have the propositions that are the content of the utterances and mental states of participants in law practices. What is wrong with the idea that those propositions constitute legal content, so that law practices, once they are understood to include facts about mental and linguistic content, automatically have legal content? I will begin with the least serious problems—those concerning the attribution of nonlegal content. Although we are normally able to at-
44
MARK GREENBERG
tribute attitudes to people based on what they say and do and to attribute standard meanings to a large number of sentences of a language we speak, there are difficulties in attributing nonlegal content to aspects of a putative law practice. Here are a few examples. First, when I say that we can take for granted mental and linguistic content, I mean that we need not ignore the mental and linguistic content that is available. We should not, however, assume that all of the contents of the mental states of all of the people involved in law practices are available. That would obviously be false. In general, what is available in the standard reports of law practices is not sufficient to attribute much in the way of attitudes to the people who actually performed the actions and made the utterances; the fact that a particular legislator voted for a bill or a certain judge signed an opinion is not in general sufficient to attribute beliefs, intentions, hopes, and so on to her. Moreover, the law restricts what evidence of the intentions and beliefs of legislators and judges is acceptable to determine the content of the law. Even when the intentions of a legislator or judge are relevant to the content of the law, it is not the case that, say, her private letters or diary may be a source of that intention. Something must determine which evidence of legally relevant attitudes is legally acceptable. Second, though many sentences of natural languages have standard meanings, it is notorious that this is not true of some of the sentences uttered by those engaged in making law practices. The point here is not that in legal contexts linguistic expressions often have specialized meanings that are not straightforwardly connected to their ordinary meanings. Rather, some of the contorted sentences in the law books have no standard meaning in a natural language. Third, even when sentences taken alone have standard meanings, collections of those sentences may fail to do so. In other words, the property of having a standard meaning (on a notion of standard meaning appropriate for present purposes) is not closed under conjunction (for example, because context may introduce ambiguity into an otherwise unambiguous sentence). Setting aside these problems with ascertaining nonlegal content, we can turn to the more important question of the bearing of nonlegal content on legal content. One problem is that the nonlegal content of some elements of law practices has, or arguably has, little or nothing
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
45
to do with the legal content determined by those practices. Consider sentences in statutory preambles, sentences in presidential speeches at bill-signing ceremonies, and sentences in judicial opinions that are not necessary to the resolution of the issue before the court. Another example is the actual but unexpressed hopes of the members of the legislature as to how the courts would interpret a statute. Countless sentences are written and spoken at different stages of law-practice-making by people with myriad attitudes.30 Something must determine which sentences’ and attitudes’ contents are relevant. Another problem is that the contribution of a particular law practice to the content of the law may not be the meaning of any text or the content of any person’s mental state. The actual attitudes of appellate judges may be irrelevant; instead the relevant question may be what a hypothetical reasonable person would have intended by the words uttered by the judges or what would be the best, or the narrowest, explanation of the result reached. Another possibility is that aspects of law practices that contribute to nonlegal content in one way contribute to legal content in an entirely different way; facts about what was said and done may have peculiarly legal significance. An obvious example is that common words such as “malice” and “fault” are often used in legal discourse in a technical sense. To take a more subtle instance, when a panel of several judges is badly split, it can be a complex and tricky matter to ascertain the relevance to legal content of the meanings of the words of the different judicial opinions. Similarly, facts about the circumstances in which sayings and doings occurred that have little to do with the nonlegal content of the people’s attitudes and words may significantly affect the content of the law. For example, in a judicial decision, the fact that an issue is not in controversy arguably prevents the court’s statements on that issue from making any contribution to the content of the law. 30 In the case of a judicial decision, for example, the possibly relevant sentences include sentences uttered by the parties to the controversy, by lawyers, and by judges to lawyers and other judges. They include sentences written by judges in orders and judicial opinions. Judicial opinions alone include a large number and variety of sentences: they state facts, give reasons, summarize, make general claims about the content of the law, state holdings; moreover, there are concurring and dissenting as well as majority opinions.
46
MARK GREENBERG
Even when the content of sentences and mental states is relevant to the content of the law, there can be no mechanical derivation of the content of the law. For example, how are conflicting contents to be combined? In general, there remains the problem of how the nonlegal contents associated with different law practices interact with each other (and with other relevant aspects of law practices) to determine the content of the law. We have surveyed a number of reasons why nonlegal content—the meanings of sentences and contents of mental states—does not simply constitute legal content. But this way of thinking about the problem will have an artificial quality for those familiar with legal reasoning. The idea that the nonlegal content of law practices constitutes their legal content presupposes roughly the following picture. Associated with each law practice is a text (and perhaps some mental states). Once we have the meanings of the texts and the contents of the mental states, each law practice will be associated with a proposition or set of propositions. Ascertaining the law on a particular issue is just a matter of looking up the propositions that are applicable to the issue. Even if this picture were accurate, we have discussed a number of reasons why nonlegal content would not automatically yield legal content. But the problem is worse than these reasons would suggest. As I will now suggest, the whole picture is wrongheaded. Law practices do not determine the content of the law by contributing propositions which then get amalgamated. Here is the real problem of legal content. There are many different law practices with many different aspects or elements. There is an initial question of which facts are parts of law practices and which are not. Are preambles of bills, legislative findings, legislative committee reports, dissenting opinions, unpublished judicial decisions, customs, the Federalist Papers, and so on to be included in law practices? In my view, this question is really just part of a second question: Which aspects of, for example, judicial or legislative practices are relevant to the content of the law? Just to suggest the dimensions of the problem, here are some candidates for the relevant elements or aspects of practices. With respect to a judicial decision: the facts of the case, the judgment rendered, the words used by the court in the majority opinion, the reasons given for the outcome, the judges’ beliefs, the
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
47
judges’ identities, the level and jurisdiction of the court; with respect to a legislative action: the words of the statute, the legislature’s actual intention (if there is such a thing), the purposes that the words of the statute could reasonably be intended to implement, statements by the person who drafted the statute, speeches made during the legislative debate preceding passage, the circumstances in which the legislature acted, subsequent decisions not to repeal the statute. Third, once we know which elements of practices are relevant, the problem of determining the content of the law is not simply a problem of adding or amalgamating the various relevant aspects of practices. One obvious point is that some elements of practices are far more important than others, and elements of practices matter in different ways. But more fundamentally, as anyone familiar with legal reasoning knows, the content of the law is not determined by any kind of summing procedure, however complicated. For example, judicial decisions, constitutional provisions, and legislative history can affect what contribution a statute makes. It is not that those practices contribute propositions that are conjoined to a proposition contributed by the statute. The statute’s correct interpretation may be determined by a potential conflict with a constitutional provision or by the outcome of cases in which courts have interpreted the same or related statutes. To take a different kind of example, constitutional provisions, statutes, and judicial decisions can have an impact on the contribution of judicial and administrative decisions to the content of the law by affecting our understanding of the proper role of courts and administrative agencies. Or, differently, statutes can have an impact on what judicial decisions mean by making clear what the legislature cares about, thus affecting which differences between cases matter and consequently whether past precedents control the present issue. A final example is that the principle that a series of cases stands for is not the conjunction of the propositions announced in each case. It is safe to conclude that the law does not automatically acquire content when actions, utterances, and sentences involved in law practices are attributed content. It is a mistake even to think that the issue is how to convert nonlegal content into legal content. We need to reject the simplistic picture in which each law practice contributes to the content of the law a discrete proposition (or set of propositions),
MARK GREENBERG
48
which is the result of converting the nonlegal content of sentences and mental states into legal content. The bearing of nonlegal content on the content of the law is not mechanical. Once we root out any idea of a mechanical conversion of nonlegal content to legal content, it is clear that something must determine which aspects of law practices are relevant to the content of the law and what role those relevant aspects play in contributing to the content of the law. IV. Can Law Practices Themselves Determine How They Contribute to the Content of the Law? In this section, I consider the possibility that law practices can themselves determine how they contribute to the content of the law. I will argue that without standards independent of practices, practices cannot themselves adjudicate between ways in which practices could contribute to the content of the law. For convenience, let me introduce a term for a candidate way in which practices could contribute to the content of the law. I will call such a way a model (short for a model of the role of law-determining practices in contributing to the content of the law).31 The rational-relation doctrine tells us that there are systematic, intelligible connections between practices and the content of the law. It thus guarantees that there are rules that, given any pattern of law practices, yield a total set of legal propositions. A model is such a rule or set of rules. A model is the counterpart at the metaphysical level of a method of interpretation at the epistemic level. (A model’s being correct in a given legal system is what makes the corresponding theory of interpretation true.) Although the term is not ideal, I use “model” rather than “method of interpretation” to signal that my concern is constitutive or metaphysical, not epistemic; that is, the issue is how practices make it the case that the law’s content is what it is, not how we can ascertain the law’s content from law practices. Because it is more idiomatic, however, I will sometimes write in epistemic terms when discussing models. 31
My thanks to Nicos Stavropoulos for suggesting this term.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
49
(By way of analogy, it may be helpful to compare, on the one hand, the relation between practices and the content of the law with, on the other, the relation between words and the meaning of a sentence or group of sentences. The meaning of a sentence depends in a systematic, intelligible way on the arrangement of constituent words; analogously, the content of the law—in a given legal system at a given time—depends on the pattern of law practices. A specification of the meanings of individual words and of the compositional rules of the language is a specification of the rules by which the words determine the meaning of the sentence. Analogously, a specification of a model is a specification of the rules by which law practices determine the content of the law. In this sense, a model is the analogue of the meanings of individual words and the compositional rules for the language.) I will use the term “model” sometimes for a partial model—a rule for the relevance of some aspect of law practices, for example of legislative findings or of dissenting judicial opinions, to the content of the law—and sometimes for a complete model—all of the rules by which law practices determine the content of the law. The context should make clear whether partial or complete models are in question. The legally correct (or, for short, correct) model in a particular legal system at a particular time is the way in which practices in that legal system at that time actually contribute to the content of the law (not merely the way in which they are thought to do so). Which model is correct varies from legal system to legal system and from time to time within a legal system, since, as we will see, which model is correct depends in part on law practices. Models come at different levels of generality. More specific ones include the metaphysical counterparts of theories of constitutional, statutory, and common-law interpretation. Models can also be understood to include very general putative ways in which law practices determine what the law requires. Thus Hart’s rule-of-recognition-based theory of law and Dworkin’s “law as integrity” theory are accounts of very general models. Very general models give rise to more localized models of the contributions made by specific elements of practices. Candidate models are candidate ways in which practices contribute to the content of the law. Since the issue of how practices contribute to the content of the law has several components, models have several
50
MARK GREENBERG
closely related roles: they determine what counts as a law practice; which aspects of law practices are relevant to the content of the law; and how different relevant aspects combine to determine the content of the law, including how conflicts between relevant aspects are resolved. The question of what determines how practices contribute to the content of the law can therefore be reformulated as the question of what determines which models are correct. What settles, for example, the question whether the original-intent theory of constitutional interpretation is true? We can now turn to the main topic of this section: whether law practices can themselves determine which model is correct. Certainly the content of the law, as determined by law practices, concerns, in addition to more familiar subjects of legal regulation, what models are correct. That is, the content of the law includes rules for the bearing of law practices on the content of the law. For example, it is part of the law of the United States that the Constitution is the supreme law, that bills that have a bare majority of both houses of Congress do not contribute to the content of the law unless the president signs them, and that precedents of higher courts are binding on lower courts in the same jurisdiction. The content of the law cannot itself determine which model is correct, however, for the content of the law depends on which model is correct. If, for example, statutes contributed to the law only the plain meaning of their words, the content of the law would be different from what it would be if the legislators’ intentions made a difference. Obviously, which legal propositions are true depends on which model is correct. But as we have just seen, which model is correct depends in part on the legal propositions. The content of the law and the correct model are thus interdependent. This interdependence threatens to bring indeterminacy. Consider the law practices of a particular legal system at a particular time and ask what the content of the law is. Suppose that if candidate model A were legally correct, a certain set of legal propositions would be true, according to which model A would be correct. And if candidate model B were correct, a different set of legal propositions would be true, ac-
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
51
cording to which model B would be correct. And so on. Without some other standard, each mutually supporting pair of model and set of legal propositions is no more favored than any other pair. 32 Can law practices determine which model is correct? The prima facie problem is that we cannot appeal to practices to determine which model is correct because which model a set of practices supports itself depends on which model is correct. But let us consider the matter in more depth. If practices are to determine which model is correct, there are two possibilities. First, a privileged foundational practice (or set of foundational practices) could determine the role of other practices. This possibility encounters the problem of how practices themselves can determine which practices are foundational. For example, the fact that a judicial opinion states that only the rationale necessary to the decision of a case is contributed to the content of the law cannot determine that that is a correct account of the contribution of judicial decisions to the content of the law. Something must determine that the judicial opinion in question is relevant and trumps other conflicting practices. A putatively foundational practice cannot non-question-beggingly provide the reason that it is foundational. Moreover, it is unwarranted to assume that the significance of a putatively foundational practice is simply its nonlegal content. Its significance depends on which model is correct—the very issue the practice is supposed to resolve. In sum, a 32
This note registers a rather technical qualification and can be skipped without losing the main thread of the argument. A candidate model, given the law practices, may yield a set of legal propositions that lends support to a different, inconsistent model. To the extent that this is the case, we can say that the model is not in equilibrium (relative to the law practices). Models that are in equilibrium (or are closer to it) are plausibly favored, others things being equal, over those that are not (or are further from it). There is no reason to expect, however, that there will be typically be only one model that is closer to equilibrium than any other model. In fact, indefinitely many models are guaranteed to be in perfect equilibrium (yet yield different sets of legal propositions). For example, any model that includes a rule that practices (and thus the true legal propositions) have no bearing on which model is correct is necessarily in perfect equilibrium. Without some independent standard for what models are eligible, there is no way to rule out such models. Hence the varying degree to which different candidate models are in equilibrium does not ensure a unique correct model and determinate legal content. See also the discussion of a coherentist solution in the text below.
MARK GREENBERG
52
foundationalist solution is hopeless because it requires some independent factor that determines which practices are foundational (and what their contribution is). Second, if no practices can be assumed to have a privileged status, the remaining possibility is that all law practices together can somehow determine their own role. Such a coherentist solution might at first seem to have more going for it than the foundationalist one. The idea would be, roughly speaking, that the (total) law practices support the model that, when applied to the practices, yields the result that the practices support that very model. If no model is perfectly supported in this way, the one that comes closest is the correct one. The problem with this suggestion, crudely put, is that without substantive standards that determine the relevance of different aspects of law practices, the (total) law practices will support too many models. For any legal proposition, there will always be a model supported by the practices that yields that proposition. Or to put it another way, the formal requirement that a model be supported by or cohere with law practices is empty without substantive standards that determine what counts as a relevant difference. Suppose a body of judicial decisions seems to support the proposition that a court is to give deference to an administrative agency’s interpretation of a statute. It is consistent with those decisions for an agency’s interpretation of a statute not to deserve deference when there is a reason for the different treatment. Such a reason could be, for example, that the agency in the earlier cases, but not in the present case, had special responsibility for administration of the relevant statutory scheme. But since the facts of every case are different, if a model can count any difference as relevant, there will always be a model that is consistent with all past practices yet denies deference to agency interpretations of statutes. As I have argued more fully elsewhere, such considerations show that practices cannot determine legal content without standards independent of the practices that determine which differences are relevant and irrelevant.33 Hence law practices alone cannot yield determinate legal requirements. The point is a specific application of a familiar, 33
See Mark Greenberg & Harry Litman, The Meaning of Original Meaning, 86 614–617 (1998).
GEO L.J. 569,
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
53
more general point that Susan Hurley has developed.34 Formal requirements such as consistency are meaningful only in the light of substantive standards that limit which factors can provide reasons. It would be missing the point to suggest that law practices themselves can determine the appropriate standards. Without such standards, a requirement of adherence to practices is empty. In epistemic terms, we cannot derive the standards from the practices because the standards are a prerequisite for interpreting the practices. It may be helpful to notice that the problem has a structure similar to that of two famous philosophical puzzles: Nelson Goodman’s problem about green and grue, and Saul Kripke’s problem about plus and quus.35 In order for there to be legal requirements, it must be possible for someone to make a mistake in attributing a legal requirement (if just any attribution of a legal requirement is correct, the law requires that P and that not P and so does not require anything). One makes a mistake when one attributes a legal requirement that is not the one the law practices yield when interpreted in accordance with the correct model. For any candidate legal requirement, however, there is always a nonstandard or “bent” model that yields that requirement. It is therefore open to an interpreter charged with a mistake to claim that in attributing the legal requirement in question, she has not made a mistake in applying one model but is applying a different model. The proponent of the coherence solution will respond that law practices themselves support certain models. For example, in appealing to practices to decide cases, courts have developed well-established ways of understanding the relevance of those practices to legal content. The problem is that there will always be bent models according to which the judicial decisions (and other practices) support the bent models rather than the purportedly well-established ones. This kind of point See S.L. HURLEY, NATURAL REASONS 26, 84–88 (1989). Hurley credits Ramsey’s and Davidson’s uses of arguments with similar import. See, e.g., Donald Davidson, The Structure and Content of Truth, 87 J. PHIL. 279, 317–320 (1990). 35 See NELSON GOODMAN, FACT, FICTION, AND FORECAST 72–81 (3d ed. 1973); SAUL KRIPKE, WITTGENSTEIN ON RULES AND PRIVATE LANGUAGE 7–32 (1982). These puzzles involve concepts that seem bizarre and gerrymandered. One challenge is to determine what it is that rules such concepts out (at least in particular contexts), for if they are not ruled out, unacceptable results follow. 34
MARK GREENBERG
54
shows that there must be factors, not themselves derived from the practices, that favor some models over others. Here is an example.36 Suppose that on February 1, 2005, a judge in a state court in the United States must decide whether a woman has a federal constitutional right not to be prevented from obtaining an abortion. Imagine that the judge holds that the woman does not have such a right. It seems that the judge has misread Roe v. Wade,37 the seminal decision of the United States Supreme Court. The judge claims, however, that according to the correct model of how judicial decisions contribute to legal content, when constitutional rights of individuals are at stake and strong considerations of justice support the claims of both sides, such decisions should be understood as establishing a form of “checkerboard” solution. According to such a solution, whether a person has the right in question depends on whether the person is born on an odd- or even-numbered day.38 Since Jane Roe was born on an odd-numbered day (let us assume), Roe v. Wade’s contribution to content is that only women born on odd-numbered days have a constitutional right to an abortion. Before discussing the example, it must be emphasized that the point is not that the judge’s position should be taken seriously; on the contrary, the example depends on the fact that the judge’s position is plainly a nonstarter. Since it is evident that the position cannot be taken seriously, there must be factors that rule out models like the one in the example. The example makes the point that these factors must be independent of practices. Since the unacceptable positions that we want to exclude purport to determine what practices mean, the factors that exclude these positions cannot be based on practices. Moreover, there is no way to rule out such positions on a purely logical level, since, as will become evident, it is easy to construct self-supporting, logically consistent systems of such positions. The claim is, then, that our unwillingness to take the judge’s position seriously suggests 36
The example borrows from Dworkin’s discussion of a “checkerboard” solution to the abortion controversy. See DWORKIN, supra note 6, at 178–186. Dworkin cannot be held responsible, however, for my example. 37 Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973). 38 See DWORKIN, supra note 6, at 178–179.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
55
that we must be depending on tacit assumptions independent of law practices in determining which models are acceptable. Let us look at the example to see why practices themselves cannot exclude the judge’s model. The first objection to the judge’s position may be that the Supreme Court in Roe v. Wade said nothing about the abortion right’s depending on birth dates. The judge replies that according to the correct model, the reasons that judges give in their opinions make no or little contribution to the content of the law. A second objection may move to a different level: the practices of the legal system do not support the judge’s model. Judicial decisions, for example, do not interpret the contributions made by other decisions in such a checkerboard fashion, nor do they ignore the reasons judges give. The judge, however, claims that according to his model, judicial decisions have all along been using a bent model, according to which the reasons judges give are significant until February 1, 2005, but not afterwards. Similarly, the model specifies no checkerboard contributions to content until that date, then requires them afterwards. All of the judicial decisions so far are logically consistent with the hypothesis that they are using the bent model. Obviously a third-level objection—that the practices do not support models that give dates this sort of significance—can be met with the same sort of response. In another version of the example, the judge might claim that according to the correct model, in all cases involving the right to abortion, a Supreme Court decision’s relevance to content ends, without further action by the Court, as soon as a majority of the current Supreme Court believes that the decision was wrongly decided. Since the judge believes that that is now the situation with regard to Roe v. Wade, he claims that Roe v. Wade no longer has any bearing on the content of the law. If it is objected that the judge’s position is not an accurate account of how judicial decisions interpret past judicial decisions, the judge will claim that judicial decisions have been following his model all along. Since (let us suppose) it has never been the case before that a majority of the Supreme Court has disagreed with a past Supreme Court decision on the right to abortion, the evidence of past decisions supports the judge’s model, which treats only abortion rights cases idiosyncratically, as strongly as a more conventional one.
