ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
Selected Titles in ABC-CLIO’s CONTEMPORARY
WORLD ISSUES Series
American Families in Crisis, J...
120 downloads
4111 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
Selected Titles in ABC-CLIO’s CONTEMPORARY
WORLD ISSUES Series
American Families in Crisis, Jeffrey S. Turner Campaign and Election Reform, Glenn H. Utter and Ruth Ann Strickland Chemical and Biological Warfare, Al Mauroni Childhood Sexual Abuse, Karen L. Kinnear Climate Change, David L. Downie, Kate Brash, and Catherine Vaughan Corporate Crime, Richard D. Hartley Domestic Violence, Margi Laird McCue Education in Crisis, Judith A. Gouwens Emergency Management, Jeffrey B. Bumgarner Energy Use Worldwide, Jaina L. Moan and Zachary A. Smith Food Safety, Nina E. Redman Gangs, Karen L. Kinnear Globalization, Justin Ervin and Zachary A. Smith Lobbying in America, Ronald J. Hrebenar and Bryson B. Morgan Mainline Christians and U.S. Public Policy, Glenn H. Utter Mental Health in America, Donna R. Kemp Modern Sports Ethics, Angela Lumpkin Nuclear Weapons and Nonproliferation, Sarah J. Diehl and James Clay Moltz Obesity, Judith S. Stern and Alexandra Kazaks Policing in America, Leonard A. Steverson Renewable and Alternative Energy Resources, Zachary A. Smith and Katrina D. Taylor Rich and Poor in America, Geoffrey Gilbert Sentencing, Dean John Champion U.S. National Security, Cynthia A. Watson U.S. Social Security, Steven G. Livingston Waste Management, Jacqueline Vaughn For a complete list of titles in this series, please visit www.abc-clio.com.
Books in the Contemporary World Issues series address vital issues in today’s society, such as genetic engineering, pollution, and biodiversity. Written by professional writers, scholars, and nonacademic experts, these books are authoritative, clearly written, up-to-date, and objective. They provide a good starting point for research by high school and college students, scholars, and general readers as well as by legislators, businesspeople, activists, and others. Each book, carefully organized and easy to use, contains an overview of the subject, a detailed chronology, biographical sketches, facts and data and/or documents and other primarysource material, a directory of organizations and agencies, annotated lists of print and nonprint resources, and an index. Readers of books in the Contemporary World Issues series will find the information they need to have a better understanding of the social, political, environmental, and economic issues facing the world today.
ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE A Reference Handbook Second Edition
David E. Newton
CONTEMPORARY
WORLD ISSUES
Santa Barbara, California Denver, Colorado Oxford, England
Copyright © 2009 by ABC-CLIO, LLC All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Newton, David E. Environmental justice : a reference handbook / David E. Newton. — 2nd ed. p. cm. — (Contemporary world issues) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-59884-223-4 (hard copy : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-1-59884-224-1 (ebook) 1. Distributive justice. 2. Environmental justice—Social aspects. 3. Civil rights. I. Title. JC578.N485 2009 363.7—dc22 2008044400 13 12 11 10 09
1 2 3 4 5
ABC-CLIO, LLC 130 Cremona Drive, P.O. Box 1911 Santa Barbara, California 93116–1911 This book is also available on the World Wide Web as an ebook. Visit www.abc-clio.com for details. This book is printed on acid-free paper Manufactured in the United States of America.
Once again, for Delores and Reg with as much love as ever!
Contents
List of Tables, xv Preface, xvii 1
Background and History, 1 Warren County, North Carolina: September 15, 1982, 1 Environmental Inequities, Environmental Racism, and Environmental Justice, 2 Examples of Environmental Inequities, 6 West Dallas, Texas, 6 Churchrock, New Mexico, 7 “Cancer Alley,” 9 Pesticide Exposure, 11 Consumption of Toxic Fish from the Detroit River, 13 Proposed Select Steel Corporation Plant (Flint, Michigan), 14 Sweet Valley and Cobb Town, Alabama, 15 West Harlem Environmental Action and Diesel Buses, 16 Southern Nuclear Operating Company, 17 Environmental Justice: Environmentalism and Civil Rights, 18 The Modern Environmental Movement, 20 The Civil Rights Movement, 22 Environmental Justice Comes of Age, 23 The Commission on Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ, 23 The Michigan Conference, 25 Governmental Recognition in the 1990s, 26 First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit, 26
ix
x Contents
Environmental Justice as a Social Movement, 27 Growth and Challenges, 29 References, 33 2
Problems, Controversies, and Solutions, 37 Do Environmental Inequities Actually Exist?, 38 Progress and Environmental Degradation, 42 NIMBY, PIBBY, and LULUs, 43 Concerns about Environmental Issues among People of Color, 44 Access to Tools of Protest, 46 Job Blackmail, 47 The Effects of Environmental Regulations, 50 Environmental Inequities: By Chance or By Choice?, 53 The Legal Question of “Intent” in Environmental Inequities, 57 Responding to Environmental Inequities, 59 The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the United States, 60 Environmental Inequities Exist, 60 Federal, State, Regional, and Local Governmental Agencies Have a Responsibility to Find, Study, and Deal with Cases of Environmental Inequities, 61 The Federal Government Has Not Been a Strong Advocate for Environmental Justice, 65 Complaints Filed with the EPA Have Not Been an Effective Means of Dealing with Environmental Inequities, 68 Environmental Justice Advocates Have Largely Failed to Obtain Redress from Inequities through the Judicial System, 69 The U.S. Congress Has Failed to Take Action on Basic Environmental Justice Legislation, 71 Environmental Justice Activists Have Learned to Use a Combination of Tools for Achieving Their Goals, 73 References, 76
3
Worldwide Perspective, 81 Environmental Inequities Worldwide, 81 Mineral Extraction in Papua New Guinea, 82
Contents xi
Environmental Discrimination against the Roma in Central Europe, 83 Ecotourism and the Maasai, 85 The Bakun Hydroelectric Project in Sarawak, 86 Thor Chemicals and Mercury “Recycling,” 87 The Voyage of the Khian Sea, 89 A Background for the Transboundary Dumping of Hazardous Wastes, 91 The Basel Convention, 93 Other Treaties and Bans, 96 Environmental Justice and Climate Change, 97 Environmental Justice and Sustainable Development, 103 References, 108 4
Chronology, 113
5
Biographical Sketches, 137 Dana Ann Alston, 137 Bunyan Bryant, 139 Robert Bullard, 140 Dollie Burwell, 141 César Chávez, 142 Torri Estrada, 143 Margie Eugene-Richard, 144 Jay Feldman, 145 Deeohn Ferris, 146 LaDonna Harris, 148 Hazel Johnson, 149 Pamela Tau Lee, 150 Graciela Martinez, 151 Norris McDonald, 152 Paul Mohai, 153 Richard Moore, 155 Na’taki Osborne, 155 Swati Prakash, 157 Patricia E. Salkin, 158 Peggy Shepard, 159 Gail Small, 160 Damu Smith, 161 Beverly Wright, 163
xii Contents
6
Data and Documents, 165 Documents, 166 Civil Rights Act of 1964, 166 Fair Housing Act of 1968, 167 National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, 168 Siting of Hazardous Waste Landfills and Their Correlation with Racial and Economic Status of Surrounding Communities (1983), 171 Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States (1987), 172 Principles of Environmental Justice (1991), 173 Environmental Equity: Reducing Risks for All Communities (1992), 175 Executive Order 12898 (President Clinton)—Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations (1994), 178 Not in My Backyard: Executive Order 12898 and Title VI as Tools for Achieving Environmental Justice (2003), 181 2003–2008 EPA Strategic Plan: Direction for the Future (2003), 182 Toolkit for Assessing Potential Allegations of Environmental Injustice (2004), 185 Evaluation Report: EPA Needs to Consistently Implement the Intent of the Executive Order on Environmental Justice (2004), 188 Redefining Rights in America: The Civil Rights Record of the George W. Bush Administration, 2001–2004 (2004), 190 Environmental Justice: EPA Should Devote More Attention to Environmental Justice When Developing Clean Air Rules (2005), 197 Toxic Wastes and Race at Twenty (2007), 198 S. 2549: Environmental Justice Renewal Act (2008), 202 Data, 209
7
Directory of Organizations, 213 Governmental Organizations, 214 Nongovernmental Organizations, 217 National and International, 217 State, Regional, and Local, 235
Contents xiii
8
Resources, 245 Books, 245 Articles, 261 Reports, 280 Internet Sources, 282
Glossary, 289 Index, 295 About the Author, 308
List of Tables
6.1 1980 Census Population, Income, and Poverty Data for Census Areas Where Landfills Are Located, 172 6.2 Racial and Socioeconomic Characteristics of People Living Near Hazardous Waste Facilities, 209 6.3 Racial and Socioeconomic Disparities between Host Neighborhoods and Non-Host Areas for the Nation’s 413 Commercial Hazardous Waste Facilities (1990 and 2000 Census), 210 6.4 People of Color Percentages for Host Neighborhoods and Non-Host Areas by EPA Region, 211 6.5 Socioeconomic Disparities between Host Neighborhoods and Non-Host Areas by EPA Region, 212
xv
Preface
E
nvironmentalism and the civil rights movement have been two of the most important social movements in the United States over the past half century. At first glance, these two great movements would appear to have little or nothing in common. And, in fact, some observers have argued that steps taken to improve the nation’s environmental quality may actually have had a deleterious effect on the social and economic status of African Americans, Hispanic Americans, Asian Americans, and Native Americans. Studies have shown, for example, that laws passed to reduce environmental impacts overall have, in some cases, had an unfair impact on minority or poor communities. Only within the last three decades has it become apparent that environmentalism and civil rights do have a great deal in common. That realization has come about primarily as the result of redefining the “environmental issues” to which Americans should turn their attention. More and more individuals and groups are pointing to the special environmental problems facing minority and low-income communities: hazardous waste sites, polluting industries, occupational hazards, and exposure to lead and other toxic metals, for example. The emphasis seems to be shifting from an almost exclusive concern with issues such as wilderness preservation and protection of endangered species to maintenance of livable environments for people of color and low-income communities. Out of this view of environmental issues has grown a new movement—the environmental justice movement—that attempts to analyze patterns of disproportionate exposure to environmental hazards experienced by minority and low-income communities, to understand how such patterns have developed,
xvii
xviii Preface
and to develop programs by which disproportionate exposures can be remedied and prevented. The environmental justice movement has undergone a significant evolution in the last three decades. At first, the concerns expressed by its leaders were largely ignored or regarded with little concern. Low-income and minority communities themselves seldom had the knowledge or the skills to deal with the special environmental inequities with which they were confronted. Over time, however, that situation changed. Strong leaders from the African American, Asian American, Native American, Hispanic American, and other communities began to develop theory and practices on which to base a strong and effective environmental justice movement. In some ways, a turning point for the movement was reached in 1994, when President Bill Clinton issued an executive order requiring all federal agencies to make environmental justice an integral part of their missions. Progress in dealing with environmental inequities has not, however, been smooth or constant. It has fallen prey to the influence of varying social, economic, and political forces that have (and often have not) supported the growth of efforts to achieve environmental justice. During the administration of President George W. Bush, for example, much of the momentum created by President Clinton’s executive order was lost, as Bush officials stepped back from vigorous enforcement of environmental policies and regulations and, indeed, attempted to redefine the meaning of environmental justice itself. This book examines the nature, growth, and vicissitudes of the environmental justice movement. Chapter 1 provides a general introduction to the history of the movement, explaining the forces that led to its birth, the philosophy that underlies much of its work today, and the tools through which it attempts to achieve its goals. The chapter also contains a number of examples of cases in which environmental inequities have affected individual communities. The irony of the modern environmental justice movement is that it carries such great hope for low-income people and minority communities in the relief of the environmental hazards to which they are often exposed. But concrete success in dealing with many of the issues has often seemed too slow and much too inadequate. Chapter 2 reviews some of the problems and controversies that may have contributed to this situation. It also dis-
Preface xix
cusses some possible solutions to the problems that hinder the development of the movement. One might easily think of environmental justice as a uniquely American movement grounded in environmental problems found exclusively in the United States. And, in some ways, that view is accurate. Many of the problems faced by low-income and minority communities (and by Americans as a whole) result from the prodigious industrial complex operating in this country, with its consequent effluents and wastes constantly being released into the environment. But people in other parts of the world face similar problems of inequitable exposure to hazardous materials based on income and race. For example, industries in developed nations have long viewed less-developed nations as legitimate dumping grounds for the wastes they produce at home. Chapter 3 considers some issues related to environmental inequities in parts of the world other than the United States. Chapters 4 through 8 provide a variety of resources to help the reader continue further study of environmental justice. Chapter 4 contains a chronology of the movement, a movement that, although still young, has made some important strides. Chapter 5 consists of biographical sketches of some important figures in the movement. Chapter 6 contains documents relating to the growth and work of the environmental justice movement, including relevant laws, recommendations for action, and proposed legislation. Chapter 7 provides a list of organizations active in the field. The list is representative only; one characteristic of the environmental justice movement is its emphasis on action by local and regional groups, which precludes the ability to provide an exhaustive list. Chapter 8 contains a selected bibliography of books, articles, reports, and Internet sources relating to the environmental justice movement. A glossary of terms commonly used in dealing with environmental justice issues is included, and an index is also provided.
1 Background and History
Warren County, North Carolina: September 15, 1982 The protest tactics seemed clear enough. Most residents of Warren County knew how civil rights battles of the 1960s had been fought: with civil disobedience and nonviolent protest. The issue in 1982 was somewhat different, involving the construction of a waste disposal dump for toxic chemicals, but poor African Americans in Warren County knew their history well enough. The road to follow was not one of violent confrontation but of nonviolent demonstration and protest. The issue had arisen four years earlier when the Ward Transformer Company of Raleigh had illegally and surreptitiously disposed of 31,000 gallons of toxic polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) along 240 miles of roadways in 14 North Carolina counties. When the state of North Carolina uncovered the action, it was faced with the problem of digging up and relocating 40,000 cubic yards of contaminated soil. The state decided to bury those wastes in rural Shocco Township in Warren County. The state’s decision came under criticism almost immediately. Geological studies showed that soil under the proposed landfill was not impervious to leaching from the landfill, as required by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations, and the water table in the area was only about 7 feet below the landfill bottom, 43 feet shallower than required by the EPA. Since the majority of Warren County residents obtain their water from wells, these geological conditions raised serious questions
1
2 Background and History
about the state’s decision. On June 4, 1979, however, the EPA gave North Carolina a waiver on both of these requirements and issued a permit for the landfill. Residents of Warren County had had little experience in fighting political battles. As a group, they were poor (the county ranked 97th among North Carolina’s 100 counties in per capita income) and African American (75 percent in Shocco Township and 64 percent in Warren County) and lacked the resources, knowledge, and skills to fight a state political and bureaucratic system. Still, they used the skills they had. They made public appeals, called for help from national leaders of civil rights and environmental groups, and, in the end, prostrated their bodies in front of trucks carrying PCB-contaminated soil to their community. In all, 523 protestors were arrested. In one sense, the Warren County protest failed. Over a sixweek period, the 20-acre landfill was filled with 7,223 truckloads of wastes. The wastes remained in place for nearly 20 years, all the while leaching contaminants into the underlying soil. In a larger sense, however, the protest was more successful than anyone could have imagined. For the first time in history, poor African Americans banded together—with the support of civil rights and environmental groups on a national level—to fight an environmental problem affecting a poor minority community.
Environmental Inequities, Environmental Racism, and Environmental Justice Most great social movements in history can be marked by a “defining moment,” a single event so powerful and moving that later generations can look back and say, “It all started at . . . .” Rosa Parks’s refusal to give up her seat on a Montgomery, Alabama, bus to a white man and move to the back of the bus is one such example of a defining moment in the civil rights movement. Historians may well look back at the protest by Warren County citizens and say, “That protest was the defining moment of the environmental justice movement.” Of course, such views of history are usually overly simplified and often incorrect. A nascent civil rights movement had been active long before Parks’s heroic decision to confront racist laws in Montgomery. And the seeds of a movement that would
Environmental Inequities, Racism, and Justice 3
confront environmental inequities had been planted years before the Warren County protest brought the movement to public attention. The issue facing residents of Warren County, North Carolina, in 1982 was and is not unique in the United States. The issue has been described as environmental inequity or environmental racism, terms that refer to the generally accepted evidence that environmental hazards are not distributed equally among various groups of people, either in the United States or throughout the world. Instead, communities of color and, to a lesser extent, poor people in general are exposed to hazardous and toxic wastes, dangerous working conditions, polluted air and water, and other environmental insults to a greater degree than are noncolored communities and people of higher economic status. Although the reasons for this pattern are disputed, its existence has been confirmed by multiple research studies. The term communities of color, as described by those active in the environmental justice movement, refers to people who are nonwhite: African Americans, Hispanic Americans, Asian Americans, and Native Americans, for example. The terms used to talk about this phenomenon are important because they focus on and emphasize quite different aspects of the issue. Environmental inequity refers to a geographic reality, a pattern in which hazardous waste sites, polluting industries, nuclear waste dumps, and other environmental threats are more likely to be located within or adjacent to communities of color or poor communities. The existence of environmental inequities in the United States, within individual states, or in other localities can be determined—at least in principle—by research studies. Researchers count the number of environmentally hazardous facilities and determine whether inequities are likely to occur in such communities. Such studies have been conducted, and the evidence implies that environmental inequities do exist in the United States. For example, researchers at the Southeast Community Research Center in Atlanta reported in 2007 on the use of agricultural pesticides in and near communities of color in the rural U.S. South. They found that such communities were exposed to greatly disproportionate numbers of pesticide use events compared to comparable communities of white residents (Griffith, Tajik, and Wing 2007). A number of similar studies, along with some that dispute the existence of environmental inequities, are discussed later in this chapter.
4 Background and History
Environmental racism is a term that introduces a second concept into the discussion of environmental inequities. Environmental racism goes beyond acknowledging that such inequities exist and suggests a reason for their existence: racism. The phrase environmental racism was first used in 1982 by Benjamin Chavis, then executive director of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), in connection with the protest at Warren County. He later explained precisely what he meant by the term during testimony before the U.S. House of Representatives Subcommittee on Civil and Constitutional Rights on March 3, 1993: “Environmental racism is defined as racial discrimination in environmental policy making and the unequal enforcement of environmental laws and regulations. It is the deliberate targeting of people of color communities for toxic waste facilities and the official sanctioning of a life-threatening presence of poisons and pollutants in people of color communities. It is also manifested in the history of excluding people of color from the leadership of the environmental movement” (U.S. Congress 1993, 6). A second term, environmental discrimination, is also used in referring to the unequal distribution of environmental insults but may suggest that such inequalities affect communities other than those of color, such as those of low income. An important feature of both environmental racism and environmental discrimination is that they suggest that environmental inequities occur not because of chance, random events in history but as the concrete and specific consequences of official public and corporate policies, whether conscious and deliberate or not. Proving the existence of environmental racism or environmental discrimination is a quite different matter from proving the existence of environmental inequities. Even if one grants that such inequities exist, it does not necessarily follow that they are the result of some specific intent on the part of an individual or a corporation. The debate as to whether environmental inequities occur as the result of concrete policies and practices designed to bring them about or as the incidental consequences of other business practices will be reviewed later in this book. The term environmental justice alludes to yet another aspect of this issue. It refers to policies and practices by which existing environmental inequities can be corrected and prevented in the future. It focuses on research programs that attempt to detect the existence of environmental racism and environmental
Environmental Inequities, Racism, and Justice 5
discrimination; that uncover the underlying reasons that hold such practices in place; and that promote the enforcement of existing laws and regulations, the adoption of new rules and regulations, and the changes in philosophies and attitudes needed to eliminate environmental racism and environmental inequities from society. The achievement of environmental justice among communities is also called environmental equity, the situation in which environmental risks and benefits among all groups of people are approximately comparable. Dr. Robert D. Bullard, one of the most prolific and articulate writers on the subject of environmental justice, has identified three broad categories into which the field of environmental justice can be subdivided. These are procedural equity, geographic equity, and social equity. Procedural equity refers to questions of fairness, “the extent to which governing rules and regulations, evaluation criteria, and enforcement are applied in a nondiscriminatory manner.” Geographic equity refers to the location of environmental hazards with regard to communities of color and poor communities. Social equity concerns the way in which social factors, such as race, ethnicity, class, and political power, have an impact on and are reflected in environmental decision making (Bullard 2000, 116). The environmental inequities that exist in the United States include a variety of hazardous conditions. During the 1970s, much attention was focused on air and water pollution. Data from that period clearly show that the impact and costs of these environmental problems—although often not explicitly stated in reports—were not shared equally by all Americans. Two decades later, in the early stages of the environmental justice movement, research focused on municipal landfills, hazardous waste dumps, and emissions from chemical plants. As the movement has matured, however, it has become clear that many other forms of environmental inequities exist: in the siting of nuclear waste sites; in the nature and extent of occupational hazards to which workers are exposed; in the health hazards to which people are exposed in their daily diets; in planning for and construction of highways and public transit systems; in the siting of parks and other recreational facilities; in the production, testing, and disposal of conventional weapons systems; in the international distribution of hazardous and toxic wastes; and in the manufacture and sale of hazardous products.
6 Background and History
Examples of Environmental Inequities The term racism may cause one to focus on the inequalities that African Americans have historically experienced in the United States. It is clear, however, that other groups within American society—including Native Americans, Asian Americans, Pacific Islanders, and Hispanic Americans—have also been subjected to similar kinds of discrimination. The examples on the following pages are a few of the hundreds that could demonstrate the environmental insults to which minority and low-income groups within American society have been exposed. The cases illustrate the disproportionate exposure of minorities to environmental hazards; however, they do not in and of themselves necessarily prove the existence of environmental racism.
West Dallas, Texas In the late 1980s, West Dallas was a predominantly poor African American section of Dallas, Texas, with a population of 13,161, of whom 85 percent were African American. In recent decades, the area has grown considerably (2000 population: 24,132) and become primarily Hispanic American. But it remains one of the poorest regions of Dallas. When the area was annexed by Dallas in 1954, a number of private homes were torn down as part of a “slum clearance” program to make way for large public housing projects. As a result of this program, the Dallas Housing Authority became the largest single landlord in West Dallas. Immediately adjacent to the housing authority’s 3,500-unit West Dallas housing projects is the 63-acre West Dallas RSR lead smelter, originally the Murph Metals secondary lead smelter. At its peak operation in the 1970s, the smelter released more than 269 tons of lead into the air annually. A significant fraction of the lead was blown across the homes and recreational areas of West Dallas. In theory, such emissions came under the control of a strong lead emissions ordinance passed by the Dallas city council in 1968. According to Robert D. Bullard, however, “city officials systematically refused to enforce [the city’s] lead emission standards” (Bullard 2000, 47). In support of this observation, studies found blood lead levels in West Dallas children to be 36 percent higher than those in children in control areas, a result attributed to the children’s exposure to smelter emissions.
Examples of Environmental Inequities 7
The period between the mid-1960s and the early 1980s was marked by the continuing release of lead particulates from the smelter, multiple studies showing elevated blood lead levels in West Dallas children. Ongoing efforts by citizens of West Dallas to gain relief from their exposure to polluted air met with persistent stonewalling by local and national officials in the enforcement of existing regulations. The issue was resolved in 1983, when the state of Texas and the city of Dallas sued RSR for violations of city, state, and federal lead emission standards. The case was settled out of court when RSR agreed to clean up soil in the West Dallas area that had been contaminated by lead emission from its smelter, to conduct a blood lead screening program for children and pregnant women in West Dallas, and to install antipollution equipment on its West Dallas plant. The final point of the agreement became moot four months later when the smelter was closed permanently. The final word in this story may have been written in 1985, when RSR also agreed to a settlement in a civil case brought on behalf of 370 children in West Dallas. The company agreed to a program of payments that eventually reached nearly $45 million paid to those harmed by its smelter’s emissions. Although the cash settlement was large, it can never, as Bullard has pointed out, “repay the harm caused by lead poisoning of several generations of West Dallas children.” On the other hand, it does send a message, he says, “that poor black communities are no longer willing to accept other people’s pollution” (Bullard 2000, 51).
Churchrock, New Mexico Churchrock Chapter is a governmental unit within the Navajo Nation, the largest Native American tribe in the United States. The chapter is located east of Gallup, New Mexico, in an area characterized by extremely dry conditions with an average annual rainfall of about seven inches. The major source of water in the region is the Rio Puerco, a stream that runs only intermittently, when fed by snow runoff or rainstorms. Churchrock is the site of the longest continuous period of uranium mining in the Navajo Nation. That period began in 1954 with the discovery of uranium deposits along the north edge of the Rio Puerco Valley and continued until 1986. Mining rights were leased to uranium mining companies by the Navajo tribal government, but without the consent or participation of
8 Background and History
individual Navajo families living in the area. During most of the 30-year period during which mining continued, residents of the Churchrock Chapter had relatively little information about the environmental effects caused by uranium mining and milling in their area. One of the most important of those effects was the removal of water from the Morrison Formation aquifer near the head of the Rio Puerco. Mining companies pumped water out of the aquifer at the rate of 5,000 gallons per minute to support the construction and operation of underground mines for the removal of uranium. That water was then returned to the Rio Puerco, converting the river into a continuously flowing stream. This practice had two important effects on the Churchrock environment. First, it resulted in a significant loss of underground water from which many people drew water by means of wells. Second, it resulted in the release of water contaminated with radioactive wastes into the Rio Puerco, the region’s major water source. For years, the two companies mining uranium in the Churchrock region—the Kerr-McGee Nuclear Corporation and United Nuclear Corporation—argued that the Federal Water Pollution Control Act did not apply to their operations since the Rio Puerco was located on Native American lands and was not, therefore, a part of the United States. It was not until 1980 that the courts confirmed that the two companies were subject to the same Clean Water Act jurisdiction as were companies operating in other parts of the United States. In 1983, the staff of the Southwest Research and Information Center in Albuquerque examined Kerr-McGee and United Nuclear records to determine the extent to which the two companies were in compliance with federal Clean Water Act regulations. They found that Kerr-McGee was out of compliance 7 of the 35 months studied, and United Nuclear was out of compliance 13 of 38 months in one location and 25 of 37 months in a second location. “Out of compliance” meant that mines were releasing waters that contained a higher concentration than permitted of dissolved uranium and/or radium-226, carried an excess of suspended solids, had a pH (a measure of the water’s acidity or alkalinity) that was higher or lower than permitted, or failed to meet other water quality standards. As unsatisfactory as these records were, they were dwarfed by a serious accident: the failure of a United Nuclear uranium
Examples of Environmental Inequities 9
mill tailings dam on July 16, 1979. More than 94 million gallons of contaminated liquids with a pH of 1 (roughly comparable to that of battery acid) were released into the Rio Puerco. The spill posed a serious health threat not only to Native Americans living in the area, but also to the livestock upon which many Native Americans depended for their livelihood. In 1985, United Nuclear settled a lawsuit brought as a result of this accident by agreeing to pay $550,000 to 240 plaintiffs, an award of about $2,000 per plaintiff. Still, it was not the 1979 spill that has been the most serious problem for residents of the Churchrock area. William Paul Robinson, research director of the Southwest Research and Information Center, has written that the spill “does not appear to have had as devastating an effect on the Rio Puerco as the decades of mine dewatering (the removal of water that seeps into a mine as it is dug), which preceded the spill. Studies of human and livestock health effects after the spill indicated that the same pollutants found in high concentrations in mine and tailings water had shown up in abnormally high levels in the muscles and organs of cattle, sheep, and goats that grazed along the Rio Puerco downstream of the mines and mills” (Robinson 1992, 160). As is often the case in environmental justice cases, actions against uranium mining in the Churchrock area may have been more successful than one might have imagined. Residents have formed the Puerco Valley Navajo Clean Water Association to learn more about the dangers of polluted waters and to search for new and safer water supplies for their community. As Robinson has pointed out, the Association’s 10th anniversary celebration on July 16, 1989, “focused on the need for water in the communities, not the horror of the spill itself” (Robinson 1992, 161).
“Cancer Alley” In some instances, a pattern of environmental inequity may extend over broad regions, affecting many communities at once. Such is the case with an 85-mile stretch of land along the Mississippi River between Baton Rouge and New Orleans, Louisiana. Louisiana has long publicized itself as a “sportsman’s paradise” and depended on agriculture and fishing as its main sources of income. At the end of World War II, however, the state’s political economy began to change. Attracted by the potential for easy transportation and waste disposal as well as the availability of
10 Background and History
cheap labor, chemical and petroleum companies moved into the region between the state capital and its largest city. Over the decades, these companies dramatically changed the character of the region. Today, more than 125 companies producing fertilizers, gasoline, paints, plastics, and other chemical products line the banks of the Mississippi. Approximately one-quarter of the nation’s petrochemicals are produced in the region. In addition, the plants release huge amounts of toxic wastes into the air, water, and surrounding countryside. By one estimate, more than 2 billion pounds of toxic chemicals were emitted in the two-year period between 1987 and 1989 (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993). For this reason, the region has been given the name “Cancer Alley” by residents of the area. The Washington Post has referred to the region as a “massive human experiment” and “a national sacrifice zone” (Maraniss and Weisskopf 1989, A1). The development of the new industrial complex along Cancer Alley, while undoubtedly beneficial to the state economy, has caused severe dislocations among communities along the river. In a 1993 study of Cancer Alley, the Louisiana Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights selected eight communities to study in detail: Revilletown, Sunrise, Morrisonville, Alsen, Wallace, Forest Grove, Center Springs, and Willow Springs. The committee found that the interaction between corporations and communities differed from town to town, and the ultimate resolution of disputes between the two entities also differed from case to case. In some instances, residents were able to prevent a new plant from moving into an area. In such cases, the community was able to survive, although it was not necessarily spared a significant increase in exposure to air- and water-borne pollutants released by nearby plants. In other cases, towns acceded to offers from companies to sell their homes and land to make room for new plants. Two of the communities studied, Revilletown and Sunrise, were dismantled completely as a result of buyout programs, and a third, Morrisonville, was relocated to make room for a plant. Despite the accommodations made by individual communities, the committee came to the conclusion that the 85-mile stretch of Cancer Alley had, indeed, earned its name. It reported to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights that “black communities in the corridor between Baton Rouge and New Orleans are dis-
Examples of Environmental Inequities 11
proportionately impacted by the present State and local government systems for permitting and expansion of hazardous waste and chemical facilities. These communities are most often located in rural and unincorporated areas, and residents are of low socioeconomic status with limited political influence facilities” (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993, 63). The committee further concluded that a major reason for the existence of Cancer Alley was that “state and local governments have failed to establish regulations or safeguards to ensure such communities are reasonably protected from a high concentration of hazardous waste and industrial facilities and risks associated with living in and around such facilities” (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993, 63).
