hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page i 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Global Business Today
hiL1...
17 downloads
881 Views
22MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page i 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Global Business Today
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page ii 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page iii 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
fifth edition
Global Business Today Charles W. L. Hill University of Washington
Boston Burr Ridge, IL Dubuque, IA Madison, WI New York San Francisco St. Louis Bangkok Bogotá Caracas Kuala Lumpur Lisbon London Madrid Mexico City Milan Montreal New Delhi Santiago Seoul Singapore Sydney Taipei Toronto
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page iv 1/22/07 9:41:01 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
GLOBAL BUSINESS TODAY Published by McGraw-Hill/Irwin, a business unit of The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 1221 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY, 10020. Copyright © 2008 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior written consent of The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., including, but not limited to, in any network or other electronic storage or transmission, or broadcast for distance learning. Some ancillaries, including electronic and print components, may not be available to customers outside the United States. This book is printed on acid-free paper. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 DOW/DOW 0 9 8 7 ISBN 978-0-07-321054-4 MHID 0-07-321054-4 Editorial director: John E. Biernat Development editor I : Kirsten Guidero Associate marketing manager : Margaret A. Beamer Media producer: Lynn Bluhm Project manager: Jim Labeots Senior production spervisor: Carol Bielski Senior designer: Kami Carter Photo research coordinator: Kathy Shive Photo researcher: Teri Stratford Senior media project manager: Susan Lombardi Cover design: Mary Kazak Interior design: Mary Kazak Typeface: 10/12 Janson Text Roman Compositor: Techbooks Printer: R. R. Donnelley Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Hill, Charles W. L. Global business today / Charles W. L. Hill. — 5th ed. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN-13: 978-0-07-321054-4 (alk. paper) ISBN-10: 0-07-321054-4 (alk. paper) 1. International business enterprises—Management. 2. International trade. 3. Investments, Foreign. 4. Capital market. I. Title. HD62.4.H548 2008 658⬘.049—dc22 2006100722
www.mhhe.com
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page v 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
r Fo
J
e un
and
Mike Hill, my pa
ren
ts
v
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page vi 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
about the author Charles W. L. Hill is the Hughes M. Blake Professor of International Business at the School of Business, University of Washington. Professor Hill received his PhD in industrial organization economics in 1983 from the University of Manchester’s Institute of Science and Technology (UMIST) in Great Britain. In addition to his position at the University of Washington, he has served on the faculties of UMIST, Texas A&M University, and Michigan State University. Professor Hill has published more than 40 articles in peer-reviewed academic journals. He has also published four college textbooks, one on strategic management, one on principles of management, and the other two on international business (one of which you are now holding). He serves on the editorial boards of several academic journals and previously served as consulting editor at the Academy of Management Review. Professor Hill teaches in the MBA and executive MBA programs at the University of Washington and has received awards for teaching excellence in both programs. He has also taught in several customized executive programs. He lives in Seattle with his wife Lane and children.
vi
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page i 1/11/07 8:11:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Global Business Today
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page vii 1/11/07 8:11:06 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
brief contents PREFACE
xv
PART ONE
Introduction and Overview 2 Chapter One
PART TWO
Globalization 3
Country Differences 40 Chapter Two
National Differences in Political Economy 41
Chapter Three
Differences in Culture 87
Chapter Four
Ethics in International Business 123
PART THREE Cross-Border Trade and Investment 154
PART FOUR
PART FIVE
Chapter Five
International Trade Theory 155
Chapter Six
The Political Economy of International Trade 191
Chapter Seven
Foreign Director Investment 227
Chapter Eight
Regional Economic Integration 261
Global Money System 294 Chapter Nine
The Foreign Exchange Market 295
Chapter Ten
The International Monetary System 325
Competing in a Global Marketplace 358 Chapter Eleven
The Strategy of International Business 359
Chapter Twelve
Entering Foreign Markets 397
Chapter Thirteen
Exporting, Importing, and Countertrade 423
Chapter Fourteen
Global Production, Outsourcing, and Logistics 445
Chapter Fifteen
Global Marketing and R&D 473
Chapter Sixteen
Global Human Resource Management 507
GLOSSARY
534
ENDNOTES
543
INDEX
569 vii
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page viii 1/11/07 8:11:06 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
contents PREFACE xv PART ONE
PART TWO Chapter Two
Introduction and Overview 2
Chapter One Globalization 3 Opening Case: IKEA—The Global Retailer 3 Introduction 4 What Is Globalization? 7 The Globalization of Markets 7 The Globalization of Production 8 The Emergence of Global Institutions 9 Drivers of Globalization 11 Declining Trade and Investment Barriers 11 The Role of Technological Change 14 The Changing Demographics of the Global Economy 18 The Changing World Output and World Trade Picture 18 The Changing Foreign Direct Investment Picture 19 The Changing Nature of the Multinational Enterprise 21 The Changing World Order 23 The Global Economy of the Twenty-First Century 25 The Globalization Debate 26 Antiglobalization Protests 26 Globalization, Jobs, and Income 27 Globalization, Labor Policies, and the Environment 30 Globalization and National Sovereignty 32 Globalization and the World’s Poor 32 Managing in the Global Marketplace 34 Key Terms 36 Summary 36 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 37 Research Task 38 Closing Case: The Globalization of Health Care 38 viii
Country Differences 40 National Differences in Political Economy 41 Opening Case: Chavez’s Venezuela 41 Introduction 42 Political Systems 43 Collectivism and Individualism 43 Democracy and Totalitarianism 46 Economic Systems 48 Market Economy 48 Command Economy 49 Mixed Economy 50 Legal Systems 50 Different Legal Systems 50 Differences in Contract Law 52 Property Rights and Corruption 52 The Protection of Intellectual Property 56 Product Safety and Product Liability 58 The Determinants of Economic Development 59 Differences in Economic Development 59 Broader Conceptions of Development: Amartya Sen 61 Political Economy and Economic Progress 64 Geography, Education, and Economic Development 68 States in Transition 69 The Spread of Democracy 69 The New World Order and Global Terrorism 71 The Spread of Market-Based Systems 72 The Nature of Economic Transformation 73 Implications of Changing Political Economy 77 Focus on Managerial Implications 78 Key Terms 82
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page ix 1/11/07 8:11:06 PM elhi
Summary 82 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 83 Research Task 84 Closing Case: Indonesia—The Troubled Giant 84 Chapter Three Differences in Culture 87 Opening Case: DMG-Shanghai 87 Introduction 88 What Is Culture? 89 Values and Norms 90 Culture, Society, and the Nation-State 91 The Determinants of Culture 92 Social Structure 93 Individuals and Groups 93 Social Stratification 95 Religious and Ethical Systems 98 Christianity 98 Islam 100 Hinduism 104 Buddhism 106 Confucianism 106 Language 108 Spoken Language 108 Unspoken Language 109 Education 109 Culture and the Workplace 110 Cultural Change 113 Focus on Managerial Implications 115 Key Terms 119 Summary 119 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 120 Research Task 120 Closing Case: Matsushita’s Culture Changes with Japan 120 Chapter Four
Ethics in International Business 123 Opening Case: Oil for Bribes 123 Introduction 124 Ethical Issues in International Business 125 Employment Practices 125 Human Rights 126 Environmental Pollution 128 Corruption 129 Moral Obligations 131 Ethical Dilemmas 133
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
The Roots of Unethical Behavior 134 Personal Ethics 134 Decision-Making Processes 135 Organization Culture 135 Unrealistic Performance Expectations 136 Leadership 136 Philosophical Approaches to Ethics 138 Straw Men 138 Utilitarian and Kantian Ethics 141 Rights Theories 142 Justice Theories 143 Focus on Managerial Implications 144 Key Terms 150 Summary 150 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 151 Research Task 152 Closing Case: Mired in Corruption—Kellogg, Brown and Root in Nigeria 152 PART THREE
Cross-Border Trade and Investment 154
Chapter Five
International Trade Theory 155 Opening Case: International Trade in Information Technology and U.S. Economic Growth 155 Introduction 156 An Overview of Free Trade 157 The Benefits of Trade 157 The Pattern of International Trade 158 Trade Theory and Government Policy 159 Mercantilism 159 Absolute Advantage 161 Comparative Advantage 162 The Gains from Trade 164 Qualifications and Assumptions 165 Extensions of the Ricardian Model 166 Heckscher-Ohlin Theory 170 The Leontief Paradox 171 The Product Life-Cycle Theory 172 Evaluating the Product Life-Cycle Theory 173 New Trade Theory 175 Increasing Product Variety and Reducing Costs 175 Economies of Scale, First-Mover Advantages, and the Pattern of Trade 176 Implications of New Trade Theory 177 Contents
ix
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page x 1/11/07 8:11:06 PM elhi
National Competitive Advantage: Porter’s Diamond 178 Factor Endowments 179 Demand Conditions 180 Related and Supported Industries 180 Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry 181 Evaluating Porter’s Theory 181 Focus on Managerial Implications 183 Key Terms 185 Summary 186 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 187 Research Task 187 Closing Case: Logitech 188 Chapter Six
The Political Economy of International Trade 191 Opening Case: Boeing, Airbus, and the World Trade Organization 191 Introduction 192 Instruments of Trade Policy 194 Tariffs 194 Subsidies 195 Import Quotas and Voluntary Export Restraints 196 Local Content Requirements 198 Administrative Policies 198 Antidumping Duties 199 The Case for Government Intervention 200 Political Arguments for Intervention 201 Economic Arguments for Intervention 204 The Revised Case for Free Trade 207 Retaliation and Trade War 207 Domestic Policies 208 Development of the World Trading System 208 From Smith to the Great Depression 208 1947–1979: GATT, Trade Liberalization, and Economic Growth 209 1980–1993: Protectionist Trends 210 The Uruguay Round and the World Trade Organization 210 WTO: Experience to Date 212 The Future of the WTO: Unresolved Issues and the Doha Round 215 Focus on Managerial Implications 220 Key Terms 222 Summary 223 x
Contents
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 224 Research Task 224 Closing Case: Trade in Textiles—Holding the Chinese Juggernaut in Check 224 Chapter Seven
Foreign Direct Investment 227 Opening Case: Starbucks’ Foreign Direct Investment 227 Introduction 229 Foreign Direct Investment in the World Economy 229 Trends in FDI 229 The Direction of FDI 230 The Source of FDI 233 The Form of FDI: Acquisitions versus Greenfield Investments 234 The Shift to Services 235 Theories of Foreign Direct Investment 235 Why Foreign Direct Investment? 236 The Pattern of Foreign Direct Investment 238 The Eclectic Paradigm 239 Political Ideology and Foreign Direct Investment 241 The Radical View 241 The Free Market View 242 Pragmatic Nationalism 242 Shifting Ideology 243 Benefits and Costs of FDI 244 Host-Country Benefits 245 Host-Country Costs 248 Home-Country Benefits 249 Home-Country Costs 249 International Trade Theory and FDI 250 Government Policy Instruments and FDI 250 Home-Country Policies 250 Host-Country Policies 251 International Institutions and the Liberalization of FDI 253 Focus on Managerial Implications 254 Key Terms 256 Summary 257 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 257 Research Task 258 Closing Case: Cemex’s Foreign Direct Investment 258
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xi 1/11/07 8:11:06 PM elhi
Chapter Eight
Regional Economic Integration 261 Opening Case: NAFTA and the U.S. Textile Industry 261 Introduction 262 Levels of Economic Integration 264 The Case for Regional Integration 265 The Economic Case for Integration 265 The Political Case for Integration 266 Impediments to Integration 267 The Case against Regional Integration 267 Regional Economic Integration in Europe 268 Evolution of the European Union 268 Political Structure of the European Union 269 The Single European Act 272 The Establishment of the Euro 274 Enlargement of the European Union 277 Regional Economic Integration in the Americas 278 The North American Free Trade Agreement 279 The Andean Community 282 MERCOSUR 282 Central American Common Market, CAFTA, and CARICOM 283 Free Trade Area of the Americas 284 Regional Economic Integration Elsewhere 285 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 285 Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation 285 Regional Trade Blocs in Africa 287 Focus on Managerial Implications 288 Key Terms 290 Summary 290 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 291 Research Task 292 Closing Case: Car Price Differentials in the European Union 292 PART FOUR Chapter Nine
Global Money System 294
The Foreign Exchange Market 295 Opening Case: The Curse of the Strong Dollar at STMicro 295 Introduction 296
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
The Functions of the Foreign Exchange Market 297 Currency Conversion 297 Insuring against Foreign Exchange Risk 299 The Nature of the Foreign Exchange Market 302 Economic Theories of Exchange Rate Determination 303 Prices and Exchange Rates 304 Interest Rates and Exchange Rates 310 Investor Psychology and Bandwagon Effects 311 Summary 311 Exchange Rate Forecasting 313 The Efficient Market School 313 The Inefficient Market School 314 Approaches to Forecasting 314 Currency Convertibility 315 Focus on Managerial Implications 317 Key Terms 320 Summary 321 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 322 Research Task 322 Closing Case: The Rising Euro Hammers Auto Parts Manufacturers 323 Chapter Ten
The International Monetary System 325 Opening Case: China’s Managed Float 325 Introduction 326 The Gold Standard 328 Mechanics of the Gold Standard 328 Strength of the Gold Standard 328 The Period between the Wars: 1918–1939 329 The Bretton Woods System 330 The Role of the IMF 331 The Role of the World Bank 332 The Collapse of the Fixed Exchange Rate System 332 The Floating Exchange Rate Regime 334 The Jamaica Agreement 334 Exchange Rates since 1973 334 Fixed versus Floating Exchange Rates 337 The Case for Floating Exchange Rates 337 The Case for Fixed Exchange Rates 338 Who Is Right? 339 Contents
xi
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xii 1/11/07 8:11:06 PM elhi
Exchange Rate Regimes in Practice 339 Pegged Exchange Rates 340 Currency Boards 341 Crisis Management by the IMF 341 Financial Crises in the Post–Bretton Woods Era 342 Mexican Currency Crisis of 1995 343 The Asian Crisis 344 Evaluating the IMF’s Policy Prescriptions 348 Focus on Managerial Implications 352 Key Terms 354 Summary 354 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 355 Research Task 356 Closing Case: Recycling Petrodollars 356 PART FIVE Chapter Eleven
Competing in the Global Marketplace 358
The Strategy of International Business 359 Opening Case: MTV’s Global Strategy 359 Introduction 361 Strategy and the Firm 361 Value Creation 362 Strategic Positioning 363 Operations: The Firm as a Value Chain 365 Organization: The Implementation of Strategy 367 In Sum: Strategic Fit 369 Global Expansion, Profitability, and Profit Growth 370 Expanding the Market: Leveraging Products and Competencies 370 Location Economies 371 Experience Effects 373 Leveraging Subsidiary Skills 376 Summary 377 Cost Pressures and Pressures for Local Responsiveness 377 Pressures for Cost Reductions 378 Pressures for Local Responsiveness 378 Choosing a Strategy 381 Global Standardization Strategy 381 Localization Strategy 382 Transnational Strategy 383 xii
Contents
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
International Strategy 384 The Evolution of Strategy 385 Strategic Alliances 387 The Advantages of Strategic Alliances 387 The Disadvantages of Strategic Alliances 388 Making Alliances Work 389 Key Terms 392 Summary 392 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 393 Research Task 394 Closing Case: Wal-Mart’s Global Expansion 394 Chapter Twelve
Entering Foreign Markets 397 Opening Case: JCB in India 397 Introduction 398 Basic Entry Decisions 399 Which Foreign Markets? 399 Timing of Entry 400 Scale of Entry and Strategic Commitments 401 Summary 403 Entry Modes 405 Exporting 405 Turnkey Projects 406 Licensing 407 Franchising 408 Joint Ventures 409 Wholly Owned Subsidiaries 411 Selecting an Entry Mode 412 Core Competencies and Entry Mode 412 Pressures for Cost Reductions and Entry Mode 413 Greenfield venture versus Acquisition 414 Pros and Cons of Acquisitions 414 Pros and Cons of Greenfield Ventures 417 Greenfield or Acquisition? 417 Key Terms 418 Summary 418 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 419 Research Task 420 Closing Case: Tesco Goes Global 420 Chapter Thirteen
Exporting, Importing, and Countertrade 423 Opening Case: FCX Systems 423 Introduction 424
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xiii 1/11/07 8:11:07 PM elhi
The Promise and Pitfalls of Exporting 425 Improving Export Performance 426 An International Comparison 427 Information Sources 427 Utilizing Export Management Companies 429 Export Strategy 429 Export and Import Financing 431 Lack of Trust 432 Letter of Credit 433 Draft 434 Bill of Lading 435 A Typical International Trade Transaction 435 Export Assistance 436 Export–Import Bank 437 Export Credit Insurance 437 Countertrade 438 The Incidence of Countertrade 438 Types of Countertrade 439 The Pros and Cons of Countertrade 440 Key Terms 441 Summary 441 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 442 Research Task 442 Closing Case: Megahertz Communications 443 Chapter Fourteen
Global Production, Outsourcing, and Logistics 445
Opening Case: Li & Fung 445 Introduction 446 Strategy, Production, and Logistics 447 Where to Produce 450 Country Factors 450 Technological Factors 452 Product Factors 455 Locating Production Facilities 456 The Strategic Role of Foreign Factories 457 Outsourcing Production: Make-or-Buy Decisions 460 The Advantages of Make 460 The Advantages of Buy 462 Trade-Offs 465 Strategic Alliances with Suppliers 465
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Managing a Global Supply Chain 466 The Role of Just-in-Time Inventory 466 The Role of Information Technology and the Internet 467 Key Terms 468 Summary 468 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 469 Research Task 469 Closing Case: Microsoft—Outsourcing Xbox Production 470 Chapter Fifteen
Global Marketing and R&D 473 Opening Case: Levi Strauss Goes Local 473 Introduction 474 The Globalization of Markets and Brands 475 Market Segmentation 477 Product Attributes 479 Cultural Differences 479 Economic Development 480 Product and Technical Standards 480 Distribution Strategy 480 Differences between Countries 481 Choosing a Distribution Strategy 483 Communication Strategy 484 Barriers to International Communication 484 Push versus Pull Strategies 487 Global Advertising 490 Pricing Strategy 491 Price Discrimination 491 Strategic Pricing 493 Regulatory Influences on Prices 494 Configuring the Marketing Mix 495 New-Product Development 496 The Location of R&D 497 Integrating R&D, Marketing, and Production 499 Cross-Functional Teams 500 Building Global R&D Capabilities 501 Key Terms 502 Summary 502 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 503 Research Task 504 Closing Case: Kodak in Russia 505 Contents
xiii
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xiv 1/11/07 8:11:07 PM elhi
Chapter Sixteen
Global Human Resource Management 507 Opening Case: XCO China 507 Introduction 509 The Strategic Role of International HRM 510 Staffing Policy 511 Types of Staffing Policy 512 Expatriate Managers 515 Training and Management Development 519 Training for Expatriate Managers 520 Repatriation of Expatriates 521 Management Development and Strategy 522 Performance Appraisal 523 Performance Appraisal Problems 523 Guidelines for Performance Appraisal 524 Compensation 524 National Differences in Compensation 524 Expatriate Pay 525
xiv
Contents
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
International Labor Relations 527 The Concerns of Organized Labor 527 The Strategy of Organized Labor 528 Approaches to Labor Relations 529 Key Terms 530 Summary 530 Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 531 Research Task 531 Closing Case: Molex 532 GLOSSARY 534 ENDNOTES 543 INDEX 569
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xv 1/11/07 8:11:07 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
preface Global Business Today is intended for the first international business course at either the undergraduate or MBA level. My goal in writing this book has been to set a new standard for international business textbooks. I have attempted to write a book that 1. Is comprehensive and up-to-date. 2. Goes beyond an uncritical presentation and shallow explanation of the body of knowledge. 3. Maintains a tight, integrated flow between chapters. 4. Focuses on managerial implications. 5. Makes important theories accessible and interesting to students. 6. Incorporates ancillary resources that enliven the text and make it easier to teach. Over the years, and through now five editions, I have worked hard to adhere to these goals. It has not always been easy. An enormous amount has happened over the last decade, both in the real world of economics, politics, and business, and in the academic world of theory and empirical research. Often I have had to significantly rewrite chapters, scrap old examples, bring in new ones, incorporate new theory and evidence into the book, and phase out older theories that are increasingly less relevant to the modern and dynamic world of international business. That process continues in the current edition. As noted below, there have been significant changes in this edition, and that will no doubt continue to be the case in the future. In deciding what changes to make, I have been guided not only by my own reading, teaching, and research, but also by the invaluable feedback I receive from professors and students around the world who use the book, from reviewers, and from the editorial staff at McGraw-Hill/Irwin. My thanks go out to all of them.
Comprehensive and Up-to-Date To be comprehensive, an international business textbook must • Explain how and why the world’s countries differ. • Present a thorough review of the economics and politics of international trade and investment. • Explain the functions and form of the global monetary system. • Examine the strategies and structures of international businesses. • Assess the special roles of an international business’s various functions. I have always endeavored to do all of these things. Too many other texts have paid insufficient attention to the strategies and structures of international businesses and to the implications of international business for firms’ various functions. This omission has been a serious deficiency. Many of the students in these international business courses will soon be working in international businesses, and they will be expected to understand the implications of international business for their organization’s strategy, structure, and functions. This book pays close attention to these issues. xv
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xvi 1/22/07 9:41:02 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Comprehensiveness and relevance also require coverage of the major theories. It has always been my goal to incorporate the insights gleaned from recent academic work into the text. Consistent with this goal, over the last four editions I have added insights from the following research: • The new trade theory and strategic trade policy. • The work of Nobel Prize–winning economist Amartya Sen on economic development. • The work of Hernando de Soto on the link between property rights and economic development. • Samuel Huntington’s influential thesis on the “clash of civilizations.” • The new growth theory of economic development championed by Paul Romer and Gene Grossman. • Empirical work by Jeffery Sachs and others on the relationship between international trade and economic growth. • Michael Porter’s theory of the competitive advantage of nations. • Robert Reich’s work on national competitive advantage. • The work of Nobel Prize–winner Douglas North and others on national institutional structures and the protection of property rights. • The market imperfections approach to foreign direct investment that has grown out of Ronald Coase and Oliver Williamson’s work on transaction cost economics. • Bartlett and Ghoshal’s research on the transnational corporation. • The writings of C. K. Prahalad and Gary Hamel on core competencies, global competition, and global strategic alliances. • Insights for international business strategy that can be derived from the resourcebased view of the firm. In addition to including leading-edge theory, in light of the fast-changing nature of the international business environment, I have made every effort to ensure that the book was as up-to-date as possible when it went to press. A significant amount has happened in the world since I first began work on this book. The Uruguay Round of GATT negotiations were successfully concluded and the World Trade Organization was established. In 2001, the WTO embarked upon another major round of talks aimed to reduce barriers to trader, the Doha Round. The European Union moved forward with its post-1992 agenda to achieve a closer economic and monetary union, including the establishment of a common currency in January 1999. The North American Free Trade Agreement passed into law, and Chile indicated its desire to become the next member of the free trade area. The Asian Pacific Economic Cooperation forum emerged as the kernel of a possible future Asia Pacific free trade area. The former Communist states of Eastern Europe and Asia continued on the road to economic and political reform. As they did, the euphoric mood that followed the collapse of communism in 1989 was slowly replaced with a growing sense of realism about the hard path ahead for many of these countries. The global money market continued its meteoric growth. By 2006, more than $1.5 trillion per day was flowing across national borders. The size of such flows fueled concern about the ability of short-term speculative shifts in global capital markets to destabilize the world economy. The World Wide Web emerged from nowhere to become the backbone of an emerging global network for electronic commerce. The world continued to become more global. Several Asian Pacific economies, most notably China, continued to grow their economies at a rapid rate. Outsourcing of service functions to places like China and India emerged as a major issue in developed Western nations. New multinationals continued to emerge from developing nations in addition to the world’s established industrial powers. Increasingly, the globalization of the world economy affected a wide range of firms of all sizes, from the very large to the xvi
Preface
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xvii 1/22/07 9:41:03 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
very small. And unfortunately, in the wake of the terrorist attacks on the United States that took place on September 11, 2001, global terrorism and the attendant geopolitical risks emerged as a threat to global economic integration and activity. To reflect this rapid change, in this edition of the book I have tried to ensure that all material and statistics are as up-to-date as possible as of 2006.
What’s New in the Fifth Edition The success of the first four editions of Global Business Today was based in part upon the incorporation of leading-edge research into the text, the use of the up-to-date examples and statistics to illustrate global trends and enterprise strategy, and the discussion of current events within the context of the appropriate theory. Building on these strengths, my goals for the fifth revision have been threefold: 1. Incorporate new insights from recent scholarly research wherever appropriate. 2. Make sure the content of the text covers all appropriate issues. 3. Make sure the text is as up-to-date as possible with regard to current events, statistics, and examples. As part of the overall reviA New Round of Talks: Doha Antidumping actions, trade in agricultural sion process, changes have been products, better enforcement of intellectual property laws, and expanded market access were four of the issues the WTO wanted to tackle at the 1999 meetings in made to every chapter in the book. Seattle, but those meetings were derailed. In late 2001, the WTO tried again to launch All statistics have been updated a new round of talks between member states aimed at further liberalizing the global trade and investment framework. For this meeting, it picked the remote location of to incorporate the most re- Doha in the Persian Gulf state of Qatar, no doubt with an eye on the difficulties that protesters would have in getting there. Unlike the Seattle meetings, cently available data. New ex- antiglobalization at Doha, the member states of the WTO agreed to launch a new round of talks and amples, cases, and boxes have staked out an agenda. The talks were originally scheduled to last three years, although they have already gone on longer and may not be concluded for a while. been added and older examples updated to reflect new developments. New material has been inserted wherever appropriate to reflect recent academic work or important current events. See below for three primary examples.
