Electrostatic Discharge
IEEE Press 445 Hoes Lane Piscataway, NJ 08854 IEEE Press Editorial Board Lajos Hanzo, Editor i...
148 downloads
1780 Views
31MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Electrostatic Discharge
IEEE Press 445 Hoes Lane Piscataway, NJ 08854 IEEE Press Editorial Board Lajos Hanzo, Editor in Chief R. Abari J. Anderson S. Basu A. Chatterjee
T. Chen T. G. Croda S. Farshchi B. M. Hammerli
O. Malik S. Nahavandi M. S. Newman W. Reeve
Kenneth Moore, Director of IEEE Book and Information Services (BIS) Jeanne Audino, Project Editor
Electrostatic Discharge Understand, Simulate, and Fix ESD Problems Third Edition
Michel Mardiguian
A John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Publication
Copyright © 2009 by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey. All rights reserved. Published simultaneously in Canada. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, or online at www.wiley.com/go/permission. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic formats. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available. ISBN: 978-0470-39704-6 Printed in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
Preface to the First Edition
ix
Preface to the Third Edition Acknowledgements
xi
xiii
1. The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon 1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4.
Physics Involved 1 Influencing Parameters 6 Various Types of Electrostatic Charging with Humans and Objects 9 Statistics of Voltages and Currents Reached During ESD 1.4.1. Personnel ESD Statistics 15 1.4.2. Furniture and Objects ESD Statistics
1.5.
1
Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
13
18 23
1.5.1. Personal ESD Waveforms 23 1.5.2. Furniture ESD Waveforms 28 1.5.3. Summary: Comparison of Dynamic Parameters for Personnel and Furniture ESD 30 1.5.4. Actual versus Idealized ESD Waveforms 31 References 37
2. Effects of ESD on Electronics 2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 2.4.
Direct Discharge to an Electronic Component 39 Direct Discharge to Electronic Equipment Enclosure 50 Indirect Discharge 53 Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry 2.4.1. Magnetic Field Coupling 55 2.4.2. Electric Field Coupling from Indirect ESD on Floating Parts 58 2.4.3. Measured E- and H -Field Values near an ESD to a Grounded Structure 60 2.4.4. Effect of Wave Impedance on Voltages Induced in Nearby PCBs and Small Circuits 64
39
54
vi
Contents
2.5.
2.4.5. Effect of a Typical Metallic Cabinet on ESD-Radiated Effects 2.4.6. Common Impedance Coupling with an ESD 69 Response of Victim Circuits and Type of Errors 70 2.5.1. Influence of Circuit Impedances 72 2.5.2. Specific Disturbance Created by the Hand/Metal Initial Spike 2.5.3. Errors/Malfunctions Induced in Analog Devices 74
67
74
2.6.
Prediction of Actual ESD-Induced Error, Fast Approximation Method 75 2.7. Remarks on the Actual Current Paths and Associated Radiation 2.8. Personnel or Furniture ESD: Which One is Worse? 78 References 79 3. Principal ESD Specifications ESD Test Specifications for Device Sensitivity 82 3.1.1. MIL-Std 883 82 3.1.2. EIA/JEDEC and ESD Association Test Methods 83 3.2. ESD Specifications for Equipment Immunity 84 3.2.1. International Standard IEC 61000-4-2 84 3.2.2. ANSI C.63-16, ESD Test Methods, and Criteria for Electronic Equipment 85 3.2.3. ESD Immunity for Automobile Electronics, SAE J1113-13 and ISO 10605 85 3.2.4. MIL-Std 1541, ESD Immunity Requirements for Space Systems 3.3. Antistatic Control Procedures 86 3.3.1. Military Domain: MIL-Std 1686 and MIL 263 Handbook 86 3.3.2. Industry Standards for Static Control Programs 87 References 88
78
80
3.1.
4. ESD Diagnostics and Testing 4.1.
4.2. 4.3. 4.4.
4.5.
ESD Simulators: How They Work 90 4.1.1. Arc or Direct Contact 92 4.1.2. Simulators for Equipment Test, Based on IEC 61000-4-2 Standard 95 4.1.3. Detailed Review of the IEC 61000-4-2 Simulator Definition 96 4.1.4. Generators with Different Networks, Very High Voltage and Field Enhancement Accessories 105 4.1.5. Special Relays Required for ESD Simulators 108 Furniture Versus Personnel ESD Simulation 109 Other Types of ESD Simulators for Component Testing 112 ESD Test Setup—Direct and Indirect ESD 114 4.4.1. Ground Reference 115 4.4.2. Direct versus Indirect ESD 115 4.4.3. Roles of the HCP and VCP 118 4.4.4. Grounding the Simulator and the EUT 120 4.4.5. External Cables and System Configuration 120 ESD Test Routine and Discharge Procedures 121
86
89
Contents 4.5.1. Preparation of EUT for Test Readiness 4.5.2. Application of the Discharges 122
4.6. 4.7.
121
No Error/No Damage Concept: The Several Layers of Severity The Error per Discharge Concept or Multiple-Trials Approach 4.7.1. Practical Application of the Error per Pulse Concept 4.7.2. ESD Test Plan with Cost-Effectiveness Constraints ESD Test During Design and Development 137
140 143
5. Design for ESD Immunity
5.2.
148
ESD Protection at Component Level 150 5.1.1. Integrated Circuits with Internal ESD Protection 150 5.1.2. Additional ESD Protection: When Is It Needed and How Much? 153 ESD Protection at the PCB Level (Internal Circuitry) 5.2.1. 5.2.2. 5.2.3. 5.2.4.
5.3. 5.4.
125 129
134 135
4.8. 4.9. ESD For Field Diagnostics and Forced Crash Method 4.10. Home-Made Investigation Tools and Diagnostic Hints References 146
5.1.
vii
Reducing the Field-to-PCB Coupling Mechanisms PCB Connectors Areas 159 Signal Ground versus Chassis Ground 160 PCB Hardening with Plastic Products 160
157 158
ESD Protection by Internal Wiring and Mechanical Packaging ESD Protection by Box Shielding and Envelope Design 169
161
5.4.1. 5.4.2. 5.4.3. 5.4.4. 5.4.5.
5.5.
Some Shielding Basics 170 How to Maintain Shield Integrity with Metal Housings 178 How to Make Shield Barriers for Plastic Housings 183 Treatment of Shield Openings 187 Nonmetallized Plastic Boxes 189 ESD Protection of External Cables and I/O Ports 191 5.5.1. External Cable Shielding 192 5.5.2. ESD Hardening of I/O Ports 200 5.5.3. I/O Cable Entries ESD Protection with Plastic Products 219
5.6. ESD Immunity by Software and Noise Inhibition Techniques 5.7. ESD Immunity with Miniature, Portable Devices 223 5.8. System ESD Immunity 225 5.9. ESD Control at Installation Level 226 References 228 6. ESD Cases Studies 6.1. 6.2. 6.3. 6.4. 6.5.
Case Case Case Case Case
1: 2: 3: 4: 5:
The Reradiating Ground Strap 231 ESD Hardening of a Printer 232 The Data Terminal with Floating Tray The Safety Wire “Antenna” 235 The Touchy Watchdog 236
221
230
233
viii
Contents
6.6. 6.7.
Case 6: The Trigger-Happy Air bag Initiator Conclusion: Troubleshooting Hints 237
236
Appendix A. ESD Protection by Design of Chips and Microcircuits
240
Appendix B. Prediction of ESD Damage Level for a Semiconductor Junction 252 Appendix C. Spark-Over Voltages
255
Appendix D. Fatigue Phenomena During Repeated ESD Testing
258
Appendix E. Prediction of ESD-Induced Noise by Fast FrequencyDomain Calculations 260 Appendix F. More Experiments on ESD Coupling to Boxes
269
Appendix G. Examples of Simple SPICE Modeling of ESD Coupling Effects 279 Appendix H. Time-to-Frequency Conversion for a Single Transient Index
295
293
Preface to the First Edition
Static electricity is the most ancient form of electricity known to humans. More than 2000 years ago, the Greeks recognized the attraction between certain materials when they were rubbed together; indeed, the word electricity comes from the Greek elektron, which means amber. During the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, several key experiments were conducted to understand and measure static electricity. But the discovery of electromagnetism and its formidable breakthrough has rapidly outgrown interest in static electricity. Even today, where the industrial applications of static electricity are not insignificant, they cannot compare with those of electromagnetism and electrodynamics. Ironically, as much as static electricity was relegated to the attic of scientific evolution, she continuously occupied (I say “she” because electricity, in French, is feminine—don’t ask me why) the headlines with her undesirable effects. If we consider the thousands of lightning strikes hitting the terrestrial atmosphere every minute, we have to realize that our planet with its surrounding clouds is nothing more than a huge electrostatic machine constantly charging and discharging on itself. For decades, people have been learning the hard way that statics can cause explosions of fuels and ammunitions. In 1937, the German flying boat Hindenburg arriving in Lakehurst, New Jersey, caught fire while anchoring at its landing mast. What could have been a severe incident became a tragedy: Due to international tension, the United States had put an embargo on helium sales to Germany and the vessel was inflated with hydrogen instead. The resulting fire caused the death of 37 of its hundred or so passengers. Although the causes have not been completely understood, electrostatic discharge (ESD) is at the top of the list. More recently, during the 1970s in the United States, a spacecraft lauching rocket exploded during the fueling operation, killing three engineers. The cause was, beyond any doubt, identified as ESD. Satellites have paid a heavy toll because of ESD, from minor anomalies to severe malfunctions, as in the European Space Agency (ESA) MARECS satellite. In January 1985, during the assembly of a Pershing missile near Heilbronn, Germany, the motor case, made of Kevlar, was repeatedly rubbed against the cushioning in its container. The ensuing ESD caused the 4 tons of highly flammable propellant to catch fire and the motor exploded, blowing parts 125 meters away, killing three people and injuring nine. Although such catastrophes are terrible and spectacular, they are quite rare; but a more insidious aspect of ESD bloomed in the early 1970s, with the massive
x
Preface to the First Edition
arrival of integrated microelectronics. The plants producing integrated circuits (ICs) started to experience disappointing percentage yields. Once thoroughly investigated, the problem was found to be largely due to ESD during all fabrication steps and handling. Although the problem has been fully explained and drastic solutions adopted, ESD is still costing millions of dollars a year of pure losses. Considering the astronomical quantities of ICs manufactured each year, the mere fact that 3 to 30% of them die in infancy because of ESD represents an impressive amount of money. To quote G. C. Quinn, technical editor of Electronics Test Magazine (April 1984): “The volume range of ESD sensitive components is rising faster than the development and usage of ESD protections . . . Estimating costs of ESD failures not caught at manufacturing inspection is far more difficult. Many of the degraded, walking-wounded devices may not show up until after termination of the manufacturer’s guarantee.” Around 1980, Lockheed Corporation reported a one-year cost savings of $1.8 million through static protection measures, which reduced ESD-related failures by a 16 to 1 ratio. Arithmethic, then, tells us that Lockheed had endured losses of $1.92 million the previous year. Even with severe protection measures, some manufacturers still confess that ESD is causing 39 to 48% of their IC rejects. The only hope that the plague will ever be dominated is a progressive awareness of people and the growing use of robots on manufacturing lines. But the worst was yet to come: With the proliferation of microelectronics in all possible applications, an even bigger number of complaints flourished about ESD-related erratic bugs, transient malfunctions, erased memories, and the like. Although the economic losses resulting from erroneous transactions and corrupted data of all kinds are difficult to evaluate, it is probably an even larger figure than the one for chip damage during fabrication. It seems ironic that a physical fact, known for 2500 years as doing nothing but nasty things to us, has continued to defy electronics engineers. Solving the problem of transient errors induced by ESD has not been given the same concerted effort as the manufacturing aspect. Most early research was performed by isolated pioneers fighting with their own weapons. Initiating the research themselves, seldom supported by vast budgets, these men used their sagacity and all the resources they could find to investigate a problem for which no measuring techniques existed. They had to invent the tools they needed, and they had to be statisticians, chemists, and radio-frequency (RF) designers all at once. The names of Ted Madzy, W. Byrne, Michael King, Ralph Calcavecchio, Richard Simonic, and many others that I don’t know of are the people to whom all of us who followed are indebted. By mentioning their work, this book will try to render a piece of the recognition they deserve: They paved the road for bringing the understanding of ESD from black magic up to an analytic method. We hope this book will demystify ESD and give a step-by-step strategy for predicting, testing, and reducing its effects on electronic equipment. Gainesville, Virginia June 1985
Michel Mardiguian
Preface to the Third Edition
The two previous editions of this book had a very favorable reception from the EMC community. However, the first and second editions, published by the EMC consulting firm Interference Control Technologies, had a rather limited distribution and have been out of print since the year 2000. A new edition was sorely needed, incorporating current technological advances with the needs of the engineering community. Since the first edition of this book 22 years ago, the electrostatic discharge (ESD) phenomenon has continued to plague the electronic industry. In spite of undisputable progress in ESD awareness and protection measures, which are inforced by regular audits and accreditations, the “sleeping sentinel” syndrome takes its toll. Inspections often reveal that in an assumed static-free manufacturing chain, all but one of the workstations or handling/packing posts are adequately protected. This single defective link is enough to compromise the entire ESD line of defense. Sometimes it was the very apparatus intended to eliminate human influence, for example, automatic handling by robots, that created a new ESD problem, sometimes worse than the one it was supposed to cure. Once these pernicious problems are fixed, the return on investment of a flawless ESD control program is often spectacular, not forgetting that this is a constant battle because today’s problem is frequently the consequence of some unanticipated effect of yesterday’s solution. Nonetheless, once marketed and sold, some modern equipment, although it has undergone a compete EMC test program that includes ESD, is still experiencing malfunctions, a tangible share of which is traceable to ESD. Consider a recent example: This author, among other consultants, was asked to solve a problem on a certain model of car. Five percent of owners were experiencing a very unpleasant dashboard failure: During operation some displays would freeze up, eventually becoming totally dark without a possibility of reset, even after a stop-and-start action. The problem was a peculiar ESD configuration that had escaped the standard test program. In order to cope with such omnipresent threats, intensive research has continued worldwide, using instrumentation that is much more elaborate than that available in the 1970s and 1980s to the pionneers of ESD studies. Recent studies have covered arc formation, initial spike with the hand/metal scenario, fields radiated in the vicinity of the discharge, and the like. Among the engineers who
xii
Preface to the Third Edition
investigated these facets of ESD, one of the most prolific has certainly been D. Pommerenke of Missouri University. In the first few chapters of this new edition, we give an overview of these recent studies. The problem of poor repeatability has always also plagued ESD testing, as with many EMC tests in general. But, while other tests have gained significant improvements in accuracy and credibility, ESD remains the black sheep of the herd, raising sarcastic jokes among EMC practicioners and lab technicians, who are struggling constantly with these “ESD guns that don’t shoot right” or “ESD tests that make failing products pass and good products fail.” Therefore, a substantial share of the R&D effort has been aimed at reducing the uncertainty attached to ESD generators and test procedures. However, we have some reservations: While a tremendous amount of activity has been deployed toward ESD generator modeling, calibration, and error analysis that is basically “simulating the simulators,” it seems that the EMC community has lost sight of the actual fact we are trying to counteract: the real, everyday electrostatic discharge. To our knowledge, no organized, wide ranging statistical survey of ESD events has been conducted since the last outstanding work done by R. Simonic around 1973–1974. Things have changed: People’s habits are different: interior decoration, furniture, and clothing are different. Instrumentation that could capture and record ESD is now more accurate, with much greater bandwidth than in the early 1970s. As a result there is a danger that we may very well be trying to reproduce perfectly, with today’s advanced simulators, events as they were recorded 35 years ago. St. Remy les Chevreuse, France May 2009
Michel Mardiguian
Acknowledgments
After writing the word end , my gratitude goes to to those who provided their timely assistance and information: Etienne Sicard and Alain Charoy who gave me valuable details on IC protection, David Pommerenke who shed some light on his very specific series of measurements and modeling, Diethard Mohr and William Rhoades for bringing me up to date on some current ESD documents status. My thanks go also to Joel Raimbourg and Sebastien Bazzoli who provided invaluable support for some practical experiments. Last, but not the least, I am grateful to Mark Montrose and Michael King—the latter being a living memory of the pionneering era of ESD—who expressed their encouragement for the making of this third edition. Many thanks also to Jeanne Audino and Steve Welch of the IEEE Press team, for their very professionnal assistance that gave life to my crude manuscript, and again to Mark Montrose who did the technical review, adding some precious remarks. Very special thanks go to the editorial team at Wiley: Lisa Van Horn, Ernestine Franco, and Dean Gonzalez, respectively, senior production editor, copy editor, and illustration manager, who performed a meticulous editing and turned my crude sketches into fine drawings. I also thank my wife Corinne for her patience, not to mention that she has been the one who typed some of the chapters, as it is often the case with we engineers, who pretend to become writers. M. M.
Chapter
1
The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon Although a thorough description of the electrostatic phenomenon is beyond the scope of this book and has been covered by several authors (1–4), it might be useful to start by reviewing briefly how static electricity takes place, what are the contributing parameters, and why, eventually, it ends abruptly in its threatening consequence: the electrostatic discharge (ESD). The following section is an extremely simplified view of the electrostatic charging mechanisms. While clearly not a treatise on static electricity, it illustrate the physics involved, in a simple manner. Readers with a good basic knowledge of electrostatics can probably skip this preliminary portion.
1.1. PHYSICS INVOLVED Any material is made of atoms. Unless submitted to certain external influences (heating, rubbing, electrical stress, etc.), the atom is at equilibrum; that is, the amount of negative charges represented by the electrons orbiting around the nucleus is exactly balanced by an equal number of positive charges or protons aggregated in the nucleus. Therefore, the net electric charge seen from the ouside is zero. In good conductors, the mobility of electrons is such that the conditions of equilibrium will always exist; that is, no significant static field will exist between different zones of the same piece of metal. With nonconductive materials, however, the lesser mobility of electrons does not provide such a rapid recombination of charge unbalance. If heated, or rubbed strongly (which also creates heat), a nonconductor will free up electrons. Depending on the nature of its outer valence orbit, a nonconductive material may be likely to give up electrons or to capture wandering electrons. Electrostatic Discharge, Third Edition, by Michel Mardiguian Copyright © 2009 the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
1
2
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
− −
−
+ + + + + +
−
−
−
Figure 1.1 If by heating, rubbing, and the like, one electron is leaving the orbit, the material is left with six protons and only five electrons.
A nonconductive material that gives up an electron, as shown in Figure 1.1, will become positively charged. Such unbalanced atoms with a lack of electrons are called positive ions. A nonconductive material that takes extra electrons will become negatively charged, and its atoms with excess electrons are called negative ions. Charges with like sign repel while charges with opposite sign attract. Therefore, it seems that nature will rapidly take care of the unbalance by recombining the charges. Unfortunately, while this recombination is instantaneous in metals (i.e., indeed, how a current flows), the high resistance of nonconductive materials makes it unlikely to happen, until such a high gradient of field is reached that either an arc or a mechanical attraction will occur. Besides rubbing or heating, which is the common generation mechanism, an object can become charged by contact with another previously charged object. This ability of nonconductive materials to acquire electrostatic charges is known as triboelectricity. Once a nonconductive material has been subject to triboelectric charging, the charges trapped on its dielectric surface are not easily removed. Grounding the piece of material will do nothing since, on insulators, charges have no mobility. Only a flow of ionized air, hot steam, or conductive liquid can remove the charge unbalance. Static charging ability is frequently shown on triboelectric scale, such as the one in Table 1.1 Materials labeled “positive” will take on a positive charge every time they are frictionned against a material lower on the scale. Although this kind of scale is true overall, the precise ranking of each material within the scale should not be definitely relied upon in real-life situations. Many authors and practicians in the ESD community, such as A. Testone (3), have shown how deceptive such triboelectric tables can be.
1.1. Physics Involved
3
Table 1.1 Triboelectric Series More (+)
More (−)
Dry air Plexiglass Bakelite Cellulose acetate Silicon wax Glass, mica Nylon Wool Human hair Silk Paper, cotton, wood Amber, resins (natural or synthetic) Styrofoam, polyurethane Polyethylene Rubber Rayon, Dacron, Orlon PVC Silicon Teflon
For example, let us take a reel of ordinary office adhesive tape. If we quickly unwind some length of tape, everyone knows that this segment becomes charged and can attract small particles of dust, hairs etc and the like. But since both sides of the tape are the same material, they rank the same (e.g., positive for acetate) on the table, and this piece of film could not develop an electric field against itself. However, after unwinding this short segment (Fig. 1.2), we notice that it is strongly attracted by the rest of the reel, which indicates that there has been a charge transfer, whereas one side of the tape has acquired electrons that the other side has lost. How can the same material be at the same time a “taker” and a “giver” of electrons, thus contradicting the triboelectric scale? Furthermore, if we cut this piece of tape (using insulating gloves and scissors to prevent our conductive body from influencing the results), and approach it to the reel, some areas of the tape are attracted, while others may be repelled. The mechanisms coming into play in this apparently simple experiment are multiple and complex. For one, the materials involved are not just acetate against acetate; there is the adhesive layer and also the air itself, which is on the top (+) side of the scale. Then, the tape surfaces have changed their radii as they were separated, such as the “run-away” electrons do not face exactly the same region as when the contact was tight. Therefore, even two insulating materials of the same nature can eventually develop opposite charges if sufficient friction, shear, or bending is applied. This happens hundreds times a day in a photocopier when foil is slipped over the paper stack.
4
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
−
+
+
+
+
+
−
−
−
−
Figure 1.2 Stripped end of acetate tape is attracted by the surface of the tape reel.
Thus, although triboelectric scale is a fair indication of the polarity of the charge acquired by materials, we must stay away from peremptory statements when facing an electrostatic charging situation. Static field meters are good instruments to get a true measure of the static voltage acquired by various materials. Now consider the classical example of a person walking on a synthetic carpet, rubbing his body on an insulated chair pad, or moving his nylon shirt sleeve over a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) surface: the farther apart the two materials are on the triboelectric scale and the faster the relative motion of the person, the more electrons will be freed by the givers and captured by the takers. This creates a charge unbalance—hence a latent electric field. Figure 1.3 suggests a scale of merit for the propensity of materials to create more or less ESD problems. It is based on the surface resistance in ohms per square (i.e., the resistance of a sample square, whether it is 1 cm2 or 1 m2 , yields the same results). Material with more than 109 /square are likely to develop electrostatic potentials that will not bleed-off by themselves due to the high insulation of
Ω /square 1014
Static generating materials
1012 1010 108 10
Insulators Anti-static, but Non-dissipative Anti-static, dissipative
6
104
Conductors Conductors
Figure 1.3 Propensity of materials to create ESD problems, based on surface resistance in ohms/square.
1.1. Physics Involved
5
the material. Materials with less than 109 /square, even if not real conductors, will not keep the charge unbalance very long because recombination will occur through the material itself. Aguet (5) relates the propensity to electrostatic charge to the dielectric constant of the materials that are rubbed. He indicates the surface charge density σs : σs = 15 × 10−6 (εr1 − εr2 ) Coulomb/m2
(1.1)
where εr1 , εr2 are the relative permittivity of the two materials. For instance, if one looks at a rubber shoe sole (εr1 = 2.5) representing 250 cm2 and a nylon carpet (εr = 5), the maximum total charge Q that can be acquired is Q = 15 × 10−6 (5−2.5)250 × 10−4 m2 = 0.93 × 10−6 Coulomb If the corresponding foot-to-ground capacitance C is about 100 pF, the static voltage is derived from Q = CV
(1.2)
Hence, V =
Q = 9300 V C
It might seem, therefore, that there is practically no upper limit to what voltage a person can attain. Why not 50 kV 100 kV? Richman, in his very illustrative pamphlet on ESD (6), explains that, hopefully, personnel electrostatic voltage cannot exceed 30 kV in the most extreme cases because: 1. The capacitance of the human body, no matter what we do, cannot drop below 30–40 pF, a value that Richman calls our “capacitance to infinity.” 2. Above approximately 25 kV, the corona will start to self-limit our voltage by bleeding off the charge, that is, the assumption of constant charge Q is no longer valid. So, in most practical situations, the upper range of human body static voltage is 20–25 kV. Summarizing this short description of electrostatic charging, we can say that static electrification is a complex phenomenon that one cannot solely characterize by any single parameter, such as the ranking of the material on a triboelectric scale, its surface resistivity, or dielectric constant. To the contrary, static dissipation can be dependably related to resistivity.
6
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
1.2. INFLUENCING PARAMETERS Once the type of materials present is known, the most important parameter is relative humidity. It is well known that, during winter and spring seasons, all integrated circuit manufacturers have recorded an increased rate of “infant mortality” in their chips, and field engineers report an increasing number of service calls for computer failures. Several things happen when relative humidity is low: •
•
Normally, the moisture content in the air tends to decrease the surface resistance of floors, carpets, table mats, and the like by letting wet particles create a vaguely conductive (or say, less than 109 /square) film over an otherwise insulating surface. If the relative humidity decreases, this favorable phenomenon disappears. The air itself, being dry becomes a part of the electrostactic buildup mechanism every time there is an airflow (wind, air conditioning, blower) passing over an insulated surface.
