IMAGINING TH E A N T I P O D E S
IMAGINING THE A N T I P O D E S
C U L T U R E , T H E O R Y A N DT H E V I S U A L T...
10 downloads
740 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
IMAGINING TH E A N T I P O D E S
IMAGINING THE A N T I P O D E S
C U L T U R E , T H E O R Y A N DT H E V I S U A L T H E W O R K O F B E R N A R D S M I T H
P e t e r B e i I h a rz School of Sociology, Politics and Anthropology La Trobe University
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
I N
PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE
The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK 40 West 20th Street, New York NY 10011-4211, USA 477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia Ruiz de Alarcon 13,28014 Madrid, Spain Dock House, The Waterfront, Cape Town 8001, South Africa http://www.cambridge.org © Peter Beilharz 1997 This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1997 First paperback edition 2002 Typeface Palatino 10/13 pt. A catalogue recordfor this book is available from the British Library National Library of Australia Cataloguing in Publication data Beilharz, Peter. Imagining the Antipodes: culture, theory, and the visual in the work of Bernard Smith. Bibliography. Includes index. ISBN 0 521 58355 1. 1. Smith, Bernard, 1916- . 2. Art criticisms - Australia. 3. Art critics - Australia. 4. Authors, Australian - 20th century. 5. Painting, Australian. I. Title. 709.2 Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data Beilharz, Peter. Imagining the antipodes: culture, theory, and the visual in the work of Bernard Smith/Peter Beilharz. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0 52158355 1 (hardback) 1. Smith, Bernard, 1916- - Criticism and interpretation. I. Smith, Bernard, 1916- . II. Title. N7483.S55B45 1997 709/.2-dc21 96-52054 ISBN 0 52158355 1 hardback ISBN 0 521 52434 2 paperback
CONTENTS
Preface vii Introduction xi 1
Beginnings 1
2
Encountering Australian Painting 27
3
Imagining the Pacific 63
4
The Antipodean Manifesto 97
5
Death of the Hero as Artist 127
6
Modernity, History and Postmodernity
7
Conclusions - Imagining the Antipodes 183 Notes 194 Index 206
155
PREFACE
In the autumn of 1992 I visited a friend of mine, Peter Gathercole, in Cambridge. I was bleary; a car alarm had been triggered in the middle of the night in London, where I'd been staying, so the night was sleepless, but the trip was pacific and I was pleased to catch up with Peter. We had met in 1990 in Brisbane at a conference on the work of the Australian Marxist archaeologist Vere Gordon Childe, and hit it off immediately, even though Peter was a specialist in anthropology and I was a refugee in sociology; he'd been a Marxist as well, indeed had been taught by Gordon Childe. In Cambridge we walked together and talked, took tea back at his flat. We'd spoken about Cambridge and communism, about my ongoing work on Australian intellectuals, and about his own acquaintance with Bernard Smith over the years. At 4 p.m. Peter took a nap, leaving me sitting at his desk downstairs with the various copies of Smith's books that Bernard had given him over the years. It dawned on me. I became convinced that I must write about Bernard Smith. Somehow his work spoke directly to me, across all those cleavages claimed to divide the generations. Imagining the Pacific was a strikingly contemporary way of seeing. The idea of European vision was brilliant. Bernard had left his umbrella with Peter on a previous visit. Could I perhaps return it? Finally I declined, because it was a real one, no foldups here and I was already overweight with books and things, though I knew I was passing up on an obvious excuse to call on Smith: 'Here, best wishes from Peter Gathercole, is your umbrella, my calling card.. / So I got back on to the train without the umbrella, but with a commitment. I should write an essay at least - maybe a book? - on Smith's work. Of vii
viii
PREFACE
course I'd known of Smith before, as a Communist and art historian, and my friend Martha Macintyre seemed very often to have European Vision and the South Pacific on her desk.
I managed to find a copy in a London second-hand shop before I got on the plane. Back in Melbourne, I read his autobiography, The Boy Adeodatus, with intrigue, and the essays, began to gather other writings, and I wrote Bernard Smith a letter, introducing myself and stating my intentions. We made contact. I felt a strong attraction to Bernard Smith - a lovely man, as everyone said, someone who defended the locals but without the poisonous taint of chauvinism, saw that we were always ever cosmopolitan. We had both been schoolteachers, both been Marxists, had both slipped in the backdoor of the academy (though Bernard also went in the front door of the Warburg Institute). He confirmed his readiness to cooperate. We agreed that I should work through his papers, meticulously ordered and largely still in his possession. I planned to spend six months visiting his house, Jeansville, in Nicholson Street near the Exhibition Gardens, mainly on Fridays; but Bernard Smith was such a pleasure, and his work so intriguing, that it took another year again. For there were other connections for me as well. I realised that Smith's home was in exactly the same area of Fitzroy that my parents and in-laws had inhabited on arrival as aliens in Melbourne. Bell Street and Johnston Street were what they called 'the old stamping ground'. There were other echoes. From Bernard's upstairs room, where I worked, I could see the Women's Hospital, where my wife and later our children were born. I watched the seasons change and imagined my folks on the street. I came upon odd memories of my own discovery of the world of art, and I remembered my friends who tried to break in to the art scene. So I sat and pondered Bernard's books and paintings, files, papers, reviews and manuscripts, letters and passports, itineraries and postcards. But best of all, this was the first living archive I'd had the privilege of working with, so we'd talk of many things, share a meal, wash up, and when my children came to visit they were not only encouraged to use the banisters, things unknown to them, but given clues on how aerodynamically to maximise acceleration. When the time came to write, to stay home at my own desk, I felt sad, but here, nevertheless, is the result. As I explain later, this is not a biography, though Bernard Smith certainly deserves one. Nor is it a work in art history or criticism. This
PREFACE
may surprise some, but it ought not, for my purpose is to defend a way of thinking about the world we inhabit. This is an argumentative essay, which seeks both to establish and to defend the content of Smith's work. Smith's work is useful in the best possible sense; it is good to think with. So there are parts of the argument which follow which may be mine more than his, and the other way around. Finally, this is a book about identity and being in the world system, based on a sequential reading of Smith's published works and on a careful reading of his private papers, which remain largely in his possession but will later find a home in the collections of the Mitchell and the Australian National Library. My thanks, first of all, go to Bernard. I am grateful for the help of Peter Gathercole, Terry Smith, Martha Macintyre, Stuart Macintyre, Ian McLean, Beryl Langer and Ian Britain. Terry and Stuart offered abundant and thoughtful criticism of the penultimate draft. To Stuart I owe an especial word of thanks; for years now he has supported me in everything I have done, for no apparent reason other than that I have chosen to do it. Chris Wallace-Crabbe's generosity of spirit has been unbroken; it is more than I deserve. Robert Dessaix and Peter Timms gave me encouragement and their wisdom and wit. My friend and colleague Trevor Hogan manages still to find the patience to read everything I write, and to help me improve it. Fuyuki Kurasawa read the final draft for me. My own final reading of the manuscript reminded me how much I owe to Cornelius Castoriadis. John Iremonger and Humphrey McQueen helped me to clarify what the book was not. Phillipa McGuinness helped me confirm what it was. Ruth Fincher and David Goodman of the Australian Centre at Melbourne University and Barry Hindess at the Research School, Australian National University, gave me space to think. I am grateful, as ever, for the help of the archivists at the Mitchell Library and the endless kindness of the Sociology support staff at La Trobe. The manuscript was typed by Bronwyn Bardsley, Beth Robertson, Elaine Young and Merle Parker. Maggi and Kate gave me friendship I had no right to expect. That this book is for Bernard will be obvious; between the lines, it is for Judy Robinson. Let it also be for Rhea and Nikolai, Moni and Dor. Peter Beilharz
ix
INTRODUCTION
Who is Bernard Smith? Now eighty, with more than a dozen books to his credit, Bernard Smith is most widely known as an art historian and critic. Others will know a different, related Smith - as anthropologist this time for his work on the Pacific and the West. These are probably his two most obvious audiences, those who read Australian Painting and those who read European Vision and the South Pacific respectively, and usually in isolation. Other readers will know another Smith; those who work in literature or biography or who work in Australian Studies will likely identify him with his autobiography, The Boy Adeodatus. He has done more, however, than work with words. Others yet again will know him as local activist and educator, teacher and founder of the Power Institute in Sydney, art critic for the Melbourne Age, 1940s Communist, lifelong Marxist. According to Humphrey McQueen, Smith is Australia's greatest living historian; as Smith himself put it, his work is in cultural history with a primary interest in the visual.1 Yet students of Australian history probably barely consider his work, and social theorists have their heads in other places. Certainly, as you read through reviews and papers Smith's work is credited with being visionary; a copy of European Vision seems to sit on every obvious anthropologist's desk. Most recently, for example, the extraordinary work of Nicholas Thomas takes up its own orientation via Smith.2 Now there is even an undeclared struggle of sorts over the legacy; for it is the anthropologists who seek more actively to follow Smith, perhaps, than the art historians, and it is not too much of a provocation to say that Smith's greatest impact has been in European Vision rather than Australian Painting.
INTRODUCTION
Who, then, reads Bernard Smith? Apparently anthropologists and art historians, though they do not obviously read the same books, and readers of biography, whose curiosity imaginably does not extend to the more scholarly works. And this would be the obvious place for a newcomer to start. I'd say, if asked: 'Read the autobiography first, then European Vision and the South Pacific. Or else try this book, or seek out
the essay penned by Bernard Smith in 1950 where the ideas which coordinate European Vision were first spelled out, before my time. In any case, read Smith'. There is an irony, then, in the reception of Smith's work. Some people will know it very well, but partially, and this often in both senses. This book is partly for them, for its argument is that there is an extraordinary integrity in Smith's work; it needs, really, to be read or considered all together for its splendour and impact to become fully apparent. But this book is also for those who have never read Smith, those in sociology or politics, philosophy or cultural studies to whom the name may mean nothing on first contact. My claim is that Smith is best read, in fact, as a social theorist, a theorist of peripheral vision. His is a project of profound insight, not least of all into what hitherto has been called 'national character', matters to do with cultures local and imperial, central and peripheral. So the imaginary audience for this book is those who already know Smith's work, but partially, and also those who will not know his work at all, but whose time is ripe. Is this a book for art historians? I can only honestly answer this question by saying that I do not know. Likely some in that field will view me as a poacher, and fail to recognise the Smith they were brought up with in these pages. To them, and others, I could only say: sit down with the works, and read them serially, inquire for yourself into the conceptual constellations that hold Smith's thinking together. For the argument that I put here is that Bernard Smith's work is perhaps the most significant social theory yet generated by an Australian. This is not a biography, though it includes an attempt to place Smith in context; its larger aspiration is to place Smith's work in intellectual context, both with reference to his other writings and with reference to the cultures which created his work. It is an attempt at an integral reading of his work; and it is a proposal that his work is good to think with, capable of extension. Indeed, my own sense is that Smith's work, often misunderstood and sometimes maligned in its own time, was so
I NTRODUCTION
far ahead of its time that it can only now be understood, when the rest of us have caught up. It may be the case that it is only now that we can read his work properly, or in such a manner as to address openly those questions summarised by Gauguin: where have we come from? who are we? where are we going? For Bernard Smith is a major thinker in the history of European consciousness, as well as a central source for imagining the antipodes. Imagining the Antipodes then involves a thinking through of the work of Bernard Smith. The meaning of the title will become more apparent as the argument of this book unfolds. The idea of interpretation plays on both meanings of 'thinking', thinking through, with, the work, working it through and viewing through it, using it, viewing it as a living legacy rather than an authorial voice or claim to authority. The first chapter of this book begins with Smith's autobiography, partly as context, partly to set out some themes, sources, in order to establish some issues of identity and naming. Like Antonio Gramsci, Smith came to know both centre and periphery, and came to problematise the complex processes of cultural power and exchange between them. He came, in particular, to think about politics and art civilisationally, in terms of a notional sensibility that history seems always to repeat itself but never in exactly the same form, especially into the phase after the Renaissance which we call modernity. The second chapter then describes and discusses Smith's two texts on Australian painting, Place, Taste and Tradition and Australian Painting. My reading of these books
suggests that Smith early establishes basic themes about cultural imperialism as a necessarily unequal but nevertheless generative process; the subordinate, or colonial partners in the global relation of master and slave also affect the dominant culture, however opaquely. Culture, like power, never follows absolutely unilateral circuits or flows; this is one reason why, or one sense in which, progress occurs at the same time as does cultural decay or retrogression. In the third chapter we shift into what, arguably, is the centre of Smith's work: the corpus of his work on imperialism, the Pacific and ways of seeing. Smith's writing on Australian art needs to be read in this context, against the backdrop of his work on the Pacific; for the analysis of the Pacific runs into Europe just as that on Australian painting leads to the centres of Europe and America and back. To put this in different terms, Smith is always working on the axis which we call the antipodes; but
xii
X I V
I NTRODUCTION
the antipodes must be understood as a relation, not a place. Neither Australia, nor Argentina, nor New Zealand constitute essentialist places where the antipodes is found in the soil or inscribed into the landscape; being antipodean necessarily means being constructed into a relationship of subordination which is usually called colonial, or postcolonial. Chapter 4 expands on this theme of being antipodean, as it shifts directly into The Antipodean Manifesto drafted by Smith, and the controversy which still surrounds it. The fifth chapter then turns to the discussion of Australian painters, especially those who might be significant for Smith. Smith's own lapse from the medium of paint, his choice of the word, helps to explain his biographical work on Noel Counihan; Counihan in a way is Smith's alter ego, at least in the sense that he followed a path open to Smith but which Smith chose to close. Counihan stayed with paint and more conventionally with communism; Smith's journey took him elsewhere. Smith's work on Jack Lindsay, similarly, represents a kind of homage to a thinker at once inspirational and embodying a different path. I call this chapter 'Death of the Hero as Artist' as a way to include Smith's views on 'The Death of the Artist as Hero', and to discuss his particular views of significant others, such as John Brack, Fred Williams and Francis Lymburner and critics like Robert Hughes and Peter Fuller. Chapter 6 then takes up Smith's arguments concerning modernism, modernity and postmodernity. The conclusion returns to and extends the major organising theme, that of imagining the antipodes. It seeks further to clarify the nature of Smith's work as social theory, as an historicism which enables theory to happen. Smith's project is one characterised by a remarkable theoretical consistency, within which changes and developments have more to do with shifting substantive concerns than with changes of mind or heart. Smith's orienting themes animate all his work, right across a fifty-year writing period. These arguments both reach back to the war period and extend into his critical response to our century and, in a way, anticipate the questions of the philosophy of history with which the study opens. For it is with history that Bernard Smith's work begins and ends, and in this and much else we follow him. This book, then, is both an integral reading of Smith's work, and a specifically located interpretation of its theoretical impact. Yet Smith defines his own work as cultural history, not as social theory. What
INTRODUCTION
might it mean to speak of culture, theory and the visual as ways in which to read Smith? Why read his work in these terms, and not, say, as art history, given his chosen field of profession? Certainly it is customary to describe Bernard Smith as Australia's leading art historian, though there are now more competitors for that role than there were thirty years ago, and the younger people he often taught might be inclined to question the judgement, view themselves as leaders instead. Smith's self-definition is indeed as an historian of art, only he diverges from the stricter sensibilities concerning art in order to define it broadly as well as narrowly. He employs both an anthropological as well as an aesthetic sense of art. On the one hand, art is defined as high culture, in particular established genres, and judged by Kantian criteria of taste. On the other, it encompasses virtually everything we make or do, from children's papier-mache forms to visual design, tables and chairs, crafts as well as high art. Bernard Smith actually persists with this dual vision, for it indicates both professional and democratic or popular sensibilities. For Smith, there will always be at least two meanings of art.3 These tensions work through history or civilisations. Smith's project is an historicism, consistently guided by the sense that style or meaning is historical. It is anthropological, in the sense that it offers ways of thinking which draw upon practical culture as well as on exemplary works or styles of art. All this is to say that Smith's project is also theoretical, in an historical way, using the visual as its customary subject matter, whether artwork or artifact. To speak of Imagining the Antipodes, then, is to evoke not fantasy but the anticipation of activity and its mental shadowing, for as we are, so do we imagine. And we imagine within flows of culture and history which are beyond our choosing. We create, but not ex nihilo, not exactly as we please. We work in and through a plurality of traditions, and imaginably the quality of the results of these processes depends upon the consciousness we have of these flows and not only upon our talents. The enormity of Bernard Smith's scholarly achievement is matched only by the modesty of his methodological approach to making sense of the world. For as we interpret, so do we use what is given us, so does our work return into the streams of history which make us.
xv
CHAPTER 1
BEGINNINGS
THE BOY ADEODATUS Who is Bernard Smith? We do not need to accept his version of the story, but he has left us one. In 1984 Bernard Smith published his autobiography. Just this side of seventy, his life's achievements were already remarkable. Smith had written the two most significant works of Australian art history, and had travelled to London to work at the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes on the thesis that became one of the most respected in the field, European Vision and the South Pacific. He had
coordinated the controversial Antipodean Exhibition in Melbourne in 1959 and had established the Power Institute of Fine Arts at the University of Sydney. He had taught at a bush school, painted and stopped painting, walked up the hill between Potts Point and the Gallery of New South Wales, promoted public art education, had a family, served as art critic for the Age and he had loved his first wife, Kate - not bad for a ward of the state, a bastard for whom things might have turned out differently. Yet none of this triumphal public path, so much itself the stuff of conventional biography, was to figure in The Boy Adeodatus - The Portrait of a Lucky Young Bastard. Indeed, the charm of
the book has to do with its focus upon that with which we empathise youth, suburbs, kitchens with fresh linen and Vacola jars, fences to be climbed, worlds to be discovered or constructed, childhood, not the success of adults; the city, the bush, the self, new worlds, rather than suits and grave men and seriosity. The charm of Smith's approach in The Boy Adeodatus is also disarming; he knew that there were things about which we should
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
remain silent. The Boy stops in 1940, when Smith was twenty-four. As he tells, this was a moment of transition. He had made three momentous decisions - to stop painting and to begin writing about art, to join the Communist Party, and to marry Kate Challis. Already we sense something powerful about Smith's modesty, about the unspoken, even as we are also reminded of the significance of childhood and youth, before it all gets bitter and jaded as we discover ourselves to be surrounded by schemers or idiots. And he wrote it in third person, a difficult strategy, suggesting as it does somehow a divine interpreter who looks over the shoulder or a neutral voice of documentary, as in Trotsky's attempt at an autobiography. But through Smith's pen the strategy works, and brilliantly; together, perhaps, with Drusilla Modjeska's Poppy and Robert Dessaix's A Mother's Despair, The Boy is a work as evocative as Australian autobiography gets (though it also connects back, given Smith's duration, to other works like Jack Lindsay's Life Rarely Tells and Donald Home's Education of Young Donald). Perhaps the difference, more than any, is that Smith was writing as an historian, as an act of memory; later he was to describe himself not as an art historian but as a cultural historian with a primary interest in the visual. The Boy is certainly an act that Ruskin would recognise as word painting; but it is more than that, for it is anthropology as well as aesthetics. The book follows the traces of the women who made his life, his natural mother and his foster-mum, the first who gave him life by following the unexpected pregnancy through rather than terminating it, the second who raised little Bennie in the Sydney suburb of Burwood until teaching and art drew him to the city of Sydney. The Boy is a kind of personal memoir to the social, it is a hymn to dependence, to the others who helped make Bernard Smith. The implication about meaning and context would not be lost, for like Marx and Freud, Smith knew that history's tales were not self-evident, that you had to look sideways and back to see or at least to understand what was apparently in front of your face. This is one implication of The Boy Adeodatus, that vision needs to be lateral if it is to connect. Another message was that of happy complexity, together with the usages of naming. Bernard Smith had two mothers, and a father who walked, who disappeared. His book manages to pass over the latter with grace, but to celebrate both mothers rather than mourn the loss of the original and bemoan or
BEGINNINGS
belittle the substitute he ended up with. What this suggests is that already Smith as a boy was made aware that we each possess significant others who persist in seeing us individually in different ways. Even as children, before we are inserted into social divisions of labour, our friends and relatives construct us as possessing different personas, or pick up on different aspects of our personalities. Young Ben already had more than one context or family; and in connection with this he had various different names. Bernard William Smith - he copped his father's name, even in his father's absence; Joseph, in parentheses, was added to the baptismal certificate. To some he was Ben, Little Ben, Bennie - later, always Bernard, momentarily, in the Communist Party, Bernie; his mum was Rose Anne Tierney, his minder Mum Keen. When he painted in the 1940s and again briefly in the 1980s, he used the name Joseph Tierney, as a sign to his other mother, so he could be all these things to all these people, and carry all these names. Thinking back on his past, in writing The Boy Adeodatus, Smith came to encounter the same theme which in a sense animates European Vision and his books on Australian painting. Perspective, experience make for difference; naming is but the act of mortals striving to capture momentarily the ephemeral and the fugitive of life's meaning. We see what we know as well as what seems to present itself to us; and we name things differently, depending on where we stand, from whence we come, which side of the blanket, antipodes or centre, margin or metropolis. The Boy Adeodatus plays on its connection with Augustine, and his unwanted son, but it works more powerfully on the theme of the enclosed garden, the suburban paradise of childhood lost. The book opens with Little Ben in the garden; it is somewhere around the end of the Great War, though the image could just as easily be in the 1950s or 60s. Mum Keen minds him; Dad Keen insists he read the Bible, and it is the Bible and Marx, he says in later life, which become the major texts for his life. The optic of Bernard Smith's life opens thus, in the backyard, but then the narrative steps back, to cover the lives of his mothers and their people. He finetools the opening, for words are important. Addressing the National Book Council on its award for 1984, Smith indicated that he wanted to avoid stereotypes of success or failure, of triumphalism or the god or gods that failed. 'Disillusion is a variety of self-pity and I wanted to avoid all forms of self-pity. Because for bastards self-pity is fatal; our natural strength lies in a kind of
IMAGINING
T H E ANTIPODES
detachment', which in turn explains the reliance on third persona. The images were carefully tuned: 'He would remember the garden', the opening line, evoking the backyard, and Eden, and the pastoral in William Morris' News from Nowhere; the second sentence, the Japanese plum in the garden indicating the thing itself, the symbol of his St Theresa in Rome, and his mother's bridal photo; the green and yellow loquats symbolising again the setting, but also Bernard and Valerie Welsh, the two state wards growing up together in the house called Braeside at Burwood.1 Little Ben was nine months old when he arrived there. The household became his world, Mum Keen at its centre, Dad Keen marginal, his natural mother nearby, up the road, trying to make ends meet. But there is little blame, or cause for blame in the narrative; reflecting back upon the story Smith knows that Rose Anne suffers, and suffers more than he does for her inability to provide. When later his mother married and changed name, she wrote to the boy, addressing the letter to the new name, to Bennie Kahl. 'She hoped it would help him to realise that he was one of the family . . . But when he received it he did not like that name at all. His name was Smith. He knew who his real father was. He had gone away. So he sat down, and with Bertha's help, wrote his first letter', signed it Bennie Smith xxxxxx.2 His new lot were Congregationalists, read Charles Kingsley, so Bernard attended the Salvation Army Sunday School, learned about the importance of service, and independence. Bernard encountered some good schoolteachers and initiated a lifelong relationship with libraries. Already discussion became serious, socialism, religion, Douglas Credit, communism, fascism, the New Guard, almost anything in the papers. He read Bradley's Shakespearean Tragedy, Darwin, Huxley, Haeckel, did well, won a teacher's scholarship, was disappointed in turn with those who taught teachers, but met May Marsden, an inspiring teacher of art, met the images of Cezanne, the Dutch genre painters who somehow reminded him of home, the household and its matriarch. He visited Queensland, where his natural mother now worked the land and lived in rural poverty, and he learned something of the difference between the European garden within which he grew and the Australian garden in which he found himself, tonally, texturally different, different in density and (as everyone came to say) in colour. Then Smith's story leads to his bush school in Murraguldrie, outback of Wagga in New
BEGINNINGS
South Wales, where he painted landscape, read again Ruskin's Elements of Drawing as he sketched and pondered the difference between vision and nature and struggled with the will-to-power of his hormones. Now he discovered surrealism. Protected from the Great War by his years in Mumma Keen's backyard garden, he knew nothing yet of its roots, in arguments about crisis and decay, Dada and futurism. Still in the sticks, now schoolteaching, he read Herbert Read's Art Now, and Andre Breton's What is Surrealism? Surrealism was a rupture, a symbol of movement and a sign of the times, of the realms of imagination and politics. He wrote in his diary in November 1938: 'I look at the world with greater confidence and with less desire to compromise with it. Surrealism recently has pointed out a new path to me in art. It is the thing for which I have been unconsciously waiting'. 3 Did Smith then become a surrealist? Not quite, for that was an honour to be carried in Australia very largely by the lonely figure of James Gleeson. For Bernard it worked more like a can-opener, and certainly he painted in its shadow, as of the darkness of the impending war. But for Smith the attraction was somehow more to political dissidence than to the aesthetics of dissonance alone. He read Joseph Freeman's American Testament, subscribed to the realist New Masses which Freeman came to edit. Now he struck up a relationship with Lindsay Gordon. Parts of their correspondence appear in The Boy Adeodatus; the originals are in the Mitchell Library where Bernard liked to work in those years. Gordon works as an irritant; his letters to Smith are often inflammatory, he helps goad Smith out of his still too-innocent respect for art. The global situation was one of decline, and Gordon was one who spoke his mind; jaded, indeed bitter, he helped Bernard to realise that the conventional, Clive Bell distinction between art and society was becoming increasingly irrelevant. Poets and artists were already dying, in Spain. But Australians still largely felt too far away from this. In Sydney they were too smug, in Melbourne too dull. Smith visited Melbourne for the first time in Easter 1938, to look at the holdings of the Felton Bequest in the Gallery and to visit Heidelberg; but the canvas of the local impressionists had already given way to asphalt. He had read William Moore's two-volume catalogue Story of Australian Art, and was depressed that no audience existed for the book; it was remaindered, he picked it up cheap at Dymocks in Sydney. He read another big book which appeared in two volumes and sold well to the
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
faithful, Soviet Communism by Beatrice and Sidney Webb. Like Spengler's Decline of the West, these were two volumes given to civilisational analysis. He felt compelled to choose. And so, on returning to Sydney he joined the Teachers' Branch of the Communist Party of Australia, for communism was a bastard tradition; somehow it called to him, though the attraction did not outlast the war. The others in the branch called him Bernie; this time the habit of naming generated some confusion, at least for the secret police, whose file blurred Bernard with another Bernie Smith, known to frequent bars with young seamen at Circular Quay. Now came the famous Herald Art Show organised by Keith Murdoch. Modernism arrived in Australia, or at least its European precedents were aired locally, Gauguin, Dali. There was even a painting in the collection by a lapsed Australian called John Power. Bernard read one of the few available keyholes into the European situation, in Peter Thoene's blue Pelican book Modern German Art (1938). No sooner had the optic of modernism opened than its enemies sought to close it down. Thoene's was a response, a cry of anguish among other things against the 1937 Nazi anti-art exhibition of 'degenerate' work in Munich; Thoene was a pseudonym for Oto Bihalji-Merin, who lived under this other name to tell the story. Yet for Smith the situation was different to Gleeson, perhaps more like Thoene; you needed to write, to educate, to contribute to some kind of critical culture which might help to resist the barbarians. And then there came his third big event, Kate. But there The Boy Adeodatus stops. Why would a writer of distinction exercise such discretion as this, and stop now? As I have suggested, Smith's work is dynamic, personal and personable, but it is also modest in scope; he knows when to remain silent. His purpose in The Boy Adeodatus is not to present the tortured soul of romantic biography but to indicate something about common experience as well as different. For the kinds of difference or dissent with which Smith aligned himself, in aesthetics or in politics, were also obviously shared by others in Melbourne and Sydney, Madrid and Berlin. Smith was attracted neither to romanticism nor to the idea of the avant-garde, though of course the Communist Party veered between popular front and vanguard politics. As he wrote in a manuscript on 'This Culture Stuff in 1939, against the cult of the avant-garde: 'Small groups of individuals cannot hope to make any appreciable difference to a
BEGINNINGS
change in the cultural standards of any country, unless they are in harmony with these determinates of change'.4 He had not yet joined the Communist Party, but the thinking was pre-eminently Marxist context rules, as Marx had put it in the 1859 Preface, people make their own history but not as they please in The Eighteenth Brumaire. What was true of history was also true of art history. Discussing the 'poets of decadence', he wrote a year later that 'no form of art can, I believe, maintain itself solely by the continual refinement of its own conventions'.5 Lindsay Gordon had relieved Smith of any final sense that art was, or could be, autonomous. Of course, it had its own institutional life and logic, galleries and dealers; but its autonomy was nevertheless illusory, not least of all in periods of social decay and crisis. This did not mean, however, that art was merely an aesthetic level corresponding to the pertinent stage of capitalist development. As Smith put it much later, in his inaugural lecture for the Power Institute in 1968: 'If you will permit me a high level of generalization I think it is broadly true to say that over the past two hundred years the artistic tradition has been consistently antagonistic to the values and structure of modern industrial society'.6 Capitalist society and economy, ironically, had been unable to generate its own autochthonous cultural forms. The new society was industrial, consumerist and passive; art in general remained romantic, even to the extent later that postmodernism also replayed vital themes of romanticism via surrealism. Art, in other words, was as often inclined to negation as to affirmation, and this especially in periods of decline. As Smith read Thoene's text he marked the passage in the margin: 'An atmosphere of catastrophe in the social sphere, the division of the ego in the private sphere; brooding revolt against fate, narrow morality and an ecstatic, almost religious individualism; these are the essential marks of German expressionism'.7 Yet Smith resisted the apocalyptic, partly because he was already drawn to the idea that history is patterned, however differently. Surrealism attracted him more as an aesthetic than as a politics. Its politics could be suitably radical, but already he encountered the awkwardness that some artists seemed to have with politics; they wanted to preserve the image of their autonomy against the stain. It was a problem he was to encounter again, later when it came to the controversies surrounding the politics of art in The Antipodean Manifesto.
