Seeking Environmental Justice
At the Interface
Series Editors Dr Robert Fisher Dr Nancy Billias
Advisory Board Dr Alejandro Cervantes-Carson Professor Margaret Chatterjee Dr Wayne Cristaudo Dr Mira Crouch Dr Phil Fitzsimmons Dr Jones Irwin Professor Asa Kasher
Owen Kelly Dr Martin McGoldrick Revd Stephen Morris Professor John Parry Professor Peter L. Twohig Professor S Ram Vemuri Revd Dr Kenneth Wilson, O.B.E
Volume 46 A volume in the Probing the Boundaries series ‘Environmental Justice and Global Citizenship’
Probing the Boundaries
Seeking Environmental Justice
Edited by
Sarah Wilks
Amsterdam - New York, NY 2008
The paper on which this book is printed meets the requirements of “ISO 9706:1994, Information and documentation - Paper for documents Requirements for permanence”. ISBN: 978-90-420-2378-9 ©Editions Rodopi B.V., Amsterdam - New York, NY 2008 Printed in the Netherlands
Contents Preface Section 1:
Theories in Environmental Management Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future: Orientations in Perverse Ecologies Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
Section 2:
Section 3:
9 33
Framework Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope Kendal Hodgman
53
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia: Contributing Factors and Current Incentive Schemes Jo Kehoe
77
Class and Conflict Global Environmental Governance: Mapping Unequal and Contested Terrain Andrew Deak Sustainable Outcomes through Effective Conflict Management Tania Sourdin
Section 4:
1
97
121
Information Management The Public Debate on Genetic Modification (GM) - Varieties of Understanding Linda Hadfield
143
Environmental Justice: Bridging the Gap Between Experts and Laymen Kim Loyens
159
Section 5: Environmental Activism
Section 6:
Section 7:
Promoting Environmental Citizenship? A Critique of the Moral Persuasiveness of Direct Action Environmental Protest Belinda Clements
179
How many Koalas are there on Kangaroo Island? Sarah Wilks
203
Education Environmental Education in a Course on Ethics and International Development Judith Andre
227
Carbon Justice? The Case Against a Universal Right to Equal Carbon Emissions Derek R. Bell
239
Professionals and Corporations The Final Frontier: Free Trade, Corporate Capitalism and International Environmental Law Kristy J. Buckley
261
Empowerment of Professionals as a Strategy for Effective Sustainability of the Built Environment Joseph Akin Fadamiro
281
Notes on Contributors
293
Welcome to a Probing the Boundaries Project Seeking Environmental Justice emerges from a larger inter-disciplinary and multi-disciplinary research project which aims to explore the role of ecology and environmental ideas in the context of contemporary society, international politics and global economics, and to begin to assess the implications for our understandings of fairness, justice and global citizenship. The project will develop a focus on four interlocking areas; Area 1: will examine the changing relationship between nature, culture, and society and will look at the impact of environmental thinking and ethics on issues such as animal/species welfare and rights, conservation and preservation, sustainable resources, food and feeding, space and air space, present and future needs, human ‘rights', and our obligations to future generations. Area 2 will examine the ethical and political impact of environmental thinking, looking at its emergence and role in political contexts, the factors which influence the formation of environmental policy, what (if any) is the place of economic methods and considerations, differing perspectives on the interpretation of scientific data, and the ability of national and international communities to successfully implement environmental policies. Area 3 will examine the international nature of environmental issues and look at the problem solving processes which are or might be employed particularly in light of globalisation. Themes will include how environmental negotiation works in the context of international relations, the responsibilities of multinational companies, the feasibility of establishing environmental ‘laws’, and the future of ecological ‘business’. Area 4 will examine the themes of justice, community and citizenship, looking at the tensions present in ecological debates, the influence of cultural values, the meaning of ethical business practice, the assessment of what counts as environmental equality, inequality, and justice, and our responsibilities toward the world in which we live. Dr Robert Fisher Inter-Disciplinary.Net http://www.inter-disciplinary.net
Preface Welcome to this volume, which contains developed versions of presentations made to the 5th conference on Environmental Justice and Global Citizenship, held in Oxford, UK in July 2006. This interdisciplinary conference included perspectives from traditionally widely divergent disciplines. Within this forum, the carbon auditor and the conflict management specialist met, the environmental lawyers met those more concerned with the role of environmental education, the Gaia theorist and the zoologist met, mixed, and came away enriched. While the very different paradigmatic viewpoints and modes of work employed by such a disparate group of workers necessitated special efforts to communicate, understand and assimilate the ideas being proposed, this challenge was by and large not too difficult to overcome and left all participants the better for the experience. Various themes surfaced, dived, resurfaced, and came to permeate the conference. As might be expected from the title of the conference, issues relating to environmental justice were prominent. Other themes explored included wider theoretical perspectives of the environment in a greater sense; policy and framework issues as both barriers and possible facilitators; knowledge and information, and in particular whose knowledge and information was most to be heeded; environmental activism in its various guises; and class and equity issues, amongst others. Some of the participants from less developed countries offered particularly valuable contributions, reminding us once again that we should strive not to be ‘white middle class male Tarzans.’1 The chapters in this volume were chosen by the Steering Group with great care and after consultation with the conference participants, as a wide ranging sample of the breadth and depth of the ideas heard at the conference. Inevitably it was not possible to include more papers; however, an eBook of the working conference papers contains most if not all of the actual conference presentations and the reader is referred to this resource. Necessarily, in a book, contributions have to be arranged in some sort of order which inevitably imposes - or implies - some sort of structure. However, this structure is not intended to constrain. The chapters in this volume are arranged in couplets; it is intended that they speak to each other as well as to the broader themes. Several of them in particular take up themes presented in other duets. The resulting structure of the book then, is not a linear listing of bifurcations on particular circumscribed topics but more a multidimensional network of interconnectedness and opportunities to take new pathways through this network. It is our hope that some of these new pathways through the network will be explored by others after reading our works in this book.
2
Preface
The book opens with two different ‘takes’ on theories of environmental management. Opening with the statement: “The connection between nature and society configures a field in which nature, society and economy must be studied together,” Doriana Daroit and Luis Philipe Nascimento looked at some different theories of the environment, analysing them from management economy and sociology perspectives, and finding that all the presented theories had something to offer in different manners to the comprehension of nature-society relationships. In the following chapter, from a Gaian perspective, Serena D’Anderlini proposes a radically different way of looking at love and loving, arguing that a reconfiguration of the (Modern) distinction between Eros and other forms of love would assist the endeavour towards a more ecologically sustainable future. The next section examines the subject of frameworks. Kendal Hodgman has developed a whole of government template for communicating and evaluating sustainability issues, which is successfully and extensively deployed by the largest State administration in Australia (the New South Wales Government). This chapter shows how, by breaking things into do-able, bite sized pieces, and by providing an adequate scaffold, the hopelessness of a seemingly large and overwhelming problem can be reduced; importantly, this approach has the capacity to enroll employees at all levels into sustainable thinking and a considerable educative capacity. Still within Australia, but in another State (Queensland), Jo Kehoe considered the part voluntary conservation agreements between private landholders and governments can play with respect to the protection of biodiversity, well demonstrating some of the problems inherent to voluntary approaches, not least historical/contextual issues (in this instance mutual distrust between landholders and the Queensland government), and the balance that must be struck between how sharp the ‘fangs’ of such an agreement must be in order for it to work effectively, but how toothless it must be for any sane landowner to enter into it voluntarily. We then turn to issues relating to class and conflict. Examining global environmental governance, taking a trans-national class analysis view, Andrew Deak questions the likelihood of many environmental initiatives originating from the ‘middle class’ to be any more than weakly effective, due to a fundamental linkage of this class with capitalist imperatives, which need to be readjusted prior to effective action on environmental degradation; and stressing the need of non government organisations to resist being indirectly co-opted into capitalism-based philosphies. Tania Sourdin then looks at the different mechanisms available to apply to environmental conflict resolution. The pros and cons of facilitative conflict resolution as opposed to adversarial or other processes are examined, with the finding that although facilitative
Sarah Wilks
3
processes have potential merits, the nature of environmental conflicts, which often involve very value-laden positions, incurs a need to look particularly carefully at planning and resourcing issues, lest this approach fails to deliver satisfactory outcomes. ‘Information management’ is the broad heading of the next couplet. Linda Hadfield undertook a qualitative analysis of a large number of responses to a (UK) Government sponsored website which canvassed public opinions about Genetically Modified foods. This work is a blueprint for the potential application of this approach in many other fields; the power of the methodology employed, and the detailed underlying attitudes teased out through its high powers of resolution make for a highly interesting and informative read. Still looking at knowledge and information management, Kim Loyens considered to what extent, (if at all), the gap between expert knowledge and layman’s knowledge could be bridged. By studying three models for expert-layman participation, she found that this was not necessarily an easy endeavour and neither were the models foolproof; however, where experts are willing to make the effort to translate their expert knowledge into forms more comprehensible to non experts, this gap can be bridged. Section Five, on environmental activism, considers two forms of the many manifestations of environmental activism, (while still running along the theme of different knowledges and ways of knowing). Belinda Clements examined the discourses of environmentalists engaged in ‘direct action’ campaigns, seeking connectivity with (academic) environmental ethicists. Sarah Wilks’ chapter examined the progress of a single issue animal rights group, which was striving to protect an animal from perceived endangerment in the face of evidence that in places the animal was in fact overabundant and threatening not just itself but other species due to high numbers and over browsing of vegetation. Both chapters come up against the issue of how representative these forms of environmental activism are of other people’s opinions. In the Clements chapter, it was seen that some local people did not support the efforts of ‘imported’ activists to save bits of their locality for them, and in the Wilks chapter, the injustice felt by the local people, subject to the effects of a high-profile anti- animal control campaign run by an overseas funded organisation based two states away was clearly demonstrated. In Section Six, (titled Education), Judith Andre vividly describes some of the reasons why American youth may lack connectedness with the environment and considers the role a well structured educational course in environmental ethics, with an especial stress on assisting students to gain an awareness of the environmental context2, has partially redressed this situation. Derek Bell’s chapter considers some of the arguments for and against the equal right of all to pollute (in the form of equal rights to emit carbon) within the context of climate change justice.
4
Preface
While on the surface, carbon egalitarianism is an appealing notion, he questions if there should in fact be ‘equal rights’ in this respect, arguing that this assumption is an oversimplification of a very complex issue. In the final section, Professionals and Corporations, Kristy Buckley delivers an account of how the actions of multi-national corporations are essentially without effective legal regulation when these entities operate in Nation-states with weak or failed legislations; leading frequently to adverse environmental impacts and penalties paid by local inhabitants to beneficiaries in wealthy countries, where the corporations are based. She argues that international law needs to ‘catch up’ with the activities of these corporations in order to protect exploited people and environments worldwide. Joseph Fadamiro’s chapter pulls together issues of contextuality, education, and social justice and needs; he discusses some of the past pressures within his native country, Nigeria, which may have been responsible for this nation’s past failure to realise full potential economically and socially. He then proceeds to outline some of the implications these considerations have for those who create the built environment, i.e., builders, architects and the like; and what the needs of these professional in training, in context, are, and how these needs could be met. It is my sincere hope that readers of this volume will find it worthwhile and thought provoking. Frequently, when faced with very big and complex issues such as global justice and the world environment, just looking at the issue can be overwhelming and intimidating. The sheer magnitude and complexities of these issues make it hard to get a conceptual ‘hook’ into them, let alone figure out a way to examine a part without losing the connectedness and context of the whole. By and large, the papers in this book have done both these things; and not a few of them embody positive messages. As a whole, this collection of work lights some paths and leaves promising avenues well signposted for others. Enjoy exploring! Finally, I would like to thank all the contributors to this volume not just for their timely submission of manuscripts which were (mostly!) so well prepared that little editing was required, but also for the width, breadth and depths of their perspectives, so ably communicated, making this an enjoyable learning experience for us all. Sarah Wilks. Sydney, May 2007
[email protected]
Sarah Wilks
5
Notes 1
A response from a Papuan New Guinean woman to a presentation (NOT at the present conference) by an environmental activist condemning mining companies’ involvement in PNG. The activist was a sincere man who had given up his time, money and energy in this pursuit. The woman, from an undeveloped area, had only been educated and offered health care (and given the infant mortality rates in the district, very possibly owed her life to this) as a direct result of the mining company’s presence. The ensuing, lengthy, ding-dong exchange was illuminating for the audience and for each of the speakers. 2 And how not to be ‘white middle classTarzans...’
Section 1 Theories in Environmental Management
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society Doriana Daroit Luis Felipe Nascimento Abstract The connection between nature and society configures a field in which nature, society and economy must be studied together. Such a relationship unveils different approaches and interpretations about environmental questions and their management in organisations. In order to understand this field, one must move beyond descriptions into studies that promote questioning, thus leading to transformations in management and production regimes. This study discusses environmental management from management, economy and sociology perspectives. Data were collected from ISO9000 companies, in the Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil. The literature review highlights the efficiency criteria used by the Scientific Management and in the works of Herbert Simon, the concept of Transaction Costs Economics derived from Coase, Williamson and North, and discusses the importance of conflicts and power in environmental decision making and action implementation. Data analysis shows that all presented theories may contribute in different manners to the comprehension of nature-society relationships. Key words: Environment, organisational theory, efficiency, transaction costs, environmental discourse, power. 1.
Introduction The use of nature is at the base of human economic and social organisation. To human-developed techniques, the scientific method was added, generating knowledge that was further transformed into technologies, thus resulting in further “discoveries.” The exploitation of natural resources leads to the existence of food, clothing, computers, and spaceships. Nature is subordinated to our economic interests. However, how are such relationships established? Can such a complex set of relationships be solely driven by economics? Some approaches to organisational management seem to enhance the economic view, without discussing its implications for nature-society relationships. By denying questioning of the subject, and of which relationships are desirable, some studies become descriptions of what already exists, immune to thinking that could transform production management and generate positive consequences to the environment and to society. This work aimed to discuss the contribution of organisational and
10
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
economic theories to environmental management. A survey, followed by case studies, was conducted in ISO9000 companies in Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil. Data analysis was conducted using different and wellestablished theories in the management and economics fields: scientific management, Simon’s research on decision making and efficiency, and the studies on transaction costs performed by Coase, Williamson and North. In addition, work by Foucault and Hardy and Phillips were considered as inspirations for the power analysis used in the definition of environmental practices. 2.
Environmental Quality in Rio Grande do Sul State Companies In 2000, a survey was conducted in ISO9000 companies in the Rio Grande do Sul State, Brazil. The study’s objective was to identify the main negative environmental impacts generated by companies and the respective counter-measure responses adopted. The population was composed of 188 companies, out of which 33 collaborated in the survey. The 33 companies were from the following sectors: metal-mechanic, plastics and rubber, chemical and petrochemical, and electro-electronic. Five were selected for in-depth interviews according to environment harm reduction criteria, scope of environmental measures and financial quantification of such measures. These five companies belong to the secondary sector. Survey results detected as the most prominent environmental problems, the generation of solid waste, energy consumption and effluent generation. Although production processes varied considerably among sectors, energy consumption and solid waste generation presented problems for most respondents, across all sectors. This was not true in the case of liquid effluents, since no company from the plastic-rubber sector indicated the presence of liquid effluents as a significant negative environmental impact of their production process. Another highlight was the small number of companies that pointed to consumption of non-renewable resources as one of their main environmental impacts. This might mean that most respondents did not consider the whole lifetime of their products in their production process analyses. Such was the case even for the metal-mechanic sector, whose raw materials were minerals, or petrochemical and plastic-rubber sectors, whose raw materials are fossil fuel. Case studies showed that companies were concerned with the environmental quality of their suppliers, requiring them to have an operations licence from the Environmental Protection State Agency (FEPAM), although the licence alone does not guarantee environmental quality. Two companies were more strict concerning recycling and storage services provided by their suppliers. One of the companies had an audit
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
11
team to verify the adherence of its contractors to its environmental policy. Such relationships with suppliers might indicate the start of better environmental practices dissemination through the production chain. Regarding environmental impacts, gaseous emissions were not an oft nominated factor. The greatest number of quotations of this factor derived from petrochemical companies. The case studies demonstrated that, for companies in this sector, emission control (and thus air quality control) was performed by a neighbouring company, without the direct intervention of the studied company. Another company from the petrochemical sector was starting emissions characterisation, but even those companies were not intensively acting on this specific aspect of their processes. In accordance with the main environmental impacts pointed to by companies themselves, the environmental measures adopted translated into actions aimed at reducing waste generation instead of directing it appropriately. Companies acted strongly on outflows, and on projects and processing. Through the interviews with the best practices companies it was verified that all of them tried to act over the whole process, since this would imply not only avoiding waste disposal but also the generation of environmental impacts. Such conduct is in line with the literature, i.e. independently of the program used - ISO14000, Cleaner Production, Responsible Action or even practices that are not connected to those acting over the whole process is seen as the most efficient manner of elevating the company’s environmental quality. One opinion held by interviewees that drew attention throughout the research was that, for all of them, environmental quality represented an issue of efficiency of the production process. Technological enhancements aimed at waste reduction, minimisation of energy, water and raw material consumption, as well as adequate disposal of waste represent opportunities for cost reduction. When businesspeople become aware of this economic dimension of environmental practices, support and investments are facilitated. For that reason, it is important to quantify the economic benefits of these environmental measures. All enterprises responsible for best practices consider knowledge on costs and returns of environmental measures to be important, since it helps raising business peoples’ awareness, besides showing the efficiency of the Environmental Management System (EMS). Most interviewees chose to point out as the main environmental measure1 the process of culture change that takes place in the enterprise as soon as environmental activities are developed. Changes in attitude and behavior among employees were seen as necessary to continue the process of environmental improvement; and therefore, as crucial for the development of an efficient EMS.
12
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
The interviews showed that there is need for better organisation and formalisation of the EMS, so that an enterprise has a system of indicators that reflects its environmental performance, i.e., that measures the efficiency of its activities. The most commonly used indicators correspond to energy, water and raw material consumption, production and recycling of solid wastes, and compliance with the law. Specific indicators, which are adequate to the enterprise’s production process, are added to those indicators. These indicators represent process stages or activities that need to be controlled in order to measure the impacts and efficiency of developed activities. With regard to indicators of environmental performance related to manufactured products, none of the interviewed enterprises had indicators that allowed us to assess issues related to use and final disposal. The enterprises that had a structured system of indicators defined and performed their activities based on the results expressed by these indicators. The results were discussed and presented to the board as a way to demonstrate the efficiency of actions, results of investments and to encourage higher investments. In addition, these results were disclosed to the other employees to encourage more participation. Judging by the in-depth interviews carried out in all five enterprises, one cannot say that there is a necessary link between quality systems and environmental quality as a requisite so that assessed enterprises can develop environmental practices and improve their environmental performance. But it can be said that environmental practices are inserted in routine activities carried out by the enterprises, as well as in their strategic planning. Although there was a concern about improving the environmental quality of products, processes and services, none of the enterprises pointed market demands as motivation. This is particularly valid for the national market. The demands these enterprises were expecting to cope with were consequences of the international market, mainly represented by Europe and the USA, and of future situations. Such future situations could be increased environmental awareness by consumers, who, according to the viewpoint held by assessed enterprises, would start demanding less impacting products and services, as a consequence of processes with better environmental performance. The enterprises under investigation were preparing themselves, by adopting practices that were less aggressive to the environment, with the aim of increasing competitiveness due to their current position as exporting enterprises or according to their expectations of future market demands. It was possible to identify the integration of environmental quality to the enterprise’s business strategy, e.g. by forming partnerships to develop products that are less aggressive to the environment. Two enterprises in the case studies exemplified this, one partnered with
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
13
universities, and another that had a strong link to CNTL. Sale of wastes represented the main source of one new environmental businesses; one enterprise had set up a unit in the city of Rio Grande to export wood chips unused in its own processes. Therefore, the result of this study indicated that the enterprises under investigation presented different methods for improving the environmental quality of their products, processes and services. The existence of an organised SGA allows enterprises to be treated in a more comprehensible manner, i.e., the whole production process is considered for the development of their environmental practices under a proactive perspective. Based on the answers given to proposed objectives, some considerations and operational recommendations can be made. The analysis of the whole production process is crucial to identify the environmental impacts caused by the enterprise. This leads to a deeper knowledge of the production process, allowing the identification of activities that may be enhanced. The results are not only better environmental performance, but also cost reductions, and generation of innovation. More intensive work regarding suppliers of raw materials, whose environmental impact on the enterprise’s activities cannot be disregarded, is also indicated. The development of a system of environmental indicators to express as reliably as possible the enterprise’s environmental performance promotes the increase in efficiency of developed activities, thus resulting in better practices from the environmental standpoint. However, if the final destination of products is not adequately measured, the environmental impacts that could be avoided by a change in the project or product formulation, or even by guiding consumers about proper disposal, are not known. Because the environmental quality of products and services as a consequence of processes that are less aggressive to the environment is not exploited in promotional advertisements, there is no encouragement to develop the market of environment-minded consumers. Environmental practices are only seen as cost reductions and not as market opportunities; therefore, it is recommended that these enterprises adopt more aggressive strategies to promote the environmental quality of their products, processes and services. Now the data have been presented, we now analyse them, considering some organisational theories that may contribute to the economic treatment of environmental issues.
14
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
3.
The Criterion of Efficiency Since its early days, administration has been characterised by the search for efficiency. Taylor, by studying times and movements, aimed at the best way to perform a task. Ford organised the production process so that it would accelerate productivity through the assembly line. Theories of human relationships focus on employees’ well-being so that they become more efficient. More recent aspects of administration, such as total quality and information technology, represent forms of increasing administrative efficiency and, therefore, of production processes. Engineering considers efficiency as the rate between factor consumption and production obtained, and can be measured in terms of energy. But, after all, what is efficiency? A. Efficiency in Scientific Management According to Taylor, efficiency referred to the relationship between real performance in a given task and the standard set for its accomplishment. The study of times and movements represented an attempt of elevating workers’ efficiency levels via the rationalisation of the work, thus leading to greater productivity. Efficiency was achieved through the standardisation of movements and tools.2 The initial trend in management was to consider administrative questions as engineering problems.3 According to March and Simon,4 this is explained by Taylor’s background and by the situations he and his collaborators experienced. One of the goals of the time and movements study was to describe the characteristics of the human body as if it were a simple machine performing an equally simple task. This is aligned with the view of organisations as machines. Taylor’s method requires detailed observations and precise measurements of routine tasks, enabling one to find the optimal manner of performing them. The impact of the method on myriad organisations is clear nowadays and its use boosted labour performance, i.e. efficiency.5 According to Taylor,6 maximum company performance, and, consequently maximum employee success, is achieved through the maximum productivity of those responsible for company functions, in turn achievable via training. Therefore, efficiency and productivity are interwoven concepts. Through time and movements studies, human problems associated with production defects and productivity became reasonably simple to address, particularly after the integration of the studies with the assembly line. Ford, in his turn, was concerned with the organisation of the production process, bringing standardisation to all stages. Labour division and specialisation, in the standardised assembly lines, raised labour efficiency considerably, generating a productivity increment; this allowed industry growth. Ford believed so much in division and specialisation that he extended the concept to managerial levels, thus
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
15
creating specific activities such as quality management. Production efficiency still is the main goal of many programs that combine process management with environmental management. ISO 14000 and Clean Production are the main examples of popular programs in the environmental area. B. Taylor, Ford, and the Environment Although the presentation of scientific administration was condensed, its effects on the management of organisations were extensive. Production coordination and organisation principles are still broadly used, a situation that is not different in environmental management. Through interviews, it became evident that preoccupation had moved from end-of-pipe solutions to process modifications that minimise wastes and costs.7 This is especially noticeable in the Cleaner Production program, whose main appeal is cost reduction through modifications in the procedures and in production technology. ISO14000 privileges the standardisation of production and administrative practices so that they become correctly executed, i.e. efficient. This is achieved through workers’ training in new practices that are less environmentally aggressive. Concerns related to measuring the results of environmental management systems, particularly through waste generation and energy consumption indicators, reflect concerns with achieving established performance standards. The presentation of indicators to the board of directors has demonstrated the importance of production efficiency as a factor in the maintenance or expansion of environmental investments. Since efficiency and productivity concepts are strongly related, greater production efficiency may lead to greater productivity. On the one hand, attention to the method employed in task execution leads to resource savings, be they labour, energy, raw materials or equipment usage; on the other hand, such greater efficiency, when allied to greater productivity, may result in greater resource consumption due to the increase in the company’s productivity. Although the company’s activities might be considered less environmentally aggressive from a process-based standpoint, they might not result in a reduction of the company’s environmental impacts from a global perspective. C. Simon: Criteria of Efficiency According to Simon,8 social sciences do not have as precise mechanisms as those owned by natural sciences. Efficiency in administrative decisions is a concept “almost identical to the concept of utility9 maximization in the economic theory.”10 Efficiency is related to the existence of scarce resources, and the activities involve the comparability of reference values. Therefore, “the efficiency criterion
16
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
determines the choice of alternatives that lead to the maximization of results when scarce resources are applied.”11 However, alternatives cannot be exhausted because the decision maker does not have the necessary computational power and only owns incomplete information; besides many alternatives do not represent an adequate solution. Therefore, in order to be effective and economical, the search for an alternative must be based on previous knowledge about the domain at stake. The decision is made when one of the alternatives presents a satisfactory item, achieving an expectation level formed on the basis of past experiences, and one that allows a judgment on decision quality. However, the expectation level must be adjusted as a function of the parameters found in the domain and during the unfolding of the situation, parameters that do not refer to utility only.12 The efficiency criterion consists of a common denominator among the values considered in decision making and corresponds to the predominant criterion in rational decisions. However, the efficiency criterion is neutral: it does not solve the value comparison problem. Rationality allows the choice of the alternative that is most aligned with the organisational objectives. A predefined set of values allows the evaluation of the impacts of such choice. Simon considers objectives as value premises that serve as the basis for decision making, whereas reasons represent the causes that lead individuals to selecting a few of the objectives as premises for their decisions. In the every-day function of an organisation, decision situations cannot be related to a single objective, but to a set of them, related to the requirements and barriers that bound the decision situation. Objectives are used to define action pathways toward the creation of alternatives and the evaluation of satisfactory ones. This implies that the manager must exercise judgment. Since administrative activity is a group function, its identification with the values of an organised group, or an organisation, orients it according to the organisational objectives, not according to myriad human values. Ethical premises of the organisation constitute the organisation’s objectives. The organisational roles assumed by individuals connect them to organisational objectives, which can be independent from personal objectives.13 The individual differences explain the different behaviours during the execution of a given role and during the decision-making process. When the organisation provides the decision maker with fundamental values, it restricts his or her choices. Therefore, for commercial organisations (using an expression used by Simon14), the fundamental premise corresponds to profit and decisions are oriented to maximise income or minimise cost. Money corresponds to the common denominator that allows the choice of one alternative among the many available. As described by Simon, rationality is limited since:
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
17
On the one hand, the individual is limited by capacity, habits, reflexes, which do not belong to its conscious mind. Its performance can be limited, for example, by its dexterity, reaction time, or physical force. Decision processes can be limited to the speed of its mental processes, its elementary arithmetic knowledge and so forth. On the other hand, the individual is limited by its values and its concepts of achievement, which influence its decision-making. If its loyalty to the organisation is intense, its decisions will expose a sincere acceptance of the organisation’s objectives; if loyalty is not present, however, personal reasons may interfere on administrative efficiency. 15 According to this view, the administrative man operates in a complex world, but his perception is simple. Therefore, he compromises, since he cannot maximise. Decisions seek a satisfactory action course, for previous examination or knowledge of all alternatives is not doable. Thus, efficiency is related to the satisfactory action course. D. Simon and Environmental Management Efficiency according to the scientific view of management has been exposed. However, when companies adhere to ISO14000, employee well-being16 and the establishment of environmental policies and values enter the scene. Thus one has the starting point of the understanding of environmental management according to the efficiency criterion discussed by Simon. The environmental management activities present in a company are directed by the values and policies established by the company. According to Simon, pre-established values serve to limit decision makers’ choices, since such values represent the organisation’s objectives. Their clear establishment hinders the decision maker from considering all values that are present in a community or in his memory. Thus decision is made on the basis of a more restrict number of alternatives. Alternatives are further restricted when one deals with profitoriented commercial organisations. Organisational objectives are established via authority and communication channels. In general, quality programs require as a fundamental step, the commitment from the top management, not only for the liberation of investments, but also for the establishment of an environmental policy, the latter based on a set of values, i.e., organisational objectives. This was verified in the studied companies. Since they were profit-seeking organisations, it is natural to
18
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
have profit as the decision-guiding factor. This partly explains why environmental activities in the studied companies are directed to costs minimisation or to the discovery of business opportunities, practices that not necessarily transform polluting programs. For example, the petrochemical and plastic-sector companies visited used a non-renewable raw material, oil; in addition, the latter companies produce building materials from PVC, a chemical compound that is already banned in Europe for hospital and toy applications. Therefore, environmental decisions represent an adequacy of means to the ends, i.e. one chooses the technological alternative (be that equipment or managerial) that assures the minimisation of cost and the maximization of revenue. These decisions do not involve questioning whether the goals are ethical or not, for this was pre-established during the discussion of organisational values and the environmental policy defined by top management; as referred by Simon, management is concerned with de facto judgment. However, decisions are made on the basis of limited rationality. Choices are satisfactory. Therefore, decisions are also guided by intrinsic values learned by each one of the decision makers. In the case studies, it was observed that all companies went through an initial phase, in which employee culture change is attempted. Training was used not only as a means of teaching new procedures but also to highlight the importance of the environment, health, safety and the well-being of employees, the company and the community itself. The preoccupation described as production efficiency places economic gains derived from new practices and opportunities at the centre of environmental management. The emphasis on competitiveness is evident; as quoted in more than one interview: national and international markets may require a proof that the company is seeking impact reduction. This means that the profit dimension governs environmental management. The question that cannot be answered by this study is whether organisations would maintain their environmental practices to the detriment of profit reduction, thus revealing an influence of environmental values that are not linked to profitability. 4.