Many evaluations have been made of the electrostatic voltages reached by a person walking on several types of floors. Generally, these tests are made using a kind of “standard walking procedure.” The person walks a given number of steps with a given type of shoes; then his (her) charging voltage is immediately measured with an electrostatic voltmeter having a quasi-infinite input impedance. The importance of measuring the voltage immediately after charging, and preferably having this same short time for all experiments, is seen in Figure 1.4. If the time elapsed between the end of the charging phase and the instant of the measurement is not kept constant, comparisons between materials, clothes, shoes, and the like become inaccurate. Figure 1.5 shows the range of acquired electrostatic voltages for several floor types and two values of the relative humidity (RH). On the left side, the voltages are shown for an RH of 50%. Even with a notoriously bad type of carpet such as nylon, the voltage stays within 1–3 kV. Note that this is already enough to kill some integrated circuits if the person touches directly a module or a printed circuit board (PCB). But the scale in the middle merely suggests the likely consequences when the charged person touches a typical electronic cabinet, without direct contact to a module or connector pin. What is shown as “likely consequences” assumes that the stressed equipment is of an ordinary design, not especially hardened against ESD. (Chapter 5 will explain how a system can be made reasonably immune to ESD.) The right side of the chart shows what happens with the same kind of floor coverings when RH goes down to 20%. Nylon jumps to 6–11 kV, and some other synthetic carpets cause people to charge up to 8 kV. The diagram in Figure 1.5 is restricted to the most current types of floors. With some specific materials, things can go even worse. The worst floor ever is probably a silicon waxed wooden floor where human ESD voltages over 20 kV
1.2. Influencing Parameters
7
Time in seconds 10
20
30
40 500
200
200
100
100
50
50
20
20
10 0
10
30
20
Operator potential in volts
Operator potential in volts
500
0
10 40
Time in seconds Legend Shoe sole Composition or leather Leather Composition Leather Composition Composition Conductive
Floor
RH
Vinyl
4%
Conductive (0.27 MΩ) Conductive (0.95 MΩ) Conductive (0.27 MΩ) Conductive (0.27 MΩ) Conductive (0.27 Ω) Conductive
5% 4% 45% 5% 45%
Figure 1.4 Electrostaticgenerated voltages will decay at a rate that is dependent on relative humidity, floor covering, and type of clothing worn by personnel. Decay times can take several minutes to reach safe levels (7).
have been commonly reported. A well-known, and often painful, static environment is that of an automobile interior (Fig. 1.6), since a car is a metallic envelope isolated by its tires and replete with plastic and synthetic textiles. It may seem that a relative humidity of 20% is a rather low. Indeed, as shown in Table 1.2 for relative humidity over the year in major U.S. cities, only a few locations have an RH less than 20%. But in absolute numbers, cities such as Albuquerque, Tucson, and Phoenix are industrial/business areas representing millions of people with hundreds of thousands of electronic devices installed, which must function correctly, even during the winter/spring months. In fact, the problem is more critical than Table 1.2 would have us believe: The recorded RH values are those found outdoors by the weather bureau. A significant difference may exist between the RH outdoors and its actual value in a heated building. This is due to the fact that, given the same quantity of water, warm air has a greater ability to absorb moisture; therefore, its relative humidity (compared to saturation) is lower. Equation (1.3) shows that in a restricted space whose temperature is T2 , the relative humidity is RH2(T2 ) = RH1(T1 )
T2 C(1/T2 −1/T1 ) e T1
(1.3)
8
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon 20 15
Static voltage in kV
10
× 5
Range for nylon and acrylic
3 2
ol
Wo
c” tati ) ti s ative n “A sip s (Di
×
1 0.6 60
50
30
20
15
10
Relative humidity in % 12
8
10 1
8
6
6 Poor
4
2
4
5 Marginal 1
3 2
2
3 4
4
5
6
Static voltage in kV
Static voltage in kV
10
12 Disastrous Material Code 1. Regular nylon 2. Com’l antistatic nylon Possible 3. Vinyl asbestos tile physical 4. High pressure laminate damage 5. Acrylic and polyester Very 6. Compu-Carpet poor
Safe
0
6
2 0
50% RH
Equipment reliability
20% RH
Figure 1.5 Typical range of static voltages generated by walking on common floor covering materials (adapted from Ref. 8).
where RH1 is the relative humidity of the outer ambient, at temperature T1 , and C a constant equal to 5370 between −20◦ C and +70◦ C; T1 and T2 in the formula are given in kelvins. The equation has been plotted in Figure 1.7 for a few typical situations. For instance, on a winter day where the outside temperature is 0◦ C (273◦ K) and the
1.3. Various Types of Electrostatic Charging with Humans and Objects
9
25
Charge voltage in kv
Polyester seat Nylon clothing
20
Vinyl seat Nylon clothing
15 Polyester seat Polyester clothing
10 Nylon/
5 Viscose
Nylon/ Viscose seat
seat Cotton Polyester clothing clothing
Leather seat Cotton clothing
Leather seat Nylon clothing
Vinyl seat Cotton clothing
Figure 1.6 Electrostatic charging voltages for various car driver/car seat combinations (9).
RH about 40%, the actual RH in a room heated at 22◦ C will be only 9%! Unless the heating, ventilation, or air-conditionning system (if there is one) compensates for this lack of water vapor, which it generally does rather poorly, or a humidifier is installed, the ESD risk is very high. Besides the type of material and the relative humidity, other factors play a role in the severity of the human electrostatic charge: Type of clothing and shoes Speed and manner of walking Sex and size of the person Body capacitance Body resistance The two last factors will be discussed in the next section because they strongly influence the dynamic characteristics of the discharge.
1.3. VARIOUS TYPES OF ELECTROSTATIC CHARGING WITH HUMANS AND OBJECTS Although an infinity of ESD cases have been reported, the ones that are plaguing the electronic industry belong to either the human body discharge or the charged object discharge. (9) So far, we have emphasized the electrostatic charges generated by human beings, as shown in the most common scenarios of Figure 1.8.
10
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
Table 1.2
1.3. Various Types of Electrostatic Charging with Humans and Objects For :
11
θ2 = 20°C inside
100
80
θ1 = 30°C θ1 = 40°C
θ1 = 20°C
Inside
Hθ2 (%)
60
θ1 = 10°C
40
20
θ1 = 0°C Outside
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Hθ1 (%) Hθ2 = Hθ1K·
θ2K 1 _ 1 · e 5400 ( θ1K θ2K) θ1K
Hθ : Relative humidity at temperature θ θ : Temperature in K (formula valid for −20 to + 60°C)
Figure 1.7 Actual vs. apparent relative humidity.
Notice that depending on the nature of the two materials being rubbed together, the person can exhibit positive or negative charging. Although humans tend to treat themselves as very special, physics does not care and treats us as a mere conglomerate of materials, vaguely conductive. There are thousands of occasions where the human body is not the electrostatic generator, but simply the carrier, or even is not involved at all (Fig. 1.9). An example of a human as a carrier occurs when a person gets out from a car after a ride on a bright, cold, and windy winter day. The moment he puts his foot on the ground while his hand is touching the door handle, he often feels a violent ESD zap. The body was not the electrostatic generator in this case, the car was.There have been reports of highway toll gate attendants who could not stand their job because of too many ESD zaps when drivers where handling them the money! Following is a list of some nonhuman ESD sources: • • • •
Wheelchairs, carts, rolling furniture Rubber or textile belts and conveyors and their pulleys/rollers Cooling fans with plastic rotor blades Helicopter rotor blades (generally made of composite material)
12
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
+ −
− +
−
−
+
+
−
−
−
−
+
+
+
−
−
−
− +
+
+
+
+
+
+ −
+ −
+ −
Figure 1.8 Some of the classical ways a human can accumulate static charges.
+ + + + + +
− − − − − −
Figure 1.9 ESD with or without a human body involved.
1.4. Statistics of Voltages and Currents Reached During ESD • •
• •
13
Paper movement (printers, copiers) Rapid flow or friction of gas, liquid, or granule against an insulating material or unground conductor such as: • Cleaning with airgun • PVC “skin-packing” with hot air blast • Cleaning with solvent • Fuel lines (including filling-in or draining-off a fuel tank) • Loading or dumping grains in silos • Rocket exhaust nozzle • Radomes, fiberglass hoods, and tips • Thermal blankets (spacecrafts) Device-manipulating robots on manufacturing lines Electrostatic painting process (the spray nozzle being charged around 80–100 kV)
Also, we must remember that a nonconductive object can become charged by contact with another, previously charged, object. This static-contaminated object will, in turn, be a potential hazard for electronics. In all cases, whether a person is involved or not, the charged object will “seek” the first opportunity to recombine the unbalanced charges: This may occur smoothly by a progressive bleed of charges through a moderately conductive path, or may occur abruptly and generally accompanied by an arc. In the case of a “self”-recombination, a small amount of current will flow during a certain time, and the result will be generally harmless. To the contrary, with an abrupt recombination, the discharge will occur during a very short time due to the high-voltage gradients involved, and the corresponding current will be high. Since its average value is I (A) =
Q(Coulomb) t (s)
(1.4)
when a discharge of microcoulombs takes place within tens of nanoseconds, the average current amounts to several amperes, with peak values that can reach up to hundreds of amperes.
1.4. STATISTICS OF VOLTAGES AND CURRENTS REACHED DURING ESD Although the ESD phenomenon has been experienced and fought against for decades by electrical and electronics industries, it is only around the early 1970s that thorough studies were carried on its dynamic parameters. Measurements have been published of voltages and/or currents encountered during real or re-created ESD situations, sampled over a certain period of time or among a certain number of individuals. The statistics that have been gathered, to the knowledge of this author, can be classified as follows:
14
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon • • • •
Measured voltages of human ESD, depending on the materials involved (garments, type of shoes, type of floor covering) Measured voltages of human ESD, depending of the relative humidity (correlated or not with the time of the year) Measured voltage of objects and furniture ESD, against the type of objects and sometimes the type of environment (humidity and floor covering) Measured currents with furniture ESD, against type of environment and time of the year
Although they are more spectacular and seem to relate the most obviously with the severity of the discharge, the data collected on ESD voltages are not the most meaningful, neither are they the most crucial when trying to develop representative specifications for ESD simulation. The voltages at which the persons were charged during the measurement campaign can be an ambiguous or inaccurate database. Was the voltage measured at its peak, right after a static buildup? Or was it recorded at the moment of an actual discharge? What were the mean value and standard deviation of the voltage decay between its peak value (as generated) and its value at the exact moment of the discharge? Were the people in the study aware that ESD voltages were gathered? Every statistician knows that people in such surveys often tend to “sympathize” with the experimenter, helping him to find what he likes to find (in our case, for instance, by shuffling their shoes more conscienciously on the carpet). Statistics is a discipline requiring specific precautions. In some of the often mentionned experiments, it is not clear that these precautions were taken or were feasible. Doing a parallel between ESD and lightning, one could say that focusing on ESD voltages only is probably as irrelevant as would be concentrating on cloud-to-Earth voltages when studying lightning strikes: all sound statistics on lightning severity are based on lightning currents. Similarly, ESD statistics based on current seem the most dependable and usable. As for any transient, random events, statistical analysis is important for determining what is the risk that a certain value of electrostatic discharge will be reached (or the probability P that this value will be exceeded). Do we want to test the immunity of an electronic device or equipment to something that can happen once a day or once a year? How many failures per week or month do we risk by testing a machine only to a certain ESD level? A rough example of recording the number of electrostatic discharges is shown in Figure 1.10. During a particularly cold and dry spring (early April 1982) in Virginia, the author had taken a limited survey of the number of discharges (as they were felt by people) in a set of offices where about 12 people were using one copier, a telex, a desk-top computer, a postage meter, and a word processor. Discharges were recorded on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays for 3 weeks. These discharges did not necessarily cause equipment malfunction—in fact most of them did not—but the purpose of the survey was to count the
1.4. Statistics of Voltages and Currents Reached During ESD
15
29
18 16 13
Wed.
7
8
10
10 Thur.
Tues.
11
11
6
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Day of the month
Figure 1.10 Number of discharges/day in a medium-size office area with copier, computer, word processor, telex, and mailing machine.
ESD events, not the eventual failures. It must be also noted that discharges of less than 1500–2000 V were generally not felt by a person and, therefore, were not recorded: They represent no risk for normal electronic equipment, but their absence in a sampling could skew the statistical analysis and produce overly pessimistic conclusions. A much more intensive survey was done by Simonic (10, 11). During two surveys spread over several years, he has compiled with an impeccable rigor thousands of measurements of both human and furniture ESD in quasi-real-life conditions. His work represents such an outstanding contribution to the subject that it deserves a detailed analysis, as shown hereafter.
1.4.1. Personnel ESD Statistics The first compilation made by Simonic covered personnel ESD events. The survey was run for 16 months, and its analysis allows one to predict, given a human contact discharge, the probability P of exceeding a peak discharge current I . The highlights of the analysis are the following: • • •
The rooms surveyed had a high human activity (terminal room with 16 operator-attended stations). The rooms had uncontrolled (or poorly controlled) RH and wool carpet. The purpose of the survey was to record the number of discharges, not the number of machine failures, which would have restricted the scope of the study.
16
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
Therefore, to be sure that what was measured was the ESD current caused by people (and not furniture ESD), and to provide every person with the same calibrated discharge path, a special monitoring setup was devised: • • •
•
•
IESD was measured by a current probe (current transformer) placed on a specially equipped metal doorknob. Only the interior side of the door handle was equipped, so only personnel ESD from inside the room was recorded. The current probe was connected to a recorder with 9 separate channels, set to specific threshold levels. The probe had a 100-MHz bandwidth, but accounting for the whole instrumentation chain, the final 3-dB bandwidth was 30 MHz. Each channel was recording the number of occurrences its own threshold was exceeded [therefore it can be directly translated in a P (I > 1x) statistic]. The RH was constantly monitored.
The study collected data from 498 eight-hour shifts, with an average of 120 discharges per shift. Thus, about 60,000 ESD events were logged and arranged in 3800 data entries. Using sound statistical practices, a regression analysis weighted to the number of human contacts was performed. Over a more limited period, one type of antistatic carpet was also surveyed. Since some people had finger rings, wrist straps, and the like, it is likely that a certain percentage of human/metal discharge is included in the collected data. The 30-MHz bandwidth seems insufficient to measure ESD pulses with 1-ns rise time (which would need at the very least a 350-MHz bandwidth). But the system was calibrated by a reference ESD pulser delivering a waveform with a 2-ns rise time, 320-ns time constant, and a source impedance of 2000 (behaving like a current source). Thus, the correlation between the 30-MHz limited bandwidth and the actual pulse bandwidth was taken care of by the calibration. The analysis reveals, of course, a strong correlation between the RH and the peak currents reached. A convenient equation for predicting the current I , given a probability P , was derived from the analysis: I ≥ 10A P B (RH)C
(1.5)
with A = 4.12
B = −0.645
within the following range: 0.95 confidence RH% comprised between 15 and 55 Probability P (I ) = 0.001 < P < 1
C = −3.39
1.4. Statistics of Voltages and Currents Reached During ESD
17
Table 1.3 Peak Current (in Amperes) Having a Probability P (I ) of Being Exceeded by Personnel ESD P (I ) RH Percent 15 < 20 < 25 < 30 < 35 < 40 < 45 < 50 <
< 20 < 25 < 30 < 35 < 40 < 45 < 50 < 55
1
0.5
0.1
0.01
0.22 0.14 0.11 0.072 0.059 0.052 0.042
0.80 0.73 0.35 0.20 0.11 0.075 0.055
2.4 1.9 1.1 0.80 0.40 0.17 0.10 0.072
8.7 7.1 3.5 2.2 1.3 0.56 0.25 0.15
For example, what is the current that will be exceeded only 10% of the time, given a RH% of 20, with 95% confidence? I ≥ 104.12 (0.1)−0.645 0.645.(20)−3.39 I ≥ 2.2 A Equation (1.5) has been arranged in a tabular form in Table 1.3, with the results of the survey plotted in Figure 1.11, where personnel ESD event curves give the current I having a probability P (0.01 < P < 1) of being exceeded. Table 1.3 shows the current increasing approximatively like the inverse cube of RH. Given a same probability (P ), currents will be 20–40 times greater at
Current (I ) .03
.1
.3
1
3
30 1
−2 0%
.1
%
−35
30
50% 45−
.03
15
RH
RH
.1
.3
RH
.3 Probability (P)
10
.03
.01
.01
.003
.003
.001 .01
.03
.1
.3
1
3
10
Current (I )
Figure 1.11 Simonic’s personnel event curves.
30
.001
Probability (P)
.01 1
18
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
RH = 15% than at RH = 45%. Also a given current I will be exceeded 100 times more often at RH 15% than at RH 45%. Since the RH% has been recorded at intervals of 15–20, 20–25, and so on, the curves shown in Figure 1.11 are mean values of P in these intervals. Given the strong dependency of P (I ) on the relative humidity, even a 5% RH interval corresponds to large variations of P for a given I , around the mean value. For instance, for a 15–20 RH interval, assuming the average RH is 17.5%, a current of 5 A will have a 0.025 (or 2.5%) probability of being exceeded. However, for this interval and a same (P ) the lower bound (RH = 15%) corresponds to 8.4 A, while the upper bound (RH = 20%), gives only 3.2 A. To complicate the issue, the average value of RH in the interval does not correspond to the mean value of P (I ) in that interval. Therefore, the curves of Figure 1.11 are a good indication considering that, in reality, RH has daily fluctuations that often exceed 5%; if a more accurate prediction is needed, Eq. (1.5) should be used. A reconstituted histogram of the personnel ESD events is shown on Figure 1.12. In addition to the current intervals, two voltages are also indicated on its lower scale: • •
The voltage at which a 1-k pulse generator should be charged to replicate the same event. The voltage at which an IEC-type simulator (see Section 3.2) should be charged to create the same currents. This takes into account the fact that above 8 kV, the IEC simulators switch from contact discharge (hand/metal) mode to air discharge.
Of course, this attempt of relating P to a number of events/shift is broadly indicative. While the probability P for a current I is a well-supported figure, the total number of events/shift in a room depends strongly on its size, occupancy, and activity. The rooms in this study could have exhibited from a few tens to several hundred events/shift. A gross estimate would give, for a low RH and carpeted room, an average total of 100 events per shift. Also not shown, but reported in Simonic’s study, is the fact that antistatic carpet (acrylic carpet incorporating conductive fibers) did show a 36 times reduction in ESD currents for the (15–20)% RH interval and 23 times reduction for the (30–35)% interval.
1.4.2. Furniture and Objects ESD Statistics The second of Simonic studies covered furniture ESD events. The survey lasted several years, and addressed ESD voltages in both computer rooms and data processing offices. The statistics are not compiled in percent probability but in number of ESD events per shift. Being a meticulous experimenter, Simonic had to select sites with significant probability of ESD occurrences. With ordinary offices, as was the case
1.4. Statistics of Voltages and Currents Reached During ESD
19
RH = 15–20% 10 8 RH = 45–50%
5.5 .15
.25
(3–5)
(5–8)
(8–15) (15–25) IESD in A
3–5 kv
5–8 kv
8–15 kv 15–25 kv
[4.5–7.5 kV]
[500–1 kV]
[300–500 V]
VESD, based on an IEC–type gun (Ztot ≅ 300 Ω)
[150–300 V]
(1–1.7) (1.7–3) Hypothetical VESD, assuming 1 kΩ body 500–1 kv 1–1.7 kv 1.7–3 kv resistance
[2.5–4.5 kV]
(.5–1)
.8
[1.5–2.5 kV]
(.1–.5)
1.3
[1–1.5 kV]
Number of events/shift/room (based on ≅ 100 events)
(Personnel discharge currents were recorded by a current probe on the doorknob.) 30 20
Figure 1.12 Reconstituted histogram. Events/shift for personnel ESD.
with the personnel ESD survey, site selection was not a problem because a large sample of locations was available. The situation was different with computer rooms: Sites with a significant history of ESD events were sometimes modified prior or during the survey, for instance, by increasing the RH%, or replacing some furniture with antistatic type, to correct a serious ESD problem. As a result, the measured event rate was biased by artificially reduced ESD voltages. Simonic did his best to document such situations when they could not be avoided. The highlights of the analysis are: • •
The sites selected were locations with ESD problems, preferrably where no corrective measures had yet been taken. The two kinds of sites were: • •
•
Computer rooms with raised metal floor and humidity control: 10 sites, 11 machines, totaling 3360 eight-hour shifts Carpeted offices with no humidity control: 8 sites, 8 terminals, 282 shifts
All machines were floor standing units with metal covers.
20
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon • • •
•
This time, the ESD event detector was a current probe placed around the machines input/output and power cables. The detector was sensing the peak current and was calibrated to correlate with a given discharge at typical contact points on the machine. The detector was optimized for furniture ESD, that is, voltage source (low impedance metal object). Then the readout was converted into an assumed ESD source voltage (see Note 1). The detector 3-dB bandwidth was 100 MHz. As for the personnel study, the recorder had nine channels with preset levels, which counted each occurrence where the treshold was exceeded.
Note 1 The idea behind this detector was that a charged furniture behaves much like a voltage source. By knowing the average value of the discharge path impedance, which includes the total loop resistance, the arc resistance and the loop inductance, the unknown ESD voltage can be derived as VESD = Ipeak × Zloop . The only questionable point would be how dependable is the conversion factor when the actual ESD current waveform did not fit the standard “template.” A calibration setup, simulating the minimum (worst-case) loop impedance of the ESD is shown in Figure 1.13. Its dynamic R,L,C impedance is approximately 45 , therefore:
VESD (unknown) = Ipeak (measured) × 45 √ For such an RLC network with R < 2 L/C, the discharge is an underdamped oscillatory waveform, with a 20–80% rise time Tr approximately equal to the charging time constant, that is, ≈ 10 ns. It is important to stress once more that this calibration assumes the furniture discharge to behave as a voltage source, whose current is only dependent on the load, that is, the above discussed loop impedance. As a consequence, a personnel-type discharge will be also seen by the recorder, with its true current, but the derivation of the actual ESD voltage would be wrong, the human body having a significantly higher internal resistance. In contrast to the former personnel discharge measurements, where the probe on a door handle prevented any other-than-people ESD from being captured, here the furniture ESD survey had no means to segregate between actual furniture
16 Ω 155 pF
180 nH
Figure 1.13 Circuit used for the reference discharge.
1.4. Statistics of Voltages and Currents Reached During ESD
21
events and possible human events. A more thorough examination of the statistic curves will provide us, nevertheless, with a basis for this differentiation. Figure 1.14 shows the event rate (events/machine/shift) in the 10 computer rooms surveyed, with the table on top giving the spread of RH for both the computer and the terminal rooms. The curve labeled mean is the mean of all recorded events (all machines and seasons combined), weighted by the number of shifts monitored at each site. For instance, the likelihood of having a 1-kv furniture discharge (corresponding to approximately 22-A discharge current) on a computer frame is about 0.11 per shift, that is, 50 times a year for 250 working days and 2 shifts/day. This does not seem catastrophic unless the dependability of the system is such that one error per week is intolerable. But one must remember that this is an average figure. It is very likely that the majority of these events will be concentrated in the low RH period, that RH in % Season
Min
Max
V MAX Recorded
Winter & Spring
14
55
5.4 kV
Summer
42
53
1.7 kV
3
10 100
10 wi
nt
m
er ,w or stn, ca we se ig ht loc ed at ion by nu m be ro fs hi
ea
1
1
su
.1
.1
er
m
m
Events per machine/shift
10
.01 Likelihood that recorded data also contain .001 human ESD .3
fts
1
2
3
Events per machine/shift
100
Furniture ESD in kV 1 2
.3
.01
5
.001 10
Furniture ESD in kV (6 A) 2 kV
(20 A) 6 kV
Necessary charging voltage for an IEC-type simulator
(60 A) 20 kV
(200 A) (Corresponding current in the monitoring probe)
Figure 1.14 Computer room furniture ESD events (3360 shifts, 10 sites, 11 machines). Graph combines sites dependency and season dependency.
22
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
is, January to March, which may actually translate into one error per day! The threshold between what a computer user feels as being tolerable and what is not is always subtle, and by no means a step function, but a system experiencing one error per day, during several weeks, is generally unacceptable. In Figure 1.14, the 95% confidence interval is shown as an upper bound of worst-case locations (site and season) and a lower bound of least occurrences. Keeping our previous example of a 1-kV furniture ESD, one sees that there is high probability (95%) that more than 0.025 events/shift exceeds that level, but only 5% chances (1–0.95) that it occurs more than 0.5 times/shift. From the statistical regression analysis, an equation was derived, giving (more accurately than the curves) the furniture ESD events exceeding a certain voltage. For low values of P (P ≤ 1 ), the mean event rate/shift is Pfurn = 10A × E(volts)B
(1.6)
with, for computer rooms: A = 6.37,
B = −2.44
for terminal rooms (carpeted floor, no RH control): A = 5.5, Example will be
B = −1.86
In computer room, the average number of event/shift exceeding 1 kV Pfurn = 106.37 × 1000−2.44 = 0.11
Although the study does not specifically give a quantitative correlation between a given event rate and a given RH%, this can almost be deduced from the data. For a 20-A(≈ 1 kV) discharge, there is a 25 : 1 ratio between the highest and lowest event rate extremes. There is a strong chance that the highest voltages (5 kV) were recorded during the lowest RH periods, and the lowest on the highest RH period (although some low readings could occur during dry season as well, if a piece of furniture did not have the time to yield a high static voltage before a contact occurred). Addressing terminal rooms (severe environment), Figure 1.15 is even more revealing. The 8 carpeted offices with workstations show a spread of Emax /Emin = 62 times. In the personnel statistics for carpeted offices, Eq. (1.5) showed that for a given event rate P , the ESD current was varying like (RH)−3.39 for 15 ≤ RH ≤ 55. If we apply this relationship to the carpeted offices for furniture ESD (there is no reason to believe that carpets would not behave the same way), the predicted ratio of Emax /Emin would be 71 times, which is close to what it was in reality. The mean event rate for a 1-kV furniture discharge in these carpeted offices without RH control is about 1 per machine per shift. When attempting to determine what fraction of these readouts could be due to personnel ESD being mixed in the presumed furniture data, we must keep
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
23
RH in % Season
Min
Max
V MAX Recorded
Winter & Spring
20*
25
5.6 kV
Summer ? *RH can go as low as 5% at times.
53
.09 kV
Furniture ESD in kV .3
100
1
2
3
10 100
wi
nt
m
er ,w or st n, -c we as igh e lo te ca d by tio n nu m be ro fs
10
ea
1 .3
su
m
.1
m
er
1 .3 .1
hif
ts
.03 .01
.001 .1
.03 Likelihood that recorded data also contain human ESD
(2 A)
.3
Events per machine/shift
Events per machine/shift
10
.01
1 2 3 Furniture ESD in kV
(6 A) 2 kV
(Corresponding current in the monitoring probe)
(20 A) 6 kV
5
(60 A) 20 kV
.001 10 (200 A)
Necessary charging voltage for an IEC-type simulator with total discharge impedance ≅ 300 Ω
Figure 1.15 Terminal room furniture ESD events (282 shifts, 8 sites, 8 machines). Graph combines sites dependency and season dependency.
in mind that the highest voltage a person can realistically build up and keep more than a few seconds is about 20 kV. With a typical human body resistance during an ESD being 1 k, the highest likelihood of personnel ESD data being inadvertantly mixed in furniture data woud be Ip = 20 A, which would appear as 800 V on the event rate curves in Figures 1.14 and 1.15 and Fig. 1.16 histogram. This has been shown as a shaded area on the left in both figures.