Chapter 6 has been updated to discuss progress on the current round of talks sponsored by the WTO aimed at reducing barriers to trade, particularly in agriculture (the Doha Round). See pages 215–220 for the rest of this section.
TRENDS IN FDI The past 30 years have seen a marked increase in both the flow and stock of FDI in the world economy. The average yearly outflow of FDI increased from $25 billion in 1975 to a record $1.2 trillion in 2000, before falling back to an estimated $897 billion in 2005 (see Figure 7.1).2 Over this period, the flow of FDI accelerated faster than the growth in world trade and world output. For example, between 1992 and 2005, the total flow of FDI from all countries increased more than fivefold while world trade by value grew by some 140 percent and world output by around 40 percent.3 As a result of the strong FDI flow, by 2004 the global stock of FDI exceededhiL10544_ch06_190-225.indd $9 trillion. At least21970,000 parent companies had 690,000 affiliates in foreign markets that collectively employed more than 50 million people abroad and generated value accounting for about one-tenth of global GDP. The foreign affiliates of multinationals had an estimated $19 trillion in global sales, much higher than the value of global exports, which stood at close to $11 trillion.4
Chapter 7 now includes updated statistics on trends in foreign direct investment flows that took place in the 2001–04 period. See pages 229–230 for the rest of this section.
Additionally, at several places in the book, there is extended discussion of the outsourcing of service activities, from software testing and diagnosis of MRI scans to telephone call centers and billing functions, to developing nations such as India. The implications of this development for international business are explored. hiL10544_ch07_226-259.indd 229
ENLARGEMENT OF THE EUROPEAN UNION A major issue facing the EU over the past few years has been that of enlargement. Enlargement of the EU into Eastern Europe has been a possibility since the collapse of communism at the end of the 1980s, and by the end of the 1990s, 13 countries had applied to become EU members. To qualify for EU membership, the applicants had to privatize state assets, deregulate markets, restructure industries, and tame inflation. They also had to incorporate complex EU laws into their own systems, establish stable democratic governments, and respect human rights.18 In December 2002, the EU formally agreed to accept the applications of 10 countries, and they joined on May 1, 2004. The new members include the Baltic countries, the Czech Republic, and the larger nations of Hungary and Poland. The only 12/12/06 10:28:24 AM new members not in Eastern Europe are the Mediterranean island nations of Malta and Cyprus. Their inclusion in the EU expanded the union to 25 states, stretching from the Atlantic to the borders of Russia; added 23 percent to the landmass of the EU; brought 75 million new citizens into the EU, building an EU with a population of 450 million people; and created a single continental economy with a GDP of close to €11 trillion.
12/12/06 6:34:13 PM
The section on the European Union in Chapter 8 has been revised to reflect the fact that 10 more member states were admitted on May 1, 2004. See page 277 for the rest of this section.
Preface
xvii
However, being absolutely up-to-date is impossible because change is always with us. What is current today may be outdated tomorrow. Accordingly, this edition is accompanied by two programs created to help instructors stay in touch with current events and issues: Enhanced Course Cartridge We have also created an enhanced course cartridge for this text, which walks students through each chapter with remedial activities, quizzes that report directly to an instructor gradebook, and interactive review exercises to help students master the concepts presented in the book. (www. mhhe.com/hillgbt5e)
Revised and Expanded DVD Finally, a revised and expanded DVD accompanies this text to help spark classroom discussions. Classic footage joins new stories to help you engage your students in international business topics. The Instructor’s Manual includes notes on how to use the videos with each chapter.
xviii Preface
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd xviii
1/25/07 8:28:42 PM
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xix 1/11/07 8:11:09 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Beyond Uncritical Presentation and Shallow Explanation Many issues in international business are complex and thus necessitate considerations of pros and cons. To demonstrate this to students, I have adopted a critical approach that presents the arguments for and against economic theories, government policies, business strategies, organizational structures, and so on. Related to this, I have attempted to explain the complexities of the many theories and phenomena unique to international business so the student might fully comprehend the statements of a theory or the reasons a phenomenon is the way it is. I believe that these theories and phenomena are explained in more depth in this book than they are in competing textbooks, which seem to use the rationale that a shallow explanation is little better than no explanation. In international business, a little knowledge is indeed a dangerous thing. To help students go a step farther in expanding their understanding of international business, each chapter incorporates two globalEDGE research tasks designed and written by Tunga Kiyuk and the team at Michigan State University’s globalresearch. com site to dovetail with the content just covered. GlobalEDGE
Research Task
http://globalEDGE.msu.edu
Use the globalEDGE site (http://globalEDGE.msu. edu/) to complete the following exercises: 1. Until recently, the U.S. Department of State has provided annual country reports on economic policy and trade practices. Locate the archives of these reports and prepare a description of the exchange rate and debt management policies of an emerging market of your choice based on the latest report available.
2. The Biz/ed Web site presents a “Trade Balance and Exchange Rate Simulation” that explains how a change in exchange rate influences the trade balance. Locate the online simulator (check under the Academy section of globalEDGE) and identify what the trade balance is assumed to be a function of. Run the simulation to identify how exchange rate changes impact exports, imports and trade balance.
Integrated Progression of Topics A weakness of many texts is that they lack a tight, integrated flow of topics from chapter to chapter. In Chapter 1 of this book, students will learn how the book’s topics are related to each other. I’ve achieved integration by organizing the material so that each chapter builds on the material of the previous ones in a logical fashion.
The globalEDGE task for Chapter 10 focuses on learning how to research the U.S. Department of State’s statistics on other countries’ economic policies and trade practices, as well as on discovering how exchange rates affect trade balances. See page 356 for more details.
PART ONE Chapter 1 provides an overview of the key issues to be addressed and explains the plan of the book.
PART TWO Chapters 2 and 3 focus on national differences in political economy and culture, and Chapter 4 examines ethical issues in international business. Most international business textbooks place this material at a later point, but I believe it is vital to discuss national differences first. After all, many of the central issues in international trade and investment, the global monetary system, international business strategy and structure, and international business operations arise out of national differences in political economy and culture. To fully understand these issues, students must first appreciate the differences in countries and cultures. Ethical issues are dealt with at this juncture primarily because many ethical dilemmas flow out of national differences in political systems, economic systems, and culture. hiL10544_ch10_324-357.indd 356
12/18/06 4:41:52 PM
Preface
xix
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xx 1/11/07 8:11:10 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
PART THREE Chapters 5 through 8 investigate the political economy of international trade and investment. The purpose of this part is to describe and explain the trade and investment environment in which international business occurs. PART FOUR Chapters 9 and 10 describe and explain the global monetary system, laying out in detail the monetary framework in which international business transactions are conducted.
PART FIVE In Chapters 11 through 16, attention shifts from the environment to the firm. Here the book examines the strategies that firms adopt to compete effectively in the international business environment and explains how firms can perform key functions—production, marketing, R&D, human resource management, accounting, and finance—in order to compete and succeed in the international business environment. Throughout the book, the relationship of new material to topics discussed in earlier chapters is pointed out to the students to reinforce their understanding of how the material comprises an integrated whole.
Focus on Managerial Implications I have always believed that it is important to show students how the material covered in the text is relevant to the actual practice of international business. This is explicit in the later chapters of the book, which focus on the practice of international business, but it is not always obvious in the first half of the book, which considers many macroeconomic and political issues, from international trade theory and foreign direct investment flows to the IMF and the influence of inflation rates on foreign exchange quotations. Accordingly, at the end of each chapter in Parts Two, Three, and Four— where the focus is on the environment of international business, as opposed to particular firms—there is a section titled “Focus on Managerial Implications.” In this section, the managerial implications of the material discussed in the chapter are clearly explained.
Focus on Managerial Implications For example, Chapter 5, “International Trade Theory,” ends with a detailed discussion of the various trade theories’ implications for international business management. See pages 183–185 for the rest of this feature.
xx
Preface
Focus on Managerial Implications Why does all this matter for business? There are at least three main implications for international businesses of the material discussed in this chapter: location implications, first-mover implications, and policy implications.
Location Underlying most of the theories we have discussed is the notion that different countries have particular advantages in different productive activities. Thus, from a profit perspective, it makes sense for a firm to disperse its productive activities to those countries where, according to the theory of international trade, they can be performed most efficiently. If design can be performed most efficiently in France, that is where design facilities should be located; if the manufacture of basic components can be performed most efficiently in Singapore, that is where they should be manufactured; and if final assembly can be performed most efficiently in China, that is where final assembly should be performed. The result is a global web of productive activities, with different activities being performed in different locations around the globe depending on considerations of comparative advantage, factor endowments, and the like. If the firm does not do this, it may find itself at a competitive disadvantage relative to firms that do.
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xxi 1/11/07 8:11:10 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
In addition, each chapter begins with an opening case that sets the stage for the chapter content and familiarizes students with how real international companies conduct business.
chapter
2
National Differences in Political Economy
Opening Case
Chavez’s Venezuela opening case
H
ugo Chavez, a former military officer who was once jailed for engineering a failed coup attempt, was elected president of Venezuela in 1998. Chavez, a self-styled democratic socialist, won the presidential election by campaigning against corruption, economic mismanagement, and the “harsh realities” of global capitalism. When he took office in February 1999, Chavez claimed that he had inherited the worst economic situation in the country’s recent history. He wasn’t far off the mark. A collapse in the price of oil, which accounted for 70 percent of the country’s exports, left Venezuela with a large budget deficit and forced the economy into a deep recession. Soon after taking office, Chavez proceeded to try to consolidate his hold over the apparatus of government. A constituent assembly, dominated by Chavez followers, drafted a new constitution that strengthened the powers of the presidency and allowed Chavez (if reelected) to stay in office until 2013. Subsequently, the national congress, which was controlled by Chavez supporters, approved a measure allowing the government to remove and appoint Supreme Court justices, effectively increasing Chavez’s hold over the judiciary. Chavez also extended government control over the media. By 2005, Freedom House, which annually assesses political and civil liberties worldwide, concluded that Venezuela was only “partly free” and that freedoms were being progressively curtailed. On the economic front, things remained rough. The economy shrank by 9 percent in 2002 and another 8 percent in 2003. Unemployment remained persistently high at 15 to 17 percent and the poverty rate rose to more than 50 percent of the population. A 2003 study by the World Bank concluded that Venezuela was one of the most regulated economies in the world and that state controls over business activities gave public officials ample opportunities to enrich themselves by demanding bribes in
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 41
Chapter 2, “National Differences in Political Economy,” for example, opens with a case that describes how the political economy of Venezuela is changing under the leadership of Hugo Chavez and what this might mean for foreign investors. See pages 41–42 for the remainder of this case.
1/11/07 5:42:38 PM
I have also added a closing case to each chapter. These cases are also designed to illustrate the relevance of chapter material for the practice of international business as well as to provide continued insight into how real companies handle those issues. Closing Case closing case Indonesia—The Troubled Giant Indonesia is a vast country. Its 220 million people are spread out over some 17,000 islands that span an arc 3,200 miles long from Sumatra in the west to Irian Jaya in the east. It is the world’s most populous Muslim nation—some 85 percent of the population count themselves as Muslims—but also one of the most ethnically diverse. More than 500 languages are spoken in the country, and separatists are active in a number of provinces. For 30 years, this sprawling nation was held together by the strong arm of President Suharto. Suharto was a virtual dictator who was backed by the military establishment. Under his rule, the Indonesian economy grew steadily, but there was a cost. Suharto brutally repressed internal dissent. He was also famous for “crony capitalism,” using his command of the political system to favor the business enterprises of his supporters and family. In the end, Suharto was overtaken by massive debts that Indonesia had accumulated during the 1990s. In 1997, the Indonesian economy went into a tailspin. The International Monetary Fund stepped in with a $43 billion rescue package. When it was revealed that much of this money found its way into the personal coffers of Suharto and his cronies, people took to the streets in protest and he was forced to resign. After Suharto, Indonesia moved rapidly toward a vigorous democracy, culminating in October 2004 with the inauguration of Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, the country’s first directly elected president. The economic front has also seen progress.
Public debt as a percentage of GDP fell from close to 100 percent in 2000 to less than 60 percent by 2004. Inflation declined from 12 percent annually in 2001 to 6 percent in 2004, and the economy grew by around 4 percent per annum during 2001–05. But Indonesia lags behind its Southeast Asian neighbors. Its economic growth trails that of China, Malaysia, and Thailand. Unemployment is still high at around 10 percent of the working population. Inflation started to reaccelerate in 2005, hitting 14 percent by year end. Growth in labor productivity has been nonexistent for a decade. Worse still, foreign capital is fleeing the country. Sony made headlines by shutting down an audio equipment factory in 2003, and a number of apparel enterprises have left Indonesia for China and Vietnam. In total, the stock of foreign direct investment in Indonesia fell from $24.8 billion in 2001 to $11.4 billion in 2004 as foreign firms left the nation. Some observers feel that Indonesian is hobbled by its poor infrastructure. Public infrastructure investment has been declining for years. It was about $3 billion in 2003, down from $16 billion in 1996. The road system is a mess, half of the country’s population has no access to electricity, the number of brownouts is on the rise as the electricity grid ages, and nearly 99 percent of the population lacks access to modern sewerage facilities. The tsunami that ravaged the coast of Sumatra in late 2004 only made matters worse. Mirroring the decline in public investment has been a slump in private
The closing case to Chapter 2, for example, looks at how endemic corruption in Indonesia has raised the costs of doing business in that country. To see the rest of this case, turn to pages 84–85.
Preface
xxi
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xxii 1/22/07 9:41:05 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Another tool that I have used to focus on managerial implications are Management Focus boxes. There is at least one Management Focus in most chapters. Like the opening cases, the purpose of these boxes is to illustrate the relevance of chapter material for the practice of international business.
Management Focus The Management Focus in Chapter 2, for example, looks at how Starbucks won an important battle its intellectual property in China. This box illustrates the important role that national differences in the protection of intellectual property rights can play in international business. See page 57 for the rest of this Focus.
Management FOCUS Starbucks Wins Key Trademark Case in China Starbucks has big plans for China. It believes the fast-growing nation will become the company’s secondlargest market after the United States. Starbucks entered the country in 1999, and by the end of 2005 it had 209 stores open. But in China, copycats of well-established Western brands are commonplace. Starbucks too faced competition from a look alike, Shanghai Xing Ba Ke Coffee Shop, whose stores closely matched the Starbucks format, right down to a green and white Xing Ba Ke circular logo that mimics Starbuck’s ubiquitous logo. Moreover, the name mimics the standard Chinese translation for Starbucks. Xing means “star” and Ba Ke sounds like “bucks.” In 2003, Starbuck decided to sue Xing Ba Ke in Chinese court for trademark violations. Xing Ba Ke’s general manager responded by claiming that it was just an accident that the logo and name were so similar to that of Starbucks. Moreover, he claimed the right to use the logo and name because Xing Ba Ke had registered as a company in Shanghai in 1999, before Starbucks entered the city.
“I hadn’t heard of Starbucks at the time,” claimed the manager, “so how could I imitate its brand and logo?” However, in January 2006 a Shanghai court ruled that Starbucks had precedence, in part because it had registered its Chinese name in 1998. The Court stated that Xing Ba Ke’s use of the name and similar logo was “clearly malicious” and constituted improper competition. The court ordered Xing Ba Ke to stop using the name and to pay Starbucks $62,000 in compensation. While the money involved here may be small, the precedent is not. In a country where violation of trademarks has been commonplace, the courts seem to be signaling that a shift toward greater protection of intellectual property rights may be in progress. This is perhaps not surprising, since foreign governments and the World Trade Organization have been pushing China hard recently to start respecting intellectual property rights. Sources: M. Dickie, “Starbucks Wins Case against Chinese Copycat,” Financial Times, January 3, 2006, p. 1; “Starbucks: Chinese Court Backs Company over Trademark Infringement,” The Wall Street Journal, January 2, 2006, p. A11; and “Starbucks Calls China Its Top Growth Focus,” The Wall Street Journal, February 14, 2006, p.1.
Accessible and Interesting The international business arena is fascinating and exciting, and I have tried to communicate my enthusiasm for it to the student. Learning is easier and better if the subject matter is communicated in an interesting, informative, and accessible manner. One technique I have used to achieve this is weaving interesting anecdotes into the narrative of the text, that is, stories that illustrate theory. The use of Another Perspective boxes also serves to provide additional context for the chapter topics.
Another Perspective For example, this Another Perspective box in Chapter 12 illustrates further how mode of entry and freedom of information caused conflict for Microsoft in China. See page 399 for the rest of the picture.
Another Perspective Microsoft in China: Where Does Freedom of Information Fit into Modes of Entry? The almost meteoric rise of information on the Internet presents decisions and challenges that extend to human rights issues. Microsoft says it was simply ìfacing realityî when it agreed to shut down the MSN Spaces Web site, a demand made by the Chinese government, in order to gain access to the 103 million Chinese Internet usersóand that figure is growing wildly. China added almost 10 million new Internet users in the first six months of 2005. Microsoftís official statement about the site shutdown in China was: Microsoft does business in many countries around the world. While different countries have different standards, Microsoft and other multinational companies have to ensure that our products and services comply with local laws, norms and industry standards. Reporters Without Borders, a group in Paris that tracks censorship around the world, vehemently protested Microsoftís actions. They call on all corporations to uphold the free flow of information and even recommend that Western governments take action against corporations that restrict the flow of information. They see it as a loss of freedom for Chinese Web users and a fundamental human rights issue.
xxii Preface
In addition to the Management Focus feature, most chapters also have a Country Focus box that provides background on the political, economic, social, or cultural aspects of countries grappling with an international business issue. Country Focus Country FOCUS Corruption in Nigeria When Nigeria gained independence from Great Britain in 1960, there were hopes that the country might emerge as an economic heavyweight in Africa. Not only was Nigeria Africa’s most populous country, but it also was blessed with abundant natural resources, particularly oil, from which the country earned over $400 billion between 1970 and 2005. Despite this, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries in the world. According to the 2005 Human Development Index compiled by the United Nations, Nigeria ranked 158 out of 177 countries covered. Gross national income per capita was just $430, 32 percent of the adult population was illiterate, and life expectancy at birth was only 43 years. What went wrong? Although there is no simple answer, a number of factors seem to have conspired to damage economic activity in Nigeria. The country is composed of several competing ethnic, tribal, and religious groups, and the conflict among them has limited political stability and led to political strife, including a brutal civil war in the 1970s. With the legitimacy of the government always in question, political leaders often purchased support by legitimizing bribes and by raiding the national treasury to reward allies. Civilian rule after independence was followed by a series of military dictatorships, each of which seemed more corrupt and inept than the last (the country returned to civilian rule in 1999). During the 1990s, the military dictator, Sani Abacha, openly and systematically plundered the state treasury for his own personal gain. His most blatant scam was the Petroleum Trust Fund, which he set up in the mid-1990s ostensibly to channel extra revenue from an increase in fuel prices into much-needed infrastructure projects and other investments. The fund was not independently audited, and almost none of the money that passed through it was properly accounted for. It was, in fact, a vehicle for Abacha and his supporters to spend at will a sum that in 1996 was equivalent to some 25 percent of
the total federal budget. Abacha, aware of his position as an unpopular and unelected leader, lavished money on personal security and handed out bribes to those whose support he coveted. With examples like this at the very top of the government, it is not surprising that corruption could be found throughout the political and bureaucratic apparatus. Some of the excesses were simply astounding. In the 1980s an aluminum smelter was built on the orders of the government, which wanted to industrialize Nigeria. The cost of the smelter was $2.4 billion, some 60 to 100 percent higher than the cost of comparable plants elsewhere in the developed world. This high cost was widely interpreted to reflect the bribes that had to be paid to local politicians by the international contractors that built the plant. The smelter has never operated at more than a fraction of its intended capacity. Has the situation in Nigeria improved since the country returned to civilian rule in 1999? In 2003, Olusegun Obasanjo was elected president on a platform that included a promise to fight corruption. By some accounts, progress has been seen. His anticorruption chief, Nuhu Ribadu, has claimed that whereas 70 percent of the country’s oil revenues were being stolen or wasted in 2002, by 2004 the figure was “only” 40 percent. But in its most recent survey, Transparency International still ranked Nigeria among the most corrupt countries in the world in 2005 (see Figure 2.1), suggesting that the country still has long way to go. Mr. Ribadu has suggested that the problem lies with state governments, who are still riddled with corruption.
In Chapter 2, for example, one Country Focus box discusses the steps that India has taken over the last decade to build a dynamic, market-based economic system. See page 55 for more on India’s transformation.
Sources: “A Tale of Two Giants,” The Economist, January 15, 2000, p. 5; J. Coolidge and S. Rose Ackerman, “High Level Rent Seeking and Corruption in African Regimes,” World Bank policy research working paper no. 1780, June 1997; D. L. Bevan, P. Collier, and J. W. Gunning, Nigeria and Indonesia: The Political Economy of Poverty, Equity and Growth (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999); “Democracy and Its Discontents,” The Economist, January 29, 2005, p. 55; and A. Field. “Can Reform Save Nigeria?” Journal of Commerce, November 21, 2005, p. 1.
Ancillary Resources That Enliven the Text and Make It Easier to Teach For instructors, this text offers a number of materials to help them keep their students active and engaged in the learning process. In addition to the course cartridge and International Business DVD, the Instructor’s Resource CD-ROM is a one-stop place for several key instructor aids, including the following: • Instructor’s Manual. The Instructor’s Manual, prepared by Veronica Horton, contains course outlines; chapter teaching resources, including chapter overviews and outlines, teaching suggestions, chapter objectives, teaching suggestions for opening cases, lecture outlines, answers to critical discussion questions, teaching suggestions for the closing case, and two student activities (some with Internet components); and expanded Video Notes with discussion questions for each video. The answers to globalEDGE research tasks will also be included here. • Test Bank. The test bank was prepared by Amit Shah of Frostburg State University and contains approximately 100 true-false, multiple-choice, and essay questions per chapter. New to this edition, the test bank questions are also categorized by Bloom’s taxonomy levels of learning and how they meet various AACSB objectives. • EZ Test. A computerized version of the test bank is available, allowing the instructor to generate random tests and to add his or her own questions. Preface xxiii
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd xxiii
1/25/07 12:22:59 AM
• PowerPoint®. Recreated for this edition by Veronica Horton, the PowerPoint program consists of approximately 500 slides featuring original materials not found in the text in addition to reproductions and illuminations of key text figures, tables, and maps. Quiz questions to keep students on their toes during classroom presentations are also included, along with instructor notes. Finally, the book’s Online Learning Center (www.mhhe.com/hillgbt5e) is available for all adopters of Global Business Today. The password-protected instructor version grants access to the Instructor’s Manual, PowerPoints, Video Cases, and globalEDGE answers. Instructors can also view student resources to make more effective supplementary assignments.
For students, this book also provides rich interactive resources to help them learn how to practice international business. The Online Learning Center (www.mhhe.com/hillgbt5e) for students includes chapter quizzes, student PowerPoints, and chapter overviews. Students can also access the text glossary as well as all Global Business Today interactive modules, including the following: Concept Exercises Concept Exercises help students learn how to solve realistic problems by exploring Flash modules, linked to the appropriate chapter, of the Hofstede study, absolute and comparative advantage, foreign direct investment, balance of payments, purchasing power parity and inflation, historical exchange rates, and export and import financing.
xxiv Preface
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd xxiv
1/25/07 8:28:43 PM
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xxv 1/22/07 9:41:06 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Concept Videos The eight Concept Videos, complemented by cases and discussion questions written by Charles Hill, are also exclusive to these online activities. Students can watch and learn more when they access this activity for the appropriate chapter.
Global Business Plan The Global Business Plan helps students take it one step further into applications, allowing them to build their own business plan one section at a time to prepare for entering a foreign market.
Enhanced Cartridge The enhanced cartridge, already mentioned above, allows students access to additional remedial activities that capture grades for instructors and promotes greater accountability for student engagement with the course. Preface xxv
hiL10544_fm_i-xxvi.indd Page xxvi 1/22/07 9:41:07 PM elhi
/Volumes/108/MHID016/mhhiL/hiL5fm
Acknowledgments Numerous people deserve to be thanked for their assistance in preparing this book. First, I want to thank all the people at McGraw-Hill/Irwin who have worked with me on this project: John E. Biernat, editorial director Ryan Blankenship, senior sponsoring editor Kirsten L. Guidero, developmental editor Meg Beamer, marketing manager Damian Moshak and Lynn Bluhm, media producers Susan Lombardi, media project manager Laura Griffin and Jim Labeots, project managers Kami Carter, senior designer Mary Kazak, freelance designer Carol Bielski, production supervisor Kathy Shive, photo research coordinator Second, my thanks go to the reviewers, who provided good feedback that helped shape this edition of the book: R. Apana, University of Cincinnati David Bruce, Georgia State University Bruce Keillor, University of Akron Anthony Koh, University of Toledo Joseph Leonard, Miami University of Ohio Mingfang Li, California State University Northridge Hoon Park, University of Central Florida Janis Petronis, Tarleton University Lee Pickler, Baldwin-Wallace College Gary Shantz, University of LaVerne Charlie Shi, Diablo Valley College Len Trevino, Washington State University Tim Wilkinson, University of Akron Andrzej Wlodarczyk, Lindenwood University
xxvi Preface
Global Business Today
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 1
12/7/06 6:34:42 PM
rld /AP W ide W o
Heribert Proe ppy
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
part 1
1 2 3 4 5
Introduction and Overview Understand what is meant by the term globalization. Be familiar with the main drivers of globalization. Appreciate the changing nature of the global economy. Understand the main arguments in the debate over the impact of globalization. Appreciate how the process of globalization is creating opportunities and challenges for business managers.