The New Institutionalism From the 70’s, institutionalism has undergone a set of transformations in its economic, sociologic and political realms. According to Carvalho, Goulart and Vieira, the political approach started to emphasise the autonomy of political institutions and institutional policies that lead to international cooperation instead of legal and governance structures. The sociological area had its emphasis on power relationships and focused on adherence to legitimated standards and organisational homogeneity. The economic vein focused on the analysis of
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
19
endogenous micro-processes.17 A. Transaction Costs Economics Cost transaction economy represents one of the most recent developments in theory of the firm, inaugurated by the classical theory but reconfigured by the work of Ronald Coase, in 1937: The nature of the firm.18 Before Coase’s work, the costs of buying and selling were considered negligible and production costs were the key to define the production quantity that maximised the firm’s profit.19 In order to answer why firms exist and what determines their actions, Coase introduced the concept of transaction costs. These correspond to research and information costs, bargaining and decision costs and control costs, present in a transaction. According to Coase, the economy traditionally considered the price mechanism as responsible for the coordination of the economic system. Firms were islands of conscious power in a sea of unconscious cooperation. However, if the coordination is effected by the price mechanism, Coase asked why firms would exist; what was the need for firm existence. For him, inside the firm, market transactions are eliminated and replaced by the entrepreneur-coordinator, who directs the production, i.e. there is no intervention of the price mechanism. The only reason for the establishment of a firm is the existence of costs of use of price mechanisms: price identification costs, negotiation costs and contracting costs. The contracts for the conduct of firm activities via process mechanisms are replaced by a smaller number of contracts inside the firm, e.g. contracts among the employer and his employees. They are long-term contracts in order to avoid negotiation and renewal costs. Under these conditions, the buyer (owner) becomes responsible for the resource allocation and avoids market costs. This allows the appearance of the firm, i.e. one may say that firms are alternative forms of organisation and that they only exist when such organisation is cheaper than another that would be achieved through market mechanisms. Uncertainty is another essential condition for firm creation. Absence of uncertainty means that information is perfect for all individuals, without opportunities for the coordination of production activities. If all individuals knew all about a given situation there would be no leeway for an alternative organisation format, for there would be no differential costs to effect a transaction. In addition, the mutability of factors involved in the organisation of markets and firms renders the resource organisation process a dynamic endeavour, beyond the static analysis offered by the neoclassic theory. In a different work entitled The problem of social cost20 in 1960, Coase deals with firms’ actions that harm others, such as pollution. These negative effects of one firm on another entity are called externalities.
20
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
Within the neo-classic economic theory, externalities are solved according to the work of Pigou:21 through the responsabilisation of the producer via taxes and fines in proportion to the harm caused. For Coase, the pollution problem is reciprocal in nature. If A provokes a nocive effect on B, avoiding B’s problem may harm A. Coase describes the analysis via price mechanisms and via an example involving a cattle raiser and a farmer with the neighbouring property.. The absence of a fence separating the properties allowed the cattle to destroy the farmer’s produce. If the cattle raiser increases his herd, so does he increase the farmer’s losses. Since the cattle raiser is responsible for the damage, he should build the fence. However, he will only do so if the cost is lower than the additional damage to the crops. Alternatively, the cattle raiser might pay the farmer to abandon his harvest, if the forfeit equalled or exceeded production costs. The situation is analogous to that of a company emitting pollutants in a populated neighbourhood. The costs associated with dealing with the company’s emissions might be extremely high and governmental regulation might be a manner of establishing property rights and what may or may not be done. However, government administration is not free of problems and costs. Thus, efficiency of the economic system is not guaranteed and the optimal solution may be no action regarding pollution. Coase believes that inside the firm, opportunity costs and a comparison between revenues from a certain combination of production factors to make decisions should also be an option when dealing with issues such as pollution - avoiding tax mechanisms and comparing the whole product generated from alternative social arrangements. The works of Coase started the new institutional economy. According to Scott, the new institutional economy is concerned with systems of governance and rules developed to regulate or manage economic exchanges.22 In fact, the new institutional economy considers four levels of analysis that are related and under mutual influence: 1) informal institutions, costumes, traditions, rules, and religion; 2) institutional environment: game rules and property; 3) governance: unfolding of the game and agreements; and 4) resource allocation and employment. The main concern of the new institutional economy focuses on levels 2 and 3.23 According to Williamson, The problem of social cost has given rise to studies on institutional environment, on the rules of the game; whereas The nature of the firm has favoured the development of studies related to governance and to the unfolding of the game. 24 During the early work, these two trends received the same treatment; however, as the work progressed, they became autonomous but not isolated fields. Following Coase’s work on transaction costs and property rights, Oliver Williamson developed the Transaction Cost Economy (TCE) maintaining the emphasis on the importance of firm coordination
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
21
activities, the market and property rights. According to Fiani, transaction costs are significant due to limited rationality, uncertainty, complexity, opportunism and asset specificity. Limited rationality, previously discussed, gains importance when the environment is complex and not predictable, i.e. when uncertainty is present. These factors create the conditions for opportunistic behavior by agents, through the selective transmission of information, distortion and false commitment. Asset specificity reduces the number of agents who can participate in a transaction, generating dependence relations that are mutual or unilateral. This may facilitate the development of opportunistic behavior; thus, the preoccupation of TCE with contracts. For Williamson, the firm is a governance structure. 25 In the TCE, firms and markets represent alternative forms of governance and the distribution of activities among them stems from the institutional environment. What is governance, however? According to Williamson: Governance is the means by which to infuse order, thereby to mitigate conflict and to realise ‘the most fundamental of all understandings in economics,’ mutual gain from voluntary exchange.26 Since governance structure and institutional environment are not isolated fields, Williamson follows North’s definition of institutions: “institutions are the rules of the game in a society or, more formally, are the humanly devised constrains that shape human interaction.”27 Therefore, the institutional environment and governance institutions play a very important role in the industrial organisation: the environment is taken as provided and the economic agents may work their transactions and governance structures so as to achieve higher income levels. In order to succeed, the organisation needs to adapt itself to the environment, ether via autonomous parts that respond to market opportunities or via cooperation, maintaining a complex equilibrium through management. This also influences vertical integration, since transactions differ in their attributes and governance structures differ in costs and competencies, transactions must be aligned with appropriate governance structures. Limited rationality directly influences the elaboration of contracts, which are naturally incomplete. This occurs because individuals are limited in their abilities to plan the future - due to lack of knowledge, or capacity to foresee contingencies. Even if a perfect forecast were possible, the parties would have problems in negotiating. Those problems are mostly related to difficulties associated to the development of a common language to describe the actions and the states of a world where both have little previous experience. Moreover, if one assumes that the parties are able to negotiate and renegotiate a whole executory contract, it
22
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
is still difficult to communicate the exact plans to a third person who will judge and support the development of the plan.28 Besides Coase’s influence, TCE resorts to Simon’s notion of limited rationality. The latter directly influences the elaboration of contracts, which are considered intrinsically incomplete. Apart from the problems associated with the impossibility of foreseeing all situations associated to a transaction during contract closure, one must consider the opportunistic behavior of the agents. Ex ante governance is essential to avoid ex post opportunism problems. Instead of the satisfying, derived from limited rationality, TCE seeks the economising. Economising refers to reducing waste, bureaucracy and other types of adaptation losses; it aims at better contractual alignment, organisation, incentives and controls. Therefore, for Williamson the solution involves an evolution of administrative transaction practices directed at economising, i.e. to results maximization; the coordination of the transaction is coordinated by hierarchy (the firm) or by the market according to the largest reduction in transaction costs.29 TCE presents three levels that transact and are responsible for the firm’s governance structure. The institutional environment, which influences the form and its governance structures and which, in its turn, affects the individual. The reverse path is also valid for the TCE.30 This is clear in the description by North: Institutions, together with the standard constraints of economic theory, determine the opportunities in a society. Organisations are created to take advantage of those opportunities, and, as the organisations evolve, they alter the institutions. The resultant path of institutional change is shaped by (1) the lock-in that comes from the symbiotic relationship between institutions and the organisations that have evolved as a consequence of the incentive structure provided by those institutions and (2) the feedback process by which human beings perceive and react to changes in the opportunity set. Transaction costs derive not only from the inefficiency of property rights stemming from the institutional environment, but also from the imperfect mind models of the agents when they try to understand the complexity of routine problems; Long-run economic change is the cumulative consequence of innumerable short-run decisions by political and economic entrepreneurs that both directly
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
23
and indirectly (via external effects) shape performance. The choices made reflect the entrepreneurs’ subjective modeling of the environment. Therefore, the degree to which outcomes are consistent with intentions will reflect the entrepreneurs’ models are true models. North considers human motivation as more complex than the utility maximization model and states that culture change is necessary to define the path representing greater efficiency. B. Transaction Costs and the Environment? Something not so Strange… The influence of institutions on the economic system in the TCE is well developed by North. Regarding environmental management, the question is: what are the game rules in regard to the environment? There are two main components here: making money, the objective of any capitalist enterprise, and being concerned with the environment. However, according to the practices described by the studied companies, both are intrinsically connected. The presence of environmental inspection bodies, like FEPAM, and the consequent possibility of fines for bad environmental behavior prod companies towards the adoption of environmental management processes. However, following Coase's reasoning on social cost, taxes and fines are not enough to curb negative externalities such as pollution. Even governmental administration has its costs and the system efficiency can be affected. Therefore, market mechanisms aimed at the inclusion of environmental norms have been increasingly preferred - ISO14000 is a clear example; others are carbon credits, green stamps for specific sectors or products such as the Forest Stewardship Council. This reasoning privileges the economic view both from the active and from the passive subjects, avoiding fines, reducing costs or improving the company's image. The value that guides environmental preoccupation is income maximization, from which the need of clear property rights regarding the environment stems. This generates a conflict with the views regarding the environment as a public good.31 Even after the clear establishment of property rights, they may influence environmental preferences and direct transactions, affecting the final allocation of resources:32 the lowest total cost alternative may not be selected and other policies and controls may be chosen by the authorities. The profit component seems to have a greater importance as a “game rule,” since the adoption of practices that stretch beyond what is required by law may meet the objective of saving resources and meeting present and future market demands. The market assumes a capital importance, because it considers the existence of consumers who value
24
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
products and services that are less environmentally aggressive. This involves not only purchase relationships but also the company's image as environmentally non-aggressive, a fact that may avoid transaction costs. The existence of such environmental values in society may change the institutions, the rules of the game, and, consequently, the focus of environmental management in the organisations. Changes within organisations and institutions may reinforce the values of the individuals themselves, that is, a higher number of less aggressive environmental practices possibly raises new values in the community; those values, in turn, may influence the administrative decisions. Partnerships developed with universities, and with the National Center of Clean Technologies, may represent a step towards a more effective insertion of environmental values in organisations. In their relationship with suppliers, some companies attempt to demand environmental responsibility, a requirement of the ISO14000 standard. Complying with such demands becomes easier if the environmental body issues an operation licence; warranting that the company will meet the requirements of the legislation. Other actions developed in partnership with raw material or packaging suppliers are also employed with the aim of increasing profits or reducing costs. The improvement of environmental performance is an additional consequence. Different governance structures were found within the studied companies; they are also ruled by the economising principle. The hierarchy (firm) commands the environmental measures as a way to measure and control environmental indicators for process activities. Waste disposal and part of the planning and implementation of environmental programs, however, including training and process improvement, are ruled by third party agreements. One of the companies, for example, sought long-term contracts, actively participating in suppliers’ environmental audits, whereas others simply controlled their suppliers through a set of pre-established requirements, like operations licences issued and renewed by FEPAM, as a means of avoiding control costs. The common denominator to all companies where in-depth interviews occurred is the existence of an engineering staff responsible for the environmental area, in hierarchically distinct levels. The engineers worked with human resource and product development professionals, indicating an adaptation to the complex institutional environment represented by ecological requirements. Opportunistic behaviours were occasionally noticed. For example, a PVC producer stated its product was recyclable, but did not reveal that PVC has carcinogenic properties (the reason for the ban on PVC toys and medical products in Europe). In general, environmental concern regarding the production process is a manner of avoiding transaction costs that stem from ex post governance, e.g. fine negotiation, conduct codes required by the public power.
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento 5.
25
Discourse, Power and Environment Discourse promotes and reflects power relations. It is simultaneously a text, a discursive practice and a social practice. The text dimension refers to linguistic analysis; the practical dimension is related to the nature of production processes and textual interpretation, namely, the types of discourse and their combinations; the social practice dimension refers to the institutional and organisational context and its influence on the discursive practice. The discursive practice focuses on the concepts of ideology and hegemony that are produced, reproduced and transformed in the discourse.33 For Foucault, discourse involves procedures of exclusion: interdiction - one cannot say whatever one wants in any situation (prohibited words); separation and rejection which generate oppositions in our society such as reasoning and madness, true and false.34 Discourses also possess procedures of control, such as the principle of classification, ordination, distribution, and the determination of conditions of functioning that allows one to become qualified to pronounce a discourse. The position of a subject and his subjectivity constitute the discourse itself which influences the way the discourses are received, interpreted, developed, disseminated. Springett states that the environmental discourse has been highly controlled.35 It emerges from the business discourse like the green business, which does not analysis the exploitation of people and resources. The participants of her research do not seriously question the growing paradigm as the basis for a sustainable future. Growing is seen as necessary to sustain environment and not as its dependent. For Foucault, power is not found in a single aspect, but in power correlations that generate different ever-unstable states of power.36 Power means a multiplicity of forces that belong to the domain that they organise. These forces oppose themselves, design strategies and the institutional framework, and shape power mechanisms that don’t come from a central point like State.37 These relations of power are expressed and constituted in the discourse. Therefore, discourse is the power that is to be seized. For Hardy and Phillips, discourse produces concepts that are ideas that represent our view of the world.38 Concepts can be transformed in time and with respect to the situation producing them, disseminated and interpreted by different social agents. These concepts do not live in harmony. Much to the contrary, they are source of disputes among the agents seeking their legitimacy and hegemony. Different concepts evoke different objects and involve different practices to deal with this object. According to Olivo and Misoczky, in the environmental discourse presented in the Brundtland report, there is a predominance of economic logic to determine the concept of sustainable development and strategic actions of sustainability.39 The logic of life preservation was left
26
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
in second place. Springett points out that the term ‘sustainable development’ is confused with other concepts. Government members, NGOs and companies use concepts such as triple bottom line, sustainability, sustainable management, sustainable growth, and ecoefficiency as synonyms. The confusion is also a reflection of the dispute among agents. Therefore, environmental discourse and its different interpretations and uses involves the understanding of environmental practices not only as efficient ones, but also as those that are better situated in the power space involving governmental agencies, NGOs and society. A. Power Sighs During in-depth interviews, it was possible to identify the green business discourse and a lack of questioning about the ecological limits, since environmental questions were considered efficiency issues linked to processes and profitability. Companies’ preoccupations with their image is also clear in the discourse; the companies under study participated in meetings, seminars, expositions, so as to demonstrate their practices and be seen as environmental leaders, adopting similar strategies for the dissemination of the environmental discourse. Internal dissemination of the discourse is formal, through training, policies, indicators and references, such as boards and sketches placed in a visible spot; it is also accomplished in an informal manner by the environment personnel both within and outside the company. It was possible to observe clashes between FEPAM and companies, companies stating that FEPAM does not participate in the solution of environmental problems, only inspecting and fining. Although not explicitly mentioned by the interviewees, clashes also exist inside companies, between environmental staff and the board, between different departments and different job positions. In such situations it is possible to notice the influence of cultural and local issues related to environmental management. For example; one of the studied companies adopted a closed system of water consumption to respond to pressure from the community and from the public powers. Cultural issues are crucial in country likes Brazil where the choice between economic success and environmental preservation usually involves difficult choices that are to be made in a situation of constant financial difficulties and ideological clashes. Pressure to get a good shortterm financial result usually renders environmental investments unviable. The economic growth and free market ideologies are not questioned in the company, nor by the company representatives, and the environmental discourse is one of transformation and responsibility towards future generations.
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento 6.
27
Final Considerations It is important to stress that this work has not aimed at presenting complementary theories, but different views of the same question. Moreover, the economic approach was favoured because it still is a cornerstone in the environmental practices of companies. This does not mean that the sociological and political approaches are not interesting. On the contrary, their use in the development of new studies is essential to widen the understanding of the relationships among society, economy and environment. Organisational theories that are directed to economic explanations such as those discussed in this study, reveal the importance of the economic aspect in environmental issues, but also point to its limitations. As already mentioned in the introduction, nature-society relations have a complexity that stretch beyond economic explanations. Nevertheless Scientific Management and Simon’s works bring about practices to reduce resources consumption and recognise the need for values, politics, and environmental objectives to be defined; and TCE notice environmental costs and governance structures to give a adequate answer to institutional exigencies, one is led into inquiring whether management practices based on efficiency or economising, such as ISO14000, PML and other market mechanisms, may lead to sustainable development or may represent the maintenance of old environmentally aggressive management practices, especially when profitability levels are at stake. These economic explanations and their associated management practices do not seem to respond to the necessary changes in naturesociety relations as pointed out by the World Bank at World Development Reports and the Worldwatch Institute, and seem to represent global practices based on the Anglo-Saxon management model. However, this model and its intended universality do not satisfy the set of local requirements and characteristics that affect decisions, actions and organisational objectives. Other theories need to be mobilised, together with other viewpoints, so that nature-society relations are understood. Power approaches open perspectives for the understanding of local relationships and their influence on nature-society and on more adequate development options. The power approaches allow us to discuss new environmental values and other questions that are not economic. It was difficult to analyse the data obtained, because they were collected without considering the different theories presented herein. This was particularly relevant during the analysis of the agents’ opportunistic behavior and the environmental discourse and associated power relations. Finally, as stated by Simon, decisions are embodied by values. The choice of theories stemmed from the authors’ need to question environmental practices and their relation to the organisational theory and the economy. The richness of the field seems to open the doors to new
28
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
views that aggregate different understandings about the subject, in the construction of a discussion space where new elements are constantly added. Each element, individually, and their associated relationships, can be responsible for the reconfiguration of the field and a different understanding of nature-society relations.
Notes 1
The culture change could be understood as an effect from training or as an expression from an ancient knowledge set. It could be also a motivation for the next actions. 2 Antonio C. A. Maximiano, Introdução à administração. (5 ed. São Paulo: Atlas, 2000). 3 Bertram M Gross, Organizations and their managing ( New York: The Free Press, 1968). 4 J.G. March, H.A. Simon, Les organisations (12 ed. Paris : Dunod, 1969). 5 Gareth Morgan, Images de l’organisation (Canada: Université Laval et Éditions ESKA, 1989). 6 Frederic W Taylor, La direction scientifique des entreprises (Paris : Dunod, 1971). 7 In the situation described was important also the exigencies from the environmental agency and ecological conscience of the community. 8 Herbert A. Simon, Comportamento administrativo (Rio de Janeiro: USAID, 1965). 9 Utility is the satisfaction level a person experiences when using goods or services. 10 Ibid, 207. 11 Ibid, 209. 12 Herbert A. Simon, “Methodological foundations of economics,” Praxiologles and the philosophy of economics 1 (1992): 25-41. 13 Herbert A. Simon, “Rationality in psychology and economics,” Journal of Business 59 (1986) 209-224. 14 Herbert A. Simon, “On the concept of organizational goal,” Administrative Science Quarterly 9 (1964) 1-22. 15 Simon, 1965. 16 The welfare of the employee could be related to productivity and loyalty to the organization. 17 Cristina A. Carvalho et al., “A inflexão conservadora na trajetória histórica da Teoria Institucional,” CD ROM do XXVIII Encontro Anual da Associação dos Programas de Pós-Graduação em Administração (Curitiba, 2004). 18 Ronald H Coase, “The nature of the firm,” in: The firm, the market, and the law (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1988).
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
29
19
Ronaldo Fiani, “Teoria dos Custos de Transação,” in: Economia Industrial: fundamentos teóricos e práticas no Brasil (Rio de Janeiro: Campus, 2002). 20 Ronald H Coase, “The problem of social cost,” in: The firm, the market, and the law (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1988). 21 A. C Pigou, The economics of welfare, (London: Macmillan and Co., 1960). 22 23
Oliver E. Williamson, “ The new institutional economics: taking stock, looking ahead,” Journal of Economic Literature, 38 (2000) 595-613. 24 Oliver E Williamson, “ Transaction costs economics: how it works; where it is headed,” The Economist 146 (1998). 25 Oliver E Williamson, The mechanisms of governance (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996). 26 Oliver E. Williamson, “The theory of the firm as governance structure: from choice to contract,” Journal of Economic Perspectives 16 (2002) 171-195. 27 Douglass North, Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1990). 28 Christopher S. Boerner, Jeffrey T. Macher, “Transaction costs economics: an assessment of empirical research in social sciences,” Working paper (2005). 29 Thomas Kemp, “Of transactions and transaction costs: uncertainty, policy, and the processes of law in the thought of Commons and Williamson,” Journal of Economic Issues 40 (2006) 45-58. 30 The institutional environment is take-for-granted, which difficult the interaction of the levels. 31 Garret Hardin, “The tragedy of the commons,” Science 162 (1968) 1243-1248. 32 Alessandra Arcuri, “A different reason for “de-coasing” environmental law and economics,” European Journal of Law and Economics, 20 (2005) 225–246. 33 Norman Fairclough, Discurso e mudança social (Brasília: Editora Universidade de Brasília, 2001). 34 Michel Foucault, A ordem do discurso. (São Paulo: Edições Loyola, 2004). 35 Delyse Springett, “Business conceptions of sustainable development: a perspective from critical theory,” Business Strategy and the Environment 12 (2003) 71-86. 36 Michel Foucault, Histoire de lq sexualité I: La volonté de savoir. (Editions Gallimard, 1976). 37 Michel Foucault, Microfísica do poder. (Rio de Janeiro: Edições Graal, 2002).
30
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
38
Cynthia Hardy, Nelson Phillips, “No joking matter: discursive struggle in the canadian refugee system,” Organization studies 20 (1999) 1-24. 39 Vania M.F Olivo, Maria C. A. Misoczky, “As estratégias discursivas presentes na origem do referencial para o desenvolvimento sustentável: uma análise crítica do Relatório de Brundtland. CD ROM do Encontro Nacional sobre Gestão Empresarial e Meio Ambiente (São Paulo, 2003).