1.5. WAVEFORMS OF ELECTROSTATIC DISCHARGES 1.5.1. Personal ESD Waveforms In trying to match the measured waveforms with the physical explanations of Sections 1.2 and 1.3, simple waveforms for the ESD current have been devised
24
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
Events/machine/shift
35
RH = 45−50%
17
RH = 15−20%
5 1.7
.2
.035
5–8
8–15
15–25
1.5–2.5 kV 2.5–4.5 kV
25–40
.6
.15
40–70
70–120
7.5–12 kV 12–21 kV 21–36 kV
IESD in A Vtest based on IEC-type gun (Ztot ≅ 300 Ω)
Figure 1.16 Reconstituted histogram, events/machine/shift for furniture ESD.
with the following parameters: I = peak value of the current tr = rise time of the current, measured between the10 and 90% points (approximate fit to the rise time of the triangle envelope) τ = pulse width at 50% amplitude = 0.7RC If we concentrate on the human body discharge, the main electrical parameters that play a role in the rise and fall of the current are: L = self-inductance of the loop formed by the body, its arm, the machine, and the ground return. The range of values is 0.3 to 1.5 μH, with 0.7 μ H typical Rd = resistance of the discharge loop, dominated by body resistance, practically ranging from 1 to 30 k (Fig. 1.17) C = capacitance of human body to ground, with the following range of values: min = 50 pF max = 300 pF typ. = 150 pF The pulse rise time would be infinitely small if the capacitor simply discharged in a resistive network. In reality, this rise time is dictated by the charging time constant L/Rd . The pulse width of the discharge depends on the RC time constant of the circuit.
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
100
1
Human body resistance in kΩ 3 10
25
20 100
30
Body voltage ≈ 1kV
10
3
30
10
1
3 10 Human body resistance in kΩ
Cumulative distribution in %
Cumulative distribution in %
Body voltage 20v
3 20
Figure 1.17 Distribution of human body resistances.
Table 1.4 gives a recap of the approximative range of rise times (tr ) and pulse widths (τ), given all combinations of the extremes values for R, L, and C. They correlate rather well with actual measured waveforms. One could be tempted to combine some average values and come up with a “standard” waveform. However, this is quite risky—an average figure for a normal distribution represents the value that is met in 50% of the cases, hence exceeded in 50% of the cases. A specification designed upon this criteria would “underprotect” the equipment. It is safer to consider a reasonable maximum, such as the upper decile, for instance (the value that is exceeded in 10% of the cases only). To come up with a reasonably severe waveform, let us look at the table showing the influence of R, L, and C and select the combination that provides the worst influence of each: For the human model Rd is generally larger than L/dt, the inductive impedance of the loop; when L decreases, the charging time constant decreases, when Rd decreases, the peak current increases, for a given static voltage, but this also slows down the rise time by varying the charging time constant. Byrne (12) has performed a thorough analytical study of human ESD by assimilating the body to a set of cylindrical shapes with their respective capacitances and inductances. He ends up with some low-end extremes of 30 ps
26
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
Table 1.4 Possible Combinations of R, L, C Variables for Personal ESD and Their Influence on Pulse Rise Time and Fall Time L RD Current rise τr ∼ = 1.4 L/Ra C RD Decay time constant τC = RC
Min Min 420 psc Min Min 50 ns
Min Max 13 psb Min Max 1.5 μs
Max Min 2.1 ns Max Min 300 ns
Max Max 63 ps Max Max 10 μs
Typ Typ 280 ps Typ Typ 750 ns
Typc Min 980 ps Typ Min 150 ns
a
The 20–80% rise time is approximately equal to 1.4 times the charging time constant L/R. The 50% pulse width would be ∼ = 0.69τC . b The interest of this figure is purely academic. It would correspond to a peak current of a few hundred milliampere. However, dI /dt would still be there. c The spread of human body inductances is not very large; therefore, a standard waveform based on a typical value of L is justified. In contrast, the spread of human body resistances is huge, and a standard waveform for a “reasonable worst case” should aim to the lower bound of human body RD .
for the rise time. Such short rise times were not found in actual measurements. This does not mean they cannot exist; displaying a 30-ps rise without distortion requires an analog bandwidth of 12 GHz, which was not within the possibilities of memory oscilloscopes at the time. In any case, such a discharge would be associated with large values of Rd corresponding to smaller peak current: Therefore, the dI /dt derivative, which is, what counts for the magnetic coupling of the pulse to the victim, is fairly constant. As an attempt to allocate R,L,C elements to the human body, Figure 1.18, top, displays what resembles their physiological location, although it is not strictly workable as an equivalent model for simulation software tools. Different models have been devised that produce close-to-real ESD waveforms. Of the many equivalent circuits that have been tried, one is described on the lower schematic of Figure 1.18. It generates in a 1- shunt a current pulse very similar to the standard IEC hand/metal test. The hand/metal sharp current spike and the longer human body pulse can be seen separately by the two dedicated 1- shunts, acting as current mirrors. To see the whole pulse at once, the user needs to run a plot adding the voltages across R01 and R02 . Figure 1.19 shows a simplified waveform corresponding to a “standard” severe case, with a sharp 1-ns rise time and a long exponential decay. A simplified frequency spectrum of this pulse is also shown based on a triangular waveform; being a single event, the pulse repetition period is infinite, and the corresponding spectrum has no discrete spectral lines: It is a Fourier integral, with spectral density given in amperes per megahertz of bandwidth. The spectrum starts (at a frequency equal to 1/infinity) with an amplitude of 2Ipeak τ (for I in amperes and τ in microseconds). The A/MHz envelope is flat up to the first corner frequency F1 = 1/πτ, then decrease like 1/F , or −20 dB per decade slope, up to the second corner frequency F2 = 1/πtr reciprocal of the rise time and often referred to as the “occupied bandwidth.” From then on, the amplitude rolls off like 1/F 2 , or −40 dB per decade.
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
27
short ground path or long ground path
Forearm, hand and finger C1
R1
L1
150–200 Ω 120–180 nH
6.5 pF C2
R2
V02 ≡ i02
L2
320 Ω
145 pF
1Ω
V0
R01 1Ω
V01 ≡ i01
R02
Figure 1.18 More complete lumped-element model of personnel ESD.
Spectral density
−20
2At A/MHz
ec
/d ad
tc tr = 1 ns time tc = RC = 150 ns t(50%)= 0.69 RC = 100 ns
e
Current (I)
R
ade dB
t (50%)
e−t/RC
dec
0
I=
V
dB/
−4
10 A
A
3
350
Frequency in MHz 2At = 2 × 10 × 10−7 A/Hz ≡ 2 A/MHz = 126 dBmA/MHz
Figure 1.19 Simplified current waveform and spectrum occupancy, for a 10-kV personnel ESD (1-k human body resistance assumed).
28
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
1.5.2. Furniture ESD Waveforms If we look now at the furniture or large-object discharge, the parameters are significantly different, as seen below: L = self-inductance of the loop formed by the furniture (e.g., a cart), the victim (equipment, device etc.) and the ground return. The range of values is min : 0.03 μH
max : 1 μH
typ : 0.3 μH
Rd = resistance of the discharge loop. This can be extremely low, a few ohms, for instance. C = capacitance of the furniture or object to ground; can vary widely, from 30 to 500 pF. Here the inductive part of the loop cannot be neglected versus Rd . Compared to the human body discharge, the charging time constant has increased. On the other hand, the peak current will reach much higher values. Worst is that, instead of a slow falling slope, we now have a damped sine wave, typical of an underdamped, “ringing” RLC circuit. Chapter 2 will explain the impact of this ringing on the severity of the radiation coupling into nearby electronics. Figure 1.20 shows the waveform of a severe furniture discharge. Note that the ESD voltage at which the furniture was charged is significantly less than for the human discharge. This seems to contradict the fact that furniture discharge often appears more severe. However, consider this: The furniture has a capacitance to the surounding (i.e., the ground and the victim equipment) that is typically larger than for the human body case. This is due to the larger dimension of the conductive areas facing each other. A cart or metallic chair may have two to five times more capacitance than a person. Given that the quantity of electricity involved is about the same as for human—in fact in many cases, the furniture has been charged from a human source, by charge transfer—the equation Q = CV implies that for a given energy storage Q, if C increases, the corresponding voltage has to be less. Figure 1.20 also displays a corresponding frequency spectrum, with the rise in spectral amplitude around the ringing frequency. Several well-documented measurements, such as those of King (16) support this model of a low-impedance ringing circuit. Together with Simonic’s study (see Section 1.4) they tend to prove that the classical triangular pulse of human ESD is not enough to cover the variety of possible ESD events, and a furniture-type test with a discharge network having less than 50 impedance would be a necessary supplement. To facilitate extrapolation, Figure 1.21 shows a typical furniture ESD waveform normalized to a 1-kV charging voltage.
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
2.9 A/MHz
A0
e cad
Current (I) in A
/de
A2 = 10 A
(120 dB μ A/MHz)
dB
A/MHz
A1
40
−40
1 A/MHz
20
12.5 ns Time
50 ns
Frequency in MHz
Initial electrostatic voltage = 2000 Volts L = 0.3 μH
RD < 2 L/C, Underdamped oscillation
RD = 15 Ω
damping =
C = 200 pF
A0 = A1 =
n A1/A2 2π
= R/2 C/L = .195
V
A1/A2 = n−1 (π R C/L)
L/C − R2/4 V
L/C + 1.6 R (L/C)½
Figure 1.20 Furniture ESD current waveform and frequency spectrum.
15 Ω
Solution for underdamped oscillation, i.e., R<2 L/C (imaginary roots)
1 kV
ω0 = 1.28 × 108 rad/s
0.3 μH
f0 ≅ 20 MHz (pseudo-frequency of oscillation)
I2 ≅ 0.3I1
30
0
10
20
Time in ns 30 40
200 pF 50
60
70 30
Current (I) In A
I1 20
20 I2
10 0
10 0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Current (I) In A
Ipeak =
V L/C + 1.6 R (L/C)½
70
Time in ns
Figure 1.21 Furniture ESD current waveform, normalized to 1-kV initial charge.
29
30
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
VESD
1 Personnel R = 1000 Ω
2 Furniture R = 15 Ω L = 0.3 μH, C = 200 pF
3 Personnel (IEC) with hand / metal contact
10,000 V
2,000 V
8,000 V
ΔI/Δt
10 A/ns
Duration of steepest current change
≅ 3.5 ns
≅ 5 A/ns
30 A/ns (initial peak)
≅ 10 ns (during the negative going of the 1st pulse)
1 ns
40 2
Current (A)
3 30
20 1
10
10
20
30
50
100
time (ns)
Figure 1.22 Comparison of dynamic parameters of typical personnel and furniture ESD.
1.5.3. Summary: Comparison of Dynamic Parameters for Personnel and Furniture ESD In order to compare the dynamic characteristics of personnel versus furniture discharge, two typical waveforms, representing a severe (but not overly severe) case, have been overlaid in Figure 1.22. An interesting result is that, given two ESD events having similar probabilities of occurring in a busy work space with uncontrolled RH, the personnel discharge is the one that seems to have the highest dI/dt, and therefore likely to create the worst-case couplings. However, the duration of the steep change, that is, the time during which the derivative exists is 20 larger for the furniture discharge than for personnel. The important consequences of this will be discussed in Chapter 2.
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
31
1.5.4. Actual versus Idealized ESD Waveforms No two electrostatic discharges look alike. Pretending that the personnel or furniture ESD waveforms seen before are close to what actually happens would be presumptuous. The idealized waveforms such as those in Figures 1.21 and 1.22 have been devised as a repeatable test criterion, such as equipment that resists such standard ESD waveforms is likely to resist real ESD waveforms of similar amplitudes in the field. As early as the end of the nineteenth century, engineers tried to figure out what sort of electrical circuit could be equivalent to a charged human body. The prime concern at the time was the spontaneous explosions in coal mines and ammunition or gunpowder storage. They came up with the resistor/capacitor set very similar to the basic human body model (HBM) in use today. It was only around the 1960s that accurate ESD current measurements began to be performed. (Fig. 1.23, 1.24) Mazdy (13), one of the first to measure ESD waveshapes, has selected a group of fearless volunteers who charged themselves to a high-voltage power supply, then discharged on a grounded 1- shunt. The waveform was recorded, then a calculation was made to retrieve what RC network would best fit with actual data. Figure 1.24 shows a summary of the results. No inductance was put into the model because the study was mainly aimed at determining the destructive effect of ESD when handling modules, that is, the pulse duration was the concern, not the rise time. However, at a time where no standard existed for ESD immunity of integrated circuits, Mazdy’s data and the simulator he built using them, has been widely used by IBM for the quality control of its modules. As early as 1968 Tucker (14) recorded current waveforms from body discharges. His data show differences between ESD from the fingertip, ESD from the side of hand, and ESD enhanced by a sharp handheld tool (the most severe; see Fig. 1.23). Later, King (15) began a thorough study of ESD waveshapes (Figs. 1.26, 1.27) involving mainly personnel, except in one case where an oscilloscope cart pushed against the discharge set was used. The bulk of King’s data for personnel is shown in Figure 1.25. One sees that with the classical personnel discharge, with the finger approaching not too fast, such as ionization occurs, the measured waveforms are fairly close to the idealized waveshapes of Figure 1.20. In contrast, when the field is locally enhanced by a sharp tool, the raising edge shows some odd shapes, with a “precursor” current spike having only a few hundred picoseconds of rise time. This is somewhat reminiscent of lightning where a precursor is often followed by one or several restrikes. This sharp precursor mostly appear with fast speed of approach and the so-called hand/metal ESD. It does not happen with the hand alone, which generates less peak current. King and other ESD pioneers attribute this precursor to a localized generator where the hand (and the handheld tool) distributed capacitance to the target object is discharged first, and so fast that this segment of the body is likely disconnected from the rest.∗ This mechanism could be described as follows: When the charged ∗ This
also occurs with wristbands, rings, coins, keys, and the like.
32
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
Time in ns 20
40
60
80
100 Experimental calculated
Vo = 40 kV
60
60 Current I in A
120 80
Vo = 30 kV 40
40 Vo = 20 kV
Current I in A
80
0
20
20 Vo = 10 kV 0
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 120
200
250
300
Time in ns (a)
0
50
100
Time in ns 150
Vo = 40 kV
15
15
10
10
Vo = 20 kV
5
Current I in A
Current I in A
Vo = 30 kV
5
Vo = 10 kV 0
0
50
100
150
200
250
0 300
Time in ns (b)
Figure 1.23 (a) Personnel ESD waveforms recorded with an artificially charged person discharging via a handheld metal tool (14). (b) Personnel ESD waveforms recorded with an artificially charged person discharging by his fingertip (14).
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
33
T = 5t
Discharge Rp Charge
Cp
Equivalent circuit of human body RC experiment—nonconductive shoes/surface Cp/Rp experimental results Person #
Cp (pF)
1 2 3 4 5 6 Average
140 145 140 170 180 80 142.5
t (ms)
Rp (kΩ)
.30 .30 .30 .40 .35 .15 .30
2.1 2.0 2.1 2.3 1.9 2.4 2.1
Figure 1.24 Experiment validating an equivalent circuit of the human body (13).
tool edge comes close enough to the target surface, the strong local E field is causing the local air gap breakdown. The corresponding current circulates in the small loop formed by the finger, target, and forearm. Then the current decreases for a few hundred picoseconds, with eventually a deionization of the path, until the rest of the charges left behind reach the finger area and are responsible for the main discharge, with the current returning by the entire human–machine–ground loop. After King, several authors (17–19) have closely studied this predischarge and the way to simulate it. They found that the dI /dt during the predischarge can be as high as 30 A/ns if a finger is approached fast enough, and the phenomenon can be adequately modeled with an additional R,L,C element replicating the human hand (Fig. 1.28). The investigations of Ryser and Daout (18) and Frei and co-workers (20) also reveal that, for personal ESD, the dI /dt of the rising edge is strongly dependent on the speed of approach; these measurements were made by using an artificial finger with a motor-driven movement, such that the speed could be recorded accurately. More recent studies, so far, are generally in
34
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
(a)
(b)
(c)
Time base: 20 ns/div Vertical: 5 V/div @ 1 Ω load
Time base: 5 ns/div Vertical: 2 V/div @ 1 Ω load
Same as (b)
Measurement conditions: The above data were taken under the conditions of • Initiating level: 5000 V • Human subject holding metallic intervening object (screwdriver) as the ESD path • Motion: Discharge load slowly approached to allow maximum ionization to occur. Vvolts
Extremes of IESD range (Amp)
IESD aver.
Zaver. = V/Iaver.
500
0.9 to 1.8
1.3
385 Ω
1000
1 to 3.6
2.3
435 Ω
2000
4 to 5.8
3.5
570 Ω
4000
1.8 to 7.6
4.25
940 Ω
6000
1.2 to 26
10
600 Ω
8000
1.8 to 8
6
1250 Ω
5.2
1920 Ω
10,000
4 to 6.5
Figure 1.25 A few of the personnel ESD waveforms recorded by King (15) using artificially charged volunteers and enhanced discharges with screwdrivers. Pictures (b) and (c) with expanded scale show large variations of rise times—1–15 ns— between different persons and attitudes. Currents/voltages compilation reveal an increase of dynamic impedance with voltage. This nonlinearity can be explained (to some extent) by the increasing arc impedance.
accordance with these former findings. However, increasing attention has been paid to this predischarge spike because it is extremely aggressive for modern high-speed digital circuits and complicates the making and repeatability of ESD tests (see Chapters 2 and 4). At low levels, say up to 6 kV, the localized charge distribution between hand/finger and the target creates the precursor current spike (Fig. 1.29). At higher levels, the increased arc path length and inductance (a 1.5-cm arc has about 15 nH of inductance, presenting 15 to a nanosecond current rise) slow down the rise front and permit a more complete transfer of the whole body charges, without the sharp spˆıke seen at lower levels. The transition between
1.5. Waveforms of Electrostatic Discharges
35
Discharge points Grounded plane Target To mem. Discharge point scope
0.60 m
Double shielded coax
0.90m Mobile furniture for cart-type ESD
ESD
9 × 1.8 Ω carbon res.
50 Ω
50 Ω
0.2 Ω
To scope 50 Ω input
BNC connector Discharge plate
Grounded plane
Equivalent circuit
Coaxial ESD “Target”
Figure 1.26 Test setup used by King (16) for furniture discharge study. For the chair and the cart, the person was initially charged through a dc power supply. In desk chair, ESD from chair base
Discharge from chair base
Vertical: 10 A/div Time: 10 ns/div
Vertical: 20 A/div Time: 20 ns/div
Vertical: 20 A/div Time: 10 ns/div
Displayed: Ip: 45 A Spike 25 A Surge
Displayed: Ip: 64 A
Displayed: Ip: 79 A
Cart (5000 Volts)
Note 30 A early component
Figure 1.27 A few of the 50 furniture ESD signatures recorded by King (16). Large variations are attributed to small changes in speed of motion toward the target. The predischarge phenomenon is visible, as in personnel ESD, but disappears above 2.5 kV, instead of 6–8 kV for personnel.
36
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon VESD in kV dl/dt 30
5
10
15 30 25
20
20
15
15
10
10
Current rise in A/ns
Current rise in A/ns
max 25
min 5
5
5
10
15
VESD in kV
Figure 1.28 Range of dI /dt reported by Ryser (18), depending on the speed of approach of discharge probe. In top right corner, see the ambiguity in dI /dt caused by the precursor and other odd wave shapes.
low- and high-level behavior occurs around 6–8 kV [a phenomenon also shown in the earlier measurements by Tucker (14)]. An additional explanation for this is that around 6–8 kV, the physics of arc discharge, that is, the transition from simple gap breakover to corona effect, introduce some nonlinearity between VESD and Ipeak . For instance, if a real 5-kV initiation generates a 10-A peak current, a 15-kV level does not necessarily create a 30-A current. Nevertheless, although personnel ESD waveforms seem to vary widely, in a random, unpredictable manner defeating any serious simulation, they appear as essentially governed by three basic variables: electrode geometry, electrostatic voltage, and speed of approach of the charged finger or electrode. Once these varaibles are set, the spread of discharge waveforms is greatly reduced. Pommerenke (21) developed a mathematical model that replicates closely this hand/metal discharge. In a follow-up of these experiments, King (16) adressed furniture discharge. The main findings are shown in Figure 1.26–1.27. The √ decaying oscillations typical of an underdamped R,L,C circuit with R < 2 L/C are clearly seen. The peak currents are impressive as well. King’s experiments were conducted with many precautions concerning the high-frequency response of his setup. A copper ground plane was used to avoid uncontrolled parasitic inductance in the return path. The shunt used to read the current was a coaxial mount and the instrument 3-dB bandwidth was larger than 500 MHz.
References
37
1 L1
2
C1 i2
Fast approach + hand holding metal
Typical 1st slope: 10–30 A/ns with 5 kV
1
2
+
2
Human body only, slow approach
Figure 1.29 Proposed explanation for the precursor discharge. C1 and L1 being very small, the rise time and duration of the current are very short.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
Jowett, C. E. Electrostatics in the Electronics Environment. McMillan, New York, 1976. Horvath, A., and Berta, I. Static Elimination. Wiley New York, 1982. Testone, A. Static Electricity in Electronic Industry. Testone Enterprise, Lee, MA. 1981. Jonassen, N. Static Electricity. Applied Physics Laboratory, Technical University of Denmark, 1991. Aguet, M. D´echarges d’origine electrostatique. Bulletin SEV/VSE 74, Switzerland, 1983. Richman, P. ESD Protection Handbook . Keytek Instrument Corp., 1983. Kirk, W. Eliminate Static Discharges. Electronic Design, March, 1976. p. 80–85. Yenni, D. Huntsman, J. and Mueller, G. 3M Static Products Documentation, 1995. ISO-TC 22, 1989. Simonic, R. Personnel ESD Statistics. IEEE/EMC Symposium, Boulder, CO, 1981. Simonic, R. Furniturel ESD Events Rates. IEEE/EMC Symposium, Santa Clara, CA, 1982. p. 191– 197. Byrne, W. An ESD Model for Electronic Systems. IEEE/EMC Symposium, Santa Clara CA. 1982, p. 199– 205.
38
Chapter 1 The Electrostatic Discharge Phenomenon
13. Mazdy, T. Static Discharge Modelling. EMC Symposium, Montreux, Switzerland, 1975, p. 134– 139. 14. Tucker, T. Spark Initiation Requirements. Annals of New York Academy of Sciences, Vol. 152, Oct. 1968. 15. King, M. Dynamic Waveforms of Personnal ESD. EOS/ESD Symposium, Denver, 1979, p. 78–87. 16. King, M. Pulse Waveforms of Personnel/Furniture ESD. IEEE/EMC Symposium, Santa Clara, CA, 1982, p. 212– 219. 17. Hyatt, H. and Mellberg, H. Bringing ESD Testing into the 20th Century. IEEE/EMC Symposium, Santa Clara, CA, 1982, p. 220–225. 18. Ryser, H. and Daout, B. Fast Discharge Mode in ESD. EMC Symposium, Zurich, 1985, p. 41–46. 19. Richman, P., and Tasker, A. ESD Testing: Interface between Simulator and EUT.” EMC Symposium, Zurich, 1985, p. 25–30. 20. Frei, S., Senhgaas, M., and Jobava, R. Influence of Speed of Approach and Humidity on Intensity of ESD. EMC Symposium, Zurich, 1999. 21. Pommerenke, D. and Aidam, M. ESD Waveform Calculation of Human & Simulated ESD. Journal of Electrostatics, Vol. 38, Nov. 1996, p. 33–51.
Chapter
2
Effects of ESD on Electronics B
efore addressing the various ESD simulators and test methods, we found it necessary to cover the essential coupling mechanisms by which an ESD actually disturbs or damages electronic circuits. The reason being that, a sound test should not only reproduce the discharge itself but also excite, in a realistic manner, the complex interactions between the charged person (or object) and the test item. Not accounting for the multitude of ESD incidents in the modern environment, and focusing on the impact of ESD on electronic devices, the phenomenon can be broken down into three essential scenarios: • • •
Direct discharge to an electronic component (integrated or discrete) Direct discharge to an electronic equipment housing Indirect discharge
2.1. DIRECT DISCHARGE TO AN ELECTRONIC COMPONENT Direct electrostatic discharge to an electronic device is one of the most severe threats to component reliability during the manufacturing and handling of electronic parts. It costs millions of dollars in losses of dead chips and severe breeches in the percent yield of integrated circuit (IC) manufacturing lines, not to mention the latent wounds that will later show up as unexplained failures in the field. This problem was recognized in the late 1960s, and all the large manufacturers of electronic components have since implemented strict static control programs consisting of: • •
Static awareness for employees Static-free work areas and manufacturing hardware
Electrostatic Discharge, Third Edition, by Michel Mardiguian Copyright © 2009 the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
39
40
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics • •
Monitoring of percent yields and chip infant mortality to detect ESD symptoms Antistatic precautions for card handling in the field
The scope of this book is not to address thoroughly component failure but rather the malfunctions of a complete device. The reader who is also interested in the component damage aspect of ESD in manufacturing is referred to the abundant literature on the subject (1–4). We will simply consider a brief reminder of this aspect of ESD by showing a few typical episodes. In Figure 2.1(a), the module on a workbench is “zapped” by a person who touches it. Note that: •
•
The culprit may not even notice the ESD event if he (she) was charged at less than 1.5–2 kV (threshold of feeling); therefore no warning exists of a possible damage. The sad thing is that if the workbench was conductive and grounded (an intuitively good antistatic practice) this would only make things worse, by decreasing the impedance of the ground path.
The moral is that antistatic precautions should be applied across the board. Nobody should handle modules without using a grounded wrist-strap or, at the very least, touching a grounded structure first; workbenches should be conductive but “softly” grounded by a few hundred kilohm resistor. Plastic-encased modules are prime victims of this type of event since the field gradient creates arcing or charge transfer from the case surface to the chip itself then sinks to ground via the leads. Metal-encapsulated modules have better chances of surviving if the arc flows on a metal can and breaks over the can-to-benchtop air gap. Figure 2.1(b) shows the opposite situation where the module is standing leads-up, often referred to as the “dead bug” case. Here metallic-canned modules may be as badly damaged. Figure 2.1(c) shows a more insidious scenario: The module has become charged by sliding in carousel rails or by being put in ordinary plastic bags, crates, skin packing and the like. The device can remain charged a significant amount of the time, until it finds an occasion to get rid of its charge, hence experiencing a self-inflicted wound. A variation of this, known as the charged device model (CDM) has been analyzed in several studies (5). There is no such massive statistical data base for this charged device pulse as there is for the human body model (HBM) or furniture event. In fact, the shorted IC internal impedance is extremely dependent on the nature of the current path. Given that the through resistance of the device, as well as the resistance of the discharge path, can be very low on some pins, one can expect a significant peak current, while other IN/OUT pin arrangements in the same module could present a high resistance. Furthermore the package (leaded, unleaded, ball-grid, socketed, or not) is also playing a significant role. As a result, with a real charged device, no definite discharge waveform can be taken for granted. Instead, a corresponding, equivalent CDM circuit test setup
2.1. Direct Discharge to an Electronic Component
41
(a) Charged person zapping a module placed on a conductive workbench: discharge from finger → IC case → chip → pins
(b) Charged person zapping a module placed on a conductive workbench: discharge from finger → pin → chip → IC case.