Pesticide Exposure For more than half a century, U.S. farmers have relied heavily on the use of synthetic chemicals to protect their crops from destruction by insects, rodents, microorganisms, and other predators. Names such as DDT, aldrin, malathion, parathion, chlordane, heptachlor, toxaphene, and Sevin are now familiar to many Americans whether they are engaged in agriculture or not. These chemicals have been popular with farmers because they kill pests effectively at relatively modest costs. As the use of synthetic chemicals spread through agriculture, however, some important disadvantages became evident. Among other problems, some of the most popular pesticides proved to be toxic not only to pests but also to harmless or beneficial animals and to humans themselves. One of the most influential books on the problems posed by pesticides was Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring, published in 1962. In her book, Carson wrote about a spring in which no bird songs could be heard (the “silent spring”) because they had been killed by pesticides. Responding to growing public concerns about the risks posed by pesticides, the EPA began regulating agricultural chemicals much more closely in the early 1970s. In 1972, for example, it banned the widely popular pesticide dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT). In the same year, the U.S. Congress passed amendments to the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA), imposing much stronger regulations on the use of many pesticides. With actions such as these, many Americans began to feel that the most serious environmental
12 Background and History
problems posed by synthetic pesticides were being brought under control. However, pesticides continued to pose dangers to farmworkers. Many of the regulations passed to protect consumers from pesticides made no mention of the dangers posed to men and women working in the fields. Among the products banned by the EPA were a number of chlorinated hydrocarbon pesticides, such as aldrin, dieldrin, endrin, heptachlor, and chlordane. This class of pesticides tends to be persistent, meaning that they remain on fruits and vegetables long enough that they may be present when consumed by the general public. Farmers switched instead to pesticides known as organophosphates (malathion, parathion, and methyl parathion, for example) and carbamates (Sevin, Zectran, and Temik, for example). These compounds are more toxic but less persistent. They pose less threat to consumers (because they have degraded by the time fruits and vegetables reach the marketplace) but greater threat to farmworkers (Miller 2003). The problem of pesticide exposure is an important issue in the environmental justice movement because a large proportion of farmworkers are Hispanic Americans, especially Mexican Americans. Many are illegal aliens who work for less-thanminimum wages, often under difficult and illegal working conditions. They are seldom in a position to complain about working conditions since objections are likely to be met with dismissal from their jobs. It is true that laws have been passed to protect farmworkers. In general, however, those laws have been weak, poorly enforced, and, therefore, largely ineffective. For example, it is illegal to use pesticides on a field in such a way that workers will be sprayed directly. But this regulation does not necessarily protect workers on an adjacent field from being exposed to pesticides blown onto them. Also, state officials are allowed to use otherwise unlicensed pesticides in an emergency, such as the unexpected appearance of a pest. In such a case, the implication is that it is acceptable to expose farmworkers to a chemical hazard to save crops. Some regulations exist governing the period of time after spraying during which workers are not allowed to reenter fields. Given the paucity of data on safe intervals for most pesticides, however, such regulations may not be effective (Wasserstrom and Wiles 1985; Moses 1989, 1993). Overall, one observer has
Examples of Environmental Inequities 13
concluded that “the reality [of existing pesticide legislation] is that the extant legislation leaves farmworkers virtually unprotected against pesticide hazards” (Perfecto 1992, 216).
Consumption of Toxic Fish from the Detroit River Environmental inequities can exist in many forms. One that is probably less apparent than the cases described previously is in the dietary patterns of minorities who rely on fish taken from the Detroit River. An analysis of this issue was carried out by Patrick C. West, associate professor in the School of Natural Resources and Environment at the University of Michigan, and his colleagues in 1992. The study was motivated by the fact that state and federal guidelines currently specify the amount of toxic contaminants that may be released into surface waters. The regulated level of contaminants is determined, in turn, by assuming that the average person will consume a certain amount of fish per day. For example, the state of Michigan’s Rule 1057, which regulates the discharge of toxic chemicals into the state’s surface water, assumes that the average level of fish consumption in Michigan is 6.5 grams per person per day. Under those circumstances, an allowable amount of no more than 0.1 milligrams of a toxic substance in the fish would avoid endangering the health of the consumer. The flaw in this logic, however, is that some residents of Michigan are likely to consume more than 6.5 grams of fish each day on a regular basis. A person who regularly eats 10 or 20 grams of fish, for example, would then be exposed to two or three times the toxic amount assumed by the regulatory agency. Rather than being protected by federal or state regulation, consumers are instead lulled into a false sense of safety. West and his colleagues attempted to find out the extent to which this situation might exist in the state of Michigan and, if it did, the extent to which certain individuals might be exposed to unexpected environmental risks from eating fish. West’s team made two interesting discoveries. First, they found that, among those who fish in the Detroit River, 21.7 percent of whites in the sample were more likely to fish for both recreational purposes and to obtain food for meals, whereas 58 percent of nonwhites fished for both recreational purposes and to obtain food.
14 Background and History
In addition, the West research team found that members of all minority groups studied (African Americans, Native Americans, and other minorities) consumed about five times the amount of fish per day as assumed by Michigan’s Rule 1057. The team concluded that the regulation was, therefore, inadequate to protect those who fish primarily for food rather than for recreation. They ended their report with the observation that “to rely on a policy of fish consumption advisories creates more of a hardship for minorities because a needed protein source is at stake, not just a chance to catch that big one that didn’t get away” (West et al. 1992, 111).
Proposed Select Steel Corporation Plant (Flint, Michigan) The “justice” of the environmental justice movement sometimes seems so obvious that one wonders how critics can complain about efforts to ameliorate cases of environmental inequities. One answer to that question can be found in a complex case involving plans by the Select Steel Corporation of America in the late 1990s to build a new factory in Michigan’s Genesee County. Most residents of the county were delighted to hear of the plans as the new plant promised to bring with it at least 200 new jobs in an economically depressed region of the state. At least one group of citizens was not pleased with the proposal, however. Father Phil Schmitter and Sister Joanne Chiaverini of the St. Francis Prayer Center in Flint, Genesee County’s largest city, raised objections with the EPA, claiming that pollution from the new plant would cause disproportionate health effects on minority people living near the construction site. The complaint was the first of its kind to be presented to the EPA since the agency had adopted its Interim Guidance for Investigating Title VI Administrative Complaints Challenging Permits, a set of guidelines for ruling on environmental justice cases. The EPA soon discovered, however, that its guidelines were too vague to permit a clear decision on some facets of the Select Steel case. It eventually decided, however, that there was no evidence that the plant would produce toxic releases greater than standards set by the state itself and by the EPA. It rejected the SchmitterChiaverini claim.
Examples of Environmental Inequities 15
Dissatisfied with this result, complainants asked the EPA to reconsider its decision. Meanwhile, Select Steel was eager to get a resolution to its problems. It threatened to move to Ohio if approval were not granted for the Genesee plant, and, finally, in April 1999, it announced that it would be building the new plant in Delta Township, near Lansing, Michigan. At this point, very few people were satisfied with the outcome of this environmental justice complaint, some feeling that justice had not been done, and others viewing the complaint as an overreaction by environmentalists to a nonproblem. As Michigan governor John Engler said about the case, “The EPA is imposing their bureaucratic will over this community and punishing a company with the latest environmental standards, all because of a baseless complaint. . . . The net result is that the EPA is a job killer” (Alex J. Sagady & Associates 1998).
Sweet Valley and Cobb Town, Alabama Residents of the Sweet Valley and Cobb Town neighborhoods of Anniston, Alabama, generally expected to live out their lives in their poor but comfortable homes. Then they learned about the toxic wastes produced by the Monsanto PCB (polychlorinated biphenyl) plant only a few hundred feet from their houses. Monsanto had purchased the plant in the 1930s and taken over production of PCBs from its previous owners. Polychlorinated biphenyls are a class of organic compounds once widely used in a variety of products, including coatings of electrical wiring and electronic components, flame retardants, sealants, adhesives, paints, coolants and insulating fluids for transformers, additives in pesticides, and carbonless copy paper. Both Monsanto and the African Americans who called Sweet Valley and Cobb Town home shared the lowest land in Anniston for the same reason: it was inexpensive. Wealthier white residents generally lived in higher parts of the town, less exposed to toxic gases and runoff from the plant. By the 1970s, almost everyone had become aware of the harmful effects of PCBs on the environment. The EPA eventually banned their production and use in 1979 (although Monsanto had stopped production in Anniston eight years earlier). Still, it was not until the early 1990s that Sweet Valley and Cobb Town residents realized the potential health threats they faced from exposure to PCBs. They began to see what they thought of as an
16 Background and History
unusually large number of cases of cancer, birth defects, and other health problems that they attributed to years of PCB exposure. Organized as the Sweet Valley/Cobb Town Environmental Justice Task Force, they filed suit and sought EPA assistance in gaining compensation from Monsanto for their health problems. Six years later, the case was resolved. In 2001, Monsanto agreed to pay residents of the area $42.8 million to facilitate their relocation. Even though valid and reliable evidence for a connection between PCBs and human health disorders was still largely absent, the company decided that it no longer wanted to fight what appeared to be a losing battle. Environmental justice for the citizens of Sweet Valley and Cobb Town had been achieved, but at what health cost still remained to be seen.
West Harlem Environmental Action and Diesel Buses For low-income and minority communities, examples of environmental racism are often ubiquitous, if not immediately obvious. Over the last decade, the disproportionate effect of highway construction and public transit systems on such communities has become increasingly evident and of greater concern to environmental justice groups. One of the first instances in which a complaint was filed about environmental inequities in transportation occurred in 2000, when West Harlem Environmental Action (WE ACT) filed a complaint with the EPA. That complaint claimed that New York City’s Metropolitan Transit Authority (MTA) disproportionately affected citizens in its part of the city. WE ACT pointed out that six of the city’s eight major bus depots are located in Harlem. Diesel buses traveling throughout the city almost all have to drive through Harlem at some point in their trips. The pollutants released by these buses, WE ACT said, are an important factor in the abnormally high rate of asthma among children in the region. WE ACT pointed out in its complaint that options were available for reducing diesel bus emissions. For example, the MTA’s plans to close a downtown terminal could be reversed, distributing pollution problems to a wider part of the city. Also, the agency could consider using buses that produce less pollution, such as natural gas or diesel-electric hybrids. In response to the organization’s criticisms, the MTA agreed to take some
Examples of Environmental Inequities 17
steps to deal with WE ACT’s concerns, primarily the use of lesspolluting vehicles. In 2005, the EPA formally rejected the WE ACT complaint, explaining that it had found no evidence of intentional environmental racism in the MTA’s policies and practices. It did admit, however, that some of the concerns expressed by the organization in its formal filing did have justification. Meanwhile, the MTA continued to waffle on its agreement with WEACT about dealing with the pollution caused by its buses in Harlem. In 2004, it announced that it was no longer considering shifting to natural gas–powered buses because diesel technology had improved so much that MTA vehicles no longer posed a health threat to residents of Harlem. Four years later, it changed its mind again, announcing that it would begin buying fuelefficient, low-polluting diesel-electric hybrid buses for use in the city. But the battle over buses was still not over. Reacting to the MTA’s 2004 decision, WE ACT executive director Peggy Shepard said that “we do understand that C.N.G. [compressed natural gas] and hybrid diesel buses are measuring about the same level in terms of emissions. But without an agreement in place on a variety of environmental measures that we want them to implement in Harlem, I cannot say we are not opposed” (Chan 2005).
Southern Nuclear Operating Company Proponents of environmental justice take pride in pointing to the many cases in which their complaints have been successful and some measure of recompense has been provided to victims of environmental inequities. A broader view of the topic reveals, however, that activists frequently lose such cases. Understanding the reasons for these losses is important because it helps environmental justice advocates deal with their problems more effectively in the future. An example of such a case is the petition filed in 2007 by five groups interested in environmental justice: the Center for a Sustainable Coast, Savannah Riverkeeper, the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, the Atlanta Women’s Action for New Directions, and the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League. These groups appeared before the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel to challenge Southern Nuclear Operating (SNO) Company’s petition for an
18 Background and History
early site permit at its Vogtle Electric Generating Plant near Waynesboro, Georgia. The five groups argued that the SNO environmental report had not given adequate attention to the possible disproportionate health effects produced by the plant on low-income and minority populations in its vicinity. They pointed out that residents of the area already have unusually high cancer rates (as a result of eating fish contaminated with toxic chemicals) and that the plant’s operation may only magnify this effect. Finally, they said that SNO had made no special provisions for low-income and minority groups in case of a nuclear accident at the plant. In March 2007, the panel ruled on the group’s complaint. That ruling reflected a theme common among cases in which environmental justice activists have failed to make their arguments before governmental agencies. The panel said that the groups had failed to meet two essential requirements established for deciding environmental justice cases: (1) providing evidence for “the alleged existence of adverse impacts or harm on the physical or human environment” and (2) showing that “these purported adverse impacts could disproportionately affect poor or minority communities in the vicinity of the facility at issue.” For these reasons, the panel rejected the groups’ complaint (Lee 2007).
Environmental Justice: Environmentalism and Civil Rights The movement for environmental justice represents the confluence of two older movements in the United States—the environmentalist and civil rights movements. The origins of the environmentalist movement in this country can be traced to the late 19th century. Before then, concern about the environment was virtually nonexistent in the United States. Instead, the dominant philosophy was that of the biblical injunction to “go forth and conquer the Earth.” Early pioneers sweeping westward from the original 13 colonies encountered unimagined riches of land, minerals, timber, and wildlife. They harvested and used those resources without consideration about preserving or conserving them for some future use. Indeed, official governmental policy encouraged this rape of the land and its resources. The Preemp-
Environmental Justice: Environmentalism and Civil Rights 19
tion Act of 1841, for example, allowed a settler and his family to buy homestead land of up to 480 acres for 50 cents an acre. In many cases, lumber companies hired gangs of men to claim the land and hand it over to the companies. A similar practice was followed by cattle barons, who hired cowboys to claim homesteading lands under the Desert Land Act of 1877 and then use the lands for grazing their cattle (Petulla 1988). It was only with the end of the westward migration, as pioneers reached the Pacific Coast, that some individuals began to realize that the continent’s resources were not, in fact, unlimited. This realization spurred the first environmental movement in the United States. That movement actually consisted of two themes—conservationist and preservationist. The term conservation refers to the practice of harvesting natural resources in a controlled manner so that they will be available for future generations. The current U.S. government policies of “multiple use, sustained yield” reflect this philosophy. Conservationists do not argue that nature is sacred and inviolable but that it provides humans with many valuable resources that they must learn to use wisely. One of the most articulate spokespersons for the early conservationist movement was Gifford Pinchot, chief of the Division of Forestry (later the National Forest Service) in the Department of Agriculture (Wild 1979). In contrast to the views of the conservationists was the philosophy of preservation. Preservationists argue that there is a beauty and value in nature that has nothing to do with the commercial value for humans. Humans have the obligation to protect vast portions of the natural world for no other reason than for its inherent value. According to preservationists, large segments of the world’s forests, deserts, grasslands, and other natural resources should be set aside forever, for their own protection and for their enjoyment by humans. The philosophy of preservation owes much to the early writings of Henry David Thoreau. Thoreau once wrote that “there is a subtle magnetism in Nature, which, if we unconsciously yield to it, will direct us aright” (Thoreau 1962, 265). Perhaps the most famous preservationist was John Muir, one of the founders of the Sierra Club and the man largely responsible for convincing President Theodore Roosevelt of the need for the U.S. National Park system. The traditional environmental movement, then, was one that strongly emphasized the connection between humans and nature. Hiking, backpacking, mountain climbing, bird-watching,
20 Background and History
photography, canoeing, and many other forms of recreation were the preferred activities of those who called themselves “environmentalists” until the mid-20th century. The environmental groups that sprung up within this movement—groups such as the Sierra Club, the Wilderness Society, and the National Parks and Conservation Association—strongly reflected that emphasis. Their goal was to protect the natural environment for a variety of human uses, whether for pure enjoyment or limited commercial exploitation.
The Modern Environmental Movement The 1960s saw the rise of a quite different kind of environmental movement. This movement was inspired by a dawning recognition of the havoc humans were wreaking on the natural environment. Some people credit Rachel Carson’s book Silent Spring (1962) as the defining moment in the modern environmental movement. Carson showed how the indiscriminate use of pesticides killed insects and the birds who fed on them. She called attention to the fact that many of the wonders of modern science and technology that made life healthier, safer, and more pleasant for humans were, at the same time, causing extensive damage to the physical and biological environment. Out of this dawning realization grew a host of new environmental groups, groups whose focus was not primarily on the enjoyment of nature but on issues such as air and water pollution, hazardous waste disposal, and land use. Examples of such groups are the Acid Rain Foundation, the Citizens Clearinghouse for Hazardous Wastes, the Environmental Action Foundation, and the Friends of the Earth. Groups that make up the traditional and modern environmental movements are often considered mainstream environmentalists. Early activists in the environmental justice movement have often argued, however, that they have little in common with mainstream environmentalism. One reason for this position is that mainstream environmentalist groups tend to be largely white and middle or upper class. One study of the membership of mainstream environmental groups in the 1940s, for example, found that 96 percent of the 1,468 respondents classified themselves as caucasian/European. Almost half (48 percent) had a total family income of more than $10,000, and 15 percent had a total family income of more than $25,000. In comparison, only
Environmental Justice: Environmentalism and Civil Rights 21
10 percent of American families made $13,000 or more at the time of the survey (as cited in Smith 1974). In addition, the evidence suggests that most mainstream environmentalist groups have traditionally had little interest in issues faced by poor, minority, urban people. When members of the Sierra Club were asked in the 1970s, for example, whether the club should concern itself with the conservation problems of such special groups as the urban poor and ethnic minorities, about 40 percent said “no” and about 15 percent said “yes” strongly (as cited in Smith 1974). When a similar poll was conducted more than a decade later, a proposal to increase involvement in environmental issues faced by the urban poor and communities of color was defeated by a vote of about three to one (Freudenberg 1984). Under the circumstances, it is hardly surprising that at least some observers have had harsh words for mainstream environmentalism. For example, Richard Hatcher, then mayor of the city of Gary, Indiana, observed in 1970 that “the nation’s concern with the environment has done what George Wallace had been unable to do: distract the nation from the human problems of black and brown Americans” (“The Rise of Anti-Ecology?” 1970, 42). In fact, the accomplishments of mainstream environmentalism have sometimes exacerbated the environmental problems of low-income people and people of color. As an example, new regulations on the use of pesticides in agriculture—rules enacted under the pressure of mainstream environmental groups—have in some cases increased the risk to farmworkers. Agricultural business people have replaced pesticides of lower toxicity and longer persistence (thereby providing greater protection to consumers) with pesticides of greater toxicity and shorter persistence (thus increasing the risk to farmworkers) (Perfecto 1992). In any case, many of those active in the environmental justice movement retain doubts about the ability of mainstream environmentalist groups to understand or respond to the issues about which people of color are most concerned. In assessing the current relationship between mainstream environmentalism and the environmental justice movement, Robert Bullard has written that “the mainstream environmental movement has proven that it can help enhance the quality of life in this country. . . . Yet, few of these groups have actively involved themselves in environmental conflicts involving communities of color. Because of this, it’s unlikely that we will see a mass influx of people of color into
22 Background and History
the national environmental groups any time soon. A continuing growth in their own grassroots organizations is more likely” (1993, 38).
The Civil Rights Movement For some historians, the modern civil rights movement in the United States can be traced to December 1, 1955, when African American seamstress Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat in the first row of the “colored” section of a Montgomery, Alabama, bus to a white man. The event precipitated a yearlong boycott of Montgomery buses by African Americans in the city and culminated in a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that segregation on public bus systems was illegal. The next decade was marked by the battle by African Americans and their allies to eliminate the whole fabric of segregation that had been constructed in the South over the preceding century. Important events included the Alabama Freedom Rides of 1961; civil rights demonstrations in Birmingham, Alabama, and the March on Washington, D.C., in 1963; and the marches on Selma, Alabama, in 1965. Although protests were strongly influenced by the philosophy of nonviolence, they were often met with extreme violence, resulting in injuries to and the deaths of hundreds of protestors. The civil rights movement’s major goals were slowly accomplished, however, with the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1957, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Fair Housing Act of 1968, and similar legislation. Courts also confirmed that segregation of any kind in American society was unconstitutional and set forth rigorous programs for the elimination of bias in education, housing, employment, and other fields. Although the centuries-old evils of segregation were hardly eliminated, the nation’s highest legislative and judicial bodies had made clear that official forms of apartheid in the United States were illegal (Grossman 1993; Morris 1984). The environmental justice movement probably owes more to one parent—the civil rights movement—than to the other— the environmental movement. Although the issues with which environmental justice deals are environmental issues—air and water pollution, hazardous waste sites, and the like—the political philosophy that underlies action is a reflection of the civil rights philosophy. In addition, most of the groups currently act-
Environmental Justice Comes of Age 23
ing on environmental justice issues began their existence as civil rights groups and not environmental organizations. As Robert Bullard has said, “The push for environmental equity is an extension of the civil rights movement, a movement in which direct confrontation and the politics of protest have been real weapons” (1994, 13).
Environmental Justice Comes of Age Walter E. Fauntroy, then representative from the District of Columbia to the U.S. House of Representatives, participated in and was arrested for his part in the 1982 Warren County protest described previously. Following his release from jail, Fauntroy asked the U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO) to conduct a study on the relationship between pollution and minority communities. The report found that three of the four largest landfills located in the Southeast were located in predominantly poor and African American communities (U.S. General Accounting Office 1983). The GAO study was rather modest in its scope, but it was important for another reason. It brought to the attention of the general public, probably for the first time, a possible association between race and income on the one hand and exposure to environmental hazards on the other. In addition, it highlighted the serious lack of fundamental research on this issue.
The Commission on Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ In response to the gap in fundamental research, the Commission on Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ decided to initiate an even more extensive study of the environmental problems faced by minority and poor communities. The commission analyzed the location of hazardous waste sites in all zip (postal) codes and counties in the United States. The results of the study were released in 1987 and were immediately hailed by experts in both environmental and civil rights communities. In a 1987 editorial, for example, the Atlanta Constitution observed that the study put an end to any doubts that white America had been pursuing a policy of dumping its garbage in black neighborhoods. The commission report, it said, clearly pointed out where public
24 Background and History
health officials and environmental inspectors needed to look for potential problems before they became health hazards. What was it that the Commission on Racial Justice had actually found? Among the most important points in the commission report were the following: • People of color are twice as likely to live in a community with a commercial hazardous waste site than are whites. They are three times as likely to live in a community with more than one hazardous waste site. • About 60 percent of African Americans live in a community with an abandoned hazardous waste site. • The average annual income of people living in communities with a hazardous waste site is significantly less than those living in communities without such a site. • In spite of the preceding point, race, more than income, is a more reliable factor in predicting the presence of a hazardous waste site. • Three of the five largest hazardous waste sites, accounting for about 40 percent of the nation’s total landfill capacity, are located in communities that are predominantly African American or Latino. • Fifteen million African Americans and 8 million Hispanic Americans live in communities with one or more hazardous waste sites. • Of the six cities with the largest number of hazardous waste sites, African Americans make up a far greater fraction of residents than do whites. The numbers for those cities are as follows: Memphis (43.3 percent African Americans; 173 sites), St. Louis (27.5 percent; 160 sites), Houston (23.6 percent; 152 sites), Cleveland (23.7 percent; 106 sites), Chicago (37.2 percent; 103 sites), and Atlanta (46.1 percent; 94 sites). For comparison, African Americans make up 11.7 percent of the general U.S. population. (Commission on Racial Justice 1987) As dramatic as the Commission on Racial Justice report was, it was certainly not the first serious study of the relationship among environmental hazards, race, and income. For example, an early study by David Harrison found that the costs of air pollution were more likely to be borne by low-income groups than by middle- or high-income groups (1975).
Environmental Justice Comes of Age 25
Another important study was the one completed by Robert D. Bullard and reported in 1983. Bullard found that the pattern of siting for municipal landfills, incinerators, waste transfer stations, and other forms of waste disposal facilities in Houston was similar to what was later reported by the Commission on Racial Justice. That is, all five of the city-owned landfills were located in predominantly African American neighborhoods; six of eight garbage incinerators were located in such neighborhoods, with the remaining two in a predominantly Hispanic American neighborhood and a predominantly white area (Bullard 1983). Over three decades, a number of studies similar to those of Bullard’s have been conducted in specific cities, counties, and states. (The bibliography in Chapter 8 lists the reports from many of these studies.)
The Michigan Conference As the decade of the 1990s dawned, environmental justice was a topic of considerable interest across a wide spectrum of citizens from all walks of life. In 1990, two academicians relatively recently introduced to the issues of environmental justice—Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai at the University of Michigan School of Natural Resources (now the School of Natural Resources and Environment)—convened a conference of scholars and activists in Ann Arbor to present their latest research, discuss their ideas, and consider possible solutions to the problems of environmental racism and environmental inequities. A number of papers presented at the Michigan Conference were later reprinted in Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards, edited by Bryant and Mohai. The Michigan Conference was important because of other events it initiated. First, participants at the conference drafted a letter to Louis W. Sullivan, secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; William K. Reilly, administrator of the EPA; and Michael R. Deland, chair of the Council on Environmental Quality. The letter asked for an opportunity to meet with government officials to discuss a number of topics relating to environmental justice. Among these issues was the request for more research on the nature of environmental inequities in the United States, the development of projects targeted at providing aid to low-income and minority populations, the appointment of special assistants for environmental equity in government agencies,
26 Background and History
and the development of a policy statement on environmental equity. Representatives of the Michigan Conference met with Reilly and other government officials on September 13, 1990, in what appeared to be a highly productive meeting.
Governmental Recognition in the 1990s Although the administration of President George H. W. Bush took no concrete action to deal with the issues of environmental justice, an important seed had been planted. That seed came to fruition with the election of Bill Clinton as president in 1992. Clinton appointed Benjamin Chavis and Robert Bullard, both activists in the field of environmental justice, to serve on his transition team in the area of natural resources (which included the EPA and the Departments of the Interior, Energy, and Agriculture). Then, on February 11, 1994, President Clinton issued Executive Order 12898 establishing the Office of Environmental Justice within the EPA and the National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (NEJAC). Clinton’s action is arguably the most important step to occur in the environmental justice movement in its short history. The creation of the Office of Environmental Justice and the NEJAC provided the mechanism and the financial support needed for those concerned about environmental justice issues to meet at regular intervals, design programs of research, present their concerns directly to the federal administration, hold public meetings at which groups and individuals can testify, and comment on federal programs that have a relevance to environmental inequities. The NEJAC consists of about two dozen members selected from community-based groups, business and industry, academia, tribal governments, nongovernmental organizations, and environmental groups. The NEJAC is organized into four subcommittees—Waste and Facility Siting, Enforcement, Health and Research, and Public Participation and Accountability.
First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit Another important event in the organization of a national environmental justice movement took place in October 1991. Under the auspices of the Commission on Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ, the First National People of Color Environ-
Environmental Justice as a Social Movement 27
mental Leadership Summit was convened in Washington, D.C. More than 500 participants from a wide variety of ethnic, racial, cultural, and economic groups came together to talk about their mutual concerns about the environment and environmental inequities. More than 50 presentations, workshops, panels, caucuses, and other sessions were held during the three-day conference. At the conference’s conclusion, the participants adopted a 17-part statement, “Principles of Environmental Justice,” outlining their combined view on the state of environmental inequities in the United States. The principles have become a guideline for much of the thought and work that now takes place in environmental justice groups throughout the nation. (See Chapter 6 for a statement of the principles.)