Bibliography Arcuri, Alessandra. “A different reason for “de-coasing” environmental law and economics,” European Journal of Law and Economics, 20 (2005) 225–246. Boerner, Christopher S., Macher, Jeffrey T. “Transaction costs economics: an assessment of empirical research in social sciences,” Working paper (2005). Carvalho, Cristina A., Goulart, Sueli, Vieira, Marcelo M. F. “A inflexão conservadora na trajetória histórica da Teoria Institucional,” CD ROM do XXVIII Encontro Anual da Associação dos Programas de Pós-Graduação em Administração.(Curitiba, 2004. Coase, Ronald H. “The nature of the firm,” in: The firm, the market, and the law. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1988. Coase, Ronald H. “The problem of social cost,” in: The firm, the market, and the law. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1988. Fairclough,Norman. Discurso e mudança social. Brasília: Editora Universidade de Brasília, 2001. Fiani, Ronaldo. “Teoria dos Custos de Transação,” in: Economia Industrial: fundamentos teóricos e práticas no Brasil. Rio de Janeiro: Campus, 2002. Foucault, Michel. Histoire de lq sexualité I: La volonté de savoir. Editions Gallimard, 1976. Foucault, Michel. Microfísica do poder. Rio de Janeiro: Edições Graal, 2002. Foucault, Michel. A ordem do discurso. São Paulo: Edições Loyola, 2004.
Doriana Dariot and Luis Felipe Nascimento
31
Gross, Bertram M Organizations and their managing. New York: The Free Press, 1968. Hardin, Garret “The tragedy of the commons,” Science 162 (1968) 12431248. Hardy, Cynthia, Phillips, Nelson. “No joking matter: discursive struggle in the canadian refugee system,” Organization studies 20 (1999) 1-24. Kemp, Thomas. “Of transactions and transaction costs: uncertainty, policy, and the processes of law in the thought of Commons and Williamson,” Journal of Economic Issues 40 (2006) 45-58. March, J.G., Simon, H.A. Les organisations. 12 ed. Paris : Dunod, 1969. Maximiano, Antonio C. A. Introdução à administração. 5 ed. São Paulo: Atlas, 2000. Morgan, Gareth. Images de l’organisation. Canada: Université Laval et Éditions ESKA, 1989. North, Douglass. Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1990. Olivo,Vania M.F., Misoczky, Maria C. A. “As estratégias discursivas presentes na origem do referencial para o desenvolvimento sustentável: uma análise crítica do Relatório de Brundtland. CD ROM do Encontro Nacional sobre Gestão Empresarial e Meio Ambiente. São Paulo, 2003. Pigou, A. C The economics of welfare, 4 ed. London: Macmillan and Co., 1960. Scott, W. Richard. Institutions and organizations, Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications, 1995. Simon, Herbert A. Comportamento administrativo. Rio de Janeiro: USAID, 1965. Simon, Herbert A. “Methodological foundations of economics,” Praxiologles and the philosophy of economics 1 (1992): 25-41. Simon, Herbert A. “Rationality in psychology and economics,” Journal of Business 59 (1986) 209-224.
32
Search for a Theory Linking Environment and Society
Simon, Herbert A. “On the concept of organizational goal,” Administrative Science Quarterly 9 (1964) 1-22. Springett, Delyse. “Business conceptions of sustainable development: a perspective from critical theory,” Business Strategy and the Environment 12 (2003) 71-86. Taylor, Frederic W. La direction scientifique des entreprise. Paris : Dunod, 1971. Williamson, Oliver E. The mechanisms of governance. New York: Oxford University Press, 1996. Williamson, Oliver E “ Transaction costs economics: how it works; where it is headed,” The Economist 146 (1998). Williamson, Oliver E. “ The new institutional economics: taking stock, looking ahead,” Journal of Economic Literature, 38 (2000) 595-613. Williamson, Oliver E. “The theory of the firm as governance structure: from choice to contract,” Journal of Economic Perspectives 16 (2002) 171-195.
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future: Orientations in Perverse Ecologies Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio Abstract A politics of love for an ecologically sustainable future is based on two main ideas: there is an erotic element in all forms of love; and, as in Gaia theory, the biota, or sum of biosphere and atmosphere, is a live being in which humans feature as mere cells. The modern concept of sexuality has resulted in a societal view of selfless forms of erotic love as diseased. The argument proposed here is that the medicalisation of love is in itself a pernicious disease for it places erotic expression under the tyranny of scientific normativity. The healing arts have buffered the effects of this tyranny by relying on imaginativeness and creativity, as well as practice, tradition, and experience. Accordingly, a politics of love that envisages a Gaian post-modernity involves a transmigration of tropes from the healing arts to the loving arts, whereby the semantic realm that modernity describes as sexuality is reconceived as the realm of the arts of loving. In this realm, alternative lovestyles, including those practiced in gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, and polyamorous communities are valued for their sustainability; their emphasis on pleasure, caring, and sharing resources is a boon in the project of containing the dangerous effects of excessive human impact on Gaia. Key Words: Gaia hypothesis; the arts of loving; ecology; erotic expression; biopolitics; sexuality; healing; bisexuality, Polyamory. 1.
Introduction: Selfish and Selfless Love Western modernity’s biopower assumes that there are two distinct kinds of love, one selfless and one selfish. Selfless love includes affection for family members, friends, and fellow travelers in one’s affinity groups; care for the elderly and sick; and the responsibility of selfcare. This allegedly selfless love is also constructed as sexless, and as such it can extend to the concern for one’s communities; it can find a patriotic dimension in the care for one’s homeland; a sacred dimension in the worship of one’s deities; and an ecological dimension in the care for one’s planet. Part of the reason why this love can pass for both selfless and sexless is that it can multiply for as many people as those who need it, for example, a parent’s love multiplies for whatever number of children s/he happens to have. The more selfish counterpart to this allegedly selfless type of love does include a sexual element, with its accompanying romance and erotic expression. This sexual love is often understood as
34
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
selfish because its multiplication is viewed as aberrant and incompatible with this type of love’s very intent. The bio-politics of love I propose exposes this dichotomy as both deluded and self-defeating. Since it hinges on the cultural notion of sexuality, this dichotomy, I propose, may very well only denote the epistemological limitations of Western modernity; such limitations, unfortunately, tend to be in the way of creating an ecologically sustainable Gaian post-modernity. I claim that the dichotomy is deluded because affectional types of love are necessary for our survival as a species, and, therefore, not as selfless as they are believed to be. It is self-defeating because all forms of love have an erotic component the denial of which causes unhappiness and produces substantial amounts of hatred, often enough to defeat the forces of love. 2.
“Sex” Among the Protists: Margulis’ take on Gaia Theory In presenting this bio-politics of love for a Gaian post-modernity, I propose to revisit the concept of sexuality, which, notably in Foucault’s work, has been seen as a social construction of modernity, and which, at this juncture, I claim, is more part of the problem than it is part of the solution. Hence, I direct my attention to new ways to create emotional and erotic sustainability that are not “sexual” in conventional terms. These ways, I suggest, have the merit of empowering people to navigate the postmodern fluxes of today’s globalizing world, and thus generate plateaus of tantric elation, vitality, and creativity. In this context, I invoke the work of Lynn Margulis, a bioscientist whose take on the Gaia hypothesis comes from the perspective of microorganism. Her rigorously scientific argument is both challenging and intriguing. To begin with, Margulis, who often writes with her son Dorion Sagan, and was at one point married to the famous astronomer Carl Sagan, puts human love and life in perspective by reminding us that “the global community of bacteria” which is where the first sex happened, “is four billion years old.”1 This reminder advises humility for the human species. After all, we are the new kids on the block and could very well be the first ones to go too. Bacteria, Margulis explains, have sex when they pick up from, and donate genes to, their neighbours.”2 This form of sex is called mitosis. Bacteria are also promiscuous, and many of them, such as protists, have a natural tendency to engage in “massive org[ies]” in which they “[m]istak[e] food for sex and sex for food.”3 So the perspective presented by Margulis emphasises that in nature sex is neither exclusive nor necessarily related to reproduction. The alleged selfishness of romantic and erotic love that is often used to justify its exclusivity appears to be a mere human invention, not a natural thing, and one would do well to question how attuned to Gaia’s sensibility this invention might be.
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
35
Margulis also emphasises that evolution happens just as much by symbiosis as it does by selection, something Darwin was well aware of but has tended to get lost in the dissemination of his theories. Meiotic sexuality is the sexuality of conjugating haploid cells, namely cells whose genetic information combines when they mate.4 Just as the promiscuity of bacteria is pervasive, as they have sex with any of their neighbours whenever necessary, so the different evolutionary stages of sex occur in organisms at many levels. For example, in men meiosis occurs throughout life as they produce meiotic sperm cells. In women, it only occurs during life in the womb, for at birth all of our meiotic cells, or ova, have already been produced. Sexuality, Margulis further claims, is very similar to symbiosis.5 Indeed, symbiogenesis, or “the formation of new organs and organisms through symbiotic mergers” is as natural in evolution as is socalled natural selection. 6 In her definition of sex, Margulis emphasises that from an evolutionary viewpoint what we moderns know as sexuality is not necessary. As she argues, in the biological sense [sex] . . . is not intrinsically related to reproduction or gender . . . [I]t is a genetic mixing in organisms that operates at a variety of levels . . . and occurs in some organisms at more than one level simultaneously . . . By this definition . . . an influenza virus infecting humans is engaging in sex by inserting its genetic material into the cells of its host. 7 In other words, it is not just the famed “bees” and “flowers” we often use to answer our kids’ questions about where babies come from that are having sex. Sex is happening all the time in our very bodies, with or without our cooperation, thanks to the activities of the orgiastic microorganisms that constitute them. “In this evolutionary side show of odd sex lives,” we are, Margulis argues, “oddly coupled, colossal collections, an orgiastic, if organised, intermingling of beings,” a biological site for bacteria to engage in “advanced sex.”8 Microorganisms, including human cells, bacteria, protists, viruses, and others, engage in “sex” to rejuvenate themselves and to inject new life energy in their species. This happens even as the process often implies death for its individuals, as when a sperm reaches an ovum and both individual cells die to give birth to the embryo. 3.
The Disease of Turning Love into a Disease Even as, by her own admission, Margulis’ views have a history of controversy,9 the notion of sex she proposes, an all-pervasive activity that is neither selfish, nor exclusive, nor necessarily related to
36
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
reproduction, is by now enough accepted in biology as to be the basis for textbooks. I propose that from the humanities isle, those of us who theorise about cultural notions of gender, sexuality, and erotic expression, take notice. Margulis’ biological notion of “sex” is not unrelated to Freud’s psychological notions of an all pervasive eros, or love’s vital energy, which comes with its counterpart, thanatos, a memento mori within the wider life cycles Freud envisaged as a participant in the last fringes of idealist philosophy. These notions can be traced back within the Western tradition to late nineteenth and early twentieth century notions of vitalism, and they also reflect the more recent influence of alternative Eastern traditions, like Tantric Hinduism, which emphasises sacred embodiment and transformation, as well as the notions of a universal life energy embodied in the Buddhist concepts of prana and chi. However, Margulis’ concept of sex is based on the symbiotic love of two Gaian cells ready to die to become one. I would argue that this is the kind of selfless, yet highly erotic love, that, when happening in humans, modern psychoanalytical practices have constructed as a disease a dysfunction of one’s self-preservation system variously classified as enmeshment, codependence, or both. To construct human love as a disease, is, I claim, pernicious to our species and, given the power that humans now have on Gaia, to the whole biota. This construction, not the love therein, is, I submit, the disease. At this end of modernity, I suggest, the whole concept of human sexuality is based on an implied notion of heteronormativity that emphasises its reproductive function, and has recently expanded to include homosexual practices that conform to its alleged monosexual exclusivity. But this expansion is too supervised and puny compared to the more symbiotic and inclusive bio-politics of love Gaia needs. Hence, I want to argue that it is best to envisage the whole concept of sexuality, with the possible, but not granted, exception of bisexuality, on which I will return later, as a construct of modernity whose semantic area stands to gain by being recuperated under a more humanistic aegis, as a pre-modern realm of “the arts of loving,” which is both Gaian and postmodern too. Indeed, as humans we have amply fulfilled the biological impulse to “populate the earth,” which might, at one point, have propelled the reproductive heterosexist imperative of our species. It now becomes us to prove that we can also be considerate of this imperative’s effect and its dangerous impact on Gaia’s global ecosystem. In a Gaian post-modernity, I’d like to suggest, “sex” is erotic expression, the joy of taking and giving, the orgiastic revitalizing pleasures of bacteria. It is the art of loving that lives is the wider space of the arts of healing, and, as an art, is shy of any normativity. This, I submit, is the politics of love that will usher a Gaian post-modernity in and will rehabilitate us as a species that, unlike viruses that do kill their hosts, is
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
37
capable of living in harmony with its hostess, the biota teeming with life that planet Earth now still is. 4.
Tough Love and the Absurd This notion of the biota as a mantle teeming with life whose will is the sum total of all the wills of its interdependent cells is popular in the imagination of countercultural groups like Neopagans, Wiccans, and others who practice living as if the earth was a being with a life and will of its own. The Gaian awareness generated therein implies a large dosage of tough love and a good sense of the absurd. If we are mere cells in Gaia’s superorganism, we can neither be Darwin’s endpoint of biological evolution, nor the special creatures made “in god’s image” suggested by the proponents of creationism. In Gaia, the proponents of this hypothesis further imply, we humans are the scourge of the planet that risks turning its mantle teeming with life back into a rock. One has to admit that it is not very pleasant to think that we might be the virus whose degenerate form of symbiosis eats up the host and thus destroys the virus too. A certain amount of tough love is necessary to come to this unflattering recognition. The pollution we humans produce, the climate changes that ensue, and the indiscriminate use of non-renewable sources of energy that causes it, cannot destroy the hard-rock planet that lies under the biota. But they can kill the biota and us, who are a part of it. Hence the absurdity of our position, when we know that we must love Gaia to love ourselves, even as loving Gaia may imply allowing her to get rid of us. I submit that the biopolitics of love necessary to invent a Gaian post-modernity preside over the vitality and mobility of the cells in Gaia’s body that we are and the exchanges of erotic and affectional energies therein. To return to the macroscopic aspects of this proposition, let me rehearse here that when James Lovelock was part of the first Mars expedition as a probe was sent on that planet to find out if there was water on it, he compared pictures of Mars, Venus, and Earth, all taken from a distance. Both Mars and Venus have atmospheres with 95 percent carbon dioxide, even though Mars is closer to the Sun than Earth, and Venus is more distant. Also both Mars and Venus look a greysh brown, while Earth still looks a bright blue and white, due to the 21 percent oxygen in its atmosphere. Contrary to what previous scientists believed, Lovelock observed, the difference between Mars and Venus on the one side, and Earth on the other, cannot be attributed to Earth’s being just at the “right” distance from the Sun, for that would not explain why its neighbours on opposite sides of the Sun look so alike. It is rather due, Lovelock hypothesised, to the different ages in the biological development of these three superbeings. Mars and Venus have already concluded their respective life cycles, while Earth is still in it. This inscribes the whole of our species into the wider life cycle of the superorganism that hosts it -
38
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
hence the awareness that there are no intrinsic reasons why Earth and its neighbours should be so different. This sense of the absurd makes us humans look so little - perched on a precarious biota that could disappear. It also gives new meaning to Western modernity’s relentless effort to achieve the mastery of nature it believes to be necessary - an effort that, predictably, has turned out to be deluded. 5.
Un-Mastering Nature and Surrendering one’s Anxieties to It Feminist discourses that reflect the perspectives and understandings of women in a variety of situatednesses, now include ecological feminism, which, with its emphasis on gender as ecology and on the ecology of gender, has made significant contributions to correcting western modernity’s self-serving and dangerous belief system. Its more gnoseological view of nature can be traced back to pre- and early-modern times in the Western system and still prevails among indigenous people. Hence, in the perspectives proposed by Val Plumwood, Karen Warren, Carol Adams, Shamara Shantu-Riley, Paula Gunn Allen, and many other voices, the idea that humans can master nature is but a myth of modernity that became more prominent with secularism and the scientific and industrial revolutions. Their view of nature includes humans and emphasises modes of knowledge that are both secular and spiritual and aspire to sustainable, harmonious forms of coexistence rather than mastery. The reality, these theorists affirm, is that humans cannot master nature and there is no reason why they should. Indeed, the more intent we become in this effort, the more the ever changing body of nature becomes elusive, with us deluded about a control impossible to achieve, and unable to benefit from the more realistic project of supporting nature and aligning our intents with hers. The belief that one can master nature implies reducing those who do not fit in the Cartesian category of res cogitans to mere resources. Historically, this category technically reserved to things has often included humans, conveniently redefined as racially or otherwise inferior slaves, as uncivilised savages, as incomplete or otherwise deficient women, and in general as people who, in one way or another, fall short of some or another basic human characteristics. Traditionally, the category of mere resources has also of course included animals raised for food, as well as most forests, bodies of water, gases, and minerals. In a Gaian perspective the concept of ‘mere resources’ becomes useless, for in Gaia there are no mere resources, and everything has purpose, intention, meaning. This is the secular spirituality we humans need in order to create the sustainable other possible worlds of the future. The main claim in the new bio-politics of love I propose is that the accepted view that reduces parts of Gaia’s body to mere resources is the actual source of today’s global anxieties, for the current consumption
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
39
of resources this anxiety produces is unsustainable and this undertow of incongruity is anxiety producing at the global level - with the West’s most overdeveloped countries most severely affected. The energy crisis the system is in requires a new balance in biopower. The unfortunate reality is that non-violent alternative views are scarcely accessible to most people due to a barrage in the mainstream media and polarisations in the educational systems.10 As most people with a sound sense of ecology and a peaceful spirit will agree, oil wars will not resolve the energy crisis. I submit that a different way of thinking about ‘mere resources’ will. I believe that the political problem of today is a problem of love because only hatred and fear can cause people to construct enemies that do not exist - while they ignore the most serious and impending issues. I propose holism as an ecologically-sound approach to bio-political issues that heals the thought system that causes anxiety, rather than attacking the enemies this system constructs. Love is therefore the problem which is also the solution of modernity’s diseases and the absurd position these diseases put us humans in. In homeopathic terms, love is the disease which is the cure. Indeed, if as humans aware of being mere cells in Gaia’s organism, we could love as selflessly as the two unicellular organisms who die to merge into one larger symbiotic being, we could perhaps cure ourselves of modernity’s diseases. 6.
Eros and the Arts of Loving In today’s ecological debates, a Gaian awareness indicates that love is the issue. Therefore one must explore what is problematic in the current cultural construction of love. Sexuality is that particular aspect of love that western modernity constructs as exclusive, and therefore ‘selfish,’ and which, unlike the supposedly ‘selfless’ types of love, is governed by the incest taboo. Historically, the concept of sexuality came into being with modernity to bring under scientific jurisdiction knowledge about what had theretofore been thought of as ars erotica, ars amatoria, pleasure, and ‘sin.’ The modern concept of sexuality freed erotic love and the art of its expression from the dogmatic jurisdiction of organised religions like Christianity, which, in its various forms, concurred in defining it as sin, unless practiced under its aegis and rules. To the extent that it did, the concept of sexuality is of course part of the cure. But the side effect of this cure is that love is no longer an art or a gift, but rather a dysfunction. Love has turned out to be the disease ‘sexuality’ set out to cure. Hence, the semantic area that modern discourses designate as sexuality is the solution which is the problem, the cure which is the disease. Indeed, with Freud, psychoanalysis has been configured as the study of ‘sexuality,’ a process that turns the ars erotica and ars amatoria
40
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
celebrated by Ovid and other classical authors into a field of scientific inquiry, free of religious dogma and the stigma of ‘sin.’ But with ‘sexuality’ these ‘arts’ ceased to be viewed as artistic, and became objects of scientific investigation at a time when the objectivity of science was not disputed and when science was intent in establishing universal laws. Hence, ‘sexuality’ subjected the former arts of love to the scientific tyranny of normativity. Furthermore, it reduced sex to ‘nature’ in the modern sense: a ‘mere resource,’ a utility for the achievement of material happiness as defined by modernity’s secularism. This placed erotic expression under a new and perhaps worse tyranny, all of which has produced the impasse in which western discourse about eros is now mired. The bio-politics I propose envisage a solution. It describes sexuality as that which connotes a pleasure from without. It is that which induces desire, and the desire to desire what others desire Girard has so aptly theorized in his work on mimesis.11 This process abets capitalistic production and its accompanying excessive consumerism. On the other hand, I propose that eros connote that which can be described as a pleasure from within, with this pleasure being what enables cognitive, epistemological explorations of a person or group of persons’ unique needs, based on intimate connectedness with others and with one’s inner being. In this perspective, it is easier to envisage new bio-political conceptualisations of that cure/disease that erotic and romantic love can be. 7.