(c) Charged modules (from nonconductive plastic bags, rails, crates etc…) discharging on grounded personnel.
2 A/division
(d) Charged IC discharging on itself (charged device model)
1 ns/division
Figure 2.1 Integrated circuit ESD damage during handling.
has been defined, briefly described in Chapter 3. Notice that, thanks to the low value of the devices self-capacitance (typically less than 20 pF), the discharge pulse duration is only a few nanoseconds. A third possibility exists in the manipulation of ICs with robots, automatic handlers, and the like. Similar to the furniture discharge (see Chapter 1), this
42
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
scenario assumes that the IC will be handled by a massive device, some elements of which, like three-dimensional (3D) rotating arms, jaws, conveyor belts, and the like are poorly grounded or nonmetallic. This ESD threat, for ICs, is known as the (charged) machine model, or MM (6–8). The solution against these potential ESD damages is to always ship ESD-sensitive devices in static dissipative bags, preferably the shielded type, and to have their pins shorted-out in a conductive foam pad. Remember also that all the above scenarios repeat themselves throughout the life of a device: • • • • •
During wafer processing, test, and cutting During chip transport, test, substrate mounting, and encapsulation During module handling, test, and storage At the next step, that is, PCB level; contrary to a common myth, an IC mounted on a PCB is still vulnerable In the host machine itself, during maintenance
Figures 2.2 and 2.3 show a typical static-free workstation and examples of static dissipative hardware used at the factory or repair shop. What ESD levels does it take to damage a component that is at rest, unpowered? The answer, of course, depends on: • •
The type of technology The dimensional rules: SiO2 thickness, traces width and thickness, traces and pad spacing
Ionized Air Blower
1-MΩ Resistor Table Mat
Wrist Strap Building Ground 1-MΩ Resistor Heel Strap Floor Mat
Figure 2.2 Example of a static-free workstation.
2.1. Direct Discharge to an Electronic Component
(a)
1. Conductive and humidity independent metallic (Ni) outer layer that is: • Continuous • 100 A° thick Transparent (40% or more light transmission) • Resistant to UV exposure • High abrasion resistance
2. A polyester film of nominal 1 mil thickness • High tensile strength • High tear resistance • High puncture resistance • High dielectric strength
3. A polythylene film of nominal 1.5 mil thickness • Anti-static formulation • Heat sealable
(b) static shielding bag and its construction (Courtesy of 3M Static Control)
(c) Conductive tote boxes with ≤104 Ω/sq. resistance (Courtesy of WEZ Plastic Industries)
Figure 2.3 Static protection at the factory.
43
44
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics •
The type of built-in protection provided by the manufacturer (assuming the protection resistances and clamping diodes are themselves ESD resistant, which is not always true)
Electrostatic discharge failures occur generally by upsetting the breakdown voltage of the SiO2 isolation or overheating of the metallization. For instance, in metal–oxide semiconductor (MOS) structures with typical oxide thicknesses ˚ (10−7 m), the rigidity of 5–7 MV/cm is exceeded if a voltage of of 1000 A 50–70 V is reached between two isolated channels. Failure by joule effect occurs where a junction or a metallized trace deteriorates and blows up like a fuse: When the current density exceeds 2 kA/mm2 , aluminum particles start migrating, reducing the available section in the conductor, which ultimately will melt, above 30 kA/mm2 for a typical ESD duration, or delaminate. Copper metallization can handle about 2.5 times more current. Integrated active or passive elements can also be damaged: 300- polysilicon resistors for complementary MOS (CMOS) input protection or surge clamping diodes for transistor-transistor logic (TTL) and bipolar are generally damaged above 2.5–3 kV with the HBM test. Damages can also be parametric, mainly with bipolar logic and op-amp, causing fan-out alteration, gain loss, and an increase in noise factor. Latch-up is a different failure mode, affecting powered CMOS circuits when overstressed. In either case of damage the criteria is often the available pulse energy. For current MOS technology, for instance, the threshold of damaging energy is on the order of 1–10 μJ. A straightforward calculation, based on the available energy in a capacitor, will give the damaging voltage range, for a human body discharge. Since W (joule) = 0.5CV 2 where solving for W = 1 − 10 μJ and C = 100 pF (average human body capacitance) we get, for 1 μJ, Vmax = 140 V and for 10 μJ, Vmax = 450 V Also, since energy = power × time, and given that the 50% pulse duration of human ESD is about 150 ns,we can derive, based on 1 μJ, a not-to-exceed pulse power of P =
10−6 = 6.6 W 150 × 10−9
Another approach is to calculate the not-to-exceed peak current, based on the damaging energy. For a triangular approximation of an exponentially decaying pulse, with 50% duration T50 : W = 0.7RI 2 T50
2.1. Direct Discharge to an Electronic Component
45
where T50 = 50% pulsewidth R = device through resistance √ Solving for Wmax = 1 × 10−6 J and T50 = 150 ns, we get Imax = 3/ R. For instance, if the device resistance (pin-to-ground) R = 100 , Imax = 0.3 A peak For a 1500- human body resistance and an unprotected device, this correspond to VESDmax = 0.3(1500 + 100) = 480 V Figures 2.4(a) and 2.4(b) show some typical ESD damage in microelectronics. Although CMOS and field-effect transistor (FET) devices are notorious for their fragility to ESD, other technologies can be victims too. The trend toward hyperintegration (VLSI and ULSI with 10,000 to a million devices per ˚ make things worse since all spacchip) and gate dielectric down to 250 A ings and thicknesses are further reduced. Most highly integrated chips now have several layers (up to six–eight levels of metallizations). It is not an overstatement to say that if ESD vulnerability is not treated drastically, it can be a major obstacle in the challenge toward faster speeds and shorter propagation delays. Table 2.1 is often reported in the literature (1) and shows the susceptibility of various electronic devices to a standard human body ESD. For someone used to dealing with a certain degree of accuracy, this table may appear as neither very serious or reliable. Which ESD level destroys a JFET: 140 V or 7000 V? or a CMOS: 250 V or 3000 V? How can any protection strategy be optimized if the data are so vague? Nobody is to blame; there was no sloppiness in the gathering or compilation of data. But actual thresholds of ESD failure can, indeed, vary by 1 order of magnitude or more, based on the following: •
• •
• •
Damage thresholds differ depending on how the pulse is applied: one pin against all (n − 1) pins shorted together? Or each pin selectively against the grounded case? Or all possible combinations? Damage thresholds differ according to pulse polarity. Damage thresholds of a same part number, same manufacturer, vary from one vintage to another, depending on the plant of origin or the serial number of the masks used. Damage thresholds are not the same for a unique test pulse than as for repeated pulses. Damage thresholds of identical, compatible part numbers from different manufacturers vary widely.
46
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
Junction burnout E B C
• PJ = IVBD • TJ → TC
Junction Bipolar discrete short IC
Alloy
• Junction Short (90% of damages with Bipolar) Oxide punchthrough AL
V
• V > VBD
SiO2
• Punchthrough
SI
• Oxide Short
Oxide short
MOS discretes
(27% of damage with MOS) Metallization burnout AL
• PM = i2R
SiO2
• TM → TC
Open Bipolar & MOS
• Open Trace ( 10% of damage for Bipolar 63% of damage for MOS) (a)
3
C2
(b)
Figure 2.4 (a) Typical ESD damages in microelectronics. (b) Magnified view of IC damaged by ESD. (Adapted from JPL, report by Trigonis.)
2.1. Direct Discharge to an Electronic Component
47
Table 2.1 ESD Susceptibility of Various Electronic Devices to Human Body ESD Device Type
Range of ESD Susceptibilty (V)
VMOS MOSFET GaAsFET EPROM JFET SAW OP AMP CMOS Schottky diodes Film resistors (thick, thin) Bipolar transistors ECL (PC board level) SCR Schottky TTL HCMOS (74HCOO) with integrated protection NMOS 3 μ (with protection) NMOS 1 μ (with protection)
•
30–1800 100–200 +100, −800 100 140–7000 150–500 190–2500 250–3000 300–2500 300–3000 380–7000 500–1500 680–2500 1100–2500 2000–4000 6000 3000
Reported levels depend on the criteria selected: Was a part declared failed when it was functionnally wrong? Or as soon as its direct current (dc) parameters deviated from initial specification?
In Figure 2.5 a check of V , I characteristics reveals a breakdown voltage deterioration. Figure 2.6 shows, on a Weibull distribution graph, the ESD threshold of CMOS inverters from four different brands. The monitored parameters consist in an input current > 1 μA (indicating a damaged gate insulator) or an output not responding to input change, whichever failure came first. The graphs show ratios of 3 to 1 or 4 to 1 between the best part and the worst part of the sample. Also the deviation varies widely from one manufacturer to another. Another example showing that the ESD damage level is never a “green light/red light” situation is shown in Table 2.2. The product tested was a bipolar logic gate type 54L04 (TTL, low power). One hundred devices were tested for multiple pulses until a failure occurred. The criteria for failure was to monitor the deviation of two critical parameters from their normal value: Iinput
High
Voutput
Low
Normal = 10 μA max;
failure if I > 20 nA
Normal = 0.3 V max;
failure if V > 0.05 V
The results are shown in number of parts that did not survive to N pulses at level V . All the parts survived after the application of up to 175 pulses at 2000 V; then 10 died between 176 and 200 pulses. The survivors were stressed to 2750 V, where casualties are seen as soon at the first pulse. Finally, of the 15 survivors that came victoriously through the 200 pulses at 5000 V, 10 died at the first
48
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics 4
8
12
20 30
Gate section D out of specification (inputs low)
20
20
Gate section C in specification (inputs low)
10
0
16
CD4001A ISS vs. VDD
0
4
8
10
12
Leakage current in mA
Leakage current in mA
30
0 20
16
Volts
Figure 2.5 Example of deteriorations in reverse breakdown (9).
Table 2.2 Failure Decision Is Never a Step Function (11) Pulse Level (V)
Number of Pulses to Cause Failure (N) 1
5750 5000 4250 3500 2750 2000
10 12 16 9 2
2
3
4
1 2 1
8 2 1 1 1
50
1
75
1
125
1
175
2
200
3 8 11 10
application of a 5750-V ESD. Can we then say that we have a product that can withstand ESD at 2000 V? or up to 5000 V? This is the case where all the usual methodology of stress tests and quality control (QC) have to be used to come up with a reliable number that will characterize the ESD immunity with a certain confidence level (12). In all these tests an unstressed sample lot should be verified to avoid the introduction of an uncontrolled variable not related to ESD. An interesting question arises: Would the 15 heroes that came through 5000 V have gone even further if they had not been inflicted, at lower levels, with 600-V discharges? Some test plans require that after every run at a given ESD voltage, the entire lot under test be replaced by a new one. This is a way to characterize the true ESD immunity of this product. However, the cumulative effect of multiple discharges, with increasing levels, is missed. Some technologies can be significantly more fragile than the previous example. The following relates to the ESD test results of an analog
2.1. Direct Discharge to an Electronic Component
100 99.9
300
Stress in volts 1000
49
99.9
In (time/stress) B
99 C,D
A
50 30
50 30
10
10
3
3
1
1
0.3
0.3
0.1
0.1
0.03
0.03
0.01 100
300
1000
Cumulative failutre in %
Cumulative failure in %
99
0.01
Stress in volts
Figure 2.6 ESD failure level for 4001 inverters from Manufacturers A, B, C, and D (10).
radio-frequency (RF) mixer IC, containing GaAs components, in a SOT (small outline technology) package: Sample size: 30 parts Type of test: human body, pass/fail treshold: 100/200 V Type of test: machine model, fail treshold: 100 V This is clearly a very ESD-sensitive device because of GaAs technology, requiring serious handling precautions and external protection components in its application. Another related problem is one of latent failures: a part which still appears undamaged after an ESD test may in fact have its lifetime affected. There are several confirmations that parts which have been subjected to ESD (either by fortuitous or intentional event) become “walking-wounded” that will exhibit abnormal failure rates in the field (12). But even this is not always true: some sample lots which were ESD stressed have exhibited, during accelerated life tests, better life-times than the sample lot, unstressed! This self-healing phenomena has been given several explanations, the description of which would be far beyond the scope of this book.
50
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
Since 1980, the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) has issued a standard document, DOD-Std 1686, defining all the requirements for an ESD control program for electronic components and assemblies. Originally intended for suppliers and subcontractors of the DOD, it has become a commonly used reference for the industry in general. The DOD Standard (2006 Rev.) calls for: •
• • • •
Identification and tagging of ESD-sensitive items (Class 1 with sensitivity between 250 and 2000 V and Class 2 with sensitivity between 2000 and 4000 V); details of the corresponding test given in Chapter 3 Built-in circuit protection at chip and card level ESD-proof handling, shipping, and other procedures QC and audits Field maintenance precautions
The standard also requires that subcontractors rule out Class 1 devices when a Class 2 device is available that could perform identical functions. As a complement to DOD-Std 1686, the Department of Defense has issued Handbook 263, which gives ESD control guidelines and details of failure mechanisms. The document also contains classifications of ESD protection equipment, materials, manufacturing, and shipping procedures. (For an excerpt from Handbook 263, see Appendix A.) Other organizations such as the ESD Association or the IEC (International) also publish complete static control programs intended for manufacturers of electronic devices and equipment (see Chapter 3).
2.2. DIRECT DISCHARGE TO ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT ENCLOSURE The direct discharge is the most classic case and the easiest to understand. The charged person or object (the “source”) touches a metal enclosure (the “load”). Most of the time [Fig. 2.7(a)] the discharge occurs on a purely mechanical part, which is touched intentionally (knob, key, switch, handle) or fortuitously (frame, covers, connector shell). Some more severe occurrences are shown in [Fig. 2.7(b)]: • • •
Finger approaching an unprotected input/output (I/O) connector Finger arcing through, or arc creeping around, a light-emitting diode (LED) or incandescent display Discharge on a PCB-mounted switch in which case a subsequent arc occurs internally between the toggle and the active contacts of the switch
In these latter cases, the ESD current can in fact reach directly the electronic components by a conducted path. Except for some damping caused by the wire or trace length, the situation is almost as severe as the direct discharge to a module pin, as was discussed in Section 2.1.
2.2. Direct Discharge to Electronic Equipment Enclosure
51
Metallic loudspeaker element
Wiring or PCB
to PBX ground
Plastic housing (a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 2.7 Personnel ESD coupling by direct contact.
Figure 2.7(c) shows another variation where the discharge occurs on a telephone set, via the earphone and its loudspeaker capsule. The consequences in this case are severe: The ESD transient is causing a hang-up of the conversation or loss of the memorized numbers. Whatever the scenario, the current then returns to ground by all possible routes, with amplitudes prorated to the impedances of these respective paths. This means that the bulk of the current will flow by the lowest impedance path, the remainder flowing through all other possible routes. For instance, Figure 2.8 illustrates what these routes can be for a single stand-alone machine. At this point in our discussion, let us briefly return to the actual waveform of a hand/metal (the most severe) type of personnel ESD, seen in Section 1.5 and Figure 1.29. The sharp peak of initial current caused by the local discharge of the forearm-to-target capacitance does not return by the machine-to-ground path. Instead, it remains confined in the loop formed by the hand and the machine cover. Only the main part of the current pulse, with rise time of 5–10 ns, is reclosing by the machine-to-ground impedance. In Figure 2.8(a), the discharge current path seems obvious, the machine being grounded by its safety wire and/or its neutral wire (neutral is generally grounded at the building level). However, the reality of this path does not resist a closer
52
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics (a) Charged body
Grounded item IESD
(b) Charged body
Ungrounded item IESD
Several kV (c) Uncharged body
Charged item IESD
Figure 2.8 Personnel ESD coupling routes, showing return current paths.
look. The self-inductance of a round wire above ground is 1–1.5 μH/m, resulting in 3 μH of inductance for a typical 2-m power cord. For a current rise time of 5 ns, its dynamic impedance would be 3 × 10−6 L = = 600 dt 5 × 10−9 notwithstanding the additional length of building earth wire. Why would the entire ESD current choose to run across more than 600 while a lower impedance path exists in parallel? Figure 2.8(b) shows what this easier path can be. Any machine containing conductive parts has a capacitance to ground. In the case of a metallic casing, the capacitance to ground can reach 100 or even 1000 pF. For instance, a mainframe having a bottom area of 1 m2 , located 8–10 cm above ground, will have a parasitic capacitance of 100 pF. For a rise time of 5 ns, this corresponds to a dynamic impedance of about 50 . If the machine is lifted 0.80 m above ground, on a nonconductive table, this stray capacitance will decrease to approximately 40 pF, representing 120 of impedance, still less than what the ground wire can offer. Therefore a large proportion of the ESD current (specially during its rise, the most threatening one) will sink via the chassis-to-ground stray capacitance. This can be verified by the following, simple experiment: An ESD simulator is discharged on a grounded equipment. Then the power cord is removed completely
2.3. Indirect Discharge
53
and the test is repeated on the now floating frame. A discharge will occur with no difficulty and, if a current probe is inserted over the generator tip, it will read about the same peak current as with the grounded configuration. What will be affected is the discharge time constant of the pulse; in other words, the machine will stay charged for a longer time. Does this mean that for a normally grounded machine, no current is flowing into the ground wire? Certainly not: The same current probe, slipped over the power cord, would read a peak current that can be few percent to 10% of the total ESD current. In Figure 2.8(c) a third possibility is shown: the reverse discharge. In this case a machine has been charged by: • • •
Successive previous discharges from people and objects Internal static generations Laminar flow of air, specially dry or cold air or rubbing against a dry, isolated material
If the machine is floating versus ground (table-top equipment with power cord not connected, battery-powered device, and the like), the recombination of charges is not occurring or very slowly. When somebody approaches the machine, or takes the power cord to plug it in, a discharge will occur. If the machine is off, no harm is done to it, but the resulting surge creates locally a power line transient that may alter the operation of other machines nearby. Eventually, if the machine was in a stand-by, self-powered mode, a lock-up can occur that may necessitate a more or less elaborate restart.
2.3. INDIRECT DISCHARGE With an indirect discharge, the person does not (or even cannot) discharge directly on the equipment. For instance, if the machine is entirely housed in plastic with no or few accessible metal parts, nobody will discharge on it. In the early 1970s, with the massive arrival of plastic housings for electronic office products and electronic data processing (EDP) terminals, there was a general belief that they would mark the end of the electrostatic nightmare. “Bye-bye ESD” was the song, but people did not dance to it for very long: Field reports came in by legions to show that these products were experiencing even more ESD crashes than those with metal casings! Figure 2.9 shows what happens. A person discharges on any nearby metallic part: a door frame, a water pipe, a furniture, perhaps the very desk on which the machine is standing. Then, the ESD pulse radiates a strong local electromagnetic field, which couples into the nearby electronics since a plastic enclosure offers no shielding at all. With a desktop machine, for instance [Fig. 2.9(a)], if the motherboard lies flat on the bottom of the unit, the printed circuit is within 2 or 3 cm of the ESD current path. Figure 2.9(b) is a more diabolic variation of indirect ESD witnessed
54
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
IESD
IESD
(a) On metallic desk supporting a plastic product
(b) On a desk lamp
Figure 2.9 Indirect discharge.
by the author: A battery-operated calculator with a printer was being used by a draftman. During winter months, when the draftman switched his desk lamp on and off, the calculator would print a burst of erratic figures. At first a power-line transient was suspected but, besides the fact that the unit was not plugged into anything, the printer would turn on even when the lamp was simply touched. In fact, the ESD current was flowing via the lamp shade and the stem, coupling to the power cord via the large capacitance between the flexible tube and the wire inside and then to the ground. This long current path was radiating like an antenna on the plastic calculator circuit board. [Note: The author remembers a cocktail party where he experienced discharges on a large metal dish where the hors-d’oeuvres were arranged: The dish was on a cloth-covered wooden table, obviously grounded nowhere. But the charge transfer was enough to cause a violent ESD. Hopefully, sauteed chicken livers on toast and shrimps-a-la-creole are fairly ESD immune.]
2.4. COUPLING MECHANISMS OF ESD PULSE INTO THE VICTIM’S CIRCUITRY At the very instant of the discharge, a locally strong electromagnetic field excitation takes place: • •
The electric (E) field, which was established at a high value by the charged body, is collapsing abruptly. A magnetic (H ) field caused by the discharge current suddenly raises to a large value.
Both dE /dt and dH /dt field derivatives play a role, but all practical experience has confirmed that the severity of the threat is strongly related to the magnitude of
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry
55
the current. This is not to say that it could not be predicted from the initial voltage, but everything being equal—generator capacitance, discharging path dimensions, initial voltage, and arcing gap length—tests done with the least source resistance are generally causing the most machine malfunctions. The hypothesis that the arc length and the E field in its vicinity are predominant factors in the ESD susceptibility is usually contradicted by this fact: A machine withstanding 10 kV ESD with a generator having 2000 of internal resistance will almost certainly fail at a lower level with a tester having only 150 or 300 of internal resistance. In fact, a test condition considered as the most severe of all is one where the arc no longer exists, the discharge being done with direct contact of the probe tip. The role of the arc for air discharge is important in that it dictates the speed of ionization of the gap, hence contributing to the rise time, but the arc itself is not the predominant radiator. Instead, the radiating structure is made of: • • •
The human body (or charged furniture) The arm, terminated by the short arc The wall of the victim structure, with return by a more or less defined ground path
In the majority of cases [with the exception of Fig. 2.8(b) acknowledged], the electronic circuits of the victim equipment are not directly in the conducted path of the ESD current, which flows usually on housings and metallic structures. There is, therefore, a near-field coupling mechanism by which the localized field created by the discharge induces a voltage spike into the exposed circuit.
2.4.1. Magnetic Field Coupling Figure 2.10 shows a simplified model of this phenomenon, based on the discharge current only. A first thing to point out is that the dimensions of the ESD generating circuit are large compared to its distance to the receiving circuit. Therefore, it cannot be treated as a punctual source. Simple solutions of Maxwell’s equation for small electric or magnetic doublets with their resulting (1/d)2 and (1/d)3 field-to-distance dependency cannot be straightforwardly applied. A rigorous approach would be to apply the method of moments to the current path, broken down in small filaments. The much simpler model shown assimilates the ESD current path to a long radiating wire for which the resulting magnetic field is easily calculated from the Biot and Savart law. The ESD drain path to ground being long versus the distance of observation the magnetic field is given by: H (A/m) = I /(2πd) where I = ESD current in amperes d = distance from ESD path to victim circuit
(2.1)
56
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics IESD
S
R
H
Simplified model: the H field is modeled from an infinite straight wire, carrying IESD
Ampère's law: H = I /2p R Example: IESD = 15 A (from a 4 kV simulated ESD) Distance R
H peak
Voltage induced in 1 cm2 loop Rise time 1 ns Rise time 5 ns
3 cm
80 A/m
10 V
2V
10 cm
24 A/m
3V
0.6 V
30 cm
8 A/m
1V
0.2 V
Figure 2.10 ESD coupling by radiation.
If the area of the circuit illuminated by the ESD field is known, a derivation of the field over the rise time gives an approximation of the open-loop voltage induced, generally sufficient for a quick prediction. Vi = −
dφ A dB = dt dt
(2.2)
where Vi = induced voltage, V A = victim circuit area, m2 B = induction in teslas, with 1 tesla = 104 gauss = 80 × 104 A/m Rearranging Eqs. (2.1) and (2.2) and using more convenient units, we end up with: I A Vi = 2 (2.3) td
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry
where I A t d
= = = =
57
change in ESD current, A victim circuit loop area, cm2 rise time of the ESD current, ns distance from ESD path to victim circuit, cm
Figure 2.10 gives the results in voltages induced per centimeter squared of victim area, for three distances from the ESD path, assuming rise times of: • •
1 ns typical of the fast precursor peak with a hand/tool discharge ≤ 8 kV 5 ns more typical of simple hand discharge, or air discharge above 8 kV
Example Two printed traces 1 cm apart, with a 5-cm parallel run, located at 10 cm from the ESD flow will see a peak transient of 1 V/cm2 × 5 cm2 = 5 V. This is enough to create an erroneous bit in most logic technologies. Although very elementary, this method of predicting the ESD pulsed fields, hence the induced parasitic voltages, gives adequate approximation when compared to actual measurements. Even though the current flows more as a spread stream than as in a thin wire, the H field around its path can still be found by Eq. (2.3). This field from the ESD pulse has two effects: • •
It couples to the inner circuits of the machine: circuit boards, flat cables, discrete wiring It illuminates also the outside, all around the ESD source and discharge path (Fig. 2.11), where external signal and power cables behave as receiving antennas as well
1 2A Ipeak
−
+ 3
2B
Figure 2.11 ESD coupling mechanisms: (1) The discharge current flows over the equipment cabinet. (2A) Cabinet imperfections let the high-frequency component (near or above the λ/2 resonances) penetrate and shine inside. (2B) The discharge current radiates on the I/O cables. (3) Circuits inside intercept the high-frequency field. Note that these mechanisms are derivative, that is, frequency dependent.
58
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
Another criticism could be raised against this overly simple model: Considering the frequencies involved, the current flow is supposed to stay confined on the outer skin of the metallic cabinet (assuming a direct discharge) because of the skin effect: At 100 MHz, for instance, the skin depth in steel is about 30 μm, therefore, a 1-mm steel cover would be 30 skin depths thick and, according to basic shielding theory, no ESD current should be found on the inner side. This would be true if the whole housing was a homogeneous shield, which is not the case: Slots, joints, vents, displays, cable entries create huge leakages especially at these high frequencies (this will be addressed in Chapter 5, under packaging aspects). As a result, the ESD current excites the many slot antennas formed by box discontinuities, cooling apertures, ungasketed seams, and the like. At the lower part of the frequency spectrum, these openings represent a minuscule fraction of wavelength, and their attenuation is significant. But for that part of the ESD spectrum that approaches or exceeds their λ/2 resonance, they shine inside with practically no attenuation. Therefore, in a device not specially hardened against ESD [or high-frequency electro magnetic interference (EMI), up to 1 GHz], the ESD current will flow on the inside of the cabinet as well as the outside. Now guess which part of the ESD-radiated field induces the largest voltages in the exposed PCB traces and in the cables? The high-frequency end, of course. However, knowing just the magnetic field may not be sufficient. A deeper knowledge of the nature of the electromagnetic field near the ESD path may be wished, as explained next.