Environmental Justice as a Social Movement The environmental justice movement in the United States stands out among other social movements. Although it has begun to take on some of the trappings familiar to the movements from which it sprang, namely, a centralized organization located in large governmental and nongovernmental bodies, it still remains to a large degree a highly decentralized movement. While academicians and activists were coming together at the Michigan Conference and in the development of the EPA Office of Environmental Justice, dozens of small, local groups were being organized to deal with the very real issues faced by individual neighborhoods and communities. (For a superb discussion of all facets of the environmental justice movement, see Lazarus [1993].) The 1990s saw the formation, for example, of groups such as the Coalition for Environmental Consciousness in Ridgeville, Alabama; California Indians for Cultural and Environmental Protection in Santa Ysabel, California; the Citizens League Opposed to Unwanted Toxins in Tifton, Georgia; Ke Kua’aina Hanauna Hou in Kaunakakai, Hawaii; the Flint-Genesee United for Action, Justice, and Environmental Safety in Flint, Michigan; Concerned Citizens of Sunland Park in Sunland Park, New Mexico; Fort Greene Community Action Network in Brooklyn, New York; Eufaula Street Landfill Committee in Fayetteville, North
28 Background and History
Carolina; Environmental Services Office of the Cherokee Nation in Tahlequah, Oklahoma; People Organized in Defense of Earth and Its Resources in Austin, Texas; and the Environmental Center for New Canadians in Toronto. Representatives of such groups often stay in contact with each other and draw on each other’s resources through tribal, regional, cultural, or other affiliations, such as the Southwest Network for Environmental and Economic Justice, the Asian Pacific Environment Network, the Gulf Coast Tenants Organization, or the National Congress of American Indians. Yet, in many cases, the bulk of their actual work occurs within a neighborhood, a small town, a tribe or reservation, or a county. Local groups also stay in contact with each other through a number of journals, magazines, newsletters, and other publications that have grown up over the past three decades. These include Race, Poverty, and the Environment (published by Urban Habitat), Everyone’s Backyard (Center for Health, Environment, and Justice), RACHEL’s Hazardous Waste News (Environmental Research Foundation), Toxic Times (Chemical Injury Information Network), Voces Unidas (Southwest Organizing Project), and PAN magazine (Pesticide Action Network North America). An interesting feature of the modern environmental justice movement is the critical role played by women. Mothers, housewives, secretaries, and rural women have long been at the forefront of protests, community action, leafleting, public testimony, and other actions on topics concerning environmental inequities and environmental racism. A number of writers have observed that many issues in the field of environmental justice strike close to the individual home and thus arouse more interest among housewives and mothers than would issues from mainstream environmentalism, such as the protection of endangered species or the development of national parks. Celene Krauss, assistant professor of sociology and coordinator of Women’s Studies at Kean College of New Jersey, for example, has drawn on interviews with women active in the environmental justice movement to place their participation in a broader context of feminist political philosophy. She concludes that women who can be described as “female blue-collar activists” often have a political philosophy similar to those in the field of environmental justice and a suspicion of the relevance of mainstream environmental organizations to the concerns of women like themselves (Krauss 1994).
Growth and Challenges 29
Growth and Challenges By the first decade of the 21st century, the environmental justice movement had become a strong, diversified, active, and successful crusade in the United States. Each new edition of the basic reference text, the People of Color Environmental Groups Directory, showed a significant increase in the number of environmental groups in the United States, Puerto Rico, Canada, and Mexico: from 205 such groups in 1992 to about 300 groups in 1994 to more than 400 groups in 2000. And stories of successful battles by local environmental groups against a variety of corporate groups and governmental agencies continued to flood the academic and movement literature (see the chronology in Chapter 4 and resources in Chapter 8 for more detail). By the mid-1990s, environmental justice groups had found that they had two powerful tools for exposing and acting against cases of environmental injustice: President Clinton’s Executive Order 12898 and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VI specifies that “no person in the United States shall, on the ground of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance” (Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act). Since a great many governmental and nongovernmental organizations and agencies receive at least some part of their budget from the federal government, these organizations and agencies are subject to the provisions of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act. Groups concerned about environmental justice realized that they could file complaints with the EPA against organizations and agencies that they believed practiced environmental racism. The first case on record involving this type of action took place in 1992, when members of the St. Francis Prayer Center in Flint, Michigan, filed a complaint with the EPA to prevent construction of a new “mini-mill” plant near Flint by the aforementioned Select Steel Corporation of America. (Because the EPA apparently mislaid the complaint, it was not acted upon until 1998; U.S. EPA 1998.) A year later, a group of environmental justice organizations also filed complaints with the EPA against the Louisiana and Mississippi Departments of Environmental Quality, claiming that, in violation of the provisions of Title VI, they discriminated against low-income and minority communities in making environmental policies and decisions. Within a matter of
30 Background and History
years, the instances of using Title VI as a tool against industries and government agencies had become a flood, with well over 100 cases being filed by the year 2000. Environmental justice groups have not, however, met with a great deal of success thus far in the use of Title VI as a means of gaining redress against situations that they regard as environmental racism. An article published in the November 2003 issue of the New York Law Journal found that, of the 136 claims submitted by environmental justice groups based on Title VI standards to date, all decisions had been to deny the claim. Of the 136 cases, 75 were rejected without investigation, 26 were investigated and found to have no evidence of discrimination, and 30 were still pending at the time of the article. The most common reason for rejecting a claim, the article reported, was that the complaint had not been filed in a timely manner. The EPA has also been perhaps unduly deliberate in considering complaints presented to it. In one case, it issued a decision almost 10 years after the original complaint had been filed (Gerrard 2003, 3). A summary of similar cases that had been presented to the EPA since the law journal article was published can be found on the American Bar Association’s Update Web site. More than 20 of the cases discussed resulted in rejection of claims by the EPA; less than 5 were favorably reviewed or accepted by the agency or by any other state or federal court or agency (American Bar Association 2008). President Bill Clinton’s Executive Order 12898 on environmental justice has also had somewhat less of an impact on environmental inequities than many people had once hoped and expected. A major problem appears to have been the low priority placed on environmental justice issues by the administration of President George W. Bush. Over the eight-year period of Bush’s administration, a number of governmental and nongovernmental commissions studied the implementation of Executive Order 12898. For example, the inspector general of the EPA issued a report in March 2004 noting that little progress had been made in implementing the executive order and that, in fact, the Bush administration had reinterpreted the meaning of environmental justice to exclude low-income and minority populations (Office of Inspector General 2004). Later the same year, the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights issued a comprehensive review of the status of civil rights issues during Bush’s first term. The commission concluded that
Growth and Challenges 31
despite a decade of active pursuit, Executive Order 12898 is still not part of EPA’s core mission. President Bush did not consider implementation of the order a primary goal. . . . [The] EPA has not developed a clear vision or a comprehensive strategic plan, nor established values, goals, expectations, and performance measurements regarding the order. Further, EPA has not provided regional or program offices with standards for what constitutes a minority or low-income community, or defined the term “disproportionately” as it relates to environmental justice. If EPA does not identify parameters for environmental justice, it will not be able to comply with Executive Order 12898. (U.S. Commission on Civil Rights 2004, 75–76) As of late 2008, a comparable scorecard on the Bush administration’s record during its second four-year term was not available. It can be noted, however, that the Republican Party did not include any mention of environmental justice in its 2004 platform (the Democratic Party platform did have a section under this title), and little progress appears to have been made in the implementation of Title VI or Executive Order 12898 policies. The record of the U.S. Congress in dealing with environmental justice issues has not been much better than that of the administration. Rep. John Lewis (D-GA) and Sen. Al Gore Jr. (D-TN) introduced an environmental justice act into Congress in 1992, but the bill was not acted upon. A year later, Lewis and Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT) reintroduced the same act, again without success. Since that time, some version of the Lewis-Gore-Baucus bill has been introduced into Congress in 1998, 1999, 2002, 2003, 2005, 2007, and 2008. Since 1998, a primary purpose of the environmental justice legislation has been to codify Executive Order 12898 to provide it with greater legal force. In no case has an environmental justice bill come even close to passage; such bills often do not get out of the committees to which they are assigned. In spite of the somewhat dismal record of the federal government in the area of environmental justice over the past decade, a number of individual success stories can be told. These stories often involve successful court cases at the local and state level and, even more often, successful negotiations between polluting industries and local grassroots environmental justice
32 Background and History
organizations. A typical example is the ongoing battle by residents of the Baldwin Hills neighborhood of Los Angeles to prevent despoliation of a large open space in their district. The open space in question consists of about two square miles of undeveloped land, the largest such area in urban Los Angeles. In 2001, the state of California announced plans to grant a license to La Jolla Energy Development, Inc., to build a new power plant in the park as a way of responding to the state’s energy crisis. With only 30 days to prepare for a hearing on the proposal, residents of Baldwin Hills (78.5 percent African American in the 2000 census) quickly brought together a coalition of concerned citizens and organizations to object to the plan. The coalition was able to mass more than 1,000 people at the June 21 hearing on the proposal. Faced with such daunting opposition, La Jolla Energy eventually withdrew its plans to build in Baldwin Hills park. That victory was somewhat short-lived, however, as the city of Los Angeles announced only two years later that it planned to build a garbage dump on the fringes of Baldwin Hills park. Again, residents came together to oppose those plans and, again, they won. The city decided to place the “solid waste transfer station” in another location. Finally (if it truly turns out to be “finally”), residents of Baldwin Hills were able to convince the city in 2007 to place a moratorium on the construction of 24 new oil wells in the park (although wells had been in place in some parts of the park since the 1920s). Whether the 2007 decision marks the end of attempts to encroach on the park is still to be seen. The modern environmental justice movement in the United States poses something of an enigma for those concerned about environmental and civil rights issues. On the one hand, the movement has achieved some amazing successes in its less-thanthree-decade history. Poor people and minority communities have won redress and compensation from giant multinational corporations for the health risks they pose. Many states, regions, and local governments have acknowledged the significance of environmental justice issues and have passed laws and adopted regulations to ameliorate the effects of environmental inequities. But much remains to be done. The federal government, after an impressive early initiative on behalf of environmental rights in the 1990s, has largely ignored the issue since. The president, Congress, and the courts at nearly all levels appear not to recognize the existence of environmental inequities or their need to act against such problems. What stumbling blocks do environmental
References 33
justice activists still face, what basic questions about environmental inequities remain, and what can be done to more fully reach the goals of environmental equity that were first highlighted in the 1982 protest in Warren County? Chapter 2 examines these issues.
References Alex J. Sagady & Associates. 1998. “E-M:/Engler News Release on Select Steel Case.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/14/08.] http://www.great-lakes.net/lists/enviro-mich/. American Bar Association. Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources. 2008. “The Law of Environmental Justice: Update Service.” [Online article or information; retrieved 4/22/08.] http://www.abanet .org/environ/committees/envtab/ejupdates.html. Bullard, Robert D. 1983. “Solid Waste Sites and the Black Houston Community.” Sociological Inquiry 53 (2–3): 273–288. Bullard, Robert D. 1993. “Anatomy of Environmental Racism and the Environmental Justice Movement.” In Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots, edited by R. D. Bullard, chap. 1. Boston: South End Press. Bullard, Robert D. 1994. Unequal Protection: Environmental Justice and Communities of Color. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. Bullard, Robert D. 2000. Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality, 3rd ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Chan, Sewell. 2005 (March 28). “City to Buy Diesel-Electric Buses, Not Natural Gas Ones.” New York Times. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/14/08.] http://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/28/nyregion/ 28bus.html?n=Top/Reference/Times%20Topics/Organizations/N/ New%20York%20City%20Transit. Commission on Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ. 1987. Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States: A National Report on the Racial and Socio-Economic Characteristics of Communities Surrounding Hazardous Waste Sites. New York: United Church of Christ. Freudenberg, N. 1984. “Not in Our Backyards: Community Action for Health and the Environment.” Monthly Review Press 22:34–39. Gerrard, Michael B. 2003. “EPA Dismissal of Civil Rights Complaints.” New York Law Journal, November 28, 3+. Griffith, Matt, Mansoureh Tajik, and Steve Wing. 2007. “Patterns of Agricultural Pesticide Use in Relation to Socioeconomic Characteristics
34 Background and History
of the Population in the Rural U.S. South.” International Journal of Health Services 37:259–277. Grossman, Mark. 1993. The ABC-CLIO Companion to the Civil Rights Movement. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO. Harrison, David, Jr. 1975. Who Pays for Clean Air: The Cost and Benefit Distribution of Automobile Emission Standards. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger. Krauss, Celene. 1994. “Women of Color on the Front Line.” In Unequal Protection: Environmental Justice and Communities of Color, edited by Robert D. Bullard, chap. 14. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books. Lazarus, Richard J. 1993. “Pursuing ‘Environmental Justice’: The Distributional Effects of Environmental Protection.” Northwestern University Law Review 87 (March): 101–170. Lee, Charles. 2007. “Environmental Justice in the News for the Week Ending April 20, 2007.” [Online article or information; retrieved 4/20/07.] http://www.epa.gov/compliance/resources/newsletters/. Louisiana Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. 1993. The Battle for Environmental Justice in Louisiana . . . Government, Industry, and the People. Kansas City, MO: U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Central Regional Office. Maraniss, David, and Michael Weisskopf. 1989. “Jobs and Illness in Petrochemical Corridor.” Washington Post, December 22, A1. Miller, G. Tyler. 2003. Living in the Environment: An Introduction to Environmental Science, 13th ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. Morris, Aldon D. 1984. The Origins of the Civil Rights Movement: Black Communities Organizing for Change. New York: The Free Press. Moses, Marion. 1989. “Pesticide Related Health Problems in Farm Workers.” American Association of Occupational Health Nurses Journal 37:115–130. Moses, Marion. 1993. “Farmworkers and Pesticides.” In Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices from the Grassroots, edited by Robert D. Bullard, chap. 10. Boston: South End Press. Office of Inspector General. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2004. EPA Needs to Consistently Implement the Intent of the Executive Order on Environmental Justice. Washington, DC: Environmental Protection Agency. Perfecto, Ivette. 1992. “Pesticide Exposure of Farm Workers and the International Connection.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 14. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
References 35
Petulla, Joseph M. 1988. American Environmental History, 2nd ed. San Francisco: Boyd & Fraser. “The Rise of Anti-Ecology?” 1970. Time, August 3, p. 42. Robinson, William Paul. 1992. “Uranium Production and Its Effects on Navajo Communities along the Rio Puerco in Western New Mexico.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 12. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Smith, James Noel, ed. 1974. Environmental Quality and Social Justice in Urban America. Washington, DC: The Conservation Foundation. Thoreau, Henry David. 1962. “Walking.” In Excursions. New York: Corinth Books. Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. [Online information; retrieved 5/5/08.] http://www.usdoj.gov/crt/cor/coord/titlevistat.htm. Updated November 13, 2000. U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. Office of Civil Rights Evaluation. 2004. Redefining Rights in America: The Civil Rights Record of the George W. Bush Administration, 2001–2004. Washington, DC: U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. U.S. Congress. 1993. House. Committee on the Judiciary. Environmental Justice Hearings before the Subcommittee on Civil and Constitutional Rights. 103rd Congress, 1st sess., March 3 and 4. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 1998. “In Re: Select Steel Corporation of America.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/15/08] http://www.gridauh.fr/sites/fr/fichier/447aec8d1257e.pdf. U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO). 1983. Siting of Hazardous Waste Landfills and Their Correlation with Racial and Economic Status of Surrounding Communities. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Wasserstrom, R. F., and R. Wiles. 1985. Field Duty: U.S. Farmworkers and Pesticides Safety. Study 3. Washington, DC: World Resources Institute, Center for Policy Research. West, Patrick C., J. Mark Fly, Frances Larkin, and Robert W. Marans. 1992. “Minority Anglers and Toxic Fish Consumption: Evidence from a Statewide Survey of Michigan.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 8. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Wild, Peter. 1979. Pioneer Conservationists of Western America. Missoula, MT: Mountain Press.
2 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
T
he environmental justice movement has grown rapidly, has spread extensively throughout the world, and has achieved some remarkable successes in the past three decades. Today, most people who are interested in social justice, environmental issues, and human rights are aware of the context into which environmental justice has placed these topics for people of color and low-income communities. Still, the movement has just begun to achieve the goals it has set out for itself and for society as a whole. Hazardous waste sites are still being sited in minority and low-income communities, petrochemical and other plants still deliver unacceptably high levels of pollutants to such communities, farmworkers and workers in hazardous industries are still exposed to health risks that could and should be reduced, and developed nations of the world still tend to think of developing nations as dumping grounds for products and wastes that they, themselves, do not allow in their own countries. This chapter reviews some of the major problems and controversies still faced by the environmental justice movement. It considers whether environmental injustice really does exist and, if so, what evidence there is for it. It also asks to what extent residents of low-income and minority communities are exposed to inequitable amounts of environmental risks, whether these risks develop intentionally as the planned acts of government and/or industry, and what low-income and minority communities can do to combat these risks.
37
38 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
Do Environmental Inequities Actually Exist? The fundamental premise of the environmental justice movement is that low-income and minority communities are exposed to a disproportionate risk from hazardous waste sites, workplace hazards, polluting industries, and other facilities potentially harmful to human health. To some extent, this premise was initially based on anecdotal evidence provided by people living in such communities. By the late 1970s, however, research studies also began to provide support for the premise. Perhaps the best known of these early studies was one conducted by Robert D. Bullard, then an assistant professor of sociology at Texas Southern University in Houston. Bullard’s research was conducted to support a lawsuit filed by his wife, Bean v. Southwestern Waste Management, Inc., in which plaintiffs claimed that black citizens in Houston were being unfairly discriminated against because of the siting of hazardous waste dumps in the city. Bullard’s research showed that all five city-owned garbage dumps, six of the eight city-owned garbage incinerators, and three of the four privately owned landfills were sited in black neighborhoods. The evidence strongly supported claims of environmental inequities in the city. Bullard’s research, completed in 1979, was eventually published as “Solid Waste Sites and the Black Houston Community” in the spring 1983 issue of Sociological Inquiry. Over the next decade, researchers collected an increasingly extensive body of evidence to support the premise that poor and minority communities are disproportionately affected by hazardous working conditions and industrial facilities. These studies investigated problems such as the siting of radioactive waste sites on Native American lands; the consumption of contaminated fish by minority communities around Puget Sound, Washington; the exposure of farmworkers to hazardous pesticides; and the risks to minority communities of hazardous waste sites in Massachusetts [for a summary of research studies conducted on environmental inequities, see the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (2006) “Environmental Justice Bibliography Database”]. Many of the case studies presented in Chapter 1 were documented during this period. Perhaps the most significant of all studies on environmental inequities conducted in the 1980s was sponsored by the Commission on Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ, discussed
Do Environmental Inequities Actually Exist? 39
in Chapter 1. The evidence from that study was so well documented and convincing that, by the time of its publication in 1987, many researchers had concluded that the case of environmental inequities in the United States had essentially been proved. The United Church of Christ report was, however, by no means the only study on the existence of environmental inequities. As an additional example, Paul Mohai and Bunyan Bryant at the University of Michigan School of Natural Resources, organizers of the Michigan Conference on Environmental Justice, undertook a review in 1992 of 16 major studies on the relationship between race and income and the distribution of environmental hazards. They found significant correlations between these factors in all of the studies on which they reported (Mohai and Bryant 1992). The conclusions drawn by Bullard, the United Church of Christ study group, Mohai, Bryant, and other researchers were not, however, entirely convincing to all investigators. By the early 1990s, a number of questions were being raised about the methodological accuracies of many early environmental justice studies. Some researchers had begun to ask if the apparent correlations between income and race on the one hand and environmental risk on the other were accurate or whether, in fact, they represented an artifact produced by faulty methodology. These investigators reported that the evidence from their own research seemed to contradict the basic premise of environmental justice; their studies seemed to suggest, that is, that low-income and minority communities are at no greater risk from hazardous exposure than are middle-income and nonminority communities. Perhaps the most famous studies that came to these conclusions were those conducted by Douglas L. Anderton and his colleagues at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst in the early 1990s. The initial studies were funded by Chemical Waste Management, Inc., currently the largest waste management corporation in the world. Anderton’s research team focused on the smallest population units for which reliable national data are available. These units are the census tracts used by the U.S. Bureau of the Census in its decennial census. When the Anderton team compared the demographic characteristics of 1990 census tracts containing toxic waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities (TSDFs) with similar tracts lacking such facilities, they found essentially
40 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
no differences in the racial status of residents of the two tracts. They reported their results in a series of papers published in the mid- and late 1990s (Anderton et al. 1994a, 1994b; Anderton, Oakes, and Eagan 1996, 1997). In a summary of this research, Anderton’s team drew three primary conclusions. First, the appearance of environmental inequity depends on the way in which areas of potential impact are defined. Second, if one uses census tract areas, as defined by the U.S. Census Bureau, hazardous waste sites are no more likely to be located in nonwhite neighborhoods as in other tracts. Third, the most consistently significant effect on the location of hazardous waste sites is the proportion of workers employed in industrial activities. That observation, the researchers said, should hardly be surprising since industrial operations tend to locate near other industrial facilities (Anderton et al. 1994a). Anderton and his colleagues continued their research on environmental inequities based on race and income for a number of years. In 2000, he and colleague Pamela Davidson reported on a review of hazardous waste facilities governed by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). Their results did not show disproportionate siting of such facilities based on income (facilities most commonly were placed in working-class neighborhoods), although the hazardous waste sites did tend to be located near minority communities. Overall, Davidson and Anderton concluded that “the siting of RCRA facilities does not merit high priority among the potential hazards and burdens to which minorities and the disadvantaged are disproportionately exposed” (Davidson and Anderton 2000, 466). As might be expected, Anderton’s research itself became the subject of some dispute, with other observers raising questions about the methodology used in his studies. Indeed, the scientific data on which claims of environmental inequities are based have been and continue to be the subject of considerable controversy among researchers. For example, some researchers point out the problems of proving that clear evidence exists for the connection between exposure to hazardous materials and cancer and other diseases, birth defects, and death. It can be very difficult to say that just because people live near a hazardous waste site, for example, their health problems are caused by exposure to those wastes.
Do Environmental Inequities Actually Exist? 41
Questions have also been raised about the way generalizations have been made by environmental justice advocates from specific situations in one locality to general patterns of environmental inequities throughout the nation or around the world. Situations are so different, some critics say, that each problem area must be studied and treated on its own. The debate over the correlation among race, income, and environmental hazards is far from over. Scholarly articles in the first decade of the 21st century are still arguing the best approaches to use in studying these factors, and experts are still debating how extensive environmental inequities in the United States are. But other research questions remain also. To the extent that environmental inequities exist, researchers would like to know the answers to a number of related questions, such as how these conditions have arisen, whether they represent conscious intent on the part of industry and/or government, and how such inequities can be reduced in the future. Precisely how environmental inequities develop is a complex question, one that has not yet been answered to everyone’s complete satisfaction. Yet, some forces contributing to this state of affairs are reasonably clear. These forces can be characterized as follows: • Progress and environmental degradation: Improvements in our way of life often lead to a diminished quality of the environment for all citizens, but often and especially for poor communities and communities of color. • Siting decisions: The choices that governments and industries make in locating hazardous facilities can damage the environment. • Access to tools of protest: Lack of education and experience can reduce the ability of some communities to understand and respond to environmental issues they face. • Job blackmail: Individuals faced with a diminished environment are often forced to choose between keeping their jobs and accepting those conditions or battling for a better life and, perhaps, losing their jobs. • Effects of environmental regulations: Ironically, governmental regulations designed to improve the overall environmental quality for an area sometimes have undesirable impacts on poor and minority communities.
42 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
Progress and Environmental Degradation Environmental degradation comes about because societies strive for a better way of life—nicer, more comfortable homes; better clothes; more effective medicines; and more efficient means of transportation, for example. The largest single difference between the “have” and “have-not” countries of the world reflects the abilities of some nations to provide their citizens with better material goods and a larger supply of energy—a higher standard of living—than can other nations. But the systems of production, distribution, and consumption of material goods and energies always result in the release of waste products into the environment. Polluted air and water, hazardous waste dumps, and dangerous occupations are all examples of the price a society pays for improving its standard of living. And the more the standard of living is improved, the greater the amount of waste released into the environment. In a perfect world, the benefits and burdens of a high standard of living would be distributed equally throughout a society. Everyone would have equal access to new products and would have to live with increased levels of environmental degradation. But no perfect society exists. Instead, in every form of government devised—socialism, communism, fascism, or democracy— there are haves and have-nots. Some people receive a larger share of the benefits, and others receive a larger share of the burdens. One of the goals of almost any social movement is to obtain a more fair distribution of these benefits and burdens. How is the distribution of benefits and burdens determined in the real world? One factor is the way in which various groups within the society are viewed. In the United States (as in many other nations), white people tend to have the advantage over people of color, men over women, the physically well over the physically handicapped, heterosexuals over gay men and lesbians, and so on. This pattern is reflected in the wage gap among various groups in the United States. In 2006, for example, the last year for which data are available, white women earned about three-quarters (73.5 percent) as much as men in the United States; black men earned 72.1 percent as much; black women, 63.6 percent as much; Hispanic men, 57.5 percent as much; and Hispanic women, 51.7 percent as much (Infoplease 2008).
NIMBY, PIBBY, and LULUs 43
The unequal distribution of power and prestige is also reflected in the relative numbers of men and women, whites and nonwhites, and other demographic groups in positions of power. In the 110th Congress of the United States (2007–2009), for example, there are 16 women (16 percent; all white) in the Senate compared to 84 men (84 percent), whereas the percentage of women in the general population is about 52 percent. At the same time, there are 74 women (17 percent) in the House, of whom 15 (3 percent) are African American, 3 (0.6 percent) are Asian Pacific Americans, and 7 (1.6 percent) are Hispanic Americans (Amer 2008). Under these circumstances, it is not difficult to see why white males tend to receive the highest proportion of material goods available in the U.S. society. And the burdens—such as increased amounts of hazardous wastes, polluted air and water, and greater occupational hazards—that develop as a result of an improved lifestyle for the more privileged are likely to fall on poor people of color. The environmental justice movement has fought to make that fact abundantly and unquestionably clear.
NIMBY, PIBBY, and LULUs Beyond political and social philosophy, however, there are some concrete reasons that the burdens of environmental degradation have fallen disproportionately on communities of color and on people of low economic status. In the first place, decisions as to where polluting industries, hazardous waste dumps, radioactive storage sites, and other environmentally undesirable sites are to be located are commonly made by governmental bodies, such as city councils, planning departments, or zoning committees. It is not uncommon for such bodies to consist of a disproportionate number of the local “power structure,” which usually means white males. The tendency in many cases may be, then, for environmentally undesirable sites to be located in “their” neighborhoods rather than in “our” neighborhoods. This tendency is reinforced by the reluctance of ordinary citizens to have such sites located in their neighborhoods. One of the most familiar phrases in land-use issues in the last few decades has become “not in my backyard,” or NIMBY. The phrase reflects the fact that most people recognize that undesirable factories,
44 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
prisons, halfway houses, hazardous waste sites, and other “locally unwanted land uses” (LULUs) are now a reality in our society. Given our way of life, they have to exist. But few people want them near their homes. They would prefer to have them constructed “somewhere else.” In many cases, this outlook has led to a new attitude, the “put it in the blacks’ backyard,” or PIBBY, syndrome.
Concerns about Environmental Issues among People of Color Consonant with the NIMBY principle has been the belief, spoken or unspoken, that African Americans and other minorities are not concerned about environmental issues. Some people have argued that people of color have too many other concerns—jobs, housing, and health problems, for example—to care about the surroundings in which they live. A number of research studies have been conducted to determine the factual accuracy of this attitude. In his study of environmental problems in five largely African American communities, Robert Bullard found that residents were very much interested in and concerned about such issues. Overall, more than half of the respondents in Bullard’s survey had taken part in some form of environmental activism, such as writing a letter to or telephoning an official about an issue, signing or circulating a petition, attending or organizing a meeting in one’s home, marching in a demonstration, attending a public meeting, or helping to raise funds (Bullard 2000; also see Buttel 1987; Lowe and Pinhey 1982; Taylor 1989). An associated finding of the Bullard study was that environmental activism among African Americans tended to take place not within traditional environmental groups but through other organizations, such as churches, social clubs, labor unions, civil rights groups, or parental groups. On average, 16.3 percent of Bullard’s subjects belonged to an environmental group defined as such, whereas memberships were 76.5 percent in churches, 27.9 percent in community involvement groups, and 23.1 percent in parent groups (Bullard 2000). More recent studies confirm the evidence adduced from this earlier research. In 2003, Paul Mohai reported the results of his
NIMBY, PIBBY, and LULUs 45
review of data from three sources: the University of Michigan National Opinion Research Center Detroit Studies from 1990 and 2002, the findings of Urban League studies collected over a 20year period, and the People of Color Environmental Groups Directory. Mohai’s analysis covered not only environmental attitudes of African Americans but also factors such as lifestyle choices, political actions, environmental group memberships, and the environmental voting records of African American legislators. He found four major trends: • In most respects, African Americans are more likely to make lifestyle choices that are better for the environment than do whites: They consume less meat, buy more pesticide-free foods, and drive less. In a few categories, they trail whites. For example, African Americans tend to recycle less than do whites. • No statistical difference exists between the number of African Americans and the number of whites who join environmental groups. The major difference between the two groups is that the former tend to affiliate with local grassroots organizations while the latter join more traditional, “mainstream” environmental groups. • African Americans are more likely to express concerns about environmental issues that affect them directly, such as exposure to lead, high noise levels, and abandoned or run-down properties. Mohai points out that these differences probably reflect the environment in which African Americans live compared to white neighborhoods. • African American legislators are significantly more likely to support environmental legislation than are their white counterparts. The rate for African American legislators ranges from about 75 to 85 percent; for white Democrats, from about 60 to 80 percent; and for white Republicans, from about 20 to 40 percent. Mohai concluded that “environmental issues are not ‘luxury’ issues to African Americans. Survey results such as these demonstrate that environmental quality issues are a priority on many different levels” (2003, 25). Two later studies confirmed Mohai’s conclusions. In 2005, Matthew Whittaker of the University of Iowa, Gary M. Segura
46 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
at the University of Washington, and Shaun Bowler at the University of California at Riverside reported on their study of Latinos in California over a period covering just over two decades. They found that the subject population evidenced greater interest in environmental issues than did whites, but only on issues that related directly to their own lives (Whittaker, Segura, and Bowler 2005). A year later, Robert Emmet Jones of the University of Tennessee and Shirley A. Rainey of Austin Peay State University described their study of 247 people living in a “highly polluted” community of color. They found that their respondents had a very different perception of which environmental issues were of concern to them than did a control group of whites and that they showed a greater level of interest and participation than did whites (Jones and Rainey 2006).