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
On 16 October 1940 Smith gave a paper on surrealism to the Teachers' Federation Art Society. He argued that surrealism was a comet, but a significant one. It represented the new, and as such was bound to be rubbished by those who knew better. It was received as rubbish in the same way that impressionism had been in the 1890s, new, therefore not art. For Smith, such developments begged questions about the nature of modernity and of history; they needed to be viewed globally or civilisationally. 'Being a world phenomenon it can only be considered by taking a world view. At this point I shall state definitely that to my mind western civilization has experienced a breakdown and is now undergoing a process of degeneration'.8 Smith's view was personal, but it was not only that. He summoned three varied but representative thinkers to make the case. Marx, Spengler and Toynbee all pointed this way, representing respectively the viewpoint of history according to communism, fascism and democracy. To introduce the theme of decadence, however, was not to await the apocalypse. If there was decadence now, in the midst of war, then the theme raised the issue of previous periods of decadence. Decadence implied resurgence, not the end of the world. Speaking trans-historically, Smith argued that decadent periods were typically marked by paintings possessing surrealist qualities; the paintings of Bosch, in this regard, anticipated the work of Dada. Decadence called out a new spirit, was positive in this way; and the innovative turn often involved a new source or point of perspective: 'the new art forms which arise after a period of Surrealism generally flourish upon new soil away from the older cultures which originally fertilised them'.9 Surrealism, for Smith, was then like modernism, nothing new, at least not in the sense that Dada supposed. Surrealism was a generic phenomenon, a cyclical trend which became manifest trans-historically. Or to put it more precisely, surrealism, like romanticism, was part of a great cultural repertoire which humans in different places periodically felt compelled to draw upon. Smith was suggesting that a general theory of history, in the manner of Marx, Spengler or Toynbee also indicated something about art; decadence returned, and so did surrealism. The conclusion was obvious: faced by the experience of the world wars and the interwar years, 'we have to realise that we are either witnessing the birth of a new social order or the end of civilization as we know it'.10 Sensitive critics of the period often observed that somehow the old was dying, but the new was not
BEGINNINGS
born yet; still, as Smith insisted, this scenario involved the end of civilisation as we know it. All the same, surrealism was about endings rather than beginnings. And it internalised the world, by insisting that the problems before us were in the mind more than the world. Smith's conclusion was different. The dream world was fascinating but it was not primary. The social was primary; in the beginning was us, not me. More, if surrealism was cyclical, so then must realism be. Modern realism or social realism also had its antecedents - in Swift, Voltaire, Milton and Goya. Somehow Smith had managed already to think of the long run of civilisations, rise and decline, and to grasp the dominant frames of the twentieth century, those two world wars which brought with them communism and fascism. Fascism, communism, crisis, decadence, the possibility of renewal hang over his thinking as they still do. Surely it was his intimate childhood contact with the Bible that helped to plant this sense of history as the long run. But then came Marx and Spengler and Toynbee, and others. Bernard Smith read voraciously into the 1940s - Eliot, Nordau, Daiches, Sir James Frazer, Freud, Christopher Caudwell, Herbert Read, Fry, Ruskin, William Morris, Jack Lindsay, Joseph Freeman; and he talked. He talked with Dale Trendall, the classicist, and with Tom Rose, his philosophical connection to John Anderson, the libertarian philosopher at Sydney University. He argued with Lindsay Gordon. He read classics, Aristotle, Lessing, Longinus. Obviously these things were encountered in different ways, for insight can be as accidental as it is systemic in arrival. Lindsay Gordon pushed Smith hard about materialism; 'truth can only be realised through practical activity'.11 He harangued Smith on what today we would call philosophical anthropology, using terms of reference reminiscent of Marx and Engels in The German Ideology, where labour and creation are the context of art and culture.12 Smith wrote to Lindsay on the eve of his first departure from Australia, 10 May 1948, from Potts Point: 1 shall always remember your letters to me at Murraguldrie, precious things they were to me . . . they meant more to me than anything I have read since'.13 In the meantime he did the hard graft. He read Marx and Engels' The German Ideology, Marx's Theses on Feuerbach and Engels' Origin of the Family, the
State and Private Property. The works of the young Marx, the famous Paris Manuscripts were unavailable to him. He found some good theoretical support amongst the flotsam of authorised Dialectical
10
IMAGINING
T H E ANTIPODES
Materialism in the superior work of Max Eastman and Sidney Hook, especially Hook's Hegel to Marx, which focused on the young Marx and the young Hegelians, Ruge, Bauer and Feuerbach. He read Marx's throwaway lines about the appeal of Greek art and sat through Capital. He persevered with Spengler's massive two-volume study, Decline of the West and the slighter book on Man and Technics. And he worked through Toynbee's A Study of History, especially volumes four to six (picked them up at David Jones' Book Corner in 1942). He read Sorokin's fat volumes on civilisation in the Mitchell Library. What was the substance of all this, where did it point, the content and message of all these big books? Spengler became, as Smith had observed, complicit with Nazism; but he had a theory of history that was worth taking seriously. Spengler's message, in this way like Smith's, was that decline meant something else as well; his theory of history was not one of unilateral demise, but of cyclical return and reformation. Toynbee's optic was structurally similar to Spengler's; civilisations rise and fall, reach peaks and collapse; in this there should be no surprises. The more interesting question becomes that of how change occurs, whether it is internal or externally triggered. Toynbee was bound to appeal more to Smith, for even though Toynbee spat at Marx at the same time he drew on his thinking. Toynbee took on the language of class as an analytic device. It was simple: the breakdown of civilisation involved class war, even if this did not lead, as Marx sometimes imagined, to socialism or the end of history. Class war, for Toynbee, works as the trigger of history: thus the breakdown of a civilization gives rise to a class-war within the body social of a society which was neither divided against itself by hard-and-fast divisions nor sundered from its neighbours by unbridgeable gulfs so long as it was in growth . . . [therefore] the nature of the breakdowns of civilization can be summed up in three points: a failure of creative power in the minority, an answering withdrawal of nemesis [following] on the part of the majority, and a consequent loss of social unity in the society as a whole.14
Toynbee's lines were first published in 1939; during 1942 Smith took them in. In 1937 there was the Munich Degenerate Art Exhibit, in 1939 the 'phoney war': plainly Toynbee spoke to Smith and to his moment.
BEGINNINGS
But Toynbee was also sharp, and critical of Spengler as well as Marx. Spengler was too mythological, too organic, Marx too technological; Smith noted in the margin Toynbee7 s claim that technique and economy were not the same.15 You needed to look hard to find the social actors among these conceptual abstractions. Toynbee's cultural universe was rich and expansive, taking in democracy, education, creativity, the Greeks, moderns, Nazis, communists, nationalism, slavery, the American Civil War, Hellenism, Judaism and Christianity. He spoke with ease of proletarian revolution, a dominant minority (in decline) and a creative majority (in growth). He referred to ours as a 'Post-Modern' Age, just as Smith was soon to characterise contemporary Australian art as post-modern, after modernism.16 Finally, Toynbee suggested that societies in transition often seize upon images of future or past in order to legitimate themselves; he invented two types, futurism and archaism, to evoke this possibility.17 Still Smith wanted to use Marx, for Toynbee's system was clever and suggestive but somehow too modular and sealed (and smug?). In his papers a two-page fragment from 1941-2 spells out 'Some problems connected with the Marxist approach to art criticism'. Smith opens his reflections with the observation that there is a methodological tension in Marx's work, between the systems-logic of Capital and the historicist narrative of The Civil War in France. Marx is torn between historical and analytical ways of thinking. Those who follow Marx are in a way obliged to live with the tension; they can work from history or from first principles. The choice is ultimately unsatisfactory, for like materialism and idealism these are names for ways of prioritising which are not mutually exclusive. Smith elects on this occasion to follow first principles and to use history as a check. The primary concern of his reflection is the question of the autonomy of art. Marx's defence of the Greeks implies that while successive modes of production indicate progress, art does not progress in the same way; it is culturally framed, not technologically given. So, for example, the Greek epic was only possible when the Greeks believed in their gods, not when they had developed a position of scepticism.18 Parts of Smith's argument, then, are sympathetic with Marx, parts with Toynbee. The vital point of sympathy between Smith, Marx and Toynbee and even Spengler is the necessity of historicism. The point for art history is that modernism (or
1 1
12
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
surrealism) has to age; therefore it must be placed, and it can be expected to recycle in some form or other. To talk about art, in particular, was necessarily to talk about the long view, to speak of civilisations in the plural, Egypt, Persia, China and the West. Smith had become a civilisational thinker, and therefore a pluralist. Smith's teacher's thesis of November 1940 is similarly suggestive of the synthesis. Tendencies in modern English verse' centres upon the work of T. S. Eliot. Eliot's major poem 'The Waste Land' had first been published by Virginia and Leonard Woolf in 1922; but somehow it, too, seemed to speak directly to the thirties. Smith's judgement was consistent with his earlier views on surrealism and decadence: T. S. Eliot made the fatal mistake of imagining that our present civilization is a 'Waste Land' because of its present religious impotence and sterility ... He has forgotten, too, that the decay of a particular set of social relationships is not to be equated with the decay of civilization itself.. .19 As you look at Smith's own paintings of the 1940s you can see the presence of Eliot, all the same; for part of him was enchanted, overruled by the urgent period sense of decline. Yet he strove for the balance, and eschewed pessimism in his prose. In discussion of Eliot he summoned up Toynbee as the thinker of the idea that 'the poets of disintegrating cultures tend toward an "archaism" of symbolism, in a futile attempt to recapture the unified "style" of that same culture's growth period'.20 The synthesis in Bernard Smith's own mind was not unlike that constructed by Melvin Rader in his important 1939 study No Compromise: The Conflict Between Two Worlds.™ Smith read the book closely
and carefully annotated it. The two worlds between which citizens had to choose were not communism and fascism but democracy and fascism. Rader explains and contextualises Spengler's work and its relation to fascism; then he discusses philosophy of history, explicitly with reference to Spengler, Sorokin and Toynbee. As in Smith's reading, Toynbee comes out best, Marx in the shadows. Like Smith in this setting, Rader makes the choice that between democracy and fascism, but he aligns socialism and the Soviet Union with democracy. Fascism
BEGINNINGS
offends worst of all because it is publicly reactionary, it is the explicit attempt to reverse the revolutionary and humanist currents of 1789. But the bind is also apparent. Fascism seems more barbaric because it is openly antihumanist, publicly anti-universal. Can fascism be more dangerous because it is publicly contemptuous of democracy? Or is communism not worse, finally, because it masks its contempt? The choice between democracy and fascism was not as simple as it seemed. With wicked wit, the brilliant Viennese satirist, Karl Kraus, is reputed to have said: If you ask me to choose between two evils I choose neither'. This is not, however, the way citizens encountered the world in the 1930s, because individual integrity then had to be weighed against the pragmatics of commitment. The intellectual attraction to the work of Marx was one thing, for Bernard Smith. The politics of opposition to fascism and of commitment to the culture of pedagogy in the Teachers' Branch of the Communist Party was another. He signed up; yet his was ultimately a cultural Marxism. So after a decade his membership lapsed. The benevolent Marxist state in the east was more restrictive of art and freedom than the parallel market institutions of the west. Fascism gone with war's end at the level of state power in Germany and Italy, his choice could finally be with Karl Kraus. For contrary to the abstract Marxist proposition that history represented a linear sequence of unfolding modes of production, Smith knew history to be a mess, an ordered chaos of conflicting wills and actors, agents and institutions, who made their world but not just as they chose. As he was to put it later, this also meant that culture was always already mixed: Some kind of classicism or primitivism seems to be invariably present in all radical ideology . . . Classicism, medievalism and primitivism are the principal means by which radicals have attacked the conservative art values of the present, including the innovating present.. ,22
Socialists, too, on this basis could conjure up all kinds of ghosts from the past and chimeras for the future, all of which they did to a frenzy in the Soviet crucible, in art and in politics alike. As for Karl Kraus, when his moment came in the 1930s the satirist also had to make a choice, this time between social democracy and the Austrian state. He chose the state.