Pleasures, Gnosis, Plateaus, and Love’s Wisdom Inasmuch as it is a reaction to modernity, post-modernity tends to question what modernity takes for granted. For example, theorists of postmodernity like Deleuze and Guattari propose paradigms that enable the global peace and justice movement to envisage the “other possible worlds” we need to survive western modernity as a planet and species - with many activists in the global peace and justice movement eagerly referring to them. An important area in which this reaction is happening is the healing arts, whose practitioners are reclaiming the ability to restore health and offset disease as an art that relies on imaginativeness and creativity, and therefore lies outside the realm of a merely secular, scientific normativity. They effectively use clinical evidence, indigenous knowledge, practices of the body, touch, food, ritual, and tradition as part of their healing-arts repertoire. I claim that a similar move is necessary in the realm of erotic expression. If the cultural construct of sexuality is in the way of a successful exit from the tunnel of modernity, I propose the solution of getting rid of it, and replacing it with an expanded concept of the healing arts that includes the arts of loving and lives in the interstitial zone between epistemology and hermeneutics. This ‘knowledge in the making’ is based on practice and intuition, and, I claim, is very similar to what the
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
41
French feminist philosopher Luce Irigaray calls theosophy, namely a knowledge of the sacred inspired by love. It is also what inspires scientists whose genius dares to challenge the status quo our system of knowledge is mired in, including, of course, James Lovelock and Lynn Margulis. After all, if, as Margulis implies, everything is “sex,” then it may as well be said that nothing is. In this context, the trajectory I propose here for a bio-political theorisation of the arts of loving as a Gaian concept begins with Michel Foucault’s pre-modern nostalgia and arrives at Luce Irigaray’s eastern turn via the alternative globalisation theories proposed by the two male duos most respected in the global peace and justice movement, the French philosopher Gilles Deleuze and psychoanalysts Felix Guattari; and the north American Italianist Michael Hardt and Italian political theorist Antonio Negri. In his well known History of Sexuality, Vol. 1, Foucault makes an important claim about eros. As he explains, In the erotic art, truth is drawn from pleasure itself, understood as a practice and accumulated experience [and] evaluated in terms of intensity, its specific quality, its duration, its reverberation in the body and the soul. 12 In this important passage, the theorist clearly establishes a semantic space for erotic love which lies outside any religious or scientific jurisdiction. The measure of erotic love is pleasure, a pleasure that has a spiritual dimension and is enhanced by one’s skilful practice of it, a practice that presumably banks on experience. It is precisely this spiritual dimension of erotic pleasure that Foucault’s pre-modern nostalgia seeks to recuperate for modernity, and, I claim, actually ends up projecting into a postmodern direction. On the other hand, Irigaray’s ‘eastern turn’ marks her decision to seek answers to modernity’s problems in a supposed outside to the Western tradition. In her recent book, The Way of Love, she directly confronts the issue of what love is or can be in modernity by having love, and the ways in which it finds its expressions, be the topic of her book. Her central claim is that philosophy is not merely “the love of wisdom,” but also, and perhaps more importantly, “the wisdom of love.” In her etymological discussion of how the word philosophy came to be, she suggests that “[t]he wisdom of love is perhaps the first meaning of the word ‘philosophy’.”13 With this rather bold statement, Irigaray stands all of western philosophy on its head. She shows that all of the canonical white male philosophers who were animated by a generic ‘love for wisdom’ have looked everywhere is search of this wisdom but in the very love that animated that search to begin with. Foucault’s and Irigaray’s
42
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
propositions reflect distant yet interconnected perspectives and positions, and I propose that the theoretical, historical, and cultural space between them is where the concept of the arts of loving lives. Foucault’s stance reflects the pre-modern nostalgia that pervades his work, with its soft-spot for aristocratic refinement and indulgence - the cultural niche where pleasure supposedly had citizenship, as in the lives of those who lived on the fringes of the Ancien Régime. On the pre-modern side Foucault aligns pleasure, ars erotica, the practices of the body he often indicates as the most effective antidotes to modernity, and the reverberations in the soul that accompany them. On the other hand, he aligns with modernity the very concept of sexuality, with its attendant science of psychology, both of which result in the forms of surveillance he execrates so vehemently elsewhere in his work, and the ensuing enforcement of a scientifically-based normativity. I don’t have trouble imagining the semi-closeted gay man indulging his pleasures and eschewing surveillance and normativity, but also seeking in these pleasures redemption from modernity’s secular materialism. On the other hand stands Irigaray’s eastern turn, with its emphasis on the Tantric tradition, and its parallel search for alternative models of masculinity in An Ethics of Sexual Difference. As Simone Roberts aptly comments, for the French feminist philosopher, Western masculinity emphasises control over intimacy. As she explains, Irigaray’s eastern turn points to a situation in which control has become a central characteristic of masculinity under patriarchy . . . which fuels fear (of losing control, or seeming to be out of control), competition and aggression (in order to get control), and has the effect of cutting men off from the possibility of emotional intimacy (out of control) (26-29). . . A dominant person who creates their sense of control and safety with the tools of fear and (potential) violence must live paranoid that the repressed group or person will rebel and undermine their control and authority. 14 If control acts like a cultural imperative that dominates modern philosophical discourse, this is reflected in Western modernity’s obsession with the mastery of nature, and the inherently self-destructive masculinity ecofeminism so eloquently points to. Roberts suggests that Irigaray’s interest for Eastern philosophy is a way to evade this control and tap into sources less contaminated by it. As she explains, the Tantric tradition is seen as oppositional within Hinduism, even as it is included in the system. The Vedantic tradition emphasises asceticism, sees the world as an illusion and embodiment as a defeat, and constructs each reincarnation as
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
43
a further deferment of the final and desired unity with the divine. The Tantric tradition, on the other hand, emphasises embodiment and constructs the world as a body of multiplicity that loves in divine unity. Pleasure is in the making and/or doing of this ongoing multiplicity, where plateaus of tantric ecstasy are reached when control is released. In a string of books since the 1990s, Irigaray has tapped Eastern philosophy in search of answers to the questions left open by the Western tradition. This quest seems to have culminated in the design of The Way of Love and claims therein. After 3000 years of alleged love for wisdom and vain searching for it, when Irigaray comes along philosophy discovers that its name actually means “the wisdom of love” and not simply “the love of wisdom.” Thereby, Irigaray points out, one finds that it is in love that wisdom resides. The irony here is that all the philosophers, who have been looking for wisdom by elaborating discursive mastery and control systems, are now faced with the proposition that what they sought was in the very unconditional, control-free love for it they were unable to offer. This symbiotic love is both selfless and selfish, and that is its wisdom. The pink heart-shaped image filled with tree branches and leaves on the cover of Irigaray’s book symbolizes this surrender to a mode of knowledge that has love as its path and medium. And precisely because the wisdom of love is a form of knowledge that has love as its path and medium, as its goal and means, The Way of Love can be seen as a manifestation of what Mignolo presents as gnosis in his postcolonial theory. Indeed, the wisdom of love, namely Irigaray’s philosophy, is a knowledge-in-the-making based on practice and intuition that corresponds to it. If bacterial orgiastic tendencies and promiscuity are “advanced sex,” and if they have been welcome guests of Gaia’s body for four billion years, then maybe at this juncture we humans can learn something from bacteria too. The gnosis implied in Irigaray and Mignolo’s vision is another facet of the erotic dance whose mystery Margulis and Sagan propose to unveil by going at evolution backwards, by turning one’s face towards the past as in a Navajo metaphor for history. 15 When pursued under the aegis of the arts and humanities, this gnosis can thrive for the following reasons: in the arts and humanities, erotic expression can be understood as an art that can be learned; as in the fine arts, there is no normativity, but creativity and originality are the gist of it; and, as in the healing arts, practice, style, sensibility, taste, and variety are all but encouraged. 8. Ecological Orientations of the Erotic In this context, all non-normative forms of erotic expressions, including homosexuality, lesbianism, fetishism, transgenderism, bisexuality, and polyamory can be seen as ecological orientations that contribute to creating the “other possible worlds” advocated by the global peace and
44
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
justice movement. The alternative lovestyles that in Krafft-Ebing’s sexological times were categorized as ‘perversion’ have since made a concerted effort to be included into an expanded realm of normativity. I propose that they can now be reconceptualised as part of a realm that defies regulation to begin with, and that there is, therefore, a recognizable ecological intention in them. Indeed, as arts, the arts of loving can only thrive in the wider space of imaginativeness and creativity, a realm that extends to include all genuine erotic expressions involving humans. Most gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender activists and sympathisers agree that queer people can make good parents and are prepared to support LGBT rights in this area. Nonetheless, queer communities are aware that same-sex couples are less likely to contribute to the globe’s overpopulation, which is, ecologically speaking, a very good thing. With the count of humans on the planet now at six billions, the creationist mandate to ‘go and multiply’ has clearly been fulfilled. The new ecological imperative is that of containing the excessive spread of our species. This bio-politics of love privileges the erotic arts that emphasise pleasure, health, care, affection, and well being, over those that obey the impulse to provide continuity for one’s individual genes. To the unaccustomed liberal observers for whom these styles of love occur as orientations in perverse ecology, I suggest learning from them, since they often encourage an ethos of racial and cultural hybridism that offsets most damages of racial, ethnic, and cultural competition. Some of these orientations in perverse ecology have already accessed the realm of desire; they have already acquired a certain legitimacy. Others are still more purely in the erotic realm. For example, civil unions of same-gender couples are now legal in some states of the union, but polyamorous communities in the US have not yet staked their claims for plural marriages. In bi and poly activist communities, the homophobic paranoia of the “red states,” which brought the fundamentalist vote to the polls in the recent US election, is read as proof that the inevitable is occurring. Why would the Christian Coalition be so concerned if not because more and more people question sanctified sex and its alleged normativities? Indeed, when one learns that in Spain, home to the infamous Inquisition and traditionally one of the most conservative countries in Europe, the current progressive government has approved of gay civil unions, one may very well believe them, even though many US bi and poly activists feel that same-gender unions must be more widely accepted before the legalization of group marriage can be proposed. 16 As they have accessed the realm of desire, the newly admitted lovestyles have also changed the rules that govern it. For example, male homosexuality’s successful claims to legitimacy have expanded the modern scope of erotic expression to include the reproduction-free and erotically rich anal pleasure. Lesbianism has legitimated women’s desire
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
45
to desire other women, and our multiple styles of pleasure, including the unreproductive labial and clitoral pleasures. Bisexuality busts the modern divide between straights and queers while it enhances the gnoseological value of erotic expressions inclusive of both genders and the specific pleasures that reside in each, both simultaneously and sequentially. It is a portal between modernity and its dichotomous construction of sexuality as either hetero or homo, and a Gaian post-modernity where the pre-modern returns through the persistent notion of bisexedness implied in it; the idea that, as Betty Dodson puts it, by just touching our genitals, by making love to ourselves, “we are all quite queer.”17 Polyamory expands bisexuality’s emphasis on plural erotic experiences to the exploration of plural amorous relationship that happen in the context of one’s families and communities. Both these lovestyles are barely on the threshold of making a move toward establishing their own legitimacy.18 Polyamory’s focus on parenting contributes to legitimating alternative family styles. Fetishism has made no major claims to legitimacy yet, yet it is practiced in different guises and in a variety of erotic communities. The new spin it puts on “things” points to the awareness implied in the idea that, in Gaia, there are no “mere resources,” but only objects of love and affection. Transgenderism, whose claims to legitimacy often align with the logic of the conventional twogender medical system, defeats gender binarisms and emphasises the eroticism of the “in-between.” Reconfigured as ecological erotic orientations, the lovestyles that correspond to former perversions are found to have a positive effect on Gaia’s health for various reasons: they multiply the possibilities of love; they help to expand the boundaries of the loving arts; and they contribute to establishing regimes of love that help in the sharing of resources and the creation of sustainable emotional communities. In view of post-modern theory, these reconfigurations, I claim, are essential to a Gaian postmodernity. For Deleuze and Guattari, resilent life is rhizomatic, it is made of a multiplicity of elements in a free-range order, with each element different from the next, yet all recognizably part of the whole. The two theorists further claim that post-modernity is characterized by the fluxes of energy that emanate from the deterritorialisations and reterritorialisations globalisation produces. When navigated adeptly, these fluxes produce the plateaus that help people find purpose and meaning. Their plateau theory suggests that by navigating fluxes with intentions that may be at odds with those of corporate globalisation forces, the communities that share these intentions can produce tantric plateaus that anticipate the “other possible worlds” auspicated by the global peace and justice movement. The theories about community formation that Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri present in Multitudes expand on Deleuze and Guattari’s intuitions. These authors describe the postmodern multitudes that become empowered to effect change as the ones that organise in rhizome-shaped
46
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
“distributed networks”; these non-territorially based communities are often organised in cyberspace via digital technology. The digital waves of “swarm intelligence” that traverse these groups allow them to operate in respectful, de-centered, ways and come together occasionally in concerted unison. When pranic forces are at play, the group enhances the strength of its individuals. As for Margulis’ microbes, the principle applies that “being with others is good for you.” Being deprived of pleasure is bad for immunity, while a moderate exposure to “others” is only good for one’s defense system. Love rejuvenates the system. Understanding love as an art helps to see longevity as a virtue, for as one learns more one becomes a better teacher. It also helps young people look forward to a beautiful and joyous future when they will be older too. Love is free and it can be multiplied at will. It is a renewable resource that saves one from the trappings of useless consumerism. One only has to participate in a few bisexual and/or polyamorous support group meetings, community conferences, and discussion groups to become aware of how close to these descriptions the group dynamic therein can be. In my experience as a bi and poly community member, facilitator, and activist I have participated in several editions of the poly conferences LovingMore and Poly Living, and I have also been a cocoordinator of the San Diego based bisexual community association known as Bi Forum. Because of the confidentiality of these experiences, I do not report directly about them here. I feel a need to protect my communities from the risk of exposure to the mainstream, a risk enhanced by the current conservative climate and by their being still largely outside of the desire zone, at least with respect to the narrow screen of American academic discourse. It is this narrowness that I want to pierce through, so that the connections between ecology and eros can be seen. Some academics, even in queer studies, still wonder whether bisexuals really exist. In a conference in Italian Studies I presented a reading of Hamam, an Italian film by Ferzan Ozpetek, a director from Turkey. Its climactic scene shows a bisexual kiss in which a gay man and a woman in the process of becoming queer imagine the late male lover they shared. To represent this fantasy, the director inserts two split-second cuts of the dead bisexual man kissing his male lover and his now widowed wife. In my presentation, I isolated the cut so everyone could see it. It was technically difficult, because the director had made it so brief as to be almost invisible. It was intended to operate subliminally. But it was there. The panel organiser asked me, “how did you see it?” The answer was simple, “I knew it could be there because I know that bisexuality exists.” It is as a person who straddles the ground between the ivory tower and my beloved communities that I present my biopolitical propositions, as a theorist who refuses to be locked in and takes on the responsibility of
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
47
finding out what is rather than serving the interests of preconceived notions of being. 9.
Conclusion A politics of love that envisages a Gaian post-modernity involves a transmigration of tropes from the healing arts to the loving arts, whereby the semantic realm that modernity describes as sexuality is reconceived as the realm of the arts of loving. In this realm, erotic and affectional expressions of love commingle and share legitimacy, as they do in the Cuddle Parties my bi and poly friends and I go to. The healing arts emphasise practices of the body that, in Foucault’s vision, redeem people from modernity’s secular materialism. They are effective through the empowerment of healing persons and communities, and this effectiveness can be measured via practice, experience, and tradition. They treat the mind and body as a unit and consider meditation and self-awareness as keys to healing Irigaray’s focus on love as philosophical wisdom allows the shift from the healing-arts practices to the arts of loving. An examination of how these arts feature in alternative lovestyles communities reveals their intentional ability to organise as Deleuzian rhizomes and plateaus where the principles that govern the healing arts extend to the erotic and affectional realms. In this context, erotic expression is a practice of the body attuned to Foucault’s theory. While the sexuality invented by Western modernity presumes that each sexual player has an innate, instinctual truth to be found in the process of becoming who this person was meant to be, erotic expression is about imagination, energy fluxes, adaptability, and resilience. It is a fine-arts skill that improves with experience. In both persons and groups, it gets better with age for we become more knowledgeable of it. The bio-politics of love I propose may not instantly resolve all global problems, but the perspective it puts things in does encourage better global ecologies. Good health is conducive of good erotic activity and the pleasures it brings, and the lovestyles that ecological orientations encourage are also conducive of good body ecology and the health benefits it brings. The body is nature’s temple and the erotic expressions it participates in worship its beauty, knowledge, and experience. In a Gaian post-modernity, the arts of healing and loving are manifestations of affectionate and erotic love in a space of Gaian awareness where the sacred is present. Every time a loving reciprocity occurs, Irigaray’s “I love to you” manifests Gaia’s healing erotic energy in the cells of Gaia’s body that this reciprocity engages. An “I” makes love to the divine in a “you.” It turns out that Foucault’s nostalgic ars erotica is also an ars amatoria and an ars sacra.
48
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
Notes 1
Margulis, 1991: 27. Margulis, 1997: 285-86. 3 Margulis, 1991: 189-90 (quotation), 2001-2 and passim. 4 Margulis, 1997: 295-306 and 289. 5 Margulis, 1991: 190 and 303. 6 Margulis, 1998: 33. 7 Margulis, 1997: 285. 8 Margulis, 1991: 190 and 202. 9 Margulis ,1998: 13-32. 10 One notable attempt to break though this barrage is Al Gore’s film, An Inconvenient Truth, on the facts of global warming and the political interests that make it difficult to face its threats. 11 Girard 1990: passim. 12 Foucault, 1990: 57. 13 Irigaray, 2002: 1. 14 Roberts, 2004, par. 9. 15 Margulis, 1991: 29. 16 For poly marriage see Aviram 2005; for gay marriage in Spain see Zapatero 2005. 17 Dodson, 2005. 18 The HBO new serial Big Love is about a family of lapsed Mormons who practice a woman-friendly yet asymmetric form of polygamy. The serial has brought the issue of enforced monogamy to the attention of a wider public, even though the show has so far avoided women’s non-monogamy and bisexuality issues. Polyamorist groups, who practice forms of responsible non-monogamy inclusive of both genders and often of bisexual expression too, discuss its effects in and out of their communities. 2
Bibliography Adams, Carol ed. Ecofeminism and the Sacred. New York: Continuum, 1993. Big Love. Playtone Producers, 2005-06. Casanova, Giacomo. The Story of My Life. Sartarelli, Stephen and Sophie Hawkes trs. London: Penguin, 2001.
Serena Anderlini D’Onofrio
49
Deleuze, Gilles, and Felix Guattari. A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Tr. Brian Massumi. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1987. Deleuze, Gilles, and Felix Guattari. Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Tr. Robert Hurley. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1983. Dodson, Betty. “We Are All Quite Queer.” In Plural Loves. (155-164.) Serena Anderlini D'Onofrio ed. Binghamton, NY: The Haworth Press, 2005. Foucault, Michel. Discipline and Punish. New York: Pantheon, 1977. Foucault, Michel. The History of Sexuality, Vol. 1. Tr. Robert Hurley. New York: Vintage, 1990. Girard, René. Deceit, Desire, and the Novel. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990. Guggenheim, Davis. An Inconvenient Truth. (Film with Al Gore.) Laurie David, Lawrence Bender and Scott Z. Burns Producers: 2005. Gunn Allen, Paula. The Sacred Hoop: Recovering the Feminine in American Indian Traditions. Boston: Beacon Press, 1986. Hardt, Michael, and Antonio Negri. Empire. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2000. Hardt, Michael, and Antonio Negri. Multitude: War and Democracy in the Age of Empire. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2004. Irigaray, Luce. The Way of Love. London: Continuum, 2002. Lovelock, James. Gaia: A New Look at Life on Earth. Oxford University Press, 1979. Lovelock, James. The Ages of Gaia: A Biography of Our Living Earth. New York: Commonwealth Fund, 1988. Margulis, Lynn. “Big Trouble in Biology.” In Slanted Truths: Essays on Gaia, Symbiosis, and Evolution (266-282). New York: Copernicus, 1997.
50
Gaia: The Politics of Love and the Globe’s Future
Margulis, Lynn. Symbiotic Planet: A New Look at Evolution. New York: Basic Books, 1998. Margulis Lynn and Dorion Sagan eds. Slanted Truths: Essays on Gaia, Symbiosis, and Evolution. New York: Copernicus, 1997. Plumwood, Val. Feminism and the Mastery of Nature. London: Routledge, 1993. Pratt, Mary Louise. Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation. London: Routledge, 1992. Roberts, Simone. “Irigaray’s Eastern Turn: The Tantra of An Ethics of Sexual Difference.” Rhizomes: 9 (Fall 2004): http://www.rhizomes.net/issue9/issue9.htm Shantu Riley, Shamara. “Ecology is a Sistah’s Issue Too.” In Carol Adams ed. Ecofeminism and the Sacred. Carol Adams ed. New York: Continuum, 1993. Warren Karen ed. Ecological Feminist Philosophies. Bloomington: Indian University Press, 1996. Zapatero, José Luis. “La ley de matrimonios gay.” Speech delivered to the Spanish Congress on June 30th, 2005.
Section 2 Framework
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope Kendal Hodgman Abstract This paper tells the story of Sustainability1 in action. It is a story of hope, celebration and co-operation in a major public administration in Australia. So often the message of Sustainability is overshadowed by the seeming hopelessness of the enormous environmental, social and economic problems facing the planet. This paper looks at how the effective communication of established Sustainability knowledge and practice can act as an inspirational and empowering change agent in a whole of government context. The paper outlines the Sustainability Analysis Framework (SAF). The SAF is a novel whole of government mechanism for evaluating and communicating Sustainability initiatives, issues, practice and models. Moreover, it identifies best practice and innovation, along with the wisdom gained from service delivery within Sustainability thinking. It also has a powerful educative capacity, in that public administrators, through their interaction with the simple whole of government mechanisms, are given a practical understanding of the importance of integrating social, economic and environmental considerations in their decision-making. The SAF has now been deployed across thirty-eight agencies in the largest State administration in Australia, the Government of New South Wales, but has general applicability. Key words: Communication; Knowledge; Language; Visualisation; Economic Rationalism; Whole of Government. 1.
Preamble If you want to build a ship, don't herd people together to collect wood and don't assign them tasks and work, but rather teach them to long for the endless immensity of the sea.
Antoine de Saint-Exupery (quoted above) was a master of capturing imaginations. His Little Prince, first published in 1943, is reputedly the third most widely sold book on the planet after The Bible and Das Kapital. The simple story of interplanetary adventure and the little prince’s yearning for his beloved rose delivers a compelling message of the paramount importance of love, home, togetherness and care. Its tender message, “What is most important is invisible…”2 has touched the
54
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
hearts of millions, yet, sadly, it seems often forgotten in the hurry of life on Earth, where time and value are now bound up with money and power. Understanding our inter-connectedness with all of life, past, present and future and the importance of care in all our relationships is fundamental to Sustainability philosophy. It is this philosophy which has guided the author in devising the Sustainability Analysis Framework, the structure and deployment of which is the focus of this paper. It is, thus, timely to briefly outline the principles of Sustainability thinking.
2.
The Fragmentation of Knowledge We are living in a world of increasing complexity. The natural systems upon which we rely for survival are depleting, collapsing and transforming at a rate never before experienced.3 Additionally and simultaneously, as our natural world’s components have been splintering under the pressure of humanity’s demands upon it, so have our social frameworks. Social fragmentation has increased exponentially with the onset of the industrialisation, mechanisation, globalisation and corporatisation of the world’s economic systems. This, in turn, has resulted in an ever increasing compartmentalisation of knowledge and action. With this specialisation of knowledge we have lost our sense of interconnectedness with the larger whole. We have stopped thinking about the myriad consequences of our behaviour. Sustainability thinking aims to address this imbalance. Sustainability’s overarching philosophy links social, economic and environmental aspects in the decision-making process. Sustainability thinking remembers that for every cause there is an effect. Sustainability thinking acknowledges that we are responsible for our actions and for the cumulative impact of our choices. Sustainability thinking understands that we are responsible for the life we choose to live and how that impacts on the lives of others, human and otherwise, alive or, as yet, unborn. Sustainability thinking realises that life on Earth is in jeopardy. 3.
Thinking with ‘The End’ in Mind The sad fact is that Sustainability thinking is not new. Indeed, the sounding of the alarm about the earth’s inability to withstand the modern human assault has been growing louder over the last fifty years. For decades, eminent scientists have been presenting data asserting the urgency of the emergency. The global community’s demand for a change in human attitude and behaviour towards the earth and each other has been reverberating since the 1972 United Nations Conference on the Human Environment, and more particularly the Rio Earth Summit of 1993. Yet, so many political and corporate leaders, armed with this knowledge, have continued to throw caution to the wind. They have, on the whole, acted too slowly, if at all. Instead, they have ignored the message or decried it as being alarmist propaganda from the enemies of the prevailing political and
Kendal Hodgman
55
economic orders. Otherwise, they have sheltered on the sidelines of scientific debate, waiting for an unequivocal statement from the scientific community that human activity is the major contributor to the current and impending crises. That unequivocal statement was finally made this year by the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the working group of around 3,000 of the world’s leading experts in the field, from 113 countries. Launching the 2007 IPCC Report in Paris, the co-chair of the working group Susan Solomon stated: “Warming of the climate system is now unequivocal… There can be no question that the increases in these greenhouse gases are dominated by human activity.” Hitherto, the political stalling has taken advantage of natural scientists’ reluctance to issue definite statements apportioning blame or to forecast predictions when they are dealing with such complex systems as biology, ecology, climatology, hydrology, oceanography and the like. Economics, on the other hand, which has proven itself to be an inaccurate social science, is not nearly as shy in asserting its predictions of the complex systems of human and market behaviour. In much of the world, economic predictions and data continue to drive the political agenda, in spite of economists’ dismal record of inaccurate forecasts and inappropriate direction, which often have had devastating effects. Nevertheless, the natural scientists’ hesitancy in issuing edicts about the deteriorating state of the environment has been convenient for the prevailing neo-conservative economists and politicians who advocate the universal capacity of the globalised, ‘free’ markets, generally known as ‘The Market’, to deal with any crisis. Yet, we are now in the midst of, arguably, the biggest crisis humanity has ever faced and so far, ‘The Market’ has failed to deal with it. Indeed, Sir Nicholas Stern, one of the world’s most respected economists, has stunned the sceptics by stating that: “Climate change…is the greatest and widest-ranging market failure ever seen.”4 The author would argue that biodiversity loss, along with other phenomena such as deforestation, desertification, the consequences of human alteration of land and water scapes, are equally devastating consequences of market failure. Such argument aside, ‘The Market’ has not proved itself up to the task of rectifying the natural balance, necessary to avert what is acknowledged as the Sixth Species Extinction Event in the Earth’s history.5 It is glaringly obvious that united and urgent action is needed now and that a power system with economics at the helm is not the answer. Sustainability posits an alternative, holistic approach to stewardship and decision-making. It suggests that trade-offs are the last resort and that, instead, social, economic and environmental considerations should be given equal weighting in decision-making and policy direction. However, given the ascendancy of economic rationalism in the current governance paradigm, we need to ask how can social and environmental considerations gain equal standing in the negotiating space?
56
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
The SAF is a model, albeit a fledgling one, which goes towards providing part of the solution. The SAF has been implemented across thirty-eight agencies in the largest State Government in Australia, the Government of New South Wales (NSW). It has demonstrated that a whole of government perspective for evaluating and communicating Sustainability initiatives, issues, practice and models is achievable. 4.
Positioning Sustainability in Governance in NSW The full gamut of the Australian governance structure in respect of Sustainability is outside this paper’s scope. However, it is important to understand that the Commonwealth of Australia is a Federation of States. Each State Parliament has the constitutional authority to make laws on any subject of relevance to that State, meaning that, to a great extent, the States are, in many areas, stewards of their own destiny. NSW is Australia’s most populous state, with more than 6.6 million residents. Sydney, Australia’s only global city, is the NSW capital. Boasting the largest and most diverse economy in Australia, the NSW economy, alone, is larger than the national economies of Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore, the Philippines and New Zealand. With a Gross State Product of A$250 billion, NSW is undoubtedly the powerhouse of the Australian economy, which is the fifteenth largest in the world.6 The NSW Government has, for the past decade and a half, committed itself, in its rhetoric and in a legislative and policy sense, to the principles of Sustainability. Despite this, NSW, like Australia and the world generally, continues to slide backwards in its quest for Sustainability.7 Sustainability is an emerging area of administrative endeavour, with little global experience or wisdom to guide its process. It is to this end that the NSW Government commissioned the author, in 2004, to evaluate its extensive and diverse Sustainability practice in the report entitled: Sustainability: A New South Wales Whole of Government Approach (‘The Report’).8 The level of the NSW Government’s commitment to this process is evidenced by the fact that it was coordinated at the highest levels of the administration and engaged highlevel input from a comprehensive portfolio of its agencies. It is notable that the project was undertaken through the NSW Premier’s Department and was given high priority status. The request for data, entitled The Sustainability Survey of NSW Government Agencies (‘The Survey’) was sent from the Director General of the Premier’s Department to other Directors-General or Chief Executive Officers. The project’s high status was critical in obtaining timely responses and gave the author extensive access to the Government’s Sustainability data. The Survey had requested selected agencies to submit all legislation, policies, strategies, projects and experience relevant to Sustainability practice and thinking. The agencies’ responses were
Kendal Hodgman
57
voluminous and unstructured. Thus, the author’s first task was to evaluate the common Sustainability issues facing the disparate arms of government. From the data submitted to ‘The Survey’ the following ten prevailing issues were identified: Conservation of Biological Diversity, Conservation of Resource, Partnerships & Synergies, Pollution Minimisation, Research and Development, Social Equity & Education, Social Equity as a Regional/Spatial Driver, Sustainability Reporting, Sustainability Trade-offs, and Sustainable Quality of Life. Once these commonalities were identified, two processes had to be undertaken. Firstly; the definition of the Sustainability issues, in order that a common vocabulary was established. Thereafter, a uniform and conceptually accessible frame was constructed, through which the accumulated sustainability knowledge could be managed and communicated. The next sections of the paper will outline the development of this shared Sustainability language and form. 5.
A Common Sustainability Language The lack of such a common Sustainability language was identified by the author as one of the key hindrances to Sustainability knowledge transfer and understanding in the NSW Government’s organisational context and beyond. The importance of ‘right language’ in the administration of important affairs is as ancient as it is modern. This is evidenced by the following summary of one of the two and a half thousand year old Analects, attributed to the Chinese philosopher, Confucius: If language is not correct, then what is said is not what is meant. If what is said, is not what is meant, then what ought to be done, remains undone. If this remains undone, then morals and acts deteriorate and justice goes astray. Hence, there must be no arbitrariness in what is said. This matters above everything. 9 For the purposes of ‘The Survey’ the Premier’s Department had adopted the following definition of Sustainability: “Meeting the needs of current and future generations through an integration of environmental protection, social advancement and economic prosperity.”10 To date, however, in the NSW public sector, there has been no statutory direction given as to how the social, economic and environmental considerations are to be integrated in decision-making processes. Indeed, the NSW statutory direction is limited to the concept of Ecologically Sustainable Development (ESD), which integrates only environmental and economic considerations. This definition was first enunciated in NSW in the Protection of the Environment Administration Act 1991 (NSW), s 6(2):
58
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope (a) ecologically sustainable development requires the effective integration of economic and environmental considerations in decision-making processes. Ecologically sustainable development can be achieved through the implementation of the following principles and programs: (a) the precautionary principle—namely, that if there are threats of serious or irreversible environmental damage, lack of full scientific certainty should not be used as a reason for postponing measures to prevent environmental degradation. In the application of the precautionary principle, public and private decisions should be guided by: (i) careful evaluation to avoid, wherever practicable, serious or irreversible damage to the environment, and (ii) an assessment of the risk-weighted consequences of various options, (b) inter-generational equity—namely, that the present generation should ensure that the health, diversity and productivity of the environment are maintained or enhanced for the benefit of future generations, (c) conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity—namely, that conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity should be a fundamental consideration, (d) improved valuation, pricing and incentive mechanisms—namely, that environmental factors should be included in the valuation of assets and services, such as: (i) polluter pays—that is, those who generate pollution and waste should bear the cost of containment, avoidance or abatement, (ii) the users of goods and services should pay prices based on the full life cycle of costs of providing goods and services, including the use of natural resources and assets and the ultimate disposal of any waste, (iii) environmental goals, having been established, should be pursued in the most cost effective way, by establishing incentive structures, including market mechanisms, that enable those best placed to maximise benefits or minimise costs to develop their own solutions and responses to environmental problems.