56
MARK GREENBERG
The point should be obvious by now: these sorts of unacceptable models are unacceptable because there are standards independent of practices that determine that some sorts of factors are irrelevant to the contributions made by practices to legal content. The practices themselves cannot be the source of the standards for which models are permissible. In this section, I have argued that practices themselves cannot determine how practices contribute to the content of the law. Although I will not discuss the point here, it is worth noting that my argument is not limited to the law. For example, the argument shows that without standards independent of the practices, no set of practices can rationally determine rules. What rules a set of practices rationally determines will depend on what aspects of the practices are relevant and how those aspects are relevant. And the practices cannot themselves resolve those issues. Similarly, my argument does not depend on the complexities of contemporary legal systems. My point therefore holds even for extremely simple cases. Even if there were only one lawmaker who uttered only simple sentences, and even if it were taken for granted that the lawmaker’s practices were legally relevant, the precise relevance of those practices would still depend on factors independent of the practices. For example, there would still be an issue of whether the relevant aspect of the practices was the meaning of the words uttered, as opposed to, say, the lawmaker’s intentions or the narrowest rationale necessary to justify the outcome of the lawmaker’s decisions. V. Objections I want now to consider three closely related objections. First, it may be objected that in practice there is often no difficulty in knowing which aspects of a practice are relevant or which facts provide reasons. Bent models are not serious candidates. Second, it may be objected that practitioners’ beliefs (or other attitudes) about value questions, not value facts, solve the problem of determining how practices contribute to the content of the law. Third, it may be said that in limiting law practices to descriptive facts, I have relied on too thin a con-
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
57
ception of law practices. Properly understood, law practices can themselves determine the content of the law. I replied to a version of the first objection in discussing the example of the abortion-rights decision, but I will make the point in more general terms here. As I have emphasized, the question of the necessary conditions for law practices to determine the content of the law is a metaphysical, not an epistemic, question. The problems that I have raised concerning how law practices determine the content of the law are not practical problems that legal interpreters encounter in trying to discover what the law requires. Hence it is no objection to my argument that legal interpreters do not encounter such problems. I have argued that there is a gap between law practices and the content of the law that can be bridged only by substantive factors independent of practices. If legal practitioners have no difficulty in crossing this gap—for example, in eliminating bent models from consideration—that must be because they take the necessary factors for granted. With respect to the example of the abortion-rights decision, I argued that practices themselves cannot rule out the judge’s bent models. Therefore our unwillingness to take the judge’s position seriously is evidence that we are relying on tacit assumptions about what models are acceptable. The lack of difficulty in practice suggests not that substantive constraints are not needed but that they are assumed. This point leads naturally to the second objection, which holds that it is the assumptions or beliefs of participants in the practice that solve the problem of how practices determine the content of the law. For example, it might be that a consensus or shared understanding among judges or legal officials determines the relevance of practices to the content of the law. Beliefs about value, not value facts, do the necessary work. As an epistemic matter, of course, we rely on our beliefs about value to ascertain what the law is. But that is exactly what we would expect if the content of the law depended on value facts. After all, in working out the truth in any domain, we must depend on our beliefs. That we do so in a given domain in no way suggests that the truth in that domain depends on our beliefs. Notice, moreover, that if the content of the law depended on beliefs about value, then in order to work out what the law was, we would have to rely on our beliefs about our
58
MARK GREENBERG
beliefs about value. For example, we might ask not whether democratic values favor intentionalist theories of statutory interpretation, but whether there is a consensus among judges that democratic values do so. The most important point is that facts about what participants believe (understand, intend, and so on) could not do the necessary work because such facts are just more descriptive facts in the same position as the rest of the law practices. As with the facts about the behavior of lawmakers, we can ask whether facts about participants’ beliefs are relevant to the content of the law, and if so, in what way. Since the content of the law is rationally determined, the answers to these questions must be provided by reasons. As I have argued, the law practices, including facts about participants’ beliefs, cannot determine their own relevance. More generally, the same kind of argument explains why the questions of value on which the content of the law depends must be resolved by substantive standards rather than by value-neutral procedures. In general, there are procedural ways to resolve value questions—flipping a coin and voting are examples. Such procedures are in the same position as other law practices, however. There have to be reasons that determine that a given procedure is the relevant one and what the significance of the procedure is to the content of the law. The third objection claims that the additional substantive factors are part of law practices themselves. I have already addressed the suggestion that the law practices, conceived as facts about behavior and mental states, determine their own relevance. The present objection is that my conception is too narrow. It somehow fails to do justice to law practices to take them to consist of ordinary empirical facts about what people have done, said, and thought. If the objection is to be more than hand-waving, the objector needs to say what practices consist of beyond such facts and how the enriching factor solves the problem. For example, it would of course be no objection to my argument to claim that the descriptive facts need to be enriched with value facts. Another unpromising possibility, addressed in Section II.C above, is for the objector to maintain that law practices are legal-content-laden. According to this version of the objection, facts about what counts as a legislature, who has authority to make law, what counts as
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
59
validly enacted, what impact a statute has on the content of the law—in general, legal-content facts concerning the relevance of law practices to legal content—are somehow part of the law practices. As argued, however, unless legal content is to be metaphysically basic, there must be an account of what determines legal content that does not presuppose it. It simply begs the question to take law practices to include legal-content facts. The objector challenges my conception of the law practices on the ground that it is too restrictive. Here is one line of thought in support of my conception. We normally assume that law practices can be looked up in the law books. But all that can be found in the law books, other than legal-content facts, are facts about what various people—legislators, judges, administrative officials, and so on—did and said and thought. If there is something else to law practices, how do we know about it? To put the point another way, if I tell you all the facts about what the relevant people said and did, believed and intended, you can work out what the law is without knowing any more about the law practices. So if there is an aspect of law practices other than these facts, it does not seem to play a role in determining the content of the law. (It is true that you may have to be skilled at legal reasoning to work out the content of the law, and that skill may include an understanding of the significance of the practices to legal content. But I have already addressed the suggestion that it is participants’ understandings, rather than the substantive factors that are the subject of those understandings, that do the necessary work.) VI. The Need for Substantive Factors Independent of Law Practices I have argued that law practices cannot themselves determine the content of the law because they cannot unilaterally determine their own contribution to the content of the law. There must be factors, independent of practices, that favor some models over others. In this section, I sketch where this argument leaves us. In particular, I explain the sense in which the argument requires facts about value, and the nature of the claimed connection between law and value.
60
MARK GREENBERG
A. Value Facts? In order for practices to yield determinate legal requirements, it has to be the case that there are truths about which models are better than others independently of how much the models are supported by law practices. Since practices must rationally determine the content of the law, truths about which models are better than others cannot simply be brute; there have to be reasons that favor some models over others. We have seen that law practices cannot determine their own contribution to the content of the law. By contrast, value facts are well suited to determining the relevance of law practices, for value facts include facts about the relevance of descriptive facts. For example, that democracy supports an intentionalist model of statutes is, if true, a value fact. What about the relevance of the value facts themselves? At least in the case of the all-things-considered truth about the relevant values, its relevance is intelligible without further reasons. If the all-things-considered truth about the relevant considerations supports a certain model of the law practices, there can be no serious question of whether that truth is itself relevant, or in what way. The significance for the law of the fact that a certain model is all-things-considered better than others is simply the fact that that model is better than others. It might be suggested that an appeal to conceptual truth offers a way to avoid the conclusion that the content of the law depends on value facts. The idea would be that the concept of law (or some other legal concept), rather than substantive value facts, determines that some models are better than others. As noted above, conceptual truth is the kind of consideration that could provide reasons of the necessary sort. The question is whether conceptual truth does so in the case of law. My response begins with two points about what notion of conceptual truth this kind of suggestion can rely on. According to what we can call a superficialist notion, conceptual truths are truths about the use of concept-words, truths that are tacitly known by all competent users of those words or are settled by community consensus about the use of the words. Given such a notion of conceptual truth, we should reject the idea that there are conceptual truths that can do the neces-
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
61
sary work. Ronald Dworkin famously argued that disputes about the grounds of law are substantive debates, not trivial quarrels over the use of words.39 Positivists have generally responded by denying that they hold the kind of view Dworkin was attacking. Thus, both sides agree that questions about which models are better than others are not merely verbal questions that can be settled by appeal to consensus criteria for the use of words. And both sides are correct on this point. When, for example, Justices of the Supreme Court debate whether legislative history is relevant to the content of the law, the dispute cannot be settled by appeal to agreed-on criteria for the use of words. A lawyer or judge who challenges well-established models is not ipso facto mistaken. For example, a lawyer could advance a novel theory according to which New Jersey statutes make no contribution to the content of the law (on the ground, say, that there is a constitutional flaw in New Jersey’s legislative process). The claim would not be straightforwardly wrong merely because it goes against the consensus model, though it is likely mistaken on substantive grounds. Second, we have seen that the practices of participants in the legal system cannot be the source of the standards that support some models over others. It follows that if conceptual truth is to be the source of the standards, conceptual truth must not be determined by the practices of participants in the legal system; it must depend on factors independent of our law practices. The consequence of these two points is that if conceptual truth is to provide the needed standards, it would have to be conceptual truth of a kind that is not determined by consensus about the use of words and is not determined by our law practices. I am sympathetic to such a notion of conceptual truth. Given such a notion, however, it is not clear that an appeal to conceptual truth is a way of avoiding the need for substantive value facts. Instead, the conceptual truths in question may include or depend on value facts, for example, facts about fairness or democracy. At this point, the burden surely rests on a proponent of the conceptual-truth suggestion to offer a position that avoids the two problems that I have just described without collapsing into a dependence on substantive value facts. 39 DWORKIN,
supra note 6, at 31–46.
62
MARK GREENBERG
A different kind of appeal to conceptual truth is possible. It could be argued not that there are conceptual truths about which models are better than others, but that conceptual truth determines that such issues are determined by a specific internal legal value. This appeal to conceptual truth does not attempt to avoid the need for value facts; it attempts to explain those value facts as internal to the law. I will turn now to the nature of legal value facts. It is worth noting, however, that an appeal to conceptual truth as the source of internal value facts will encounter the same challenge as the appeal to conceptual truth to avoid the need for value facts. Such an appeal requires an account of conceptual truth according to which truths about the concept of law are independent of our law practices yet also independent of genuine value facts. I have argued that the content of the law depends on substantive value facts. What is the nature of those value facts? The most straightforward possibility is that, other things being equal,40 models are better to the extent that they are favored by the all-things-considered truth about the applicable considerations—the Truth, for short. In other words, the legally correct standard or value is simply the truth about value. On this view, there is no special legal standard or value. For example, the bearing of legislative history on the content of the law depends on considerations of democracy, fairness, welfare, stability—on every consideration that is in fact relevant to the issue. A second possibility is that, in the special context of the law, the allthings-considered truth about the relevant considerations is that the standard for models is not the general, all-things-considered truth about the relevant considerations but some different standard. For example, it might be that, taking into account all relevant considerations, the Truth is that the legally correct resolution of value questions is the one that maximizes community wealth. According to this second possibility, special legal value facts are genuine value facts; they are the consequence of the application of genuine value facts—Truth—to the specific context of law.41 On this view, the fact that, say, wealth 40 “Other things being equal” because practices also play a role in determining which models are better than others. See Section VI.B. 41 The position Dworkin calls “conventionalism” could be advanced as a version of possibility two, though that is not exactly the way in which he presents it. See DWORKIN, supra note 6, at 114–150.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
63
maximization is the virtue of models is a genuine value fact. A version of this possibility would allow the special legal value facts to vary from legal system to legal system. On the first and second possibilities, the content of the law depends on genuine value facts in a way that is inconsistent with both hard and soft positivism. A positivist might try to argue that even if my argument so far is sound, there is a third possibility. According to this possibility, there are substantive standards that within the law do the work of value facts in resolving value questions but are not genuine value facts. We might describe this possibility by saying that legal value facts are internal to the law. The hypothetical positivist’s suggestion that legal value facts are internal to the law would have to mean more than that they have no application outside of law. There could be legal value facts that were genuine value facts applicable only in the legal context. In that case, the second possibility would be actual, and the content of the law would depend at base on genuine value facts. The third possibility is supposed to avoid the conclusion that the content of the law depends on genuine value facts. Perhaps the idea would be that legal value facts matter only to those who are trying to participate in the legal system (and only to that extent). (As with the second possibility, a version of the third possibility would allow that the internal legal value can vary from legal system to legal system.) I do not mean to suggest that the idea of internal legal values is unproblematic or even fully coherent. I therefore do not need to explain exactly what it would mean for there to be internal values. Nor do I need to explain what, other than the Truth, could make it the case that there is a special legal value. I mention the idea only because it seems to have some currency in philosophy-of-law circles. My point is simply that I do not claim in this paper to have ruled out the view that the content of the law depends on internal value facts rather than genuine ones. I will briefly comment on the problems facing this view. We have already ruled out the possibility that law practices determine their own relevance to legal content. Therefore something other than law practices would have to determine the internal value standard—to make it the case that this standard was the relevant one for the law (or for the
64
MARK GREENBERG
particular legal system). It is difficult to see what that could be other than the relevant considerations—the Truth. If we appeal to the Truth, however, we have returned to the first or second possibility. Any account of internal value facts thus faces a challenge of steering between the law practices on the one hand and the Truth on the other. I have already described the way in which an attempt to ground internal legal facts in conceptual truth faces this challenge. But the challenge confronts any account of internal value facts. For example, suppose a theorist appeals to the function of law or legal systems to ground internal value facts. On the one hand, as we saw with conceptual truth, if the law’s function is going to provide the value facts necessary for practices to determine the content of the law, that function must be determined by something independent of the law practices. On the other hand, if the law’s function is determined by the all-things-considered truth about the relevant factors, an appeal to function is not a way of avoiding an appeal to genuine value facts. Until we have an account of internal value facts that meets the challenge, it is difficult to evaluate the potential of an appeal to internal value facts. An internal-value view faces a more substantive challenge as well. Internal value facts would have to have appropriate consequences for the nature of law. In a normal or properly functioning legal system, the content of the law provides reasons for action of certain kinds for certain agents. Whether the content of the law can provide such reasons may depend on the nature and source of the legal value facts. For example, it is plausible that for a legal system to be functioning properly, the content of the law must provide genuine reasons for action for judges. An internal-value theorist must explain how legal content determined exclusively by law practices and internal value facts can provide genuine, as opposed to merely internal, reasons for action. More generally, we can investigate the nature of legal value facts by asking what role such facts must play in a theory of law. B. The Role of Value Facts Let us now turn to the role of value facts in determining the content of the law. Since I do not want to beg the question against the possibility
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
65
of a special legal value (whether internal or not), I use “X” for that property in virtue of which models are better than others. X might be, for example, (the promotion of) wealth maximization, the maintenance of the status quo, security, fairness, or morality. (If there is no special legal value, X is the Truth, in the technical sense explained above.) Note that the fact that a particular model is favored by X may be a descriptive fact (e.g., if X is wealth maximization). In that case, the relevant value fact is that X is what the goodness of models consists in. I will make two clarifications about the role of X and then consider the implications for the relation between law and value. The first point is that X only helps to determine which models are correct. X’s favoring model A over model B is neither necessary nor sufficient for A to win out over B. As we saw in Section IV, practices play a role in determining which model is better. Hence the model that is best all things considered may not be the same as the model that is ranked highest by X alone. (For simplicity I sometimes omit this qualification.) In Section IV we discussed the interdependence between models and legal content. We saw that if we hold law practices constant, different candidate models yield different sets of legal propositions. Without X, each mutually supporting pair of model and set of legal propositions is as favored as any other such pair, and indeterminacy threatens. X’s independence makes it possible for the interdependence of model and legal content not to lead to global indeterminacy. In particular, what bearing practices have on the legally correct model depends on which model is most X-justified in advance of any particular practices. For X constrains the candidate models of practices and thus makes it possible for practices to determine anything. Practices themselves have something to say about the second-order question of how practices contribute to the content of the law. But X helps to determine what practices have to say on that question. Roughly speaking, the legally correct model is the one that is most X-justified after taking into account practices in the way that it is most X-justified to take them into account.42 In other words, the legally correct model is the one that is most X-justified, all things considered. 42 In many legal systems, the practices, when taken into account in the way that is most X-justified in advance of the practices, will support a model that is not the most X-justified in advance of the practices. And when taken into account in accordance
66
MARK GREENBERG
The second point can be brought out with an objection. Suppose it is objected that X need determine only what considerations are relevant to the content of the law but need not go further and determine how conflicts between relevant considerations are to be resolved. According to this suggestion, X would eliminate some candidate models as unacceptable but would have nothing to say between models that give weight only to relevant aspects of law practices. The objector grants my argument that without an independent standard of relevance, practices could not determine which models were correct. The objector points out, however, that once we have an independent standard of relevance, practices themselves might be able to determine which models are correct. Here is a brief sketch of a reply to the objector. In order for there to be determinate legal requirements, X must do more than determine what considerations are relevant; X must favor some resolutions of conflicts between relevant considerations over others. Otherwise, given the diversity of relevant considerations and the complexity of factual variation, law practices will not yield much in the way of determinate legal requirements. Inconsistent propositions of law (and inconsistent models) will typically have some support from relevant aspects of law practices. Therefore, in order for there to be determinate legal requirements, X must not only help to determine what considerations are relevant but must also help to determine the relative importance of elements of law practices and how such elements interact. In fact there is a deeper problem with the objection. It assumes that there are discrete issues of what considerations are relevant to the content of the law and how the relevant considerations combine to determine the content of the law. It may be convenient to separate the two kinds of issues for expository purposes, but we should not be misled with that model, the practices may support yet a different model. The question therefore arises of how important it is for a model to be supported by the practices (taken into account in accordance with that model). (In the terminology of note 32 above, the more that a model is supported by the practices, the more the model is in equilibrium.) Since X is the virtue of models, X is what determines how important it is for a model to be supported by the practices. This is why it is fair to say, as I do in the text, that the legally correct model is the one that is most X-justified after taking into account the practices in the way that it is most X-justified to take them into account.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
67
into thinking that they are resolved separately. It is not the case that there is an initial, all-or-nothing determination of whether a type of consideration is relevant and then an independent, further determination of the relative importance of the relevant considerations. Rather, the reason that a consideration is relevant determines how and under what circumstances it is relevant and how much force it has relative to other considerations. For example, legislative history’s relevance to the content of the law derives, let us suppose, from its connection to the intentions of the democratically elected representatives of the people. Thus, in order to determine how important legislative history is relative to other factors, we need to ask exactly how it is related to the relevant intentions and what the importance of those intentions is. The point is that the contribution to content of some aspect of a law practice and how it interacts with other relevant aspects depend on why the aspect is relevant. If this suggestion—that relevance and relative importance are not independent questions—is right, then in helping to determine the relevance of various considerations, X will necessarily be (helping to) resolve conflicts between relevant considerations. I have argued that there is a certain kind of connection between law and value. I would like to conclude by saying something about the implications of this connection. Just for the purpose of exploring these implications, I will assume that X is morality. The point of this assumption is to make clear that even if morality were the relevant value, the consequences for the relation between law and morality would not be straightforward. As I will show, it would not follow that the content of the law would necessarily be morally good or even that the moral goodness of a candidate legal proposition would count in favor of the proposition’s being true. First, although (by assumption) morality provides legally relevant reasons independent of the content of the law, the legally correct model is not simply whatever model is morally best (or most justified). “Morally best” here means most supported or justified by moral considerations in advance of consideration of the practices of the legal system. The legally correct model need not be the morally best one in this sense because, as we have seen, practices also have an impact on which model is legally correct.