13
1 4
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
WORDS AND IMAGES By the time of Bernard Smith's inaugural Power Lecture in 1968, and given the reflective space which the occasion offered, Australia's leading art historian was in a position to offer some powerfully insightful comments on words and things. It was almost thirty years since he had stopped working in paint, and chosen instead to paint in words. The power of western mythologies, of number and word now presented itself to Smith as a civilisational sign. Science is dominated by number, arts by the word; yet Smith simultaneously worries that the larger problem might be elsewhere, in the power of the image. This was a way to raise again his ongoing concerns, from European Vision to Imagining the Pacific, with the idea that imaging and imagining somewhere run together, even as they also represent different orders of seeing. On the occasion of his inaugural lecture Smith's particular interest was less with number or word than with the mixture of words and images which we are now accustomed to calling mass media. So he argued that: If the liberal tradition is to be sustained in these powerful new areas of mass-communication, critical modes of procedure will have to be developed appropriate to the mixed media. We need an etymology and semantics of the visual image as vigorous as that of the word: to grasp the role of the mixed image in conveying information, in rhetoric, in persuasion, in the expression of feelings and the ways in which images may be conjoined with words.23 For Smith, such a need was consonant with the logic and intention of the Power Bequest; the Power Institute ought, in his eyes, to work as a kind of institutionalisation of restlessness, the gift of an alienated man for the promotion of change as well as its location in tradition. Change, like tradition, was a basic feature of the human condition. But how are we to judge or to discern? Smith's thinking typically works out of both the Kantian legacy and the tradition of historicism. At the same time he advocates and recognises the importance of a separation of spheres, forms of practices and ways of thinking of them and recognises that all these things, from art to politics and life, are actually mixed media. The connection between art and politics was to shadow his path. The crossover alluded
BEGINNINGS
to in the inaugural lecture also reflected Smith's civilisational sensibilities. One aspect of Smith's work concerns the way in which art history, among other things, reflects general societal trends towards secularisation, powerful though necessarily ever incomplete. The rise of modern painting, in this view, involves its relocation, from the church to the gallery; the shift in institutional location also indicates a shift of the kind of politics involved. To modify Hegel's throwaway that moderns read the morning newspaper as a ritual to replace church or confession - Smith's sense is that moderns, among other things, offer secular praise to the collections now held in galleries; secularisation, therefore, never quite means what it implies, for it indicates not the death of god but the retranslation of belief patterns into modernised forms of ritual. To worry about the especially modern combination of word and image in mass media as a rhetoric, as Smith did in his inaugural lecture, was therefore to anticipate the cultural forms now often called postmodern, and to call for a certain form of cultural studies to read them. Smith's historicism and his residual Marxism, however, always insist on what cultural studies today too easily overlook: power, context, history, violence. The themes were among some which Smith returned to later, in a seminar on the 1890s at the Humanities Research Centre in Canberra. Word and number matter, for Smith, indeed they are the gods of our modern lives. But they are not only to be invoked cosmologically, filmically, as symbols without substance. In his comments on the 1890s Smith developed a different line of argument. When it came to art, art history and criticism had been transformed not by the cult of the visual which has so taken French theory in particular, so much as by the fetish of writing.24 It is the act of writing, not seeing, which has transformed the nature of art criticism, for hitherto the social practice we now call 'art criticism' was primarily verbal; it grew out of the churches, not out of the print medium. Before the modern, art response was essentially verbal, and its concern was with a non-verbal, that is, visual experience. Painting, for example, used to be outside verbal communication, sacred rather than pedestrian or profane. But now: All this has changed. With the ascendancy of reproduction has come also the ascendancy of verbal commentary - so that we only see what we read we are seeing, and not what our eyes would by their own
15
16
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
intuitive visual explorations of visual reality presented to us if unaided by art-critical verbal diktats.23 Like Kant, Smith is attracted to distinction, and to the exercise of the appropriate form of judgement. Difference matters; everything is not everything else. Never innocent or primal, the visual experience is nevertheless transformed by the endless palaver of acceptable interpretation. As Smith was to argue later, this was nowhere more evident than in the rampant inflation of the idea of reading, which today works as an equivalent for interpreting or explaining. We no longer look at a painting or a street scene, we read it. The hegemonic claims of the text, the word, therefore jostle with what the French tend to view as the terror of the eye or the gaze.26 To use a more concrete example, as much as we can delight in the viewing of Australian landscape by Fred Williams, there comes a point where we seem to see Fred Williams' paintings in nature, no longer nature in Williams' representations. Of course, it can be objected that we only inhabit a chaotic world in which there is an endless proliferation or traffic of signs, and we never know what came first, never are innocent or capable of an innocence in interpretation. The implication of Smith's argument, however, is that it is no longer the case, as we imagine, that the artist leads and the critic follows. In effect, the critic leads; the critic authorises and allocates value. The guidebooks we carry as we wander through galleries are no longer what they seem; they are authorised by Deleuze and Guattari. Every other art catalogue opens with a quotation from Michel Foucault. Our encounter with the visuals of art are thus framed by the texts which license particular locations of them. Theory here leads, or at least philosophers do; whereas for Smith understanding follows history, arrives late if at all.27 As Robert Nelson puts it, the reception of works of art somehow becomes theoretically overdetermined to the point that the discredited avant-garde, having left by the front door, return now through the rear entrance in the varying roles of cultural advisers.28 We all need philosophers by our elbows to explain everyday life. Smith's relation to art was more public and democratic, even if this meant dropping the more severe kind of authority which would allow professors to divide the world into those who know (can paint or speak of painting) and those who can't. His earliest endeavours in the
BEGINNINGS
art world had been public, working on the promotion of art holdings in borrowing libraries, travelling exhibits especially beyond the cities, judging in local and children's shows, doing the rounds of the community. Let us remember, Smith was a teacher, and a deeply committed educator who understood the difference between teaching and learning but knew also that the processes involved, opaque as they are, warrant enthusiasm and passion as well as information and repetition. There were other connections, of a theoretical kind. Working with children called out the sympathy of surrealism and psychoanalysis; child painting, primitivism, naive art, raised obvious questions about how we come to see, hear and speak in particular ways. Arts, in short, were also like crafts, just as images shaded into imaginings. But not all Smith's practical efforts in art education had these loftier connections. Largely they involved the politics of persuasion, borrowing the paintings and getting them safely transported across the countryside on trains, locating half-suitable venues, beating up some support for publicity and so on - work more like that of a road manager than a leading light of the local art scene. Smith, by now, had escaped from the classroom and was working for the Gallery of New South Wales, seeking to connect life in the Gallery with that in the New South Wales Department of Education. He had done his time at Murraguldrie, was happy to have known the country but also to have moved on, though still feeling connected to it in some ways. A manuscript in Smith's personal papers looks back over the experience; it bears the title Taking art to the country: how it began'. On 10 October 1944 an exhibition, the first of its kind of any distinction, opened in Wagga. It was entitled One Hundred and Fifty Years of Australian Painting, and it had been organised by a Smith who was also immersed in the creation of his first book on Australian painting, Place, Taste and Tradition. It was an amazing feat; the exhibition included works from Conrad Martens to Thea Proctor, William Dobell, Noel Counihan, James Gleeson, Russell Drysdale and Margaret Preston. After Wagga the show went to Newcastle, Gosford, Goulburn, Lithgow, Bathurst, Orange, Wellington and Mudgee, ending in Dubbo on 4 July 1945. It was followed in December 1944 by a second travelling exhibition entitled Some Recent Australian Painting in Canberra, then classified still as a country town, where works by Jean Bellette, Grace Crowley, Ralph Balson and Frank Hinder among a hundred others
17
18
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
were shown for the first time. There were no galleries in the national capital then, as Smith observed, but there was a Scout troop, so the exhibition was held in the Scout Hall.29 He organised it all. Smith's sense, in retrospect, was that this new opening was part of the spirit of the times, anticipating postwar reconstruction. It was also reflective of what committed actors could achieve in a situation where the Gallery's administration was almost non-existent. Smith worked for the Gallery as a seconded teacher, discovering among his obligations the staging of the 1944 Archibald Prize and the highly popular American War Art Show of 1944-5, as well as controlling the movements of five different exhibitions then circulating simultaneously around New South Wales. This kind of activity was consistent with Smith's other commitments, to the Teachers' Federation Art Society and the Studio of Realist Artists, organising with May Marsden's other students public lectures by Sali Herman and James Gleeson, Smith himself speaking on topics ranging from Egyptian art to surrealism. At a later moment in his life he viewed the use of Power Institute funds for visitors similarly as part of a public responsibility, for example, he took Power Lectures to every major city and territory in Australia. In the period 1943 to 1945 Smith also collaborated with Katharine Susannah Prichard and George Farwell (and later Ken Levis and Rod Shaw) on Australian New Writing, another one of those little magazines that have contributed so substantially to Australian culture. Smith wrote for it, as did Lindsay Gordon, Vic O'Connor and Miles Franklin. The focus was often on everyday life, art and the working class. The theme of decadence figured with some prominence. In the third issue Smith penned a piece on the 'Encouragement of art', again arguing for the kind of localism which he practised. The point was a common one: war had cut barriers between masses and elites, opening new possibilities such as factory or workshop art.30 In later years this kind of sentiment was still evident, for example, in Smith's weekly articles as the art critic of the Melbourne Age between 1963 and 1966. Here the democratic or civic impulse which motivated the New South Wales travelling exhibits was still at work, for Smith as popular critic strives to give everyone a guernsey; in the Age columns he covers all artists exhibiting in Melbourne each week, even when their work is ordinary or plain, and he avoids editorialising or character assassination, referring only intermittently and sotto voce to the
BEGINNINGS
Antipodeans, the hegemony of abstraction and the decline of figuration as a lost cause. Pro-Labor into the 1970s, Smith was also critical of Gough Whitlam's art policies - put simply, they were elitist, which was a limit because they would generate nothing new. Whitlam's policies failed to develop local strength, confirming or extending already recognised talent rather than cultivating it from below. This was an error of imaginative omission rather than commission. Unfortunately the Whitlam Government began to provide generous support for the arts without any well thought-out policy as to its purposes or those of art. Smith used an historic parallel which at least would make sense to the Great Man. Louis XIV had used the talents of Colbert to encourage the social development of art from below; Catherine the Great had followed a different strategy in arts policy, which involved buying the art of others for the Hermitage, which resulted in a wonderful collection with no apparent connection to a local art scene - art in Russia therefore remained provincial. In 1933, Smith's story went on, Whitlam's hero Franklin Roosevelt had followed the Louis/Colbert strategy rather than Catherine's - he established the Public Works of Art Project, a mysteriously Soviet-sounding organisation with substantial results. The Project hired 3749 artists who created 15 633 works of art for public institutions (in the America Of the 1930s, as in Smith's New South Wales of the 1940s, art display was, by definition, a metropolitan experience). Whitlam's error, in Smith's eyes, was to follow Catherine's policy, buying up significant works such as Pollock's Blue Poles but behaving as though the collection of art was more closely connected to the realm of consumption than of production. The strategy largely supported already established artists at the expense of the new.31 The echoes of the Catherine/Whitlam story reach back into Smith's earlier beliefs and practices. Australian New Writing could be sneered at by superior minds as the mock proletarian outcome of popular front strategies, or as populism outright. Yet some of its writers wrote powerfully and movingly. The art of children can be notoriously amateurish, but the mind of the child in league with the hand can also generate insight and difference sufficient to astonish. The potters and Sunday Masonite painters whose work Smith reviewed in the art pages of the Age deserved better than to be sneered at; like the work of children or of craftworkers, theirs was an autonomous expression of
19
20
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
creativity; it told us something about who we were, even if it was not beautiful or harmonious in proportion as were the classics of the Renaissance. The students of fine arts attracted by the Power Institute were also encouraged to get paint under their skin at the art studios in the Tin Sheds off campus where Smith again arranged for the possible contact, at least, between realms of art production and consumption. For art, now, was work as well as creation or aura, it was pedestrian as well as sacred or divine; it lived in the streets, for the modern world after Kant was all mixed up, to the extent that we might now observe more beauty in the construction or fitting of Sydney's Museum of Contemporary Art than in its hangings, or contemplate balance more happily looking out the windows of the Louvre than staring at the objects on its walls. Smith's critique of Whitlam's policy ended with an advocacy of the idea of the neighbourhood workshop. His specific allusion was to recent experience on the east side of Manhattan. Again, the echo in Smith's earlier view was familiar. He had long advocated community workshops, though the enthusiasm was revived with the sense of cultural opening attendant on Whitlam's election in 1972. Into the middle of the 1970s Smith advanced the argument that academic art had not been replaced by industry, rather the two coincided, they mixed forms. Industry had not killed art any more than photography shot portraiture; the much-announced death of art emerged merely as a new way of behaving.32 Dada, now, is always with us. The cornmodification of the art scene had always been a more substantial problem. Small, decentralised workshops were necessary to help others get around the art boom and its negative effects. In art, as increasingly in critical theory, performance, fashion and television threatened to freeze movement by legitimating and authorising a handful of talents and ignoring the rest.33 Smith was not a romantic. He was attracted to the precedents established by John Ruskin and William Morris, for whom the practice of drawing was a necessary part of appreciating art, for whom furniture and the art and craft of the vernacular were as important as great works of art in their different spheres of existence. But Smith was no medievalist; his desire was not to return to some imaginary past but to work with the tensions within which we find ourselves. This was a modernist attitude, for better and worse, because it presumes that we are stuck within both. So he argued that:
BEGINNINGS
Technological evolution, like organic evolution is not linear; where over-specialised forms have had their run, more primitive but more flexible forms gain a kind of second wind. This is the point to remember about the present growth of decentralised workshops throughout the country; though they may look as though they are imitating oldfashioned even medieval forms, they are in fact a response to urgent contemporary needs which centralised structures of industrialism can now no longer successfully cope with.34
Such was Smith's world-view already into the 1940s, after encountering Marx and Toynbee and Spengler. Progress was never linear, nor was there merely a clear and devastating descent into barbarism; the new was never simply that for it recycled parts of the old, some of which would be recognisable to us, while others were transformed in the process. So as much as we need the familiar, we need the other, and our desires for the new and different and the routine always play upon us. Being moderns we are restless, restless even for a moment's peace or rest. But we live with speed as well as tedium, with repetition as well as novelty; we live with the ambivalence of modernity, so much torn between past and future as to eclipse the present. IMAGES AND WORDS Smith's defence of community art as well as fine art obviously reflects a sense of community, again a highly contested value these days, championed by some as conferring place and meaning, spurned by others as too grimly compulsory and traditionalistic. It is consistent with Smith's position to feel torn or compromised over these matters; we can expect Smith to argue that we need city and community alike, even though they do not come together. Famously a citizen of Fitzroy as well as earlier of Potts Point, a state ward in suburban Burwood, only partly at home in Murraguldrie, Smith was also an active citizen of Glebe. The city neighbourhoods he has lived in actually sound like those enthused about in Adelaide by Hugh Stretton, peculiarly Australian as Australian city and suburban forms do not readily follow European or American paths where the choice is arguably clearer. Smith defends urbanism, but also warms to proximity. In the context of the struggle to save Glebe from overdevelopment, Smith began from the period and strategic observation that 'a real university is one that you can walk to'. 'Suburban romanticism' he found dangerous, setting
21
22
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
as it did work (bad) against leisure (good) and therefore centre against suburb: 'According to this burdensome [cultural] legacy work is a grind which exhausts and debilitates; vitality is restored by sport, recreation and leisure in a non-urban setting'. His stronger claim was that the university needs really to be part of a community, in this case that of Glebe.35 The echoes in his case are with the views of someone like the New Yorker of the 1950s, Jane Jacobs, for whom urban is good because or to the extent that it is mixed. Place matters; this is a major motif in the work of Bernard Smith, though it also works in an interrogative as well as assertive way. So what, then, do we mean by place? space? and how much of its meaning is mobile, transformative, negotiated? These are some of the kinds of questions raised even by the thematic titles of Smith's great work Place, Taste and Tradition, European Vision and the South Pacific, Imagining the Pacific, The Antipodean Manifesto - all of which are as suggestive of a
sense of question as of a sense of answer. Smith's work emerges as a dialogue between word and image where the tension shifts with the course of time. For young Bernard, Bennie, perhaps it is the visual which dominates; Smith paints into the 1940s, spends another four decades struggling with words and their relations to the visual, then himself paints again early into the 1980s before returning again to words, and to more words about those who chose to stay with paint, like Counihan. Moving closer to his eightieth year, his work turned towards something like a Sumtna, a reconsideration of all he had done and of its century, the century of modernism, of wars and surrealism, fascism and communism, abstraction and postmodernism. Smith's debut as a modern painter is exemplified in two works both of which appeared most recently in the Surrealism - Revolution by Night exhibition of 1993. The Advance of Lot and his Brethren was first
exhibited in the National Gallery of Victoria in 1940; Pompeii was first shown in the Federation Art Society in Sydney. While neither work is surrealist in the sense exemplified by Gleeson, both fit under the aegis of the collection gathered for Revolution By Night. Both are apocalyptic, civilisational canvases, peopled by casts of thousands. In Lot there is the image of decline and fall of archaic civilisations which have ridden on the backs of the suffering masses. As Smith put it, in self-analysis, the 'monuments of Greece, Rome, Byzantium and the Gothic world are shaken by the wrath of God as the people pass through vast seas of
BEGINNINGS
blood struggling towards the Promised Land'.36 This was an optimistic apocalypse, then; the masses were down but not out, a sense of turbulence, of movement persisted. Lot is a painting as much shadowed by images of Eliot's Waste Land as it is by surrealism and German expressionism. Surrealism in the manner of Dali was, in any case, the effective monopoly of Gleeson. But if Lot indicates against Eliot that movement persists over decline, Pompeii indicates the dominance, or negative prospect of decline as the Second War unfolds. If Lot is influenced by Picasso's Guernica and El Greco, Pompeii is haunted by Bosch. Smith's reflections on these early paintings published in 1982 in Art and Text are more confessional than this, offering senses of explanation to do with communism, guilt and the personal traumas of emotional entanglement. What is most captivating about the piece, like his autobiography, is the happy modesty of its conclusion. Having now given up painting, I destroyed all my other paintings except Pompeii, and left Lot with a picture framer in George Street, Sydney, where it was deposited for collection at the end of the Sydney showing of the Contemporary Art Society Exhibition, late in October 1940. It was in any case a painting that disturbed me and I did not want to see it again. I thought they had destroyed it. But thirty years later I got a ring from the same framer to say that it was still there. It must have been 1974 or 1975. They were very kind about the storage. On seeing it again it seemed to me to be quite a good painting. So I took it home.37
Like a long-lost friend he took it home; they did not talk. But later Smith's desire to paint revived. In May 1985 there opened at the University Gallery, University of Melbourne, an exhibit by one Joseph Tierney. His mother's second name, a given name he might have had but eventually didn't. He began to paint again in May 1984; he used a studio in the Trades Hall 1984-5. He wrote around the time to Jack Lindsay, apprehensive but excited at the prospect of returning to the visual image. His autobiography was completed; it was an obvious occasion to revisit, to reconsider, however fleetingly, the choice he had made at age twenty-four not to paint, but to write and educate about the visual. Lindsay caught on to the awkwardness of revisiting. He wrote to Smith: 'Your decision to turn to artwork emerges quite logically and yet at the same time is strange for someone clearly so absorbed
23
24
IMAGINING
THE ANTIPODES
in artistic practice as well as theory .. Z38 Smith had mentioned to Lindsay his subject matter, everyday more than surreal this time: 'People in Melbourne streets .. .perhaps a bit naive in places'.39 'Three men in a Melbourne Park' up the road from Nicholson Street; more symbolically, mocking Disney: 'His Australian Highness Mickey OA meets his people'. Twenty-six new paintings went on display, together with two from 1940, Lot and Pompeii. There is some continuity in style across the paintings; as with his writing it is the subject matter which shifts, from the apocalypse of war and fascism to the Sunday paintings of carnivals and demonstrations, Moomba, Labour Day, Palm Sunday in Melbourne in the eighties, the new Labor regime barely established, no talk here of Roosevelt or Louis XIV. Where Pompeii and Lot had both worked on a massive scale, structured archaeologically into levels above ground and under, layered into a multiplicity of levels and potential meanings, the 1980s' paintings were almost documentary, moments of lives, more figurative and direct in representation. But Smith was not to become a painter again, any more than he had been in the 1940s. The ghosts of his past had been settled by the revisitation, which had served its purpose. His own purpose was still to work upon that larger canvas of words and images, words about images and as images. For his purpose was not to offer the definitive grid through which art, or the pacific or the antipodes could be screened; it was more radical than that, for it was (among other things) to direct attention precisely to the existence of grids and their usages, not to construct a metatheory of reception or interpretation but to encourage the activity of criticism while establishing its conditions of existence between the eye, head and heart, the imagination and memory and the artwork. As he had put it in a talk on the ABC in 1964, his own shift from painting to writing, from the artwork to criticism had been a philosophical or anthropological one: T had become more interested in painting than ever but not my own. Who were we? Were we Australian artists? Where had we come from? What were we trying to do?'40 The questions were like those used by Gauguin to frame his triptych: 'who are we? where have we come from? where are we going?'. Smith had come to the conclusion that criticism was an integral part of the mechanism or psychology of creation. He had also come to understand the profound local ignorance of Australian art; so he began to write books about it. He became an historian, in this particular sense,
BEGINNINGS
an historian of visual culture whose curiosities were framed by the sense that history was best understood civilisationally. In 1984 Bernard Smith published his autobiography, hanging on the discretion, the unsaid of later life. He had planned a second volume, and actually began to draft it; but it became unravelled. There is a folder in his papers entitled 'Personal project for the continuation of Autobiography. The 1940's in Sydney'. It sketches out a kind of historical sociology of art in Sydney, the art establishment, the outsiders; it charts out a chronology month by month from 1939 to 1952, which becomes more skeletal as it proceeds. It is, that is to say, no longer an autobiography; it commences on the level of autobiography, but it progressively turns into a sociology or history of the institutions of Australian or Sydney art. Smith was writing himself out of the script, partly in discretion and in modesty, partly because the nature of the story seemed to shift so much further away from the closed suburban garden of childhood in Burwood. This was not for want of trying. Another document in Smith's papers bears the title 'Among the others'; it is an early draft for the planned sequel to The Boy Adeodatus. Again, its content concerns context, mainly the Sydney art scene into the 1940s, its implied extent and duration. Smith tucks away a great period vignette of Sali Herman in the manuscript. The voice sounds to contemporary ears like Flacco: Tve no trouble with Australians at all', he would say in his rather throaty continental accent. 'I go to a pub with a friend and when I get too many curious looks I wait for a break in the noise, then I stare at my friend and say in a loud voice, 'The real trouble with this bloody country is that there are too many fucking foreigners in it". He would then turn and greet everyone in the bar with a disarming grin. It never failed to work.41
So Smith weaves together personal and social, discussing in detail, for example, the 1940s controversies over art shows in Sydney, the modernist phantoms locked up in the cellars for safe keeping, the moderns cast disarmingly, for example, by Julian Ashton as degenerate, an extraordinary indiscretion in the shadow of the 1937 Munich Display. It was all of a piece. For his own shift out of painting was also political in part, a response to these times, a response more directly to
25
26
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
Lionel Lindsay's chauvinistic attack on modernism and the Jews. Perhaps writing was a better field in which to work on the art of persuasion. The second volume of Smith's autobiography disappeared into silence, together with his history of Australian architecture. There were other matters more urgent and enduring on which Smith would raise his voice.