2.4.2. Electric Field Coupling from Indirect ESD on Floating Parts Electrostatic discharge to an ungrounded, passive structure is a peculiar, although quite common, variation of indirect ESD. The basic coupling scenario is shown in Figure 2.12 and found in many practical situations such as in Figure 2.13. The charged person touches a floating, conductive object representing a sufficient surface—say more than a few tens of square centimeters. At the instant of contact, this object is acting as the armature of a capacitor that suddenly raises to the intruder’s voltage. In contrast with the previous cases with a grounded structure, where the ESD source was basically short-circuited by the target, what we have here is: • • •
A floating armature that is abruptly brought to kilovolts (+ or −) The local, narrow current spike i1 due to the small finger-to-target discharge, with the corresponding H field A strong E field impressed on the circuits of the victim equipment facing this armature
The effects of this E-field surge are generally less a problem than those caused by the H field in the previous examples. However, the circuits that are basically
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry i1
Floating armature A C1-G Victim circuit
59
1 to 2 kΩ A
VESD i2
C1-G
τ
ZGND
i2 Z(PCB-to-Ground) Impedance, wired or capacitive
Equivalent schematic
Example:
General scenario
VESD = 5 kV Rd = 1 kΩ
C1-G = 5 pF
ZC1−G << 1 kΩ ZGND << 1 kΩ i2 = 5 A peak RC = 5 ns τ50% = 3.5 ns
Figure 2.12 Scenario of E-field ESD coupling via floating structures.
Victim equipment
Metallic top
Plastic dashboard PCB
C1-G
Electronic module
Plastic or wooden desk Chassis GND
Actual event On the metalic top of a nonconductive desk (a)
Actual event On the metal portion (floating trim or button) of plastic dashboard (b)
Figure 2.13 Two practical situations of indirect ESD with E-field (capacitive) excitation.
“trapped” between the hot armature and ground will see a capacitive current: V i2 = C1−G (simplified formula, assuming a constant voltage slope) t (2.4) V0 −t (2.5) i2 = e RC1−G (more general formula) R
60
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
where C1−G = stray capacitance of the floating armature to the exposed circuit V0 = source voltage Capacitance C1−G depends on the area of the exposed vicim circuitry and its distance to the armature. Typical values range from one to tens of picofarads; t is the time it takes for the floating structure to reach the full intruder’s electrostatic voltage. This time, in turn, is related to the stray capacitance involved (Fig. 2.13). Example Taking 3 pF as an average value for C1−G , and a 5-kV/1 ns voltage front, the equivalent circuit of Figure 2.13 results in
i2 = 5 A peak RC = 5 ns,
and τ (50% pulsewidth) = 3.5 ns
Depending on how the victim circuits are arranged versus the path of this capacitive current, whether they are shielded or protected by a PCB ground plane and the like this coupling can cause a malfunction such as a logic change-of-state or lock-up. In the IEC type of ESD test (see Chapter 4), this configuration is re-created by using a vertical or horizontal coupling plate (VCP or HCP).
2.4.3. Measured E - and H -Field Values near an ESD to a Grounded Structure In 1984 this author conducted a set of experiments to evaluate both E and H fields. Fields were measured by miniature monopoles, short balanced dipole, and magnetic loop (electrically shielded). The probes were connected to an Electro-Metrics ESA 1000 spectrum analyzer. A slow scan speed and sufficient RF attenuation were chosen to avoid spectrum analyzer error due to the broadband nature of the measurement. The ESD simulator was a Schaffner NSG 430 (150 /150 pf Network) set on repetitive mode in order to obtain multiple scan overlays. First, the test setup of Figure 2.14 was arranged to measure the field amplitude facing an ESD in the absence of any protective shield. This would be the case of a discharge to a grounded metal object near an equipment having only a plastic enclosure. This also serves as a reference to further shielding effectiveness assessment. Although the nonuniformity of the field makes closer measurements less accurate, E- and H -field magnitudes have been measured at 10 cm, 30 cm, and 1 m. The vertical structure was a 50-cm by 6-cm aluminum plate, firmly bonded to the copper ground plane. The ESD gun was set to 10 kV. An arc discharge, with a slow repetition rate was made on the upper edge of the plate. The ground return for the ESD gun was a flat strap about 30 cm long to reduce the effect of both inductance and location of the return conductor. For the same repeatability reason, the orientation of this strap was always kept in the vertical plane formed
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry
61
Grounded metal plate
Electric or magnetic field probe
50 cm
ESD simulator
Short, wide ground strap
Feed-through BNC
Copper ground plane Coaxial lead to spectrum analyzer
Figure 2.14 Experimental setup for ESD field measurements.
by the gun and the target structure. Figure 2.15 shows the results of electric and magnetic fields, after bandwidth and antenna factor correction. A few remarks are in order. 1. Comparison with other measurements: The 1-m results correlate within about 15 dB with few other reported measurements, done with similar ESD simulators on air discharge mode. 2. Field roll-off with distance: Compared to the 1-m results, the 30-cm and 10-cm results seem to show a 1/(distance)1/2 dependency instead of a 1/(distance)2 or 1/(distance)3 as one would expect in such induction (near-field) regions. In this instance, it must be kept in mind that the radiator is the whole circuit formed by the simulator and the vertical discharge structure. Seen from an antenna located at less than 1 m, this structure behaves as a long radiating wire and not a dot source or small doublet. 3. Wave impedance: Comparing E dBμV/m and H dBμA/m (see Table 2.3) shows a wave impedance E/H varying: • At 1 m from about 100 around 30 MHz to 300 above 300 MHz • At 10 cm from about 10 around 10 MHz to 150 above 300 MHz This indicates that for actual arcing on a metallic structure, the ESD generates a predominately magnetic (low-impedance) field in the induction region, tending to the theoretical 120-π wave impedance in the far-field zone. Since the changeover of near to far field is wavelenght dependent, the transition occurs at different frequencies for the various distances of the experiment; the change is very pronounced for the 10-cm case.
62
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics ESD fields at a distance of 1 m Frequency in MHz 1
3
10
30
100
300
dBmV/m/MHz and dBmA/m/MHz
E-field (vertical monopole) 100
100 E-field (horizontal)
80
80
TS
60
60 H-field (loop at maximum orientation) 40
40
TS Near field
20
20
dBmV/m/MHz and dBmA/m/MHz
120
120
Far Field 1
3
10
30
100
300
Frequency in MHz (a) ESD fields at a distance of 30 cm Frequency in MHz 10
30
120 dBmV/MHz and dBmA/m/MHz
100
300
E-field (vertical monopole)
120 100
100 E-field (horizontal) 80
TS
60
60 H-field (loop at maximum orientation)
40 20
80
40 TS
Threshold of sensitivity (TS) is shown for reference Near field 3
10
30
100
20 Far field 300
Frequency in MHz (b)
Figure 2.15 ESD field at (a) 1-m, (b) 30-m, and (c) 10-cm free-field radiation.
dBmV/MHz and dBmA/m/MHz
3
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry
63
Frequency in MHz 1
3
10
30
100
300
140
140 120
120
100
100 H-field (loop at maximum orientation)
80
80
TS
60
60 40
40
TS
20
Near field
20
1
3
10
30 100 Frequency in MHz
dBmV/m/MHz
dBmA/m/MHz
E-field (vertical monopole)
300
(c)
Figure 2.15 (continued)
Table 2.3 Average Wave Impedance of ESD Radiated Fields Frequency
3 MHz
30 MHz
Distance 1 m Zwave Aver
Near Region 100
Transition 120 160
Distance 10 cm Zwave Aver
100 MHz
300 MHz Far Region 317
Near Region 14
40
158
500 MHz
Transition Region 178
Stating that the field is predominately magnetic near the discharge path may be surprising. It is a common belief that ESD, being electrostatic, has to be an electric field. A close look at the discharge network can clarify this: Simple field theory says that in the near-field region, low-impedance (<377 ) sources will radiate predominately magnetic fields, while high-impedance (<377 ) sources radiate predominately electric fields. The ESD simulator used was an IEC-65 (1985) type, with an internal resistance of 150 , thus behaving more as a magnetic source in near field. Will “real-life” electrostatic discharges really appear like this? Actual furniture-type discharges from large metal objects, carts, chairs, and the like
64
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
Table 2.4 Combined Results of Actual ESD Related Field, from Several Authors ESD Type and Voltage (All actual human, except 4)
Distance (m)
Peak Field E field H field
Results Normalized to 1 kV and 0.10 m
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
1.50 1.50 1 1 0.1 0.10 0.45
120 V/m 60 V/m 200 V/m 110 V/m 13 kV/m 10 A/m 11 kV/m 30 A/m 3 A/m
450 V/m/kV 150 V/m/kV 300 V/m/kV 110 V/m 2.6 kV/m 2 A/m 2.2 kV/m 6 A/m 2.7 A/m
4 kV (fastest rise time) 6 kV (slow) 7 kV (fast) 10 kV (slowest rise time) 5 kV (slow arc) (fast discharge) 6. 5 kV simulator (fast)
may exhibit dynamic impedances 10 times smaller or even less, creating more magnetic field in the near region. While human body resistance, being at least 3 times higher, will create less magnetic field. 4. Integration of the field spectrum: a rough integration over the frequency domain gives the following approximation for the time-domain E- and H -field peak amplitudes: • At 1m = 70 V/m 0.4 A/m • At 30 cm = 120 V/m 1.2 A/m • At 10 cm = 220 V/m 6 A/m A few authors (13–16) have also measured the E field during human or artificial ESD, using calibrated wide-band antennas. Their field spectrum data are close to the plots of Figure 2.15. Since they also recorded peak field values in the time domain, some other results are reproduced in Table 2.4, being well in the range with the results of our coarse integration. The last column artificially normalizes all results to 1 kV ESD and 0.10 m distance.
2.4.4. Effect of Wave Impedance on Voltages Induced in Nearby PCBs and Small Circuits In the second part of the experiment, the antennas were replaced by a PCB having a unique trace representing a loop of 10 cm × 10 cm. This trace was alternatively terminated into 1 k, open-ended, and then terminated into a short. The voltage induced was read on the spectrum analyzer, with all precautions to prevent possible pick-up by the coaxial cable.The effects of varying the far end terminating resistances is interesting in the perspective of understanding which of the H -field or E-field coupling predominates. Figure 2.16 shows the induced voltages in dBμV/MHz, the PCB being oriented tangent to wavefront. For better comprehension, Figure 2.17 shows the traditional model for a small rectangular circuit illuminated by an electromagnetic field. The E field creates a transverse voltage V2 , which appears as a
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry Frequency in MHz 3
10
30
100
100
C
300
110 100
Z
90
90 Ground 80
80 A or B 70 60
dBmV/MHz
110
1
70
1
3
10
30
100
60
300
Frequency in MHz A : with Zfar end = 1 kΩ B : with Zfar end = ∞ (open)
in all cases Znear end (Receptor) = 50 Ω
C : with Zfar end = 0 (short) Calculated voltage based on H-field coupling only Calculated voltage based on E-field coupling only
Figure 2.16 Broadband voltage induced in a 100-cm2 PCB run located 10 cm from the ESD path, parallel to wave front (PCB not oriented for maximum H -field interception).
1 V1 = −
Zwire
h
Z1
df dt
Z2 2
Vx E
l′
q H
Figure 2.17 Traditional model for voltages induced in a small circuit illuminated by an EM field.
65
66
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
high-impedance source (current source) with an open-circuit voltage: V2 = E.2l
π cos θ cos α λ
(2.6)
where θ = angle between the E field and the direction of propagation α = angle between the plane of the loop and the direction of propagation λ = wavelength Given the 50- input of the “victim” receptor end (spectrum analyzer), a high impedance on the far end, like 1 k or ∞, will double the available transverse voltage, while a shorted end will nullify it. In contrast, the H field creates a longitudinal voltage V1 appearing as a low-impedance source (voltage source) with a value: V1 = −
dφ = −ωBlh dt
(2.7)
Here the effect of varying impedances is totally different. The voltage Vx across the receptor end is V1(H coupling) =
Z2 Z1 + Z2 + Zwiring
(2.8)
In our experiment, Z2 = 50 and Zwiring = 0.1 + j ω(0.4 μH). A highimpedance Z, on the far end, will nullify the magnetically induced voltage. A short circuit on the far end will maximize it. In Figure 2.16 the curve C corresponds to the far end being shorted. Therefore, the electrical contribution is minimum while the magnetic contribution is enhanced. The flat portion of the voltage spectrum corresponds to the domain where the H field decreases like 1/F [as seen in Fig. 2.15(c)], while at the same time the coupling coefficient increases like F . Above 10 MHz, the wiring impedance in Eq. (2.8) starts to create series insertion loss, causing less and less voltage available at the 50- end. Finally, above 150–200 MHz, the H -field spectrum itself decreases like 1/F 2 , causing the available voltage to collapse even more rapidly. By comparison, the values for magnetically induced voltage using Eqs. (2.7) and (2.8), or the graphical method (17) are also plotted in Figure 2.16. They are in fair agreement with the measured data. Curves A and B of Figure 2.16 correspond to a high impedance on the far end, which minimizes the magnetic contribution. What is left is the electrical contribution, which is clearly one order of magnitude less than the magnetic one. This furthermore supports the previous statement that the radiation of the “standard” discharge, in the near field, tends to be predominantly magnetic. Then, the PCB was rotated 90◦ to be perpendicular to the wavefront, such as to intercept the maximum magnetic flux. The results are shown in Figure 2.18 and can be interpreted in exactly the same way as for the previous case. In this
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry
67
Frequency in MHz 3
10
30
100
110
300
110
Z C
dBmV/MHz
Ground 90
90
A
80
dBmV/MHz
100
100
80 B 70
70 60
3
10
30
100
300
60
Frequency in MHz A : with Zfar end = 1 kΩ B : with Zfar end = ∞ (open)
in all cases Znear end (Receptor) = 50 Ω
C : with Zfar end = 0 (short)
Figure 2.18 Broadband voltage induced in a 100-cm2 PCB run located 10 cm from the ESD path perpendicular to wave front (PCB intercepting maximun H field).
setup, however, the magnetic contribution is so pronounced that even with a far end termination of 1 k (curve A), it overrides the electric contribution. In fact the difference between curves A and C below 10 MHz correspond approximately to the ratio of 1000- to 50- termination. Interestingly enough, integrating the spectrum of curve C corresponds to a peak voltage of about 15 V.
2.4.5. Effect of a Typical Metallic Cabinet on ESD-Radiated Effects If instead of being plastic, the cabinet housing the electronic circuit is metallic (or metallized), the ESD field should be attenuated by the normal shielding effect of the material. Therefore, and not accounting for the external pick-up by I/O cables, shown in Figure 2.11, it seems that internal circuit boards and wiring should be fairly well protected. However, real-life enclosures are full of slots, seams, apertures, and the like, disrupting the shield integrity. Every shield discontinuity across the ESD current path will “shine” inside, with an efficiency proportional to its length compared to the half wavelength. The ESD spectrum extending up to, and sometimes above 500 MHz, any slot longer
68
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
than a few centimeters will exhibit significant leakage. To show this effect on the ESD mechanism, the “witness” PCB was placed inside a 1-mm-thick aluminum rack; to calibrate the experiment, all mating surfaces were thoroughly brushed and screwed, and the ESD gun, set to 10 kV, was discharged on all sides and especially in the seam areas. No value exceeded the sensitivity level of the test setup. Then, several typical shield imperfections were introduced by removing some of the top cover screws and inserting thin cardboard liners under the seams to simulate an ungasketed cover with ordinary manufacturing tolerances. Figure 2.19 shows the results: The induced voltage can be read up to 100 MHz, for the enhanced magnetic coupling (far end shorted), which demonstrates two points: • •
The thin seam unequivocally spoils the protection offered by the box to ESD coupling. The reradiated field inside is, once again, predominantly magnetic.
An interesting effect was also simulated: One of the threaded holes used to attach the top cover was painted and the cover was mounted using a long screw, protruding about 2.5 cm (1 inch) inside the box. The results are also shown in Figure 2.19. It seems that the screw generates a secondary arc inside, between the fillets and the inner box surface.
3
10
Frequency in MHz 30
100
40
90 dBmV/MHz
cm
50 cm
100
C
80
300
Victim PCB
100
Grounded aluminum rack
90
80
B
dBmV/MHz
1
70
70 A
60
60
1
3
10
30
100
300
Frequency in MHz A
ESD on protruding screw head, PCB terminated into 1 kΩ
B
ESD on protruding screw head, PCB terminated into short
C
ESD on vertical or horizontal seam with a forced 1 mm gap, PCB being 5 cm behind discharge point
Figure 2.19 Voltage induced on the 10-cm × 10-cm PCB trace housed in an aluminum rack.
2.4. Coupling Mechanisms of ESD Pulse into the Victim’s Circuitry
69
As formerly shown in Figure 2.11, this radiated field from the ESD pulse has therefore two effects: 1. It couples to the inner circuits of the machine: circuits boards, flat cables, discrete wiring. 2. It also exists outside, causing external cable pick-up, all around the ESD source, and therefore couples into the external signal and power conductors. Starting in 1995, very fast digital sampling oscilloscopes became widely available, with analog bandwidths greater than 1 GHz, along with ESD generators having fast 0.7–1 ns calibrated rise times. Several authors, including this one, using miniature field probes, did more experiments. Some are reported in Appendix F, with results generally in line with the ones just described, accounting for the wider available frequency range.
2.4.6. Common Impedance Coupling with an ESD Finally, another coupling mechanism, generally of second order, has to do with common impedance pollution (Fig. 2.20). Even if they are conductive, metal or metallized parts have a certain RF impedance. The impedance of a 1-mm-thick steel plate for a 1-ns rise time is 0.4 /sq. As long as the ESD current is concentrated on the exterior side, the ZI longitudinal voltage has little influence, thanks to the skin effect. But as soon as metal-to-metal assembly exists, like spot-welding, riveting, or even tightly screwed joints, there is a strong local increase of the longitudinal impedance. Another example would be a metallized plastic, whose conductive paint cannot match a real metal barrier. For instance, the resistance of some nickel or graphite paints range from 1 to 10 /sq. For a 10-A ESD current, this corresponds to an instantaneous ground shift of 10–100 V, respectively, between A and B.
lESD
A Z increase
Z
B Actual Ideal (Skin depth for steel = 10 μm @ 1 ns)
Figure 2.20 Common impedance coupling caused by the ESD current.
70
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
Two electronic subassemblies having their signal reference (0 V) grounded at these points will be submitted to this common mode voltage.
2.5. RESPONSE OF VICTIM CIRCUITS AND TYPE OF ERRORS So far, we have evaluated the peak amplitude of voltages induced into victim circuits illuminated by the ESD pulse. In many cases, the amplitudes were far above the logic thresholds, so an erroneous change in logic status was expected. However, the induced transient is extremely short and it must be compared, on a time scale, to the alternating current (ac) noise immunity ot the victim logic (Fig. 2.21). For instance, a bipolar gate of the TTL-Low-power Shottky (TTL-LS) scheme with 7 ns switching speed has a worst-case dc noise margin of 0.4 V (0.8 V typ.) for a junction temperature of 85◦ C. If the noise pulse is shorter than 7 ns, it takes more amplitude to trigger the gate, that is, to provide the nanojoules that the gate needs to operate. As shown on the curve, the faster the logic, the more vulnerable it is to ESD induced pulses. One could also compare the frequency spectrum of ESD with the various bandwidths of CMOS, TTL, ac, and so forth (Fig. 2.22). The slow CMOS [Fig. 2.22(a)] is no longer used in new developments and is shown for reference to emphasize the fact that slow technologies can be efficiently out-of-band filtered against ESD. Applications requiring rise times < 3 ns cannot be error-protected by simple filtering, since most of the ESD spectrum is present in their useful bandwidth.
5
V τ
Volts
3
OS HCM ACT
4
2
CMOS standard
1 STTL
mi typ n TTL
ECL .3 .5
1
2 3 5
Typical induced pulse width (personnel)
10
30
100
Typical induced ESD pulse width (furniture)
τ in ns
Figure 2.21 Noise immunity of logic families versus pulse width.
2.5. Response of Victim Circuits and Type of Errors
10 Ref 0 dB
71
A 100 ns t
1 ns
−20 dB
−40 dB
A
10 kHz
30
100 kHz 300
1 MHz
3
B
10 MHz 30 100 MHz 300
C D
1 GHz
3
10 GHz
Frequency
Figure 2.22 Time and frequency aspects of the current from a 10-A/1-ns human body ESD pulse, compared to typical logic bandwidths: (a) slow CMOS, no longer used in new developments; (b) HC and HCT; (c) ac and ACT; (d) Bi-CMOS.
An important aspect to take into consideration is the coupling factor by which the ESD transient induces a parasitic voltage. Except for the cases where the discharge is directly impressed on the victim circuit, the coupling factor is a time (or frequency) dependent term: the induced voltage is not a replica of the ESD waveform but its derivative. Thus, the duration of the induced spike will be approximately equal to the rise time of the ESD current (the time during which the derivative dφ/dt exists). This is shown in Figure 2.23(a). Note also the sign of the voltage Vi , which is the opposite to the sign of the field change: Of course, in terms of the actual polarity of the induced noise, this sign will depend on the orientation of the victim circuit. In Section 1.3, we did say that depending on the nature of the triboelectric materials that created the electrostatic charge, the ESD pulse can be positive or negative. A polarity reversal in the ESD pulse would create a corresponding reversal in the induced noise: A typical logic gate is susceptible to a positive-going level when it is in a LOW input (logic 0) state, and susceptible to a negative-going level when it is in a HIGH input (logic 1) state. But it is not always so: Some critical entries such as Reset, Watchdog, and the like can be normally at a HIGH level, activated by a LOW level. Therefore, it makes sense to perform an ESD test with both polarities: Depending on what the logic circuits are doing at the
72
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics (b) Furniture
(a) Personnel IESD
IESD
time
HESD =
1 2πd
time
HESD time
VInduced =
−d∅ dt
time VInduced
time
time
τr personnel
τr furniture
Example: 10 kV personnel, 10 A peak, 1ns. Open voltage induced in 1 cm2 circuit area, 10 cm from discharge
Example: 2.5 kV furnlture, 50 A, τr = 15 ns Open voltage induced in 1 cm2 circuit area, 10 cm from discharge 0.7 V
7 mV 2 volts
1.2V 1 ns
A
12.5 ns
B
Figure 2.23 Comparison of induced voltages from normal human body and furniture ESD, showing influence of time derivatives.
time of the ESD event, the equipment under test could be more vulnerable to one polarity than the other. Figure 2.23(b) shows the same cascade of couplings for a furniture discharge. Since the rate of change of the ESD current, in amperes/nanoseconds is generally less than for personnel, it seems that the threat is less severe: however, the rise time being much longer (e.g., 15 ns), the induced spike is also longer and could exceed the dc noise margin of most logics: This is why, among other things, a furniture discharge can be a more threatening kind of ESD.
2.5.1. Influence of Circuit Impedances In most cases where the ESD event is causing a high peak current, we have seen that the strongest contributor to induced noise is the magnetic field: Consequently,
2.5. Response of Victim Circuits and Type of Errors −
+
ZW
VL
Vi
ZS
73
ZL
Iinduced
VL = Vi
ZL | ZS | + | ZW | + | ZL |
ZS ZL
CMOS
TTL
Output low
150–500
30
Output high
150–500
150
1 MΩ /7 pF
3-5 kΩ/5 pF
Input
Figure 2.24 Influence of victim’s circuit impedances on coupled voltage.
the induced voltage will appear in series in the circuit (Fig. 2.24). The resulting voltage at the victim component input will be Vdiff = Vi
ZL ZL + Zs + Zw
(2.9)
where ZL = input impedance of victim component (e.g., logic gate, op-amp) Zs = source impedance of driver Zw = impedance of wiring Since, for obvious reasons, the victim input generally has a higher impedance than the signal source, Eq. (2.9) shows that most of the noise will appear at the victim input. For the same reason, this usual impedance configuration will cause the noise coupled by the electric field to be less a problem since it will appear differentially across the line, seeing the parallel combination of ZL shunted by ZS . In any case, two other considerations may prevail: •
•
Above a certain level (50–100 V for some ESD-sensitive technologies) even if the device is not triggering a malfunction, some permanent overstress may have occurred. Certain technologies, such as CMOS, exhibit a latch-up mechanism if the input becomes more positive than Vcc or goes more negative than the 0-V reference. In these conditions the parasitic PNP and NPN transistors within the device behave like an SCR (Silicon-Controlled Rectifier) that is fired. Even once the pulse has gone, the SCR stays in conduction. The current is limited only by the external loads and can lead the device to destruction since the parasitic switch can only be defused by powering off the supply.
74
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
2.5.2. Specific Disturbance Created by the Hand/Metal Initial Spike We have shown that in the case of a personnel discharge with the hand/metal scenario (person holding a key, a coin, tool, wearing a ring, wrist bracelet), a very narrow “precursor” discharge takes place. Actual 10–90% rise time ranges from 100 ps to 1 ns, with a fall time more or less in the same range. Remembering that, locally, the H -field pulse has the same shape as the current, the dH /dt field derivative is the replica of the current derivative. Therefore this sharp current spike can cause significant induced voltage in exposed circuitry. For instance, assume a victim loop at 10 cm from the discharging finger, with an 8-kV ESD voltage; taking Ipeak = 30 A and t = 0.7 ns, we get from Eq. (2.3): I Acm2 Vi = 2 td =
2 × 30 Acm2 = 8.5 V/cm2 0.7 × 10
Clearly, this short initial spike can be a bigger threat than the subsequent, longer pulse. This peculiar aspect has been a growing concern for the manufactures of ESD generators and the test engineers using them (17). As we will see in Chapter 4, a substantial uncertainty in ESD test results can be attributed to this precursor spike, which is not always produced the same way by different brands of generators.
2.5.3. Errors/Malfunctions Induced in Analog Devices So far, we have emphasized the ESD effect on logic circuits because of their inherent ability to respond to a unique, isolated short pulse. However, although the likelihood of an ESD disturbing analog circuits is low, because of their generally limited bandwidth and the long time averaging of their response, the possibility exist. Consider this example: If an ESD discharge is made in the room while an ordinary radio set or audio-amplifier is turned on, a popping noise will be heard in the loudspeaker. Therefore, although limited to a few tens kHz passband, the IF circuits and amplifiers did pick up some ESD noise. This can be visualized in the frequency domain, by considering the broadband spectrum of an ESD-induced glitch, a portion of which will fall within the bandwidth of the analog (tuned or baseband) device. This can be visualized also in the time domain by considering that the short-width, high-amplitude pulse will be integrated through the long time constant of the analog device. The pulse will stretch over a longer time, with less amplitude, but yet enough to initiate a circuit response since the threshold of analog amplifiers is usually very low (Fig. 2.25).
2.6. Prediction of Actual ESD-Induced Error, Fast Approximation Method
75
Frequency response of a tuned circuit ESD induced noise
ESD spectrum
Time response of analog Bp
Resulting pulse Frequency
Frequency domain
Time Time domain
Figure 2.25 Conceptual view of the response of an analog device to ESD noise.