Access to Tools of Protest The most important single reason that LULUs end up in neighborhoods with a majority of people of color or of people in lower economic strata may be the difference in access that various groups of people in the United States have to the political process. One might argue that a community of color has the same opportunity to protest the siting of a hazardous waste site or a polluting industry as does any other community. It can take its case before a zoning board or bring suit in a court of law to prevent the siting of an undesirable facility, for example. The reality is, however, that people of color and poor people probably lack the experience, the training, or the financial resources to engage in the same kinds of battles that affluent white communities routinely use to keep their neighborhoods free of environmentally offensive sites. Mohai and Bryant have summarized the disadvantages under which communities of color operate when confronted with environmental hazards. In the first place, the residents of such communities are usually unaware of policy decisions that impact them, and they generally do not have the resources, time, money, experience, or knowledge of the political system to know how to react to those policies. In addition, minority communities tend to be underrepresented on bodies that make and administer policies determining environmental quality (Mohai and Bryant 1992).
NIMBY, PIBBY, and LULUs 47
Job Blackmail The siting of LULUs in communities of color or low-income communities often presents a difficult dilemma. The construction of a factory or a hazardous waste site may mean new jobs and an expanded tax base for such communities, an important economic incentive when unemployment may be high and municipal services minimal. When Chemical Waste Management, Inc. (CWM), purchased an existing hazardous waste landfill in Sumter County, Alabama, in 1978, for example, it worked hard to convince local residents of the landfill’s economic benefit to the community. A chart the company made public, “How Much Will We Get from Chem Waste?” showed 21 different governmental and nongovernmental bodies—for example, the Sumter County General Fund; the Sumter County Board of Education; the Sumter County Water Authority; the Livingstone University General Fund; the towns of Gainesville, Geiger, and Emelle; the cities of Livingstone and York; and the Sumter County Historical and Preservation Society, the Sumter County Library System, and the Sumter County Fine Arts Council—receiving tax benefits from the landfill. Overall, CWM was to become the largest single taxpayer in the county, producing about half of all public funds collected (Bailey and Faupel 1992). Poor communities find it difficult to reject an economically productive facility such as this one, even if it might present serious environmental and health hazards. Individual workers face a similar dilemma. It seems unlikely that anyone would choose to work in a hazardous waste landfill or a factory in which noxious fumes are constantly released, but a dangerous job may be better than no job at all. This form of job blackmail is hardly new to minority workers. Throughout history, African Americans, Asian Americans, Hispanic Americans, or other minority groups have been given jobs that whites would not want or take. Migrant workers probably do not choose to work 12-hour days in hot, dry fields where they are exposed to dangerous pesticides, for example, because they enjoy the outdoor life. They take such jobs because they may be the only ones open to them. Probably the earliest comprehensive discussion of job blackmail can be found in a book by Richard Kazis and Richard L. Grossman, Fear at Work: Job Blackmail, Labor, and the Environment, in which they first use the term (Kazis and Grossman 1982).
48 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
In many cases, the assignment of minorities to dangerous and difficult jobs has been justified by pseudoscientific theories about differences in physical or biological traits among various ethnic groups. For many years, for example, the iron and steel industry assigned African American men to work at its coke ovens because of the supposed ability of African Americans to withstand heat better than whites. Similarly, workers with dark skin were once more frequently assigned to work with caustic chemicals in some industries because job-induced skin irritations would supposedly be less noticeable and less objectionable than they would be with lighter-skinned workers (Davis 1977). Job blackmail on a somewhat more comprehensive scale is sometimes referred to as “economic blackmail,” a posture taken by both industry and government. One form of the argument is that low-income and minority communities should think seriously about objecting to environmental problems caused by a polluting industry. If you make too much trouble, that argument goes, the industry will go somewhere else, and you will all be left without jobs. One of the widest applications of economic blackmail in the United States historically has been the use of Native American lands for the mining of coal, oil, natural gas, uranium, and other valuable minerals; for the construction of energy-generating plants; and for hazardous waste disposal sites. In such cases, corporations have traditionally made tribes very attractive financial offers to allow them to build facilities that probably could not be built elsewhere or at much greater expense. The consequence of this trade-off has been the accumulation of considerable wealth for some tribes, accompanied by a significantly diminished environment with consequent health risks to individuals and communities. Although Native American tribes have become much more sophisticated in dealing with the issue of economic blackmail, temptations continue. In 2007, the Burnham Chapter of the Navajo Nation in the Four Corners region of the Southwest (where Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, and Utah meet) was confronted with the proposed construction of the Desert Rock power plant, a joint project of the tribe’s Diné Power Authority and Sithe Global, a private, multinational company based in Houston. Diné and Sithe Global noted that the plant would create 200 new jobs for the community and that an additional 200 jobs would be created at the coal mine supplying the plant its
NIMBY, PIBBY, and LULUs 49
fuel. In addition, the new plant would produce far less pollution than others of its kind in the area. Although the planned construction seemed a win-win situation for everyone, environmental activists were less certain. They pointed out, first, that a number of opportunities for alternative energy generation facilities were available, such as those involving the use of solar power. In addition, they wondered why the owners of the plant selected one of the most impoverished, Indian-occupied lands in the area on which to build rather than choosing land occupied primarily by middle-class whites. Finally, they suggested that reducing pollution significantly does not solve the environmental health problems already faced by Native Americans in the area. As one observer noted, “just because you go from 10 quarts of whiskey a week to four doesn’t mean you’re clean and sober,” and reducing pollution even by half still results in unacceptable levels of noxious gases being released into the atmosphere (Binkly 2007). Job blackmail and economic blackmail present, therefore, a damned-if-you-do and damned-if-you-don’t choice for both individuals and communities. In his article “Environmental Blackmail in Minority Communities,” Robert Bullard pointed out that many polluting facilities such as paper mills, chemical plants, heavy metals operations, and waste disposal and treatment facilities saw minority communities as a logical choice for their facilities. They assumed that such communities reasoned as Third World communities might, believing that development of any kind, no matter how dangerous, is better than no development at all. Foul-smelling air and polluted water were, they reasoned, a fair trade-off for jobs and security (Bullard 1992). An intriguing point about the job/economic blackmail argument is that it often presents a false dichotomy, forcing individuals and communities to choose between two apparently incompatible alternatives. But those alternatives are not necessarily incompatible. In some cases, industries that have said they could not survive unless their demands were met did, indeed, survive (and often prospered), even though they were not able to get their way with a community. One case sometimes mentioned involves the paper industry in Maine, which claimed that the provisions of the Federal Water Pollution Control Amendments (the so-called Clean Water Act) of 1972 would put it out of business because it would be forced to install new pollution control devices. In fact, there appeared to be little economic impact on
50 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
the industry once it complied with the legislation, and it was not until a decade later that employment actually dropped—as a result of new automated production methods (Sayen 1995). Other observers point out that meeting new environmental regulations can even benefit an industry. By switching from older, outmoded systems to newer, more-efficient systems, industries can create new jobs and realize unexpected profits. When speaking about pollution problems in his Cincinnati neighborhood, for example, activist Mike Henson reflected on the fact that a local industry, Queen City Barrels, now brags on its Web site about having the best pollution control equipment available in operation at its facility. But, he points out, the company installed the equipment only because of pressure by community activists and, eventually, new city regulations (Pierce 2007).
The Effects of Environmental Regulations The picture painted thus far of the environmental inequities faced by people of color and poor people seems bleak. Yet, the United States has developed a much more enlightened view of the environment in the past three decades. People in general are probably much better informed and more concerned about the environment, and federal, state, and local governments have become much more aggressive about passing legislation and enforcing regulations that protect the environment. Do these changes suggest that progress is being made in dealing with the disproportionate exposure faced by people of color and poor people in the United States? It would be difficult to argue that no overall improvement has been made as a result of such changes. Somewhat remarkably, however, it is also clear that many new environmental regulations have actually increased the environmental hazards to which minorities are exposed. Again, the benefits of environmental regulations for some groups of people have resulted in an increased burden for other groups of people. First, new programs to protect the environment clearly cost money. Those costs are borne by all taxpayers in the society, poor as well as rich. They are borne by all taxpayers whether or not they benefit directly from the environmental program in question. Programs to protect national wildlife areas or national seashores are paid for by African Americans, Hispanic
The Effects of Environmental Regulations 51
Americans, and Native Americans, as well as by whites. Every time an environmental regulation raises the cost of an automobile because of new pollution control devices, increases the cost of housing because of new land-use regulations, or raises the cost of food products because of new pesticide-use rules, people of lower-income groups pay a disproportionate percentage of that cost. In other words, the economic costs of new environmental regulations are more likely to have a more significant effect on low-income people than on high-income people. If the costs of environmental regulations average out to $500 per person nationwide, those costs will be more detrimental for someone making $10,000 per year than for someone making $100,000 per year. One attempt to measure the economic impact of the air pollution policy in the United States was conducted by Leonard P. Gianessi, Henry M. Peskin, and Edward Wolff. This study was used to determine the costs and benefits that could be anticipated from the full implementation of the federal Clean Air Act. The researchers found that the effects of the Clean Air Act were regressive; that is, people of low income would pay proportionally more than would those of high income. For those with an income ranging between $3,000 and $8,000 per year, the net costs of the Clean Air Act were about 0.9 to 1.0 percent of their income. In contrast, those with incomes of more than $8,000 uniformly experienced a net cost of about 0.5 percent of their income (Gianessi, Peskin, and Wolff 1979; also see Johnson 1980). The costs of environmental regulation can also be measured in terms of exposure to regulated pollutants. In his doctoral thesis at the University of California at Berkeley, Michel Gelobter analyzed the amount of air pollution to which individuals in selected urban areas were exposed in the period between 1970 and 1986. He found that all the racial and all the income groups he studied were exposed to lower levels of ambient air pollutants at the end of that period than they were at the beginning. However, Gelobter found differences in exposure among both income and racial groups. For example, in 1970, 1975, 1980, and 1984, the average white resident of the urban areas studied was exposed to 100, 75, 75, and 62 micrograms of total suspended particulates per cubic meter of air, respectively, whereas the comparable figures for nonwhites during those four years were 122, 85, 82, and 70 micrograms of total suspended particulates per cubic meter of air, respectively. In an analysis of the “relative
52 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
benefit from air quality improvements” that included a variety of measures, Gelobter found that whites and nonwhites rated almost exactly the same in 1970. Over the next 15 years, however, the difference in relative benefits diverged until whites were approximately 5 percent “better off” according to these measures. Gelobter later summarized the results of his research in a chapter for the book Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai (Gelobter 1992). A number of studies have produced another interesting finding: the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the U.S. government agency primarily responsible for the prevention and cleanup of polluted sites, has itself been guilty of discriminatory policies and practices in dealing with communities of color and low-economic status. In a study conducted for Clean Sites, Inc., in 1990, for example, Kate Probst found that the EPA was less likely to include rural poor communities on its list of potential Superfund sites than other communities (Probst 1990). One of the most telling studies on this issue was conducted by Lavelle and Coyle in 1992. These researchers found, first of all, that the EPA was likely to make minority communities wait even longer than low-income communities to receive Superfund listing. The pattern was for low-income areas to wait 11 percent longer than high-income areas, and for minority areas to wait 20 percent longer than white areas. Lavelle and Coyle also found that, after a minority community did receive a Superfund listing, the agency was more likely to institute a program of waste containment than to arrange for toxicity reduction or removal, as was the case with white communities. Finally, for instances of pollution in minority communities the fines assessed by the EPA averaged only 20 percent of those assessed in white communities (Lavelle and Coyle 1993). Critics have argued that an indication of the EPA’s attitudes toward racial issues can be found in the agency’s hiring policies. One way in which the agency could demonstrate a greater sensitivity to issues of environmental inequities, they suggest, would be to make greater efforts to include members of minorities on its staff. Yet, according to an agency report published in 1992, less than 10 percent (33 out of 412) of the new management positions filled during the previous year were given to members of a minority. In the following year (1992), 42 of 354 management hires
Environmental Inequities: By Chance or By Choice? 53
went to minorities. In comparison, the number of white females hired was 142 (34 percent of new hires) and 126 (36 percent) in 1991 and 1992, respectively (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1992). In a critique of the nation’s environmental protection policies, Robert Bullard has written that these policies have “(1) institutionalized unequal enforcement; (2) traded human health for profit; (3) placed the burden of proof on the ‘victims’ and not on the polluting industry; (4) legitimated human exposure to harmful chemicals, pesticides, and hazardous substances; (5) promoted risky technologies, such as incinerators; (6) exploited the vulnerability of economically and politically disenfranchised communities; (7) subsidized ecological destruction; (8) created an industry around risk assessment; (9) delayed cleanup actions; and (10) failed to develop pollution prevention as the overarching and dominant strategy” (Bullard 2000, 115).
Environmental Inequities: By Chance or By Choice? Even if everything said above were entirely true, one critical question remains—the question of intent. Do environmental inequities exist because corporations, governmental bodies, and/or individuals plan for them, or do they come about simply as the result of business and/or technical decisions based on other factors? This question has been at the core of environmental justice issues because, from the earliest days of the movement, the assumption has been that environmental inequities are a manifestation of racism and, perhaps to a lesser degree, class issues. Recall that Benjamin Chavis defined environmental racism as “the deliberate targeting of people of color communities for toxic waste facilities and the official sanctioning of a life threatening presence of poisons and pollutants in people of color communities” (U.S. Congress 1993, 6). Some people, however, while acknowledging the existence of environmental inequities, argue that racism is a minor or nonexistent factor. Such inequities come about not because business, industry, and government intend to expose poor and minority communities to environmental insults; instead, these problems arise as a by-product—and an unfortunate by-product
54 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
that needs to be addressed—of business decisions that have no racial or class component. This issue is, of course, a crucial one within the environmental justice arena. Perhaps corporations and governments routinely make decisions about the siting of LULUs based strictly on economic factors, such as labor costs, availability of land, and access to transportation. Racial, ethnic, or other social factors might then have little or no impact on their decisions. In such a case, minority communities could expect to work with corporations and governments to find ways of siting such facilities with less disproportionate impact on themselves. The affected communities and the agencies responsible for environmental inequities could work together with trust and confidence in each other. On the other hand, it might be that factors other than economic matters enter into the siting of LULUs. One could imagine that those responsible for making such decisions hold African Americans, Hispanic Americans, Asian Americans, Native Americans, and poor people in less regard than they do middleand upper-class white citizens. In such a case, solving the problem of environmental inequities poses a different dilemma. Minority communities would be faced with the task of changing attitudes among those in corporations or government whose respect they currently do not have. Or they might have to use a more confrontational approach to problem solving (such as court cases) to deal with environmental inequities. As a matter of fact, it is the latter position that most of those active in the environmental justice movement appear to hold currently and to have held since the earliest days of the movement. Still, many observers continue to deny the presence of social attitudes, such as racism, in the origin of environmental inequities. An example is the comment made by Kent Jeffreys, director of Environmental Studies for the Competitive Enterprise Institute, in testimony before the Subcommittee on Civil and Constitutional Rights of the U.S. House of Representatives on March 3, 1993. Jeffreys said that “racism exists. Environmental problems exist. These facts, however, do not reveal whether or not environmental racism is occurring. Regardless of whether any particular case fits the definition of environmental racism, the fact remains that environmental problems—from a minority perspective—are rather trivial in comparison to the larger economic and civil liberty issues: solve these and you have solved most, if not all, of the environmental inequities” (U.S. Congress 1993, 64).
Environmental Inequities: By Chance or By Choice? 55
This viewpoint was also reflected during hearings before the Louisiana Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights in February 1992. The hearings were held to determine the status of environmental problems in certain parts of the state. At the conclusion of its fact-finding sessions, the committee concluded that “many black communities located along the industrial corridor between Baton Rouge and New Orleans are disproportionately impacted by the present State and local government system for permitting and expansion of hazardous waste and chemical facilities” (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993, iii). The committee did not specifically attribute the environmental inequities it found to racism, but its final report contains a number of allusions that suggest that the majority of committee members may have held this viewpoint. At one point the report says, for example, that “some black citizens and organizations view with skepticism and distrust some agencies in State government, including the Department of Environmental Quality. These views are held because of poor access to government and an ongoing perception that State government discriminated against them to promote and sustain the interests of industry and business” (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993, iv). Perhaps the best view of the committee’s mind-set on this issue comes from one member who wrote a dissenting statement to the report. John S. Baker Jr., professor of law at the Louisiana State University Law Center, concluded that “absent from the report is the one finding most clearly supported by the evidence: Environmental Racism has not been shown to exist in Louisiana. . . . None of the extensive findings contains anything about, nor could they support a finding of, ‘deliberate targeting’ or ‘official sanctioning’” (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993, 69 [emphasis in original]). Baker argued that members of the committee knew in advance of the hearings that discriminatory motive would not be found and that the sessions were conducted with other purposes in mind than the search for such a motive. Baker continued in his dissent: The overall handling of this project reminds me of the situation that occasionally occurs during a criminal case. Sometimes during voir dire when a potential juror is asked whether he or she can presume the innocence of the defendant and give him a fair trial, the juror will answer quite innocently in terms that effectively say:
56 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
“Of course, I’ll give him a fair trial before convicting him.” Like the prospective juror, the staff and committee members, I believe, are acting with the best of intentions. Nonetheless, the report, and the process that produced it, have blindly stepped over and around the evidence, which so clearly establishes no racially motivated discrimination on environmental decisions in Louisiana. (Louisiana Advisory Committee 1993, 71–72) The issue being raised in this debate might be characterized as a chicken-and-egg debate: Which came first—the hazardous waste facility or low-income and minority communities? In other words, do industries tend to choose an existing minority and/or low-income community in which to locate because they have less regard for the health and welfare of people living there, or does an industry build a landfill (or other LULU) and low-income and minority people then choose to move into that area? Some research has been done on this question, but the findings are not yet conclusive. For example, Vicki Been, associate professor of law at New York University School of Law, has reanalyzed the demographics of waste disposal sites previously studied by the U.S. General Accountability Office (GAO) and by Robert Bullard in Houston. Her intent was to pay greater attention to the economic and racial status of an area before a toxic waste landfill was constructed. Been obtained somewhat conflicting results from her examination of the GAO and Bullard studies. In the former case, she found that the four communities where waste disposal sites were sited were originally both predominantly low-income and minority communities. She also found that neither the proportion of low-income nor the proportion of minority individuals increased after the siting. In the Houston (Bullard) case, Been found that waste disposal sites were occupied predominantly by minority populations, but not by low-income populations, before facilities were installed. After the facilities were opened, however, the percentage of African Americans and of low-income people increased. Been concludes from her research that “research examining the socioeconomic characteristics of host neighborhoods at the time they were selected, then tracing changes in those characteristics following the siting, would go a long way toward answering the question of which came first—the LULU or its minority or poor neighbors. Until that research is complete,
The Legal Question of “Intent” in Environmental Inequities 57
proposed ‘solutions’ to the problem of disproportionate siting run a substantial risk of missing the mark” (Been 1994, 124). One of the difficulties in conducting studies of this type is the difference between older hazardous waste sites, many now closed, and new or proposed sites. At one time, it was relatively easy to build a hazardous waste site, and older sites can be found throughout the United States. Now, obtaining permission to construct a hazardous waste site is much more difficult. It follows that the factors involved in making the decision as to where to build a newer site might, therefore, be somewhat different now than in the past. One study bearing on this issue was completed by James T. Hamilton. Hamilton found that counties planning to expand waste disposal sites apparently made no distinction among areas on the basis of racial or economic conditions. He also found, however, that sites scheduled for closure were more likely to be located in white areas than in minority communities (Hamilton 1993). In his summary of the new research needed in the field of environmental justice, Benjamin Goldman returns to the question of causality in the siting of LULUs. He points out that the majority of studies he reviewed make use of correlation analysis, which shows how two variables are mathematically related to each other, but do not demonstrate whether or how one variable is dependent on the other. Thus, the fact that the siting of hazardous facilities is mathematically related to a high density of nonwhite and/or poor populations does not prove that one of these factors causes or is caused by the other (Goldman 1993). Yet, as Goldman also points out, studies like those by Been and Hamilton deal with the very core of the environmental justice movement. He goes on to say that the basic questions for those concerned about environmental justice are about how the decisions made by legal, social, economic, and other cultural institutions result in disproportionate environmental impacts and what legal remedies are available for resolving those impacts, whether or not one can prove intent by an offending industry.
The Legal Question of “Intent” in Environmental Inequities Goldman’s summary refers to another key issue in the dispute over environmental inequities: the question of intent. Many
58 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
involved in the environmental justice movement would like to demonstrate that environmental harm has come about as a result of decisions and actions taken by business, industry, or governmental bodies and then to obtain some relief from that harm from the appropriate body. That is, an environmental justice organization might like to prove that Company X placed its hazardous waste landfill adjacent to a predominantly African American community because that was the easiest decision for the company to make. The organization might then argue that health effects to the community resulting from the company’s decision were the company’s responsibility, and that the company should be forced to pay a financial penalty for its decision. And in some cases, this approach has worked, and companies have paid large fines or made large financial settlements to members of communities harmed by their activities. But such instances are relatively rare. One reason is that a stringent standard of proof is often required by courts in cases of environmental harm. This standard was established in the landmark decision in Washington, Mayor of Washington, D.C., et al. v. Davis et al. In that case, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a plaintiff must be able to prove that harmful actions taken by an individual, a group, or a corporation are intended to cause harm to the plaintiff and not that the harm occurred as an unexpected by-product of the action. This legal standard is a difficult one to employ since it requires that a plaintiff somehow find out what was in the minds of a businessperson or government official and then demonstrate “intent” to the court. The hurdles created by the intent standard have meant that many environmental justice activists have used means other than legal challenges to deal with environmental issues. As one example, the Lumbee Indians of Robeson County, North Carolina, were involved in an extended dispute with the GSX Corporation, which planned to build a hazardous waste facility on lands sacred to the Lumbee. The tactics used by the Lumbee were not legal challenges but a more personal campaign featuring traditional Native American dance and music at public hearings, leafleting at churches, and participation in all planning sessions held on the GSX request (Austin and Schill 1994). Grassroots activities such as these have been common and successful in situations where long, expensive, and complex legal challenges would have held much less promise.
Responding to Environmental Inequities 59
Responding to Environmental Inequities Some obvious methods for dealing with environmental inequities have been suggested thus far. Some communities have found that direct political action—protests and demonstrations, for example—have accomplished their goals. Others have sought relief in the courts. A debate remains, however, as to the best mechanism by which a community dealing with a LULU can protect itself against the dangers of such a facility. On the one hand, some people believe that environmental justice is, to a large extent, a problem with which governments have to deal. New and better laws and stronger enforcement of existing laws can prevent future environmental inequities and can help deal with instances now existing. Robert Bullard, for example, has called for government to take five steps to ensure environmental justice: creating national legislation modeled on civil rights acts, eliminating existing environmental hazards, shifting the burden of proof for guilt or innocence in environmental inequity cases from affected communities to polluting industries, modifying the current legal standard of intent in dealing with cases of environmental inequities, and providing compensation and assistance to communities most seriously affected by environmental inequities (Bullard 1994). An opposing view to the solution of environmental inequities calls for greater dependence on market forces in the private sector and less on government involvement. Companies that benefit from the use of land for the construction of LULUs should be required to pay a fee for this privilege. That fee would then be transferred to minority and poor communities on whom the burdens of the LULU siting fall. An example of this approach is legislation proposed in the state of Wisconsin in 1981. This legislation required negotiations between a company wishing to build a hazardous waste facility and the municipality in which the facility would be located. Three advantages of the Wisconsin plan, as noted by Christopher Boerner and Thomas Lambert of the Center for the Study of American Business at Washington University in St. Louis, are that the statute “clearly specifies ‘the players of the game’—that is, who negotiates with whom. Both developers and potential host communities are required to establish negotiating committees, with the rules regarding these representatives explicitly set
60 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
forth in the statute. Secondly, the legislation assures that these ‘players’ will not only negotiate, but also that the results of their negotiations will be legally binding. . . . Finally, the Wisconsin statute provides a ‘back-up plan’—a way to arbitrate siting decisions should negotiations fail or should one party refuse to cooperate” (Boerner and Lambert 1995, 99).
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the United States The March 2007 United Church of Christ report Toxic Wastes and Race at Twenty includes a timeline of important events in the environmental justice movement from 1987 to 2007 (Bullard et al. 2007, chap. 2). That timeline provides a succinct review of the progress (or lack of progress) in dealing with environmental inequities in the United States and a hint as to the problems and challenges still facing the movement. A few of the generalizations that can be drawn from the timeline are described in the following sections.
Environmental Inequities Exist Despite all the debate that has taken place over whether environmental inequities exist, what groups of people are most affected by such inequities, whether inequities occur as the by-product of industrial development or because of corporate intent, and other details, the fact remains that very few experts any longer doubt that low-income and minority communities in the United States suffer disproportionate health risks because of their exposure to hazardous waste dumps, nuclear processing plants and disposal sites, unsafe occupational settings, petrochemical and chemical industries, and other facilities that emit harmful products into the environment. Report after report begins with some mention and acknowledgment of this reality. The 2003 report by the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Not in My Backyard: Executive Order 12898 and Title VI as Tools for Achieving Environmental Justice, for example, notes that “clearly, race and class play significant roles in environmental decision-making; moreover, communities of color and low-income communities are disproportionately affected by siting decisions and the permitting of facilities. Siting
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 61
and permitting decisions are not, however, the sole sources of environmental concerns in these communities. Exposure to leadbased paint, diesel emissions, noise, odor, and other pollutants also diminishes the health of these communities.” Minority and low-income communities are exposed to multiple pollutants from multiple sources, the report continued; however, there has been insufficient data collection and scientific research identifying the health risks created by these multiple exposures (U.S. Commission on Civil Rights 2003, 27). Two years later, the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) issued a report on clean air rulemaking by the EPA. Its letter of transmittal about the report began with the statement that “[l]ow-income and minority populations are disproportionately exposed to air pollution and other environmental risks, according to Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) studies” (U.S. Government Accountability Office 2005, 1). Shortly after the GAO report appeared, the Associated Press reported on “a little-known government research project” dealing with the prevalence of environmental inequities using data from the 2000 census. That report indicated that 79 percent of African Americans were more likely to live in neighborhoods where pollution could pose health risks than are whites. It concluded that “residents in neighborhoods with the highest pollution scores also tend to be poorer, less educated and more often unemployed than those elsewhere in the country.” The study also found that similar patterns do not hold nationwide for Asians and Hispanics, although they do occur in certain states (12 states for Hispanics and 7 for Asians) (Pace 2005).