CHAPTER 2
E N C O U NTE RING AUSTRALIAN PAI N T I NG
PLACE, TASTE AND TRADITION 'In 1940 no one in Sydney took any real interest in Australian art/ 1 Thus wrote Smith in the opening lines of the Second Preface to his first history of Australian art. Written into 1944, it was first published by Sidney Ure Smith in 1945. Out of print for years, it was finally reprinted by Oxford University Press in 1979. In the 1979 Preface Smith surveyed the interim period. Looking back, the indifference about Australian work is difficult to imagine. By our own times, of course, Tom Roberts jostled with Ken Done in postcard racks, and Fred Williams had joined Sidney Nolan as a national iconographer; even Juan Davila might periodically show up in public places. The situation Smith entered was a silence unto death. William Moore's Story of Australian Art of 1934 had been remaindered two years after publication. Smith viewed it as a fairly important achievement in its context; he blamed the soil on which it fell. These were not good times. Along with Lot and Pompeii Smith had completed in 1940 another painting, Drought, which also showed up in the 1993 Surrealism show. It was an Australian landscape executed perhaps under the influence of Eliot's Waste Land. While the Nazis were destroying art by fire in Germany, meantime, the philistines and phoneys in Australia always looked elsewhere when they heard the word 'art'. The Sydney scene was a waste land as well. All the same, Moore's book made clear to Smith his own ignorance. He threw himself into educational activities, seeking to substitute the spoken word for the written in its absence. He was reading Marx and Toynbee, visiting Melbourne. So he wrote his book in the shadow of Guernica. He had 27
28
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
come to the conclusion that if Marx wrote about historical and dialectical materialism, as radical wisdom received them, then the history bit was worth pursuing. Dialectics worked more as a cruel joke than as an imperative to social change. At best, dialectics meant process; at worst, mumbo-jumbo, a magic wand. And though European art had often been viewed in Australia in the form of paler reproductions, the local works were there to be discovered. Smith made a commitment to the archive, and put to good use its capacity to compel thought anew. He was an historian, after all. The leap from Moore's book to Smith's own is extraordinary. For Smith's achievement in Place, Taste and Tradition was not only to establish some clearer lines of narrative, but also to frame his concerns in such a way as make them deeply provocative in an intellectual sense. Reading through these pages we already detect a number of the vital curiosities which were to inform his later work, especially European Vision and the South Pacific. Place, Taste and Tradition is already an
evocative enough title, the kind that fifty years later still (or more) gets you wondering, thinking about associations and distinctions: place, space, culture, context, taste, high, low, forms of judgement, tradition, frame, grids, ways of seeing. Smith conceived the title after reading a book by Samuel Alexander, Space, Time and Deity. The words were mimetic, thematic, inviting. The opening lines of Smith's text already indicated its purpose beyond the narrative: 'This study is concerned with the relation between the course art has taken in Australia and the concurrent European tendencies from which art here has drawn so largely. Australian art comment has presented a distorted view of Australian art by paying little attention to this relation'. 2 Already, in opening the optic Smith was raising questions about the nature of colonial and postcolonial art reception, the image of empire and the theme of cultural exchange so central to this work. The issue of determining the 'cultural cringe' was already in the air, but it was not only a question of the extent to which, say, painting in Australia was derivative or not. Smith was suggesting, rather, a different way of thinking these relations. Smith saw it as his business to historically reveal tendencies, to mark out contours in time which would render the structure of the present intellectual and aesthetic landscape intelligible; the challenge was as much to do with how we think as it was with what we think. To do this, he would discuss Johann
ENCOUNTERING
AUSTRALIAN
PAINTING
Winckelmann's Germanic Hellenism in the same breath as he would Brian Fitzpatrick's study of British imperialism in Australia. So what was the story of Australian art per Smith? The white invaders of Australia brought much with them in material form, but they also brought a cultural repertoire; they brought with them not only a desire to dominate or a curiosity about the great south land, but they also brought something stronger, a homesickness for the old. They carried a nostalgia of vision; the human habit of recycling wisdoms from previous epochs was accentuated by the contact between new world cultures and the old. Smith's concern was, therefore, directly with the reception of art, and not only with the artifacts themselves. Smith was, in effect, bringing the eyes of a stranger, an outsider, to the inside. All phenomena, especially those we think we know, can be treated as though they are exotic. Why should Australian painting often resemble the English, and representations of Australia look like England? The answer was to be found in the fact that the viewers and painters brought certain habits of vision with them, which endowed natural scenes with the forms and residues of memory, of the other: 'This is what Paul Nash meant by saying that "nature is what the artists of the day before yesterday made people believe in"'. 3 This is to say that the early colonists saw Australian landscape with English eyes, that they endowed that landscape with the formal qualities of landscapes to which they were aesthetically accustomed in England. To put it in a blunter vernacular, the colonists could not see what was in front of their faces, so much did they live in the life of the mind; but nobody can, or does, this was a common problem, not a unique one. Vision Smith quoted Wolfflin - vision then had a history.4 The component parts of this local history included some significant themes, like melancholy, romanticism, primitivism. More generally, Smith's guiding curiosity was in the sense that cultural forms like art would always be hybrid, but even more emphatically in the framework of imperialism. Tradition was not flat; it rested on assimilation, on processes of unequal but significant cultural exchange between metropolis and periphery. As Toynbee had indicated, historically cultures are given to recycling, and the outcome is never entirely predictable. A purely Australian modern art was therefore impossible; even as a reactionary strategy of self-defence, it could only make sense as an archaistic revivalism staking itself against
29
30
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
the dominant historical movement. Not that there was a shortage of sources for those who might choose to argue for the antipodean as a peculiarity of essence, of primordial time and space. Smith uses Marcus Clarke as an epigram for his opening chapter on the beginnings of colonial art: 'In Australia alone is to be found the grotesque, the weird, the strange scribblings of Nature learning how to write'.5 European romanticism had sought the Gothic and the sublime in northern nature; only the southern experience suggested better. The flora, the fauna, the landscape, the natives were all constructed by Europeans as exotic if repugnant and grotesque. So the first chapter of Place, Taste and Tradition opens already with more questions, puzzles about intellectual framing and perception, reception. Smith begins with a discussion, not of gum-trees and paint, but of scientific recording and romanticism. Like Freud, he presumes that the story he is tracing will not carry its truth openly; we will always need to be prepared to look elsewhere to explain what is before us, in this case to the global experience of imperialism. Art, as Smith argues, is often attendant upon religion; in Australia it came together with science. Cook's expedition brought much else, but it also brought Banks and botany. Over a thousand surviving works of botanical and zoological value were produced before 1800, a veritable catalogue of ways of seeing, as well as objects seen. The black swan, the kangaroo were nothing if not exotic. As Smith observes, the arrival of the first kangaroo in England created a furore. All that was categorically solid melted into air; for unlike faked mermaids this was live, it moved, was publicly displayed, admittance one shilling per person. Thus the curious, the strange, the odd, the mysterious helped to build associations that were growing around the word 'romantic'.6 Anticipating Edward Said's work on Orientalism by thirty years, Smith linked this enthusiasm for the creation of exotica with the cult of Chinoiserie. The semantic connection was important, for however complex it was, the distinction between China and Chinoiserie was of the same order as the difference between the primitive and the cult of primitivism. The historical connection is also powerful, for romanticism was fed at the source by commercial imperialism.7 The earliest white representations of Aborigines were, therefore, less an accurate statement about experience than an illustration of the hypothetical 'noble savage' associated with Rousseau. Early topo-
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
graphical paintings were also presented with a romantic aura. But this could not last, for art is never independent of its place, and it takes on the features of its locality as surely as it takes on the features of its time: Through the broken image of the English tradition the contours of a new continent were visible, and those contours were to bend and distort the European vision to the ways of a new country, with a different environment and other ways of living'.8 More than Edward Said let on or his followers cared to acknowledge, the subordinate partner or place in the relationship of domination would also affect the superior culture. Europe would never be the same after its contacts with the antipodes, even if Europeans themselves would be slow to concede this formally. Into the nineteenth century, however, the balance was still predominantly English. Artists searched for and concocted the picturesque, the sublime, the romantic, even as they complained that the landscape was too alien, unlike home; they endeavoured to transform Australian landscape into English, shifting from topography to country houses in the process. Even some of the best early painting, like that of Conrad Martens, suffered from, or was characterised by, a need for Anglicising nostalgia.9 A discernible shift came mid-century, together with changes in political economy: gold. Australian art now began more obviously to assume national characteristics, as in the photographic tableau-work by S. T. Gill. But there was still not, indeed for Smith there never could be, an essentially Australian art. As he wrote: There can be no such thing as an Australian art-form. Lines and colours of themselves have no nationality. It is only after certain combinations of form and colour have become associated with a race or nation over a long period that structural art-forms may be said to have a racial or national quality.10
What is a nation, in any case, or a culture? Among other things, these are ex post facto categories which effectively take on lives of their own; but when we call them to analysis, all we see is the sum of their collected parts, and pasts. Fin-de-siecle fears may have been less heightened in Australia than in Europe, if only because the scars of the Industrial Revolution were yet barely perceptible. Mechanics' Institutes prospered,
31
32
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
encouraging amateur art and criticism, and the emerging middle class was keen to develop art as evangelism, both as a moral code of human development and as a commercial advocate. By Federation, of course, art became connected to nation-building, though again this is probably something which is more apparent in retrospect. Perhaps more significant for the self-consciousness of Australian art in the making was the experience of impressionism. The result, in Smith's estimation, was clear. For its first century of white civilisation, Australian art had been English. Then it took a French turn, where the visual was now valued over the conceptual. Such was the achievement of the Heidelberg School, though as Smith noted, painters like Tom Roberts were basically realist in manner.11 The Heidelberg painters were not, however, overtly nationalist; they may have viewed themselves as contributing to, or even crystallising, a culture, but they did not see their work as nation-building. The French were not the only influence, nor by virtue of Smith's logic could they have been; for Smith's work is always governed by the sensibility that the categories come after the event and that they - we use them unfairly to screen out manifold diversities. Modern art is always mixed, it is never like Johann Gottfried von Herder's concept of a unified and unifying language, it is always plural. Alongside the impressionism of Phillips Fox there was the mysticism of Sydney Long and the more widely Anglo enthusiasm for Ruskin and the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, Hans Heysen and Charles Conder and the indulgent fleshy decadence of Norman Lindsay; and these were those who were recognised, for there were always parallel paths without written history or critical recognition. With Lindsay and Bernard O'Dowd national mythmaking came closer; the image of a healthy national vision became more formally aligned with the pastoral and primitive, with images of nature set against images of the evils of cities. As in America, but even more powerfully, romanticism outshone modernism as the new world experiences grasped for the symbols of the old, green, pleasant land which still dominated memory. In Australia archaism could reach directly for Aboriginal culture and idealise it at the very same time as extermination was taking place. In 1944 Smith was to anticipate contemporary argument and allusion to the possibility that white Australian civilisation has an
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
empty heart.12 We moderns live on the edges of the continent, looking out and away from the red centre and heart, missing something peculiarly Aboriginal about our identity, therefore feeling hopelessly homeless - or so the story goes. It is as though the culture of domination has to elevate the symbolic image of the other at the same time as it tramples its bearers or their descendants, as though whites are compelled perversely to tell the truth while we live a lie. But the representation of the Aboriginal as primitive is a very particular kind of projection more than it is a 'truth'. As Smith argues, there are few other instances so powerful of the way in which an occupying culture projects archaism into the centre of its nationalism. The Americans may have done it in film, but their art forms became more conventionally modernist. Smith compares the Australian experience to the Mexican, where imperialism of the deed, despite enslavement, brought some more significant kind of cultural exchange: The colonization of Mexico, in spite of the enslavement of the native Mexicans, during the beginnings of settlement, is an example of the development of a vigorous living art with its own distinctive qualities from the blending of two ethnic types. But such a growth results only from a two-way development, the mutual contribution of two living traditions that eventually intermingle as they continue their adaptation to a common environment.13 This was not an argument for cultural assimilation, but rather for what Smith was later to identify as cultural convergence. In the Mexican case its achievement was already evident in the 1930s, say, in the work of Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera. Moments of exchange occurred in Australia, between say Heysen and Albert Namatjira, or in Margaret Preston's borrowings of Aboriginal motifs, as Smith indicated; the problem was that extermination first had to stop for any kind of progress to occur. Thus Smith spoke harshly of cultural nationalism, the Jindyworobaks movement with the phoney naturalism of its claims to return to pure singular culture - as though the French or English influences on Australian painting could be reversed by fiat.14 The Jindyworobaks were in pursuit of something completely elusive, something like the image of 'authenticity', a free Australia without any
33
34
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
outside influences. As Smith replied, no cultural development had ever followed this path, for culture itself was a process of absorption and adaptation, of change rather than eternity. The idea of a pure or original 'national culture', by comparison, had awful resonances in the setting of the Second World War. And in Australia, in any case, the Americans had arrived anyway; and they were not only woman-stealers, the butt of Albert Tucker's symbolic wrath in Victory Girls, they were also part of the audience for Place, Taste and Tradition. Smith had spent time with his copy of Jack Lindsay's Short History of Culture, spent time working with Toynbee and Marx, and had come to the conclusion that we lived always in change, even if not with change of our own choosing. Change, traffic, contact, difference were the kinds of processes that made up culture. The purists and nativists were reactionary, for they sought to identify national art and national character with landscape. But culture, as we know it, springs not from the soil or even from beautiful if paradoxical mirage-representations of it. Culture, like identity is human and therefore transient. Authenticity is a redundant, indeed a dangerous notion. ART, WAR AND MODERNISM Then was war. Modernism preceded the Great War, but it was the experience of war which manoeuvred its reception. Smith writes as though the two world wars make modernity completely different, and dominate the twentieth century ever after. I think he is right. As Pitirim Sorokin observed, the twentieth century achieved more mass slaughter than any other even in its first quarter. Smith read Sorokin, and read about him in Rader's No Compromise. Sorokin, I think, was also right. Looking back on the twentieth century the significance of the wars becomes even more powerful; as Trotsky liked to observe, ours was the epoch of wars and revolutions. The rise of communism and fascism only make sense in the context of the Great War; those regimes then set into motion the processes which generate the Second World War, establish the postwar division of the globe, and then reconstruction in the west alongside postcolonialism elsewhere. With the fall of the Berlin Wall, the unification of Germany and the collapse of the old Soviet Union into the nineties we are now only just able to glimpse the idea of a world after the Great War, and in this sense after modernism.
E N C O U N T E R I N G
AUSTRALIAN
PAINTING
Modernism, in the form of postimpressionism, emerged as a movement in Anglo art, according to received wisdom, in 1910 with the controversial Impressionist Exhibition organised by Roger Fry in London. Modernism was also, among other things a feminist movement, so it comes as no surprise to us today that the most striking of early Australian women artists appear at this time. Grace Cossington Smith, Thea Proctor, Margaret Preston, Aletta Lewis, Grace Crowley this was work which we would view as having a strong European feel, even as (in the case of, say, Preston and Lewis) connections into the Aboriginal and Pacific are reminiscent of Gauguin as well as Picasso. By this point Smith's narrative had almost caught up to his own direct experience. For it was around 1936 that surrealism, already in its old age on the continent, arrived in the antipodes. Surrealism itself was also caught up with the war. The Italian Futurists, such as Filippo Marinetti had, like German writers such as Ernst Jiinger, sung in praise of war; war, it appeared, was good for you, at least from a distance. The apocalyptic experience of the trenches somehow failed to live up to these exuberant hopes. War, apocalypse, decadence and decay became more powerful symbols than the progress of man and machine which Futurists and fascists alike had banked on. Australia was only notionally on the edge of all this; the tyranny of distance was lost at Gallipoli. Into the thirties fascism in Europe was closer than it may at first have seemed. Surrealism in the strong sense depicted the apocalypse, but also the other, the inner, the dreamworlds which at least momentarily aligned Trotsky with Freud and Breton with Marx. In some hands this ended in the playful silliness of Dali, already hinted at by Duchamp; in others, including those of James Gleeson, the message was more frightening and sombre, about the wolf in man, the sewers below the cities of the mind. Dropping its prefix, surrealism also led in moments to realism. Now realism was to become something of an encumbrance to Bernard Smith, who is often identified with it. This would not be so bad, perhaps, if it were self-evident what realism means. Given the extremes of heat generated by arguments around issues of realism, figuration and abstraction, it is unfortunate that we cannot simply define realism as the other of surrealism rather than the other way around. For surrealism also obviously addresses the real, in different ways; dreams, for example, we encounter as real and yet somehow as less than
35
36
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
immediately real. The core values of Smith's commitment to realism are social and historical as much as they are aesthetic. Surrealism, on this account, looks perhaps too much to the inner, to the private mind, whereas what makes us truly human is the fact that we share space and time, place and tradition with others. We are, for Smith as for Marx, pre-eminently social individuals who create as well as suffer, who are imprinted as well as imprinting, who make and make what we call craft as well as art. Realism might, then, for Smith, be defined with reference to context or history. It should not be confused with naturalism, which in any case is artificial, a way of seeing which seeks to elude its own existence. Smith's attraction is to the kind of realism we encounter in painters like Breughel, Daumier, Courbet and Goya.15 In Australia, at the moment in which Smith was writing, the interesting painters seemed to be political radicals with social commitment. After William Dobell and Russell Drysdale, there were Noel Counihan, Victor O'Connor, Josl Bergner. As Smith put it when writing in 1944, these were postmodernist painters.16 The use of terminology followed Toynbee but had a logic of its own; just as postimpressionism followed impressionism, so could it be expected that postmodernism would follow modernism, for the whole point about modernity was transience; what was called modern, experienced as modern in one epoch, would look passe in another. Modernism by definition would, therefore, be obliged to be obsolete, while the modern impulse would continue. What was modern, or at least contemporary for Smith and for the readers of Place, Taste and Tradition, was the Second World War. Modernism by the 1940s could be viewed as tried, or tired, though fascism could also be encountered as antimodern, even though it was not only that. Fascism and communism were both highly stylised in romantic and reactionary terms, and yet were also movements which were staking a claim to an alternative modernity. In this context Smith's first history of Australian painting had achieved a great deal. Viewed most minimally, Place, Taste and Tradition had forced the issue of recognising Australian art by establishing something of its narrative. The point of radical novelty in Smith's text was that it had also problematised its object. It had achieved this by placing the nature of white Australian culture and history under question: Who were we? where had we come from? where were we going? Located in the
E N C O U N T E R I N G
AUSTRALIAN
PAINTING
37
antipodes half-way through the century we could and ought to ask the same questions as had Gauguin, but we would not come up with the same answers. White Australian civilisation was obviously introduced to the south land so it already involved, at the very least, a dialogue of conflict and tension between space and vision, place and imagination or memory. Further, it involved sequences of European influence, from English botany to landscape to French impressionism, glimmerings of German expressionism, cosmopolitan surrealism, realism, vorticism. A new world experience, it grasped for archaic roots, looking for soul in all the wrong places. And it had been dragged through the valley of the shadow of death now in the devastating European wars and the Asian-Pacific theatre as well. All this makes it apparent that there was a social theory emerging out of Smith's history, even if it was only to be elucidated more fully later, especially in European Vision and the South Pacific. Perhaps it was the case that Smith's thinking, already so powerfully suggestive, needed time to settle and stretch, and the benefit of a different location more fully to fill out. Perhaps the situation was simpler, for Smith's overwhelming concern was with the politics of the moment. Much to the displeasure of his various well-heeled reviewers, he ended Place, Taste and Tradition with politics, so much so that Sid Ure Smith prevailed upon him to leave some of it out. Bernard Smith's claim was obvious. There was a war going on, and art was part of this whether we chose to like it or not. He recoiled from the bizarre traditionalism of the salon-types, for whom the world could collapse about our ears if only art could be protected, a kind of Peter Pan fantasy of eternal youth.17 Consistent with his own intellectual culture, Smith was not simply warning of the apocalypse. Notwithstanding the paternalistic endeavours of its self-appointed minders, art would continue to change. Already the once-radical innovations of Cezanne and Picasso had been passed on; it was this sense of movement which led Smith to anticipate postmodernism. Smith now anticipated a resurgence of realism, which had already presented itself in the work of Henry Moore, Eric Gill, Rivera and Jose Clemente Orozco, locally, Counihan and his mates. Smith anticipated, and hoped for, a flight from abstraction. Realism was aligned with radicalism in politics and so Smith broke aesthetic etiquette by closing his book in the discussion of politics. Bear in mind that the barbarism of the Second World War was only now becoming fully evident, into its
38
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
closing phase. Smith was writing at the same moment as Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno penned their elegaic text, Dialectic of Enlightenment. The conclusions were similar; Smith, for his part, wrote that we 'have been witnesses to the calculated destruction of Western European culture'.18 The difference between the view of Horkheimer and Adorno and his own position was significant. The German philosophers implied powerfully that decline was final and irreversible; we could continue to inhabit the rubble, but the idea of progress was over. Smith's dismay at the extent of destruction was abundant; fascism had been an experience without precedent (communism, behind that, even more so). Fascism was also, however, a phenomenon which drew upon romanticism and archaism, seeking to hold back modernity by traditional means at the very same time as it relied on modern means of destruction and propaganda to defend reactionary goals of iron and blood. As far as Smith could see, part of the problem was to be located in modernism's own necessary contradictions - for modernism was not ever fully modern, nor could it be. Modernism remained at heart deeply romantic; as recent works by Christopher Lasch and John Carey remind us, heroism and the cult of the creative individual remain powerfully nostalgic presences in modernity.19 As Smith put it: Modernism, here, as elsewhere, although famous for its many palace revolutions in the sphere of technique took over from the nineteenth century the tenets of aestheticism - the unique nature of the artist's personality, the 'prophetic role' of the artist, the philistinism of the multitude - completely without question.20
For Smith's generation, the difference between then and now was expressed by the pathetic distance between the stance of Julian Bell and that of his father. Clive Bell, Bloomsbury connoisseur, doyen of English aesthetes, wrote that the 'one good thing society can do for the artist is leave him alone'. Julian Bell, himself a writer and poet, died fighting with the International Brigade in Spain.21 Luckily for us, today, the choices are less immediately brutal; sometimes, today, they are not clear at all. Perhaps there are none that really matter, and if today everything goes then nothing really matters - the denizens of postmodernity feel at home with the wisdom of Karl Kraus. Smith's
ENCOUNTERING
AUSTRALIAN
PAINTING
39
sensibilities in closing Place, Taste and Tradition remained closer to the crisis, and to Jack Lindsay's own conclusion in his Short History of Culture, that to make no decision was the worst decision of all.22 Smith ended his first book in sympathy with Rader's advocacy of a potentially democratic art, which together with Rader he associated with Ruskin, Morris, Wright, Gropius and Mumford.23 Sid Ure Smith advised Bernard Smith, and the two were friends; but Sid's publishing sense indicated against the inclusion of Bernard's further conclusions. Perhaps it was just as well; already the reviewers were complaining about the intrusion of politics into the placid theatre of art. The difficult section was expelled from Place, Taste and Tradition and ended up in Communist Review for June and July 1946. It appeared under the title The fascist mentality in Australian art and criticism'. Perhaps it was simply the problem that you could criticise German fascists but not the local currents. In any case, the whole business was more than a little risky, so that Smith wrote here under an apt pseudonym, 'Goya'. Goya again recommended Rader's book to his readers. He proceeded to associate fascism generically with the cultic praise of rural life, irrationalism, the paternalism of race-breeding, and antimodernism. He probed the inner connection within fascist thinking between antisemitism and antibolshevism. Fascism's praise of the imagined purer past went together with and fuelled its antimodernism.24 Modernists we remained, however, for better and for worse. Already into the 1940s, then, Bernard Smith had managed to achieved a modicum of recognition for art history and a degree of notoriety for introducing into it the stain of politics. As dutiful young Bennie had finally lapsed from his Salvation Army classes, 'never absent never late', so he finally escaped the Education Department. Without a complete BA degree, he managed to secure a scholarship from the British Council to work on the project that became European Vision. The rupture, leaving Australia, also helped to clarify what it meant to be antipodean from the other end. He left behind the Communist Party. Anthony Blunt at the Courtauld Institute indulged Smith neither as aesthete nor as a fellow communist; he effectively dismissed Smith, sniffily, from whence the local lad travelled further, took up with Charles Mitchell and Rudolf Wittkower at the Warburg. In 1949 Smith addressed the British Council on the topic 'Australian Art and the English Tradition'. It was a delicate brief, educating one's
40
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
superiors, but it was handled with clarity and tact, irony abundant. As Smith now put it: It is difficult, of course, to talk about English qualities in Australian art without starting a quarrel... How often have we read accounts of Australian art that might be summarised thus: for a hundred years after Australia was settled [they] painted in an English manner, and they couldn't - poor devils - paint gum trees, and this art was very bad, then along came a man called Streeton who could paint the sky and draw gum trees. After that Art was Australian and it was good .. .25 Good or bad, better or worse, these were the dominant terms of reference and judgement - English culture and Australian landscape were folded together, a kind of maturation process emerging in which Australian painting together with national culture came of age. Smith's concern, by comparison, was to multiply the factors and to set their interaction into motion. As he wrote for the British Council: I think we can say that there are three primary elements in Australian art. The English influence, the French influence, and the influence of our own environment. I would not like to say which of them is the most important. I do not think we can do without any of them.26 The real twist in Smith's thinking was that he was also thinking about thinking. So, in a BBC talk for the Third Program on 'The Australian landscape' broadcast on 17 November 1950, he made it clear that this was not some kind of cookshop or cultural alchemy which simply mixed different components of national cultures. Rather, the imagination had a primary significance in these processes. Australian landscape, Smith argued, began as a dream, and this not only in the Aboriginal sense; for the image of the 'antipodes' also had a dream past in the European imagination. The antipodes was all that the English made it out to be: the other, the subordinate, the bodily and vulgar; below the equator was below the belt. Europe was like the proverbial satyr, mind in England or on the continent, body and bodily functions elsewhere. It was the evil of the underground, but at the same time it was an imaginary fantasia, cornucopia, a land of wonders, monsters, the great Southern Land of abundance in the imagination of the Spanish explorers. Plainly Smith's thinking for European Vision and the