Besides these dynamic aspects, low-speed analog devices can present another inherent problem, because of their typically very high input impedance. In the presence of an electrostatic field (without a discharge), the input(s) can raise to any voltage, depending on the divider network formed by the electrostatic source-to-device capacitance and the device-to-ground capacitance. Solutions to this problem, more a static than an actual ESD issue, are presented in Chapter 5.
2.6. PREDICTION OF ACTUAL ESD-INDUCED ERROR, FAST APPROXIMATION METHOD The following, expedited method is using the simple H -field time derivative of Eq. (2.3), assuming a regular slope for the peak ESD current. A more elaborate method, based on frequency spectrum considerations, and cascading all the frequency-dependent coupling mechanisms is described in Appendix E. The principle of frequency approach for a complete vulnerability prediction, very classical in EMI (18), is summarized in Figure 2.26. Since these parameters, such as induction, half-wave length resonances, shielding attenuation, and out-of-band rejection, are best described in frequency domain, a more organized approach to the solution can be made. On the other hand, time domain offers the advantage of a straightforward solution whose accuracy is generally sufficient. In contrast, frequency domain requires some more complex transformations. Example The ESD scenario of our application is shown in Figure 2.27. A personnel ESD occurs near a flat cable running running close from the ESD “drain path.” The cabinet structure is metallic, but no integral shielding is expected from the cover (they could be plastic). The ESD is a severe, 8-kV hand/metal-type discharge as simulated by IEC 61000-4-2 or similar specification. The standard current waveform for such 8-kV discharge is sketched, but we have overlaid a simplified envelope, which we will use in our quick calculation.
76
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics
IESD peak
Volts induced per Gauss = wBS
BG/MHz
B (or H) peak
× τr
τr
ESD waveform (time domain)
Induced V/MHz
=
F1
Frequency
Calculation of magnetic field (time domain)
Frequency
T→F conversion
Victim input rejection
×
F2
Pass
F3
Fcut-off
Frequency
V/MHz
=
Stop
Frequency
F1 F2 F3 Frequency
Figure 2.26 Frequency domain aspects of a complex ESD coupling.
PCB
#1 f 0vReframe to
Ipk = 30 A
Triangular approximation of actual waveform
25 cm
IESD 60 ns B
PC
#2
ef 0vR frame to
4 cm 8 cm
Ins Simplified
−5V
120 ns
600 V Induced voltage into (25 x 4)cm2 loop Actual t
Figure 2.27 ESD scenario for the prediction example of Section 2.6.
The victim element of our concern is a 25-cm ribbon cable interconnection between the backplanes of two stacked racks. For such a short link, the two interconnected daughter cards are simply using high-speed CMOS (HCMOS) logic interfaces with the following characteristics: DC noise margin (worst case): 0.7 V Logic rise time: 4 ns Single-ended (nondifferential) drivers and receivers
2.6. Prediction of Actual ESD-Induced Error, Fast Approximation Method
77
Assuming that the hand-held tool (or key) is touching a metal member at 8-cm from the vertical cable chute, with the discharge current running along this frame edge, returning to the source by the ground plane, is there a risk of error by ESD field coupling? Note that the signal ground (0-V reference) is connected to the chassis ground at both ends. The center of the loop can be averaged at a distance d = 8 cm + 4 cm/2 = 10 cm. The bulk induced voltage is given by Eq. (2.3): Vi = 2(I A cm2 /td) = 2 × 30 × 100 cm2 /(1.10) = 600 V This is the common-mode voltage appearing in series in the loop. Since the PCBs signal references (0 V) are grounded at both ends, the rejection of common mode (CM) noise is extremely poor, for such a nondifferential link. In addition, CMOS having a high input impedance, virtually the full CM voltage will appear at the input end (see Section 2.5.1) of the victim circuit. However, H-CMOS offers a somewhat limited bandwidth∗ compared to the spectral occupancy of the induced pulse, considering that the duration of the induced spike is approximately equal to the rise time of the ESD current. An attenuation due to bandwidth limitation must be accounted for: Victim’s impulse BWidth ESD Spectral BWidth ESD rise time ≈ Victim logic time constant
Bwidth rejection =
Finally, the equivalent voltage seen by the HCMOS input will be 600 V
1 ns 4 ns
= 150 V
In conclusion: •
•
∗ The
The bulk 600-V transient impressed on the wires versus ground could be damaging with sensitive ICs. But we can assume that this is at least a Class 2 device (see discussion of component sensitivity classes in Chapter 3) with ≥ 2-kV ESD immunity to human ESD, so it will not suffer permanent damage. With 150 V, the equivalent input voltage is 200 times the 0.7-V dc noise margin. Logic errors will occur. Notice that the slower part of the pulse induces also −5 V on the same loop, which is not totally innocuous to the logic, and the solution must be able to reduce the two effects.
impulse bandwidth of a first-order low-pass circuit is approximated by its 7-dB bandwidth.
78
Chapter 2 Effects of ESD on Electronics •
Any attempt to solve the problem by “opening the ground loop,” that is, floating either one of the PCBs from chassis ground would be useless: For a nanosecond rise time, the parasitic capacitance of the PCB represents a rather low impedance, behaving as a virtual short.
2.7. REMARKS ON THE ACTUAL CURRENT PATHS AND ASSOCIATED RADIATION Although the current waveform, as measured on artificial targets, which are basically discrete resistors, appears as a unique pulse, it results actually from the combination of two currents, which in real-life ESD do not follow the same path, as visible in Figure 1.29. 1. The narrow spike i2 is confined to the limited hand-to-machine zone and its corresponding capacitance. This current is a radiating element of limited length, approximately 10–30 cm long, depending on the incident angle of the finger, or the ESD test electrode. This “cone of influence” is well described by Pommerenke (17). Therefore, the “infinite wire” model used in the previous example can only be applied to the victim’s elements shorter than 30 cm and not farther than ≈ 30 cm from the discharge point. So, as explained in Section 2.5.2, this precursor spike is a major threat, but only within its limited 3D boundary of influence. 2. The bulk of the current pulse i1 with rise time of 5–15 ns, depending on the inductance of the return path, runs along the entire machine-to-ground path. Taking a typical height for human torso/arm, the path length represents a one-way trip of about 1.50 m, so the “long wire model” is perfectly applicable up to 1 m around the discharge path. The outcome of this is that a more accurate calculation should take into account the two currents i2 and i1 with their respective shapes and paths and combine their effects on the exposed victim circuit.
2.8. PERSONNEL OR FURNITURE ESD: WHICH ONE IS WORSE? From what we have seen (Fig. 2.23), it looks like the furniture ESD, due to higher current and resultant magnetic field, is the biggest threat. However, consider this: 1. Furniture ESD will only occur at some points of the victim equipment. Some other areas will never be touched by a moving cart, chair, and the like. 2. Furniture ESD usually exhibit much lower voltages than personnel: Therefore recessed parts and metal parts or cicuits behind a plastic barrier will never be zapped by a furniture ESD because the voltage does not reach
References
79
the breakdown value of the air gap or plastic barrier. On the contrary, a 15- or 20-kV personnel ESD will reach by arcing these remote points. Therefore, as already said in Chapter 1, it seems that a complete ESD simulation should address both types of discharges.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.
Yenni, D. Huntsman, J. and Mueller, G. 3M Static Products Documentation, 1995. Greason, W. ESD Damage in Electronics. Research Study Press, Letchworth, England, 1990. ESD with Passive Components, EMC Technology Magazine, Nov., 1988, p. 45. Vinson, J, Bernier, J., and Croft, G. ESD Design & Analysis Handbook. Kluwer Amsterdam, 2003. Verhage, K. Compound Level ESD Testing. μ Electronics Reliability Journal , 1998. Fukuda, K. VLSI Protection, HBM and MM. EOS/ESD Symposium, 1988. Kelly, M, et al. Comparison of ESD Models for CMOS. EOS/ESD Symposium, 1995. Boissieres, F. Electrical Interface Presentation. ST MiCroElectronics Corp. 2008. Allen, R. How to Set Up an ESD Control Program. Evaluation Engineering Magazine, Feb., 1999. Petrizio. Electrical Overstress vs Device Geometry. EOS/ESD Symposium, Denver, 1979. Branberg, G. ESD and CMOS Logic. EOS/ESD Symposium, Denver, 1979. Denson, D. ESD Testing of Advanced Schottky TTL. EOS/ESD Symposium, Orlando, FL, 1982. Kozlowski, A. Barski, M. and Stulchly, S. Characterization of ESD Tester. IEEE/EMC Symposium, Washington, DC, 1990, p. 270–273. Wilson, P.-Ma, M. Fields Radiated by ESD. IEEE/EMC Transactions, Feb., 1991, p. 10– 18. Pommerenke, D., and Aidam, M. ESD Waveform, Field and Current of Human & Simulated ESD. Journal of Electrostatics, Vol. 38, 1996, Nov. 1996 p. 33– 51. Smith, D. Unusual Forms of ESD. EOS/ESD Symposium, 1999, Orlando, FL. Pommerenke, D., and Aidam. To What Extent Do Contact Mode and Indirect ESD Test Reproduce Reality? EOS/ESD Symposium, 1995, San Diego CA, p. 101– 109. White, D., and Mardiguian, M. EMI Control Methodology & Procedures. ICT, Gainesville, VA, 1989.
Chapter
3
Principal ESD Specifications Since the discovery of the ESD threat to electronic equipment, several testing specifications have been established by international and professional bodies. Although they more or less address the same phenomenon, the values recommended by the different organizations vary widely, depending on the type of application with which they deal. Some call for a specific rise time, some others do not. This chapter describes briefly the esssential ESD specifications in use. No details are given on test methods since these will be covered in Chapter 4 for the major ESD test specifications for components and equipment. The standards and specifications reviewed hereafter are only those exclusively dedicated to ESD testing or static control. There are hundreds of other specifications, practices and the like that cover various industries or families of products where a simple section or paragraph deals with ESD. They have, of course, not been listed here. For most of them, they follow or refer to the major ESD documents presented hereafter. Electrostatic discharge specifications can be classified into two simple categories: component level (1, 2) and machine/system level:
1. At component level : They specify the device’s (integrated and discrete components) immunity to static discharges, to characterize the risk of immediate or latent failures. It is essentially a test of the unpowered device survival, in a manufacturing or servicing environment. 2. At machine/system level : They specify the immunity of electronic equipment to ESD-induced errors or alterations. This is a survival issue as well as a test for functional integrity of the powered equipment, in a user-type environment, Table 3.1 gives a recapitulation of the various types of ESD specifications presently in effect. The test voltage is labeled “maximum” because many
Electrostatic Discharge, Third Edition, by Michel Mardiguian Copyright © 2009 the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
80
81
ECMA 237 (from TC20) SAE J1113 Part13 & ISO 10.605 (Automobile) MIL-Std 1541 Spacecraft STANAG 4235, 4239 (NATO Std)
For Equipment IEC 61000.4.2 (former IEC 801-2) ANSI C.63-16
IEC 61.340-5.1 and 5.2 replaces former 1000.15.1
DOD Std 1686 & Handbook 263 EIA/JEDEC Test Method 5.1 HBM Test Method 5.2 MM Test Method 5.3 CDM
For Devices MIL-Std 883
Category
4–8 kV (contact) 4–25 kV (Air) 10 kV & more 25 kV 300 kV
Up to 8 kV (contact) 15,000 V (Air) Up to 8 kV (contact) 15,000 V (Air) 2 k/330 pF or 330 /150 pF Arc source 500 /500 pF 1 /1 μH/1 nF
330 /150 pF
330 /150 pF
15 /0.5 μH/200 pF 30 /30 nH/10 pF
Up to 800 V Up to 2 kV N.A
100 pF/1500
100 pF/1500
Discharge Network
Up to 8 kV
2 kV(Class 1) up to 8 kV N.A.
Max. Voltage Pol. +/−
Table 3.1 Summary of Current and Proposed ESD Standards
Mandatory, part of EMC regulatory compliance Similar to IEC, with differences in simulator and test procedure Follows IEC 61000.4.2 Different test for modules and for vehicle install. Network depends on application Personnel Helicopter discharge
ESD control program ESD protection guidelines Used for device sensitivity evaluation (nonmandatory) (theoretically, R = 0) R,L,C parameters may vary depending on IC package Antistatic control procedures Approach similar to MIL-Std
Human Body Model (HBM)
Comments
82
Chapter 3 Principal ESD Specifications
specifications regulate the amplitude in function of the type of environment (controlled or not) where the product is marketed.
3.1. ESD TEST SPECIFICATIONS FOR DEVICE SENSITIVITY 3.1.1. MIL-Std 883 The Military Standard 883 (2006 revision) is a voluminous document describing all reliability tests (electrical, mechanical, etc.) for microcircuits. ESD test method 3015.7 is only a tiny portion. It clearly excludes electroexplosive devices (EEDs)∗ and ammunitions. The highlights are as follows: •
•
•
According to the results, the device under test (DUT) is classified into the following categories: • Class 1: sensitivity of 2 kV or less • Class 2: sensitivity of 2–4 kV • Class 3: sensitivity of 4 kV or more The test pulse is generated via a 100-pF, 1500- discharge network, typical of the human body model (HBM). Maximum rise time is 15 ns. Figure 3.1 shows the basic test circuit, with an example of the current of a 2-kV test pulse. It is clear that this test pulse is significantly less severe than most actual personnel discharges (see Chapter 1). One reason is that ESD test of devices is generally aimed at IC factories, where a minimum of antistatic precautions are expected. The test pulse is applied: • All pins together vs. case = (+) and (−) • All combinations of input vs. ground, output vs. ground, Vcc vs. ground, for (+) and (−) pulse
1 to 3000 MΩ
HV supply
1500 Ω Ipeak : 1.33 A for 2 kV Test
Bounceless switch 100 pF∗ ∗Insulation resistance > 1010 Ω
T50% = 100 ns Device under test (DUT)
t tr = 15 ns
Figure 3.1 Test circuit for MIL-Std 883, with a 2-kV test pulse shown as example.
∗ ESD immunity of EEDs is generally covered in specific equipment specifications, such as MIL-Std 1512 (USAF), requiring a 25-kV pulse via a 500-pF/5-k network.
83
3.1. ESD Test Specifications for Device Sensitivity •
The calibration is checked via a current probe clipped on a short replacing the DUT. Notice that the simulator behaves as a current source only for DUT resistances 1500 .
3.1.2. EIA/JEDEC and ESD Association Test Methods These device test methods cover all the possible variations of ESD events, arranged in three test setups: •
•
•
ESD Test Method S.5.1 (HBM): The human body model is the oldest and most widespread method. The test circuit is similar to MIL-Std 883. Test voltage is up to 8 kV, eventually 15 kV for harsh environment applications. ESD Test Method S.5.2 (MM): The need for a machine model was urged by the findings that robots and automatic chips or wafer handling tools could generate strong ESD (see discussion of furniture discharge in Chapter 1). Typical device test circuit and waveform are shown in Figure 3.2 ESD Test Method S.5.3 (CDM): The charged device model is an attempt to replicate actual situations of device handling or storage in manufacturing/servicing areas (see discussion in Chapter 2 on, direct discharge to components). The test setup, simulating a device discharging on itself, is shown in Figure 3.3. A variation of this test uses the socketed device model (SDM).
None of the test voltages is a mandatory criteria but rather a way to characterize various devices, making the users aware of their susceptibility and eventually apply adequate protection measures. In general, manufacturers or their clients set their own acceptable failure criteria. For comparison of the respective threats posed by these HBM, MM, and CDM tests, see Appendix A.
1 to 1000 MΩ
HV Supply
(Theory : 0 Ω 0.5 μH Low R Practically: few ohms)
200 pF
DUT
I peak : 7 A for 400 V Test
Shunt for measuring I t 60 ns
Figure 3.2 ESD test circuit for Machine Model (MM).
84
Chapter 3 Principal ESD Specifications
DUT Dielectric C 1 to 1000 MΩ
Charging armature
Example : 7 A peak for 500 V Test Rd = 30 Ω C = 10 pF Lp = 20 nH
Rd Lp
I measur.
HV supply
Figure 3.3 ESD test circuit for Charged Device Model (CDM). The DUT in “dead bug” position is charged through its self-capacitance and the charging plate. The device is then discharged on itself.
3.2. ESD SPECIFICATIONS FOR EQUIPMENT IMMUNITY 3.2.1. International Standard IEC 61000-4-2 Among the many standards and proposals existing in the industry, the IEC 61000-4-2 has the stature of an international reference. Initially released in January 1985 as IEC 801-2, it was at first intended for industrial control equipment and used the simple arc discharge. In 1990 a definite improvement was introduced by imposing a high voltage (HV) relay for triggering the discharge. Since then, it has continuously evolved into a very complete—and complex—document, whose important practical contents will be described in Chapter 4. Several test severities are recommended, according to the class of environment: Relative
Discharge Test Voltage
Severity Level
Humidity %
Floor Material
Contact
Air
1 2 3 4 Xa
≥ 35 ≥ 10 ≥ 50 ≥ 10
Antistatic Antistatic Synthetic Synthetic
2 4 6 8
2 4 8 15
a X is a special “open choice” category for specific environments, with levels that can be between or above the others.
Application of discharge is normally done by direct contact to the target zone. For the recessed areas that cannot be physically touched by the probe, but are still reachable by arc, the air discharge (similar to the early version) is still required. For equipments having no, or very little, metal structure, an indirect ESD test is applied via a coupling plane placed at 10 cm from the test item. Although its prime scope was directed to industrial controls, this standard has been rapidly generalized and adopted by the European Community under the
3.2. ESD Specifications for Equipment Immunity
85
title EN (European Norm), legally mandatory for any equipment marketed in Europe, as part of the general (EMC) electro magnetic compatibility compliance. In many areas for which it was not intended in the first place, such as medical devices, public transportation, metrology, and the like, this test method has been also found convenient and is called for in various product specifications. Recognizing the wide variety of equipments to be tested, and the diversity of operations they perform, this IEC standard does not establish specific criteria for success/failures but recommends categorizing the severity of ESD effects as follows: • • •
ESD ESD ESD ESD
causes a random but repeatable event. causes a consistent and permanent malfunction, suggesting that after is applied, an error condition persists. causes permanent hardware damage or loss of data.
3.2.2. ANSI C.63-16, ESD Test Methods, and Criteria for Electronic Equipment This standard is, in general, similar to the IEC 61.1000-4-2, this being due to the fact that many experts in the EMC community, worldwide, are sharing their views in the preparation of the two documents. Yet, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standard contains substantial differences on the test procedures and pass/fail criteria, the presentation of which are better organized and justified. The initial rise time for the contact discharge, being 0.4–0.6 ns, is faster than the IEC, which means an IEC successfull test could eventually fail if repeated with ANSI instrumentation. The early versions of the ANSI ESD standard did mention the furniture discharge test, but this requirement has been suppressed in the more recent versions.
3.2.3. ESD Immunity for Automobile Electronics, SAE J1113- 13 and ISO 10605 Although it generally follows the IEC 61000-4-2 test principles, ESD standard for automobiles is using different R,C discharge networks, taking into account the specifics of vehicle environment. Since the occupant is basically inside a metallic envelope, isolated from ground, with many synthetic parts (upholstery, dashboard, seats, etc.), the body model capacitance is 330 pF for inside elements that are touchable by the normal user or eventually a repairman. For example: • • • •
Radio and audio/video entertainment devices Power door locks and window switches Power seat control Blinkers and multifunctions levers
86
Chapter 3 Principal ESD Specifications • • •
Headlight switches Steering wheel and column Side mirror controls
This includes accessible connector pins such as diagnostic connector socket, dashboard removable devices, and the like. Severity ranges from 4 to 8 kV for contact discharge and up to 25 kV for air discharges, depending on the critical aspect of a temporary or permanent malfunction. Complete airbag systems, including EEDs, are always tested in the most severe configurations. Corresponding test methods are briefly described in Chapter 4.
3.2.4. MIL-Std 1541, ESD Immunity Requirements for Space Systems As for airborne equipment, systems installed in satellites and other space vehicles are exposed to severe ESD threats. Based on NASA experience (3), and depending on which part of the vessel and which phase of the flight is concerned (lauching, stages separation, orbital, galactic trajectory, etc.), several generators are recommended: HV coil, flat plate, and direct capacitor injection: • •
Test voltages range from kV up to 300 kV, available energy from nanojoules to hundreds of millijoules. Source capacitances vary from nanofarads to hundreds of nanofarads, with peak discharge currents from 1 A to kA.
3.3. ANTISTATIC CONTROL PROCEDURES Apart from the strict device/equipment testing, a vast number of standards and recommendations have been published by the DOD and industry associations, regarding handling, packaging, grounding, and antistatic material evaluations. These ESD avoidance programs include also quality control (QC), people awareness, and educational aspects.
3.3.1. Military Domain: MIL-Std 1686 and MIL 263 Handbook The MIL-Std 1686 (1995 Rev.), ESD Control Program, is deemed to be a complementary document to MIL 883, dealing uniquely with electronic components, EEDs being namely excluded. In the past, the two standards did not cross reference each other, and the sensitivity classes were not harmonized, leaving some doubt as to whether or not they were part of a concerted strategy. This has been fixed, and the two documents are now coordinated.
3.3. Antistatic Control Procedures
87
MIL-Std1686 is a very complete document, including antistatic recommendations and control plan for parts, assemblies, and devices. Its main contents are as follows: • • • •
Requirements for device ESD test, per MIL 883, with identification/tagging of sensitive (ESDS) parts. Details of test plan with minimum number of pulses, pass/fail criteria, and failure analysis. Parts that have been submitted to ESD characterization should not be considered as deliverable items. ESD is NOT a burn-in kind of test. Obligation to vendors/subcontractors of military equipment to implement full ESD control at manufacturing, storage, delivery, and maintenance levels. This includes periodic audits of percent yields.
In later versions, the document also requires that assemblies and equipments meet the 2- or 4-kV immunity of industry standard IEC 61000-4-2. A recent trend of military agencies to standardization and paperwork reduction seems to indicate that MIL 1686 will be withdrawn and replaced by the corresponding ANSI/ESD S.20-20. The MIL 263 Handbook is an ESD control guide, helping in the successfull implementation of the 1686 ESD control program. Not a mandatory requirement, it covers: • • •
Basics of ES discharge and device failure mechanisms Implementation of protected areas, workstations, and static-free harware (handling, shipping etc.) Design tips and integrated protection networks for IC immunity
3.3.2. Industry Standards for Static Control Programs In addition to device testing, the ESD Association (accredited by ANSI) publishes technical reports and develops ESD standards, covering testing of antistatic materials. The EIA (Electronic Industry Association) and its related JEDEC (Joint Electronics Development Engineering Council) publish standards and procedures, such as EIA-625, for ESD-sensitive device handling. The international IEC 61340 Parts 1 to 5 (endorsed by the European CENELEC Comit´e Europ´een de Normalisation Electrique) provides a complete ES control strategy: • • •
Characterization of electronic components ESD sensitivity Static control procedures in factories: working areas, shipping, marking, packing, workers garments, machinery, and the like Evaluation methods and QC of antistatic materials, equipment, and working practices
88
Chapter 3 Principal ESD Specifications
Except for a few details, these standards and recommended practices are generally in line with the military documents, their technical authors often sharing their expertise among several technical Committees.
REFERENCES 1. Verhaege, K., Recommendations to Improvement of HBM Component Test Specification, EOS/ESD Symposium, 1996. 2. Sicard, E., Bendhia, S., and Ramdani, M., EMC of Integrated Circuits. Springer, New York, 2006, Chapter 5. 3. Guidelines for Controlling Spacecraft Charging Effects, NASA Tech. Report, No. 2361.
Chapter
4
ESD Diagnostics and Testing U
ntil the early 1980s, it seemed that electromagnetic interference (EMI) and ESD were two different worlds. The two worlds paralleled, and in many companies and organizations the same people were wearing the two hats—but there were still two hats. EMI susceptibility studies were checking the behavior of equipment exposed to steady electromagnetic ambient fields and power line disturbances, while ESD tests attempted to reproduce human or furniture discharges and their effect on fragile circuits. Yet, testing a product for ESD vulnerability is one of the most important, versatile, and relatively easy to perform of all the EMI tests. Thanks to its huge bandwidth, greater than 300 MHz, and to the strong field created locally, the test can reveal all at once many weak spots of an equipment: • • • • •
Vulnerable PCB layout Insufficient immunity of I/O ports Missing or improperly bonded cable shields Improperly mounted filters Missing or inadequate shielding of the housing
These defects could have taken a much longer time to detect by classical methods, such as radiated susceptibility testing, which requires a shielded/ anechoic room, a set of transmitting antennas, and a powerful amplifier. However, as simple as it may look, the foundation of sound ESD testing is, of course, an accurate, repeatable test setup. Not all ESD simulators were created equal, and the test arrangement can also introduce some severe discrepancies. The early tests of the 1970s were quite often a “hit-or-miss” game. Product designers had to be content with such foggy results as “the equipment stand 2 kV but fails at 6–8 kV,” with results that could vary depending on where, when, or by whom the test was done. Although those days are gone, an ESD test giving dependable
Electrostatic Discharge, Third Edition, by Michel Mardiguian Copyright © 2009 the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
89
90
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
results is still a hard-to-reach goal, the first stumbling block being the core of the test set: the generator.
4.1. ESD SIMULATORS: HOW THEY WORK The earliest ESD generators were quite rough, people using sometimes home-made devices from ignition coils, TV set high-voltage power supplies, piezoelectric lighters, or even high-voltage cattle prods. Since 1970, many ESD simulators (which the EMC community quickly nicknamed “guns” or “zappers”) have been marketed, the most recent ones being generally thoroughly designed. Improvments have aimed at the reproducibility of the rise time, the accuracy of high-voltage setting, and the like. These simulators are based on the simplified models of Section 1.5, with the R,C network packaged in a convenient, generally handheld, unit (Fig. 4.1). A capacitor is charged by a high-voltage dc supply, then discharged on the equipment under test (EUT), through a determined resistance. One armature of the high-voltage capacitor is connected to the injection probe, generally shaped like a finger. The other armature is connected to the reference ground or any desired return path. To perform ideally, an ESD simulator should have the following features: •
A variable ESD voltage, easy to set∗ with an accurate readout (10% is an absolute minimum, with 5% being recommended). The setting can be continuous or by 100- to 300-V increments. Rch
Rd
≥ 1 MΩ
HV
Cd
EUT or calibration target
Figure 4.1 ESD simulator basic schematic. ∗
A problem exists as to how this voltage is monitored. Simple simulator designs set the capacitor charging voltage, then disconnect its hot side from the high-voltage supply (this is the isolated capacitor scheme) before the probe is discharged. This makes it difficult to retain a good voltage accuracy more than few seconds since the capacitor charge will constantly bleed-off, especially as the probe is approaching the target. To some extent, this happens also with real human body ESD. Other simulators monitor constantly the tip voltage (regulated high-voltage scheme) to keep it constant until the actual discharge. This gives a good repeatability, at the expense of an artificially severe condition, whereas the charge is constantly fed into the tip, even during the milliseconds preceding the discharge.