It is obvious, however, that the NSW Government accepts the need to integrate the three social, economic and environmental
Kendal Hodgman
59
considerations in delivering sustainable outcomes for the State. It has demonstrated this in many policy arenas. The most cogent articulation of this aspiration is contained in the NSW Government’s Four Key Commitments,11 which, for the purposes of ‘The Survey’ and ‘The Report’, define the Core Sustainability Principles in the NSW Context: x x x x
Integrating environmental protection into all activities Encouraging economic development and sustainable employment Achieving greater social justice for all members of the community Delivering more financially responsible programs that reduce public debt and unfunded liabilities.
The processes for evaluating and reporting on economic and financial impacts are well established, and procedures for environmental impact assessment have been developing over recent decades. However, a review of the NSW statutory and policy literature reveals that evaluating and reporting on social impacts of decisions and defining social justice/equity lags in comparison. Given ‘The Survey’ questions’ emphases on impacts on communities and the social aspects of Sustainability, it was necessary to discern how Social Justice/Equity is defined in the NSW context. For the purposes of ‘The Survey’ and ‘The Report’ the definition was extrapolated from the intent contained in the NSW Social Justice Budget Statement 2003-04: We want all of the people of this State to have a fair go: a fair chance in life, a fair share of public resources, and a fair say in the decisions that affect their lives. Our social justice agenda has two foundations: a strong economy to provide jobs and opportunity for all, and social spending for those who need support. 12 Within the statutory context, the NSW Government has embraced the Sustainability imperative for social inclusion and equity in s 3(1) of the groundbreaking Community Relations Commission and Principles of Multiculturalism Act 2000 (NSW). Indeed, NSW was the first Australian state to enshrine into law the principles of multiculturalism. This Act provides the framework for a broader, more inclusive concept of NSW community relations. The author anticipates that, as the NSW Government progresses its whole of government approach to Sustainability, there will be future discussion and consideration of the concepts of Social Sustainability and community impact in the NSW statutory and policy contexts. The author, thus, provided the Government with a number of
60
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
definitions which were suggested to provide guidance for such future discourse. 6.
Rationale for Sustainability Issues Selection In the discharge of their functions, agencies face various Sustainability challenges depending on their roles, operations and statutory responsibilities. This is, indeed, the case within the NSW Government context. Agencies in an overarching sector (e.g. electricity utilities, land development agencies, etc.) share similar Sustainability issues, yet, they will also face individual challenges which arise from their specific locale, service community and economic position. Thus, relevant Sustainability issues were evident from agency responses to ‘The Survey’. These various issues were broadly categorised and then detailed in subcategories. This method allowed for major commonalities to be defined, as well as detailing the challenges specific to agencies. Ten prevailing Sustainability issues emerged from the data. Definitions for these issues were then derived from an extensive survey of the international Sustainability literature. These definitions were then employed by the author for the analysis of ‘The Survey’ submissions. As noted previously, a comprehensive definition of such Sustainability issues had not been, hitherto, undertaken in the NSW Government context. The definitions were employed as principles for data analysis and do not seek to limit or define the scope of agency practice. Moreover, the author does not wish to limit to ten the number of common Sustainability issues facing NSW Government agencies. The ten issues identified and subsequently defined arose directly from ‘The Survey’ submissions, which were influenced by ‘The Survey’ questions. Thus, it is likely that some other issues may arise from different questions and data sets. 7.
Defining the Sustainability Issues The ten prevailing Sustainability issues are: Conservation of Biological Diversity, Conservation of Resource, Partnerships & Synergies, Pollution Minimisation, Social Equity & Education, Social Equity as a Regional/Spatial Driver, Sustainability Reporting, Sustainability Tradeoffs, and Sustainable Quality of Life.
A. Conservation of Biological Diversity Australia has ratified the international Convention on Biological Diversity (1992) negotiated under the auspices of the United Nations Environment Program.13 NSW Government decision makers are directed that “conservation of biological diversity should be a fundamental consideration.” 14 The Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995, (NSW) s. 4, defines “Biological diversity” as the diversity of life and is made up of the following three components: (a) genetic diversity - the variety of genes (or
Kendal Hodgman
61
units of heredity) in any population, (b) species diversity - the variety of species, and (c) ecosystem diversity - the variety of communities or ecosystems. The Objects of the TSC Act are: (a) to conserve biological diversity and promote ESD, and (b) to prevent the extinction and promote the recovery of threatened species, populations and ecological communities, and (c) to protect the critical habitat of those threatened species, populations and ecological communities that are endangered, and (d) to eliminate or manage certain processes that threaten the survival or evolutionary development of threatened species, populations and ecological communities, and (e) to ensure that the impact of any action affecting threatened species, populations and ecological communities is properly assessed, and (f) to encourage the conservation of threatened species populations and ecological communities by the adoption of measures involving co-operative management. B. Conservation of Resource Resources are categorised as: Material flows - Natural capital and Man-made capital; and Human Resource - Human capital and Social capital: Natural capital refers to renewable and non-renewable natural resources, and ecosystem services, that make possible all economic activity, indeed all life. These services are of immense economic value; some are literally priceless, since they have no known substitutes. Failure to take into account the value of these limited assets results in natural capital being degraded and liquidated by the wasteful use of such resources as energy, materials, water, fibre, and topsoil. Other types of capital that sustain well-being - because of their levels and distribution - include man-made capital (e.g. machinery, equipment, structures and infrastructures), human capital (e.g. knowledge, skills and competencies), and social capital (eg networks of shared
62
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope values and understanding that facilitate co-operation within and between groups).15
And in the words of a large NSW agency: Human impact on the environment is largely associated with material flows into and out of an economy. As economic activity increases, there is an expansion in exploitation of resources, and a corresponding increase in waste. A primary objective of Sustainability is to reduce the material flows and decouple increases in resource usage and waste with economic activity. This can be achieved in three ways: Minimise the use of resources; Reduce waste generation; Recycle waste to be used again as a resource. 16 C. Partnerships and Synergies Synergy is defined as production by two or more agents whose combined effect is greater than the sum of their separate effects.17 Partnerships should integrate the economic, social and environmental dimensions of sustainable development in their design and implementation. They should be consistent, where applicable, with sustainable development strategies… and foster discussion, including sharing lessons learnt, progress made and best practices… Partnerships should have a multi-stakeholder approach and preferably involve a range of significant actors in a given area of work. They can be arranged among any combination of partners, including governments, regional groups, local authorities, non-governmental actors, international institutions and private sector partners. 18 D. Pollution Minimisation Pollution Minimisation aims to protect the environment through a range of initiatives to halt global warming (by reducing greenhouse gas emissions), ozone depletion, and the contamination of land, water and air. It also encompasses the management of effluent and other wastes, as well as noise and visual impacts.
Kendal Hodgman
63
E. Research and Development States should co-operate to strengthen endogenous capacity-building for sustainable development by improving scientific understanding through exchanges of scientific and technological knowledge, and by enhancing the development, adaptation, diffusion and transfer of technologies, including new and innovative technologies.19 F. Social Equity and Education Education is critical for promoting sustainable development and improving the capacity of people to address environment and development issues. It is critical for achieving environmental and ethical awareness, values and attitudes, skills and behaviour consistent with sustainable development and for effective participation in decision making.20 G. Social Equity as a Regional/Spatial Driver Social Equity as a Regional/Spatial Driver recognises that social and economic development are dependent on the health of individuals, communities and the environment. Thus regional/spatial strategies must promote initiatives that enhance productivity, community safety and identity, accessibility, transport, urban amenity, diversity and socioeconomic well being, through design and maintenance of the natural and built environment. H. Sustainability Reporting Sustainability Reporting provides a public account of an organisation’s performance against social and environmental indicators as well as the more traditional economic/financial measures. This process seeks to elevate social and environmental reporting to the same level of rigour, comparability, credibility, and verifiability expected of financial reporting. It also serves the information needs of a broad array of stakeholders and is built on the pillars of inclusiveness, transparency, and technical excellence. 21 I. Sustainability Trade-offs Whilst the aim of Sustainability is to integrate social, economic and environmental considerations in the decision making process, the author recognises that in some instances at least one of the three considerations suffers a loss at the expense of the others’ gain. It is useful
64
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
in such instances of conflicting interest to separate Sustainability into its economic, environmental, and social components: An economically sustainable system must be able to produce goods and services on a continuing basis, to maintain manageable levels of government and external debt, and to avoid extreme sectoral imbalances which damage agricultural or industrial production. An environmentally sustainable system must maintain a stable resource base, avoiding over-exploitation of renewable resource systems or environmental sink functions, and depleting nonrenewable resources only to the extent that investment is made in adequate substitutes. This includes maintenance of biodiversity, atmospheric stability, and other ecosystem functions not ordinarily classed as economic resources. A socially sustainable system must achieve distributional equity, adequate provision of social services including health and education, gender equity, and political accountability and participation.22 J. Sustainable Quality of Life The real aim of development is to improve the quality of human life. It is a process that enables human beings to realise their potential, build self-confidence and lead lives of dignity and fulfilment. Economic growth is an important component of development, but it cannot be a goal in itself… Although people differ in the goals that they would set for development, some are virtually universal. These include a long and healthy life, education, access to the resources needed for a decent standard of living, political freedom, guaranteed human rights, and freedom from violence. Development is real only if it makes our lives better in these respects.23 Following this categorisation and definition phase, a visually accessible and structured mode of communication was devised, in order that the highlighted Sustainability practice could be shared across the whole of government. 8.
Creating the Frame At the heart of this paper is the author’s contention that one of the key problems jeopardising our common future on Earth is the lack of
Kendal Hodgman
65
effective tools to communicate Sustainability thinking and practice. In the course of the project, upon which this paper is based, the author identified the need for a visually and conceptually accessible mechanism to accelerate the uptake of Sustainability practice in a whole of organisation context. In designing the SAF the author employed two of humanity’s fundamental learning tools - the diagram and the story. The power of story is inestimable. It is a universal mode of human communication. It is through the sharing of stories across millennia that the cultures and technologies of humanity have grown. Civilisations have come and gone but their wisdom has remained in the annals of history. Yet, story is as modern as it is ancient. We still receive and give our news in the form of story and we conceptually communicate about the world, both imaginary and real, in story form. Thus, the central importance of deploying story, as a Sustainability knowledge communication tool in the SAF was identified at the outset. The framing of these Sustainability stories within a visually accessible form was, however, a challenge. The challenge of visualisation in complex problem solving is not new, as this observation by physicist Richard Feynman, whilst working on the Manhattan Project in 1945 attests: “The single biggest problem we face is that of visualisation.” Therefore, the importance of creating a framework which was visually accessible and simple conceptually was deemed an imperative in the SAF design process. Conceptually, the SAF is based upon communications and cognitive research, which concurs that, visually, readers are most likely to access and engage with single page documents, rather than lengthy reports. Thus, the two mechanisms comprising the SAF, the Sustainability Review Matrix and the Sustainability Issue and Practice Table, are modelled to fit on either A4 or A3 single page formats, depending upon the nature and scope of the agency submissions. The diagrams are templates which illustrate the flow of data and knowledge through the SAF. Figure 1 depicts the SAF in full, figure 2 the agency specific, Sustainability Review Matrix, and Figure 3 the whole of government tool, the Sustainability Issue and Practice Table.
66
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
Figure 1. Sustainability Analysis Framework
Kendal Hodgman
67
GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENT TITLE I N I T I A T I V E S
SOCIAL
ECONOMIC
Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title
Title of Sustainability Issue I S S U E S
Title of Sustainability Issue Title of Sustainability Issue
ENVIRONMENT
Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title
Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title Project Title
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
INTEGRATED OUTCOMES AND MODELS Title of Sustainability Issue
Selected case studies are utilised to showcase innovation & integration & agencies’ experience of sustainable service delivery.
Title of Sustainability Issue
Selected case studies are utilised to showcase innovation & integration & agencies’ experience of sustainable service delivery.
Title of Project (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Title of Project (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Figure 2. Template of Sustainability Review Matrix.
68
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
TITLE OF SUSTAINABILITY ISSUE AGENCY
PRACTICE
Title of Agency 1
Title of Project (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Title of Agency 2
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Title of Agency 3
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Title of Agency 4
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Title of Agency 5
Project Title (s) Story of Project (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned
Case Study The case study is given more space in order that more details of the successful practice can be showcased. Title of Agency Project Title (s)
Story of Project: (aims, objectives etc.) Synopsis of the Issues and Processes addressed Sharing of the Sustainability Lessons Learned Figure 3. Template of Sustainability Issue and Practice Table
Kendal Hodgman
69
9.
The Sustainability Analysis Framework The SAF consists of two related parts, namely the Sustainability Review Matrix (SRM), which is the agency specific assessment tool and the Sustainability Issues Practice Tables (SIPT), which are the whole of government communications tools. To aid visualisation of the SRM method, the SRM conceptual template is detailed in Figure 2 and the SIPT conceptual template is detailed in Figure 3. The Sustainability Review Matrix (SRM) provides a world first model for integrated analysis of Sustainability initiatives, issues and practice. As a matrix in both the mathematical and literal senses, it treats each Government agency/organisation as an entity, comprised of various Sustainability components. These components are outlined in three sets, namely Initiatives, Issues and Integrated Outcomes and Models. x x x
Initiatives are categorised into the Sustainability considerations of Social, Economic and Environment. Issues are categorised into the Sustainability issues arising from the full data set analysis. How the agency addresses a prevailing challenge is then detailed. Integrated Outcomes and Models highlight innovation and notable practice in how the agency is dealing with a prevailing Sustainability issue. This set of the SRM serves to demonstrate integration of social, economic and environmental considerations as well as when an activity has a net Sustainability benefit.
The Sustainability Issues and Practice Table (SIPT) is the whole of government mechanism. In the full execution of the SAF Methodology, each of the prevailing Sustainability Issues identified from the full data set analysis would be allocated a SIPT. Drawing from the SRM analysis; best practice models and case studies of how agencies deal with the Issue are selected for inclusion in the SIPT, and; selected case studies are utilised to showcase innovation and integration and agencies’ experience of sustainable service delivery. A.
Rationale for Practice Model and Case Study Selection While the NSW Government has underscored its commitment to Sustainability with core directives, it has also allowed for a flexible and evolutionary approach to Sustainability. This has enabled agencies to determine what Sustainability means to them. This has resulted in the development of innovative practice models, which have been selected for inclusion in the SIPT on the basis of the following criteria:
70
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope x x x x x
innovation; integration of the core Sustainability principles; development of performance indicators; processes of reporting and evaluation; and general applicability.
Case studies selection was made on the basis of successful implementation, innovation and general applicability of the Sustainability Practice Model. 10.
Findings There is a wealth of Sustainability knowledge, enthusiasm and practice within the NSW public sector. The author considers it vital that this priceless resource be shared, encouraged and harnessed. Whilst it is outside the scope of this article to include the thirty-eight SRMs and the related SIPTs, created during the research project, these provided a snapshot of what each of the sampled agencies, and thus the Government generally, was doing in regard to Sustainability practice. It is the author’s opinion that this service effort and accomplishment is considerable and is worthy of appreciation, support and encouragement by the NSW Government’s central administration, and by the public at large. The extensive scope and agency specific experience of Sustainability initiatives, issues and practice across the significant sample of the NSW public sector were distilled in the SRMs, yet other significant generalised findings can be condensed into the following points: x x x
x
x
All of the analysed NSW Government agencies were delivering Sustainability outcomes, through initiatives, policies and programs. Many of these agencies were delivering world-class Sustainability outcomes and the wisdom gained from their practice and development is worthy of widespread promotion. The opportunity to share the challenges and difficulties of delivering Sustainability outcomes was not widely embraced by ‘The Survey’ submissions. The author believes there is much wisdom to be gained from pursuing such a line of inquiry. ‘The Survey’ questions did not specifically ask for submissions about how agencies were engaging or hope to engage the private sector and the wider community in their Sustainability endeavours. The author believes there is much wisdom to be gained from pursuing such a line of inquiry. The concept of ESD in the NSW statutory context is limited to integrating only the environmental and economic considerations. There is a need to provide legislative direction to embrace the
Kendal Hodgman
x
x x
x
x
11.
71
internationally accepted understanding of Sustainability, which adds the social dimension to the integrated decision-making process. Across the sampled agencies there was not a comprehensive or coherent understanding of the prevailing and internationally accepted definition of Sustainability. The responses to ‘The Survey’ indicated that there is a widespread belief that Sustainability is limited to environmental protection. There is, therefore, a need for a Sustainability education campaign to be undertaken across the Government. There had, hitherto, been no established co-ordinated approach to communicating Sustainability approaches across the Government. The SAF proved effective in this regard. The employment of the SAF revealed the breadth and innovative capacity of the whole of government approach to Sustainability and the ability of this simple communications tool to broadcast Sustainability best practice. Many agencies were committed to working with others to synergise Sustainability outcomes and expressed a desire for greater engagement with others in Sustainability partnerships. The author would encourage the fostering of such synergies and partnerships. It is inappropriate for the author to detail the process findings and recommendations contained in ‘The Report’, as these were provided to the department for its own information. However, it is notable that the Government of NSW is acting upon a number of the key recommendations. Information in this regard is available at the NSW Premier’s Department Web site.24
Outcomes The value of ‘The Report’ and its recommendations has been publicly acknowledged at the highest levels of the NSW administration. It has merited favourable mention in the NSW Parliamentary Hansard; has been cited as one of the Government’s major achievements in Sustainability, in evidence submitted to the Parliament of NSW Public Accounts Committee;25 and has been endorsed by the (then) Chairman of the NSW Environment Protection Authority as part of a recommendation to Government that the SAF be adopted as the whole of NSW Government model of Sustainability communication. From 2004 to the present the author has been invited to conduct seminars on the Framework to all levels of government in Australia namely, State, Federal and Local governments. These seminars have demonstrated the educative capacity of the SAF. This is evidenced by the
72
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
fact that a number of agencies were empowered to submit for analysis comprehensive and completed SRMs. What is particularly encouraging is that most seminar participants have responded to the extensive Sustainability practice demonstrated by the SAF, with exclamations of amazement and enthusiasm at the breadth and scope of what is being done to tackle the Sustainability challenges facing NSW. They indicated that within such a large public administration and within their own departmental organisations they had often felt isolated and disconnected. They stated that having seen how their work interwove with the work of others across the government, a rich tapestry of effort and accomplishment was obvious and achievable. This was a cause for celebration and empowerment. Moreover, the fact that they could witness, within the Framework, that the various social, economic and environmental aspects of their work were interlinked, enabled them to see holistically the context of their decision-making and project deployment. The combination of the SAF’s visual and story-telling aids educated the public administrators that they are part of a larger whole which has the capacity to work synergistically towards achieving the NSW Government’s Four Key Commitments, which enshrine the principles of Sustainability thinking. 12.
Conclusion The Government of NSW, through its rhetoric and statutory, policy and program delivery, appears to be committed to progressing Sustainability. This commitment has been translated into considerable Sustainability achievements in various sectors. However, ‘The Report’, upon which this article is based, identifies that continued and accelerated progress is necessary if New South Wales is to sustainably deliver a healthy environment, a dynamic economy and a society, which nurtures its citizens. ‘The Report’, alone, is a significant advance. It suggests definitions and principles for a common Sustainability language, the lack of which is identified as a key hindrance to achieving sustainable outcomes. It provides the novel SAF, through which Sustainability initiatives, issues, practice, and models are identified and communicated. The successful deployment of the SAF across a significant bureaucracy shows that this mechanism is effective in the collation of data, the sharing of information, the organisation of knowledge and the communication of wisdom in a whole of government context. This generally applicable framework acknowledges the enormous value of experience to organisations. It has demonstrated within a sample of only one government that much Sustainability experience has already been gained and that this knowledge is ready and possible to be shared. Furthermore, this knowledge can be simply stored and thereafter utilised for the whole of organisation’s benefit and beyond. The simplicity of its form and method gives the SAF the flexibility to be deployed in most
Kendal Hodgman
73
organisational contexts, to assist in the collection, maintenance, re-use, access and sharing of Sustainability knowledge not only in particular instances but to aid in broader problem solving. It is the author’s contention that the communication and sharing of successful Sustainability experience, practice and wisdom will help to accelerate the dynamism of cultural change necessary to ensure a sustainable world. The SAF offers a method for doing this. It does not profess to be the answer to all the world’s woes, far from it! However, it does demonstrate that through a simple framework we can individually and together start to implement Sustainability and share in ‘the solutions’. By so doing we can move forward with an understanding that what matters most we may not live to see, but we will know that it was created amidst a spirit of good will and a vision of hope. Nothing worth doing is completed in our lifetime, Therefore, we are saved by hope. Nothing true or beautiful or good makes complete sense in any immediate context of history; Therefore, we are saved by faith. Nothing we do, however virtuous, can be accomplished alone. Therefore, we are saved by love…. Rienhold Niebuhr
Notes 1
The terms Sustainability, Ecologically Sustainable Development and Sustainable Development refer to the same concept generally defined as: ‘Development that meets the needs of present generations while not compromising the ability of future generations to also meet their needs.’ as per World Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common Future, Australian Edition, (Melbourne Oxford University Press, 1987), 87. 2 Antoine de Saint Exupery, The Little Prince, (London, William Heinemann Ltd, 1977), 74. 3 Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005. Synthesis Reports (Available at: http://www.millenniumassessment.org//en/Products.Synthesis.aspx viewed 14/5/2005). 4 Nicholas Stern, Stern Review: The Economics of Climate Change, (U.K., Cambridge University Press, 2006), (i). 5 S.L. Pimm and T.M. Brooks, The Sixth Extinction: how large, how soon and where? in P.H. Raven and T. Williams (eds.), Biodiversity (National Academy Press, 1999), 46-62. 6 Government of New South Wales (NSW), Competitiveness Report, (Sydney, Department of State and Regional Development, 2003), see generally.
74 7
Sustainability: Framing a Shared Vision of Hope
International Panel on Climate Change, Working Group II, Fourth Assessment Report. Climate Change 2007: Climate Change Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability; Summary for Policymakers, ( Available at: www.ipcc.ch/SPM6avr07 viewed 22/4/07); and Millennium Ecosystem Assessment 2005, see generally. 8 Kendal Hodgman, Sustainability: A New South Wales Whole of Government Approach, (Sydney, Government of New South Wales, Premier’s Department, 2005). 9 Attributed to Confucius, Book XIII Analects; cited in C.H.A.O.S.S.: An Essay and Glossary for Students and Practitioners of Global Environmental Governance, Saunier, R., and Meganck, R., (U.K., A.A. Balkema Publishers, 2004), 27. 10 Government of Western Australia, Western Australian State Sustainability Strategy, Hope for the Future, (Perth, Government of Western Australia 2003), 12. 11 These principles are generally known within the NSW Government context as ‘The Four Pillars’. They were first enunciated in 1998 in the Urban Infrastructure Management Plan, which was developed by the then Ministry of Urban Infrastructure Management, (Available at: http://www.premiers.nsw.gov.au/our_library/infrastructure/uimp98.pdf ). 12 Government of New South Wales, NSW Social Justice Budget Statement 2003-04, Foreword, (Sydney, Government of NSW, 2004), 2. 13 The Convention on Biological Diversity, otherwise known as the Bratislava Convention, came into force legally in December 1993. 14 Protection of the Environment Administration Act 1992 (NSW), s. 6(2)(c). 15 Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment. Creating our Future: Development for New Zealand, (Available at: www.pce.govt.nz ), 39 Also see Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Policies to enhance sustainable development: meeting of the OECD council ministerial level, (Paris, OECD, 2001); and OECD Sustainable development: critical issues, (Paris, OECD, 2001). 16 Based on Sydney Olympic Park Authority, Waste Reduction & Purchasing Plan 2002, (Sydney, Government of NSW, 2002), 8. 17 Guiding Principles for Partnerships for Sustainable Development (‘type 2 outcomes’), World Summit on Sustainable Development 2002. (Available at: http://www.iisd.ca/wssd/download%20files/annex_partnership.pdf ) 18 The Shorter Oxford Dictionary, (New York, Oxford University Press, 1993). 19 United Nations Commission on Environment and Development (UNCED), Principle 9, Rio Declaration on Environment and Development: The Principles of Agenda 21, (Paris, United Nations, 1992). 20 Ibid., Chapter 36, 2.
Kendal Hodgman 21
75
This definition blends ideas from Landcom Sustainability Report 2003, (Sydney, Government of NSW, 2003), 4, and the 2002 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines, (Global Reporting Initiative Available at: www.globalreporting.org viewed 22/4/07), 1. 22 J. Harris, Basic Principles of Sustainable Development, (Global Development and Environment Institute, Tufts University, Working Paper 00-04. June), 5-6. (Available at: http://ase.tufts.edu/gdae viewed 22/4/07). 23 International Union for Conservation of Nature, Caring for the Earth; A Strategy for Sustainable Living, (Gland, Switzerland, United Nations Environment Program, World Wide Fund for Nature, 1991), 9-12. 24 Government of New South Wales, Premier’s Department, Website, (Available at: http://www.premiers.nsw.gov.au/WorkAndBusiness/WorkingForGovernm ent/SustainabilityInitiatives.htm viewed 22/4/07). 25 The Public Accounts Committee is the Parliament of NSW’ bipartisan committee charged with evaluating the NSW Government’s efficacy in key areas of responsibility. .
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia: Contributing Factors and Current Incentive Schemes Jo Kehoe Abstract Biodiversity continues its unrelenting demise on vast areas of privately held land within Australia, particularly in the state of Queensland. One means towards solving this problem is by voluntary conservation agreements between the agricultural community and the government. To date such agreements are yet to be fully utilised, despite their potential to play an increasingly essential role in natural resource management. Varieties of voluntary agreements are currently being tested, for example, the vegetation incentives program in Queensland. The aim of this paper is to explore some of the factors which contribute towards the utilisation of voluntary conservation agreements in Queensland together with a consideration of some current incentive schemes. There are important lessons to learned from the initial implementation stages that may be usefully employed by interested stakeholders. Keywords: conservation agreements, voluntary agreements, contributing factors, incentive schemes, Queensland, Australia. 1.
Introduction Voluntary conservation agreements represent a dynamic and evolving policy area in environmental law. They range from covenants in perpetuity binding successors in title, to short-term contracts binding only on parties to the agreement. The agricultural community in Queensland under-utilises such agreements. Nonetheless, effective long-term conservation of natural resources on private land requires that landholders become an integral part of the resolution to biodiversity loss. Voluntary agreements alone are not a solution; but they present an important aspect of the move towards sustainable agricultural management. 2.