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
41
South Pacific had spread into and out of his work on Australian art. In the BBC broadcast he referred to colonial painters like Thomas Watling, with their capacity to combine the visual and the mythical; and he spoke about Marcus Clarke's reaction to our 'melancholy landscape', a theme already posited in Place, Taste and Tradition and subsequently amplified in Australian Painting. On this occasion Smith worked the point that this melancholy is ours, not its; we projected it upon a vista which refused to be properly English. Darwin, on his visit was to see it better, Smith claimed; Louis Buvelot was the first more adequately to capture it in paint.27 Yet Smith's concern with Australian painting was never just symbolic or limited to internal matters of interpretation. He was a Marxist; he was interested in history, context, power, money, classes and institutions. Art was also mediated through this social fabric, even after fascism had collapsed and perhaps loosened again the claims of period demand between the wars to connect up politics and art. In the first edition of Place, Taste and Tradition Smith had come closer, perhaps, to the idea that because it was decadent, modernity corrupted art, for in a note to the second edition he added the following afterthought: I no longer believe that a general decline in taste may be attributed to the effects of industrialism, rather the reverse. Industrialism made good art available to a far larger number of people than hitherto. On the other hand industrialism does seem to have brought with it a slow but steady decline in the quality of those fine arts that are based, as painting and sculpture still largely are, upon handcraft.28 The contradiction was clear, and it was us. Modernity cut both ways; yet Smith still adhered to that partial wisdom and insight of Marxism and the English romantics, for which decline was never just circular or recurring. There were also ways in which modernity did it worse than hitherto preceding civilisations. There remained ways in which it was meaningful to say that Australian art had lost opportunities. Thus Smith wrote in a scanner, 'Fifty years of Australian painting' for Meanjin that: the great promise that gleamed for a moment in the late eighties and early nineties [of the nineteenth century] was not realised; within a decade the painters of the Australian school were mainly concerned
42
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
with gaining recognition at the Royal Academy and the Paris Salon, more than in producing original art.29 This was the same kind of irritation as that which Smith had turned against Whitlam's art policies. Art was so much governed by markets that it was hard to see how either aesthetic judgement or the craft movement could really survive. Bernard Smith's concerns in this regard were to parallel those of a critic like Pierre Bourdieu, whose work would become known in Australia only thirty years later. Bourdieu's project rests on the sense that language, the vision and power are all implicated together; this means, for example, that academic authority is governed by a star system which is deeply implicated with the media, and that art is necessarily formed by its institutions - such as galleries - and the social institutions of class and the authorised culture which, in turn, form them.30 The cluster of concerns connecting vision and experience with the antipodes and the world system were thus one major global axis for Smith; the local specificities of power and authority in the art market were another. If language, vision and power were actually always mixed up, it nevertheless remained the case that art should have criteria of its own, different to those of the market. Aesthetic transactions did not belong in the temples or on the stock exchange; but with ongoing commodification, of course, they did. Since Ruskin, at least, radicals and critics had fumed about the meaning of beauty and its value on the market; in the midst of the unfolding postwar boom these kinds of distinctions increasingly failed to make sufficient sense. Economic value came also to swallow up matters of aesthetic value. As Smith spat at the process, in his speech opening an exhibition by Charles Doutney in Sydney in the 1950s: in this connection - while I do not wish to sound anything that savours of a patronising note, I think I should point out a danger that the artist who becomes well known is likely to be exposed to - particularly in this city, where again and again, it has been possible to witness how quickly an artist's work deteriorates after a certain measure of success .. .3I Smith's own work and life have been remarkable not least in this regard: that he has resisted the corruption of power, and that his own
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
43
work has been consistently insightful and provocative. He has neither sold out, nor have his ideas evaporated with the passing of time, even if they have sometimes been passed over. Indeed, his whole project is animated by a consistent ethical sensibility coupled to a remarkable ongoing curiosity about the world as it transforms before us, we with it. AUSTRALIAN PAINTING Place, Taste and Tradition had served its purposes. Smith had established some new lines of historical thinking about Australian culture and had argued for a politics of art. He had also identified some ongoing puzzles about the antipodes and questions of vision. In 1962 he published his second history, Australian Painting; the version we know today is supplemented by three additional chapters on Australian painting since 1970 written by his student, Terry Smith.32 Perhaps Bernard had to leave Sydney to escape from all the other Smiths. The focus was thus expanded at the same time as it was narrowed from 'art' to 'painting'. Australian Painting is a book of a different moment. Its setting lacks the political urgency of Place, Taste and Tradition. Its prose is more relaxed and more detailed, its paragraphing lengthy and more leisured, its personnel fuller and more inclusive. Australian Painting opens with material that could just as well have appeared in European Vision and the South Pacific - Cook and Banks, the 'grand tour' of the globe, imperialism and science, representation in art. Smith's first issue, of course, is the image of the 'noble savage' and the Anglicisation of landscape. The theme of the antipodes and its representation was increasingly prominent. How did the English, in particular, deal with the apparent inversion of the proper order of things, with freak forms like the black swan - hitherto imagined to be a logical fantasy in classical philosophy - and even stranger, the kangaroo and platypus? In his connection Smith also discussed a theme which increasingly came to be associated with the work of Michel Foucault in the seventies in its enthusiastic Englishlanguage reception. Only for so long could oddities like the platypus be treated as anomalies, as violations of the order of things. After the shock, the new freaks had also to be classified, assimilated not only into conventional patterns of distinction but also located in the systems and family trees of species and things. In Smith's analysis, here and elsewhere, practices such as botany were to become especially fascinating,
44
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
as they worked across a whole series of axes, aesthetics and science, nature and Enlightenment, similarity and difference. Smith was writing Australian Painting before the English-language celebration of structuralism or the arrival of Marxist-structuralism; the latter, in the hands of a thinker like Louis Althusser, he found arid and unedifying. Yet the curiosities which animate his work here are nevertheless in some ways like those of a thinker such as Claude Levi-Strauss, questions of how different groups of humans in different locations of place and time categorise and classify other inhabitants of their worlds. The predictable result in early Australian art was the generation of hybrid forms, so that, for example, early engravings representing Australian scenery often resemble an English park, though tropical plants such as palm and the grass tree are usually added for local flavour.33 The difference, in Smith's eye, was that this kind of phenomenon was taken to be significant, symbolic of elementary forms of cultural exchange rather than of simple cultural arrogance and distortion. The process of representation would shift: the subject matter of Australian painting would become what we would call more recognisably Australian, and at some point on the long scales of civilisational time the subordinate culture would also begin to affect the superior culture of the haughty metropolis. Human nature, in other words, might or might not be more or less fixed, but culture was always shifting, never was essential or final. The conquerors of world history inevitably took on the effects of their new world settings; they all went 'native', but in ways so subtle and various as often to be almost imperceptible. The subsequent paths of development sketched out in Australian Painting do not diverge notably from those indicated in Place, Taste and Tradition. At the same time they tend to be more powerfully thematised so that, for example, the second chapter has more to say about the themes of pastoral and the 'frontier'. When landscape shifts to figurative painting the 'ignoble savage' replaces the noble savage, a symbolic concurrence which runs together with the extermination of Aborigines. Now there appears the figure of the noble frontiersman to take the savage's place, as indeed he was actually doing. Similarly Smith extends his discussion on the theme of melancholy. The representation of the noble savage had inhabited a romantic wilderness; the noble frontiersman entered into a land of sweet pastures.34 As the
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
invaders transformed the land, so they imagined the landscape anew. Institutional transformations were also underway; until the end of the 1820s colonial art in Australia was produced almost entirely for an English audience, but now a small local market was confirmed. Portraiture and country-house painting were expanded by peripatetic artists such as Conrad Martens. But the painters of the 1860s and 1870s found Australia no paradise of sunshine and adventure; to their eyes, it was a weird, melancholy land, and as Smith observes, this sensibility came to characterise both art and writing. What was the meaning of this melancholy? Given Smith's sense that misrecognition resulted not from error or simple arrogance but from the interreaction between ways of thinking and location, he now chose to probe melancholy as a similarly mixed phenomenon. As Smith argued, it was not to be presumed (as it typically was) that the expression of melancholy about the alien nature of the land was purely external. Returning to Marcus Clarke, Smith argued that the sense of melancholy in art was not only negative or superior; the best artists tended, rather, to identify with the weirdness and melancholy which they found in or projected upon the landscape. Clarke had indeed written of the sense that Australia was grotesque, weird, had invoked the imagery of primitivism, musing on what he called the strange scribblings of nature learning how to write. But alongside trees without shade, flowers without perfume, flightless birds and upright animals there was a sense of wonder and beauty in the place itself; only it possessed a different hieroglyphics, as Clarke put it, so you needed also to see what was in front of your face as well as use whatever was between your ears.35 Habits of study abroad brought new eyes again to Australian vision, implicating Australian painting more extensively into English and French practices and institutions. Thus Heidelberg, and Sydney Long and Norman Lindsay follow a similar trajectory into the new century, which Smith had portrayed from closer proximity in Place, Taste and Tradition. But what can be said about the painting of the 1950s? It is not as though these times were any less controversial than those before. Indeed, in Melbourne at least they led up to the display of the Antipodeans and the publication of The Antipodean Manifesto in 1959. The work of John Brack in Melbourne, Ian Fairweather in Brisbane, the religious painting of Justin O'Brien indicated flourishings of various different kinds. The 1950s were, nevertheless, received or remembered
45
46
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
as the period of high cultural cringe, in part because, as Smith complained, there was a distorted process whereby the British applauded those who like Barry Humphries and then Robert Hughes told them what they wanted to hear: sorry (or not), no high culture downunder. As the 1950s drifted into the 1960s the results of postwar developments emerged more clearly. Smith opened his chapter on the 1960s with an epigraph from his old friend and colleague at the University of Melbourne, Franz Philipp, an Austrian expatriate: 'There are two types of cultural provincialism: unawareness and overawareness of the "centre", a hedged complacent identity and a loss of it in a desperate chase to keep up with the Joneses of the international art scene'.36 Smith's sense of the 1960s agrees with the one more widely held: that there was some sort of arrival after the postwar boom, an increased sense of contestation and heightened senses of conflict as well as consolidation. Smith's argument began by stepping back, in order to restate his sense that modern Australian civilisation had been built upon the process of cultural traffic. Cultural flows between centre and periphery had always been mutual as well as unequal. White Australian culture was never simply derivative because no culture could be; cultures were not unpacked like tins of Andy Warhol's soup from British or American boxes, for even their uses and applications would vary with place and time, habit and initiative. In other words, Smith's sense of culture is always anthropological or civilisational; inasmuch as he avoids identifying art exclusively with high art, he also eschews the circumstantial elitism which privileges metropolitan centres over peripheries and therefore, mistakenly, constructs art as some select liquid or potion which never flows uphill. In his immediate setting, Smith was jousting inter alia with Robert Hughes, the brilliant young critic in a hurry from Sydney. Hughes, like other expatriates of that period, had argued publicly that to stay in Australia was to die for want of air, or proper cultural fluid. Smith, by contrast, had always rejected the idea that Australian art was foreshortened by the tyranny of distance or the fact of isolation. In fact, we were never isolated, but to the contrary all too often struck up poses towards the centres that were nothing short of obsequious. Distance might cause a time-lag, but it did not itself induce dependency. Provincialism was a problem, but like melancholy it was less than completely straightforward. In sympathy with his cue from Franz
E N C O U N T E R I N G
AUSTRALIAN
PAINTING
Philipp, Smith argued that provincialism cut both ways. Provincialism could either fawn over the alleged achievements of the centres, or else it could deny them and become chauvinistic and know-nothing about the outside, stupidly praising only the local. To remember Karl Kraus, now in a different setting, this was not exactly a terrific choice. It could be aligned, for sake of elucidation, with the respective claims of high art and populism; the former sought to look out, never in, the latter the opposite, celebrating the vernacular for its own sake. This is not to say that provincialism was not a problem, only that it was not a simple or singular one. Into the 1960s, the indications were that Australia's provincial situation was being transformed. Smith was anticipating processes of change later to be associated with ideas like modernisation and globalisation. Culture was becoming more mixed, and cultural traffic increasing. By 1970, as he put it, there were indications that Australia was beginning to create nascent metropolitan situations of its own in its main capital cities.37 Increasingly this would mean that Australia would be regarded, however opaquely, as a cultural producer and not only as a cultural consumer of gleaming cosmopolitan products from New York or Hollywood. According to Smith the sense of emerging metropolitanism was caught up with three main factors: first, the migration policy inaugurated at the end of the Second World War had begun the creation, slowly at first and now at an increasing rate, of cosmopolitan communities in the main capital cities of the country; second, improved travel facilities, especially by air, increased the movement of artists, critics and information between countries; and third, the emergence of provincial communities and popular tastes within the country that looked to the metropolis for standards and styles, on the one hand, but also made use of art, to a greater extent than the metropolis, as a means towards regional and national self-identification.38 It was a long way from Murraguldrie, a few books in the mail with black and white reproductions and sketching in the foothills while reading Ruskin. Yet Smith's response to what we now call globalisation, modernisation, or urbanisation was as sensibly mixed and circumspect as ever; he did not expect these processes to result in an homogenised global culture, even though that was part of the story; he expected the local to persist, take its own path, transform but not disappear. The hegemony of abstract art in international guise remained a concern for Smith, for he understood that
47
48
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
abstract internationalism in art, as in politics, usually meant some particularism smuggled in surreptitiously. Abstract expressionist painting into the 1960s contained an American heart, the pulse of Manhattan in particular, just as the abstract political internationalism of mid-century communism had a Soviet core. Having taken in Marx's German Ideology in the forties, Bernard Smith was suspicious of the particularity concealed in claims to universality even as he remained committed to other universals, like freedom and dignity. The 1960s in Australia was a period of fresh contestation when it came to matters of national identity. Within the Marxist traditions the Communist Party of Australia had begun to shift from its high national populism in the 1940s towards its shortlived Eurocommunist or social democratic phase. Trotskyism revived around the struggles against the Vietnam War, and Maoism did its best to develop a new populism, setting the local icon of Blinky Bill against the rapacious symbols of Hollywood's cultural imperialism (like Mickey Mouse OA). Smith's analysis in Australian Painting gave the sense that while the artistic sphere and those of radical politics were certainly not identical, some similarities were emerging through such differences. These kinds of differences were never neat, for again we organise them mentally in retrospect with the use of categories which imply logical division at the expense of historical crossover. Nevertheless, those differences, inward and outward in orientation, towards the red heart or towards Europe, are real. As Smith observed the art scene in the 1960s he saw the difference as between one group dedicated to experiment, internationalism, a metropolitan-type culture, and another group seeking national identity through art. Both responses, he stressed, were real; indeed the situation could hardly be other, for this storm and stress reflected the consistent pressure established since the days of European vision, between place and mind, location and mentality, antipodes and cultural centres. But if, for Smith, this difference was the necessary consequence of modern Australian history, it was also and again asymmetrical in nature. Though both groups were good at making noise, one set spoke a language which would more readily be heard in the centres. Smith was thinking about mobility, traffic, the allure of international circuit; he was reading David Riesman's modern classic The Lonely Crowd. So these groups were also generational, in a way, though they were not only that:
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
The one based upon a young, urbanised and - in Riesman's phrase other-directed, highly mobile elite group, the other upon older, suburban and rural groups, the members of which expect to live out their lives in Australia, draw some cultural sustenance and a sense of identity from its legends and history and make, at most, one visit overseas during a lifetime. The emergence of these two kinds of art, reflecting two kinds of life .. . testifies both to the growth of civilization in Australia and to a stratification of the artistic culture grounded in different living conditions and different cultural expectations.39
Globalisation meant that while Australian culture had always been part of an imperialist world-system, there was also now an increasing chance that it would gain some place or exposure in that system. Australians very slowly became interesting to the inhabitants of the centres, even if they were also to be exoticised in the process. But increasingly it seemed possible for Australian intellectuals and artists to make it overseas, and not only as expatriates. Now they would have to choose: was it better to stay in Australia or to follow the sun? What were their responsibilities and obligations, and what were the powers of insight generated by living on the margins which might be lost (or caricatured) in the centres? At least since Goethe and Carlyle writers and artists had viewed themselves as participating in a European world literature or discourse. At the same time, most defences of European art reduced at some point to the less secret championing of work in Germany or France. White Australians, in any case, had always been European; in Murraguldrie too they spoke of fascism and the European theatre of war. And then there were painters like John Brack, imagists of flat suburban lives that could have been lived anywhere in the west, and yet whose cultural experience was overwhelmingly antipodean; for Brack was a European stylist who only travelled to Europe late, after Whitlam. In other words, it was no massive challenge to find reclusive local Europeans living and working in Australia, or to locate noisy Australians in New York or London. Yet given the ongoing obsession of antipodeans, as subordinate partners in the imperialist system, with questions of national identity these issues continued to matter, and they still do. Viewed more universally, if that is possible, they were also the questions put earlier by Gauguin, concerning who we were, where we had come from, and now, towards the new millennium, where we might be going.
49
50
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
To begin even to take in questions about national identity is incredibly complicating, for it is also to open questions of recognition and the identities of individuals. To be recognised locally by the Archibald Prize is one thing; to be told you count in New York is another. And obviously all the institutions of influence in art and ideas are made manifest in some ways by the acts of individual couriers or messengers who break through the media cordons. Some of this can be dealt with as a matter of choice, yet as Smith concluded, it was also a matter of power and influence which corrupt or, at best, lead away from the projects which individuals or groups might otherwise set themselves. Recognition was a cleft stick, institutionalisation a mixed blessing. The results of Australian painting were uneven. What can we say about the status of Smith's art history in Australian Painting? Let me be provocative and assert that art historians, like others, would find themselves more sparked by European Vision or by Place, Taste and Tradition than by Australian Painting.
The political edge, and the raw energy of Place, Taste make it a remarkable text. European Vision more than any of Smith's texts stretches the reader, taking the subject places we ought to recognise easily but do not: the rough tensions of enlightenment, imperialism, art and colonialism, natural and cultural history all entwined. Australian Painting, by comparison, instructs patiently as it explains, seeking to elevate context beyond the often-encountered conventional pattern where art is represented through the analysis of single exemplary works by leading painters of romantic genius. In the 1945 book it narrows down from 'taste' to painting. As Terry Smith has observed, Bernard Smith's strategy in Australian Painting is to introduce art historical categories, ideas, and then encapsulated life-and-work summaries of Australian artists. The logic of the argument in Australian Painting indicates four main periods or phases of development, in summary form: colonial, the Heidelberg School, the rise of modernism, and the tensions between the Antipodeans and the (Sydney) abstractionists. Further sketches of developments into the 1960s and 1970s were later added by Bernard Smith to the 1971 edition and by Terry Smith to their coauthored version.40 Given the arriviste sensibilities of postmoderns, we ought not to be surprised that later analyses could be taken to mean that Bernard Smith had missed the boat, had stopped Australian Painting just when the story got interesting. Certainly it is tempting to
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
51
share the sense that history begins with us, now, and that more recent work has seen the fuller blossoming of Australian art. Charles Green's book, Peripheral Vision, for example, is plainly a book of its time, as Australian Painting was for its own. Even so, the idea of peripheral vision is one already implicit at least in work like Gramsci's and latent in European Vision and The Antipodean Manifesto. So much is apparent; some books carry their period-marking and contexts more visibly than others, yet others again speak across moments. This is one other factor which explains the remarkable ongoing resonance provided by European Vision and the South Pacific. The theses of European Vision
manoeuvre the most significant concerns of Smith's project; it is here, rather than in Australian Painting, that the brilliance of Smith's insight resides, and it is here that art historians and anthropologists alike ought to begin, and return to. Of course there are other interpretations of Australian Painting, such as Humphrey McQueen's punt that Smith's prose had become tight and his own vision constricted by its moment, jammed up against the wall of the Cold War. McQueen's case, respectful yet critical, seems to be that Smith's generation lost the sense of fire in the belly because of McCarthyism or its local strains.41 Looking back, it seems to me that if Australian Painting is a relatively sober book this is because of its brief and its moment in Smith's life. Bernard Smith has acquired various identities in his journey through cultural history; thus, for example, one sometimes encounters those for whom it is by Cook's voyages, or Baudin's, catalogues and maritime artifacts that Smith is known. Australian Painting comes out of the period in which Smith's professional influence was consolidating, as the practice of art history arguably was too. The critical trajectory of European Vision dates back to 1950; anticipated in his earlier writings in the 1940s, Smith was still following through its consequences in Australian Painting, though he was doing other things as well. European Vision may be the central work in his project, but it does not anticipate or hold together everything else that he did, or thinks. Around 1960 Smith was polishing up European Vision and drafting Australian Painting; he was teaching, administering, on the path to the Power Institute. In this setting it is hardly surprising that Smith should have been worrying more about taste or judgement, in the conventional sense, even at the same time as he continued to review for the Age and encourage art for craft's sake. Into the sixties, in
52
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
other words, Smith was engaged in institution-building. He was moving into his fifties, consolidating, teaching, watching art history shift into the newer universities, active in the Academy of the Humanities, promoting art as he was earlier, in the years of those travelling exhibitions. For if art, too, is an institution, then those who are committed to it will also necessarily be institution-builders, even if they are outsiders or rebels at the same time. Smith was publishing European Vision, pushing the Antipodeans, and working on Australian Painting all at the same time, but the image of the outsider besuited, bespectacled, lantern slides under the arm was only one of his identities. 'Taste' or 'Tradition' in any case gives way to Australian 'Painting', a focusing of vision which again opens further, later. INTERPRETING ART IN AUSTRALIA Plainly, Smith was also a part of the story of Australian painting, not just an outsider claiming to explain it more independently. For his own part, I think it is fair to say that he pursued the most honourable yet politically astute path. Smith sought influence but not power. His own frames of meaning, Burwood to the bush, Sydney Teachers College and the University, the Communist Party and its Teachers' Branch led to London first of all, the Institutes of Art at the University of London, the puzzle of the reciprocal and mixed gaze from London to the antipodes and back, from Cook and Banks to Bernard Smith following their voyage in reverse - and yet not. Mild-mannered though he is, Smith was also bound to speak his piece, and he did, whether against European fascism or local antisemitism, in Place, Taste and Tradition or later, against abstraction in The Antipodean Manifesto. At the same time there is a tension in Smith's work between personal preference, political judgement and cultural tolerance which has not always been recognised or understood. To say that Smith advocated the idea of an Australian art through The Antipodean Manifesto is true, but then begs the question of what exactly we mean (or he or his mates meant) by Australian. Evidently not insular, internal, primitivist; that would go against the logic of all his work: that Australian was antipodean, an identity and an art constructed in traffic between centre and periphery, across imperialism and place. Viewed theoretically, the problem might still be seen as one regarding the combination of modern life and the distinction of spheres
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
of activity and judgement; and it may well be that this is an escapable bind. On the one hand, we know that politics and art and society are all mixed up, that these are artificial categories introduced after life in order to make it meaningful by breaking it up artificially into bits we can analyse. On the other, we also know that differences are worth defending and preserving; the market has its logic, which is not the same as that of the state or the university (look what happens when they get mixed up); art has criteria, say, of beauty which are not the same as those of politics even though both work in realms caught up with notions of representation. Having spoken out against the increasing hegemony of abstract international painting, Smith was consequently imagined by some to be a nativist; yet he has always appreciated and promoted art of all kinds, from Cezanne to Christo, and is deeply attracted to work like that of Brett Whiteley and Mike Brown (the latter not least of all for its politics - and its cheek). For there was also a politics of art, as Brown consistently made apparent in his visual attacks on galleries, critics and the money-power mafia that both held the institution together and to ransom. But if there was a politics of art, in this way, then art also necessarily called out anti-art, from Duchamp to Warhol; yet anti-art was also art, was sold and interpreted as art. Only above and beyond the politics of art, there was the political art of visual fascism, antifascism, socialist realism, celebratory forms of national art, the implication of art with nation-building. Smith was bound anyway to the notion that all art was civilisational, recycled, plural; the world of art would always be a Babel of styles and voices. Civilisations, for Smith, also raised questions of actors, subjects, groups and classes of men and women, art as craft; in other words, civilisations had to be conceived anthropologically, and to think anthropologically is to think of the figure of the human being. Smith's commitment to figuration was anthropological, or cosmological; we were, and are, of the world, therefore of and in its art. Antihumanists might recoil, but then Smith never accepted theoretical or political antihumanism. For Smith, to be a modern, to belong to the epoch after the Renaissance, was to be humanist whether we liked it or not; though when the argument comes this far it is also time to remember the arbitrary nature of the sign called 'humanism', for very many of Smith's most powerful insights echo through the vocabularies of the traditions we now call structuralism and poststructuralism.