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work • • •
•
• • •
• • • • • •
• • • •
•
91
A selectable positive or negative discharge. The ability to deliver up to 3.7 A/kV in a shorted output mode, with 0.5to 1-ns rise times. Several (at least two) discharging resistors, easily interchangeable, for instance, 330–2000 for personnel and 10–50 for furniture, along with several capacitor options. The ability to generate a discharge with or without an arc (in the latter, the high voltage is applied only once the probe tip is in electrical contact with the EUT). A shot counter, such as the operator, applies a known number of discharges on each part of the EUT. A time-out device disabling the HV probe when the preselected number of shots is reached. An option of selecting a single shot or a repetitive mode, for instance, slow rate (e.g., 0.5–5 pulses/s) for formal testing and accelerated rate (20–50 pulses/s) for quick investigations. A warning (audible or visible) signal in case of aborted or sputtering discharge (restrikes). A way to bleed off smoothly the charge from the tip in case of discharge to floating parts. A ground return connection hardware that is safe, convenient, and idiot-proof. An automatic electromechanical or electronic safety latch that removes the HV from the tip when the gun is at rest. A remote control interface for unmanned operation. A filtered ac power input to avoid pollution of the ac mains, which could create false ESD problems by pulses coming through the back door (the power cord), thus yielding misleading test results. A sturdy hardware fixture for stand-mounted, instead of handheld, operation. This stand, tripod, and the like must be nonmetallic. Good portability and sturdy construction, for occasional or frequent field usage. Ease of calibration checks. A built-in, or separate quick checking device, which can be used before a new series of test to verify that no serious malfunction or component alteration has occurred. This is independent from the normal yearly calibration (1). Carefully selected components in the high-voltage section, for a long life expectancy.† Relay, resistors, capacitors, and switches must be of the
† An ordinary ESD test will easily totalize 1000–10,000 discharges applied to the entire EUT. For an EMC lab performing 50 tests/year, and adding the development test iterations, this could mean 100,000 to one million of high-voltage on/off switching per year for the discharge circuit .
92
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
high-voltage/high-frequency brand: no arcing, no creepage, minimum parasitic inductance, no bouncing. Resistances must have a low R/V voltage coefficient. Of the existing simulators available commercially, to the author’s knowledge, no one meets all these criteria, although some models have almost all of them. Differences exist among the current models, concerning the maximum voltage, the making of the RC discharge network, and the like. Variations are also found in the operator–instrument interface. The access to the various settings (voltage, polarity, air or contact discharge, preset number of shots, etc.) can make significant differences. Some simulators have very intuitive controls, while others have menu-driven options that are a real nightmare. Each manufacturer advocates his choices using arguments whose technical basis are not always clear. One must admit that, although the basic schematic is simple, the making of an ESD simulator is not. The realization faces all the difficulties of a high-voltage transient generator, compounded by the challenge of extremely short rise times. Moreover, the basic construction bears an inherent weakness: It is presumptuous to assume that an assembly of discrete capacitors, resistors, and wires will act in the same manner as the capacitance of a human body, which is distributed over a wide surface. So far only one simulator has faithfully replicated the body (or furniture) spread capacitance: This tester was the IBM Type 5800 ESD simulator, which is briefly described in Section 4.2 but no longer available to our knowledge.
4.1.1. Arc or Direct Contact Another dilemna, nowhere near to being resolved, is the following: •
•
Should the simulator replicate by all means the conditions of an actual human (or furniture) discharge, by arcing, eventually at the expense of losing some reproducibility? Should the simulator sacrifice the arc conditions and inject, without an air gap, a calibrated, repeatable pulse waveform, that will stress the EUT “as if” it were the actual event, even though the electrical mechanisms are not all there?
Indeed, the issue is one of test philosophy, and the two theories have their pros and cons.The patrons of the “with-an-arc” ESD put forward several positive aspects: Air discharge does include, naturally, all real-life arc parameters (air gap disruption, strong localized electric field near the tip, arc resistance in the path, etc.). It can also, under certain conditions, create the “precursor” phenomenon, that prearcing we have seen occurring below 6–8 kV (see Section 1.5.4). And zapping with an arc can be performed rather easily on any accessible point of the EUT, even recessed areas such as spacing between keys and the like.
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
93
The supporters of direct injection ESD have also many strong points, some being an answer to the weaknesses of “arc ESD.” For instance, the arc introduces an uncertainty because air breakdown will not reproduce itself exactly from one discharge to another, causing test conclusions that can be inaccurate. By eliminating the arc, direct contact ESD guarantees a clean, “sanitized,” easily reproducible waveform. “Not true” will argue the supporters of air discharge: Unless the target area is a clean metal zone, discharging on a painted or coated area does include an arc. Though not seen, it crosses through the paint, still creating the same uncertainty that the direct contact was deemed to eliminate. Therefore, true direct ESD can only be achieved by making a firm electrical contact on bare metal parts, protruding screws, keys and the like. For other areas, the operator must scratch or pierce the paint, then trigger the discharge, which complicates the test routine. The counterargument to this is that the so-called easier setup of the air discharge is, indeed, masking a real difficulty: regardless of the actual voltage setting on the HV dial, the arc will occur at the breakdown voltage of the air gap. In case of repeated discharges, it is the spacing of the probe tip to the discharge surface that will trigger the arc and may actually set the test voltage (Fig. 4.2). The only way to recreate actual arc ESD is to either: • •
•
Approach the EUT with the probe until an arc occurs, and keep moving to touching the target. Then move back and start all over again. Given a specified ESD voltage, set a gap slightly larger than the breakdown distance (using 13 kV/cm as a rule of thumb) and reduce the gap gradually until an arc occurs. Then retain this setting for the given test run. Monitor constantly the probe voltage instead of merely the HV supply setting. This is what some simulators do (KeyTek).
Another issue in favor of direct contact ESD is that it eliminates most of the operator’s body effects. With air discharge, the added stray capacitance of the operator may influence the test waveform, especially if he stays close to the probe. Finally, arc ESD necessitates control of the relative humidity during the test (air ionization can be influenced by the RH) while direct contact ESD is less sensitive to RH. A whole chapter could be filled with these arguments. In an attempt to clear the waters, Table 4.1 lists seven pros and cons and gives to each item a (+) or (−) score, weighted by its relative importance. Although the score unavoidably bears some subjective biasing of the author, we see that the two methods come very close. The next section will show how some typical ESD simulators have handled these conceptual problems.
94
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
?
doptimal (cm) ≅
VESD, kV 13
(a) ESD with single probe arc gap Problem: • Inaccuracy of gap setting • Different results when probe not perpendicular
(b) Improvement with a spacer • More accurate gap setting • Probe 90° to target • Does not work if target is a protruding shape: switch, key, etc. Graduations can be scaled in mm or approximate discharge voltage Contact probe
Arc setting distance (c) Further improvement The gap is set independently of contact shape and angle of approach. Relay in high-pressure bulb Enable/Disable
Rdischarge
HV setting
Pulser (single shot or repetitive) (d) Ultimate evolution • No more air gap arcing
Figure 4.2 Evolution of the discharge probe concepts.
d
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
95
Table 4.1 Arc Discharge vs. Contact Discharge, Pros and Consa Topic
Arc ESD
Replicates real-life arc condition Guarantee of a well-reproducible waveform Cannot be performed on hard-to-reach recessed areas Requires scratching the paint Requires a carefully set gap dimension Insensitive to operator’s body proximity and other human factors Insensitive to RH Totals:
+3
−1
+2
Direct Contact ESD +3 −3 −2 +2 +1 +2
a Each
topic is either a bonus or a penalty, but is never counted on both sides. A 1 (less important) to 3 (most important) weigthing factor has been used.
4.1.2. Simulators for Equipment Test, Based on IEC 61000-4-2 Standard Since this standard enjoys a large international acceptance, the corresponding simulator will be briefly described. As shown in Figure 4.4, it is based on the simplified equivalent circuit of human body ESD (see Section 1.5), but with a discharge resistor of 330 , instead of the 1–2 k, more typical of human body models. The 150-pF storage capacitor is charged through a 10- to 100-M limiting resistor, providing a maximum charging time constant RC of 15 ms, such that after about 0.075 s (5 × RC) the capacitor is considered fully charged. This 330- value for the discharge resistor, replacing the 150- early versions, has several advantages: 1. For a given inductance L of the complete discharge loop, it forces a smaller L/R time constant, hence a faster rise for the main discharge current. 2. It is closer to the statistical low value for human body resistance, when in the kilovolt/nanosecond region. The schematic in the earlier, pre-1990 version simply used a switch on the capacitor charging side. The discharge was triggered by approaching the probe on the target surface; thus it was always an air discharge. The subsequent updates imposed that the capacitor be discharged by a switch, which is unavoidably a high-voltage relay. This relay permits a contact discharge without an arc, except for the recessed areas that the probe cannot physically touch. Consequentely, two probe tips are prescribed: • •
A pointed tip for contact discharge, so, eventually, a paint or oxide film can be penetrated, avoiding an uncontrolled arc through the paint. A spherical tip, as in the earlier versions, for air discharges.
96
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
Looking at the IEC recommended test levels (see Chapter 3), we see that the contact discharge test, simulating the field-enhanced hand/metal object is only required up to 8 kV. Above this voltage, the standard requires air discharge. There are two reasons for this: One is that ESD event studies have shown that above 6–8 kV, the superfast initial spike is unlikely to occur. The other is that HV relays capable of switching millions of times 10–16 kV are expensive. For these reasons, many IEC-type generators, when in the air discharge mode, do not actually switch on and off the relay above 8 kV, but simply keep it closed during this test option.
4.1.3. Detailed Review of the IEC 61000–4-2 Simulator Definition The IEC (2) type of ESD simulator, along with its companion procedure, offers the advantage of a worldwide agreed-upon evaluation technique, with broadly accepted values. This provides a common baseline for assessing ESD immunity of many products (not always remembered, though, is the fact that the original IEC 801–2 “mother version” did not claim to address all sorts of electronic equipment, but simply industrial process controls). The following review is based on the current version (2001) of the standard but also takes into account the essential amendments of the recent drafts (2000–2006), not yet released at the time of this writing. The earlier, pre-1990 version, IEC simulator and its standard setup did have several shortcomings, of which a practitioner should be aware: Not that we intend to lead a visit through the museum of ESD history, but because we think that mentioning some past deficiencies will enlighten the comprehension of the more recent versions. Also, thousands of simulators of the first definition are still in use since some product specifications and purchasing requirements still refer to the IEC-801–2 standard, with the air discharge and 150-/150-pF network. Therefore we will describe the most significant problems of IEC 801–2 and how they are corrected in the current IEC 61000-4-2, acknowledging that the choice between direct contact or air discharge is still possible, and sometimes mandatory. 4.1.3.1. The Former, IEC 801–2 Simulator
Armed with the discussion about “arc vs. no arc” (Section 4.1.1), the reader will probably identify some of the latent weaknesses of the IEC in its earlier definition. Besides the problems pertinent to the sole air gap discharge, few others were peculiar to the IEC document itself: 1. The rise time and peak current requirements indulge too much on the simulator inacurracy. The specified rise time at 4 kV is 5 ns + 30%, with the corresponding current 18 A + 30%. This gives way to a large variance between the highest and lowest possible time derivatives: one compliant
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
97
generator could deliver dI /dt, which is 3.5 times greater than another. The current IEC standard sets tighter tolerances for the current and rise time (Figs. 4.3 and 4.4). 2. The sharp precursor effect, typical of hand/metal discharge in dry air was neither specified or measured. It was more or less left to chance, depending on the speed and angle of approach, notwithstanding that the 8-mm spherical electrode does not invite the initial predischarge. The current IEC version impose a template for the initial peak . 3. The choice of a unique discharge resistance of 150 is a trade-off: Being midway between a severe human ESD (the low range of body resistance is about 1 k) and a furniture ESD (very low impedance), it has the
150 Ω + EUT
100 MΩ 150 pF
HV
2−16.5 kV
Grounding strap: 2 m × 20 mm width Insulating sleeve
Brass electrode
Steel ball
6 mm
8 mm
80 mm Probe discharge finger Circular array of discharger ≥2 Ω
Total parallel combination ≥ 2 Ω 50 Ω
0.9 I t
9 A @ 2 kV 37 A @ 8 kV 70 A @ 15 kV
0.1 I tr To simulator ground electrode test setup to check IESD waveform
Ipeak requirement: ± 30% when tested according to setup
Required waveform @ 4 kV: Rise time tr = 5 ns ± 30% Pulse width t = 30 ns ± 30%
Figure 4.3 Early IEC 801– 2 simulator characteristics (air discharge only).
98
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing Vacuum relay (bounceless)
330 Ω
50-100 MΩ
EUT
150 pF
HV ±
Ground Strap Probe for air discharge: Slmilar to 1984 standard
Probe for contact discharge
φ8 25°−40°
Ipeak 1 (100%) 90% Ipeak 2 at 30 ns
I at 60 ns 10% 30 ns τr = 0.7 to 1 ns
60 ns
t
Ipeak1 (±10%)
Ipeak2 at 30 ns (±30%)
I at 60 ns (±30%)
7.5 A
4A
2A
8A
4A
22.5 A
12 A
6A
30 A
16 A
8A
Level (contact discharge)
HV (kV)
1
2
2
4
15 A
3
6
4
8
Figure 4.4 IEC 61000– 4-2 simulator characteristics. Current waveform is measured via a 2- coaxial target, with the measuring instrumentation in a shielded enclosure. The location of the discharge resistor is as shown on the IEC document, but manufacturers may choose to put it on the probe side.
advantage of simplicity. Yet it lacks the important aspect of furniture discharge, that is, the oscillatory waveform of the underdamped RLC network (see Section 1.5). It is not clear if this shortcut was supported by ad hoc studies or if it was a deliberate choice, for the sake of simplicity. No rationale for it was given in the IEC recommendation or subsequent annex. This is somewhat improved in the current IEC version. In fact, by changing
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
99
to a higher (330 ) discharge resistance, the new simulator comes closer to the actual human body resistance for the kilovolt/nanosecond domain, but it is departing even farther from the furniture high current ringing waveform. 4. The pulse polarity was positive only. 5. The requirement for the discharge current return path was rather sloppy, leading to large differences between the calibration current waveform and the actual waveform delivered during a test, leading to poor repeatability. Figure 4.5 shows the stretching of the pulse rise time caused by the 1.5- to 2-μH inductance of the 2-m ground strap. The present calibration method with the coaxial target (see next section) eliminates the impact of the ground return strap on the rise time of the first peak. With the predischarge being generated at the probe itself, and thanks to the higher value of the discharge resistance, the ground strap has less critical effect, the location of the main current hump being somewhere between 10 and 30 ns after the initial peak (Fig. 4.6).
LS
RS:150 Ω
18 A
Ipeak
ZD ≥ 2 Ω
tr = 5 ns (a) Calibration LS
RS 18 A
Lloop 15 ns
(b) Actual test conditions, Lloop ≅ 1.2 mH for 2 m
Figure 4.5 Effect of self-inductance of the generator ground strap, stretching the rise time.
100
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing IA
20 15 8 KV (AD)
10
4 KV (CI)
5 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
tns
IA 30 25 20
15 KV (AD)
15 8 KV (CI) 10 5 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
tns
Figure 4.6 Measured currents with an IEC 61000– 4-2 generator, for air discharge (AD) vs. current injection (CI) on a coaxial 2- target [after Mohr (9)].
4.1.3.2. A Few Specific Aspects of the Latest IEC Simulators
The research on the ESD generator improvements for better accuracy and repeatability has been intense during the past decade (3–8). Some of the results of these works are reflected in the latest draft versions of IEC, as well as ANSI C-63.16 (9), ESD test standards, and we will review them briefly: Template for the Current Waveform A min/max window is prescribed for the contact discharge waveform. If we look at the present specifications, the tolerances are:
Output voltage ±5% Output current (first peak) ±15% Contact discharge rise time (first peak) 0.8 ns ±25% Output current at 30 ns (beginning of the main “hump” fall off) ±30% No tolerances are given for the air discharge, the assumption being that a generator capable of meeting the above template will deliver a correct air
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
101
discharge waveform. Calibration is done with a 2- coaxial target (25, leadless, 51- resistors), matched to 50 via a conical coaxial adapter. The total insertion loss of the calibration jig, from target to oscilloscope input must be ≤ ±0.5 dB up to 1 GHz. The oscilloscope must have a minimum 2-GHz analog bandwidth, and be installed in a shielded enclosure, with the coaxial target mounted as a feed-through. However, although the tolerances have been severely tightened, probably close to the limits of what high-voltage components technology can achieve today, the uncertainty on the initial discharge spike is still significant. Let us assume two simulators, with tolerances set at their worst, for a 8-kV discharge:
Ipeak (Nom. 30 A) Rise time (Nom. 0.8 ns) dI /dt (Nom. 37.5 A/ns) Total departure from nominal Voltage induced per cm2 for a victim circuit located at 15 cm Total peak-to-peak deviation between the two generators:
Generator 1
Generator 2
−15% 25.5A +25% 1 ns 25.5 A/ns −3.3 dB 3.4 V/cm2
+15% 34.5 A −25% 0.6 ns 57.5 A/ns +3.7 dB 7.7 V/cm2 7 dB
Although both generators conform to the specifications, the test made with generator 2 will be 2.2 times more disturbing than with generator 1. If we compare this uncertainty, regarded as systematic, nonrandom instrument error, to the typical error budget of a radiated EMC test, we find radiated EMC instrument error at about 3 dB (one instrument). Therefore, instrumentwise, an ESD test has a mediocre score on uncertainty, yet not much worse than an ordinary radiated EMC test. Figures 4.7 and 4.8 show two modern ESD simulators conforming to the IEC standard. As of 2008, about eight manufacturers worldwide offer ESD generators that conform to IEC, with various hardware options. The one in Fig. 4.7 is made by Teseq (ex Schaffner). It is extremely handy, battery-operated, easy to hand carry on a plane for short-notice trips, and is rated up to 16 kV (30 kV for the NSG437 model). Its discharge probe is strictly based on the IEC prescription. The one in Figure 4.8 is the MiniZap, by Keytek. It has been the workhorse of many test labs and EMC specialists for more than 15 years, being constantly improved. It also has options of several possible discharge head adaptors, to enhance either the E or H field. Transient Electromagnetic Field During Initial Spike At the very instant of contact closure, the HV side of the relay and associated hardware generate locally a transient E field. The way this field is distributed and the corresponding
102
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
Figure 4.7 Example of commercial ESD generator: TESEQ//SCHAFFNER NSG 435. The gun is shown with its demountable elements: battery pack, pointed and ball discharge tips, mounting plate for fixed stand, and external power supply.
Figure 4.8 The KEYTEK MiniZap. The HV relay has guaranteed 2 million operations at full current. There is an option of ultra-short 0.4-ns rise time for low-voltage discharges, per ANSI C.63– 16.
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
103
charge displacement current are very different from the actual human hand/metal event (Fig. 4.9). The reason can be understood by comparing the geometry of an actual hand/metal event with that of the ESD simulator front end. With the actual event, the air gap breakdown is equivalent to an ultrafast switch closing the HV circuit exactly at the point of contact. The “hot” side of the circuit is the metallic tip of the handheld object. In contrast, the switch of an ESD gun is located at 10–15 cm from the contact tip. The right-hand part of the discharge network is at the target (EUT surface) potential, while the “hot” side is on the left side of the yet-open switch. The gun-to-target stray capacitance as well as E-field distribution are different. This distribution of the E-field lines is also dependent on the hardware design, shape, and dimensions of the gun head, which include the exact location of the discharge resistor. This introduces an additional uncertainty in the test results from different guns discharging on the same EUT. A “round-robin” test performed in 2006–2007 at the request of the IEC Technical Committee has confirmed that not
Actual
Simulated
Rd E field
HV 330 Ω Discharge head
EUT surface
Figure 4.9 Simulated vs. actual hand-metal transient field: the geometry of the initial spike artificial generation (right) is quite different from the actual phenomenon (left).
104
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
only the EUT response to the precursor radiated coupling is not the same with an artificial contact discharge than with an actual human ESD, but it also varies between several IEC-compliant simulators (3). This variation, for the same EUT error rate correspondes to differences of several kilovolts in the HV setting. The problem cannot be controlled by the current calibration since the coaxial target mount is by nature insensitive to the radiation coupling (4). Attempts made to shield the HV head switch to prevent its spurious radiation resulted in unacceptable alteration of the rise time, due to the added capacitance. In fact, the point is not to eliminate this field but to render it more close to the “standard” hand and object phenomenon in a way that all simulators would replicate. One key improvement, for instance, could be to relocate the switch very close to the contact point. Problems with Steepness of Initial Spike The poor repeatability of the air discharge has been eliminated by the clean and fast closing of a relay. But in some cases, this fast relay was found to be too fast, closing in 100 ps, that is, 3–10 times faster than the fastest hand/metal discharge. As a result, the intended and spurious effects of the initial spike, related to the dI /dt value, are exaggerated, and the EUT will be overtested [Fig. 4.10 and (5)]. Many manufacturers have tried hardware solutions to overcome this problem, which in fact is linked with that of the constant rise time, as will be seen in the next section. The falling slope of the spike also raises some suspicion, as it is not specified in the IEC calibration. However, attempts to compare the results of modified, controlled fall time ESD guns with unmodified ones were not strongly conclusive, and this topic has not been incorporated in the latest simulator requirements. Problems with Constant Rise Time With the ESD generator in contact discharge, the rise time of the first spike is dictated by the relay closure and associated R,L,C elements; in other words, the rise time is constant. Measurements of low voltage, quasi-natural ESD with small gap length and fast approach 12 simulator A simulator C simulator B
20
10 E-field kV/m
Current derivative [A/ns]
40
0 20
A
8
B
6
C
4
D
2 −40
0
1
5 Time [ns]
10
0
0
2
4
8
Time [ns]
Figure 4.10 Variations in current derivative and E field at 0.10 m, from several IEC-compliant generators and 5-kV discharge [from Rhoades (5) and Pommerenke (6)]. All these different dI /dt and field waveforms correlated with different run/fail thresholds for the same EUT.
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work
105
(11) have shown that discharges below 3 kV have very short rise times. For instance (Fig. 4.11), a fast 1-kV metal-to-metal discharge exhibits initial current rise <0.5 ns, the rise time being more or less linear with voltage in this submillimeter region. Since most ESD-induced malfunctions are related to the current (or field) derivative, it appears that a 1-kV hand/metal ESD with 0.3 ns rise time can be as threatening as 4 kV with 1.2 ns rise time. The two induced disturbances have the same amplitude, the difference being in their duration. Considering that in a given environment, there are statistically much more 1-kV discharges than 4-kV ones, this would lead to an ESD test plan imposing more error-free discharges at lower levels (see Error per pulse criteria, Section 4.7).
4.1.4. Generators with Different Networks, Very High Voltage and Field Enhancement Accessories A certain number of applications such as automobile electronics, aircraft and aerospace equipment, and electroexplosive devices require different RC Rise time vs. voltage for low voltage discharge (small gap and fast approach)
tr (ns)
2 1.5 1 0.5 1
2
3
4
5
kVESD (Aver. of pos. and neg. discharges) Discharge current I (3 kV) I (2 kV) I (1 kV)
t Induced PCB voltage Vi 0.4 ns
0.8 ns
1.2 ns t
Figure 4.11 Rise time with low-voltage, small gap discharges.
106
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
networks. Most modern IEC-type simulators have such options, offered as user-replaceable modules (Fig. 4.12, 4.13). In this case the specifc current and waveforms can be different from the original IEC definition. Ultrahigh voltage ESD generators are required for automobile and airborne equipment tests. Because of the physical nature of their environment (high static buildup in a confined space, isolated from ground) and the life-threatening consequences of some ESD-induced failures, test voltages higher than maximum severity class of the IEC or ANSI standards are required. The most common example is the ISO 10605 or SAE J1113-13, which require 25 kV immunity for safety-critical automotive systems such as braking/ABS, airbags, and door locks. In order to have some design margin for prototype testing and investigations, manufacturers offer in general up to 30 kV capability
(a)
(b)
Figure 4.12 ESD generator with very high voltage, mostly used in automobile and airborne applications. It has a quick self-check option, (a) automatic residual charge dumper and (b) convenient plug-in discharge networks. (Courtesy of Schloder.)
4.1. ESD Simulators: How They Work Discharge Network (DN)
107
Relay Module (RM)
ESD3000
Batteries standard type AA
Sharp Tip for contact discharge (CD) Rounded Tip for air discharge (AD) 30 mm Tip Electrode for (AD) V > 16 kV
Figure 4.13 Example of easily interchangeable discharge modules. (Courtesy of EMC Partner.)
Figure 4.14 A 30-kV ESD generator testing a portion of an automobile harness. (Courtesy of Schaffner/Teseq.)
(Fig 4.14). Although 30 kV is just twice the highest IEC test value (severity 4), such simulators must be used with some precautions. At 30 kV, the discharge electrode starts exhibiting ionization and corona effects about 5–10 cm around the probe tip. Even though a 30-kV/100 ns duration pulse is not lethal, it is an unpleasant experience and the test people should as much as possible operate the generator in remote control mode (Fig 4.15), once the preliminary adjustments are completed.
108
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
Figure 4.15 Air-discharge generator with fully automated robotic operation, eliminating the error-prone manual handling. (Courtesy of Schaffner/Teseq.)