Federal, State, Regional, and Local Governmental Agencies Have a Responsibility to Find, Study, and Deal with Cases of Environmental Inequities The first major governmental action dealing with environmental inequities was Executive Order 12898, signed by President Bill Clinton on February 11, 1994. (Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 has also become an important tool in dealing with environmental justice issues, although it was not adopted specifically for that purpose.) Since the time of Clinton’s proclamation, a number of other executive, legislative, and regulatory orders have been
62 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
adopted for dealing with problems of environmental injustices. In 2003, for example, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation adopted a new policy requiring the inclusion of environmental justice considerations in the issuance of new permits. The new policy amended the existing permitting process by “identifying potential environmental justice areas; providing information on environmental justice to applicants with proposed projects in those communities; enhancing public participation requirements for proposed projects in those communities; establishing requirements for projects in potential environmental justice areas with the potential for at least one significant adverse environmental impact; and providing alternative dispute resolution opportunities to allow communities and project sponsors to resolve issues of concern to the community.” A year later, New Jersey governor James McGreevey became one of the first state executives to take action on environmental justice issues. On January 19, 2004, he issued an executive order similar to Clinton’s order of 1994 that required all state departments, agencies, boards, commissions, and other bodies to “provide meaningful opportunities for involvement to all people regardless of race, color, ethnicity, religion, income, or education level” (“Environmental Justice Executive Order [New Jersey]” 2004). The order included a number of specific provisions, such as requiring that notices on health and environmental issues be made available in Spanish as well as in English, studying existing and proposed industrial and commercial facilities located near minority and low-income communities to determine their impact on the health of individuals in those communities, developing advisories concerning consumption of fish that may contain high levels of hazardous materials, creating a strategy for dealing with health problems faced by low-income and minority communities as a result of exposure to particulate matter in the air, and creating or reconstituting a number of state agencies with responsibility for environmental justice issues. In 2004, the section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities of the American Bar Association and the Public Law Research Institute of the University of California’s Hastings College of Law issued a comprehensive report on the actions taken in all 50 states in the field of environmental justice. The report shows that a host of tools has been developed by the states for dealing with problems of environmental inequities, ranging from statutes and executive orders to policy statements and special training
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 63
programs. As one might expect, dramatic differences exist in the extent to which states (if any) acknowledge the existence of environmental inequities and/or take action to deal with those inequities, as well as in the tools they have developed to use in environmental justice problems. The examples that follow demonstrate the differences (all information as of 2004 and obtained from Bonorris 2004). Alaska has no laws or regulations dealing with environmental inequities. Arizona has no state laws on environmental justice, but the state’s Department of Environmental Quality has expressed a commitment to monitor and act on issues of environmental inequities that come to its attention. It maintains one full-time employee to deal with such issues. California has one of the most extensive and comprehensive collections of laws and regulations for dealing with environmental justice issues of any state. The first such law was passed in 1999 designating the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research as the lead agency for environmental justice programs and directing the California Environmental Protection Agency to take a number of actions to ensure that the state is notified of and takes actions on specific instances of environmental injustice that occur in the state. During the three-year period from 2001 to 2004, the state legislature passed eight more bills dealing specifically with environmental justice concerns, such as diesel engine emission reduction programs, cleanup programs for small parcels of land contaminated with hazardous wastes, models for the siting and operation of hazardous waste disposal sites, and a program of small grants for communities dealing with environmental and health problems specific to their neighborhoods. Florida has, like most other states, adopted laws and regulations ensuring that problems of environmental inequities are discovered and acted upon. But it has also developed a somewhat unusual model in that most of the actions taken to deal with environmental justice issues take place outside of state agencies and within the state’s university system. Much of this work is carried out through five university
64 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
divisions: the Environmental Sciences Institute, the Center for Environmental Equity and Justice, the College of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, the Institute of Public Health at the Florida Agricultural and Mechanical University, and the Interdisciplinary Center for Brownfield Rehabilitation Assistance at the University of South Florida. These divisions are responsible for conducting research and working with communities on problems of environmental injustice. Indiana stands out among states as having been especially proactive in dealing with its problems of environmental inequities. The state’s Department of Environmental Management (IDEM) adopted a strategic plan for environmental justice in August 2001. Key elements in that plan include identifying geographic areas in which environmental inequities of significance exist and developing procedures by which communities can make their concerns known to state agencies. Although the state’s approach to environmental justice has been recognized as a “model for change” by the National Academy of Public Administration (NAPA), some internal problems remain. Since other state agencies responsible for air and water quality and solid waste management continue to function independently of IDEM, the latter agency’s ability to bring about significant change is somewhat limited (see National Academy of Public Administration 2002, 37–43; Bonorris 2004, 24). Kentucky is an example of a state with minimal environmental justice provisions. A 2002 law requires that the Kentucky Regional Integrated Waste Treatment and Disposal Facility Siting Board consider the social and economic impacts on communities and the environment of any proposed new or existing waste treatment or disposal site. The state has virtually no other statutory or regulatory provisions for dealing with environmental inequities. New Jersey was another state recognized by the 2002 NAPA study of “models of change” in environmental justice. The NAPA report especially applauded the state’s decision to include environmental justice considerations in its broader plan to deal with an array of state problems, including urban sprawl, availability of open space, preservation of agri-
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 65
cultural lands, rehabilitation of brownfield sites, and redevelopment of older, industrialized cities. Well before Governor McGreevey’s executive order on environmental justice (see above), Robert C. Shinn Jr., commissioner of the state’s Department of Environmental Protection, issued a number of orders dealing with environmental inequities. The first, issued in 1998, created the Environmental Equity Task Force to develop policy and make recommendations for environmental justice in the state. The second, issued in 1999, was designed to carry out the task force’s recommendations. And the third, issued in 2000, set out an extensive and comprehensive state environmental justice policy that reflected the recommendations of the task force. Virginia first recognized the problem of environmental inequities in 1993 when the legislature adopted a joint resolution requiring the Joint Legislative Audit Review Commission (JLARC) to study the “siting, monitoring, and cleanup of solid and hazardous waste facilities, with an emphasis on how waste facilities affect minority communities” (Bonorris 2004, 55).
The Federal Government Has Not Been a Strong Advocate for Environmental Justice Early in the environmental justice movement, many people were confident that they possessed two powerful tools to challenge cases of environmental inequities: President Clinton’s Executive Order 12898 and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. They believed the executive order could be used by federal officials (and, perhaps, by example, state, regional, and local officials) to use their regulatory powers to find and fight cases in which low-income and minority communities are exposed to disproportionate health risks from hazardous waste dumps, occupational hazards, nuclear mining operations, and other hazardous facilities. The executive order created a new federal framework for dealing with environmental justice and required all federal departments to develop strategies for including the principles of environmental justice within their overall philosophies and day-to-day operations. From the outset, however, that expectation met with mixed results. Some departments appointed task forces to study the
66 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
ways in which the executive order could be implemented within their own agencies, appointed men and women with specific responsibilities for environmental justice activities, offered training classes in dealing with environmental justice issues, offered grants for research and action programs on environmental justice, and otherwise complied with both the spirit and the letter of the executive order. Other departments moved more slowly or, in some cases, hardly at all. The potential for action using the executive order was reduced significantly with the accession of George W. Bush to the presidency. Many observers believed that Bush was not particularly interested in environmental justice, and his appointees to the EPA tended to reflect that position. Over the years, the first efforts to include environmental justice concerns within departments faded or disappeared entirely. The Interagency Working Group established by the executive order became moribund and, by 2008, touted a conference on environmental justice as its main accomplishment and indication that it was still active and moving aggressively on environmental justice issues (Gogal, 2008). During the first decade of the 21st century, a number of governmental and nongovernmental organizations and agencies began to issue reports highlighting the failure of the federal government to take environmental justice concerns seriously, often criticizing specific agencies for their tendency to ignore precise instructions in the executive order. For example, the EPA’s own Office of Inspector General (OIG) issued a report in March 2004 reviewing the agency’s efforts to implement Executive Order 12898. The OIG concluded that the “EPA has not fully implemented Executive Order 12898 nor consistently integrated environmental justice into its day-to-day operations. EPA has not identified minority and low-income, nor identified populations addressed in the Executive Order, and has neither defined nor developed criteria for determining disproportionately impacted” (Office of Inspector General 2004, i). The OIG report goes on to suggest that, although the agency has been actively involved in implementing Executive Order 12898 for 10 years, it has not developed a clear vision or a comprehensive strategic plan and has not established values, goals, expectations, and performance measurements. The agency did make an attempt to issue an environmental justice toolkit, endorsed environmental justice training, and required that all
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 67
regional and programmatic offices submit “action plans” to develop some accountability for environmental justice integration. In the absence of environmental justice definitions, criteria, or standards from the agency, the OIG report concluded, many regional and program offices have taken steps, individually, to implement environmental justice policies. This has resulted in inconsistent approaches by the regional offices. Thus, the implementation of environmental justice actions is dependent not only on minority and income status but on the EPA region in which the person resides. A comparison of how environmental justice protocols used by three different regions would apply to the same city showed a wide disparity (Office of Inspector General 2004, i–ii). Two years later, the OIG issued a second report on the EPA’s internal implementation of the provisions of the executive order and found that very little had been accomplished (Office of Inspector General 2006). Reviews from outside the EPA found similar results. In July 2005, a report by the GAO found that the EPA had essentially ignored Executive Order 12898 and any consideration of environmental justice concerns when it issued three new regulations on air quality. Perhaps the most striking feature of the Bush administration’s approach to environmental justice has been its attempt to redefine the meaning of the term in such a way as to subvert its fundamental intent, namely, to focus on the disproportionate environmental inequities faced by minority and low-income communities. It decided to define environmental justice as “the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, color, national origin, or income, with respect to development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies” (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2008). In a June 2002 memo to employees of the EPA, the agency’s Office of Environmental Justice offered a redefinition of its mission. “Senior management should recognize,” the memo said, “that the environmental justice program is not an affirmative action program or a set-aside program designed specifically to address the concerns of minority communities and/or low-income communities. To the contrary, environmental justice belongs to all Americans and it is the responsibility of Agency officials, as public servants, to serve all members of the public” (as quoted in Office of Inspector General 2004, 10). In other words, the purpose of the EPA’s environmental justice program
68 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
was not to provide relief to those low-income and minority communities who suffer disproportionate health risks from exposure to hazardous materials but to distribute the risks and the benefits of environmental justice (whatever the term now means) to all Americans equally. The OIG rejected this action by the EPA’s Office of Environmental Justice. “We believe the Agency is bound by the requirements of Executive Order 12898,” the OIG report said, “and does not have the authority to reinterpret the order. The Acting Deputy Administrator needs to reaffirm that the Executive Order 12898 applies specifically to minority and low-income populations that are disproportionately impacted” (Office of Inspector General 2004, ii). The EPA’s efforts to redefine environmental justice also produced a firestorm of objection from environmental justice groups and from legislators. In August 2005, for example, more than 70 Democratic members of Congress wrote the EPA objecting to its attempts to redefine the meaning of environmental justice and its failure to carry out the objectives of Executive Order 12898 (Featherstone 2005).
Complaints Filed with the EPA Have Not Been an Effective Means of Dealing with Environmental Inequities During the early 1990s, activists decided that the best way to challenge environmental inequities faced by low-income and minority communities was to file complaints with the EPA based on the equal rights provisions contained in Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. In the decade following 1993, when the first such complaint was filed, the EPA received 143 complaints. Of that number, the EPA rejected 82 cases outright, primarily because they did not meet regulatory requirements or because the complaints were made against companies or agencies that did not receive EPA funding (a requirement for such claims). As of November 2003 (the last date for which complete data are available), 29 complaints were still pending before the EPA. Of the 32 cases that have been closed, 2 were settled informally, and 2 were referred to other agencies. Ten more cases became moot because the complaint was dropped, the challenged permit was withdrawn or denied, or some other mitigating action was taken. Of the 18 cases on which the EPA took action, it rejected the
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 69
complaint in every case. In most cases, the EPA found that complainants did not show a direct causation between hazardous wastes or emissions and human health problems, did not demonstrate that low-income or minority communities had been disproportionately affected by exposure to hazardous wastes, or dealt with nonessential issues (such as not providing information in languages other than English). As one expert in the field has concluded, “it now appears that the EPA’s complaint procedure is not providing an effective source of redress . . . unless some of the 29 cases still pending have different outcomes than the 105 already closed” (Gerrard 2003, 6; also see Toffolon-Weiss and Roberts 2004, 265; Pace 2005).
Environmental Justice Advocates Have Largely Failed to Obtain Redress from Inequities through the Judicial System Another avenue activists can use to pursue environmental justice complaints is through the courts. Early in the movement’s history, some authorities believed that court cases could be brought based on the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. That amendment says that “no state shall . . . deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” Since disproportionate exposure to hazardous materials would seem to violate this clause, a number of complaints were filed in courts claiming discrimination. These complaints, however, failed almost universally (for details of this history, see Peter 2001). Eventually, attorneys decided that environmental justice clients were more likely to achieve success suing on the basis of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. That is, they planned to sue corporations or governmental agencies on the basis that their clients’ civil rights were being violated by disproportionate exposure to hazardous and toxic materials. A number of court cases were filed under this rubric, but without much success. An example of such cases was Sierra Club v. Gates, a suit filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana in early 2007. A group of environmental organizations sought to enjoin the U.S. Department of Defense and its private agent, Veolia Environmental Services, from incinerating 1.8 million gallons of the chemical warfare agent VX, which is converted into the chemical
70 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
known as hydrolysate before disposal. Veolia planned to conduct this operation in Port Arthur, Texas, on land adjacent to a largely low-income, African American community. That neighborhood already faced a number of environmental hazards from adjoining refineries and chemical facilities and had been found to have an unusually high rate of respiratory problems; ear, nose, and throat disorders; asthma; cancer; and liver and kidney diseases compared to control groups in nearby Galveston. Residents blamed their health problems on exposure to hazardous wastes produced by the nearby plants and feared that the planned incineration of VX would only exacerbate those problems. On August 3, 2007, Judge Larry J. McKinney denied the request for an injunction against the Department of Defense and Veolia, saying that the army had made its decision to incinerate the VX materials on scientific principles and that the environmental groups stood little chance of success in pursuing their case. The environmental groups then sought the aid of state and federal lawmakers in an effort to prevent the incineration. Those efforts also failed, and as of late 2008, almost all of the VX had been destroyed in Port Arthur. Perhaps the most promising court ruling for proponents of environmental justice came on April 19, 2001, when U.S. District Court judge Stephen Orofsky ruled for the plaintiffs in South Camden Citizens in Action v. New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (145 F. Supp. 2d 446 [2001]). Judge Orofsky decided that the state environmental agency had failed to consider the potential disproportionate and adverse effects posed by air emissions from the proposed St. Lawrence Cement Company’s plant in South Camden. The legal basis of Orofsky’s decision rested in draft guidelines that the EPA had prepared for such cases and on the assumption that individuals have the right to sue to enforce regulations that have disparate effects on communities under Title VI. Environmental justice advocates were delighted with the ruling, one of the first upholding the general philosophy under which Title VI could be used to deal with environmental inequities. That delight lasted only five days, however. On April 24, The U.S. Supreme Court issued its decision in the case of Alexander v. Sandoval, a case unrelated to environmental justice substantively (it dealt with the issuance of a driver’s license). In writing for the Court, Justice Antonin Scalia noted that “neither
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 71
as originally enacted nor as later amended does Title VI display an intent to create a free standing private right of action to enforce [these] regulations.” Scalia explicitly stated that neither section 601 nor section 602 of Title VI permits individuals to sue on the basis of disproportionate exposure to hazardous materials (Alexander v. Sandoval, 532 U.S. 275 [2001]). The Supreme Court’s decision has been devastating to the environmental justice movement. As one legal expert has observed, The effect of Justice Scalia’s decision in Sandoval is very profound. For over fifty years, Civil Rights advocates challenged agency decisions using § 602 [of Title VI]. There was extensive case law, which established that an implied private right of action existed under § 602. Furthermore, Justice Scalia indicated § 1983 may not be used to enforce a violation of § 602 because § 601 does not prohibit unintentional discrimination. The only way advocates can challenge agency decisions is to prove intentional discrimination. Requiring plaintiffs to prove intentional discrimination to substantiate disparate impact claims, without alternate legal mechanisms, will sound the death knell for the environmental justice movement (Zywicki 2002). Other activists are more sanguine. However dismal the situation may look at the federal level, state courts operating under state constitutions may be more receptive to claims for redress because of environmental inequities. In California, for example, recent changes in the law have made it permissible for individuals to sue state agencies to enforce state regulations. As one legal expert has written, such changes may mean that “California may soon emerge as the leader in the effective use of civil rights laws to address environmental inequities” (Rechtschaffen 2003).
The U.S. Congress Has Failed to Take Action on Basic Environmental Justice Legislation The first legislation dealing with environmental justice in the U.S. Congress was introduced by Rep. John Lewis (D-GA) in 1992. That bill was referred to the House Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment, but no action was ever taken. Lewis
72 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
reintroduced the bill in 1998, and it was referred to the Subcommittee on National Parks and Public Lands. Again, no action was taken. Similar legislation on environmental justice was introduced into later sessions of Congress, with similar bills appearing, in some cases, in both the House of Representatives and Senate. In no case did a bill ever get any further than being referred to some subcommittee of the House or Senate. After President Bill Clinton’s Executive Order 12898 of 1994, the purpose of these bills was to codify into law the provisions of the executive order. While members of the government bureaucracy are supposed to abide by the provisions of an executive order, they are not constrained to do so in the same way they would be by a law passed by Congress. Supporters of environmental justice have, therefore, argued for more than 15 years that Congress should pass a law to strengthen the requirements of Clinton’s executive order. A reading of the most recent versions of the environmental justice bills shows how similar they are to the executive order itself. Given that national legislators have clearly decided not to act on environmental justice bills, it appears that the movement cannot hope, for the foreseeable future, for support for its cause from the U.S. House or Senate. As noted above, advocates have decided, therefore, to look to state legislatures for such actions. A number of states have moved in this direction, with laws on environmental justice now having been passed in about a dozen states. These laws vary widely from state to state, with some establishing a complete set of environmental justice provisions similar to those found in Executive Order 12898 and others dealing with only a specific aspect of environmental justice. For example, the state of Oregon adopted new environmental justice legislation in 2007, which took effect on January 1, 2008, requiring all 14 state agencies that deal with natural resources to develop procedures that will increase the participation of citizens affected by agency actions. The law also created an environmental justice task force charged with advising the governor and natural resources agencies on environmental justice issues, with defining environmental justice issues in the state, with identifying minority and low-income communities that may be affected by environmental decisions made by the agencies, with meeting with environmental justice communities, and with making recommendations to the governor regarding concerns raised by these communities.
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 73
Other state laws are more limited. Mississippi, for example, has an “anti-concentration” law that prohibits the siting of more than one hazardous facility in any one county of the state. The law contains a loophole, however, as it allows a variance from this restriction if state needs change in such a way as to make the construction of more than one facility advantageous. Alabama and Georgia have similar anti-concentration laws. An example of some of the weakest environmental justice legislation is North Carolina’s law on the issuance of solid waste permits. The law requires a permitting agency to “consider” the most recent census data for an area in which a waste disposal site is to be located, but it gives no guidance as to how the agency is to use that data.
Environmental Justice Activists Have Learned to Use a Combination of Tools for Achieving Their Goals Any organization striving to eliminate environmental inequities will necessarily have to consider legal and administrative remedies for such situations. But given the poor record of federal legal and judicial bodies in responding to environmental justice claims, activists have long realized that they also need to explore other tools for reaching their objective. These tools include the intensive involvement of community members; reliance on experts in science, technology, the law, sociology, political science, and other fields; networking among social, civil rights, and environmental justice organizations; and the use of education and political pressure on decision makers. An example that illustrates the way environmental justice activists can use these tools is the Environmental Justice for Cleaning Workers Campaign (EJCWC) of the Massachusetts Coalition for Occupational Safety and Health (MassCOSH). MassCOSH is a nonprofit organization of workers, unions, community groups, and health and safety activists to organize and advocate for safe, secure jobs and healthy communities throughout eastern and central Massachusetts. The focus of the EJCWC is the health of more than 30,000 custodians and janitors who work in homes, commercial buildings, and a variety of public facilities throughout the commonwealth of Massachusetts. These workers wash and strip floors, clean toilets and other equipment, maintain and shine furniture, and carry out a variety of other tasks that require the use of
74 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
materials that may be irritating or hazardous to one’s health. According to some evidence, these materials may be implicated in high rates of asthma, bladder and prostate tumors, heart attack deaths, cancer of the lower urinary tract, chemical burns, stillbirths and preterm delivery, birth defects, and Down syndrome. The vast majority of cleaning workers in Massachusetts (as is the case throughout the country) are people of color and/or immigrants. These workers seldom have the education or experience that allows them to understand the hazards they face or to take action to remove such hazards from their workplace. MassCOSH has decided on a three-tier program to improve the working conditions for cleaning workers in Massachusetts. The first tier involves active participation by workers themselves to collect the information needed to document the hazards they face on the job. Tier two calls for organizing workers and supporters of EJCWC to promote safer working conditions. Tier three involves public advocacy among decision makers to replace hazardous working materials with green products that do not pose a health risk for workers. To achieve these goals, MassCOSH formed a partnership with other stakeholder organizations in Massachusetts, such as the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 615 and its nonprofit subsidiary, the Voice and Future Fund; the Boston School Custodial Union; the Boston Urban Asthma Coalition (BUAC); the Boston Urban Asthma Initiative; and Urban Edge and Viet AID, two local community development corporations. By following the above agenda, MassCOSH has achieved remarkable success in reducing the environmental hazards to which cleaning workers are exposed. Data collected from workers in 2004 have led some major public employers to change the way their facilities are cleaned. The contractor responsible for cleaning Logan International Airport, for example, has agreed to replace all hazardous cleaning materials with safer alternatives and to provide a display at the airport explaining to workers how the new materials are to be used. SEIU Local 615 has integrated health and safety materials into its training manual for shop stewards. And the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) has agreed to use green cleaning products in place of hazardous materials. In 2005, custodians in four of Boston’s public schools conducted a pilot program to study the effect on asthma rates among employees using green cleaning materials rather than traditional
The Current Status of the Environmental Justice Movement in the U.S. 75
cleaning supplies. As a result of that study, the Boston school system announced in 2006 that it would begin to change its cleaning procedures and start purchasing only green products in the future. Also in 2005, MassCOSH responded to a request from Urban Edge to analyze and reassess its cleaning program. Urban Edge is a community development corporation that works for the development of sustainable housing in the Jamaica Plains and Roxbury neighborhoods of Boston. The two entities were able to develop a new set of cleaning guidelines that replaced materials and practices hazardous to a worker’s health with green products that are safer to use. (For a copy of these guidelines, see http:// urbanedge.org/green-housing.php?subcode=Green%20 Cleaning.) The combined efforts of MassCOSH and its collaborators have demonstrated how proponents of environmental justice can bring about significant change, even absent the force of federal or state legislation and/or the power of judicial decisions. The battle of the Sokaogon Mole Lake Chippewa and Forest County Potawatomi Indian tribes in Wisconsin to prevent development of a zinc and copper mine near their land provides another illustration of imaginative ways in which environmental justice activists can achieve success in their efforts. The battle goes back to the 1970s, when the Exxon Corporation purchased more than 5,000 acres of land about 100 miles north of Green Bay. Over time, ownership changed hands a number of times, with Nicolet Mineral Company being the most recent owner. From the moment the mine was originally proposed, members of the two tribes expressed concerns about possible environmental effects on the health of their members. They feared that runoff from mining operations would contaminate the wild rice beds upon which they depend for an important part of their food supply. They also worried that wastes from the mine would pollute their water supplies and contaminate the air with particulates. For more than 25 years, however, the tribes were unsuccessful in deterring Nicolet and its predecessors from proceeding with plans for the mine—until October 2003. At that point, an extended period of bargaining between the two tribes and Northern Wisconsin Resources Group, the timber arm of Nicolet, concluded with an agreement to sell the 5,939-acre mine site, the mineral rights, and some associated timber rights to the two tribes for $16.5 million. About half of the money was to come from profits from a Potawatomi gaming casino near Milwaukee, and the rest from a loan to be obtained by the Mole Lake tribe.
76 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
When the deal was announced, representatives of the tribe also reported that they would immediately withdraw a pending application that had been filed by the Nicolet company for a permit to mine in the area. The tribes had finally resolved a very long controversy over operations they believed would threaten their health. “Buying off” a corporation whose activities pose an environmental risk is only one more approach to the resolution of environmental justice issues. Lacking access to administrative, legislative, and judicial venues for such cases, environmental justice activists are becoming increasingly skillful and effective in developing and using the tools that remain available to them to obtain relief from the problems they face.
References Amer, Mildred L. 2008. Women in the United States Congress: 1917–2008. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service. Updated May 7. Anderton, Douglas L., et al. 1994a. “Hazardous Waste Facilities: ‘Environmental Equity’ Issues in Metropolitan Areas.” Evaluation Review 18 (2): 123–140. Anderton, Douglas L., Andy B. Anderson, John Michael Oakes, and Michael R. Fraser. 1994b. “Environmental Equity: The Demographics of Dumping.” Demography 31:229–248. Anderton, Douglas L., John Michael Oakes, and Karla L. Eagan. 1996. “Methodological Issues in the Spatiotemporal Analysis of Environmental Equity.” Social Science Quarterly 77:508–515. Anderton, Douglas L., John Michael Oakes, and Karla L. Egan. 1997. “Environmental Equity in Superfund: Demographics of the Discovery and Prioritization of Abandoned Toxic Sites.” Evaluation Review 21 (1): 3–26. Austin, Regina, and Michael Schill. 1994. “Black, Brown, Red, and Poisoned.” The Humanist 54 (July/August): 9–16. Bailey, Conner, and Charles E. Faupel. 1992. “Environmentalism and Civil Rights in Sumter County, Alabama.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 11. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Been, Vicki. 1994. “Locally Undesirable Land Uses in Minority Neighborhoods: Disproportionate Siting or Market Dynamics?” Yale Law Review 103(6): 1383–1422.
References 77
Binkly, Gail. 2007 (November 8). “‘Economic Blackmail’ Fueling PowerPlant Push? ‘Big Coal’ Author Says Desert Rock Project Makes No Sense in Southwest.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08] Alpcentral. http://www.alpcentral.com/article.php?article_id=1948. Boerner, Christopher, and Thomas Lambert. 1995. “Environmental Justice Can Be Achieved through Negotiated Compensation.” In Environmental Justice, edited by J. S. Petrikin, chap. 7. San Diego: Greenhaven Press. Bonorris, Steven. 2004. Environmental Justice for All: A Fifty-State Survey of Legislation, Policies, and Initiatives. San Francisco: Hastings College of the Law, University of California. Bullard, Robert D. 1983. “Solid Waste Sites and the Black Houston Community.” Sociological Inquiry 53 (2–3): 273–288. Bullard, Robert D. 1992. “Environmental Blackmail in Minority Communities.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 6. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Bullard, Robert D. 1994. Worst Things First? The Debate over Risk-Based National Environmental Priorities. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future. Bullard, Robert D. 2000. Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class, and Environmental Quality, 3rd ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Bullard, Robert D., Paul Mohai, Robin Saha, and Beverly Wright. 2007. Toxic Wastes and Race at Twenty: A Report Prepared for the United Church of Christ Justice & Witness Ministries. Cleveland, OH: Justice and Witness Ministries, United Church of Christ. Buttel, Frederick R. 1987. “New Directions in Environmental Sociology.” Annual Review of Sociology 13:465–488. Davidson, Pamela, and Douglas L. Anderton. 2000. “Demographics of Dumping II: A National Environmental Equity Survey and the Distribution of Hazardous Materials Handlers.” Demography 37 (4): 461–466. Davis, M. E. 1977. “Occupational Hazards and Black Workers.” Urban Health 6 (August): 16–18. “Environmental Justice Executive Order [New Jersey].” 2004. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://www.state.nj.us/dep/ ej/ejeo.pdf. Featherstone, Liza. 2005 (August 1). “E-Raced: EPA Says Race, Income Shouldn’t Be Environmental Justice Factors.” Grist. [Online article or information; retrieved 6/19/08.] http://www.grist.org/news/maindish/ 2005/08/01/featherstone-ej/.
78 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
Gelobter, Michel. 1992. “Toward a Model of ‘Environmental Discrimination.’” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 5. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Gerrard, Michael B. 2003. “EPA Dismissal of Civil Rights Complaints.” New York Law Journal, November 28, 3+. Gianessi, Leonard P., Henry M. Peskin, and Edward Wolff. 1979. “The Distributional Effects of Uniform Air Pollution Policy in the United States.” Journal of Economics 93 (May): 281–301. Gogal, Daniel. 2008. Personal communication, April 29. Goldman, Benjamin A. 1993. Not Just Prosperity: Achieving Sustainability with Environmental Justice. Washington, DC: National Wildlife Federation. Hamilton, James T. 1993. “Politics and Social Cost: Estimating the Impact of Collective Action on Hazardous Waste Facilities.” RAND Journal of Economics 24 (Spring): 101–125. Infoplease. 2008 (June 19). “The Wage Gap, by Gender and Race.” [Online article or information; retrieved 6/19/08.] http://www.infoplease .com/ipa/A0882775.html. Johnson, F. Reed. 1980. “Income Distributional Effects of Air Pollution Abatement: A General Equilibrium Approach.” Atlantic Economic Journal 8 (4): 10–21. Jones, Robert Emmet, and Shirley A. Rainey. 2006. “Examining Linkages between Race, Environmental Concern, Health, and Justice in a Highly Polluted Community of Color.” Journal of Black Studies 36 (4): 473–496. Kazis, Richard, and Richard L. Grossman. 1982. Fear at Work: Job Blackmail, Labor, and the Environment. New York: Pilgrim Press. Lavelle, Marianne, and Marcia Coyle. 1993. “Unequal Protection: The Racial Divide in Environmental Law.” National Law Journal 21 (September): S1–S12. Louisiana Advisory Committee to the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. 1993. The Battle for Environmental Justice in Louisiana . . . Government, Industry, and the People. Kansas City, MO: U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Central Regional Office. Lowe, G. D., and T. K. Pinhey. 1982. “Rural-Urban Differences in Support for Environmental Protection.” Rural Sociology 47 (1): 114–128. Mohai, Paul. 2003. “Dispelling Old Myths: African American Concern for the Environment.” Environment Magazine 45 (June): 10–26. Mohai, Paul, and Bunyan Bryant. 1992. “Environmental Racism: Reviewing the Evidence.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental
References 79
Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 13. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. National Academy of Public Administration. 2002. Models for Change: Efforts by Four States to Address Environmental Justice. Washington, DC: National Academy of Public Administration. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. 2003. “Environmental Justice and DEC Permits. Summary of Commissioner Policy CP-29, Environmental Justice and Permitting.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://www.dec.ny.gov/public/36929.html. Latest Date Revised: March 19, 2003. Office of the Inspector General. Environmental Protection Agency. 2004. EPA Needs to Consistently Implement the Intent of the Executive Order on Environmental Justice. Washington, DC: Environmental Protection Agency. Office of the Inspector General. Environmental Protection Agency. 2006. EPA Needs to Conduct Environmental Justice Reviews of Its Programs, Policies, and Activities. Washington, DC: Environmental Protection Agency. Pace, David. 2005 (December 13). “AP: More Blacks Live with Pollution.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://hosted .ap.org/specials/interactives/archive/pollution/part1.html. Peter, Ellen M. 2001. “Implementing Environmental Justice: The New Agenda for California State Agencies.” Golden Gate University Law Review 31 (Spring): 529–591. Pierce, Margo. 2007 (April 8). “Equal Environmental Rights: Ending the Link between Poverty, Race and Pollution.” City Beat. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://citybeat.com/2007–04–18/cover .shtml. Probst, Kate. 1990. Hazardous Waste Sites and the Rural Poor: A Preliminary Assessment. Arlington, VA: Clean Sites, Inc. Rechtschaffen, Clifford. 2003. “Using California’s Anti-Discrimination Law to Remedy Environmental Injustice.” Environmental Justice Committee Newsletter, ABA Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities. http://www.abanet.org/irr/committees/environmental/ newsletter/dec03/Civilrights.html. Sayen, Jamie. 1995. “Obligatory Skepticism: The Environmental Movement’s Internal Enemy.” Earth Island Journal 10 (Spring). [Online article or information; retrieved May 28, 2008.] http://www.earthisland.org/ eijournal/new_articles.cfm?articleID=830&journalID=75. Taylor, Dorceta E. 1989. “Blacks and the Environment: Toward an Explanation of the Concern and Action Gap between Blacks and Whites.” Environment and Behavior 21 (March): 175–205.