MARK GREENBERG
68
Second, morally good models do not guarantee morally good legal propositions. Even if the legally correct model was a highly morally justified one, the content of the law might be very morally bad. A democratically elected and unquestionably legitimate legislature could publicly and clearly promulgate extremely unjust statutes, such as a statute ostensibly excluding a racial minority from social welfare benefits. The judicial decisions may rely on highly morally justified models, ones that, among other things, give great weight to such morally relevant features of legislative actions as the clearly expressed intentions of the elected legislators. The most justified model, all things considered, will be a morally good one yet will yield morally bad legal content. In fact, in such a legal system less justified models could yield morally better legal content than more justified models. (In such cases, a judge might sometimes be morally obligated to circumvent the law by relying on the less justified model.) 43 Although morally justified models do not guarantee morally good legal propositions, it might be suggested that part of what makes a model morally justified is that it tends to yield morally good legal requirements.44 For example, assume that, other things being equal, a legal requirement is morally better the more it treats people fairly. Some models will in general have a greater tendency to yield legal requirements that treat people fairly. According to the suggestion under consideration, that a model has such a tendency would be one factor supporting that model. Suppose that the suggestion were correct. According to one line of thought, it follows that the content of the law would simply be whatever 43
The relation between a judge’s moral obligations and morally justified models raises interesting issues, but space does not permit discussion. 44 At the extreme, for example, a model could hold that in some circumstances the goodness of a candidate legal proposition tips the balance in favor of that legal proposition and against competing candidates. (A different way to describe such a position would be to say that value not only can help to determine which model is best, thus indirectly favoring some candidate legal propositions over others, but also can favor candidate legal propositions directly. I will not use this terminology.) As I say in the text, such a model may be less supported both by morality and by practices than models that give less weight to content-oriented considerations. I suggest below (see the last four paragraphs of Section VI.B), that the role that such a model assigns to value facts is outside the role that this paper’s arguments support.
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
69
it would be morally good for it to be (or more generally, whatever it would be most X-justified for it to be). In that case the practices would be irrelevant. This line of thought might therefore be taken to provide a reductio of my argument for the role of value in determining the way in which practices contribute to the content of the law. The line of thought is not sound, however. First, even if the tendency of a model to yield morally good legal propositions counts in favor of that model, a variety of other moral considerations favor models that make the content of the law sensitive to relevant aspects of law practices. A model may be morally better, for example, to the extent that it respects the will of the democratically elected representatives of the people, protects expectations, enables planning, provides notice of the law, treats relevantly similar practices similarly, minimizes the opportunity for officials to base their decisions on controversial beliefs, and so on. Roughly, we have a distinction between content-oriented considerations and practice-oriented considerations. The relative weight accorded by morality to these two kinds of considerations is a question for moral theory that I will not take up here. On any plausible account, however, morality will give substantial weight to practice-oriented considerations. So the morally best model (considered in advance of law practices) will make the law sensitive to relevant aspects of law practices. Second, as we have seen, the legally correct model also depends on the law practices. Apart from the weight that morality gives to practice-oriented considerations, the practices themselves may support models that make the law sensitive to practices. (Contemporary positivists, my primary target in this paper, are likely to be sympathetic to the view that practices support models that make the law sensitive to practices.) For example, although I will not defend the claim here, in the U.S. and U.K. legal systems, practices themselves strongly support models that make the law sensitive to law practices. Practices are thus a second reason that the role of value need not have the consequence that the all-things-considered best model will be one that tends to yield morally good legal propositions. (Also, even a model that has a tendency to produce morally good legal propositions may not do so, given the law practices of a particular legal system.)
70
MARK GREENBERG
Third and finally, if we reflect on the argument for value’s role in determining the content of the law, we see that it supports only a limited role for value, one that does not involve supplanting law practices or making them irrelevant. Our starting point was that law practices must determine the content of the law and that they must do so by providing reasons that favor some legal propositions over others. The crucial step in the argument was that law practices cannot provide such reasons without value facts that determine the relevance of different aspects of law practices to the content of the law. The argument thus supports the involvement of value facts in determining the content of the law only for a limited role: determining the relevance of law practices to the content of the law. We can apply this point to the specific question of to what extent a legal proposition’s goodness can help to make it true: the goodness (in terms of morality or of value X) of a candidate legal proposition is relevant to the proposition’s truth only to the extent that its goodness contributes to making it intelligible that an aspect of a particular law practice has one bearing rather than another on the content of the law. I will call this the relevance limitation. I want to emphasize that the point is only that the argument of this paper supports no more than such a limited role for value facts; the argument does not show that the role of value facts must be so limited. Whether there is some other or more expansive role for value in determining the content of the law is left open. This paper’s argument for the conclusion that value facts play a role in determining legal content is that value facts are needed in order to determine the relevance of law practices to the legal content. The argument therefore supports only that role for value facts. There might, of course, be a different argument that shows, say, that morality or some other value supplants the law practices (though of course almost no contemporary legal theorist, least of all one of my positivist targets, thinks that there is such an argument). Let us consider more specifically the implications of the relevance limitation. The limitation does not imply that the goodness of a legal proposition can never be relevant to its truth.45 The goodness of a le45 It is easy to see that the goodness of a legal proposition could have evidentiary relevance to the content of the law. Suppose that the intention of legislators matters to the content of the law. If there is reason to believe that the legislators would have
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
71
gal proposition will be relevant to the extent that it has a bearing on the intelligibility of law practices’ supporting that legal proposition over others. A Dworkinian theory of law provides a helpful example.46 Consider a model according to which law practices contribute to the content of the law precisely that set of legal propositions that best justifies those law practices. Whether this model respects the relevance limitation will depend on the notion of justification involved in the Dworkinian model. Consider a simplistic understanding of justification that has the following implication: the set of propositions that best justify the law practices is that set that results from taking the morally best set of propositions and carving out specific exceptions for the law practices of the legal system—exceptions tailored in such a way as to have no forward-looking consequences. On this understanding of justification, the model would not respect the relevance limitation, because value facts would not determine the significance of the practices; instead, the practices would simply be denied any significance by a kind of gerrymandering. On a more sophisticated notion of justification, to the extent that a legal proposition is bent or gerrymandered, it will be less good at justifying law practices. (In the extreme case just considered, where a particular law practice is simply treated as an exception without further application, that practice is not justified at all by the propositions to which it is an exception.) I think it is plausible, though I will not argue the point here, that, given a proper understanding of justification, the Dworkinian model I have described respects the relevance limitation. (Below I will consider a different model, often attributed to Dworkin, that arguably does not respect that limitation.) The relevance limitation implies that the goodness of a legal proposition is never sufficient to make it true. That value facts are needed to intended what is morally better (at least other things being equal), the moral goodness of candidate legal propositions will have a bearing on their truth because it will have a bearing on what the legislators intended. The discussion in the text concerns the question of whether the goodness of candidate propositions can have constitutive rather than evidentiary relevance. 46 I say “a Dworkinian theory” rather than “Dworkin’s theory” to avoid questions of Dworkin exegesis. I believe that the position I describe is the best understanding of Dworkin’s position. See also note 47.
72
MARK GREENBERG
determine the contribution of law practices to the content of the law does not provide a basis for making law practices irrelevant. To put it another way, that a candidate proposition is a good one does not make it intelligible that the law practices, regardless of what they happen to be, support that proposition. It might be tempting to regard a model on which the goodness of a legal proposition can, at least in some circumstances, be sufficient to make it true as the degenerate or limiting case of a model that determines the relevance of law practices to the content of the law. The model determines that in the relevant circumstances, practices have no relevance. But though this description may be formally tidy, the argument that value facts are needed to enable law practices to determine the content of the law provides no support for a model on which value facts can make practices irrelevant. In other words, though we can describe a putative “model” according to which practices provide a reason favoring any particular set of legal propositions (the morally best ones, for example), it does not follow that practices could provide such a reason. What reasons practices provide is a substantive, not a formal, question. We can apply this point to an intermediate case. Consider a model that includes rules for the contribution of law practices to the content of the law but also includes a rule of the following sort: If more than one legal proposition is supported by the (total) law practices (given the other rules of the model) to some threshold level, the legal proposition that is morally best (of those that reach the threshold) is true.47 47 Dworkin sometimes seems to suggest such a rule. See, e.g., Dworkin, supra note 6, at 284–285, 387–388; DWORKIN, TAKING RIGHTS SERIOUSLY 340, 342 (1977). And his commentators typically interpret him in this way. See, e.g., LARRY ALEXANDER & EMILY SHERWIN, THE RULE OF RULES ch. 8 (2001); John Finnis, On Reason and Authority in Law’s Empire, 6 LAW & PHIL 357, 372–374 (1987); RAZ, supra note 3, at 222–223. I think that this is not the best understanding of Dworkin’s view (and Dworkin has confirmed as much in conversation). On the best understanding, fit is merely one aspect of justification, there is no threshold level of fit, and how much fit matters relative to other aspects of justification is a substantive question of political morality. (The idea of a threshold of fit that interpretations must meet to be eligible and beyond which substantive moral considerations become relevant should be taken as merely a heuristic or expository device.) See DWORKIN, A MATTER OF PRINCIPLE 150–151 (1985); Dworkin, “Natural” Law Revisited, 34 U. FLA. L. REV. 165, 170–173 (1982); DWORKIN, supra note 6, at 231, 246–247. A
HOW FACTS MAKE LAW
73
I suggest that R is not supported by this paper’s argument for the role of value. In general, that legal proposition A has morally better content than legal proposition B does not ipso facto make it intelligible that law practices support A over B. Adding the hypothesis that law practices provide strong support for both A and B—support above some threshold level—does not change this conclusion. A moral reason for favoring proposition A over proposition B is not itself a reason provided by law practices, since it is independent of law practices. If this argument is right, my argument for the role of value facts does not support a role like that captured by R—one in which there is room for value facts to favor one legal proposition over another independently of law practices. (Again, however, the point is only that this paper’s argument does not support such a role for value facts, not that such a role is necessarily illegitimate.) In sum, even if value X were morality, it would not follow that the most morally justified model would be legally correct, and even a morally justified model would not guarantee morally good legal requirements. It is no part of the role of value argued for in this paper that the goodness of a proposition ipso facto counts in favor of the proposition’s truth. The role of value is in determining the relevance of law practices to the content of the law. VII. Conclusion I have argued that law practices, understood in a way that excludes value facts, cannot themselves determine the content of the law. Different models of the contribution of practices to the content of the law would make it the case that different legal propositions were true, and a body of law practices cannot unilaterally determine which model is different point is that Dworkin sometimes seems to suggest that there is an aspect of the question of the extent to which interpretations fit law practices that is purely formal or at least not normative. See, e.g., DWORKIN, TAKING RIGHTS SERIOUSLY, at 107 (suggesting that how much an interpretation fits is not an issue of political philosophy); see also DWORKIN, TAKING RIGHTS SERIOUSLY, at 67–68 (perhaps suggesting that there are aspects of institutional support that do not depend on issues of normative political philosophy).
74
MARK GREENBERG
correct. In order for there to be determinate legal requirements, the content of the law must also depend on facts about value. What is the role of such value facts? I have suggested that they support some models over others—that is, they help to determine which features of law practices matter and how they matter. It is not that the goodness of a candidate legal proposition counts in favor of its truth. Rather, the role of value is in helping to determine how practices contribute to the content of the law. This paper does not attempt conclusively to rule out the view that the needed legal value facts are internal to law. I have argued, however, that the proponent of such a view must overcome significant obstacles to explain how internal legal value facts could be independent of both law practices and genuine value facts. The paper also suggests a way forward: We can ask what the nature and source of legal value facts must be in order for law to have its central features, for example, for a legal system to be able to provide certain kinds of reasons for action.
3
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
On the Normative Significance of Brute Facts Ram Neta Introduction Sometimes, there are reasons for us to think or act in certain ways. We pay our taxes, we show up on time for our classes, we refuse to assent to claims that we recognize to be inconsistent, and we refrain from wanton violence, and we do each of these things because – we take it – there are reasons for us to do them. I’ll express the general point by saying that there are norms that apply to us, and to our thought and action. For a norm to apply to a person is for there to be a reason for that person to think or act in a particular way, the way indicated by the norm. Perhaps this reason is one that the person herself doesn’t in any way recognize or acknowledge. But the reason itself – whether or not it is recognized or acknowledged by the person for whom it purports to be a reason – is a norm. For instance, I might not recognize or acknowledge various norms concerning theft. But those norms still exist, and they still apply to me; there is a reason for me not to steal, whether or not I recognize or acknowledge that reason. My failure to recognize or acknowledge such reasons doesn’t make them any less real or any less applicable to me. The fact that a norm applies to someone – the fact that there is a reason for someone to think or act in a certain way – is what I’ll call a “normative fact”. All other facts I will call “non-normative”. This distinction between normative and non-normative facts has often been thought to have great metaphysical importance. In order to explain why it has been thought to have this importance, I should first draw a different distinction between two mutually exclusive and jointly ex-
RAM NETA
76
haustive kinds of facts.1 There are the “evaluative” facts, which are facts about what is good, what is bad, what is better than what, what is worse that what, and so on. All other facts are “non-evaluative”. So there are normative facts and non-normative facts (that is one exclusive and exhaustive way of dividing up the facts), and there are evaluative facts and non-evaluative facts (that is another exclusive and exhaustive way of dividing up the facts). For present purposes, we need not take a stand on how the first pair of categories is related to the second pair of categories. Now, philosophers have often been inclined to think of the world as consisting fundamentally of nothing more than the non-normative, non-evaluative facts.2 I’ll use Anscombe’s phrase “brute facts” to denote all and only those facts that are both non-normative and nonevaluative.3 Using this terminology, I will say that philosophers have often struggled to understand how the brute facts can somehow add up to normative facts of various kinds. How – they have wondered – can the brute facts make it the case that we have reason to think or act in particular ways? Typically, philosophical attempts to address this question lead to one of three results: reductionism, eliminativism, or emergentism. Reductionists attempt to show how a conglomeration of brute facts can somehow add up to a normative fact of some kind. Thus, we might try to reduce moral facts to facts about what behavior would maximize utility or fitness, epistemic facts to facts about the reliability of our belief-forming processes, semantic facts to facts about the covariation of neural events and external events, and so on. Eliminativists claim that such reduction is impossible, and so conclude 1
I hope and believe that all this talk of different “kinds of fact” is neutral with respect to various metaphysical disputes concerning facts. In any case, I seek a neutral formulation, and invite the reader to suggest one if she takes the formulation in the text to be non-neutral. 2 I will not attempt to document this historical claim, nor will I attempt to explain it. I refer the interested reader to the classic work on this topic, Burtt 1924. 3 Anscombe 1958. As Anscombe uses the term, a fact A is “brute” only relative to another fact B. She leaves it open whether there are facts that are brute relative to any other facts. She also leaves it open whether the relative bruteness of a fact has to do with its being normative or non-normative, evaluative or non-evaluative. So I’m not sure that my use of the term “brute fact” bears any significant resemblance to her use. Nonetheless, the term strikes me as both convenient and appropriately evocative.
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
77
that there really are no facts of the normative kind in question (i.e., no moral facts, no epistemic facts, no semantic facts). And finally, emergentists claim that reduction is impossible, and so conclude that the world contains facts over and above the brute facts. In his paper “How Facts Make Law”,4 Mark Greenberg offers an elegant and apparently compelling argument for emergentism about legal normative facts, or what I will call “legal emergentism”. In other words, he argues that facts about what we have legal reason to do or not to do cannot be reduced entirely to the brute facts. This is not to suggest that Greenberg thinks that the legal normative facts are metaphysically basic or primitive: he explicitly denies this. Rather, what Greenberg claims is that, while the legal normative facts might be reduced to some other facts, they cannot be reduced entirely to the brute facts. According to Greenberg, unless there were some evaluative facts, there could be no legal normative facts. In this sense, then, Greenberg’s metaphysics includes more than simply the brute facts. It also includes the evaluative facts, and it must, for Greenberg, include the evaluative facts if it is to include the legal normative facts. This is what I am calling his “legal emergentism”. Greenberg’s argument for legal emergentism seems to have very radical implications, for it suggests a more general argument for emergentism concerning all normative facts, or what I will call “normative emergentism”. If there is a sound, general argument for normative emergentism, that would be news of the very greatest importance to philosophy, for we would then know that the sparse metaphysical picture that includes nothing more than the brute facts leaves out something. If Greenberg’s argument really does give us a way to show something of this sort, then we should find this out. In this paper, I intend to find out. Specifically, I will do two things. First, I will argue that the generalization of Greenberg’s argument is not sound, and so does not establish normative emergentism. But the flaw in the generalized version of Greenberg’s argument reveals something important about his local argument for legal emergentism. And this brings me to the second goal of this paper, which is to show that the compellingness of Greenberg’s local argument for legal emergentism depends upon contingent and possibly unknown facts of legal history. If Greenberg’s 4
Greenberg. This volume.
RAM NETA
78
argument establishes its conclusion, then the fact that it establishes its conclusion cannot be known a priori. Before I begin, I must issue a brief warning about terminology. As I use the term “norm”, a norm is a reason to think or act in some way. But many philosophers – especially philosophers of law – use the term “norm” differently, so that, from the proposition that there is a norm that we V, it doesn’t immediately follow that there is a reason for us to V.5 Such philosophers might use the term “norm” to denote a certain class of actual beliefs, or statements, or sentences, or intentions, or practices. They might then sensibly ask whether there is any reason to do what certain legal norms enjoin us to do. Now, I use the term “norm” in a different sense than do these philosophers; I cannot sensibly ask whether there is any reason to do what a legal norm enjoins us to do: if there is a norm that enjoins us to do it, then it immediately follows – on my use of “norm” – that there is reason to do it. This may strike some readers as perverse stipulation on my part, but by way of excuse I note that there is no way to avoid some stipulation in the use of the term “norm”: it is a term of art, and different authors use it to mean different things. Furthermore, in using the term as I do, I follow what I take to be Greenberg’s usage. Since he is my chief target in this paper, it seems to me sensible to follow his usage. Greenberg’s Argument for Legal Emergentism In this section, I’ll state Greenberg’s argument for legal emergentism. First, I’ll briefly summarize Greenberg’s explanations of the terminology that he uses in his argument: “Legal decisions” are decisions that legislators, judges, and other people make, as well as other legally relevant historical events that can be fully characterized in brute terms. (I leave aside the difficult but irrelevant issue of what’s involved in being able to understand a historical event “fully”: however we end up settling that issue, Greenberg can then define “legal decisions” in the appropriate terms.) “Legal content” is the normative content of the law, i.e. what is legally forbidden or required, or more generally, what legal norms there are. 5
This is true of Hart, Finnis, and Raz, among others.
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
79
I should note that Greenberg distinguishes legal content from semantic content: the former is what is forbidden or required by a law, whereas the latter is what is meant by a particular sentence or thought. Using this distinction between legal content and semantic content, we can say that it is open question – and one that we don’t need to discuss here – whether the legal content of a particular law is identical to the semantic content of a sentence or thought that expresses, or lays down, that law. “Legal propositions” are propositions articulating legal content. If the entire legal content of a particular legal system were articulated in legal propositions, then the semantic content of those legal propositions would fix the entire legal content of that particular system. It is possible, though, for some of the legal content of a particular legal system to be unarticulated. From its being the law that P, it doesn’t immediately follow that anyone has articulated any legal proposition that means that P.6 Finally, to say that one thing A “provides reason for” another thing B is to say that A makes it the case that B, and makes it the case in a way that makes it at least somewhat reasonable for it to be the case that B. Equivalently, we can say that A “rationally determines” B. To illustrate: there is nothing reasonable or unreasonable about the fact that water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit, and so whatever makes it the case that water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit does not rationally determine that fact. Nothing rationally determines the fact that water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit. In contrast, it is at least somewhat reasonable for the law to require that people who are not convicted of crimes not receive punishment. It’s not just a fact that the law requires this, but it is a reasonable fact. Thus, whatever makes it the case that the law requires this, provides a reason for the law to require it, and so rationally determines that the law requires it. These examples should provide one with a general sense of how Greenberg is using the terms “provide a reason” and “rationally determine”. Admittedly, I have not given a rigorous account of these notions, but then Greenberg doesn’t offer a rigorous account either, and I’m following his practice for now in order to state his argument. It will turn out that 6
point.