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 2
12/7/06 6:34:43 PM
chapter
1
Globalization IKEA–The Global Retailer opening case
I
KEA may be the world’s most successful global retailer. Established by Ingvar Kamprad in Sweden in 1943 when he was just 17 years old, the home-furnishing superstore has grown into a global cult brand with 230 stores in 33 countries that host 410 million shoppers a year and generated sales of ¯c14.8 billion ($17.7 billion) in 2005. Kamprad himself, who still owns the private company, is rumored to be the world’s richest man. IKEA’s target market is the global middle class who are looking for low-priced but attractively designed furniture and household items. The company applies the same basic formula worldwide: Open large warehouse stores festooned in the blue and yellow colors of the Swedish flag that offer 8,000 to 10,000 items, from kitchen cabinets to candlesticks. Use wacky promotions to drive traffic into the stores. Configure the interior of the stores so that customers have to pass through each department to get to the checkout. Add restaurants and child care facilities so that shoppers stay as long as possible. Price the items as low as possible. Make sure that product design reflects the simple, clean Swedish lines that have become IKEA’s trademark. And then watch the results–customers who enter the store planning to buy a $40 coffee table and end up spending $500 on everything from storage units to kitchenware. IKEA aims to reduce the price of its offerings by 2 to 3 percent per year, which requires relentless attention to cost cutting. With a network of 1,300 suppliers in 53 countries, IKEA devotes considerable attention to finding the right manufacturer for each item. Consider the company’s best-selling Klippan love seat. Designed in 1980, the Klippan, with its clean lines, bright colors, simple legs, and compact size, has sold some 1.5 million units since its introduction. IKEA originally manufactured the product in Sweden but soon transferred production to lower-cost suppliers in Poland. As demand for the Klippan grew, IKEA then decided that it made more sense to work with suppliers in each of the company’s big markets to avoid the costs associated with shipping the product all over the world. Today there are five suppliers of the frames in Europe, plus three in the United States and two in China. To reduce the cost of the cotton
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 3
12/7/06 6:34:46 PM
slipcovers, IKEA has concentrated production in four core suppliers in China and Europe. The resulting efficiencies from these global sourcing decisions enabled IKEA to reduce the price of the Klippan by some 40 percent between 1999 and 2005. Despite its standard formula, to achieve global success IKEA had to adapt its offerings to the tastes and preferences of consumers in different nations. IKEA first discovered this in the early 1990s when it entered the United States. The company soon found that its European-style offerings didn’t always resonate with American consumers. Beds were measured in centimeters, not the king, queen, and twin sizes with which Americans are familiar. Sofas weren’t big enough, wardrobe drawers were not deep enough, glasses were too small, curtains too short, and kitchens didn’t fit U.S. size appliances. Since then, IKEA has redesigned its U.S. offerings to appeal to American consumers, which has resulted in stronger sales. The same process is now unfolding in China, where the company plans to establish 10 stores by 2010. The store layout in China reflects the layout of many Chinese apartments, and since many Chinese apartments have balconies, IKEA’s Chinese stores include a balcony section. IKEA also has had to adapt its locations in China, where car ownership is still not widespread. In the West, IKEA stores are generally located in suburban areas and have lots of parking space. In China, stores are located near public transportation, and IKEA offers delivery services so that Chinese customers can get their purchases home. Sources: K. Capell, A. Sains, C. Lindblad, and A.T. Palmer, “IKEA,” BusinessWeek, November 14, 2005, pp. 96–101; K. Capell et al., “What a Sweetheart of a Love Seat,” BusinessWeek, November 14, 2005, p. 101; P.M. Miller, “IKEA with Chinese Characteristics,” Chinese Business Review, July–August 2004, pp. 36–69; and C. Daniels, “Create IKEA, Make Billions, Take Bus,” Fortune, May 3, 2004, p. 44.
Introduction A fundamental shift is occurring in the world economy. We are moving away from a world in which national economies were relatively self-contained entities, isolated from each other by barriers to cross-border trade and investment; by distance, time zones, and language; and by national differences in government regulation, culture, and business systems. And we are moving toward a world in which barriers to cross-border trade and investment are declining; perceived distance is shrinking due to advances in transportation and telecommunications technology; material culture is starting to look similar the world over; and national economies are merging into an interdependent, integrated global economic system. The process by which this is occurring is commonly referred to as globalization. In this interdependent global economy, an American might drive to work in a car designed in Germany that was assembled in Mexico by DaimlerChrysler from components made in the United States and Japan that were fabricated from Korean 4
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 4
12/7/06 6:34:46 PM
steel and Malaysian rubber. She may have filled the car with gasoline at a BP service station owned by a British multinational company. The gasoline could have been made from oil pumped out of a well off the coast of Africa by a French oil company that transported it to the United States in a ship owned by a Greek shipping line. While driving to work, the American might talk to her stockbroker on a Nokia cell phone that was designed in Finland and assembled in Texas using chip sets produced in Taiwan that were designed by Indian engineers working for Texas Instruments. She could tell the stockbroker to purchase shares in Deutsche Telekom, a German telecommunications firm that was transformed from a former state-owned monopoly into a global company by an energetic Israeli CEO. She may turn on the car radio, which was made in Malaysia by a Japanese firm, to hear a popular hiphop song composed by a Swede and sung by a group of Danes in English who signed a record contract with a French music company to promote their record in America. The driver might pull into a drive-through coffee shop run by a Korean immigrant and order a “single, tall, nonfat latte” and chocolate-covered biscotti. The coffee beans came from Brazil and the chocolate from Peru, while the biscotti was made locally using an old Italian recipe. After the song ends, a news announcer might inform the American listener that antiglobalization protests at a meeting of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, have turned violent. One protester has been killed. The announcer then turns to the next item, a story about how fear of interest rate hikes in the United States has sent Japan’s Nikkei stock market index down sharply. This is the world in which we live. It is a world where the volume of goods, services, and investment crossing national borders has expanded faster than world output consistently for more than half a century. It is a world where more than $1.2 billion in foreign exchange transactions are made every day, where $10.41 trillion of goods and $2.41 trillion of services were sold across national borders in 2005.1 It is a world in which international institutions such as the World Trade Organization and gatherings of leaders from the world’s most powerful economies have called for even lower barriers to cross-border trade and investment. It is a world where the symbols of material and popular culture are increasingly global: from Coca-Cola and Starbucks to Sony PlayStations, Nokia cell phones, MTV shows, Disney films, and IKEA stores. It is a world in which products are made from inputs that come from all over the world. It is a world in which an economic crisis in Asia can cause a recession in the United States, and the threat of higher interest rates in the United States really did help drive Japan’s Nikkei index down in the spring of 2006. It is also a world in which vigorous and vocal groups protest against globalization, which they blame for a list of ills, from unemployment in developed nations to environmental degradation and the Americanization of popular culture. And yes, these protests have on occasion turned violent. For businesses, this process has produced many opportunities. Firms can expand their revenues by selling around the world and reduce their costs by Another Perspective producing in nations where key inputs, including labor, are cheap. As we saw in the opening case, The United States in Perspective this is exactly what the Swedish retailer, IKEA, The United States has the highest level of output in the has done. IKEA generates only 8 percent of its world, with the GDP valued at more than $12.5 trillion in revenues from its home country, Sweden, and now 2005. The U.S. GDP per capita is $42,129. With around has stores in 32 other nations. The company uses 4.6 percent of the world’s population, the United States prothe same basic retailing formula worldwide to sell duces about 20.4 percent of the global GDP. (The Economist, May 1, 2006; Factsheet, CIA Factbook) its merchandise—big stores offering a wide selection of well-designed products sold at a low price. Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 5
5
12/7/06 6:34:46 PM
Making profits at a low price point requires IKEA to source merchandise from low-cost locations around the globe. The expansion of enterprises like IKEA has been facilitated by favorable political and economic trends. Since the collapse of communism at the end of the 1980s, the pendulum of public policy in nation after nation has swung toward the free market end of the economic spectrum. Regulatory and administrative barriers to doing business in foreign nations have come down, while those nations have often transformed their economies, privatizing state-owned enterprises, deregulating markets, increasing competition, and welcoming investment by foreign businesses. This has allowed businesses both large and small, from both advanced nations and developing nations, to expand internationally. Thus, IKEA now has six stores in Russia, four in China, and seven in Poland, all countries that were off limits to Western enterprises for much of the second half of the twentieth century. At the same time, globalization has created new threats for businesses accustomed to dominating their domestic markets. Foreign companies have entered many formerly protected industries in developing nations, increasing competition and driving down prices. For three decades, U.S. automobile companies have been battling foreign enterprises, as Japanese, European, and now Korean companies have taken business from them. General Motors has seen its market share decline from more than 50 percent to about 28 percent, while Japan’s Toyota has passed Chrysler, now DaimlerChrysler, to become the second-largest automobile company in America behind GM and ahead of Ford. As globalization unfolds, it is transforming industries and creating anxiety among those who believed their jobs were protected from foreign competition. Historically, while many workers in manufacturing industries worried about the impact foreign competition might have on their jobs, workers in service industries felt more secure. Now this too is changing. Advances in technology, lower transportation costs, and the rise of skilled workers in developing countries imply that many services no longer need to be performed where they are delivered. The outsourcing trend is even hitting health services. An MRI scan, transmitted over the Internet, might now be interpreted by a radiologist living in Bangalore. Similar trends can be seen in many other service industries. Accounting work is being outsourced from America to India. In 2005, some 400,000 individual tax returns were compiled in India. Indian accountants, trained in U.S. tax rules, perform work for U.S. accounting firms.2 They access individual tax returns stored on computers in the United States, perform routine calculations, and save their work so that it can be inspected by a U.S. accountant, who then bills clients. As the best-selling author Thomas Friedman has recently argued, the world is becoming flat.3 People living in developed nations no longer have the playing field tilted in their favor. Increasingly, enterprising individuals based in India, China, or Brazil have the same opportunities to better themselves as those living in Western Europe, the United States, or Canada. In this book we will take a close look at the issues introduced here, and at many more besides. We will explore how changes in regulations governing international trade and investment, when coupled with changes in political systems and technology, have dramatically altered the competitive playing field confronting many businesses. We will discuss the resulting opportunities and threats and review the different strategies that managers can pursue to exploit the opportunities and counter the threats. We will consider whether globalization benefits or harms national economies. We will look at what economic theory has to say about the outsourcing of manufacturing and service jobs to places such as India and China, and at the benefits and costs of outsourcing, not just to business firms and their employees, but also to entire economies. First, though, we need to get a better overview of the nature and process of globalization, and that is the function of the current chapter. 6
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 6
12/7/06 6:34:46 PM
What Is Globalization? As used in this book, globalization refers to the shift toward a more integrated and interdependent world economy. Globalization has several facets, including the globalization of markets and the globalization of production.
THE GLOBALIZATION OF MARKETS The globalization of markets refers to the merging of historically distinct and separate national markets into one huge global marketplace. Falling barriers to cross-border trade have made it easier to sell internationally. It has been argued for some time that the tastes and preferences of consumers in different nations are beginning to converge on some global norm, thereby helping to create a global market.4 Consumer products such as Citigroup credit cards, Coca-Cola soft drinks, Sony PlayStation video games, McDonald’s hamburgers, Starbucks coffee, and IKEA furniture are frequently held up as prototypical examples of this trend. Firms such as those just cited are more than just benefactors of this trend; they are also facilitators of it. By offering the same basic product worldwide, they help to create a global market. A company does not have to be the size of these multinational giants to facilitate, and benefit from, the globalization of markets. In the United States, for example, nearly 90 percent of firms that export are small businesses employing less than 100 people, and their share of total U.S. exports has grown steadily over the last decade to now exceed 20 percent.5 Firms with less than 500 employees accounted for 97 percent of all U.S. exporters and almost 30 percent of all exports by value.6 Typical of these is Hytech, a New York–based manufacturer of solar panels that generates 40 percent of its $3 million in annual sales from exports to five countries, or B&S Aircraft Alloys, another New York company whose exports account for 40 percent of its $8 million annual revenues.7 The situation is similar in several other nations. In Germany, for example, which is the world’s largest exporter, a staggering 98 percent of small and mid-sized companies have exposure to international markets, either via exports or international production.8 Despite the global prevalence of Citigroup credit cards, McDonald’s hamburgers, Starbucks coffee, and IKEA stores, it is important not to push too far the view that national markets are giving way to the global market. As we shall see in later chapters, significant differences still exist among national markets along many relevant dimensions, including consumer tastes and preferences, distribution channels, culturally embedded value systems, business systems, and legal regulations. These differences frequently require companies to customize marketing strategies, product features, and operating practices to best match conditions in a particular country. In the opening case, for example, we saw how IKEA has had to alter its merchandise and location strategy to take national differences into account. Similarly, automobile companies will promote different car models in different nations, depending on a range of factors such as local fuel costs, income levels, traffic congestion, and cultural values. The most global markets currently are not markets for consumer products—where national differences in tastes and preferences are still often important enough to act as a brake on globalization—but markets for industrial goods and materials that serve a universal need the world over. These include the markets for commodities such as aluminum, oil, and wheat; for industrial products such as microprocessors, DRAMs (computer memory chips), and commercial jet aircraft; for computer software; and for financial assets from U.S. Treasury bills to eurobonds and futures on the Nikkei index or the Mexican peso. In many global markets, the same firms frequently confront each other as competitors in nation after nation. Coca-Cola’s rivalry with PepsiCo is a global one, as
LEARNING OBJECTIVE 1 Understand what is meant by the term globalization.
Globalization The shift toward a more integrated and interdependent world economy.
Globalization of Markets The merging of historically distinct and separate national markets into one huge global marketplace.
Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 7
7
12/7/06 6:34:46 PM
are the rivalries between Ford and Toyota, Boeing and Airbus, Caterpillar and Komatsu in earthmoving equipment, and Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft in video games. If a firm moves into a nation not currently served by its rivals, many of those rivals are sure to follow to prevent their competitor from gaining an advantage.9 As firms follow each other around the world, they bring with them many of the assets that served them well in other national markets—including their products, operating strategies, marketing strategies, and brand names—creating some homogeneity across markets. Thus, greater uniformity replaces diversity. In an increasing number of industries, it is no longer meaningful to talk about “the German market,” “the American market,” “the Brazilian market,” or “the Japanese market”; for many firms there is only the global market. Globalization of Production Sourcing goods and services from locations around the globe to take advantage of national differences in the cost and quality of various factors of production.
Factors of Production Components of production such as labor, energy, land, and capital.
8
THE GLOBALIZATION OF PRODUCTION The globalization of production refers to the sourcing of goods and services from locations around the globe to take advantage of national differences in the cost and quality of factors of production (such as labor, energy, land, and capital). By doing this, companies hope to lower their overall cost structure or improve the quality or functionality of their product offering, thereby allowing them to compete more effectively. Consider the Boeing’s 777, a commercial jet airliner. Eight Japanese suppliers make parts for the fuselage, doors, and wings; a supplier in Singapore makes the doors for the nose landing gear; three suppliers in Italy manufacture wing flaps; and so on.10 In total, some 30 percent of the 777, by value, is built by foreign companies. For its next jet airliner, the 787, Boeing is pushing this trend even further, with some 65 percent of the total value of the aircraft scheduled to be outsourced to foreign companies, 35 percent of which will go to three major Japanese companies.11 Part of Boeing’s rationale for outsourcing so much production to foreign suppliers is that these suppliers are the best in the world at their particular activity. A global web of suppliers yields a better final product, which enhances the chances of Boeing winning a greater share of total orders for aircraft than its global rival Airbus Industrie. Boeing also outsources some production to foreign countries to increase the chance that it will win significant orders from airlines based in that country. For another example of a global web of activities, consider the example of the Lenovo ThinkPad laptop computer.12 Lenovo, a Chinese company, acquired IBM’s personal computer operations in 2005. The ThinkPad is designed in the United States because Lenovo believes that the country is the best location in the world to do the basic design work. However, the case, keyboard, and hard drive are made in Thailand; the display screen and memory in South Korea; the built-in wireless card in Malaysia; and the microprocessor in the United States. In deciding on where to manufacture each component, Lenovo assessed both the production and transportation costs involved in each location. These components are then shipped to a plant in Mexico where the product is assembled before being shipped to the United States for final sale. Lenovo located the assembly of the ThinkPad in Mexico because of low labor costs in the country. The marketing and sales strategy for North America was developed in the United States, primarily because Lenovo believes that U.S. personnel possess better knowledge of the local marketplace than people based elsewhere (for more on Lenovo, see the Management Focus feature later in this chapter). Early outsourcing efforts were primarily confined to manufacturing enterprises, such as those undertaken by Boeing and Lenovo; increasingly, however, companies are taking advantage of modern communications technology, particularly the Internet, to outsource service activities to low-cost producers in other nations. The Internet has
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 8
12/7/06 6:34:47 PM
allowed hospitals to outsource some radiology work to India, where images from MRI scans and the like are read at night while U.S. physicians sleep and the results are ready for them in the morning. Similarly, in December 2003, IBM announced it would move the work of some 4,300 software engineers from the United States to India and China (software production is counted as a service activity).13 Many software companies now use Indian engineers to perform maintenance functions on software designed in the United States. The time difference allows Indian engineers to run debugging tests on software written in the United States when U.S. engineers sleep, transmitting the corrected code back to the United States over secure Internet connections so it is ready for U.S. engineers to work on the following day. Dispersing value-creation activities in this way can compress the time and lower the costs required to develop new software programs. Other companies, from computer makers to banks, are outsourcing customer service functions, such as customer call centers, to developing nations where labor is cheaper. Robert Reich, who served as secretary of labor in the Clinton administration, has argued that as a consequence of the trend exemplified by companies such as Boeing and IBM, in many cases it is becoming irrelevant to talk about American products, Japanese products, German products, or Korean products. Increasingly, according to Reich, the outsourcing of productive activities to different suppliers results in the creation of products that are global in nature, that is, “global products.”14 But as with the globalization of markets, companies must be careful not to push the globalization of production too far. As we will see in later chapters, substantial impediments still make it difficult for firms to achieve the optimal dispersion of their productive activities to locations around the globe. These impediments include formal and informal barriers to trade between countries, barriers to foreign direct investment, transportation costs, and issues associated with economic and political risk. For example, government regulations ultimately limit the ability of hospitals to outsource the process of interpreting MRI scans to developing nations where radiologists are cheaper. Nevertheless, the globalization of markets and production will continue. Modern firms are important actors in this trend, their very actions fostering increased globalization. These firms, however, are merely responding in an efficient manner to changing conditions in their operating environment—as well they should.
The Emergence of Global Institutions As markets globalize and an increasing proportion of business activity transcends national borders, institutions are needed to help manage, regulate, and police the global marketplace, and to promote the establishment of multinational treaties to govern the global business system. Over the past half century, a number of important global institutions have been created to help perform these functions, including the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GAT T) and its successor, the World Trade Organization (W TO); the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and its sister institution, the World Bank; and the United Nations (UN). All these institutions were created by voluntary agreement between individual nation-states, and their functions are enshrined in international treaties. The World Trade Organization (like the GATT before it) is primarily responsible for policing the world trading system and making sure nation-states adhere to the rules laid down in trade treaties signed by W TO member states. As of 2006, 149 nations that collectively accounted for 97 percent of world trade were W TO members, thereby giving the organization enormous scope and influence. The WTO
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) International treaty that committed signatories to lowering barriers to the free flow of goods across national borders; led to the WTO.
World Trade Organization The organization that succeeded the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade and now acts to police the world trading system.
Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 9
9
12/7/06 6:34:47 PM
is also responsible for facilitating the establishment of additional multinational agreements between W TO member states. Over its entire history, and that of the GAT T before it, the W TO has promoted the lowering of barriers to cross-border trade and investment. In doing so, the WTO has been the instrument of its member states, which have sought to create a more open global business system unencumbered by barriers to trade and investment between countries. Without an institution such as the WTO, the globalization of markets and production is unlikely to have proceeded as far as it has. However, as we shall see in this chapter and in Chapter 6 when we look closely at the W TO, critics charge that the organization is usurping the national sovereignty of individual nation-states. International The International Monetary Fund and the World Bank were both created in Monetary Fund 1944 by 44 nations that met at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire. The IMF was International institution established to maintain order in the international monetary system; the World Bank set up to maintain order was set up to promote economic development. In the 60 years since their creation, in the international monetary system. both institutions have emerged as significant players in the global economy. The World Bank is the less controversial of the two sister institutions. It has focused on making low-interest loans to cash-strapped governments in poor nations that wish to undertake significant infrastructure investments (such as building dams or roads). World Bank The IMF is often seen as the lender of last resort to nation-states whose economies International organization set up to are in turmoil and currencies are losing value against those of other nations. Repeatedly promote economic during the past decade, for example, the IMF has lent money to the governments of development, primarily troubled states, including Argentina, Indonesia, Mexico, Russia, South Korea, Thailand, by offering lowinterest loans to cashand Turkey. IMF loans come with strings attached, however; in return for loans, the strapped governments IMF requires nation-states to adopt specific economic policies aimed at returning their of poorer nations. troubled economies to stability and growth. These requirements have sparked controversy. Some critics charge that the I MF’s policy recommendations are often inappropriate; others maintain that by telling national governments what economic policies they must adopt, the IMF, like the WTO, is usurping the sovereignty of nationstates. We shall look at the debate over the role of the IMF in Chapter 10. The United Nations was established October 24, 1945, by 51 countries committed United Nations An international to preserving peace through international cooperation and collective security. Today organization made up nearly every nation in the world belongs to the United Nations; membership now totals of 191 countries 191 countries. When states become members of the United Nations, they agree to charged with keeping international peace, accept the obligations of the UN Charter, an international treaty that establishes basic developing cooperation principles of international relations. According to the charter, the UN has four between nations, and purposes: to maintain international peace and security, to develop friendly relations promoting human rights. among nations, to cooperate in solving international problems and in promoting respect for human rights, and to be a center for harmonizing the actions of nations. Although the UN is perhaps best known for its peacekeeping role, one of the organization’s central mandates is the promotion of higher standards of living, full employment, and conditions of economic and social progress and development—all issues that are central to the creation of a vibrant global economy. As much as 70 percent of the work of the UN system is devoted to accomplishing this mandate. To do so, the UN works closely with other international institutions such as the World Bank. Guiding the work is the belief that eradicating poverty and improving the The United Nations has the important goal of improving the well being of well-being of people everywhere are necessary steps people around the world. Mario Tama/Getty Images in creating conditions for lasting world peace.15 10
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 10
12/7/06 6:34:47 PM
Drivers of Globalization Two macro factors seem to underlie the trend toward greater globalization.16 The first is the decline in barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and capital that has occurred since the end of World War II. The second factor is technological change, particularly the dramatic developments in recent years in communication, information processing, and transportation technologies.
LEARNING OBJECTIVE 2 Be familiar with the main drivers of globalization.
DECLINING TRADE AND INVESTMENT BARRIERS During the 1920s and 30s, many of the world’s nation-states erected formidable barriers to international trade and foreign direct investment. International trade occurs when a firm exports goods or services to consumers in another country. Foreign direct investment (FDI) occurs when a firm invests resources in business activities outside its home country. Many of the barriers to international trade took the form of high tariffs on imports of manufactured goods. The typical aim of such tariffs was to protect domestic industries from foreign competition. One consequence, however, was “beggar thy neighbor” retaliatory trade policies, with countries progressively raising trade barriers against each other. Ultimately, this depressed world demand and contributed to the Great Depression of the 1930s. Having learned from this experience, the advanced industrial nations of the West committed themselves after World War II to removing barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and capital between nations.17 This goal was enshrined in the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. Under the umbrella of GAT T, eight rounds of negotiations among member states (now numbering 149) have worked to lower barriers to the free flow of goods and services. The most recent round of negotiations, known as the Uruguay Round, was completed in December 1993. The Uruguay Round further reduced trade barriers; extended GAT T to cover services as well as manufactured goods; provided enhanced protection for patents, trademarks, and copyrights; and established the World Trade Organization to police the international trading system.18 Table 1.1 summarizes the impact of GAT T agreements on average tariff rates for manufactured goods. As can be seen, average tariff rates have fallen significantly since 1950 and now stand at about 4 percent. In late 2001, the W TO launched a new round of talks aimed at further liberalizing the global trade and investment framework. For this meeting, it picked the remote location of Doha in the Persian Gulf state of Qatar. At Doha, the member states of
International Trade Occurs when a firm exports goods or services to consumers in another country.
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) Occurs when a firm invests resources in business activities outside its home country.
1913
1950
1990
2005
table
France
21%
18%
5.9%
3.9%
Germany
20
26
5.9
3.9
Italy
18
25
5.9
3.9
Average Tariff Rates on Manufactured Products as Percent of Value
Japan
30
—
5.3
2.3
Holland
5
11
5.9
3.9
Sweden
20
9
4.4
3.9
Great Britain
—
23
5.9
3.9
United States
44
14
4.8
3.2
1.1
Source: 1913–1990 data are from “Who Wants to Be a Giant?” The Economist: A Survey of the Multinationals, June 24, 1995, pp. 3–4. Copyright © 1995 The Economist Ltd. Newspaper. All rights reserved. The 2005 data are from World Trade Organization, 2005 World Trade Report (Geneva: WTO, 2006). Used by permission.
Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 11
11
1/3/07 6:13:12 PM
the W TO staked out an agenda. The talks were scheduled to last three years, although it now looks as if they may go on significantly longer. The agenda includes cutting tariffs on industrial goods, services, and agricultural products; phasing out subsidies to agricultural producers; reducing barriers to cross-border investment; and limiting the use of antidumping laws. The biggest gain may come from discussion on agricultural products; average agricultural tariff rates are still about 40 percent, and rich nations spend some $300 billion a year in subsidies to support their farm sectors. The world’s poorer nations have the most to gain from any reduction in agricultural tariffs and subsidies; such reforms would give them access to the markets of the developed world.19 In addition to reducing trade barriers, many countries have also been progressively removing restrictions to foreign direct investment. According to the United Nations, some 93 percent of the 2,156 changes made worldwide between 1991 and 2004 in the laws governing foreign direct investment created a more favorable environment for FDI.20 The desire of governments to facilitate FDI also has been reflected in a dramatic increase in the number of bilateral investment treaties designed to protect and promote investment between two countries. As of 2004, 2,392 such treaties involved more than 160 countries, a 12-fold increase from the 181 treaties that existed in 1980.21 Such trends have been driving both the globalization of markets and the globalization of production. The lowering of barriers to international trade enables firms to view the world, rather than a single country, as their market. The lowering of trade and investment barriers also allows firms to base production at the optimal location for that activity. Thus, a firm might design a product in one country, produce component parts in two other countries, assemble the product in yet another country, and then export the finished product around the world. The data summarized in Figure 1.1 imply several things. First, more firms are doing what Boeing does with the 777 and 787 and Lenovo with the ThinkPad:
figure
3,100
Volume of World Trade and World Production, 1950–2005
2,600
Index 1950 = 100
1.1
2,100 1,600 1,100
12
05
02
20
98
20
94
19
90
19
86
19
82
19
78
Total merchandise exports
19
74
19
70
19
19
66 19
62 19
58 19
54 19
19
50
600
World production
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 12
12/7/06 6:34:48 PM
dispersing parts of their production process to different locations around the globe to drive down production costs and increase product quality. Second, the economies of the world’s nation-states are becoming more intertwined. As trade expands, nations are becoming increasingly dependent on each other for important goods and services. Third, the world has become significantly wealthier since 1950, and the implication is that rising trade is the engine that has helped to pull the global economy along. According to W TO data, the volume of world merchandise trade has grown faster than the world economy since 1950 (see Figure 1.1).22 From 1970 to 2005, the volume of world merchandise trade expanded 27-fold, outstripping the expansion of world production, which grew about 7.5 times in real terms. (World merchandise trade includes trade in manufactured goods, agricultural goods, and mining products, but not services. World production and trade are measured in real, or inflationadjusted, dollars.) As suggested by Figure 1.1, due to falling barriers to cross-border trade and investment, the growth in world trade seems to have accelerated since the early 1980s. What Figure 1.1 does not show is that since the mid-1980s the value of international trade in services has grown robustly. Trade in services now accounts for almost 20 percent of the value of all international trade. Increasingly, international trade in services has been driven by advances in communications, which allow corporations to outsource service activities to different locations around the globe (see the opening case). Thus, as noted earlier, many corporations in the developed world outsource customer service functions, from software maintenance activities to customer call centers, to developing nations where labor costs are lower. The evidence also suggests that foreign direct investment is playing an increasing role in the global economy as firms increase their cross-border investments. The average yearly outflow of FDI increased from $25 billion in 1975 to a record $1.2 trillion in 2000, before falling back to an estimated $897 billion in 2005.23 Over this period, the flow of FDI accelerated faster than the growth in world trade and world output. For example, between 1992 and 2005, the total flow of FDI from all countries increased more than fivefold while world trade by value grew by some 140 percent and world output by around 40 percent.24 As a result of the strong FDI flow, by 2004 the global stock of FDI exceeded $9 trillion. At least 70,000 parent companies had 690,000 affiliates in foreign markets that collectively employed more than 50 million people abroad and generated value accounting for about one-tenth of global GDP. The foreign affiliates of multinationals had an estimated $19 trillion in global sales, much higher than the value of global exports, which stood at close to $11 trillion.25 The globalization of markets and production and the resulting growth of world trade, foreign direct investment, and imports all imply that firms are finding their home markets under attack from foreign competitors. This is true in Japan, where U.S. companies such as Kodak, Procter & Gamble, and Merrill Lynch are expanding their presence. It is true in the United States, where Japanese automobile firms have taken market share away from General Motors and Ford. And it is true in Europe, where the once-dominant Dutch company Philips has seen its market share in the consumer electronics industry taken by Japan’s JVC, Matsushita, and Sony, and Korea’s Samsung and LG. The growing integration of the world economy into a single, huge marketplace is increasing the intensity of competition in a range of manufacturing and service industries. However, declining barriers to cross-border trade and investment cannot be taken for granted. As we shall see in subsequent chapters, demands for “protection” from foreign competitors are still often heard in countries around the world, including the United Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 13
13
12/7/06 6:34:48 PM
States. Although a return to the restrictive trade policies of the 1920s and 30s is unlikely, it is not clear whether the political majority in the industrialized world favors further reductions in trade barriers. If trade barriers decline no further, at least for the time being, this will put a brake upon the globalization of both markets and production.
THE ROLE OF TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE
The lowering of trade barriers made globalization of markets and production a theoretical possibility. Technological change has made it a tangible reality. Since the end of World War II, the world has seen major advances in communication, information processing, and transportation technology, including the explosive emergence of the Internet and World Wide Web. Telecommunications is creating a global audience. Transportation is creating a global village. From Buenos Aires to Boston, and from Birmingham to Beijing, ordinary people are watching MTV, they’re wearing blue jeans, and they’re listening to iPods as they commute to work.
Moore’s Law The premise that the power of microprocessor technology doubles and its cost of production drops in half every 18 months.
Microprocessors and Telecommunications Perhaps the single most important innovation has been development of the microprocessor, which enabled the explosive growth of high-power, low-cost computing, vastly increasing the amount of information that can be processed by individuals and firms. The microprocessor also underlies many recent advances in telecommunications technology. Over the past 30 years, global communications have been revolutionized by developments in satellite, optical fiber, and wireless technologies, and now the Internet and the World Wide Web (W W W). These technologies rely on the microprocessor to encode, transmit, and decode the vast amount of information that flows along these electronic highways. The cost of microprocessors continues to fall, while their power increases (a phenomenon known as Moore’s Law, which predicts that the power of microprocessor technology doubles and its cost of production falls in half every 18 months).26 As this happens, the cost of global communications plummets, which lowers the costs of coordinating and controlling a global organization. Thus, between 1930 and 1990, the cost of a three-minute phone call between New York and London fell from $244.65 to $3.32.27 By 1998, it had plunged to just 36 cents for consumers, and much lower rates were available for businesses.28 Indeed, by using the Internet, the cost of an international phone call is rapidly plummeting toward just a few cents per minute. The Internet and World Wide Web The rapid growth of the World Wide Web is the latest expression of this development. In 1990, fewer than 1 million users were connected to the Internet. By 1995, the figure had risen to 50 million. By 2007, the Internet may have more than 1.47 billion users, or about 25 percent of the world’s population.29 The WWW has developed into the information backbone of the global economy. Web-based transactions hit $657 billion in 2000, up from nothing in 1994, and reached some $6.8 trillion in 2004.30 Included in the expanding volume of Web-based traffic is a growing percentage of cross-border trade. Viewed globally, the Web is emerging as an equalizer. It rolls back some of the constraints of location, scale, and time zones.31 The Web makes it much easier for buyers and sellers to find each other, wherever they may be located and whatever their size. It allows businesses, both small and large, to expand their global presence at a lower cost than ever before. Transportation Technology
In addition to developments in communication technology, several major innovations in transportation technology have occurred since World War II. In economic terms, the most important are probably the development
14
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 14
12/7/06 6:34:49 PM
Before the advent of containerization, it could take several days and several hundred longshoremen to unload a ship and reload goods onto trucks and trains. Digital Vision/Punchstock/DIL
of commercial jet aircraft and super-freighters and the introduction of containerization, which simplifies transshipment from one mode of transport to another. The advent of commercial jet travel, by reducing the time needed to get from one location to another, has effectively shrunk the globe. In terms of travel time, New York is now “closer” to Tokyo than it was to Philadelphia in the Colonial days. Containerization has revolutionized the transportation business, significantly lowering the costs of shipping goods over long distances. Before the advent of containerization, moving goods from one mode of transport to another was very labor intensive, lengthy, and costly. It could take days and several hundred longshoremen to unload a ship and reload goods onto trucks and trains. With the advent of widespread containerization in the 1970s and 1980s, the whole process can now be executed by a handful of longshoremen in a couple of days. Since 1980, the world’s containership fleet has more than quadrupled, reflecting in part the growing volume of international trade and in part the switch to this mode of transportation. As a result of the efficiency gains associated with containerization, transportation costs have plummeted, making it much more economical to ship goods around the globe, thereby helping to drive the globalization of markets and production. Between 1920 and 1990, the average ocean freight and port charges per ton of U.S. export and import cargo fell from $95 to $29 (in 1990 dollars).32 The cost of shipping freight per ton-mile on railroads in the United States fell from 3.04 cents in 1985 to 2.3 cents in 2000, largely as a result of efficiency gains from the widespread use of containers.33 An increased share of cargo now goes by air. Between 1955 and 1999, average air transportation revenue per ton-kilometer fell by more than 80 percent.34 Reflecting the falling cost of airfreight, by the early 2000s air shipments accounted for 28 percent of the value of U.S. trade, up from 7 percent in 1965.35
Implications for the Globalization of Production
As transportation costs associated with the globalization of production declined, dispersal of production to geographically separate locations became more economical. As a result of the technological innovations discussed above, the real costs of information processing and communication have fallen dramatically in the past two decades. These developments Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 15
15
12/7/06 6:34:49 PM
make it possible for a firm to create and then manage a globally dispersed production system, further facilitating the globalization of production. A worldwide communications network has become essential for many international businesses. For example, Dell uses the Internet to coordinate and control a globally dispersed production system to such an extent that it holds only three days’ worth of inventory at its assembly locations. Dell’s Internet-based system records orders for computer equipment as they are submitted by customers via the company’s Web site, then immediately transmits the resulting orders for components to various suppliers around the world, which have a real-time look at Dell’s order flow and can adjust their production schedules accordingly. Given the low cost of airfreight, Dell can use air transportation to speed up the delivery of critical components to meet unanticipated demand shifts without delaying the shipment of final product to consumers. Dell also has used modern communications technology to outsource its customer service operations to India. When U.S. customers call Dell with a service inquiry, they are routed to Bangalore in India, where English-speaking service personnel handle the call. The Internet has been a major force facilitating international trade in services. It is the Web that allows hospitals in Chicago to send MRI scans to India for analysis, accounting offices in San Francisco to outsource routine tax preparation work to accountants living in the Philippines, and software testers in India to debug code written by developers in Redmond, Washington, the headquarters of Microsoft. We are probably still in the early stages of this development. As Moore’s Law continues to advance and telecommunications bandwidth continues to increase, almost any work processes that can be digitalized will be, and this will allow that work to be performed wherever in the world it is most efficient and effective to do so. The development of commercial jet aircraft has also helped knit together the worldwide operations of many international businesses. Using jet travel, an American manager need spend a day at most traveling to his or her firm’s European or Asian operations. This enables the manager to oversee a globally dispersed production system.
Implications for the Globalization of Markets In addition to the globalization of production, technological innovations have also facilitated the globalization of markets. Low-cost global communications networks such as the World Wide Web are helping to create electronic global marketplaces. As noted above, low-cost transportation has made it more economical to ship products around the world, thereby helping to create global markets. For example, due to the tumbling costs of shipping goods by air, roses grown in Ecuador can be cut and sold in New York two days later while they are still fresh. This has given rise to an industry in Ecuador that did not exist 20 years ago and now supplies a global market for roses (see the accompanying Country Focus). In addition, low-cost jet travel has resulted in the mass movement of people between countries. This has reduced the cultural distance between countries and is bringing about some convergence of consumer tastes and preferences. At the same time, global communication networks and global media are creating a worldwide culture. U.S. television networks such as CNN, MTV, and HBO are now received in many countries, and Hollywood films are shown the world over. In any society, the media are primary conveyors of culture; as global media develop, we must expect the evolution of something akin to a global culture. A logical result of this evolution is the emergence of global markets for consumer products. The first signs of this are already apparent. It is now as easy to find a McDonald’s restaurant in Tokyo as it is in New York, to buy an iPod in Rio as it is in Berlin, and to buy Gap jeans in Paris as it is in San Francisco. Despite these trends, we must be careful not to overemphasize their importance. While modern communication and transportation technologies are ushering in the 16
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 16
12/7/06 6:34:50 PM
Country FOCUS Ecuadorean Valentine Roses It is 6:20 a.m. February 7, in the Ecuadorean town of Cayambe, and Maria Pacheco has just been dropped off for work by the company bus. She pulls on thick rubber gloves, wraps an apron over her white, traditional embroidered dress, and grabs her clippers, ready for another long day. Any other time of year, Maria would work until 2 p.m., but it’s a week before Valentine’s Day, and Maria along with her 84 coworkers at the farm are likely to be busy until 5 p.m. By then, Maria will have cut more than 1,000 rose stems. A few days later, after they have been refrigerated and shipped via aircraft, the roses Maria cut will be selling for premium prices in stores from New York to London. Ecuadorean roses are quickly becoming the Rolls-Royce of roses. They have huge heads and unusually vibrant colors, including 10 different reds, from bleeding heart crimson to a rosy lover’s blush. Most of Ecuador’s 460 or so rose farms are located in the Cayambe and Cotopaxi regions, 10,000 feet up in the Andes about an hour’s drive from the capital, Quito. The rose bushes are planted in huge flat fields at the foot of snowcapped volcanoes that rise to more than 20,000 feet. The bushes are protected by 20-foot-high canopies of plastic sheeting. The combination of intense sunlight, fertile volcanic soil, an equatorial location, and high altitude makes for ideal growing conditions, allowing roses to flower almost year-round. Ecuador’s rose industry started some 20 years ago and has been expanding rapidly since. Ecuador is now the world’s fourth-largest producer of roses. Roses are the nation’s fifth-largest export, with customers all over the world. Rose farms generate $240 million in sales and support tens of thousands of jobs. In Cayambe, the population has increased in 10 years from 10,000 to 70,000, primarily as a result of the rose industry. The revenues and taxes from rose growers have helped to pave roads, build schools, and construct sophisticated irrigation systems. In 2003, construction was to begin on an international airport between Quito and Cayambe from which Ecuadorean roses will begin their journey to flower shops all over the world. Maria works Monday to Saturday, and earns $210 a month, which she says is an average wage in Ecuador and substantially above the country’s $120 a month minimum wage. The farm also provides her with health care and a pension. By employing women such as Maria, the industry
has fostered a social revolution in which mothers and wives have more control over their family’s spending, especially on schooling for their children. For all of the benefits that roses have bought to Ecuador, where the gross national income per capita is only $1,080 a year, the industry has come under fire from environmentalists. Large growers have been accused of misusing a toxic mixture of pesticides, fungicides, and fumigants to grow and export unblemished pest-free flowers. Reports claim that workers often fumigate roses in street clothes without protective equipment. Some doctors and scientists claim that many of the industry’s 50,000 employees have serious health problems as a result of exposure to toxic chemicals. A study by the International Labor Organization claimed that women in the industry had more miscarriages than average and that some 60 percent of all workers suffered from headaches, nausea, blurred vision, and fatigue. Still, the critics acknowledge that their studies have been hindered by a lack of access to the farms, and they do not know what the true situation is. The International Labor Organization has also claimed that some rose growers in Ecuador use child labor, a claim that has been strenuously rejected by both the growers and Ecuadorean government agencies. In Europe, consumer groups have urged the European Union to press for improved environmental safeguards. In response, some Ecuadorean growers have joined a voluntary program aimed at helping customers identify responsible growers. The certification signifies that the grower has distributed protective gear, trained workers in using chemicals, and hired doctors to visit workers at least weekly. Other environmental groups have pushed for stronger sanctions, including trade sanctions, against Ecuadorean rose growers that are not environmentally certified by a reputable agency. On February 14, however, most consumers are oblivious to these issues; they simply want to show their appreciation to their wives and girlfriends with a perfect bunch of roses. Sources: G. Thompson, “Behind Roses’ Beauty, Poor and Ill Workers,” The New York Times, February 13, 2003, pp. A1, A27; J. Stuart, “You’ve Come a Long Way Baby,” The Independent, February 14, 2003, p. 1; V. Marino, “By Any Other Name, It’s Usually a Rosa,” The New York Times, May 11, 2003, p. A9; A. DePalma, “In Trade Issue, the Pressure Is on Flowers,” The New York Times, January 24, 2002, p. 1; and “The Search for Roses without Thorns,” The Economist, February 18, 2006, p. 38.
“global village,” significant national differences remain in culture, consumer preferences, and business practices. A firm that ignores differences between countries does so at its peril. We shall stress this point repeatedly throughout this book and elaborate on it in later chapters. Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 17
17
12/7/06 6:34:50 PM
The Changing Demographics of the Global Economy LEARNING OBJECTIVE 3 Appreciate the changing nature of the global economy.
Hand in hand with the trend toward globalization has been a fairly dramatic change in the demographics of the global economy over the past 30 years. As late as the 1960s, four stylized facts described the demographics of the global economy. The first was U.S. dominance in the world economy and world trade picture. The second was U.S. dominance in world foreign direct investment. Related to this, the third fact was the dominance of large, multinational U.S. firms on the international business scene. The fourth was that roughly half the globe—the centrally planned economies of the Communist world—were off-limits to Western international businesses. As will be explained below, all four of these qualities either have changed or are now changing rapidly.
THE CHANGING WORLD OUTPUT AND WORLD TRADE PICTURE In the early 1960s, the United States was still by far the world’s dominant industrial power. In 1963 the United States accounted for 40.3 percent of world output. By 2005, the United States accounted for 20.1 percent of world output, still by far the world’s largest industrial power but down significantly in relative size since the 1960s (see Table 1.2). Nor was the United States the only developed nation to see its relative standing slip. The same occurred to Germany, France, and the United Kingdom, all nations that were among the first to industrialize. This change in the U.S. position was not an absolute decline, since the U.S. economy grew at a robust average annual rate of more than 3 percent from 1963 to 2005 (the economies of Germany, France, and the United Kingdom also grew during this time). Rather, it was a relative decline, reflecting the faster economic growth of several other economies, particularly in Asia. For example, as can be seen from Table 1.2, from 1963 to 2005, China’s share of world output increased from a trivial amount to 15.4 percent. Other countries that markedly increased their share of world output included Japan, Thailand, Malaysia, Taiwan, and South Korea. By the end of the 1980s, the U.S. position as the world’s leading exporter was threatened. Over the past 30 years, U.S. dominance in export markets has waned as Japan, Germany, and a number of newly industrialized countries such as South Korea and China have taken a larger share of world exports. During the 1960s, the United States routinely accounted for 20 percent of world exports of manufactured goods. But as Table 1.2 shows, the U.S. share of world exports of goods and services had slipped to 10.1 percent by 2005. Despite the fall, the United States still remained the world’s
table
The Changing Demographics of World Output and Trade Sources: IMF, World Economic Outlook, April 2006. Data for 1963 are from N. Hood and J. Young, The Economics of the Multinational Enterprise (New York: Longman, 1973). The GDP data are based on purchasing power parity figures, which adjust the value of GDP to reflect the cost of living in various economies.
18
Share of World Output, 1963
Share of World Output, 2005
Share of World Exports, 2005
40.3%
20.1%
10.1%
Germany
9.7
4.1
9.0
France
6.3
3.0
4.4
Italy
3.4
2.7
3.6
United Kingdom
6.5
3.0
4.5
Canada
3.0
1.8
3.4
Japan
5.5
6.4
5.3
China
NA
15.4
6.7
1.2 Country United States
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 18
12/7/06 6:34:50 PM
largest exporter, ahead of Germany, Japan, France, and the fast-rising economic power, China. Another Perspective As emerging economies such as China, India, and Brazil continue to grow, a further relative India’s Tech Export Business decline in the share of world output and world Surges and EMC Gains India’s computer-software and services industry, which exports accounted for by the United States and started out about 20 years ago, undertaking routine outother long-established developed nations seems sourced office functions for companies based in the United likely. By itself, this is not bad. The relative decline States and United Kingdom, has extended its scope of opof the United States reflects the growing economic erations and grown into a $23.6 billion export business. The development and industrialization of the world industry employed 1.3 million people in 2006, according to economy, as opposed to any absolute decline in the National Association of Software and Service Compathe health of the U.S. economy, which by many nies (Nasscom), India’s lobbying group. They estimate measures is stronger than ever. 382,000 students will graduate with engineering qualificaMost forecasts now predict a rapid rise in the tions in 2006–2007. share of world output accounted for by developing EMC Corp, the world’s biggest maker of storage computnations such as China, India, Indonesia, Thailand, ers and software, plans to more than double its investment in India to $500 million by 2010 to expand sales, research, South Korea, Mexico, and Brazil, and a and the local market. Research will account for most of commensurate decline in the share enjoyed by rich EMC’s spending because India’s primary draw is the qualindustrialized countries such as Great Britain, ity of the country’s technology professionals. Wages are Germany, Japan, and the United States. If current about one-sixth of those in the united States. However, trends continue, by 2020 the Chinese economy EMC says there are countries lower in cost than India and could be larger than that of the United States, while that the company is going for quality investment. What do the economy of India will approach that of Germany you think? (Ashok Bhattacharjee, Bloomberg News, (see the Another Perspective box at right for details). June 21, 2006) The World Bank has estimated that today’s developing nations may account for more than 60 percent of world economic activity by 2020, while today’s rich nations, which currently account for more than 55 percent of world economic activity, may account for only about 38 percent. Forecasts are not always correct, but these suggest that a shift in the economic geography of the world is now underway, although the magnitude of that shift is not totally evident. For international businesses, the implications of this changing economic geography are clear: Many of tomorrow’s economic opportunities may be found in the developing nations of the world, and many of tomorrow’s most capable competitors will probably also emerge from these regions.
THE CHANGING FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT PICTURE Reflecting the dominance of the United States in the global economy, U.S. firms accounted for 66.3 percent of worldwide foreign direct investment flows in the 1960s. British firms were second, accounting for 10.5 percent, while Japanese firms were a distant eighth, with only 2 percent. The dominance of U.S. firms was so great that books were written about the economic threat posed to Europe by U.S. corporations.36 Several European governments, most notably France, talked of limiting inward investment by U.S. firms. However, as the barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and capital fell, and as other countries increased their shares of world output, non-U.S. firms increasingly began to invest across national borders. The motivation for much of this foreign direct investment by non-U.S. firms was the desire to disperse production activities to optimal locations and to build a direct presence in major foreign markets. Thus, beginning in the 1970s, European and Japanese firms began to shift labor-intensive manufacturing operations from their home markets to developing nations where labor costs were lower. In addition, many Japanese firms invested in North America and Europe—often as a hedge against unfavorable currency movements and the possible Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 19
19
12/7/06 6:34:51 PM
1figure
1.2
45.0
Percentage Share of Total FDI Stock, 1980–2004
40.0
Source: Calculated by author from data in United Nations, World Investment Report, 2005 (Geneva: United Nations, 2005).
35.0 30.0 25.0 20.0 15.0 10.0 5.0 0.0 United States
Stock of Foreign Direct Investment The total accumulated value of foreign-owned assets at a given time.
20
United Kingdom
Japan
Germany
1980
1990
France Netherland Developing economies
2004
imposition of trade barriers. For example, Toyota, the Japanese automobile company, rapidly increased its investment in automobile production facilities in the United States and Europe during the late 1980s and early 1990s. Toyota executives believed that an increasingly strong Japanese yen would price Japanese automobile exports out of foreign markets; therefore, production in the most important foreign markets, as opposed to exports from Japan, made sense. Toyota also undertook these investments to head off growing political pressures in the United States and Europe to restrict Japanese automobile exports into those markets. One consequence of thease developments is illustrated in Figure 1.2, which shows how the stock of foreign direct investment by the world’s six most important national sources—the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, the Netherlands, France, and Japan—changed between 1980 and 2003. (The stock of foreign direct investment refers to the total cumulative value of foreign investments.) Figure 1.2 also shows the stock accounted for by firms from developing economies. The share of the total stock accounted for by U.S. firms declined from about 38 percent in 1980 to 21 percent in 2004. Meanwhile, the shares accounted for by France and the world’s developing nations increased markedly. The rise in the share of FDI stock accounted for by developing nations reflects a growing trend for firms from these countries to invest outside their borders. In 2004, firms based in developing nations accounted for 10.6 percent of the stock of foreign direct investment, up from only 1.1 percent in 1980. Firms based in Hong Kong, South Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, and mainland China accounted for much of this investment. Figure 1.3 illustrates two other important trends—the sustained growth in cross-border flows of foreign direct investment that occurred during the 1990s and the importance of developing nations as the destination of foreign direct investment. Throughout the 1990s, the amount of investment directed at both developed and developing nations increased dramatically, a trend that reflects the increasing internationalization of business corporations. A surge in foreign direct investment from 1998 to 2000 was followed by a slump from 2001 to 2003 associated with a slowdown in global economic activity after the collapse of the financial bubble of the late 1990s and 2000. However, the growth of foreign direct investment resumed in 2004 and continued through 2005. Among
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 20
12/7/06 6:34:51 PM
1,600
figure
1,400
FDI Inflows 1988–2005
$ billions
1,200
1.3
Source: Calculated by author from data in United Nations, World Investment Report, 2005 (Geneva: United Nations, 2005). Data for 2005 are from United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, "Data Shows Foreign Direct Investment Climbed Sharply in 2005," press release, January 23, 2006.