80 Problems, Controversies, and Solutions
Toffolon-Weiss, Melissa, and J. Timmons Roberts. 2004. “Toxic Torts, Public Interest Law, and Environmental Justice: Evidence from Louisiana.” Law & Policy 26 (April): 259–287. U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. 2003. Not in My Backyard: Executive Order 12898 and Title VI as Tools for Achieving Environmental Justice. Washington, DC: U.S. Commission on Civil Rights. U.S. Congress. 1993. House. Committee on the Judiciary. Environmental Justice. Environmental Justice Hearings before the Subcommittee on Civil and Constitutional Rights, 103rd Congress, 1st sess., March 3 and 4. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 1992. Women, Minorities and People with Disabilities. Washington, DC: Environmental Protection Agency. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). “Environmental Justice.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://www.epa.gov/ compliance/environmentaljustice/. Updated February 5, 2008. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). “Environmental Justice Bibliography Database.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://cfpub.epa.gov/ejbib/. Updated June 18, 2006. U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO). 2005. Environmental Justice: EPA Should Devote More Attention to Environmental Justice When Developing Clean Air Rules. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Accountability Office. Whittaker, Matthew, Gary Segura, and Shaun Bowler. 2005. “Racial/Ethnic Group Attitudes toward Environmental Protection in California: Is ‘Environmentalism’ Still a White Phenomenon?” Political Research Quarterly 58 (3): 435–447. Zywicki, Michael. 2002. “Scalia Scalds Environmental Justice Movement.” Vermont Journal of Environmental Law 4 (October 10). [Editorial.] [Online article or information; retrieved 5/24/08.] http://www.vjel.org/ editorials/ED10033.html#ref20.
3 Worldwide Perspective
T
he environmental justice movement in the United States is premised on the belief that low-income and minority communities are exposed to a disproportionate share of the hazardous waste products (in one form or another) produced by the nation’s industries. Study after study conducted over the past three decades has demonstrated the validity of that premise. In recent years, a similar pattern on an international scale has become apparent. At least partly because of the globalization of business, raw materials and waste products now flow more freely than ever within and among countries and throughout the world. As a result of that process, low-income communities in developing countries around the world are increasingly exposed to the hazards involved in the production, consumption, and disposal of a seemingly limitless range of products, from pesticides and drugs to nuclear power plants and electricity generating facilities. This chapter considers some examples of environmental racism throughout the world, the special problems posed by global climate change and the need for sustainable communities, and the progress being made by environmental justice groups worldwide.
Environmental Inequities Worldwide As the U.S. example shows, environmental inequities can occur in any country, whether highly developed or still in its earliest stages of development. On an international scale, however, one overall pattern tends to predominate: Developed nations such as
81
82 Worldwide Perspective
the United States and members of the European Union tend to treat less-developed nations in much the same way that industries in the United States treat low-income and minority communities. That is, they place resource extraction facilities, garbage dumps, industrial plants, and other polluting operations in areas where residents are generally less able to object to the environmental insults associated with these operations. The following cases illustrate only a few of the ways in which this generally north-to-south environmental injustice has occurred in the past.
Mineral Extraction in Papua New Guinea One might easily think of the island of New Guinea as a somewhat backward region of spectacularly beautiful scenery having but little contact with the modern world. That picture is only partially accurate. The scenery is spectacular, containing a number of the rarest animal and plant species in the world, but modern industrialism has become an important part of Papuan culture. Starting in the 1950s, the Australian government (which then governed Papua) sold mining rights on the island to multinational corporations with no input from local citizens or their leaders and essentially no concerns about possible deleterious impacts on the local environment or residents’ health and welfare. When Papua New Guinea (PNG) achieved its independence in 1975, the new government continued that practice. As a desperately poor nation, PNG saw resource extraction as a critical way of attracting foreign investment in the young country. As is sometimes the case, mining companies paid relatively little attention to laws and regulations relating to environmental protections. Indeed, the PNG government even exempted some corporations from its own environmental laws, accepting environmental impact statements written by the companies as being more “suitable” than those of its own government agencies. One of the most notorious cases of environmental injustice in PNG involved a mine at Ok Tedi, near the mouth of the Fly River, that belonged to the Australian corporation BHP-Billiton. For the two decades during which it operated, the mine produced an average each day of about 80,000 tons of tailings containing copper, zinc, cadmium, and lead, all toxic to plant and animal life (Marshall 2002). Before long, the mine’s toxic wastes had decimated plant and animal life along the Fly River. For
Environmental Inequities Worldwide 83
residents of the region, the most serious problem was the loss of the abundant fish population, which formed a major part of their diet. But one study showed that, beyond the loss of fish, “[a] decline in the turtle population has also been seen as the sandy banks where eggs were laid have been replaced by particulate copper and mud. Prawns, lobsters, and bivalves have also declined, and birds that depend on riverine life (egrets, kingfishers, Brahmin kites) have also left. The water is no longer safe for bathing, washing clothes, swimming, or drinking” (Johnston 1994, 92). Over time, the potential liabilities for BHP continued to grow until, in January 2002, it negotiated a deal with PNG to sell the mine to the government. In return, the government was to indemnify the company against all future claims. As a result of that agreement, BHP was able to exit PNG facing no liabilities for its actions in the country. The government took over ownership of the mine, which it decided to keep operating for at least a decade because of its enormous potential for income. And the people of PNG, who had already suffered severely from environmental degradation, faced another 10 years of mine operation with its consequent destruction of their lands. Throughout this sordid affair, evidence accumulated revealing PNG governmental and BHP corporate dismissive attitudes toward indigenous peoples of the nation. They were apparently heard to comment that those people were not intelligent enough to understand what was going on in their land or to make decisions about how the land was to be used. As the sale of the mine was concluded, one representative of the PNG Environmental Law Centre said: “Based on my conversations with the local people, it is quite clear that in my opinion the people who are signing this agreement do not know what they are signing” (Marshall 2002). Perhaps not, but they had another decade to live with its consequences.
Environmental Discrimination against the Roma in Central Europe Discussions of environmental inequities around the world often focus on obvious candidate countries in Africa, South America, and parts of Asia. But environmental discrimination also occurs in regions more commonly thought of as “developed” or “advanced.” For example, many countries in Central and Eastern
84 Worldwide Perspective
Europe, some of which were part of the former Soviet bloc, have made impressive economic progress since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991. Still, as in the United States, it is not difficult to find examples of environmental racism in the most highly developed nations. One recurring example involves the Roma (or Romany), also known as gypsies, who occupy most of Central Europe. Historically, the Roma have been subjected to widespread and aggressive discrimination in almost every nation they inhabit. In recent decades, that discrimination has shown up over and over again in the form of environmental racism. A common theme appears in most of these cases: A company or local government seeks a site for a new factory, municipal waste dump, or other potentially hazardous entity. Because land on which the Roma live is often the least expensive and least desirable for residential purposes, it is often selected for the new facility. Roma are moved out of the area or, more commonly, allowed to remain on land immediately adjacent to the facility. Over succeeding years, a variety of health problems develop among the Roma who are exposed to the hazardous facility. These problems are exacerbated because often the only jobs available to Roma workers are at the same hazardous facility. For example, scientists have studied in some detail a case in Heves, Hungary, where a primary source of income for Roma men was the recycling of lead taken from batteries in an illegal dump near their homes. Eventually, more than 1,500 individuals were exposed to high levels of lead, one 15-month-old girl died, and 65 children were hospitalized (Steger 2007, 21). The situation for Roma in Romania is no better. A recent report by the Central European University Center for Environmental Policy and Law, the Health and Environment Alliance, and the Coalition for Environmental Justice listed a number of instances in which Roma were relocated by local, regional, and federal governments into areas where they would be exposed to disproportionately high levels of toxic emissions. The town of Episcopia Bihor, for example, relocated its Roma community to a new settlement that was built on top of the town’s municipal rubbish dump. Under such circumstances, an epidemic of health problems is almost guaranteed. In some parts of Central Europe—Hungary, for example—Roma have a life expectancy 10 to 15 years less than comparable non-Roma populations (Steger 2007, 25–26).
Environmental Inequities Worldwide 85
Ecotourism and the Maasai Instances of environmental injustice sometimes arise in the most unlikely of situations. Consider the Maasai (or Masai) tribe that once populated wide stretches of East Africa. The Maasai are transhumance pastoralists, a term referring to a population that moves about the countryside annually with its animals, constantly looking for new grazing grounds and permitting overgrazed areas to recover. With the arrival of British colonists in East Africa in the early 20th century, the Maasai were restricted to ever-smaller areas on which to live. The British saw the Maasai as a “nuisance” and negotiated more and more restrictive treaties limiting their movement to smaller and smaller regions (Narimatsu 2008). This pattern continued throughout the 20th century, even after the replacement of British rulers by native governments beginning in the 1960s. Most young African governments realized early on the potential value of safari travel, ecotourism, and other travel experiences that emphasized the enormous natural wonders of their nations. The government of Kenya, for example, established a goal of hosting 1 million tourists by the year 1990. One element in such programs was the creation of new national parks, a goal that, in turn, required governments to even further restrict the Maasai. Ironically, then, the effort of African governments to save endangered species such as the tiger, lion, rhinoceros, and hippopotamus resulted in severely changing the lifestyle of one of the continent’s indigenous peoples. In their view, “The Maasai people have been systematically driven off our traditional lands in the wake of economic development, irresponsible tourism, large-scale farming, and other activities that destroy wildlife habitat” (Maasai Environmental Resource Coalition 2008). For almost a century, the Maasai were essentially pawns in the economic and environmental policies of, first, the British colonists and, later, native African governments in Kenya, Tanganyika, and other East African countries. They had little experience and few tools for dealing with the more sophisticated European and native governments. Toward the end of the 20th century, however, the Maasai began to better understand the options available to them in protecting their traditional culture and
86 Worldwide Perspective
began organizing to make their needs and wishes known. Maasai activists have now organized into an umbrella organization known as the Maasai Environmental Resource Coalition, consisting of about a dozen local groups. These groups include the Aramat Association, Arusha Women’s Group, and Ilkisongo Maasai Cultural Organization of Tanzania; the Enkong’u Narok Cultural Center, Kajiado Integral Rural Association for Development, Maasai Mara Women’s Group, and Olchorro-Oirowua Wildlife Conservation Association of Kenya; and the Maasai Cultural, Wildlife and Ethical Tourism Society of Kenya and Tanzania. The mission of the organization is to protect traditional land rights of the Maasai people and to help conserve, manage, and develop sustainable use systems for the ecosystems of East Africa.
The Bakun Hydroelectric Project in Sarawak In the most egregious examples of environmental racism, human populations are sometimes treated as disposable commodities to be relocated and moved around without regard to their own culture, traditions, lifestyles, and best interests. A striking example of that policy can be found in plans for building the Bakun hydroelectric facility in the Malaysian state of Sarawak on the island of Borneo. The earliest studies for such a facility began in the 1960s and were approved by the Malaysian government in 1986. Four years later, however, the government changed its mind and put construction plans on hold. In 1993, plans for the dam were revived, and a no-bid contract was signed with Ekran Berhad, a close friend of then–prime minister Mahathir Mohammad. Those plans called for the flooding of an area of about 270 square miles (about the size of the island of Singapore) at a cost of about $6 billion by the year 2003. Construction would require the removal of about 9,000 indigenous people, members of the Iban, Dayak, and Bidayuh tribes. These peoples have traditionally practiced subsistence agriculture, depending on the forest for most of their food, housing, clothing, and other needs. The area to be flooded was also home to one of the largest collections of threatened and endangered species of plants and animals in the world (Friends of the Earth 1996; Malaysian Timber Council 2002). The dam project was halted a second time in 1997, this time because of the widespread Asian financial crisis and reduced estimates of the amount of electricity needed in Malaysia. Studies
Environmental Inequities Worldwide 87
showed that energy consumption in the whole state of Sarawak was about 500 megawatts and that generating facilities already in operation were producing 700 megawatts. In addition, experts predicted that existing facilities could be expanded to produce about 1,000 megawatts. Other studies showed that energy use in Sarawak was expected to decline from 9.8 percent in 2000 to 5.6 percent in 2010. Under those circumstances, it was no longer clear that the Bakun dam was needed. Nonetheless, plans for the dam were revived yet again in May 2000 with a new completion date of 2010. Statistics associated with the project are impressive. The dam will be the tallest concrete-faced rockfill dam in the world, capturing the largest lake in Malaysia by storage volume and producing the largest amount of electric power of any station in the country. In addition, the submarine cable that carries power from Sarawak to the Malaysian peninsula will be the longest in the world. The required displacement of indigenous peoples has now been completed. Most of them have been relocated to a longhouse settlement in Bakun, a dramatically different lifestyle than the one with which they are familiar. Jobs at the dam that were promised them have largely not materialized, and unemployment rates are very high among the tribespeople. The deportees are expected to pay up to $15,000 for the new housing they are being provided, although such sums are essentially unimaginable to people who had previously had virtually no experience with money. Unlike some environmental justice stories, the Bakun dam saga appears to have no happy ending associated with it. The Iban, Dayak, and Bidayuh have lost their traditional homes to a giant modern industrial project.
Thor Chemicals and Mercury “Recycling” Historians of the international environmental justice movement sometimes point to the Thor case as one of the first events to attract worldwide attention. It began in 1988, when the British company Thor Chemicals moved its mercury reprocessing operations from Margate, in Kent, England, to the small industrial village of Cato-Ridge in the South African province of Kwazulu-Natal. Thor’s decision to move from England to South Africa was occasioned by concerns raised by the British government’s Health and Safety Executive about excessive levels of mercury in the air around the Margate facility and in the urine of workers employed
88 Worldwide Perspective
at the plant. Thor was aware that environmental protections in South Africa were less stringent than in the United Kingdom and that continued operation of the plant was possible only if the move was made. The new Thor plant in Cato-Ridge soon drew the attention of manufacturers around the world. It was one of the few facilities worldwide willing and able to accept wastes containing mercury for reprocessing. Two of the largest contributors to the Thor recycling program were the American companies Borden Chemicals and Plastics and American Cyanamid. In a 1999 report, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) said that the two companies were shipping about 190 tons of mercury-containing wastes annually to the Cato-Ridge facility (Fondaw 2008). Evidence of the harmful effects of the mercury reprocessing facility began to appear shortly after the plant began operations. Water samples taken from the Mngeweni River, into which Thor discharged its wastes, contained 1.5 million parts per billion (ppb) of mercury, 1,500 times greater than the current EPA recommended limit for mercury in water. The river is the main source of drinking water for the city of Durban (current population: 3.5 million) and the primary source of water for the region’s agricultural and dairy industries. Even 40 miles downstream from the plant mercury levels reached 20 times the EPA recommended limits. The South African government did not appear to be unduly concerned about the potential health hazards posed by the Thor plant. It ordered a four-week closure to permit the plant to clean up its operations, then issued a new license to the facility. In 1994, the Department of Environmental Affairs sent a secret memo to the South African cabinet praising Thor’s “sensible operations” and commending its “sound work” (Cook and Koch 1992, 9). The situation at Cato-Ridge first drew international attention in 1990, when the St. Louis Post-Dispatch conducted a study of hazardous waste disposal policies and practices in the United States. The paper traced the link from Borden Chemicals and American Cyanamid to Thor and followed up with an extensive report on conditions in and around the Thor plant. Its story soon attracted the attention of environmental groups, particularly Earthlife Africa and Greenpeace International, which began their own investigations of Thor and of the South African government’s “cozy” relationship with the company. Almost simultane-
Environmental Inequities Worldwide 89
ously, reports of the first deaths of workers at the Thor plant began to surface. According to one report, workers at the Thor plant had mercury levels as high as 600 to 1,000 ppb in their urine, compared to generally accepted limits of 50 ppb. As more and more information about Thor’s operations became available, a number of individuals began filing suits for damage as a result of their employment at the Cato-Ridge facility. The company settled out of court for a total of $2.1 million for 20 such claims in 1997 and then again in 2000 for a total of $353,000 for an additional 20 employees. In 1992, the company announced that the plant would cease operations as of 1996. In 2000, the South African government invited experts from the EPA to visit the Thor site and recommend procedures for cleaning it up (Knight 2001).
The Voyage of the Khian Sea Arguably, the most famous example of the use of developing nations for the disposal of hazardous wastes involves the voyage of the freighter Khian Sea, which was attempting to dispose of about 14,000 tons of ash from a municipal incinerator in the city of Philadelphia’s Roxborough neighborhood. The incinerator, like most municipal incinerators, burned household wastes consisting of everything from newspapers and garbage to cigarettes and dead batteries. Lacking space within the city limits to dispose of incinerator ash, Philadelphia contracted with outlying areas (primarily in New Jersey) to accept its wastes. Although the materials burned in the Roxborough incinerator were relatively benign products of home and municipal use, the ashes that resulted were not. They contained by-products such as dioxins, furans, cadmium, and lead, considered to be toxic, teratogenic, carcinogenic, or otherwise hazardous to human health. In 1984, the state of New Jersey informed authorities in Philadelphia that it would no longer accept the city’s incinerator ash for disposal. Instead, the city contracted with the firm Paolino and Sons, Amalgamated Shipping and Coastal Carrier, to dispose of the ash. Paolino’s original intent was to dispose of the wastes on a manmade island in the Bahamas—except that the Bahamian government denied the company a permit to unload its cargo on the island. Over the next year, the Khian Sea roamed the Caribbean looking for a place to dispose of the ash. Between September 1986 and August 1987, it was turned away from Bermuda,
90 Worldwide Perspective
the Dominican Republic, Honduras, Guinea-Bissau, and the Netherlands Antilles. Efforts were then made to convince the Panamanian government to accept the ash for use in roadbuilding in Panama, an offer that was refused (Schwartz 2000). On December 31, 1987, the Khian Sea arrived in Haiti and obtained a permit from the government to unload a portion of its cargo, described to officials as “fertilizer.” Between January 20 and January 31, the ship offloaded 4,000 tons of the ash, only to be interrupted by an order from the Haitian government to reload its cargo and return to sea. The Khian Sea did return to sea, but without reloading the ash it had already left on Gonaives beach. After a brief return to Philadelphia in February 1988, the Khian Sea set off once more to find a dumping ground for the remaining ash in its hold. Over the next six months, it was refused permission to unload its cargo in Morocco, Senegal, Sri Lanka, and Yugoslavia, where it put in for repairs in August 1988. When it was escorted from the country by the Yugoslav navy, it had a new name—the Felicia—and a new country of registry—Honduras. Before long, its name was changed once more, this time to the Pelecano. On September 28, 1988, it passed through the Suez Canal, listing Singapore as its destination. By the time the Khian Sea/Felicia/Pelecano reached Singapore in November 1988, the troublesome ash cargo had disappeared. The captain later admitted that the ash had been dumped into the Indian and Atlantic oceans on the way from North America to the Pacific. In 1993, William P. Reilly and John Patrick Dowd, officers of Coastal Carriers Inc., which operated the Khian Sea, were convicted of perjury in the United States and sentenced to jail. No convictions were ever obtained for the dumping of ash in Haiti or on the open seas. In 1997, a coalition of the Greenpeace environmental organization and Haitian environmental groups joined to form the Return to Sender project, aimed at having Philadelphia’s hazardous ash removed from Gonaives beach. The project was eventually able to obtain funds from the city of Philadelphia to hire Waste Management, Inc. (WMI), to complete that task. In April 2000, WMI began the work and eventually removed the remaining 2,500 tons of waste to a docking point in Florida’s St. Lucie Canal. After resting at that location for two years, the ash was returned to its final burying ground in Franklin County, Pennsylvania, by WMI in June 2002 (Greenpeace 2008).
A Background for the Transboundary Dumping of Hazardous Wastes 91
A Background for the Transboundary Dumping of Hazardous Wastes The case studies presented here may strike an observer as examples of horrible disregard for the health and lives of people in less-developed countries (LDCs) by uncaring corporations and upscale consumers in more-developed countries (MDCs). Although that assessment may be correct in some ways, it ignores developments in MDCs such as the United States that made these environmental injustice examples not only possible but perhaps inevitable. One of the important but unexpected consequences of the American environmental movement of the 1960s and 1970s was that the United States began to adopt laws and regulations far more severe than those of most other nations of the world, certainly more restrictive than those of less-developed nations. Pesticides that could no longer be used in the United States because of their toxicity were, in many cases, still legal in other nations. Companies that could no longer sell their products to American farmers because of their toxicity might well be able to sell them to farmers in Indonesia, Ghana, Somalia, and other struggling nations (Norris 1982). Such practices could be thought of as just another form of environmental inequity, and perhaps environmental racism, but on a much grander scale. During the late 1980s and early 1990s, a number of waste disposal problems made this analogy even more obvious. In 1988, for example, the city of Philadelphia hired a Norwegian company, Bulkhandling, Inc., to transport 15,000 tons of toxic incinerator ash to Kassa Island, part of the African nation of Guinea. Only when plant and animal life began to die off on the island did the government discover what had happened and ordered Bulkhandling to remove and return the ash to Philadelphia (Mpanya 1992). As permits and land for hazardous waste landfills on the continental United States became more and more difficult to obtain, dumping in African nations became more and more attractive. The number of such cases increased by a factor of 10 in the three-year period between 1987 and 1989, rising from 3 cases in 3 countries in the first of these years to 40 cases in 25 nations in 1989 (Mpanya 1992).
92 Worldwide Perspective
As with possible cases of environmental racism in the United States, such practices often make good economic sense: They provide an answer to a difficult corporate problem (waste disposal) while bringing significant economic benefit to people who need it (poor African nations). In fact, this argument in a slightly different context was made by Lawrence Summers, chief economist of the World Bank, in a memo of December 12, 1991. The memo was obtained by and then reprinted in the British journal The Economist in its February 8, 1992, issue. “Just between you and me,” Summers wrote, “shouldn’t the World Bank be encouraging more migration of the dirty industries to the LDCs?” (The real author of the now infamous “Summers memo” was apparently one of his aides, Lant Pritchett, a longtime employee of the World Bank and, as of 2008, professor of economics at Harvard University [Wade 1997, 712].) The Summers memo presented three reasons for this recommendation. First, it argued that the cost of illness and death resulting from pollution is essentially a measure of lost earnings from these conditions. Since wages are lowest in LDCs, the economic cost of exposure to pollution is lowest in those countries. Second, the memo suggested that the cost of pollution is nonlinear. That is, as the amount of pollution increases, the economic costs it produces grow geometrically. The countries best able to absorb the initial costs of pollution problems, then, are those that already have very little pollution, the LDCs. The writer of the memo said specifically, “I’ve always thought that under-populated countries in Africa are vastly UNDERpolluted, their air quality is probably vastly inefficiently low compared to Los Angeles or Mexico City” (Whirled Bank Group 2008). Finally, the memo writer said that people living in LDCs probably do not view exposure to pollution in the same way as do people in MDCs. In the latter, people live relatively long lives, during the latter parts of which they develop a number of diseases that eventually cause their deaths, such as prostate cancer. But people who live in LDCs tend to have much shorter life spans. They are, therefore, less likely to worry about late-life diseases and more likely to appreciate the benefits of an enhanced income early in their lives, even if it means exposure to potentially toxic or hazardous materials. As an adjunct to this point, the memo writer pointed out that complaints about pollution often refer to “visibility impairing particulates” that may be
A Background for the Transboundary Dumping of Hazardous Wastes 93
aesthetically displeasing but that “may have very little direct health impact” (Whirled Bank Group 2008). The Summers memo is hardly the only expression of support for the shipment of hazardous wastes from MDCs to LDCs. For example, in a 1995 book for young adults presenting a variety of viewpoints on environmental justice, Harvey Alter, manager of the Resources Policy Department of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, argued for a more liberal view of such trade. Humanitarian instincts, he said, prompt us to want to cut back on our trade in hazardous wastes, but the long-term effect of bans on such trade would be disastrous for underdeveloped countries because it brings very poor nations a dependable and significant source of income, thereby improving the lives of their citizens. The net effect of efforts to ban trade in hazardous wastes, he said, would be to make poverty in developing nations an even more serious problem and, at the same time, to increase the severity of the environmental problems nations are trying to solve (Alter 1995). Alter and the Chamber of Commerce have also promoted this view of trade on the international stage. During early discussions over the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal (the so-called “Basel Convention”; see below for more detail), Alter and the chamber argued vigorously against a proposed ban on all shipment of waste materials between Organisation for Economic Development and Co-operation (OECD) states and nonOECD nations. In fact, some observers have credited Alter and the chamber with effectively scuttling U.S. efforts to ratify the treaty (which it still has not done as of late 2008), thus preventing implementation of this aspect of the convention (Clapp 2001, 75–76).
The Basel Convention In spite of the views of Larry Summers (and/or his aides), Harvey Alter and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and like-minded individuals and groups, concerns about the deleterious effects of international trade in hazardous wastes grew throughout the 1980s. That concern culminated in the adoption in 1989 of the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal, also known simply as the Basel Convention. The Basel Convention was signed in Basel,
94 Worldwide Perspective
Switzerland, on March 22, 1989. It was an agreement among 103 nations establishing certain requirements for the shipment of hazardous wastes between nations. In particular, it required that a nation desiring to ship hazardous wastes to a second nation notify that nation of its intent and that the receiving nation acknowledge its willingness and consent to receive the shipment. The Basel treaty arose, in a general sense, as the result of two major changes in the disposal of hazardous wastes. The first change was the accumulation of new environmental legislation in many developed countries limiting or restricting the production, use, and disposal of toxic and hazardous materials. Industries in the United States, European Union, Canada, Australia, and other developed countries that had previously discarded their hazardous wastes in the ground, in lakes and rivers, in the oceans, or into the air could no longer use those methods of disposal. They found it necessary to ship their wastes to other parts of the world, to nations that had not yet developed stringent environmental legislation. In addition, the technical means for making such transfers became much more sophisticated, so that a U.S. industrial facility could rather easily package its wastes for shipment to almost any part of the world. Within this general milieu, however, was a series of specific incidents involving the transfer of hazardous wastes from MDCs to LDCs that provided the impetus for the meetings that led to the Basel Convention. Perhaps the best known of these incidents was the long voyage of the freighter Khian Sea, described previously. A number of other similar events, however, contributed to a growing international concern about the problem of hazardous waste transfers across national boundaries. As with many international agreements, the Basel treaty had a long gestation period. The first formal step in the development of an international agreement about trade in hazardous wastes occurred in May 1981, when the governing council of the UN Environmental Programme (UNEP), meeting in Montevideo, Uruguay, appointed the Ad Hoc Committee of Legal Experts to review the problem of international trade in hazardous wastes. The committee recommended the appointment of a working group to develop policies and plans for the handling, transport, and disposal of hazardous wastes. More than six years later, the governing council of UNEP accepted a report of the working group (known as the Cairo Guidelines) and authorized the appointment of a new working group to begin planning for an international convention on the
A Background for the Transboundary Dumping of Hazardous Wastes 95
international movement of hazardous wastes. The first steps in planning for that convention were a series of organizational meetings involving experts from 96 nations and 50 organizations held in Budapest, Hungary; Geneva (twice); Caracas, Venezuela; Luxembourg; and Basel. These organizational meetings, in turn, led finally to the Basel Convention itself, held in the Swiss city of that name in March 1989. The Basel Convention met with mixed success. On the one hand, 35 individual nations and the European Community did sign the convention. But a number of important states, most prominently, the United States, refused to sign. The U.S. government strongly opposed any ban on the shipment of hazardous waste to developing nations even though those nations themselves strongly supported such a ban. In the end, no African government signed the convention either. The most prominent nongovernmental environmental group present at the meeting, Greenpeace International, walked out of the final meetings, claiming that the convention had become an “instrument of legalization of waste trade [because it failed] to ban even the most immoral and environmentally damaging waste trade” (Basel Action Network 2008). As with all international treaties, signings and ratifications continued over many years. In May 1992, the convention entered into force when Australia became the 20th nation to ratify the treaty. As of late 2008, 170 nations had signed the Basel Convention, and all but a handful had also ratified the treaty. The current holdouts are Afghanistan, Haiti, and the United States. Authorities have offered a number of reasons for the unwillingness of the United States to sign the amended Basel treaty, but some believe that companies interested in continuing the trade in hazardous wastes have had an important influence on the government’s decision. In the view of Jim Pluckett, coordinator of the Basel Action Network, for example, “the United States position on this important moral and environmental question has been dictated by a very small sector of the business community. This special interest lobby wishes to maintain a free trade in toxic wastes so that they can export their pollution problems to dubious, dangerous and dirty recycling operations in developing countries” (Center for International Environmental Law 2001). Reasons for the failure of Afghanistan and Haiti to sign the Basel treaty are not clear, although the disorganized state of both national governments over the past decade or more may well be a factor.