I am grateful to two referees for Legal Theory for pressing me to clarify this
80
RAM NETA
his argument is subject to criticism no matter how precisely these notions are explicated. Using the terminology above then, here is Greenberg’s argument: (1) Premise D: In the legal system under consideration, there is a large body of determinate legal propositions. (2) Premise L: The legal decisions in part determine the content of the law. (3) The legal decisions can determine the content of the law only by providing reason for the content of the law being what it is. (In other words, the legal decisions can determine the content of the law only by rationally determining it.) (4) The legal decisions provide reason for the content of the law being what it is. (From 2, 3) (5) In a legal system with a large body of determinate legal propositions, the legal decisions by themselves cannot fully determine what reason they provide for the content of the law being what it is. (That is, the legal decisions cannot fully determine exactly how they rationally determine the content of the law.) (6) Something else besides the legal decisions must help to determine what reason the legal decisions provide for the content of the law being what it is. (From 1, 4, 5) (7) Evaluative facts are the only things that can play the role of helping to determining what reason the legal decisions provide for the content of the law being what it is. (8) Evaluative facts enter into determining the content of the law in the legal system under consideration. (From 6, 7) If this argument is sound, then all attempts to reduce legal content to the history of legal decisions, or to the semantic contents of written and spoken texts, or to what judges had for breakfast, must fail. For instance, all versions of legal positivism and legal realism fail. None of the brute facts can, by themselves, fully rationally determine the content of the law. That’s because they can enter into determining the content of the law only by providing reason for the law being what it is. But these facts cannot fully rationally determine their own rational significance. That is, they cannot fully rationally determine what reason they have the power to provide. And that would be true no matter how
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
81
broadly we extend this range of facts, so long as they exclude the evaluative facts and the facts about legal content. That totality of facts still could not fully determine its own rational significance for the content of the law. And so we would, according to Greenberg, need to add something to it in order fully to determine the content of the law. Here’s one intuitive way to think about Greenberg’s thesis: The law requires us to act in all sorts of determinate ways, and it forbids us to act in all sorts of determinate ways. But there must be some reason for the law to require some things and forbid other things – the law’s requirements, unlike the boiling point of water, are either reasonable or unreasonable, and something makes them either reasonable or unreasonable. The brute facts by themselves cannot provide reason for the law to issue these determinate requirements. The brute facts cannot, on their own, makes the legal requirements either reasonable or unreasonable. So there must be something over and above the brute facts that provides reason for the law to issue these determinate requirements. And this extra factor is the value facts. Greenberg thus argues that no version of legal reductionism can be right. If we grant premise 2, and so reject legal eliminativism, Greenberg makes it look as if we must accept legal emergentism. The Generalization of Greenberg’s Argument Part of what makes Greenberg’s argument so important is that it suggests a more general argument concerning all normative systems of any interest whatsoever – moral, epistemic, semantic, and so on. To see this, let’s consider whether the premises of Greenberg’s argument for legal emergentism apply more generally. Premise 1 says that in the legal system under consideration, there is a large body of determinate legal propositions. But something analogous will be true of any interesting normative system. For instance, any interesting moral code will include a large body of determinate moral requirements. Any interesting methodology will include a large body of rules for theory-choice. Any interesting linguistic system will include a large body of semantic rules. And so on. So it seems that we can generalize premise 1 as follows:
82
RAM NETA
Premise 1’: In the normative system under consideration, there is a large body of determinate normative propositions (hereafter, “norms”). Premise 2 of Greenberg’s argument says that certain brute facts – here, the legal decisions – in part determine the content of the law. But again, it seems that something analogous will be true of any interesting normative system. For instance, the normative content of a moral code depends to some extent upon various brute facts about the creatures to which the code applies (e.g. that they are mortal, that they are capable of suffering pain, that they can communicate, they are susceptible to certain kinds of temptation, and so on). The normative content of a particular scientific methodology depends to some extent upon various brute facts about the theoretical practice and practitioners to which that methodology applies (e.g. that they have certain sense organs and not others, that they are capable of making certain sorts of calculations easily but others only with great difficulty, that their sense organs can be trained to respond reliably to certain ranges of energies and not others, and so on). And the normative content of a particular linguistic system depends to some extent upon various brute facts about the creatures that employ that linguistic system (e.g. that they have a certain universal grammar hard wired, that they have learned to speak a SVO language instead of a SOV language, that they have learned to pronounce certain phonemic combination and not others, and so on). So it seems that we can generalize premise 2 as follows: Premise 2’: The brute facts in part determine the norms. Now it may be objected against premise 2’ that there are some normative facts that are metaphysically basic: they do not depend on any contingent features of the creatures to whom they apply. For instance, one might think that the categorical imperative, or modus ponens, is such a rule. I will not contest such claims here (even though I do think that they are false).7 But even if they are true, we can still accept that premise 2’ holds for all normative systems of which premise 1’ is true, 7 Briefly, the categorical imperative is not a reason for anyone to do anything: rather it is a constraint upon something’s being a good practical reason. Again, modus ponens is not a reason for anyone to think anything, but, in tandem with the laws of logic, places a constraint upon what it is for something to be a good theoretical reason.
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
83
i.e., all normative systems that generate many determinate norms. The categorical imperative, all by itself, doesn’t generate many determinate norms. It can only generate many determinate norms when it’s conjoined with lots of contingent facts about the features of the actual agents to whom it applies. The same holds of any other allegedly necessary and basic normative fact. So, even if there are necessary and basic normative facts, this does not threaten the substance of premise 2’. Premise 3 of Greenberg’s argument says that the legal decisions can determine the content of the law only by providing reason for the content of the law to be what it is. Recall that the phrase “providing reason” is here being used to signify a metaphysical relation: X provides reason for Y just in case X makes Y obtain and also makes it reasonable for Y to obtain. In this sense, nothing provides reason for water to boil at 212 degrees Fahrenheit: it just does boil at that temperature. But something does provide reason for the law to require that people not convicted of a crime not receive punishment. Instead of using the phrase “providing reason” to designate this metaphysical relation, we might equally well use the phrase “make it reasonable”. Now, we might worry that these examples do not give us a firm grasp on the metaphysical notion of “providing reason” or “making it reasonable”. Greenberg tells us a bit more about this notion, at least in its application to the law. Here’s what he says: “The basic idea is that the content of the law is in principle accessible to a rational creature who is aware of the relevant law practices. It is not possble that the truth of a legal proposition could simply be opaque, in the sense that there would be no possibility of seeing its truth to be an intelligible consequence of the law practices. In other words, that the law practices support these legal propositions over all others is always a matter of reasons – where reasons are considerations in principle intelligible to rational creatures.” I’m eventually going to raise a question about how to interpret this passage. But for now, I’ll allow the passage to stand without comment, and I’ll ask whether something analogous to this passage could be said about the determination of norms in other kinds of normative system. For instance, do the brute facts that enter into determining the norms of a moral code make it reasonable for the norms to be what they are? Do the brute facts that enter into determining the norms of a
84
RAM NETA
particular methodology make it reasonable for the norms to be what they are? Do the brute facts that enter into determining the semantic norms of a particular linguistic system make it reasonable for the norms to be what they are? I think it’s not entirely clear how to answer these questions. But I shall now argue that there is at least some plausibility in answering each of them affirmatively. Here’s my argument: If the brute facts do not make it reasonable for the norms to be what they are, then either nothing makes it reasonable for the norms to be what they are, or else the reason for the norms to be what they are includes something independent of the brute facts. Let’s consider what follows from each of these two hypotheses. If the first hypothesis is right, then nothing makes it reasonable for the norms to be what they are. In that case, it’s arbitrary that the norms are what they are, i.e., there is nothing reasonable about the norms being what they are rather than some other way; they just are that way. But if there is nothing reasonable about the norms being what they are, then those norms are like the rules of a game that there is no reason to play, or the rules of a practice that there is no reason to participate in. That is not merely to say that some particular person has no reason to follow those norms. It is rather to say that there is no reason to follow those norms. But recall that a norm, as I’m using the term here, is just a reason: if there is a norm that says to think or act in a certain way, then that is just for there to be a reason to think or act in that way. If there is no reason to follow a norm, then it is not really a norm at all. But by hypothesis, we are talking about norms. Therefore, the first hypothesis cannot be right, and so something must make it reasonable – at least more or less reasonable – for the norms to be what they are. There cannot be norms which are such that nothing makes it reasonable for them to be what they are.8 This line of reasoning will give rise to two objections: first, it may be objected that it generates an infinite regress of norms. But this isn’t so. We can avoid the infinite regress either by appeal to a big circle of 8 I remind the reader that the term “norm” is used in different ways in the literature, and on some of these uses, the reductio argument that I’ve just given will seem to be a non sequitur. It’s important, then, in going through this argument, to recall that, as I use the term “norm”, it is just a reason to think or act in a certain way.
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
85
norms, or by appeal to some foundation that makes it reasonable for the norms to be as they are, but is not itself a norm (i.e., is not itself a reason for thinking or acting in any particular way). We needn’t choose between these strategies here. Second, it might be objected that, many of the norms that actually do apply to us are arbitrary, but are, for all that, still norms. For instance, it may be said, we have reason to follow the particular linguistic norms of our language community, even though those norms are arbitrary. Again, the law gives us reason to stay within the speed limit, or to drive on a particular side of the road, even though that is arbitrary as well. The problem with this objection is that these are not cases of there being reason to follow arbitrary norms. Rather, they are cases in which the specific norms that there is reason to follow are determined by more general non-arbitrary norms, together with various non-normative contingencies. For instance, there is a general norm to the effect that we should speak in such a way as to make ourselves understood. But this general norm makes it reasonable for us to comply with the more specific norms of our linguistic community, whatever those happen to be. Again, there is a general norm to the effect that one should promote social coordination. This general norm makes it reasonable for us to comply with the laws of our land, whatever those happen to be (at least within limits). In each of these cases, one has a reason to do some specific thing by virtue of one’s reason to do some more general thing, along with the contingencies of one’s particular situation. These are not cases of having a reason to do something for no reason at all. And so these cases do not invalidate the principle used in the preceding argument: if nothing makes it reasonable for a norm to be as it is, then there is no reason to follow the norm, and so it is not really a norm at all. I conclude that the first hypothesis cannot be right. If the second hypothesis is right, then the reason for the norms to be what they are is independent of the brute facts that determine those norms. In that case, it’s arbitrary that the norms are binding on all and only those creatures of which the determining brute facts obtain. For instance, it’s arbitrary that the norms are binding on mortal creatures who are capable of feeling pain, rather than on angels. And in that case, again
86
RAM NETA
there’s nothing that makes the norms in question binding on creatures like us. And that is just to say that, while the norms might really be norms for some creatures, they are not really norms for us. There is nothing about us that engages the binding power of the norms. They are like rules of a game that creatures like us have no reason to play. On the strength of these considerations, I provisionally conclude that neither the first nor the second hypothesis can be right. (I will raise a question about this conclusion below, when I reconsider the question of what it is for one thing to “provide reason” for another thing.) It seems then, that for any normative system of which premises 1’ and 2’ are true (i.e., any normative system that has determinate norms that are binding on us), the brute facts that determine the norms of that system must provide reason for us to comply with those norms, and so provide reason for those norms to be what they are. If the preceding line of thought is correct (and, as I said, I will re-examine it below), then we can generalize premise 3 as follows: Premise 3’: The brute facts can determine the norms only by providing reason (i.e., making it reasonable) for the norms being what they are. Premise 5 of Greenberg’s argument says that, in a legal system with a large body of determinate legal propositions, the legal decisions by themselves cannot fully determine what reason they provide for the content of the law being what it is. There are many possible mappings from legal decisions to legal content, and the legal decisions, according to Greenberg, cannot themselves determine which possible mapping is the correct one. That’s why other facts, besides the legal decisions, are needed to determine the correct mapping. Now, so far as I can see, whether or not premise 5 is true depends upon nothing that is peculiar to legal normativity. Whatever it is that makes it the case that legal decisions cannot determine the correct mapping from themselves onto the facts of legal content, that same thing makes it the case that brute facts cannot determine the correct mapping from themselves onto the normative facts. If there is supposed to be something special about the determination of legal norms in this regard, it’s not at all clear what it could be. This suggests that, if premise 5 is true, then so is.
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
87
Premise 5’: In a normative system with a large body of determinate norms, the brute facts by themselves cannot fully determine what reason they provide for the norms being what they are. Finally, premise 7 says that evaluative facts are the only things that can play the role of helping to determine what reason the legal decisions provide for the content of the law being what it is. Greenberg explains this point in the following passage: “In order for practices to yield determinate legal requirements, it has to be the case that there are truths about which models are better than others, independently of how much the models are supported by law practices. Since practices must rationally determine the content of the law, truths about which models are better than others cannot simply be brute; there have to be reasons that favor some models over others.” The reason that favors some models over others includes facts about which models are better. And these are evaluative facts. But for the same reason that evaluative facts are needed fully to determine the correct mapping from legal decisions onto legal norms, so too, it seems, evaluative facts will be needed fully to determine the correct mapping from brute facts onto other norms generally. If premise 7 is true, then so is Premise 7’: Evaluative facts are the only things that can plausibly play the role of helping to determine what reason the brute facts provide for the norms being what they are. With all this in mind, we can now consider the following generalization of Greenberg’s argument: (1’) Premise D: In the normative system under consideration, there is a large body of determinate norms. (2’) Premise L: The brute facts in part determine the norms. (3’) The brute facts can determine the norms only by providing reason for the norms being what they are. (4’) The brute facts provide reason for the norms being what they are. (From 2’, 3’) (5’) In a normative system with a large body of determinate norms, the brute facts by themselves cannot fully determine what reason they provide for the norms being what they are.
88
RAM NETA
(6’) Something else besides the brute facts must help to determine what reason the brute facts provide for the norms being what they are. (From 1’, 4’, 5’) (7’) Evaluative facts are the only things that can play the role of helping to determine what reason the brute facts provide for the norms being what they are. (8’) Evaluative facts enter into determining the norms in the normative system under consideration. (From 6’, 7’) By generalizing Greenberg’s argument, we’ve constructed an argument for normative emergentism. The argument assumes (premise 2’) that normative eliminativism is false, but from this assumption it argues against normative reductionism. What’s Wrong with this General Argument for Normative Emergentism? I will now argue that this general argument for normative emergentism is not compelling, for either premise 5’ is false or else we have no reason to accept premise 3’. I’ll begin by leveling an objection against premise 5’, and then I’ll argue that the only way to save premise 5’ from this objection is to interpret the notion of “providing reason” in such a way that we have no reason to accept premise 3’. Premise 5’ says that in a normative system with a large body of determinate norms, the brute facts by themselves cannot fully determine what reason they provide for the norms to be what they are. But let’s consider whether or not this general claim is borne out by cases. Of course, any discussion of such cases – any discussion of why we have reason to do one thing or another – is bound to be controversial. I cannot hope to find a case that will uncontroversially tell for or against the generalization of Greenberg’s argument. But we can test that argument against what seem to us to be plausible views concerning familiar examples of normativity. To this end, I will now briefly consider the normativity of promising. Suppose that Alice mowed the lawn because John promised to pay her 400 dollars if she mowed the lawn. Now, what makes it wrong for John to break his promise? It seems to me that any plausible answer to
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
89
this question will involve the following claim: what makes it wrong for John to break his promise in this case is that it would be a case of breaking a promise, and it’s generally wrong to break promises. That’s an essential feature of the practice of promising: making a promise places one under an obligation to keep it (except in very special circumstances). The practice of promising essentially involves norms that are binding on all those who participate in that practice, and these norms include the norm that it’s wrong to break a promise. When I say that the practice of promising “essentially” involves these norms, I mean that it’s not just true by convention that the practice of promising involves the norm that it’s wrong to break one’s promise. For instance, it’s not just that we happen to use the word “promising” to designate practices that have this feature. Rather, the practice of promising essentially involves the norm in question because there’s no way for the practice of promising to exist over time without that norm. If people were generally permitted to break their promises, then people would know (or soon come to know) this fact, and so would not expect other people to keep their promises, and so would tend not to act on any such expectation. Everyone would soon come to know all of this, and so no one would continue to expect her own promises to have any impact. Each person would thereby lose any motivation to make promises. In short, the institution of promising would quickly cease to exist if people were generally permitted to break their promises. For there to be an institution of promising, it must be impermissible – and known to be impermissible – for people to break their promises. Thus, it’s an essential feature of the practice of promising that it involves the norm that it’s wrong to break your promises. 9 But this just pushes our original question back a step. Now, instead of asking why John must keep his promise, we can ask why John has reason to participate in this essentially norm-governed practice of 9 Again, although this point about promising seems very plausible to me, I recognize that it is not uncontroversial. (For an instance of an opposing view, see Ardal 1968.) I don’t know of any examples that will serve my dialectical purposes at this point and that are entirely uncontroversial. But I hope and believe that, in order to motivate the present dilemma to the generalization of Greenberg’s argument, I needn’t rely on there being any uncontroversial examples of norms fully determined by the brute facts. It should suffice if I can display the epistemic possibility that there are such examples.
90
RAM NETA
promising. And there could be any number of answers to this question. For instance, John might have an interest in having his lawn mowed, and he recognizes that the only way that he can get his lawn mowed is by promising some able-bodied person that he’ll pay them if they mow it. Or John might, like some children, simply enjoy participating in a social practice that affords him opportunities for market interactions with others. But whatever the story, so long as John has some reason to participate in the practice of promising, he has reason to comply with the norms of that practice, and so they are norms for him. Now let’s consider whether I have indeed provided “the reason”, in Greenberg’s sense, for why it’s wrong for John to break his promise. We can assess this issue by considering what it is for a normative fact to obtain “for a reason”, on Greenberg’s use of that phrase. Paraphrasing the passage from Greenberg quoted above, we can say this: for norms to obtain for some reason is for the contents of those norms to be in principle accessible to a rational creature who is aware of the relevant brute determinants of the norms. It is not possible that the obtaining of those normative facts could simply be opaque, in the sense that there would be no possibility of seeing them to be intelligible consequences of the relevant brute determinants. In other words, that the relevant brute determinants support these normative propositions over all others is always a matter of considerations in principle intelligible to rational creatures. Now, it seems that, in the story that I’ve told about promising, I’ve shown how the wrongness of John’s breaking his promise follows from the general prohibition against breaking promises. But that general prohibition is an intelligible consequence of various brute facts about the practice of promising. And John’s reasons for engaging in that practice are themselves intelligible consequences of various brute facts about John (e.g., what he likes and doesn’t like). Thus, it seems, I’ve articulated the reason why it’s wrong for John to break his promise. I’ve provided an explanation of what makes it wrong for John to break his promise, and my explanation adverts solely to brute facts about the social function of the institution of promising, and about John. If my explanation is correct, then premise 5’ is false. (And if you disagree with my explanation of what makes it wrong for John to break his promise, then I invite you to consider whether there isn’t another case that would falsify premise 5’.)