53
54
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
In a perverse way art history had turned a kind of cycle as Smith sat staring. Its origins in landscape painting had been abstract, nonfigurative, privileging notions of place even as it distorted them through the refracting lenses of prejudice and taste. By the 1970s abstract painting, colour painting like that by Mark Rothko had replaced senses of place by no-place, yet still in the absence of the human hands and faces which assembled paint and canvas. Not that Smith did not admire either Thomas Watling or Rothko; the reservation he had was more one of mistaken or misplaced identity about the anthropology of art. If art said something about us, both these admitted extremes of naturalism and abstraction told us that we were not present; the earliest work denied the finger that pressed the photographic shutter even while it confessed to human presence in its detail, the colour painters elevating paint as a medium but opening the question about nihilism, whether we as actors existed at all (or even deserved to). The appeal of work like Rothko's is powerful, not least of all in moments of increasing uncertainty; and there are always sound philosophical reasons for wondering what humans are, and what they have made themselves out to be. Self-doubt is the alter ego of the modern subject; impossibilism or nihilism always shadows the confident faustian desire for development at any cost. This may well be something that marks modernity out against other periods in civilisation; nihilism coincides with periods of decline, but it is also the perpetual stranger in the doorway. Nihilism also comes together with the melancholy of narcissism, the obsessive innerness of modern anxiety; and while it is quite real for those who choose or are chosen by it, it might also be viewed as the kind of luxury indulged by decadence. Most of the global population at any one moment is probably caught up with more pedestrian problems of holding life together in the material world. In Australia, this suggests perhaps, among other things, taking the conditions of everyday life more seriously than the frames or buzzwords of 'French philosophy' or 'literary texts'. The latter, of course, have their place, but so do the former, more predominantly in terms of what Marx called the dull compulsions of everyday life, as well as its rituals and pleasures/For Smith, then, the earlier problem of the hegemony of gum-tree painting did not reflect badly on gum-trees so much as on the social reception of their portrayal. As he wrote:
E N C O U N T E R I N G
AUSTRALIAN
PAINTING
This preoccupation with landscape has been largely responsible for the creation and maintenance of a false consciousness of what it is to be Australian. For most Australians, including Australian artists, are born and reared in the suburbs. The suburb is their environmental reality; a reality which few, if any, have chosen to describe.42
Abstract expressionism was too far away from this, in Smith's judgement. Pop art had more powerful potential, perhaps, as it pointed away from landscape and towards the city and city life. This indeed was part of Smith's own conclusion about white Australian art, that it fascinated precisely to the extent that it combined European vision and technologies in different ways with the peculiarities of place. Yet he also suggested that the best art, at least occasionally, was also provocative, challenging the dominant values of Australian society in the way, for example, that Mike Brown's catcalls did. The achievement of Australian art was asymmetrical; it owed more to Europe than to local craft or art tradition: Lacking a folk-tradition of long standing from one section of society, or a well-informed aristocratic patronage of the arts from the other, Australian artists have constructed what is national and distinctive in their art in the face of the anti-art values of their society. That is why good Australian art is so often tough-minded and sardonic: not because of the desert but because of the people.43
Feminists might disagree with the implicit class analysis, and advocates of Aboriginal art could now anticipate its increasing projection on to a world screen. Smith's claim, however, was that art and identity result from the negotiation of traditions and locations; they come of culture, of cultivation, of activity and shifting pressure and not of the soil. As Smith put it later: 'Art in Australia is a lazy dialectic between a slow moving colonial and post-colonial tradition and its continuous assimilation of northern hemisphere innovations introduced by successive waves of messengers .. Z44 Like culture, art was always already mixed. In Australia, it had often been caught up with radicalism of some sort. But radicalism was also always already mixed; as Smith observed 'Some kind of classicism or primitivism seems to be invariably present in all radical ideology'. Classicism, medievalism and
55
56
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
primitivism are the principal ideologies by means of which radicals have attacked conservative art values of the present, including the innovating present.43 Thus art, like politics, was always in a state of contestation and pluralism, even though art was by no means inevitably radical, any more than values like classicism, medievalism or primitivism were. CONTROVERSIES OVER AUSTRALIAN ART Bernard Smith's work in Australian art history has been pioneering. He wrote two of its pathbreaking texts, and worked through institutions like the Power Institute to cultivate a second generation of Australian art historians and critics. How was this work received? By virtue of its priority and its nature such work is bound to generate controversy and critique, some of it caught up with the Oedipal crises of fathers and academic children; some to do with the necessary changes in cycles of interpretation and theoretical fashion, others to do with matters of perspective, inclusion and exclusion. Was Smith's art history genderblind? This is one question bound to be raised by the rising feminist presence within art history. It is certainly not fair to claim that Smith ignores the classic work of women such as Cossington Smith, Preston or Crowley, though it is indeed entirely reasonable to observe that until fairly recently painting in Australia was a boys' club, a fact which, in turn, inevitably influences the reception or construction of art history.46 Certainly Smith's art history opened a challenge for feminist historians to do better than he had at theorising the connection between women painters and modernism. Alongside charges of omission, however, go charges of commission. Two such stand out. Had Smith got it wrong? The first such charge came from Richard Haese, in his 1981 book Rebels and Precursors - The Revolutionary Years of Australian Art. Haese works
from the premise that the effect of communism in Australian art and art writing was negative and constricting. My own sense is that Haese makes the mistake of stigmatising a category, 'communism', as though this were the beginning and end of Smith's Marxism or his thinking. As I have shown, Smith's thinking was Marxist in the best sense, historically curious and oriented to notions of activity, suffering, anthropology and culture, and it was interpreted through a complex web of personal experience and reading, from Toynbee to Jack Lindsay. Haese argues fairly consistently that Smith's writing and practice were interesting
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
but marked down by the stain of communist politics. In one way the charge is less than fully surprising, given Haese's own purpose: he is concerned with trying to make sense of his own theme, radicalism, art and its Australian setting, not with pursuing the nuance of individual positions. Smith's Marxism could be claimed to be exceptional in its breadth and depth. Conversely, it could also be argued that Haese misses the point, that he has not portrayed sufficient historical understanding of communist experience transnationally or in Australia where, exactly as Smith would say in European Vision or his books on Australian art, the culture of Soviet communism had first to be mediated by local cultures. Communism in Australia was deeply Australian, as the 'ordinary Stalinism' of the French was substantially local; cultural exchange was never equal, but it did occur, and the power of vernacular or indigenous cultures of communism is something to be reckoned with, not least of all in far-flung countries like Australia, where the only real Soviet contacts were not in the Communist Party rooms but hidden darkly in the Embassies. More perhaps than any other, Australian communists created the Soviet experience in their own image. If it is fair to claim that Haese failed sufficiently to understand the culture of global or Australian communism, however, it could also be argued by extension that his book shows no sufficient appreciation of communism in Sydney, where it is widely recognised that one most substantial authority was always a renegade - John Anderson. Smith's thinking was not directly influenced by Anderson but indirectly through Smith's friend, Tom Rose. Rose, one of his closest friends into the 1940s, studied with Anderson while Smith studied with Dale Trendall. In any case, Smith's thinking was already pluralistic in the forties, influenced like Anderson by the aesthetic writing of Samuel Alexander, and consonant with Anderson's thinking in that it was attracted to ideas of production or creation as well as others of consumption and taste. The spirit of Sydney leftism, it might be said, was libertarian and pluralist, closer to decadence than to discipline. Thus Smith was unconvinced by Haese. He responded to Haese's argument in a talk, 'Reflections on the forties' in 1986. According to Smith, Haese essentialises communism as Sovietism and socialist realism as though, once defined or thus established, this not only places the object but also resolves problems of interpretation, or resolves them by virtue of
57
58
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
placing them in a binary constellation or grid. The analytical bind is evident: a binary grid cannot account for pluralism or for density of context, with the particulars and differences that make up what we call history. Haese presumed that, being a communist, Smith himself divided the world into two, and therefore placed Smith emphatically into one of two compulsory categories, this to the extent that he misquoted Smith in terms of his imputed divide.47 An erratum slip was inserted into Haese's book correcting the misrepresentation of Smith's views, but it is unlikely that this did much to moderate the effect of the charge that Smith was a dogmatic Marxist. Smith emerges from the pages of Rebels and Precursors as neither rebel nor precursor. Rather, he appears dressed as a circumstantial yet grim communist on the road to good sense, nevertheless for the moment a social realist and thereby implicitly a socialist realist, a Marxist and thereby secretly a Stalinist, or else publicly a communist and privately a pragmatist because nobody could really have been stupid enough to be a communist, not least of all if they really knew anything about art. The democratic impulse of his work in education and in the travelling exhibitions was overlooked. The 'stain of politics' cliche was thus stapled together with another, which Trotsky sneered at as 'Marxism as measles', something adolescent which intelligence or maturity is bound to substitute for as one grows up, sooner or later. The logic of Haese's critique of Place, Taste and Tradition is really that it was anachronistic rather than pioneering, the implication being that it might best be forgotten. A different reading, such as that offered in these pages, suggests that, read in context, it is the first instalment of a social theory or a way of thinking about being antipodean that is without parallel and deserves extending. Smith acted with characteristic generosity towards Haese's book, which he recommended and even launched notwithstanding the jaundiced view of his own work and the hostile tenor of particular claims, for example, that he had identified surrealism with fascism or had rejected romanticism as beyond reason and reality.48 As I have indicated above, Smith, in fact, empathised with surrealism, and he viewed romanticism as the constant voice responding to classicism as the various streams flowed together or separately in differing phases of history as civilisation. Rebels and Precursors was an important book, as Smith publicly recognised. Yet as he remarked on another occasion, its author
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
59
projected the Cold War dichotomies with which he grew up back on to the experience of the forties, when, as Rader implied, there were rather at least three competing forces - communism, fascism and democracy.49 As Smith now put it, in retrospect, 'My encounter with Haese's book must have been one of the reasons why I decided to write my autobiography', not to refute Haese's particular story so much as to suggest a different one.50 Haese's final judgement was that in Place, Taste and Tradition Smith had, in fact, written two books: one about politics and one, perhaps with a legacy, about art.51 Amusingly, by the time the second major volley against Smith's work on art had occurred the charge, in effect, was that when it came to Australian Painting he had left out the politics. In 1988 Ian Burn, Nigel Lendon, Charles Merewether and Ann Stephen published a new radical manifesto, The Necessity of Australian Art. An Essay about Interpretation.52 It was not simply an attack on Smith, but among other things it was an attempt to revise the received view of Australian art by putting Smith in his place, opening the way for the next generation and its superior achievement and insight. Obviously Smith had made it, for this was to make of his work a new orthodoxy which periodically would need tearing down. What was Smith's crime? The Necessity of Art is an intriguing document, for it seems to accuse Smith of actually perpetuating that which he himself sought to bring down, the myth of cultural dependency. As Terry Smith pointed out in the supplementary chapters to the third edition of Australian Painting, the theoretical efflorescence of especially French structuralist and poststructuralist and subsequently postmodern intellectual debate in Australia into the 1980s powerfully influenced art as well as theory circles. Just as earlier generations had devoured Baudelaire and Breton, the rising generation ate up works by Jean Baudrillard, sometimes Barthes, Althusser leading into Foucault and perhaps most fashionably, Deleuze and Guattari. To have read or sighted these kinds of books was now the minimum entrance requirement in properly critical circles. Increasingly, art criticism became discourse about words rather than looking at pictures. The Necessity of Australian Art is not especially overburdened by theoretical dress, but it is nevertheless part of a moment of theoretical rejuvenation. In one regard it represents an attempt to align art more closely to phases in the development of political economy, for example the pastoral with
60
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
pastoralism. The book also develops claims, common to thinkers such as Smith and Bourdieu, that modern art always needs to be located within the context of the market institutions which form it. Althusserian Marxism, which Smith had rejected, however, formed the general framework of the critique, with especial reference to influential period work by Arghiri Emmanuel and Samir Amin on unequal exchange and unequal development on a world scale. Burn and his colleagues used these newer arguments - extensions, in fact, of the classical Marxist critique of imperialism which developed it into the language of centre and periphery - to charge Smith with becoming an apologist for American cultural imperialism.53 The first thing to say about this charge is simply that it dismays. Smith had, after all, coauthored among other things The Antipodean Manifesto in 1959, which was largely, if inaccurately, received as a nationalist manifesto. In Place, Taste and Tradition, and then more emphatically in European Vision and
the South Pacific he had argued against the idea of one-way cultural flows or domination, suggesting rather a theory of unequal cultural exchange - apparently the understanding which Burn and his friends thought they had themselves invented. More generally, it was Smith's scepticism about the dominance of the metropolitan centres and especially New York in making the art scene which informed his own criticism of abstract impressionism. Smith's discussion of cultural imperialism in Place, Taste and Tradition becomes, in the view of his critics, an endorsement of dependency as the most dominant or significant aspect of art in Australia.54 It is as though Smith's discussion of unequal cultural exchange is taken as an apology for it. But this is to miss the point about the antipodes, and doubly so, for Smith's concern is with cultural traffic more than its unilateral imposition by great powers on to their colonies. The point about the Heidelberg School, then, is not that it was imitation French but that it represented a specifically local negotiation between cultures, techniques and environments. It is not fair to accuse Smith of centring his analysis on dependency; if it has a pivot it is rather in something like asymmetrical negotiation, which helps to explain not only culture but also imperialism and even national class relations. Smith's critics seem to presume a zero-sum theory of power, in which the centre holds everything and the periphery has no power at all. Smith's premise is quite different, as his anthropology suggests. All subjects are actors,
E N C O U N T E R I N G
A U S T R A L I A N
PAINTING
whatever their constraints; the subordinated always have some room to move, to create their own meaning. This is a different way of thinking about power and creation to the kind of political nihilism which informs the work of the early Foucault and underwrites widely influential unilateralist texts like Edward Said's Orientalism. It is a view of the world which is far closer to that of the Sardinian Marxist, Antonio Gramsci, where politics and culture are structured but uncertain and indeterminate realms of manoeuvre.55 Where will we end up? - it all depends. When it comes to the critique of Australian Painting, Burn and his colleagues argue, like Haese, that by the second text Smith had become more scholarly. The claim that 'Smith's views over those intervening years had undergone significant changes' since Place, Taste and Tradition is not demonstrated because, I suggest, it cannot be.561 shall attempt in this book to show the contrary, that to read Smith's work carefully in sequence is to be struck precisely by its consistency. The objects of Smith's concern shift, of course, and he develops more detailed hypotheses and lines of inquiry as he proceeds, otherwise his work would not possess its fascination. But the basis of his project is already clearly laid into the 1940s, when he had already understood a great deal more about social theory than contemporary fashion these days still sets up as radical insight. At least Richard Haese had offered an alternative view; what the authors of The Necessity of Australian Art left on the table was a manifesto containing a series of imperative demands as to what a proper explanation would look like, a list of proclaimed absences, together with a striking incapacity to locate Smith's thinking across Australia and the Pacific. Indeed, there is no single reference in their critique to European Vision and the South Pacific, the work almost universally acclaimed as the acme of Smith's achievement and the text which establishes the centrality not of dependency but of unequal cultural exchange. Having received Smith as an art historian they also constructed him as one, narrowly. Killing the father, however, meant trampling on him as well, as when Burn and his colleagues accused Smith of devaluing Australian art.37 This is absurd as well as hurtful, for Smith had given much of his life to promoting it. Smith's own response to The Necessity of Australian Art, unpublished among his papers, unsurprisingly lacks the generosity of his response to Haese. Smith protested that the text ideologised
61
62
IMAGINING
THE ANTIPODES
art and overinterpreted art writing. He was not altogether hostile to their purpose, however; it follows from his own sense of philosophy of history that progress and retrogression must occur, that nothing civilisationally now stays the same. He wrote: I am much in favour of what lies apparently at the heart of our authors' endeavours: a history of Australian art that reveals its increasing independence from European and North American sources. I have thought that that is what I had given most of my life to.58
The logic of Smith's conclusion was impeccable - he recognised that his work needed to be replaced, but by fresh research and argument, not an immense theoretical revolution. All things would perish, and it was not to be presumed that knowledge would ever just accumulate in volume until enlightenment arrived. Such progress as might occur, however, needs to seize the wisdom already available to us, and to locate it transculturally as well as at home. If we are to be disappointed by the aporias of theory, then at least we never confront a poverty of cultures.
CHAPTER 3
IMAGINING TH E PACI FIC
THE POLITICS OF VISION How do we see? What do we see? The centrality of vision in social theory and thinking has only more recently been fully registered, not least of all in Martin Jay's magisterial survey, Downcast Eyes and, differently, in Terry Smith's extraordinary study, Making the Modern.1 Light, vision, the obscure and dark, these kinds of image have characterised human consciousness in the west since the Bible (one of Smith's major formative texts) and even more emphatically since the Enlightenment. The hegemony of vision should not be overstated; the eye has always had to compete with the word and deed, and as we have had cause to observe above, the visual appreciation of art has certainly been dominated to some extent by the power of the word, as though art were an illustration of some philosophy or text rather than a realm of its own. Alongside the intellectual analysis of the respective merits or powers of word, eye, and deed, there are the more ubiquitous ordinary usages of vision which crowd everyday life. We use seeing as a synonym for understanding ('can't you see?'), we readily manipulate images of blindness and insight, and so on. The problem of vision in the work of Bernard Smith shifts across these two usages, theoretical and everyday. Smith does not develop a theory of vision or optics so much as a theory of culture which, given his interest in art, is primarily visual. Thus, 'seeing' in Smith's work acts exactly as a limited metaphor for understanding. The field he labours in is that of reception, why some can see more or less than others, why and how 63
64
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
some see their imaginary templates so clearly that fresh experiences replicate the frame rather than modifying it. Why, for example, or how, have the critics of Smith's work on Australian painting seen something different in them than I have, whether it be imported proAmericanism or alleged Soviet dualisms? One way to follow the argument would be to enter the realms of psychoanalysis; at the very least we project as well as receive. We see what we want, or what the psyche or the situation will allow us to. For Smith, however, it is the dynamics of the latter process which captivate: seeing is a creative process as well as a receptive one, and this is how culture is formed and re-formed. All this is already evoked in the titles Smith constructed for his books - European Vision and the South Pacific and
Imagining the Pacific - both referring to the space between or the process across hitherto existing cultures as they are brought into contact by modernity. As I have argued above, these concerns were already evident in Smith's work on Australian art; they already establish the orientation of Place, Taste and Tradition, which Smith wrote in 1944. My sense is that Smith's work acts as a kind of shifting project, which was anticipated early in terms of sensibilities about an always existing world-system of cultures and civilisations, and then expands into different fields like a patchwork quilt. European Vision does not capture all of this, but it condenses some of it. European Vision and the South Pacific is widely recognised as a
pioneering work; published in 1960, it anticipates themes in social theory and the liberal arts which have only now come more fully into focus. But Smith had also anticipated his own themes in the first version of 'European vision', which appeared a decade earlier in the journal of Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, the editors of which included
Anthony Blunt and E. H. Gombrich. Smith, however, had in turn anticipated at least some of its themes ten years earlier again, in a paper he wrote in 1940. He called it 'Reversion and growth in art', the civilisational thinking again indicated in the title, Marx and Toynbee in the shadows. Together with a later document on 'Art and imperialism', and an earlier lecture on surrealism, it is highly suggestive of Smith's earlier thinking on these matters. 'Reversion and growth in art' crosses over the kinds of concerns which dominated Smith's thinking into the forties, fascism in the more immediate sense, the vicissitudes of European civilisation more
I M A G I N I N G
T H EPACI Fl C
globally. One connecting theme was the idea of primitivism. Primitivism, Smith knew, was to primitive as was Chinoiserie to China or Orientalism to Orient: it named the discourse about the phenomenon, said more about us than it. Yet in terms of aesthetics and culture, primitivism was a different order of discourse; it was also cultural, but more so, it represented a particular politics of culture. In the first version of his manuscript, Smith began with a discussion of the May 1940 issue of Art and Australia. The theme was the proposition that Aboriginal culture represented the 'missing foundation' of white Australian civilisation. Smith mentally strung together a number of related yet distinct developments - the nativism of the Jindyworobaks in Australia, the work of Gauguin and the Fauves, the phenomenon of negritude. The questions in his own mind were apparent: why do civilisations refer back? Why can they not produce their self-understanding sufficiently out of a contemporary or modern cultural repertoire? Smith's response here was like Toynbee's, only a little less certain, more curious. Forms of cultural reversion had no obvious or simple explanation, but they seemed to correspond with periods of acute social instability.2 When a strong culture is challenged it pushes back; when a culture lacking in self-confidence is stressed it can resort to or draw upon nostalgia or decadence. The second and third versions of the manuscript work over this terrain, pursuing further the question why moderns (in particular) should be so obsessed with the past, in art or in life. After all, moderns might be supposed to be self-obsessed, enchanted by the new, the self. Part of the answer is obvious, for those who follow these paths - modernity generates a great deal but it erodes meaning, it destroys God, the individual, community, and so on. Modernity is the culture of speed, of endless change; moderns inevitably reach back, or outward, for sources of meaning. It is this sense of emptiness which ultimately explains, or at least contextualises, primitivism as the need for the other. All the echoes were there, in Smith's immediate setting in the 1940s: the art of Rivera and Orozco, the New Masses, the significance of surrealism, Freud, dreaming, the classicism of Marx's own views on art, expressionism, naive art, the paintings of children. The argument about primitivism anticipates by fifty years Smith's recent writing on postmodernism, not least in the sensibility that cultures revive the exotic and the archaic in order to legitimate themselves and confer meaning.1
65
66
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
'Reversion and growth' was never published; a later version of it was given to the Teachers' Federation Art Society on 16 September 1942. Two years earlier, Smith gave another paper to that Art Society, of which he was organiser. On 16 October 1940 he read a paper on surrealism. This was the context in which Smith had used the views of Marx, Spengler and Toynbee to sketch out a general theory of decadence. Decadence meant revival, just as reversion and growth went together. History did not repeat, it reformed old and new. Smith now went on, in effect, to propose a general theory of surrealism, of which the twentieth-century experience was only one example. Surrealism, in other words, was nothing new; look again at Hieronymus Bosch.4 The decadence of surrealism, therefore, simultaneously opened the way for the new; surrealism was a cyclical, transhistorical trend, not just a phenomenon unique to the European context of the Great War. Civilisations came and went, and with them surrealisms. Decadent periods, then, were marked by paintings possessing surrealist qualities, which could be interpreted either positively, as signs of movement and renewal, or negatively, as terminal, of closure. There was a global or regional factor as well: the new art forms which arose after a period of surrealism generally flourished upon new soil, away from the older cultures which had fertilised them originally.5 Yet the assessment of these developments was always bound to be irredeemably perspectival: 'We have to realise that we are either witnessing the birth of a new social order or the end of civilization as we know i t . . .'6 - as we know it. Smith entertained the period sense that the old was dying, the new not yet being born, but he insisted on holding the two in tension rather than opting for optimism of the intellect or pessimism of the will. Smith worried about the waste land of modernity into the forties, but his view of history seems to have prevented him from the grim alternatives of depression or apocalyptics. He knew that to summon up the past was not to return to it; it was only to behave as humans would. This he had learned from Marx, with his notion of progress in history occurring even as its actors call up the ghosts of the past, as from Toynbee, with his more formal sense that disintegrating cultures fell back on an archaism of symbols in a futile attempt to recreate the apparent unity of style and purpose of more stable times.7 Smith was able to think about modernity because he worried about history and thought civilisationally; he was able to think about the
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
Pacific, about Europe and the region, because he had thought about imperialism. In the early 1940s he gave a lecture on 'Art and imperialism'. There he wrote that: Australian art is a colonial a r t . . . Colonial art has certain characteristics. If we would understand our own art we should have some knowledge of the nature of art in colonies ancient and modern . . . a study of the art of colonies would lead one to suppose that they receive a diffused and weakened form of the dominant art style of Imperialism . . . This dominant art style breaks down the national culture of the colonies. The result of this tendency may be either 1. The extermination of the colonial culture 2. The 'renaissance' upon a higher plane of the culture of the colony by investing the technical form of imperialism with a contemporary] attitude and intensity 3. the borrowing of the 'forms' of colonial art by the highbrows of imperialism, and the development of an eclectic pseudo-international art that appeals to the dilettantes in capital cities of the Empire, and leaves the people of the Empire unaffected . . . The culture of Australia in common with the culture of other countries has experienced in a certain degree all of these tendencies.8
Note the patterns of thought. Smith shifts promptly from particular to general, not through abstraction but by comparison and context. Colonies are constructed by empires; ours is a colonial experience of a particular kind, therefore it will be an occurrence with precedents. Imperialism, like surrealism, is a general phenomenon. Smith always sees us and our experience as a moment; he always works through the context of the long view. Thus he observes the massive silence on the relationship between imperialism and art, with the odd exception, referring as locals might say to Australian dependence on America, but missing the global and transhistorical (Greek, Roman, Egyptian) nature of the problem. No wonder Smith was unpopular with those who wanted to keep art discussion safe and sacred. In connecting art to civilisation he also connects it to history, to violence and to militarism, and at the same time, he brings its eternity into question, for as he suggests, the diffusion of a style also leads to its end.9 For Smith, then: 'As far as art is concerned . . . the development of an imperialism is attended by the diffusion of the culture of the imperial power and a contrary
67
68
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
development of national culture and forms upon the fringes of the Empire'.10 Imperialism also generates reaction, not simply diffusion or transference; it leads to national resurgence, or else to cultural devastation. The former, Smith connects here again to Central American experience after Cortes and Pizarro; the latter, he associates with the experience of Australia.11 Imperialism therefore works by its own means, but it is always cultural in form; indeed, one can imagine Smith arguing that inasmuch as culture is also about power, imperialism itself is pre-eminently cultural. But as he was to confirm, cultural imperialism also has an inbuilt feedback mechanism, the master also becomes more like the slave, whether via the cult of primitivism or some other means. The colonisers always go native, even if in subtle and varied ways that they cannot grasp or name, for this is the way that culture flows. As Smith quoted from William James, while reading Samuel Alexander's Beauty and Other Forms of Value: 'half comes from the object and half from the observer's mind'.12 The halves, of course, depend on perspective, are never neat mathematical percentages; environment and consciousness interact more than the actors themselves ever understand. It was this interaction which Smith drew out in the 1950 essay version of European Vision. Smith's frame here is basically the same as that which holds the book of the same name together. We turn in detail to the more extensive version in the next section. For the moment it will suffice simply to observe the precedents in his thinking. Smith's concern in the first version of his argument is with the eyes that the explorers brought to the antipodes; he sets out to read their records, to examine their use of distinction and classification, their discovery of novelty and their assimilation of it into their own precedents where vision violated their own cultural horizons too much. James Cook's brief was to inquire into the world of the South Land, to examine and record nature, flora, fauna and peoples. Cook was a scientist, but he was also an anthropologist of sorts. Joseph Banks was on a different expedition, in a way, for his was a grand European tour with a difference, in that it went right around the globe. Art was central to this experience, for its occurrence preceded photography; the visual record depended exclusively on art work. This expedition then represents, for Smith, something like a crucible of Enlightenment; and Enlightenment, like humanism, is not something Smith rejects, so much as worries
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
over, for it cuts both ways. It cuts both ways in the Pacific, as well, for it generates both positive and negative effects, and it draws together an array of fascinations which we now analytically separate, such as nature and intellect, botany and science, culture and classification.13 For any readers who still harbour fantasies about the alleged certainty of the western project, Smith also reminds them of the role of the accidental and arbitrary. Banks, in particular, carries two personal agendas, one more like work or science, the other closer to life. The expeditionary artists are instructed to fit in with this dichotomy: to paint more accurately, for the scientific purposes of the trip, and also to use more license in the pictures done for Banks' circle, who seek entertainment and thrill. Accident intervenes; one of the two key artists (Alexander Buchan) dies, leaving the other (Sydney Parkinson) to pick up both jobs. The in-principle distinction between entertainment and documentary is lost; Banks to his chagrin is stuck with Parkinson, left with art as entertainment. All the same, the empirical, experimental curiosity of Enlightenment is intact; the explorers do travel in order to discover, it is only that they assimilate the new into the comfort of the established ways of seeing which they carry with them as reliably as they carry syphilis, alcohol and the Bible. The results of the art vary. Flora is probably most accurately rendered; the artists did not yet carry Ruskin in their pockets, but they worked in anticipation of his exhortation to draw from nature each fibre or tendril. Coastal views, then significantly known as 'perspectives', also needed to be unambiguous, as they were a practical aid to navigation. Yet sometimes the artists could not help themselves; they projected romantic or gothic senses on to mountains and grottoes in period style, which meant that they were painting English picturesque landscape in the antipodes. As James had remarked in Smith's reading of Alexander, they were combining half the object and half the observers' mind or culture. Cook's artists thus had a choice of sorts; they could paint analytically or picture the picturesque. William Hodges became the painter who most strikingly combined the two. If landscape (or animal life) could quite readily if awkwardly be rendered into English, the power of cultural imagination was even more perceptible when it came to the portrayal of local peoples. Aesthetic romanticism and primitivism now came into their own. Initially the inhabitants of the Pacific were personified as the noble
69
70
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
savage. They were Hellenised, dressed like Greek heroes or like Scots highlanders, dressed up as gods or goddesses, painted into backgrounds of arcadia, abundance, paradise. The horror of this depiction was less in its portrayal than in its consequence. Innocence turned into original sin. Having made them gods, the white men then made them devils; the fall arrived, and (as Smith put it) there now arrived a new human type, the ignoble savage, and his arrival was coterminous with extermination. The noble savage of the romantic imagination was always precariously superior to us, having escaped the poison and corruptions of industry and the modern city; but this could not last or outlast the fall. The image of the noble savage was doomed and so were the peoples it had been projected upon. Or that, again, was where state power and the legal fiction of terra nullius led. The emergence of painterly melancholy in nineteenth-century Australian art was somehow an appropriate note on which to conclude this story. For Smith's part, the connections were now more apparent. In order to speak or to write about Australian art, he had to make sense of 'Australia', its implication in Empire, upon power through culture. To explain the 'us' of European Australia would also mean seeking to explain Europe and its institutional and visionary arrival in the antipodes, which it constructed as other, as subordinate and as echo. To make sense of culture it was necessary to enter realms of imagination, vision and civilisation across time and place. It would be necessary to think both our own subordination to the centres and our subordination, in turn, of those who came before us. The Pacific thus nestles in the very centre of Smith's world, and work; it points back, to Toynbee, Marx and civilisation, to England and the profound ambivalence of Enlightenment, to the local, the antipodean; it connects forward, textually, to the Antipodean Manifesto, to the Boyer Lectures on Truganini, laterally to Place, Taste and Australian Painting and to the shadow of the new, American Pacific hegemony across the water. It pointed, finally, to the cultural mix which some would celebrate as the postmodern, or postcolonial. In the most direct sense, it would point to his central text. EUROPEAN VISION AND THE SOUTH PACIFIC European Vision and the South Pacific first appeared in 1960, the text followed by black and white reproductions carried together at the end of the book. The pleasure of the book was increased enormously in the
I M A G I N I N G
T H E
PACI
FIC
second edition, quarto format, with colour reproductions inserted throughout the text. In the Preface to the Second Edition (1984) Smith opened up a number of problems to do both with the idea of reception and with the particular reception of his own book. Smith begins by observing that the twenty-year interval between editions witnesses something of a sea change in the writing of cultural history. It was a change which his own work had helped to bring on; the purview of history and the definition of art had expanded, while the social sciences had begun to renegotiate their artificially severed relationship with history. Smith did not here use the word 'perspective', but he imparted the sense that his own book had participated in and further encouraged a repositioning and revaluing of perspective. The idea of perspective, vision, position, experience was now both seen more as a theoretical or epistemological problem and as a fact of location for scholars. As Smith put it, the rediscovery of perception (in this case European perception) encouraged the rediscovery (especially among the rising generation of anthropologists and ethnohistorians) of the inescapable relativity of their own perceptions: The use of the term "European Vision" declared a belief in a cognitive theory of perception: that seeing is conditioned by knowing'.14 Recognition, however, brought with it misrecognition; Smith had now to deal with the fact that while his own work had attracted some attention, it had not been read with care (or else, like other great books, had not been read at all). Some among its readers, or receivers, imagined Smith to be claiming that English idiots could see nothing, so powerful was the dominant European ideology in their heads: But the book nowhere suggested that Europeans (or for that matter the members of any other ethnic or cultural grouping) are incapable as individuals of seeing what is actually before them, or that they are incapable of knowing that they are in the presence of the (for them) new, though they may well find, and usually do find, difficulty in assembling appropriate words, images, symbols and ideas to describe accurately their experience . . . The book was not written as an apologia for an extreme cultural relativism.15
When it came to knowledge or values, Smith was not a nihilist; as we have seen, he viewed nihilism as a cultural phase rather than as a terminal world-condition or dreary personal choice.