96 Worldwide Perspective
Other Treaties and Bans Perceived deficiencies in the final Basel treaty of 1989 were serious enough that a handful of the 116 nations attending the convention refused to sign the final agreement and walked out of the meetings before they were adjourned. Feelings ran highest among African nations, which were angry that actual bans on the trade of hazardous wastes were not instituted. These nations decided to conduct a series of their own meetings on the trade in hazardous wastes. Those meetings eventually led to a number of other agreements. The first such agreement was negotiated in 1989 as part of a series of treaties between the European Union (EU) and 71 African, Caribbean, and Pacific (ACP) nations. These treaties are known as the Lomé Conventions, after the capital city of Togo, where most of the meetings were conducted. Lomé IV, concluded in December 1989, contained provisions severely limiting the shipment of hazardous wastes from the EU to any ACP country without that country’s express permission. Three other international agreements were signed in the next two years. The first was concluded in October 1990 at a meeting in Trinidad and Tobago of environment ministers from Latin America and the Caribbean. A second agreement was signed two months later by presidents of Central American countries. And the third treaty—the Bamako Convention—was adopted in January 1991, when 12 African nations meeting under the auspices of the Organization of African Unity (OAU) agreed to prohibit imports of hazardous wastes to the African continent. Meanwhile, individual nations and regional groups had begun to pass legislation and adopt regulations related to the transboundary shipment of hazardous wastes. On February 1, 1993, for example, the EU adopted Shipping Regulation 259/93, which banned the shipment of hazardous wastes from EU member states to any country other than those that are members of the European Free Trade Association (EFTA). That ban became effective on May 1, 1994 (European Economic Community 2008). Similar bans on the shipment of hazardous wastes were recommended and/or adopted later in the same year by other regional groups: the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) in September, members of the Convention for the Protection of the Mediterranean Sea against Pollution (the so-called Barcelona Convention) in October, and attendees at a meeting of the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean
Environmental Justice and Climate Change 97
(ECLAC) in November. By the end of 1993, more than 100 nations had also adopted bans on the exportation and/or importation of hazardous wastes into and/or out of their own countries under at least some circumstances (Basel Action Network 2008). Adoption of the Basel Convention has by no means solved the problem of the transboundary shipment of hazardous wastes. The original treaty was somewhat vague in many respects, and a number of meetings were held to clarify the meanings of terms and to develop clear and strong bans against the shipment of hazardous wastes to developing countries. In September 1995, the third conference of the Parties to the Basel Convention meeting in Geneva adopted an amendment to the treaty intent on clarifying and strengthening the original document’s stand on hazardous wastes. A group of developed countries, including Australia, Canada, Japan, New Zealand, South Korea, and the United States, opposed the amendment, so other members of the convention decided to go ahead without the support of these nations. The conference adopted the amendment with specific reference to the group of nations most strongly in agreement with its intent: the EU, the OECD, and the principality of Liechtenstein (Basel Convention 2008). As of late 2008, 63 nations have ratified the ban amendment. As noted above, the United States has still not ratified either the original Basel Convention or the ban amendment. Although many government officials, politicians, experts, and ordinary citizens in the country do subscribe to the philosophy that developed nations should not dump their hazardous wastes in developing nations, the federal government has not yet become a formal member of the international organization espousing and acting on that view.
Environmental Justice and Climate Change Individuals and groups interested in environmental justice on both a national and an international scale have recently turned their attention to a new facet of the problem: global climate change. Since the 1970s, evidence has been collecting to indicate that the world’s average annual temperature is rising. Most experts agree that the primary reason for this change is the release of carbon dioxide and other so-called greenhouse gases produced by human activities that trap heat reflected from the Earth’s surface. Increases in Earth’s average annual temperature,
98 Worldwide Perspective
most experts believe, are likely to result in a number of significant changes in the planet’s surface characteristics, such as melting of glaciers, ice sheets, and other accumulations of ice, as well as a significant warming of the oceans. These changes, in turn, may produce dramatic effects on human civilizations, such as drowning of coastal cities and some low-lying islands; changes in precipitation and local temperature patterns; alterations in the distribution of natural plant and animal species; changes in disease patterns among humans, other animals, and plants; and new patterns of severe storm systems, such as hurricanes, typhoons, cyclones, and tornadoes. In 2007, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) released its most recent report on these changes (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change 2007a). It concluded, as in earlier reports, that some aspects of climate change are well documented and virtually beyond dispute (such as changes in global temperature patterns), that other data are generally accepted, although legitimate disputes still exist as to their significance (such as the causes of temperature change), and that still other conclusions about climate change are subject to considerable disagreement and dispute (such as possible effects on the human and natural environment of temperature changes). Some of the most pessimistic commentators predict very troubling consequences of global climate change. A 2008 report by Cable News Network highlighted some of these predictions. The report warned that • more than a billion people worldwide will face water shortages because of the melting ice pack; • about a billion people will lose their livelihoods because of desertification of their lands; • more than 200 million people will become refugees because of rising sea levels, erosion, and loss of agricultural lands; • in one country alone, Bangladesh, about 17 million people could lose their homes because of flooding and severe storms; • the number of Africans at risk for malaria will increase by more than 60 million if temperatures rise by 2°C; and • more than 180 million residents of sub-Saharan Africa could die of diseases “directly attributable” to climate change. (Oliver 2008)
Environmental Justice and Climate Change 99
Nearly all aspects of the global climate change problem have strong racist and classist elements. In December 2006, Oxford University professor J. Timmons Roberts and Bradley C. Parks of the Millennium Challenge Corporation in Washington, D.C., published a thorough-going analysis of this problem in their book, A Climate of Injustice: Global Inequality, North-South Politics, and Climate Policy (Roberts and Parks 2006). They showed that, although the richest nations in the world produce more than 60 percent of all greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere, developing nations face by far the greatest risk of damages caused by climate change. A number of factors contribute to the greater risk faced by poor people and people of color throughout the world as a result of climate change. One factor is simply geographical location. Many of the areas most likely to be affected by rising ocean levels are occupied by people of color: the low-lying regions of the Indian subcontinent and many small Pacific islands. Among the first communities of color to be threatened by rising ocean levels are likely to be those residents of small island nations, such as Kiribati, the Maldives, Nauru, Tuvalu, and Vanuatu. Some of these island nations are no more than a few meters in elevation at their highest points, and residents may have no choice other than to abandon their homelands to avoid being swamped by the ocean. In fact, the first population to have been relocated as a result of rising ocean waters was probably the residents of the village of Lateu, on Vanuatu, who were evicted from their homes in December 2005 because of the risk of rising tides (Environment News Service 2005). Similarly, populations living in coastal regions in East Asia (almost exclusively communities of color) are at high risk from more frequent and severe storms, such as cyclones that strike the area every year. The devastating cyclone that hit the Irrawaddy River delta of Myanmar (formerly Burma) on May 9, 2008, underlines the problems faced by people who are already poor when they are the victims of a severe storm. When even their own national government refused aid from other nations, these people suffered death, injury, and disease not only from the direct effect of winds and water but also from the loss of access to food, clean water, clothing, shelter, and medicine, some of which were lacking in their lives even before the cyclone struck. Some of the specific consequences resulting from climate change predicted by the IPCC in its 2007 report are as follows:
100 Worldwide Perspective
• Between 75 million and 250 million people will be exposed to increased water stress due to climate change by the year 2020. • In some countries, yields from rain-dependent crops could be reduced by up to 50 percent. • Climate change will intensify already severe pressure on populations in all parts of Asia as a result of urbanization, industrialization, and economic development. • The populations of eastern, southern, and southeastern Asia will face the threat of endemic morbidity and mortality as a result of increased diarrheal diseases associated primarily with floods and droughts. • Extensive tropical forests in central South America will gradually convert to savannahs, and semi-arid regions will convert to arid land as the result of significant decreases in annual rainfall and increases in temperature. (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change 2007b) Over the last decade, a number of environmental justice groups have begun to stress the environmental justice aspects of the climate change problem, referring in many cases to a campaign for “climate justice.” One of the most important of these efforts was a statement of general principles adopted in August 2002 by a group of organizations meeting during the 2002 Earth Summit conference of the UN Environment Programme in Johannesburg, South Africa. In all, 14 organizations—CorpWatch, US; Friends of the Earth International; Global Resistance; Greenpeace International; Groundwork, South Africa; the Indigenous Environmental Network; Indigenous Information Network, Kenya; the National Alliance of People’s Movements of India; National Fishworkers Forum, India; Oilwatch Africa; OilWatch International; Southwest Network for Environmental and Economic Justice, US; Third World Network, Malaysia; and World Rainforest Movement, Uruguay—signed the agreement, now known as the Bali Principles of Climate Justice. The statement was developed using Environmental Justice Principles adopted at the People of Color Environmental Justice Leadership Summit held in Washington, D.C., in 1991 as a blueprint. Among the principles enunciated in the statement are demands that: • “governments are responsible for addressing climate change in a manner that is both democratically account-
Environmental Justice and Climate Change 101
•
•
•
•
•
•
able to their people and in accordance with the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities”; “communities, particularly affected communities[,] play a leading role in national and international processes to address climate change”; “fossil fuel and extractive industries be held strictly liable for all past and current life-cycle impacts relating to the production of greenhouse gases and associated local pollutants”; governments recognize “the rights of victims of climate change and associated injustices to receive full compensation, restoration, and reparation for loss of land, livelihood and other damages“; “the right of all workers employed in extractive, fossil fuel and other greenhouse-gas producing industries to a safe and healthy work environment without being forced to choose between an unsafe livelihood based on unsustainable production and unemployment”; “the right to self-determination of Indigenous Peoples, and their right to control their lands, including subsurface land, territories and resources and the right to the protection against any action or conduct that may result in the destruction or degradation of their territories and cultural way of life”; and “the right of indigenous peoples and local communities to participate effectively at every level of decisionmaking, including needs assessment, planning, implementation, enforcement and evaluation, the strict enforcement of principles of prior informed consent, and the right to say ‘No.’” (India Resource Center 2002)
The analysis of climate change issues from an environmental justice perspective often highlights unexpected consequences of climate-control actions that otherwise receive favorable reviews—for example, one of the powerful tools developed as a result of the Framework Convention on Climate Change adopted at a conference held in Kyoto, Japan, in December 1997. According to this agreement, nations and corporations can reduce their measured contribution to climate change by engaging in carbon trades. A company that produces large amounts of greenhouse gases, for example, can have the overall contribution to climate change reduced by buying carbon credits from companies that
102 Worldwide Perspective
pollute less (such as those, perhaps, found in LDCs) or by contributing to the development of climate change–ameliorating projects, such as the development of tree farms in undeveloped areas. But analysis often shows that such carbon-trading efforts actually result in a disproportionate effect on poor people of color. As one scholar has written, “Climate change policies addressing transportation, energy production, industry, commercial enterprises, housing, land use, and agriculture will inevitably have significant social and economic repercussions—on the poor, on consumers, and on affected industries. Notwithstanding the critical importance of significant greenhouse gas (GHG) reductions, policies designed in a vacuum, focusing solely on reductions, could create significant and unintentional adverse consequences. Moreover, policies to address climate change have the potential to address long-standing societal problems, like distributional inequities” (Kaswan 2008, 1; also see EJ Matters 2008; Smith 2007). Concerns about the environmental justice aspect of climate change policies has resulted in the growth in the number of academic papers on the subject, activist efforts to influence domestic and international policy, the formation of new organizations, and other activities associated with the appearance of new political movements. For example, in the United States, a number of new organizations have appeared to study, educate, and lobby about issues in “climate justice.” One of the most influential of these organizations is the Environmental Justice and Climate Change Initiative (EJCCI), located in Oakland, California. EJCCI is a consortium of 28 environmental, civil rights, and environmental justice groups, including the Black Leadership Forum, Communities for a Better Environment, CorpWatch, the Deep South Center for Environmental Justice at Xavier University, the Indigenous Environmental Network, Southern Organizing Committee, Southwest Network for Economic and Environmental Justice, and West Harlem Environmental Action. In 2001, EJCCI developed a document titled “10 Principles for Just Climate Change Policies in the U.S.” Those principles were as follows: 1. Stop Cooking the Planet 2. Protect and Empower Vulnerable Individuals and Communities 3. Ensure Just Transition for Workers and Communities
Environmental Justice and Sustainable Development 103
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
Require Community Participation Global Problems Need Global Solutions The U.S. Must Lead Stop Exploration for Fossil Fuels Monitor Domestic and International Carbon Markets Caution in the Face of Uncertainty Protect Future Generations (Environmental Justice and Climate Change Initiative 2008)
EJCCI says that these 10 principles form the guidelines for changing the focus of the debate over climate change in the United States, for attempting to improve the accountability of industry and the U.S. government in matters of climate change, for involving more youth in the campaign against climate change, and for driving its efforts for fund-raising. As efforts to control human activities that may be responsible for climate change increase, efforts to monitor the disproportionate effects on low-income and minority communities around the world are almost certain to continue and, most likely, intensify.
Environmental Justice and Sustainable Development Perhaps the most popular catchphrase making the rounds among environmentalists on an international scale today is sustainable development. The term first became generally known as the result of its use in the UN World Commission on Environment and Development’s report Our Common Future (also known as the Brundtland Report), published in 1987. The report defined sustainable development as “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (World Commission on Environment and Development 1987, 43). The concept of a world in which all people live safely and comfortably without devastating the environment is an overwhelmingly attractive idea. However, the precise mechanisms by which such a goal can be reached have never been entirely clear. As the editor of a special issue of the Duke Environmental Law & Policy Forum has observed, “Sustainable development is a little like Zen. Everybody talks about it, but few people really know what it is” (Murray 1999, 148).
104 Worldwide Perspective
Over the past two decades, the significance of sustainable development as a guiding principle in policy making around the world has been increasingly accepted by international, regional, and national organizations and agencies. For example, the World Summit for Social Development held in Copenhagen in 1995 proclaimed that “[w]e are deeply convinced that economic development, social development and environmental protection are interdependent and mutually reinforcing components of sustainable development, which is the framework for our efforts to achieve a higher quality of life for all people” (World Summit for Social Development 2008). In spite of any uncertainty about the exact meaning of the term sustainable development, its connection with the field of environmental justice has long been clear and unquestionable to many observers. The Copenhagen Declaration went on to connect sustainable development specifically with the principles of environmental justice: “Equitable social development that recognizes empowering the poor to utilize environmental resources sustainably is a necessary foundation for sustainable development. We also recognize that broad-based and sustained economic growth in the context of sustainable development is necessary to sustain social development and social justice” (World Summit for Social Development 2008). The task for individuals and organizations, then, is to find the specific points at which the goals and methods of sustainable development intersect with those of environmental justice. A report by the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL), One Species, One Planet, suggests three points of confluence: • the right to life, including the right to a healthy environment; • the traditional and customary property rights of indigenous and other local communities, especially those in the global south; and • participatory and procedural rights. (Center for International Environmental Law 2002) A significant portion of One Species, One Planet is devoted to an analysis of the way in which environmental justice and sustainable development intersect in these three areas. In the first case, the report emphasizes the fact that the right to life is the most basic of all human rights and, by its very nature, implies a
Environmental Justice and Sustainable Development 105
right to a healthy environment. Without such an environment, a healthy life, and even life itself, may not be possible. Many nations have now adopted constitutional or legal guarantees for a safe and healthy environment that may also include the right to a safe workplace, the right to organize, the right to an adequate standard of living, and the right to participate in decision making that affects peoples’ lives. One Species, One Planet points out the importance of community rights in addition to the rights of individual persons. It takes special note of the fact that, in many nations, this concept is still largely lacking. Those nations may acknowledge the individual rights of its citizens but ignore the special and legitimate claims of ethnic, racial, linguistic, or other groups. Such a philosophy is especially injurious to communities dependent on natural resources for their survival. When a national government places resource recovery over the needs of individual communities, the rights of those communities have been violated. Any number of examples of this political philosophy can be found in many countries of the world, not the least of which is the United States. In this country, the federal government has long regarded lands owned by Native Americans as fair game in the search for and extraction of natural resources such as coal, oil, and uranium, even though such activities may profoundly disrupt the lives of Native Americans. The CIEL report also reviews the concept of communitybased property rights (CBPRs), which has been developed by legal experts interested in environmental justice and sustainable development. CBPRs are quite different from more traditional and familiar “common property” and “community-based natural resource management” legal strategies in that they place much more emphasis on the rights of an ethnic, racial, or other group. “The distinguishing feature of CBPRs,” the report explains, “is that their exercise derives its authority from the community in which they exist, not from the state where they are located” (Center for International Environmental Law 2002, 14 [emphasis in original]). Finally, the report explains the critical role of community participation in making decisions related to community survival and livelihood. Currently, hundreds of millions of natural resource–dependent poor and indigenous people, primarily in the global south, have essentially no control over the environmental factors that affect their lives. They are almost entirely at the
106 Worldwide Perspective
mercy of national governments and, sometimes, transnational corporations that make decisions about resource allocation on the basis of factors that have little or no connection with the lives of local inhabitants. Neither environmental justice nor sustainable development can have any meaning at all unless local communities develop the skills for analyzing and solving the environmental and social problems they face. To achieve this goal, the CIEL report argues, national governments must accept the importance of and be willing to promote the concept of participatory democracy among their poor and indigenous communities. Implied by this term are a number of individual rights, such as the right to receive and disseminate information, the right to take part in planning and decision making, and the right of access to administrative and judicial justice. One Species, One Planet is only one of many documents that have tried to establish a philosophical basis for the intersection of sustainable development and environmental justice. There appear to have been fewer instances in which national, regional, state, or local governments have tried to develop policies and programs that actually put this philosophy into practice. One interesting exception is a report released by the Scottish government in December 2005 titled Choosing Our Future: Scotland’s Sustainable Development Strategy. The report attempts to show how the principles of sustainable development can be used to inform and drive culture, policy, and action in Scotland. Chapter 8 of the report deals specifically with the intersection between sustainable development and environmental justice. After explaining that a major emphasis of the report is to “improv[e] the quality of life of individuals and communities in Scotland, securing environmental justice for those who suffer the worst local environments,” the report lists a number of specific actions through which those goals can be achieved. They include reducing the country’s dependence on landfills (which have disproportionate effects on nearby communities); improving transport systems in such a way as to more evenly distribute the costs of road traffic, congestion, and air pollution; tackling problems of fuel poverty and unsafe construction in communities dealing with these problems; providing more parks and green spaces to make neighborhoods safer and healthier places in which to live and work; improving protection from floods; enhancing public access to information about their environment and to participation in decision making; and developing new educational programs to
Environmental Justice and Sustainable Development 107
provide special benefits to communities where they are needed (Scottish Executive 2005, 42). The challenge for both environmental justice and sustainable development groups today is to find specific ways in which objectives from both areas of concern can be achieved at the same time. People around the world are trying various programs to achieve this goal. As only one example, concerned citizens in the Dudley Street neighborhood of Roxbury in Boston have founded the Dudley Street Neighborhood Initiative (DSNI) to work for sustainable development of their community based on the principles of environmental justice. The organization was created by members of the community in 1984 “out of fear and anger to revive their neighborhood that was devastated by arson, disinvestment, neglect and redlining practices, and protect it from outside speculators” (“Dudley Street Neighborhood Initiative” 2008). By the early 1980s, the Dudley Street neighborhood had become a classic run-down, crime-infested urban slum with a population that was about three-quarters African American and Cape Verdean, about one-quarter Latino, and less than 5 percent white. About 1,300 parcels of land, nearly a third of the district’s 60 acres, had been abandoned by their owners. The vacant land had become a convenient location for trash companies and individuals to deposit their garbage, and the neighborhood soon became known as “Boston’s dump yard” (Porter 2005). In contrast to many urban neighborhoods of this kind, however, Dudley residents decided to do something about their increasingly desperate situation. The organization they formed has since become a model of what highly motivated activists can achieve when they use the best features of both the environmental justice and sustainable development movements. Within three years, DSNI had become the first (and so far only) community group in the United States to achieve the right to use the power of eminent domain over property within its area, had formed a land trust to administer that property, and had been the first inner-city neighborhood to win a state grant to create a town common. Over the succeeding two decades, it built on these early beginnings, eventually developing more than 600 of the original vacant lots and building more than 300 units of affordable housing in the process. Typical of DSNI’s commitment to the melding of environmental justice and sustainable development is the organization’s
108 Worldwide Perspective
urban agricultural project in which rehabilitated brownfields have been turned into urban gardens. In 2002, the group received a $25,000 grant from the EPA for its Food Project. The money went for training, educating, and employing youth in the neighborhood to practice sustainable agriculture and integrated pest management as ways of creating a sustainable food supply within the context of an environmental justice philosophy. DSNI also continues to work with 14 waste-related industries in the neighborhood to develop systems for waste reduction and waste recycling. For its achievements in combining the best features of environmental justice and sustainable development, DSNI has received a number of awards, including Boston’s Best Kept Neighborhood Civic Award, the 1997 American Planning Association Award for housing planning, and the 2001 American Express Building Leadership Award. Without much doubt, as prestigious as these awards may be, the greatest accomplishment of DSNI has been the revitalization and enhancement of its own community. Today, DSNI remains a powerful force in the integration of sustainable development and environmental justice principles in the Boston metropolitan area. Stories similar to that of the Dudley Street neighborhood are now beginning to appear in low-income and people-of-color communities around the world. They illustrate some of the great accomplishments that can be realized when the principles of environmental justice are melded with the ideals of sustainable development in enhancing the lives of people who have long faced profound social, health, political, and environmental challenges.
References Alter, Harvey. 1995. “Halting the Trade in Recyclable Wastes Will Hurt Developing Countries.” In Environmental Justice, edited by J. S. Petrikin, chap. 9. San Diego: Greenhaven Press. Basel Action Network. 2008. “About the Basel Ban/A Chronology of the Basel Ban.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 18, 2008.] http://www.ban.org/about_basel_ban/chronology.html. Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal. 2008. “Ban Amendment to the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal Geneva, 22 September 1995.” [Online article
References 109
or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://www.basel.int/ratif/ ban-alpha.htm. Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). 2001 (August 9). “Green Groups Call on USA to Ratify International Toxic Waste Dumping Ban as Part of Basel Treaty.” http://www.ciel.org/Chemicals/ Ban_BASEL_9Aug01.html. Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). 2002. One Species, One Planet: Environmental Justice and Sustainable Development. Washington, DC: Center for International Environmental Law. Clapp, Jennifer. 2001. Toxic Exports: The Transfer of Hazardous Wastes from Rich to Poor Countries. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Cook, Jaclyn, and Eddie Koch, eds. 1992. Going Green: People, Politics and the Environment in South Africa. Cape Town, South Africa: Oxford University Press. “Dudley Street Neighborhood Initiative.” 2008. [Online article or information; retrieved May 24, 2008.] http://www.dsni.org/. EJ Matters. 2008. “The California Environmental Justice Movement’s Declaration on Use of Carbon Trading Schemes to Address Climate Change.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://www.ejmatters.org/declaration.html. Environment News Service. 2005 (December 6). “Pacific Island Villagers Become Climate Change Refugees.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://www.ens-newswire.com/ens/dec2005/2005–12 –06–02.asp. Environmental Justice and Climate Change Initiative. 2008. “10 Principles for Just Climate Change Policies in the U.S.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://www.ejcc.org/10%20Principles% 20of%20Climate%20Justice.pdf. European Economic Community. 2008. “Council Regulation (EEC) No 259/93 of 1 February 1993 on the Supervision and Control of Shipments of Waste within, into and out of the European Community.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://eur-lex.europa.eu/ LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:31993R0259:EN:NOT. Fondaw, Corey. 2008. “Environmental Justice Case Study: Thor Chemicals and Mercury Exposure in Cato-Ridge, South Africa.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 18, 2008.] http://www.umich.edu/ ~snre492/Jones/thorchem.htm. Friends of the Earth. “The Bakun Hydroelectric Project: Impacts on the Indigenous People.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.]
110 Worldwide Perspective
http://www.foe.co.uk/resource/briefings/bakun_indigenous_people .html. Last modified November 1996. Greenpeace. 2008. “Philadelphia Ash Dumping Chronology.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 18, 2008.] http://www.essential action.org/return/chron.html. India Resource Center. 2002 (August 28). “Bali Principles of Climate Justice.” http://www.indiaresource.org/issues/energycc/2003/bali principles.html. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. 2007a. Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report. Geneva: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. [Online article or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/syr/ar4_syr.pdf. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. 2007b. Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report: Summary Report. Geneva, Switzerland: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. [Online article or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ ar4/syr/ar4_syr_spm.pdf. Johnston, Barbara Rose. 1994. Who Pays the Price: The Sociocultural Context of Environmental Crises. Washington, DC: Island Press. Kaswan, Alice. 2008. “Environmental Justice and Domestic Climate Change Policy.” Environmental Law Reporter (May). Posted online January 18. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08] http://papers.ssrn .com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1077675. Knight, Danielle. 2001 (March 29). “Foreign Mercury Waste Still Contaminating South Africa.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://www.afrol.com/News2001/sa017_mercury_waste.htm. Maasai Environmental Resource Coalition (MERC). 2008. [Online article or information; retrieved May 16, 2008] http://www.maasaierc.org/ missionandprojects.html. Malaysian Timber Council (MTC). “Bakun Hydroelectric Project.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://www.mtc.com .my/publication/library/bakun/bakun1.htm. Last modified on January 25, 2002. Marshall, Will. 2002 (April 9). “Australian Mining Giant Leaves Environmental Disaster in Papua New Guinea.” World Socialist Web Site. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://www.wsws.org/ articles/2002/apr2002/png-a09.shtml. Mpanya, Mutombo. 1992. “The Dumping of Toxic Waste in African Countries: A Case of Poverty and Racism.” In Race and the Incidence of Environmental Hazards: A Time for Discourse, edited by Bunyan Bryant and Paul Mohai, chap. 15. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
References 111
Murray, Kali N., ed. 1999. “Introduction.” Duke Environmental Law & Policy Forum 9 (Spring): 147–152. Narimatsu, Julie. 2008. “Environmental Justice Case Study: Maasai Land Rights in Kenya and Tanzania.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 16, 2008.] http://www.umich.edu/~snre492/Jones/maasai.htm. Norris, Ruth, ed. 1982. Pills, Pesticides & Profits: The International Trade in Toxic Substances. Croton-on-Hudson, NY: North River Press. Oliver, Rachel. 2008 (February 18). “Rich, Poor and Climate Change.” CNN.com. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://edition.cnn.com/2008/BUSINESS/02/17/eco.class/. Porter, Tim. 2005 (September 22). “One Neighborhood, Many Stories.” Poynternonline. http://www.poynter.org/column.asp?id=69. Roberts, J. Timmons, and Bradley C. Parks. 2006. A Climate of Injustice: Global Inequality, North-South Politics, and Climate Policy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Schwartz, Jerry. 2000 (September 5). “The Full Story of the Khian Sea and the Gonaives Ash Mountain.” [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://www.webster.edu/~corbetre/haiti-archive/msg05049 .html. Scottish Executive. 2005. Choosing Our Future: Scotland’s Sustainable Development Strategy. Edinburgh, UK: Scottish Executive. Smith, Kevin. 2007. The Carbon Neutral Myth: Offset Indulgences for Your Climate Sins. Amsterdam: Transnational Institute. [Online article or information; retrieved 5/20/08.] http://www.carbontradewatch.org/pubs/ carbon_neutral_myth.pdf. Steger, Tamara. 2007. Making the Case for Environmental Justice in Central & Eastern Europe. Budapest, Hungary: CEU Center for Environmental Policy and Law, the Health and Environment Alliance, and the Coalition for Environmental Justice. Wade, Robert. 1997. “Greening the Bank: The Struggle over the Environment (1970–1995).” In The World Bank: Its First Half Century, edited by Devesh Kapur, John P. Lewis, and Richard Webb, chap. 13. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution. Whirled Bank Group. 2008. “Larry Summers: The Bank Memo.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 18, 2008.] http://www.whirled bank.org/ourwords/summers.html. World Commission on Environment and Development. 1987. Our Common Future. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. World Summit for Social Development. 2008. “Copenhagen Declaration on Social Development.” [Online article or information; retrieved May 20, 2008.] http://www.un-documents.net/cope-dec.htm.
4 Chronology
T
he environmental justice movement is relatively young. Its origin is often traced to the protests held in Warren County, North Carolina, in 1982. Yet, many of the elements of the modern movement can be traced back much further, at least to the Civil Rights Act of 1875 and the first environmental law of 1899. This chapter summarizes some of the most important events in the history of the modern environmental justice movement. 1899
America’s first environmental law, the Refuse Act of 1899, is passed. The act is originally written to protect navigable waters from pollution by sediments, disease-carrying organisms, and oil discharges, but it is broad enough to cover many environmental problems through the early 1970s.
1947
The Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act of 1947 is passed by Congress. The act originally deals only with pesticides shipped across state lines. The act is amended and extended in 1972 to cover broader aspects of pesticide production and use.
1948
The Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 is passed by Congress. The statute provides a mechanism by which the federal government can work with state and local governments to reduce or eliminate pollution of interstate waterways and to improve the
113
114 Chronology
1948 (cont.)
quality of surface and underground water resources. The act is never implemented because almost no funds are appropriated for it.
1956
A stronger version of the 1948 Water Pollution Control Act is adopted. The act is amended and strengthened a number of times in following years.
1960
The U.S. Supreme Court rules that segregation in interstate bus and train stations is illegal. A year later, the Interstate Commerce Commission officially prohibits such practices.
1964
The 24th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution is adopted. The amendment abolishes the poll tax, a primary means by which people of color were long prevented from voting. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 is adopted, guaranteeing to all American citizens equal access to employment and public accommodations, regardless of race, creed, color, sex, or national origin.
1965
The Voting Rights Act of 1965, strengthening its predecessor, the Voting Rights Act of 1957, is passed.
1968
The Fair Housing Act of 1968 is adopted, prohibiting discrimination based on race, color, religion, or national origin in rental or purchase of homes, real estate advertising, mortgage lending, homeowner’s insurance, and zoning.