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
91
Of course this is not because of something special about promising. Whether or not my story about promising is correct, it seems that many other norms may be equally susceptible of explanation in terms of brute facts. In order to rescue premise 5’ from all such apparent counterexamples, the proponent of the argument above seems to have only one way out, and that is to claim that these explanations are not explanations of the right kind at all – they do not explain what reason there is for the norms being what they are. Now, I’m not sure how strong a case can be made for or against this way of avoiding the objection that I’ve just leveled, and that’s because I’m not sure exactly what’s involved in the metaphysical constitutive relation that Greenberg uses the term “providing a reason” to designate. What exactly is involved in the relation between normative facts and their brute determinants being “a matter of reasons” or “in principle intelligible to a rational creature”? Since I’m not sure how to answer these questions, I will not attempt to argue against this proposed way of avoiding my objection to premise 5’. Instead, I’ll point out that it does the proponent of the argument above no good. For if my aforestated explanation of why it’s wrong to break a promise doesn’t “provide a reason” (in the relevant sense) for why it’s wrong to break a promise, then I don’t see why we should think that anything else “provides a reason” (in the relevant sense). In other words, if I haven’t provided a reason for why it’s wrong to break a promise, then why should we think that there is any reason (in the relevant sense) for why it’s wrong to break a promise? Why shouldn’t we just think that the wrongness of breaking a promise is a metaphysically basic fact of the world? Or it obtains not by virtue of something else providing a reason for it, but rather by virtue of something making it obtain, in some non-rational way? Now recall that we have already considered a plausible argument against these apparent possibilities: if there is no reason for the norms to be as they are, then we have no reason to comply with those norms, and so they are not really norms. Now, I do find something plausible about this argument, when the notion of “reason” that it employs is broad enough to include the kind of reason that I gave above for why it’s wrong to break a promise. But if the notion of “reason” is interpreted more narrowly than that, then the argument seems to me to lose
92
RAM NETA
its plausibility. Why should there be a “reason”, in this special, narrow sense, for why it’s wrong to break a promise? If there is no “reason”, in this special narrow sense, for why it’s wrong to break a promise, then how does it follow that we have no “reason”, in a broad, ordinary sense, for not breaking our promises? Pending an answer to this question, there seems to be nothing to favor premise 3’. In sum, if we grant that premise 5’ is false, then we have no reason to believe premise 3’. Either way, the general argument above for normative emergentism is not compelling. Maybe normative emergentism is true, but its truth is not proven by the general argument constructed in the previous section. Now what, if anything, does this show about Greenberg’s local argument for legal emergentism? The Consequences for Greenberg’s Local Argument for Legal Emergentism In the preceding section, I argued that the generalization of Greenberg’s argument is not compelling: either premise 5’ is false (for the brute facts do fully determine that John must pay Alice 400 dollars), or else we have no reason to believe premise 3’ (for we don’t know enough about the rational determination relation). I will now argue that an analogous, but somewhat weaker, conclusion is true of Greenberg’s local argument for legal emergentism: either premise 5 is subject to historical falsification (for all we know a priori, the legal decisions may be such as to fully determine their own rational significance), or else we have no reason to believe premise 3 (for we don’t know enough about the rational determination relation). Recall that premise 5 says that in a legal system with a large body of determinate legal propositions, the legal decisions by themselves cannot fully determine what reason they provide for the content of the law being what it is. Now, in defending this premise, Greenberg considers a foundationalist challenge to it and a coherentist challenge to it. I would like to focus on the foundationalist challenge, and Greenberg’s response to it. Here is the relevant passage: “If practices are to determine which model is correct, there are two possibilities. First, a privileged foundational practice (or set of foun-
ON THE NORMATIVE SIGNIFICANCE OF BRUTE FACTS
93
dational practices) could determine the role of other practices. This possibility encounters the problem of how practices themselves can determine which practices are foundational. ...A putatively foundational practice cannot non-question-beggingly provide the reason that it is foundational.” Now, I’d like to ask why a putatively foundational decision cannot provide the reason that it is foundational. Suppose that, when the framers drafted the American Constitution, they had included a clause that stated explicitly and precisely how the content of the law was to depend upon the legal decisions. Couldn’t their decision to include this clause be a foundational decision, and provide the reason why it is foundational? Perhaps Greenberg would object that their decision to include this clause could not have non-question-beggingly provided the reason why it is foundational: if their decision is foundational, that’s just because the decision says that it is foundational, and so its foundational character is founded in a question-begging way. But then I ask: why must the reason why a decision is foundational be non-question-begging, in this sense? I can imagine, on Greenberg’s behalf, the following response to this question: suppose that there are two putatively foundational but inconsistent decisions. In that case, neither decision can provide a reason why it, rather than the other, is really the foundational decision. And so neither decision can be foundational, except by dint of the help of some additional factor. In that case, each decision has its rational significance for the content of the law only by dint of the help of this additional factor. I’ll grant that this is true in the case in which we have two putatively foundational but inconsistent decisions. But I don’t see why it should also be true for the case in which we have only one putatively foundational decision, the dictates of which are consistent with all of the legal decisions. In short, I don’t see why there cannot be a genuinely foundational decision that provides the reason why it is itself foundational. Of course, different philosophical accounts of law will provide us with different understandings of what sort of event can qualify as a genuinely foundational decision, and how such a foundational decision can provide the reason why it is itself foundational.
RAM NETA
94
But we do not need to canvass these differences here in order to appreciate the force of the general challenge to Greenberg’s argument. Now, it is open to Greenberg to reply to this general challenge as follows: in the case that I’ve described, what we have is a legal decision that metaphysically determines the correct model, but not a legal decision that provides a reason why one model is correct. Since I don’t have a fully firm grip on the notion of “providing a reason”, I will not object to this response. But then, if that is the response, I wonder what reason we have to think that decisions determine the content of the law by “providing reason” (in the relevant sense) for that content being what it is. So my challenge to Greenberg stands as follows: If, as a matter of contingent historical fact, the framers had included a clause explicitly stating precisely how legal decisions were to determine legal content, and this clause was consistent with all other legal decisions, then either premise 5 of Greenberg’s argument is false, or else we don’t have any reason to accept premise 3. Either way, the compellingness of Greenberg’s argument depends on a matter of contingent, and possibly unknown, fact of legal history. 10 Works Cited Anscombe, G.E.M. 1958. “On Brute Facts”. Analysis 18: 69-72. Ardal, Pall. 1968. “’And That’s a Promise’.” The Philosophical Quarterly 18: 225-237. Burtt, E.A. 1924. The Metaphysical Foundations of Modern Physical Science. Doubleday: New York. Greenberg, Mark. Forthcoming. “How Facts Make Law.” Legal Theory.
10
I am grateful to Mark Greenberg, Doug Lavin, Eric Marcus, Ori Simchen, and two anonymous referees for Legal Theory for helpful discussion of an earlier draft of this paper, and for much useful discussion of the relevant issues. I am also grateful to Enrique Villanueva for organizing the very useful conference for which this piece was written.
4
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
On Practices and the Law1 Mark Greenberg In a recent article, “How Facts Make Law” (Greenberg 2004; hereafter HFML), I launch an attack on a fundamental doctrine of legal positivism. I argue that nonnormative facts cannot themselves constitutively determine legal facts. In response, Ram Neta (this volume) defends the view that nonnormative social facts are in general sufficient to determine2 normative facts, including moral and legal facts. Neta’s paper provides a useful opportunity to address a spelled-out version of this view, which in various forms is widely held in philosophy of law and other areas of philosophy. 3 Some terminology will be helpful. A legal fact4 is a true legal proposition – a fact about the content of the law. That contracts for the sale of land must be in writing is a legal fact in many legal systems. A normative fact is a true normative proposition, such as a true proposition about what is good or bad, right or wrong, fair or 1 I am grateful to Ram Neta for his rich and interesting paper, to which I am not able to do full justice here. Thanks to Pamela Hieronymi, Kinch Hoekstra, Herb Morris, Stephen Munzer, Ram Nea, Keemin Ngiam, Scott Shapiro, Seana Shiffrin, and Nicos Stavropoulos for comments on drafts and helpful discussions. 2 Throughout, unless otherwise specified, the relevant kind of determination is constitutive, not modal. For more on constitutive and modal determination, see Greenberg 2005. 3 For examples of writers who hold that nonnormative social facts are sufficient to determine legal facts, see Coleman (2001, chaps. 7, 11); Hart (1994, chaps. 5-6); Himma (2002); Raz (1983, chaps. 3-4; 1994); Shapiro (1998). As noted below, not all of these writers would agree with Neta that legal facts are normative facts. See below note 7 and accompanying text. For examples of writers who hold that nonnormative facts are sufficient to determine normative facts (outside the legal domain), see Hart (1994, chaps. 4-5, pp. 256-257); Gilbert (2000, chap. 5); Schapiro (2003). 4 In HFML (p. 158), I used the uglier term “legal-content fact.”
96
MARK GREENBERG
unfair.5 A descriptive fact is a nonnormative, contingent fact. Lawdetermining practices, or law practices for short, are descriptive facts – paradigmatically facts about the attitudes, sayings, and doings of members of constitutional assemblies, legislatures, and courts – that are constitutive determinants of the legal facts. I call the relevant facts “law-determining practices” rather than “legal decisions” because the term “decisions” tends to suggest judicial decisions in particular. (In this somewhat unidiomatic usage, law practices are facts.)6 One clarification may be helpful at the start. Unlike some legal positivists, Neta holds that legal facts are normative facts. In particular, he holds that part of what it is for a legal standard to apply to someone is for there to be a reason for that person to act in accordance with the standard.7 Indeed, a main theme of Neta’s paper is that the le5 I use the term “normative facts” here in the way that I used “value facts” in HFML. Thus, I use the term to include what are sometimes called “evaluative facts,” such as facts about what is good or bad. For further explanation of the notion of a normative fact, see below note 7 and HFML, p. 167 n. 22. It is worth noting that some nonnormative facts are not descriptive facts, for descriptive facts, as defined in the text immediately below, do not include necessary truths. Therefore, even if descriptive facts cannot alone determine the content of the law, it does not immediately follow that normative facts must play a role. See HFML, pp. 165-166, 187-188. 6 For elaboration of the notion of a law practice, see HFML, Sections II.B. & II.C.. For ease of exposition, I use legal-content-laden terms, such as “legislature” and “court” in characterizing law practices. Strictly speaking, however, the law practices should be understood to be the underlying descriptive facts in virtue of which the relevant legal facts obtain. Since legal facts are not basic, there must be non-legal facts that constitute the legal-content-laden practices. These more basic facts will include descriptive facts—in particular, the facts that I am calling “law practices.” For example, the fact that a legislature enacted a statute must hold in virtue of complex descriptive facts about people’s attitudes and behavior and perhaps also normative facts. (If, in order to account for legal-content-laden practices, we have to appeal not merely to descriptive facts but also to normative facts, so much the worse for the positivist thesis that the content of the law depends only on descriptive facts.) The convenience of talking as if law practices consisted in legal-content-laden facts about the behavior of legislatures, courts, and so on should not obscure the fact that there must be more basic facts in virtue of which the legal facts obtain. 7 See Neta (2004, pp. 75-76). Neta defines “normative fact” as a “fact that there is a reason for someone to think or act in a certain way” (p. 75). See also text accompanying notes 22-24 below. As I am using the term, the category of normative facts is broader than the category captured by Neta’s definition. (For one thing, as
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW
97
gal domain and a range of normative domains are on a par. He takes a view about all normative facts (or at least about many kinds of normative facts) that is parallel to the legal positivist’s view about legal facts. The project of HFML and the present paper is to argue that normative facts determine legal facts without assuming that legal facts are themselves normative facts. A consequence of these terms of engagement is that my case against Neta’s view is more straightforward outside the legal domain, for example in the case of moral norms. In the case of non-legal norms, I simply argue that Neta’s account fails to explain the existence of reasons for action. In particular, I show that there are many cases in which his purported sufficient conditions for the existence of norms are satisfied, though there is no reason to act in accordance with the putative norms. In the legal case, I forswear a parallel strategy because, as noted above, my goal is to show that normative facts are constitutive determinants of legal facts without assuming that legal facts are normative facts. In HFML, I therefore offer a different kind of argument – an argument driven by a claim about the nature of constitutive determination in the legal domain. In the present paper, we see that the argument of HFML provides leverage in the legal domain that is neither available nor necessary in the moral domain. 1. Rational Determination I begin by summarizing my argument in HFML and Neta’s response. My argument starts from the relatively uncontroversial premise that descriptive facts are among the constitutive determinants of the content of the law. What is controversial is whether descriptive facts can alone determine the content of the law or whether normative facts must also play a part. I argue that a full account of what makes the law have the content that it does will have to appeal to normative facts. remarked in note 5 above, I include what are sometimes called evaluative facts among the normative facts.) But any fact that is constituted in part by the fact that there is a reason for someone to think or act in a certain way is certainly a normative fact. Any differences between Neta’s and my understanding of the term will not matter for purposes of this paper.
98
MARK GREENBERG
A variety of domains – the aesthetic, the political, the legal – are plausibly not metaphysically or ontologically basic. That is, the facts of those domains are constituted by more ontologically basic facts. In each case, the obtaining of the more basic facts makes it the case that the facts of the target domain obtain. For example, perhaps facts about the arrangement of paint on a surface make it the case that a painting is elegant or clumsy. I take for granted that legal facts are not a metaphysically basic aspect of the world (HFML, pp. 158-159). In the legal case, the more basic determining facts include law practices – facts about the attitudes and behavior of various people – and may or may not include various normative facts as well.8 The nature of the making-it-the-case or constitutive determination relation may vary from domain to domain. To make progress on the central issue of the determinants of legal content, we need to investigate the nature of the determination relation in the legal domain. I claim that this relation is what I call rational determination. Suppose that we are trying to give a constitutive account of the facts of a target domain. Suppose further that we are able to specify constitutive determinants of the target facts that modally entail those target facts. In some domains, this may be all that a constitutive account can do. The constitutive determinants need not provide reasons why the target facts obtain. A reason, in the relevant sense, is a consideration that makes an explanandum intelligible in rational terms (as opposed to, say, emotional or aesthetic ones) – or, as I will sometimes write, that makes an explanandum rationally intelligible.9 By contrast, if the nature of the determination relation in a domain is rational determination, the determining facts must make it rationally intelligible that the facts of the target domain are thus and so. We can call this the rational-relation requirement.10 8 To be precise, for a given domain, there may be more than one (sufficient and non-redundant) set of determining facts at different levels of ontological basicness. For example, in the legal case we could consider the relation between microphysical facts and legal facts, rather than the relation between facts about behavior (and attitudes) and legal facts. In the present paper, I focus on the relation between facts about behavior and legal facts. See also note 12 below. 9 For more on the notion of a reason, see HFML, pp. 164-166. 10 In HFML, I use the term rational-relation doctrine. That certain facts provide reasons for the target facts is only a necessary, not a sufficient, condition for their
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW
99
Let us consider an example of a domain in which there need be no reasons of the relevant sort. I mentioned above the view that aesthetic facts obtain in virtue of physical facts. A painting is elegant or clumsy in virtue of the arrangement of paint on the canvas.11 But arguably the facts about the arrangement of paint need not provide a reason for the painting’s elegance or clumsiness (though those facts will no doubt be part of a causal, for example psychological, explanation of our reactions). For example, a small difference in the arrangement of paint might make a clumsy scene elegant, without providing a reason for the difference. (Imagine trying to explain the impact on the painting’s beauty to a rational Martian or to a fully rational human being who lacked the relevant sensitivity.) The claim that the relevant determination relation in law is rational determination is a claim that the relation is different in this respect from the relation between physical and aesthetic facts.12 There must be reasons why the relevant facts, for example about decisions of legislatures and courts, have the effects on the law that they do. (This metaphysical truth is reflected in the requirement that judges must articulate reasons for their decisions.) For example, it could not be a brute fact – one that cannot be rendered rationally intelligible – that a particular change in the wording of a statute produces a particular change in the content of the law.13 rationally determining those target facts. See HFML 163-164; Greenberg 2006, section II. 11 On another possible view, facts about the artist’s intentions are also determinants of the aesthetic facts. On that view too, it is plausible that the determining facts need not provide reasons for the obtaining of the aesthetic facts. 12 It might be asked whether, for a given domain, the nature of the relation between determining facts and target facts could be different for different sets of determining facts at different levels. My view, which I will not argue for here, is that rational determination requires only that the legal facts be intelligible in light of some set of non-legal facts. At any rate, as noted above, when I discuss the nature of the determination relation in the legal domain, I mean to consider the relation between, on the one hand, facts about behavior and attitudes and, on the other, legal facts. 13 This point will not make sense unless one is careful to distinguish between, on the one hand, legal texts (and the meaning of those texts) and the content of the law. Neither a statutory text, nor its meaning, is the content of the law, though they may be determinants of the content of the law. See HFML, Section III.
100 MARK GREENBERG
Two clarifications will be important for what follows. First, rational intelligibility is a relation between the determinants of legal facts and the legal facts, not a monadic property of the legal facts.14 The obtaining of particular legal facts, as opposed to others, must be rationally intelligible in light of the determining facts. The rational-relation requirement imposes no requirement on the content of the law independent of the determining facts. For example, it does not demand that the content of the law be reasonable or rational. Second, the rational-relation requirement does not specify that the reasons it requires must be normative facts. The reasons that the determinants of legal content must provide are considerations that explain in rational terms why the law has the content that it does. As far as the rational-relation requirement is concerned, it is an open question whether there are nonnormative facts that could constitute such reasons – and indeed whether there are normative facts that could do so.15 (The point is important because otherwise positivists could not accept the rational-relation requirement. The strategy of the argument is to use the rational-relation requirement, which I claim most legal theorists implicitly accept, to argue for the controversial conclusion that normative facts must be determinants of legal content.) The present paper creates a special risk of confusion with respect to this point because I also use the term “reason” in another context. A crucial issue in the debate between Neta and me concerns reasons for actions, and in fact I distinguish two types of reasons for action.16 I therefore want to emphasize that the reasons that the rational-relation requirement demands are not reasons for action. Again, they are considerations that explain in rational terms why particular legal facts obtain.17 14
See HFML, p. 165. See HFML, pp. 165-166. My ultimate view, of course, is not that normative facts could themselves provide such reasons, but that both nonnormative and normative facts are needed. Law practices are essential. 16 See section 2 below. 17 I do not mean to suggest that the term “reason” is ambiguous. As noted below, Pamela Hieronymi (MS) helpfully offers an account of a reason as a consideration that bears on a question. See below note 31. In these terms, the reasons that the rational-relation requirement demands are considerations that bear on the constitutive 15
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 101
In HFML, I sketch some arguments for the proposition that the relation between law practices and legal facts is rational determination, at least in the U.S. and U.K. legal systems and perhaps in all legal systems,18 though I do not attempt anything like a full defense of that proposition. I also give reasons for thinking that the proposition is fundamental to our ordinary understanding of the law and taken for granted by much contemporary legal theory, though seldom articulated (HFML, pp. 170-172). 19 I then argue that law practices cannot themselves rationally determine legal facts, or indeed norms of any kind. In brief, the argument is that law practices cannot unilaterally determine their own relevance. Factors independent of law practices must be part of what makes their contribution intelligible in rational terms. In the case of law, the best candidates for such factors are normative facts. (In other domains, there may be other candidates (see HFML, p. 161, Section VI.A.).) For example, facts about democracy and fairness explain the relevance of the publicly promulgated decisions of elected legislators to the content of the law.20 question of why particular legal facts, rather than others, obtain. The two types of reasons for action that I distinguish in section 2 below are considerations that bear on the question of what to do (“normative reasons”) and considerations that bear on the question why a person acts in a particular way (“motivating reasons”). 18 To be more precise, all those in which the legal facts are determined by law practices. 19 I am not especially concerned with the question of whether rational determination is the determination relation in all possible legal systems. Readers who believe that rational determination is the determination relation only in some legal systems can understand my arguments as applicable only to those legal systems. 20 The rational-relation requirement demands that there be reasons for legal facts, not that there be reasons for the relevance of law practices to legal facts. So why do I say that normative facts explain the relevance of law practices to legal facts? An intuitive summary of why law practices cannot themselves provide reasons for legal facts is that there are many possible ways in which law practices could bear on the legal facts, and they cannot determine their own relevance. For this reason, I sometimes express the rational-relation requirement by saying that there have to be reasons that determine the contribution of law practices to the legal facts. This way of putting things should not mislead us into thinking that the rational-relation requirement is a requirement not only that there be reasons for the legal facts, but that there be reasons that explain why those reasons are reasons. That line of thought could suggest that an explanatory regress lurks. What the rational-relation requirement demands is not
102 MARK GREENBERG
Neta’s leading idea is that descriptive facts21 can alone provide a full account of normativity. He first argues that, in all normative domains, descriptive facts in part determine the content of the norms, and the relevant determination relation is rational determination. Next, he tries to show that a full account of moral norms need appeal only to descriptive facts. In particular, he offers an account of the wrongness of promise-breaking entirely in terms of descriptive facts. He concludes that it does not follow from the fact that rational determination is the relevant determination relation that normative facts must play a role. Neta also gives a purported counterexample in the legal domain – a case in which he claims that descriptive facts can themselves rationally determine the content of the law. I now turn to Neta’s attempts to show that descriptive facts can alone determine norms in the moral and legal domains. First (section 2), Neta’s account of why it is wrong to break promises fails. It begs the question by taking for granted that a person’s desires or other motivational states necessarily justify the actions that they motivate. Second (section 3), I turn to Neta’s alleged legal counterexample. Here I draw on the notion of rational determination to move the argument beyond an appeal to intuitions. I show that the facts to which Neta appeals cannot be reasons of the required sort, for they already take for granted what needs to be explained – the bearing of law practices on the content of the law. Also, Neta fails to consider the possibility that normative facts are playing a silent role in his example. Finally, in section 4, I turn to the larger issue of how far my argument applies to other normative domains.
higher-order reasons, but determining facts that together provide reasons for the legal facts. In Greenberg 2006, I discuss objections that claim that if normative facts are needed to explain the relevance of law practices, an infinite regress is generated. See Greenberg 2006, section VI, especially note 57 and accompanying text. 21 Neta uses “brute fact” instead of “descriptive fact.” For the notion of a descriptive fact, see above p. 1. It is important to note that in HFML and here, I use “brute fact” in a way different from Neta’s. See above text accompanying notes 13 and HFML, pp. 160, 171. To avoid confusion, I replace Neta’s “brute fact” with “descriptive fact” in quotations from his article (using square brackets to indicate the change).