71
72
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
In Smith's perception, the problem of reception was fairly straightforward. Frequently read or cited, the book was also frequently misread or manipulated. Some at least of his readers had read out or projected upon his argument that which most attracted them - the noble savage: The most common reading was that eighteenth-century Europeans saw Pacific peoples as "noble savages'".16 As we have seen even from the outline sketch of the early essay version, however, this issue nestles among others about the ambiguity of Enlightenment, and it positions the aura of the 'noble savage' against that of the impending 'ignoble savage'. Another misreading of, or projection upon, European Vision concerned the romantic commonsense that the impact of Europe on the island societies was fatal. Just as the 'noble savage' was one of a number of competing and conflicting stereotypes which Europeans manoeuvred in order to make sense of the Pacific, so was the 'fatal impact' only part of the story. In any case, as Smith responded, the focus of his book was less on the impact of Europe on the Pacific than on the impact of the imagined and experienced Pacific upon European cultures.17 In elevating or selecting these kinds of radically chic themes, the reception of Smith's book had managed to miss part of his purpose. He chose to emphasise two neglected themes in return. Both were, in a certain sense, epistemological, to do with ways of seeing and thinking in the Enlightenment context in the margin of modernity and on the edge of the world-system. The first was to do with the significance of the Pacific as a kind of countercase to European sensibility. European experience of the Pacific was one of cultural exchange. The Pacific region provided a challenging new field of experience for Europeans, for it was one which placed unprecedented pressure on the biblical theory of creation and simultaneously provided a wealth of new evidence which pointed towards evolution. This was to remind readers that, like other Enlighteners, the English had strong empirical curiosities as well as rational claims. They may have created a composite image of the Pacific and a barrage of tropes to help explain it, but they also discovered the Pacific, as a field of difference and differences, other things, people, other worlds.18 As Smith suggested, in period terms this aligned the 1960 text of European Vision with the 1962 publication of Thomas Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions. The two books together belonged to something like a sociology of science, beginning to place its practices within institutions, politics, vision and social
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
context - power. The later reception of ideas like these, however, was lost in the enthusiasm for arguments concerning genealogy, archaeology and power/knowledge; Foucault now ruled. The second theme which Smith sought to recentre concerned art, though it also, thereby, concerned thinking. According to Smith, the second theme of the book was that the predominant mode in nineteenth-century landscape painting arose from the need to discover and evoke what was typical. The mode of art history which Smith had been subjected to worked on premises of individual genius and great masterpieces which were linked together serially by means of stylistic and iconographic analysis. The result was an art history at once too exclusively European and ahistorical. As Smith wrote, like Pacific art itself: Within that practice this book was something of an anomaly since its main concerns lay not with art masterpieces but with visual images produced primarily for the purposes of information, and devoted itself not so much to explicating the creative role of artists in their societies (the central myth of art history) but to the use of visual documents for a clearer understanding of the European penetration of the Pacific.19
That Smith was a typological thinker is already evident in his views on civilisations, imperialisms and surrealisms. His is not the compulsory or brutal typology of some heavy-handed model-building sociology; he associates, and cross-refers, thinks through similarity and difference, sympathy and conflict. The types at work in Smith's thinking are not the schematic two-by-two boxes which force all history into preexisting schemata; they are the looser types of precedent, of deja-vu, of recycling, return, re-formation, transformation, of context rather than abstract logic. The point about landscape painting, then, was that like life in Kuhn's portrayal of science, there emerge and pass different ways of seeing or classification which rise to dominance and then move on. The European project of controlling the world required a landscape practice that could first survey and describe, then evoke in the new settlers an emotional engagement with the land that they had alienated from its Aboriginal inhabitants.20 In other words, landscape painting was part of a technology or will-to-power, but it was also part of a cultural cosmos of symbols which would include the new by
73
74
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
conferring meaning upon the old. Landscape had a place in the world, not only in the gallery or textbook. To argue in this way, as Smith did, was to draw together in one optic, or way of seeing, the human sciences and the natural sciences. Botany, zoology, geology, geography, meteorology, anthropology, symbolism, art, culture all came together; the point was not that each needed to be mastered or known in its integrity, so much as that the ontological connections between them be recognised, that nature, culture and their classification be reviewed as the arc which forms and fractures the human condition. Moving closer to the text, in the Preface to the First Edition Smith located his project against that of Place, Taste and Tradition. The point of their connection has been made already, but it bears emphasis, not least of all against those readings of Smith's work which would appropriate it partially, anthropologists to the left, art historians to the right (or whichever). The origin of European Vision is plainly apparent in the framing of Place, Taste and Tradition; from whence did we come? White Australian culture, perhaps more conspicuously than others of its type, was not indigenous or implanted, but the result of traffic. To inquire into the 'origins' of contact and traffic was also, as Smith understood, to pursue the interrelation between the history of art and the history of science, or the history of the politics which held them together.21 Here the unity of purpose between Place, Taste and Tradition and European Vision is apparent; both seek, in different ways, to view art in its social or institutional setting within the framework of imperial culture. Each is defined by the other, Europe by the Pacific, Australia by Europe. It is this sense of context and reciprocity which holds together the elongated version of Smith's narrative. He lets it fall into place deliberately, distinction leading to explanation. In our own moment, when Cook, like Columbus, has become an item of ridicule and vilification, modernist as fascist, the invading white barbarian in pursuit of state power, British imperialism personified, Smith's book opens as follows: Tn the year 1768 the Royal Academy was established and the Royal Society promoted Cook's first voyage to the South Seas'.22 Science and art are aligned but not explained by reduction; the will to power and the will to know are connected, not collapsed into each other. All these, like Smith's major categories - vision and experience - are held together in tension. The wisdom of the Royal
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
Academy, its way of seeing, was to represent nature not with its accidental accretions but in its perfect forms, knowledge of which came not from nature directly but from the history of art. The Royal Society, by contrast, appealed to nature, to a different audience, to notions of technical accuracy and experiment. It was the empirical approach of the Society and not the neo-classicism of the Academy which flourished under the impact of the new knowledge won from the Pacific.23 But the tensions remained and they also flourished, in the discovery of paradise and men like Greek gods in the Pacific. As those illusions crumbled, so did the stature of neo-classicism erode: The opening of the Pacific is therefore to be numbered among those factors contributing to the triumph of romanticism and science in the nineteenth-century world of values'.24 Note the inflexion of Smith's argument, holding together the tensions; it is not Enlightenment and Science which conquer all in the usual triumphalist or plague-on-allyour-houses view of modern history, rather romanticism and science which, as unruly partners, ex post facto categories, reign together, the old and new clipped together in tension more than harmony. As Smith suggests, it is not fatal impact which raises his curiosity so much as Pacific stimulation of the dominant imagination. With Smith we are looking into the optics of what we call romanticism and science in order to observe how the world of the Pacific stimulated European thinking concerning the world of nature as a whole; in the case of the former, as the subject of imitation and expression, in the latter, as the object of philosophical speculation.25 If Cook then symbolises the Empire in contemporary mythology, Smith's purpose is also to relocate the institutions which hold the two symbolic abstractions of individual and power together. Cook's voyage was the first large scientific maritime expedition in whose promotion the Royal Society played a major role; by way of parallel, the Society is the equivalent of a university or research institute today, and it has a similar kind of significance. Thus the connection with Kuhn. Cook's voyage is mediated through specific institutions which reinforce the senses of purpose he carries. Cook's mission was not only actively oppressive; it was part of that same moment as was inhabited by Montesquieu, Bougainville, De Brosses, and the Forsters. Cook was to set out to discover Europe's other, to inquire into its environment and difference in geography, society and botany. The logic of discovery,
75
76
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
or seeing afresh is, however, one of disruption as well as of confirmation. People see what they want, but partially rather than absolutely As Kuhn put it, dominant discourses within science assimilate anomalies but there are some such which so violate the orthodoxy that it has to shift. And the Pacific was full of anomaly when it came to continental commonsense about animals and plants, people and the proper order of things. Not that the emerging Enlightenment optic was discarded, for we still inhabit it. Yet its empirical axis had to throw back the deductive sensibilities which presumed that it was Europe which was facing the right way up, closest both to God and to Reason. The point about perception in all this becomes plain. As we encounter the unfamiliar we (any such we) are bound to translate it. Smith's thinking rests on the idea that while difference is fundamental, humans think through similarity. This is what makes us humans, anthropologically speaking. In order to explain the new (or anomalous) we say that it is like something; we think through metaphor. The problem for us (in this case, Europeans) is that the process risks ending here, where it should begin. Metaphorical thinking risks assimilation, or abstract violence towards difference as it identifies through association. We slip easily from a is like b to a is b, and then we learn nothing, or at least we learn nothing new. The problem for the voyagers, then, is not that they fail to see but that they engage in forms of recognition which conceal as much as they reveal. At the same time, the point of Smith's argument is precisely that perception and culture shift. They move, both forward and cyclically, sometimes for better, sometimes for worse, sometimes in regress. Neo-classical attitudes to landscape are undermined by the realisation that the perfection of forms is a philosophical aspiration more than it is a natural one. The cult of the noble savage gives way to the social Darwinism of the ignoble savage; this is also part of the cruel game we call civilisation. One fascinating undercurrent in Smith's European Vision is that the gaze of the outsider is also unwittingly reversed. As the Europeans come to stare at the natives so we, now, stare at the Europeans staring. The anthropologists, as it were, become visible to us as observers and observed. Smith opens his second chapter, on Cook's First Voyage, with a quotation from Francis Bacon, On Travel: Tt is a strange thing that in sea-voyages, where there is nothing to be seen but sea and sky, men should make diaries, but in land travel wherein so much is to be
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
observed, for the most part they omit it' - thus Bacon.26 Western men are animals who write, who keep diaries, this says to us, but they are also terrified by death; they write so much because they are confronted by what they encounter as nothingness. And by other criteria, more temporal, they behave without any logic at all, less exotic than idiotic; they are as strange to us as the natives were to them and they to the natives. Sometimes the results of these encounters are marvellously comic, as in the kangaroo painted for Banks by George Stubbs. The painting is beguiling, especially as the incredulity wears off; Stubbs' kangaroo is not what we know as a kangaroo, rather it resembles a cross between a mouse and a fox. But then the kangaroo is an icon for us, as well as an animal we know by acquaintance; Stubbs instead assimilated it into the forms already known to him (and to his audience). Little wonder that, as with mermaids, there was some imperial concern that these antipodean animals had been made up, literally sewn together in mischief to upset the authorities; indeed, had they not existed there is a good local case that they should have been invented. Thus did the exotic and the scientific run together, this to the extent that controversy broke out concerning the possibility that the bizarre nature and variety of antipodean wildlife clearly indicated the occurrence of promiscuous intercourse among types of animals. Perhaps Stubbs' kangaroo really was the result of illicit relations between mice and foxes. This was indeed a world that seemed to those from above to be upside down. At the same time there were those in the metropolis who took advantage of the wisdom of the explorers into satire; for the wisdom of the north could be inverted there, as well, jeered at there as pompous and ridiculous or even made risque. So it is that to our eyes, today, the oddity is in the reception of the explorers as much as they saw it in culture and environment. Viewing some of the pictures in European Vision in a detached way, especially the engravings which follow but embellish on earlier versions, is a bit like contemplating the duck-rabbit device or pondering interpretations of ink blots. The artists certainly took their license, whether reviewing New Zealand grottoes in rococo style or casting Tahitians as Greeks. Such imaginary assimilation consistently reinstates the tension which, Smith argues, characterises the period. Classicism and romanticism constantly vie with more literal or realist interpretations. As Marx and Toynbee had it, later civilisations were perpetually given to calling up
77
78
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
ghosts of the past, recycling arcadian and archaic motifs; this was primitivism in early modern art, primitivism well before Picasso, but it was also perhaps more than that, as the classical echoes hit foundational mythic themes for the Enlightenment, Greece and Rome as imagined origins for London or Weimar or Paris. As we see Fred Williams when we walk in the bush, so Bougainville wrote that when he walked on Tahiti he felt as though he were transported to the Garden of Eden.27 This was the other, the euphoric end of the emotion which Bacon named without commenting on, the fear of the sea as the unknown, death, oblivion. But like the momentary idyll constructed around the romantic aura of the noble savage, this stillness could not last. Modernity accentuated the impulse to change, in culture and in fact; and the empirical aspect of Enlightenment would ever struggle against the cerebral. No matter how much they enthused for Tahiti, the experience also cut both ways. There were two sides to Tahiti or its image, a light side and a dark side. Tahiti proved that there was once a Golden Age; Tahiti also proved that it had long since passed away. The island's symbolic impact was as much in terms of its transience as in its apparent claim to happiness untrammelled by western civilisation. Like civilisation and arcadia, the idea of the antipodes cut both ways. The image of antipodes as hell, topsy-turvy, the absurd other could be used by the English to fix in place both the hard primitives like Aborigines and the mediocre mixed white stock after invasion and immigration; as Bernard Smith discovered when he took his curiosity regarding the Pacific to the Courtauld Institute, in superior eyes there was no such thing as art in Australia or any other place outside the centres. But the antipodes could also upset the stability of hitherto existing cultural hegemonies. Sooner or later the antipodeans would reflux from below and return to haunt the metropolitan consciousness. Even in their own time, the antipodes would not be still. As Smith noted: 'The idea of an antipodean inversion of natural laws was not an easy one to reconcile with the idea of a carefully ordered hierarchy both physical and moral which was securely held together by the laws of nature'.28 The bottom end upset the proper order of things, morality, sexuality, belief - nothing was spared. The consequence was like that set into motion by Montesquieu in The Persian Letters, for the realisation of the other was subversive. The discovery that others lived differently could be used to stigmatise them, but the process of comparison was
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
more dangerous than that. Maybe the Persians or the Tahitians were right. Before we knew it, the whole world could be turned upside down. Cook's second voyage saw the establishment of William Hodges as Cook's painter. The Forsters, father and son, served as naturalists. Georg Forster, the younger, even then took umbrage against Hodges' artistic subjection of nature to artifice. Forster's argument was significant, not least of all because it is illustrative of the way in which some participants on the voyages were themselves already aware of the difficulties of vision and reception which the painters were engaged in. Smith quotes a passage from Forster's Voyage Round the World, 1777: it concerns Hodges' classical representation of Cook's Landing at Middleburgh (Eua). Forster wrote that Hodges was guilty of playing to the gallery: Mr Hodges designed this memorable interview in an elegant picture, which has been engraved for captain Cook's account of this voyage. The same candour with which I have made it a rule to commend the performance of this ingenious artist, whenever they are characteristic of the objects, which he meant to represent, obliges me to mention, that this piece, in which the execution of [by] Mr Sherwin cannot be too much admired, does not convey any adequate idea of the natives of Eaoowhe or Tonga Tabbo. The plates which ornamented the history of captain Cook's former voyage, have been justly criticised, because they exhibited to our eyes the pleasing forms of antique figures and draperies, instead of those Indians of which we wished to form some idea. But it is also greatly to be feared, that Mr Hodges has lost the sketches and drawings which he made from NATURE in the course of the voyage, and supplied the deficiency in this case, from his own elegant ideas. The connoisseur will find Greek contours and features in this picture, which have never existed in the South Sea. He will admire an elegant flowing robe which involves the whole head and body, in an island where the women very rarely cover the shoulders and breast; and he will be struck with awe and delight by the figure of a divine old man, with a long white beard, though all the people of Ea-oowhe shave themselves with muscle-shells.29 Forster's appeal to NATURE against the imposition of artifice may rankle with us today, reminiscent as it is of Locke's attack on the opacity of
79
80
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
metaphor as ornament. Plain speaking, or painting, will not always do. The power of Forster's insight is nevertheless striking; it makes it clear that the contemporary participant could also understand the problem of romanticising the other. Indeed, Smith's use of the passage from Forster makes the critical point even more powerfully than Smith himself can, as interpreter after the fact. Forster's witness makes us recognise that some of the participants, at least, in Cook's voyages knew what was happening, understood that representation (and misrepresentation) of culture was also at stake here. This was indeed a period of projection, of the European cult of the exotic and primitive. The visit of the first kangaroo to England caused an uproar. Then the arrival of Omai, a native of Huahine, created another English sensation. No less prestigious a figure than Sir Joshua Reynolds painted a full-length portrait of Omai in full classical splendour, barefoot like Christ but otherwise dressed to kill. The noble savage had been let into the parlour. Hodges, for his part, on this occasion portrayed Omai more realistically. Once again, however, the results were mixed and unpredictable. The local satirists turned insult into injury: Omai became a stock-figure of great use in the attack on the morals and manners of contemporary English society.30 The intruders in paradise were being filmed, as it were, even as they filmed the exotic, and they made themselves look ridiculous in the process. As Smith repeatedly observes, this difference in response serves to remind that there is no such thing as romanticism, only romanticisms, harder or softer. Both the satirists and the ladies and gentlemen in Banks' parlour project romantic sensibilities on to Omai, but of different kinds. In other words, the category of romanticism, like primitivism (or more recently Orientalism) has to be handled with care; it needs to be remembered that it is an ex post facto category, which we allow too easily to freeze and fix that which moves {a is not like b, it is b). The critical point remains, however, that even a stigmatic category such as the 'noble savage' could cut both ways. Smith quotes John Scott's 'Cook cycle' poem of 1775, where Scott has Omai turn on his oppressors, and say: Can Europe boast, with all her pilfer'd wealth, A larger store of happiness, or health? What then avail her thousand arts to gain
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
The store of every land and every main; Whilst we, whom love's more grateful joys enthral, Profess one art - to live without them all.31 Smith's view cuts hard - it was a short step from the use of Tahitian life to criticise the shortcomings of English society, to the claim that European civilisation would corrupt life in the Pacific Islands. This is exactly the logic of Smith's argument about cultural exchange, that however unequal and saturated with power it may be, the flows go unpredictably, the traffic feeds back, reverses, crosses over, culture and politics flow subliminally uphill. Yet even these flows refused to conform to expectation. Thus, Smith notes that, ironically for art historians, European thought was so preoccupied with philosophy of nature during the eighteenth century that Pacific arts and crafts hardly made the impression which the peoples themselves did. The problem was all of a piece. The idea of art, itself implying industry, was not easily to be incorporated within the arcadian dream of islanders who gained their bread and milk 'without toil from the trees'.32 The idea of Pacific art had to precede its discovery. If history was visual, then vision had its historicity. In a particular sense, politics meantime reigned. An anonymous English pamphlet of 1780, A Letter from Omai to the Right Honourable . . .