Voluntary Agreements - An Under-utilised Policy Option Within Australia, and particularly in the state of Queensland, biodiversity continues its unremitting decline.1 While some sectors of the agricultural community routinely take account of biodiversity conservation in their management strategies, there is much room for improvement.2 There is scope, arguably imperative, that private landholders and government utilise voluntary conservation agreements to promote sustainable management of natural resources. To date such agreements are an under-utilised policy option and this is particularly so in Queensland. Such agreements should complement and be supported by traditional command and control legislation. Here is an aspect of
78
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
environmental policy making which highlights the overarching philosophical dilemma of “balancing the collective against the individual interest”3 and of the intrinsic tensions of public approaches to sustainable land management on private property owners.4 Agriculture is the most extensive form of land use in Australia accounting for 58 per cent of the total land area, or 447 million hectares, of which 141.4 million hectares is devoted to agriculture in Queensland. 5 Much of the agricultural activity is centred on livestock grazing with relatively small pockets of the state currently under nature conservation or managed resource protection.6 In Queensland, land tenure is primarily divided into private freehold ownership and Crown leasehold or pastoral leases.7 3.
Types of Voluntary Agreement Voluntary agreements may encompass various types of arrangements from the most extensive; being a covenant in perpetuity registered on the land title, to the least extensive being, for example, a one-off payment to a landholder for a particular task such as fencing an area. In between these two ends of the spectrum lie various contractual and non-contractual arrangements including combinations of both covenants and contracts. For example, a covenant may run in perpetuity alongside a contractual management plan that runs for a five-year period with annual payments. Generally, covenants run with the land and bind successors in title. Because of the doctrine of privity, a contract only binds the original parties to the agreement. Agreements may contain provision for the landholder to encourage a successor in title to take over the contract; but the limitation of this type of arrangement is that it is directly linked to the current owner of the land. This paper will consider voluntary agreements that are the result of direct bargaining between individual landholders and Queensland government agencies. Initial consideration is given to the centralised approach to natural resource management currently taken by the Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council (NRMMC). This is followed by a discussion of the factors likely to contribute towards the adoption of a voluntary agreement. The paper then provides a brief analysis of the statutory framework for voluntary agreements and, as Australia has a federal system of government, both federal and state legislations are considered, noting that Commonwealth legislation is not utilised at all. In order to provide a perspective on Queensland the paper then focuses on two current incentive schemes both statutory and non-statutory. Finally, the contributing factors will be re-visited in relation to the two incentive schemes examined in order to assess the extent to which voluntary agreements are utilised in the state, particularly by the agricultural community.
Jo Kehoe
79
4.
The Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council Meaningful employment of voluntary agreements requires a centralised and consistent approach; the latest body established to do this in Australia is the NRMMC. According to the NRMMC, there are indications that voluntary agreements with landholders have the potential to play an increasingly important role in natural resource management within Australia.8 Equally, the National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality (NAP), National Markets Based Instruments (MBI) Pilots Program is a recent example that is likely to encourage utilisation of voluntary agreements.9 Varieties of MBIs are currently being tested, for example, the bush tender in Victoria and the vegetation incentives programme in Queensland.10 These instruments are heralded by the NRMMC as being more cost effective than legislation and more flexible in that participants negotiate an agreement which, in turn, encourages innovation and changes in behaviour.11 5.
Utilisation of Voluntary Agreements - Contributing Factors Future use and likelihood of success with voluntary agreements is very much dependent on various contributing factors. 12 A. Economic incentives The success of voluntary agreements is liable to depend upon accessible and worthwhile incentives and, importantly, the availability of sufficient funding. Significant steps in fiscal commitment were taken in 1997 in Australia, when the Commonwealth government established the Natural Heritage Trust (NHT) the purpose being to restore and preserve the environment and natural resources.13 This financial obligation was extended in the 2004 Federal budget to provide funding until 2007-2008 making the overall NHT investment $3 billion.14 This is in addition to $1.4 million from the NAP. Both the NHT and the NAP will combine an integrated delivery of management of natural resources at a regional level.15 The NRMMC oversee the implementation of natural resource management programs. Adequate funding therefore does not appear to be an issue. B. Design and implementation of voluntary agreements Effective utilisation of any instrument will be more readily facilitated and acceptable to potential parties if their rights, duties and obligations are clarified. It is possible with a voluntary agreement to enter into an oral contract or an arrangement lacking the basic legal requirements of a contract. However, a basic standard form incorporating the relevant criteria ensures certainty and need not be legally overwhelming. The following criteria are accordingly set down which incorporate the basic requirements, not only of an agreement, but also to assist in focusing the direction of negotiations: 16
80
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia x x x x
x
x x
x x
x x
Parties - to the agreement. Property - a description of the land, title number and plan. Recitals - background to the conservation target/goal the agreement is set to achieve. Landholder obligations - if a financial incentive is to be paid the amount and details of how payment is to be made. The contractual consideration here would be the landowner’s obligations under the agreement in return for the incentive payment. Term - the period during which the agreement will run, either for a fixed term or in perpetuity to bind successors in title. If the agreement is a perpetual covenant, the remaining criteria may be included in a management plan. The advantage of a management plan being that it can be adapted to changing circumstances and landowners. Target/goal - should be clearly outlined after prior consultation with the landholder. Monitoring - regulator or non-government body inspection of conservation land to be at agreed intervals, for example each year. Prior notice should be given of the inspection and assistance should be provided, if necessary, if the target/goal is falling short. Breach - details of what will constitute a breach. Some flexibility should be included here to take account of, for example, drought or climatic changes beyond the control of the landholder. Enforcement - may be set down in statute. In the absence of regulation potential penalties must be clearly articulated. At the very least the landholder should be obliged to return any incentive paid for failing to comply with the contract obligations. Provision for modification, extinguishment and release - of the agreement should be included. Mediation - in the event of any dispute arising under the agreement the parties should have the option to refer the matter, at least in the first instance, to mediation. This would be in keeping with the voluntary aspects of these arrangements and may promote their use
C. Motivation Motivation to enter into voluntary arrangements may be restricted to the conservation minded. The reality for many landholders, particularly those operating on a smaller scale, renders conservation an ideal often difficult to incorporate into daily subsistence. For many, “everything comes down to the dollar and trying to make a living. In the sugarcane area at the moment we are struggling to stay afloat, so conservation is the last thing on our minds.”
Jo Kehoe
81
Equally, many “are keen on conservation, but time and costs are a problem when we are flat out trying to survive.” These comments came from farmers as part of a state wide survey to determine landholder issues of importance for nature conservation on rural properties.17 This survey concluded that the main areas of concern for farmers were feral animals, weeds and problems with wildlife. Management for nature conservation did not rate highly.18 Moreover, it is clear from the Queensland Farmers Federation that Queensland farmers currently have more immediate and pressing concerns in order to operate a viable business, such as drought assistance and exceptional circumstances relief.19 D. Is the Target Group Accessible and do they have a Strong Representative Body? One of the prime difficulties in dealing with the agricultural community in Queensland must surely be the geographical isolation of many landholders. Nonetheless, this is a close knit and supportive community, internet access is commonplace, word of mouth prolific and the rural press reinforces solidarity.20 Landholders in Queensland have, primarily, two representative bodies: Agforce21 and the Queensland Farmers Federation.22 Agforce is the larger organisation and, despite being at variance politically with the current government, recent collaboration has been facilitated by schemes such as Agforward. Agforward came about as part of the Queensland government’s financial commitment to landowners when announcing the land-clearing moratorium. The financial pledge of $150 million included $8 million to support rural industry groups to promote best management practices in sustainable agriculture.23 This $8 million went to Agforce and started Agforward. This initiative is set to run for four years, the primary aim appears to be to assist landholders in understanding the various regulatory regimes brought about by changes to the vegetation management legislation. The Agforward team is presently touring the state presenting workshops. The Queensland Farmers Federation is a smaller body than Agforce. This body is developing a working relationship with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). They have a committee on environment and natural resources and cite this as a key policy area. However, none of their natural resource management issues includes any information on voluntary agreements. 24 Their latest conference on enhancing sustainable agriculture is supported by the EPA.25 The Minister’s welcoming speech at this conference abounded with motherhood statements, such as, “Farmers and environmentalists have not always been friends in Queensland, but the time is right for a new partnership.”26 The conference was however, the outcome of a two-year project developed in partnership between the Federation and the EPA’s
82
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
sustainable industries division. The Minister urged farmers “to approach the EPA for practical advice, assistance or partnerships.”27 E. Mutual Respect and Trust The complicated dynamics of the relationship between the current Queensland government and the agricultural community mean that there are currently barriers to mutual respect and trust. Current unrest amongst the rural community in Queensland may well be hampering the willingness of landholders to tap into the potential of conservation agreements. This is particularly the case when the proposed partnership for a voluntary agreement lies with the Department of Natural Resources and Mines (DNRM) who administer the Vegetation Management Act 1999 (VMA). Recent times have seen the introduction of unpopular amendments to this legislation, such as the phasing out of broadscale clearing of remnant vegetation by the end of December 2006. In providing the statutory framework for the government’s moratorium on land clearing, this Act has played a pivotal role in the tension that exists within some sectors of the agricultural community. Despite, and probably because of, the strained relations between the farmers and the state, attempts have been made to foster a better working relationship. In February 2005 the ‘Blueprint for the Bush’ project was founded.28 The Blueprint is a 10 year plan to work in partnership. During the first stage (to gather input from the agricultural community about their concerns), it was estimated some eight hundred people attended in various rural centres around the state.29 After these meetings, the President of Agforce said: The overwhelming message we heard from the bush from Hughenden to Emerald, from Nebo to Dalby was resounding - the bush believes the government does not trust them and is favouring a big stick approach to legislative compliance over extension and advice.30 There are indications of a willingness to rectify this as the President subsequently noted; despite being mistrustful of the government, landowners were: …willing to give the Blueprint concept a go. They appreciate that a resolution to many of the issues facing rural Queensland will require a genuine partnership and a rebuilding of the trust which seems to have been lost on both sides.31 From the initial Blueprint consultation process core areas of importance and areas where key initiatives need to be addressed have been
Jo Kehoe
83
formulated by Agforce. These key initiatives include: “Land and environment initiatives to support land management practices that are both productive and environmentally sound.”32The Blueprint further elaborates by articulating the need “to develop economic incentives for rural producers to manage and maintain the land in a sustainable manner.”33This particular key initiative may be a useful vehicle to promote the utilisation of voluntary agreements but the Blueprint makes no specific reference to them. The current climate is hardly conducive to the promotion of voluntary negotiated agreements. The current Labor government has much to do to build confidence in the farming community. The existing government lacks the affinity of the rural lobby and they, in turn, lack the influence they held under the (non-Labor) Bjelke-Peterson administration. Both sides have much ground to cover to reach a stage whereby voluntary agreements may be negotiated in an atmosphere of mutual respect and trust. The Blueprint, however, is a long term 10 year project and may provide the momentum to start the journey. F. Soft Effects The soft effects of voluntary agreements cannot be underestimated.34 This must particularly be the case for smaller farming bodies. Soft effects include shared forms of knowledge and learning and best practice methods, the dissemination of information and general support; not only from the relevant regulator but also from other participants in a given scheme. In 2002, a national survey was undertaken of landholders with conservation covenants.35The general findings of this survey were that landholders received more assistance during the setting up of the covenant than after.36Schemes varied in the levels and types of assistance made available.37 During the establishment phase over 90 per cent of landowners regarded as important a property visit, advice on assessing remnant vegetation and wildlife habitat, together with guidance on funding and funding assistance.38 Once the covenant had been established, funding was still the most significant aspect, with over 90 per cent declaring financial assistance and rebates important.39 This was followed by the need for access to technical experts; labour for on ground works, field days, publications and links with other covenant holders.40 The legal implications of a covenant in perpetuity do not appear to have been addressed in this survey. It would be interesting to see if all respondents had independent legal representation and if the regulator advised them to seek such representation. This would avoid any element of potential unconscionability in the negotiations and completion of the agreement. This survey provides a useful lens into conservation minded landholders already participating in a voluntary scheme. It is the
84
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
landowners who are currently not inclined to consider voluntary programs that need to be targeted, particularly as they are the majority group. Empirical data collected from this majority group may provide useful insights into the current barriers preventing landholders from utilising voluntary agreements. Commonwealth Legislative Provision: The Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 The potential role for Federal government in the voluntary agreement domain lies with the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Commonwealth, ‘EPBC’). This statute commenced in 2000 and initial analysis generally described this law as a major and key reforming agent to existing environmental law.41The Act brought Australia into line with the international environmental arena and signalled an important role for the Commonwealth. The objects of the EPBC are wide-ranging and make provision, amongst other things, for the promotion of ecologically sustainable development and the conservation of biodiversity.42One particular vehicle for the conservation of biodiversity is by means of conservation agreements. 43 To date no agreements have been made.44This would appear to be a policy decision as Commonwealth funding in natural resource management is currently unparalleled. Voluntary agreements may however lend themselves more readily to regional bodies and non-government organisations where local knowledge is invaluable. 6.
State Legislative Provision: The Nature Conservation Act 1992 (Qld) In Queensland, provision is made under the Nature Conservation Act 1992 (NCA) for landowners to enter into voluntary conservation agreements. The EPA administers this statute and deals with negotiations on the agreements. The object of the Act is the conservation of nature. 45 There are twelve classes of protected areas under the Act, which include nature refuges.46 The emphasis is on community participation in the administration of the NCA.47 Within Queensland, there are currently 182 nature refuges covering 412,700 hectares.48The first nature refuge was declared in 1994.49 This was the Berlin Scrub refuge and covered some 41.9 ha.50 Total areas for each refuge vary enormously, for example, most recently the range is from less than one hectare to 215,454 hectares.51 This latter refuge, declared in 2005, is the Mulligan River refuge and is the largest in Australia.52 This refuge alone amounts to just over half of the total area devoted to refuges in the state. Importantly, in terms of utilisation of this type of agreement by the agricultural community, this refuge was made with the North Australian Pastoral Company.53Ordinarily, information on 7.
Jo Kehoe
85
the landholder entering into the agreement is not in the public domain, this particular refuge however received much publicity within the state. Available information on each refuge includes the name of the refuge and description of the land, the significant cultural and natural resources and values of the area, the proposed management intent and use and the duration of the agreement. This information therefore does not provide any indication of the land usage and it is therefore impossible to determine if the nature refuges are situated on areas otherwise used for agriculture and in particular, if farmers are entering into these voluntary agreements. At present landowners entering into this scheme range from primary producers to eco tourism ventures.54 To what extent are nature refuges utilised on agricultural land in Queensland? The total area of agricultural activity in the state amounts to 141.4 million hectares.55 The total current area of 412,700 hectares devoted to nature refuges therefore amounts to 0.29%. This extremely low percentage does not reflect the true picture, as the 412,700 figure also incorporates nature refuges that are not on agricultural land. It is apparent that nature refuges are utilised and that their use is growing, but there is much room for expansion. One means to encourage utilisation is to target particular areas, which the vegetation incentives programme has recently done. 8.
Non-statutory Voluntary Agreements — The Vegetation Incentives Programme The Queensland government has committed $12 million towards a vegetation incentive programme. Under this scheme a voluntary conservation agreement may be negotiated between the DNRM and landholders. Originally, this programme envisaged using a perpetual covenant registered on the land title and a management plan. The covenant was particularly onerous and restrictive. The management plan was a contract intended to run for five years with periodic payments during the term. It was not clear what would happen at the expiry of the management plan or if further funding would be available. Landholders were invited to submit an expression of interest. The DNRM then assessed each application and invited applicants with suitable land to submit a tender. The state was divided into regions and the first round, which targeted the southern region, saw 21 expressions of interest; of these, 16 were invited to submit a tender and eight did so.56 Ultimately, the bids were high from this final group and not regarded by the DNRM as good value: the tenders were not accepted.57 This scheme has evolved and landholders may now choose to enter into a perpetual covenant as part of the nature refuge scheme run by the EPA, a limited term covenant, or a declaration, in which the landholder declares the vegetation as remnant and therefore protected by applicable legislation.58 An important lesson was learned from round one -
86
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
the very strict covenant probably contributed to the low participation rate and inflated bids.59 Utilisation may also be encouraged by providing more assistance towards the difficult task of collating a bid. The second round of this scheme covered the remainder of the state with the exception of southeast Queensland.60 Of the 87 expressions of interest 46 were invited to submit a tender and 38 took the opportunity to do so. 61The North Coastal region accounted for 31 of those 38 tenders.62 This area includes the Atherton Tablelands and is characterised by smaller non-farming properties, the average size of the applications being 11.55 hectares.63 9.
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland — The Impact of Contributing Factors
A. Economic incentives Financial incentives are the most significant and direct means to promote utilisation of voluntary agreements.64 Australia is currently experiencing an unprecedented availability of financial resources, nonetheless voluntary conservation agreements appear to primarily attract the conservation minded. Are current economic incentives sufficient to be meaningful to property owners? Such incentives have been denounced, in the past, as inappropriate for failing to take account of the long-term requirements of sustainable land management.65 The provision of permanent financial incentives may generate more interest in voluntary agreements; but this must be weighed against the reality that enduring fiscal commitments are beyond the scope and political life of governments. There is a general view that landholders ought not to receive monetary assistance in return for environmental compliance.66 A voluntary conservation agreement however is arguably beyond requisite compliance. The dilemma appears to be in deciding the amount of financial tender and here the government is shifting the onus on to the landholder. The most recent voluntary schemes in Queensland have made use of a competitive tender system. The NRMMC have found this to be a significant cost saving in terms of the delivery of such instruments.67 It is clear however, from the vegetation incentives program, that landholders need more assistance in the complicated task of developing a financial bid and taking part in a tender process. B. Design and implementation of voluntary agreements The implementation and design of voluntary agreements is enhanced by a statutory framework as presently exists for perpetual covenants under the NCA. To be as effective as possible voluntary agreements need a legislative under pinning to cover matters such as
Jo Kehoe
87
obligations under the covenant and how incentives are to be paid and repaid in the event of breach. Such matters are set down in the NCA.68 Moreover, voluntary agreements require a multi-discipline approach that incorporates economics, ecology and law. In the absence of legislation, guidelines and a basic standard form contract covering the essential contractual requirements could be provided by, and are within the terms of reference of, the NRMMC. This would be an important strategy for developing a national approach to the conservation of Australia’s natural resources. Equally, it would ensure - in view of the funding that is provided - that non-statutory voluntary agreements are legally binding. C. Motivation It is difficult to motivate landholders to engage in voluntary agreements when the prime concern (particularly for the smaller organisations) is economic viability. Queensland remains in the grip of prolonged drought. It is apparent that, for some landholders, natural resource management is not at the top of the priority list. Nature refuges amount to 0.29% of the privately held land in Queensland. The majority of private landholders in the state apparently lack the motivation to engage in voluntary agreements. The recent declaration of the Mulligan River refuge is promising; and publicity from this refuge may motivate others to follow. Landholders motivated to enter voluntary agreements under the second round of the vegetation incentives scheme came primarily from the North Coastal region of the state. The main area of success to date therefore has not been with the agricultural community, but in conservation conscious and non-farming communities where this programme is likely to be preaching to the converted. D. Is the target group accessible and do they have a strong representative body? Queensland farmers have two main representative bodies in Agforce and the Queensland Farmers Federation. Agforce are recently in receipt of substantial funding of $8 million; the purpose of such funding being to ‘support rural industry groups in promoting best management practices in sustainable agriculture.’69 Agforce should consider making provision to incorporate voluntary agreements as part of their promotion of best management practices. Both representative bodies are strong and frequently lobby the government on behalf of their members. For example, Agforce has recently been successful in persuading the government to freeze rural rents for two years. The recent Blueprint partnership is a positive initiative, but it lacks any clear emphasis on effective and sustainable natural resource management nor includes any mention of voluntary conservation agreements. Collaboration with the current Labor government represents a significant shift and pragmatic step on the part of
88
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
the Agforce President. His position is an elected one and time will tell if he can carry the support of the members. The President of the Queensland Farmers Federation is less forward looking, but possibly more representative of landholders, in his recent comment that farmers “want to see less of the government not more.”70The pathway to environmental public and private partnerships has the potential to be facilitated by each representative body, particularly by Agforce. E. Mutual respect and trust The government and the agricultural community have much ground to cover to reach a stage whereby voluntary agreements may be negotiated in an atmosphere of mutual respect and trust. The Blueprint for the Bush partnership project may be one avenue to provide the impetus to start the journey. As perpetual conservation covenants are now dealt with solely by the EPA a great deal rests on the nature refuge officer assigned to any given district to engage with and build trust with landholders. Moves towards partnership have recently been made with the EPA and the Queensland Farmers Federation. F. Soft effects A perpetual covenant requires perpetual maintenance. The provision of adequate support after the agreement has been finalised requires sufficient resources and time from the relevant agencies and this ongoing cost should be factored into the overall costing of a scheme. Covenant holders under the NCA have nature refuge officers assigned to their area to assist with technical expertise and advice; provide information on natural resource management and, in short, general support and regular updates on biodiversity management.71 The assistance received by covenant holders after the establishment phase has been found wanting.72 On-going maintenance is clearly a resource issue, particularly in the remote regions of Queensland. This may be an area in which nongovernment bodies such as Greening Australia could be engaged. The vegetation incentive scheme promises networking with other landholders, peer support and management information.73 10.
Conclusion The focus of this paper has been on voluntary agreements that are the result of direct bargaining between private landholders and public government agencies in the state of Queensland. Such agreements range from covenants in perpetuity to short term contracts and combinations of both covenants and contracts. Utilisation of voluntary agreements will be aided by a centralised approach to natural resource management. The potential role therefore of the NRMMC is crucial for consistency and knowledge transfer. An
Jo Kehoe
89
emphasis on practical aspects, such as the provision by the NRMMC of an adaptable standard form contract, would ensure consistency and legality. The dilemma is that sustainable agriculture requires long-term solutions which, in terms of voluntary agreements, are best suited to perpetual statutory covenants. Such instruments, however, tend to include very limiting land use restrictions and are less likely to be taken up by landholders. Contracts appear more acceptable to property owners and may promote the transition to more sustainable natural resource management. Such agreements however, are bound to the original owner by the doctrine of privity and potentially bound to a five-year term if further funding is not forthcoming. Consideration was given to two voluntary schemes: the nature refuge scheme and the vegetation incentives programme. Nature refuges are growing but they are generally under utilised. The total area of land devoted to refuges amounts to 0.29 per cent of the state and more than half of this area is taken up by one refuge. The vegetation incentive program has, to date, attracted primarily the conservation minded non-farming property owners in the North Coastal region of Queensland. Very little of the $12 million financial package has been distributed. An examination of factors contributing to the uptake of voluntary agreements by the agricultural community indicate that, despite financial incentives being available, more thought needs to be invested into design and implementation, particularly of non-statutory agreements. Farmers, primarily at the smaller end of agricultural production, appear to lack motivation. This is exacerbated by an agricultural community which has some way to go to negotiate with the government in an atmosphere of mutual respect and trust which the utilisation of voluntary agreements necessarily requires. To date voluntary agreements remain under-utilised by the agricultural community in Queensland.
Notes 1
Australia State of the Environment Report, Biodiversity Theme Report, CSIRO,2001, (15 /2/06 ) http://www.deh.gov.au/soe/2001/biodiversity/index.html 2 Ibid. 3 Tim Bonyhady, “Property Rights” Environmental Protection and Legal Change, ed. Tim Bonyhady (Sydney: Federation Press, 1992) p30. 4 Gerry Bates, Environmental Law in Australia (Sydney, Butterworths, 2002) p362. 5 Australian Bureau of Statistics, 24 March 2006, (15 February 2006). http://www.abs.gov.au/Ausstats/
[email protected]/46d1bc47ac9d0c7bca256c4700 25ff87/F7635B38F792374BCA256DEA000539DA?opendocument
90
6
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
See, for example, the national land use map in Australian Natural Resource Atlas, 2001, (14 March 2006) http://audit.deh.gov.au/anra/agriculture/gifs/ag_report/section_1/figure1_2 .gif 7 For a map depicting land tenure within Australia see Australian Government, Geosciences Australia (13 March 2006) http://www.ga.gov.au/education/facts/images/tenure1.gif 8 Natural Resource Management Ministerial Council Communiqué, October 2005,(14 February 2006) http://www.nrm.gov.au/publications/nrm-mbi/mbi.html#what 9 Australian Government, Management of natural resources, “Managing our natural resources: can markets help”? 26 August 2004, (14 February 2006) http://www.nrm.gov.au/publications/nrm-mbi/mbi.html#what 10 In Victoria, the bush tender incentive scheme has had much success, 2006, ( 23 March 2006) http://www.dse.vic.gov.au/ 11 Australian Government, n 9. 12 Neil Gunningham, “Voluntary and Negotiated Agreements in Agriculture: Towards a partnership approach to Resource Management” The Australasian Journal of Natural resources Law and Policy 8 (2003) p25 - 28. Gunningham cites contributing factors which European evidence suggests are crucial to public-private partnerships, these include: the degree of mutual respect and trust; the accessibility of the target group and their representative body; and soft effects. These contributing factors have been considered in the light of the state of Queensland. 13 Natural Heritage Trust, 23 May 2006,(14 March 2006) http://www.nht.gov.au/index.html 14 Ibid. 15 Australian Government, Natural Resource Management, 12 January 2005 ( 27 March 2006) http://www.nrm.gov.au/about-nrm.html 16 Commentary on the criteria for the content of voluntary agreements is also considered in the following: Gunningham, n 12, p23-25, who cites the OECD criteria. Alexander Danne,” Voluntary environmental agreements in Australia,” Environmental Planning & Law Journal 20 (2003) p291 who collates the criteria of other commentators. Patrick Ten Brink P “Future Use: Tools for developing agreements” in “Voluntary Environmental Agreements: process, practice and future use.” ed. Patrick Ten Brink ( UK:Greenleaf Publishing, 2002) reproduces the European Commission Guidelines on voluntary agreements. 17 Miller J, Chew C, Tarrant P & Walsh D, “Listening to Landholders, Community Nature Conservation Market Research 2000” Queensland Government, Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service. In this survey 2000 rural businesses were contacted and elicited 716 responses. 18 Ibid p 2 & p6.