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 103
2. Neta’s Account of Promising Neta uses the case of promising to argue that the full metaphysical explanation of normative facts need appeal only to descriptive facts. He offers an example in which “Alice mowed the lawn because John promised to pay her four hundred dollars” and tries to explain “what makes it wrong for John to break his promise.” (p. 88).22 According to Neta, “any plausible answer” involves the claim that “what makes it wrong for John to break his promise ...is that it would be a case of breaking a promise, and it’s generally wrong to break promises” (pp. 88-89). This first step appeals directly to a normative fact – that “it’s generally wrong to break promises.” The success of Neta’s argument depends on whether he can explain, without appealing to any normative (or evaluative) facts, why it is generally wrong to break promises.23 Let’s call the moral requirement that one not break promises – the requirement that Neta is trying to explain – “the promising norm.” Before proceeding, we need to clarify one terminological matter. As I will use the term “norm,” a necessary condition for there to be a norm is that there actually be reasons for agents to act in the way required by the norm. (Occasionally, I will use “genuine norm” rather than merely “norm” as a reminder of my usage.) Other writers sometimes use the term in a purely descriptive way according to which, roughly speaking, for there to be a norm in a particular group requiring that people act in a certain way, it is sufficient that members of the group think and act as if there were a genuine norm requiring that people act in that way. Consider the putative norm of a crime gang that its members must commit an assassination once a year. In my usage, the fact that the gang members accept the putative norm – regularly comply with it, enforce it by punishing those who fail to comply, believe that they are justified in doing so, and so on – does not make it the case that the putative norm is a norm. Neta is very clear that he uses “norm” in my sense.24 I
22
Page numbers standing alone are references to Neta (this volume). When Neta writes that it is “generally wrong to break promises,” I assume that he means that it is wrong to break promises without good enough reasons, or that it is wrong prima facie or pro tanto. For brevity, I will follow his way of talking. 24 See Neta (this volume, pp. 78, 84 & n. 8, also p. 75). 23
104 MARK GREENBERG
will continue to use “putative norm” to express the purely descriptive sense of “norm.”25 Neta’s attempted explanation appeals crucially to the existence of “the practice of promising.” In what follows, I show that Neta’s practice-based explanation of the wrongness of breaking promises doesn’t work. I want first to note a problem with the whole approach, however. Neta seems to assume, as many writers do, that promising could not take place in the absence of a particular kind of social practice or convention.26 In my view, this is a mistake. A Robinson Crusoe who has never made a promise and has no practices or conventions with regard to promising can, when he encounters a castaway for the first time, promise to help him (and it would be wrong for Crusoe to break that promise without good enough reasons). The fact that breaking promises is wrong in the absence of any practice supports the view that the existence of a practice is not what accounts for the wrongness of breaking promises even in cases where there is a practice. On this view, which I do not attempt to defend here, the appeal to practices is misguided from the start. But for present purposes, I consider Neta’s practice-based explanation on its own terms. Neta’s attempted explanation begins with the claim that “[t]he practice of promising essentially involves” the promising norm (p. 89). This claim might be taken to suggest that he is using the notion of a practice in such a way that the existence of a practice is constituted in part by the obtaining of normative facts. If that were the case, it would be question-begging to appeal to a practice as a necessary part of the explanation, for the goal is to explain normative facts in nonnormative terms. (See HFML, Sections II.C, V). Neta soon makes clear, however, that the claim is that “the institution of promising would quickly cease to exist if people were gener-
25 Other pairs of terms, such as “social rule”/“normative rule” and “effective norm”/“valid norm” have been used to mark distinctions in the general neighborhood of the distinction that I explain in the text. I prefer my terminology because it does not suggest that norms and putative norms are two species of a single genus. 26 There is a large literature on promising. Three recent papers, which provide citations to the literature, are Seana Shiffrin (MS); David Owens (2006); Jay Wallace and Nico Kolodny (2003).
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 105
ally permitted to break their promises” (p. 89).27 There is no suggestion here that the existence of the practice is constituted by normative facts. Rather, when Neta claims that the norm is essential to the practice, he means that as a causal or historical matter, if people did not treat promises as creating obligations, the practice would cease to exist. We need to be clear what exactly is necessary for the practice to exist. Is it that breaking promises be wrong? Or is it that people believe that it is wrong, criticize others for breaking their promises, think it is appropriate to criticize others for this reason, and so on? Neta uses phrases that are ambiguous with respect to this point. That it is “permitted” to break promises could mean either that people permit each other to break promises with impunity (i.e., that they act as if promising were not wrong) or that breaking promises (even without good reason) is in fact morally permissible. What is required in order for people’s expectations not to be disappointed and thus for the practice to continue is that many people believe it is wrong to break promises, not that it actually be wrong. In fact, even this formulation seems too strong: what is necessary is not that people believe that it is wrong to violate the norm, but that people act as if they believe it is wrong – or, to oversimplify in order to save words, that people generally comply with the promising norm. Whether in practice people will not comply with the norm unless they believe that it is wrong to violate it (as opposed to believing, for example, that others believe it is wrong and will punish violations) is an empirical question. In sum, all that Neta can take to be necessary for the promising practice is that people often act in accordance with the putative promising norm, not that it be wrong to violate it. Neta sees that this kind of dependence of a practice on a putative norm does not suffice to show that violating the putative norm is wrong, i.e., that it is a genuine norm. But he thinks that all that needs to be added to complete the account is that a person has a reason to participate in the practice: 27 We need a qualification similar to that of the previous note. I assume that Neta means that the institution would quickly cease to exist if people were generally permitted to break their promises without good enough reasons, or if people did not even count the existence of a promise as a prima facie or pro tanto reason for acting in accordance with it.
106 MARK GREENBERG
[That the norm is essential] just pushes the original question back a step. Now, instead of asking why John must keep his promise, we can ask why John has reason to participate in this essentially norm-governed practice of promising. And there could be any number of answers to this question. For instance, John might have an interest in having his lawn mowed, and he recognizes that the only way that he can get his lawn mowed is by promising some able-bodied person that he’ll pay them if they mow it. Or John might, like some children, simply enjoy participating in a social practice that affords him opportunities for market interactions with others. But whatever the story, so long as John has some reason to participate in the practice of promising, he has reason to comply with the norms of that practice, and so they are norms for him (pp. 89-90).
At this point, Neta takes himself to have established what he set out to show – that it is wrong to break promises (p. 90). In short, Neta’s argument is that if a person (believes he) could obtain something he wants28 or enjoys by participating in a practice that would not exist if people did not generally comply with certain putative norms, then those putative norms are genuine norms, and it is wrong, even morally wrong, not to comply with them. Neta’s account cannot be right. There are many silly, corrupt, or evil practices that would “cease to exist” if the participants did not generally comply with certain putative norms. The practices of operating fraudulent investment schemes, hazing new recruits, and selling children into sexual slavery are examples. People can obtain things they want by participating in these practices. It hardly follows that it is wrong, even pro tanto, not to comply with the putative norms of the practices. 28 I interpret John’s having “an interest in having his lawn mowed” as John’s wanting his lawn mowed (or wanting other things that require having his lawn mowed), as opposed to some evaluative fact, e.g., that it is good for John to have it mowed. Neta is supposed to be appealing only to descriptive facts. Moreover, if Neta intended to appeal to the goodness of John’s lawn being mowed, as opposed to John’s motivation, there would be no need for him to appeal to John’s recognition “that the only way that he can get his lawn mowed is by promising some able-bodied person that he’ll pay them if they mow it.” (p. 90).
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 107
It is useful to develop one example a little more fully. Consider the protection racket – organized crime’s practice of providing “protection” for restaurants, shops, and other businesses in return for regular payments. It is essential to the existence of the practice that many of the lower-level criminals who carry out the work of extorting protection money follow putative norms requiring them to use violence against shop owners who fail to pay protection money, and requiring them not to inform on their bosses. Similarly, it is essential to the continued existence of the practice that many of the small business owners follow putative norms requiring them to pay on time and not to complain to the police. Therefore, the protection-racket practice “essentially involves” the putative norms that it is wrong to refuse to pay protection money and that it is wrong to report the organizers to the police in exactly the sense in which Neta claims that the promising practice essentially involves the promising norm.29 The criminals who extort the protection fees can obtain things they want by participating in the practice – they earn a living and avoid being punished by their bosses. Even the business owners have self-interested reasons for participating in the practice. They avoid having their shops burned down or worse, and they may in fact receive some protection from petty criminals and other benefits from being on good terms with the organized crime gangs. According to Neta’s position, it is enough that they have “some reason to participate,” not that the all-things-considered balance of reasons supports participating (though in some cases it may do so). It hardly follows that the putative norms of the practice are genuine norms, let alone that it would be wrong not to comply, for example, by reporting the organizers to the police or refusing to pay protection money. Where does Neta’s argument go wrong? First, it is not warranted to move from John’s wanting to have his lawn mowed to John’s having 29 It might be suggested that it matters to Neta’s account not only that participants comply with putative norms but that they believe that it would be wrong not to do so. In response, we may suppose that it is essential to the protection racket that many of the lower-level criminals believe that it would be wrong of them to refuse to extort money, to report their bosses to the police, and so on. We could even suppose that it is essential to the continued existence of the practice that many of the small business owners who pay for protection believe that it would be wrong of them not to pay. It still would not follow that it would be wrong for anyone to violate the putative norms.
108 MARK GREENBERG
reason to comply with the essential norms of the practice of promising. That someone could obtain something he wants by participating in a practice does not show that he has even a narrowly self-interested reason for complying with all the putative norms necessary for the practice to exist. One might get what one wants by making promises without keeping them. Perhaps in the case of promising it is plausible that one must generally comply with the promising norm in order to be able to use promises effectively to get what one wants. It is easy, however, to imagine practices such that one can obtain their benefits through partial or apparent participation, i.e., without complying with all of their putative norms. Moreover, at most John’s wanting to have his lawn mowed gives him a reason for keeping his promises when not doing so will hurt his reputation (or hurt his reputation more than the benefit from breaking it). It is a commonplace that there may be cases in which it is evident that breaking a promise will not harm his reputation. For instance, John might make an unwitnessed promise to a dying friend moments before the friend dies. Neta might respond that John’s behavior does not really count as promising unless he intends to keep his promises, believes that it is wrong to break them, and so on. In order to promise, one must be participating in the practice, and the promising norm is “an essential feature” of the practice.30 As emphasized above, however, Neta’s argument that the promising norm is essential establishes only that the practice wouldn’t exist if many or most people didn’t comply with (or believe in) the putative norm. It doesn’t follow that John or any particular person must believe it is wrong to break promises or intend to keep his promises in order to count as promising. But suppose that we waive this point and grant that one does not count as promising unless one accepts the promising norm. In that case, however, Neta has not shown that John has reason to promise, only that he has reason to make apparent or pseudo-promises. For pseudo-promises may well be enough for John to get what he wants. Hence, even given the assumption that one does not count as promising unless one accepts the promising norm, it does not follow, so far as Neta has argued, that John has 30 As noted above, in my view, one need not be participating in a practice in order to make a promise. For purposes of argument, I set this point aside.
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 109
any reason to accept the promising norm. Neta here runs into a problem that dogs attempts to show that it is rational to act morally. That one would be worse off if no one complied with a putative norm does not show that one has reason to comply (even if others do comply). Neta is not free to assume away the free-rider problem. A second problem with Neta’s argument is the move from John’s having a reason to comply with a putative norm to its being a genuine norm that is applicable to him (“he has reason to comply with the norms of that practice, and so they are norms for him”). This step in the argument seems to depend on an equivocation on the term “reason.” Michael Smith helpfully distinguishes between “normative reasons,” which are considerations that count in favor of, or justify Fing, and “motivating reasons,” which are factors that (potentially) motivate someone to F. (Smith 1994, pp. 14, 94-98).31 Neta’s examples of John’s reasons are John’s wanting to have his lawn mowed and his enjoyment in participating in the practice. Neta takes it as obvious that these are reasons, and offers no further explanation. Consequently, in pointing out that John has reasons to engage in the practice, Neta must be using the term to mean motivating reason. For the fact that John has a desire that would be satisfied by Fing or enjoys Fing shows immediately that John has a motivating reason to F but, without further argument, does not show that he has a normative reason to F. But the plausibility of moving from John’s having a reason to comply with a putative norm to its being a genuine norm depends on John’s reason being a normative reason. That someone believes that he can get what he wants by Fing cannot be sufficient to show that there is a norm requiring him to F. Since the issue is whether normative facts can be accounted for entirely in nonnormative terms, it obviously begs the question to move without argument from the existence of a moti31 For convenience, I will use Smith’s terminology in this paper. But my point does not depend on accepting his view of the underlying issues. It suffices for my purposes that a desire or other factor that explains an action does not necessarily justify the action or count in favor of it. Pamela Hieronymi (MS) gives an illuminating account of reasons, according to which there is only one kind of reason. On her view, the relevant distinction is between two types of questions on which reasons can bear. For my purposes, we can be neutral between Smith’s, Hieronymi’s, and other accounts. For helpful discussion of different accounts, see Hieronymi (MS).
110 MARK GREENBERG
vating reason – a descriptive fact – to the existence of a normative reason – a normative fact. It might be objected that the term “reason” is not simply ambiguous. Many motivating reasons are, or involve, normative reasons. For example, at least one kind of motivating reason to act in a particular way is in part constituted by a belief that there is a normative reason to act in that way. There are certainly important connections between motivating reasons and normative reasons. But because motivating reasons need not be normative reasons, an explanation of the existence of a normative reason must do more than point to the existence of a motivating reason. The critical question is whether it is necessary to appeal to normative facts as well. Even when a motivating reason constitutes a normative reason, the question remains whether normative facts are part of the explanation of what makes the motivating reason a normative reason. Taking for granted that no explanation is needed to get from the existence of a motivating reason to the existence of a normative reason begs the question of whether the wrongness of promise-breaking can be explained without appeal to normative facts. It might be wondered whether Neta’s position could be defended by appeal to a substantive theory according to which any desire or other state that (potentially) motivates someone’s taking a certain action counts in favor of the person’s taking that action. In the first place, such a theory is highly implausible. Moreover, the theory makes a normative claim, a claim about what kinds of things provide justifications. So an account of normativity that relies on the theory does not restrict itself to descriptive facts. At this stage, an obvious suggestion is that only good practices, or practices that it is right to engage in, generate genuine norms. The problem, again, is that the suggestion explains normativity only by appealing to normative facts – facts about which practices are good or which courses of action are right. There are further problems with Neta’s account. That it is wrong to break promises (even prima facie or pro tanto) is a stronger claim than that there is some normative reason for not doing so. This is not the place to attempt a full account of exactly how it is stronger. One type of case will suffice. I have reasons to have annual medical tests.
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 111
It does not follow that it is wrong for me not to do so, not even pro tanto. Certainly, it doesn’t follow that it is morally wrong.32 Furthermore, it would not make a difference if there were a practice to which the putative norm of annual medical tests was essential in Neta’s sense. In fact, even if we granted for the sake of argument that all motivating reasons were normative reasons (and assumed that normative facts were not an essential part of the explanation of this proposition), Neta’s account would seem to lack the resources to explain specifically moral wrongness. John’s wanting to have his lawn mowed, even if it is a normative reason, is the wrong kind of material with which to explain the moral wrongness of his breaking promises. And since Neta’s project is to explain the wrongness of breaking promises without appealing to normative facts, Neta obviously cannot appeal to moral facts. 3. Neta’s Legal Counterexample I now turn to Neta’s purported counterexample to my claim that normative facts are needed to determine the contribution of law practices to the content of the law – or, as I will say, to determine which model (of the contribution of law practices to the content of the law) is correct.33 He supposes that the framers of the U.S. Constitution “had included a clause that stated explicitly and precisely how the content of the law was to depend upon the law practices” (p. 93). In the last section, we were able to undermine Neta’s claim that nonnormative facts are sufficient to determine normative facts simply by considering the evidence of actual and hypothetical cases. Examples like that of the protection racket are difficult to reconcile with the claim that practices (and motivating reasons to participate in them) 32 Even moral reasons to F do not necessarily make it wrong not to F. For there can be moral reasons to take actions that are supererogatory. For example, I have moral reasons to give nine-tenths of my income to charity. It does not follow that it is morally wrong for me not to do so, not even pro tanto. 33 For more on the term model, see HFML, pp. 178-179. The legally correct (or, for short, correct) model is the way in which practices in a given legal system actually contribute to the content of the law (not merely the way in which they are thought to do so).
112 MARK GREENBERG
necessarily generate normative reasons. (It is for similar reasons that Hart’s critics were able so conclusively to dispatch Hart’s practice theory of rules as a general theory of moral and other norms.) 34 As noted, Neta assumes that legal facts constitute normative reasons for action.35 Given that assumption, it would be straightforward to mount an argument against Neta’s legal counterexample parallel to my argument against his account of normative facts generally. That a practice involves a document that explicitly and precisely (and without contradiction from other documents) specifies how the practice is to generate rules does not ensure that the practice generates normative reasons for action. As noted in the Introduction, however, I want to avoid relying on an assumption that legal facts constitute reasons for action (or, more generally, that legal facts are normative facts), so as not to beg any questions against legal positivists who do not accept the assumption. Consequently, my argument that descriptive facts cannot themselves determine legal facts must take a different form than my argument that descriptive facts do not determine moral and other normative facts. HFML introduced a new way of answering the question whether descriptive facts can themselves determine legal facts. This approach appeals to an argument about the properties the determinants of legal facts must have. In particular, I argue in HFML that in law, in contrast to many other domains, the determinants must make the facts of the target domain rationally intelligible. In Neta’s example, it is plausible, though by no means obvious, that the explicit constitutional clause would be foundational – that it would determine the relevance of other law practices to the content of the law, and that its contribution to the content of the law would not be affected by other law practices. The relevant question, however, is whether the existence of that clause (and other descriptive facts, such as the absence of competing clauses) could be the full explanation of why that clause was foundational. As we will see below, an important possibility, which Neta does not consider, is that normative facts are part of the explanation. For example, values of democracy, stability, 34 See Dworkin 1977, pp. 48-58; Raz 1999, pp. 53-58. See also Hart 1994, pp. 255-256. 35 See above note 7 and accompanying text.