read like a postcard from the visiting Persian, or child/savage: And after thanking you for the powder, shot, gun, crackers, sword, feathers and watch, let me thank you also for my conversion to Christianity: I ought perhaps have mentioned this before the sword and crackers, but as the fire and the sword have commonly taken the lead, I will not dispute their title to it.33
It was less and less clear who the barbarians were, or who possessed better vision. Perhaps realising that this uncertainty was amongst them, the colonisers then recast the savages as ignoble. The focus of European Vision now turns to Australian settlement, and the hard primitivism of the portrayal of Aborigines. The local people could be assimilated into the category of primitives; anomalies like the kangaroo caused bigger headaches for systems of classification, and they, in turn, could be partly assimilated into various different categories but finally
81
82
IMAGINING
THE ANTIPODES
warranted the construction of a category of their own. Neither would go away. This was, indeed, one reason why the intruders spoke of a 'new world', for it violated the order of things in the 'old' world, and yet it was there. So the pre-existing European categories were fudged together, resulting in makeshift hypotheses such as those which suggested that aberrant forms resulted from promiscuous intercourse among animals. The local peoples would more readily be placed, but they were also viewed differently. Dampier constructed them as repulsive miserables; Cook viewed their lives rather as simple and austere.34 Australian natives were viewed as hard primitives, spartans rather than arcadians. Classical antiquity was ever in these margins. Smith notes that these kinds of divergence in view remind that there were two quite contradictory attitudes to nature in what we know of eighteenthcentury thought. On the one hand, it was claimed that all our misfortunes are due to our departure from nature's laws, while on the other, it was claimed that man could only raise himself above the brute creation by improving on nature.35 Late moderns share with their predecessors this fundamental ambivalence about civilisation; we adore it, but it makes us mad. And in our madness we lust after the past, youth, childhood, innocence, the other, the sublime. Thus, the adventurers of the eighteenth century waxed lyrical about the antipodes, where they saw Rome and Athens all over again. Australia was not an English garden, but it could be. Then the projection of desire turns nasty, as fantasy refuses to materialise and the landscape refuses to behave as it is bid by foreign command. The local peoples, similarly, refused to behave by disappearing; so they were turned by artists into grotesque caricatures and in the landscape paintings were replaced by sheep, as they were shot or poisoned offstage, expelled from the pastoral in image and deed alike. The Anglicisation of the pictorial landscape was no longer an aesthetic projection; the topographical landscape itself was increasingly Europeanised.36 So sheep eat men and women in the antipodes as well, more readily even because they are primitives. Life followed art, even as art worked in the interests of empire. In Smith's trajectory, the story now pointed to Australian Painting as a consolidation of Place, Taste and Tradition; and it indicated the later line of thought on Truganini for his Boyer Lectures. In the context of his own writing, however, there is nothing as fascinating as
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
European Vision. The concerns signalled in it, he extended in Imagining the Pacific. IMAGINING THE PACIFIC
Imagining the Pacific appeared thirty years later, in 1992, bringing together various essays in the wake of European Vision. It is, in a way, a kind of second-order discourse around the themes of the earlier study. Imagining the Pacific begins with an epigram from Wordsworth's Prelude: 'imagination, which, in truth is but another name for absolute power and clearest insight'. The implication of this choice of orientation is approving and curious about romanticism and its effects; for it follows from Smith's view of history that romanticism is perpetually part of us as well as a dominant phase of a cyclical kind which can be identified as such after the fact. The tension is a constant one in Smith's thought, and in modern culture: his anthropological inclination and his aesthetic criticism deserve to be described as materialist, but his fascination with symbol and meaning forever throw focus back on the ideal. We do not only imagine the Pacific, our forebears invade it, and we inhabit it; yet the imagination also has what might be called material effects, as when Europeans actually bring antipodean landscape into line with their images of it. We imagine the Pacific and the antipodes, and we also make them. What might it mean, then, to imagine? Smith suggests that, as we think it, 'imagination' consists of two major components, imaging and imagining. Imaging involves the construction of an image in the presence of its object; imagining is a more abstract process, where an image is constructed in the absence of the direct sensory contact with the field from which the imagery of the imagining is constructed. Between imaging and imagining there are discontinuities, but continuity is also apparent; the relation between the two is like a spectrum, for they alike constitute an activity. Imaging involves not only sensation and perception but also reconstructive skills and memory. Memory itself also works through imagination. As for imagination, it also refers back necessarily to perception of experience.37 Thus, to refer to example, we might say that Kafka's Amerika is more strictly a work of the imagination than D. H. Lawrence's Kangaroo, for Lawrence experienced something of Australia whereas Kafka did not visit America at all. Nevertheless, Kafka also knew something about America, just as all
83
84
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
Australian children who watch television know it and know it well. With a similar sense of complexity, in this kind of comparison, Lawrence knew Australia better than Kafka knew America, and it was this knowledge which led him more fully (and more fancifully) to imagine it. Somewhat later Jean Baudrillard, more like Lawrence, visits America but then also imagines or constructs it as the misplaced, the cultural rather than geographical antipodes of Europe. These kinds of experience tell us a great deal about human thinking, even if they are impossible to codify. Knowing and imagining, image and imagination are all mixed together in Smith's understanding, not least of all because the image also appears vitally in art, whereas imagination acts in and beyond art. To think the Pacific, or the antipodes, for Smith, is to do more than to think about thinking or to interpret representations. There is the world, or worlds, and there are its texts; but the world does not end with its texts. If we are to begin to understand, say, the Pacific, we must also accept the reality of the objects and the historicity of those processes out of which 'the Pacific' was constructed together with the habits of those European minds out of which the concept of the Pacific was constructed, and those Pacific minds that found themselves at once the objects and victims of that 'understanding'. In imagining the Pacific, Europeans imagined a reality that they had to come to terms with, not a fancy or fantasy that might eventually disappear.38 The echoes of this are in Toynbee, as usual, for Smith seeks here (among other things) to probe the source of Europe's own need to imagine the Pacific in a particular way in its original 'primitivism', the civilisation of ancient Greece and the enduring cultural model which that civilisation produced and which we have since reproduced.39 There are also some echoes of the kind of argument found in Collingwood's Idea of History, that the historian's task is to rethink past thinking, to enter into dialogue with the past from present horizons as hermeneutics would recommend. The themes of Imagining the Pacific are as varied as are the papers in the collection. Smith now pursues, for example, the earlier theme that art is always institutionally embodied and socially embedded. In the Pacific, art works in the service of science and travel. That art is sacred in its origins is widely acknowledged, and so is its relation to the church. Smith aligns it with other forces as well, the educated class and
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACI FIC
its grand tours and scientific aspirations. The exotic was discovered not only in the antipodes, but in new worlds like America and in older, more proximate strange worlds within Europe. Europeans may henceforth have stigmatised the other, but at least they recognised its existence, and thereby acknowledged the relativity of their own existence. As Smith expressed it in a different chapter, art also worked as information; Cook was less an invader or conqueror than an inquirer (the invaders came later). Then there was the related story in which Cook himself was pictorially depicted as hero (the revisionists also came later). Vision itself has a history. Where white men travelled, self-doubt went with them. The invaders behaved like barbarians, but some of them knew it. Thus Parkinson, after an affray with Tahitians in which one of them had seized a musket from a sentinel: A boy, a midshipman, was the commanding officer, and giving orders to fire, they obeyed with the greatest glee imaginable, as if they had been shooting wild ducks, killed one stout man, and wounded many others. What a pity, that such brutality should be exercised by civilized people upon unarmed ignorant Indians.40 Young Georg Forster was more direct: If the knowledge of a few individuals can only be acquired at such a price as the happiness of nations, it were better for the discoverers and the discovered, that the South Sea had still remained unknown to Europe and its restless inhabitants'.41 Where Parkinson worries in terms of pity, brutality and ignorance, Forster, closer in spirit to Smith, views the situation as one expressive both of the desire for liberty and of the modern imperative seen in its eternal restlessness. Europeans after the Enlightenment could not help but explore the planet; their own restlessness led them in turn to idealise the apparent rest of the South Seas. These European inconsistencies also underpin Smith's criticism of Edward Said in the chapter in Imagining the Pacific on 'Style, information and image in the art of Cook's voyages'. It is worry enough that something newly set, tough-cast and ruthlessly hegemonic called Orientalism emerges from Said's writing. Smith's disagreement with the neatness of this unilateral flow can be read between the lines: Said, he says, 'concludes that these views, which he describes as Orientalist, are consistent and
85
86
IMAGINING
T H E ANTIPODES
relatively unchanging, and present a view of the East from Egypt to China that is addressed to the past and achieves a kind of timeless quality'.42 Said claims to construct Orientalism upon a theoretical position which runs between Foucault and Gramsci. The power ontology of the early Foucault swallows up the sense of transaction and process in Gramsci in no time. Romanticism and primitivism, Smith argues, are always mixed and variable; on this basis, a larger discursive field, like Orientalism, could only be more so. This is not for a moment to deny the stigmatic power of othering; it is only to inquire as to how best it might be explained. For if Europeans did not see the same thing in the Pacific or, for that matter, the Indian Ocean, then neither did the French, English, Dutch or Spanish. And if there is no such thing as a single occidental vision, then there can hardly be any unified or essential discourse of Orientalism, either. The victims or their representatives also universalise, falsely. Smith's judgement of Said in his own sphere of competence follows directly from his premises: 'it would be false, surely, to conclude that the early visual imagery of the Pacific issuing from Cook's voyages is internally consistent in the way that characterises the orientalist imagery described by Said'. For Pacific peoples are rendered in sequence according to Oriental, classical and mannerist imagery and the beginnings of racialist-type imagery into the nineteenth century. But at the very least these portrayals alternate between images of bliss and purgatory and characterise local peoples accordingly. 'European imagery of the Pacific does possess a durable though contradictory inner consistency'.43 The truth is elusive and it is never simple. In this argument, as elsewhere in Smith's work, we sense an attraction to something like naturalism, or a certain kind of realism which resurfaces, especially in The Antipodean Manifesto. If for Smith, as for Forster, one of the weaknesses of moderns is their restlessness, so too then is their need for, or attraction to, abstraction. Modern culture, as Marx and later Simmel argued, is too abstract and cerebral. We think too much and we thus overinterpret that which may be less complex than it appears; we search endlessly for hidden meanings which may not be there, at least until they are projected out by us. Our weakness for grand explanatory categories or spray-ons like 'capitalism' or 'Orientalism' means that we eschew contradiction and obscure the patterns of contestation which often hold up these categorical hypostatisations. In other words,
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
abstraction eats up content, universalises falsely, and finally disables us. The truth, such as it is, is local and highly variable, specific to place, taste and circumstance, and then still is dependent on perspective. If we contest big bad categories we lose the game by submitting to its rules. We need to resist this will to power, both in intellectual and in institutional terms if we seek to tell the truth. To tell the truth, in turn, means owning up to contradiction and ambivalence. To argue in this way is also to indicate that morality is never straightforward. That was Karl Kraus' mistake; to stigmatise the two dominant evils as identical and juxtapose them to a third, imaginary option is to substitute wit for ethics and to reinsinuate the dualities which he originally set out to oppose. Thus Smith's final, personal judgement on Cook. Should we be for Cook, or against? or both? Cook, in his lifetime, had absorbed enough of the hopes and expectancies of the Enlightenment to become aware by his third voyage that his mission to the Pacific involved him in a profound and unresolvable contradiction. In order to treat native peoples in the enlightened way ... and in order to survive, he had to establish markets among people who possessed little if any notions of a market economy. The alternative was to use force from the beginning as the Spaniards and Portuguese had . . * Cook began contacts by gifting; but the year he sailed on his last voyage (1776) was also the year in which Adam Smith symbolically pitched the flag of free trade in The Wealth of Nations. So in the Pacific, for Smith, Cook had to play as best he could at being Adam Smith's god, acting out his hidden hand: 'The third voyage records not only his death but, before that, his loss of hope'.45 Cook was no hero, at least; Smith has no time for pretenders to the role, and nor, arguably, should we. For heroes, like gods or emperors, end up showing naked torsos, or frailties or feet of clay before the procession moves on. Nor can appeals to history save us, for they are appeals to misleading senses of certainty; we may perceive history as repetition, but it is always more than that, and the similarities we detect between our own moment and others are also inevitably imaginary.46 As I have suggested, Smith's work in the field of vision no more indicates the presence of a theory of vision than his enthusiasm for
87
88
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
history indicates a philosophy of history in the conventional sense. That kind of theory, implicitly or explicitly, works typically at the kind of level of a priori abstraction which Smith rejects. The point of his own analyses is rather that the nuance of difference emerges in particular stories, though they also combine or are associated by us when we think typically. In order to make sense of a general proposition, such as unequal cultural exchange, we need to enter a particular historical labyrinth. Smith is an historicist; his social theory only makes sense within the idea of history as particular moments in the larger civilisational flow. Seeing, then, is like naming, a way of organising the social world which obscures at the same time as it enables. Naming, classifying symbolically, organising the world by thinking is not, as some imagine, a mentality peculiar to moderns or a consequence of the Enlightenment. There is a good anthropological case to the contrary, as exemplified in the work of Levi-Strauss, that human beings cannot survive without classifying. As Levi-Strauss shows, most famously in his book on 'savage thinking', what looks illogical to European eyes is the result of the application of a different system of knowledge. Bees and pythons, for example, are placed by us into quite distinct classificatory categories, but other people associate them on the basis of colour.47 It was this kind of positive insight (as well as some more dubious attractions of rationalist prowess) that brought structuralism into prominence in France and then in English-speaking intellectual cultures. Signs, as Ferdinand de Saussure had suggested, were arbitrary; dogs barked with different voices in different European cultures. Names were, therefore, also arbitrary if symbolic of local context and meaning. History, then, as Smith understands it, has to be transcultural, and in this sense it is anthropological or civilisational. It cannot be internal to national culture because finally there is no such thing, except as an analytical convenience or an annexe of state power and its attendant projects of nation-building. As Freud had it, not least of all in his structuralist appropriation, this sense of the transcultural was vital because you could never presume that the truth of an object was in it, or nearby; it could be elsewhere, or meaning could emerge accidentally, arbitrarily, in sign or symptom as much as in deep analysis. Yet if we are historical beings, this also means that we are unmistakably modern, driven by modern obsessions as well as by the impulses of the human
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
condition. We learn in the process, even if the substance of our knowing remains opaque. As Smith put it in a lecture given in 1954, western art was characterised increasingly by its celebration of transience, its uncertainty, by doubt rather than absolutes; like much else in modern history it was Janus-faced, its claim to certainty also revealing its very fragility in transience. 'Western art', he wrote, 'has tended to be expressive and restless rather than harmonious and peaceful and in these conditions its greatest masterpieces have not only recognised but also celebrated the transience of man and nature'.48 Western art thus constantly reverts, returns to the theme of restlessness; but this also marks its achievement: 'It has been in the recognition, the artistic acceptance and the celebration of the insubstantial pageant [of modern life] that the central achievement of western art lies'.49 IMAGINING THE OTHER Cook was no hero but a significant actor in the insubstantial pageant of modern history. Smith did not take sides with Cook, or with the British against the Aborigine. The purpose of his work on Cook is to seek better to place and provisionally to explain him. For Smith at the same time sought to place and explain the oppression and survival of Australian Aborigines. His most important text here is the public lecture series of 1980, the ABC Boyer Lectures which he entitled The Spectre of Truganini. Cook had imagined or envisioned the Tahitians as soft primitives, primitives of ease and abundance. Cook more admired the people he cast as hard primitives, those living the apparently austere lives of the Australian Aborigines. The extermination and brutalisation of these peoples resulted less from his own initiative than it flowed from the efforts of Banks; it was Banks who had argued in London for colonisation. The results of the process of occupation were undeniable, and much denied. This was the terrain upon which Smith's Boyer Lectures worked. They anticipated the discourse of reconciliation, not least of all in their call not for cultural assimilation but cultural convergence. They anticipate something of the spirit of the debate after Mabo. Smith set out to ask the same kinds of questions as he had in European Vision: not only how did European civilisation impact upon Aborigines, but also, how did their culture affect that of the invaders? What effects would the answers to questions such as these have upon
89
90
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
the received images of Australian cultural history? Smith slid into the problem through Marx's metaphor of ghosting, this time in the Communist Manifesto: 'It seems to me that a spectre has haunted Australian culture, the spectre of Truganini'. The cliche of modern nation-building is that nations are founded in blood, in war, revolution in 1789 or 1917, Gallipoli in 1915. Smith reminds us that in 1876 there ended another Australian war; it was the only war that, unaided, white Australians could claim, one-sidedly, to have won completely. It was the war against Tasmanian Aborigines.50 Culture rests on power, increasingly with the passing of modern time on the violence of state power. Civilisations rise and fall, transhistorically, but some are pushed. State power rests on violence, and not only on claims to culture or legitimacy. Imperialism cannot exist without violence. This was the moment in which modern Australia was founded, from 1788 to 1876. Bad enough that it should happen, but then to deny it? For what Aboriginal peoples have had to remember, white Australians have tried to forget: Indeed at times it would seem as if all the culture of old Europe were being brought to bear upon our writers and artists in order to blot from their memories the crimes perpetrated upon Australia's first inhabitants. In recent years, however, both sides, black and white alike, have become increasingly aware of the continuing colonial crime, the locked cupboard of our history. It is this new awareness of what actually occurred that, it seems to me, constitutes a central problem for the integrity and authenticity of Australian culture today.31
The locked cupboard of our history - the awful secret that we know about but which we render invisible, so that it comes back to haunt us - this metaphor points to a possible resolution, and not only to the horrible deed of matricide. As Smith suggests in his lectures, a possible way forward is to begin to again link arguments concerning culture, place and morality. Post-Christian though we may be, notions of ethics and morality nevertheless persist in underpinning our ways of life. The foundational myths for white Australians may be Federation or Gallipoli, but they are also formed by images which come from classical Greece and from the Bible. They refer not only to ideas of unity or dedication, but also to values such as democracy and justice. Thus,
I M A G I N I N G
T H E PACIFIC
Smith uses civilisational categories to indicate that whatever has been, once recognised, can also be improved upon by us. Marxism, with which Smith publicly identified as Boyer lecturer, of course, partakes of both those earlier European points of orientation, biblical and Hellenic. Whatever weight we ascribe to forces of an economic or technological kind, then, Smith nevertheless wants to insist that it is nevertheless primarily culture which holds us together. Ethical systems, in particular, play this kind of role, generating solidarity over conflict.52 Apart from the Aboriginal component, which developed its own ethical systems from an intimate association with the environment over thirty thousand years or more, ours is an ethically dependent culture as well as an aesthetically dependent one: 'We brought our moral values with us in, so to speak, our travelling trunks; but when tested at the frontiers of Australian experience . . . they have become more often than not seriously affected. Australian morality is a history of damaged goods'53 says Smith, quoting Margaret Kiddle. The metaphors twist and turn, the damaged goods of universalistic humanist ethics applied selectively to white men only, the travelling trunks and cupboards locked, holding ghosts and secrets that take their revenge on us as well. Smith suggests in his lectures that white Australians did generate at least one peculiar or notable ethical sensibility, that which we refer to as mateship. A radical mythology, begot of rural nomadology, the aura of bush workers and the Bulletin, the local ethic of mateship is, like egalitarianism, selective in its application. You couldn't, in that period, have a Chinaman or a woman for a mate. As always, Smith's interpretation of white Australian civilisation seeks out the balance; what we today inherit from the struggles of the previous fin-de-siecle is irreversibly mixed, a source simultaneously of pride and shame. Inclusive in some ways, it was, and is still, also exclusive. The themes Smith labours here are reminiscent of a pathbreaking book like Humphrey McQueen's seventies missile A New Britannia, but they also extend on the sense of discomfort and ambivalence characteristic of an earlier benchmark work such as Donald Home's The Lucky Country. The whole point about white Australian civilisation, in this account, is that whatever its claims to being exceptional it also embodies the story of modernity and perhaps something of that of the human condition more generally. Its achievements are deeply and irredeemably
91
92
I M A G I N I N G
T H E ANTIPODES
ambivalent; every achievement won in the social laboratory seems to carry with it some other affront or brutality. Smith's conclusion is blunt: The greatest weakness of the mateship ethic' in the context of his discussion 'was that it did not include the Australian Aborigine'.54 The earlier myth of the noble savage was supplanted by the aesthetic and ethical image of the ignoble savage; ignobility carried with it, by extension, the licence to kill, for these were allegedly now a doomed people, doomed because thought to be captured within primitivity, incapable of innovation, caught in their own unchangeable rituals and myths. This kind of social Darwinism dominated cultural attitudes from around 1870 into the 1920s and beyond. Difference, here, was made into something pernicious, punishable by death. Social Darwinism erected an almost impenetrable barrier between the deep spirituality of Aboriginal culture and the materialism of white Australian culture. The problem was less in the idea of a universalistic western humanism than its partial and violent application. None of this, however, could even begin to be registered in a dominant culture based upon denial. In this regard, at least, Smith drew a parallel between the formation of individual subjects and the path of national development. Genocide, for most white Australians, was a nightmare to be thrust out of the foreground of the mind. Yet like most traumatic experiences of childhood it persists, in some form or another. He quoted Freud: It is universally admitted that in the origin of the traditions and folklore of a people, care must be taken to eliminate from the memory such a motive as would be painful to the national feeling'.55 Smith's analysis thus anticipated the increasing western intellectual fascination with problems of memory and forgetting; but his precedents were older, because the ideas were. Freud, and in different ways other thinkers like Durkheim and Renan, had already puzzled over these questions of constructing meaning out of tradition, including and excluding symbols from an already existing cultural repertoire. Our fate, in Australia, was to cop events like Federation or Gallipoli as national monuments; other local traditions such as wifebeating or shooting Aborigines were spirited away symbolically, at least within the field established by the national super-ego. Then Smith turned to Cook; he keeps returning in Smith's work on the Pacific. Cook was possessed of the humanist ethics of the Enlightenment; if this were insufficient, he had detailed advice from
IMAGINING
T H E PACIFIC
the President of the Royal Society to go placidly amongst Pacific peoples. Cook was advised that: shedding the blood of these people is a crime of the highest nature. They are the natural, and in the strictest sense of the word, the legal possessors of the several Regions they inhabit. No European Nation has a right to occupy any part of their country, or settle among them without their voluntary consent. Conquest over such people can give no just title; because they can never be Aggressors.56 Cook transgressed; he took visitation for possession. Smith's point was simple but powerful. It was not in the centre but on the periphery that the Enlightenment began its local process of degeneration. The wisdom of the centre came unravelled on its edge; cultural traffic ran uphill. This was an issue of frontiers, understood as confronting cultural horizons rather than as geographical fictions. Cook chose to force the issue, to take the law into his own hands when he thought that he could get away with it. In Australia, at least, he took no lives; as Smith reminds, Cook held, or claims to have held, Aborigines in high esteem. Cook viewed Aborigines as noble savages indeed, with both terms under emphasis; they were free of the pestilential breath of western civilisation and of all its encumbrances. They lived in perpetual peace (so far) and without the blight of inequality: until Cook's followers arrived to construct them out of the landscape, aesthetically and practically. The new, local Utopia emerged together with the work of the Heidelberg School and its sun-kissed arcadia relieved of Aboriginal blemish. Smith traces in pencil sketch the period significance of Nietzsche, not least of all via Norman Lindsay. Lindsay's influence took in the idea of mental, rather than physiological evolution; survival of the fittest led to the creation of mental supermen, a mateship of the elect which could claim a certain kind of white primitivism at the expense of Aboriginal Australians. Yet at the same moment that some leading white Australian intellectuals were avoiding the issue, the centres were returning to it, in the work of Engels, Spencer and Gillen, Frazer, Freud and Durkheim. Not that the curiosity coming out of the centres was innocent, either; but at the very least it was timely. As Smith understood, moderns would become romantics, seize at their
93
94
IMAGINING
T H E ANTIPODES
own notion of the primitive when threatened or ill-at-ease with their world; and so the new moderns, entering the twentieth century, would also discover the other from their own points of vantage and advantage. He did not name it here, or refer to the text, but Smith seems to be writing out of Hegel's image in The Phenomenology of Mind: master and slave, how they entrap each other in evane