4.1.5. Special Relays Required for ESD Simulators Either for the ESD guns implementing the direct contact (no-arc) principle, or for the component ESD testers of Section 4.3, a special relay is needed to switch the capacitor into discharging mode. Although it looks trivial on the basic schematic, this relay or switch is key to a well-reproducible waveform, in the direct contact, “no-arc” discharge. This relay has to withstand the full charging voltage and operate the transfer without bouncing. Also, even though the direct contact technique was deemed to eliminate the arc problem, nothing is free in physics, and there is still an arc, but it now occurs inside the relay. Until time comes where solid-state switches with subnanosecond transition time will handle 20 kV, the only way is to use high-voltage relays with minimum arcing and bouncing. A former study (12) found that, after all, rather than eliminating the arc, a well-controlled triggered spark gap (manufacturer EG & G) can give also an acceptable waveform, but the range of possible voltages is limited to the specific type of gap used. Hopefully, modern industry has become an important consumer of HV switches, for applications such as defibrillators, electrosurgery, magnetic resonance imagers, RF antenna switching, and the like so the limited markets for ESD generators have benefited from this high demand. For instance, mercury relays like those made by Magnecraft/USA can be successfully used up to 10 kV or more. The Paschen law (see Appendix C) indicates that, in a high degree of vaccum, breakdown voltage rises to much higher values than in air at normal pressure, with the added benefit of a long contact lifetime, since the arc occurs in an oxygen-free space. Accordingly, high-voltage relays have been developed
4.2. Furniture Versus Personnel ESD Simulation
109
by manufacturers such as Kilovac, who offers hard vacuum, fast bounceless relays up to 15 kV. Above this voltage, vacuum relays tend to generate X rays, so relays with pressurized SF6 gas are used instead. The relay contacts are in a sealed bulb with a high-pressure gas that can withstand more than 20 kV/mm of gap (see Appendix C). These SF6 relays are “make-only” (no break). Simple, almost home-made ESD generators can be made using reed relay switches: Inexpensive models can be found with 1–2 kV continuous rating, but they can switch up to 6 kV in pulsed mode. Beyond this value they exhibit multiple arcing and ringing because of their parasitic capacitance. A primitive ESD generator can also be made with gas tube overvoltage protectors: They have fast switching times, but they trigger for only one given voltage, thus requiring several devices.
4.2. FURNITURE VERSUS PERSONNEL ESD SIMULATION Section 1.5 showed that furniture or large objects creates waveforms, hence frequency spectra and induced effects, that are very different from personnel ESD. While in the near-field region, the higher voltages of personnel ESD create a strong E-field transient but lower H field, furniture ESD by its low source resistance creates stronger H field. Because of the longer duration of the ringing wave, the induced voltage in exposed electronics can be more disturbing, especially with medium-speed circuits. One should not conclude that an equipment passing a furniture-type ESD test would be implicitly immune to personnel ESD, rendering this latter test needless. We have seen (Section 2.8) that furniture discharge is not feasible in all areas of the EUT, and that its lower voltages (always below 5 kV) do not permit arcing on many hidden or recessed areas. In addition, the super fast rise time of hand/metal personnel ESD creates intense E-field transients that are not replicated by furniture discharge. Having selected discharges with approximately identical probability of occurrence, the respective frequency spectra of personnel (direct hand/metal and air discharge) and furniture ESD are displayed in Figure 4.16. This comparison shows where furniture spectrum overrides the others. Therefore we can say that: • • •
A single test based on personnel ESD alone (Rd > few hundred ohms) may overestimate the equipment immunity to furniture ESD. A single test based on furniture ESD alone (Rd < 50 ) may overestimate the equipment immunity to personnel ESD. Although it simplifies testing, a trade-off discharge network with 330 resistance and approximately 2 μH of loop inductance does not replicate adequately the large oscillatory current of furniture ESD.
This leads to the conclusion that, for the time being, a fully representative test program should include both personnel and furniture ESD (8). If the objective
110
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
100 300 1 MHz
10
Frequency 3 10 30
10
10
B
C
3
A/MHz
100 300 1 GHz 3
3
1
1
.3
.3
.1
.1
A
.03
.03
.01
.01
.003
.003
.001
.001
10 kHz 30
100 300 1 MHz
3 10 30 Frequency 40 A
30 A
100 300 1 GHz 3
A/MHz
10 kHz 30
10
40 A
16 A
30 ns 0.7-1ns
60 ns
A New IEC contact discharge 8 kV
≥ 20 ns
60 ns
B Air discharge 15 kV
Fo ≅ 20 MHz C Furniture discharge 2 kV
Figure 4.16 Waveforms and frequency spectra of 3 test discharges, representing severe ESD events having approximately the same probability; between 15 and 60 MHz, the furniture-type spectrum overrides the others.
of a product manufacturer is merely to design a product that passes the tests and complies with the standard requirements for getting a CE (Communaut´e Europ´eenne) mark or other approval, the personnel ESD test is a sufficient shelter. But this includes the risk of having a compliant product that will sometimes fail in the field. Simulators capable of reproducing furniture (as well as personnel) ESD have been commercially available. The EMC engineers at the IBM R&D laboratory in Kingston had developed for their own use the ESD tool 5800 (also made by Andy Hish). It performed very efficient and repeatable tests (13). Commercial versions were marketed after 1990 by ElectroMetrics and by Keytek Corp. but not widely used. The essential features of this tester are shown on Figure 4.17.
0.30 m
0.50 m
4.2. Furniture Versus Personnel ESD Simulation
111
H.V. relay and discharge resistance
Relay coil control
C1
Base ref. plate
EUT i1 surface
HV C2
I2
EUT-to-gnd impedance
i1, C1 = gap capacitive current path i2, C2 = machine capacitive current path
Figure 4.17 Vane-type ESD simulator (13). The charges are evenly spread as surface charges, instead of concentrated in a “gun.”
One of its definite advantages belongs to the crossed-vanes structure, which ideally replicates the distributed capacitance of a human body, or large metal object, standing close to the EUT. Moreover, the capacitance of this X-shaped armature is insensitive to the presence of other nearby conductive objects. Another remarkable aspect is that this armature is coupled to the entire setup in a way that is very similar to an actual ESD, via two distributed capacitances: • •
The vane-to-EUT distributed capacitance, C1 , representing approximately 20 pF. The vane-to-ground capacitance, C2 (150 pF), of which the vane pedestal acts as the “hot” armature, the other armature being simply the simulator base, that is, the local ground plane.
This close-to-real capacitance arrangement eliminates the 2-m ground strap of the ESD gun. Paramount to the effective generation of a fast initial rise time, the HV switch—a 7-kV, mercury-wetted relay—is located exactly where an actual ESD would be arcing, thus solving the problem of the correct transient field generation (see discussion in Section 4.1.3.2). It is packaged in a small module
112
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
with the contact probe. This module can be equipped with a 15- (furniture) or 1800- (personnel) discharge resistor. A slotted bracket, by sliding on the vane wing, allows to adjust the module at the desired discharge height facing the EUT, without changing the distributed capacitances. And finally, indirect ESD was easily made by discharging the vane on its own base. Regrettably, because of its weight and size, this tester was rather bulky to install and required some practice to use, so the industry has been reluctant to adopt it. ECMA European Computers Manufactures Association and ANSI working groups, which recommended its use in the early versions of their ESD standard, have since abandoned this concept.
4.3. OTHER TYPES OF ESD SIMULATORS FOR COMPONENT TESTING Referring to the gun described by the IEC-61000-4-2, ESD Test standard, to our knowledge, there is no fundamental difference between the types of ESD simulators available on the market today for equipment testing. Differences lay principally in the RC networks required by specifications others than the IEC, the sophistication of the features and commodities offered (see list in Section 4.1), and the possibility or not to create a direct contact (no air gap) discharge. However, there is a category of ESD testers that is quite different in its realization: These testers are the simulators used to address component vulnerability per MIL-StD 883 or JEDEC/ESDA, for instance. The purpose is to subject a given ESD level to every possible pin combination of an integrated circuit (or eventually any ESD-sensitive component) (Fig. 4.18). These tools do not look any more like a handheld gun but rather as a workstation with a programmable module socket. The selected pin(s) and the test sequence can be semi- or fully automated. Discharges can be configured for HBM, and machine or charged device models. A more accurate test waveform (transmission line pulse) has been recently introduced. The test results can be visualized on a separate curve tracer or sometimes on a screen displaying the I,V curves of the stressed device, an overall bar chart printout (Fig. 4.19) On some models, like the one in Figure 4.20, the user can program complex test sequences. All these features may seem a luxury; however, simply look at a manufacturer who has to monitor regularly the ESD sensitivity of its products. Consider, for example, a 56-pin integrated circuit. Each pin must be tested, for instance, against all the other pins grounded together. That makes 56 tests times 2 polarities. And since what is looked at is a quality figure, a statistical distribution of the failure levels is necessary. Therefore, the voltage will be gradually increased from 500 to 4000 V, in 250-V steps. Let us assume also that we need to repeat each pulse 5 times. For the sole HBM, the total number of measurements to take, depending on the spread of the devices characteristics, will vary between:
4.3. Other Types of ESD Simulators for Component Testing
ESD injection contact
To V,I measure and read out
Test socket
Polarity reversal HV relay > 1 MΩ +/− HV supply 1500 Ω 5 kV minimum 100 pF − /+
Grounding contact
Programmed sequencing for driving injection pin and grounding pin
Figure 4.18 Principle of an automated ESD tester for components.
Voltage 1K
2K
3K
4K
5K
1
1
5
5
10
10
15
15
20
20
25
25
30
30
35
35
40 0
1K
2K
3K
4K
Pin #
Pin #
0
40 5K
Voltage
Figure 4.19 Example of a bar chart printout from an automated ESD IC tester (Hartley AutoZap).
113
114
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
Figure 4.20 Example of a modern ESD test station for components evaluation (Keytek ZapMaster). It accepts uncanned chips and packaged ICs upto 768 pins. Human body (HBM) and machine (MM) discharge models can be selected. Advanced design prevents spurious non-ESD effects, like trailing edge of the SF6 high-voltage relay. It provides full pretest and post-test status report.
56 × 2 × 5 = 560 for those devices failing after the first voltage step 56 × 2 × 5 × (4000 − 500)/250 = 7840 for those devices that resist up to 4000 V It is of course out of the question to have these tests done manually.
4.4. ESD TEST SETUP—DIRECT AND INDIRECT ESD The following sections describe the details of the test installation. When there are variations between what is recommended here and what some of the principal specifications require, this will be mentionned. The basic setup for ESD testing is shown on Figure 4.21. The equipment under test (EUT) is normally installed above a ground reference plane (GRP), at a height dictated by its wheels, feet, casters, and the like. By default, 5- to 10-cm insulating spacers can be used. The return conductor (preferably a strap) of the generator is grounded to this reference plane. For EUT with metal housing, the test is made by direct discharges (D-ESD), that is, the discharges are applied to all points of the EUT likely to be touched by personnel and, eventually, furniture. For EUT with plastic housing, the test is made by indirect discharges (I-ESD) on a nearby horizontal or vertical metal plate. Several variations of this basic installation will be described, especially when the EUT housing is not entirely metallic.
4.4. ESD Test Setup—Direct and Indirect ESD
115
10 Ω to several kΩ Adjustable up to 25 kV Rd EUT
100 to 300 pF Ground return strap Safety ground
Test ground plane
Figure 4.21 Basic setup of an ESD test.
4.4.1. Ground Reference A GRP is of prime importance and must be present every time to stabilize the EUT-to-ground capacitance, thereby allowing repeatable testing. Without this plane, the return path of the discharges would be totally uncontrolled, shared between some undefined ground plane and the room/building grounding wires; thus the rise time and the spread of the return currents would differ, and the test results would not be reproducible from one setup to another. The GRP is the common reference for all the elements participating in the test: The generator, the EUT, the various accessories will be directly or indirectly referenced to the GRP. This plane can be made of a copper or aluminum plate or foil, which must extend at least 0.30 m around the EUT, or more, enough to widely encompass both the EUT (which can be a system of several units) and the simulator. A good rule of thumb is that the GRP boundaries shall exceed the EUT perimeter by a dimension equal to the EUT height. To avoid the GRP from raising up to an undefined potential after many successive discharges, possibly creating testing unacurracy or even shock hazard, the plane must be connected to the local ground terminal. This connection to the grounding network is regarded as an ordinary safety wire, having no importance for the high-frequency response of the test itself.
4.4.2. Direct Versus Indirect ESD The EUT-to-ground configuration can be more complex than the simple sketch of Figure 4.21. The EUT can be an upright, floor-standing machine, a table-top device, or eventually a wall-mounted device. It may have a metallic housing
116
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
or a nonconductive one. The following recommendations address these different options, summarized in Figure 4.22. For Equipment with Metallic Housing (Direct ESD)
If floor standing, the equipment should stand over the GRP, as shown in the typical configuration of Figure 4.23. Regarding the height above this GRP, a default value of 10 cm is generally adopted, except when a fixed height above a conductive floor is defined by specific application constraints. If the EUT is a table-top equipment, most standards state that it should rest on a nonconductive table, and a horizontal coupling plane (HCP) be added to simulate the coupling with a metallic table (Fig. 4.24). A legitimate question arises: Since table-top devices can be used on metallic as well as nonmetallic desks and workbench, why select a wooden table, and then simulate a metallic desk by adding a sheet of metal? Why not use a metallic table from the start? The choice is not that simple; whether the EUT is metallic, as is the case here, or plastic, its coupling to the floor-level plane will be different whether it is resting on a metallic top or not. Deciding which configuration is the worst case for ESD is very speculative, as it depends on the internal design of the EUT and the I/O cable arrangement. Only a comparative test could identify the most vulnerable configuration, and this could vary with each EUT. So the standard setup of IEC or other industry specifications is a fair trade-off, given that it is easier to turn a wooden table into a metallic desk top than doing the reverse (see discussion on HCP in Section 4.4.3). Testing metallic and plastic table-top equipment with both a conductive and nonconductive table would seem extravagant, but experience has shown that
or
GRP
GRP Metal housing, floor standing
GRP
Metal housing, table top
VCP HCP
GRP Plastic housing, floor standing
GRP Plastic housing, table top
Extended GRP System test
Figure 4.22 Overview of various ESD test setup depending on types of machines.
4.4. ESD Test Setup—Direct and Indirect ESD wall at ≥ 1 m
Typical position for Direct ESD Safety ground wire
117
EUT
Typical position for Indirect ESD 0.1 m
VCP 470 kΩ
Power cables Signal cables
L=2m
> 0.5 m
Insulating stand-off 10 cm thick GRP
Figure 4.23 Test installation for floor standing equipment (per IEC or ANSI). For I-ESD, notice the horizontal position of the gun at the edge of the VCP.
depending on the orientation of PCBs inside the unit, the points of entry and internal routing of the cables, one configuration may be more critical than the other. As a suggestion to save test time, one can run a first exploratory test with both configurations and find out which one gives the weakest ESD fail levels. Then retain this setup for the rest of the testing. For Equipment with Plastic Housing (Indirect ESD)
If floor standing, the EUT will be installed on a ground plane, as for the previous case. However, since there are no or very few accessible metal parts for direct discharge, the test following procedure will apply: • •
Direct discharges on all eventually accessible metal parts. Indirect discharge by discharging the probe on vertical coupling plates (VCP), grounded via high value resistances to the GRP. Discharges will be made at 10 cm from each side of the EUT. (This 10-cm distance is deemed to represent the closest reasonable worst case where people will actually discharge on nearby metallic objects. However, for some specific products, another distance can be selected.)
For table-top equipment, the EUT will be installed on a nonconductive table, covered with the HCP. The height of the EUT above this plane is simply dictated by its feet or stand-offs. No incidental contact to the HCP should occur by protruding screws or metallic parts on the bottom of the EUT. This is usually taken
118
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing Simulator position for discharges to the EUT
Simulator position for discharges to the VCP Safety earth conductor
0.1 m >0.5 m to next structure and walls
VCP Insulation 0.1 m HCP Simulator position for discharges to the HCP
HCP discharging resistors (2 × 470 KΩ)
Ground reference plane (GRP)
Keep ground strap >0.2 m from the EUT and its cables
Figure 4.24 Test installation for table-top equipment. During the test, the EUT may need to be relocated on the HCP (or the HCP cut to size) to achieve the 0.1-m distance from the edges.
care of by putting an insulating foil on top of the HCP. A VCP will be installed on the HCP, via an insulating stand. The following test procedure will apply: •
•
Direct discharge on any accessible metal part (switches, keys, screws, conductive elements of an otherwise plastic cover, etc.). This includes contact or arc, whichever comes first. Indirect discharge by discharging the probe on a VCP (as done above), and on the table-top HCP, following a perimeter about 10 cm from the EUT sides.
4.4.3. Roles of the HCP and VCP With I-ESD, the test aims at reproducing the scenario where a charged person is touching a metallic structure (furniture, other equipment or appliance, door or window frame, etc.), very close to the nonmetallic EUT (see Chapter 2). For replicating the case where the EUT is resting on a metallic desktop, the gun will be discharged on the edge of a metal plate (the HCP). All the same, to simulate the case where the EUT would be close to a large vertical object, the gun will be discharged on the edge of a 0.50 × 0.50 m vertical coupling plate (VCP). Although this seems a sound approach, several issues are not clearly addressed or resolved in IEC and major testing standards:
4.4. ESD Test Setup—Direct and Indirect ESD
119
1. The connection of the HCP (or VCP) to the ground reference plane (GRP) is treated differently depending on the specification. The IEC demands that they be virtually isolated from the GRP via two 470-k resistors, acting only as a “soft” static sink for discharging the plate a few milliseconds after each discharge. At the moment of the discharge, this makes the VCP (or HCP) jump abruptly to the tip voltage, creating locally a strong E-field transient, hence a capacitive coupling to the EUT circuits (a plastic housing offers no Faraday shielding). But this is missing the large VCP-to-ground discharge current that would occur with a true grounded structure, radiating a correspondingly high magnetic field. A wise approach, at least during development time, is to arrange a test with the VCP (or HCP) alternatively floated via the 470 k, then directly grounded, and concentrate on the worst susceptible configuration. 2. How should the VCP be located with respect to the actual EUT target zone? Intuitively, and this is what the IEC document is suggesting, one would align the VCP center to face target zone. In fact, theory and experiments (14) have shown that the maximum current density, hence field concentration, is near the edges of the VCP. 3. The VCP and HCP are required regardless of nonmetallic or metallic type of EUT. There seems to be not much sense in discharging on a metal plate at 10 cm from an EUT, while this latter is already in a metallic housing, submitted to the much more threatening direct discharges. However, some rare situations (see Section 4.5.1) can justify this demand. 4. For EUTs with a very low height-to-perimeter form factor, such as 35 × 35 cm device only 5–6 cm high (e.g., a DVD player), there is no sense exciting the VCP since the E-field coupling from the HCP will be a much more severe threat. So, except for “going by the book,” ESD investigation and troubleshooting can be made with the HCP alone. 5. The E and H fields generated by the gun’s HV circuitry vary significantly with its tilt angle on the HCP (or VCP). With guns held vertically, Pommerenke and Frei (14) measured 2/1 H -field and up to 6/1 E-field variations between different guns. These ratios reduce to 1.25/1 if the gun is held co-planar with the HCP. On the other hand, the strongest coupling with the initial spike occurs with the gun held vertical. Thus, the dilemna was the following: •
•
The larger amplitude (vertical position) reproduces better the worst-case field near a human/metal discharge, but it aggravates the differences between various simulators. Differences are reduced with the gun held horizontally, but at the expense of a lesser field value.
Waiting for a better definition of simulator characterization, and at the risk of some undertesting, the second choice is retained in the IEC standard.
120
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
4.4.4. Grounding the Simulator and the EUT The EUT should be grounded through its normal grounding conductor, to the ground terminal of the power outlet. If the EUT has no ground conductor (class II equipment) or is battery operated, it will then be ungrounded. In no circumstances should the EUT be directly grounded to the GRP, unless this is the way it would be normally installed in the field, as, for instance, airborne or automobile equipment. The return path for ESD pulse to the generator must be a large strap, its recommended length being 2 m (see discussion in Section 4.1.3 about how of this length can affect the rise time), bonded to the GRP via a “C” clamp or similar. This dimension is a trade-off between the need of a limited length with less inductance, and a sufficent slack for being able to move the gun around the EUT. This wire or strap must have an insulating jacket to prevent other uncontrolled ground loops. The simulator should not be grounded to the EUT frame or the table-top HCP, except for some exploratory diagnostics. Note This deviates from some older test methods, which showed in certain cases the simulator being grounded to the EUT itself. This is questionable since, in real life, charged people will have their feet on the ground, and not on the EUT cabinet. In addition, grounding the simulator to the EUT frame will decrease, or even nullify, the electric field gradient between the lower part of the EUT (especially the bottom plate) and the ground plane. This field change is important in the possible coupling to I/O cables near their entry points. When the EUT has no connection to ground (battery-operated system, completely floating power sytem, etc.), there must be a way to discharge the floating metal parts after each discharge. This can be made by touching them with a grounded wire loaded by a few 100-k resistors. Some ESD gun manufacturers provide a bleeder network attached to the discharge tip, which systematically remove the discharge after each shot.
4.4.5. External Cables and System Configuration Very often, the ESD test may have to replicate the conditions of a system configuration. There can be several reasons for this: For instance, the EUT may be one unit of a multiple box set in which case the vulnerability of the whole system must be evaluated by testing one box after the other. Alternatively, the EUT may be designed as stand-alone, “attachable” to several types of peripherals or ancillary equipment. In this case, the peripheral devices must be connected to the EUT, even if they are not themselves being tested. However, in the latter, it is necessary that the units not being tested have an ESD level consistent with the test objective (see Section 5.7).
4.5. ESD Test Routine and Discharge Procedures
121
For a system configuration, the whole system must be installed over the GRP. If this is not practical, one ground plane per box can be used, provided that these planes are interconnected by wide straps. All the external cables that can be connected to the EUT in its maximum configuration should be in place and be laid out in a typical installation arrangement. To avoid too much variance in results due to different heights, they should be laid at a constant, repeatable height above the ground plane. Unless other heights are dictated by specific applications, a height of 10 cm, using wooden or plastic spacers, is a good average.
4.5. ESD TEST ROUTINE AND DISCHARGE PROCEDURES 4.5.1. Preparation of EUT for Test Readiness 1. Determine a clear, indisputable malfunction status that can be recognized without the need of an external oscilloscope, data-logger, and the like such as hard-error, wrong readout, inadvertent reset, alarm, on power down. This point is very important. No external ancillary equipment should be used to diagnose a fault condition because the very presence of additional probes and cables, and the monitoring device itself, can cause the EUT to fail at lower levels and give wrong test results. Very possibly, the oscillscope or data-logger can itself be disturbed by the ESD and give misleading information. The only exception would be by using a fiber-optic link to detect a change of state of some critical signals; but this assumes the EUT is already fitted with such diagnostic commodities. Therefore, if the EUT is a programmable device, it may be useful to develop a software routine that: • •
Exercises continuously all EUT operations, in closed loops without requiring an operator intervention. Indicates clearly by a printout, display message, alarm, buzzer, indicator light, dead display, locked keyboard, and the like that a fault has occurred.
With a large computer-based system, it would be sound to develop for all the transient immunity tests—not just ESD—a software that exercises every special-purpose routine, designed to operate in specific hardware areas. This will give a better efficiency for the hardware test program to approach a 100% probability of shooting in the worst sensitivity window, without running an excessively long test. It also facilitates the error diagnosis and faultly hardware location. It is not recommended to go to the extreme by trying to synchronize the ESD pulse rate with the EUT operation. Static discharges and machine cycles must remain two independent events (see Section 4.7).
122
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing Type of equipment
YES
Metal covers on six sides ?
D-ESD only
NO
I-ESD (For instance : 4 – 16 kV for personnel ESD)
D-ESD • On all metallic touchable parts • On all arc-reachable parts
Figure 4.25 Decision chart for discharges mode. Notice that a D-ESD is practically always to be attempted on a plastic-covered product because of the possibility of a few metallic targets.
2. Make a zoning by dividing each side of the equipment into approximately 0.1-m2 (30 cm × 30 cm) areas. Mark/code each ESD target area. Include signal cables and power cord entry areas. Determine if the discharges will be entirely direct (D-ESD), indirect (I-ESD), or hybrid (Fig. 4.25). It may seem wasteful applying I-ESD on a 6-sided metallic housing and, indeed, it generally proves to be useless, whereas the worst suspeptibility is found by D-ESD. However, there are rare cases where an I-ESD test with a metallic EUT reveals a weaker failure level than a direct discharge on the envelope: This happens when the EUT has much smaller dimensions than the 0.50 m × 0.50 m of the VCP, and is equipped with unshielded (or poorly shielded) external cables. In this specific case, the cable exposure to ESD field is stronger with the VCP than with the direct discharge on the EUT.
4.5.2. Application of the Discharges 1. Set the ESD level at about 3 kV (for a personnel-type discharge) or other determined value, depending on whether it is an investigation or a quality control (QC) test.‡ ‡ Some standards (e.g., IEC) recommend that, with D-ESD, the test be started only at the required immunity level, without passing by the lower levels, but this is risky. Even with D-ESD, EUTs can exhibit the following response: Assume Vs is the specification level: For voltages Vi < Vs , the discharge current follows a certain path on the EUT, eventually inside. For levels > Vi , and up to Vn , internal arcings can take place, giving way to a different current path that can be more, but sometimes less, disturbing than with a test at Vi . By testing only at the highest level, one could miss this response. It is safer testing at ALL inferior levels.
4.5. ESD Test Routine and Discharge Procedures Metal spring
Conductive paint
Metallic name plate/logo
Magnetic head LCD module with metal rim
123
Metallic connector PC board
Metallic card frame Targets : • Accessible metal parts connected to internal conductive parts • Floating metal parts (no arc, but E-field coupling inside) • Internal parts reachable by arc
Figure 4.26 Fictitious plastic equipment showing potential D-ESD targets.
2. Zap each of the coded areas marked in the preliminary step. If this area includes switches, keys, indicators, connectors, screws, rivets, and the like, apply the discharge on those points. Apply also the discharge on the seams, slots, display edges, and any protruding shape, angle, or surface discontinuity existing in the area. Otherwise, simply apply the discharge in the middle of the coded area. If the EUT housing is plastic, perform indirect ESD, applied on the edge of the HCP and of the VCP, at 10 cm from the target face. However, a direct discharge should still be tried on screws, rivets, decorative trims, and the like as suggested in Figure 4.26. There can be EUT areas that are accessible only under specific circumstances, such as: • •
Parts touched by end user during service (batteries, cassettes, ink cartridges., etc) I/O connectors not equipped with their cables.
Since some of these service operations are performed “Power On”, the corresponding zones should be tested with a minimum requirement of no damage or no permanent change of conditions (loss of data, alarm, etc.).§ § Some
standards (IEC) recommend that these areas be exempted from the test. In our opinion, this exemption is not justified since these operations are often done with the equipment being simply in stand-by. For instance, metallic receptacles, even with recessed female contacts, can still be reached by a frontal air discharge before the finger even touches the peripheral shell.
124
Chapter 4 ESD Diagnostics and Testing
3. For those targets that cannot be touched by direct contact (pointed tip), use the air discharge. 4. Repeat the discharges until the prescribed number have been applied without unacceptable EUT response. If no minimum number of pulses is prescribed, use 50 as a default, in each polarity. However, the minimum number of pulses to guarantee the test depends on the complexity of the EUT operations (see Fig. 4.30). Section 4.7 discusses this problem of the number of trials more in detail. 5. Repeat step 4 for all coded areas and record which ones failed. If none failed, increase the level by 1 kV and rerun the test. Above 8 kV, most s