Jo Kehoe
19
91
Queensland Farmers Federation, Hot Issues: http://www.qff.org.au/hot.asp (accessed 13/03/06). 20 One such newspaper is the weekly Queensland Country Life. Available at: http://qcl.farmonline.com.au/home.asp (accessed 27/3/06).Anecdotally this paper is known as “The Bible of the Bush.” In Queensland, it is used as a vehicle by both Agforce and The Queensland Farmers Federation and is politically and often vehemently opposed to the Beattie administration. The paper distributes 41,000 copies per week and core readership is primary producers – e-mail confirmation of figures was provided by Queensland Country Life dated 29/3/06. 21 Agforce. Available at: http://www.agforceqld.org.au/ (accessed 13/3/06). 22 Queensland Farmers Federation. Available at: http://www.qff.org.au/ (accessed 13/3/06). 23 Hon. S Robertson, Minister for Natural Resources and Mines, Queensland Parliamentary Hansard, Vegetation Management and Other Legislation Amendment Bill , Second Reading, ,18/5/04, p 63. Available at: http://www.parliament.qld.gov.au/ (accessed 13/3/06). 24 Queensland Farmers Federation, Core Business: Environment & Natural Resources: available at :http://www.qff.org.au/core.asp?dbcat=2 (accessed 13/3/06). 25 Enhancing Sustainable Agriculture Conference, March 2006: http://www.qff.org.au/hot.asp?dbid=21 ( accessed 13/3/06). 26 The Honourable Desley Boyle, Minister for Environment, Local Government, Planning and Women Wednesday, 22/3/ 2006 “Partnerships benefit farmers and the environment” Media release, available at:http://statements.cabinet.qld.gov.au/MMS/StatementDisplaySingle.aspx ?id=45217 (accessed28/3/06). 27 Ibid. 28 Blueprint for the Bush: consultation report, Phase 1, September 2005. Available at:http://www.agforceqld.org.au/PDFs/Blueprint%20Consultation%20repo rt%20Phase%201%20Final%20(2).pdf (accessed 14/3/06). 29 Blueprint for the Bush. Available at: http://www.agforceqld.org.au/blueprintforthebush.htm (accessed 14/306). 30 Blueprint Tour, Peter Kenny, President, Agforce Queensland, July 2005. Available at: http://www.agforceqld.org.au/blueprintforthebush.htm p2. (accessed 14/306). 31 Ibid p2. 32 Blueprint for the Bush, Discussion paper – Agforce Champion Initiatives. Available at: http://www.agforceqld.org.au/PDFs/AgForce%20Blueprint%20initiatives. pdf p2 (accessed 14/3/06).
92
33
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
Blueprint for the Bush, Discussion paper n 114, p7. Gunningham N, n 12, p28. 35 Stephens S, “Landholders views on conservation covenants” (2002) Australian Landcare. 1141 survey forms were distributed and 466 (41%) returned. 36 Ibid. 37 Stephens S, n35. 38 Stephens S, n35. 39 Stephens S, n35. 40 Stephens S, n35. 41 Lisa Ogle, “The Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth): How Workable is it?” Environmental Planning & Law Journal 17 (2000) 468; Sophie Chapple, “The Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth): One year Later” Environmental Planning & Law Journal 18 (2001) 523. 42 Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) s3 (1) (a) (b) (c). Volume 1:(6 February 2006) http://www.frli.gov.au/comlaw/Legislation/ActCompilation1.nsf/0/B958A 90F4DB0AAF3CA2570000009230A/$file/EnvProtBioDivCons99Vol1W D02.doc 43 Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999(Cth) Part 14, Volume 2. (6 February 2006) http://www.comlaw.gov.au/comlaw/legislation/actcompilation1.nsf/0/400 F5C3D07430F99CA25700000094F3A/$file/EnvProtBioDivCons99Vol2 WD02.do 44 Australian Government, Department of Environment & Heritage, Notices.14April2004,(8March2006)http://www.deh.gov.au/epbc/publicnot ices/species/index.html#making-agreements This was confirmed as at 8 March 2006 by e-mail correspondence from the Database and Internet Management Section, Approvals and Wildlife Division, at the DEH. 45 Nature Conservation Act 1992 (Qld) s4, (15 March 2006)http://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/LEGISLTN/CURRENT/N/Nature ConA92.pdf . 46 Nature Conservation Act 1992 (Qld) s 14 (a) to (l). 47 Nature Conservation Act 1992 (Qld) s6. 48 The Hon. Desley Boyle MP, Environment, Local Government, Planning & Women, “Queensland native refuge network continues to grow” Media release, 8 March 2006, ( 20 March 2006) http://statements.cabinet.qld.gov.au/ 49 It is possible to track all declared nature refuges by going through the superseded to current versions of the Nature Conservation (Protected Areas) Regulation 1994. (26March2006) http://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/SL_AsMade/SL_AsMade.htm 34
Jo Kehoe
50
93
Nature Conservation (Declaration of Nature Refuges) Regulation 1994.(26 March 2006) http://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/LEGISLTN/SLS/1994/94SL135.pdf 51 Environmental Protection Agency, Annual Report on the administration of The Nature Conservation Act, 2004-2005. (27March2006) http://www.epa.qld.gov.au/register/p01702ar.pdf 52 Nature Conservation (Declaration of Nature Refuges) Regulation (No 1) 2005.(14March2006)http://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/LEGISLTN/SLS/2 005/05SL137.pdf 53 Environmental Protection Agency, Nature Refuges. (14 March 2006) http://www.epa.qld.gov.au/nature_conservation/nature_refuges/ The ABC Landline coverage on the Mulligan River refuge is available at this site. 54 E-mail correspondence with the state wide nature refuge coordinator, EPA, Brisbane,13 February 2006. 55 See Australian Bureau of Statistics, n 5. 56 Emma Commerford & Jim Binney, “Lessons learned to date from the Queensland Vegetation Incentives Program in moving from a conceptual ideal to practical reality” paper presented to the Sustainable Agriculture State Level Investment Program, Resource Economics Workshop, Department of Primary Industries, Rockhampton, Queensland, 28 October 2005. 57 Ibid. 58 Commerford & Binney, n 56, p 2-6. 59 Commerford & Binney, n 56, p 2-6. 60 Emma Commerford & Jim Binney “ Lessons learned from the Queensland Vegetation Incentives Program – applying auction theory to vegetation protection” (2006) unpublished paper. 61 Ibid. 62 Commerford & Binney, n 60, p3-4. 63 Commerford & Binney, n 60, p3-4. 64 Carl Binning & Michael Young, “Motivating People: Using management agreements to conserve remnant vegetation,” (Australia: Land & Water Resources, Research & Development Corporation, 1999), p33. 65 Neil Gunningham and Peter Grabosky, Smart Regulation: Designing Environmental Policy (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998) p287. 66 Bates, n4, p35 cites a wealth of commentary in support of this view. 67 NRMMC, Resolution, Market based instruments – Agreement for round two funding. 15 April 2005, (5 April 2006) :http://www.mincos.gov.au/pdf/nrmmc_res_08.pdf 68 Nature Conservation Act 1992 (Qld) s44. 69 Hon. S Robertson, Minister for Natural Resources and Mines, Queensland Parliamentary Hansard, Vegetation Management and Other
94
Voluntary Agreements in Queensland, Australia
Legislation Amendment Bill , Second Reading, ,18/5/04, p 63. Available at: http://www.parliament.qld.gov.au/ (accessed 10/4/06). 70 Sansom G, “Govt Blueprint Needs to get the Basics Right For Rural Revival” QFF (Media release 14 November 2005). Available at: http://www.qff.org.au/media.asp?dbid=29&dbdate=Past (accessed 9/4/06). 71 EPA,NatureRefuges,http://www.epa.qld.gov.au/publications/p01316aa.p df/Nature_refuges.pdf (accessed 27/3/06). 72 Stephens S, n 35. 73 Australian Government, DEH, “Bush.” October 2005.Available at: http://www.deh.gov.au/land/vegetation/bush/index.html (accessed 6/4/06). This edition contains details of the various voluntary covenant programs available in each state.
Section 3 Class and Conflict
Global Environmental Governance: Mapping Unequal and Contested Terrain Andrew Deak Abstract This essay seeks to use a transnational class analysis to get at the complexity of the global environmental governance. This analysis abstracts three main groups from the global political economy: the ruling ‘capitalist’ class, the managerial cadre class in the middle and those on the receiving end of the global governance processes. My first task will be to expound on this social ontology. My second task will be to explain the assumptions adopted in this paper regarding the contradictory nature of modernity and capitalism, and environmental degradation as the routine exploitation of nature. From this class perspective, I will consider responses to environmental degradation seen in current forms of global environmental governance. The response is largely orchestrated by the middle ‘cadre class’, which is organically linked to both the imperatives of the ruling class to protect private property as well as grassroots movements emanating from those on the receiving end of the global governance process - the ‘masses’ to put it crudely. The response will be seen as largely split along reformist and more radical lines. The former sees capitalism as sustainable and requiring better regulation and marketbased solutions; the latter has a tendency to question the sustainability of capitalism and pushes for greater change. I will conclude that a future deepening of ecological crises - which at this rate seems unavoidable - will provide the conditions for a convergence of the various cadre factions into a movement away from neoliberal market solutions. Keywords: global environmental governance; global political economy; transnational historical materialism; World Bank and social movements 1.
Introduction “Be Worried. Be very worried.” Time Magazine, Front cover, April 2006.
There is an ever-increasing sense of urgency surrounding environmental problems such as climate change. Furthermore, issues of global environmental governance are perplexing. This is because one might assume that everyone has a vested interest in global environmental issues, as we are all situated within one global environment. Because we should all be equally concerned, it is all too often considered a “non-class issue.”1 The issues, however, are much more complex due to systemic tendencies of capitalism, the contradictory nature of modernity,
98
Global Environmental Governance
geographical location, issues of gender and race, and subsequent understandings and interpretations of the global governance process and environmental degradation. This essay seeks to use a class analysis to try and get at the complexity of the subject matter, while also placing classes within an understanding of capitalism and modernity. I will try to capture both differences in class and geo-political location by applying a transnational class analysis, which abstracts three main groups from the global political economy: the ruling ‘capitalist’ class, the managerial cadre class in the middle and those on the receiving end of the global governance processes. My first task will be to expound on this social ontology. My second task will be to explain the assumptions adopted in this paper regarding the contradictory nature of modernity and capitalism, and environmental degradation as the routine exploitation of nature. From this class perspective, I will consider responses to environmental degradation seen in current forms of global environmental governance. The response is largely orchestrated by the middle ‘cadre class’, which is organically linked to both the imperatives of the ruling class to protect private property as well as grassroots movements emanating from those on the receiving end of the global governance process - the ‘masses’ to put it crudely. The response will be seen as largely split along reformist and more radical lines. The former sees capitalism as sustainable and requiring better regulation and market-based solutions; the latter has a tendency to question the sustainability of capitalism and pushes for greater change. I will conclude that a future deepening of ecological crises - which at this rate seems unavoidable - will provide the conditions for a convergence of the various cadre factions into a movement away from neoliberal market solutions. 2.
Social Forces Involved in the Global Governance Process As noted, I will be approaching the central question from the perspective of three classes. Before explaining these classes, I will justify the adoption of this framework. This paper takes as a given; …that the contemporary nature and possible future of global environmental governance are heavily shaped and circumscribed by the organization of the global economy…then production has to assume a central role in our analysis.2
Capitalism is the dominant mode of production. To be specific, modern capitalism “involves the generalised production of commodities on the basis of wage labour.”3 This generalised production is production for a world market. People organise along the dominant mode of
Andrew Deak
99
production; that is, they form the social relations of production. It is out of these social relations, then, that we can abstract our three classes. At the global level, the dominant social interests are large business and powerful states. They are the owners of capital. But under what sort of imperatives and assumptions does this class operate? In a word, the protection of private property. This is because they retain wealth and resources within the dominant capitalist mode of production which is based on the liberal idea of private property rights. In their description of the current phase of capitalism as the second financial hegemony, dated from the 1980s onwards, and which refers to “the authority and control that the wealthiest owners of capital and financial institutions exercise over the economy and society in general”, Duménil and Lévy highlight the internal differentiation of this class and its relation to the others: Finance prevails over the other fractions of ruling classes - this is where internal contradictions are at issues in a democracy - and these classes, in turn, dominate the rest of society. Within this configuration, the upper middle classes occupy an intermediate position between ruling classes and the classes which are straightforward victims of the neo-liberal order.4 This upper middle class is part of what Kees van der Pijl and others have called the ‘managerial cadre class’. In addition to the classic notions of a (ruling) bourgeois class and the (subordinate) working class, we have this; …new class taking shape in conditions of late capitalism…The cadre are a class of mediators who execute directive tasks for the ruling class, but like the workers, they are simultaneously a salaried stratum dependent on the sale of labor power.5 According to van der Pijl, “planning and the propagation and monitoring of social norms have historically evolved into a special category of functionaries subordinate to the ruling class - the cadres.” 6 Furthermore, …the cadres represent modernity, but the definition of what modernity is, the momentary code of normalcy inscribed in a hegemonic concept, derives from the balance of class and fractional forces deciding the thrust of overall development rather than any inherent outlook of the cadres.7
100
Global Environmental Governance
Along with this preference for modernity there is an implicit leaning towards a specific form of rationality. Another “problematic characteristic” is that of the preference for democratisation (ibid.). This runs against the assumption of technocracy which the cadre adopts; that is, problems are best solved by the experts. Different segments of the cadre will take on these characteristics in different ways, making their responses to societal problems contradictory. Overall, the cadre mind is framed by systems analysis, so there are points of convergence during times of system wide crisis.8 As for those on the receiving end, little can be said but that they are an amalgamation of various working classes and marginalised peoples that lie under the process of global governance - characterised by the current financial hegemony that Duménil and Lévy speak of - and while they can mobilise to fight for their interests, they largely bear the brunt of the various crises induced by and within capitalism; especially ecological crises. As O’Brien notes: …it has always been the case that much environmental damage, whether it is radiation leakage from nuclear power stations, asbestos poisoning or polluted water, has a disproportionate affect on those people working the industries themselves and their communities.9 We must be careful, however, not to reduce these three classes to homogenous groups. In relation to environmental issues, this third ‘oppressed’ class would include groups that do not have access to resources, are victims of environmental injustice, as well as those who are outside of the key decision-making processes10. This latter faction can overlap with the cadre class as many within this middle class are fully employed and enjoy the benefits of global circuits of capital. In short, the lines are blurry, and the more you try to ‘look’ at a particular class the less you ‘see’ it. It should be noted that even though this paper adopts a transnational class perspective, it is by no means suggesting that the role of nation states is diminished or negligible. What makes this perspective particularly useful is that we are considering global environmental problems vis-à-vis a global capitalist economy which is in a neoliberal era. As Craig Murphy puts it: the social forces that have continued to back the neoliberal agenda are truly transnational, which implies that to understand contemporary global governance we need to develop a class analysis that transcends national boundaries.
Andrew Deak
101
Yet he also notes, Global governance is not simply a superstructure responding to the needs of an already differentiated global ruling class. It is more a site, one of many sites, in which struggles over wealth, power and knowledge are taking place.11 Similarly, Peter Newell and Matthew Paterson effectively demonstrate the decisive role of the state in mitigating the scope of international climate change regimes.12 They also show how one aspect of capital - namely the energy sector - has come to be seen as representative of ‘capital-in-general’, and as such the state systemically tends to favour their interests over other fractions of capital vis-à-vis discussions on climate change.13 In sum, we ought to keep the role of the state in mind, as well as the differentiated and complex nature of both capital and class. 3.
Ecological Degradation, Modernity, and Capitalism. The central issue which this paper addresses is how the classes outlined in the pervious section both perceive, and mobilise in response to, ecological degradation. Before looking at specific responses, we need to better understand what is meant by environmental degradation. First of all, it needs to be understood in relation to both modernity and capitalism which must not be conflated, but seen as historically linked. Environmental degradation “arises out of the normal and mundane practices of modernity and not from the accidental or abnormal.”14 Global environmental problems are a result of normal practices of modernity. To put this in Marxist terms, it is the routine exploitation of nature. A further consequence, according to Julian Saurin, is that “Knowledge of degradation is severely restricted and substantially mediated.”15 Drawing from an ecological Marxist account of capitalism, we see another organic link to environmental degradation. As James O’Connor argues, most Marxists “accept the premise based on the real conditions of capitalist exploitation that capitalism is a crisis-ridden system.”16 When considering the environment, this would lead to an emphasis on the “way that combined power of capitalist production relations and productive forces self-destruct by impairing or destroying rather than reproducing their own conditions.”17 A clear example: “the warming of the atmosphere will inevitably destroy people, places, and profits, not to speak of other species life.”18 In sum, I am adopting two different, though not entirely incompatible, assumptions: (1) environmental degradation is a result of modernity, which in turn obfuscates our understanding of the origin of degradation; and (2) one of the crises of capitalism is seen in its disregard
102
Global Environmental Governance
for the environment and the exhaustion of the society-nature nexus. An important consequence of the second assumption is that “crisis forcibly causes capital and state to exercise more control or planning over production conditions.”19 This helps provide us some insight into the material conditions at the base of the cadre response. Below is the theory behind such planning, as well examples of how this can occur in the global political economy. 4.
Ecological Modernisation The cadre’s response should not be conceived as mechanistic, or as part of a deterministic functionalist system. Rather it involves the (re)production of ideology to make sense of the problems with which they are confronted. The dominant ideology taken up by the reformist aspects of the cadre class in lieu of environmental degradation is that of ecological modernisation. Much like the original modernisation ideology, the ecological version views progress through the lens of economic growth, except now with more explicit considerations for the environment. There have been calls for a “new type of industrialism,”20 which involves investment into ‘natural capital’. Vlachou sums up the position well: In particular, mainstream ecological modernisation sees environmental degradation as a structural problem of capitalism and advocates the restructuring of capitalism along more ecologically sound lines. It takes capitalist economies for granted, that is it does not require an altogether different organization of society. The key argument for ecological modernisation is that there is money in it for business. This is the driving force that induces industry to modernise in ecologically compatible ways. State regulation can strengthen the incentives for business to expand their focus beyond short-terms profits to long-run competitiveness and profitability. In this sense, ecological modernisation legitimizes the intervention of the state. Ecological modernisation also makes efforts to include major middle-class environmental groups in aspects of policy formation. It thus implies a partnership in which governments, businesses, moderate environmentalists and scientists cooperate in the ecological restructuring of capitalism.21 The latest rendition of this argument can be seen in Jonathon Porritt’s Capitalism As if the World Matters.22 He makes two observations in the book: first, “Capitalism is basically the only economic game in
Andrew Deak
103
town, and the vast majority of people (in both the rich and poor world) are content for it to remain so for the definable future”; and second, Learning to live sustainably on the only planet we’ve got is a non-negotiable imperative if we want to avoid an accelerating descent into resource wars, collapsing eco-systems and traumatic social and economic decline.23 These quotes nicely capture the tensions in recognising and acting on environmental degradation from the more institutionalist cadre perspective. There is acknowledgement that major changes need to occur, and yet more radical reorganisation of society is “off-limits.”24 Critics of this perspective note “it would be reckless to underestimate the full lifeforce of capitalism, with its beating heart of capital accumulation which in turn depends on the cycle of commodification and monetisation.”25 And as Vachlou points out, “mainstream ecological modernisation takes for granted capitalism, thus embracing capitalist exploitation and its social ills.”26 We will consider these critical perspectives more in depth later on in this essay. Ecological modernisation is what lies behind a more conservative or reformist response of the cadre that seeks to incorporate ecological principles into the regulation of the market. As we will see below, there are contradictory attempts to build what Sklair calls a “sustainable development historic bloc.”27 This refers to a Gramcian concept, which can be defined as follows: An historical bloc refers to an historical congruence between material forces, institutions and ideologies, or broadly, an alliance of different forces politically organised around a set of hegemonic ideas that gave strategic direction and coherence to its constituent elements. Moreover, for a new historic bloc to emerge, its leaders must engage in ‘conscious planned struggle.28 In the current neoliberal era, the congruence is around protecting private property rights and most solutions proposed are essentially market based. To gain better understanding, we can turn to some real-life manifestations of market-based solutions to environmental problems. We can consider two examples: (1) the proposals for a World Environment Organisation; (2) new sustainable development approaches adopted by the World Bank and other development agencies. The first example will show the tensions within the cadre as to how to define the problems and what solutions to propose; the second will illustrate how the real-life response that this segment of the cadre is pursuing is contradictory in that it furthers
104
Global Environmental Governance
privatisation as well as tries to meet demands for a democratised and truly sustainable modus operandi of the World Bank. 5.
Case Study 1: The World Environmental Organisation: By Who and for Whom? The World Environmental Organisation is an example of a series of proposals for a large institution of comparable status to other institutions of global governance such as the WTO. I will focus on a particular version presented by Whalley and Zissimos29 and the subsequent critique by Newell.30 The WEO that Whalley and Zissimos are after would “address the underlying causes of ineffective international action on the environment.”31 Much of this is in reference to shortcomings of how the UN has addressed global environmental issues. This particular proposal would seek to focus on the issue of “internationalisation” which is “traditionally understood to mean internalising the cost of environmental degradation at source and removing ‘spill over’ effects”. The assumptions underlying this approach is “that market failures are responsible for poor levels of environmental protection and that creating markets for environmental goods is the most efficient and effective way to provide them.”32 The WEO would achieve internationalisation via “engaging in deal brokering, whereby environmental commitments are exchanged for financial payments” which it would then oversee.33 For this to work, issues of property rights would have to be resolved. Newell critiques the proposals saying that it is the ‘wrong solution to the wrong problem’ and that it is “unlikely to make much progress in delivering…because of misplaced assumptions about the existing political order and the ability of a deal-brokering WEO to remedy the problems they identify.”34 For Newell, it is an impractical solution that amounts to “institutional tinkering.”35 How can we conceive of this proposal within the class analysis? Segments of the cadre class would oppose increased public regulation, as that implies likely restrictions on wealth and capital (re)generation and thus challenge the status quo. In a memo leaked from the World Bank, the chief economist advocates “shifting polluting industries to the Third World on grounds that this was in line with their comparative advantage in capacity to absorb pollution.”36 However, as Sklair points out, the capitalist class always faces a challenge from below37, and I would argue that environmental problems are a part of that challenge, but also are more all encompassing - they can both contribute to class antagonism as well as affecting the conditions of production out of which the ruling class extract their profits. Thus, it is conceivable that some factions of the cadre class acting (or in many cases, just speaking) on behalf of the ruling class would agree with the establishment of a global institution that regulates the environment on the condition that it would reinforce property rights, as
Andrew Deak
105
well as bolster market efficiency. The proposal of the WEO outlined above seems compatible with this, as it would free up the WTO’s resources to focus on liberalising world trade.38 The WEO is a typical incarnation of the cadre class. We can conceive of it as an effort to carve out a space where effective mediation can take place. The mobilisation around environmental issues is analogous (or a macrocosm) of the movement for a New International Economic Order (NIEO) in the 1970s. Here the pressure that the ruling classes felt from the leftist social movements of the 1960s set the backdrop for the cadre to mobilise and generate substantive discussions around the formation of a NIEO in which states would assert their sovereignty over corporations.39 Similarly, during the 1980s the environmental movement gained prevalence throughout the world, but especially in the US.40 Thus, the push in the 1990s for something like the WEO is a result of shifts in the political climate. Much like the NIEO, the cadre push for global environmental governance has failed thus far to generate any concrete results in the form of the creation of large regulatory institutions like the WEO. Nonetheless, we can still understand how the WEO represents a moment of heightened cadre activity, as it tries to both solve problems while understanding the ‘existing reality’ - that is, among other things, the current institutional make-up of the global governance process with all its limitations - and also pushing for increased democracy. In short, they are both aspirational and practical. But as Newell points out, from a criticalleft cadre perspective, the proposed WEO would not improve the undemocratic forms of global governance. In his words: It would do little to address the exclusionary nature of global policy-making on the environment, which means that Southern countries concerns are rarely adequately represented. Under the WEO scheme, the allocation and exploitation of global commons resources would be privatised.41 This brings us to consider the perspective of those at the receiving end of the global governance process. One of the main issues that this subordinate class would have is the bypassing of the existing channels through which they have traditionally expressed their views, namely the UN fora.42 A likely reaction of the global south would probably be analogous to their refusal to support the Global Environment Facility (GEF), an initiative of the World Bank that would provide grants to developing countries for implementing activities that “generate global environmental benefits.”43 As a result the GEF is having difficulty in meeting its mandate. As Skair notes “ecological demands were
106
Global Environmental Governance
problematically translated and drafted into the service of the transnational capitalist class.”44 Others have termed such a phenomenon “green imperialism.”45 I will further explore this in the next section. 6.
Case Study 2: Development Organisations as Proponents of ‘Green neo-liberalism’ “All environmental problems can be mitigated by microeconomic tools…That’s how we find the true value of nature” - a Senior World Bank Official.46
As Vachlou tells us, there is much evidence highlighting the “significant problems, limitations and setbacks in the greening of capitalism.”47 One of the key avenues for such greening has been through development agencies and their projects. Two important studies are Michael Goldman’s study of the World Bank’s response to pressure from environmental movements as well as Zoe Young’s critical assessment of the GEF, the offshoot of the World Bank mentioned above. When Young shows that the GEF acts as a kind of greenwash to the Bank’s programs, Goldman sees the Bank’s greening “neither simply window dressing, nor mere public relations, as many critics argue. It is rather the Bank’s latest and most profound discursive framework, producing a power/knowledge regime of green neoliberalism.”48 What is interesting from our class perspective, is that Goldman details how the bank responded to strong social movements and the subsequent pressures to properly address environmental problems in a democratic and participatory way. One well-known example is the social movement against the displacements caused by the construction of the Narmada dam in India: the Bank’s executive directors had little choice but to vote to pull out of the project. This episode was important not only to social activists around the world, who could now see their potential power, but for the World Bank Itself. The ‘Narmada effect,’ as it has come to be called, is invoked regularly inside the Bank and reminds staff that the Bank must ‘reform or die.’49 Because of the success of the World Bank’s social-movement critics, they have been forced to “enlist scores of social actors and institutions to help generate its green neoliberal regime”. Furthermore, “while activists and academics build their case against a World Bank that they see as ecologically and socially destructive, the Bank plugs away at greening its works, engaging more ecosystems and populations in its loan portfolio, and involving ever more partners and populations from the
Andrew Deak
107
private and public sectors.”50 The result is that now the World Bank is one of the powerful - if not the most powerful - environmentalist institutions in the world. It has been able to cleverly carve out its own green agenda, taking its newly developed tools, finances, environmental policies and applied environmental science and training professionals in borrowing countries to implement and “indigenize” it.51 The response from the World Bank can then be viewed as a process of incorporating - or better yet, co-optation of environmental critics, and reproducing its hegemony. This is by no means an innocent process either, as Goldman notes one of the dangerous consequences of green neo-liberalism is further accumulation by dispossession52, which is said to: Include the commodification and privatisation of land and the forceful expulsion of peasant populations; the conversation of various forms of property rights (common, collective, state, etc.) into exclusive private property rights; the suppression of rights to the commons; the commodification of labour power and the suppression of alternatives (indigenous) forms of production and consumption; colonial, neo-colonial, and imperial processes of appropriation of assets (including natural resources); the monetization of exchange and taxation, particularly of land; the slave trade; and usury, the national debt, and ultimately the credit system, as radical means of primitive accumulation.53 So much for effective solutions for environmental problems. If we take this as a consequence of the actions of the more conservativereformist cadre, than it seems that further environmental degradation is inevitable, leading to further social instability, and as such, more resistance from below. Although the World Bank is a dominant force within the development industry, it is not the only actor. This green neo-liberalism can be seen elsewhere in the development field, albeit in more nuanced and subtle forms. We need only turn to the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development to see that they had adopted an explicitly market-based approach to the environment: Government policy which promotes economic growth and private sector development should adequately promote sustainable resource use and good environmental management through appropriate regulation, property rights and market-based instruments.54
108
Global Environmental Governance
Together, these institutions only comprise of one facet of the cadre class, and their efforts to manage the environment. There are a plethora of radical movements in the midst of the global political economy, such as the movements against the Narmada damn in India, that reach similar conclusions to Goldman, namely that the World Bank needs to be shut down and radical alternatives should be independently sought. We will consider some of these in the next section. 7.