1,000 800 600 400 200 0 1988⫺ 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 93 Developed countries
Developing countries
developing nations, the largest recipient of foreign direct investment has been China, which in 2004 and 2005 received $61 billion a year in inflows. As we shall see later in this book, the sustained flow of foreign investment into developing nations is an important stimulus for economic growth in those countries, which bodes well for the future of countries such as China, Mexico, and Brazil, all leading beneficiaries of this trend.
THE CHANGING NATURE OF THE MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISE A multinational enterprise (MNE) is any business that has productive activities in two or more countries. Since the 1960s, two notable trends in the demographics of the multinational enterprise have been (1) the rise of non-U.S. multinationals and (2) the growth of mini-multinationals.
Multinational Enterprise (MNE) Any business that has productive activities in two or more countries.
Non-U.S. Multinationals In the 1960s, global business activity was dominated by large U.S. multinational corporations. With U.S. firms accounting for about two-thirds of foreign direct investment during the 1960s, one would expect most multinationals to be U.S. enterprises. According to the data summarized in Figure 1.4 (see page 22), in 1973, 48.5 percent of the world’s 260 largest multinationals were U.S. firms. The secondlargest source country was the United Kingdom, with 18.8 percent of the largest multinationals. Japan accounted for 3.5 percent of the world’s largest multinationals at the time. The large number of U.S. multinationals reflected U.S. economic dominance in the three decades after World War II, while the large number of British multinationals reflected that country’s industrial dominance in the early decades of the twentieth century. By 2004 things had shifted significantly. Some 25 of the world’s 100 largest nonfinancial multinationals were now U.S. enterprises; 14 were French; 14, German; 12, British; and 9, Japanese. In terms of the global stock of foreign direct investment, 21 percent belonged to U.S. firms, 14 percent to British, 8 percent to French firms, 8.5 percent to German firms, 5.6 percent to Dutch firms, and 4 percent to Japanese.37 Although the 1973 data are not strictly comparable with the later data, they illustrate the trend (the 1973 figures are based on the largest 260 firms, whereas the later figures are based on the largest 100 multinationals). The globalization of the world economy has resulted in a relative decline in the dominance of U.S. firms in the global marketplace. According to UN data, the ranks of the world’s largest 100 multinationals are still dominated by firms from developed economies.38 However, four firms from developing economies entered the UN’s list of the 100 largest multinationals. They were Hutchison Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 21
21
12/22/06 8:52:08 PM
1figure
1.4
60
National Origin of Largest Multinational Enterprises, 1973 and 2004
50
Source: Calculated by author from data in United Nations, World Investment Report, 2005 (New York & Geneva: United Nations, 2005). The 1970 data are from N. Hood and J. Young, The Economics of the Multinational Enterprise (New York: Longman, 1973).
40
30
20
10
0 United States
Japan
United Kingdom
1973
France
Germany
Other
2004
Whampoa of Hong Kong, China, which ranked 16 in terms of foreign assets; Singtel of Singapore, which was ranked 66; Petronas of Malaysia; and Samsung of Korea.39 The growth in the number of multinationals from developing economies is evident when we look at smaller firms. By 2004, the largest 50 multinationals from developing economies had foreign sales of $202 billion out of total sales of $512 billion and employed 1.08 million people outside of their home countries. Some 60 percent of these companies came from China or countries with large ethnic Chinese population (20 percent from Hong Kong, 18 percent from Singapore, 16 percent from Taiwan, and 6 percent from mainland China). Other nations with multiple entries on the list included South Korea, Brazil, Mexico and Malaysia. We can reasonably expect more growth of new multinational enterprises from the world’s developing nations. Firms from developing nations can be expected to emerge as important competitors in global markets, further shifting the axis of the world economy away from North America and Western Europe and threatening the long dominance of Western companies. One such rising competitor, Lenovo of China, is profiled in the accompanying Management Focus.
The Rise of Mini-Multinationals Another trend in international business has been the growth of medium-size and small multinationals (mini-multinationals).40 When people think of international businesses, they tend to think of firms such as Exxon, General Motors, Ford, Fuji, Kodak, Matsushita, Procter & Gamble, Sony, and Unilever—large, complex multinational corporations with operations that span the globe. Although most international trade and investment is still conducted by large firms, many medium-size and small businesses are becoming increasingly involved in international trade and investment. For another example, consider Lubricating Systems, Inc., of Kent, Washington. Lubricating Systems, which manufactures lubricating fluids for machine tools, employs 22
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 22
12/7/06 6:34:52 PM
Management FOCUS China’s Lenovo Acquires IBM’s PC Operations In late 2004, the Chinese personal computer manufacturer Lenovo stunned the business world when it announced that it would acquire IBM’s PC operations for $1.25 billion. Lenovo, formerly known as Legend, was founded in 1984 by a group of young Chinese scientists with government financing. The company started as a distributor of computers and printers, selling IBM, ACT, and Hewlett-Packard brands. In the late 1980s, however, the company moved into manufacturing and began to design, make, and sell its own personal computers. Taking advantage of China’s low labor costs, Lenovo quickly emerged as a low-cost provider. By 2004, the company led the PC market in China, where it had a 26 percent share. But for Lenovo’s founders, this was not enough. They were worried about the entry of efficient foreign competitors, such as Dell, into the Chinese market. Lenovo might have low labor costs, but its 2.3 percent share of global PC sales left it trailing far behind Dell and Hewlett-Packard, which held 18.3 percent and 15.7 percent of the global market, respectively. Dell and HP could realize substantial economies of scale from their global volume. As a result, increasingly they were able to match Lenovo on costs. At the same time, Lenovo’s managers wondered whether it was time to expand internationally and turn Lenovo into a global brand. To deal with Dell at home, and expand into the global marketplace, Lenovo’s managers realized that they needed to do two things: (1) attain greater scale economies to further lower
costs, which meant more sales volume, and (2) match Western companies on product innovation, differentiation, and brand. Their solution was to acquire IBM’s PC business, which held 6 percent of the global market in 2004. The IBM purchase not only gave Lenovo potential scale economies and global reach, but it also brought Lenovo IBM’s renowned engineering skills, exemplified by the company’s best-selling line of ThinkPad laptop computers, and IBM’s extensive sales force and long-established customers. Top executives at Lenovo were smart enough to realize that the acquisition would have little value if IBM’s managers and engineers left the company, so they made another surprising decision—they moved Lenovo’s global headquarters to New York! Moreover, the former head of IBM’s PC division, Stephen Ward, was appointed CEO of Lenovo, while Yang Yuanqing, the former CEO of Lenovo, will become chairman, and Lenovo’s Mary Ma will be CFO. The 30-member top management team is split down the middle—half Chinese, half American—and boasts more women than men. English has been declared the company’s new business language. The goal, according to Yang, is to transform Lenovo into a truly global corporation capable of going head-to-head with Dell in the battle for dominance in the global PC business. Sources: D. Barboza, “An Unknown Giant Flexes Its Muscles,” The New York Times, December 4, 2004, pp. B1, B3; D. Roberts and L. Lee, “East Meets West,” BusinessWeek, May 9, 2005, pp. 1–4; and C. Forelle, “How IBM's Ward Will Lead China's Largest PC Company,” The Wall Street Journal, April 21, 2005, p. B1.
25 people and generates sales of $6.5 million. It’s hardly a large, complex multinational, yet more than $2 million of the company’s sales are generated by exports to a score of countries, including Japan, Israel, and the United Arab Emirates. Lubricating Systems also has set up a joint venture with a German company to serve the European market.41 Consider also Lixi, Inc., a small U.S. manufacturer of industrial X-ray equipment; 70 percent of Lixi’s $4.5 million in revenues comes from exports to Japan.42 Or take G.W. Barth, a manufacturer of cocoa-bean roasting machinery based in Ludwigsburg, Germany. Employing just 65 people, this small company has captured 70 percent of the global market for cocoa-bean roasting machines.43 See the Management Focus box above for a look at how Lenovo is entering the global PC market. International business is conducted not just by large firms but also by medium-size and small enterprises.
THE CHANGING WORLD ORDER Between 1989 and 1991 a series of remarkable democratic revolutions swept the Communist world. For reasons that are explored in more detail in Chapter 2, in country after country throughout Eastern Europe and eventually in the Soviet Union itself, Communist Party governments collapsed like the shells of rotten eggs. The Soviet Union is now receding into history, having been replaced by 15 independent republics. Czechoslovakia has divided itself Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 23
23
12/7/06 6:34:52 PM
into two states, while Yugoslavia dissolved into a bloody civil war, now thankfully over, among its five successor states. Many of the former Communist nations of Europe and Asia seem to share a commitment to democratic politics and free market economics. If this continues, the opportunities for international businesses may be enormous. For half a century, these countries were essentially closed to Western international businesses. Now they present a host of export and investment opportunities. Just how this will play out over the next 10 to 20 years is difficult to say. The economies of many of the former Communist states are still relatively undeveloped, and their continued commitment to democracy and free market economics cannot be taken for granted. Disturbing signs of growing unrest and totalitarian tendencies continue to be seen in several Eastern European and Central Asian states, including Russia, which under the government of Vladimir Putin has shown signs of shifting back toward greater state involvement in economic activity.44 Thus, the risks involved in doing business in such countries are high, but so may be the returns. In addition to these changes, more quiet revolutions have been occurring in China and Latin America. Their implications for international businesses may be just as profound as the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe. China suppressed its own pro-democracy movement in the bloody Tiananmen Square massacre of 1989. Despite this, China continues to move progressively toward greater free market reforms. If what is occurring in China continues for two more decades, China may move from Third World to industrial superpower status even more rapidly than Japan did. If China’s gross domestic product (GDP) per capita grows by an average of 6 to 7 percent, which is slower than the 8 percent growth rate achieved during the last decade, then by 2020 this nation of 1.273 billion people could boast an average income per capita of about $13,000, roughly equivalent to that of Spain’s today. The potential consequences for international business are enormous. On the one hand, with more than 1 billion people, China represents a huge and largely untapped market. Reflecting this, between 1983 and 2005, annual foreign direct investment in China increased from less than $2 billion to $61 billion. On the other hand, China’s new firms are proving to be very capable competitors, and they could take global market share away from Western and Japanese enterprises (for example, see the Management Focus about Lenovo). Thus, the changes in China are creating both opportunities and threats for established international businesses. As for Latin America, both democracy and free market reforms also seem to have taken hold. For decades, most Latin American countries were ruled Another Perspective by dictators, many of whom seemed to view Western international businesses as instruments of Economic Freedom and Globalization: A Different Picture imperialist domination. Accordingly, they restricted The Frasier Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World direct investment by foreign firms. In addition, the Report, which measures economic freedom using poorly managed economies of Latin America were 38 variables, indicates a strong correlation between characterized by low growth, high debt, and economic freedom, per capita growth, and life expectancy. hyperinflation—all of which discouraged investment In the 2005 report, Hong Kong has the highest rating for by international businesses. In the last two decades economic freedom (8.7 of 10) closely followed by Singapore much of this had changed. Throughout most of (8.5). New Zealand, Switzerland, and the United States tied Latin America, debt and inflation are down, for third with ratings of 8.2. Botswana’s ranking of 30 is the governments have sold state-owned enterprises to highest-ranking African economy and ranks higher than private investors, foreign investment is welcomed, France (38) and Italy (54). See the 2005 report results and and the region’s economies have expanded. Brazil, data at www.freetheworld.com. Mexico, and Chile have led the way here. These 24
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 24
12/7/06 6:34:52 PM
changes have increased the attractiveness of Latin America, both as a market for exports and as a site for foreign direct investment. At the same time, given the long history of economic mismanagement in Latin America, there is no guarantee that these favorable trends will continue. Indeed, in Bolivia and Venezuela there have been shifts back toward greater state involvement in industry in the last few years, and foreign investment is now less welcome than it was during the 1990s. In both nations, the government has seized control of oil and gas fields from foreign investors and has limited the rights of foreign energy companies to extract oil and gas from their nations. Thus, as in the case of Eastern Europe, substantial opportunities are accompanied by substantial risks.
THE GLOBAL ECONOMY OF THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY As discussed, the past quarter century has seen rapid changes in the global economy. Barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and capital have been coming down. The volume of cross-border trade and investment has been growing more rapidly than global output, indicating that national economies are becoming more closely integrated into a single, interdependent, global economic system. As their economies advance, more nations are joining the ranks of the developed world. A generation ago, South Korea and Taiwan were viewed as second-tier developing nations. Now they boast large economies, and their firms are major players in many global industries, from shipbuilding and steel to electronics and chemicals. The move toward a global economy has been further strengthened by the widespread adoption of liberal economic policies by countries that had firmly opposed them for two generations or more. Thus, in keeping with the normative prescriptions of liberal economic ideology, in country after country we have seen state-owned businesses privatized, widespread deregulation adopted, markets opened to more competition, and commitment increased to removing barriers to cross-border trade and investment. This suggests that over the next few decades, countries such as the Czech Republic, Mexico, Poland, Brazil, China, India, and South Africa may build powerful market-oriented economies. In short, current trends indicate that the world is moving rapidly toward an economic system that is more favorable for international business. But it is always hazardous to use established trends to predict the future. The world may be moving toward a more global economic system, but globalization is not inevitable. Countries may pull back from the recent commitment to liberal economic ideology if their experiences do not match their expectations. Periodic signs, for example, indicate a retreat from liberal economic ideology in Russia. Russia has experienced considerable economic pain as it tries to shift from a centrally planned economy to a market economy. If Russia’s hesitation were to become more permanent and widespread, the liberal vision of a more prosperous global economy based on free market principles might not occur as quickly as many hope. Clearly, this would be a tougher world for international businesses. Another Perspective Also, greater globalization brings with it risks of its own. This was starkly demonstrated in 1997 Globalization and Complexity and 1998 when a financial crisis in Thailand Another way to understand globalization is to think of it as spread first to other East Asian nations and then the result of our increasing ability to deal with complexity. in 1998 to Russia and Brazil. Ultimately, the crisis Some cultures such as the Chinese, Japanese, and Middle threatened to plunge the economies of the Eastern (see Chapter 3 for high context and high power developed world, including the United States, distance) are inclined to work well with complexity. Will into a recession. We explore the causes and these cultural traits serve as a comparative advantage as consequences of this and other similar global globalization proceeds? financial crises in Chapter 10. Even from a purely Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 25
25
12/7/06 6:34:52 PM
economic perspective, globalization is not all good. The opportunities for doing business in a global economy may be significantly enhanced, but as we saw in 1997–98, the risks associated with global financial contagion are also greater. Still, as explained later in this book, firms can exploit the opportunities associated with globalization, while at the same time reducing the risks through appropriate hedging strategies.
The Globalization Debate LEARNING OBJECTIVE 4 Understand the main arguments in the debate over the impact of globalization.
Is the shift toward a more integrated and interdependent global economy a good thing? Many influential economists, politicians, and business leaders seem to think so.45 They argue that falling barriers to international trade and investment are the twin engines driving the global economy toward greater prosperity. They say increased international trade and cross-border investment will result in lower prices for goods and services. They believe that globalization stimulates economic growth, raises the incomes of consumers, and helps to create jobs in all countries that participate in the global trading system. The arguments of those who support globalization are covered in detail in Chapters 5, 6, and 7. As we shall see, there are good theoretical reasons for believing that declining barriers to international trade and investment do stimulate economic growth, create jobs, and raise income levels. As described in Chapters 6 and 7, empirical evidence lends support to the predictions of this theory. However, despite the existence of a compelling body of theory and evidence, globalization has its critics.46 Some of these critics have become increasingly vocal and active, taking to the streets to demonstrate their opposition to globalization. Here we look at the rising tide of protests against globalization and briefly review the main themes of the debate concerning the merits of globalization. In later chapters we elaborate on many of the points mentioned below.
ANTIGLOBALIZATION PROTESTS Street demonstrations against globalization date to December 1999, when more than 40,000 protesters blocked the streets of Seattle in an attempt to shut down a World Trade Organization meeting being held in the city. The demonstrators were protesting against a wide range of issues, including job losses in industries under attack from foreign competitors, downward pressure on the wage rates of unskilled workers, environmental degradation, and the cultural imperialism of global media and multinational enterprises, which was seen as being dominated by what some protesters called the “culturally impoverished” interests and values of the United States. All of these ills, the demonstrators claimed, could be laid at the feet of globalization. The World Trade Organization was meeting to try to launch a new round of talks to cut barriers to cross-border trade and investment. As such, it was seen as a promoter of globalization and a legitimate target for the antiglobalization protesters. The protests turned violent, transforming the normally placid streets of Seattle into a running battle between “anarchists” and Seattle’s bemused and poorly prepared police department. Pictures of brick-throwing protesters and armored police wielding their batons were duly recorded by the global media, which then circulated the images around the world. Meanwhile, the World Trade Organization meeting failed to reach agreement, and although the protests outside the meeting halls had little to do with that failure, the impression took hold that the demonstrators had succeeded in derailing the meetings. Emboldened by the experience in Seattle, antiglobalization protesters now turn up at almost every major meeting of a global institution. Smaller scale protests have occurred in several countries, such as France, where antiglobalization activists destroyed a McDonald’s restaurant in August 1999 to protest the impoverishment of French culture by American imperialism (see the Country Focus, “Protesting Globalization in 26
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 26
12/7/06 6:34:53 PM
Demonstrators at the WTO meeting in Seattle in December 1999 began looting and rioting in the city’s downtown area. Why do you think they felt that behavior was necessary? Daniel Sheehan/Getty Images
France,” for details). While violent protests may give the antiglobalization effort a bad name, it is clear from the scale of the demonstrations that support for the cause goes beyond a core of anarchists. Large segments of the population in many countries believe that globalization has detrimental effects on living standards and the environment, and the media have often fed on this fear. In 2004 and 2005, for example, CNN news anchor Lou Dobbs ran a series that was highly critical of the trend by American companies to take advantage of globalization and “export jobs” overseas. Both theory and evidence suggest that many of these fears are exaggerated, but this may not have been communicated clearly and both politicians and businesspeople need to do more to counter these fears. Many protests against globalization are tapping into a general sense of loss at the passing of a world in which barriers of time and distance, and vast differences in economic institutions, political institutions, and the level of development of different nations, produced a world rich in the diversity of human cultures. This world is now passing into history. However, while the rich citizens of the developed world may have the luxury of mourning the fact that they can now see McDonald’s restaurants and Starbucks coffeehouses on their vacations to exotic locations such as Thailand, fewer complaints are heard from the citizens of those countries, who welcome the higher living standards that progress brings.
GLOBALIZATION, JOBS, AND INCOME One concern frequently voiced by globalization opponents is that falling barriers to international trade destroy manufacturing jobs in wealthy advanced economies such as the United States and the United Kingdom. The critics argue that falling trade barriers allow firms to move manufacturing activities to countries where wage rates are much lower.47 D.L. Bartlett and J.B. Steele, two journalists for the Philadelphia Inquirer who gained notoriety for their attacks on free trade, cite the case of Harwood Industries, a U.S. clothing manufacturer that closed its U.S. operations, where it paid workers $9 per hour, and shifted manufacturing to Honduras, where textile workers receive 48 cents per hour.48 Because of moves such as this, argue Bartlett and Steele, the wage rates of poorer Americans have fallen significantly over the past quarter of a century. Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 27
27
12/7/06 6:34:53 PM
Country FOCUS Protesting Globalization in France One night in August 1999, 10 men under the leadership of local sheep farmer and rural activist Jose Bove crept into the town of Millau in central France and vandalized a McDonald’s restaurant under construction, causing an estimated $150,000 damage. These were no ordinary vandals, however, at least according to their supporters, for the “symbolic dismantling” of the McDonald’s outlet had noble aims, or so it was claimed. The attack was initially presented as a protest against unfair American trade policies. The European Union had banned imports of hormone-treated beef from the United States, primarily because of fears that it might lead to health problems (although EU scientists had concluded there was no evidence of this). After a careful review, the World Trade Organization stated the EU ban was not allowed under trading rules that the EU and United States were party to, and that the EU would have to lift it or face retaliation. The EU refused to comply, so the U.S. government imposed a 100 percent tariff on imports of certain EU products, including French staples such as foie gras, mustard, and Roquefort cheese. On farms near Millau, Bove and others raised sheep whose milk was used to make Roquefort. They felt incensed by the American tariff and decided to vent their frustrations on McDonald’s. Bove and his compatriots were arrested and charged. They quickly became a focus of the antiglobalization movement in France that was protesting everything from a loss of national sovereignty and “unfair” trade policies that were trying to force hormone-treated beef on French consumers, to the invasion of French culture by alien American values, so aptly symbolized by McDonald’s. Lionel Jospin, France’s prime minister, called the cause of Jose Bove “just.” Allowed to remain free pending his trial, Bove traveled to Seattle in December to protest against the World Trade Organization, where he was feted as a hero of the antiglobalization movement. In France, Bove’s July 2000 trial drew some 40,000 supporters to the small town of Millau, where they camped outside the courthouse and waited for the verdict. Bove was found guilty and sentenced to three months in jail, far less than the maximum possible sentence of five years. His supporters wore T-shirts claiming, “The world is not merchandise, and neither am I.”
About the same time in the Languedoc region of France, California winemaker Robert Mondavi had reached agreement with the mayor and council of the village of Aniane and regional authorities to turn 125 acres of wooded hillside belonging to the village into a vineyard. Mondavi planned to invest $7 million in the project and hoped to produce top-quality wine that would sell in Europe and the United States for $60 a bottle. However, local environmentalists objected to the plan, which they claimed would destroy the area’s unique ecological heritage. Jose Bove, basking in sudden fame, offered his support to the opponents, and the protests started. In May 2001, the Socialist mayor who had approved the project was defeated in local elections in which the Mondavi project had become the major issue. He was replaced by a Communist, Manuel Diaz, who denounced the project as a capitalist plot designed to enrich wealthy U.S. shareholders at the cost of his villagers and the environment. Following Diaz’s victory, Mondavi announced he would pull out of the project. A spokesman noted, “It’s a huge waste, but there are clearly personal and political interests at play here that go way beyond us.” So are the French opposed to foreign investment? The experience of McDonald’s and Mondavi seems to suggest so, as does the associated news coverage, but look closer and a different reality seems to emerge. McDonald’s has more than 800 restaurants in France and continues to do very well there. In fact, France is one of the most profitable markets for McDonald’s. France has long been one of the most favored locations for inward foreign direct investment, receiving over $100 billion of foreign investment between 2003 and 2005, more than any other European nation with the exception of Britain. American companies have always accounted for a significant percentage of this investment. Moreover, French enterprises have also been significant foreign investors; some 1,100 French multinationals account for around 8 percent of the global stock of foreign direct investment. Sources: “Behind the Bluster,” The Economist, May 26, 2001; “The French Farmers’ Anti-global Hero,” The Economist, July 8, 2000; C. Trueheart, “France’s Golden Arch Enemy?” Toronto Star, July 1, 2000; J. Henley, “Grapes of Wrath Scare Off U.S. Firm,” The Economist, May 18, 2001, p. 11; and United Nations, World Investment Report, 2005 (New York and Geneva: United Nations, 2005).