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 113
and fairness support giving great weight to what the ratifiers of the Constitution and the public believed the ratifiers to be agreeing on. Should we accept Neta’s view that the descriptive facts of his hypothetical case are sufficient to determine that the imagined constitutional clause is foundational? Or do normative facts do part of the work? We can adjudicate between these and other competing accounts of legal facts by asking whether their proposed determinants satisfy the rational-relation requirement. Let us begin by distinguishing two very different approaches that a positivist could take in attempting to show that normative facts are not necessary to satisfy the rational-relation requirement. According to the first approach, the explanation of why descriptive facts are able to satisfy the rational-relation requirement is special to the legal case. Such an explanation appeals to an alleged basic truth about the nature of law (or perhaps a conceptual truth about law). An example of such an alleged truth would be the Hartian thesis that officials’ “acceptance”36 of a given rule of recognition makes that rule the correct model in the community’s legal system. A theorist might argue that understanding this thesis – grasping the explanatory significance of officials’ acceptance of a rule – is part of understanding what law is. In “Hartian Positivism and Normative Facts” (Greenberg 2006; hereafter “Hartian Positivism”), I consider an attempt to defend a Hartian account of law – the most influential contemporary version of legal positivism – in this way. I argue that the Hartian thesis is not part of our reflective understanding of law. 37 The second approach makes no appeal to specifically legal truths. Ordinary descriptive facts, for example about the behavior and attitudes of people, are sufficient to satisfy the rational-relation requirement. Neta’s view falls in this second camp, as he makes no appeal to specifically legal truths and in general assimilates the legal domain to other normative domains. In discussing Neta’s example here, we should therefore set aside any ideas we might have of basic truths about law. The question is whether the ordinary empirical facts about 36
Hart 1994, pp. 55-57, 255. I say “a Hartian account” rather than “Hart’s account” because I try to address the most powerful and plausible version of a position in the neighborhood of Hart’s, rather than to be faithful to the details of Hart’s own view. 37
114 MARK GREENBERG
the sayings and doings of various people are themselves able to satisfy the rational-relation requirement.38 In HFML (pp. 180-181), I considered the possibility of a “foundational practice” – one that determines the bearing on the content of the law of other practices, but whose own bearing does not depend on that of any other practice. I argued that a putative foundational practice could not by itself rationally determine that it was in fact foundational. More fundamentally, it could not rationally determine its own significance to the law. Neta concedes that if there were “two putatively foundational but inconsistent practices,” some additional factor would be needed to make intelligible why one practice rather than the other is foundational. He focuses, instead, on a case in which “we have only one putatively foundational [practice], the dictates of which are consistent with all of the law practices.” In this case, Neta suggests that the sole putatively foundational practice can provide the reason “why it is itself foundational” (p. 93). Neta’s description of the case takes three elements as given. First, the practice in question is putatively foundational. Second, no other practice is putatively foundational. Third, the content of the putatively foundational practice (its “dictates”) is consistent with the content of all other law practices. Stipulating these three elements begs the question of whether the descriptive facts can themselves determine which model is correct. For these three elements are not descriptive facts, but facts that are logically posterior to what is at issue – the correct model in the legal 38 Another version of the second approach – the one that makes no appeal to specifically legal truths — would appeal to truths about the way in which social facts determine rules in a domain or class of domains that is broader than and includes the legal domain. I consider this approach and comment on the obstacles it faces in Greenberg 2006 (section III). As I explain there, legal positivists have not seriously pursued this approach. (It is important to note that H.L.A. Hart’s (1994) account of law does not treat legal rules as an instance of a more general case of social rules. See, e. g. Hart (1994, p. 256). For on Hart’s account, roughly speaking, what makes a standard a legal rule is not that it is accepted, but that it is specified by an accepted rule. See Greenberg 2006, text accompanying notes 30 and 34.) Neta does not attempt to show that legal norms are an instance of the (putative) norms of practices that he discusses, and such an attempt would not be plausible.
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 115
system. For example, for a law practice to be the only putatively foundational practice in a legal system, it must be the case that no other law practice has a bearing on what the putatively foundational practice contributes to the content of the law. Whether that condition is satisfied depends, however, on which model is correct. Similarly, whether the putatively foundational practice is consistent with all other law practices depends on the legal significance of all the law practices. And, again, the legal significance of law practices depends on which model is correct. In sum, the elements on which Neta relies are not the descriptive facts to which he is entitled, but facts that take for granted a model. What has gone wrong with Neta’s argument? It is a descriptive fact that only one legal practice in the legal system has associated with it a sentence asserting that the practice has a foundational role. And it is a descriptive fact that no other legal practice has associated with it an inconsistent sentence. Neta seems to equate these descriptive facts with the facts he stipulates – that there is only one putatively foundational practice, and that its content is not in conflict with the content of any other practice. Thus, he implicitly assumes that the significance of a law practice is no more and no less than the ordinary non-legal content of the sentences associated with it. We know that this assumption is false, however. For example, the fact that judicial decisions have interpreted other law practices in a particular way bears on the contribution of law practices to the content of the law, regardless of whether the interpreting judicial decisions explicitly say anything about how law practices are to be interpreted. More generally, as I argue at length in HFML, the contribution of law practices to legal content is not constituted by the conjunction of the contents of sentences associated with those practices (HFML, Section III). The significance of law practices depends on reasons, and there are reasons for law practices to contribute the content of the law in ways that do not track the meaning of sentences associated with those practices. Another problem with Neta’s account is that he seems to assume that it is a matter of contingent historical fact whether a constitutional clause of the sort he describes would rationally determine that the clause was foundational. He says that the example of the constitutional
116 MARK GREENBERG
clause shows that my account is “historically falsifiable” and “dependent on a matter of contingent, and possibly unknown, fact of legal history”. This claim seems to confuse the question of whether the clause would be foundational with whether the descriptive facts (of the existence of the clause and the absence of a conflicting practice) are the full explanation of its being foundational.39 As noted above, Neta neglects the possibility that normative facts play a role in explaining the bearing of his hypothetical constitutional clause. Again, it is plausible that the clause would have foundational significance. But the best explanation may not be simply that the clause says so. There are powerful reasons, for example of democracy and fairness, for giving great weight to the plain meaning of the constitutional text. In order to see that such reasons may be playing a silent role in Neta’s example, consider how much less effective the example would be if the single putatively foundational clause were in a decision of a minor administrative official. Neta’s explanation of the foundational nature of his clause may legitimately appeal only to purely descriptive facts. Given the important normative considerations that support the Constitution’s special status, it is difficult to be sure that our evaluation of the example is influenced only by the descriptive facts. 40 It might be objected that the problem with Neta’s example is that constitutional requirements are themselves part of the content of the law and therefore cannot ultimately determine how practices determine the content of the law. Perhaps a version of Neta’s example would fare better if it involved not a constitutional provision, but the attitudes and dispositions of legal officials that, on a Hartian account, make a rule of recognition the correct model for a legal system.41 As noted above, in “Hartian Positivism,” I consider whether a Hartian account can satisfy the rational-relation requirement. I show that the arguments of HFML yield the same conclusion with respect to officials’ acceptance of a rule of recognition as with respect to Neta’s constitutional clause. 39 Another problem is that it is a subtle legal issue, not a straightforward matter of descriptive fact, whether a clause is foundational. 40 For discussion of a related objection, see Greenberg, this volume, pp. 137-141. 41 I am grateful to an anonymous referee for Legal Theory for the suggestion that I consider this case.
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 117
4. Other Normative Domains I have thus far criticized Neta’s attempts to explain moral and legal facts entirely in terms of nonnormative facts. The relevance of the moral domain to my original paper depends on a more general claim that Neta makes. The claim is that my argument generalizes to all normative domains: more precisely, all normative domains have the structural features of the legal domain that are necessary to generate my original argument. In order to defend the argument of HFML against Neta, I don’t need to deny this claim, for I have already argued against Neta’s attempt to explain moral norms in nonnormative terms. But the issue of how far my argument generalizes is of independent interest. In this final section, I first consider and reject Neta’s argument that purports to show that all normative domains have the relevant features of the legal domain. I then offer a competing picture of some other normative domains. A crucial premise of my original argument is that descriptive facts are among the determinants of the legal facts, and the determination relation between the determinants and the legal facts is rational determination (see HFML, section IIB). A version of the argument can be developed only in domains in which a corresponding premise is true. I suggest, for example, that the determination relation in the domains of aesthetics, humor, and mental content is not rational determination (HFML, pp. 160, 170-171 & fns. 18, 25). If that suggestion is correct, a version of the argument cannot be developed in those domains. 42 Neta claims that all normative domains have the structure that I attributed to law. Call this claim the generalized premise: In all normative domains, descriptive facts are among the determinants of the content of the norms, and the relevant determination relation is rational determination.
I am sympathetic to a view that generalizes my conclusion to all normative domains. In particular, I am sympathetic to the view that a full explanation of the existence of any genuine norms cannot be 42
II.E.
For discussion of the scope of the argument, see HFML, p. 161 and Section
118 MARK GREENBERG
given entirely in terms of descriptive facts. I did not argue for this view in the original article, however, and will not do so here. As I will show, Neta’s argument for the generalized premise is not successful. Moreover, the generalized premise is not plausible. Hence, the specific argument that I gave does not generalize in the way that Neta claims. A number of passages in Neta’s comments suggest that he is working with a determination notion different from the notion of rational determination. For example, when he explains the determination notion, he writes: there is nothing reasonable or unreasonable about the fact that water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit, and so whatever makes it the case that water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit does not rationally determine that fact. ... In contrast, it is at least somewhat reasonable for the law to require that people who are not convicted of crimes not receive punishment. ... Thus, whatever makes it the case that the law requires this, ... rationally determines that the law requires it (p. 79).
Similarly, he writes: “there must be some reason for the law to require some things and forbid other things – the law’s requirements, unlike the boiling point of water, must be at least somewhat reasonable.” (p. 81). Neta here contrasts domains in which the notion of reasonableness applies to the content of the relevant propositions and domains in which it does not. It is neither reasonable nor unreasonable that water boils at a certain temperature. It is reasonable that the law imposes certain requirements and not others. Moreover, the quoted passages taken together suggest that Neta thinks the content of the law is rationally determined if and only if the content of the law is “somewhat reasonable.” Neta’s notion of the reasonableness of a norm’s content is not the same as my notion of rational determination.43 As noted above, to say 43
If Neta has misunderstood what I mean by “rational determination,” my lack of clarity in HFML is surely to blame. Neta tells me (personal communication) that he was assuming that if the A facts rationally determine the B facts, the B facts “must be at least prima facie somewhat reasonable.” I disagree. Suppose that facts about
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 119
that the A facts rationally determine the B facts is to say that the obtaining of the B facts must be intelligible in rational terms in light of the obtaining of the A facts. Consider the legal requirement that contracts for the sale of land be in writing. The intelligibility issue is not whether this requirement is a reasonable or wise one, but whether the existence of the requirement is explained by, or intelligible in the light of, for example, statutes and judicial decisions. Rational intelligibility concerns not the content of the higher-level facts, e.g., that contracts for the sale of land must be in writing, but the relation between the determining facts and the higher-level facts (HFML, pp. 164-165), e.g., between statutes and judicial decisions and the fact that contracts for the sale of land must be in writing. The reasonableness of the content of a norm is consistent with its being opaque why the determinants have the consequences that they do for the content of the norm. For example, one could consistently think that it is a good idea for the Constitution to ban the death penalty, yet that the relevant facts, e.g., about the text of the Constitution or the intentions of its ratifiers, do not make the existence of such a ban rationally intelligible. Conversely, even if it is a terrible idea to allow a tax deduction for mortgage interest, the existence of that deduction might be perfectly intelligible in light of the Internal Revenue Code. (Indeed, the relation between the arrangement of microphysical particles and macrophysical facts, such as the fact of water’s boiling point, might be intelligible even if the notion of reasonableness is not applicable to the macrophysical facts.) In evaluating Neta’s argument for the generalized premise, we need to ensure that we evaluate it with respect to the correct notion. microphysics rationally determined facts about the boiling points of liquids. It would not follow that the notion of reasonableness even has application to facts about the boiling points of liquids. Whether rational determination places some constraint on the content of the law is an interesting and complicated question. For discussion, see HFML, VI.B. But such subtleties are unnecessary for present purposes. As we will see shortly, Neta’s argument on the first horn of his dilemma relies not on the assumption just mentioned, but on its converse - that if the relevant determination relation is not rational determination, then the content of the norms is not reasonable. Given my notion of rational determination, there is no basis for this assumption. With respect to the second horn of the dilemma, the problem that I identify with Neta’s argument would remain even if both the assumption and its converse were true.
120 MARK GREENBERG
Neta’s argument takes the form of a reductio. He begins with the following conditional: “If the [descriptive] facts do not make it reasonable for the norms to be what they are, then either nothing makes it reasonable for the norms to be what they are, or else the reason for the norms to be what they are includes something independent of the [descriptive] facts.” He then argues that both possibilities lead to contradictions, so the antecedent of the conditional must be rejected. The argument is phrased as if the question is the reasonableness of the content of the norms. But as I have just explained, that is not the right question. So it is important to reformulate the argument in terms of rational determination. We first need to clarify one point about the antecedent of Neta’s conditional. Substituting rational determination for reasonableness (and switching to my terminology), the antecedent becomes: “the descriptive facts do not rationally determine the normative facts.” Does this mean that the descriptive facts do not even in part rationally determine the normative facts or that they do not alone do so? Remember that the crucial premise of my argument in the legal case is that the descriptive facts in part rationally determine the normative facts. Since Neta is trying to show that the corresponding premise is true in all normative domains, the antecedent of the conditional (i.e., the premise of his reductio) must be the negation of that premise. Therefore, the correct understanding of the antecedent has to be that the descriptive facts do not even in part rationally determine the normative facts. We can now address Neta’s dilemma. As to the first horn, he argues that if “nothing makes it reasonable for the norms to be what they are,” then “there is no reason to follow those norms,” and thus they are not really norms at all (p. 84). The relevant condition is not, however, that nothing makes it reasonable for the norms to be what they are. It is that the determination relation in the domain in question is not rational determination – i.e., that it is possible that the obtaining of the norms is not intelligible in light of the determinants of the norms. Why should we assume that, in that case, there is no reason to follow those norms? From the fact that the determination relation is not rational determination, nothing follows about the content of the norms. Hence one possibility is that the content of a norm can be the source of reasons, quite apart from the relation between the determining facts and the content of the norm. For example, it might be that the reasons
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 121
to follow moral norms derive from their content. (Indeed, it is common to contrast legal and moral norms with respect to whether the content of a norm is the source of the relevant reasons.) More generally, it cannot simply be assumed that putative norms have no normative force if the relevance of the determinants of those norms to the norms need not be reason-based. For that is to assume precisely what is at issue – that rational determination is the relevant determination relation. With respect to the second horn, Neta argues that “if the reason for the norms to be what they are is independent of the [descriptive] facts that determine those norms ... it’s arbitrary that the norms are binding on all and only those creatures of which the determining [descriptive] facts obtain.” In that case, he concludes, “there’s nothing that makes the norms in question binding on creatures like us,” which is to say again that they are not norms after all (pp. 85-86). Neta seems to think that the relevant condition is that 1) descriptive facts determine the norms, and 2) the relevant determination relation is rational determination, yet 3) something independent of the descriptive facts provides the reasons that explain the existence of the norms. But it is hard to see why one would take this to be the relevant condition. If rational determination is the relevant determination relation (so we are not on the first horn of the dilemma) and the descriptive facts do not even in part rationally determine the content of the law (by hypothesis), then descriptive facts are not among the determinants of the normative facts at all. For example, the normative facts might be necessary truths that do not depend on contingent practices. (I sketch a picture in which fundamental moral and epistemic norms have such a status.) If descriptive facts are not determinants of the normative facts, there is no concern that “it’s arbitrary that the norms are binding on all and only those creatures of which the determining [descriptive] facts obtain.” So far I have criticized Neta’s argument that rational determination is the determination relation in all normative domains. I now say something about a few illustrative cases. Consider first the moral domain. According to a plausible and widely held view, fundamental moral truths44 are necessary truths that are independent of any descriptive facts. Applied (or “mixed”) moral truths are applications of the fun44
For what I mean by “fundamental moral truths,” see HFML, p. 159 fn. 7.
122 MARK GREENBERG
damental moral truths to particular circumstances. Perhaps it is a fundamental moral truth that it counts in favor of an action, other things being equal, that it would reduce suffering. In combination with contingent facts about the sources of suffering (and perhaps also with other fundamental moral truths), that fundamental truth yields many applied moral truths, for example, that we should provide infants with nurturing environments. I take this picture for granted here (though Neta would not accept it). On this picture, the interesting metaphysical question is the explanation of the fundamental moral truths. Given that explanation, the explanation of the applied moral truths follows straightforwardly. And it is obvious that normative facts – the fundamental moral truths – play a role in that explanation. I will not of course offer an account of fundamental moral truths here. The present point is that the legal case is a non-starter as a model for such an account. It is uncontroversial that the content of the law obtains in virtue of law-making practices. Fundamental moral truths do not obtain in virtue of practices. That reducing suffering counts in favor of an action (say) is a necessary truth, not something that is contingent on what people do or decide. There is no legal analogue of fundamental moral truths – legal truths that could not be otherwise and that yield all the more specific legal facts when applied to particular circumstances.45 The question of the explanation of the fundamental moral truths is not one on which my argument is intended to shed light. An interesting example is provided by the assumption that all desires or motivating states justify the actions that they (potentially) motivate. This assumption, we saw, was necessary to Neta’s account of promising. Notice that it is better understood as a candidate for a necessary truth than a contingent one. It would be very strange to maintain that some contingent social practice makes it the case that all desires justify actions. The defender of such an assumption would presumably take it to be a necessary truth, which, in combination with facts about what desires people happen to have, yields truths about what justifies particular actions. Hence, Neta’s account of the As an anonymous referee for Legal Theory pointed out, there may be some legal facts that could not be otherwise, e.g., that what is not prohibited is permitted. But even if there be such non-contingent legal facts, they do not, when applied to particular circumstances, yield all the more specific legal facts. 45
ON PRACTICES AND THE LAW 123
normativity of promises, once we make explicit the assumption that all desires justify actions, can be seen to instantiate the picture of the moral domain that I have sketched.46 In my view, the epistemic case is similar to the moral one. Fundamental epistemic norms do not depend on contingent social practices. Again, more specific, applied epistemic norms are the result of applying the fundamental norms to particular circumstances. Neta also considers the case of “the normative content of a particular linguistic system” (p. 82). I am not sure what he has in mind, but we can consider an example I mention in passing in HFML (fns. 18, 25). It is plausible that facts about a person’s or community’s use of words are among the determinants of what those words mean. I do not think that the facts about what words mean are normative facts, so this issue may be a point of disagreement between Neta and me. But this case nonetheless provides a helpful comparison with the legal case. As I say (HFML, fn. 25), it may be that the relation between facts about our use of words and facts about meaning is not rational determination. In sharp contrast to the legal case, I see no reason to think that the relation between the use of words and their meaning is necessarily rationally intelligible. It may be that many possible meanings are ruled out arbitrarily (i.e., in ways for which reasons cannot be given) and that we have non-rational mechanisms that exclude these possibilities from consideration. I can sum up these brief remarks in an intuitive way. At bottom, we do not create epistemic and moral norms. Fundamental moral and epistemic normative truths are necessary, and do not depend on the contingencies of our practices. We do create the facts about what words mean, but we do so in a way that need not be rationally accessible. In the legal domain, we create the facts, and we do so in a way that must be rationally accessible. References Coleman, J. 2001: The Practice of Principle. New York: Oxford University Press. Dworkin, R. 1977: Taking Rights Seriously. London: Duckworth. 46
I thank Seana Shiffrin for pointing this out.