Radical Movements Away from the Neoliberal Market Solutions As Newell points out, the idea of a sustainable development historic block “implies a division between reformers and radicals within the environmental movement that hold opposing views of the compatibility of neo-liberal capitalism with sustainable development.”55 There are more radical movements, generally neglected by the media.56 There are, however, important and should be considered as part of the cadre response. For example, the landless movement in Brazil, known by the acronym MST, have a distinctly environmentalist agenda that goes hand in hand with their challenges to property rights. 57 This means that they can conceive of radical possibilities beyond those bounded by the neo-liberal paradigm. There are also several radical movements in the North, such as efforts at localisation and establishment of local currency that valorises goods and services within a particular community or set of communities independently of the world market. 58 What is more pertinent for the analysis being conducted in this paper is the congealing of these movements. Indeed, There is also evidence of connections increasingly being forged in the North between environmental groups and organisations that are traditionally assumed to represent the working class, such as trade unions, in the context of broader campaigns for fair trade or anti-globalisation protests.59 This was demonstrated at the protests against the WTO Seattle, 1999, with the apt slogan “Teamsters and turtles, together at last.”60 By distinguishing between the different waves of environmentalism, Newell helps us gain a more nuanced view. Second wave environmentalism, that is generally “white and middle class in its staff, membership and perspective,” and the third wave of grassroots environmentalists that are mostly “working class people, many of whom are people of colour”. Importantly, …the latter bring different histories and experiences to the table because of their backgrounds and often have
Andrew Deak
109
less faith in the law and more experience with non-legal strategies than mainstream environmentalists having uncovered through their on experience ‘the hidden power of pollution and environmental laws’61 The split between second and third way environmentalism is analogous to the split between the reformist and radical factions of the cadre, respectively. Generally speaking, those who are second wave view capitalism as compatible with sustainability, and the third wave consider contemporary capitalism as the source of the problem. Something that has not been considered thus far has been whether capitalism is ultimately sustainable or not from the perspective adopted in this paper. Earlier I explained how the current phase of neo-liberal phase of capitalism carries with it the tendency towards crises, which identified long ago by Marx.62 Can ecological crises be overcome under the auspices of capitalism? And if so, what sort of implication does that have for more radical strategies? As Vachlou notes, Interestingly, the possibility of a sustainable capitalism can be clearly derived from a Marxist analysis of the changes and adjustments made in capitalism in response to the ecological problems the latter creates. Such an analysis offers new empowering insights to radical movements regarding the workings of contemporary capitalism and the risks of incorporation; hence it should not be readily discounted as a ‘justifier of corporate environmentalism’.63 This is significant as it allows for convergence between the reformist and radical factions, while empowering the latter to not become absorbed and neutralised by the former. While the outlook is bleak from a more conservative wing of the cadre response, David Law does indicate some transformative possibilities within the global political economy that might be the basis for a more fundamental approach to ‘greening’: NGOs, including co-operatives like the Spanish Mondragon group, self-help community-based movements like Sarvodaya Sharmadana and people’s banks like the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, might make people and governments less dependent on big business and capital markets This would serve to limit the ‘structural power’ of capital both economically as it institutionalises and exemplifies an to total reliance on markets and profit-seeking enterprises. A true greening
110
Global Environmental Governance of the Bank would be one supportive of democratization and the development of civil society, where the latter is much more than the private business sector.64
Indeed, the sort of alternatives Law highlights would allow for indigenous knowledges to emerge and for more awareness and detection of environmental degradation would potentially increase. Furthermore, they are less capitalistic and would be less prone to contributing to a system that both causes and is extremely susceptible to ecological crises. Law goes on to conclude: Above all, GROs [grass-roots organisations] and NGOs need to build up sources of structural power including knowledge defined broadly to include local environmental expertise and skills in networking. Perhaps then, especially with a deepening environmental crisis in the future, multilateral institutions like the World Bank, will have to engage in some radical ‘structural adjustment’ themselves.65 Real ‘solutions’ to the problem have to come from those who possess knowledge that lies outside modern rationality, namely among the oppressed classes; as well as those with access to resources, namely radical factions of the cadre class which are open to reinterpreting understandings of modernity and can broaden their systems analysis to include the possibility of radical alternatives. “[In] order to affect radical social transformation, emphasis should be given to the articulation of these different struggles through a united coalition able to challenge capitalism.”66 Making a similar argument, Lucy H. Ford notes: A collective global consciousness would bring insiders and outsiders together in a symbiotic strategy. Some radical movements are point out the dangers of cooptation through global civil society, as well as the dangers of adopting orthodox discourses. They are recognising the need for the engagers to retain links with grassroots in the battle over the agency of global society and attempts to radicalize and expand it…Similarly, grassroots movements that “think globally” while resisting locally, nationally, and transnationally across the globe can remain in dialogue with the institutionalized environment organisations, keeping them alert and keeping the radical message of ecology and social justice alive by challenging the arbitrary limits of social reality and social practice. 67
Andrew Deak
111
8.
Fundamental Obstacles, Possibilities for Change and Some Concluding Remarks The proposition of the WEO is one institutionalist way that the cadre class is responding ecological crisis, yet we also saw the current proposals are not feasible from a critical-cadre perspective. The sustainable development frameworks articulated by the likes of Porritt and adopted by the World Bank, DFID and other agencies can be chalked up to a form of green neo-liberalism. How are we to explain these institutionalist and market-based responses and their tendency to provide only partial solutions at best? The cadre are impeded because of the tendency of modernity to mask the origins of degradation. The “restorative, but ultimately ineffective, efforts” of the cadre are a distraction for the real causes of environmental problems inherent in the capitalist system itself.68 Furthermore, the environmental movements that have been incorporated into the cadre class are often made up of the typical middle-class population that is reluctant to challenge property relations or questions of access to land, and thus; …the political interests of the class they represent make it unlikely that anything other than a weak sustainability reformist agenda can be pursued given the extent to which they benefit, directly and indirectly, from the status quo.69 However, we also saw significant movement from the critical-left segment of the cadre, which is willing to push the envelope in terms of broad systemic changes - such as a move from ideologies of globalisation to localisation. There is a case for the convergence of the conservative, reformist and radical elements of the cadre class. The ideology of the reformist, ecological modernisation, does legitimise the role of the state, which can then be a tool for comprehensive and democratic regulation of the environment. But also, it is possible to conceive of a sustainable capitalism from a radical, and even Marxist, ecological perspective. Surely, the deepening of ecological crises will provide a precedent for such a convergence. In order to effectively nudge the cadre trajectory on a path away from neoliberal solutions, the radical movements and criticalNGOs need to hold onto their radical perspectives that challenge the fundamentals of capitalism. That way they avoid the risks of incorporation and the stymieing of the broader movement in the name of capital.
112
Global Environmental Governance
Notes 1
David Harvey, “The Nature of Environment: Dialectics of Social and Environmental Change” in Socialist Register: Real Problems, False Solutions., eds. Miliband, R. and Pantich, L. (London: Merlin Press, 1993). 2 Peter Newell ‘Race, Class and the Politics of Environmental Inequality’, Global Environmental Politics (2005): 81 3 Derek Sayer, Capitalism and Modernity: An Excursus on Marx and Weber. (London: Routledge, 1991), 24. 4 D. Duménil and D. Lévy ‘Neo-liberal Dynamics – Towards a New Phase?’ in Global Regulation: Managing Crises after the Imperial Turn., eds. van der Pijl, K. et al. (Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire; New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004), 31. 5 Kees van der Pijl. ‘Globalization or Class Society in Transition?’ Science and Society. 65(4) (2001): 499. 6 Kees van der Pijl, Transnational Classes and International Relations. (London: Routledge, 1998), 138. 7 ibid., 142 8 van der Pijl, 2001, 498 9 Obrien (2001) cited in Newell (2005): 83 10 Hardt and Negri make a similar point: “In a previous era the category of the proletariat centered on and was at times effectively subsumed under the industrial working class, whose paradigmatic figure was tha make factory worker…Today that working class has all but disappeared from view. It has not ceased to exist, but has been discplaced from its privileged position in the capitalist economy and its hegemonic position in the class composition of the proletariat…The fact that under the category of proletariat we understand all those exploited by and subject to capitalist domination should not indicate that the proletariat is a homogenous or undifferentiated unit.” Empire (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2000), 52-3. 11 Murphy (2002) cited in Newell (2005): 81. 12 Peter Newell and Matthew Paterson ‘A climate for business: global warming, the state and capital’. Review of International Political Economy, 5(3) (1998): 679-703. 13 For further discussions on these themes, consult the Levy, D. and Newell, P (eds.) (2005) The Business of Global Environmental Governance. 14 Julian Saurin ‘Global Environmental Degradation, Modernity and Environmental Knowledge’, Environmental Politics. 2(4) (1993): 46-64. (Saurin, 1993, p.62).
Andrew Deak
113
The reader is reminded of van der Pijl’s definition of modernity: ‘the momentary code of normalcy inscribed in a hegemonic concept’. 15 ibid. 16 J. O’Connor, ‘Capitalism, Nature, Socialism. A Theoretical Introduction’, Capitalism, Nature, Socialism. 1(1) (1989): 11-37. 17 ibid., 25 18 ibid. 19 ibid., 29 20 Paul Hawkins et al, Natural Capitalism: Creating the Next Industrial Revolution (Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1999). 21 A. Vlachou, ‘Capitalism and ecological sustainability: the shaping of environmental policies’, Review of International Political Economy. 11(3), (2004): 926-952. emphasis added 22 Jonathan Porritt, Capitalism as if the world matters. (London: Earthscan, 2005). 23 Jonathan Porritt, “As if the world matters”: reconciling sustainable development and capitalism” openDemocracy, November, 30, 2005. 24 Vachlou, 2004, 943 25 Simms, 2005, “The debt to pay” openDemocracy, December, 6, 2005. 26 Vlachou, 2004, 943 27 Leslie Sklair, The Transnational Capitalist Class. (Oxford: Blackwell, 2001) 28 Stephen Gill, Power and Resistance in the New World Order. (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003) 29 Whalley and Zissimos, 2002 30 Peter Newell ‘A World Environment Organisation: The Wrong Solution to the Wrong Problem’, World Economy. 25(5) (2002): 659-671 31 ibid. 32 ibid., 661 33 ibid 34 ibid., 660 35 ibid., 670 36 D. Law ‘Global Environmental Issues and the World Bank’ in Globalisation, Democratisation and Multilateralism., ed. Gill, S. Basingstoke, Tokyo: Macmillan; United Nations University Press, 1997). 37 Sklair, 2001. 38 Newell, 2002, 660 39 R.W. Cox (1978) ‘Ideologies and the New International Economic Order: Reflections on Some Recent Literature’, International Organization. 33(2), (1978): 257-302. 40 Zoe Young, A New Green Order? The World Bank and the Politics of the Global Environmental Facility. (Stirling, Virginia: Pluto Press, 2002). 41 Ibid., 667 42 ibid.
114
43
Global Environmental Governance
ibid., 664 Sklair cited in Young, 2002, 15 45 L. Pratt and W. Montgomery “Green Imperialism: Pollution, Penitence, Profits” in Socialist Register, ed. Leo Panitch (London: Merlin Press, 1997). 46 Micheal Goldman, Imperial Nature: The World Bank and Struggles for Social Justice in the Age of Globalization. (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2005) 47 Vlachou, 2004, 945 48 Young 2002, 5 49 ibid.,152-3 50 ibid., 182 51 ibid., 156-7 52 ibid., 290 53 David Harvey, The New Imperialism. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003), 145. also cited in Susanne Soederberg, Global Governance in Question: Empire, Class and the New Common Sense in Managing North-South Relations, (London: Pluto Press, 2006), 48. For more on ‘accumulation by dispossession’, see Harvey (2003) or alternatively consult the following piece online: http://titanus.roma1.infn.it/sito_pol/Global_emp/Harvey.htm 54 DFID website, 2006, emphasis added. 55 Newell, 2005, 84 56 Derek Wall, Babylon and Beyond: The Economics of Anti-Capitalist, Anti-Globalist and Radical Green Movements. Pluto Press, 2005; Mueller, Tadzio. Other Worlds, Other Values: Alternative value-practices and the European Anticapitalist movement. Phd Thesis, University of Sussex. 2006. 57 Peter Houtzager (2005). ‘The Movement of the Landless (MST) and the juridical field in Brazil’ IDS Working Papers (2005). G. Meszaros, ‘No ordinary revolution: Brazil’s Landless Workers’ Movement’ Race and Class. 42(2) (2000): 1-18. 58 Edward Goldsmith and Jerry Mander, The Case Against the Global Economy. (San Fransisco: Sierra Club Books, 2001). See also Mueller, 2006, for an account of the Escanda, a nascent eco-community that operates using alternative value-practices, which also serves as an important node in the broader European anticapitalist network. V. Bennholdt-Thomsen, and M. Mies, The Subsistence Perspective: Beyond the Globalised Economy. (New York: Zed Books, 1999). De Sousa Santos, B. ed., Another Production is Possible: Beyond the Capitalist Canon (London: Verso, 2006). 59 Obach, 2004, quoted by Newell, 2005, 84 60 ibid., 85 61 Ibid; Cole, 1992. p.643 44
Andrew Deak
115
62
K. Marx, Capital – Volume 3. (London: Penguin, 1981) .Vlachou, 2004, 948 64 Law, 1997, 187-8 65 ibid., 193 66 Vlachou, 2004, 948 67 Lucy H. Ford, ‘Challenging the Global Environmental Govrenance of Toxics: Social Movement Agency and Global Civil Society’ in The Business of Global Environmental Governance. 68 Julian Saurin, ‘Global Environmental Crisis as the ‘Disaster Triumphant’: The Private Capturing of Public Goods’ Environmental Politics. 10(4) (2001): 63-84. 69 Newell, 2005, 84 63
Bibliography Bennholdt-Thomsen, V., Faraclas, N. and von Werlhof, C. (eds.) There is an alternative: Subsistence and Worldwide Resistance to Corporate Globalization. New York: Zed Books, 2001. Bennholdt-Thomsen, V. and Mies, M. The Subsistence Perspective: Beyond the Globalised Economy. New York: Zed Books, 1999. Cole, L. “Empowerment as the Key to Environmental Protection: The Need for Environmental Poverty Law.” Ecology Law Quarterly 19 (1992): 619–683. Cox, R.W. “Ideologies and the New International Economic Order: Reflections on Some Recent Literature” International Organization. 33(2) (1978): 257-302. DFID (2006). DFID’s Approach to the Environment. February. Downloaded from http://www.dfid.gov.uk/mdg/environment.asp April 4, 2006. Duménil G. and Lévy, D. (2004). “Neo-liberal Dynamics - Towards a New Phase?” in Global Regulation: Managing Crises after the Imperial Turn. Edited by van der Pijl, K., et al. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire; New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004 Gill, S. Power and Resistance in the New World Order. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003
116
Global Environmental Governance
Goldsmith, E. and Mander, J. The Case Against the Global Economy. San Fransisco: Sierra Club Books, 2001. Goldman, Michael. Imperial Nature: The World Bank and Struggles for Social Justice in the Age of Globalization. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2005 Goldman, Michael. “The birth of a discipline: Producing authoritative green knowledge, World Bank-style” Ethnography. 2(2) (2001): 191-217 Houtzager, P. “The Movement of the Landless (MST) and the juridical field in Brazil” IDS Working Papers. 2005. Downloaded April, 3 2006 from: http://www.ids.ac.uk/ids/bookshop/wp/wp248.pdf Hardt, M. and Negri, T. Empire. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2000. Harvey, David. The New Imperialism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003. Harvey, David “The ‘New Imperialism’: on spacio-termporal fixes and accumulation by dispossession”, 2003. Downloaded from http://titanus.roma1.infn.it/sito_pol/Global_emp/Harvey.htm May 30, 2006. Harvey, David “The Nature of Environment: Dialectics of Social and Environmental Change” Socialist Register: Real Problems, False Solutions. Edited by Ralf Miliband and Leo Panitch. London: Merlin Press, 1993. Law, David. “Global Environmental Issues and the World Bank” in Globalisation, Democratisation and Multilateralism. Edited by Stephen Gill. Basingstoke, Tokyo: Macmillan; United Nations University Press, 1997. Levy, D. and Newell, P (eds.). The Business of Global Environmental Governance. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2005. Marx, K. Capital - Volume 3. London: Penguin, 1981. Meszaros, G. “No ordinary revolution: Brazil’s Landless Workers” Movement’ Race and Class. 42(2) (2000): 1-18
Andrew Deak
117
Mueller, Tadzio. Other Worlds, Other Values: Alternative value-practices and the European Anticapitalist movement. Unpublished Phd Thesis, University of Sussex. 2006 Murphy, C. “Why Pay Attention to Global Governance?” in Global Governance: Critical Perspectives. Edited by R. Wilkonson and S. Hughes. London: Routledge, 2002. Newell, P. “Race, Class and the Politics of Environmental Inequality” Global Environmental Politics. (2005): 70-94. Newell, P. “A World Environment Organisation: The Wrong Solution to the Wrong Problem” World Economy. 25(5) (2002): 659-671. Newell, P. and Paterson, M. “A climate for business: global warming, the state and capital” Review of International Political Economy, 5(3), (1998): 679-703. O’Brien, M. “Labour” in Anti-Capitalism: A Guide to the Movement. Edited by E. Bircham and J. Charlton. London and Sydney: Bookmarks Publications, 2001. O’Connor, J. “Capitalism, Nature, Socialism. A Theoretical Introduction’” Capitalism, Nature, Socialism. 1(1) (1988):11-37. Obach, Brian. Labour and the Environmental Movement: The Quest for Common Ground. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2004 van der Pijl, K. “Globalization or Class Society in Transition?” Science and Society. 65(4) (2001): 492-500. van der Pijl, K. Transnational Classes and International Relations. London: Routledge, 1998. Porritt, J. “As if the world matters”: reconciling sustainable development and capitalism” openDemocracy, November, 30, 2005. Downloaded March, 15: http://www.opendemocracy.net/globalizationclimate_change_debate/capitalism_3074.jsp Porritt, J. Capitalism as if the world matters. London: Earthscan, 2005. Pratt, L. and Montgomery W. “Green Imperialism: Pollution, Penitence, Profits” Socialist Register. Edited by Leo Panitch. London: Merlin Press, 1997.
118
Global Environmental Governance
Sayer. Derek Capitalism and Modernity: An Excursus on Marx and Weber. London: Routledge, 1991. Saurin, Julian. “Global Environmental Crisis as the ‘Disaster Triumphant’: The Private Capturing of Public Goods” Environmental Politics. 10(4) (2001): 63-84. Saurin, Julian. “Global Environmental Degradation, Modernity and Environmental Knowledge” Environmental Politics. 2(4) (1993): 46-64. Simms, A. “The debt to pay” openDemocracy, December, 6, 2005. Downloaded March, 15: http://www.opendemocracy.net/globalizationclimate_change_debate/replies_porritt_3093.jsp Sklair, Leslie. The Transnational Capitalist Class. Oxford: Blackwell, 2001. Soederberg, Susanne. Global Governance in Question: Empire, Class and the New Common Sense in Managing North-South Relations, London: Pluto Press, 2006. De Sousa Santos, Bouventrua (ed.) Another Production is Possible: Beyond the Capitalist Canon London: Verso, 2006. Time. “Special Report on Global Warming” Time, April 3, 2006. Vlachou, A. “Capitalism and ecological sustainability: the shaping of environmental policies” Review of International Political Economy. 11(3) (2004): 926-952. Wall, Derek Babylon and Beyond: The Economics of Anti-Capitalist, AntiGlobalist and Radical Green Movements. London: Pluto Press, 2005. Whaller, J. and Zissimos B. “An internationalisation-based World Environment Organisation” World Economy. 25 (2002): 650-658. Whitelegg, J. “Beyond Capitalism” openDemocracy December 6, 2005. Downloaded March 15, 2005:http://www.opendemocracy.net/globalizationclimate_change_debate/replies_porritt_3093.jsp Young, Zoe. A New Green Order? The World Bank and the Politics of the Global Environmental Facility. Stirling, Virginia: Pluto Press, 2002.
Andrew Deak
119
The author would like to acknowledge the comments from Lilian Yap and Dr. Peter J. Newell; their feedback has been essential in refining the arguments put forth in the paper. I am of course, responsible for any oversights or mistakes in the paper.
Sustainable Outcomes through Effective Conflict Management Tania Sourdin Abstract It is now relatively common for facilitative dispute resolution processes to be used in many countries where public policy disputes arise. Such processes are often supported by government agencies and may vary according to the individual dispute and the facilitators involved. Public issue disputes or “disputes which affect members of the public as well as the principal parties”1 can be divided into three main categories: enforcement disputes (relating to compliance with laws and regulations); permitting disputes (relating to planned construction of new facilities); and policy or law-making disputes (related to the establishment of new policy or standards in management). There are few guidelines available to assist in the development of approaches to deal with complex public disputes.2 These disputes can present environmental, economic and social dilemmas. Wootten divides these categories into “site-specific disputes and policy-related matters.”3 Increasingly, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) processes are being used to help plan and manage discussions about these disputes. This approach is a departure from the ‘Commission’ or ‘Inquiry’ approach where recommendations appear to be largely unimplemented and the discussions often feature positional rather than interest- or needs- based approaches. In many public disputes there appears to be some reluctance to use ADR processes, particularly among those in the conservation movement.4 On the other hand, such processes can be viewed as encouraging more participatory decision making. This paper discusses the use of facilitative dispute management processes in managing environmental conflict and focuses on system design issues that include broader definitional issues, negotiation dilemmas as well as framework constraints. Key words: Dispute resolution, conflict negotiation, environment, sustainable outcomes 1.
resolution,
mediation,
Introduction Facilitative dispute management processes have emerged in response to a growing recognition that adversarial approaches to environmental conflict resolution do not ordinarily address underlying interests (as they focus on positions), promote lasting outcomes, compliance with outcomes or support the development or maintenance of relationships. However facilitative processes have been the subject of
122 Sustainable Outcomes through Effective Conflict Management criticism in the environmental area for a range of reasons. Lack of ‘court’ oversight, suggestions about ‘secret’ deals, concerns about the impartiality or credentials of ‘facilitators’ as well as concerns about outcomes and compliance with core environmental principles are primary issues where facilitative processes are used in environmental conflict management.5 These criticisms have been mostly related to mediation processes, rather than the full range of facilitative processes. Horn has stated: On balance, mediation is not suited to environmental conflicts where the risk of damage to the environment is serious because there is no certainty that the environment will be protected. More progress is needed to establish an appropriate institution which can monitor standards, consider complaints and enforce accountability on the part of mediators. There are also no means of ensuring that environmental policies and legislation are taken into account when the mediated settlement is agreed to. The practice of mediation of environmental conflicts is not adequately monitored to ensure that the process is ethical and that the outcome prevents degradation to the environment and protects the interests of present and future generations.6 Are such concerns valid when the entire range of facilitative processes is considered (rather than mediation only)? And, if they are valid, can such concerns be addressed by ensuring that conflict resolution and management processes are adequately planned and considered prior to and during their use? Many conflict resolution theorists and practitioners consider that mediation may not be the ‘answer’ to complex environmental conflict but that carefully facilitative structured processes may assist in most so called ‘intractable’ disputes.7 On the other hand, mediation has clearly played a major role in the resolution of many complex national and international conflicts over the past two decades. However, in complex environmental disputes most commentators suggest that the broader range of facilitative processes, which may incorporate mediatory aspects, are of greater assistance. A. The Nature of Conflict Questions about the utility of facilitative processes cannot be considered without considering why this fuller range of conflict resolution processes has developed in recent years. Perhaps it is not surprising given the abundance of conflict in many societies, particularly those with an individualistic focus. Clearly, conflict exists at all levels of society. Humans fight, go to war, injure each other, compete, avoid, submit and use other more cooperative or peaceful processes when in conflict.
Tania Sourdin
123
Conflict can exist between states, at home, at work and in the neighbourhood. Conflict is ubiquitous. As one eminent conflict theorist, G Tillett, has noted: “It can focus on trivia or the future of life on earth.”8 Strategies to deal with the resolution of conflict (even in the environmental arena) have included reference to principles of justice, morality and divine guidance.9 Conflict is a constantly changing phenomenon. Perceptions and interpretations are used to translate the past, present and future. Small, seemingly irrelevant actions (or a lack of action) by one party in conflict have the capacity to shape large changes in the perceptions of others and to influence outcomes in significant ways. It is probable that many conflicts grow out of disputes after events, actions and responses have been interpreted, re-interpreted, exaggerated and in part distorted or ‘hallucinated’ by the perceptual filters of all those concerned. Conflict is as individual as those who are involved in it. Conflict has also been described as the product of unmet needs (physiological and/or psychological) and of differences that remain unrecognised and unacknowledged. Conflict is a normal product of our interaction as humans. The effects of conflict vary; conflict produces change that can be viewed as positive or negative. Arguably, without conflict our society could not change and develop. B. Conflict Management Individuals and groups can deal with conflict in a range of ways. The most common way of