In the last few years, the same fears have been applied to services, which have increasingly been outsourced to nations with lower labor costs. The popular feeling is that when corporations such as Dell, IBM, or Citigroup outsource service activities to lower-cost foreign suppliers—as all three have done—they are “exporting jobs” to low-wage nations and contributing to higher unemployment and lower living standards in their home nations (in this case, the United States). Some lawmakers in the 28
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 28
12/7/06 6:34:54 PM
United States have responded by calling for legal barriers to job outsourcing. Supporters of globalization reply that critics of these trends miss the essential point about free trade— the benefits outweigh the costs.49 They argue that free trade will result in countries specializing in the production of those goods and services that they can produce most efficiently, while importing goods and services that they cannot produce as efficiently. When a country embraces free trade, there is always some dislocation—lost textile jobs at Harwood Industries, or lost call center jobs at Dell—but the whole economy is better off as a result. According to this view, it makes By outsourcing its customer service call centers to India, Dell can little sense for the United States to produce textiles at reduce its cost structure and pass on the savings to their customers. home when they can be produced at a lower cost in STR/AFP/Getty Images Honduras or China (which, unlike Honduras, is a major source of U.S. textile imports). Importing textiles from China leads to lower prices for clothes in the United States, which enables consumers to spend more of their money on other items. At the same time, the increased income generated in China from textile exports increases income levels in that country, which helps the Chinese to purchase more products produced in the United States, such as pharmaceuticals from Amgen, Boeing jets, Intel-based computers, Microsoft software, and Cisco routers. The same argument can be made to support the outsourcing of services to low-wage countries. By outsourcing its customer service call centers to India, Dell can reduce its cost structure, and thereby its prices for PCs. U.S. consumers benefit from this development. As prices for PCs fall, Americans can spend more of their money on other goods and services. Moreover, the increase in income levels in India allows Indians to purchase more U.S. goods and services, which helps to create jobs in the United States. In this manner, supporters of globalization argue that free trade benefits all countries that adhere to a free trade regime. Nevertheless, some supporters of globalization concede that the wage rate enjoyed by unskilled workers in many advanced economies may have declined in recent years.50 However, the evidence on this is decidedly mixed.51 A U.S. Federal Reserve study found that in the seven years preceding 1996, the earnings of the best-paid 10 percent of U.S. workers rose in real terms by 0.6 percent annually while the earnings of the 10 percent at the bottom of the heap fell by 8 percent. In some areas, the fall was much greater.52 Another study of long-term trends in income distribution concluded, Nationwide, from the late 1970s to the late 1990s, the average income of the lowest-income families fell by over 6 percent after adjustment for inflation, and the average real income of the middle fifth of families grew by about 5 percent. By contrast, the average real income of the highest-income fifth of families increased by over 30 percent.53 While globalization critics argue that the decline in unskilled wage rates is due to the migration of low-wage manufacturing jobs offshore and a corresponding reduction in demand for unskilled workers, supporters of globalization see a more complex picture. They maintain that the apparent decline in real wage rates of unskilled workers owes far more to a technology-induced shift within advanced economies away from jobs where the only qualification was a willingness to turn up for work every day and toward jobs that require significant education and skills. They point out that many advanced economies report a shortage of highly skilled workers and an excess supply of unskilled workers. Thus, growing income inequality is a result of the wages for Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 29
29
12/7/06 6:34:54 PM
skilled workers being bid up by the labor market and the wages for unskilled workers being discounted. If one agrees with this logic, a solution to the problem of declining incomes is to be found not in limiting free trade and globalization, but in increasing society’s investment in education to reduce the supply of unskilled workers.54 Some research also suggests that the evidence of growing income inequality may be suspect. Robert Lerman of the Urban Institute believes that the finding of inequality is based on inappropriate calculations of wage rates. Reviewing the data using a different methodology, Lerman has found that far from income inequality increasing, an index of wage rate inequality for all workers actually fell by 5.5 percent between 1987 and 1994.55 A 2002 study by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, whose members include the 20 richest economies in the world, also suggests a more complex picture. The study noted that while the gap between the poorest and richest segments of society in some OECD countries had widened, this trend was by no means universal.56 In the United States, for example, the OECD study found that while income inequality increased from the mid-1970s to the mid-1980s, it did not widen further in the next decade. The report also notes that in almost all countries, real income levels rose over the 20-year period looked at in the study, including the incomes of the poorest segment of most OECD societies. To add to the mixed research results, a 2002 U.S. study that included data from 1990 to 2000 concluded that during those years, falling unemployment rates brought gains to low-wage workers and fairly broad-based wage growth, especially in the latter half of the 1990s. The income of the worst-paid 10 percent of the population actually rose twice as fast as that of the average worker during 1998–2000.57 If such trends continued into the 2000s—and they may not have—the argument that globalization leads to growing income inequality may lose some of its punch.
GLOBALIZATION, LABOR POLICIES, AND THE ENVIRONMENT A second source of concern is that free trade encourages firms from advanced nations to move manufacturing facilities to less developed countries that lack adequate regulations to protect labor and the environment from abuse by the unscrupulous.58 Globalization critics often argue that adhering to labor and environmental regulations significantly increases the costs of manufacturing enterprises and puts them at a competitive disadvantage in the global marketplace vis-à-vis firms based in developing nations that do not have to comply with such regulations. Firms deal with this cost disadvantage, the theory goes, by moving their production facilities to nations that do not have such burdensome regulations or that fail to enforce the regulations they have. If this were the case, one might expect free trade to lead to an increase in pollution and result in firms from advanced nations exploiting the labor of less developed nations.59 This argument was used repeatedly by those who opposed the 1994 formation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) between Canada, Mexico, and the United States. They painted a picture of U.S. manufacturing firms moving to Mexico in droves so that they would be free to pollute the environment, employ child labor, and ignore workplace safety and health issues, all in the name of higher profits.60 Supporters of free trade and greater globalization express doubts about this scenario. They argue that tougher environmental regulations and stricter labor standards go hand in hand with economic progress.61 In general, as countries get richer, they enact tougher environmental and labor regulations.62 Because free trade enables developing countries to increase their economic growth rates and become richer, this should lead to tougher environmental and labor laws. In this view, the critics of free trade have got it backward—free trade does not lead to more pollution and labor exploitation, it leads to less. By creating wealth and incentives for enterprises to produce technological innovations, the free market system and free trade could make it easier for the world to cope with pollution and population growth. Indeed, while pollution levels are rising 30
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 30
12/7/06 6:34:55 PM
figure
1.5
Income Levels and Environmental Pollution
Pollution Levels
Carbon dioxide emissions
Other pollutants
$8,000
Income per Capita
in the world’s poorer countries, they have been falling in developed nations. In the United States, for example, the concentration of carbon monoxide and sulphur dioxide pollutants in the atmosphere decreased by 60 percent between 1978 and 1997, while lead concentrations decreased by 98 percent—and these reductions have occurred against a background of sustained economic expansion.63 A number of econometric studies have found consistent evidence of a hump-shaped relationship between income levels and pollution levels (see Figure 1.5).64 As an economy grows and income levels rise, initially pollution levels also rise. However, past some point, rising income levels lead to demands for greater environmental protection, and pollution levels then fall. A seminal study by Grossman and Krueger found that the turning point generally occurred before per capita income levels reached $8,000.65 While the hump-shaped relationship depicted in Figure 1.5 seems to hold across a wide range of pollutants—from sulphur dioxide to lead concentrations and water quality—carbon dioxide emissions are an important exception, rising steadily with higher income levels. Given that increased atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations are implicated in global warming, this should be a concern. The solution to the problem, however, is probably not to roll back the trade liberalization efforts that have fostered economic growth and globalization, but to get the nations of the world to agree to tougher standards on limiting carbon emissions. Although UN-sponsored talks have had this as a central aim since the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, there has been little success in moving toward the ambitious goals for reducing carbon emissions laid down in the Earth Summit and subsequent talks in Kyoto, Japan, in part because the largest emitter of carbon dioxide, the United States, has refused to sign global agreements that it claims would unreasonably retard economic growth. Supporters of free trade also point out that it is possible to tie free trade agreements to the implementation of tougher environmental and labor laws in less developed countries. NAF TA, for example, was passed only after side agreements had been negotiated that committed Mexico to tougher enforcement of environmental protection regulations. Thus, supporters of free trade argue that factories based in Mexico are now cleaner than they would have been without the passage of NAFTA.66 They also argue that business firms are not the amoral organizations that critics suggest. While there may be some rotten apples, most business enterprises are staffed by managers who are committed to behave in an ethical manner and would be unlikely to move production offshore just so they could pump more pollution Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 31
31
12/7/06 6:34:56 PM
into the atmosphere or exploit labor. Furthermore, the relationship between pollution, labor exploitation, and production costs may not be that suggested by critics. In general, a well-treated labor force is productive, and it is productivity rather than base wage rates that often has the greatest influence on costs. The vision of greedy managers who shift production to low-wage countries to exploit their labor force may be misplaced.
GLOBALIZATION AND NATIONAL SOVEREIGNTY Another concern voiced by critics of globalization is that today’s increasingly interdependent global economy shifts economic power away from national governments and toward supranational organizations such as the World Trade Organization, the European Union, and the United Nations. As perceived by critics, unelected bureaucrats now impose policies on the democratically elected governments of nation-states, thereby undermining the sovereignty of those states and limiting the nation’s ability to control its own destiny.67 The World Trade Organization is a favorite target of those who attack the headlong rush toward a global economy. As noted earlier, the W TO was founded in 1994 to police the world trading system established by the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. The W TO arbitrates trade disputes between the 149 states that are signatories to the GAT T. The arbitration panel can issue a ruling instructing a member state to change trade policies that violate GAT T regulations. If the violator refuses to comply with the ruling, the W TO allows other states to impose appropriate trade sanctions on the transgressor. As a result, according to one prominent critic, U.S. environmentalist, consumer rights advocate, and presidential candidate Ralph Nader: Under the new system, many decisions that affect billions of people are no longer made by local or national governments but instead, if challenged by any W TO member nation, would be deferred to a group of unelected bureaucrats sitting behind closed doors in Geneva (which is where the headquarters of the W TO are located). The bureaucrats can decide whether or not people in California can prevent the destruction of the last virgin forests or determine if carcinogenic pesticides can be banned from their foods; or whether European countries have the right to ban dangerous biotech hormones in meat. . . . At risk is the very basis of democracy and accountable decision making.68 In contrast to Nader’s rhetoric, many economists and politicians maintain that the power of supranational organizations such as the W TO is limited to what nation-states collectively agree to grant. They argue that bodies such as the United Nations and the WTO exist to serve the collective interests of member states, not to subvert those interests. Supporters of supranational organizations point out that the power of these bodies rests largely on their ability to persuade member states to follow a certain action. If these bodies fail to serve the collective interests of member states, those states will withdraw their support and the supranational organization will quickly collapse. In this view, real power still resides with individual nation-states, not supranational organizations. GLOBALIZATION AND THE WORLD’S POOR Critics of globalization argue that despite the supposed benefits associated with free trade and investment, over the past hundred years or so the gap between the rich and poor nations of the world has gotten wider. In 1870, the average income per capita in the world’s 17 richest nations was 2.4 times that of all other countries. In 1990, the same group was 4.5 times as rich as the rest.69 While recent history has shown that some of the world’s poorer nations are capable of rapid periods of economic growth— witness the transformation 32
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 32
12/7/06 6:34:56 PM
that has occurred in some Southeast Asian nations such as South Korea, Thailand, and Malaysia—there appear to be strong forces for stagnation among the world’s poorest nations. A quarter of the countries with a GDP per capita of less than $1,000 in 1960 had growth rates of less than zero from 1960 to 1995, and a third had growth rates of less than 0.05 percent.70 Critics argue that if globalization is such a positive development, this divergence between the rich and poor should not have occurred. Although the reasons for economic stagnation vary, several factors stand out, none of which have anything to do with free trade or globalization.71 Many of the world’s poorest countries have suffered from totalitarian governments, economic policies that destroyed wealth rather than facilitated its creation, endemic corruption, scant protection for property rights, and war. Such factors help explain why countries such as Afghanistan, Cambodia, Cuba, Haiti, Iraq, Libya, Nigeria, Sudan, Vietnam, and Zaire have failed to improve the economic lot of their citizens during recent decades. A complicating factor is the rapidly expanding populations in many of these countries. Without a major change in government, population growth may exacerbate their problems. Promoters of free trade argue that the best way for these countries to improve their lot is to lower their barriers to free trade and investment and to implement economic policies based on free market economics.72 Many of the world’s poorer nations are being held back by large debt burdens. Of particular concern are the 40 or so “highly indebted poorer countries” (HIPCs), which are home to some 700 million people. Among these countries, the average government debt burden is equivalent to 85 percent of the value of the economy, as measured by gross domestic product, and the annual costs of serving government debt consumes 15 percent of the country’s export earnings.73 Servicing such a heavy debt load leaves the governments of these countries with little left to invest in important public infrastructure projects, such as education, health care, roads, and power. The result is the HIPCs are trapped in a cycle of poverty and debt that inhibits economic development. Free trade alone, some argue, is a necessary but not sufficient prerequisite to help these countries bootstrap themselves out of poverty. Instead, large-scale debt relief is needed for the world’s poorest nations to give them the opportunity to restructure their economies and start the long climb toward prosperity. Supporters of debt relief also argue that new democratic governments in poor
Even as India makes strides towards economic development, it continues to carry a high budget deficit that cannot meet the needs of its soaring population. Dr. Parvinder Sethi/DIL
Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 33
33
12/7/06 8:09:54 PM
nations should not be forced to honor debts that were incurred and mismanaged long ago by their Another Perspective corrupt and dictatorial predecessors. In the late 1990s, a debt relief movement began A Question of Debt in Emerging, to gain ground among the political establishment Poor Economies The Group of Eight Nations (G-8)—United States, Russia, in the world’s richer nations.74 Fueled by highFrance, Japan, Germany, Italy, Canada, and the United profile endorsements from Irish rock star Bono Kingdom—canceled about $60 billion of debt owed them in (who has been a tireless and increasingly effective 2005 by the world’s poorest countries, known as the highly advocate for debt relief ), Pope John Paul II, the indebted poor countries, or HIPCs. However, in 2006, Dalai Lama, and influential Harvard economist emerging lenders such as China, India, Brazil, and South Jeffrey Sachs, the debt relief movement was inKorea are offering preferential loans and export credits to strumental in persuading the United States to enthese same poor nations. The emerging lenders want to act legislation in 2000 that provided $435 million sell infrastructure-related exports into the HIPCs. China in debt relief for HIPCs. More important perhaps, has announced $10 billion in these loans and credits. the United States also backed an IMF plan to sell These loans and credits don’t sit too well with the G-8 some of its gold reserves and use the proceeds to finance ministers who have just issued debt relief to these same poor countries. They take the position that it is help with debt relief. The IMF and World Bank imperative to prevent the buildup of unsustainable debt in have now picked up the banner and have embarked HIPCs. A World Bank study found that eight former HIPCs— on a systematic debt relief program (see Another including Uganda, Bolivia, Nicaragua. and Ethiopia—are Perspective box at left). again facing debt problems. The challenge continues: Will For such a program to have a lasting effect, howthis continued debt activity help or hinder HIPC economies? ever, debt relief must be matched by wise investment (Michael. Phillips, “G8 Warns China about Loans to in public projects that boost economic growth (such Poorest Nations,” The Wall Street Journal, June 12, 2006, as education) and by the adoption of economic polihttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB115005845957077212.html) cies that facilitate investment and trade. The rich nations of the world also can help by reducing barriers to the importation of products from the world’s poorer nations, particularly tariffs on imports of agricultural products and textiles. High tariff barriers and other impediments to trade make it difficult for poor countries to export more of their agricultural production. The World Trade Organization has estimated that if the developed nations of the world eradicated subsidies to their agricultural producers and removed tariff barriers to trade in agriculture this would raise global economic welfare by $128 billion, with $30 billion of that going to developing nations, many of which are highly indebted. The faster growth associated with expanded trade in agriculture could reduce the number of people living in poverty by as much as 13 percent by 2015, according to the WTO.75 Debt relief is not new; it has been tried before.76 Too often in the past, however, the short-term benefits were squandered by corrupt governments who used their newfound financial freedom to make unproductive investments in military infrastructure or grandiose projects that did little to foster long-run economic development. Developed nations contributed to past failures by refusing to open their markets to the products of poor nations. If such a scenario can be avoided this time, the entire world will benefit.
Managing in the Global Marketplace LEARNING OBJECTIVE 5 Appreciate how the process of globalization is creating opportunities and challenges for business managers.
34
Much of this book is concerned with the challenges of managing in an international business. An international business is any firm that engages in international trade or investment. A firm does not have to become a multinational enterprise, investing directly in operations in other countries, to engage in international business, although multinational enterprises are international businesses. All a firm has to do is export or import products from other countries. As the world shifts toward a truly integrated global economy, more firms, both large and small, are becoming international businesses. What does this shift toward a global economy mean for managers within an international business?
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 34
12/7/06 6:34:56 PM
As their organizations increasingly engage in cross-border trade and investment, managers need to recognize that the task of managing an international business differs from that of managing a purely domestic business in many ways. At the most fundamental level, the differences arise from the simple fact that countries are different. Countries differ in their cultures, political systems, economic systems, legal systems, and levels of economic development. Despite all the talk about the emerging global village, and despite the trend toward globalization of markets and production, as we shall see in this book, many of these differences are very profound and enduring. Differences between countries require that an international business vary its practices country by country. Marketing a product in Brazil may require a different approach from marketing the product in Germany; managing U.S. workers might require different skills than managing Japanese workers; maintaining close relations with a particular level of government may be very important in Mexico and irrelevant in Great Britain; the business strategy pursued in Canada might not work in South Korea; and so on. Managers in an international business must not only be sensitive to these differences, but they must also adopt the appropriate policies and strategies for coping with them. Much of this book is devoted to explaining the sources of these differences and the methods for successfully coping with them. A further way in which international business differs from domestic business is the greater complexity of managing an international business. In addition to the problems that arise from the differences between countries, a manager in an international business is confronted with a range of other issues that the manager in a domestic business never confronts. The managers of an international business must decide where in the world to site production activities to minimize costs and to maximize value added. They must decide whether it is ethical to adhere to the lower labor and environmental standards found in many less-developed nations. Then they must decide how best to coordinate and control globally dispersed production activities (which, as we shall see later in the book, is not a trivial problem). The managers in an international business also must decide which foreign markets to enter and which to avoid. They must choose the appropriate mode for entering a particular foreign country. Is it best to export its product to the foreign country? Should the firm allow a local company to produce its product under license in that country? Should the firm enter into a joint venture with a local firm to produce its product in that country? Or should the firm set up a wholly owned subsidiary to serve the market in that country? As we shall see, the choice of entry mode is critical because it has major implications for the long-term health of the firm. Conducting business transactions across national borders requires understanding the rules governing the international trading and investment system. Managers in an international business must also deal with government restrictions on international trade and investment. They must find ways to work within the limits imposed by specific governmental interventions. As this book explains, even though many governments are nominally committed to free trade, they often intervene to regulate cross-border trade and investment. Managers within international businesses must develop strategies and policies for dealing with such interventions. Cross-border transactions also require that money be converted from the firm’s home currency into a foreign currency and vice versa. Because currency exchange rates vary in response to changing economic conditions, managers in an international business must develop policies for dealing with exchange rate movements. A firm that adopts a wrong policy can lose large amounts of money, whereas one that adopts the right policy can increase the profitability of its international transactions. In sum, managing an international business is different from managing a purely domestic business for at least four reasons: (1) countries are different, (2) the range of problems confronted by a manager in an international business is wider and the
International Business Any firm that engages in international trade or investment.
Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 35
35
12/7/06 6:34:56 PM
problems themselves more complex than those confronted by a manager in a domestic business, (3) an international business must find ways to work within the limits imposed by government intervention in the international trade and investment system, and (4) international transactions involve converting money into different currencies. In this book we examine all these issues in depth, paying close attention to the different strategies and policies that managers pursue to deal with the various challenges created when a firm becomes an international business. Chapters 2 and 3 explore how countries differ from each other with regard to their political, economic, legal, and cultural institutions. Chapter 4 takes a detailed look at the ethical issues that arise in international business. Chapters 5 to 8 look at the international trade and investment environment within which international businesses must operate. Chapters 9 and 10 review the international monetary system. These chapters focus on the nature of the foreign exchange market and the emerging global monetary system. Chapters 11 and 12 explore the strategy of international businesses. Chapters 13 to 16 look at the management of various functional operations within an international business, including production, marketing, and human relations. By the time you complete this book, you should have a good grasp of the issues that managers working within international business have to grapple with on a daily basis, and you should be familiar with the range of strategies and operating policies available to compete more effectively in today’s rapidly emerging global economy.
Key Terms globalization, p. 7
International Monetary Fund, p. 10
globalization of markets, p. 7
World Bank, p. 10
globalization of production, p. 8
United Nations, p. 10
factors of production, p. 8
international trade, p. 11
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), p. 9
foreign direct investment (FDI), p. 11
World Trade Organization, p. 9
Moore’s Law, p. 14
stock of foreign direct investment, p. 20 multinational enterprise (MNE), p. 21 international business, p. 34
Summary This chapter sets the scene for the rest of the book. It shows how the world economy is becoming more global and reviews the main drivers of globalization, arguing that they seem to be thrusting nation-states toward a more tightly integrated global economy. We looked at how the nature of international business is changing in response to the changing global economy; we discussed some concerns raised by rapid globalization; and we reviewed implications of rapid globalization for individual managers. The chapter made the following points: 1. Over the past two decades, we have witnessed the globalization of markets and production. 2. The globalization of markets implies that national markets are merging into one huge 36
marketplace. However, it is important not to push this view too far. 3. The globalization of production implies that firms are basing individual productive activities at the optimal world locations for the particular activities. As a consequence, it is increasingly irrelevant to talk about American products, Japanese products, or German products, since these are being replaced by “global” products. 4. Two factors seem to underlie the trend toward globalization: declining trade barriers and changes in communication, information, and transportation technologies. 5. Since the end of World War II, barriers to the free flow of goods, services, and capital have
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 36
12/22/06 8:52:09 PM
6.
7.
8.
9.
been lowered significantly. More than anything else, this has facilitated the trend toward the globalization of production and has enabled firms to view the world as a single market. As a consequence of the globalization of production and markets, in the last decade world trade has grown faster than world output, foreign direct investment has surged, imports have penetrated more deeply into the world’s industrial nations, and competitive pressures have increased in industry after industry. The development of the microprocessor and related developments in communication and information processing technology have helped firms link their worldwide operations into sophisticated information networks. Jet air travel, by shrinking travel time, has also helped to link the worldwide operations of international businesses. These changes have enabled firms to achieve tight coordination of their worldwide operations and to view the world as a single market. In the 1960s, the U.S. economy was dominant in the world, U.S. firms accounted for most of the foreign direct investment in the world economy, U.S. firms dominated the list of large multinationals, and roughly half the world—the centrally planned economies of the Communist world—was closed to Western businesses. By the mid-1990s, the U.S. share of world output had been cut in half, with major shares now being accounted for by Western European and Southeast Asian economies. The U.S.
share of worldwide foreign direct investment had also fallen, by about two-thirds. U.S. multinationals were now facing competition from a large number of Japanese and European multinationals. In addition, the emergence of mini-multinationals was noted. 10. One of the most dramatic developments of the past 20 years has been the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe, which has created enormous long-run opportunities for international businesses. In addition, the move toward free market economies in China and Latin America is creating opportunities (and threats) for Western international businesses. 11. The benefits and costs of the emerging global economy are being hotly debated among businesspeople, economists, and politicians. The debate focuses on the impact of globalization on jobs, wages, the environment, working conditions, and national sovereignty. 12. Managing an international business is different from managing a domestic business for at least four reasons: (i) countries are different, (ii) the range of problems confronted by a manager in an international business is wider and the problems themselves more complex than those confronted by a manager in a domestic business, (iii) managers in an international business must find ways to work within the limits imposed by governments’ intervention in the international trade and investment system, and (iv) international transactions involve converting money into different currencies.
Critical Thinking and Discussion Questions 1. Describe the shifts in the world economy over the past 30 years. What are the implications of these shifts for international businesses based in Great Britain? North America? Hong Kong? 2. “The study of international business is fine if you are going to work in a large multinational enterprise, but it has no relevance for individuals who are going to work in small firms.” Evaluate this statement. 3. How have changes in technology contributed to the globalization of markets and production? Would the globalization of production and markets have been possible without these technological changes?
4. “Ultimately, the study of international business is no different from the study of domestic business. Thus, there is no point in having a separate course on international business.” Evaluate this statement. 5. How might the Internet and the associated World Wide Web affect international business activity and the globalization of the world economy? 6. If current trends continue, China may be the world’s largest economy by 2020. Discuss the possible implications of such a development for (a) the world trading system, (b) the world monetary system, (c) the business strategy of Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 37
37
12/7/06 6:34:57 PM
today’s European and U.S.-based global corporations, and (d) global commodity prices. 7. Read the Country Focus in this chapter on the Ecuadorean rose industry, then answer the following questions: a. How has participation in the international rose trade helped Ecuador’s economy and its people? How has the rise of Ecuador as a center for rose growing benefited consumers in developed nations who purchase the roses? What do the answers to these questions tell you about the benefits of international trade?
Research Task
b. Why do you think that Ecuador’s rose industry only began to take off 20 years ago? Why do you think it has grown so rapidly? c. To what extent can the alleged health problems among workers in Ecuador’s rose industry be laid at the feet of consumers in the developed world and their desire for perfect Valentine’s Day roses? d. Do you think governments in the developed world should place trade sanctions on Ecuador roses if reports of health issues among Ecuadorean rose workers are verified? What else might they do to improve the situation in Ecuador?
http://globalEDGE.msu.edu
Use the globalEDGE site (http://globalEDGE.msu. edu/) to complete the following exercises:
the average population growth rates should be listed for management’s consideration.
1. Your company has developed a new product that is expected to achieve high penetration rates in all the countries in which it is introduced, regardless of the average income status of the local population. Considering the costs of the product launch, the management team has decided to initially introduce the product only in countries that have a sizeable population base. Using the Population Reference Bureau as a resource, you are required to prepare a preliminary report with the top 10 countries of the world in terms of population size. Since growth opportunities are another major concern,
2. Being sensitive to appropriate behavior in public is an important element of business relationships and developing an internal handbook on cultural sensitivity for your firm. Given that your organization is implementing a strategy that focuses on developing economies, learning more about the countries in which your firm has operations is imperative. By identifying and using a resource that explains in detail proper business customs and etiquette, prepare a brief report that outlines unacceptable public conduct in the three main countries your firm has facilities: Colombia, India, and Malaysia.
closing case The Globalization of Health Care Conventional wisdom holds that health care is one of the industries least vulnerable to dislocation from globalization. After all, like many service businesses, health care is delivered where it is purchased, right? If an American goes to a hospital for an MRI scan, won’t that scan be read by a local radiologist? And if the MRI scan shows that surgery is required, surely the surgery will be done at a local hospital in the United States. Until recently, this was true, but we are now witnessing the beginnings of globalization in this traditionally most local of industries.