124 MARK GREENBERG
——1986: Law’s Empire, London: Fontana Press. Gilbert, M. 2002: Sociality and Responsibility, Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield. Greenberg, M. 2004: “How Facts Make Law”, Legal Theory, 10, 157-198, reprinted in E. Sosa and E. Villanueva, eds., this volume, and in 1) Hershovitz, S., ed., Exploring Law’s Empire (Oxford University Press, 2006); 2) E. Cáceres, I. Flores, J. Saldaña, and E. Villanueva, eds., Problemas Contemporáneos de la Filosofía del Derecho (Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 2005); and 3) Problema, 2 (forthcoming) (cited as “HFML”). ——2005: “A New Map of Theories of Mental Content: Constitutive Accounts and Normative Theories,” Philosophical Issues, 15, p. 299. ——this volume: “Reasons Without Values?,” in E. Sosa and E. Villanueva, eds., this volume. ——2006: “Hartian Positivism and Normative Facts: How Facts Make Law II” (cited as “Hartian Positivism”) in Scott Hershovitz, ed., Exploring Law’s Empire (New York: Oxford University Press). Hart, H.L.A. this volume The Concept of Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press (2nd ed.). Hieronymi, P. MS: “Reasons, Actions, and Attitudes” (unpublished manuscript). Himma, K. 2002: “Inclusive Legal Positivism,” in J. Coleman and S. Shapiro, eds., Oxford Handbook of Jurisprudence and Philosophy of Law. New York: Oxford University Press. Neta, R. this volume: “On the Normative Significance of Brute Facts,” Legal Theory, 10, 199-214, reprinted in E. Sosa and E. Villanueva, eds., this volume. Owens, D. 2006: “A Simple Theory of Promising,” Philosophical Review, 115, pp. 51-77. Raz, J. 1983, The Authority of Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ——1994: “Authority, Law and Morality,” in Ethics in the Public Domain. New York: Oxford University Press. ——1999: Practical Reasons and Norms. Oxford: Oxford University Press (2nd ed.). Schapiro, T. 2003: “Compliance, Complicity, and the Nature of Nonideal Conditions,” The Journal of Philosophy, 100, pp. 329-355. Shapiro, S. 1998: “On Hart’s Way Out,” Legal Theory, 4, pp. 469-507. Shiffrin, S. MS: “Promising, Intimate Relationships, and Conventionalism” (unpublished manuscript). Smith, M. 1994: The Moral Problem. Oxford: Blackwell. Sosa E. and Villanueva E., eds., this volume. Wallace, J. and Kolodny, N. 2003: “Promises and Practices Revisited,” Philosophy & Public Affairs, 31, pp. 119-154.
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
5
Supervenience, Value, and Legal Content Enrique Villanueva* I congratulate Prof Mark Greenberg for writing this enlightening paper1 and for bringing into the fore some Metaphysical issues of law. Prof. Mark Greenberg is concerned with fundamental issues among them the place value facts have in law’s content. He states his view in the face of both Legal Positivists and Strong Legal Moralists. His view enlightens the issue and constitutes a new exiting proposal. I have quite a number of questions that spring out of this rich paper but I have to restrain myself to two of them. Mark Greenberg’s view on the relationship between legal content and value facts steers between Positivism and Strong Moralism. Legal Positivism holds that law’s content is propositional and is a social fact and relates to value only contingently. There could be law even where there is no value or where there are negative values or counter values. It holds further that any values that may play a role in law had to be internal to law, they have to be expressly stated or implied by law’s content. Legal Moralism holds that legal content has to do with moral value facts or keeps a conceptual, non-contingent, connection with moral value facts; it is a sort of necessary condition for legal content. Strong Legal Moralism holds that moral values are sufficient for legal content. There are two sorts of value-facts, namely, genuine or external to law and internal to law. *
Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, UNAM. HOW FACTS MAKE LAW, included in the present volume. My comments address a previous version of Mark Greenberg’s paper that was titled “The strange and Intelligible Metaphysics of Law”. 1
126 ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA
Mark Greenberg opposes both, Strong Legal Moralism and Legal Positivism when they claim to provide sufficient conditions for legal content: neither legal decisions nor moral values are sufficient for legal content, according to Greenberg. I. On the Supervenience of Law My first question concerns a general ontological question, namely, What is the ontological status of Law? Is Law a separate entity vis a vis the physical world? Or is Law something that supervenes from the physical world? Thus I am concerned with Mark Greenberg’s view on supervenience. He holds that law facts supervene on physical facts. But then when considering the role value-facts play in law’s content he introduces the rational determination relation (RDR) and holds that this relationship is not captured by supervenience and thus should be considered apart from supervenience. Let’s see how he states his view. Mark Greenberg introduces two sorts of supervenience one s1 that goes from physical facts into moral and legal facts and another s2 that goes from legal decisions or practices into law’s content. We can infer by transitivity that law’s content supervene on physical facts. If there is a difference in descriptive facts there will be a difference in legal facts. More locally, if there is a difference in legal decisions there will be a difference in legal content. And if there is a difference in legal content we can infer that there was a difference in both, legal decisions and physical facts. Now Mark Greenberg says that legal content is made out not only of legal decisions but of values too and that these values impose an epistemic constraint for unless reasons come into (and with reasons enter value) there will not be determinate content (will be vague or non-existent). Mark Greenberg tries to capture reasons’ role by the rational determination relation (RDR). But now, he holds that supervenience fails to capture RDR and thus that RDR does not supervene s2. Or is it that besides supervening s2 RDR gets an ‘extra’ status and that this extra status is not captured by supervenience? But couldn’t it be instead that the RDR is the form that takes the supervenience relation in this case? Or does he want to hold that the RDR is another relation ontologically wholly independent of supervenience2?
SUPERVENIENCE, VALUE, AND LEGAL CONTENT 127
I fail to see why RDR cannot also supervene on physical facts. For even if RDR is an epistemic relation, as Mark Greenberg holds, there is no obstacle to think that epistemic facts also supervene from physical facts and thus that RDR does equally supervene. I must underline here that the metaphysical relationship of supervenience does no prohibit differences between the subvenient base and the resulting supervenience; the only difference excluded is an ontological difference between subvenient base and what supervenes. As RDR does not entail an ontological difference, only an epistemic one, we can conclude that RDR also supervenes on the subvenient physical base and on the legal facts that make the legal decisions. There is no absurdity in holding that legal decisions, reasoning, legal facts, all contribute to fix legal content and thus that legal content supervenes from all that subvenient base. If Materialism is not to be rejected out of hand it should be agreed that reasoning on legal value or RDR does supervene. Reasoning and giving reasons cannot be kept apart from what is material but rather should be kept continuous with it. II. Reasons, Value and the Determination of Legal Content The second thesis I want to consider is that legal content will remain undetermined unless value facts are called into to make it determinate. That legal reasoning had to incorporate value facts in order to provide legal reasons and thus to reach some legal content. That unless resource is made to value facts there will be no legal content and no legal proposition (individual norm). Contra Positivism Mark Greenberg holds that social practices or meanings of words cannot determine the content of law; more generally, that legal decisions cannot by themselves determine law’s content. That if we restrict ourselves to legal practices no determinate content will be reached. The view is that legal decisions together with value facts determine which elements of legal decisions are relevant and how they combine to determine the content of law. Value facts by themselves cannot ei-
128 ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA
ther determine law’s content. This is the necessary role value facts play. It is it a heuristic or interpretive role the one granted to value facts. But Mark Greenberg wants to hold further, that by thus entering into legal content value facts are not just heuristic but become an ontological constituent of law. Thus value facts are both epistemological and ontological. And then, thirdly, he entertains that value facts may have to be external or foreign (moral) to legal decisions for otherwise they cannot fulfil their criterial role in the practice of legal interpretation. I find the transition from knowledge into legal content obscure. The question can be set in this way: why is it that value facts foreign to legal decisions have to be brought into in order to make determinate legal content? Why is it necessary to import these foreign value facts in the legal case? Thus, according to Mark Greenberg value facts are (metaphysical) constituents of law. They also have heuristic relevance and because of that somehow they get into the content of legal propositions. How exactly they reach into the content together with legal decisions? Here is an answer: value facts have a relevance limitation, namely, that value facts determine the relevance of different aspects of legal decisions to the content of law. That when reasoning one has to determine which features of legal decisions matter and how they matter and in order to sort this out by legal reasoning resource has to be made to some value-facts, to what is worth in such and such legal decisions, and thus to what provides reasons to settle the issue one way or another. Mark Greenberg states this much and leaves open what sort of value facts are required to decide if the values required have to be internal or external to law; further argument is needed to decide this last issue but he says that he argues for the need to bring into moral values in another paper. Let us look further into this issue: on the one hand, value facts are criteria and thus have to be independent facts not included in the legal decisions themselves; on the other, they are worth, they have a worthy content. Independence and worthiness are independent features of value facts. That in order to fix a standard that allows sorting out some feature of legal decisions the standard has to enjoy some independence from these legal decisions, seems to be a purely logical point.
SUPERVENIENCE, VALUE, AND LEGAL CONTENT 129
The standard meter (in Paris) is a meter long but it also plays the role of being the standard to determine if some length is one meter long or not; besides being a meter long it plays the role of determining lengths. It is one and the same piece of metal that plays two independent roles, there is no need to have two different pieces of metal, one for each role. On the other hand, this purely logical point has nothing to do with value facts. If we want to say that the standard sets the value of one meter long, that sense of value has nothing to do with being worth, being morally worth, for example. We have to see how being independent or playing as criteria and having value work together. Worth relates to what is (intrinsically) good in (a given) value. Mark Greenberg attributes to value facts a double function, namely, they are criteria that help to choose between the many different features of legal decisions and they are (intrinsically) worth. Value facts are necessary to make law determinate but they are necessary because of their worthiness or because they are (independent) criteria? Let us consider a case. A judge may consider that such and such features of the legal decisions are the ones that are relevant, salient, to reach a sentence; but the judge does not consider these features because they are worth but, for example, just because they fit with the content of the general norm which in its turn fits with the social conventions (and these may be unworthy), or because they will produce such and such behavioral effects (without value), etc., and the judge may choose these features even if they are counter-values or they are morally wrong; he will choose them because he considers that they fit best the legal norms. Again, the sentence issued by the judge may or may not be morally worth but the judge didn’t consider any value-aspect but reached his sentence only on the basis of legal technical reasons. But does the fact that the judge chooses these features and not others make the judge’s decision a value fact? It seems as if by judging the official has to choose among features of legal decisions and choosing involves giving or providing reasons for his decision and in order to do this he must make resource to something independent and what Mark Greenberg holds is that this independent something must be a value fact and his argument seems to be that if it is not a value fact there will be no reason at all and no determinate content of law. The judge will not be using reasons unless the one he surmises includes or en-
130 ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA
tails some value fact and an external value at that. These reasons are value-loaded. But it seems that one can grant that there is legal reasoning that appeals to (independent) criteria but that using that criteria does not imply making resource to some value facts. Legal content will be made determinate without any appeal to value facts. Let us turn again to the judge’s case. Our legalistic judge makes a reasoned choice among the features of the legal decisions but his choice does not bring into any moral or legal values. He just moves inside the content of the legal decisions and chooses the ones that he considers better. Now, better to what? Better to the legal text stated in the norm. His is an internal reasoning that moves inside the legal decisions that help the judge to apply what the norm states in general, to a given case. Reasoning does not involve values but providing reasons in favor of X or Y feature of legal decisions seems to involve some value facts, a minimum of appraisal and value. It seems that giving reasons imply, in the case of law, taking into account some value, something worth. But this minimum worth that the judge, for example, has to take into account does not imply that the judge thinks that it is worth but that it is in fact something worth. Mark’s view states that there will not be legal reasoning, no evaluation or sorting of possibilities, without resource to independent value-facts. Does this mean that an act of choosing whose reason didn’t involve some value facts wouldn’t be intelligible? That providing legal reasons implies making resource to value facts? That without value facts there are no reasons. That choosing without appeal to value facts will be an irrational choosing or no choosing at all. That reasoning or choosing has built into it some value facts at least. There is something obscure, (mystical?) in this conception of ‘providing reasons’, something that the RDR relationship is far from making clear; but far from bridging the gap between ‘reasons’ and ‘values’ only obscures it. This crucial point demands fundamental elucidation. There is something importantly obscure under the name ‘value fact’ for this ‘fact’ has not to be conceived as non-brute or non- conventional, but whatever its ontological status that ‘fact’ has got to provide an explanation of the constituents that will be selected when choosing one model among many other models available.
SUPERVENIENCE, VALUE, AND LEGAL CONTENT 131
But this is precisely what the case of the legalistic judge brings out. Our legalistic judge makes a reasoned choice between alternatives and claims that under the circumstances his is the best possible choice for in reaching it he sticks to the letter both of the text of the legal decisions and of the general norm. This judge made a legally grounded choice but did not take into account any particular value. He may have a general conception according to which observing the text of the legal decisions and norms preserves social coherence, or so, but no particular value follows from it. This judge claims that he made a better choice because it was better that a number of alternatives available (among them some morally informed ones according to which resource had to be made to foreign moral values, that is, foreign and even opposite to the text of the legal decisions and norms). It was better because it fitted better the legal texts than any of the alternatives available. I think this is a very common case in legal practice. It is true that there is some value involved in the judge’s choice, namely, that he considers worthy to keep as close as possible to the law’s text. This value is a general precept or rule, something rather instrumental lacking in intrinsic worthiness. This is a minimum value, not a moral one, and could even be a morally evil value as it was the case in Nazi Germany. Summing up this second point I think that there are two situations in the legal cases, namely, one in which there is no value involved, just the letter of the legal texts and another in which there are some values, and this last possibility branches into two cases, namely, one in which the values are contained already into the legal decisions or in the norm and another of values brought from outside of these legal decisions. I think Mark Greenberg accepts only the last possibility because he feels a double pressure, namely, one coming from the need to interpret the legal texts and another second one coming from the need of independent criteria. I submit that in the legal case there is a gap between reasoning, providing reasons and appealing to value facts and some additional argument has to be supplied in order to fill in that gap. That you may reason a legal case without making any resource to any moral or otherwise external-to-legal-decisions intrinsically worth value facts. That there is no compulsion to abide for such kind of value facts when interpreting the law.
132 ENRIQUE VILLANUEVA
I cannot even begin to provide an account of what is involved in bridging the gap between legal reasons, values, and legal content and neither can claim that such an account is reachable. A first step would be to fix the adequacy conditions that such account should fulfill if it is to claim to be worth. But I am grateful that Mark Greenberg paper touches that central question with enlightening clarity and allows us to see into the problem.2 Tepoztlán, 7/5/03, Petesburgo, 9/1/04
2 I want to express my gratitude to Mark Greenberg and to Ram Neta, my co-symposiasts, who read some previous versions of the present text and help me to correct some unhappy and muddled sentences.
6
SOCIAL, POLITICAL, & LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, 2 Law: Metaphysics, Meaning, and Objectivity, 2007
Reasons Without Values?1 Mark Greenberg In “How Facts Make Law” (Greenberg 2004; hereafter HFML), I argue that a constitutive account of legal facts must appeal to normative facts.2 In the present paper, I take up a challenge raised by Enrique Villanueva (this volume). My argument in HFML begins from two premises. First, the constitutive determinants of legal content include non-normative, contingent facts – descriptive facts, for short.3 The relevant descriptive facts are law-determining practices (or law practices), for example facts about decisions of legislatures, courts, and administrative agencies.4 Second, the determinants of the content of the law rationally determine the content of the law.5 A consequence is that the determinants of the content of the law must include reasons6 why law practices make the contribution that they do to the content of the law. Law practices – and, indeed, descriptive facts more generally – cannot themselves provide the necessary reasons.7 1 I am grateful to Enrique Villanueva for his challenging and thought-provoking paper. I would also like to thank Andrea Ashworth, Kinch Hoekstra, and Seana Shiffrin for valuable comments. 2 I develop the argument in Greenberg (2006a) and Greenberg (2006b). 3 I use the term “normative facts” here in the way that I used “value facts” in HFML (n. 22). See also Greenberg (2006a, n. 5 and accompanying text). 4 See HFML (pp. 162-163, Section II.C.). 5 For elaboration, see HFML (pp. 160, 163-166, 170-172) and Greenberg (2006a, section 1). 6 For more on the relevant notion of a reason, see HFML (pp. 164-166); Greenberg (2006b, section II). 7 For a fuller summary of my argument, see Greenberg 2006a; 2006b.
134 MARK GREENBERG
In section 1 of this paper, I address a preliminary question raised by Villanueva, concerning the relationship between rational determination and supervenience. On this matter there is no fundamental disagreement between us, and I am grateful for the opportunity to clarify the nature of rational determination. In section 2, I turn to Villanueva’s main challenge. He suggests that, to put it very briefly, descriptive facts can be reasons of the relevant kind. Therefore, even if the content of the law depends on reasons, it does not follow that law practices cannot themselves determine the content of the law. Villanueva proposes a value-neutral criterion – textualism. In other words, he suggests that the descriptive facts about the meaning of legal texts are themselves reasons that determine the contribution of law practices to the content of the law. This suggestion depends on too shallow a conception of the requirement of reasons. For the law to be rationally determined, it is not enough that there be some value-neutral criterion that specifies that law practices have certain consequences for the content of the law. There have to be reasons that explain why that criterion, as opposed to others, is the legally correct one – the one that, in the relevant legal system, determines the contribution of law practices to the content of the law.8 Villanueva is right that, in general, normative facts are not the only reasons of the relevant kind. In the case of a constitutive account of legal facts, however, normative facts are the best candidates for such reasons. And, in fact, Villanueva’s textualist criterion derives its appeal from normative facts. 1. Rational Determination and Supervenience It is uncontroversial that the content of the law supervenes on descriptive facts – that is, that the descriptive facts modally determine the content of the law (HFML, p. 159). I claim, however, that the descrip8 The notion of legal correctness here is metaphysical not epistemic. In other words, the legally correct criterion is not the one that judges use to ascertain the content of the law, but the one that determines the content of the law. Of course, judges’ beliefs and practices will have an impact on what is legally correct. See also HFML (p. 179).
REASONS WITHOUT VALUES? 135
tive facts are not the whole story about what constitutively determines, or makes it the case,9 that the law has its content. The making-it-thecase relation in the legal domain is rational determination. And descriptive facts alone are inadequate to rationally determine the content of the law. Villanueva questions the need for me to appeal to rational determination. His suggestion seems to be that I could substitute a thesis about the supervenience base of the content of the law – i.e., about the modal determinants of the content of the law – for a thesis about the rational determinants of the content of the law (Villanueva, this volume, pp. 126-127). Rational determination is a kind of ontological relation, more specifically a kind of constitutive or making-it-the case relation. Supervenience, by contrast, is a modal relation. In my view, it is a mistake to try to cash constitutive claims in modal terms, though this is not the place to argue the point (see Greenberg 2005). In fact, it is natural to appeal to constitutive truths to explain modal ones. For example, that the A facts constitute the B facts explains why the B facts supervene on the A facts. I maintain that descriptive facts and normative facts together rationally determine the content of the law. It follows that the content of the law supervenes on descriptive facts and normative facts (HFML, p. 163).10 But normative facts supervene on descriptive facts (see HFML, p. 159). Hence, it follows from my claim that descriptive facts and normative facts rationally determine the content of the law that the content of the law supervenes on descriptive facts. 9 In this paper, I will use the term “makes it the case” for constitutive rather than modal determination. Also, I use “determination” (“determines,” “determinants,” etc.) for constitutive, rather than modal, determination. (When I mean modal determination, I will be explicit.) For discussion of constitutive and modal determination, see Greenberg 2005. 10 In HFML (pp. 163-164), I make a supervenience condition an explicit part of the account of rational determination. I now think that a better explication of rational determination, along the lines indicated in the text, would not use any modal notion. In order for the A facts (wholly) to rationally determine the B facts, the obtaining of the A facts must make it the case that the B facts obtain. This condition entails that the B facts supervene on the A facts. For suppose that the B facts do not