1969
Ralph Abascal, a young attorney and general counsel to California Rural Legal Assistance, files suit on behalf of six migrant farmworkers that eventually results in a ban on the use of the pesticide DDT.
1970
Congress passes and President Richard M. Nixon signs the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969. The act is the single most comprehensive legislative action dealing with environmental issues in the nation’s history. It establishes, for the first time, a
Chronology 115
comprehensive environmental policy for the U.S. government and all of its constituent agencies. It also creates the President’s Council on Environmental Quality, the primary responsibility of which is to develop regulations that will implement the law’s policies. Of perhaps greatest significance, NEPA requires that all federal agencies submit environmental impact statements that describe the impact of major agency actions on the human, biological, and physical environment. Congress passes and the president signs the Clean Air Act of 1970, the strongest and most comprehensive air pollution legislation to date in the United States. The two most important features of the law are the creation of new standards for the presence of air pollutants—the New Source Performance Standards (NSPS) and National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP). These standards express maximum tolerable limits that will protect human health for a variety of pollutants. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is created as an independent agency in the Reorganization Plan No. 3 of 1970. Sen. Philip Hart (D-MI) arranges a meeting among environmental groups, labor unions, and minority organizations to consider issues of the urban environment of concern to all such groups. April 22 is declared to be Earth Day. By some estimates, more than 20 million people demonstrate on behalf of improved environmental conditions in the United States and around the world. 1971
The annual report of the Council on Environmental Quality acknowledges that environmental quality is affected by the racial and class status of communities.
1972
The Water Pollution Control Act of 1972 is adopted. The act represents a giant step forward in the nation’s
116 Chronology
1972 (cont.)
commitment to protect its water resources from pollution. Its primary achievement is to consolidate and reorganize provisions for dealing with water pollution contained in 11 preceding laws dealing with various aspects of water quality.
1975
The Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act Amendments of 1975 are adopted. These amendments update the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act of 1947, as amended in 1964, and the Federal Environmental Pesticide Control Act of 1972. These laws are further updated and extended in 1980, 1988, 1990, 1991, and 1996. In each case, the authority of the federal government to regulate and control the production, sale, and use of a variety of pesticides is made more comprehensive.
1976
The Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) of 1976 and Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 are adopted. TSCA is the first comprehensive legislation giving the federal government authority to regulate new and existing chemical substances. RCRA requires federal agencies to develop methods for assessing the impact of hazardous wastes on the physical, biological, and human environment. A conference on the urban environment is held at Black Lakes, Michigan. The conference is organized by the United Auto Workers and includes representatives from unions, environmental organizations, religious groups, and those concerned with economic justice. The Urban League creates Project Que: Environmental Concerns in the Inner City.
1977
The Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act are revised and updated. Grants totaling $66,000 permit the Urban Environment Conference to fund 11 nationwide conferences on issues related to environmental justice.
Chronology 117
1978
Lois Gibbs first takes action on the health threats posed by hazardous wastes buried beneath the Niagara Falls, New York, neighborhood in which she lives. Gibbs’s efforts eventually lead to the abandonment of the Love Canal area in which she lived and a cleanup that eventually leads to the relocation of more than 800 families.
1979
“City Care: A Conference on the Urban Environment” is held in Detroit. Organizers include the National Urban League, the Urban Environment Conference, and the Sierra Club. One result of the meeting is a sense that traditional environmental groups are going to be uncomfortable with the inclusion of social justice issues in their agendas. Residents of the Northwood Manor neighborhood of Houston sue Southwestern Waste Management, Inc., to prevent the construction of a waste disposal site in their community. The 82 percent black neighborhood claims that it is being unfairly discriminated against by the company’s plans. The community eventually loses the lawsuit, but Bean v. Southwestern becomes a landmark case in that it is the first time a claim of environmental discrimination forms the basis of legal action.
1982
Residents of Warren County, North Carolina, supported by the United Church of Christ, stage a demonstration in opposition to the siting of a polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) landfill near the community of Afton. More than 500 African American protestors are arrested in an unsuccessful attempt to block construction of the landfill. This event is widely regarded as the real beginning of the modern environmental justice movement.
1983
“Taking Back Our Health—An Institute on Surviving the Toxic Threat to Minority Communities” is held in New Orleans. The conference is sponsored by the Urban Environment Conference shortly before it loses its funding and goes out of business.
118 Chronology
1983 (cont.)
A report by the General Accounting Office (now the Government Accountability Office; GAO) states that three out of four hazardous waste sites in EPA Region 4 (Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee) are located in African American communities. The Olin Corporation announces that it will fund the cleanup of a waste site near Triana, Alabama, that had been contaminated by DDT wastes from the Redstone Arsenal. The action is the first time that an EPA order has resulted in a health care settlement for a specific local population. The total cost of the operation is about $25 million. Triana had earlier been called the “unhealthiest town in the United States” as a result of the contaminated site.
1985
The grassroots committee, People Concerned about MIC (methyl isocyanate), is organized in Institute, West Virginia. Consisting largely of African Americans, the group is created in response to a chemical leak from a nearby Union Carbide plant that resulted in about 135 residents being sent to the hospital. The EPA commissions the Council of Energy Resource Tribes to conduct a study of potential hazardous waste sites located on or near Indian lands. The survey reveals as many as 1,200 hazardous waste sites on or near 25 Indian reservations.
1986
Activists in the West Harlem neighborhood of New York City organize to take action against pollution being produced by the city’s North River Sewage Treatment plant. Two years later, the organization is formalized as West Harlem Environmental Action (WE ACT), still one of the strongest and most active neighborhood environmental justice groups in the United States. Juana Beatriz Gutierrez leads a group of her neighbors in protesting the construction of a new state prison in their community. They are eventually suc-
Chronology 119
cessful, and the state decides in 1992 not to build the structure. The protestors eventually organize as the Las Madres del Este de Los Angeles (Mothers of East Los Angeles). 1987
The Commission for Racial Justice of the United Church of Christ publishes a report, “Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States,” showing that race, even more than income level, is the critical factor shared by communities exposed to toxic wastes. Robert D. Bullard publishes Invisible Houston, one of the first books to describe in detail environmental racism and social injustice in black neighborhoods of Houston. Italian businessmen Gianfranco Raffaeli and Renato Pent sign an illegal agreement with Nigerian businessman Sunday Nana, to use his property for the disposal of hazardous wastes from Italy. The wastes are shipped under the guise of building materials and waste chemicals. More than two dozen workers become ill as a result of handling the wastes in Nigeria. The government of Haiti issues a permit for the importation of fertilizer from the United States onboard the freighter Khian Sea. The shipment contains, in fact, not fertilizer, but 13,476 tons of toxic wastes from a Philadelphia incinerator.
1988
The U.S. Supreme Court rules that the development of geothermal energy plants in the Hawaiian Islands does not impinge on the First Amendment right to freedom of religion among native Hawaiians. Native Hawaiians had claimed that the development of such plants would destroy the rainforests and interfere with their worship of the volcanic goddess Pele. A shipment of garbage and incinerator ash from Philadelphia, originally rejected by both Haiti and Panama aboard the Khian Sea, is accepted by the Guinean government. Later reports claim that the
120 Chronology
1988 (cont.)
trees on Guinea’s Kasa Island, where the shipment is dumped, turn brown and die.
1989
Residents of the “Cancer Alley” section of the lower Mississippi River organize the Great Louisiana Toxic March in an attempt to bring attention to their polluted living conditions. Representatives of a number of Indian tribes meet to discuss issues related to natural resource extraction and environmental issues affecting Native Americans. This and succeeding meetings lead to the creation of the Indigenous Environmental Network in 1990. Las Madres del Este de Los Angeles successfully protest the construction in their neighborhood of a $29 million incinerator designed to burn 125,000 pounds of toxic wastes per day. Thirty-three nations sign the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal (the “Basel treaty”). To date, 170 nations have signed the treaty, and 63 have ratified it.
1990
Students at the Harvard Law School, the New York University Law School, the University of California at Berkeley Law School, and Washington University in St. Louis hold conferences on the issue of environmental justice. The first national gathering on environmental justice is held at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. The attendees at that conference, the so-called Michigan Coalition, issue a report titled “Race and the Incidence of Environmental Health.” They send a letter to William Reilly, administrator of the EPA, “demanding action on environmental risks in minority and low-income communities and on tribal lands.” In response to the letter, Reilly appoints the Environmental Equity Workgroup.
Chronology 121
A number of grassroots environmental justice organizations, including the Gulf Coast Tenants Organization, the Southwest Organizing Project, the United Church of Christ Commission for Racial Justice, and the Southern Organizing Committee for Economic and Social Justice, jointly write to the so-called “big 10” of mainstream environmental groups, expressing their concerns about the groups’ historic lack of attention to the special needs and interests of people of color and other minorities and challenging them to end their racist and elitist policies and practices. New York City adopts a “fair share” act intended to ensure that every part of the city receives a fair share of hazardous facility sitings. Robert D. Bullard publishes one of the classic texts on environmental justice, Dumping in Dixie. 1991
The Dow Chemical company pays about $10 million to relocate 110 homes near its plant in Morrisonville, Louisiana. The company decides it is cheaper to move residents than to invest in pollution abatement equipment at the plant. The First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit is held in Washington, D.C. Attendees adopt the 17-point “Principles of Environmental Justice,” which has served as a guideline for the movement ever since. In what is apparently the first significant contribution from the law community on the issue of environmental justice, Rachel D. Godsil, a student, publishes a commentary on the subject in the University of Michigan Law Review. The article is titled “Remedying Environmental Racism.” The U.S. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) initiates a number of actions relating to environmental inequities, including the
122 Chronology
1991 (cont.)
Minority Environmental Health Conference and a study of minority communities located near National Priorities List hazardous waste landfills.
1992
The Charles Stewart Mott Foundation provides a grant for the publication of the first edition of the People of Color Environmental Groups Directory. It listed more than 300 such groups. Students at Columbia University and the Universities of Michigan and Minnesota hold conferences on issues of environmental justice. The EPA establishes the Office of Environmental Justice. The EPA releases a report, “Environmental Equity: Reducing Risks for All Communities.” A report in the National Law Journal, “Unequal Protection: The Racial Divide in Environmental Law,” claims that the EPA pursues discriminatory practices in enforcement of environmental laws and regulations. A national workshop, “Equity in Environmental Health: Research Issues and Needs,” is held at Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, under the sponsorship of the EPA, ATSDR, and the National Institute for Environmental Health Sciences. Rep. John Lewis (D-GA) and Sen. Al Gore Jr. (D-TN) introduce the Environmental Justice Act of 1992. Rep. Cardiss Collins (D-IL) introduces an amendment to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act that would require a “community information statement” for the construction of any new hazardous facility. The statement would include a description of the demography of the proposed site as well as a projected estimate of the impact of the facility on the area.
Chronology 123
1993
On Earth Day, President Bill Clinton pledges that he will issue an executive order instructing federal agencies to take cognizance of the issues raised by the environmental justice movement and to take actions that will reduce the problems emphasized by that movement. The EPA establishes the National Environmental Justice Advisory Council. Representative Lewis and Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT) reintroduce the Environmental Justice Act. Hearings on the proposed promotion of the EPA to cabinet status include discussion of environmental justice issues. The Texas Air Control Board and the Texas Water Commission jointly create the statewide Task Force on Environmental Equity and Justice to deal with basic issues, such as the reasons hazardous facilities tend to be located in minority communities, policies and procedures of the two agencies that relate to issues of environmental inequities, methods by which the agencies can become more “user friendly” to communities of color, and data-gathering methods by which the government might become more aware of environmental inequities in hazardous facilities sitings. Citizens of Wallace, Louisiana, in the state’s notorious Cancer Alley, successfully defeat plans for the construction of a new rayon and pulp-processing plant in their community by Louisiana Formosa Plastic. Tensas Parish had rezoned part of the town to permit construction of the plant, but residents, concerned about health effects of the plant’s waste products, were able to deter Formosa’s plans to build the plant. The Asian Pacific Environmental Network (APEN) is established to provide a mechanism by which Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders can express their
124 Chronology
1993 (cont.)
concerns about environmental injustices suffered by their communities. Nine farmworker organizations from the United States and the Caribbean with a combined membership of about 50,000 join to create the Farmworker Network for Economic and Environmental Justice (FNEEJ). Environmental justice groups file the first law-suits under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 against the Louisiana and Mississippi Departments of Environmental Quality. The suits are based on the premise that the two state agencies discriminate against low-income and minority communities in making environmental policies and decisions, thereby violating the provisions of Title VI. Over the next decades, more than a hundred such suits are filed against state, regional, and local agencies, although very few are successfully prosecuted.
1994
President Bill Clinton signs Executive Order 12898 on Environmental Justice ordering federal agencies to abolish and prevent policies that lead to a disproportionate distribution of environmental hazards to communities of color or low income. The Interagency Symposium on Health Research and Needs to Ensure Environmental Justice, sponsored by the EPA, is held in Arlington, Virginia. The Federal Interagency Working Group on Environmental Justice is created. The Environmental Justice Resource Center (EJRC) at Clark Atlanta University, in Atlanta, is created with Robert D. Bullard as its director. EJRC publishes the second edition of its People of Color Environmental Groups Directory, listing more than 600 environmental justice groups in the United States, Puerto Rico, Canada, and Mexico.
Chronology 125
The United Church of Christ issues an update of its 1987 report, “Toxic Waste and Race Revisited,” providing further evidence on the relationship between race and toxic waste facilities. The Environmental Law and Justice Center at Texas Southern University’s Thurgood Marshall School of Law is formed. Researchers at the University of Massachusetts publish a study indicating that minorities and lowincome people may not be disproportionately targeted in the construction of waste sites and that, in fact, such sites may actually have benefits for such communities. The study is funded by Waste Management, Inc., the largest solid waste disposal company in the world. 1995
The first public meeting of the Interagency Working Group on Environmental Justice is held at Clark Atlanta University. The EPA announces the award of $3 million to assist 174 community-based organizations, tribal governments, and academic institutions to address environmental justice issues in their communities. The awards reflect an increase from the $500,000 awarded to 61 recipients in 1994. A conference, “Environmental Justice and Transportation: Building Model Partnerships,” is held in Atlanta, under the joint sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Transportation and the Clark Atlanta Environmental Justice Resource Center. The conference is a part of the department’s public outreach plan as mandated by President Clinton’s Executive Order 12898. Six environmental justice networks—the Asian Pacific Environmental Network, Southwest Network for Environmental and Economic Justice, Indigenous Environmental Network, Farmworker Network for
126 Chronology
1995 (cont.)
Economic and Environmental Justice, Southern Organizing Committee for Economic and Social Justice, and Northeast Environmental Justice Network—join to establish the Environmental Justice Fund, an alternative mechanism for funding grassroots environmental justice organizations. Diné CARE, a Navajo Nation environmental justice group, prevails on the Bureau of Indian Affairs of the U.S. Department of the Interior to develop an environmental impact statement (EIS) and a 10-year forest management plan (FMP) for the Navajo Nation. Previously, both plans had been developed by the Peabody Coal Company, which was responsible for extensive mining projects on the tribal reservation. The Asian Pacific Environmental network initiates its Laotian Organizing Project (LOP) to provide a means by which members of the Laotian immigrant community in Richmond, California, can express their views on environmental justice issues.
1996
The Seventh Generation Fund sponsors the AntiNuclear Summit in Albuquerque. Indigenous peoples from North America and the Pacific whose lives are affected by the production of nuclear materials agree on a joint declaration of their approach to nuclear issues. Grassroots leaders in Pensacola, Florida, convince the EPA to relocate an entire community of 358 African American and/or low-income households living adjacent to the Escambia Wood Treatment waste treatment facility in Pensacola. The African American Environmental Justice Action Network is formed as a collaborative activity of about 75 community groups working for environmental justice in 11 southern states. The U.S. Institute of Medicine conducts a “toxic tour” of the so-called Cancer Alley in Louisiana as part of
Chronology 127
its data-gathering activities in preparation for its 1999 report Toward Environmental Justice. 1997
The People of Color and Disenfranchised Communities Environmental Health Summit is held in Waveland, Mississippi, to develop plans for dealing with the disproportionate effect of nuclear materials development activities on minority communities. As a result of the conference, the Department of Energy and other federal agencies begin to work with the coalition to build more positive relationships with such communities. The “Healthy and Sustainable Communities Conference: Building Model Partnerships for the 21st Century” is held in Atlanta. The conference focuses on success stories in the environmental justice movement; conducts a review of best practices and model community initiatives; discusses successful tools, methodologies, and strategies; and provides opportunities for workers in the field to network with each other about common areas of interest. The ATSDR of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) creates the Community/Tribal Subcommittee of the ATSDR Board of Scientific Counselors to advise it on issues relating to tribal communities that are affected by hazardous waste sites or other facilities. Citizens against Nuclear Trash (CANT), an organization of grassroots activists from Forest Grove (population 150) and Center Springs (population 100), Louisiana, are successful in their efforts to prevent British Nuclear Fuels from constructing a uraniumprocessing plant in their neighborhood.
1998
The EPA issues its “Interim Guidance for Investigating Title VI Administrative Complaints Challenging Permits.” The purpose of the document is to update the EPA’s procedural and policy framework to deal with the increasing number of Title VI complaints
128 Chronology
1998 (cont.)
that allege discrimination in the environmental permitting context. The guidelines meet with considerable opposition, and the EPA begins to revise them almost immediately. The EPA rules on the first two Title VI complaints brought to its attention. In one, involving Shintech, Inc., the case becomes moot when the company decides to build its new polyvinyl plant at a different location. In the second, involving Select Steel, the EPA rules against the complainants. Select Steel is an important case because it is the first decision the EPA makes on Title VI claims. Florida A&M University establishes the Environmental Justice and Equity Institute in Tallahassee. The Wisconsin state legislature passes the Wisconsin Mining Moratorium Law, placing strict conditions on the issuance of permits for new metal sulfide mines. The law is strongly supported by Indian tribes because of their concerns about the adverse effects of mining on their lands and people.
1999
More than 300 black grassroots environmental justice activists from 37 states meet in New Orleans to discuss issues of common interest. They agree to form a new organization, which they call the Interim National Black Environmental and Economic Justice Coordinating Committee (INBEEJCC). In 2001, the organization changes its name to the National Black Environmental Justice Network (NBEJN). The Institute of Medicine releases its landmark study on environmental inequities in the United States, Toward Environmental Justice: Research, Education, and Health Policy Needs. Rep. James Clyburn (D-SC), chair of the Congressional Black Caucus, convenes a conference titled “Environmental Justice: Strengthening the Bridge between Economic Development and Sustainable Com-
Chronology 129
munities,” held at Hilton Head, South Carolina. The conference is hosted by the Medical University of South Carolina’s Environmental Biosciences Program. California state senator Hilda L. Solis introduces the first state legislation on environmental justice to be adopted in the United States. Since that time, the state has developed an extensive and aggressive program for discovering and combating environmental inequities in California. 2000
The Environmental Justice Resource Center publishes the third edition of the People of Color Environmental Groups Directory, listing more than 1,000 environmental justice groups in the United States, Puerto Rico, Canada, and Mexico. The Indigenous Environmental Network and Project Underground join forces to establish the Indigenous Mining Campaign Project, an effort to train indigenous people in dealing with mining issues on tribal lands. The National Environmental Policy Commission (NEPC) is created, largely as a result of recommendations made by the Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) Environmental Justice Braintrust, led by Representative Clyburn (D-SC). The purpose of the NEPC is to develop an alternative environmental policy that takes into account environmental justice, human health, economic considerations, and other important factors. The North Carolina General Assembly allocates $7 million to begin cleanup of the PCB landfill in Warren County, the environmental inequity issue that marked the beginning of the environmental justice movement in 1982.
2001
Greenpeace sponsors the “Celebrity Tour of Cancer Alley,” which features actor Mike Farrell, Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA), and writer Alice Walker. The tour
130 Chronology
2001 (cont.)
revisits a number of infamous sites on the lower Mississippi River that have been denuded and devastated by industrial pollution and hazardous wastes. A New Jersey district court rules in South Camden Citizens in Action v. NJ Dept of Environmental Protection that compliance with environmental laws is not equivalent to compliance with civil rights laws. The court rules that the state of New Jersey has violated Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The case is significant because it is the first instance in which a complaint of this kind has prevailed. The district court’s decision is later overturned by the Third Circuit of Appeals. After nearly six years of litigation, the Monsanto Company agrees to a $42.8 million settlement with an environmental justice group called the Sweet Valley/Cobb Town Environmental Task Force, representing residents of a neighborhood of primarily black and low-income people adjacent to Monsanto’s Solutia PCB plant. The production of PCBs was outlawed in the United States in 1978, and the Monsanto plant was only one of two facilities in the country where the chemicals were being made.
2002
After more than four decades of protests, negotiations, and litigation, the Shell chemical company agrees to pay for the relocation of more than 100 homeowners in the town of Norco, Louisiana. Some homes had been located less than 15 feet from the company’s plant, and residents blamed the high rate of cancer and other disorders on exposure to emissions from the facility. A total of 2,500 tons of toxic incinerator ash are buried at the Mountain View Reclamation Landfill, in Franklin County, Pennsylvania. The ash was part of a shipment of municipal wastes originally shipped from Pennsylvania on the freighter Khian Sea in 1986 for disposal in the Bahamas. When the Bahamian government, the Dominican Republic, Honduras,
Chronology 131
Panama, Bermuda, Guinea Bissau, and the Dutch Antilles all refused to accept the wastes, the Khian Sea dumped 4,000 tons of the wastes on a beach near Gonaives, Haiti. It proclaimed that the wastes were fertilizer. Now, 14 years later, Waste Management, Inc., recovers the 2,500 tons of ash and returns it to the United States, where it is eventually buried in Pennsylvania. The Second People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit is held in Washington, D.C. More than 1,400 activists attend the conference. A coalition of environmental justice groups consisting of the Black Leadership Forum, the Southern Organizing Committee for Economic and Social Justice, the Georgia Coalition for the Peoples’ Agenda, and Clear the Air release a report, Air of Injustice: African Americans and Power Plant Pollution, on the differential effects on African American communities of air pollution from power generation. The University of Michigan School of Natural Resources and Environment sponsors a conference titled “Latinos and the Environment.” 2003
The U.S. Commission on Civil Rights issues its report, Not in My Backyard: Executive Order 12898 and Title VI as Tools for Achieving Environmental Justice. The report attempts to assess the effectiveness with which four federal agencies—the EPA, the U.S. Department of the Interior, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, and the U.S. Department of Transportation—have implemented Executive Order 12898 and Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. They find that the four agencies have a relatively poor record in this regard. The state of North Carolina completes its cleanup of the PCB toxic waste site in Warren County, where the environmental justice movement began more than two decades earlier.
132 Chronology
2003 (cont.)
The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation issues a new policy that environmental justice concerns are to be included in decisions on the issuance of permits. The University of Michigan School of Natural Resources and Environment establishes the Minority Environmental Leadership Development Initiative (MELDI) to enhance the leadership and career development opportunities available to minority students and minority environmental professionals. The University of Michigan School of Natural Resources and Environment sponsors the conference “Environmental Justice and Climate Change.”
2004
The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) publishes its policy on the treatment of environmental justice issues in the issuance of licenses for nuclear power plants. Critics suggest that the NRC policies will actually limit the attention it pays to environmental justice issues in general and to Executive Order 12898 in particular. The Special Committee on Environmental Justice of the American Bar Association (ABA) publishes Environmental Justice for All: A Fifty-State Survey of Legislation, Policies, and Initiatives, summarizing statutes, policies, and other legal rulings on environmental justice. The report is also made available on the ABA’s Web site, where it is updated on a regular basis. The Office of Inspector General of the EPA issues its report, EPA Needs to Conduct Environmental Justice Reviews of Its Programs, Policies, and Activities, summarizing the agency’s progress (or lack of it) in dealing with issues of environmental inequity. The District Court for the Eastern District of Texas finds “a reasonable trier of fact to find racially discriminatory intent” in the city of Dallas’s refusal to close down an illegal hazardous waste disposal site
Chronology 133
in a neighborhood of predominantly black residents (Cox v. City of Dallas). Parents and the Detroit Public Schools reach an agreement on a pending case concerning the construction of a public school on an industrial site. The school system agrees to develop a system to ensure the safety of the site and a set of mechanisms permitting parents to monitor that safety (Lucero v. Detroit Public Schools). 2005
The EPA issues the document “Draft Final Title VI Public Involvement Guidance for EPA Assistance Recipients Administering Environmental Permitting Programs (Recipient Guidance).” The document is designed to provide guidance for personnel who administer environmental permitting programs and enhance public participation in those programs. White residents of Dallas sue the city, claiming environmental racism in the construction of public housing in their neighborhood. They claim that the city’s choice of their neighborhood for public housing was racially motivated and violated their equal protection rights under the Fourteenth Amendment. The local court disagrees with this reasoning and rejects the residents’ suit, a decision that is later affirmed by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals (Walker v. City of Mesquite). The EPA issues the “Draft Framework for Integrating Environmental Justice” and the “Draft Environmental Justice Strategic Plan Outline,” which together form the foundation for the agency’s Environmental Justice Strategic Plan for 2006–2011. The EPA plan is met with severe and widespread complaints, and more than 45 organizations interested in environmentalism and environmental justice sign a letter objecting to the plans. The GAO publishes Environmental Justice: EPA Should Devote More Attention to Environmental Justice When
134 Chronology
2005 (cont.)
Developing Clean Air Rules, a report on the EPA’s implementation of Executive Order 12898 with regard to air quality. The GAO concludes that the EPA has not been sufficiently vigilant in following the provisions of the order. The California legislature passes a bill requiring local governments to include consideration of environmental justice issues in the development of their general plans. New Mexico governor Bill Richardson signs an executive order requiring all state departments, boards, and commissions to provide “meaningful opportunities” for local communities to be involved in decisions affecting minority and low-income communities.
2006
Warren County begins plans for the construction of Justice Park at the site of the former PCB waste disposal dump, where the environmental justice movement began in 1982. The NRC Licensing Board rules that a claim of environmental inequity filed by neighbors of the Palisades Nuclear Plant near South Haven, Michigan, is not valid and that the plant is eligible for relicensing. The EPA issues its “Title VI Public Involvement Guidance for EPA Assistance Recipients Administering Environmental Permitting Programs.” The purpose of the document is to assist licensing agencies in paying proper attention to issues of environmental justice so that they will not eventually be exposed to Title VI claims by affected groups. The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 requires regulators to consider how emissions control systems may affect low-income and minority communities disproportionately. The nonpartisan think tank Resources for the Future (RF) issues a report suggesting that grants issued by
Chronology 135
the EPA’s Office of Environmental Justice (OEJ) tend to go to communities with large minority and low-income populations, but that grant recipients tend to be exposed to relatively low concentrations of hazardous materials. RF recommends that the OEJ reevaluate the criteria under which it issues its grants to remedy this problem. The NRC rules that five environmental justice groups objecting to the construction of the new Vogtle Electric Generating Plant near Waynesboro, Georgia, have not provided evidence that minority and lowincome communities in the area will be disproportionately affected by the plant’s operation. A coalition of more than 70 organizations concerned with issues of environmental justice initiate the National Environmental Justice Tour for All, with simultaneous trips in the Northeast, the South, and the West to highlight the effects of environmental racism on poor and minority communities around the United States. 2007
An environmental justice conference is held at Howard University in Washington, D.C., “to explore new ideas and new approaches to environmental justice.” A similar conference is held in 2008. Michigan governor Jennifer Granholm signs an executive directive requiring the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality to develop and implement a state environmental justice plan that, among other things, ensures that all state agencies and departments integrate the principles of environmental justice into their decision-making procedures and activities. A coalition of environmental justice groups in Los Angeles defeats efforts to approve the drilling of 24 new oil wells in the Baldwin Hills neighborhood of the city. Members of the same coalition had earlier prevented the construction of a power plant (2001) and a garbage dump (2003) in the area. The city finally
136 Chronology
2007 (cont.)
agrees to build a two-square-mile park in Baldwin Hills, which has one of the most heavily concentrated populations of blacks in the city.
2008
The Oregon Task Force on Environmental Justice, created by the legislature in 2007, begins operation. Its responsibilities include ensuring that all 14 of the state’s natural resources departments and commissions include procedures for input by minority, lowincome, and other affected groups on issues that may involve disproportionate environmental effects on projects for which the agencies are responsible. Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-NY) introduces the latest version of the federal environmental justice bill, S. 2549. The bill has been introduced, but never acted upon, in every legislative session for more than a decade.
5 Biographical Sketches
T
he biographical history of the environmental justice movement is quite different in some ways from that of other major movements, such as the traditional environmental and civil rights movements. The environmental justice movement is largely decentralized, manifested in the activities of dozens or hundreds of local groups, rather than centralized, operating under the direction of large national organizations. As a result, many of the real heroes and heroines of the environmental justice movement are organizers or chairpersons of town, county, village, or parish organizations; they are people whose names are probably not well known outside of the environmental justice movement itself. To be fair, this chapter should probably contain biographical sketches of many of those who have led small, local groups as well as those whose names are more widely known. Since space does not permit the inclusion of all of those whose names belong here, the chapter provides a sample of women and men who have made significant contributions to the environmental justice movement, at whatever level they may have worked.
Dana Ann Alston (1951–1999) Among her many accomplishments, Dana Ann Alston is perhaps best remembered for an inspiring speech at the 1991 First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit. In that speech, she challenged mainstream environmental groups to expand their view of environmental issues to include
137
138 Biographical Sketches
the problem of environmental inequities. Modern-day leaders of the environmental justice movement continue to refer to and quote from that speech. Only a year later, Alston led a delegation of leaders from the environmental justice movement at