38
Consider the MRI scan: The United States has a shortage of radiologists, the doctors who specialize in reading and interpreting diagnostic medical images, including X-rays, CT scans, MRI scans, and ultrasounds. Demand for radiologists is reportedly growing twice as fast as the rate at which medical schools are graduating radiologists with the skills and qualifications required to read medical images. This imbalance between supply and demand means that radiologists are expensive; an American radiologist can earn as much as $350,000 a year. In 2002, an Indian radiologist
Part One Introduction and Overview
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 38
12/8/06 5:55:07 PM
working at the prestigious Massachusetts General Hospital, Dr. Sanjay Saini, thought he had found a clever way to deal with the shortage and expense—beam images over the Internet to India where they could be interpreted by radiologists. This would reduce the workload on America’s radiologists and also cut costs. A radiologist in India might earn one-tenth of his or her U.S. counterpart. Plus, because India is on the opposite side of the globe, the images could be interpreted while it was nighttime in the United States and be ready for the attending physician when he or she arrived for work the following morning. As for the surgery, here too we are witnessing the beginnings of an outsourcing trend. In October 2004, for example, Howard Staab, a 53-year-old uninsured self-employed carpenter from North Carolina had surgery to repair a leaking heart valve—in India! Mr. Staab flew to New Delhi, had the operation, and afterward toured the Taj Mahal, the price of which was bundled with that of the surgery. The cost, including airfare, totaled $10,000. If Mr. Staab’s surgery had been performed in the United States, the cost would have been $60,000 and there would have been no visit to the Taj Mahal. Howard Staab is not alone. Some 170,000 foreigners visited India in 2004 for medical treatments. That number is projected to rise by 15 percent a year for the next several years. According to the management consultancy McKinsey & Co., medical tourism (overseas trips to have medical procedures performed) could be a $2.3 billion industry in India by 2012. In another example, after years of living in pain, Robert Beeney, a 64-year-old from San Francisco, was advised to get his hip joint replaced, but after doing some research on the Internet, Mr. Beeney elected instead for joint resurfacing, which was not covered by his insurance. Instead of going to a nearby hospital, he flew to Hyderabad in southern India and had the surgery done for $6,600, a fraction of the $25,000 the procedure would have cost in the United States. Mr. Beeney had his surgery performed at a branch of the Apollo hospital chain. Apollo, which was founded by Dr. Prathap C. Reddy, a surgeon trained at Massachusetts General Hospital, runs a chain of 18 state-of-the-art hospitals throughout Asia. Between 2001 and 2004, Apollo treated 43,000 foreigners, mainly from nations in Southeast Asia and the Persian Gulf, although a growing number are from Western Europe and North America. In 2004, 7 percent of its revenue came from foreigners. With 200 U.S.-trained doctors on his staff, Dr. Reddy reckons that he can offer medical care equivalent to that in the United States, but at a fraction of the cost. Nor is he alone; Mr. Staab’s surgery was performed by Dr. Naresh Trehan, a cardiac surgeon who was trained at New York University School of Medicine and worked there for a decade. Dr. Trehan returned home to India and opened his own cardiac hospital, which now conducts 4,000 heart surgeries a year, with a 0.8 percent mortality rate and
0.3 percent infection rate, on par with the best of the world’s hospitals. So will demand for American health services soon collapse as work moves offshore to places like India? That seems unlikely. Regulations, personal preferences, and practical considerations mean that the majority of health services will always be performed in the country where the patient resides. Consider the MRI scan: To safeguard patient care, U.S. regulations require that a radiologist be licensed in the state where the image was made and that he or she be certified by the hospital where care is being given. Given that not many radiologists in India have these qualifications, no more than a small fraction of images can be interpreted overseas. Another complication is that the U.S. governmentsponsored medical insurance program, Medicare, will not pay for services done outside of the country. Nor will many private insurance plans. . . or not yet anyway. Moreover, most people would prefer to have care delivered close to home, and only in exceptional cases, such as when the procedure is not covered by their medical plan, are they likely to consider the foreign option. Still, most experts believe that the trends now in place will continue. Given that health care costs in America are the highest in the world, it seems likely that increasingly, a small but significant percentage of medical service will be performed in a country that is different from the one where the patient resides. The trend will certainly get a big boost if insurance companies start to offer enrollees the option of getting treatment abroad for expensive surgeries, as some are rumored to be considering. Sources: G. Colvin, “Think Your Job Can’t Be Sent to India?” Fortune, December 13, 2004, p. 80; A. Pollack, “Who’s Reading Your X-Ray,” The New York Times, November 16, 2003, pp. 1, 9; S. Rai, “Low Costs Lure Foreigners to India for Medical Care,” The New York Times, April 7, 2005, p. C6; J. Solomon, “Traveling Cure: India’s New Coup in Outsourcing,” The Wall Street Journal, April 26, 2004, p. A1; J. Slater, “Increasing Doses in India,” Far Eastern Economic Review, February 19, 2004, pp. 32–35; and U. Kher, “Outsourcing Your Heart,” Time, May 29, 2006, pp. 44–47.
Case Discussion Questions 1. A decade ago the idea that medical procedures might move offshore was unthinkable. Today it is a reality. What trends have facilitated this process? 2. Is the globalization of health care good or bad for patients? 3. Is the globalization of health care good or bad for the American economy? 4. Who might benefit from the globalization of health care? Who might lose? 5. Do you think that the U.S. government should restrict the outsourcing of medical procedures to developing nations? What if physicians in those countries are certified by U.S. medical institutions? Chapter One Globalization
hiL10544_ch01_001-039.indd 39
39
12/7/06 6:34:57 PM
Wide W orld
Pedro Lara/A P
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
part 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Country Differences
Understand how the Political systems of countries differ. Understand how the economic systems of countries differ. Understand how the legal systems of countries differ.
Be able to explain what determines the level of economic development of a nation. Discuss the macro-political and economic changes taking place worldwide. Describe how transition economies are moving toward market-based systems. Articulate the implications for management practice of national differences in political economy.
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 40
12/23/06 12:40:57 PM
chapter
2
National Differences in Political Economy Chavez’s Venezuela opening case
H
ugo Chavez, a former military officer who was once jailed for engineering a failed coup attempt, was elected president of Venezuela in 1998. Chavez, a self-styled democratic socialist, won the presidential election by campaigning against corruption, economic mismanagement, and the “harsh realities” of global capitalism. When he took office in February 1999, Chavez claimed that he had inherited the worst economic situation in the country’s recent history. He wasn’t far off the mark. A collapse in the price of oil, which accounted for 70 percent of the country’s exports, left Venezuela with a large budget deficit and forced the economy into a deep recession. Soon after taking office, Chavez proceeded to try to consolidate his hold over the apparatus of government. A constituent assembly, dominated by Chavez followers, drafted a new constitution that strengthened the powers of the presidency and allowed Chavez (if reelected) to stay in office until 2013. Subsequently, the national congress, which was controlled by Chavez supporters, approved a measure allowing the government to remove and appoint Supreme Court justices, effectively increasing Chavez’s hold over the judiciary. Chavez also extended government control over the media. By 2005, Freedom House, which annually assesses political and civil liberties worldwide, concluded that Venezuela was only “partly free” and that freedoms were being progressively curtailed. On the economic front, things remained rough. The economy shrank by 9 percent in 2002 and another 8 percent in 2003. Unemployment remained persistently high at 15 to 17 percent and the poverty rate rose to more than 50 percent of the population. A 2003 study by the World Bank concluded that Venezuela was one of the most regulated economies in the world and that state controls over business activities gave public officials ample opportunities to enrich themselves by demanding bribes in
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 41
12/8/06 5:16:56 PM
return for permission to expand operations, or enter new lines of business. Indeed, despite Chavez’s anticorruption rhetoric, Transparency International, which ranks the world’s nations according to the extent of public corruption, has noted that corruption has increased under Chavez. In 2005, Transparency International ranked Venezuela 130 out of 158 nations, down from 114 a year earlier. Consistent with his socialist rhetoric, Chavez has progressively taken various enterprises into state ownership and has required that other enterprises be restructured as “workers’ cooperatives” in return for government loans. In addition, the government has begun to seize large rural farms and ranches that Chavez claims are not sufficiently productive, turning them into state-owned cooperatives. In 2004, the world oil market bailed Chavez out of mounting economic difficulties. Oil prices started to surge from the low $20s, reaching $70 a barrel by the spring of 2006, and Venezuela, the world’s fifth-largest producer, started to reap a bonanza. On the back of surging oil exports, the economy grew by 18 percent in 2004 and another 9 percent in 2005. Chavez’s reaction to the oil price increase was to extend government control over foreign oil producers doing business in Venezuela, which he accused of making outsized profits at the expense of a poor nation. In 2005, he announced an increase in the royalties that the government would take from oil sales from 1 percent to 30 percent, and he increased the tax rate on sales from 34 to 50 percent. In April 2006, he announced plans to reduce the stakes held by foreign companies in oil projects in the Orinoco regions and to give the state-run oil company, Petroleos de Venezuela SA, a majority position. Sources: D. Luhnow and P. Millard, “Chavez Plans to Take More Control of Oil away from Foreign Firms,” The Wall Street Journal, April 24, 2006, p. A1; R. Gallego, “Chavez’s Agenda Takes Shape,” The Wall Street Journal, December 27, 2005, p. A12; “The Sickly Stench of Corruption: Venezuela,” The Economist, April 1, 2006, p. 50; and “Chavez Squeezes the Oil Firms,” The Economist, November 12, 2005, p. 61.
Introduction International business is much more complicated than domestic business because countries differ in many ways. Countries have different political, economic, and legal systems. Cultural practices can vary dramatically, as can the education and skill level of the population, and countries are at different stages of economic development. All these differences can and do have major implications for the practice of international business. They have a profound impact on the benefits, costs, and risks associated with doing business in different countries; the way in which operations in different countries should be managed; and the strategy international firms should pursue in different countries. A main function of this chapter and the next is to develop an awareness of and appreciation for the significance of country differences in political systems, economic systems, legal systems, and national culture. Another function of the two 42
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 42
12/8/06 5:16:56 PM
chapters is to describe how the political, economic, legal, and cultural systems of many of the world’s nation-states are evolving and to draw out the implications of these changes for the practice of international business. The opening case illustrates some of the issues covered in this chapter. Under the leadership of Hugo Chavez, Venezuela has shifted to the left. The state has become more involved in business activity, regulation has expanded, and private enterprise is on the defensive, which has hurt economic growth. Corruption, long a problem in the country, has if anything gotten worse, despite the fact that Chavez originally came to power running on an anticorruption platform. As we shall see in this chapter, corruption also tends to depress economic growth. Moreover, Chavez has unilaterally rewritten the contracts with foreign oil companies that have invested in Venezuela, raising royalty rates and taxes and demanding that the state-run oil company be given a majority stake in all oil projects. While this may increase the government’s take in the short run, if foreign enterprises respond by reducing their investments in Venezuela, as some are now doing, this could further constrain the country’s economic growth down the road. This chapter focuses on how the political, economic, and legal systems of countries differ. Collectively we refer to these systems as constituting the political economy of a country. We use the term political economy to stress that the political, economic, and legal systems of a country are interdependent; they interact and influence each other, and in doing so they affect the level of economic well-being. In addition to reviewing these systems, we also explore how differences in political economy influence the benefits, costs, and risks associated with doing business in different countries, and how they affect management practice and strategy. In the next chapter, we will look at how differences in culture influence the practice of international business. As noted, the political economy and culture of a nation are not independent of each other. As will become apparent in Chapter 3, culture can exert an impact on political economy—on political, economic, and legal systems in a nation— and the converse can also hold true.
Political Economy The interdependent combination of a country’s political, economic, and legal systems.
Political Systems The political system of a country shapes its economic and legal systems.1 As such, we need to understand the nature of different political systems before discussing economic and legal systems. By political system we mean the system of government in a nation. Political systems can be assessed according to two dimensions. The first is the degree to which they emphasize collectivism as opposed to individualism. The second is the degree to which they are democratic or totalitarian. These dimensions are interrelated; systems that emphasize collectivism tend toward totalitarian, whereas those that place a high value on individualism tend to be democratic. However, a large gray area exists in the middle. It is possible to have democratic societies that emphasize a mix of collectivism and individualism. Similarly, it is possible to have totalitarian societies that are not collectivist.
LEARNING OBJECTIVE 1 Understand how the political systems of countries differ.
COLLECTIVISM AND INDIVIDUALISM Collectivism refers to a political
Collectivism
system that stresses the primacy of collective goals over individual goals.2 When collectivism is emphasized, the needs of society as a whole are generally viewed as being more important than individual freedoms. In such circumstances, an individual’s right to do something may be restricted on the grounds that it runs counter to “the good of society” or to “the common good.” Advocacy of collectivism can be traced to the ancient Greek philosopher Plato (427–347 BC), who in The Republic argued that individual rights should be sacrificed for the good of the majority and that property
A political system that stresses the primacy of collective goals over individual goals.
Political System The system of government in any nation.
Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 43
43
12/8/06 5:16:56 PM
should be owned in common. Plato did not equate collectivism with equality; he believed that society should be stratified into classes, with those best suited to rule (which for Plato, naturally, were philosophers and soldiers) administering society for the benefit of all. In modern times, the collectivist mantle has been picked up by socialists. Socialism The political system that believes in state ownership of a country’s means of production, distribution, and exchange so that all can benefit.
Communists Those who believe that socialism can only be realized through violent revolution and totalitarian dictatorship.
Social Democrats Those who believed in achieving socialism through democratic means.
44
Socialism Modern socialists trace their intellectual roots to Karl Marx (1818–83), although socialist thought clearly predates Marx (elements of it can be traced to Plato). Marx argued that the few benefit at the expense of the many in a capitalist society where individual freedoms are not restricted. While successful capitalists accumulate considerable wealth, Marx postulated that the wages earned by the majority of workers in a capitalist society would be forced down to subsistence levels. He argued that capitalists expropriate for their own use the value created by workers, while paying workers only subsistence wages in return. According to Marx, the pay of workers does not reflect the full value of their labor. To correct this perceived wrong, Marx advocated state ownership of the basic means of production, distribution, and exchange (i.e., businesses). His logic was that if the state owned the means of production, the state could ensure that workers were fully compensated for their labor. Thus, the idea is to manage state-owned enterprise to benefit society as a whole, rather than individual capitalists.3 In the early twentieth century, the socialist ideology split into two broad camps. The communists believed that socialism could be achieved only through violent revolution and totalitarian dictatorship, whereas the social democrats committed themselves to achieving socialism by democratic means, turning their backs on violent revolution and dictatorship. Both versions of socialism waxed and waned during the twentieth century. The communist version of socialism reached its high point in the late 1970s, when the majority of the world’s population lived in communist states. The countries under Communist Party rule at that time included the former Soviet Union; its Eastern European client nations (e.g., Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary); China; the Southeast Asian nations of Cambodia, Laos, and Vietnam; various African nations (e.g., Angola and Mozambique); and the Latin American nations of Cuba and Nicaragua. By the mid-1990s, however, communism was in retreat worldwide. The Soviet Union had collapsed and had been replaced by a collection of 15 republics, many of which were at least nominally structured as democracies. Communism was swept out of Eastern Europe by the largely bloodless revolutions of 1989. Although China is still nominally a communist state with substantial limits to individual political freedom, in the economic sphere the country has moved sharply away from strict adherence to communist ideology. Other than China, communism hangs on only in some small fringe states, such as North Korea and Cuba. Social democracy also seems to have passed a high-water mark, although the ideology may prove to be more enduring than communism. Social democracy has had perhaps its greatest influence in a number of democratic Western nations, including Australia, France, Germany, Great Britain, Norway, Spain, and Sweden, where Social Democratic parties have often held political power. Other countries where social democracy has had an important influence include India and Brazil. Consistent with their Marxists roots, many social democratic governments after World War II nationalized private companies in certain industries, transforming them into state-owned enterprises to be run for the “public good rather than private profit.” In Great Britain by the end of the 1970s, for example, state-owned companies had a monopoly in the telecommunications, electricity, gas, coal, railway, and
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 44
12/8/06 5:16:56 PM
shipbuilding industries, as well as substantial interests in the oil, airline, auto, and steel industries. However, experience demonstrated that state ownership of the means of production ran counter to the public interest. In many countries, state-owned companies performed poorly. Protected from competition by their monopoly position and guaranteed government financial support, many became increasingly inefficient. Individuals paid for the luxury of state ownership through higher prices and higher taxes. As a consequence, a number of Western democracies voted many Social Democratic parties out of office in the late 1970s and early 1980s. They were succeeded by political parties, such as Britain’s Conservative Party and Germany’s Christian Democratic Party, that were more committed to free market economics. These parties sold stateowned enterprises to private investors (a process referred to as privatization). Even where Social Democratic parties have regained the levers of power, as in Great Britain in 1997 when the left-leaning Labor Party won control of the government, they too now seem committed to continued private ownership.
Individualism The opposite of collectivism, individualism refers to a philosophy that an individual should have freedom in his or her economic and political pursuits. In contrast to collectivism, individualism stresses that the interests of the individual should take precedence over the interests of the state. Like collectivism, individualism can be traced to an ancient Greek philosopher, in this case Plato’s disciple Aristotle (384–322 BC). In contrast to Plato, Aristotle argued that individual diversity and private ownership are desirable. In a passage that might have been taken from a speech by contemporary politicians who adhere to a free market ideology, he argued that private property is more highly productive than communal property and will thus stimulate progress. According to Aristotle, communal property receives little care, whereas property that is owned by an individual will receive the greatest care and therefore be most productive. Individualism was reborn as an influential political philosophy in the Protestant trading nations of England and the Netherlands during the sixteenth century. The philosophy was refined in the work of a number of British philosophers, including David Hume (1711–76), Adam Smith (1723–90), and John Stuart Mill (1806–73). Individualism exercised a profound influence on those in the American colonies who sought independence from Great Britain. Indeed, the concept underlies the ideas expressed in the Declaration of Independence. In more recent years, several Nobel Prize–winning economists, including Milton Friedman, Friedrich von Hayek, and James Buchanan, have championed the philosophy. Individualism is built on two central tenets. The first is an emphasis on the importance of guaranteeing individual freedom and self-expression. As John Stuart Mill put it,
Privatization The sale of state-owned enterprises to private investors.
Individualism The philosophy that an individual should have freedom in his or her economic and political pursuits.
The sole end for which mankind are warranted, individually or collectively, in interfering with the liberty of action of any of their number is self-protection. . . . The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient warrant. . . . The only part of the conduct of any one, for which he is amenable to society, is that which concerns others. In the part which merely concerns himself, his independence is, of right, absolute. Over himself, over his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign.4 The second tenet of individualism is that the welfare of society is best served by letting people pursue their own economic self-interest, as opposed to some collective Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 45
45
12/8/06 5:16:56 PM
Another Perspective More on Aristotle In addition to believing that the means of production should be privately owned, Aristotle thought that if we were to abolish private property, we would do moral harm to ourselves. Without private property, there would be no need to exercise generosity. “Without private property, no man will be seen to be liberal and no man will ever do any act of liberality; for only in the use of money is liberality made effective.” (The Politics, Book 2, Ch. 5, trans. T.A. Sinclair). The Peruvian economist Hernando De Soto develops Aristotle’s point in the argument that the underlying, basic source of poverty and underdevelopment is the lack of a legal system that allows for transferable, titled, private property. (The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else, Basic Books, 2000).
body (such as government) dictating what is in society’s best interest. Or as Adam Smith put it in a famous passage from The Wealth of Nations, an individual who intends his own gain is led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention. Nor is it always worse for the society that it was no part of it. By pursuing his own interest he frequently promotes that of the society more effectually than when he really intends to promote it. I have never known much good done by those who effect to trade for the public good.5
The central message of individualism, therefore, is that individual economic and political freedoms are the ground rules on which a society should be based. This puts individualism in conflict with collectivism. Collectivism asserts the primacy of the collective over the individual; individualism asserts the opposite. This underlying ideological conflict shaped much of the recent history of the world. The Cold War, for example, was in many respects a war between collectivism, championed by the former Soviet Union, and individualism, championed by the United States. In practical terms, individualism translates into an advocacy for democratic political systems and free market economics. Since the late 1980s, the waning of collectivism has been matched by the ascendancy of individualism. Democratic ideals and free market economics have swept away socialism and communism in many states. The changes of the past 20 years go beyond the revolutions in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union to include a move toward greater individualism in Latin America and many of the social democratic states of the West (e.g., Great Britain and Sweden). This is not to claim that individualism has finally won a long battle with collectivism. It has clearly not (indeed, during 2005 and into 2006 there were signs of a swing back toward left-leaning social democratic ideas in several countries, most notably in Latin America). But as a guiding political philosophy, individualism has been on the ascendant. This is good news for international business because the pro-business and profree trade values of individualism create a favorable environment within which international business can thrive.
Democracy A political system in which government is by the people, exercised either directly or through elected representatives.
Totalitarianism A political system in which one person or political party exercises absolute control over all spheres of human life and prohibits opposing political parties.
46
DEMOCRACY AND TOTALITARIANISM Democracy and totalitarianism are at different ends of a political dimension. Democracy refers to a political system in which government is by the people, exercised either directly or through elected representatives. Totalitarianism is a form of government in which one person or political party exercises absolute control over all spheres of human life and prohibits opposing political parties. The democratic–totalitarian dimension is not independent of the collectivism–individualism dimension. Democracy and individualism go hand in hand, as do the communist versions of collectivism and totalitarianism. However, gray areas exist; it is possible to have a democratic state in which collective values predominate, and it is possible to have a totalitarian state that is hostile to collectivism and in which some degree of individualism—particularly in the economic sphere—is encouraged. For example, China has seen a move toward greater individual freedom in the economic sphere, but the country is still ruled by a totalitarian dictatorship that constrains political freedom.
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 46
12/8/06 5:16:57 PM
Democracy The pure form of democracy, as originally practiced by several city-states in ancient Greece, is based on a belief that citizens should be directly involved in decision making. In complex, advanced societies with populations in the tens or hundreds of millions this is impractical. Most modern democratic states practice representative democracy. In a representative democracy, citizens periodically elect individuals to represent them. These elected representatives then form a government, whose function is to make decisions on behalf of the electorate. In a representative democracy, elected representatives who fail to perform this job adequately will be voted out of office at the next election. To guarantee that elected representatives can be held accountable for their actions by the electorate, an ideal representative democracy has a number of safeguards that are typically enshrined in constitutional law. These include (1) an individual’s right to freedom of expression, opinion, and organization; (2) a free media; (3) regular elections in which all eligible citizens are allowed to vote; (4) universal adult suffrage; (5) limited terms for elected representatives; (6) a fair court system that is independent from the political system; (7) a nonpolitical state bureaucracy; (8) a nonpolitical police force and armed service; and (9) relatively free access to state information.6
Representative Democracy A democracy in which citizens periodically elect individuals to represent them in government functions.
Communist Totalitarianism A version of collectivism advocating that socialism can only be achieved through a totalitarian dictatorship.
Totalitarianism In a totalitarian country, all the constitutional guarantees on which representative democracies are built—an individual’s right to freedom of expression and organization, a free media, and regular elections—are denied to the citizens. In most totalitarian states, political repression is widespread, free and fair elections are lacking, media are heavily censored, basic civil liberties are denied, and those who question the right of the rulers to rule find themselves imprisoned, or worse. Four major forms of totalitarianism exist in the world today. Until recently, the most widespread was communist totalitarianism. Communism, however, is in decline worldwide, and most of the Communist Party dictatorships have collapsed since 1989. Exceptions to this trend (so far) are China, Vietnam, Laos, North Korea, and Cuba, although all these states exhibit clear signs that the Communist Party’s monopoly on political power is retreating. In many respects, the governments of China, Vietnam, and Laos are communist in name only since those nations now adhere to market-based economic reforms. They remain, however, totalitarian states that deny many basic civil liberties to their populations. A second form of totalitarianism might be labeled theocratic totalitarianism. Theocratic totalitarianism is found in states where political power is monopolized by a party, group, or individual that governs according to religious principles. The most common form of theocratic totalitarianism is based on Islam and is exemplified by states such as Iran and Saudi Arabia. These states limit freedom of political and religious expression with laws based on Islamic principles. A third form of totalitarianism might be referred to as tribal totalitarianism. Tribal totalitarianism has arisen from time to time in African countries such as Zimbabwe, Tanzania, Uganda, and Kenya. The borders of most African states reflect the administrative boundaries drawn by the old European colonial powers rather than tribal realities. Consequently, the typical African country contains a number of tribes. Tribal totalitarianism occurs when a political party that represents the interests of a particular tribe (and not always the majority tribe) monopolizes power. Such one-party states still exist in Africa. A fourth major form of totalitarianism might be described as right-wing totalitarianism. Right-wing totalitarianism generally permits some individual economic freedom but restricts individual political freedom, frequently on the
Theocratic Totalitarianism A political system in which political power is monopolized by a party, group, or individual that governs according to religious principles.
Tribal Totalitarianism A political system in which a party, group, or individual that represents the interests of a particular tribe monopolizes political power.
Right-Wing Totalitarianism A political system in which political power is monopolized by a party, group, or individual that generally permits individual economic freedom but restricts individual political freedom, including free speech, often on the grounds that it would lead to the rise of communism.
Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 47
47
12/8/06 5:16:57 PM
Communist totalitarianism is still the political system in Vietnam, where red banners in the Hanoi marketplace remind citizens and visitors of the government’s control. Tim Hall/Getty Images/DIL
grounds that it would lead to the rise of communism. A common feature of many right-wing dictatorships is an overt hostility to socialist or communist ideas. Many right-wing totalitarian governments are backed by the military, and in some cases the government may be made up of military officers. The fascist regimes that ruled Germany and Italy in the 1930s and 1940s were right-wing totalitarian states. Until the early 1980s, right-wing dictatorships, many of which were military dictatorships, were common throughout Latin America. They were also found in several Asian countries, particularly South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Indonesia, and the Philippines. Since the early 1980s, however, this form of government has been in retreat. Most Latin American countries are now genuine multiparty democracies. Similarly, South Korea, Taiwan, and the Philippines have all become functioning democracies, as has Indonesia (see the closing case).
Economic Systems LEARNING OBJECTIVE 2 Understand how the economic systems of countries differ.
It should be clear from the previous section that political ideology and economic systems are connected. In countries where individual goals are given primacy over collective goals, we are more likely to find free market economic systems. In contrast, in countries where collective goals are given preeminence, the state may have taken control over many enterprises; markets in such countries are likely to be restricted rather than free. We can identify three broad types of economic systems—a market economy, a command economy, and a mixed economy.
Market Economy An economic system in which the interaction of supply and demand determines the quantity in which goods and services are produced.
48
MARKET ECONOMY In a pure market economy, all productive activities are privately owned, as opposed to being owned by the state. The goods and services that a country produces are not planned by anyone. Production is determined by the interaction of supply and demand and signaled to producers through the price system. If demand for a product exceeds supply, prices will rise, signaling producers to produce
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 48
12/8/06 5:16:57 PM
more. If supply exceeds demand, prices will fall, signaling producers to produce less. In this system consumers are sovereign. The purchasing patterns of consumers, as signaled to producers through the mechanism of the price system, determine what is produced and in what quantity. For a market to work in this manner, supply must not be restricted. A supply restriction occurs when a single firm monopolizes a market. In such circumstances, rather than increase output in response to increased demand, a monopolist might restrict output and let prices rise. This allows the monopolist to take a greater profit margin on each unit it sells. Although this is good for the monopolist, it is bad for the consumer, who has to pay higher prices. It also is probably bad for the welfare of society. Since a monopolist has no competitors, it has no incentive to search for ways to lower production costs. Rather, it can simply pass on cost increases to consumers in the form of higher prices. The net result is that the monopolist is likely to become increasingly inefficient, producing high-priced, low-quality goods, and society suffers as a consequence. Given the dangers inherent in monopoly, the role of government in a market economy is to encourage vigorous free and fair competition between private producers. Governments do this by outlawing monopolies and restrictive business practices designed to monopolize a market (antitrust laws serve this function in the United States). Private ownership also encourages vigorous competition and economic efficiency. Private ownership ensures that entrepreneurs have a right to the profits generated by their own efforts. This gives entrepreneurs an incentive to search for better ways of serving consumer needs. That may be through introducing new products, by developing more efficient production processes, by pursuing better marketing and after-sale service, or simply through managing their businesses more efficiently than their competitors. In turn, the constant improvement in product and process that results from such an incentive has been argued to have a major positive impact on economic growth and development.7
COMMAND ECONOMY
In a pure command economy, the government plans the goods and services that a country produces, the quantity in which they are produced, and the prices at which they are sold. Consistent with the collectivist ideology, the objective of a command economy is for government to allocate resources for “the good of society.” In addition, in a pure command economy, all businesses are state owned, the rationale being that the government can then direct them to make investments that are in the best interests of the nation as a whole rather than in the interests of private individuals. Historically, command economies were found in communist countries where collectivist goals were given priority over individual goals. Since the demise of communism in the late 1980s, the number of command economies has fallen dramatically. Some elements of a command economy were also evident in a number of democratic nations led by socialistinclined governments. France and India both experimented with extensive government planning and state ownership, although government planning has fallen into disfavor in both countries. While the objective of a command economy is to mobilize economic resources for the public good, the opposite seems to have occurred. In a command economy, stateowned enterprises have little incentive to control costs and be efficient, because they cannot go out of business. Also, the abolition of private ownership means there is no incentive for individuals to look for better ways to serve consumer needs; hence, dynamism and innovation are absent from command economies. Instead of growing and becoming more prosperous, such economies tend to stagnate.
Command Economy An economic system in which the government plans the allocation of resources, including determination of what goods and services should be produced and in what quantity.
Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 49
49
12/8/06 5:17:01 PM
MIXED ECONOMY Between market economies and command economies can Mixed Economy An economic system in which certain sectors are left to private ownership and free market mechanisms, while other sectors have significant government ownership and government planning.
be found mixed economies. In a mixed economy, certain sectors of the economy are left to private ownership and free market mechanisms while other sectors have significant state ownership and government planning. Mixed economies were once common throughout much of the world, although they are becoming much less so. Not long ago, Great Britain, France, and Sweden were mixed economies, but extensive privatization has reduced state ownership of businesses in all three nations. A similar trend can be observed in many other countries where there was once a large state sector, such as Brazil, Italy, and India. In mixed economies, governments also tend to take into state ownership troubled firms whose continued operation is thought to be vital to national interests. Consider, for example, the French automobile company Renault. The government took over the company when it ran into serious financial problems. The French government reasoned that the social costs of the unemployment that might result if Renault collapsed were unacceptable, so it nationalized the company to save it from bankruptcy. Renault’s competitors weren’t thrilled by this move because they had to compete with a company whose costs were subsidized by the state.
Legal Systems LEARNING OBJECTIVE 3 Understand how the legal systems of countries differ.
Legal System Rules that regulate behavior and the processes by which the laws of a country are enforced and through which redress of grievance is obtained.
Common Law A system of law based on tradition, precedent, and custom, which is flexibly interpreted by judges as it applies to the unique circumstances of each case.
50
The legal system of a country refers to the rules, or laws, that regulate behavior along with the processes by which the laws are enforced and through which redress for grievances is obtained. The legal system of a country is of immense importance to international business. A country’s laws regulate business practice, define the manner in which business transactions are to be executed, and set down the rights and obligations of those involved in business transactions. The legal environments of countries differ in significant ways. As we shall see, differences in legal systems can affect the attractiveness of a country as an investment site or market. Like the economic system of a country, the legal system is influenced by the prevailing political system (although it is also strongly influenced by historical tradition). The government of a country defines the legal framework within which firms do business— and often the laws that regulate business reflect the rulers’ dominant political ideology. For example, collectivist-inclined totalitarian states tend to enact laws that severely restrict private enterprise, whereas the laws enacted by governments in democratic states where individualism is the dominant political philosophy tend to be pro-private enterprise and pro-consumer. Here we focus on several issues that illustrate how legal systems can vary—and how such variations can affect international business. First, we look at some basic differences in legal systems. Next we look at contract law. Third, we look at the laws governing property rights with particular reference to patents, copyrights, and trademarks. Then we discuss protection of intellectual property. Finally, we look at laws covering product safety and product liability.
DIFFERENT LEGAL SYSTEMS There are three main types of legal systems—or legal tradition—in use around the world: common law, civil law, and theocratic law. Common Law The common law system evolved in England over hundreds of years. It is now found in most of Great Britain’s former colonies, including the United States. Common law is based on tradition, precedent, and custom. Tradition refers to a country’s legal history, precedent to cases that have come before the courts in the past,
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 50
12/8/06 5:17:01 PM
and custom to the ways in which laws are applied in specific situations. When law courts interpret common law, they do so with regard to these characteristics. This gives a common law system a degree of flexibility that other systems lack. Judges in a common law system have the power to interpret the law so that it applies to the unique circumstances of an individual case. In turn, each new interpretation sets a precedent that may be followed in future cases. As new precedents arise, laws may be altered, clarified, or amended to deal with new situations.
Civil Law A civil law system is based on a detailed set of laws organized into codes. When law courts interpret civil law, they do so with regard to these codes. More than 80 countries, including Germany, France, Japan, and Russia, operate with a civil law system. A civil law system tends to be less adversarial than a common law system, since the judges rely upon detailed legal codes rather than interpreting tradition, precedent, and custom. Judges under a civil law system have less flexibility than those under a common law system. Judges in a common law system have the power to interpret the law, whereas judges in a civil law system have the power only to apply the law.
Civil Law System A system of law based on a detailed set of written laws and codes.
Theocratic Theocratic Law A theocratic law system is one in which the law is based on Law System religious teachings. Islamic law is the most widely practiced theocratic legal system A system of law in the modern world, although usage of both Hindu and Jewish law persisted into based on religious the twentieth century. Islamic law is primarily a moral rather than a commercial law teachings. and is intended to govern all aspects of life.8 The foundation for Islamic law is the holy book of Islam, the Koran, along with the Sunnah, or decisions and sayings of the Prophet Muhammad, and the writings of Islamic scholars who have derived rules by analogy from the principles established in the Koran and the Sunnah. Because the Koran and Sunnah are holy documents, the basic foundations of Islamic law cannot be changed. However, in practice Islamic jurists and scholars are constantly debating the application of Islamic law to the modern world. In reality, many Muslim countries have legal systems that are a blend of Islamic law and a common or civil law system. Although Islamic law is primarily concerned with moral behavior, it has been extended to cover certain commercial activities. An example is the payment or receipt of interest, which is considered usury and outlawed by the Koran. To the devout Muslim, acceptance of interest payments is seen as a grave sin; the giver and the taker are equally damned. This is Another Perspective not just a matter of theology; in several Islamic states it has also become a matter of law. In the No Interest in Islamic Banking? Why? How can a banking system operate without interest (riba in 1990s, for example, Pakistan’s Federal Shariat Arabic)? The basic economic idea is that commercial risk Court, the highest Islamic lawmaking body in the should be shared. In the Western approach, interest guarcountry, pronounced interest to be un-Islamic and antees the banker a return, so on a collateralized loan, the therefore illegal and demanded that the governbanker avoids much of the commercial risk that’s inherent ment amend all financial laws accordingly. In in business. No matter what happens to the business, 1999, Pakistan’s Supreme Court ruled that Islamic the banker gets a return. In contrast, Islam requires that banking methods should be used in the country the banker share this commercial risk. If the business after July 1, 2001.9 By 2005, some 300 Islamic fiventure is successful, the banker shares the profit. If the nancial institutions in the world collectively manventure doesn’t do well, neither does the banker. The value aged more than $250 billion in assets. In addition of community in Islam is stronger than the value of to Pakistan, Islamic financial institutions are found individual profit. See Chapter 3 for more on this point. in many of the Gulf states, Egypt, and Malaysia.10
Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 51
51
12/8/06 5:17:02 PM
DIFFERENCES IN CONTRACT LAW
Contract A document that specifies the conditions under which an exchange is to occur and details the rights and obligations of the parties involved.
Contract Law The body of law that governs contract enforcement.
United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CIGS) A set of rules governing certain aspects of the making and performance of commercial contracts between sellers and buyers who have their places of businesses in different nations.
Property Rights The bundle of legal rights over the use to which a resource is put and over the use made of any income that may be derived from that resource.
52
The difference between common law and civil law systems can be illustrated by the approach of each to contract law (remember, most theocratic legal systems also have elements of common or civil law). A contract is a document that specifies the conditions under which an exchange is to occur and details the rights and obligations of the parties involved. Some form of contract regulates many business transactions. Contract law is the body of law that governs contract enforcement. The parties to an agreement normally resort to contract law when one party feels the other has violated either the letter or the spirit of an agreement. Because common law tends to be relatively ill specified, contracts drafted under a common law framework tend to be very detailed with all contingencies spelled out. In civil law systems, however, contracts tend to be much shorter and less specific because many of the issues are already covered in a civil code. Thus, it is more expensive to draw up contracts in a common law jurisdiction, and resolving contract disputes can be very adversarial in common law systems. But common law systems have the advantage of greater flexibility and allow for judges to interpret a contract dispute in light of the prevailing situation. International businesses need to be sensitive to these differences; approaching a contract dispute in a state with a civil law system as if it had a common law system may backfire, and vice versa. When contract disputes arise in international trade, there is always the question of which country’s laws to apply. To resolve this issue, a number of countries, including the United States, have ratified the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CIGS). The CIGS establishes a uniform set of rules governing certain aspects of the making and performance of everyday commercial contracts between sellers and buyers who have their places of business in different nations. By adopting the CIGS, a nation signals to other adopters that it will treat the convention’s rules as part of its law. The CIGS applies automatically to all contracts for the sale of goods between different firms based in countries that have ratified the convention, unless the parties to the contract explicitly opt out. One problem with the CIGS, however, is that fewer than 70 nations have ratified the convention (the CIGS went into effect in 1988).11 Many of the world’s larger trading nations, including Japan and the United Kingdom, have not ratified the CIGS. When firms do not wish to accept the CIGS, they often opt for arbitration by a recognized arbitration court to settle contract disputes. The most well known of these courts is the International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce in Paris. In 2004, this court handled some 561 requests for arbitration involving 1,682 parties from 116 countries.12 Almost 60 percent of disputes involved sums in excess of $1 million.
PROPERTY RIGHTS AND CORRUPTION In a legal sense, the term property refers to a resource over which an individual or business holds a legal title; that is, a resource that it owns. Resources include land, buildings, equipment, capital, mineral rights, businesses, and intellectual property (ideas, which are protected by patents, copyrights, and trademarks). Property rights refer to the legal rights over the use to which a resource is put and over the use made of any income that may be derived from that resource.13 Countries differ in the extent to which their legal systems define and protect property rights. Although almost all countries have laws on their books that protect property rights, in many countries these laws are not enforced by the authorities and property rights are violated. Property rights can be violated in two ways—through private action and through public action.
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 52
12/8/06 5:17:02 PM
Private Action In this context, private action refers to theft, piracy, blackmail, and the like by private individuals or groups. Although theft occurs in all countries, a weak legal system allows for a much higher level of criminal action in some than in others. For example, in Russia in the chaotic period following the collapse of communism, an outdated legal system, coupled with a weak police force and judicial system, offered both domestic and foreign businesses scant protection from blackmail by the “Russian Mafia.” Successful business owners in Russia often had to pay “protection money” to the Mafia or face violent retribution, including bombings and assassinations (about 500 contract killings of businessmen occurred in 1995 and again in 1996).14 Russia is not alone in having Mafia problems (and the situation in Russia has improved significantly since the mid-1990s). The Mafia has a long history in the United States (Chicago in the 1930s was similar to Moscow in the 1990s). In Japan, the local version of the Mafia, known as the yakuza, runs protection rackets, particularly in the food and entertainment industries.15 However, there was a big difference between the magnitude of such activity in Russia in the 1990s and its limited impact in Japan and the United States. This difference arose because the legal enforcement apparatus, such as the police and court system, was so weak in Russia following the collapse of communism. Many other countries from time to time have had problems similar to or even greater than those experienced by Russia.
Private Action Theft, piracy, blackmail, and the like by private individuals or groups.
Public Action and Corruption Public action to violate property rights occurs
Public Action
when public officials, such as politicians and government bureaucrats, extort income, resources, or the property itself from property holders (see the opening case for an example). This can be done through legal mechanisms such as levying excessive taxation, requiring expensive licenses or permits from property holders, taking assets into state ownership without compensating the owners, or redistributing assets without compensating the prior owners. It can also be done through illegal means, or corruption, by demanding bribes from businesses in return for the rights to operate in a country, industry, or location.16 Corruption has been well documented in every society, from the banks of the Congo River to the palace of the Dutch royal family, from Japanese politicians to Brazilian bankers, and from Indonesian government officials to the New York City Police Department. The government of the late Ferdinand Marcos in the Philippines was famous for demanding bribes from foreign businesses wishing to set up operations in that country.17 The same was true of government officials in Indonesia under the rule of former president Suharto. No society is immune to corruption. However, there are systematic differences in the extent of corruption. In some countries, the rule of law minimizes corruption. Corruption is seen and treated as illegal, and when discovered, violators are punished by the full force of the law. In other countries, the rule of law is weak and corruption by bureaucrats and politicians is rife. Corruption is so endemic in some countries that politicians and bureaucrats regard it as a perk of office and openly flout laws against corruption. According to Transparency International, an independent nonprofit organization dedicated to exposing and fighting corruption, businesses and individuals spend some $400 billion a year worldwide on bribes related to government procurement contracts alone.18 Transparency International has also measured the level of corruption among public officials in different countries.19 As can be seen in Figure 2.1, the organization rated countries such as Finland and New Zealand as clean; it rated others, such as Russia, India, Indonesia, and Zimbabwe, as corrupt. Bangladesh ranked last out of all 158 countries in the survey, and Finland ranked first.
The extortion of income or resources from property holders by public officials, such as politicians and government bureaucrats.
Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 53
53
12/8/06 5:17:02 PM
figure
2.1
Rankings of Corruption by Country, 2005 Source: Transparency International, “Global Corruption Report,” 2006.
Finland New Zealand United Kingdom United States France Japan Malaysia Italy Brazil China India Zimbabwe Russia Indonesia Nigeria Bangladesh 0
2
4
6
8
10
Corruption Perceptions Index (10 = clean; 0 = totally corrupt)
Economic evidence suggests that high levels of corruption significantly reduce the foreign direct investment, level of international trade, and economic growth rate in a country.20 By siphoning off profits, corrupt politicians and bureaucrats reduce the returns to business investment and, hence, reduce the incentive of both domestic and foreign businesses to invest in that country. The lower level of investment that results hurts economic growth. Thus, we would expect countries such as Indonesia, Nigeria, and Russia to have a much lower rate of economic growth than might otherwise have been the case. A detailed example of the negative effect that corruption can have on economic progress is given in the accompanying Country Focus, which looks at the impact of corruption on economic growth in Nigeria.
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act U.S. law regulating behavior regarding the conduct of international business in the taking of bribes and other unethical actions.
54
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act In the 1970s, the United States passed the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act following revelations that U.S. companies had bribed government officials in foreign countries in an attempt to win lucrative contracts. This law makes it illegal to bribe a foreign government official to obtain or maintain business over which that foreign official has authority, and it requires all publicly traded companies (whether or not they are involved in international trade) to keep detailed records that would reveal whether a violation of the act has occurred. Along the same lines, in 1997 trade and finance ministers from the member states of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), an association of the world’s 30 most powerful economies, adopted the Convention on Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions.21 The convention obliges member states to make the bribery of foreign public officials a criminal offense. However, both the U.S. law and OECD convention include language that allows for exceptions known as facilitating or expediting payments (also called grease payments
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 54
12/8/06 5:17:03 PM
Country FOCUS Corruption in Nigeria When Nigeria gained independence from Great Britain in 1960, there were hopes that the country might emerge as an economic heavyweight in Africa. Not only was Nigeria Africa’s most populous country, but it also was blessed with abundant natural resources, particularly oil, from which the country earned over $400 billion between 1970 and 2005. Despite this, Nigeria remains one of the poorest countries in the world. According to the 2005 Human Development Index compiled by the United Nations, Nigeria ranked 158 out of 177 countries covered. Gross national income per capita was just $430, 32 percent of the adult population was illiterate, and life expectancy at birth was only 43 years. What went wrong? Although there is no simple answer, a number of factors seem to have conspired to damage economic activity in Nigeria. The country is composed of several competing ethnic, tribal, and religious groups, and the conflict among them has limited political stability and led to political strife, including a brutal civil war in the 1970s. With the legitimacy of the government always in question, political leaders often purchased support by legitimizing bribes and by raiding the national treasury to reward allies. Civilian rule after independence was followed by a series of military dictatorships, each of which seemed more corrupt and inept than the last (the country returned to civilian rule in 1999). During the 1990s, the military dictator, Sani Abacha, openly and systematically plundered the state treasury for his own personal gain. His most blatant scam was the Petroleum Trust Fund, which he set up in the mid-1990s ostensibly to channel extra revenue from an increase in fuel prices into much-needed infrastructure projects and other investments. The fund was not independently audited, and almost none of the money that passed through it was properly accounted for. It was, in fact, a vehicle for Abacha and his supporters to spend at will a sum that in 1996 was equivalent to some 25 percent of
the total federal budget. Abacha, aware of his position as an unpopular and unelected leader, lavished money on personal security and handed out bribes to those whose support he coveted. With examples like this at the very top of the government, it is not surprising that corruption could be found throughout the political and bureaucratic apparatus. Some of the excesses were simply astounding. In the 1980s an aluminum smelter was built on the orders of the government, which wanted to industrialize Nigeria. The cost of the smelter was $2.4 billion, some 60 to 100 percent higher than the cost of comparable plants elsewhere in the developed world. This high cost was widely interpreted to reflect the bribes that had to be paid to local politicians by the international contractors that built the plant. The smelter has never operated at more than a fraction of its intended capacity. Has the situation in Nigeria improved since the country returned to civilian rule in 1999? In 2003, Olusegun Obasanjo was elected president on a platform that included a promise to fight corruption. By some accounts, progress has been seen. His anticorruption chief, Nuhu Ribadu, has claimed that whereas 70 percent of the country’s oil revenues were being stolen or wasted in 2002, by 2004 the figure was “only” 40 percent. But in its most recent survey, Transparency International still ranked Nigeria among the most corrupt countries in the world in 2005 (see Figure 2.1), suggesting that the country still has long way to go. Mr. Ribadu has suggested that the problem lies with state governments, which are still riddled with corruption. Sources: “A Tale of Two Giants,” The Economist, January 15, 2000, p. 5; J. Coolidge and S. Rose Ackerman, “High Level Rent Seeking and Corruption in African Regimes,” World Bank policy research working paper no. 1780, June 1997; D. L. Bevan, P. Collier, and J. W. Gunning, Nigeria and Indonesia: The Political Economy of Poverty, Equity and Growth (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999); “Democracy and Its Discontents,” The Economist, January 29, 2005, p. 55; and A. Field. “Can Reform Save Nigeria?” Journal of Commerce, November 21, 2005, p. 1.
or speed money), the purpose of which is to expedite or to secure the performance of a routine governmental action.22 For example, they allow for small payments made to speed up the issuance of permits or licenses, process paperwork, or just get vegetables off the dock and on their way to market. The explanation for this exception to general antibribery provisions is that while grease payments are, technically, bribes, they are distinguishable from (and, apparently, less offensive than) bribes used to obtain or Chapter Two National Differences in Political Economy
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 55
55
12/8/06 5:17:04 PM
Intellectual Property Property that is the product of intellectual activity.
maintain business, because they merely facilitate performance of duties that the recipients are already obligated to perform.
THE PROTECTION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY Intellectual
property refers to property that is the product of intellectual activity, such as computer software, a screenplay, a music score, or the chemical formula for a new drug. Patent A legal device that Patents, copyrights, and trademarks establish ownership rights over intellectual grants the inventor of a property. A patent grants the inventor of a new product or process exclusive rights new product or process for a defined period to the manufacture, use, or sale of that invention. Copyrights exclusive rights for a defined period to the are the exclusive legal rights of authors, composers, playwrights, artists, and pubmanufacture, use, or lishers to publish and disperse their work as they see fit. Trademarks are designs sale of that invention. and names, often officially registered, by which merchants or manufacturers designate and differentiate their products (e.g., Christian Dior clothes). In the highCopyrights technology “knowledge” economy of the twenty-first century, intellectual property Exclusive legal rights has become an increasingly important source of economic value for businesses. of authors, composers, Protecting intellectual property has also become increasingly problematic, particuplaywrights, artists, and publishers to publish larly if it can be rendered in a digital form and then copied and distributed at very and dispose of their low cost via pirated CDs or over the Internet (e.g., computer software, music and work as they see fit. video recordings).23 The philosophy behind intellectual property laws is to reward the originator of a Trademarks new invention, book, musical record, clothes design, restaurant chain, and the like, for Designs and names, his or her idea and effort. Such laws stimulate innovation and creative work. They often officially registered, provide an incentive for people to search for novel ways of doing things, and they reby which merchants or manufacturers designate ward creativity. For example, consider innovation in the pharmaceutical industry. A and differentiate their patent will grant the inventor of a new drug a 20-year monopoly in production of that products. drug. This gives pharmaceutical firms an incentive to undertake the expensive, difficult, and time-consuming basic research required to generate new drugs (it can cost $800 million in R&D and take 12 years to get a new drug on the market). Without the World Intellectual Property guarantees provided by patents, companies would be unlikely to commit themselves to Organization extensive basic research.24 An international The protection of intellectual property rights differs greatly from country to organization whose members sign treaties country. Although many countries have stringent intellectual property regulations on to agree to protect their books, the enforcement of these regulations has often been lax. This has been the intellectual property. case even among many of the 183 countries that are now members of the World Intellectual Property Organization, all of which have signed international treaties designed to protect intellectual property, including the oldest such treaty, the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, which dates to 1883 and has been signed by some 169 nations as of 2006. Weak enforcement encourages the piracy (theft) of intellectual property. China and Thailand have recently been among the worst offenders in Asia. Pirated computer software is widely available in China. Similarly, the streets of Bangkok, Thailand’s capital, are lined with stands selling pirated copies of Rolex watches, Levi Strauss jeans, videotapes, and computer software. A security guard stands near a pile of pirated CDs and DVDs before they were Piracy in music recordings is rampant. The destroyed at a ceremony in Beijing on Saturday, February 26, 2005. Thousands International Federation of the Phonographic of pirated items were destroyed in the event. AP/Wide World Photos Industry claims that about one-third of all recorded 56
Part Two Country Differences
hiL10544_ch02_040-085.indd 56
12/8/06 5:17:07 PM
Management FOCUS “I hadn’t heard of Starbucks at the time,” claimed the manager, “so how could I imitate its brand and logo?” However, in January 2006 a Shanghai court ruled that Starbucks had precedence, in part because it had registered its Chinese name in 1998. The Court stated that Xing Ba Ke’s use of the name and similar logo was “clearly malicious” and constituted improper competition. The court ordered Xing Ba Ke to stop using the name and to pay Starbucks $62,000 in compensation. While the money involved here may be small, the precedent is not. In a country where violation of trademarks has been commonplace, the courts seem to be signaling that a shift toward greater protection of intellectual property rights may be in progress. This is perhaps not surprising, since foreign governments and the World Trade Organization have been pushing China hard recently to start respecting intellectual property rights.
Starbucks Wins Key Trademark Case in China Starbucks has big plans for China. It believes the fast-growing nation will become the company’s secondlargest market after the United States. Starbucks ent